Mediterranean Desertification
Mediterranean Desertification: A Mosaic of Processes and Responses Edited by N.A. Geeson
King’s College, University of London, UK C.J. Brandt
King’s College, University of London, UK and J.B. Thornes
King’s College, University of London, UK
Copyright 2002
John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England Telephone (+44) 1243 779777
Email (for orders and customer service enquiries):
[email protected] Visit our Home Page on www.wileyeurope.com or www.wiley.com All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise, except under the terms of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP, UK, without the permission in writing of the Publisher. Requests to the Publisher should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England, or emailed to
[email protected], or faxed to (+44) 1243 770571. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the Publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought.
Other Wiley Editorial Offices John Wiley & Sons Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA Jossey-Bass, 989 Market Street, San Francisco, CA 94103-1741, USA Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, Boschstr. 12, D-69469 Weinheim, Germany John Wiley & Sons Australia Ltd, 33 Park Road, Milton, Queensland 4064, Australia John Wiley & Sons (Asia) Pte Ltd, 2 Clementi Loop #02-01, Jin Xing Distripark, Singapore 129809 John Wiley & Sons Canada Ltd, 22 Worcester Road, Etobicoke, Ontario, Canada M9W 1L1 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Mediterranean desertification: a mosaic of processes and responses / edited by N.A. Geeson, C.J. Brandt, and J.B. Thornes. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references (p.). ISBN 0-470-84448-5 (alk. paper) 1. Desertification–Mediterranean Region. I. Geeson, Nichola. II. Brandt, C. Jane. III. Thornes, John B. GB618.68.M43 M4 2001 333.73′ 6′ 091822–dc21
2001046911
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0-470-84448-5 Typeset in 9/11pt Times by Laserwords Private Limited, Chennai, India Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire This book is printed on acid-free paper responsibly manufactured from sustainable forestry in which at least two trees are planted for each one used for paper production.
Contents
List of Contributors
ix
Preface
xv
Part 1
Thematic Issues
1
Section I
Introduction
3
Chapter 1
The Evolving Context of Mediterranean Desertification J.B. Thornes
5
Section II
Climate, Processes and Responses
13
Chapter 2
Extreme Climatic Events over the Mediterranean M. Conte, R. Sorani and E. Piervitali
15
Chapter 3
Potential Effects of Rising CO2 and Climatic Change on Mediterranean Vegetation C.P. Osborne and F.I. Woodward
33
Use of NOAA-AVHRR NDVI Data for Climatic Characterization of Mediterranean Areas Giovanni Cannizzaro, Fabio Maselli, Luciano Caroti and Lorenzo Bottai
47
Section III
Land Use, Processes and Responses
55
Chapter 5
The Effect of Land Use on Soil Erosion and Land Degradation under Mediterranean Conditions C. Kosmas, N.G. Danalatos, F. L´opez-Berm´udez and M.A. Romero D´ıaz
57
Chapter 4
Chapter 6
Agro-pastoral Activities and Land Degradation in Mediterranean Areas: Case Study of Sardinia G. Enne, G. Pulina, M. d’Angelo, F. Previtali, S. Madrau, S. Caredda and A.H.D. Francesconi
71
Chapter 7
Landscape Protection from Grazing and Fire N.S. Margaris and E. Koutsidou
83
Chapter 8
Bioengineering Principles and Desertification Mitigation J.N. Quinton, R.P.C. Morgan, N.A. Archer, G.M. Hall and A. Green
93
vi
Contents
Section IV
Physical Processes and Responses
Chapter 9
Differing Responses of Greek Mediterranean Plant Communities to Climate and the Combination of Grazing and Fire A. Dalaka, E. Papatheodorou, G. Iatrou, T. Mardiris, J. Pantis, S. Sgardelis, C. Lanara Cook, T. Lanaras, M. Argyropoulou, K.J. Diamantopoulos and G.P. Stamou
Chapter 10
Vegetation Cover Assessment in Mediterranean Semi-arid Landscapes F.J. Garc´ıa-Haro, J. Meli´a, M.A. Gilabert and M.T. Younis
Chapter 11
The Impact of Rock Fragments on Soil Degradation and Water Conservation B. van Wesemael, J. Poesen, C. Kosmas, N.G. Danalatos and J. Nachtergaele
107
109
119
131
Chapter 12
Aridification in a Region Neighbouring the Mediterranean ´ am Kert´esz, Tam´as Husz´ar, D´enes L´oczy, B´ela M´arkus, J´anos Mika, Ad´ Katalin Moln´ar, S´andor Papp, Antal S´antha, L´aszl´o Szalai, Istv´an T´ozsa and Gergely Jakab
147
Chapter 13
Soil Salinization in the Mediterranean: Soils, Processes and Implications L. Postiglione
163
Section V
Tools for Exploring Desertification
175
Chapter 14
Environmentally Sensitive Areas in the MEDALUS Target Area Study Sites A.C. Imeson and L.H. Cammeraat
177
Investigation on Environmental Characteristics to Underpin the Selection of Desertification Indicators in the Guadalent´ın Basin L.H. Cammeraat, A.C. Imeson and L. Hein
187
Chapter 15
Chapter 16
MEDRUSH: A Basin-scale Physically Based Model for Forecasting Runoff and Sediment Yield M.J. Kirkby, R.J. Abrahart, J.C. Bathurst, C.G. Kilsby, M.L. McMahon, C.P. Osborne, J.B. Thornes and F.I. Woodward
203
Part 2
Regional Studies
229
Section VI
The Guadalent´ın Basin, South-east Spain
231
Chapter 17
Natural Resources in the Guadalent´ın Basin (South-east Spain): Water as a Key Factor ´ and F. Belmonte F. L´opez-Berm´udez, G.G. Barber´a, F. Alonso-Sarria Serrato
Chapter 18
Local and Regional Responses to Global Climate Change in South-east Spain C.M. Goodess and J.P. Palutikof
233
247
Chapter 19
Chapter 20
Chapter 21
Chapter 22
Contents
vii
The Impact of Land Abandonment on Regeneration of Semi-natural Vegetation: A Case Study from the Guadalent´ın J.A. Obando
269
Lithology and Vegetation Cover Mapping in the Guadalent´ın Basin as Interpreted through Remote Sensing Data M.T. Younis, J. Mel´ıa, M.A. Gilabert, F.J. Garc´ıa-Haro and A.J. Bastida
277
Changing Social and Economic Conditions in a Region Undergoing Desertification in the Guadalent´ın Asunci´on Romero D´ıaz, Pedro Tobarra Ochoa, Franc´ısco L´opez-Berm´udez and Gonzalo Gonz´alez-Barber´a Management Plan to Combat Desertification in the Guadalent´ın River Basin L. Rojo Serrano, F. Garc´ıa Robredo, J.A. Mart´ınez Artero and A. Mart´ınez Ruiz
289
303
Section VII
The Agri Basin, Southern Italy
319
Chapter 23
General Description of the Agri Basin, Southern Italy F. Basso, E. Bove and M. del Prete
321
Chapter 24
The Agri Valley – Sustainable Agriculture in a Dry Environment: Crop Systems and Management F. Basso, M. Pisante and B. Basso
331
Chapter 25
Soil Erosion and Land Degradation F. Basso, M. Pisante and B. Basso
347
Chapter 26
Social and Economic Conditions of Development in the Agri Valley E. Bove and G. Quaranta
361
Chapter 27
Characterization of Soil Hydraulic Properties in a Desertification Context Alessandro Santini and Nunzio Romano
369
Chapter 28
Aspects of Forestry in the Agri Environment Agostino Ferrara, Vittorio Leone and Malcolm Taberner
385
Chapter 29
Modelling Large Basin Hydrology and Sediment Yield with Sparse Data: The Agri Basin, Southern Italy J.C. Bathurst, J. Sheffield, C. Vicente, S.M. White and N. Romano
397
Section VIII Conclusions
417
Chapter 30
419
Emerging Mosaics J.B. Thornes
Glossary
429
Index
433
List of Contributors
R.J. Abrahart
School of Geography, University of Nottingham, University Park, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK
F. Alonso-Sarr´ıa
Laboratorio de Geomorfolog´ıa, Universidad de Murcia, Campus de “La Merced”, c/Santo Cristo 1, E-30001 Murcia, Spain
M. d’Angelo
Centro Interdipartimento di Ateneo NRD (Nucleo di Ricerca sulla Desertificazione), Dipartimento di Scienze Zootecniche, Universit`a degli Studi di Sassari, Facolt`a de Agraria, Via de Nicola, I-07100, Sassari, Italy
N.A. Archer
Division of Environmental and Applied Biology, Biological Sciences Institute, University of Dundee, Dundee DD1 4HN, UK
M. Argyropoulou
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
B. Basso
Dipartimento di Produzione Vegetale, Universit`a degli Studi della Basilicata, Via Nazario Sauro 85, 85100 Potenza, Italy
F. Basso
Dipartimento di Produzione Vegetale, Universit`a degli Studi della Basilicata, Via Nazario Sauro 85, 85100 Potenza, Italy
A.J. Bastida
Departamento de Geolog´ıa, Universtitat de Val`encia, Spain
J.C. Bathurst
Water Resource Systems Research Laboratory, School of Civil Engineering and Geosciences, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne NE1 7RU, UK
F. Belmonte Serrato
Laboratorio de Geomorfolog´ıa, Universidad de Murcia, Campus de “La Merced”, c/Santo Cristo 1, E-30001 Murcia, Spain
L. Bottai
FMA, Via Einstein 36, 50023 Campi Bisenzio, Firenze, Italy
E. Bove
Dipartimento Tecnico-Economico perla Gestione del Territorio Agricolo-Foresstale, Universit`a degli Studi della Basilicata, Via Nazario Sauro 85, 85100 Potenza, Italy
L.H. Cammeraat
IBED-Fysische Geografie en Bodemkunde, Universiteit van Amsterdam, Nieuwe Achtergracht 166, NL 1018 WV Amsterdam, The Netherlands
G. Cannizzaro
TelespazioSpA, Via Tiburtina 965, 00156 Rome, Italy
S. Caredda
Centro Interdipartimento di Ateneo NRD (Nucleo di Ricerca sulla Desertificazione), Dipartimento di Scienze Zootecniche, Universit`a degli Studi di Sassari, Facolt`a de Agraria, Via de Nicola, I-07100, Sassari, Italy
L. Caroti
CeSIA-Accademia dei Georgofili, Logge Uffizi Corti 1, 50122 Firenze, Italy
x
List of Contributors
M. Conte (deceased)
Formerly at Istituto Fisica Atmosfera CNR, PZA L. Sturzo 31, 00144, Rome, Italy
A. Dalaka
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
N.G. Danalatos
Department of Agriculture, University of Thessaloniki, 38221 Volos, Greece
M. del Prete
Dipartimento di Produzione Vegetale, Universit`a degli Studi della Basilicata, Via Nazario Sauro 85, 85100 Potenza, Italy
K.J. Diamantopoulos
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
G. Enne
Centro Interdipartimento di Ateneo NRD (Nucleo di Ricerca sulla Desertificazione), Dipartimento di Scienze Zootecniche, Universit`a degli Studi di Sassari, Facolt`a de Agraria, Via Enrico de Nicola, 9-07100, Sassari, Italy
A. Ferrara
Dipartimento di Produzione Vegetale, Universit`a degli Studi della Basilicata, Via Nazario Sauro 85, 85100 Potenza, Italy
A.H.D. Francesconi
Centro Interdipartimento di Ateneo NRD (Nucleo di Ricerca sulla Desertificazione), Dipartimento di Scienze Zootecniche, Universit`a degli Studi di Sassari, Facolt`a de Agraria, Via Enrico de Nicola, 9-07100, Sassari, Italy
F. Garc´ıa Robredo
Fundaci´on Universidad Empresa de Murcia, Escuela de Negocios de la Regi´on de Murcia, Campus de Espinardo, 30100 Espinardo (Murcia), Spain
F.J. Garc´ıa-Haro
Remote Sensing Unit, Universitat de Val`encia, Dr Moliner 50, 46100-Burjassot, Val`encia, Spain
M.A. Gilabert
Remote Sensing Unit, Universitat de Val`encia, Dr Moliner 50, 46100-Burjassot, Val`encia, Spain
G. Gonz´alez-Barber´a
Departamento de Coservacion de Suelos y Agua, CEBAS-CSIC, Campus Universitario de Espinardo, Apartado 4195, 30080 Murcia, Spain
C.M. Goodess
Climatic Research Unit, University of East Anglia, Norwich, Norfolk NR4 7TJ, UK
A. Green
National Soil Resources Institute, Cranfield University, Silsoe, Bedford MK45 4DT, UK
G.M. Hall
National Soil Resources Institute, Cranfield University, Silsoe, Bedford MK45 4DT, UK
L. Hein
FSD, PO Box 570, NL 6700 AN Wageningen, The Netherlands
T. Husz´ar
Dept of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112 Budapest, Hungary
G. Iatrou
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
A.C. Imeson
IBED-Fysische Geografie en Bodemkunde, Universiteit van Amsterdam, Nieuwe Achtergracht 166, NL 1018 WV Amsterdam, The Netherlands
List of Contributors
xi
G. Jakab
Department of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112, Budapest, Hungary
´ Kert´esz A.
Department of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112, Budapest, Hungary
C.G. Kilsby
Water Resource Systems Research Laboratory, School of Civil Engineering and Geosciences, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne NE1 7RU, UK
M.J. Kirkby
School of Geography, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK
C. Kosmas
Laboratory of Soil Chemistry, Agricultural University of Athens, Iera Odos 75, 11855 Athens, Greece
E. Koutsidou
Department of Environmental Studies, University of the Aegean, “Xenia” Building, 81100 Mytilini, Lesvos, Greece
C. Lanara Cook
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
T. Lanaras
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
V. Leone
Dipartimento di Produzione Vegetale, Universit`a degli Studi della Basilicata, Via Nazario Sauro 85, 85100 Potenza, Italy
D. L´oczy
Department of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112, Budapest, Hungary
F. L´opez-Berm´udez
Department of Physical Geography, Laboratorio de Geomorfolog´ıa, Universidad de Murcia, Campus de “La Merced”, c/Santo Cristo 1, E-30001 Murcia, Spain
S. Madrau
Centro Interdipartimento di Ateneo NRD (Nucleo di Ricerca sulla Desertificazione), Universit`a degli Studi di Sassari, Facolt`a de Agraria, Via de Nicola, I-07100, Sassari, Italy
T. Mardiris
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
N.S. Margaris
Department of Environmental Studies, University of the Aegean, “Xenia” Building, 81100 Mytilini, Lesvos, Greece
B. M´arkus
Department of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112, Budapest, Hungary
J.A. Mart´ınez Artero
DGCONA, Ministerio de Medio Ambiente, Avda. Alfonso X El Sabio 6, 30008 Murcia, Spain
A. Mart´ınez Ruiz
Fundaci´on Universidad Empresa de Murcia, Escuela de Negocios de la Regi´on de Murcia, Campus de Espinardo, 30100 Espinardo (Murcia), Spain
F. Maselli
IATA-CNR, P. le delle Cascine 18, 50144 Firenze, Italy
M.L. McMahon
Infocom (UK) Ltd, York Science Park, York, UK
J. Meli´a
Remote Sensing Unit, Universitat de Val`encia, Dr Moliner 50, 46100-Burjassot, Val`encia, Spain
J. Mika
Department of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112, Budapest, Hungary
xii
List of Contributors
K. Moln´ar
Department of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112, Budapest, Hungary
R.P.C. Morgan
National Soil Resources Institute, Cranfield University, Silsoe, Bedfordshire MK45 4DT, UK
J. Nachtergaele
Laboratory for Experimental Geomorphology, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
J.A. Obando
Department of Geography, Kenyatta University, PO Box 43844, Nairobi, Kenya
C.P. Osborne
Department of Animal and Plant Sciences, University of Sheffield, Sheffield S10 2TN, UK
J.P. Palutikof
Climatic Research Unit, University of East Anglia, Norwich, Norfolk NR4 7TJ, UK
J. Pantis
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
E. Papatheodorou
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
S. Papp
Department of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112, Budapest, Hungary
E. Piervitali
CRATI s.c.r.l., Universit`a della Calabria, Rende (CS), Italy
M. Pisante
Dipartimento di Produzione Vegetale, Universit`a degli Studi della Basilicata, Via Nazario Sauro 85, 85100 Potenza, Italy
J. Poesen
Laboratory for Experimental Geomorphology, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven Redingenstraat 16, B-3000 Leuven, Belgium
L. Postiglione
Faculty of Agriculture, University of Naples Federico II, via Universit´a, 100, 80055 Portici (NA), Italy
F. Previtali
Dipartimento di Scienze dell’Ambiente e del Territorio, Universit`a di Milano–Biocca, Milano, Italy
G. Pulina
Centro Interdipartimento di Ateneo NRD (Nucleo di Ricerca sulla Desertificazione), Dipartimento di Scienze Zootecniche, Universit`a degli Studi di Sassari, Facolt`a de Agraria, Via de Nicola, I-07100, Sassari, Italy
G. Quaranta
University of Basilicata–DITEC, Via Macchia Romana, I-85100 Potenza, Italy
J.N. Quinton
National Soil Resources Institute, Cranfield University, Silsoe, Bedfordshire MK45 4DT, UK
L. Rojo Serrano
DGCONA, Ministerio de Medio Ambiente, Gran V´ıa de San Francisco 4, 28005 Madrid, Spain
N. Romano
Department of Agricultural Engineering, Division for Land and Water Resources Management, University of Naples “Federico II”, Via Universita’, 100, 80055 Portici (Naples), Italy
M.A. Romero D´ıaz
Department of Physical Geography, University of Murcia, Campus de “La Merced”, c/Santo Cristo 1, E-30001 Murcia, Spain
List of Contributors
xiii
A. S´antha
Department of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112, Budapest, Hungary
A. Santini
Department of Agricultural Engineering, Division for Land and Water Resources Management, University of Naples “Federico II”, Via Universita’, 100, 80055 Portici (Naples), Italy
S. Sgardelis
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
J. Sheffield
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey 08544, USA
R. Sorani
Servizio Meteorologico dell’Aeronautica, Rome, Italy
G.P. Stamou
Department of Biology, Aristotele University of Thessaloniki, GR 540 06 Thessaloniki, Greece
L. Szalai
Department of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112, Budapest, Hungary
M. Taberner
c/o Institute for Environment and Sustainability, Ispre, Italy
J.B. Thornes
Department of Geography, King’s College London, the Strand, London WC2R 2LS, UK
P. Tobarra Ochoa
Department of Fundamentals of Economical Analysis, University of Murcia, Spain
I. T´ozsa
Department of Physical Geography, Geographical Research Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1112, Budapest, Hungary
B. van Wesemael
D´epartement de G´eographie, Universit´e Catholique de Louvain, Place Louis Pasteur 3, B-1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
C. Vicente
C/Cafetos #4, Col. Campestre, Cordoba, Veracruz 93653, Mexico
S.M. White
Institute of Water and Environment, Cranfield University, Silsoe, Bedfordshire, MK45 4DT, UK
F.I. Woodward
Department of Animal and Plant Sciences, University of Sheffield, Sheffield S10 2TN, UK
M.T. Younis
Remote Sensing Unit, Universitat de Val`encia, Dr Moliner 50, 46100-Burjassot, Val`encia, Spain.
Preface
Desertification has been recognized as one of the biggest problems facing the European Mediterranean countries. By desertification we mean land degradation resulting from various factors, including climatic variation and human impact, and it is the long history of human intervention, from Classical times onwards, that has particularly shaped the landscape here. Water resources have been exploited unsustainably, resulting in chemical pollution, salinization and exhaustion of aquifers. As economic activity has flourished in coastal areas so abandonment and degradation of land in the interior, previously sustained by traditional farming practices, have continued. Portugal, Spain, Italy and Greece are all now signatories to the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification and implementation of the convention within national and regional action plans will require further organization of research and monitoring. The European Commission has funded a number of projects within the Environment Programme (DGXII), aimed at improving the understanding of the whole range of desertification issues. This book is based on the results of one of those projects, MEDALUS II, where 44 different universities and other institutions combined their expertise to clarify the processes of desertification operating in the Mediterranean environment, and the responses to those processes. Scientists of many disciplines, ranging from remote sensing to microbiology, researched climate, land use and the physical processes within soil and vegetation systems in order to design tools to describe and monitor desertification. Part 2 of this book describes how these processes and tools have been applied specifically. The regional studies illustrate how the application of remedial action cannot usually be uniform, but must respect the mosaic of physical environments and social and historical variations that interact within the geographical space of two of the target areas: the Guadalent´ın Basin of south-east Spain, and the Agri Valley of southern Italy. The editors feel privileged to have had the opportunity to work with the MEDALUS projects and to edit this book. All the authors should feel very proud of the unique spirit of co-operation that the projects have engendered. Each individual contribution makes up a part of the mosaic of our current knowledge, and the years of work behind this achievement are very much appreciated. Nichola Geeson Jane Brandt John B. Thornes Department of Geography, King’s College, University of London, UK November 2001
PART 1
THEMATIC ISSUES
Section I
Introduction
1
The Evolving Context of Mediterranean Desertification
J.B. THORNES
Department of Geography, King’s College London
1 INTRODUCTION In the last 10 years, the issue of desertification has not only become more widely recognized, both internationally and regionally, but the social and political framework has changed dramatically in a way that makes a change in the research approach crucial. It is the purpose of this chapter to outline these changes in order to set the context for further assessment of the problem. There have been a number of major syntheses that reflect the wider consciousness and appraisal of the problem. Despite these changes, the UNEP (United Nations Environment Programme) definition of desertification as “land degradation in arid, semi-arid and dry sub-humid areas resulting from various factors including climatic variations and human activities” remains as helpful today as it was in 1990 (UNEP 1990). Bearing in mind that “land” means the terrestrial bioproductive system that comprises soil, vegetation, other biota and the ecological and hydrological processes that operate within the system, the definition is particularly relevant. “Land degradation” means reduction and loss of the biological and economic productivity caused by land-use change, or by a physical process or a combination of the two. If anything, it would be useful to incorporate the rural depopulation implied in the French language usage, especially in a European context, where desertion of rural areas has been stressed as a pivotal problem in European Agricultural Reform. More light was spread on the problems of desertification in southern Europe by the conference held jointly by the Directorate General for Research of the European Commission and the Greek Government from 29 October to 1 November 1996. The proceedings have been published in two volumes (Balabanis et al. 1999, 2000). Another source is the documentation arising from the Concerted Action on Mediterranean Desertification, funded by the Research Directorate under Framework V and published in three volumes (Burke and Thornes 1998, in press a, b). A further important contribution, in addition to the publication of the two major books on the MEDALUS Project (Brandt and Thornes 1996; Mairota et al. 1998), is van der Leeuw’s brilliant synthesis of the Archaeomedes Project (van der Leeuw 1998).
2 AGENDA 21 AND SUSTAINABILITY At the international level, the UNCED Rio Conference of 1992 urged signatory nations to “reposition their economies, their societies and their collective purpose to maintain all life on earth, peacefully, equitably and with sufficient wealth to ensure that all are content in their survival” (O’Riordan and Voisey 1998, p. xiii). In Europe, this requirement was foreseen in the Fifth Environmental Plan, a precursor to the Rio Conference’s position on sustainability. Although progress has been relatively slow in some European countries and almost non-existent in others, the plan anticipates a level of public empowerment in environmental matters that will, in the longer term, enlighten environmental affairs. In Portugal, the establishment of Environmental Protection Associations at four different Mediterranean Desertification: A Mosaic of Processes and Responses. Edited by N.A. Geeson, C.J. Brandt and J.B. Thornes 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
6
Mediterranean Desertification
levels (Reibeiro and Rodrigues 1998) has strong affinities with the Land Care approach of Australia, in its emphasis on community and end-user involvement. This bodes well for the future contemplation of measures against desertification. Greece has been somewhat slower to act, according to Greek authors (Fousekis and Lekakis 1998), but the difficulties are the same: the lack of familiarity with, and acceptance of, consultation of the people; the late development of institutions of government, especially those concerned with environment; and the shortage of basic data that are required for decision making at the local level. Another major change since the start of the MEDALUS Project has been the shift in the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) as a result of changing public awareness of the failures of the agricultural price support system and, specifically, the negotiations in 1992 of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT).
3
AGRI-ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES AND AGENDA 2000
Perhaps the largest socio-economic change to occur in Europe that may be expected to have a bearing on the desertification problem is the Cork Declaration. In this, Commissioner Fischer stated his determination to reform the CAP into a more broadly based rural policy, integrating environmental issues. This was to bring to an end 40 years of price support and potentially affect an area of 141 million hectares, 44% of the total land surface of the 15 European Union states and probably change the landscape of Europe forever. There is a close link here to Agenda 21, because the need for sustainable agriculture is one of the key forces driving the reform of the CAP. This reform is called Agenda 2000. Here sustainable use means “The use of components of biological diversity in a way and at a rate that does not lead to the long-term decline of biological diversity, thereby maintaining its potential to meet the needs and aspirations of present and future generations” (according to the International Convention on Biodiversity, Rio 1992). In their assessment of the new CAP proposals, Birdlife International (1997) described the old CAP as “the engine of destruction in the countryside”. The productionist philosophy, with its link to regional and national development, led to the intensification of agriculture after the Second World War, through increased mechanization, fertilizer application and the promotion and extension of irrigation, that was so notable in the Mediterranean, leading to the conversion of dry farming to dense, fast-growing, heavily fertilized and pest-treated crops. It also led to a sharp increase in the demand for irrigation water and massive extraction of groundwater resources (see below). The original CAP (arising in the earliest days of the Community from the Treaty of Rome) was “an outdated, expensive, inefficient, inequitable and environmentally-damaging collection of policies that by 1992 was in need of further reform”. This was urgent for several reasons: • • • •
the proposed enlargement of the European Community; the requirement to meet the needs of the Uruguayan round of GATT and to prepare for the next round of World Trade negotiations with an emphasis on the reduction of trade-distorting subsidies; the commitment at the Rio Conference to promoting sustainable agriculture and protecting and enhancing the natural environment, as well as helping to meet the needs of rural communities; public demand for economic reform, relating to the budgetary costs and the economic inefficiency of the CAP.
The Commission decided to follow the McSharry approach to reforms by reducing support payments to world levels and replacing production incentives with direct payments. For example, the sharp cuts in beef and cereal prices are designed to allow food to be exported into world markets without subsidy enabling an enlarged EU to sell off its surpluses in these commodities. The East European countries that are joining will need to develop their agricultural systems in a sustainable way while meeting the needs of their rural communities. It is too early to see the outcomes of these policy shifts, which tend to be obscured by short-term fluctuations, such as the rise in grain prices that enabled export without subsidy in 1995–1996. The
The Evolving Context of Mediterranean Desertification
7
increased harvest in 1996 and the subsequent fall in world grain prices have reintroduced the need for export subsidies. The potential for significant increases in production brought some difficulties in meeting GATT limits on subsidized exports, requiring a significant increase in the set-aside rates. What is clear is that rural depopulation remains an important issue. A key objective of Agenda 2000 is to maintain the viability of rural communities by maintaining employment and incomes in rural areas through sustainable long-term use of resources. According to Birdlife International (1997), the number of people employed in agriculture in the 12 member states of the EU declined from 16.3 million in 1970 to 7.0 million in 1994, falling from 13.5% to 5.5% of total employment. At the same time, farm sizes and agricultural production have increased, resulting in increased levels of subsidies going to smaller numbers of farmers. As employment in agriculture continues to decline, the benefits of the (original) CAP are becoming less apparent. This valuable appraisal goes on to say that “Europe’s rural development problems cannot be addressed by support for agricultural production alone. They require a more integrated approach to rural policy, which places agriculture within the context of the whole rural economy” (Birdlife International 1997, p. 19). It is hard to disagree with this view and it must be added that the failure to address the most severe crisis in southern Europe, land degradation, highlights this lack of an integrated approach. The Agenda 2000 reforms are a great opportunity to couple economic regulations with environmental reforms. This has been done directly, to some extent through the “extensification measures” and indirectly through Environment Impact Directives. The ideal agri-environmental programme would, among other things, provide opportunities for all farmers to manage land for erosion mitigation rather than allow them to pass externalities (such as reservoir siltation) to the tax payers.
4 LAND ABANDONMENT It is often claimed that land abandonment invariably leads to land degradation and desertification, partially at least through the failure to maintain agricultural terraces. However, as Baudry (1991) points out, land abandonment is not a new phenomenon. It has been constantly occurring in Europe since 1950 and has been widespread in eastern North America since 1920. Rather than simply blame land abandonment on European Union policy, we need to know better what lessons can be learned from history. In the Mediterranean, there have been phases of strong outward migration. These have been both local (such as the impact of the Phylloxera plague on vines in the Spanish Alpujarra in the early years of the 20th century), and regional (as in the out-migrations for employment from southern Spain to northern Europe in the mid-20th century). Land abandonment does not necessarily mean that land is no longer used, either by agriculture or any other rural economy; it means a change in land use from the traditional or recent pattern to another, less intensive pattern. Nevertheless, we need to be able to identify how the landscape will change in relation to our knowledge of the erosion risk. Perhaps it is self-evident that the land at greatest risk is most likely to be abandoned. There are two sides to the coin: land abandonment occurs either because of external stresses and/or because of its inherently low productive capacity. Land abandonment occurs as a result of external driving forces, such as market changes, or internal changes that are “intrinsic”, for example if the system crosses some invisible threshold, such as the critical soil depth for plant growth. Once crossed, the tendency is for change to be negative, self-reinforcing and irreversible. Over the years, farming practice has brought the farming systems more stability, making them more resilient to changes. It is claimed that the mixed tree–grass–herb–grazing system of Extremadura, Spain (the dehesas) is highly stable to change because of its need for very low external inputs, its high biological diversity and the highly partitioned tree and herb layer (Bernaldez 1991). On the other hand, ecosystems are more unstable and susceptible to change when there is a strong competition between components. Thus Thornes (1990) was able to demonstrate the low stability in Mediterranean ecosystems where plants and soils compete for water, a situation that can lead to catastrophic changes as a result of small changes in the inputs and outputs (rainfall and grazing take-off, respectively). Progressive slow degradation
8
Mediterranean Desertification
can move the system towards an unstable state without the dangers being recognized. The trick is to identify the “position” of the threshold in state-space, so that trajectories towards instability can be recognized. The trajectory towards instability becomes apparent over time. After fire, it often takes 8–10 years before the pre-fire equilibrium between vegetation cover and sediment yield is reestablished. Unfortunately, abandonment and the associated neglect often bring the system rapidly to a threshold that, when crossed, may lead to irreversible erosion. Abandonment after ploughing results in a succession that requires about 20 years to reach equilibrium as a mature ecosystem under the prevailing grazing. Alpha diversity increases with succession and niche amplitude tends to diminish, the new plant species becoming specialists of increasingly narrower habitats (Pineda et al. 1981). Traditional sylvo-pastoral systems are subjected to either increases or decreases in grazing pressures. The former leads to destruction of natural pastures and the replacement of valuable grasses and legumes by unpalatable nitrophilous vegetation as has occurred at the MEDALUS field site in north-west Lesvos Island, Greece, observed by Kosmas et al. (1998). Replacement of nutritious herbs by rough pasture has also been described in Spain (De Miguel 1989). If this “matoralization” process proceeds unchecked, it eventually induces a decrease in biological diversity and a decrease in stability, as described by Naveh and Whittaker (1974), and an increase in fire risk.
5
WATER RESOURCES
Problems of water resources are inextricably bound to, but not synonymous with, desertification. As land degradation occurs, soil storage capacity is reduced, runoff increases and erosion thresholds are passed. The high inter-annual variability of rainfall moves Mediterranean soils inexorably towards the thresholds of land degradation as the pressure on vegetative cover increases through lack of soil moisture. The gathering pace of confidence in the observation of the existence of global warming and revised estimates by the ICCP indicate more difficult times ahead for hillslope hydrology as systems dry out. MEDALUS research suggests significant reductions in the biomass of grass and bushlands in areas having more than seven rain-free months per year in the Iberian Peninsula, as temperatures and atmospheric CO2 rise (Diamond and Woodward 1998), and estimates made by the Spanish Ministerio de Obras Publicas indicate important (17–20%) reductions in the flow of major Spanish rivers. Even accepting the scope for errors in these model estimates, the contemporary data already show that the supply of water for river flow replenishment and aquifer recharge is decreasing. In Mediterranean regions with average rainfalls of less than 300 mm per year, high inter-annual variability and high summer temperatures, there is a more or less continuous threat of water scarcity. In meteorological droughts this is caused by failure of precipitation, as has occurred in Italy, Greece and Spain in the last two decades of the last century. The whole of Italy was affected by severe drought during 1988–1999. A sequence of three years with low rainfall were accompanied by high temperatures; snow depths were also considerably reduced, with lower snowfalls than normal, combined with high temperatures. Large areas of Greece are susceptible to drought, notably eastern Greece and some Aegean islands. Catchments are often small and underlain by highly permeable karstic formations. There was an extended drought in the Athens area from 1987 to 1993, when rainfall was only 50% of normal, including two extremely dry years (1989/90 and 1991/2) that were the most severe over the last century. Most of Spain, except the north-west coast, was severely drought affected in the years 1990–1996. An analysis of seasonal rainfall (Institute of Hydrology and ISPRA 1999) indicates that the rainfall deficit was generally concentrated in winter and spring. Autumn rainfall was normal or above average and summer rainfall fairly regular. Mean percentage departure from normal rainfall exceeded −20% in the southern part of the country, which was worst affected. The drought reached its maximum coverage in September 1994 and August 1995 when rainfall reached −25%, and over two-thirds of Spain was affected. MEDALUS research by Goodess and Palutikof (Chapter 18) demonstrates the close coupling of the Atlantic Ocean pressure differences between the Azores High and the Iceland Low, on the one
The Evolving Context of Mediterranean Desertification
9
hand, and pressure fields over the Mediterranean that are linked to rainfall aberrations on the other. Earlier, Turkes (1996) showed, by the analysis of normalized rainfall patterns, that anticyclonic activity affected Turkey more frequently over the period 1973–1993. The abrupt decrease in rainfall since the early 1970s has been attributed to the northward shift of the Polar front, resulting from a more easterly extension of the drought-dominated subtropical anticyclone extending from the Azores to the eastern Mediterranean. According to the Institute of Hydrology/ISPRA report (1999), a study by Reynard et al. (1997) concluded, inter alia, that • there is a general tendency for an increase in annual average runoff in northern Europe and a decrease in southern Europe of over 30% in some areas; • the greatest sensitivity to change is in the drier parts of southern and eastern Europe; • before the 2050s there could be a substantial reduction in snowfall that would alter the current temporal distribution of river flows by reducing or eliminating the spring peak and substantially increasing winter flows in central and eastern Europe. In addition to the impacts of meteorological drought, the public perception of desertification has been heightened by water resource shortage arising from anthropologically induced water problems, including: • the huge and continuing rise in demand for water to meet the needs of tourism growth, which has locally caused salinization because aquifers have been drawn down, as in the case of Benidorm, Spain; • a number of major floods, whose magnitude and time-to-rise have almost certainly been affected by vegetation removal and soil erosion, but whose impact has resulted from the failure of planning measures to provide flood plain zoning; • the heavy reliance in Mediterranean countries on irrigation for agricultural production: in Greece, 80% of water is used for irrigation, in Italy 50%, in Spain 68% and in Portugal 52%; • the continued rise in the demand for irrigation water, which has led to a reversion to engineeringtype solutions. An example of the latter is the National Hydrological Plan of Spain, which foresees the transfer of water from the lower Ebro to both Catalonia (Barcelona) and Murcia. There has been a bitter debate by the people of Aragon who claim that the water needs for the poorer areas of Aragon are also exacerbating underdevelopment. There is a crisis of democracy because the central government has had to try to balance out the needs of the wet north and the dry south. In 1998, in the severe drought, the existing transfer canal taking water from the River Tajo in Castilla la Mancha to the River Segura in Murcia failed to stave off the impacts of drought in Murcia, where large numbers of fruit trees were lost. The Tajo–Segura Trasvase (transfer canal) has a capacity for transferring 6 × 108 m3 year−1 and the Spanish government ordered the diversion of a further 5.5 × 107 m3 to “save” Murcia. It is against this background that the current bitter row over transfer from the Ebro to Murcia is being waged. At a demonstration in the Aragon city of Zaragoza, two-thirds of the population of Aragon turned out to protest against the projected transfer, instead of letting the water flow to the Ebro delta and the irrigated lands around Tortosa. Meanwhile Barcelona is negotiating with France for water from the Rhˆone. Water quality deterioration is adding to the environmental crisis that has been confused and compounded with desertification and coupled to the issues of sustainability and the defence of rural areas. Again, the effects of productionist agriculture are evidently the major causes and any action taken to mitigate desertification through regulatory measures in an integrated catchment context will have to address the water quality problem (Foster 2000). The flux of fertilizer returns in water in the northern states is three times greater than in the southern states and contributes 73% of the total. Of the national amounts, the largest returns are of irrigation water (Egypt and Italy) and power station cooling water (France).
10
6
Mediterranean Desertification
A MOSAIC AND A PALIMPSEST
One of the major difficulties facing this planning operation is the fact that the Mediterranean landscape is one of the most complicated in the world. Over space, conditions rarely remain the same for more than a kilometre or two because of local variations in topography, soils, land use, climate and surface water conditions. Another source of variety is that almost every municipality bears the imprint of national, regional and local constraints throughout history. The challenge for those concerned with planning for environmental sustainability in a local Agenda 21, including desertification and land degradation, is threefold: • • •
to identify the local-scale causes of desertification and its manifestations, and develop suitable sensitive indicators to do this; to understand the historical development of the problem, also at different time-scales; to develop regulations that, far from being applicable to the whole of Europe, are sufficiently flexible to accommodate the local variations in history and conditions in the hope that this will facilitate implementation and contribute towards successful outcomes from the interventions.
Given the multiple pressures on national and regional governments from the International Convention, from the European Community and from national and local pressure groups, rural planning has shifted sharply into focus. With it has come the need for empowerment of local people in finding and negotiating optimal strategies to meet these legally binding requirements (Thornes 1998).
REFERENCES Balabanis P, Peter D, Ghazi A and Tsogas M (1999) Mediterranean Desertification. Research Results and Policy Implications, Volumes 1 and 2. Plenary Session Papers, European Commission, Directorate General for Science, Research and Development, EUR 19303, Brussels. Baudry J (1991) Ecological consequences of grazing, extensification and land abandonment. Role of interactions between environment, society and techniques. Options Mediterraneennes, Serie Seminaires 15, 13–19. Bernaldez FG (1991) Ecological consequences of the abandonment of traditional land use systems in central Spain. Options Mediterraneennes, Serie Seminaires 15, 23–29. Birdlife International (1997) A future for Europe’s Rural Environment: Reforming the Common Agricultural Policy. Birdlife International European Community Office, Brussels, p. 55. Brandt CJ and Thornes JB (1996) Mediterranean Desertification and Land Use. John Wiley, Chichester. Burke S and Thornes JB (1998) Volume 1, Actions taken by national governmental and non-governmental organisations to mitigate desertification in the Mediterranean; Volume 2, Thematic review (in press); Volume 3, Summary (in press). Concerted Action on Mediterranean Desertification. European Commission, Directorate General for Science, Research and Development, EUR 18490EN, Brussels, p. 349. De Miguel JM (1989) Estructura de un sistema silvopastoral de dehesa. PhD thesis, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Facultat de Ciencias (in Spanish). Diamond S and Woodward I (1998) Vegetation modelling. In P Mairota, JB Thornes and N Geeson (eds) Atlas of Mediterranean Environments in Europe: The Desertification Context . John Wiley, Chichester, pp. 68–69. Foster S (2000) Sustainable groundwater exploitation for agriculture: current issues and recent initiatives in the developing world. Papers of the Groundwater Project, Madrid, Marcelin Botin Foundation, Series A, No. 6. Fousakis P and Lekakis J (1998) Adjusting to the changing reality: the Greek response. In T O’Riordan and H Voisey (eds) The Transition to Sustainability: The Politics of Agenda 21 in Europe. Earthscan, London, pp. 214–229. Institute of Hydrology (UK) and ISPRA 1999. Workshop on Drought and Drought Mitigation. Space Applications Institute, Ispra, Varese, Italy, February 1999. Kosmas C, Bakker M, Bergkamp G, Detsis V, Diamantopoulos J, Gerontidis St, Imeson A, Levelt O, Maranthianou M, Oortwijn R, Oustwoud Wijdnes D, Poesen J, Vandevkkerckhove L and Zaphirou Th (1998). Mairota P, Thornes JB and Geeson N (eds) (1998) Atlas of Mediterranean Environments in Europe: The Desertification Context. John Wiley, Chichester. MEDALUS III Meeting, Lesvos, 24–28 April 1998. MEDALUS Lesvos Field Guide. Laboratory of Soils and Agricultural Chemistry, Agricultural University of Athens.
The Evolving Context of Mediterranean Desertification
11
Naveh Z and Whittaker RH (1974) Structural and floristic diversity of shrublands and woodlands in northern Israel and other Mediterranean areas. Vegetation 41, 171–190. O’Riordan T and Voisey H (eds) (1998) The Transition to Sustainability: The Politics of Agenda 21 in Europe. Earthscan, London, pp. 214–229. Pineda FD, Nicolas JP, Ruiz M, Peco B and Bernaldez FG (1981) Succession, diversite at ampliyude de niche dans les paturages du centre de la Peninsula Iberique. Vegetation 47, 267–277 (in Spanish). Rebeiro T and Rodrigues V (1998) The evolution of sustainable development strategies in Portugal. In T O’Riordan and H Voisey (eds). The Transition to Sustainability: The Politics of Agenda 21 in Europe. Earthscan, London, pp. 202–214. Reynard NS, Hulme M, Conway D and Faulkner D (1997) In NW Arnell (ed.) The Impact of Climatic Change on Hydrological Regimes and Water Resources in Europe. Final Report to EC DCXII. Thornes JB (1990) The interaction of erosional and vegetational dynamics in land degradation: spatial outcomes. In JB Thornes (ed.) Vegetation and Erosion. John Wiley, Chichester, pp. 41–55. Thornes JB (1998) Mediterranean desertification and Di Castri’s fifth dimension. Mediterraneo 12/13, 149–166. Turkes M (1996) Meteorological drought in Turkey: an historical perspective 1930–1993. Drought Network News 8(3). UNEP (1990) Desertification revisited: proceedings of an ad hoc consultative meeting on the assessment of desertification. UNEP/DC/PAC, Nairobi, pp. 289–294. Van der Leeuw S (1998) The Archaeomedes Project – Understanding the Natural and Anthropogenic Causes of Land Degradation and Desertification in the Mediterranean Basin. European Commission, Directorate General for Science, Research and Development, EUR 18181EN, Brussels.
Section II
Climate, Processes and Responses
2
Extreme Climatic Events over the Mediterranean
M. CONTE,1 R. SORANI2 AND E. PIERVITALI3 1
Istituto Fisica Atmosfera CNR, Rome, Italy Servizio Meteorologico dell’Aeronautica, Rome, Italy 3 Universita` della Calabria, Rende (CS), Italy 2
1 INTRODUCTION Violent meteorological phenomena, including strong winds, heavy precipitation and intense thermal conditions, may lead to events such as floods and forest fires, with disastrous consequences to land cover and land use. The resulting damage, particularly to agricultural settlements, can lead to abandonment and degradation of once cultivated land. In the Mediterranean region the normal climate includes sparse rainfall and high temperatures, so that extreme meteorological events can have a big impact, destroying the fragile balance between climate, soils and vegetation. A small increase in aridity may be enough to prevent regeneration of vegetation, and cause soil erosion and salinization. In this way extreme climatic events are an agent of desertification, in a wider context. In this chapter attention is directed to some extreme meteorological events, covering large areas but having heavy consequences locally. “Meteorological bombs”, heat waves and precipitation patterns, particularly extreme rainfall episodes, have been studied.
2 THE METEOROLOGICAL BOMB IN THE MEDITERRANEAN 2.1 Introduction and Definition
Several studies have been devoted to meteorological “bombs” in the last few years because of the serious damage attributed to them. Strong winds, intense precipitation and resultant floods are generally associated with these “bombs”. T. Bergeron defined a very rapidly deepening extratropical low as “a depression in which the central sea-level pressure falls at a rate of 1 hPa h−1 or more for a period lasting at least 24 hours”. As Bergeron’s definition referred to the latitude of 60 ◦ N, a geostrophically equivalent rate can be obtained for a latitude ϕ by multiplying this rate by sin ϕ/sin 60◦ . The resulting critical rate, denoted as 1 bergeron by Sanders and Gyakum (1980), varies from 28 hPa 24h−1 at the pole to about 9 hPa 24h−1 at 20 ◦ N, which is the southern limit at which the phenomenon has been observed. In the Mediterranean, applying the geostrophic correction, the critical value of 1 bergeron is obtained with a deepening of 20 hPa 24h−1 at the extreme northern boundary, and of 14 hPa 24h−1 at the deep southern limit of the basin. An average value of 17 hPa 24h−1 is the critical value for an average latitude of 38 ◦ N. Sanders and Gyakum (1980) described this explosive extratropical cyclogenesis as a meteorological “bomb”. General case studies of “meteorological bombs” were examined by Mansfield (1974), Bosart (1981), Anthes Keiser (1979) and Mullen (1983). Specifically in the Mediterranean there have been studies by Bassani (1983), Capaldo et al. (1980) and Karakostas and Flocas (1983). In addition, a synoptic-dynamic climatology of the “bomb” was developed by Sanders and Gyakum Mediterranean Desertification: A Mosaic of Processes and Responses. Edited by N.A. Geeson, C.J. Brandt and J.B. Thornes 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
16
Mediterranean Desertification
(1980) for part of the northern hemisphere, but not including the Mediterranean. In this chapter a synoptic climatology of this extreme meteorological system in the Mediterranean Basin is presented for the 31-year period 1965–1995. Using various data sources, 101 “bomb” events from this time period have been examined. 2.2
Mechanism of Development of the ‘‘Bomb’’ in the Mediterranean
A synoptic but accurate analysis of the 101 events studied indicated that for the most part (93%) the “bombs” occurred, in broad outlines, following only two fundamental types of meteorological development. In the first type many elements pointed out by Karakostas and Flocas (1983) are recognizable. In broad terms the “bomb” develops from an interaction between a baroclinic, open long wave and an unstable short wave. In addition, the resulting cyclonic vorticity, the upper air temperature advection, and the sensible and latent heat exchange support the rapid and intense deepening of the cyclone. During the analyses carried out for this synoptic climatology over the Mediterranean region, it was observed that, in several situations, the effect of the Alpine barrier can be very important in initiating a small-scale cyclogenesis, known as “cyclogenesis in the lee of the Alps”. This can interact with a wave at a larger scale and degenerate to form a “bomb”. In other words, the function of the short wave of the Karakostas and Flocas mechanism may be enhanced by the Alps or assumed by cyclogenetic factors to be related to the Alps. This type of development of a “bomb” is hereafter denoted as KF (after Karakostas and Flocas 1983). The second type of development follows the dynamics reported in the work of Capaldo et al. (1980). In this case the “bomb” originates from the interaction between a middle-latitude depression at synoptic scale, deeply penetrated into the Mediterranean, and a depression of African origin, sometimes at sub-synoptic scale. Often the interaction can be an effective intrusion of a smallscale African depression into a larger scale low-pressure area drawn from middle latitudes. In this process the low-level jet-stream and the intense baroclinicity have very important roles, related to the strong thermal contrast between the two systems of quite different origins. Other relevant features, especially in the initial stage of the development, are the very intense upper air vorticity due to a marked closeness of a branch of the polar jet-stream to a branch of the subtropical jet-stream and the release of sensible and latent heat. This type of growth of a “bomb” is hereafter denoted as CC (after Capaldo et al. 1980). In both types of development the fact that the Mediterranean sea surface temperatures (SST) are higher than Atlantic sea surface temperatures seems to be of relevant importance. The “bomb” is essentially a meteo-marine phenomenon. 2.3
The Calendar and the Geographical Distribution of the ‘‘Bombs’’ in the Mediterranean for the Period 1965–1995
Annual calendars of the incidence of “bombs” occurring in the Mediterranean region in the period 1965–1995 were compiled, and an example for 1965 is shown in Table 2.1. The date of maximum intensity is reported, as well as a value for that intensity in bergeron, and the geographical location of the centre of the “bomb”. An indication of the mechanism of development (CC, KF or other) is also given. The complete set of calendars (1965–1995) is available from the authors. Figure 2.1 shows the geographical distribution of the “bomb” events between 1965 and 1995 within location quadrilaterals, (2◦ latitude) × (3◦ longitude). Three particular areas of incidence appear: the Corsican–Sardinian Sea and the central and southern Thyrrenian Sea; an area including the central and southern Adriatic Sea and the northern Ionian Sea; and an area including the Aegean Sea. This is in accordance with observations over sea areas by Sanders and Gyakum (1980), who stated that explosive developments of “bomb” type occur over a wide range of sea surface temperatures (SST), but frequently near and a little south of their strongest gradients. Actually the three preferential areas in the Mediterranean are situated a little south of moderate or strong gradients of SST.
17
Extreme Climatic Events over the Mediterranean Table 2.1 Calendar of ‘‘bomb’’ development in the Mediterranean region in 1965
Year
Date of maximum activity
1965
Location of “bomb” centre
21 Jan 4 Feb 9 Feb 20 Apr 12 Nov
1.29 1.25 1.25 1.10 1.25
40N-12E 36N-32E 41N-12E 43N-14E 41N-05E
11 Dec 31 Dec
1.29 1.06
40N-18E 39N-21E
long.N
Intensity (bergeron)
3 1 1
2
3 6
4
3 7
12
7
5 6
5
4
Mode of development
KF KF KF KF Frontal cyclogenesis in a western flux CC CC
40
1
1
1
6
1
7 1
1
9 1
1
1
30 0
lat.W
1
10
2
3
10
20
19
22
15
30
7
7
10
lat.E
1
3
Figure 2.1 Geographical distribution of ‘‘bomb’’ events between 1965 and 1995 within location quadrilaterals (2◦ latitude) × (3◦ longitude) 2.4 Simple Statistical Distribution of the Mediterranean ‘‘Bombs’’
The monthly distribution of all cases of Mediterranean “bomb” is reported in Figure 2.2, showing that the phenomenon is much more frequent in the cold winter season. Only two summer events were observed in 31 years. Most of the winter “bombs” were associated with KF or CC development. No “bomb” developed during summer associated with CC, since in this season the African depressions are very infrequent. Figure 2.3 indicates that the KF mechanism occurs more frequently than does CC development. Only 7 cases out of 101 are due to developments other than KF and CC. The influence of the Alps in initiating the process of development of a “bomb” has also been determined, by the examination of the cyclogenesis. Mediterranean low-pressure areas, which can degenerate into “bombs”, either arrive in the basin from external regions, generally from the Atlantic, or originate in the basin, in particular in association with the orographic effect of the Alps. Figure 2.3 shows that the Alps play a significant role. The cyclogenesis of about 42% of the “bombs” is influenced by the Alps. Our analysis has also shown that the frequency of “bomb” development is higher in months during which the air temperature is lower than normal. This is probably due to the fact that
18
Mediterranean Desertification 25
Number of "bombs"
20
15
10
5
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Month
Figure 2.2 Monthly distribution of ‘‘bomb’’ cases identified over the Mediterranean during the period 1965–1995
80 70
Number of "bombs"
60 50 40 30 20 10 0 KF mechanism
CC mechanism
Other mechanism
cases influenced by the Alps cases not influenced by the Alps
Figure 2.3 Distribution of type of development of ‘‘bombs’’ identified over the Mediterranean (1965–1995): either KF (after Karakostas and Flocas 1983), CC (after Conte et al. 1986) or an alternative mechanism
19
Extreme Climatic Events over the Mediterranean
in cold periods the difference between the SST and the air temperature is higher than at other times. A high temperature difference favours a transfer of sensible heat and water vapour from the sea to the atmosphere, thus increasing the energy available for the development of intense cyclogeneses. 2.5 The ‘‘Bomb’’ in the Framework of Large-scale Mediterranean Atmospheric Circulation
The annual number of meteorological “bombs” is shown in Figure 2.4, with a clear negative trend over the whole period, and a shift in the mean since 1982. The difference between the mean of the period 1965–1981 and the mean of the period 1982–1995 is statistically significant at the 95% level (Student’s t-Test). The observed shift should not be attributed to inhomogeneity in the data series, since all data have been recorded by the Meteorological Service of the Italian Air Force, which also performs stringent data quality controls. Colacino and Conte (1993a) investigated the behaviour of the height of the 500 hPa level over the Mediterranean. It is well known that the evolution of this level represents very well the physical situation of the whole atmosphere in a large area, such as the Mediterranean Basin. The analysis concluded that a positive trend is present in the 500 hPa height, over most of the Mediterranean, during the past 45 years. The height of the 500 hPa level appears to have particularly increased during the 1980s. High values of the 500 hPa are related to high frequency and persistence of anticyclones, i.e. high pressure systems that should prevent or limit the cyclogenetic activity. As a consequence, we would expect that the annual frequency of the “bombs”, which are very severe cyclonic systems, should also be reduced by the increased anticyclonic patterns in the Mediterranean. This conclusion appears to be supported by the regression analysis between the annual numbers of “bombs” and the 500 hPa height: these two series are negatively correlated, with a correlation coefficient of −0.7. 8 7
Number of events
6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1960
1965
1970
1975
1980
1985
1990
1995
2000
Year
Figure 2.4 Number of Mediterranean ‘‘bombs’’ per year, showing how the mean annual number of events has changed since 1982
20
Mediterranean Desertification
2.6 The Meteorological ‘‘Bomb’’, Damage and Desertification The intense wind, torrential precipitation and floods associated with the “bombs” cause severe damage, and therefore research into their behaviour is important. One example of a particularly disruptive meteorological “bomb” occurred over the southern Tyrrhenian Sea on 25 October 1973. A deep depression, with intense precipitation, thunderstorms and winds, affected the northern coast of Sicily in particular, where the whole of Palermo Harbour was badly damaged. From an economical point of view the negative impact was evaluated in hundreds of billions of Italian lira (Lauteri et al. 1974). Impacts on a lesser scale frequently affect agricultural settlements. Damage to crops and soil erosion may be enough to ruin farmers, causing them to abandon their land and find alternative employment elsewhere. Land abandonment leading to land degradation and desertification in the relatively dry and hot environment of southern Europe is a widespread problem. 2.7 Conclusions on the Meteorological ‘‘Bomb’’ From the discussion above we can draw the following conclusions:
(i) Meteorological “bombs” are not unusual over the Mediterranean Basin during the winter season. (ii) “Bombs” can be produced by two different dynamic processes, and the process proposed by Karakostas and Flocas (1983) appears to occur more frequently than that proposed by Capaldo et al. (1980). (iii) Statistical analysis indicates that the greatest number of events occurs in the central Mediterranean, while a secondary maximum is found over the Aegean Sea. This distribution suggests a possible role of Alpine orography in triggering these events. (iv) In recent years an increase of the atmospheric pressure over the central and western basin has been recorded. This appears to be associated with a trend in which the annual number of “bombs” has been reduced. (v) Meteorological “bombs” can have serious impacts on agricultural settlements, damaging the terrain and reducing crop production.
3
HEAT WAVES IN THE CENTRAL MEDITERRANEAN BASIN
3.1 Introduction During the warm season (from June to September) over large areas of the Mediterranean Basin, the air temperature sometimes increases up to several degrees above the normal value. These hot spells can either be sudden and very intense, but of short duration (3–5 days), or more gradual and less intense, but of long duration (i.e. 10 days or more). Studies regarding such phenomena over Greece and surrounding regions of the eastern Mediterranean have been made by Karapiperis and Mariopoulos (1956), who defined these thermal events as “heat waves”, and more recently by Metaxas and Repapis (1978) and Metaxas and Kallos (1980). For the central Mediterranean Basin a synoptic study was carried out by Conte (1986), who examined some specific cases. This chapter presents research that analyses all heat waves that occurred over the central Mediterranean during the period 1950–1995. The mechanisms of their development are outlined, essentially from the point of view of synoptic meteorology. A simple statistical presentation of all events has also been carried out. The study was focused on the central Mediterranean area, but, since the patterns leading to the heat waves are of western origin, most of them also influence the Iberian Peninsula, southern France and the coastal areas of north Africa and other Mediterranean countries. 3.2 Definition of the Short- and Long-lasting Heat Waves We define a short-lasting heat wave as a sudden and disruptive increase of air temperature, which, in three separate reference stations located in southern Italy, reached temperatures from 7 ◦ C to 15 ◦ C above the normal monthly mean computed for the period 1951–1980. This event usually has a
Extreme Climatic Events over the Mediterranean
21
Table 2.2 Incidence of short-term heat waves over the central Mediterranean (1950–1995), showing that the highest frequency occurs in July and August
June 19–21/1972 24–27/1982
July 04–07/1952 19–21/1956 11–13/1962 23–27/1962 03–05/1965 20–23/1967 08–11/1968 01–04/1981 30–01 Aug/1982 03–07/1985 23–27/1985 24–28/1987 04–08/1988 26–29/1992 03–06/1993
August
September
12–15/1952 11–13/1960 25–28/1960 03–06/1963 13–15/1963 03–05/1967 07–09/1970 06–08/1971 03–05/1981 20–24/1985 14–17/1989 03–07/1992
07–11/1962 11–14/1970 03–05/1974 03–06/1988 21–25/1995
Table 2.3 Incidence of longer term heat waves over the central Mediterranean (1950–1995)
June 16–28/1950 10–27/1952 09–22/1966 14–26/1970 08–17/1981 02–13/1983 19–30/1990 01–10/1993
July 14–23/1964 16–29/1969 07–16/1974 01–20/1982 13–02 Aug 1983 07–16/1984 11–21/1993 02–15/1994 15–28/1995
August 16–31/1967 01–14/1969 12–23/1971 27 July–12/1980 08–18/1981 27 July–16/1986 13–28/1987 25 July–14/1988 17–03 Sep/1991 25 Jul/08 1994
September 08–17/1951 15–28/1961 14–27/1975 19–27/1983 08–24/1987 08–18/1992
duration of about 3–5 days, and encompasses all of Italy, also reaching Corsica, Malta, the Adriatic side of the former Yugoslavia, Albania, part of Greece and North Africa. A list of all the heat waves of this type that occurred in the period 1950–1995 is shown in Table 2.2. The total number of events was 34, with 131 days influenced by these heat waves, and a mean duration of the phenomenon of about four days. In contrast, the long-lasting heat waves give rise to a gradual air temperature increase, with temperatures that are about 5 ◦ C higher than the normal monthly mean over most of the central basin, and lasting for 10 days or more. Table 2.3 shows that in the study period there were 33 events that influenced, with a mean duration of about 14 days, 462 days of the warm summer season. 3.3 Mechanism of Development of Heat Waves
Short-term Heat Waves The mechanism of development of short-term heat waves is outlined using a simple composite analysis of 12 events lasting four days, which is the mean duration of this kind of phenomenon,
22
Mediterranean Desertification
and a synoptic analysis of the meteorological patterns of an intense event that occurred during 24–27 June 1982. Figure 2.5 shows the pattern of the tropopause/maximum windspeed on 25 June 1982, in which the Subtropical Jet Stream (STJ) appears to be largely north of its normal position, which is in the southern sector of the basin. Following the divergence–vorticity relationship (Palmen and Newton 1969), on the right-hand side of the Jet Streak (the band of the maximum windspeed) a strong upper air convergence gives rise to downward vertical motion, which, in turn, produces warming by adiabatic compression of the atmosphere and, thus, the heat wave. When the STJ returns to its normal position the temperatures return to normal values. Since the latitudinal oscillations of the STJ occur rapidly and are short term, the associated heat waves have the same characteristics.
(a)
275
275
PJ 250
80 0 10
250
225 60
STJ
225 200
175 200 (b)
0
0
0
0 D
0.3
0.2 0
0.1
0.1
0
Figure 2.5 (a) Heat wave development. Tropopause/maximum wind pattern on 00 UTC of 25 June 1982. STJ, Subtropical Jet Stream; PJ, Polar Jet Stream; heights of tropopause (- - - - ) in hPa; isotachs in knots ( ). (b) Vertical motion (Pa s−1 ) on 06 UTC of 25 June 1982. Data from the European Centre for Medium Range Forecasting (ECMWF). Reproduced by permission from Societe` Italiane di Fisice
23
Extreme Climatic Events over the Mediterranean
Longer term Heat Waves The mechanism of development of the long-lasting heat wave is briefly analysed, taking as an example a case that occurred in July 1983. In this type of event the atmospheric circulation in the Euro-Atlantic region, outlined using the pattern at the 500 hPa level, is always characterized by a socalled “omega” pattern (due to its resemblance to the last letter of the Greek alphabet) moving very slowly from west to east (Figure 2.6). The southerly winds blowing between the western depression of the “omega” and the central anticyclonic ridge progressively invade the western and central parts of the Mediterranean. With this southerly flux there is usually associated a horizontal advection of very warm air masses moving from north Africa, which invade the basin, producing the increase in air temperature.
Comparison of Short-term and Longer Term Heat Waves All cases in Tables 2.2 and 2.3 were identified using both the temperature increases recorded in the three reference stations (as well as information for the whole central Mediterranean) and synoptic analyses similar to those outlined above for the two typical cases (Conte 1986). The clear similarities between meteorological patterns associated with the different situations permitted us to group events into short-term and longer term cases. In summary, the main difference between the two heat wave mechanisms is as follows: the shortterm heat waves are essentially determined by downward motion, although the adiabatic compression is exerted on a dome of warm air of African type. The longer term events are produced essentially by horizontal motions, especially if temporary and brief incursions of the STJ can reinforce the phenomenon by adiabatic compression. 3.4 Some Statistical Considerations on Mediterranean Heat Waves
During the study period (1950–1995) the number of summer-time days influenced by a short or longer term heat wave was 586. Since the total number of days in June, July, August and September (summer season) in the whole 46 years is 5612, about 10% of the summer period in the central Mediterranean was influenced by warming due to heat waves. This is an appreciable percentage and indicates that the phenomenon is not infrequent or exceptional and it should probably be considered as a feature of the Mediterranean summer. Table 2.4 summarizes the monthly distribution of the events, the number of days influenced by heat waves and their relative percentages. Two-thirds of the total number of events occur in July and August. The number of days affected by heat waves shows a difference between July and August. Short-term events tend to be more frequent in July, with more long-term events in August. The number of heat wave days in each year of the study period is reported in Table 2.5. The linear trend gives an increase, with a value of 0.4 days year−1 and the polynomial smoothing of seventh order indicates a 20-year oscillatory pattern. Interesting patterns do occur, and recently Colacino and Conte (1993a) detected in the pressure field over the central and western Mediterranean an oscillation having the Hale period (i.e. about 22 years), together with a clear increasing trend. This Table 2.4 Summary of heat wave events (1950–1995)
Month
No. of short-term events
No. of longer term events
Total number of events
% per summer month
No. of days affected by events
% per total summer days affected
June July August September
2 15 12 5
8 9 10 6
10 24 22 11
15 36 33 16
109 183 198 96
19 31 34 16
Total
34
33
67
100
586
100
58
15 JULY 46
L
58
L
82 H
82
52
64
64 70
24
8 JULY L
64 70
70 76
70
82
64
76
H
L 58
82
76 70
L
L
82 76 88
L
88
H
H
94 22 JULY
94 29 JULY
L 52
64 H
52
52
L
70
64
58
64
58 70
64
82 76
88
94 H
82
H 94
H
L
82
70
76 L
76
L
76 88
88 88
H 94
Figure 2.6 Development of the ‘‘omega pattern’’ at the 500 hPa level, producing the long-term heat wave of July 1983. Reproduced by permission from Societe` Italiane di Fisice
25
Extreme Climatic Events over the Mediterranean Table 2.5 Number of heat wave days during the years of the study over the study area
Year
No. of heat wave days
Year
No. of heat wave days
Year
No. of heat wave days
Year
No. of heat wave days
Year
No. of heat wave days
1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959
13 10 26 0 0 0 3 0 0 0
1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969
7 14 13 7 10 3 14 23 4 28
1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979
20 15 3 0 13 14 0 0 0 0
1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989
17 28 27 42 10 15 21 38 30 4
1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995
12 18 20 25 29 19
pattern of the pressure field was associated with an oscillatory, but progressive increase over the Mediterranean of the persistence of anticyclonic systems, particularly of the Azores anticyclone, over the last fifty years. Heat waves are strongly connected with anticyclonic patterns. A comparison of the number of days influenced by heat waves and the 500 hPa heights over Cagliari, Sardinia, which is in the core of the central basin, shows a general agreement between the two data sets, with low values during the 1950s and the 1970s and higher values in the 1960s and the 1980s. The correlation coefficient for the two data sets is 0.64, which is statistically significant at the 95% level. The heat waves produce very warm and dry environmental conditions, and prolonged drought can lead to desertification (Palutikof et al. 1996). In addition, dryness and high temperature can exacerbate ideal conditions for forest fires to rage out of control over large areas. Fires destroy crops, both forestry and agricultural, and can also destroy the ecological balance within the vegetation and fauna. Colacino and Conte (1993b) examined the pattern of forest fires in the Mediterranean region in connection with the number of heat waves. The number of heat waves recorded in the period 1980–1985 was about 70% higher than in the period 1970–1975, and a similar increase was recorded in the extension of forest burned in the regions of the Mediterranean Basin, for which data are available. Unfortunately more and more fires are started deliberately rather than naturally, but it is evident that the aridity of the soil and vegetation, and the warming associated with heat waves, play an important role in maintaining and extending the fires. Finally, it must be remembered that the heat waves can influence the health of the population, and mortality is often enhanced during these events. A study carried out for the heat wave of 13 July–2 August 1983 indicated that during and immediately after the warmest days, the number of deaths in Rome was 450 more than the normal average seasonal value (Todisco 1987). 3.5 Conclusions on Heat Waves
The following conclusions have been drawn: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v)
There exist two different types of heat wave: the first very intense and of short duration, the second less intense but of longer duration. These two heat wave types are associated with different meteorological patterns. In the study period (1950–1995) the total number of heat waves was 67: 34 short-term events and 33 long-term episodes. Heat waves occur in summer, most frequently in August. Analysis of heat wave events during the study period suggested a 20-year oscillatory pattern, with a superimposed trend of increasing incidence.
26
Mediterranean Desertification
(vi)
(vii)
4
4.1
This behaviour is similar to that found for the same period for atmospheric pressure in the western and central Mediterranean and a connection with the anticyclones in the basin is probable. The impacts of heat waves are important because they may contribute to drought, desertification and forest fires, and may negatively influence the health of the population.
SPACE – TIME PRECIPITATION PATTERNS IN THE WESTERN AND CENTRAL MEDITERRANEAN BASIN AND ANALYSIS OF EXTREME CASES Introduction
Many examples of climatological research are at present focused on climate evolution in association with anthropogenic enhancement of the greenhouse effect. Studies concerning the trend of increased air temperatures and the impact of this increase include those of Jones et al. (1986) and Hansen and Lebedeff (1987). Particular attention is devoted to the hydrological cycle and to the precipitation regime because a reduction in precipitation limits water resources, while increased events of intense rain could cause more frequent floods. Papers published on this subject at a global scale (Bradley and Groismann 1989; Diaz et al. 1989; Vinnikov et al. 1990) indicate that an increase in precipitation has been recorded at latitudes higher than 50 ◦ N, while at lower latitudes an opposite pattern is found. However, the regional analyses do not confirm this general picture, and give contradictory results (Kutiel 1991; Ben-Gai et al. 1994; Beniston et al. 1994; Groismann and Easterling 1994; Lettenmaier et al. 1994; Norsallah and Balling 1996). Several studies have been carried out in the Mediterranean Basin, but some do not refer to the recent period (Maheras 1988) and only a few papers give quantitative results (Palutikof et al. 1994). Here analysis of the trends of yearly and seasonal precipitation in the central and western Mediterranean is given for the period 1951–1995. The study area is subdivided into three latitudinal belts: northern (>42 ◦ N), central (38 ◦ N–42 ◦ N) and southern (<38 ◦ N). For every belt, a regional time series using the Thiessen method (Ven Te Chow 1964) has been obtained and the Standardized Anomaly Index (Nicholson 1983) has been calculated. In every belt a significant decrease in the precipitation amount has been found. At the seasonal scale the strongest reduction has been shown in winter. A detailed analysis of the extreme events was carried out for the core area of the typical Mediterranean climate, using monthly values. The results showed a decreasing trend, similar to the previous analysis. 4.2
Data Set
Precipitation patterns in the central and western Mediterranean Basin, for the period 1951–1995, have been analysed using data from the stations reported in Figure 2.7. There are annual data (September to August) for all stations and additional seasonal and monthly rainfall totals for 14 stations. Italian data have been provided from the Meteorological Service of the Italian Air Force, data for Spain, Portugal, Algeria, Tunisia from the respective National Services, and data for the other countries from the World Climate Disc (1992). Quality controls have been performed by the data-gathering institutions. 4.3
Annual and Seasonal Analysis of Data
In order to evaluate precipitation trends over the Mediterranean Basin, a regional series using Thiessen’s method was constructed. The method is suitable for calculating a weighting for each station with respect to the location of the different observatories, since they are not uniformly spaced. For this data series a decreasing trend for the annual total precipitation has been observed (Figure 2.8). For the study period 1951–1995, the reduction in annual precipitation was about 142 mm (about 21%), but this is a relatively short time span, and the picture could be different over a longer time period.
Extreme Climatic Events over the Mediterranean
27
Northern belt
Central belt
Southern belt
Figure 2.7 Stations used for annual (•) or annual plus seasonal () precipitation data analysis across three latitudinal belts. The most southerly station has not been included in annual analyses. Reproduced by permission from Societe` Italiane di Fisice
850
Precipitation (mm)
800 750 700 650 600 550 500 450 1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
Year
Figure 2.8 Regional precipitation series of the central and western Mediterranean Basin, obtained by the Thiessen method. The trend of decreasing precipitation since 1951 is very clear. Reproduced by permission from Societe` Italiane di Fisice
In addition to this analysis, in order to obtain a regional normalized series, the Standardized Anomaly Index (SAI) has been computed. This index can be evaluated since the distribution of the yearly values is nearly Gaussian. The trend of the SAI for the three latitudinal belts in Figure 2.7 indicates that in all the cases the precipitation decreased significantly (statistically significant). The index ranges from values higher than 0.25 to values lower than −0.25 (Nicholson 1983). A possible interpretation is associated with the increase, recorded for the same period over the central and western basin, of the atmospheric pressure both at the surface and at the upper levels. This trend is known as the Mediterranean Oscillation and has been analysed by Conte et al. (1989), Colacino and Conte (1993a) and Douguedroit (1994).
28
Mediterranean Desertification 2.0 Autumn 1.5 1.0
SAI
0.5 0.0 −0.5 −1.0 −1.5 −2.0 1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2.0 Winter 1.5 1.0
SAI
0.5 0.0 −0.5 −1.0 −1.5 −2.0 1940
1950
1960
1970 Year
1980
1990
2000
Figure 2.9 SAI trend for precipitation in autumn and winter, over the core area of the Mediterranean Basin since 1951. In winter the trend line exceeds the probability limits and the reduction in precipitation is statistically significant. Reproduced by permission from Societe` Italiane di Fisice
Precipitation analysis was then extended to look at seasonal behaviour in the core area of the Mediterranean climate (for stations marked by in Figure 2.7). The regional rainfall patterns over this part of the basin show trends of decreasing precipitation, but the reduction is not the same across all seasons, and tends to be greater in the cold season, in winter. In autumn the percentage reduction was 12.4%, in winter 29%, in spring 8.2% and in summer 6.7%. Figure 2.9 shows the trend for the SAI in autumn and winter. Only in winter was the reduction statistically significant. 4.4
‘‘Extreme’’ Monthly Events
Extreme precipitation events have also been investigated, using monthly data available for 14 stations in the core area of the typical Mediterranean climate. Mean monthly rainfall amounts for the 1951–1995 period have been computed and the most rainy month has been listed for each station. We have defined “extreme” as all the cases in which the monthly total precipitation in one station was higher than, or equal to, two times the mean precipitation value of the most rainy month,
Extreme Climatic Events over the Mediterranean
29
12
Number of events
10
8
6
4
2
0 1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
Years
Figure 2.10 The number of ‘‘extreme’’ precipitation events over the central Mediterranean Basin between 1951 and 1995. There is a trend of decreasing precipitation
Pi ≥ 2 Pim. Figure 2.10 shows the number of extreme episodes over the whole central Mediterranean Basin in the study period. The highest numbers were in 1959 (9 cases), in 1961 (7 cases), in 1966 (11 cases), in 1976 (8 cases), and in 1990 (7 cases). The linear trend shows a decreasing pattern, with a value of −0.06 cases year−1 (i.e. a reduction of 56.6% for the total 45 considered). 4.5 Conclusions on Extreme Events
The following conclusions have been drawn: (i)
The volume of annual precipitation received over the central and western Mediterranean Basin is decreasing. (ii) The SAI (Standardized Anomaly Index) trends for three latitudinal belts all show a statistically significant reduction in precipitation for the study period, 1951–1995. (iii) The seasonal analysis indicates that the rainfall decrease is mainly felt in winter. (iv) A decrease in the number of “extreme” precipitation events since 1951 has also been observed. These results indicate that there has been a decrease in the volume of precipitation over the central Mediterranean between 1951 and 1995. It is possible that this trend could be associated with human interventions in the environment, and the greenhouse effect (Frederick and Major 1997). However, for a true picture these trends would have to be analysed in the context of a much longer time-scale, as they may be merely part of a natural climatic variability. Unfortunately the long-term historical data for such an analysis is not available.
REFERENCES Anthes RA and Keiser D (1979) Test of a fine mesh model over Europe and United States. Monthly Weather Review 107, 963–984.
30
Mediterranean Desertification
Bassani M (1983) Brevi considerazioni su un ciclone a mesoscala nell’area mediterranea. Rivista di Meteorologia Aeronautica XLIII, 297–307. Ben-Gai T, Bitan A, Manes A and Alpert P (1994) Long term changes in annual rainfall patterns in Southern Israel. Theoretical and Applied Climatology 49, 59–67. Beniston M, Rebetez M, Giorgi F and Marinucci MR (1994) An analysis of regional climate change in Switzerland. Theoretical and Applied Climatology 49, 135–159. Bosart LF (1981) The President’s day snowstorms of 1819 February 1979. A subsynoptic scale event. Monthly Weather Review 109, 1004–1018. Bradley RS and Groismann PYa (1989) Continental scale precipitation variations in the 20th century. In Proceedings of the International Conference on “Precipitation Measurements”, WMO, Geneva, pp. 168–184. Capaldo M, Conte M, Finizio C and Todisco G (1980) A detailed analysis of a severe storm in the central Mediterranean: the case of the Trapani flood. Rivista di Meteorologia Aeronautica XL, 183–199. Colacino M and Conte M (1993a) Greenhouse effect and pressure patterns in the Mediterranean Basin. Nuovo Cimento C 16, 67–76. Colacino M and Conte M (1993b) Clima mediterraneo ed incendi boschivi, Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche, Istituto di Fisica dell’Atmosfera, Report 93-50. Conte M (1986) Short-lasting heat waves in the central Mediterranean. WMO Long-Range Forecasting Research Report, WMO/TD no. 87, pp. 146–152. Conte M, Giuffrida A and Tedesco S (1989) The Mediterranean Oscillation: impact on precipitation and hydrology in Italy. Conference on Climate and Water 1, Publications of the Academy of Finland 9/89, pp. 121–137. Diaz HF, Bradley RS and Eischeid JK (1989) Precipitation fluctuations over global land areas since the late 1800s. Journal of Geophysical Research 94, 1195–1210. Douguedroit A (1994) Regionalization of the precipitation in the Mediterranean Basin: Mediterranean Oscillation? Meeting on Atmospheric Physics and Dynamics in the Analysis and Prognosis of Precipitation Fields, Rome, 15–18 November. Frederick KD and Major DC (1997) Climate change and water resources. Climatic Change 37, 7–23. Groisman PY and Easterling DR (1994) Variability and trends of total precipitation and snowfall over the United States and Canada. Journal of Climatology 7, 184–205. Hansen J and Lebedeff S (1987) Global trends of measured surface air temperature. Journal of Geophysical Research 29(D11), 13 345–13 372. Jones PD, Wigley TML and Wright PB (1986) Global temperature variations between 1861 and 1984. Nature 322, 430–434. Karakostas TS and Flocas AA (1983) The development of the ‘bomb’ over the Mediterranean area. Proceedings of “Blue Water Green Water” meeting, Marseille. Karapiperis L and Mariolopoulos E (1956) On the annual march of the air temperatures in Athens and their anomalies. Publ Met, University of Athens. Kutiel H (1991) Recent spatial and temporal variations in mean sea level pressure over Europe and the Middle East and their influence on the rainfall regime in the Galilee, Israel. Theoretical and Applied Climatology 44, 151–166. Lauteri P, Conte M and Mancino L (1974) Some synoptic aspects of an advective storm over the southern Thyrrenian sea, 25 October 1973. Proceedings of the Regional Training Seminar “Meteorological Services to Marine and Coastal Activities”, WMO, Rome, 1–12 April 1974. Instituto di Fisica del’ Atmosfera–Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche, Rome, pp. 372–382. Lettenmaier DP, Wood EF and Wallis JR (1994) Hydro-climatological trends in the continental United States, 1948–88. Journal of Climatology 7, 586–607. Maheras P (1988) Changes in precipitation conditions in the Western Mediterranean over the last century. Journal of Climatology 8, 179–189. Mansfield DA (1974) Polar lows: the development of baroclinic disturbances in cold air outbreaks. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society 100, 312–328. Metaxas DA and Kallos G (1980) Heat waves from a synoptic point of view. Rivista di Meteorologia Aeronautica XL, 107–119. Metaxas DA and Repapis CC (1978) Large warm advection over Athens: a climatological and synoptic study. Archives f¨ur Meteorologie, Geophysik und Bioklimatologie B 26, 51–61. Mullen SL (1983) Explosive cyclogenesis associated with cyclones in polar air streams. Monthly Weather Review 111, 1537–1548. Nicholson SE (1983) Subsaharan rainfall and the years 1976–80: evidence of continued drought. Monthly Weather Review 111, 1646–1654.
Extreme Climatic Events over the Mediterranean
31
Norsallah HA and Balling RC (1996) Analysis of recent climatic changes in the Arabian Peninsula Region. Theoretical and Applied Climatology 53, 245–252. Palmen E and Newton CW (1969) Atmospheric Circulation Systems. Academic Press, New York. Palutikof JP, Goodess CM and Guo X (1994) Seasonal scenarios of the change in potential evapotranspiration due to the enhanced greenhouse effect in the Mediterranean Basin. International Journal of Climatology 14, 853–869. Palutikof J, Conte M, Casimiro Mendes J, Goodess CM and Espirito Santo F (1996) Climate and climatic change. In CJ Brandt and JB Thornes (eds) Mediterranean Desertification and Land Use. John Wiley, Chichester, pp. 43–86. Sanders F and Gyakum JR (1980) Synoptic dynamic climatology of the ‘bomb’. Monthly Weather Review 108, 1589–1606. Todisco G (1987) Indagine biometeorologica sui colpi di calore verificatisi a Roma nell’estate del 1983. Rivista di Meteorologia Aeronautica XLII, 189–197. Ven Te Chow PhD (1964) Handbook of Applied Hydrology (a compendium of water resources technology). McGraw Hill, New York. Vinnikov KYa, Groismann PYa and Lugina KM (1990) Empirical data of contemporary global climate changes (temperature and precipitation). Journal of Climatology 3, 662–677. World Climate Disc (1992) University of East Anglia. Chadwyck & Healey (global climatic change data on CD-ROM).
3
Potential Effects of Rising CO2 and Climatic Change on Mediterranean Vegetation
C.P. OSBORNE AND F.I. WOODWARD
Department of Animal and Plant Sciences, University of Sheffield, UK
1 INTRODUCTION The Mediterranean climate is characterized by seasonal variations in temperature and precipitation that result in a cool, wet winter and a hot, dry summer. In common with other dry climates, precipitation events are highly irregular and total precipitation varies considerably between years, resulting in a high frequency of drought (Ehleringer and Mooney 1983). Vegetation throughout the Mediterranean Basin is therefore adapted to periodic drought, being dominated by evergreen broadleaved species, which are typically deep-rooted and characterized by sclerophyllous leaves with adaptations for minimizing water loss and damage due to high temperatures (Archibold 1995). Water availability strongly limits net primary productivity in sclerophyllous vegetation, for example, net photosynthesis in Quercus suber declined by around 75% at a site in Portugal as a consequence of declining soil water potential (Tenhunen et al. 1987). The structure of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation also varies significantly within the region, from sparse shrubland with a low stature, to forest which can reach 15 m in height, partly as a consequence of geographical variation in water availability (e.g. Lossaint 1973; Merino et al. 1990). Sclerophyllous shrubs and trees are gradually replaced by drought-deciduous shrubs and tussock grass steppe towards the warmer, drier parts of the region, where the summer drought period increases in duration and intensity, and by winter-deciduous trees in cooler, wetter areas, particularly at high altitudes (Tomaselli 1981; Woodward 1987). Water availability is therefore important in controlling both the productivity and structure of Mediterranean vegetation. Atmospheric CO2 is predicted to rise from its current concentration of 350 ppm to between 450 and 550 ppm by the middle of the 21st century (Schimel et al. 1996), and this increase is likely to have significant impacts on the structure and functioning of global vegetation (Betts et al. 1997). Climatic changes in the Mediterranean region are expected to accompany rising CO2 . Briefly, mean annual temperature is likely to rise by around 1.2 ◦ C by 2050 (Mitchell et al. 1995), and total precipitation is likely to decline, although the magnitude of this decrease is uncertain (Palutikof et al. 1994). However, increasing evaporation resulting from the rise in temperature is likely to cause a decline in soil water availability, irrespective of changes in precipitation (Palutikof et al. 1994). Understanding relationships between soil water availability and the effects of rising CO2 concentration will therefore be critical for predicting the future impact of climatic change on the productivity and structure of Mediterranean vegetation. This chapter explores some potential interactive effects of varying soil water and rising CO2 on Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation. First, results are reviewed from experiments that have investigated the effects of elevated CO2 on natural stands of sclerophyllous vegetation. Second, modelling approaches are used to examine interactions between rising CO2 and variation in soil water availability at a range of spatial and temporal scales. Mediterranean Desertification: A Mosaic of Processes and Responses. Edited by N.A. Geeson, C.J. Brandt and J.B. Thornes 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
34
2
Mediterranean Desertification
RISING CO2 AND WATER RELATIONS IN MEDITERRANEAN SCLEROPHYLLOUS SHRUBS
Experiments testing the effects of elevated CO2 on natural stands of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation have been mainly conducted at sites in central Italy, and have used CO2 springs and open-top chambers to provide high CO2 environments during growth. CO2 springs are the vents for deep geothermal CO2 sources, and vegetation surrounding them has been exposed to elevated CO2 concentrations probably for many hundreds of years (Miglietta et al. 1993). Open-top chambers consist of transparent plastic cylinders that surround clumps of natural vegetation in situ, and atmospheric CO2 concentration is controlled using a vertical flow of air through the chamber. Results from both sets of studies suggest that the responses of Mediterranean vegetation to high CO2 may be similar to those of woody plants in general, and indicate interactions between CO2 concentration and plant water relations. Elevated CO2 concentration can indirectly affect plant water relations by causing stomatal closure, but decreased stomatal conductance does not necessarily result in reduced transpiration in stands of vegetation. Canopy boundary layer conductance may be low relative to stomatal conductance, resulting in feedbacks which tend to stabilize transpiration, and increased canopy leaf area may compensate for lower rates of water loss per unit area (Field et al. 1995). Reduced transpiration at elevated CO2 does result in slower decreases in soil water during drought periods in some experiments (e.g. Field et al. 1995). However, the effect of high CO2 on soil water availability for Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation varies between studies. Soil water availability can be assessed using measurement of pre-dawn plant water potential, which provides an indirect estimate of soil water potential, provided that the plant has reached equilibrium with the soil overnight (Richter 1997). High CO2 generally leads to decreases in leaf stomatal conductance, but responses are highly variable in woody species, varying between season and species in Mediterranean sclerophyllous shrubs (Morison 1985; Curtis and Wang 1998). Elevated CO2 led to a decline in stomatal conductance compared with controls during the spring in Arbutus unedo, but had no effect during the summer drought period, when conductance was low irrespective of CO2 concentration (Jones et al. 1995). However, the pre-dawn water potential of shoots was higher during the summer in elevated CO2 than controls, suggesting higher soil water potential (Jones et al. 1995). Stomatal conductance also decreased at elevated CO2 in Pistacea lentiscus during the spring, but was unchanged in Quercus ilex and Phyllirea angustifolia at the same site (Scarascia-Mugnozza et al. 1996a). The pre-dawn water potential in Q. ilex shoots was lower at elevated CO2 during the summer drought in this mixed stand of sclerophyllous shrubs (Scarascia-Mugnozza et al. 1996a). In contrast, there was no effect of elevated CO2 on pre-dawn water potential or stomatal conductance in Q. ilex a month earlier at a nearby site, and decreases in transpiration were inferred from sap flow measurements (Tognetti et al. 1996). Effects of CO2 concentration on soil water potential under stands of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation therefore vary significantly between sites. Some of this variation can be attributed to differences between species in the sensitivity of stomatal conductance to CO2 , but other factors also seem to be involved. Photosynthesis in the growth environment of plants with the C3 photosynthetic pathway is usually higher in elevated CO2 than in ambient CO2 controls (Drake et al. 1997). Results from a range of Mediterranean sclerophyllous species fit this general pattern, showing a stimulation of leaf photosynthesis at elevated CO2 , irrespective of water availability, and with no evidence of acclimation of the photosynthetic system (Jones et al. 1995; Scarascia-Mugnozza et al. 1996b). A combination of increased photosynthesis without change or with a decrease in stomatal conductance results in higher instantaneous water-use efficiency (CO2 -uptake per unit water loss) at elevated CO2 , and can lead to higher growth rates in Mediterranean sclerophyllous shrubs. Branch volume in Q. ilex shrubs was significantly higher than in controls after three years’ growth in open-top chambers at elevated CO2 , but was lower than controls in Q. ilex trees growing in a CO2 spring (Scarascia-Mugnozza et al. 1996a; H¨attenschwiler et al. 1997a). However, trunk volume in the latter trees was greater than in controls (H¨attenschwiler et al. 1997a). The relative effect of elevated CO2 on trunk size was greatest
Effects of Rising CO2 and Climatic Change on Vegetation
35
in younger trees, and in years with a dry spring period, suggesting that increased water-use efficiency has an important effect on the growth of Q. ilex at high CO2 (H¨attenschwiler et al. 1997b). Results from the experimental studies reviewed here provide a basis for suggesting potential responses of vegetation in central Italy to future increases in CO2 concentration, and highlight mechanisms that could be involved in interactions between elevated CO2 and soil water availability. However, extrapolation of these findings to the whole Mediterranean region, and over longer time-scales, requires the use of dynamic simulation models. The remainder of this chapter uses a mechanistic simulation model of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation to examine potential interactions between rising CO2 concentration and variation in water availability, at a range of spatial and temporal scales. Mechanistic models integrate the current understanding of vegetation responses to the environment, and allow the predictive power of this understanding to be assessed by comparison of model results with real observations. Given a satisfactory explanation of vegetation responses in terms of underlying mechanisms, models then provide a method for extrapolation to the future, and for examining the potential effects of rising CO2 and climatic change scenarios.
3 REGIONAL VARIATION IN RESPONSES OF MEDITERRANEAN SHRUBS TO RISING CO2 Experimental studies in Italy suggest interactions between high CO2 concentrations and the water relations of sclerophyllous shrubs. Stomatal conductance declines at elevated CO2 in some species, with important potential effects on transpiration and therefore soil water availability (see section 2 above). However, these effects on transpiration may be mediated at the canopy level by changes in leaf area which result from increased productivity and water-use efficiency at high CO2 . In addition, results from experimental studies suggest that stomatal conductance may be insensitive to CO2 in other species (section 2). This section explores potential interactions between elevated CO2 , stomatal conductance, leaf area, transpiration and soil water potential, and their implications for productivity and biomass, using the MEDRUSH vegetation model, which is a dynamic, mechanistic simulation model. The MEDRUSH vegetation model was developed for simulating primary production and water use in Mediterranean sclerophyllous shrub vegetation, using only standard meteorological data and CO2 concentration as inputs (see MEDRUSH in Chapter 18). The model successfully predicted 57% of biomass observations (n = 14), 80% of net primary productivity (NPP) observations (n = 5) and 77% of leaf area index (LAI) observations (n = 13) within an estimate of their 95% confidence interval, for sites throughout the Mediterranean region. The model was used to test the hypothesis that decreases in stomatal conductance at elevated CO2 will lead to a decline in transpiration and an increase in soil water potential in stands of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation. The hypothesis was tested at three sites in the western Mediterranean Basin where model predictions of biomass, NPP and LAI were within the confidence interval for observations at each site. Water availability varied significantly between these sites because of regional variation in precipitation and potential evapotranspiration. The effects of an elevated CO2 concentration of 500 ppm were tested by running the model to equilibrium, which was defined as being when total biomass varied by less than 1% in consecutive years. Stomatal conductance (gs ) either declined by 18% at high CO2 (+CO2 , −gs ), or was insensitive to CO2 (+CO2 , = −gs ). Climate input data for the model consisted of a single year of long-term monthly means for Murcia (south-east Spain), Seville (south-west Spain) and Perpignan (southwest France), which were used repeatedly until equilibrium (M¨uller 1982). Annual precipitation and mean annual temperature were 304 mm and 18.0 ◦ C for Murcia, 535 mm and 18.8 ◦ C for Seville, and 639 mm and 12.5 ◦ C for Perpignan, and the sites therefore differed significantly with respect to climate, particularly precipitation. Biomass was always higher at elevated CO2 than in the control, irrespective of the site, or sensitivity of stomata to CO2 (Figure 3.1). When stomatal conductance declined at elevated CO2 , the increase in biomass was due to a rise in NPP, which varied from 32% for Murcia to 17% for
2
200
1
0
100
M
S Site
P
M
S Site
P
NPP (g m −2 year −1)
Mediterranean Desertification Biomass (kg m −2 )
36
0
LAI (m2 m−2)
300 200
1
100 0
M
S Site
P
Control + CO2, − gs + CO2, = gs
M
S Site
P
Transpiration (mm year −1)
2
0
M = Murcia S = Seville P = Perpignan
Figure 3.1 Potential effects of elevated CO2 on sclerophyllous vegetation at three sites in the western Mediterranean Basin: Murcia (south-east Spain), Seville (south-west Spain) and Perpignan (south-west France). Equilibrium model simulations of mean annual above-ground biomass, net primary productivity (NPP), mean annual leaf area index (LAI) and transpiration are shown for each. Model simulations tested the effects of an elevated CO2 concentration of 500 ppm with either an 18% decrease (+CO2 , −gs ) or no change (+CO2 , = gs ) in stomatal conductance compared with the control. CO2 in the control simulations remained at the current ambient concentration of 350 ppm
Seville, and 21% for Perpignan (Figure 3.1). The rise in NPP at elevated CO2 was accompanied by a decline in annual transpiration for Murcia (12%) and Seville (15%), but an increase in annual transpiration for Perpignan (8%) (Figure 3.1). Results therefore illustrate that a reduction in stomatal conductance does not necessarily result in decreased transpiration. In the case of Perpignan, this was because LAI was higher throughout the year at elevated CO2 than in the control (Figures 3.1 and 3.2). Model results also show that the decrease in total transpiration that can accompany a decline in stomatal conductance at elevated CO2 does not necessarily result in higher soil water potential. Reduced annual transpiration at elevated CO2 was associated with a higher soil water potential for Seville, but lower soil water potential for Murcia during the spring and summer (Figure 3.2). This discrepancy could be explained by seasonal patterns of transpiration. Transpiration followed similar seasonal patterns in elevated CO2 and the control for Seville, although it was lower throughout the year at elevated CO2 because of reduced stomatal conductance (Figure 3.2). However, transpiration was higher at elevated CO2 than in controls during the spring in Murcia, and soil water potential therefore declined more rapidly (Figure 3.2). This increase in transpiration occurred despite the decrease in stomatal conductance, and could be attributed to a higher LAI (Figure 3.2). During the summer, LAI declined markedly at elevated CO2 , and reached a value that was lower than the control (Figure 3.2). This change was accompanied by a decline in transpiration and a faster recovery of soil water potential from the summer drought at elevated CO2 than the control (Figure 3.2). Results therefore highlight the importance of considering seasonal variation in the responses of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation to high CO2 .
37
Murcia
Seville
Perpignan
2 1
LAI (m2 m −2 )
0 2
Water potential (MPa)
Transpiration (mm day −1)
Effects of Rising CO2 and Climatic Change on Vegetation
0
1 0
−2 −4 Jan Apr Jul
Oct
Month Control;
Jan Apr Jul Month +CO2,− gs;
Oct
Jan Apr Jul
Oct
Month +CO2, = gs
Figure 3.2 Seasonal variation in the effects of elevated CO2 on water relations of sclerophyllous vegetation at three sites in the western Mediterranean Basin: Murcia (south-east Spain), Seville (south-west Spain) and Perpignan (south-west France). Equilibrium model simulations of transpiration rate, leaf area index (LAI) and soil water potential are shown for each. Model simulations tested the effects of an elevated CO2 concentration of 500 ppm with either an 18% decrease (+CO2 , −gs ) or no change (+CO2 , = gs ) in stomatal conductance compared with the control. CO2 in the control simulations remained at the current ambient concentration of 350 ppm
Annual transpiration for Murcia and Seville also decreased at elevated CO2 when stomatal conductance was insensitive to CO2 concentration (Figure 3.1). In both cases this was because LAI was lower at elevated CO2 than in the control, especially during the summer drought period (Figure 3.2). This resulted in soil water potential being greater during the summer at elevated CO2 than in controls, despite the insensitivity of stomatal conductance to CO2 concentration (Figure 3.2). A different pattern occurred for the Perpignan site, where high CO2 concentrations led to an increase in transpiration when stomatal conductance was unchanged (Figure 3.1). This resulted in a more rapid decline in soil water potential at elevated CO2 (Figure 3.2). Annual NPP was unchanged or higher at elevated CO2 for all sites when stomatal conductance was insensitive to CO2 (Figure 3.1). In addition, biomass was greater at elevated CO2 through higher NPP or reduced rates of litter production (Figure 3.1). However, the increase in biomass at elevated CO2 was always greater when stomatal conductance also decreased (Figure 3.1). The hypothesis that declining stomatal conductance will lead to higher soil water potential at elevated CO2 was tested. MEDRUSH simulations for three sites in the western Mediterranean Basin suggested that this hypothesis is not generally applicable. Indeed, at the Murcia site, soil water potential was lower at elevated CO2 during the summer when stomatal conductance declined, but higher when conductance remained unchanged (Figure 3.2). Model simulations suggested that the relationship between stomatal conductance, transpiration and soil water potential at elevated CO2 is complex, site-specific and mediated by seasonal changes in LAI (Figure 3.2). Simulation of LAI is dynamic in the MEDRUSH vegetation model and depends on a range of interacting factors. Leaf growth depends on flushes during the spring which utilize stored carbohydrate, and NPP, which depends on the balance between canopy photosynthesis and respiration. Leaf loss depends on the rate of litter production, which increases when carbohydrate stores decline to starvation levels during drought periods. Some potential interactions between these processes at elevated CO2
38
Mediterranean Desertification
are explored later in this chapter (section 5). However, the next section examines the potential for rising CO2 concentration to offset the adverse effects of long-term decreases in water availability. Model simulations for Murcia, Seville and Perpignan all indicated an increase in annual wateruse efficiency (NPP/transpiration) at elevated CO2 , irrespective of whether stomatal conductance decreased (Figure 3.1). Increased water-use efficiency could allow a similar NPP to be maintained at elevated CO2 using less water.
4
RISING CO2 AND LONG-TERM DECLINE IN WATER AVAILABILITY
The Mediterranean Basin is likely to become more arid in future because of a regional increase in evaporation, accompanied by declining precipitation in some areas (Palutikof et al. 1994; Segal et al. 1994). However, adverse effects of decreasing water availability on primary production could be offset by increasing water-use efficiency, resulting from the concurrent rise in CO2 concentration. Here, we use the MEDRUSH vegetation model to quantify the extent to which rising CO2 concentration could offset the adverse effects of decreasing precipitation. The study focuses on south-east Spain, an area where the MEDRUSH model has been tested, aridity has increased since pre-industrial times, and precipitation is likely to decline in future (Palutikof et al. 1994; Araus et al. 1997). Simulations test a range of CO2 and precipitation scenarios, and their interacting effects on simulated shrub biomass in south-east Spain. Future increases in CO2 concentration will depend on global changes in anthropogenic emissions, which are largely under political control. Uncertainty in predicting future changes in precipitation arises from unreliability in the predictive power of general circulation models (GCMs) of climate. The UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) have used state-of-the-art global carbon cycle models to predict atmospheric CO2 in the 21st century. Future scenarios of CO2 emissions in these models depended on a range of political factors, and resulted in modelled CO2 concentrations for 2050 of between 450 and 550 ppm (Leggett et al. 1992; Schimel et al. 1996). This range was therefore used for model runs, in order to test the potential range of future vegetation responses. A temperature increase of 1.2 ◦ C in 2050 was used in all model runs (Mitchell et al. 1995); however, sensitivity of simulated biomass to increasing temperature is low compared with sensitivity to CO2 or precipitation (results not shown). A range of changes in precipitation were tested, from no change to a maximum decrease of 25% in 2050, encompassing projected decreases for south-east Spain from a range of studies (Palutikof et al. 1994; Rotmans et al. 1994; Jones et al. 1996). Modifications in climate and CO2 were all imposed as linear changes from the present day to 2050. In contrast to the previous section, the MEDRUSH model was run using a transient climate, and control climate data were a daily mean series from the Alcantarilla meteorological station. Simulations therefore accounted for inter-annual variability in climate. If CO2 remained constant, decreases in precipitation below about 5% in 2050 led to a decline in simulated biomass (‘+Temperature’, Figure 3.3). A 25% decline in precipitation in 2050 caused a 40% decline in simulated biomass (‘+Temperature’, Figure 3.3). Future effects of increasing aridity on sclerophyllous vegetation in south-east Spain could therefore be very significant in the absence of rising CO2 . However, rising CO2 concentrations partially offset these adverse effects of drought in the region. Biomass remained unchanged compared with the control simulation if precipitation declined by 14% and CO2 rose to 450 ppm in 2050 (lower limit of ‘Rising CO2 ’ range, Figure 3.3), the lowest concentration suggested by the IPCC. Similarly, a 19% reduction in precipitation in 2050 had no effect on biomass if it was accompanied by an increase in CO2 concentration to 550 ppm (upper limit of ‘Rising CO2 ’ range, Figure 3.3), the highest concentration suggested by the IPCC. Vegetation model simulations therefore indicate that a rising CO2 concentration has the potential to completely offset the adverse effects of increasing aridity suggested for the Mediterranean by regional climate models. However, the extent to which this occurs will depend critically on the magnitude of both increases in CO2 concentration and decreases in precipitation in the region. Experiments on Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation at high CO2 suggest that productivity could be greater (on a relative basis) when water availability is low, since elevated CO2 increases water-use efficiency, and can potentially decrease the rate of water use (see sections 2 and 3). A
39
Effects of Rising CO2 and Climatic Change on Vegetation 40 Rising CO2
Change in biomass (%)
20
0
−20
+ Temperature −40
−20
−10
0
Change in precipitation (%)
Figure 3.3 Potential change in the biomass of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation caused by climatic change, relative to a control with no change in climate. Climatic change was imposed as linear changes in climate inputs with time. Above-ground biomass was simulated for Alcantarilla in south-east Spain using the MEDRUSH vegetation model, and the responses to climate shown were calculated using mean values for the period 2041–2050. The dashed line indicates the effects of increasing temperature by 1.2 ◦ C in 2050 for a range of decreases in precipitation. Dotted lines delimit the range of effects of increasing CO2 concentration to between 450 and 550 ppm in 2050 (the full range of IPCC scenarios), in conjunction with temperature and precipitation changes
review of the effects of elevated CO2 on natural herbaceous vegetation suggested that this could be a general pattern (Koch and Mooney 1996). However, in the long-term model simulations described in this section, elevated CO2 had a similar relative effect on biomass irrespective of water availability (Figure 3.3). The next section explores this potential interaction between water availability and rising CO2 on shorter time-scales, and suggests mechanisms that may mediate this response in Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation.
5 ELEVATED CO2 AND SHORT-TERM VARIATION IN WATER AVAILABILITY Precipitation varies considerably between years in dry parts of the Mediterranean Basin, and the positive effect of elevated CO2 on primary productivity might therefore also show significant interannual variation, being greater in dry years than in wet years (on a relative basis) due to increased water-use efficiency and reduced rates of water use. In addition, long-term decreases in water availability might be expected to increase the positive effect of rising CO2 for the same reasons. Here, we tested the hypothesis that the relative effects of CO2 on primary productivity are inversely related to water availability on a time-scale of months to years. We used simulation results from the MEDRUSH model to compare the responses of spring and annual growth to water availability and elevated CO2 .
40
Mediterranean Desertification
The MEDRUSH vegetation model was run until 2050 for a site in south-east Spain, with the CO2 concentration rising to 500 ppm (IS92a), and with no change in temperature or precipitation. The CO2 concentration was then held constant, and the model run for a further 30 years. Results were compared from two consecutive years within this latter period, where annual precipitation differed markedly, being 300 mm in the first, “wet” year and 113 mm in the second, “dry” year. Long-term mean annual precipitation for the site was 289 mm, close to that in the “wet” year. In agreement with the general trend suggested by experiments (H¨attenschwiler et al. 1997b), elevated CO2 had a larger relative effect on NPP during the spring when water availability was low, than when water availability was high. NPP was 35% greater at elevated CO2 than the control in the dry year, but only 22% greater in the wet year (Table 3.1 and Figure 3.4). This could be explained by differences between years in the relative effect of elevated CO2 on photosynthesis. Total canopy photosynthesis in the spring rose by 21% at elevated CO2 in the wet year; however, this stimulation was more than 30% in the dry year (Table 3.1 and Figure 3.4). Interaction between water availability and CO2 concentration arose through a greater stimulation of both photosynthesis per unit leaf area and canopy leaf area index at elevated CO2 in the dry year (Table 3.1). This interaction was associated with increased water-use efficiency for growth (higher NPP for a given Table 3.1 Seasonal variation in the effects of an elevated CO2 concentration of 500 ppm, compared with a control (350 ppm), on model simulations of the physiology and structure of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation in south-east Spain. Results are shown for the spring and summer periods of two consecutive years where annual precipitation differed: 300 mm in the ‘‘wet’’ year and 113 mm in the ‘‘dry’’ year. Mean annual precipitation for the area was 289 mm
Wet Year
Spring (March–May) NPP (g m−2 ground area day−1 ) Total photosynthesis (g m−2 ground area day−1 ) Photosynthetic rate (g m−2 leaf area day−1 ) LAI (m2 m−2 ) Stomatal conductance (mmol m−2 leaf area s−1 ) Summer (June–August) Biomass in June (g m−2 ) Total respiration (g m−2 ground area day−1 ) Specific respiration rate (g CH2 O g−1 biomass) Wood biomass fraction (dimensionless) Biomass in August (g m−2 ) Whole Year NPP (g m−2 ground area day−1 )
Dry Year
Control
Elevated CO2
% Change
Control
Elevated CO2
% Change
0.80
0.97
22
0.32
0.43
35
6.4
7.7
21
2.6
3.5
32
17.6
20.4
16
4.8
5.7
20
0.56 77
0.62 58
0.35 123
0.36 93
3 −24
11 −24
468 5.9
596 7.1
27 21
426 3.1
563 4.2
0.007
0.006
−7
0.004
0.004
1
0.83
0.84
2
0.95
0.95
0
517
657
27
344
445
29
0.40
0.47
18
0.13
0.18
32
32 35
Effects of Rising CO2 and Climatic Change on Vegetation dry year
12 8 4 0 0 −4 −8
0 −1 −2 −3 −4
2 1
Biomass (g m −2)
0
Litter (g m −2 day −1)
NPP (g m −2 day −1)
Respiration (g m −2 day −1)
Photosynthesis (g m −2 day −1)
wet year
41
Aboveground
600 400 200
Storage
0
80
−2
60
−3
40
−4
20
−5
P (mm month−1) T air (°C)
Ψsoil (MPa)
0 −1
0 J FM A M J J A SO N D J FM AM J J A SO N D Month
Figure 3.4 Simulated effects of an elevated CO2 concentration of 500 ppm (solid symbols) compared with a control (350 ppm, open symbols) on canopy photosynthesis (g CH2 O m−2 day−1 ), maintenance respiration (g CH2 O m−2 day−1 ), above-ground net primary productivity (NPP, circles, g biomass m−2 day−1 ), above-ground litter production (triangles, g biomass m−2 day−1 ), above-ground biomass (circles, g m−2 ) and the mass of stored carbohydrate (squares, g m−2 ) for Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation in south-east Spain (all on a ground area basis). In all cases, fluxes that led to an increase in biomass are shown as positive values, and fluxes that led to a decrease in biomass are shown as negative values. Results are shown for two consecutive years with differing annual precipitation: 300 mm in the ‘‘wet’’ year and 113 mm in the ‘‘dry’’ year. Mean annual precipitation for the area was 289 mm. Seasonal changes in monthly precipitation (bars, mm), daily mean temperature (solid line, ◦ C) and soil water potential (lines with symbols, MPa) are also shown
42
Mediterranean Desertification
soil water potential) and reduced stomatal conductance during the spring at elevated CO2 (Table 3.1), but also with a slightly greater soil water potential during spring in the dry year (0.2 MPa; Figure 3.4). Underlying mechanisms for the interaction were therefore similar to those observed in experiments on Mediterranean sclerophyllous shrubs at elevated CO2 (section 2). Greater spring growth in Mediterranean sclerophyllous shrubs at elevated CO2 had important consequences for survival during the summer drought period. Total respiration during summer in the wet year was 21% greater at elevated CO2 , but 34% greater in the dry year (Table 3.1 and Figure 3.4). Increases in respiration were largely due to the greater respiring biomass at elevated CO2 compared with the control (Table 3.1). The respiration rate per unit mass was similar or lower in high CO2 , because of a higher proportion of biomass in woody organs, which have lower respiration rates than more metabolically active organs such as leaves and fine roots (Table 3.1). Stored carbohydrates are mobilized to provide the substrate for respiration during the summer when photosynthesis in Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation is limited by drought (Larcher 1995). However, in the dry year, carbohydrate stores were depleted before the end of the summer, and starvation of plant organs led to abscission of leaves and fine roots, and the progressive death of woody tissues, which formed litter (Figure 3.4). Since total respiration was higher at elevated CO 2 , litter production was also significantly greater (Table 3.1 and Figure 3.4). Although soil water potential during the summer was slightly lower at elevated CO2 than in the control, it was below the minimum water potential for photosynthesis in both (Figure 3.4; wilting point = −3.6 MPa), and would not have influenced the carbon balance. Greater rates of respiration and litter production during the summer partially offset the interactive effect of elevated CO2 and water availability during the spring. Biomass was 32% higher at elevated CO2 than in controls during June in the dry year, and 27% higher in the wet year (Table 3.1 and Figure 3.4). However, by the end of the summer this increase had fallen to 29% in the dry year, remaining unchanged in the wet year (Table 3.1). Seasonal changes in the effects of elevated CO2 therefore explain why elevated CO2 and annual precipitation do not have an interactive effect on simulated biomass at this site in south-east Spain. For the two-year example presented above, there was an interaction between water availability and NPP. Elevated CO2 stimulated NPP by 18% in the wet year, but by 32% in the dry year (Table 3.1). However, when 30 consecutive years from the model were considered, there was no interaction between CO2 and precipitation for annual NPP (Figure 3.5). A statistically significant correlation between stimulation of NPP in the spring and precipitation was observed, but the data showed considerable scatter (Figure 3.5). Why was the interaction between elevated CO2 and precipitation not apparent for annual NPP in the whole data set of 30 years? Two mechanisms can be suggested to explain the observed contrast between spring and annual NPP. First, as described above, the greater increase in respiration at elevated CO2 during dry years would have tended to offset the similar increase in photosynthesis. However, this mechanism cannot explain the whole discrepancy, since an interaction was still observed for the two years presented above as an example. Second, since elevated CO2 had only a minor effect on soil water potential, NPP fell to zero in response to water deficit at similar times in both elevated CO2 and the control (Figure 3.4). For extreme or long dry periods, therefore, elevated CO2 had no effect on NPP, and a similar effect would have occurred when photosynthesis was limited by low temperature (Long 1991). However, long wet periods would have allowed NPP to continue, leading to a positive effect of elevated CO2 on NPP for longer. In combination, these effects would have tended to reverse the expected interaction, leading to a greater effect of CO2 during wet than dry years, and seem to have been most pronounced during autumn (Figure 3.5). Trends for summer in the 30-year data set were intermediate to those in spring and autumn (Figure 3.5), and the CO2 effect on NPP during winter was limited by low temperature (not shown). In summary, model results for south-east Spain show that synergistic interaction between elevated CO2 and water availability does occur for photosynthesis and NPP when short periods are considered, especially during the spring. However, the interaction seems to vary significantly within and between seasons, and compensatory mechanisms during the dry season offset any interaction for annual NPP or biomass.
Effects of Rising CO2 and Climatic Change on Vegetation
43
Whole year 50
25
0
−25
0
200
400
600
Change in NPP due to elevated CO2 (%)
Precipitation (mm) Spring 100 75 50 25 0
−25 Autumn 100 75 50 25 0
−25
0
100
200 Precipitation (mm)
300
Figure 3.5 Inter-annual and seasonal variability in the effect of elevated CO2 on net primary productivity (NPP) for Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation in south-east Spain. The effect of elevated CO2 concentration (500 ppm) on simulated NPP is expressed relative to a control simulation (%). Variability is shown for annual NPP and NPP for the spring (March–May) and autumn (September–November), in relation to precipitation during the same periods (mm). Results are shown for 30 consecutive years. There was a statistically significant correlation between the relative change in NPP at elevated CO2 and precipitation for the spring (r 2 = −0.453, p = 0.014)
44
6
Mediterranean Desertification
CONCLUSIONS ON RISING CO2 AND WATER-USE
Experimental and model studies of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation at high CO2 suggest the following: 1. The rate of water loss from soil under stands of Mediterranean sclerophyllous shrubs may decrease with rising CO2 because of reduced rates of transpiration, and lead to higher water availability for vegetation during the summer drought period. Experimental studies have suggested that this decrease in transpiration can result from stomatal closure at elevated CO2 (section 2). In addition, model studies suggest that transpiration can also potentially decline because of a reduction in leaf area at elevated CO2 , irrespective of stomatal responses (section 3). However, responses are highly site-specific, and both experimental and model studies demonstrate that higher soil water potential is not an inevitable consequence of rising CO2 . Stomata may be insensitive to CO2 in some Mediterranean sclerophyllous species, and leaf area could potentially increase at elevated CO2 (sections 2 and 3). As a result, transpiration may be higher and soil water potential lower under stands of vegetation in a high CO2 world (sections 2 and 3). 2. The efficiency of water use in primary production increases with rising CO2 in Mediterranean shrub vegetation. Experimental studies indicate an increased water-use efficiency for both photosynthesis and growth (section 2), and model studies support this finding for a range of sites in the Mediterranean region, irrespective of whether total water use decreases at elevated CO2 (section 3). The result is that rising CO2 has the potential to partially alleviate the adverse effects of drought on primary production, even in areas where soil water availability could decrease (sections 3 and 4). This finding could be of crucial importance in the future with increasing aridity in the Mediterranean Basin, especially in areas where precipitation is predicted to decline (section 4). 3. Responses of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation to high CO2 vary on a seasonal and interannual basis in relation to soil water availability. Experimental studies indicate that stomata may be less sensitive to CO2 during the summer drought period than during the spring, when the majority of growth occurs in Mediterranean vegetation (section 2). Spring growth may be greater (on a relative basis) in dry years (section 2). In addition, model simulations suggest that the responses of transpiration, leaf area and soil water potential to high CO2 may also differ between spring and summer (section 3), and between years (section 5). Seasonal variation means that generalizations possible for other natural vegetation types may not be applicable to Mediterranean shrubs. In particular, the observation that effects of high CO2 on primary productivity (on a relative basis) may be greater when water availability is low, seems to be highly dependent on the time-scale under consideration. Model studies indicate that the interaction could potentially apply during the spring, but may be counteracted by vegetation processes occurring during the summer drought (section 5). In particular, relationships between respiration, storage and litter production seem to be important (section 5), and may underpin seasonal changes in water use (section 3). Understanding the effects of elevated CO2 on these processes may be critical to successful predictions of the structure and functioning of Mediterranean sclerophyllous vegetation in a high CO2 world.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank Dr D.J. Beerling for helpful comments and discussion during the course of this work. Climate data for the Alcantarilla meteorological station were provided by C. Goodess of the Climate Research Unit, University of East Anglia, UK.
REFERENCES Araus JL, Febrebo A, Buxo R, Camalich MD, Martin D, Molina F, Rodriguez-Ariza MO and Romagosa I (1997) Changes in carbon isotope discrimination in grain cereals from different regions of the western Mediterranean Basin during the past seven millennia. Palaeoenvironmental evidence of a differential change in aridity during the late Holocene. Global Change Biology 3, 107–118.
Effects of Rising CO2 and Climatic Change on Vegetation
45
Archibold OW (1995) Ecology of World Vegetation. Chapman & Hall, London. Betts RA, Cox PM, Lee SE and Woodward FI (1997) Contrasting physiological and structural vegetation feedbacks in a climate change simulation. Nature 387, 796–799. Curtis PS and Wang X (1998) A meta-analysis of elevated CO2 effects on woody plant mass, form, and physiology. Oecologia 113, 299–313. Drake BG, Gonz´alez-Meler MA and Long SP (1997) More efficient plants: a consequence of rising atmospheric CO2 ? Annual Review of Plant Physiology and Plant Molecular Biology 48, 607–637. Ehleringer JR and Mooney HA (1983) Productivity of desert and Mediterranean-climate plants. In OL Lange, PS Nobel, CB Osmond and H Zeigler (eds) Physiological Plant Ecology IV. Ecosystem Processes: Mineral Cycling, Productivity and Man’s Influence. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 205–231. Field CB, Jackson RB and Mooney HA (1995) Stomatal responses to increased CO2 : implications from the plant to the global scale. Plant, Cell and Environment 18, 1214–1225. H¨attenschwiler S, Miglietta F, Raschi A and K¨orner Ch (1997a) Morphological adjustments of mature Quercus ilex trees to elevated CO2 . Acta Oecologica 18, 361–365. H¨attenschwiler S, Miglietta F, Raschi A and K¨orner Ch (1997b) Thirty years of in situ tree growth under elevated CO2 : a model for future forest responses? Global Change Biology 3, 463–471. Jones MB, Brown JC, Raschi A and Miglietta F (1995) The effects on Arbutus unedo L. of long-term exposure to elevated CO2 . Global Change Biology 1, 295–302. Jones PD, Hulme M, Briffa KR, Jones CG, Mitchell JFB and Murphy JM (1996) Summer moisture availability over Europe in the Hadley Centre general circulation model based on the Palmer drought severity index. International Journal of Climatology 16, 155–172. Koch GW and Mooney HA (1996) Response of terrestrial ecosystems to elevated CO2 : a synthesis and summary. In GW Koch and HA Mooney (eds) Carbon Dioxide and Terrestrial Ecosystems. Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 415–429. Larcher W (1995) Physiological Plant Ecology. Ecophysiology and Stress Physiology of Functional Groups. Springer, Berlin. Leggett J, Pepper WJ and Swart RJ (1992) Emissions scenarios for the IPCC: an update. In JT Houghton, BA Callander and SK Varney (eds) Climate Change 1992. The Supplementary Report to the IPCC Scientific Assessment. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 69–95. Long SP (1991) Modification of the response of photosynthetic productivity to rising temperature by atmospheric CO2 concentrations. Has its importance been underestimated? Plant, Cell and Environment 14, 729–739. Lossaint P (1973) Soil–vegetation relationships in Mediterranean ecosystems of Southern France. In F di Castri and HA Mooney (eds) Mediterranean Type Ecosystems: Origin and Structure Chapman & Hall, London, pp. 199–210. Merino O, Martin MP, Martin A and Merino J (1990) Successional and temporal changes in primary productivity in two mediterranean scrub ecosystems. Acta Oecologia 11, 103–112. Miglietta F, Raschi A, Bettarini I, Resti R and Selvi F (1993) Natural CO2 springs in Italy: a resource for examining long-term response of vegetation to rising atmospheric CO2 concentrations. Plant, Cell and Environment 16, 873–878. Mitchell JFB, Johns TC, Gregory JM and Tett SFB (1995) Climate response to increasing levels of greenhouse gases and sulphate aerosols. Nature 376, 501–504. Morison JIL (1985) Sensitivity of stomata and water use efficiency to high CO2 . Plant, Cell and Environment 8, 467–474. M¨uller MJ (1982) Selected Climate Data for a Global Set of Standard Stations for Vegetation Science. Dr W Junk Publishers, The Hague. Palutikof JP, Goodess CM and Guo X (1994) Climate change, potential evapotranspiration and moisture availability in the Mediterranean Basin. International Journal of Climatology 14, 853–869. Richter H (1997) Water relations of plants in the field: some comments on the measurement of selected parameters. Journal of Experimental Botany 48, 1–7. Rotmans J, Hulme M and Downing TE (1994) Climate change implications for Europe – an application of the ESCAPE model. Global Environmental Change – Human and Policy Dimensions 4, 97–124. Scarascia-Mugnozza GE, De Angelis P, Matteucci G and Kuzminsky E (1996a) Carbon metabolism and plant growth under elevated CO2 in a natural Quercus ilex L. “Macchia” stand. In Ch K¨orner and FA Bazzaz (eds) Carbon Dioxide, Populations, and Communities. Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 209–230. Scarascia-Mugnozza GE, De Angelis P, Matteucci G and Valentini R (1996b) Long-term exposure to elevated [CO2 ] in a natural Quercus ilex L. community: net photosynthesis and photochemical efficiency of PS II at different levels of water stress. Plant, Cell and Environment 19, 643–654.
46
Mediterranean Desertification
Schimel D, Alves D, Enting I, Heimann M, Joos F, Raynaud D and Wigley T (1996) Radiative forcing of climate change. In JT Houghton, LG Meira Filho, BA Callander, N Harris, A Kattenberg and K Maskell (eds) Climate Change 1995: The Science of Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 65–131. Segal M, Alpert P, Stein U, Mandel M and Mitchell MJ (1994) Some assessments of the potential 2 × CO2 climatic effects on water balance components in the eastern Mediterranean. Climatic Change 27, 351–371. Tenhunen JD, Beyschlag W, Lange OL and Harley PC (1987) Changes during summer drought in leaf CO2 uptake rates of macchia shrubs growing in Portugal: limitations due to photosynthetic capacity, carboxylation capacity, and stomatal conductance. In JD Tenhunen, FM Catarino, OL Lange and WC Oechel (eds) Plant Response to Stress. Functional Analysis in Mediterranean Ecosystems. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 305–327. Tognetti R, Giovannelli A, Longobucco A, Miglietta F and Raschi A (1996) Water relations of oak species growing in the natural CO2 spring of Rapolano (central Italy). Annales des Sciences Foresti`eres 53, 475–485. Tomaselli R (1981) Relations with other ecosystems: temperate evergreen forests, mediterranean coniferous forests, savannahs, steppes and desert shrublands. In F di Castri, DW Goodall and RL Specht (eds) Ecosystems of the World 11. Mediterranean-type Shrublands. Elsevier Scientific, Amsterdam, pp. 123–130. Woodward FI (1987) Climate and Plant Distribution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
4
Use of NOAA-AVHRR NDVI Data for Climatic Characterization of Mediterranean Areas
GIOVANNI CANNIZZARO,1 FABIO MASELLI,2 LUCIANO CAROTI1 AND LORENZO BOTTAI3 1
Telespazio SpA, Roma, Italy IATA-CNR, Firenze, Italy 3 FMA, Campi Bisenzio, Firenze, Italy 2
1 INTRODUCTION The current debate on global environmental change has stimulated great research efforts related to the monitoring of vegetation dynamics over large areas. Vegetation in fact plays a fundamental role as an interface between atmosphere and land surface, and it is also a direct indicator of environmental conditions (Sellers et al. 1995). Several studies have therefore resorted to remotely sensed data as the only effective means for monitoring vegetation at wide scales (Richards 1993; Hall et al. 1995). Satellite-derived vegetation indices, in particular, are an appropriate tool with which to characterize the status and changes of vegetation cover (Bannari et al. 1995). Of these indices, one of the most popular is the NDVI (Normalized Difference Vegetation Index), which is computed as (near-infrared reflectance − red reflectance)/(near-infrared reflectance + red reflectance) The NDVI is a direct expression of plant photosynthetic activity and, when derived from NOAAAVHRR data, offers the greatest potential for vegetation monitoring at a global scale (Prince 1991). In a number of studies NOAA-AVHRR NDVI data have been related to several environmental parameters, such as green biomass, plant productivity and meteorological driving factors (Baret and Guyot 1991; Benedetti et al. 1994; Bannari et al. 1995). Rainfall in particular has been demonstrated to be the major controlling factor for NDVI development in semi-arid regions, which is mainly due to the dependence of the local vegetation cycles on precipitation levels (Maselli et al. 1993). The situation is more complex in temperate and Mediterranean environments, where vegetation development is controlled contemporaneously by thermal and pluviometric factors as well as by human activities on the territory. As regards Mediterranean areas, recent studies of our research group have shown that inter-year NDVI variations of homogeneous zones are mainly dependent on the thermal factor at the beginning of the growing season (January–March) and on the pluviometric factor during the arid season (July–September), but a strong variability exists related to climatic and land-use features (Caroti et al. 1995). This behaviour, clearly related to the main vegetation cycles in Mediterranean environments, can be a good starting point for the derivation of aridity indices from NDVI data. As is well known, several aridity indices have been proposed by classical authors for characterizing the mean climate of a region as well as inter-year variations (De Martonne 1948; Thornthwaite 1948). These indices are generally derived from parameters that are measured from meteorological stations, mainly daily or monthly temperature and rainfall. The extension of the climatic estimates over the land surface therefore becomes a fundamental issue, especially in topographically complex regions Mediterranean Desertification: A Mosaic of Processes and Responses. Edited by N.A. Geeson, C.J. Brandt and J.B. Thornes 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
48
Mediterranean Desertification
(Trewartha and Horn 1980). The definition of sound and straightforward relationships between these indices and NDVI data would provide such extended estimates with a high spatial resolution (1.1 × 1.1 km) and could also serve for the prompt delineation of inter-year aridity variations (Maselli et al. 1998). This is the objective of the research described here, carried out in a region in central Italy with typical Mediterranean features (Abruzzo). In the case study NDVI images have been related to meteorological data taken at five ground stations over eight years. Some preliminary processing has allowed the definition of the station pixels most suitable for comparison. Correlation analysis and environmental considerations have then been employed to define an optimum NDVI combination that minimizes unimportant land-use variations and can therefore be taken as an aridity index. This has finally been extended over the region for the eight study years (1986–1993) to depict the variations in aridity levels during this period.
2
STUDY AREA AND DATA
The Abruzzo Region (central Italy) was a primary test site for the MEDALUS II Project (Figure 4.1). The topography of the region varies from the coastal plains to the inner mountains, with the climate ranging from Mediterranean to cold sub-humid. The flat and hilly areas near the coast are mainly used for agriculture, while the mountains inland are mainly covered by deciduous woods and pastures. The AVHRR data, already in the form of NDVI, were taken from the archives of Telespazio (Rome, Italy) within the framework of the MEDALUS II Project. The standard procedure for the production of these data comprised the geo-referencing and pre-processing of the original images by
Abruzzo
Italy
Figure 4.1 Geographical position of the Abruzzo Region
Climatic Characterization of Mediterranean Areas
49
a cubic convolution algorithm, the radiometric calibration of the first two bands to derive apparent reflectances following Rao and Chen (1994), and the computation of NDVIs to finally obtain maximum value composites, MVCs (Holben 1986), on a monthly basis. The final products were therefore 12 monthly NDVI MVCs covering all of 1990, and these were used for the current analysis. Standard meteorological measurements (daily minimum and maximum temperatures and rainfall) were taken from the available stations of the regional service. Only five stations had complete records for the study period (Tornimparte, Alanno, Teramo, Santa Eufemia a Maiella and Castel del Monte) and from them monthly values of mean temperature and total rainfall were derived as a basis for further processing. The five stations were located in different environmental and climatic areas (from the coastal area with a Mediterranean climate to the cold sub-humid zone of the inland mountains), so that, even with a small number of stations, a good representation of the entire region could be assumed.
3 DATA PROCESSING 3.1 Computation of Aridity Indices
Since only temperatures and rainfall were available for the meteorological stations studied, these data were used to compute simplified aridity indices as proposed by classical authors. The first index was that of De Martonne (1948), IDM , which is based on the following summation: IDM =
12 i=1
Pi /(Ti + 10)
(1)
where Pi is the total rainfall in month i (mm), and Ti is the mean temperature in month i ( ◦ C). As can be easily understood, the De Martonne index is actually a pluviometric one, since its increase corresponds to a decrease in aridity level. The same can be said for the second index considered, the humidity index of Thornthwaite (1948), IT , which relies on a more sophisticated computation of the water balance through the concept of potential evapotranspiration (ETP): IT =
12 i=1
(Pi − ETPi )/ETPi
(2)
where ETPi is the total potential evapotranspiration in month i (mm), computed from the mean temperature. Both indices were computed for each study year (1986–1993) with the meteorological data of the five stations. The period of summation was kept different from the solar year (January–December) since it had to approximate the effects of climate on vegetation development. Thus, both indices were calculated with monthly data from October of one year to September of the following year, when the growing cycle of Mediterranean vegetation is generally finishing. 3.2 Correlation Analysis
The annual aridity indices from the five study stations were first regressed against the available NDVI data. A linearity in the relationship between the two variables was assumed based on the fact that the response of NDVI to vegetation limiting factors can be considered approximately linear within restricted ranges of variation (Maselli et al. 1993). The analysis also assumed that the effect of land-use variability was minor with respect to that of the limiting factors. This assumption is valid in only a few cases, so further processing to reduce the consequent disturbances was carried out in a subsequent phase (see below). For the analysis, more or less homogeneous areas with respect to vegetation features were first selected around the five meteorological stations. This was done by means of a cluster analysis carried out on the NDVI profiles as fully described in Caroti et al. (1995). About 10 pixels were selected containing each station, and the relevant monthly NDVI data were extracted. Linear regression
50
Mediterranean Desertification
analysis was finally applied to the NDVI data from January to September (during the growing cycles of vegetation) with respect to the climatic indices.
4
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Both climatic indices considered showed interesting correlations with the monthly NDVI levels. As can be seen from Table 4.1, negative correlations were found for the first months of the year, with a peak in February. The period April–May showed lower correlations, while high positive correlations were noted for the summer months, with a peak in July. Slightly higher correlations were found with the De Martonne index, and most of the correlation coefficients were significant at least at the 95% confidence level. These results can be interpreted on the basis of the previous study carried out on the same data set (Caroti et al. 1995). In that case it was found that temperature was positively correlated with NDVI at the beginning of the year and negatively correlated after the April–May period. The opposite trend was found for rainfall. On this basis, it can be hypothesized that the thermal factor contained in the climatic indices is most influential on the NDVI levels at the beginning of the season, while the pluviometric factor is dominant during the arid months. Since the effects of the two factors on the values of the indices are contrasting, the negative correlations at the beginning of the season and the positive correlations in summer can be understood. In effect, it is well known that in Mediterranean environments vegetation development is mainly limited by temperature in winter and by rainfall in summer (Pinna 1977). The scheme of Figure 4.2 shows typical NDVI profiles in Mediterranean and temperate environments of the northern hemisphere and can help in interpreting the results obtained. Typical NDVI profiles in temperate–humid areas show a marked increase in spring and a long plateau in summer when actual transpiration is at a maximum due to high temperatures and water availability. As the climate becomes more Mediterranean–arid, the vegetation growing cycle changes due to the increased actual transpiration in late winter–early spring, while a summer minimum appears due to increasing aridity. In practice, the transition from temperate–humid to Mediterranean–arid climates is accompanied by a primary decrease in vegetation activity in summer and a secondary increase in late winter. The trend is more confused in spring due to the interaction of different contrasting factors. This is obviously only a general scheme which can be strongly modified by several factors, particularly land-use differences. Such modifications can also help to explain why the correlation coefficients never reached very high values. Table 4.1 Correlation coefficients found between the two study aridity indices and the monthly NDVI data from January to September (1–9 = sequential months), with relevant significance levels (∗ = significant correlation, P < 0.05; ∗∗ = highly significant correlation, P < 0.01)
Month 1 De Martonne aridity index Thornthwaite aridity index
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
−0.59∗∗ −0.65∗∗
−0.49∗∗ −0.23
−0.39∗
0.72∗∗ 0.81∗∗ 0.83∗∗ 0.81∗∗
−0.54∗∗ −0.65∗∗
−0.52∗∗ −0.28
0.30
0.63∗∗ 0.76∗∗ 0.73∗∗ 0.73∗∗
Calculations are based on eight-year data from five weather stations. A unique De Martonne or Thornthwaite value is computed for each year and weather station and all the resulting values are regressed against the monthly values of NDVI. For example, the correlation coefficients in column 9 derive from a regression analysis between the NDVI September values of each of the eight years and the De Martonne or Thornthwaite values computed for each of the same eight years
51
Climatic Characterization of Mediterranean Areas 0.7 0.6
Mediterranean − arid 0.5
Temperate − humid
NDVI
∗∗ 0.4
Intermediate
0.3 Increasing aridity
∗ 0.2 0.1
∗
Thermal factor
∗∗
Pluviometric factor
0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Month
Figure 4.2 General scheme for the interpretation of vegetation development in relation to the prevalent climatic regime
These considerations hold both for spatial variations and for inter-year differences. They can therefore be a good starting point for the definition of an NDVI-derived index which can optimally approximate a climatic one. Such an index should possess the following desirable features: 1. 2. 3. 4.
easy derivability from monthly NDVI data; sound conceptual basis according to the previous discussion; reduction of the effects of land-use differences; maximization of the correlation with climatic indices.
On the basis of these points and of the results of the previous analysis, various combinations of winter (January–February) and summer (July–August) NDVI values were considered mainly in analogy with difference, ratio and normalized difference indices (e.g. a ratio-like index was computed as NDVIwinter /NDVIsummer ). Among these combinations, the highest correlations with the climatic indices were obtained using the following formula: INDVI = (NDVI7 + NDVI8 ) − (NDVI1 + NDVI2 )
(3)
where the subscripts refer to the sequential months. This new index responded to all the requirements mentioned and gave a high correlation coefficient with both traditional climatic indices (Figure 4.3). In practice, these correlations were very close to the global correlation coefficients obtained by multivariate regression analysis with all monthly NDVI data from January to September. As for the two traditional climatic indices, here also increases in INDVI correspond to decreases in aridity levels. The distribution of this “optimum” index in the eight study years (1986–1993) is shown in Figure 4.4. The high spatial variability of the index in the region can be appreciated, mainly related to its topographic features. Also, strong inter-year differences in the index can be noted, which are mostly due to different meteorological seasons.
5 CONCLUSIONS The current debate on the possible causes and effects of climate changes has enhanced the utility of aridity indices that were proposed by classical authors several decades ago. Conventional methods
52
Mediterranean Desertification (a)
100 90
r = 0.882
80 De Martonne Index
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0
−0.25
0.25
0.5
0.75
1
1.25
0.75
1
1.25
NDVI Index 3.0
(b)
r = 0.858
2.5
Thornthwaite Index
2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 0
−0.25
0.25
0.5
−0.5 −1.0 −1.5 NDVI Index
Figure 4.3 Linear regressions between the (a) De Martonne and (b) Thornthwaite climatic indices and the new index derived from NDVI data measured in the five study stations for the eight study years (both correlations are highly significant, P < 0.01)
of obtaining these indices are generally based on point measurements from meteorological stations. The collection of the input data, however, is not always easy and, in particular, the extension of the estimates on the land surface is usually problematic, especially in complex terrain. In this research a simple and straightforward methodology is presented to derive aridity estimates from NOAA-AVHRR NDVI data in temperate and Mediterranean areas. These data are available for most regions in the world at least on a monthly basis, and with a relatively high spatial resolution. Based on theoretical considerations and the correlations experimentally found for a region in central Italy, it has been hypothesized that a difference between NDVI levels measured in summer (when the effect of the pluviometric factor on vegetation prevails) and in winter (when the thermal factor mostly determines vegetation development) can be taken as an estimator of usual aridity indices.
Climatic Characterization of Mediterranean Areas
−1
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
0
53
1
Figure 4.4 Aridity maps of the Abruzzo Region derived from monthly NDVI data (NDVI7 + NDVI8 − NDVI1 − NDVI2 ) for the eight study years, 1986–1993
This hypothesis has been validated according to the De Martonne and Thornthwaite indices. More generally, it can be supposed that such an approach will work anywhere where the thermal factor is limiting for vegetation development in winter and the pluviometric factor is limiting in summer. In practice, the methodology could be applied to most areas with climate types ranging from Mediterranean–arid to temperate–cold.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The present work was partly funded by the EU MEDALUS II Project. The authors would like to thank the Coordinator of the MEDALUS research group in the Abruzzo Region, Dr Claudio Conese, and the Nuova Telespazio team and Dr Claudio Serafini, for their collaboration within the framework of the Project.
REFERENCES Bannari A, Morin D, Bonn F and Huete AR (1995) A review of vegetation indices. Remote Sensing Reviews 13, 95–120. Baret F and Guyot G (1991) Potentials and limits of vegetation indices for LAI and APAR assessment. Remote Sensing of Environment 46, 213–222. Benedetti B, Rossini P and Taddei R (1994) Vegetation classification in the Middle Mediterranean area by satellite data. International Journal of Remote Sensing 15, 583–596.
54
Mediterranean Desertification
Caroti L, Maselli F and Serafini C (1995) Valutazione dell’informazione agroecologica contenuta in profili NOAA-NDVI. In A Zaghi and M Gomarasca (eds) Proceedings of the VII National Congress of AIT (Associazione Italiana di Telerilevamento). CSEA, Torino, pp. 487–492. De Martonne E (1948) Trait´e de G´eographie Physique, 7th edition. Colin, Paris. Hall FG, Townshend JR and Engman ET (1995) Status of remote sensing algorithms for estimation of land surface state parameters. Remote Sensing of Environment 51(1), 138–156. Holben BN (1986) Characteristics of maximum-value composite images from temporal AVHRR data. International Journal of Remote Sensing 7, 1417–1434. Maselli F, Conese C, Petkov L and Gilabert MA (1993) Environmental monitoring and crop forecasting in the Sahel through the use of NOAA NDVI data. A case study: Niger 1986–1989. International Journal of Remote Sensing 14, 3471–3487. Maselli F, Petkov L and Maracchi G (1998) Extension of climate parameters over the land surface by the use of NOAA-AVHRR and ancillary data. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing 64, 199–206. Pinna M (1977) Climatologia. Ed UTET, Torino, Italy. Prince SD (1991) Satellite remote sensing of primary production for use with coarse resolution satellite data. International Journal of Remote Sensing 12, 1313–1330. Rao CRN and Chen J (1994) Post-launch calibration of the visible and near infrared channels of the Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer on NOAA-7, -9, and 11 spacecraft. NOAA Technical Report NESDIS 78, US Department of Commerce, Washington, DC, August 1994. Richards JA (1993) Remote Sensing Digital Image Analysis: An Introduction, 2nd edition. Springer-Verlag, Heidelberg. Sellers PJ, Meeson BW, Hall FG, Asrar G, Murphy RE, Schiffer RA, Bretherton FP, Dickinson RE, Ellingson RG, Field CB, Huemmrich KF, Justice CO, Melack JM, Roulet NT, Schimel DS and Try PD (1995) Remote sensing of the land surface for studies of global change: models–algorithms–experiments. Remote Sensing of Environment 51(1), 3–26. Thornthwaite CW (1948) An approach toward a rational classification of climate. Geographical Review 38, 55–94. Trewartha GT and Horn LH (1980) An Introduction to Climate, International Student Edition, Tokyo.
Section III
Land Use, Processes and Responses
5
The Effect of Land Use on Soil Erosion and Land Degradation under Mediterranean Conditions
3 ´ ´ C. KOSMAS,1 N.G. DANALATOS,2 F. LOPEZ-BERM UDEZ AND M.A. ROMERO D´ıAZ3
1
Laboratory of Soil Chemistry, Agricultural University of Athens, Greece Department of Agriculture, University of Thessaloniki, Volos, Thessaloniki, Greece 3 Department of Physical Geography, University of Murcia, Spain 2
1 INTRODUCTION Soil erosion is the most serious land degradation hazard in the Mediterranean uplands. It brings about siltation of water courses, infilling valleys and reservoirs, and forming deltas in coastal areas. It drastically reduces soil productivity, due to soil structural deterioration, nutrient wash out, and reduction of the water-holding capacity, limits vegetation growth and eventually leads to extensive desertification. Soil erosion is a natural phenomenon, a process by which all protruding surfaces of land are worn down gradually by the elements, only to be uplifted and re-formed time and again by geological forces. Soil erosion problems begin when human activity intervenes to accelerate the natural process far beyond the rate at which nature can redress it (Hillel 1991). Though it is clear that land degradation in the Mediterranean is in many ways a product of human activity, nevertheless it is significantly amplified by physical factors. Thus, the high erosion rates occurring in Mediterranean type areas are attributed to the climatic regime (Langbein and Schumm 1958), to the existing generally poor vegetation cover, and to land-use management (Douglas 1969; Reed 1971; Williams and Reed 1972; Patton and Schumm 1975; L´opez-Berm´udez et al. 1984; Newson 1985; Bryan and Campbell 1986). Mediterranean environments are characterized by strong seasonal contrasts in climate. When this is coupled with low annual rainfall and parent materials of high erosional susceptibility, the potential for erosion is very high (Romero D´ıaz et al. 1988). The extreme intensity and irregularity of annual precipitation events is a primary cause of soil erosion in Mediterranean Europe. During such rainfall events, the energetic impact of rainfall at the soil surface (rainsplash) modifies the soil physical properties; as a consequence, the soil particles are destabilized, detached and subsequently transported downslope by the running water. The pressure exerted by the raindrops subjects the soil to strong compaction and consolidation of its surface, resulting in an impermeable crust that inhibits infiltration and increases runoff. Romero D´ıaz et al. (1995) found that, as expected, the mean rainfall intensity was the factor best correlated with runoff coefficient and sediment production. Total rainfall correlated modestly, whereas vegetation cover influenced the runoff coefficient but no effects on sediment yields were detected. Studies conducted during MEDALUS projects I and II point to the existence of a relationship between annual rainfall and runoff, and sediment loss for different kinds of land use, and therefore between annual precipitation and soil erosion in the Mediterranean region. The following land-use types can be graded in order of decreasing effect on soil erosion: vines > eucalyptus > wheat > shrub land > olives. In the Mediterranean the topography of a region exerts a powerful influence on settlement patterns and land-use practices, as well as being a contributory factor in soil erosion. The physiography Mediterranean Desertification: A Mosaic of Processes and Responses. Edited by N.A. Geeson, C.J. Brandt and J.B. Thornes 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
58
Mediterranean Desertification
of the Mediterranean area includes a diverse array of land-forms, a large proportion of which are dominated by sparsely vegetated upland zones (Perez-Trejo 1992). Such a physiographic relief presents ideal conditions for the generation of water erosion on slopes, resulting in loss of soil productivity and desertification. The slope aspect greatly influences the temperature of the local environment, which in turn affects evaporation and subsequently vegetation growth and resilience. A greater slope inclination also influences infiltration rates and accelerates runoff and sediment loss. The steepest slopes generate mass movements, such as landslides and mudflows. The vegetation patterns that cover a landscape affect the soil in all its dynamics, including water redistribution over and within the soil, and microbiological activity. Biotic interactions occur which generate and maintain soil structure in the upper soil through the process of aggregation. Aggregation is a strong determinant of the soil’s hydrological and biological characteristics (Imeson 1984), and affects erosional response. Extensive Mediterranean areas cultivated with rainfed crops such as cereals, vines, almonds and olives are mainly confined to hilly lands with shallow soils very sensitive to erosion. These areas become vulnerable to erosion and desertification because the reduced vegetation cover means less protection from raindrop impact during heavy rains (Faulkner 1990), the reduction of infiltration rates due to compaction from heavy machinery (Fullen 1985), and the formation of a surface crust (Morin and Benyamini 1977; Casenave and Valentin 1992; Romero D´ıaz et al. 1998). Many authors have demonstrated that in a wide range of environments, both runoff and sediment loss decrease exponentially with increasing percentage of vegetation cover (Elwell and Stocking 1976; Lee and Skogerboe 1985; Francis and Thornes 1990). Without vegetation, all the runoff energy is directed to soil erosion and the removal of the detached material over various distances. Thus, vegetation and land use are in that respect of paramount importance, controlling the intensity and the frequency of overland flow and surface wash erosion (Bryan and Campbell 1986; Mitchell 1990). Large-scale deforestation of semi-arid areas accompanied by intensive cultivation and overgrazing has resulted in accelerated erosion and the formation of badlands with very shallow soils. Erosion rates measured in Mediterranean badlands vary widely from 0.4 to 1.7 mm year−1 (Yair et al. 1982; Benito et al. 1992). However, even greater erosion rates have been reported elsewhere, as in the Trevelez river basin in Spain in which an average soil loss value of 2.4 mm year−1 has been measured (Martin-Vivaldi and Jimenez Olivencia 1992). In critical semi-arid areas of Spain, soil loss of 12 mm year−1 or 200 t ha−1 year−1 has been reported (L´opez-Berm´udez 1990). These values can easily be surpassed during heavy rainfall events occurring occasionally over the Mediterranean (Alias-Perez and Ortiz-Silla 1986; L´opez-Berm´udez et al. 1991; Romero D´ıaz et al. 1995).
2
HISTORICAL EVOLUTION OF LAND USE IN THE MEDITERRANEAN REGION
The Mediterranean must be the region of the world most badly affected by human-induced degradation over thousands of years. The evidence of degradation is very clear, with only relict patches of the indigenous forest cover remaining and entire landscapes no longer able to sustain any cultivation. Accelerated soil erosion is as old as farming. Two early leaders of the US Conservation Service, Hugh Bennett and Clay Lowdermilk, wrote in the 1938 Yearbook of Agriculture: “soil erosion began when the first heavy rain struck the first furrow turned by a crude implement of tillage in the hands of prehistoric man. It has been going on ever since, wherever man’s culture of the earth has bared the soil to rain and wind” (USDA 1938). Soil erosion was first reported by Homer in The Iliad. Greek hillsides were originally forested and covered by a fertile soil mantle, which, however, was rather shallow and vulnerable to erosion. Upland grazing and farming probably began around the middle of the second millennium and began the initial damage to forests. Several thousands of years of exploitative agriculture have greatly contributed to a dramatic reduction of agricultural productivity in the region, something that had already been mentioned by Plato, who, speaking for Attica in the 4th century BC (Critias III), noted the occurrence of massive floods and landslides, the disappearance of forests and the denudation of cattle pasture. This description provides us with one of the earliest recorded examples of degradation and desertification, but also implicates climatic as well as anthropogenic causes. Two centuries earlier, Solon had already advocated discontinuing grain
Effect of Land Use on Soil Erosion and Land Degradation
59
cultivation on the sloping lands of Attica, and recommended planting olives and grapes instead. His advice was echoed in the 4th century BC by Theophrastus in his “Cause of Plants”. Considering the effects of land use on erosion and particularly the positive effects of olive groves (see below), one realizes how suitable this early land-use change plan of Solon was. However, neither man’s advice addressed the root cause of the problem, which was not the choice of the crop as such but the process of erosion and the failure of the ancient Greeks to control it. Additional historical evidence relating to the effects of degradation on vegetation can be traced to Roman times when land degradation resulted in the creation of large pastoral estates. Wherever Romans established their dominion, they repeated the same pattern of extensive forest clearing, over-cultivation and overgrazing of land to satisfy the avaricious demands of their centre of power (Hillel 1991). Land-use changes in the Mediterranean during recent history are mainly due to physical and technical factors as well as socio-economic reasons. Particular land uses have been related to specific population behaviours, spatial distribution changes, and pressure over natural resources. The region has suffered important transformations since the middle of the 19th century, when the agricultural development really began. Land mismanagement stimulated by demographic dynamics resulted in shifting of the agricultural population (and activities) to marginal areas unsuitable for agriculture. Human impact on the landscape was increasingly negative through conventional large-scale extensive agriculture, negatively affecting soil properties and enhancing the erosion processes. The extension of cultivated areas at the expense of forest land implies high ecological alterations due to deforestation and the break-up of the original equilibrium between cultivation, grazing and forestry. Short-term capital investment and intensive cultivation have often resulted in land degradation. Land profits are usually not invested for land conservation measures, but are simply reinvested for cultivating another area. The most significant change in the current land-use distribution in Mediterranean Europe is the increasing intensification of agricultural land in terms of mechanization, extensive use of agro-chemicals, and irrigation. The Guadalent´ın Basin in south-eastern Spain may serve as an example for demonstrating the impacts of land transformation changes and population evolution on land degradation (Barbera et al. 1997). The basin is characterized by the greatest hydrological deficit in the Iberian Peninsula and also in Europe. Historically the lack of water resources and the pressure for land-use change have been constant factors. Land-use changes have been related to specific population behaviour and spatial distribution, and pressure on natural resources, often as a response to economic demands. The Guadalent´ın has suffered significant transformation since the latter half of the 19th century, when agricultural development began. Since then agricultural activities and some mining have seriously affected the rural landscape and the whole environment in general. Population evolution in the Guadalent´ın Basin has been analysed from the middle of the 18th century and indicates substantial interaction of population dynamics with land-use changes (L´opez-Berm´udez et al. 1995). On the other hand, extreme climatic events typical for the region have also exerted an important socio-economic influence. Soil erosion cannot be considered as a human-induced disaster of only recent times (Wise 1982). Archaeological and geomorphological evidence from the badlands in southern Spain shows that the basic physical properties such as drainage patterns and degree of slope have been in place for some 4000 years. In the hilly Guadalent´ın Basin, human-induced land degradation has been particularly due to intensive cereal cropping, grazing and exploitation of Quercus forest resources (Figure 5.1). Inappropriate agricultural practice and management in relation to soil properties, topography and climate have stimulated economically based political decisions that have resulted in the migration of people and their agricultural activities to marginal areas with poor soils not necessarily suitable for agriculture. Another negative human impact on the landscape has been through conventional largescale extensive agriculture using mechanization, weakening soil properties in relation to weathering and erosive processes. Due to economic reasons and also as a response to soil degradation, large areas then had to be abandoned or used only for grazing. The following discussion focuses on the impacts of precipitation and land use on erosion rates based on an extensive database collected in various northern Mediterranean sites, located in Portugal, Spain, France, Italy and Greece. These sites represent a variety of landscapes under a variety of land
60
Mediterranean Desertification Dry land
Irrigated land
Forested land
1850
1981
60
Area (%)
50 40 30 20 10 0 1755
Year
Figure 5.1 Changes in land-use types in the Guadalent´ın Basin (Spain) since 1755 ´ (Lopez-Berm udez et al. 1995) ´
uses typical for the Mediterranean region, such as agricultural land cultivated with rainfed cereals, vines, olives, eucalyptus plantation or under natural vegetation (shrub land).
3 3.1
LAND USE AND EROSION RATES The Impact of Vegetation and Surface Soil Conditions
The effects of soil surface conditions and percentage vegetation cover are of paramount importance to rainwater runoff and sediment loss. These effects were clearly demonstrated across a hillslope catena, where land use was the only dependent parameter and where all other factors, e.g. weather, soils and topography, remained almost standard. The hillslope (gradient 14.5–16.2%) is formed on a sandstone formation near Athens (southern Greece). The climate of the area is Thermo-Mediterranean with an average air temperature of 17.8 ◦ C. The average annual precipitation is 495 mm with more than two-thirds (71%) falling between November and April. The following soil-surface conditions/land uses were studied, all being typical for Mediterranean environments: • • • • •
Olive grove under semi-natural conditions, with winter-annual understorey vegetation. The soil surface was sufficiently protected from raindrop impact by the ground cover (including the plant residues). No ploughing of the soils took place for more than 20 years. Vine cultivation with moderate inputs involving sufficient weed control. The soil was ploughed parallel to the contours. Surface roughness was estimated at 14 cm, and clod/furrow angle at 30◦ . Bare land abandoned for 2.5 years, without any vegetation (kept bare by controlling weeds) and with an average soil surface roughness of 4 cm. Land abandoned for 2.5 years. The soil contained large rock fragments (15 cm average diameter) partially embedded in the soil surface, and covering 17.8% of it. The average soil-surface roughness was 4 cm. Land with annual vegetation and abandoned for 2.5 years. The soils were under natural vegetation (no weeding) with an average soil-surface roughness of 4 cm.
Four rainfall events (27.5, 24.9, 28.5 and 18.2 mm) inducing incipient ponding fell between the end of November and late January 1994, and runoff volumes were measured from the different plots. There was considerable variation in the total runoff, reflecting the enormous importance of surface conditions on runoff generation and land degradation (Figure 5.2). The presence of annual vegetation and the plant residues covering about 90% of the soil surface in the olive grove prevented
61
Effect of Land Use on Soil Erosion and Land Degradation 12
(a)
Runoff (mm)
9
6
3
0
27.5
24.3
28.5
18.2
Rainfall events (mm) (b) 64.10
Sediment loss (t km−2)
olives 48.07 vines bare
32.05
rock fragments annual vegetation
16.02
0.00
27.5
24.3
28.5
18.2
Rainfall events (mm)
Figure 5.2 (a) Rainfall runoff and (b) sediment loss measured during four rainfall events under different land uses and surface soil conditions
the formation of surface sealing and minimized the velocity and volume of runoff water. A total runoff of only 1.0 mm was measured from four rainfall events (Figure 5.2(a)). An intermediate water runoff (16.3 mm) was measured on the plots of the abandoned land where annual vegetation had been allowed to grow. In contrast, the lack of vegetation cover in the plots kept bare, or in the vineyard, favoured much greater volumes of runoff, with values of 22.6 mm and 21.0 mm, respectively, from the four rainfall events. The greatest runoff (30.3 mm) was generated from the bare soil containing rock fragments (cobbles), at a rate even higher than the bare, stonefree soil. Figure 5.2(b) shows how the total sediment loss varied according to land use after each of the four ponding rainfall events. The sediment loss was at a maximum (203.3 t km−2 ) on the soil containing rock fragments at the soil surface. In contrast, the abandonment of the olive grove for a long time, and thus the presence of annual vegetation and plant residues on the soil surface, was responsible for
62
Mediterranean Desertification
the drastic reduction of soil loss to negligible values (0.1 t km−2 ). Therefore, under olives grown like this, further degradation of the land is very restricted. Rock fragments on the soil surface appeared to play the most important role against erosion, especially during particularly heavy showers (i.e. heavier than those mentioned previously). A plant cover of 48% growing after abandonment of the land for 2.5 years reduced the total soil loss due to erosion by 35% as compared to the stone-free bare soil. Contour ploughing of the soils under vines also significantly decreased runoff and sediment loss. The absence of vegetation and the low aggregate stability (mean aggregate size equal to 0.6 mm) favoured surface sealing and increased runoff and sediment loss. 3.2
The Combined Effects of Land Use and Climate
The considerable variation in total runoff and sediment loss measured at various field sites along the northern Mediterranean reflect the great importance of total rainfall as well as land use on runoff generation and sediment loss, and therefore soil erosion. A number of runoff plots were installed at eight different sites (Figure 5.3), mainly formed on sedimentary rocks, i.e. schist, slates and phyllites, limestones, marls, sandstone-marls or unconsolidated alluvial deposits with slightly gravelly to gravelly, coarse to moderately fine-textured soils. In the following paragraphs, the effect of total rainfall on runoff and sediment loss is compared for the six study sites kept under the same land use.
Cereals Rainfed cereals, particularly wheat and barley, are widespread on the Mediterranean uplands. However, in some years the prevailing weather conditions during the growing period of these crops may be so adverse that the soils remain bare, creating favourable conditions for overland flow and erosion. Any loss of soil volume from these marginal lands greatly reduces the potential for biomass production, ultimately leading to desertification. Desertification at present threatens only the shallow and severely eroded soils. This threat, however, may expand to the majority of soils due to the adverse effects of global climatic change. Figure 5.4 indicates that the total annual runoff from the fields under rainfed cereals is positively related to the annual rainfall. It appears that runoff is a very small portion of the total rainfall (less than 1.5%) if the latter does not exceed 380 mm. However, amounts of rainfall greater than
Var Roussillon Petralona
Vale Formoso EI Ardal
Spata Santa Lucia
Rambla Honda
Figure 5.3 Location of the eight experimental field sites where erosion rates under various land uses were studied 1, Vale Formoso (Portugal); 2, El Ardal (Murcia, Spain); 3, Rambla Honda (Almeria, Spain); 4, Roussillon (Pyrenees, France); 5, Var (Pyrenees, France); 6, Santa Lucia (Sardinia, Italy); 7, Spata (Athens, Greece); 8, Petralona (Thessaloniki, Greece)
Effect of Land Use on Soil Erosion and Land Degradation Vale Formoso
(a) 300
El Ardal
63
Petralona
Y = −3.83 − 0.12∗X + 0.00056∗X 2
Runoff (mm year −1)
R = 0.82, n = 65 200
100
0 100
300
500
700
900
Rainfall (mm year −1) (b)
Portugal
Sediment loss (g m−2 year −1)
120
Spain
Greece
Y = −12.7 + 0.046∗X + 0.000083∗X 2 R = 0.60, n = 65
90
60
30
0 100
300
500
700
900
Rainfall (mm year −1)
Figure 5.4 (a) Rainwater runoff and (b) sediment loss versus total annual rainfall measured at three Mediterranean sites under rainfed wheat (Kosmas et al. 1997)
700 mm generated runoff volumes of up to 24% of the total precipitation. Most runoff events under Mediterranean conditions occur in the period from early October to late February. The rains falling during this period are of high intensity and long duration, and the soils cultivated with rainfed cereals are not sufficiently covered and protected from raindrop impact. As Figure 5.4 shows, in Mediterranean areas with a total precipitation of less than 280 mm, sediment loss is really not a threat. Sediment loss increases with increasing rainfall and may fluctuate between about 15 and 90 t km−2 year−1 for the range of 280–700 mm rain per year (Kosmas et al. 1997). Inbar (1992) reported a value of 20 t km−2 year−1 for the Catalunya area of Spain with an annual precipitation of 600–700 mm which is less than the values measured in wheat fields in wet years. Despite the wide variability existing, the obtained data show an increasing trend of sediment loss with increasing annual precipitation. The area cultivated with cereals around the northern Mediterranean is currently diminishing following a decline in the market prices for cereals, the rising cost of fertilizers and fuel, and the increased frequency of dry years. Most uplands with shallow soils have already been abandoned, and this abandonment seems likely to continue in the future.
64
Mediterranean Desertification
Vines The available data suggest that vine cultivation creates conditions for increased water runoff and sediment loss. This is because the soils cultivated with vines remain almost bare during autumn, winter and early spring due to the removal of annual vegetation by ploughing or the application of pesticides (to control weeds). Very high runoff rates have been measured in Spata (Greece) and Roussillon (France) with values of up to 31.8% of the annual precipitation, which reached 850 mm. The greatest runoff occurred typically in winter when the soil was wet and characterized by a low sorptivity and infiltration rate (Danalatos 1993). Infiltration was further diminished by the high compaction of the plough layer. It should be noted that the soils under vines are usually ploughed twice in mid-spring and are treated once or twice a year with herbicides. As the soils are very susceptible to dispersion, and rainfall intensities can be extremely high in the area (e.g. rainfall of 700 mm in one day was recorded at the Roussillon site in 1947, and 185 mm at Spata in 1994 in one day with a maximum intensity of 335 mm h−1 ), soil crusting occurs very often after ploughing, creating favourable conditions for overland flow and erosion. As with rainwater runoff, the greatest volumes of sediment loss were measured under vines, ranging from 67 to 460 t km−2 year−1 . These values greatly exceed those measured in fields cultivated with wheat. Data for sediment yields are not available from the Roussillon site. Further experiments and data are required in order to establish a clear trend of runoff and sediment loss in relation to annual rainfall along the whole northern Mediterranean.
Eucalyptus Eucalyptus cultivation, especially for pulp production, is very important, covering more than 500 000 ha in both Spain and Portugal and about 70 000 ha in Italy. Available data on soil erosion under eucalyptus plantations, which have been collected at Rio Santa Lucia (Sardinia), suggest that, as with vines, eucalyptus creates conditions for increased overland flow and erosion. Eucalyptus plantations are dense and dark and create adverse conditions for the growth of understorey annual or perennial vegetation so that the soil remains almost bare during the whole year. The total annual runoff under eucalyptus measured over a period of four years ranged from 0.6% to 8.2% of the annual precipitation, which varied from 171 mm to 564 mm. Figure 5.5 illustrates that the average sediment loss ranged from 1.4 to 65.6 t km−2 year−1 (SD = 1.2–46.8 t km−2 year−1 ) for the same precipitation range, demonstrating a serious erosion hazard for any soil reforested with eucalyptus as compared to the soils left under natural vegetation
Runoff (mm year −1)
Sediment loss (g m−2 year −1)
Runoff and sediment loss
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 171
453
473
564
Rainfall (mm year −1)
Figure 5.5 Runoff and sediment loss measured in hilly areas cultivated with eucalyptus at Rio Santa Lucia, Sardinia, over a four-year period (Kosmas et al. 1997)
Effect of Land Use on Soil Erosion and Land Degradation
65
(Aru and Barrocu 1993). These erosion rates are generally lower than those measured from soils under vines and generally higher than those measured under wheat. Runoff and sediment loss may be expected on any cultivated Mediterranean upland area, but especially where the soil is left bare for large parts of the year. If, in addition, heavy cultivation machinery is used, soil aggregate stability and organic matter content are decreased. This further increases the likelihood of soil erosion.
Olives Olive groves cover an appreciable part of the Mediterranean hilly areas. Where they grow as seminatural vegetation, annual vegetation and accumulating plant residues provide a high soil-surface cover, occasionally up to 90%, so preventing surface sealing and minimizing the velocity of the runoff water. Figure 5.6 shows that runoff in excess of 5% of the total rain, and sediment loss greater than 5.3 t km−2 year−1 never occurred under olive groves monitored for four years in southern Greece (Spata, Athens). Thus, the presence of annual vegetation and plant residues on the soil surface allows negligible soil loss and olives can play a big part in protecting Mediterranean uplands from further degradation and desertification. In fact, large areas around the Mediterranean region have been covered with olive trees since ancient times but many now grow untended as the prices obtained for olive oil have declined and made harvesting uneconomic in some places. Land-use planning should recognize the benefit of growing olives for the conservation of the soil before advocating alternative crops, such as eucalyptus, for only a short-term profit. Olives show a particularly high adaptation and resistance to long-term droughts and support a remarkable diversity of flora and fauna, greater than in some natural ecosystems (Margaris et al. 1995). The olive groves can be considered as a natural forest highly adapted to dry Mediterranean conditions, with lower vulnerability to fire than pine or eucalyptus forests, and protecting hilly areas from desertification in many ways. Much Mediterranean upland has been terraced for cultivating cereals, vines, olives and other crops (Figure 5.7). In many cases the stonewalled terraces are hundreds or even thousands of years old. Sometimes individual crescent-shaped terraces have been carefully constructed for individual trees. Soil was removed from other places to fill these terraces. This type of conservation management requires high labour costs to maintain the terraces in good repair. In the last few decades the value of such terraces for an agricultural return has markedly declined because of difficulties associated with poor accessibility and the limited use of labour-saving machinery. Many of these
Sediment loss (g m−2 year −1)
Runoff (mm year −1)
Runoff and sediment loss
10 8 6 4 2 0 349
453
508
575
Rainfall (mm year −1)
Figure 5.6 Runoff and sediment loss versus total annual precipitation measured between 1991 and 1994 at an olive grove under semi-natural conditions in Greece (Spata, Athens)
66
Mediterranean Desertification
Figure 5.7 Terraced olive grove well protected from erosion on the island of Lesvos
areas have been abandoned and if the stonewalling is allowed to collapse, removal of the retained soil by the runoff water can happen very quickly. Unfortunately maintaining such abandoned terraces appears a very expensive practice in labour terms compared to most other alternatives for soil erosion control.
Shrub Land Through the First and Second World Wars much upland was cleared of natural vegetation and cultivated mainly for cereal production to ensure sufficiency of cereal supply to the local populations. In the first years of cultivation, the production was fairly good, but very soon soil degradation reached serious levels, productivity started to decline dramatically and so did the local population and agriculture in those uplands. Land abandonment has continued until recent times, so that more areas are left under semi-natural vegetation. At least this is not accelerating soil erosion. Vegetation cover in the abandoned areas is variable and depends on the amount and distribution of rainfall. Figure 5.8 demonstrates the tendency of increasing overland flow with decreasing annual rainfall. Of course there is an inevitable variation between the different experimental sites, which is attributed to soil-surface properties, slope grade and length, and rainfall intensity and duration. Vegetation cover is crucial to runoff generation and alters throughout the Mediterranean uplands depending on climatic conditions and the period of the year. In areas such as southern Spain (Almeria, Murcia), with an annual precipitation lower than 280 mm year−1 and high evapotranspiration rates, the soil water available to plants is drastically reduced and therefore the soil remains relatively bare, favouring overland flow. Runoff reached values up to 10% of the total rainfall at the rather dry Almeria site. The available data show a peak of runoff with an annual precipitation total of 280–300 mm. The relationship between annual sediment loss and precipitation shows a trend of increasing loss with decreasing precipitation as long as the latter exceeds 280–300 mm year−1 . If annual precipitation falls below this range, then erosion decreases with increasing aridity. Inbar (1992) reported similar trends for different watersheds in the coastal area of Israel. Data for sediment loss from the wetter experimental sites of Petralona (northern Greece) and Rio Santa Lucia (Sardinia), having an average annual precipitation of 464 and 448 mm, respectively, showed the lowest values, ranging from 13.8 to 0.5 t km−2 year−1 . Sediment loss increases if one moves from areas of higher precipitation to areas of lower precipitation (such as Murcia and Almeria, southern Spain). The maximum value of sediment loss was recorded in Almeria (21.5 t km−2 year−1 ), associated with an annual precipitation of 282 mm. Under drier climatic conditions, sediment loss is greatly reduced to values similar to those measured in the relatively wetter sites.
Effect of Land Use on Soil Erosion and Land Degradation
67
20
Runoff (mm year −1)
n = 18
15
10
n = 21
5
n =8
n = 12
0
n = 17
100−200 200−300 300−400 400−500 500−600 Rainfall (mm year −1)
Sediment loss (g m−2 year −1)
20
15
10
5
0
100−200 200−300 300−400 400−500 500−600 Rainfall (mm year −1)
Figure 5.8 Annual runoff and sediment loss versus rainfall measured in shrub lands at various experimental sites across the northern Mediterranean region (Kosmas et al. 1997)
3.3 Land Abandonment
There is a growing interest in the evolution of abandoned dry lands (Gordon et al. 1981; RuizFlano et al. 1992), which are now marginal from an environmental and socio-economic point of view (Esteve et al. 1993). The abandoned fields may show quite different evolutions depending on various environmental and land-use features. Some of these, especially soil type, water availability and the type of previous and post-abandonment land use, could play a more important role in some places than others. A wide variety of situations are generated, so that it is difficult to predict future evolution. The evolution of vegetation types depending on age of abandonment shows clear tendencies: the predominance of annuals in the fallow land and the field abandoned for five years, and a progressive decrease of annuals until they barely appear by the time scrub lands have developed. Shrubs and herbaceous perennials show the opposite behaviour, though in a less pronounced way and with
68
Mediterranean Desertification
different time-scales. It can take more than 20 years for shrub lands with a high percentage of ground cover to develop. Martinez-Fernandez et al. (1996) studied the effects of land abandonment in eight abandoned fields in Murcia (Spain) with 1–30 years since abandonment, N–S exposure, similar present-day conditions and limestone substratum. The pedological property most related to vegetation dynamics was found to be the organic matter content. This factor also has important implications in soil degradation processes. Organic matter content shows a clear relationship with age of abandonment, which confirms a tendency already pointed out in previous studies (Martinez-Fernandez et al. 1994). The agricultural use of these fields led to a loss of organic matter content, being usually less than 1% under actual crops close to these abandoned fields. The results show that, after the abandonment of agricultural practices, an evident recovery of this factor may be detected, even in the early stages. The organic matter content gradually reverts to the situation before agricultural use. Recovery is helped if the abandoned field has a northern exposure, which loses soil moisture less readily than a field with a southern exposure. The post-abandonment uses of the abandoned fields have major importance in their evolution. Moderate grazing has a minor effect on the partial rejuvenation of the communities, visible through the maintaining of intermediate successional stages and high diversity index. These results may be of interest for all Mediterranean semi-arid areas showing similar environmental conditions, in which the abandonment practices are relevant. This is also true of sediment production. Generally, the greatest soil losses occur during the months with the highest rainfall, especially those with high hourly intensities, such as happen frequently in the month of October. However, in other months with significant rainfall, such as April and November 1984, November and December 1985, and January and April 1986, there was hardly any sediment production. Such observations confirm that the degree of correlation between rainfall, runoff and sediment production is low in semi-arid south-east Spain (Romero D´ıaz et al. 1998). Other controls are still only partly understood (Fisher et al. 1985), such as annual variations in the content and retention of soil moisture, biomass production, the incorporation of organic material, the quantities of soluble anions and cations, conductivity, etc. All these factors play an important role in the complex relations between rainfall, runoff and sediment production.
REFERENCES Alias-Perez LJ and Ortiz-Silla R (1986) Proceedings of XIV National Soils Meeting. Spanish Sciences Society of the Soil (CSIC), University of Murcia, Spain. Aru A and Barrocu G (1993) The Rio Santa Lucia catchment area. In Mediterranean Desertification and Land Use, MEDALUS Final Report. Commission of the European Communities. Contract number EPOC-CT900014-(SMA), pp. 533–559. Barbera GG, L´opez-Berm´udez F and Romero D´ıaz MA (1997) Cambios de uso del suelo y desertificac en el Mediterraneo: El caso del Sureste Iberico. In JM Garcia-Ruiz and P Lopez Garcia (eds) Accion humana y desertification en ambientes semiaridos. Instituto Pirenaico de Ecologia, Zaragoza, pp. 9–39. Benito G, Gutierrez M and Sancho C (1992) Erosion rates in Badland areas of the Central Ebro Basin (NESpain). Catena 19, 269–286. Bryan RB and Campbell IA (1986) Runoff and sediment discharge in a semi-arid drainage basin. Zeitschrift f¨ur Geomorphologic 58, 121–143. Casenave A and Valentin C (1992) A runoff capability classification system based on surface features criteria in semi-arid areas of West Africa. Journal of Hydrology 130, 231–249. Danalatos NG (1993) Quantified analysis of selected land use systems in the Larissa region, Greece. PhD thesis, Agricultural University of Wageningen, Wageningen. Douglas I (1969) Sediment yields from forested and agricultural lands. Proceedings of the Symposium on The Role of Water in Agriculture. University of Wales (Aberystwyth) Memorandum No. 12, E1–E22. Elwell HA and Stocking MA (1976) Vegetal cover to estimate soil erosion hazard in Rhodesia. Geoderma 15, 61–70. Esteve MA, Calvo F, Ibernon M, Gimenez A, Palazon JA and Ramirez-Diaz L (1993) Tierras marginales en ecosistemas semiaridos del Sureste Iberico: descriptores, relacion con los factores fisicos y aplicaciones a la gestion ambiental. Problematica Geoambiental y Desarrollo. V Reunion Nacional de Geologia Ambiental y Ordenacion del Territorio, Murcia, pp. 777–786.
Effect of Land Use on Soil Erosion and Land Degradation
69
Faulkner H (1990) Vegetation cover density variations and infiltration patterns on piped alkali sodic soils: implications for the modelling of overland flow in semi-arid areas. In JB Thornes (ed.) Vegetation and Erosion, Processes and Environments. John Wiley, Chichester, pp. 317–346. Fisher GC, Romero D´ıaz A, L´opez-Berm´udez F, Thornes JB and Francis F (1985) Vegetation litter production and effects in an eroding Mediterranean ecosystem, Mula, SE Spain. IX Coloquio de Geografos Espanoles, Murcia, Poniense, V2. Francis CF and Thornes JB (1990) Runoff hydrographs from three Mediterranean vegetation cover types. In JB Thornes (ed.) Vegetation and Erosion, Processes and Environments. John Wiley, Chichester, pp. 363–384. Fullen MA (1985) Soil compaction, hydrological processes and soil erosion on loamy sands in East Shropshire, England. Soil and Tillage Research 29(6), 17–29. Gordon M, Guillerm JL, Poissonet J, Poissonet M, Thiault M and Trabaud L (1981) Dynamics and management of vegetation. In FDi Castri, DW Goodal and R Specht (eds) Mediterranean-type Scrublands. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 317–344. Hillel D (1991) Deforesting the earth. In D Hillel (ed.) Out of the Earth, Civilization and the Life of the Soil . University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles, pp. 175–185. Imeson A (1984) An eco-geomorphological approach to the soil degradation and erosion problem. In R Fantechi and NS Margaris (eds) Desertification in Europe. Proceedings of the Information Symposium in the EEC Programme on Climatology. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 153–168. Inbar M (1992) Rates of fluvial erosion in basins with a Mediterranean type climate. Catena 19, 393–409. Kosmas C, Danalatos N, Cammeraat LH, Chabart M, Diamantopoulos J et al. (1997) The effect of land use on runoff and soil erosion rates under Mediterranean conditions. Catena 29, 45–59. Langbein WB and Schumm SA (1958) Yield of sediment in relation to mean annual precipitation. American Geophysical Union Transactions 39, 1076–1084. Lee CR and Skogerboe JG (1985) Quantification of erosion control by vegetation on problem soils. In Al Swaify, WC Moldenhauer and A Lo (eds) Soil Erosion and Conservation. Soil Conservation Society of America, Ankeny, IA, pp. 437–444. L´opez-Berm´udez F (1990) Soil erosion by water on the desertification of a semi-arid Mediterranean fluvial basin: the Segura basin, Spain. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment , 33(2), 129–145. L´opez-Berm´udez F, Thornes JB, Fisher G and Francis C (1984) Erosion y Ecologia en la Espana semiarida (Cuenca de Mula, Murcia). Cuadernos de Investigacion Geografica 10(1–2), 113–126. L´opez-Berm´udez F, Romero D´ıaz MA and Martinez-Fernandez J (1991) Soil erosion in semi-arid Mediterranean environment. El Ardal experimental field (Murcia, Spain). In M Sala, JL Rubio and JM Garcia-Ruiz (eds) Soil Erosion Studies in Spain. Geoforma Ediciones, Logrono, pp. 137–152. L´opez-Berm´udez F, Sancez-Fuster MC and Romero D´ıaz A (1995) Incidencia de los modelos de gestion socioeconomica (siglos XIX y XX) en la degradacion del suelo en el Campo de Lorca (Cuenca del Guadalentin, Murcia). Papeles de Geografia 22, 5–18. Universidad de Murcia. Margaris N, Koukoutsidou E, Giourga Ch, Loumou A, Theodorakis M and Hatzitheodoridis P (1995) Managing desertification. In MEDALUS II Project 3, Managing Desertification, EV5V-CT92-0165, pp. 83–110. Martinez-Fernandez J, Romero D´ıaz MA, L´opez-Berm´udez F and Martinez-Fernandez J (1994) Parametros estructurales y funcionales de Rosmarinus officinalis en ecosistemas mediterraneos semiaridos. Studia Oecologica, 10–11, 309–316. Martinez-Fernandez J, Romero D´ıaz MA and Belmonde-Serrato F (1996) Evolution of vegetation and pedological characteristics in fields with different age of abandonment: a case study in Murcia (Spain). In JL Rubio and A Calvo (eds) Soil Degradation and Desertification in Mediterranean Environments. Geoforma Ediciones, Logrono, pp. 279–290. Martin-Vivaldi MC and Jimenez Olivencia Y (1992) Estudio de la erosion en la cuenca del Rio Trevelez (Granada). In F L´opez-Berm´udez C Conesa-Garcia and A Romero D´ıaz (eds) Estudios de Geomorfologia en Espana. Sociedad Espanola de Geomorfologia, Murcia, pp. 93–103. Mitchell DJ (1990) The use of vegetation and land use parameters in modelling catchment sediment yields. In JB Thornes (ed.) Vegetation and Erosion, Processes and Environments. John Wiley, Chichester, pp. 289–314. Morin J and Benyamini Y (1977) Rainfall infiltration into bare soils. Water Resources Research 13, 813–817. Newson MD (1985) Forestry and water on the uplands of Britain – the background of hydrological research and options for harmonious land use. Journal of Forestry 79, 113–120. Patton PC and Schumm SA (1975) Gully erosion, North-western Colorado: a threshold phenomenon. Geology 3, 83–90. Perez-Trejo F (1992) Desertification and Land Degradation in the European Mediterranean. European Commission, EPOCH programme, Directorate General XII, Science, Research and Development, EUR 14 850.
70
Mediterranean Desertification
Reed LA (1971) Hydrological and sedimentation of Corey Creek and Elk Run Basins, North-Central Pennsylvania. US Geological Survey Water Supply Paper. Rodriguez-Aizpeolea J, Perez-Badia R and Cerda-Bolinches A (1994) Colonizacion vegetal y produccion de escorrentia en bancales abandonatos: Vall de Gallinera. Alacant. Cuaternario y Geomorfologia. Romero D´ıaz MA, L´opez-Berm´udez F, Thornes JB, Francis CF and Fisher GC (1988) Variability of overland flow erosion rates in a semi-arid Mediterranean environment under matorral cover in Murcia Spain. Catena, supplement 13, 1–11. Romero D´ıaz A, Barbera GG and L´opez-Berm´udez F (1995) Relaciones entre erosion del suelo, precipitacion y cubierta vegetal en un medio semiarido del sureste de la peninsula iberica. Lurralde 18, 229–243. Romero D´ıaz A, L´opez-Berm´udez F and Belmonte Serrato F (1998) Erosion y escorrentia en el Campo Experimental de “El Ardal” (Murcia). Nueve anos de experencias. Papeles de Geografia 26, 129–144 Ruiz-Flano P, Garcia-Ruiz JM and Ortigosa L (1992) Geomorphological evolution of abandoned fields. A case study in the Central Pyrenees. Catena 19, 301–308. USDA (1938) Soils and Men, 1938 Yearbook of Agriculture. USDA, Washington, DC. Williams KF and Reed LA (1972) Appraisal of stream sedimentation in the Susquehanna River basin. US Geological Survey Water Supply Paper. Wise SM (1982) How old are the badlands? A case study from south-east Spain. In R Bryan and A Yair (eds) Badland Geomorphology and Piping. GeoBooks, Norwich, pp. 259–277. Yair A, Goldberg P and Brimer R (1982) Long term denutation rates in the Zin-Havarim badlands of northern Negev, Israel. In R Bryan and A Yair (eds) Badland Geomorphology and Piping. GeoBooks, Norwich, pp. 279–291.
6
Agro-pastoral Activities and Land Degradation in Mediterranean Areas: Case Study of Sardinia
G. ENNE,1 G. PULINA,1 M. D’ANGELO,1 F. PREVITALI,2 S. MADRAU,1 S. CAREDDA1 AND A.H.D. FRANCESCONI1 1
Dipartimento di Scienze Zootecniche, University of Sassari, Sassari, Italy Dipartimento di Scienze dell’Ambiente e del Territorio, Universita` di Milano–Biocca, Milano, Italy 2
1 INTRODUCTION Livestock farming is one of the main agricultural activities in the Mediterranean Basin, both in terms of the numbers of people employed and in its distribution throughout the region. There are about 100 million livestock units (LSU) of herbivores in the countries of the Mediterranean Basin, 53.8% of which are in Europe, 23.2% in Africa and 23% in Asia (FAO 1995). Most LSU are ruminants (cattle, sheep and goats) and their main feeding source is natural or cultivated pastures grazed directly. The international scientific community has recognized that agro-pastoral activities are clearly one of the main causes of land degradation in the Mediterranean. In southern Spain, Greece and Portugal, wide areas intensively exploited by small ruminants have already reached a severe level of land degradation. The spread of agro-pastoral activities in most Mediterranean countries and the increased grazing pressure are also related to past European Union (EU) policies, which favoured the uncontrolled development of modern agricultural practices. Those policies provided a system of guaranteed prices and subsidies to farmers for the production of meat and wheat which resulted in the cultivation of marginal areas. In addition, the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) led to a steep rise in productivity by encouraging mechanization. As has been shown by several studies, this production-orientated model protected farmers against the economic consequences of environmental degradation and also removed their responsibility toward environment management (Buller 1992). Fortunately, since the beginning of 1992, all State Members of the EU have focused their attention on a new concept of environmental sustainability, as laid out by the Treaty of Maastricht. The EU concerns about the rural environment, land abandonment and its consequent degradation have led to it supporting environmentally friendly practices. For example, Council Regulation Number 2078/92 concerns aid to encourage agricultural production methods with a low impact on the environment, while Number 2080/92 concerns aid to encourage afforestation. Furthermore, in order to give scientific assistance to the political decisions on land degradation issues, the EU has promoted several research programmes, including MEDALUS, aimed at understanding the major causes of land degradation, and developing schemes to mitigate and prevent land degradation.
2 SARDINIA: AN ISLAND THREATENED BY LAND DEGRADATION Sardinia is one of the Italian regions most threatened by land degradation. Although it is a relatively low-lying region (the highest peak being Punta la Marmora, 1834 m a.s.l.), which does not exceed Mediterranean Desertification: A Mosaic of Processes and Responses. Edited by N.A. Geeson, C.J. Brandt and J.B. Thornes 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
72
Mediterranean Desertification
the upper limit of vegetation, the unproductive lands, excluding urban and coastal areas and inland waters, represent about 12% of the total area. These are distributed over the whole island as a result of the land use through the centuries, which has always been agro-pastoral to a great extent. Today, about 85% of Sardinian land is used for agriculture (ISTAT 1976, 1982, 1992), and livestock farming is one of the main economic activities. There are about 622 835 LSU of herbivores, of which 50% are dairy sheep (Table 6.1). This fact has greatly influenced land use in Sardinia: meadows and pastures are intensively grazed, and both wooded areas and arable land are cultivated to provide forage and other animal feeding sources. Agro-pastoral activities are a major cause of fires. A detailed analysis of the causes of forest fires shows that more than 90% of the total number of fires are started deliberately, and are historically and traditionally related to human activities (Figure 6.1). Fire has been considered an important practical and economical tool for clearing lands for grazing. Land fragmentation and the heterogeneity of land cover, typical of Mediterranean environments, have in many cases favoured fire propagation from grasslands to shrublands and wooded areas, thus compromising forested ecosystems (Figure 6.2). Although in the Mediterranean Basin fire has always been present in the ecosystem, promoted by hot dry periods common in the Mediterranean climate and the particularly inflammable characteristics of typical Mediterranean vegetation (Molina 1996), in the last 50 years its occurrence has dramatically increased, and is now a major factor of desertification. The destruction of the vegetation cover and the effects on the underlying soil (Chandler et al. 1983) result in an increased erosion risk. In Table 6.1 Grassland, livestock and stocking rate evolution (1971–1991)
Year
1971 1981 199l a
Agricultural land (ha)
2 159 245 2 047 811 2 050 731
Grassland (ha)
1 613 279 1 497 503 1 539 224
Livestock number (LSU)a Cattle
Sheep
Goats
Total
273 050 287 798 286 840
215 323 226 714 313 129
25 070 22 463 22 867
513 443 536 875 622 835
LSU = 450 kg live weight (1 cattle; 10 sheep; 10 goats).
Figure 6.1 Typical aspect of an over-exploited pasture in Sardinia. Overgrazing and the frequent use of fires are among the main causes of land degradation
73
Agro-pastoral Activities and Land Degradation in Sardinia
Figure 6.2
Erosive processes in an area recently affected by fire
Table 6.2 Number of fires and areas affected by fires in Sardinia (1982–1996)
Year No. of fires Wooded area (ha) Pasture (ha) Other areas (ha) Total area (ha)
1982–1986
1987–1991
1992–1996
Annual average (1982–1996)
14 406 64 720 217 621 17 299 299 640
16 111 35 694 150 246 12 562 198 502
16 438 48 537 128 324 14 429 191 290
3 130 9 930 33 079 2 953 45 962
Source: RAS (1996). Sardinia, during the period 1982–1996, an area of 689 432 ha of land was swept by fire (Table 6.2). The mean annual area affected by fire amounts to about 46 000 ha, about 72% of which is pasture. With particular reference to woodlands, during the period 1989–1993 about 1.6% of the total area was annually swept by fire; when compared to the European Mediterranean average (1%) (EEC 1996), this datum shows the significant incidence of this phenomenon in Sardinia. These are the main reasons why Sardinia has been considered a representative study area for the impact of grazing systems on desertification processes. On the island there are two main forage systems: agro-silvo-pastoral activities in hilly and mountainous areas and cereal–dairy sheep farming on the plains and low hills. Between these two systems there are various intermediate conditions. The traditional agro-pastoral system, based on pasture with or without fertilization and with shortterm forage crops, is very common in hilly and mountainous areas of Sardinia. This system makes it very difficult for forage availability and animal feed requirements to coincide (Caredda et al. 1992). The green forage production is mainly concentrated in spring, while the maximum dairy sheep feed requirements are concentrated in autumn–winter, at the end of ewe pregnancies and at the beginning of lactation. Generally, this problem is solved either by vertical transhumance or, more often, by feeding sheep with hay and concentrates. During the 1950s and 1960s, a reduction of the traditional rotation of cereal-grazed fallow brought about the abandonment of arable lands and different land-use management. As a consequence, the
74
Mediterranean Desertification
Figure 6.3 Maquis clearing in favour of cultivated pastures can result in severe surface erosion when carried out on unsuitable lands
balance between crop and pasture was altered, leading to an increased abundance of low-growing palatable species on the abandoned land and a reduction in forage availability. Unplanned and irrational grazing patterns (autumn overgrazing and/or spring undergrazing) caused a progressive reduction of palatable species and an increase in bare soil areas, which generated soil losses, particularly on slopes. During the 1970s and 1980s an increase in sheep milk prices led to a large increase in sheep numbers in lowlands and hilly areas. In order to increase forage availability on natural pastures, farmers utilized different agronomic techniques which, particularly on slopes, tended to lead to erosion. For example, inadequate machines (e.g. scrapers) were used to clear the ground of stony and shrubby vegetative cover and trees, and removed the topsoil irreversibly. Generally, forage intensification is based on cultivation of short-term forage crops that are grazed in winter and harvested as hay or grain in late spring. However, because of the lack of sufficient flat surfaces, forage crops are also cultivated on slopes, often by ploughing across rather than parallel to the contours, and without adopting soil conservation practices. As a consequence, gullying due to runoff after autumn rainfalls is frequently observed in hilly regions (Figure 6.3). Indeed, the risk of soil erosion on hillslope areas is concentrated at the end of the summer and autumn, when frequent and intense rains coincide with the soil being recently ploughed or bare, and very vulnerable to the strength of rainwater (Rivoira et al. 1989; Roggero et al. 1995). Even though agro-pastoralism, especially overgrazing, has often been considered as the main cause of land degradation, Seligman (1996) maintains that “among all the factors that contribute to landscape degradation in the Mediterranean Basin, high stocking rates must be placed low on the list”. In order to contribute to the clarification of this matter, this chapter mainly deals with the general effects of agro-pastoral activities on vegetation and soil degradation, and presents some experimental results of the MEDALUS II research carried out in Sardinia on this topic. Finally, practical implications of irrational grazing practices on soil fertility are examined and some guidelines on proper land management in an agro-pastoral context are proposed.
3
EFFECTS OF GRAZING ON VEGETATION AND SOIL
In agro-pastoral systems, animals, plants and environment interact with each other in a complex manner, and are directly affected by human activities. The common belief that grazing is always
Agro-pastoral Activities and Land Degradation in Sardinia
75
detrimental to vegetation is a result of the confusion between grazing and overgrazing, with only the latter being destructive to plants and soil. Mathematical models have been devised to aid the understanding of the complex interactions of the diverse components that make up the soil–animal–plant interaction system (Doucet and Sloep 1992). Rational management should encourage certain positive influences of grazing on vegetation and soil resources. Indeed, grazing delays maturation of the vegetation (Vallentine 1990), keeping plants in a vegetative, forage-producing state. Grazing also stimulates growth and regrowth by its pruning effect, maintaining optimum leaf area index (LAI = total leaf area per unit ground area), improving the nutritive value of available forage, and reducing excessive accumulations of standing dead vegetation and mulch. This reduces the vegetation biomass which, if allowed to build up, provides the undergrowth that favours outbreaks of fires and their propagation during the hot dry periods of summer. On the other hand, other common agro-pastoral activities can have negative effects. Soil is easily compacted due to trampling by livestock, and the soil can become bare due to overgrazing or ploughing. If fire is used to destroy vegetation to clear land for pasture, valuable organic matter is also lost from the soil. An understanding of the effects of grazing on vegetation and soil is fundamental for the development of a rational grazing management strategy within a more sustainable agro-pastoral context. 3.1 Grazing Effects on Vegetation
Grazing involves biting, pulling and breaking off plant parts, which causes defoliation, or even pulling entire plants out of the ground, if they are not well rooted. Furthermore the trampling and treading of the vegetation may damage the stand. Seed dispersal, internally through the animal digestive system, or externally by temporary attachment to animal hair, fleece or hooves, is an ecological factor affecting a perennial forage stand, but the impact will range from favourable to unfavourable, depending upon the plant species and site being affected (Vallentine 1990). Covering some parts of the vegetation with faeces and urine is another effect of grazing. Manure spots are generally avoided by animals visiting later, even though the nutritive quality of the affected forage (particularly rich in nitrogen) may be better than that on adjacent ground. Rejection is presumably on grounds of palatability based on smell or taste, and perhaps designed to avoid recycling internal parasites (Van Soest 1994). Measurement of the leaf area index (LAI) is a very useful indicator of how forage responds to grazing. Undergrazing allows overgrowth and shading by senescent foliage, which reduces photosynthesis and increases respiration. Optimum grazing pressure improves the effective LAI, whereas higher pressures, which result in excessive defoliation and a related decrease in forage yield, diminish it (Van Soest 1994). In addition to the reduction in leaf area per plant by grazing, the thinning out of grass species, which is a consequence of the selective feeding action of the animals or of the exposure of roots to the cutting edge of the hooves, can have a strong impact on final LAI and quality of forage. Plant recovery from defoliation depends not only on the available carbohydrate reserves but also on the quantity of the remaining foliage and its photosynthetic capacity. The rate of development of new foliage and photosynthetic capacity of new leaves is also important (Caldwell 1984). Generally, the lower the level of reserve carbohydrates, the more important the remaining leaf area is in promoting regrowth. Also, while perennial forage plants are influenced by the conditions in current and preceding years, which affect their root reserves and spring regrowth, annual forage plants are not. The supply of nutrients needed for the regrowth of annual forage plants after defoliation is primarily dependent on the remaining leaf area rather than storage compounds (Vallentine 1990). The optimum rational grazing management strategy should allow the maximum level of defoliation that will still maintain sustainable forage production and animal response. The definition of the optimum moment for grazing, the optimum frequency and duration of grazing, and the intensity of defoliation, by using a proper stocking rate, are of great importance (Brandano and Rossi 1975).
76 3.2
Mediterranean Desertification Grazing Effects on Soil
The negative effects of grazing on the soil are felt directly, through trampling, and indirectly, through the reduction of vegetation cover and removal of organic matter from the soil (Pulina et al. 1995a). The treading of soil by grazing animals may be detrimental, causing soil compaction, surface horizon disruption, reduction of infiltration, creation of terracing on steep slopes, development of animal trails, and thus erosion (Vallentine 1990). The degree of impact the animal treading has on a specific site depends on the interaction between vegetation, soil, weather and animals. Soil compaction by hooves causes a reduction in soil porosity which reduces water infiltration and percolation in the soil, leading to increased water runoff and erosion on sloping terrain, and a tendency to hydromorphism or to stagnation on flat terrain. Soil compaction depends both on the characteristics of the animals’ behaviour, such as their tendency to walk, run or jump, or to graze in groups, and on agro-pastoral interventions, such as the presence of concentration areas (shade of trees, areas protected from predominant winds, drinking places and artificial feeding places, etc.). Compaction depends not only on the stocking rate but also on the specific pressure of the hooves per square centimetre. For instance, a calculation based on hoof area and body weight of various animals has estimated an average pressure per unit area of 0.47 kg cm−2 for sheep, 0.98 kg cm−2 for cattle and 1.01 kg cm−2 for donkeys (Pulina et al. 1995a). The destruction of the soil surface by penetration of hooves is more likely to occur when soils are wet, where there are clay-textured soils and where there is poor vegetation cover. Other factors that may accentuate damage to soil properties include allowing grazing in the wet winter months, high stocking rates at any time, or a preponderance of cattle rather than lighter animals. The creation of terracing on sloping terrain, and of trails on flatter terrain, is a result of the routes chosen by animals while grazing and being transferred from one pasture to another. Trails, which become areas of bare soil, are created in direct proportion to stocking rates and in inverse proportion to the availability of forage. At times these trails may become a high proportion of the total pasture area, especially at waiting points near gates and in areas with a high movement of animals, such as near drinking places. These areas may suffer from significant wind erosion during the dry season. Overgrazing may remove part of the vegetation cover which, in its turn, brings about an increase in raindrop impact and surface soil crusting, and a decrease in organic soil matter, aggregate stability, and water infiltration rates (Blackburn 1983, 1984). All these effects may cause increased water runoff, reduced soil water content, and increased erosion. Organic matter in the soil is an important component of soil fertility and essential for the maintenance of good soil structure, which can counteract the erosive action of water and wind. The removal of organic matter by animals is due to an imbalance between the amount of dry matter they consume and the dry matter that returns to the soil in the form of faeces and urine (Pulina et al. 1995b). It is not easy to estimate the quantity of organic matter actually returned and incorporated into the soil by animals. Organic matter restitution is efficient only during wet seasons, when faeces are easily incorporated into the soil. At this time it is soft as a consequence of the animals’ intake of fresh grass with a high moisture content. On the other hand, in dry seasons, the faeces are much drier as a result of feeding on dry stubble and some internal body defence mechanisms that protect animals from wasting water. Dry faeces can remain on the soil surface for months and are likely to be completely oxidized.
4
THE CASE STUDY OF SARDINIA
In order to evaluate the effect of agro-pastoral activities on land degradation in Sardinia, a series of laboratory and field experiments were conducted under the aegis of the MEDALUS II project. A two-year experiment (1994–1995) was carried out on the main factors influencing cattle grazing behaviour. Initially the experimental site in north-western Sardinia at the Astimini-Fiume Santo basin (Figure 6.4), a region characterized by semi-arid climate (mean annual rainfall is 544 mm over a 39-year period), was overstocked (20 heifers of Limousine × Bruno Sarda cross occupying 10 ha with an initial stocking rate of 450 kg ha−1 ) (Enne et al. 1996). The average slope in this hilly area
77
Agro-pastoral Activities and Land Degradation in Sardinia Experimental area Stintino E A
Porto torres
Sardinia (Italy)
H
B
G I
Astimini-fiume santo basin
km 0
F
C
D
Experimental area 5
10 Legend Enclosure limits Sub-catchment and sub-areas limits
Subarea Surface (ha) A B C D E F G H I
Figure 6.4
0.40 1.87 1.02 1.49 0.35 0.84 1.46 0.69 1.08
Variables Aspect N NE N N W W NW N NW
Slope
Land cover
Soil
<30 Maquis Shallow soil 30−35 Sparse shrubs Shallow soil 30−35 Natural sward Shallow soil but eroded 35−40 Natural sward Shallow soil <30 Natural sward Shallow soil <30 Sparse shrubs Shallow soil >40 Natural sward Shallow soil <30 Sparse shrubs Shallow soil >40 Maquis − rock outcrop Rock outcrops
Location and main characteristics of the study area (Sardinia, Italy)
was greater than 35% and height above sea level ranged from 235 to 379 m. Soils can be classified as dystric, lithic, lithic ruptic–xerorthentic xerochrepts and lithic xerorthents (Soil Survey Staff 1996) over Paleozoic metamorphic substrates. Grazing behaviour was assumed not to be influenced by forage quality and availability because the vegetation was composed of a natural sward with mainly homogeneous species and ground cover, except for a small part of the area that was covered with maquis and scattered shrubs. Animals were given 4.7 kg DM hay daily (65% of their voluntary intake) throughout the experimental period, to compensate for the high stocking rate. Following a photo-interpretation method of analysis, the experimental area was theoretically divided into nine sub-areas homogeneous for topographical features, land-cover typologies and pedological characteristics. Site visitation by animals was influenced by the location of an artificial feeding site and of a resting area, time of day and season, local meteorological conditions, and topographical characteristics. Very early in the morning animals moved directly from the resting area, which was located at the upper part of the enclosure, downhill to the artificial feeding site, where they were afterwards found grazing. Then they moved around in regular patterns, shifting gradually to higher sub-areas in the afternoon and evening (Figure 6.5). During the experimental period, the animals tended to be distributed more homogeneously over the area, probably due to the effects of overstocking, there being too many of them for them all to find food in one place. In dry seasons animals tended to visit the sub-areas closest to the foraging site more frequently, while in wet seasons the distribution pattern was more homogeneous, and animals also tended to move and graze at higher elevations. On windy days, especially when winds blew from
78
Mediterranean Desertification 2
2
Legend Morning Afternoon Evening
250
250
1 2
300
300 1
Resting area Feeding area
1
350
350 (a) Wet season
0
(b) Dry season
100
200 m
Figure 6.5 Topographic map showing seasonal movement patterns of cattle in the experimental area Table 6.3 Average cumulative trampling pressure (kg cm−2 ) for each sub-area
Sub-area
A B C D E F G H
Period
Total
J–F
M–A
M–J
N–D
J–F
M–A
0.00 0.00 5.52 3.03 21.06 2.46 2.71 0.90
1.05 4.71 1.87 1.22 34.38 3.45 0.00 0.06
1.32 8.21 0.00 1.40 39.20 3.40 0.00 0.06
2.31 1.77 5.09 0.21 50.26 4.43 3.05 2.37
0.16 3.70 4.38 4.43 34.97 4.86 3.22 2.91
0.00 5.52 4.35 2.69 31.73 10.74 5.48 4.90
4.85 23.91 21.21 12.97 211.61 29.34 14.46 11.20
the north-west, animals preferred the most protected and leeward areas. The most visited sub-area in all seasons was the one nearest to the foraging area (E), followed by a bordering area (B) that was protected against strong winds. The least visited sub-areas were one mainly covered with maquis (A) and another that was relatively inaccessible and more exposed to strong winds (H). Even under high stocking rates, animals preferred some sites, which had a cumulative trampling pressure as high as 211.61 kg cm−2 , while other sites were visited much less frequently, with a cumulative trampling pressure as low as 4.85 kg cm−2 (Table 6.3). This part of the experiment showed that the traditional stocking rate (LSU ha−1 ) cannot be considered as a grazing pressure index without taking animal behaviour into account. In order to determine the effects of stock trampling on soils, samples of soil were taken from the grazed area of the above-described experiment and from an ungrazed control area (Previtali 1996). The surface horizons of the ungrazed soils showed an average bulk density of 1.0 g cm−3 (wellstructured medium-textured soil, with a medium to high organic matter content) and an average penetration resistance (soil strength) of 2.5 kg cm−2 (low penetration resistance). On the other hand, the surface horizons of the grazed soils showed some structural modification as shown by higher average bulk density (1.6 g cm−3 ) and higher average penetration resistance (4 kg cm−2 , moderate penetration resistance). Some micromorphological soil alterations were found after a one-year grazing period (Table 6.4), especially in the structural porosity (SP) of the soil which varied from 28% to 12% in the surface A horizon, and from 20% to 10% in the subsurface B horizon, in the
79
Agro-pastoral Activities and Land Degradation in Sardinia Table 6.4 Micromorphological characteristics in the grazed and ungrazed areas
Horizon
A horizon B horizon
Ungrazed area
Grazed area
Structural porosity (SP) %
Textural porosity (TP) %
Structural porosity (SP) %
Textural porosity (TP) %
28.4 19.7
27.9 18.2
11.7 10.0
33.1 29.9
ungrazed and grazed areas, respectively. These values show that cattle trampling influenced not only the surface horizons, but also the structural characteristics of the subsurface horizons. Analysis of the hydrological state of the soil in the basin studied highlighted that restoring normal soil water storage did not take place before November (Madrau et al. 1995). From November until March, the period in which rainfall in this semi-arid climate is more concentrated, the average soil moisture content on some days crossed the modified threshold of plasticity limit of 31%. From springtime onwards, the soil moisture dropped below such a critical value. Thus, winter is the season during which the risk of soil degradation by animal trampling is highest in this climatic and pedological context. As part of the large-scale experiment described above, the effect of continuous high stocking grazing was compared with the situation in ungrazed areas. Pastoral value and forage production were studied in this natural pasture region of north-western Sardinia for two years (1993/94 and 1994/95) (Caredda et al. 1996). The natural pasture of the experimental basin, which was representative of many other Sardinian marginal areas, was characterized by low productive potential, because of the steep slopes, superficial rockiness and limited soil depth. The use of a high and continuous stocking rate caused an increase in the area of bare soil surface particularly in the second year (10% higher than in the ungrazed area), thus increasing the risk of soil erosion. Grazing influenced the floristic composition of the vegetation by reducing the presence of some weeds, such as Galactites tomentosa, and grasses, probably due to animal selection; grazing also increased the presence of subclover (Trifolium subterraneum), thus improving the pastoral value. The botanical composition of the fresh grass available in both treatments was dominated mainly by species from the Compositae family. In both treatments, dry matter production was always below 2 t ha−1 year−1 , with a maximum value of forage availability and growth rate in spring. Seasonal rainfall distribution and temperature determine the length of growing period in Sardinia, leading to a huge variation of forage availability during the year. As a consequence, pasture tends to be overgrazed in dry autumn and/or cold winter, and undergrazed during favourable conditions of spring. For grazed and ungrazed treatments, the amount of residual organic matter was very high, particularly in autumn, because of the great quantity of non-utilized biomass, unpalatable and thorny species from the previous year. An increase in the percentage of residual organic matter, on the basis of dry matter content, occurred at the end of spring. In the ungrazed basin, total residual dry matter in summer was high, increasing the risk of fire. In another trial carried out in northern Sardinia, comparisons were made between a ploughed– cereal cultivated area, and an area with natural Mediterranean maquis. Based on this study and on some other trials that have been conducted for 10 years (Caredda et al. 1996), it was found that a good permanent pasture sward or a dense Mediterranean maquis was adequate vegetation cover to maintain soil losses far below critical levels in the autumn months. The intensification of cropping on hillslopes using annual short-term forage and winter crops increased erosion risk, particularly if crop establishment was slow and ploughing was done across the contours, rather than parallel to them. Figure 6.6 compares the effect of land use on percentage vegetation cover in the winter months, and illustrates the difference in potential erosion risk between maintaining pasture and cultivating arable crops, which leave the soil surface almost bare for weeks or months. Therefore, the incorrect methods of ploughing on steep slopes, and the lack of vegetation between ploughing and sowing time can be considered as dangerous agricultural practice as far as desertification is concerned.
80
Mediterranean Desertification 100
Vegetation cover (%)
80
60
40
20
0 Oct
Nov
Dec
natural pasture short-term forage crop
Jan
Feb
Mar
improved pasture cereal
Figure 6.6 Comparison of the change in % vegetation cover for pasture and for arable crops between October 1993 and March 1994, at Ottava-Sassari
Furthermore, cereal crops cultivated in those marginal areas not only increase erosion risk but are uneconomic as they also show a low yield.
5
CONCLUSIONS
Agro-pastoralism is one of the most important economic activities in the whole of the Mediterranean Basin. In southern Mediterranean countries, the increased demographic pressure, urbanization, the improved standard of living and the needs of the human diet, based on proteins from milk and meat of goats and sheep, will lead to an increased food demand in the near future. Therefore, one might expect an increase in over-exploitation of agricultural lands in these areas due to an increase in stocking rates of small ruminants. On the other hand, particularly during the last decade, the north Mediterranean countries have experienced land abandonment in rural areas which has led to the appearance of land degradation phenomena. The studies carried out in Sardinia, an area characterized by both over-exploitation and land abandonment, showed that practices related to agro-pastoral activities, such as overgrazing, badly planned cultivation and the use of fire to clear pastures, can be considered the main causes of desertification. Based on those studies, the following general guidelines for preventing and mitigating desertification can be suggested: 1. Evaluation of land suitability for grazing should be done by standardized methods that must be adapted to different scales (regional, local and point scale). 2. Estimation of pasture productivity using mathematical models based on meteorological and vegetation parameters may allow the determination of sustainable stocking rates according to the season and year. 3. Determination of low-impact animal production systems should consider animal species and varieties adapted to local environmental conditions, rational grazing management, and lowimpact pasture improvement practices. 4. Development of integrated models for the management of agro-silvo-pastoral resources in the area with particular reference to common lands. Farm development plans should be linked to planning and management tools at a larger scale.
Agro-pastoral Activities and Land Degradation in Sardinia
81
REFERENCES Blackburn WH (1983) Livestock grazing impacts on watersheds. Rangelands 5(3), 123–125. Blackburn WH (1984) Impacts of grazing intensity and specialized grazing systems on watershed characteristics and responses. In Developing Strategies for Rangeland Management , National Research Council and National Academy of Science. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado, pp. 927–983. Brandano P and Rossi G (1975) La razionale utilizzazione dei pascoli ed i problemi inerenti la determinazione del carico. L’Informatore Agrario 32, 20 139–20 148. Buller HJ (1992) Agricultural Change and the Environment in Western Europe. Mansell Press, London. Caldwell MM (1984) Plant requirements for prudent grazing. In Developing Strategies for Rangeland Management, National Research Council and National Academy of Science. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado, pp. 117–152. Caredda S, Porqueddu C, Roggero PP, Sanna A and Casu S (1992) Feed resources and feed requirements in the sheep agro-pastoral system of Sardinia. Proceedings of the IV International Rangeland Congress, Montpellier, 22–26 April 1991, pp. 734–737. Caredda S, Ledda L, Porqueddu C and Sulas L (1996) Pastoral value and forage production of grazed and ungrazed natural swards in a semi-arid Mediterranean area of Sardinia. In G Parente, J Frame and S Orsi (eds) Grassland and Land Use Systems. Arti Grafiche Friulane, Tavagnacco, pp. 395–399. Chandler C, Cheney P, Thomas P, Trabaud L and Williams D (1983) Fire in Forestry. Forest Fires Behaviour and Effects. John Wiley, New York. Doucet P and Sloep PB (1992) Mathematical Modelling in Life Sciences. Ellis Horwood, Chichester. EEC (1996) Forest Fires in the South Mediterranean Union. European Commission, Directorate General for Agriculture, Brussels. Enne G, Pulina G, d’Angelo M and Masala G (1996) The role of animal grazing behaviour on land degradation in Mediterranean environments. In International Conference on Land Degradation, Abstract. University of Cukurova, ¸ Adana, Turkey. FAO (1995) FAO Yearbook Production 1994 . FAO Statistics Series, FAO, Rome. ISTAT (1976) II Censimento Generale dell’Agricoltura. Istituto Centrale di Statistica, Rome. ISTAT (1982) III Censimento Generale dell’Agricoltura. Istituto Centrale di Statistica, Rome. ISTAT (1992) IV Censimento Generale dell’Agricoltura. Istituto Centrale di Statistica, Rome. Madrau S, Deroma MA, Dess`ı G and Goussikpe Y (1995) Soil properties and trafficability of the Rio AstiminiFiume Santo experimental plots (North-western Sardinia). In A Aru, G Enne and G Pulina (eds) Land Use and Soil Degradation. MEDALUS in Sardinia. La Celere Editrice, Alghero, pp. 211–220. Molina MJ (1996) Impact of forest fires on desertification processes: a review in relation to soil erodibility. In JL Rubio and A Calvo (eds) Soil Degradation and Desertification in Mediterranean Environments. Geoforma Ediciones, Logrono, Spain. Previtali F (1996) Soil degradation processes and land use in north-western Sardinia (Italy). Proceedings of the International Conference on Land Degradation, Abstract. University of Cukurova, ¸ Adana, Turkey. Pulina G, Zanda A and Enne G (1995a) The impact of animal husbandry on the degradation of the soil. In A Aru, G Enne and G Pulina (eds) Land Use and Soil Degradation. MEDALUS in Sardinia. La Celere Editrice, Alghero, pp. 231–240. Pulina G, Masala G, Zanda A and Enne G (1995b) Analysis of biomass balance and stocking rate in cattle and sheep production systems in Mediterranean areas. MEDIT 1, 27–30. RAS (1996) Piano per la difesa contro gli incendi nei boschi e nelle campagne. Regione Autonoma della Sardegna–Assessorato della Difesa dell’Ambiente, Cagliari. Rivoira G, Roggero PP and Bullitta S (1989) Influenza delle tecniche di miglioramento dei pascoli sui fenomeni erosivi dei terreni in pendio. Rivista di Agronomia 4, 372–377. Roggero PP, Porqueddu C, Sulas L and Caredda S (1995) Relationships between land use and water run-off and soil erosion in a Mediterranean environment. In NE West (ed.) Proceedings of the V International Grassland Congress, Society of Range Management, Denver, Colorado, pp. 481–482. Seligman NG (1996) Management of Mediterranean grasslands. In J Hodgson and AW Illius (eds) The Ecology and Management of Grazing Systems. CAB International, Oxon, pp. 359–391. Soil Survey Staff (1996) Keys to Soil Taxonomy. United States Department of Agriculture, National Resource Conservation Service, Washington, DC. Vallentine JF (1990) Grazing Management. Academic Press, San Diego. Van Soest P (1994) Nutritional Ecology of Ruminants, 2nd edition, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York, pp. 93–107.
7
Landscape Protection from Grazing and Fire
N.S. MARGARIS AND E. KOUTSIDOU
Department of Environmental Studies, University of the Aegean, Lesvos, Greece
1 INTRODUCTION During recent decades, the number of wildfires and the surface area burned have increased in most countries of the Mediterranean region. Forest fires have become a major concern for politicians and the general public. Although fires have affected the Mediterranean region for millions of years, it is likely that changes in land use brought about by recent socio-economic changes may have affected when, where, how big, how frequent and how intense these fires are. Until now, in most countries fire suppression has been the main policy, and large and increasing sums are spent on fighting fires every year. To introduce new policies that would reduce fire risk and its impacts, it is necessary to have a good understanding of how fire affects the structure and functioning of ecosystems. The purpose of this chapter is to evaluate the main ways in which fire (combined with overgrazing) affects ecosystem properties in Mediterranean-type areas and what ecological principles management policies should take into account to reduce fire-related hazards (Figure 7.1). A major part of the Mediterranean landscape is made up of the semi-natural (non-cultivated but managed) system. The plants dominating in this system in the “Mediterranean-type” climate have developed adaptations to water stress during the dry period. They may be evergreen sclerophyllous (called maquis in the Mediterranean Basin, choresh in Israel, matorral in Chile, and chaparral in California) at the wet end of the precipitation gradient (975 mm annual precipitation), or, at the dry end of the precipitation gradient (around 275 mm annual precipitation), they may show seasonal dimorphism, which considerably reduces the transpiring surface area of the plant in the hot season. Such plants (known as phrygana in Greece, tomillares in Spain, batha in Israel, and coastal sage in California) are mainly thorny with a low cushion structure. Evergreen sclerophyllous plants of the maquis are characterized by small thick leathery evergreen leaves. These leaves often show a combination of anatomical modifications including thick cuticles, well-developed palisade mesophyll and the enclosure of stomata within small pits or grooves which are often partially occluded by hair or wax tubules. In general, evergreen species have leaves with a relatively high mass per unit area. This greater density of the evergreen leaf may be important in promoting water conservation and predator protection. Over the Greek Peninsula and the Aegean Islands these plant types are widely distributed, absent only in mountainous areas, and becoming sparse on the northern coast of the Aegean Sea. It has been estimated that the phrygana occupy between 1 and 1.6 million hectares while the maquis area covers about 775 000 ha (Papanastasis 1977; Diamantopoulos 1983). The total area of phryganatype vegetation in the Mediterranean Basin has been estimated at about 25 million hectares (Le Houerou 1981).
2 ADAPTATION OF THE MEDITERRANEAN ECOSYSTEMS TO SURVIVE FIRE Fire is a very common event in the areas covered by Mediterranean-type ecosystems, due to the combination of high air temperatures and water deficiency during the summer. During the long Mediterranean Desertification: A Mosaic of Processes and Responses. Edited by N.A. Geeson, C.J. Brandt and J.B. Thornes 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
84
Mediterranean Desertification
Figure 7.1 Annual fire pre-suppression costs are not related to the area of burned land or the financial loss caused by fires at national level
dry season, maximum temperatures may exceed 40 ◦ C, dry continental winds sweep coastward and air relative humidity may drop below 5%. The vegetation becomes extremely dry (less than 10% moisture on a dry weight basis). In this desiccated state the Mediterranean-type ecosystems are very susceptible to fire, a fact long recognized by scientists (Griesebach 1872). Typically, major fires in any particular area occur with a frequency of once every 20 to 30 years. It is clear that fire is an important element in the actual evolution of maquis and other sclerophyllous shrub vegetation in all regions with a Mediterranean-type climate. The positive influence of fire in the evolution of these ecosystems has been indicated by many authors (Shantz 1947; Biswell 1974; Margaris 1981; Trabaud 1982). Surprisingly, there seem to be evolutionary tendencies towards increased flammability in these plants, for example by the production of volatile oils in many phryganic species. It has been suggested
Landscape Protection from Grazing and Fire
85
that the plants are adapted to survive fairly regular burning, where fire temperatures are controlled, and the plants are only superficially damaged. However, if the volume of flammable plant material on the surface has been allowed to build up, then any subsequent fire would be intense and at very high temperatures, damaging plant structures above and below ground, and destroying seed banks in the surface soil (Moreno and Oechel 1994). Plants dominating Mediterranean-type ecosystems are equipped with adaptive strategies to help their post-fire recovery (Margaris 1981; Arianoutsou and Margaris 1982). Thus fire and adaptations to fire are part of the properties of the ecosystem. Under normal fire frequencies (every 80–100 years for pine forest, every 20–30 years for shrubs; Trabaud 1982), fire acts as a selective force in these systems so that the results of fire can be considered as fire-induced or fire-adapted. Post-fire survival of the woody community can be accomplished by re-sprouting and by increased seed germination from the soil seed bank. Re-sprouting is carried out from dormant buds located at the crown where they are not destroyed by fire. This can be observed quickly after fire in the maquis and after the first autumn rains in the phrygana. Vegetative regeneration is very fast, and in a period of less than 10 years full reconstitution takes place because the rate of photosynthesis in the young stems is particularly high (Naveh 1973). In the phryganic species this fast reconstitution can be due to the new leaves which are both larger and richer in chlorophyll than normal. For example, the increase in the chlorophyll content in leaves after fire was 150% compared to that before fire in Sarcopoterium spinosum, allowing photosynthesis to be significantly increased (Arianoutsou and Margaris 1982). Survival of the dominant woody species by increased germination of its own seed is an adaptation that occurs mainly in Pinus species and in the phrygana, while in the maquis the only method of survival seems to be the ability to re-sprout. This re-sprouting soon results in a stand without great age dissimilarities between the individuals. Under normal fire frequencies herbaceous plants appear in large numbers during the first few post-fire years, which is the result of the activated germination of seeds of those herbaceous species lying in the soil seed bank. This short-lived herbaceous interlude has two major advantages. First, the vegetation cover protects against soil erosion, and second, through the nitrogen-fixing ability of leguminous species, atmospheric nitrogen is brought back to the soil, since approximately 95% of the nitrogen contained in the above-ground biomass is removed from the ecosystem in smoke from fires. Leguminous species return nitrogen to the soil via the nodules on their roots (Arianoutsou and Margaris 1981). The proportion of the herb biomass is greater during the first two years after fire, then declines rapidly, with shrubby species dominating from the third year onwards. The life span of the dominant woody species of the phrygana, such as Phlomis fruticosa, Euphorbia acanthothamnos, Sarcopoterium spinosum and Cistus sp., may be a few decades, but this period might be less than the time interval between two successive fires. Cistus sp. live for up to 15 years and the same is true for Phlomis fruticosa. Euphorbia acanthothamnos, Sarcopoterium spinosum and Thymus capitatus have longer life spans, reaching 50 years (Arianoutsou and Margaris 1982). Consequently these species must base their recovery mechanisms on germination of dormant seeds after fire, and this is reflected in their age distribution. This is normal for the woody plants of the phrygana but not for the maquis. We have shown that there is an optimum frequency of fires to ensure the survival of the ecosystem species, but the intervention of human activities may result in a fire frequency that is either higher or lower than the optimum. In both cases the equilibrium is affected, and systems may become degraded. This will be our point of focus, since only a higher fire frequency is considered to cause damage. About 200 000 ha of forests and shrublands are burned annually in the Mediterranean Basin (Le Houerou 1973). The numerous adaptations to fire shown by plants dominating these ecosystems suggest that fire has been a selective force for a long time. The important point is that the plant ecosystems can recover from the regular burning regime that they have become adapted to, but interference from humans, and other associated factors such as grazing or trampling by livestock, can interrupt that process and cause long-term damage to the plant communities. Humans have been burning the Mediterranean forest for the past 6000 years in order to obtain better pasture and crop lands, and this practice still remains an important cause of forest fire in Corsica, certain parts of Italy, Greece, Turkey, Spain and Algeria. When fires occur too frequently
86
Mediterranean Desertification
(every 10 years or less) the plant community structure loses its ability to regenerate and becomes very simple, with only low shrubs and herbs (Le Houerou 1981).
3
GRAZING IN MEDITERRANEAN ECOSYSTEMS AND THE RELATIONSHIP WITH FIRE
The breeding of sheep and goats began in the eastern Mediterranean between 12 000 and 8000 BP. Humans have partly co-evolved with these ecosystems. The breeding of ruminants is still the principal agricultural activity in the Mediterranean countries (Le Houerou 1981). Rangelands, as surveyed by the National Statistical Service of Greece, include all non-productive forests as well as maquis and phryganic ecosystems. In fact, all semi-natural vegetation, apart from a few timber-producing forests, is used by domestic herbivores and can be considered as rangeland (Paraskevopoulos 1991). As with fire, the Mediterranean vegetation is well adapted to withstand complete devastation by grazing livestock by having thorns and aromatic substances that make it unpalatable (Le Houerou 1981). These are the essential oils and resins that also make the vegetation highly flammable during periods of drought. Like fire, grazing only causes permanent damage to the plant communities if it is uncontrolled. If it is carried out using rational criteria (i.e. choosing the optimum time of the year for grazing, not allowing grazing in one place all year round, and recognizing an optimum period for which land should be left fallow) and with the correct stocking rate, grazing will improve plant productivity and biodiversity, and will reduce the accumulation of flammable dry biomass. In general, one year of grazing should be followed by two years left ungrazed (Paraskevopoulos 1991). The plant ecosystems have adapted to withstand fire and grazing, except where the pressure is too great. Shepherds know very well that herbaceous plants are abundant after fire and that leguminous species in particular are an excellent source of food for sheep. For this reason fires may be started on purpose. If fires are followed by intense grazing, and the juicy herbaceous plants and re-sprouting are either eaten or trampled during grazing, the whole system will be out of equilibrium and cannot recover because the otherwise efficient adaptive mechanisms cannot continue. The only plants capable of survival are those particularly resistant to fire and grazing. Since most of these are unpalatable, shepherds wishing to get rid of them use the same practice, i.e. setting fires more frequently. This is especially true for Sarcopoterium spinosum, a Mediterranean dwarf shrub, because this shrub is not suitable for animal fodder. Another reason why the overgrazing that follows wildfires has a destructive impact on the land productivity is that the supply of nitrogen to the system is reduced. Also, because the low productivity of the Mediterranean rangelands may not be sufficient to cover the dietary needs of livestock, shepherds are often forced to supplement the diet with fodder. Keeping livestock is not an easy living, and in order to increase productivity and to reduce the production costs of dairy products on a short-term basis the cycle of fires and overgrazing continues every year. This approach completely undermines the equilibrium between vegetation, fire and grazing, and leads to widespread degradation. Maintaining an equilibrium between vegetation, fire and grazing, within the limits of the adaptations described above, is the only method available of sustaining the ecosystem in the long term. An example of where the increase in grazing pressure (even now there is a trend to increase the number of grazing animals) has resulted in ecosystem degradation and desertification, is on the Aegean Islands. In some desertified areas the dominant species is Asphodelus microcarpus, a plant well adapted to dry conditions, fire and overgrazing since its deep-rooted underground part avoids permanent damage to the plant (Pantis 1987). In general, these asphodel deserts can be considered to be the last stage of degradation of the maquis systems. Under normal conditions Asphodelus microcarpus is a geophyte that grows in the maquis as well as in the phrygana. It has a flower stalk 1 m high, which is greater than the height of most shrubs, so it can be distinguished easily by pollinators and therefore reproduces effectively. Asphodel deserts are systems of extremely low productivity. The above-ground biomass does not surpass 150 g m−2 , compared to non-degraded maquis with an above-ground biomass of at least 4 kg m−2 .
Landscape Protection from Grazing and Fire
87
Since historical times the inhabitants and farmers of the Mediterranean landscape have been acquainted with the potential problems and have taken measures against desertification. On the Aegean Islands, isolation and scarcity of resources forced islanders to develop special systems of management in which agriculture and animal husbandry were key parts. Landscapes that lacked flat plains and a reliable water supply forced the development of terrace agriculture and the cultivation of either annual (cereals, legumes, etc.) or perennial (olives, almonds, figs, etc.) plant species. This agro-pastoral system included grazing and was usually organized on a rotation system so that 50% of the land was under cultivation and the other 50% under grazing, reversing the land use the following year. Grazing was permitted only in certain areas and not all year round. For hundreds of years this form of management allowed a continuous but sustainable exploitation of environmental resources right across the Mediterranean Basin (Margaris 1992). As long as equilibrium is maintained, rates of desertification remain very low. This optimal system has collapsed dramatically during recent decades. On the Aegean Islands this has mainly been due to the increased mechanization of agriculture on the plains of the Greek mainland, which has meant that the islanders could no longer produce cereal, etc., at competitive prices and so were forced to abandon their usual agriculture activities. With the abandonment of terrace cultivation, animal husbandry has begun to dominate on all the islands (Table 7.1). Although the area given over to pasture has increased, the grazing pressure has not been reduced because in recent years the number of animals has also increased, mainly as a result of subsidies provided by the EC. The result has been an increase in desertification processes on the islands, a phenomenon that requires immediate action wherever possible. The relatively high stocking rate and the lack of planning for development and exploitation of pastures, together with the frequency of fires (almost annual) on the Aegean islands, has led to a general impoverishment of the pastoral value of the natural vegetation, followed by a progressive reduction and then elimination of the most favoured species (legumes and grasses) and their replacement by species that are unpalatable to livestock (Le Houerou 1977; Clark 1996). The most serious damage is done when grazing is permitted on soil still bare during the first year after a burn, when the woody or herbaceous young shoots are still tender. Herbaceous plants and re-sprouting shoots are eaten or trampled by grazing animals and the vegetation has no further means to regenerate. Where overgrazing removes seedlings before new seed is set, the seed bank for regeneration with annual herbaceous species after fire is progressively depleted. While a natural phryganic ecosystem supports approximately 20 woody species, where degradation is occurring the number of species declines so that eventually only two or three species, particularly Sarcopoterium spinosum, Thymus capitatus or Cistus sp., remain. Only plants that can regenerate from deep-seated underground parts, like the asphodel, can survive the most intensive fire and grazing. On the Aegean Islands it is clear that the productive capacity of the pastures is not enough to support the current number of animals on a long-term basis. Since the low productivity of the rangeland is not sufficient to cover the dietary needs of the livestock, shepherds are forced to supplement the diet with imported fodder. The total animal food products imported to the islands is increasing year by year. On the island of Lesvos, for example, natural pasture biomass is only providing 30% of animal requirements. Shepherds wishing to get rid of unpalatable thorny plant species and promote the short-term growth of palatable herbaceous and re-sprouting species are Table 7.1 Changes in the number of sheep and goats (in flocks and nomadic) between 1965 and 1995 on selected Aegean islands
Island Dodecanisa Cyclades Lesvos Samos Chios
1965
1970
1975
1980
1985
1990
1995
119 540 175 605 183 501 29 647 13 542
121 119 172 999 188 620 30 629 24 472
78 788 132 763 174 896 13 194 15 220
117 300 239 047 293 172 22 042 31 830
146 320 242 247 336 533 25 039 23 778
145 802 281 237 372 856 28 232 37 736
150 063 248 623 405 129 32 081 42 613
88
Mediterranean Desertification
still using fire on a frequent basis. As many as 40% of the total number of fires on the islands may be caused intentionally by shepherds (Koutsidou 1995). The growth of the livestock population combined with the low natural productivity of the pastures explains very clearly the rapid and intense degradation of Mediterranean vegetation seen in recent decades. Without intervention, the final result will be irreversible desertification.
4
THE MANAGEMENT OF MEDITERRANEAN-TYPE ECOSYSTEMS
Ecosystem degradation caused by the combination of frequent fires and subsequent overgrazing has led to the consideration of fire as a catastrophic event usually attributed to criminal actions. The healthy ecosystem’s natural requirement for regular burning tends to be forgotten. Due to this misunderstanding a policy of complete fire exclusion was initiated, and this brought more problems. The direct consequence of a fire exclusion policy is that biomass accumulates in the ecosystem. Therefore, when fire does break out, the burns reach high temperatures and the vegetation and the seed bank may be too damaged to allow recovery afterwards. This fact was realized about 25 years ago in California, and today carefully controlled burning techniques are a common practice in California (Conrad and Oechel 1982). Also, from the ecological point of view, in the systems where fire is excluded the diversity is reduced in terms of both plant and animal species. So fire exclusion policies are not protecting the maquis at all. Fires are needed, prescribed regularly, and controlled during the moister part of the year to reduce the temperatures reached. This technique is also being used as a modern and efficient tool for the management of certain other vegetation types commonly reputed to be very sensitive, such as the Pinus halepensis forests of Greece. The result is real protection not only of these ecosystems but also of human settlements. The shortcomings of this technique are that (a) enormous quantities of energy and organic matter are lost and (b) there is always the danger of the fire running out of control. Although experience from California is very positive, countries around the Mediterranean are proving unwilling to abandon fire exclusion policies, which are both inefficient and very costly. In Greece, even political stability is threatened because of annual fires. There, an area of approximately 15 000 ha is burnt every year. Failure of these measures to solve the problem has never led to any evaluation of their validity, as common logic might suggest. On the contrary, every Mediterranean government seems willing, even after years of widespread destruction, to further increase the budget available for so-called “fire protection policies” and for reforestation afterwards. It is ironic that today Mediterranean countries are importing 80% of their liquid fuels, while at the same time mismanaging the potential of natural vegetation as fuel. Huge amounts of money are spent on fire fighting and fire protection, and every year about 200 000 ha are burned out in the Mediterranean Basin. Margaris et al. (1985) have shown that if maquis ecosystems are harvested every 10 years, this practice can provide fuel and also reduce the risk of uncontrolled high-temperature fires which cause so much damage. After 10 years, biomass accumulation in the maquis is moderate, but not as great as at the mature stage, which takes 20–30 years. Education of farmers and landowners is required, to avoid further unnecessary exploitation and damage.
5
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF DESERTIFICATION: THE CASE OF THE ISLAND OF CHIOS
The northern territory of the island of Chios is a typical example of an area where there have been annual fires throughout a whole decade (1981–1991). Productivity of the rangelands was not sufficient to feed the animals, and fodder imports increased every year. At the same time, to minimize the costs of imported fodder, the natural ecosystem has been completely overgrazed. The combination of overgrazing and fires is the main cause of desertification in this area. The objective of this analysis is to evaluate and compare the total costs of overgrazing and fire with a more sustainable approach. Our aims would be to eliminate the deliberate starting of fires by shepherds to bring about a short-term increase in shoots palatable to livestock, and to alter the form
89
Landscape Protection from Grazing and Fire
of stock-farming from extensive to intensive, by subsidizing stock farmers so that they replace the plant biomass that is removed from the pasture by the livestock. The environmental benefits from the achievement of this goal are apparent both in terms of the reduction in the number of fires on the national and local scale, and in relation to the regeneration of vegetation that takes place when grazing is prohibited (Koutsidou 1995). Table 7.2 shows official classifications of the causes of fires on the northern part of Chios, and also for all of Greece for the period 1981–1991. It is likely that many of those fires with an unknown cause were in fact arson, but this is always difficult to prove. So we shall consider that 30% of fires of unknown causes and 20% of those caused due to negligence were unproved acts of arson. With this assumption, 44.1% of the fires in northern Chios were probably started deliberately, specifically to increase the area suitable for pasture (in the decade 1981–1991, 41.6 ha of agricultural land and 17.7 ha of forests became pasture). An economic analysis of the costs involved includes pre-suppression costs (PC), suppression costs (SC), partial-rectification costs (RC), added to suppression costs, and fire damage (FD). Pre-suppression costs are regarded as the purchase of machinery (aircraft, fire engines, wireless, communication systems, etc.), the construction work involved in creating anti-fire protection facilities (fire control watch towers, anti-fire zones, etc.) and the salaries of personnel (forest guards, seasonal fire-fighters, etc.). Suppression costs are regarded as all the costs that arise during firefighting operations (labour hours, operational costs of machinery, consumable equipment, etc.). An attempt has been made to estimate the forest-fire prevention costs in northern Chios by means of a graduated approach. Of the total annual pre-suppression costs, 50% are apportioned to northern Chios, while the total annual suppression costs are apportioned between northern and southern Chios according to the location where the fire-fighting operations took place. Damages caused by the fire (FD) were estimated according to the percentage of burnt land area in the either part of the island, while partial-rectification costs (RC) in northern Chios are considered to be 50% of the total costs. Table 7.3 shows an analysis for northern Chios, for the period 1981–1991, taking 1991 as the base year, with costs expressed in American dollars. This analysis includes the commercial value of the wood destroyed, the cost of fire prevention and fire fighting, and the cost of regeneration, but does not take into account associated damage such as flash floods causing sheet erosion, leading to sedimentation and silting up of dams and canals, and the reduction of fertility and productivity of damaged soils and vegetation (Turner et al. 1994). The annual fluctuation of pre-suppression costs in order to fight fires in northern Chios does not necessarily cause a change on the same scale as the burnt land area or the financial loss caused by the fires. This lack of correspondence between the scale of the annual pre-suppression costs and the burnt land surface is also the case at the national scale (Skourtos and Dimitrakopoulos 1991). The average (1981–1991) expenditure per year, including direct and indirect costs, amounts to $9 884 170 per 915.97 ha (average burnt area per year) of burnt land surface on northern Chios. Table 7.2 Classification of causes of fires in Greece and northern Chios, 1981–1991
Cause of fire
Deliberate and arson Negligence Unknown cause Thunderbolt Ammunition used during military exercises Miscellaneous
All of Greece (%)
Northern Chios (%) Official classification
Alternative classification
27.66 24.31 40.38 2.92 0.84
27.5 24.5 40 3.44
44.1 19.6 28.3 3.44
3.89
4.56
4.56
Source: Chlikas, Ministry of Agriculture, Greece, personal communication, 1993.
Costs
1981
Aircraft 36 612 Vehicles 18 092 Buildings 408 Functional 377 Vehicle maintenance 336 Salaries of permanent 11 099 personnel 4 372 Salaries of seasonal and contract workers (SC)a Prevention strategiesb – Total PC for Chios 71 296 35 648 50% of PC for N. Chiosc PC for N. Chios (fixed 194 796 on 1991 rates) Burnt land on N. Chios 6147.5 (ha), and as % of (100%) total area burned on Chios Suppression and 47 631 rectification costs (based on 1991 rates) of N. Chios FD of N. Chios 61 881 648 (based on 1991 rates) Total PC + SC + RC + FD a
62 124 080
1982
1983
1984
20 901 17 188 511 359 295 15 322
26 066 16 283 561 480 553 19 483
94 707 15 378 651 613 1022 23 974
182 072 57 237 916 615 1855 30 622
7 530
10 079
33 280
32 484
– 62 105 31 053 139 875
3809 77 316 38 658 144 786
329 169 954 84 977 268 914
69.4 (47.8%)
370.7 (100%)
27 335
78 269
204 (49.3%)
28 437
1985
1988
1989
1990
526 316 102 727 2086 1089 2234 56 122
– 96 632 1579 1356 1365 67 859
29 210 – 90 536 166 678 1904 2309 903 1165 2958 8158 79 609 96 118
50 526
71 191
66 868
134 270 146 424
3332 309 132 154 566 409 986
5523 18 056 213 207 1 578 799 106 604 789 400 229 747 1 461 849
22 079 783 842 391 921 638 306
21 375 257 033 128 516 184 118
36 885 37 602 376 273 458 454 188 137 229 227 223 700 229 227
678 (70%)
126.1 (100%)
1083.8 (100%)
98 (65.5%)
413.2 (43.8%)
3289
227 782
45 365
15 710
78 602
1986
1987
– 1 350 329 115 247 108 822 1086 727 914 994 3934 1411 44 372 47 934 42 132
1060 (63.2%)
145 604
1991
45 (64.8%)
23 075
2 055 474
709 122 3 752 589 6 875 428 1 292 763 10 966 740 10 704 605 1 012 766 4 167 763 460 526
2 223 790
881 243 4 099 770 7 364 020 1 525 800 12 656 370 11 488 520 1 242 250 4 407 170 712 828
The cost covers salaries of contract workers and drivers working on a seasonal basis, fire-fighters and fire-guards. The cost covers construction work for the construction of anti-fire zones, fire watch-towers, etc. c Northern Chios comprises 42.61% of the total area of the islands. However, it was considered rational to allocate the costs equally in both parts of Chios due to the more frequent occurrence of fires in northern Chios. b
90
Table 7.3 Pre-suppression (PC), suppression (SC), reforestation–rectification costs (RD) and financial damage (FD) caused by fires on northern Chios between 1981 and 1991 (in American dollars, at current rates with 1991 as the base year)
Landscape Protection from Grazing and Fire
91
Table 7.4 Estimated cost of substantial cereal diet during the gestation period (in American dollars, at current rates with 1991 as the base year)
A cereal diet Vetch Straw Maize Roughage Cotton cake Total fodder for seven months per animal Number of sheep and goats
Animal needs per day (kg) 0.3125 0.13 0.781 0.25 0.0625 312.5 37 900
Cost 0.15 0.11 0.16 0.14 0.13 48.75 1 847 548
Source: Union of Agricultural co-operatives of Chios island, personal communication, 1994. Of this expenditure, 40% is due to fires caused by shepherds and amounts to $3 953 668 for the corresponding year. The costs presented in Table 7.4 show clearly the benefits to be had from using land-use practices that minimize the incidence of fire damage. The productivity of pastures in northern Chios was estimated as 10 732 612 kg dry matter (average productivity of 1989 and 1990; Koutsidou 1995). The grazing lands are used chiefly during the period from March to September. According to the statistics provided by the National Statistics Service of Greece for 1991, the extensive stock-raising comprises 37 900 animals: 7777 sheep and 30 123 goats. The seven months’ dietary needs of the animals that graze in the northern part of Chios, measured in dry matter, are 11 258 425 kg. It is clear that the productivity of the phryganic rangeland is not sufficient to cover the dietary needs of the livestock capital that grazes in the northern parts of Chios and additional fodder has to be imported. In the summer period shepherds are forced to supplement the diet with a total of 525 813 kg fodder (Koutsidou 1995). Therefore, to reduce the costs associated with imported fodder, shepherds cannot resist the temptation to set fires to grazing lands in order to increase, just for a short period of course, the pasture productivity, and subsequent livestock productivity, in terms of dairy products. A substantial cereal diet for all livestock during the gestation period, which equals the quantity of dry matter that would be taken from the ecosystem by the animals for seven months, costs $1 847 548. It is obvious that the subsidy of fodder costs less than the cost of fire-fighting, so we can avoid these fires by paying much less money directly to shepherds. It must be noted that the above figure is even smaller if the amount of money paid by shepherds as rental costs for the grazing land is taken into account. Finally, if we take into account that the best management for pasture rangelands is one year of grazing followed by one year of land being set aside, the total cost of subsidies may be reduced by half.
6 CONCLUSION We can say that Mediterranean-type ecosystems are very resilient and sustainable plant communities, following a long evolutionary history of frequent disturbances (fires and grazing). Fire is beneficial if low-intensity fires occur every 10–20 years and grazing is controlled. The problems of degradation and desertification only begin if the system is brought out of balance. Problems occur if (1) fire is used annually to stimulate new palatable growth for livestock, but a ground cover of vegetation is not maintained; (2) overgrazing also depletes the ground cover; and (3) highintensity fires occur because of the accumulation of dry biomass in mature Mediterranean ecosystems. The Mediterranean ecosystem can, however, be managed to allow all the required land uses, but in moderation.
92
Mediterranean Desertification
REFERENCES Arianoutsou M and Margaris NS (1981) Fire induced nutrient losses in a phryganic ecosystem. International Journal of Biometeorology 25, 341–347. Arianoutsou M and Margaris NS (1982) Phryganic (East Mediterranean) ecosystem and fire. Ecologia Mediterranea 8, 473–48