Metalanguage in Interaction
Pragmatics & Beyond New Series (P&BNS) Pragmatics & Beyond New Series is a continuation of Pragmatics & Beyond and its Companion Series. The New Series offers a selection of high quality work covering the full richness of Pragmatics as an interdisciplinary field, within language sciences.
Editor Andreas H. Jucker
University of Zurich, English Department Plattenstrasse 47, CH-8032 Zurich, Switzerland e-mail:
[email protected]
Associate Editors Jacob L. Mey
University of Southern Denmark
Herman Parret
Jef Verschueren
Susan C. Herring
Emanuel A. Schegloff
Belgian National Science Foundation, Universities of Louvain and Antwerp
Belgian National Science Foundation, University of Antwerp
Editorial Board Shoshana Blum-Kulka Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Jean Caron
Université de Poitiers
Indiana University
Masako K. Hiraga
St.Paul’s (Rikkyo) University
University of California at Los Angeles
Deborah Schiffrin
David Holdcroft
Georgetown University
Sachiko Ide
Kobe City University of Foreign Studies
Sandra A. Thompson
Thorstein Fretheim
Catherine KerbratOrecchioni
John C. Heritage
Claudia de Lemos
Teun A. van Dijk
Marina Sbisà
Richard J. Watts
Robyn Carston
University College London
Bruce Fraser
Boston University University of Trondheim University of California at Los Angeles
University of Leeds Japan Women’s University
University of Lyon 2 University of Campinas, Brazil University of Trieste
Paul Osamu Takahara
University of California at Santa Barbara Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona University of Berne
Volume 181 Metalanguage in Interaction. Hebrew discourse markers by Yael Maschler
Metalanguage in Interaction Hebrew discourse markers
Yael Maschler University of Haifa
John Benjamins Publishing Company Amsterdamâ•›/â•›Philadelphia
8
TM
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences – Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ansi z39.48-1984.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Maschler, Yael. € Metalanguage in interaction : Hebrew discourse markers / Yael Maschler. €€€€€€ p. cm. (Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, issn 0922-842X ; v. 181) Includes bibliographical references and index. 1.€ Hebrew language--Discourse analysis. 2.€ Discourse markers. 3.€ Hebrew language-Spoken Hebrew--Israel.€ I. Title. PJ4752.M37 ╅╅ 2009 492.4'0141--dc22 isbn 978 90 272 5426 9 (hb; alk. paper) isbn 978 90 272 8950 6 (eb)
2009004733
© 2009 – John Benjamins B.V. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publisher. John Benjamins Publishing Co. · P.O. Box 36224 · 1020 me Amsterdam · The Netherlands John Benjamins North America · P.O. Box 27519 · Philadelphia pa 19118-0519 · usa
In memory of my deeply beloved sister Dorit Bahir Maschler Jerusalem 8.5.1972 – Singapore 30.8.2000
Table of contents Transcription conventions Preface Acknowledgments
xi xiii xv
chapter 1.╇ Introduction Metalanguage in interaction: Discourse markers as a system Metalanguagingâ•… 1 1. Language alternation at discourse markersâ•… 2 2. 2.1 Relation to previous approaches to discourse markersâ•… 7 3. The dataâ•… 9 Distributional patterning: Negotiating frame shifts via discourse 4. markersâ•… 10 Defining discourse markersâ•… 16 5. 5.1 Previous approaches to prosody in defining discourse markersâ•… 20 6. Functional patterning of discourse markersâ•… 21 6.1 Previous approaches to realms of operation of discourse markersâ•… 26 7. Structural patterning of discourse markersâ•… 27 Grammaticization of discourse markersâ•… 33 8. 8.1 Traugott’s theory of grammaticization and semantic changeâ•… 37 9. Interacting as an Israeliâ•… 39
1
chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm The discourse marker nu: Israeli Hebrew impatience in interaction 41 Introduction╅ 41 1. Data╅ 45 2. Hastening co-participant to get on with some non-verbal action╅ 46 3. Nu urging further development within a topic╅ 52 4. 4.1 Narrational discourse╅ 52 4.1.1 Urging a move on to the next episode of a narrative╅ 52 4.2 Urging further development within a non-narrational topic╅ 55 4.3 Nu as a continuer╅ 59
Metalanguage in Interaction
4.4
5. 6. 7.
8.
Summary of the ‘urging further development of topic’ functionâ•… 64 Granting permission to perform an actionâ•… 64 Summary of sequential functions of nuâ•… 68 Keying functions of nu: joking/provokingâ•… 69 7.1 From joking to provokingâ•… 69 7.2 Nu in combination with other discourse markersâ•… 71 7.2.1 Nu in combination with 'az ma? (‘so what?’)â•… 72 Grammaticization of nuâ•… 74
chapter 3.╇ The textual realm The discourse marker bekitsur: Retroactively constructing digressions 79 Introduction╅ 79 1. Data╅ 84 2. Summarizing bekitsur╅ 85 3. 3.1 Summary following a list╅ 85 3.2 Summary of episode╅ 87 3.3 Drawing conclusions from episode╅ 91 4. Resumptive bekitsur: Returning to the main topic╅ 95 4.1 Collaboration in returning to the main topic╅ 96 4.2 Returning from interaction-based digressions╅ 103 4.3 Returning from content-based digressions╅ 104 4.3.1 Following listener-initiated digressions╅ 104 4.3.2 Following storyteller-initiated digressions╅ 106 4.3.2.1 Following a story aside╅ 106 4.3.2.2 Following orientation╅ 108 4.3.2.3 Following evaluation╅ 110 4.3.2.4 Organizing the hierarchy of episodes in a story╅ 112 4.4 Returning from insertion sequences╅ 114 5. Foregrounding bekitsur: Introducing a new narrative╅ 116 Grammaticization of bekitsur╅ 119 6. Interacting as an Israeli via bekitsur╅ 124 7. chapter 4.╇ The cognitive realm The discourse marker ke'ilu: Realizing the need to rephrase Introduction╅ 127 1. Data and methodology╅ 132 2. A quantitative perspective on the different functions of ke'ilu╅ 133 3. 4. Functional distribution of ke'ilu: A qualitative perspective╅ 134 4.1 Ke'ilu as a conjunction in the literal sense╅ 134
127
Table of contents
Ke'ilu as hedgeâ•… 137 4.2.1 Post-positioned ke'ilu as hedgeâ•… 137 4.2.2 Pre-positioned ke'ilu as hedgeâ•… 138 4.2.3 Interpersonal constraints on hedging ke'iluâ•… 140 4.3 Ke'ilu as focus markerâ•… 143 4.3.1 Pre-positioned ke'ilu as focus markerâ•… 145 4.3.2 Post-positioned ke'ilu as focus markerâ•… 147 4.3.3 Post-positioned focus-marking ke'ilu in aposiopesisâ•… 148 4.3.4 Interpersonal constraints on focus-marking ke'iluâ•… 150 4.4 Ke'ilu as discourse marker of self-rephrasalâ•… 152 4.4.1 Ke'ilu in self-rephrasals of clarification sequencesâ•… 154 4.4.2 Self-rephrasal ke'ilu tokens as fillersâ•… 157 4.5 Ke'ilu in quotationsâ•… 158 4.5.1 Ke'ilu in double-voiced ironic quotationsâ•… 160 The functional itinerary of ke'iluâ•… 162 Grammaticization of ke'ilu in cross-linguistic perspectiveâ•… 165 Interacting as an Israeli via ke'iluâ•… 166 4.2
5. 6. 7.
chapter 5.╇ Between realms The discourse marker tov: Accepting while shifting 171 Introduction╅ 171 1. Data╅ 176 2. Interpersonal tov╅ 176 3. 3.1 Acceptance of some state of things╅ 177 3.2 Third turn receipt╅ 180 3.3 Concession╅ 181 3.4 Ironic agreement: Disagreement╅ 185 4. Textual tov: Marking expected transition╅ 188 4.1 Transitional tov into the beginning of a narrative╅ 188 4.2 Transitional tov between the episodes of narrative discourse╅ 189 4.3 Transitional tov returning to an interrupted action╅ 190 4.4 Transitional tov ending a topic/action╅ 191 5. Ambiguous cases: Between interpersonal and textual tov╅ 193 5.1 Third turn receipt + ending an action╅ 193 5.2 Third turn receipt + transition into following episode/action╅ 195 5.3 Acceptance of some state of things + transition into following episode/action╅ 196 5.4 Concession + transition into following episode/action╅ 198 5.5 Concession and return to main topic╅ 200 6. Grammaticization of tov╅ 201
Metalanguage in Interaction
chapter 6.╇ Concluding remarks Grammaticization from interaction The system of discourse markers permeating interaction╅ 207 1. 1.1 Function╅ 207 1.2 Metalaguaging at frame shifts╅ 209 1.3 Structure╅ 210 2. Grammaticization of discourse markers╅ 214 2.1 Grammaticization of nu, bekitsur, ke'ilu, and tov╅ 214 2.2 Common threads and differences among the grammaticization patterns studied╅ 220 2.3 Projectability and grammaticization of constructions╅ 225 3. Interacting as an Israeli╅ 229
207
Bibliography
233
Author index
251
Subject index
253
Transcription conventions Each line denotes an intonation unit (Chafe 1994). For Hebrew texts, each line is followed by an English gloss. Where this gloss is not close enough to an English utterance, it is followed by a third line supplying a usually literal (but sometimes functional) translation. Transcription basically follows Chafe 1994, with a few additions: ... – half second pause (each extra dot = another 1/2 second) .. – perceptible pause of less than half a second (3.22) – measured pause of 3.22 seconds ´ – primary stress ` – secondary stress ´´ – particularly marked primary stress , – comma at end of line – continuing intonation (‘more to come’) . – period at end of line – sentence final falling intonation ? – question mark at end of line – sentence final rising intonation, ‘appeal intonation’ (Du Bois et al.€1992). ! – exclamation mark at end of line – sentence final exclamatory intonation ø – lack of punctuation at end of line – a fragmentary intonation unit, one which never reached completion. -- two hyphens – elongation of preceding vowel sound square bracket to the left of two consecutive lines indicates overlapping speech, two speakers talking at once alignment such that the right of the top line is placed over the left of the bottom line indicates latching, no interturn pause /??????/ – transcription impossible /words within slashes/ indicate uncertain transcription p – piano (spoken softly) pp – pianissimo (spoken very softly) mp – mezzo-piano (spoken fairly softly) f – forte (spoken loudly) ff – fortissimo (spoken very loudly) mf – mezzo-forte (spoken fairly loudly)
Metalanguage in Interaction
acc. – accelerando (speeding up) ritard. – ritardando (slowing down) cresc. – crescendo (progressively louder in volume) decresc. – decrescendo (progressively softer in volume) {in curly brackets} – t ranscriber’s comments concerning paralinguistics and prosody which do not have an agreed upon symbol in this transcription system. [xxxxx] – m aterial within square brackets in the gloss indicates exuberances of translation (what is not there in the original (Ortega y Gasset 1959, Becker 1982)). ' – uninverted quotation mark in the middle of a transliterated word indicates the glottal stop phoneme. ’ – inverted quotation mark in the middle of a transliterated word indicates an elided form (e.g., ts’xa instead of tsrixa (‘needs’, fem. sg.)). Utterances under consideration are given in boldface.
Preface I remember making a point to myself as an eight-year-old coming to live in the U.S. for a year: whenever you need some time to think in the midst of conversation, don’t say 'e--m, as they do in Israel; rather, say u--h or uhm. This will make you sound more like the other kids in class. Many years later, as an undergraduate student of classical Indo-European philology, certain words, such as Greek gar, men, de; Latin enim, autem, nam; Sanskrit tadaa, tathaa; or Old English þaa, hwaet caught my attention in the various languages I was studying. They often appeared at key locations in the text, such as at beginnings of stories or paragraphs. Each such word had several translations, usually into high-register Hebrew words. And perhaps most interestingly, my professors were a bit lost whenever I inquired about the relationships among the different translations of a single such word and about its ‘exact meaning’. This is mirrored by what Longacre has written about what he termed ‘mystery particles’: the “sentential particles continue to defy analysis even at a relatively advanced stage of the research” (1976:€468). Later, as a graduate student working on a dissertation on Hebrew-English bilingual discourse, this type of word and the ‘hesitation utterances’ from my childhood turned out to have a very interesting property in common. In the HebrewEnglish bilingual corpus I was studying, about 2 out of every 3 such utterances involved the bilingual discourse strategy of language alternation (what has been termed ‘code-switching’, a language metaphor I would like to avoid here) (Wittgenstein 1958, Reddy 1979, Maschler 1988, 1991). Just as my Hebrew-English bilingual informants often alternated from English to Hebrew when about to verbalize such words as look, yeah, but, on the other hand, anyway, or first of all, so they often switched to Hebrew when they were about to hesitate with an uh or an uhm. It turned out that this pattern of language alternation showed up again and again in other language contact situations (e.g., Brody 1987, Salmons 1990, Matras 1998, and the collection of articles in Maschler 2000a). The more linguistics I studied, the more phenomena seemed to be encapsulated by these mystery particles. I decided to go back to my first language, Hebrew, and investigate in depth these words, which by now had a name – ‘discourse markers’ (Schiffrin 1987).
Metalanguage in Interaction
Research in the field of discourse markers has flourished in the past two decades. The goal of the present study is to investigate in depth these elements in Hebrew discourse, both as individual utterances and as a system. I focus on how such utterances may come about, on their functions in conversation, on what processes of grammaticization (Hopper 1987, 1988) they may undergo, and on what we can learn from them about Israeli culture and society. Katriel has written several rich ethnographies of communication in Israeli culture (e.g., 1986, 1991, 1999, 2004). Her research focuses on key words in the contemporary Hebrew lexicon as a window onto Israeli culture. Through a close exploration of the life of certain content-words in Israeli culture (e.g., dugri, lefargen, gibush, kiturim), she illuminates the essence of being Israeli. In this book, I am interested in exploring the essence of interacting as an Israeli. Rather than focus on content-words, then, I focus on function-words – the grammatical category of discourse markers – which are employed for frame shifting in Hebrew talk-in-interaction, as will be shown. I study the system of discourse markers punctuating spoken discourse because I view these markers as the backbone of interaction. The study thus provides a bridge between the two disciplines of linguistics and communication. The opening chapter of this book explores Hebrew discourse markers as a system. Through this exploration, my own approach to discourse markers is unraveled and compared to some previous approaches. In the chapters that follow, I focus on several particular markers, illuminating through them certain quintessential aspects of Israeli society, identity, and culture. The final chapter ties together the patterns gleaned from the studies of the individual markers and delineates my approach to the grammaticization of discourse markers. I do not, of course, claim this to be a comprehensive study of all the discourse markers of Hebrew – a task far too ambitious for the current project. Rather, it is intended as an exploration into a variety of such markers, in the quest for unraveling the essence of interacting as an Israeli. This study is informed by a variety of approaches to the study of discourse: studies of intonation and spoken discourse (e.g., Chafe 1987, 1994, Du Bois et al.€1992), work in the discourse functional tradition (e.g., Hopper 1979, Chafe 1980, Becker 1984, Thompson 1984, Du Bois 1985), the methods and findings of conversation analysis (CA) (e.g., Sacks, Schegloff, and Jefferson 1974, Jefferson 1993, Sacks 1992, Schegloff 1993, 1996a,b), and studies in linguistic anthropology (e.g., Becker 1979, Goffman 1981, Gumperz 1982, Katriel 1986, 1991, 1999, 2004, Tannen 1984, 1989). It contributes to a cross-language perspective on the grammaticization of discourse markers (cf. Auer 1996, Traugott and Dasher 2002, Fleischman and Yaguello 2004) and asks “how linguistic structures [discourse markers] and patterns of use are shaped by, and themselves shape, interaction” (Selting and CouperKuhlen 2001:€1). This book, then, is about Hebrew interactional linguistics.
Acknowledgments Metalanguage in Interaction: Hebrew discourse markers was inspired by the work of many linguists to whom I feel deeply indebted. It was my great privilege to study under the mentorship of Alton L. Becker. Although this took place over two decades ago, his humanistic linguistics, inseparable from his character and personality, sparkles brightly in my mind. Wallace Chafe taught me how to approach spoken discourse and think about cognitive constraints. From Paul Hopper I learned about grammaticization and emergent grammar, and also how to read Wittgenstein. I have also learned much from John Du Bois, Emanuel Schegloff, Deborah Schiffrin, Deborah Tannen, Sandra Thompson, and Elizabeth Traugott, all of whom I had the good fortune to study with at one or another of the Linguistic Society of America summer institutes in 1985, 1987, and 2001. I am grateful to the people who have read various parts and versions of this book and provided many useful comments. They include Mira Ariel, Peter Auer, Elizabeth Couper-Kuhlen, Cecilia Ford, Susanne Günthner, Paul Hopper, Tamar Katriel, Deborah Schiffrin, Sandra Thompson, Elizabeth Traugott, and several anonymous reviewers. Of course, I remain solely responsible for the use I have made of all their comments. I also owe a debt to Suzanne Fleischman, who sadly passed away in 2000. It was Suzanne who, back in the summer of 1999, on the terrace of the Israel Museum in Jerusalem, encouraged me to begin my first study of a discourse marker in monolingual Hebrew conversation. My colleagues and students at the University of Haifa have provided me with an important context for research. I am especially grateful to Gonen Dori-Hacohen, Roi Estlein, Tamar Katriel, Irit Meir, Carmit Miller, Bracha Nir, Chaim Noy, Hilla Polak-Yitzhaki, Rivki Ribak, Michele Rosenthal, and Tamar Zewi for the intellectually stimulating environment they create and for their friendship. Likewise, I am grateful for the friendship of Jenny Mandelbaum and Susanne Uhmann. Permission to update and expand two articles is gratefully acknowledged: Maschler, Yael. 2002. On the grammaticization of ke‘ilu (‘like’, lit. ‘as if ’) in Hebrew talk-in-interaction. Language in Society 31: 243–276. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Maschler, Yael. 2003. The discourse marker nu: Israeli Hebrew impatience in interaction. Text 23: 89–128. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. It has been a pleasure to work with the people at John Benjamins. Andreas Jucker has been a wise and most efficient series editor. Isja Conen and Martine van
Metalanguage in Interaction
Marsbergen from the production department have been professional, considerate, and patient with me. I am also extremely grateful to the Freiburg Institute for Advanced Studies (FRIAS) at Albert-Ludwigs-Universität, Freiburg, Germany, for an External Senior Fellowship I received at the School of Language and Literature. This fellowship provided me with an ideal setting in which to complete the very final touches on this book. In Israel, I have been especially lucky for close friendships, particularly Shari and David Satran, Lilach and Eran Ishai, Ilan Yaniv and Daniela Yaniv Richter, and Naomi De-Malach and David Blanc. I would also like to mention my gratitude to Tamar Kron and David Wieler. My parents have been a source of much support throughout the years. My mother Hanna Maschler also proved to be an excellent proof-reader. It is my great sorrow that my father Michael Maschler did not live long enough to see this book in print. His genuine interest in my work has always been a source of much happiness, and the example he set of a hard-working, devoted, and honest academic – an inspiration. I dedicate this book to the memory of my deeply beloved sister Dorit, whose sudden untimely death will always darkly color our lives in many more ways than we would have ever imagined. My own family deserves the greatest acknowledgment. My children, Shira, Maya, and Yotam, have not only provided a wealth of excerpts for analysis (some of which have found their way into the pages of this book); they continue to be my partners in unearthing Israeli ways of talking and being in the world, while constituting a source of great joy, pride, and meaning in life. Lastly, and most importantly, I owe an immense debt of gratitude to my husband and partner Paul Woodward Inbar for listening to me talk about this book endlessly, for his sharp linguistic insights, criticism and advice, for his sound editing, generosity, and care, and most importantly, for his love and friendship.
chapter 1
Introduction Metalanguage in interaction: Discourse markers as a system
1. Metalanguaging I begin by elaborating on what is unique to my own approach to discourse markers. There have been many studies of discourse markers over the past two decades, most notably, Schiffrin 1987 (for overviews, see Brinton 1996, Jucker and Ziv 1998, Schourup 1999, Maschler 2000a, Schiffrin 2001, Fischer 2006, Maschler 2008). While there exist a few article-length studies of Hebrew discourse markers (e.g., Ariel 1998, Even-Zohar 1982, Henkin 1999, Livnat and Yatziv 2003, 2006, Shloush 1998, Ziv 1998, 2001), my own are exceptional in being based on naturally occurring conversation (Maschler 1997a, 1998b, 2001, 2002 a,b, 2003, 2009). However, the most unique aspect of the present approach is that it focuses on the process of metalanguaging in relation to employment of discourse markers. With the term ‘metalanguaging’, I wish to evoke a term coined by A. L. Becker, ‘languaging’. Becker moved from a notion of ‘language’ to a notion of ‘languaging’ in order to shift from an idea of language as something accomplished to the idea of languaging as an ongoing process (1988:€25). A similar shift is found in Hopper’s ideas about emergent grammar (1987, 1988, see below), which he contrasts with a priori grammar. Languaging is possible at two levels of discourse. Generally when we use language, we look through it at a world we believe to exist beyond language. However, we can also use language in order to look through it at the process of using language itself (Maschler 1994b). I investigate here this latter process of metalanguaging – using language in order to communicate about the process of using language. Metalanguaging, I argue, is the semantic-pragmatic process which is at the heart of both the employment and grammaticization (Hopper 1987) of discourse markers. Discourse markers are viewed here as linguistic elements employed for metalanguaging – languaging about the interaction, as opposed to languaging about the extralingual world. In other words, rather than referring to the world perceived by speakers (through language) to exist beyond language, discourse markers refer to the text itself, to the interaction among its speakers, or to the cognitive processes taking place in their minds during verbalization.
Metalanguage in Interaction
Every act of languaging involves always both levels – the lingual and the metalingual1. On the one hand, the utterances we employ for metalanguaging almost always (apart from very few utterances such as uh or uhm) refer also to something in the extralingual world. On the other hand, languaging about the world involves continually signaling the frame (Goffman 1974) through which our utterance is intended; in other words, it involves metalanguaging. Languaging, then, always happens at these two levels, but some utterances are particularly high in their metalingual dimension, and it is those utterances which form the focus of this book. In this chapter, I first show that, from the emic perspective of participants in an interaction, discourse markers constitute a distinct linguistic category employed for metalanguaging. I then move on to give a detailed definition of discourse markers based on their semantic and structural properties. I show that discourse markers constitute a system exhibiting three types of patterning involving: (1) the moments at which discourse markers are employed in interaction, (2) the functions fulfilled by discourse markers, and (3) their structural properties. I introduce the topic of grammaticization of discourse markers, which will be explored for particular markers in the ensuing chapters and portrayed as a whole in the concluding chapter, and I close with a brief overview of the particular discourse markers studied in depth in the remainder of this study. 2. Language alternation at discourse markers My approach to discourse markers originates in a phenomenon I noticed many years ago in bilingual conversation – language alternation at utterances which all have something in common; namely, that they are high in the metalingual dimension and occur at conversational action (Ford and Thompson 1996) boundaries (Maschler 1988, 1994b). Examine, for instance, the following excerpt, typical of much bilingual conversation. Shira and Grace, two bilingual relatives in their early thirties who emigrated to Israel from the U.S. 17 and 6 years prior to this conversation, respectively, are discussing two children, a brother and sister (Gad and Nira) in their family. They are in the midst of a discussion concerning whether boys are treated differently than girls by their parents2:
1. I prefer the term ‘metalingual’ to ‘metalinguistic’, because we are concerned here with the level meta to language, not to linguistics. 2. The larger conversation from which excerpts 1 and 2 are taken was analyzed in detail in Maschler 1988.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
Excerpt 1: 1 Shira: ... they shòuld not be tréated so differently. 2 I’m sáying 3 Grace: áre they? 4 /really?/ 5 .. réally? 6 Shira: .... kén (‘yeah’), 7 ... mà shebarúr (‘what’s for sure’) is that, 8 ... the totsa'á (‘result’) is vèry different. 9 Grace: yés. 10 .. but 11 Shira: 'axshav (‘now’) grá--nted, 12 .... I accé--pt, 13 ... that.. whát’s his name is a lìttle different. {referring to the boy Gad} 14 .. 'aval (‘but’) 15 ... kén (‘yeah’), 16 Grace: Gad? 17 Shira: gám (‘also’), 18 he doesn’t get the sá--me yaxas (‘attentiveness toward the other’), 19 ... as Níra does, 20 .. he gets dífferent 21 .. and sometimes 22 Grace: yeah but that’s also cause she’s ó--lder, 23 .. and hè’s yóu--nger, 24 Shira: bé--seder (‘alright’), 25 Grace: I think there’s something about, 26 ... that you treat a bóy dìfferently 27 .. do yóu treat 28 .. do you think yóu treat Yo'av {Shira’s son} 29 Shira: 'ani betuxá (‘I’m sure’), 30 ... that if hé was a gì--rl, 31 ... I would treat him dífferently. 32 ... 'ani betuxá (‘I’m sure’), Apart from the nouns yaxas3 (‘attentiveness toward the other’, line 18) and totsa'á (‘result’, line 8), two relatively highly culture-bound concepts in Israeli culture, 3. Katriel writes that yaxas (‘attentiveness toward the other’) is among the relational terms which have greatly proliferated in recent years in Israeli society. “These terms denote interpersonal behavior that concretizes the notion of interpersonal support. The term yaxas refers to humanizing gestures of attentiveness and considerateness” (2004:€206–207).
Metalanguage in Interaction
perhaps even ‘key words’ (Katriel 1999), all the utterances accompanied by the strategy of language alternation here are high in the metalingual dimension. In these 32 mostly English intonation units (Chafe 1994), we find 9 such Hebrew utterances. Some of them function metalingually in the realm of the text, signaling relationships between prior and upcoming discourse: 'axshav (‘now’, line 11), 'aval (‘but’, line 14), gam (‘also’, line 17). Others function metalingually in the interpersonal realm, negotiating relations between speaker and hearer (ken (‘yeah’, lines 6, 15)) or between speaker and text (mà shebarúr (‘what’s for sure’, line 7), 'ani betuxá (‘I’m sure’, lines 29, 32)). One Hebrew utterance, the concessive béseder (‘alright’, line 24), functions metalingually both interpersonally – granting the interlocutor her point – as well as textually, indicating an upcoming utterance which will oppose prior discourse (here, that differences in the ways boys and girls are related to have more to do with their sex than with their relative order in the family). Yet another type of Hebrew metalingual utterance is illustrated in excerpt 2, in which Grace compares working women with working men: Excerpt 2: 1 Grace: ... do you think that they’re any léss ìsolated than mèn are. 2 .. now they have the sàme competítion at work. 3 ... they have the sàme láck of ti--me, 4 .. as a mán who wo--rks, 5 Shira: ze lo4 (‘it’s not’) have the sáme competition, 6 ... sòmetimes they have hárder situations at work, 7 Grace: okáy, 8 okáy, 9 Shira: ... but they ha--ve 10 'e-- (‘uh’).. agaí--n, 11 ... they há--ve a dífferent nétwork of suppórt. {-------------ritard.---------------------} Here we find another type of switched utterance, the Hebrew hesitation utterance 'e-- (‘uh’), at the return to a previous point, marked also by English again. Over and 4. Here we find another motivation for language alternation. The strategy is employed here in an iconic manner (Becker 1982, Maschler 1993), in order to highlight a contrast in the discourse by presenting the two contrasting segments, each one in a different language. Shira contrasts her opinion with Grace’s, by repeating Grace’s English utterance (‘have the same competition’) following its negation in Hebrew (ze lo – ‘it’s not’). The contrast between the two languages is employed here not to highlight the contrast between the lingual and the metalingual (as in the case of discourse markers), but rather in order to mirror the contrast between old and new information, and between Grace’s opinion vs. Shira’s (see Maschler 1997b for a detailed study of this iconic strategy).
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
over, we find Shira employing the Hebrew hesitation markers 'e-- and 'e--m (with the front, half-open vowel [ε]) at conversational action boundaries. Only once in a 40-minute conversation does she employ in this environment the mid-central vowel, or the schwa [∂]; namely, English uh. This use is particularly prominent because Shira, having learned Hebrew later in adolescence, generally speaks Hebrew with an accent very much influenced by English. As one of the most difficult things to adopt when acquiring another language is nativelike usage of fillers, we would expect to hear an American accent when employing fillers, not vice versa. Chafe has shown that spoken discourse, as it unfolds, manifests evidence of the cognitive processes taking place at the time in the mind of the speaker (1987, 1994). One notable phenomenon is that episode boundaries generally involve longer pauses and hesitations, because more time is necessary at those moments of discourse for the processing of greater amounts of new information. Shira’s hesitation markers at conversational action boundaries can be viewed as metalingual at the cognitive realm of talk, referring to (in the sense of attesting) the cognitive processes taking place in her mind during verbalization. Just as Shira consistently employs the strategy of language alternation at textual and interpersonal metalingual utterances, so she employs it at cognitive metalingual utterances. Thus, Shira’s employment of Hebrew fillers can be explained once we view these hesitation markers as operating on a level meta to discourse, as in the case of the textual and interpersonal metalingual utterances. The two excerpts above illustrate three types of metalingual utterance – textual, interpersonal, and cognitive. We have seen that this classification is not always clear-cut, as some utterances operate in more than one realm simultaneously. What is common to all of these metalingual utterances, however, is that each one functions to negotiate a frame shift (Goffman 1981), or a conversational action (Ford and Thompson 1996) boundary in the interaction. The shift can be a fairly minute one, such as the shift from a first pair part to a second in an adjacency pair (Sacks 1992, vol. 2: 521–570); for example, the shift from Grace’s assertion in excerpt 1, lines 22–23 to Shira’s response to it in line 24, negotiated via the discourse marker béseder (‘alright’, line 24). It could be a somewhat more pronounced frame shift, as in a return to a previous discourse topic, such as ‘women’s different network of support’ in excerpt 2 (lines 10–11) negotiated via 'e-- (‘uh’) and English again. Alternatively, it could be a very major frame shift, such as the beginning of a completely new narrative or discourse topic. We shall return to this point in Section 4. We have seen that what is common to all these switched utterances is that they are metalingual and occur at conversational action boundaries, or at frame shifts. Bilingual discourse offers the unique possibility of iconically separating actions of languaging from those of metalanguaging by performing each of these two types of activity in a different language. The bilingual employs one of the two available
Metalanguage in Interaction
languages in order to comment on, or manage, interactions taking place mostly in the other. The result is a discourse taking place mostly in one language, whose metalingual frame of discourse markers takes place generally in the other5. In my data, the phenomenon of language alternation at discourse markers occurred for 66% of the discourse markers throughout the speech of the more balanced bilingual, Shira6. Furthermore, 85% of all her discourse markers occurred in a cluster of discourse markers including at least one Hebrew marker (Maschler 1994a,b). The phenomenon of language alternation at discourse markers has since been documented in many situations of bilingualism (e.g., Brody 1987, McConvell 1988, Salmons 1990, Stroud 1992, de Rooij 1996, Auer 1995, Li Wei and Milroy 1995, Ösch-Serra 1998, Alfonzetti 1998, Matras 1997, Moyer 1998, Maschler 1988, 1998a, 2000a,b,c, Hlavac 2006, and Kyratzis 2007, to mention just a few). It is the phenomenon responsible for the eventual borrowing of words such as English okay or Yiddish nu into many of the world’s languages, to the point that such words have become part of the language now used also by monolingual speakers7. The study of bilingual discourse strategies thus leads us to a characterization of discourse markers which is applicable also to the study of discourse markers in monolingual discourse: they are metalingual utterances occurring at conversational action boundaries, or frame shifts. We have seen that bilingual discourse provides evidence for considering fillers and hesitation markers which occur at conversational action boundaries to be discourse markers. Furthermore, the strategy of language alternation at discourse markers suggests that discourse markers are perceived as a distinct and unified category – the category of utterances employed to metalanguage conversational action boundaries – because bilinguals consistently switch languages in verbalizing discourse markers. Bilingual linguistic behavior thus constitutes evidence that the category ‘Discourse Marker’ is not merely a linguists’ construct, but rather a substantial and meaningful category for speakers. Unlike some other linguistic categories, it constitutes a linguistic category operating only at the discourse level, with no existence at lower levels of linguistic analysis.
5. Recent studies show that this strategy is in use by bilingual children already at preschool age (Kyratzis 2007). 6. Furthermore, returning to these same two speakers twelve years later, I found further grammaticization of this pattern in their emergent bilingual grammar, such that cognitive and textual discourse markers occurred in Hebrew significantly more frequently than in the earlier corpus and interpersonal markers were further grammaticized in a qualitative sense, exhibiting more fixed, formulaic expressions compared to the earlier corpus (see Maschler 2000c). 7.
For the different stages of this process of language contact, see Goss and Salmons, 2000.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
2.1
Relation to previous approaches to discourse markers
In a recent comparison of some major approaches to discourse markers, Fischer (2006) posits several dimensions along which to compare the multitude of approaches to these utterances. One such dimension is that of integratedness – the degree to which a discourse marker is viewed as part of the utterances it connects, as opposed to viewing it as an independent element. By showing that discourse markers constitute the metalingual frame of the discourse, the present approach views discourse markers as maximally detached from the discourse they frame. The bilingual discourse strategy of iconically separating out this frame through the strategy of language alternation underscores the unintegratedness of these elements of talk. Another dimension of comparison posited by Fischer is the question of what type of class discourse markers constitute: semantic, syntactic, functional, or no class at all (2006:€2). By focusing on the function of discourse markers to negotiate frame shifts in interaction, the present approach views discourse markers primarily as a functional class. However, we will see that through their repetitive use in this function, and by nature of the process of grammaticization, discourse markers also form a syntactic category, one operating at the discourse level. Many studies approach discourse markers based on relevance theory (Sperber and Wilson 1986). According to these approaches, discourse markers impose constraints on the way an utterance is relevant in its context (e.g., Blakemore 1987, Watts 1988, Jucker 1993, Andersen 1998). The present approach begins not with a theory, but rather with a corpus. I ask what the particular discourse markers are doing in the interactions in which they appear. As Aijmer writes in relation to relevance theory: “a different approach may be better suited to explain what [discourse markers] are doing in authentic texts and why the speaker has chosen one particle and not another. Moreover, the focus on a single explanation [i.e., the issue of relevance] means that other reasons for using them […] may be neglected” (2002:€11). Many previous approaches to discourse markers relate to their textual function of relating utterances to other discourse units. For instance:
(1) according to Schiffrin, discourse markers are “sequentially dependent elements which bracket units of talk. […T]he beginning of one unit is the end of another” (1987:€31).
(2) according to Fraser, a discourse marker is “an expression which signals the relationship of the basic message to the foregoing discourse” (1996:€186).
(3) according to Hansen, discourse markers are “linguistic items of variable scope, and whose primary function is connective” (1997:€160).
Metalanguage in Interaction
(4) according to Redeker, discourse markers are “linguistic signals of textual coherence links” (1991:€1139).
Other approaches relate to the interactional functions of discourse markers, for instance:
(1) Schourup writes that discourse markers “constitute the range of conventionalized reponses in English” (1985:€3).
(2) according to Östman, discourse markers “implicitly anchor the act of communication to the speaker’s attitudes towards aspects of the on-going interaction” (1981:€5, 1982:€152).
(3) Stubbs (1983:€193) considers discourse marks as “essentially interactive”.
Many approaches relate the textual and interactive functions of discourse markers to each other in various theoretical frameworks (e.g., Östman 1982, Schiffrin 1987, Traugott 1995a, Brinton 1996, Aijmer 2002). However, very few approaches relate to the cognitive functions of discourse markers. Zwicky, for instance, considers the English hesitation marker uh a discourse marker (1985), but as Schourup writes, this item would regularly be excluded from the group of elements considered discourse markers by many scholars (1999:€235). Even-Zohar (1982:€191) combines the textual with the cognitive when he characterizes these elements (‘void pragmatic connectives’ in his terminology) as indicating “ ‘the speaker’s strong need to organise his discourse’ or ‘the speaker’s anxiety to draw maximum attention to all his shifts of mind’ ” (emphasis mine). This last phrase combines the focus on cognitive constraints with the idea of shifting; however, the focus is not on frame shifting in Goffman’s sense, as it is here. The present approach, as we have seen, differs from most previous approaches by extending the categorization of discourse markers from elements whose function is in the textual and/or interpersonal realms, also to those functioning in the cognitive realm of discourse8. I have presented evidence from bilingual discourse to justify this categorization. Furthermore, we shall see that the present corpusbased approach suggests a framework in which these three realms of interaction – textual, interpersonal, and cognitive – constitute a coherent whole enabling particular affinities across realms.
8. Two more recent approaches relating discourse markers to the cognitive realm of discourse are Bazzanella 2006 and Yang 2006.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
3. The data We now move to the study of discourse markers in Hebrew monolingual conversation. The present study is based on the Haifa Corpus of Spoken Israeli Hebrew (Maschler 2004), comprised of casual Hebrew conversations among college-educated Israelis in their twenties with their friends and relatives, which I have been collecting over the past decade or so. The data comprise 50 conversations, ranging in length from approximately 1 to 9 minutes and taking place between 2 to 5 participants. Altogether, the corpus comprises approximately 150 minutes of talk among 124 different speakers, collected over the years 1994–2002, with the exception of one conversation recorded by myself in 1986. The conversations were recorded by my discourse analysis students over the years, in interactions in which they participated. They were submitted as part of course projects, along with information concerning the prior-text (Becker 1979) of the interaction, the nature of interpersonal relations among participants, and, occasionally, relevant non-verbal behavior which participants were able to recall. I include here only those interactions for which consent was obtained from participants9. Many of the conversations in the corpus constitute narratives. This is not to say that discourse markers are employed only in narrative discourse – Maschler 1997a, 1998b show the contrary (and see Section 4 below). This has more to do with the texts students happened to select for their projects. The instructions given were to record several long stretches of naturally-occurring casual talk (at least two audio-cassettes’ worth) and choose a segment one feels enthusiastic about, one they see themselves spending an entire semester with, a text having a clear beginning, middle, and end. Interestingly, the majority of conversations selected turned out to be narratives. The data have been carefully transcribed and segmented into intonation units (Chafe 1994), marking intonation contours, pauses, primary and secondary stress, as well as other paralinguistic features such as tempo and volume which seemed prominent in the particular excerpts (See the Transcription Conventions Section which opens this study)10. This transcription method reflects the importance of the intonation unit as the basic unit of spoken interaction (Chafe 1987, 1994), a unit serving as the structural basis for my definition of discourse markers (see below). 9. These students attended my courses at three different institutions in Israel: at the University of Haifa, at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and at Oranim College near Haifa. They studied at departments of Communication, Hebrew Language, and English in these three institutions. I wish to express my gratitude to the students for their generosity with the data. 10. I wish to thank my research assistants Michal Peled-Kaveh, Tamar Rubin, Shlomo Kim, Tamar Mencher, Tal Dori, Hilla Polak-Yitzhaki, Hadar Netz, Roi Estlein, and Carmit Miller for help with transcription and coding.
Metalanguage in Interaction
4. Distributional patterning: Negotiating frame shifts via discourse markers There is a great deal of systematicity in the ways discourse markers are employed besides the systematicity of language alternation at discourse markers observed in bilingual conversation. First, we return to the issue of the employment of discourse markers as a function of the type of frame shift involved. In his study of footing, Goffman writes: A change in footing implies a change in the alignment we take up to ourselves and the others present as expressed in the way we manage the production or reception of an utterance. A change in our footing is another way of talking about a change in our frame for events. [...] participants over the course of their speaking constantly change their footing, these changes being a persistent feature of natural talk (1981:€128, emphasis mine).
Goffman ends his study with the belief that “linguistics provides us with the cues and markers through which such footings become manifest, helping us to find our way to a structural basis for analyzing them” (ibid.: 157). Because of their metalingual nature, discourse markers play a significant role in framing the discourse. They are employed in order to create and reflect frame shifts, thus functioning as contextualization cues (Gumperz 1982) signaling those shifts (Maschler 1997a, 1998b). Discourse markers constitute one of the most prominent linguistic strategies for negotiating footing, or frame shifts, in interaction. In a study of 11 out of the 50 Hebrew conversations on which the present study is based11, altogether 336 discourse markers were employed. Of the 595 frame shifts found throughout that database, 247 (42% of all frame shifts) were accompanied by at least one discourse marker (Maschler 1997a, 1998b). Furthermore, the corpus shows systematicity in the ways discourse markers are employed at frame shifts. In general, the ‘higher’ the boundary between conversational actions, the more the linguistic material necessary for its construction. ‘Larger packages’ (Sacks 1992), such as the beginning of a new episode in a narrative, open with more discourse markers – and particularly more clusters of discourse markers – than ‘smaller packages’, such as the beginning of a ‘second’ in an adjacency pair. Table 1 illustrates the distribution of discourse markers across the 595 frame shifts found throughout the 11 conversations, separated into segments of narrative and non-narrative discourse stretches12:
11. These 11 conversations comprise 30 minutes of naturally-occurring monolingual Hebrew casual conversation among 31 different participants (friends and family relatives), collected throughout the years 1994–1997. 12. For more detail, see Maschler 1997a, 1998b.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
Table 1.╇ Distribution of discourse markers and discourse marker clusters at boundaries (Maschler 1997a, 1998b) Type of boundary
Number of boundaries
Number of boundaries + marker
Number of boundaries + cluster
I supertopic/story
25
11 (44%)
3 (12%)
II episode (narrative) III sub-episode (narrative)
61 99
30 (49%) 38 (38%)
9 (15%) 8 (8%)
II subtopic (non-narrative) III turn in adjacency pair (non-narrative)
99 311
46 (46%) 122 (39%)
10 (10%) 20 (6%)
Total
595
247 (42%)
50 (8%)
We see that higher-level boundaries between conversational actions (i.e., level-II boundaries), such as those between episodes in narrative or between sub-topics in non-narrational discourse, involve the use of a discourse marker in 49% and 46% of such boundaries, respectively, whereas lower-lever boundaries (i.e., level-III boundaries), such as between sub-episodes in narrative or between the two parts of an adjacency pair in non-narrative discourse, involve the use of a discourse marker in only 38% and 39% of such boundaries, respectively. The pattern is particularly apparent when examining boundaries involving employment of clusters of discourse markers (right-most column of Table 1). Clusters are almost twice as common at level-II boundaries (15%, 10%) as they are at level-III boundaries (8% and 6%). Level-I boundaries (beginnings of new stories or major discourse topics) exhibit an employment rate of discourse markers somewhere in between level-II and level-III boundaries (44% of all level-I boundaries involve discourse markers, 12% involve clusters). This has to do with the fact that at such moments in interaction, we often find longer metalingual utterances, such as rotse lishmoa keta? (‘wanna hear something weird/funny [lit. ‘a segment’]?’) or 'ani 'asaper lexa mashehu 'al… (‘let me tell you something about…’) – longer utterances (usually sentences) not sufficiently crystallized in order to be considered discourse markers. An illustration of this point can be seen in excerpt 3, a conversation among 5 family members – a couple and their 3 children Shmulik, Meirav, and Noga. Shmulik and Meirav are in their early twenties. Noga is their little sister. Shmulik is in the midst of an orientation (Labov 1972) to a story about a little boy, but he is constantly being interrupted by his family members:
Metalanguage in Interaction
Excerpt 3 (‘Wounds’): 54 Shmulik: .. 'az hayeled haze--, so the boy this so this boy, 55
... 'eh kaze, uh [is] like,
56
min profesor, sort of [a] professor,
57
kmo she'amarti, as I said,
58
hu sho'el hakol vehu v he asks everything and he an
59
ve'im 'at lo 'ona lo beduyak and if you (fem.) don’t answer him in accur
60
be.. bimduyak, in.. in accuracy accurately,
61
vehu yode'a be'erex, and he knows just about and he knows only the general idea of things,
62
.. 'az 'eh 'i 'efshar lehapil 'oto. so uh [it’s] impossible to fool him.
63
z’tomeret hu-in other words he-- [is]
64 Meirav:
.. ben kama? son of how much how old?
65 Shmulik:→ .. 'eh 'ani yode'a? uh [do] I know uh what do I know? 66
'e.. 'ole le.. kita 'aleph sh u.. going up to grade a uh.. going up to first grade
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
67
be'od shnatayim shalosh. in another two years three in another two-three years. 'eifo hatelefon? where[’s] the phone?
68 Father: 69 Shmulik:→ ... bekitsu--r, anyway, 70 Meirav: 71 Mother:
.. kan kan. {concerning the phone} here here. sivanush shalxa 'otam. Sivanush sent them.
72 Father:
'ah tov. {concerning the phone} oh good.
73 Noga:
shshshshshsh.
74
.. n--u!
75
tnu lo lesape--r! let him tell!
76 Shmulik: →'az 'eh so uh 77
→ ki haya fadixot, because there were screw ups,
78
hi 'eh hayta xola sham, she uh was sick there,
79
ve.. revital ve'ani halaxnu levaker 'otam. and.. Revital and I went to visit them.
80
→ve'az 'e--h, and then u--h,
81
hu kaze mis he like loo
82
ba kaze, comes like,
Throughout these lines, Shmulik attempts a return to the narrative (a task he finally accomplishes at line 81) while also dealing with the interruptions. The move from a first to a second pair part of an interruption (such as from a clarification question to an answer, or from a side-comment to a response to it) is of a lower
Metalanguage in Interaction
order than the move from responding to an interruption back to the narrative. Let us compare Shmulik’s employment of discourse markers throughout his attempts to return to narration (level-II boundaries) with those he employs in order to deal with participants’ side comments (level-III boundaries). One of Shmulik’s sisters, Meirav, latches on at line 64, asking how old the boy is. After answering her question (lines 65–67), Shmulik attempts a return to the narrative with the discourse marker bekitsur (‘anyway’, line 69). His father is meanwhile engaged in asking where the phone is (line 68). Meirav answers the father (line 70), while the mother makes a side comment related to Shmulik’s orientation, giving the reason why Shmulik and his friend Revital went to the place where they met the boy whom this story concerns (line 71): sivanush shalxa 'otam. (‘Sivanush sent them.’). While the father acknowledges finding the phone (72), the little sister, Noga, quiets everybody down (73) and hastens Shmulik to go on with the narrative (lines 74–75). Shmulik attempts another return, this time with a cluster of two discourse markers – 'az 'eh (‘so uh’, line 76). He then stops this move at mid-utterance (as indicated by the fragmentary intonation unit at 76) and switches to relate to the mother’s side comment (lines 77–79). His response begins with one discourse marker – ki (‘because’), explaining why Sivanush sent them – she was sick (line 78). Finally, at line 80, he returns to the story yet again, this time with a cluster of 3 discourse markers – ve'az 'e--h (‘and then u--h’). We see that at level-II boundaries of attempting to return to his narrative, Shmulik generally employs more discourse markers, and particularly more clusters: bekitsur (‘anyway’, 69), the cluster 'az 'eh (‘so uh’, 76), and the cluster ve'az 'e--h (‘and then u--h’, 80)13, whereas at the level-III boundary of relating to a side-comment, he employs only one discourse marker - ki (‘because’, line 77). However, this pattern is not adhered to in 100% of the cases. For instance, in responding to Meirav’s question (line 64) concerning the age of the boy (a level-III boundary), Shmulik actually employs a cluster of 3 discourse markers: 'eh 'ani yode'a? 'e (‘uh what do I know? uh’, lines 65–66). Furthermore, Meirav’s move at the level-II boundary of line 64 manifests no discourse markers at all. Perhaps in order to minimize the disruption, she shapes her question as a co-construction (Lerner 1991), building on Shmulik’s previous utterance. She grafts her question onto the subject of the previous utterance – hu (‘he’) – introduced by Shmulik in the previous intonation unit in the midst of a rephrasal of his own utterance, which he began with the discourse marker z’tomeret (‘in other words’, line 63). Table 1 shows a general tendency throughout the corpus – the higher the boundary in the hierarchy of frame-shifts, the greater the amount of metalingual 13. These 6 discourse markers employed by Shmulik to return to the narrative were counted as occurring at 3 separate level-II boundaries: lines 69, 76, and 80.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
material that is employed to construct that boundary. This does not mean, of course, that no level-III boundaries (for instance) will ever exhibit a discourse marker cluster. On the whole, however, this happens in only 6% of level-III boundaries in non-narrative discourse and in only 8% of level-III boundaries in narrative discourse. We see, then, that discourse markers constitute a system exhibiting patterning in terms of their quantitative distribution in conversation. This patterning can be compared with Couper-Kuhlen’s finding (1998) concerning the role of high onsets (the height of the first stressed syllable in a turn constructional unit) in indicating that a ‘big package’ is underway. This is a nonverbal strategy for managing the production of a multi-unit turn (1998:€ 19), whereas the current study shows a metalingual (and therefore verbal) strategy accomplishing a similar end. Studies in the field of historical discourse analysis (e.g., Enkvist and Wårvik 1987) also mention a patterning reminiscent of the one presented here. Studies of ancient Germanic written texts note that certain formulas, termed ‘introductory saga formulas’, ‘narrators’ formulas’, ‘transition formulas’, and ‘concluding formulas’, although not fixed and quite productive, function to shift scenes and mark new episodes in the written texts (e.g., Clover 1974, 1982, Lönnroth 1976). “These formulas are not obligatory and their presence is in large part determined by the length of time elapsed between scenes. The longer this is, the more likely and the more elaborate the formula is” (Clover 1982:€88, cited in Brinton 1996:€18). We see that in this approach as well, the size of the ‘package’ is related to the type and quantity of metalingual utterances employed at the boundary. The larger the ‘package’, the greater the amount of metalingual material necessary for the frame shift. Furthermore, as in the present approach, these metalingual utterances are seen to have not only a textual function, but often an interactive one as well14. They are viewed as “a set of narrative directions – formulas in which the narrator addresses the audience on the mechanics of composition” (Clover 1982:€89). Finally, these studies provide further evidence for the view taken here on the emergence of some discourse markers from longer metalingual utterances, as will be elaborated in the following chapters.
14. Not surprisingly, the cognitive function of such utterances in not discussed in relation to these written texts.
Metalanguage in Interaction
5. Defining discourse markers We are now in a position to define discourse markers more clearly. A variety of terms have been used to refer to discourse markers15 (e.g., pragmatic markers, discourse particles, connectives, pragmatic expressions, discourse operators, markers of pragmatic structure) and they have not always been clearly defined. Brinton mentions more than twenty such terms (1996:€29) and notes that the many definitions bear little resemblance to one another. The differences result from the pragmatic function of these markers that is viewed as primary. Some approaches stress their function in expressing relevance to prior discourse, others stress their structural function, or their function as response signals, as a means to achieve conversational continuity, or their interactive character (ibid.: 30–31). None of the previous approaches anchors the definition of discourse markers in the process of metalanguaging involved in their employment. Schiffrin (1980, 1987:€328) mentions that meta-talk expressions such as this is the point, or what I mean is can function as discourse markers. However, for her, this is a subcategory of the set she considers discourse markers. In the present approach, on the other hand, the claim is that all discourse markers are metalingual. This approach stems, as we have seen, from observations concerning the ways these markers function in bilingual conversation. However, there are some metalingual utterances that do not constitute discourse markers. The following excerpt, also from the conversation between Shira and Grace (excerpts 1,2) illustrates this: Excerpt 4: 1 Grace: ... I don't 2 .. but I meá--n, 3 .. if you say, 4 .. somebody is.. s..eárching for apprecià--tion, 5 ... it seems like they're 6 .. it soú--nds like, 7 .. they're searching to b--e, 8 .. pùt on a pédestal.. n.. to s.. to sóme extent 9 .. I mean /????/ 10 Shira: 'a.. lò 'ani lo mitkavénet leze, oh.. no I don’t mean this oh.. no that’s not what I mean,
15. For a comprehensive review, see Brinton 1996:€29–31.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
In intonation unit 10, we find the Hebrew ‘equivalent’ of the English change-ofstate token (Heritage 1984, Schiffrin 1987, Maschler 1994b) 'a (‘oh’) and the discourse marker lo (‘no’) followed by the metalingual utterance 'ani lo mitkavénet leze (‘that’s not what I mean’). This is a longer metalingual utterance not sufficiently grammaticized in order to be considered a discourse marker (cf. Section 4 above). It is, however, reminiscent of the Old Germanic metalingual utterances cited by Clover (1982) and Lönnroth (1976), a metalingual utterance which might some day develop into a discourse marker. We shall return to this point below. Having examined many discourse markers in both bilingual and monolingual conversation, I noticed that the great majority of them share not only the semantic property of metalinguality, but also certain structural properties. I thus arrived at an operational definition of discourse markers in this study. Definition of discourse markers In order to qualify as a discourse marker, the utterance in question must fulfill a semantic requirement: a. The utterance must have a metalingual interpretation in the context in which it occurs. In other words, rather than referring to the extralingual world, it must refer metalingually to the realm of the text (in which case we are concerned with a ‘textual discourse marker’), to the interaction among its participants (including relations between speaker and his/her utterance – ‘interpersonal discourse marker’), or to their cognitive processes (‘cognitive discourse marker’). In order to qualify as a prototypical discourse marker, the utterance must fulfill a structural requirement as well: b. The utterance must occur at intonation-unit initial position, either at a point of speaker change, or, in same-speaker talk, immediately following any intonation contour other than continuing intonation. It may occur after continuing intonation or at non-intonation-unit initial position only if it follows another marker in a cluster (Maschler 1998b: 31). We have already seen that all of the boldfaced utterances in excerpts 1 and 2 above are metalingual in one of the three realms – textual, interpersonal, or cognitive. This is the case also for the discourse markers discussed in excerpt 3: 'eh is cognitive, attesting the cognitive processes occurring at frame shifts, 'ani yode'a? (‘what do I know’) is interpersonal, referring to relations of uncertainty of the speaker towards his utterance, while bekitsur (‘anyway’), ve- (‘and’) 'az (‘so’) and ki (‘because’) are textual, constructing relations between parts of the text. Similarly, the 'a (‘oh’) of excerpt 4 functions cognitively, realizing new information, and the lo
Metalanguage in Interaction
(‘no’) following it functions in the interpersonal realm, disaligning the speaker with the interlocutor’s previous words. As for the structural requirement, all the discourse markers in the preceding excerpts occur intonation unit initially, unless they are part of a cluster. The discourse markers at excerpt 1, lines 6, 11, 24, and 29, and excerpt 3, lines 65, 76, and the 'a (‘oh’) of excerpt 4, line 10 occur at points of speaker change. Those at excerpt 1, lines 14, 15, and 32, excerpt 2, line 10, and excerpt 3, lines 69, 77, and 80 occur in same-speaker talk following non-continuing intonation contours. The remainder – those at excerpt 1, lines 6–7 and 14–17 occur in same-speaker talk in discourse marker clusters: ken, ma shebarur (‘yes, what’s for sure’) and 'aval[ø16] ken, gam (‘but[ø] yes, also’), as do those at excerpt 3, lines 65–66 ('eh 'ani yode'a? 'e ‘uh what do I know? uh’), lines 76 ('az 'eh ‘so uh’) and 80 (ve'az 'e--h ‘and then u--h’)17 and the lo (‘no’) of excerpt 4, line 10. Thus, all discourse markers discussed so far fulfill both the semantic and the structural requirements for discourse markerhood and constitute therefore prototypical discourse markers18. In Maschler 2002a, I investigated all the discourse markers employed throughout 16 of the 50 recorded conversations on which the present study is based19. Altogether, 613 discourse markers fulfilling the semantic requirement above were employed. Of those, 574 markers (94%) fulfill the structural requirement as well, i.e. constitute prototypical discourse markers. The remaining 39 discourse markers (6%) occur at intonation-unit initial position in same-speaker talk, but they follow continuing intonation and no discourse marker precedes them (i.e., they do not follow another marker in a cluster). These, then, are the non-prototypical discourse markers, to which we shall return in Section 7. As for the structural requirement concerning intonation-unit initial position, all but one instance of ke'ilu (Chapter 4, footnote 23) share this property in the present corpus. I will suggest a reason for this property of Hebrew discourse markers in the concluding chapter and relate also to the phenomenon of discourse
16. The lack of punctuation at the end of line 14 (highlighted by the ø) indicates a fragmentary intonation unit (Chafe 1994). 17. In other words, 'ani yode'a? (‘what do I know?’, excerpt 3, line 65), for instance, indeed does not occur at intonation-unit initial position, but it satisfies the structural requirement because it follows another marker – 'eh – in a cluster. 18. All other discourse markers appearing in excerpt 3 (but not discussed here) fulfill these two requirements as well. 19. The database for the 2002a study is comprised of the 11 conversations of the 1997a and 1998b studies (see footnote 11), as well as of five more conversations. Altogether, the 2002a corpus consists of 40 minutes of naturally-occurring monolingual Hebrew casual conversation among 43 different speakers, collected throughout the years 1994–1997.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
markers regularly occurring at intonation-unit final position in languages typologically different from Hebrew (Chapter 6, Section 1.3). The first study to examine in detail a discourse marker negotiating relations of speaker to text (‘stance discourse marker’) in spoken Hebrew discourse is Maschler and Estlein 2008. In that study, we followed Biber and Finegan’s definition of stance as “the overt expression of […] attitudes, feelings, judgments, or commitment concerning the message” (1988:€1) and investigated Hebrew be'emet (‘really, actually, indeed’, lit. ‘in truth’) in the corpus20. Our study shows that 8 out of 44 (18%) metalingual tokens of be'emet do not fulfill the structural requirement for prototypical discourse markerhood. The majority of these tokens still occur intonation-unit marginally; however, they are found at intonation-unit final position21. It seems that in the case of stance discourse markers, a percentage greater than 6% do not fulfill the structural requirement for prototypical discourse markerhood, but further study is needed here. With respect to the syntactic category of adverb, based on a study of adverbs in a variety of languages, Ramat and Rica have suggested a scalar, or even radial category “with prototypical instantiations and less typical or even marginal ones” (1994:€289). For example, in one of two approaches they present, prototypical adverbs are those identified as manner predicate adverbs (e.g., English quickly), whereas ‘setting’ adverbs of space and time, such as today, now, here are less prototypical, and focalizers such as only, also, even are even further away from the center. At the very margin of their classification are what they call ‘text adverbs’ like firstly, consequently, nevertheless, pertaining to the level above the sentence. These are the ‘textual discourse markers’ in the present approach. Based on the study of be'emet, we have suggested a prototypical syntactic category of discourse marker, which is constituted by tokens fulfilling both the semantic and the structural requirements in the definition above. Non-prototypical tokens fulfill only the semantic requirement: […] just as the category of adverb is a scalar, or even radial one […], so the category of discourse marker can be viewed in a similar fashion: prototypical be'emet discourse markers (those which are highly metalingual (interactional) and have a very minor referential dimension) fulfill both the semantic and the structural requirements in the definition of discourse markers, whereas less prototypical discourse markers (those operating metalingually (interactionally) as well as 20. By then the corpus was extended to 91 conversations constituting approximately 270 minutes of talk among 223 different speakers. 21. Another Hebrew discourse marker which sometimes appears intonation-unit finally is 'aval (‘but’), though no examples were found in the corpus (cf. Mulder and Thompson (in press) for English but). Interestingly, like some instances of be'emet, this discourse marker expresses adversativity.
Metalanguage in Interaction
referentially) fulfill the requirements only partially. Of this latter category, discourse markers having a higher interactional dimension […] occur intonationunit initially or finally, while those which are both interactional and referential occur intonation-unit internally (Maschler and Estlein 2008:€312).
I suggest, then, conceptualizing the category of discourse marker as a scalar category, with tokens fulfilling both the semantic and the structural requirements constituting the prototypical instantiations. In Section 7 and throughout the continuation of this study, we will see various factors resulting in non-prototypical discourse markers. We shall also see that in the process of grammaticization, it is the tendency of discourse markers to gradually ‘gravitate’22 towards the structural position reserved for discourse markers in the language. 5.1
Previous approaches to prosody in defining discourse markers
No other approach to discourse markers that I am aware of supplies an operational definition of discourse markers based, among other things, on the concept of the intonation unit and on prosody in general. As noted by Aijmer (2002:€262), prosody is a neglected area in the research on discourse markers. Few approaches relate to prosody at all, and when they do, it is not for the purpose of defining discourse markers, but rather for separating out different uses of a particular marker23. Tabor and Traugott, e.g., emphasize the intonation contour of the discourse marker itself (1998:€ 254). Ferrara 1997, Aijmer 2002, and Yang 2006, e.g., show that different functions of discourse markers are correlated with particular intonation contours and durational features across different markers. In the present approach, as we have seen, prosody constitutes one of the major components in the definition of prototypical discourse markers, and it is the intonation contour of the intonation unit preceding the discourse marker that is found to be relevant for the analysis. Another one of the dimensions along which Fischer compares the different approaches to discourse markers is that of the medium through which the interaction takes place. According to her, approaches that focus on the unintegrated nature of discourse markers in relation to the discourse they connect (see 2.1 above) study the medium of conversation, whereas those focusing on the integrated nature of the items often account also for written text (2006:€9). The current definition of prototypical discourse markers stems, of course, from the spoken nature of the data on which this study is based. However, Chafe has shown that the concept 22. Cf. Mulder and Thompson (in press) for this metaphor of ‘gravitation’, or “movement along a pathway of grammaticization” in their terminology. 23. In the following chapters, we shall see that the present approach also correlates different uses of a particular discourse marker with different prosodic features.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
of the intonation unit is relevant also to written discourse, where it becomes the ‘idea unit’ (1985). Written idea units are generally separated from each other by punctuation marks, which partially imitate the intonation contours of spoken discourse. Thus, although my approach takes an ‘unintegrated view’ of discourse markers in Fischer’s terms, the present definition of prototypical discourse markers could be adapted to written discourse without too much difficulty24. 6. Functional patterning of discourse markers One way of characterizing frame shifts can be achieved by viewing them through the prism of Becker’s approach to text as constrained by six different realms of context: the interpersonal, referential, structural, prior-textual, medial, and silential (1988). In Becker’s view, any act of languaging involves at least these six different contextual realms, because in using language, we are always performing acts from these six different realms simultaneously. In languaging, we are always simultaneously interacting with people (often with ourselves), referring to an extralingual world we believe to exist beyond language, shaping linguistic structures, remembering and evoking prior-text (Becker 1979), using a particular medium, and occupying space which, if not for our utterance, would have consisted of silence. We have already seen that not all frame shifts are alike. In focusing on changes in “the alignment we take up to ourselves and the others present” (Goffman 1981:€128), it appears that Goffman views frame shifting as a phenomenon shaped mostly by interpersonal constraints. However, a closer look reveals that besides a shift in interpersonal alignment, additional shifts in other contextual realms often occur at these moments of talk, particularly when we are concerned with a higherorder frame shift. At this type of frame shift, one also often switches to another referential world (a new discourse topic or sub-topic), thus making other priortextual material relevant. One often switches then to a new linguistic structure (e.g., different tense or aspect), and one switches into cognitive processes of a different nature in relation to those taking place at other moments of interaction (Chafe 1994), as we have seen manifested by the fillers and hesitation markers employed at conversational action boundaries. In his article on footing (1981), Goffman provides examples of shifts in prosody and non-verbal behavior often accompanying frame shifting as well. A moment of frame shift (or a conversational action boundary) can be defined on the basis of Becker’s approach to text as 24. Indeed, in a recent M.A. thesis, this approach has been applied to studying the discourse markers segmenting Hebrew Quasi-Synchronous Computer-Mediated Communication (‘Chat discourse’) (Krupik 2007).
Metalanguage in Interaction
constrained by the various contextual realms. A moment of frame shift is perceived here as a moment at which we find maximal shifts, relative to the surrounding discourse, in constraints from the various contextual realms shaping discourse (For elaboration and an example, see Maschler 1994b). I have suggested sorting out discourse markers according to the realm in which there are maximal shifts in contextual constraints when the particular marker in question is employed (Maschler 1994b, 1997a). Markers were found to function in three of the realms identified by Becker (1988) – the interpersonal, referential, and structural, as well as in the cognitive realm. Table 2 presents the 574 prototypical discourse markers (fulfilling both the semantic and the structural requirements) found throughout the 16-conversation corpus (Maschler 2002a). Markers constrained mostly by the interpersonal25 realm negotiate issues of closeness vs. distance among participants of an interaction (Bateson 1972[1956], Scollon 1982). They include perception verbs, verbs of saying, agreement and disagreement tokens, urging tokens, expressions of amazement, enthusiasm, lack of enthusiasm, discontent, and maintaining contact, among others. Markers constrained mostly by the referential realm are comprised of both deictics and conjunctions. The conjunctions mark relations between conversational actions in a way that mirrors semantic relations in the extralingual world marked by those conjunctions (e.g., consequence, coordination, contrast, cause, disjunction, condition, and concession). The deictics have a discourse function which mirrors their deictic function in the world narrated by the text (e.g. proximal vs. distal deixis). Markers constrained mostly by the structural realm include utterances signaling the ways conversational actions are related to one another in terms of order and hierarchy (e.g., organizing the order of actions, introducing or ending a conversational action, returning to a main action, summarizing an action, or closing a digression). The referential and structural markers together make up the textual markers, because they all deal with relationships between different parts of a text. Markers constrained mostly by the cognitive realm include markers attesting the cognitive processes taking place at conversational action boundaries (e.g., processing information, realizing new information, realizing the need to rephrase one’s previous utterance).
25. Recall that interpersonal markers negotiating relations between speaker and text were generally not investigated in these earlier studies.
Organizing order of actions Deictics 'axshav (now) (13) kodem kol (first of all) (3) 'axar kax €(then) (2) hadavar hasheni (second) (1) rega (one sec) (12) xake / xaki (wait) (3)
'at shoma'at? (you hear?) (1) tishma (listen) (1) 'ata yode'a / 'at yoda'at (you know) (7) 'ani yode'a? (what do I know?) (1) lo y'dat (I dunno) (2) 'an’lo yoda'at (I don’t know) (1)
'ani 'asbir lexa€(I’ll explain to you) (1) tsapri li (tell me) (1)
yaxol lihyot (could be) (1) ze yaxol lihyot €(this could be) (1) betax (sure) (1) mhm€(10) be'emet (really) (2) hm€(7) 'aha (aha) (1)
ma pit'om (no way) (1) lo naxon (wrong) (1) higzamt (you’ve gone too far) (1)
Perception verbs tir'e / ti'ri (look) (5) 'at ro'a! (see!) (1) ta'amini li (believe me) (2) lo ta'amini (you won’t believe [this]) (1) 'ata mevin? / 'at mevina? (you see?) (2) tavin (understand) (2) lo hevanti ((I) didn’t get it) (1)
Verbs of saying tagidi (say) (3) tagidi li (tell me) (2) me'anyen ma tagidi (I wonder what you’ll say) (1)
Agreement ken (yeah) (28) naxon (right) (4) 'okey (okay) (3) bídyuk (exactly) (1) beseder (alright) (2) metsuyan €(great) (1)
Disagreement lo (no) (20) 'an’lo betuxa (I’m not sure) (1) bexáyexa (come on) (1)
Realizing the need to rephrase s’tomeret (I mean) (7) ma s’tomeret (meaning) (1) ke'ilu€ (like) (7) klomar (that is to say) (1)
Realizing new information 'a (oh) (15) 'aha (3) 'oy (4)
Processing information 'e--h (uh) (39) 'e--m€ (uhm) (4) 'e (2) hm (1)
(11 Types, N=84)
Cognitive 15%
(92 types) (Maschler 2002a)
Back to main action bekítsur (anyway) (5) hakítser €(anyways) (1) 'akítser (in short, anyways)(1)
Ending an action zehu €(that’s it) (8) ya (German ‘yes’) (1)
Coordination ve... (and) (81)
Contrast 'aval (but) (28)
Introducing an action tov (okay) (15) kaxa (like this) (1)
Consequence 'az (so) (96)
(14 Types, N=56)
(10 Types, N=231)
(57 Types, N=203)
Structural 10%
Referential 40%
Interpersonal 35%
Table 2.╇ Distribution of the 574 Discourse Markers throughout the Hebrew Database
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
tsk (1)
he (stance marker) (1) ha'emet (truth is) (1) naxon? (right?) (1)
Expressing discontent lo bseder (very bad) (1)
Other bo/bo'i.... (let’s...) (4) ha (stance marker) (1)
Lack of enthusiasm 'az ma (so what) (1)
Concession lamrot she- (although) (1) meyle she- (never mind that) (1)
Displaying enthusiasm 'axla keta! €(great story!) (1) 'eize keta! (what a story!) (1)
'eize tsxok (how funny) (1) yofi (great) (2)
Condition 'im (if) (1)
Closing digression lo xashuv (never mind) (1)
Disjunction 'o € (or) (3)
yo (wow) (1) shyo (wow) (1) wow (10) wai (6) (wow)
Amazement ken? (yeah?) (4) be'emet? (really?) (5) ma€ (what) (10)
Maintaining contact ken (yes) (1)
Summarizing besax hakol (all in all) (2) basof€(in the end) (2)
Cause ki (because) (5)
ken? (yeah?) (1) yalla (go on) (1)
Urging speaker to continue nu (go on) (26)
(14 Types, N=56)
(10 Types, N=231)
(57 Types, N=203)
Structural 10%
Referential 40%
Interpersonal 35% (11 Types, N=84)
Cognitive 15%
Metalanguage in Interaction
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
Each column consists of utterances operating in a different realm of discourse, but all markers have something in common – they function metalingually – as we have seen. Clearly, a discourse marker can operate in more than one of these realms, which is why we sometimes find the same marker in more than one column in Table 2. Furthermore, many markers operate in more than one realm simultaneously (excerpt 1, line 24, for instance). In such cases, the marker was classified into the realm which seemed the most dominant in that particular context, a decision which is not always clear-cut. It turns out that more often than not, constraints from all contextual realms are at work when a particular discourse marker is employed, just as constraints from all contextual realms are usually at work at every moment of languaging (Becker 1988). This is one of the major factors motivating the grammaticization of discourse markers. We shall return to this point in Section 8 below and in the following chapters. Table 2 is, of course, not exhaustive of all prototypical discourse markers employed in Hebrew, but only of those found in the 16 conversations on which it is based. The above caveats in mind, one can still draw some general quantitative conclusions based on Table 2 concerning casual Hebrew talk among friends and family members of this socioeconomic group. The largest group of discourse markers (exactly 50%) function in the textual realm, creating and reflecting relations between different parts of a text. 35% of all discourse markers deal with interpersonal relations between discourse participants. However, the relatively high number of different types available for this purpose (57 different types) points to the great complexity of interpersonal relations negotiated in interaction, in contrast to the much more limited variety of relations between parts of a text (24 types). Only 15% of all discourse markers attest cognitive processes occurring at frame shifts26. As for the most common functions within each realm, we see that in the referential column, by far the most common relations between conversational actions are those of consequence and coordination (96 and 81 occurrences, respectively). In the structural column, speakers are engaged in organizing the order of conversational actions most frequently, with introducing them, and somewhat less frequently with ending actions. In the interpersonal realm, participants engage most frequently in agreeing and disagreeing, in displaying their amazement, and in urging each other to continue. Despite the high tolerance for disagreement in 26. It must be remembered that only hesitation markers occurring at conversational action boundaries are considered in Table 2. There are far more hesitation markers throughout the data, such as at instances of self-repair (Schegloff, Jefferson, and Sacks 1977), but as long as they did not fulfill the structural requirement for discourse markerhood, they were not included in this table.
Metalanguage in Interaction
this culture (Katriel 1986, Maschler 1994a, Blum-Kulka 1997), tokens of agreement are far more frequent than those of disagreement (60 as opposed to 25)27. A glimpse at this table provides a very general quantitative portrait of what it is that Israelis do most at conversational action boundaries in casual conversation. Whereas Table 1 is probably less language specific (as suggested by historical discourse analysis studies such as Clover 1982, Lönnroth 1976), Table 2 is particular to the genre of informal discourse among Israeli students, their friends, and family relatives studied here. According to Aijmer, “among the characteristic properties of discourse particles which have not received enough attention in the literature is their ‘clustering’ (2002:€31). The classification of discourse markers into interpersonal, referential, structural, and cognitive categories is useful also in explaining their tendency to cluster at conversational action boundaries. If each discourse marker in a cluster is associated with a change in a particular type of contextual constraint, and if a conversational action boundary (particularly a higher-level one) is characterized by shifts in constraints from several contextual realms, then indeed we would expect to find clusterings of discourse markers around conversational action boundaries (Maschler 1994b). Table 1 gives some initial quantitative findings concerning the frequency of discourse marker clusters as a function of the level of the boundary. However, further study is needed in order to reveal the exact patterning of clustering. Many questions remain open, such as what the restrictions are on the types of markers that can appear together in a cluster, or what constraints exist on the order of markers with respect to the contextual realms they come from in a cluster. 6.1
Previous approaches to realms of operation of discourse markers
The present view of discourse markers functioning in the four realms of discourse – the referential, structural, interpersonal, and cognitive – bears some resemblance to Schiffrin’s view of discourse markers as “contextual coordinates of talk” (1987:€312). According to Schiffrin, discourse markers locate an utterance in five planes (1987:€24–28) or ‘domains’ (2006:317) of talk: the ideational structure (“propositions with semantic content” (1987:€ 26)), the action structure (the sequence of speech acts in a discourse), the exchange structure (“the organization of turns at talk” 2006:317), the participation framework (“the more social side of speaker and hearer: their identities, alignments, relationships to each other and to what they are saying” (ibid.), and the information state (“what speakers and hearers know: their 27. This finding must be regarded with caution, however, since many agreement tokens appear in ‘yes, but’ constructions, as part of a disagreement actually. This word of caution applies to Table 2 in its entirety: counting forms removed from context can be misleading.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
organization and management of knowledge and meta-knowledge” (ibid.)). Each discourse marker is seen to be primarily associated with one of these planes, but all markers have secondary uses in at least one other plane (1987:€316, Figure 10.2). The actual classification into realms differs across the two approaches. What is shared is the idea that a marker may function within more than one realm. This view is shared by many other previous approaches, as we have seen in 2.1. 7. Structural patterning of discourse markers So far we have seen systematicity in two aspects regarding employment of discourse markers in monolingual conversation – the moments in discourse at which they are employed and the functions they fulfill. In order to investigate the third type of systematicity – that involving their structural properties – let us return to the non-prototypical 6% category of markers fulfilling only the semantic but not the structural requirement in the definition of prototypical discourse markers28. For example, in the following excerpt, Sharon recounts a conversation she had with her father. Excerpt 5 (‘Obituaries’): 51 Sharon: ... 'amárti lo, I said to him, 52
.. 'ata yodéa shehu mèt. you know that he died.
53
... 'az hu 'omér li, so he says to me,
54
'òy yoy yó--y! oh n--o!
55
... 'az xashávti--, so I thought,
56
... she--hu st´ám mitbadeax 'iti 'oy yoy yoy, {----very high pitch-------} { regular pitch} that he’s just kidding around with me [saying] oh no,
57
... ke'ilu ló’xpàt lo, sort of like [it] doesn’t matter to him,
28. Parts of Section 7 draw on Maschler 2002a. However, whereas that article explores the construction of multivocality via discourse markers, here I focus on the general structural patterning of discourse markers.
Metalanguage in Interaction
Sharon constructs her father’s response following her announcement of bad news (lines 51–52). The father’s constructed dialogue (Tannen 1989) consists of the discourse marker 'òy yoy yóy, roughly equivalent to English oh no (line 54). We see that this discourse marker occurs at intonation-unit initial position in samespeaker talk (Sharon’s), but it follows a continuing intonation contour (line 53) with no additional discourse marker preceding it (i.e., not following another marker in a cluster, as, e.g., in excerpt 1, line 17). The 'òy yoy yóy of line 54 follows the continuing intonation of an intonation unit presenting the constructed dialogue into the discourse: 'az hu 'omér li, (‘so he says to me,’ line 53). In the database, there are no cases in which the intonation unit introducing constructed dialogue and the discourse marker opening the constructed dialogue itself are separated by final intonation. The connection between these two parts of an utterance is too strong to be separated by final intonation. If they are at all separated into two intonation units, the first one is verbalized in continuing intonation. As Chafe writes, the simplest way to signal a link between one intonation unit and the next is by separating them with continuing intonation (1988). Thus, the frame shift between the speaker’s voice introducing the constructed dialogue and the constructed dialogue itself is accomplished via a compromise – employing a discourse marker signaling the frame shift, but one that is not separated as strongly from the intonation unit introducing it. This is not the only environment in which discourse markers follow continuing intonation in same-speaker talk. In line 57 we find another discourse marker, ke'ilu, following continuing intonation (line 56). Sharon tells here how at first she didn’t think her father was responding seriously to her bad news29: xashávti--, she-hu st´ám mitbadeax 'iti 'oy yoy yoy, (‘I thought, that he’s just kidding around with me [saying] oh no’, lines 55–56), imitating the father’s voice ('oy yoy yoy) in a pitch contour different than that of the first part of this intonation unit. She then moves away from imitating the father’s voice and adds a self-rephrasal of this somewhat unusual construction (see below). The discourse marker ke'ilu precedes the selfrephrasal: ke'ilu ló’xpàt lo, (‘sort of like [it] doesn’t matter to him’). Ke'ilu will be studied in depth in Chapter 4. At this point I mention only that a speaker’s realizing the need to rephrase his or her utterance is a cognitive process attested by ke'ilu, which is therefore classified here as a cognitive discourse marker. 29. Sharon had good reason to suspect that this might be the case. Her story tells of macabre humor she tried out on her father: she arbitrarily picked out some name from the obituaries section of the newspaper he was reading, planned to ask him whether he knew the person (assuming he wouldn’t), and upon his negative answer, planned to say that he also never will know him. This didn’t turn out to work so well, because Sharon happened to pick a name of a person her father actually did know. For more detail here, see Maschler 1998b.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
According to Chafe, during verbalization, speakers move from one focus of consciousness to the next, forming superfoci of consciousness which “bring together chunks of information too large to be accommodated within a single focus of consciousness” (1994:€145). These chunks are termed ‘centers of interest’ and they represent “attempts, with varying degrees of success, to push the mind beyond the constraints of active consciousness” (ibid.). Once a speaker judges that a scanning of a center of interest has been accomplished, he or she expresses that judgment with a sentence-final intonation contour. The realization that one’s utterance is in need of rephrasal is independent of the judgment concerning completion of a center of interest. This is why we sometimes find continuing intonation preceding self-rephrasals30. In moving from imitating the father’s 'oy yoy yoy to the self-rephrasal at line 57, Sharon also moves back from constructed dialogue to non-constructed dialogue. Thus, this move actually blends the two categories illustrated so far: moving between non-constructed dialogue and constructed dialogue (albeit in the opposite direction here) as well as rephrasing one’s previous utterance. The strategy of constructed dialogue often involves also moving into a different voice of the speaker’s, because speakers often include their own (ridiculing, ironic, joking, etc.) evaluation of the speech they are constructing. In Bakhtin’s words, “the speaker’s expressivity penetrates through the boundaries and spreads to” (1986:€92) the voice of the person whose voice is being constructed. This is the “layering of voices” studied by Günthner (1997, 1999a). Thus, the two strategies investigated here often blend in interaction. Of the 39 discourse markers following continuing intonation throughout the data (Maschler 2002a), 59% open constructed dialogue and another 13% begin self-rephrasals31. What is common to these two environments, besides the continuing intonation unit preceding the discourse marker, then, is that both involve the phenomenon of multivocality, or polyphony (Bakhtin 1981, 1986) in conversation. In both cases, we find a move to a different voice of the speaker – either the voice of another in some narrated world as constructed by the speaker (constructed dialogue), or another voice of the speaker, rephrasing what he or she just said in the world of narration. This is a move of a level lower than that between subepisodes in narrative or between turns in an adjacency pair (i.e., lower than 30. However, it is still more common to complete a center of interest prior to self-rephrasal.€ In the study of ke'ilu (Chapter 4), I found 58 tokens of self-rephrasal ke'ilu. Of those, 44 (75.9%) occurred following non-continuing intonation, whereas only 13 (22.4%) followed continuing intonation, as seen in excerpt 5. One token occurred intonation-unit finally. 31. In the remaining 28%, we find referential ve- (‘and’, 4 tokens) and 'az (‘then’, 2 tokens), cognitive 'uysh (realizing negative information), and interpersonal 'at yoda'at (‘you (fem.) know’), ze naxon (‘it’s true’), ma (‘what’), and naxon? (‘right?’). See Maschler 2002a: 28–30.
Metalanguage in Interaction Higher-level boundary
complex metalingual utterance cluster of several consecutive prototypical discourse markers prototypical discourse marker fulfilling both semantic and structural requirements non-prototypical discourse marker fulfilling only semantic requirement Ø discourse marker Ø intonation unit boundary blurring of syntactic properties
Lower-level boundary
Figure 1.╇ Strategies for the construction of frame shifts in interaction (Maschler 2002a)
level-III boundaries of Table 1) because it is a move to a voice ‘of second order’ in relation to the speaker’s voice. In Section 4 we saw that higher-order frame shifts generally appear with heavier discourse marking compared to lower-order frame shifts. Here we see that this pattern is adhered to also when lower-level boundaries (level-IV boundaries) are concerned. The lower the boundary between conversational actions, the more subtle the strategy constructing it. Figure 1 sketches the various strategies found throughout the conversations for constructing frame shifts on a scale from heavier to lighter marking. As seen earlier, highest-order frame shifts, such as the beginning of a story or a supertopic, are characterized by the heaviest metalingual material – complex metalingual utterances which haven’t crystallized into discourse markers because they are less frozen (i.e., they vary for person, number, gender) and are longer in nature. With time, some of these will undergo processes of grammaticization and become full-fledged discourse markers. Next we find clusters of several consecutive prototypical discourse markers, often each from a different contextual realm. For the majority of boundaries, the frame shift is accomplished via a single prototypical discourse marker fulfilling both the semantic and the structural requirements in the definition of discourse markers (as do 94% of the markers throughout the data). For more subtle frame shifts, such as those introducing a voice ‘of second order’ of the speaker, we find a non-prototypical discourse marker fulfilling only the semantic requirement, as in excerpt 5, lines 54 and 57. Frame shifts of an order even lower than this exhibit no discourse markers at all, or no boundary between intonation units, as for instance in the following excerpt, exhibiting the discourse marker within the same intonation unit introducing the constructed dialogue:
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
Excerpt 6 (‘Reznik Residence Halls’): 89 Li'at: ...'amarti la tir'i, I said to her look, 90
tevareri 'od hatsa'ot. find out [about] other offers.
When listening to intonation unit 89, it is clear that none of the criteria for identifying intonation unit boundaries (Chafe 1994:€57–60) are found between its two grammatical units. There is no pause between 'amarti la (‘I said to her’) and tir'i (‘look’), no terminal pitch contour, no acceleration-deceleration pattern, and no change in overall pitch or voice quality (e.g., creakiness). The further down we progress along the continuum of Figure 1, strategies for indicating the ‘upcoming package’ become more subtle, and the ‘packages’ themselves become smaller. Higher-level frame shifts are constructed via semanticpragmatic strategies such as clusters of prototypical discourse markers and longer metalingual utterances, whereas lower-level frame shifts are constructed prosodically through the distinction between final vs. non-final intonation contours or not marked at all. Strategies for constructing the most minute frame shifts may even interfere with the syntactic patterns of the language. We have already mentioned the unusual syntactic construction of excerpt 5, line 56. The discourse marker 'oy yoy yoy (‘oh no’) imitating32 the father’s constructed dialogue at line 54 occurs at intonation-unit final position, following the verb mitbadeax (‘kidding around, joking’). This is another case in which the element introducing the (imitated) constructed dialogue and the (imitation of) the constructed dialogue itself appear with no intonation unit boundary separating them (cf. excerpt 6). However, if the strategy of constructed dialogue constitutes a voice ‘of second order’ of the speaker, imitating constructed dialogue constitutes a voice of an even lower order. This is mirrored by an even more subtle frame shifting strategy at line 56. The verb mitbadeax functions at intonation unit 56 as a verbum dicendi in an uncharacteristic way. Mitbadeax (‘joking, kidding around’) is an intransitive verb and should thus take no complements. In the present context, however, it has become a verb of saying introducing imitated constructed dialogue, with the imitation ('oy yoy yoy, ‘oh no’) having the relation of direct object to the verbum dicendi. Thus, an intransitive verb has become transitive in this particular context, and the motivation to mark this extremely low-level boundary preceding imitated 32. That this is a direct quote is supported by the prosodic properties of intonation unit 56: the very high pitch at the beginning of the intonation unit is contrasted with the regular pitch employed to imitate the father’s voice in the latter part of the unit.
Metalanguage in Interaction
constructed dialogue has not only erased intonation unit boundaries but also interfered with the syntax of the language, blurring syntactic properties of verbs. Thus we see that motivation to mark the very subtle boundary between the imitation of constructed dialogue and its introduction into the discourse can interfere with the argument structure of a verb. In their study of transitivity and argument structure based on conversation, Thompson and Hopper come to the conclusion that predicate […] ‘meanings’ are actually generalizations from many repetitions of hearing predicates used in association with certain types of human events and situations over the course of a person’s lifetime. What appears to be a fixed ‘structure’ [such as the argument structure of a particular verb] is actually a set of schemas, some more ‘entrenched’ […] than others, arising out of many repetitions in daily conversational interactions. […] ‘Argument structure’ needs to be replaced by a greatly enriched probabilistic theory capturing the entire range of combinations of predicates and participants that people have stored as sorted and organized memories of what they have heard and repeated over a lifetime of language use. (2001:€47).
The current use of the verb mitbadeax (‘joking, kidding around’) as a transitive verb is not a very ‘entrenched’ use at all, one with a rather low probability in Thompson and Hopper’s proposed probabilistic theory of argument structure. It is the fluidity of grammatical categories that enables this very ‘unentrenched’ use originating from the discourse situation – the need to signal an exceptionally minute frame shift in interaction. Excerpt 5 provides an example of one of the least entrenched uses of this particular verb, as well as a possible context for its employment. In a more recent study of the openness of grammatical construction, Hopper writes: Because grammar is a result of interactions rather than a prerequisite to them, it is not a fixed code but is caught up in a continual process of local adaptation (emergence). These adaptations are microscopic (for instance, the nonce use of an intransitive verb with a direct object), and either go unnoticed or are dismissed as “errors”, but they provide the potential basis for future use and for the analogical spread of forms. (2004:€153, emphasis mine).
Excerpt 5 is precisely an example of such a “nonce use of an intransitive verb with a direct object”. This excerpt thus makes the ties between discourse and grammar apparent both in the structural patterning of discourse markers and in their relations to the syntactic structures of the language. This concludes the third patterning involving discourse markers illustrated in this chapter. Discourse markers were shown to exhibit patterning in terms of (1) the moments at which they are employed in interaction, (2) the functions they
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
fulfill, and (3) their structural properties. Combining the first and third patterns discussed here, we see that the system of discourse markers permeating Hebrew interaction constitutes part of a larger, iconic system of grammatical and prosodic features (and most likely kinesic ones as well), helping participants distinguish higher-order frame shifts from those that are more subtle in nature. Example 5, along with the quote from Hopper 2004 above, lead us next to consider the grammaticization of discourse markers. 8. Grammaticization of discourse markers Studies in the Social Sciences often focus on the tension between structure and event. An event among people, be it a news broadcast, talk show, job interview, or casual conversation, takes place against the background of a structure, a fixed scheme functioning as a mold for that event. As this structure is employed in the various events of that genre, however, a process of negotiation takes place. This process leads to changes in the initial structure and to the emergence of a new structure. Hopper pointed out that, parallel to this cultural process, which Giddens (1984) termed “structuration”, there is a linguistic process, grammaticization, by which new grammatical patterns emerge from interaction. As an unintended outcome of communicative behavior, grammar is a product of “structuration” (Giddens, 1984) rather than a bounded object to be thought of as structure (Hopper 1998:€158).
It is this linguistic process of grammaticization which I am interested in investigating with respect to discourse markers here. Hopper and Traugott define grammaticalization as “the change whereby lexical items and constructions come in certain linguistic contexts to serve grammatical functions and, once grammaticalized, continue to develop new grammatical functions” (2003: xv). In the earlier edition of their 2003 study, they discuss the two terms – “grammaticalization” and the newer “grammaticization”: Some linguists have told us that they avoid the longer word because “grammaticalization” could be understood as “entering the grammar of a language”, i.e., becoming “grammatical”. “Grammaticization”, by contrast, suggests a process whereby a form may become fixed and constrained in distribution without committing the linguist to a view of “grammar” as a fixed, bounded entity. A similar point is sometimes made in a different way: it is said that “grammaticalization” stresses the historical perspective on grammatical forms, while “grammaticization” focuses on the implications of continually changing categories and meanings for a synchronic view of language, thus placing the entire notion of synchrony into question” (1993: xvi).
Metalanguage in Interaction
Grammaticalization is the more common term and the one used by linguists prior to Hopper and Traugott’s 1993 publication (e.g., Meillet 1912, Kuryłowicz 1964, Heine and Reh 1984, Lehman 1985, Traugott and Heine 1991, Heine, Claudi, and Hünnemeyer 1991). Hopper and Traugott write that, because it is far from obvious to them that these distinctions between the two terms actually exist, and because the work they are writing – an introductory textbook on the subject – doesn’t seem the right place to use a new term, they opt for the more traditional “grammaticalization” (1993: xvi). I, however, do perceive a distinction between the two terms. I would like here to move away from the notion of grammaticality and wish to focus on the continually changing categories and meanings from a discourse-pragmatic, rather than a historical-diachronic, perspective. I therefore use the newer term, as it is used by Hopper (1987, 1988, 1998): The notion of Emergent Grammar is meant to suggest that structure, or regularity, comes out of discourse and is shaped by discourse as much as it shapes discourse in an on-going process. Grammar is hence not to be understood as a pre-requisite for discourse, a prior possession attributable in identical form to both speaker and hearer. Its forms are not fixed templates, but are negotiable in face-to-face interaction […] Because grammar is always emergent but never present, it could be said that it never exists as such, but is always coming into being. There is, in other words, no “grammar” but only “grammaticization” – movements toward structure which are often characterizable in typical ways (1987:€142, 148).
Grammaticization has been studied both from a diachronic and a synchronic perspective (Lehmann 1985:€303). The majority of studies are historical, investigating the sources of grammatical forms and their “grammaticalization chains” (Heine, Claudi, and Hünnemeyer 1991:€171–174). Less frequently, grammaticization is also seen as a “primarily syntactic, discourse pragmatic phenomenon, to be studied from the point of view of fluid patterns of language use” (Hopper and Traugott 2003:€2). It is from this latter synchronic perspective that I approach discourse markers in the present study. Consistent with Hopper and Traugott’s view that grammaticization “is motivated by speaker-hearer interactions and communicative strategies” (ibid.: 73), and with Bybee and Hopper’s view that “the notion of emergence [...] relativizes structure to speakers’ actual experience with language” (2001:€ 3), this study concerns itself with identifying some actual patterns of language use which have resulted in grammaticization of discourse markers in Hebrew. Grammaticization has come to be investigated in the context of discourse markers in a variety of languages: e.g., for English, Romaine and Lange 1991, Finell 1992, Traugott 1995a,b, 2003a,b, Ferrara 1997, Tabor and Traugott 1998; for Old and Middle English, Brinton 1996; for English, French and other languages,
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
Fleischman and Yaguello 1999, 2004; for Hebrew-English bilingual discourse, Maschler 1994a, 1997b, 1998a; for Hebrew, Maschler 2001, 2002b, 2003, Maschler and Estlein 2008; for English and Japanese, Traugott and Dasher 2002; for German, Günthner 2000; for French, Vincent 2005; for Swedish, Lindström and Wide 2005; for Italian, Visconti 2003, 2005; for Spanish, Pons Bordería and Schwenter 2005. Let us return now to the metalanguaging property of discourse markers. In the following chapters, I wish to illuminate some aspects of the emergent grammar by which the metalanguage employed in interaction crystallizes into the fixed utterances we call ‘discourse markers’. This, then, is a synchronic study of the grammaticization of discourse markers, a phenomenon studied so far mostly from the diachronic perspective. Book-length studies of the grammaticization of discourse markers are very few (Brinton 1996, Suzuki 1999, Aijmer 2002, Onodera 2004). Previous articlelength studies of the grammaticization of discourse markers (e.g., Finell 1989, 1992, Brinton 1990, 2001, König 1991, Traugott and König 1991, Abraham 1991, Onodera 1995, Traugott 1995a,b 2003a,b, Wårvik 1995, Aijmer 1985, 1996, Jucker 1997, Tabor and Traugott 1998, Manoliu 2000, Schwenter and Traugott 2000, Traugott and Dasher 2002 (Chapter 4), Visconti 2003, 2005, Lindström and Wide 2005, Pons Bordería and Schwenter 2005) trace a particular marker throughout its history in various written documents from different periods of a language. While illuminating in many respects, this approach is also problematic. For example, in the beginning of her book Pragmatic Markers in English, Brinton writes: I investigate whether medieval narrative might be structured much like contemporary oral narrative and whether these linguistic features might be functionally motivated in ways analogous to pragmatic markers in Modern English discourse, that is, textually and interpersonally. However, I recognize that the function of oral features in the written texts of Old and Middle English may be somewhat different from the function of comparable features in the strictly oral discourse of Modern English, perhaps being used self-consciously as stylized pragmatic markers (1996:€8).
Almost a decade later, ending a study of the grammaticization of Swedish particles of the you know type, Lindström and Wide come to a similar conclusion: There is […] a general difficulty that these oldest texts are not very interactive in their nature, and thus there is little room for the use of dialogically sensitive elements. This remains a methodological problem in diachronic studies like the one carried out here (2005:€232).
The written nature of the data, and the fact that they do not always come from the same genre, render this approach somewhat problematic.
Metalanguage in Interaction
The natural habitat of language, its primordial site (Schegloff 1993, 1996a,b), is casual everyday conversation. Bakhtin (1986) viewed conversation as the most basic genre from which all genres derive. Since this is the prime locus of the use and development of language, it is only natural that this is where we should study grammaticization processes, and in particular, those relating to quintessentially interactional phenomena such as frame shifting. The present study is based, as we have seen, on a synchronic corpus of Hebrew conversations recorded over the years 1994–2002. Ideally, it would have been better to have spoken corpora from at least two different periods of the language in order to investigate grammaticization processes. However, an earlier corpus of casual Spoken Hebrew does not exist33. As Schourup writes, “historical investigation of DMs obviously cannot rely on naturally-occurring spoken texts” (1999:€261). One might wonder how, missing a diachronic perspective, it would still be possible to investigate grammaticization phenomena. This is possible because, upon a close synchronic analysis of the tokens of a particular discourse marker in the spoken corpus, we often find that a certain token functions in more than one way simultaneously. These ambiguous tokens are particularly illuminating for research on discourse markers, as close examination of the contexts in which they occur reveals how a particular marker might come to serve more than one function, thus suggesting the functional itinerary followed by the particular marker34. Comparisons with “equivalent” discourse markers in other languages can also be made in order to support the grammaticization paths suggested. This is because, as noted by Hopper and Traugott, grammatical morphemes “tend to be polysemous in similar ways across languages, and to undergo similar paths of development as a result of human discourse and interaction.” (2003:€33). Grammatical morphemes “reflect the metaphorical processes that are based on human cognitive make-up, and they reflect the inferences that humans commonly make when they communicate” (Bybee, Perkins, and Pagliuca 1994:€302). 33. For the chapter on ke'ilu (‘like’) (see below), a discourse marker which has greatly proliferated in the language in recent years, it was possible to compare conversations collected during the earlier part of the corpus construction (1994–1997) with those collected later (1998–2002), and thus arrive at a diachronic perspective based on two spoken corpora. 34. Thus, if we assume that this variation of more than one function per marker is representative of a diachronic process underway, the study can be viewed as a diachronic analysis of sorts. I thank Cecilia Ford for pointing this out to me. For other synchronic studies of grammaticization, see Thompson and Mulac 1991, Thompson 2002, Kärkkäinen 2003, Imo 2007, Keevallik 2006, 2007 – all on the grammaticization of epistemic parentheticals from the canonical Subject + Verb form – and Auer 2005, Günthner 2007, 2008, Pekarek Doehler 2007, Laury and Seppänen 2008, Hopper 2004, Hopper and Thompson 2008, for synchronic studies of grammaticization of other constructions.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
Other studies of the grammaticization of discourse markers taking this synchronic perspective include Auer 1996, 2005, Günthner 1996, 2000, Fleischman and Yaguello 1999, 2004. 8.1
Traugott’s theory of grammaticization and semantic change
Recall that in the present approach, the metalinguality of discourse markers was discovered through a synchronic investigation of the strategy of language alternation at metalingual utterances (Section 2). This led to the semantic criterion in the definition of discourse markers – that the utterance have a metalingual interpretation in the context in which it occurs. What is interesting to remark on from the very start is that the metalinguality of discourse markers, discovered through synchronic investigation in the current approach, is judged to be the final stage of grammaticization, a judgement arrived at in diachronic approaches. Based on a series of diachronic studies of Old, Middle, and Present Day English (e.g., Traugott 1980, 1982, 1986, 1989, 1995a,b, 1999, 2003a,b, Traugott and Dasher 2002), Traugott proposed a model for the semantic change involved in grammaticization phenomena. She showed certain pragmatic-semantic tendencies in this change (see Figure 2 below). As forms become increasingly grammaticized, there is “a tendency toward metatextual meaning, or more specifically a shift from […] ‘the world being talked about’ to ‘the speaker’s organization of that world in the act of speaking’” (Traugott and Dasher 2002:€40). With this shift towards the world of the speaker, as s/he is involved in the act of speaking, meanings become first more subjective (“increasingly based in the speaker’s subjective belief/state/attitude toward the proposition” (Traugott 1989:€35)), and then more intersubjective: [intersubjectivity is best construed] in parallel with subjectivity […as] the explicit expression of speaker’s/writer’s attention to the ‘self ’ of addressee/reader in both an epistemic sense (paying attention to their presumed attitudes to the content of what is said), and in a more social sense (paying attention to their ‘face’ or ‘image needs’ associated with social stance and identity). (Traugott 2003a: 128).
a. b. c. d.
non/less subjective > subjective > intersubjective content > content/procedural > procedural non-metatextual > metatextual scope within clause > scope over clause > scope over discourse
Figure 2.╇ Pragmatic-semantic tendencies (Traugott 2001)
Metalanguage in Interaction
There is a move from focusing on the “world out there” to the world of the interaction, with its metatextual structure, procedures for organizing that structure, and interactional aspects such as intersubjectivity. Correlated with these changes is an increase in the scope of the grammatical element from an element whose scope is within the clause, to one whose scope is over the entire clause, and finally to one whose scope is over a discourse segment. However, “[a]lthough correlated, the individual horizontal trajectories [in Figure 235] are not necessarily vertically aligned” (Traugott and Dasher 2002:€40). Earlier studies by Traugott claimed that early grammaticization involved unidirectional meaning change which may proceed along the path: propositional > (textual) > expressive
(Traugott 1982:€257)
where “expressive” was later replaced by “subjective”. (Both terms can be subsumed under the term “interpersonal”, as it is used in the present study – negotiating relations between speaker and hearer or between speaker and text). This ordering later appeared to be too strong (e.g., Heine, Claudi and Hünnemeyer 1991:€ 190–191, Brinton 1996), and was therefore revised as a set of tendencies which may overlap: Tendency I: meanings based in the external described situation > meanings based in the internal (evaluative/perceptual/cognitive) described situation. Tendency II: Meanings based in the external or internal described situation > meanings based in the textual and metalinguistic situation. Tendency III: Meanings tend to become increasingly based in the speaker’s subjective belief state/attitude toward the proposition. (Traugott 1989:€34–35).
Notice that although Traugott’s studies do not address cognitive discourse markers per se, as does the present study, Tendency I covers this type of discourse marker as well. In the present, synchronic, approach, we have seen that languaging is perceived of as happening in all realms of discourse simultaneously (Becker 1988), that is, in the referential, interpersonal, structural, prior-textual, medial, and silential realms. Languaging is constrained also by the cognitive constraints to which human interlocutors are subject (Chafe 1987). Correspondingly, metalingual utterances are constrained by these various contextual realms simultaneously, 35. The figure in Traugott and Dasher 2002 is slightly but crucially different than the one of Traugott 2001, which I have adopted. Instead of the trajectory non-metatextual > metatextual of Traugott 2001, Traugott and Dasher 2002 have truth-conditional > non-truth-conditional.€ However, below their figure they mention that “it [...] follows that there is a tendency toward metatextual meaning, or more specifically a shift from de re to de dicto meaning” (ibid.: 40). Since truth-conditions are completely irrelevant to my analysis, whereas metalanguage is central, I adopt the figure in Traugott 2001.
Chapter 1.╇ Introduction
although, as we have seen, often a particular realm is more prominent than others in a particular context. Therefore, there is no fixed cline of unidirectionality in the present approach, as found in Traugott’s earlier studies (e.g. 1982). By starting out with the notion of the interaction, with its three aspects of (1) structure of the text, (2) interaction among participants, and (3) cognitive processes taking place in a speaker’s mind during verbalization, we saw that metalanguage operates at these three realms of discourse – the textual, interpersonal, and cognitive (Section 2). There are no hierarchical relations between these realms, and so the present approach avoids getting into the question of whether interpersonal meanings stem from textual ones or vice versa. Every act of languaging is constantly constrained by the various contextual realms shaping discourse, and discourse markers are no exception. There are, of course, many affinities and interrelations among the various contextual realms, but they are not fixed and depend on the particular utterance in question. In the following chapters, most of all in Chapter 5, we will see that these affinities are responsible for the particular functional paths followed by the discourse markers. What is interesting, however, is the fact that Traugott’s final stage of grammaticization arrived at through diachronic study – the “metatextual”, relating to the speaker’s organization of the world being talked about in the act of speaking – correlates precisely with the most essential property of discourse markers – their metalingual nature, arrived at synchronically in the present approach. Synchronic and diachronic approaches, then, are seen to complement, other rather than to contradict, one another. 9. Interacting as an Israeli We have seen that Table 2 allows only a bird’s-eye view of all the discourse markers found throughout the database. In order to achieve a more accurate understanding of the ways discourse markers function in interaction, one must complement this table with a detailed study of every single discourse marker, a task far too ambitious for the present study. I have chosen to focus on four particular discourse markers. Three of them are representative of the three main realms in which discourse markers operate – the interpersonal, textual, and cognitive. In order to study more closely the ways constraints from these different contextual realms interact and result in grammaticization of discourse markers, I have chosen an additional discourse marker – one that functions ‘in between’ realms. For the interpersonal realm, I focus on the urging token nu ( ‘yeah, go on’), for the textual realm – on the resumptive token bekitsur (‘anyway’, lit. ‘in short’), and for the cognitive realm – on the token of self-rephrasal ke'ilu (‘like’, lit. ‘as if ’). As a
Metalanguage in Interaction
marker functioning ‘in between’ realms, we shall examine tov (‘okay, fine’, lit. ‘good’), which operates both interpersonally and textually throughout the interactions. Table 3 supplies quantitative information concerning the extent to which each one of these markers is employed throughout the database – the 50 conversations on which the present study is based. We see that nu is the most widespread of all four markers. In fact, it is the second most common interpersonal discourse marker throughout the database (following ken (‘yeah’)). Of the markers investigated in depth in this study, nu is followed by tov in terms of frequency, with 62 tokens in this corpus. Ke'ilu is the most widespread utterance of the four (120 tokens), but only 58 function as discourse markers. Finally, the least frequently employed discourse marker among the four is bekitsur, with 49 tokens. These four discourse markers have not been chosen for further study arbitrarily. Not only is each one relatively prevalent throughout the conversations in relation to other discourse markers from the same realm36, but also each marker illuminates certain quintessential aspects of Israeli identity, society, and culture. I therefore believe these four discourse markers are particularly telling for understanding the essence of interacting as an Israeli. In order to explain this statement, however, we must turn to the actual studies of the particular markers. Table 3.╇ Distribution of the four discourse markers focused on in this study Interpersonal
Textual
Cognitive
nu 115
bekitsur 49
ke'ilu 120 (58)
Interpersonal and Textual tov 62
36. Although based on a smaller corpus, Table 2 provides quantitative support for this claim.
chapter 2
The interpersonal realm The discourse marker nu: Israeli Hebrew impatience in interaction
1. Introduction1 Growing up in a Jewish-Israeli household to a mother of Austrian-German background, there were several things I was not allowed to say to my mother. One of them was nu. If I used nu in conversation, I would get scolded. My mother perceived this word as disrespectful and impolite2, though she couldn’t help employing nu sometimes in her own talk to me. There is no satisfying English equivalent for this word, but some tokens may be translated as ‘well?’, ‘go on’, ‘so’, or ‘so what’. Nu often sounds impolite also to Americans living in Israel. My American husband once said to me: ‘Don’t nu me!’ following my use of this word in our English discussion. In another genre, classroom discourse, nu is considered highly inappropriate, particularly in the talk of student to teacher, at least at the university level. I distinctly recall only two such incidents in the course of my teaching over the past ten years, both of which struck me at the time as rather impolite. Hebrew casual conversation, however, is abundant with nus. Although the word is often generally perceived by Israelis as having an impolite aura, most of its tokens do not seem to be interpreted as impolite in actual ordinary talk-in-interaction because in fact they function to encourage the flow of discourse rather than obstruct it. Examine, for instance, the following conversation between a man and two women in their early twenties. The women are co-telling the man about their experiences in a diving course down in Eilat, humorously describing how most of the women in the group dropped out at various stages of the course: 1. This chapter was originally published in 2003 in Text 23: 89–128. It has been extended and updated here to examine additional nu tokens from 20 more conversations so as to fit in with the larger study. 2. The term ‘impolite’ is used here in its everyday sense, rather than as a term in a theory of politeness.
Metalanguage in Interaction
Excerpt 1 (‘Diving Course’): 29 Orna: harofé hipìl 'ota, the doctor dropped her [i.e., caused her to drop out], 30
.. ya'ani. sorta.
31
.. 'al.. 'e--h.. refu'í hi naflà. on uh medical [reason] she fell. for uh medical reasons she dropped out.
32 All:
{laughter}
33 Ran: /'atem 'al?????????/ you [dropped out] for???????? 34 Orna: ló /naxon/. {--laughing--} not true. 35 Anat: ... 'anàxnu nafálnu, we dropped out, 36 tude]
'al sotsyométri. {---laughing---} on sociometric [grounds] for sociometric reasons. [i.e., for not having the right social atti-
37 All:
{laughter}
38 Orna: ... nish'àrnu 'árba banot. {----------laughing---------} we were left four girls. 39
... to al
40
... tóv! alright!
41 Ran: ... nu,
42
'ani maksh I’m listn
43
.. 'ani mexake lá-{-----laughing---} I’m waiting for the
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
44
.. lapo'énta. {--laughing--} for the point. la-- pántsh layn. {-------laughing-----} for the punch line
45 Anat: 46 Orna: ... tóv! alright! 47
.. magía hayom hashenì. arrives the day the second the second day arrives.
The story (which had actually begun several minutes before line 29) proceeds at length, with many long digressions and much laughter. Ran employs nu at line 41 immediately preceding his metalingual comment 'ani maksh.. 'ani mexake la--.. lapo'enta. (‘I’m listn.. I’m waiting for the.. for the point’, lines 42–44) in the midst of Orna’s narrative (lines 38–40), urging her on to get to this story’s point. This is flavored with humor indicated by Ran’s laughter as well as with perhaps some degree of patronizing. However, no impoliteness is oriented to by the other participants here: Anat picks up the humor and laughingly co-constructs (Lerner 1991) with Ran, completing his 'ani mexake la-- (‘I’m waiting for the’, line 43) with the English borrowing la-- pantsh layn, (‘for the punch line’, line 45); and Orna proceeds enthusiastically, as her tov3! (‘alright!’, line 46) indicates, to the next episode of the narrative, concerning the second day of the course (line 47). Nu is a non-lexical form in Hebrew. Only two of five Hebrew dictionaries I checked list nu as an entry. Even-Shoshan’s dictionary (2003) classifies nu as an interjection borrowed from European languages4 meaning 'efo (‘therefore’) hava (‘let us’) uvxen (‘well then’)–all words of high register. However, this classification says little about the uses of nu in casual Hebrew conversation, such as the one above. Avneyon’s dictionary (1997) comes closer: milat zeruz (‘hastening word’). Although nu was borrowed from European languages, particularly Yiddish and Russian, this word has gained new meanings in Israeli Hebrew, different from those it had in the languages of origin5. For instance, as I am often told by Israelis 3.
For the study of tov, see Chapter 5.
4. See Goss and Salmons 2000, Maschler 2000 a, b, and Chapter 1 of the present study, for studies of the role of language alternation in the grammaticization of discourse markers. 5. Nu is often heard also in varieties of Jewish American English whose speakers originate in Eastern Europe. In Weinreich’s Yiddish-English dictionary (1977), we find Yiddish nu translated as English ‘go on! well? on!’. According to Rosten (1968: 271–273), aside from oy and the
Metalanguage in Interaction
upon hearing that I am studying nu, one characterization of new immigrants from the former Soviet Union to ‘Israeli ears’ is that when these people speak Hebrew, they employ nu much more frequently in comparison to native-born Hebrew speakers, and often in contexts which do not seem appropriate. In a pilot study, Mazo and Voloshin (1999) found that Russian nu has some softening functions which are not found for Israeli nu. In previous studies of the system of discourse markers segmenting Hebrew talk-in-interaction (Maschler 1997a, 1998b, 2002a. See Table 2, Chapter 1), nu was classified as a discourse marker functioning in the interpersonal realm of discourse (Becker 1979) ‘urging speaker to continue’. Recall that in the present study, a prototypical discourse marker is defined as an utterance fulfilling two conditions; one semantic, the other structural: a. Semantically, the utterance must have a metalingual interpretation in the context in which it occurs. In other words, rather than referring to the extralingual world, it must refer metalingually to the realm of the text, to the interaction between its participants, or to their cognitive processes. b. Structurally, the utterance must occur at intonation-unit initial position, either at a point of speaker change, or, in same-speaker talk, immediately following any intonation contour other than continuing intonation. It may occur after continuing intonation or at non-intonation-unit initial position only if it follows another marker in a cluster (Maschler 1998b: 31)6.
articles, nu is the most frequently used word in Yiddish. Rosten adds: ‘From Russian nu: ‘well’, ‘well now’, etc.; cognates are common in Indo-European languages.’ (Rosten 1968: 271). I wish to express my gratitude to Sandra Thompson for showing me this reference. In a recent article, Sorjonen studies two Finnish particles, no, which she characterizes as a go-ahead response (Schegloff 1990), and nii, another Finnish continuer (Schegloff 1982), both manifesting some of the functions of Hebrew nu (see below). She mentions that the Finnish etymological dictionary compares Finnish no to German nun and na and suggests that ‘it is partially an original Finnish word, also found in other Baltic-Finnish and Sámi languages, [...] which has also been influenced by foreign languages, most notably by Germanic languages’ (2002: 166). See also Hilmisdóttir’s study of Icelandic nú and núna (2007). It seems, then, that other languages besides Hebrew and Jewish varieties of English have borrowed forms related to nu from Germanic languages. 6. In Chapter 1 we saw that the two criteria in this definition coincide for 94% of the discourse markers found throughout the database. We saw that the remaining 6% satisfy the semantic, but not the structural requirement, and that the majority of these 6% category discourse markers are employed to construct two types of multivocality in discourse–constructed dialogue (Tannen 1989) and self-rephrasal.€ In this chapter, I include nu tokens following continuing intonation in same-speaker talk as well. All but two such instances occur in the move from non-constructed to constructed dialogue.
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
The nu of excerpt 1, for example, satisfies both requirements for prototypical discourse markerhood. It functions metalingually in the interpersonal realm as Ran is urging Orna to continue her story and finally get to its point (lines 41–44), and it fulfills the structural requirement as it appears at intonation unit initial position at a point of speaker change. This nu, then, like the majority of tokens throughout the database (68.7% of all instances of nu, see Table 1 below), fits the characterization ‘interpersonal discourse marker urging speaker to continue’. However, there are many subtleties in the functions of nu which the characterization above does not capture, and we will also see some tokens of nu for which this characterization is less relevant. The present chapter attempts a finer characterization of the functions and flavor of nu in a corpus of casual Hebrew talk-ininteraction. At the same time, it relates to the possible grammaticization path followed by nu in Hebrew and to the role of impatience in creating interpersonal involvement in Israeli discourse. 2. Data Nu was found to be the second most common interpersonal discourse marker throughout the 50 conversations of the Haifa Corpus of Spoken Israeli Hebrew (Maschler 2004) on which the present study is based (see Chapter 1, Section 3). Following ken (‘yeah’) with over 240 occurrences, nu manifests 115 tokens, which corresponds to an average of one nu token every 1.3 minutes7. A few additional excerpts manifesting tokens of nu were broadly transcribed immediately after having heard them employed in interactions in which I participated. They, too, will be discussed in the present chapter, although they are not counted in the following table. Table 1 sketches an overall picture of the functions of nu in the recorded database: Table 1.╇ Distribution of nu tokens according to function throughout the database Hastening non-verbal action
Urging further development within main topic
Granting permission to perform action
Providing joking/provoking key
Total
6 (5.2%)
79 (68.7%)
3 (2.6%)
27 (23.5%)
115 (100%)
7. The next most common interpersonal marker in the corpus after nu, lo (‘no’), was employed significantly less frequently.
Metalanguage in Interaction
The following sections elaborate on the headings of this table and illustrate the various functions of nu in this corpus of casual Hebrew talk-in-interaction. 3. Hastening co-participant to get on with some non-verbal action Let us begin with the least metalingual use of nu. This word can be employed in order to hasten a co-participant to get on with some non-verbal action. For example, in the following interaction, David is cooking some soup in the kitchen while telling his close friend Dalia a story. At the end of the story, he wants her to taste his soup, an action she repeatedly refuses to perform: Excerpt 2 (‘Soup’): 124 David: .. pashút, simply, 125
.. ló rotse lehaxzir ta’ xovòt. doesn’t want to return the debts.
126
'axsháv nit'am mehamara/ve/k8. now we’ll taste from the soup now we’ll taste the soup.
127
{David tastes the soup}
128 Dalia: (4.05) nu 'éx yatsa? nu how came out nu how did it come out? 129 David: .. 'aní xoshev sheyatsa tòv, I think that came out good I think it came out good, 130
.. bó'i tit'amì. come taste [it].
131 Dalia: .. ló rotsa. don’t want [to]. 132 David:
bó'i tit'amì! {-----ff-----} come taste [it]!
8. The Hebrew word for soup is marak and we know that this is what is cooking from other parts of the text. However, something approximating the syllable -ve- is heard inserted within the final syllable of this word here: mara/ve/k.
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
ló rotsa. don’t want [to].
133 Dalia:
'ani 'eshpóx 'et ze 'alàyix. I’ll spill this on you I’m gonna spill this on you.
134 David: 135 Dalia: .. ló rotsa. don’t want [to]. 136 David: (3.92) 'amrù lax pá'am they told you once did they ever tell you 137
'amárti lax pà'am, I told you once did I ever tell you,
138
she'at domà egárfild? that you similar to Garfield that you look like Garfield?
139 Dalia: .... kén, yes, 140
'amárta li, you’ve told me,
141
shloshím 'elef pà'am, thirty thousand times,
142 David:
nu! get on with it already! {moving soup spoon closer to Dalia’s mouth}
143 Dalia:
she'ani domá le that I similar to that I look like
144
.. ló rotsà! {-------ff-------} don’t want [to].
145 David: tit'amí--! {----ff----} taste [it]! At line 127 David tastes the soup and Dalia asks him nu 'ex yatsa? (‘nu how did it come out?’, 128). This use of nu will be dealt with in Section 7. David then invites
Metalanguage in Interaction
her to taste the soup herself in a series of two requests (lines 130, 132), both of which Dalia refuses (lo rotsa (‘don’t want [to]’), lines 131, 133). It takes several additional increasingly direct requests to get Dalia to taste the soup. At line 142, David moves the soup spoon closer to her mouth9, uttering nu! in sentence final exclamatory intonation. Dalia refuses yet again (line 144), this time more loudly, at which point David resorts to a direct order: tit'ami--! ‘taste [it]!’, line 145. The nu at line 142, then, urges Dalia to perform a non-verbal action. Here it is accompanied by impatience mixed with humor, as indicated by the prosody of lines 142 and 145, particularly the fact that the intonation contour of 145 imitates that of 144, with a marked high-low-high intonation pattern on the last syllable of tit'amí--! (line 145) uttered in loud volume. In excerpt 3, Yosi tells his wife about a conversation he engaged in with two cashiers at the local grocery store. Yosi retells how one of the cashiers was telling the other about some extraordinary place which her husband had taken her to while they were abroad. The other cashier responded with some embarrassment that she, too, had been there, at which point Yosi joins in, expressing his curiosity about the place. At a crucial point in the story, right before the identity of the place is revealed, Yosi describes the cashier dealing with the customer ahead of him in line. Yosi employs nu (line 68) in his own constructed dialogue (Tannen 1989) addressed to the cashier, dramatizing his hastening of the cashier to be done with that customer so that she could tell him the end of the story: Excerpt 3 (‘Cashiers’): 63 Yosi: .. 'ani kvar ló yax I already not ca I can’t anymo 64
.. 'ani / muxráx/ lishmòa, I / must/ hear,
65
.. 'ani mét mimètax 'axshav. I’m dying of suspense now.
{laughter}
66 Tali:
67 Yosi: ... 'ani ló yaxol lehaxzík ma'amàd, {---------laughing------------} I not can hold on I can’t wait any longer, 9. The interaction was audio-, rather than video-taped, but the person who first transcribed it was Dalia, who remembered the non-verbal action accompanying this utterance. The warning 'ani 'eshpox 'et ze 'alayix (‘I’ll spill this on you’) at 134, and the ensuing discussion concerning her resemblance to Garfield (136–142), further support this location of the spoon relative to Dalia’s face.
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
68
.. nú, {laughing, change of tone} come on,
69
.... tigmerí maher 'im haben'adám haze! {-------------laughing-----------------} finish quickly with the human being this be done with this person already!
70 Tali:
..... nú?
71 Yosi:
{laughter}
72 Tali:
{laughter}
73 Yosi:
... 'az hi 'oméret, so she says,
74
.. tishmá, {Â�Â�Â�Â�---pp---} listen,
75
.... lakxú 'otanu, {-------pp----------} they took us,
76
lexanùt le'avizarèy mín. {--------pp---------} {----laughing-----} to a store for accessories of sex to a sex shop.
The key is quite humorous in this narrative, indicated by the laughter, as Yosi constructs his talk to the cashier (lines 68–69) and her response (lines 74–76). In fact, Yosi’s laughter while uttering the cashier’s response (line 76) reveals his evaluation of her constructed speech: as he later says explicitly (excerpt 3a below), he views these cashiers’ bashful attitude towards sex shops ridiculous. The laughter accompanying line 76 manifests the layering of voices (Bakhtin 1986, Günthner 1999a) in discourse–specifically, the layering of Yosi’s ridiculing voice over the cashier’s constructed dialogue. The action Yosi would like the cashier to hasten in the midst of this humorous segment is described by the verb of the intonation unit following nu: tigmeri maher (‘finish quickly’) 'im haben'adam haze (‘with this human being’), or ‘be done with this person already’, line 69. Unlike the previous example, then, here nu occurs in continuing intonation and is followed by an utterance spelling out the action being urged. Note that while Yosi’s nu of line 68 hastens an action in the extralingual world, Tali’s nu of line 70, to which we shall return later, relates to the world of the text and is therefore considered metalingual here.
Metalanguage in Interaction
Discourse markers are often employed in the little dialogues we carry on with ourselves. A speaker can also urge him/herself to perform some action. No such examples were found in the corpus, but an interaction around our dinnertable supplies an example. In the following excerpt, which I transcribed immediately after the utterance took place10, five-year-old Yotam begins to sing to us his version of a song they learned that day at school: Excerpt 4 (‘Song’): 1 Yotam: hashu'al, {--singing--} the fox, 2
'avar miderex, {-----singing---} passed from a path,
3
'el 'el 'el, {--singing--} to to to,
... nu.
4
5
.... 'ex kor'im le'eifo sheha'anavim? how one calls to where that the grapes what do you call the place where the grapes are?
6 Mother: kerem. vinyard. 7 Yotam: 'el 'el 'el, {--singing--} to to to, 8
hakerem. {--singing--} the vinyard.
At line 4 Yotam stops singing because he had forgotten the continuation of the song. Employing nu in sentence-final falling intonation, he hastens himself to remember the missing words. Following a longer than average pause, in the following intonation unit, he requests my help in this task. Once reminded, he continues singing (line 7 and on).
10. These excerpts are transcribed using broader transcription conventions because they were not recorded.
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
Children are aware of this use of nu quite early. Following Yotam’s employment of nu at a similar context, I asked him why he said nu there. His answer was quick and simple: nu she'ani 'ezkor kvar! (‘nu [so] that I remember already!’). In this case, then, nu may be better characterized as a cognitive discourse marker–one providing information about cognitive processes occurring at frame shifts which are often revealed in the medium of spoken discourse, rather than as an interpersonal discourse marker. The context of recalling a word also places this use of nu closer to being metalingual, rather than functioning in the extralingual realm. The following excerpt supplies another nu token urging an action which is on the boundary between the lingual and metalingual. It comes from an interaction I heard between my two daughters. Nine-year-old Maya was trying again and again to get her sister, twelve-year-old Shira, to play the Harry Potter trivia game with her, which Shira repeatedly refused. Following a series of attempts on Maya’s part, Shira finally said: Excerpt 5 (‘Trivia Games’): 1 Shira: nu, 2
'aval 'ani sonét lesaxek, but I hate to play but I hate playing,
3
misxakèy trívya! games of trivia trivia games!
When I immediately asked why she said nu there, the answer was as quick as her brother’s was in the previous example: nu sheday lenadned! (‘nu [so] that enough already with the nagging!’). In other words, the action Maya was urged to do in this context was ‘stop nagging her sister’. The action of stopping to nag somebody here clearly involves language, although it involves other aspects of behavior as well, a fact making this instance of nu another token functioning on the fuzzy boundary between the lingual and the metalingual. Nu as a hastener of non-verbal actions is not that common in the corpus–only about 5.2% of the tokens–because most of the conversations do not take place while participants are also performing accompanying non-verbal actions. Yet this function seems to me to be the basic function of nu, the non-metalingual function from which other functions originate. It is difficult to confirm this, as it would involve examining the functions of nu in Yiddish, Russian, and Hebrew spoken corpora from the time in which nu was first borrowed into Hebrew. However, it is in agreement with characterizations of the semantic process involved in grammaticization as involving a metaphorical shift from the concrete to the
Metalanguage in Interaction
abstract (Traugott 1982, Sweetser 1988), or from the propositional to the ‘metalinguistic’ (Traugott 1988, Traugott and König 1991). 4. Nu urging further development within a topic Just as one can be urged to perform a non-verbal action, so can a speaker urge an interlocutor to perform a verbal action. The majority of nu tokens in this database (more than 2 out of every 3 tokens, 68.7%) function to urge the speaker to move on in the development of a discourse topic (Chafe 1994). This happens in both narrational and non-narrational discourse, and the flavor of nu changes as a function of the genre in which it is employed. We will see that this type of nu can be characterized as a ‘continuer’ (Schegloff 1982) with some modification. 4.1
Narrational discourse
Nu can function to urge a participant to move on in the development of a narrative. This includes urging the speaker (1) to begin a narrative the hearer knows is about to be told, (2) to move on to a current narrative’s next episode (Chafe 1987) thus advancing towards its point, or (3) to return to the narrative following a digression. I illustrate only the second category here. 4.1.1 Urging a move on to the next episode of a narrative In the following excerpt, Tamir describes to his male friend Erez a fight he witnessed between two men: Excerpt 6 (‘Violence’): 35 Tamir: .. 'axsháv, now, 36
.. hahù kvar haya-- 'al haritspá, the other one already was on the floor, the other one [i.e., the victim] was already on the floor,
37
.. ke'ilu, like,
38
.. hu baràx bizxilá, he had escaped crawling,
39
.. hu ló-- barax beritsà. he hadn’t escaped running.
... 'ata mevín?
40
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
you understand see?
41
.. ke'ilu--, like,
42
.. kaze, like
{demonstrating victim’s crawling}.
43
44 Erez:
.... wá wá! wow wow
... nú?
45
46 Tamir: .. vedofék bo makòt, and slamming at him blows and [he] is hitting him hard, 47
48 Erez:
.. vehu ló, and he doesn’t, /xxxxxxxx/
49 Tamir: ... lò meraxém 'alav. doesn’t have [any] pity for him. At line 36 Tamir describes the state the victim of the fight was in at that point in the story: hahù kvar haya-- 'al haritspá (‘the other one was already on the floor’). He backtracks to point out that the victim had been hurt in the fight so badly, that he had escaped crawling, not running (lines 37–39). This is done via two rephrasals employing kaze and ke'ilu (lines 37–43) (two ‘equivalents’ of English like11), both verbally (lines 38–39) and non-verbally by demonstrating the victim’s crawling (lines 42–43). At line 44 Erez manifests his involvement in this description/ dramatization with the interjection wa wa! uttered in sentence-final intonation. He then employs nu? (line 45) in appeal intonation12. This is followed by Tamir’s move on to the next episode of the narrative, describing the next complicating action: vedofek bo makot, (‘and [he] is hitting him hard’, line 46). The shift to the new episode from the background of the narrative to its foreground is indicated by Tamir’s use of the discourse marker ve- (‘and’, line 46) as well as by his switch in tense and aspect (Hopper 1979) from barax (‘had escaped’, past perfective, lines 11. For the functions of Hebrew kaze (lit. ‘like this’) and ke'ilu (lit. ‘as if ’), see Maschler 2001 and Chapter 4, respectively. 12. “The question mark (?) indicates a class of intonation contours whose transitional continuity is regularly understood as an appeal [...] ‘Appeal’ here refers to when a speaker, in producing an utterance, overtly seeks a validating response from a listener” (Du Bois et al.€1992: 30).
Metalanguage in Interaction
38, 39) to dofek (‘is hitting’, present imperfective, line 46). Thus, this nu was indeed interpreted as a request to move on to the following episode of the narrative. Another such move can be seen in excerpt 3, line 70, when Tali’s nu? occurs at the boundary between Yosi’s complication (Chafe 1994) describing his hastening of the cashier (lines 68–69) and the climax (Chafe 1994) of the story (lines 73–76) revealing the identity of the place–a sex shop. In fact, nu here can be seen as a direct response to the well known evaluative strategy of delaying the point of a narrative (Labov 1972), thereby increasing audience involvement. This use of nu is reminiscent of the use described by Sorjonen for Finnish nii: [T]he utterance to which nii(n) responds forms a place of maximum incompleteness. That is, the speaker has reached a place in her talk after which the delivery of a point of the activity is imminent. Before proceeding to the point she momentarily stops her talk, thereby yielding a place for a possible response by the recipient (202: 183).
However, Sorjonen does not discuss the interpersonal dimension of this momentary stop preceding the use of nii. The nu of excerpt 3, line 70 shows a particularly high degree of interpersonal involvement partly due to the iconicity (Becker 1982) it reveals: Tali’s impatience in the interaction, concerning getting to the story’s point, mirrors Yosi’s impatience in the storyworld, concerning discovering the identity of the place. One more example is, of course, the one opening this chapter. Ran’s nu (excerpt 1, line 41) is uttered precisely at the end of Orna’s episode describing how the first of five women dropped out of the diving course on the first day: nish'àrnu 'árba banot... to... tóv! (‘we were left four girls... al... alright!’, lines 38–40). Following Ran’s metalingual comment (lines 41–45) which begins with nu, Orna proceeds to the next episode, describing the second day of the course (lines 46–7). It is in this sense that nu can reflect a high degree of interpersonal involvement between speaker and hearer. By exhibiting their impatience in moving towards the climax of a story–to the point of taking the liberty to control the flow of another’s discourse–hearers can show maximal involvement in the narrative. This is another aspect of the Israeli dugri (‘direct’) way of speaking (Katriel 1986), an aspect which may be paraphrased in the following manner: ‘we are so close, that not only can I tell you things without worrying too much about your positive face wants (Brown and Levinson [1978] 1987, Katriel 1986, Blum-Kulka 1992), I also don’t have to waste too much time on your negative face wants and can thus take the liberty to speed up the flow of your talk’. Within this frame (Goffman 1981), impatience contributes positively to the interaction, rather than being interpreted as impolite, because it is viewed as indicative of the audience’s high involvement in the talk.
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
This is in agreement with previous studies of the high degree of interpersonal involvement in Israeli discourse (Blum-Kulka and Katriel 1991, Maschler 1994a, Blum-Kulka 1997), and it is similar to the positive functioning of overlaps (Tannen 1984) and argumentativeness (Schiffrin 1984) in the talk of Jewish Americans of East European background. The parallelism is particularly apparent in the case of overlap, because overlap and employment of nu can be viewed as two diametrically opposed strategies: in the strategy of overlap, the hearer takes the liberty to begin his or her talk without waiting for a transition relevance place which is to follow the turn constructional unit being produced (Sacks, Schegloff, and Jefferson 1974). In the case of nu, the hearer not only gives up the floor, but also takes the liberty to hasten the speaker upon reaching a transition relevance place13, indicating that the speaker should go on. In both cases there is an attempt to control the flow of discourse. In the former case–in order to grab the floor, in the latter–in order to hasten the other’s occupying of it. 4.2
Urging further development within a non-narrational topic
As an example of nu in non-narrational discourse, examine excerpt 7 from the argumentative genre–a family dinner conversation between two parents, their son, Gabi, and daughter, Shani, both in their early twenties. The context here is a political argument between father and son, following the peace agreement signed between Israel and Jordan in 1994. Excerpt 7 (‘Political Argument’): 20 Gabi: .... 'atá lò maskím 'iti, you don’t agree with me, 21
.. shehaheském hateritoryali, that the agreement the territorial, that the territorial agreement,
22
'im yardén, with Jordan,
23
hu mutsláx? is successful is good?
13. This transition relevance place, however, is not necessarily a complex transition relevance place (a ‘CTRP’, Ford and Thompson 1996), because intonation can be non-final at this point (see below).
Metalanguage in Interaction
24 Father: ... 'ìm 'anì lo maskim 'itxá, if I don’t agree with you, 25 Shani:
todá. {to Mother, concerning the food being served} thank you.
26 Father: .... 'ìm 'anì lo maskim 'itxá, if I don’t agree with you, 27
... 'ata titén li lehagìd 'et da'ati? you will let me say my opinion will you let me express my opinion?
28 Gabi:
... /rak / tipa ki 'ani lo yaxol /????????/. /just/ a bit because I can’t /????????/.
29
.. 'avál, but,
30
.... 'ata maskím 'iti, you agree with me do you agree with me,
31
.. shehaheském hateritoryali, that the agreement the territorial, that the territorial agreement,
32
'im yardén, with Jordan,
33
hu-is
34 Father: ló. no. 35
'eh.. /tir'e/, uh.. look,
36
.. 'ani lò maskím 'itxa! I don’t agree with you!
37
.. 'amárti lexa, I’ve told you, láma lo. why not.
38 Gabi:
'ata kól pa'am sho'èl 'oti, you every time ask me,
39 Father:
40
'et 'otá
sh
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
the same qu
41
.. ló maskìm. don’t agree.
shshsh--
42 Mother:
láma hu lo mutslàx? why it’s not successful why isn’t it good?
43 Gabi:
'ani ló sovèlet, I can’t stand [it],
44 Mother: 45
..she/'anaxnu tso'akím bamitbax/. that /we scream in the kitchen/. 'ani 'asbír lexa, I’ll explain to you,
46 Father: 47
làma ló. why not.
... nú.
48 Gabi:
49 Father: ... xaké! wait!
50 Gabi:
51
... nu, tasbír! explain!
52 Father: ... 'áleph, a {first letter of Hebrew alphabet}, 53 54 Gabi:
...... 'im if 'ata 'omèr leshem havikúax? [are] you saying [this] for the sake of the argument?
55 Father: ... ló. no. 56 Gabi:
..... nu 'az láma hu lo mutslàx. nu so why it not successful nu so why isn’t it good.
57 Father: .... mipney she, because,
Metalanguage in Interaction
Already at the beginning of this excerpt we learn that this is not these speakers’ first political argument and that the father feels his son doesn’t allow him to express himself (lines 26–27). At line 38 and then again at line 43, the son, Gabi, asks his father why he views the peace agreement with Jordan as lo mutslax (‘not successful’) or ‘not good’. The father answers announcing in a rather patronizing way that he will explain to him why the agreement is not a good one: 'ani 'asbír lexa, làma ló. (‘I’ll explain to you, why not’, lines 46–47). Perhaps as a response to this patronizing tone, at line 48, employing nu, Gabi urges his father to get on with the argument. But unlike the cases above, this particular urging to move on in the development of the topic does not serve to move the discourse forward. On the contrary; the father pauses even further in his argument and orders his son: xake! (‘wait!’, line 49). In the previous Section (4.1.1), we have seen that in casual Hebrew conversation, it is acceptable for one to attempt to control the flow of another’s discourse by hastening the speaker, as long as it is clear that this is done in the name of genuine enthusiasm concerning his or her talk. When a participant takes the liberty of controlling another’s flow of discourse, a momentary inequality between participants is created in the interaction. In the argumentative context, such a move is more likely to be perceived as ‘be done with your argument already, so that we can get to my turn finally’. In such contexts, an attempt to control the other speaker’s talk may well be perceived negatively, and the nu may be destructive to the flow of talk. The speaker might decide to pause purposely and make the urging participant wait even longer, in protest of this hastening. This is precisely what happens in the present interaction. Note the minor dueling over who will get to control the flow of discourse in the exchange at lines 48–51. Gabi does not accept his father’s order to wait, and once more attempts to control the situation with an elaborated rephrasal of line 48: nu, tasbir! (‘nu, explain!’, lines 50–51), explicitly mentioning, via the metalingual verb tasbir (‘explain’), the action which nu hastens. We are now in a position to understand the infrequent employment of nu in the talk of student to teacher in classroom discourse. Nu is highly inappropriate in this context not only because this is a relatively formal situation, but particularly because the student is perceived as attempting to control the discourse flow of a participant quite higher than him/her in status. On the other hand, the frequency of nu in the discourse of parents to their young children can be explained by the parents’ higher status relative to the child and the informality of the situation. Thus we see that the nature of the interaction can mitigate those aspects of nu related to impoliteness. While nu usually does carry an impolite aura, at least in speakers’ metalinguistic awareness, this aura is often neutralized by the nature of the interaction and the relationship between its participants. Whether or not nu is perceived as impolite and functions to obstruct the flow of talk depends on the
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
genre and the general context of the interaction. Interpretation of nu, then, is an emergent phenomenon, shaped by a variety of contextual constraints. 4.3
Nu as a continuer
In discussing English uh huh, yeah, mm hm and the like, Schegloff writes that a continuer is a minimal vocalization exhibit[ing...] an understanding that an extended unit of talk is underway by another, and that it is not yet [...] complete. It takes the stance that the speaker of that extended unit should continue talking, and in that continued talking should continue that extended unit. [It] exhibit[s] this understanding, and take[s] this stance, precisely by passing an opportunity to produce a full turn at talk. (1982:€81).
This characterization of a ‘continuer’ fits nu with some modification: nu involves not only taking the stance that the speaker should continue talking, but actively urging the speaker to do so. The extended unit of talk underway can vary in size from a single prosodic sentence14 to a whole narrative. One Hebrew continuer is ken (‘yeah’), the most common interpersonal discourse marker throughout the database (over 240 tokens). Indeed, the functions of ken and nu show some overlap, as can be seen from the following non-narrational excerpt. This is a conversation between David, Avner, and myself. A certain degree of tension exists between Avner and David throughout this interaction, resulting from their different attitudes towards patriotism, about which I have written elsewhere (Maschler 1997a). About half an hour into the beginning of this dinnertable conversation, David summarizes why he wanted to go into an army pilot training course after high school: Excerpt 8 (‘Pilot Training’): 1 David: ... bekìtsur 'anáxnu hayinu patriyotim, in short we were patriots, 2 Yael:
.... kén? yes?
3 Avner: .... nu--?
4 David: ... vekulà--nu ratsinu lihyot kraviyí--m, and we all wanted to be battle unit [soldiers], 14. A prosodic sentence is defined by Chafe (1994:€137–145) as an intonation unit, or a group of successive intonation units separated by continuing intonation, ending in sentence-final intonation. Chafe observes that once a speaker judges that the scanning of a center of interest (such as a sub-episode in a story-episode) has been completed, s/he expresses that judgment with a sentence-final intonation contour.
Metalanguage in Interaction
5
.. ve--'éx ze holex hayom, and how it goes today and how does it go these days,
6
.. be--xèl 'avir kulám harey holxim, in force air everybody PART. goes to the air force, as you know, everybody goes,
7
.. ma, .. what [do you mean],
8
ze--.. ze.. kavòd gadó--l. it it honor great it’s.. it’s.. a great honor.
David ends intonation unit 1 with continuing intonation. He pauses for a period which both Avner and I judge to be too long, and we both employ continuers at precisely the same moment (manifesting what Erickson and Shultz (1982) call rhythmic synchrony). I employ the continuer ken? (line 2), and Avner employs nu? (line 3), both in appeal intonation. David then continues his utterance in the following lines, ending his prosodic sentence at line 8. In this instance, then, nu functions as a continuer, overlapping one of the uses of ken. However, the nature of the interaction between Avner and David results in the flavor of Avner’s continuer being not only ‘I’m listening, go on’, as in the case of my ken?, but also ‘go on, let’s hear what you’ve now got to say’. Nu, however, can be employed as a continuer even when no particular tension in the discourse is involved, as in the following narrative in which a young man begins to tell two women friends about a revelation he had concerning the type of woman he liked: Excerpt 9 (‘Women’): 134 Eyal: .. li, to me, 135
.. ze karà pa'am 'axát, it happened one time,
136
.. kshehayiti be'ey--ze kontsért, when I was at some concert,
137 Yafit:
.... nu.
138 Eyal:
be'avonotáy. in [all] my sins to my shame.
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
Eyal begins to tell a story that took place when he went to some concert. He ends intonation unit 136, the orientation to his narrative, in continuing intonation and pauses for longer than average (indicated by 4 dots at line 137). A point of incompletion is thus achieved. Yafit judges this pause to be ‘too long’, at which point she employs nu as a continuer: she displays her understanding that a larger discourse unit (a prosodic sentence in this case) is underway, and urges Eyal to continue its production. Eyal indeed continues and adds be'avonotáy (lit., ‘in [all] my sins’), a formulaic phrase roughly equivalent to English ‘to my shame’, only then ending in sentence-final intonation (line 138). Going to a concert is apparently not a ‘cool’ thing to do among members of this social group, and Eyal jokingly admits to having performed this ‘shameful’ deed. His narrative continues in a light key, with no tension between participants throughout the interaction. This use of nu as a continuer, then, carries a neutral flavor, unlike the one of excerpt 8. Another typical place for the continuer nu is right after an initial conditional clause. The following excerpt comes from a conversation between three male students in their early twenties arguing over the quality of their departmental newspaper. Here they compare this newspaper (called perspektivi,‘Perspectival’) to the newspaper edited by the university’s student union (called pesek zman ‘Time Out’). The latter newspaper’s readers are compared to the readers of Bazuka gum wrappers: Excerpt 10 (‘Departmental Newspaper’): 122 Yoni: ... 'ím 'ata ben 'adà--m, if you[’re a] person, 123
shel 'e--h, of u--h,
124
... sheyésh’xa koax lashèvet, that there is to you energy to sit, that you have the energy to sit,
125
velikró, and to read,
126
velehit'amék, and to go deeply [into things],
127
... 'az 'ata tikrà perspektívi. then you’ll read Perspectival.
128 Ido:
ha.. ha'idiot hax the the idiot the most the bi[ggest] idiot
Metalanguage in Interaction
'aval 'ím 'ata ben 'adàm, but if you[’re a] person,
129 Yoni: 130
shekore bazúka, who reads Bazuka,
131 Avner:
nú.
132 Yoni:
.. 'ata tikrà pesek zmán. you’ll read Time Out.
Avner employs his continuer immediately following Yoni’s second conditional clause 'aval 'ím 'ata ben 'adàm, shekore bazúka, (‘but if you’re a person, who reads Bazuka’, lines 129–130). Yoni pauses just slightly past this conditional clause–long enough for Avner’s continuer, which in fact overlaps the beginning of Yoni’s ‘then’clause 'ata tikrà pesek zmán. (‘you’ll read pesek zman’, line 132). Note that Avner does not employ nu between the two clauses of the first conditional sentence in this excerpt (lines 122–127), even though there is actually a longer pause between these two clauses (line 127) in comparison to the barely audible pause in line 132. We have here a parallel construction of two conditional sentences, contrasted by 'aval (‘but’), whose ‘if ’-clauses both open with the formula 'ím 'ata ben 'adàm, she (‘if you’re a person, who’) and whose ‘then’-clauses both open with ['az]'ata tikrà ((‘then) you’ll read’). This parallelism makes a strong projection that the end of this rather long figure is approaching, as well as a projection concerning what its ending might be. Avner and Yoni are on the same side in this argument–they both think the departmental newspaper is of high quality, while the student union’s paper is not (Ido is the one who thinks less highly of it). Thus, Avner’s nu urging Yoni at line 131 is neutral; it is not prompted by any particular tension between himself and the person he is hastening, as was the case in excerpt 8, but rather by a projection of the end of a rather long figure15. Previous studies (e.g., Haiman 1978, Schiffrin 1992, Ford 1993) document the function of conditionals in presenting given information. In her study of adverbial clauses in American English conversation, Ford writes that initial adverbial 15. However, the 7 tokens of nu throughout the three-minute male interaction from which excerpt 13 is taken are one of many factors contributing to its somewhat more rough nature, placing this conversation closer to a ‘masculine’ end of a continuum of discourse styles as a function of gender (Coates 1997). This is particularly so because employment of this token of nu between two clauses of a conditional sentence–a likely place for the strategy of co-construction (Lerner 1991) or co-production (Ferrara 1992), and particularly within the parallel construction we have seen above–comes at the expense of employing this latter collaborative strategy. This is one of the features placing this conversation closer to a ‘masculine’ end of a continuum of discourse styles, in which participants assume less collaborative footings (Goffman 1981) towards each other (Maltz and Borker 1982, Tannen 1990, 1999).
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
clauses, and initial conditional clauses in particular, “form pivotal points in the development of talk and present explicit background for material that follows” (1993:€62). This would motivate the function of nu to urge further development of the (‘new’) topic in excerpt 10, particularly in this double contrastive conditional, where the second initial conditional is ‘given’ not only because of its initial position, but also because of its contrast with the previous conditional clause. Ford also writes that “ordering an adverbial clause before its main clause insures that no point of possible completion will be reached before the entire complex is delivered” (ibid.: 52). Nu between the adverbial and main clauses can be viewed as the interlocutor’s response to this strategy: nu hastens precisely that part of the utterance that presents the ‘given’ background and is there to delay reaching a point of possible completion. Nu, then, can be a response to two types of delay on the part of the speaker–delaying the point of a narrative (Section 4.1.1) or delay in reaching a point of possible completion, further supporting its characterization as a marker of impatience. Clancy et al. define a reactive token as “a short utterance produced by an interlocutor who is playing a listener’s role during the other interlocutor’s speakership. That is, reactive tokens will normally not disrupt the primary speaker’s speakership, and do not in themselves claim the floor” (1996:€356). They further subcategorize reactive tokens into four groups, one of which is the backchannels–a nonlexical vocalic form, serving as “a ‘continuer’ (Schegloff 1982), display of interest, or claim of understanding” (Clancy et al. 1996:€359). This is relevant to those instances of neutral nu functioning as continuers, as seen in the last two excerpts. Clancy et al. compared reactive tokens in English, Japanese, and Mandarin, showing that these languages differ in the reactive tokens they favor and in their frequency and distribution in conversation. The goal of their study was “to examine the communicative strategies in each language with respect to culture-specific expectations about the degree of interaction that the non-primary speaker will engage in”. None of the languages investigated in their study manifest a reactive token similar to nu. We have seen that in Hebrew discourse, there are culturespecific expectations about a relatively high degree of interaction that the nonprimary speaker will engage in, to the point of allowing this non-primary speaker to attempt to control the flow of the primary speaker’s talk. 4.4
Summary of the ‘urging further development of topic’ function
The majority of nu tokens in this database, then, are employed in order to urge a speaker to move on in the development of a topic. This can be done in both narrational and non-narrational topics, at discourse unit boundaries of various hierarchical levels, from a prosodic sentence to a whole narrative. We saw that the
Metalanguage in Interaction
general impolite aura accompanying nu in speakers’ metalinguistic awareness can be neutralized by the nature of the interaction and the relationship between its participants. In fact, the impatience exhibited by nu is often a sign of high involvement and enthusiasm. Finally, we saw that this type of nu can be characterized as a continuer, except that rather than just “taking the stance that the speaker should continue talking” (Schegloff 1982), nu actively urges it. 5. Granting permission to perform an action Another function of nu, not nearly as common as the function described in Section 4, is that of granting permission to perform some action. This ‘allowing’ of some action, usually verbal, is often done somewhat reluctantly. Only 2.6% of all tokens throughout the database function in this role. The following excerpt supplies two examples. This is a conversation between a young woman in her early twenties, Orna, and her parents. The mother is telling a story which is interrupted at line 193 by the father suddenly making a comment concerning the tape recorder: Excerpt 11 (‘Family Gossip’): 192 Mother: .. mà 'ód hu 'amar, what else he said what else did he say, tagídi, tell (fem. sg.) me,
193 Father: 194
.. 'at hexláft po batarìya? you changed here battery did you change batteries here?
195 Orna:
.. ló. no.
196 Father: ... 'át yoda'at shehadavàr haze 'ovéd you know that the thing the this works you know that this thing works 197
.... 'ani ganávti 'et ze--, I stole this,
198 Mother:
'ani be'émtsa mishpàt. I[‘m] in [the] middle of [a] sentence.
199 Orna:
'ima be'émtsa Mom[‘s] in [the] middle of
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
200
{laughter}
201 Mother: .. 'ani mishtagá'at mimxa! I’m going crazy from you you’re driving me crazy! tòv 'aval ze norá xashuv, okay but it’s terribly important,
202 Father: 203
ladá'at 'et ze. to know this.
204 Orna:
{laughter}
205 Father:
{laughter}
206
... beshiv'ím veshmòne, in seventy eight,
207
ganàvti 'et ze mimé'ir 'adív, I stole this from Meir Adiv,
208
.. meshumásh. used.
209 Orna:
... tizahér hakol maklitím po, be careful everything is being recorded here,
210
.. 'ába. Dad.
211
{laughter}
212 Father: ... ga I st 213
.. ganavti bemerxa'ót. I stole in quotation marks.
214 Orna:
{laughter}
215 Mother: ... 'at shomá'at? you (fem. sg.) hear do you hear what I’m saying? 216 Orna:
nu.
217 Father:
hish'árti lo 'et hamaxshev sheli 'al hashulxan. I left him the computer mine on the table I left him my computer on the table.
218 Orna:
'ába, Dad,
Metalanguage in Interaction
219
.. 'ima hayta be'èmtsa mishpát! Mom was in [the] middle of [a] sentence!
220 Father: ... nú. 221 Mother: ... 'az hu 'amàr la shehi 'itít, so he told her that she is slow so he told her she was slow, In all of the excerpts of Section 4, nu was employed as a first pair part of an adjacency pair (Schegloff and Sacks 1973). In Excerpt 11, nu is used as a second pair part. Rather than initiate a new move, a return to the main topic, each of the two nu tokens in this excerpt responds to an utterance which itself initiated a new move. In line 215 Orna’s mother addresses her daughter with 'at shoma'at? (lit., ‘you (fem. sg.) hear?’ or ‘do you hear what I’m saying?’). This is a pre-pre (Schegloff 1980), as the mother here requests her daughter’s cooperation in getting back to the story despite her husband’s interruption. Orna responds to this pre-pre with a nu (line 216) granting the mother permission to go on with the story, i.e., as a goahead token (Schegloff 1990). However, the father overlaps this nu with a continuation of his justification for having ‘stolen’ the tape recorder back in 1978–in return, he left his own computer for the person whose tape recorder he ‘stole’ (line 217). This further attempt to make himself look better is interrupted by Orna’s objection, a partial repetition of lines 198–199 earlier: 'aba, 'ima hayta be'emtsa mishpat! (‘Dad, Mom was in the middle of a sentence!’, lines 218–219). This objection functions also as the daughter’s request (and thus, first pair part) that her father stop interrupting and let her mother go on with the telling. The father agrees to this somewhat reluctantly, as the prosody of line 220 suggests, with another nu in second position, responding to Orna’s first pair part of lines 218–219, and allowing the mother to continue her story, as she indeed does at line 221. Although relatively few tokens of nu function in this role in the corpus, family discourse in which young children are present (a context abundant with pre-pre’s, as Sacks (1972) has shown) often manifests such uses of nu, as, for example, in the following interaction between my then nine-year-old daughter and myself: Excerpt 12 (‘Ballet’): 1 Maya: ... 'ima, Mom, 2
... yesh li she'ela. there is to me question I have a question.
3 Mother: ...nu.{impatiently, in the midst of preparations for leaving the house}
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
4 Maya: ... 'ani lo yoda'at ma la'asot, I don’t know what to do, 5
... ki, because,
6
.. 'im 'ani 'eshan 'etsel hadasi, if I sleep over at Hadasi’s,
7
.. 'ani 'etstarex lehafsid, I’ll have to miss,
8
shi'ur balet. lesson ballet [my] ballet lesson.
Again we find a pre-pre (Maya’s announcing her upcoming question, lines 1–2). The tone of my nu (line 3) is rather impatient, and allows her to proceed with the requested act somewhat reluctantly, thus functioning as a go-ahead token. Unlike the impatience in most of the previous excerpts, here it is definitely not genuine interest in the topic that motivates the tone. In this instance, we might tie the impatience to the rush in the midst of which this utterance occurred, but many such nu tokens are found in our family’s discourse when no special rush is involved. This use of nu is very similar to the use of Finnish no described by Sorjonen: [A]s a turn of its own no typically provides a response to coparticipant’s prior utterance that acts as a preliminary (pre) to something else yet to come [...] The particle no offers a second pair part to the preliminary: it provides a ‘go-ahead’ response (Schegloff 1990:€61), that is, it invites the coparticipant to get on with the production of the main action. (2002:€166–167).
The adjustment I would suggest for Israeli discourse is that rather than inviting the coparticipant to get on with the talk, nu allows it, and often rather reluctantly. Thus, while Finnish employs two different particles, one–nii(n)–urging further development within the topic, the other–no–functioning as a ‘go-ahead’ token, in Hebrew, a single utterance–nu (originating probably from the same Germanic source as the two Finnish particles)–performs both functions. Lines 43–53 from excerpt 7 are telling for understanding how it might come about that a single form will come to be used in these two functions. The nu of line 48 is a borderline case between urging further development within a main topic and granting permission to perform an action. If lines 46–47 'ani 'asbír lexa, làma ló. (‘I’ll explain to you, why not.’) are viewed as a response (and, therefore, a second pair part) to line 43 láma hu lo mutslàx? (‘why isn’t it [the peace agreement with Jordan] good?’), then the nu of line 48 can be viewed as a first pair part of the following sequence, in which Gabi is urging his father to go on with the explanation.
Metalanguage in Interaction
But if we view lines 46–47 as beginning something new, rather than as responding to line 43 (and the mother’s comment at lines 44–45 can certainly be said to break the continuity of the previous sequence), then 'ani 'asbír lexa, làma ló. (‘I’ll explain to you, why not.’) can be viewed as a pre-pre. We have seen that nu granting permission to perform an action generally occurs in response to a pre-pre, and often reluctantly so. Viewed this way, the nu at line 48 can be interpreted as a very reluctant granting of permission by the son to his father to proceed with his explanation. It is these ambiguous cases that constitute transitional examples between the function of nu to urge further development of a topic and the function of granting permission to perform an action. 6. Summary of sequential functions of nu All of the functions of nu seen so far in Sections 3, 4, and 5, have to do with moving the (verbal) action along, and thus have sequential implications. I would like to suggest a continuum of ‘degree of encouragement to proceed with action’ along which this discourse marker could be described. The continuum includes (from ‘most encouraging’ to ‘least encouraging’): hastening, urging, granting permission, allowing, and allowing reluctantly, and it involves both metalingual and nonmetalingual actions. All of the tokens of nu examined thus far fall at various points along this continuum. 7. Keying functions of nu: joking/provoking In sharp contrast to the previous three categories, which all have to do with sequential functions, the fourth category, consisting of about 23.5% of all nu tokens, has to do with the notion of key. Structurally, what is common to these tokens is that they are always followed by additional talk of the same speaker, very often within the same intonation unit. This additional talk does not specify an action being urged (as in excerpt 3, for instance). Keying nu adds a joking or provoking tone to the following utterance and it often involves some resultative meaning. Excerpt 2, line 128 constitutes such an example. At 126 David declares somewhat dramatically: 'axsháv nit'am mehamara/ve/k. (‘now we’ll taste the soup’). At line 127 he proceeds to taste it, after which Dalia asks nu 'éx yatsa? (‘nu how did it come out?’, line 128). Dalia’s question is a result of David’s declaration of the action he was about to engage in and of his actual tasting of the soup. Nu adds a joking tone to Dalia’s utterance, perhaps in response to David’s dramatic declaration of this rather mundane act.
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
7.1
From joking to provoking
A clearer example of the joking key is found in excerpt 13. Shani constructs here an utterance which was said upon the descent of her boyfriend, Shaxar, her father, and herself from an approximately $80,000 new jeep of a friend: Excerpt 13 (‘Jeep’): 122 Shani: ... basof sháxar /??? / in the end Shaxar /??????/ 123
'e--h yarádnu, uh we came down [from the jeep],
124
.. 'az 'ába sheli 'omèr leshaxar, so father my says to Shaxar so my father says to Shaxar,
125
.. nu mat'ím lexa jìp kazè? nu suits to you jeep like this nu does a jeep like this suit you?
126
.. 'az /ab/ shàxar 'osé lo, so /my f/ Shaxar does to him so /my f/ Shaxar goes,
127
ló! no!
128 Dalia: {laughter} 129 Shani: {laughter} 130
... ka'éle xamudìm, like these cute so cute,
131
.. ya 'ála! boy!
The joking key originates from the fact that it is evident to all that such a jeep is way beyond Shaxar’s means. Without this nu, it would have been possible to ask Shaxar seriously whether such a jeep suited him. Following this utterance, Shani tells (line 126) that Shaxar responded to this question in the same joking key lo! (‘no!’, line 127), i.e., that such a jeep does not suit him, both women laugh at the telling of this short interchange, and Shani concludes with an evaluation of her boyfriend and her father: ka'éle xamudìm, ya 'ála! (‘so cute, boy!’)–all further supporting the joking reading of this excerpt. The resultative meaning comes from the
Metalanguage in Interaction
fact that her father’s question is relevant as a result of the fact verbalized in the preceding utterance (line 123)–that they had just descended from this jeep. The boundary between joking and provoking is, of course, not always clear. In the following conversation, which took place the morning after a party, Amir is telling his girlfriend Tami about the breakup of another couple: Excerpt 14 (‘Breaking Up’): 19 Tami: .. hu nifràd midalít? he broke up from Dalit? ken. yeah.
20 Amir: 21 Tami: .... 'ani lò ma'aminá. I don’t believe I can’t believe it. 22 Amir: ... nu ma xashávt, nu what did you think, 23
shehu bá 'etmòl e--h, that he came yesterday u--h,
24
.... levád, on his own,
25
.. ki bá lo? because came to him because he felt like it?
Amir is half mocking, half ridiculing Tami for not having understood why the man came to the party unaccompanied by his girlfriend Dalit. He does so by employing the utterance nu ma xashavt (‘nu what did you think’, line 22) followed by the ridiculous interpretation of the event, that the man showed up at the party on his own because he happened to feel like it (lines 23–25). Nu allows Amir to construct this partly mocking, partly ridiculing tone. The doubt concerning whether the key is mocking or ridiculing/provoking, is no longer apparent in the case of the political argument of excerpt 7, when Gabi asks his father nu 'az láma hu lo mutslàx (‘nu so why isn’t it good’, line 56 ), about the peace agreement with Jordan, following the dueling over who will get to control the flow of discourse (lines 48–51). The general tone of the conversation at that point indicates that we are no longer dealing with mocking or even with ridiculing. A provocation, quite disrespectful, is at issue. The resultative meaning is constructed here also by the discourse marker 'az (‘so’), but the disrespect is provided not by 'az, but rather by the nu, as well as by the prosodic elements of the utterance.
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
We have seen that the nature of the interaction and the relationship between its participants determines whether or not the impatience exhibited by nu is perceived as impolite, and whether or not the continuer nu functions neutrally. Similarly, whether keying nu functions jokingly or provocatively is also a matter of the context in which it is employed. In the present corpus, out of the 27 tokens of this type of nu, 12 are employed in a joking key whereas 15 are used provocatively. This suggests a characterization of Israeli humor; namely, that the boundary between humor and provocativeness in this culture is elusive and blurry. However, more study is needed in order to support this claim. 7.2
Nu in combination with other discourse markers
Keying nu often occurs in conjunction with other discourse markers. In this database, it is found most frequently (in 8 out of 27 keying tokens) with 'az (‘so’) (supporting the resultative meaning frequently involved in its use), as well as with betax (‘sure, of course’), bexayex (‘come on’, lit. ‘in your life’), and ve- (‘and’). Another common cluster is nu be'emet (‘nu really’), though it is not found in the present database16. Nu is almost always the first member of these discourse marker clusters. I elaborate here on only one combination, because it is particularly relevant to the interpersonal function of nu. 7.2.1 Nu in combination with 'az ma? (‘so what?’) The idiom 'az ma? is the Israeli version of the much-discussed ‘so what?’ question (Labov 1972:€366). As Labov has noted in relation to narratives (and as Tannen (1989) has observed in relation to non-narrational discourse), this question is the worst response to be encountered by a storyteller upon ending their story. Much of what conversationalists do is ward off this question by continually employing involvement creating strategies throughout their talk. The ‘so what?’ question is accompanied by an additional threat for the Israeli storyteller. The Israeli hearer might not only wonder about the worthiness of the telling. This hearer might also take the opportunity to mock/ridicule/provoke/act derogatorily towards the speaker for not having considered this matter beforehand. This additional tone is what nu provides when added to the 'az ma? question, as, for example, in the continuation of excerpt 3:
16. Surprisingly, Maschler and Estlein 2008 found only one instance of this cluster in the extended corpus, comprised of 91 conversations (270 minutes of talk among 223 different speakers), adding 41 conversations to the present corpus.
Metalanguage in Interaction
Excerpt 3a (continued) (‘Cashiers’): 73 Yosi: ... 'az hi 'oméret, so she says, 74
.. tishmá, {Â�Â�Â�Â�---pp---} listen,
75
.... lakxú 'otanu, {-------pp----------} they took us,
76
lexanùt le'avizarèy mín. {--------pp---------} {----laughing-----} to a store for accessories of sex to a sex shop.
77
{laughter}
78 Tali:
{laughter}
79
... habe'alím shelahem? the husbands theirs their husbands?
80 Yosi:
.... habe'a the husb
81
.. habe'alím, the husbands,
82
.. 'o ha'áx shel habà'al, or the brother of the husband,
83
.. /???????/.
84
{laughter}
85 Tali:
{laughter}
86 Yosi:
... 'ani 'omér, {laughing} I say,
87
.. nú, {laughing}
88
.. 'az má--, {laughing} so what,
.. yófi--!
89
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
{laughing} great!
90
... hi 'oméret li, she says to me,
91
.. 'aval hadór shelí, {imitating cashier’s talk (Russian accent?)} but the generation mine but my generation,
92
.. shonè legámre--y! {imitating cashier’s talk (Russian accent?)} different completely is completely different!
93
... /???? holex lesham/. {imitating cashier’s talk (Russian accent?)}
/???? goes there/.
94
.. 'az nú, so nu,
95
.. 'az hirgàsht tse'irá, so you felt young,
96
.. 'az má yesh. {laughing} so what is there so what’s the big deal.
97
{laughter}
98 Tali:
{laughter}
We have already seen that Yosi views these cashiers’ bashful attitude towards sex shops as ridiculous. After recounting the cashier’s revealing of the identity of the place to him, and after much laughter on the part of both Yosi and his wife, Yosi proceeds to recount his response to the cashier (lines 86–89): 'ani 'omér, nu, 'az ma, yofi! (‘I say, nu, so what, great!’). This is an explicit instance of the dreaded ‘so what?’ question, ornamented by the extra ridiculing tone provided by nu. After reporting the cashier’s objection to this unimpressed and ridiculing response, saying (in what sounds like a poor imitation of perhaps a Russian accent) that in her generation things are different (lines 90–93), Yosi recounts (back in his own voice) his further belittlement of the point of the cashier’s story: 'az nú, 'az hirgàsht tse'irá, 'az má yesh. (‘so nu, so you felt young, so what’s the big deal’).
Metalanguage in Interaction
The occurrence of nu in conjunction with the ‘so what?’ question is related, of course, to the fact that nu is often employed at points of maximal incompleteness, such as right before the climax of a narrative in response to the storyteller’s delay of the delivery of the point, as illustrated in excerpt 3, line 70. Nu preceding the ‘so what?’ question is, in fact, the mirror image of nu immediately preceding the climax of a narrative, because it is employed immediately following the climax, and rather than exhibiting enthusiasm, it communicates a lack of enthusiasm concerning the point. 8. Grammaticization of nu We have seen that nu is the second most common interpersonal discourse marker throughout the database, and that speakers in this corpus employ nu most frequently (in 68.7% of the cases) in order to urge further development of an ongoing topic. This suggests that part of the Israeli discourse experience is to allow a fairly high degree of impatience in casual interaction. Impatience is manifested in hearers’ attempts to speed up the flow of their interlocutors’ discourse. However, despite the impolite aura nu carries in Israelis’ metalinguistic awareness, the impatience constructed by this discourse marker in Hebrew casual conversation is not necessarily perceived negatively. Quite the contrary. We have seen that impatience is most often interpreted in this corpus as indicative of the audience’s high involvement in the speaker’s talk. By exhibiting their impatience in moving forward in a topic–to the point of attempting to control the flow of another’s discourse via nu–hearers show maximal involvement in the talk. Thus, the nature of the interaction and the relationship among its participants can neutralize the impolite aura often associated with nu. In this way, its meaning is emergent from the discourse. We have also seen that of the four main functions of the discourse marker nu, three have to do with moving the (verbal) action along, and thus involve the sequential aspect of talk: hastening non-verbal actions, urging further development within a topic, and granting permission to perform an action. The fourth function has to do with key; namely, providing a joking/provoking tone. I have already related to the functional itinerary (Traugott 1995a) of nu with respect to the first three functions. Of course, without a corpus providing diachronic perspective (as in Traugott 1989 or Traugott and Dasher 2002, e.g.), the path of development of nu can only be hypothesized. I suggested the primacy of nu as a hastener of non-verbal actions. The one example provided in the dictionary (Avneyon 1997) which is relevant to nu in casual conversation–nu kvar (‘nu already’), hastening mostly non-verbal actions–provides partial support for this, as-
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
suming examples given in dictionaries have something to do with providing representative, basic examples. Certainly, this is the first function learned by children acquiring nu. More support comes from studies of grammaticization, claiming that such processes generally happen in the less metalingual to more metalingual direction (e.g., Sweetser 1988, Traugott 1988), but only external evidence of nu from Yiddish, Russian and earlier periods of Hebrew will clarify this point. We have seen that just as one can be urged to perform a non-verbal action, so can a speaker urge an interlocutor to perform a verbal action. Sequential nu was described along a continuum of ‘degree of encouragement to proceed with action’, moving from ‘most encouraging’ to ‘least encouraging’: hastening, urging, granting permission, allowing, allowing reluctantly. Nu could be described along another continuum–that of key, with joking and acting derogatorily towards addressee on either end, and the additional possibilities (mocking/ridiculing/provoking/ provoking disrespectfully) in between. (These two continua are illustrated schematically by the diagonal lines in Figure 1 below). Thus, nu is ambiguous both with respect to its sequential nature as well as with respect to key. Again, the meaning of a particular token emerges from the context in which it is employed. The question is, how is it that a word involved in encouragement to proceed with an action comes also to have a keying function in discourse? I would like to suggest that the keying function of nu originates in the impolite aura nu may carry in its sequential functions. Attempting to control the actions of another is inherently impolite; indeed in some cases we have seen that nu is accompanied by a derogatory tone (excerpt 7, e.g.). However, when the nature of the interaction neutralizes its inherent impoliteness, the speaker employing nu will often do it humorously (excerpt 1, e.g.). The humor can compensate for the impoliteness sometimes associated with this type of move, and it can also attribute the utterance with a somewhat self-mocking tone, as if saying ‘I know I’m doing something which could, in some contexts, be considered impolite’. To further explain how a token functioning in the sequential realm of discourse comes to function also in its interpersonal realm, we need to posit yet a third continuum along which nu could be described–that of metalanguage (illustrated by the horizontal line in Figure 1). On one of its ends would be nu urging non-metalingual actions (such as in excerpt 2, line 142); on the other would be nu urging metalingual actions via explicit metalingual utterances. The majority of cases fall in between these two ends–urging metalingual actions (mostly, further development of a topic) unaccompanied by a longer metalingual utterance. In other words, sometimes the metalingual utterance is spelled out, as in excerpt 7, lines 50–51: nu, tasbir! (‘nu, explain!’). But more frequently, the metalingual utterance is only implied and is to be gathered from context, as in excerpt 6, line 45: nu?.
Metalanguage in Interaction
This is the case particularly with the tokens in the fourth category; namely, keying nu. The metalingual utterance is seldom spelled out in these instances. For example, the nu of excerpt 13, line 125 nu mat'ím lexa jìp kazè? (‘nu does a jeep like this suit you?) can be interpreted as urging an implied metalingual utterance such as nu tagid li, or nu ma 'ata 'omer, mat'ím lexa jìp kazè? (‘nu tell me’ or ‘nu what do you say, does a jeep like this suit you?’), or the nu of excerpt 3a, lines 94–95 'az nu, 'az hirgasht tse'ira (‘so nu, so you felt young’) can be interpreted as implying a longer metalingual utterance such as 'az nu, ma 'at mitlonenet, 'az hirgasht tse'ira (‘so nu, what are you complaining about, so you felt young’). Other metalingual utterances implied by keying nu tokens found in the corpus are: nu, 'ata lo mevin she... (‘nu, don’t you see that...’), nu, tasik kvar 'et hamaskana (‘nu, draw the conclusion already!’), or even nu 'az tasbir li 'im 'ata yaxol, ve'ani lo ma'amin she'ata yaxol (‘nu so explain to me if you are able to, and I don’t believe you are’) in the political argument of excerpt 7, line 56: nu 'az láma hu lo mutslàx (‘nu so why isn’t it good’). An interaction around our dinnertable supports this suggestion. Yotam, 7 years old at the time, was telling us how he and his friends were cracking unshelled pine nuts with hammers. His 11-year-old sister Maya said that she preferred cracking them with a big stone, because this doesn’t crack the meat inside. To this, Yotam responded in a slightly belittling tone: Excerpt 15 (‘Pine Nuts’): Yotam: nu gam 'im patish ze lo shover. nu also with [a] hammer it doesn’t break [them]. When I asked him why he said nu there, Yotam couldn’t answer the question. Maya, however, said that it was because she didn’t understand that when he had told us about cracking the nuts with a hammer, hu kvar hitkaven shegam 'im patish hem lo nishbarim (‘he had already meant that also with a hammer they don’t break’). In other words, this nu stands for a longer metalingual utterance such as nu 'at lo ro'a she'hitkavanti shegam 'im patish ze lo shover (nu don’t you see that I meant that also with a hammer they don’t break’). Thus, a longer metalingual utterance is implied in her interpretation of this belittling nu token. Figure 1 summarizes the three continua along which nu could be described. Had the keying nu tokens occurred accompanying such explicit metalingual utterances, they might have carried a derogatory, impolite aura, as in excerpt 7, lines 50–51: nu, tasbir! (‘nu, explain!’). Alternatively, their impolite aura could have been neutralized by the nature of the interaction, and a humorous tone could have replaced it, as in many of the nu tokens throughout the data (e.g., excerpt 1, lines 41–44). Accordingly, what is left of these longer metalingual utterances–the nu–embodies only the key, from derogatory to joking; it verbalizes only the tone encompassed by the longer utterance vaguely in the background. Like the smile of
Chapter 2.╇ The interpersonal realm
the Cheshire Cat, then, the keying nu token is all that remains of the longer metalingual utterance implied. In this way, a word functioning in the sequential realm of discourse comes also to have an interpersonal keying function. joking
reluctantly allowing action key
urging nonmetalingual action
nu
metalanguage
urging metalingual action via metalingual utterance
sequentiality hastening action
Figure 1.╇ Nu along the dimensions of sequentiality, key, and metalanguage
derogatory
chapter 3
The textual realm The discourse marker bekitsur: Retroactively constructing digressions
1. Introduction The Hebrew word bekitsur (‘succinctly, in short’) is a Modern Hebrew manner adverb associated with the adjective katsar (‘short’), found already in Biblical texts. Bekitsur is composed of the preposition b(e)- (‘in’, ‘with’)1 attached to the verbal noun2 kitsur (‘doing something in short, shortening’) of the verb lekatser which came to be used only later on, starting in the Talmudic period. Bekitsur is not found as a separate entry in Even-Shoshan’s 2003 dictionary, but in a sub-entry of the adjective katsar (‘short’) it is listed as an equivalent of another manner adverb from the same root, biktsara, a higher-register equivalent of bekitsur (also from the Modern period): lo ba'arixut, bekitsur, bemilim mu'atot (‘not at length, succinctly, in few words’). An example in fairly high register is provided: saper-na biktsara 'ex kara hadavar. A translation might be: ‘pray-tell succinctly how the matter happened’. 1. The adverb bekitsur belongs to a group of adverbs, all composed of the preposition b(e)- attached to a nominal form associated with an adjective, such as: ba'arixut (‘at length’, lit. ‘with length’), bimhirut (‘quickly’, lit. ‘with quickness’), bizrizut (lit. ‘with agility’), be'itiyut (‘slowly’, lit. ‘with slowness’), bixvedut (‘heavily’, lit. ‘with heaviness’), bekalut (‘easily’, lit. ‘with ease’), etc. In fact, prefixing adjectival nouns with the b(e)- morpheme is a productive way of forming adverbs in Hebrew. 2. This verbal noun belongs to the verbal group (binyan) pi'el, which in 3rd person sg. past tense consists of the three verbal root consonants, √k.ts.r., the first two separated by the vowel i, the second two by the vowel e: kitser (masc. sg. past, ‘he lessened, reduced’ (Biblical period), ‘he did something in short’ (Talmudic period), or ‘he shortened’ (Modern period (Enlightenment period and on)). The symbol ts in the middle root consonant (sometimes transcribed as c, as e.g. in Shloush 1998), denotes here the affricate composed of the stop t and the fricative s, which constitutes a single phoneme in Hebrew. Note that the adjective katsar is found already in Biblical Hebrew (though only in the form ktsar-, as the first member of the smixut construction (‘construct state’), e.g., ktsar-yad (lit. ‘short-handed’, ‘weak, incapable of doing things’)), whereas the verb lekatser meaning ‘to shorten’ is not found before the Modern period (Even-Shoshan 2003, Avneyon 1998).
Metalanguage in Interaction
However, in the corpus of 50 casual conversations on which the present study is based, bekitsur is never found to function as an adverb. A typical usage is given in excerpt 1, a conversation between two young women in their early twenties, in which Hanna tells the story of how she was wounded during her army service at the Lebanese border. In the orientation (Labov 1972) to the narrative, she describes what she and her women soldier companions were wearing – heavy equipment which caused her to stumble and “be wounded”: Excerpt 1 (‘Wounded in Lebanon’): 91 Hanna: .. hem 'e--h sàmu 'aleynu shaxpáts. they u--h put on us [a] shaxpats {a type of bullet-proof vest}. 92
... 'aval kavéd kazè, but heavy like3,
93
.. mehaye--shaním. of the old [ones]. of the old kind.
94 Galia: .. max.. matól neged tànkim? {------------laughing-----------} max.. matol {a type of weapon} against tanks? né--shek, [a] gun,
95 Hanna:
96 Galia:
97 Hanna:
{laughter} {laughter}
98
.. né--shek, {---laughing--} [a] gun,
99
... shéva maxsaniyòt mele'òt, seven magazines full seven full magazines,
100 Galia: 101
má 'at 'omèret, what are you saying,
.. she'áf 'axat ló yoda'at lirò--t betax. that no one not knows to shoot probably when no one knows how to shoot probably.
102 Hanna: ... máshehu kazè. something like that. 3.
For a study of Hebrew kaze, one ‘equivalent’ of English like, see Maschler 2001.
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
103
.... xagór, [an] ammunition belt,
104
... sh--téy meymiyòt, two canteens,
105
.. shehayu tsrixót lihiyot, that had to be,
106
.. mele'ót kòl 'axat, full each one full each,
107 Galia:
mhm.
108 Hanna: .. ve--kaplá--d! and [a] kaplad! 109
... kaplá--d! [a] kaplad! ze, it’s,
110 Galia: 111
... má ze kaplád? what[’s a] kaplad?
112 :
kaplád,
113
... ke'ílu, like4,
114
.. kasdá, [a] helmet,
115
.. 'avàl mipladá, but [made out] of steel,
116 Galia:
'áh! oh!
117 Hanna: ... ló ha'ele hakalòt. not the those the light not those light ones. 118 Galia: 119
mhm. ... s.. slixá 'al haburùt. s.. sorry for the ignorance.
4. For the study of Hebrew ke'ilu, another ‘equivalent’ of English like, see Chapter 5.
Metalanguage in Interaction
120 Hanna: ... ló meshane. doesn’t matter never mind. 121
..... bekitsú--r,
122
az 'e so uh
123
... 'e--h, u--h,
124
... baleyló--t, during the nights,
125 ... 'axarey shehayinu mexapsòt lalevanòniyot bayamím, after that we would search the Lebanese (fem.pl.) during the days after we would search the Lebanese women during the days, 126
.... baleylòt hayinu yoshvót 'e--h, during the nights we would sit u--h,
127
ba.. xamál. in the.. xamal {acronym5 for war room}.
Bekitsur of line 121 appears as a separate intonation unit, is not part of any grammatical sentence, and cannot be said to function as an adverb of any verb. It occurs after the rather long orientation describing the equipment Hanna and the women were carrying, which includes a clarification sequence concerning the blending kaplad (‘steel helmet’) (lines 110–120), which Galia was not familiar with. At the end of this clarification sequence, Galia apologizes half-jokingly for not knowing what a kaplad was: s.. slixa 'al haburut. (‘s..sorry for the ignorance’, line 119), Hanna accepts with lo meshane (‘never mind’, line 120), pauses a rather long pause, and then moves on to describe the location of the incident (lines 122–127). This is still part of the orientation to her narrative, but a different sub-episode (Chafe 1994) of it – one describing the location rather than the equipment. The move to this new sub-episode, and out of the preceding clarification sequence, apology, and acceptance, is signaled by bekitsur (line 121). In previous studies of the system of discourse markers segmenting Hebrew talk-in-interaction (Maschler 1997a, 2002a. See Table 2, Chapter 1), bekitsur was classified, along with its slang variants hakitser and 'akitser, as a textual discourse 5. Israeli army parlance is noted for its pervasive invention of acronyms and blendings. The focus of the clarification sequence of this segment, kaplad, is another case in point: kasda (‘helmet’) miplada (‘made out of steel’).
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
marker denoting the function ‘back to main action’, somewhat equivalent to that of the English discourse marker anyway (e.g., Kussmaul 1978, Owen 1985, Altenberg 1986, Schourup and Waida 1987, Chafe 1987, Schiffrin 1987, Bublitz 1988, Lenk 1995, 1998, Ferrara 1997, Takahara 1998, Tabor and Traugott 1998). Recall that in the present study, a prototypical discourse marker is defined as an utterance fulfilling two conditions; one semantic, the other structural: (a) Semantically, the utterance must have a metalingual interpretation in the context in which it occurs. In other words, rather than referring to the extralingual world, it must refer metalingually to the realm of the text, to the interaction between its participants, or to their cognitive processes. (b) Structurally, the utterance must occur at intonation-unit initial position, either at a point of speaker change, or, in same-speaker talk, immediately following any intonation contour other than continuing intonation. It may occur after continuing intonation or at non-intonation-unit initial position only if it follows another marker in a cluster (Maschler 1998b: 31)6. For example, bekitsur of excerpt 1 satisfies both conditions. Structurally, it occurs at intonation-unit initial position following final intonation (line 120) (here in same-speaker talk). Semantically, bekitsur cannot be interpreted to function literally here – the ensuing discourse is neither ‘short’ nor ‘succinct’ and, as we have seen, there is no verb in the surrounding intonation units to which bekitsur could function as adverb. This word refers to the realm of the text, rather than to the extralingual world. In other words, it functions metalingually, rather than lingually, and signals a move from the aside clarifying the word kaplad back to the main topic of (the orientation to) the narrative. Bekitsur is reminiscent of the English discourse marker anyway, marking “prior discourse as tangential to the main point” (Schiffrin 1987:€165). Another argument for the discourse marker status of bekitsur relies on the tendency of discourse markers to cluster at conversational action boundaries7: in excerpt 1, bekitsur opens a cluster of four discourse markers: bekitsur,..'az 'e...'e--h (‘bekitsur,..so uh... u--h’). When linguistic elements come to function as discourse markers, they often undergo prosodic and phonological changes (Schiffrin 1987:€328, Ferrara 1997). This is apparent in a series of prosodic and phonological changes undergone by 6. In Chapter 1 we saw that the two criteria in this definition coincide for 94% of the discourse markers. The remaining 6% satisfy the semantic, but not the structural requirement. These statistics are based on a sub-corpus consisting of 16 conversations (40 minutes of discourse among 43 participants, see Maschler 2002a). In the present extended corpus of 50 conversations, only 2 out of 49 instances of bekitsur (4.1%) did not satisfy the structural requirement. We will examine one of these cases below. 7.
See Chapter 1, Section 6.0.
Metalanguage in Interaction
bekitsur and its variants, beginning with the change in the position of the stress of this word from bekitsúr to bekítsur8, following with a vowel change to bekítser, the deletion of the prepositional component b(e)- in hakítser, 'akítser, and kitsúr, and on to the more complicated sound changes (modeled after Arabic word patterns) of be'uktsur, all of which are found in the present corpus. Other, more playful forms which I have heard on occasion are bekítskets, hakítskits, and even 'akíbitser9. Based on made-up examples, and paying no attention to prosody, Shloush studied bekitsur with reference to relevance theory. Her work will be discussed below. The goal of the present chapter is to deepen our understanding of the functions of bekitsur and of the conversational actions of digressing and returning from a digression, based on the study of naturally occurring Hebrew conversation. First, I examine the employment of bekitsur in my corpus and compare it to that of English anyway. Second, I suggest a path of grammaticization (Hopper 1987, 1988, 1991, Hopper and Traugott 1993, Bybee and Hopper 2001) for bekitsur. Finally, I consider this discourse marker in the wider context of Israeli culture. 2. Data In the 50 conversations of the Haifa Corpus of Spoken Israeli Hebrew (Maschler 2004) on which the present study is based (see Chapter 1, Section 3), altogether 49 tokens of bekitsur are employed. Thus, bekitsur is employed at an average frequency of one token every 3.06 minutes in this corpus. The tokens are distributed among the following functions: Table 1 shows that, far and away, the main function of bekitsur in this corpus (approximately 77.6% of all tokens) is to signal a move by the speaker back to the main topic, or, in other words, to return to the main topic following what is marked retrospectively as a digression. Let us examine these functions in more detail. Table 1.╇ Functions of bekitsur throughout the database Summarizing
Signaling resump- Requesting tion of main topic resumption of main topic
Foregrounding new narrative
Total
5 (10.2%)
38 (77.6%)
5 (10.2%)
49 (100%)
1 (2%)
8. This stress displacement does not take place in all instances of the discourse marker bekitsur. The token in excerpt 1 is such an instance where it does not. More on this below. 9. This last token involves fusion with the Yiddish word for ‘beggar’, kibitser.
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
3. Summarizing bekitsur I begin with the least metalingual use of bekitsur, that of summarizing some point in the discourse. We will see two variants here: summarizing a list (3.1) and summarizing an episode (3.2). A related function, drawing conclusions from an episode, will be discussed in Section 3.3. 3.1
Summary following a list
In the following excerpt, Nili, a woman in her forties, tells another couple and her own husband about her first experience using Chat on the internet: Excerpt 2 (‘Chat’): 40 Nili: .... 'az, so, 41
.. 'az hayù kàma hitkatvuyó--t, so there were [a] few correspondences so there was some writing back and forth,
42
.. s’tomeret, I mean,
43
.. 'eh uh
44
.. nehenèti mehamisxá--k, I enjoyed the game,
45
... shel 'e--h la'anó--t, of u--h answering,
46
.. velehakshí--v, and listening,
47
.. vetikra pratí--m, and you read details and reading details,
48
.. ve, and,
49
.... bekitsúr, in short,
Metalanguage in Interaction
50 51 Gil'ad: 52
.. letargél 'et ha'inyàn. drilling the issue getting some practice with the whole thing. ken, yeah, .. ze ktsàt nexmád kaze bahatxala. it a bit nice like at first it’s sort of like nice at first.
Shloush mentions an ‘appositional’ or ‘equative’ use of bekitsur, whose occurrence “is motivated by an urge to conclude, or more specifically [...] to summarize the preceding list under a ‘super category’, once the information is taken to be selfevident” (1998:€ 63). Shloush’s characterization fits here. Nili lists the things she enjoyed about that first experience of using chat: neheneti mehamisxa--k,... shel 'e--h la'ano--t,.. velehakshi--v,.. vetikra10 prati--m, (‘I enjoyed the game, of uh answering, and listening, and reading details’, lines 44–47). The final two members of this three-item list begin with the coordinative conjunction ve- (‘and’, lines 46, 47), and ve- introduces also a fourth member of the list which is never completed, ending in continuing intonation (line 48). After a pause and a token of bekitsur (line 49), Nili summarizes the list of things she enjoyed: letargel 'et ha'inyan (‘getting some practice with the whole thing’, line 50). The actions of answering, listening, and reading on Chat are summarized by the ‘super-category’ of ‘getting some practice with the whole thing’. Gil'ad’s response at lines 51–52, overlapping the summary, ken,.. ze ktsat nexmad kaze bahatxala. (‘yeah, it’s sort of like nice at first’), shows that the information Nili was conveying was indeed ‘taken to be self-evident’ by at least some of the audience immediately before it was summarized. Prosodically, bekitsur occurs following a series of continuing intonation contours (lines 45–48) which it summarizes under a ‘super-category’. Here, the literal English translation of bekitsur, ‘in short’, is adequate. This is paralleled by the fact that this is one of only two tokens of bekitsur following continuing intonation throughout the database (see footnote 6). In this instance, it is the continuing intonation of the unfinished list ending at line 48, which contributes to the impression that the list actually contains many more items that just did not get mentioned. As we have seen (Chapter 1, Section 7), iconically, higher-level 10. Notice, however, the lack of equivalence between the syntactic elements conjoined in this list. Whereas the first two consist of infinitives – la'anot, lehakshiv (‘to answer’, ‘to listen’) – the third consists of a finite verb + complement: tikra pratim (‘read details’). Here we find the second person masculine singular future form of the verb, tikra (‘you will read’), used as an imperative in the impersonal sense. Summarizing the list, the speaker returns to the infinitive – letargel (‘to drill/get some exercise’).
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
boundaries are marked by a ‘heavier’ strategy, namely, final intonation, whereas lower-level boundaries are marked by a ‘lighter’ strategy – continuing intonation. The boundary between listing items of some category and summarizing them by a ‘super-category’ is certainly of a lower level than the boundary between a digression and a return to the main topic, as in excerpt 1. Therefore, it is not surprising to find continuing, rather than final intonation at line 48. In this instance, then, the structural requirement for discourse-markerhood is not fulfilled, and the semantic requirement is only partially fulfilled: the literal translation ‘in short’ is adequate here, but this bekitsur does not function as adverb to any verb in the surrounding intonation units. The bekitsur of line 49 is interpreted as standing for (in a way that is no longer apparent to the speaker) some longer metalingual utterance, such as 'im lomar bekitsur (lit., ‘if to say in short’, ‘to say succinctly’ or ‘put succinctly’), and is therefore considered to function metalingually here. One of Hopper’s principles of grammaticization is persistence, which he formulates in the following manner: When a form undergoes grammaticalization from a lexical to a grammatical function, so long as it is grammatically viable some traces of its original lexical meanings tend to adhere to it, and details of its lexical history may be reflected in constraints on its grammatical distribution (1991:€22).
This principle is a refinement of a phenomenon first observed by Bybee and Pagliuca and termed ‘retention’, according to which older meanings of a form “glimmer through” as they are retained from their original lexical sources (1987:€109). “The phenomenon of retention is usually associated with single tokens of a form observable at different stages of development and in different linguistic contexts” (Ziegeler 2000:€31). We see the retention, or persistence, of lexical features at this stage of the grammaticization of bekitsur from adverb to discourse marker. 3.2
Summary of episode
In the following excerpt, which takes place during a breakfast conversation about a couple who recently broke up, Amir explains to his girlfriend Tami why the man, Shmulik, who had been married before, left his girlfriend, Dalit:
Metalanguage in Interaction
Excerpt 3 (‘Breaking Up’): 39 Tami: .. haya lahem kol kax tóv beyàxad harey. it was to them so good together PART11. they were so happy together after all. 40 Amir: ... gam ló haya tov, also to him it was good he too was happy, 41
.. 'aval 'e--h, but u--h,
42
.. pashut hi--, simply she it’s just that she,
43
.... Dalít kvar ló tse'ira. Dalit already not young Dalit isn’t young anymore.
44
.... ratsta--, [she] wanted,
45
.. hi bikshá mimeno, she asked him,
46
ke'ílu--, like,
47
.. sheya'avrù-- lagur beyáxad, that they move in to live together to move in together,
48 49
ve-and .... bekitsúr, in short,
50
lehitmaséd shuv. to become established again.
51 (2.5) hahu nivhál. that one became scared that one [i.e., Shmulik] got cold feet. 11. In a study of this particle, Ariel notes: “A speaker who uses Hebrew harey indicates to her addressee that the proposition under its scope imparts information which is already available to him.” (Ariel 1998: 224).
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
52 (4.5) 'amár la, told her, 53
shetsàrix la'asot 'eyze hafsaká. that it’s necessary to do some break that they had to take a break.
54 (3.00) bekítsur, in short, 55
.. hem ló medabrim kvar shalósh12 shavu'ot. they not talking already three weeks. they haven’t been talking for three weeks now.
56 Tami: .. lò medabrím kvar shloshà shvu'ot? not talking already three weeks haven’t been talking for three weeks now? lo medabrím. not talking haven’t been talking.
57 Amir: 58
.... lo nifgashím, not meeting haven’t been meeting,
59
.. lo klúm. not anything nothing.
In this elicitational discourse segment (Chafe 1994, see footnote 16) discussing the couple Dalit and Shmulik, Amir begins, in ‘listing intonation’, to recount the things Dalit asked Shmulik prior to his leaving her: hi bikshá mimeno, ke'ílu--,.. sheya'avrù-lagur beyáxad, ve-- (‘she asked him, like, to move in together, and’, lines 45–48). This list is never completed and ends with a fragmented intonation unit (line 48). Instead, after a longer than average pause at line 49, Amir summarizes this neverto-be list with bekitsúr, lehitmaséd shuv. (‘in short, to become established again.’). This case is similar to the one we saw in excerpt 2, except that the list here is much shorter. After a 2.5 second pause, at line 51, Amir moves on to describe Shmulik’s
12. Agreement between numerals and the nouns they modify is one of the first morphological patterns to become neutralized in Israeli Hebrew (see Ravid 1995). Notice, however, Tami’s correction of this grammatical ‘mistake’ in the following intonation unit: Amir’s shalosh shavu'ot (‘three (fem.) weeks (masc. pl.)’) gets corrected to shlosha shvu'ot (‘three (masc.) weeks (masc. pl.)’).
Metalanguage in Interaction
reaction to Dalit’s request. This is done via two prosodic sentences13 separated by a long pause: hahu nivhál. (‘he got cold feet.’) (4.5) 'amár la, shetsàrix la'asot 'eyze hafsaká. (‘told her, that they had to take a break.’). Following another long pause at line 54, he summarizes the result of these actions: (3.00) bekítsur,.. hem ló medabrim kvar shalósh shavu'ot. (‘in short, they haven’t been talking for three weeks now’). Here bekitsur occurs following a series of final intonation contours. Line 55 both summarizes the result of the actions described in the preceding intonation units (lines 51–53) and returns the participants to the discussion of the state Shmulik and Dalit are at now, the topic they were discussing prior to this segment. Excerpt 3, then, manifests a transitional case between summarizing an episode and returning from a digression. Indeed, a likely conversational action prior to returning to a main action is summarizing the previous action. Summarizing in this way can also help construct the previous action as ‘tangential to the main point’, as noted by Schiffrin (1987) for anyway. Thus, even if throughout lines 42– 53 the participants did not perceive the discourse taking place as a digression from some main topic, employment of bekitsur following this stretch of talk helps to construct it as such in retrospect. Note the position of the stress in these two instances of bekitsur. We see that stress placement here is not a matter of personal style, as both tokens are uttered by the same speaker. At line 49, summarizing a list, Amir verbalizes bekitsúr with the stress in standard position. However, in the transitional case between summarizing an episode and returning to a main action, he verbalizes bekítsur, displacing the stress in the more colloquial fashion. In this instance, then, we find a prosodic feature distinguishing the two functions of bekitsur, such that the function further away from the literal meaning of the word (summarizing an episode and returning to the main action) is the one accompanied by the prosodic change. This is reminiscent of a different prosodic shift described for anyway: Ferrara found that this resumptive discourse marker is accompanied by an intonation contour that differs markedly from the intonation contours of the adverbial uses of anyway as an additive (‘besides’) and a dismissive (‘nonetheless’), which are similar to one another (1997:€354–359).
13. A prosodic sentence is defined by Chafe (1994:€137–145) as an intonation unit, or a group of successive intonation units separated by continuing intonation, ending in sentence-final intonation. Chafe observes that once a speaker judges that the scanning of a center of interest (such as a sub-episode in a story-episode) has been completed, s/he expresses that judgment with a sentence-final intonation contour.
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
3.3
Drawing conclusions from episode
There is one case throughout the database in which bekitsur is employed not preceding a summary of the episode, but rather preceding a conclusion that is drawn from it. This comes from a story that Ada, a woman who accompanied the Israeli delegation to Oslo during the peace talks with the Palestinians in the mid-1990’s, tells her friend Micha. She tells about an incident in which she and a member of the Palestinian delegation, Abdullah, found themselves lost on a tram in Oslo because the group they were with had gotten off the tram while they weren’t paying attention. After realizing their group was no longer there, they got off the tram and started walking back: Excerpt 4 (‘Ada and Abdullah in Oslo’): 60 Ada: .... hitxalnu lexapés ta’kvutsà, we started looking for the group, 61
... /'aval/ lo matsánu otam. /but/ not found them /but/ we didn’t find them.
62
.... velo yadànu gam le'éyfo hem holxim, and not know also to where they are going and we also didn’t know where they were going,
63
.. ki lo hikshávnu, because we didn’t listen because we didn’t pay attention,
64 Micha: (2.45) /nu/ 'éyfo ze haya, /go on/ where it was /go on/ where was it, 65 66 Ada:
be'óslo? in Oslo? ken. yeah.
67 Micha: (2.47) nu? go on?
68 Ada:
69
..... bekítsur, .. hitxàlnu laxzór laxzór laxzór laxzór, we started to go back to go back to go back to go back, we started going back back back back,
Metalanguage in Interaction
70
ve'az 'amarnu tóv 'èn 'e--h.. derex, and then we said okay there isn’t u--h a way [to find them],
71
'az nitkashér la--madrixìm shelanu. so we’ll call to the guides ours so we’ll call our guides.
72
...... 'az 'e--h, so u--h, hamadrixìm yad'u--.. norvégi the guides knew.. Norweg
73 Micha: 74
'e--h... 'anglít? u--h.. English?
75
/dibártem 'itam/? /you spoke to them/? ken. yes.
76 Ada: 77
.... 'az 'amarti, so I said,
78
yá--, {interjection}
79
yésh li t’a-there is to me the I’ve got the
80
yesh li t’a télefon shel ha--, there is to me the phone of the I’ve got the phone [number] of the,
81
.. madrixim batík, guides in [my] bag,
82
... ve'ani matxila lexapès batík, and I start looking in the bag,
83
... ló motsèt. don’t find can’t find anything.
84 Micha:
85 Ada:
{laughter} matxila lexapes ba --xagoràt béten shehayta li, [I] start looking in the--beltstomach that there was to me I start looking in the money belt I had,
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
86 87 88 89
... ló motsèt. don’t find can’t find anything. .... ve'az hu 'omér, and then he says, 'á--h, yesh lax t’atélefon shel hamadrìx haze vehaze? there is to you the phone of the guide this and this do you have the phone [number] of some particular guide?
90
... kén ken bétax! {Ada’s voice to Abdullah} yes yes sure!
91
.. 'ani matxila lexapés beze, {--laughing--} I start looking in this I start looking here,
92
.. 'an’ló motsèt. can’t find [anything].
93
.. mexapéset, [I] look [there],
94
.. ló motsèt. can’t find [anything].
95
... bekítsur hayinu mevohalím laxalutín. bekitsur we were alarmed completely bekitsur we were completely alarmed.
96
.. 'amarti tóv, I said okay,
97
nitkasher venish'al beshagrirùt yisra'él. we’ll call and ask at embassy Israel we’ll call and ask at the Israeli embassy.
98
.... hitkasharti lamerkaziyà shel.. 'e--h.. 'óslo, I called the operator of.. u--h.. Oslo,
99
... bikáshti /ta’ telefon shel/ hashagrirùt, I asked for /the telephone [number] of/ the embassy,
100
... hitkashárti lashagrirùt, I called the embassy,
Metalanguage in Interaction
In lines 60–72 Ada describes in past tense the actions she and Abdullah took in order to try to locate their group (there is a short clarification sequence concerning where all this happened in the midst of this description (lines 64–67), with bekitsur employed to return from it at line 68). After dealing with another clarification request from Micha concerning the language they spoke with the guides (lines 73–76), she moves on to the present tense, to the episode of looking to no avail for the guide’s phone number in various places: in her bag (lines 78–83), in her money belt (lines 85–86), and in other places (lines 87–94). In conclusion, she returns to the past tense and describes the state they were in as a result of these various unsuccessful searches: hayinu mevohalím laxalutín. (‘we were completely alarmed’, line 95). This conclusion is preceded by bekitsur. However, with this word, Ada also returns to the past tense description of the actions they took in order to try to locate their group which she began earlier (lines 60–72). At line 96 she begins to describe the next action; namely, calling the Israeli embassy. Thus, the ‘looking to no avail’ episode (lines 77–94) is retroactively constructed as a digression from the main storyline of describing the actions taken in order to locate the group. In this sense, the bekitsur of line 95, too, is a transitional case – here, between drawing a conclusion from an episode and returning from a digression. Indeed, a likely way to end an episode is to describe its conclusions or results14. As in excerpt 2, this token of bekitsur likewise follows a series of prosodic sentences ending in final intonation contours: lines 77–83, 85–86, 87–89, 90, 91–92, 93–9415. Throughout the database, there is only one such case of drawing conclusions from an episode preceded by bekitsur. Because drawing conclusions and summarizing are closely related activities, I consider them both to be in the same category of ‘summarizing’. Table 1 shows that only 5 instances (10.2%) of this less metalingual use of bekitsur are found in the corpus, two of which are already borderline between this function and that of returning to the main topic following a digression, as we have seen in excerpts 2 and 3. Let us move now to this latter function, the main function of bekitsur, which is never found following continuing intonation. 14. This point is underscored by one of the meanings of the English verb ‘to conclude’; namely, ‘to end’. 15. Note that this is different from Shloush’s ‘inferential use’ of bekitsur, for which she constructs the following example: david mevsSel, menake, Sotef ricpa, megahec ... bekicur, keday lax leha’asik oto (‘David, cooks, cleans, does the floors, irons ... in short, you should hire him’). (1998: 63). Shloush characterizes this case in the following manner: “once sufficient information has been provided, what follows bekicur is an inference rather than a mere equation [as in the case of summarizing a list]” (ibid.: 64) and “the cutting of the list in question by bekicur signals a conclusion related to the discourse topic” (ibid.: 67). No such lists were found in the corpus. The only time bekitsur was employed to draw conclusions from previous discourse occurred following an episode which was made up of a series of prosodic sentences (i.e., units ending in final intonation contours), unlike Shloush’s constructed example. This is one of the problems of constructing examples – one cannot look at prosody.
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
4. Resumptive bekitsur: Returning to the main topic I use the term ‘topic’ or ‘discourse topic’ here in Chafe’s (1994) sense. In Chafe’s model of information flow in discourse, as people speak, ideas of events, states, and the referents that participate in them are constantly changing activation states in their minds. Information can be in any one of three activation states: active, semiactive, or inactive. As new concepts become activated, previously used concepts gradually become inactive. “Intonation units are hypothesized to be the linguistic expression of information that is, at first, active in the consciousness of the speaker, and then, by the utterance of the intonation unit, in the consciousness of the listener, or at least that is the speaker’s intent” (1994:€69). In chapters 10 and 11 of his book, Chafe considers units larger than the intonation unit: We need now a name for the larger amount of information that can be semiactive [in the speaker’s mind]. I will use the term topic in this way, qualifying it when necessary as discourse topic to distinguish it from the other phenomena to which the term has been applied. The usage here is thus in accord with such expressions as the topic of a paragraph, changing the topic, and the like (cf. Keenan and Schieffelin 1976, Brown and Yule 1983, pp. 71–106). [...] We can think of each such topic as an aggregate of coherently related events, states, and referents that are held together in some form in the speaker’s semiactive consciousness (ibid.: 120–121).
In Chafe’s approach, then, topics are on the one hand aggregates of semiactive information that segment discourse into chunks larger than intonation units. On the other hand, a topic is interpreted in the lay sense of what speakers understand they are talking about at a given time. The question of when one topic ends and another begins, or of when one topic is briefly interrupted for a digression (in itself a new topic) and then returned to, is open to negotiation by the participants of an interaction, as is the question of whether or not a topic is of secondary importance and therefore a digression. The notion of topic, then, is a flexible one, and whether or not a digression has occurred is a relative issue. In what follows, we will continue to see that one of the main functions of bekitsur is to retroactively construct the topic that has just ended as a digression relative to the continuation of the discourse. Table 2.╇ Distribution of bekitsur according to discourse type Narrational discourse
Elicitational discourse
45 (91.8%)
4 (8.2%)
Metalanguage in Interaction
Table 2 shows the distribution of bekitsur tokens in the present database according to the type of discourse16 in which they appear. We see that the great majority of bekitsur tokens (45 tokens or 91.8%) occur in narrational discourse, although this word is not restricted to this type of talk. Interestingly, 3 out of the 4 tokens of bekitsur employed in elicitational discourse are of the summarizing variety (Section 2). We will see bekitsur employed in particular in the moves from elicitational back to narrational discourse. 4.1
Collaboration in returning to the main topic
Ferrara found that the majority of anyway discourse marker tokens in her data, which consisted of narrative discourse17, were teller-triggered. In other words, 74% of anyway tokens followed a digression initiated by the teller of the story, while only 26% followed a digression initiated by the listener. She concludes that the discourse marker anyway is mainly a self-digression management marker (1997:€ 359). By contrast, in the present corpus, bekitsur is more often listenertriggered than it is teller-triggered: Table 3.╇ Distribution of resumptive bekitsur according to trigger of digression Listenertriggered
Tellertriggered
Listener+ teller triggered18
Situational digression
Indeterminable19
Total
22 (57.9%)
11 (28.9%)
1 (2.6%)
1 (2.6%)
3 (7.9%)
38 (100%)
16. Chafe distinguishes two types of discourse topics: narrational and elicitational.€ While movement through a narrational topic develops according to the narrational scheme (cf. Labov’s narrative structure (1972)), movement through an elicitational topic is driven by the interaction between participants. One participant functions as an eliciter and the other as a responder. The eliciter introduces the topic, but it is the responder “who possesses the bulk of the interesting information. The topic is, in other words, one about which the eliciter finds it interesting to gain more knowledge, and he or she accomplishes that goal partly by asking questions, partly in other ways” (Chafe 1994: 123). 17. There is a difference in employment of the term ‘narrative discourse’ here in comparison to Ferrara (1997). Whereas Ferrara takes the elicitational segments interrupting the stories to be part of her corpus of narratives, I count bekitsur tokens appearing in these elicitational segments as occurring in elicitational discourse. 18. This is a case in which bekitsur is employed after a long stretch of laughter by both teller and listener, following an orientation of a narrative. Thus, the digression was triggered both by the teller and the listener. 19. No recording of the earlier segment is available.
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
In other words, bekitsur occurs following digressions initiated by the listener roughly twice as often as it occurs following digressions initiated by the teller. However, listener-triggered digressions in this corpus often develop into long elicitational segments, and the question of who triggered the digression is no longer relevant because speakers are probably no longer aware of who initiated the digression when they attempt to resume the main topic. What is more important is their collaboration in getting back to the main topic. A case in point is the following excerpt from a conversation between two women in their early forties. Nurit is recounting to Sarah the long story of the dealings her husband Ofer had with various medical doctors: Excerpt 5 (‘Doctors’): 39 Nurit: .. 'axsháv doc now Doc 40
.. haláxnu lif we went bef
41
.. lifnéy shehalaxnu la'ortopèd, before that we went to the orthopedic surgeon before we went to the orthopedic surgeon,
42
hayìnu 'etsel doctor 'ábu, we were at Doctor Abu[’s],
43
.. kvar ló zoxeret bishvil mà. no longer remember for what [I] can’t remember anymore what for.
44
.. nidmé li, seems to me I think,
45
bishvil hapétek shel haxofesh maxalà. for the note of the vacation sickness for the sick leave note.
46
.. ló meshane. doesn’t matter never mind.
47
.. ve.. doctor 'ábu 'amàr, and.. Doctor Abu said,
48 Sarah:
xòfesh maxala lemí? vacation sickness for whom sick leave for whom?
Metalanguage in Interaction
49 Nurit: .. le--'ófer, for Ofer, 50
lir'ót, to see,
51
'uláy 'e--h.. bitùax te'unot 'ishiyo--t, maybe u--h.. insurance accidents personal maybe u--h.. personal accident insurance [will pay for his sick leave], 'ah 'ah 'ahá, oh oh aha,
52 Sarah:
'ulày bituax le'umí, maybe insurance national maybe social security,
53 Nurit: 54 Sara:
hevánti. I understood got it.
55 Nurit:
míshehu. somebody.
56
tishme'i, listen,
57
xodsháyim hu kvar lò 'ovéd! two months he already not working it’s been two months now that he hasn’t been working! naxón, right,
58 Sarah: 59
naxon. right.
60
.. yésh bitùax leze, there is [some] insurance for this,
61
.. 'ad káma she'ani yodà'at. as much that I know as far as I know.
62 Nurit:
ló yoda'at. don’t know.
63 Sarah: yésh mashehu. there is something.
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
64 Nurit:
ló yoda'at. don’t know.
65 Sarah:
nú? go on?
66
kén? yeah?
67 Nurit: .. bekitsú--r,
68
.. doctor 'àbu 'amár, Doctor Abu said,
The listener, Sarah, is the one who interrupted the flow of this story, asking for clarificatory information (sick leave for whom?, line 48), but she is also the one who initiates the return to the main topic with nu? (‘go on?’) ken? (‘yeah?’) in lines 65–66. Only after this urging does Nurit return to the main storyline, opening with bekitsur (line 67). This digression was listener-triggered, but the storyteller collaborated with the listener in following the digression for a relatively long stretch of talk (lines 49–64), so that at line 65 it was the listener, not the storyteller, who initiated the move back to the story. We see that this type of bekitsur, like the episode-summarizing variety, follows a series of prosodic sentences ending in final intonation contours (lines 49–55, 56–57, 58–59, 60–61, 62, 63, 65, 66). Most importantly, the intonation unit immediately preceding it (ken?, ‘yeah?’) ends in sentence-final intonation. This is the case with all but one bekitsur token in the resumptive category as well as with all narrative-introducing bekitsur tokens. Collaboration with the sequence listener: nu? (‘go on’) storyteller: bekitsur, can also be found in much shorter digressions, as in excerpt 4, lines 64–68. In fact, about a fifth of resumptive bekitsur tokens and bekitsur tokens introducing new narratives (9 out of 43 cases) in this corpus follow a token of nu (‘go on’) uttered by the listener. The mere fact that the second most prevalent interpersonal discourse marker in Hebrew, nu (‘yeah, go on’), is one whose main function is to urge further development within a main topic20 is proof of the highly collaborative nature of returning from digressions in this culture. In a study of English anyway and some of its corresponding Japanese discourse markers, Takahara writes: “a close of digression or return to the main topic is almost always marked by this characteristic linguistic unit anyway” (1998:€335). 20. See Chapter 2.
Metalanguage in Interaction
Bekitsur is indeed the discourse marker most frequently employed to return from digressions in my Hebrew data. There seems to be an important difference, however, between bekitsur and English anyway with respect to collaboration. The Israeli language games of digressing and returning from a digression are more collaborative. First, as we have seen, in contrast to Ferrara’s study of anyway (1997), digressions preceding bekitsur are more often initiated by the listener than by the teller. Second, the listener is also more involved in returning from them. This is in line, of course, with other features of this relatively high-involvement (Tannen 1984, Schiffrin 1984) speaking style (Katriel 1986, Blum-Kulka and Katriel 1991, Maschler 1994a, Blum-Kulka 1997). To explain the relatively high frequency of digressions in discourse, Ferrara quotes Basgoz, who suggests a possible rationale for this frequency – that of bridging the cultural gap between speakers and hearers (Ferrara 1997:€366): “A gap – small or big, historical, linguistic, social or ecological in nature – develops between the past and present cultures. [....] Digression bridges this gap, making the unknown known, irrational rational, obscure clear, incredible credible...” (Basgoz 1986:€3). In the conversations collected here, the cultural gap between participants is minimal because they are usually close friends or family members. Yet their conversations abound with digressions. The reason for this is interactional: digressions tie discourse participants to each other, enabling them to make their interlocutors’ discourse more relevant to their own experience. When digressing-listeners then also initiate a move back to the main topic, they are able to reassure the speaker of their continuing involvement in their talk. Even the listener herself can employ bekitsur in order to return the storyteller from a digression. This happens in only one instance throughout the corpus, in a conversation between two women in their early twenties about a couple who had broken up. Beforehand, the couple had bought sofas the woman did not like: Excerpt 6 (‘Sofas’): 95 Gila: ..... hayu shlosha tsva'ím shel 'e--h, there were three colors of u--h, 96
... praxìm 'al hasapá. flowers on the sofa.
97
.. 'az hi hexlìta shehi titsbá. so she decided that she will color [in].
98
... 'exad mehatsva'ím shehi lo 'ahavà. one of the colors that she didn’t like.
{laughter}
99
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
100
.... tikne tséva, [she]’ll buy [some] color,
101
vetitsbá 'otam. and color them [in].
102
... 'ani nisiti lehoríd 'ota mehara'ayòn, I tried to get off her from the idea I tried to get her off the idea,
103
.. shetetsapé 'et zè! that she put upholstery [on] it! get her to upholster them!
104
.... 'o máshehu. or something.
105
.. 'an’ló yoda'at, I dunno,
106
.. 'aval she but that lamròt sheze 'ód kesef, {------laughing-----} although that that more money although that’s more money,
107 Yonat: 108
.. ken? yeah?
109 Gila:
.... ze be'ayà shel mi shekone sapót, this [is the] problem of [one] who buys sofas,
110
velo bodék, and doesn’t check,
111
.. 'im hu 'ohév 'otam, if he likes them,
112
'o ló 'ohèv 'otam, or doesn’t like them,
113
.. 'o 'im hem mat'imòt lo labáyit. or if they match for him to the house or if they match his house.
114 Yonat: .. tòv 'akítser, okay 'akitser,
Metalanguage in Interaction
115
sof hasipùr hu shehem nifredú? [the] end of the story is that they broke up?
116 Gila:
shehem nifredu, that they broke up in the end they broke up,
117
vehadavar harishón sheli'at 'amrà, and the thing the first that Li'at said and the first thing Li'at said was,
118
'òy yófi, oh great,
119
'ani 'etèn lo 'et hasapót, {--------laughing------} I’ll give him the sofas,
120
ve'ani 'eknè li xadashót. {-------laughing--------} and I’ll buy myself new [ones].
121
..... zéhu. that’s it.
sóf hasipùr end of the story
At lines 102–104, Gila says she tried to dissuade her friend from coloring in the flowers on the upholstery and to get her to re-upholster the sofas instead. At line 107 Yonat objects to this idea with the concessive discourse marker lamrot she(‘although’) (cf. Günthner 2000), saying that that would have cost even more money. Gila answers her at lines 109–113, beginning with the formula ze be'aya shel mi she... (‘this is [the] problem of one who...’), justifying her solution with the idea that if one buys unwisely, one should ‘pay for it’ (i.e., it’s the unwise woman’s problem, not hers). Yonat does not pursue this line, and at line 114 returns Gila to her story, requesting its ending: tov 'akitser, sof hasipur hu shehem nifredu? (‘okay 'akitser, the end of the story is that they broke up?’), which Gila then provides (lines 116–121). We see that Yonat brings Gila back from the digression (which Yonat herself started at line 107) with the colloquial 'akitser in the discourse marker cluster tov21 'akitser (‘okay 'akitser’). Using this more jocular form of bekitsur may also be functioning to compensate for the disagreement between them. Thus, while initiating return from a digression allows participants to manifest their involvement 21. On the dual nature of tov (‘okay’) here, as both an interpersonal and a textual discourse marker, see Chapter 5, Section 5.
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
in each others’ talk, when the digression is a disagreement, it can also help avoid unwelcome topics. Let us move now to a closer look at the various types of digression from which bekitsur returns. Dascal and Katriel classify digressions into three types: utterancebased, interaction-based, and insertion sequences: Utterance-based digressions are characterized by the fact that some kind of ‘content’ relation holds between the mainstream utterance and the digressional ones. Interaction-based digressions exhibit no such relations. Insertion sequences, in our use of the term, refer to a large variety of corrective and clarificatory speechacts. They have an intermediary standing between utterance- and interactionbased digressions (1982:€82).
While defining a ‘content’ relation is not a simple matter, and Dascal and Katriel acknowledge this, I use their classification as a preliminary way of describing the employment of resumptive bekitsur in the corpus. 4.2
Returning from interaction-based digressions
Only one instance of bekitsur throughout the data functions to return participants from an interaction-based digression to the main topic. However, this paucity of tokens is due mainly to the nature of the data; namely, that participants in this corpus are not generally having a conversation while also doing something else. I have often heard this discourse marker employed to return from interaction-based digressions, such as following a phone call or an interruption of a conversation by a child. In the following excerpt two women, Sharon and Dalia, close friends in their early twenties, are sharing a night-shift in one of the offices of Israel’s Electric Company. As Sharon later explained to me, they are sitting in front of a map in which locations of callers who call in to report problems are flagged. Their job is to dispatch engineers in order to deal with the problems. In line 1, Dalia asks Sharon whether she has dealt with two calls that had come in: Excerpt 7 (‘Prince’): 1 Dalia: ... 'asìt 'et shneyhém? {-----------------pp-----------------} you did both of them did you do both of them? 2 Sharon: ... 'asiti 'exád. { ---pp---} I did one.
Metalanguage in Interaction
3 Dalia: .. betuxá? { ---pp---} [are you] sure? 4 Sharon:
ken. { -pp-} yeah.
5 Dalia: ... hakítse--r, {------f------} 6
.. hi 'oméret li, {------f------------} she says to me,
7
.... yashávnu dibárnu veze--, {-------------f---------------} we sat [and] talked and so on,
Following this short interchange concerning the calls they are supposed to deal with (lines 1–4), Dalia returns to a story she heard from another friend (line 6). The return to this story is preceded by hakitser (5) and accompanied by a marked prosodic change in volume, as well as by employment of the pronoun hi (‘she’, line 6), which would not have been employed at the beginning of a narrative. No ‘content’ relation holds between this digression and the narrative, and we have here an interaction-based (or ‘situational’, Lenk 1998:€60) digression. 4.3
Returning from content-based digressions
By far, the great majority of bekitsur tokens in this corpus function to return participants to the main topic following a digression which does bear some ‘content’ relation to the main topic. I present here a finer classification of these instances, based on the nature of the digression. 4.3.1 Following listener-initiated digressions Oftentimes during narration, the storyteller pauses for a question or an elicitational segment related to the story which is initiated by some member of the audience. After dealing with this new topic, the storyteller moves back to the narrative with bekitsur or one of its variants. In the following excerpt, David describes to his close friend, Dalia, a chase after a tractor that he was supposed to repossess as part of his work that day:
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
Excerpt 8 (‘Tractor Chase’): 11 David: haxokér hapratí 'amar, the investigator private said the private investigator said, 12
shehu nimtsa be'eyze makóm, that he is located in some place that he [the defaulting purchaser] can be found in some place,
13
... géshem zal'afót baxuts, rain raging outside it’s raining cats and dogs outside,
14
ke'ílu, I mean,
15
... má ze gèshem, what is rain what [do I mean by] rain,
16
... shexavál 'al hazmàn. that it’s a waste of time. unimaginable rain.
17
.. ràk metumtamím, only idiots,
18
yots'ím mehabàyit. go out of the house. kamóxa. like you.
19 Dalia:
naxón. right.
20 David: 21
.. nu 'az mí yefarnès, nu so who will earn the living,
22
.. 'át? you?
23 Dalia:
nu--? go on. {smiling}
24 David: .... be'uktsú--r, {in American accent}
Metalanguage in Interaction
25
.... 'anaxnu mezahìm 'et ha.. klí, we identify the.. vehicle,
To illustrate how strong the rain was during this tractor chase, David adds: rak metumtamim, yots'im mehabayit. (‘only idiots, go out of the house’., lines 17–18). Dalia quickly joins in, mocking her close friend: kamoxa (‘like you’, line 19), to which David responds with humorous sarcasm: nu 'az mí yefarnès,.. 'át? (‘nu22 so who will earn the living, you?’, lines 21–22). At line 23, smiling, Dalia urges him to go on with the story with the discourse marker nu--?, which David does at line 25 following the most playful variation on bekitsur in this corpus – be'uktsur. This form is modeled after an Arabic word pattern and is uttered in an American accent continuing the mockery and playfulness of this digression. We see, then, a return to the main topic following an audience-initiated, topically-relevant digression. In this case, the digression is only 5 intonation units long, but in other instances throughout the data (such as excerpt 4), the digression often becomes a long elicitational segment and bekitsur functions to move from elicitation back to narration. The mocking tone of be'uktsur in the preceding example is influenced by the general mocking tone of the digression. However, in considering the variation in form of the discourse marker anyway (anyways, anyhow, at any rate), Ferrara mentions the jocular form anyhoo as one of the variants of anyhow (1997:€370). It is not surprising to find a jocular tone when a speaker returns from a digression, particularly one initiated by the listener. In doing so, the speaker signals to the listener that what they have just said is of secondary importance, a move potentially carrying interpersonal ramifications. Joking is a natural compensation for an interpersonally threatening move of this type. 4.3.2 Following storyteller-initiated digressions 4.3.2.1 Following a story aside Bekitsur can be employed by the storyteller to return from a digression she herself initiated, as in the following case in which Li'at tells her friend Anat a story about trying to switch residence halls with some woman: Excerpt 9 (‘Reznik Residence Halls’): 34 Li'at: .. kódem kol, first of all,
22. While nu at line 23 functions to urge the speaker to go on with the story, at line 21 it precedes the discourse marker 'az (‘so’) and functions to add a mocking tone to this statement. See Chapter 2.
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
35
hi kol hazman norà paxadá, she all the time terribly was afraid she was constantly terribly scared,
36
.. biglal zé she, because of the fact that,
37
... yitfesú 'otanu--, they’ll catch us,
.. veya'alú
38
'al ze,
and they’ll find out about it,
39
.. vema yikré--, and what[’s gonna] happen,
40
ve..ma haprotsedúra. and what[’s] the procedure.
41
hi hayta betuxa shehì teshalem lí ta’, she was sure that she would pay me the,
42
.. 'et ma she'ani be.. berám? what I [pay] in.. in Ram?
43
... begiv'at rám? in Ram Hill [residence hall]?
44
vehi and she
45
'aní 'ashalèm la ta’reznik, I’ll pay her the Reznik [residence hall],
46
ve--bixlál, and in general,
47
.. hi haytà me'ód lo ba'inyanim. she was very much not in the issues she was very much out of it.
48
... vehitbarèr bixlal shehi lomedet 'itánu! and it turned out at all that she studies with us and it turned out she even studies with us!
49 Anat:
/????/
50
/????/
51 Li'at:
ken, yeah,
Metalanguage in Interaction
52
shaná rishonà. year first first year.
.... hakítser,
53
54
'amárti la, I said to her,
At line 48 the storyteller digresses to give an external fact about the woman she was trying to switch residence halls with; namely, that it turned out she was a first year student in their department. After a very short discussion of this (lines 49–52), she returns to the narrative with hakitser (line 53), clearly marking the preceding digression as tangential to the main point. The relativity of digressions is underscored by the employment of bekitsur by the storyteller in the midst of a narrative, between its various episodes (Labov 1972, Chafe 1994). Such episodes are clearly not digressions from the narrative, but in the progression towards the climax of the story (Chafe 1994), they can be retroactively constructed as secondary, thus aiding the listener in following the main storyline. Sections 4.3.2.2 - 4.3.2.4 illustrate this retroactive construction of backgrounding (Hopper 1979) in narrative via bekitsur. 4.3.2.2 Following orientation In the following excerpt, the storyteller employs 'akitser to move from the orientational episode of her story to the beginning of the complication. First, she describes a computerized form that workers in her office are supposed to fill out when interviewing women for some job: Excerpt 10 (‘Office Gossip’): 154 Galit: .. 'axshav yésh bamaxshe--v, now there is in the computer 155
.. 'e--h.. kmo-- rúbrika, u--h like [a] rubric,
156
.. rúbrika kazot, [a] rubric like,
157
... shel 'e--h, of u--h,
158
.... hofa'á. appearance.
159
... 'az yésh 'e--m, so there is uh--m,
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
160
... gru'á, awful (fem. sg.),
161
... regilá, ordinary (fem. sg.),
162
... 'e--h tová, u--h good (fem. sg.),
163
.. yitsugít, presentational (fem. sg.),
164
.. vetovà me'ód. and good (fem. sg.) very and very good.
165
.... beséder? okay?
166
... ve'ef and wh
167
... vebedérex klal, and usually
168
.. mà she'ani 'amura lasím, what (that) I[’m] supposed to put [down],
169
... ze regilá. is ordinary.
170
.. ke'ilu, like,
171
.. 'ata yodé'a, you know,
172
.. lò--.. yitsugí bi..myuxad, not presentational especially not particularly presentational,
173
.. velò.. garú'a bimyuxad. and not awful especially and not particularly awful.
174 Nir:
{cough}
175 Galit: ..... 'akítser, 176
.. hayom 'ani-- korét xavat dà'at, today I[’m] read[ing a] report,
Metalanguage in Interaction
177
... 'az 'eh 'ari'éla kotèvet, so uh Ariela writes,
178 ... 'e--h.. baxurà mamash mexo'éret. {-----laughing----} uh young woman really ugly u--h.. a really ugly woman. Following the orientation explaining the form workers in this office are supposed to fill out, at line 175 Galit moves on to describe a particular form she encountered that day that was filled out rather tactlessly by one of her co-workers. This is the beginning of the complication of her narrative, and it is preceded by 'akitser (line 175). Certainly, lines 154–170 are not a digression from her story. However, in progressing towards the climax of the story, they are of secondary importance compared to the complicating action, and 'akitser helps construct them as such. This is similar to Ferrara’s characterization of English anyway: in 40% of this discourse marker’s tokens throughout her data, anyway occurs “after preceding orientational detail given by the teller” (1997:€359). This use is much less prevalent in the Hebrew data – only 2 such cases (out of 37 resumptive bekitsur tokens, 5.4%) were found in the present database. However, as the following sections show, bekitsur occurs not only between orientation and complication in narratives, but also at other narrational episode boundaries. 4.3.2.3 Following evaluation A storyteller can retroactively construct an evaluative section of the narrative as being of secondary importance. One example comes from the Tractor Chase conversation, in the midst of the complicating action, as David describes his chase after the owner of the tractor that he is supposed to repossess: Excerpt 11 (‘Tractor Chase’): 46 David: .... ve'ani kmo metumtám, and I like an idiot, 47
... rodéf 'axaràv. am running after him.
48
... ke'ilu like
49
.. barégel, by foot,
50
'axarèy tráktor, after a tractor,
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
51
betòx kol habóts haze? in all the mud this in all this mud?
52
... veke'ilu haragláyim sh’xa, and like the feet your (masc. sg.) and like your feet,
53
nitka'ot bifním kaze, get stuck inside like get stuck inside like,
kx kx kx kx. {sounds imitating the sound of feet in the mud}
54
55
... bekitsúr vela'inyá--n, in short and to the point,
56
... 'axaré--y, after,
57
.. mirdáf she--, a chase that,
58
ne'eràx kemispàr dakó--t, lasted roughly a few minutes,
59
.... hitslàxti lehagia 'ad latráktor, I managed to get to the tractor,
60
.. lisgór lo ’ta to close for him the to close his
61
ke'ìlu lexabót ta’manòa, like to turn off the engine like to turn off his engine,
62
lakáxti ta’maftèax. I took the key.
In lines 46–47, David describes the ridiculousness of the situation. Lines 48–51 are a self-rephrasal of this description, preceded by the discourse marker of self-rephrasal ke'ilu (‘like’, line 48), explicating the phrase kmo metumtam (‘like an idiot’) of line 46. From these lines we learn why David felt like an idiot running after the guy whose tractor he was supposed to repossess: he was running after a moving tractor by foot, in the mud. To further enhance his story and involve the audience, he adds a short evaluative episode depicting the feet getting stuck in the mud (lines
Metalanguage in Interaction
52–53) along with the sound they make in this state (line 54)23. At line 55, however, he returns to the complication describing the actions he took – reaching the tractor, switching off its engine, and taking the key (lines 59–62). This return to the complicating actions is preceded by the discourse marker bekitsur embellished by the fixed formula (Pawley and Syder 1983) bekitsúr vela'inyán (‘in short and to the point’), implying that the previous utterance was perhaps not precisely ‘to the point’. Again, the evaluative episode, contribute as it might to audience involvement in the story, is constructed as being of secondary importance as far as progressing towards the climax of the story is concerned. The characterization of evaluative material as being of secondary importance is consistent with Labov’s description: A complete narrative begins with an orientation, proceeds to the complicating action, is suspended at the focus of evaluation before the resolution, concludes with the resolution, and returns the listener to the present time with the coda. The evaluation of the narrative forms a secondary structure which is concentrated in the evaluation section but may be found in various forms throughout the narrative (Labov 1972:€369, emphasis mine).
This characterization of the secondary nature of evaluation is also in agreement with other studies of foregrounding and backgrounding in discourse, e.g., Reinhart 1984:€783, Brinton 1996:€45. 4.3.2.4 Organizing the hierarchy of episodes in a story In long and involved stories which often include embedded stories as episodes, bekitsur functions to organize the hierarchy of episodes, thus aiding the listener in following the main storyline. In the continuation of the ‘Doctors’ narrative, Nurit tells that Doctor Abu had recommended some antibiotic, but the orthopedic surgeon they then went to on a Thursday decided to take a culture and give another antibiotic instead. Nurit then proceeds to an episode constituting an embedded story lasting 37 intonation units (only the end of which is given here) about how the nurse sent this culture to the lab only on Sunday, and how they found that out from Doctor Abu. In the following segment, Nurit summarizes this embedded story and moves on to the continuation of the first story: Excerpt 12 (‘Doctors’): 172 Nurit: .. ve... vedoctor 'ábu berèr, and and Doctor Abu checked,
23. For a detailed study of this segment, particularly with respect to the tokens of kaze (‘like’) and ke'ilu (‘like’) found in it, see Maschler 2001 and Chapter 4.
Chapter 3.╇ The textual realm
173
.. pashút, simply,
174
.. hitkashér lama'abadà--, called (to) the lab,
175
.. venatàn ta’mispar te'udat zehú--t, and gave the number of certificate identification and gave the number of the ID card, ke--n. yeah.
176 Sarah: 177 Nurit: .. veta’ and ev 178 Sarah:
ken. yeah.
179 Nurit: .. ta’kó--l, everything, 180
.. vehistabé--r, and it turned out,
181
sheràk beyom rishón, that only on day first that only on Sunday,
182
hi masrá 'et ze. she sent it.
183
.... kitsú--r,
184
.. hu-- 'amár, he said,
185
shexayavìm lehaxlif ta’'antibyótika. that they must change the antibiotic.
At line 183 Nurit employs kitsur to return from this embedded story about the nurse, and proceeds to the following complicating action of the main story describing Doctor Abu’s instructions to change the antibiotic given by the orthopedic surgeon. This token of bekitsur, then, helps organize the various embedded stories in this 262 intonation unit long story. Several linguists suggest that grounding is not a dichotomous matter of some binary foreground vs. background distinction, but rather, that it is a scalar matter (e.g., Hopper and Thompson 1980:€ 252, Fleischman 1985:€ 854, 862, 1990:€ 169, 184–185, Enkvist and Wårvik 1987:€ 224, Wårvik 1987:€ 380, 385–386, Brinton
Metalanguage in Interaction
1996:€269). The majority of these studies focus on the formal aspects of the verb constructing grounding in discourse. The present study examines employment of discourse markers for this purpose. The existence of a marker retroactively constructing background episodes supports the view of grounding as scalar, because it shows that participants themselves treat grounding as a flexible matter that they can manipulate. 4.4
Returning from insertion sequences
The final category in Dascal and Katriel’s classification of digression is that of insertion sequences; namely, corrective and clarificatory conversational actions which “have an intermediary standing between utterance- and interaction-based digressions” (1982:€82). One such case was seen in excerpt 1, line 121, following the clarification sequence initiated by the addressee concerning the term