Microwave Photonics
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Edited by Stavros Iezekiel © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 978-0-470-84854-8
Microwave Photonics Devices and Applications Edited by
Stavros Iezekiel Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Cyprus, Cyprus
This edition first published 2009 # 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd Registered office John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 8SQ, United Kingdom For details of our global editorial offices, for customer services and for information about how to apply for permission to reuse the copyright material in this book please see our website at www.wiley.com. The right of the author to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, without the prior permission of the publisher. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. Designations used by companies to distinguish their products are often claimed as trademarks. All brand names and product names used in this book are trade names, service marks, trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The publisher is not associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Microwave photonics : devices and applications / edited by Stavros Iezekiel. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978 0 470 84854 8 (cloth) 1. Microwave devices. 2. Photonics. 3. Electrooptics. 4. Optoelectronics. I. Iezekiel, Stavros. TK7876.M265 2009 621.3810 3 dc22 2008052215 A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. ISBN: 978 0 470 84854 8 Set in 10/12pt Times New Roman by Thomson Digital, Noida, India. Printed in Great Britain by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham, Wiltshire.
Contents List of Contributors
vii
Preface
xi
List of Acronyms
xv
Part I 1
Introduction to Microwave Photonics
Microwave Photonics – an Introductory Overview Stavros Iezekiel
1 3
Part II Component Technologies
39
2
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics Rajeev Ram and Harry Lee
41
3
High-power Distributed Photodetectors for RF Photonic Applications Sagi Mathai and Ming C. Wu
67
4
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation Andreas St€ ohr and Dieter J€ ager
85
5
Terahertz Sources R. E. Miles and M. Naftaly
111
Part III Systems Applications
131
6
Analogue Microwave Fibre-optic Link Design Edward I. Ackerman and Charles H. Cox, III
133
7
Fibre Radio Technology Dalma Novak, Ampalavanapillai Nirmalathas, Christina Lim, and Rod Waterhouse
169
vi
Contents
8
Microwave Photonic Signal Processing Jos e Capmany, Jos e Mora, Daniel Pastor, Beatriz Ortega, and Salvador Sales
191
9
RF and Microwave Photonics in Biomedical Applications Afshin S. Daryoush
239
10 Characterization of Microwave Photonic Components Stavros Iezekiel
291
Index
333
List of Contributors Edward I. Ackerman Photonics Systems, Inc., 900 Middlesex Turnpike, Building #5, Billerica, MA 01821, USA. Email:
[email protected] Jose Capmany Optical and Quantum Communications Group, ITEAM Research Institute, Polytechnic University of Valencia, Camino de Vera, s/n 46022 Valencia, Valencia, Spain. Email:
[email protected] Charles H. Cox, III Photonics Systems, Inc., 900 Middlesex Turnpike, Building #5, Billerica, MA 01821, USA. Email:
[email protected] Afshin S. Daryoush Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Drexel University, Bossone 312, 3141 Chestnut Street, Philadelphia, PA 19104-2875, USA. Email:
[email protected] Stavros Iezekiel Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Cyprus, 75 Kallipoleos Avenue, P.O. Box 20537, 1678 Nicosia, Cyprus. Email:
[email protected] Dieter J€ ager Universit€at Duisburg-Essen, ZHO/Optoelektronik, Lotharstr. 55, 47057 Duisburg, Germany. Email:
[email protected] Harry Lee Physical Optics and Electronics Group, Research Laboratory of Electronics, Room 26-459, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, MA 02139-4307, USA. Email:
[email protected] Christina Lim ARC Special Research Centre for Ultra-Broadband Information Networks (CUBIN), Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, The University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia. Email:
[email protected]
viii
List of Contributors
Sagi Mathai Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences and Berkeley Sensors and Actuators Center, 261M Cory Hall, 3-0808, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720-1770, USA. Email:
[email protected] Bob Miles Professor of Semiconductor Electronics, Institute of Microwaves and Photonics, School of Electronic Electrical Engineering, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK. Email:
[email protected] Jose Mora Optical and Quantum Communications Group, ITEAM Research Institute, Polytechnic University of Valencia, Camino de Vera, s/n 46022 Valencia, Valencia, Spain. Email:
[email protected] Mira Naftaly National Physical Laboratory, Hampton Road, Teddington, Middlesex TW11 0LW, UK. Email:
[email protected] Ampalavanapillai Nirmalathas ARC Special Research Centre for Ultra-Broadband Information Networks (CUBIN), Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, The University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia; and National ICT Australia, Victoria Research Laboratory. Email:
[email protected] Dalma Novak Pharad, LLC, 797 Cromwell Park Drive, Suite V, Glen Burnie, MD 21061, USA; and ARC Special Research Centre for Ultra-Broadband Information Networks (CUBIN), Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, The University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia. E-mail:
[email protected] Beatriz Ortega Optical and Quantum Communications Group, ITEAM Research Institute, Polytechnic University of Valencia, Camino de Vera, s/n 46022 Valencia, Valencia, Spain. Email:
[email protected] Daniel Pastor Optical and Quantum Communications Group, ITEAM Research Institute, Polytechnic University of Valencia, Camino de Vera, s/n 46022 Valencia, Valencia, Spain. Email:
[email protected] Rajeev Ram Research Laboratory of Electronics and Professor of Electrical Engineering, Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, Room 36-491, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA. Email:
[email protected]
List of Contributors
ix
Salvador Sales Optical and Quantum Communications Group, ITEAM Research Institute, Polytechnic University of Valencia, Camino de Vera, s/n 46022 Valencia, Valencia, Spain. Email:
[email protected] Andreas St€ ohr Universit€at Duisburg-Essen, ZHO/Optoelektronik, Lotharstr. 55, 47057 Duisburg, Germany. Email:
[email protected] Rod Waterhouse Pharad, LLC, 797 Cromwell Park Drive, Suite V, Glen Burnie, MD 21061, USA; and ARC Special Research Centre for Ultra-Broadband Information Networks (CUBIN), Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, The University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia. Email:
[email protected] Ming C. Wu Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences and Berkeley Sensors and Actuators Center, 261M Cory Hall, 3-0808, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720-1770, USA. Email:
[email protected];
[email protected]
Preface Microwave engineering and photonics technology are two areas of electrical engineering that have had a dramatic impact on everyday life, in particular in the fields of communication and sensing. The last few decades have seen optical techniques dominating long haul communications, and optical-fibre-to-the-home deployment is being actively pursued in some regions. The huge bandwidth of optical fibres has acted as the spur to develop techniques such as wavelength division multiplexing and to design optoelectronic components, driver electronics and receiver electronics operating at ever higher speeds. This means that the designers of optical-fibre systems have to now consider microwave design issues when dealing with optoelectronic components and their associated electronics. We have also witnessed phenomenal growth in wireless communications in order to support an increasingly mobile and nomadic lifestyle, and this has been driven by advances not only in signal processing but also microwave components and systems. Whilst early generations of wireless systems have operated at a few GHz, there is substantial research and development activity in mm-wave wireless technology and this has been supported by the development of radio-over-fibre in which optical networks are used for signal distribution and also mm-wave signal generation. Whatever form future generations of communications networks take, it is clear that the physical layer will continue to be dominated by photonics technology (for wired) and microwave technology (for wireless). The ‘interface’ between microwave and photonics technologies will therefore also be of major importance and this ‘interface’ has created a new interdisciplinary field known as microwave photonics. In order to gain a clearer definition of microwave photonics, it is perhaps best to refer to applications and examples. Whenever one has to consider bit rates of several Gb/s in an optical fibre communication system, then microwave design techniques must be applied to components such as modulators and photodiodes. Thus the application of microwave engineering to the design of high-speed optoelectronic components and optical fibre systems is an example of microwave photonics. However, it is the availability of high-speed optoelectronics and optical fibres that has also opened up the possibility of using optical fibre links to transport microwave signals in applications such as phased array antennas, radio astronomy arrays and distributed antenna arrays for in-building wireless communications. Hence the application of photonics technology and techniques to microwave systems is another example of microwave photonics. As microwave photonics has matured, however, we have seen the emergence of more advanced applications of photonics to microwave engineering, leading to enhanced ‘functionality’. Light modulated at microwave frequencies is now being investigated for medical imaging, and we are also seeing the emergence of ‘microwave photonic signal generation and processing’. The
xii
Preface
primary motivation here is to take advantage of the large time-bandwidth product available from optical fibres. A good example of this is the use of optical fibres (in the form of recirculating loops, and more recently through the use of Bragg grating structures and optical amplifiers) to perform filtering of microwave signals. This area of microwave photonics has since expanded to include the development of microwave oscillators using fibre loops (socalled optoelectronic oscillators) and the implementation of analogue-to-digital converters, photonic ‘time stretch’ and arbitrary waveform generation. In addition, we have seen the use of photonics techniques to generate microwave and mm-wave signals through the realization of optical comb generators and optical phase-locked loops in addition to optical heterodyning. This last technique also forms the basis of THz signal generation, where the primary interest is in using the THz spectrum to explore sensing and imaging applications. (The advantage here is that the wavelengths in the THz part of the spectrum enable spectroscopy of molecules.) In fact the THz spectrum has now begun to enter the domain of microwave photonics, since it occupies the ‘gap’ between microwaves and optics. As such, techniques for THz signal generation from both microwave engineering (e.g. Gunn diodes) and from photonics (e.g. heterodyning) are being explored, and the field uses concepts and component designs originating from both microwaves and optics. From an educational perspective, the fields of microwave engineering and photonics are often taught in separate courses (this being yet another symptom of the modularization of many modern degree courses). It is quite rare to find textbooks let alone courses which treat both in a unified way, and as a consequence the field of microwave photonics tends to be populated by practitioners with a mix of backgrounds physicists and electrical engineers mostly. Some have come to the topic as microwave engineers, optical engineers or semiconductor optoelectronics specialists, each having to learn something of the others fields. This is challenging, since microwave photonics encompasses physical concepts, devices and systems in two different parts of the spectrum. A microwave photonics engineer needs to be well-versed in electromagnetism, semiconductor electronics and optoelectronics, circuit and optics design and communications theory and systems to name but a few topics. Over time a small community of microwave photonics engineers has developed, as evidenced for example by special joint issues of the IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques/OSA Journal of Lightwave Technology and the development of conferences such as the IEEE Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics. The time is now appropriate for the publication of books in this field, and some texts have already been published on the topics of analogue links and component technology. The aim of this book is to provide some flavour of the work being carried out in this field, and as such it is more an ‘anthology’ rather than an exhaustive compendium of knowledge. To do full justice to the breadth of work being done under the umbrella of microwave photonics would result in an unwieldy tome and the fast pace of innovation and the generation of new applications would soon require the inclusion of new topics in a future edition. Instead I have sought to provide a snapshot of selected work at both the device level and the application level that gives an indication of how microwave photonics can be applied to the design of highspeed optoelectronics and how such high-speed optoelectronics can be exploited for applications in areas such as wireless communications, medical imaging and measurements. Each of the chapters has been written by experts in these particular areas, and it is hoped that both existing practitioners and researchers new to the field will find something that whets their appetite for future work in this exciting area.
Preface
xiii
My sincere thanks and appreciation go to the contributing authors who took time out of their busy schedules to write and revise their chapters. In addition, I thank all my students and colleagues (past and present) who have indirectly contributed to the book via discussions on various parts of microwave photonics technology. On the publishing side, I am particularly indebted to Juliet Booker for helping me through the final stages of production. Finally, I must thank my family (and especially Kalina) for their constant support and understanding. Stavros Iezekiel Nicosia, Cyprus October 2008
List of Acronyms ADC AGC ALMA APD AR ASE AWG BCL BDT BEON BER BLNA BS BSCCO BWC BWO CATV CDMA CMOS CMRR CNR CO CPS CPW CTB CW DAS DAST DBR DD/IM DE-MZM DFB DFG DHBT
analogue to digital converter automatic gain control Atacama Large Millimetre Array avalanche photodiode anti-reflection amplified spontaneous emission arrayed waveguide grating bipolar cascade laser ballistic deflection transistor bilateral electro-optic network bit-error rate bilateral lightwave network analyzer base station Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8 backward wave cancellation backward wave oscillator cable television code division multiple access complementary metal oxide semiconductor common mode rejection ratio carrier-to-noise ratio central office coplanar strip coplanar waveguide composite triple beat continuous wave distributed antenna system 4-(4-Dimethylaminostyryl)-1-methylpyridinium tosylate distributed Bragg reflector direct detection/intensity modulation dual-electrode Mach Zehnder modulator distributed feedback difference frequency generation double heterojunction bipolar transistor
xvi
DS DUT EAM EDFA EM EMI EML EO E/O ESA FBG FC/APC FDA FDLF FDPM FEL FEM FET FGDLF FIR FO FP FSR FTTH FWM HBV HD HEMT HFC HIC HiperLAN HR IF IIR IM IM/DD IMD IMD3 IMPATT IP LAN LCA LCFBG LMDS LO LT LTI
List of Acronyms
dual sources device under test electro-absorption modulator erbium-doped fibre amplifier external modulation electromagnetic interference electro-absorption-modulated laser electro-optic electrical to optical European Space Agency fibre Bragg grating fibre connector/angled physical contact Food and Drug Administration fibre delay line filter frequency-domain photon migration free-electron laser finite element model field effect transistor fibre grating delay line filter finite impulse response fibre optic Fabry Perot free spectral range fibre-to-the-home four-wave mixing heterostructure barrier varactor harmonic distortion high electron mobility transistor hybrid fibre coax hybrid integrated circuit high-performance radio LAN high-reflection intermediate frequency infinite impulse response intensity modulation intensity modulation/direct detection intermodulation distortion third-order intermodulation distortion impact avalanche transit time internet protocol local area network lightwave component analyser linearly chirped fibre Bragg gratings local multipoint distribution system local oscillator low-temperature grown linear time invariant
List of Acronyms
MAN MASER MBE MIC MLLD MMF MMI MMIC MQW MSLR MSM MS-TWDP MTI MWP MWPSP MZI MZM NDR NEP NF NIR OA O/E OEL OFCG OFDM OMD OP OPO OPPL OSSB OSSBþC OTDR PAN PCS PD PDW PF-VMDP PIN PIIN PLL PM PMD PMT PO PRF PRI
metropolitan area network microwave amplification by stimulated emission molecular beam epitaxy monolithic integrated circuit mode-locked laser diode multimode fibre multimode interference microwave monolithic integrated circuit multiple quantum well main-to-secondary lobe ratio metal semiconductor metal multisection travelling wave distributed photodetector moving target identification microwave photonic microwave photonic signal processing Mach Zehnder interferometer Mach Zehnder modulator negative differential resistance noise equivalent power noise figure near infrared optical amplifier optical to electrical optoelectronic optical frequency comb generators orthogonal frequency division multiplexing optical modulation depth optical prefiltering optical parametric oscillator optical phase locked loop optical single sideband optical single sideband with carrier optical time domain reflectometry personal area network personal communication system photodetector photon density waves parallel fed VMDP a junction diode with an intrinsic layer between doped p and n layers phase induced intensity noise phase locked loop polarization-maintaining polarization mode dispersion photomultiplier tube photonic oscillator pulse repetition frequency inter-pulse period
xvii
xviii
PVDF QB Q-BER QCSE QCL RF RIN RN RoF RTD SBS SCH SCM SCML SDE SEM SFDR SI SIS SKA SLED SLM SNR SOA SPM SRS SS SSB TAR TFBG TO TRS TUNNETT TWPD UMTS USB UTC UTC-PD VCSEL VMDP VNA VOA WDM WI-MUX WI-OADM XPM
List of Acronyms
polyvinylidenfluorid quadrature bias point quasi-ballistic electron reflection quantum confined Stark effect quantum cascade laser radio frequency relative intensity noise remote node radio over fibre resonant tunnelling diodes stimulated Brillouin scattering separate confinement heterostructure subcarrier multiplexing subcarrier multiplexed label standard diffusion equation scanning electron micrograph spur-free dynamic range semi-insulating superconductor insulator superconductor Square Kilometre Array superlattice electron device spatial light modulator signal-to-noise ratio semiconductor optical amplifier self-phase modulation stimulated Raman scattering signal source single sideband thru-attenuate-reflect tapered fibre Bragg grating transistor outline time-resolved reflectance spectroscopy tunnel injection transit time travelling wave photodetector universal mobile telecommunications system upper sideband uni-travelling carrier uni-travelling-carrier photodiode vertical cavity surface emitting laser velocity match distributed photodetector vector network analyser variable optical attenuator wavelength division multiplexed wavelength-interleaved multiplexer wavelength-interleaved optical add-drop multiplexer cross-phase modulation
Part I Introduction to Microwave Photonics
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Edited by Stavros Iezekiel © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 978-0-470-84854-8
1 Microwave Photonics – an Introductory Overview Stavros Iezekiel In the 1960s, photonics was seen by some visionaries as a possible alternative to microwaves for future high-speed communications. Towards the end of that decade it was not clear which one of these two technologies would eventually prevail for terrestrial telecommunications; indeed, there were trials of a long-distance ‘Millimetric Waveguide’ system by the UK Post Office [1] (which would eventually be abandoned in favour of optical fibre). It was always clear, however, that the two technologies are complementary to one another in many ways, and it is not surprising that they should overlap and merge to form a new interdisciplinary topic microwave photonics. In this chapter we aim to: (i) define what is meant by the term ‘microwave photonics’, (ii) describe its evolution, (iii) discuss its advantages and limitations and (iv) describe its applications.
1.1 The Roots of Microwave Photonics Microwave photonics combines technology developed for both the microwave and optical parts of the spectrum (Figure 1.1) [2]. From a historical basis, examples of simple optical communications have existed since ancient times; these relied on human vision to observe signals, such as those generated using semaphore codes by Chappe’s optical telegraph in revolutionary France [3]. The subsequent appearance of the electrical telegraph [4], however, suppressed optical communications for over a century. The first commercially successful transatlantic telegraph cable was installed in 1866 and it would take another century before the publication by Kao and Hockham [5] of a paper outlining how, with suitable reductions of losses in silica, dielectric waveguides in the form of optical fibres could be used for signal transmission. In addition to the telegraph, researchers in the 19th century also began to examine wireless communications. Despite the demonstration of the photophone in 1880 [6] the first example of a free-space link in which modulation of a light beam’s intensity and photodetection of it
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Edited by Stavros Iezekiel © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 978-0-470-84854-8
4
RF & Microwaves
30 MHz
X-ray
Ultraviolet
Visible
Mid-infrared
Far-infrared
10-8 10-9
Optics
Electronic techniques
30 kHz
1 nm
1 µm
1 mm
10-4 10-5 10-6 10-7
Sub-Mm-wave
10-2 10-3
Microwave
10-1
1
Ultrashortwave
Shortwave
10
Extremely ultrashortwave
102
Mediumwave
Longwave
1 cm
Wavelength (m)
104 103
Mm-wave
1 km
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
3 GHz 30 GHz
THz Gap
Photonics
3 THz
3 PHz
Frequency
Figure 1.1
The electromagnetic spectrum
was employed for telephone transmission radio techniques eventually took over and have dominated wireless transmission ever since. The advantages of higher frequencies were recognized early on, and mm-wave transmission was pioneered by Chandra Bose [7] in the 1890s. It was the Second World War and the need for radar, however, that provided the impetus for increased research activity in microwave engineering. Vacuum tubes were the workhorse of microwave electronics for radar systems and then satellite communications, but compound semiconductor technology has since dominated the field of active microwave circuits. In particular, GaAs microwave monolithic integrated circuits (MMICs) have enabled compact and complex circuits of the type needed in applications such as mobile communications and satellite navigation receivers, and the evolving technologies of SiGe and RF CMOS contribute to the continued development of low-cost transceiver technology. A key component in a communication system is a sinusoidal oscillator. One method of producing coherent oscillations is through stimulated emission, and in the early 1950s the first maser (microwave amplification by stimulated emission) was demonstrated. It was to be the optical maser [8], however, better known as the laser that would eventually revolutionize communications (and also many other areas of science and technology). The first solid-state laser was developed by Maiman in 1960 [9] and was soon followed by the first gas laser [10]. Lasing was to be demonstrated subsequently in many other material systems, including semiconductors. If one considers the free-space wavelength of the first laser (ruby), which is 694.3 nm, the corresponding frequency is 432 THz. Even 1% modulation of this frequency still results in a bandwidth far in excess of microwave systems and it was simple calculations such as these that caught the attention of communication engineers in the early 1960s [11]. In spite of the obvious attractions of an optical oscillator, it was still some years away from commercial success and significant progress would have to be made in the many other components needed for an optical communications link. Aside from the practical difficulties of modulating an
Microwave Photonics
an Introductory Overview
5
optical carrier at high frequencies and then detecting it, there remained the significant problem of guiding it between transmitter and receiver. Proposals for hollow waveguides with periodically located lenses were at one point under serious consideration, but were eventually discarded as impractical. Looking back at a review of the field from 1970 [12] gives some indication of how there was scepticism as to whether optical communications would supplant microwave and mm-wave communications: Whether or not there will be a real need for the potentially large bandwidth possibilities in the optical and near optical region remains something of a question. Even some of the warmest adherents of optical communications laugh at questions about ‘payoff’. Some of them assert that they are working with optical devices and systems out of scientific curiosity, because it is fun, because it is intriguing, and other such reasons. Nilo Lindgren, Optical Communications A Decade of Preparations, 1970 [12]
The above statement was made only four years after the feasibility of optical fibre was reported in Kao and Hockham’s seminal paper [5], and barely a decade after semiconductor laser diodes were demonstrated [13]. Despite the rather cautious nature of Lindgren’s analysis, the communications industry viewed the large potential bandwidth of optical communications as being sufficient incentive to pursue the continued development of both optical fibre and semiconductor optoelectronic components. Breakthroughs such as Corning’s demonstration of relatively low attenuation in silica fibre [14] and room-temperature operation of laser diodes [15] provided some of the ingredients needed for commercially viable optical links. Since then, the success of optical fibre communications has more than surpassed what many of its earliest developers would have dared hoped for. Field trials of first-generation systems in the late 1970s using multimode fibre operating at 850 nm had bit-rate distance products of approximately 1 Gb/s-km. This figure-of-merit would go on to double approximately every two years due to the development of a further four generations of optical communications [16]; techniques such as wavelength division multiplexing [17] and soliton transmission [18], both of which were enabled by optical amplifiers [19], meant that long-distance optical fibre links had broken the 1 Tb/s barrier by 2000 (Figure 1.2). Long-awaited developments in fibre-to-thehome (FTTH) are also starting to bear fruit, with a steady evolution from 10 Gb/s Ethernet (10 GbE) through to recent interest in 40 Gb/s and 100 Gb/s Ethernet (IEEE 802.3). Most optical fibre links are used for digital communications, but due to the high bit rates that are often involved, one must apply analogue microwave techniques to the design of components such as high-speed lasers, optical modulators and photodetectors. In a Mach Zehnder modulator, for example, it is important to design the electrodes correctly in order to match the phase velocities of the microwave and optical signals. This is a problem in transmission line design. Travelling wave effects must also be considered in certain photodetector designs, while impedance matching techniques play an important part in microwave fibre-optic link design. The study of the interaction of optoelectronic devices with microwave signals is a cornerstone of microwave photonics, but the topic is much wider than this as we shall see in the following sections. Before proceeding to define exactly what ‘microwave photonics’ means, some mention should be made of the root words. The term ‘microwaves’ [20] refers to signals in the frequency
6
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
10
Using polarization multiplexing
0
Tb /s
2008 1998
100
10
Improving photonics
Number of wavelength channels
1000
2006
10 2003
1998
Tb /
s
1996
1
1995 1993 1989
1977
1 1983 1986 1987 1991 Improving electronics
0.1 0.01
2001 2003 2001
0.1
Tb /s
1995
10
G b/ s
1 10 100 Data rate per channel (Gb/s)
10
0
G b/ s
1000 Total capacity
Figure 1.2 Improvements in optical fibre link bit rates and link distance; data points prior to 2004 taken from H. Kogelnik, ECOC’04 (Paper Mo1.1.1)
range between 300 MHz and 300 GHz (while the term ‘mm-waves’ refers to signals with wavelengths of the order of millimetres). ‘Photonics’ [21] is a term that is analogous to electronics, in that it implies control of photons (as opposed to electrons) in either free-space or matter. The photon energies of interest are in the range 0.5 eV to 2 eV, corresponding to freespace wavelengths spanning the visible spectrum as well as the infrared and ultraviolet on either side. One may argue that the term optics could be applied instead, given that we are dealing with the optical part of the spectrum. The fact that multiple terms are available in this field including optoelectronics, electro-optics and lightwaves can be confusing, especially given the lack of complete agreement over the precise meaning of these terms. The fields of electronics and photonics are, at the fundamental physical level, intertwined in any case, since accelerating electrons generate light and light propagating through optical media interacts with dipoles. Whilst electron electron interaction is strong (with the result that devices such as transistors are feasible), light light interaction is weak and devices such as lasers and photodiodes rely on electron photon interaction. In the former electrons control the flow of photons, while in the latter the roles are reversed. According to Saleh and Teich [21], electro-optics is used to refer to optical devices in which electrical effects play a key role (examples include lasers and modulators); optoelectronics refers to devices that are essentially electronic (e.g. diodes) in which optical effects are important (examples include photodiodes). In recent years the term ‘lightwave’ has also proved popular, and the term is to ‘microwave’ as photonics is to electronics. Lightwave technology is commonly used to refer to systems that combine electro-optic and optoelectronic devices with an optical transmission medium (usually optical fibre) in order to transmit and/or process optical signals. Here we will largely use the word photonics to deal with devices and systems in which photons may be generated, transmitted, controlled or detected. As such, the photons are likely to interact with matter and electrons at various points in the system.
Microwave Photonics
7
an Introductory Overview
1.2 What is Microwave Photonics? Microwave photonics has been defined by Seeds and Williams [22] as having two aspects: (i) the study of photonic devices which are capable of processing microwave signals, and (ii) the application of photonic components and techniques to microwave systems. The first definition will be familiar to those who have worked with high-speed fibre-optic links. This line of research parallels the general field of optical fibre communications, in which significant progress has been made with devices such as lasers, modulators and photodetectors that are capable of handling digital signals up to several Gb/s (or analogue signals up to several GHz). The second definition is a consequence of high-speed optoelectronic components (that were originally developed for the telecommunications industry) being available ‘off-theshelf’. This has allowed them to be used not only for transmission of analogue microwave signals over optical fibre, but also for the processing of microwave signals in the optical domain. This includes tasks such as filtering and analogue-to-digital conversion, and a major advantage of using photonics in a microwave system is the huge bandwidth potential of optical fibre coupled with low optical loss.
1.3 Why Use Microwave Photonics? Microwave and photonic components process electromagnetic waves, albeit in different parts of the spectrum. When combined together in an appropriate sequence, we have a microwave photonic system, and a simple example illustrating the basic concepts is shown in Figure 1.3. This diagram uses terminology borrowed from the lightwave measurements community (see Chapter 10 and also [23]), in which analogue electrical signals in the microwave frequency range are denoted by ‘E’ and optical signals modulated by these same electrical signals are denoted by ‘O’. Conversion between the two domains is carried out by an E/O (electrical-tooptical) transducer at the input and an O/E (optical-to-electrical) transducer at the output end. Between the E/O and O/E stages is the O/O component, which in many examples is optical fibre. It is the exceptional qualities of optical fibre as a transmission medium which are behind the success of optical communications in general, and which provided one of the primary motivations for microwave photonics research. These include low cost, low weight (typically 1.7 kg/km for fibre as opposed to 567 kg/km for coaxial cable [2]), low cross-sectional area, high degree of physical flexibility, immunity to electromagnetic interference and relatively low dispersion (especially at 1310 nm for silica single-mode fibre) and very low loss (as low as 0.2 dB/km at 1550 nm in terms of optical loss, which is equivalent to just 0.4 dB/km of electrical loss). This last quality of optical fibre is compared with other transmission media in Figure 1.4;
Input
Drive circuit
E/E Figure 1.3
Modulated optical source
E/O
Optical fibre
O/O
Photoreceiver
O/E
Output Amplifier
E/E
Block diagram of a basic microwave photonics link. Reproduced from [23] ( 2008 IEEE)
8
Figure 1.4
100 ip
0.1
0.1
Su
pe
str cro
rco
nd
uc
tor
mi
ac ou sti cw
1.0
av e
M
10
ip
str
o icr
Su rfa ce
Propagation loss for 1 µs delay (dB)
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Single-mode fibre at 1.55 µm
1.0 10 Frequency (GHz)
100
Propagation loss characteristics of various delay media (after [102])
the figure shows that an additional advantage of optical fibre is that the loss is flat as a function of microwave frequency. This is because the fractional (i.e. modulation) bandwidth is so small compared to the optical carrier, that is only a minute part of the 1550 nm wavelength window is being used. From a communications perspective, it is the fibre attenuation and dispersion (along with noise and nonlinearity due to E/O and O/E conversion) which are most crucial in determining signal degradation, but their impact differs according to the application of the link. If digital signals are applied at baseband to the link in Figure 1.3, our primary concern is to recover them at the output at an acceptable BER (bit-error rate typically 10 9) assuming that the E/O and O/E transducers can handle sufficiently high bit rates. By using Poisson statistics it is possible to arrive at the required O/E receiver sensitivity [24] for a given bit rate, which can then be used (along with knowledge of the E/O source power and fibre loss) to determine the maximum repeaterless transmission distance. The figure-of-merit that is of most interest for digital links, therefore, is the maximum bit rate distance (BL) product for a specified BER. In addition to attenuation, however, we must also consider dispersion since this will be more deleterious as bit rates increase beyond the so-called attenuation limit (Figure 1.5). In a digital link, we can tolerate a certain amount of signal degradation as long as the pulse distortion does not result in excessive bit errors at the receiver. We can use optical amplification and regeneration at regular intervals along an optical fibre in order to increase the transmission distance. Moreover, in the electronic domain advanced pulse shaping and error recovery techniques are available. From the point of view of a digital link, therefore, our main aim is to maximize the distance between repeaters and the fact that optical fibre is a superior medium (in terms of attenuation) when compared with free-space, say, is the key factor in the uptake of optical communications over long distances. When one considers analogue links one must now also factor in the effect of the E/O and O/E transducers. This is because the function of an analogue microwave photonic link is to convey a microwave signal from the input to the output with as little signal degradation as possible, and so we compare it with conventional microwave transmission media. Ideally the link should act as a ‘transparent tube’, in which the output is a delayed replica of the input signal. Looking at
Microwave Photonics
1000
Distance (km)
9
an Introductory Overview
Standard single-mode at 1550 nm Standard single-mode at 1310 nm
100 Step-index multimode
10 Graded-index multimode
1 0.1
1
10 100 Bit rate (Mb/s)
1000
10000
Figure 1.5 Attenuation and dispersion limited distance for various optical fibres; the fibres are dispersion limited at the high bit rate end and attenuation limited at the low bit rate end
the effect of the optical fibre alone, it certainly outperforms something like microstrip by a substantial margin (Figure 1.4). Not only is its loss lower, but it has a flat frequency response. These two qualities of low transmission loss and large bandwidth capability are the main factors which first persuaded researchers to investigate the use of photonic techniques in microwave systems. In order for a microwave signal to encounter this low fibre loss, it must first be converted to microwave modulation of an optical carrier and then recovered through photodetection. The E/O and O/E conversion processes introduce a penalty, typically anywhere between 20 dB and 40 dB. When this is included into the link loss calculations, then microwave fibre-optic links only yield lower loss than coaxial cables once they exceed a crossover point, as shown in Figure 1.6. A major goal of microwave photonic link design is the reduction of overall link loss, and to this end improvements can be obtained either through improved O/E conversion [25, 26] or transformer-based matching techniques [27]. In addition to affecting link loss, the inclusion of active E/O and O/E components will also have an impact on three other important performance parameters. The first of these is the overall frequency response of the link, which in turn is affected by the small-signal frequency response (also termed the modulation response when looking at E/O conversion) of the E/O and O/E components. The second is the noise figure; noise is introduced into the link by both the E/O and O/E conversion processes. Finally, E/O (and to a lesser extent O/E) components are inherently nonlinear, and thus they will act to limit the dynamic range of the microwave photonic link. The above discussion highlights the importance of improving the design and fabrication of E/O and O/E components, along with the development of link design techniques (such as impedance matching) in order to derive the most out of the excellent properties of optical fibre. Later in this book we will discuss the different technologies that are available to achieve these goals, but first we will look at how microwave signals are ‘processed’ by a microwave photonic system.
10
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications 100
Link loss (dB) at 1 GHz
90
3/8” Coax
80 70
E/O and O/E transducer losses
60 50
Upper bound 40 dB
40 30
Fibre link loss Lower bound 20 dB
20 10 0 0.001
0.01
0.1 Distance (km)
1
10
Figure 1.6 Comparison of typical coaxial cable loss compared to standard single mode fibre; between 20 dB and 40 dB of E/O and O/E transducer losses are included for the fibre
1.4 Anatomy of a Basic Microwave Photonic System We now examine the E/O and O/E conversion processes in more detail, as shown in Figure 1.7. Many microwave photonic systems use laser diodes for the E/O source module. The laser diode is basically an oscillator, which upon application of a bias current will produce lightwaves with an optical frequency (vo) of about 200 THz (assuming we choose a typical emission wavelength such as 1550 nm). If we assume the existence of a perfectly monochromatic laser and also neglect noise, the electric field at a fixed point can be represented by a time-varying complex quantity: EðtÞ ¼ E0 exp jðv0 t þ f0 Þ. In principle, the amplitude (|Eo|), frequency (vo) or phase (fo) of the lightwave may be modulated; this is analogous to the situation found in microwave communications. Once modulation has been applied to the lightwave, it will be guided by the optical fibre and be subjected to attenuation, dispersion and possible changes in polarization. At the fibre output, a photodetector is used to recover the original modulation signal. The first stage in a photodetector is a photodiode; this is a square-law device that produces a photocurrent that is directly proportional to the square of the electric field magnitude. This quantity is proportional to the intensity (W/m2), which in turn is proportional to the optical power. A photodiode can therefore only directly detect intensity modulation (i.e. modulation of |Eo|2), hence the term direct detection. Most fibre link designs are based on intensity modulation/direct detection (IM/DD) partly to have simple receiver architectures. This is in a loose sense the optical equivalent of the amplitude modulation/envelope detection scheme in radio communications, a scheme which is relatively primitive when compared to the more advanced techniques commonly used in wireless systems, such as those based on phase shift keying. The word ‘loose’ is used in the previous sentence, because if we apply a sinusoidal microwave signal of frequency vm to an E/O component, the resulting optical field will contain a central optical frequency vo and multiple sidebands at vo nvm. The exact
Microwave Photonics
ωO RF input
11
an Introductory Overview
Microwave signals reside as sidebands on an optical carrier
Modulated optical source Single-mode optical fibre
[E/O modulation]
ωm Direct modulation (intensity modulation)
External modulator
CW laser
RF input
RF output
Modulated optical input
Photo -diode
Or
Or External modulation
ωm
Direct detection
Intensity modulated optical signal (“AM”)
Directly modulated laser diode
[O/E demodulation]
Receiver options:
Source options:
RF input
RF output
Photoreceiver
Modulated optical signal Intensity, phase, or frequency modulation
Coherent detection Modulated optical input CW laser (LO)
Optical coupler
RF output
Photodiode
+ Square-law detection and LPF
Figure 1.7 Microwave photonic link architectures for direct and external modulation, and for direct and coherent detection. Reproduced from [23] ( 2008 IEEE)
form of the spectrum depends on the E/O device and bias conditions. This is in contrast to the amplitude modulation of radio signals, which normally produces no more than two sidebands. Intensity modulation can be achieved either directly or externally. Direct modulation of a laser simply means adding a time-varying current which results in the intensity (i.e. optical power) tracking changes in the current. Direct modulation up to about 30 GHz is possible, but one disadvantage of this scheme is chirp, that is the optical frequency is inadvertently modulated. This can be overcome by operating the laser in CW (continuous wave) mode and using an external modulator instead; these are voltage-driven devices and have larger modulation bandwidths (beyond 100 GHz for polymer-based devices). An added advantage of these devices is that in addition to intensity modulation, they can also provide phase and frequency modulation. However, detection of phase and frequency modulation requires coherent photoreceivers using local oscillator lasers. Whilst coherent detection offers improved sensitivity (through the use of high-power local oscillator lasers which effectively amplify the incoming signal), it is more complex to implement than direct detection and places stringent requirements on the linewidth of the source and local oscillator lasers. Moreover, the use of optical amplifiers as pre-amplifiers for photoreceivers means that the sensitivity of direct detection has been improved relative to that of coherent receivers.
12
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
1.5 Device Technology In this section we describe some of the devices which are available to provide the basic functions of E/O and O/E conversion in a microwave photonic system and we briefly discuss O/O components.
1.5.1 E/O Conversion As mentioned previously, intensity modulation of light can be achieved either through direct modulation of a laser diode or by using a modulator to externally modulate light from a CW laser [28]. External modulation is preferred in ‘high-performance’ applications whereas the advantage of direct modulation is low cost, especially when uncooled laser diodes are used. 1.5.1.1 Directly Modulated Laser Diodes The advantage of laser diodes is that they are compact and only require a few mA of drive current in order to operate; they also offer a potential route to monolithic integration with a variety of other electronic and photonic structures on the same chip. If we confine our discussion to single frequency signals, then in a directly modulated laser diode (Figure 1.8), the drive current IL is given by IB[1 þ mcos(vmt þ wm)], where IB is the bias current and m is the modulation index. We can show that the electric field emitted by the device (if we neglect chirp) has the form: p ð1:1Þ EðtÞ ¼ E0 1 þ m cos vm t expðj½vo t þ fo Þ For small-signal modulation m 1 so we can use Bessel functions to expand the electric field expression. We can show that this contains multiple frequency components of the form vo nvm. In effect the E/O transducer is an up-converter, mixing vm onto an optical carrier. However, the optical intensity will be given by the square of the electric field magnitude. If we square the magnitude of Equation (1.1), we find that the optical output power is of the form P0 ð1 þ mðcos vm t þ um ÞÞ where Po is the average power, vm is the microwave modulation
Figure 1.8
Typical light current characteristic for a laser diode. Reproduced from [23] ( 2008 IEEE)
Microwave Photonics
13
an Introductory Overview
frequency and um the phase. If we consider the light current characteristic of a laser diode, the above result makes sense. The light current (L I) characteristic is a plot of optical output power versus drive current as shown in Figure 1.8. This resembles the DC piecewise-linear I V characteristic of a diode. Above threshold and below saturation, the L I characteristic can be approximated very well by a straight line segment with a slope given by sL ¼ dPL/dIL, where sL is the slope efficiency in W/A. Ideally we want the slope efficiency to be as high as possible but it is fundamentally limited by the quantum efficiency of the laser. Hence, if we ensure that the drive current does not go below threshold or into saturation, the optical power will follow the drive current (Figure 1.8). The ‘DC’ components are related via Po ¼ sLIB, where Po is the average optical power. Although it is not obvious from the L I curve, the slope efficiency is frequency-dependent. At a given frequency, the sinusoidal components of the current and optical power can be described using phasors, and they are related via: sL ðjvm Þ ¼
pL ðjvm Þ iL ðjvm Þ
ð1:2Þ
where iL(jvm) is the modulation current phasor and pL(jvm) is the corresponding output optical power phasor. sL(jvm) is referred to as the intensity modulation response and is an important parameter. Directly modulated laser diodes have a low-pass second-order response which places a limit on the bandwidth they can support, as shown in Figure 1.9. The second-order response is a consequence of the interaction between carrier recombination and photon emission, which in the simplest case is described by a pair of nonlinear ordinary differential equations (the rate equations, as described in greater detail in Chapter 2). These can be solved to determine both the damping factor and the resonance frequency, which in turn influences the small-signal intensity modulation bandwidth. It should also be borne in mind that the bond wire and package parasitics will influence the overall response (usually in an adverse way), so optimization of these is required in high-speed laser diodes. When considering direct modulation for microwave photonics systems, we therefore have to be aware of a number of performance parameters and device limitations. Two important parameters are the slope efficiency (which will impact the overall link gain as discussed in Chapter 6) and also the bandwidth (which given the fact the O/E transducers generally have very high bandwidths will often be the limiting factor in overall link bandwidth). Limitations of the direct modulation approach include: (i) the inadvertent modulation of wavelength Parasitics can degrade the response (parasitic roll-off)
p L ( jω m ) i L ( jω m )
Resonance peak: The laser is modulated at frequencies below this point
Roll-off = 40 dB/dec (Due to second-order response)
ωm Figure 1.9
Typical intensity modulation response for a laser diode
14
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
(the chirp referred to earlier), which when combined with fibre dispersion will lead to signal degradation; (ii) nonlinearity, which can be significant at the resonance frequency (and in severe cases can lead to chaos); (iii) multiple-sideband modulation, which when combined with fibre dispersion can lead to power fading (this depends on the fibre length and the laser wavelength); (iv) relative intensity noise (RIN), which will affect the overall noise figure performance of a microwave photonic system; (v) a differential quantum efficiency which is less than unity, which results in E/O conversion loss; and (vi) perhaps most important of all, lower bandwidth compared to external modulation. In spite of the above limitations, the simplicity and relatively low cost of direct modulation are very attractive for many applications, and this continues to drive forward research in highspeed laser diodes. We can categorize laser diodes according to device structure, three main types being Fabry Perot, distributed feedback (DFB) and vertical cavity surface emitting lasers (VCSELs); these are compared in Figure 1.10. We can also classify the laser material according to whether it is bulk, quantum well or quantum dot. Over the years a large body of research has aimed to engineer both the device structure and materials in order to increase bandwidth, improve slope efficiency and also yield other improvements (such as reduced threshold current and temperature sensitivity). The use of multiple quantum wells for DFB lasers has proved particularly successful, leading to increased differential gain and reductions in threshold current compared to bulk devices. Bandwidths in excess of 30 GHz have been demonstrated for InGaAsP quantum well lasers operating at 1550 nm [29] and for distributed Bragg reflector devices [30]. In recent years much effort has been put into quantum dot devices [31], since these lasers promise near zero threshold currents and reduced sensitivity of threshold current to temperature fluctuations. This last feature is important, since it dispenses with the need for temperature control circuits, thereby leading to reduced cost. Devices for 10 Gb/s applications have been reported [32]. The theme of low cost also crops up in the development of VCSELs; here the vertical emission opens up the possibility of on-wafer test and the circular beam profile also simplifies the laser-to-fibre coupling problem. Given the renewed interest of multimode fibre for microwave photonics applications, as discussed later, the VCSEL takes on added significance for the implementation of in-building fibre radio networks for example. Modulation bandwidths of the order of 10 GHz have been obtained at 1550 nm [33]. Significant work has also been carried out with more complex structures to improve slope efficiency (e.g. the gain lever laser [34] and bipolar cascade laser [25,35]). The use of multiple junction laser transmitters [36] is discussed in more detail in Chapter 2. Recently, much work has also been done to extend the modulation frequency performance of laser diodes. Some techniques are narrowband and rely on using external optical cavities with frequency selective feedback in order to enhance the resonant response [37], while an alternative method is based on optical injection locking [38] and this has been used to demonstrate an enhanced resonance frequency of 72 GHz [39]. In this last technique, the free running lasers typically have modulation bandwidths of no more than 10 GHz. By using high optical injection ratios, it is possible not only to achieve resonant enhancement but also to enhance the 3 dB bandwidth, improve the modulation efficiency (by a factor of 10) and reduce the relative intensity noise (to 140 dB/Hz) [38]. Optical injection locking also reduces distortion, leading to enhanced spur-free dynamic range (SFDR). Recent work has focused on cascaded optical injection locking, in which an additional slave laser is introduced [40]. This enables 1.55 mm VCSELs with a free running 10 GHz bandwidth to exhibit up to 66 GHz bandwidth, thus opening up their use in mm-wave fibre radio systems.
Figure 1.10 Example structures for Fabry–Perot, DFB and VCSEL lasers
Microwave Photonics an Introductory Overview 15
16
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
1.5.1.2 External Modulation As implied by the name, external modulation entails the use of an external device (i.e. the modulator) to vary either the intensity or phase of the light emitted by a laser diode emitting a constant power level (CW mode). The obvious disadvantages are the added cost, complexity and increase in the size of the E/O module, but these are accepted in many instances because of the greater bandwidth on offer (especially important for mm-wave applications) and the greater control over which the modulation is carried out, which opens up possibilities such as singlesideband operation. Furthermore, unlike direct modulation, external modulation does not suffer from the problem of chirp. Many of the performance requirements that were discussed for direct modulation also apply in the case of external modulation, namely the need for high modulation efficiency, large bandwidth and good linearity. There are also some differences, however, the most evident being that external modulators are voltage driven rather than current driven. In addition, they have an optical input (connected to the CW laser) as well as an optical output, and so low optical insertion loss is required. Since the basic effect in an external intensity modulator is varying absorption of the optical input from the CW laser, it is desirable to have high optical power handling capability. As with direct modulation, a number of material systems and device structures are available. The most successful from a commercial perspective is the Mach Zehnder structure implemented in lithium niobate, but there are also many examples of electro-absorption modulators (fabricated from III-V semiconductors) and polymer-based devices. A particular advantage of electro-absorption modulators is the possibility of monolithic integration with the CW laser. The underlying mechanism in lithium niobate modulators is the Pockels (or linear electrooptic) effect in which an electric field (originating from an external drive voltage) induces change in the refractive index, which in turn will lead to a change in phase. When an interferometric structure is used, the phase modulation is converted to intensity modulation. The electro-optic effect is found in crystals such as lithium niobate and gallium arsenide as well as poled polymers. Figure 1.11 shows the basic structure of a lithium niobate Mach Zehnder modulator. The basic idea is that an applied voltage can be used to vary the phase shift between the two optical waveguide arms, such that when light is combined from these arms at the output it can vary between a minimum level (corresponding to destructive interference) and a maximum (due to constructive interference). The simplest Mach Zehnder design is one in which phase modulation is applied to only one of the arms, but it is also possible to have dual electrode designs and these have been used for optical single sideband generation (OSSB) in order to overcome the dispersion penalty which occurs in mm-wave fibre radio systems. In a similar vein to the analysis carried out for the directly modulated laser diode, we can consider the static transfer characteristic (Figure 1.12) of an external modulator in order to deduce parameters such as the slope efficiency. The approach has several important differences though. (i) The actual optical power level (Po) depends not only on the modulator but also on the power supplied by the CW laser source (Pi); the y-axis is a ratio of powers rather than being absolute power. (ii) The x-axis is also a ratio, of the drive voltage Vm to Vp (this being defined as the voltage required for a phase shift of p between the two modulator arms).
Microwave Photonics
17
an Introductory Overview Ti-diffused optical waveguide
CW light
Lithium niobate substrate
Figure 1.11
Electrodes
Modulated light
Simplified diagram of Mach Zehnder modulator
(iii) The transfer characteristic is periodic, in principle allowing more choice in terms of choosing the bias point. One suitable bias point is located at 3 Vp/2 as shown in Figure 1.12, and if we apply small-signal modulation then excursions in voltage will occur over a quasi-linear part of the characteristic. (It can be shown quite easily that the optimum bias point for maximum modulation efficiency can be located at any odd multiple of Vp/2.)
Figure 1.12
Mach Zehnder modulator transfer characteristic
18
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
As for the case of the directly modulated laser diode, we are interested in the slope of the characteristic in the vicinity of the bias point. The important difference here is that the points (i) and (ii) above indicate that the slope will depend on both Vp (which crudely speaking can be thought of as analogous to the threshold current in a laser diode, in that it is a property of the device) and Pi (which is in effect an external control parameter). For directly modulated laser diodes, the slope efficiency is essentially dictated by the device’s differential quantum efficiency alone. The transfer characteristic for the Mach Zehnder modulator is given by: Po Tff pVm 1 þ cos ¼ Pi 2 Vp
ð1:3Þ
where Tff is the optical insertion loss of the modulator when it is biased for maximum transmission (e.g. at zero volts). If we now apply a bias voltage of VB ¼ nVp/2 (where n is odd) and a small-signal modulation component given by vm(t), then linearization of Equation (1.3) around the bias point will yield: Po Tff pðVB þ vm ðtÞÞ Tff pvm ðtÞ ð1:4Þ 1 þ cos 1 ¼ Pi 2 2 Vp Vp from which the slope efficiency (in W/V) is obtained as: sM ¼
dPo Tff p ¼ Pi : dvm 2Vp
ð1:5Þ
Equation (1.5) shows one advantage of using an external modulator, namely that by increasing the CW laser power Pi we can increase the slope efficiency of the external modulation process. In other words the external laser acts as a ‘bias’ which can be used to control modulator efficiency, and in turn the gain of the microwave photonic link. Indeed, this approach has been used to demonstrate link gain without any other optical or electronic amplification being used. The above equation also illustrates one of the key issues of modulator design, namely the desire to reduce the drive voltage Vp so as to bring it within the range available from drive electronics (ideally below 3.5 V). One technique for doing so is to increase the microwave-optical interaction length (i.e. the electrode length), but this demands reductions in electrode and optical waveguide loss, and wafer size will ultimately place a limit on length. This can be overcome by using folded structures [41]. A further issue in modulator design is that of velocity matching, and as such this represents an excellent case study of classical microwave engineering techniques being used to optimize the performance of a microwave photonic device. In travelling-wave modulators, the electrodes are designed to act as microwave transmission lines, with the microwave signals propagating in the same direction as the optical signals (the optical waveguides being parallel with the electrodes). One advantage is that these devices are not capacitance limited in terms of their frequency response, thus enabling relatively long electrode designs (typically thousands of wavelengths [28]). It then becomes imperative that the phase velocities of the microwave signals and optical signals are matched to one another, and this should be done over a range of frequencies. In lithium niobate, the microwave signal has a lower velocity than the optical signal and so it must be speeded up usually by appropriate modification of the transmission line capacitance per unit length, this being achieved with a silicon dioxide buffer layer. Conversely,
Microwave Photonics
an Introductory Overview
19
in GaAs and InP devices this situation is reversed and the microwave signal needs to be slowed down; this can be achieved through periodic capacitive loading of the electrodes. The other transmission line issue for Mach Zehnder modulators relates to having to avoid standing wave formation on the electrode structure due to reflections from impedance mismatches. Ideally the characteristic impedance of the electrodes should match that of the driver electronics. As was the case for directly modulated laser diodes, a Mach Zehnder modulator will in general produce multiple optical sidebands when modulated by a microwave sinusoid, leading to terms in vo nvm. This is a consequence of the nonlinearity of the E/O conversion process. However, through appropriate bias and modulation conditions, it is possible to suppress higher order sidebands, leaving a carrier plus an upper and lower sideband, namely vo and vo vm. It is also possible to generate a single sideband as mentioned above, and this has uses in optical filter measurements (Chapter 10) and mm-wave fibre radio (Chapter 7). Extensive work has been done on linearization schemes for lithium niobate Mach Zehnder modulators. One of the motivations for this is to improve the dynamic range of microwave photonic links. The general approach is to connect two modulators together (either in a cascade or in a ‘dual signal’ arrangement) and select appropriate bias points such that the composite device behaves more linearly than either one of the individual modulators [42]. One of the difficulties of these approaches is the susceptibility to tight tolerance requirements and the increased optical losses due to the use of two modulators rather than one. A comparison of different schemes in terms of their bandwidth is available in [43]. Recently a new design of Mach Zehnder has been proposed in which linearization is performed by using phase control and a resonator on one of the modulator arms, leading to reduced optical losses compared to earlier techniques [44]. The one disadvantage of lithium niobate as a material is that it cannot be integrated with the laser diode source, a fact which has motivated the investigation of III-V semiconductors, including both GaAs and InP. Semiconductor-based modulators are also more compact, but the linear electro-optic (Pockels) effect is weaker than that in lithium niobate and there tends to be a poor overlap between the optical mode and the applied electric field. Furthermore the refractive index of InP, for example, is relatively higher (3.5) than that for silica optical fibres, all of which leads to increased fibre-to-fibre insertion loss for these modulators (typically 10 dB). Nevertheless, some impressive results have been achieved, including demonstrations of low drive voltage (0.45 V for a GaAs Mach Zehnder modulator for an estimated bandwidth of 50 GHz [45]) and demonstrations of 80 Gb/s modulation (for an InP modulator with capacitively loaded electrodes [46]). Another material system that has attracted much interest is organic polymers, the primary motivation being the potential for low-cost manufacturing [47]. These materials can be endowed with an electro-optic effect via high-temperature poling, resulting in a Pockels coefficient (r33) as high as 320 pm/V at 1550 nm [48], as opposed to 31 pm/V for lithium niobate. Another parameter that works in favour of electro-optic materials is the fact that the dielectric constant for the microwave signals is approximately equal to the square root of the refractive index in the optical range, meaning excellent velocity matching between microwave and optical signals on the same substrate. This removes the need for techniques such as capacitive loading of electrodes and also results in extremely wideband performance. Bandwidths in excess of 100 GHz were demonstrated some time ago [49], while drive voltages in the sub-volt region have recently been demonstrated at 1550 nm [50]. A further benefit of the polymer approach is that it lends itself to hybrid packaging of both microwave and optical
20
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
components on the same platform [51]. In spite of all these advantages, polymer modulators have been beset by a number of difficulties, including optical power handling capability and long-term bias point stability. Research work continues on refining the technology [52]. In addition to be being able to exploit the electro-optic effect in semiconductor materials in order to form Mach Zehnder modulators, it is also possible to use the electro-absorption effect. Electro-absorption can occur in both bulk semiconductors and quantum well structures; for the former it is referred to as the Franz Keldysh effect while in the latter it is called the quantum confined Stark effect (QCSE) [53]. Several examples of multiple quantum well (MQW) electro-absorption modulators (EAMs) have been reported. A typical EAM structure is one in which MQWs are embedded within the intrinsic region of a reverse-biased PIN diode, which being relatively thin (of the order of 0.1 mm) means that only a few volts will result in very large electric fields. QCSE is based on the concept of excitonic absorption, which in a MQW is stronger than in bulk materials and has a sharp spectrum at wavelengths corresponding to the bandgap energy. Application of reverse bias, however, will lead to a reduction of excitonic absorption and broadening of the spectrum, as the exciton absorption line shifts to longer wavelengths [54]. The end result of these physical effects is the set of absorption spectra shown in Figure 1.13. Because the shift of absorption spectra with varying bias occurs over a relatively narrow window of wavelengths, precise alignment between the wavelength of the CW source laser and the EAM is required. EAMs have been successfully demonstrated at frequencies as high as 60 GHz [55], and the envisioned application here would be 60 GHz fibre radio picocells. The fact that EAMs can be monolithically integrated with lasers points toward the possibility of low cost, although it should be pointed out that packaging issues still need to be resolved as does sensitivity to changes in temperature and/or bias voltage.
1.5.2 O/E Conversion An O/E transducer performs the reverse of E/O conversion, that is it converts incoming modulated light into corresponding variations of current. The term photodetection is commonly used. However, incident modulated light can also interact with electronic devices such
Absorption
Wavelength of CW source
Increasing reverse bias
Wavelength
Figure 1.13 Absorption spectra for EAM; as the bias is adjusted the absorption will vary for a given wavelength as shown
Microwave Photonics
an Introductory Overview
21
as diodes and transistors, a field known as optical control of microwaves; an excellent review can be found in [56]. Optical control can be used to perform functions such as amplifier gain control, oscillator tuning and optoelectronic mixing [57]. Although a large body of work exists on the modelling, characterization and use of optically controlled microwave devices, it is a niche area and we will concentrate on discussing high-speed photodetection instead. 1.5.2.1 Photodetection Just as the requirement of high bandwidth and conversion efficiency is demanded of E/O components for microwave photonics, the same is true for photodiodes although in this case we refer to responsivity (in A/W) as opposed to slope efficiency (in W/A or W/V) when considering conversion efficiency. The DC responsivity is given by the slope of the characteristic shown in Figure 1.14, and is defined as: R¼
IP ql ¼h PI hc
ð1:6Þ
where IP is the photocurrent generated in response to the incident optical power PI, h is the quantum efficiency, which is limited to a theoretical maximum of unity, h is Planck’s constant, c is the speed of light, q is the electron charge and l is the operating wavelength. The incremental responsivity, which will be frequency-dependent, is given by R(jv) ¼ iP(jv)/pI(jv). Here we are dealing with the modulation component of both the current and optical power. In a high-quality photodiode the responsivity will have a fairly flat frequency response. Often there is also a need for high-power handling capability, which originates from the fact that externally modulated systems have increased link gain if higher powers are used for the CW laser driving the modulator. In addition, it is required to avoid optical reflection from the device input in order to maximize the optical power entering the active region, so antireflection coatings are often used for this purpose. Two main classes of photodiode exist lumped element designs (which include vertically illuminated photodiodes and edge coupled waveguide photodiodes) and distributed designs (such as travelling wave photodiodes and periodically loaded travelling wave photodiodes). These are illustrated in Figure 1.15.
Figure 1.14
Photodiode transfer characteristic. Reproduced from [23] ( 2008 IEEE)
22
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 1.15
Examples of lumped (on the left) and distributed (on the right) photodiodes
Before discussing these various device types, brief mention should be made of the avalanche photodiode (APD), which unlike the structures in Figure 1.15 offers internal gain and hence improved receiver sensitivity without the need for external amplification. In addition, for high enough multiplication factors (i.e. gain) there is an improvement in the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) that becomes shot-noise limited provided there is little excess noise [24]. One limitation of APDs is that there is a fixed gain bandwidth product resulting from the fact that for higher multiplication factors there is an increased time required in order for the avalanche to build up within the photodiode structure [58]. This means there is a trade-off between bandwidth and gain. Gain bandwidth products in excess of 300 GHz have been demonstrated in waveguide APDs [59], hence such devices are restricted to a few tens of GHz at most if even modest gains of the order of 10 are required. Moreover, the APD structure is notorious for temperature sensitivity and the avalanche gain process requires higher operating voltages compared to photodiodes without internal gain. The device that is most commonly used in microwave photonic applications is the PIN, which has a simple structure it is a junction diode with an intrinsic layer between doped p and n layers, hence the name PIN [60]. The simplest PIN is a vertically illuminated structure in which light enters the upper layers of the device and is absorbed as it travels through the structure, generating electron-hole pairs in the depletion region. The depletion region extends mostly over the intrinsic region, being formed by a reverse bias voltage. The generated electron-hole pairs are then swept by the bias electric field to the device contacts to produce a photocurrent. One advantage of the vertical illumination scheme (also known as surface illumination) is the ease with which light can be coupled into the device. A disadvantage is the trade-off between conversion efficiency and transit-time limited microwave performance. The transit time is defined as the time taken for the photogenerated carriers to reach the device contacts and it is determined by both the width of the active absorption region and the saturation velocity in the semiconductor material. The thickness of the active region will also determine how much optical power is absorbed, with this being given by: PðdÞ ¼ P0 ð1 e
aðlÞd
Þ
ð1:7Þ
Microwave Photonics
an Introductory Overview
23
where Po is the incident optical power, P(d) is the optical power absorbed in a distance d and a(l) is the optical absorption coefficient. It is assumed here that there is no optical reflection off the device surface. Equation (1.7) clearly indicates that for improved responsivity the device must be thick enough to absorb a large fraction of the incident optical power, but this then leads to increased transit time and hence reduced bandwidth. The maximum bandwidth efficiency product for single-pass surface illuminated PIN photodiodes is of the order of 30 GHz [61]. It should also be remembered that device parasitics will affect the frequency response and must therefore be minimized, and the lumped nature of the PIN device leads to an RC time constant which can become an issue if the area of the active region is relatively much bigger than the thickness, leading to increased capacitance. In addition to bandwidth, it was mentioned earlier that power handling capability is important. The space charge effect [62] limits the extent to which optical input power can be increased before saturation, and therefore increased nonlinearity occurs. One technique for overcoming the bandwidth efficiency limitations of the vertically illuminated PIN is to try to increase the distance over which photons travel through the absorption region in order to maximize optical absorption, whilst keeping the distance that the electron-hole pairs travel as small as possible to minimize the transit time. This may be achieved through creating a resonant optical cavity in order to set up multiple passes of the optical signal through the active region [63], but the resonance leads to wavelength selectivity thus making these devices of more interest for use in wavelength division multiplexed (WDM) systems. An alternative way of increasing optical absorption and reducing the transit time impact is to use edge-coupling, thus allowing the optical input to enter the intrinsic region directly and to propagate orthogonally to the electric field. In effect the structure becomes an optical waveguide, allowing the design of long but narrow absorption regions which ensure that a large fraction of the input power is absorbed whilst maintaining low transit times [64]. Waveguide photodiodes with bandwidths in excess of 100 GHz have been demonstrated [65], and typical bandwidth efficiency products for these devices are about 55 GHz [66]. The waveguide photodiode has two disadvantages. First, the thickness of the active layer is often less than 1 mm, leading to a significant reduction in coupling efficiency between the photodiode and single-mode fibre. This can be mitigated to some extent by using tapered fibre or by fabricating devices that have doped optical guiding layers around the absorption region [60]. Secondly, the ‘long and narrow’ topology creates a capacitive region with a large area-to-thickness ratio, resulting in increased capacitance which causes an RC time limitation once device contact and load resistances are taken into account. The PIN structures discussed above are lumped element approaches. In order to eliminate the limitation of the RC time constant and to improve impedance matching, distributed designs were proposed in the early 1990s [67 69]. These are commonly known as travelling-wave photodetectors [70 72] and they are a natural evolution of the edge coupled waveguide PIN structure discussed above. In this case, in addition to the optical waveguiding mechanism, the device contacts are engineered to support microwave travelling waves; the approach is similar to Mach Zehnder travelling wave modulators in that it is another example of transmission line effects in microwave photonics. Coplanar waveguide is typically chosen which supports a quasi-TEM mode; the transmission line parameters are determined by the device capacitance and the contact strip inductance. Absorption of optical power occurs in a distributed manner along the length of the device, setting up a travelling wave on the electrodes as it does so (Figure 1.16). Such a device is no longer limited by RC effects but by the velocity mismatch
24
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Contacts (Transmission line) Electrical signal Optical input
Optical signal
Absorption region and optical waveguide
Figure 1.16
Distributed effects in a travelling wave photodetector
between the optical group velocity and electrical phase velocity [60]. When velocity matching is achieved, then long device lengths compared to waveguide photodiodes are possible in principle. The fact that the absorption volume is increased also means that these devices will saturate at a higher power level [73]. A large variety of travelling-wave photodiodes have been demonstrated and exhibit excellent performance. Bandwidths in excess of 500 GHz have been reported for PIN based devices [66], but structures based on metal semiconductor metal (MSM) [74], Schottky [75] and phototransistor structures [76] have also been published. In contrast to the other structures, the phototransistor-based travelling wave photodetector provides electrical gain as high as 35 at DC [76]. Recent work [77], however, indicates that the carrier spreading occurring in the base layer of a heterojunction phototransistor travelling-wave structure prevents independent longitudinal operation of the device in response to a position-dependent signal. The extent of the spreading leads to an effective minimum area over which a lumped capacitance limitation still remains. One method for overcoming this problem is to move away from a fully distributed topology to one which is analogous to a microwave travelling-wave amplifier, that is to use a periodically distributed photodetector. The theory of these structures is well known [69] and a variety of approaches to its implementation have been reported, including the use of multimode interference (MMI) couplers [78]. An added advantage of the periodically distributed photodetector is that it can handle higher optical powers. An alternative approach to handling high optical powers, that also offers high electrical output power is the uni-travelling-carrier (UTC) photodiode [79,80]. Applications of InPbased UTC photodiodes include optical generation of high-power mm-wave signals via heterodyning [81]. The basis of the UTC structure is that of a travelling-wave photodiode, but here the optical waveguide and absorption functions are physically separated. Optical waveguiding occurs in the n layer whilst absorption occurs in the p layer. In this way, the optical power absorption still occurs over an extended region, but the photogenerated current consists solely of electrons hence the term uni-travelling-carrier. The major advantage is that electrons are faster than holes in materials such as InP, leading to potentially high bandwidths as well as high saturation powers.
1.5.3 O/O Components The broad bandwidth of optical media is a major driver for microwave photonics, and so we will briefly discuss some O/O components suitable for microwave photonics. The main one is
Microwave Photonics
25
an Introductory Overview
Dispersion-induced power penalty (dB)
optical fibre, and many of the microwave photonic systems reported in the literature use standard single-mode fibre and associated components (such as Bragg gratings, circulators, couplers, optical amplifiers and WDM multiplexers). A major advantage of single-mode fibre is the low loss of 0.2 dB/km at 1550 nm, but one also needs to be aware that signal degradation due to chromatic dispersion, polarization-mode dispersion and nonlinearity may need to be considered. If one considers intensity modulated light then, as argued earlier, this can be considered analogous to amplitude modulation. As the optical carrier and its upper and lower sideband propagate through the fibre, dispersion will introduce a phase shift between these components [82], leading to periodic power fading [83] with distance as shown in Figure 1.17. Optical single-sideband modulation can mitigate against this fading, and this can be used to implement WDM-based fibre-radio systems as described in Chapter 7. However, one must then be wary of cross-phase modulation due to optical nonlinearities, which leads to crosstalk between WDM channels [84]. In recent years, multimode fibre has begun to be considered for microwave photonics [85], despite it having a relatively low bandwidth distance product of 500 MHz.km. This interest is due to the potential low cost of multimode fibre systems, the fact that most installed in-building fibre is multimode and the use of lasers rather than LEDs, with the subsequent demonstration of links operating up to 20 GHz [86]. Given that multimode dispersion can be thought of as equivalent to a transversal optical filter, its transfer function exhibits fading that is reminiscent of multipath fading in wireless systems. Hence orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) techniques developed to combat multipath fading for wireless systems have been investigated for multimode fibre radio [87]. Although many microwave photonic systems use passive fibre components, mention should also be made of active O/O components, namely the erbium-doped fibre amplifier (EDFA) and the semiconductor optical amplifier (SOA). The latter is of interest because of the potential to integrate it with E/O and O/E devices, while the former is better suited for splicing into fibre
0
20 GHz
-5
30 GHz
-10 -15
60 GHz
-20 -25 -30 0
1
2
3
4
5
Distance (km)
Figure 1.17 Dispersion induced power fading for standard single mode fibre at 1550 nm; curves obtained using method described in [83]
26
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
systems. A number of microwave photonic filters make use of EDFAs, while both EDFAs and SOAs have been proposed for relatively short fibre links as a means of compensating for E/O and O/E conversion losses. In this second case, optical power levels are relatively high, forcing the amplifier to operate in the gain saturation region. It has been shown theoretically and experimentally that the small-signal microwave frequency response for this mode of operation in an SOA is quasi-high-pass [88].
1.6 Applications of Microwave Photonics There are a large number of systems and devices that can be said to involve microwave photonics. The main system functions can be divided into: (i) transport of microwave and mmwave signals over optical fibre (discussed in Chapter 6); (ii) filtering and processing of microwave signals in the optical domain (discussed in Chapter 7); (iii) generation of microwave, mm-wave and THz signals using photonic techniques (discussed in Chapters 4 and 5). These three areas in turn can be subdivided into specific applications including: radio over fibre (Chapter 7), antenna remoting for radar systems, antenna beam forming, local oscillator generation for radio astronomy arrays, and THz spectroscopy. Since Chapters 4 to 10 deal with many of the above applications in detail, we will simply provide a brief overview here.
1.6.1 Signal Transport The use of optical fibre for transmission of microwave signals is often advocated due to the advantageous properties of the optical fibre itself [89]. These include low losses, good dispersion management (over the relatively short distances used in some applications), flexibility and immunity to electromagnetic interference. Moreover, the ability to first modulate and then detect modulated light for microwave modulation frequencies up to a few tens of GHz means that such links find applications in the remote location of antennas and radar signal processing, for example. The basic architecture follows the scheme in Figure 1.3. Key parameters of interest are: link gain, noise factor and spur-free dynamic range. A recent review of analogue links by Cox et al. [89] points to a number of requirements for E/O and O/E devices in order to enable higher link gain, lower noise and a wider SFDR. These include (i) directly modulated laser diodes with greater slope efficiency, bandwidth and lower relative intensity noise, (ii) CW lasers with higher output power and lower RIN, (iii) external modulators with lower Vp and higher power handling ability, and (iv) photodetectors with higher responsivity, bandwidth and saturation power. When a microwave signal is transported over fibre, the resulting link is often termed as being analogue in order to distinguish it from the digital links used in telecommunications. It is possible, however, to digitally modulate a microwave signal before transmission over an ‘analogue’ link and so Cox et al. distinguish between an analogue and digital optical link as follows. An analogue link involves small optical modulation depths, thus ensuring small-signal operation of the E/O and O/E devices, whereas a digital link relies on on off keying that may involve modulation depths close to 100 %. Perhaps the simplest signal that can be transmitted over an analogue link is a sinusoid, and there are several applications for distribution of RF, microwave and mm-wave carriers. A high
Microwave Photonics
an Introductory Overview
27
profile example is the development of fibre networks for radio astronomy facilities [90] such as SKA (the Square Kilometre Array based in Australia) and ALMA (the Atacama Large Millimetre Array based in Chile). ALMA will consist of over 60 12-metre parabolic antennas which can interferometrically detect signals between 27 GHz and 938 GHz [91]. This large frequency range is spanned by 10 bands, and the low noise heterodyne receivers at each antenna each require a local oscillator which is generated optically. The local oscillator signals are then distributed via a fibre network, which must accommodate a maximum antenna separation of 25 km. In this particular application, an optical fibre distribution network offers numerous advantages. Apart from the low loss and large bandwidth provision, the use of fibre also allows a single LO reference to be located at a central office, removing the need for individual LO units at each antenna. This is a feature that also appears in the radio-over-fibre networks (Figure 1.18) discussed below. In addition to the distribution of local oscillator signals, both fibre radio and radio astronomy arrays have a requirement for data transmission over fibre, and the different schemes for sending data over analogue fibre-optic links will be outlined in Section1.6.4.
1.6.2 Signal Generation The ALMA project represents but one example of the need for ever higher oscillator frequencies. Other examples include mm-waves for multi-Gb/s wireless communication, where there is much work at 60 GHz, and even demonstrations of 10 Gb/s transmission using a carrier frequency of 120 GHz [92]. Generation of microwave and mm-wave signals has
Figure 1.18
Architecture of a mm wave fibre radio system
28
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
traditionally been the realm of electronic oscillators using III-V devices [93], although recent work has also proved the feasibility of using cheaper SiGe CMOS technology [94]. Nevertheless, as one goes beyond 100 GHz the power available from electronic oscillators declines. There is then a so-called ‘gap’ in the THz region before one reaches optical frequencies, where laser sources are available. The THz region itself is of growing importance in sensing and biomedical applications [95]. It is possible to use photonic techniques to generate mm-wave and THz signals, and one immediate advantage is that the signals can then be transported immediately over optical fibre. The availability of high-speed photodiodes and photomixers then ensures relatively efficient conversion into the wireless domain. The two obvious techniques for optical generation of microwaves are direct and external modulation as discussed above, but the former is limited to about 30 GHz while the latter can suffer from dispersion-induced fading at mm-wave frequencies. One can generate microwave and mm-wave frequencies by a number of other methods as discussed below: (a) Heterodyning of two laser sources, in which the wavelength difference corresponds to the subsequent microwave signal’s frequency. One advantage is that very high optical singlesideband frequencies can be generated. This is discussed in detail in Chapters 4, 5 and 10. (b) Actively and passively mode locked lasers. Of particular interest here is work at Drexel [96] on the use of microchip lasers. A microchip laser is a solid-state laser (based on erbiumdoped lithium niobate for example) of short length onto which dielectric mirrors are deposited directly. It is a potentially low cost solution which is very suitable for mode locking at mm-wave frequencies. Performance-wise, the microchip laser is inherently more stable than a semiconductor laser, has higher output power and lower relative intensity noise. (c) Optical phase locked loops (OPPLs) [97] and optical frequency comb generators (OFCGs) [98]. The OPLL architecture is similar to a conventional phase locked loop, but in this case a master and slave laser produce a heterodyne signal. After photodetection this is mixed with a mm-wave reference from an oscillator, and the resulting phase error signal is used to tune the slave laser so that the heterodyne signal frequency equals the reference frequency. The OFCG is an amplified recirculating optical delay line into which a phase modulator is inserted. By applying microwave modulation to the modulator, and through the process of continued recirculation (and hence ‘remodulation’), an optical comb spectrum is generated in which the spacing between combs corresponds to the modulation frequency. One can then select two of the combs using injection-locked slave lasers and then subsequently photodetect the heterodyned signal. This technique can potentially produce frequencies well over 100 GHz. (d) Optoelectronic oscillators (OEL) [99]. The basic configuration of an OEO (Figure 1.19) is based on the loop oscillator principle, in which the open loop gain must balance out losses. In this structure the oscillation frequency is inversely proportional to the fibre group delay. An OEO is a hybrid oscillator in the sense that it uses both microwave and photonic components, and the oscillation can be extracted either from the electronic part of the loop or the optical part. One of its perceived advantages is the potential to offer better phase noise performance than electronic oscillators at microwave frequencies [99] in addition to higher Q. A disadvantage of the scheme in Figure 1.19, however, is the thermal dependence of the fibre delay (although this does make it possible to use an OEO for sensing applications).
Microwave Photonics
29
an Introductory Overview
Low noise “pump” laser
Fibre coupler
Mach–Zehnder modulator
Optical output
Fibre loop Electrical loop
Microwave output Microwave directional coupler
Microwave amplifier
Photodiode
Bandpass Filter
Figure 1.19
A single loop optoelectronic oscillator
1.6.3 Signal Processing
RF input
Mach–Zehnder modulator
a0 1 × N optical splitter
CW optical source
Commensurate optical delays
a1 a2
T 2T
NT
1 × N optical combiner
Weights
As shown in Figure 1.4, optical fibre has a much lower loss than alternative technologies such as surface acoustic wave devices for a given delay. Put another way, this means that at a given microwave frequency an optical fibre can provide longer delays than competing media, which translates into a large time bandwidth product. Single-mode fibre offers a time bandwidth product in excess of 106, thus making it suitable for the processing of wideband signals. An early application of microwave photonic signal processing was in optical fibre recirculating delay lines designed for the storage of microwave signals [100]. This was then followed in the early 1980s with implementations of microwave photonic filters at Stanford using delay line structures [101]. Since then the field has expanded significantly and a very large body of published work exists. Excellent review [102] and tutorial papers [103] provide a comprehensive discussion of much of this work. An example of a very simple microwave photonic filter is shown in Figure 1.20. This architecture is an extension of the Mach Zehnder interferometer, and can be shown to be
Photodetector RF output
aN-1
Figure 1.20 Example of a microwave photonic filter (for more details, see Figure 8.4 of Chapter 8)
30
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
functionally equivalent to a tapped delay line filter. Since the various fibre delays are commensurate, it is possible to use z-domain techniques from the field of digital filtering for analysis and synthesis purposes. (This is done for mathematical convenience, since microwave photonic filters are analogue.) Borrowing from digital filter terminology, the structure in Figure 1.20 is termed FIR (finite impulse response). It is also possible to have IIR (infinite impulse response) transfer functions by using recirculating loops. Just as one might compare an analogue fibre link with a coaxial cable, one may compare a microwave photonic filter with a conventional microwave filter using lumped components, transmission lines or waveguides. The need for E/O and O/E conversion raises the question of whether the added complexity is worthwhile. However, given the increased interest in systems such as fibre radio, in which microwave signals are already being generated and transported optically, it seems reasonable to filter them in the optical domain as well. Moreover, as pointed out by Minasian [102], photonic signal processing offers numerous advantages, including highspeed, parallel processing and high sampling frequencies (in excess of 100 GHz as opposed to a few GHz for electronics). These advantages, coupled with advances in photonic technology such as fibre Bragg gratings (both uniform and chirped), optical amplifiers, high-speed modulators and detectors, WDM multiplexers and demultiplexers, and tuneable lasers, have created new opportunities not only for advanced microwave photonic filter structures but also other functions. Microwave photonics technology has been used to implement analogue to digital converters (ADC) [104], arbitrary waveform generators [105] and beamformers for phased array radars [106]. An example of a photonic ADC is shown in Figure 1.21; a good review of the field is given in [104].
1.6.4 Radio Over Fibre Radio over fibre (RoF) is one of the major applications of microwave photonics and there is some significant commercial activity in this field. The main concept is shown in Figure 1.18 and
v
Analogue input
λ1 t Electro-optic modulator
Mode-locked laser
λ1λ2
λN t
t
ADC 1
Photodiode 2
ADC 2
λ2
Optical demultiplexer
λN
Photodiode 1
Photodiode 1
Multiple sample digital interleaving
ADC 1
Modulated pulse train
Figure 1.21 Example of a photonic analogue to digital converter. The analogue signal is sampled by a pulse train by using external modulation. The output of the external modulator is then demultiplexed according to wavelength prior to photodetection and electronic quantization. (There are examples of purely photonic ADCs, in which both sampling and quantization are performed in the photonic domain)
Microwave Photonics
an Introductory Overview
31
it involves the merging of wireless networks (indoor and also outdoor) with a fibre backbone (which is often WDM-based). Motivation for using RoF includes providing a solution to the ‘last mile’ problem and the improvement of wireless coverage (for example in buildings and ‘dark zones’ such as tunnels). Indoor distributed antenna systems (DAS) currently have a large share of the RoF market [107]. They are designed to transport cellular and WLAN signals to remote antenna units distributed throughout a building, and the key driver here is to reduce costs. This is facilitated by the fact that the frequencies are low enough (in the range 800 MHz to 2.5 GHz) to allow the use of directly modulated laser diodes, even though device linearity is an issue. Since there is already a large amount of installed multimode fibre, significant efforts have been made to develop multimode RoF for DAS [108]. As the demand for higher data rates (for applications such as HDTV) continues to increase, more use will be made of mm-wave carrier frequencies. Of particular interest is the availability of several GHz of spectrum centred on 60 GHz, which will ease some of the spectrum congestion of cellular systems. The sizeable atmospheric losses at this frequency lead to relatively small cell sizes (known as picocells), thus allowing greater frequency reuse which enhances network capacity. The small size of picocells means that a large number of remote antenna units must be produced, implying that their architecture must be suitably simple. In this manner the complexity moves to the central office, in which the functions of data modulation and multiplexing are housed. There are trade-offs between complexity of the picocells and the central office, leading to different schools of thought as to which is the best overall approach. These can be broadly defined as: (i) optical generation and transport of mm-wave signals at 60 GHz, and (ii) optical transport of data signals with remote upconversion to 60 GHz at the picocell site. The former approach is known as RF over fibre. It results in simple picocell architectures, which at their bare minimum use electro-absorption transceivers [109] plus an antenna and associated circuits this passive picocell approach removes the need for electronic amplification. It does, however, require use of the techniques described in Section1.6.2 in order to generate the mm-wave carrier. The second approach is known as baseband over fibre and it removes the need for high-speed components, but in its place it requires local oscillators to be generated locally at each picocell unit. A third approach, known as IF over fibre is also possible, and this technique is illustrated in Figure 1.22 along with the other two signal transport approaches.
1.7 Conclusions Microwave photonics is a field in which many advances have been made since the 1960s, and the high level of research activity continues unabated. In this introductory chapter we have sought to give a brief flavour of the topic from the perspective of devices and their various system applications. Later chapters will report on advances in some of these devices (e.g. direct modulation of lasers, photodiodes and THz generation with O/E and E/O devices) and will focus on how microwave photonic functionality can be used to implement microwave signal processing (e.g. microwave filters and analogue links) and to implement advanced communication systems (e.g. fibre radio).
32
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications • Potentially very simple RAP. • Could, in theory, use only passive mmwave components.
Optical carrier
ωRF OLSB
Antenna
OUSB
O/E Coupler
ω Central office
RF over fibre
Diplexer
E/O RAP
• Need to generate 60 GHz by optical means at central office. For optical double sideband signals, fibre dispersion leads to a “beating” effect (see Figure 1.17). This can be overcome with single-sideband methods.
•60 GHz carrier recovered at RAP. •Need high bandwidth O/E and E/O components.
•Relaxed bandwidth requirements on O/E and E/O components. •More tolerant of chromatic dispersion.
O/E
ω
Central office
Coupler
ωIF
Diplexer
Local Oscillator E/O
Mixer
IF over fibre
RAP
•60 GHz carrier generated at RAP. •Need mm-wave components such as mixers and oscillators; phase noise can be an issue. •However, modified architectures (including remote LO delivery) are possible.
Optical carrier O/E
Central office
LO
Diplexer
Baseband over fibre
E/O
•Digital fibre optic link •Mature technology, relatively cheap •Tolerant of fibre link impairments (e.g. nonlinearity, dispersion)
Figure 1.22
IF
Coupler
ω
RAP •Similar comments as for the RF over fibre case apply to the RAP
The three main classes of signal transport for radio over fibre compared and contrasted
It is highly likely that microwave photonics will continue to flourish as a research field, given that the demand for ever increasing bit rates in both wireless and optical communications shows no signs of stopping yet. There are also a number of growing applications in areas such as THz technology for sensing. To date, much of the progress in microwave photonics has been driven by impressive advances in optical fibre components. However, a number of key challenges remain (including the issue of producing low-cost components in high volumes) and there are also new opportunities on the horizon. These include: (i) the demonstration of high-speed modulators on silicon [110], which opens up a route to cheaper components that can be integrated with silicon drive electronics,
Microwave Photonics
an Introductory Overview
33
(ii) ‘new physics’, such as the use of slow light to perform phase shifting for use in microwave filters [111], and (iii) the development of new structures such as micro-ring resonators that promise more compact optical filters designed with techniques that are well established in the area of microwave filters [112].
References [1] J.E. Midwinter, “The start of optical fiber communications as seen from a U.K. perspective”, IEEE J. Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, vol. 6, pp. 1307 1311, Nov./Dec. 2000. [2] J. Capmany and D. Novak, “Microwave photonics combines two worlds”, Nature Photonics, vol. 1, pp. 319 330, June 2007. [3] D. Crowley and P. Heyer,(Eds) “Chapter 17: The Optical Telegraph” in Communication in History: Technology, Culture and Society ( Fourth Edition), Allyn and Bacon, Boston, MA, USA, pp. 123 125, 2003. [4] G. Cookson, ‘The Cable: the Wire that Changed the World’, Tempus, Stroud, Gloucestershire, UK, 2003. [5] K.C. Kao and G.A. Hockham, “Dielectric fiber surface waveguides for optical frequencies”, Proc. Inst. Electr. Eng., vol. 133, pp. 1151 1158, July 1966. [6] A.G. Bell, “On the production and reproduction of sound by light”, Am. J. Sci., Third Series, vol. XX, pp. 305 324, Oct. 1880. [7] D.T. Emerson, “The work of Jagadis Chandra Bose: 100 years of millimeter wave research”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Tech., vol. 45, pp. 2267 2273, Dec. 1997. [8] A.L. Schawlow and C.H. Townes, “Infrared and optical masers”, Phys. Rev., vol. 112, pp. 1940 1949, Dec. 1958. [9] T.H. Maiman, “Stimulated optical radiation in ruby masers”, Nature, vol. 187, pp. 493 494, Aug. 1960. [10] A. Javan, W.R. Bennett, Jr. and D.R. Herriott, “Population inversion and continuous optical maser oscillation in a gas dischargecontaing a helium neon mixture”, Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 6, pp. 106 110, Feb. 1961. [11] J.T. Verdeyen Laser Electronics ( Third Edition), Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, USA, 1995. [12] N. Lindgren, “Optical communications a decade of preparations”, Proc. IEEE, vol. 58, pp. 1410 1418, Oct. 1970. [13] R.N. Hall, G.E. Fenner, J.D. Kingsley, T.J. Soltys and R.O. Carlson, “Coherent light emission from GaAs junctions”, Phys. Review Lett., vol. 9, pp. 366 369, Nov. 1962. [14] F.P. Kapron, D.B. Keck and R.D. Maurer, “Radiation losses in glass optical waveguides,” in IEE Conf. Trunk Telecommunications by Guided Waves, London, U.K., Sept. Oct. 1970. [15] I. Hayashi, M.B. Panish, P.W. Foy and S. Sumski, “Junction lasers which operate continuously at room temperature,” Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 17, no. 3, pp. 109 111, Aug. 1970. [16] E. DeSurvire, “Lightwave Communications: The Fifth Generation,” Scientific American, vol. 266, pp. 114 121, Jan. 1992. [17] M.J. O’Mahony, “Optical multiplexing in fiber networks: progress in WDM and OTDM”, IEEE Communications Magazine, vol. 33, pp. 82 88, Dec. 1995. [18] H.A. Haus, “Optical fiber solitons, their properties and uses”, Proc. IEEE, vol. 81, pp. 970 983, July 1993. [19] R. Giles and L. Tingye, “Optical amplifiers transform long distance lightwave telecommunications,” Proc. IEEE, vol. 84, pp. 870 883, June 1996. [20] D.M. Pozar, Microwave Engineering ( Third Edition), John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA, 2004. [21] B.E.A. Saleh and M.C. Teich, Fundamentals of Photonics, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA, 1991. [22] A.J. Seeds and K.J. Williams, “Microwave photonics”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 24, pp. 4628 4641, Dec. 2006. [23] S. Iezekiel, “Measurement of microwave behavior of optical links”, IEEE Microwave Magazine, vol. 9, pp. 100 120, June 2008. [24] G.D. Keiser, Optical Fiber Communications ( Third Edition), McGraw Hill, Singapore, 1999. [25] S.G. Ayling, D.R. Wight, M.B. Allenson, K.P. Hilton and G.W. Smith, “Novel integrated laser devices with greatly enhanced quantum efficiency and intrinsic RF matching for low loss, broad band opto microwave applications”, IEEE International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, Princeton, NJ, USA, pp. 161 164, 1998. [26] J.T. Getty, O. Buchinsky, R.A. Salvatore, B. Mason, P.G. Piva, S. Charbonneau, K.S. Grabowski and L.A. Coldren, “Monolithic series connected 1.55 mm segmented ridge lasers”, Electron. Lett., vol. 35, no. 15, pp. 1257 1258, 1999.
34
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
[27] C.H. Cox, Analog Optical Links, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2004. [28] N. Dagli, “Wide bandwidth lasers and modulators for RF photonics”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Tech., vol. 47, pp. 1151 1171, July 1999. [29] Y. Matsui, H. Murai, S. Arahira, S. Kutsuzawa and Y. Ogawa, “30 GHz bandwidth 1.55 mm strain compensated InGaAlAs InGaAsP MQW laser”, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 9, pp. 25 27, 1997. [30] O. Kjebon, R. Schatz, S. Lourdudoss, S. Nilsson, B. Stalnacke and L. Backbom, “30GHz direct modulation bandwidth in detuned loaded InGaAsP DBR lasers at 1.55 mm wavelength”, Electron. Lett., vol. 33, pp. 488 489, 1997. [31] D. Bimberg, “Quantum dot based nanophotonics and nanoelectronics,” Electron. Lett., vol. 44, pp. 168 171, 2008. [32] Y. Chu, R.V. Penty, I.H. White, M. Kuntz, G. Fiol, M. Lammlin, D. Bimberg, C. Schubert, A.R. Kovsh, A. Jacob and A. Umbach, “10 Gb/s data transmission with a 1.3 mm InGaAs quantum dot laser”, in ECOC 2005, 31st European Conference on Optical Communication, pp. 621 622, 2005. [33] W. Hofmann, G. Bohm, M. Ortsiefer, E. Wong and M. C. Amann, “Uncooled high speed ( >11 GHz) 1.55 mm VCSELs for CWDM access networks”, in 32nd European Conference on Optical Communication, Cannes, France, 2006, Post deadline session Th4.5.4. [34] C.P. Seltzer, L.D. Westbrook and H.J. Wickes, “The “gain lever” effect in InGaAsP/InP multiple quantum well lasers”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 13, pp. 283 289, 1995. [35] J.T. Getty, L.A. Johansson, E. J. Skogen and L.A. Coldren, “1.55 mm bipolar cascade segmented ridge lasers”, IEEE J. Sel. Topics Quantum Electron., vol. 9, pp. 1138 1145, May 2003. [36] J.P. van der Ziel and W.T. Tsang, “Integrated multilayer GaAs lasers separated by tunnel junctions”, Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 41, pp. 499 501, 1982. [37] R. Nagarajan, S. Levy and J.E. Bowers, “Millimeter wave narrowband optical fiber links using externalcavity semiconductor lasers”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 12, pp. 127 136, 1994. [38] L. Chrostowski, X. Zhao and C.J. Chang Hasnain, “Microwave performance of optically injection locked VCSELs”, IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., vol. 54, pp. 788 796, Feb. 2006. [39] E.K. Lau, H. K. Sung and M.C. Wu, “Ultra high, 72 GHz resonance frequency and 44 GHz bandwidth of injection locked 1.55 mm DFB lasers”, in Optical Fiber Communication Conference, Anaheim, CA, USA, 2006. [40] X. Zhao, D. Parekh, E.K. Lau, H. K. Sung, M.C. Wu, W. Hofmann, M.C. Amann and C.J. Chang Hasna, “Novel cascaded injection locked 1.55 mm VCSELs with 66 GHz modulation bandwidth”, Optics Express, vol. 15, pp. 14810 14816, 2007. [41] W.K. Burns, M.M. Howerton, R.P. Moeller, A.S. Greenblatt and R.W. McElhanon, “Broad band reflection traveling wave LiNbO3 modulator”, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 10, pp. 805 806, June 1998. [42] W.B. Bridges and J.H. Schaffner, “Distortion in linearized electrooptic modulators”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory Tech., vol. 43, pp. 2184 2197, Sept. 1995. [43] U.V. Cummings and W.B. Bridges, “Bandwidth of linearized electrooptic modulators”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 16, pp. 1482 1490, Aug. 1998. [44] B.B. Dingel, “Ultra linear, broadband optical modulator for high performance analog fiber link system”, IEEE International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, pp. 241 244, 2004. [45] M. Jarrahi, T.H. Lee and D.A.B. Miller, “Wideband, low driving voltage traveling wave Mach Zehnder modulator for RF photonics”, IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett., vol. 20, pp. 517 519, April 2008. [46] H.N. Klein, H. Chen, D. Hoffmann, S. Staroske, A.G. Steffan, and K. O. Velthaus, “1.55 mm Mach Zehnder modulators on InP for optical 40/80 bit/s transmission networks”, Indium Phosphide and Related Materials Conference Proceedings, pp. 171 173, 2006. [47] R.A. Norwood, “Electro optic polymer modulators for telecommunications applications”, Optical Fiber Communication/National Fiber Optic Engineers Conference, pp. 1 3, 2008. [48] T.D. Kim, J.W. Kang, J. Luo, S.H. Jang, J.W. Ka, N.M. Tucker, J.B. Benedict, R. Dalton, T. Gray, R.M. Overney, D.H. Park, W.N. Herman and A.K. Y. Jen, “Ultralarge and thermally stable electro optic activities from supramolecular self assembled molecular glasses”, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., vol. 129, no. 3, pp. 488 489, 2007. [49] D. Chen, H.R. Fetterman, A. Chen, W.H. Steier, L. Dalton, W. Wang and Y. Shi, “Demonstration of 110 GHz electro optic polymer modulators”, Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 70, pp. 3335 3337, 1997. [50] Y. Enami et al., “Hybrid cross linkable polymer/sol gel waveguide modulators with 0.65 half wave voltage at 1550 nm”, Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 91, art. no. 093505, 2007.
Microwave Photonics
an Introductory Overview
35
[51] Jin Tae Kim, Jung Jin Ju, Suntak Park, Seung Koo Park, Min Su Kim and Myung Hyun Lee “UV embossed polymer optical bench for integration of polymer waveguide devices”, LEOS Summer Topical Meetings, Digest of the IEEE, pp. 111 112, 2007. [52] Y. H. Kuo, Jingdong Luo, W.H. Steier and A.K. Y. Jen, “Enhanced thermal stability of electrooptic polymer modulators using the diels alder crosslinkable polymer”, Photonics Technology Letters, IEEE, vol. 18, pp. 175 177, Jan. 2006. [53] D.A.B. Miller, D.S. Chemla, T.C. Damen, A.C. Gossard, W. Wiegmann, T.H. Wood and C.A. Burrus, “Electric field dependence of optical absorption near the bandgap of quantum well structures”, Phys. Rev. B, Condens. Matter, vol. 32, no. 2, pp. 1043 1060, 1985. [54] W.S. Chang (Ed.), RF Photonic Technology in Optical Fiber Links, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2002. [55] Tsu Hsiu Wu, Yi Jen Chiu and Fang Zheng Lin, “High speed (60 GHz) and low voltage driving electroabsorp tion modulator using two consecutive steps selective undercut wet etching waveguide”, Photonics Technology Letters, IEEE, vol. 20, pp. 1261 1263, 2008. [56] A.J. Seeds and A.A.A. deSalles, “Optical control of microwave semiconductor devices”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Tech., vol. 38, pp. 577 585, May 1990. [57] S. Iezekiel and N. Bourhill, “Optical control of millimetre wave p HEMTs with applications to fibre radio”, in IEEE International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, Oxford, UK, 2000. [58] J. Rue, M. Itzler, N. Agrawal, S. Bay and W. Sherry, “High performance 10 Gb/s PIN and APD optical receivers”, in Proc. Electronic Components and Technology Conference, San Diego, CA, USA, pp. 207 215, June 1999. [59] G.S. Kinsey, R. Sidhu, A.L. Holmes, Jr., J.C. Campbell and A.G. Dentai, “High speed waveguide avalanche photodetectors”, Device Research Conference, Notre Dame, IN, USA, pp. 149 150, June 2001. [60] K. Kato, “Ultrawide band/high frequency photodetectors”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory Tech., vol. 47, no. 7, pp. 1265 1281, 1999. [61] J.E. Bowers and C.A. Burrus, “Ultrawide band long wavelength p i n photodetectors”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 5, pp. 1339 1350, 1987. [62] K. Williams, R. Esman, R. Wilson and J. Kulick, “Differences in p side and n side illuminated p i n photodiode nonlinearities”, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 10, pp. 132 134, Jan. 1998. ¨ nlu and S. Strite, “Resonant cavity enhanced photonic devices”, J. Appl. Phys., vol. 78, pp. 607 639, [63] M. Selim U July 1995. [64] J.E. Bowers and C.A. Burrus, “High speed zero bias waveguide photodetectors”, Electron. Lett., vol. 22, pp. 905 906, Aug. 1986. [65] K. Kato, A. Kozen, Y. Muramato, Y. Itaya, T. Nagatsuma and M. Yaita, “110 GHz, 50% efficiency mushroom mesa waveguide p i n photodiode for a 1.55 mm wavelength”, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 6, pp. 719 721, June 1994. [66] K.S. Gibony, R.L. Nagarajan, T.E. Reynolds, S.T. Allen, R.P. Mirin, M.J.W. Rodwell and J.E. Bowers, “Travelling wave photodetectors with 172 GHz bandwidth and 76 GHz bandwidth efficiency product”, IEEE Photonics. Technol. Lett., vol. 7, pp. 412 414, April 1995. [67] M.C. Wu and T.Itoh, “Ultrafast photonic to microwave transformer (PMT)”, in Proc. LEOS 1993, 1993. [68] L.Y. Lin, M.C. Wu, T. Itoh, T.A. Vang, R.E. Muller, D.L. Sivco and A.Y. Cho, “High speed photodetectors with high saturation for high performance microwave photonic systems”, in Proc. 1996 Int. Topical Meeting Microw. Photon., pp. 313 316, 1996. [69] C.L. Goldsmith, G.A. Magel and R.J. Baca, “Principles and performance of traveling wave photodetector arrays”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory Tech., vol. 45, no. 8, pp. 1342 1350, 1997. [70] K.S. Giboney, M.J.W. Rodwell and J.E. Bowers, “Traveling wave photodetector theory”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory Tech., vol. 45, no. 8, pp. 1310 1319, 1997. [71] K.S. Giboney, M.J.W. Rodwell and J.E. Bowers, “Traveling wave photodetector design and measurements”, IEEE. J. Sel. Topics Quantum Electron., vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 622 629, 1996. [72] G. Rangel Sharp, R.E. Miles and S. Iezekiel, “Traveling wave photodetectors: a review”, URSI Radio Science Bulletin, no. 311, pp. 55 64, Dec. 2004. [73] J. W. Shi and C K. Sun, “Design and analysis of long absorption length travelling wave photodetectors”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 26, pp. 2176 2187, July 2008. [74] J. W. Shi, K. G. Gan, Y. J. Chiu, Y. H. Chen, C. K. Sun, Y. J. Yang and J.E. Bowers, “Metal semiconductor metal travelling wave photodetectors”, IEEE Photonics. Technol. Lett., vol. 16, pp. 623 625, 2001.
36
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
[75] M. Alles, U. Auer, F. J. Tegude and D. Jaeger, “Distributed velocity matched 1.55 mm InP travelling wave photodetector for generation of high millemterwave signal power”, Proc. IEEE International Microwave Symposium, pp. 1233 1236, 1998. [76] D.C. Scott, D.P. Prakash, H. Erlig, M.A. Bhattacharya, H.R. Fetterman and M. Matloubian, “High power, high frequency travelling wave heterojunction phototransistors with integrated polyimide waveguide”, Proc. IEEE International Microwave Symposium, pp. 1237 1240, 1998. [77] G. Rangel Sharp, R.E. Miles and S. Iezekiel, “Physical modeling of traveling wave heterojunction photo transistors”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 26, pp. 1943 1949, July 2008. [78] S. Murthy, M.C. Wu, D. Sivco, and A.Y. Cho, “Parallel feed travelling wave distributed pin photodetectors withintegrated MMI couplers” Electronics Letters, vol. 38, pp. 78 80, 2002. [79] H. Ito, and T. Ishibashi, “Ultrafast uni traveling carrier photodiode”, 58th Device Research Conference Digest. pp. 165 168, 2000. (Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/DRC.2000.877133). [80] H. Ito, H. Fushimi, Y. Muramoto, T. Furuta, and T. Ishibashi, “High power photonic microwave generation at K and Ku bands using a uni traveling carrier photodiode”, Microwave Symposium Digest, IEEE MTT S Interna tional, vol. 1, pp. 65 68, May 2001. [81] A. Madjar, P.R. Herczfeld, A. Rosen, P. Yu and D. Jager, “Design considerations for a uni traveling carrier traveling wave photo detector for efficient generation of millimeter wave and sub MM wave signals”, European Microwave Conference, vol. 1, pp. 3, Oct. 2005. [82] R. Hofstetter, H. Schmuck and R. Heidemann, “Dispersion effects in optical millimetre wave systems using self heterodyne method for transport and generation”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory Tech., vol. 43, pp. 2263 2269, 1995. [83] U. Gliese, S. Nørskov and T.N. Nielsen, “Chromatic dispersion in fiber optic microwave and millimeter wave links”, IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., vol. 44, pp. 1716 1724, Oct. 1996. [84] L. Cheng, S. Aditya, Z. Li, A. Arokiaswami and M. Ong, “Nonlinear distortion due to XPM in dispersive WDM microwave fiber optic links with optical SSB modulation”, in International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, pp. 241 244, 2005. [85] I. Gasulla and J. Capmany, “RF transfer function of analogue multimode fiber links using an electric field propagation model: application to broadband radio over fiber systems”, in International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, pp. 1 4, 2006. [86] P. Hartmann, Xin Qian, A. Wonfor, R.V. Penty and I.H. White, “1 20 GHz directly modulated radio over MMF link”, in International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, pp. 95 98, 2005. [87] B.J. Dixon, R.D. Pollard and S. Iezekiel, “Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing in wireless communication systems with multimode fiber feeds”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Tech., vol. 49, pp. 1404 1409, Aug. 2001. [88] R. Boula Picard, M. Alouini, J. Lopez, N. Vodjdani and J. C. Simon, “Impact of the gain saturation dynamics in semiconductor optical amplifiers on the characteristics of an analog optical link”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 23, pp. 2420 2426, 2005. [89] C.H. Cox III, E.I. Ackerman, G.E. Betts and J.L. Prince, “Limits on the performance of RF over fiber links and their impact on device design”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Tech., vol. 54, pp. 906 920, 2006. [90] J. Payne, B. Shillue and A. Vaccari, “Photonic techniques for use on the Atacama Large Millimeter Array”, in International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, pp. 105 108, 1999. [91] W. Shillue, “Fiber distribution of local oscillator for Atacama Large Millimeter Array”, in Optical Fiber Communication Conference, San Diego, CA, USA, pp. 1 3, 2008. [92] A. Hirata, T. Kosugi, H. Takahashi, R. Yamaguchi, F. Nakajima, T. Furuta, H. Ito, H. Sugahara, Y. Sato and T. Nagatsuma, “120 GHz band millimeter wave photonic wireless link for 10 Gb/s data transmission”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Tech., vol. 54, pp. 1937 1944, 2006. [93] M.J. Howes and D.V. Morgan (Eds), Microwave Devices: Device Circuit Interactions, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA, 1976. [94] B. Floyd, U. Pfeiffer, S. Reynolds, A. Valdes Garcia, C. Haymes, Y. Katayama, D. Nakano, T. Beukema, B. Gaudier and M. Soyuer, “Silicon millimeter wave radio circuits at 60 100 GHz”, in Topical Meeting on Silicon Monolithic Integrated Circuits, pp. 213 218, 2007. [95] J.M. Chamberlain, “Where optics meets electronics: recent progress in decreasing the terahertz gap”, Phil. Trans. Royal Soc. A, vol. 362, pp. 199 213, 2004. [96] A.J.C. Vieira, P.R. Herczfeld, A. Rosen, M. Ermold, E.E. Funk, W.D. Jemison, and K.J. Williams, “A mode locked microchip laser optical transmitter for fiber radio”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Tech., vol. 49, pp. 1882 1887, 2001.
Microwave Photonics
an Introductory Overview
37
[97] L.A. Johansson and A.J. Seeds, “Generation and transmission of millimeter wave data modulated optical signals using an optical injection phase lock loop”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 21, pp. 511 520, 2003. [98] S. Bennett, B. Cai, E. Burr, O. Gough and A.J. Seeds, “1.8 THz bandwidth, zero frequency error, tunable optical comb generator for DWDM applications”, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 11, pp. 551 553, 1999. [99] X.S. Yao, “Opto electronic oscillators”, in RF Photonic Technology in Optical Fiber Links, W.S. Chang (Ed.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2002. [100] C.C. Wang, R.P. Moeller, W.K. Burns and I.P. Kaminow, “Fibre optic recirculating analogue delay line”, Elect. Lett., vol. 20, pp. 486 488, 1984. [101] B. Moslehi, J.W. Goodman, M. Tur and H.J. Shaw, “Fiber optic lattice signal processing”, Proc. IEEE, vol. 72, pp. 909 930, 1984. [102] R.A. Minasian, “Photonic signal processing of microwave signals”, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Tech., vol. 54, pp. 832 846, 2006. [103] J. Capmany, B. Ortega and D. Pastor, “A tutorial on microwave photonic filters”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 24, pp. 201 229, 2006. [104] G.C. Valley, “Photonic analog to digital converters”, Opt. Express, vol. 15, pp. 1955 1982, 2007 [105] B. Bortnik, J. Chou, B. Jalali, H.R. Fetterman and I.Y. Poberezhskiy, “RF photonic generation of high power ultrawideband arbitrary waveforms using predistortion”, Optical Fiber Communication Conference, Anaheim, USA, 2006. [106] A.J. Seeds, “Optical technologies for phased array antennas”, IEICE Trans. Electron., vol. E76 C, pp. 198 206, 1993. [107] D. Wake, “Trends and prospects for radio over fibre picocells”, in International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, Awaji Island, Japan, pp. 21 24, 2002. [108] C. Lethien, C. Loyez and J. P. Vilcot, “Potentials of radio over multimode fiber systems for the in buildings coverage of mobile and wireless LAN applications”, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 17, pp. 2793 2795, 2005. [109] D. Wake and D.G. Moodie, “Passive picocell prospects for increasing the radio range”, in IEEE International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, Duisberg, Germany, pp. 269 271, 1997. [110] A. Liu, R. Jones, L. Liao, D. Samara Rubio, D. Rubin, O. Cohen, R. Nicolaescu and M. Paniccia, “A high speed silicon optical modulator based on a metal oxide semiconductor capacitor”, Nature, vol. 427, pp. 615 618, 2004. [111] M. Sales, F. Ohman, J. Capmany and J. Mork, “Controlling microwave signals by means of slow and fast light effects in SOA EA structures”, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 19, pp. 1589 1591, 2007. [112] V. Van, “Synthesis of elliptic optical filters using mutually coupled microring resonators”, J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 25, pp. 584 590, 2007.
Part II Component Technologies
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Edited by Stavros Iezekiel © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 978-0-470-84854-8
2 Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics Rajeev Ram and Harry Lee
2.1 Introduction to Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics Today, nearly 100 companies are involved in the transport of RF or microwave signals over fibre optics primarily a modulated RF carrier residing on the optical signal. The applications for such systems range from in-building distribution of wireless signals (for example in shopping malls and tunnels), wireline interconnections between base stations and microcellular antennas, antenna remoting for various commercial (wing-tip antennas in aircraft) and military radar systems and broadcasting of cable television signals in both hybrid fibre coax (HFC) and triplexer based fibre-to-the-home (FTTH) systems. The simplest, lowest cost and hence most widely deployed system consists of a directly modulated laser, a length of optical fibre and a detector. This simple link is referred to as an intensity modulation/direct detection (IM/DD) system in contrast to externally modulated systems. While direct modulation links tend to be simpler and cheaper, generating and modulating the photons in a single device the laser clearly entails compromises in overall performance that can be avoided by separating these functions as in an externally modulated link. In particular, the effect of nonlinearity and noise must be considered (Figure 2.1). However, as we shall show here, the performance gap between externally modulated and directly modulated links can be narrowed with judicious design of the semiconductor laser. As in all optical systems, the performance requirements for the individual components are set by the overall system specifications. For analogue IM/DD links, the three most important system parameters for specifying optical components are unamplified link gain (typically 25 dB, best case þ 6 dB), unamplified link noise figure (typically 40 dB, best case 17 dB) and spurious free dynamic range (typically 100 dB-Hz2/3, best case 127 dB-Hz2/3). The link gain is a simple function of the efficiency with which the laser can convert an electrical signal to a modulated optical waveform, the optical transmission loss and the efficiency for a detector to
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Edited by Stavros Iezekiel © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 978-0-470-84854-8
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
42 Second-order distortion
Intensity noise
Figure 2.1 Schematic showing sinusoidal modulation of a laser and the results of second order distortion and noise
convert the modulated optical waveform back to the electrical domain. The noise figure depends on the link gain as well as the noise added at each O/E (optical to electrical) and E/O (electrical to optical) conversion step. The dynamic range depends on the link gain and noise figure as well as the linearity of the E/O and O/E conversion processes. All of these concepts are conveniently summarized in Figure 2.2. The fundamental has a slope of one and the third-order intermodulation distortion (IMD3) has a slope of three. The input noise is shown as thermal noise with the corresponding output noise floor. The output and input signal-to-noise ratio is shown along with the noise figure (NF). The spur-free dynamic range (SFDR) is also shown.
N in = kT
0
P in = Pout
IP3
-20 -40 -60
G
Pout (dBm)
-80
Fundamental
IMD3
-100 SNRout
-120 -140
SFDR N out = GkT + N las
-160 NF
-180
GNin = GkT
-200 -220
SNRin -200
-150
-100
-50
0
Pin (dBm)
Figure 2.2 Received (electrical) signal power versus transmitted (electrical) signal power; the plot indicates the thermal noise level at the transmitter and receiver as well as the level of third order distortion
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
43
In this chapter, we will describe the detailed physical processes that contribute to both the typical and best case link performance for IMDD. Section 2.2 offers a quick tutorial on the physical processes within a laser which in later sections will be shown to set the important limits on the signal strength, noise and linearity. Section 2.3 discusses the physics behind link gain, Section 2.4 discusses the physics behind signal bandwidth and Section 2.5 discusses distortion in an IMDD system. The final sections of the chapter present specific case studies that are important for the future development of IMDD systems. Section 2.6 discusses low-cost VCSEL based links and Section 2.7 discusses cascade based lasers for positive link gain and low noise figure.
2.2 Review of Semiconductor Laser Devices The semiconductor laser is more intrinsically linear than any other active semiconductor device. Diodes and LEDs obey the highly nonlinear diode law and therefore exhibit very poor linearity. However, beyond threshold, a semiconductor laser has a light output versus electrical current input curve that is extremely linear (Figure 2.3(a)). Semiconductor lasers although utilizing p n junctions exploit optical feedback to effectively suppress the diode nonlinearity. In fact, a semiconductor laser moderately above threshold has essentially the same I V characteristics as a resistor (Figure 2.3(b))! In order to explain how a laser is able to achieve such a highly linear response it is useful to compare the laser diode with an LED. From this discussion, not only will we clarify the origin of the semiconductor lasers linearity but also gain an insight into the distortion that can be generated when the laser is modulated at high speeds (relaxation oscillation nonlinearity) or biased with high injection currents (spatial hole burning and optical gain compression nonlinearities).
2.2.1 Laser Structures Any description of the physical processes that give rise to lasing action in a semiconductor must begin with a careful look at the structure within which electrons, holes and photons interact.
Figure 2.3 (a) Measured light output power versus injected electrical current for a single mode DFB laser. (b) Measured voltage versus injected electrical current for the same laser
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
44
Leakage
Electron injection Electron density
SCH
Recombination
SCH Quantum wells
Hole density Hole injection
Figure 2.4 Schematic of a separate confinement heterostructure (SCH) quantum well laser showing the key transport process for electrons and holes
The vast majority of modern semiconductor lasers rely on quantum wells that trap electrons and holes. The quantum wells are located at a p n junction so that both electrons and holes can be supplied from the doped regions (Figure 2.4). Stimulated emission relies on accumulating sufficient numbers of electrons and holes within the quantum wells so that population inversion is established. From Figure 2.4, it is clear that different bandgap materials are employed to make the carrier confining quantum wells, the separate confinement heterostructure (SCH) and highly doped carrier reservoirs. In order to foster stimulated emission by photons trapped in the vicinity of the quantum wells, additional materials are used to form a waveguide cladding around the active region of the laser. The arrangement of quantum wells in conventional multiple quantum well lasers offers injected electrons the option of recombining in any one of the quantum wells. As such, there can be at most one photon emitted for every electron injected from the doped regions. One approach to circumvent this limit is the bipolar cascade laser structure that will be presented in Section 2.7. In addition towaveguideconfinement in the transverse direction, photonsmustalso be confined by resonator structures. Without high quality resonators the escape rate of photons is so large that the average number of photons near the quantum wells would always be less than one and stimulated emission would always remain negligible. The resonator and the quantum well materials together determine the wavelength of the light emerging from the laser. There are three common resonator geometries that arewidely used today; these are the Fabry Perot resonator, the distributed Bragg reflector (DBR) laser and the distributed feedback (DFB) laser. Figure 2.5 shows schematics of the backward and forward propagating photons within the optical resonator. The simplest resonator for providing optical feedback is the cleaved facet Fabry Perot laser. Here the light is amplified by stimulated emission on its trajectory across the laser resonator (Figure 2.5(a)). Once it reaches the facet it is reflected by the semiconductor-to-air boundary typical reflectivities for most uncoated facets are 56%. An extension of the basic Fabry Perot resonator is to rely on multilayer coatings to increase the mirror feedback (as in a vertical cavity
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
45
Figure 2.5 Schematics of the backward and forward propagating photons within the optical resonator for (a) the Fabry Perot resonator, (b) the DBR or VCSEL resonator, (c) the weak grating DFB and (d) the strong grating DFB
surface emitting laser VCSEL) or to rely on wavelength selectivegratings in place of the cleaved facets; both geometries are referred to as DBR lasers (Figure 2.5(b)). In DBR lasers, the grating reflector is passive and does not provide gain to the propagating light beam. However, it is possible to co-locate the gain and the wavelength selective grating to make a single mode laser; these structures are referred to as DFB lasers. Figures 2.5(c) and 2.5(d) show two DFB laser schematics for weak ((c)) and strong ((d)) grating feedback. The strength of the grating is quantified by the parameter kLg for weak gratings this is simply the reflectivity of the total grating [1]. In the weak grating case, the optical field has a spatial distribution similar to the Fabry Perot laser (Figure 2.5(a)). In the strong grating case, the grating tightly confines the photons within the laser resonator. A typical laser emission spectrum for a DFB semiconductor laser is shown in Figure 2.6 the grating preferentially provides optical feedback that favours a single lasing mode; here, the lasing mode is approximately 40 dB more intense than the next strongest mode. It is important to note that in all of these laser structures the light distribution shown in Figure 2.5 is not spatially uniform. This nonuniformity in the distribution of photons plays an important role in the signal distortion that occurs when these structures are modulated. Even from this cursory view, it is clear that an intermediate strength grating in a DFB geometry will allow for a nearly uniform photon distribution. In fact, the highest dynamic range semiconductor lasers do, in fact, utilize such moderate strength gratings. The optimal grating strength for uniform photon distribution is kLg 0:7 for DFB lasers with one HR coated facet and one AR coated facet [2]. These spatially uniform DFB lasers are the workhorse of the CATV Hybrid Fibre Coax (HFC) distribution network.
2.2.2 Rate Equations When the photon distribution is uniform along the length of the laser cavity, it is possible to describe the dynamics of the device by considering only the spatially averaged
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
46
Figure 2.6
Optical spectrum of a single mode DFB laser with cleaved (uncoated) facets
photon density (S) and carrier density (N). Figure 2.7 shows the various processes that are involved in converting the stream of injected electrons into a stream of output photons. The dynamics of a semiconductor laser are most easily described by a rate equation model that accounts for the various electron and photon generation and recombination/loss processes. (All modes) (Lasing mode)
Spontaneous emission
Current injection
Carrier density, N
Stimulated emission
Photon number, S
Optical output
Leakage
Stimulated absorption Nonradiative recombination
Absorption (outside of active region), scattering loss
Figure 2.7 The various transport and recombination processes within a semiconductor laser resonator. The most important processes which contribute to inefficient conversion of injected current into output light are: (a) carrier leakage, (b) nonradiative recombination, (c) spontaneous emission into nonlasing modes and (d) parasitic absorption and scattering of photons within the laser resonator
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
47
Our development closely follows that of [1]. dN hi I ¼ Rnr ðNÞ Rsp ðNÞ vg gðN; SÞS dt qV Gvg gðN; SÞnsp dS S ¼ Gvg gðN; SÞS : Vp dt tp The rate equations are a system of coupled, nonlinear differential equations for the spatially averaged photon density (S) and carrier density (N). Within the above equations, I is the injected electrical current, hi is the injection efficiency into the active region, Rnr(N) is the rate of nonradiative recombination and Rsp(N) is the total rate of spontaneous emission into all colours and modes, gðN; SÞ is the optical gain per unit length for the lasing mode, G is the spatial overlap of the lasing mode with the active region (quantum wells), vgis the group velocity of photons in the lasing mode, tp is the lifetime of photons in the optical resonator, nsp measures the relative importance of stimulated emission and absorption in the net optical gain (it is typically between 2 5 for diode lasers above threshold), V is the volume of the active region (quantum wells) and Vp is the mode volume of the lasing mode. At low optical powers, the net optical gain is only a function of the carrier density. Figure 2.8 shows the optical gain versus wavelength and carrier density for a typical quantum well active material emitting at 1550 nm. The complex dependence of optical gain on carrier density and wavelength is often compressed into a simple analytic form. The peak optical gain increases with carrier density. However, the magnitude of this increase diminishes as the energy levels at a given optical transition fill with electrons. This band filling results in a logarithmic dependence on carrier density. Finally, at high optical densities, the low-energy carriers are quickly removed by stimulated emission and leave behind a hot electron distribution. These hot electrons do not
Figure 2.8
Calculated optical gain for typical quantum well material emitting at 1550 nm
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
48
efficiently populate the individual states thereby lowering the peak gain of the active material. This is the dominant physical mechanism for gain compression in semiconductors. All of these factors are often incorporated into a phenomenological model for the active region gain: g0 N : ln gðN; SÞ ¼ 1 þ «S Ntr Here, Ntr is the transparency carrier density when stimulated emission balances active region absorption and « is the gain compression factor which accounts for the effect of carrier heating on the net optical gain. In steady-state, the equations can be parameterized to give the current and photon density in terms of the carrier density: I¼
qV ðRnr ðNÞ þ Rsp ðNÞ þ vg gðN; SÞSÞ hi
S¼
Gvg gðN; SÞnsp : 1=tp Gvg gðN; SÞ
Furthermore, the intracavity photon density (S) can be related to the output optical power, Pout ¼ S hn Vp ðvg am Þ Fout ; where hv is the photon energy, am ¼ 1=2L lnð1=R2 Þ is the total mirror loss, and Fout is the fraction of the intracavity power that exits from a single facet. The above system of equations can easily be plotted by varying the carrier density from zero to the point where the net optical gain balances the total cavity loss: vg gth ðNth ; S ¼ 0Þ ¼ 1=Gtp ¼ vg ðam þ ai Þ=G: For reasons we will address shortly, this condition is often called the threshold condition but in truth it is the upper limit to the steady-state carrier density that can be injected into the laser. The resulting optical power and current are shown in Figure 2.9. Note that the carrier density increases as the current in increased. However, when N Nth , the increase in carrier density becomes very small and we can consider the steady-state carrier density to be clamped. Also, at this point the output optical power rises rapidly. Every additional electron that is injected into the active region cannot increase the carrier density appreciably and must rapidly generate a photon via stimulated emission. In fact, the likelihood of stimulated emission for electrons injected above threshold is nearly unity limited only by carrier leakage. Clamping the carrier density near threshold suppresses the intrinsic nonlinearity within the semiconductor device. It is for this simple reason that the semiconductor laser diode has a highly linear optical response (light versus current) and electrical response (I V curve). Carrier density clamping due to optical feedback is the essential difference between a laser diode and an LED. Any process that prevents clamping of the carrier density will unleash the intrinsically nonlinear optical and electrical response of the diode. The key processes that prevent the carrier density from clamping are: . .
spatial-hole burning (no local carrier density clamping), current leakage,
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
49
Opt ca power (mW)
15 10 5 0 0 4
18
5
10
15
20
25
5
10
15
20
25
10 15 Current (mA)
20
25
x 10 N th
Carr er dens ty (cm -3)
3 2 1 0 0
N th
0
5
Figure 2.9 Steady state output optical power and carrier density versus current for a semiconductor laser diode; while the carrier density is always increasing with current, N Nth near the lasing threshold
. .
gain compression (carrier heating induced by stimulated emission), and current modulation.
Spatial hole-burning can be suppressed by judicious design of the laser cavity to ensure that the photon density is uniform. Current leakage can be suppressed by appropriate design of the quantum wells and SCH. However, gain compression («) and the effects of modulation are fundamental to the operation of a semiconductor laser and cannot be easily engineered away. Of particular concern for communications links is that modulation frustrates carrier density clamping and results in a nonlinear device response. This will be discussed in greater detail in Sections 2.4 and 2.5.
2.3 RF Signal Strength and Optical Link Gain Section 2.1 has alluded to some of the challenges in converting an electrical signal into an optical signal. The most important processes that result in the inefficient conversion of injected current into output light are (a) carrier leakage, (b) nonradiative recombination, (c) spontaneous emission into nonlasing modes and (d) parasitic absorption and scattering of photons within the laser resonator. However, in addition to these internal processes, there is the challenge of
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
50
delivering an electrical signal into the laser. Specifically, RF or microwave signals are usually delivered as power (PRF, in) travelling along a transmission line of known impedance (Z0). Because a semiconductor laser is typically a forward biased p n junction diode, its electrical impedance is typically only a few ohms a notable exception being single-mode VCSELs. The small load impedance presented by the laser results in large RF reflections if no impedance matching scheme such as a transformer is employed. A unique aspect of a directly modulated semiconductor laser is that only the RF current not the RF voltage generates an optical modulation. This means that it is more important to deliver RF current to the laser diode than to deliver RF power. A little analysis will clarify this often puzzling and misunderstood fact. The injection current can be related to the input electrical power by r 2PRF;in ð1 GRF Þ I¼ Z0 where GRF ¼
ZL Z0 ZL þ Z0
is the electrical reflection due to impedance mismatch. The optical signal generated by the laser travels through the link and generates an RF electrical current at the detector: r 2PRF;in ð1 GRF Þ; Idet ¼ hlas HðvÞhcp hdet Z0 where hlas is the overall conversion efficiency from electrons to photons in the laser, H(v) is the modulation response of the laser, hcp is the optical link loss, and hdet is the quantum efficiency of the detector. The ratio of the received electrical signal power to the input electrical signal power is the link gain (G). Assuming that the detector drives a load Z0;det , the link gain is given by G ¼ ðhlas HðvÞhcp hdet Þ2 ð1 GRF Þ2
Z0;det : Z0
In order to isolate the inefficiency associated with electrical impedance mismatch we separate the terms in the link gain associated with impedance mismatch and define this to be the mismatch link gain (Gmismatch): Gmismatch ¼ ð1 GRF Þ2
Z0;det : Z0
The mismatch gain is plotted as a function of diode laser resistance in Figure 2.10. When the laser is impedance matched to the input electrical transmission line here, assumed to be 50 W the mismatch gain is unity. As the laser impedance rises above 50 W, the electrical reflections increase and most of the electrical power is delivered as a voltage across the laser. Both effects reduce the optical signal strengths. Surprisingly, reducing the laser impedance actually enhances the gain of the device. As the laser impedance drops, more of the electrical power is delivered as a load that can effectively modulate the light output. This more than compensates for the electrical reflections.
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
51
6 G mismatch(dB)
4
2
0
-2
-4
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90 100
Figure 2.10 The contribution to link power gain due to impedance mismatch between the laser and the input electrical transmission line (with a 50 W impedance). The ‘mismatch’ gain is plotted as a function of laser (differential) resistance
If the electrical signal source can tolerate the impedance mismatch and reflections, it is often desirable to drive the small load of the laser diode directly. However, sensitive or complex signal sources require some effort to achieve impedance matching. In order to optimize the link gain while reducing reflections requires the use of transformers for reactive impedance matching. While such reactive loads are useful in RF applications such as CATV, they are of limited utility in microwave applications such as wideband radar. An alternative approach to improve the overall link gain is to increase the ‘internal’ conversion efficiency of semiconductor lasers by forcing each individual electron to emit multiple photons. This enables laser (differential) efficiencies greater than one and is a promising route to broadband positive link gain. This approach will be discussed in greater detail in Section 2.7.
2.4 Signal Bandwidth and High-speed Lasers In this section, we will continue with our discussion of optical link gain but now focus on the modulation response of the semiconductor laser, H(v). The goal of this section is to describe the optical signal that results from a modulation on the injection current. While most communication systems utilize large signal modulation of the optical signal, it is instructive to consider a linearized or small-signal analysis of the laser dynamics. Here we shall consider the current, electron density and photon density to be composed of steady-state terms plus terms that represent a modulation: I ¼ I0 þ DI, N ¼ N0 þ DN, and S ¼ S0 þ DS. For now, we will focus on the linear response of the system and therefore will not consider the influence of nonlinear terms in the rate equations, that is we will ignore any terms that involve products of the small signals: DNDS 0; DN 2 0; etc.. Similarly, the gain function can be expanded in a Taylor series to the first order since DN and DS are very small. Thus, we can substitute: gðN0 þ DN; S0 þ DSÞ gðN0 ; S0 Þ þ aN DN aP DS; where aN ¼ @g=@DN and aP ¼ @g=@DS. Inserting the current, carrier density and photon density (including modulation) into the rate equations of Section 2.2 gives the following: dDN hi DI ¼ vg aN S0 DN vg g0 DS þ vg aP S0 DS dt qV
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
52
and dDS G DS ¼ Gvg aN S0 DN þ vg g0 DS Gvg aP S0 DS : dt Vp tp Since we are typically considering a laser biased well above threshold, we only consider carrier recombination due to stimulated emission in the above rate equations. The solutions for these small-signal rate equations for sinusoidal modulation at v are: DN ¼
HðvÞ h ðGvg aP S0 þ jvÞ i DI 2 qV vR
DS ¼
HðvÞ h Gvg aN S0 i DI; 2 qV vR
where HðvÞ ¼ v2R
v g aN S0 v þ jvðvg aN S0 Þ þ tP
1
2
:
A characteristic frequency is evident in the form of the modulation response. This frequency is the relaxation oscillation frequency v2r ¼
v g aN S0 : VP
For moderate damping, the 3 dB modulation bandwidth is about 20 50% larger than the relaxation oscillation frequency so design for high relaxation oscillation frequency is equivalent to design for high bandwidth. Figure 2.11 shows the modulation response of a diode laser as a function of the steady-state optical power [3]. As the device is biased to higher powers, the increased rate of stimulated emission directly shows up as a higher modulation bandwidth.
Response (dB)
10 1.3
5
0.4
3.1
8.0 20.9
0
43.3 mW
5
-10
0
5
10 15 Frequency (GHz)
20
Figure 2.11 Modulation response as a function of steady state optical power for a 980 nm laser diode [3] ( 1992 IEEE)
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
Figure 2.12
53
Modulation response for a coplanar fed 1550 nm high speed laser diode [4]
Designing for high relaxation oscillation frequency for a given amount of input current can be accomplished by designing the active material to have a high differential gain, increasing the confinement factor, decreasing the active volume, and heatsinking so that the device can be biased far above threshold. This can be seen by recasting the relaxation oscillation frequency as v2r ¼
vg aN Ghi ðI0 ITH Þ: qVP
The desire to bias the laser at the largest injection current and output power requires that adequate thermal management is employed to extract heat from the laser. In practice, state-ofthe-art multiquantum well diode lasers are limited by device heating and electrical parasitics. Figure 2.12 shows a 1550 nm diode laser with an integrated coplanar microwave transmission line to mitigate inductive and capacitive parasitics in the input electrical signal [4]. Finally, Figure 2.13 shows the evolution of high speed lasers. The record modulation bandwidth is still 45 GHz for a 980 nm diode laser. Today, several designs exist for 1550 nm diode lasers with bandwidths from 30 35 GHz. So far, we have only considered the small signal (linear) modulation response of the laser. In order to look at practical input modulation signals, it is useful to define the optical modulation depth (OMD): OMD ¼
DS HðvÞ h ¼ 2 Gvg aN i DI: qV S0 vR
The next section looks at the modulation response of the laser when the OMD is appreciable.
2.5 Signal Distortion and Spurious Free Dynamic Range In Section 2.2, we demonstrated that clamping the carrier density near threshold suppresses the intrinsic nonlinearity within the semiconductor device. This section describes the nonlinear response of semiconductor lasers given failure of gain clamping due to gain compression and current modulation.
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
54 50 InGaAs/GaAs Modulation bandwidth [GHz]
GaAs/AlGaAs 40
1.3µm InGaAsP/InP 1.55µm InGaAsP/InP
30
GaAS VCSEL
20
10
0 1980
1985
1990 Time of publication
1995
2000
Figure 2.13 Historical data showing improvements in direct modulation bandwidth for various semiconductor lasers
A perfectly linear device will generate a purely sinusoidal intensity modulation in response to a sinusoidal current modulation. For linear devices, superposition guarantees that multiple electrical channels driving a single element will not suffer from crosstalk. However, the superposition principlefailswhenconsideringnonlineardevices.Twoperfectlysinusoidalinputswillgeneratea host of output signals of varying frequencies. Figure 2.14 shows the RF frequency spectrum for a laser that is driven by two large signal sinusoids. The fundamental (linear) response is clearly visible as are the second-order (quadratic) and third-order (cubic) distortion products. To analyse the nonlinear distortions, the small signal expansion performed in Section 2.5 is applied, except this time, higher-order terms are kept as driving terms to the linear
Power relat ve to fundamental (dBc)
10 Fundamentals
0
Third order in band intermodulation products
Second order harmonic and intermodulation product
-10 -20 -30
Third order harmonics and intermodulation products
Second order harmonic and intermodulation product
-40 -50 -60 -70 -80
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Frequency (GHz)
Figure 2.14 RF spectrum of an optical link driven by two channels with large signal sinusoids. The various second order and third order distortion products are labelled
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
55
equations. This is based on the assumption that the overriding response of the system is linear and that the nonlinear distortions serve only to generate harmonics and intermodulation products which are subsequently filtered by the linear system. This assumption was used when deriving the small signal frequency response. This method will not work in general for arbitrary inputs, but for two-tone modulation with predictable nonlinear distortion products we can assume a sum of complex exponentials for the variations in the photon and carrier densities and substitute into the equations. The resulting series of equations in distortion products is closed by assuming the higher-order distortion products are much smaller than the lower-order ones, which allows a closed form solution with higher-order distortions expressed in terms of lower-order distortions. This is a reasonable assumption based on the experimental results and also from power series expansions of the optical power versus current response at low frequencies. As in Sections 2.2 and 2.4, the spatially homogeneous, single mode equations will be used to derive the majority of the discussion for this introduction. Near resonance, this model provides an accurate representation of even multimode lasers if appropriate model parameters are used. The small signal equations, retaining only the dominant intrinsic nonlinear driving terms for illustrative purposes are given below. In general, solving the nonlinear rate equations analytically is very difficult. However, for a sum of sinusoids it is straightforward to develop a scheme that gives reasonably simple analytic expressions. The basic idea is to assume a form of the current modulation: DI ¼ DI1 ejv1 t þ DI2 ejv2 t þ cc and a resulting carrier density and photon density modulation containing distortions of all orders of interest. Here cc denotes the complex conjugate. For example, to calculate the intermodulation distortions requires assuming the following form for the photon density: DS ¼ s11 ejv1 t þ s12 ejv2 t þ cc s21 ej2v1 t þ s22 ej2v2 t þ s23 ejðv1 þ v2 Þt þ s24 ejðv2 v1 Þt þ cc s31 ej3v1 t þ s32 ej3v2 t þ s33 ejð2v2 v1 Þt þ s34 ejð2v1 v2 Þt þ cc and similarly for the carrier density (see Table 2.1). After substituting these expressions into the rate equations and multiplying out the nonlinear terms, we collect the terms that have the same frequency dependence as the distortion product of interest and solve the resulting linear system, only keeping the driving term contributions of lower order than the distortion product of interest. Using this hierarchy, closed form solutions for the intermodulation distortion products can be calculated. Table 2.2 lists the solutions for the various distortion terms in the optical response of the laser. The contributions from the various device nonlinearities for second harmonic distortion are shown in Figure 2.15. Table 2.1 Form for the nonlinear photon density response under two tone modulation. Photon density Harmonic distortion Intermodulation distortion
2HD DS ¼ s1 ejvt þ s2 ej2vt 3HD DS ¼ s1 ejvt þ s2 ej2vt þ s3 ej3vt DS ¼ s11 ejv1 t þ s12 ejv2 t þ cc s21 ej2v1 t þ s22 ej2v2 t þ s23 ejðv1 þ v2 Þt þ s24 ejðv2 v1 Þt þ cc s31 ej3v1 t þ s32 ej3v2 t þ s33 ejð2v2 v1 Þt þ s34 ejð2v1 v2 Þt þ cc
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
56
Table 2.2
Definition of photon response terms used in Table 2.1.
Linear terms s1 ¼ S0 OMD Second-order harmonic terms Hð2vÞ 2 v ðOMDÞs1 v4R Third-order harmonic terms 3 Hð3vÞHð2vÞ 2 2 v2R 2 v v þ jvv þ s1 s3 ¼ OMD2 R 2 2 v4R s2 ¼
Third-order intermodulation terms 1 HðvÞHð2vÞ 2 2 v2R 2 s1 v v þ jvv þ s33 ¼ OMD2 R 2 2 v4R
Figure 2.15 The second order harmonic distortion in the optical modulation response of a laser diode. The heavy line is the total distortion. Also shown are the various device nonlinearities that contribute to the harmonic distortion
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
57
Figure 2.16 The third order intermodulation distortion in the optical response. Also, shown are the DC nonlinearities which also appear in the L I curve. For reference, the analytic expressions obtained by [5] and [6] when there is no gain compression are also shown
The separate contributions from the nonlinearity due to stimulated emission (intrinsic) and the gain compression nonlinearity are shown. At low frequencies, the intrinsic and gain compression nonlinearities are equal and cancel as seen by the roll off in the total driving terms. This cancellation is the “local” cancellation of these two effects that comes from the feedback stabilization of the carrier and photon densities at their steady- state values. Figure 2.16 shows the third-order intermodulation distortion often referred to as the inband distortion. The components of the third-order intermodulation driving terms are not shown because cancellation effects are not explicitly evident. However, since the third-order terms are generated by the second-order terms, a reduction in the second-order nonlinearities in general leads to a reduction in the third-order nonlinearities. Near resonance, the nonlinear driving terms are dominated by the intrinsic nonlinearity. The third-order intermodulation distortion is plotted in units of dBm/mA3 for different laser injection currents. The units are chosen per mA3 of modulation current because third-order distortions scale as the cube of the input modulation current. The intermodulation distortion spectrum contains two peaks: one at the relaxation oscillation peak and one at half of that frequency. The half frequency peak occurs because at that frequency, the second harmonic, which is a driving component for the third-order distortion, is resonant with the relaxation oscillation resonance. The main peak occurs because both the fundamental and the in-band third-order intermodulation distortion are resonant with the relaxation oscillation resonance.
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
58
3
Intermodulation distortion (dBm/mA )
40 20 0 –20
Output power (mW)
60
80 40 20 0
50 Blas (mA)
0
100
–40 –60 –80 –100 –120 5 10
Increasing output power 106
107
108 Frequency (Hz)
109
1010
1011
Figure 2.17 The third order intermodulation distortion as a function of increasing DC bias on the laser
The intermodulation distortion decreases as the modulation frequency decreases below the relaxation oscillation frequency because the gain clamping improves, which damps the nonlinear response. The same effect also occurs as the injection current increases because the larger steady-state photon density provides stronger feedback against carrier and photon density variations (see Figure 2.17). From this figure, it appears that to minimize the distortion, at a given modulation frequency, it is desirable to bias the laser as high as possible. There is a limit, however, that depends on the gain compression factor and device heating. From the above discussions, we see that there are different dependencies on DC output power for the various distortion components. In general, spatial-hole burning nonlinearities increase with output power whereas the intrinsic or stimulated emission nonlinearity improves with bias. The gain compression nonlinearity can cancel either of the above in different frequency ranges. Figure 2.18 shows that there will generally be an optimal bias point for minimizing the overall distortion.
2.6 Low-cost VCSEL RF Photonic Links Vertical cavity surface emitting lasers (VCSELs) benefit from their small form factor and circular geometry. The form factor enables massive parallelism in semiconductor manufacture and the circular geometry simplifies device packaging; both contribute to the relatively low cost of high-speed VCSELs. As a result, these small, inexpensive devices are finding their way into a large array of applications from sensing to data communications. Historically, the major thrusts of VCSEL design have been to minimize the threshold current, reduce the resistance of the DBR mirrors, increase device modulation speed and increase the single mode output power. All of these factors contribute to the increased utility of VCSELs for microwave photonics applications. With the VCSELs favourable optical properties, it is no surprise that there is a wealth of work done to characterize VCSELs for use in communication applications.
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
59
Figure 2.18 The measured spur free dynamic range for a Fujitsu CATV DFB laser. The dominant distortion considered was third order intermodulation distortion
Early work with high-speed characterization was carried out by Choa et al. [7] in 1991, and Shtengel et al. [8] and Mahon et al. [9] in 1993. Choa et al. provided modulation response measurements of high efficiency ion implanted VCSELs and demonstrated intensity and frequency modulation bandwidths as high as 8 GHz with a differential quantum efficiency estimated to be 50% which corresponds to a maximum link gain of 6 dB. However, when including the impedance matching to the 450 W differential resistance, the maximum link gain drops to 20 dB. Shtengel et al. demonstrated modulation bandwidths as high as 14 GHz with a differential quantum efficiency of only 8.4% which corresponds to a maximum link gain of 21.5 dB. When factoring in the measured differential resistance of 95 W, the maximum link gain is 31.7 dB assuming perfect coupling and perfect detector quantum efficiency. The second harmonic distortion was also measured and shown to be 5 dB below the fundamental when the input modulation power was 0 dBm, corresponding to a current of 4 mA. This gives a second harmonic distortion of 36 dB/mA2. Mahon et al. studied the relative intensity noise and second- and third-order harmonic distortion in multimode VCSELs. The modulation bandwidth was approximately 5 GHz with differential quantum efficiency of 20 % (14 dB maximum link gain) with differential resistance of 663 W (31 dB maximum total link gain). The second harmonic distortion estimated from the published data is 24 dB/mA2. More recently, investigations into the modulation response and linearity in VCSELs were carried out by Hietala et al. [10] in 1997. In that work, the modulation response and distortion was measured for an oxide aperture VCSEL along with light emission from square wave excitation. The maximum modulation bandwidth measured was 19 GHz with 40 % differential quantum
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
60 10 5
L nk Ga n (dB)
0 –5 1996 [11] –10
1996 [11]
1995 1996
–15
1987 [18] 1991 [15]
–20 1991 –25
1993 [16]
–30 –35 0
1993 [17] 100
200
300
400 500 600 700 Differential Resistance (Ω)
800
900
1000
Figure 2.19 The calculated link gain based on historical data for VCSEL quantum efficiency and electrical differential resistance. The solid curve is the calculated mismatch gain based only on the electrical impedance
efficiency (7.8 dB maximum link gain) and differential resistance of 264 W (17.8 dB maximum total link gain). The input IP3 was 6.5dBm. Subsequent studies of analogue modulation properties of VCSELs were carried out by Wesselmann et al. [11], who measured the spurious free dynamic range in long wavelength 1.3 mm and 1.5 mm VCSELs of 69 dB in an unspecified bandwidth. The IP3 was approximately 10 dBm; however, this measurement included an erbium doped optical amplifier whose gain was not specified. Dalal et al. [12], measured the dynamic range in short wavelength 980 nm VCSELs with maximum dynamic range of 85 dB in 1 Hz bandwidth. Finally, recent work by Lee et al. [13] and Carlsson et al. [14] explores the dynamic range of links employing oxide aperture VCSELs. The historical data discussed above is summarized in Figure 2.19. It shows a steady trend during the 1990s that coupled the reduction in electrical series resistance and enhanced external quantum efficiency to the overall improvements in link gain. We have employed relatively large diameter VCSELs to both reduce the series resistance, and therefore improve the mismatch link gain, and increase the external differential efficiency, since the boundary scattering is minimized. Measured SFDR for a 27 m multimode optical link employing an 850 nm VCSEL link is plotted in Figure 2.20. As the bias current increases the bandwidth over which high dynamic range can be achieved also increases. At low frequencies, the multimode link suffers from mode partition noise and therefore has a reduced dynamic range. The highest dynamic range (approximately 110 dB-Hz2/3) occurs for a number of bias currents in a range of frequencies between 900 MHz and 2.5 GHz. The centre of mass of the dynamic range is 105 dB- Hz2/3. From these measurements, it is clear that the dynamic range
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
61
Figure 2.20 The measured spur free dynamic range for an 850 nm VCSEL in a 27 m multimode fibre link [13]
intrinsic to the VCSELs is comparable to edge emitting lasers [15] and opens the possibility for considering VCSELs in high fidelity RF photonic links.
2.7 Cascade Laser Optical Links Here, we present a new class of laser structures which can be directly modulated and do not have any of the conventional restrictions on loss of electrical signal strength or increased noise of conventional semiconductor lasers. A conventional semiconductor laser emitting photons with perfect quantum efficiency has a slope efficiency of one; for every electron injected into the laser one photon is emitted from the laser. Some fraction of the generated photons is coupled into single mode fibre and arrives at the detector. Cascade lasers can compensate for link losses by generating more than one photon for every electron injected into the laser. This is possible because each carrier injected into the laser can sequentially tunnel into each of the multiple active regions, stimulating photon emission in each. Because each carrier injected into an N-stage cascade laser can undergo N photoemission events, the slope efficiency can potentially see an N-fold increase as well. If the noise in each of the photon streams from the N stages is independent of the noise in the other photon streams, a concomitant improvement in the signalto-noise ratio of the link is expected. In order to better appreciate the difference between a conventional multiple quantum well laser and a bipolar cascade laser (BCL) the reader is referred to Figure 2.21. In the conventional laser an injected electron may go into any one of the multiple quantum wells, but never more than one. The quantum wells may therefore be viewed as being in parallel. Figure 2.21 shows a three quantum well (or, equivalently, three gain section) BCL. In this case the injected electron can participate in a recombination event in the first quantum well, quantum mechanically tunnel from the valence band of the first gain section to the conduction band of the second gain section, and on through to the third gain section. In this case the electron goes through all the quantum wells and they are seen as being connected in series.
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
62
Electron
Figure 2.21 In a conventional multiple quantum well laser an injected electron may go into any one of the quantum wells and recombine, but only one. A cascade laser contains three quantum wells which are electrically in series
Assuming that enough photons can be generated (by connecting a sufficiently large number of lasers in series) to compensate for any loss in transporting the photons to a photodetector, it is conceivable that more electrons will be generated at the receiver than were put in at the source. This results in the concept of radio frequency (RF) gain. It is important to realize that this is not ‘creating energy’. The voltage drop across the series connected diodes is equal to N times the voltage drop across a single diode, where N is the number of diodes in series. Gain only occurs in the ‘small signal’ sense. The promise of cascade lasers for high-performance microwave links was first understood by researchers at DRA Malvern [16] and MIT [15] in a set of experiments employing series connected laser arrays. The series connected lasers mimic the enhanced efficiency expected in a cascade laser array. Indeed, these experiments demonstrated that positive link as high as þ 4 dB in a fibre coupled 1550 nm optical link could be achieved [15]. More importantly the additional photons were only weakly correlated in terms of their noise so the overall noise figure improved with the number of elements in series. A 6 dB improvement in the overall link noise figure was realized in these laser arrays (Figure 2.22).
2.7.1 Bipolar Cascade Lasers It is worthwhile to consider the historical evolution of the BCL. While all the devices described below operate on the same principle each is different from the others in some critical way. Careful study of each of these devices indicated the design limitations that prevented them from demonstrating room temperature, continuous wave performance. The BCL was first introduced by van der Ziel et al. in 1982 [18]. Three bulk 850 nm active region edge emitting lasers were connected electrically in series during the epitaxial process via two tunnel junctions. The device exhibited pulsed operation at room temperature with a duty cycle of 0.1 %. A differential efficiency of 80 % was achieved. Little was done with the concept until Garcia et al. [19] realized a similar device with an eye toward high-power arrays in 1997. The devices consisted of a two-stage cascade operating at 950 nm in the top-most junction and 980 nm in the bottom-most junction. The active regions were made of three quantum wells each. These devices also operated at room temperature and pulsed. A differential efficiency of 79 % was achieved.
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
63
Figure 2.22 Theoretical noise figure for a series connected laser array and bipolar cascade lasers [17]. The squares show the measured noise figure for the series array [15]
Kim et al. [20] also achieved room temperature pulsed operation of a three-stage device operating at 1.55 mm in 1999. This edge emitter was unique in that all of the three gain stages were contained inside a single waveguide. A pulsed slope efficiency of 125 % was obtained. BCL designs were not limited to edge emitters. Schmid et al. [21] achieved continuous wave operation of a two-stage BCL in a vertical cavity surface emitting laser (VCSEL) at an operating temperature of 95 K in 1998. Two gain sections of three quantum wells each were cascaded at an emission wavelength of 980 nm. The first room-temperature, continuous wave operation of a BCL was achieved by Patterson et al. [22]. A two-stage device operating at 990 nm achieved a quantum efficiency of 99.3 %. Figure 2.23 shows the room-temperature,
Figure 2.23 The measured light versus current curve for a room temperature bipolar cascade laser. The slope efficiency is 99.3 %. The inset shows the near field emission from the laser. Reproduced from [22]
64
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
continuous wave, L-I characteristics, of a nominally 5 mm wide and 450 mm long, bipolar cascade laser. The slope efficiency is 99.3 % (0.622 W/A) above threshold. A slope efficiency of 0.6 W/A is maintained up to a current of 58 mA, corresponding to a slope efficiency of 95.7 %. Such high efficiency is characteristic of cascade devices. Since that time a continuous wave, room-temperature demonstration of a BCL VCSEL has been reported by T. Kn€ odl et al. [23] at 980 nm and a room temperature pulsed VCSEL has been demonstrated by Kim et al. [24] at 1.55 mm. Kn€ odl et al. have recently achieved external quantum efficiencies of 130 % and have observed the enhancement in efficiency directly on the modulation properties of the device [25]. However, there is much that needs to be done to demonstrate the improved noise figure expected of these novel cascade laser devices. There is room for a new generation of directly modulated optical links which can provide unprecedented noise figures and dynamic ranges with the simplicity inherent in intensity modulated, direct detection optical links.
References [1] L.A. Coldren and S.W. Corzine, Diode Lasers and Photonic Integrated Circuits, Microwave and Optical Engineering, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA, 1995. [2] J. Chen, R.J. Ram and R. Helkey, “Linearity and third order intermodulation distortion in DFB semiconductor lasers”, IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics, vol. 35, no. 8, pp. 1231 1237, Aug. 1999. [3] R. Nagarajan, T. Fukushima, M. Ishikawa, J.E. Bowers, R.S. Geels and L.A. Coldren, “Transport limits in high speed quantum well lasers: experiment and theory”, IEEE Photonics Tech. Lett., vol. 4, no. 2, p. 121, 1992. [4] O. Kjebon, R. Schatz, S. Lourdudoss, S. Nilsson, B. Stalnacke and L. Backbom, “30 GHz direct modulation bandwidth in detuned loaded InGaAsP DBR lasers at 1.55 micron wavelength”, Electronics Letters, vol. 33, pp. 488 489, March 1997. [5] T.E. Darcie, R.S. Tucker and G.J. Sullivan, “Intermodulation and harmonic distortion in InGaAsP lasers”, Electron Lett., vol. 21, pp. 665 666, Aug. 1995. [6] J. Wang, M.K. Haldar and F.V.C. Mendis, “Formula for two carrier third order intermodulation distortion in semiconductor laser diodes”, Electron. Lett., vol. 29, pp. 1341 1343, July 1993. [7] F.S. Choa, Y.H. Lee, T.L. Koch, C.A. Vurrus, B. Tell, J.L. Jewell and R.E. Leibenguh, “High speed modulation of vertical cavity surface emitting lasers”, IEEE Photon. Techn. Lett., vol. 3, pp. 697 699, Aug. 1991. [8] G. Shtengel, H. Temkin, P. Brusenbach, T. Uchida, M. Kim, C. Parsons, W.E. Quinn and S.W. Swirhun, “High speed vertical cavity surface emitting laser”, IEEE Photon. Tech. Lett., vol. 5, pp. 1359 1362, Dec. 1993. [9] C.J. Mahon, M.L. Majewski, M.G. Peters, F.H. Peters and L. A. Coldren, “Relative intensity noise and modulation distortion characteristics of vertical cavity surface emitting laser diodes”, in LEOS 1993 Conference Proceedings, IEEE/Lasers & Electro Opt. Soc., IEEE, San Jose, USA, pp. 372 373, Nov. 1993. [10] V.M. Hietala, K.L. Lear, M.G. Armendariz, C.P. Tigges, H.Q. Hou and J.C. Zolper, “Electrical characterization and application of very high speed vertical cavity surface emitting lasers”, in IEEE MTT S International Microwave Symposium Digest, Denver, USA, pp. 355 358, June 1997. [11] J.R. Wesselmann, N.M. Margalit and J.E. Bowers, “Analog measurements of long wavelength vertical cavity lasers”, Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 72, pp. 2084 2086, Apr. 1998. [12] R.V. Dalal, R. J. Ram, R. Helkey, H. Roussell and K.D. Choquette, “Low distortion analogue signal transmission using vertical cavity lasers”, Electronics Letters, vol. 34, no. 16, pp. 1590 1591, Aug. 1998. [13] H.L.T. Lee, R.V. Dalal, R.J. Ram and K. D. Choquette, “Dynamic range of vertical cavity surface emitting lasers in multimode links”, IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, vol. 11, no. 11, pp. 1473 1475, Nov. 1999. [14] C. Carlsson, H. Martinsson, R. Schatz, J. Halonen and A. Larsson, “Analog modulation properties of oxide confined VCSELs at microwave frequencies”, Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol. 20, pp. 1740 1749, Sep. 2002. [15] C.H. Cox, III, H.V. Roussell, R.J. Ram and R.J. Helkey, “Broadband, directly modulated analog fiber link with positive intrinsic gain and reduced noise figure”, International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics. Piscataway, NJ, USA, pp. 157 160, 1998.
Direct Modulation for Microwave Photonics
65
[16] S. Ayling, D. Wight, M. Allenson, K. Hilton and G. Smith, “Intrinsically matched 50 ohm laser arrays with greater than 100% quantum efficiencies for optically coupled transistors and low loss fiber optic links”, Proceedings of the International Society for Optical Engineering, vol. 3285, pp. 199 208, 1998. [17] F. Rana and R.J. Ram, “Photon noise and correlations in semiconductor cascade lasers”, Applied Physics Letters, vol. 76, no. 9, pp. 1083 1085, Feb. 2000. [18] J.P. van der Ziel and W.T. Tsang, “Integrated multilayer GaAs lasers separated by tunnel junctions”, Applied Physics Letters, vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 499 501, Sept. 1982. [19] J.C. Garcia, E. Rosencher, P. Collot, N. Laurent, J.L. Guyaux, B. Vinter and J. Nagle, “Epitaxially stacked lasers with Esaki junctions: a bipolar cascade laser”, Applied Physics Letters, vol. 71, no. 26, pp. 3752 3754, Dec. 1997. [20] J.K. Kim, E. Hall, O. Sjolund and L. A. Coldren, “Room temperature, electrically pumped, multiple active region VCSELs with high differential efficiency at 1.55 mu m”, Technical Digest. CLEO/Pacific Rim 99. Pacific Rim Conference on Lasers and Electro Optics, vol. 2, pp. 553 L 554, 1999. [21] W. Schmid, D. Wiedenmann, M. Grabherr, R. Jager, R. Michalzik and K. J. Ebeling, “ CW operation of a diode cascade InGaAs quantum well VCSEL”, Electronics Letters, vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 553 555, March 1998. [22] S.G. Patterson, G.S. Petrich, R.J. Ram and L.A. Kolodziejski, “Continuous wave room temperature operation of bipolar cascade laser”, Electronics Letters, vol. 35, no. 5, pp. 395 397, March 1999. [23] T. Knodl, R. Jager, M. Grabherr, R. King, M. Kicherer, M. Miller, F. Mederer and K.J. Ebeleing, “CW room temperature operation of a diode cascade InGaAs AlGaAs quantum well VCSEL”, IEEE LEOS Annual Meeting Conference Proceedings, vol. 1, pp. 143 144, 1999. [24] J.K. Kim, S. Nakagawa, E. Hall and L.A. Coldren, “Near room temperature continuous wave operation of multiple active region 1.55 mu m vertical cavity lasers with high differential efficiency”, Applied Physics Letters, vol. 77, no. 20, pp. 3137 3139, Nov. 2000. [25] T. Knodl, M. Golling, A. Straub and K.J. Ebeling, “Multi diode cascade VCSEL with 130 % differential quantum efficiency at CW room temperature operation”, Electronics Letters, vol. 37, pp. 31 33, Jan. 2001.
3 High-power Distributed Photodetectors for RF Photonic Applications Sagi Mathai and Ming C. Wu
3.1 Introduction Photodetector linearity is of paramount importance in external intensity modulated direct detection (IMDD) analogue fibre-optic links. This realization has created a demand for high bandwidth, high saturation current photodetectors. Additionally, high current photodetectors have the potential to simplify receiver designs by eliminating the need for impedance matched electronic amplifiers. Applications that can benefit from high-performance photodetectors include antenna remoting, fibre-radio and terahertz signal generation by photomixing. The system level benefits of high current photodetectors may be seen by plotting the link RF gain (GRF), noise figure (NF), and spurious free dynamic range (SFDR) versus photocurrent for a hypothetical external IMDD link. The curves in Figure 3.1 clearly demonstrate the benefits of high current photodetectors. As the photocurrent increases so does the link performance until laser RIN dominates the noise floor. Link performance may be further improved by utilizing balanced detection, in which case laser RIN is suppressed, the shot-noise limited regime is extended, and with increasing photocurrent, GRF, NF and SFDR improve dramatically. Space charge effects and thermal runaway are the primary factors limiting photodetector high power operation [1]. Large photocurrent density in the absorption regions can screen the applied electric field leading to a lowering of the photogenerated carrier velocity and, ultimately, the complete collapse of the applied electric field [2]. Consequently, RF photoresponse decreases and nonlinearities generated by the photodetector start to degrade the system dynamic range.
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Edited by Stavros Iezekiel © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 978-0-470-84854-8
68
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications (a)
40
G RF (dB)
20
0
-20
-40
-60 0.01
0.1
1
100
10
1000
Photocurrent (mA)
(b) 80
NF (dB)
60
40
Conventional
20
Balanced 0 0.01
0.1
1
10
100
1000
Photocurrent (mA)
(c) 130
SFDR ( dBxHz 2/3 )
Balanced
110
Conventional
90
70 0.01
0.1
1
10
100
1000
Photocurrent (mA)
Figure 3.1 Simulated performance of an external intensity modulated direct detection analogue link, with and without balanced detection, in terms of (a) RF gain, (b) noise figure and (c) spurious free dynamic range. (Vp ¼ 6 V, hPD ¼ 0.9, link loss ¼ 15 dB, RIN ¼ 165 dBc/Hz and 50 W matched impedance)
High power Distributed Photodetectors for RF Photonic Applications
69
High photocurrent density also causes excessive Joule heating (bias voltage photocurrent) of the absorption region leading to thermally activated dark current runaway [3], which eventually results in catastrophic photodiode failure. Dark current and the effective barrier height for dark current flow are the fundamental device parameters involved in thermal runaway [4]. Photodetectors with low dark currents and high effective barriers have been found to sustain larger amounts of Joule heating before catastrophic failure. For example, metal semiconductor metal (MSM) photodetectors have much lower effective barriers than p i n diodes, and consequently, MSMs fail at 700 K [5] whereas p i n junctions can withstand temperatures up to 900 K [4]. It should also be mentioned that device fabrication induced damage, such as poor surface passivation and plasma induced damage, can increase the dark current and contribute to premature device failure. These issues are especially problematic in lumped element photodetectors, operating under high-power illumination, that rely on a small absorption volume (10 mm3) to achieve high bandwidth. An intuitive approach to mitigate space charge effects and thermal runaway is to distribute the photogenerated carriers over an enlarged absorption volume. First suggested in [6] by Taylor, the travelling wave concept applied to photodetectors has received considerable attention due to its ability to distribute photogenerated carriers over a large absorption volume without succumbing to RC time speed limitations found in lumped element devices. By embedding the photodetector in a transmission line, the diode capacitance becomes part of the transmission lines distributed admittance, while the load impedance associated with the lumped element device RC time is de-embedded. Hybrid [7, 8] and monolithic [9 16] implementations have been demonstrated. Most monolithic implementations are a variation of the p i n waveguide photodetector (WGPD) [17, 18] with the transmission line terminated at the input by a matched impedance. As shown in Figure 3.2, two types have been demonstrated: (1) continuous and (2) distributed. The continuous type is normally referred to as the travelling wave photodetector (TWPD), while the distributed type is referred to as the velocity match distributed photodetector (VMDP). In a TWPD, the absorption region spans the entire length of the microwave transmission line. Due to capacitive loading from the thin intrinsic absorption layer, the characteristic line impedance is typically lower than 50 W, and the microwave phase velocity is much lower than the optical group velocity (typically 30 % lower). This velocity mismatch can limit the bandwidth due to phase walk-off between the optical and electrical signals. Consequently, TWPDs are kept short to mitigate the effects of velocity mismatch. In VMDPs, the absorption length is divided among discrete transit time limited photodiodes periodically placed along a transmission line. The separation between diodes is used to dilute the capacitive loading on the transmission line and simultaneously achieve 50 W impedance and velocity matching. Consequently, the photocurrents from each photodiode are coherently added along the transmission line. This chapter reviews the research our group has performed in the area of high-speed high-power distributed photodetectors. Section 3.2 develops a transmission line modelling tool to design distributed photodetectors. Section 3.3 presents our experimental work on VMDPs, including balanced VMDPs. Section 3.4 presents a means to increase the saturation photocurrent in VMDPs by using parallel optical feed. Section 3.5 addresses the issue of backward travelling wave cancellation and a summary of the chapter is given in Section 3.6.
70
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 3.2 Physical layout of (a) a TWPD and (b) a VMDP. In the TWPD, the transmission line spans the entire length of the photodiode, while in the case of the VMDP, photodiodes are periodically arrayed along the transmission line
3.2 Transmission Line Model Design Tool The frequency response of distributed photodetectors may be calculated using the ABCD transfer matrix approach [19]. An equivalent circuit for the transmission line is shown in Figure 3.3. It consists of an array of unit cells comprising a section of transmission line with length D and a photodidode. The photodiodes are represented using a Norton equivalent circuit comprised of a series resistance, RS, and capacitance, Cj, shunted by an effective current source, ieff. The Norton equivalent photocurrent feeding the transmission line is related to the photocurrent generated in a photodiode, iph, by the following expression: ieff ¼
1 iph : 1 þ jvRs Cj
ð3:1Þ
The ABCD matrix for the transmission line segment of length D is written in terms of its characteristic line impedance, Z, and propagation constant g, while the ABCD matrix for the I0
I1
I2
IN-1
IN
+
+
+
+
+
Z T V0
V1
V2
VN-1
-
-
-
-
M1
VN ZL
-
M2 (a) Rs Cj
ieff
(b)
Figure 3.3 Equivalent circuit representations of (a) a distributed photodetector and (b) a single photodiode
71
High power Distributed Photodetectors for RF Photonic Applications
photodiode can be written in terms of an admittance Y. " # coshðg DÞ Zsinhðg DÞ M1 ¼ 1 sinhðg DÞ coshðg DÞ Z 1 0 M2 ¼ Y 1 Y¼
1 Rs þ j v1Cj
1
ð3:2Þ ð3:3Þ ð3:4Þ
The voltage and currents at the terminals of the unit cell may now be evaluated iteratively using: 0 Vn Vn þ 1 ¼ M2 M1 þ F expð jbo D nÞ ð3:5Þ ieff;n þ 1 t In þ 1 In where bo, n, and Ft are the optical propagation constant, unit cell index (n 2 [0,N]), and normalized transit time frequency response [20], respectively. The relationships between VN, IN and V0, I0 are obtained from Equation (3.5) by setting ieff to zero and assuming an input termination impedance ZT. The homogeneous solutions,V 0 N ; I 0 N , are obtained by setting V0, I0 to zero. 0 VN 1 V ¼ 0 N þ ðM2 M1 ÞN M1 1 V ; ð3:6Þ IN IN 1=ZT 0 where N is the total number of diodes. The total solution is obtained by superposition [14]. To investigate the effect of periodic loading on the transmission line, consider the simple case of a lossless transmission line. When the spacing between photodiodes is small compared to the microwave wavelength on the transmission line (< ¼ l/10), it may be considered electrically smooth. In this case, the loaded microwave phase velocity (vL) and characteristic impedance (ZL) are modified by the photodiode admittance or an effective capacitance, Ceff: vL ¼ q s ZL ¼ Ceff ¼
1 CTL þ
Ceff D
LTL CTL þ CDeff
1 j v Rs þ
1 Cj
:
ð3:7Þ LTL ð3:8Þ ð3:9Þ
Note that the capacitive loading can be tailored to achieve simultaneous velocity and impedance matching. If the transmission line loss can be neglected, the bandwidth of the VMDP is essentially limited by the intrinsic speed of a single photodetector in the array.
72
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
3.3 Velocity Matched Distributed Photodetectors In the VMDP, photodiodes are evanescently coupled to an underlying passive optical waveguide and periodically feed a transmission line. A unique advantage of the VMDP lies in its flexibility in optimizing the optical waveguide, photodiode and microwave transmission line independently. The optical waveguide can be designed with a large mode size for low fibreto-waveguide coupling loss and left undoped to minimize free-carrier absorption. The photodiodes can be optimized for high speed (as in conventional ultrafast photodiodes), and low optical confinement in the absorber for high saturation current. Impedance and velocity matching can be incorporated in the transmission line design, as well as low microwave propagation loss. The distributed design also mitigates thermally induced catastrophic failure due to thermal runaway [5]. The VMDP concept is so flexible that numerous types of photodiode structures have been implemented: metal semiconductor metal (MSM) [9, 14], Schottky [21], p i n [22] and the uni-travelling-carrier photodiode (UTC-PD) [13]. In our group, we demonstrated MSM based VMDPs on GaAs [14] and InP [10] material systems, but switched to p i n structures as they are less susceptible to thermal runaway and able to achieve much higher saturation current [22]. A crucial issue in VMDPs is the photocurrent distribution along the photodiode array. To characterize the distribution, VMDPs with split electrical contacts to each photodiode were fabricated. Figure 3.4 describes the photocurrent distribution among four photodiodes along an array. When the fibre-towaveguide alignment was optimized for the first photodiode, the responsivity was maximum, but the photocurrent distribution and linear current (22 mA) were poor. By optimizing the alignment to photodiodes farther away from the input waveguide facet, lower responsivity but much higher linear photocurrents (Figure 3.5) were possible. The best response was achieved when optimizing the alignment to the third photodiode: 35 GHz bandwidth and 45 mA linear DC photocurrent were achieved. At a higher photocurrent (55 mA), the waveguide input facet experienced catastrophic failure, while the p i n photodiodes remained operational [22].
Figure 3.4 Measured responsivity of individual photodiodes in a split contact VMDP with the input fibre alignment optimized for maximum photocurrent in the (a) first, (b) second, (c) third and (d) fourth photodiode. Reproduced from [22] ( 2001 IEEE)
73
High power Distributed Photodetectors for RF Photonic Applications
45.3mA R=0.36A/W
Photocurrent (mA)
50 35mA R=0.39A/W
40
22mA R=0.42A/W
30
20
Alignment optimized VMDP nd
2 PD
10
rd
3 PD
0 0
25
50
75
100
125
150
Input power (mW) Figure 3.5 Total photocurrent versus optical input power when the fibre to waveguide alignment was optimized for maximum responsivity in VMDP with a continuous transmission line, and to the second and third photodiodes in a split contact VMDP. Reproduced from [22] ( 2001 IEEE)
An important development in microwave photonics was the introduction of high-power balanced photodetectors for common mode optical noise (laser RIN and added amplified spontaneous emission noises) suppression. Shot-noise limited performance was demonstrated with a hybrid balanced detector built with commercially available low frequency photodetectors [23]. For high bandwidth operation, monolithic devices are required. Figure 3.6 shows the schematic and equivalent circuit of a monolithically integrated balanced photodetector based on the VMDP concept. It consists of a pair of parallel optical waveguides periodically coupled to high-speed p i n diodes and a coplanar waveguide (CPW) transmission line with a 50 W loaded characteristic impedance. Balanced mode operation is set by applying the reverse bias voltage between the ground electrodes of the CPW.
Figure 3.6
Schematic diagram and equivalent circuit of the balanced VMDP [22] ( 2001 IEEE)
74
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 3.7 Record high (a) CMRR versus photocurrent and (b) broadband laser RIN suppression in a balanced VMDP. Reproduced from [22] ( 2001 IEEE)
Figure 3.7 reports record high common mode rejection ratio (CMRR) of more than 37 dB from a few nA to 31 mA and laser RIN suppression of more than 40 dB from a few MHz to 8 GHz [22]. For comparison, in a balanced photodetector, 31 mA is equivalent to 62 mA in standard photodiodes.
3.4 Parallel Optical Feed Photodetectors The first diode in VMDPs and the input facet of continuous TWPDs usually generate the highest photocurrent density (per unit length) in the entire photodetector, and therefore failure occurs at the first diode or input facet, respectively. Techniques to improve the uniform distribution of photocurrent density include: tailoring the optical confinement factor in the absorber [24], employing electro-absorptive active materials to independently control the absorption coefficient in the propagation direction [21] and splitting the optical power equally among an array of discrete photodiodes using optical fibre delay lines [7]. Among these, parallel optical feed is the most direct avenue to achieve uniform photocurrent density. The VMDP concept is quite compatible with parallel optical feeds. A schematic of a parallel fed VMDP (PF-VMDP) is shown in Figure 3.8. It utilizes a 1 N multimode interference (MMI) optical power splitter [25], an array of high-speed photodiodes, a coplanar strip (CPS) microwave transmission line and an on-chip 50 W thin film resistor.
High power Distributed Photodetectors for RF Photonic Applications
Figure 3.8
75
Schematic diagram of the PF VMDP
We fabricated PF-VMDPs with MSM [26] and p i n photodiodes [27]. Although the saturation current was limited by the absorption volume in each individual photodiode, a higher saturation current can be achieved by increasing the MMI splitting ratio. Figure 3.9 shows DC linearity measurements on two PF-VMDPs employing identical MSM photodiodes but different MMI splitting ratios. The device with the 1 4 MMI saturates at 13.5 mA, while in the 1 8 case, linearity is maintained until device failure at 20.1 mA [28]. The maximum linear photocurrent can be further increased by increasing the splitting ratio and optimizing the MMI excess loss. A PF-VMDP implemented with p i n diodes showed even higher linear response. Referring to Figure 3.10, the DC photocurrent and detected RF power at 10 GHz are linear up to 52.2 mA and 9 dBm, respectively, without device failure. In this experiment, the available optical power limited the maximum photocurrent and RF power [27].
Figure 3.9 DC linearity measurements on MSM based PF VMDP. Higher MMI splitting ratio results in higher saturation current. Reproduced from [28] ( 2000 IEEE)
76
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 3.10 p i n based PF VMDP (a) DC saturation current measurement and (b) RF linearity at 10 GHz. Reproduced from [27] ( 2002 IEEE)
Although the saturation photocurrent can be increased by increasing the optical power splitting ratio, the quantum efficiency in PF-VMDPs is limited by the length of the individual photodiodes. Index matching layers (Figure 3.11) have been proposed as a means to increase the responsivity and reduce the length of waveguide coupled lumped element photodetectors [29].
Figure 3.11 Waveguide coupled photodiode epitaxial layer design with an index matching layer
High power Distributed Photodetectors for RF Photonic Applications
77
Figure 3.12 (a) Frequency response and (b) RF response at 20 GHz for photodetectors with different index matching layer extension (Detector A ¼ 8 mm, and Detector B ¼ 18 mm). Reproduced from [30] ( 2002 IEEE)
By varying the matching layer extension in front of the photodiode, the absorption profile can be tailored to improve the linearity of the device without sacrificing bandwidth [30]. Figure 3.12 compares the frequency response and RF response at 20 GHz for two detectors (A and B) with different matching layer extensions (A ¼ 8 mm and B ¼ 18 mm). Detectors A and B had identical RC limited bandwidths of 30 GHz, but detector B exhibited nearly an order of magnitude improvement in RF response at 20 GHz [30].
3.5 Backward Wave Cancellation A fundamental issue for travelling wave devices is the backward propagating wave illustrated in Figure 3.13. Without the input termination being matched to the line impedance, the backward wave, reflected at the open input termination, can destructively interfere with the forward propagating wave and thus limit the bandwidth. To improve the bandwidth, an impedance matched to the line impedance may be employed, but at the expense of efficiency. This point is illustrated experimentally in Figure 3.14 for a TWPD with and without a 50 W input termination [33]. With a 50 W input termination, the RF
78
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 3.13 Illustration of backward and forward waves generated by photodiodes along a VMDP with (a) open input termination and (b) matched termination
response drops by 6 dB, while the bandwidth broadens by a few gigahertz. High-speed operation without sacrificing responsivity can be obtained by backward wave cancellation (BWC) using a multisection transmission line, originally proposed by Ginzton for distributed amplification in travelling wave tubes [32]. A schematic of our multisection travelling wave distributed photodetector (MS-TWDP) and its equivalent circuit is shown in Figure 3.15. Much like the VMDP, it consists of a passive optical waveguide loaded with an array of photodiodes represented by current sources. Similar structures have been proposed in [15]. The forward travelling photocurrents are coherently combined on a multisection transmission line, while the backward travelling photocurrents are eliminated. The impedance mismatch between adjacent sections causes a negative reflection coefficient, G, such that the reflected photocurrent, GI1, cancels the backward propagating photocurrent, bI2.
Figure 3.14 Effect of input termination on the frequency response of TWPD. Reproduced from [33] ( 2003 IEEE)
High power Distributed Photodetectors for RF Photonic Applications
79
Figure 3.15 Schematic of (a) the MS TWDP and (b) its equivalent circuit. The arrows indicate forward and backward wave current flow. Reproduced from [33] ( 2003 IEEE)
For example, between sections 1 and 2, the following condition must be satisfied. GI1 þ bI2 ¼ 0:
ð3:10Þ
By applying a similar condition at each node between transmission line segments a general condition for the line impedance can be derived. nX þ1
Zn þ 1 j¼1 ¼ n X Zn
Ij ð3:11Þ Ii
i¼1
where Zn, Zn þ 1, and Ii are the impedances of sections n and n þ 1 (n increasing from the input end) and the photocurrent generated by the i-th diode, respectively. For the case of equal photocurrent contributions from each photodiode, the equation simplifies to Zn ¼ Z1 =n, where Z1 and Zn are the line impedance of the input and n-th sections, respectively [33]. Initially, we demonstrated BWC for unequally distributed photocurrents [31], but later employed photodiode arrays with uniform photocurrent distribution [33]. Figure 3.16 compares the frequency response of a standard distributed TWDP (SS-TWDP) with a continuous CPS and MS-TWDP. The low frequency roll-off was due to the measurement equipment and not the photodetectors. In each case, the optical waveguides, total absorption volume and responsivity ( 0.25 A/W) were nearly identical. In the continuous CPS case, the efficiency reduced by 6 dB while the bandwidth increased by more than a factor of two when the input was terminated with the line impedance. In the MS-TWDP, less than 2 dB reduction in efficiency was seen when an input termination was used, which indicates that 1 dB of photocurrent was flowing towards the input. More importantly, the bandwidth of MS-TWDP
80
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 3.16 Experimental demonstration of bandwidth and efficiency improvement using BWC in MS TWDP. The MS TWDP achieves similar bandwidth to the standard distributed TWDP without sacrificing efficiency. Reproduced from [31] ( 2002 IEEE)
was comparable to the terminated continuous CPS version but with a 6 dB response improvement [31]. A scanning electron micrograph (SEM) of a MS-TWDP with uniform photocurrent distribution is given in Figure 3.17. The widths of the coplanar lines and separation between ground and signal were adjusted to obtain the desired impedances of 150 W, 75 W and 50 W in the three sections. The waveguide design employed index matching layers to optimize the absorption profile in each diode for high linearity, while the lengths of the photodiodes were adjusted for uniform photocurrent generation. Referring to Figure 3.18, the measured frequency without an input termination was 38 GHz, 2.5 times higher than the round-trip bandwidth limit of 15 GHz, thus confirming successful BWC. Note also the steep roll-off beyond the 3 dB bandwidth (much steeper than the typical RC roll-off in lumped element devices) this is indicative of multisection transmission line designs. The 1 dB compression point at 40 GHz is 5 dBm, at which point failure occurs due to
Figure 3.17 SEM of a fabricated MS TWDP with three p i n diodes and a three section coplanar strip line. The impedances needed for BWC at each section are indicated on the respective transmission line segments [33] ( 2003 IEEE)
High power Distributed Photodetectors for RF Photonic Applications
81
Figure 3.18 RF performance of a MS TWDP: (a) frequency response (3 dB bandwidth equal to 38 GHz) and (b) linearity measurements at 40 GHz. Reproduced from [33] ( 2003 IEEE)
thermally induced interconnect metal breakage at the first diode. Consequently, the responsivity dropped by 30 %, but the MS-TWDP remained operational. With thicker metals and improved heat sinking, much higher linear RF power is achievable [33, 34].
3.6 Conclusion High-power, broadband, impedance matched photodetectors are crucial components in highperformance external IMDD analogue fibre-optic links. If high saturation power photodetectors are available, excess laser power can be utilized to simultaneously improve RF gain, noise figure and spurious free dynamic range. The VMDP concept provides the flexibility to design photodetectors with the potential to meet these challenges. Our toolbox for implementing high performance VMDPs includes a travelling wave transmission line model (ABCD matrix approach), novel optical waveguide designs (evanescent coupling and matching layers), multiple architectures (serial and parallel optical feed) and microwave techniques (backward wave cancellation). By selecting the best methods from our toolbox, and with more recent advances in photodiode epitaxial layer design and heat sinking, the VMDP concept has the potential to make an even greater impact on RF photonic systems.
82
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
References [1] K.J. Williams and R.D. Esman, “Design considerations for high current photodetectors”, Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol. 17, pp. 1443 1454, 1999. [2] K. Kato, “Ultrawide band/high frequency photodetectors”, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 47, pp. 1265 1281, 1999. [3] J.S. Paslaski, P.C. Chen, J.S. Chen, C.M. Gee and N. Bar Chaim “High power microwave photodiode for improving performance of RF fiber optic links”, Proc. SPIE, Photonics and Radio Frequency, Denver, CO, USA, vol. 2844, pp. 110 119, 1996. [4] M.S. Islam, T. Jung, T. Itoh, M.C. Wu, A. Nespola, D.L. Sivco and A.Y. Cho, “High power and highly linear monolithically integrated distributed balanced photodetectors”, Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol. 20, pp. 285 295, 2002. [5] A. Nespola, T. Chau, M. Pirola, M.C. Wu, G. Ghione and C.U. Naldi, “Failure analysis of traveling wave MSM distributed photodetectors”, International Electron Devices Meeting, San Francisco, CA, USA, 1998. [6] H.F. Taylor, O. Eknoyan, C.S. Park, K.N. Choi and K. Chang, “Traveling wave photodetectors”, Proc. SPIE, Optoelectronic Signal Processing for Phased Array Antennas II, Los Angeles, CA, USA, vol. 1217, pp. 59 63, 1990. [7] C.L. Goldsmith, G.A. Magel and R.J. Baca, “Principles and performance of traveling wave photodetector arrays”, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 45, pp. 1342 1350, 1997. [8] H.H. Hashim, and S. Iezekiel, “Traveling wave microwave fiber optic links”, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques vol. 54, pp. 951 958, 2006. [9] E.H. Bottcher, H. Pfitzenmaier, E. Droge, S. Kollakowski, A. Strittmatter, D. Bimberg and R. Steingruber, “Distributed waveguide integrated InGaAs MSM photodetectors for high efficiency and ultra wideband oper ation”, Eleventh International Conference on Indium Phosphide and Related Materials, Davos, Switzerland, pp. 79 82, May 1999. [10] T. Chau, L. Fan, D.T.K. Tong, S. Mathai, M.C. Wu, D.J. Sivco and A.Y. Cho, ‘“Long wavelength velocity matched distributed photodetectors”’, CLEO, San Francisco, CA, USA, p. 377, May 1998. [11] K.S. Giboney, J.W. Rodwell and J.E. Bowers, “Traveling wave photodetector theory”, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 45, pp. 1310 1319, 1997. [12] V.M. Hietala, G.A. Vawter, T.M. Brennan and B.E. Hammons, “Traveling wave photodetectors for high power, large bandwidth applications”, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 43, pp. 2291 2298, 1995. [13] Y. Hirota, T. Ishibashi and H. Ito, “1.55 mm wavelength periodic traveling wave photodetector fabricated using unitraveling carrier photodiode structures”, Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol. 19, pp. 1751 1758, 2001. [14] L.Y. Lin, M.C. Wu, T. Itoh, T.A. Vang, R.E. Muller, D.L. Sivco and A.Y. Cho, “High power high speed photodetectors design, analysis, and experimental demonstration”, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 45, pp. 1320 1331, 1997. [15] J. W. Shi C. K. Sun and J.E. Bowers “Taper line distributed photodetector”, 14th Annual Meeting of the IEEE Lasers and Electro Optics Society, San Diego, CA, USA, pp. 382 383, Nov. 2001. [16] A. Stohr and D. Jager, “Ultra wideband traveling wave photodetectors for THz signal generation”, IEEE LEOS Annual Meeting, Westin Rio Mar Puerto Rico vol. V 1, pp. 200 201, Nov. 2004. [17] K. Kato, A. Kozen, Y. Muramoto, Y. Itaya, T. Nagatsuma and M. Yaita, “110 GHz, 50% efficiency mushroom mesa waveguide p i n photodiode for a 1.55 mm wavelength”, IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, vol. 6, pp. 719 721, 1994. [18] A.R. Williams, A.L. Kellner, X.S. Jiang and P.K.L. Yu, “InGaAs/InP waveguide photodetector with high saturation intensity”, Electronics Letters, vol. 28, pp. 2258 2259, 1992. [19] D.M. Pozar, ‘Microwave Engineering’, second edition, John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York, USA, 1998. [20] J.E. Bowers and C.A. Burrus, Jr., “Ultrawide band long wavelength p i n photodetectors”, Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol. LT 5, pp. 1339 1350, 1987. [21] M.P. Nesnidal, A.C. Davidson, G.R. Emmel, R.A. Marsland and M.C. Wu, “Efficient, reliable high power VMDPs for linear fiber optic signal transmission”, PSAA 10, Monterey, CA, USA, 2000. [22] M.S. Islam, S. Murthy, T. Itoh, M.C. Wu, D. Novak, R.B. Waterhouse, D.L. Sivco and A.Y. Cho, “Velocity matched distributed photodetectors and balanced photodetectors with p i n photodiodes”, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 49, pp. 1914 1920, 2001.
High power Distributed Photodetectors for RF Photonic Applications
83
[23] K.J. Williams and R.D. Esman, “Optically amplified downconverting link with shot noise limited performance”, IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, vol. 8, pp. 148 150, 1996. [24] S. Jasmin, N. Vodjdani, J.C. Renaud and A. Enard, “Diluted and distributed absorption microwave waveguide photodiodes for high efficiency and high power”, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 45, pp. 1337 1341, 1997. [25] R.M. Jenkins, R.W.J. Devereux and J.M. Heaton, “Waveguide beam splitters and recombiners based on multimode propagation phenomena”, Optics Letters, vol. 17, pp. 991 993, 1992. [26] S. Murthy, T. Jung, T. Chau, M.C. Wu, D.L. Sivco and A.Y. Cho, ‘“A novel parallelly fed traveling wave photodetector with integrated MMI power splitter”’, Baltimore, MD, USA, 2000. [27] S. Murthy, M.C. Wu, D. Sivco and A.Y. Cho, “Parallel feed traveling wave distributed pin photodetectors with integrated MMI couplers”, Electronics Letters, vol. 38, pp. 78 80, 2002. [28] S. Murthy, T. Jung, C. Tai, M.C. Wu, D.L. Sivco and A.Y. Cho, “A novel monolithic distributed traveling wave photodetector with parallel optical feed ”, IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, vol. 12, pp. 681 683, 2000. [29] R.J. Deri and O. Wada, “Impedance matching for enhanced waveguide/photodetector integration”, Applied Physics Letters, vol. 55, pp. 2712 2712, 1989. [30] S. Murthy, T. Jung, M.C. Wu, Z. Wang and W. Hsin, “Linearity improvement in photodetectors by using index matching layer extensions”, 15th Annual Meeting of the IEEE Lasers and Electro Optics Society, Glasgow, UK, vol. 2, pp. 424 425, Nov. 2002. [31] S. Murthy, T. Jung, M.C. Wu, D.L. Sivco and A.Y. Cho, “Traveling wave distributed photodetectors with backward wave cancellation for improved AC efficiency”, Electronics Letters, vol. 38, pp. 827 829, 2002. [32] E.L. Ginzton, W.R. Hewlett, J.H. Jasberg and J.D. Noe, “Distributed amplification”, Proc. I.R.E., vol. 36, pp. 956 969, 1948. [33] S. Murthy, K. Seong Jin, T. Jung, W. Zhi Zhi, H. Wei, T. Itoh and M.C. Wu, “Backward wave cancellation in distributed traveling wave photodetectors”, Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol. 21, pp. 3071 3077, 2003. [34] N. Duan, X. Wang, N. Li, H.D. Liu and J.C. Campbell, “Thermal Analysis of High Power InGaA InP Photodiodes”, IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics, vol. 42, p. 1255, 2006.
4 Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation Andreas St€ ohr and Dieter J€ager
4.1 Introduction The photonic oscillator concept is a rather new technique for providing low-phase noise continuous-wave signals in the THz regime. Compared to other electrical and optical generation techniques, photonic oscillators exhibit a number of unique features such as ultra-wideband tuneability, compactness and ability to operate over a broad temperature range making it an interesting device for several THz applications. According to a recent study initiated by the European Space Agency (ESA), photonic oscillators utilizing advanced photodetectors are considered as one of the most promising candidates for the generation of THz signals [1]. This chapter reviews the state-of-the-art in photonic oscillators for THz generation and compares this new technique with other existing electrical and optical approaches. Since the development of terahertz photonic oscillators is strongly related to the invention of ultra high-frequency photodetectors we will also cover recent achievements in high-frequency photodetectors in this chapter. Explicitly, we will discuss the high-frequency performance of distributed travelling-wave photodetectors which exhibit a great potential for efficient local oscillator (LO) generation at THz frequencies. This fact is experimentally proven by demonstrating compact photonic oscillators employing advanced travelling-wave photodetectors which are indeed capable of providing sufficient LO power at THz frequencies (e.g. to pump a superconductor insulator superconductor (SIS) mixer at around 500 GHz). A key and unique feature of a photonic oscillator compared to other THz sources is its ability to allow for tuning the LO frequency over a wide frequency range. As an example, compact photonic oscillator modules exhibiting an amazingly large tuning range of almost 1 THz will be presented.
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Edited by Stavros Iezekiel © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 978-0-470-84854-8
86
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
1meV
1cm
10meV
1mm
100meV
energy
100 µm
1eV
wavelength 10 µm
10eV
100nm
1 µm 1.55 1.3
mm
30GHz
THz (submm)
300GHz
far-IR
3THz
frequency
IR
30THz
visible
300THz
UV
3PHz
Figure 4.1 The electromagnetic spectrum between 30 GHz and 3000 THz. The term THz is commonly applied to the submm wave frequency range which extends from 300 GHz up to about 3 THz
4.2 THz Sources Today, the term terahertz is commonly applied to submillimetre-wave (submm-wave) energy that fills the wavelength range of 1000 mm 100 mm (300 GHz 3 THz). Below 300 GHz, we enter the millimetre-wave (mm-wave) regime covering the wavelength region of 10 1 mm (30 300 GHz). Beyond 3 THz and up to 30 THz (100 10 mm) we enter the far-infrared (far-IR), but the exact border between submillimetre and far-infrared is still rather blurred since the frequency range 3 10 THz is more or less unclaimed territory. Above 30 THz there is the infrared region covering the wavelength span 10 1 mm (frequency 30 300 THz). In Figure 4.1, the commonly assigned terms for the various frequency bands of the electromagnetic spectrum between 30 GHz and 3 PHz are indicated. So far, the THz frequency regime has been of interest for some more or less niche applications existing in that high-frequency range. Today, we notice a significantly increased interest in THz technologies which is in part stimulated by some recent space and earth exploration experiments such as the Atacama large millimetre array (ALMA) telescope project [2]. The ALMA telescope will be the largest ground telescope for astronomers in the next decade, comprising some 64 submm-wave high quality antennas. ALMA will make it possible to scan and map the emission lines of a variety of lightweight molecules within the frequency region from 30 to 950 GHz for studying the formation of stars and planets. However, besides astronomy there is also much interest in THz technology for imaging applications (Tray imaging), for security applications and even for some communication systems. An excellent overview of the various applications in the THz frequency band can be found in the review paper by Siegel [3]. Despite the fact that there is quite some interest in THz frequencies, the commercial use (e.g. the development of compact THz sources) is only just beginning to emerge. Looking at the various existing concepts for high-frequency LO power sources summarized in Figure 4.2, it is noticeable that all-electronic solutions such as Gunn diodes, IMPATT diodes, resonant tunnelling diodes (RTD) or frequency doublers and triplers are widely employed in the mm-wave and ‘lower’ submm-wave regions. On the other hand, all-optical sources, namely different types of lasers such as p-doped Ge lasers or quantum cascade lasers (QCLs) are
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
87
Figure 4.2 Overview of available all electrical and all optical power sources versus operating frequency; power slopes with frequency are also indicated (original data has been prepared by J. Hesler [1])
employed in the far-IR. Among optical sources, QCLs are very promising devices for the lower far-IR region, being currently limited in terms of their lower cut-off frequency at around a few THz. For lower frequencies in the THz frequency range, there is almost no power source available as can be seen from Figure 4.2, not to mention the complexity of the few sources existing at all. Obviously, at this point the question arises as to whether optoelectronics could provide a compact source technology not only for the THz frequency range but also for lower frequencies in the mm-wave range. Recently, some promising high-frequency optoelectronic or photonic solutions have been investigated and the achievements in this field of research indicate that the photonic oscillators (PO) concept indeed has great potential for the generation of continuous-wave THz signals with reasonable power levels. As compared to purely electrical and optical solutions the PO concept exhibits some unique advantages such as ultra-wide tuneability, compactness and the possibility of room-temperature operation. These advantages have increased the interest in the PO concept but so far the implementation of optoelectronics for THz signal generation has been delayed; this is mainly because of the limited power level of POs and because of some technological uncertainties of this emerging technique. However, in the course of ongoing research and developments, the power level provided by POs is increasing while on the other hand the required power levels for example the power level to pump a THz mixer are decreasing. This fact will foster the future development and improvement of THz POs which do have the potential to become a baseline technology for a wide variety of high-frequency applications as we will show later in this chapter. At first, we shall discuss the effect of optical heterodyning or photomixing in a photodetector, which is the fundamental physical mechanism employed in a PO for generating a highfrequency sinusoidal signal. Then, the basic constitution of a photonic oscillator for highfrequency sinusoidal or quasi-sinusoidal signal generation is explained. Since the performance of a PO in terms of maximum operating frequency and maximum available power is to a large extent determined by the high-frequency photodetector being used, we will look at the various
88
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
existing types of high-frequency photodetectors and compare them in terms of their highfrequency performance. Next, the high-frequency performance of travelling-wave photodetectors (TWPDs) is investigated using an analytical model describing the vertical and longitudinal carrier transport in a TWPD. By using this model, the major physical effects determining the efficiency of TWPDs at high frequencies are studied. In Section 4.5, various fabricated photonic oscillator modules will be presented, yielding either quasi-optical free space radiation of the generated THz signals or guided transmission within a rectangular metallic waveguide. Ultra-wideband (0.02 0.7 THz) bow-tie antenna integrated and narrow band 0.46 THz slot antenna integrated photonic oscillators are presented in detail, as well as rectangular waveguide coupled TWPDs that enable ultra-wideband continuous-wave signal generation from 0.06 THz up to 1 THz.
4.3 Optical Heterodyning or Photomixing in a Photodetector The fundamental physical principle that is used in photonic THz oscillators is to down-convert optical infrared signals to the THz regime by employing a high-frequency photodetector. This principle, which is also called optical heterodyning or photomixing, is illustrated in Figure 4.3. Two phase-locked infrared waves with angular frequencies v1 and v2 are superimposed and injected into a high-frequency photodetector that down-converts the infrared input signal to the THz frequency regime by generating an electrical signal at the frequency v2-v1. To explain this in more detail, let us consider the relation between the generated electrical output signal and the two superimposed optical input waves from a more physical point of view. For simplicity, we assume that the two optical input waves are linearly polarized monochromatic plane waves in the infrared which propagate in the þ z direction. Let ^ 1 e jðv1 t E1 ¼ E
k1 z þ w1 Þ
e1 ;
ð4:1Þ
^ 2 e jðv2 t E2 ¼ E
k2 z þ w2 Þ
e2 ;
ð4:2Þ
and
Beam splitter ω2 − ω1
Photodiode
ω1
ω2~ω1, ω2,ω1>>ω2 − ω1
+z direction ω2
Figure 4.3 Principle for optical heterodyne generation employing a high frequency photodetector. The angular frequencies of the two optical input waves v1 and v2 are in the IR region (e.g. 200 THz), whereas the difference frequency v2 v1 of the generated output signal is much lower, typically in the THz or mm wave region
89
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
^ 1 and E ^ 2, be the complex electrical field vectors of the two optical waves, with field amplitudes E angular frequencies v1 and v2 and wave numbers k1 and k2. The phase of each optical input wave is considered by w1 and w2 and e1 and e2 are the unit vectors determining the orientation of the electrical field vector of the linearly polarized optical input waves. The intensities of the constituent waves are given by the magnitude of their Poynting vectors and are therefore given by r 1 «r «0 ð4:3Þ jE1 j2 ; I1 ¼ 2 m0 and I2 ¼
1 2
r
«r «0 jE2 j2 : m0
ð4:4Þ
If the two incident optical waves are perfect plane waves and have precisely the same polarization (e1 ¼ e2), the resulting electrical field E0 of the optical interference signal is the sum of the two constituent input fields and hence we can write E0 ¼ E1 þ E2. Taking the squared absolute value of the optical interference signal we obtain jE0 j2
¼
jE1 þ E2 j2 ¼ jE1 j2 þ jE2 j2 þ E1 E2 * þ E1 * E2
¼
jE1 j2 þ jE2 j2 þ 2jE1 jjE2 jcosððv2 v1 Þ t ðw2 w1 ÞÞ
:
ð4:5Þ
From Equation (4.5) and by using Equations (4.3) and (4.4), it follows that the intensity of the interference signal I0 is given by p I0 ¼ I1 þ I2 þ 2 I1 I2 cosððv2 v1 Þ t ðw2 w1 ÞÞ: ð4:6Þ By launching this optical interference signal into a photodetector, a photocurrent i is generated which can be expressed as s i ¼ h0 q=hf1 P1 þ h0 q=hf2 P2 þ 2hfc q=h
P 1 P2 cosððv2 v1 Þ t ðw2 w1 ÞÞ; ð4:7Þ f1 f2
where q is the electron charge and P1 and P2 denote the optical power levels of the two constituent optical input waves. The photodetector’s DC and high-frequency quantum efficiencies are represented by h0 and hf c . It is of course important to consider that the detector’s quantum efficiency is not independent of the frequency. Several intrinsic and extrinsic effects such as transit time limitations or microwave losses will eventually limit the high-frequency performance of the detector and thus the detector’s DC responsivity h0 is typically much larger than its high-frequency responsivity hf c . In our case, we can further simplify the photocurrent equation (Equation (4.7)) by considering the fact that the two optical input waves are close in frequency (f1 f2) whereas the difference frequency fc is by far smaller ( fc ¼ f2 f1 f1, f2). As an example, if we employ a photodetector operating in the infrared at 1.55 mm wavelength, we might use optical input wavelengths at l1 ¼ 1.55 mm ( f1 ¼ 193.4 THz) and l2 ¼ 1.542 mm ( f2 ¼ 194.4 THz). In this case, the difference frequency would be exactly fc ¼ 1 THz which is about 200 times smaller than the optical frequencies. A small detuning of
90
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
one input laser wavelength by only 0.8 nm (at 1.55 mm) thus results in a remarkable change of the beat frequency by about 100 GHz. If we further assume for simplicity that the power levels of the two optical input waves are equal (Popt P1 P2), Equation (4.7) becomes i ¼ 2s0 Popt þ 2sf c Popt cosð2pfc t þ DwÞ;
ð4:8Þ
fc ¼ f 2 f 1 ;
ð4:9Þ
where
denotes the difference frequency or beat frequency of the two constituent optical input waves and Dw ¼ w2 w1. Here s0 ¼ h0q/hf and sf c ¼ hf c q=hf are the photodetector’s DC and highfrequency responsivities given in A/W. Equation (4.8) is the fundamental equation describing optical heterodyning in a photodetector. The first term is the DC photocurrent generated by the constituent optical input waves and the second term is the desired high-frequency signal oscillating at the difference frequency fc (down-converter). From a physical point of view, it is important to note that by optical heterodyning no signal is generated which oscillates at the sum of the two optical frequencies. This is in contrast to nonlinear effects such as three-wave mixing in a second-order nonlinear optical medium where not only the difference frequency but also a wave at a higher frequency f1 þ f2 (up-converter) is generated. According to the theoretical discussion above, a photonic oscillator for sinusoidal LO generation thus consists of an optical heterodyne source generating the dual wavelength or dual mode optical signal and a high-frequency photodetector. Schematically, this concept is illustrated in Figure 4.4. Besides compact size, light weight and room temperature operation, a large tuning range is another important advantage of the PO concept. Slightly shifting the wavelength of one laser by only 0.8 nm results in a remarkable tuning of the beat frequency by 100 GHz as discussed above. The maximum tuning range of the PO is mainly determined by the high-frequency responsivity of the employed photodetector and the locking range of the optical heterodyne source. As we will see later in this chapter, the tuning range can be quite large and a tuning range of about 1 THz has already been achieved experimentally. Instead of using a dual-mode optical input signal to the photodetector (PD) one can also use a multimode optical input signal for generating a quasi-sinusoidal oscillator signal. This concept is shown schematically in Figure 4.5. Here the optical spectrum consists not only of two modes but of a larger number of modes, with a constant difference frequency fc between all
Phase P e locked l k optical heterodyne source ur
Popt
High frequency nc photodiode p o
λ2
λ1 ∆λ0 λ0
fc ≈ c0 ⋅
∆λ λ20
λ
Figure 4.4 Typical set up of a photonic local oscillator consisting of a stabilized optical source generating a phase locked optical heterodyne signal and a high frequency photodetector generating the electrical beat signal in the THz frequency regime
91
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
Optical p multimode e source e
Popt
High-frequency i n photodetector p o d t o
fc
λ0
fc
λ
Figure 4.5 Typical set up of a photonic local oscillator consisting of a stabilized optical source for generating an optical comb signal featuring a constant difference frequency fc between the various longitudinal optical modes
neighbouring modes. In this case, the photodetector generates a quasi-sinusoidal output signal at the difference frequency fc. The multimode optical source employed in this approach could be a mode-locked laser diode (MLLD) for example. In order to generate an oscillator signal with high spectral purity and high stability the locking of the optical modes is crucial. Different injection techniques for achieving optical mode locking have been proposed and investigated. The selection of two phase locked modes from a multimode optical source, such as a Fabry Perot laser, a mode-locked laser diode [4] or an optical comb generator [5, 6] is a comparably straightforward approach. Other approaches are based upon optical injection locking of two independent lasers using an optical phase locked loop (PLL) configuration [7]. For verification of the spectral purity and stability of the optically generated oscillator signal, phase and amplitude noise measurements have been performed. So far, this has been done mainly at ‘lower’ frequencies in the microwave and mm-wave frequency range. As an example, the phase noise of a mode-locked photonic oscillator in the microwave region has been measured to be as low as 125 dBc/Hz at 10 kHz offset from the oscillator frequency. At higher frequencies in the mm-wave regime the typical phase noise is of the order of 80 dBc/Hz to 95 dBc/Hz at 10 kHz offset. The phase and amplitude noise of a PO at THz frequencies has not been thoroughly investigated yet but from initial experiments there is evidence that the phase noise of photonic THz oscillators is comparable to the phase noise of allelectronic Gunn oscillators and warm multiplier assemblies [8]. Further key specifications of a photonic oscillator, namely the frequency and power level of the generated signal as well as the possible tuning range, depend strongly on the performance of the employed high-frequency photodetector. From Equation (4.8) we note that the output power of the generated high-frequency oscillator signal is linearly dependent on the detector’s responsivity at that frequency and the optical input power injected into the detector. Thus, for generating high-power oscillator signals in the THz frequency range, the photodetector is required to exhibit a reasonably high responsivity at THz frequencies and, secondly, it should allow for a high optical input power. In other words, the detector should exhibit a large saturation photocurrent. In the next section we will compare the various types of photodetectors in terms of their highfrequency and high-saturation photocurrent performances. This general comparison will be followed by a more detailed discussion on the high-frequency performance of so-called travelling-wave photodetectors (TWPDs). It will be shown that TWPDs offer great potential for high-power THz generation, that is they can be designed to exhibit a high responsivity at high frequencies and a high-saturation photocurrent.
92
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
4.4 Travelling-wave Photodetectors The high-frequency photodetector is a key component for any photonic oscillator. The most important requirement for this kind of application is a high responsivity at THz frequencies not necessarily a large 3 dB bandwidth. In the following subsection we will review recent achievements in high-frequency photodetectors and we will look at the physical effects limiting the detector’s quantum efficiency, especially at THz frequencies. For a comprehensive review on the bandwidth efficiency product of photodetectors the interested reader is referred to Kato [9]. The physical effects determining the detector’s high-frequency performances are usually represented by time constants describing the dynamics of the photogenerated carriers. Most important are the transit time and the carrier lifetime. Generally speaking, these two time constants represent the average time it takes a carrier to travel between the electrodes and the average time a free carrier exists before it finally recombines. Further, conventional lumped photodetectors are limited by some internal and external RC time constants. At very high frequencies ( > 100 GHz) electrical wave propagation effects must also be considered since the electrical wavelength is getting close to the device dimensions and further on microwave propagation losses become more significant. Looking at the various types of photodetectors, the conventional vertically illuminated photodetectors such as the p n or the p i n photodetector introduce a trade-off between quantum efficiency or responsivity and high-frequency or bandwidth. In conventional photodetectors, light is coupled in through the upper layers of the device and is absorbed as it travels through the structure. This fundamental absorption process generates electron hole pairs travelling under the influence of the applied electric field to the device contacts thus producing a photocurrent. The frequency response of such conventional vertical photodetectors depends on the transit time taken for the photo-induced carriers to reach the contacts. For short transit times the absorbing layer of a conventional pn-PD or pin-PD needs to be thin; this, on the other hand, results in a low efficiency and a large capacitance and thus the RC time constant is extremely large preventing the conventional vertical PD from being used at very high frequencies. An approach to reduce the RC time constant of the conventional PDs is to utilize very narrow and closely spaced contact fingers which is usually done in metal semiconductor metal (MSM) PDs. Obviously, due to the closely spaced contact fingers, the transit time is short and also the device capacitance is small due to the small surface area. The short transit time and the small capacitance together allow wide-bandwidth operation but the quantum efficiency of a vertically illuminated MSM-PD is comparably small for reasonable applications. A promising approach for achieving a high-efficiency is to utilize the uni-travelling carrier (UTC) concept. In the UTC-PD the absorbing layer is p-doped and therefore only electrons travel across the depletion layer, with holes disappearing quickly since they are majority charge carriers. Due to the much higher drift velocity of electrons and due to the fact that electrons can travel at overshoot velocity, the space charge effect is significantly reduced. This principle allows high-saturation currents or higher optical input power. The bandwidth of a UTC-PD is restricted by transit time effects mainly determined by the diffusion time of electrons travelling in the p-doped absorbing layer and of course it is also limited by the RC time constant. Recently, high-bandwidth UTC-PDs have been demonstrated and in terms of the bandwidth efficiency product, UTC-PDs exhibit much better performances than conventional pin-diodes [9].
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
93
To circumventthetransittime limitation onecanalso employ a material with avery shortcarrier lifetime. Besides the RC time constant the transit time determines the detector’s frequency response provided that the carrier lifetime is much shorter than the transit time. For several years, research has been carried out to grow GaAs layers at low temperatures. Due to the low temperature the grown GaAs layers contain numerous impurities which capture the free carriers and thus reduce the carrier lifetime. Recently, low-temperature grown GaAs operating at around 850 nm wavelength have been utilized for high-frequency signal generation in the THz range [10]. Edge-coupled or waveguide photodetectors can overcome some of the limitations discussed above by allowing the optical signal to enter through the edge of the device. Thus the electrical carrier transport is perpendicular to the propagation of light. In principle, this approach allows for a long but narrow absorption layer having both a low transit time and a high efficiency. On the other hand, the detector’s RC time constant becomes significantly large due to the long absorbing layer, leading to the well-known lumped element RC time limitation. All approaches discussed above lead to lumped elements since the detector’s responsivities are determined by the total dimensions of the devices. These lumped element photodetectors, however, can no longer cope with the requirements as the frequencies extend into the THz regime. To overcome the RC time limitation so-called distributed or travelling-wave photodetectors (TWPDs) have been investigated since the early 1990s. In a TWPD the photoabsorption process occurs in a distributed manner along the length of the device such that it contributes to the overall electrical signal in the contact transmission line. Thus, travellingwave pin PD (TWPDs), being two-port devices, are not limited by the RC time constant since electrically the devices are not lumped elements with a concentrated capacitance but an electrical waveguide (typically microstrip or coplanar) with a given characteristic impedance. The bandwidth of a TWPD is therefore mainly determined by its transit time. Since it is not RC time limited the travelling-wave concept can accomplish quite thin absorbing layers leading to short transit times and high bandwidths. A major drawback is that the electrical characteristic impedance of a TWPD needs to be matched to the external circuitry and, secondly, the optical group velocity needs to match with the electrical phase velocity for achieving the highest efficiencies. Although TWPDs exhibit a couple of challenges that need to be solved, they do offer a great advantage for high-power THz signal generation, namely the prospect of independently optimizing its quantum efficiency and saturation photocurrent. For this reason various TWPD structures have been investigated by different research groups in the past. These include p i n [11, 12], MSM [13], Schottky [14] and photo-transistor configurations [15], all showing excellent performance at high frequencies. In the following subsection we will discuss the various physical effects determining the high-frequency performance of a p i n TWPD in more detail using a theoretical model that describes the vertical and longitudinal transport of the photogenerated electrical carriers in a TWPD.
4.4.1 Drift-diffusion Model for p–i–n Photodetectors A sketch of a high-speed travelling-wave photodetector (TWPD) employing a pin waveguide structure is shown in Figure 4.6. The detector consists of an optical waveguide and an electrical transmission line. The optical heterodyne signal launched into the optical strip loaded waveguide is gradually absorbed resulting in a distributed current generation along the detector’s length which contributes to the overall current propagating along the electrical transmission line of the TWPD.
94
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 4.6 The left hand figure schematically shows a waveguide photodetector with a coplanar metallization. On the right, a typical cross section of a detector’s layer structure is shown. It consists of an intrinsic core region with an absorbing (Wg < hf ) and two adjacent non absorbing (Wg > hf ) waveguiding layers
As can be seen from Figure 4.6, the p i n waveguide structure of the detector consists of an intrinsic region sandwiched between p- and n-doped semiconductor layers. In order to enable optical waveguiding, the intrinsic core region needs to have a larger refractive index, that is a smaller bandgap energy, compared with the p- and n-doped cladding layers. Further on, the intrinsic region often consists of multiple layers instead of a single absorption layer. This is mainly to reduce the modal absorption per unit length in order to allow for a long absorption length. In our model we thus assume a waveguide core consisting of an intrinsic photon absorbing layer with a thickness d0, and two adjacent nonabsorbing layers with thicknesses dip and din as illustrated in Figure 4.6. In general, the photogenerated carrier transport in the p i n waveguide structure can be described by the continuity equation. By neglecting the transversal carrier transport and assuming harmonic time dependence, the one-dimensional (1D) complex continuity equations for the electron and hole densities n(x) and p(x) are given by jv nðxÞ ¼ Dn
d2 d nðxÞ ½nðxÞ vn ðxÞ Rc þ Gc ; 2 dx dx
ð4:10Þ
jv pðxÞ ¼ Dp
d2 d pðxÞ pðxÞ vp ðxÞ Rc þ Gc : 2 dx dx
ð4:11Þ
The first term in the continuity equations describes the carrier diffusion with the electron and hole diffusion constants represented by Dn and Dp. These diffusion constants are functions of carrier mobility and electric field and it has been shown in [10] that the carrier diffusion constants become very small in value for high electric fields in excess of 20 kV/cm. Assuming
95
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
that the intrinsic layer(s) thickness of a high-frequency p i n detector is well below 500 nm and also that a reverse voltage of a few volts is applied, high electric fields well above 20 kV/cm occur. Thus, we can neglect carrier diffusion in the intrinsic region of the reverse biased photodetector. The carrier recombination rate represented by Rc can also be neglected for our purposes, since the carrier lifetime is in the order of a few nanoseconds [11] which is about three orders of magnitude larger than the average transit time of the investigated structure. Thus the continuity equations (4.10) and (4.11) can be simplified to jv nðxÞ ¼
1 d ðJn Þ þ Gn ; q dx
jv pðxÞ ¼
1 d ðJp Þ þ Gp : q dx
ð4:12Þ ð4:13Þ
The first term in Equations (4.12) and (4.13) describes the carrier drift in the presence of an electric field with vn(x) and vp(x) representing the electron and hole velocity, respectively. The carrier generation rate is a function of the optical intensity at any point along the detector. We can therefore infer that the generation rates of holes and electrons are equal and can be expressed as G ¼ Gn ¼ Gp ¼ G0 expð g opt zÞ
ð4:14Þ
with G0 ¼
hl aopt Iopt : hc
ð4:15Þ
Here h denotes the external quantum efficiency, g opt is the complex propagation constant of the optical heterodyne input signal and Iopt represents the optical intensity. It should be noted that the carrier generation rate is a function of the longitudinal coordinate z due to the optical wave propagation determined by the complex heterodyne optical propagation constant g opt. Since diffusion can be neglected as discussed above, the electron and hole current densities in the absorbing layer are given by Jn ðxÞ ¼ q vn ðxÞ nðxÞ;
ð4:16Þ
Jp ðxÞ ¼ q vp ðxÞ pðxÞ:
ð4:17Þ
Here we assume that electrons and holes in the intrinsic region travel at constant saturation velocities vn and vp, an assumption which is appropriate for reverse biased photodetectors with strong internal electric fields. Introducing Equations (4.14) (4.17) into Equations (4.12) and (4.13) we derive two first-order differential equations with constant coefficients describing the carrier densities in the absorbing layer: dJn jv ¼ Jn q G; dx vn
ð4:18Þ
96
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
dJp jv ¼ þ Jp þ q Gp : dx vp
ð4:19Þ
To solve the above differential equations we make use of the fact that electrons only travel in the positive x-direction and thus the electron carrier density at x ¼ 0 needs to be equal to zero. Similarly, we can state that the hole current density is equal to zero at x ¼ d0: Jn ðx ¼ 0Þ ¼ 0:
ð4:20Þ
Jp ðx ¼ d0 Þ ¼ 0
ð4:21Þ
By using the two boundary values in Equations (4.20) and (4.21) we can solve the differential Equations (4.18) and (4.19) and derive the electron and hole current densities in the absorbing layer Jn ¼
q G vn e jv
q G vp e Jp ¼ jv
jv vxn
jv
1
d0 x vp
ð4:22Þ
1
ð4:23Þ
In a similar way, we can now proceed to find the current densities in the adjacent nonabsorbing intrinsic layers. For simplicity, we only consider the hole current density in the following derivation; the procedure for deriving the electron current density is similar. Due to the fact that there is no photon absorption in these two layers the continuity equation for holes Equation (4.11) becomes quite simple. jv p ¼
1 d ðJp Þ: q dx
ð4:24Þ
This leads to the following simple differential equation for the carrier density d jv ðJp Þ ¼ Jp : dx vp
ð4:25Þ
The required boundary values to solve Equation (4.25) are given by the consistency of the current density at the boundary. From Equation (4.23) it follows that q G vp Jp ðx ¼ 0Þ ¼ e jv
d
jv vp0
1
ð4:26Þ
and by using Equation (4.26) we derive the hole current density in the nonabsorbing intrinsic layer Jp ¼
q G vn h e jv
d
jv vn0
i 1 e
jv
x
d0 vn
:
ð4:27Þ
97
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
i0 ðzÞ ¼ 2
q G0 expð g opt zÞ w din þ dip þ d0 jv
vn vn d0 6 vn jv d0 jv exp jv v n 6 6 6 vp vp d0 6 6 þ vp d0 exp jv 6 jv jv vp 6 6 6 6 þ v exp jv d0 1 vn vn exp jv n 6 vn jv jv 6 6 6 4 vp vp d0 þ vp exp jv exp jv 1 vp jv jv
3 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 din 7 7 vn 7 7 7 5 dip vp
ð4:28Þ
The total current density is given by superimposing the electron and hole current densities in the absorbing region (Equations (4.22) and (4.23)) and the electron and hole current densities of the nonabsorbing regions (see Equation (4.27)). If we further proceed by integrating the total current density along y, we gain the total photogenerated current per unit length generated at any point z along the detector. This equation not only comprises the carrier transport and generation within the intrinsic absorptive layer of the photodetector but also the carrier transport through the adjacent non-absorptive intrinsic regions of the waveguide core.
4.4.2 Transmission Line Model for Travelling-wave Photodetectors In this section we will develop a transmission line model describing the contribution of the distributed current source found above to the overall electrical wave propagating along the electrical transmission line of the travelling-wave photodetector. The type of transmission line formed in this TWPD is a slow-wave hybrid coplanar/microstrip waveguide [16]. Generally, such transmission lines require ‘full-wave’ analysis for rigorous modelling. However, for our purposes the quasi-TEM analysis using a quasistatic equivalent circuit model as shown in Figure 4.7 satisfactorily describes the high-frequency properties of the detector’s transmission line. Here, the photogenerated current per unit length is represented by the distributed current source i0 (z). R0 and L0 are the resistance and the inductance of the metal centre conductor per unit length, respectively. R0 S represents the semiconductor losses associated with transverse current flow in the doped cladding layers and C 0 i and G0 i are the capacitance and the conductance of the intrinsic core layer per unit length. For high frequencies in the THz regime we also need to consider the capacitance of the doped semiconductor layers C0 S and the outer air capacitance C0 0 . For further considerations employing a transmission line model, it is advantageous to separate the active current source from the passive impedances. This is achieved by transforming the distributed current source i0 (z) into a form which is in parallel to all other passive impedances of the equivalent circuit as shown in Figure 4.8. The former current source is transferred to a distributed current source i0 0 which is in parallel with a completely passive electrical transmission line of unit length represented by its characteristic impedance Z0 and
98
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications ZS l Rl ZH
Ll R Sl
C Sl
G il
C il
C 0l
l
i l (z )
YV l
Z il
Figure 4.7 Equivalent circuit representing a unit section of a travelling wave photodetector
propagation constant g el. For the transformed distributed current source i0 0 ðzÞ we obtain i0 0 ðzÞ ¼ i0 ðzÞ
Z 0 i ðvÞ : Z 0 i ðvÞ þ Z 0 S ðvÞ
ð4:29Þ
The impedances shown in Figure 4.8 are not affected by this transformation and thus remain unchanged. Therefore we can state that the characteristic impedance and the electrical wave propagation constant are given by r Z0H ; ð4:30Þ Z0 ¼ Y 0V g el ¼
p
Z0H Y 0V :
ð4:31Þ
Now, we can proceed and define a transmission line model for the travelling-wave photodetector which is shown in Figure 4.9. Here Ze represents the electrical impedance at the input port of the detector’s transmission line and Za is the load impedance at the output port. In order to calculate the total power delivered by the TWPD to the load impedance Za, we use a superposition approach. First, we determine the photocurrent delivered by each current source independently (the other sources are considered as open) and then we calculate the total
Z0,γel
i´0(z)
dz Figure 4.8 Equivalent circuit representing a unit section of a TWPD with a transformed current source in parallel with a passive transmission line
99
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
Z0, γ
..
Z0, γ
Z 0, γ
Z 0, γ
..
IZ a
i´0(0)
Ze
i´0(Z)
.. dz Figure 4.9
i´0(L)
Za
.. dz
dz
dz
Transmission line model for a TWPD with input impedance Ze and load impedance Za
photocurrent by integrating the contributions of all current sources. The photocurrent, delivered to the load impedance Za by the current source i0 0 ðzÞ located at z ¼ zs, can be calculated using the equivalent circuit shown in Figure 4.10 where all other current sources are considered as open. The electrical input reflection coefficient re and the output reflection coefficient ra are respectively: re ¼
ZE Z0 ; ZE þ Z0
ð4:32Þ
ra ¼
Za Z0 : Za þ Z0
ð4:33Þ
Using these two reflection coefficients, we can further simplify the equivalent circuit as shown in Figure 4.11, by transforming the input and the output impedances to the location of the photocurrent source at z ¼ zs. The resulting transformed impedances are then given by ZeT ¼ Z0
1 þ re e 1 re e
2g zS 2g zS
;
ð4:34Þ
Figure 4.10 Equivalent circuit for the TWPD considering only the current source per unit length at the position z ¼ zs
100
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
i´h(zs)
i´
0(zs)
T
ZaT
Ze
Figure 4.11 Equivalent circuit for the TWPD considering only the current source per unit length at the position z ¼ zs. Both the input and output impedances are transformed along the detector’s transmission line to the location of the current source
ZaT ¼ Z0
1 þ ra e 1 ra e
2g ðL-zS Þ 2g ðL-zS Þ
;
ð4:35Þ
and by using these equations, we can determine the forward propagating photocurrent generated by the current source at z ¼ zs at the position of the load impedance ZS. This photocurrent contribution is called i0 ha and is given by i0 ha ðzS Þ ¼
i0 0 ðzS Þ ð1 þ re e ð1 þ re e 2g zS Þ ð1 ra e
2g zS 2g ðL
Þ ð1 ra e 2g ðL zS Þ Þ e g ðL zS Þ zS Þ Þ þ ð1 r e 2g zS Þ ð1 þ r e 2g ðL e a
zS Þ Þ
:
ð4:36Þ Now, we can determine the total photocurrent travelling to the load impedance by integrating all contributions along the detector’s length ðL iha ðz ¼ LÞ ¼
i0 ha ðzS Þ dzS ;
ð4:37Þ
z¼0
and by considering the output reflection coefficient at the end of the detector’s transmission line we can finally determine the total photocurrent at the load impedance and thus the total electrical power delivered to the load impedance. In order to numerically calculate the generated power the circuit parameters of the TWPD equivalent circuit must be determined first. Generally, these parameters are frequency dependent but for frequencies in excess of 20 GHz the parameters L0 , R0 S , C0 i and G0 i are considered to be constant. Only R0 increases with the square root of frequency due to the skin effect. As a good approximation C 0 i can be determined by C 0 i ¼ «0«rw/di. The constant conductor resistance per unit length at frequencies below 10 GHz is given by R0 ¼ rAu/(wdmet). For frequencies in excess of 10 GHz R0 is considered to increase with the square root of the frequency. The series resistance of the doped semiconductor layers for a 6 mm wide rib waveguide with 15 mm separation between the centre and the ground electrode is typically of the order of R0 S 0.25 W mm. The parallel conductance G0 i and the transversal inductance L0 can be determined from experimental S-parameter measurements. With all the equivalent circuit parameters known, the complex characteristic impedance Z0 and the complex electrical propagation constant g el of the TWPD transmission line can be calculated.
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
101
Figure 4.12 Simulated frequency response of a 50 mm long and 6 mm wide TWPD. Dots indicate measured output power levels of the same device up to 110 GHz
Of course, in the above models we assumed some boundary conditions simplifying the real physical effects inside the detector, leaving enough space for future optimizations or extensions of the presented approach. Nevertheless, by using the frequency domain model developed here we can study the most relevant intrinsic effects such as transit time limitations as well as propagation effects such as microwave losses and the mismatch between the optical group velocity and the electrical phase velocity. Furthermore, external effects such as the influence of an impedance mismatch between the detector’s transmission line and the load impedance can be investigated in detail and the contribution of the different effects on the total roll-off at high frequencies can be identified. Therefore, although some simplifications were made, the model yields a very good simulation as can be seen from Figure 4.12. There is good agreement between measured and simulated data with a maximum variation of about a few dB. This proves the accuracy and reliability of the analytical model. The total rolloff of 50 dB for the full frequency span from DC to 1 THz is due to the transit time effects and intrinsic effects arising from carrier transport in the doped sections of the TWPD. In addition, propagation effects such as microwave losses and velocity mismatch contribute to the total rolloff. At frequencies in excess of 0.1 THz we found that the delivered power decreases with frequency by about f- 3 for the investigated devices.
4.5 Terahertz Photonic Oscillators The first promising photonic oscillators for continuous-wave THz generation were demonstrated in the mid-1990s, using LT-GaAs photodetectors [17]. State-of-the-art LT-GaAs photodetectors utilize a vertically illuminated MSM-PD on LT-GaAs either coupled to a log-spiral antenna for wideband or coupled to a resonant dipole antenna for narrowband operation. Even LT-GaAs based MSM-TWPDs have been developed and successfully employed for quasi continuous-wave narrowband THz generation [18]. A major disadvantage associated with LT-GaAs is the thermal failure due to the high thermal resistance of the LT-GaAs which limits the maximum current density. Furthermore, the optimum optical wavelength for LT-GaAs
102
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
photodetetors is around 800 nm and thus advanced lasers and amplifiers developed for the communication industry operating in the optical C-band cannot be employed. The employment of photonic oscillators for continuous-wave THz signal generation using 1.55 mm lasers is a relatively new approach and there have only been a few experimental results. In the following, we will summarize the achieved results and we will explicitly describe the constitution of compact photonic THz oscillators employing 1.55 mm photodetectors. The presented photonic oscillators either yield free-space coupling by using resonant slot-antenna structures for narrowband or bow-tie antenna for wideband operation. Guided wave coupling of the generated oscillator signal using WR10 and smaller rectangular waveguides has also been achieved. In the photonic oscillators presented in the following paragraphs, a dual-mode optical heterodyne input signal was used that was generated by two free-running and tuneable 1.55 mm DFB lasers. A subsequent erbium-doped amplifier (EDFA) was used for boosting the optical power level. This concept allows one to easily sweep the frequency of the generated signal from DC to THz frequencies, which is especially important for investigating wideband performances of the POs. For detecting the generated high-frequency oscillator signals in the millimetre-wave region up to 220 GHz, external single-diode harmonic mixers have been used. At higher frequencies in the THz regime a number of detectors exist, including liquid helium cooled bolometers with a typical noise equivalent power (NEP) of about 2 pW/Hz 1/2 or Golay cells with a typical NEP of 100 200 pW/Hz 1/2. Although the Golay cell does not provide such a good NEP it does not require any expenditure for liquid helium cooling since it operates at room temperature. Therefore it is well suited for the experimental characterization of high-power POs. A typical experimental set-up consisting of the photonic THz oscillator and a Golay cell as THz detector is shown schematically in Figure 4.13.
4.5.1 Wideband Photonic Oscillators Employing Waveguide coupled THz Transmitter For specific applications, guided transmission in a rectangular waveguide is more desirable than free-space radiation of the generated THz signals and, consequently, efficient optical heterodyne generation of guided THz waves has already been studied and demonstrated in [19 22], [25] and [27] up to about 600 GHz using WR10 waveguide integrated high-speed photodetectors. Polarization control tuneable LD λ0+ ∆λ EDFA DFB LD 1560 nm λ0
Golay cell
Photonic transmitter fRF
c0 ∆λ λ 20
Figure 4.13 Photonic THz oscillator consisting of two tuneable 1.55 mm DFB lasers, an EDFA and a photonic transmitter employing a TWPD. The generated THz oscillator signal is detected using a Golay cell
103
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
Generated (sub)mm-wave power (dBm)
0
TW-PD/WR10 -10 -20 di=100nm -30 -40
di=350nm
~f -4
-50 -60 -70 10
100 Frequency (GHz)
1000
Figure 4.14 Ultra wideband power generation employing rectangular waveguide (WR10) coupled TWPDs with different intrinsic region thicknesses of 100 and 350 nm
The following experiment, performed at the Universit€at Duisburg-Essen, Germany, demonstrates ultra-wideband guided transmission up to 1 THz employing a high-speed 1.55 mm TWPD coupled to different rectangular waveguides (WR10, WR8 and WR5) [23]. For experimental characterization the fabricated TWPDs have been connected using commercial coplanar to waveguide transitions. The power levels of the generated oscillator signals have been measured using a Golay cell as described in Figure 4.13 by quasi-optical coupling the THz power from the waveguide into the Golay cell. The measured THz power level is shown in Figure 4.14 for an ultra-wide frequency range up to about 1 THz. It should be pointed out that the lower cut-off frequency at around 70 GHz is given by the lower cut-off frequency of the WR10 waveguide not by the TWPD employed in the PO which can operate even at DC. As can be seen in Figure 4.14, the maximum power level of about 100 mW is achieved at frequencies around 0.1 THz within the W-band. Here, the TWPD with an intrinsic region thickness of d0 ¼ 100 nm generates about 5 dB more power than the TWPD with the 350 nm thick intrinsic region which is due to the lower transit time penalty. It can further be observed, from Figure 4.14, that the power decreases with frequency to the power of four. Similar results were found by Huggard et al. in [20]. In their work, they fully-packaged a commercial waveguide PD chip into a compact transmitter module with a WR10 waveguide output (Figure 4.15). The measured frequency response as shown in Figure 4.16 reveals a similar frequency dependence of the generated power level as shown in Figure 4.13 with a lower cut-off at 70 GHz due to the WR10 waveguide. The maximum power level is about 100 mW. To investigate the power dependence on frequency further, the smaller waveguides (WR8 and WR5) were used since those waveguides exhibit significantly fewer modes that can propagate at frequencies above 100 GHz. Figure 4.17 shows the generated power level using the same TWPD coupled to a WR8 and a WR5 waveguide. In addition, the cut-off frequencies
104
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Detected power (W)
Figure 4.15 Fully packaged transmitter module developed by P. Huggard et al. at the Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, UK, in cooperation with the University of Kent and NRAO, USA. Reproduced from [20] by permission of Peter Huggard ( 2002 IEEE)
10
3
10
4
30 mW Optical power estimate
10 5
10 6
10
7
10 mW Optical power
10
8
100
Frequency (GHz)
1000
Figure 4.16 Ultra wideband power generation employing a WR10 coupled waveguide photodetector. The experiment has been carried out by P. Huggard at the Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, UK, in cooperation with the University of Kent and NRAO, USA. Reproduced from [20] by permission of Peter Huggard ( 2002 IEEE)
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
105
Figure 4.17 Ultra wideband (sub)mm wave power generation employing a WR8 and a WR5 rectangular waveguide coupled TWPD
of the higher-order modes that can propagate in the two waveguides are indicated by arrows in Figure 4.17. A step-like response is observed with an almost flat response around the cut-off frequencies of the higher-order modes. At lower frequencies the TWPD generates higher power levels when coupled to a WR8 waveguide but at frequencies above 220 GHz the power level is about four times larger when the TWPD is coupled to a WR5 waveguide.
4.5.2 Wideband Photonic Oscillators Employing Broadband Antennacoupled THz Transmitter Although resonant type antennas exhibit a reasonably large bandwidth (e.g. to cover a single astronomical band [12] in the ALMA telescope) it is also of great interest to develop an ultrawideband photonic transmitter that could eventually be employed not just for a single band but for a number of astronomical bands or for spectroscopic THz imaging applications. For developing an ultra-wideband photonic oscillator the high-speed TWPD in the transmitter part of the PO needs to be integrated with a wideband antenna structure which exhibits a fairly constant impedance within a large frequency range that can be matched to the detector’s impedance. As an example, TWPDs have been integrated with bow-tie antenna structures as shown in Figure 4.18 [26]. The inset shows a photograph of a fabricated chip. The length and width of the TWPD and the opening angle of the bow-tie antenna are 116 mm, 3.2 mm and u ¼ 9.4 , respectively. The chip was also mounted on a hemispherical silica lens for improving free-space coupling efficiency and in order to focus the generated THz oscillator signal. The packaged modules were investigated using the experimental set-up shown in Figure 4.13. Here the generated power was quasi-optically radiated into the Golay cell without using any imaging optics. Figure 4.19 shows the measured THz power received by the Golay cell. Coupling losses associated with the quasi-optical radiation into the Golay cell have not been excluded from the measured results. As can be seen from Figure 4.19, the maximum power received by the Golay cell is about 0.5 mW for a photocurrent of about 6 mA. The generated power level is fairly flat within a frequency range from 20 GHz to 0.1 THz. Above 0.1 THz we observed that the power
106
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 4.18 Schematic of a TWPD monolithically integrated with a planar ultra wideband bow tie antenna. The inset shows an SEM picture of a fabricated transmitter chip
level approximately decreases with frequency to a power of three which is in accordance with the simulations. Similar frequency dependence of a wideband antenna integrated photodetector was also found in [24].
4.5.3 Narrowband Photonic Oscillators Employing a Slot Antenna Coupled THz Transmitter To investigate the performances of a narrowband photonic oscillator and to demonstrate their feasibility to pump the SIS junction of an astronomical receiver, a photonic 0.46 THz
Figure 4.19 TWPD
Ultra wideband (sub)mm wave power generation employing a bow tie antenna integrated
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
107
transmitter has been fabricated. A sketch of the developed transmitter chip is shown in Figure 4.20(a). In the transmitter, the TWPD was monolithically integrated with a planar fullwave slot antenna resonant at 460 GHz. A passive bias-T was also integrated on-chip employing radial stubs as low-pass filters to allow for external DC-bias supply to the PD. The SEM pictures in Figure 4.20(b) and Figure 4.20(c) show a top view of a transmitter chip array and a single transmitter chip, respectively. The inset in Figure 4.20(c) shows an enlarged view of the waveguide PD (top) and the radial stub low-pass filter (bottom). The covered single slot antenna, which cannot be seen in Figure 4.20, is located at the intersection between the waveguide PD and the radial-stub filter and it is horizontally oriented to the optical waveguide of the PD. The overall dimensions of a single transmitter chip are about 2.3 1.7 mm, and about 300 transmitters have been fabricated from a single 2 inch InP substrate. The transmitter chip was further mounted on a hemispherical silica lens with a diameter of 10 mm as sketched in Figure 4.20(d). The silica lens couples the antenna to free space, producing a near Gaussian submm-wave beam, which can be re-imaged on any receiver optics (lens and horn). Finally, the lens with the transmitter chip was packaged as can be seen from Figures 4.20(e) and 4.20(f). To demonstrate the capabilities of the packaged THz transmitter module to pump an astronomical receiver with an SIS junction an experiment has been undertaken using the
Figure 4.20 (a) Schematic of a photonic emitter consisting of a slot antenna integrated TWPD; (b) photograph of a fabricated array of 0.46 THz transmitter; (c) SEM picture of a single emitter; (d) schematic of an emitter mounted in the centre of a silicon ball lens; (e) and (f) photographs of the fabricated modules
108
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 4.21 DC current voltage curves derived from the SIS junction of a 460 GHz astronomical receiver (photo) which was either pumped by a Gunn oscillator (black line) or by using the developed photonic 0.46 THz oscillator at different photocurrent levels (grey curves)
astronomical receiver as a mixer for down-converting the 0.46 THz signal generated by the photonic oscillator. In the experiment, all receiver components are operated at liquid helium temperature. At first, a 460 GHz solid-state oscillator chain consisting of a Gunn oscillator with a subsequent tripler was used to pump the SIS junction of the receiver. The output power of the solid-state oscillator was adjusted for optimum sensitivity (i.e. lowest noise temperature) of the SIS junction and the corresponding DC bias curve of the SIS junction was recorded (dark line in Figure 4.21). Hereafter, the solid-state oscillator signal was replaced by the optically generated LO signal from the photonic oscillator module. Different DC bias curves of the SIS junction
Figure 4.22 THz power received by the SIS junction of a receiver with respect to the detector’s photocurrent
109
Photonic Oscillators for THz Signal Generation
Generated mm-wave power (dB)
0
fc = 100GHz
-5
Uncooled Cooled T = 14°C
-10 -15 -20 -25 -30 -35 1
10
100
Photocurrent (mA)
Figure 4.23
Generated output power as a function of DC photocurrent
were recorded as a function of laser input power level, that is as a function of the detector’s photocurrent (grey lines in Figure 4.21). The inset in Figure 4.21 shows a photo of the employed liquid helium cooled receiver which was used. As can be seen from Figure 4.21, at a photocurrent of about 20 mA the power generated by the PO is equivalent to the power generated by the solid-state LO. Thus, the developed photonic transmitter is capable of pumping the SIS junction of the receiver under optimum conditions. The total THz power generated by the photonic oscillator module is shown in Figure 4.22 as a function of the photocurrent in the TWPD. The total power generated by the TWPD follows the square-law principle, as can be seen from Figure 4.23. No saturation effects are observed for photocurrents up to 20 mA.
References [1] B. Leone et al., “Optical Far IR wave Generation An ESA review study”, Proceedings of the 14th International Symposium on Space Terahertz Technology, Tucson, USA, April 2003. [2] See for example “The Atacama Large Millimeter Array”, The ESO Messenger, no. 107, March 2002. [3] P.H. Siegel, “Terahertz Technolgy”, IEEE Trans. On Microwave Theory and Techn., vol. 50, no. 3, March 2002. [4] A. Hirata, M. Harada and T. Nagatsuma, “120 GHz Wireless Link Using Photonic Techniques for Generation, Modulation, and Emission of Millimeter Wave Signals”, IEEE J. of Lightwave Technol., vol. 21, no. 10, October 2002. [5] T. Yamamoto, H. Takara and S. Kawanishi, “Generation and Transmission of Tuneable Terahertz Optical Clock”, International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, Awaji Island, Japan, T2 2, pp. 97 100, Nov. 2002. [6] P. Shen and P.A. Davies, “Millimetre Wave Generation Using an Optical Comb Generator with Optical Pase Locked Loops”, International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, Awaji Island, Japan, T2 3, Nov. 2002. [7] See for example L.A. Johansson and A.J. Seeds, “Millimeter Wave Modulated Optical Signal Generation with High Spectral Purity and Wide Locking Bandwidth Using a Fiber Integrated Optical Injection Phase Lock Loop”, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 12, no. 6, June 2000. [8] M. Ishiguro et al., “A hybrid Option for the First LOs using Direct Photonic LO Driver”, ALMA memo 435, September 2002. [9] K. Kato, “Ultrawide Band/High Frequency Photodetectors”, IEEE Trans. On Microwave Theory and Techni ques, vol. 47, no. 7, July 1999.
110
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
[10] See for example E.R. Brown, “THz Generation by Photomixing in Ultrafast Photoconductors”, Int. J. of High Speed Electronics and Systems, vol. 13, no. 2, 2003. [11] A. Stohr, R. Heinzelmann, A. Malcoci and D. Jager, “Optical Heterodyne Millimeter.Wave Generation Using 1.55 mm Travelling Wave Photodetectors“, IEEE Trans. on Microwave Theory and Techn., vol. 49, no. 10, October 2001. [12] V. Hietala, G.A. Vawter, T.M. Brennan and B.E. Hammons, “Traveling Wave Photodetectors for High Power, Large Bandwidth Applications”, IEEE Trans. on Microwave Theory and Techn., vol. 43, no. 9, September 1995. [13] J. W. Shi, Y. H. Chen, K. G. Gan, Y. J. Chiu, C. K. Sun and J.E. Bowers, “High Speed and High Power Performances of LT GaAs Based Metal Semiconductor Metal Traveling Wave Photodetectors in 1.3 mm Wavelength Regime”, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 14, no. 3, March 2002. [14] M. Alles, U. Auer, F. J. Teude and D. Jager, “Distributed velocity matched 1.55 mm InP traveling wave photodetector for generation of high millimeterwave signal power,” IEEE Int. Microwave Symposium, MTT S Digest, Baltimore, USA, pp. 1233 1236, 1998. [15] D.C. Scott, D.P. Prakash, H. Erlig, M.A. Bhattacharya and H.R. Fetterman, “High Power, High Frequency Traveling Wave Heterojunction Phototransistors with Integrtaed Polyimide Waveguide”, IEEE Int. Microwave Symposium, MTT S Digest, Baltimore, USA, pp. 1237 1240, 1998. [16] D. Jager, “Slow Wave Propagation Along Variable Schottky Contact Microstrip Line,” IEEE Trans. on Microwave Theory and Techn., vol. 24, no. 9, September 1976. [17] E.R. Brown, K.A. McIntosh, K.B. Nichols and C.L. Dennis, “Photomixing up to 3.8THz in Low Temperature Grown GaAs”, Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 66 (3), pp. 285 287, 1995. [18] S. Matsuura and G.A. Blake, “A travelling wave THz Photomixer based on Angle Tuned Phase Matching”, J. Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 74, no. 19, pp. 2872 2874, May 1999. [19] A. Stohr, R. Heinzelmann, C. Kaczmarek and D. Jager, “Ultra Broadband Ka to W band 1.55 mm Travelling Wave Photomixer,” Electron. Lett., vol. 36, no. 11, 970 972, May 2000. [20] P.G. Huggard, B.N. Ellision, P. Shen, N.J. Gomes, P.A. Davies, W.P. Shillue, A. Vaccari and J.M. Payne, “Efficient Generation of Guided Millimeter Wave Power by Photomixing,” IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 14, no. 2, 197 199, February 2002. [21] P.G. Huggard, B.N. Ellision, P. Shen, N.J. Gomes, P.A. Davies, W.P. Shillue, A. Vaccari and J.M. Payne, “Generation of Millimetre and Sub millimetre Waves by Photomixing in a 1.55 mm Wavelength Photodiode”, Electon. Lett., vol. 38, no. 7, 327 328, 2002. [22] T. Noguchi, A. Ueda, H. Iwashita, S. Takano, Y. Sekimoto, M. Ishiguro, T. Ishibashi, H. Ito and T. Nagatsuma, “Millimeter Wave Generation using a Uni traveling carrier Photodiode”, Proceedings of the 12th International Symposium on Space Terahertz Technology, San Diego, CA, USA, 2001. [23] A. Stohr, A. Malcoci, A. Sauerwald, I.C. Mayorga, R. Gusten and D. Jager, “Ultra Wide Band Traveling Wave Photodetectors for Photonic Local Oscillators”, IEEE J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 21, no. 12, December 2003. [24] A. Hirata, T. Nagatsuma, R. Yano, H. Ito, T. Furuta, Y. Hirota, T. Ishibashi, H. Matsuo, A. Ueda, T. Noguchi, Y. Sekimoto, M. Ishiguro and S. Matsuura, “Output Power Measurement of Photonic Millimetre wave and Sub millimetre wave Emitter at 100 800GHz”, Electron. Lett., vol. 38, no. 15, 798 799, July 2002. [25] A. Stohr and D. Jager, “Ultra Wideband Travelling Wave Photodetectors for THz Signal Generation”, IEEE LEOS Annual Meeting, Puerto Rico, Nov. 2004. [26] A. Malcoci, A. Stohr, A. Sauerwald, S. Schulz and D. Jager, “Waveguide and Antenna Coupled Travelling Wave 1.55 mm Photodetectors for Optical (Sub)Millimeter Wave Generation”, in Microwave and Terahertz Photonics, Proceedings of the SPIE, vol. 5466, ISBN 0 8194 5389 7, pp. 202 209, 2004. [27] A. Stohr and D. Jager, “THz Photomixers: An Overview”, in Millimeter wave and Terahertz Photonics, Proceedings of the SPIE, vol. 6194, ISBN 0 8194 6250 0, April 2006.
5 Terahertz Sources R. E. Miles and M. Naftaly
5.1 Introduction The terahertz (THz) region of the electromagnetic spectrum is commonly defined as that lying at frequencies between 0.1 and10 THz. The frequently-heard expression ‘the THz gap’ refers to the fact that at these frequencies generation and detection of radiation becomes very difficult using either electronic or optical means. Nevertheless, with the growth of interest in THz research and applications and a great expansion of activities in this area, a large number and variety of sources have been developed and have become widely available. These include THz lasers, laser-activated emitters and electronic devices. Broadly speaking, in applications requiring a continuous-wave narrow-line signal at frequencies below 1 THz, electronic sources predominate. Examples include local oscillators for astronomical instruments and security scanners. On the other hand, lasers and laser-activated emitters are mainly used for broadband THz spectroscopy covering a bandwidth of several THz. This division of functions is likely to persist since electronic THz sources are, by their nature, singlefrequency devices, whereas laser-based sources are either inherently broadband or widely tuneable. Nevertheless, both types of THz emitting devices have found numerous applications, and will be described here.
5.2 Terahertz Generation from Laser Sources The recent rapid expansion of the field of terahertz research and applications owes much of its existence to the development of suitable laser sources and methods of THz generation. These developments fall into two categories: direct emission from far-infrared lasers and optical down-conversion of near-infrared lasers. Owing to the flexibility of the systems and the broad tuning range, down-conversion greatly predominates as the technique of choice, and accounts for the vast majority of work in the THz field.
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Edited by Stavros Iezekiel © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 978-0-470-84854-8
112
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
5.2.1 Far-Infrared Lasers These include molecular lasers, p-Ge lasers, and free-electron lasers (FELs). 5.2.1.1 Molecular Lasers Molecular lasers [1] use as their active media gases which have a permanent dipole moment. THz (far-infrared) emitting transitions take place between adjacent rotational levels of the same vibrational state. Excitation is via optical pumping, typically by a high-power (>10 W) CO2 laser. Depending on the gas used, several different lines can be generated, although the laser is not continuously tuneable. Narrow linewidths of a few GHz are obtainable because the gases are used at low pressures in order to reduce collisional relaxations. A variety of gases are used in molecular lasers, including CH4, CH3OH, CH3NH2 and C2H2F2, producing lines in the range of 40 1200 mm (7.5 0.25 THz). CW laser powers of the order of several mW are generated. The limitation of these sources is that they offer a discrete set of lines with no tuneability, and so are unsuitable for the majority of spectroscopic applications. 5.2.1.2 p-Ge Lasers A p-Ge laser consists of a p-doped Ge crystal cryogenically cooled to 4 K and mounted in a magnet [2]. Such lasers operate in pulsed mode, with a repetition rate of tens of Hz. The average THz power produced is 10 100 mW, with peak powers of several watts. The emission frequency can be tuned by varying the magnetic field: the typical range is 1.5 4.5 THz. The magnetic field required by the laser can be of several Tesla, and therefore necessitates a superconducting magnet. p-Ge lasers are useful for THz spectroscopy, especially where high incident THz power is required, but their applications are limited owing to the size and complexity of the auxiliary systems. 5.2.1.3 Free-electron Lasers Free-electron lasers (FELs) or synchrotron sources [3] are continuously tuneable over a range of tensofTHzandcanproduceseveralwattsofcontinuous-wavenarrow-bandradiation.Althoughan FEL is in many respects an ideal THz source, it is in fact a type of high-energy electron beam accelerator.Itisthereforealarge-scaleinstallation,whichseverelylimitsitspracticalapplicability.
5.2.2 Optical Down-Conversion THz generation by optical down-conversion falls into two types: broadband emission employing ultrafast lasers and single-frequency tuneable emission employing difference-frequencygeneration. Of these, broadband generation is by far the most widely used method, largely owing to the advantages of coherent detection available in a pump-probe configuration (these include high sensitivity and a large dynamic range). 5.2.2.1 Broadband THz By far the most widespread method of THz generation involves employing ultrafast lasers. These are mode-locked lasers whose pulse length is typically less than 200 fs, and more usually
113
Terahertz Sources
Laser intensity
(a)
Time THz amplitude
(b)
Time THz amplitude
(c)
Frequency
Figure 5.1
(a) Laser pulse, (b) THz pulse and (c) THz spectrum
well under 100 fs. The most commonly used are Ti sapphire lasers which typically deliver pulse lengths of 50 100 fs, and can be as short as 10 fs. Ytterbium and erbium solid-state or fibre lasers have longer pulse lengths of 100 300 fs. The repetition rate of all such lasers is of the order of 50 100 MHz; the average power is typically in the range 0.2 2 W. Consequently, the peak optical pulse power is of the order of 108 W. There are two types of broadband THz emitter in common use: optical rectification by electro-optic crystals and biased photoconductive emitters (also known as Auston switches). Both of these produce a single-cycle THz pulse whose amplitude is proportional to the time derivative of the optical intensity of the laser pulse, as seen in Figure 5.1. It follows therefore that a shorter laser pulse will produce a correspondingly shorter THz pulse, with a consequent broader spectral content. 5.2.2.2 Optical Rectification Optical rectification in electro-optic (EO) crystals first emerged in the late 1980s as a means of producing broadband THz radiation from ultrafast laser sources. Typically, zinc-blende semiconductors such as ZnTe, GaP and GaSe, or organic crystals (e.g. 4-(4-Dimethylaminostyryl)1-methylpyridinium tosylate (DAST)) are used for this purpose, all having bandgaps in the 2 2.5 eV range. In order to avoid absorption of the incident radiation, the laser wavelength must be longer than the bandgap of the material, that is Ephoton ¼ hc/l < Eg, making 800 nm Ti-sapphire lasers suitable for this purpose [4]. Optical rectification arises as a result of the transient polarization which occurs when a short, high-intensity laser pulse interacts with the electro-optic medium. The THz power generated is proportional to the square of the optical power, is determined by the second-order optical nonlinear coefficient (x (2)), and varies with the relative orientation of the laser polarization and the crystallographic axes. An important issue is phase matching, which limits the interaction length in the crystal and restricts the usable crystal length. Optical rectification can be viewed as a mixing of different
114
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
spectral components of the laser pulse separated by the THz frequency: vopt and vopt þ vTHz. This also serves to explain why a shorter laser pulse containing a broader spectral bandwidth produces a broader THz spectrum (via Dn/Dt 1). The phase-matching condition for the wave vector k is then [5]: Dk ¼ kðvopt þ vTHz Þ kðvopt Þ kðvTHz Þ ¼ 0
ð5:1Þ
Neglecting optical dispersion, the coherence length lc for phase matching is given by: lc ¼ p=Dk ¼ pðvTHz jnopt nTHz jÞ
ð5:2Þ
where n is the refractive index. For bandwidths of up to 3 THz in commonly used EO crystals lc is of the order of 0.5 mm. However, owing to dispersion, it is reduced to < 50 mm when ultrabroadband generation ( > 3 THz) is required. Typical THz bandwidths obtained from optical rectification in EO crystals are 0.1 3 THz, with a total average THz power of a few mW. However, much broader THz emission has been achieved. In both ZnTe and GaSe bandwidths of up to 40 THz have been demonstrated, as seen in Figure 5.2 [6]. 5.2.2.3 Biased Photoconductive Emitters Broadband THz generation using biased photoconductive emitters activated by ultrafast lasers was first explored in the 1980s, and has since become the most commonly used method in both research and commercial THz systems. An emitter consists of a semiconductor wafer with bias electrodes deposited on its surface (Figure 5.3) [4]. In contrast to optical rectification, a photoconductive emitter must be excited by a laser wavelength that is shorter than the bandgap
Figure 5.2 Temporal waveform (upper figure) and spectrum (lower figure) of THz waves measured by the GaSe (solid line) crystal and the ZnTe (dotted line) crystal, respectively. Reprinted with permission from Kai Liu, Jingzhou Xu and X. C. Zhang, Applied Physics Letters, 85, 863 (2004). 2004, American Institute of Physics
115
Terahertz Sources Small-gap emitter / antenna
Large-gap emitter
Gold electrodes Gold electrodes
GaAs substrate
GaAs substrate
Laser beam
Laser beam Stripline gap: 30-100 µm Line thickness: 10-50 µm Line length: 1-2 mm Electrode gap: 5-20 µm
Figure 5.3
Electrode length/width: 3-10 mm Electrode gap: 0.5-1 mm
Schematic drawings of typical biased photoconductive emitters
of the material, that is Ephoton ¼ hc/l > Eg. When a laser beam is incident on the semiconductor, the absorbed photons generate photocarriers, electrons in the conduction band and holes in the valence band. These are accelerated by the bias field, while simultaneously their density changes under the varying laser intensity. As a result, ultrashort high-peak currents are generated in the semiconductor, which radiate into free-space at THz frequencies. In order for the process to be efficient, the carrier lifetime of the semiconductor material must be short on the timescale of the laser pulse. Most THz emitters employ GaAs, either in its semiinsulating (SI) form or low-temperature grown (LT), owing to its short carrier lifetime and its bandgap of 1.42 eV allowing absorption of the 800 nm radiation from Ti-sapphire lasers. LTGaAs has a shorter photocarrier lifetime (< 0.5 ps) than SI-GaAs (100 ps), which improves its THz-emitting performance. The gap between the electrodes can vary from a few microns to several millimetres. In large-gap emitters ( > 0.1 mm) the shape of the electrodes has little effect on THz generation. However, in small-gap emitters the bias electrodes also act as a radiating antenna, and are designed accordingly. Owing to the additional energy supplied by the bias current, photoconductive emitters produce an average THz power of tens of mW, that is an order of magnitude higher than electrooptic crystals. It may be assumed, especially in the case of large-gap emitters, that the transient photocurrent J(t) is not affected by the electrodes, and is directly proportional to the induced conductivity s(t) and the applied bias field E [7]: JðtÞ sðtÞ E:
ð5:3Þ
This then leads to the conclusion that the average THz power Pave produced by the emitter scales with the square of the optical power Popt and the square of the applied voltage E: Pave P2opt E2 :
ð5:4Þ
116
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
THz amplitude (a u )
1
0.1
0.01
1E-3
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
Frequency (THz)
Figure 5.4
A typical THz spectrum from a large gap biased photoconductive emitter
The THz spectral content delivered by photoconductive emitters is significantly narrower than that obtainable from optical rectification. Figure 5.4 shows a typical THz spectrum generated by an emitter which was fabricated on SI-GaAs with an electrode spacing of 0.5 mm, biased at 200 V and excited by 0.8 W average power from a 60 fs Ti-sapphire laser. The usable THz spectrum extends to nearly 4 THz; however, the power decreases exponentially with frequency as explained in Figure 5.1 above. Small-gap LT-GaAs emitters employing short-pulse lasers of 10 fs are capable of generating much larger THz bandwidths, although at the cost of greatly reduced total power. A usable THz spectrum of up to 20 THz has been demonstrated as shown in Figure 5.5 [8]. Note, however, that the spectrum suffers from substrate absorption at 5.2 and 8.0 THz.
5.2.3 Difference Frequency Generation There are two types of THz source operating by difference frequency generation (DFG) and using near-infrared lasers. Both employ two laser beams which are detuned by the desired
Figure 5.5 The Fourier transform amplitude spectrum (upper trace, solid line) together with the spectrum measured in the presence of PTFE sample (lower trace, dotted line). Reprinted with permission from Y. C. Shen, P. C. Upadhya, E. H. Linfield, H. E. Beere and A. G. Davies, Applied Physics Letters, 83, 3117 (2003). 2003, American Institute of Physics
117
Terahertz Sources
THz frequency, and rely on frequency mixing to generate the desired radiation. In both cases the THz frequency can be tuned continuously by varying the wavelength of one of the lasers. The first type employs biased photoconductive emitters and the second electro-optic crystals. 5.2.3.1 CW THz DFG from Photoconductive Emitters The principle of operation is similar to that of broadband emission; however, in this case two CW lasers are used instead of a single pulsed source. THz frequencies are generated in the biased photoconductor due to the fluctuations in carrier density, which produces a signal via the heterodyne process [9]: ½E1 cosv1 t þ E2 cosv2 t2 ¼ const þ E1 E2 cosðv1 v2 Þt
ð5:5Þ
where E1 and E2 are the respective field amplitudes of the two sources, and v1 and v2 are their respective frequencies. As in the broadband case, the THz power produced scales with the square of the optical power and the applied voltage. However, it also depends crucially on the carrier lifetime of the material and on the efficiency of the antenna. A very short carrier lifetime (< 200 fs) is required for successful THz generation. The typical THz power generated is of the order of 1 mW [10] and the bandwidth is limited to approximately 1.5 THz. Owing to these limitations, such emitters have not found wide application. 5.2.3.2 Pulsed THz DFG from Electro-optic Crystals Recently there has been growing interest in difference-frequency THz generation using electro-optic crystals activated by pulsed lasers. A typical set-up employs a Q-switched Nd-YAG laser pumping an optical parametric oscillator (OPO), which together provide the two laser wavelengths detuned by the desired THz frequency. These are focused onto an EO crystal, where the THz difference frequency is generated via three-wave mixing. As with optical rectification, DFG is a parametric process which arises from transient polarization whose efficiency is dependent on the second-order optical nonlinear coefficient x(2). The emitted THz power at the frequency vTHz from a crystal of length L and using exciting beams of power P1 and P2 is [11]: PTHz v2THz ðcð2Þ Þ2 L2 P1 P2 :
ð5:6Þ
As a consequence of the dependence on vTHz, the efficiency of DFG and the obtained THz power tend to increase with THz frequency. This is the reverse of what happens in broadband generation, where THz power decreases with frequency (Figure 5.1). Since the THz power is proportional to the product of powers of the two mixing beams, pulsed lasers with high peak powers are necessary to activate the process. The laser wavelength must be well below the bandgap of the crystal, to avoid absorption. The phase matching condition for the wave vectors k is similar to that for optical rectification (Equation (5.1)): Dk ¼ kðvopt þ vTHz Þ kðvopt Þ kðvTHz Þ ¼ 0:
ð5:7Þ
118
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 5.6 THz output energy as a function of the THz frequency with 1 and 0.5mm thick DAST crystals: solid line, 1 mm DAST; broken line, 0.5 mm DAST. Reused with permission from T. Taniuchi, S. Okada and H. Nakanishi, Journal of Applied Physics, 95, 5984 (2004), 2004, American Institute of Physics
However, in this case noncollinear phase matching is possible, so that the vector form is retained. Owing to dispersion, the crystal must be rotated as the THz frequency is tuned, in order to preserve the relationship between the three wave vectors. This allows the phase matching condition to be maintained in crystals over a length of several millimetres, thus providing a longer interaction length and increasing the THz power produced. Using DFG, THz peak powers of the order of hundreds of milliwatts have been demonstrated. Other advantages of THz DFG include the availability of THz frequencies above 3 THz, the ability to produce a tuneable narrow-line single frequency (instead of having to generate and analyse a complete broad spectrum) and the simplicity and compactness of the systems. A number of THz DFG systems have been demonstrated. Tuning over 0.5 7 THz has been obtained in a GaP crystal, with peak THz powers of around 100 mW [12]. In an organic DAST crystal continuous tuning between 2 and20 THz has been achieved, with peak powers of > 10 W (Figure 5.6) [13].
5.3 Electronic Sources It is true to say that the progress that has occurred in terahertz technology over the last 15 years has mainly resulted from the development of the Auston switch [14] as discussed in Section 5.2. Previous to this, terahertz waves were generated electronically, but in devices based on vacuum-tube technology. Such devices as the backward wave oscillator (BWO) can deliver THz power in the tens of milliwatt range but they have a relatively short lifetime (in modern electronic terms) and are not always readily available. At the time of writing, modern semiconductor based electronic sources which can oscillate at frequencies in the range of 0.7 THz to 2 THz are still not available, but steady development, as will be discussed below, sees the maximum frequencies of operation moving slowly upward. THz power can be produced from below the THz gap by multiplication up from lower frequencies and such sources [15,16] have been used extensively in space science for remote sensing. On the other (higher frequency) side of the THz gap the frequencies delivered by
Terahertz Sources
119
quantum cascade lasers (QCLs) are slowly moving downward and have in fact reached the 1THz region, albeit with the added complexity of requiring an applied magnetic field. Although QCLs can deliver significant amounts of power (tens of mW) they do suffer from the disadvantage of having to operate at cryogenic temperatures and are not readily tuneable. Whilst it is clear that THz frequencies have significant uses, mainly in scientific areas such as spectroscopy where the cost and size of femtosecond systems are less of an issue, it can be argued that the technology will not become ubiquitous until inexpensive and robust electronic sources are available. The situation today can be compared with that of the semiconductor diode laser 50 years ago where, at that time, they could only operate at cryogenic temperatures. Who then would have predicted that every household would own a diode laser (in CD players), that we would be using them as pointers in the class room and buying them from DIY stores to replace the humble spirit level to produce horizontal lines on a wall to act as a tiling guide? Many uses for terahertz waves have been suggested, for example molecular recognition, flame tomography, gas sensing, damp detection, archaeology and various medical and security applications, but none of these has taken off because of the expense, large physical size and fragility of the femtosecond systems. Given an inexpensive electronic source, THz technology would be in a much better position to compete with existing techniques. The need is also becoming more urgent as processing speeds in integrated circuits move up into the THz region and greater bandwidths (and therefore higher frequencies) are required in communications. The section will discuss the state of the art in THz electronic sources.
5.3.1 Two-terminal Devices Gunn diodes (sometimes known as transferred electron devices), IMPATT (impact avalanche transit time) diodes and TUNNETT (tunnel injection transit time) diodes [17] are wellestablished sources at microwave and mm-wave frequencies. In each case, the device structures are designed to generate a negative slope in the current voltage characteristic, giving rise to a region of negative differential resistance (NDR) as illustrated in Figure 5.7. When a DC voltage large enough to bias the device into the NDR is applied, it creates an inherently unstable state and the device goes into oscillation. Frequencies up into the mm-wave region can be generated but the specific mechanisms giving rise to the NDR impose an upper
Figure 5.7
Current voltage curve showing the negative differential resistance region (shaded)
120
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
limit to the oscillation frequency. As the name ‘transferred electron device’ suggests, the cause of the NDR in Gunn diodes is the transfer of electrons from the light to the heavy mass conduction bands. This process takes a finite time, which in turn limits the highest frequency available. Similarly, in the IMPATT diode a finite amount of time is needed to build up to the avalanche condition. If the negative resistance instability can be produced by another and faster mechanism then the way would be open for THz generation. Modern molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) growth techniques have resulted in TUNNETT diodes with very short transit time layers which are thus capable of oscillating at over 600 GHz [18], but with very low power levels. Two other types of device which can potentially exhibit NDR at high enough frequencies are possible candidates for THz generation. They are the resonant tunnelling diode (RTD) and the superlattice electron device (SLED). These devices are approaching the THz gap from the lower frequency side. The quantum cascade laser (QCL) which is approaching the 1 THz region from above is also a two-terminal device but relies on laser action rather than NDR. A common feature of all of these devices is that they take advantage of semiconductor bandgap engineering to produce the desired electrical characteristics. 5.3.1.1 Resonant Tunnelling Diodes Resonant tunnelling diodes have a double barrier structure as shown (under zero bias) in Figure 5.8(a). In the narrow space between the barriers the electron energies are quantized into discrete levels. At a particular DC bias (Figure 5.8(b)) the energy levels at the bottom of the conduction band on the left-hand side align with the lowest level in the well giving rise to a resonant condition whereby electrons can tunnel through the barriers. As the bias is increased further (Figure 5.8(c)), the resonant condition no longer holds and the current falls as the applied bias voltage increases. At even higher applied voltages the current once more increases under the combined action of electron excitation over, and tunnelling through, the barriers. This results in an I V curve which has an NDR region and hence can lead to oscillations. Tunnelling times of about 10 14 s are expected, holding out the prospect of operation into the THz region and beyond. In practice, the highest frequency demonstrated to date is 712 GHz, a result that dates back to 1991 [19]. The THz power generated was in the mW region a level too low for most applications. The reason for this low power can be explained from the I-V curve as (c)
(b)
(a)
EF EF
EF qV = 0
qV P
IP qV V
Figure 5.8 Double barrier resonant tunnelling diode (DBRTD) conduction band edge diagrams: (a) zero bias, (b) at resonance and (c) in the NDR region
121
Power ≈ ∆I∆V
∆I
Current (I )
Terahertz Sources
∆V
Voltage (V )
Figure 5.9 I V characteristic of a resonant tunnelling diode showing the very steep negative differential resistance region
depicted in Figure 5.9 where it can be seen that the region of NDR is rather narrow along the voltage axis. The power generated is determined by the product DI DV where the terms represent the current and voltage swings so a small DV results in low power. The 712 GHz figure was achieved many years ago and has not been improved upon. However, research continues using materials other than GaAs/AlGaAs heterostructures and perhaps involving quantum dots. 5.3.1.2 Superlattice Electron Devices (SLEDs) As mentioned above, Gunn diodes rely on interband electron transfer for their NDR. However, if the material band structure is such that the electrons gain extra mass without transferring to another band then an NDR effect could occur which would not be transfer-time limited. The required band structure does in fact exist as illustrated in the typical semiconductor energy/ momentum (or E k) curve of Figure 5.10(a). As the momentum increases, the curve becomes less steep and this is equivalent to an increase in effective mass for the electrons. At high enough bias, the electrons will therefore slow down producing an NDR. The trouble is that in natural semiconductors, the electrons either transfer, or begin to transfer, to another energy band before they reach this region. Superlattice devices, because of the periodicity of the artificial structure (Figure 5.10(b)), allow us to engineer a material which eliminates the band-to-band transition. A wide range of component materials can be used in SLED structures and of course the periodicity can also be optimized. At the time of writing SLEDs have demonstrated power generation but only up to around 200 GHz and then only at very low sub-microwatt power levels. However, continuous steady progress, especially in heat dissipation, is being made and 1 mW at 1 THz is predicted. Another motivation for the development of SLEDs is to produce a THz frequency Bloch oscillator. With reference to Figure 5.10(a), as an electron is accelerated from rest (k ¼ 0) by an externally applied electric field in the positive k direction up the (lower) E k curve, it eventually reaches the edge of the Brillouin zone at k ¼ p/a, At this point its momentum is reversed and it proceeds back upon itself to k ¼ p/a where a further momentum reversal
122
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications E
k -π/a
Reduced k space
EC
π/a
(a)
(b)
Figure 5.10 (a) Reduced energy/momentum (E k) curves for a periodic structure; (b) superlattice structure with conduction band profile
occurs. In the ideal case this process repeats itself continuously giving rise to an oscillatory motion. Much has been published on this phenomenon but it is not clear that Bloch oscillations have actually been observed. However, from the results mentioned above, it may well be that the future of SLED THz oscillators lies in the optimization of domain formation resulting from the Bloch effect. 5.3.1.3 Quantum Cascade Lasers (QCLs) Quantum cascade lasers (QCLs) are also superlattice devices but in this case they have been engineered to emit THz radiation directly by laser action. The problem with the THz laser is that, at this frequency, the photons have energies of 4 meV. With room temperature corresponding to 25 meV normal laser action tends to be wiped out because of thermal excitation of electrons between the laser energy levels. In the superlattice structure the laser levels can be separated in space as well as energy, making laser action more likely, but for operation in the THz gap, the devices still have to be cooled to near cryogenic temperatures for useful operation. Power is not a problem with current performance figures of 0.6 mW at 1 THz rising quickly to about 10 mW at 2 THz. However, the figures at 1 THz have only been achieved with the addition of a magnetic field which of course increases the complexity, cost, power consumption and physical size. In general, the higher powers are achieved under pulsed biasing conditions and the lower the frequency the lower must be the operating temperature temperatures as low as 40 K are needed at 1 THz. QCLs are not conveniently tuneable by, for example changing the bias voltage. This may not be a serious disadvantage, except perhaps in spectroscopy, but this has been overcome for mid-IR frequencies by Benjamin Lee et al. [20] who, on a single chip, fabricated an array of single mode distributed feedback QCLs, each emitting at a different frequency. Steady progress is being made in the performance of QCLs as the technology improves [21].
123
Terahertz Sources
5.3.1.4 Josephson Plasma Sources When a DC bias V is applied across a Josephson junction an AC signal of frequency f is produced given by: f ¼ 2qV=h
ð5:8Þ
where q is the charge on the electron and h is Plancks constant. For a typical DC bias of 1 mV the frequency of the AC current produced is 0.5 THz. A single junction will supply very little power but, if the currents produced by a number of interconnected junctions can be combined coherently, then a useful amount of power in the mW range may be possible. This possibility was predicted by Tilley as long ago as 1970 [22] but it is only recently (2007) that a practical device has been reported by Ozyuzer et al. [23]. Using crystals of the high-temperature superconductor Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8 (BSCCO), Ozyuzer et al. formed a stack of Josephson junctions made up of superconducting CuO2 layers separated by insulating Br Sr 0 layers in a mesa structure about 1 mm high as shown in Figure 5.11. The vertical side walls of the mesa reflect the waves generated at the junctions backwards and forwards as in a laser bringing all of the components of the radiation into phase. The THz power output of the device scaled as n2 where n is the number of junctions but with too many junctions the device would not operate because the temperature would then rise above the critical value for superconductivity. At a temperature of 50 K the authors recorded a power of 0.5 mW at a frequency of 0.85 THz but predict that up to 0.5 mW could be generated in the 0.5 1.5 THz range. The frequency capability of these devices nicely fills the remaining THz gap between transit-time devices and QCLs but the power levels may still be a bit on the low side for practical applications and of course, they do need to be cooled down to low temperatures. In principle, tuning could be achieved by varying the applied DC voltage but the length of the cavity also determines the frequency of the emitted signal.
Figure 5.11 Josephson Plasma Source using the high temperature superconductor Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8 (BSCCO) sandwiched around nonsuperconducting insulators. (From Science, 318, No. 23, Nov 2007. Reprinted with permission of AAAS)
124
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications GATE S
D L
Figure 5.12
Basic structure of a field effect transistor
5.3.2 Three-terminal Devices In electronics, conventional three-terminal devices are based on the flow of current over a defined distance from one region to another. For bipolar transistors the current carriers make a transition across the base region; in field effect devices the carriers must flow from source to drain (Figure 5.12). The time taken for current carriers to flow across a device that is the ‘transit time’ determines the maximum frequency of operation. The shorter the transit length (L) and the higher the carrier velocity (v), the shorter will be the transit time and the higher will be the maximum frequency. However, current carriers (usually electrons) in semiconductors have a maximum speed (or saturation velocity vSAT but see below) in the region of 105 ms 1. (Beyond this speed they quickly give up their kinetic energy to the semiconductor lattice.) Therefore, the only way to make the devices faster is to reduce the transit distance. This in turn leads to difficulties because at small separations (<1 micron) electrical breakdown can easily occur. So, cut-off frequency, fT v/L but v has an upper limit 105 ms 1. Therefore for operation at 1 THz, L 0.1 mm. The maximum voltage VMAX that can be applied across a device is limited by electrical breakdown, that is VMAX ¼ EBL where EB is the breakdown field and the power generated 2 P / VMAX
which can then be written as P / EB2 n2SAT =fT2 ; that is the power falls off as the inverse square of the frequency. vSAT depends on the material so with careful choice the power can be maintained at higher frequencies. Also as the dimensions get smaller, the probability of an electron making a collision with the lattice in the transit region reduces and ballistic transport can occur. In this situation there is no speed limit on the electrons (except of course, for the velocity of light.) The frequency of operation of ‘conventional’ electronic devices is slowly creeping up towards the 1 THz figure and the following sections will describe how these improvements are being brought about in different devices. 5.3.2.1 The Heterojunction Bipolar Transistor (HBT) Workers at the University of Illinois [24] in the USA have designed, fabricated and tested double heterojunction bipolar transistors (DHBT) with a cut-off frequency (i.e. unity current
Terahertz Sources
125
gain) fT of 765 GHz at room temperature (855 GHz at 218 K). The first consideration for this device is the choice of material which, in this case, was to use the InP/GaAsSb system. This has a high breakdown field and thermal conductivity but does have the disadvantage of relatively slow diffusion through the base region. To overcome this difficulty, the composition of the base region was graded to produce a built in electric field so that the electrons were driven through by a combination of drift and diffusion. In any electron device the ultimate performance is affected by parasitic circuit effects such as contact resistance and interlayer capacitance. In the DHBT, the choice of materials served to reduce these effects but also precision electron beam lithography was used to define the device geometry and hence minimize unnecessary lengths of parasitic material. The thicknesses of the graded base and InP collector layers were 25 nm and 65 nm respectively. In practice, the devices were only characterized up to 50 GHz and hence the cut-off frequency is estimated by extrapolation. 5.3.2.2 Field Effect Transistors (FETs) As with the DHBT, the capabilities of field effect transistors (FETs) are slowly moving up in frequency. This movement can again be put down to developments in material growth and device processing. Again, the favoured material is InP because of its high electron mobility. In December 2007 at the International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), Northrop Grummans Space Technology Sector announced an InP high electron mobility transistor (HEMT) with fT > 1 THz [25]. This device has a sub 50 nm gate length, a 25% increase in electron mobility in the channel and a similar reduction in resistivity which lowers the contact resistance. The HEMTs were used in a three-stage common source low-noise MMIC amplifier which exhibited > 18 dB gain at 300 GHz and 15 dB gain at 340 GHz. Extrapolation of these results to 0 dB gain gives the fT > 1 THz. There is also another pressure on the drive to make FETs operate at ever higher frequencies. This comes from digital technology where the FET, operating as a switch, is the device of preference in integrated circuits. To keep Moores Law on course, ever faster switches are needed. In 2001 both Intel and IBM announced that they had developed ‘terahertz transistors’ aimed at the 45 nm generation of chip technology (see, for example, [26, 27]). The Intel THz transistor is fabricated on a silicon substrate, but unlike the conventional device, is separated from the substrate by a layer of oxide. This layer reduces leakage between the source and drain thus reducing parasitic power consumption. For the same reason, a new dielectric layer is used under the gate. Thicker source and drain layers are introduced to reduce the series parasitic resistance. The gate length is 45 nm. Terahertz switching speeds have also been achieved in ‘ballistic deflection transistors’ (BDTs) which have been developed at the University of Rochester [28]. These devices are fabricated using nanolithography and have dimensions less than the mean free path of electrons in the material hence ‘ballistic’ as the motion is collision free. As illustrated in Figure 5.13, electrons directed into the BDT are deflected to the right (indicating logic 1) or to the left (logic 0) by the polarity of the potential difference between the control electrodes. Because of the nanometre dimensions, the parasitic capacitances are also very small in the attofarad range resulting in sub-picosecond response times.
126
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Figure 5.13 The ballistic defection transistor: (a) schematic and (b) micrograph of device structure. (Reproduced by permission of the University of Rochester)
5.3.2.3 Plasma Wave Device Dyakonov and Shur [29] have proposed and developed a novel application of a three-terminal device for THz wave generation. Their ‘plasma wave transistor’ looks very much like a HEMT (Figure 5.14) but operates in a very different way. In their device, plasma waves are set up in the electron gas in the channel rather like sound waves in a wind instrument hence their name ‘electronic flute’. With a suitable choice of channel length, a THz frequency standing wave can be generated between the source and drain, which in turn causes a current at this frequency to flow in the external circuit. In 2006, Dyakonova et al. [30] described the emission of radiation in the 0.2 4.5 THz range from AlGaN/GaN HEMTs operating at room temperature. Power levels of 0.1 mW were observed.
Figure 5.14
Schematic representation of the plasma wave transistor
5.3.3 Multiplication Terahertz signal generation by multiplication up from a lower frequency is perhaps the longest established electronic technique for example, see [31]. The motivation for this technology stems largely from the astronomy and remote sensing communities where compact and robust systems are a priority for mounting in space vehicles and cost is not a primary factor. A wide range of sources are available from companies such as Virginia Diodes (VDI) and an example of one of their THz sources is shown in Figure 5.15. The starting point for this device is a low frequency (< 25 GHz) signal which is multiplied by a factor of 72 to give an output in the 1 THz range. However, frequency multiplication is a relatively inefficient process so the
127
Terahertz Sources
Figure 5.15 ATHz source consisting of a low frequency coaxial input, an integrated doubler/amplifier, a quadrupler and two triplers. It has generated up to 25 mW in the WR 0.65 waveguide band, total length is 6 inches, no mechanical tuners are used. (Reproduced with permission from Virginia Diodes)
resulting THz power is only 25 mW, which may not be sufficient in some of the anticipated THz applications such as imaging, stand-off detection or communications. The nonlinear component that is at the heart of the VDI sources is the tried and tested Schottky diode whose history dates back to the early days of radio communications and is perhaps the first ever solid-state electronic device. Over the last few years researchers in Sweden [32] have been developing an alternative nonlinear multiplier know as the heterostructure barrier varactor (HBV). The HBVuses modern growth techniques to produce a device which has a symmetrical capacitance voltage (C V) characteristic (Figure 5.16) and hence, when acting as a multiplier, produces only the odd harmonics of the drive signal. This feature has the advantage of minimizing the number of different frequencies generated and removes
0.2
0.2 IEEE
0
0.1
-0.2 -60
-40
-20
0
20
40
Capacitance [fF/µm2]
Current [µA/µm2]
© 2007
60
Voltage [V]
Figure 5.16 Capacitance voltage and current voltage measurements for a 12 barrier 700 mm2 HBV. Reproduced by permission of Josip Vukusic, Tomas Bryllert, T. Arezoo Emadi, Mahdad Sadeghi and Jan Stake, IEEE Electron Device Letters, 28, no. 5, May 2007. ( 2007 IEEE)
128
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
the need to terminate the circuit at the even harmonics. Operated as a tripler, the HBV develops an output power of 240 mW at 110 GHz with a conversion efficiency of about 20%. In quintupler mode it develops 20 mW at 202 GHz at a conversion efficiency of about 3%. This performance is comparable with that of state-of-the-art Schottky diodes and further developments already in progress in material systems, heat sinking and circuit design will undoubtedly lead to significant improvements. However, at the present state of development, the frequencies achieved are still only just in the THz range! Ong and Hartnagel [33] have suggested a structure based on quasi-ballistic electron reflection (Q-BER) which according to their simulations should be superior to the HBV at the higher frequencies. At the time of writing, results for actual devices have not been published.
5.4 Conclusion Terahertz technology is a rapidly developing and expanding field. Historically, the utilization of these frequencies has been limited by the scarcity and low brightness of sources. Currently, however, a number of different technologies are increasingly bridging what used to be known as the ‘THz gap’. These include both optical techniques, based on laser down-conversion, and a variety of electronic technologies. It may therefore be expected that in the next few years terahertz technology and its applications will become as widespread and well-established as that of other spectral regions.
References [1] P. K. Cheo (Ed.), Handbook of Molecular Lasers, CRC Press, New York, USA, 1987, ISBN:0824776518. [2] A. Bergner, U. Heugen, E. Brudermann, G. Schwaab, M. Havenith, D.R. Charmberlin and E.E. Haller, ‘‘New p Ge THz laser spectrometer for the study of solutions: THz absorption spectroscopy of water’’, Review of Scientific Instruments, vol. 76, 063110, 2005. [3] C.A. Brau, Free Electron Lasers, Academic Press, Inc., Boston, USA, 1990. [4] D. Dragoman and M. Dragoman, ‘‘Terahertz fields and applications’’, Progress in Quantum Electronics, vol. 28, 1 66, 2004. [5] A. Corchia, C.M. Ciesla, D.D. Arnone, E.H. Linfield, M.Y. Simmons and M. Pepper, ‘‘Crystallographic orientation dependence of bulk optical rectification’’, Journal of Modern Optics, vol. 47, no. 11, pp. 1837 1845, 2000. [6] K. Liu, J. Xu and X.C. Zhang, ‘‘GaSe crystals for broadband THz wave detection’’, Applied Physics Letters, vol. 85, no. 6, 863 865 2004. [7] M.R. Stone, M. Naftaly, R.E. Miles, J.R. Fletcher and D.P. Steenson, ‘‘Electrical and radiation characteristics of semilarge photoconductive terahertz emitters’’, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 52, no. 10, 2420 2429, 2004. [8] Y.C. Shen, P.C. Upadhya, E.H. Linfield, H.E. Beere and A.G. Davies, ‘‘Ultrabroadband terahertz radiation from low temperature grown GaAs photoconductive emitters’’, Applied Physics Letters, vol. 83, no. 15, 3117 3179, 2003. [9] I.S. Gregory, W.R. Tribe, M.J. Evans, T.D. Drysdale and D.R.S. Cumming, ‘‘Multi channel homodyne detection of continuous wave terahertz radiation’’, Applied Physics Letters, vol. 87, 034106, 2005. [10] M.R. Stone, M. Naftaly, R.E. Miles, I.C. Mayorga and A. Malcoci, ‘‘Generation of continuous wave terahertz radiation using a two mode titanium sapphire laser containing an intracavity Fabry Perot etalon’’, Journal of Applied Physics, vol. 97, 103108, 2005. [11] Y.J. Ding and W. Shi, ‘‘Widely tunable, monochromatic, and high power terahertz sources and their applica tions’’, J. Nonlinear Optical Physics and Materials, vol. 12, no. 4, 557 585, 2003. [12] T. Tanabe, K. Suto, J. Nishizawa, K. Saito and T. Kimura, ‘‘Frequency tunable terahertz wave generation via excitation of phonon polaritons in GaP’’, Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics, vol. 36, 953 957, 2003.
Terahertz Sources
129
[13] T. Tanuichi, S. Okada and H. Nakanishi, ‘‘Widely tunable terahertz wave generation in an organic crystal and its spectroscopic application’’, Journal of Applied Physics, vol. 95, no. 11, 5984 5987, 2004. [14] D. H. Auston, K. P. Cheung, J. A. Valdmanis and D. A. Kleinman, ‘‘Cherenkov Radiation from Femtosecond Optical Pulses in Electro Optic Media’’, Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 53, 1555 1558, 1984. [15] T.W. Crowe, ‘‘GaAs Schottky Barrier Mixer Diodes for the Frequency Range 1 10 THz’’, Int. J. lnfrared Millimeter Waves, vol. 10, no. 7, PP. 765 777, 1989. [16] J. Stake, T. Bryllert, J. Vukusic and A. Øistein Olsen, ‘‘Development of high power HBV multipliers for millimeter wave applications’’, Proc. SPIE, vol. 6739, PP. 67390U 1 8, 2007. [17] P. Plotka, J. Nishizawa, T. Kurabayashi and H. Makabe, ‘‘240 325 GHz GaAs CW Fundamental Mode TUNNETT Diodes Fabricated With Molecular Layer Epitaxy’’, IEEE Trans Electron Devices, vol. 50, no. 4, 867 873, 2003. [18] J. Nishizawa, P. Plotka, H. Makabe and T. Kurabayashi, ‘‘GaAs TUNNETT Diodes Oscillating at 430 655 GHz in CW Fundammental Mode’’, IEEE Microwave and Wireless Components Lett, vol. 15, no. 9, 2005. [19] E.R. Brown, J.R. Soderstrom, C.D. Parker, L.J. Mahoney, K.M. Molvar and T.C. McGill, ‘‘Oscillations up to 712 GHz in InAs/AISb resonant tunnelling diodes’’, Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 58, no. 20, 2291 2293, 1991. [20] B.G. Lee, M.A. Belkin, R. Audet, J. MacArthur, L. Diehl, C. Pflugl, F. Capasso, D.C. Oakley, D. Chapman, A. Napoleone, D. Bour, S. Corzine and G. Hofler, ‘‘Widely Tunable single mode quantum cascade laser source for mid infrared spectroscopy’’, Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 91, 231101 1 2007. [21] B.S. Williams, ‘‘Terahertz Quantum Cascade Lasers Review Article’’, Nature Photonics, vol. 1, 517 525, 2007. [22] D.R. Tilley, ‘‘Superradiance In Arrays Of Superconducting Weak Links’’, Phys. Lett., vol. 33A, 205 206, 1970. [23] L. Ozyuzer, A.E. Koshelev, C. Kurter, N. Gopalsami, Q. Li, M. Tachiki, K. Kadowaki, T. Yamamoto, H. Minami, H. Yamaguchi, T. Tachiki, K.E. Gray, W.K. Kwok and U. Welp, ‘‘Emission of Coherent THz Radiation from Superconductors’’, Science, vol. 318, no. 5854, pp. 1291 1293, 2007. [24] W. Snodgrass, Bing Ruey Wu, K.Y. Cheng and M. Feng, ‘‘Type II GaAsSb/InP DHBTs with Record fT 670 GHz and Simultaneous fT, fMAX > 400 GHz’’, Proceedings of the IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting, IEDM 07, Washington, D.C., USA, pp. 663 666, 2007. [25] R. Lai, X. B. Mei, W.R. Deal, W. Yoshida, Y. M. Kim, P.H. Liu, J. Lee, J. Uyeda, V. Radisic, M. Lange, T. Gaier, L. Samoska and A. Fung, ‘‘Sub 50 nm InP HEMT Device with Fmax Greater than 1 THz’’, IEEE International Electron Devices Tech. Digest, Washington, D.C., USA, pp. 609 611, 2007. [26] http://www.pctechguide.com/21Architecture TeraHertz technology.htm. [27] P. J. Silverman, ‘‘The Intel Lithography Roadmap’’, Intel Technology Journal, vol. 6, issue 2, pp. 55 61, May 2002. [28] Q. Diduck, M. Margala and M.J. Feldman, ‘‘ATerahertz Transistor Based on Geometrical Deflection of Ballistic Current’’, IEEE International Microwave Symposium Digest, pp. 345 347, 2006. [29] M.I. Dyakonov and M.S. Shur, ‘‘Plasma wave electronics: Novel terahertz devices with two dimensional electron fluid’’, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 43, no. 10, pp. 1640 1645, 1996. [30] N. Dyakonova, A. El Fatimy, J. Łusakowski, W. Knap, M. I. Dyakonov, M. A. Poisson and E. Morvan, ‘‘Room temperature terahertz emission from nanometer field effect transistors’’, Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 88, p. 141906, 2006. [31] R. E. Miles, P. Harrison and D. Lippens(Eds), Terahertz Sources and Systems, Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Workshop on Terahertz Sources and Systems, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Holland, 2001. [32] J. Vukusic, T. Bryllert, A. Emadi, M. Sadeghi and J. Stake ‘‘A 0.2 W Heterostructure Barrier Varactor Frequency Tripler at 113 GHz’’, IEEE Electron Device Letters, vol. 28, no. 5, pp. 340 342, May 2007. [33] D. S. Ong and H. L. Hartnagel, ‘‘Enhanced THz frequency multiplier efficiency by quasi ballistic electron reflection in double heterojunction structures’’, EPL, vol. 81, pp. 48004 48009, 2008.
Part III Systems Applications
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Edited by Stavros Iezekiel © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 978-0-470-84854-8
6 Analogue Microwave Fibre-optic Link Design Edward I. Ackerman and Charles H. Cox, III
6.1 Introduction Since the development of low-loss optical fibre in the late 1960s [1], designers of all sorts of systems for transmitting, detecting and processing electronic signals have sought to exploit its uniquely advantageous characteristics, which are discussed further at various points throughout this chapter. To do this has required the development of devices that generate light at the optical frequencies usually expressed in terms of the corresponding optical wavelengths in free space that propagate best in the fibre, devices that allow the electronic signal of interest to modulate this light at one end of the fibre and devices that restore the signal to electronic form at the other end of the fibre. The interconnection of these devices in a configuration that results in the conveyance of the electronic signal of interest from one point to another by means of the optical fibre is what is known as a fibre-optic link. Figure 6.1 illustrates an example of how a fibre-optic link referred to simply as a ‘link’ in the remainder of this chapter conveys a radio-frequency (RF) microwave signal [2]. In the example shown, a signal consisting of a single frequency fRF modulates a single-frequency optical carrier at frequency fopt for propagation in the optical fibre as sidebands at frequencies fopt fRF , which beat against the carrier in the photodetector to produce an output electronic signal at the original frequency fRF. (It should be noted that Figure 6.1 specifically depicts the spectral patterns of signals in a link that employs the intensity modulation and direct detection techniques; these techniques are fully described further on in this chapter.) For the purposes of discussion, in this chapter a straightforward or ‘intrinsic’ link is defined to include the optical source, the modulator, the fibre and the optical receiver, but not any electronic amplifiers. The link has electronic input and output ports and as such can include passive circuits which transform the impedances of these ports to match those of the modulation and detection device impedances, respectively.
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications Edited by Stavros Iezekiel © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ISBN: 978-0-470-84854-8
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
134
‘Simple’ Link Detection (S/N)in
Optical source
f RF Sin
f RF
Modulation Photodetector
RF / Optical modulator
RF input
Figure 6.1
f opt
Optical fibre
(S/N)out
Sout
RF output
Definition of an ‘intrinsic’ analogue fibre optic link. Reproduced from [2] ( 1997 IEEE)
The microwave fibre-optic link design process always involves the selection of appropriate devices for generating, modulating and detecting light, and possibly also includes special circuit designs and the selection of electronic amplifiers to modify the performance of the straightforward (i.e. without amplifier) link. However, before all these steps, microwave fibreoptic link design always begins with a definition of specifications for the link, and can be considered complete when the design meets those specifications. How the specifications are met depends on the answers to a series of questions that the designer poses in pursuing a solution. These questions are interspersed throughout the section that follows.
6.2 Requirements What constitutes a suitable link depends on the application into which it is to be inserted. The most basic question to ask oneself before beginning the design of a fibre-optic link is probably as follows. Why a fibre-optic link and not a microwave link consisting of some combination of electronic amplifiers and a coaxial cable or other metallic RF waveguide? Optical-fibre communication is an impressive technology, maturing with every passing year to address an ever-increasing range of system design issues. Like any technology, though, it is not the right tool for every job. For a system in which a coaxial cable’s performance characteristics are perfectly acceptable, it is overkill to design a fibre-optic link unless the system will benefit from leveraging one of the truly distinguishing properties of optical fibre its light weight, small size, immunity and passivity to the electromagnetic environment, or the transparent and nondispersive properties that allow it to propagate a large range of optical wavelengths over great distances. What are the maximum tolerable size, weight, DC power consumption and cost of all the hardware at the two ends of the link? A successful design depends upon this question being asked at some point. Moreover it is prudent to ask it early on, because its answers may save time by immediately ruling out specific link architectures requiring devices that are too bulky, power-hungry or expensive. Another question that is best asked early on in the process is as follows. To what range of environmental conditions will the link be exposed, and under what conditions must it operate with the specified performance?
Analogue Microwave Fibre optic Link Design
135
This is not really a single question but rather a pair of related questions, in that often the range of environmental conditions over which the link must exhibit its promised performance is broader than the range over which it must simply survive so as to again deliver this performance once the narrower range of conditions is restored. The specified ‘range of environmental conditions’ often amounts to simply a range of temperatures, although in some systems pressures, humidity levels and vibration levels may be specified as well. This question should be asked early on in the process to avoid spending time designing a link using specific devices that are later discovered to be too sensitive to changes in environmental conditions. Sometimes system designers will answer a ‘What is required from the link?’ question with a ‘What is the best you can do?’ answer. This is quite often true of the next question the link designer must ask. Over what distance must the optical fibre carry the signal? A related question is as follows. What range of microwave frequencies comprises the signal? The combined answers to these last two questions may dictate a great deal about the link design, possibly precluding the use of certain types of optical sources, modulators, fibres and detectors. Finally, the designer must find out the answer to the following question. Which microwave figures of merit will be used to quantify the link performance, and for each of these what specific minimum or maximum values must be achieved in the link design? The most commonly specified figures of merit are summarized here.
6.2.1 Gain Performance Figure 6.2 shows how several of the figures of merit commonly used to quantify the performance of microwave components are defined. The first to be examined here is the intrinsic small-signal gain, gi, because several of the other figures of merit depend in some way upon this one. For an input RF signal power expressed in W (or mW or mW), gi is the dimensionless ratio of the output RF power to this input power. When this ratio is less than unity, it is generally called loss rather than gain. Similarly, for input and output powers expressed in dBm, Gi is the difference between these and is expressed in dB, with a negative difference representing loss rather than gain: gi ðdimensionlessÞ ¼
sout ðin WÞ sin ðin WÞ
Gi ðin dBÞ ¼ 10 logðgi Þ ¼ Sout ðin dBmÞ Sin ðin dBmÞ:
ð6:1aÞ ð6:1bÞ
The ‘small-signal’ aspect of the definitions of gi and Gi refers to the fact that these figures of merit must be specified for input signals which are not sufficiently strong enough to undergo a measurable degree of amplitude compression. As Figure 6.2 shows, for all sufficiently small input signals Gi is a constant.
6.2.2 Signal-to-noise Performance The ratio of signal output power to noise output power, usually expressed in dB, is almost always one of the most important figures of merit in any system design. For many communications
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
136
IPnout
Output signal powers (dBm)
Sout,max Sout,1dB
IPnin Sin,max Sin,1dB
G = Sout – Sin
n
Noise figure
F
1
1
nth -or
me
da un
int erm
ne
to
der
tal
f 2)
od s
f 1, s(
Spurious-free dynamic range
n 1
Nout 1-dB Compression dynamic range Full compression dynamic range k T0 B
Minimum detectable signal
Input fundamental tone (f1,f2) signal powers (dbm) Figure 6.2 Principal figures of merit for analogue two port devices, including analogue fibre optic links
systems, the input signal strength is controlled and therefore known, in which case the output signal-to-noise ratio might always be designed to meet or exceed a specified value at this input power. In detection systems such as radars, however, this input signal strength is unknown, and so the output signal-to-noise ratio cannot be readily specified. For such systems a useful figure of merit is the noise figure (nf or NF), which is defined as the extent to which the signal-to-noise ratio degrades:
ðs=nÞin;a nf ðdimensionlessÞ ¼ ðs=nÞout
nin ¼kT0 B
¼
nout : kT0 B ga
NFðin dBÞ ¼ 10 logðnf Þ ¼ ðS=NÞin;a ðin dBÞ ðS=NÞout ðin dBÞ ¼ Nout ðin dBmÞ 10 logðkT0 BÞ ðin dBmÞ Ga ðin dBÞ:
ð6:2aÞ
ð6:2bÞ
In Equation (6.2a), s/n is the dimensionless ratio of signal power s to noise power n (both expressed in W), and in Equation (6.2b) S/N is the difference in dB between these two powers (both expressed in dBm). The input noise is specified as only the noise arising from thermal sources. This input noise is the product of k (Boltzmann’s constant), T0 (room temperature,
Analogue Microwave Fibre optic Link Design
137
standardized by the IEEE as 290 K [3]) and B (the instantaneous bandwidth of the electronic receiver, sometimes called the ‘resolution bandwidth’ or ‘noise bandwidth’). Because the output noise term nout is also proportional to B, the noise figure is independent of B. The terms ga and Ga are the link’s available gain, defined as in Equation (6.1) for the special case resulting from perfect matching of the link input port impedance to the microwave signal source’s impedance. Figure 6.2 shows how NF can be determined graphically from measurable quantities, using Equation (6.2b). It also shows how to determine graphically another important figure of merit that expresses the signal-to-noise performance of a link, which is the minimum detectable signal (mds). This quantity, which is defined as the smallest signal power appearing at the link input that can be distinguished from the noise at the link output, is related to the noise figure as follows (and as shown in Figure 6.2): mdsðin WÞ ¼
nout ¼ kT0 B nf : ga
MDSðin dBmÞ ¼ Nout ðin dBmÞ Ga ðin dBÞ ¼ kT0 B ðin dBmÞ þ NFðin dBÞ:
ð6:3aÞ ð6:3bÞ
6.2.3 Dynamic Range Just as the existence of noise sets a lower limit on the link’s input signal power, there is also an upper limit on the input signal power. This upper limit exists because of the nonlinear characteristics of the link components that give rise to phenomena such as output signal compression (sometimes called gain compression) and the generation of harmonic and/or intermodulation distortion, as will be explained further below. The link’s dynamic range is defined as the ratio of the largest input power (expressed in W) that it can usefully convey to the smallest such input power, which is the mds (or as the difference in dB between these two powers if they are both expressed in dBm, which is the MDS). How one defines the largest input power that the link can usefully convey depends upon the application. In some applications this is simply the input signal power that causes full compression of the output signal, such that further increases of the input power do not cause the output power to increase (and may even cause it to decrease), and for these applications the full-compression dynamic range (cdrfull) is defined as (and as shown in Figure 6.2): cdrfull ðdimensionlessÞ ¼
sin;max ðin WÞ mds ðin WÞ
CDRfull ðin dBÞ ¼ Sin;max ðin dBmÞ MDS ðin dBmÞ:
ð6:4aÞ ð6:4bÞ
Sometimes the largest input power that the link can usefully convey is considered to be that at which the output power has been compressed by 1 dB. This input signal power, Sin,1dB, is the power for which the output power Sout,1dB satisfies the following equation: Sout;1dB ðin dBmÞ ¼ Sin;1dB ðin dBmÞ þ Ga ðin dBÞ 1 dB:
ð6:5Þ
138
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
From this relationship the 1-dB-compression dynamic range as shown in Figure 6.2 is defined as (where from here on we dispense with the linear expression and give only the more useful logarithmic one): CDR1dB ðin dBÞ ¼ Sin;1dB ðin dBmÞ MDS ðin dBmÞ:
ð6:6Þ
In many applications, the generation of harmonic and/or intermodulation distortion by nonlinear components in the link sets the upper limit on the useful input signal power and therefore dictates the dynamic range. If a signal consisting of a single tone at frequency f1 is present at the input to the link, harmonic distortion products caused by the link’s nonlinearity appear at the output at frequencies pf1, where p is the set of all positive integers. If the input signal instead consists of two tones f1 and f2, then the resulting output harmonics at pf1 and pf2 will be accompanied by intermodulation distortion products at pf1 qf2 and pf2 qf1, where both p and q are positive integers. Intermodulation distortion products are generally more problematic than harmonics for two reasons: 1. for two equal-strength input tones at f1 and f2, the resulting output intermodulation tones at pf1 qf2 and pf2 qf1 are stronger than the output harmonics at (p þ q) f1 and (p þ q) f2 for any given positive integers p and q for which p q, and 2. in applications covering less than an octave of bandwidth (i.e. those in which the maximum frequency of operation is less than twice the minimum frequency), all harmonics fall out of band and can therefore be filtered out, whereas, for f1 and f2 sufficiently close to one another, many of the intermodulation products whose ‘order’ n ¼ p þ q is an odd number can fall within the band of operation and therefore preclude being filtered out. In applications such as radar, in which spurious output tones at the intermodulation distortion frequencies give rise to false detections, the upper end of the spurious-free dynamic range (SFDR) is defined as the input power that causes any output intermodulation product to exceed the output noise. The dominant order of distortion, n, determines this maximum input power, and a somewhat complicated set of considerations determines n. Generally, the lower the order of distortion, the lower the input power must be to generate an intermodulation product of a given strength. Therefore, unless there is a reason not to begin with the assumption that n ¼ 2, that is the starting assumption one should make. However, if the system operates over less than one octave of bandwidth, second-order distortion products will always fall out of band and therefore permit being filtered out, so that it instead makes sense to begin with the assumption that n ¼ 3. A discussion of ‘linearization’ in a later part of this chapter goes into further detail about determining the correct value of n for a given set of link components. For an input signal consisting of two equal-power tones of small magnitude, the output intermodulation distortion products will be negligible because they will fall very far below the output noise. However, as the two-tone input signal power is increased, the output power at the intermodulation frequencies will increase as the input power to the nth power, so that on Figure 6.2’s plot of output versus input power in dBm the slope of the intermodulation products is n, compared to a slope of one for the fundamental signal tones. A useful figure of merit is the input power at which these two slopes would hypothetically intersect were they to not compress as shown in Figure 6.2. This input power is known as the nth-order intercept IPnin and the
Analogue Microwave Fibre optic Link Design
139
corresponding output power is IPnout. The more linear the devices used in the link, the higher these powers will be. From the geometric arrangement of the lines in Figure 6.2, it can be seen that the SFDR is limited by the nth-order distortion products to: n1 ½IPnin ðin dBmÞ MDSðin dBmÞ n n1 ¼ ½IPnout ðin dBmÞ Nout ðin dBmÞ n
SFDRn ðin dBÞ ¼
ð6:7Þ
6.2.4 Other Figures of Merit Additional figures of merit are important in the design of links for certain applications. The designers of distribution systems for cable television (CATV) signals, for example, wish to have a single link carry as many channels as possible without significant distortion of any one channel. They use a measurable parameter called composite triple beat (CTB) to quantify the level of distortion resulting from a given number of channels. When channels are spaced at equal frequency intervals, a mixture of the information transmitted on three of the channels can appear as distortion on a fourth channel transmitted at a frequency that is the sum of two channel frequencies minus the third channel’s frequency. Thus CTB, like SFDR, is related to the link’s nonlinear distortion properties. It has been shown that to satisfy the CTB requirements of CATV applications, the link’s SFDR must exceed 110 dB in a 1 Hz bandwidth [4]. Microwave components are often additionally characterized in terms of their frequencydependent scattering matrix [Smn], where Smn is the complex ratio of signal intensity out of port m to the signal intensity into port n when all ports other than port n are terminated by the complex conjugates of their input impedances. For a two-port microwave component in which the input and output ports are denoted ports 1 and 2, respectively, the squares of the amplitudes of the four scattering parameters have particular significance: jS11 j2 jS12 j2 jS21 j2 jS22 j2
¼ ¼ ¼ ¼
input return loss backwards isolation insertion loss ðor insertion gain if jS21 j2 > 1Þ output return loss:
The importance of the gain (|S21|2) has been explained in Section 6.2.1. The backwards isolation (|S12|2) is identically zero in most fibre-optic links, in that most modulators cannot detect light and most detectors cannot modulate light; notable exceptions are the dual-function electro-absorption modulator/detector devices demonstrated in the laboratories of the US Navy and the University of California [5]. Because other microwave signal components are not essentially unidirectional, microwave signal reflections at the input and output ports of a link that functions in a chain of microwave components can have adverse affects on the performance of the complete chain. Therefore a link must often be designed such that its input and output return losses (|S11|2 and |S22|2, respectively) lie below a specified level. Lastly, since most of the figures of merit discussed in this chapter are frequency-dependent, a designer will often be required to minimize their variation over the specified bandwidth. With all of these specifications in mind, the designer must make a series of decisions that together
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
140
will ultimately result in the link design. These decisions are the subject of the section that follows.
6.3 Link Design Options The design of a microwave fibre-optic link to meet a set of performance specifications requires the making of a few important decisions.
6.3.1 What Optical Wavelength to Use A wide range of optical wavelengths can propagate in optical fibre with low attenuation. Figure 6.3 shows the attenuation per unit length versus wavelength for silica fibres, with vertical lines indicating the three wavelengths around which activity in the field of fibre-optics has centred since the invention of the optical fibre itself [6]. The availability of Si and AlGaAs sources and detectors prompted some of the earliest developers of links to use wavelengths in the region around 850 nm. By the late 1980s, however, as the designers of CATV and telecommunications systems endeavoured to produce links that spanned longer and longer distances, they began investigating the wavelength region near 1300 nm. In this wavelength region, standard single-mode optical fibre exhibits a minimum of
Infrared absorption tail from lattice transitions
50 20
–OH absorption peaks
Fibre attenuation (dB/km)
10 5 2 1 Perfectly ‘dry’ fibre
0.5
Rayleigh scattering
0.2 0.1 AlGaAs
1.0
1.2
1.30
0.8
0.85
0.02 Red 0.6
InGaAsP Ge InGaAs
Si
1.4
Sources Detectors
1.55
0.05
1.6
1.8
2.0
Wavelength (µm) Figure 6.3
Attenuation in a typical single mode optical fibre versus wavelength. Reproduced from [6]
Analogue Microwave Fibre optic Link Design
141
chromatic dispersion, which is often the phenomenon that limits a link’s bandwidth length product. But by the mid-1990s the availability of erbium-doped fibre amplifiers, which can be optimized for operation at wavelengths ranging from about 1530 1565 nm, motivated most designers of long-distance links to design for this wavelength range so as to exploit this significant and advantageous technological development. It was later found that, through adjustments to the geometry and refractive index profile, the dispersion characteristic of a single-mode fibre could be tailored to have optimum propagation properties in this longerwavelength region instead of near 1300 nm, and this development was accordingly named ‘dispersion-shifted fibre’. An additional benefit of working in this longer wavelength region is the reduced attenuation that arises from Rayleigh scattering relative to shorter wavelengths, as shown in Figure 6.3. Since the development of erbium-doped fibre amplifiers and dispersion-shifted single-mode fibre, most developers of the lasers, modulators, detectors and other components used in fibreoptic links have concentrated product development in the 1550 nm wavelength region. Therefore, deciding to use 1550 nm light gives the fibre-optic link designer the widest range of component options. In some cases, however, shorter wavelengths might offer the optimum solution. Specifically, if the maximum signal frequency and/or the transmission distance are not very large, and the required RF performance is not very challenging, then a design using 850 nm light might yield the lowest-cost solution. This situation is explained further in the sections that follow.
6.3.2 What Type(s) of Optical Fibre to Use A fibre’s geometry primarily the diameter of the higher-index core and its index profile determine whether it will support a single, a few or many spatial modes. The larger the core diameter, the easier it is to efficiently couple light into it and the more spatial modes it supports. As is discussed in a later section of this chapter, maximizing the efficiency of coupling between the fibre and other important link components is necessary for enabling the best possible link performance. In general, to propagate light modulated at high frequencies over long distances, the ideal number of spatial modes supported by a fibre is one. Therefore, with the exception of some components primarily ones optimized for 850 nm operation most commercially available lasers, modulators and detectors have been designed to interface with single-mode fibre and are sold already coupled to single-mode fibre pigtails. Coupling light between single-mode fibre and larger-core multimode fibre is generally inefficient because of mode mismatch issues, and therefore it is important to use fibre of one type throughout the link. An exception to this general rule is the case when polarizationpreserving single-mode fibre is required. This situation exists when one of the devices in the link prefers a specific orientation of the light’s polarization. An external modulator made of an anisotropic inorganic material, such as lithium niobate, is one such device. Lithium niobate modulators are often pigtailed by their manufacturers with polarization-maintaining (PM) single-mode fibres (at least on the optical input port), and therefore unmodulated, continuouswave (CW) light is provided to this device most easily from a laser whose output is also coupled into this type of fibre pigtail. Polarization-preserving fibre is, however, more expensive than standard telecommunications-grade single-mode fibre, and therefore it usually does not make sense to use PM fibre anywhere in a link except between the CW laser and the polarizationsensitive modulator in an external modulation link.
142
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
The properties of optical fibre most likely to affect the link performance are its attenuation, nonlinearity and dispersion properties. Each of these is discussed here only briefly; for more thorough explanations of these properties, the reader is encouraged to consult the references [7 11]. 6.3.2.1 Attenuation As shown in Figure 6.3, the attenuation per unit length in standard single-mode fibre is at its absolute minimum between 0.2 and 0.3 dB/km at wavelengths near 1550 nm. Shorter wavelengths suffer from greater loss due to Rayleigh scattering, which arises from subwavelength-scale variations in the density of the fibre’s fused silica core [7]. Additionally, unless extreme care is taken to rid the fibre material of water ions to produce what is called a ‘dry’ fibre, OH absorption peaks cause much greater attenuation at and around specific wavelengths shorter than 1500 nm. Light at wavelengths longer than 1600 nm incurs significant attenuation by being absorbed and exciting vibrations in the silica crystal lattice [7]. Additionally, the radiative losses caused by fibre bends are more severe at longer wavelengths [12]. As is discussed further in later sections of this chapter, maximizing analogue optical link performance requires that the photodetector in the link be illuminated by nearly the maximum optical power that it can withstand without saturating. Therefore, the fibre attenuation can dictate a maximum length for a link that must meet the complete set or some subset of the performance requirements discussed in Section 2.6. Often, however, the other characteristics of the fibre its nonlinearity and/or its dispersion properties impose a more stringent link length limitation than the attenuation does. 6.3.2.2 Nonlinearity The two most problematic nonlinear phenomena in optical fibre are stimulated Brillouin scattering and stimulated Raman scattering. Stimulated Brillouin scattering arises because of the tendency of an intense concentration of photons to generate an acoustic wave along the fibre length, causing the refractive index of the core to be increased or decreased at the peaks and troughs of the wave. This periodic variation of the index comprises a zeroth-order grating that reflects light back in the reverse direction. The greater the optical power, the more reflective the grating that forms, and this relationship sets an upper limit on the product of the optical power and the length of transmission in the fibre. For standard telecommunications-grade fibre, stimulated Brillouin scattering sets a limit of approximately 29 mWkm [8]. The stimulated Raman scattering effect manifests itself as absorption of the photons by the silica atoms, which in turn emit new photons at an optical frequency about 17 THz lower than that of the original photons. This effect has been exploited to yield what are known as Raman fibre amplifiers, in which light injected at the higher optical frequency ‘pumps’ the silica atoms so that input photons at the lower optical frequency can stimulate the emission of more in-phase photons at this same frequency, yielding amplification of a modulated optical input. Because the threshold for stimulated Raman scattering is rather high, Raman fibre amplifiers are not as widely used as doped-fibre amplifiers (especially erbium-doped fibre amplifiers). Similarly, its high threshold makes stimulated Raman scattering a less problematic phenomenon than stimulated Brillouin scattering, imposing a less restrictive power length limitation [8].
Analogue Microwave Fibre optic Link Design
143
6.3.2.3 Dispersion Dispersion is the property that causes different components of a signal to propagate at different velocities in a waveguide, such that detection after sufficient length will result in reconstruction of a signal that is a distorted copy of the original. In fibre designed for multimode propagation at short wavelengths (850 nm), intermodal dispersion typically imposes a bandwidth length product of a few hundred MHzkm. Much greater bandwidth length products are possible in standard telecommunications-grade fibres up to 200 GHzkm or more, depending on the type of optical source (i.e. laser), its centre wavelength and linewidth and how it is modulated. No laser exists with a truly monochromatic (single optical frequency) output characteristic, and therefore the tendency for individual wavelengths within the output spectrum to propagate at different speeds (chromatic dispersion) precludes high-fidelity restoration of a signal of a given frequency beyond a certain length. This limit has been circumvented, however, by following very long lengths of standard telecom fibre in the link either with optical gratings or with specific lengths of another type of fibre specially designed to have a dispersion slope (derivative of velocity with respect to wavelength) opposite in sign to that of the telecom fibre [9,10]. The broader the laser line, the shorter this limiting distance is for a given signal frequency. For this reason, solid-state and doped-fibre lasers which have linewidths on the order of 1 kHz make better optical sources for long-haul links than do semiconductor lasers, the best of which have linewidths on the order of 10 MHz. Because solid-state and doped-fibre lasers cannot be directly modulated at high frequencies like semiconductor lasers can, external modulation is more likely to be employed in a long-haul link than is direct modulation. If a semiconductor laser is preferred as the CW source because of its much lower cost or smaller size the largest possible bandwidth-length product is enabled by a distributed-feedback (DFB) laser. Whereas mirrors supply the required optical feedback in a simple Fabry Perot laser, resulting in an output spectrum with multiple peaks, in a DFB a narrowband grating restricts the optical feedback to a narrower portion of the spectrum, resulting in an output spectrum more closely resembling that of a high-quality solid-state laser in its shape (although much broader in width). Another type of dispersion that can impose a link length limitation is polarization mode dispersion (PMD), which is caused by the birefringence in the fibre dictating different propagation velocities for the two orthogonal polarizations of light supported by the fibre. However, this is not often a serious problem for designers of analogue microwave fibre-optic links, and therefore the reader is referred elsewhere [11] for a discussion of methods for dynamic compensation to mitigate the effects of PMD.
6.3.3 What Detection Technique to Use Once the wavelength and the type of optical fibre have been selected, it is necessary to select components for generating and modulating the light at the input end of the link and detecting it at the output end. It is easier to proceed by selecting the detection technique first, because this choice may in turn limit the choice of a modulation technique, as is discussed further on in Section 6.3.9 of this chapter. At the output end of a fibre-optic link two different methods can be used to recover the analogue signal from the optical carrier it is modulating: direct detection and coherent detection. Figure 6.4 shows block diagrams of links using these two detection techniques.
Integrator
Input signal
∫
Phase modulator LO laser
Photodetector
Photodetector
Optical source
(b)
IF amplifier
Limiter
τ
Output signal
Output signal
only for phase modulation
∫
Output signal
Square-law device
[ ]2
Integrator
IF amplifier
IF amplifier
Envelope detector
Photodetector
Photodetector
Photodetector
Phase discriminator
LO laser
Intensity modulator Input signal
Intensity modulator Input signal
(a)
Optical source
Figure 6.4 Detection methods in fibre-optic links. Direct detection can recover an analogue signal that has been made to modulate the intensity of an optical carrier, whereas amplitude, phase or frequency modulation of an optical carrier can only be recovered by a process known as coherent detection. Reproduced from [13] ( 1994 IEEE)
only for frequency modulation
Optical source
or the frequency or phase of light
modulating the amplitude
can retrieve optical signals
Coherent detection
can only retrieve optical signals modulating the intensity of light
Direct detection
144 Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
Analogue Microwave Fibre optic Link Design
145
In the direct detection process of Figure 6.4(a), a photon incident upon a photodetector has a specific probability of exciting a valence-band electron into a higher-energy conduction band, and therefore a photodetector responds to a modulation of incident photon intensity with a proportional modulation of output photocurrent, provided the detection process and the device in which it occurs are both sufficiently fast. Representing the incident optical field E as E0e j(2pnt þ u), where E0, n and u, are respectively the amplitude, frequency and phase of the light, direct detection results in a photocurrent ID, where ID ¼ rd jEj2 ¼ rd E02 :
ð6:8Þ
In Equation (6.8) the proportionality constant is known as the detector’s responsivity, rd, which is expressed in A/W (although for photodetectors designed to be used in fibre-optic links, mA/mW is a more magnitude-appropriate unit ratio). Notice that the only property of the optical field to which the photodetector responds is its intensity (which is the square of its amplitude), except to the extent that rd is itself dependent on the optical frequency. Most semiconductor photodetectors can absorb photons over a very broad range of optical wavelengths and therefore direct detection is not a viable option for recovering a signal that is modulating the optical frequency; direct detection of optical phase modulation is also implausible. From a quick examination of Figure 6.4(b), which shows the hardware necessary to perform coherent detection of amplitude, frequency or phase modulation, it is clear why most analogue fibre-optic link designers choose to work with direct detection of an intensity-modulated signal. Not only is more hardware required for coherent detection, but also greater control must be exercised to stabilize the relationship between the frequencies and phases of the two lasers so that any detected change in this relationship will be only that which is induced by the modulation signal. Additionally, the signal-to-noise ratio at the output of a coherent-detection link can be degraded by the presence of optical phase noise. This means that a coherentdetection link can have inferior performance to a direct-detection link (which is immune to optical phase noise in the absence of any phenomenon that converts this into intensity noise) unless the two optical sources in the coherent-detection link both have very narrow linewidths [13]. Because of the increased cost and challenge of implementing coherent detection architectures, to the authors’ knowledge no fielded system exists at this time in which the modulation signal is retrieved from the optical carrier using one of these coherent detection techniques. Once the detection technique has been selected, the specific detector to be used in the link must be chosen as well. High-speed photodetection can be accomplished in a variety of devices, including photoconductors, phototransistors, metal semiconductor metal photodiodes, p i n photodiodes and avalanche photodiodes. The majority of fielded RF links use p i n photodiodes. InGaAs and InGaAsP p i n photodiodes respond very efficiently and quickly (as demonstrated to frequencies of > 300 GHz [14]) to light at the 1300 nm and 1550 nm wavelengths at which single-mode optical-fibre transmission has been optimized, and are therefore the most commonly selected detectors for use in analogue fibre-optic links with operating frequencies exceeding 1 GHz. For comprehensive discussions of photodetector design, the reader is referred to descriptions of state-of-the-art devices by Magnin et al. [15] and Tulchinsky et al. [16], and to comprehensive reviews of various device types by Yu [17] and Kato [18].
146
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
6.3.4 What Modulation Technique to Use At the input end of the link, an optical source generates a carrier at the desired wavelength, and a modulator imposes the analogue signal on the optical carrier. If the optical source and modulator are separate devices, the light is said to be externally modulated by the analogue electronic signal. Alternatively, the optical source and modulator can be a single device, such as a semiconductor laser, whose optical output is directly modulated by an analogue signal applied in conjunction with the DC bias current that provides the electrical pump for the laser. In a direct modulation link a semiconductor laser directly converts a small-signal modulation around a bias point set by a DC current into a corresponding small-signal modulation of the optical amplitude, frequency, phase or intensity (or, most likely, all of these) of photons emitted around the average values of these quantities that occur at the bias point. Because of the complexity and challenge involved in implementing a link in which coherent detection is used to retrieve direct modulation of the optical amplitude, frequency or phase, from this point in the chapter onwards when the terms ‘directly modulated’ or ‘direct modulation’ are used, it can be assumed that the only modulated property of the light that is detected is its intensity. The modulation bandwidth of a directly modulated semiconductor laser is limited by its relaxation resonance frequency, which in turn can be shown to be proportional to the square root of its optical output power. A 3 dB modulation bandwidth of 40 GHz has been demonstrated for a multiquantum-well laser operated at a large output power (35 mW) [19]. Another key performance parameter of a directly modulated semiconductor laser is its slope efficiency, s‘, expressed in W/A (or the more magnitude-appropriate units mW/mA); this is the efficiency with which the RF modulation current is converted to modulated optical power [6]. Figure 6.5 shows the transfer functions for the diode laser and photodetector in an intensitymodulation/direct-detection (IM/DD) link in which the laser’s optical output intensity is directly modulated with slope efficiency s‘. The detector’s slope efficiency sd shown in the figure is the same as its responsivity, rd, described in Section 6.3.3. Conversely to rd, a directly modulated laser’s ideal slope efficiency is the photon energy hc/l divided by the electron charge q. The product of s‘ and sd is the change in detector output current for a given change in laser input current; gi, the output-to-input signal power ratio for an intrinsic (i.e. without amplifier) link, is thus proportional to the square of this product. Therefore, theoretically the maximum possible gi is obtained if each electron that comprises the laser’s input current generates one photon, and if each photon reaches the detector and generates one electron-hole pair; this would correspond to (s‘sd)2 ¼ 1 [6]. Most fielded direct modulation analogue links use diode lasers designed to emit 1300 nm or 1550 nm light from the edge of the semiconductor chip. In edge emitters the optical feedback necessary to enable lasing is realized using either a Fabry Perot (FP) cavity created by end-facet mirrors or a pair of first-order Bragg gratings that achieve distributed feedback (DFB). Within the gain spectrum of the semiconductor, a DFB laser has only one longitudinal mode that is not strongly suppressed by the gratings, and therefore a single narrow line dominates its optical output spectrum; by contrast an FP laser supports many longitudinal modes within this same gain spectrum, and consequently its optical emission spectrum typically consists of several lines. The DFB’s improved spectral characteristic is usually accompanied by better noise and linearity characteristics, in addition to better fibre propagation characteristics (as explained in Section 6.3.2.3). For these reasons, most high-performance direct modulation analogue optical links use DFB semiconductor lasers.
Analogue Microwave Fibre optic Link Design
147 +
+
ID
IL
RFIn
RFOut
P0
PD Photodiode ID (mA)
PD (mW)
Diode Laser
sl (W/A)
I L (mA)
sd (A/W)
PD (A/W)
Figure 6.5 The key components of a direct modulation intensity modulation/direct detection (IM/DD) analogue fibre optic link, and the definitions of the directly modulated laser and the photodetector slope efficiencies (after [6])
The 1990s and the earliest years of the twenty-first century have seen progress in the development of lasers that emit light from the surface of the semiconductor chip, which lend themselves much more readily to automated testing and low-cost manufacturing. To date most of the work on such devices called vertical cavity surface-emitting lasers (VCSELs) has been in GaAs or AlGaAs, both of which lase at short wavelengths (800 1000 nm) where fibre characteristics are less desirable than at 1300 nm or 1550 nm. Therefore, while a VCSEL can exhibit slope efficiency as high as that of an edge emitter, and costs much less to test and to align to fibre than an edge emitter, so far this type of laser has rarely (e.g. [20, 21]) been used in highperformance links for analogue applications. For more comprehensive overviews of the present state of the art in semiconductor lasers for direct modulation links, the reader is referred to reviews by Holonyak [22], Dagli [23] and Mansuripur and Wright [24]. In an external modulation link, separate devices serve as the optical source and RF/optical modulator. As is described further on in this chapter, an external modulation link’s performance improves when the optical power supplied to the modulator is increased (up to the maximum power that the modulator or detector can handle). Because the optical source does not have to be a semiconductor laser designed for high-frequency direct modulation, one can choose instead a semiconductor laser designed for high-power CW output, or can even choose a high-power solid-state or doped-fibre laser. At most RF frequencies the noise characteristics of solid-state and doped-fibre lasers are typically preferable to those of a semiconductor laser; however, they are also typically much larger and costlier. It is possible to externally modulate the amplitude, phase or intensity of the laser’s CW output. However, using coherent detection to detect external modulation of the amplitude or
148
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
phase of the light is much more complex and challenging than direct detection of external intensity modulation; therefore from this point in the chapter onwards all discussion pertains to IM/DD links in which the intensity of light is externally modulated. At present, the type of external modulator most commonly used in analogue fibre-optic links is the Mach Zehnder interferometric (MZI) modulator. Selecting the material in which to fabricate an MZI modulator involves weighing the importance of several characteristics: absorptive loss of optical waveguides in the material, coupling loss between these waveguides and the input and output fibre pigtails, strength of the electro-optic effect in the material, stability of the material and the cost of manufacture. The low optical loss and strong electrooptic tensor of the inorganic material lithium niobate has made it the most commonly used material for MZI modulators. Since the latter half of the 1990s, however, MZI modulators have also been demonstrated in lower-cost polymeric materials [25, 26]. In addition, MZI modulators can be, and have been, fabricated in semiconductors like GaAs and InP [27, 28]. A semiconductor MZI modulator is most inexpensively integrated with a semiconductor laser source. However, the optical losses incurred coupling into and out of the semiconductor optical waveguides, and the limited optical power handling capability of both polymer and semiconductor modulators to date, have prevented the performance of links using modulators made in either of these materials from rivaling that of links using MZI modulators made in lithium niobate. In any MZI modulator, an optical waveguide is fashioned close to the top surface of the material, and between the input and output edge of the substrate this waveguide is made to split into two waveguides that run in parallel for a given length and then recombine into one waveguide. In the middle section the two parallel optical waveguides traverse a region in which an applied electric field changes the phase of the light in one of the waveguides relative to the other, affecting the interferometric recombination of these two guided waves. The electric field, and therefore the modulator’s optical output, is modulated by the small-signal RF modulation voltage across a set of electrodes on the surface of the substrate. The electro-optic effect, by which an applied electric field changes the phase shift incurred by an optical wave propagating through a material, can also be exploited to achieve optical intensity modulation in devices other than an MZI modulator. Interferometric conversion of the phase modulation to intensity modulation can also be accomplished in a Fabry Perot cavity or other type of optically resonant structure [29]. Additionally, guide/antiguide structures [30] can be realized in such a way that the electro-optic effect determines how much light is coupled out of the waveguide and therefore also how much of the light remains guided. Neither resonant interferometric nor guide/antiguide modulators, however, have matured to the point of commercial availability. Presently a commercial alternative to the MZI modulator is the electro-absorption modulator (EAM), in which an applied electric field affects the output intensity by shifting the optical absorption band edge in a semiconductor via either the Franz Keldysh effect or the quantumconfined Stark effect. Much of the interest in EAMs stems from their potential for low-cost integration with semiconductor laser sources. A number of electro-absorption-modulated laser (EML) products have become commercially available. It is possible to derive a slope efficiency for external modulators analogous to that of a directly-modulated laser. In an external modulation fibre-optic link, gi is proportional to the square of the product of the small-signal slope efficiencies of the external modulator and the detector. As shown on the transfer function for the modulator in Figure 6.6, the modulator’s
Analogue Microwave Fibre optic Link Design
149 +
+
ID
V RFIn
RFOut
P0
CW Laser PD
PI
Photodiode
PD /PI
ID (mA)
Mach-Zehnder Modulator
sd (A/W)
sm (W/A)
Vπ
PD (A/W)
V
Figure 6.6 The key components of an external modulation IM/DD analogue fibre optic link, and the definitions of the external modulator and the photodetector slope efficiencies (after [6])
slope efficiency sm is the change in its optical output power for a given change in input current. Specifically, dpM;O ðvM Þ ; ð6:9Þ sm dv m
vm ¼0
where PM,O is the modulator’s output optical power, which is a function of vM, the total voltage on the modulator, which is in turn the sum of a DC bias voltage VM and the modulation signal voltage vm. If the modulator’s transfer function (i.e. the mathematical relationship between its output optical power and input voltage) is known, Equation (6.9) can be used to derive a useful expression for sm. An MZI modulator, for example, has the transfer function: TFF PI p vM 1 þ cos pM;O ¼ ; ð6:10Þ 2 Vp where TFF is the modulator’s fibre-to-fibre optical insertion loss, PI is the CW optical power supplied to its input fibre, and Vp is the voltage change necessary to shift the optical phase in one of the ‘arms’ of the interferometer by p radians relative to the other (and therefore to switch between completely constructive and completely deconstructive interference at the modulator output, see Figure 6.6). Remembering that vM ¼ VM þ vm, substituting (6.10) into (6.9) yields: p TFF PI RM p VM ; ð6:11Þ sm ¼ sin 2 Vp Vp where a factor RM equal to the modulator’s resistance has been included to yield the same dimensions for sm as those of the direct modulation slope efficiency s‘ (i.e. W/A).
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
150
Equation (6.11) shows that the MZI modulator’s slope efficiency is a function of its DC bias voltage VM, and is maximum at the so-called ‘quadrature’ bias voltage VM ¼ Vp/2. Also notice from Equation (6.11) that one can increase the modulator slope efficiency by increasing PI, such that it is theoretically possible to achieve (smsd)2 > 1 so that the intrinsic link gain Gi can exceed 0 dB. Practical considerations such as the size and cost of high-power lasers and the damage threshold of the modulator, the fibre and the photodetector preclude increasing PI indefinitely, of course, but at l ¼ 1300 nm PI values as high as 400 mW have been successfully fed through a lithium niobate MZI modulator, resulting in Gi > 30 dB [31]. Besides increasing PI, another way to increase sm is to reduce Vp. In general, one way to reduce the Vp of an MZI modulator, or its equivalent on off switching voltage in another type of modulator, is to lengthen the region in which the optical and applied electrical fields interact. However, as this interaction length increases it becomes more likely that at the analogue frequencies of interest the modulation voltage cannot be approximated as constant during an optical transit time through this region. Therefore, to maximize modulation efficiency at microwave signal frequencies, the electrodes are typically fashioned in a travelling-wave configuration so that the analogue modulation signal propagates along a transmission line in parallel to the optical waveguides. The highest-frequency external modulation link results have been achieved when the microwave-frequency propagation velocity in the travelling-wave electrode structure has been tailored to be approximately equal to the velocity of the light in the optical waveguides [32]. For comprehensive overviews of the present state of the art in external modulators, the reader is referred to reviews by Zhou and Taylor [33], Li et al. [34] and Dagli [23].
6.3.5 How to Interface to the Link Input and Output Ports Section 6.3.4 has outlined the effect of device slope efficiencies sl for a directly modulated laser, sm for an external modulator and sd for a photodetector on an IM/DD link’s intrinsic gain, gi, and the equations in Section 6.2 showed the effect of this one parameter on nearly all the other important figures of merit that quantify analogue link performance. Specifically, it was shown that 2 s2d gi / s2‘ TL-D
2 or s2m TM-D s2d ;
ð6:12Þ
where the two different products of squared quantities are appropriate to direct and external modulation links, respectively, and where the terms TL-D and TM-D have been included to represent the ratios of optical power illuminating the detector to the optical power that is coupled into the output fibre pigtail of the directly modulated laser or external modulator, respectively. The products of quantities in Equation (6.12) represent squared ratios of signal current from the photodetector relative to signal current into the external modulator or directly modulated laser. Because the gain is defined as the ratio of output to input microwave signal powers (see Equation (6.1a)) rather than the squared ratio of signal currents in the devices, the missing proportionality factor in Equation (6.12) is a ratio of impedances. The exact value of this ratio depends on the types of circuits that are used to interface these devices to the link input and output ports. Figure 6.7 shows equations for direct and external modulation link gi that result from the four combinations of photodetector and external modulator or directly modulated laser interface
Resistive matching circuit
Interface from link input port to external modulator or directly modulated laser
Signal source
RS
Source resistance
Signal source
RS
Source resistance
RS
Signal modulation current
Lossless, passive impedance transformer
RS
Signal modulation current
Modulation device impedance
Modulation device impedance
in
ga
Impedance matching resistor
sic
rin
Int
or sm2 TM2 − D sd2
g i = sl2 TL2− D sd2
or sm2 TM2 − D sd2
g i = sl2 TL2− D sd2
Detector impedance
Signal photocurrent
RLOAD RM
RLOAD RL
RLOAD RS
RLOAD RS
Load resistance
R LOAD
No matching circuit
or sm2 TM2 − D sd2
g i = sl2 TL2− D sd2
or sm2 TM2 − D sd2
RLOAD 4 RM
RLOAD 4 RL
RLOAD 4 RS
RLOAD 4 RS
R LOAD
Impedance matching resistor
g i = sl2 TL2− D sd2
Detector impedance
Signal photocurrent
Resistive matching circuit
Load resistance
R LOAD
Figure 6.7 Equations for direct and external modulation link gi that result from four combinations of photodetector and external modulator or directly modulated laser interface circuits
Lossless, passive impedance transformation circuit
Interface from photodetector to link output
Analogue Microwave Fibre optic Link Design 151
Microwave Photonics: Devices and Applications
152
circuits that are most relevant to the types of photodetectors, modulators and directly modulated lasers presently available and most suitable for use in RF-frequency analogue fibre-optic links. In the case of the circuit that interfaces the photodetector to the link output port, the most common situations are illustrated by the two circuit diagrams across the top of Figure 6.7. The type of photodetector most commonly employed in high-frequency IM/DD links is a reversebiased p i n photodiode, which has a very large impedance that is dominated at low RF frequencies by its depletion region’s large capacitive reactance. Therefore, attaching the detector directly to the output port of the link causes the detected signal photocurrent to act effectively as a current source driving the link’s output load impedance (typically 50 W) without the need for interface circuitry. The commercial manufacturers of high-speed photodetectors, however, commonly include a 50-W matching resistor in parallel to the photodetector, because this tends to yield a packaged device frequency response that is flatter (relative to the ‘no matching circuit’ case) all the way from low frequencies through to high microwave frequencies at which parasitic resistances and reactances can exceed the magnitude of the depletion region’s capacitive reactance. Comparing the left-hand column in Figure 6.7 to the right-hand column, it can be seen that the penalty that comes with the flatter frequency response of the ‘resistive matching circuit’ case is a factor of four reduction in gi (or 6 dB reduction in Gi) relative to the ‘no matching circuit’ case. In the case of the interface circuit between the link input port and either the external modulator or the directly modulated laser in an IM/DD link, the most common situations are illustrated by the two circuit diagrams along the left-hand edge of Figure 6.7. The forwardbiased semiconductor diode lasers used in direct modulation links typically have a resistance RL of only a few ohms, and therefore the easiest method for achieving a broadband impedance match between the laser and the source resistance RS is to connect them via a resistor with resistance equal to RS RL. In this case, as shown in the top row in Figure 6.7, the intrinsic direct modulation link’s gain gi is simply the squared ratio of output to input currents as shown in Equation (6.12), multiplied by the ratio of output load to input source impedances in the case of no detector matching circuit, or one-fourth of this value in the case of a resistive matching circuit in the detector package, that is 2 s2d gi ¼ s2‘ TL-D
RLOAD RS
or
2 gi ¼ s2‘ TL-D s2d
RLOAD ; 4 RS
ð6:13Þ
respectively. Equation (6.13) is further simplified in the most common case where RLOAD ¼ RS ¼ 50 W, so that RLOAD/RS ¼ 1. Higher direct modulation link gain can be achieved across any band over which the impedance match between RL and RS can be accomplished using a passive impedance transformer, provided the transformer has negligibly small resistive loss. At any frequency where a ‘perfect’ match is achieved, if the transformer is approximately without loss, then, as is shown in the bottom two equation boxes