MINIMAL FLOWS AND THElR EXTENSlONS
NORTH-HOLLAND MATHEMATICS STUDIES Notas de Matematica (122)
Editor: Leopoldo Nachbin Centro Brasileiro de Pesquisas Fisicas Rio de Janeiro and University of Rochester
NORTH-HOLLAND -AMSTERDAM
NEW YORK
OXFORD .TOKYO
153
MINIMAL FLOWS AND THEIR EXTENSIONS
Joseph AUSIANDER Department of Mathematics University of Maryland CollegePark MD 20742 U.S.A.
1988
NORTH-HOLLAND -AMSTERDAM
0
NEW YORK
0
OXFORD
TOKYO
Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., 1988
All rights reserved. No part of this publications may be reproduced, stored in a retrievalsystem, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner.
ISBN: 044470453 1
Publishers:
ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHERS B.V. P.O. BOX 1991 1000 BZ AMSTERDAM THE NETHERLAND
Sole distributors for the U S A . and Canada:
ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHING COMPANY, INC. 52 VAN DER BI LT AVENUE NEW YORK, N.Y. 10017 U.S.A.
Library of Congress Cataloging4n-PublicationData Auslander, Joseph, 1930Minimal flows and their extensions. (North-Holland mathematics studies ; 153) (Notas de matedtica ; 122) Bibliography: p. 1. Topological dynamics. I. Title. 11. Series. 111. Series: Notas de matemztica (Rio de Janeiro, Brazil) ; no. 122. QAl.N86 no. 122 iQA611.51 510 s 15141 88-1 51 14 ISBN 0-444-70453-1 ( U . S . )
PRINTED IN THE NETHERLANDS
V
Introduction In this monograph, I present certain developments in the abstract theory of topological dynamics, with emphasis on the study of minimal flows and their extensions. The main theme is the internal structure of minimal flows and the relations among different minimal flows, rather than such questions as their location and stability as subsets of a larger flow (which arise in those areas of topological dynamics which are inspired by the qualitative theory of differential equations). By a
flow we
mean the jointly continuous action of a topological
group on a compact Hausdorff space. A minimal subset of a flow is one which is "dynamically indecomposable" - a closed invariant set which contains no proper closed invariant non-empty subsets.
If the space itself
is minimal under the action of the group, we call it a minimal flow. Almost by definition, the aim of the subject is the classification and construction of all minimal flows. This has been achieved only in the case of equicontinuous minimal flows, and we study these in detail. A fruitful way of looking at minimal flows in general is to consider how
they are related to equicontinuous flows, and we investigate some classes of flows which are "close" to the equicontinuous ones.
Most notable
among these are the distal minimal flows, the study of which culminates in the beautiful structure theorem of H. Furstenberg. This leads to the study of distality, and its opposite, proximality, in arbitrary minimal flows, and also has inspired more general structure theorems. If the "objects" of topological dynamics are the flows, the "morphisms" are the continuous equivariant maps - the homomorphisms (or
Introduction
vi
extensions).
Most of the notions of topological dynamics can be
"relativized" - one speaks of distal and proximal extensions for instance. Indeed, the relative notions are essential in formulating and proving the structure theorems in the subject. Another major theme in this book is what might be called the "universal" approach. That is, we study entire classes of minimal flows, rather than flows in isolation. An important concept in this direction is disjointness, which is a kind of independence condition. For example, we show that the weakly mixing minimal flows are precisely those which are disjoint from every equicontinuous minimal flow. This approach is also exemplified by the use of the universal minimal flow, of which every minimal flow is a factor, and which acts on every minimal flow.
As was mentioned earlier, the theory is developed in the context of the action of an arbitrary group on a compact Hausdorff space. However, in some cases (the Furstenberg structure theorem, the equicontinuous structure relation, and disjointness) it is assumed in addition that the phase space is metrizable and/or that the flow admits an invariant measure. Chapter 13 pursues a topic which is somewhat apart from the main development of the book.
It is devoted to a remarkable theorem of
Kakutani which shows that a large class of (real) flows can be represented as flows on a function space. Some generalizations to other acting groups are also presented. Examples of minimal flows, which, as in all branches of mathematics, indicate the boundaries of the theory and suggest general theorems, are woven into the theoretical development. In most cases in the examples the acting group is the integers (powers of a single homeomorphism) o r the real numbers (a one parameter flow).
Introduction
vii
The book should be accessible to a student who has had courses in real analysis (including the elements of functional analysis) and general topology. I have included appendices on uniform spaces and convergence in topology (by means of nets) since these topics are unfortunately no longer included in elementary graduate education in the United States. Of course, I have been influenced by and am indebted to many books on topological dynamics. A bibliography follows this introduction. The monograph of Nemytskii and the book of Nemytskii and Stepanov are important early contributions and contain much material which is related t o stability theory of differential equations. The A . M . S . Colloquium volume of Gottschalk and Hedlund on which the author was "raised" as a graduate student, develops the notation which is used in the present work and played a significant role in the development of the subject. The monograph of Ellis, which appeared in 1970, was an extremely important contribution, and treats many of the same topics as we do, but from a somewhat uncompromising algebraic viewpoint. The book of Bronstein also covers much of the same ground as the present work.
The more specialized
monographs of Glasner and Furstenberg should also be mentioned. The latter, in particular, is a tour de force in which topological dynamics and ergodic theory are applied to obtain deep results in combinatorial number theory. Finally, a number of books in ergodic theory, notably those of Parry, Petersen, Walters, and Denker, Grillenberger and Sigmund, contain substantial amounts of material on topological dynamics.
I was introduced to topological dynamics by Professor Walter Gottschalk over thirty years ago.
Iwthe course of writing this book, I
have received help from many individuals.
Among those who made sugges-
tions, answered questions or read parts of the manuscript are Ken Berg, Ethan Coven, Gertrude Ehrlich, Elie Glasner. Jonathan King, the late
Introduction
viii
Doug McMahon, Bill Parry, Jonathan Rosenberg, Jaap van der Woude, and Jim Yorke. Special thanks are due to Nelson Markley, who read several chapters, suggested a number of changes and additions, and supplied firm but constructive criticism. Professor Leopoldo Nachbin invited me to contribute this monograph to the prestigious series "Notas de Matematica." I owe him many thanks for his encouragement and patience during its preparation. The technical typists at the University of Maryland, Kristi Aho, Virginia Sauber, and Stephanie Smith capably produced the camera ready manuscript and cheerfully endured my many changes and corrections. Jim Hummel helped with a typographical problem.
I would also like to thank
the editorial staff at North Holland Press for their cooperation.
I have two further acknowledgements. The first is to the profound influence of Robert Ellis. More than any other individual, Bob is responsible for the development of the subject of topological dynamics. Among h i s many contributions which appear in this book are the enveloping semigroup, the joint continuity theorem, and several of the structure theorems for minimal flows. But of greater than o r equal importance to his specific contributions is Bob's insistence that topological dynamics is a theory, and not merely a collection of techniques.
I hope that this
point of view manifests itself in the present work. Finally, I want to thank my dear friend Barbara Meeker for her love and support. ThAs was expressed by a skillful and judicious combination of encouragement and prodding, which provided me with the self confidence to complete this work. J . Auslander College Park, MD January, 1988
USA
Bibliography 1.
J. Auslander, L. Green, and F. Hahn, Flows on.homogeneousspaces, Ann. of Math. Studies, no. 53, Princeton Univ. Press, 1963.
2.
I . U . Bronstein, Extensions of minimal transformation groups, Sitjthoff and Noordhoff, 1979, (Russian edition, 1975).
3.
M. Denker, C. Grillenberger, K. Sigmund, Eraodic theory on compact spaces, Lecture Notes in Mathematics, vol. 527, Sprin’ger-Verlag, 1976.
4.
R. Ellis, Lectures in topological dynamics, Benjamin, 1969.
5.
H. Furstenberg, Recurrence in ernodic theory and combinatorial number theory, Princeton Univ. Press, 1981.
6.
S. Glasner, Proximal flows, Lecture Notes in Mathematics, vol. 517,
Springer-Verlag, 1976. 7.
W.H. Gottschalk and G.A. Hedlund, Topological dynamics, Amer. Math. SOC. Colloq. Publ. vol. 36, 1955.
8.
V.V. Nemytskii, Topological problems in the theory of dynamical systems, Uspehi. Math. Nauk. 5 (19491, Amer. Math. SOC.Translation, ~
no. 103 (1954). 9.
V. V. Nemytskii and V. V. Stepanov, Qua1 itat ive theory of differential eauat ions, Princeton Univ. Press, 1960 (Russian edit ion, 1949).
10
W. Parry, Topics in ernodic theory, Cambridge Univ. Press, 1981.
11
K. Petersen, Ergodic Theory, Cambridge Univ. Press, 1983.
12
W. A. Veech, Topological ‘dynamics,Bull. Amer. Math.
SOC. 83, 775-830
(1977). 13.
P. Walters, Lectures in ergodic theory, Lecture Notes in Mathematics, vol. 458, Springer-Verlag. 1975.
14.
J. C.S.P. van der Woude, Topological dynamix, Mathematische Centrum, Amsterdam, 1982.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
xi
Contents Introduction
V
Bibliography
ix 1
Chapter 1
Flows and Minimal S e t s
Chapter 2
E q u i c o n t i n u o u s Flows
35
Chapter 3
The E n v e l o p i n g Semigroup o f a T r a n s f o r m a t i o n Group, I
49
Chapter 4
J o i n t C o n t i n u i t y Theorems
57
Chapter 5
D i s t a l Flows
65
Chapter 6
The E n v e l o p i n g Semigroup, I1
83
Chapter 7
The F u r s t e n b e r g S t r u c t u r e Theorem f o r Distal Minimal Flows
95
Chapter 8
U n i v e r s a l Minimal Flows and Ambits
115
Chapter 9
The E q u i c o n t i n u o u s S t r u c t u r e R e l a t i o n and Weakly Mixing Flows
125
Chapter
The A l g e b r a i c Theory of Minimal Flows
137
Chapter
Disjointness
149
Chapter
I n v a r i a n t Measures o n Flows
169
C h a p t e r 13
Kakutani-Bebutov Theorems
183
C h a p t e r 14
G e n e r a l S t r u c t u r e Theorems
195
Appendix I
Nets
253
Appendix I1
Uniform S p a c e s
259
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
1
Chapter 1 Flows and Minimal Sets Topological dynamics may be regarded as the study of "long term" or "asymptotic" properties of families of self maps of spaces.
In most
cases of interest, the collection of maps is a group under composition. The natural setting is that of a transformation group. 1.
Definition. A transformation group is a triple
is a topological spac'e, continuous map of
X
x
(X.T,n) where
T is a topological group, and n
X
is a
T to X, satisfying
(i)
n(x,e) = x
(x E X, e the identity of T)
(ii)
n(n(x,s),t) = n(x,st)
(x
E
X, s , t E TI.
A synonym for transformation group is flow, - and we will mostly use the
latter term. X
is called the -phase space and T
the phase group or --
act ing group. -Each t E T defines a continuous map
t (x) = n(x,t).
71
nt
of X
to X
by
If t,s E T, it is immediate that nSnt = nts; in e
,
the identity map of X, so each nt t -1 = nt -1 . homeomorphism of X onto itself, with ( n ) particular ntnt-' =
IZ
With occasional exceptions, we will suppress the map and just write on" x
xt
in X to obtain another point
flow appear as:
We regard t
in place of n(x,t).
the map
(x,t)Hxt
xt
in X.
II
is a
notational y,
in T as "act ng
Thus the axioms for a
is continuous, xe = x, and
(xslt = x(st). We will usually write
(X,T) (or just X,
if the group T is
understood) for a flow. What we have defined as a transformation group could be called a right
chapter I
2
transformation group (or right flow). flow
(p,C,X) or
Of course, we could define a left
(C,X) in the obvious way. p
g(hx) = (ghlx, etc.
If
T can be defined by
tx = xt
:
GxX~X, p(g,x) = gx,
(X,T) is a (right) flow, then a left action of -1
.
For the most part, we will be concerned with right flows. However, we
will sometimes encounter a situation where we have two group actions on a space. A bitransformation group mation group (gxlt = g(xt) every t E TI.
(G,X,T) consists of a right transfor-
(X,T) and a left transformation group
(x
E
X, g E G, t E TI
Thus we may write
( s o every
(C,X) such that
g E G
"commutes" with
gxt unambiguously.
We will always suppose the phase space X of a flow is Hausdorff this is a standing assumption. (Of course, in any constructions we carry out, o r examples we present, the Hausdorff property must be verified; this will usually be trivial.) In fact, the theory which we will develop
is for actions of groups on compact Hausdorff spaces, but we will not assume compactness for the time being. As for the group
T; it can be abelian or non-abelian, although
almost all of our examples are of the former. It is not to be compact,
or act in a compact manner.
While actions of compact groups (indeed,
even of finite groups) are important in many branches of mathematics ( f o r example. parts of topology and differential geometry), in our subject compact group actions are "dynamically trivial." The Justification for this assertion will emerge as we proceed.
In general, we will identify an element t of X
T with the homeomorphism
E
it defines (nt in our original riotation). Thus T may be
regarded as a subgroup of the total homeomorphism group of X. course, it is possible that distinct elements s the same homeomorph'ism: xs = xt
for all x
E
X.
and
Of
t of T define
The action of T
is
Flows and Minimal Sets
called effective if this does not occur for some x E X.
--
3
t
i.e., if
#
e, then xt
This is only a minor technical problem.
is not effective, let F = [t E Tlxt = x for all x E XI. closed (since X group T/F
#
x
If the action Then F
is a
is Hausdorff) normal subgroup of T, The quotient
acts on X by
x(Ft) = xt, and this action is clearly
effect ve. Therefore, we can assume that the action of T
on X
is
effect ive. Moreover, the topology of the group is really not that important. We are interested in the action of a group of homeomorphisms on a topological space, and the given topology on the group is for most purposes irrelevant. For this reason, we will frequently assume that T has the discrete topology.
(Some of our definitions will apparently
depend on the topology of T, but we will show that they are in fact indepenae..t of it. ) The most intensively studied cases have been where the acting group T is Z
or R
respectively). of X
(the additive groups of integers and real numbers, If T = a ,
and cpn(xl = xn.
iterate of cp
cpfx) = xl.
let
(As usual, if
-1 n and cp-” = ( c p 1 1.
Then cp
n > 0, cpn
is a homeomorphism
denotes the nth
Conversely, if cp
is a self
homeomorphism of X, it defines an action of Z as above.
is effective if and only if We will refer to the pair
(pn
f
identity, for a1
(X,cp)
as a cascade.
n
*
(The action
0.1
(Other terms in use
are discrete flow - and discrete dynamical system.) Thus a cascade consists of a homeomorphism and its powers. use the letter T for a homeomorphism
--
(Warn ng:
we will sometimes
in this case we will always
refer to the ”cascade (X,T).”) If T = R,
then the action defines a one-parameter group of
homeomorphisms (9,) of the space X.
and in this case we write cpt(x)
Chapter 1
4
instead of xt.
The axioms appear as cpo(x) = x and
cps(cpt(x)) = cpS+,(x).
Customary terms for an R
system, real flow, and continuous - --
action are dynamical
flow.
It is admittedly somewhat inconsistent for us to write the generating homeomorphism of a Z
action, as well as the action of R,
on the left
However, this corresponds to the usual practice in the subject. The classical example of an R
action is the one defined by the
solutions of autonomous systems of differential equations. Let D be a region in Fin,
= f(x),
and consider the system
where f
:
D+Rn
and f satisfies conditions sufficient to guarantee that solutions exist, are unique, depend continuously on initial conditions, and are defined and remain in D for all real t. define =
f(x)
If xo
E
D and t
E IR,
t(xo ) = u(x 0't) where a(xO,*) denotes the solution of
cp
for which a(x , O ) = xo. Let xo
yo = cpt(xO). Let
0
$(s)
= cps+t(~O)
E
D, s,t E
= u(xo,t+s).
Then
R, $(s)
and let is a solu-
tion satisfying $(O) = yo, so by uniqueness $ ( s ) = a(yo,s) = cp (yo). S
Then 'P,+~(X~)= $(sl = cps(yo) = cps(cpt(xo)). other conditions (continuity of
Thus 'P,+~ = 'Ps'Pt. The
( x O , t ) ~ ctp(xo 1 and cpo = identity)
are obvious, so we do indeed have an R
action on D.
The observation that the solutions of an autonomous system define a flow motivated much of the early work in topological dynamics. It is possible to define and discuss many of the notions in the qualitative theory of differential equations in purely "topological dynamics" terms, but this is not the direction which we w i l l pursue in this monograph. (This point of view is developed in the books "Qualitative Theory of Differential Equations" by V. V. Nemytskii and V. V. Stepanov (Princeton University Press, 1960) and "Stability Theory of Dynamical Systems" by N. P. Bhatia and
C.
P. Szego (Springer-Verlag, 1970).)
Flows and Minimal Sets
5
Before proceeding with the development of the theory, let us briefly mention some variations of the concept of a flow. An obvious modification is to replace the acting group by a semigroup. In the case of H, the additive semigroup of positive integers, this corresponds to the study of the iterates of a continuous (in general non-invertible) map of a space.
The study of the dynamics of maps of a
closed interval is currently an extremely active research area.
(See
2. Nitecki, "Topological dynamics on the interval," Ergodic Theory and
Dynamical Systems, Progress in Mathematics, Vol. 21, Birkhauser, 1979.) If
cp :
X+X
is a continuous map of a compact space, it can be
"converted" to a homeomorphism by an "inverse limit" construction. Let
XL
denote the space of 2-sided sequences of elements of X, with the
product topology, and let
2
denote the subset of 'X
1 = x those sequences x = (x 1 for which cp(x i i+l i easily from the compactness of X that Let
:
i+?
be defined by
is a homeomorphism of
2.
(p(x) = x',
%
consisting of
It follows
(i E Z ) .
is a non-empty compact space.
where xi = cp(xi).
Then
Using this device it is possible to obtain
certain dynamical results for continuous maps by first proving them for homeomorphisms.
(See H. Furstenberg "Recurrence in Ergodic Theory
and Combinatorial Number Theory," Princeton University Press. ) Another object which has been studied is a "partial flow" or "local (semi) dynamical system," which is a generalization of real actions. this case, n
is a "partial" map of XxR
to X.
That is, n
defined on an open subset of XxR. Thus, if x E X, n(x,t) for t
in an interval Ix
cases 0 I ax), they are defined
- (ax,px)
(--OD 6
ax
< p,
5
00,
In
is
is defined
or in some
and the usual axioms for a flow are satisfied insofar as (so
n(n(x,t).s)
= n(x,t+s)
if the left side is
defined). These arise from autonomous systems of differential equations
Chapter 1
6
for which the solutions are not defined for all real
t
("finite escape
time") and also from functional differential equations with time lag. (See N. P. Bhatia and 0. HaJek "Local Semi-Dynamical Systems," Lecture Notes in Mathematics, 90, Springer-Verlag, 1969. Now we proceed with the discussion of flows. Let
(X,T) be a flow,
let K be a subset of X, and B a subset of T. We write Kl3 the set
[xblx E K, b
E
Bl.
is called the orbit of x.
notation O(x)
If x
E
If T = H
for the orbit of x.
for
X, the set xT = {x)T = [xtlt E TI or
IR
we will frequently use the
(In these cases, the term
trajectory is sometimes used. 1 The subset K of X (equivalently KT c K).
is said to be invariant if KT = K Thus a set is invariant if and only if it is a
union of orbits. The proof of the fo lowing proposition is immediate. 2. Proposition.
K be an nvariant set. Then the closure, complement,
( i ) Let
boundary, and interior of K are all invariant sets. ( i i ) If
{K,)
is a family of invariant sets, then u KO, and n KO!
are invariant.
It follows from this proposition that if x
E
X,
the orbit -closure
3 is invariant. There are several standard ways of obtaining new flows from given ones. The first is trivial, but nevertheless very useful. Let be a flow and let 2 be an invariant subset of X interest 2 is also closed). "subflow" of
(X.T).
Then T acts on 2 ;
Secondly, if
(with the same acting group TI,
(Xa,T1 ( a E A )
(X,T)
( i n most cases of we say
(2,T) is a
is a family of flows
then T acts on the product space
Flows and Minimal Sets
7
TI Xa by acting on each coordinate: if x = (xa), then (xt),, = x t. a
a
We write
(nXa,T) for this product flow. a
In later chapters, we will
consider "large" products (i. e. , with uncountably many factors Xa).
In
this case, the product space is not metrizable, even if all the factors are. For this reason, we will not in general assume that the phase space is metrizable in our development of the theory. Another construction, using,equivalence relations on the phase space, will be discussed later in the chapter, in connection with homomorphisms of flows. Now we are ready to define minimal sets, the study of which is the main focus of this monograph.
(X,T) be a flow. A subset M of X is a -minimal set if M
Let
closed. non-empty and invariant, and if M these properties.
or N = 4 . )
N = M
(That is, if N c M
is
has no proper subsets with
with N
closed invariant, then
Note that a non-empty subset M
of X
is minimal if
and only if it is the orbit closure of each of its points. For, if M is mimimal and x E M, non-empty so
= M.
-
its orbit closure xT
is closed invariant and
On the other hand, if M
is not minimal, let
4 * N $ M with N closed invariant. Then, if x -
xT
*
E
N,
c
N
so
M.
Thus every point of a minimal set "generates" it.
Minimal sets are
also called "minimal orbit closures."
It is possible - and this is the case which will be of most interest that
(X,T) is itself minimal (equivalently X =
this case
(X,T) (or X)
3
for all x E XI.
In
is called a minimal transformation group or
minimal flow. ~Since the intersection of closed invariant sets is closed invariant,
Chapter 1
8
we immediately obtain Proposition. Let
3.
(X,T) be a flow and let M I
subsets of X. Then MI = Mz
or
MI
n b$ =
and Mz
be minimal
4.
It is not in general the case that X is a union of minimal sets. However, as we now show, minimal sets always exist when the phase space is compact. 4. Theorem. Let
(X,T) be a flow with compact Hausdorff phase space
X. Then X contains a minimal set. Proof. Let M denote the class of non-empty closed invariant subsets of X. Note that X
{Ma) M
*
E
M,
so
M
f
4.
Partially order A by inclusion. If
is a totally ordered subfamily of
= n
MU
f
4,
M, then by compactness of X,
and clearly it is closed invariant, so
M
* E
M.
Thus by
Zorn’s lemma, 1 contains a minimal element, which is a minimal subset
x.
of
Thus if the phase space of a flow is compact, it always contains a minimal subset.
(We will see later that this is not the case if only
local compactness is assumed.) It is not necessarily the case that a minimal subset of a flow is “interesting.“ minimal set is a fixed point of the flow -x t = x for all 0 0’
t
E
--
An example of a “trivial“ a point x0 such that
T. (Synonyms -- especially when T = R -- are
rest point, equilibrium point and stationary point.) Obviously the --
is a minimal set. Another simple example -- in case
singleton tx,)
T=
Z
and cp
the generating homeomormorphism
--
is a periodic orbit
that is, the orbit of a point xo for which (pp(xo) = xo is the smallest such positive integer) ~(x,) =
ZZQ =
{x,,(p(x,~,
--
(where p > I
so
. . . ,cpP-l(xo~) is minimal.
Similarly, if {pt) defines an action of R on X, and x
E
X is
Flows and Minimal Sets
not a fixed point of the flow, but cp
S
(XI
=
9
x for some
*
s
is called a periodic point, and its orbit O(x) = {cpt(x)) orbit. The minimum T of those
s
> 0 such that
cp
s
(XI
0, then x
is a periodic = x
is called
the period of x, and it is easily seen that O(x) = {cpt(x) (0 I t < and so is homeomorphic to a circle. (Note that the set F of which cp,(x)
= x
is a closed subgroup of
and since F
R
smallest positive element T and F = {ntln
E
f
for
s
R,
T},
F has a
H).)
Fixed points and periodic orbits are sometimes referred to as "trivial" minimal sets.
(Periodic orbits can be defined for arbitrary
acting groups -- see exercise 3.) Throughout the book, we will be presenting examples of "non-trivial"minimal sets, mostly for acting groups Z
and R.
It is perhaps now appropriate to explain our point of view concerning minimal sets. We have referred to fixed points and periodic orbits as "trivial" minimal sets. Of course, there are many circumstances in mathematics in which a group acts on a space and one wishes to determine whether there is a fixed point or a periodic orbit (the latter is a fundamental question in differential equations), and the answers to such questions are often decidedly "non-trivial." However, our main concern in this monograph is with the internal structure of the minimal sets themselves and the relations among them, and from this point of view there is not too much which can be said about fixed points and periodic orbits.
In this connection, the following theorem is of interest. 5. Theorem. Let
(X,T) be a flow with T = Z or IR and X Hausdorff.
Then an orbit is compact if and only if it is periodic. Proof. Obviously, a periodic orbit is compact. Suppose T = IR, usual, the action of R
is denoted by {cp,).
and as
Let x E X with O(x)
Chapter I
10
compact, so we may suppose X = O(x). Kx = [cpt(x) It E K].
and write
Then there is a countable subset C of IR
u cpc(Kx).
that X = O(x) =
Let K = [-1,11,
such
By the Baire category theorem, some cpc(Kx)
ccc
has non-empty interior, so pT(x) R
int(Kx).
E
has non-empty interior. Let z E K with
Kx
Suppose cpt(x)
x for all t
#
onto X defined by d t ) = cpt(x)
*
0. Then the map
is a continuous bijection.
a of
If
(r
were a homeomorphism, the compact space O(x) = X would be homeomorphic with R,
which is impossible. So a is not a homeomorphism, and it
follows easily that there is a sequence cpt (x)+(pT(x).
Since cp,(x)
E
k
s c K with cpt ( x ) = cps(x),
{tk)+m
(or
-m)
with
int(Kx1, there is some tk > 1 and O(x)
so
is periodic. This completes the
k
and we omit the easy proof for T = Z.
proof for T = R,
Now we will develop an important "recursive" concept. Let T be a topological group. A subset A of T there is a compact subset of K of
T = AK
(=
If T
[akla E A, k
= Z
or R ,
relatively dense Let
--
E
is said to be (left) syndetic if
T such that
K1).
a subset of T is syndetic if and only if it is that is, it does not contain arbitrarily large gaps.
(X,T) be a flow, and let x c X.
We say that x
periodic point if for every neighborhood U of x,
is an almost
there is a syndetic
subset A of T such that xA c U. Almost periodicity is a strong form of recurrence
--
the orbit returns
to an arbitrary neighborhood infinitely often. We omit the definition of recurrent for general acting groups T Chapter 7 ) .
For an action {pt) of R,
(see Gottschalk and Hedlund, a point x
is recurrent if and
only if, for every neighborhood U of X and z > 0, there is a t with
It1 > z such that cpt(xl
E
U. The definition is similar for H
E
R
Flows and Minimal Sets
11
act ions. As Gottschalk has remarked, a point is periodic if it returns to
itself every hour on the hour and is almost periodic if it returns to an arbitrary neighborhood every hour within the hour (where the length of the "hour" depends on the neighborhood1. Almost periodic points and minimal sets are intimately related, as the following results show. (X,T) be a flow, with X
6. Lemma. Let
Then, if x
locally compact Hausdorff.
is an almost periodic point, the orbit closure
3
is
compact. Proof. Let U be a compact neighborhood of x, and let
A = [t
Tlxt
E
E
Ul. Since x
is almost periodic, there is a compact
subset K of T such that T = AK. Thus xT = xAK c UK,
which is
compact, so ZT is compact. (X,T) be a flow, with X
7. Theorem. Let
Then x ;;T
E
locally compact Hausdorff.
X is an almost periodic point if and only if the orbit closure
is a compact minimal set.
Proof. Suppose M = 3 is a compact minimal set and let U be a neighborhood of x.
First note that M c UT.
(If not
M
\ UT
is a
By compactness, there is a finite n Uti. Now, if T E T, subset K = itl,. . . ,tn} of T such that M = i=l -1 XT E Uti, for some i with 1 5 i 5 n, so xzti E U. So, if closed invariant proper subset of M.)
u
A
=
[t Ixt
E
U],
syndetic, and x
r t ; '
E
A,
t E
Ati c AK, and T = AK. That is, A is
is almost periodic.
Conversely, suppose x
is an almost periodic point.
By the preceding
lemma, ZT is compact. If ZT is not minimal, it contains a minimal subset M'.
Let U and V be disjoint open sets with x
E
U and
Chapter 1
12
M' c V, and let K be a compact subset of such that WK-l c V.
neighborhood of M'
T with xs
s E
E
T. Let W be a Now M' c 3, so there is an
W. Then xsK-' c WK-' c V and xsK-' n U = $. then T
follows that if A = [tlxt E Ul, arbitrary compact subset of T, A
*
AK.
Since K
It
is an
x is not
is not syndetic, and hence
almost periodic. Theorem 7 has a,number of immediate corollaries, which are not obvious consequences of the definition of almost periodicity. 8.
(X,T) is a flow with X compact Hausdorff, then
Corollary. If
there is an almost periodic point in X. Proof. Every point of a minimal subset of X (X,T) is a flow (with X
9. Corollary. If
then x
E X
is almost periodic. locally compact Hausdorff)
is almost periodic if and only if it is discretely almost
periodic (i.e., almost periodic with respect to the discrete topology of TI.
10.
X
Corollary.
Let
(X,T) be a flow with X compact Hausdorff.
hen
is a (necessarily disjoint) union of minimal subsets i f and only f
every point of X
is almost periodic.
(In this case, we say X
is
pointwise almost periodic. 1 The first part of the proof of theorem 7 also yields the following corollary. 11.
Corollary. Let
(X,T)
be a minimal flow with X compact
Hausdorff, and let U be a non-empty open subset of X. Then there i's a n
finite subset K = {tl,,.., tn)
of T such that X = UK =
u j=l
Ut
j'
O u r next result is an "inheritance" theorem, which relates the action
of a syndetic subgroup of T to the action of T.
Rows and Minim1 Sets
Let
Lemma.
12.
T.
Suppose
Suppose
y E
a.Then
S
is normal, t h e r e are
Since
1
-1
xs i ' + y t
such t h a t
.
S be a normal subgroup of
is an almost p e r i o d i c point f o r t h e flow
xt
xts.+y.
so
X
E
t E T,
Then, i f Proof.
x
be a flow, and let
(X,T)
13
is an almost p e r i o d i c point f o r
x
Since
is
t h e r e is a n e t i
'
E S
(X,S). in
such t h a t
S
such t h a t
xsi't+y,
almost p e r i o d i c , t h e r e are
S
s
.
and s o t h e r e are
yt-lsi''+x
s
{si)
(X,S).
s
i
"' E S such t h a t
i
E
"
S
ys "t-'+x i
ysi"'+xt.
or
Theorem.
13.
Suppose
T.
subgroup of
(X,T)
Then
is a flow and
(X,T)
is a s y n d e t i c normal
S
is pointwise almost p e r i o d i c i f and only i f
(X,S) is pointwise almost periodic. Proof.
Suppose
compact subset of that
y
is
Then
= xk
{ti)
s i E S,
with
follows t h a t ys +x' i
T = SK.
S almost periodic.
t i = s .1 k i ' i
with
T
t h e r e is a net
periodic,
ys j x ' .
is pointwise almost p e r i o d i c .
(X,T)
ki
Then
in
K.
T
(X,T)
and l e t
such t h a t
xk-'
is
S
k k i
-1
be a
K
y
such
E
is pointwise almost
+e,
Write
yti+x.
W e may suppose
and s i n c e
i l
-1 .
Since
x E X
E K,
ki+k
and a l s o ysiki = y t i + x ,
ysiki+x'k
ys k.k-l+x'
E
Let
Let
and t h a t
x = x'k.
so
It
we have
almost p e r i o d i c , s o
x
is
S
almost periodic, by l e m m a 12. Suppose t h a t let
y E
n.
Let
where
si E S,
k E K
such t h a t
is pointwise almost p e r i o d i c .
(X,S)
be a net i n
{t.) 1
1
x s +yk-l. i s
i
with
xti-+y.
x
E
X
ti = siki,
Write
'
E S
Since
(X,S)
such t h a t
is pointwise almost
yk-lsi8-+x,
so
x E
F.
t h a t t h e proof of t h i s implication does not use t h e assumption t h a t
is normal. 1
and
As i n t h e first p a r t of t h e proof, t h e r e is a
k. E K.
p e r i o d i c , t h e r e are
T
Let
(Note
S
Chapter 1
14
Now we present some examples of non-trivial minimal flows. The simplest example of an (infinite) minimal cascade is an irrational rotation of the circle. To be precise, regard the circle K as the set of complex numbers of absolute value one, and let u (n f 01, phism cp
a = exp(2nie1, where 0
so
with an
#
1
is irrational. Let the homeomor-
be defined by ( p ( z ) = uz. We show that the orbit of
: K+K
the complex number 1 K.
E K
(that is, the set of powers {a"))
is dense in
Once this is proved, it will follow that every orbit is dense (since
n n if z E K, cp ( 2 ) = a z )
proving minimality of
(K,(p).
Let @ be a limit point of the (infinite) set {an)n=1,2,,
and let
..
> 0. Then there are non-zero positive integers n and k such that
c
&
Ian-@[ < and < 2' - Thus k Z H ~ z is an isometry, it follows that
- un I
<
n n+k
For some m, the points u , a E
n+mk
,. ..,u
> 0, the set {an)
Since the map
E.
lun+2k-un+kI =
and, in general, Iun+(m+l)k - ,n+mk
E,
Thus, for any
<
I
<
(m=1,2,. . . 1.
E
"wind" around the circle.
(n > 0 )
is
E
dense in K. This
completes the proof. Closely related to this example is the example of the irrational (real) flow on the torus. Let the two-dimensional torus K2 be represented as the plane R2
modulo the integer lattice points Z2. m
Thus we regard
(x,y) = (x',y')
if and only if
(x-x',y-y')
Let 1.1 be an irrational number, and define the flow
(p
E ZL.
: KxR-+K
by
cp((x,y),t) = (pt(x,y)= (x+pt,y+t). Thus the orbits of this flow ("flow lines") are parallel lines with slope p. (0,O) is dense. Let
t
0
+ n = y'
such that
(mod 11,
(x',y'l
E K
2
We show that the orbit of
, and let
E
> 0. Let t = y', 0
so
for all integers n. Now, choose an integer n
IptO-x'+pnI <
E
(mod 1).
The choice of such an n
is
possible because of the minimality of the irrational rotation of the
Flows and Minimal Sets
15
circle, which we have just proved. Then
whose distance from (0,O)
on K2
(x',y')
is less than
Then the orbit of
E.
is dense.
It is easy to show that all orbits are dense, as in the case of the cascade
(K,cp)
above. Actually,, these are examples of equicontinuous
flows, and we will prove in the next chapter that for such flows minimality is equivalent to the existence of a dense orbit.
(This is not -
the case for an arbitrary flow.) Similarly, the (real) flow defined on K where
aP
is irrational, is minimal.
flow defined above, then
2
by
In fact, if p =
a
P- and cpt
is the
A rich source of examples is
$t = pPt.
be a finite set of cardinality
provided by the symbolic systems. Let A which we write as {0,1,2,.. . ,p-l}.
p > 1,
$,(x,y) = fx+at,y+@t),
Let
R denote the collec-
tion of two-sided infinite sequences w = (w(n)),
with o(n) E A,
I
define a metric on s1 by d(w,o') =
and
(an equivalent
n=-m metric is given by
D(w,w') =
1 -, n+1
negative integer such that w(n)
#
where n
or w(-n)
w'(n)
z
given the discrete topology, then 51 = A , Tychonoff's theorem.
(In fact, R
Note that the points w
and w'
agree on some large "central block"
is the smallest non-
*
w'(-n)).
If A
is
which is compact by
is homeomorphic to the Cantor set.) of R
-- that
are close together if they is, if d n ) = w'(n),
for
In1 I N.
A homeomorphism u of R to itself is defined by d w ) ( n ) = o(n+l) (n E Z). The map u (s1,u)
is called the shift homeomorphism and the cascade
is the shift dwamical system on
p smbols. These cascades are
Chapter 1
16
also called symbolic systems. We introduce some suggestive terminology and notation. The set A
is
called the alphabet, and a word (or a block) is a finite sequence of "letters" of A a word in w
(for example, if p = 2, 01101 is a word).
is a word of the form o(m)w(m+l)
. . . o(m+r)
r 2 0. If a and b are words, we can form the word
If w
E
Q
for some
ab
in the
obvious way, by juxtaposit on. We may also speak of (left or right) infinite words.
Of course any w E Q
is a (two-sided) infinite
word. Note that if w , w ' E Q,
then w' E
if and only if every word in
is also a word in w .
w'
In general, we are interested in closed invariant sets of the shift system, in particular minimal subsets, rather than the "full shift" (Q,a). To obtain a minimal subset of
Q,
to construct an almost periodic point
o
It is easy to see that w E R if every word in w
it is sufficient by theorem 7 (so
o(w) is a minimal set.)
is an almost periodic point if and only
occurs "syndetically often." That is, if a
word in w , there is an N > 0 (depending on a) such that if
a
is a subword of
(Note that in w
o
w(n)w(n+l).
--
n E Z,
. .w(n+N).
is a recurrent point of w
occurs again
is a
if every word which occurs
and therefore infinitely often.)
The construction of almost periodic points in A'
which are not
periodic (equivalently of non-trivial minimal subsets of
z
A )
is by no
means trivial. One of the earliest examples is due to Marston Morse. Let
p = 2, so
a point of AN
A = {0,1}. We first define a one-sided sequence (i. e. ,
(where N = {0,1,... } . I
Write
0' = 1,
a = ala2...am is a word, define a' = al'a2' . . . a
m
'.
1' = 0 and if
(For example, if
a = 01101. a' = 10010.)To define the "Morse sequence," we define
Flows and Minimal Sets
17
inductively a sequence of words a where each a n n
al = 0. and if a n
fact the first half) of an+l. Let defined, let an+l = a a '. n n
is a subword (in has been
Thus a2 = 01, a3 = 0110, a4 = 01101001,
etc. The "limit word" is a right infinite word w = 0110100110010110. . . Another way of constructing the one-sided Morse sequence is as follows. If b
is a word, let b
the length of b) 1+10.
*
denote the word (of length twice
obtained from b by the "substitution" 0401,
(For example, if b = 01101, then
b = al = 0, and inductively let 1
*
b = ak, for k k
*
S
n.
*
bn+l - bn* . *
.
(b 1' = (b')
it is easy to see that
For,
bn = a n'
Now suppose, inductively, that bn+l
[4'
I .
Let
--
*
*
= a = n ) ' = b b ' = a a'= = bn-l*(bn-l* n n n n
It follows that the limit word
substitution 0+01,
In fact
Then bn = an = an-lan-l' ,
(an-lan-l') = an-1an-1 = any1 a n+l'
*
b = 0110100110. )
w
bn
reproduces itself under the
1-+10.
From this latter characterization, if follows that every finite word which occurs in w
For
occurs syndetically often.
0 occurs syndetically often since the sequence is made up of
pairs 01 and
10. But the sequence reproduces itself under the
substitution 0+01
and
l+
01 also occurs syndetically
10 so
often. For the same reason, the initial words 0110, 01101001, etc. occur syndetically often. But this sequence of initial words (in our notation bn)
include all words of w
as subwords, so all words occur
syndetically.
To obtain an almost periodic point of A' "reflection.
we extend
w
by
That is, if n < 0, define w(n) = w(-n-1).
the two-sided infinite sequence w =
Thus o
J.
. .. 100101100110100110010110. . . ,
where the vertical arrow indicates the 0th position o(0). Equivalently,
(if, when b = bl...b
m
is a word,
6
denotes the
is
Chapter 1
18
"reverse" of b.
6=
bmbm-l...bl) then w
is the "limit" of the words
c a a where the Oth position is the initial letter of a n n n' the point
w E A
=a that a2n+1
To see that
just defined is indeed an almost periodic point, note for n = 1,2,. . .
2n+1'
(this is an easy induction) and
an argument similar to the one above for the one-sided Morse sequence shows that a 2n+1"2n+1
It follows as above
occurs syndetically in w .
that all words which occur actually occur syndetically. Therefore w
--
an almost periodic point
its orbit closure
is
is called the Morse
Mo
minimal set. It is not difficult to give a combinatorial proof that o periodic, but we present a "dynamical" proof.
is not
If we now write wo
for
the one-sided Morse sequence, then w = wowo.
t
An argument similar to the
80'wo
is also an almost periodic
shows that C =
one given above for w point
(< =
J
. . . 0110100101101001. . . ) . M1.
also a minimal set
that
lim d(d(w),un(<))
Then the orbit closure of
Now, since w(n) = <(n) = 0, (we say that
asvmmptotic) and since d(w) E Mo,
w
<
is
for n 1 0 , i t follows and
<
are positively
on(<) E M1, Mo = MI.
(Recall that
distinct minimal sets are disjoint, and so must be a positive distance apart.) But it is immediate that a finite minimal set cannot contain (distinct) asymptotic points. infinite, and w
Therefore the Morse minimal set is
is not periodic.
Another description of the one-sided Morse sequence is obtained as follows. If n
is a positive integer, write n =
ci2' 1=o
ck = 1.
Let
e(n)
where c = 0 i
(mod 21, and 0 ( 0 ) = 0. Then
=
i =o For, if 0
J)+1
S j
< , ' 2
it is immediate that
(mod 21, so O(j+zJ
= O(J1'.
Since e ( 0 ) = 0 = ~ ( 0 1 ,
19
Flows and Minimal Sets
the result follows by induction. The existence of asymptotic points in the Morse minimal set is characteristic of minimal subflows of the symbolic system. For is a two-element set, A = { O , l } ,
simplicity we suppose A
be an infinite minimal subflow of Q = A
N t 2, there are points wN and ~ ~ ’ (=0 1) and
w (n) = oN’(n)
N
these points is established, let = w
lim wN
that
and
i
and ;’
are in X.
= c’(n)
;(n)
2
z . We will show that for each
wN ’
for
{Ni}
-
lim wN‘ = w’ i
in X such that wN ( 0 ) = 0 ,
1 In
for n t 1, so
5
N.
Once the existence of
be a sequence with exist. Since X
;(O) = 0, ; ‘ ( O )
Also
and let X
= 1, so
lim d(rn(G),o-n(;‘)) nJm
G
N i +co
such
-
is closed, w
*
z‘,
but
= 0. (Thus
and
are positively asymptotic.1 Now suppose for some N
above.
we cannot find points wN
Then, if w , w‘ E X with (say) w ( 0 ) = 0, ~ ‘ ( 0=) 1,
an N 2 1 such that
w(n)
f
w’(n)
for some n with
is, the sequence of values w ( 1 ) , w ( 2 ) , . . .w(N) w E X.
w(n)
and wN ’
Since X
for each m.
as there is
1 I n I N.
determines w ( 0 )
That for
is shift invariant, o(m+l), . . . ,o(m+N) determines Hence X must be finite.
Asymptoticity is a special case of proximality which, together with related notions, will be studied extensively in this book. a flow, then x and y z E X
@.nd a net
{ti)
in X are said to be proximal in T such that
xti+z
If
(X,T) is
if there is a
and yti+z.
If X
is compact, x and y are proximal if and only if for every a E (the unique uniformity of X) Thus if
there is a t E T such that
%
(xt,yt) E a.
X is a compact metric space, x and y are proximal if and
only if inf d(xt,yt) = 0. tET We write P or P(X)
f o r the proximal relation in
Chapter 1
20
X
:
P is a reflexive symmetric T
P = [(x,y)lx and y are proximal].
invariant relation, but is in general not transitive or closed. Note that (if X is compact Hausdorff) P = n [crTla E % I . If x and y are not proximal, they are said to be distal, and the flow (X,T) is called distal if there are no non-trivial proximal pairs (i.e., P = A,
the diagonal).
The analysis of distal flows will be
carried out in chapters 5 and 7 . Other examples of flows arise from consideration of spaces of functions. Let CO(T)
denote the set of bounded continuous real (or
complex) valued continuous functions, provided with the topology of uniform convergence equivalently, the topology defined by the norm llfll = sup If(t)l). taT
If t
E
T, and f
E
CO(T).
ft is defined by
It is immediate that this defines an action
translation: ft(7) = f(tr). of T on CO(T). If T = R,
the additive group of reals ( s o ft(7) = f(t+r))
then
f E C (T) is an almost periodic point if and only if it 1s a Bohr 0
uniformly almost periodic function: if
2:
> 0, there is a relatively
dense (syndetic) subset A of R such that
< 2: for T E A . (Of course, this is the reason for t a use of the term "almost periodic" in arbitrary flows.) It will be shown
sup If(t+t)-f(t)I
in the next chapter that f
E
C (R) 0
has compact orbit closure if and
only if i t is almost periodic. If t
E
T, then T acts as an isometry on CO(T); d(ft,gt) = d(f,g)
Thus, this flow is (where d(f,g) = IIf-gll = sup If(t)-g(t)I). taT "equicontinuous." The formal definition and properties of equicontinuous flows are the subject of the next chapter, and as we will see. equicontinuous flows have a more or less complete classification. Therefore,
Flows and Minimal Sets
21
the flow on C (T) is of limited dynamical interest. A more interesting 0
flow is obtained by endowing the space of bounded continuous functions with the topology of uniform convergence on compact sets. For this purm
pose, suppose T is sigma-compact (T = and define a metric by p(f,g) = sup min[{;z; n
u Kn, where Kn n=1 If(t)
-
is compact)
g(t)l,a}].
Let
n BO(T) be the bounded continuous functions with the topoloky induced by in the case of CO(T),
p.
As
of
T on Bo T I ;
translation of functions defines an action
the flow (BO(T),T) is called the Bebutov system. In
contrast with the flow (CO(T),T) which has "few" compact orbit closures, every (left) uniformly continuous function has compact orbit closure in BO(T) (exercise 12).
Most important, (BO(T),T) has a "universal"
property. For a large class of acting groups (including T = R )
any
flow on a locally compact metric space (subject to an obvious necessary condition on its fixed point set), can be regarded as a subflow of BO(T). The precise statement and proof will be presented in Chapter 13. In any mathematical system, one is interested in the maps which respect the structure of the system. The appropriate maps in topological dynamics are those which are continuous and equfvariant. To be precise, let
(X,T) and
(Y,T) be flows (with the same acting group).
homomorphism from X to Y is a continuous map A n(xt) = n(x)t
(x E X, t
E
:
A
X j Y such that
TI.
If there is a homomorphism
II
from X onto Y, we say that Y
factor of X, and that X is an extension of Y. 14.
Proposition. Let (i)
A :
X+Y
be a homomorphism.
If Xo is a minimal subset of X, then Yo = lt(XO)
is a
minimal subset of Y. (ii)
If Y is minimal and X is compact, then
H
is onto.
is a
Chapter 1
22
( i i i ) If X
is minimal, and n,#
:
X+Y
are homomorphisms which
agree at one point, then n = #. and Yo are minimal subsets of X and Y respectively
(iv) If Xo
such that n(Xo) n Yo
f
then n(Xo) = Yo.
$,
Proof. (i)
(ii)
If yo
If Xo
E
Yo and x0
E Xo
with n(xo) = yo, then
is a minimal subset of X, then n(X)
3
n(Xo)
(t
E
T).
=
Y, by
(i). (iii)
If n(xo) = $(xo),
then n(x,t)
and # agree on a dense set, so
= #(xot)
Thus n
n = 14,.
(iv) follows from (1) and the fact that the minimal subsets of a flow are disjoint or equal. Since our main interest is in minimal flows, it will usually not be necessary to specify that a homomorphism is onto. The meaning of the terms isomorphism, endomorphism, and automorphism should be clear. Almost by definition the properties which will interest us are those which are preserved by isomorphisms. The next result shows that homomorphisms of minimal flows have a "semi-open" property. 15. Theorem. Let U
n:X+Y
be a homomorphism of minimal flows, and let
be a non-empty open set in X. Then n(U)
Proof. Let V
has non-empty interior.
be a closed set in X with V c U and
int V f $. n Since X is minimal, there are t 1' . . . ,tn E T such that Vti = X, so i=1 n n Y = n(X) = n(Vti) = n(V)ti. Therefore n(V)ti has non-empty intei=1 i=1 rior for some ti, so int n(V1 * 4. Since n(U) D n(V1, int n(U) * 4.
u
u
u
FIows and Minimal Sets
Note that if s
:
X+Y
is an onto homomorphism, then
R(n) = R = [(x,~') 6 X x X)n(x) = n(x')l equivalence relation. (x,x') E R and t
E
(That is, R
is a closed
is a closed T
R is not closed, then the quotient space X/R
map
X-+X/R
invariant
T, then (xt,x't) E R.) Conversely, if
lence relation, then the quotient space X/R
by
T
is a closed subset of X x X and if
flow with X compact Hausdorff and R
T acts on X/R
23
(X,T) is a
invariant equiva-
is compact Hausdorff.
(If
will not be Hausdorff.)
(xR)t = (xt)R, for x E X, t
E
T, and the natural
is a homomorphism. Hence these are just two ways of
talking about the same thing, and we will use them interchangeably. A standard method for obtaining such equivalence relations is by means
of compact group extensions. Let
(G,X,T) be a bitransformation group
with X compact Hausdorff and G compact. Then the action of G defines a closed invariant equivalence relation R on X x' = gx
for some g E C.
"orbit space" of G.
We write X/G
(Cx)t = C(xt).
for X/R.
(x,x')
E R
if
Thus T acts on the
In this case X
is said to be a
group extension (or C extension) of (X/C,T).
It is frequently assumed that the action of C is stronnly effective):
x
E
X.
if g E C with g
#
e
free (a synonym is
then gx
*
x for all
(We write e for the identity element of both groups C and
T.) Note that if (X,T) is minimal, then an (effective) G actions is always free. For g E C
defines an automorphism of
gx = x for some x E X, then g
(X,T) and if
is the identity automorphism
(proposition 14, (iii)).
For an example of a group extension, consider the automorphism order 2 of the Morse minimal set Mo "interchange" map
rp
where, as.above, w'
(po
of
obtained by restricting the
of the full shift S2 = { O , l ) '
to
Mo
(cp(o) = w ' ,
is obtained from w by interchanging 0 and
1.)
Chapter 1
24
If o =
,
0
J. . .lOOlOllOlOOl.. .
is the generating point of
is easy to see that oo' = cp(u0)
E
Mo
an automorphism of order 2 of Mo, on Mo
so
Mo,
then it
(proposition 14, (iv))
is
'po
and thus defines an action of Z
2
which commutes with the shift u.
Another important class of homomorphisms are the proximal extensions. The homomorphism 71:X+Y
n(x) = n(x'), R(n) c P(X).
then x and
is proximal if whenever x,x'
x'
E
X with
are proximal. Equivalently,
As we will see in the final chapter, the proximal and group
extensions are used as "building blocks" for a certain class of flows which include many of the known examples. We now present two examples of minimal cascades on which proximal homomorphisms are defined.
In both of these examples the proximal
relation P is a closed equivalence relation, and the homomorphism is the canonical map X+X/P. The first example is a "non-homogeneous" minimal set, which is a modification of a construction of E. E. Floyd.
In the ensuing discussion
"rectangle" will mean a closed rectangle in the plane with sides parallel to the axes.
If B
is a rectangle, B = Ia,a+hl x [b,b+kl, then h ( B )
disjoint rectangles h ( B ) = B0 v B1 v B2, h k 2h 3h Bo = [a,a+glx [b,b+~], B1 = [a+T,a+Tl x [b,b+kl, and 4h k B2 = [a+>,a+hl x [b+-,b+kl. That is, h ( B ) is obtained from B 2
denotes a union of 3
where
by
deleting the "middle fifths" rectangles and then deleting the top and bottom halves respectively of the remaining left and right rectangles. n If K is a disjoint union of rectangles K = Bi, then we define
u
m
h(K) =
i=1
u h(Bi). i=1
Now, let B ( O ) = [O,l] x [ O . l l , B(n+l) = X(B(")).
and define inductively
Flows and Minimal Sets
Thus B(n)
consists of 3"
n (k = 0,1,2,...,3 -1)
25
disjoint rectangles (1)
arranged as follows Bo
,
Bil)
and B2('1
the "left," "center" and "right" rectangles (corresponding to and B2
in the definition of h
above).
(n+l)u B(n+l) u B(n+l) j+3n j+2*3 n'
= Bj
Bo, El,
At the next stage, let
1 from left to right. h(B:"))
are
In general
from left to right. The first two
stages of the construction are shown in figures 1 and 2 (where the rectangles are labeled 0,1,2, and 0,1,2,. . . ,8, Let
X =
n
B(~). Since B(n)
respectively).
is a decreasing sequence of
n=O,1,2,. ..
compact sets, X
is
a compact metric space, which consists of vertical
line segments, some (in fact all but countably many) of which are degenerate (single points).
There is one segment of length 1
every n > 0, infinitely many of length homogeneous
as x
--
if x
E
1/2".
X, its dimension at x
The space X
and, for is non-
is 1 or 0 according
is on a non-degenerate or degenerate segment.
A homeomorphism T of X
is defined by permuting the rectangles
B(n) J .
The permutations B!n) uB!~) (where j+l is understood J J+1 n modulo 3 ) induce a map of X to itself. (Note that n B(n) # 4 jn
and only if j n+1 n
B!~) Jn
n
p
to n B (n) +l. jn
jn (mod 3
)
so
if
the permutations induce a map of
If these sets are non-degenerate vertical line
segments, map the first linearly onto the second.)
To show that the cascade (X,T) is minimal, let to be the unique line segment of length one in X, and let
Xo
be a minimal subset of
X. I t is sufficient to show that to c Xo. Since the orbit of every point of X xo
E
intersects every rectangle Bin)
X0 n to. But if x'
E to, and
there is a point
V is a neighborhood of x'
there
26
Chapter I
I] Fig. I
Fig. 2
El
Flows and Minimal Sets
is a rectangle B!n) J (X,T) is minimal.
c
V,
O(xo) n V
so
*
4.
27
Hence x’
E
Xo, and s o
The homeomorphism T permutes the vertical segments, and it is easy to see that
x and x’ in X are proximal if and only if x and x‘
are on the same vertical segment. Thus the proximal relation P closed equivalence relation, and T quotient space X/P.
is a
induces a homeomorphism on the
The latter space is homeomorphic to a Cantor set.
The factor cascade will be analyzed in the chapter on equicontinuous flows. An interesting biproduct of this example is the construction of a cascade with a locally compact phase space which has no minimal subsets. Before describing this construction, we note a property of the proximal relation in X. such that tive)
(x,x’) E P with x
If
d(T”(x),T”(x’))
>
f
x’
then there is an
E
> 0
for infinitely many (positive and nega-
E
n. This follows from the fact that there are infinitely many
segments of length 1/2 and the homeomorphism T maps the segments
1 i near 1y . Now, let
Y
=
P
\
A
(so
y = (x,x’) E Y
if and only if x
t
x’
and
x and x‘ are on the same vertical segment. Since Y is an open subset of the compact space P, it is locally compact.
Let
$ : Y j Y
be the restriction of the product homeomorphism T x T. To show that
(Y,$) has no minimal subsets, we define a real-valued function u on Y with the following two properties:
00,d y ‘ ) 5 dy), then for some- y ‘ . 00, ~ dy‘) <
(i)
If y,y‘ E Y
(ii)
If y
E
Y,
with y’
E
The existence of such a function u subsets. For, if y If
r
E
Y and
r
=
implies that
00,let
were minimal, we would have y
E
O(y‘)
and dy).
Y has no minimal
y‘ E Y with d y ’ ) < dy). and d y ) I d y ’ ) < u(y1,
Chapter 1
28
a contradiction.
If
y = (x,,x,)
E
Y, let
u(y) = d(T
dy') = dy).
mk
IC,
= dy),
invariant: cr($(y))
(y)+y'
E
Moreover, if
for y
y,y'
E
E
where
lo.
k
is the
are on lo. Note that
Y,
so if
u
y' E Cl(y),
{m k1 is a sequence such that
Y, then dy') < dy).
of generality-, that
k xl),T (x,))
k and T x,)
k
unique integer such that T (x1 ) is 9
k
ImkI-+m
and
To see this suppose,.without loss
Since
!.0 is the unique segment of
length one, and T maps segments linearly mk mk 1 1 d(T (xl),T (x,)) 5 sd(x1,x2) = ~ ( y ) , s o , if y' = (x'1'x'), 2 then
= d(x',x') 1 2
1 -cr(y).
Finally, as was noted above, there is an n nk k E > 0, and a sequence nk+m such that d(T (xl),T (x,)) 2 E , so n k there is a y' E Y with $ (y)+y' (and therefore, as we have just u(y')
5
2
shown dy') < dy)).
Thus properties ( i ) and (ill are satisfied.
Our next example is the "two circle" minimal set, due to Ellis. Let
Y be the circle, regarded as the real numbers modulo 2n, and let Y1 Y2 be two disjoint copies of Y. Points in Y 1 and Y2 will be written (y,l) and (y,2) respectively. Let X = Y u Y 1 2' X will be
and
topologized by specifying an open closed neighborhood base for each point.
If
E
> 0, let
N(y,l,c) = [(y+t,l)lO
S
t < el u [(y+t,2)10 < t
5
el
and
N(y,Z,c) = [ (y+t,1) 10 > t 2 -el u [(y+t,2)10 2 t > -el; N(y,2,e) are open closed basic neighborhoods of respectively. With this topology X
N(y,l,c) and
(y,l) and
(y,Z)
is a compact Hausdorff zero
dimensional space which is first countable but not second countable (and therefore not metrizable). by
Let T
be the homeomorphism of
z(y,j) = (y+1,j) (j=1,2). Then the cascade
(Although each of Y1 and Y2
X defined
(X,r) is minimal.
is invariant under
t,
a neighborhood of
x = (y,j) contains points of both Y1 and Yz and it follows easily
Flows and Minimal Sets
29
from the minimality of the corresponding rotation of the circle that every orbit meets every basic neighborhood.) If y E Y, then and
(y,2) are proximal
tn(y,l)
--
(y,l)
for every E > 0 there is an n such that
and rn(y,2) are both in N(y,l,c). Thus, the map
(j = 1,2), defines a proximal homomorphism of
fy,j1-y
Y onto the rotation of
the circle by one radian. A flow is said to be proximal if it is a proximal extension o,f the
trivial (one point) flow
--
equivalently every pair of points is proximal.
Abelian groups admit no minimal proximal actions (exercise 16). A simple example of a minimal proximal flow is provided by the action
of T = SL(2,R) on X = R v
{m}.
(the group of 2 If x
E
x
2 real matrices with determinant
i]
X and t =
~
It is well known and easily checked that the action of T on X transitive (if x,x'
X, there is a t
E
T with xt = x')
so
is
certainly
are distinct points of X,
(X,T) is minimal. Moreover, if x and x'
then there is a t E T with xt = 0, x't = 1. action of T on X
1)
ax + b E T. Define xt = cx + d'
Thus, to show that the
is proximal, it is sufficient to show that x = 0
lim xtn = lim x't = 0, so
x
and x'
are proximal.
Exercises. 1.
Let
(X,cpt) be a real flow, and let x
E
X.
Then the orbit of x
is a single point, a periodic orbit, or a one-to-one continuous image of R.
In the latter case, the orbit is homeomorphic with R
if and only if
x is not recurrent. There is apparently no known topological characterization of orbits. (Not every continuous one-to-one image of R
is an orbit - for example,
Chapter 1
30
a "figure eight" cannot be an orbit.) 2. Let
be a real flow in the metric space X.
{cp,)
is the set o+(x) = [cpt(x) t
semi-orbit of x of
x
w(x) =
is defined by
The positive The omeRa limit set
2 01.
n 0+ (cpZ(x)). T>-O
(i)
i f and only if there is a sequence
y E w(x)
and
tn+m
lim cpt (XI = y. Hence x n-m n
{tn)
in R
with
is (positively)
recurrent i f and only if x E o(x). (ii)
O+(x) = O+(x) v w(x)
and this union is disjoint if and only if
x e w(x).
(iv) The omega limit set is (positively and negatively) invariant and if t
E
(so
R , w(cpt(x)) = o(x)
we may speak of the omega limit
set of an orbit). (v)
If X
is compact, d x )
is non-empty and connected.
The omega limit set can be defined for cascades in the obvious manner. The properties above {except for the conclusion
d x ) is connected in (v)) 3. Let
hold in this case as well.
be a transformation group and let x E X. The period of
(X,T)
XI.
x
is the set P = [t
x
is said to be a periodic point if
E
Tlxt =
is clearly a subgroup of T,
P
P
locally compact and separable, then x
is syndetic. Show:
is continuous and
bijective and is a homeomorphism if and only if the map e. 1
4.
(i)
Let
(X,p)
space.
Let
be a minimal cascade, with X E
is
is periodic if and only if xT
is compact. (The map of TIP to xT, P t w x t
at
if T
and
twxt
is open
a compact metric
> 0. Show that there is an n > 0 such that, if
Flows and Minimal Sets
x
(ii)
E
X, the set
I(pj(x) 1 ljl
n)
is c
dense in X.
Generalize (i) to an arbitrary minimal flow (X,T). (T is an arbitrary group and X
5. Let
5
31
is a compact Hausdorff space.)
(X,T) be a minimal flow (with X compact) and let p
invariant measure on X.
(That is, p
p(X) = 1 and p(At) = p(A)
for A
be an
is a Bore1 measure on X with
measurable and
t
E
T.) Then, if V
is a non-empty open subset of X, p(V) > 0. 6. The flow
(X,T) is called topologically transitive if every non-
empty open invariant set is dense, and point transitive if it has a dense orbit.
(Points with dense orbits are called "transitive points.") Note
that the "full shift" on p symbols is point transitive. Every point transitive flow is topologically transitive, and if the phase space is second countable the converse holds.
In this case the set
of transitive points is residual.
(X,cp) is said to be totally minimal if (X,cpn)
7. A minimal cascade
is minimal for all integers n (i)
f
0.
Show that a minimal cascade with a connected phase space is totally minimal.
(ii) Suppose
(X,cp) is minimal but not totally minimal.
(a) Let
p
be the smallest positive integer such that 1 is not minimal. Show that p1 is prime.
(b) Show that all minimal subsets of
(c) Let
(X,(ppl) are isomorphic.
X1 be such a minimal subset, and let
(X ,(p ) 1 1
(X,(ppl)
(pl = (pplIxl.
If
is not totally minimal, then the smallest positive
integer p
2
such that
(X,,(p~I is not minimal is a prime
with p2 2 PI' Continuing in this manner, we either obtain a totally
Chapter I
32
minimal cascade p1 5 p2
,.. .
5
(Xn,qn) or a sequence of primes (In the case of the non-homogeneous minimal
set considered in this chapter, all 8. Let
w = w w w
For
syndetically.) by
w(n) =
,
A.
(That is, every finite word in o occurs n = 0,1,2,. .,,
let
.L . O w w l...wnwn+l..,
..OO..
.
position. Let
o*
Show that
=
lim u'~').
w(")
be the bisequence defined
where, as usual, the vertical
arrow denotes the O'th the w("),
i = 3.)
be a one sided almost periodic sequence on the
0 12"'
finite alphabet
p
w
*
w*
be a subsequential limit of
is an almost periodic point of
n.-m 1
A".
Show that any two such points define the same minimal set.
9. Consider the point
J
[O
defined for j > 0 by
in { O , l ) '
w = (w.)
k if j = 3 (3n+l)
z . ) Show that w is an z almost periodic (and not periodic) point of ({0,1) ,u). (This sequence (Extend by reflection to obtain a point in {0,1)
can be constructed "in stages" as follows. Corresponding to write
k = 0,
0 1 ~ 0 1 ~ 0 1 ~ 0 1. .~ .0 1Next, ~ , start "filling in the gaps"
by the above pattern,
so
corresponding to k = 1, we obtain
0 1 ~ 0 1 ~ 0 1 ~ 0 1 ~ 0 1O~. .0. , 1 ~and 0 1 continue this process for
k = 2,3,... . I 10. Let R = {0,1}'
a : R+n x
by
and u: R+n
be the shift homeomorphism. Define
a(xI(2n) = a(x)(2n+l) = x(n)
by the "substitution" 0-00,
1-11].
(so
Let
is obtained from
a(x)
xo
E
R
be a
bisequence which contains all finite blocks and define xn by
xn = ~r(x~-~).Let no =
u
O(xnI.
n=O,1,2,. ..
inductively
Show that the cascade
Flows and Minimal Sets
0
has no minimal sets.
,IT)
Suppose T = R
11.
(i)
or
(The space Ro
33
is not locally compact.)
h.
(X,T) is minimal with X compact.
Suppose
Then X
"positively minimal" (i.e., for every x E X, O+(x) Suppose X
(ii)
is locally compact and
is almost periodic (and so (X,T)
(iii) Suppose x E X
X
is dense).
(X,T) is positively x
Suppose there is a recurrent point
minimal.
is
in X.
Then x
is in fact compact).
is minimal with X
locally compact and every
is positively and negatively recurrent. Then X
is
compact. 12. Suppose the group T
is sigma compact. Show that
f
E
BO(T)
has
compact orbit closure if and only if it is left uniformly continuous. (That is, if c > 0 there is a neighborhood U of e -1 s1 s2 E U
such that
If(sl)-f(s2)I < c . )
implies
13. Show that the conclusion of theorem 15 remains valid if it is only assumed that the set of almost periodic points in X
is dense
(X is
not necessarily minimal) 14.
Let
( Y , I )
be the cascade discussed in this chapter which has no
minimal subsets. Show that every point of Y has a non-empty omega
limit set, but that 15. Let
(X,T) and
(Y,+) has no recurrent points. (Y,T) be flows and let
II :
X+Y
be a
homomorphism. (i)
Show that
x(P(X1) c P(Y).
is minimal, and there is a y E Y such that 0 -1 whenever x , x ' E K (yo), (x,x') E P(X). Show that II is a
(ii) Suppose Y
proximal homomorphism.
Chapter 1
34 16.
(i)
Let
(X,T) be a flow and let
(x,y) E P and also
x,y E X.
Show that if
(x,y) is an almost periodic point of
(XxX,TI then x = y. ( i i ) If the group
T
is abelian, then there are no non-trivial
minimal proximal actions of
T.
35
Chapter 2 Equicontinuous Flows A
flow is called esuicontinuous if the collection of maps defined by
the action of the group is a uniformly equicontinuous family.
(The for-
mal definition is given below.) The equicontinuous flows are dynamically the "simplest" ones; in fact, there is a complete classification of equicontinuous minimal flows. Indeed, a fruitful way of looking at a general minimal flow is to consider to what extent it "differs" from being equicor.tinuous. This will be made precise in later chapters. Our discussion of equicontinuous flows will extend over several chapters. If these flows were our only concern, we could obtain our results more economically. However, our procedure will enable us to introduce certain concepts which will be useful in the study of more general minimal flows. Outlines of alternate proofs of some of the results will be indicated in the exercises. Now for the precise definition. A transformation group equicontinuous if, for any a E ?$, there is a 6 whenever
(x,x')
E
f3,
then
(xt,x't)
E
a, for all t
(This may be phrased more succinctly as: f3 E
?.$
E ?.$ E
(X,T) is
sucn that
T.
if a E I$, there is a
such that f3T c a. 1
If X
is metrizable, with compatible metric d, then. this reduces to
the familiar
"E-6"
definition: if
E
that if d(x,x') < 6, then d(xt,x't).< Note that if the phase space X
> 0, there is a 6 > 0 such E,
for all
t
E
T.
is compact, then equicontinuity is a
topological notion, since a compact space has a unique compatible uniformity. (If the space is not compact, then in fact equicontinuity
Chapter 2
36
depends on the uniformity, and not merely the topology. However, we will not be concerned with this case.) As
is the case throughout this monograph, our main concern is the
analysis of minimal flows. However, in the first part of this chapter, we will consider equicontinuous flows which are not necessarily minimal. Except where otherwise stated, we will assume that the phase spaces of the flows involved are compact Hausdorff. The following proposition is almost obvious. Nevertheless, it is of considerable importance for the study of equicontinuous flows. 1.
Proposition.
1)
If
(X,T) is equicontinuous and if S
is a subgroup of T, then
(X,S) is equicontinuous. 2) If
(X,T) is a flow, with T a compact group, then
equicontinuous. (Hence, i f T, then
S
(X,T) Is
is a subgroup of the compact group
(X,S) is equicontinuous.1
(As usual, the action of S
on X
is Just the restriction of the action
of T.1 Proof. 1) is obvious. If T (x,t)wxt Our
is compact, the defining map
is uniformly continuous, so
(X,T) is equicontinuous.
first substantial result on equicontinuity is that it is
equivalent to a strong form of almost periodicity. The flow (X,T) is said t o be uniformly almost periodic, if, for every a E syndetic subset A of T such that a E A.
(For short, xA
c xu,
s,
there is a
(x,xa) E u for all x E X ahd
for all x
E
X.
2. Theorem. The flow (X,T) is equicontinuous if and only if it is uniformly almost periodic. Proof. Suppose (X,T) is uniformly almost periodic. Let
EquicontinuousFlows
(=?$I,
a E 21
fl
let
3
E 21
such that f3
T with xA c xf3, for all x such that T = AK. (x,x')
E U
Now, let 6
implies (xk, x'k)
E 6
(x,y) E 6, then t-' = ak
c a, and let A
X. Let K
E
E
31
be a compact subset of T
such that if k
P ("6(K u K-')
(for some a
be syndetic in
E A,
K u K-I, then
E
c p"). k
E
Then (xt,xta) E f3, (xta,yta)= (xk-l,yk-l)E f3,
If t
K),
so
E
T and
ta = k-'.
yta,yt) E 6 ,
so
3
(xt,yt) E f3 c a, and thus 6T c a. Therefore, (X,T) is equicontinuius. To prove the converse direction, we require several lemmas. 3. Lemma.
If
(X,T)
is equicontinuous, it is pointwise almost
periodic (that is, every x Proof. Let x U
Let a
E
t E T
such that
E
arbitrary, x
E U
such that PT c a. If y
(xt,y) E Is.
5,
E
X is an almost periodic point).
It is sufficient to show that ?i' is minimal.
X.
and let /3
E
Then (x,yt-')
E
E
?i', there is a
PT c a. Since a
E U
is
and the lemma is proved.
It follows from the above lemma that an equicontinuous flow is minimal if and only if it has a dense orbit. The easy proof of the next lemma is omitted. (Xi,T)(1 = 1 , . . . ,n) is a finite collection of n equicontinuous flows, then the product flow ( II XI,T) is i=1 4. Lemma.
If
equicontinuous. (In fact, an arbitrary product of equicontinuous floh-? is equicontinuous. This is exercise 2.) Our final lemma is a "finite" version of our theorem. 5. Lemma. Let X
',. . . ,xn E X.
xiA
c
xia (i =
(X,T) be equicontinuous, let a
Then there is a syndetic subset A 1,
. . . ,n).
E
21,
of T
and let such that
Chapter 2
38
Proof. Consider the product flow (Xn,T) which, by the preceding
*
21 be defined by Xn (n times). That is,
lemma, is equicontinuous. Let a
a+ = a(n)
= axax.. . x a
[(xi,.. . ,xA,) (yi,.
. . ,yk))
E a*
E
if and only if
(x;,y;)
a,
E
(i = 1,. . . ,n). Now, by our first lemma, x = (xl,. . . ,xn) is an almost
periodic point of (X",T) so there is a syndetic A c T such that xA c xa
.
It follows immediately that xiA c x.a (i = 1
1,.
. . ,n),
and the
lemma is proved. Now we can prove the converse direction of the theorem. Suppose (X,T) is equicontinuous, and let a E 21. and let 6
E 'U
such that 6T c 8.
3
Choose f3 E 21 with 0 c a,
Now, let xl,.
. . ,xn
subset of X which is "6 dense" - that is, if y (y,x,)
E 6,
X, then
E
for some i = 1,.. . ,n. By the last lemma, there is a
syndetic subset A of T with xiA c xis (i = 1 , ..., n). and a and
E A.
be a finite
Then (y,xi)f 6 ,
(xia,ya)E /3
for some i, (1 I i
S
n), (xi,xia)E 6 ,
2
(since 6T c 8).
Now let y E X
Then (y,ya) E 6 f3 c /3
3
c a,
and we
have yA c ya, which proves uniform almost periodicity. 6. Corollary. A factor of an equicontinuous flow is equicontinuous.
Proof. Let
(X,T) and
(Y,T) be flows and let
II :
X+Y
be an
(onto) homomorphism. Suppose (X,T) is equicontinuous, and let f3 Let a
E 'f$
such that
(nxn)(a)c f3.
Since (X,T) is uniformly almost
periodic, there is a syndetic set A c T such that all X E X , aEA. Then (n(x)a,n(x)) (ya,y)ef3 for Y E Y, a E A ,
so
E
E
(nxn)(a)c 8.
(xa,x)E U ,
for
That is,
(Y,T) is uniformly almost periodic,
hence equicontinuous. Now we turn to the systematic construction of equicontinuous minimal flows. To this end, we define a compactification of the topological
Equicontinuous Flows
group T to be a pair and cp G.
:
T+G
(G,cp) where G
is a compact topological group
is a continuous homomorphism such that
In this case, T acts on C by
Moreover, if H
39
is dense in
(g,t)++gcp(t) (the group product).
is a closed subgroup of C,
homogeneous space G/H
cp(T)
then T acts on the
(Hglt = H(gcp(t)).
of left cosets by
It is easy
to see that the flow (C,T) is minimal and equicontinuous. (Equicontinuity follows, for example, from proposition 1.) the identity e
is dense, so the minimality of
The orbit of
(G,T) follows from
lemma 3. It fallows from corollary 6 that the flow
(C/H,T)
is equicon-
tinuous. We will see in the next chapter that all equicontinuous minimal flows arise in this manner. Compactifications of the additive groups Z of integers and R
of
real numbers are called, respectively, monothetic and solenoidal groups. Intrinsic characterizations of these groups are provided by the following theorems (due to Anzai and Kakutani).
7. Theorem. Let G be a compact abelian group. Then the following are equivalent:
(i)
G
(ii)
There is a g
is monothetic.
n
{g 'n=o, 21,.. .
E
G such that the set of powers of g, is dense in G.
(Such an element is called a
topolonical generator of G.) n
(iii) The character group G of G to
is (alRebraicallY) isomorphic
a subgroup of the circle group.
8. Theorem. Let
G be a compact abelian group. Then the following
are equivalent: (i)
G
is solenoidal.
(ii)
G is separable and connected.
CIIupter 2
40 A
(iii) G
is (algebraically) isomorphic to a subgroup of
R.
We omit the proofs of these two theorems except for a brief indication of the implication ( i i i )
;$
Suppose
(i) in theorem 8 .
.. into R.
isomorphism of G
Then if a
1
= exp(iat(x))
(1E GI,
<,
and
<,
C. By the Pontrjagin
is a character of (p(a) E
G such that
It is easily verified that
= exp(iaz(x1).
are defined by A
duality theorem, there is a unique
R
E
is an algebraic
7
x(cp(a)) =
is a continuous
(p
*
homomorphism. If such that
(p(R)
xo((p(a))=
were not dense in G, there would be a
1 for all a
whose range is the complex number T(x,)
f
0, so
exp(iaor(xo))
xo
but
E R
Since
1).
E
G
*
1.
(the character
1
is an isomorphism
T
1 for some a.
f
f
xo
xo(cp(ao))
and
E R,
This contradiction completes the proof.
For the complete proofs of theorems 7 and 8 see volume I. chapter 6 of Hewitt and Ross Abstract Harmonic Analysis, Springer-Verlag.
The first two examples in chapter 1 (the irrational rotation of the circle and the real flow on the two torus) are equicontinuous minimal flows, since the transformations which define them are isometries. Now consider the cascade
2 ( K ,(p)
defined by
where 0 < a, f3 < 1, and na + m/3 P Z for are rationally independent).
Again,
(p
(p(x,y) = (x+a,y+P),
(m,n) f ( 0 , O )( a and 13
is an isometry,
so
2
(K
,(p)
is
equicontinuous, and hence pointwise almost periodic. We show that the orbit of
(0,O) is dense. Since its orbit closure is minimal, there is
N
an N > 0 such that d((O,O),(p (0,O)l < for some integers j and f3
guarantees that
in the cascade flow defined by 2 is dense in K .
(K,(p
r N
= )
e,
E.
Now
N
(p
( 0 , O )= (Na-j,Np-l)
and the rational independence of a and
Np-e is irrational. Thus the orbit of Na-j is a subset of the orbit of
qt(x,y) = (x+rt,y+t), which, since Since
(pN
(0,O)
(0,O) in the (real)
r
is irrational,
"pushes" points along this flow orbit in
Equicontinuoiis Flows
cpN
steps" it follows that the
"E
41
orbit of
is
(0,O)
E
dense in the
n
flow orbit, and hence 2~ dense in .'K {cpJ ( 0 , O ) } j E n
2 is 2& dense in K .
Thus certainly the orbit
Since
is arbitrary, this proves
E
mini ma1 ity . Note that if a and p for some
(m,n)f ( 0 , O ) )
are rationally dependent
2
in this case, the set
2
then the cascade
[(x,yf E K Imx + ny
(K ,cp) E
kZ1
(ma + np = k E Z )
is not minimal.
For,
is a non-trivial closed
invariant subset of K"
It is easily shown by induction that the cascade generated by the of Kn given by cp(xl, . . . , xn) = (xl+al, . . . , x +an) is n
homeomorphism cp
minimal if and only if al,...,anare rationally independent. Another example of an equicontinuous minimal cascade is provided by the dyadic group (also called the "adding machine"). C =
Il {O,l}, i=O,1,2,.. .
where
{0,1) has the discrete topology. Thus the
elements of G are one-sided sequences g = (g0 , g 1'"'
or
1.
Let
We define addition in G
where gi = 0
by componentwise addition modulo
2,
We may also regard G as the collection of "formal
with "carrying." W
power series" l g i a i , where gi = 0
or
1.
If go = (1,0,0 ,... 1
i =O then go
is a topological generator (since the set of multiples of g 0
consists of all elements of the form all
1, with not (xo,xl,...,xn,O,O,...
xi = 0, and this set is certainly dense in GI.
-go = (1,1,1,.. . I .
Note that
From the general considerations mentioned earlier, it
follows that the homeomorphism
t : G j G ,
t(g) = go + g (g E GI,
gives
rise to an equicontinuous minimal cascade. Note that G homeomorphism
t
is homeomorphic to the Cantor set and. in fact, the can be defined in terms of the usual "middle thirds"
construction. At the n-th stage of this construction, we have a closed
42
Chapter 2
set Xn which consists of 2” disjoint segments S(n,m) ( 0 where if 0
5
k
S
2”-l, S(n,k) and S(n,k+2”-’)
terminal thirds, respectively, of S(n-1,k).
X
=
n
n=O,1,.. . {x) =
Then I/J
:
Xn
(where Xo = [ O , l l )
n
n=O,1 , . . . X+X
S(n.mn)
(0 S
m
5
2”-1),
are the initial and
Then the Cantor set
and, if x
mn
S
E
I 2”-1, mn+l
X then
=
n mn(mod 2 1 ) .
is defined by
{$(x))
=
n
n=O,1,.. .
S(n,mn+l(mod 2”)),
and it is easily verified that the cascades (CJ)
and
(X,$) are
isomorphic. Recall that i n chapter 1 we introduced the flow (CO(T),T) where C (TI is the set of real or complex valued bounded continuous functions 0
on T with the uniform topology and T acts on C0 (TI by translation: where ft(z) = f(tr).
(f,t)i-+ft
Clearly, T acts as a group of
isometries, so the flow (CO(T),T) is equicontinuous. Now the space
CO(T) is not locally compact, so we cannot apply our theorems in Chapter 1 directly to establish the relation between almost periodicity and
compact minimal sets in CO(T).
For this purpose we require the
following lemma and its corollary. (Compactness of the phase space is not assumed. 9. Lemma. Let
and let x
E
(X,T) be an equicontinuous flow, where X
X be almost periodic. Let
subset K of T such that xK is Proof. Let 6 correspond to
E
E
&
> 0. Then there is a compact
dense in xT.
in the definition of equicontinuity,
and let A be a syndetlc subset of T such that d(xa,x) < 6 a
E A.
is metric,
for
Let K be a compact subset of T such that T = AK and let
Equicontinuous Flows
t
E
T. Then t = ak, for a 10. Corollary.
Let
metric space, and let x -
xT
43
k E K, and d(xt,xk) = d(xak,xkl <
E A,
X a complete
(X,T) be equicontinuous with E
c.
X be almost periodic. Then the orbit closure
is compact. Proof. It follows immediately from lemma 9 that xT
n)
is totally bounded. Since X
is complete,
n
(and therefore
is compact.
Note that in lemma 9 and corollary 10, the assumption that equicontinuous can be relaxed to
"T is equicontinuous at
(X,T) is
x."
Since C (TI is a complete metric space, the next theorem follows 0
easily from corollary 10, theorem 2, and theorem 7 of Chapter 1. 11.
Theorem. Let
f E CO(T).
(i)
f
(ii)
The orbit closure
(iii)
E
Then the following are equivalent:
i s an almost periodic point of the flow
(iv) TT If T = R,
fl
(CO(T),T).
is compact.
is a compact minimal set.
is a compact equicontinuous minimal set. then, as we noted in Chapter 1,
periodic point if and.only if f
f E C (R) 0
is an almost
is a Bohr almost periodic function.
The equivalence of Bohr almost periodicity and the relative compactness of the translates of f
((i) and (ii) above, respectively) is due to
Bochner. The latter property was taken by Von Neumann as the definition of an almost periodic function on an arbitrary group.
It can be shown
(Hewitt and Ross, volume I, p. 246) that this property is equivalent to the relative compactness of the "left orbit" - that is, the orbit of f with respect to the action defined by
f(r) = f(rt).
Note that the only compact orbit closures in CO(T)
are equicontin-
uous minimal sets. The final result in this chapter gives a sufficient condition for
Chapter 2
44
equicontinuity in terms of the action of the automorphism group. The proof depends on a lemma from general topology which is not quite standard, s o we include it here. Let X be a topological space, and let Y be a metric space. Let cpn
:
(n = 1,2, . . . 1 and let cp : X+Y.
X+Y
We say that cpn
convewes
&Q
cp c
uniformly
neighborhood U bf x and an integer No < c
d(cp(x'),cpn(x'))
for n
every c > 0, we say
x, for every x
E
No.
E
at x
if there is a
n
c
such that if x' E U,
If cpn-+cp
uniformly at x
c
uniformly at x.
Q +cp
easy to check that cpn-+cp at
2
X and
> 0.
Let x
If X
for
is compact, it is
uniformly if and only if cpn+cp
uniformly
X.
12. Lemma. Suppose X
is a Baire space (i.e., the countable
intersection of open dense sets is dense) and let cpn be a sequence of continuous functions from X x
Let E be the set of x
X.
E
cp n ( x ) + c p ( x )
to Y such that
for every
in X €or which rpn3 9 uniformly at
x. Then E is a residual set. Proof. For c > 0, let A ( & ) cpn+cp
uniformly at xo,
E
We show that A ( & )
Clearly A ( & )
I s dense.
Let W
E
X such that
is open and E =
1
n
A(E).
.
k=1,2,. .
be a non-empty open set in X.
If
K = [ z E Wld(cp(z),cpm(z)) < c/5, for all n for some n, Kn contains a non-empty open
is a positive integer, let
n
m
be the set of xo
w
=
uKn, so
U. Let x
E
U and let p
nl. Then
2
set
2
n. Then there is an integer q
2
n
(x)) < c/5 and a point z E U n Kn such that 4 d(cp (x),cp (z)) < c/5 and d(cp (x),cp (z)) < c / 5 . Then d(cp(x),cp (XI) S P P 4 q P d(cp(x),cp (XI) + d(cpq(x),pq(z)) + d(cpq(z),cp(z)) + d((p(z),cp (z)) + for which d(cp(x),(p
4
(z),cp(XI)< P P
d(rp
c
< ~ 1 5 ) . That is, if
(since z
x
E
U,
E
Knv d(cp(z),cp
q
d(cp(x),cp ( X I )<
P
P (z)) and d(cp(z).y, E
for all P
2
( z ) ) are
P n,
so
Equicontinuous Flows
cpn-+cp
E
uniformly at all points of U.
45
Hence W n A(&)
3
U
f
+,
and
the proof is completed. 13. Theorem. Let
(X,T) be a minimal flow with X
Suppose the automorphism group A
of
compact metric.
(X,T) is transitive.
with cp(x) = y. 1 Then
if x,y E X there is a cp E A
(That is,
(X,T) is
equicont inuous. (or more precisely the family of self maps of X
Proof. We regard T
which T defines) as a subset of C(X,X) the continuous maps from X to itself, provided with the topology of uniform convergence. sufficient by the Ascoli-Arzelk theorem, to show that T compact in C(X,X).
Let
{ti)
is relatively
be a sequence in T and let x E X. 0
Then there is a subsequence which we still call
{ti)
such that
lim xOti exists. It follows from the transitivity of A exists for every x E X. Then there is a map
t i +h
(h(x) = lim xt
pointwise
i
lim cp(x)ti = lim cp(xti) = cp(h(x)). X. x
1'
h
If cp
We show that
t +h
1
E
X-+X
:
for x E XI.
By lemma 12, there is an x E X such that Let x E X and let
It is
J
t +h
J
that lim xti such that
E
A, h(cp(x))
uniformly on uniformly at
> 0. Let cp E A such that cp(xl)
let 6 > 0 such that if d(zl,z2) < 6
=
&hen d(cp(zl),cp(z2))
<
= E.
x and Let
U1 be a neighborhood of x1 and j, a positive integer such that if j 1 jo and
y
E
ul, d(yltj,h(yl))
d(cp(y t ),cp(h(yl)) < 1 J j 2 jo. Hence t -+h j
E.
Thus if y
< 6. E
Then d(cp(Y1
U = c p ( U l ) , d(yt
j
1) = for
uniformly on X.
Exercises.
1.
Let
(X,T) be an equicontinuous flow, with
Then there is an equivalent invariant metric. p
(X,d) a metric space.
That is, there is a metric
on X, which induces the same topology as d, such that
Chapter 2
46
2. Let
(Xa ,TI (a E 9) be a family of equicontinuous flows. Then the
product flow (Wa,T) is equicontinuous. a 3. Let
(X,T) be a flow, and let S be a syndetic subgroup of T.
Suppose
(X,S) is equicontinuous. Then
4. Let
(X,T) be an equicontinuous minimal flow, where the group T
(X,T) is equicontinuous.
is abelian. Define a group structure as follows. Let
xo E X, and
(xot)(xos) = xOts (t,sE TI.
define multiplication on the orbit xoT by
Show that this multiplication is well defined and can be extended to all of X, so that X is a compact abelian group with identity xo.
Does
this procedure work if T is not abelian? 5. Later in this book, we will extensively study the regionally proximal
relation Q. This is defined by Q = n[ala if and only if for any neighborhood U of x there are x'
/3 E I$
E
U, y'
V, and t
E
E
E
31. Note that
(x,y) E Q
and V of y, and any T such that
(x't,y't)
E
8.
Show that the flow (X,T) is equicontinuous if and only if Q = A ( s o that
6. If
(X,T) has no non-trivial regionally proximal pairs).
(X,T) is any flow, let R denote the orbit closure relation, so
(x,y) E R
-
if and only if xT =
relation if and only if a) If
F.
Note that R
is an equivalence
(X,T) is pointwise almost periodic.
(X,T) is equicontinuous, then the orbit closure relation is
closed. b) The flow (X,T) is equicontinuous if and only if the orbit closure relation in (XxX,T) is closed (use exercise 5). 7. Suppose
(X.T) is equicontinuous and topologically transitive (every
invariant open set is dense).
Show that
(X,T) is minimal.
Equicontinuous Flows
47
t,al , . . . ,ak be non-zero real numbers and let
8. Let
there is a relatively dense (i.e., syndetic) subset A
> 0. Then
E
of integers such
-
m a 1 < c. i i (Let X 1 , . . . , X k be pairwise disjoint circles with circumferences k lall,.. . , lakl respectively, and let X = u Xi. Define a homeomorphism
that if n
E
there are integers ml,..,,mk and
A,
Int
i=l X+X
(p :
9. If
such that the cascade ( X , ( p ) (X,V)
is a uniform space, and
to itself, then @ a@ =
[(cp,+)l(p,+
and
E Q,,
t
@ = [n
It
(cp(x),+(x))
TI
E
Q,
generated by the family
a, x
E
XI,
where a
E
Y.
is equicontinuous if and only if the
(X,T) E
is a family of maps from X
@
is the uniformity on
Show that the flow collection
is equicontinuous.)
is totally bounded with respect to the above
uniformity. 10. Let
ft
E
C(X)
(X,T)
be a flow, and let f E C ( X ) .
with respect to
(X,T)
compact in C ( X ) . f
E
C(X)
ft(x) = f(xt).
be defined by
E
%.
that if 11.
Then there is an
<
E,
E
is relatively
(Use the Ascoli-Arzeli theorem as well as
X be a compact Hausdorff space, and let E
> 0, and a finite subset
for all
f E F, then
x+a, R (x) = x+B. Find conditions on a and 6 factor of Ra.
T, let
is almost periodic
TI
F of C ( X )
such
(x,y) E a.)
Consider the rotations of the circle defined by
B
E
(X,T) is equicontinuous if and only if all
Show that
are almost periodic.
If(x)-f(y)l
We say f
if the collection [ftlt
the following lemma: Let a
If t
so
a and 13: Ra(x) = that R
13
is a
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
49
Chapter 3 The Enveloping Semigroup of a Transformation Group, I The enveloping semigroup of a flow, which was introduced by Ellis, is
It has proved to be
a kind of compactification of the acting group.
extremely useful in the study of dynamical properties of transformation groups. The enveloping semigroup, as well as certain objects derived from it, will be used throughout the book.
In this chapter, we develop the elementary properties of the enveloping semigroup. We use it t o obtain the structure of equicontinuous minimal flows, and also indicate its connection with the proximal relat ion. If X
is a compact Hausdorff space, then Xx
denotes the collection
of all (not necessarily continuous) maps from X
to itself, provided
with the product topology, or, what is the same thing, the topology of pointwise convergence. By Tychonoff’s theorem, Xx
8,
If 5, E
Hausdorff.
is compact
we write x5, for the value of
E at x
the
“x’th“ coordinate of 5 ) .
Xx also has a semigroup structure defined by composition of maps: i f <,r)
E
Xx
then 5s
E
Xx is given by x(5,r))
=
(x<)(r)), (x E XI.
The semigroup Xx has rather limited continuity properties. that if xcn+x<,
(5,)
X is a net in X , then
for all x
(if x E X, xr)
E
X
is easy to see that
E
so
En+$.
X. Thus if E, +E,
and
n
xr)C;,-+xw$).
Enr)+Er),
If
in Xx
r)
r)
E
Recall
if and only if
X
X ,
then r)5,,-+~5,
is a continuous map, then i t
but in general 5,
nQ+
Thus Xx
is
not a topological semigroup. Now consider a transformation group, which for the moment we write
Chapter 3
50
?
=
(x
E
(where X
(X,T,n)
again as
t [ n It
E
TI
X, t
E
TI).
(recall nt Thus
f
'i:
T acts on Xx
7
and note that
regard
(E,T)
in X
X.
E(X,T)
Let
X . Thus E
is also compact Hausdorff.
(x)
by
(or E ( X )
ts
t
( ( I 1s = TZ
E
X X , t E TI
(s,tf TI),
is also invariant. Thus T acts on E,
so
E,
and we may
as a transformation group. Note that (as a special case of
convergence in
xX 1,
a net
if and only if xt +x< n
{ntn)
for all
We will usually identify t and write t
X
Let
xnt = xt
is defined by
is an invariant subset
?
the closure of
X+X
:
is a subset of
or E) be the closure of Recall that
is compact Hausdorff).
+<
n
x
E
i
converges to t: E E, n
t
n+<,
X.
T with the map n L which it defines,
E
instead of n
in
t
"+<.
Thus T
is regarded as a subset
X (and of X 1,
This is a slight abuse of notation, since it is t possible that s and t are distinct group elements, but nS = I of E
(that is, xs = xt, for all x
E
XI,
but this will usually not present
a problem. Moreover, if
{tn)
is a net in T and
refer to convergence in E
tn+t
(xt,+xt,
t
E
then tn- + t
T,
for all x
E
X).
will
Of course, if
with respect to the topology of T, then also tn+t
in E,
but not conversely (consider the example of the irrational flow on the torus). Now, let
5 , E ~E
and let
{sn) be a net fn T
with s - 9 . n
Then
E. Since E is closed, we have T q E E. Hence X E2 = EE c E, and E is a subsemlgroup of X . E is called the <s,+
and <sn
E
envelopinn seminroup (or Ellis seminroup) of the transformation group (X, TI.
We emphasize that while T
(or more precisely
is a group of
homeomorphisms of X to itself, the elements of E are, in general,
The Enveloping Semigroup of a Transformation Group, I
51
neither one to one nor onto nor continuous. The possession by
E of
these properties under various conditions is correlated with dynamical properties of the flow (X,T), as we shall see.
As a flow (E,T) is point transitive, that is, it has a dense orbit, since 3 = of
T
(=
-., , T)
=
E. In general, (E,T) is not minimal. Minimality
(E,T) also has dynamical implications.
It is easy to verify that E(XxX,T), "naturally" isomorphic with E(X) <,q E
E(X) then the expression
as well as E(E(X),T)
(see exercise 2 ) .
are
Therefore, if
is unambiguous - it has the same
meaning whether it is regarded as a semigroup product in E(X) q
1.
E
E(E(X))
xt +y. n
If y E
E(X).
(X,T) is a flow, and x
Proposition. If
Proof.
<E
acting on
n,
or as
{tn)
then there is a net
Let (a subnet of) t,+c
y = x< E xE. The proof that
xE c
E
X, then xE =
E
in T such that
E. Then xtn+x<.
a
n.
so
is similar.
Thus an advantage of the enveloping semigroup is that it allows us to replace arguments involving limits (y = xp, for some p
E
(y = lim xt ) n n
by equalities
E).
Now we use the enveloping semigroup to determine the structure of equicontinuous minimal flows. To this end, note that if flow, then T
t (or more precisely [ n It
subset of Cu(X,X),
E
(X,T) is any
TI) may be regarded as a
the collections of continuous maps from X
to
itself, with the topology of uniform convergence (as well as a subsetpf
XX , as discussed above).
If
(X,T) is equicontinuous (not necessarily
minimal) the uniform closure clU(T) = G, is a compact subset of C (X,X) by the Arzela-Ascoli theorem. Moreover, using elementary U
properties of uniform convergence, it is easily shown that G
is a
Chapter 3
52
topological group. For instance, if in T with t
-+c,
n
s
E
G
and
isn) are nets
{tn),
(uniformly!), then tns,-+
-+T)
n
maps from TxT-+G and XxT-+X. and
<,?I
Also the -1
(t,s)‘ts
defined respectively by
( x , t ) H x t are uniformly continuous, and so extend to continuous
maps of GxG+G,
and XxG-+X.
Thus G
is a compact topological group
and G acts as a group of homeomorphisms on X. Summarizing, we have proved: 2. Theorem. Let
(X,T) be an equicontinuous flow. Then there is a
compact group G and an action of G on X which extends the action of T. As
we observed in the preceding chapter, if a compact group G
on X, the action of C
acts
is equicontinuous, as is the action of any
subgroup T of G. The theorem just proved shows that all equicontinuous flows arise this way. (X,T) is equicontinuous, its enveloping
Next, we show that when semigroup coincides with G.
For let
j : Cu(X,X)+Xx
be the inclusion
map; clearly j is continuous. If clu and cl denote uniform and P pointwise closure, respectively, then j(clUT) = cl T (equality holds since cl T U
map,
so
G =
is compact).
E and
jlC is a homeomorpsism.
equicontinuous, and {tn) and only if tn+<
P That is, j ( G ) = E. But j is the inclusion Thus, if
is a net in T, then tn+<
(X,T) is pointwise if
uniformly.
We have therefore proved one direction of the following theorem. 3.
Theorem. A flow is equicontinuous if and only if its enveloping
semigroup is a group of homeomorphisms. The sufficiency, which is much deeper, wil chapter.
be proved in the next
The Enveloping Serniqroup of a Transformation Group, I
An equivalent formulation of this result is:
53
let G be a group of
homeomorphisms of the compact Hausdorff space X. Suppose’ G regarded
as a
subset of Xx, is compact. Then G acts equicontinuously on X.
4. Lemma. Let
(X,T) be a flow, with T abelian.
(1)
If p E E(X), t E T, pt = tp.
(2)
If
(X,T) is equicontinuous, E(X)
Proof. Let
{si) be a net in T with si-+p.
tsi+tp, sit-+pt (since t E T
Then tsi = s.t, 1
is continuous), and
tp = pt. This
The proof of ( 2 ) follows from (1) and the fact that all
proves (1). p E E(X)
is abelian.
are continuous, when
5. Lemma.
If
(X,T) is equicontinuous.
(X,T) is an equicontinuous flow, then the flow
(E,T)
is minimal. Proof.
(E,T), as a subflow of
X (X ,T) is equicontinuous, hence
pointwise almost periodic. Since (E,T) is also point transitive, it must be minimal.
(An easy direct proof of this lemma is also possible.) (X,T) is a flow, and x E X, the map
Note that if
p ~ x pdefines
a homomorphism of the flow (E,T) onto the subflow (3,T) of ( s o if
(X,T)
(X,T) is minimal, this map defines a homomorphism of E onto
XI. Now we are ready for the theorem on the structure of equicontinuous minimal flows. 6. Theorem. Let x E
X.
Let F = Fx = [p E E(X) Ixp =
of E(X).
XI.
Then F
is a closed subgroup
T acts on the space of left cosets [Fqlq E El, by
(Fq)t = F(qt) (t If T
(X,Tl be an equicontinuous minimal flow, and let
E
TI, and the flow (E/F,T) 1s isomorphic with
is abelian, F = {e}
and
(X,T) is isomorphic with
(X,T).
(E,T).
Chapter 3
54
Proof. Most of the assertions are obvious (or follow easily from the If T
previous discussion). xtp = xpt = xt, so
E
F, t
E
T, then
is the identity on xT. Since p
p
(X,T) and (Y,T) be flows and let
7. Theorem. Let
is continuous,
= X.
is the identity on
p
is abelian, p
71 :
X+Y
be an
onto homomorphism. Then there is a unique continuous semigroup homomorphism
8 : E(X)+E(Y)
(x E X, p
n(xp) = n(x)e(p)
such that
We write (just for this proof) TX and Ty
Proof.
E(X)).
E
for the maps defined
T on X and Y respectively, and endow TX and Ty with the Y topology and uniformity inherited from Xx and Y . Then the map
by
TX+Ty
8 :
defined by O(t) = t
is uniformly continuous (this is an
immediate consequence of the definition of flow homomorphism).
Thus 8
has a continuous extension, still called 8, to a continuous map of
E(X)
Since n(xt) = r(x)t = n(x)e t),
to E(Y).
(x E X, p
E
E(X)),
and n(xpq) = n(xp)0(q) = n(x)0(p)0(q).
n(xpq) = n(x)O(pq),
so,
TX is dense in E(X), If
I[
:
X+Y
the map e
E
is onto), 8(p)8(q) = 8(pq).
(since II
so the uniqueness of
notationally, and just write yp Thus we regard E(X)
this case, it is possible that p y
Also
0
Finally
is Immediate.
is a homomorphism of flows, we will frequently suppress
y E Y, p E E(X).
all
then ~ ( x p )= n(x)e(p)
1
#
p2
(instead of ye(p))
as acting on in E(X)
but
for
Y. Of course, in ypl = yp2,
for
Y (which is the case if and only if 8(p1) = 8(pz)).
The enveloping semigroup is particularly useful in studying proximality.
If
(X,T) is a flow recall (chapter 1) that
proximal if there is a net
xt + z n
and yt + z . n
{tn)
in T and z
x,y
E
X are
in X such that
The close connection of the enveloping semigroup
and proximality will be intensively studied in a later chapter. At this
The Enveloping Semigroup of a Transformation Group, I
55
point, we prove a simple proposition indicating this relation. (This is another example of how the enveloping semigroup enables us to replace
limits by equalities.) 8. Proposition. The points x and y
in X are proximal if and only
if xp = yp, for some p E E(X).
{tn)
Proof. Suppose x and y are proximal. Let let z E X such that xtn+z will still denote by
{tn),
and ytn+z. such that
tn+p
be a net in T and
Choose a subnet, which we E
E(X).
Then clearly
xp = z = yp. Conversely, if z = xp = yp, for some p E E, then there is a net
and x
itn)
in T, with t,+p,
so
xtn+xp
= z,
and ytn+z,
and y are proximal.
Exercises. Let
1.
(X,T) be a flow, with T abelian. Then the following are
equivalent: a) E(X)
is abelian.
b) All elements of E(X)
are continuous.
c) The action of T on every minimal subset of X 2. Let
in the following sense. If {tn)
E(X),
tn+F,
(X,T) be a flow. Show that E((E(X),T))
E
E(X)
if and only if tn+t
semigroup product q< E
E(E(x))
3. Let
is isomorphic with
is a net in T, then
E E(E(X)),
is equal to qg
and, if q E E(X),
the
the action of
on q E E(x).
(X,T) and
homomorphisms. Then to E(Y).
in E(X)
is equicontinuous.
(Y,T) be flows, and let K ~ , K: X+Y ~ A
1
and a2
be (onto)
induce the same homomorphism of E(X)
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 4 Joint Continuity Theorems This chapter is devoted to proving the theorem, due to Ellis, that a transformation group is equicontinuous if and only if its enveloping semigroup is a group of homeomorphisms, as well as several related theorems. The proof given here is essentially due to J.P. Troallic (Bull. SOC. Math. France 107 (19791, 127-137). If Y and 2 are topological spaces, C(Y,Z) will denote the to 2 provided with the topology
collection of continuous maps from Y
of pointwise convergence. Unless the contrary is stated, all topological notions in C(Y,Z) will be with regard to this topology.
If
(Z,?$)
is
denotes the uniformity on C(Y,Z) defined (Y,Z) [ ; l a E 31, where (f,g) E if and only if
a uniform space, then U by the base
(f(y),g(y)) E a, for all y E Y. We write
C (Y,Z) for this uniform U
space. Here (as elsewhere) we will frequently assume, without explicit mention, that an element of a uniformity is symmetric. 1.
Lemma. Let Y be a compact Hausdorff space, and let
Z
be a metric
space. Then (1)
A
A pointwise separable subspace
of C(Y,Z)
is uniformly
separable. (2) Let
H E C(Y,Z) and let f E
subset D of H such that f E (3) Let
subset of
fi.
Then there is a countable
6.
B be a non-empty subset of C(Y,Z) is a Baire space. Let
V
E
?l(y,z).
such that every closed Then there is an
f E B such that f Q B\V[fl. Proof.
(1) We will construct metrizable spaces
and.
2,
with
2
Chapter 4
58
separable, and a subset
such that, if A and
of C ( ? , z )
given the relative topology from Cu(Y,Z) then A Let
and
and CU(v.F)
are
respectively,
are homeomorphic.
D be a countable pointwise dense subset of
N
2
Y = Iff(yfffEAIyE Y] c ZA and
=
u f(Y) c
A.
Let
?
Note that
2.
is
fEA metrizable (since it is homeomorphic to its image in the metrizable space
ZD via the projection map
separable metric (since each f(Y) pointwise dense in A).
If g
= [ n lg E
@I
C
U
E
is a compact metric space and
A,
let
n
g
:
P+z
is
D
is
be the projection
A].
(I[
(?,s) is a separable metrizable space (since i
its subspace
so
2
((f(y))fEA) = g(y)), and let g It is easily checked that 2 and A are homeomorphic.
onto the g’th coordinate Y
A
and that
(f(y))fEAH(f(y))fED),
is separable. Since A
2
is separable metric),
is homeomorphic with
i, A
is separable.
(2) If h
(where d
E
H, and m
is the metric on 2 ) .
For fixed m
and n, the set
m,n} hEH is an open cover of Ym, which has a finite subcover
{‘h,
{Rh,m,n1heH . m, n f
and n are positive integers, let
E
Then D =
u
H is a countable subset of H and m,n m ~ n
E. (3)
Suppose first that B
is countable. Then
is pointwise
Let
separable, and therefore uniformly separable, by (1). countable uniformly dense subset. Then if
E
> 0,
c
Dc
u SCl2(f)
be a (where
fED
S (f) denotes the closed &
in Cu(Y,Z)).
g
c
u
S,/Z(f) feD
ball about
E
Now each Sc/Z(f) A
g.
Since
i?
A
k
f with respect to the metric
is pointwise closed and
is a Baire space there is an fo E D and
Joint Continuity Theorems
a non-empty (pointwise) open set such that Then if f
E w n
B, clearly f
e'
59
*
$I
w n
c Sc/2(fo) n
i.
B\SEo.
Now, let B be an arbitrary subset of C(Y,Z) and suppose the conclusion fails. Then there is an c > 0 such that f E B.
all that
f
E
By ( 2 ) , there is a countable subset Df
fJf.
D1
inductively by
defined, let Dn+l =
Ed
E
B\Sc(f),
of B\Sc(f)
Choose f E B and define a sequence D (n = 1,2, n
subsets of B
d E
f
= {f},
u
u
D\SEo,
for all
such
...
of
and, if D1,...,Dn have been
Db. Then D = Dn bEDn n=1,2,.. .
c Dn(B\Sc(d)) c
for
d E D.
is countable and
But this contradicts
the first part of the proof.
2. Lemma. Let X be a locally compact Hausdorff space, Y a compact Hausdorff space, and Z continuous, and let V
a uniform space. Let U
E
cp :
X+C(Y,Z)
be
Then there is a dense open set
(Y,Z)'
X such that if x E U, then cp-l(V[cp(x)I) Proof. We first suppose that Z
U
in
is a neighborhood of x.
is a metric space. Then we may suppose
that there is an c > 0 such that
V
< c, for all y
= [(f,,f,)ld(f,(y),f,(y))
U =
u
int cp
-1
(ScI2('p(a))). Then U
E
Yl.
Let
is open, and if
x
E
U,
acX cp-l(Sc(cp(x))) is a neighborhood of
x. To show that U is dense in X,
let o be a non-empty relatively compact open set in X. such that
cp(b)
e'
Let
(lemma 1, ( 3 ) ) . Since cp
(~(w)-S,/~(cp(b))
b E w is
~~
continuous, b so
0-cp
-1
(ScI2(cp(b))).
b E w n U. Therefore U
Hence b E int cp-1(Sc,2(cp(b)))
is dense in X.
Now consider the general case. The uniform structure by a family M
of pseudometrics on Z .
associated metric space, let and let
rm : C(Y,Z)+C(Y,Zm)
c U,
II
m
:
Z+Zm
For
m
E
A,
%
is defined
let Zm be the
be the canonical projection,
be defined by rm(f) = xmof. Now if
Chupter 4
60
there is a finite set ml, . . . , m E M such that (writing P YY,Z) for Zm , ri for rm , etc.) there are V, E 25 with L I i i i
P
n
(rixri)
-1
(V,) c V.
Let
'pi
= rioq
X-+C(Y,Z).
The,n
'pi
is
i=1
continuous, so applying the first part of the proof, there is an open set
Ui,
which is dense in X, such that
f
ui,
x e
is a cp~l(~i[(pi(x)~)
D
neighborhood of
x
E
3.
x.
U, cp-l(V[cp(x)l)
Then U =
U i=1 i
is open and dense in X, and if
is a neighborhood of x
is compact in the pointwise topology
(that is, in the topology induced on G
G on Y
Proof.
from C(Y,Y)).
Let
V
E ?1
(Y,Y)'
hgo E U.
By lemma 2, V[hgo]
gho, and it follows that VIgol
we regard
cp
a a map from G
Therefore G = cp(G)
G+C(Y,Y),
:
the
be a dense open set in G
and let U
satisfying the conclusion of lemma 2. Now let such that
Then the action
is equlcontinuous.
In lemma 2, take X = G, 2 = Y and cp
inclusion map.
of
X.
Theorem. Let G be a group of homeomorphisms of the compact
Hausdorff space Y, and suppose G
of
E
go
E
G
and choose h E G
is a (pointwise!) neighborhood
is a neighborhood of go.
to Cu(Y,Y),
then
'p
Thus, if
is continuous.
is compact in the uniform topology, and so by
Ascoli's theorem G acts equicontlnuously.
4. Theorem. Let
(X,T) be a transformation group, with X compact
Hausdorff, and suppose the enveloping semigroup E(X) homeomorphisms. Then Proof. Take C = E(X)
(X,T)
is a group of
is equicontinuous.
in theorem 3. Then G acts equicontinuously
and so does its subgroup T. In theorem 4, it is essential that E(X)
be a group (that is, all
elements are invertible), and not merely a semigroup of continuous maps.
Joint Continuity Theorems
X as the one point compactifica-
A simple example is provided by taking
tion of the reals ( s o X
is homeomorphic to the circle) and
the
(p
(p(x) = x+l for x real and the point
homeomorphism of X defined by at infinity w
61
a fixed point.
(X,(p)
The cascade
is certainly not
equicontinuous. However, the enveloping semigroup consists of the powers of
together with the constant map
(p
(x E X).
XHU
On the other hand, if we require minimality, the assumption that all are continuous is sufficient for equicontinuity. For
elements of E(X)
this we need a lemma, which says that if a flow is "pointwise equicontinuous" it is equicontinuous. We omit the simple proof.
5. Lemma. Let
(X,T) .be a transformation group, with
Hausdorff. Suppose, for every a neighborhood V
t
all
E
E
\,
X compact
and every x E X, there is a
of x, such that if y E V,
then
(xt,yt) E a, for
T. Then (X,T) is equicontinuous.
6. Theorem. Let
(X,T) be a minimal flow, and suppose that all
elements of E(X)
are continuous. Then
Proof. Let
(p :
X+C('E(X),X)
(x E X, p E E(X)). andlet
U E %
V = [ (f,g)I (f(p),g(p)) in X
hood of x.
So,
(E(X),X)
x s 0
E
hood of xos, so
x's
E
Wo
and
so E
El. By lemma 2, there is a dense
such that if x
E
U, W = (p-'(V[(p(x)])
if x'
U.
is continuous. Now, let
cp
p
E
E
a, all
W, ((p(x),(p(x'))
thing, (xp,x'p) E a, for all such that
(p(x)(p) = xp
be defined by
Since E(X) c C(X,X),
V=ae'U
open set U
(X,T) is equicontinuous.
Let Wo =
-1
Wos
p E E. cp
-1
V, or what is the same
E
Let
xo E X, and let s E T
(V[(p(x,s)l).
Then Wo
is a neighborhood of
(x st,x'st) E a for all 0
a neighborhood of xo such that
t
is a neighbor-
E
T.
xo,
so if
is a neighbor-
-1 x' E Wos ,
That is, W* = W s-l 0
if x' E W*, (xt,x't) E a, for all
is
Chapter 4
62 T E
T. It follows from lemma 5 that
(X,T) is equicontinuous.
7. Theorem. Let T be a locally compact Hausdorff space with a group
structure for which group multiplication is separately continuous, and suppose T acts on the compact Hausdorff space X continuous manner.
(That is. the defining map x
in a separately :
XxT+X
separately continuous.) Then the action of T on X
is
is jointly
cont inuous. Proof. Let imply that
cp : cp
T-+C(X,X)
be defined by cp(t)(x)
=
xt. The hypotheses
is continuous. It is sufficient to show that cp
continuous when it is regarded as a map from T to Cu(X,X).
is This is
accomplished, using lemma 3, as in the proof of theorem 7. In theorem 7, we may assume that the space X is locally compact Hausdorff. For, if Xu = X u {d is the one point compactification of X, we may extend the action of T to Xw by defining ot = w (t
E
TI.
Then theorem 7 can be applied to the action of T on Xu. The hypotheses of theorem 6 cannot be weakened to "all elements of a minimal right ideal are continuous." For consider the minimal flow
is the circle, and T is the total homeomorphism group.
(X,T) where X
The unique minimal right ideal in E(X,T)
consists of the collection of
constant maps, but the flow (X,T) is not equicontinuous (in fact, i t is a proximal flow
-
all pairs x and y in X are proximal).
8. Theorem. Let X be a compact Hausdorff space which has a group
structure and suppose that multiplication is separately continuous. Then
X is a topological group. Proof. Let X act on itself (on the right) by
( x , y ) ~ x y . By
assumption, this action is separately continuous. I t follows from theorem 7 that the action is jointly continuous. Thus multiplication in
Joint Continuity Theorems
X
63
is jointly continuous. Continuity of inversion follows easily, using
the compactness of X, from the joint continuity of multiplication. The conclusion of theorem 8 still holds if it is only assumed that X is locally compact. Using the remark following theorem 7, it is shown,
just as in the proof of theorem 8, that multiplication in X
is jointly
continuous. The proof that inversion is continuous is somewhat more involved. A proof was given by Ellis (Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 8 (19571, 372-373). Theorems 3, 4, 7, and 8 are also due to Ellis (Duke Math. Jour.
24 (19571, 119-125). Other proofs of Ellis' theorems are by Namioka (Pacific Jour. Math. (Acta Math.
(19741, 515-531) and de Leeuw and Glicksberg
10s (19611, 63-97).
The latter proof is reproduced in the
book Weakly almost periodic functions
on seminroups, by
R.B. Burckel
(Gordon and Breech, 1970). Theorem 6 is a "folk theorem." The author has not seen it in print.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
65
Chapter 5 Distal Flows In this chapter, we begin the systematic study of distal flows, which were mentioned briefly in chapter 1.
These are generalizations of
equicontinuous flows, and, as we shall see, these two classes of flows have some common properties. Chapter 7 will be devoted to the striking structure theorem for distal minimal flows, due to H. Furstenberg. Recall that a flow (X,T) pairs.
That is, if
is distal if it has no non-trivial proximal
x,y E X with x
#
y, then there is an a E
(depending on x and y, of course) such that
t
E
T.
If
and only if
(xt,yt) Q a, for all
(X,d) is a (compact) metric space, then inf d(xt,yt) > 0 whenever x teT
#
%
(X,T) is distal if
y.
It is easy to see that equicontlnuous flows are distal. For, suppose (X,T)
is equicontinuous, and x,y E X are proximal.
let 6 E
3
such that 6T c a.
Let
t
(x,y) = (xt,yt)t-' E 6~ c a. Since a E
E
Let a
E
I$,
and
T such that (xt,yt) E 6,
I$
so
is arbitrary, it follows
that x = y. A simple example of a non-equlcontinuous distal flow is provided by a
disk rotated at different rates around a common center. Precisely, consider the homeomorphism
(p
of the disk D
in the plane given by
(p(r,e) = (r,e+r) ((r,e) are polar coordinates). Clearly the cascade (D,(p)
is distal.
(If two points are on different circles, their orbits
remain on these circles, and on a given circle, see that
(D,(p)
multiple of
II
(p
is a rotation.) To
is not equicontinuous, choose r to be a rational and let n
J
be a sequence of integers tending to
infinity such that nJr is an even multiple of
II,
say
nJr
= 2 mJ- n *
Chapter 5
66
Let
E .
=
n n,
and let r = r+c j
j'
so
(r e ) + ( r , e ) ,
J'
but
J~
cpnJ(r,e)= (r,8+2m n) and (pnj(r , e l = (r 6+(2m.+l)n). Hence the J J j' J cascade (D,cp)
is not equicontinuous. The construction of minimal
distal flows which are not equicontinuous is more difficult, and will be undertaken later in the chapter. Before continuing the discussion of distal flows, we will consider the proximal relation in some detai;.
The results obtained will also be used
in later chapters. The proximal relation in or
P(X) o r Px).
(X,T) will be denoted by
That is, P = [(x,y)
E
P (or P(X,T)
XxXIx and y are proximall.
P is obviously a reflexive symmetric and T invariant relation ((xt,yt) E P whenever (x,y) E P I ,
but, as we shall see in later
chapters is not in general transitive or closed. If x E X, the proximal set of y E X such that
a distal point.
of x, denoted by P(x)
(x,y) E P. If P(x) = {x),
is the
or XP
then x
is called
(So the flow (X,T) is distal if all points are distal
points; equivalently if P = A. 1 Minimal flows with distal points ("point distal flows") will be considered in a later chapter. Although the proof is simple, the following proposition is,very useful.
It may be paraphrased as:
"proximality and almost periodicity
(in the product space) are incompatible."
1.
Proposition. Let
(X,T) be a flow.
periodic point in XxX, with x Proof. Suppose
y, then x and y
are distal.
(x,y) is an almost periodic point and that x
are proximal. Then there is a net that
If (x,y) is an almost
(x,y)ti+(z,z).
{ti)
in T and a point
z
and y E
X such
Since (x,y)T = (z,z)T is a minimal subset of
Distal Flows
XxX, (x,y) E (z,z)T. But
A,
so
67
is obviously a subset of the diagonal
x = y,
In the next proof (and also in the discussion of universal minimal flows) we will use the notion of an almost periodic set. a flow. Then a subset A whenever D
Let
of X is called an almost periodic set if,
is a set whose cardinality equals that of A,
with range z = A,
(X,T) be
and z
E
XD
then z is an almost periodic point of the flow
D (X ,TI. It is clear that this definition depends only on the subset A Naively, the point z
may be thought of as A
of X.
"spread out" to a point
in a product space. 2. Lemma. Let
(X,T) be a flow, and let A
be an almost periodic set
in X. Then there is a maximal (with respect to inclusion) almost periodic set B such that A c B. Proof. Let 5 denote the collection of almost periodic sets in X which contain A.
Since a neighborhood in a product space depends on
only finitely many coordinates, 5
is of finite character, and we may
apply Zorn's lemma to obtain a maximal element (actually, we apply Tukey!s lemma; see Kelley, General TODO~ORY). 3.
Theorem. Let
(X,T) be a flow and let x
E
X.
Then there is an
almost periodic point x* which is proximal to x. Proof. If x
is almost periodic, take x* = x.
maximal almost periodic subset of X, denotes the cardinality of A)
and let z
If not, let A E
with range z = A.
X I*'
be a
(where !A]
Consider
w = (z,x)E XtA'xX. Note that there is an almost periodic point of the form w* = (z,x*) E 3. For if (zf',x*)E periodic, then z"
E
with
(z".xf')
almost
5, which is a minimal set and, if z"tn+z
Chapter 5
68
then ( a subnet of) x"tn-+x*
and
is an almost periodic point, so
A
(z",x")t +(z,x*). n
u {x*)
periodic set. By maximality of A
for some net
(sn)
in T, we have
(x,x*) E P. Now z
= range z u {x*)
we must have x* E A.
appears as one of the coordinates of
x*
Now
z.
-+x* n
XIS
Since
(z,x*)
is an almost That is to say,
(z,x)sn+(z,x*)
and xs +x*, n
is almost periodic, and therefore x*
so
is almost
periodic, and the proof is completed. Every known proof of this theorem requires the use of a "large" product space (another proof will be given in the next chapter).
It
would be interesting to find a direct proof. Proposition 1 and theorem 3 have the following useful corollary.
4. Corollary. Let (i)
(X,T) be a flow. Then
If the product flow
(XxX,T) is pointwise almost periodic,
(X,T) is distal. (ii)
If x
(iii) I f
E
is a distal point, it is an almost periodic point.
X
(X,T) is distal, it is pointwise almost periodic.
Now, returning to our discussion of distal flows per se, we have the following simple lemma. 5. Lemma. - Let
(Xi,T) ( i E 9 ) be a family of distal flows (with the
same acting group TI. Then
(TD(
i
i
,TI is distal if and only if every
(Xi,T) is distal. Proof. Suppose some yj
f
yi.
(X T)
J'
Let x,x' E TMi
is not distal. Let
(y.,y'.) E P(X ) with J J be such that xj = yj, xj = yj and xi = xi
i
for i E 4 with
i
#
j. Then clearly
(x,x')
E
P(X).
The converse is
obvious. The next theorem provides several conditions which are equivalent to distality.
Distal Flows
6. Theorem. Let
69
(X,T) be a transformation group. Then the following
are equivalent: (i)
(X,T) is distal.
(ii)
(Xa,T) is distal, for all cardinal numbers a
(iii) (Xa,T) is distal, for some cardinal number
2 1.
a 2 1. a 2 1.
(iv)
(Xa,T) is pointwise almost periodic, for all
(v)
(P,T) is pointwise almost periodic, for some a
(vi) The enveloping semigroup E(X)
h
2.
is a group.
Proof. The equivalence of ( 1 1 , (ii) and (iii) follows from lemma 5, and these conditions imply (iv) by corollary 4, (iii). implies (v).
If (v) holds, then
pointwise almost periodic, and distal. Thus (i Suppose E(X)
(XxX,T), as a factor of
so,
by corollary 4 , ( I ) ,
(Xa,T) is
(X,T) is
- (v) are equivalent. is a group, and let
of chapter 3) xp = yp, for some p (yp1p-l = y, and X
almost periodic. If almost periodicity of
(x,y) E P. Then (by proposition 7
E
E(X),
so
x = (xp)p-' =
is distal.
Finally, suppose (iv) holds. p
E
E(X),
X (X ,TI, e
Thus e = pq, for some q inverse, and E
Obviously (iv)
E
E.
X Then the flow (X ,T) is pointwise p E
E
a, so
by the assumed pointwise
= pE
(chapter 3, proposition 1).
Thus every element of E has a right
is a group. This completes the proof.
7. Corollary. (a) A distal flow is equicontinuous if and only if all elements of its enveloping semigroup are continuous maps. (b) A distal flow is minimal if and only if it is point transitive (has a dense orbit). (c) A factor of a distal flow is distal. Proof.
(b) is an immediate consequence of the pointwise almost
Chapter 5
70
periodicity of distal flows. To prove (a),use theorem 4 in the “Joint continuity theorems” chapter. If Y is a factor of the distal flow X, then YxY is a factor of the pointwise almost periodic flow X x X . Obviously YxY
is pointwise almost periodic so
Y
is distal.
Theorem 6 underlines some of the similarities of distal and equicontinuous flows - both are pointwise almost periodic and, for both classes of flows, the enveloping semigroup is a group. Partly for these reasons, it was conjectured at one time that distal minimal flows were necessarily
equicontinuous. Counterexamples will be presented at the end of the chapter. However, there is a deep connection between distal and equicontinuous minimal flows. The Furstenberg structure thereom, which we will state and prove in the next chapter, asserts that any distal minimal flow arises from an equicontinuous flow by a (possibly transfinite) sequence of “almost periodic“ o r “equicontinuous”extensions. In particular, a distal minimal flow always has a nontrivial equicontinuous factor. We now “relativize“the notion of distal. Let n homomorphism of flows. Then n whenever r(xl 1 = n(x2),
E
X-+Y be a
is said to be distal provided that
with x1
(Equivalently, f (x,,x2)
:
f
x
2’
P, with x1
then x1 and x are distal 2
*
x2, then n ( x , l
* n(x2)).
In this case, we also say that X is a distal extension of Y. Note that X
is a distal extension of the trivial (one point) flow if and
only if X is a distal flow. 8.
Proposition. A distal extension of a distal flow is distal.
Proof. Let n
:
X+Y
be a distal hofnomorphism with
Suppose (x1,x2) E Px. Then (n(x1),n(x2)) n(xl) = n(x,),
and since n
E
Y distal.
Py. Since Y is distal
is distal, it follows that
x1 = x2.
Distal Flows
71
A relatively simple way to obtain distal extensions is by means of Cartesian products. Let and let
(Y,T) and
X onto Y is a
X = YxZ. Then clearly the projection of
distal homomorphism. periodic.
If Y
2 distal,
(Z,T) be flows, with
is minimal, then X
is pointwise almost
(This is proved most easily using the enveloping semigroup
although it is also possible to give a proof using almost periodic sets.
A more general result will be given in theorem 15 of chapter 7.) Thus any minimal subset of X
is also a distal extension of Y.
An important subclass of the distal extensions are the group extensions, which were defined in chapter 1. bitransformation groups
(G,X,T)
is the orbit space, on which T
Recall that these arise from is compact, and that Y = X/G
where G acts by
(Gxlt = Uxt) (t
also that the group extension is said to be free if g implies gx
f
x f o r all
E
E
G
TI. Recall
with g
e
f
x E X.
9. Proposition. A free group extension is distal.
Proof. Let Y = W G be the natural map. some g E G.
If
as in the above discussion and let Thus n ( x ) = dx')
so
X+X/G
=
Y
if and only if x' = gx for
(x,x') = (x,gx) is proximal, there is a net {tn)
T and z E X such that xtn+z, g(xtn)+gz,
R :
(gx)t +z. n
But also
a
(gx)tn =
gz = z. By freeness, g = e, and x' = x.
In fact, as we shall see in a later chapter, group extensions are "almost periodic" extensi ons. Now we present a criterion for minimality of a class of group extensions of minimal cascades. Let
(Y,T) be a minimal cascade ( s o
homeomorphism of
Y and not a group).
group, and let cp
:
Y+G
Let
C
be a continuous map.
T
is a
be a compact abelian If X = Y x G ,
a homeomorphism S of X by S(y,g) = (T(y),p(y)g).
we define
Obviously, the
Chapter 5
72
projection
( y , g ) ~ ydefines a group extension of Y. The cascade
skew product.
(X,S) is called a
The following theorem, which gives a necessary and sufficient condi(X,S), involves the character group of G.
tion for the minimality of
Let K be the unit circle in the complex plane, K = [ z E CCIlzl = 11. Then G, the character group of G, is the multiplicative group of A
continuous homomorphisms of
G to K
(if yl,r2
(rl;yl)(g)= yl(g)r2(g)).
is defined by
E
,.
G then' r l r 2 E G
The identity of G
(the
n
"trivial character"), denoted by ;r = 1, f o r all
g
E
is the
E
G with r ( g ) = 1
G.
(Y,T) be a minimal cascade and suppose
10. Theorem. Let
(X,S) are as above. Then the cascade
r
E G
with
r
and
(X,S) is minimal if and only i f
the functional equation f(T(y)) = g(cp(y))f(y) solution f : Y+K,
G, cp
has no continuous
1
f
Proof. Suppose the functional equation has a solution f f o r some
continuous S invariant function on X.
If
would have t o be constant. Buf, if g
G such that z(g)
F(y,g)
f
F(y,e), so
(h
E
G),
(X,S).
M
(so
f
1, then
(X,S) is not minimal.
Conversely, suppose subset of X
E
(X,S) were minimal, F
#
(X,S) is not minimal.
X).
Let
M be a minimal
Now, if G acts on X by h(y,g) = (y.hg)
then hS = Sh, and C acts as a group of automorphisms of So,
hM n M = 4.
if h
E
G, hM
is a minimal subset of X and hM = M or
If H = [h E ClhM = MI,
G. Moreover, H
#
C. For, let
n(y,g) = y. Since Y
11
:
then H
X+Y
is a closed subgroup of
be the projection
is minimal, n(M) = Y, so, if y
E
Y. (y,g) E M,
Distal Flows
If H = G, (y,g) E M, for all g
for some g E G.
that M = YxG = X and
,. E G,
let
f E C(Y) (y,g') g'g-'
r(g'g
so
where
(y,g) E M.
-1
1
=
1, r(g) = r(g').
so
(so
f(y) = r(g).
f(yn)-+f(y).
f(yn) = r(gn)), Since
nM
fl
4, g'g-lM
lim f(yn)
let (a subnet of)
exists.
= r((p(y))f(y),
If
(yn,gn)-+(y,g)
M,
E
so
(y,g) E M, S(y,g) = (T(y),(p(y)g)
f(T(y1) = r((p(y)g) = r(cp(y))r(g)
M, and
be a net in Y with yn-+y.
{y } n
r is continuous, r(gn)+r(g),
Finally, if
=
Thus f is well defined.
is compact, we may suppose that
(yn,gn) E M
Note that if also
(g'g-')M
so
To show that f is continuous, let Since K
G, and it follows
1 such that r(h) = 1, for h E H. Define
f
by f(y) = r(g),
H,
E
with
E
(X,S) is minimal, contrary to hypothesis. Now,
M, g'g-l(y,g) = (y,g'),
E
13
and f
E
M
so
is a solution of
the functional equation. We apply the theorem just proved to show the minimality of a class of skew products on
Kk+1,
the
(k+l) torus, namely
k-1 z)wk)
T(z,wl,. . . ,wk) = (az,(p(z)wl,(p(/3z)w2,.. . ,p(P where a,@ E K and
(p :
K+K
extension of K.
as a Kk
must choose a,P and
(p
are to be chosen. Here we regard
Since the character group of Kk
so
k is Z ,
Let
w
E
*
..
f
0 for every
with integral coefficients. Choose @ E K not a root of
unity and let N = [ l < n(1) < n(2) < such that
if
(0,. ,O).
K be non-algebraic. That is, p(w)
polynomial p
I@n(i)-wl
< T1 ,
for i L 1.
such that for some constant c,
n
., . 1
be a sequence of integers
Choose a not a root of unity
la -11 I
C
-,2
for n
in a subsequence
n of N.
we
that the functional equation f(az) =
(p(~)~~(p(f3z)~~. . .(p(pkz)mkf(z) has no continuous solution f : K+K,
(mo,ml,.. . , \ I
Kk+ 1
(We will show below how to obtain such a). Still call this
Chapter 5
74
subsequence N.
Let
rn
and define H(z) =
n anz . n=-cu
C
Now
C lan I
converges uniformly on K, and H(z)
- -H(z) = zanzn = cp(z1
=
Ca-,z-”
= H(z),
so
S
cC-12 <
rn,
so
the series
n
is continuous. Moreover,
H(z)
is real valued. We define
exp(2niH(z)). If f
Now, suppose the functional equation has a solution f. degree
e,
then f(z) =
ze
exp[2zig(z)l,
e
= aexp[2ni(g(az)-g(z))l,
uous. f(az)/f(z)
where g : K-+W
is of
is contin-
2nie and (writing a = e 1
there is a solution if and only if there is an integer u such that k eQ+g(az)-g(z) = moH(z)+mlH(f3z)+. . .+mkH(i3 z ) + u . Let g ( z ) have the
-
n C(an-l)bnzn, Fourier series g(z) ,..Cbnz , SO g(az)-g(z) jn n m.H(PJz) = E m anS z , and comparing coefficients for n # 0 we obtain J n J n n ( a -l)bn = an(mo+mlf3 +. . .+mkgnk) = anp(pn) (where p(A) =
k
C miAi 1.
i =o
n Now, if n E N, an = a -1 Hence C(bn12 =
#
* 0.
0, and we have bn = p(pn)-+p(w)
m.
This is a contradiction, since the sum of the squares of the Fourier
coefficients of a continuous function always converges.
To construct a satisfying the required properties, proceed as follows. It is sufficient to find an irrational number a such that
la
-
mml3’ m(i) r(i) I
and some integer r(i).
for some subsequence { m ( 1 ) )
in [ O , l l of
{n( i I ) ,
(The equivalence of this with the.origina1
Distal Flows
problem is an elementary exercise).
Put
75
m(1) = n(l),
and let
Il(j)
be the closed interval
m(1)-1
u
F1 =
Let
j=l
and let
Choose m(2) = n(i21
Il(j),
12(k) =
[m k - - - +1
k
such that
2
1
mo < -m(1) 3’
, 1 5 k 5 m(2)-1,
and
m(2) m(2)-1
F
u
=
IZ(k).
Note that each
k=l of the form
12(k).
I 1 (j) contains at least two intervals
Proceeding in this way, choose m(i) 2
mo < -
original sequence) so that
(from the
1
m( i-1)
2’
m
contains at least two
Ii-1
the same cardinality as
(r). Then
n Fi
is a subset of
[O,.ll with
i=l
[0,1], and so this intersection contains an
irrational number a. Obviously a has the required properties. The cascades just constructed are in general not equicontinuous. This
is a consequence of a more general theorem on coalescence of equicontinuous flows (see the exercises to this chapter). For now, we note that the cascade on K‘,
T(z,w) = (az,zw) ( a is not a root of unity) is
distal, minimal, and not equicontinuous. Distality and minimality follow as before. k
f
k (The functional equation in this case is f(az) = z f(z),
0; its nonsolution is proved by a simple Fourier series argument, or
by an elementary argument involving degree).
To see that the cascade
(K2,T) is not equicontinuous. note that, f o r n > 0, n(n-1)
Tn (z,w) = ( anz , a
Tn ( z , w ) n
znw), n(n-1)
= ( anzn,-a
w).
and let Now
z = exp($). n
(zn,1)+(l,w),
Then but
Chapter 5
76
ITn(1,w)-Tn(zn,w) I 2 2, so the cascade is certainly not equicontinuous.
Now we turn to a discussion of (real) flows on three dimensional nilmanifolds. These are homogeneous spaces of nilpotent Lie groups. We present here an ab initio treatment, which does not depend on the theory of Lie groups.
We begin by discussing coset flows in general.
G be a topological group, and let H be a closed subgroup of
Let
G. Consider the right coset space G/H = [Hglg E GI,
with the
uniformity defined by the collection 21 = [orvIV E 31,
(where 3
neighborhood system of the identity e a
V
= [(Ha,Hb)la,b E
G, b-’a E V).
and
Note that a neighborhood base of
Hg
is given by the collection [HVglV E 91.
in G/H
We will usually suppose that
K
where
in GI,
is the
is compact).
H is a syndetic subgroup of C
In this case, the coset space G/H
Note that G acts transitively on C/H
by
(G =
HK,
is compact.
(Hg,g‘)H(Hglg’ =
H(gg’) (g,g‘) E G I . The next theorem gives criteria for the action of C on G/H
to be
distal. Theorem. Let
11.
H be a syndetic subgroup of the topological group
G. Then the following are equivalent. (a) (G/H,G) is distal. (b) H =
n HUH
(where, as above, 3 denotes the neighborhood system
UEY
of e
in GI.
(c) If g 4 H, e 4
Proof. (i)
m.
The proof is carried out by noting that each of the statements
- (xii) below
is equivalent to the one following.
(i)
(G/H,C) is distal.
(ill
Whenever Hgl
f
HgZ, and g3 E G, there is a U E 3 ’
such that
Distal Flows
77
G not both Hglg E Hug3 and Hg g E Hug3. 2 -1 (iii) If g g g E G such that glgz d H, there is a U € 9 such 1' 2' 3
if g
E
that if g
(iv)
G not both glg E Hug3 and g g E Hug3. 2 -1 If g1,g2 E G with g1g2 e H, there is a U E
-1 -1 gl HU n g2 HU =
g g-'HU 12
A
9 with
E
9 such that
+.
-1 d H, there is a U If g1,g2 E G with g1g2
(v)
E
HU = 4.
(vi)
If g d H, there is a U
E
9
(vii)
If g d H, there is a U
E
9 such that g d HUH.
(viii) 'H c
such that
gHU
A
HU = @.
u (HUH)'. UE9
n HUH. UEB
(ix)
H
(XI
H =
(xi)
If g d H, there is a U
E
9 with g d HUH.
(xii) If g d H, there is a U
E
3 such that
3
n HUH U€9
(xiii) If g
[1
e H, e
:]
(this is (b)).
t
U n HgH =
m.
Now, let G denote the group of upper triangular 3x3 G =
0
lal,a2,a3E R]
1: 0
+.
(G
matrices,
is the "Heisenberg group"),
and let
H be the closed subgroup of G whose entries are integers. Then G and H are homeomorphic with lR3
1
syndetic in G.
of those
0
1:
and P3
respectively and H
is
(It is easily checked that G = HK, when K consists with 0 Sk. 5 1.) We will sometimes write 1
0
(al,a2,a3) for an element of C. (al+bl.a2+b2,a3+b3+alb2) ( s o
e = (O,O,O), and
Note that
(a a a ) (bl,b2,b3) = 1' 2' 3
G and H are not abelian, the identity
(al,a2,a3I-l= (-al,-aZ,-a 3+a1a21.
We apply 11 to show that
(C/H,G) is distal. by showing
Chapter 5
78
e = (O,O,O) d
HgH
f o r all
g Q H.
a = (a1,a2,a31, b = (bl,b2,b3),
Let
g = (g1,g2,g3) with a,b E H. Then agb = (al+gl+bl,aZ+g2+b2,a3+b3+g3+alg2+alb2+g1b2).Now
i = 1,2,3. If gl Q Z,
f o r at least one
to
0
(since al+gl E Z ) ,
then g3
ct
1 2 3
E G,
12. Lemma. G = H(h(Ra)),
H,
is never
we write Ra = [al,al+l)x[a ,a +l)x[a 2
for every a
2
a +l). 3' 3
E G.
g = (gl,g2,g3)E C.
hl = al-g1+a2, h2
If h
with k E Z
E
1 be defined by h(g) = (g,,g2,g3+2g1g2).
If a = (a ,a ,a )
B.
= k+g3
If g1,g2
so e P HgH.
Let A : G 4 C
Proof. Let
b +g
+g
gi d Z
then al+gl+bl is never close
and similarly if g2 Q Z.
Z, and a +b +a g +a b
close to 0 ,
g P H, so
-
Then there are 6 ,6 , 6 E [0,1) with 1 2 3 1 a2-g2+62, h3 = a3+63+-2 (a 1+61)(a 2+62 1-83-h1 g2 all in
= (hl,h2,h3), then
hg = (a +6 ,a +6 a +6 a ( ' + +6 )(a2+62)) E A(Ra). 1 1 2 2'3 3 2 1 1 Now let cp
:
GxlR-+G
be defined by
1 1 2 (alt,a2t,(a --a a It++ a t 1. 3212 2 1 2
cpa(t)pa(s)
= pa(t+s),
so,
A routine computation yields
f o r each a E G, pa
Note also that cp ( 1 ) = (a a a 1, a 1' 2' 3 subgroup of C
so
:
is a homomorphism.
R+C
9, defines the one parameter
"through" a.
13. Lemma. Let G = H'p(UxlR+)
cp(a,t) = 'pa(t) =
U be a non-empty open subset of G.
(where R+ =
Proof. Note that
Then
[O,m)).
h-l(gl.g2.g3) = (gl,g2,g3-plg2), 1 so
h-1cp(x,t). = (xlt,x2t,( X ~1- ~ X ~ X ~ )and ~ ) ,h-ldUxR+) =
r(ylt,y2t,y3t)iy = (y1,y2,y3) E A non-empty open subset of C. that there is an a E C with Then G = H(X(Ra))
c Hv(UxR+).
-1
(u), t. 2 0 1 .
NOW
A-'(u)
is a
It follows from the above representation
Ra
c A-'p(UxR+),
SO
h(Ra)
C
'p(UxlR+).
Distal Flows
If a
E
79
G, we define an action of R on C/H by
Since Ipa(t)lt
E
R]
is a subgroup of C,
(Hglt = Hgcp (t). a
the flow defined by
is
cp
a
distal. 14.
Theorem. For all a
E
C outside of a first category set, the flow
defined by the one parameter subgroup cp a
is distal, minimal, and not
equicont inuous. Proof. We have just observed that these flows are distal. prove that cpa defines a minimal orbit. To this end, let UI,Uz,..
Therefore, to
low it is sufficient to find a dense be a countable base for G, and let
E~ = [a E GI~~,(IR+I n H U = ~ 41. we show that En is closed and has no interior.
If a
E
,:E
open in G and cp
pa(t)
E
HU,
for some t
R+.
E
Since Hun
is
is continuous it follows that EE is open, and En
is closed. Now, suppose En contains a non-empty open set U. lemma, G = Hcp(UxR+).
so
Un c Hcp(UxR+)
and Hun n cp(UxlR+)
Equivalently, there is a d E U c En such that contradicts d
E
By the previous
4.
f
qd(R+I n Hun
f
4.
This
En. m
Thus En
u
is closed with no interior and so
En n=1
^Hun
category set. If a E (uEnIc = nEz, cpa(!R+l
and it follows that the 9, orbit of the coset H This proves minimality of the flow defined by
*
4,
is a first for every n,
is dense in C/H.
(pa.
Finally, we show that these minimal flows cannot be equicontinuous. In fact, the space G/H
cannot support
equicontinuous minimal flow
with an acting abelian group. For, if the flow were minimal equicontinuous, the coset space G/H group.
would have the structure of a compact abelian
However, the fundamental group z1(C/H)
non-abelian group H
(since H
is isomorphic with the
is discrete, the natural map of G
to
Chapter 5
80
G/H
is a covering map, with fiber homeomorphic to
H, and so
Since a topological
regarded as the group of covering transformations). group has an abelian fundamental group, G/H
H may be
cannot support a group
structure, and the proof is complete. These examples were constructed by L. Auslander, F. Hahn, and
L. Markus, and were the first examples of distal minimal flows which are not equicontinuous. Their work in this general area is cdntained in the monograph, Flows on homoveneous sDaces, (Annals of Math. Studies, No. 53, Princeton University Press, 1963). An interesting historical sidelight is that at the time they were not aware of the notion of distal, but were
trying to construct minimal actions of the real line on nilmanifolds. They were able to produce dense orbits, but could not prove minimality. W.H. Gottschalk suggested that these examples might be distal (and therefore necessarily minimal). The examples of skew products on the torus, which are actually simpler than the flow on nilmanifolds were shown to be distal, minimal, and nonequicontinuous later (by Furstenberg), although they had been considered many years earlier in the ergodic theory literature. The particular skew products on
Kk+1
discussed in this chapter were
first considered by Parry and Walters (Compositio Math., 22 (1970, 283-288) who used them t o obtain non-coalescent distal minimal flows
(exercise 4 ) . Exercises. 1.
The flow (X.T) is distal if and only if the flow (E(X),T)
is
minimal.
2. Let
(X,T) be a distal flow, let u E 'I$, and let F be a finite
subset of X. Then there is a syndetic subset A
of T such that
Distal Flows
xA c xu, for x 3. Let
81
F
E
be a syndetic subgroup of T.
(X,T) be a flow, and let S
Then x,y E X are proximal with respect to the action of T if they are proximal with respect to S .
Thus
(X,T) is distal if and
only if
(X,S) is distal.
4.
(X,T) be a distal minimal flow. If x
F
X
Let
= [p E E(X)Ixp =
with cp(x) = y
XI.
E
X, let
Then there is an endomorphism
if and only if Fx c F
Y’
and
if and only
(p
(p
of
(X,T)
is an automorphism if
and only if Fx = F
Y‘
5. A minimal flow is said to be coalescent if every endomorphism is an automorphism. a) Equicontinuous minimal flows are always coalescent.
(Define a
quasi-ordering - a transitive, but not necessarily anti-symmetric relation) on X by x 5 y elements of E(X) xo.
If
(p
if Fx CF
Y‘
Use the continuity of
to prove the existence of a maximal element
is an endomorphism and y0 = cp(xo),
then Fx = 0
F , YO
so
cp
is an automorphism.
b) Distal minimal flows are not necessarily coalescent. Consider the homeomorphism S
of the infinite torus defined by
where a l p , and
(p
in this chapter.
(Then the cascade
are as in the skew product example presented (Km,S) is the inverse limit
of the skew products on finite dimensional tori, so distal and minimal. 1 Let R
:
Km+Km
R(z,w1,w2,.. . ) = (@z,w2,w3,.. . 1.
(Km,S) is
be defined by
Then R
is an endomorphism of
(Km,S) which is obviously not an automorphism.
It follows also
Chapter 5
82
that
(Km,S) is not equicontinuous, and therefore (for all
sufficiently large n) the distal minimal cascades on Kn
are
not equicontinuous. 6. Show that the cascade
a root of unity)
(K2 , S )
is minimal.
defined by
S(z,w) = (az,zw) ( a not
Determine the regionally proximal relation
in this example. 7. Let
(X,T) be a distal minimal flow which is not equicontinuous.
Show that the enveloping semigroup E(X) theorem 13 of chapter 2 . )
is not metrizable.
(Hint: use
83
Chapter 6 The Enveloping Semigroup, I1 In order to investigate further the properties of the enveloping semigroup, it is convenient to abstract the situation. For this purpose, we consider for the first part of this chapter an abstract semigroup E (with no topology).
A right ideal in E
is a non-empty subset
IE c I.
I such that
A
minimal rinht ideal is one which does not properly contain a right ideal. Note that a right ideal is also a semigroup. Moreover, if
I is a
K is a right ideal in the semigroup I,
minimal right ideal in E, and
K = I.
then it is easy to see that
An idempotent in a semigroup E
is an element
u
E with. u2 = u.
E
The next three lemmas are purely algebraic in character.
1.
I be a semigroup without proper right ideals. Let
Lemma. Let
J(1) = J
be the set of idempotents in
I, for all p
I.
Suppose J
*
#.
(i)
PI
(ii)
up = p, for u E J, p E I.
(iii)
If u
(iv)
If u E J
then Iu is a group with identity u.
(v)
If p E I
then there is a unique u E J
(vi)
Let
=
E
u,v E J
pr = v
(vii)
J and p
E
E
Then
I.
I with pu = u, then p
and let
p
E
E
with
J.
pu = p.
Iu. Then there is an r
E
I with
and rp = u.
I = U IU. UEJ
(viii) If u,v E J, with u Proof.
(ii)
(i)
(pI)I = PI
Let u
E
J.
2
c
PI
f
v, then Iu n Iv
and PI c I
Then by (i),
UI = I,
=
#.
so by assumption,
so
PI = I.
p = uq, for some
Ctiapter 6
84
q
E
I. Then up (iii)
=
uuq = uq = p.
p2 = pp = p(up) = ( p u ~ p= up = p.
(iv) If p,q
E
Iu, then p = ru, f o r some r
= p; similarly q = qu and
then pu = up = p, so
u acts as an identity for
with pq = u, by (1).
inverse of p
Iu.
(v) Let p
Iu.
Then pu = pqp = vp = p.
E
ru2 = ru
=
If p
Then pqu = u
Let q E I
J.
Also
with pq = v.
E
J with pw = p.
qp = u. Then pu = pw, qpu = qpw. But
Iu,
E
Let
q
u
=
qp.
u E J.
so E
is the
= q.)
Put
u2 = q(pq)p = qvp = qp = u
Suppose there were another w
Iu,
E
and qu
(In fact, it is easy to see that qu
I and v
E
pu
so
pq = puqu = pqu E Iu. Also, if p
there is a q E I in
I
E
Iu with
qp = u, so we have u = uu =
uw = w. (vi) Let q
be the inverse of p
r = qv. Then pr = pqv = uv = v
in the group
Iu, pq = u
and rprp = rvp = rp so
and let
rp E J.
But
rpu = rp so by (v) rp = u. Properties (vii) and (viii) follow immediately from ( v ) . Note that the lemma applies to a minimal right ideal
For, suppose K c I
semigroup E.
=
is a right ideal in I,
so
KI c K.
(KI)E c KI and KI is a right ideal in E with KI c I1 c I,
Then
KI
I of a
so
I. Since KI c K c I, we have K = I. I be a minimal right ideal of the semigroup E,
2. Lemma. Let
suppose J(1)
f
$.
Suppose p E E , g,r E I
satisfy pq = pr.
and Then
q = r. Proof. Let
s = qp E
such that sv = s
is a group).
IE c I. Then sq = qpq
and let
a E I such that
= qpr =
sr. Let v
as = v
(recall that
Then q = vq = asq = asr = vr = r.
Now we define an equivalence relation in J(E).
the set of
E
J(1)
Iv
The Enveloping Semigroup, II
if uv = u and
idempotents of E by u-v
85
vu = v.
(If u-v and v-w,
then uv = u, vw = v, and uw = (uvlw = u(vw) = uv = u and similarly w u = w,
3.
u-w. Reflexivity and symmetry are obvious.)
so
I1 and I2
Lemma. Let
and let
u1
J(I1).
E
be minimal right ideals of the semigroup E
Then there is a unique u 2
E
J(12)
and ul12 c IIE c 11,
u I 1 2
such that
u1-'2'
Proof. u I E c u I 1 2
12
so
is a subideal of
I 1 and hence u I = I1.
Thus there is a u2 E I2
Note that u2
is unique.
(If u1u2 = u1p2, p2
p2 = u2. 1 So
u1u2 = ul, ulu; = (u u )u = u1u2, and again by lemma 2, 1 2 2
2
u2 = u2 and u2 E J(12). u2v1 = u2. lemma 1 )
12,
E
then by lemma 2,
Similarly, there is a v1 E J(I1)
u1 = u1u2 = ulu2v1 = ulvl. But
So
with u u 1 2 = ul.
u v
= v1
with ((ii)
of
v1 = u1 and the proof is completed.
so
We wish to apply these lemmas to the enveloping semigroup of a (Now, as before, we write E for E(X) = E(X,T)
transformation group.
the enveloping semigroup of
(X.T).)
Our first task is to show that E
contains minimal right ideals. This is accomplished by the following theorem which also provides a dynamical characterization of the minimal right ideals.
4. Theorem. A subset I of E is a minimal right ideal if and only if
I is a minimal subset of the transformation group (E,T). (Hence minimal right ideals exist, and they are closed subsets of E . )
Proof. Let closed and
I be a minimal subset of the flow (E,T). Then I is Then IE = IT c
IT c 1.
ideal. Let Q
*
K
c
f
= I,
and
I with K a right ideal, let p
-
Then q E I = pT and there is a net (a subnet of) tn+<
C
E
{tn)
E. Then q = p<
E
I E
is a right
K and q
in T with ptn+q. KE c K,
so
E
I.
Let
I c K and hence
Chapter 6
a6
I = K. Thus every minimal subset of the flow (E,T) is a minimal right ideal of the semigroup E. Conversely, suppose
I
ideal of E. Then, if p E I , pE c IE c I, and Since left multiplication in E closed. If p
E
and
so
pE = I.
(pE)E c pE, so
is continuous, it follows that
then I = pE =
I,
is a minimal right
I
I
is
is a minimal subset of
the flow (E,T).
5. Corollary. If E(X),
F is a non-empty closed T invariant subset of
(equivalently, if F
is a closed ideal in E(X))
then F
contains a minimal right deal. Next, we show that all minimal right ideals in E(X)
contain
idempotents. This is a consequence of a more general result. 6. Lemma. Let
F be a compact TI space which has a semigroup struc-
ture for which left multiplication is continuous and closed (that is, if S
is closed, then XS
i dernpotent
is closed, for x E F ) .
Then F contains an
.
Proof. Let C denote the class of non-empty closed subsets S of F 2
such that S c S . If
An application of Zorn's lemma shows that there is a
minimal
S
SS E 1.
Since SS c Sz c S. SS = S by minimality of S. Let p
E C.
such that s p = s ,
s E
S, then (sS)(sS)c SS and sS is closed, so E
and let L = [a E Slsa = sl. Then p E L, and
is a non-empty closed subset of S. If a,b E L, sab = sb = s , 2 L c L. Thus L = S and, in particular s E L so
s2 = s .
S L
so
Then s is
an idempotent (of course, it follows that the minimal element S of C is a singleton set).
7. Corollary. Let F be a compact Hausdorff space with a semigroup structure such that left multiplication is continuous. Then F contains an idempotent.
The Enveloping Semigroup, II
8. Corollary.
If I
87
is a minimal right ideal in E(X,T),
then
I
contains an idempotent. Of course, in this chapter, we are only concerned with the case that
F is Hausdorff. However, the full force of lemma 6 will be used in a later chapter. In any case, our lemmas apply to the enveloping semigroup. E(X) contains minimal.right ideals, and every minimal right ideal contains idempotents ( "minimal idempotents"1. Now we pursue further the relationship of the enveloping semigroup with proximality, which we touched on the first enveloping semigroup chapter. 9. Theorem.
Let
(X,T) be a flow, and let x,y E X.
Then the
following are equivalent. (i)
x and y are proximal.
(ii)
xp = yp, for some p E E(X).
(iii) There is a minimal right ideal
I in E(X) such that xp = yp.
for all p E I. Proof. The equivalence of ( i ) and (ii) has been proved earlier. Obviously ( i i i ) implies (ii). By hypothesis F
*
$,
Suppose ( i i ) holds, and let F = [p E Etxp = y p l . and it is clear that F is a closed ideal. By
corollary 5, F contains a minimal right ideal. This completes the proof. Now suppose E contains exactly one minimal right ideal (x,y)
E
P and
Suppose
(y,z) E P. By the theorem just proved, xp = yp, and
also yp = zp, for p E I , P
I.
so
is an equivalence relation.
In fact, we have
xp = zp (p E I . )
Hence, in this case,
Chapter 6
88
10. Theorem. The proximal relation is an equivalence relation if and
only if the enveloping semigroup has a unique minimal right ideal Proof.
Sufficiency has been proved in the preceding discussion. Suppose
P is an equivalence relation and let I1 and I2 be minimal right Let u1 E J(I1), u2 E J(Iz)
ideals in E.
x
X. Then (x,xul)E P, (x,xu2) E P s o
E
with u1
(xu1,xu2) E P.
(xu1,xu2)u2 = (xu u xu ) = (xu ,xu2), so 1 2’ 2 1
have
.+u2,
(XxX,T). Hence xu = xu2’ Since x
arbitrary ul = u2
E
n
I2
Corollary. If P
Proof.
u
1
E
and
Suppose I1
J(I1), u2
This completes the proof.
I2
are minimal right ideals in E(XI,
with u1
u2
*
and let
x E X.
(xu2,xu1) = (xu2,xu1u21 = lim (x,xu1) s j’ where
T such that s.-+u2. J
X is
is closed, it is an equivalence relation.
and
J(12)
E
E
I 1 = I2 (recall that two minimal
and
subsets o f a flow are disjoint o r equal). 11.
Now also we
(xu1.xu2) is an almost
periodic point of
I1
and let
Since P
Then {sj)
let
(x.xul) E P
is a net in
is closed (and invariant) we have
But as we have noted in the proof o f theorem 10,
(xu2,xu1) E P.
(xu ,xul) is an almost periodic point, so 2 arbitrary u2 = ul. Hence
I 1 = I2
and
xu2 = xul, and since x E(X)
is
contains a unique minimal
right ideal. The conclusion now follows from theorem 10.
12. Theorem. Let
(X,T) be a flow and let
I be a minimal right ideal
in E(X). (i)
If x
E
X, then XI
( i i ) Let x E X. (a) x
(b) x
is a minimal subset of X.
The the following are equivalent:
is an almost periodic point. E
XI.
(c) xu = x.
for some u
E
J(1).
The Enveloping Semigroup, II
Proof.
is a homomorphic image of t h e minimal f l o w
( i ) XI
t h e map
(1,T)
via
p+xp.
(ii)
(b)
XI =
and
x
*
( a ) and ( c )
( a ) f o l l o w from ( i ) .
.$
If
x
is almost
3 is minimal, and X I is a minimal s u b s e t of
periodic,
If
89
F = [p
let
E XI,
s u b s e t of
Hence ( a )
x E XI.
1 and
FL c F.
+
XI.
F
Then
is a c l o s e d non-empty
c o n t a i n s a n idempotent, and (b) +
F
Hence
so
(b).
Ilxp =
E
xE =
(C).
Let
Theorem.
13.
(i)
If
x E X
(ii)
If
x E X,
(X,T) and
be a flow. v
E(X),
is a n idempotent i n
then
t h e r e is a n almost p e r i o d i c p o i n t
x’
( x , x v ) E P. such t h a t
( x , x ‘ ) E P. (iii) If
(X,T)
(x,y) E P
is minimal t h e n
minimal r i g h t i d e a l
I
E(X)
in
if and o n l y i f t h e r e is a
and a
v E J(1)
such t h a t
y = xv. Proof.
(i)
( i i ) Let
( x v ~ v= xv2 = xv,
( i i i ) If
ideal i n
E.
( x , x v ) E P.
be a minimal r i g h t i d e a l i n
I
x’ = xv E X I ,
Then
so
so
( x , y ) E P,
Let
v
E
xv
is a n almost p e r i o d i c p o i n t and
then
J(1)
v E J(1).
and l e t
E,
xp = yp,
for all
yv = y.
such t h a t
p E I Then
( x , x ’ ) E P.
a minimal r i g h t
y = yv = xv.
Recall (from t h e c h a p t e r on d i s t a l f l o w s ) t h a t a d i s t a l p o i n t i n a flow is a point
x
such t h a t i f
y
f
x,
then
x
and
are not
y
proximal. 14.
Corollary.
point. 15.
with
Then
Theorem.
x
Let
(X,T)
be a flow, and l e t
x E X
be a d i s t a l
is an almost p e r i o d i c p o i n t .
Let
(X,T)
and
x a d i s t a l p o i n t and y
(Y,T)
be flows and l e t
an almost p e r i o d i c p o i n t .
x
E
X, y E Y
Then
(x,y)
Chapter 6
90
is an almost periodic point of the product flow
Proof. Let v
n : XxY-+Y
be a minimal idempotent in E(Y)
be the projection map and let
of lemma 6, so there is an idempotent = (x,y)w. Then
z'
n((x,y)w) = R(x',Y')
= z and
y'.
=
Since x
yv = y. Let be the
satisfies the conditions
w in
8
-1
(v).
is an almost periodic point and
(theorem 12 ( i i ) , and theorem 13 (i)).
z'
such that
E(XxY)+E(Y)
8 :
induced semigroup homomorphism. Then O-l(v)
(x,x') E P(X).
(XxY,T).
Let
z' = (x',y')
(z,z') E
P(XxY)
Now y = yv = n(x,y)8(w) = ( z , z ' ) E P(XxY1,
Moreover, since
is a distal point, x' = x and therefore
z = (x,y) is an almost periodic point.
(X,T) be a distal flow, and (Y,T) be pointwise
16. Corollary. Let
(XxY,T) is pointwise almost periodic.
almost periodic. Then
We conclude this chapter with an application of the result that a point in a flow is proximal with an almost per odic point (theorem 13, (ii))
to combinatorial number theory. We will present Furstenberg's
proof of a theorem of N. Hindman on partitions of the set of positive integers. First we require one more general lemma. 17. Lemma. Let
(X,T) be a flow, let x
E
X and let y be an almost
periodic point, with x and y proximal. Let y. Then there is a Proof. Let
E(X)
t
E
U
be a neighborhood of
T such that xt and yt are in U.
I be a minimal right ideal in the enveloping semigroup
such that xp = yp for p E I
such that yu = y.
so
u be an idempotent in I
and let
xu = yu = y. Let
{t
J
}
be a net in T with
t -+us J
Then for J 2 j xt and yt are in U. 0' J J Now for our combinatorial application. A set D of positive integers
is called an IP set if there is a sequence p p p
1' 2' 3'"'
integers such that
of positive
D consists of all finite sums of the form
The Enveloping Semigroup, 11
pi +pi +. . .+pi 1 2 k
i l < i2 <
with
...
< ik.
distinct but the subscripts il,...,ik
91
(The p
need not be
J
are distinct. Thus D
additive semigroup if and only if each p
is an
is repeated infinitely often.)
i
IP sets is exhibited
The relation between topological dynamics and by the following definition and theorem. Definition. A set
S of positive integers is called a central set if
there is a cascade
(X,T), a point
x
E
X, an almost periodic point y
proximal to x, and a neighborhood U of
s
= [n
y such that
> OIT"(~) E UI.
IP set.
18. Theorem. Every central set contains an
(X,T) be a cascade, x
Proof. Let such that
E
X, y an almost periodic point
x and y are proximal. and let
is a neighborhood of y,
S
so
S =
Tpl(x), Tpl(y) E U1
(Note that
y
E
Tpil+.
+pin(x)
. . +Pin-2 ( T p i n-
=
so
Theorem. Let
H, H =
B1 u
...
that
U1 = U
and let pI
Tp2(~),Tp2(y)E Uz
Inductively, we have
and TPk(~),TPk(y)
p. +. * . T 11 +pin-l(Tpin(x))
E
Uk.
Then
Pil+.. . +Pi T
Pil+.. . +Pin-2 (Ui 1 ) c T (ui
C
...
1 =
(U,
I
n
c Tpil(Ui ) c
n-1
2
B1,B2,.. . ,Bq be a finite partition of
u B Then one of the B 4' J
E S.
U2 = U n T-P1(U1). 1
(lemma 17) and put
n
19.
U
and a sequence {pi}
then pi +. . .+pi 1 k
< ik,
U = U n T-p2(U2). 3 2
and TPk (Uk+l) c Uk
P11+Pi2+. ..
T
...
Uz. 1 Next, choose p2
(lemma 17 again) and let Uk+l c Uk
< i2 <
y
determines the required IP set.) Let
(Thus {p,} such that
i
U], where
E
is a central set. We will define induc-
tively a sequence of open neighborhoods Un of of integers such that if
[nlTn(x)
contains an
IP set
Chapter 6
92
It is only necessary to show that some B
Proof.
set. For this purpose consider the shift on q
. . ,q)z ,
R = {l,Z,,
and m(n) = w(n+l)
of fl such that for n > 0, <(n) = i r)
E
R
symbols
for w E R.
E
Rlw(0) = j l
S = [nlun(<)
E
U]
<
Let
be a point
if and only if n E B i ’
be an almost periodic point which is proximal to
then U = [ w
is a neighborhood of
ern(<)
is a central set. Now
un(<)(0) = j if and only if <(n) = j
Sc B
contains a central
J
If q(0) = j,
and
r),
E
<.
and let
U
if and only i f
n E B
if and only i f
so
jr
and the proof is completed.
J
Exercises. Let
1.
(X,T) be a flow, x,y E X.
u [I I I
xq = yq, for all q E
2. Let
Then (x,y)T c P
a minimal right ideal I .
(X,T), (Y,T) be minimal flows.
phism (i.e., if n(x) = n(x’)
then
A :
X+Y
(X,T) be a flow, let x
and a point Let
rxn(P
X
x’
E
N such that x and x‘
P(X,)
with n(x,)
(X,T) be a flow.
such that if F E
I c E(X)
XI = N,
such that
are proximal.
Py. In fact, if (y1.y2) E Py and x1
there is an x2
t
(x,x’) E Px.
A : X j Y be a homomorphism of minimal flows. Then
) =
5. Let
E
(y,y’) E Py
Suppose
X and let N be a minimal subset of
Then there is a minimal right ideal
xT.
4.
E
a proximal homomor-
(x,x’) E Px).
and x,x’ E X with n(x) = y, n(x’) = y‘. Then 3 . Let -
if and only i f
T such that
E
X with n(x,) = yl,
= y2.
A proximal
is a finite subset of A, (xt,yt) E a for all x.y
in X
is a subset
and a E 11 E
F. Show that
for some (equivalently, all) x
of X
then there is a
proximal set if and only if there is a minimal right ideal such that A c xJ(1)
A
E A.
A
I
is a
in E(X)
The Enveloping Semigroup, II
6. Let
(X,T) and
periodic.
Let
(Y,T) be flows, with
n : X+Y
93
(Y,T) pointwise almost
be a distal homomorphism.
Then
(X,T) is
point wi se almost periodic.
7. Let
I
u,v E J(1).
be a semigroup satisfying the conditions of lemma 1 and let Then the groups
Iu and
Iv are isomorphic.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
95'
Chapter 7 The Furstenberg Structure Theorem for Distal Minimal Flows We begin this chapter by considering the relativization of the concept of an equicontinuous flow. Let
II :
X+Y
is called equicontinuous if, for every a that if t
E
T.
(xl,x2)E (For short:
relation defined by
be a homomorphism. Then E
'l$
there is a p
E
'l$
'T[
such
and R(x,) = R(x,),
then (x t,x2t) E a, for all 1 "pT n R(n) c a" where, as usual, R ( R ) is the R,
R(n) = [(x 1,x2)IR(x,)
= dx2)l.)
Obviously, a
flow is equicontinuous if and only if it is an equicontinuous extension of the trivial flow. (An equicontinuous extension is also called an almost periodic extension.)
It is easily checked that an equicontinuous extension is a distal extension, so if Y
is distal and
is distal. However, it is
R :
X-+Y
is equicontinuous, then X
the case that an equicontinuous extension
of an equicontinuous flow is equicontinuous. The skew product flow on the torus
(z,wlH ( a z , zw) provides an example.
the projection
(Z,W)HZ
It is immediate that
is an equicontinuous extension of the
equicontinuous cascade z w a z on the circle, but, as we saw in the preceding chapter, the cascade on the torus is not equicontinuous. Indeed, this phenomenon (that an equicontinuous extension of a distal minimal flow is distal, but not in general equicontinuous) is the point of departure for the analysis of the structure of distal minimal flows. The theorem of Furstenberg, which will be stated below, says essentially that any distal minimal flow is realize3 as a sequence (in general transfinite) of equicontinuous extensions. In order to state the theorem precisely, we need one more definition. A projective system of minimal flows is
a collection of minimal flows
Chapter 7
96
(Xx ,T) indexed by ordinal numbers h family of homomorphisms, (i)
If v < h <
( i i ) If p I e
Q
(p,
5 8,
(for some ordinal e l ,
for v < h I
Xh+Xv,
:
then
8
and a
satisfying
A1)
= (p,ph.
p :
is a limit ordinal, then X
the Cartesian product flow
(xx 1
A
S 8
(
is the minimal subset of Ir lT Xh,T) consisting of all h
ll Xh with xu = (pv(xh) ( v < A < p ) and (pr : X +Xh is c1 h
x =
E
pro.iective limit) of the flows Xh ( A < p). Another way of looking at this is to consider a minimal flow X = Xe, and a family of closed invariant equivalence relations Rh
X, = X ( A I e l . R
Re
which satisfy (i)
Rh, and ( i i i ) if h
=
in
Ax, ( i i ) if v < h
is a limit ordinal, then
RA =
S 8,
n Rp.
If
h
XA = X/RA and the homomorphisms
(ph
v
are the canonical maps, obviously
this collection of flows and homomorphisms constitutes a projective system. Now we are ready to state the Furstenberg structure theorem.
1. Theorem. Let K :
X+Y
(X,T) and (Y,T) be distal minimal flows and let
be a homomorphism. Then there is a projective system of
minimal flows (Xh,T) ( A
X < e, if
A+ 1 (px
:
Xx+l+Xh
5 0)
with Xe = X, Xo = Y such that if
is an equicontinuous extension.
In particular,
(X,T) is distal minimal. there is a projective system as above, with
Xo = 1, the trivial flow. The proof we present here, due to Bronstein, is a simplification of Furstenberg’s proof, (Amer. J. Math., 8s (19631, 477-5151, and is under the assumption that the phase space is metrizable.
(The metrizability
assumption is only used in the last stage of the proof. )
In the course
of the proof, a number of results are obtained (some of which are not
The Furstenberg Structure Theorem
97
restricted to distal flows) which are of independent interest.
(Other
proofs of the structure theorem have been given by Ellis (Lectures ToDolonical Dynamics, Benjamin, 1969) and Namioka, (Math. Systems Theorq
S
( 19721,
193-2091.1
An essential concept in the proof is the relativized regionally proximal relation. If
X+Y
I :
n
proximal relation Q(n) =
is a homomorphism, the n-regionally
DT n R(n).
Note that
(x.x') E,Q(I)
if
VEZIX
and only if for every a (x,xo) E a, (x',xb) nets {xn), {x;} (xn,x;1)
E
:
X+X/R
Q(R) =
a and
E
{tn)
in T
E
X
=
'7E?-fX
R(n),
E
with x +x, n
x'+x', n
(xntn,x;, tn)+AX.
the quotient map, we write
n
(x0 , X I0)
with
if and only if there are
(xot,x;)t) E a
in X, and and
there are xo,xA
is a closed invariant equivalence relation in
If R n
R(n)
E 'I+
n
Q(R)
X, and
instead of Q(n).
Thus
m.
QE%
The relation between equicontinuous extensions and relative regional proximality is provided by the following proposition.
2. Proposition. The extension
A :
X+=Y
is equicontinuous if and only
if Q(n) = A. Proof. Suppose n and choose f3 E Since a If
I
BT n R(n)
E
5
is equicontinuous and
(x,x')
with f3T n Rfa) c a. Then
'I$ is arbitrary we have
E
Q(n).
(x,x') E BT
@ E
A
a R(I)
%
E
c
G.
x = x'.
is not equicontinuous, then there is an u E a for all
Let
such that
?$. That is, for every 6 there is an
,XI) E f3 n R(I) and t E T such that (x t ,x't 4 a. Regarding B B B B B B B {x t 1 and {x't } as nets, then (subnets of) x t +x, x't +x' and B B 613 B P B B it is immediate that (x,x') E Q(I) with x # x'.
(x
Chapter 7
98
Let
Theorem.
3.
X
be a homomorphism.
and
Y
Then
be d i s t a l minimal flows. and let
11
X-+Y
:
is open.
n
W e first r e q u i r e a l e m m a .
Lemma.
4.
y E Y
such t h a t
Let
Proof.
n
*
(yip n n - l ( y )
E(X)
as a c t i n g on
-1
( y ) p c n-'(y).
n-l(y)p-'
Since a l s o
n
-1
y
E
{x,}
a net
Now l e t
x' E n
and x'p E
in
X
xi
Now, let
xA+x'
Y, x E X
n(xn) = yn
with
E X,
E X
such t h a t
-1
(y)q = n
-1
(y).
qn+q
That i s ,
n(xn) = yn
Let
E E(X)
Thus t h e r e is a
x = x"qn+x"q x = x"q n n' n
with
(y). Then
(y).
That is
*
we have
0,
and t h e lemma is proved. and
{yn)
x +x. n
and
n ( x i ) = yn
n(x') = y = H(x).
so
and let (a subnet o f )
yn.
TI
-1
-1 '-1 (y)p n n (yl
t h a t t h i s is equivalent t o openness of t h e map
-1
x = xop,
so
x"
E
and
and
x +x, n
{yn})
and
( I t is easy t o see
n.)
and let (a subnet o f ) x l q n = xh
qn E E(X)
such t h a t
x'q = x'.
By t h e lemma
n-'(y)
x"q = x.
such t h a t
n(xnl = n(x"q n )
= x
Y with
a net i n
W e show t h a t t h e r e is a subnet (which we s t i l l call
yn+y.
n
(y).
(We regard t h e enveloping
c n -1 ( y ) , s o n -1 ( y ) p = n - l ( y ) ,
To prove t h e theorem, let
-1
and
i . e . , we suppress t h e map
Y,
n ( x ' ) = y, n(x'p1 = n ( x ' ) p = yp = y
n
= n
n-'(y)p
d x ) = y and
= yp.
- see chapter 3. )
t3 : E ( X ) + E ( Y )
Then
0.
so
n n-'(yI,
y = n ( x ) = n(x,p)
Then
semigroup
-1
x E n-'(y)p
= y.
n(x,)
p E E(X)
Under t h e hypotheses of t h e theorem, suppose
If
= n(x'q ) = n(x'1 =
n
so, as noted above,
n
is open.
IT
I t w i l l be shown i n chapter 10 t h a t any d i s t a l homomorphism of minimal flows is open.
5.
Corollary.
Let
X
be a d i s t a l minimal flow, let
cpx : E(X)--+X be defined by
Proof.
E(X) =
a
(px(pl = xp ( p
E
E(X)).
x
E
Then
is an o r b i t c l o s u r e i n t h e d i s t a l flow
X, (p
and let X
(#,TI
is open.
so
The Furstenberg Structure Theorem
E(X)
is d i s t a l minimal.
Thus
99
is a homomorphism o f d i s t a l minimal
'px
flows, and is t h e r e f o r e open. 6.
Lemma.
a E
s.
Then
Let
Proof.
Let
Let
T)
= ( i n t n(V)xint n(V))T.
and
T),
(y ,y') n n with
1Ly.
be a non-empty open subset of
V
T)
Corollary.
7.
be a homomorphism of minimal flows, and l e t
(nxn)(a) E
set which meets Ay c
X+Y
K :
Ay, E
%.
Let
Then K :
8.
Theorem.
(nxn)(aT)
X+Y
such t h a t
VxV c a.
is a non-empty i n v a r i a n t open
YxY.
Since
3 T),
so
Ay
is a minimal s e t ,
(nxn)(aT) E 'I$.
Let
be a homomorphism of minimal flows.
with
YxY
n ( x ) = yn, n(x;l) = y;l, n
T.
T)
t h e diagonal of
be a net i n
in
Then
X
(yn,y;l)-+Ay.
and
Then t h e r e are
(xntn,x;ltn)+AX
xn' x'n
f o r some net
E X
itn}
Consider t h e commutative diagram of minimal flows and
homomorphisms.
Clearly
Proof. nets
{(yn,y;))
B(yn) = p(y;l) x
x' E X n' n
some net
in
and
with {tn)
(nxn)Q(u) c Q ( @ ) . YxY
and
{7n)
(yntn,y;ltn)--+Ay.
n(xn) = y n ~ n .n(x;) in
T.
Note t h a t
@n(XA)= a(xA).
L e t (subnets of)
dx') = y'
a ( xn T-'n)
and
(xntn,xhtn)--,Ax,
Let
and so
in
(y,y') E with
T
Q(P).
Then t h e r e are
(yn,y;l)+(y,y'),
By c o r o l l a r y 7, t h e r e are = yz,,
and
( x n t n , x ' n t n )+Ax
a ( x n ) = pn(xn) = p ( y n t n ) = p(y;lt,) X
-1
~
-
-
-1 +Tx , ~ x z n + x ' ,
so
for =
n(x) = y,
a(xzil). Then (xnT~l(sntnl,X;IT,l(Tntn)) = (x,?) E Q(a) with ( n x n ) ( x , x ' ) = ( y , y ' ) .
=
Chapter 7
100
9. Corollary,
If
n
X
Y
flows and homomorphisms, then f3
is a commutative diagram of minimal
is an equicontinuous extension if and
only if Q(a) c R(n).
Proof. Suppose p
is an equicontinuous extension. If
then
E Q(f3),
(n(xl),n(x2))
so
n(x 1 ) = n(x2)
Conversely, suppose Q ( u ) c R(n), there are
(x,,x2)
(xl,x2) E R(n),
E
so
and let
Q ( a ) with n(xi) = yi
(xl,x2) E Q ( a ) ,
(x1,x2)E R n).
and (y,,y,)
E Q(f3).
Then
(i = 1,2). Then
y1 = n(x ) = n(x2) = y2. 1
Thus Q ( f 3 ) c Ay
and
is equicontinuous. 10. Corollaru. Let
X be a minimal flow and let R and
invariant equivalence relations in X such that canonical homomorphism of X/S
to X/R
S
c R.
be closed
S
Then the
is equicontinuous if and only if
S 3 Q(R).
Proof. This is just a rephrasing of the previous corollary. 11.
Lemma.
Let
(X,T) be a distal minimal flow and let R be a closed
invariant relation in X. of
Let
(x,y) E R and let
U
be a neighborhood
x. Then there is a neighborhood V of y such that, if y1
E
V,
E U such that (xl.yl)E R. 1 (Note: It is not assumed that R is an equivalence relation.1
there is an x
Proof.
It is sufficient to show: if {yn)
yn-+y, then there is a net pn E E(X) with
yn = yp,.
{Xn)
with xn+x
since R
and
with
(xn,yn) E R.
Since the homomorphism p ~ y pof
X is open, and y = ye, there is a net and r +e. n
is a net in X
If xn = xrn, then xn+x
is closed invariant.
{rn) and
on E(X)
Let
E(X) to
with yrn = yn
(xn,yn) = (xrn,ym) E R,
The Furstenbe% Structure Theorem
12. Theorem. Let
101
(X,T) be a distal minimal flow, and let
closed invariant equivalence relation in X.
Then Q(R)
R be a
is a closed
invariant equivalence relation. (x,y),(y,z) E Q ( R ) = r )
Proof. Let
(a n R)T.
U and W be
Let
neighborhoods of x and
z
respectively. Now Q(R)
closed invariant relation
so
by Lemma 11, there is a neighborhood V
y such that if y’
V,
E
there is a z’ E W
with
is certainly a
(y’,~’) E Q(R).
let a E I$, and choose /3 E I$ with P4 c a. Since there are x1 E U, y1 (xltl,yltl)E P.
E
V, t
Since X
1
T with
E
(x ,y ) 1 1
is distal, XxX
E
of
Now,
(x,y) E Q ( R ) ,
R and
is pointwise almost
periodic, and N = (x ,y IT is minimal. Then there is a finite subset 1 1 (x;,y;) E N, (x;,y;)K
K of T such that, for all (x;,yi) E N,
That is, if and
(y;k,yi) E 8,
6E
there is a k E K such that
for some k
is a k E K such that
”f3-dense“ in N.
is
E
K.
(x;k,x;)
<E
In particular, if
(xl
satisfy 6K c 6,
E(X),
(Note that
there
Now, let
and let 0 be a neighborhood of e
such that x10 c U, y10 c V.
E j3,
in E(X)
x10 and y10 are neighbor-
hoods of x1 and y1 respectively, because of the openness of the homomorphism from E(X) there is a z1 E W there is a y2 (y t , z t 1 22 22
E
6
E
y2 = ylEo.
again the
with
(yl.zl) E Q ( R ) .
y10 and z
2
E
From the definition of
W such that (y2,z2)
for some t2 E T. Since 6K c f3,
(y2t2k,z2t2k) E 6, with
From the defining property of V,
to X.)
for k
E
K.
Also, y2
E
E
Q(R),
R, and
we have
ylO, so there is a E0 E (9
Then x2 = xlc0 E x10 c U and
(x,,y,)
E
R. Using
“f3 dense” property of K, there is a ko E K with
(x15 0t 2k0, y15 0t 2k01 E (xltl)Bx(y,tl)f3, (yl~ot2ko,yltl) E f3.
Since also
which means
(x t ,y t 1 1 1 1
E f3,
(x1E0t2k0,xltl) E P, we have
Chapter 7
102
( X1<0t2k0
P
E
Yl
says that
p3.
Recall that x2 = xlco, y2 = ylco, so this
(X2t2k0y2tZko) E p3,
and we have above that
K, so (x2t2k0 'z 2t2k0 ) E P4 c a. 2 Recapitulating, we have (x2,y2) E R, (y2,z2) E R so (x2,z,) E R c R, (y2t2k,z2t2k)
x2 E X1o
U, z 2
C
for all k
P,
E
E
E
W with (x2tZko,z2t2ko)
E
a, which proves that
(x,z)E Q(R). If X
13. Corollary.
is an equicontinuous extension
equivalence relation in X, then X/Q(R) In particular (taking R = XxX) Q
of X/R.
is a closed invariant
is distal minimal and R
is a closed invariant
equivalence relation and the quotient flow X/Q
is the maximal
equicontinuous factor of X. Proof. This follows from corollary 10 and theorem 12. Now let
(X,T) and
(Y,T)
be distal minimal flows, and let
be a homomorphism. For each ordinal number A,
I[
and let Q, = R.
ordinals If h
p
< A.
Suppose Q,
(so
has been defined for all
If A = <+1 define QA = QS+, = Q(Q<) =
n Q,
is a limit ordinal, define QA =
X+Y
we define inductively a
closed invariant equivalence relation QA in X. Write Y = X/R R = R(n)),
:
n
la n Qt)T.
(thus Q, = Q(Qo) = Q(R)).
,
is a successor ordinal, it follows from theorem 12 that Q,
an equivalence relation. Q,
is
is obviously an equivalence relation if A
is a limit ordinal.
If h <
it is clear that Q,
Q Since each QA is closed, it P' follows from general considerations that there is an (least) ordinal number
A >
8
p,
3
for which Qe+l = Qe, and
so
Qe = QA =
nla
n
Q8)T,
for all
8.
If we could assert that Q, = Ax,
for some
8,
the Furstenberg
structure theorem would follow easily, and it is at this point that we
The Furstenberg Structure Theorem
invoke the assumption that the phase space X
103
is metrizable. Let d be
1 and let a = [(x,y)ld(x,y) < n1 n (n = 1,2,.. . 1. Then, if 0 is as above Q, = Q,+l = n (an n Q,)T. n=1,2,.. . Therefore (an n Qe )T is a dense open subset of Q,, for each n, and it follows from the Baire category theorem that n(a n QO)T is dense n
a metr c defining the topology of X,
-
- -
-
Then Q, = n(an n Qe)T c nunT = Px = Ax
in Q,.
Ax,
and X/QO = X.
We now have all the ingredients for the proof of the structure theorem, in case the space X If
is metrizable.
is as in the preceding discussion, then the flows XA = X/QA
0
and the associated homomorphisms define a projective system. (Note that X,
= X/Q,
= X/Ax = X
QA+l = Q(Q,) X/QA+l+X/QA
and Xo = W Q 0 = X/R = Y . )
(A < 0).
Moreover, since
corollary 13 tells us that the homomorphism
(or XA+l+XA)
is an equicontinuous extension.
This completes the proof. The projective system of flows {X,} homomorphisms { qAv ) is sometimes called a “Furstenberg tower.“ Theorem 1 has a valid converse. In fact, if n phism of minimal flows and {XA},
A {q,)
:
X-+Y
and
is a homomor-
is a projective system of flows
and homomorphisms with Xe = X, Xo = Y and
(pi’’
an equicontinuous
extension, then it follows directly by transfinite induction that n
is
distal. Indeed, a relatively straightforward modification of the proof we have presented proves that a distal homomorphism can be characterized as in theorem 1.
(That is, the flows need not be distal; what is
essential is that the homomorphism is distal.) Suppose now that X
is distal minimal and not equicontinuous. Then,
using the notation of the structure theorem Xo = 1, and X1 = X/Q,
= WQ. Hence Xl
For, if X = Xe. X1 = 1,
then Xz,
then
8
the trivial flow,
is equicontinuous. Moreover, X1
>. 1 (since X
is not equicontinuous).
as an equicontinuous extension of XI = 1,
is
#
If
1.
Chapter 7
104
itself equicontinuous. But X, s o X2 = X,,
X, = X/Q,
XI is the maximal equicontinuous factor of
and Qz = Q,.
Thus Q, = Q, = Q for all A ,
and X =
is equicontinuous, which is a contradiction.
Thus we have proved. (X,T) is distal minimal and not equicontinuous.
14. Theorem. Suppose
Then X has a non-trivial equicontinuous factor. Note that the ‘discussion just completed shows: if X and Y are distal minimal flows with metrizable phase spaces, and n non-trivial homomorphism, then Q(n) Q, = R ( n ) , Q, = Q(Q,) Q,
= R(n),
#
R(n).
X+Y
is a
For, if Q(n) = R ( n ) ,
= Q(R(n)) = Q(n) = R(n) = Q,,
for all ordinals A .
:
then
and it follows that
Thus Qe = A = R ( n ) ,
so
n
is an
isomorphism. Moreover, the proof of the Furstenberg theorem in general (i.e., when the phase space is not metrizable) follows from this property. For, suppose whenever X and Y are distal minimal, and n non-trivial homomorphism, then Q(n) f R ( n ) . the ordinal for which Qe+l Q(n) = Qe+l = Qe = R(n),
isomorphic with X.
As
= Qe
and, if
:
X+Y
a
Then, if, as above, 8
n : X+X/Q,,
is
R( n ) = Q,,
and so n must be trivial and X/Qe
is
we have seen, this implies the Furstenberg
theorem. A sketch of the proof of this property in the general case will be given at the end of the chapter. Now we present some applications of the structure theorem. The first, on eigenfunctions of distal minimal flows, is under the assumption that the acting group is abelian. If
(X,T) is a flow, with T abelian, an einenfunction of
a continuous map
cp :
X+K
that, for some character
(X,T) is
(the unit circle in the complex plane), such
r of T, cp(xt)
=
r(t)cp(x)
(x E X, t
E
TI.
Suppose now that X = (X,T) is a distal minimal flow. with T abelian,
The Furstenberg Structure Theorem
105
and let Y be a non-trivial equicontinuous factor (theorem 1 4 ).
As we
have noted, Y may be given the structure of a compact abelian group. Choose y E Y as the identity and let cp
be a non-constant character
0
of Y, so
(t
E
Let
:
T-+K
a(t)
be defined by
= cp(yot)
Recall that the group structure on Y satisfies (y,s)(yot)
TI
yo(St)
cp(yo) = 1.
s,t E TI, so a ( s t l = rp(y 0st) = cp((yos)(yot))
a(s)a(t).
If y E Y and {sn}
yosnt+yt, p(yosnt)+cp(yt)
and also rp(yosnt) = r(sn)r(t),
the equicontinuous flow (Y,T). If by composing cp
with
15. Theorem. Let
T with yosn+y,
is a net i n
Thus cp(yt) = y(t)rp(y)
cp(y0sn)-+cp(y).
= cp(yos)cp(yot)
and
K :
=
then
r(sn) =
is an eigenfunction of
cp
X-+Y
=
is a homomorphism, then,
we obtain
IK
(X,T) be a distal minimal flow, with T abelian.
Then there is a non-constant eigenfunction of
(X,T).
As a corollary to the existence of eigenfunctions, we show that a
simply connected space cannot support a distal minimal flow under the action of an abelian group. For suppose T
is abelian and acts distally
and minimally on the simply connected space X. Let @ tion of the flow (X,T). Since X
@(XI
= exp i$(x),
@(xt)@(x)-'
where $
be an eigenfunc-
is simply connected, we may write
is real valiied and continuous. Then
= exp i($(xt)-$(x)l
and also @(xt)@(x)-'
= .a(t),
character of T. That is, for fixed t E T, exp i($(xt)-$(x)) constant, and since $
is continuous, $(xt)-y?(x)
2 2 a(t2) = $(xt )-$(x) = $(xt )-$(xt)+$(xt)-@(xl
in general, $(xtn)-y?(x)
= a(tn) = na(t1.
have a(t) = 0, and $(xt) = constant, and therefore @
16. Theorem. Let
@(XI.
= a(t).
= a(t)+a(t)
Since @
a is a
Then
= 2a(t),
and,
is bounded, we must
Since (X,T) is minimal, @
is
is constant. Then we have proved.
(X,T) be a distal minimal flow with X non-trivial,
Chapter 7
106
and T abelian. Then the space X is not simply connected. In particular, the n-sphere Sn cannot support a distal minimal flow, if n t 2 . Our next application concerns invariant measures for distal minimal flows. By an invariant measure for the flow (X,T) we mean a Bore1 on X such that p(At) = p(A)
probability measure p
measurable subsets A and t E T. Equivalently, p
for all
may be regarded (via
the Riesz representation theorem) as a positive linear functional on the continuous real valued functions on X with p(1) = 1,
C(X),
that p(ft) = p(f)
(f E C(X), t E TI, where ft
ft(x) = f(xt1.
If
p
pt(f) = p(ft).
Thus
for all t
E
is a measure on X, pt p
E
C(X)
such
is defined by
is the measure defined by
is an invariant measure if and only if pt = p
T.
In chapter 12 we will obtain necessary and sufficient conditions on a group T such that all flows with acting group T
admit invariant
measures. Here we prove the existence of invariant measures for all distal minimal flows. As one would expect, the proof proceeds by "lifting" the invariant measure through the equicontinuous extenslons and
limits guaranteed by the Furstenberg structure theorem. To this end, we need to study the structure of equlcontinuous extensions more intensively. Our main result in this direction is that all fibers of an equicontinuous extension are homeomorphic, and that there is a transitive group of self homeomorphisms of each fiber. In fact, first suppose that Let
I
X-+Y
be a minimal right ideal in E(X)
idempotent in I identity on H(XU) =
H :
H
-1
is just a distal extension. let y
E
Y and let u be an
with yu = y. We first note that u acts as the (y).
yu = y = n(x)
(If x E n-l(y), xu and since
A
1s proximal with
x and
is d stal, xu = x. 1 Now, let
The Furstenberg Structure Theorem
p E 1.
For any extension n -1 (yip c n -1 (yp).
we show that n -1 (yip = n-'(yp), map
p maps
A
-1
(y) to n
-1
107
In this case
( n distal)
from which it follows easily that the
(yp) bijectively (since n
is distal this
map is obviously one-to-one). Let q -1
n
-1
n
E
I such that pq = u. Then n
(ylpq c n-+yp1q c n (y) =
-1
II
-1
(ypq) = n
I
applied to yp we have n
-1
(yplqp = n
For y
E
-1
-1
-1
(y) = n -1
-1
(ylu =
(y), so
(yip = n
-1
(yplqp. Now qp = w
and ypw = yp, so by the same argument (yplw = n
-1
(yp) and n
-1
(yp) = n
-1
(yp)w =
(YIP.
Y, suppose yu = y, and consider p
the above discussion n -1
(yu) = n
(yplq. It follows that n
is also an idempotent in
II
-1
-1
-1
(y)p = n
-1
E
I with yp = y. By
(y), and p defines a bijection of
If we identify two such p1,p2 E I when they define the same -1 map on n (y) (i.e., if xpl = xp2 for all x E n (y)), we obtain a R
(y).
-1
group E (The inverse of the map defined is defined by q E I where Y' pq = u.) Summarizing we have obtained
17. Theorem. Let n
:
X-+Y
be a distal homomorphism of minimal flows,
and let y E Y with yu = y. Then -1 (i) If p E I , p maps II (y) bijectively to
R
-1
(ii) E is a group with identity u, and xE = n Y Y -1 x E n (y). Now suppose that n
(yip = n-l(yp).
-1
(y) for
is an equicontinuous extension. Then it follows
homeomorphism) and in fact that
Ey
E
is continuous (hence a Y is a compact group (see the proofs
easily from the definition that each p
E
of theorems 2 and 3 in the first enveloping semigroup chapter).
Using
these facts and theorem 17, we have 18.
Theorem.
Let R : X+Y
be an equicontinuous homomorphism of
Chapter 7
108
Then E is a compact group of Y -1 homeomorphisms acting transitively on the fibers n (y). If p
minimal flows, and let y E Y.
-1 a (y) homeomorphically onto
maps
19. Lemma. Let
flows and let y TI
-1
m
E
xq
E
:
X+Y
-1
I, p
(yp).
be an equicontinuous extension of minimal
Y. Then there is a unique probability measure on
(y) which is invariant under the action of the group E Y'
Proof. Let
x
n
R
E
m
denote normalized Haar measure on the group E Y' n-1 ( y ) , define a measure m X on n -1 ( y ) by
f(xqp)dm(qp) = mx(f)
(f) = JE f(xqp)dm(p) =
If
(the second equality
JEY Y holds due to the invariance of the Haar measure). transitively on n
-1
we have rnx = m x'
(y),
call this common measure
r
E
E
Y'
fr(x) = f(xr),
p.
Since E acts Y -1 for all x,x' E n ( y ) ;
If we define, for f
E
C(n
-1
a similar computation shows that
(y)) and p(fr) = p(f),
is invariant under E Now suppose 1.1' is any probability Y' -1 Then, if f E C(E 1, measure on n (y) which is invariant under E Y' Y
so
p
p'(fl
=
f(x)dp'(x)
-1 (Yl
=
f (x)d(p'q)(x)
L
W
f (x)d(p'q) (x)dm(q) = E' Y 'n-'[y)
The Furstenberg Structure Theorem
109
= p(f).
p(f)dp'(x) (Y) If
II :
X+Y
is a flow homomorphism and p
probability measure on X, the np
is a T-invariant
will denote the T-invariant
probability measure on Y defined by
np(f) = p(fn) (f
E
C(Y)).
Our
next result shows that in the case of equicontinuous extensions, an invariant measure can be lifted from Y 20. Theorem. Let
n
:
X+Y
to
X.
be an equicontinuous extension of minimal
flows. Suppose there is a T-invariant probability measure Then there is a T-invariant probability measure p
u
on Y.
on X such that
np = u . -1
(y) has a unique E invariant measure, which we call Y as a measure on X which is concentrated on py. We may regard each p Y -1 II (y). We first show that p = pyt (t E T). Note first that p t is Yt Y -1 concentrated on n (yt). Now if p E E then tpt-' E E so if Yt' Y' Proof. Each n
p E Eyt, ( p t)(p) = p (tpt-')(t) = pyt. Thus p t is a probability Y Y Y -1 invariant. By measure (concentrated) on n (yt) which is E Yt uniqueness, p t = pyt. Y Now we define a probability measure p on X by setting
The existence of this integral will follow once we know that the integrand is a continuous function of y, and this matter is attended to below.
Assuming it for now, let
t
E
T.
Then
(pt)(f) = p(ft) =
(ft)du(y) = p t(f)du(y) = (f)du(y) = Sp (f)dut-l(y) = fpy(f)du(yl Y S Y Y = p(f), and so p is the required invariant measure. /p
Chapter 7
110
The continuity assertion mentioned above is equivalent to showing that the map y w p (y E Y) from Y to C(X)* (with the weak * Y topology) is continuous. That is, if {yn) is a net in Y with yn+y,
we want to show p (f)+py(f), n'
suppose p
, and show p' = py.
+p'
f E C(X).
for all
At all events p'
We may
is concentrated
Yn -1
(y). Let q E E and let pn E M with ypn = y , . We may Y' suppose p +u, where u is an idempotent in M with yu = y. (For, n
on
II
if pn+p
E
M, then yp
y and if pu = p, then yu = y.
=
with rp = pr = u, then yr = ypr = yu = y, so rp +rp n x E n
-1
to X
= u.)
(y).
Since
71
yrpn = ypn
If r
E
M
-- yn and
is a distal extension, xu = x, for all
Now the group T, regarded on a family of maps from n
-1
(y)
is an equicontinuous family, and thus it follows from the
Arzeli-Ascoli theorem that identity map of
II
-1
(y).
pnln-l(y1
Let
the inverse map of p In-'(yn1 n
rn E M
r qp = p n' Yn n n
(y)
-1
rnln
.
Now, since
r qp +p'q
Y, n n
Yn n n
I
f(xq)dp' (x) = (p'qlf.
)
is a probability measure concentrated on n
under all q E E Y' 19 that JL' - Py.
weak
Yn
Therefore, p'q = p', -1
(y)
*.
(XI,
r qp (f) = If(xrnqpn)dp
(To see this note that, for f E C ( X ) , p which is close to
(y) is
From the defining
uniformly, it follows that p
-1
n
with pnrn = u, so
and ynrnqpn = yn.
properties of the fiber measures, p
-1 pnln (y)+id
converges uniformly to the
so
p'
which is invariant
It follows from the uniqueness assertion in theorem
Hence the property of possessing an invariant measure is lifted by In equicontinuous extension. Our next result shows that this property is also preserved under projective limits. 21.
Lemma. Suppose X = X
7
is a limit of the minimal flows Xa (a <
r),
The Furstenberg Structure Tharem
and each Xa admits an invariant measure v invariant measure
p
Proof. Write cp
(instead of c p z )
Xa.
If a < 7
a
Then va
extends to a linear functional
ia(l) =
a
for the projection of X = X
onto
7
)
as a subspace of C(X)
(via the
may be regarded as a linear functional of the
norm one on a subspace of C(X).
and, since
Then there is an
a'
for X.
we may regard C(X
map f+fOcpa).
111
va(l) = 1,
By the Hahn-Banach theorem, va
ia on C(X) such that II,;II we have
IIiall
=
1.
Thus
5
a
IIvall,
is a
probability measure, and clearly cp (i 1 = ua' a a
-
Of course, there is no reason to expect any of the measures v a
to be
T-invariant. An invariant measure is obtained as follows. For each a < 7.
let Pa
denote the class of probability measures p
on X such
that cp p
va
is T-invariant on X for all f3 I a. We note that P a - - a Pa, for, if P < a, cpP va = cpPcpava - cpPva, which, as we have
P
-
E
observed, is T-invariant. Clearly, if a < a', sets {Pa)(a
see that each Pa
then Pa, c Pa,
satisfy the finite intersection property.
is weak *
n Pa *
compact, so
so
the
It is easy to
0.
a57
Now, let p E nP,.
We show that pt = p (t E T),
complete the proof. To this end, let Ba
be the subalgebra of C(X)
consisting of functions of the form f o p a (f E C(Xa)).
, subalgebra since Ba c B
whenever a < a',
of limit, it follows immediately that Hence UBa f E C(Xa), p((focpa)t)
UBa
is uniformly dense in C(X). so
p(F) = p(focpa) = cpap(f).
= p((ft)ocpa)
pt(F) = p(F)
for F
follows that pt = p.
and this will
uBa
is a
and, from the definition
separates points of X. If F E Ba, F = focp,
If t
= cpap(ft) = pap(f),
E
for some
T, pt(F) = p(Ft) =
since p E Pa. Therefore
in a uniformly dense subset of C(X)
and it
Chapter 7
112
Now suppose
(X,T) is a distal minimal flow, and let
be a projective system for
(X,T) = (X,,T)
and
(XA,T) ( A
5 0)
(XO,T) the trivial
flow, as in the Furstenberg structure theorem. It follows easily by transfinite induction and the two preceding theorems that all the flows (XA,T) admit an invariant probability measure.
Thus we have proved.
Theorem. A distal minimal flow admits an invariant probability
22.
measure.
It would be interesting to find a direct proof of this theorem (that is, a proof which does not invoke the structure theorem). We conclude this chapter by sketching the proof of the following theorem, which, as we have noted, implies the Furstenberg structure theorem. Theorem. Let
23. H
:
X+Y
(X,T) and
(Y,T) be distal minimal flows, and let
be a homomorphism. Then
Q(H)
*
R(H).
(This theorem, which is due to McMahon and Wu (Proc. Amer. Math. SOC.
82 ( 1981), 283-294), applies to any distal homomorphism.1 If K
is a subgroup of T, and
homomorDhism is a continuous map cp
(x
E
X, k
E
(X,T) and :
X+Y
(Y,T) are flows, a K
such that
cp(xk) = cp(x)k
K).
The main step in the proof of Theorem 23 is the construction of a commutative diagram
where K
is a countable subgroup of T, ( 5 , K ) and
(YK,K) are metric
The Furstenberg Structure Theorem
trivial.
cp,(n-'(y))
are K homomorphisms with nK non-
and $K
minimal flows, nK, cpK,
-1
=
113
($,(y))
(y
E
Y),
and
(cpKxcpK)(Q(n)) c Q(nK).
First we show that the existence of diagram ( * ) implies that
*
Q(n)
R(I).
For suppose
:
is a homomorphism of distal minimal flows with
Consider the diagram ( * I , with the indicated properties.
R(n) = Q(n).
E XK, x xK ,x' K K
Let
X+Y
*
xi and
K (xK 1 = IK (x'). K
'pK(x) = xK, cpK(x') = x'
K and n(x) = n(x'1.
-1
for y
'pK(r-l(y)) = nK ($(y)),
(since (cpKxcpK)(Q(n)) = Q(nK)), R(nK) = Q(nK).
But
E
Y. )
(This is possible since
Then
we have
x,x' E X with
Let
TI
(x,x')
E
R(n) = Q(n),
(xK,xi) E Q(nK,).
That is,
XK and YK are metric spaces, so (by our
discussion of the structure theorem in the metric case) R(nK) This contradiction shows that The flows
(XK,K) and
R(n)
f
E
Q(nK).
(YK,K) are constructed as follows. Let
d
d(x,x') I 1 for all
(For instance, d may be defined by d(x,x') = lf(x)-f(x')l,
X.
f
where
*
Q(n).
be a continuous pseudometric on X, with
x,x'
so
is continuous.1 Let
: X+[O,lI
K = {ki}i=l,2,.. . be a
countable subgroup of T, and define the pseudometric dK on X by m
1
=
dK( x,x'
1
d(xki,x'ki).
*
We define a pseudometric dK on Y as
i=l 2
fo1 lows. Let '2
be the Hausdorff pseudometric on X
and let DK A,B
*
E
denote the collection of non-empty closed sets of X,
X 2 DK (A,B) = max[max d(a,B), max d(b,A)I. acA b€B
dK(Y,y' 1 = DK(n-'(y),rr
-1
equivalence relations ((x,x') E
%
*
YK = Y/%,
Define pK
5<
and
X+AKxYK,
:
X-+AK,
*
Then dK
dk:
if
is defined by
The pseudometrics dK and d* K define
<
on X and Y respectively
if dK(x,x') = 0 and similarly for
and let a :
(y')).
induced by
*K
:
Y+YK
* 5<).
Let
AK = X/%,
be the natural projections.
by 'pK(x) = (a(x),+K(n(x)),
and let XK = (pK(X).
Chapter 7
114
Finally, define nK
XK
:
XK+YK,
by nK(a,y) = y.
and YK are metric, that K acts on XK
and YK,
various maps define the commutative diagram ( * I . -1
nK ($,(y))
= cp,(n-l(yl)
It is immediate that
The property that
is a somewhat involved but straightforward
computation. Note also, that the homomorphism nK ( prov i ded
dK
is non-trivial).
and dK(x,x') > 0. Then a(x) (oL(x'),$~(~)) in XK,
and that the
Let x,x' # OL(X'),
E
is nontrivial
X with n(x) = n ( x ' ) =
and so
(a(x),$(y))
y
#
with nK(uK(x),#K(~)) = nK(aK(~'),#K(~))= $,(y).
Thus, for any pseudometric d on X and countable subgroup K of T -1 -1 we can obtain a diagram of type ( * ) satisfying nK ($K(y)) = (oK(n (y)) (y E Y).
In order to ensure that the K-flows
minimal, and that cpK(Q(n)) c Q(nK),
(XK,K) and
(YK,K) are
it is necessary to choose the
subgroup K more carefully. We omit this construction; it is carried out in the cited paper of McMahon and Wu.
115
Chapter 8 Universal Minimal Flows and Ambits A minimal flow
(M,T) is said to be universal if for any minimal flow
(X,T) there is a homomorphism 7
from
(M,T) to
(X,T).
The first part of this chapter is devoted to showing that there is a unique universal minimal flow.
1.
Theorem.
If T
is a topological group, there exists a universal
minimal flow (M,T), and any two universal minimal flows are isomorphic. Proof. Let
M
= [(X,,T)la
be the collection of (isomorphism
E A]
classes) of all minimal flows with phase group T.
(Note that no logical
difficulties are involved in the definition of A.
If
(X,T) is a mini-
mal flow, then X contains a dense subspace whose cardinality is less than or equal to
(TI, the cardinality of T, so
1x1
in the definition of A we are only considering flows
*
less than or equal to a fixed cardinal.) Let X =
I 2
1x1
(X,T) with
ma, and
*
(X ,TI
let
U
be the product flow. Let
M
*
be any minimal subset of X
(since if n a
:
X +Xa
homomorphism from M
is the
.
Then M
is clearly universal
a'th projection, then nalM
is a
to Xa).
This proves existence. The proof of uniqueness is considerably more involved. We first note that it is sufficient to find a coalescent minimal flow (Z,T) such that
(M.T) is a homomorphic image of
(Z,T).
(Recall that a minimal flow is coalescent if every endomorphism is an autornorphism.)
For, in this case, let
mal flow, and let a Then rf3a : Z+Z
:
Z+M, p
:
M+M',
(M',T) be another universal mini7 :
M'+Z
be homomorphisms.
is an endomorphism. By the assumed coalescence of 2 ,
Chapter 8
116
is an automorphism, and it follows that
ypa
It follows also that
phism.
and M
Z
p
:
M+M'
is an isomor-
are isomorphic, so the universal
minimal flow is coalescent. M,
To show the existence of a coalescent pre-image of
we prove a
more general result . 2. Lemma. Let
(X,T) be any minimal flow. Then there is a cardinal
number a and a minimal subset M of
(Xa,T) such that the flow ( M , T )
is coalescent. Proof.
Recall that in the chapter on distal flows, we introduced the
X, and showed that maximal
notion of an almost periodic subset of
X exist. Let C be a maximal almost
almost periodic subsets of periodic subset of
X and let
E
M.
Now z'
C' = range z' z'
:
C+C'
X"
such that
range z = C and z
= c, f o r each c E C ) .
is one to one (for example z
let z'
z E
Let
M = 3, and
is an almost periodic point, and so
is an almost periodic set.
In fact, C'
is one to one. The proof that C'
is maximal, and
is maximal is similar to
the proof of theorem 3 in the chapter on distal flows, and is omitted.
To see that z' {sn)
is one to one, suppose c1,c2 E C with
is a net in T with
z's + z .
n
one to one, it follows that
Then zc = z 1 c2'
almost periodic set.
If
7
z
7(C)
z
and
= (p(z)),,
for c
is
(z,cp(z))
is an
is an
range cp(z) are both maximal
range z = range cp(z).
is a permutation (bijection) of C, let
induced automorphism of
and since z
C2
so range z u range p ( z )
(MxM,T),
But range
almost periodic sets, so
Let
= z'
l
c
1 = c2. Now, let 9 be an endomorphism of (M,T). Then
almost periodic point of
.
z' C
(Xc,T) ((y*(z)lc = E
C. Since cp(z),
r
*
denote the
Define
r
by
(regarded as a map of C
Universd Minimal Flows and Ambits
to X)
117
range (p(z1 = range z , 7
is one to one and
is a permutation of
4
C and
7 (2) = (p(z). 4
Since ( p [ z ) 4
so
(p
= 7
IM
M,
E
7
(MI
and thus
(p
A
M
f
0,
so
7
*
4
(MI = M.
Now
7 ( z ) = (p[z),
is an automorphism. This completes the proof.
M later in the
We will give another proof of the existence of
chapter, and another proof of uniqueness is sketched in exercise 3 . proof of existence doesn't guarantee that
M
is "non-trivial." Later in
the chapter, we'll show that if the group T T on M
Our
is discrete, the action of
is free.
A flow i s said to be point transitive if
it has a dense orbit.
In
this case, a point whose orbit is dense is called a transitive point. An ambit is a point transitive flow with a distinguished transitive point. Precisely, an ambit (or T ambit) is a triple is a point transitive flow and x E X with 0 Of course, if
(X,T,xO), where = X.
(X,T) is a minimal flow, and xo
is an ambit (a "minimal ambit"). If
(X,T)
E
X,
then
(X,T,xO)
(X,T) is any flow, then
(E(X),T,e) is an ambit (which is, in general, not minimal). We will usually write
(X,xo) for an ambit, when the acting group T
is understood.
If
(X,xo) and
homomorphism
(p
:
(Y,y0) are ambits, an ambit homomorphism is a flow
X-+Y
with (p(xo) = yo.
If such an ambit homomorphism
exists, it is clearly unique - in this case we write Obviously, if (Y,yo) and so
(X,xo) t (Y,yo) 2 (X,xo) then t
(X,x0)
(X,xo) t (Y,yo).
is isomorphic to
is a partial ordering on the collection of
(isomorphism classes) of T ambits. A universal
T ambit is a T ambit
(U,uo) t (X,xo) for every T
T ambit exists, it is unique.
ambit
(U,u,)
(X,xo).
such that Obviously, if a universal
Chapter 8
118
The existence of a universal T ambit can be proved in a manner simi'u be the collection
lar to the proof for universal minimal flows. Let of T ambits
(X,x) E 11,
(X,x). If
#
X = TI Xx. Let XX€U
x, and let U
=
z
be the point of
we write
Xx for X, and let
whose X ' t h
X#
X
coordinate is
5. It is clear that (U,T,z) is a (hence the)
universal T ambit. (X,T) is a flow, then
We observed earlier that if ambit, and if lar,
(X,x,)
is an ambit, then
(E(U),e) 2 (U,uo ,
ambit that Thus U
(U,u,)
and
(X,x,).
2
In particu-
and it follows from uniqueness of the universal (E(U),e) are isomorphic, and may be identified.
is endowed with a semigroup structure, in which the maps <-+q,E
are continuous. We may also regard U E(U))
(E(X1.e)
(E(X),T,e) is an
as acting on any flow X
x< = lim xt n'
where t
n
= et
- if x
+C
n
(via the identification with
E
E
U.
X, and 5 E U
then
The same remarks apply to the
universal minimal flow M. Now we present an alternate construction of the universal ambit, in case the acting group T
is discrete. This is accomplished by means of
the Stone-tech compactification PT of T. Recall that /3T is characterized by the property that any map from T to a compact Hausdorff space has an extension to PT.
Precisely, there is an embedding u of
T onto a dense subspace of PT, such that if X space and cp
-cp
:
PT+X
dT),
so
T+X
:
then there is a (necessarily unique) continuous
such that cp = (pu. (Equivalently, if we identify T T
extension of
is regarded as a dense subspace of PT, then (p (p
= ts
(t
E
with
is an
to a continuous map of PT to X.) This permits us to
define an action of T on PT.
as(t)
is a compact Hausdorff
T). Then as
If s
E
T
let as
:
T+PT
gS
:
PT+BT.
extends to a map
by
If
Universal Minimal Flows and Ambits
5
/3T, write
E
g S ( < ) . Now if
for
<s
s,s’ E
119
( 5 s ) ~ ’=
(since both sides agree on the dense subspace T), so TI.
( < E /3T, s , s ’ E
and
-6 s s ,
T, then gS,gs =
3
(/3T,T) is a flow. Note that
=
T
~ ( S S ’ )
= /3T, so
(/3T,e) is an ambit. In fact, (PT,e) is the universal T-ambit. For if
(X,x )
ambit the map
t H x0t of T to X extends to a homomorphism
PT+X
Therefore
II :
If M
such that n(e) = xo.
/3T+X,
II :
(flT,e)2 (X,xo).
“IM
then
maps M
minimal subsets of pT
(For if
x E PT and
t
onto X.) This also shows that all
are isomorphic.
T with t
E
#
e, then xt
first outline a construction of f3T. from T to
I
Let
= [O,ll.
(f E 9). Then q(T)
r) :
T+19
f
is a subset of the compact space
space, and let p : T+X,
show lim p(t .}
25
(p :
X+I
of
J
I+<.
J
) =
and let
in
That is lim f(t
L i1
BT.
J
)
9
I .
(q(t)If = f(t)
I3, and we
Let us indicate why /3T
be a compact Hausdorff Then there is a net exists, for all
x exists. If not, there are subnets {tlj}
f
{tj}
9. We
E
and
{t.) with p(t )+xl and p ( t Z j ) + x 2 , and x I # x2’ Let J 1.j be continuous with cp(x 1) = 0 and cp(x2 = 1, and define
f E 3 by f(t) = (p(p(t)) (t f(t
<E
(That is, if
x.) For this purpose, we
be defined by
has the required extension property. Let- X
r)(t
is free.
3 denote the set of all maps
Let
define /3T to be the closure of r)(T)
in T with
is a (hence
(X,T) is minimal, and
Next we show that the action of T on PT
{t
M
is any minimal subset of PT, it follows that
the) universal minimal flow for T.
is an
0
= (p(p(t
E
T).
Then eventually
1
. I ) < 8, and f(t 2J ) = (p(p(t2J 1) >
15
does not exist.
3
so
lim f(t 1
J
This is a contradiction.
Therefore x = lim p(t .I
J.
exists, and we define GCS) = x.
For
further details on the construction and properties of the Stone-eech
Chapter 8
120
compactification see Kelley, General To~ology,chapter 5 (where it is carried out for a completely regular Hausdorff space). With this representation of PT, t E T and a net f E 3.
If
ti+E s E
E
BT
if and only if
T, and t.-+< 1
E
is identified with
lim f(ti) exists, for every
PT then <s = lim(f(tis))fEg.
fore, in order to show that the action of T on PT find an f
E
9
such that
lim f(ti) # lim f(tis),
To this end, define two elements t
if
T =
(f(t))fE3,
and
is free, we must (provided s
of T to be
T
There-
#
e).
s equivalent
tsk for some integer k, and let H c T be a set containing
one element from each s equivalence class. Thus T union of the sets Hsn
. . . 1.
If s
is not of finite order,
I
if n is even for H. If the 1 if n is odd k k is m, define f by f(hs 1 = - (hEH, k = 1 , 2, . . . , m-1).
define f on T by order of s
(n = O , k l ,
is the disjoint
Then (in both cases)
f(hsn) =
0
m
Jf(tis)-f(ti)l 2
f.
so
lim f(ti)
#
lim f(tis).
Therefore we have proved: 3.
Theorem. If the group T
is discrete, the action of T on the
universal T ambit, (and hence on the universal minimal flow for TI
is
free. W.A. Veech has proved this theorem in case the group T
is locally
compact (Bull. Amer. Math. SOC.,83, 775-8301, If
(M,T) is the universal minimal flow, then
transitive. It is not known whether
(E(M),T)
is point
(E(M),T,e) is the universal
T
ambit. We conclude this chapter with a sketch of yet another construction of the universal ambit, by means of the maximal ideal space. This approach
will be useful when we consider invariant measures on flows. Let T be a topological group, and let fs
denote the bounded right
Universal Minimal Flows and Ambits
121
(A function f
uniformly continuous real valued functions on T. is right uniformly continuous if, for every
E
hood
V of the identity e in T such that
here
1) 1)
T-+R
:
> 0 there is a neighbort [If-f 11 <
for t
E,
E
V;
denotes the supremum norm and ft is defined by
t
4
f ( s ) = f(st), provide B4
for s,t E T.) Let
*
with the weak
of T on B
by
topology.
t (pt)(fl = p(f 1.
and let B be the weak
Now each pt
In this topology a net
p +p
n
It is easily verified that this
action is jointly continuous. If t (f E 2 3 ) .
denote the dual space of 8 and
for every f E 8. We may define an action
if and only if p (f)-+p(f) n 4
B
E
*
T, define pt by pt(f) closure of the set
= f(t)
[ptlt E TI.
has norm one, and therefore so does each q
It
in B.
follows from Alaoglu's theorem (Hewitt and Ross, Abstract Harmonic Analysis, I, p. 458) that
B
is compact. Moreover, if t,s E T and
f E 8, (pt)s(f) = pt(fsl = fs(t) = f(ts) = pts(f)
so
is clearly point transitive. B
(B,T)
is multiplicative
-
(f,g E 8 ) . From this it follows immediately that
pt(fg) = pt(f)pt(g)
identify B
is an
TI
is called the maximal ideal sDace or
structure space of 8. It is obvious that each pt
is multiplicative. Now if f E 23,
?(q) = q(f),
E
is a compact invariant set, The flow
orbit and its closure B
each q E B
[ptlt
for q
E
we define
?:
E C(B)
by
B. The correspondence f + + ? allows us to
with C(B).
This correspondence is one to one (since linear
functionals separate points), preserves algebraic operations, and separates points (if q , p f E 8, so that
F(p)
#
B with q
E
*
p,
then q(f)
*
p(f1
for some
It follows from the Stone-Weierstrass theorem
F(q)).
[?If E 81 = C(B).
This process can be repeated word for word for any uniformly closed invariant subalgebra B'
t then f E 3'.
for all
of 13.
t
E
(By "invariant" we mean that if f E B ' ,
T.1 Let B'
be the maximal ideal space of
Chapter 8
122
8' - that is, B' pi = pt18,.
is the weak
*
closure of
[piit
E
TI, where
T acts on B',
Just as above, it follows that
(B',T) is point transitive, and the correspondence f -? 8' with C(B').
The map from 8*
to B'*
the flow identifies
is
p++pltB'
defined by
onto (this is a consequence of the Hahn-Banach theorem) and this map restricts to an ambit homomorphism from
(B,T,pe) to
(B',T,pk).
In fact, (B,T,pe) is the universal T ambit.
(X,T,x )
For, let
0
be an ambit. In light of the above discussion, it
is sufficient to show that Let
(X,T,xO) is isomorphic with some
8' = [f E Blf(t) = F(xot),
for some F E C(X)l.
(B',T.p;?).
It is easily
checked that 8' is a uniformly closed subalgebra. Let
B'
be its
maximal ideal space, as constructed above. We first define u : B'+X on the orbit of
p' by e
extended to all of B'.
d p ' ) = xot, and then show that
u can be
t
In fact, if
p E
B',
p = lirn p'
for some net
tn in T, s o
{tn)
lim p' (f) exists for all tn
lirn f(tn) = lim F(xotn) exists in X u(p) =
x'.
Hence u
exists for all
(since C(X)
F
E
f E 8'. C(X).
That is
Then
separates points of XI
lim xOtn = x'
and we define
That is, if f and F are related as above p(f) = F(x'). is a homomorphism from
(B',T,pk)
to
(X,T,xO). The proof
will be completed if we show that u
is one to one and this is almost a
tautology. For if d p ) = u(r)) = x'
then p(f) = F(x') =
this equality holds for all
f
E
B',
we have p =
a(f).
Since
r).
Exercises.
1.
If the group T admits non-distal minimal flows, then there is no
universal minimal ambit. That is, there is no ambit minimal, such that
2.
(M,mol with M
(M,mo) t (X,xo), for every minimal ambit (X,xo).
If (X,T) is any flow, and I is a minimal right ideal in the
Universal Minimal Flows and Ambits
enveloping semigroup E ( X ) , (Hint: if cp cp(p) = r p ,
then the minimal flow
is an endomorphism of
for some r
1.1
E
(1,T) then cp
123
(1,T is coalescent. is o f the form
This provides another proof of the
coalescence (and hence uniqueness) of the universal minimal flow. 3. Let
'G
be a non-empty collection of minimal flows
if C'
is any subcollection of
lT[X'IX'
E 'G'],
then N E C.
of
Xo.
and N
is a minimal subset of
Shoy that there is a unique
That is, Xo
minimal flow Xo.
'G
(X,T) such that
E 'G
and if X
E
'G,
"i7 universal"
then X
is a factor
Examples of such classes C are the equicontinuous and distal
minimal flows.
(The 'G
following property: that p(x)
x,y
universal minimal flows are characterized by the E
Xo,
there is an automorphism cp
of
Xo
such
and y are proximal (J. Auslander, Regular Minimal Sets, I,
Trans. Amer. Math. SOC.,123 (19661, 469-479).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
125
Chapter 9 The Equicontinuous Structure Relation and Weakly Mixing Flows In earlier chapters, we have determined completely the structure of the equicontinuous minimal flows. These are, in a sense, the simplest minimal flows, so one may inquire whether an arbitrary minimal flow can be "reduced" to an equicontinuous one. That is, can one "divide out"
Of
appropriately so that the resulting factor flow is equicontinuous?
course, the trivial (one point) flow is an equicontinuous factor of any flow, and later in this chapter we consider the weakly mixing flows, which can be characterized as those minimal flows with no non-trivial equicontinuous factor. Our first result is that every flow (not necessarily minimal) has a "maximal" equicontinuous factor, and then we give a reasonably explicit characterization of the equivalence relation which defines this factor.
1. Theorem.
If
(X,T) is any flow, there is a smallest closed
such that the quotient flow invariant equivalence relation S eq (X/S TI is equicontinuous. eq' Proof. Let
S denote the family of closed invariant equivalence
relations S such that
(WS,T) is equicontinuous. Since the one point
flow is equicontinuous X x X Then S*
E
S,
so
S
*
$.
Let
S* = n [ S I S
E
Sl.
is certainly a closed invariant equivalence relation.
Moreover, the flow $* : X+X/S*
(X/S*,T) is equicontinuous. For, if @s : X+X/S,
are the canonical homomorphisms, then (X/S*,T) may be
regarded as a subflow of the product flow
@*(XI-+ [@s(x))s.
lT W S , T SES
via the map
Since subflows and product flows of equicontinuous
flows are equicontinuous, it follows that
(WS*,T) is equicontinuous.
Chapter 9
126
Clearly S*
s*
=
is the smallest such equivalence relation, and therefore
s
eq' is called the equicontinuous structure The equivalence relation S eq relation and the factor flow (X/S T) is called the maximal eq' equicontinuous factor of (X,TI. Obviously, such an "existential" proof as this one cannot tell us much about the equicontinuous structure relation. We can acquire a better understanding by considering the regionally proximal relation. If
(X,T) is a flow, recall that the regionally proximal relation Q,
(or Q)
is defined by
only if there are nets x
-+x, xn '+x'
n
and
Qx = n ( $ 1 ~ {xn},{xn')
E
%I.
Thus, (x,x')
in X, and
Q
if and
in T with
{tn)
(the diagonal of X x XI.
(xntn,xn'tn')+AX
is a closed invariant relation, which contains
see that
E
Ax,
Q
and it is easy to
(X,T) is equicontinuous if and only if Q = Ax.
Thus it would
be reasonable to expect that an equicontinuous flow can be obtained from an arbitrary flow by "dividing out" by the regionally proximal relation. In general, the regionally proximal relation is not an equivalence relation. A simple example, with T = H
is obtained by considering
three concentric invariant circles in the plane which are joined by spirals. Thus it I s necessary at least to divide out by the closed invariant equivalence relation generated by
Q
("closed" so that the
quotient space so obtained is compact Hausdorff, and "invariant" so that the group T acts on the quotient space).
This is indeed
sufficient as the next theorem shows. First we require a lemma.
2. Lemma. Let x.+x. 1
(X,T) be a flow, and let {xi) be a net in X with
Let q E E(X),
Proof. Let
I) E
and suppose x qjx'. i
I$. Then, for
i
1
Then
io, (x,xi)E
(x',xq) E Q. 7,
so
127
The Equicontinuous Structure Relation
3, are
(xq,xiq) E
therefore
(xq,x') E
q. Hence
n
(xq,x') E
a = Q.
VE%
(X,T) be a flow, and let S*
3. Theorem. Let
be the smallest
closed equivalence relation which contains the regionally proximal relation Q.
(That is, the intersection of all closed invariance equivalence
relations containing Q.) Then S* = S eq' 3 S*, since an equicontinuous flow can' t contain eq = S*, it is non-trivial regionally proximal pairs. To show that S eq sufficient to prove that (X/S*,T) is equicontinuous. To this end, we
Proof. Clearly S
prove that its enveloping semigroup E(X/S*)
(See theorem 2 in the "Joint continuity theorems" chapter. 1
phisms. IT:
is a group of homeomor-
X+X/S*
be the canonical homomorphism, and regard the enveloping
semigroup of X as acting on X/S*. We first show that XIS* distal. Suppose
(y,,y,)
E
P(X/S*).
a minimal right ideal of E(X). n(x2) = y2.
I , n(xlu) = n(x2u).
E
X with n(x,)
for all p
E
I,
so if
= yl,
u
2
Hence X/S*
and let q E E(X).
Let
{xi)
with n(xi) = yi, and let (a subnet of) xi+x, subnet of) xiq+x' (x',xq)
E
Q, so
E
so
= n(xlu)
is distal, and it is sufficient to
show that all elements of E(X/S*) are continuous. Let with yi+y
is an
NOW (xiu,xI)E P(X) (i = l , Z ) ,
(since P c Q c S*), n(xi) = n(xiu), (i = 1,2) and y1 = n(x i = n(x u) = n(x2) = yz.
is
Then ylp = y2p, for all p E I,
Let x 1,x2
Then n(xlp) = n(x,p),
idempotent in
in X/S*
Let
X. Then yiq = n(xiq)+n(x').
so
{yi) be a net
be a net in X n(x) = y.
Let (a
By the lemma,
dx') = dxq) = yq. Thus yiq-+yq, and the proof is
completed. Thus the equicontinuous structure relation has been characterized as the closed equivalence relation generated by the regionally proximal relation. As we have noted the regionally proximal relation need not be
128
Chapter 9
an equivalence relation. However, it is a remarkable fact that for a large class of minimal flows (which include those f o r which the acting group is abelian, as well as point distal flows) the regionally proximal relation
an equivalence relation.
(Since it is always closed
invariant, it coincides with the equicontinuous structure relation in these cases.) What we prove here is that f o r a minimal flow (X,T) which possesses an invariant Bore1 probability measure, Q
is an equivalence relation.
We will show in chapter 12 that an invariant measure exists for a large class of acting groups (including abelian groups).
As we showed in the
"Furstenberg structure theorem" chapter, distal minimal flows admit an invariant measure, so our theorem will apply in this case as well.
(Of
course, we also showed directly in that chapter that regionally proximal is an equivalence relation i n distal minimal flows. 1
is an equivalence relation is preceded by a
The proof that Q
sequence of lemmas, some of which may be of independent interest. We proceed somewhat more generally than is necessary for the purposes of this chapter. The added generality is needed for the chapter on disjointness of flows. Let
(Y,T) be minimal flows, and suppose (Y,T) admits
(X,T) and
an invariant measure A.
(In this chapter, we are concerned with the
IY,T) = (X,T).1
case
If N N(x) = [y
is a subset of X x Y and x E
Yl(x,y)
E
E
X, then the "section"
N).
4. L a . Let N be a closed inva,riet subset of X x Y. Then, if x,x'
E
X, A(N(x1) = A(N(x'1).
Proof. Let
c
> 0 and let V be an open set with N(x) c V and
The Equicontinuous Structure Relation A ( V ) < A(N(x)) +
E.
Let
{tn)
be a net in T for which
is easy to see that N(x'tn) c V
for n 2 no.
n
) =
A(N(x'tn))
S A(V)
arbitrary, we have h(N(x'))
< A(N(x)) +
I A(N(x)).
It
x'tn+x.
(This is equivalent to
the upper semicontinuity of the set map XHN(X).)
A(N(x')t
129
=
Hence A(N(x'))
Since c > 0 is
E.
By symmetry h(N(x))
5
A(N(x')),
and the lemma is proved. If N metric
is a closed invariant subset of X
DN on X
by
x
Y, we define a pseudo-
DN(x.x') = A(N(x) A N(x')).
symmetrjc difference: A A B = ( A \ B) u (B \ A);
(Here A
denotes the
it is well known, and
easily proved that DN is a pseudometric.
5. Lemma. The pseudometric DN is T-invariant and continuous. Proof. The T-invariance of DN is an immediate consequence of the assumed T-invariance of the measure A. we first note that if U A(U\N(x)) <
In fact, if N(x0 c U. A(U)
-A(N(x)) = A(U\N(x))
xn+x. Then, if
Let n
DN(x,x ) < n
E,
sufficiently close to x.
for x'
- A(N(x'))
then A(U\N(x')) = A ( U )
<
n N(xn) c U 0'
tion, and A(N(xn)\N(x)) SO
<
c.
Now, let
{x
}
n
=
be a net in X with
> 0, U open in Y with NIX) c U and A(U\N(x))
E
2
DN is continuous,
is an open set in Y, with N(x) c U, and
then A(U\N(x'))
E,
To show that
and A(U\N(xn)) <
I A(U\N(x))
Thus, if xn+x,
E.
< E.
E,
<
E.
by the above observa-
Similarly A(N(x)\N(xn))
< e,
It follows
we have DN(x,x )+O. n
immediately that DN is continuous. Now, let
$
be the equivalence relation defined by
DN
:
(x,x') E
KN
if DN(x,x') = 0. 6. Lemma.
%
is a closed T-invariant equivalence relation which
contains Q. Proof.
The previous lemma implies that
is closed and invariant.
130
Chapter 9
(x,x') f Q, let {xn),{x;l)
If
with xn+x,
x'nt n-+z,
a net in T
for some z E X.
Now
and also D (x , X I ) = DN(xntn,xAtn)+DN(z,z) = 0 , N n n
DN (xn ,x')+DN(x,x') n so we have
and xnt n+ z ,
x'n+x',
{tn)
be nets in X and
DN(x,x') = 0 and
(x,x') E
5.
is the smallest Since the equicontinuous structure relation S eq closed invariant equivalence relation which contains 8 , we immediately obtain
7. Corollary. If N
is a closed invariant subset of X
x
Y,
then
KN.
'eq
Now we specialize to the case Y = X. 8. Theorem. Let
(X,T) be a minimal flow with an invariant Bore1
probability measure h .
Then the equicontinuous structure relation S
eq
coincides with the regionally proximal relation Q. Proof. Since always Q c S it i s sufficient to show that eq' S c Q. Let (x,y) E S and let V be a neighborhood of x. eq eq' Consider the closed invariant subset N of X x X defined by
N =
u
(y,x')T =
u r n .
Hence
x' EV
L
x't n+w,
N = closure (z,w)lytn+ z ,
for some X'E V, and net
Then V c N(y)
closed, V c N(x).
5.
Since V
(x,y) E
S eq'
hood of x, then there is an x' E V and a
t E
yr are in V.
and
is open and N(x)
is
(x,y) E S so (x,y) E eq' For, h(V\N(x)) S h(N(y)-N(x)) 5
A(N(x) A N(y)) = 0, since (x,y) E Summarizing, if
Since V
in T.]
5,
(take tn = el. Now
it follows that V c N(x).
{tn)
and V
is a neighbor-
T such that x ' t
is arbitrary, it follows that
and
(x,y) E Q.
Note that the proof just given shows that in the definition of Q one
The Equicontinuous Structure Relation
131
can take one of the nets in X to be constant. Precisely, we have: 9.
Corollary. Under the hypotheses of the preceding theorem
(x,y) E Q
if and only if there are nets {xn)
with x +x, n
xntn+x
in X and
{tn)
in T
and yt -+x. n
In turn this corollary can be reformulated to yield: 10. Corollary.
If x E X, Q(x) =
n aT(x). "Ilx
That some restriction (either on the group or the action) is necessary in order that Q be an equivalence relation, is shown by the following example, due to McMahon. The space X is generated by the homeomorphisms cp
is the circle, and the group T and @.
The homeomorphism cp
is
a rotation through an irrational angle ( s o certainly (X,T) is minimal). @
-. A
has fixed points at 0, 2
IC,
3H T , and maps the arcs between the fixed
points onto themselves in the same "increasing" manner: where
~ ( 0 >)
0. I t is easily checked that
A
(0,2)
E
#(0) = 0
+
~(01,
n
Q, ( z , n ) E Q, but
( 0 , ~e)Q.
Now we use the technique just developed to investigate the class of flows which are "highly non-equicont inuous. "
The flow
(X,T) is called
weaklv mixing if every non-empty open invariant subset U of X x X dense in X x X*'
is
(as usual, "invariant" is with respect to the product
action (x,y)t = (xt,yt)). mixing, then Q = X x X, so
It is easy to see that if (X,T) is weakly (X,T) has no non-trivial equicontinuous
*'The term "weakly mixing" is used because of an analogous concept in ergodic theory. A measure theoretic system is called weakly mixing if the product system is ergodic. The phrase "topologically ergodic" is sometimes used as a synonym for "topologically transitive" - every invariant open set is dense (so if the phase space is metric this is equivalent to the existence of a dense orbit).
Thus the flow (X,T) is
weakly mixing if and only if the product flow (X x X,T) is ergodic.
Chapter 9
132
factor. In fact, in the class of minimal flows which admit an invariant measure, this property imp1ies weak mixing. For, suppose
is minimal, not weak mixing, and let A
(X,T)
invariant measure. Let U be an open invariant subset of X
U
4 and N = fi
f
*X
x X.
is an open set V with x
Let x E
N(x) = X, i t follows that N Then V7
n
W c N(x71,
E
X.
X
x
XI.
Let
A(N(xT)\N(x))
so
(X,T)
1
7 E
A((V7
X, with
x
is minimal, there
*
Now W = X \ N(x)
V c N(x). =
Since
be an
0
(for if
T such that V-c n W n
W)\N(x))
#
0.
=
h(Vz n W) > 0. Hence D (X,XT) > 0. N be the equivalence relation defined by DN Again, let
5
if and only if DN(x,x’) = 0). Since DN is nontrivial,
((x,x’) E then of
f
and
X x X,
is a non-trivial equicontinuous factor
(X/S,T)
( X , TI.
Thus weak mixing is equivalent to having no non-trivial equicontinuous factor. The next results show that proximality abounds in weak mixing minimal flows. 11. Theorem. Let metric. Suppose
(X,T) be a weakly mixing minimal flow with X admits a regular Bore1 probability measure A .
(X,T)
A be a countable subset of X.
Let
proximal with every a Proof. If x
E
E
Then there is a z
which is
E X
A.
X, then X
=
Q(x) =
n
so
that aT(x)
is
“Ilx open and dense in X. Let {ai}i=1,2 be a countable base for the uniformity 11,
B
ij
and let A = {a1,a2,.. . } .
is open and dense in X,
dense in X I .
so
Let B
n (oliT)(a
1=
1, . i
If z
f
n BiJ’
i,J
clearly (z,a.) E J
ij
= (aiT)(a 1.
J
Then
n BiJ * 9 (in fact 1,J P for J = 1,2,..
12. Corollary. Under the hypotheses of the previous theorem,
..
The Equicontinuous Structure Relntwn
P
2
= X x X,
and P(x)
is dense in X
for every x
133
E
X.
We summarize the characterizations of weakly mixing minimal flows in the following theorem. The equivalence of the statements have either been proved, or follow easily from our discussion. 13. Theorem. Let
(X,T)
be a minimal flow, with
admits an invariant measure A.
X metric, which
Then the following are equivalent:
a)
(X,T)
b)
( X , T) has no non-trivial equicontinuous factor (i.e.,
s
eq
=
is weakly mixing.
x
x XI.
c)
(X,T) has no non-trivial distal factor.
d)
Q = X x X .
e) The proximal relation P f) P
2
is dense in X x X.
= x x x .
P(x)
s dense in X
for every x E X .
h) P(x)
s dense in X
for some x E X .
g)
At present there is no general structure theorem for weakly mixing minimal flows, although certain subclasses have been intensively studied. An example of a weakly mixing flow will be given in the final chapter. Our final result in this chapter is that for a minimal flow with an invariant measure regional proximality can be effected "in any direction." That is, if
then there are nets {x;} {yn},
{xn} , {yn) are nets with xn+x,
(x,y) E Q and
and
respectively, and a net
{y;}
"arbitrarily close" to
{tn}
in T such that
yn-+y {xn}
and
(x;tn,y;tn)4A.
The precise statement follows. 14. Theorem. Let
(X,T)
be a minimal flow with an invariant
probability measure and let neighborhoods W1
of x and
(x,y) E Q. Let
W2
a
E
?$.
Then there are
of y such that if U1 and U2
are
Chapter 9
134
and W2,
non-empty open subsets of W 1
x'
U,, y'
E
E
respectively, then there are
and t E T such that
U2
(x't,y't) E a.
For the proof, we first require a lemma.
Let V1
15. Lemma.
Q(V,)
is open.
Then Q ( V , )
If x1 E V1,
Proof.
V2.
and V2 x
be open subsets of
X and suppose that
c (V, x V2)T.
Q(V,)
construct N
as in theorem 8, using
That is +z,
x't +w, n
for some X'E V2, and some net
Then, as in the proof of theorem 8, if y1 {y,) x Vz c N.
Q(V,)
x
Since x1
V2 c l V l x V2)T.
E
V1
open subset of X.
is open by assumption so we may x
U )T n W
x
2
Let let
n
:
*
We show that i f
U1
and U2
x
V 2 IT.
W be a non-empty
are open sets in X
respectively, then
$.
X-+X/Q
T with
T E
Q(V 2 1 c IV,
(x,y) E Q and let
which are sufficiently close to x and y. (U,
T.]
Q(xl) = S (xl), eq is arbitrary, it follows easily that
Now Q(V,)
Now we prove theorem 14. Let
in
{tn)
E
iterate the above process to obtain Q(V,)
z
x1 and
be the canonical homomorphism, let
zt
E
int n(W)
and let
V
z = n(x) = n(y),
ff
be an open neighborhood of
*
such that V T c int n(W). Let
W1 and W2
n(Wi) c V
Let
*
be open sets in X
(i = 1,2). Let
U1 c W1
and
with x E W1, y E Wz
U c W2 2
and
be non-empty open sets.
n(U 1) ( i = 1 , Z ) . Then n(V,) and Q(Vi) = i ( i = 1,Zl are open. By lemma 15, Q(V1)xQ(V2) c (VlxVZ)T so
V i = Ui n n-'(int
n-'n(Vi)
(Q(V,lxQ(V,))T
c
(U1XU2)T n W *
$,
c
(U1XUZ)T.
Therefore, to conclude that
it is sufficient to show (Q(Vl)xQ(V2)lT
nW
#
$.
Now
The Equicontinuous Structure Relation
135
n(Q(V.)r) c V * z c int n(W) (j = 1,2), so there are x'. E Q(V.1 such J J J -1 that n(x'.z) E int n(W) (j = 1.2). Thus there are x; E I xi)), J -1 :x E I (n(x;)) such that x;r, X*T 2 E W. But x; E Q(x;) c Q(V,) and similarly xa
E
QCV,),
so
(Q(V,)xQ(V,))T
n
W
*
4.
The techniques and many of the results in this chapter, in particular the use of the pseudometric DN and the equivalence relation
%,
due to McMahon (Trans. Amer. Math. SOC. 236 (19781, 225-237).
This is
are
also the case for the results in the disjointness chapter concerning flows with an invariant measure. Exercises. 1.
Determine the maximal equicontinuous factor of the minimal flow which
is the orbit closure of the almost periodic point in {O,l}'
defined in
exercise 9 of chapter 1.
2. Let P be a family of flows (with fixed acting group TI satisfying: (i)
the trivial (one-point) flow is in P.
(ii)
P is productive (any product of flows in P is also in P).
(iii) P is hereditary (a closed invariant subflow of any flow in P
is in P I . Then if (X,T) is any flow, X has a "maximal P factor.
'I
That is,
there is a smallest closed invariant equivalence relation R such that (X/R,T) is in P. 3.
Note that "distal" is a class of flows to which the previous exercise
applies. Show that the distal structure relation is the smallest closed invariant equivalence relation which contains the proximal relation P. (In general, P
is not an equivalence relation for minimal flows, and
even if P is an equivalence relation, it need not be closed. 1 4.
A flow
(X,T) is mixing if given U and V non-empty open sets in
chapter 9
136
X, there is a compact subset K of T such that Ut n V t
E
S.
T
\
f
4,
for all
K. Show that a mixing flow is weakly mixing.
In the case
(X,T) is minimal, give a proof of theorem 3 , which uses
theorem 8 in the “Furstenberg structure theorem” chapter. 6. Show (under the hypotheses of theorem 13) that if
(X,T) is weakly
mixing, with T abelian, then P is not an equivalence relation. More generally, show that the enveloping semigroup E(X)
contains infinitely
many minimal right ideals. 7. Let
(X,T) be a (not necessarily minima 1 weakly mixing flow, with T
abelian. Then any finite product
(X x X x
..
x
X,T) is topologically
ergodic (hence weakly mixing). 8.
Let
Show that
(X,T) be a proximal minimal flow (all pairs are proximal). (X,T) is weakly mixing.
(This problem is more difficult than
the other problems - see Glasner, Proximal Flows, chapter 11.
Note that
for a proximal minimal flow, T must be non-abelian, and the flow (X,T) need not admit an invariant measure, chapter does not apply. 1
so
that the theory developed in this
137
Chapter 10 The Algebraic Theory of Minimal Flows We begin this chapter by reviewing and amplifying some of the contents of the chapter "Universal minimal flows and ambits." We will assume throughout this chapter that the acting group T M = (M,'f)
Let
is discrete.
be the universal minimal flow for T.
minimal right ideal in the enveloping semigroup E ( M ) , i n E M,
the map
p w m p defines a homomorphism of
I
defining property of M,
is isomorphic with M,
If I
is a
then for any
I onto M.
By the
and since M
is
is an isomorphism. Hence we can carry over
coalescent, the map p-mp
I to M.
the semigroup structure of
With this identification, M
can
be regarded as a semigroup, and we can endow it with the structure of a minimal right ideal, as developed in earlier chapters.
In particular, M
contains idempotents -- we write J(M) for the set of idempotents in M and fix u E J ( M ) . Thus it is meaningful to write and p E M.
That is, each ti
defines, ti+p
E
I c E(M),
ti+p,
where
{ti)
is a net in T
is identified with the element of
and
#
it
I is identified with M as discussed
above. If X
is a factor of X'
then, as we have noted a number of times,
we can regard the enveloping semigroup of X' K : X'+X
then n(x')p'
= n(x'p')
as acting on X
for x' E X'
and p' E E ( X ' ) .
Using this convention, together with the identification of M minimal right ideal in its enveloping semigroup E ( M ) , (M,T) p E M,
J
where
{t
J
}
is a net in T
with a
we can think of
as acting on any minimal flow (X,T). That is, if x then xp = lim xt
-- if
E
X, and
such that
Chapter 10
138
tJ+p. xM =
(X,T) is a minimal flow and x
(It follows that if =
E
X, then
X.)
Similarly, the universal T ambit (X,T,x): if x
BT, then x< = lim xt
where J. pT. Of course, since the universal minimal flow M is a E
X and
(@T,T,e) acts on any ambit
E
t.+< E J minimal subset of the flow (pT,T) this shows again that M acts on X. Several arbitrary choices have been made in the above discussion universal minimal set M, a semigroup structure for M choosing a minimal right ideal phism from I to MI
I in E(M)
--
a
(obtained by
and specifying a homomorin M.
and an idempotent u
These will be fixed
throughout the chapter. Let G = Mu. chapter, C
From Lemma 1 (iv) of the second enveloping semigroup
is a group with identity u. G can be identified with the
group of flow automorphisms of M
--
if a
E
G, cp(p) = ap
(p E M)
is
obviously an automorphism of M, and it can be shown that all automorphisms are of this form (see exercise 1). Note that if p a
E
G
Let
and w
E
E
M, p has a unique decomposition as p = aw where
J(M).
In fact, if pw = p.
then p = (pu)w.
(X,x) be a minimal ambit. We will assume throughout the chapter
that xu = x where u
is the idempotent in M
which was fixed above.
The ~rouz,of I! with baseDoint x is defined by
B ( X , x ) = [ a E Glxa =
XI
It is immediate that B(X,x) is a subgroup of G. Thus to each minimal ambit subgroup of G.
If x'
x'p = x. Then if a
E
E
(X,x) with xu = x, we have associated a
X with x'u = x',
P(X,x), x'f3ap-l = x'
then there is p E G with and !?(X,x')
=
pG(X,x)p-l.
That is, a change of basepoint gives rise to a conjugate subgroup of C.
It turns out that the subgroups P ( X . x ) are very useful in the study of proximal and distal extensions.
Recall thatxa homomorphism I I : X+Y
The Algebraic Theory of Minimal Flows
of minimal flows is proximal if whenever
x,x'
then x and x'
71
x,x'
E
are proximal, and that
X with x
and n(x) = n(x'),
x'
#
In these cases, we also say that
X
E
139
X with n(x) = ~(x'),
is distal if whenever
then x and x'
are distal.
is a proximal (or distal) extension
of Y. Note that a homomorphism is both proximal and distal if and only if it is an isomorphism.
Of course, an extension need not be either proximal
or distal. of C determines
Now we consider to what extent the subgroup B(X,x)
the ambit. Obviously isomorphic ambits define the same subgroup, and if X:
(X,x)-+(Y,y)
is a homomorphism then B(X,x)
is a subgroup of
Our first results show that the ambit is determined "modulo a
B(Y,y).
proximal extension." 1.
Theorem. Let
R :
(X,x)-+ (Y,y) be a homomorphism of minimal
ambits. Then B(X,x) = k?(y,y)
is a proximal
if and only if TI
extension.
Proof. If B(X,x) is a proper subset of B(Y,y), p
Then n(xf3) = yp = y = dx),
B(Y,y)\B(X,x).
E
(x,xp) e P, so
n
Then x'u
x6 = x'u,
xs 2.
f
x<,
so
sg-l
but
E
(x',~'')
X with
~[(x'u) = K(x"u).
Let
&
71
is not
P and n(x'f
S.<
E
=
G with
Then y6 = n(xa) = ~(x'u) = 71(x"u) = R(x<) = y< so
-1
Theorem. Let (i)
x"u
#
x< = x"u.
y6C-l = y and 6<
xf3 # x, and
is not proximal. Conversely, suppose
proximal. Then there are x', X"
x(x").
let
B(Y,y).
E
s!
f
X"U,
B(X,X).
(X,x) and
D(X,x) c B(Y,y) extension X'
On the other hand, since x'u
(Y,y) be minimal ambits. Then
if and only if Y
of X.
Is
a factor of a proximal
Chapter 10
140
(ii) B(X,x) = B(Y,y)
if and only if there is a minimal flow X'
which is a proximal extension of both X and Y. Proof. If
z = (x,y) E X x Y
if a
is proximal and
x'
E
X'
with x'u = x'
and
x, then 9(X',x') = 9(X,x) c B(Y,y). If B(X,x) c B(X,y),
=
n(x')
X'+X
TL:
B(x,x),
E
and let X' =
x'
so
then zu = z
B(Y,y),
z.
Now if a
za = z
E C,
is a proximal extension of X. i f and only'if
a
E
let
if and only
If B(X,x) =
B(X,x) = B(Y,y),
so
X'
is a proximal extension of both X and Y. The next few results show that in the case of distality, the group determines the flow. Theorem. Let
3.
(X,x) and
(Y,y) be minimal ambits, with Y
distal. Then B(X,x) c B(Y,y) if and only if there is a homomorphism with n ( x ) = y.
n : X+Y
Proof. By theorem 2, there is a proximal extension X' that Y
is a factor of X'.
That
Y
of
X such
is actually a factor of X
is a
consequence of the following lemma. 4. Lemma. Let
(X,T), (Y,T) and
(X',T)
be minimal flows with
and 9 : X'+Y
(Y,T) distal. Suppose u : X'+X
with u proximal. Then there I s a homomorphism nu =
71:
X-+Y
such that
*.
Proof.
If x
E
X, define n ( x ) = I/J(x')
dx") = x then (x',~'')
$(x")
are homomorphisms
since Y
E
P(X')
so
is distal. Thus
H
where dx') = x.
(#(x'),#(x''))
E
If also
P(Y) and *(x') =
is well defined, and the proof is
completed. 5. Corollary. Let
Then
(X,x) and
(X,x) and
(Y,y) be distal minimal ambits.
(Y,y) are isomorphic if and only if B(X,x) = B(Y,y).
The Akebraic Theory of Minimal Flows
141
The next two theorems concern distal homomorphisms of minimal flows and ambits.
In the chapter on distal flows, we introduced the notion of
an almost periodic &
-- this is a subset A of X such that if
XIA' with range z
z E
A, then z
=
is an almost periodic point of the
(XIA',T).
flow
n : X+Y
6. Theorem. Let
be a homomorphism of minimal flows.
Then the following are pairwise equivalent: (i)
n
is distal.
(ii)
n-l(y)
(iii) If y
n (ivl
-1
is an almost periodic set, for every y E
Y and v
(y)v = n
If y
E
If x E n
R
-1
and it follows that R
-1
M, n -1 (yp) = n-'(y)p.
E
is distal. Let
(y),
(x,xv) E P, so
Now
such that yv = y, then
E J(M)
(y).
Y and p
Proof. Suppose yv = y.
-1
y
Y and v
E
~ ( x v )= yv = y,
(x,x')
that
so
xv = x. That is xv = x, n-'(y)
E
with
J(M)
R(X) = y
for all x
=
E
n
R(XV).
-1
(y),
is an almost periodic set. Conversely, if
x, x'
(y) is an almost periodic set, then if
then
Y.
E
is almost periodic, so
(x,x')
CZ
E R
-1
(y) with x
P. Then n
#
x',
is distal,
and (i) and ( i i ) are equivalent. Now if n-'(y)v
R
is distal and yv = y
c n-'(y)
paragraph that
and if xv = x so
it is clear that n
-1
x
(y E Y,v E j ( M ) )
n-'(y),
E
-1
II
(y)v = n
then
it follows as in the preceding -1
(y). If n-'(y)
= n-'(y)v
then
(y) is an almost periodic set. Hence (i), (ii),
and (iii) are equivalent. Suppose
K
is distal, and let y E Y,
idempotents in M rp = v
with yw = y,
pv = p,
p E
M. Let v and w be
and let
(Enveloping Semigroup, 11, lemma 1, (vi)).
r
E M
with pr = w,
Chapter I0
142
NOW
n n
-1 -1
always n
(ylpr c x (y)w = n
-1
-1
(y)p c n-l(yp),
(yp)r c n
-1
(ypr) = n
-1
(yp)r =
11
-1
-1
(y)w =
-1 (yw) = n (y). By (iii),
Thus
(y).
(iii) again (applied to yp), -1
-1
n
-1 (y), so all the inclusions above are equalities; in
particular n
H
so
(ypl = n
-1
(YIP,
-1 n
we have
( y p ) ~= n -1
-1
(yp)v = n
-1 (yp)rp = n (YIP.
-1
By
(yp), and so
which is (iv).
Clearly (iv) implies (iii) (take p = v
J(M)
E
with yv
y)
=
and the
proof is completed. 7. Theorem. Let flows. Then n
n
:
(X,x)+ (Y,y) be a homomorphism of minimal
is distal if and only if n
-1
(yp) = xg(Y,y)p,
for all
p E M. yu = y. Suppose n
Proof. Recall we are assuming xu = x, so distal. Then always xg(Y,y) c n ( i i i ) of theorem 6, x'u =
x',
x' = xqu and .qu E 9(Y,y). then by theorem 6 (iv), suppose n
a1.a2
E
*
.
xD(Y,y)p,
F(Y,y).
If
Let
8.
II
so if
-1
= xq, H
-1
(yp) = n-'(y)p for all
v
E J(M)
n
-1
for q
(y) then by
E
M,
(y) = xO(Y,y).
p E M,
such that
E
= xg(Y,y)p.
p E M such that
y
= yp.
If p
E
M,
Conversely,
and let x1
*
then
*
-1
Then
-
xa2p,
pv = p,
then
x2 with
*
=
(y
with
(x1, x21 is an almost periodic point, and it
is distal.
be a distal homomorphism of minimal
Theorem. Let K : X+Y
flows. Then H
x'
and we have x1 = x y p , x2
(xl,xz)v = (xl,x2), so follows that
(y) and if x'
Therefore,
-1 (yp) = xB(Y,y)p,
n(x,) = n(x2) = y R -1 (yp) =
H
-1
is
is open and all fibers n
-1
(y) have the same
cardinality. Proof. Let y E Y, xo y,+y.
Let
q E M
n
E
n
-1
(y) and let
with yqn = yn. Let
{y,)
be a net in Y with
(a subnet of) q +q
n
so
The Atebraic Theory of Minimal Flows
yq = y. x'q = x0.
(y)q = n-'(y).
Q
-1
from H
one-to-one so card(n ( y) 1 =
xn+x0
Let and
x' n(x
E
n-l(y)
such that
n ) = n(x'q n )
=
= yq
n
is open.
TI
y, y' E Y and let p
defines a map
card ( n-'
H
Then, if xn = x'qn,
yn. This proves that Let
-1
By theorem 6,
143
-1 (y))
E
M
(y) to card(n
5
with yp = y'. -1 T[
(y').
-1 (y')).
Then xo ++ XOP
Since
s distal, u
H
is
By symmetry
card( H-' ( y' ) 1.
Theorem 8 shows that distal homomorphisms have properties similar to those of covering maps.
Another such property is given in the following
theorem, which generalizes theorem 3. 9. Theorem. Let
(X,x), (Y,y) and
xu = x, yu = y, zu = z . be homomorphisms with <:
(X,x)+(Y,y)
91,
Let
( 2 , ~ )be minimal ambits with
H : (X,x - + ( Z , z )
and
$ : (Y,y)+(Z,z)
distal. Then there is a homomorphism H =
such that
$5
if and only if B(X,x) c B(Y,y).
We omit the proof (see J. Auslander, Homomorphisms of minimal transformation groups Topology, 9 (19701, 195-203.) Now we turn to the question of determining which subgroups of C the groups of some minimal ambit. It turns out that with a topology (the
"t
C
are
can be endowed
topology") and that the subgroups which
correspond to minimal ambits are precisely the subgroups which are closed in this topology.
For this purpose, we need to consider the induced flow on the closed subsets of a space.
is a compact Hausdorff space, let '2
If X
the collection of non-empty subsets of X.
A base for a topology on
is defined as follows. If U1,.. . ,Un are open sets in X, let .. n x {Ul,.. .,Un} = [ A E 2 I A c Ui, and A n U * $, i = 1,..., n]. i i=l
u
collection of all sets {Ul, ..., Un}
denote
'2
The
defines a compact Hausdorff topology
Chapter 10
144
on '2
X 2 , provided with the Hausdorff
(the Hausdorff toDolorrv).
topology, is often referred to as a "hyperspace".
{A 1 J
A net
a E A,
aJ
E
A
in 2'
converges to A
there is an a
j
and a