Model-oriented Systems Engineering Science: A Unifying Framework for Traditional and Complex Systems (Crc Complex and Enterprise Systems Engineering)

MODEL-ORIENTED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING SCIENCE A Unifying Framework for Traditional and Complex Systems COMPLEX AND ENTER...

Author: Duane W. Hybertson

63 downloads 1045 Views 4MB Size Report

This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!

Report copyright / DMCA form

DOWNLOAD PDF

MODEL-ORIENTED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING SCIENCE A Unifying Framework for Traditional and Complex Systems

COMPLEX AND ENTERPRISE SYSTEMS ENGINEERING Series Editors: Paul R. Garvey and Brian E. White The MITRE Corporation www.enterprise-systems-engineering.com

Designing Complex Systems: Foundations of Design in the Functional Domain Erik W. Aslaksen ISBN: 1-4200-8753-3 Publication Date: October 17, 2008 Architecture and Principles of Systems Engineering Charles Dickerson and Dimitri N. Mavris ISBN: 1-4200-7253-6 Publication Date: January 30, 2009 Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science: A Unifying Framework for Traditional and Complex Systems Duane W. Hybertson ISBN: 1-4200-7251-X Publication Date: February 15, 2009 Enterprise Systems Engineering: Theory and Practice George Rebovich, Jr. and Brian E. White ISBN: 1-4200-7329-X Publication Date: April 15, 2009 Leadership in Decentralized Organizations Beverly G. McCarter and Brian E. White ISBN: 1-4200-7417-2 Publication Date: May 15, 2009 Engineering Mega-Systems: The Challenge of Systems Engineering in the Information Age Renee Stevens ISBN: 1-4200-7666-3 Publication Date: June 25, 2009 Complex Enterprise Systems Engineering for Operational Excellence Kenneth C. Hoffman and Kirkor Bozdogan ISBN: 1-4200-8256-6 Publication Date: November 16, 2009 Social and Cognitive Aspects of Engineering Practice Stuart S. Shapiro ISBN: 1-4200-7333-8 Publication Date: March 30, 2010

RELATED BOOKS Analytical Methods for Risk Management: A Systems Engineering Perspective Paul R. Garvey ISBN: 1-5848-8637-4 Probability Methods for Cost Uncertainty Analysis: A Systems Engineering Perspective Paul R. Garvey ISBN: 0-8247-8966-0

MODEL-ORIENTED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING SCIENCE A Unifying Framework for Traditional and Complex Systems

Duane W. Hybertson

Zachman enterprise framework © 1987 John A. Zachman; hexagon model © 1998 Zachman Framework Associates; derivative work © 2002 Zachman Framework Associates; metamodel projection © 2008 Zachman Framework Associates. 2009 single commercial publication license 291345 issued to Duane W. Hybertson. All rights reserved.

Auerbach Publications Taylor & Francis Group 6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300 Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742 © 2009 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC Auerbach Publications is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business No claim to original U.S. Government works Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 International Standard Book Number: 978-1-4200-7251-8 (Hardback) This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the consequences of their use. The authors and publishers have attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material reproduced in this publication and apologize to copyright holders if permission to publish in this form has not been obtained. If any copyright material has not been acknowledged please write and let us know so we may rectify in any future reprint. Except as permitted under U.S. Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.copyright.com (http:// www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that provides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Hybertson, Duane W. Model-oriented systems engineering science : a unifying framework for traditional and complex systems / author, Duane W. Hybertson. p. cm. -- (Complex and enterprise systems engineering) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-4200-7251-8 (alk. paper) 1. Systems engineering--Simulation methods. 2. System analysis--Technique. 3. Engineering models. I. Title. II. Series. TA168.H93 2009 620.001’171--dc22 Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com and the Auerbach Web site at http://www.auerbach-publications.com

2008044364

Contents #PPL4VNNBSZYWJJ 1SFGBDFYJY "DLOPXMFEHNFOUTYYJ "CPVUUIF"VUIPS YYJJJ

1

0QQPSUVOJUJFTBOE$IBMMFOHFTGPS4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH The State of Aﬀairs of SE $IBSBDUFSJ[JOH5SBEJUJPOBM4& The NFFEUP4USFOHUIFO54& 'BJMFE1SPKFDUT %FBMJOHXJUI$IBOHFBOE0UIFS(FOFSBM4IPSUDPNJOHT 6OFYQFDUFE4ide Eﬀects 0QQPSUVOJUJFT5ZQFTPG&YQBOTJPO $IBSBDUFSJTUJDTPG$4 &YBNQMF$4.PEFMTBOE4ZTUFNT $IBOHJOH1FSTQFDUJWFTPO$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT .PSF1FPQMF*OWPMWFE.BTT$PMMBCPSBUJPO 5SBEJUJPOBM.BTT$PMMBCPSBUJPO 4UPSZUFMMJOH 4DBMJOHJO"MM%JSFDUJPOT 4DBMJOH6Q4& 4DBMJOH%PXO4& .VMUJTDBMF4& 4DBMF7JFXQPJOUT The BSJEHF*OGPSNBUJPO $PNQVUBUJPO 4PGUXBSF 54&3FMBUFE$IBSBDUFSJTUJDT $4&3FMBUFE$IBSBDUFSJTUJDT #SJEHF3FMBUFE$IBSBDUFSJTUJDT $IBMMFOHFT"'PVOEBUJPO/FFEFEGPSUIF'VUVSF4& (FOFSBM$IBMMFOHF4VQQPSU&YQBOEFE4DPQF (FOFSBM$IBMMFOHF6OJGZ v

vi

O Contents

6OJGZ54&BOE$4& 6OJGZ.VMUJQMF%JTDJQMJOFT 4peciﬁc RFRVJSFNFOUT-JTUGPS/FX4&'PVOEBUJPO 3FTQPOTF.PEFM0SJFOUFE4&4DJFODF 4DPQFBOE#BTJD"TQFDUT 4DPQFPG.04&4 "TQFDU%FTDSJQUJPOT 8IZ.04&4 1PUFOUJBM"VEJFODFT 0SHBOJ[BUJPOPGUIF#PPL 3FGFSFODFT

2

4ZTUFNT4DJFODF$POUFYU $PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPG4DJFODF 8IBU*T4DJFODF 1SFSFRVJTJUF-BXT -BXPG3FRVJTJUF7BSJFUZ -BXPG(SBEBUJPO -BXPG3FRVJTJUF1BSTJNPOZ 4DJFODFBOE&OHJOFFSJOH 1SFWJFX4DPQFPG4DJFODFBOE&OHJOFFSJOH /BUVSBMBOE"Stiﬁcial Science: DJTUJODUJPOTBOE1BSBMMFMT $PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPG&OHJOFFSJOH &OHJOFFSJOH8IBU%PFT*U.FBOGPS$PNQMFYPS)ZCSJE4ZTUFNT 3FMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFO4DJFODFBOE&OHJOFFSJOH 4IBXBOE'JODI)JTUPSJDBM1BUUFSO .04&4$PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO 4ZTUFNT4DJFODFBOE$44 8IZ4ZTUFNT4DJFODF*T*NQPSUBOUGPS4& Themes )PMJTN .VMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJUZPS(FOFSBMJUZ $MPTF*OUFSUXJOJOHXJUI$44JOUIF-JUFSBUVSF &TTFODFPG44BOE*UT3FMBUJPOTIJQXJUI$44 %JTDJQMJOFT$POUSJCVUJOHUP4&4 6OJUZBOE6niﬁcation 4ZTUFNT5BYPOPNZBOEUIF.04&4'PVOEBUJPO 3FGFSFODFT

3

$PSF$PODFQUTPG.PEFM0SJFOUFE4&4DJFODF .04&4 .04&4JO"DUJPO"4UPSZBCPVU#VJMEJOHBO"VUPNBUFE$BS 4FUUJOHUIF4UBHF .04&4 1SPCMFN4JUVBUJPO "VUPNBUJPO*TTVFT 6TJOHBOE5BJMPSJOH.PEFMT

Contents

O

vii

"QQSPBDIFTUP-FBSOJOH "QQSPBDI1Sedeﬁned RVMFT#BTFE "QQSPBDI4JNVMBUJPO-FBSOJOH#BTFE "QQSPBDI0CTFSWBUJPO-FBSOJOH#BTFE -BOHVBHFBOE1SFDJTJPOPG.PEFMT &OHJOFFSJOH1SPDFTTBOE5PPMT 7eriﬁcation and 5FTUJOH "VUPNBUJPO'FBUVSFT %PDVNFOUJOH 3FTQPOTFGPS"QQSPBDI1Sedeﬁned RVMFT 3FTQPOTFGPS"QQSPBDI4JNVMBUJPO-FBSOJOH 3FTQPOTFGPS"QQSPBDI0CTFSWBUJPO-FBSOJOH $PSF$PODFQUT*4ZTUFN .PEFM $PSSFTQPOEFODF ,FZ4ZTUFN5FSNT The RFMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFO4ZTUFNBOE.PTBJD 4ZTUFN#PVOEBSJFT .PEFM .PEFM%eﬁnition .PEFMBT4ZTUFN $IBSBDUFSJTUJD $PSSFTQPOEFODFBOE3FHJPO $PSSFTQPOEFODF 3FHJPO &YBNQMFTPG$PSSFTQPOEFODFBOE3FHJPO 4peciﬁcation and IUT3FMBUJPOUP.PEFM $PSF$PODFQUT**$POOFDUJPO0OUPMPHZ 5FSNTBOE$PODFQUT 3PMFT 4VNNBSZ 3FGFSFODFT

4

'FBUVSFTPG.04&4 .PEFM0SJFOUBUJPO #BTJD$PODFQUTPG.PEFM0SJFOUBUJPO 5ZQFTPG.PEFMTJOUIF&YUFOEFE4& (FOFSJD5ZQFT 5SFOETUPXBSE$PNQMFY4ZTUFN $4 .PEFMT *MMVTUSBUJPOTPG.PEFMJOH$IPJDF .PEFM4QBDF -JNJUTPG.PEFMJOH .PEVMBSJUZPG.04&4%FDPVQMFE$PODFQUT .PEVMBSJUZBOE3FEVDUJPOJTN $POUSPMBOE)JFSBSDIZ .PEFMBOE4ZTUFNBOE.PEBMJUZ *OUSPEVDUJPO .PEFMBOE4ZTUFN4FQBSBUJPO

viii O Contents

.PEBMJUZBOE*UT4FQBSBUJPO *OUFHSBUJPOWJB$PSSFTQPOEFODF4FU $PNQMFY4ZTUFNT&YUFOTJPOTPG.PEBMJUZBOE$PSSFTQPOEFODF .PEFM%FSJWBUJPOBOE"QQMJDBUJPO 4peciﬁed BFIBWJPSBOE7BMVBUJPO 6TFGVMOFTTBOEi5SVUIw 4VNNBSZ 3FGFSFODFT

5

4&.PEFM4QBDF .PEFM4QBDF$POUFYUBOE3FRVJSFNFOUT 8IBU*TB.PEFM4QBDF 4DPQFPGUIF4&.PEFM4QBDF $POUFYUPGUIF.PEFM4QBDF 3FRVJSFNFOUTPGUIF4&.PEFM4QBDF .PEFM4QBDF%FTJHO "QQSPBDIFT "QQSPBDI1BSUJUJPOJOUP4FQBSBUF"QQMJDBUJPO%PNBJO.PEFM4QBDFT "QQSPBDI0OF$PNNPO4&.PEFM4QBDF *OUFSOBM.PEFM4QBDF4USVDUVSF $PNQPTJUJPO $PNNPOJ[BUJPO $PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO 5JNF 7JFX 3FMBUJPOTBNPOH%JNFOTJPOT .PEFM4QBDF*NQMFNFOUBUJPO $POUFOU.PEFMT The 7JTJPO $VSSFOU4UBUF .BOBHFNFOU5PPMTBOE1SPDFTTPST &YJTUJOH3FQPTJUPSZ"QQSPBDIFT *&&& %JHJUBM-JCSBSZ3FGFSFODF.PEFM 4BNQMF3FQPTJUPSJFT 4PNF.PEFM4QBDF-JUFSBUVSF4PVSDFT The MPEFM4QBDF*EFB $ISJTUPQIFS"MFYBOEFS"DUVBM8PSME 1JDUVSFT BOE1BUUFSOT $PSSFMBUJPOXJUIUIF.PEFM4QBDF #FSUSBOE.FZFS8IBU%PFT4PGUXBSF.PEFM $PSSFMBUJPOXJUIUIF.PEFM4QBDF .JDIBFM+ackson: The 8PSMEBOEUIF.BDIJOF $PSSFMBUJPOXJUIUIF.PEFM4QBDF #SVDF#MVN.PEFMTBOE%PNBJOT +JN/FJHICPST)JFSBSDIZPG%PNBJOT 8MBEJTMBX5VSTLJ4peciﬁcations and DPNBJOT

Contents

O

ix

.PEFM4QBDF%JNFOTJPOT 1IJMPTPQIZ &TQFDJBMMZ0OUPMPHZ 8IJUFIFBET%JTDVTTJPOPG(FOFSBMJ[BUJPOBOE4UBCJMJUZ$IBOHF *OGPSNBUJPO4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH4PVSDFT 4VNNBSZ 3FGFSFODFT

6

$PNQPTJUJPO 'BNJMJBS$PNQPTJUJPO&MFNFOUTBOE$IBSBDUFSJTUJDT &MFNFOUT $IBSBDUFSJTUJDT $PNNPO4USVDUVSF.PEFMT #BTJD.PEFM5ZQFT 7BSJBUJPOT *OUFSOBM.PEFM7BSJBUJPOT &YUFSOBM.PEFM7BSJBUJPOT 3FMBUJPOBOE*OUFSBDUJPO.PEFMT #JOBSZ3FMBUJPOBOE*OUFSBDUJPO.PEFM /BSZ3FMBUJPO*OUFSBDUJPO.PEFMT $PNQPTJUJPO1SPQFSUJFT &YDMVTJWJUZ .VUBCJMJUZ 4ZNNFUSZ 3elations among the ThrFF$BUFHPSJFT 3FMBUJPOTCFUXFFO8IPMFTBOE1BSUT #BTJD8IPMFo1BSU$PODFQUT 4QBOPG$POUSPM %eﬁning the SFUPG#BTJD3FMBUJPOT %eﬁning the SFUPG&YUFOEFE3FMBUJPOT .VMUJMFWFM$PNQPTJUJPO4USVDUVSFTBOE4DBMFT .VMUJMFWFM4USVDUVSFT .VMUJQMF-FWFMTPG-JWJOH4ZTUFNT $PNQPTJUJPO4DBMF*TTVF .FNCSBOF$IBSBDUFSJTUJDT &YUSFNF&ODBQTVMBUJPO#PYPMPHZ 1BSUJBMPS/P&ODBQTVMBUJPO $PNQPTJUJPO3FMBUFE1SPDFTTFT 1SPDFTTFT "HFOUT &YBNQMFTPG%JSFDU"HFOU$PNQPTJUJPO &YBNQMFTPG/PO"HFOU$PNQPTJUJPOTPS*OEJSFDUPS7JSUVBM"HFOUT 1BSUJBMPS.JYFE%JSFDU*OEJSFDU"HFOUT 3FGFSFODFT

7

$PNNPOJ[BUJPO #BTJD$PODFQUT4JNJMBSJUJFTBOE%iﬀerFODFT $BUFHPSZBOE,JOE4USVDUVSFT

x

O

Contents

$PNNPOJ[BUJPO3FMBUJPOTBOE.VMUJMFWFM4USVDUVSFT &YBNQMF5ool: The GFOFSJD.PEFMJOH&OWJSPONFOU -FWFSBHF -JNJUTPG(FOFSBMJUZ*TB6OJWFSTBM"SDIJUFDUVSF1PTTJCMF ,OPXMFEHF #PEZPG,OPXMFEHF #P, 8IBUJTB#P, ,OPXMFEHF$BUFHPSJFT 7BMVFPG#P,(VJEF $POUSJCVUPSTUP4&#P, $VSSFOU4UBUFPG4&#P, 4VNNBSZPG$PNNPOJ[BUJPO3FMBUFE1SPDFTTFT 3FGFSFODFT

8

$PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO $PBVUIPSFECZ-FP0CSTU $PODFQUTBOE%eﬁnitions %eﬁning Categories in an OOUPMPHZ 4FUVQ&YBNQMF $IBMMFOHFPG.VMUJQMF%PNBJOT 3FTQPOTFUPUIF$IBMMFOHF .JUJHBUJPO 0ntology EﬀorUTBOE5PPMT 6QQFS0OUPMPHJFT %PNBJO0OUPMPHJFT #SJEHJOHBOE.BQQJOH0OUPMPHJFT 4UPSZUFMMJOH "VUPNBUJPO 4QFDUSVNPG4FNBOUJDTBOE0OUPMPHJFT6TFEJO4&.PEFMT 4ample of Languages That SVQQPSU4& 4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHFT 4ZTUFN.PEFMJOHBOE%FTJHO-BOHVBHFT "SDIJUFDUVSF%FTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHFT "%-T 4PGUXBSF-BOHVBHFT #VTJOFTT1SPDFTT-BOHVBHFT 3FRVJSFNFOUT&YUFSOBM4peciﬁcation Languages 9.- .BSLVQ-BOHVBHFT ,OPXMFEHF3FQSFTFOUBUJPO0OUPMPHZ-BOHVBHFT .BUIFNBUJDTBOE4DJFODFT BOE0UIFS4VQQPSUJOH%JTDJQMJOFT /BUVSBM-BOHVBHF -BOHVBHF-FWFSBHF 3FMBUJPOTPG$PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO%JNFOTJPO 3FMBUJPOTCFUXFFO.PEFMT 3FMBUJPOUP$PNNPOJ[BUJPO%JNFOTJPO 3FMBUJPOUP$PNQPTJUJPO%JNFOTJPO 3FGFSFODFT

Contents

9

O

xi

5JNF 5JNFBOE$IBOHF"O*OUSPEVDUJPOUP#BTJD$PODFQUT %iﬀerFODFTXJUIJOBOEBDSPTT4ZTUFNT 8IFUIFS4PNFUIJOH*T4UBUJDPS%ZOBNJD .FBTVSJOH$IBOHF 5ZQFTPG$IBOHF $ZDMJD.PEFMT Scale Eﬀects on ADZDMJDBOE$ZDMJD.PEFMT $IBOHFPG*OUFSFTU *OWBSJBOU7JFX 4DBMF7JFX )JEJOH7JFX 0UIFS$PODFQUT1FSTJTUFODFBOE%VBMJUZ 4UBUFBOE3PMF1FSTJTUFODF %VBMJUZ 5FOTJPO BOE1BSBEPYJO5JNF7BSJBCMFT .PEFMJOH-FWFMTPG1SPDFTTBOE$IBOHF .PEFMTPG-FWFM$IBOHF .PEFMTPG-FWFM$IBOHF 5SBEJUJPOBMBOE$PNQMFY4ZTUFN$IBOHF.PEFMT #PVOEBSZ$SPTTJOH$IBOHF $PNQBSJTPOPG4FMFDUFE&OHJOFFSJOH.PEFMT .PEFMTPG-FWFM$IBOHF $IBOHFPG4peciﬁc MPEFMT $IBOHFPG(FOFSBM.PEFMT .PEFMTPG$IBOHF*OWPMWJOH-FWFMTBOE "VUPQPJFTJT 1IBTF4QBDF$PODFQUT 1IBTF5SBKFDUPSJFT 0SCJUT 1PSUSBJUT 1IBTF5SBOTJUJPO 4FMG0SHBOJ[JOH1SPDFTTFT 4FMG0SHBOJ[BUJPO 4FMG0SHBOJ[FE$SJUJDBMJUZ 1BOBSDIZ .PEFMTBU3VOUJNF .PEFMTPG$IBOHF*OWPMWJOH-FWFMTBOE &YBNQMF "QQMZJOH#JPMPHJDBM&WPMVUJPO &WPMVUJPO%eﬁnition and IOUSPEVDUJPO %eﬁne the UOJUPG4FMFDUJPO "QQMJDBUJPOT %JTUJODUJPOT %iﬀerFODFT $PODMVTJPOT/FFEFE$IBOHF.PEFMT 5JNFBOE$IBOHF3FMBUFEUP0UIFS%JNFOTJPOT %VBM)JFSBSDIZ 0UIFS3FMBUJPOT 3FGFSFODFT

xii O Contents

10 7JFXT *OUSPEVDUJPO*OUVJUJWF$PODFQUT 7BSJFUZ&OHJOFFSJOHBOE#FZPOE 7JFXTJO#SPBEFS$POUFYU "6OJWFSTBM*TTVF"EESFTTJOHUIF)JFSBSDIZ1SPCMFN Scientiﬁc DJTDJQMJOFT "SF4DJFODFBOE.BUIFNBUJDT3BUJPOBMBOE-PHJDBM $PVSUSPPN5SJBM 6OJWFSTBM%JTUJODUJPOCFUXFFO%JTDSFUFBOE$POUJOVPVT1IFOPNFOB #BTJD4&3FMBUFE 7JFXTPG)VNBOT %FWFMPQNFOUWFSTVT0QFSBUJPOPGB4ZTUFN %eﬁned 8PSMET 7JFXTPG*OUFSBDUJOH4ZTUFNT 40*BOE3FMBUJWF)PMBSDIZ &YBNQMFPG1FSTQFDUJWF"MFYBOEFST"SDIJUFDUVSF1BUUFSOT .JTDFMMBOFPVT 7BSJFUZ"SDIJUFDUVSF3FMBUFE $PNQPTJUJPO7JFXT %FTJHO7JFXT &OUFSQSJTF"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSLT ;BDINBO&"'SBNFXPSL ;BDINBO$PSSFTQPOEFODFUP.04&4.PEFM4QBDF 3.0%1'SBNFXPSL %P%"' .0%"' /"''SBNFXPSLTBOE61%. 50("' '&" 40"BOE0UIFS5SFBUNFOUT 40"'SBNFXPSLT "EEJUJPOBM5SFBUNFOUTPG"SDIJUFDUVSF7JFXT -BZFSFE"SDIJUFDUVSF The Inﬁnite Loop -FWFSBHF %VBM)JFSBSDIJFT "TQFDU0SJFOUFE%FWFMPQNFOU "TTFTTNFOU %VBMJUZ %eﬁnitions, Categories :JOBOE:BOH%VBMJUZ $POUSBTU )BSNPOZ %eﬁnitions $BUFHPSJFTPG7JFXT "SFBTGPS"EEJUJPOBM3FTFBSDI *OUFHSBUJPO /FFEGPS%PNJOBOU4USVDUVSFPS7JFX 7JFX$BUFHPSJFT 4VNNBSZ 3FGFSFODFT

Contents

O

xiii

11 4QFDJﬁDBUJPO*OGPSNBUJPO *OUSPEVDUJPO4peciﬁcation 5ZQFTBOE4USVDUVSF &YQBOE&YUFSOBM#FIBWJPS$BUFHPSJFT 4peciﬁcation Content 5ZQFT $POUFOU-JTU *OUFSOBM4peciﬁcation Content DJTDVTTJPO *OUFSOBM4peciﬁcation 7JFXT *OUFSOBM*OUFSBDUJPO*OWPMWJOH"HFOUT &YUFSOBM4peciﬁcation Content DJTDVTTJPO &YUFSOBM4peciﬁcation 7JFXT *OUFSGBDF4peciﬁcation Content DJTDVTTJPO 6ODFSUBJOUZ1SPCBCJMJTUJD4peciﬁcations 1SPCBCJMJUZ%JTUSJCVUJPO%FOTJUZ'VODUJPO &YBNQMF6TJOH$POEJUJPOBM1SPCBCJMJUJFT 0UIFS6ODFSUBJOUZ.FUIPET 1BSUJBMOFTT'V[[Z4peciﬁcations &YBNQMFT ")VNBO1FSGPSNBODF&YBNQMF 0UIFS4LFUDIFT 0SHBOJ[BUJPO "SNZ &WFSZEBZ&YBNQMF4BGFUZ%FQPTJU#PY 4DBMJOHEPXOUIF"QQSPBDIGPS4PGUXBSF 3FGFSFODFT

12 .BQQJOHBOE6OJﬁDBUJPO 0CWJPVT.BQQJOHT &YQMPSJOHBO&OWJSPONFOUBM7JFXPG3FRVJSFNFOUT &YBNQMFT $BS&YBNQMF &WPMVUJPOBSZ3FTFBSDIFS&YBNQMF &NQMPZFF*OUFSWFOUJPO&YBNQMF 2VBMJUZ.FUSJDT "OBMZTJT 0QQPTJUF&OEPGUIF5FMFTDPQF6TFS7JFXQPJOU *OEJSect Eﬀect RFRVJSFNFOUTBOE$PSSFTQPOEFODF4FU $4"DUVBMJ[BUJPO 0UIFS&OHJOFFSJOH.BQQJOHT &YQMPSJOH3FRVJSFNFOUTCZ-PPLJOH*OXBSE 3FTVMUJOH3FRVJSFNFOUT.BQQJOH4QFDUSVN .BQQJOH*OUFSBDUJPO"SUJGBDUT 4igniﬁcance of the OvFSBMM&OHJOFFSJOH.BQQJOH The MBQQJOH.BLFT%FQFOEFODJFT$MFBS "MM"SUJGBDUT"SF7JFXTPGUIF.PEFM4QBDF4USVDUVSF 4&(FOFSBM1SPCMFN4PMWJOH

xiv

O

Contents

"VUPOPNPVT4ZTUFNTXJUIPVU&YUFSOBM.PEFMT "EBQUBUJPOBOE7FSTBUJMJUZ %eﬁnitions of 5SBEJUJPOBM"SUJGBDUT .BQQJOH&OUFSQSJTF.BOBHFNFOU&MFNFOUT &OUFSQSJTF&OHJOFFSJOH.BOBHFNFOU &&. &OUFSQSJTF"VUPOPNZ &" 4VNNBSZPG.04&4'FBUVSFTBOE6niﬁcation "SFBTPG.04&46niﬁcation 4VNNBSZPG,FZ.04&4'FBUVSFT 3FGFSFODFT

13 4&"DUVBMJ[BUJPO1SPDFTTFT 5SBEJUJPOBM1SPDFTTFT (FOFSBM.PEFMT 4UBOEBSET *&&&BOE*40 */$04&)BOECPPLBOE(VJEFUP#P, 64%FQBSUNFOUPG%FGFOTF %P% "DRVJTJUJPO 0UIFS4PVSDFT 1SPCMFNTXJUI5SBEJUJPOBM1SPDFTTFT 'PDVTPO1SPDFTT 1SPCMFN4PMWJOH&OHJOFFSJOH1SPDFTT*Ti%JTDJQMJOFEwUPCF-JOFBS BOE6OOBUVSBM %PFT/PU"EFRVBUFMZ%FBMXJUI$IBOHF .ZUIPGUIF#MBOL4MBUF .ZUIPG3FRVJSFNFOUT%SJWFO $BOEJEBUF$4&&YQBOTJPO1SPDFTTFT (BSCBHF$BO.PEFM (PBM0SJFOUFE.FUIPET $"40SHBOJ[BUJPOBM'SBNFXPSL $"4& +PJOU$PHOJUJWF4&1SPDFTT "HJMF1SPDFTTFT &OUFSQSJTF&OHJOFFSJOH #SJDPMBHFBOE.uddling ThrPVHI .PEFMJOH"QQSPBDIFT 0CKFDU1SPDFTT.FUIPEPMPHZ 4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH'SBNFXPSL 0UIFST "6niﬁed ADUVBMJ[BUJPO1SPDFTT $IBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOE5ZQFT 0QQPSUVOJTUJD1SPDFTT7JFX $IBOHF1SPDFTT7JFX $PMMFDUJWF"DUVBMJ[BUJPO The Challenge

Contents

O

xv

$PODFQUTPGUIF"DUVBMJ[BUJPO1SPDFTT #BMBODFBOE'PDVT 3BEJDBMBOE/PSNBM%FTJHO .BJOUBJOJOHBOE7FSJGZJOH'JEFMJUZPG.PEFMT "QQMZJOHUIF$PODFQUT $POTJEFSBUJPOT 7JTVBMJ[BUJPOT 3FGFSFODFT Acronyms Index

Book Summary "UPQMFWFMPWFSWJFXPGUIFCPPLDIBQUFSTJTQSFTFOUFECFMPX&BDIDIBQUFSOBNFJTGPMMPXFECZ LFZDPODFQUTJOUIFDIBQUFS

Chapter 1:

0QQPSUVOJUJFTBOE$IBMMFOHFTGPS4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH $PNQMFYTZTUFNT TDBMJOH OFFEGPSGPVOEBUJPO

Chapter 2:

4ZTUFNT4DJFODF$POUFYU 4&TDJFODFEJTDJQMJOFTTVQQPSUJOH4& TZTUFNTUBYPOPNZ

Chapter 3:

$PSF$PODFQUTPG.PEFM0SJFOUFE4&4DJFODF .04&4 4ZTUFN NPEFM DPSSFTQPOEFODF DPOOFDUJPOPOUPMPHZ TQFDJﬁDBUJPO

Chapter 4:

'FBUVSFTPG.04&4 .PEFMPSJFOUBUJPO NPEFMTQBDFNPEVMBSJUZEFDPVQMJOH

Chapter 5:

4&.PEFM4QBDF $POUFYU SFRVJSFNFOUT EFTJHO JNQMFNFOUBUJPOPGNPEFMTQBDF EJNFOTJPOT

Chapter 6:

$PNQPTJUJPO 8IPMFTBOEQBSUT IPMBSDIZ JOUFSUXJOJOHPGJOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBMWJFXT

Chapter 7:

$PNNPOJ[BUJPO 4JNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFT DBUFHPSJFTBOELJOET MFWFSBHF CPEZPGLOPXMFEHF

Chapter 8:

$PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO -BOHVBHF POUPMPHZ SFQSFTFOUBUJPO TFNBOUJDT 4&MBOHVBHFHSPVQ

xvii

xviii O

Book Summary

Chapter 9:

5JNF $IBOHFBOETUBCJMJUZ NPEFMTPGDIBOHF UISFFMFWFMTPGDIBOHF

Chapter 10: 7JFXT $SPTTDVUUJOH GSFFGPSN BSDIJUFDUVSFSFMBUFE EVBMJUZ WJFXDBUFHPSJFT

Chapter 11: 4QFDJﬁDBUJPO*OGPSNBUJPO *OUFSOBM FYUFSOBM BOEJOUFSGBDFDPOUFOU QSPCBCJMJTUJD GV[[Z

Chapter 12: .BQQJOHBOE6OJﬁDBUJPO .BQQJOHNPEFMTUPUSBEJUJPOBMBSUJGBDUT VOJﬁDBUJPOGFBUVSFT

Chapter 13: 4&"DUVBMJ[BUJPO1SPDFTTFT 5SBEJUJPOBM $4& NPEFMJOH BOEBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTFT

Preface ThFﬁFMEPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 4& IBTBDIJFWFEBEFHSFFPGNBUVSJUZCVUJTDVSSFOUMZFYQFSJFOD JOHBTJHOJﬁDBOUFYQBOTJPOPGTDPQFCFZPOEJUTDPNGPSU[POFThFFYQBOTJPOJTQSFEPNJOBOUMZJO UIFBSFBPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNT $4 UIBUJT TZTUFNTUIBUUFOEUPJODMVEFQFPQMFPSPUIFSBVUPOPNPVT BHFOUT DSPTTPSHBOJ[BUJPOCPVOEBSJFT DIBOHFDPOUJOVBMMZ BOECFMFTTQSFEJDUBCMF MFTTEFUFSNJO JTUJD NPSFDIBPUJD MFTTDFOUSBMMZDPOUSPMMFE BOENPSFTFMGPSHBOJ[JOHBOEBEBQUJWFUIBOJTUSVF PGXIBUXFDPOTJEFSUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTThFFYQBOTJPOBEEJUJPOBMMZJODMVEFTTDBMJOHCPUIVQ BOEEPXOThFTDBMFVQFYQBOTJPOJTSFﬂFDUFEJOTPDJPUFDIOJDBMTZTUFNTTVDIBTPSHBOJ[BUJPOT FOUFSQSJTFT BOETZTUFNTPGTZTUFNT 4P4 ThFTDBMFEPXOFYQBOTJPOJTSFﬂFDUFEJOTZTUFNTBUUIF MFWFMPGTZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZBOEOBOPUFDIOPMPHZ 4&JT UIFSFGPSF BUBKVODUVSFJOJUTIJTUPSZXIFSFJUOFFETUPTUSFOHUIFOBOEFYUFOEJUTNFUIPET JOPSEFSUPTVQQPSUJUTBUUFNQUFESFBDI"OJNQPSUBOUQBSUPGUIFTPMVUJPOJTUPBEEDPNQMFY4& $4& UPUIF4&ﬁFME6TJOHBNBDIJOFNFUBQIPSGPSTZTUFNTPGUIFQBTUBOEBOPSHBOJTNNFUB QIPSGPSTZTUFNTPGUIFGVUVSFCSJOHTJNQPSUBOUDPODFQUTUPUIFUBCMF)PXFWFS JGUIBUJTBMMXFEP XFTUJMMIBWFOPUBEESFTTFEBOJNQPSUBOUSFBMJUZ.PTUTZTUFNTUIBU4&XJMMFOHJOFFSJOUIFGVUVSF BSFDPNCJOBUJPOTPGNBDIJOFTBOEQFPQMF OPUTUSJDUMZPOFPSUIFPUIFS*OBEEJUJPO NBOZPGUIFN FYJTUBUNVMUJQMFTDBMFT SBOHJOHGSPNUIFOBOPMFWFMUPUIFNBDSPTZTUFNPGTZTUFNT 4P4 MFWFM ThJTNFBOTUIBU$4&EPFTOPUSFQMBDFUSBEJUJPOBM4& 54& CVUNVTUCFJOUFHSBUFEXJUIJUJOB VOJﬁFEQFSTQFDUJWF. ThFQSPCMFNJTUIVTPOFPGCPUIFYQBOTJPOBOEVOJﬁDBUJPO )PXTIPVMEUIF4&DPNNVOJUZSFTQPOEUPUIJTFWJEFOUOFFE 5XPEJﬃcVMUJFTQSFTFOUUIFN TFMWFT'JSTU $4&BOE54&BSFTJHOJﬁDBOUMZEJﬀFSFOUBQQSPBDIFT4ZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTXPVMEIBWF EJﬃcVMUZBQQMZJOHBDPOCJOBUJPOPGUIFUXPUPQSPEVDFBDPIFSFOUTZTUFN4FDPOE UIFDPODFQU PG$4&JTOFXBOEJNNBUVSFXIJMFQFPQMFBSFFYQFSJNFOUJOHXJUIDFSUBJOFMFNFOUT JODMVEJOH OBOPUFDIOPMPHZ TZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZ BOE$4&PSJFOUFEQSPDFTTFT XFEPOPUZFUSFBMMZIBWFBCPEZ PGLOPXMFEHFPOIPXUPFOHJOFFS$4*OEFFE UIFSFJTOPUZFUBHFOFSBMVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGXIBU FOHJOFFSJOHB$4NFBOT PSBDPOTFOTVTUIBUJUJTFWFOQPTTJCMF8IJMFPVSWJFXJTUIBUJUJTQPTTJCMF UPFOHJOFFS$4 XFBDLOPXMFEHFUIBUUIFVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIJTBSFBJTWFSZMJNJUFE 4PIPXDBOXFBDIJFWFCPUIFYQBOTJPOBOEVOJﬁDBUJPO -FUTMPPLBUXIBUXFEPIBWF8F IBWFBTFUPGTDJFODFTUIBUJTSFMBUJWFMZNBUVSFBOEBWBJMBCMFGPSTVQQPSUJOHBOFYQBOEFEBOEVOJ ﬁFE4&ThFTFJODMVEFTZTUFNTTDJFODF 44

XIJDIEFTDSJCFTDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUBSFDPNNPOUP BMMTZTUFNT BOEDPNQMFY44 $44

XIJDIESBXTGSPNBGBNJMZPGTDJFODFTTVDIBTCJPMPHZ TPDJPMPHZ DPHOJUJWFTDJFODF PSHBOJ[BUJPOBMUIFPSZ NBOBHFNFOUTDJFODF DPNQVUFSTDJFODF BOE OFUXPSLTDJFODFUIBUIBWFLOPXMFEHFVTFGVMUP4&4PNFJOGPSNBUJPOGSPNUIFTFTDJFODFTJT JOUIFTDPQFPG54&CVUDPOTJEFSBCMFQPSUJPOTPGUIFBWBJMBCMFLOPXMFEHFIBWFZFUUPCFFYQMPJUFE JO4&*GXFDPVMEDPMMFDUBOEVOJGZNPSFLOPXMFEHFGSPNUIFTFTDJFODFTJOUPBDPNQSFIFOTJWF xix

xx

O Preface

BOEDPIFSFOUTDJFODFPG4& UIBUXPVMEQSPWJEFBGPVOEBUJPOPOXIJDIUPEFWFMPQBOENBUVSFBO FYUFOEFEBOEVOJﬁFE4& ThFHPBMPGUIJTCPPLJTUPEPKVTUUIBUEFﬁOFBOPSHBOJ[FEBOEVOJﬁFETDJFODFGPVOEBUJPOGPS UIFFYUFOEFEBOEVOJﬁFE4&PGUIFGVUVSFBO4&TDJFODF 4&4 UIBUJTUIFSFTVMUPGDPMMFDUJOHBOE PSHBOJ[JOHBQQSPQSJBUFJOGPSNBUJPOGSPNBWBSJFUZPGTDJFODFT JODMVEJOHUIPTFMJTUFEBCPWFThF SFTVMUJTJOUFOEFEUPCFBTFBNMFTTBOEUBJMPSFETDJFODFPGUIFDMBTTPGTZTUFNTXJUIJOUIFFYUFOEFE TDPQFPGUIFOFX4&ThJT4&4GPVOEBUJPOTIPVMEUIFOQSPWJEFBHPPECBTJTGPSQPTJUJPOJOHFYJTU JOH4&BQQSPBDIFTBOEGPSEFﬁOJOHBOENBUVSJOHOFXBQQSPBDIFTUIBUBEESFTTUIFCSPBEFS4& TQFDUSVNPGUIFGVUVSF JODMVEJOHUIF$4&QBSUPGUIFTQFDUSVN 8FEJEOPUDBMMUIFCPPL4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH4DJFODFXFDBMMFEJU.PEFM0SJFOUFE4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH4DJFODF .04&4 8IBUJTNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPO .0

BOEXIFSFEPFTJUﬁUJOUIJT QJDUVSF *OUIJTCPPLXFFYUFOEFYJTUJOHNPEFMJOHBQQSPBDIFTJOUPBO.0UIBUWJFXTBMMTDJ FODFBSUJGBDUT TVDIBTUIFPSJFT MBXT BOEPCTFSWFEQBUUFSOT BOEBMMFOHJOFFSJOHBSUJGBDUT TVDI BTSFRVJSFNFOUTTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTBOEEFTJHOT BTNPEFMTPGTZTUFNT#BTFEPOUIJTPSJFOUBUJPO BMM USBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFY4&NFUIPET QSPDFTTFT BOEBSUJGBDUTBOEBMMTVQQPSUJOHTDJFODFT BSF PSHBOJ[FEJOUPBWJSUVBMTUSVDUVSFESFQPTJUPSZDBMMFEUIF4&NPEFMTQBDF*OFﬀFDU UIFNPEFM TQBDFJTFOWJTJPOFEBTBDPOUBJOFSGPSUIFVOJﬁFE4&4BOEVOJﬁFE4&CPEZPGLOPXMFEHFPGUIF GVUVSF "CSJFGEJTDVTTJPOPGUIFSPMFPG44 $44 BOE.0JOFYUFOTJPOBOEVOJﬁDBUJPOXJMMGVSUIFS DMBSJGZUIFJNQPSUBODFPG.0JOUIJTCPPL44QSPWJEFTTVQQPSUGPSCPUIFYUFOTJPOBOEVOJﬁDB UJPO#VU UIFIFBWZ MJGUJOHJOFYUFOTJPO JT QSPWJEFE CZ $44 CFDBVTF $44 IBT LOPXMFEHF PG UIF DMBTTPGPSHBOJDTZTUFNTUIBUJT UPBTJHOJﬁDBOUFYUFOU NJTTJOHGSPN54&"OEUIFIFBWZMJGUJOH JOVOJﬁ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hFTVCTUBODFPG4&4JTQSPWJEFECZUIFCPEJFTPGLOPXMFEHFJOUIFDPOUSJCVUJOHTDJFODFTThF JOUFHSBUJPOBOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOPGUIJTLOPXMFEHFBSFTVQQPSUFECZ.0BOEUIFNPEFMTQBDFThF NPEFMTQBDFTUSVDUVSFBMTPJOﬂVFODFTUIFXBZ4&4JTQSFTFOUFEJOUIJTCPPL ThF UBTL PG EFﬁOJOH.04&4JTNBEF FBTJFS CZ UIF GBDU UIBU NPTU PG UIF TPMVUJPO FMFNFOUT BMSFBEZ FYJTU JO TPNF GPSN 44 IBT EFWFMPQFE B CPEZ PG LOPXMFEHF TPNFUJNFT DBMMFE HFOFSBM TZTUFNT UIFPSZ BOE TZTUFNT UIJOLJOH $POTJEFSBCMF LOPXMFEHF PG $4 FYJTUT JO $44 NVDI PG JU BMSFBEZ JO UIF GPSN PG NPEFMT "O BSSBZ PG NPEFMJOH BQQSPBDIFT FYJTUT UIBU FYUFOET CFZPOE UIF NBUVSF ﬁFME PG TJNVMBUJPO UP FNCSBDF B CSPBEFS FOHJOFFSJOH TQFDUSVN *O BEEJUJPO UP 4& JUTFMG SFMBUFEEJTDJQMJOFTTVDIBTTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHBOEPQFSBUJPOTSFTFBSDIBMTPIBWFFYUFOTJWF LOPXMFEHFPGBOEFYQFSJFODFJONPEFMJOHThFJOUFOUPGUIJTCPPLJTUPPSHBOJ[FBOEJOUFHSBUFBMM UIFTFFMFNFOUTJOUPBDPNNPOGSBNFXPSL UIFSFCZNBLJOHUIFNNPSFBDDFTTJCMFUP4&TDJFOUJTUT NFUIPEPMPHJTUT SFTFBSDIFST QSBDUJUJPOFST BOENBOBHFST ThFCPPLﬁSTUEFTDSJCFTUIFOFFEUPFYQBOEBOEVOJGZ4& BOEWBSJPVTPQQPSUVOJUJFTUIBUFYJTU UPTBUJTGZUIJTOFFEThFDPOUSJCVUJPOPG44BOEBWJFXPGUIFSFMBUJPOPG44UP4&BSFQSFTFOUFE OFYU GPMMPXFECZDPSFDPODFQUTBOEBEFTDSJQUJPOPGTPNFLFZGFBUVSFTPG.04&4ThFOBTFSJFTPG DIBQUFSTMBZTPVUUIFNPEFMTQBDFBOEUIFQBUUFSOTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIFBDIPGJUTEJNFOTJPOTThFMBUFS DIBQUFSTDPWFSUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDI UIFNBQQJOHPGUSBEJUJPOBM4&BSUJGBDUTUPUIF.04&4 TUSVDUVSF BOETPNFEJTDVTTJPOPGUIFFYQBOEFE4&QSPDFTTDBMMFEDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPO

Acknowledgments ThSFF LFZ FMFNFOUT XFSF JOTUSVNFOUBM JO UIF DPVSTF PG BO JOUFSNJUUFOU KPVSOFZ PWFS UIF QBTU ZFBSTUIBUMFEUPUIJTCPPL*XBOUUPFYQSFTTNZBQQSFDJBUJPOUPUIPTFSFTQPOTJCMF'JSTU UIF 4PGUXBSF1SPEVDUJWJUZ$POTPSUJVNBOEJOQBSUJDVMBS'SFE7BO)PSOFGPTUFSFEUIFTUBSUPGUIF KPVSOFZJOo'SFETUJNVMBUFENZUIJOLJOHJOOVNFSPVTDPOWFSTBUJPOTXFIBEEVSJOH UIBUQFSJPEBOEJOPDDBTJPOBMEJTDVTTJPOTTJODFUIFO BOEIFQPJOUFENFUPTPNFTFNJOBMCPPLT BOEQBQFST4FDPOE .*53&GVOEFEBOJOUFSOBMSFTFBSDIQSPKFDUPOBSDIJUFDUVSFGPVOEBUJPOT UIBU * MFE GSPN UP .BOZ PG UIF JEFBT JODMVEJOH UIF CBTJDT PG NPEFM PSJFOUBUJPO SFBDIFE DSJUJDBM NBTT GSPN UIJT XPSL ThJSE JO UIF QBTU GFX ZFBST #SJBO 8IJUF PG .*53& IFMQFEFYQBOEUIFJEFBTBOEQSPWJEFEUIFJNQFUVTGPSUVSOJOHUIFNJOUPBCPPL1BSUPG#SJBOT DPOUSJCVUJPOXBTUISPVHIDPOOFDUJPOXJUIBOJOGPSNBMHSPVQPODPNQMFYTZTUFNTBU.*53& BOEQBSUJDJQBUJPOJOUIFTZTUFNTTDJFODFHSPVQUIBU#SJBOMFEBU*/$04&ThFPUIFSQBSUXBT UISPVHITVQQPSUGPSNZXPSLBOEUISPVHIUIFFTUBCMJTINFOU XJUI1BVM(BSWFZ PGUIJTTZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOHCPPLTFSJFT .BOZ QFPQMF BﬀFDUFE NZ UIJOLJOH UIBU XFOU JOUP UIJT CPPL UPP NBOZ UP BDLOPXMFEHF IFSF #VU * XPVME MJLF UP FYQSFTT NZ UIBOLT UP B OVNCFS PG QFPQMF XIP IBWF NBEF QBSUJDVMBS DPOUSJCVUJPOTPWFSUIFQBTUZFBSPSUXPThF*/$04&4ZTUFNT4DJFODF(SPVQDPOUSJCVUFECPUICZ QSPWJEJOHTUJNVMBUJOHEJTDVTTJPOTBOEFYQBOEJOHNZVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIJTJNQPSUBOUBSFB BOE CZSFWJFXJOHNZFBSMZDIBQUFSTBOEQSPWJEJOHIFMQGVMDPNNFOUT FTQFDJBMMZ$IBQUFS i4ZTUFNT 4DJFODFwThFSFWJFXFSTJODMVEFE&SJL"TMBLTFO "MJSF[B'FSFJEVOJBO 5JN'FSSJT +PF,SVQB +BNFT .BSUJO %BO.D(SBUI BOE/JDLZ4J[FNPSF .BOZ PG NZ .*53& DPMMFBHVFT NBEF DPOUSJCVUJPOT *O UIF FBSMZ TUBHFT PG UIF CPPL +PF %F3PTBQSPWJEFEGFFECBDLPOTPNFPGNZQSFMJNJOBSZJEFBT 1BVM(BSWFZHBWFGFFECBDLPOPOFPG UIFﬁSTUESBGUDIBQUFST BOE5POZ%J1JFUSPSFWJFXFEFBSMZWFSTJPOTPGUIFﬁSTUTFWFSBMDIBQUFSTBOE HBWFNFIFMQGVMGFFECBDL*OUIFMBUFSTUBHFT )VFJ8BO"OH 1BVM#BSS 'BUNB%BOEBTIJ (FPSHF 3FCPWJDI .JDIBFM4BNVFMT BOE.JLF5JFSOFZSFWJFXFEBOEDPNNFOUFEPOWBSJPVTDIBQUFST 4FWFSBM.*53&DPMMFBHVFTQSPWJEFEFYQFSUJTFJOTQFDJﬁDBSFBT-FP0CSTUNBEFTVCTUBOUJBM DPOUSJCVUJPOTUP$IBQUFS UPUIFFYUFOUUIBUIFCFDBNFDPBVUIPSPGUIFDIBQUFS&SJD#MBJSNBEF TJHOJﬁDBOU JNQSPWFNFOUT UP UIF USFBUNFOU PG QSPCBCJMJUZ JO $IBQUFS XIJMF .BSD $PMPTJNP QSPWJEFEGFFECBDLBOEWBMJEBUJPOPGCJPMPHJDBMBTQFDUTPG$IBQUFS4FWFSBMQFPQMFBTTJTUFEPO $IBQUFS+PIO"OEFSTPODPOUSJCVUFEUPUIFEJTDVTTJPOPGBSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLTBTXFMMBT PUIFSQBSUTPGUIFDIBQUFS(BSZ7FDFMMJPBOE(FPﬀ 3BJOFTQSPWJEFEGFFECBDLBOEDMBSJﬁDBUJPO

xxi

xxii O

Acknowledgments

POPCKFDUPSJFOUFEJOIFSJUBODFBOE"OHFM"TFODJP 1BVM#BSS ,FWFO3JOH BOE&EXBSE#VSLF QSPWJEFEGFFECBDLPOBTQFDUPSJFOUFEEFWFMPQNFOU 4QFDJBMBDLOPXMFEHNFOUTHPUPUXPJOEJWJEVBMTXIPSFWJFXFEUIFFOUJSFCPPLBOEQSPWJEFE DPNNFOUTThFZXFSF.JLF/VFTMFJOPG.*53&BOE+BNFT.BSUJOPG"FSPTQBDF XJUIXIPN* JOUFSBDUFEJOUIF*/$04&4ZTUFNT4DJFODF(SPVQ'JOBMMZ .BEHF)BSSJTPOPG.*53&FEJUFE UIFFOUJSFCPPLBOENBEFOVNFSPVTTVHHFTUJPOTGPSJNQSPWFNFOUT * XPVME BMTP MJLF UP UIBOL 3JDI 0)BOMFZ BOE "SJ 4JMWFS PG 5BZMPS 'SBODJT GPS UIFJS HVJEBODFUISPVHIUIFQVCMJTIJOHQSPDFTT %VBOF)ZCFSUTPO

About the Author %VBOF )ZCFSUTPO JT B SFTFBSDIFS BOE NFNCFS PG UIF UFDIOJDBM TUBﬀ JO UIF *OGPSNBUJPO BOE $PNQVUJOH 5FDIOPMPHJFT $FOUFS BU UIF .*53& $PSQPSBUJPO JO .D-FBO 7JSHJOJB )F IBT B CSPBECBDLHSPVOEJOTPGUXBSFBOETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH CPUISFTFBSDIBOEQSBDUJDF)FIBTDPO EVDUFESFTFBSDIJOUIFGPVOEBUJPOTPGBSDIJUFDUVSFBOEIBTQVCMJTIFEQBQFSTPOBVOJGPSNNPEFM JOHBQQSPBDIUPBSDIJUFDUVSFBOETPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH)FIBTTVQQPSUFEFOUFSQSJTFBSDIJUFDUVSF EFWFMPQNFOUBOEEFﬁOFETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHBQQSPBDIFTGPSMBSHFTZTUFNTGPSTFWFSBMDJWJMJBO EFGFOTF BOEJOUFMMJHFODFBHFODJFTPGUIF64(PWFSONFOU)FIBTBMTPDPOEVDUFESFTFBSDIPO DBQUVSJOHTFDVSJUZQBUUFSOTBOEEFUFSNJOJOHIPXUPJOUFHSBUFUIFTFQBUUFSOTJOUPBVTBCMFFOUFS QSJTF FOHJOFFSJOH DPOUFYU ThF PVUDPNF PG UIJT SFTFBSDI XBT B CPPL PO TFDVSJUZ QBUUFSOT UIBU IFDPBVUIPSFEBOEDPFEJUFE)JTSFDFOUSFTFBSDIIBTCFFOJOTUSFOHUIFOJOHUIFGPVOEBUJPOPG TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHXJUIJODSFBTFEWJTJCJMJUZPGTZTUFNTTDJFODF BOEJOFYUFOEJOHBOEBQQMZJOH QSJODJQMFTPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHUPDPNQMFYTZTUFNTTVDIBTPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBOEPUIFSTZTUFNTUIBU JODMVEFQFPQMF

xxiii

Chapter 1

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering iThFTQJSJUVBMUFNQMFPGUIFGVUVSF XIJMFJUXJMMCFCVJMUMBSHFMZPGUIFPMEXFMMQSPWFE NBUFSJBMT XJMMSFRVJSFOFXBOEBNQMFSGPVOEBUJPOTJOUIFMJHIUPGUIFJNNFOTFFYUFO TJPOPGPVSJOUFMMFDUVBMIPSJ[POTw +4NVUT )PMJTNBOE&WPMVUJPO ThFﬁFMEPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 4& IBTBDIJFWFEBEFHSFFPGNBUVSJUZBOETVDDFTTJOJUTUSBEJUJPOBM TDPQFPGBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTTVDIBTBFSPTQBDF EFGFOTF USBOTQPSUBUJPO BOEDPOTUSVDUJPO8IJMF 4&JTXPSLJOHUPTUSFOHUIFOJUTNFUIPETBOEJODSFBTFJUTEFHSFFPGTVDDFTT DIBOHFTBSFTJNVMUBOF PVTMZPDDVSSJOHJOUIF4&FOWJSPONFOUUIBUHFOFSBUFBGPSDFGPSFYQBOTJPOCFZPOEUIFUSBEJUJPOBM TDPQFPG4&ThFQSJNBSZBSFBPGDIBOHFJTUIFFYQBOTJPOUPRVBMJUBUJWFMZNPSFDPNQMFYTZTUFNT 'PSFYBNQMF CVJMEJOHBQPXFSQMBOUJTBDPNQMFYFOHJOFFSJOHBDUJWJUZJOWPMWJOHCPUIUFDIOJDBM BOETPDJBMFMFNFOUTCVUUIFCFIBWJPSPGBQPXFSHSJEBDSPTTBSFHJPOJTTVCTUBOUJBMMZNPSFDPNQMFY BOEMFTTQSFEJDUBCMFThF4&DPNNVOJUZJTOPUPOMZCFHJOOJOHUPFYQBOEGSPNQPXFSQMBOUTUP QPXFSHSJET CVUJTBMTPCFHJOOJOHUPUBDLMFQSPCMFNTFWFOGVSUIFSCFZPOEJUTUSBEJUJPOBMIPSJ[POT 3FQSFTFOUBUJWFQSPCMFNTJODMVEFBWPJEJOHEJTFBTFQBOEFNJDT DSFBUJOHBNPSFWJBCMFIFBMUIDBSF TZTUFNNPEFM BOUJDJQBUJOHUIFFﬀFDUTPGBMUFSOBUJWFFOFSHZQPMJDJFT JNQSPWJOHUIFFﬀFDUJWFOFTTPG UIFDSJNJOBMKVTUJDFTZTUFN BOEQSFWFOUJOHPSEFBMJOHXJUIJOTVSHFODZBOEUFSSPSJTN"TFDPOE BSZGPSDFGPSFYQBOTJPOJTUIFFNFSHFODFPGOFXUFDIOPMPHZBSFBTTVDIBTOBOPUFDIOPMPHZBOE TZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZThFTFUFDIOPMPHJFTBSFNBLJOHTJHOJﬁDBOUQSPHSFTTCVUUIFEJﬃDVMUZPGCVJMEJOH TZTUFNTBUEJﬀFSFOUTDBMFTNBLFTDMFBSUIFOFFEGPSFYUFOEFE4&TVQQPSU ThFDVSSFOUTUBUFPG4&UIVTDPOUBJOTCPUIPQQPSUVOJUJFTBOEDIBMMFOHFTThFPQQPSUVOJUJFT BSFUIFQPTTJCMFBSFBTPGFYQBOTJPOJOUIFﬁFMEThFDIBMMFOHFTBSFUPTUBSUXJUIBO4&UIBUIBT TUSFOHUITBOEXFBLOFTTFTXJUIJOJUTDVSSFOUTDPQF BOEUPEFﬁOFBO4&UIBUJTNPSFSPCVTU DPWFSTB TJHOJﬁDBOUMZFYQBOEFETDPQF BOEDPOTUJUVUFTBDPIFSFOUXIPMFPGUIFPMEBOEUIFOFX'PSUVOBUFMZ NBOZPGUIFTPMVUJPOFMFNFOUTGPSBOFYQBOEFEBOESPCVTU4&BMSFBEZFYJTU JOTPNFDBTFTXJUIJO 4&CVUJOPUIFSDBTFTJOSFMBUFEPSTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT8IBUJTOFFEFEJTUPCSJOHUIFTPMVUJPO 1

2 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

FMFNFOUTUPHFUIFSJOUPBVOJﬁFEXIPMFThBUJTXIBUUIJTCPPLBJNTUPEPEFﬁOFBSPCVTUBOE VOJGZJOHGPVOEBUJPOGPSBOFYQBOEFE4&PGUIFGVUVSF ThJTDIBQUFSEJTDVTTFTTJYUPQJDT UIFTUBUFPGBﬀBJSTPGUSBEJUJPOBM4& UIFBSFBTPGQPUFO UJBMFYQBOTJPO BCSJEHFCFUXFFOPMEBOEOFX UIFDIBMMFOHFTPGEFﬁOJOHBGPVOEBUJPOGPS UIFGVUVSF BOJOUSPEVDUJPOUPUIFQSPQPTFENPEFMPSJFOUFE4&TDJFODF .04&4 GPVOEBUJPO BOE UIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOPGUIFCPPL

The State of Affairs of SE Characterizing Traditional SE 0WFSUIFQBTUIBMGDFOUVSZ 4&IBTEFWFMPQFEBTBEJTDJQMJOFJODFSUBJODMBTTJDBMBSFBT NPTUOPUB CMZBFSPTQBDFBOEEFGFOTF*UIBTBMTPCFFOBQQMJFEJOUSBOTQPSUBUJPOBOEDPOTUSVDUJPOFOFSHZ NBOBHFNFOU BOENBOVGBDUVSJOHBOENFEJDBM FOWJSPONFOUBM BOEJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNT*UXBT EFWFMPQFEUPQSPNPUFBIPMJTUJDPSTZTUFNJDBQQSPBDIUPTZTUFNT BTPQQPTFEUPGPDVTJOHPOFBDI TFQBSBUFQBSUBOEBEESFTTJOHJOUFHSBUJPO JGOFFEFE BTBOBGUFSUIPVHIUThF4&UIBUIBTCFFOJO QMBZEVSJOHUIJTQFSJPE 54& PSHPPEPMEUSBEJUJPOBM4& (054&

IBTBDIJFWFEDPOTJEFSBCMFTVD DFTTJONBOZDBTFTCVUIBTBMTPFYQFSJFODFENPSFUIBOBGFXTJHOJﬁDBOUGBJMVSFT 54&IBTBSFBTPOBCMZXFMMVOEFSTUPPETUBODFUPXBSEUIFTZTUFNTJUFOHJOFFSTThF54&WJFX PGFOHJOFFSFETZTUFNTJTUIBU O ThFZBSFMBSHFTDBMFNBDIJOFTUIBUIBWFSFMBUJWFMZQSFEJDUBCMFCFIBWJPS O ThFZIBWFDPNQPOFOUTGSPNNVMUJQMFEJTDJQMJOFT TVDIBTQPXFSTPVSDFT FMFDUSJDBMBOE NFDIBOJDBMTZTUFNT DPNQVUFSIBSEXBSFBOETPGUXBSF DPOUSPMTZTUFNT TBGFUZ TFDVSJUZ BOEDPNNVOJDBUJPOT O ThFJSDPNQPOFOUTBSFNBDIJOFTPSNFDIBOJTUJDFMFNFOUT XIJDIDBOJODMVEFBOZQIZTJ DBMNBUFSJBMVTFEUPDPOTUSVDUTZTUFNTTVDIBTBJSDSBGU BTXFMMBTUSBEJUJPOBMTPGUXBSFBOE FMFDUSPOJDJUFNT FH DPNQVUFST ThJTTDPQFXBTDMFBSMZBSUJDVMBUFEJO(PPEFBOE.BDIPM

XIPBDLOPXMFEHFEDPNNPOQPJOUTPGJOUFSFTUXJUITPDJBM CJPMPHJDBM BOEFDP MPHJDBMTZTUFNT CVUFYDMVEFEUIFNGSPNUIFTDPQFPG4&ThJTMJNJUIBTCFFOSFJUFSBUFE BMNPTUWFSCBUJNCZ,PTTJBLPﬀ BOE4XFFU

XIPTBZUIBU4&FYDMVEFTDPNQMFY TZTUFNTTVDIBTTPDJBMTUSVDUVSF MJWJOHPSHBOJTNT BOEFDPTZTUFNT O ThFJSDPNQPOFOUTFYDMVEFQFPQMFThJTJTJNQMJFECZUIFQSFWJPVTJUFNCVUJTJNQPSUBOU FOPVHIUPQPJOUPVUTFQBSBUFMZThFDMBJNJTTPNFUJNFTNBEFJO54&UIBUTZTUFNTJODMVEF QFPQMFBOEQSPDFTTFT)PXFWFS JO54& QFPQMFVTVBMMZQMBZPOFPGUISFFSPMFT BMMPGXIJDI SFTJEFPVUTJEFUIFTZTUFNBOEBSFUSFBUFEBTEJTUJODUGSPNUIFTZTUFNThFﬁSTUSPMFJTUIF TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSUIFTFDPOEJTUIFQSPKFDUNBOBHFS JF UIFNBOBHFSPGBO4&QSPKFDU UIBUFOHJOFFSTBTZTUFN BOEUIFUIJSEJTUIFVTFSPSPQFSBUPSPGBTZTUFN BEESFTTFEJOUIF BSFBTPGIVNBONBDIJOFJOUFSBDUJPO IVNBOGBDUPST BOEFSHPOPNJDT ThFSFGPSF JOUIF USBEJUJPOBMWJFX QFPQMFBSFOPUTZTUFNDPNQPOFOUT O ThFZBSFSFMBUJWFMZTUBCMFThFZDIBOHFPOMZJGUIFPXOFSEFDJEFTUPDIBOHFUIFN-FGUUP UIFJSPXOEFWJDFT UIFZSFNBJOTUBUJDPSUIFZEFUFSJPSBUFUISPVHIOPSNBMVTF O %FWFMPQNFOUBOEPQFSBUJPOBSFTFQBSBUFQIBTFTPGUIFTZTUFNTMJGF O ThFZBSFEFTJHOFEBOEPSHBOJ[FECZBOFYUFSOBMEFTJHOFSUIBUJT CZUIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFS ThFTFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTTFFNSFBTPOBCMF FWFOPCWJPVT BOEUIFZJOEJDBUFUIFCSFBEUIPG54& .BOZPGUIFTFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBSFJNQMJDJUJOUIF4&MJUFSBUVSF&YBNQMFTPGUIFMJUFSBUVSFJODMVEF #MBODIBSE BOE 'BCSZDLZ

,PTTJBLPﬀ BOE 4XFFU

4BHF BOE "SNTUSPOH

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O

3

.BSUJO

#VFEF

%P%

*40 *40*&$

*&&& B C

BOE */$04& #PPLTBOETUBOEBSETPO54&UZQJDBMMZGPDVTPO4&MJGFDZDMFQSPDFTTFTBOE NBOBHFNFOU UIBU JT CPUI NBOBHFNFOU BOE UFDIOJDBM FOHJOFFSJOH BTQFDUT PG 4& ThF MBUUFS UZQJDBMMZJODMVEFDPODFQUGPSNVMBUJPO EFﬁOJUJPOBOEBOBMZTJTPGBMUFSOBUJWFT EFDJTJPOTVQQPSU TZTUFNEFTJHO TZTUFNJOUFHSBUJPO BOEFWBMVBUJPO0UIFSDPNNPOQSPDFTTFTBSFSFRVJSFNFOUT EFﬁOJUJPO UFDIOPMPHZBTTFTTNFOU NPEFMJOHBOETJNVMBUJPO BOEPUIFSBTQFDUTTVDIBTIVNBO GBDUPST MBXTBOESFHVMBUJPOT BOETFDVSJUZBOETBGFUZ*OTPNFDBTFT NBOBHFNFOUQSPDFTTFT IBWFCFFOFYUFOEFEUPSFﬂFDUNPSFPGUIFXIPMFTZTUFNTNPEFMJOHTDPQFEJTDVTTFEJOUIFTFD UJPOFOUJUMFEi3FTQPOTF.PEFM0SJFOUFE4&4DJFODFw'PSFYBNQMF *40*&$ *40*&$

JOBEEJUJPOUPQSPKFDUNBOBHFNFOUQSPDFTTFT EFﬁOFTFOUFSQSJTFQSPDFTTFTTVDIBTJOWFTU NFOUNBOBHFNFOUBOESFTPVSDFNBOBHFNFOU BOEBHSFFNFOUQSPDFTTFTTVDIBTBDRVJTJUJPO 0VSQVSQPTFJOQSPWJEJOHUIJTCSJFGQPSUSBZBMJTUPTFUBDPOUFYUGPSUIFGPDVTBOETDPQFPGXIBU .04&4BEESFTTFT'SPNUIBUQFSTQFDUJWF UIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTEFTDSJCFEBCPWFDPOTUSBJOUIFUZQFPG TZTUFNBEESFTTFECZ4&UPXIBUXFDBMMBTZTUFNBTNBDIJOFNFUBQIPSUIFZSFﬂFDUBNFDIBOJTUJD WJFXPGTZTUFNT8FBSHVFJOUIJTDIBQUFSUIBUUIJTDPOTUSBJOUJTCFHJOOJOHUPNBLFUSBEJUJPOBM4& MFTTWJBCMFJOMJHIUPGUIFSFDFOUUFOEFODZPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTUPFYQBOEJOUPPUIFSNPSFDPNQMFY UZQFTPGTZTUFNT8FOFFEUPSFUIJOLUIFTDPQFPG4& OPUPOMZUPTVQQPSUDVSSFOUFYQBOTJPO CVU BMTPUPQSPWJEFBHSPXUIQPUFOUJBMGPSGVUVSFPQQPSUVOJUJFT

The Need to Strengthen TSE Failed Projects .BOZTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHQSPKFDUTGBJMThFZEPOPUQSPEVDFBTZTUFNPOTDIFEVMF UIFZPWFSSVO UIF CVEHFU UIF TZTUFN EPFT OPU QFSGPSN BEFRVBUFMZ PS UIF TZTUFN JT OPU FWFO CVJMU #BS:BN EFTDSJCFTBOVNCFSPGXFMMLOPXO4&QSPKFDUTUIBUGBJMFE JODMVEJOHUIF'"""EWBODFE "VUPNBUJPO4ZTUFN ""4 UIBUXBTJOEFWFMPQNFOUPWFSBEFDBEFJOUIFTBOEFBSMZT BOEUIFOXBTBCBOEPOFEBGUFSNPSFUIBOCJMMJPOXBTTQFOU 8IZIBWFTPNBOZ4&QSPKFDUTGBJMFE "TJHOJﬁDBOUQBSUPGUIFQSPCMFN BDDPSEJOHUP#BS:BN BOEPUIFSPCTFSWFST JTUIBUUIFTFTZTUFNTIBWFCFDPNFTPMBSHFBOEDPNQMFYUIBUUIFUSBEJUJPOBM CJHCBOHBQQSPBDIUIBUJT CVJMEUIFFOUJSFTZTUFNBOEEFQMPZJUBUPOFUJNFIBTMJUUMFDIBODF PGTVDDFFEJOH"TJHOJﬁDBOUQBSUPGUIFDPNQMFYJUZJONBOZPGUIFTFTZTUFNT JODMVEJOHUIF'"" ""4 XBT UIF TPGUXBSF 0OF BOTXFS JT UP VTF BO FWPMVUJPOBSZ BQQSPBDI 4UBSU XJUI TPNFUIJOH TNBMMBOENBOBHFBCMFUIFOHSPXBOEFWPMWFJUPWFSUJNFJOUPUIFGVMMTZTUFNThJTUZQFPGQSPDFTT JTEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJO$IBQUFS

Dealing with Change and Other General Shortcomings *OJUTNPEFSOGPSN 4&XBTEFWFMPQFEJOUIFTBUMFBTUJOQBSUBTBNPSFTZTUFNBUJDBQQSPBDI UIBOUIFBEIPDBDUJWJUJFTVOEFSUBLFOEVSJOH8PSME8BS** BMUIPVHIOPUBMM8PSME8BS**4&XPSL XBTBEIPDUIF.BOIBUUBOQSPKFDUUIBUQSPEVDFEUIFBUPNJDCPNCDFSUBJOMZXBTOPU 4PNF PGUIJTIJTUPSZJTFYBNJOFECZ'FSSJT B C %VSJOHUIF$PME8BS 4&JOUIF64 *ONPTUPGUIJTCPPL XFGPMMPXUIFDPNNPOFOHJOFFSJOHVTBHFPGUIFUFSN“FWPMVUJPO ”BTUIFHSBEVBMDIBOHF JOBOJOEJWJEVBMTZTUFNPWFSUJNF FWFOUIPVHIUIJTJTOPUXIBUCJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPONFBOT8FEJTDVTTUIF EJTUJODUJPOJO$IBQUFS

4 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

NJMJUBSZIBEBHSFBUMVYVSZQMFOUZPGNPOFZBOEQMFOUZPGUJNFThFQSPDFTTPWFSUJNFCFDBNF MBSHFBOEDVNCFSTPNFCFDBVTFUIFSFXBTMJUUMFPSOPGPSDJOHGVODUJPOUPLFFQJUMFBOBOEBHJMF*O GBDU BDDPSEJOHUPUIF/3$

UIFMFOHUIPGUJNFGPSUIF%P%UPQSPDVSFBNBKPSTZTUFNJO SFDFOUZFBSTJTUXPPSUISFFUJNFTBTMPOHBTJUXBTPSZFBSTBHP"TBNQMFPGNBKPSQSPHSBNT GSPNUISPVHI JODMVEJOHEFWFMPQJOHUIFBUPNJDCPNCBOEHPJOHUPUIFNPPO TIPXFE BSBOHFGSPNUPZFBST XIJMFBTBNQMFPWFSUIFQBTUUISFFEFDBEFTTIPXTBSBOHFGSPNUP ZFBSTThJTUSFOEJTPDDVSSJOHFWFOUIPVHI TJODFUIFFOEPGUIF$PME8BS UIFUJNFQSFTTVSFIBT QSFTVNBCMZJODSFBTFECFDBVTFNJMJUBSZTJUVBUJPOTXFSFDIBOHJOHNVDINPSFSBQJEMZ#PUIHPWFSO NFOUBHFODJFTBOEQSBDUJUJPOFSTIBWFCFFOTMPXUPNPWFCFZPOEUSBEJUJPOBMQSPDFTTFTBOEBEPQU PUIFSTUIBUTVQQPSUOBUVSBMQSPCMFNTPMWJOHNPSFFﬀFDUJWFMZ "MUFSOBUJWFTUPUIFSJHJETFRVFODFPGUIFiXBUFSGBMMwQSPDFTTIBWFFNFSHFE TVDIBTJODSFNFOUBM TQJSBM BOEiBHJMFwNFUIPET CVUHPWFSONFOUBOEUPTPNFFYUFOUJOEVTUSZJTTUSVHHMJOHUP EFWJTF4&QSPDFTTFTUIBUBSFTVﬃcJFOUMZBEBQUBCMFBOEﬂFYJCMFXIJMFTUJMMNBJOUBJOJOHQMBOOJOH BOEBDDPVOUBCJMJUZ4JHOJﬁDBOUQSPHSFTTJTOFFEFEJOUIJTBSFBThF%P%SFDPHOJ[FTTPNFPGUIF TIPSUDPNJOHTPGUIFDVSSFOUQSPDFTTFTBOEJTUBLJOHTUFQTUPSFWJUBMJ[F4&JOUIF%P%DPNNV OJUZ4PNFPGUIFFﬀPSUTBSFEFTDSJCFEJOUIF0DUPCFSJTTVFPGUIF%P%KPVSOBM$SPTTUBML TFF$SPTTUBML ThJTJTTVFPGUIFKPVSOBMBMTPFNQIBTJ[FTUIFFYQBOEJOHSPMFPGTPGUXBSFJO TZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH B UPQJD UIBU XF EJTDVTT JO UIF TFDUJPO FOUJUMFE iThF #SJEHF *OGPSNBUJPO $PNQVUBUJPO 4PGUXBSFw 4& TZTUFNT UIBU DIBOHF SBQJEMZ HP XFMM CFZPOE NJMJUBSZ TZTUFNT "T #SBIB FU BM FTQFDJBMMZ$IBQUFS BSHVF 54&JTPSJFOUFEUPXBSEXFMMCFIBWFETZTUFNTUIBUDBOCFQSFDJTFMZ EFTDSJCFE XJUI DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PG TUBCJMJUZ SFMJBCJMJUZ DFSUBJOUZ BOE PQUJNBMJUZ #VU UIFﬁFME JTOPXEFBMJOHXJUITZTUFNT TVDIBTUIF*OUFSOFU QPXFSHSJET NBSLFUT NVMUJOBUJPOBMFOUFS QSJTFT BOEUSBOTQPSUBUJPOOFUXPSLT UIBUIBWFEJﬀFSFOUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT BTXFEJTDVTTGVSUIFSJO UIFOFYUTFDUJPO*OBTFOTF NBOZPGUIFTFTZTUFNTIBWFBMJGFPGUIFJSPXOXIJMFXFDBOJOﬂV FODFUIFN XFEPOPUDPOUSPMUIFNThFZDPOUJOVBMMZDIBOHF BOEHSPX BOEJOWPMWFTJHOJﬁDBOU VODFSUBJOUJFT ZFUUIFZTFFNUPXPSL54&JTOPUXFMMFRVJQQFEUPIBOEMFUIJTUZQFPGTZTUFN 0UIFSHFOFSBMXFBLOFTTFTPG54&IBWFCFFOEFTDSJCFECZ*/$04& BOE3PVTF */$04&BSHVFTUIBUUIFSFJTOPTFUPGVOJﬁFEQSJODJQMFTBOENPEFMTUPTVQQPSU4&VTFPWFSBXJEF SBOHFPGEPNBJOTThFWJFXJOUIJTCPPLJTUIBUBDMFBSEFﬁDJUJO54&JTUIFGBDUUIBUUIFGPVOEB UJPOBMDPODFQUTPGTZTUFNTTDJFODF 44 IBWFOPUCFFOVTFEJOBTZTUFNBUJD FYQMJDJUXBZUPTVQQPSU 54&ThF54&BOE44DPNNVOJUJFT JODMVEJOHUIFMJUFSBUVSF IBWFCFFOMBSHFMZEJTKPJOU"OPUIFS XFBLOFTTTUBUFECZ*/$04&JTUIBU54&EPFTOPUDPOTJTUFOUMZBEESFTTBOEJOUFHSBUFBMMFMFNFOUT PG B TZTUFN CFZPOE IBSEXBSF BOE TPGUXBSF 'BDJMJUJFT QSPDFEVSFT QSPDFTTFT BOE UIF SPMFT PG QFPQMFNBZBMTPCFTJHOJﬁDBOUQBSUTPGTZTUFNT 3PVTF BSHVFTUIBUXFOFFEBO4&UIBUJODPSQPSBUFTBOEJOUFHSBUFTBTFUPGWJFXTUIBU JODMVEFTCPUIUIFUSBEJUJPOBM4&QFSTQFDUJWFPGIJFSBSDIZBOETZTUFNTUBUFT BOEUIFDPNQMFYTZT UFNTQFSTQFDUJWFPGOPOMJOFBSNFDIBOJTNTBOEBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUTThJT4&OFFETUPTIPXIPX BMMUIFTFWJFXs ﬁUUPHFUIFS

Unexpected Side Effects .BOZPGUIFQSPCMFNTXJUITZTUFNTUIBU4&CVJMETBSFUIFVOFYQFDUFETJEFFﬀFDUTJOUIFFOWJSPO NFOUJOXIJDIUIFTZTUFNPQFSBUFT%ÚSOFS EJTDVTTFTUIFEJﬃcVMUZPGBOUJDJQBUJOHUIFTJEF FﬀFDUTPGEFDJTJPOTBOETZTUFNTJODPNQMFYTJUVBUJPOT)JTDPODFQUPGBTZTUFNJTUIBUJUIBTNBOZ JOUFSEFQFOEFOUWBSJBCMFT BOEUIFSFBSFNBOZTJEFFﬀFDUTXIFOBTZTUFNJTDIBOHFEPSBTPMVUJPOJT JOUSPEVDFEJOUPUIFFOWJSPONFOU5BLJOHBNPSFIPMJTUJDWJFXPGUIFFOWJSPONFOUIFMQTBOUJDJQBUF

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O

5

UIFFﬀFDUTPGJOUSPEVDJOHBTZTUFN"TJNJMBSJEFBJTSFQSFTFOUFEJOUIFDPODFQUPGJOUFSWFOUJPO TZTUFN .BSUJO BOEJUTFﬀFDUTPOUIFDPOUFYUXIFOJUJTEFQMPZFEThPTFFﬀFDUTBSFPGUFO EJﬀFSFOUGSPNXIBUXBTJOUFOEFE 4&OPXOFFET BOEUPTPNFFYUFOUBMXBZTOFFEFE UPDPOTJEFSBMMJOUFSDPOOFDUFEWBSJBCMFT JNQMJ DBUJPOT BOETJEFFﬀFDUTPGEFDJTJPOT#PUI%½UOFS BOE.BSUJO JNQMZUIBUXFNBZCF BCMFUPNPEFMUIJTBSFOBBOEBQQSPBDIJUNPSFLOPXMFEHFBCMZBOETZTUFNJDBMMZ XIJDINFBOTUIBUXF NBZCFBCMFUPCSJOHUIFTFJTTVFTJOUPUIFSFBMNPGFOHJOFFSJOH. ThBUWJFXJTTIBSFEJOUIJTCPPL

Opportunities: Types of Expansion 4FWFSBMDVSSFOUUSFOETSFQSFTFOUFYUFOTJPOTUP54&ThFEPNJOBOUHFOFSBMDBUFHPSZPGUIFFYUFO TJPOTJTDPNQMFYTZTUFNT $4 )FSFBSFXBZTJOXIJDIDPNQMFYTZTUFNTFYUFOE4&NPSFUZQFTPG TZTUFNT NPSFQFPQMFJOWPMWFEJOUIFFOHJOFFSJOH BOENPSFTDBMJOH

Characteristics of CS $PNQMFYTZTUFNTIBWFUIFQPUFOUJBMUPFYIJCJUPOFPSNPSFPGUIFGPMMPXJOHDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT O ThFZBSFUIPVHIUPGBTPSHBOJTNTXIPTFCFIBWJPSJTUPTPNFEFHSFFVOQSFEJDUBCMF O ThFZIBWFBWBSJFUZPGDPNQPOFOUT BOEPGUFOBWFSZMBSHFOVNCFSPGDPNQPOFOUT UIBUBSF IJHIMZJOUFSDPOOFDUFE BOEUIFCFIBWJPSPGUIFXIPMFTZTUFNEFQFOETJOBTJHOJﬁDBOUXBZ POUIFJOUFSBDUJPOTBNPOHDPNQPOFOUT O ThFTZTUFNTBSFUPTPNFEFHSFFBVUPOPNPVT BDUJOHPOUIFJSPXO O ThFJSDPNQPOFOUTBSFDPOTJEFSFEUPCFQFPQMFPSPSHBOJDPSBVUPOPNPVTFMFNFOUT XIJDI DBO JODMVEF BOZUIJOH JO UIF SFBMN PG CJPMPHZ QTZDIPMPHZ BOE TPDJPMPHZ BOE B SBOHF PGSFMBUFEEJTDJQMJOFTTVDIBTFDPOPNJDT MBX BOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMUIFPSZ*OBEEJUJPOUP IVNBOT FYBNQMFTJODMVEFDFMMT PSHBOT BOETPDJBMHSPVQTTVDIBTPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBOETPDJ FUJFT0UIFSFYBNQMFT TVDIBTTFMGNPEJGZJOHMFBSOJOHTPGUXBSFBOEDFMMVMBSBVUPNBUB BSF OPUOFDFTTBSJMZPSHBOJDCVUDBOCFNPEFMFEBTPSHBOJDPSBVUPOPNPVT O ThFZ BSF BEBQUJWF BOE MFBSO HSPX BOE FWPMWF JO SFTQPOTF UP UIFJS FOWJSPONFOU -FGU BMPOF UIFZ HSPX BOE JNQSPWF ThFZ DPOUJOVBMMZ DIBOHF CVU UIFZ BMTP IBWF TJHOJﬁDBOU BTQFDUTPGTUBCJMJUZ. ThFZBMTPDIBOHFUIFJSFOWJSPONFOU O 'PMMPXJOH B GPSNBUJPO QFSJPE UIFJS EFWFMPQNFOU BOE PQFSBUJPO BSF DPOﬂBUFE JOUP BO POHPJOHFWPMVUJPOQSPDFTTJOXIJDIDIBOHFPDDVSTXIJMFUIFTZTUFNJTJOPQFSBUJPO O ThFZBSFTFMGPSHBOJ[JOH BOEUIFXIPMFTZTUFNFNFSHFTPWFSUJNFBTBSFTVMUPGDPPQFSB UJPOBOEDPNQFUJUJPOBNPOHDPNQPOFOUT O &NFSHFOUQSPQFSUJFTBOECFIBWJPSBSFPGUFODPOTJEFSFEBLFZDIBSBDUFSJTUJD O ThFZIBWFFYQBOEJOHTDPQFUIFZHPCFZPOEUFDIOJDBMJTTVFTUPTPDJBM QPMJUJDBM BOEPSHB OJ[BUJPOBMJTTVFT ThFTFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTSFﬂFDUBTZTUFNBTPSHBOJTNNFUBQIPS BOPSHBOJDWJFXPGTZTUFNT BO BVUPOPNPVT BHFOU WJFX $MFBSMZ UIFTF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT BSF JO DPOUSBTU UP UIPTF EFTDSJCFE FBSMJFS GSPN UIF QFSTQFDUJWF PG 54& 8F FNQIBTJ[F UIF DPOTUSBJOU UIBU B DPNQMFY TZTUFN QPUFOUJBMMZ FYIJCJUTPOFPSNPSFPGUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTJOUIFMJTUOPUBMMPGUIFNThFQVSQPTFJTOPUUP FRVBUFPSHBOJD BVUPOPNPVT BEBQUJWF FNFSHFOU BOETFMGPSHBOJ[JOH1BSUPGUIFKPCPGCSJOHJOH UIFTFUZQFTPGTZTUFNTJOUPUIF4&BSFOBJTUPEJﬀFSFOUJBUFUIFWBSJFUZPGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUUIF DPNNVOJUZ BOEUIJTCPPL JEFOUJGZVOEFSUIFSVCSJDPGiDPNQMFYTZTUFNTw

6 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThFDPOUSBTUPGUIFPSHBOJTNPSBHFOUQFSTQFDUJWFXJUIUIFNBDIJOFQFSTQFDUJWFJTSFﬂFDUFEJO DFSUBJODIBOHFTJONJOETFU XIFSFDPOTUSVDUTUIBUBSFWJFXFEOFHBUJWFMZJO54&BSFFNCSBDFEBT QPTJUJWFPSBUMFBTUQPUFOUJBMMZQPTJUJWFJOB$4BQQSPBDI. ThFTFDPOTUSVDUTJODMVEF O $IBOHF$IBOHFJTTPNFUIJOHUPCFBWPJEFEJO54& PSBUMFBTUDBSFGVMMZDPOUSPMMFE*O $4 DIBOHFJTBOBUVSBMQSPDFTT*UDBOCFQPTJUJWF OFHBUJWF PSOFVUSBM CVUJONBOZDBTFT DIBOHFSFﬂFDUTMFBSOJOH HSPXUI JNQSPWFNFOU BOEBEBQUBUJPO O 3JTL54&BUUFNQUTUPNJOJNJ[FPSBWPJESJTL"$4BQQSPBDITFFTOPUPOMZSJTL CVUBMTP PQQPSUVOJUZ UIe ﬂJQTJEFPGSJTL BTBQPTJUJWFQPUFOUJBMGPSTJHOJﬁDBOUHBJOT O 6ODFSUBJOUZBOEMBDLPGDPOUSPM54&USJFTUPNBJOUBJONBYJNVNDPOUSPMBOEUPNJOJNJ[F VODFSUBJOUZ8JUI$4 FOHJOFFSTDBOZJFMETPNFPGUIBUDPOUSPMUPTZTUFNTUIBUFYIJCJU BVUPOPNZBOETFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPO XIJDISFEVDFTUIFBNPVOUPGOFDFTTBSZJOTUSVDUJPOTPS FYQMJDJUTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT*OTUFBEPGUIFFOHJOFFSIBWJOHUPBOUJDJQBUFFWFSZUIJOHGPSUIFTZT UFN MFU UIF TZTUFN XPSL UIJOHT PVU GPS JUTFMG BT JU HPFT BMPOH *O .04&4 UIJT PWFSBMM QSPDFTTJTDBMMFEDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPO O $POUSBEJDUJPO BOE QBSBEPY 54& TFFLT UP BDIJFWF DPOTJTUFODZ BOE BWPJE DPOUSBEJDUJPO QBSBEPY UFOTJPO BOE DPOUSBTU $PNQMFY TZTUFNT BDDFQU DPOUSBEJDUJPO UFOTJPOT EVBMJ UJFT BOE DPOUSBTUT BT SFQSFTFOUJOH CBMBODF BOE EJWFSTJUZ JO UIF TQJSJU PG ZJO BOE ZBOH $POUSBTUJOHFMFNFOUTBSFSFDPODJMFE JOQBSU XJUIUIFVTFPGWJFXT ThFJODMVTJPOPGQFPQMFJOTZTUFNTBOEUIFMBDLPGDPOUSPMBSFDMFBSMZDPOOFDUFE1FPQMFBSF OPUTJNQMZJOGPSNBUJPOQSPDFTTJOHDPNQPOFOUTPGBTZTUFNUIFJSCFIBWJPSJOSFTQPOTFUPFOWJSPO NFOUBMTUJNVMJJTTJHOJﬁDBOUMZNFEJBUFEUISPVHIUIFJSJOUFSOBMNPEFMPSWJFXPGUIFXPSMEBOE UIFJS JOUFOUJPOT %FWFMPQNFOUT JO DPHOJUJWF TDJFODF BOE UIFJS BQQMJDBUJPO JO DPHOJUJWF TZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH FH )PMMOBHFMBOE8PPET

QSPWJEFOPUPOMZNPEFMTPGIVNBOTBTDPNQPOFOUT PGTZTUFNT CVUBMTPHPCFZPOEUIBUUPQSPWJEFIPMJTUJDNPEFMTPGTZTUFNTUIBUJODMVEFCPUIQFPQMF BOENBDIJOFT*ODPHOJUJWFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH TVDITZTUFNTBSFDBMMFEKPJOUDPHOJUJWFTZTUFNT JOUIJTCPPLXFDBMMUIFNIZCSJETZTUFNT 'PSNPSFJOGPSNBUJPOPOUIF$4WJFX TFFSFQSFTFOUBUJWFMJUFSBUVSF"TBNQMFS"YFMSPEBOE $PIFO

#PDDBSB

)PMMBOE

,VSBT BOE 8IJUF

4JNPO

BOE 4VTTNBO " TJHOJﬁDBOU OVNCFS PG JOTUJUVUFT VOJWFSTJUJFT BOE PUIFS PSHBOJ[BUJPOT IBWF CFFODPOEVDUJOHSFTFBSDIJODPNQMFYTZTUFNTBOEDPNQMFY44GPSEFDBEFT&YBNQMFTJODMVEFUIF 4BOUB'F*OTUJUVUF 4'*

UIF/FX&OHMBOE$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT*OTUJUVUF /&$4*

BOE UIF6OJWFSTJUZPG.JDIJHBO$FOUFSGPSUIF4UVEZPG$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT $4$4 JOUIF6OJUFE 4UBUFT BTXFMMBTNBOZJOPUIFSQBSUTPGUIFXPSME

Example CS Models and Systems Th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

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O

7

DBSFBOEDVMUVSBMTIJGUTBJSUSBﬃDDPOUSPMFNFSHFODZQSFQBSFEOFTT FH GPSIVSSJDBOFT DPOHFT UJPOTFOTJOHBOENJUJHBUJPOJODSJUJDBMJOGSBTUSVDUVSFTZTUFNTDSJNJOBMKVTUJDFTZTUFNTFEVDBUJPO EJTUBODFMFBSOJOHUIF*OUFSOFUQVCMJDQPMJDZBOEVSCBOQMBOOJOHNJMJUBSZDPOﬂJDU JOTVSHFODZ BOEUFSSPSJTNBOEBVUPOPNPVTBOEBEBQUJWFJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNT CPUIOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMThF 4&DPNNVOJUZJTBMSFBEZCFHJOOJOHUPBEESFTTTZTUFNTJOUIFTFDBUFHPSJFT'PSFYBNQMF TFF.*5

3PVTF

BOE#MVNTUFJO *ONBOZDBTFT B$4NPEFMBQQMJFTUPBWBSJFUZPGEJTDJQMJOFTPSEPNBJOT"OFYBNQMFJTUIF BQQMJDBUJPOPGCJPMPHJDBMNPEFMTUPNBOZPUIFSEPNBJOTTVDIBTFDPOPNJDNBSLFUT USBﬃc QBU UFSOT BOETPDJBMPSHBOJ[BUJPOTThFﬁFMEPGCJPNJNJDSZFYBNJOFTCJPMPHJDBMPSHBOJTNTBOEQSP DFTTFTBTBCBTJTGPSJNQSPWJOHUIFEFTJHOPGIVNBOFOHJOFFSFETZTUFNT4FFGPSFYBNQMF#FOZVT BOE.BSHBMJPU

Changing Perspectives on Complex Systems 'SPNUIF$4BOE44MJUFSBUVSF XFDBOJOUFSQSFUUISFFQFSTQFDUJWFTPODPNQMFYTZTUFNTUIBUIBWF FWPMWFEPWFSUIFQBTUDFOUVSZThFﬁSTUXFXJMMDBMMi5SZJOHUPFOHJOFFSDPNQMFYTZTUFNTBTNBDIJOFTw ThJTQFSTQFDUJWF EPNJOBOUJOUIFFBSMZUXFOUJFUIDFOUVSZCVUTUJMMJOFYJTUFODF JODMVEFTUIFiTDJFO UJﬁDNBOBHFNFOUwPG5BZMPS

NBOBHFNFOUUIFPSZ9EFTDSJCFEJOCZ.D(SFHPS

BOEJOHFOFSBM IJFSBSDIJDBMMFWFMT TQBOPGDPOUSPM DIBJOPGDPNNBOE BOEPQUJNBMFﬃcJFODZ ThFTFDPOEQFSTQFDUJWFXFXJMMDBMMi5SZJOHUPVOEFSTUBOEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNTBT BTDJFODFwThJTQFSTQFDUJWFIBTCFFOBDUJWFTJODFUIFT JOUIFGPSNPGDZCFSOFUJDT TZTUFNTUIF PSZ PSHBOJ[BUJPOBMUIFPSZ BOEUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPGOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMDPNQMFYTZTUFNNPEFMT ThFUIJSEQFSTQFDUJWFSFUVSOTUPFOHJOFFSJOHXFXJMMDBMMJUi5SZJOHUPFOHJOFFSDPNQMFYTZT UFNT BT PSHBOJTNT PS BHFOUTw ThJT QFSTQFDUJWF IBT FNFSHFE JO UIF QBTU EFDBEF PS TP ThF OFX UIJOLJOHJTUIBUUIFDFOUVSZPMEDPODFQUPGFOHJOFFSJOH$4EJEOPUGBJMCFDBVTFJUXBTJOIFSFOUMZB CBEJEFBJUGBJMFECFDBVTFJUVTFEJOBQQSPQSJBUFNPEFMT3FHBSEJOHQFPQMFBTNFDIBOJTUJDTZTUFNT EJEOPUXPSL3FHBSEJOHQFPQMFBTPSHBOJDTZTUFNTPSBHFOUTNBZXPSLCFUUFSCFDBVTFJUJTBCFUUFS ﬁU8FOPXIBWFTFWFSBMEFDBEFTPGBEEJUJPOBMTDJFOUJﬁDLOPXMFEHFPGQFPQMFBOEPUIFSDPNQMFY TZTUFNTUPCSJOHUPCFBSPOUIFUBTLPGFOHJOFFSJOHDPNQMFYTZTUFNT TPMFUTIBWFBOPUIFSHPBU JUUIJTUJNF XJUINPSFSFBMJTUJDBOEVTFGVMNPEFMT ThFUISFFQFSTQFDUJWFTDBOCFTVNNBSJ[FEUIJTXBZ VTF54&UPFOHJOFFS$4 TUVEZ$4 UPEFﬁOFBTDJFODF $44 BOE EFﬁOFBOEVTF$4&CBTFEPO$44UPFOHJOFFS$4 ThJTCPPLVTFTUIFTFDPOEQFSTQFDUJWF $44 BTBLFZQBSUPGBGPVOEBUJPOUPTVQQPSUUIFUIJSE QFSTQFDUJWF $4& XJUIJOUIFMBSHFS4&ThFFYQBOEFETDPQFPGTZTUFNTJEFOUJﬁFEJOUIFQSFWJPVT TFDUJPOSFQSFTFOUTGFSUJMFHSPVOEGPS4&ThFCFMJFGJTUIBUOPUPOMZDBOXFPCTFSWFBOEEFTDSJCF UIFTFDPNQMFYBOEPSHBOJDTZTUFNT CVUXFDBOBMTPFOHJOFFS JOUIFDPOUFYUPGDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[B UJPO TQFDJﬁDTZTUFNTPGUIFTFUZQFT UIBUJT TZTUFNTUIBUUPWBSZJOHEFHSFFTDPOUSPMUIFNTFMWFT BDU BVUPOPNPVTMZ BOEDIBOHFPOUIFJSPXO4PNFPGUIFFYBNQMFTBCPWFJMMVTUSBUFEUIBUUIFﬁFMEJT FYQBOEJOHJOUIJTEJSFDUJPO1PUFOUJBMMZ4&DBOBEESFTTTZTUFNTFWFOBUUIFMFWFMPGTPDJFUJFT QVCMJD QPMJDZ DVMUVSFT SFMJHJPOT XBS QFBDF DPBMJUJPOT USFBUJFT MBXT BOEGPSNTPGHPWFSONFOUJGXF DBOEFﬁOFBEFRVBUFNPEFMTUIBUXPSL

More People Involved: Mass Collaboration ThFTUPSZPGUIF-JOVYPQFSBUJOHTZTUFNJTXFMMLOPXO*O -JOVT5PSWBMETSFMFBTFEUIFLFSOFM PGBWBSJBOUPGUIF6/*9PQFSBUJOHTZTUFNBOEPQFOFEJUVQGPSQFPQMFUPSFWJFXJUBOEDIBOHF JUThJTXBTBSBEJDBMMZEJﬀFSFOUEFWFMPQNFOUNPEFMGSPNUIFUSBEJUJPOBMDMPTFEQSPQSJFUBSZUFBN

8 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

BQQSPBDIUPTPGUXBSFEFWFMPQNFOUThFSFTVMUUIBUIBTFNFSHFEGSPNUIJTBQQSPBDIJTUIBU-JOVY JTTFFOBTSPCVTU SFMJBCMF BOEBEBQUBCMF BOEJUIBTHSPXOJOUPXJEFTQSFBEVTFBTBDPOTFRVFODF *UDPOUJOVFTUPFWPMWFGSPNUIFFﬀPSUTPGUIPVTBOETPGWPMVOUFFSTXPSMEXJEF BOEUIFPQFOTPVSDF NPWFNFOUIBTTQSFBEUPPUIFSUZQFTPGTPGUXBSF ThFPOMJOFGSFFFODZDMPQFEJB 8JLJQFEJB JTBMTPBXFMMLOPXOTUPSZ"TNBMMDPPSEJOBUJOHHSPVQ PWFSTFFTBMBSHFOVNCFSPGQFPQMFXIPIBWFWPMVOUFFSFEUPXSJUFFOUSJFTBOESFWJFXBOEFEJUPUIFS FOUSJFT GPSUIFFODZDMPQFEJBThFSFTVMUJOUIFTQBDFPGBGFXZFBST 8JLJQFEJBIBTBDDVNVMBUFEPWFS NJMMJPOBSUJDMFTJOMBOHVBHFT JODMVEJOHPWFSNJMMJPOJO&OHMJTIBTPG%FDFNCFS 8JLJQFEJB "MUIPVHIUIFSFJTTPNFEFCBUFPOUIFRVBMJUZ BBOBMZTJTTVHHFTUFEUIBUUIF RVBMJUZPG8JLJQFEJBBSUJDMFTXBTDMPTFUPUIBUPG&ODZDMPQFEJB#SJUBOOJDBBSUJDMFT (JMFT )PXBSFUIFTFFYBNQMFTSFMBUFE -JOVYBOEUIFPQFOTPVSDFNPWFNFOU BOE8JLJQFEJBBSF FYBNQMFTPGXIBU5BQTDPUUBOE8JMMJBNT DBMMiQSPTVNFST wXIJDIJTBDBUFHPSZPGNBTT DPMMBCPSBUJPOJOXIJDIDPOTVNFSTCFDPNFQSPEVDFSTThFTVDDFTTPGUIJTNPEFMIBTNBEFDMFBS UIBUOPOIJFSBSDIJDBM TFMGTFMFDUJOHHSPVQTDBONBOBHFBOEDPOUSPMUIFNTFMWFT BOEDBOXPSLTVD DFTTGVMMZBTBWFSZEJTUSJCVUFEHSPVQFWFOHMPCBMMZEJTUSJCVUFE BTXJUI-JOVYBOE8JLJQFEJB UISPVHINJOJNBMSVMFTBOETPDJBMOPSNTJOTUFBEPGIJFSBSDIJDBMDPOUSPM 5BQTDPUUBOE8JMMJBNTBMTPEFTDSJCFTFWFSBMPUIFSDBUFHPSJFTPGNBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPO VOEFSUIF HFOFSBMUFSNi8JLJOPNJDTw0OFJTDBMMFEUIFHMPCBMQMBOUﬂPPS VTFECZDPNQBOJFTGPSFOHJOFFS JOHBOEQSPEVDJOHQIZTJDBMHPPET*OUIJTEPNBJO UIFBQQSPBDI#PFJOHVTFEGPSJUTFBSMJFSBJSDSBGU TVDIBTUIF DPOUSBTUFEXJUIJUTBQQSPBDIPOUIFBJSDSBGU 5BQTDPUUBOE8JMMJBNT $IBQUFS 5SBEJUJPOBMMZ #PFJOHEFﬁOFEBMMEFUBJMFESFRVJSFNFOUTBOEEFWFMPQFEUIFDPNQMFUF EFTJHOPGUIFBJSDSBGUBOEJUTQBSUT*UHBWFEFUBJMFEEFTJHOTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTUPTVQQMJFST XIPXFSF FYQFDUFEUPCVJMEQBSUTUPUIPTFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT *O UIF BQQSPBDI CPUI UIF SFRVJSFNFOUT BOE EFTJHO XFSF EFﬁOFE DPMMBCPSBUJWFMZ XJUI TVQQMJFSTBOEVTFST XIPN#PFJOHCSPVHIUJOBTQBSUOFSTFBSMZJOUIFQSPDFTTThJTDPOUSBTUJTB DMFBSFYBNQMFPGUIFEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOBUSBEJUJPOBM4&BQQSPBDIBOEUIFNPWFNFOUUPXBSEB QPUFOUJBMMZNPSFDPMMBCPSBUJWF4&BQQSPBDI *UJTJNQPSUBOUUPOPUFUIBUUIFKVSZJTTUJMMPVUPOUIFSFTVMUPG#PFJOHTFYQFSJNFOU8IFUIFS UIBUFYQFSJNFOUTVDDFFETPSGBJMT UIFQBUUFSOPGJODSFBTFEDPMMBCPSBUJPOTFFNTUPCFHBJOJOHUSBD UJPOJONVMUJQMFJOEVTUSJFT'PSFYBNQMF UIFNPUPSDZDMFJOEVTUSZJO$IJOBIBTSBQJEMZPWFSUBLFO UIBUPGUIF+BQBOFTFJOUIFXPSMENBSLFUCZFYQMPJUJOHUIJTQBUUFSO BDDPSEJOHUP5BQTDPUUBOE 8JMMJBNT o /PUFWFSZPOFBHSFFTPOUIFTVDDFTTPGNBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPO,FFO TUSPOHMZDSJUJDJ[FTUIF iBNBUFVSwOBUVSFPGSFTVMUJOHDPOUFOU.BOZRVFTUJPOXIFUIFSNBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPOQSPEVDFTBMPX FTUDPNNPOEFOPNJOBUPSBOEFYDMVEFTXPSLTPGHFOJVT 0VSQPJOUJOEJTDVTTJOHUIJTBQQSPBDIJTOPUUPTBZUIBUJUJTBQBOBDFBPSJTCFUUFSUIBONPSF USBEJUJPOBMBQQSPBDIFTJOBMM4&TJUVBUJPOT CVUJUDBOCFTFFOBTBOBMUFSOBUJWFBQQSPBDIUIBU IBTBDIJFWFEFOPVHITVDDFTTUPNFSJUGVSUIFSDPOTJEFSBUJPOBOEBOBMZTJTGPS4& BOEUPJODMVEF JUBTBQPUFOUJBMUPPMJOBMBSHFSUPPMTFUThFHFOFSBMQPJOUJTUIBUJUJTBOPUIFSXBZJOXIJDI4& JTFYQBOEJOH

Traditional Mass Collaboration 0GDPVSTF NBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPOJTOPUBOFXQIFOPNFOPO"MPOHTUBOEJOHFYBNQMFPGNBTTDPM MBCPSBUJPOJTUIFDSFBUJPO NFBOJOH BOEVTBHFPGXPSETJOBOBUVSBMMBOHVBHFTVDIBT&OHMJTI 8FUFOEUPUIJOLUIBUEJDUJPOBSZXSJUFSTEFﬁOFXIBUJTDPSSFDUNFBOJOHBOEVTBHF BOEUIBUEJD UJPOBSJFTBSFOPSNBUJWFPSQSFTDSJQUJWF#VUEJDUJPOBSJFTBSFBEFTDSJQUJPOPGXIBUUIFQPQVMBUJPO

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O

9

UIJOLTXPSETNFBOBOEIPXUIFZTIPVMECFVTFE%JDUJPOBSZXSJUFSTBSFPCTFSWFSTBOESFDPSEFST OPUQSFTDSJCFST8FJMMVTUSBUFXJUIUISFFXPSETEFﬁOFEBOEEJTDVTTFEJO.FSSJBN8FCTUFS JOﬂBNNBCMF WFSTVTﬂBNNBCMF

JSSFHBSEMFTT WFSTVTSFHBSEMFTT

BOEDPNQSJTFThFﬁSTUUXPQBJST BSFXPSETUIBUMPPLMJLFBOUPOZNTCVUBSFTZOPOZNTThFUIJSEXPSEJTCJQPMBSJUIBTUXPNFBO JOHTUIBUBSFBOUPOZNT O *OﬂBNNBCMFNFBOs ﬂBNNBCMF*UJTKVEHFECZUIFQPQVMBUJPOUPCFBOBDDFQUBCMFXPSE O *SSFHBSEMFTTNFBOTSFHBSEMFTT"MUIPVHIJUIBTCFFOVTFEGPSOFBSMZBDFOUVSZ JUIBTDPOTJT UFOUMZCFFOKVEHFECZUIFQPQVMBUJPOUPCFBOVOBDDFQUBCMFXPSEJOQVCMJTIFEXPSLT O $PNQSJTF IBT UXP PQQPTJUF NFBOJOHT JODMVEF CF NBEF VQ PG &YBNQMF ThJT CPPL DPNQSJTFTDIBQUFST DPNQPTF DPOTUJUVUF &YBNQMFDIBQUFSTDPNQSJTFUIJTCPPL PSUIJTCPPLJTDPNQSJTFEPGDIBQUFST ThFUXPNFBOJOHTIBWFCFFOBSPVOEGPSPWFSB DFOUVSZ BOEUIFTFDPOENFBOJOHIBTBMXBZTCFFODSJUJDJ[FEBTXSPOHThJTTFDPOENFBO JOHIBTCFFOVTFEJOTDJFOUJﬁDBOEUFDIOJDBMXSJUJOH CVUOPUJOMJUFSBSZXSJUJOH3FDFOUMZ IPXFWFS MJUFSBSZVTBHFIBTTIJGUFE BOEOPXUIFTFDPOENFBOJOHJTVTFEBCJUNPSFCVU JUJTOPUDPNQMFUFMZBDDFQUFEZFUJOUIBUDPNNVOJUZBOETUJMMDSJUJDJ[FE/FWFSUIFMFTT UIF UJEFJTUVSOJOHThFNFBOJOHPWFSBQFSJPEPGEFDBEFTBQQFBSTUPCFSFWFSTJOHJUTFMGJUJT DIBOHJOHQPMBSJUZ PSQFSIBQTDIBOHJOHGSPNCJQPMBSUPQPMBS ThFEJDUJPOBSZEPFTOPUTBZXIBUJTDPSSFDUBOEJODPSSFDUJUSFDPSETXIBUJTHFOFSBMMZDPOTJE FSFE CZNBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPO UPCFDPSSFDUBOEJODPSSFDU"OEUIFQPQVMBUJPOBTTFTTNFOUFWPMWFT PWFSUJNF*OBEEJUJPO EJDUJPOBSZXSJUFSTEPOPUDSFBUFOFXXPSETUIFQPQVMBUJPODSFBUFTJUTPXO XPSET /BUVSBM MBOHVBHF JT PSHBOJD OPU NFDIBOJTUJD ThF QPQVMBUJPO JT TFMGHPWFSOJOH XIFO JU DPNFTUPOBUVSBMMBOHVBHF

Storytelling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

Scaling in All Directions 4&JTFYQFSJFODJOHFYUFOTJPOTPGTDBMFJOBMMEJSFDUJPOTVQ EPXO BOEIPSJ[POUBM)PSJ[POUBMTDBM JOHJTSFﬂFDUFEJOUIFNBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPOQSBDUJDFTXFIBWFEJTDVTTFE BOEBMTPJOUIFWFSZMBSHF OVNCFSTPGQBSUTJODPNQMFYTZTUFNT EJTDVTTFEJOUIFTQBOPGDPOUSPMQPSUJPOPG$IBQUFS6Q BOEEPXOTDBMJOHJTBEESFTTFEIFSF

Scaling Up SE 4&JTBEESFTTJOHMBSHFSTZTUFNTThFFYBNQMFPGFYUFOEJOHGSPNQPXFSQMBOUUPQPXFSHSJESFﬂFDUFE UIJTThFUFSNiTZTUFNPGTZTUFNTwJTTPNFUJNFTVTFEUPSFﬂFDUBIJHIFSTDBMF XIFSFBWFSZMBSHF

10 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

TZTUFNJTQVUUPHFUIFSGSPNFYJTUJOHTZTUFNT"OPUIFSBSFBPGTDBMFVQJTPSHBOJ[BUJPOTPSFOUFS QSJTFT&OUFSQSJTFDBONFBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOPSNJTTJPOCVUDBOFYUFOEVQUPNVMUJPSHBOJ[BUJPOFOUJ UJFTPSNVMUJOBUJPOBMDPBMJUJPOGPSDFTThJTMFWFMPGTDBMFFYUFOETCFZPOEUIFTDPQFPGNBOBHFNFOU PGBTJOHMFPSHBOJ[BUJPOBOEQPTFTJUTPXODIBMMFOHFT

Scaling Down SE *OSFDFOUZFBST TNBMMTDBMFCJPMPHJDBMBOEQIZTJDBMTZTUFNTIBWFCFFOBOBSFBPGDPOTJEFSBCMFJOUFS FTU DSFBUJWJUZ SFTFBSDI BOEEFWFMPQNFOU0WFSMBQQJOHUPQJDTJODMVEFNJDSPFOHJOFFSJOH OBOP UFDIOPMPHZ OBOPCJPMPHZ OBOPTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH TZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZ TZTUFNTCJPMPHZ CJPMPHJDBM FOHJOFFSJOH NPMFDVMBSDPNQVUJOH BOERVBOUVNDPNQVUJOHThFTFBSFBTIBWFHSFBUQSPNJTFJO NBOZBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT JODMVEJOHNFEJDJOFBOEDPNQVUJOH6OJWFSTJUZEFHSFFQSPHSBNTBOE KPVSOBMTIBWFCFFODSFBUFEUPGPDVTPONBOZPGUIFTFJOEJWJEVBMUPQJDBSFBT 4ZTUFNTCJPMPHZBOETZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZBSFQBSUJDVMBSMZJOUFSFTUJOHBOEQBSUJBMMZPWFSMBQQJOH BSFBT*GUIFSFJTBEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOUIFUXP JUJTUIBUUIFHPBMPGTZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZJTUPFOHJOFFS CJPMPHJDBM QBSUT PS i#JP#SJDLT w BOE UIF HPBM PG TZTUFNT CJPMPHZ JT UP CVJME TZTUFNT GSPN UIFTF TUBOEBSEQBSUT.*5IBTFTUBCMJTIFEB3FHJTUSZPG4UBOEBSE#JPMPHJDBM1BSUT 3FHJTUSZ ThF QVSQPTFTBOEFNFSHJOHQSBDUJDFPGTZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZBSFEJTDVTTFEJO/BUVSF ThFFDPOPN JDTPGTZTUFNTCJPMPHZ JOUFSNTPGUIFQSPTQFDUTPGTVDDFTTGVMMZCVJMEJOHTZTUFNTGSPNTUBOEBSE CJPMPHJDBMQBSUT JTEJTDVTTFEJO)FOLFMBOE.BVSFS %PUIFTFTNBMMTDBMFTZTUFNTSFMBUFUP4& :FT TZTUFNTBSFCFJOHFOHJOFFSFEBUUIJTMFWFM BOE BOZXIFSFTZTUFNTBSFFOHJOFFSFEFWFOJGUIFZBSFBUBWFSZTNBMMTDBMFXPVMETFFNUPCFBO BQQSPQSJBUFBSFOBGPSBQQMZJOH4&ThJTTFOUJNFOUJTSFJOGPSDFECZUIFDVSSFOUTUBUFPGUIFFﬀPSU EFTDSJCFEBCPWFUPCVJMETZTUFNTGSPNMJCSBSJFTPGTUBOEBSECJPMPHJDBMQBSUT1BSUTIBWFCFFOTVD DFTTGVMMZCVJMU BMPOHXJUITPNFFYQFSJNFOUBMDJSDVJUT CVUUIFDPNNVOJUZJTTUSVHHMJOHUPCVJME XPSLJOH TZTUFNT GSPN UIFTF QBSUT "O FYBNQMF JT B SFQPSU UIBU PO POF TZTUFNT CJPMPHZ FﬀPSU UIF HSPVQ TQFOET PG JUT UJNF USZJOH UP ﬁOE BOE ﬁY VOJOUFOEFE JOUFSBDUJPOT CFUXFFO QBSUT ,FBTMJOH SFQPSUFEJO)FOLFMBOE.BVSFS ThJTQSPCMFNTPVOETWBHVFMZGBNJMJBSUP TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTThFTFTZTUFNTCJPMPHJTUTNJHIUCFOFﬁUGSPNBEEJUJPOBM4&BTTJTUBODFBOEFEVDB UJPO"EWPDBUFTGPSBO4&WJFXPGOBOPUFDIOPMPHZJODMVEF%BTFUBM BOE3PVTF

Multiscale SE .BOZPGUIFTFTZTUFNTJOWPMWFBOBMZTJTBOENPEFMJOHPGEJﬀFSFOUTDBMFTJOUIFTBNFTZTUFNThF QSFTFODFPGFNFSHFOUQSPQFSUJFTBUIJHIFSMFWFMTJTBEFTJSFEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGUIFTFTZTUFNT CVUJU BMTPDPNQMJDBUFTUIFBOBMZTJTBOEFOHJOFFSJOH0OFFYBNQMFPGUIJTJTUIFBOBMZTJTPGUIFQIZTJ DBM DIFNJDBM BOECJPMPHJDBMQSPQFSUJFTPGJPOJDMJRVJET UPDPNCJOFUIFNJOBXBZUIBUQSPEVDFT EFTJSFEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBUBIJHIFSTDBMF 3PHFST "OBQQMJDBUJPOPGUIJTJTUIFQSPEVDUJPOPG MJRVJENJSSPSTGPSUFMFTDPQFT'PSFYBNQMF POFQSPQPTBMJTUPQSPEVDFBNJSSPSUPNFUFST JOEJBNFUFSGPSBUFMFTDPQFPOUIF.PPOUIBUJUJTCFMJFWFEXPVMEHJWFVOQSFDFEFOUFEWJFXTPGUIF FBSMZVOJWFSTF #PSSB "OPUIFSFYBNQMFJTUIFFYQFDUFEGVUVSFVTFPGDBSCPOOBOPUVCFTJO DPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGU BTEFTDSJCFEJO/BUVSF ThFFYQFDUBUJPOJTUIBUDPNQPTJUFTNBEF GSPNOBOPUVCFTXJMMSFTVMUJOBJSDSBGUTUSVDUVSFTUIBUSFUBJOUIFOFDFTTBSZTUSFOHUICVUTJHOJﬁDBOUMZ SFEVDFUIFXFJHIUJODPNQBSJTPOUPQPMZNFSCBTFd ﬁCFST 4ZTUFNTTVDIBTUIFTFSFRVJSFBO4&BQQSPBDIUIBUDBOBOBMZ[FBOENPEFMNBOZEJﬀFSFOUTDBMFT JOBTZTUFNBOEDBOSFMBUFUIFEJﬀFSFOUTDBMFTBOEMFWFMTUPFBDIPUIFSThFTBMJFOU4&RVFTUJPOGPSB HJWFOTZTUFNJT8IBUMFWFMTPSTDBMFTEPFT4&OFFEUPBEESFTT "NVMUJTDBMFNPEFMJOHBOEBOBMZTJT

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O 11

DPNNVOJUZJTFYBNJOJOHUIJTJTTVF"OFYBNQMFJTUIF$FOUFSGPS*OUFHSBUJWF.VMUJTDBMF.PEFMJOH BOE4JNVMBUJPO $*..4 BUUIF$BMJGPSOJB*OTUJUVUFPG5FDIOPMPHZ $*..4 $*..4 JTBNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZDFOUFSTFUVQUPNPEFMBOEBOBMZ[FDPNQMFYTZTUFNTBDSPTTNVMUJQMFTDBMFT PGCPUIUJNFBOEMFOHUI"SFBTPGTUVEZJODMVEFBTUSPEZOBNJDT BUNPTQIFSF FBSUIRVBLFT ﬂVJE NFDIBOJDT TJHOBMQSPDFTTJOH JNBHJOH NBUFSJBMT CJPMPHJDBMTZTUFNT BOEOBOPTDBMFTZTUFNT

Scale Viewpoints .BOZPGUIFFYBNQMFTQSFTFOUFEJOUIJTDIBQUFSSFﬂFDUDIBOHFTPGTDBMF0OFQFSTQFDUJWFPONBTT DPMMBCPSBUJPOPOBHMPCBMTDBMFJTUIBUJUSFQSFTFOUTBTDBMFVQPGFOHJOFFSJOH CVTJOFTT BOELOPXM FEHF QSPEVDUJPO $MFBSMZ CJPMPHJDBM TZTUFNT BOE OBOPUFDIOPMPHZ SFQSFTFOU TDBMFEPXO #PUI TDBMFVQBOETDBMFEPXOIBWFPDDVSSFEPWFSUIFQBTUGFXEFDBEFTThJTTUSFUDIJOHJOCPUIEJSFD UJPOTQSFTFOUTJNQPSUBOUDIBMMFOHFTGPSTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 5PBEFRVBUFMZVOEFSTUBOEUIFSPMFBOEFYUFOUPGTDBMFT XFOFFEUPMPPLBUBNPSFHFOFSBMDPO UFYU OBNFMZ UIFQPUFOUJBMSBOHFPGTDBMFTGSPNTFWFSBMWJFXQPJOUTThFTFWJFXQPJOUTUZQJDBMMZBSF USFBUFETFQBSBUFMZBMUIPVHIUIFZPWFSMBQTJHOJﬁDBOUMZ. ThFZJODMVEF O 1IZTJDBMThFQPUFOUJBMSBOHFPGTDBMFTFYUFOETGSPNTVCBUPNJDQBSUJDMFTVQUPUIFFOUJSF VOJWFSTFBTXFLOPXJU O 4PDJBMPSPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMThFSBOHFFYUFOETGSPNJOEJWJEVBMQFPQMFVQUPTPDJFUJFT OBUJPOT BOENVMUJOBUJPOBMDPBMJUJPOTPSHSPVQT TVDIBTUIF6OJUFE/BUJPOT O &OUFSQSJTFThFSBOHFJOUIJTWJFXQPJOUUZQJDBMMZFYUFOETGSPNTZTUFNTUPPSHBOJ[BUJPOTPS FOUFSQSJTFT*OUIJTDPOUFYU TZTUFNUZQJDBMMZNFBOTTPNFUIJOHMJLFJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNPS NBDIJOF BOEFOUFSQSJTFUZQJDBMMZNFBOTPSHBOJ[BUJPOPSNJTTJPO CVUDBOHPVQUPNVMUJ PSHBOJ[BUJPOHSPVQTPSNVMUJOBUJPOBMDPBMJUJPOT*OSFDFOUZFBST UIFDPODFQUPGiTZTUFN PGTZTUFNTwUIBUJT BMBSHFTZTUFNQVUUPHFUIFSGSPNFYJTUJOHTZTUFNTIBTCFFOEJT DVTTFE PGUFOCVUOPUBMXBZTJOUIFDPOUFYUPGUIJTWJFXQPJOU O #JPMPHJDBM ThF SBOHF FYUFOET GSPN OBOPCJPMPHZ BTTFNCMJFT PG CJPNPMFDVMFT VQ UP FDPTZTUFNT O -JGFPSMJWJOHTZTUFNTThFSBOHFFYUFOETGSPNPSHBOJDNPMFDVMFTPSDFMMTVQUPNVMUJOB UJPOBMHSPVQT PSBQQSPYJNBUFMZUIFDPNCJOFESBOHFPGCJPMPHJDBM FOUFSQSJTF BOETPDJBM PSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTDBMFTThFGVMMFTUFYQSFTTJPOPGUIJTWJFXQPJOUJT+BNFT.JMMFSTNPOVNFO UBMXPSL-JWJOH4ZTUFNT O .BDIJOFThFSBOHFJOUIJTWJFXQPJOUFYUFOETGSPNOBOPEFWJDFTVQUPMBSHFNBDIJOFT UIBUBSFBOBMPHPVTUPPSHBOJTNTJOUIFTPDJBMPSCJPMPHJDBMWJFXQPJOUThBUJT BDBSPSUSBJO PSBJSDSBGUPSTIJQPSDPNQVUFSJTPGUFOSFHBSEFEBTBNBDIJOF CVUBUSBOTQPSUBUJPOTZTUFN PSBﬂFFUPGTIJQTPSBDPNQVUFSOFUXPSLJTVTVBMMZSFHBSEFEBTBOJOUFSBDUJOHHSPVQPG NBDIJOFTBOEPUIFSFMFNFOUTUIBUJT BTZTUFNBOEOPUBTBNBDIJOF O *OGPSNBUJPOThFSBOHFFYUFOETGSPNCJUTUPBMBSHFHMPCBMJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFN PGXIJDI UIF*OUFSOFUJTUIFEPNJOBOUFYBNQMF O 5JNF ThFSBOHFPGUFNQPSBMTDBMFTFYUFOETGSPNOBOPTFDPOETPSUJNFDZDMFTPGBUPNJD CFIBWJPSUPCJMMJPOTPGZFBSTPSUIFMJGFPGUIFVOJWFSTF

/PUFUIBUCFDBVTFTPNFTZTUFNTBSFOPUSFHBSEFEBTNBDIJOFTEPFTOPUNFBOUIBUNBDIJOFTBSFOPUSFHBSEFE BTTZTUFNT.BDIJOFT BOEJOGBDUNPTUJUFNTBDSPTTUIFSBOHFPGTDBMFTJOBMMUIFWJFXQPJOUTJEFOUJﬁFEIFSF BSF SFHBSEFEBTTZTUFNT BTUIJTCPPLFNQIBTJ[FTUISPVHIPVU

12 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

The Bridge: Information, Computation, Software *OGPSNBUJPO TZTUFNT JODMVEJOH DPNQVUBUJPO BOE FTQFDJBMMZ TPGUXBSF GPSN B QPUFOUJBM CSJEHF CFUXFFOUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT3FDFOUEFWFMPQNFOUTJOUIJTEPNBJOSFQSFTFOU TJHOJﬁDBOUTUFQTUPXBSESFBMJ[JOHUIJTQPUFOUJBMThJTTFDUJPOEFTDSJCFTUIFQPUFOUJBMPGBOETUFQT UPXBSE SFBMJ[JOH JU $PNQVUBUJPO BOE TPGUXBSF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT BSF EJWJEFE JOUP UISFF TFUT 54& SFMBUFE$4&SFMBUFEBOECSJEHFSFMBUFE

TSE-Related Characteristics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ﬀ BOE4XFFU JEFOUJGZBVUPNBUJPOBTUIFGBTUFTUHSPXJOHBOETUSPOHFTUJOﬂVFODFPO4& ThF*OUFSOFUBOEUFDIOPMPHJFTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIF*OUFSOFUIBWFCFDPNFJODSFBTJOHMZJNQPS UBOUJO4&4PGUXBSFJTBLFZQBSUPG*OUFSOFUQSPDFTTFTBOEUFDIOPMPHJFT

CSE-Related Characteristics "NBKPSBSFBPGTPGUXBSFTVQQPSUUP$4&JTBHFOUCBTFETZTUFNT.VDIXPSLIBTCFFOEPOFJOUIJT BSFB FYQMPSJOHDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTTVDIBTBVUPOPNZ MFBSOJOH BEBQUBUJPO FWPMVUJPO GBVMUUPMFSBODF BOESPCVTUOFTT 0WFSUIFQBTUEFDBEFPSNPSF UIFDPODFQUPG TPGUXBSF DPHOJUJWFBHFOUTIBTCFFOQVSTVFE'PS FYBNQMF )VIOTBOE4JOHI EJTDVTTUIFHFOFSBMDPODFQU BOE.BKJEBOE"INFE EJT DVTTBTQFDJﬁDBQQMJDBUJPO*OGBDU UIFJEFBPGBTDSJCJOHDPHOJUJWFPSNFOUBMRVBMJUJFTUPNBDIJOFT TPGUXBSF XBTQSPQPTFEZFBSTBHPCZ+PIO.D$BSUIZ "DPNNPONPEFMVTFEJOEFﬁO JOHBOESFBTPOJOHBCPVUDPHOJUJWFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGTPGUXBSFBHFOUTBTXFMMBTNPEFMJOHIVNBO BHFOUTJTUIF#%*NPEFM CFMJFGT EFTJSFT BOEJOUFOUJPOT 3BPBOE(FPSHFﬀ 1 *O *#.QSPQPTFEBDPODFQUDBMMFEBVUPOPNJDDPNQVUJOH ,FQIBSUBOE$IFTT

XIJDIUIFZEFTDSJCFBTBTZTUFNJDWJFXPGDPNQVUJOHNPEFMFEBGUFSBTFMGSFHVMBUJOHCJPMPHJDBM TZTUFNThFGPVSBSFBTXFSFTFMGDPOﬁHVSBUJPO TFMGIFBMJOH TFMGPQUJNJ[BUJPO BOETFMGQSPUFDUJPO ThFPSJHJOBMNPUJWBUJPOXBTMBSHFMZUIFGBDUUIBUNBOZDPNQMFYJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTJOPQFSBUJPO BSFCSJUUMFBOEOPOSPCVTUBHBJOTUJOQVUPSFOWJSPONFOUWBHBSJFT BOELFFQJOHUIFNPQFSBUJOHJT CFDPNJOHBEJﬃcVMUBOESFTPVSDFJOUFOTJWFFﬀPSU4JODFUIFO UIFDPODFQUIBTCFDPNFBOBDUJWF BSFBPGSFTFBSDI BOEUIFTDPQFIBTCSPBEFOFEUPJODPSQPSBUFNPSFNBOBHFNFOUBTQFDUT 4BMFIJF BOE5BIWJMEBSJ 'PSFYBNQMF NPEFMTPGCJPMPHJDBMQSPDFTTFTBSFCFJOHBQQMJFEUPBTTJTUJO QPMJDZEFDPNQPTJUJPO ,FFOFZBOE8BEF "OPUIFS BSFB JT UIF JODSFBTJOH FNQIBTJT PO POUPMPHZ FOHJOFFSJOH BOE NBDIJOFNBOJQVMBCMF TFNBOUJDT4PGUXBSFQMBZTBNBKPSSole in these eﬀorts. This arFBJTEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJO$IBQUFS

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O

13

Bridge-Related Characteristics 4PGUXBSFJTBQSPNJOFOUTFHVF BMJOL CFUXFFOUIFNFDIBOJTUJDBOEPSHBOJDNPEFMT*UDBOSBOHF GSPNNFDIBOJTUJDTUSBJHIUGPSXBSEBMHPSJUINTPSEBUBQSPDFTTJOHUPBQQFBSJOHUPCFBOJOUFMMJHFOU BHFOUThFQPJOUBQQMJFTUPBVUPOPNZBTXFMMBTJOUFMMJHFODFTPGUXBSFBOEDPNQVUFSTZTUFNTDBOFYJTU BOZXIFSFJOUIFBVUPOPNZTQFDUSVNCFUXFFOUIFDPOUSPMMFENBDIJOFBOEUIFBVUPOPNPVTIVNBO 4PGUXBSFJTJOIFSFOUMZNPEFMPSJFOUFEThFTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHﬁFMEIBTJOWFTUJHBUFENPEFMJOH JOHSFBUEFQUIBOEIBTQSPEVDFENVDINPEFMJOHNBDIJOFSZGPSEFTJHOBOEBOBMZTJTPGBMMEPNBJOT .PEFMJOHJTTPNFUIJOHUIBUBQQMJFTUPUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGCPUIUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT 4PDJBMBOECJPMPHJDBMTDJFODFTBSFBTPVSDFPGNVDIJOGPSNBUJPOGPSUIFOFX FYQBOEFE4&ThF TPGUXBSFDPNNVOJUZIBTBMSFBEZHJWFOUIFOFX4&BCJHIFBETUBSUUPXBSEQSFQBSJOHUIJTJOGPSNB UJPOGPS4&CZEFWFMPQJOHBOEFYFDVUJOHNPEFMT.VDIPGUIJTXPSLJTJOBHFOUNPEFMJOH "OPUIFSQFSTQFDUJWFPOUIFTPGUXBSFSPMFGPDVTFTPOUIFDIBMMFOHFTPGTPGUXBSFJUTFMG FTQFDJBMMZ MBSHFTDBMF TZTUFNT ThF 4PGUXBSF &OHJOFFSJOH *OTUJUVUF BU $BSOFHJF .FMMPO QSPEVDFE B SFQPSU POVMUSBMBSHFTDBMFTZTUFNTPGUIFGVUVSFBOEUIFJSDIBMMFOHFT JNQMJDBUJPOT BOEBSFBTPGOFFEFE SFTFBSDI 'FJMFSFUBM ThFTFMBSHFTPGUXBSFTZTUFNTBSFDIBSBDUFSJ[FEBTEJﬀFSFOUJOLJOE UIFZOFFEUPCFWJFXFEOPUBTTZTUFNTPSTZTUFNTPGTZTUFNT CVUBTTPDJPUFDIOJDBMFDPTZTUFNT ThFZFYIJCJUNBOZPGUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGMBSHFDPNQMFYTZTUFNT JODMVEJOHDPOUJOVBMDIBOHFBOE FWPMVUJPO DPOﬂJDUJOHHPBMT BOEEFDFOUSBMJ[FEDPOUSPM 4PGUXBSFQMBZTBLFZSPMFJOCPUIUIFFYUFOTJPOPG4& WJB$4NPEFMTBOEBHFOUT BOEJOVOJ ﬁDBUJPO TQFDUSVN PG BVUPOPNZ CSJEHF 54& BOE $4& BTQFDUT &YUFOTJPO BOE VOJﬁDBUJPO BSF DIBMMFOHFBSFBTEJTDVTTFEJOUIFOFYUTFDUJPO

Challenges: A Foundation Needed for the Future SE #BTFE PO UIF TUBUF PG 54& UIF PQQPSUVOJUJFT GPS 4& FYQBOTJPO BOE UIF TPGUXBSF CSJEHF UIJT TFDUJPOQSFTFOUTUIFDIBMMFOHFTPGEFﬁOJOHUIF4&PGUIFGVUVSF5XPFMFNFOUTSFQSFTFOUUIF4& DIBMMFOHFBOEBSFEJTDVTTFEJOUIJTTFDUJPOThFﬁSTUJTUIFHFOFSBMOFFEUPTVQQPSUBOFYQBOEFE 4&ThFTFDPOEJTUIFHFOFSBMOFFEGPSVOJﬁDBUJPOPGUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT JODMVEJOH BVOJﬁFEUBYPOPNZPGTZTUFNT BOEBVOJﬁFEGPVOEBUJPOThFDIBMMFOHFTBSFUIFODBQUVSFEBTB TFUPGSFRVJSFNFOUTUIBUBO4&BQQSPBDIOFFETUPTBUJTGZUPBEFRVBUFMZTVQQPSUUIFFYQBOEFEBOE VOJﬁFE4&

General Challenge: Support Expanded Scope *G4&JTHPJOHUPFYQBOEJOUIFEJSFDUJPOTJOEJDBUFEJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi0QQPSUVOJUJFT5ZQFT PG&YQBOTJPO wJUXJMMOFFEUPEFﬁOFNFUIPETUIBUTVQQPSUUIFBTTPDJBUFE$4DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT$4 FOHJOFFSJOH PS$4&4VDITVQQPSUJODMVEFTBMBSHFSWBSJFUZPGTZTUFNUZQFTBOEUIFJSBTTPDJBUFE EJTDJQMJOFT NBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPO BOENPSFTDBMJOH CPUIVQBOEEPXO "MUIPVHITPNFJOUIF4&DPNNVOJUZIBWFCFHVOUPFYBNJOFIPXUPFOHJOFFSUIFNGPS FYBNQMF#SBIBFUBM BOE,VSBTBOE8IJUF UIFDPODFQUPG$4&JTTUJMMSFMBUJWFMZ JNNBUVSFThFEJﬃcVMUJFTIBWFCFFOWBSJPVTMZEFTDSJCFEBTXJDLFEQSPCMFNT 3JUUFMBOE8FCCFS

NFTTFT "DLPﬀ o

BOE B TXBNQ 4DIÚO *O UIFJS CPPLT PO TZTUFN "TFUPGQPUFOUJBM$4&NFUIPETJTJEFOUJﬁFEJO$IBQUFS

14 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

BSDIJUFDUJOH 3FDIUJO BOE.BJFSBOE3FDIUJO IBWFFYUFOEFECFZPOE54&JOUPBSDIJ UFDUJOH PG DPNQMFY TZTUFNT TVDI BT FDPOPNJD TZTUFNT PSHBOJ[BUJPOT DPNQFUJOH PS BEWFSTBSJBM TZTUFNTTVDIBTXBSGBSF BOEUIFDBUFHPSZPGTPDJPUFDIOJDBMTZTUFNTThFGPDVTJTPOIFVSJTUJDTBOE HFOFSBMEJTDVTTJPOPGJTTVFT BTXFMMBTUIFVTFPGNPEFMT 4JHOJﬁ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

General Challenge: Unify Unify TSE and CSE &WFO JG XF NFFU UIF DIBMMFOHF PG EFﬁOJOH B $4& NFUIPE UP TVQQPSU UIF $4 FYQBOTJPO PG 4& XF TUJMM IBWF B QSPCMFN ThF OFX TDPQF JT TP MBSHF BOE IFUFSPHFOFPVT UIBU 4& XJMM OPU IBWF B DPIFSFOU NFUIPE UIBU DPWFST JU BMM 54& BOE $4& IBWF TJHOJﬁDBOUMZ EJﬀFSFOU BTTVNQUJPOT $PODFQUVBMJ[JOHUIFTZTUFNTPGUIFQBTUBTNBDIJOFTBOEUIFTZTUFNTPGUIFGVUVSFBTPSHBOJTNT PSBHFOUTCSJOHTVTFGVMBOEOFFEFEDPODFQUTUPUIFUBCMFCVUMFBWFTPVUBOJNQPSUBOUSFBMJUZ.PTU TZTUFNTUIBU4&XJMMFOHJOFFSOPXBOEJOUIFGVUVSFBSFBDPNCJOBUJPOPGNBDIJOFTBOEQFPQMF OPUTUSJDUMZPOFPSUIFPUIFS8FDBOOPUTJNQMZSFQMBDF54&XJUI$4&"OEBEJTKPJOU4&DPOTJTU JOHPGUIF54&CPPLBOEUIF$4&CPPLXJMMOPUTVﬃcFXIFONPTU4&TZTUFNTSFﬂFDUBTQFDUTPG CPUI0VSQPTJUJPOJTUIBUUIFZNVTUCFJOUFHSBUFEJOUPBVOJﬁFE4&

Unify Multiple Disciplines 54&JTDPOTJEFSFENVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZThFOFXﬁFMETPGTZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZ OBOPCJPMPHZ BOEPUIFST BUUIBUTDBMFBSFNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZJOUIFNTFMWFT TPUIFZBEEUPUIFNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZTDPQFPG4& *OBEEJUJPO DPNQMFYTZTUFNTBSFCSPBEMZNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZCFDBVTFUIFJSNPEFMTBQQMZUPNBOZ EJﬀFSFOUBQQMJDBUJPOBSFBTThFSFTVMUJTUIBUUIFFYUFOEFE4&SFJOGPSDFTBOEFYUFOETUIFNVMUJEJT DJQMJOBSZTDPQFPG4&*OGBDU UIFSFBSFTFWFSBMXBZTJOXIJDI4&JTNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZ JODMVEJOH O 4&TZTUFNTBSFCVJMUJONBOZEJﬀFSFOUBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTEFGFOTF BFSPTQBDF USBOT QPSUBUJPO DPOTUSVDUJPO FOFSHZQMBOUT NFEJDJOF PSHBOJ[BUJPOT FUD O "OZHJWFO4&TZTUFNUZQJDBMMZSFQSFTFOUTNVMUJQMFEJTDJQMJOFTJOJUTDPNQPOFOUT O 4&NPEFMT JODMVEJOHNBUIFNBUJDBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNNPEFMT DVUBDSPTTPSTVQQPSU NVMUJQMFEJTDJQMJOFT O ThF 4& PG UIF GVUVSF DBO CF FYQFDUFE UP QBSUOFS XJUI PS BU MFBTU VTF LOPXMFEHF QSP WJEFE CZ UIF WBSJPVT TVQQPSUJOH EJTDJQMJOFT PG 4& JODMVEJOH 44 $44 BOE PUIFST UIBU XFMJTUCFMPXBOEJEFOUJGZNPSFGVMMZJO$IBQUFS*GXFBSFTFSJPVTBCPVUVTJOHIPMJTUJD BQQSPBDIFTUPTPMWFQSPCMFNTJOUIFOFXFYUFOEFE4& XFOFFEUPNPWFCFZPOEQJHFPO IPMFEBOETUPWFQJQFEEJTDJQMJOFT 5P NBLF UIJT NVMUJUVEF PG EJTDJQMJOFT XPSL UPHFUIFS JO B DPIFSFOU GBTIJPO SFRVJSFT TJHOJﬁDBOU VOJﬁDBUJPO

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O Extend? TSE

CSE?

15

Extended and Uniﬁed SE of the Future TSE ........... CSE Provide basis for

First deﬁne extended and uniﬁed science foundation

CSE = Complex Systems Engineering CSS = Complex Systems Science SE = Systems Engineering TSE = Traditional Systems Engineering

Figure 1.1

New Extended and Uniﬁed SE Science Foundation Traditional sciences Extend Life/social sciences – CSS – Physics – Biology – Chemistry – Psychology – Materials science – Sociology –... – Organization theory – Economics . . . Unify General systems science; Computation; Mathematics

Need for extended and uniﬁed SE science foundation.

)PXEPFTUIF4&DPNNVOJUZSFTQPOEUPUIJTFWJEFOUOFFE 0VSBOTXFSJTJMMVTUSBUFEJO'JHVSF *USFﬂFDUTUIFWJFXUIBUTJNQMZBEEJOH$4&UP54&JTOPUBEFRVBUF BTXFJOEJDBUFEBCPWF 4PXIBUJTBCFUUFSXBZUPQSPDFFE -FUTMPPLBUXIBUXFEPIBWF*OBEEJUJPOUPUSBEJUJPOBM EJTDJQMJOFTTVDIBTQIZTJDTBOENBUIFNBUJDT XFIBWFBTFUPGTDJFODFTBOEPUIFSTVQQPSUJOHEJT DJQMJOFTUIBUBSFSFMBUJWFMZNBUVSFBOEBWBJMBCMFGPSTVQQPSUJOHBOFYQBOEFEBOEVOJﬁFE4&44 EFTDSJCFTDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUBSFDPNNPOUPBMMTZTUFNT BOEBMPOHXJUIDPNQVUBUJPOBOENBUI FNBUJDTGPSNTUIFVOJGZJOHGPVOEBUJPO0SHBOJDPSMJGFTPDJBMTDJFODFT TVDIBT$44 CJPMPHZ QTZ DIPMPHZ TPDJPMPHZ PSHBOJ[BUJPOUIFPSZ BOEFDPOPNJDT QSPWJEFLOPXMFEHFPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNT UIBUJTVTFGVMUP4&*GXFDPVMEDPMMFDUBOEVOJGZLOPXMFEHFGSPNUIFTFTDJFODFTJOUPBDPIFSFOU TDJFODFPG4& PSNPSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZBTDJFODFPGBMMQPUFOUJBM4&TZTUFNT UIBUXPVMEQSPWJEFBHPPE GPVOEBUJPOGPSFWPMWJOHBOFYUFOEFEBOEVOJﬁFE4&

Speciﬁc Requirements List for New SE Foundation #BTFEPOUIFHFOFSBMDIBMMFOHFTBOEUIFJTTVFTSBJTFEJOUIFDIBQUFSUIVTGBS XFDBOEFﬁOFBMJTUPG SFRVJSFNFOUTGPSBGPVOEBUJPOPGUIFGVUVSF4&"OFOBCMJOHGPVOEBUJPOGPSBVOJﬁFE4&TIPVME TBUJTGZUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTMJTUFEJO5BCMF$PMVNOJOEJDBUFTBKVEHNFOUPGXIJDISFRVJSFNFOUT 54&TBUJTﬁFTTVCTUBOUJBMMZ 4 PSQBSUJBMMZ 1 'PSUIFNBKPSJUZPGSFRVJSFNFOUTOPUTBUJTﬁFECZ 54& UIFSFBTPOJTUIFVTFPGUIFNFDIBOJTUJDNPEFMPGTZTUFNT 54&BQQFBSTUPBUMFBTUQBSUJBMMZTBUJTGZNPTUPGUIFTFSFRVJSFNFOUT#VUUIFIPMFTBSFTJHOJﬁ DBOUPSHBOJD IZCSJE DIBOHF BOEVOJﬁFEBQQSPBDIBSFMBSHFHBQT

Response: Model-Oriented SE Science ThF4NVUTRVPUFHJWFOBUUIFTUBSUPGUIJTDIBQUFSXBTUBSHFUFEUPiUIFNBJOQSPCMFNTPGTDJFODFBOE QIJMPTPQIZ FUIJDT BSU BOEBMMJFETVCKFDUTw 4NVUT Y )PXFWFS UIFRVPUFDBOBMTPCFJOUFS QSFUFEBTBHPPETVNNBSZPGUIFDVSSFOUTJUVBUJPOGBDJOH4&EFQJDUFEJOUIJTDIBQUFSUIFTZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOHUFNQMFPGUIFGVUVSF XIJMFJUXJMMCFCVJMUMBSHFMZPGUIFPMEQSPWFONBUFSJBMT XJMMSFRVJSF OFXBOEBNQMFSGPVOEBUJPOTJOUIFMJHIUPGUIFJNNFOTFFYUFOTJPOPGPVSJOUFMMFDUVBMIPSJ[POT

16 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science Table 1.1

Requirements of a Future SE Foundation

No.

Requirement

1 2 3

Support mechanistic characteristics of systems Support organic and agent characteristics of systems Support a hybrid mix of traditional and complex or sociotechnical systems in multiple disciplines (people and machines) in a seamless way, including characteristics in common to both TS and CS, and characteristics in which TS and CS differ Support a mix of matter, energy, and information elements in systems (i.e., a mix of conceptual and physical elements in systems) in a seamless way, including the dominant role of information and computation Support scale-up and scale-down of systems, and multiple scales in a single system, to include a variety of scale viewpoints Support arbitrary, fuzzy, and uncertain system boundaries Support the modeling of the interaction of a system with its environment, to anticipate mutual adaptation and side effects Facilitate precision, minimalism, and simplicity Support formal and informal approaches Be ﬂexible, adaptable, and extensible, and evolve as needed Facilitate incorporation and use of knowledge and experience Support appropriate mass collaboration in systems engineering, including innovation and mechanisms for intellectual property Support multiple views and perspectives of a given system or class of systems Support tensions, dualities, contradictions, contrasts, and paradoxes in a uniﬁed way that includes both their separation and their integration; in the manner of yin-yang principles Support balance of simplicity and complexity: everything should be as simple as possible, but no simpler; recognize imperative of complexity Support balance of commonality and variability: Find everything in common but do not force one-size-ﬁts-all; recognize imperative and beneﬁts of diversity Support balance of stability and change: ﬁnd everything that is stable but do not force false stability; recognize imperative and beneﬁts of change Support clear communication among all SE stakeholders but recognize that not all clear communication is explicit; support both explicit and implicit communication Support clear articulation of problems and solutions Support analysis of alternatives Support uncertainty in speciﬁcations Support SE management by providing clear communications and analysis via appropriate management models Support the engineering modeling process; automate as much of it as possible Provide a uniﬁed approach to organizing and harnessing the knowledge from the array of disciplines supporting SE

4

5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14

15 16 17 18

19 20 21 22 23 24

TSE Satisﬁes? S

S

P

P P S S

S

P S

P

P S P P P

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O

17

8FDBTUUIJTUBTLJOUFSNTPGEFﬁOJOHBO4&TDJFODF 4&4 ThFBQQSPBDIXFUBLFJTXIBUXF DBMMNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPO .0

TPUIFOBNFPGPVSQSPQPTFEGPVOEBUJPOJTNPEFMPSJFOUFETZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH TDJFODF PS .04&4 *U JT JOUFOEFE UP QSPWJEF UIF iOFX BOE BNQMFSw GPVOEBUJPOT .04&4EFQJDUTBGVUVSFTUBUFPGBTDJFODFPG4& 4&4

XIFSF4&IBTUIFFYQBOEFETDPQFEFTDSJCFE JOUIJTDIBQUFS BOECPUIUIF4&4BOEUIF4&BSFNBUVSFThFQVSQPTFPG.04&4JTUPTBUJTGZUIF SFRVJSFNFOUTJEFOUJﬁFEJOUIFQSFWJPVTTFDUJPO ThFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPSBTQFDUTPG.04&4BSFJOUSPEVDFEBOECSJFﬂZEJTDVTTFEJOUIJTTFDUJPO UIFZBSFBEESFTTFENPSFGVMMZJOUIFSFNBJOJOHDIBQUFSTPGUIFCPPL"MTPEFTDSJCFEJOUIJTTFDUJPO JTUIFSBUJPOBMFGPS.04&4BOEQPUFOUJBMBVEJFODFTPG.04&4

Scope and Basic Aspects .04&4 JT EFQJDUFE IFSF JO UXP XBZT 'JSTU UIF TDPQF PG UIF DPNQPTJUF .04&4 JT TIPXO JO 'JHVSF 4FDPOE UIF JUFNT JO UIF ﬁHVSF BSF FMBCPSBUFE BOE EFTDSJCFE BT B TFU PG .04&4 BTQFDUT

Scope of MOSES ThJTDIBQUFSIBTEJTDVTTFEUIFFYUFOTJPOPGTDPQFJOUIFUZQFTPGTZTUFNTUIBU4&JTBUUFNQUJOH UPFOHJOFFS)PXFWFS UIFUPUBMTDPQFPG4& BOEUIFDPSSFTQPOEJOHTDPQFPGBO4&TDJFODF HP CFZPOEUIFTZTUFNTUIBUBSFFOHJOFFSFE'JHVSFTVNNBSJ[FTUIFTDPQFPG.04&4ThFTZTUFNT

Systems Taxonomy

Modeling Scope

1 SE Application Domains (D1…Dn)

Collective actualization space Dn

Model Space

Problem space TS/CS diﬀerent in kind

2a

Traditional systems 3a

2b

Complex systems

TS/CS diﬀerent in degree

3b Complex

Traditional

Deﬁne need

Complex

4 Traditional

Highest level system

All SE application domains…

TS is special case

5

Characteristics of all SE systems Traditional and complex

6

Characteristics of all systems

Indivisible unit Model of individual system or component

Universal model

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure Solution domain

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

Produce solution

Deployment

Satisfy need

Solution/system space

Systems taxonomy partitions SE systems and shows traditional and complex systems relations Collective actualization space includes all SE and management processes, artifacts, contexts Problem space includes all application domains SE supports and in which systems are deployed Model Space contains all engineering and management artifacts (as models) Solution/system space includes all solutions/systems produced by actualization processes

Figure 1.2

Composite MOSES map.

Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization – Language/notation – Universe of discourse

e

D7

Ti m

D6

Composition

D5

C – om – Kin mo Ca d ni te s zat go io rie n s

D1 D2 D3 D4

18

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

UBYPOPNZPOUIFMFGUTIPXTUIFTDPQFPGTZTUFNTBEESFTTFE XIJMFUIFNPEFMJOHTDPQFPOUIFSJHIU TIPXTUIFTDPQFPGNPEFMTBOEUIFNPEFMJOHDPOUFYU"TQFDJﬁDMJOLCFUXFFOUIFUXPJTUIBUUIF TZTUFNTUBYPOPNZTIPXTUIFWBSJFUZPGTZTUFNTUIBUTIPXVQJOUIFTZTUFNTQBDFPOUIFSJHIUThF TZTUFNTUBYPOPNZJODPSQPSBUFTBMMTZTUFNTPGJOUFSFTUUP4& CPUIUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZT UFNTThFUBYPOPNZBMTPTIPXTDBUFHPSJFTPGTZTUFNTSBOHJOHGSPNTQFDJﬁDBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT TVDIBTUSBOTQPSUBUJPOPSEFGFOTF UPUIFNPTUHFOFSBMDBUFHPSZPGBMMTZTUFNTEFﬁOFECZ44 ThFNPEFMJOHTDPQFDPNQSJTFTTFWFSBMTQBDFT0OFTQBDFJTUIFPWFSBMMDPMMFDUJPOPGFOUJUJFT SFRVJSFEUPFOHJOFFSUIFEFTJSFETZTUFN.BSUJO DBMMTUIJTTQBDFUIFSFBMJ[BUJPOTZTUFNXF DBMMJUUIFDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDFThFFOUJUJFTDBOJODMVEFPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBOEQFPQMF GBDJMJ UJFT FRVJQNFOU NBUFSJBMT QPMJDJFT TUBOEBSET QSPDFTTFT NFUIPET UPPMT BOEJOGPSNBUJPO4FDPOE JTUIFQSPCMFNTQBDF UIFFOWJSPONFOUJOXIJDIBQSPCMFNBQQFBST4&PGUFOFOHJOFFSTBTZTUFNJO SFTQPOTFUPBQSPCMFNJOTPNFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOBOEJOTPNFPQFSBUJPOBMFOWJSPONFOUPSDMBTT PGFOWJSPONFOUT ThJSEJTUIFNPEFMTQBDF BOPSHBOJ[FESFQPTJUPSZPGBMMFOHJOFFSJOHBOENBOBHFNFOUBSUJ GBDUTPSEPDVNFOUT JO.04&4 NPEFMT UIBUGFFEJOUPPSSFTVMUGSPNUIFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT ThFNPEFMTQBDFEPFTOPUJODMVEFUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFPSTPMVUJPOTQBDF CVUJUEPFTJODMVEFNPEFMT PGUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFBOENPEFMTPGTPMVUJPOTJOUIFTPMVUJPOTQBDF BTXFMMBTNPEFMTPGUIFDPM MFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDFBOENPEFMTPGPUIFSNPEFMTJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF'PVSUIJTUIFTPMVUJPO PSTZTUFNTQBDF XIJDIDPOUBJOTBTPMVUJPO UZQJDBMMZBTZTUFN EFQMPZFEUPTBUJTGZBOFFEThF ﬁGUITQBDFJTUIFFOWJSPONFOUJOXIJDIUIFTZTUFNJTEFQMPZFE XIJDIJTDMPTFMZSFMBUFEUPUIF QSPCMFNTQBDFCFDBVTFUIFTZTUFNJTEFQMPZFEUPTPMWFUIFQSPCMFN)PXFWFS UIFEFQMPZNFOU TQBDFBMTPJODMVEFTBMMFOUJUJFTUIBUJOUFSBDUXJUIUIFEFQMPZFETZTUFNBOEUIFFOUJUJFTSFRVJSFE UP PQFSBUF NBOBHF TVTUBJO BOE FWPMWF UIF TZTUFN ThF TZTUFN XIFO EFQMPZFE DIBOHFT UIF QSPCMFNFOWJSPONFOU /PUFUIBUUIFMJOFTEFTJHOBUFEi%FﬁOFOFFE wi1SPEVDFTPMVUJPO wBOEi4BUJTGZOFFEwBSFOPU BSSPXTThJTNFBOTUIBUUIFTFRVFODFJOXIJDIUIFZPDDVSJTOPUDPOTUSBJOFE4PNFUJNFT BOFFE ESJWFTBTPMVUJPOCVUPUIFSUJNFT UFDIOPMPHZPﬀFSTBTPMVUJPOCFGPSFUIFOFFEJTJEFOUJﬁFE ThFNPEFMJOHTDPQFJO'JHVSFJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIFDPODFQUPGXIPMFTZTUFNTNPEFMJOHBT EFﬁOFECZBXPSLJOHHSPVQBU*/$04& 3JOH

BOEXJUIUIFDPMMFDUJPOPGTZTUFNTJOUIF TDPQFPG4&EFﬁOFECZ.BSUJO BTUIFTFWFOTBNVSBJ

Aspect Descriptions ThFJUFNTJO'JHVSFBSFOPXGVSUIFSFMBCPSBUFEBTBTFUPGBTQFDUTPG.04&4*OBEEJUJPO UIF DIBQUFS T XIFSFFBDIBTQFDUJTEJTDVTTFEJONPSFEFUBJMJTJOEJDBUFEThFBTQFDUTBSFJUFNJ[FEJO 5BCMF BMPOHXJUIUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTUIBUFBDITBUJTﬁFT &YQBOEFEDPODFQUTPGTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOH"OVNCFSPGTVQQPSUJOHTDJFODFT JODMVEJOH44 $44 BOEDPNQVUJOHTDJFODF DVUBDSPTTOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNT XIJDIMFBETUPUIFDPODFQU PGBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODFBTXFMMBTOBUVSBMTDJFODF$4&BUUFNQUTUPFOHJOFFSPSJOﬂVFODFUIPTFTZTUFNT UIBUJODMVEFQFPQMFBOEPUIFSBHFOUT XIJDIDVUTBDSPTTOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMFMFNFOUTBOEMFBET UP UIF DPODFQUPG FOHJOFFSJOHOBUVSBM BOE BSUJﬁDJBM DPNQPOFOUT JOUP NJYFE PS IZCSJE TZTUFNT ThJTUPQJDJTEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJO$IBQUFSThFFYQBOEFETDPQFJTBEESFTTFECZBOPUIFS.04&4 BTQFDU DPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPO XIJDIJTEJTDVTTFECFMPX .PEFMPSJFOUBUJPO EFTDSJCFENPSFGVMMZJO$IBQUFS JTBQSPNJOFOUGFBUVSFPG.04&4 BOE DPOTJTUTPGTFWFSBMDPNQPOFOUT ThFTZTUFNTUBYPOPNZJTEFWFMPQFEBOEEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O Table 1.2

19

Basic Aspects of MOSES

Aspect of MOSES Expanded and uniﬁed taxonomy of systems, including TS and CS Expanded and uniﬁed supporting disciplines Expanded scope of science and engineering, especially relative to natural vs. artiﬁcial systems, driven by SS, CSS, and CSE Model orientation: –Artifacts of SE and all supporting disciplines are models –Whole systems modeling: problem, model, solution, actualization spaces –Model space: dimensions: self-similar repeating patterns; scope includes models in all spaces, across full systems taxonomy, in all supporting disciplines, and in SE –Modular decoupled concepts –Uniﬁed speciﬁcation approach: external, internal; common info types –Exploit software and computation as unifying bridge

Reqmts Satisﬁed 1, 2, 3, 14, 15 11, 24 2, 3, 24

1, 2, 3, 4, 11, 20, 24 7, 24 5, 10, 11, 13, 16, 17, 18, 20, 24

8, 10 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 8, 9, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19, 21, 24 3, 4, 7, 23, 24

Collective actualization: –Actualization as a technical and social process: model vs. 2, 8, 12, 18 speciﬁcation –Management as part of actualization: Management as engineering 22 –Actualization process: opportunistic; support for change 12, 23

ThFCBTJDDPODFQUJTUIBUBSUJGBDUTPGBMMFOHJOFFSJOH TDJFODF NBUI DPNQVUJOH BOEPUIFS TVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFTUISPVHIPVUUIFTZTUFNTUBYPOPNZBSFDPOTJEFSFEUPCFNPEFMT 8IPMFTZTUFNTNPEFMJOHBDPNQMFUFUSFBUNFOUPG4&DPOTJTUTPGNPEFMJOHUIF1SPCMFN TQBDF .PEFMTQBDF 4PMVUJPOTQBDF BOE"DUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF XIJDIJTXIFSFNPEFMJOH FOHJOFFSJOH NBOBHFNFOU BOETFMGPSHBOJ[JOHQSPDFTTFTFYJTUThFTFTQBDFTBOEUIFJSCBTJD SFMBUJPOTIJQTBSFTIPXOJO'JHVSF ThF.PEFMTQBDFJTUIFDFOUSBMGPDVTPG.04&4*UJTTUSVDUVSFECZUIFEJNFOTJPOTPG DPNQPTJUJPO XIPMFoQBSU

DPNNPOJ[BUJPO HFOFSBMoTQFDJﬁD

DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO MBO HVBHFBOEDPODFQUT

BOEUJNF TUBCJMJUZBOEDIBOHF

BMPOHXJUIUIFDSPTTDVUUJOHDPODFQU PGWJFX*UDPOUBJOTNPEFMTJOBMMTQBDFT BDSPTTUIFGVMMTZTUFNTUBYPOPNZ JOBMM4&BOE TVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT*USFQSFTFOUTBLOPXMFEHFCBTFPG4&BOEBMMTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT JEFOUJﬁFEJO$IBQUFS*UTTUSVDUVSFJTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS BOEBTQFDUTPGJUBSFEFUBJMFE JO$IBQUFSTUISPVHI6MUJNBUFMZ UIFWJTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFJTUIBUJUXJMMCFTVC TUBOUJBMMZBVUPOPNJDPSTFMGNBOBHJOHTFMGMFBSOJOH TFMGBEBQUJOH TFMGDPSSFDUJOH .PEVMBSEFDPVQMFEDPODFQUT.04&4JTIJHIMZNPEVMBS$PODFQUTUIBUBSFPGUFODPVQMFE TVDIBTIJFSBSDIZBOEDPOUSPM BSFEFDPVQMFEJO.04&4. ThFTFBSFEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS 6OJﬁFETQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDI.04&4EFﬁOFTBDPNNPOBQQSPBDIUPTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPG NPEFMTUIBUBQQMJFTUISPVHIPVUUIFTZTUFNUBYPOPNZBOEUISPVHIPVUUIFNPEFMTQBDF ThFSFBSFUXPQSJNBSZNPEFMUZQFTFYUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBMThFBQQSPBDIBOEUIFDPNNPO TFUPGJOGPSNBUJPOGPSFBDIUZQFBSFEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFSThFTQFDBQQSPBDIJTBMTP

20

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science Table 1.3 Elements of Collective Actualization

Enterprise Produced System

Engineering

Autonomy

EEM

EA

enterprise engineering/management

enterprise autonomy

SE

SA

system engineering

system autonomy

JEFOUJﬁFEJOUIF.PEFMTQBDFJO'JHVSFThFBSSPXJOEJDBUFTUIBUUIFJOUFSOBMFYUFSOBM TQFDJﬁDBUJPOUZQFTBSJTFGSPNUIFTUSVDUVSFPGUIF$PNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPO &YQMPJUTPGUXBSFBOEDPNQVUBUJPO.04&4FYQMPJUTUIFSPMFT FYUFOTJPO CSJEHJOH BOE BWBJMBCMFNPEFMT JODMVEJOHBHFOUNPEFMT JOUIFTPGUXBSFBOEDPNQVUBUJPOBSFB BTEJT DVTTFEJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEiThF#SJEHF*OGPSNBUJPO $PNQVUBUJPO 4PGUXBSFwThJTJT BUIFNFUIBUBQQFBSTJOOVNFSPVTQMBDFTJOUIFCPPL JODMVEJOHUIFSPMFPGTPGUXBSFJO QBSUJBMMZBVUPOPNPVTTZTUFNT $PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOJTEJTDVTTFEIFSF ﬁSTUJOUFSNTPGTUSVDUVSFBOEUIFOJOUFSNTPGQSP DFTT ThF TUSVDUVSF PG DPMMFDUJWF BDUVBMJ[BUJPO DPOTJTUT PG UIF FMFNFOUT JO 5BCMF $PMMFDUJWF BDUVBMJ[BUJPO BEESFTTFT CPUI FOUFSQSJTF BOE QSPEVDFE TZTUFN CPUI FOHJOFFSJOH BOE BVUPOPNZ ThFUBCMFSFWFBMTXBZTJOXIJDI.04&4FYUFOETUSBEJUJPOBMNBOBHFNFOUBOETZTUFNTFOHJOFFS JOH BOEIPXUIFZSFMBUFUPFBDIPUIFS &OUFSQSJTFJTBHFOFSBMJ[FEUFSNGPSNBOBHFEFOUJUZBUBOZTDBMF*UJTJOUFOEFEUPJODMVEFOPU POMZPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBOEQSPKFDUT CVUBMTPNBOZPUIFSUZQFTTVDIBTTPDJBMHSPVQT TPDJFUJFT TPDJBM OFUXPSLT NVMUJPSHBOJ[BUJPOBM QBSUOFSTIJQT PS BMMJBODFT PS NVMUJOBUJPOBM DPBMJUJPOT ThF UFSN iNBOBHFEFOUJUZ wBOEUIFSFGPSFiFOUFSQSJTF wJTOPUSFTUSJDUFEUPBNBOBHFNFOUTUZMFPGIJFSBSDIJ DBMDPOUSPM*UBMTPBENJUTBTUZMFPGDPNQMFUFBVUPOPNZPSTFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPO PSBOZXIFSFCFUXFFO UIFUXP"TJNQMFBOEDPNNPOVTFPGFOUFSQSJTFJTUIBUJUJTBQSPKFDUUPQSPEVDFBTZTUFN BOE UIFQSPKFDUJTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBMBSHFSFOUFSQSJTFDBMMFEBOPSHBOJ[BUJPO'PSFYBNQMF #PFJOHBTBO PSHBOJ[BUJPOTFUTVQBQSPKFDUUPEFTJHOBOEQSPEVDFUIFBJSDSBGUTZTUFN8FVTFUIJTFYBNQMF UPJMMVTUSBUFUIFEFﬁOJUJPOTPGUIFUBCMFFMFNFOUT O 1SPEVDFETZTUFNJOUIFUBCMFNFBOTBTZTUFNUIBUJTCFJOHFOHJOFFSFEPSQSPEVDFECZUIF FOUFSQSJTF. ThFBJSDSBGUJTBQSPEVDFETZTUFN O &OHJOFFSJOH JOHFOFSBM BTEFﬁOFEJO$IBQUFS

JTUIFTZTUFNBUJDQSBDUJDFPGBHFOUTUBL JOHQVSQPTFGVMBOEDPOTUSBJOFEBDUJPOUPBDIJFWFBTZTUFNPGBDFSUBJODMBTTXJUIDFSUBJO EFTJSFEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT*O5BCMF UXPDMBTTFTPGTZTUFNBSFCFJOHFOHJOFFSFEFOUFSQSJTF BOEQSPEVDFETZTUFNQSPKFDUBOEBJSDSBGU O &OUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOHNBOBHFNFOU &&. JTUIFBQQMJDBUJPOPGTDJFODFCBTFENBOBHFNFOU LOPXMFEHFUPBOFOUFSQSJTFThFOBNFPGUIFSPMFQFSGPSNJOH&&.DBOCFFOUFSQSJTFFOHJ OFFSPSNBOBHFS*OUIF#PFJOHQSPKFDU &&.JTUIFQPSUJPOPGUIFQSPKFDUNBOBHFE PSJOﬂVFODFECZUIF#PFJOHQSPKFDUNBOBHFNFOUUFBN O 4ZTUFNFOHJOFFSJOH 4& JTFOHJOFFSJOHBQQMJFEUPUIFQSPEVDFETZTUFN/PUFUIBUUIJT4& CPYJO5BCMFJTBTVCTFUPGUIFMBSHFSTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHSPMFUIBUJTUIFTDPQFPGUIJT

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O

21

CPPLBOEUIBUJODMVEFTBMMUIFFMFNFOUTPG5BCMF*OUIF#PFJOHQSPKFDU UIF4& CPYJTUIFQPSUJPOPGUIFBJSDSBGUFOHJOFFSJOHQFSGPSNFEPSJOﬂVFODFECZUIFTZTUFN FOHJOFFSJOHUFBN O "VUPOPNZJTDIBSBDUFSJ[FECZTFMGEFﬁ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ﬂFDUBDIBOHFUPUSBEJUJPOBMNBOBHFNFOU OBNFMZ UIFBEEJUJPO PGBVUPOPNPVTFMFNFOUTPGFOUFSQSJTFTUSVDUVSFBOECFIBWJPS*OTUFBEPGBNBOBHFSPSFOUFSQSJTF FOHJOFFSNBLJOHBMMFOUFSQSJTFNBOBHFNFOUEFDJTJPOT UIFEFDJTJPOTBSFOPXTIBSFEPSTQMJUThF FOUFSQSJTFDPNQPOFOUTUIFNTFMWFTNBLFTPNFEFDJTJPOTSFHBSEJOHUIFJSCFIBWJPS UIFJSSPMFJOUIF FOUFSQSJTF BOEIPXUIFFOUFSQSJTFJTPSHBOJ[FEBOEPQFSBUFTThFFOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSPSNBOBHFS OPXTIBQFTBOEJOﬂVFODFTSBUIFSUIBOEJDUBUFT*OBEEJUJPO UIF&&QBSUPG&&.JTJOUFOEFEUP FNQIBTJ[FNPSFTZTUFNBUJDNBOBHFNFOUCBTFEPOTDJFODF JODMVEJOHNBOBHFNFOUTDJFODF PSHB OJ[BUJPOBMUIFPSZ BOEDPNNVOJUZWFUUFECFTUQSBDUJDFQBUUFSOTThJTEPFTOPUNFBOUIBUJOUVJUJPO BOEQFSTPOBMFYQFSJFODFBSFOPUVTFEJO&&. PSJO4& *UNFBOTUIBUUIFJOUVJUJPOBOEQFSTPOBM FYQFSJFODFBSFCFUUFSTVQQPSUFEBOEHSPVOEFE4FFBMTPUIFEJTDVTTJPOPGIFVSJTUJDTCFMPX $PMMFDUJWFMZ 4&BOE4"SFﬂFDUBDIBOHFUP54&BOBMPHPVTUPUIFDIBOHFJOUSBEJUJPOBMNBOBHF NFOU OBNFMZ UIFBEEJUJPOPGBVUPOPNPVTFMFNFOUTPGTZTUFNEFTJHOPSCFIBWJPS*OTUFBEPGBTZTUFN FOHJOFFSNBLJOHBMMTZTUFNEFTJHOEFDJTJPOT UIFEFDJTJPOTBSFOPXTIBSFEPSTQMJUThFTZTUFNDPNQP OFOUTUIFNTFMWFTNBLFTPNFEFDJTJPOTSFHBSEJOHUIFJSCFIBWJPS UIFJSSPMFJOUIFTZTUFN BOEIPXUIF TZTUFNJTPSHBOJ[FEBOEPQFSBUFT. ThFTZTUFNFOHJOFFSOPXTIBQFTBOEJOﬂVFODFTSBUIFSUIBOEJDUBUFT #PUIFOHJOFFSJOHBOEBVUPOPNZJOWPMWFQVSQPTFGVMBDUJWJUZThFSFBTPOUIFBVUPOPNZBDUJWJUZ JTOPUDPOTJEFSFEFOHJOFFSJOHPGUIFQSPEVDFETZTUFNJTUIJTUIFQVSQPTFGVMBDUJWJUZPGFOHJOFFSJOH JODMVEFTUIFIPMJTUJDBOEFNFSHFOUCFIBWJPSBOEQSPQFSUJFTPGUIFQSPEVDFETZTUFNThFQVSQPTF GVMBOEBVUPOPNPVTBDUJWJUZPGUIF4" POUIFPUIFSIBOE JTUZQJDBMMZEJSFDUFEUPJUTPXOCFIBWJPS BOEJUTJOUFSBDUJPOXJUIPUIFSDPNQPOFOUTJOUIFTZTUFNThJTEJTUJODUJPOJNQMJFTUIBUBOFOUJSFMZ TFMGPSHBOJ[JOHTZTUFNFNFSHFTPSJTQSPEVDFEXJUIOPFOHJOFFSJOHBDUJWJUZJUJTBMMGSPNBVUPOP NPVTCFIBWJPS 4" "UUIFPUIFSFYUSFNF JGOPBVUPOPNPVTCFIBWJPSJTQSFTFOU JUJTFRVJWBMFOUUP USBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOH. ThFTBNFBSHVNFOUBQQMJFTUPUIFEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFO&&.BOE&" "OPUIFSJNQPSUBOUBTQFDUPGCPUI&&.BOE4&JTUIFVTFPGIFVSJTUJDTThFTFBSFHFOFSBMSVMFT PGUIVNCCBTFEPOJOTJHIUBOEFYQFSJFODFUIBUIBWFOPUCFFOPS DBOOPUCFSFEVDFEUPTQFDJﬁD FOHJOFFSJOHSVMFT#VUUIFZDBOCFTIBSFEBDSPTTBDPNNVOJUZ)FVSJTUJDTBSFBOJOUFHSBMQBSUPG TZTUFNTBSDIJUFDUJOHJO3FDIUJO BOE.BJFSBOE3FDIUJO *O.04&4 TPNFIFVSJT UJDTDBOCFDBQUVSFEJONPEFMTBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOT"OFYBNQMFPGBIFVSJTUJDJO3FDIUJO JTi4VDDFTTJTEFﬁOFECZUIFCFIPMEFS OPUCZUIFBSDIJUFDUwThJTJTBUMFBTUQBSUJBMMZDBQUVSFEJOUIF 2VBMJUZPG&YQFSJFODFJUFNJOUIFFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS

22 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

$PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOBTQSPDFTT.04&4BEESFTTFTUIFTFBEEJUJPOBMTVQQPSUJOHDPODFQUT PGBDUVBMJ[BUJPO "DUVBMJ[BUJPOBTBTPDJBMBOEBUFDIOJDBMQSPDFTTUIFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTJOWPMWFTNBOZTUBLF IPMEFSTPSBHFOUTPGEJﬀFSFOUUZQFT JODMVEJOHCPUIIVNBOBOETPGUXBSFBHFOUT"DIJFWJOHB DPNNPOPSTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGBNPEFMBNPOHBHFOUTJTJNQPSUBOU#VUJOBNBUVSF EPNBJO NVDI PG UIF TIBSFE VOEFSTUBOEJOH CFUXFFO LOPXMFEHFBCMF BHFOUT JT JNQMJDJU BOE EPFTOPUOFFEUPCFXSJUUFOEPXO*O.04&4 UIFDPNQMFUFTIBSFENFBOJOHPGBNPEFMJT DBMMFEBTQFDJﬁDBUJPO BOEUIFFYQMJDJUQBSUPGUIBUTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTUIFNPEFM*O'JHVSF NPEFMTBSFDPOUBJOFEJOUIF.PEFMTQBDFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTFYJTUJOUIFMBSHFS$PMMFDUJWFBDUVBM J[BUJPOTQBDF.PSFDPNQMFUFEFﬁOJUJPOTPGNPEFMBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPO BOEBEJTDVTTJPOPGUIFJS SFMBUJPO BSFHJWFOJO$IBQUFS ThFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTEFﬁOFEJO.04&4IBTUXPQSJNBSZEJﬀFSFODFTGSPN54&FOHJOFFS JOHQSPDFTTFT'JSTU UIF.04&4QSPDFTTSFMBYFTNPTUPGUIFDPOTUSBJOUTPGUIFUSBEJUJPOBMMJOFBS XBUFSGBMM BOEJOTUFBEQSPNPUFTBOPQQPSUVOJTUJDQSPDFTTUIBUXPSLTPOBOZBTQFDUPGUIFQSPC MFNUIBUDBOHFUUSBDUJPO4FDPOE UIF.04&4QSPDFTTBDDPNNPEBUFTDIBOHFBOEFWPMVUJPO "MUIPVHINPTUPGUIFTVCKFDUNBUUFSPG.04&4JOUIJTCPPLJTJOUFOEFEUPBQQMZUPBOZTZTUFN JOUIFQVSWJFXPGFYUFOEFE4& $IBQUFSTQFDJﬁDBMMZBEESFTTFT4&BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTFTBOE FYQMPSFTUIFBCPWFDPODFQUTJONPSFEFUBJM .PTUJGOPUBMMUIFFMFNFOUTPGUIJTDPNQSFIFOTJWF.04&4TPMVUJPOBMSFBEZFYJTUJOTPNFGPSN )PXFWFS TPNFBTTFNCMZJTSFRVJSFEJOUFHSBUJPOBOEVOJﬁDBUJPOPGUIFQBSUTJTOFFEFE

Why MOSES? 8IZEPXFTVHHFTUUIBU.04&4JTBHPPEBOTXFSUPUIFOFFETPG4& 8IBUWBMVFEPFTJUIBWF "QSFMJNJOBSZBSHVNFOUJTHJWFOIFSF BOEUIFSFNBJOEFSPGUIFCPPLJTJOUFOEFEUPNBLFBNPSF EFUBJMFEDBTF ThFCPUUPNMJOFJTUIFVOJﬁDBUJPOPGUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT4&0UIFSTIBWFOPUFE UIFJSEJﬀFSFODFT BOETPNFIBWFSFDFOUMZCFHVOUPEFﬁOF$4&NFUIPET CVUOPPOFUPPVSLOPXM FEHFIBTEFﬁOFEBXBZUPCSJOH54&BOE$4&UPHFUIFSJOUPBDPNNPO4&GSBNFXPSL ThJTCPPLDMBJNTUIBUMFBWJOHUIFUXPQBSUTPG4&TFQBSBUFBOEEJTKPJOUJTOPUBDDFQUBCMF"T BSHVFE JO UIF TVCTFDUJPO FOUJUMFE i(FOFSBM $IBMMFOHF 6OJGZ w UIF SFBTPO JT UIBU NPTU TZTUFNT BEESFTTFECZTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTJOUIFGPSFTFFBCMFGVUVSFBSFBIZCSJEDPNCJOBUJPOPGUSBEJUJPOBM BOEDPNQMFYFMFNFOUTXPWFOUPHFUIFS%FﬁOJOH$4&NFUIPETJTBOJNQPSUBOUBOEOFDFTTBSZTUFQ JOTVQQPSUJOHUIFFYQBOEFE4&CVUJUJTPOMZUIFﬁSTUTUFQThFTFDPOETUFQJTUPSFDPODJMFBOE CSJOHUPHFUIFS54&BOE$4&JOUPBTJOHMFXIPMF4& XIJMFOPUMPTJOHUIFTUSFOHUITBOEVOJRVFOFTT PGFBDI. ThBUJTUIFPCKFDUJWFPGUIJTCPPL 0OFNJHIUBTTVNFUIBUUIJTJTBEBVOUJOHKPCCVUUIFKPCJTNBEFFBTJFSCZUIFGBDUUIBUUIF TPMVUJPOQJFDFTGPSTVDIBGPVOEBUJPOBMSFBEZFYJTU8FTJNQMZIBWFUPSFDPHOJ[FUIFBQQSPQSJBUF QJFDFT BOEPSHBOJ[FUIFNQSPQFSMZJOUPBDPIFSFOUGPVOEBUJPOThFBQQSPQSJBUFTPMVUJPOQJFDFTXF JEFOUJGZJODMVEFBGFXCBTJDQSJODJQMFT NPEFMJOHEJNFOTJPOT UIFCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFPGTZTUFNT TDJFODFBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT BQQSPBDIFTUPVODFSUBJOUZBOEDIBOHF LOPXMFEHFGSPNPUIFSDPO USJCVUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT BOEBQQSPBDIFTUPTQFDJﬁDBUJPO #FDBVTFPGUIFRVBMJUZBOEQFEJHSFFPGUIFTPMVUJPOQJFDFTUIBUBMSFBEZFYJTU BOECFDBVTF PGUIFﬂFYJCJMJUZBOEFYUFOTJCJMJUZPGUIFNPEFMPSJFOUFEGPVOEBUJPOSFTVMUJOHGSPNUIFXBZ

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O

23

XFIBWFPSHBOJ[FEUIFQJFDFT XFCFMJFWFUIBUUIFGPVOEBUJPOXFEFTDSJCFJOUIJTCPPLXJMM CFBCMFUPTFSWFUIFGVUVSF4&GPSBOFYUFOTJWFQFSJPEPGUJNF BOEDFSUBJOMZJOBNVDINPSF SPCVTUXBZBOEGPSBMPOHFSQFSJPEPGUJNFUIBOXPVMEUIFBQQSPBDIPGTJNQMZBEEJOHUPUIF DVSSFOU4& ThFSFJTBOBTQFDUPGUIFKPCUIBUJTEBVOUJOHThFWPMVNFPGNBUFSJBMSFQSFTFOUJOHLOPXMFEHFJO UIFWBSJPVTEJTDJQMJOFTUIBUTVQQPSU4&NFBOTUIBUPOFCPPLDBOOPUCFHJOUPDPWFSJUBMM)PXFWFS FWFOJGXFDPVMETPNFIPXDBQUVSFBMMUIBULOPXMFEHFJOPOFMBSHFCPPL XFXPVMEOPUDIPPTFUP EPJU8IZ #FDBVTFUIBUDPNQPTJUFCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFTIPVMECFDBQUVSFEBOEPSHBOJ[FEJOUIF QSPQPTFEPOMJOFSFQPTJUPSZUIBUXFDBMMUIFNPEFMTQBDFThFSFGPSF UIJTCPPLEPFTOPUBUUFNQUUP EFﬁOFUIFDPOUFOUTPGUIFMBSHFCPEZPGLOPXMFEHF3BUIFS JUJOEJDBUFTUIFPWFSBMMTDPQFBOEUIFO GPDVTFTPOUIFFMFNFOUTPGNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOENPEFMTQBDFUIBUVOJGZBOECSJOHFWFSZUIJOH UPHFUIFS.VDIPGUIFCPPLJTPOUIFTUSVDUVSJOHWBSJBCMFTBOEEJNFOTJPOTUIBUPSHBOJ[FUIFNPEFM TQBDF*UEFTDSJCFTJMMVTUSBUJWFFYBNQMFTCVUEPFTOPUQPQVMBUFUIFNPEFMTQBDF*UJTBGSBNFXPSL GPSVOJGZJOHUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGUIFGVMMSBOHFPGUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNTJOUIJTTQBDF

Potential Audiences 8IP DPVME SFBTPOBCMZ VTF UIF .04&4 BQQSPBDI ThFSF BSF TFWFSBM QPTTJCMF BVEJFODFT 0OF JT QSBDUJDJOHTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTXIPXBOUUPJODPSQPSBUFNPSFTZTUFNTUIJOLJOHJOUPUIFJSQSBDUJDF PSXIPXBOUUPFYUFOEUIFJSXPSLUPJODMVEFNPSFDPNQMFYPSHBOJDTZTUFNTBOEUPVOEFSTUBOEIPX UIFJSFOHJOFFSJOHDBOCFJOUFHSBUFEXJUINPSFGBNJMJBSQSBDUJDFThFBQQSPBDIEPFTOPUSFRVJSF BMMOFXNFUIPETBOEUPPMTSBUIFS JUJTJOUFOEFEUPIFMQUIFQSBDUJDJOHTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTFFNPSF DMFBSMZIPXEJﬀFSFOUFMFNFOUTPG4&UJFUPHFUIFS BOEUPVTFUIFJSUPPMTBOENFUIPETJOBXBZUIBU JTNPSFFYUFOTJCMF BEBQUBCMF BOETVTUBJOBCMF )PXFWFS UIF BQQSPBDI EPFT JOUSPEVDF TPNF JNQPSUBOU DIBOHFT GPS UIJT BVEJFODF 'JSTU JU FYUFOETUIFSFQFSUPJSFPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTUPJODMVEFQFPQMF PSHBOJ[BUJPOT BOETPDJBMPSQPMJUJDBM FOUJUJFT4FDPOE JUQSPWJEFTJNQSPWFNFOUTJODVSSFOUQSBDUJDF JOBSFBTXIFSFDVSSFOUQSBDUJDFJT HFOFSBMMZJOBEFRVBUFFTQFDJBMMZJOIPXDIBOHFJTVOEFSTUPPEBOEBEESFTTFEThJSE JUQSPNPUFT BOEGBDJMJUBUFTUIFNPWFNFOUGSPNSFMJBODFPOEPDVNFOUTBTUIFQSJNBSZBSUJGBDUTPG4&UPUIF VTFPGNPEFMTBTUIFQSJNBSZBSUJGBDUT BOEUIFDBQUVSFPGNPEFMTBTCPUIBO4&BOE4&4CPEZPG LOPXMFEHF #P, JOBNBDIJOFQSPDFTTBCMFSFQPTJUPSZThFTFDIBOHFTXJMMUBLFTPNFUJNFUPNBUF SJBMJ[FCVUUIFZXJMMBﬀFDUTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTXIPBEPQUB.04&4CBTFEBQQSPBDI "TFDPOEBVEJFODFJTNBOBHFST EFDJTJPONBLFST QPMJDZNBLFST PQFSBUJPOTSFTFBSDIFST BOE JOEVTUSJBMFOHJOFFSTXIPXBOUUPVOEFSTUBOEIPXUIF4&PGUIFGVUVSFDBOQSPWJEFNPSFTVQQPSU JODMVEJOHBVUPNBUFETVQQPSU GPSNBOBHJOHQSPKFDUTBOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOTThFCPPLTVQQPSUTUIJT BVEJFODFCZQSPNPUJOHUIFVTFPGNPEFMTUIBUSFQSFTFOUNBOBHFNFOULOPXMFEHF NBOBHFNFOU QBUUFSOT CFTUQSBDUJDF BOENFUSJDT*UFYUFOET4&TVQQPSUUPIJHIFSMFWFMT UPMFBEFSTPGFOUFSQSJTFT UIBUJODMVEFDJUJFT NJMJUBSZGPSDFT BOEFWFOTPDJFUJFT CZCSJOHJOHFOHJOFFSJOHQSBDUJDFUPCFBSPO TPDJBMBOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMJTTVFT*UBMTPTVQQPSUTUIFDPODFQUPGTFMGNBOBHJOH XIJDISFEVDFTUIF NBOBHFNFOUMPBE "UIJSEBVEJFODFJT4&NFUIPEPMPHJTUT XIPDBOVTFUIFBQQSPBDIBTBGSBNFXPSLUPEFﬁOF OFYUHFOFSBUJPO4&NFUIPETBOEQSPDFTTFT CBTFEPOUIFGPVOEBUJPOT FYUFOTJPOT PSJFOUBUJPO BOE VOJﬁDBUJPOPG.04&4ThFZIBWFBDPNNPOPSJFOUBUJPOBOEBTNBMMOVNCFSPGVOJGZJOHDPO DFQUT BSUJGBDUT BOEQSJODJQMFTPOXIJDIUPCVJME BOEUIFJSNFUIPETXJMMCFXFMMHSPVOEFE "GPVSUIBVEJFODFJTQSPGFTTPSTBOETUVEFOUTJOVOEFSHSBEVBUFPSHSBEVBUF4&DPVSTFT XIP DPVMEVTFUIJTCPPLBTBTVQQMFNFOUPSBTBQSJNBSZUFYUGPSBHSBEVBUFTFNJOBSPOUIFTDJFODF GPVOEBUJPOTPG4&PSUIFGVUVSFPG4&

24

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

"ﬁGUIBVEJFODFJTSFTFBSDIFST XIPDBOVTFUIFBQQSPBDIBTBTPVSDFPGSFTFBSDIUPQJDTThFSF BSFNBOZBSFBTXIFSFSFTFBSDIBOEFYQFSJNFOUBUJPOBSFOFFEFEUPCFUUFSVOEFSTUBOEUIFGVMMTDPQF PGUIFOFX4& JODMVEJOHIPXUPFOHJOFFS$4 DPNNPOTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJOGPSNBUJPO WBSJBCMFTQFDJ ﬁDBUJPO JOGPSNBUJPO IPX UP FYQMPJU UIF CBTJD FYUFSOBMJOUFSOBM QBUUFSOT EJﬀFSFOU EJNFOTJPOT SFMBUJPOTBNPOHEJNFOTJPOT BTFUPGDPNNPOWJFXUZQFT EPNBJOTQFDJﬁ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ﬁDEPNBJOPOUPMPHJFT BOEUIPTFXIPXBOUUPGPSNBMJ[FUIFPOUPMPHZPG.04&4 O 4&TUBOEBSETCPEJFTXIPXBOUUPﬁSNVQUIFGPVOEBUJPOTPGFYJTUJOHTUBOEBSET PSXIP XBOUUPPSJFOU4&TUBOEBSETNPSFUPXBSEBSUJGBDUTNPEFMTBOEEFDSFBTFUIFDPOTUSBJOUTPO QSPDFTTFT O 4&BTTPDJBUJPOTBOEMFBEFSTXIPBSFJOUFSFTUFEJODPNQJMJOHBEJHJUBM#P,UIBUJODMVEFT UIFTDPQFPGBMM4&EJTDJQMJOFTBOEJTJOUIFGPSNPGNPEFMT BOEXIPIBWFDPOTJEFSBCMF QBUJFODF CFDBVTFUIJTXJMMUBLFBXIJMF O 3FQPTJUPSZTQFDJBMJTUTJOUFSFTUFEJOUIFDIBMMFOHFPGCVJMEJOHBXPSLJOH4&SFQPTJUPSZUIFZ DPVMETVQQPSUUIPTFJOUFSFTUFEJODPNQJMJOHUIF4&#P,EFTDSJCFEBCPWF

Organization of the Book ThJTDIBQUFSIBTEFTDSJCFEUIFDIBMMFOHFTBOEPQQPSUVOJUJFTJO4& BOEUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTGPSB TDJFODFGPVOEBUJPOGPSBOFYUFOEFEBOEVOJﬁFE4&ThFSFNBJOJOHDIBQUFSTTQFMMPVUUIF.04&4 BQQSPBDI JO TPNF EFUBJM ThF TVCKFDU PG FBDI DIBQUFS JT JOEJDBUFE JO 'JHVSF XIJDI JT UIF DPNQPTJUFNBQGSPN'JHVSFXJUIDIBQUFSOVNCFSTPWFSMBJE$IBQUFSEFTDSJCFTUIFSFMBUJPO CFUXFFOTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOHJO.04&4 JODMVEJOHUIFSPMFTPGOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODF *UBMTPEFTDSJCFTUIFTZTUFNTTDJFODFVOJWFSTBMFMFNFOUPGUIFGPVOEBUJPO$IBQUFS BGUFSHJWJOHB ﬂBWPSPG.04&4JOBOFYUFOEFEFYBNQMF JOUSPEVDFTTPNFPGUIFDPSFDPODFQUTBOEEFﬁOJUJPOT $IBQUFSGPMMPXTVQPOUIJTXJUIBEFTDSJQUJPOPGUIFLFZGFBUVSFTPG.04&4 JODMVEJOHNPEFM PSJFOUBUJPO $IBQUFS HPFT JOUP UIF DPOUFYU BOE TUSVDUVSF PG UIF NPEFM TQBDF UIF TUSVDUVSFE SFQPTJUPSZPGLOPXMFEHFPGBMM4&SFMBUFEEJTDJQMJOFT4VDDFFEJOH$IBQUFSTUISPVHIQSFTFOU NPSF EFUBJMT PG FBDI EJNFOTJPO PS TUSVDUVSJOH WBSJBCMF PG UIF NPEFM TQBDF DPNQPTJUJPO DPN NPOJ[BUJPO DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO UJNF BOEWJFXT$IBQUFSQSFTFOUTUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDI XIJDIVOJﬁFTBMMNPEFMTJOUPUXPUZQFTJOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBM$IBQUFSNBQTUSBEJUJPOBMBSUJ GBDUTUP.04&4BOEEJTDVTTFTFMFNFOUTPG.04&4VOJﬁDBUJPO$IBQUFSEFTDSJCFTUIFVOJﬁFE .04&4DPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTFT

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O Systems Taxonomy

3

1 SE Application Domains (D1…Dn) D6

D7

Dn Problem space

TS/CS diﬀerent in kind

2a

Traditional systems 3a

TS/CS diﬀerent in degree

3b Complex

Traditional Traditional

6

6 Deﬁne need

TS is special case

Characteristics of all systems

Model Space

Indivisible unit Model of individual system or component

7 Universal model

Characteristics of all SE systems Traditional and complex 2

5

Highest level system

All SE application domains…

Complex

4

5

2b

Complex systems

13

Composition

D5

12

Collective actualization space

C – om – Kin mo C a d ni te s zat go io rie n s

D1 D2 D3 D4

Modeling Scope

4

25

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating 11 internal/external structure Solution domain

8

Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization – Language/notation – Universe of discourse Views exist within and across all the dimensions

9

e

m

Ti

10

Produce solution

Deployment

Satisfy need

Solution/system space

Systems taxonomy partitions SE systems and shows traditional and complex systems relations Collective actualization space includes all SE and management processes, artifacts, contexts Problem space includes all application domains SE supports and in which systems are deployed Model Space contains all engineering and management artifacts (as models) Solution/system space includes all solutions/systems produced by actualization processes

Figure 1.3

Composite map elements allocated to chapters.

References "ckoﬀ, R. 1999. "ckoﬀ’T#FTU)JT$MBTTJD8SJUJOHTPO.BOBHFNFOU/FX:PSL+PIO8JMFZ4POT "YFMSPE 3BOE.$PIFO)BSOFTTJOH$PNQMFYJUZ0SHBOJ[BUJPOBM*NQMJDBUJPOTPGBScientiﬁc 'SPOUJFS /FX:PSL#BTJD#PPLT #BS:BN :8IFO4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH'BJMT5PXBSE$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH *OU$POG 4ZTUFNT .BO$ZCFSOFUJDT o *&&&1SFTT 1JTDBUBXBZ /+ #FOZVT +#JPNJNJDSZ*OOPWBUJPO*OTQJSFECZ/BUVSF/FX:PSL)BSQFS$PMMJOT #MBODIBSE # BOE 8 'BCSZDLZ 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH BOE "OBMZTJT UI FE &OHMFXPPE Cliﬀs, /+ 1SFOUJDF)BMM #MVNTUFJO ""O03NJTTJPOBSZTWJTJUTUPUIFDSJNJOBMKVTUJDFTZTUFN0QFSBUJPOT3FT o #PDDBSB /.PEFMJOH$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT/FX:PSL4QSJOHFS7FSMBH #PSSB &.BLJOHUIFQBQFSIPXBOJOGSBSFETQFDUSVNUFMFTDPQFDPVMECFCVJMUPOUIF.PPO/BUVSF YW #SBIB % "".JOBJ BOE:#BS:BN &ET $PNQMFY&OHJOFFSFE4ZTUFNT4DJFODF.FFUT5FDIOPMPHZ /FX:PSL4QSJOHFS #VFEF %The EOHJOFFSJOH%FTJHOPG4ZTUFNT.PEFMTBOE.FUIPET/FX:PSL+PIO8JMFZ4POT $*..4$FOUFSGPS*OUFHSBUJWF.VMUJTDBMF.PEFMJOHBOE4JNVMBUJPO $*..4

$BMJGPSOJB*OTUJUVUF PG5FDIOPMPHZIUUQXXXDJNNTDBMUFDIFEVXIBUJTDJNNTIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

$4$4 6OJW PG .JDIJHBO $FOUFS GPS UIF 4UVEZ PG $PNQMFY 4ZTUFNT i"CPVU UIF 4DJFODF PG $PNQMFYJUZwIUUQDTDTVNJDIFEVBCPVUDPNQMFYJUZIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

%BT 4 ( 3PTF . ;JFHMFS $ 1JDDPOBUUP BOE + &MMFOCPHFO "SDIJUFDUVSFT BOE 4JNVMBUJPOT GPS /BOPQSPDFTTPS 4ZTUFNT *OUFHSBUFE PO UIF .PMFDVMBS 4DBMF $IBQUFS JO *OUSPEVDJOH .PMFDVMBS &MFDUSPOJDT )FJEFMCFSH4QSJOHFS7FSMBH

26 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science %P% %FQBSUNFOU PG %FGFOTF 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH 'VOEBNFOUBMT 'PSU #FMWPJS 7" %FGFOTF "DRVJTJUJPO6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT %ÚSOFS %The -PHJDPG'BJMVSF3FDPHOJ[JOHBOE"WPJEJOH'BJMVSFJO$PNQMFY4JUVBUJPOT/FX:PSL .FUSPQPMJUBO#PPLT 'FJMFS 1 3 (BCSJFM + (PPEFOPVHI 3 -JOHFS 5 -POHTUBﬀ 3 ,B[NBO . ,MFJO - /PSUISPQ % 4DINJEU ,4VMMJWBO BOE,8BMMOBV6MUSB-BSHF4DBMF4ZTUFNTThe 4PGUXBSF$IBMMFOHFPG UIF'VUVSF$.64&* 'FSSJT 5-+B4PNF&BSMZ)JTUPSZPG4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOHTJO*3&1VCMJDBUJPOT QBSU The PSPCMFNUI*OU4ZNQ*/$04&o+VOF 4BO%JFHP $" 'FSSJT 5-+C4PNF&BSMZ)JTUPSZPG4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOHTJO*3&1VCMJDBUJPOT QBSU The 4PMVUJPOUI*OU4ZNQ*/$04&o+VOF 4BO%JFHP $" 'FSSJT 5-+&BSMZ)JTUPSZPG4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH 1BSU TJO7BSJPVT&OHJOFFSJOH4PVSDFT UI*OU4ZNQ*/$04&o+une, The NFUIFSMBOET (JMFT + *OUFSOFU FODZDMPQBFEJBT HP IFBE UP IFBE /BUVSF o 4FF BMTP /BUVSFT SFTQPOTFUP#SJUBOOJDBTPCKFDUJPOT&ODZDMPQBFEJB#SJUBOOJDBBOE/BUVSFBSFTQPOTF.BSDI IUUQXXXOBUVSFDPNQSFTT@SFMFBTFT#SJUBOOJDB@SFTQPOTFQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

(PPEF )BOE3.BDIPM 4ZTUFN&OHJOFFSJOH"O*OUSPEVDUJPOUPUIF%FTJHOPG-BSHF4DBMF4ZTUFNT /FX :PSL.D(SBX)JMM )FOLFM +BOE4.BVSFSThe FDPOPNJDTPGTZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZ.PMFDVMBS4ZTUFNT#JPM o IUUQXXXOBUVSFDPNNTCKPVSOBMWOQEGNTCQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)PMMBOE + "EBQUBUJPO JO /BUVSBM BOE "Stiﬁcial 4ZTUFNT "O *OUSPEVDUPSZ "OBMZTJT XJUI "QQMJDBUJPOT UP #JPMPHZ $POUSPM BOE "Stiﬁcial *OUFMMJHFODF $PNQMFY "EBQUJWF 4ZTUFNT $BNCSJEHF ." .*5 1SFTT )PMMOBHFM &BOE%8PPET+PJOU$PHOJUJWF4ZTUFNT'PVOEBUJPOTPG$PHOJUJWF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH#PDB 3BUPO '-$3$1SFTT )VIOT .BOE.4JOHI$PHOJUJWFBHFOUT*OUFSOFU$PNQVUJOH *&&& o *&&&B"EPQUJPOPG*40*&$4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH4ZTUFN-JGF$ZDMF1SPDFTTFT*&&& /FX:PSL*&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ *&&&C*&&&4UBOEBSEGPS"QQMJDBUJPOBOE.BOBHFNFOUPGUIF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH1SPDFTT *&&&4UE /FX:PSL*&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ */$04& *OUFSOBUJPOBM $PVODJM PO 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH */$04&

4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH 7JTJPO W 0DUPCFS */$04& */$04& 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH )BOECPPL W 4FBUUMF 8" */$04& *OUFSOBUJPOBM $PVODJMPO4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH *40*&$ 4ZTUFNT BOE TPGUXBSF FOHJOFFSJOH 4ZTUFN MJGF DZDMF QSPDFTTFT *40*&$ OEFE.BSDI ,FBTMJOH +7JEFPMFDUVSFPOTZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZ .BSDI ,FFO "The CVMUPGUIF"NBUFVS)PX5PEBZT*OUFSOFU*T,JMMJOH0VS$VMUVSF/FX:PSL%PVCMFEBZ ,FFOFZ +BOE78BEF5PXBSET1PMJDZ%FDPNQPTJUJPOGPS"VUPOPNJD4ZTUFNT(PWFSOBODFCZ"QQMZJOH #JPMPHJDBMMZ*OTQJSFE5FDIOJRVFT/FUXPSL0QFSBUJPOTBOE.BOBHFNFOU4ZNQPTJVN8PSLTIPQT o "QSJM*&&& Qo ,FQIBSt, J. and D. Chess. 2003. The vision of autonomic computing. *&&&$PNQVUFS o ,ossiakoﬀ, A. and 8/4XFFU4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH1SJODJQMFTBOE1SBDUJDF)PCPLFO /+8JMFZ ,VNBS % / 3BNBLSJTIOBO 3 )FMN BOE . 1PUUT "MHPSJUINT GPS TUPSZUFMMJOH *&&& 5SBOT ,OPXMFEHFBOE%BUB&OH o ,VSBT .BOE#8IJUF&OHJOFFSJOH&OUFSQSJTFT6TJOH$PNQMFY4ZTUFN&OHJOFFSJOH1SPD*/$04& *OU4ZNQ 3PDIFTUFS /: +VMZ .BJFS .BOE&3FDIUJOThe ASUPG4ZTUFNT"SDIJUFDUJOH OEFE #PDB3BUPO '-$3$1SFTT .BKJE 4BOE,"INFE1PTU%JTBTUFS$PNNVOJDBUJPOT"$PHOJUJWF"HFOU"QQSPBDI4FWFOUI*OU $POGPO/FUXPSLJOH*$/o"QSJM Qo .BOOJOH "4UPSZUFMMJOHBTB5PPMPG5FDIOJDBM&YQMBOBUJPO*NQSPWJTBUJPO3JTLTBOE#eneﬁts. 1SPD *&&&*OU1SPGFTTJPOBM$PNNVOJDBUJPO$POGo4FQUFNCFS Qo

Opportunities and Challenges for Systems Engineering O 27 .BSHBMJPU . #JPNJNJDSZ BOE 'V[[Z .PEFMJOH " .BUDI .BEF JO )FBWFO *&&& $PNQVUBUJPOBM *OUFMMJHFODF.BHB[JOF .BSUJO +4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH(VJEFCPPL"1SPDFTTGPS%FWFMPQJOH4ZTUFNTBOE1SPEVDUT#PDB3BUPO '-$3$1SFTT .BSUJO +The 4FWFO4BNVSBJPG4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH%FBMJOHXJUIUIF$PNQMFYJUZPG*OUFSSFMBUFE 4ZTUFNT 1SFTFOUFE BU UIF UI "OOV *OU 4ZNQ *OU $PVODJM PO 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH */$04& 5PVMPVTF 'SBODFo+VOF .D$BSUIZ + "TDSJCJOH .FOUBM 2VBMJUJFT UP .BDIJOFT *O 1IJMPTPQIJDBM 1FSTQFDUJWFT JO "Stiﬁcial *OUFMMJHFODF .3JOHMF &E#SJHIUPO 6,)BSWFTUFS1SFTT .D(SFHPS %The )VNBO4JEFPG&OUFSQSJTF"OOPUBUFE&EJUJPO/FX:PSL.D(SBX)JMM 0SJHJOBM FEJUJPOQVCMJTIFE .D(SBX)JMM

.FSSJBN8FCTUFS.FSSJBN8FCTUFS0OMJOF%JDUJPOBSZBOEThesaurVTIUUQXXXNFSSJBNXFCTUFSDPN "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

.JMMFS +-JWJOH4ZTUFNT8JOPU $06OJWFSTJUZ1SFTTPG$PMPSBEP 0SJHJOBMMZQVCMJTIFE

.*5 $FOUFS GPS &OHJOFFSJOH 4ZTUFNT 'VOEBNFOUBMT 3FTFBSDI IUUQDFTGNJUFEVSFTFBSDIIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

/BUVSF-JGFJTXIBUZPVNBLFJU &EJUPSJBM /BUVSF /BUVSF &EJUPSJBM &MFDUSJD TLJFT )PX UP OBWJHBUF B ﬂight QBUI UP HSFFOFS BJS USBWFM /BUVSF /&$4*/FX&OHMBOE$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT*OTUJUVUFIUUQXXXOFDTJPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

/3$1SF.JMFTUPOF"BOE&BSMZ1IBTF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH"3FUSPTQFDUJWF3FWJFXBOE#eneﬁts GPS'VUVSF "JS 'PSDF "DRVJTJUJPO $PNNJUUFF PO 1SF.JMFTUPOF " 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH /BUJPOBM 3FTFBSDI $PVODJM8BTIJOHUPO %$The /BUJPOBM"DBEFNJFT1SFTTIUUQXXXOBQFEVDBUBMPHIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

3BP "4BOE.1(eorgeﬀ. i.PEFMJOHSBUJPOBMBHFOUTXJUIJOB#%*BSDIJUFDUVSF wJO1SPDOE*OU $POGPO1SJODJQMFTPG,OPXMFEHF3FQSFTFOUBUJPOBOE3FBTPOJOH4BO.BUFP $".PSHBO,BVGNBOO QQ 3FDIUJO &4ZTUFNT"SDIJUFDUJOH$SFBUJOH#VJMEJOH$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT&OHMFwood Cliﬀs, NJ: PSFOUJDF)BMM 3FHJTUSZ3FHJTUSZPG4UBOEBSE#JPMPHJDBM1BSUT.*5IUUQQBSUTNJUFEVSFHJTUSZJOEFYQIQ.BJO@1BHF "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

3JOH + %JTDPWFSJOH UIF TUSBUFHZ GPS XIPMF TZTUFN NPEFMJOH 1SFTFOUFE BU UI "OOVBM $POG 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH3FTFBSDI $4&3

3FEPOEP#FBDI $"o"QSJM 3JUUFM ) BOE . 8FCCFS %JMFNNBT JO B HFOFSBM UIFPSZ PG QMBOOJOH 1PMJDZ 4DJFODFT o IUUQXXXVDUDOFUNXFCCFS3JUUFM 8FCCFS %JMFNNBT (FOFSBM@5IFPSZ@PG@1MBOOJOHQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

3PHFST 33eﬂections on ionic liquids. /BUVSF +VOF Qo 3PVTF 8&OHJOFFSJOHDPNQMFYTZTUFNTJNQMJDBUJPOTGPSSFTFBSDIJOTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH *&&&5SBOT 4ZTUFNT .BOBOE$ZCFSOFUJDT 1BSU$"QQMJDBUJPOTBOE3FWJFXT o 3PVTF 8$PNQMFY&OHJOFFSFE 0SHBOJ[BUJPOBM/BUVSBM4ZTUFNT*TTVFT6OEFSMZJOHUIF$PNQMFYJUZ PG 4ZTUFNT BOE 'VOEBNFOUBM 3FTFBSDI /FFEFE UP "EESFTT These *TTVFT (FPSHJB *OTUJUVUF PG 5FDIOPMPHZ .BSDI 4BHF "1BOE+&"SNTUSPOH +S*OUSPEVDUJPOUP4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH/FX:PSL8JMFZ 4BMFIJF .BOE-5BIWJMEBSJ"VUPOPNJD$PNQVUJOH&NFSHJOH5SFOETBOE0QFO1SPCMFNT1SPD %FTJHO BOE &WPMVUJPO PG "VUPOPNJD "QQMJDBUJPO 4PGUXBSF %&"4 4U -PVJT .0 .BZ /FX:PSL"$.1SFTT Qo 4DIÚO %",OPXJOHJOBDUJPOThe OFXTDIPMBSTIJQSFRVJSFTBOFXFQJTUFNPMPHZ$IBOHF /PWFNCFS %FDFNCFS Q o IUUQXXXFODZDMPQFEJBDPNQSJOUBCMFBTQY JE( "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

4'*4BOUB'F*OTUJUVUFIUUQXXXTBOUBGFFEV "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

4JNPO ) The 4DJFODFT PG UIF "Stiﬁcial, SE FE $BNCSJEHF ." .*5 1SFTT 0SJHJOBMMZ QVCMJTIFE

4NVUT +)PMJTNBOE&WPMVUJPO-POEPO.BDNJMMBO

28

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

4VTTNBO +$PMMFDUFE7JFXTPO$PNQMFYJUZJO4ZTUFNT.*5&4%8PSLJOH1BQFST4FSJFT &4% 81 .BZ1SPD&OHJOFFSJOH4ZTUFNT%JWJTJPO*OUFSOBM4ZNQPTJVN$BNCSJEHF ."&OHJOFFSJOH4ZTUFNT%JWJTJPO .*5 QoIUUQFTENJUFEV814&4%*OUFSOBM 4ZNQPTJVN%PDT&4%81&4%*OUFSOBM4ZNQPTJVNQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

5BQTDPUU % BOE " 8JMMJBNT 8JLJOPNJDT )PX .BTT $PMMBCPSBUJPO $IBOHFT &WFSZUIJOH 1PSUGPMJP 1FOHVJO#PPLT 5BZMPS 'The 1SJODJQMFTPGScientiﬁc .BOBHFNFOU QVCMJTIFEJO/PSUPO-JCSBSZ CZBSSBOHFNFOU XJUI)BSQFS3PX 1VCMJTIFST CZ88/PSUPO$PNQBOZ /FX:PSL 8JLJQFEJB8JLJQFEJBIUUQFOXJLJQFEJBPSHXJLJ8JLJQFEJB "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

Chapter 2

Systems Science Context 4DJFOUJTUTTUVEZUIFXPSMEBTJUJTFOHJOFFSTDSFBUFUIFXPSMEUIBUIBTOFWFSCFFO ThFPEPSFWPO,BSNBO "EBQUJOH WPO ,BSNBOT PCTFSWBUJPOT JU NBZ CF TBJE UIBU FOHJOFFSJOH TDJFODF JT UIF TUVEZPGUIBUQBSUPGUIFXPSMEXIJDIIBTCFFODSFBUFECZNBO .JDIBFM(SJﬃO

Highest level system

Indivisible Unit

Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

Deﬁne need

Composition

Systems taxonomy Modeling scope 4JODFUIFJOUFOUPGUIJTCPPLJTUPEFﬁOFBTDJ 1 SE Application Domains (D1...Dn) Collective actualization space FODF PG 4& BMUIPVHI NPTU PS BMM PG UIF QJFDFT D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn Problem space Model Space BMSFBEZFYJTU

XFTUBSUMBZJOHPVU.04&4XJUI 2a TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b All SE Traditional systems Complex systems B DIBQUFS PO TDJFODF BOE JUT SFMBUJPO UP FOHJ 3a TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b application domains... Traditional Complex OFFSJOH BOEUIFJSSPMFJOBTDJFODFPG4&4VDI 4 Complex TS is special case BEJTDVTTJPOJTOFDFTTJUBUFECZUIFFYQBOTJPOPG 5Traditional Characteristics of all SE systems and Complex 4&UPJODMVEFPSHBOJDFMFNFOUTTVDIBTIVNBOT 6 Traditional Characteristics of all systems Deployment Solution/system space ThJTFOUBJMTTPNFSFPSJFOUBUJPOJOIPXXFUIJOL BCPVU TDJFODF BOE FOHJOFFSJOH FTQFDJBMMZ XJUI SFHBSEUPOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNTThJTDIBQUFSBEESFTTFTUIFSFPSJFOUBUJPOJOUIFFYQBOEFE 4& DPOUFYU JODMVEJOH UIF SFMBUJPO CFUXFFO TZTUFNT TDJFODF 44 BOE DPNQMFY TZTUFNT TDJFODF $44 *UBMTPJOUSPEVDFTUIFGPVOEBUJPOQPSUJPOPGUIFTZTUFNTUBYPOPNZTIPXOJOEBTIFEPVUMJOF JOUIFMFGUQBSUPGUIFSFEVDFEHSBQIJDBCPWF Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe ofdiscourse discourse Universe of

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

e

m

Ti

Produce solution

Satisfy need

Conceptualization of Science ThJTTFDUJPOQSFTFOUTUIF.04&4WJFXPGTDJFODFJOHFOFSBMBOEJOUSPEVDFTBTFUPGQSFSFRVJTJUF MBXTGPSBTDJFODF

What Is Science? 8FTUBSUXJUITPNFDPNNPOEFﬁOJUJPOTPGTDJFODF 29

30

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O 3BOEPN)PVTF "CSBODIPGLOPXMFEHFPSTUVEZEFBMJOHXJUIBCPEZPGGBDUTPSUSVUITTZTUFNBUJDBMMZ BSSBOHFEBOETIPXJOHUIFPQFSBUJPOPGHFOFSBMMBXTUIFNBUIFNBUJDBMTDJFODFT 4ZTUFNBUJDLOPXMFEHFPGUIFQIZTJDBMPSNBUFSJBMXPSMEHBJOFEUISPVHIPCTFSWBUJPO BOEFYQFSJNFOUBUJPO O .PSSJT ThFTZTUFNBUJDPCTFSWBUJPOPGOBUVSBMFWFOUTBOEDPOEJUJPOTJOPSEFSUPEJTDPWFSGBDUT BCPVUUIFNBOEUPGPSNVMBUFMBXTBOEQSJODJQMFTCBTFEPOUIFTFGBDUT ThFPSHBOJ[FECPEZPGLOPXMFEHFUIBUJTEFSJWFEGSPNTVDIPCTFSWBUJPOTBOEUIBUDBO CFWFSJﬁFEPSUFTUFECZGVSUIFSJOWFTUJHBUJPO O %PSMBOE ThFTZTUFNBUJDPCTFSWBUJPOPGOBUVSBMQIFOPNFOBGPSUIFQVSQPTFPGEJTDPWFSJOHMBXT HPWFSOJOHUIPTFQIFOPNFOB ThFCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFBDDVNVMBUFECZTVDINFBOT O "NFSJDBO)FSJUBHF ThFPCTFSWBUJPO JEFOUJﬁDBUJPO EFTDSJQUJPO FYQFSJNFOUBMJOWFTUJHBUJPO BOEUIFPSFUJ DBMFYQMBOBUJPOPGQIFOPNFOB 4VDIBDUJWJUJFTSFTUSJDUFEUPFYQMBJOJOHBMJNJUFEDMBTTPGOBUVSBMQIFOPNFOB 4VDIBDUJWJUJFTBQQMJFEUPBOPCKFDUPGJORVJSZPSTUVEZ O 4JNPO o /BUVSBMTDJFODFJTLOPXMFEHFBCPVUOBUVSBMPCKFDUTBOEQIFOPNFOB8FBTLXIFUIFS UIFSFDBOOPUBMTPCFiBSUJﬁDJBMwTDJFODFLOPXMFEHFBCPVUBSUJﬁDJBMPCKFDUTBOEQIF OPNFOB<XIFSFBSUJﬁDJBMNFBOT>NBONBEFBTPQQPTFEUPOBUVSBM 4DJFODFJTEFﬁOFECPUIBTBQSPDFTTBOEBTUIFLOPXMFEHFUIBUSFTVMUTGSPNUIBUQSPDFTT4PNF EFﬁOJUJPOTSFTUSJDUTDJFODFUPUIFTUVEZPGOBUVSBMQIFOPNFOBXIJMFPUIFSTEPOPUNBLFTVDIB SFTUSJDUJPO4JNPOFYQMJDJUMZQPTFTUXPDBUFHPSJFTPGTDJFODF OBUVSBMTDJFODFJTLOPXMFEHFBCPVU OBUVSBMPCKFDUTBOEQIFOPNFOB BOE BSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODFJTLOPXMFEHFBCPVUBSUJﬁDJBMPCKFDUTBOE QIFOPNFOB 'PSUIFQVSQPTFTPGUIJTCPPL TDJFODFJTUIFTZTUFNBUJDQSBDUJDFPGPCTFSWJOHQBUUFSOTJOUIFDIBS BDUFSJTUJDTPGFYJTUJOHQIFOPNFOBPSTZTUFNT BOETIBSJOHUIPTFPCTFSWBUJPOTJOTVDIBXBZUIBUUIFZ DBOCFJOEFQFOEFOUMZFYBNJOFEPSSFQMJDBUFE,OPXMFEHFJOBTDJFOUJﬁDﬁFME BUBHJWFOQPJOUJOUJNF JTUIFTFUPGQBUUFSOTUIBUNPTUPGUIFTQFDJBMJTUTJOUIBt ﬁFMECFMJFWFUPCFUSVFBUUIBUQPJOUJOUJNF ThJTEFﬁOJUJPOEFMJCFSBUFMZFNQIBTJ[FTGPVSBTQFDUTPGTDJFODF 0CKFDUJWF0OFBTQFDUPGTDJFODFJTUIBUQIFOPNFOBJOUIFXPSMEIBWFBOPCKFDUJWFFYJTUFODF JOEFQFOEFOUPGXIBUQFPQMFPCTFSWFPSQFSDFJWF 1FSDFQUJWF"OPUIFSBTQFDUJTUIBUIVNBOLOPXMFEHFPGXIBUFYJTUTJOUIFXPSMEJTTIBEFEPS DPMPSFECZXIBUJTQFSDFJWFEWJBUIFﬁWFTFOTFTBOEBVHNFOUFECZWBSJPVTTFOTPSTBOEJOTUSV NFOUT$FOUSBMUPTDJFODFJTUIBUIVNBOTPSPCTFSWFSTQFSDFJWFQBUUFSOTUIBUJT UIFTBNF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPDDVSSJOHJONVMUJQMFDBTFT0CTFSWJOHUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGPOFTJOHMFTZT UFNBUPOFQPJOUJOUJNFPSFWFONVMUJQMFQPJOUTJOUJNF GPSFYBNQMF XPVMEOPUCFTVﬃDJFOU UPFTUBCMJTIBQBUUFSO1BUUFSOTJOUSBEJUJPOBMTDJFODFBSFUZQJDBMMZDBMMFEUIFPSJFTPSOBUVSBM MBXT*OUIJTCPPL BTDJFODFQBUUFSOJTBHFOFSBMNPEFMPGTPNFQBSUPSBTQFDUPGUIFXPSME )PXFWFS JOFBDIDBTF BQBUUFSOJTXIBUPCTFSWFSTTFFPSQFSDFJWF XIJDINBZEJﬀFSGSPN

Systems Science Context

O 31

XIBUBDUVBMMZFYJTUTJOUIFQIFOPNFOBCFJOHPCTFSWFEThPTFEJﬀFSFODFTBSFPGUFOEVFJO QBSUUPQSFFYJTUJOHDPODFQUJPOTPSCFMJFGTBCPVUUIFQIFOPNFOB XIJDINBZTIBQFBOEMJNJU UIFSFTVMUJOHPCTFSWBUJPOT BTEJTDVTTFECZ'FSSJT ThJTTIBQJOHBOEMJNJUJOHNBZCF JOUFSQSFUFEBTOFHBUJWFPSQPTJUJWF0OUIFOFHBUJWFTJEF BQSFDPODFJWFENPEFMPGXIBUJT UIFSFDBOCMJOEUIFPCTFSWFSUP PSEJTUPSUUIFQFSDFQUJPOPG XIBUJTSFBMMZUIFSF BOEUIF PCTFSWBUJPOTXJMMOPUCFWBMJEPSDBOOPUCFVTFEUPWBMJEBUFUIFNPEFM0OUIFQPTJUJWFTJEF UIFTIBQJOHBOEMJNJUTNBZSFﬂFDUBEFMJCFSBUFBOEFYQMJDJUNPEFMJOHDIPJDF EFTDSJCFEJO $IBQUFS XIPTFQVSQPTFJTUPUBLFBDFSUBJOTUBODFUPXBSEPSWJFXPGUIFQIFOPNFOB 4PDJBM ThF TPDJBMBTQFDUPG TDJFODF IBT UXP SFMBUFE DPNQPOFOUT 'JSTU TDJFOUJﬁD LOPXM FEHFJTBDPSQVTPGBHSFFNFOUPSCFMJFGBUBHJWFOQPJOUJOUJNFBNPOHUIFTDJFOUJTUTJO B ﬁFME TVDI BT QIZTJDT PS B TVCﬁFME TVDI BT QBSUJDMF QIZTJDT /PU FWFSZ TDJFOUJTU JO UIF ﬁFMENVTUCFMJFWF CVUBTJHOJﬁDBOUQPSUJPOPGUIFDPNNVOJUZNVTUCFMJFWFJOBUIFPSZ PSNPEFMGPSJUUPCFBDDFQUFEBTTDJFOUJﬁDLOPXMFEHFThJTNFBOTUIBUXIFUIFSBUIFPSZ JT DPOTJEFSFE TDJFOUJﬁD LOPXMFEHF JT OPU B CJOBSZ ZFTOP CVU SBUIFS B DPOUJOVVN UIBU SBOHFT GSPN VOJWFSTBMMZ SFKFDUFE UP VOJWFSTBMMZ BDDFQUFE ThF TPDJBM QSPDFTT PG BSSJWJOH BUUIFTFCFMJFGTJODMVEFTUIFVTVBMIVNBOFMFNFOUTPGTPDJBMJOUFSBDUJPO TVDIBTQFSTPOBM DPOﬂJDUT DPNQFUJUJPO SFQVUBUJPO PSHBOJ[BUJPOBM BﬃMJBUJPO BOE DVMUVSBM EJﬀFSFODFT ThFTF FMFNFOUT IBWF TPNF EFHSFF PG JOﬂVFODF PO TDJFOUJTUT BUUJUVEFT UPXBSE UIFPSJFT ThFTFDPOEDPNQPOFOUPGUIFTPDJBMBTQFDUJTUIBUTDJFOUJTUTPSBHFOUTPUIFSUIBOUIFQSP QPTFSPGBUIFPSZPSNPEFMDBOJOEFQFOEFOUMZFYBNJOFUIFDMBJNBOEﬁOEFWJEFODFUIBU FJUIFSTUSFOHUIFOTPSXFBLFOTUIFDMBJN $IBOHFThFWJFXPGBTDJFOUJﬁDDPNNVOJUZUPXBSEBTDJFOUJﬁDUIFPSZDIBOHFTPWFSUJNF BOETPNFUJNFTPOFUIFPSZJTSFQMBDFECZBOPUIFSUIBUUIFDPNNVOJUZCFMJFWFTJTBCFUUFS NPEFMPGXIBUJTCFJOHPCTFSWFE"XFMMLOPXONPEFMPGDIBOHFJOTDJFOUJﬁDUIFPSZJT ,VIOTEFQJDUJPOPGTDJFOUJﬁDSFWPMVUJPOT ,VIO ,VIOBTTFSUFEBDPNNPOQBUUFSO JOXIJDIBTDJFOUJﬁDUIFPSZ JOUIFGPSNPGBHFOFSBMNPEFMPSQBSBEJHN JTEPNJOBOUPWFS BQFSJPEPGUJNFEVSJOHXIJDIJUJTﬁOFUVOFE BOEUIFOBUTPNFQPJOUJTSFQMBDFEXJUI BOPUIFSUIFPSZUIBUSFQSFTFOUTBEJﬀFSFOUQBSBEJHNTh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hF WJFX PG TDJFOUJﬁD LOPXMFEHF PS UIFPSJFT BT NPEFMT IBT CFFO FYQSFTTFE CZ TPNF TDJFO UJTUTBOEQIJMPTPQIFSTPGTDJFODFPWFSTFWFSBMEFDBEFT JODMVEJOH4UFQIFO)BXLJOH iB 0CTFSWBUJPODBOUBLFBUMFBTUUXPGPSNTEJSFDUPCTFSWBUJPOPSNFBTVSFNFOUPGUIFQBUUFSO BOEJOEJSFDUPCTFS WBUJPOPSNFBTVSFNFOUCZJEFOUJGZJOHBOEPCTFSWJOHJNQMJDBUJPOTPGUIFQBUUFSO*NQMJDBUJPOTBSFJOUIFGPSN PGJNQMJFEPCTFSWBCMFDPOEJUJPOT*GQBUUFSOIPMET UIFOPCTFSWBCMFDPOEJUJPOXJMMCFPCTFSWFEThFUSFOE JOUIFQBTUDFOUVSZJOQIZTJDT GPSFYBNQMF IBTCFFOBXBZGSPNEJSFDUPCTFSWBUJPOBOEUPXBSEFYBNJOBUJPOPG JNQMJDBUJPOT"TUIFPSJFTIBWFCFDPNFNPSFTVCUMF QSPCBCJMJTUJD BOENVMUJEJNFOTJPOBM EJSFDUPCTFSWBUJPOPG QSFEJDUFEQSPQFSUJFTIBTCFDPNFMFTTGFBTJCMF

32

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

UIFPSZJTKVTUBNPEFMPGUIFVOJWFSTF PSBSFTUSJDUFEQBSUPGJU BOEBTFUPGSVMFTUIBU SFMBUFRVBOUJUJFTJOUIFNPEFMUPPCTFSWBUJPOTUIBUXFNBLFw3POBME(JFSFIBTXSJUUFOFYUFOTJWFMZ BCPVUBQIJMPTPQIZPGTDJFODFUIBUJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIFNPEFMTDPODFQUPGTDJFODF4FF (JFSF (JFSF *OBEEJUJPO ThF0YGPSE$PNQBOJPOUP1IJMPTPQIZ )POEFSJDI

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ﬀFSFOUFYQMBOBUPSZNPEFMTThF SFTPMVUJPODBNFMBUFS'FSUJMJ[BUJPOIBTBEVBMTJHOJﬁDBODFUIFUXPPQQPTJOHWJFXTBSFCPUIDPS SFDU'FSUJMJ[BUJPOCFMPOHTUPCPUIGVODUJPOBMBOEFWPMVUJPOBSZCJPMPHZThFNPSFDPNQMFUFNPEFM FNCSBDFTUIFEVBMJUZ ThFNPEFMDPODFQUIBTBMTPCFFOFYUFOEFECFZPOEUIFUSBEJUJPOBMOBUVSBMTDJFODFT*O BTFNJOBSBUUIF6OJWFSTJUZPG&EJOCVSHICSPVHIUUPHFUIFSTDIPMBSTJONBUIFNBUJDT DPNQVUFS TDJFODF FOHJOFFSJOH QIJMPTPQIZ BOETPDJBMTDJFODFTUPEJTDVTTUIFVTFPGNPEFMTJOUIFTPDJBMTDJ FODFT $PMMJOT 8IJMFUIFPWFSBMMGPDVTXBTPOTPDJBMTDJFODFT UXPPGUIFQSFTFOUFEQBQFST )FTTF)BSSÏ BEESFTTFEUIFQSPNJOFOUSPMFPGNPEFMTUIBUIBEFNFSHFEJOUIFOBUVSBM TDJFODFTBOEIPXUIBUSFMBUFTUPUIFJSSPMFJOUIFTPDJBMTDJFODFT ThFWJFXPGUIJTCPPLJTUIBU4&TDJFODFFODPNQBTTFTCPUIOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODFT"MJTU PGTVQQPSUJOHTDJFODFTBOESFMBUFEEJTDJQMJOFTBQQFBSTMBUFSJOUIJTDIBQUFS

Prerequisite Laws +PIO8BSﬁFMEIBTNBEFTFWFSBMDPOUSJCVUJPOTUPUIFBSFBTPGTZTUFNTTDJFODFBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT 0OFDPOUSJCVUJPOJTUIFJEFOUJﬁDBUJPOPGTFWFSBMiMBXTwUIBUNVTUCFGPMMPXFEXIFOEFWFMPQJOH BTDJFODF 8BSﬁFME 8FMJTUUIFMBXTIFSFUIBUBSFNPTUJNQPSUBOUUP.04&4BOECSJFﬂZ EFTDSJCFIPX.04&4BEESFTTFTUIFN

Law of Requisite Variety "TICZ EFﬁOFEUIJTMBXJOUIFDPOUFYUPGDZCFSOFUJDTBOEUIFSFHVMBUJPOPGBTZTUFNThF MBXRVBOUJﬁFTUIFWBSJFUZOFFEFEJOBSFHVMBUPS XIFSFWBSJFUZDBOCFNFBTVSFECZUIFOVNCFSPG QPUFOUJBMTUBUFT5PTVDDFTTGVMMZSFHVMBUFBTZTUFN UIFWBSJFUZPGUIFSFHVMBUPSNVTUCFBUMFBTUBT MBSHFBTUIFWBSJFUZPGUIFSFHVMBUFETZTUFN-BUFS$POBOUBOE"TICZ JEFOUJﬁFEBOJNQMJDB UJPOPGUIJTMBX XIJDIUIFZFYQSFTTFEJOUIFi(PPE3FHVMBUPSwUIFPSFNThFTJNQMFTUPQUJNBM SFHVMBUPSPGBTZTUFNJTBNPEFMPGUIBUTZTUFN JOUIFTFOTFUIBUUIFSFHVMBUPSTBDUJPOTBSFBNBQ QJOHPGUIFTZTUFNTBDUJPOTThJTUIFPSFNBQQMJFTOPUPOMZUPSFHVMBUPSTPGTFQBSBUFTZTUFNT CVU BMTPUPTFMGSFHVMBUJOHPSIPNFPTUBUJDTZTUFNT 8FBQQMZUIJTMBXBOEUIFBTTPDJBUFEUIFPSFNJOUXPXBZT'JSTU JUNPUJWBUFTUIFTDPQFPG .04&4ThFTDPQFPGBOZ4&TDJFODFNVTUCFFRVBMUPPSHSFBUFSUIBOUIFTDPQFPGUIF4&UIBUJU TVQQPSUT#FDBVTFXFBSHVFEJO$IBQUFSUIBU4&JTFYQBOEJOH DBSFNVTUCFHJWFOUPEFﬁOFBO BEFRVBUFTDPQFPG.04&4BTBTVQQPSUJOHTDJFODF8FDMBJNUIBUUIFTDPQFPG.04&4EFﬁOFEJO $IBQUFSTBOEJTTVﬃcJFOU 4FDPOE UIFMBXBOEJUTBTTPDJBUFEUIFPSFNBQQMZUPNPEFMT4QFDJﬁDBMMZ BDPOEJUJPOGPSBDIJFW JOHBEFRVBUFﬁEFMJUZPGBNPEFMUPBTZTUFNJTUIBUUIFNPEFMNVTUSFQSFTFOUBWBSJFUZBTHSFBUBT

Systems Science Context

O 33

UIFWBSJFUZPGUIFTZTUFNJUJTNPEFMJOH CVUPOMZPOUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGJOUFSFTUUPUIFNPEFM $IBQUFSEJTDVTTFTUIFMBUUFSSFTUSJDUJPOGVSUIFS

Law of Gradation ThJTMBX EFﬁOFECZ8BSﬁFME

TUBUFTUIBUBTDJFODFNVTUBDLOPXMFEHFUIBUUIFPCKFDUTJU TUVEJFTJOPVSDBTF TZTUFNTPDDVSBUWBSZJOHEFHSFFTPGDPNQMFYJUZBOETDBMF GSPNTJNQMFTU UPNPTUDPNQSFIFOTJWF BOENVTUTVQQPSUVOEFSTUBOEJOHBUBMMMFWFMTBOETDBMFT ThJTMBXJTBOJNQPSUBOUSFRVJSFNFOUGPSBTDJFODFPGUIFFYQBOEFE4&CFDBVTFJUSFQSFTFOUT UIFSBOHFPGDPNQMFYJUZBOETDBMFEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS.04&4BEESFTTFTUIJTMBXJOUFSNTPG TZTUFNTCZEFﬁOJOHBUBYPOPNZPGTZTUFNTUIBUDPWFSTUIFGVMMSBOHFPGUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFY TZTUFNTBUNVMUJQMFTDBMFT BOEBMMPXTUIJTSBOHFUPCFBDPOUJOVVN*UBEESFTTFTUIFMBXJOUFSNT PGNPEFMTCZEFﬁOJOHBSBOHFGPSFBDITUSVDUVSJOHWBSJBCMFJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF BTEFTDSJCFEJO MBUFSDIBQUFST

Law of Requisite Parsimony ThJTMBX EFﬁOFECZ8BSﬁFME

TUBUFTUIBUBTDJFODFNVTUQSFTFOUJOGPSNBUJPOJOBXBZUIBU QSFWFOUTIVNBOJOGPSNBUJPOPWFSMPBEThJTMBXEFSJWFTGSPN.JMMFST ﬁOEJOHTPOUIFMJNJUT PGIVNBOJOGPSNBUJPOQSPDFTTJOHDBQBDJUZ .04&4BEESFTTFTUIJTMBXVTJOHBCTUSBDUJPOBTBUPPMUPIFMQGPDVTPOJNQPSUBOUJTTVFTBOE JHOPSFUIFSFTU VTJOHWJFXTUPBEESFTTTFMFDUFEDPODFSOT TVQQPSUJOHJNQMJDJUFMFNFOUTPGTZTUFN TQFDJﬁDBUJPOT BOE FYQMPJUJOH BVUPOPNZ JO TZTUFNT "MM UIFTF DPODFQUVBM UPPMT BSF EJTDVTTFE JO TVCTFRVFOUDIBQUFST

Science and Engineering ThFFYQBOTJPOPG4&BOEUIFDPSSFTQPOEJOHTVQQPSUJOHTDJFODFTJOUSPEVDFTPNFEJﬀFSFOUQFSTQFD UJWFTPOTDJFODF FOHJOFFSJOH BOEUIFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOUIFNThFSFGPSF JUJTJNQPSUBOUUPEJTDVTT UIFTFQFSTQFDUJWFT JODMVEJOHTPNFOPOUSBEJUJPOBMSPMFTPGCPUITDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOH BOEXFEP TPJOUIJTTFDUJPO8FTUBSUXJUIBQSFWJFXUIBUTVNNBSJ[FTUIFTFDUJPO BOEUIFOEJTDVTTBOFYUFO TJPOPGDMBTTJDTDJFODFJOUPBOPOUSBEJUJPOBMSPMF UIBUPGTDJFODFPGBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNT4VCTFRVFOUMZ XFQSFTFOUBCSJFGDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPGFOHJOFFSJOH XIJDIJTGPMMPXFECZBOFYUFOTJPOPGDMBTTJD FOHJOFFSJOHJOUPBOPOUSBEJUJPOBMSPMFFOHJOFFSJOHPGOBUVSBMPSIZCSJETZTUFNTThFTFQFSTQFD UJWFTQSPWJEFUIFCBTJTGPSBEJTDVTTJPOPGUIFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOHJOHFOFSBM CFUXFFO44BOE$44 BOECFUXFFO4&4BOE4&

Preview: Scope of Science and Engineering ThFEJTDVTTJPOPGTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOHJOUIFDPOUFYUPGBOFYQBOEFE4&PGUIFGVUVSFSFﬂFDUT BDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPSWJFXUIBUDBMMTGPSSFFYBNJOJOHUIFEFﬁOJUJPOTPGTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOH ThFWJFXFTQPVTFEJOUIJTDIBQUFSBOEUIJTCPPLSFUBJOTUIFFTTFODF UIFDPSF PGTDJFODFBOEFOHJ OFFSJOH XIJMFSFNPWJOHOPOFTTFOUJBMSFTUSJDUJPOTUIBUNBZFYJTU UPBMMPXUIFOFDFTTBSZCSFBEUI PGBQQMJDBUJPOPGCPUI"QSFMJNJOBSZFYUFOTJPOPGTDJFODFXBTEJTDVTTFEJOUIFQSFWJPVTTFDUJPO ThF.04&4WJFXPGUIFFYUFOTJPOPGCPUITDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOHJTEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJOUIJTTFD UJPO5BCMFTVNNBSJ[FTUIFFYUFOTJPOTBOEIPXUIFZDPNQMFNFOUFBDIPUIFS4DJFODFJTGVMMZ

34

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science Table 2.1 Extended Scope of Science and Engineering Natural systems

Artiﬁcial systems

Science

Traditional

Full extension

Engineering

Partial extension

Traditional

FYUFOEFEGSPNUIFUSBEJUJPOBMTDPQFPGOBUVSBMTZTUFNTUPBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNTThBUJT UIFEFﬁOJ UJPOPGTDJFODFBTPCTFSWJOHQBUUFSOTDBOCFBQQMJFEUPBMMUZQFTPGTZTUFNT OBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBM &OHJOFFSJOH IPXFWFS JT POMZ QBSUJBMMZ FYUFOEFE GSPN JUT USBEJUJPOBM TDPQF PG BSUJﬁDJBM TZTUFNT UPOBUVSBMTZTUFNTThFFYUFOUUPXIJDIFOHJOFFSJOHQSPEVDFTOBUVSBMTZTUFNT TVDIBTIVNBOT PSHSPVQT JTOPUJDFBCMZSFEVDFEGSPNUIFFYUFOUGPSBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNTThBUJTSFﬂFDUFEJOUFSNT TVDIBTiJOﬂVFODJOHwBOEiTIBQJOHwSBUIFSUIBOiCVJMEJOHwPSiDSFBUJOHwThBUJTXIZXFVTFUIF CSPBEFSUFSNiBDUVBMJ[BUJPOwJO$IBQUFSSBUIFSUIBOiFOHJOFFSJOHwUPSFﬂFDUUIJTQBSUJBMFYUFOU JOUPUIFOBUVSBMTZTUFNTBSFOB ThFQBSUJBMFYUFOTJPOJTBOPUIFSWJFXPGUIFEJTUJODUJPOTJO5BCMFJO$IBQUFSThFTIBEFE QPSUJPO JO 5BCMF UIBU SFﬂFDUT UIF QBSUJBM FYUFOTJPO JT UIF 4& CPY JO 5BCMF UIF TZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOHXPSLUIBUDBOCFEPOFThFXIJUFPSVOTIBEFEQPSUJPOJO5BCMFJTUIF4"CPYJO 5BCMF UIFOBUVSBMTZTUFNBVUPOPNZ

Natural and Artiﬁcial Science: Distinctions and Parallels 8IFO XF UIJOL PG OBUVSBM WFSTVT BSUJﬁDJBM B DMBTTJD EJTUJODUJPO UIBU DPNFT UP NJOE JT TDJFODF WFSTVTFOHJOFFSJOH8FUFOEUPUIJOLPGTDJFODFBTPCTFSWJOHOBUVSBMUIJOHTBOEFOHJOFFSJOHBT CVJMEJOHBSUJﬁDJBMUIJOHT BTSFﬂFDUFEJOUIFi5SBEJUJPOBMwDFMMTJO5BCMF$MBTTJDFYBNQMFTPG TDJFODFBSFQIZTJDT DIFNJTUSZ BOECJPMPHZ&OHJOFFSTCVJMEBSUJﬁDJBMUIJOHTTVDIBTSBEJPT DBST CVJMEJOHT CSJEHFT BJSDSBGU TIJQT BOEDPNQVUFST#VUJOUIFEFﬁOJUJPOTBCPWF XFEJTDVTTFEUIF QPTTJCJMJUZPGTDJFODFPCTFSWJOHBSUJﬁDJBMUIJOHT0VSEFﬁOJUJPOPGTDJFODFXBTUBSHFUFEUPFYJTUJOH QIFOPNFOBPSTZTUFNT XIJDIBMMPXTUIFTUVEZPGCPUIOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMQIFOPNFOB SFﬂFDU JOH OBUVSBM TDJFODF BOE BSUJﬁDJBM TDJFODF SFTQFDUJWFMZ 8F OPX EJTDVTT TPNF QBSBMMFMT CFUXFFO OBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODF /BUVSBMTDJFODFXPSLTCFDBVTFOBUVSBMTZTUFNTFYIJCJUDPNNPOQBUUFSOT*GOBUVSFXFSFBEIPD BOEFWFSZUIJOHXBTVOJRVF OBUVSBMTDJFODFXPVMEHFUMJUUMFUSBDUJPOBOE JOGBDU XPVMEQSPCBCMZ OPUFYJTU#VUOBUVSBMUIJOHTIBWFNBOZDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTJODPNNPOUIBUJT UIFZFYIJCJUQBUUFSOT BOE UIPTF QBUUFSOT BMMPX OBUVSBM TDJFODF UP TBZ NVDI UIBU JT NFBOJOHGVM BCPVU NBOZ PG UIPTF *OUIJTDPOUFYU UIFUFSN“FYJTUJOH”JTVTFETPNFXIBUMPPTFMZJOBUFNQPSBMTFOTFThFSFBMSFTUSJDUJPOJTUIBU BQQSPQSJBUFJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUTZTUFNTNVTUFYJTU4DJFODF GPSFYBNQMF DBOTUVEZNFNCFSTPGBOJNBMPSQMBOU TQFDJFTUPEBZUIBUIBWFCFFOFYUJODUGPSUIPVTBOETPSFWFONJMMJPOTPGZFBST JGBEFRVBUFJOGPSNBUJPOJTBWBJMBCMF UPEBZ GSPNGPTTJMT GPSFYBNQMF

Systems Science Context

O 35

TZTUFNTBOEUPHSPVQUIPTFTZTUFNTJOUPDBUFHPSJFT"MMUIFBUPNTJOUIFLOPXOVOJWFSTFﬁUJOUP BCPVUBIVOESFEDBUFHPSJFT PSHBOJ[FEJOUPUIFQFSJPEJDUBCMF#JPMPHZDBUFHPSJ[FTBMMLOPXOMJW JOHUIJOHTJOUPDBUFHPSJFTDBMMFELJOHEPNT TQFDJFT FUD"MMNFNCFSTPGBTQFDJFTFYIJCJUUIFTBNF CBTJDBSDIJUFDUVSFQBUUFSO'PSFYBNQMF BCPPLPOIVNBOBOBUPNZEFTDSJCFTBOBSDIJUFDUVSFQBU UFSOUIBUBQQMJFTUPBMMJOEJWJEVBMIVNBOT"MUIPVHIFBDIIVNBOJTVOJRVFJODFSUBJOSFTQFDUT UIF BOBUPNZCPPLGPDVTFTQSJNBSJMZPOXIBUJTDPNNPOXIJDIJTDPOTJEFSBCMF ThFSFBTPOGPSTUBUJOHUIFPCWJPVTXJUIOBUVSBMTZTUFNTJTUPTFUVQBQBSBMMFMXJUIBSUJﬁDJBM TZTUFNT*UUVSOTPVUUIBUBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNT JODMVEJOHUIPTFUIBUFOHJOFFSTCVJME BMTPIBWFNBOZ DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTJODPNNPOBOEUIFZFYIJCJUQBUUFSOTUIBUBMMPXBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODFUPTBZNVDIUIBU JTNFBOJOHGVMBCPVUNBOZPGUIPTFTZTUFNTBOEUPHSPVQUIPTFTZTUFNTJOUPDBUFHPSJFT8FSFHBSE BTBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODFUIFXPSLUIBUJEFOUJﬁFTBOEDBQUVSFTUIFLFZDBUFHPSJFT QSPQFSUJFT GVODUJPOT NFBTVSFT BOE DPOWFOUJPOBM EFTJHOT PG TZTUFNT JO UIPTF DBUFHPSJFT 8JUIJO HJWFO FOHJOFFSJOH EPNBJOTTVDIBTCSJEHFT DBST BJSDSBGU PSDPNQVUFST UIFEPNBJO BTJUNBUVSFT DPOWFSHFTPOPOF PSBTNBMMOVNCFSPGCBTJDBSDIJUFDUVSFTGPSUIBUEPNBJOPGTZTUFNT&YBNQMFTBSFUIFTVTQFOTJPO CSJEHF UIFJOUFSOBMDPNCVTUJPOFOHJOF ﬁ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ﬃOVTFTUIFUFSNiFOHJOFFSJOHTDJFODFwGPSXIBU 4JNPODBMMTiBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODFw8FVTF4JNPOTUFSNJOUIJTCPPL

Missile Guidance as a TSE Artiﬁcial Science An example of an artiﬁcial science is the domain of compiled knowledge of missile guidance and control. One compilation of this knowledge is (Siouris 2004). It includes mathematical models, taxonomies of missiles and other entities, and terms (referring to the universe of discourse). Chapter 4 of the Siouris book presents laws of tactical missile guidance. Two samples are selected from the book. The ﬁrst is a taxonomy of missiles (Figure 2.1). The common characteristics and the differences between the various types are described. The second sample is the dominant guidance law, called the proportional navigation guidance law for homing missiles. It is expressed as follows:

BO/7D ELEU

where an Commanded normal (or lateral) acceleration, in [ft/sec2] or [m/sec2] N Navigation constant (also known as navigation ratio, effective navigation ratio, or navigation gain), a positive real number, [dimensionless] Vc Closing velocity, in [ft/sec] or [m/sec] dL/dt LOS (line of sight) rate measured by the missile seeker, in [rad/sec] The argument that this domain of knowledge represents an artiﬁcial science is this: it is artiﬁcial because its subject matter is a domain of engineered

36 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science Missile

Guided

Nonhoming

Unguided

Homing

Direct (or external guidance)

Inertial

Programmed

Active Semiactive Passive

Command Beam rider

CLOS

Pursuit

Figure 2.1 Missile types and classiﬁcation. (Source: Siouris, G. Missile Guidance and Control Systems. New York: Springer, 2004. Used with permission of Springer Science + Business Media.)

(i.e., artiﬁcial) systems. It is a science because it ﬁts our deﬁnition of science given above: “the systematic practice of observing patterns in the characteristics of existing phenomena or systemsz” In the Siouris book, the ﬁeld is deﬁned in the title: Missile Guidance and Control Systems. A large number of patterns of the characteristics of existing missile guidance and control systems are deﬁned and shared in this book, so clearly they can be independently examined. If other specialists disagree with these patterns or models, they can challenge them.

"OPUIFSQBSBMMFMJTUIBUGPSCPUIOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNT UIFBSDIJUFDUVSFTFWPMWFBDSPTT HFOFSBUJPOTPGTZTUFNT BOEJOTPNFDBTFTUIFDIBOHFTBSFTJHOJﬁDBOUFOPVHIUIBUUIFBSDIJUFDUVSF JTKVEHFEUPCFBOFXPOF OPUKVTUBNPEJﬁDBUJPOPGUIFPMEPOF4DJFODF OBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBM USBDLTUIJTFWPMVUJPO 8FSFHBSENBOZTDJFODFTBTBNJYPGCPUIOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMJGUIFZTUVEZCPUIOBUVSBM BOEBSUJﬁDJBMQIFOPNFOB PSJGUIFTZTUFNTUIFZTUVEZSFQSFTFOUBGV[[ZPSBNCJHVPVTCPVOEBSZ CFUXFFOOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMThFMBXTPGQIZTJDTBQQMZFRVBMMZUPOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMQIZTJDBM TZTUFNT#PUIBOBQQMFBOEBCBTFCBMMBSFDPNQPTFEPGFMFNFOUBSZQBSUJDMFTBOEBUPNTThFGBMMPG BCBTFCBMMUPUIF&BSUIJTOPMFTTBOEOPNPSFJOTUSVDUJWFUPUIFUIFPSZPGHSBWJUBUJPOUIBO JTUIFGBMMPGBOBQQMF/BOPUFDIOPMPHZBOETZOUIFUJDFMFNFOUTJODIFNJTUSZBOECJPUFDIOPMPHZ TVHHFTUUIBUFWFOUIFNPTUOBUVSBMPGTDJFODFTQIZTJDT DIFNJTUSZ BOECJPMPHZNBZOPX CFBNJYPGCPUIOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBM1FSIBQTXFBSFNPWJOHJOUPBOFSBJOXIJDIOPTDJFODFJT TUSJDUMZOBUVSBMPSTUSJDUMZBSUJﬁDJBM1TZDIPMPHZ TPDJPMPHZ FDPOPNJDT MJOHVJTUJDT BOEPSHBOJ[B UJPOBMUIFPSZyBSFUIFZOBUVSBMPSBSUJﬁDJBM PSTPNFPGCPUI *TBTPDJBMHSPVQ TVDIBTBGBNJMZPS DIVSDIPSNPC BOBUVSBMPSNBONBEFTZTUFN PSCPUI The QPTTJCJMJUZPGBStiﬁcial TDJFODFBOEUIFJODSFBTJOHJOUFSFTUJOTZTUFNTUIBUTFFNUPCMVSUIF CPVOEBSZCFUXFFOOBUVSBMBOEBStiﬁcial BSFLFZFMFNFOUTJO.04&4BTBVOJGZJOHGPVOEBUJPOGPS 4&0VSJOUFSFTUIFSFJTOPUUPBMMPDBUFTZTUFNTBOETDJFODFTUPBTUSJDUUBYPOPNZPGOBUVSBM BSUJ ﬁcial, IZCSJE PSGV[[Z*UJTSBUIFSUPNBLFUIFQPJOUUIBUTDJFODFNVTUCFBCMFUPTVQQPSUBMMUIFTF

Systems Science Context

O

37

UZQFTPGTZTUFNT UIFGVMMSBOHFPGTZTUFNT JOBTFBNMFTTXBZ"signiﬁcant ESJWFSPG.04&4JTUIF OFFEGPSBOBQQSPBDIUP4&4BOEUP4&UIBUDBODPNGPSUBCMZDSPTTUIFCPVOEBSZCFUXFFOBStiﬁcial BOEOBUVSBMTZTUFNTXJUIPVUMPTTPGDPOUJOVJUZ BOEJOGBDUJONBOZSFTQFDUTDBOCFBHOPTUJDUP UIJTEJTUJODUJPOThe VTFPGNPEFMTBOENPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOJTUIFNBKPSGBDUPSJOBDIJFWJOHTVDIB DBQBCJMJUZ

Conceptualization of Engineering &OHJOFFSJOH JT UIF TZTUFNBUJD QSBDUJDF PG BHFOUT UBLJOH QVSQPTFGVM BOE DPOTUSBJOFE BDUJPO UP BDIJFWFBTZTUFNPGBDFSUBJOUZQFPSDBUFHPSZXJUIDFSUBJOEFTJSFEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT$POTUSBJOFE BDUJPONFBOTUIBUUIFBDUJPOTUBLFQMBDFVOEFSBWBSJFUZPGDPOTUSBJOUT JODMVEJOHSFTPVSDFDPO TUSBJOUT5ZQJDBMMZXFUIJOLPGBHFOUTBTIVNBOT*GIVNBOTCVJMEBEBN XFUIJOLPGJUBTFOHJ OFFSJOH*GCFBWFSTCVJMEBEBN XFEPOPUVTVBMMZUIJOLPGJUBTFOHJOFFSJOH BMUIPVHIJUTBUJTﬁFT BMMBTQFDUTPGUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPGFOHJOFFSJOHBTTUBUFEIFSF. ThFQVSQPTFPGNBLJOHUIJTQPJOUJTOPU TPNVDIUPBSHVFUIBUCFBWFSTEPFOHJOFFSJOH CVUSBUIFSUPSBJTFUIFQPTTJCJMJUZUIBUBHFOUTPUIFS UIBOIVNBOT FH TPGUXBSFBHFOUT DPVMECFWJFXFEBTQFSGPSNJOHFOHJOFFSJOH JOTPNFDJSDVN TUBODFT$BUFHPSZNFBOTUIBUFOHJOFFSTEPOPUQSPEVDFBMMUZQFTPSDBUFHPSJFTPGTZTUFNTUIFZ QSPEVDFTZTUFNTJOUIFJSﬁFME TVDIBTDJWJMFOHJOFFSJOH FMFDUSJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH TPGUXBSFFOHJOFFS JOH PSTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH

Engineering: What Does It Mean for Complex or Hybrid Systems? ThFFYQBOEFE4&DIBMMFOHFTUSBEJUJPOBMOPUJPOTPGFOHJOFFSJOH-BSHFTDBMFDPNQMFYTZTUFNT $4 TVDIBTFOUFSQSJTFTBOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOT TNBMMTDBMFTZTUFNTJOOBOPUFDIOPMPHZBOETZOUIFUJDCJPM PHZ BOE IZCSJE TZTUFNT JO HFOFSBM FYIJCJU UIF QIFOPNFOPO PG CSJOHJOH OBUVSBM BOE BSUJﬁDJBM DPNQPOFOUTUPHFUIFSBOECMVSSJOHUIFEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOXIBUJTBSUJﬁDJBMBOEXIBUJTOBUVSBM 8IBUEPFTJUNFBOUPFOHJOFFSBOBUVSBMDPNQPOFOUPSBIZCSJETZTUFN 0SUPFOHJOFFSBQFSTPO BHSPVQ PSBOPSHBOJ[BUJPO *TJUSFBMMZFOHJOFFSJOH $PNQMFYTZTUFNT BTEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS BSFDIBSBDUFSJ[FEBTIBWJOHUIFQPUFOUJBMUPFYIJCJU CFIBWJPSUIBUJTBVUPOPNPVT VOQSFEJDUBCMF EJﬃcVMUUPVOEFSTUBOE MJLFMZUPBQQFBSDIBPUJD PS DPOUJOVBMMZDIBOHJOH*OBEEJUJPO UIFSFBSFNBOZOPOUFDIOJDBMBTQFDUT TVDIBTTPDJBM PSHBOJ[B UJPOBM FDPOPNJD BOEMFHBMThFTFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTTFFNJOHMZEPOPUMFOEUIFNTFMWFTUPFOHJOFFSJOH BTXFUSBEJUJPOBMMZDPODFJWFJU ThF .04&4 BQQSPBDI JT UIBU FOHJOFFSJOH XJMM BEFRVBUFMZ TVQQPSU UIF OFX FYQBOEFE 4& JODMVEJOH$4& VOEFSUIFCSPBEFSVNCSFMMBPGDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPO JOUSPEVDFEJO$IBQUFS *OUIJTTFDUJPOXFCSJFﬂZSFDBQJUVMBUFUIFFOHJOFFSJOHBTQFDUTPGUIJTQSPDFTT ThFCBTJDPSJFOUBUJPOJTUIBU4&TZTUFNTXJMMSBOHFGSPNGVMMZ54UPGVMMZ$4CVUNPTUXJMMCFB IZCSJE BDPNCJOBUJPOThJTNFBOTUIBUBTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSOFFETUPQFSGPSNTPNFDPNCJOBUJPOPG FOHJOFFSJOHQMBOOJOHBOEEFTJHOBMPOHXJUIGBDJMJUBUJOH TIBQJOH BOEUBLJOHBEWBOUBHFPGBVUPOP NPVTCFIBWJPSJOUIFTZTUFNThFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSIBTMFTTDPOUSPMUIBOJOBUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNCVU TUJMMIBTTPNFTIBQJOHJOﬂVFODFThFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSEPFTOPUIBWFUPEFDJEFFWFSZUIJOH4ZTUFNT FOHJOFFSTXJMMOFFEUPMFBSOIPXUPBQQMZJOﬂVFODFBOEFYQMPJUIFMQGSPNUIFTZTUFNJUTFMG ThJTDPNCJOFEBDUJWJUZPGFOHJOFFSJOHBOEBVUPOPNPVTBDUJPOBQQMJFTBMTPUPFOUFSQSJTFT" QSPKFDU BHFODZ PS DPNQBOZ JT TIBQFE BOE NBOBHFE UISPVHI B DPNCJOBUJPO PG TDJFODFCBTFE FOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOHBOENBOBHFNFOU &&.

BOEFOUFSQSJTFTFMGPSHBOJ[JOHBDUJWJUZ $IBQUFSEFTDSJCFTUIFPWFSBMMBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTGVSUIFS

38

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Relationship between Science and Engineering Shaw and Finch Historical Pattern ThFHFOFSBMSFMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFOTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOHJTUIBUTDJFODFiTVQQPSUTwFOHJOFFSJOH UIBUJT JUQSPWJEFTBOBMZUJDUPPMTBOEBOVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIFQSPQFSUJFTUIBUFOHJOFFSJOHDBOVTF JOQSFEJDUJOHRVBMJUJFTPGXIBUJUQSPEVDFT.PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ TDJFODFTVQQPSUTFOHJOFFSJOHJOUXP XBZT TDJFODF OBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBM TUVEJFTQSPQFSUJFTPGNBUFSJBMTUIBUHPJOUPUIFQSPEVDUT PSTZTUFNTUIBUFOHJOFFSJOHDPOTUSVDUT BOE BSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODFTUVEJFTUIFQSPQFSUJFT JODMVEJOH FNFSHFOUQSPQFSUJFT PGUIFQSPEVDUTPSTZTUFNTUIBUBSFFOHJOFFSFE ThFFWPMVUJPOPGUIJTSFMBUJPOTIJQJTNPSFDPNQMFY)JTUPSJDBMMZ TDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOHXFSF UXPTFQBSBUFDVMUVSFTUIBUEJEOPUJOUFSBDU0OMZJOUIFQBTUUXPPSUISFFDFOUVSJFTIBTBTDJFOUJﬁD GPVOEBUJPOCFFOFYQMJDJUMZCVJMUBOEVTFEGPSFOHJOFFSJOH"EFTDSJQUJPOPGIPXUIFSFMBUJPOTIJQ CFUXFFOTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOHEFWFMPQTBTQBSUPGUIFNBUVSBUJPOQSPDFTTJTHJWFOGPSFOHJOFFS JOHEJTDJQMJOFTTVDIBTNFDIBOJDBMBOEDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH CZ4IBX BOE'JODI

BOETVNNBSJ[FEIFSF ThFJOJUJBMQIBTFJTBEIPDQSBDUJDF JOXIJDIQSPCMFNTBSFTPMWFECZUBMFOUFEBNBUFVSTBOE WJSUVPTPTThFTPMVUJPOTPGUIFTFDSBGUTNFOUIFOHSBEVBMMZNPWFJOUPUIFGPMLMPSF CFDPNFSPV UJOF BOE CFHJO MJNJUFE QSPEVDUJPO ThJT HSBEVBMMZ MFBET UP DPNNFSDJBMTDBMF QSPEVDUJPO ThF QSPCMFNTPGMBSHFTDBMFQSPEVDUJPOUIFOTUJNVMBUFUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPGBTVQQPSUJOHTDJFODFUIBU EFﬁOFT UIF QSJODJQMFT UIBU FYQMBJO UIF CFIBWJPS UIBU QSBDUJUJPOFST IBWF BMSFBEZ PCTFSWFE BOE FYQMPJUFE"TUIFTDJFODFNBUVSFT JUﬁOBMMZHFUTPVUBIFBEPGDVSSFOUQSBDUJDFJOUIFTFOTFUIBU JUGPSNVMBUFTQSJODJQMFTUIBUDBOCFVTFEUPJNQSPWFDVSSFOUQSBDUJDFNPSFQSFEJDUBCJMJUZ GFXFS FSSPST NPSFQSFDJTFTBGFUZNBSHJOTUIBUBMMPXMFTTPWFSEFTJHOBOEUIFSFGPSFMPXFSDPTU"UUIJT QPJOU QFPQMFDBOCFFEVDBUFEJOCPUIUIFUIFPSZBOEQSBDUJDFPGUIFﬁFME BOEUIFﬁFMEJTOPXB NBUVSFEJTDJQMJOF "T UIF TDJFODF BOE FOHJOFFSJOH NBUVSF UIFZ DPOUSJCVUF UP FBDI PUIFS &OHJOFFSJOH CVJMET UIJOHT UIFQSPQFSUJFTPGXIJDITDJFODFOFFETUPBOBMZ[FBOEVOEFSTUBOEJOPSEFSUPFOBCMFNPSF FﬃcJFOUBOEFDPOPNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH

MOSES Conceptualization ThFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOHJTUIBUTDJFODFVTFTTZTUFNT PSQIFOPNFOB UPCVJME NPEFMT BOEFOHJOFFSJOHVTFTNPEFMTUPCVJMETZTUFNT4DJFODFPCTFSWFTFYJTUJOHTZTUFNTTVDIBTB DFMMPSBTPMBSTZTUFNBOEEFﬁOFTHFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUEFﬁOFXIBUTDJFOUJTUTCFMJFWFBCPVUUIFDPSSF TQPOEJOHEPNBJO FH UIFQIZTJDBMXPSMEPGNPWJOHCPEJFTBOEGPSDFT PSUIFCJPMPHJDBMXPSMEPG DFMMTBOEPSHBOJTNT BUBHJWFOQPJOUJOUJNFThFSFBSFUXPUFOEFODJFTSFMBUFEUPUIJTEJTUJODUJPO 0OFJTUIBUJOTDJFODFUIFTZTUFNTUFOEUPQSFDFEFUIFNPEFMT XIJMFJOFOHJOFFSJOHUIFNPEFMT UFOEUPQSFDFEFUIFTZTUFNTThFPUIFSUFOEFODZSFMBUFTUPXIJDIUZQFPGTZTUFNJTVTFEBTUIF TUBOEBSEPSBTTVNFEUPCFDPSSFDUXIFOUFTUJOHDPSSFTQPOEFODFCFUXFFOBNPEFMBOEBTZTUFN 4DJFODFUFOETUPVTFUIFTZTUFNBTUIFTUBOEBSE BTTVNJOHUIBUUIFNPEFMJTJODPSSFDUJGJUEPFTOPU DPSSFTQPOEUPUIFTZTUFN&OHJOFFSJOHUFOETUPVTFUIFNPEFMBTUIFTUBOEBSE BTTVNJOHUIBUUIF TZTUFNJTJODPSSFDUJGJUEPFTOPUDPSSFTQPOEUPUIFNPEFM'PSFYBNQMF FOHJOFFSTUFOEUPCFMJFWF UIBUJGBTZTUFNJTUFTUFEBHBJOTUBTFUPGSFRVJSFNFOUT BOEJUGBJMTUIFUFTU UIFOUIFSFRVJSFNFOUT BSFDPSSFDUBOEUIFTZTUFNJTXSPOH #VUUIBUJTOPUBMXBZTUIFDBTFTPNFUJNFTTDJFOUJTUTCFMJFWFBUIFPSZ NPEFM JTDPSSFDUBOEUIFJSFYQFSJNFOUBM EBUB PGUIFTZTUFN BSe ﬂBXFEJGUIFUXPEPOPUBHSFF

Systems Science Context

O

39

Mature science-based engineering Immature engineering Speciﬁc models

Build from design

Artiﬁcial or hybrid system

Engineering Specialize

General models Science

Figure 2.2

Abstract from many

Natural systems

General relationship between mature science and engineering.

'JHVSFSFQSFTFOUTPVSNPEFMPGUIFSFMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFONBUVSFTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOH 8e ﬁSTUEJTDVTTUIJTJOHFOFSBMUFSNTBOEUIFOJMMVTUSBUFJUXJUIUISFFFYBNQMFT ThFEFHSFFPGNBUVSJUZWBSJFTGPSCPUITDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOH*O'JHVSF UIFWBSJBCMFPG FOHJOFFSJOHNBUVSJUZJTFYQMJDJUXIJMFUIBUPGTDJFODFNBUVSJUZJTJNQMJDJU.BUVSFTDJFODFCBTFE FOHJOFFSJOHFYIJCJUTUIFGPMMPXJOHDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT O #PUIUIFFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOFBOEUIFTVQQPSUJOHTDJFODFEJTDJQMJOF T IBWFTPNFDPO TJEFSBCMFEFHSFFPGNBUVSJUZ O ThFFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOFNBZESBXPONVMUJQMFTDJFODFEJTDJQMJOFTJUJTOPUMJNJUFEUP POFTDJFODFEJTDJQMJOFQFSFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOF O "HJWFOTDJFODFBCTUSBDUTHFOFSBMNPEFMTPSQBUUFSOTGSPNNVMUJQMFOBUVSBMTZTUFNTJGJU JTTUSJDUMZBOBUVSBMTDJFODFPSGSPNNVMUJQMFBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNTJGJUJTTUSJDUMZBOBSUJﬁDJBM TDJFODFPSGSPNTPNFDPNCJOBUJPOPGNVMUJQMFOBUVSBM BSUJﬁDJBM PSIZCSJETZTUFNTJGJUJT BNJYPGOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODF 4QFDJBMJ[JOHUIFHFOFSBMNPEFMTJUPCUBJOTGSPNTDJFODF FOHJOFFSJOHQSPEVDFTTQFDJﬁDNPEFMT FH SFRVJSFNFOUT BSDIJUFDUVSF BOEEFTJHO UPCVJMEPOFTQFDJﬁDTZTUFN XIJDINBZCFBSUJﬁDJBM PSIZCSJE*NNBUVSFFOHJOFFSJOHJTBUBTUBHFXIFSFTQFDJﬁDNPEFMTBSFEFﬁOFE TVDIBTEFTJHO UPHVJEFUIFCVJMEJOHPGUIFTZTUFN*NNBUVSFFOHJOFFSJOHEPFTOPUIBWFPSVTFHFOFSBMNPEFMT GSPNTDJFODF .BUVSJUZPGTDJFODFJTSFﬂFDUFEJOUIFOVNCFSPGHFOFSBMNPEFMTBWBJMBCMFBOEUIFﬁEFMJUZPS DPSSFTQPOEFODFPGUIPTFNPEFMTUPUIFTZTUFNT*OHFOFSBM BNBUVSFTDJFODFIBTNPSFNPEFMTPG IJHIFr ﬁEFMJUZUIBOBOJNNBUVSFTDJFODFEPFT ThSFFFYBNQMFTBSFQSFTFOUFEThFﬁSTUUXPBSFUBLFOGSPN4IBX BOEBSFJOUFSQSFUFE BOEEFTDSJCFEJOUIFDPOUFYUPG'JHVSF O &YBNQMF$JWJMFOHJOFFSJOH$JWJMFOHJOFFSJOHJTUIFEJTDJQMJOFPGMBSHFTDBMFDPOTUSVDUJPO FﬀPSUTTVDIBTCVJMEJOHT CSJEHFT EBNT UVOOFMT IJHIXBZT BOESBJMSPBET*UIBTCFFOQSBD UJDFEGPSNJMMFOOJBBRVFEVDUTJO3PNF JSSJHBUJPOJO.FTPQPUBNJB QZSBNJETJO&HZQU -JLF NPTU USBEJUJPOBM FOHJOFFSJOH EJTDJQMJOFT JU JT CBTFE PO CPUI OBUVSBM BOE BSUJﬁDJBM

40 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

QBSUTPGUIFTDJFODFTQFDUSVNCVUJUXBTCBTFEPOBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODFMPOHCFGPSFJUXBTCBTFE POOBUVSBMTDJFODF"UUIFOBUVSBMFOEBSFNPEFMTPGTUBUJDTBOETUSFOHUIPGNBUFSJBMT CPUIPGXIJDIXFSFEFWFMPQFEBSPVOEBOEPUIFSQSPQFSUJFTPGNBUFSJBMT TVDIBT FMBTUJDJUZ XIJDI XFSF EFWFMPQFE MBUFS "U UIF BSUJﬁDJBM FOE BSF QSPQFSUJFT DPOWFOUJPOBM EFTJHOT BOE NFUIPET PG BOBMZTJT GPS QBSUJDVMBS DBUFHPSJFT PG BSUJﬁDJBM TZTUFNT TVDI BT CSJEHFT$JWJMFOHJOFFSJOHVTFTUIFHFOFSBMNPEFMTPGCPUIOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNTUP EFﬁOFTQFDJBMJ[FENPEFMTBOECVJMEBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNTPGFBDIUZQFMJTUFEBCPWF O &YBNQMF$IFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH$IFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHJTDPODFSOFEXJUIUIFJOEVTUSJBM TDBMFQSPEVDUJPOPGDIFNJDBMHPPETTVDIBTTPMWFOUT QIBSNBDFVUJDBMT BOETZOUIFUJDﬁbers. The OBUVSBMTDJFODFTVQQPSUJOHDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHJT PGDPVSTF DIFNJTUSZ#VUJOUIF T B DIFNJDBM QMBOU JOTQFDUPS (& %BWJT PCTFSWFE B DPNNPO QBUUFSO BNPOH UIF XJEFWBSJFUZPGHPPETCFJOHQSPEVDFEThe QBUUFSOXBTUIBUBMMQMBOUT QSPEVDJOHBMMUZQFT PGDIFNJDBMHPPET VTFEUIFTBNFTFUPGTUFQTﬁltration BOEclariﬁcation, IFBUFYDIBOHF EJTUJMMBUJPO TDSFFOJOH NBHOFUJDTFQBSBUJPO ﬂotation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tiﬁcial TDJFODFT UIBU JMMVTUSBUFT UIF QBUUFSO JO 'JHVSF The OBUVSBM TDJFODF QSPEVDFE HFOFSBM NPEFMT JO UIF GPSN PG iOBUVSBM MBXTw PG DIFNJT USZ The BStiﬁcial TDJFODF BT QFSGPSNFE CZ %BWJT QSPEVDFE HFOFSBM NPEFMT JO UIF GPSN PG iBStiﬁcial MBXTw PG VOJU PQFSBUJPOT $IFNJDBM FOHJOFFSJOH TQFDJBMJ[FT UIFTF HFO FSBM NPEFMT GPS B XJEF WBSJFUZ PG DIFNJDBM HPPET 'PS FBDI UZQF PG DIFNJDBM QSPEVDU JU deﬁnes speciﬁc NPEFMT BOE iCVJMETw B TZTUFN XIJDI JT B NBOVGBDUVSJOH QMBOU XJUI UIF BJE PG NFDIBOJDBM BOE DJWJM FOHJOFFSJOH BOE UIF VOJU PQFSBUJPOT QSPDFTT UP VTF 4IBXTBJEUIBUDJWJMFOHJOFFSJOHIBTBCBTJTJOUIFPSZ BOEDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHIBTBCBTJT JOQSBDUJDF8FJOUFSQSFUUIFEJTUJODUJPOUIJTXBZCPUIEJTDJQMJOFTESBXPOOBUVSBMBOEBSUJ ﬁcial TZTUFNTCVUDJWJMFOHJOFFSJOHSFMJFTNPSFWJTJCMZPOOBUVSBMTDJFODF XIJDIdeﬁnes UIF TUBUJDTBOETUSFOHUIPGNBUFSJBMT XIJMFDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHSFMJFTNPSFWJTJCMZPOBStiﬁcial science, which deﬁnes unit operations. O &YBNQMF 4PGUXBSF FOHJOFFSJOH This FYBNQMF QSPQPTFT B OBUVSBM BOE BStiﬁcial TDJ FODF PG TPGUXBSF The SPMF PG iOBUVSBMw TDJFODF JT QMBZFE CZ DPNQVUFS TDJFODF XJUI JUT GPDVT PO GPSNBM MBOHVBHFT TUSVDUVSFT BOE DPNQVUBCJMJUZ ThF BSUJﬁDJBM TDJFODF NBZ CF DBMMFE TPGUXBSF TDJFODF 8F JEFOUJGZ UISFF TBNQMFT PG BStiﬁcial) TPGUXBSF TDJ FODF The ﬁrst JT UIF XPSL PO TPGUXBSF FWPMVUJPO MBXT PS QBUUFSOT CZ -FINBOO BOE #FMBEZ This XPSL FYBNJOFE B TFU PG FOHJOFFSFE TPGUXBSF TZTUFNT BOE USBDLFE UIFJS DIBOHF PWFS UJNF BOE PCTFSWFE UIF FWPMVUJPO QBUUFSOT EFTDSJCFE JO UIF CPPL The TFDPOETBNQMFJTXPSLPOJEFOUJGZJOHBOEDPEJGZJOHTPGUXBSFQBUUFSOT TVDIBTEFTJHO QBUUFSOTBOEBSDIJUFDUVSFQBUUFSOTGPSFYBNQMF (BNNBFUBM BOE#VTDINBOO FUBM ThFBTTVNQUJPOJOOBNJOHUIFTFFﬀPSUTBTTDJFODFJTUIBUUIFQBUUFSOTUIFZ JEFOUJﬁFE XFSF BCTUSBDUFE GSPN FYBNJOBUJPO PG NVMUJQMF FYJTUJOH TZTUFNT *O CPUI UIFTF TBNQMFT UIF SFTVMUT XFSF HFOFSBM NPEFMT UIBU BQQMZ UP B QPQVMBUJPO PS DMBTT PG TZTUFNT The UIJSETBNQMFJTPGBdiﬀerFOUGPSN1PPSF DSJUJRVFTUIFTUBUFBOEEJSFDUJPOPG TPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHJODPNQBSJTPOXJUIIPXPUIFSEJTDJQMJOFTIBWFNBUVSFE)FOPUFTUIF

Systems Science Context

O

41

JODSFBTJOHHBQCFUXFFOTPGUXBSFFEVDBUJPOBOEQSBDUJDF EFTQJUFUIFWBMJBOUeﬀorUTPG7JD #BTJMJ 'SFE#SPPLT #BSSZ#PFIN )BSMBO.JMMT BOE%BWJE1BSOBTUPDMPTFUIFHBQBOEBMJHO FEVDBUJPOBOEQSBDUJDF0VSQVSQPTFIFSFJTOPUUPDPNNFOUPOUIFHBQ CVUSBUIFSUPNBLF UIJTPCTFSWBUJPO*GPOFXFSFUPDPNQJMFBMJTUPGNFNCFSTPGUIFTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHDPN NVOJUZXIPIBWFNBEFsigniﬁcant DPOUSJCVUJPOTJOPCTFSWJOHBOEQVCMJTIJOHQBUUFSOTPS NPEFMTBCTUSBDUFEGSPNTPGUXBSFTZTUFNT UIFTFJOEJWJEVBMTXPVMECFPOUIFMJTUThe LOPXM FEHFUIFZIBWFDPOUSJCVUFEUPUIFSFQPTJUPSZPGHFOFSBMNPEFMT XIJMFJOGPSNFECZDPNQVUFS TDJFODF IBT DPNF EJSFDUMZ GSPN BSUJﬁDJBM TPGUXBSF TZTUFNT ThVT JO UFSNT PG 'JHVSF UIFZGPSNBDPSFQBSUPGUIFBStiﬁcial TPGUXBSFTDJFODFDPNNVOJUZThe HFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBU TPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSTVTFDPNFGSPNCPUI OBUVSBM DPNQVUFSTDJFODFBOE BSUJﬁDJBM TPGUXBSF TDJFODF PS BMUFSOBUJWFMZ GSPNCPUIDPNQVUFSTDJFODFUIFPSZBOETPGUXBSFQSBDUJDF "OPUIFS HPPE USFBUNFOU PG UIF SFMBUJPO CFUXFFO TDJFOUJﬁD BOE FOHJOFFSJOH LOPXMFEHF JT 7JODFOUJT CPPLPOXIBUFOHJOFFSTLOPX VTJOHFYBNQMFTUBLFOGSPNUIFIJTUPSZPGBFSP OBVUJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHThFQBUUFSOTBOENPEFMTQSFTFOUFEJO7JODFOUJTCPPLBSFUIFSFTVMUPGUIF OBUVSBMTDJFODFPGQIZTJDTBOEUIFBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODFPGBJSDSBGU

Systems Science and CSS ThJTTFDUJPOEJTDVTTFTUIFFTTFODFPG44BOEJUTSFMBUJPOXJUI$445PHFUIFSUIFZGPSNBDPSFQBSU PGUIFCBTJTPGBO4&4 EFTDSJCFEJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi%JTDJQMJOFT$POUSJCVUJOHUP4&4w

Why Systems Science Is Important for SE 8FIBWFTIPXOUIBUBNBKPSDPNQPOFOUPGUIFTDJFODFGPVOEBUJPOPG4&JT44ThFOPUJPOUIBU44 TIPVMEQSPWJEFBGPVOEBUJPOGPS4&IBTBQSJNBGBDJFWBMJEJUZCVUUIFSFBSFNPSFTVCTUBOUJWFSFBTPOT GPSFYQMJDJUMZJODMVEJOH440OFSFBTPOJTUIBU EFTQJUFUIFQPUFOUJBMCFOFﬁUTPG44GPSUSBEJUJPOBM 4& 54&

44BOE54&IBWFOPUIBEBDMPTFSFMBUJPOTIJQVQUPUIJTQPJOU5PBMBSHFFYUFOU 54& QSBDUJUJPOFSTIBWFOPUJODPSQPSBUFEUIFDPODFQUTPG44JOUPUIFJSQSBDUJDF "TFDPOESFBTPO BUMFBTUBTJNQPSUBOU JTUIBUUIFOBUVSFPGUIFFYUFOEFE4&CSJOHTOBUVSBM BOEBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNTJOUPDMPTFSQSPYJNJUZ BOEJOTPNFDBTFTBCTUSBDUTBXBZUIFEJﬀFSFODFT44 TVQQPSUTUIJTBCTUSBDUJPOJUJTJOUFSFTUFEJOXIBUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTIPMEGPSBMMTZTUFNTPGBOZTJ[F TIBQF PSUZQF KVTUCFDBVTFUIFZBSFTZTUFNT44JTOPUPOMZNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZJUJTVOJWFSTBMJOUIF TFOTFUIBUJUTVQQPSUTBMMEJTDJQMJOFTUIBUEFBMXJUITZTUFNT XIJDIJOPVSWJFXJODMVEFBUMFBTUBMM FOHJOFFSJOH TDJFODF BOENBUIFNBUJDBMEJTDJQMJOFT "UIJSESFBTPOJTUIBU44JTTVﬃcJFOUMZNBUVSFUPCFVTFEBTBGPVOEBUJPO"MUIPVHIJUDPOUJO VFTUPFWPMWF JUIBTFYJTUFEJOTPNFUIJOHMJLFJUTQSFTFOUGPSNGPSNPSFUIBOBIBMGDFOUVSZ

Themes ThSFFUIFNFTTFFNUPEPNJOBUF44 JOCPUIIJTUPSJDBMBOEDPOUFNQPSBSZUSFBUNFOUT IPMJTN NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJUZ BOE DMPTFJOUFSUXJOJOHXJUI$44*OUIFMJUFSBUVSF UIFUIFNFTBSFNPTUMZ JNQMJDJU FWFOUBDJUThFZTJNQMZSFDVSJOUIFDPVSTFPGUIFEJTDVTTJPOJO44PSTZTUFNTUIFPSZQVCMJ DBUJPOTBDSPTTTFWFSBMEFDBEFT8FEPOPUUBLFUIFTFUIFNFTUPEJSFDUMZDPOTUJUVUFUIFFTTFODFPG44 CVUXFEFSJWFUIFFTTFODFGSPNUIFNBOEUIFONBQUIFNUPUIF.04&4WJFXPGUIFXPSME

42 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Holism "LFZQBSUPGTZTUFNTUIJOLJOHJTIPMJTN$POTJEFSBTZTUFNBTBXIPMFXJUIJUTPXOQSPQFSUJFT UIBUBSFTFQBSBUFGSPNUIFQSPQFSUJFTPGJUTQBSUTThJTXBTJOSFTQPOTFUPBUPNJTNPSSFEVDUJPO JTUUIJOLJOHUIBUFNQIBTJ[FEVOEFSTUBOEJOHBTZTUFNCZBOBMZ[JOHJUTQBSUT)JTUPSJDBMMZ IPMJTN BQQFBSFEJONVMUJQMFEJTDJQMJOFTBSPVOEUIFTBNFUJNFOFBSMZBDFOUVSZBHP TVDIBTQTZDIPMPHZ HFTUBMU

QIZTJDT BOECJPMPHZ ,MJS o,PFTUMFS o )PMJTNJTBXBZUPNBO BHFDPNQMFYJUZ OPUCZEJWJEJOHBOEDPORVFSJOH CVUCZDPNCJOJOHBOEDPORVFSJOH4NVUT XBTPOFPGUIFﬁSTUTZTUFNTUIFPSJTUTUPEJTDVTTBOEBEWPDBUFIPMJTN GPMMPXFECZWPO#FSUBMBOﬀZ .BOZPUIFSTZTUFNTUIFPSJTUT TVDIBT,MJS o

IBWFTJODFFNQIBTJ[FEIPMJTNBT BOBTQFDUPGTZTUFNTTDJFODF,PFTUMFS UPPLUIJTDPODFQUBTUFQGVSUIFSCBTFEPOUIFOPUJPO UIBUNBOZTZTUFNTBSFUIFNTFMWFTQBSUPGMBSHFSXIPMFT)FEFﬁOFEBTZTUFNPSFMFNFOUUIBUJT CPUIBTUBOEBMPOFXIPMFUPJUTQBSUT BOEBQBSUPGBMBSHFSXIPMF BTBIPMPO"IJFSBSDIZPGTVDI IPMPOTJTBIPMBSDIZ ,PFTUMFSNBEFUXPTJHOJﬁDBOUBOESFMBUFEDPOUSJCVUJPOTUPIPMJTN'JSTU IFFYUFOEFECFZPOE KVTUPOFMFWFMPGBTZTUFNBOEJUTQBSUT UPBNPSFTDBMBCMFNPEFMPGNVMUJQMFMFWFMTJOXIJDIBHJWFO TZTUFNQMBZTCPUIUIFSPMFPGBXIPMFBOEUIFSPMFPGBQBSU4FDPOE IFSFDPODJMFEIPMJTNBOE BUPNJTNCZSFDPHOJ[JOHUIBUCPUIBSFJOBEFRVBUFCZUIFNTFMWFT8FOFFEUPFYBNJOFCPUIXIPMFT BOEQBSUT

Multidisciplinarity or Generality " QSJNF NPUJWBUJPO GPS UIF EFWFMPQNFOU PG 44 XBT UIF SFDPHOJUJPO UIBU TJNJMBS SFMBUJPOT BOE NPEFMTBSFGPVOEJOXJEFMZEJﬀFSJOHEPNBJOTPGTZTUFNTThJTUIFNFXBTBSFBDUJPOBHBJOTUUIF JODSFBTJOHTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOPGTDJFODF XIJDISFTVMUFEJOBEJTJOUFHSBUFETUPWFQJQFTUSVDUVSFPGLOPXM FEHF$SPTTDVUUJOHBOEDSPTTEJTDJQMJOFLOPXMFEHFXBTHFUUJOHMPTUCFUXFFOBMMUIFTUPWFQJQFTQF DJBMUJFTThJTIBTBSHVBCMZCFFOUIFEPNJOBOUUIFNFJO44 FNQIBTJ[FECZNBOZ44DPOUSJCVUPST JODMVEJOH#PVMEJOH

8JFOFS

WPO#FSUBMBOﬀZ

BOE,MJS ThFGPSNBUJPO PG UIF 4PDJFUZ GPS (FOFSBM 4ZTUFNT 3FTFBSDI 4(43 OPX DBMMFE UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM 4PDJFUZ GPS 4ZTUFNT4DJFODFT<*444> JO GPDVTFEIFBWJMZPOUIJTUIFNF$ZCFSOFUJDT BTVCCSBODIPG44 DPODFSOFEXJUIJOGPSNBUJPOBOETFMGSFHVMBUJPO SFDPHOJ[FTJOGPSNBUJPOBOEGFFECBDLNPEFMTUIBU IPMEBDSPTTNVMUJQMFTZTUFNUZQFTBOEEJTDJQMJOFT "TICZ8JFOFS ,MJS EFTDSJCFT UIFNVMUJEJTDJQMJOFUIFNFJOUFSNTPGJTPNPSQIJDNPEFMTBDSPTTEJTDJQMJOFT XIFSFUIFJTPNPSQIJD PSDPNNPOBTQFDUTBSFCBTFEPODPNNPOSFMBUJPOT iTZTUFNIPPEw

OPUPODPNNPOUIJOHT UIJOH IPPE ThBU JT JO UIF DPODFQUJPO PG TZTUFN BT B XIPMF BOE BT B SFMBUJPO PO QBSUT 44 BCTUSBDUT BXBZEJﬀFSFODFTJOUIFUZQFTPGTZTUFNQBSUT BOEGPDVTFTPODPNNPOUZQFTPGSFMBUJPOTPOQBSUT %JﬀFSFOUUZQFTPGUIJOHTPSQBSUTZJFMEEJﬀFSFOUEJTDJQMJOFTBOEEJﬀFSFOUTQFDJBMJ[FETDJFODFT

Close Intertwining with CSS in the Literature .VDIPGUIFTZTUFNTMJUFSBUVSFPWFSJUTIJTUPSZIBTJOUFSUXJOFEBOEFWFODPOﬂBUFE44BOE$44" EJTDVTTJPOPGIPMJTN XIJDIJTUZQJDBMMZQPSUSBZFEBTBUIFNFPG44 PGUFOJODMVEFTBEJTDVTTJPOPG FNFSHFOUQSPQFSUJFT XIJDIJTUZQJDBMMZQPSUSBZFEBTBUIFNFPG$44#PUI44BOE$44BSFNVMUJEJT DJQMJOBSZ"GBJSBNPVOUPGTZTUFNTMJUFSBUVSFDPOOFDUT44XJUIPSHBOJDNPEFMTJODPOUSBTUUPUSBEJ UJPOBMNFDIBOJTUJDNPEFMT BOEEFTDSJCFTIPXUIFPSHBOJDNPEFMTBQQMZBDSPTTNVMUJQMFEJTDJQMJOFT .BOZ JGOPUNPTU QSJNBSZ44BVUIPSTFYIJCJUBMMUISFFPGUIFTFUIFNFTCVUGFXJGBOZNBLF UIFEJTUJODUJPOTFYQMJDJUThFZTJNQMZHPCBDLBOEGPSUICFUXFFOIPMJTNBOENVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJUZ

Systems Science Context

O 43

XJUIPVU JOEJDBUJOH UIBU UIFZ BSF DIBOHJOH UPQJDT ThF MJUFSBUVSF IBT OFJUIFS NBEF B DMFBS EJT UJODUJPOCFUXFFO44BOE$44 OPSIBTJUOPUFEUIFJSIJTUPSJDBMBOEDPOUFNQPSBSZJOUFSUXJOJOH 4PNFSFDFOUQVCMJDBUJPOT IPXFWFS IBWFCFHVOEJTUJOHVJTIJOH44GSPN$44(IBSBKFEBHIJ JNQMJDJUMZ EJTUJOHVJTIFT CFUXFFO IPMJTN BOE $44 DPWFSJOH UIF UXP UIFNFT BT EVBM QBSBEJHN TIJGUT POF JT B TIJGU GSPN BOBMZUJD UP IPMJTUJD TZTUFNT UIJOLJOH BOE UIF PUIFS JT B TIJGU GSPN B NBDIJOFNPEFMUPBCJPMPHJDBMNPEFMUPBTPDJBMNPEFMPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOT)FEPFTOPUQSFTFOUUIFTF EVBM TIJGUT BT B EJTUJODUJPO CFUXFFO TZTUFNT TDJFODF BOE DPNQMFY TZTUFNT TDJFODF ThBU JT PVS JOUFSQSFUBUJPOPGIJTEVBMTIJGUT

Essence of SS and Its Relationship with CSS 'SPNUIFTFUIFNFT XFDPOTJEFSUIFFTTFODFPG44UPJODMVEFBUMFBTUUIFGPMMPXJOHFMFNFOUT 8IPMFTBOEQBSUTBSFCPUIFTTFOUJBMUP44 BOEUIFZGPSNSFQFBUJOHTUSVDUVSFTPSIPMBS DIJFT.04&4TVQQPSUTUIJTSFMBUJPOJOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF EJTDVTTFEJONPSFEFUBJMJO$IBQUFS .VMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJUZJTBOFTTFOUJBMFMFNFOUPG44.PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ 44DBQUVSFTDIBSBDUFS JTUJDTPGTZTUFNTBDSPTTBMMEJTDJQMJOFTXIBUUIFZIBWFJODPNNPOTPMFMZCZWJSUVFPGUIF GBDUUIBUUIFZBSFTZTUFNTThJTJOGPSNBUJPOJTDBQUVSFEJOHFOFSBMNPEFMT44JTBHFOFS BMJ[BUJPOPGBMMPUIFSTDJFODFT BOEBHFOFSBMTVQQPSUGPSBMMFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOFTThJT SFMBUJPOTIJQJTTVQQPSUFEJOUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF EJTDVTTFE JONPSFEFUBJMJO$IBQUFS ThFHFOFSBMJUZPG44JOGPSNTUIFJTTVF JNQMJDJUMZSBJTFEJOUIFMJUFSBUVSF PGUIFSFMBUJPO CFUXFFO44BOE$44UIFJSJOUFSUXJOJOHBOEFWFODPOﬂBUJPO0VSQPTJUJPOJTUIBUUIF UXP BSF EJTUJODU 8IJMF CPUI 44 BOE $44 BSF NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZ UIF TDPQF PG $44 JT B TVCTFUPG44$44JTDPODFSOFEXJUIDPNQMFYPSHBOJDTZTUFNTBDSPTTNVMUJQMFEJTDJQMJOFT XIJMF44JTDPODFSOFEXJUIBMMTZTUFNT XIJDIJODMVEFTGPSUIFQVSQPTFTPG4&CPUI DPNQMFYPSHBOJDBOEUSBEJUJPOBMNFDIBOJTUJD$PNQMFYTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH $4&

TVQ QPSUFECZ$44 GPSNTUIFEPNJOBOUBSFBPGUIFFYUFOTJPOGSPN54&UPUIFOFX4& BOE44 GPSNTUIFEPNJOBOUGPVOEBUJPOGPSUIFGVMMFYUFOEFESBOHFPG4&

Disciplines Contributing to SES 8F JEFOUJGZ JO 5BCMF B TFU PG EJTDJQMJOFT UIBU DPOUSJCVUFT UP BO 4&4 BOE JO QBSUJDVMBS UP .04&4 ThF EJTDJQMJOFT BSF MJTUFE BMQIBCFUJDBMMZ XJUIJO GPVS TPNFXIBU MPPTF DBUFHPSJFT TDJ FODFT NBUIFNBUJDT DPNQVUBUJPO BOE JOGPSNBUJDT BOE PUIFS EJTDJQMJOFT 4JHOJﬁDBOU PWFSMBQ FYJTUTBNPOHNBOZPGUIFTFEJTDJQMJOFTThFXPSLPGJOUFHSBUJOHUIFTFEJTDJQMJOFT FTQFDJBMMZGSPN BNPEFMJOHQFSTQFDUJWF JTBMSFBEZCFJOHEPOFUPBTJHOJﬁDBOUFYUFOUCZ$44BOEUPBMFTTFSFYUFOU CZ4444SFTUSJDUTJUTFMGUPDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOEUBYPOPNJFTPGBMMTZTUFNT XIJDINFBOTJUJTWFSZ CSPBE CVU OPU EFFQ 8F VTF 44 BT UIF BODIPS GPS B TZTUFNT UBYPOPNZ EFﬁOFE JO UIF TFDUJPO FOUJUMFEi4ZTUFNT5BYPOPNZBOEUIF.04&4'PVOEBUJPO wXIJMF$4BSFDPOUSBTUFEXJUI54JO UIBUUBYPOPNZ

ThFTFEJTDJQMJOFTDPOUSJCVUFUPUIFTDJFODFPG4& JODPOUSBTUUPUIFNVMUJQMFBQQMJDBUJPOEJTDJQMJOFTPSEPNBJOT UPXIJDI4&JTBQQMJFE TVDIBTEFGFOTFBOEUSBOTQPSUBUJPO

44 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science Table 2.2 Disciplines That Contribute to SES Sciences

Mathematics

Algebra Anthropology Category theory Bioinformatics Complex functions Biology theory Catastrophe theory Continuous math Chaos theory (calculus, z) Chemistry Discrete math Cognitive science (logics, z) Complex systems science Dynamical systems Cybernetics Factor analysis Ecology Geometry Economics Graph theory Epidemiology Nonlinear systems Geology Numerical analysis Linguistics Probability and Medical/health science statistical theory Military science Topology Network science Organization theory/science Physics-classical, theory of relativity, quantum theory Political science Psychology Sociology Systems science

Computation, Informatics

Other Supporting Disciplines

Artiﬁcial intelligence Computer science Computing science Formal languages and methods Formal semantics Software science

Artiﬁcial life Conceptual modeling Decision theory Epistemology Forecasting Game theory Information theory Knowledge management Knowledge representation Law Mechatronics Mereology Public policy Ontology Operations research, management science Simulation Small worlds Urban planning

ThFTFEJTDJQMJOFTTVQQPSU4&JOBWBSJFUZPGXBZT&YBNQMFTUISPVHIPVUUIFCPPLJMMVTUSBUFUIF TVQQPSUPGBOVNCFSPGUIFTFEJTDJQMJOFT *UXBTOPUFEFBSMJFSUIBU44BOE$44NPEFMTIBWFCFFOBWBJMBCMFGPSBMPOHUJNFCVUIBWFOPU CFFOFYUFOTJWFMZVTFECZ54&ThJTJMMVTUSBUFTUIBUUIFFYJTUFODFPGBTDJFODFEJTDJQMJOF XJUINPE FMTUIBUXPVMECFIFMQGVMUPBOFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOF EPFTOPUOFDFTTBSJMZNFBOUIBUUIFFOHJOFFS JOHEJTDJQMJOFFYQMPJUTUIPTFNPEFMT4&JTﬁOBMMZMPPLJOHBU$44NPEFMT BOEUPTPNFFYUFOU44 NPEFMT JOBTFSJPVTXBZ BOE.04&4JTEFTJHOFEUPGBDJMJUBUFUIFVTFPGUIFTFNPEFMT 8FDPOKFDUVSFUIBUNBOZ JGOPUNPTU TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSFEJOUIFGVUVSF4&XJMMCFIZCSJETZT UFNTUIBUJODMVEFCPUIQFPQMFBOENBDIJOFTThFQSJNBSZDBVTFPGUIJTXJMMOPUCFUIBUUIFNPTBJD UIFDPOUFYUJOXIJDITZTUFNTBSFEFTJHOBUFE XJMMDIBOHF3BUIFS UIFCJHDIBOHFTXJMMCFUIBU 4&EFTJHOBUFTTZTUFNTJOBNPSFIPMJTUJDXBZ BOE 4&XJMMWJFXTZTUFNTEJﬀFSFOUMZ8FIBWF IBEBTJHOJﬁDBOUCMJOETQPU USZJOHUPUSFBUPVSTZTUFNTBTNFDIBOJTUJD BOEUIFGVUVSFFNCSBDFPGB CSPBEFS4&4CBTJTGPS4&XJMMSFNPWFUIFCMJOETQPUBOEFOBCMFVTUPVTFNPSFBQQSPQSJBUFNPEFMT JODMVEJOHPSHBOJD$44NPEFMT GPSUIFBDUVBMTZTUFNTXFBUUFNQUUPQSPEVDF *OUIFDPOUFYUPGUIFTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT BTMJHIUMZEJﬀFSFOUBOENPSFGPSNBMQFSTQFDUJWF POTZTUFNTTDJFODFIBTCFFOPﬀFSFEVOEFSUIFUFSNi3PTFUUB4UPOFw #BF[BOE4UBZ GPSUIDPN JOH ThFZEJTDVTTBUTPNFMFOHUIUIFBOBMPHJFTBNPOHQIZTJDT UPQPMPHZ DBUFHPSZUIFPSZ MPHJD BOEDPNQVUBUJPOPSDPNQVUFSTDJFODF BOETVHHFTUUIBUSFTFBSDIJOUIFDPNNPOBSFBTPGPWFSMBQ

Systems Science Context

O 45

BNPOHUIFTFﬁFMETJTCFHJOOJOHUPCVJMEBOFXHFOFSBMTDJFODFPGTZTUFNTBOEQSPDFTTFTThFDPN NPOBMJUJFTBNPOHUIFTFBSFBTBSFNBEFNPSFEJﬃcVMUUPEJTDFSOCZEJﬀFSFODFTJOUFSNJOPMPHZBOE OPUBUJPOThFDPNNPODPODFQUTBNPOHBMMUIFTFﬁFMETBSF JOHFOFSBMUFSNT UIJOHTBOEXBZTUP HPCFUXFFOUIJOHTPSTZTUFNTBOEQSPDFTTFTPOTZTUFNTThFSFTQFDUJWFUFSNTJODBUFHPSZUIFPSZ BSFPCKFDUBOENPSQIJTNJOQIZTJDT TZTUFNBOEQSPDFTTJOUPQPMPHZ NBOJGPMEBOEDPCPSEJTNJO MPHJD QSPQPTJUJPOBOEQSPPGBOEJODPNQVUBUJPO EBUBUZQFBOEQSPHSBN

Unity and Uniﬁcation ThFSFIBTCFFOEFCBUFJOUIFQBTUDFOUVSZBCPVUUIFVOJUZPGTDJFODF CPUIJUTEFTJSBCJMJUZBOEJUT BDIJFWBCJMJUZ)JTUPSJDBMMZ UIFVOJUZPGTDJFODFIBTPGUFOCFFOEJTDVTTFEJOUIFDPOUFYUPGSFEVD JOHBMMTDJFODFUPQIZTJDT ThJTIBTTQBSLFESFTJTUBODFGSPNUIF$4DPNNVOJUZ XIJDIIBTOPUFE UIFFYJTUFODFPGFNFSHFOUQSPQFSUJFTBOEIBTBSHVFEUIBUOPUFWFSZUIJOHDBOCFSFEVDFEUPUIF MPXFTUMFWFM QBSUT PS BUPNT 4PNF TZTUFNT UIFPSJTUT TVDI BT 7PO #FSUBMBOﬀZ BOE ,MJS

IBWFEJTDVTTFEBSPMFGPS44JOQSPNPUJOHVOJUZPGTDJFODFCVUUIFZNBLFBEJﬀFSFOULJOE PGBSHVNFOUUIBUJT VOJUZPGTDJFODFJTBDIJFWFEOPUCZSFEVDUJPO CVUCZBCTUSBDUJPOPSHFOFS BMJ[BUJPO44VOJﬁFTCZBCTUSBDUJOHBXBZUIFEJﬀFSFODFTJOUZQFTPGTZTUFNTBOEEFﬁOJOHXIBUJT DPNNPOUPBMM ,MJS TBZTUIBUVOJUZJTQSPNPUFECZGPDVTJOHPODPNNPOSFMBUJPOTBOEBCTUSBDUJOHBXBZ UIFiUIJOHwPSQBSUEJﬀFSFODFT7PO#FSUBMBOﬀZ QVUTJUUIJTXBZi6OJUZPG4DJFODFJT HSBOUFE OPUCZBVUPQJBOSFEVDUJPOPGBMMTDJFODFTUPQIZTJDTBOEDIFNJTUSZ CVUCZUIFTUSVDUVSBM VOJGPSNJUJFTPGUIFEJﬀFSFOUMFWFMTPGSFBMJUZwThBUJT VOJUZPGTDJFODFJTBDIJFWFEOPUBUUIFMPXFTU MFWFMQBSUTCVUBUUIFCSPBEFTUMFWFMDPODFQUT*OUFSNTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOTEFTDSJCFEJO $IBQUFS UIFSFEVDUJPOJTUQPTJUJPOXBTUIBUVOJUZPGTDJFODFJTBDIJFWFEBUUIFEFUBJMFECPUUPN PGUIFDPNQPTJUJPOTQFDUSVN XIJMFUIFTZTUFNTUIFPSJTUTBSHVFUIBUJUJTBDIJFWFEBUUIFUPQPGUIF HFOFSBMJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVN .04&4BMJHOTNPSFXJUIUIF,MJSo7PO#FSUBMBOﬀZHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOBSHVNFOU)PXFWFS PVS QPTJUJPOJTOPUBCPVUVOJUZPGTDJFODF QFSTF CVUBCPVUVOJﬁDBUJPOPGBMMBSFBTPGUIFFYQBOEFE 4&BOE4&4 UISPVHINPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOEUIFNPEFMTQBDF6OJﬁDBUJPOEPFTOPUNFBOFWFSZ UIJOHJTGPSDFEUPCFUIFTBNF*UNFBOTFWFSZUIJOHJTNBEFDPNNFOTVSBUFCZBDPNNPOGSBNF XPSLUSFBUJOHBMMFOHJOFFSJOHBSUJGBDUT TDJFOUJﬁDUIFPSJFTBOEMBXT BOENBUIFNBUJDBMSFMBUJPOT BTNPEFMTPGTZTUFNTThFGSBNFXPSLGBDJMJUBUFTDBQUVSJOHBOEFYQSFTTJOHJONPEFMTBMMFTTFOUJBM TJNJMBSJUJFTJOTZTUFNT BMMFTTFOUJBMEJﬀFSFODFTCFUXFFOTZTUFNT BOEBMMFTTFOUJBMTUBCJMJUJFTBOEBMM FTTFOUJBMDIBOHFT

Systems Taxonomy and the MOSES Foundation 4ZTUFN JT UIF NPTU HFOFSBM DPOTUSVDU UIF QJOOBDMF PG HFOFSBMJUZ PS DPNNPOBMJUZ JO UIF XPSME PGTZTUFNT)PXFWFS 44EPFTOPUTUPQUIFSF*UBMTPJEFOUJﬁFTBOEEJTUJOHVJTIFTCFUXFFOTZTUFN UZQFT )PX EP XF TUBSU DBUFHPSJ[JOH TZTUFNT EFTDFOEJOH GSPN UIBU QJOOBDMF 8IBU DBUFHPSJFT XPVMECFVTFGVM #FDBVTFXFBSFEFﬁOJOHBTDJFODFPG4& XFQSPDFFEBTGPMMPXT O ThFﬁSTUDBUFHPSZXJUIJO44JTUIFTFUPGTZTUFNTPGJOUFSFTUUP4&ThJTJODMVEFTBMMTZTUFNT UIBU4&FOHJOFFST FOWJSPONFOUTPGUIPTFTZTUFNT BOEDPNQPOFOUTPGUIPTFTZTUFNTJU BMTPJODMVEFTBMMNPEFMTPGUIPTFTZTUFNT FOWJSPONFOUT BOEDPNQPOFOUT

1a D1

1b D2

1c D3

1d D4

2. TS/CS diﬀerent in kind

2a Traditional systems

3. TS/CS diﬀerent in degree

3a Traditional

4. TS special case of CS

4 Traditional

5. Common to all SE systems

5

6. Common to all systems

6

1e D5

1f D6

1g D7

1h D8 2b

Complex systems 3b Complex

Complex

All SE systems Traditional and complex All systems

SES

1. Distinct domains*

Other supporting sciences

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

SS

46

Science foundation *Domains: Transportation; construction; aerospace; software; organizations; economy…

Figure 2.3

SE taxonomy and the range of supporting sciences.

O ThFOFYUTUFQJOUIFUBYPOPNZEJﬀFSFOUJBUFTBNPOH4&TZTUFNT1PTTJCMFDBUFHPSJFTJODMVEF PQFO WFSTVT DMPTFE TZTUFNT UBSHFU WFSTVT NPEFM TZTUFNT TNBMMTDBMF WFSTVT MBSHFTDBMF TZTUFNT USBEJUJPOBMWFSTVTDPNQMFYTZTUFNT QIZTJDBMWFSTVTDPODFQUVBMTZTUFNT OBUVSBM WFSTVTBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNT PSTUBCMFWFSTVTEZOBNJDTZTUFNT#FDBVTFPGUIFOBUVSFPGUIF FYQBOTJPOPG4& XFDIPPTFUIFUSBEJUJPOBM NFDIBOJTUJD WFSTVTDPNQMFY PSHBOJDBHFOU EJTUJODUJPOBTUIFOFYUDBUFHPSZMFWFM O 'JOBMMZ FBDIFOHJOFFSFETZTUFNJTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBOBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTVDIBTBFSP TQBDF PS USBOTQPSUBUJPO ThBU SFQSFTFOUT UIF ﬁOBM MFWFM PG DBUFHPSJFT JO PVS TZTUFNT UBYPOPNZ ThFSFTVMUJOHUBYPOPNZ TIPXOJO'JHVSF JTSFTQPOTJWFUPUIFOFFEGPSBOFYUFOEFEGPVOEBUJPO TVQQPSUJOHBOFYUFOEFEBOEVOJﬁFE4& BTXBTTIPXOJO'JHVSFThFTDPQFPGUIFDPOUSJCVU JOHEJTDJQMJOFTJOUIFGPVOEBUJPO TQFMMFEPVUJO5BCMF

SBOHFTGSPN44 XIJDITVQQPSUTBMM TZTUFNT UPEJTDJQMJOFTUIBUTVQQPSUTQFDJﬁDEPNBJOTTVDIBTUSBOTQPSUBUJPOPSDPOTUSVDUJPOThF TFQBSBUJPOBOEMJOFTCFUXFFOSPXBOEUIFPUIFSSPXTNFBOTUIBUNPTUJGOPUBMM4&EPNBJOT JODMVEFBNJYPGUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT 4PNFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBSFDPNNPOUPBMMTZTUFNTBOEBSFEFﬁOFEJOTZTUFNTTDJFODF SPX 0UIFSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBSFDPNNPOUPBMM4&TZTUFNTBOEBSFEFﬁOFEJO4&4 SPX ThFQPSUJPO PGUIFUBYPOPNZEJTUJOHVJTIJOH54GSPN$4SFﬂFDUTUISFFUZQFTPGSFMBUJPOT TIPXOJOSPXT BOEPG'JHVSF'PSTPNFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT 54TBSFBTQFDJBMDBTFPGUIFNPSFHFOFSBM$4DBTF "OFYBNQMFPGUIJTJTUIFQSFTVNFEUSBEJUJPOBMDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGBEFUFSNJOJTUJDTZTUFN XIJMFB DPNQMFYTZTUFNJTQSPCBCJMJTUJD%FUFSNJOJTUJDNFBOTBQSPCBCJMJUZPG XIJDIJTBTQFDJBMDBTF PSBQPJOUPOUIFQSPCBCJMJUZTQFDUSVNGSPNUP.BOZDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTSFQSFTFOUBEJﬀFSFODF JOEFHSFFCFUXFFO54BOE$4 SPX ThFTFSFﬂFDUBTQFDUSVNGSPNNPTUUSBEJUJPOBMUPNPTU DPNQMFY&YBNQMFTBSFEFHSFFPGVODFSUBJOUZ XJUIUSBEJUJPOBMCFJOHUIFNPTUDFSUBJOBOEEFHSFF PGBVUPOPNZ XJUIUIFUSBEJUJPOBMCFJOHUIFMFBTUBVUPOPNPVT4PNFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTSFQSFTFOUB EJﬀFSFODFJOLJOE SPX 'PSFYBNQMF BDPNQMFYTZTUFNDBOMFBSOXIJMFBUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFN DBOOPUMFBSO

Systems Science Context

O 47

*UJTJNQPSUBOUUPQPJOUPVUUIBUUIFTDPQFPG4&4BOE.04&4JTOPUKVTUSPXJO'JHVSF .04&4JTTDPQFEUPCFBTZOUIFTJTPGLOPXMFEHFGSPNBMMDPOUSJCVUJOHTDJFODFTBOESFMBUFEEJT DJQMJOFT BTEFMJOFBUFEJO5BCMF UIBUTVQQPSUBMMTJYSPXTJOUIFUBYPOPNZThJTLOPXMFEHF JODMVEFTXIBUJTDPNNPOUPBMMTZTUFNTBOEUPBMM4&TZTUFNT BOEJUJODMVEFTEJTUJODUJPOTCFUXFFO USBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT BOECFUXFFOEPNBJOT ThFDBUFHPSZPGBMMTZTUFNTJOSPXJTDMFBSMZCFZPOEUIFTDPQFPG4&)PXFWFS UIFTFDIBS BDUFSJTUJDTXJMMCFJODPSQPSBUFEJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFBGUFSBMM JGUIFZBSFUSVFPGBMMTZTUFNT UIFO UIFZBSFUSVFPG4&TZTUFNTBOEDBOCFVTFEJO4&'SPNUIJTQPJOUGPSXBSE TUBSUJOHXJUI$IBQUFS UIFTDPQFPGUIFEJTDVTTJPOXJMMCF4&TZTUFNTJOUFSNTPGUIFUBYPOPNZ SPXTUISPVHI "OPUIFSJNQPSUBOUJOUFSQSFUBUJPOPGUIFUBYPOPNZPGTZTUFNTJO'JHVSF FTQFDJBMMZUIF54 WFSTVT$4QPSUJPO JTUIBUUIFﬁHVSFEPFTOPUTBZUIBUDFSUBJOTZTUFNTBSFJOIFSFOUMZPOUIF54TJEF BOEPUIFSTBSFJOIFSFOUMZPOUIF$4TJEFThFDPSSFDUJOUFSQSFUBUJPOJTUIBUBTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSPS BDPNNVOJUZDIPPTFTUPNPEFMBEFTJHOBUFETZTUFNBTNFDIBOJTUJD BTPSHBOJD PSTPNFXIFSFJO CFUXFFO*OQBSUJDVMBS XFFYQFDUUIBUNBOZNBDIJOFTFOHJOFFSFEJO4&XJMMVTFGVMMZCFNPEFMFE BTPSHBOJDTZTUFNTPSBHFOUT ThFEJTDVTTJPOJOUIJTCPPLEPFTOPUVOJGPSNMZDPWFSBMMUIFTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT'PSFYBN QMF JUEJTDVTTFTIPX$44TVQQPSUT4&NPSFUIBOJUEPFTIPXNBUIFNBUJDTTVQQPSUT4&ThJTJT OPU CFDBVTF NBUIFNBUJDT JT MFTT JNQPSUBOU UP 4& CVU SBUIFS CFDBVTF JUT TVQQPSU GPS 4& JT DVS SFOUMZCFUUFSVOEFSTUPPEBOEBQQMJFENPSFFYUFOTJWFMZUIBOJTUIFTVQQPSUPG$44"OFYDFQUJPO JTUIBUUIJTCPPLEPFTBEESFTTUIFJNQPSUBOUBSFBPGQSPCBCJMJUZBOETUBUJTUJDT FTQFDJBMMZJUTSPMF JONPEFMJOHBOETQFDJGZJOHVODFSUBJOUZ8FBMTPOPUFUIBUDPOUJOVPVTNBUIBOEEJTDSFUFNBUI NBQBQQSPYJNBUFMZUPRVBOUJUBUJWFBOERVBMJUBUJWFNPEFMT BMUIPVHIUIFRVBMJUBUJWFDBUFHPSZHPFT CFZPOENBUIFNBUJDT ThJTDIBQUFSBEESFTTFEUIFTDJFODFFOHJOFFSJOHBYJT BOEUIFTVQQPSUJOHTZTUFNTTDJFODFDPNQP OFOU PG.04&4ThJTJOGPSNBUJPO BMPOHXJUIUIFTZTUFNTUBYPOPNZ XJMMTFSWFBTBDPOUFYUGPSUIF SFNBJOEFSPGUIFCPPL XIJDIEJTDVTTFTNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOEUIFNPEFMTQBDFJOHSFBUFSEFUBJM

References "TICZ 833FRVJTJUFWBSJFUZBOEJUTJNQMJDBUJPOTGPSUIFDPOUSPMPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNT $ZCFSOFUJDB o 3FRVJTJUF WBSJFUZ BMTP EJTDVTTFE JO "TICZ 83 "O *OUSPEVDUJPO UP $ZCFSOFUJDT /FX:PSL+PIO8JMFZ4POT

#BF[ +BOE.4UBZ'PSUIDPNJOH1IZTJDT 5PQPMPHZ -PHJDBOE$PNQVUBUJPO"3PTFUUB4UPOF5PBQQFBS JO#$PFDLF &E

/FX4USVDUVSFTGPS1IZTJDT4QSJOHFSIUUQNBUIVDSFEVIPNFCBF[SPTFUUBQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#PVMEJOH ,(FOFSBMTZTUFNTUIFPSy — The skeleton of science. .BOBHFNFOU4DJFODF o #VTDINBOO ' 3 .FVOJFS ) 3PIOFSU 1 4PNNFSMBE BOE . 4UBM 1BUUFSO0SJFOUFE 4PGUXBSF "SDIJUFDUVSF"4ZTUFNPG1BUUFSOT$IJDIFTUFS 6,+PIO8JMFZ $ISJTUFOTFO $ The *OOPWBUPST %JMFNNB The 3FWPMVUJPOBSZ#PPLUIBU8JMM$IBOHFUIF8BZ:PV %P #VTJOFTT/FX:PSL$PMMJOT#VTJOFTT $PMMJOT -6TFPG.PEFMTJOUIF4PDJBM4DJFODFT/FX:PSL8FTUWJFX1SFTT $POBOU 3BOE83"TICZ&WFSZHPPESFHVMBUPSPGBTZTUFNNVTUCFBNPEFMPGUIBUTZTUFN*OU+ 4ZTUFNT4DJ o %PSMBOE 8%PSMBOET*MMVTUSBUFE.FEJDBM%JDUJPOBSZ1IJMBEFMQIJB 1"4BVOEFST &MESJEHF /BOE4(PVME1VODUVBUFEFRVJMJCSJBBOBMUFSOBUJWFUPQIZMFUJDHSBEVBMJTN*O4DIPQG 5 &E

.PEFMTJO1BMFPOUPMPHZ4BO'SBODJTDP'SFFNBO$PPQFS 'JODI +&OHJOFFSJOHBOE8FTUFSO$JWJMJ[BUJPO/FX:PSL.D(SBX)JMM

48

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

(BNNB & 3)FMN 3+PIOTPO BOE+7MJTTJEFT%FTJHO1BUUFSOT&MFNFOUTPG3FVTBCMF0CKFDU0SJFOUFE 4PGUXBSF3FBEJOH .""EEJTPO8FTMFZ (IBSBKFEBHIJ +4ystems Thinking: MBOBHJOH$IBPTBOE$PNQMFYJUZ#PTUPO#VUUFSXPSUI)FJOFNBOO (JFSF 34DJFODFXJUIPVU-BXT$IJDBHP6OJWFSTJUZPG$IJDBHP1SFTT (JFSF 3)PXNPEFMTBSFVTFEUPSFQSFTFOUSFBMJUZ1IJMPTPQIZPG4DJFODF o (riﬃn, . 4ZTUFN &OHJOFFSJOH BOE UIF i5XP $VMUVSFTw PG &OHJOFFSJOH #PFJOH -FDUVSF 1VSEVF 6OJWFSTJUZ .BSDI IUUQTFOHJOFFSJOHQVSEVFFEV""&"CPVU6T/FXT&WFOUTEPDVNFOUT (riﬃnBoeingLecturFQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)BSSÏ 3$POTUSVDUJWFSPMFPGNPEFMT*O$PMMJOT -6TFPG.PEFMTJOUIF4PDJBM4DJFODFT/FX :PSL8FTUWJFX1SFTT Q )BXLJOH 4"#SJFG)JTUPSZPG5JNF'SPNUIF#JH#BOHUP#MBDL)PMFT/FX:PSL#BOUBN#PPLT )FTTF ..PEFMTWFSTVTQBSBEJHNTJOUIFOBUVSBMTDJFODFT*O$PMMJOT -6TFPG.PEFMTJOUIF 4PDJBM4DJFODFT/FX:PSL8FTUWJFX1SFTT Qo )POEFSJDI5The OYGPSE$PNQBOJPOUP1IJMPTPQIZ/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT ,MJS ('BDFUTPG4ZTUFNT4DJFODF/FX:PSL,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1MFOVN1VCMJTIFST ,PFTUMFS "The GIPTUJOUIF.BDIJOF/FX:PSL.BDNJMMBO ,VIO 5The SUSVDUVSe of Scientiﬁc RFWPMVUJPOT OEFE$IJDBHP6OJWPG$IJDBHP1SFTT -FINBOO .BOE-#FMBEZ1SPHSBN&WPMVUJPO -POEPO"DBEFNJD1SFTT .BZS & The (SPXUI PG #JPMPHJDBM Thought: %JWFSTJUZ &WPMVUJPO BOE *OIFSJUBODF $BNCSJEHF ." )BSWBSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT .JMMFS (The NBHJDBMOVNCFSTFWFO QMVTPSNJOVTUXPTPNFMJNJUTPOPVSDBQBDJUZGPSQSPDFTTJOH JOGPSNBUJPOThe PTZDIPMPHJDBM3FWJFX o 1PPSF +"UBMFPGUISFFEJTDJQMJOFTzBOEBSFWPMVUJPO$PNQVUFS o 4IBX .1SPTQFDUTGPSBOFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOFPGTPGUXBSF*&&&4PGUXBSF o 4JNPO )The 4DJFODFTPGUIF"Stiﬁcial, SEFE$BNCSJEHF .".*51SFTT 0SJHJOBMMZQVCMJTIFE

4JPVSJT (.JTTJMF(VJEBODFBOE$POUSPM4ZTUFNT/FX:PSL4QSJOHFS 4NVUT + )PMJTN BOE &WPMVUJPO -POEPO .BDNJMMBO 3FQSJOUFE 4IFSNBO 0BLT $" 4JFSSB 4VOSJTF1VCMJTIJOH ª4BOGPSE)PMTU

7JODFOUJ 88IBU&OHJOFFST,OPXBOE)PXThey ,OPX*U"OBMZUJDBM4UVEJFTGSPN"FSPOBVUJDBM)JTUPSZ #BMUJNPSe, MD: The JPIOT)PQLJOT6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT 7PO #FStalanﬀy - .PEFSO Theories PG %FWFMPQNFOU "O *OUSPEVDUJPO UP TheorFUJDBM #JPMPHZ 0YGPSE 0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT 7PO #FStalanﬀy - (FOFSBM 4ZTUFNT TheorZ 'PVOEBUJPOT %FWFMPQNFOU "QQMJDBUJPOT /FX :PSL (FPSHF#SB[JMMFS 8arﬁeld, J.N. 1994. "4DJFODFPG(FOFSJD%FTJHO"NFT *"*PXB4UBUF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT 8JFOFS /$ZCFSOFUJDT PS$POUSPMBOE$PNNVOJDBUJPOJOUIF"OJNBMBOE.BDIJOF OEFE $BNCSJEHF .".*51SFTT

Chapter 3

Core Concepts of ModelOriented SE Science (MOSES) i5PTFFXIBUJTHFOFSBMJOXIBUJTQBSUJDVMBSBOEXIBUJTQFSNBOFOUJOXIBUJTUSBOTJ UPSZJTUIFBJNPGTDJFOUJﬁDUIPVHIUw "8IJUFIFBE "O*OUSPEVDUJPOUP.BUIFNBUJDT Systems taxonomy 1

Modeling scope

SE Application Domains (D1...Dn)

Collective actualization space

D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn

Problem space

3a

TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b Traditional Complex

Characteristics of all systems

Highest level system

Deﬁne need

Complex 4 Traditional TS is special case 5 Characteristics of all SE systems Traditional and Complex 6

Model Space

All SE application domains...

Indivisible Unit Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Composition

TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b 2a Traditional systems Complex systems

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

ThJTDIBQUFSJOUSPEVDFTTPNFPGUIFCBTJDDPO DFQUTPGNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOESFMBUFEGFBUVSFTPG NPEFMPSJFOUFE4&TDJFODF .04&4 ThFNBJO UPQJDTBSF ﬁSTU BOFYBNQMFPGIPX.04&4DBO CFBQQMJFE BOEUIFODPSFDPODFQUTPG.04&4 JO UXP QBSUT TZTUFNSFMBUFE DPODFQUT BOE DPOOFDUJPOSFMBUFEDPODFQUT

Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

e

m Ti

Produce solution

Deployment

Satisfy need

Solution/system space

MOSES in Action: A Story about Building an Automated Car ThJTJTBTUPSZBCPVU#PCBOEIJTDPMMFBHVFTXIPVTFUIF.04&4BQQSPBDIUPCVJMEBDBSUIBUDBO ESJWFJUTFMG*OUIJTTFDUJPOXFEFWFMPQUIFFYBNQMFBOETIPXTPNFGFBUVSFTPG.04&4-BUFSXF SFGFSCBDLUPUIJTFYBNQMFBOEVTFJUUPJMMVTUSBUFBEEJUJPOBMGFBUVSFT The HFOFSBMHPBM#PCJTBTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSXIPVTFTUIFBQQSPBDIEFTDSJCFEJOUIJTCPPL)F IBTBDPMMFBHVFXIPJTBSPCPUJDTEFTJHOFS BOEBOPUIFSDPMMFBHVFXIPJTBOBVUPNPUJWFFOHJOFFS They EFDJEFUIBUUIFZXJMMEFTJHOBOECVJMEBOBVUPNBUFEDBSUIBUDBOESJWFGSPNBOZDVSSFOUMPDB UJPOUPBOZEFTJSFEMPDBUJPO TVDIBTGSPN#PCTIPNFUPIJToﬃce. They XJMMVTF.04&4JOUIJT QSPKFDU8IBUEPFTUIBUNFBO The TUPSZUIBUGPMMPXTOBSSBUFTIPX.04&4JTBQQMJFEUPFOHJOFFS B TPMVUJPO *U DPWFST UIF UPQJDT PG BVUPNBUJPO JTTVFT VTJOH BOE UBJMPSJOH NPEFMT BQQSPBDIFT UP MFBSOJOH MBOHVBHFBOEQSFDJTJPOPGNPEFMT FOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTBOEUPPMT Weriﬁcation BOEUFTU JOH BVUPNBUJPOGFBUVSFT BOEEPDVNFOUJOH"TJEFCBSPVUMJOJOHNVMUJQMFUZQFTPGNPEFMTGPSUIJT QSPCMFNJTBMTPQSPWJEFE 49

50 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Setting the Stage MOSES 0OF PG UIF GBDUPST JO UIF BQQSPBDI UP FOHJOFFSJOH B TZTUFN JT UIF EFHSFF UP XIJDI UIF HFO FSBMGPSNPGBHJWFOQSPCMFNJTLOPXOBOEVOEFSTUPPE BOEUIFHFOFSBMGPSNPGTPMVUJPOTBSF LOPXO VOEFSTUPPE BOEBWBJMBCMF*GUIFHFOFSBMQSPCMFNBOETPMVUJPOBSFLOPXO UIFOUIF TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSDBOVTFUIBUHFOFSBMLOPXMFEHFBOEUBJMPSJUGPSBTQFDJﬁDQSPCMFNThFTPMV UJPONBZCFJOUIFGPSNPGBHFOFSBMEFTJHO XIJDIDBOCFUBJMPSFEGPSUIJTQSPCMFN PSJOUIF GPSNPGDPNNFSDJBMMZBWBJMBCMFQSPEVDUT XIJDIDBOCFCPVHIU*O.04&4 LOPXOQSPCMFNT BOETPMVUJPOTBSFDIBSBDUFSJ[FEBTCFJOHDBQUVSFEJOBNPEFMTQBDFBOENBEFBWBJMBCMFUPBDPN NVOJUZThFNPEFMTQBDFJTBWJSUVBMSFQPTJUPSZPGUIFCPEZPGLOPXMFEHF #P, PGBEPNBJO 'PSTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH UIFTDPQFPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFDPWFSTBMMEPNBJOTUIBU4&TVQQPSUT UIF BQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT

UIFEPNBJOPG4&JUTFMG BOEBMMEPNBJOTXIPTFLOPXMFEHFJTSFRVJSFE UPQFSGPSN4& UIFTVQQPSUJOHEPNBJOT JODMVEJOHNBUIFNBUJDTBOETDJFODF BTEFMJOFBUFEJO $IBQUFS ThFLOPXMFEHFJTSFQSFTFOUFEJOUIFGPSNPGNPEFMT XIJDIDBOWBSJPVTMZCFJOUFS QSFUFEBTTJNVMBUJPONPEFMT SFRVJSFNFOUTTFUT DPODFQUTPGPQFSBUJPO BSDIJUFDUVSFT EFTJHOT BOEBOZPUIFSFOHJOFFSJOHBSUJGBDU'PSNBUVSFEPNBJOT UIFCBTJDQSPDFTTJTUPﬁOEHFOFSBM NPEFMTUIBUﬁUUIFFOHJOFFSJOHUBTLBUIBOE BOEUBJMPSUIFTFNPEFMTUPﬁUUIFTQFDJﬁDQSPCMFN CFJOHBEESFTTFEBOEUIFTQFDJﬁDFOWJSPONFOUJOXIJDIUIFQSPCMFNJTUPCFTPMWFE 0OUIFPUIFSIBOE JGUIFQSPCMFNJTOFX JUSFTFNCMFTBSFTFBSDIBOEEFWFMPQNFOUTJUVBUJPO BOEUIBUSFRVJSFTNPSFFYQFSJNFOUJOHBOEDSFBUJWFBDUJWJUZ'FXJGBOZNPEFMTXJMMCFJOUIFNPEFM TQBDF BOEOFXNPEFMTXJMMIBWFUPCFHFOFSBUFE*GJUJTGFMUUIBUUIJTOFXQSPCMFNBOETPMVUJPO NBZCFPGJOUFSFTUJOTPMWJOHPUIFSSFMBUFEQSPCMFNTJOUIFGVUVSF UIFOUIFNPEFMTSFTVMUJOHGSPN UIFFOHJOFFSJOHFﬀPSUGPSUIJTFYQFSJNFOUBMTZTUFNXJMMCFQVUJOUPUIFNPEFMTQBDFGPSPUIFSTUP VTFBOEFWPMWF.PSFEFUBJMTPGUIFQBSUTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFBQQFBSJO$IBQUFS

Problem Situation ThF QSPCMFN PG BVUPNBUJOH DBS ESJWFST IBT DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PG BVUPOPNPVT BHFOUT BOE SPCPUJDT TQFDJBMJ[FEGPSBUSBﬃDFOWJSPONFOUThFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTEFTDSJCFEIFSFBSFBEBQUFEGSPN;FMMFS BOE.PDL)FDLFS

XIPEFﬁOFEUIFNJOUIFDPOUFYUPGTJNVMBUJOHNVMUJQMFBHFOUTESJWJOH JOUSBﬃc. ThFQSPCMFNJODMVEFTUIFGPMMPXJOHDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT O "OBVUPNBUFEBVUPOPNPVTBHFOU IBSEXBSFBOETPGUXBSF JTPVSTZTUFNPGJOUFSFTU BOE JUJTEFBMJOHXJUIBOFOWJSPONFOUUIBUJODMVEFTNBDIJOFT DBST BOEIVNBOBVUPOPNPVT BHFOUT ESJWFST 0OFWJFXPGUIJTPWFSBMMQJDUVSFJTBDPNNVOJUZPGBVUPOPNPVTJOUFSBDU JOHBHFOUTUIBUFYIJCJUBDPNCJOBUJPOPGDPPQFSBUJPOBOEDPNQFUJUJPO O ThJT DPNNVOJUZ SFQSFTFOUT B TFMGPSHBOJ[JOH TFMGBEBQUJOH TZTUFN PG FMFNFOUT XIPTF JOUFSBDUJPOTBOEDPOﬂJDUTNVTUCFTPMWFEJOSFBMUJNFXJUIPVUBDFOUSBMTVQFSWJTPS

/PUFUIBUUIFJTTVFPGJOUFMMFDUVBMQSPQFSUZSJHIUTBOEDMBJNTJTOPUJHOPSFEJO.04&4ThBUJTTVFQVUTDPO TUSBJOUTPOXIBUJTNBEFBWBJMBCMFUPUIFMBSHFSDPNNVOJUZThFQPJOUPG.04&4JOUIJTSFHBSEJTOPUUPDIBOHF JOUFMMFDUVBMQSPQFSUZSVMFT CVUSBUIFSUPDBQUVSFBOETZOUIFTJ[FLOPXMFEHFDVSSFOUMZBWBJMBCMFJOUIFQVCMJD GPSVNGSPNCPPLT QBQFST BOEPOMJOFTPVSDFTBOEPSHBOJ[FJUJOUIFNPEFMJOHTQBDF*OBEEJUJPO FBDIDPNQBOZ PSPSHBOJ[BUJPOPSQFSTPODBOFYUFOEUIJTDPNNPOCBTFXJUIUIFJSPXOTQFDJﬁDLOPXMFEHF JODMVEJOHUIFJS VOTIBSFEJOUFMMFDUVBMQSPQFSUZ

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O

51

O *UJTBEZOBNJDDPNNVOJUZ'SPNUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGPVSBVUPNBUFEESJWFS UIJTNFBOTUIBU UIFFOWJSPONFOUPUIFSESJWFST UIFSPBE FUDDIBOHFTDPOUJOVPVTMZ O &WFSZBHFOUIBTJUTPXOHPBMT O &WFSZBHFOUIBTJUTPXOTFOTPSBOEJOGPSNBUJPOQSPDFTTJOHDPNQPOFOU TPJUDBOQMBOUIF BDUJPOTUPSFBDIJUTHPBMJOEFQFOEFOUMZ O ThFBHFOUTNVTUDPPQFSBUFUPTPNFFYUFOUUPSFBDIUIFJSHPBMTCVUUIFZDBOOPUDPNNVOJ DBUFBOEOFHPUJBUFFYQMJDJUMZ O ThFDPNCJOBUJPOPGPVSBVUPNBUFEESJWFSBOEDBSJTBIZCSJETZTUFNUIBUJT JUJODMVEFT CPUINBDIJOFTBOEBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUT *GXFDPOTJEFSUIBUPVSBVUPNBUFEBHFOUJTUIFJOGPSNBUJPOQSPDFTTPSBOEEFDJTJPONBLFSJO ESJWJOHUIFDBS UIFOUIFMBSHFSDBSESJWFSQSPCMFNJOWPMWFTUISFFCBTJDFMFNFOUTTFOTPSTUPEFUFDU UIFFOWJSPONFOU BQSPDFTTPSUPQSPDFTTUIFJOGPSNBUJPOBOEEFDJEFXIBUBDUJPOUPUBLF BOEBDUVB UPSTUPFﬀFDUUIFCFIBWJPSPGUIFDBS TVDIBTNBJOUBJOPSDIBOHFTQFFEPSEJSFDUJPO FUD

Automation Issues *O UIJT FYBNQMF DBTF PG BO BVUPNBUFE DBS UIF TJUVBUJPO JT UIBU UIFSF BSF UXP SFMBUJWFMZ NBUVSF FMFNFOUTCVUUIFZNVTUCFCSPVHIUUPHFUIFSJOQFSIBQTBOFXXBZ$MFBSMZ DBSTSFQSFTFOUBWFSZ NBUVSF FOHJOFFSJOH EPNBJO BOE SPCPUJDT JT B GBJSMZ NBUVSF EPNBJO 8F BTTVNF UIBU SPCPUJDT JODMVEFTCPUIUIFIBSEXBSFBOETPGUXBSFBHFOUFMFNFOUT CPUITFOTPSTBOEBDUVBUPST#FDBVTFUIJT FYBNQMFJTJOUFOEFEUPTIPXXIBU.04&4JTBOEIPXJUXPVMECFVTFEJGBEPQUFE XFXJMMBTTVNF UIBUUIFSFBSFNBOZNPEFMTPGDBSTBOESPCPUTBWBJMBCMFJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF*OUIJTDPOUFYU UIF UBTLPG#PCBOEIJTDPMMFBHVFTJTUPVTFUIFFYJTUJOHLOPXMFEHFBOENPEFMTPGDBSTBOESPCPUT BOE TPNFIPXQSPEVDFBWBSJBOUPGBDBSUIBUIBTJUTPXOCVJMUJOSPCPUJDESJWFSThJTDPNCJOBUJPONBZ DBVTFTPNFDIBOHFTUPBiOPSNBMDBSwBOEUPBiOPSNBMSPCPUw

Using and Tailoring Models )PXEPUIFZVTFBOEUBJMPSUIFNPEFMT TheNPEFMTPGDBSTUIBU#PCSFUSJFWFTGSPNUIFNPEFM TQBDF SFQPTJUPSZ BTTVNF UIBU UIF ESJWFS JT MPDBUFE JO POF QMBDF CFIJOE UIF TUFFSJOH XIFFM BOE PUIFS DPOUSPMT BOE IBT GPSXBSEGBDJOH WJTVBM TFOTPST *G XF BSF HPJOH UP BVUPNBUF UIF ESJWFS GVODUJPO XFBSFOPMPOHFSDPOTUSBJOFEUPIBWFUIFSPCPUJOPOFMPDBUJPO PSUPIBWFUIFTFUPG DPOUSPMTUIBUXFIBWFOPX#PCSVOTTPNFTJNVMBUJPOTJOEJDBUJOHUIBUBNPSFPQUJNVNESJWFS XPVMECFEJTUSJCVUFE4FOTPSTXPVMECFQPTJUJPOFEJOUIFQMBDFTXJUIUIFCFTUWJTVBMBDDFTTJOBMM EJSFDUJPOTGSPNUIFDBS TPUIFZDBOTFOTFBMMBEKBDFOUWFIJDMFTBOEPCKFDUTBTXFMMBTUIFJSQSPYJN JUZBOESFMBUJWFNPWFNFOU"DUVBUPSTXPVMECFQPTJUJPOFEDMPTF JOTPNFTFOTF UPXIBUUIFZBSF BDUVBUJOHFOHJOF USBOTNJTTJPO BOE VMUJNBUFMZ UIFXIFFMTBOEUJSFTGPSBDDFMFSBUJOH UVSOJOH BOECSBLJOH'PSUIFGPSFTFFBCMFGVUVSF UIFESJWFSDPOUSPMTOPXJOQMBDF TUFFSJOHXIFFM BDDFMFSB UPS CSBLF NJSSPST FUD XPVMEMJLFMZSFNBJOUPBMMPXNBOVBMPWFSSJEFJGOFFEFE*GBUTPNFQPJOU JOUIFGVUVSFUIFBVUPNBUFEUFDIOPMPHZCFDBNFTVﬃDJFOUMZSFMJBCMFBOEUSVTUFE UIFIVNBOESJWFS DPOUSPMTNJHIUCFSFNPWFEBOEUIFESJWFSTTFBUXPVMECFDPNFKVTUBOPUIFSQBTTFOHFSTFBU *OBOZDBTF UIFQBTTFOHFSDPOUSPMTXPVMESFNBJOThFZJODMVEFUFNQFSBUVSFDPOUSPM TFBUQPTJ UJPO XJOEPXDPOUSPM BOEDPOUSPMTGPSSBEJP $% PSPUIFSFOUFSUBJONFOUNFEJVN8JOETIJFME XJQFSTPSJDFTDSBQFSTXPVMEOPUCFOFFEFECZUIFTFOTPSTCVUXPVMEMJLFMZCFSFUBJOFEGPSCBDLVQ IVNBOESJWJOHPSGPSQBTTFOHFSTUPTFFUIFFOWJSPONFOU

52

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThFSPCPUJDTNPEFMTXPVMECFJOUIFGPSNPGIBSEXBSFBOETPGUXBSFNPEFMTThFIBSEXBSF XPVME JODMVEF UIF TFOTPST BOE XPVME BDUVBUF UIF UVSOJOH BDDFMFSBUJPO BOE CSBLJOH FMFNFOUT PG UIF DBS ThF TPGUXBSF BOE EBUB XPVME JODMVEF BMM UIF SVMFT QBUUFSOT BOE NPEFMT PG ESJW JOHJUXPVMESFDFJWFJOGPSNBUJPOGSPNUIFTFOTPSTBOEXPVMETFOEJOGPSNBUJPOUPUIFBDUVBUPST Th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hFSFGPSF NPEFMTPGNBDIJOFMFBSOJOHXJMMBMTPCFSFUSJFWFEGSPNUIFNPEFMTQBDF ThFSFBTPOGPSJEFOUJGZJOHUIFTFDIBOHFTBOESFRVJSFNFOUTJTUIBUUIJTJTQBSUPGUIFQSPDFTT #PCBOEIJTDPMMFBHVFTHPUISPVHIUPﬁOEBOEUBJMPSNPEFMTUPﬁUUIFUZQFPGTZTUFNUIFZXBOU UPDSFBUF ThFSFTVMUJTBDPNCJOFEDBSSPCPUTZTUFNUIBUJTBNPEJﬁFEDBSXJUIBNPEJﬁFEEJTUSJCVUFE SPCPUESJWJOHJUCBTFEPOEJSFDUJPOTGSPNUIFQBTTFOHFS T

Approaches to Learning 0OFPGUIFNPTUDIBMMFOHJOHFMFNFOUTPGCVJMEJOHUIJTTZTUFNJTFﬀFDUJWFMZUFBDIJOHUIFSPCPUIPX UPESJWFThFSFBSFBUMFBTUUISFFQPTTJCMFBQQSPBDIFT XIJDIXFDBMM QSFEFﬁOFESVMFTCBTFE TJNVMBUJPOMFBSOJOHCBTFE BOE PCTFSWBUJPOMFBSOJOHCBTFE

Approach 1: Predeﬁned Rules Based ThFFOHJOFFSTEFﬁOFBMMUIFSVMFTBOEDPODFQUTBOEESJWJOHQBUUFSOTGPSUIFSPCPU MPBEUIFTFBT JOTUSVDUJPOTGPSUIFSPCPU IBWFUIFSPCPUPQFSBUFUIFDBS JOJUJBMMZWJBTJNVMBUPS MBUFSJOﬁFMEUFTUJOH

SFﬁOFUIFSVMFT BOESFQFBUMPPQVOUJMSVMFTBSFTVﬃcJFOUUPFOBCMFSPCPUUPPQFSBUFDBSXJUIB DPNQFUFODFTJNJMBSUPBOBEVMUIVNBOESJWFS ThFSVMFTBOEQBUUFSOTJODMVEF O $PODFQUTTVDIBTFYUFSOBMWFIJDMF QFEFTUSJBO SPBE MBOF EJSFDUJPO TQFFE BOETFMGBXBSFOFTT PGTUBUFPGUIFDBS O 1SJNJUJWFESJWJOHQBUUFSOTTVDIBTNPWFGPSXBSEBWPJEIJUUJOHPUIFSWFIJDMFT O *OUFSNFEJBUFQBUUFSOTTVDIBTUVSOMFGUBUUIFOFYUTUPQMJHIUUVSOSJHIUBUUIFOFYUJOUFSTFD UJPO; ﬁOEBQBSLJOHTQPU

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O 53

O 3PVUFQBUUFSOT XIJDIBSFSPVUFTDPNNPOMZUBLFOCFUXFFOHJWFOMPDBUJPOT TVDIBT#PCT IPNFUPPﬃcF O 3PVUFQMBOOJOHQBUUFSO XIJDIﬁOETBOBQQSPQSJBUFSPVUFUPHFUGSPNDVSSFOUMPDBUJPOUP EFTJSFEMPDBUJPO CBTFEPODVSSFOUSPBEBOEUSBﬃc cPOEJUJPOT 4FFUIFTJEFCBSFOUJUMFEi&YBNQMF%SJWJOH.PEFMTPS1BUUFSOTwGPSBNPSFFYUFOEFEMJTUPGUIFTF DBUFHPSJFTPGQBUUFSOT

Approach 2: Simulation Learning Based 4QFDJGZBNJOJNBMTFUPGTUBSUFSSVMFTGPSFYBNQMF .PWFGPSXBSEUPXBSEEFTUJOBUJPO 4UBZPOSPBE "WPJEIJUUJOHPUIFSPCKFDUT ThFO TFMFDU B MFBSOJOH NPEFM GSPN DBUFHPSJFT TVDI BT BSUJﬁDJBM OFVSBM OFUXPSLT PS .BSLPW DIBJO.POUF$BSMPNFUIPET BOETJNVMBUFESJWJOHTJUVBUJPOTUIBUFOBCMFUIFSPCPUUPMFBSOIPX UPESJWFFTTFOUJBMMZCVJMEJOHVQUIFQBUUFSOTUIBU#PCBOEIJTDPMMFBHVFTXPVMEOFFEUPTQFDJGZ JO"QQSPBDI

Approach 3: Observation Learning Based ThFSPCPU PSUIFFOHJOFFST PSBDPNCJOBUJPO MFBSOUIFSVMFTUISPVHIBOBMZTJTPGUSBﬃc CFIBW JPS GPMMPXFEVQCZTJNVMBUPSGFFECBDLUPUIFSPCPU"QSFDPOEJUJPOPGUIJTJTUIFBWBJMBCJMJUZ PGBTJHOJﬁDBOUTBNQMFPGWJEFPSFDPSEJOHTPGUSBﬃc NPWFNFOUBOEﬂPXUIBUTIPXTUIFHBNVU PGUSBﬃDBDUJWJUZBOEDPOEJUJPOTThJTWJEFPTBNQMFXPVMENBLFWJTJCMFJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUUIF CFIBWJPSPGBHJWFODBSUIBUJODMVEFTTQBDJOHBOENPWFNFOUPGPUIFSOFBSCZWFIJDMFT BOEUIF HJWFODBSTCFIBWJPSSFMBUJWFUPTUPQTJHOT TUPQMJHIUT SPBETJHOT TQFFEMJNJUTJHOT WJTJCJMJUZ XFBUIFS DPOEJUJPOT SPBE DPOEJUJPOT BOE USBﬃc DPOEJUJPOT FH IFBWZ MJHIU ThFO FJUIFS UIFSPCPUPSUIFFOHJOFFSTFYUSBDUBOEBCTUSBDUGSPNUIFWJEFPNPEFMT SVMFT BOEQBUUFSOTPG PCTFSWFEDBSCFIBWJPSJOUIFUSBﬃc FOWJSPONFOUTh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ﬃc oOBWFSBHFNPWFTBUTQFFE4

54 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O *G4 49 UIFQSPCBCJMJUZPGCFJOHTUPQQFECZBQPMJDFDBSSJTFTGSPNUP O *G4 49 UIFQSPCBCJMJUZPGBDBSCFJOHJOBOBDDJEFOUSJTFTGSPNBQSPCBCJMJUZPG 1BUP1C ThJT NFUIPE DPVME HFOFSBUF NBOZ PG UIF ESJWJOH QBUUFSOT CVU XPVME QSPCBCMZ OFFE UP CF TVQQMFNFOUFECZ"QQSPBDIJGUIFFOHJOFFSTBSFEPJOHUIFSVMFTFYUSBDUJPO PSCZ"QQSPBDIJG UIFSPCPUFYUSBDUTUIFSVMFTThFFOHJOFFST BTTVNJOHUIFZIBWFESJWJOHFYQFSJFODFJOUSBﬃc IBWF BTJHOJﬁDBOUBEWBOUBHFCFDBVTFUIFZBMSFBEZLOPXNVDIPGUIFJOGPSNBUJPOBOENBOZPGUIFSVMFT UISPVHIUIFJSPXOFYQFSJFODF XIFSFBTUIFSPCPUJTTUBSUJOHXJUIBCMBOLTMBUFThFPCTFSWFEUSBG ﬁDXPVMESFﬂFDUBSBOHFPGESJWJOHIBCJUTGSPNQPPSUPHPPE BEJTUJODUJPOUIBUJTIJOUFEBUJOUIF TBNQMFSVMFTBCPWFThJTEJTUJODUJPO BOEXIBUUIFSPCPUMFBSOTGSPNJU BSFGVSUIFSEJTDVTTFECFMPX VOEFSi%FGFOTJWF%SJWJOHw 0CTFSWFUIBU"QQSPBDIJMMVTUSBUFTBTDJFODFPGESJWJOH CZPVSEFﬁOJUJPOPGTDJFODFJO$IBQUFS CFDBVTFJUEFﬁOFTQBUUFSOTCBTFEPOPCTFSWBUJPOTPGFYJTUJOHTZTUFNT"SFMBUFEBOETPNFXIBU NPSFTVCUMFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDUIBUEJTUJOHVJTIFT"QQSPBDIFTBOEGSPN"QQSPBDIJTUIBUUIFSVMFT EFﬁOFEJOUIFﬁSTUUXPBQQSPBDIFTBSFQSFTDSJQUJWF ESJWFUIJTXBZEPOPUESJWFUIBUXBZ FUD

XIJMFUIFSVMFTEFﬁOFEJO"QQSPBDIBSFEFTDSJQUJWF JGBDBSCFIBWFTUIJTXBZ 9XJMMIBQQFO XJUIQSPCBCJMJUZ1YJGUIBUXBZ :XJMMIBQQFOXJUIQSPCBCJMJUZ1Z FUD ThFEFTDSJQUJWFSVMFT JO"QQSPBDIDBOUIFOCFVTFEBTBCBTJTGPSQSFTDSJQUJWFSVMFTTJNJMBSUPUIPTFJOUIFﬁSTUUXP BQQSPBDIFTThFSFBTPOUIFZDBOCFNBEFQSFTDSJQUJWFJTUIBU#PCBOEIJTDPMMFBHVFTQMBDFBQPTJ UJWFWBMVFPOUIFSPCPUTDBSCFIBWJOHJOBXBZUIBUBWPJETDPOUBDUXJUIPUIFSWFIJDMFT BOEQMBDFB OFHBUJWFWBMVFPOUIFDBSCFIBWJOHJOBXBZUIBUSFTVMUTJODPMMJTJPOT PSHFUUJOHTQFFEJOHUJDLFUT PSPUIFSESJWJOHiJODJEFOUTw ThFEJTDVTTJPOIFSFSFMBUFTUPUXPGFBUVSFTPG.04&4UIBUBSFEJT DVTTFEJO$IBQUFSNPEBMJUZBOEWBMVBUJPOPGCFIBWJPS*UBMTPIJOUTBUUIFUPQJDPGTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT JODMVEJOHQSPCBCJMJTUJDTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT

XIJDIJTUIFTVCKFDUPG$IBQUFS

Example Driving Models or Patterns Examples of models of driving a car, in the form of various types of patterns: O Basic object or concept patterns: Self (dimensions, mass, engine power, turning radius, braking effectiveness, fuel level, many general health status indicators, direction of movement, speed, etc.); external: car; vehicle; pedestrian; animal; obstacle; bicycle; road; lane; surface condition; speed; destination; direction of movement; adjacent vehicle (front, rear, left, right); clearance between vehicles, curve in road, straight ahead, right turn, left turn, right of way, speed limit, trafﬁc signs, rain, snow, ice, slippery, wind speed and direction, temperature, amount of visibility, etc. O Basic primitive driving patterns: Avoid hitting other vehicles and pedestrians; change from stopped to moving forward, from moving forward to stopped, from stopped to moving backward, from moving backward to stopped; when moving forward, leave space in front 5 ft + (5 ft * speed in mph); drive in middle of lane; keep speed at posted speed limit; slow down if road is slippery; turn left turn signal on 10 sec and

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES) 150 ft prior to turning left; likewise right signal prior to turning right; give right of way to oncoming trafﬁc when turning left; turn left signal on prior to moving one lane to the left, and right signal on prior to moving one lane to the right; go around an obstacle. N Stop light pattern: stop at stop light if red, proceed if green, right turn after stop allowed on red if clear. N Stop sign pattern: stop, then proceed when clear right and clear left and clear ahead. O Basic intermediate patterns: Keep driving on current road unless otherwise instructed; turn left at the next stop light; turn right at the next intersection; ﬁnd a parking spot; parallel park; keep speed low enough to maintain traction and keep car on road; override posted speed limit if adjacent cars are all exceeding the speed limit, and adjust to their speed. N Legal driving pattern: several primitives, including avoid hitting other cars, comply with trafﬁc signs and stop lights, use turn signals, etc. N Defensive driving pattern: all patterns listed so far + drive no slower than 10 mph under the speed limit, conditions permitting; if major obstacles appear, go around them if possible, otherwise stop immediately; if minor obstacles appear (pothole, small to medium size rock, small box) and there is heavy trafﬁc following close behind the car, do not stop, and if trafﬁc is on both sides of car, do not go around the obstacles; at all times, assume the possibility that: N Surrounding vehicles may not follow same rules (e.g., they may not stop at stop lights or stop signs). N Trafﬁc may suddenly stop. N The road may suddenly become slippery. N Obstacles may suddenly appear in road. N Pedestrians on the side of the road may suddenly walk on road in front of car. N Animals may suddenly run onto road in front of car. N Emergency driving pattern: avoid hitting other cars and pedestrians and major obstacles, keep speed low enough to maintain traction and keep car on road; proceed as fast as possible within those constraints; slow down when approaching stop sign or red stop light until verifying that cross road is clear; use turn indicators; all other rules are suspended. O Route patterns: The basic form is Drive from location A to location B (e.g., from Bob’s home to his ofﬁce). Each route consists of a connected series of intermediate or primitive patterns, similar to the directions of a typical Internet direction ﬁnding service (e.g., turn right out of driveway, go straight 3 blocks, turn left on 11th Avenue, etc.). These patterns may be produced on-the-ﬂy, rather than stored in the repository. But the repository might make it appear to the user that the route was stored; for example, the user asks for a route from A to B; the repository query processor requests an Internet service to determine this and passes the result along as if it were stored in the repository. For the purposes of this automated car, the most common routes between commonly used locations may be loaded into the robot data store and reused each day.

O

55

56 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science O Route planning pattern: There is one basic pattern: It ﬁnds an appropriate route to get from current location to desired location, based on current road and trafﬁc conditions (e.g., trafﬁc backups, road construction, ice conditions, etc.). It can work with or without a route pattern. Example of using the planning pattern with a route pattern: Suppose there are two route patterns for getting from Bob’s home to work, called Primary and Backup. Each day just before Bob gets into the car, the route planning pattern follows an algorithm something like this: Check Primary route current conditions using online trafﬁc service; if OK, then today’s route Primary; if not OK, then check Backup route current conditions; if OK, then today’s route Backup; if not OK, then go to online route-ﬁnding service and get another route, to exclude routes equivalent to Primary and Backup. Algorithm for using the planning pattern without a route pattern: First, go to online service and ﬁnd a route from location A to location B. Then check current conditions of the route. If OK, use that route. If not OK, go back to the route ﬁnding service and get a different route; check current conditions of that; if OK, use that route.

Language and Precision of Models 8FVTFEJOGPSNBMMBOHVBHFJOPVSTUBUFNFOUTPGUIFQBUUFSOTCVUUIFBDUVBMNPEFMTJO.04&4 XPVMEMJLFMZCFNPSFQSFDJTF'PSFYBNQMF UIFSPVUFQBUUFSOJTTUBUFEBT%SJWFGSPNMPDBUJPO"UP MPDBUJPO# PSJO#PCTDBTFGSPN)UP8. ThF.04&4NPEFMNJHIUMPPLMJLFUIJT O 1SFDPOEJUJPO#PCJTBUIPNF MPDBUJPO) BUUJNF5 O 1PTUDPOEJUJPO#PCJTBUIJTPﬃcF MPDBUJPO8 TBGF VOJOKVSFE BUUJNF5BN JOUJNF[POFXIFSF#PCXPSLT XIFSF5¦5IPVS XJUIQSPCBCJMJUZ1PG#PC SFBDIJOH8TBGFBOEVOJOKVSFE BOEQSPCBCJMJUZ1PG#PCSFBDIJOH8CZUJNF5 O $POTUSBJOU.PEFPGUSBWFMJTBVUPNBUFEDBS O %FQFOEFODJFTPGUIFBVUPNBUFEDBS QBSUJBMMJTU "QQSPQSJBUFBJSJTBWBJMBCMFGPSUIFFOHJOF 'VFMJTBWBJMBCMF "DPOUJOVPVTTVSGBDFBQQSPQSJBUFGPSESJWJOHBDBSFYJTUTCFUXFFO)BOE8 "GPSDFFYJTUTUPQVTIUIFDBSBHBJOTUUIFTVSGBDFUPFOBCMFUSBDUJPOUPFNFSHF "MMEFQFOEFODJFTFYDFQU XPVMEMJLFMZCFJNQMJDJUUIFZDBOCFBTTVNFE

Engineering Process and Tools 8IBUJTUIFTFRVFODFGPSUIFFOHJOFFSJOHBDUJWJUJFTPGEFTJHOJOHBOECVJMEJOHBOBVUPNBUFEDBS 8FCSJFﬂZEFTDSJCFUXPBTQFDUTQSPDFTTBOEUPPMT3FHBSEJOHUIFQSPDFTT #PCBOEIJTDPMMFBHVFTEP OPUUBLFBTFRVFOUJBMXBUFSGBMMBQQSPBDI*OTUFBE UIFZGPMMPXUIF.04&4BQQSPBDIPGBOPQQPS UVOJTUJDQSPDFTTUIBUJT UIFZTUBSUXJUIUIFJOGPSNBUJPOBOELOPXMFEHFUIBUUIFZIBWF XIJDIJT XIBUUIFZBMSFBEZLOPXGSPNUIFJSUSBJOJOHBOEFYQFSJFODF BOEXIBUUIFZGPVOEJOBTFBSDIPG UIFNPEFMTQBDFGPSDBSEFTJHOTBOESPCPUEFTJHOTThFZXPSLPOBSFBTXIFSFUIFZDBOHFUUSBDUJPO SBUIFS UIBO BEIFSJOH UP B ﬁYFE TFRVFODF JO EFWFMPQJOH UIF DPODFQU PG PQFSBUJPOT $0/014

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O

57

SFRVJSFNFOUT BSDIJUFDUVSF BOEEFTJHOThFZHPCBDLBOEGPSUICFUXFFOUIFJOUFSBDUJPOPGUIF BVUPNBUFE DBS XJUI JUT FOWJSPONFOU BOE UIF SPCPU TPGUXBSF BOE IBSEXBSF ThF HPBM JT UP ﬁMM JOBMMUIFQJFDFT MJLFBKJHTBXQV[[MF TPJUXJMMCFDPNQMFUFBUUIFFOE3FBTPOTGPSUIJTJODMVEF BMMQBSUTPGUIFFOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTBSFUPTPNFEFHSFFJOUFSEFQFOEFOU BOE UIFZXBOUUP UBLFBEWBOUBHFPGQSFFYJTUJOHQJFDFT'PSFYBNQMF UIFZEPOPUOFFEUPEFWFMPQBQBSBMMFMQBSLQBU UFSOUIBUQJFDFPGUIFQV[[MFBMSFBEZFYJTUT ThFNPEFMTQBDFJTFRVJQQFEXJUIBWBSJFUZPGBTTPDJBUFEUPPMTUIBUPQFSBUFPOBOBSSBZPGNPE FMT*ODMVEFEBSFUPPMTGPSTFBSDIJOH SFUSJFWJOH BOBMZ[JOH DPNQBSJOH JODMVEJOHNPEFMNBUDIJOH

USBOTMBUJOH PQUJNJ[JOH UBJMPSJOH NPEJGZJOH FYFDVUJOH BOETUPSJOHNPEFMT

Veriﬁcation and Testing "LFZQBSUPGUIFUFTUJTUPEFWJTFBDBSTJNVMBUPS BOBMPHPVTUPBﬂJHIUTJNVMBUPS UIBUJTESJWFOCZ BSPCPUJOTUFBEPGBIVNBO*GDBSTJNVMBUPSNPEFMTBSFBWBJMBCMFJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF UIFOUIFTF DBOCFVTFE*GOPTVDINPEFMTFYJTU #PCBOEIJTDPMMFBHVFTXJMMIBWFUPEFTJHOBOECVJMEBDBS TJNVMBUPS XIJDIJTQSPCBCMZBTEJﬃcVMUBTEFTJHOJOHBOECVJMEJOHUIFSPCPUESJWFSBOEJOUFHSBU JOHJUJOUPUIFDBS)PXFWFS JOUIJTFYBNQMFXFEPOPUFYQMPSFCVJMEJOHUIFTJNVMBUPSXFTJNQMZ BTTVNFJUFYJTUTBOEUIBU#PCXJMMVTFJU #PCBOEIJTDPMMFBHVFTEFDJEFUPCVJMEBOEUFTUUIFBVUPNBUFEDBSJOUXPTUBHFTPSQSP UPUZQFTThFﬁSTUQSPUPUZQFLOPXTUIFCBTJDBOEJOUFSNFEJBUFQBUUFSOTCVUOPUUIFSPVUFPS SPVUFQMBOOJOHQBUUFSOT ThFPQFSBUJPOPGUIFﬁSTUQSPUPUZQFJTQBSUJBMMZBVUPNBUFE"VTFS XIFUIFSDBMMFEBOPQFSBUPSPSBQBTTFOHFS JTOFFEFEUPEJSFDUUIFSPCPUVTJOHJOUFSNFEJBUF QBUUFSOTUVSOMFGUBUUIJTJOUFSTFDUJPO HPTUSBJHIU UVSOSJHIUBUUIFOFYUTUPQMJHIU UBLFUIF OFYUFYJU FUD ThFTFDPOEQSPUPUZQFLOPXTBMMUIFSPCPUQMBOOJOHQBUUFSOT BOEJTUIFSFGPSFUIFGVMMTZTUFN ThFPQFSBUJPOPGUIFGVMMTZTUFNJTBVUPNBUFEOPPQFSBUPSJTOFFEFEThFQBTTFOHFSUFMMTUIFDBSUIF EFTJSFEEFTUJOBUJPO BOEUIFDBSEPFTSPVUFQMBOOJOH BTEFTDSJCFEJOUIFSPVUFQMBOOJOHQBUUFSO 8IFOUIFSPVUFJTTFMFDUFE UIFDBSUIFOGPMMPXTUIFJOUFSNFEJBUFQBUUFSOTUIBUDPOTUJUVUFUIFSPVUF UPSFBDIUIFEFTJSFEEFTUJOBUJPO ThJT JT GPMMPXFE CZ ﬁFME UFTUJOH TUBSUJOH PO B UFTU USBDL XJUI OP PUIFS USBﬃc UIFO BEEJOH MJNJUFEUSBﬃc FUD'JOBMMZ GVMMSPBEUFTUJOHJTEPOF&BDITUFQJOWPMWFTGFFECBDL JUFSBUJPO BOE MFBSOJOHPOUIFQBSUPGCPUIUIFFOHJOFFSTBOEUIFSPCPU

Automation Features ThFQBTTFOHFSIBTPWFSSJEFPSJOUFSSVQUDBQBCJMJUZ'PSFYBNQMF JG#PCJTQBSUXBZUPUIFPﬃcFBOE SFNFNCFSTTPNFUIJOHIFOFFETCVUMFGUBUIPNF IFDBOTBZ i*OUFSSVQUUVSOBSPVOEBOEHPIPNFw PSi$IBOHFEFTUJOBUJPOUPIPNFw0SJGIFSFNFNCFSTUIBUIFQSPNJTFEUPQJDLVQBDPMMFBHVF POUIFXBZ IFDBOTBZ i*OUFSSVQUDIBOHFEFTUJOBUJPOUP0BL4USFFUw)FDBOBMTPDIBOHFUP TFNJBVUPNBUFENPEFBTJOUIFﬁSTUQSPUPUZQF'PSFYBNQMF IFEFDJEFTQBSUXBZUPXPSLUIBUIF XJMMUBLFUIFEBZPﬀ BOEHPFYQMPSFTPNFNPVOUBJOSPBETOFBSCZ)FDBOTBZ i*OUFSSVQUUBLFUIF OFYUFYJUBOEIFBEXFTUPO)JHIXBZw'SPNUIBUQPJOU OPSPVUFJTJOFﬀFDU BOEUIFQBTTFOHFS CFDPNFTBOPQFSBUPSVTJOHUIFJOUFSNFEJBUFQBUUFSOTUPEJSFDUUIFDBS /PUF UIBU UIJT BVUPNBUFE DBS DPVME PQFSBUF XJUIPVU BOZ PDDVQBOUQBTTFOHFS 'PS FYBNQMF #PCDPVMEEFﬁOFBSPVUFGSPNIJTIPNFUPUIFDBSNBJOUFOBODFTIPQ BOEBSPVUFGSPNUIFNBJO UFOBODFTIPQUPIJTPﬃcF)FDPVMEQSPHSBNJUPSUFMMJUUPESJWFJUTFMGUPUIFTIPQ BOEUIFOXIFO UIFNBJOUFOBODFXBTEPOF UPESJWFJUTFMGUPIJTPﬃcFUPQJDLIJNVQBGUFSXPSL

58 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Documenting "UUIFFOE XIFOUIFZBSFEPOFUFTUJOHBOEUIFBVUPNBUFEDBSJTBDDFQUFEBTTVDDFTTGVM TPNFPOF UFMMT#PCUIBUUIFZOFFEUPEPDVNFOUUIFJSSFRVJSFNFOUTJOBEFUBJMFESFRVJSFNFOUTTQFD BOEUIFZ TIPVMEIBWFEPOFUIJTVQGSPOU"GUFSUIJOLJOHBCPVUUIJTBCJU #PCHJWFTBSFTQPOTF#FDBVTFUIF SFTQPOTFJTEJﬀFSFOUGPSUIFUISFFBQQSPBDIFT BOEXFIBWFOPUTQFDJﬁFEXIJDIBQQSPBDIUIFZUPPL XFQSPWJEFUIFSFTQPOTFGPSBMMUISFFBQQSPBDIFT

Response for Approach 1/Predeﬁned Rules ThFSFRVJSFNFOUTNPEFMDPOTJTUTPGUIFDPNQMFUFTFUPGNPEFMTJOUIFGPSNPGUIFWBSJPVTQBUUFSOT CFDBVTFUIPTFNPEFMTEFTDSJCFFYBDUMZXIBUUIFTZTUFNEPFTJOJUTJOUFSBDUJPOXJUIUIFFOWJSPONFOU ThFSPVUFBOESPVUFQMBOOJOHQBUUFSOTBSFUIFUPQMFWFMSFRVJSFNFOUT UIFJOUFSNFEJBUFQBUUFSOTBSF UIFOFYUMFWFMCSFBLPVU BOEUIFQSJNJUJWFQBUUFSOTBSFUIFNPTUEFUBJMFESFRVJSFNFOUTThFDPODFQU QBUUFSOTBSFUIFiPOUPMPHZ wPSBUMFBTUUIFVOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTF PGUIJTDBSESJWJOHEPNBJO BOEUIF CBTJTGPSEFﬁOJOHUIFSFRVJSFNFOUT8FDPVMEOPUIBWFEFﬁOFEUIFNVQGSPOUCVUXFEFWFMPQFE UIFNBOEJUFSBUFEUIFNBTXFJOUFSBDUFEXJUIUIFTJNVMBUPSPSUIFQIZTJDBMFOWJSPONFOU.PSFTQF DJﬁDBMMZ UIFSFRVJSFNFOUTTQFDXFQSFTFOUDPOTJTUTPGUIJTWJSUVBMEPDVNFOUPSDPNQPTJUFNPEFM ThFTUBUFNFOUUIFBVUPNBUFEDBSTIBMMIBWFUIFBCJMJUZUPQFSGPSNBMMUIFQBUUFSOTUIBUGPMMPX JO "MM UIF SPVUF SPVUF QMBOOJOH JOUFSNFEJBUF BOE QSJNJUJWF QBUUFSOT UIFTF SFQSFTFOU UIF TVCTUBODFPGUIFSFRVJSFNFOUT ThFDPODFQUQBUUFSOTBOEEFﬁOJUJPOTUIFTFSFQSFTFOUUIFHMPTTBSZ

Response for Approach 2/Simulation Learning 8FEFﬁOFUIFTFUPGQBUUFSOTBTUIFJOJUJBMNJOJNBMTFUXFHBWFUPUIFMFBSOJOHSPCPU QMVTUIF XIPMFTFUPGQBUUFSOTBOESVMFTUIBUUIFSPCPUMFBSOFE6TJOHUIBUEFﬁOJUJPO UIFBOTXFSJTUIF TBNFBTGPS"QQSPBDIThBUJT UIFBVUPNBUFEDBSTIBMMIBWFUIFBCJMJUZUPQFSGPSNBMMUIFQBU UFSOTJOUIJTTFU*OUIJTDBTF UIFTZTUFNXSPUFNPTUPGJUTPXOSFRVJSFNFOUT#FDBVTFUIFTZTUFN SFDPSEFEJOJUTQBUUFSOEBUBCBTFFBDIUIJOHJUMFBSOFEXIFOJUMFBSOFEJU XFDPVMETBZUIBUUIF DPNQMFUJPOPGUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTNPEFMDPJODJEFEFYBDUMZXJUIUIFDPNQMFUJPOPGUIFEFWFMPQNFOU PGUIFTZTUFNCFDBVTFXIFOUIFTZTUFNXBTiEPOFwMFBSOJOH JUTEFWFMPQNFOUXBTDPNQMFUF

Response for Approach 3/Observation Learning 6OEFSUIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBUUIFFOHJOFFSTFYUSBDUFEUIFSVMFT UIFEPDVNFOUBUJPOPGUIJTBQQSPBDI JTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIBUPG"QQSPBDI6OEFSUIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBUUIFSPCPUFYUSBDUFEUIFSVMFT UIF EPDVNFOUBUJPOJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIBUPG"QQSPBDI 8FEJTDVTTUIFGFBUVSFTPG.04&4EFNPOTUSBUFEJOUIJTFYBNQMFUISPVHIPVUUIFCPPL ThFUFSNT“EPOF”BOE“DPNQMFUF”BSFVTFETPNFXIBUMPPTFMZIFSF#FDBVTFUIJTSPCPUDBOMFBSO JUXJMMDPOUJOVF UPMFBSOBOEFWPMWFJUTQBUUFSOCBTF BOEUIFSFGPSFJUTSFRVJSFNFOUT XIJMFCFJOHVTFEPQFSBUJPOBMMZ*OUIBUTFOTF UIFTZTUFNXJMMOFWFSCFEPOFMFBSOJOH BOEUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTXJMMOFWFSCFDPNQMFUF#VUJUJTMFHJUJNBUFUPVTF “EPOF”BOE“DPNQMFUF”JOUIFTFOTFUIBUBQPJOUJTSFBDIFEXIFOUIFBVUPNBUFEDBSJTHPPEFOPVHIUPNFFUJUT BDDFQUBODFDSJUFSJBBOEDBOHPJOUPPQFSBUJPOBMVTFThFTZTUFNIBTMFBSOFEFOPVHIUPHPUPXPSLBTBOBVUPOP NPVTWFIJDMF

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O

59

Core Concepts I: System, Model, Correspondence ThJTTFDUJPOJOUSPEVDFTUIFﬁSTUTFUPGCBTJDDPODFQUTVTFEJO.04&4ThFTFDPODFQUTJODMVEFTZT UFN FOHJOFFSJOH DIBSBDUFSJTUJD NPEFM DPSSFTQPOEFODF BOETQFDJﬁDBUJPO XIJDIJOUVSOQSPWJEF UIFCBTJTGPSUIFGVSUIFSEFQJDUJPOJOUIFSFNBJOEFSPGUIFCPPL ThFDPODFQUTEFﬁOFEJOUIJTTFDUJPOBOEUIFOFYUTFDUJPOUSBDLUPTPNFEFHSFFXJUIQBSUTPG UIF 1*$"3% UIFPSZ PG TZTUFNT .BSUJO BOE 'FSSJT ThJT UIFPSZ JODMVEFT UIF GPMMPXJOH FMFNFOUT 1BSUT PS QSPEVDUT

*OUFSBDUJPOT $POUFYU "DUJPOT 3FMBUJPOTIJQT BOE %FTUJOZ *O B MBSHFSTFOTF UIFDPODFQUTQSFTFOUFEIFSFCVJMEPONBOZJEFBTGSPN44 4& BOESFMBUFEEJTDJQMJOFT 5XPFYBNQMFTBSFUIFGPVOEBUJPOTQBSUPG3.0%1 BOEUIFNPEFMJOHBQQSPBDIPG4FMJD (VMMFLTPO BOE8BSE

Key System Terms "SFBTPOBCMFTUBSUJOHQPJOUGPSBOZBQQSPBDIUPTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHJTUIFDPODFQUPGTZTUFNTh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hFNFBOJOH PGUIFTFUFSNTDBOBMTPJODMVEFUIFTZTUFNJUTFMGBOEUIFDPOOFDUJPOT*OUIFDBTFPGOFJHICPS IPPE PQFOOFJHICPSIPPEFYDMVEFTUIFTZTUFN XIJMFDMPTFEOFJHICPSIPPEJODMVEFTUIFTZTUFN *O.04&4 UIFUISFFUFSNTDBOCFVTFEJOUFSDIBOHFBCMZ CVUJOUIJTCPPLXFQSJNBSJMZVTFUIF UFSNiFOWJSPONFOUw /PNJOBMMZ BTZTUFNUIBUJTOPUPQFOJTDMPTFEUIBUJT JUIBTOPFOWJSPONFOU.PTUTZTUFNT PGJOUFSFTUUPTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHBSFDPODFQUVBMJ[FEBTPQFOCVUTPNFUJNFTJUJTVTFGVMUPNPEFM DFSUBJOTZTUFNTBTDMPTFE 8IJMFUIFBCPWFJOGPSNBMDPODFQUTQSPWJEFBSFBTPOBCMFTUBSUJOHQPJOU BTMJHIUMZNPSFGPSNBM TFUPGDPODFQUTJTOFFEFEGPSUIF.04&4GPVOEBUJPO O 8PSME4QBDFUJNFSFHJPO XIJDINBZCFQIZTJDBMPSDPODFQUVBMTQBDF BOENBZCFQBTU QSFTFOU PSGVUVSFUJNF N /PUF&YBNQMFTPGXPSMETThFDVSSFOULOPXOQIZTJDBMVOJWFSTFQMBOFU&BSUIPWFS UIFGVMMUJNFQFSJPEPGJUTFYJTUFODFBTBQMBOFU QBTUBOEGVUVSF BMMIVNBOCFJOHTDVS SFOUMZBMJWFPO&BSUINZPﬃDFMBTU5VFTEBZBUBN&BTUFSO4UBOEBSE5JNFB TQFDJﬁDQBSLJOHMPUEVSJOHUIFDPVSTFPGPOFEBZUIF/PSUI"NFSJDBODPOUJOFOU ZFBSTGSPNOPXUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFPGQIZTJDTBTDVSSFOUMZEFﬁOFEUIFVOJWFSTFPGEJT DPVSTFPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHPWFSUIFOFYUZFBSTUIFXPSMEPGBMMQPTTJCMFXPSMET N /PUFThFXPSMEPGQSJNBSZJOUFSFTUUP4&JTUIFDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDFBT EFQJDUFEJO'JHVSF

60

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

N /PUF$PODFQUVBMIFSFNFBOTBOZUIJOHOPUDPNQSJTJOHQIZTJDBMBUPNT'PSFYBNQMF JOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNNPEFMJOHJODMVEFTDPODFQUVBM MPHJDBM BOEQIZTJDBMEBUBNPEFMT*O UIFDPOUFYUPG4&BOEUIJTEFﬁOJUJPOPGXPSME EBUBNPEFMTPGBMMUISFFPGUIFTFUZQFTFYJTU JODPODFQUVBMTQBDF OPUQIZTJDBMTQBDF"MMTPGUXBSF EBUB JOGPSNBUJPO BOELOPXMFEHF BSFDPODFQUVBM FWFOUIPVHIUIFZBSFSFQSFTFOUFEBOETUPSFEJOQIZTJDBMNFEJB O .PTBJD*OUFSDPOOFDUFETFUPGFOUJUJFTUIBUFYJTUJOTPNFXPSME XIFSFFYJTUNFBOTFJUIFS QIZTJDBMMZFYJTUTPSFYJTUTJOUIFTIBSFEDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPGBDPNNVOJUZJOUIBUXPSME N /PUF"QSPNJOFOUNPTBJDPGJOUFSFTUUP4&JTUIFTFUPGFOUJUJFTJOUIFQSPCMFNTQBDF BTEFQJDUFEJO'JHVSF

CPUICFGPSFBOEBGUFSTPMVUJPOTZTUFNTBSFEFQMPZFE O 4ZTUFN"EFTJHOBUJPOCZBOPCTFSWFSPGBHSPVQPGFOUJUJFT XIJDIFOUBJMTUIFTFDPNNJUNFOUT N $PNNJUNFOU UP B CPVOEBSZ UIBU MPHJDBMMZ DPOUBJOT UIF FOUJUJFT JO UIF TZTUFN BOE TFQBSBUFTJUGSPNUIFFOUJUJFTPVUTJEFUIFTZTUFN JGBOZ N /PUF: ThFCPVOEBSZNBZCFEJTUJODUBOELOPXO PSJUNBZCFGV[[ZPSVODFSUBJO N $PNNJUNFOUUPBDMBTTJﬁDBUJPOPGUIFCPVOEFEFOUJUJFTBTBTJOHMFXIPMFTZTUFN N $PNNJUNFOU UP DPODFQUVBMJ[JOH UIF TZTUFN BT DPNQSJTJOH BU MFBTU UXP SFMBUFE PS JOUFSBDUJOHQBSUT N /PUF$PNNJUNFOUUPBOZDPOTUSBJOUPOUIFQBSUTTVDIBTBTQFDJﬁDJEFOUJﬁDB UJPO OVNCFS PSDPOﬁHVSBUJPOPGQBSUTJTOPUSFRVJSFE CVUJTBMMPXFEJGTVDIB DPNNJUNFOUJTNBEF JUJTQBSUPGUIFTZTUFNEFTJHOBUJPO N *GPQFOTZTUFNDPNNJUNFOUUPDPODFQUVBMJ[JOHUIFEFTJHOBUFETZTUFNBTSFMBUFEUPPSJOUFS BDUJOHXJUIFOUJUJFTJOBOFOWJSPONFOU XJUIPVUDPNNJUUJOHUPBTQFDJﬁDFOWJSPONFOU N /PUF$PNNJUNFOUUPBTQFDJﬁDFOWJSPONFOUJTBMMPXFECVUJGTVDIBDPNNJUNFOU JTNBEF JUJTOPUQBSUPGUIFTZTUFNEFTJHOBUJPO N *GDMPTFETZTUFNDPNNJUNFOUUPDPODFQUVBMJ[JOHUIFEFTJHOBUFETZTUFNBTOPUSFMBUFE UPPSJOUFSBDUJOHXJUIFOUJUJFTJOBOZFOWJSPONFOU #BTFEPOUIFTFDPODFQUT BTZTUFNSFRVJSFTFTTFOUJBMMZUXPUIJOHTUPFYJTU SFMBUFEPSJOUFSBDUJOH FOUJUJFTJOBNPTBJD BOE BEFTJHOBUJPOPGUIFFOUJUJFTBTBTZTUFN

The Relationship between System and Mosaic "HFOFSBMWJFXPGNPTBJDJTUIBUJUJTUIFHSPVQPGBMMFOUJUJFT TPNFPGXIJDIBSFJOUFSDPOOFDUFE JO BEFﬁOFEXPSME BOEXIJDIGPSNUIFDBOWBTPOXIJDIXFPWFSMBZTZTUFNTDPODFQUTBOEFTQFDJBMMZ EFTJHOBUJPOTPGTZTUFNT8IZEPXFTBZUIBUBNPTBJDFYJTUTXIJMFBTZTUFNJTNFSFMZBEFTJHOBUJPO ThFQSFMJNJOBSZBOTXFSJTUIBUBNPTBJDJTBDPOUFYUUIBUFYJTUTJOTPNFTFOTFTFQBSBUFMZGSPNBO PCTFSWFSTEFDJTJPOUPEFTJHOBUFJUPSBTVCTFUPGJUBTBTZTUFNThFNFBOJOHJTTJNJMBSUPTJUVBUJPO BMUIPVHITJUVBUJPONBQTNPSFUPBiNPTBJDPGJOUFSFTUwPSTFMFDUFETVCTFUPGBMBSHFSNPTBJD 8FEJTDVTTUIJTEJTUJODUJPOGSPNUXPQFSTQFDUJWFTQIZTJDBMBOEDPODFQUVBM1IZTJDBMMZ BHJWFO DPMMFDUJPOPGUSFFTJODMPTFQSPYJNJUZUIBUXFDBMMBGPSFTU PSBHJWFODPMMFDUJPOPGJOUFSBDUJOHQFPQMF UIBUXFDBMMBGBNJMZ PSBHJWFODPMMFDUJPOPGCPMUFEUPHFUIFSQJFDFTPGNFUBM HMBTT BOESVCCFSUIBU XFDBMMBDBSBMMFYJTUTFQBSBUFMZGSPNBOPCTFSWFS ThFZBSFBMMMFHJUJNBUFNPTBJDT PSQBSUPGBO PWFSBMMNPTBJD"OZPCTFSWFSDBODIPPTF PSOPU UPEFTJHOBUFUIFDPMMFDUJPOPGUSFFTBTBTZTUFNUIF JOUFSBDUJOHQFPQMFBTBTZTUFNPSUIFNFUBM HMBTT BOESVCCFSBTBTZTUFN8FTFFJOUIFGPMMPXJOH EJTDVTTJPOUIBUUIFDPODFQUTXFDBMMiGPSFTU wiGBNJMZ wPSiDBSwBSFBMTPQBSUPGUIFNPTBJD /PXDPOTJEFSUIFDPODFQUVBMDBTFThFSFBSFNBOZFOUJUJFTUIBUXFUIJOLPGBTFYJTUJOHFWFOUIPVHI QIZTJDBMMZUIFZEPOPUFYJTU&YBNQMFTBSFNBSLFUTBOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOT0SHBOJ[BUJPOTTVDIBTBDPVOUSZ BTUBUF BTDIPPMEJTUSJDU BQSPGFTTJPOBMTPDJFUZ BHPWFSONFOUBHFODZ PSBDPNNFSDJBMDPNQBOZFYJTUJO

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O

61

BDPODFQUVBMTFOTFCVUOPUJOBQIZTJDBMTFOTF*#.EPFTOPUFYJTUQIZTJDBMMZFWFOUIPVHIJUIBTQIZTJ DBMBTTFUTTVDIBTCVJMEJOHT FRVJQNFOU BOEQFPQMFBOEJUDBOCVZBOETFMMPUIFSPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBOEJU QPUFOUJBMMZDBOCFCPVHIUBOETPME8FUIJOLPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBTIBWJOHUIFJSPXOTFQBSBUFFYJTUFODF TPXFJODMVEFUIFNBTMFHJUJNBUF BMUIPVHIDPODFQUVBM NPTBJDT8FBHSFFUIBU*#.FYJTUTCVUXIFUIFS BOPCTFSWFSDIPPTFTUPEFTJHOBUF*#.BTBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTZTUFNJTBTFQBSBUFEFDJTJPO ThFiXFwJOUIFGPSFHPJOHTUBUFNFOUTJOEJDBUFTBDPNNVOJUZ*OUIFDBTFPG*#. UIF6OJUFE 4UBUFTFDPOPNZ PSUIF*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PVODJMPO4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH */$04&

UIFDPNNVOJUZ UIBUBHSFFTUIBUUIFZFYJTUQSPCBCMZJODMVEFTNPTUIVNBOTPO&BSUI PSBUMFBTUUIPTFXIPIBWF IFBSEPGUIFTFFOUJUJFT*OPUIFSDBTFT UIFDPNNVOJUZUIBUBHSFFTUIBUBDPODFQUVBMFOUJUZFYJTUT JTDPOUBJOFEXJUIJOBNPSFOBSSPXMZEFﬁOFEXPSME'PSUIFQVSQPTFTPGUIJTCPPL UIPTFEFﬁOFE XPSMETBSFUZQJDBMMZEJTDJQMJOFTPSEPNBJOT ThFSF JT BOPUIFS UZQF PG FOUJUZ UIBU DBO CF QBSU PG B NPTBJD DBUFHPSZ PS HFOFSBM DPODFQU 8FBHSFFOPUPOMZUIBUUIFJOEJWJEVBMDPNQBOZ*#.FYJTUT CVUBMTPUIBUUIFDBUFHPSZDPNQBOZ FYJTUTBOEOPUPOMZUIBU#PCTJOEJWJEVBMDBSFYJTUT CVUBMTPUIBUUIFDBUFHPSZDBSFYJTUT5BCMF TIPXTTPNFFYBNQMFTPGNPTBJDFOUJUJFTBOEUIFEJTUJODUJPOTCFUXFFOQIZTJDBMBOEDPODFQUVBM BOE CFUXFFOJOEJWJEVBMBOEDBUFHPSZ "MMUIFFOUJUJFTMJTUFEJO5BCMFFYJTUJOUIFNPTBJDPGWBSJPVTEFﬁOFEXPSMET PSQPUFOUJBMMZB TJOHMFEFﬁOFEXPSMEThFUBCMFFOUSJFT BOEUIFGPMMPXJOHTUBUFNFOUTUIBUEJTDVTTUIFUBCMF BMMSFﬂFDU UIFWJFXPSPOUPMPHZPG.04&4'JSTU UIFMPXFSMFGUDFMMIBTOPFOUSJFT JOEJDBUJOHUIFWJFXUIBU BMMDBUFHPSJFTBSFDPODFQUVBM&WFSZUSFFPO&BSUIJTBQIZTJDBMJOEJWJEVBM CVUUIFDBUFHPSZiUSFFw UIBUXFIBWFEFﬁ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ﬁOJUJPOPGTZTUFN 0GUIPTFFOUJUJFTUIBUXFDPVMEEFTJHOBUFBTTZTUFNT XIJDIXPVMEXF DIPPTFUPEFTJHOBUFBTTZTUFNs? ThFEFTJHOBUJPOPGTZTUFNJTOPUBQQMJFEUPBMMQPTTJCMFTZTUFNTXF POMZEPJUJGUIFSFJTBQVSQPTFGPSJU JGJUJTVTFGVMUPVT Table 3.1

Individual

Category

Types of Mosaic Entities Physical

Conceptual

The person whose name is Bob; Bob’s car with serial no. 1234; Bob’s house with address XYZ; the U.S. power grid; the General Sherman tree in Yosemite National Park; the George Washington forest in Virginia; planet Earth —(Physical categories do not exist. See discussion in text)

Bob’s job; the company Bob works for (e.g., IBM); the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE); the names Bob, IBM, and NYSE; the serial number 1234; the address XYZ; the names General Sherman, George Washington, and Earth; the set S {1, 2, 3, 4} The categories person, car, house, power grid, tree, forest, planet. The categories job, company, stock exchange, name, serial number, address, set.

62 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

8IBUFOUJUJFTDPVMECFEFTJHOBUFEBTTZTUFNT "UﬁSTUHMBODF XFXPVMEQSPCBCMZBMMBHSFF UIBUBMMUIFQIZTJDBMJOEJWJEVBMTUIFQFSTPO UIFDBS UIFIPVTF UIFQPXFSHSJE UIFUSFF UIFGPSFTU UIFQMBOFURVBMJGZBTTZTUFNTBOEDPVMECFTPEFTJHOBUFE5PDVUUPUIFDIBTF UIF.04&4QPTJUJPOJTUIBUFWFSZFOUJUZJOUIFUBCMFDPVMECFEFTJHOBUFEBTBTZTUFN8F FYQMBJOUIJTQPTJUJPOXJUIBDPVQMFPGFYBNQMFTPOUIFDPODFQUVBMTJEF ThFOBNF&BSUI%FTJHOBUFUIFOBNFBTUIFXIPMFTZTUFNBOE& B S U IBTJUTQBSUT ThFOUIJTTBUJTﬁFTUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPGTZTUFNJUEFﬁOFTBDMFBSCPVOEBSZUIBUJODMVEFT UIPTFﬁWFFMFNFOUTBOEFYDMVEFTBMMPUIFSFMFNFOUT JUDPNNJUTUPUIFﬁWFFMFNFOUTBT UIFXIPMFTZTUFN BOEJUIBTBUMFBTUUXPSFMBUFEQBSUT ThFSFMBUJPOTBSFUIBUJOUIJTTZT UFN &QSFDFEFTBBQSFDFEFTSSQSFDFEFTUBOEUQSFDFEFTI*GUIPTFSFMBUJPOTEPOPU IPME JUJTOPUUIFTBNFOBNF)FODF UIFOBNF&BSUIDBOCFEFTJHOBUFEBTBTZTUFN ThFDBUFHPSZTFU*O.04&4 BMMDBUFHPSJFTBSFEFﬁOFEPSEFTDSJCFEBTNPEFMT EJTDVTTFE JOUIJTDIBQUFSJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi.PEFMw 0VSNPEFMPGUIFDBUFHPSZTFUXPVMECF TPNFUIJOHMJLFUIJT"TFUIBTUXPFOUJUZUZQFTDPMMFDUJPOBOEFMFNFOUBOEPOFSFMBUJPO NFNCFSPG BTJOFMFNFOUJTNFNCFSPGDPMMFDUJPO&BDIJOEJWJEVBMTFUIBTPOFDPMMFDUJPO BOE[FSPPSNPSFFMFNFOUT/PXMFUVTEFTJHOBUFUIFXIPMFTZTUFNBTUIFNPEFMPGUIF DBUFHPSZTFU BOEEFTJHOBUFDPMMFDUJPOBOEFMFNFOUBTUIFQBSUTPGUIBUTZTUFN4JODFFMF NFOUJTSFMBUFEUPDPMMFDUJPO UIJTEFTJHOBUJPOTBUJTﬁFTUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPGTZTUFN 8IBUFOUJUJFTUIBUDPVMECFTZTUFNTXPVMEXFDIPPTFUPEFTJHOBUFBTTZTUFNT ThBU PG DPVSTF EFQFOETPOUIFNPEFMJOHPSFOHJOFFSJOHTJUVBUJPO#VUJOUIFFYQBOEFE4& QSPC BCMF DBOEJEBUFT GPS TZTUFN EFTJHOBUJPO XPVME JODMVEF BMM UIF MJTUFE QIZTJDBM JOEJWJEVBMT BOEUIFDPODFQUVBMJOEJWJEVBMT JF #PCTKPC *#. BOEUIF/FX:PSL4UPDL&YDIBOHF *O DFSUBJO DJSDVNTUBODFT 4& DPVME BMTP EFTJHOBUF UIF JOEJWJEVBM OBNFT OVNCFST BOE BEESFTTFT BTXFMMBTNPEFMTPGBMMUIFWBSJPVTDBUFHPSJFT BTTZTUFNT ThFTZTUFNTBQQSPBDIFYJTUTJOSFMBUJPOUP CVUTFQBSBUFMZGSPN UIFNPTBJD ThFNPTBJDJTVOBXBSF PGUIFTZTUFNTBQQSPBDIBOETZTUFNTDPODFQUT CVUJTJOEJSFDUMZBﬀ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

System Boundaries 1BSUPGEFTJHOBUJOHBTZTUFNJTEFDJEJOHXIFSFUPESBXUIFCPVOEBSZThBUEFDJTJPODBOEFQFOEPO TFWFSBMGBDUPST JODMVEJOHUIFQVSQPTFPGUIFTZTUFNBOEUIFJOUFSDPOOFDUJOHQBUUFSOTPGUIFNPTBJD ThJTIPMETFWFOJGUIFFMFNFOUQBSUJTFNQUZ UIBUJT BOFNQUZTFUThFNPEFMIBTCPUIDPMMFDUJPOBOEFMFNFOU QBSUT SFHBSEMFTTPGUIFJSDPOUFOU"OJOEJWJEVBMTFU4DBOCF EFTJHOBUFEBTZTUFNGPSBEJﬀFSFOUSFBTPOThF NFNCFSTPGBTFUIBWFUIFSFMBUJPODPNFNCFSXJUIFBDIPUIFS

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O 63

POXIJDIUIFTZTUFNJTESBXO$POTJEFSUIFTFFYBNQMFTIVNBOCFJOH DBS UBYJDBC4VQQPTF#PC PXOTBOEESJWFTB5PZPUBXJUITFSJBMOVNCFS8FTUBSUXJUIUIFOPUJPOUIBUXFDBODMBT TJGZPSDBUFHPSJ[F#PCJONBOZEJﬀFSFOUXBZTThSFFPGUIPTFXBZTBSFDBSESJWFS IVNBOCFJOH BOETZTUFN-JLFXJTF XFDBODBUFHPSJ[F#PCTDBSJONBOZXBZT GPVSPGXIJDIBSF5PZPUB DBS WFIJDMF BOETZTUFN#PUITFUTPGDBUFHPSJFTBSFHJWFOJOJODSFBTJOHMFWFMTPGHFOFSBMJUZThFSFBTPO XFQSFTFOUUIFTFDBUFHPSJFTJTUPQPJOUPVUUIBUUIFEFTJHOBUJPOPGFOUJUJFTBTBTZTUFNJTFYBDUMZUIF TBNFBDUJWJUZUIBUXFQFSGPSNFWFSZEBZXIFOXFDBUFHPSJ[FFOUJUJFTGPSFYBNQMF XIFOXFUIJOL PG#PCBTBESJWFSPSBTBIVNBOCFJOH PSXIFOXFUIJOLPG#PCTDBSBTB5PZPUBPSBTBDBS*O GBDU DBUFHPSJ[JOHJOHFOFSBMJOWPMWFTCPVOEJOHBOEDMBTTJGZJOHFOUJUJFT /PXDPOTJEFSUIF5PZPUBSFMBUFEFOUJUJFTXJOEPXT NFUBMGSBNF FOHJOF UJSFT DPOUSPMT ESJWFS QBTTFOHFST GVFMUIBUFOUFST BJSUIBUFOUFST BJSUIBUMFBWFT FYIBVTU

SPBE GPSDFPGHSBWJUZThFCPVOE BSZPGUIFDBSTZTUFNTFFNTTUSBJHIUGPSXBSE*OTJEFUIFCPVOEBSZBSFBMMUIFNFUBM HMBTT FOHJOF UJSFT QBSUT BOEDPOUSPMFMFNFOUT TUFFSJOHXIFFM CSBLF BDDFMFSBUPS FUD UIBUNBLFVQUIF5PZPUB The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hFQBTTFOHFSTBOEESJWFSBSFQBSUPGUIF FOWJSPONFOU#VUOPXDPOTJEFSBTJUVBUJPOJOXIJDI#PCT5PZPUBJTBUBYJDBC8IBUJTUIFCPVOE BSZPGUIFUBYJDBCTZTUFN "SFBTPOBCMFNPEFMJOHDIPJDFIFSFJTBHBJOUPSFHBSEUIFQBTTFOHFSTBT PVUTJEFUIFTZTUFNCVUUPJODMVEFUIFESJWFS #PC XJUIJOUIFTZTUFNThF5PZPUBTZTUFNJTPOF QBSUPGUIFUBYJDBCTZTUFN#PCJTBIVNBOTZTUFNPVUTJEFUIF5PZPUBTZTUFNCVUJOTJEFUIFUBYJDBC TZTUFN8IZUIFEJﬀFSFODFJOUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPGUIFESJWFSJOUIFUXPDBTFT #FDBVTFXIFO XFCVZBOEVTFBQFSTPOBMDBS XFEPOPUCVZPSVTFBESJWFSXJUIJU8IFOXFCVZUIFTFSWJDFTPGB UBYJDBC XFFYQFDUCPUIDBSBOEESJWFSBTBTZTUFN BTBTFSWJDFFOUJUZ*GXFTBXBUBYJDBCDBSXJUIPVU BESJWFSJOJU XFXPVMEOPUSFHBSEJUBTBDPNQMFUFUBYJDBCTZTUFNJUIBTBNJTTJOHDPNQPOFOU 0UIFSCPVOEBSZJTTVFTBSFEJTDVTTFEMBUFSJOUIFCPPLQFSNFBCJMJUZJO$IBQUFS BOEGV[[J OFTTBOEVODFSUBJOUZJO$IBQUFS

Model Model Deﬁnition ThF.04&4EFﬁOJUJPOPGNPEFMJTEFSJWFEGSPN *&&& ThJTTUBOEBSEEFﬁOFTNPEFMBT UIFiBQQSPYJNBUJPO SFQSFTFOUBUJPO PSJEFBMJ[BUJPOPGTFMFDUFEBTQFDUTPGUIFTUSVDUVSF CFIBWJPS PQFSBUJPO PSPUIFSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGBSFBMXPSMEQSPDFTT DPODFQU PSTZTUFNw0VSEFﬁOJUJPOJT .PEFM&YQMJDJUBQQSPYJNBUJPO SFQSFTFOUBUJPO PSJEFBMJ[BUJPO PGTFMFDUFEBTQFDUTPG UIFTUSVDUVSF CFIBWJPS PQFSBUJPO QSPQFSUJFT PSPUIFSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUDBOCFBTTP DJBUFEXJUIPOFPSNPSFTZTUFNT *OBCSPBEFSTFOTF POFDPVMENPEFMNPTBJDTBOEXPSMETBTXFMMBTTZTUFNT*OUIJTCPPLUIFGPDVTJTPONPEFM JOHTZTUFNT#FDBVTFJONBOZDBTFTNPTBJDTBOEXPSMETDBOCFEFTJHOBUFEBTTZTUFNT UIJTGPDVTJTOPUPWFSMZ SFTUSJDUJWF

64 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

8IZ DIBOHF UIF GSPOU FOE BOE CBDL FOE PG UIF *&&& EFﬁOJUJPO ThF GSPOU FOE i&YQMJDJUw JT BEEFE UP EJTUJOHVJTI FYQMJDJU SFQSFTFOUBUJPOT GSPN JNQMJDJU DPODFQUT ThJT EJTUJODUJPO JO .04&4JTCFUXFFONPEFMBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPO BOEJTEJTDVTTFEJONPSFEFUBJMJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJ UMFEi4QFDJﬁDBUJPOBOE*UT3FMBUJPOUP.PEFMwThFCBDLFOE'JSTU iQSPQFSUJFTwJTBEEFECFDBVTF QSPQFSUJFTBSFDPNNPOMZVTFEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTJONPEFMJOH4FDPOE UIF*&&&EFﬁOJUJPODPVQMFTB NPEFMXJUIBTZTUFN iSFQSFTFOUBUJPOzPGBSFBMXPSMEzTZTUFNw 8FDIBOHFEiDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PGwUPiDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUDBOCFBTTPDJBUFEXJUIwUPEFDPVQMFNPEFMGSPNTZTUFNThBUJT XF XBOUBNPEFMUPFYJTUPOJUTPXOBTBEJTUJODUFOUJUZ*UTSFMBUJPOXJUIBTZTUFNTIPVMECFBTFQBSBUF BDUJWJUZPSEFDJTJPO OPUIBSEXJSFEJOUPUIFEFﬁOJUJPOThJSE XFDIBOHFEiBSFBMXPSMEQSPDFTT DPODFQU PSTZTUFNwUPiPOFPSNPSFTZTUFNTw3FBTPO8FJODMVEFDPODFQUVBMTZTUFNTBTXFMMBT QIZTJDBMTZTUFNT BOEPVSEFﬁOJUJPOPGTZTUFNJODMVEFTQSPDFTTFTBOEDPODFQUT*OBEEJUJPO XFEP OPUXBOUUPDPVQMFBNPEFMUPPOFTZTUFN"NPEFM JOBEEJUJPOUPCFJOHBOFOUJUZUIBUTUBOETPO JUTPXO DBOUBSHFUPSBQQMZUPPOFPSNPSFTZTUFNT BTXFEJTDVTTOFYU

Model as System " DPNNPO SFMBUJPO BNPOH TZTUFNT JT UIBU POF TZTUFN EFTDSJCFT JT BO BCTUSBDUJPO PG BOPUIFSTZTUFNPSTZTUFNT. ThJTEJTUJODUJPOMFBETUPBOJNQPSUBOUUBYPOPNZWJFXJOUIFPOUPM PHZPGTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOHNPEFMTZTUFN XIJDIEFTDSJCFT BOEPCKFDUPSUBSHFUTZTUFN XIJDI JT EFTDSJCFE ThBU JT B NPEFM TZTUFN EFTDSJCFT B UBSHFU TZTUFN %FTDSJCF JT VTFE IFSF BT B CSPBEUFSN UPJODMVEFSFQSFTFOU BQQSPYJNBUF JEFBMJ[F TQFDJGZ PSBCTUSBDU BOEUIFEFTDSJQUJPO NBZSBOHFGSPNWFSZHFOFSBMUPWFSZTQFDJﬁDBOEEFUBJMFE BOEGSPNGPSNBMUPJOGPSNBM BOE GSPNNBUIFNBUJDBMUPHSBQIJDBMUPUFYUVBM*UDBOBMTPSFQSFTFOUBOZNPEBMJUZ BTEJTDVTTFEJO $IBQUFS ThFTBNFTZTUFNDBOCFCPUIBNPEFMTZTUFNBOEBUBSHFUTZTUFN TVDIBTXIFOBUBSHFUTZTUFN JT JOUVSO BNPEFMTZTUFNPGBOPUIFSUBSHFUTZTUFN"TBOFYBNQMF TVQQPTFXFBSFCVJMEJOHBO JOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFN BOEXFEFﬁOFBOBSDIJUFDUVSFPGUIFEFTJSFETZTUFNBOEXFEFﬁOFBEBUBWJFX PGUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFUIBUJT XFEFTDSJCFUIFEBUBFMFNFOUTUIBUBSFWJTJCMFBOEFYDIBOHFEBNPOH UIFQBSUTPGUIFTZTUFNThFO UIFEBUBWJFXDBOCFTFFOBTBNPEFMTZTUFNXIPTFUBSHFUTZTUFNJT UIFBSDIJUFDUVSF BOEUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFJTBNPEFMTZTUFNXIPTFUBSHFUJTUIFJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFN ThFBSDIJUFDUVSFJOUIJTDBTFJTCPUIBUBSHFUTZTUFNBOEBNPEFMTZTUFN8FEFﬁOFBOFOEUBSHFU TZTUFNUPCFBUBSHFUTZTUFNUIBUJTOPUBNPEFMTZTUFN*OUIJTFYBNQMF UIFJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFN JTBOFOEUBSHFUTZTUFN/PUFUIBUBOZNPEFMVTFEJOUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGBTZTUFNDBOIBWFUIF FOHJOFFSFE FOEUBSHFU TZTUFNBTPOFPGJUTUBSHFUTZTUFNTThVT JOUIJTDBTF UIFEBUBWJFXDBO BMTPIBWFBTJUTUBSHFUTZTUFNUIFJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNUIBUJT UIFEBUBWJFXDBOCFSFHBSEFEBTB NPEFMPGUIFJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFN *OUIJTCPPL VOMFTTPUIFSXJTFOPUFE XFVTFUIFTIPSUDVUUFSNTiNPEFMwBOEiTZTUFNwUPNFBO SFTQFDUJWFMZ iNPEFMTZTUFNwBOEiUBSHFUTZTUFNw

Characteristic 4ZTUFNTIBWFOVNFSPVTDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT*OUIJTCPPLUIFUFSNiDIBSBDUFSJTUJDwJTVTFEBTBCSPBE DPODFQU UPJODMVEFOPUPOMZTZTUFNQSPQFSUJFTTVDIBTQFSGPSNBODF CVUBMTPCFIBWJPS TUBUF FYJT UFODF BOEDBUFHPSZPSUZQFPGTZTUFN*UJTJOUIFTQJSJUPGUIFVTBHFPGUIFUFSNJOUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPG NPEFMUBLFOGSPN *&&& JOUIFQSFWJPVTTVCTFDUJPO *OCPUITDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOH XFXBOUUPCFBCMFUPJEFOUJGZ EFTDSJCF GPDVTPO FYBNJOF NFB TVSF FWBMVBUF BOEDPNQBSFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUBSFPGJOUFSFTUBOEUPJHOPSFPSIJEFUIPTFUIBUBSFOPU

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O 65

8IBUXFGPDVTPO BOEXIBUXFJHOPSF WBSJFTBDDPSEJOHUPPVSQVSQPTFPSQFSTQFDUJWF*OBEEJUJPO JO FOHJOFFSJOHXFXBOUUPTQFDJGZBOECSJOHBCPVUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGJOUFSFTUBOEBWPJEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBU BSFEFUSJNFOUBM. ThFVTFPGNPEFMTJTUIFEPNJOBOUXBZXFBDIJFWFUIJTGPDVTBOETFQBSBUJPO

Correspondence and Region Correspondence* ThFEPNJOBOUSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOBNPEFMBOEBTZTUFNJTDPSSFTQPOEFODFp*UFYJTUTJOUIFDPOUFYUPG BEFﬁOFEXPSME"TZTUFNBOEBNPEFMDPSSFTQPOE PSIBWFDPSSFTQPOEFODF JGUIFTZTUFNSFTJEFT JOUIFEFﬁOFEXPSMEBOEIBTDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUNBUDIPSBSFDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIFNPEFM 0OFPGUIFDPOEJUJPOTPGDPSSFTQPOEFODFJTUIFMBXPGSFRVJTJUFWBSJFUZJOUSPEVDFEJO$IBQUFS "NPEFMdeﬁnes DFSUBJODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGJOUFSFTU BOEJHOPSFTPUIFSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT8JUIJOUIFTFU PGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGJOUFSFTU UIFNPEFMNVTUSFQSFTFOUBWBSJFUZUIBUJTBUMFBTUBTHSFBUBTUIFWBSJFUZ PGUIFTZTUFNCFJOHNPEFMFEThe MBXPGSFRVJTJUFWBSJFUZEPFTOPUBQQMZUPUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTCFJOH JHOPSFECZUIFNPEFM'PSFYBNQMF TVQQPTFXFdeﬁne BNPEFMPGUIFBDDFMFSBUJPOQFSGPSNBODFPGB DBS"DDFMFSBUJPOJTPGJOUFSFTUUPUIFNPEFMCVUPUIFSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGUIFDBS TVDIBTDPMPS BSFOPU The NPEFMNVTUCFBCMFUPSFQSFTFOUUIFSBOHFPGQPUFOUJBMBDDFMFSBUJPOPGUIFDBSUPCFBOBEFRVBUF NPEFMCVUJUEPFTOPUIBWFUPSFQSFTFOUUIFSBOHFPGQPTTJCMFDPMPSTPGUIFDBS $PSSFTQPOEFODFJTOPUEJSFDUJPOBMJUJTBTZNNFUSJDSFMBUJPO*GBTZTUFN4DPSSFTQPOETUPB NPEFM. UIFO.DPSSFTQPOETUP4 BOENPSFHFOFSBMMZCPUIBSFJOFBDIPUIFSTSFHJPO4JTPOFPG UIFTZTUFNTUIBUDPSSFTQPOEUP. BOE.JTPOFPGUIFNPEFMTUIBUDPSSFTQPOEUP4 ThJTJTBQSBDUJ DBMJTTVF OPUKVTUBOBDBEFNJDPSNBUIFNBUJDBMQSPQFSUZJTTVFThFTZNNFUSJDOBUVSFPGDPSSFTQPO EFODFBMMPXTNPEFMTBOETZTUFNTUPCFCVJMUPSEFﬁOFEJOBOZTFRVFODF BTXFEJTDVTTJO$IBQUFS 8FDBOEFﬁOFBNPEFMUPDPSSFTQPOEUPBOFYJTUJOHTZTUFN PSCVJMEBTZTUFNUPDPSSFTQPOEUPBO FYJTUJOHNPEFM Pr ﬁOEBOFYJTUJOHTZTUFNBOENPEFMBOEEFUFSNJOFJGUIFZDPSSFTQPOE $PSSFTQPOEFODFJTGVMMZEFTDSJCFEJOUFSNTPGBDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU XIJDIJTJOUSPEVDFEBOE EJTDVTTFEJOEFUBJMJOUIFDPOUFYUPGEFDPVQMJOHNPEFM TZTUFN BOENPEBMJUZJO$IBQUFS

Region 8FEJTDVTTSFHJPOGSPNUXPQFSTQFDUJWFT BHJWFONPEFM BOE BHJWFOTZTUFN 1FSTQFDUJWF *O HFOFSBM NVMUJQMF TZTUFNT DPSSFTQPOE BU MFBTU QPUFOUJBMMZ UP B HJWFO NPEFMThFFYDFQUJPOTBSFDBTFTXIFSFBNPEFMJTTQFDJﬁDBMMZEFTJHOFEUPJEFOUJGZJOEJ WJEVBMT TVDIBTBﬁOHFSQSJOU B%/"NPEFMPGBIVNBO PSBNPEFMPGBDBSUIBUJODMVEFT UIFWFIJDMFJEFOUJﬁDBUJPOOVNCFS 7*/ *OHFOFSBM BSFHJPOJTUIFTFUPGBMMTZTUFNTUIBU DPSSFTQPOEUPBHJWFONPEFM BOEXFSFGFSUPJUBTUIFSFHJPOPGUIFNPEFM PSNPSFFYQMJD JUMZ BTUIFSFHJPOPGUIFNPEFMJOUIFEFﬁOFEXPSME&YBNQMFTJOUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOH JODMVEFBMUFSOBUJWFTZTUFNTUIBUTBUJTGZBHJWFOTFUPGSFRVJSFNFOUT PSBMUFSOBUJWFTZTUFNT UIBUBEIFSFUPBHJWFOSFGFSFODFBSDIJUFDUVSFq $PSSFTQPOEFODFJOUIJTCPPLJTEJTUJODUGSPNUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFUIFPSZPGUSVUI TFFPWFSWJFXPGUIFMBUUFSJO %BWJE "TEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS XFBSFOPUJOUFSFTUFEJOXIFUIFSBNPEFMJTUSVFXIBUXFBSFJOUFSFTUFE JOJTXIFUIFSJUSFMBUFT DPSSFTQPOET UPBTZTUFNPSDBUFHPSZPGTZTUFNTJOBVTFGVMXBZ p *OUIJTTFDUJPO JODMVEJOHUIFFYBNQMFT UIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFNPEFJTBTTVNFEUPCFEFTDSJQUJWF BTPQQPTFEUP QSFTDSJQUJWF GPSFYBNQMF $IBQUFSFYUFOETUIJTUPBGVMMSBOHFPGNPEFTPSNPEBMJUJFT q "SDIJUFDUVSFBOESFRVJSFNFOUTBSFEFﬁOFEJOB.04&4DPOUFYUJO$IBQUFS

66 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

1FSTQFDUJWF *OUIJTQFSTQFDUJWF BSFHJPOJTUIFTFUPGBMMNPEFMTUIBUDPSSFTQPOEUPB HJWFOTZTUFN BOEXFSFGFSUPJUBTUIFSFHJPOPGUIFTZTUFN&YBNQMFTJOUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJ OFFSJOH JODMVEF B TFU PG EPDVNFOUT SFRVJSFNFOUT EFTJHO FUD BTTPDJBUFE XJUI B HJWFO TZTUFN PSBTFUPGWJFXTPGUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFPGBHJWFOTZTUFN

Examples of Correspondence and Region *O UIF ﬁSTU FYBNQMF XF EFTJHOBUF B DBS BT B TZTUFN BOE FYQMPSF NPEFMXPSMESFHJPO SFMBUJPOT 'JHVSFJMMVTUSBUFT&YBNQMF*OUIFﬁHVSF UIFTZTUFNTBSFSFQSFTFOUFECZEPUT UIFSFHJPOTCZUIF WBSJPVTCPYFT UIFNPEFMTCZCSBDFT\z^ BOEUIFXPSME 8 CZUIFPVUTJEFCPY$PSSFTQPOEFODF CFUXFFOBTZTUFNBOEBNPEFMJTJNQMJFECZUIFBQQFBSBODFPGUIFTZTUFNJOUIFSFHJPOXIFSFUIF NPEFMJTEFﬁOFEThFCMVFEPU DJSDMFXJUI# MBCFMFE4JTUIFTZTUFN UIFCMVF)POEB JO&YBNQMF "MMCMVFEPUT CMVFDBST BSFJOUIFSFHJPOPG.BOEBMMSFEEPUT SFEDBST BSFJOUIFSFHJPOPG. "MMCMBDL CMVF BOESFEEPUT BMMDBST BSFJOUIFSFHJPOPG."MMXIJUFEPUTBSFTZTUFNTJO8 UIBUBSFOPUDBST&YBNQMFTPGXIJUFEPUT"OZUSFF QFSTPO QFODJM IPVTF DJUZ FUD UIBUJTJO8 "OZTZTUFNUIBUJTPVUTJEFPG8 XIFUIFSDBSPSOPODBS JTOPUBEPUJOUIJTﬁHVSFJUJTPVUTJEF UIFCPY"MMEPUTPGBOZDPMPS BMMTZTUFNTJO8 BSFJOUIF.SFHJPO &YBNQMF.PEFM. O 4ZTUFN4UIFCMVF)POEB*IBEJOUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTJO O .PEFM. \^ .JTBOVODPOTUSBJOFENPEFMFWFSZTZTUFNJOUIFEFﬁOFEXPSMEDPS SFTQPOETUPJUBOEJTJOJUTSFHJPO

O .PEFM.\JT$BS^ O .PEFM.\JT$BS JT#MVF^ O %FﬁOFEXPSME8 ThF6OJUFE4UBUFTGSPNUISPVHI

R0 = Region of M0: {*} in world W1: United States in 2006

R1 = Region of M1: {isCar} in W1 R2 = Region of M2: {isCar, isBlue}

S1

B R

Figure 3.1

B

R

B

B

B

R3 = Region of M3: {isCar, isRed} R

B

B

R

B

= Blue car = Red car = Car that is not blue or red = System that is not a car

Models, systems, correspondence, and regions.

R

R R

R

W = world M = model S = system R = region

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O

67

O 3FTVMUJOHDPSSFTQPOEFODFT N .BOE4DPSSFTQPOEJO8CFDBVTF4JTBTZTUFNJO8 N .BOE4DPSSFTQPOEJO8CFDBVTF4JTBDBSJO8 N .BOE4DPSSFTQPOEJO8CFDBVTF4JTBCMVFDBSJO8 N 3FHJPO3PG.JO8"MMDBSTJOUIF64JO\z 4 z^ N 3FHJPO3PG.JO8"MMCMVFDBSTJOUIF64JO\z 4 z^ N ThFSFHJPOPG4JO8BMMDPSSFTQPOEJOHNPEFMTJO8\. . .^ .PEFMT. . BOE.JMMVTUSBUFUIBU JOHFOFSBM UIFMBSHFSBNPEFMJOUFSNTPGUIFOVNCFS PGDPOTUSBJOUT UIFTNBMMFSBOENPSFIPNPHFOFPVTUIFDPSSFTQPOEJOHSFHJPOTh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hFTF DMBTTJDBM FOHJOFFSJOH FYBNQMFT JMMVTUSBUF UIBU EFUFSNJOJOH DPSSFTQPOEFODF JT OPU TJNQMF $PSSFTQPOEFODF MJLFNBOZFMFNFOUTPG4& JTPGUFOGV[[ZPSVODFSUBJO8FPGUFOIBWFUPNBLFB KVEHNFOU TVDIBTi8FCFMJFWFUIBUUIJTTZTUFNTBUJTﬁFTUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTNPEFMwPSi8FCFMJFWF UIBUUIJTNPEFMSFQSFTFOUTUIFDMBTTPGIVNBOHFOFTw

Speciﬁcation and Its Relation to Model *O.04&4 TQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTEFﬁOFEBTUIFTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGBOBQQSPYJNBUJPO SFQSFTFOUB UJPO PSJEFBMJ[BUJPOPGTFMFDUFEBTQFDUTPGUIFTUSVDUVSF CFIBWJPS PQFSBUJPO QSPQFSUJFT PSPUIFS DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUDBOCFBTTPDJBUFEXJUIPOFPSNPSFTZTUFNT ThJTEFﬁOJUJPOMPPLTTJNJMBSUPUIFFBSMJFSEFﬁOJUJPOPGNPEFMThFCBTJDSFMBUJPOCFUXFFONPEFM BOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTUIBUBNPEFMJTUIFFYQMJDJUQBSUPGBTQFDJﬁDBUJPO"TQFDJﬁDBUJPOEPFTOPUIBWF UPCFFYQMJDJUJUDBOCFQBSUMZPSFWFONPTUMZJNQMJDJU#VUBTQFDJﬁDBUJPOIBTBOBEEFESFRVJSFNFOU UIFJEFBMJ[BUJPONVTUCFTIBSFECFUXFFOBUMFBTUUXPBHFOUT XIJDIDBOCFQFPQMFPSNBDIJOFT " NPEFMDBOFYJTUJOEFQFOEFOUMZPGDPOUFYUJUJTBTFUPGTZNCPMT"TQFDJﬁDBUJPO IPXFWFS DBOPOMZ FYJTUJOUIFDPOUFYUPGBUMFBTUUXPBHFOUTUIBUCPUIIBWFUIFTBNFVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGJUTNFBOJOH ThFHPBMPG4&JTUPQSPEVDFVTFGVMTZTUFNTUIBUTBUJTGZEFTJSFEQVSQPTFT5PBDIJFWFUIJTHPBM FOHJOFFSTQSPEVDFBSUJGBDUTUIBUDIBSBDUFSJ[FUIFTZTUFNTUIBUUIFZFOHJOFFSThFHPBMPGUIFBSUJGBDUT JTUPEFTJHOBUFJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGUIFTZTUFNTBOEUPDPNNVOJDBUFUIJTJOGPSNBUJPO UPBMMQBSUJFTTQFDJﬁDBMMZBNPOHBMMUIFTUBLFIPMEFSTPGFBDIBSUJGBDU4UBLFIPMEFSTJODMVEFQFPQMFJO WBSJPVTSPMFT TVDIBTVTFST CVZFST TVQQMJFST EFWFMPQNFOUNBOBHFST SFRVJSFNFOUTFOHJOFFST BSDIJ UFDUT EFTJHOBOEEFWFMPQNFOUFOHJOFFST GBCSJDBUJPOFOHJOFFST UFTUFST JOUFHSBUPST PQFSBUPST BOE BVEJUPST4UBLFIPMEFSTBMTPJODMVEFUPPMTBOENBDIJOFTUIBUQSPEVDFPSBOBMZ[FBSUJGBDUTPSTZTUFNT PSJOHFOFSBMNVTUiVOEFSTUBOEwDFSUBJOBTQFDUTPGUIFBSUJGBDUTPSTZTUFNT TVDIBTTPGUXBSFFEJUPST BOEDPNQJMFST IBSEXBSFTJNVMBUPST BOBMZ[FST QSPCFT TFOTPST BOENFBTVSFNFOUNFDIBOJTNT

68

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThF.04&4DPODFQUPGNPEFMJOHBOENPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOJTNFBOUUPJODSFBTFUIFTIBSFEVOEFS TUBOEJOHPGTZTUFNDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTThFBQQSPBDIJTUPNBLFBSUJGBDUTFYQMJDJUBOEQSFDJTF/PUFUIBU QSFDJTFEPFTOPUNFBOTQFDJﬁDPSEFUBJMFE*O.04&4 QSFDJTJPOJTPSUIPHPOBMUPTQFDJﬁDJUZThJT PSUIPHPOBMJUZDBOCFJMMVTUSBUFEXJUIUIFNPEFMTJO'JHVSF.PEFMT.\^ .\JT$BS^ BOE.\JT$BS JT#MVF^SFQSFTFOUEJﬀFSJOHMFWFMTPGHFOFSBMJUZ.JTUIFNPTUHFOFSBMBOE.JT UIFNPTUTQFDJﬁD)PXFWFS UIFZBSFBMMQSFDJTF.SFQSFTFOUTBMMTZTUFNT .SFQSFTFOUTBMMDBST BOE.SFQSFTFOUTBMMCMVFDBST ThFDPODFQUPGTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTNFBOUﬁSTUUPQSPWJEFUIFQPTTJCJMJUZPGBOJNQMJDJUFMFNFOUPG TIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOH BOEUIFOUPTVQQPSUUIFOBUVSBMUFOEFODZPGNBUVSJOHEJTDJQMJOFTUPNBLF UIFJNQMJDJUQBSUPGTVDIVOEFSTUBOEJOHBTMBSHFBTQPTTJCMFXJUIPVUTBDSJﬁDJOHUIFDPNNPOVOEFS TUBOEJOH/PUFUIBUTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHCFUXFFOQBSUJFTJTOPUSFTUSJDUFEUPQFSTPOUPQFSTPOTIBSJOH *U BMTP JODMVEFT QFSTPOUPNBDIJOF JODMVEJOH TPGUXBSF

NBDIJOFUPQFSTPO BOE NBDIJOFUP NBDIJOFTIBSJOH *UXPVMECFGBJSUPTBZUIBUBHPBMPGUIF.04&4DPODFQUPGNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOJTUPNBLF DIBSBDUFSJ[BUJPOTNPSFFYQMJDJU XIJMFBHPBMPGUIF.04&4DPODFQUPGTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTUPNBLF DIBSBDUFSJ[BUJPOTNPSFJNQMJDJU*TUIJTJODPOTJTUFOU "SFNPEFMTBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOTXPSLJOH BUDSPTTQVSQPTFT 'JHVSFTIPXTUIBUUIFZBSFOPUThFDPODFQUTPGNPEFMBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOXPSLJODPODFSU .BLJOHJOGPSNBUJPOFYQMJDJUJONPEFMTXPSLTUPESJWFPVUNJTVOEFSTUBOEJOHT CPUIJODIBSBDUFS J[BUJPOTUIBUBSFOPUBSUJDVMBUFE BOEJOUIPTFUIBUBSF .PEFMJOHUIFSFGPSFBJNTUPNPWF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT GSPN B MBDL PG TIBSFE VOEFSTUBOEJOH UP NVUVBM DPNQSFIFOTJPO " QSFEPNJOBOU NFBOTPGEPJOHUIJTJTUPNBLFFYQMJDJUDFSUBJOUIJOHTUIBUBSFJNQMJDJU NPWFGSPN UP

"GUFSBDIJFWJOHTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOH JOGPSNBUJPOUIBUJTFYQMJDJUJONPEFMTJTSFBEZUPNPWFJOUP UIFJNQMJDJUDBUFHPSZ ThVT BNPEFMJTBMXBZTFYQMJDJUJUNBZ PSNBZOPU CFTIBSFE" TQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTBMXBZTTIBSFEJUNBZ PSNBZOPU CFFYQMJDJU 4IBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHJTUIFQSJNBSZHPBMUIFMFGUDPMVNOJO'JHVSF BOETJUVBUJPOT BOE *GJUUBLFTBQBHFEPDVNFOUPSNPEFMUPBDIJFWFTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGTFMFDUFE DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGBTZTUFN UIFOUIBUJTXIBUXFTIPVMEQSPEVDF "TFDPOEBSZHPBMJTUPBDIJFWFUIJTVOEFSTUBOEJOHBTQBSTJNPOJPVTMZBTQPTTJCMF UIBUJT TJUVB UJPO JO'JHVSF*GXFDBOBDIJFWFTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGQBHFTPGJOGPSNBUJPOXJUIB Characteristics of Systems Shared understanding Implicit

Speciﬁcation

Explicit

1

Hide

3

Not shared understanding

Implicitly learn, adapt , den hid le e os ci Exp recon Make precise, common

2

Hidden diﬀerences

4

Ambiguous; diﬀering interpretations

Model Model: Make characteristics understood Speciﬁcation: Allow understood characteristics to be implicit

Figure 3.2

Role of model and speciﬁcation concepts in MOSES.

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O

69

QBHFEPDVNFOUPSNPEFM UIFOUIBUJTXIBUXFTIPVMEEP*OUIJTDBTF UIFTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOE JOH JF UIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPO XPVMECFFYQMJDJUBOEJNQMJDJUThFQBHFNPEFMJTOPUUIF TQFDJﬁDBUJPOJUJTUIFFYQMJDJUQBSUPGUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPO )JEEFOEJﬀFSFODFTJONBOZDBTFTDBOCFSFTPMWFEJNQMJDJUMZ BTXIFOUXPQBSUJFTMFBSOBOE BEBQUUPFBDIPUIFSTVOEFSTUBOEJOHXJUIPVUFYQMJDJUMZEFﬁOJOHXIBUJUJT UIBUJT XJUIPVUEFﬁOJOH BNPEFMThJTQSPDFTTJTSFQSFTFOUFECZUIFBSSPXEJSFDUMZGSPN UP JO'JHVSFThJTQSPDFTT MJNJUTIPXNVDITIBSFELOPXMFEHFPGBEPNBJODBOCFDBQUVSFEJOFYQMJDJUGPSN BOEUIFSFGPSF DBQUVSFE JO UIF NPEFM TQBDF /FWFSUIFMFTT JU JT B TJHOJﬁDBOU QBSU PG BOZ EJTDJQMJOF PS EPNBJO JODMVEJOH4& BOEUIFSFGPSFXFEJTDVTTJUJOBCJUNPSFEFUBJM .PTUPGUIFLOPXMFEHFUIBUCFDPNFTJNQMJDJUMZTIBSFE GSPN EJSFDUMZUP

JTQSPCBCMZUBDJU LOPXMFEHF XIJDIJTBTVCTFUPGJNQMJDJULOPXMFEHF5BDJULOPXMFEHFDBOCFVTFECVUOPUSFBEJMZ BSUJDVMBUFEBOEUIVTOPUSFBEJMZNBEFFYQMJDJU JTTIBSFEUBDJULOPXMFEHF XIJMF JTQFSTPOBM UBDJULOPXMFEHF 0VSEFﬁOJUJPOPGUBDJULOPXMFEHFJTCBTFEJOQBSUPOUIFDPODFQUPGUBDJULOPXJOHJO1PMBOZJ 1PMBOZJFNQIBTJ[FEQFSTPOBMLOPXMFEHF BOEUIFSFGPSFUIFUBDJULOPXMFEHFJO POMZ 8FJODMVEFUBDJULOPXMFEHFUIBUJTTIBSFEBNPOHUXPPSNPSFQBSUJFT OPOFPGXIPNDBOSFBE JMZBSUJDVMBUFJUpThJTJTUIFUZQFPGLOPXMFEHFSFQSFTFOUFEJODVMUVSBM TPDJBM BOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOBM HSPVQTUIBUQFSTJTUPWFSBOZTJHOJﬁDBOUQFSJPEPGUJNF BOEGPSXIJDITUPSZUFMMJOHBOEOBSSBUJWFT NBZCFBQSJNBSZNFBOTPGDPNNVOJDBUJOH %FOOJOH 4UPSZUFMMJOHJTBMTPHBJOJOHUSBDUJPO BTBNFBOTPGDPNNVOJDBUJPOJOPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMDPOUFYUTBOEBTBOFOHJOFFSJOHNFUIPE'PSUIFTF SFBTPOT UBDJULOPXMFEHF BOEUIFﬂPXGSPN EJSFDUMZUP

JTBOJNQPSUBOUQBSUPGUIFSFQFS UPJSFPGUIFFYQBOEFE4&BOE.04&4 BMUIPVHINPTUPGJUXJMMOPUCFDBQUVSFEJONPEFMT*UJT BQBSUPG4&UIBUPDDVSTPVUTJEFUIFNPEFMTQBDFCVUJUJTSFﬂFDUFEBOETVQQPSUFEJOUIF.04&4 DPODFQUPGTQFDJﬁDBUJPO " DPNNVOJUZ #P, DPOTJTUT PG BOE *O BEEJUJPO FBDI QFSTPO PS FOHJOFFS JO TVDI B DPNNVOJUZIBTIJTPXO#P, XIJDIDPOTJTUTPGUIFTVNPGLOPXMFEHFJO

BOE

BMUIPVHI BOE FMFNFOUTBSFPVUTJEFUIFSFBMNPGTQFDJﬁDBUJPOThJTEFQJDUJPODBOBQQMZUP B#P,JOTPNFEPNBJO TVDIBT4&*UDBOBMTPBQQMZUPBTFUPGJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUBTQFDJﬁDTZT UFNPSTFUPGTZTUFNT TVDIBTBTFUSFRVJSFNFOUTPSBOBSDIJUFDUVSF*OUIFMBUUFSDBTF XFXPVME SFQMBDF HFOFSBM PS EPNBJO LOPXMFEHF XJUI JOEJWJEVBM TZTUFN LOPXMFEHF *O .04&4 FYQMJDJU JOGPSNBUJPO JO CPUI DBTFT SFTJEFT JO B NPEFM TQBDF UIF #P, SFTJEFT JO HFOFSBM NPEFMT JO UIF LOPXMFEHFTQBDF BOETZTUFNJOGPSNBUJPOSFTJEFTJOTQFDJﬁDNPEFMTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIFTZTUFN JOBXPSLTQBDF -FUTMPPLCBDLBUBDPVQMFPGUIFBQQSPBDIFTUPMFBSOJOHESJWJOHCFIBWJPSJOUIFﬁSTUTFDUJPO FOUJUMFEi.04&4JO"DUJPO"4UPSZBCPVU#VJMEJOHBO"VUPNBUFE$BSwGSPNUIJTiNPEFMWFSTVT TQFDJﬁDBUJPOwWJFXQPJOU*OGBDU GPSDPOUFYU MFUTBEEJOBOPUIFSBQQSPBDI UIFNBOVBMDBTFXIFSF BIVNBOESJWFSJTMFBSOJOHUPESJWF/PXDIBSBDUFSJ[FUIFTFBQQSPBDIFTBTiIVNBOMFBSOTIPXUP ESJWFw"QQSPBDIIVNBOEFﬁOFTSVMFTGPSSPCPU"QQSPBDISPCPUMFBSOTWJBTJNVMBUJPOXIFSF "QQSPBDIBOESFGFSUPUIFBQQSPBDIFTUPMFBSOJOHJOUIFﬁSTUTFDUJPO)PXEPUIFTFNBQUP 'JHVSF /PUFUIBUXFBSFTJNQMJGZJOHUIFTJUVBUJPOIFSF-BUFSXFXJMMEJTDVTTUIFJTTVFPGEJﬀFSFOUTUBLFIPMEFSTIBWJOH EJﬀFSFOUDPODFSOT XIJDICSJOHTJOUIFDPODFQUPGWJFX $IBQUFS

BOEOFFEJOHEJﬀFSFOUSFQSFTFOUBUJPOTBOE DPODFQUT XIJDICSJOHTJOUIFEJNFOTJPOPGDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO $IBQUFS #VUUIFSPMFTBOEHPBMTPGNPEFMT BOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOTEFTDSJCFEIFSFBQQMZJOBMMDBTFT p (PTUPMJ QSPQPTFTBNPEFMPGUIFQSPDFTTCZXIJDIBTFUPGTZNCPMT JOJUJBMMZXJUIPVUNFBOJOH BDRVJSF TIBSFENFBOJOHBNPOHJOUFSBDUJOHBHFOUT

70 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O )VNBOMFBSOT4VQQPTF#PCJTUFBDIJOHIJTTPOIPXUPESJWFBOEIJTTPOIBTSFBEBESJWJOH NBOVBM"UUIFCFHJOOJOH #PCTTPOIBTWFSZMJUUMFLOPXMFEHFPGIPXUPESJWF XIJMF#PC IBTFYUFOTJWFLOPXMFEHFCVUNPTUPGJUJTJNQMJDJUThFZTIBSFBTNBMMBNPVOUPGFYQMJDJU LOPXMFEHFTheSFGPSF UIFTUBSUJOHTUBUFSFTJEFTNPTUMZBU JO'JHVSFJNQMJDJU BOEOPUTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOH"TUIFUSBJOJOHQSPDFFET UXPUIJOHTIBQQFO'JSTU #PC FYQMBJOTDFSUBJOCBTJDSVMFTBOEUIJOHTUPXBUDIGPSXIJMFESJWJOHThJTBTQFDUPGESJWJOH SVMFTJTFYQMJDJUBOEUIVTSFQSFTFOUTUIFQBUIGSPN UP JO'JHVSF4FDPOE #PCT TPOJNQMJDJUMZMFBSOTBTJHOJﬁDBOUBNPVOUBCPVUESJWJOHTJNQMZCZEPJOHJU CFZPOEXIBU #PCTBZTFYQMJDJUMZThJTSFQSFTFOUTUIFQBUIGSPN UP JOUIF ﬁHVSF"UUIFQPJOU XIFSF#PCTTPOIBTBTTJNJMBUFEBMMUIFOFDFTTBSZLOPXMFEHF GSPN#PCTFYQMJDJUUFBDI JOHBOEGSPNJNQMJDJUFYQFSJFODF

XFBSFBU JO'JHVSFCFDBVTFOPX#PCBOEIJT TPOCPUIIBWFJNQMJDJUTIBSFELOPXMFEHFBOEUIFSFJTOPOFFEUPFYQMJDJUMZEJTDVTTIPX UPESJWF O "QQSPBDI IVNBO EFﬁOFT SVMFT GPS SPCPU $MFBSMZ BU UIF TUBSU PG UIF QSPDFTT UIF SPCPU IBTOPVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGESJWJOHBOE#PCTLOPXMFEHFJTJNQMJDJU TPBHBJOUIFTUBSUJOH QPJOUJT JO'JHVSF*OUIJTDBTF UIFSPCPUDBOOPUMFBSOCVUNVTUCFFYQMJDJUMZUPME FWFSZUIJOHBCPVUESJWJOH TPUIFSFJTOPQBUIGSPN UP JOUIFﬁHVSF#PCNVTUXPSL UPNBLFBMMIJTLOPXMFEHFPGESJWJOHFYQMJDJUJOWBSJPVTNPEFMTJOUIFGPSNPGSVMFTBOE QBUUFSOT XIJDINFBOTFWFSZUIJOHJTPOUIFQBUIGSPN UP 'VSUIFSNPSF UIFSPCPU DPOUJOVFTUPSFMZPOUIFFYQMJDJUSVMFTPGESJWJOH TPOPUIJOHFOETVQBU UIFﬁOBMTUBUF PGBMMDPNNVOJDBUJPOBOEVOEFSTUBOEJOHCFUXFFO#PCBOEUIFSPCPUJTBU O "QQSPBDI3PCPUMFBSOTWJBTJNVMBUJPOThFTUBSUJOHQPJOUJTBHBJO GPSUIFTBNFSFBTPOT HJWFOJO"QQSPBDIThFSFBSFUXPTPVSDFTPGJOGPSNBUJPOGPSUIFSPCPU'JSTU #PCQSP WJEFTBMJUUMFTUBSUJOHJOGPSNBUJPOJOUIFNJOJNBMJOJUJBMNPEFMUIBUSFQSFTFOUTUIFQBUI GSPN UP JO'JHVSF#VUCFZPOEUIBU BMMLOPXMFEHFBCPVUESJWJOHJTPCUBJOFE EJSFDUMZCZUIFSPCPU8IBUQBUIJOUIe ﬁHVSFSFQSFTFOUTUIFSPCPUMFBSOJOH 5PBOTXFSUIBURVFTUJPO MFUTBTTVNFUIFGPMMPXJOHTDFOBSJP#PCOFWFSMPPLTBUUIFMFBSOFE SVMFCBTFUIBUFNFSHFEBOEXBTDBQUVSFEJOTPNFGPSNGSPNUIFSPCPUTMFBSOJOHFYQFSJFODFJO GBDU JUNBZOPUCFJOIVNBOSFBEBCMFGPSN#VU#PCQVUTJUJOUPUIFNPEFMTQBDFXIFSFPUIFSDBS ESJWJOHSPCPUTDBOBDDFTTJUBOEVTFJU BMUIPVHIJUJTOPUBDDFTTJCMFUPIVNBOESJWFST"UUIJTQPJOU UIF#P,GPSFYQFSJFODFEESJWFSTJTQBSUMZJO FH ESJWFSNBOVBMT BOEQBSUMZJO JF MFBSOFE UISPVHIFYQFSJFODF ThF#P,GPSUIFDBSESJWJOHSPCPUDPNNVOJUZJTBMMJO UIFSVMFTFU UIBUXBTMFBSOFEBOETIBSFEThFNPEFMTQBDFDPOUBJOTPOMZUIFESJWFSNBOVBMQBSUPGUIFIVNBO ESJWFS#P,CVUJUDPOUBJOTUIFFOUJSFSPCPUESJWFS#P,

Core Concepts II: Connection Ontology ThFDPODFQUTPGTZTUFN NPEFM BOEDPSSFTQPOEFODFEFﬁOFEJOUIFQSFWJPVTTFDUJPOBSFCVJMEJOH CMPDLTGPSUIFDPSFDPODFQUTPGDPOOFDUJPOBNPOHTZTUFNT JODMVEJOHTFSWJDFT UIBUBSFUIFTVCKFDU PGUIJTTFDUJPO$POOFDUJPOIFSFNFBOTSFMBUJPOPSJOUFSBDUJPOPSCPUIThFCBTJDUFSNTBOEEFﬁOJ UJPOTBSFHJWen ﬁSTU GPMMPXFECZBEJTDVTTJPOPGSPMFT

4ZTUFNJTVTFEIFSFJOUIFTFOTFPGIPMPOThBUJT UIFSFMBUJPOTBOEJOUFSBDUJPOTEJTDVTTFEJOUIJTTFDUJPODBO PDDVSCFUXFFOTZTUFNT CFUXFFOBTZTUFNBOEFOUJUJFTJOJUTFOWJSPONFOU PSCFUXFFOQBSUTPGBTZTUFN

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O 71

Terms and Concepts 'PSFBDIOBNFEDPODFQU BEFﬁOJUJPOJTHJWFOBOEJONBOZDBTFT FYQMBOBUPSZOPUFTBOEFYBNQMFT BSFBMTPHJWFO O *OUFSBDUJPO"DUJPOBNPOHUXPPSNPSFQBSUJFT /PUF ThF OVNCFS BOE UZQFT PG QBSUJFT JOWPMWFE JO BOZ JOUFSBDUJPO BSF UXP PS NPSF FOEQPJOUQBSUJFT POFPSNPSFDPOOFDUPSQBSUJFT BOE[FSPPSNPSFJOUFSNFEJBSZQBSUJFT ThFTFUZQFTPGQBSUJFTBSFEFﬁOFECFMPX

/PUF"OJOUFSBDUJPODBOPDDVSCFUXFFONPSFUIBOUXPQBSUJFTBUUIFTBNFUJNF'PS FYBNQMF POFQBSUZDBOEFMJWFSBOJUFNGPSVTFCZBMMQBSUJFTSFHJTUFSFEGPSBQBSUJDVMBSTFS WJDFThBUJTXIZUIFEFﬁOJUJPOBCPWFTBZTiBNPOHwQBSUJFTJOTUFBEPGiCFUXFFOwQBSUJFT O 3FMBUJPO"OJOUFSQFSTPOBM NBUIFNBUJDBM MPHJDBM PSDBVTBMDPOOFDUJPOBNPOHUXPPS NPSFQBSUJFT /PUF*OUFSBDUJPOTPGUFOPDDVSPSBSFBMMPXFEUPPDDVSEVFUPTPNFSFMBUJPOBNPOHUXPPS NPSFQBSUJFT'PSFYBNQMF UXPQBSUJFTNJHIUOPUJOUFSBDUVOUJMUIFZBSFXJUIJOBDFSUBJO EJTUBODFGSPNFBDIPUIFS.BUIFNBUJDBMSFMBUJPOTJODMVEFUIJOHTTVDIBTFRVBMJUZ PSEFS UPQPMPHZ BOEGVODUJPOBMJUZ$BVTBMSFMBUJPOTJODMVEFTVDIUIJOHTBTDBVTFFﬀFDU GPSDFT BOd ﬁFMET O 1BSUZ&OUJUZJOWPMWFEJOBOJOUFSBDUJPO /PUF6TVBMMZBQBSUZQMBZTUIFSPMFPGTZTUFN FYUFSOBMFOUJUZ DPNQPOFOUXJUIJOBTZTUFN PSDPOOFDUPS*UDBOCFBOZUZQFPGTZTUFN TVDIBTBQFSTPO BOPSHBOJ[BUJPO BNBDIJOF BOBOPTZTUFN BTPGUXBSFVOJUPSQSPHSBN BIZCSJETZTUFN BiTZTUFNPGTZTUFNT wPSBOZ DPOOFDUPSUZQF O &OEQPJOUQBSUZ3PMFQMBZFECZBQBSUZUIBUJTOPUBDPOOFDUPSBOEOPUBOJOUFSNFEJBSZ /PUF*OBNVMUJQBSUZFOEUPFOEMJOFBSQSPDFTTJOUFSBDUJPO UIFFOEQPJOUQBSUJFTBSFUIFQBS UJFTUIBUBODIPSUIFUXPFOETPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPO BOEUIFJOUFSNFEJBSZQBSUJFTBSFJOCFUXFFO "MMJOUFSBDUJOHFOEQPJOUBOEJOUFSNFEJBSZQBSUJFTBSFDPOOFDUFEWJBDPOOFDUPSQBSUJFT .PSF EFUBJMTPGUPQPMPHJFTBOEQSPUPDPMTPGNVMUJQBSUZJOUFSBDUJPOTBSFHJWFOJO$IBQUFS

O *OUFSNFEJBSZQBSUZ3PMFQMBZFECZBQBSUZUISPVHIXIJDIBTFDPOEQBSUZBOEUIJSE QBSUZJOUFSBDU O $POOFDUPSQBSUZ3PMFQMBZFECZBQBSUZUIBUUSBOTQPSUTTUVﬀ CFUXFFOPUIFSQBSUJFTJO BOJOUFSBDUJPO O "DUJPO"DUTNBMMFTUVOJUPGBOBDUJWJUZPSQSPDFTT O "DUJWJUZPS1SPDFTT"DUJPOPSTFRVFODFPGBDUJPOTUBLFOJOUIFDPVSTFPGBOJOUFSBDUJPO O 4UVﬀThBUXIJDIJTFYDIBOHFEBNPOHQBSUJFTJOJOUFSBDUJPOTThFNPTUDPNNPOFYBN QMFT UIFTF BSF OPU NVUVBMMZ FYDMVTJWF JODMVEF HPPET JOGPSNBUJPO DVSSFODZ TZNCPMT QFPQMF FﬀFDU DPOUSPM NBUUFS FOFSHZ GPSDF TVDIBTHSBWJUBUJPOBM OVDMFBS NBHOFUJD /PUFThJTMJTUDPOUBJOTUIFQSFQPOEFSBODFPGUZQFTPGFYDIBOHFETUVﬀ"MMJOUFSBDUJPOT JOWPMWFBOFYDIBOHFPGTUVﬀJGOPTUVﬀ JTFYDIBOHFE OPJOUFSBDUJPOPDDVSTThFMBUUFS DPOTUSBJOUEFSJWFTGSPNUIFCSPBESBOHFEFﬁOFEGPSTUVﬀ XIJDIJODMVEFTCPUIEJSFDUBOE JOEJSFDU UBOHJCMFBOEJOUBOHJCMF SFBMBOEWJSUVBM BOEDPODSFUFBOEBCTUSBDUUZQFT5XP OPUBCMF BOE EFMJCFSBUF PNJTTJPOT GSPN UIJT TBNQMF MJTU BSF TFSWJDF BOE SFTPVSDF ThFTF PNJTTJPOTBSFFYQMBJOFEJOUIFEFﬁOJUJPOTUIBUGPMMPX O 4FSWJDF "DUJWJUZQFSGPSNFECZPOFQBSUZJOUFOEFEPSJOUFSQSFUFEUPCFOFﬁUBOPUIFS QBSUZ "DUJWJUZ QFSGPSNFE CZ POF QBSUZ JOUFOEFE PS JOUFSQSFUFE UP CFOFﬁU BOPUIFS QBSUZBOEUIFSFTVMUPSFﬀFDUPGUIFBDUJWJUZPOUIFPUIFSQBSUZ

72 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O

O

O O

O O O

/PUFThFTFSWJDFBDUJWJUZNBZPSNBZOPUCFBOJOUFSBDUJPO*ONBOZDBTFTJUJTQFS GPSNFETFQBSBUFMZCZUIFTFSWJDFQSPWJEFS OPUJOJOUFSBDUJWFNPEFThFFﬀFDU BTEFﬁOFE CFMPX PGBTZTUFNPSBTFSWJDFJTJOBMMDBTFTJOWPMWFEJOBOJOUFSBDUJPO /PUF4FSWJDFJTBUZQFPGQSPDFTTJUJTOPUBUZQFPGTUVﬀ BOEJONBOZDBTFTJUJTOPUQBSU PGUIFJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOQSPWJEFSBOEDPOTVNFSUIBUJTXIZJUXBTPNJUUFEGSPNUIF FYBNQMFTPGiTUVﬀw /PUFThFSFJTBEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOBDUJWJUZBOESFTVMU3FTVMUJTEFﬁOFEBTUIFFﬀFDU TFFCFMPX 4FSWJDFQSPWJEFS1BSUZUIBUQFSGPSNTBTFSWJDFGPSBOPUIFSQBSUZBOEQSPWJEFTUIFFﬀFDU UPUIBUQBSUZ EJSFDUMZPSJOEJSFDUMZ FH UISPVHIBOJOUFSNFEJBSZQBSUZ /PUFThFQISBTFiQSPWJEFTBTFSWJDFwJTPGUFOVTFEBTTIPSUIBOEGPSUIFNPSFQSFDJTFCVU DVNCFSTPNFiQFSGPSNTBTFSWJDFBOEQSPWJEFTUIFFﬀFDUPGUIFTFSWJDFw 4FSWJDFDPOTVNFS1BSUZGPSXIPTFCFOFﬁUBTFSWJDFJTQFSGPSNFEBOEUIBUSFDFJWFTUIF FﬀFDUPGUIBUTFSWJDF /PUFThFQISBTFiDPOTVNFTBTFSWJDFwPSiSFDFJWFTBTFSWJDFwJTPGUFOVTFEBTTIPSUIBOEGPS UIFNPSFQSFDJTFCVUDVNCFSTPNFiSFDFJWFTUIFFﬀFDUPGBTFSWJDFw 4FSWJDFJOJUJBUPS1BSUZUIBUJOJUJBUFTUIFSFRVFTUGPSBTFSWJDFUPCFQFSGPSNFE /PUF: ThFTFSWJDFJOJUJBUPSNBZBMTPCFUIFTFSWJDFDPOTVNFS %JTTFSWJDF"DUJWJUZUBLFOCZPOFQBSUZJOUFOEFEPSJOUFSQSFUFEUPCFGPSUIFEFUSJNFOUPG BOPUIFSQBSUZ EJSFDUMZPSJOEJSFDUMZ /PUF "O BDUJWJUZ JT EFDPVQMFE GSPN JUT EFTJHOBUJPO BT B TFSWJDF PS B EJTTFSWJDF ThBU JT TFSWJDF BOE EJTTFSWJDF BSF OPU JOIFSFOU DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PG BO BDUJWJUZ CVU SBUIFS SPMFTPSJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTPGBOBDUJWJUZ ThFFYBNQMFTJOUIFOFYUTFDUJPOJMMVTUSBUFUIJT EFDPVQMJOH

%JTTFSWJDFQSPWJEFS1BSUZUIBUQFSGPSNTBEJTTFSWJDFGPSBOPUIFSQBSUZBOEQSPWJEFTUIF FﬀFDUUPUIBUQBSUZ %JTTFSWJDF DPOTVNFS 1BSUZ GPS XIPTF EFUSJNFOU B EJTTFSWJDF JT QFSGPSNFE BOE UIBU SFDFJWFTUIFFﬀFDUPGUIBUEJTTFSWJDF &ﬀecU3FTVMU BDUVBMPSJOUFSQSFUFE PGTZTUFNCFIBWJPSPOBOFOWJSPONFOU JODMVEJOH TFSWJDFPSEJTTFSWJDFCFJOHQFSGPSNFE *UDBOCF N "OFYDIBOHFPGTUVﬀ CFUXFFOTZTUFNBOEFOWJSPONFOUFMFNFOUT FH UBYQSFQBSFS HJWFTDMJFOUDPOTVNFr ﬁMMFEJOUBYGPSNT

N "TUBUFPSDPOEJUJPOPGFOWJSPONFOU JODMVEJOHDPOTVNFS FMFNFOUT XIJDINBZSFQSF TFOUDIBOHFPSTUBTJT FH GPSBNBDIJOFQSPQFSGVODUJPOJOHGPSBIVNBOJNQSPWFE DIBOHFE EFHSBEFE PSNBJOUBJOFEQIZTJDBM NFOUBM Pr ﬁOBODJBMDPOEJUJPO

N "DDFTTUPBSFTPVSDF N "DIJFWFNFOU PG B HPBM PG UIF FOWJSPONFOU FMFNFOU /PUF " DPOTVNFS PG B TBGFUZ EFQPTJUCPYTFSWJDFDPVMEIBWFFJUIFSPGUXPQPUFOUJBMWJFXT USBOTBDUJPOWJFX DPOTVNFSHJWFTQSPWJEFSWBMVBCMFTBUUJNF5QSPWJEFSHJWFTCBDLWBMVBCMFTUPDPO TVNFSBUBMBUFSUJNF5PS TFSWJDFWJFXDPOTVNFSXBOUTUPLFFQWBMVBCMFTTBGF GSPN5UP5IFOFFETTPNFPOFUPQSPWJEFUIJTiLFFQJOHTBGFwTFSWJDFUIFQSPWJEFS QSPWJEFTUIJTTFSWJDF*OUIJTDBTFUIFTFSWJDFWJFXJTUIFEPNJOBOUWJFX*USFQSFTFOUT UIFGVMﬁMMNFOUPGUIFDPOTVNFSTHPBM N %JﬀFSFOUGSPNUIFJOUFOEFEFﬀFDU&H UIFJOUFOEFEFﬀFDUNBZCFQPTJUJWFCVUUIF BDUVBMFﬀFDUNBZCFOFHBUJWFoUPUIFEFUSJNFOUPGUIFDPOTVNFSSBUIFSUIBOUPIJT CFOFﬁU /PUF&ﬀFDU JONBOZDBTFT JTBOJOUFSQSFUBUJPOUIBUEJﬀFSTCZPCTFSWFS

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O 73

O *OUFOEFEFﬀFDU&ﬀFDUPGBTZTUFN JODMVEJOHBTFSWJDFPSEJTTFSWJDFBDUJWJUZ UIBUJTDPO TJTUFOUXJUIUIFJOUFOU O 6OJOUFOEFEFﬀFDU&ﬀFDUPGBTZTUFN JODMVEJOHBTFSWJDFPSEJTTFSWJDFBDUJWJUZ UIBUJT JODPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIFJOUFOU /PUF ThFTF FﬀFDUT JODMVEF TJEF FﬀFDUT BOE VOBOUJDJQBUFE FﬀFDUT PGUFO DPOUSBSZ UP UIF JOUFOEFEFﬀFDUThFZPGUFOPDDVSXJUIDPNQMFYTZTUFNT5ZQJDBMMZUIFZBSJTFCFDBVTFUIF EFTJHOEJEOPUUBLFJOUPBDDPVOUUIBUBTZTUFNDIBOHFTJUTFOWJSPONFOU FH NVUVBMBEBQ UBUJPO 6OJOUFOEFEFﬀFDUTDBOCFJOUFSQSFUFEBTQPTJUJWFPSOFHBUJWF O 4FSWJDFJOUFSBDUJPO1SPWJEJOHBOEDPOTVNJOHBTFSWJDFJT JOHFOFSBM BDPNQPTJUFBDUJW JUZPSQSPDFTT"TTVNFUIBU1JTUIFQSPWJEFSBOE$JTUIFDPOTVNFSThFOUXPBDUJWJUJFT PDDVSJOUIFTFSWJDFJOUFSBDUJPO "TFSWJDFBDUJWJUZQFSGPSNFECZ1GPSUIFCFOFﬁUPG$ "OJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFO1BOE$JOXIJDI1QSPWJEFTUIFFﬀFDUPGUIFTFSWJDFUP$ /PUF*GUIFTFSWJDFFﬀFDUJTJOEJSFDU POFPSNPSFJOUFSNFEJBSZQBSUJFTNBZBMTPCFJOWPMWFE JOUIFJOUFSBDUJPO O 4ZTUFNCFIBWJPS*OUIFDPOUFYUPGBOJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOTZTUFNT UIFBDUVBMPCTFSWFE CFIBWJPSPGFBDITZTUFN FH QVMMJOHTUVﬀ iOBOEQVTIJOHTUVﬀ oVU /PUF#FIBWJPSPGBTZTUFNJOBOJOUFSBDUJPOJTWJTJCMFBUJUTQPSUT O %JSFDUJOUFSBDUJPO*OUFSBDUJPOJOXIJDIUIFTUVﬀ FYDIBOHFEJTSFBMPSDPODSFUFPSEJSFDUMZ DPOOFDUFEUPTZTUFNCFIBWJPS O *OEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPO*OUFSBDUJPOJOXIJDIUIFTUVﬀ FYDIBOHFEJTWJSUVBMPSBCTUSBDUPS JOEJSFDUMZDPOOFDUFEUPTZTUFNCFIBWJPS O $PPQFSBUJWFJOUFSBDUJPO*OUFSBDUJPOJOXIJDIBMMQBSUJFTIBWFBDPNNPOHPBM /PUF*OUIFDBTFPGNBDIJOFT XIJDIEPOPUIBWFHPBMT QFSTF UIFZBSFEFTJHOFEUPIBWF PSCFIBWFBTUIPVHIUIFZIBWF BDPNNPOHPBM &YBNQMFT1FPQMFPOBO4&UFBNXJUIUIFDPNNPOHPBMPGFOHJOFFSJOHBTZTUFNThFQBSUT PGWJSUVBMMZBMM5SBEJUJPOBM4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH 54& TZTUFNT NBDIJOFT BSFEFTJHOFEUP XPSLUPHFUIFS UPIBWFBDPNNPOHPBM O $PNQFUJUJWFJOUFSBDUJPO*OUFSBDUJPOJOXIJDIEJﬀFSFOUQBSUJFTIBWFDPOﬂJDUJOHHPBMT & YBNQMFT1MBZFSTJOBHBNFJOXIJDIPOFXJOTBOEUIFPUIFSMPTFTBSNJFTJOBXBS /PUF.BOZJOUFSBDUJPOTSFQSFTFOUBNJYPGDPPQFSBUJPOBOEDPNQFUJUJPOThJTJTBIBMM NBSLPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNT'PSFYBNQMF QFPQMFJOBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOPGUFOXPSLDPPQFSB UJWFMZUPXBSEDPNNPOPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMHPBMT XIJMFBUUIFTBNFUJNFDPNQFUFXJUIFBDIGPS SFDPHOJUJPO QSPNPUJPOT SFTPVSDFT FUD O "TZNNFUSJDJOUFSBDUJPO*OUFSBDUJPOJOXIJDIEJﬀFSFOUQBSUJFTQMBZEJﬀFSFOU UZQJDBMMZ DPOKVHBUF SPMFT &YBNQMFT DMJFOUTFSWFS QVCMJTIFSTVCTDSJCFS TFOEFSSFDFJWFS TFSWJDF QSPWJEFS DPOTVNFSMFBEFSGPMMPXFS O 4ZNNFUSJDJOUFSBDUJPO*OUFSBDUJPOJOXIJDIBMMQBSUJFTQMBZUIFTBNFSPMF"QSPNJOFOU FYBNQMFJTQFFSUPQFFSJOUFSBDUJPOT /PUF#PUIDPPQFSBUJWFBOEDPNQFUJUJWFJOUFSBDUJPOTDBOCFTZNNFUSJD /PUF&WFOJOTZNNFUSJDJOUFSBDUJPOT BUBﬁOFSHSBJOFETDBMFUIFJOUFSBDUJPOTBSFPGUFO BTZNNFUSJD&YBNQMFDPOWFSTBUJPO"UBMLTXIJMF#MJTUFOTUIFO#UBMLTXIJMF"MJTUFOT FUD O "HFOU&OUJUZUIBUIBTUIFDBQBDJUZUPDPOUJOVBMMZTFOTFJUTFOWJSPONFOU NBLFEFDJTJPOT CBTFEPOUIBUTFOTPSZJOQVU BOEUPBDUPVUUIPTFEFDJTJPOTJO JUTFOWJSPONFOUXJUIPVU SFRVJSJOHDPOUSPMCZPSQFSNJTTJPOGSPNFOUJUJFTXJUIXIJDIJUJTBTTPDJBUFEThFIBMMNBSLT

74

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

PGBOBHFOUBSFUIBUJUJTSFBDUJWF UJNFMZSFTQPOTFUPDIBOHFTJOUIFFOWJSPONFOU

HPBM PSJFOUFE OPUTJNQMZSFTQPOEJOHUPUIFFOWJSPONFOUBDDPSEJOHUPBQSFEFUFSNJOFETDSJQU

BVUPOPNPVT IBWJOHJUTPXOBHFOEB

JOUFSBDUJWF XJUIJUTFOWJSPONFOUBOEPUIFSFOUJUJFT

ﬂFYJCMF BOEBEBQUBCMF 'SPN,SVQBOTLZ

O 5SBOTBDUJPO*OUFSBDUJPOJOXIJDIFBDIQBSUZCPUIHJWFTBOESFDFJWFTTUVﬀ &YBNQMFT1BSUZ"HJWFTDVSSFODZUP1BSUZ# BOESFDFJWFTHPPETUIBU#HJWFT PSSFDFJWFT JOGPSNBUJPOUIBU#HJWFT PSDPOTVNFTBTFSWJDFUIBU#QSPWJEFT /PUF5SBOTBDUJPOJTPGUFOBTFRVFODFPGBDUJPOT JF BQSPDFTT O 3FTPVSDF1BSUZUIBUTFSWFTBTUIFTPVSDFPGTUVﬀ fPSBOPUIFSQBSUZJOBOJOUFSBDUJPO /PUF"TFSWJDFQSPWJEFSDBOCFBSFTPVSDF. ThFTUVﬀ fPSXIJDIJUJTUIFTPVSDFJTOPUUIF TFSWJDF CVUSBUIFSUIFFﬀFDUPGUIFTFSWJDF /PUF3FTPVSDFJTBTPVSDFPGTUVﬀ JUJTOPUTUVﬀ JOBOJOUFSBDUJPOThBUJTXIZJUJT PNJUUFEGSPNUIFFYBNQMFTPGTUVﬀ /PUF3FTPVSDFJTBSPMF"QBSUZDBOQMBZUIFSPMFPGSFTPVSDFJOPOFJOUFSBDUJPOBOEUIF SPMFPGTUVﬀJOBOPUIFSJOUFSBDUJPO&YBNQMF*OUFSBDUJPO*HPUPUIFCPPLTUPSFBOECVZB EJDUJPOBSZ*OUFSBDUJPO*MPPLVQUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPGSFTPVSDFJOUIFEJDUJPOBSZ *O*OUFSBDUJPO UIFCPPLTUPSFBOE*BSFUIFJOUFSBDUJOHQBSUJFT*HJWFUIFCPPLTUPSFDVS SFODZBOEUIFCPPLTUPSFHJWFTNFHPPETUIFEJDUJPOBSZThFCPPLTUPSFJTBSFTPVSDFGPS NFBTUIFTPVSDFPGUIFEJDUJPOBSZ *OJOUFSBDUJPO UIFEJDUJPOBSZBOE*BSFUIFJOUFSBDUJOHQBSUJFTThFEJDUJPOBSZHJWFTNF JOGPSNBUJPOUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPGSFTPVSDFThFEJDUJPOBSZJTBSFTPVSDFGPSNFBTUIFTPVSDF PGUIFEFﬁOJUJPO ThFEJDUJPOBSZUIVTQMBZTUIFSPMFPGTUVﬀ JOUIFﬁSTUJOUFSBDUJPO BOEUIFSPMFPGSFTPVSDF JOUIFTFDPOEJOUFSBDUJPOThJTEPFTOPUWJPMBUFUIFTUBUFNFOUBCPWFUIBUBSFTPVSDFJTOPU TUVﬀ*OJOUFSBDUJPO UIFEJDUJPOBSZJTTUVﬀ BOEJTOPUBSFTPVSDF*OJOUFSBDUJPO UIF EJDUJPOBSZJTBSFTPVSDFBOEJTOPUTUVﬀ

Roles &BDIQBSUZQMBZTBSPMFJOUIFJOUFSBDUJPO'JSTU UXPSPMFTBSFJOUFSNFEJBSZBOEFOEQPJOUQBSUJFT BTEFﬁOFEBCPWF"HJWFOQBSUZNBZCFBOJOUFSNFEJBSZJOPOFJOUFSBDUJPOBOEBOFOEQPJOUJO BOPUIFSJOUFSBDUJPO3PMFTPGFOEQPJOUPSJOUFSNFEJBSZQBSUJFTDBOJODMVEFQFFSDMJFOU TFSWFS QVCMJTIFS TVCTDSJCFSTFOEFSHJWFS SFDFJWFSQSPWJEFS BOEDPOTVNFS"TBNQMFMJTUPGSPMFTPGTQF DJﬁDBMMZJOUFSNFEJBSZQBSUJFTJODMVEFTBEBQUPS SFQFBUFS GBÎBEF USBOTGPSNFS JOUFSQSFUFS HBUFXBZ NFEJBUPS BOEQSPYZ ThFDPOOFDUPSQBSUZQMBZTPOFSPMFUPTFSWFBTUIFUSBOTQPSUWFIJDMFGPSNPWJOHTUVﬀ CFUXFFO FOEQBSUJFT$POOFDUPSJTEJTDVTTFEJONPSFEFUBJMJO$IBQUFSThFDPOOFDUPSQBSUZJOUIJTTFD UJPODPSSFTQPOETUPUIFBTTFNCMZDPOOFDUPSJO$IBQUFS 4UVﬀ QMBZT EJﬀFSFOU SPMFT ThF WBSJFUJFT PG TUVﬀ BSF JO HFOFSBM SPMFT OPU JOIFSFOU UZQFT &YBNQMF*USBEFZPVBCVTIFMPGXIFBUGPSBCVTIFMPGBQQMFT*XPVMEQSPCBCMZSFHBSEUIFXIFBUBT DVSSFODZBOEUIFBQQMFTBTHPPET:PVXPVMEIBWFUIFDPOKVHBUFWJFX:PVXPVMESFHBSEUIFBQQMFT BTDVSSFODZBOEUIFXIFBUBTHPPET*ONPTUDBTFT IPXFWFS UIFQBSUJFTTIBSFUIFTBNFWJFXPGUIF TUVﬀ eYDIBOHFENPOFZBTDVSSFODZ NFSDIBOEJTFBTHPPET JOGPSNBUJPOBTJOGPSNBUJPO "OBDUJWJUZPSQSPDFTTDBOBMTPQMBZEJﬀFSFOUSPMFTPSIBWFEJﬀFSFOUJOUFSQSFUBUJPOT'PSFYBN QMF BTJOHMFBDUJWJUZDBOCFJOUFSQSFUFECZUXPEJﬀFSFOUQBSUJFT PSCZUIFTBNFQBSUZBUEJﬀFSFOU UJNFT BTBTFSWJDFBOEBTBEJTTFSWJDFThFGPMMPXJOHFYBNQMFJMMVTUSBUFTCPUIPGUIFTFTJUVBUJPOTJO BOPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTFUUJOH

Core Concepts of Model-Oriented SE Science (MOSES)

O

75

"UUJNF5 NBOBHFS.JUDIJTQSFQBSFEUPﬁSFFNQMPZFF&ECVUFNQMPZFF&MMFOJOUFSWFOFTXJUI .JUDIUPTBWF&ETKPC)PXFWFS VOLOPXOUP&MMFO BOE.JUDI

&EXBOUFE.JUDIUPﬁSFIJN -BUFSBUUJNF5 &EﬁOETPVUBCPVU&MMFOTJOUFSWFOUJPOBOEUFMMT&MMFOUIBUIFXBOUFEUPCFﬁSFE -BUFSBUUJNF5 &EJTQSPNPUFEBOEIBTUIFKPCIFSFBMMZXBOUT8IBUBSFUIFJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTPG .JUDITSFBEJOFTTUo ﬁSF&EBOE&MMFOTJOUFSWFOUJPOBU5 O "U5&EBOUJDJQBUFTUIF EFTJSFECVUBCPSUFE ﬁSJOHBDUJPOPG.JUDIUPCFBTFSWJDFQSP WJEFECZ.JUDIUP&E)FJTEJTBQQPJOUFEXIFOJUEPFTOPUIBQQFO O "U5&MMFOSFHBSETIFSJOUFSWFOUJPOBTBTFSWJDFTIFQSPWJEFTUP&E O "U58IFO&EﬁOETPVUBCPVU&MMFOT5JOUFSWFOUJPO &ESFHBSETUIFJOUFSWFOUJPOBTB EJTTFSWJDFUIBU&MMFOQSPWJEFEUP&E O "U58IFO&EUFMMT&MMFOUIBUIFXBOUFEUPCFﬁSFE &MMFOUIFOSFHBSETIFS5JOUFSWFO UJPOBTBEJTTFSWJDFUIBUTIFQSPWJEFEUP&E BHSFFJOHXJUI&EPOUIJTQPJOUBU5 O "U5"GUFS&EHFUTIJTQSPNPUJPO CPUI&MMFOBOE&ESFHBSE&MMFOT5JOUFSWFOUJPOBT BTFSWJDFUIBU&MMFOQSPWJEFEUP&E ThFCPUUPNMJOFUIFFﬀFDUPGBOBDUJWJUZPSJOUFSBDUJPOUBLFOBUBDFSUBJOUJNFDBOCFJOUFSQSFUFE EJﬀFSFOUMZBUUIBUUJNFCZUIFQBSUJFTJOWPMWFE BOECPUIJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTDBODIBOHFPWFSUJNFThF TBNFBDUJWJUZ XIJDIJTPGDPVSTFIJTUPSJDBMMZﬁYFEBOEEPFTOPUDIBOHF DBOUBLFPOEJﬀFSFOUSPMFT JOEJﬀFSFOUWJFXTBOEBUEJﬀFSFOUUJNFT

Summary ThFFYBNQMFBOEDPSFDPODFQUTQSFTFOUFEJOUIJTDIBQUFSHJWFBOJOUSPEVDUJPOUP.04&4BOEJUT CBTJDQFSTQFDUJWFTThF.04&4GFBUVSFTEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFSHJWFBNPSFDPNQMFUFCBTJTGPSUIF NPEFMTQBDFBOEPUIFSEFUBJMTJOUIFTVCTFRVFOUDIBQUFST

References %BWJE . The $PSSFTQPOEFODF TheorZ PG5SVUI 4UBOGPSE &ODZDMPQFEJB PG 1IJMPTPQIZ IUUQQMBUP TUBOGPSEFEVFOUSJFTUSVUIDPSSFTQPOEFODF "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

%FOOJOH 4 The 4QSJOHCPBSE )PX 4UPSZUFMMJOH *HOJUFT "DUJPO JO ,OPXMFEHF&SB 0SHBOJ[BUJPOT #PTUPO ."#VUUFSXPSUI)FJOFNBOO *&&& *&&& 4UBOEBSE (MPTTBSZ PG .PEFMJOH BOE 4JNVMBUJPO 5FSNJOPMPHZ *&&& 4UE *&&& .BZ ,SVQBOTLZ +%eﬁnition: AgencyIUUQXXXBHUJWJUZDPNEFGBHFODZIUN "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

.BSUJO +BOE5'FSSJT0OUIFWBSJPVTDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOTPGTZTUFNTBOEUIFJSJNQBDUPOUIFQSBDUJDF PGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH1SPDUI"OOV*OU4ZNQ*/$04&, The NFUIFSMBOET o+VOF 1PMBOZJ .1FSTPOBM,OPXMFEHF5PXBSETB1PTU$SJUJDBM1IJMPTPQIZ/FX:PSL)BSQFS3PX 3.0%10QFO%JTUSJCVUFE1SPDFTTJOH3FGFSFODF.PEFM1BSU'PVOEBUJPOT*OUFSOBUJPOBM4UBOEBSE *5653FDPNNFOEBUJPO9 4FMJD # ((VMMFLTPO BOE18BSE3FBM5JNF0CKFDU0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH/FX:PSL+PIO8JMFZ 4POT ;FMMFS .BOE3.PDL)FDLFS.PEFMJOHBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUTJOBLOPXMFEHFCBTFETJNVMBUJPOFOWJ SPONFOU1SPD*&&&*OU$POGPO5PPMTXJUI"* #PTUPO ." /PWFNCFS Qo

Chapter 4

Features of MOSES i3FNFNCFSUIBUBMMNPEFMTBSFXSPOHUIFQSBDUJDBMRVFTUJPOJTIPXXSPOHEPUIFZ IBWFUPCFUPOPUCFVTFGVMw (FPSHF&1#PYBOE/PSNBO3%SBQFS &NQJSJDBM.PEFM#VJMEJOHBOE3FTQPOTF4VSGBDFT Systems taxonomy 1

Modeling scope

SE Application Domains (D1...Dn)

Collective actualization space

D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn

Problem space

3a

TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b Traditional Complex

Characteristics of all systems

Highest level system

Deﬁne need

Complex 4 Traditional TS is special case 5 Characteristics of all SE systems Traditional and Complex 6

Model Space

All SE application domains...

Indivisible Unit Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Composition

TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b 2a Traditional systems Complex systems

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

ThJT DIBQUFS CVJMET PO UIF DPSF DPODFQUT PG $IBQUFSCZEFTDSJCJOHNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOE UIFNPEVMBSJUZPG.04&4ThFMBUUFSEJTDVTTFT DPODFQUTUIBUBSFEFDPVQMFEJO.04&4

Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

e

m

Ti

Produce solution

Deployment

Satisfy need

Solution/system space

Model Orientation 8FBSFOPXJOBQPTJUJPOUPEFTDSJCFUIFDPODFQUPGNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOUIBUJTBOJNQPSUBOUFMF NFOUPGUIJTCPPL'JSTUXFSFWJFXUZQFTPGNPEFMTOPXBWBJMBCMFPSCFJOHVTFEJO4& BOEUIFO XFEJTDVTTIPXNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOJO.04&4FYUFOETUIJTUPBMMFOHJOFFSJOHBSUJGBDUT BOEVOJﬁFT UIFFYJTUJOHBOEFYUFOEFETFU

Basic Concepts of Model Orientation .PEFMPSJFOUBUJPOJTUIFNPTUJNQPSUBOUGBDUPSJOVOJGZJOH4& BOEJTQFSWBTJWFUISPVHIPVUUIF UBYPOPNZJOUSPEVDFEJO$IBQUFSThFCBTJDDPODFQUPGNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOJTUIBUPOFSFHBSET BMMBSUJGBDUTBDSPTTUIFFOHJOFFSJOHTQFDUSVN BTXFMMBTUIFTDJFOUJﬁDBOENBUIFNBUJDBMGPVOEB UJPO BTNPEFMT.PEFMTTJNQMJGZBOEDMBSJGZPVSXPSLThBUIBTCFFOUSVFPGUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOHBOEUSBEJUJPOBMTDJFODFJUJTFWFONPSFDSJUJDBMGPSDPNQMFYTZTUFNT.PEFMTOPUPOMZ IFMQVTGPDVTPODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGJOUFSFTU UIFZBMTPIFMQVTGPDVTPOXIBUJTDPNNPOPSXIBUJT 77

78

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

EJﬀFSFOU BOEPOXIBUJTQFSNBOFOUPSXIBUDIBOHFT EFQFOEJOHPOUIFQVSQPTFPGUIFNPEFM #FDBVTFPGUIFQPXFSPGBCTUSBDUJPO UIFNPEFMJOHBQQSPBDITDBMFTVQBOEEPXOJODPODFSUXJUI UIFWBTUSBOHFPGTZTUFNTJ[FT The NPEFMPSJFOUFENFUIPECSJOHTUIFUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYBQQSPBDIFTJOUPBDPNNPO GSBNFXPSLBTQBSUPGuniﬁcation. The USBEJUJPOBM$0/014PGBTZTUFNBOEUIFinﬂuence PGFOWJ SPONFOUPOBDPNQMFYTZTUFNBSFCPUIUSFBUFEJO.04&4BTNPEFMTPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPOPGBTZTUFN XJUIJUTFOWJSPONFOUThe diﬀerFODFJOUIFNPEFMTJTUIBUBUSBEJUJPOBMNPEFMBTTVNFTUIFTZTUFN EPFTOPUBEBQUUPUIFFOWJSPONFOUBOEEPFTOPUDIBOHFUIFFOWJSPONFOUFYDFQUJOBQSFEFUFSNJOFE NBOOFS XIJMFUIFDPNQMFYNPEFMBTTVNFTUIBUXIFOBTZTUFNFOUFSTBOFOWJSPONFOU CPUIUIF TZTUFNBOEUIFFOWJSPONFOUBEBQUUPFBDIPUIFS.04&4BTTVNFTUIFMBUUFSBTUIFHFOFSBMDBTF "USBEJUJPOBMSFRVJSFNFOUTspeciﬁcation BOEUIFGPDVTPOBDPNQMFYTZTUFNBTBXIPMFDBOCPUI CFNBQQFEUPNPEFMTPGUIFFYUFSOBMMZWJTJCMFCFIBWJPSBOEQSPQFSUJFTPGBTZTUFN"USBEJUJPOBM BSDIJUFDUVSFPSEFTJHOBOEUIFGPDVTPOBDPNQMFYTZTUFNBTBTFUPGJOUFSBDUJOHQBSUTDBOCPUICF USFBUFEBTNPEFMTPGUIFJOUFSOBMTZTUFNDPNQPOFOUTBOEUIFJSJOUFSBDUJPO$PNQPOFOUSFMBUJPOT BOEJOUFSBDUJPOTBSFNPSFEPNJOBOUJODPNQMFYJOUFSOBMTZTUFNNPEFMTUIBOJOUSBEJUJPOBMJOUFSOBM system models. All these models can be deﬁned in terms of rVMFT DPOTUSBJOUT BOEPUIFSSFMBUJPOT $MFBSMZ TJNVMBUJPO NPEFMT ﬁU UIF EFﬁOJUJPO PG NPEFM UIBU XF IBWF HJWFO 8IBU BCPVU UIF PUIFS BSUJGBDUT MJTUFE $0/014 SFRVJSFNFOUT BSDIJUFDUVSF EFTJHO 8IBU JT UIF CFOFﬁU JO UIJOLJOHPGUIFTFBTNPEFMT ThJTJTBOJNQPSUBOURVFTUJPO8FDMBJNUIBUDBMMJOHBEPDVNFOUBNPEFM XIJMFJUEPFTOPU DIBOHFUIFEPDVNFOU EPFTUFOEUPDIBOHFUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGUIFPCTFSWFS8FNBZIBWFCFFO DPOUFOUXJUIUIFNBUFSJBMBTBOBSSBUJWFPSHSBQIJDJOBEPDVNFOU CVUXIFOXFUIJOLPGJUBTB NPEFM XFTUBSUUIJOLJOHBCPVUXIBUWBSJBCMFT QSPQFSUJFT CFIBWJPST JOUFSBDUJPOT BOEDPOTUSBJOUT BSFJOWPMWFE BOEXIJDIBSFUIFNPTUJNQPSUBOU*OBXPSE XFTUBSUUIJOLJOHNPSFQSFDJTFMZ 'PSFYBNQMF TVQQPTFXFIBWFBTFUPGiTIBMMwTUBUFNFOUTJOBSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUiThF TZTUFNTIBMMEPGVODUJPO" wiUIFTZTUFNTIBMMEPGVODUJPO# wBOEUIFMJLF*GUIJTJTTJNQMZBEPDV NFOU XFUFOEUPUIJOLJOUFSNTPGXIFUIFSUIFGVODUJPOTBSFQSPQFSMZTUBUFE XIFUIFSXFIBWF JODMVEFEBMMUIFOFDFTTBSZGVODUJPOT FUD#VUJGXFOPXUIJOLPGUIJTBTBNPEFMPGUIFEFTJSFETZT UFN JUOBUVSBMMZDBVTFTVTUPUIJOLNPSFDPNQSFIFOTJWFMZBCPVUUIFTZTUFNBOEJUTFOWJSPONFOU 6OEFSXIBUDPOEJUJPOTEPXFXBOUUIFTZTUFNUPEP"PS# %P"BOE#JOUFSBDUPSJOUFSGFSFXJUI FBDIPUIFS *GUIFSFJTBDPOﬂJDU XIJDIJTUPUBLFQSFDFEFODF $BO"BOE#PDDVSUPHFUIFS *GTP VOEFSXIBUDPOEJUJPOT 0SJGOPU IPXEPXFNBLFUIBUDMFBS 0UIFSRVFTUJPOTJOWPMWFEFQFOEFO DJFT BNCJHVJUZ XIBUMFWFMTPGRVBMJUZBOEQFSGPSNBODFBSFOFFEFE BOEXIFUIFSUIFNPEFMTBSF UPPHFOFSBM UPPTQFDJﬁD PSPWFSDPOTUSBJOJOHThFOVNCFSPGRVFTUJPOTBOEUIFRVBMJUZPGTZTUFN UIJOLJOHJODSFBTFKVTUCFDBVTFXFUIJOLPGUIFBSUJGBDUTBTNPEFMT8FLOPXIPXUPDSFBUFBOEVTF NPEFMT BOEXIBUUPFYQFDUPGNPEFMT 0VSWJFXJTUIBUNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOJTUIFDVMNJOBUJPOPGBUSFOEUIBUIBTHBJOFENPNFOUVN PWFSUIFQBTUEFDBEFThe QSBDUJDFPGNPEFMJOHBOETJNVMBUJPOIBTMPOHCFFOBsigniﬁcant FMFNFOU PG54& GPS FYBNQMF 4BHF BOE "SNTUSPOH BOE .BJFS BOE 3FDIUJO *O SFDFOU ZFBSTUIFﬂavPSBOETDPQFPGNPEFMJOHIBTFWPMWFEBOEFYUFOEFECFZPOETJNVMBUJPOT"OVNCFS PGNPEFMJOHMBOHVBHFT TUBOEBSET BOENFUIPETIBWFFNFSHFEJO4&BOETPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH*O TPGUXBSF FOHJOFFSJOH UXP FBSMZ EJTDVTTJPOT PG NPEFM PSJFOUBUJPO XFSF5VSTLJ BOE #MVN 8BZOF8ZNPSFT CPPL .PEFM#BTFE4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH EFTDSJCFTBOBQQSPBDIUP 4&UIBUVTFTEJTDSFUFNBUIFNBUJDBMNPEFMTGPSBMMBSUJGBDUT8ZNPSFTBQQSPBDI XIJDIIBTSFDFOUMZ ThJTNBQQJOHPGSFRVJSFNFOUTUPBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMIPMETJOTPNFDBTFTCVUOPUJOUIFHFOFSBMDBTF$IBQUFS EFTDSJCFTJOTPNFEFUBJMUIFNPSFHFOFSBMNBQQJOHPGSFRVJSFNFOUTUPNPEFMT

Features of MOSES

O 79

CFFOSFDFJWJOHNPSFWJTJCJMJUZBU*/$04& DPVMECFBQPTTJCMFNFDIBOJTNGPSGPSNBMJ[JOH.04&4 BOEGPSFYQMPJUJOH.04&4DPODFQUTBTBNPEFMPSJFOUFE4& .04& NFUIPE .PSFSFDFOUMZ 0.(EFﬁOFEBOBQQSPBDIDBMMFE.PEFM%SJWFO"SDIJUFDUVSF .%" 0.( BOE0.(B UIBUIBTCFFOJOTUSVNFOUBMJOJODSFBTJOHUIFFNQIBTJTPONPEFMPSJFO UBUJPOJOTPGUXBSFBOETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH*/$04&T5FDIOJDBM7JTJPO */$04& EJTDVTTFTBNPSFHFOFSBMBQQSPBDIUPNPEFMCBTFE4&'SJFEFOUIBM B EJTDVTTFTUIFCFOFﬁUT BOE SFRVJSFNFOUT PG NPEFMESJWFO 4& BOE 'SJFENBO B EJTDVTTFT UIF PQQPSUVOJUJFT BOE DIBMMFOHFTPGVOJGZJOH4&UISPVHINPEFMJOH 0WFSUIFQBTUEFDBEF UIF6OiﬁFE.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 6.- UIFMBUFTUWFSTJPOJTTQFDJ ﬁFEJO 0.(C D IBTCSPVHIUTVCTUBOUJBMFMFNFOUTPGNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOUPTPGUXBSF FOHJOFFSJOH4QFDJﬁDBMMZ 6.-FYQMJDJUMZEFﬁOFTTPGUXBSFEFTJHO BOEUPTPNFEFHSFFTPGUXBSF SFRVJSFNFOUT JOUIFGPSNPGNPEFMT*UJODMVEFTTUBUJDNPEFMTTVDIBTDMBTTTUSVDUVSFEJBHSBNT DPNQPOFOU TUSVDUVSF EJBHSBNT BOE DPNQPTJUF TUSVDUVSF EJBHSBNT *U BMTP JODMVEFT EZOBNJD NPEFMTTVDIBTBDUJWJUZEJBHSBNT JOUFSBDUJPOTFRVFODFEJBHSBNT TUBUFNBDIJOFT BOEVTFDBTF EJBHSBNT 0WFSUIFQBTUTFWFSBMZFBST 0.( JODPMMBCPSBUJPOXJUI*/$04&BOE*40"1 IBTEFWFM PQFEUIF4ZTUFNT.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 4ZT.-

XIJDIJTBOFYUFOTJPOBOEDVTUPNJ[BUJPOPG6.- GPSTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 0.(E &YUFOEFEGFBUVSFTGPS4&JODMVEFCMPDLT XJUIBTTPDJBUFE CMPDL EFﬁOJUJPO EJBHSBNT BOE SFRVJSFNFOUT XJUI BTTPDJBUFE SFRVJSFNFOU EJBHSBNT 4ZT.- JT QBSUJBMMZNPEFMPSJFOUFEEVFUPJUTEFSJWBUJPOGSPN6.-CVUJUIBTOPUUBLFONPEFMPSJFOUBUJPO BQQSFDJBCMZGVSUIFS'PSFYBNQMF UIFFTTFODFPGBSFRVJSFNFOUEJBHSBNJTTUJMMBUFYUSFRVJSFNFOU TUBUFNFOU QSFTVNBCMZFYQSFTTFEJOOBUVSBMMBOHVBHF $MPTFMZSFMBUFEUPUIJTJTUIFDPMMBCPSBUJPOCFUXFFO0.(BOE*/$04&POEFﬁOJOHNPEFM CBTFETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH .#4& "TVSWFZPG.#4&SFMBUFENFUIPEPMPHJFTIBTCFFOQSPEVDFE &TUFGBO BOE BVHNFOUFE &TUFGBO "NPOH UIF NFUIPEPMPHJFT JO UIF TVSWFZ BSFUIF0CKFDU1SPDFTT.FUIPEPMPHZ 01. %PSJ

&NCFEEFE$PNQVUFS4ZTUFN"OBMZTJT BOE.PEFMJOH &$4". -BWJBOE,VEJTI

BOE.PEFM#BTFE 4ZTUFNT "SDIJUFDUJOHBOE 4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH .#"4& #PFINBOE1PSU,PPMNBOPKXPOHBOE#PFIN 4PNF4&NBOBHFNFOUMJUFSBUVSFIBTEFﬁOFEBNPSFFOHJOFFSJOHBOENPEFMJOHBQQSPBDIUP NBOBHFNFOU'PSFYBNQMF (BSWFZ EFTDSJCFTQSPCBCJMJTUJDDPTUNPEFMTGPSTZTUFNTFOHJ OFFSJOH.PSFHFOFSBMMZ UIFDMPTFMZSFMBUFEﬁFMEPG0QFSBUJPOT3FTFBSDI 03 IBTCFFOTUSPOHMZ NPEFMCBTFEGPSEFDBEFT03DBOCFFYQFDUFEUPDPOUSJCVUFUPNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOJO4& "USFOEJOGFEFSBMBDRVJTJUJPOQSBDUJDFJTUPFNQIBTJ[FNPEFMCBTFEBDRVJTJUJPOQSPDFTTFT $*0 .PEFMTBSFFODPVSBHFEBTBXBZUPEFﬁOFNPSFQSFDJTFSFRVJSFNFOUTBOEBSDIJUFDUVSFTBOE UPGBDJMJUBUFUIFVTFPGQBUUFSOT UFTUIBSOFTTFT BOEBVUPNBUJPOJOHFOFSBM 5BLFOUPHFUIFS UIFGPSFHPJOHFYBNQMFTTIPXUIBUNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOJTCFJOHFYUFOEFEGSPN USBEJUJPOBMTJNVMBUJPONPEFMTUPBNPSFQFSWBTJWFDPODFQUPGNPEFMT*O.04&4 UIFGVMMFYQSFT TJPOPGNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPODPOTJEFSTBMMUIFLFZBSUJGBDUTPGFOHJOFFSJOHBOEUIFUIFPSJFT MBXT BOE PCTFSWBUJPOTPGTDJFODFUPCFNPEFMTPGTZTUFNTThJTQFSTQFDUJWFBMJHOTTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHXJUI SFMBUFEEJTDJQMJOFT CBTFEPOPVSCFMJFGUIBUNPEFMTBSFUIFOBUVSBMMZEPNJOBOUQFSTQFDUJWF SFQPTJ UPSZPGLOPXMFEHF BOEWFIJDMFPGDPNNVOJDBUJPOJOBMMFOHJOFFSJOHBOETDJFODFEJTDJQMJOFT *OTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH NBOZRVBMJUBUJWFMZEJﬀFSFOUUIJOHTBSFNPEFMFE O .PEFMJOHTZTUFNT N 8IPMFTZTUFNT BOEJOUFSBDUJOHQBSUTPGTZTUFNT N ThFTZTUFNTFOWJSPONFOUBOEUIFJOUFSBDUJPOPGUIFTZTUFNXJUIUIBUFOWJSPONFOU N 4USVDUVSF CFIBWJPS FOUJUJFT JOUFSBDUJPOT BOESFMBUJPOT

80

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

N 1SPQFSUJFT JODMVEJOHUSBEJUJPOBMPOFTTVDIBTQFSGPSNBODFPSRVBMJUZ BTXFMMBTGV[[Z BOETUPDIBTUJDPOFT N "UUSJCVUFT RVBMJUJFT DBUFHPSJFT N 0QFSBUJPOTPSQSPDFTTFT N 4ZTUFNDIBOHFBOEFWPMVUJPO N $POTUSBJOUT JODMVEJOHXIBUJTBMMPXFE XIBUJTNBOEBUFE XIBUJTQSPIJCJUFE N 8IBUJTDPNNPOBOEXIBUJTVOJRVF N 7JFXT N *OGPSNBUJPOBCPVUUIFNPEFMTUIFNTFMWFT O .PEFMJOHUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPSBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT N -JGFTQBOQIBTFT USBEJUJPOBMMZDBMMFEMJGFADZDMFQIBTFT

N 1SPDFTTUZQFT FH XBUFSGBMM TQJSBM FWPMVUJPOBSZ FUD

N &OWJSPONFOUDIBOHFUPJOﬂVFODFBOBEBQUJWFTZTUFN O .PEFMJOHNBOBHFNFOUPG4&QSPKFDUT BOEPGFOUFSQSJTFT N .PEFMTPGTUBﬃOH DPTU SFTPVSDFT TDIFEVMFT FUD N %FDJTJPONPEFMT ThFTFBSFBTBSFBEESFTTFEJOUIFDIBQUFSTUIBUGPMMPX

Types of Models in the Extended SE Generic Types 5BCMFJEFOUJﬁFTBOECSJFﬂZEFﬁOFTWBSJPVTUZQFTPGNPEFMTUIBUIBWFSFMFWBODFUP4&.BOZPG UIFEFﬁOJUJPOTBSFNPEJﬁDBUJPOTPGUIPTFHJWFOJO,VMBLPXTLJFUBM .PEFMTJOFOHJOFFSJOHBOETDJFODFSBOHFGSPNBOBMZUJDNPEFMTUIBUSFQSFTFOUFYBDUDMPTFEGPSN TPMVUJPOT UPTJNVMBUJPOBOEPUIFSJOGPSNBMNPEFMTUIBUSFQSFTFOUNVMUJWBSJBCMFCVUTUJMMPSHBOJ[FE TPMVUJPOT UPQSPCBCJMJTUJDBOEPUIFSVODFSUBJOUZNPEFMTUIBUSFQSFTFOUFYQMJDJUMZOPOEFUFSNJOJTUJD TPMVUJPOTThJTWJFXPG5BCMFDPSSFTQPOETUP8FBWFST POFEJNFOTJPOBMSBOHFPGDPN QMFYJUZGSPNPSHBOJ[FETJNQMJDJUZUPPSHBOJ[FEDPNQMFYJUZUPEJTPSHBOJ[FEDPNQMFYJUZ

Trends toward Complex System (CS) Models Th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ﬁSTUDBNQCVUBMTPBDDFQUTB GVOEBNFOUBM $4 FYUFOTJPO PG 4& CFZPOE 54& 8F DIBSBDUFSJ[F BOE TVNNBSJ[F UIF EJﬀFSFODF CFUXFFO54&BOEUIFFYUFOTJPOBTNFDIBOJTUJDNPEFMTWFSTVTPSHBOJDPSBVUPOPNPVTNPEFMT*O UIJTCPPLXFVTFUIFUFSNTiNFDIBOJTUJDwBOEi54&wTPNFXIBUJOUFSDIBOHFBCMZ BOEUIFUFSNT iPSHBOJDwBOEi$4wPSi$4FOHJOFFSJOHw $4& TPNFXIBUJOUFSDIBOHFBCMZ

Features of MOSES

O

81

Table 4.1 Types of Models Variable Linearity

Type Linear

Non-linear

Brief Deﬁnition, Example Involves a single dimension, or all variables are of ﬁrst order, or output is proportional to input; or elements are additive. Ex: F(x) ax b; linear differential equation Not linear; at least one variable is second or higher order; output is not proportional to input; or elements are not additive. Ex: F(x) ax2 b; nonlinear differential equation.

Distribution

Lumped or centralized Distributed

Dependent variables are independent of spatial coordinates Ex: ordinary differential equations Dependent variables are functions of spatial coordinates. Ex: partial differential equations; network model

Variability

Static or time invariant Dynamic or time varying

Model parameters are constant across time. Ex: differential equations with constant coefﬁcients Model parameters vary across time. Ex: differential equations with time-varying coefﬁcients; simulations

Continuity

Discrete

Dependent variables deﬁned only for distinct values of independent variables. Ex: difference equations Dependent variables deﬁned over continuous range of independent variables. Ex: differential equations

Continuous Determinism

Deterministic

Stochastic or probabilistic Analysis method

Quantitative Qualitative

Executability

Nonexecutable Executable

Outputs are known, certain, predictable given inputs. Ex: equation with ﬁxed variables; deterministic cellular automaton model Outputs have a degree of uncertainty given inputs. Ex: equation with random variables; probabilistic cellular automaton model Uses and produces numbers; based on interval and ratio measurement scales. Ex: differential equation Uses and produces descriptions, categories, comparisons; based on nominal and ordinal measurement scales Ex: taxonomy Model does not imply a process; or no agent exists that can execute it or translate it into executable model Ex: requirements document; design document Model implies a process and an agent exists that can execute it or translate it into executable model. Ex: simulation; executable architecture; UML design model for which code generator exists; requirements written in Prolog

(Source: Kulakowski, B.T., J.F. Gardner, and J.L. Shearer. Dynamic Modeling and Control of Engineering Systems, 3rd ed. New York: Cambridge University Press. 2007. Modiﬁed with permission.)

8FQSFTFOUFEUIFDPOUSBTUJOHTZTUFNDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPG54&BOE$4JO$IBQUFS$4NPEFMT IBWFCFFOBSPVOEBTMPOHBT54&BOETPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHCVUUIFZIBWFSFNBJOFEPOTVCTUBO UJBMMZTFQBSBUFQBUITBOEJOEJﬀFSFOUDPNNVOJUJFTFTQFDJBMMZTFQBSBUFGSPNUIF54&DPNNV OJUZThFEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOUIFQFSTQFDUJWFTPG54NPEFMTBOE$4NPEFMTJTBOBMPHPVTUPUIF

82 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

EJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOUIFQFSTQFDUJWFTPG/FXUPOJBOQIZTJDTBOERVBOUVNQIZTJDT$4NPEFMTBMTP SFQSFTFOUBOJNQPSUBOUTUFQUPXBSEVOJﬁDBUJPOPGNVMUJQMFEJTDJQMJOFT ThFTUVEZPG$4IBTCFFOFYQMJDJUJOJUTVTFPGNPEFMT JODMVEJOHNBUIFNBUJDBMNPEFMTTVDI BTEJﬀFSFOUJBMFRVBUJPOT EJﬀFSFODFFRVBUJPOT DFMMVMBSBVUPNBUB HBNFUIFPSZ .BSLPWQSPDFTTFT HFOFUJDBMHPSJUINT HSBQIUIFPSZ BOEUJNFTFSJFTBOBMZTJT $4$4 8PSLJOEZOBNJDBMTZT UFNT FH )BTTFMCMBUUBOE,BUPL,VMBLPXTLJFUBM.BSUFMMJ SFQSFTFOUTBCSJEHF CFUXFFO54BOE$4 JOQBSUCFDBVTFJUJODMVEFTNPEFMTPGDIBPT BOEDIBPTJTVTVBMMZDPOTJEFSFE QBSUPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNTUIFPSZBMUIPVHIJUJTEFUFSNJOJTUJD The GPSFHPJOHNPEFMTIBWFCFFOVTFEUPSFQSFTFOUTZTUFNCFIBWJPSBOEDIBOHFJONVMUJQMFEJTDJ QMJOFT JODMVEJOHCJPMPHZ QTZDIPMPHZ TPDJPMPHZ PSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTUVEJFT FDPOPNJDT BOENFUFPSPMPHZ %PZMF JEFOUJﬁFEUIFEPNJOBODFPGOFUXPSLNPEFMTBDSPTTNVMUJQMFDPNQMFYTZTUFNEPNBJOT JODMVEJOHOFUXPSLTJOUFDIOPMPHZ *OUFSOFU XJSFMFTT FOFSHZ USBOTQPSUBUJPO OBOPUFDIOPMPHZ CJPMPHZ HFOPNJDT CJPJOGPSNBUJDT NFEJDJOF FQJEFNJPMPHZ FDPMPHZ QIZTJDT NVMUJTDBMF UVSCVMFODF DIBPT GSBDUBMT DSJUJDBMJUZ TFMGTJNJMBSJUZ

TPDJBMTDJFODFT FDPOPNJDT TPDJPMPHZ QPMJUJDT NBOBHFNFOU MBX TNBMMXPSMET BOENBUIFNBUJDT HSBQI JOGPSNBUJPO DPOUSPM EZOBNJDBMTZTUFNT GPSNBMNFUIPET 8FOPUFEJO$IBQUFSUIBU54&SFHBSETUIFIVNBOBTCFJOHPVUTJEFUIFTZTUFNThF*&&& TUBOEBSE *&&& JMMVTUSBUFT UIJT WJFX JO UIF EBUB QBDLBHF TFDUJPO PO IVNBOT JU iEPDVNFOUTDPHOJUJWF QIZTJDBM BOETFOTPSZDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGIVNBOTXIPPQFSBUF NBJOUBJO BOETVQQPSUUIFTZTUFNzwThF$4FYUFOTJPOPGTZTUFNCPVOEBSJFTUPJODMVEFIVNBOTJOTJEFUIF TZTUFNJTBTJHOJﬁDBOUTUFQGPSXBSEJO4&CFDBVTFJUSFRVJSFTBNPSFDPNQSFIFOTJWFVOEFSTUBOE JOHBOEDBQUVSFPGIVNBOCFIBWJPSJONPEFMT4PNFXPSLJOEZOBNJDBMTZTUFNTIBTBSHVBCMZ JODMVEFEIVNBOTCVUUIFZIBWFCFFOSBUIFSBCTUSBDUXJUISFHBSEUPIVNBOCFIBWJPSThFBSFOB PG$4DBOCSJOHJOTPDJBMBOECFIBWJPSBMNPEFMTUPJNQSPWFUIFﬁEFMJUZPGEZOBNJDBMNPEFMTPG IVNBOJOUFSBDUJPO 0UIFSFYBNQMFTBSFUIFJODMVTJPOPGFWPMVUJPOBTBNPEFMPGDPOUJOVJOHDIBOHFBOEUIFVTF PGQSPCBCJMJTUJDNPEFMT BTEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFSTBOE SFTQFDUJWFMZ"HJWFODMBTTPG$4NPE FMTDPSSFTQPOETUPTZTUFNTJONBOZEPNBJOTPSEJTDJQMJOFT.PEFMTPGOBUVSBMTZTUFNT TVDIBT CJPMPHJDBM FWPMVUJPO PG QPQVMBUJPOT BSF CFJOH BQQMJFE UP BSUJﬁDJBM TZTUFNT TVDI BT BSUJﬁDJBM MJGF -BOHUPO FTQFDJBMMZ3BZ .PEFMTPGBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNT TVDIBTJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNT BSF CFJOH BQQMJFE UP OBUVSBM TZTUFNT TVDI BT MJWJOH TZTUFNT GSPN DFMMT UP IVNBOT UP TPDJFUJFT .JMMFS "OPUIFSFYBNQMFPGUIFMBUUFSJTUIF1IZTJPNFQSPKFDU UPXIJDIUIF"QSJM JTTVFPGUIF1SPDFFEJOHTPGUIF*&&&XBTEFWPUFE 1IZTJPNF ThJTQSPKFDUJTBOFYBNQMFPG VTJOHBNPEFMJOHBQQSPBDIUPJOUFHSBUFEJﬀ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hFFOHJOFFSJOHPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNT IPXFWFS JTB SFMBUJWFMZOFXBSFB BOEJUJTIFSFUIBUTPNFGVSUIFSNPEFMJOHSFTFBSDIDPVMECFVTFGVM0OFFBSMZ DPMMFDUJPOPGSFTVMUTJOFOHJOFFSJOHDPNQMFYTZTUFNTJT#SBIBFUBM

Illustrations of Modeling Choice *OPVSEFﬁOJUJPOPGTZTUFN XFOPUFEUIBUTZTUFNTEPOPUFYJTUBTTZTUFNTQFSTFJOUIFXPSME"NPTBJD FYJTUT BOEBTZTUFNJTBMMPSQBSUPGUIFNPTBJDUIBUBOPCTFSWFSDIPPTFTUPEFTJHOBUFBTBTZTUFN

Features of MOSES

O

83

*ONPEFMPSJFOUBUJPO DIPJDFJONPEFMJOHJTSFMBUFEUPDIPJDFJOTZTUFNTCVUDIPJDFQMBZTBO FWFONPSFQSPNJOFOUSPMFJONPEFMJOHThFDPODFQUPGDIPJDFJOUIFEFﬁOJUJPOBOEVTFPGNPEFMT JT TVﬃcJFOUMZ JNQPSUBOU UP EJTDVTT JU JO EFUBJM *O BOZ HJWFO TJUVBUJPO XF UZQJDBMMZ IBWF NBOZ DIPJDFTJOIPXXFNPEFMThFSFJTOPUBiSJHIUwPSiXSPOHwXBZUPNPEFM PSBiSJHIUwPSiXSPOHw NPEFMThFRVFTUJPOUPBTLJTOPUi8IBUJTUIFNPEFMPGUIJTTZTUFN wThFRVFTUJPOUPBTLJTi8IBU EPXFXBOUUPBDIJFWF BOEXIBUJTBSFBTPOBCMFNPEFM PSTFUPGNPEFMT UPIFMQBDIJFWFJU wThFSF BSFBMUFSOBUJWFXBZTUPNPEFM BOETPNFNBZIBWFHSFBUFSCFOFﬁUUIBOPUIFSTGPSBHJWFOQVSQPTF BOETPNFNBZDPTUNPSFUIBOPUIFST4P DPTUCFOFﬁUSBUJPJTPOFGBDUPSJOTFMFDUJOHBNPOHUIF NPEFMJOHDIPJDFT "OPUIFS GBDUPS JO NPEFMJOH DIPJDF JT UIF QSJPS LOPXMFEHF QFSTPOBM FYQFSJFODF WJFXT QFS DFQUJPOT BOECJBTFTUIBUBNPEFMFSCSJOHTUPBNPEFMJOHTJUVBUJPO*OUIFHFOFSBMDBTF 8BSﬁFME DBMMTUIJTUIFDPHOJUJWFCVSEFOUIBUFBDIQFSTPOCSJOHTUPQSPCMFNTJUVBUJPOT 8FJMMVTUSBUFNPEFMJOHDIPJDFXJUIUIFGPMMPXJOHFYBNQMFT *OQIZTJDT /FXUPOTDPODFQUPGHSBWJUBUJPOJTUIBUJUFYFSUTBGPSDFUIBUDBVTFTBCPEZUPDIBOHF EJSFDUJPOJOMJOFBSTQBDF XIJMF&JOTUFJOTDPODFQUPGHSBWJUBUJPOJTUIBUNBUUFSDVSWFTTQBDFUJNF BOEBCPEZTNPNFOUVNTJNQMZUBLFTJUBMPOHUIFDPOUPVSTPGUIFDVSWFTThFEJTUJODUJPONBZCF TVNNBSJ[FEUIJTXBZ 1PHHF O /FXUPOJBOHSBWJUZ N .BUUFSUFMMTHSBWJUBUJPOIPXUPFYFSUBGPSDF N "GPSDFUFMMTNBUUFSIPXUPBDDFMFSBUF O (FOFSBM3FMBUJWJUZ N .BUUFSUFMMTTQBDFUJNFIPXUPDVSWF N $VSWFETQBDFUJNFUFMMTNBUUFSIPXUPNPWF ThFTF BSF UXP WFSZ EJﬀFSFOU FWFO SBEJDBMMZ EJﬀFSFOU DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOT *U JT UFNQUJOH UP TBZ CBTFEPOFYQFSJNFOUBMFWJEFODF UIBU&JOTUFJOTUIFPSJFTPGTQFDJBMBOEHFOFSBMSFMBUJWJUZBSFiUSVFw BOE /FXUPOT DPSSFTQPOEJOH UIFPSJFT BSF wGBMTFw :FU XF BSF TUJMM UFBDIJOH /FXUPOJBO QIZTJDT BMPOHXJUITQFDJBMBOEHFOFSBMSFMBUJWJUZBOERVBOUVNQIZTJDT XIJDIJOTPNFSFTQFDUTSFQMBDFE UIFNCPUIJODPMMFHFBOEVOJWFSTJUZQIZTJDTDPVSTFT8IZ #FDBVTFUIFEFQJDUJPOPGSFMBUJWJUZ BTUSVFBOE/FXUPOJBOUIFPSZBTGBMTFJTJODPNQMFUF NJTMFBEJOH BOEVOIFMQGVM"NPSFQSBDUJDBM DIBSBDUFSJ[BUJPOJTUIBUJONBOZDJSDVNTUBODFT UIFSFMBUJWJUZBOE/FXUPOJBONPEFMTZJFMECBTJ DBMMZUIFTBNFSFTVMUT XIJMFJOTPNFDJSDVNTUBODFT UIFSFMBUJWJUZNPEFMZJFMETCFUUFSSFTVMUT UIBU JT IBTOPUJDFBCMZHSFBUFSﬁEFMJUZUPUIFQIZTJDBMVOJWFSTF UIFTZTUFN UIBOEPFTUIF/FXUPOJBO NPEFM.PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ O 'PSDPNNPODJSDVNTUBODFTXIFSFXFBLHSBWJUBUJPOBMﬁFMETBOETQFFETNVDITMPXFSUIBO UIFTQFFEPGMJHIUPCUBJO UIFUXPNPEFMTHJWFSFTVMUTUIBUBSFJOEJTUJOHVJTIBCMF O 'PSDJSDVNTUBODFTJOXIJDIHSBWJUBUJPOBMﬁFMETBSFTUSPOHPSTQFFETBQQSPBDIUIFTQFFEPG MJHIU UIFSFMBUJWJUZNPEFMHJWFTTJHOJﬁDBOUMZNPSFBDDVSBUFSFTVMUT O 5IFNBUIFNBUJDTPGUIF/FXUPOJBONPEFMBSFOPUBCMZTJNQMFSUIBOUIFNBUIFNBUJDT PGSFMBUJWJUZ ThFTFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGUIFUXPNPEFMTTVHHFTUBDIPJDF5XPHFOFSBMMZEFTJSBCMFHPBMTPGNPE FMJOHBSFﬁEFMJUZBOETJNQMJDJUZ'PSUIFMBSHFOVNCFSPGBQQMJDBUJPOTJOXIJDIUIFUXPNPEFMTHJWF JOEJTUJOHVJTIBCMFSFTVMUT XFXPVMEDIPPTFUIF/FXUPOJBONPEFMCFDBVTFJUJTTJNQMFS*ODBTFT XIFSFUIFSFMBUJWJUZNPEFMHJWFTHSFBUFSBDDVSBDZ BOEXFOFFEHSFBUFSBDDVSBDZ XFXPVMETFMFDU

84 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

JUJOUIJTDBTF PVSiDIPJDFwXPVMECFIJHIMZSFTUSJDUFE"OFYBNQMFPGUIFMBUUFSDBTFJTUIF(MPCBM 1PTJUJPOJOH4ZTUFN (14 OBWJHBUJPOTZTUFN5PEFUFSNJOFUIFEFTJSFEBDDVSBDZPGMPDBUJPOPO UIF&BSUITTVSGBDF FYUSFNFBDDVSBDZJTSFRVJSFEJODMPDLTZODISPOJ[BUJPOCFUXFFOTBUFMMJUFBOE HSPVOE TJUFT $MPDL BEKVTUNFOUT BSF OFFEFE GSPN CPUI SFMBUJWJUZ NPEFMT UIF TQFDJBM UIFPSZ BOEHFOFSBMUIFPSZUPBDIJFWFUIJT(14QSFDJTJPOXPVMECFEJﬃDVMUUPBDIJFWFXJUIPVUCPUI UIFPSJFT 1BSUPGUIFDIPJDFJONPEFMJOHJTEFDJEJOHIPXUPDPODFQUVBMJ[FBTJUVBUJPO ThJTJTJMMVTUSBUFE JOUIFSBEJDBMDPODFQUVBMEJﬀFSFODFTCFUXFFOUIF/FXUPOJBO SFMBUJWJTUJD BOERVBOUVNNPEFMTPG HSBWJUBUJPO BMUIPVHIJONBOZDBTFTUIFZHJWFTJNJMBSSFTVMUT*UJTBMTPJMMVTUSBUFEJOUIFEJﬀFSFODFT CFUXFFOCJPMPHJDBM QTZDIPMPHJDBM BOETPDJBMNPEFMTPGIVNBOT"OPUIFSFYBNQMFJTUIFEVBMJUZ PGMJHIUBTXBWFBOEBTQBSUJDMF. ThFZSFQSFTFOUEJﬀFSFOUXBZTPGNPEFMJOHMJHIU ThFUXPFYBNQMFTPGIVNBOTBOEMJHIUBMTPSFQSFTFOUBOPUIFSBTQFDUPGDIPJDFDIPPTJOH NVMUJQMFNPEFMT4PNFUJNFTXFDIPPTFPOFNPEFMJOTUFBEPGBOPUIFS CVUPGUFOXFDIPPTFNVM UJQMFNPEFMTCFDBVTFOPTJOHMFNPEFMEPFTFWFSZUIJOHXFOFFE%JﬀFSFOUNPEFMTBSFVTFGVMGPS DFSUBJO EJﬀFSFOU QVSQPTFT*OUIFMJHIUFYBNQMF UIFXBWFBOEQBSUJDMFNPEFMTBSFDPNQMFNFO UBSZNPEFMT CPUIPGXIJDIBSFOFDFTTBSZGPSBDPNQMFUFVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGMJHIU BOEBDUVBMMZBMM PCKFDUT BTRVBOUVNNFDIBOJDTUFMMTVT *OUIFIVNBOFYBNQMF UIFCJPMPHJDBM QTZDIPMPHJDBM BOE TPDJBMNPEFMTBSFDPNQMFNFOUBSZNPEFMT BMMPGXIJDIBSFOFDFTTBSZUPGVMMZBDDPVOUGPSIVNBO DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT/PUFWFSZIVNBONPEFMJOHTJUVBUJPOSFRVJSFTBMMUISFFNPEFMUZQFTJONBOZDBTFT XFNBZPOMZOFFEPOFPSUXPPGUIFN *O.04&4 TVDIDPNQMFNFOUBSZNPEFMTPSEVBMJUJFTBSFDBMMFE WJFXTThFSFJTBXBWFWJFX BOEBQBSUJDMFWJFXPGMJHIUThFSFJTBCJPMPHJDBMWJFX BQTZDIPMPHJDBMWJFX BOEBTPDJBMWJFXPG IVNBOT7JFXTJODMVEJOHEVBMJUJFTBSFBOJNQPSUBOUQBSUPG.04&4BOEBSFEJTDVTTFEJONPSF EFUBJMJO$IBQUFS ThFGPMMPXJOHFYBNQMFJMMVTUSBUFTIPXEJﬀFSFOUNPEFMTSFTVMUGSPNWBSZJOHQVSQPTFBOEGPDVT 4VQQPTFXBUFSﬂPXTGSPNBTQSJOHUPMBLF- UIFOUISPVHIBDIBOOFMUPMBLF-)PXXPVMEXF NPEFMUIJT )FSFBSFTPNFQPTTJCMFQVSQPTFTBOEDPSSFTQPOEJOHNPEFMT 8FBSFJOUFSFTUFEJODPNQBSJOHUIFUXPMBLFTBOEIPXUIFXBUFSﬂoXTCFUXFFOUIFN0VS NPEFMJTTPNFUIJOHMJLFUIJTXFdeﬁne PVSTZTUFNPGJOUFSFTU 40* UPDPOTJTUPGUIFUXP MBLFTBOEUIFDIBOOFM.PSFspeciﬁcally -BOE-BSFDPNQPOFOUT UIFZJOUFSBDUWJBB DPOOFDUPS XIJDIJTUIFDIBOOFMUIFstuﬀ UIBUJTFYDIBOHFEJTXBUFSBOEUIFﬂoXPGstuﬀ JT BMXBZTPOFEJSFDUJPOBM GSom L1 to L2. This is an internal or “TZTUFNBTQBSUTwNPEFM 8FBSFJOUFSFTUFEJOCVJMEJOH PSSFCVJMEJOH UIFDIBOOFMThFDIBOOFMJTPVSTZTUFN40*UIF FOWJSPONFOUJODMVEFTXBUFSUIBUXJMMCFUSBOTQPSUFECZUIFTZTUFNUIFMBOEUFSSBJOBDSPTT XIJDIXFXJMMCVJMEUIFTZTUFN- XIJDIJTUIFTVQQMJFSUPUIFTZTUFN DPOOFDUFEUPJUT JOQVUQPSU BOE- XIJDIJTUIFDPOTVNFSPGUIFTZTUFN DPOOFDUFEUPJUTPVUQVUQPSU 4VQQPTFUIFDIBOOFMJTBOBUVSBMSJWFSBOEXFBSFJOUFSFTUFEJOUIFQSPQFSUJFTBOEEZOBNJDT PGXBUFSﬂPXUISPVHIUIFSJWFSThFTZTUFN40*JTUIFXBUFS BOEUIFFOWJSPONFOUJTUIF SJWFSCFE FTQFDJBMMZJUTTIBQFBOEDPOUPVST 4VQQPTFXFﬁOEQPTTJCMFQPMMVUBOUTJOUIFXBUFSDPNJOHPVUPG- BOEUIFTFQPMMVUBOUT BSFOPUJOUIFXBUFSDPNJOHJOUP-GSPNUIFTQSJOH0VSTZTUFN40*JT-8FXBOUUP JOWFTUJHBUFUXPUIJOHT'JSTU XIBUFYBDUMZJTUIFEJﬀFSFODFCFUXFFOUIF DMFBO JOQVUBOE UIF QPMMVUFE PVUQVU UIBU JT XIJDI QPMMVUBOUT IPX NVDI FUD 4FDPOE XIBU BSF UIF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOEﬂPXTJOUFSOBMUP- 'PSFYBNQMF JTUIFSFBSFMBUJWFMZTNPPUIHSBEJFOU GSPNiDMFBOwPOUIFJOQVUTQSJOHTJEFUPiQPMMVUFEwPOUIFPVUQVUDIBOOFMTJEF 0SJTUIFSF BMPDBMJ[FETQJLFJOQPMMVUJPOBUPOFPSNPSFQPJOUTJOUIFMBLF 0VSﬁSTURVFTUJPOMFBETUP

Features of MOSES

O 85

BOFYUFSOBMJOQVUPVUQVUNPEFMPG- BOEPVSTFDPOERVFTUJPOMFBETUPBOJOUFSOBMNPEFM PG-EFﬁOFEUPBOBMZ[FUIFHSBEJFOU 4VQQPTFUIBUUIFBOTXFSTUPUIFNPEFMJOHBOEBOBMZTJTJO BCPWFBSFBTGPMMPXT'JSTU XF JEFOUJGZUIFQPMMVUBOUTDPNJOHPVUPGUIFMBLF BOEUIFZJODMVEFBIJHIMZUPYJDTVCTUBODF XIJDIJODSFBTFTUIFJNQPSUBODFBOEVSHFODZPGﬁOEJOHBOBOTXFSBOETPMWJOHUIJTQSPC MFN4FDPOE SFTVMUTPGUIFJOUFSOBMBOBMZTJTPG-BSFJODPODMVTJWF8FIBWFOPUJTPMBUFE XIFSFPSIPXUIFQPMMVUBOUTBSFBQQFBSJOHThFTFSFTVMUTJOEJDBUFUIBUXFOFFEUPEFﬁOFB EJﬀFSFOU NPSFEFUBJMFENPEFM XIPTFQVSQPTFJTUXPGPME B 4BGFUZJTTVFT8IBUJTUIFDVSSFOUPSQPUFOUJBMEBNBHFGSPNUIFQPMMVUFEXBUFSDPNJOH PVUPG- BOEXIPPSXIBUBSFUIFWVMOFSBCMFQBSUJFT C %FUFSNJOJOHUIFDBVTF8IBUJTUIFTPVSDFPSDBVTFPGUIFQPMMVUJPO ThJTXJMMQPJOU VTUPXBSEBSFNFEZ 5PJOWFTUJHBUFJONPSFEFUBJM XFdeﬁne BNPEFMUIBUJODMVEFTFMFNFOUTUIBUXFJHOPSFEJO PVSQSFWJPVTNPEFMCFDBVTFXFDPOTJEFSFEUIFNUPCFOFHMJHJCMF.PTUMZUIFTFBEEJUJPOBM FMFNFOUTSFMBUFUPFYQBOEJOHUIFFOWJSPONFOUBTJUJTDPOOFDUFEUPJOQVUBOEPVUQVUQPSUT PG-"EESFTTJOHQVSQPTF TBGFUZ JTBTTPDJBUFENPSFXJUIPVUQVUQPSUTThese JODMVEF B 8BUFSFWBQPSBUFTJOUPUIFBJSBCPWF- C 8BUFSNBZTFFQJOUPUIFHSPVOEBOEXBUFSUBCMF CFMPX- D 1FPQMFTXJNNJOHJOUIF-DPOUBDUUIFQPMMVUBOUPOUIFJSTLJOBOENBZHFU UIFQPMMVUBOUJOUIFJSFZFT PSESJOLUIFQPMMVUFEXBUFS E 1FPQMFPSQSFEBUPSTFBUJOHﬁsh GSPNUIFMBLF BTTVNJOHUIFSFBSFBOZ NBZJOHFTUUIFQPMMVUBOUGSPNUIFﬁsh. WFOFFEUP FYBNJOFBMMUIFTFQPTTJCJMJUJFT BOEQFSIBQTﬁrst UBLFQSFWFOUJWFNFBTVSFT TVDIBTUFNQPSBS ily banning swimming and ﬁshing in L1.

"EESFTTJOHQVSQPTF DBVTF JTBTTPDJBUFENPSFXJUIJOQVUQPSUTThFTFJODMVEF B 8BUFS QSFDJQJUBUFT GSPN UIF BJS BCPWF - o QFSIBQT BDJE SBJO JT B TPVSDF PG UIF QPMMVUBOU C 1PMMVUBOUTNBZCFTFFQJOHPVUPGUIFHSPVOEVOEFS-JOUPUIFMBLFXBUFS D 1FPQMFNBZ CFEVNQJOHQPMMVUBOUTJOUP- E .BZCFUIFSFJTBOPUIFSVOLOPXOTPVSDF MJLFBOFBSCZ GBDUPSZ UIBUJTQSPEVDJOHSVOPﬀ UIBUﬂPXTJOUP- F .BZCFUIFQPMMVUBOUJTFNFSHJOH GSPNBSFBDUJPOCFUXFFOBOPOQPMMVUJOHTVCTUBODFUIBUJTFOUFSJOHUIFMBLFBOETPNFPUIFS OPOQPMMVUJOHTVCTUBODFJOUIFMBLF

"OFYBNQMFPGBSBUIFSTUBSLNPEFMJOHDIPJDFJTUIFDPOUSBTUCFUXFFOUIFDPNQMFYTZTUFNT NPEFMTPGTFMGPSHBOJ[FEDSJUJDBMJUZ 40$ BOEIJHIMZPQUJNJ[FEUPMFSBODF )05 $BSMTPOBOE %PZMF QSFTFOUBDPNQBSJTPOPGUIFOFBSMZPQQPTJUFBTTVNQUJPOTBOEGFBUVSFTPGUIFTFNPE FMT.PSFEJTDVTTJPOPGUIF40$BOE)05NPEFMTGSPNB.04&4QFSTQFDUJWFJTQSFTFOUFEJOUIF DPOUFYUPGWJFXTJO$IBQUFS "MMUIFTFDBTFTJMMVTUSBUFIPXNPEFMJOHJOWPMWFTDIPJDFTBOEEFDJTJPOTUIFSFJTOPUBOJOIFSFOU XBZUPNPEFM0VSDIPJDFTBSFJOﬂVFODFECZPVSQVSQPTFTGPSNPEFMJOHBOECZDPOTUSBJOUTFYJTU JOHJOUIFTJUVBUJPO BOETPNFUJNFTCZPVSJOUFSQSFUBUJPOPGBTJUVBUJPO

Model Space ThFNPEFMTQBDFJTBTUSVDUVSFGPSDPOUBJOJOHBOEPSHBOJ[JOHBMMNPEFMTOPUPOMZTZTUFNTFOHJ OFFSJOHBOEFOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOHBSUJGBDUTCVUUIFNPEFMTPGBMMTVQQPSUJOHTDJFODFTBOENBUIFNBU JDT&BSMJFSGPSNTPGUIJTNPEFMTQBDFBQQMJFEUPTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHXFSFQSFTFOUFEJO)ZCFSUTPO BOE BOEBTVNNBSZPGUIFFYUFOEFEGPSNGPSTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHJO)ZCFSUTPO 1SFDVSTPSTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFGPSUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOFTFYJTUJOFOHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLT TVDIBT1FSSZT$IFNJDBM&OHJOFFST)BOECPPL (SFFOBOE1FSSZ 0UIFSGPSNTPGQBSUJBMNPEFM

86

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

TQBDFTJODMVEFQVCMJTIFEHVJEFTUPCPEJFTPGLOPXMFEHF #P,T

QBUUFSOTCPPLT SFGFSFODFBSDIJUFD UVSFT BOETUBOEBSET*OUIFGVUVSF XFFYQFDUPOMJOFIZQFSMJOLFEWJSUVBMSFQPTJUPSJFTPGNPEFMTUPCF UIFOPSN BOEUIFZBSFUIFQBUUFSOGPSUIFFOWJTJPOFE4&NPEFMTQBDF*OUIFDBTFPG4& BDPOTJEFS BCMFBNPVOUPGDPOUFOUFYJTUT BMUIPVHIOPUOFDFTTBSJMZJOBGPSNUIBUJTSFBEZGPSUIFNPEFMTQBDF 0VSJOUFOUJOUIJTCPPLJTUPQSPWJEFBTUSVDUVSFGPSUIFSFQPTJUPSZPSNPEFMTQBDF BOEUP QPJOUUPTPNFPGUIFDPOUFOUGPSUIFTFUSBEJUJPOBMQSBDUJDFT BTXFMMBTOFXPOFTThFNPEFMTQBDF JTTUSVDUVSFECy ﬁWFQSJNBSZFMFNFOUTUIBUTFQBSBUF4&DPODFSOT. ThFFMFNFOUTBSF "DPNQPTJUJPOTQFDUSVNUIBUSFQSFTFOUTBXIPMFoQBSUIJFSBSDIZSBOHJOHGSPNUIFMBSHFTU TZTUFNUPUIFTNBMMFTUVOJU*UFYIJCJUTBSFQFBUJOHTFMGTJNJMBSQBUUFSOJOUIBUBHJWFOXIPMF JTQBSUPGBMBSHFSXIPMF "DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVNUIBUSBOHFTGSPNQSPCMFNEPNBJOMBOHVBHFTUPFOHJOFFSJOH EPNBJOMBOHVBHFT JODMVEJOHNBUIFNBUJDTThJTIJHIMJHIUTUIFDPNQMJDBUJOHGBDUUIBU4& BOEUIFSFGPSFUIFNPEFMTQBDF JTGVOEBNFOUBMMZNVMUJMJOHVBM "DPNNPOJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVNUIBUSFQSFTFOUTiLJOEPGwBOEiJTBwIJFSBSDIJFTSBOHJOHGSPN VOJWFSTBMNPEFMTUPJOTUBODFNPEFMT*UFYIJCJUTBSFQFBUJOHTFMGTJNJMBSQBUUFSOJOUIBUB NPEFMUIBUJTBHFOFSBMJ[BUJPODBO JOUVSO CFHFOFSBMJ[FEGVSUIFS "UJNFTQFDUSVNUIBUFOBCMFTUIFNPEFMJOHPGTZTUFNDIBOHFBOEUIFDPNQBSJTPOPGNPE FMTBUEJﬀFSFOUQPJOUTJOUJNF "DPODFQUPGWJFXUPEFﬁOFDFSUBJOCBTJDQFSTQFDUJWFTPONPEFMTBOETZTUFNTBWJFXDBOCF BNPEFM BOZTVCTFUPGBNPEFM PSJOGPSNBUJPOUIBUDVUTBDSPTTNVMUJQMFNPEFMTPSNPEFM TQBDFTQFDUSVNTThFNPEFMTQBDFEFﬁOFTBTUBSUFSTFUPGHFOFSBMMZBQQMJDBCMFWJFXTBOE WJFXQPJOUT ThFNPEFMTQBDF BOEUIFNPUJWBUJPOGPSUIFFMFNFOUT BSFEFTDSJCFEJONPSFEFUBJMJO$IBQUFS .VDIPGUIFNBUFSJBMJOUIFSFNBJOJOHDIBQUFSTJTBOFYUFOEFEEFTDSJQUJPOPGUIFFMFNFOUTPGUIF NPEFMTQBDF

Limits of Modeling *UJTJNQPSUBOUUPTUSFTTUIBUXFEPOPUDPOTJEFSNPEFMTPSNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBQBOBDFB.PEFMT DBOCFNJTVTFEMJLFFWFSZPUIFSUPPMJOUIFBSTFOBMPG4&"GFXFYBNQMFTTFSWFUPJMMVTUSBUFUIF MJNJUTBOENJTVTFPGNPEFMT ThF4PWJFUTVTFENPEFMTFYUFOTJWFMZGPSUIFJSZFBSQMBOTCVUUIFSFTVMUTEJEOPUTFFNUPNBUDI UIFJSQSFEJDUJPOT8FDBOSFBTPOBCMZBTTVNFUIBUUIFNPEFMTXFSFCJBTFECZQPMJUJDBMDPOTJEFS BUJPOT BOEUIBUUIFNPEFMTEJEOPUIBWFHPPEﬁEFMJUZUPUIFFDPOPNJDBOETPDJBMDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPG UIFTJUVBUJPOUIFZQVSQPSUFEMZNPEFMFE.PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ )PMMPXBZ EFTDSJCFEUIFEPNJ OBODFPGUIFDZCFSOFUJDNPEFMPGHPWFSONFOUJOUIF4PWJFU6OJPOJOUIFTBOETThF BQQMJDBUJPOPGDZCFSOFUJDTCZUIF4PWJFUT IPXFWFS FNQIBTJ[FEIJFSBSDIJDBMDPOUSPMBOEBDMFBS TFQBSBUJPOPGUXPTVCTZTUFNTUIFDPOUSPMMJOHBOEUIFDPOUSPMMFEThF4PWJFUDPODFQUTPGTDJFOUJﬁD NBOBHFNFOUPGTPDJFUZBOEPQUJNJ[FEQMBOOJOHXFSFFYQMJDJUMZUJFEUPUIFFBSMJFS5BZMPSTDIPPM PGTDJFOUJﬁDNBOBHFNFOUThFJSFNQIBTJTPOFYUFSOBMDPOUSPMBOETPDJFUZBTNFDIBOJTUJD SBUIFS UIBOTFMGDPOUSPMBOETPDJFUZBTPSHBOJD DBOCFTFFOBTBTJHOJﬁDBOUDPOUSJCVUPSUPUIFXFBLOFTT PGUIFJSNPEFMT ThFCPPL6TFMFTT"SJUINFUJD 1JMLFZBOE1JMLFZ+BSWJT HJWFTNBOZFYBNQMFTPGUIFNJT VTFPGNPEFMT TVDIBTNPEFMTPGBOJNBMQPQVMBUJPOTUPKVTUJGZDPOUJOVFEPWFSﬁTIJOHBOEPUIFS BDUJWJUJFTThFZQPJOUUPUPPNVDIVTFPGRVBOUJUBUJWFNPEFMTPGQPPSﬁEFMJUZBOEUPPMJUUMFVTFPG

Features of MOSES

O

87

RVBMJUBUJWFNPEFMT'PSFYBNQMF UIFZEJTDVTT Qo UIF64(PWFSONFOUTNJTVTFPGRVBOUJ UBUJWFNPEFMJOHJOUIF7JFU/BN8BS0OFPGUIFNPTUQSPNJOFOUNPEFMTXBTUIFVTFPGBOFOFNZ CPEZDPVOUBTBNFBTVSFPGTVDDFTT. ThJTIBETFWFSBMEFﬁDJFODJFT UPJODMVEF O 1PMJUJDBMPCKFDUJWFTCJBTFEUIFOVNCFST*UXBTJNQPSUBOUUPHJWFUIFJNQSFTTJPOUIBUUIFXBS XBTCFJOHXPO O $BSFFSPCKFDUJWFTCJBTFEUIFOVNCFST)JHIFSOVNCFSTNFBOUDPNNFOEBUJPOTBOEQSPNP UJPOTGPSJOEJWJEVBMDPNCBUBOUT O %FUFSNJOJOH XIJDI CPEJFT XFSF UIF FOFNZ XBT EJﬃDVMU ThBU GBDUPS DPNCJOFE XJUI UIF QSFTTVSFUPJODSFBTFUIFDPVOU SFTVMUFEJOBUSFOEUPXBSEDPVOUJOHBMMEFBE7JFUOBNFTF CPEJFTBTUIFFOFNZ O /PPOFWFSJﬁFEUIFBDDVSBDZPGUIFOVNCFSTPSUIFNPEFM O ThFNPEFMVTFEUIFXSPOHWBSJBCMF#PEZDPVOUJOUIBUTJUVBUJPOXBTOPUBHPPENFBTVSF PGTVDDFTT ThFMBTUJUFNUSVNQTBMMUIFPUIFST*GZPVTFMFDUWBSJBCMFTGPSBNPEFMUIBUEPOPUﬁUJUTQVSQPTF UIFOXIFUIFSUIFWBSJBCMFTBSFNFBTVSFEDPSSFDUMZEPFTOPUNBUUFSNVDI0OUIFPUIFSIBOE JGUIF QVSQPTFPGUIJTNPEFMXBTUPJODSFBTFEPNFTUJDTVQQPSUGPSUIFXBS UIFOJUXBTQFSIBQTTVJUBCMF GPSJUTQVSQPTF BUMFBTUGPSBXIJMF *OBEJTDVTTJPOPGDPNQMFYJUZTDJFODF 1IFMBO DBVUJPOTBHBJOTUUIFVTFPGiSFTFN CMBODFUIJOLJOHwBOEUIFVTFPGBOBMPHJFT DBMMJOHUIJTBQSBDUJDFPGQTFVEPTDJFODFSBUIFSUIBO TDJFODF'PSPVSQVSQPTFT UIJTDBOBQQMZBTBMJNJUPSDBVUJPOPOBQQMZJOHNPEFMTUIBUXFSF EFSJWFEGSPNPOFEPNBJOUPBDPNQMFUFMZEJﬀFSFOUEPNBJOXIJDI PGDPVSTF JTBOJNQPS UBOUBTQFDUPG$4NPEFMTThFDBVUJPOIFSFJTUIBUXFOFFEUPCFDBSFGVMUPIBWFTVﬃcJFOUWFSJ ﬁDBUJPOPGUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFPGBNPEFMEFSJWFEGSPNPOFEPNBJOXJUITZTUFNTJOBOPUIFS EPNBJO.04&4QSPWJEFTBTUSVDUVSFJOXIJDIUPDBMJCSBUFBOEQPTJUJPOUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODF UIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF TFF$IBQUFS ThBUJT UIJTTUSVDUVSFBMMPXT VT UP TFQBSBUF XIBU JT DPNNPO GSPN XIBU JT VOJRVF "QQMZJOH B NPEFM GSPN POF EPNBJO UPBOPUIFSNBZIBWFTPNFUIJOHTJODPNNPOBOEOPUPUIFSTJUJTOPUBMMPSOPUIJOH"O FYBNQMF JT FWPMVUJPO OPU FWFSZUIJOH BCPVU CJPMPHJDBM FWPMVUJPO BQQMJFT UP PUIFS EPNBJOT JO XIJDIFWPMVUJPONBZCFBQQMJFE8FIBWFUPBCTUSBDUPSHFOFSBMJ[FUIFCJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPOBSZ NPEFM WBSJBUJPOHFOFSBUPS TFMFDUPS UPSFBDIBQPJOUPOUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOIJFSBSDIZUIBUJT BQQSPQSJBUFGPSPUIFSEPNBJOT ThFBSUJDMFi8BS(BNJOHJOUIF*OGPSNBUJPO"HFzw #SBDLFOBOE4IVCJL EJTDVTTFT USFOET JO XBS HBNJOH TJODF UIF BEWFOU PG DPNQVUFS NPEFMJOH ThF HBNFST BOE UIF DPNQVUFS BOBMZTUTIBWFQVTIFEGPSNPSFBOENPSFEFUBJMTBOEiSFBMJTNwCFDBVTFDPNQVUFSTHBWFUIFNUIF DBQBCJMJUZUPEPTP0OFDPVMEBSHVFUIBUUIFNPEFMTIBWFJODSFBTFEﬁEFMJUZUPUIFXBSTJUVBUJPO )PXFWFS ﬁEFMJUZJTOPUUIFPOMZDSJUFSJPO'JUOFTTGPSQVSQPTFJTBMTPDSJUJDBM*OUIJTDBTF UIF PMEFSTUZMFXBSHBNFT TVDIBTCPBSEHBNFT IBEUPCFTJNQMFSBOEUIFSFGPSFGPSDFEBUUFOUJPOUP UIFLFZWBSJBCMFTThFSFTVMUXBTUIBUUIFZTVQQPSUFEJOUVJUJWFEFDJTJPONBLJOH#VUXIFONBOZ NPSF WBSJBCMFT BSF BEEFE UIF LFZ POFT CFDPNF PCTDVSFE BOE UIF QVSQPTF PG TFSWJOH NJMJUBSZ EFDJTJPONBLJOHIBTCFFOMPTUThFBVUIPSTBSHVFUIBUNJMJUBSZMFBEFSTOFFEUPBQQMZUPUIFXBS HBNJOHﬁFMEUIFTBNFQBUUFSOUIBUCVTJOFTTMFBEFSTIBWFBQQMJFEUPDPSQPSBUF*5TZTUFNTThBUJT UIFZOFFEUPUBLFDPOUSPMPGUIFXBSHBNJOHUFDIOPMPHZBOENBLFJUTFSWFUIFEFDJTJPONBLJOH QSPDFTT 4PNFUJNFT XF BDUVBMMZ OFFE NPEFMT PG MFTT ﬁdelity UP B TZTUFN UP CF NPSF VTFGVM $POTJEFS UIFIJTUPSJDBMVTFPGCJSETBTBTZTUFNXFBUUFNQUFEUPNPEFMJOCVJMEJOHﬂying NBDIJOFT*UXBT

88

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

SFBTPOBCMFFWFOPCWJPVTUPVTFNPEFMTPGCJSETUPEFTJHOﬂying NBDIJOFT#VUXFNPEFMFE JUUPPDMPTFMZ XJUIUIFXJOHQSPWJEJOHUXPGVODUJPOT ﬂoating NBJOUBJOJOHBMUJUVEF

BOEQPXFS CZﬂapping), JOBDDPSEBODFXJUIUIFCJSE8FXFSFOPUFOUJSFMZTVDDFTTGVMJOCVJMEJOHTZTUFNTUP UIJTNPEFM 5PBDIJFWFTVDDFTT XFIBEUPEFﬁOFBNPEFMXJUIMFTTﬁEFMJUZUPUIFCJSE*UUPPLBTJHOJﬁDBOU JOTJHIUUPCBDLPﬀ UIFCJSENPEFMBOESFBMJ[FUIBUXFDPVMETFQBSBUFUIFTVSGBDF ﬂPBUJOH GVODUJPO GSPNUIFQPXFSGVODUJPO BOEDPVMESFUBJOUIFﬂPBUJOHGVODUJPOGPSUIFXJOH CVUDPVMEBMMPDBUF UIFQPXFSGVODUJPOUPBEJﬀFSFOUQBSUPGUIFTZTUFNThFMFTTPOJTUIBUBHPPENPEFMJTPOFUIBU SFDPHOJ[FTXIBUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUPSFUBJOBOEXIBUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUPJHOPSF MFBWFVOTQFDJﬁFE GPS UIFQVSQPTFJUIBT4PNFUJNFT PWFSTQFDJGZJOHJTNPSFEFUSJNFOUBMUPFOWJTJPOJOHBTPMVUJPOUIBO JTVOEFSTQFDJGZJOHThFNPEFMPGUIFﬂBQQJOHXJOHﬂZJOHNBDIJOFXBTPWFSTQFDJﬁFEJUXBTOPU TVﬃcJFOUMZNJOJNBM "TBMBTUFYBNQMFPGMJNJUT NPEFMTDBOCFGV[[Z BQQSPYJNBUF BOEBNCJHVPVT CVUTUJMMCFVTF GVM5XPXFMMLOPXOJMMVTUSBUJPOTPGUIJTUZQFPGMJNJUTJOTDJFODFBSFUIFQFSJPEJDUBCMFPGDIFNJDBM FMFNFOUTBOEUIFCJPMPHJDBMUBYPOPNZPGMJWJOHUIJOHT#PUIBSFVTFGVMCVUCPUIIBWFTJHOJﬁDBOU FYDFQUJPOTBOEBNCJHVJUJFTUIBUFOHFOEFSEFCBUFTBCPVUXIFSFBTQFDJﬁDFOUJUZTIPVMESFTJEFThF NPSFDMPTFMZPOFFYBNJOFTUIFN UIFNFTTJFSUIFZCFDPNF ThFLFZQPJOUPGUIJTEJTDVTTJPOJTUIBUNPEFMTOFFEUPDPSSFTQPOEUPUIFTZTUFNTUIFZBSF JOUFOEFEUPNPEFM JOBXBZUIBUTFSWFTUIFQVSQPTFPGUIFNPEFM)PXEPXFWBMJEBUFUIJTDPS SFTQPOEFODF .PTT EJTDVTTFT EJﬀFSJOH WBMJEBUJPO BQQSPBDIFT SBOHJOH GSPN GPSNBM BQQSPBDIFTUPOBSSBUJWFTDFOBSJPT GPSNPEFMTBDSPTTUIFTQFDUSVNGSPNUIFPSZESJWFONPEFMTUP FWJEFODFESJWFONPEFMT .PEFMJOH JO .04&4 JT JOUFOEFE UP FNQIBTJ[F BCTUSBDUJPO GPDVT BOE QVSQPTF 'JEFMJUZ JT JNQPSUBOU CVU UIFSF JT B USBEFPﬀ B QPJOU PG EJNJOJTIJOH SFUVSOT CFZPOE XIJDI JODSFBTJOH EFUBJMTBOEOVNCFSPGWBSJBCMFTCFHJOUPNBTLUIFJNQPSUBOUWBSJBCMFTThJTJTBEFMJDBUFCBMBODF GPS$4CFDBVTFTNBMMDIBOHFTDBOMFBEUPIVHFEJﬀFSFODFT4FDPOE NPEFMTDBOCFXSPOHJOUIF TFOTFUIBUUIFZEPOPUDPSSFTQPOEUPUIFJOUFOEFETZTUFNTJUJTOPUFBTZUPEFﬁOFBNPEFMPGIJHI ﬁEFMJUZ"NPEFMJTHPPEGPSJUTQVSQPTFJGJUBTDFSUBJOTBOEEJTUJOHVJTIFTCFUXFFOXIBUJTNPTU JNQPSUBOUGPSUIBUQVSQPTFBOEXIBUJTMFTTJNQPSUBOU"OJOWFTUNFOUJTSFRVJSFEUPNBUVSFNPE FMTUPXIFSFUIFZDBOCFVTFGVMGPSDFSUBJOQVSQPTFT ThFQPJOUPGUIJTTFDUJPOJTUIBUNPEFMT MJLFBMMFOHJOFFSJOHUPPMT SFRVJSFDBSFBOEIFBMUIZTLFQUJ DJTNJOUIFJSVTF.PEFMTTIPVMECFEFﬁOFEUSBOTQBSFOUMZ XJUIFYQMJDJUBTTVNQUJPOT TPUIBUPUIFST DBOBTTFTTUIFJSﬁEFMJUZBOEﬁUOFTTGPSQVSQPTFThFNBUVSJUZBOEEFHSFFPGWBMJEBUJPOPGNPEFMT TIPVMEBMTPCFNBEFDMFBSCFDBVTFMFTTUSVTUTIPVMECFQMBDFEJOJNNBUVSFPSVOWBMJEBUFENPEFMT

Modularity of MOSES: Decoupled Concepts .PEVMBSJUZPSTFQBSBUJPOPGDPODFSOTJTBUSBEJUJPOBMBOEXFMMLOPXOQSJODJQMF.04&4BQQMJFT JUUPTZTUFNTJOBOVOSFNBSLBCMFXBZUIBU GSPNBUSBEJUJPOBMWJFXQPJOU EPFTOPUOFFEEJTDVT TJPO)PXFWFS .04&4BMTPBQQMJFTUIFNPEVMBSJUZQSJODJQMFUPJUTFMG BOEUIBUDSFBUFTUIFOFFEUP EJTDVTTUIFJTTVFPGEFDPVQMJOHDPODFQUTUIBUBSFPGUFOIJHIMZDPVQMFEJO4&EJﬀFSFOUMZJOUIF USBEJUJPOBMDBNQBOEJOUIFDPNQMFYDBNQ 0OFPGUIFLFZESJWFSTPG.04&4JTUIFOFFEUPDBQUVSFJNQPSUBOUDPODFQUTBOEQSJODJQMFT UIBUBQQMZUPUIFCSPBEOFXTQFDUSVNPG4&.BOZPGUIFTFDPSFDPODFQUTIBWFCVJMUVQBOBUUBDI NFOU XJUI PUIFS DPODFQUT VOUJM UIF NVMUJQMF DPODFQUT JO UIF NJOET PG NBOZ JO UIF 4& PS $4

Features of MOSES

O 89

DPNNVOJUZ BSFGVTFEJOUPBTJOHMFDPODFQU*OTPNFDBTFT UIJTGVTJPOIBTUFNQUFEUIF$4DPN NVOJUZUPUISPXPVUUIFTFNVMUJQMFDPODFQUTPSBTTJHOUIFNPOMZUP54& OPU$4& XIJDIJOPVS WJFXJTJOBQQSPQSJBUFBOEJTUIFSFTVMUPGUIJTVOGPSUVOBUFGVTJPO5PBDIJFWFUIFHPBMPGDBQUVSJOH BOEVTJOHBQQMJDBCMFQSJODJQMFT XFﬁOEJUOFDFTTBSZUPEFDPVQMFPSiVOGVTFwUIFDPODFQUTJORVFT UJPO UPSFDPWFSUIFTJNQMFSDPSFDPODFQUT 8FBSFOPUUSZJOHUPSFNPWFUIFDPVQMFEDPODFQUTSBUIFS XFBSFUSZJOHUPSFNPWFUIFDPVQMJOH BOEBMMPXUIFJOEJWJEVBMDPODFQUTUPFYJTUTFQBSBUFMZPOUIFJSPXONFSJUT*ONBOZTJUVBUJPOTUIF DPODFQUTEPCFMPOHUPHFUIFSFWFOSFDPODJMFEJOBDPNNPOGSBNFXPSL#VUDPOOFDUJOHUIFN TIPVMECFBTFQBSBUFEFDJTJPO OPUBOBQSJPSJ ﬁYFEDPOEJUJPOPGUIFJSFYJTUFODF 8FNBLFBQPJOUPGTQFMMJOHPVUUIFNPEVMBSJUZPG.04&4BOETPNFPGJUTNBOJGFTUBUJPOT CFDBVTFJUGPSNTBOJNQPSUBOUQBSUPGUIFDPSFXPSMEWJFXPG.04&44PNFNJHIUDBMMJUFYUSFNF NPEVMBSJUZCVUXFWJFXJUBTOBUVSBMBOEOFDFTTBSZGPSUIFOFXFYQBOEFE4& ThFGPMMPXJOHDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBSFEFDPVQMFEJO.04&4

.PEVMBSJUZBOESFEVDUJPOJTN $POUSPMBOEIJFSBSDIZ .PEFMBOETZTUFNBOENPEBMJUZ .PEFMEFSJWBUJPOBOEBQQMJDBUJPO 4QFDJﬁFECFIBWJPSBOEWBMVBUJPO 6TFGVMOFTTBOEiUSVUIw

8FXJMMEFTDSJCFFBDIPGUIFNJOUVSO

Modularity and Reductionism 8FOFFEUPUBDLMFUIJTJTTVFﬁSTUCFDBVTFXFDMBJNUIBU.04&4JTNPEVMBS4PNFJOUIF$4DPN NVOJUZBSHVFUIBUNPEVMBSJUZBOETFQBSBUJPOPGDPODFSOTSFﬂeDUBEJTDSFEJUFE SFEVDUJPOJTUXBZPG UIJOLJOH BOEUIBUXFOFFEUPGPDVTPOIPMJTUJDUIJOLJOHUPBEESFTT$4*GUIFZBSFSJHIU UIFSF JTOPOFFEGPS.04&4UPFYJTU3VTTFMM"DLoﬀ "DLoﬀ XBTPOFPGUIFﬁSTUUPNBLFUIJT BSHVNFOUJOUIFTXIFOIFEJTQBSBHFEUIFEJSFDUJPOPG03)JTBSHVNFOU XIJDIIBTDBSSJFE GPSXBSEUPTPNFEFHSFFUPUIFQSFTFOUUJNF DBOCFTVNNBSJ[FEUIJTXBZThFUSBEJUJPOBMXBZPG UIJOLJOHJTNBDIJOFBHFBOEIBTUIJTPSJFOUBUJPOBOBMZTJT QBSUT CPUUPNVQ POMZDBVTBMSFMBUJPOT EFUFSNJOJTN SFEVDUJPOJTN LOPXMFEHF BOENBDIJOFTXJUIPVUQVSQPTF ThFOFXXBZPGUIJOLJOH JTTZTUFNTBHFBOEIBTUIJTPSJFOUBUJPOTZOUIFTJT XIPMFT UPQEPXO FNFSHFODF NVMUJQMFSFMB UJPOT OPOEFUFSNJOJTN VOEFSTUBOEJOH BOEQVSQPTFGVMTZTUFNTVTJOHNBDIJOFT4ZOUIFTJTTIPVME CFVTFEJOTUFBEPGBOBMZTJT XIPMFTJOTUFBEPGQBSUT UPQEPXOJOTUFBEPGCPUUPNVQ ThF.04&4SFTQPOTFUPUIJTJTUIBUXFOFFECPUIQFSTQFDUJWFT"TZTUFNJTPGJOUFSFTUCPUIBTB XIPMFBOEBTQBSUTTh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

90

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Control and Hierarchy i)JFSBSDIZwJTPGUFODPVQMFEXJUIUPQEPXODPOUSPM XIJDISFﬂFDUTUIFPSJHJOTPGUIFUFSNJOSFMJ HJPVTBOENJMJUBSZTUSVDUVSFT*O.04&4 XFTFQBSBUFDPOUSPMBOETUBSUXJUIBNJOJNBMDPODFQU PGIJFSBSDIZUIBUDPOTJTUTPGBHFOFSBMNBUIFNBUJDBMSFMBUJPO'PMMPXJOHJTBEFTDSJQUJPOPGTFWFSBM UZQFTPGIJFSBSDIJFTUIBUEJﬀFSCZUIFSFMBUJPOTJOWPMWFE #BTJD NJOJNBM EFﬁOJUJPO PG IJFSBSDIZ B TUSVDUVSF HFOFSBUFE CZ B SFQFBUJOH POFUPNBOZ SFMBUJPOBUSFFTUSVDUVSFThJTCBTJDEFﬁOJUJPOJNQMJFTUIBUUIFSFMBUJPOJTBTZNNFUSJDBOE OPOSFﬂFYJWF CVUJUJTOPUSFTUSJDUFEUPEJSFDUJPOBMWFSTVTOPOEJSFDUJPOBM USBOTJUJWFWFSTVT JOUSBOTJUJWF PSCJOBSZWFSTVT/BSZThPTFDPOTUSBJOUTNBZBQQFBSJOTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOTPGUIF SFMBUJPO TPNFPGXIJDIBSFHJWFOCFMPX *G UIF SFMBUJPO JT UIBU NBOZ BSFQBSUPG POF UIFO JU JT B XIPMFoQBSU PS DPNQPTJUJPO PS BHHSFHBUJPO IJFSBSDIZThis SFMBUJPOHFOFSBUFTUIFXFMMLOPXOBOEVCJRVJUPVTXIPMFoQBSU SFQFBUJOHTUSVDUVSFThe TUVEZPSUIFPSZPGXIPMFTBOEQBSUTJTNFSFPMPHZThe QBSUPGSFMB UJPOJTUSBOTJUJWF*G"JTQBSUPG# BOE#JTQBSUPG$ UIFO"JTQBSUPG$%JSFDUJPOBOE OBWJHBUJPONBZCFBEEFEUPBDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZUPQEPXOEFDPNQPTJUJPOJNQMJFT QSPDFFEJOHGSPNUPQ PSSPPUOPEF UPCPUUPN PSMFBGOPEFT #PUUPNVQDPNQPTJUJPO JNQMJFTQSPDFFEJOHGSPNCPUUPN PSMFBGOPEFT UPUPQ PSSPPUOPEF This EJSFDUJPOBMPS TFRVFODFDPOTUSBJOUNBZCFJNQPTFEPOUIFCBTJDDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZ XIJDIJUTFMGJT OPUEJSFDUJPOBM"TXFEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS ,PFTUMFS QSPQPTFEUIFUFSNiIPMPO w XIJDI JT CPUI B XIPMF BOE B QBSU PG B MBSHFS XIPMF *O UIJT TFOTF UIF IPMPO DPODFQU HFOFSBUFT B DPNQPTJUJPO IJFSBSDIZ PS IPMBSDIZ8F BHSFF XJUI UIF DPODFQU PG IPMPO JO UIFTFOTFPGBMMPXJOHVTUPDPOTJEFSUIFTBNFFOUJUZBTBXIPMFBOEBTBQBSU8FJOUFSQSFU XIPMFBOEQBSUBTTFQBSBCMFWJFXTPSSPMFT8FTIPVMECFBCMFJOPOFDPOUFYUPSJOPOFWJFX UPDPOTJEFSBOFOUJUZBTBXIPMF JHOPSJOHJUBTBQBSUBOEJOBOPUIFSDPOUFYUPSWJFXUP DPOTJEFSUIFTBNFFOUJUZBTBQBSU JHOPSJOHJUBTBXIPMFThBUBQQSPBDITVQQPSUTQSPCMFN TPMWJOHBOEFOHJOFFSJOHCFUUFSUIBOEPFTDPOﬂBUJOHUIFUXPWJFXTJOUPPOFJOTFQBSBCMF DPODFQU *GJUJTDPNQPTJUJPOBOEUIFNBOZQBSUTBUFBDIMFWFMBSFJOUFSSFMBUFE UIFOJUJTBTZTUFNDPN QPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZThJTJTBEPNJOBOUDPODFQUJOTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHNPTUGBNPVTMZ JOUSBEJUJPOBM4&CVUBMTPJODPNQMFY4&"OJNQPSUBOUEJTDVTTJPOPGUIJTJT)FSC4JNPOT i"SDIJUFDUVSFPG$PNQMFYJUZwBSUJDMF QVCMJTIFEJO4JNPO BOE4JNPO *GUIFSFMBUJPOJTDPOUSPMPGNBOZCZPOF UIFOJUJTBDPOUSPMIJFSBSDIZThJTSFMBUJPOJTFYFN QMJﬁFECZUIFSFMBUJPOTJNQMJFEJOBUSBEJUJPOBMPSHBOJ[BUJPODIBSU BOENPTUTUSPOHMZCZB NJMJUBSZPSHBOJ[BUJPODPNNBOETUSVDUVSF *GUIFSFMBUJPOJTUIBUNBOZBSFTVCUZQFTPGPOFUZQF UIFOJUJTBTQFDJBMJ[BUJPO PSHFOFSBM J[BUJPO IJFSBSDIZThJTSFMBUJPOJTUSBOTJUJWF*G"JTBTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOPG# BOE#JTBTQFDJBM J[BUJPOPG$ UIFO"JTBTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOPG$ThFSFMBUJPOJTFYFNQMJﬁFECZBDMBTTTVCDMBTT IJFSBSDIZJOPCKFDUPSJFOUFETPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH CZBUZQFTVCUZQFIJFSBSDIZ BOECZUIF TQFDJBMJ[BUJPOIJFSBSDIZJOUIFCJPMPHZUBYPOPNZ *GUIFSFMBUJPOJTUIBUNBOZBSFJOTUBODFTPGPOFDBUFHPSZ UIFOJUJTBDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOIJFSBS DIZThJTSFMBUJPOJTOPUUSBOTJUJWFJG"JTBOJOTUBODFPGDBUFHPSZ# BOE#JTBOJOTUBODF PGDBUFHPSZ$ JUEPFTOPUGPMMPXUIBU"JTBOJOTUBODFPGDBUFHPSZ$ ThJTSFMBUJPOJTFYFN QMJﬁFE CZ B DMBTTPCKFDU PS DMBTTJOTUBODF SFMBUJPO JO PCKFDUPSJFOUFE TPGUXBSF FOHJOFFS JOH CZBNPEFMNFUBNPEFMSFMBUJPO BOECZUIFDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOIJFSBSDIZJOUIFCJPMPHZ UBYPOPNZ

Features of MOSES

O

91

ThFTFWBSJPVTUZQFTPGIJFSBSDIJFTBMMFYJTUJOUIF.04&4NPEFMTQBDFBOEBSFEJTDVTTFEJO MBUFSDIBQUFST#VUUIFNBJOQPJOUPGUIJTEFDPVQMJOHJTUIBUXIFOXFTBZIJFSBSDIZXJUIPVUGVSUIFS RVBMJﬁDBUJPOJO.04&4 XFNFBOPOMZBSFQFBUJOHPOFUPNBOZSFMBUJPO BOEXFEPOPUPUIFSXJTF DPOTUSBJOXIBUUIBUSFMBUJPONJHIUCF*ONPSFTQFDJﬁDDPOUFYUT XFBEEBQQSPQSJBUFDPOTUSBJOUT UPUIFSFMBUJPO

Model and System and Modality Introduction ThJTTFDUJPODPOTJEFSTUIFEFDPVQMJOHBOEJOUFHSBUJPOPGUIFDPODFQUTPGNPEFM TZTUFN NPEBMJUZ BOEXPSME%JTDVTTFEﬁSTUJTUIFTFQBSBUJPOPGNPEFMBOETZTUFN GPMMPXFECZUIFTFQBSBUFDPODFQU PGNPEBMJUZThFJOUFHSBUJPOPGUIFDPODFQUTJTUIFOEJTDVTTFEJOUFSNTPGBDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU 'JOBMMZ DPNQMFYTZTUFNTWBSJBUJPOTPGNPEBMJUZBOEDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUTBSFCSJFﬂZEJTDVTTFE

Model and System Separation .PEFMTBOETZTUFNTIBWFTFQBSBUFFYJTUFODFT&BDINPEFMFYJTUTJOJUTPXOSJHIU BOEFBDITZTUFN FYJTUTJOJUTPXOSJHIU.PEFMTIBWFSFMBUJPOTXJUIPUIFSNPEFMT NPEFMTIBWFSFMBUJPOTXJUITZT UFNT BOETZTUFNTIBWFSFMBUJPOTXJUIPUIFSTZTUFNT CVUXFDBOBMXBZTWJFXBNPEFMPSBTZTUFN JOJUTPXOTFQBSBUFFYJTUFODF'PSBOZHJWFONPEFMPSTZTUFN UIJTHJWFTVTUIFGSFFEPNUPFTUBCMJTI EJTDPWFS EFﬁOF DPOTJEFS PSJHOPSFSFMBUJPOTXJUIBOZPUIFSNPEFMPSTZTUFN ThJTEFDPVQMJOHSFNPWFTCVJMUJOEFQFOEFODJFTCFUXFFONPEFMTBOETZTUFNT.PEFMTDBOCF EFﬁOFEGPSXIJDIOPDPSSFTQPOEJOHTZTUFNTFYJTU PSGPSXIJDINBOZTZTUFNTFYJTU8FQMBDFOP DPOTUSBJOUPOXIJDIDBNFﬁSTUUIFNPEFMPSUIFTZTUFN0SUIFTFRVFODFNBZCFTZTUFNTFYJTU NPEFMTBSFDSFBUFE BOEUIFONPSFTZTUFNTBSFDSFBUFEUIBUDPSSFTQPOEUPUIFNPEFM *ONBUIFNBUJDT NBUIFNBUJDBMNPEFMTIBWFCFFOEFﬁOFECFGPSFPSBGUFSBQQMJDBUJPOTGPSUIF NPEFMTBSFGPVOEBOEMJOLFEThBUJT UIFNPEFMNBZFYJTUﬁSTU PSUIFDPSSFTQPOEJOHTZTUFNNBZ FYJTUﬁSTU"OFYBNQMFPGBNPEFMFYJTUJOHﬁSTUJT3JFNBOOJBOHFPNFUSZ*UXBTEFﬁOFEJOUIF OJOFUFFOUIDFOUVSZ*OUIFFBSMZUXFOUJFUIDFOUVSZ &JOTUFJOEJTDPWFSFEUIBU3JFNBOOJBOHFPN FUSZQSPWJEFEBNBUIFNBUJDBMNPEFMIFOFFEFEGPSTQBDFUJNFDVSWBUVSFBOEUIFHFOFSBMUIFPSZPG SFMBUJWJUZ 4DIVCJO $IBQUFSJOUSPEVDFTUIFCBTJDNPEFMUZQFT FYUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBM XIJDISFQSFTFOUFYUFSOBM BOEJOUFSOBMQFSTQFDUJWFTPGBTZTUFN BOEXIJDIBSFSFGFSSFEUPUISPVHIPVUUIFCPPL)PXFWFS B NPSFEFUBJMFEWJFXPGBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMJTUIBUJUJODMVEFTBTFUPGJOUFSGBDFTPSQPSUTUIBUDBOCF EFﬁOFETFQBSBUFMZBOEUIFOVTFEJOPOFPSNPSFFYUFSOBMNPEFMTThFSFGPSF JOUIJTEFUBJMFEWJFX JOUFSGBDFTBOEFYUFSOBMNPEFMTBSFBMTPEFDPVQMFEThJTJTNFOUJPOFEIFSFCFDBVTFJUJTOFFEFEGPS UIFEFUBJMFEUSFBUNFOUPGTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTJO$IBQUFS

Modality and Its Separation .PEBMJUZ JT DPODFSOFE XJUI UIF NPEF PG QSPQPTJUJPOT TVDI BT FYJTUFODF DPOUJOHFODZ OFDFT TJUZ QPTTJCJMJUZ JNQPTTJCJMJUZ PS UFNQPSBM NPEF TVDI BT GPSNFSMZ PS FWFOUVBMMZ *U JT SFﬂFDUFE /PUFUIBUFYJTUFODFIFSFSFGFSTUPUIFEFﬁOJUJPOTPGTZTUFNBOENPEFMJO$IBQUFSJUJTOPUBQSJPSJFYJTUFODF CVUBDIPJDFPSEFﬁOJUJPONBEFCZBOPCTFSWFS UIBUUIFTFFOUJUJFTDPOTUJUVUFBTZTUFN BOEUIPTFFOUJUJFTDPOTUJ UVUFBNPEFM

92

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

JO FOHJOFFSJOH TQFDJﬁDBUJPOT PS NPEFMT JO UIF EJTUJODUJPO CFUXFFO UFSNT TVDI BT TIBMM TIPVME NVTU JT XJMM NBZ JTQFSNJUUFE JTQSPIJCJUFE FUD.04&4EFDPVQMFTNPEBMJUZGSPNNPEFMBOE TZTUFN UPBMMPXNPEFMTBOETZTUFNTUPCFBTTPDJBUFEJOEJﬀFSFOUDPOUFYUTXJUIEJﬀFSFOUNPEFT 8FEJTDVTTUIFTFQBSBUJPOIFSFJOUFSNTPGEFTDSJQUJWFWFSTVTQSFTDSJQUJWFNPEFT CVUJUBQQMJFTUP BOZNPEF.PEFTBSFBOPQFOFOEFETFU.BOZNPEFTDPNFGSPNNPEBMMPHJDBOEJUTWBSJBUJPOT JODMVEJOHEFPOUJDMPHJDBOEUFNQPSBMMPHJD8FEJTDVTTTPNFQPTTJCMFBEEFENPEFTGPSDPNQMFY TZTUFNTMBUFSJOUIJTTFDUJPO "OFYBNQMFUIBUJMMVTUSBUFTXIZ.04&4EFDPVQMFTNPEBMJUZGSPNNPEFMTJTGSPN(JHFSFO[FS BOE4FMUFO iz0WFSUIFMBTUDFOUVSJFT NPEFMTPGSBUJPOBMJUZIBWFDIBOHFEXIFOUIFZDPOﬂJDUFE XJUIBDUVBMCFIBWJPS ZFU BUUIFTBNFUJNF UIFZQSPWJEFEQSFTDSJQUJPOTGPSCFIBWJPS ThJTEPVCMFSPMFUPEFTDSJCFBOEUPQSFTDSJCFEPFTOPUNBQFBTJMZPOUPBTIBSQ EJWJEFCFUXFFOEFTDSJQUJWFBOEOPSNBUJWFNPEFMTzw ThFQSPCMFNJTUIFTIBSQEJWJEF UIFWJFXUIBUBNPEFMJTJOIFSFOUMZQSFTDSJQUJWFPSJOIFSFOUMZ EFTDSJQUJWF *O .04&4 B NPEFM BU B HJWFO QPJOU JO UJNF NBZ TJNVMUBOFPVTMZ CF DPOTJEFSFE EFTDSJQUJWFPGPOFTZTUFN iThJTNPEFMEFTDSJCFTDFSUBJODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUTZTUFN"IBTw BOE QSFTDSJQUJWFPGUIFTBNFTZTUFNPSPGBOPUIFSTZTUFN iThJTNPEFMQSFTDSJCFTDFSUBJODIBSBDUFSJT UJDTUIBU4ZTUFN#TIBMMIBWFw ThFBUUSJCVUJPOTPGNPEFTTVDIBTiQSFTDSJQUJWFwPSiEFTDSJQUJWFw BSFOPUPOMZSFMBUJWFUPXIBUTZTUFNJTCFJOHSFMBUFEUPUIFNPEFM CVUBMTPUPTPNFFYUFOUBNBUUFS PGDIPJDFThFNPEFMJUTFMGEPFTOPUIBWFBOJOIFSFOUQSPQFSUZPGCFJOHQSFTDSJQUJWFPSEFTDSJQUJWF NPEFTBSFOPUJOUIFNPEFMTﬁFMEPGWJFXThFNPEFMJTTJNQMZBTFUPGEFﬁOFESVMFT TVDIBT DIBSBDUFSJTUJD$9$:$;#SJOHJOHUPHFUIFSUIJTNPEFMXJUIBTZTUFNBOEDFSUBJO NPEFJTBTFQBSBUFBDUJWJUZUIBUJTEJTDVTTFECFMPXVOEFSUIFUPQJDPGDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU *OHFOFSBM NPEBMJUZUZQFTJODMVEFGV[[ZBOEQSPCBCJMJTUJDNPEFT*O.04&4 UIFHFOFSBMMZ QSFGFSSFEXBZUPBEESFTTVODFSUBJOUZBOEGV[[JOFTTJTJOUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPO BEESFTTFEJO$IBQUFS )PXFWFS UIFSFBSFFYDFQUJPOT0OFFYDFQUJPODPVMECFJGUIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSXBOUFEUPVTF UIFTBNFNPEFMUPBTTPDJBUFXJUIEJﬀFSFOUTZTUFNT BOEXBOUFEUPBMMPXEJﬀFSFOUQSPCBCJMJUJFTGPS UIFEJﬀFSFOUTZTUFNT*OTUFBEPGEFﬁOJOHBEJﬀFSFOUNPEFMGPSFBDIDBTF WBSZJOHPOMZUIFQSPC BCJMJUJFT UIFFOHJOFFSNJHIUEFﬁOFBTJOHMFEFUFSNJOJTUJDNPEFM. JF QSPCBCJMJUZPGCFIBWJPS

BOEUIFOQVUUIFWBSZJOHQSPCBCJMJUJFTJOUIFNPEBMJUJFT TZTUFN4TIBMMXJUI1qTBUJTGZ NPEFM.4TIBMMXJUI1qTBUJTGZ.z ThFTFQBSBUJPOPGNPEBMJUZNFBOTUIBUUIFNPTUTBMJFOUBTQFDUPGBSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUPS NPEFMJTOPUUIFiTIBMMwGPSNPGUIFTUBUFNFOUTJUJTSBUIFSUIFBDUVBMSVMFT. ThFXIPMFTFUPGSVMFT JOBNPEFM.DBOCFNBEFQSFTDSJQUJWFCZTBZJOHi4ZTUFN4TIBMMTBUJTGZ. wPSNBEFEFTDSJQUJWFCZ TBZJOHi4ZTUFN4EPFTTBUJTGZ.w*OGBDU JOUIF.04&4BQQSPBDIUIFUFSNiTIBMMw PSBOZPUIFS NPEF TIPVMECFSFNPWFEGSPNSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUTNPEFMTBOEBQQMJFETFQBSBUFMZ VTJOHUIF DPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUBQQSPBDIEFTDSJCFEOFYU

Integration via Correspondence Set ThFWFIJDMFGPSCSJOHJOHUPHFUIFSNPEFMT TZTUFNT BOENPEFTJTDBMMFEBDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU*UT GPSNJT\. .1 8 4^ XIFSF O .BTQFDJﬁDNPEFMPSTFUPGNPEFMTPSNPEFM XIFSFNFBOTBMMPSMFGUPQFO O .1NPEBMQISBTFPSNPEBMJUZBTQFDJﬁDNPEFPSTFUDPODBUFOBUJPOPGNPEFT

Features of MOSES

O

93

O 8BTQFDJﬁDXPSMEPSBTFUPGXPSMETPSXPSME O 4BTQFDJﬁDTZTUFNPSTFUPGTZTUFNTPSTZTUFN PSTFSWJDF

"DPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUSFQSFTFOUTBDPNNJUNFOUUPBNPEFMNPEFTZTUFNBTTPDJBUJPOJOBEFﬁOFE XPSMEThFNPEFMBOEUIFTZTUFNEPOPUOFFEUPFYJTUUPCFJODMVEFEJOBDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU ThFVOEFﬁOFEDPOTUSVDUNBLFTBOPQFODPNNJUNFOU*GTZTUFNJTMFGUPQFO 4

UIFOUIF DPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUEFQJDUTBMMTZTUFNTJOUIFEFﬁOFEXPSMEUIBUDPSSFTQPOEUPUIFEFﬁOFENPEFM XJUIUIFEFﬁOFENPEBMJUZ-JLFXJTF JGNPEFMJTMFGUPQFO .

UIFOUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU EFQJDUTBMMNPEFMTJOUIFEFﬁOFEXPSMEUIBUDPSSFTQPOEUPUIFEFﬁOFETZTUFNXJUIUIFEFﬁOFE NPEBMJUZ 8IFOXFXBOUUPFTUBCMJTIBDPSSFTQPOEFODFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOBNPEFMBOEBTZTUFN XFDBO EPTPJOBOZPGUIFGPMMPXJOHXBZT CZDSFBUJOHBNPEFMBOEDSFBUJOHBTZTUFNUIBUDPSSF TQPOETUPJU CZDSFBUJOHBNPEFMUPDPSSFTQPOEUPBOFYJTUJOHTZTUFN CZDSFBUJOHBTZTUFN UP DPSSFTQPOE UP B QSFFYJTUJOH NPEFM PS CZ ﬁOEJOH B DPSSFTQPOEFODF CFUXFFO BO FYJTUJOH NPEFMBOEBOFYJTUJOHTZTUFN ThF FWPMVUJPO PG B DPSSFTQPOEFODF TFU DBO CF JMMVTUSBUFE XJUI B WFSZ DPNNPO 4& FYBNQMF 4VQQPTFBOBJSMJOFEFUFSNJOFTBUBQPJOUJOUJNFUIBUUIFZOFFEUPCVZBCPVUOFXDPNNFS DJBMBJSDSBGU BOEBGUFSXSJUJOHSFRVJSFNFOUTBOEEPJOHUSBEFTUVEJFT UIFZTFMFDUUIF#PFJOH #PFJOHCVJMETUIFNUIFQMBOFTBOEUIFBJSMJOFQVUTUIFNJOUPPQFSBUJPO8FDBOEFﬁOFDPSSFTQPO EFODFTFUTGPSGPVSQPJOUTJOUIFDPVSTFPGUIJTQSPDFTT O 5JNF5 N 4JUVBUJPOThFBJSMJOFEFDJEFTUIFZOFFEUPCVZTPNFDPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGU XIJDIUIFZ EFTJHOBUFBTTZTUFN4 CVUUIFZEPOPULOPXXIBUTQFDJﬁDBJSDSBGU4XJMMCFThFZ QMBOUPXSJUFBSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUDBMMFE3 N $PSSFTQPOEFODFTFU\.3 JEFOUJﬁFECVUOPUEFﬁOFE .1TIBMMXIFOPQFSB UJPOBM88XPSMEJOXIJDI4JTBDRVJSFEBOEPQFSBUFE TLFUDIFECFMPX 4 4 JEFOUJﬁFEDPOTUSBJOFEPOMZUPCFJODPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGUDBUFHPSZBQQSPYJNBUFMZ JOOVNCFSUIFZEPOPUFYJTU ^ ThFNPTBJDPGXPSME8BU5JODMVEFTUIFBJSMJOF DPNQFUJOHBJSMJOFT DPNQBOJFTUIBUCVJME DPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGU JODMVEJOH#PFJOH

FYJTUJOHDPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGUJODMVEJOH#PFJOHT BWBJM BCJMJUZPGOFXBJSDSBGUPGFYJTUJOHUZQFTJODMVEJOH#PFJOH NPEFMTPGFYJTUJOHBJSDSBGUJODMVEJOH QFSGPSNBODFQBSBNFUFST BJSUSBOTQPSUBUJPOJOGSBTUSVDUVSF BJSUSBﬃc rFHVMBUJPOT FUD O 5JNF5 N 4JUVBUJPOUIFBJSMJOFIBTXSJUUFOUIFJSSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOU3BOEJTSFBEZUPTUBSU BUSBEFTUVEZPGFYJTUJOHBJSDSBGUUZQFT N $PSSFTQPOEFODFTFU\.3 JEFOUJﬁFEBOEEFﬁOFE .1TIBMMXIFOPQFSBUJPOBM 888NPEFM344 JEFOUJﬁFEDPOTUSBJOFECZUIJTDPSSFTQPOEFODFUP CFJOTZTUFNSFHJPOPGNPEFM3BQQSPYJNBUFMZJOOVNCFSUIFZEPOPUFYJTU ^ ThFEJTUJODUJPOJOBDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUCFUXFFOTZTUFNBOETFSWJDFJTUIJTJGBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMDPSSFTQPOETUP BTZTUFN JUTTDPQFJTUIFGVMMTFUPGTZTUFNQPSUTUIBUQSPWJEFBOESFRVJSFTFSWJDFTBOEJOQVUBOEPVUQVUTUVﬀ BOE4JOUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUSFGFSTUPUIFOBNFPGUIFTZTUFN*GUIFFYUFSOBMNPEFMDPSSFTQPOETUPBTFSWJDF JUTTDPQFJTPOMZUIFQPSUUIBUQSPWJEFTUIBUTFSWJDF BOE4JOUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUSFGFSTUPUIFOBNFPGUIF TFSWJDF

94

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O 5JNF5 N 4JUVBUJPO ThFBJSMJOe ﬁOJTIFTJUTUSBEFTUVEZ TFMFDUTUIF#PFJOHBTUIF4BJSDSBGU UZQFBOEQMBDFTBOPSEFSGPSTXJUI#PFJOH N $PSSFTQPOEFODFTFU\.3 JEFOUJﬁFEBOEEFﬁOFE .1TIBMMXIFOPQFSBUJPOBM 8844#PFJOHUZQF JOOVNCFSUIFZEPOPUFYJTU ^ N $PSSFTQPOEFODFTFUTBNFBTDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU FYDFQU.1XJMMXIFOPQFSB UJPOBM UIJTJTBQSFEJDUJPOCBTFEPOFYJTUJOHT OPUBQSFTDSJQUJPO N )PXDBOTFYJTU JOUIF8QBSUPGUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODF BOEOPUFYJTU JOUIF 4QBSU "OTXFSThF4BJSDSBGUUIFBJSMJOFOFFETEPOPUZFUFYJTU CVUPUIFS BJSDSBGUEPFYJTU BOEUIPTFBSFUIFCBTJTGPSUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUQSFEJDUJPO UIBUUIF4TXJMMDPSSFTQPOEUPUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTNPEFM3 O 5JNF5 N 4JUVBUJPOUIFBJSMJOFIBTSFDFJWFEUIFBJSDSBGUGSPN#PFJOHBOEIBTQVUUIFN JOUPPQFSBUJPO N $PSSFTQPOEFODFTFU\.3 JEFOUJﬁFEBOEEFﬁOFE .1TIBMMXIFOPQFSBUJPOBM 888UIFOFXBJSDSBGU44#PFJOHUZQF JOOVNCFSUIFZ FYJTU ^ N $PSSFTQPOEFODFTFUTBNFBTDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU FYDFQU.1EPFT UIJTJTBEFTDSJQ UJPOPGFBDIPGUIFFYJTUJOH4TOPXJOUIFQPTTFTTJPOPGUIFBJSMJOF 0WFS UIF UJNF QFSJPE GSPN 5 UP 5 UIF TUBUF PS WBMVF PG BMM DPSSFTQPOEFODF TFU FMFNFOUT DIBOHFENPEFM NPEF XPSME BOETZTUFNThFNPEFiTIBMMXIFOPQFSBUJPOBMwSFNBJOFEBDSPTT UIFGVMMUJNFQFSJPECVUBEEJUJPOBMNPEFiXJMMwBQQFBSFEUFNQPSBSJMZBU5 BOEBEEJUJPOBMNPEF iEPFTwBQQFBSFEBU5ThFBJSMJOFIPQFTUIBUiEPFTwBQQMJFTGPSUIFGVMMPQFSBUJPOBMMJGFUJNFPG UIF4TThFTBNFNPEFMBOETZTUFNXFSFBTTPDJBUFEWJBUXPEJﬀFSFOUNPEBMJUJFTBUCPUI 5BOE5ThFVTFGVMOFTTPGUIFTFTJNVMUBOFPVTNPEBMJUJFTJTPOFSFBTPOGPSUIFEFDPVQMJOHPG NPEFM TZTUFN BOENPEBMJUZ XIJDIHJWFTUIFOFDFTTBSZﬂFYJCJMJUZ/PUFBMTPUIBUUIFNPEFiTIBMM XIFO PQFSBUJPOBMw DBO CF WJFXFE BT B DPNCJOBUJPO PG QSFTDSJQUJWF TIBMM BOE UFNQPSBM XIFO PQFSBUJPOBMJF EVSJOHUIFQFSJPEPGJUTPQFSBUJPOBMMJGFUJNF ThJTNBEFFYQMJDJUTPNFUIJOH UIBUJTVTVBMMZMFGUJNQMJDJUCFDBVTFJUJTPCWJPVTThFTZTUFNDBOOPUTBUJTGZUIFiTIBMMwQSFTDSJQUJPO GPSDPSSFTQPOEFODFQSJPSUPUJNF5CFDBVTFUIFTZTUFNEPFTOPUFYJTUVOUJM5ThFUFNQPSBM NPEFiXIFOPQFSBUJPOBMwJODMVEFEJOBMMUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUTTUBUFTUIFDPOEJUJPOTJOXIJDI UIFQSFTDSJQUJPOIPMETOBNFMZ TUBSUJOHBUUIFQPJOUXIFO4CFDPNFTPQFSBUJPOBMBOEFOEJOH BUUIFQPJOUXIFO4JTSFUJSFEGSPNPQFSBUJPO ThFSFRVJSFNFOUTNPEFM3XPVMEQSPCBCMZDIBOHFUPTPNFEFHSFFPWFSUIJTQFSJPEBOEBDSPTT UIFPQFSBUJPOBMMJGFPGUIFBJSDSBGUCVUXFEJEOPUTIPXUIBUCFDBVTFJUXBTOPUUIFQVSQPTFPG UIJTFYBNQMF

Complex Systems Extensions of Modality and Correspondence ThFGPSFHPJOHEJTDVTTJPOJTCBTFEPOBCJOBSZOPUJPOPGQSFTDSJQUJWFJOTPNFDPOUFYU BNPEFM JTDPOTJEFSFEFJUIFSQSFTDSJQUJWFPGBTZTUFN PSOPUQSFTDSJQUJWFPGBTZTUFN JOXIJDIDBTFJUJT EFTDSJQUJWFPSTPNFPUIFSNPEF 1SFTDSJQUJWFJTNBQQFEJOUSBEJUJPOBMNPEFMTUPDPOUSPM8FQSF TDSJCFTZTUFN4UPTBUJTGZNPEFM. BOEXFDPOUSPMUIFCVJMEJOHPG4UPFOTVSFUIBUJUEPFTTBUJTGZ .#VUGPS$4TVDIBTQFPQMFBOEPUIFSBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUT QSFTDSJQUJWFJTNBQQFEUPBTQFDUSVN PGJOﬂVFODFUIBUSBOHFTGSPNQBSUJBMDPOUSPMUPTVHHFTUJPOPSEFTJSF8FXBOU4UPTBUJTGZ. BOE XFXJMMBSSBOHFUIFFOWJSPONFOUBOEPSPUIFSGBDUPSTUPJOﬂVFODF4UPTBUJTGZ.0WFSUIFDPVSTF

Features of MOSES

O 95

PGUJNF XFNBZBMTPDIBOHF.UPJODSFBTFUIFPEETPG4TBUJTGZJOH. GPSFYBNQMF JODBTFTXIFSF UIFTZTUFN BQFSTPO DPOWJODFTUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTFOHJOFFSPSUIFVTFSUIBUUIFSFRVJSFNFOUT. TIPVMEDIBOHF .BZCF$4XJMMBEEUPUIFTUBOEBSENPEFT8IFSFJOUIFQBTUXFNJHIUIBWFTUBUFEi0SHBOJ[BUJPO 1TIBMMDPSSFTQPOEUPNPEFM. wXFNJHIUOPXTBZi0SHBOJ[BUJPO1JTFOBCMFEUPDPSSFTQPOE UPNPEFM.wPSi0SHBOJ[BUJPO1THPBMJTUPDPSSFTQPOEUPNPEFM.w0SJOTUFBEPGi:PVTIBMM DPSSFTQPOEUPNPEFM. wXFDPVMETBZi*XPVMESFBMMZBQQSFDJBUFJUJGZPVXPVMEDPSSFTQPOEUP NPEFM.w0SNPEBMJUJFTDPVMEJODMVEFJODFOUJWFTUPFODPVSBHFBHFOUTPSPSHBOJ[BUJPOTUPTBUJTGZ BSFRVJSFNFOUNPEFMi*XJMMQBZZPV9JGZPVDPSSFTQPOEUPNPEFM.w

Model Derivation and Application "OJNQPSUBOUEJTUJODUJPOJOUIFTVQQPSUPG44GPS4&JTUIBUCFUXFFOUIFEFSJWBUJPOBOEUIFBQQMJ DBUJPOPGBNPEFMThFEFSJWBUJPOPGBNPEFMJTUIFTFU DMBTT PSDBUFHPSZPGUIFTZTUFNTGSPNXIJDI JUJTEFSJWFEPSBCTUSBDUFEThFBQQMJDBUJPOPGBNPEFMJTUIFTFUPGTZTUFNTUIBUDPSSFTQPOEUPJU *GXFBTTVNFDPSSFTQPOEFODFPGBNPEFMUPCPUIJUTEFSJWBUJPOBOEJUTBQQMJDBUJPO UIFODMFBSMZUIF BQQMJDBUJPOTFUJTBUMFBTUBTHSFBUBT BOEJODMVEFT UIFEFSJWBUJPOTFUUIBUJT UIFEFSJWBUJPOTFUJTB TVCTFUPGUIFBQQMJDBUJPOTFU*OUFSNTPGNPEFMSFHJPOT UIFEFSJWBUJPOJTBiTUBSUFSTFUwPGUIFNPEFM SFHJPO BOEUIFBQQMJDBUJPOTFUJTUIFGVMMNPEFMSFHJPO *O UIF MBSHFS TDIFNF PG UIJOHT UIF EFSJWBUJPO PG B NPEFM JT PG MJUUMF JNQPSUBODF XIJMF UIF BQQMJDBUJPOPGBNPEFMJTPGDSJUJDBMJNQPSUBODF8FEPOPUDBSFXIFSFBNPEFMDBNFGSPNXFEP DBSFXIBUJUBQQMJFTUP 8IBUJGXFUSZUPBQQMZUIFCJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPONPEFMCFZPOEJUTEFSJWBUJPOTFU UIBUJT CFZPOE QPQVMBUJPOTPGPSHBOJTNTPSMJWJOHUIJOHTBTEFﬁOFEJOUSBEJUJPOBMCJPMPHZ 'PSFYBNQMF EPFDPOP NJFT PSHBOJ[BUJPOT TPDJFUJFT BJSDSBGU TPGUXBSFTZTUFNT BOECSJEHFTGPMMPXUIFNPEFMPGCJPMPHJDBM FWPMVUJPO ThBUJT EPUIFZFYJTUJOUIFSFHJPOPGUIJTNPEFM *GJUBQQMJFTBUBMM JUJTIFMQGVMUPEFUFS NJOFXIBUMFWFMPGUIFNPEFMBQQMJFT4VQQPTFXFXBOUUPBQQMZUIFNPEFMUPPSHBOJ[BUJPOTThF HPBMJTUPBQQMZUIFNPEFMBUUIFMFWFMUIBUTBUJTﬁ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hFSFJTBOPUIFSJNQPSUBOUXBZJOXIJDIUIFEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOEFSJWBUJPOBOEBQQMJDBUJPO JT JNQPSUBOU UP 4& BOE VOJﬁDBUJPO ThF OPUJPO UIBU POMZ USBEJUJPOBM NPEFMT BSF BQQSPQSJBUF GPSUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTEPFTOPUIPMEJONBOZDBTFT4&IBTNBEFDFSUBJOBTTVNQUJPOTJO54 NPEFMTBOEJNQPTFEUIFNPOUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTIPXFWFS UIFTZTUFNTIBWFWBSZJOHEFHSFFTPG ﬁEFMJUZUPUIPTFNPEFMTBOEBTTVNQUJPOT$4NPEFMTPGUFOIBWFBIJHIFSﬁEFMJUZUPUSBEJUJPOBM ThFEFSJWBUJPOTZTUFNTDBOCFBOFNQUZTFUThBUJT BNPEFMEPFTOPUIBWFUPCFEFSJWFEGSPNTZTUFNTJUDPVME CFDSFBUFEPSEFﬁOFEJOEFQFOEFOUMZ

96 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

TZTUFNTUIBOEP54NPEFMT0OFJOUFSFTUJOHFYBNQMFPGUIJT BTBSHVFEJO&SEJ

JTUIBU DMPDLT BT XFMM BT PUIFS NBDIJOFT FYIJCJU DIBPT JO UIFJS OPSNBM PQFSBUJPO $MPDLT BSF PGUFO DJUFEBTBOFYBNQMFPGRVJOUFTTFOUJBMUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTJOEJTDVTTJPOTPGDPOUSBTUTCFUXFFO 54BOE$4 ThFQPJOUJTUIBUFWFOJGXFEFDJEFXFBSFFOHJOFFSJOHBUSBEJUJPOBMNBDIJOF UIBUEPFTOPU OFDFTTBSJMZJNQMZUIBUXFTIPVMEVTFUSBEJUJPOBMNPEFMT PSPOMZUSBEJUJPOBMNPEFMT8FOFFEUP DPOTJEFSUIFGVMMSBOHFPGNPEFMTBTDBOEJEBUFTGPSBOZTZTUFNUIBU4&FOHJOFFSTPSGPSXIJDIBDUV BMJ[BUJPOJTBQQMJFE. ThJTJTBOPUIFSSFBTPOXIZUIFVOJﬁDBUJPOPG54&BOE$4&JTOFFEFE

Speciﬁed Behavior and Valuation *OUSBEJUJPOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTPGTZTUFNCFIBWJPS XFEFﬁOFXIBUJTFYQFDUFEPSOPSNBM BOEEJTUJO HVJTIJUGSPNBCOPSNBMCFIBWJPSTheBTTVNQUJPOJTUIBUBMMQBSUJFTBHSFFPOXIBUCFIBWJPSPGUIF TZTUFNJTOPSNBMPSHPPE BOEXIBUCFIBWJPSJTBCOPSNBMPSCBE)PXFWFS JOUIFDPNQSFIFOTJWF BQQSPBDIUIBUJODMVEFT$4 TVDIBTBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUT OPUPOMZBSFUIFSFNPSFDBUFHPSJFTPGQPT TJCMFCFIBWJPS JODMVEJOHBiCFUUFSUIBOFYQFDUFEwDBUFHPSZ

CVUBMTPUIFBTTJHONFOUPGBCFIBWJPS UPBDBUFHPSZ JODMVEJOHUIFUSBEJUJPOBMOPSNBMBOEBCOPSNBM JONBOZDBTFTEFQFOETPODPOUFYU SPMF WJFXQPJOU PSJOUFSQSFUBUJPO"TBOFYBNQMF TVQQPTFBNBOBHFSJOBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOCFIBWFT JOBXBZUIBUFOUBJMTBTJHOJﬁDBOUBNPVOUPGSJTLUPUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOXJUIDPSSFTQPOEJOHQPUFOUJBM GPS DPOTJEFSBCMF CFOFﬁU UP UIF PSHBOJ[BUJPO ThBU CFIBWJPS SFHBSEMFTT PG UIF TQFDJﬁD PVUDPNF NBZCFJOUFSQSFUFEBTHPPECZBSJTLUBLJOHPSHBOJ[BUJPOBOEBTCBECZBSJTLBWFSTFPSHBOJ[B UJPOTheSFGPSF .04&4BMMPXTUIFWBMVBUJPOPSJOUFSQSFUBUJPOPGBCFIBWJPS TVDIBTHPPEPSCBE UPCFEFDPVQMFEGSPNUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGUIFCFIBWJPSJUTFMG TPUIFDPOUFYUDBONBLFJUTPXO JOUFSQSFUBUJPO *O DPNQFUJUJWF HBNFT BOE DPOﬂJDU NPEFMT TVDI BT XBS UXP PS NPSF QBSUJFT IBWF PQQPTJOH WJFXTPGiHPPEwBOEiCBEwCFIBWJPSPSSFTVMUTPGCFIBWJPSThJTTJUVBUJPOSFRVJSFTEFDPVQMJOHPG WBMVBUJPOGSPNCFIBWJPS "OPUIFSSFBTPOGPSEFDPVQMJOHJTUIBUUIFWBMVBUJPOPGNBOZCFIBWJPSTJTOPULOPXOGPSTPNF QFSJPEPGUJNFBGUFSJUPDDVST PSJUNBZOFWFSCFLOPXO*GBDPNQBOZNBLFTBTJHOJﬁDBOUDIBOHFJO EJSFDUJPO UIFSFTVMUTPGUIBUDIBOHFNBZOPUCFLOPXOGPSTPNFUJNF"OEJGUIFHPBMJTUPEFUFSNJOF JGJUXBTCFUUFSUPNBLFUIFDIBOHFUIBOUPNBJOUBJOUIFTUBUVTRVP UIBUNBZOFWFSCFLOPXO "MUIPVHICFIBWJPSBOEWBMVBUJPOBSFEFDPVQMFE .04&4EPFTOPUSFRVJSFUIFNUPCFVODPO OFDUFEJOBMMDBTFT'PSBMBSHFOVNCFSPGTZTUFNTJUJTMJLFMZUIBUBMMPCTFSWFSTXPVMEBHSFFPO DFSUBJO CFIBWJPST CFJOH HPPE BOE DFSUBJO PUIFS CFIBWJPST CFJOH CBE BOE GPS UIPTF DBTFT JU JT SFBTPOBCMFUPDPNNJUUPBTQFDJﬁDWBMVBUJPOThFQPJOUJTUIBUUIJTEFDPVQMJOHJTJOUIF.04&4 SFQFSUPJSF BOEUIFSFGPSFDPNNJUNFOUEFDJTJPOTDBOCFMFGUPQFOPSEFFNFESFMBUJWFUPUIFPCTFSWFS JOBQQSPQSJBUFDJSDVNTUBODFT. ThFCFIBWJPSBOEWBMVBUJPOSFMBUJPOJTBQQMJFEJO$IBQUFS 7BMVBUJPOPGBHJWFOCFIBWJPSCZBHJWFOPCTFSWFSDBOBMTPDIBOHF BTXBTJMMVTUSBUFEJOUIF $IBQUFSTFDUJPOPOi3PMFT wXIFSFBOJOJUJBMWBMVBUJPOJOEJDBUFEBTFSWJDFCVUMBUFSBEJTTFSWJDF

Usefulness and “Truth” *OFOHJOFFSJOHJOHFOFSBM BOE.04&4JOQBSUJDVMBS XFEPOPUUBDLMFUIFJTTVFPGXIFUIFSTPNF UIJOHJTUSVF8FBSFJOUFSFTUFEJOXIFUIFSTPNFUIJOHJTVTFGVM'PSFYBNQMF 5SVUIIFSFNFBOTDPOUJOHFOUUSVUIXFEPBMMPXBOENBLFVTFPGMPHJDBMUSVUI OFDFTTJUZ UBVUPMPHZ QSPPG BOE SFTVMUTJNQMJFECZBYJPNTBOEQSFNJTFT

Features of MOSES

O

97

O /PUi*TUIJTSFBMMZBTZTUFN wPSi*TUIJTFMFNFOUJOTJEFPSPVUTJEFUIFTZTUFN wCVUi*TJU NPSFVTFGVMUPEFﬁOFUIJTTZTUFNUPJODMVEFUIJTFMFNFOUPSUPFYDMVEFJU w*OPVSFBSMJFS EFﬁOJUJPOPGTZTUFN XFBEESFTTFEUIJTJTTVFBUTPNFMFOHUI O /PUi*TUIJTNPEFMUSVF wCVUi*TUIJTNPEFMVTFGVMGPSTPNFQVSQPTF w O /PUi*TUIJTUIFSJHIUWJFX wCVUi*TUIJTWJFXVTFGVMGPSTPNFQVSQPTF w O /PUi*TUIJTTZTUFNBVUPOPNPVT wCVUi*TJUVTFGVMUPNPEFMUIJTTZTUFNBTIBWJOHBVUPO PNZ wPSi8IBUEFHSFFPGBVUPOPNZTIPVMEPVSNPEFMBUUSJCVUFUPUIJTTZTUFN w O /PUi*TUIJTTZTUFNVODIBOHJOH wCVUi*TJUVTFGVMUPNPEFMUIJTTZTUFNBTVODIBOHJOHJO UIJTTQBDFUJNFSFHJPO w

Summary ThFEFDPVQMJOHEFTDSJCFEJOUIJTTVCTFDUJPOQSPWJEFTﬂFYJCJMJUZJO.04&4ThJT UPHFUIFSXJUI UIFNPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOEFTDSJCFEFBSMJFS FOBCMFT.04&4UPTVQQPSUUIFCSPBESBOHFPGFYUFOEFE 4&. ThFDIBQUFSTUIBUGPMMPXTQFMMUIJTPVUJONPSFEFUBJM

References "ckoﬀ, R. 1979. The FVUVSFPG0QFSBUJPOBM3FTFBSDIJT1BTU +0QM3FT4PD o 1FSHBNPO1SFTT #MVN #4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH")PMJTUJD7JFX/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT #PDDBSB /.PEFMJOH$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT/FX:PSL4QSJOHFS7FSMBH #PFIN #BOE%1PSU8IFONPEFMTDPMMJEFMFTTPOTGSPNTPGUXBSFTZTUFNTBOBMZTJT*51SPGFTTJPOBM o4FFBMTPIUUQTVOTFUVTDFEVSFTFBSDI.#"4& "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#PY (BOE/%SBQFS&NQJSJDBM.PEFM#VJMEJOHBOE3FTQPOTF4VSGBDFT/FX:PSL8JMFZ #SBDLFO 1 BOE.4IVCJL8BSHBNJOHJOUIFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFUIFPSZBOEQVSQPTF/BWBM8BS$PMMFHF 3FW 4QSJOH Qohttp://ﬁndarUJDMFTDPNQBSUJDMFTNJ@N+*8JT@@BJ@ QSJOU "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#SBIB % "".JOBJ BOE:#BS:BN &ET $PNQMFY&OHJOFFSFE4ZTUFNT4DJFODF.FFUT5FDIOPMPHZ /FX:PSL4QSJOHFS $BSMTPO +.BOE+%PZMF$PNQMFYJUZBOESPCVTUOFTT 1SPD/BUM"DBE4DJ64" o IUUQXXXQOBTPSHDPOUFOUTVQQMGVMMQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

$*0&OBCMJOHUIF.JTTJPO"1SBDUJDBM(VJEFUP'FEFSBM4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE"SDIJUFDUVSF%SBGU7FSTJPO 'FC'FEFSBM$*0$PVODJM $4$4 6OJWFSTJUZ PG .JDIJHBO $FOUFS GPS UIF 4UVEZ PG $PNQMFY 4ZTUFNT "CPVU UIF 4DJFODF PG $PNQMFYJUZIUUQXXXDTDTVNJDIFEVBCPVUDPNQMFYJUZIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

%BZBO 1 BOE + 8JMMJBNT 1VUUJOH UIF DPNQVUBUJPO CBDL JOUP DPNQVUBUJPOBM NPEFMJOH 1IBSNBDPQTZDIJBUSZ 4VQQM 4o4 %PSJ %0CKFDU1SPDFTT.FUIPEPMPHZ#FSMJO4QSJOHFS7FSMBH4FFBMTPBMTPIUUQXXXPCKFDUQSPDFTT PSHBOEIUUQXXXFSCZVFEVFSTMJEFT&315%PSJQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

%PZMF +#"454MJEF &SEJ 1$PNQMFYJUZ&YQMBJOFE#FSMJO4QSJOHFS7FSMBH &TUFGBO + 4VSWFZ PG .PEFM#BTFE 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH .#4& .FUIPEPMPHJFT +FU 1SPQVMTJPO -BCPSBUPSZ $BMJGPSOJB *OTUJUVUF PG 5FDIOPMPHZ 1BTBEFOB $BMJGPSOJB IUUQXXXPNHTZTNMPSH .#[email protected]@4VSWFZ@3FW"QEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

&TUFGBO + 4VSWFZ PG .PEFM#BTFE 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH .#4& .FUIPEPMPHJFT +FU 1SPQVMTJPO -BCPSBUPSZ $BMJGPSOJB*OTUJUVUFPG5FDIOPMPHZ 1BTBEFOB $" 'SJFEFOUIBM 4 B 3FBQJOH UIF beneﬁts PG NPEFM ESJWFO TZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH .%4& */$04& */4*()5 o 'SJFENBO (B0n the uniﬁcation of systems engineering. */$04&*/4*()5 o

98

O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

(BSWFZ 131SPCBCJMJUZ.FUIPETGPS$PTU6ODFSUBJOUZ"OBMZTJT"4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH1FSTQFDUJWF/FX :PSL.BSDFM%FLLFS (JHFSFO[FS (BOE34FMUFO#PVOEFE3BUJPOBMJUZ$BNCSJEHF .".*51SFTT (SFFO %BOE31FSSZ1FSSZT$IFNJDBM&OHJOFFST)BOECPPL UIFEJUJPO/FX:PSL.D(SBX)JMM )BTTFMCMBUU #BOE",BUPL"'JSTU$PVSTFJO%ZOBNJDT8JUIB1BOPSBNBPG3FDFOU%FWFMPQNFOUT/FX :PSL$BNCSJEHF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT )PMMPXBZ %The QPMJUJDBMVTFTPGscientiﬁc NPEFMTUIFDZCFSOFUJDNPEFMPGHPWFSONFOUJO4PWJFUTPDJBM TDJFODF *O The 6TF PG .PEFMT JO UIF 4PDJBM 4DJFODFT - $PMMJOT &E #PVMEFS $0 8FTUWJFX 1SFTT Qo )ZCFSUTPO %"VOJGPSNDPNQPOFOUNPEFMJOHTQBDF*OGPSNBUJDB oIUUQXXXNJUSF PSHXPSLCFTU@QBQFSTIZCFSUTPO@TQBDFIZCFSUTPO@TQBDFQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)ZCFSUTPO %6TJOHBspeciﬁcation BQQSPBDIUPGBDJMJUBUFDPNQPOFOUUFTUJOH*O5FTUJOH$PNNFSDJBM oﬀ-the-SIFMG$PNQPOFOUTBOE4ZTUFNT 4#FZEFEBBOE7(SVIO &ET/FX:PSL4QSJOHFS7FSMBH Qo )ZCFSUTPO %6TJOHNPEFMTBOEBCTUSBDUJPOUPFYUFOEBOEVOJGZTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH1SPD*&&&*OU $POG4ZTUFNPG4ZTUFNT&OH 4P4&

-PT"OHFMFT $" o *&&&*&&&4UBOEBSEGPS"QQMJDBUJPOBOE.BOBHFNFOUPGUIF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH1SPDFTT *&&&4UE /FX:PSL*&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ */$04&4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH7JTJPO 7FSTJPO4FBUUMF*/$04& ,PFTUMFS "The GIPTUJOUIF.BDIJOF/FX:PSL.BDNJMMBO ,PPMNBOPKXPOH 4BOE##PFIN"O&NQJSJDBM4UVEZPO.#"4&BOE-FBO.#"4&'JSTU*OU4ZNQ &NQJSJDBM 4PGUXBSF &OHJOFFSJOH BOE .FBTVSFNFOU &4&. o 4FQUFNCFS Qo ,VMBLPXTLJ #5 +'(BSEOFS BOE+-4IFBSFS%ZOBNJD.PEFMJOHBOE$POUSPMPG&OHJOFFSJOH4ZTUFNT SEFE/FX:PSL$BNCSJEHF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT -BOHUPO $( &E "Stiﬁcial LJGF"O0WFSWJFX$BNCSJEHF .".*51SFTT -BWJ +BOE+,VEJTI4ZTUFNT.PEFMJOH3FRVJSFNFOUT4peciﬁcation 6TJOH&$4"."O"OBMZTJT.FUIPE GPS&NCFEEFEBOE$PNQVUFS#BTFE4ZTUFNT/FX:PSL%PSTFU)PVTF .BJFS .BOE&3FDIUJOThe ASUPG4ZTUFNT"SDIJUFDUJOH OEFE#PDB3BUPO '-$3$1SFTT .BSUFMMJ .*OUSPEVDUJPOUP%JTDSFUF%ZOBNJDBM4ZTUFNTBOE$IBPT/FX:PSL8JMFZ .JMMFS +-JWJOH4ZTUFNT-JXPU $06OJWFSTJUZ1SFTTPG$PMPSBEP 0SJHJOBMMZQVCMJTIFE

.PTT 4 "MUFSOBUJWF "QQSPBDIFT UP UIF &NQJSJDBM 7BMJEBUJPO PG "HFOU#BTFE .PEFMT + "Stiﬁcial 4PDJFUJFTBOE4PDJBM4JNVMBUJPO IUUQKBTTTTPDTVSSFZBDVLIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU.BOBHFNFOU(SPVQ .%"(VJEF7FSTJPO0.( +VOF IUUQXXXPNHPSHEPDTPNHQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU .BOBHFNFOU (SPVQ B .PEFM %SJWFO "SDIJUFDUVSF IUUQXXXPNHPSHNEB "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU .BOBHFNFOU (SPVQ C 6niﬁed .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF 0.( 6.-

4VQFSTUSVDUVSF 7 0.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU 63- IUUQXXX PNHPSHTQFD6.-4VQFSTUSVDUVSF1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU .BOBHFNFOU (SPVQ D 6niﬁed .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF 0.( 6.-

*OGSBTUSVDUVSF 7 0.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU 63- IUUQXXX PNHPSHTQFD6.-*OGSBTUSVDUVSF1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU.BOBHFNFOU(SPVQ E4ZTUFNT.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 0.(4ZT.-

70.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU 63- IUUQXXXPNHPSHTQFD 4ZT.-1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

1IFMBO 48IBUJTDPNQMFYJUZTDJFODF SFBMMZ &NFSHFODF o 1IZTJPNF 4QFDJBM*TTVFPOUIF1IZTJPNFBOE#FZPOE1SPD*&&& 1JMLFZ 0)BOE-1JMLFZ+BSWJT6TFMFTT"SJUINFUJD8IZ&OWJSPONFOUBM4DJFOUJTUT$BOU1SFEJDUUIF 'VUVSF/FX:PSL$PMVNCJB6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT

Features of MOSES

O

99

1PHHF 3 -FDUVSF 4QBDF 5JNF (SBWJUZ (FOFSBM 3FMBUJWJUZ "TUSPOPNZ *OUSPEVDUJPO UP 4UBST (BMBYJFT UIF6OJWFSTF0IJP4UBUF6OJWFSTJUZ "UUPIUUQXXXBTUSPOPNZPIJPTUBUF FEV_QPHHF"TU6OJUHSIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

3BZ 54 "O &WPMVUJPOBSZ "QQSPBDI UP 4ZOUIFUJD #JPMPHZ ;FO BOE UIF "SU PG $SFBUJOH -JGF QoJO -BOHUPO 4BHF "1BOE+&"SNTUSPOH +S*OUSPEVDUJPOUP4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH/FX:PSL8JMFZ 4DIVCJO .3JFNBOOJBO(FPNFUSZBOE(FOFSBM3FMBUJWJUZ$PVSTFTZMMBCVTIUUQXXXNBUIOFV edu/~bratus/diﬀgeom/intrPIUN "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

4JNPO )"The "SDIJUFDUVSFPG$PNQMFYJUZ1SPD"N1IJMPTPQIJDBM4PD oIUUQ XXXKTUPSPSHTJDJ TJDJ9"$"5"0$& $0# "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

4JNPO )The 4DJFODFTPGUIF"Stiﬁcial, SEFE$BNCSJEHF .".*51SFTT 0SJHJOBMMZQVCMJTIFE

5VSTLJ 8 "OE OP QIJMPTPQIFST TUPOF FJUIFS *OGPSNBUJPO 1SPDFTTJOH A 1SPD *'*1 $POHSFTT )+ ,VHMFS &E %VCMJO /PSUI)PMMBOE "NTUFSEBN Qo 8arﬁeld, J. 2006. "O*OUSPEVDUJPOUP4ZTUFNT4DJFODF%BOWFST $08orld Scientiﬁc. 8FBWFS 8 4DJFODF BOE DPNQMFYJUZ "N 4DJFOUJTU IUUQXXXDFQUVBMJOTUJUVUFDPNHFOSF XFBWFSXFBWFSCIUN "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

8IJUFIFBE ""O*OUSPEVDUJPOUP.BUIFNBUJDT /FX:PSL)FOSZ)PMU$P 3FQVCMJTIFE/FX :PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT

8ZNPSF 8.PEFM#BTFE4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH#PDB3BUPO '-$3$1SFTT

Chapter 5

SE Model Space

i*BNNZTFMGBHSFBUMPWFSPGUIFTFQSPDFTTFTPGEJWJTJPOBOEHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOUIFZIFMQ NFUPTQFBLBOEUPUIJOLw 1MBUP JO1IBFESVT Systems taxonomy 1

Modeling scope

SE Application Domains (D1...Dn)

Collective actualization space

D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn

Problem space

3a

TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b Traditional Complex

4 Traditional TS is special case 5 Characteristics of all SE systems Traditional and Complex Characteristics of all systems

Highest level system

Deﬁne need

Complex

6

Model Space

All SE application domains...

Indivisible Unit

Composition

TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b 2a Traditional systems Complex systems

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

ThFQVSQPTFPGUIJTDIBQUFSJTUPJOUSPEVDFUIF NPEFMTQBDF XIJDIJTXIFSFNPTUPGUIFBDUJPO UBLFT QMBDF JO .04&4 BOE XIJDI EFﬁOFT UIF WBSJBCMFT BOE EJNFOTJPOT UIBU BSF BEESFTTFE JO TVDDFFEJOHDIBQUFSTPGUIJTCPPLThFDIBQUFSJT MBJEPVUJOUIFGPSNPGBUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOH TFRVFODFTDPQF DPOUFYU SFRVJSFNFOUT EFTJHO BOEJNQMFNFOUBUJPO

Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

e

m

Ti

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

Produce solution

Deployment

Satisfy need

Solution/system space

Model Space Context and Requirements ThJTDIBQUFSJOUSPEVDFTBHFOFSBMDPODFQUPGBNPEFMTQBDF BMPOHXJUIUIFTDPQFBOEDPOUFYUPG UIF4&NPEFMTQBDFBOEBTUBUFNFOUPGUIFSFTVMUJOHSFRVJSFNFOUTPGBNPEFMTQBDF

What Is a Model Space? "QSFMJNJOBSZBOTXFSUPUIJTRVFTUJPOJTUIBUBNPEFMTQBDFJTBGVUVSJTUJDNPEFMPSJFOUFEDPN CJOBUJPOPGUXPUSBEJUJPOBMDPODFQUT BEPNBJOCPEZPGLOPXMFEHF #P, BOE BDPMMFD UJPOPGQSPKFDUMJCSBSJFTPSQSPKFDUEBUBCBTFT8FDBMMUIFTF SFTQFDUJWFMZ BLOPXMFEHFTQBDFBOE XPSLTQBDFTThFDPODFQUPG#P,JTEJTDVTTFEJOTPNFEFUBJMJO$IBQUFSCVUGPSOPXXFXJMM ThFUFSN“QSPKFDU”IFSFJTNFBOUUPCFHFOFSBM UPJODMVEF4&EFWFMPQNFOUQSPKFDU SFTFBSDIQSPKFDU BOEFEVDB UJPO"OZFﬀPSUUIBUFJUIFSVTFTUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFPSDPOUSJCVUFTUPJUJTJOUIFTDPQFPGQSPKFDU

101

102

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

FYQMBJOCPUIUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFBOEUIFXPSLTQBDFCZNFBOTPGBOFYBNQMF5SBEJUJPOBMFOHJ OFFSJOHIBOECPPLTQSPWJEFFYBNQMFTPGHVJEFTUPNBUVSF#P,T5XPFYBNQMFTBSF1FSSZT$IFNJDBM &OHJOFFST )BOECPPL (SFFO BOE 1FSSZ BOE .BSLT 4UBOEBSE )BOECPPL GPS .FDIBOJDBM &OHJOFFST "WBMMPOF #BVNFJTUFS BOE4BEFHI &OHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLTDPOUBJOBWFSZMBSHF OVNCFSPGNPEFMT4PNFPGUIFNPEFMTBSFCBTFEPOUIFPSZ PUIFSTPOFYQFSJNFOUBMMZPCTFSWFEEBUB DBQUVSFEJOUBCMFTPSGPSNVMBT

BOEPUIFSTPOSVMFTPGUIVNCPSIFVSJTUJDT.BOZBSFFYQSFTTFEBT NBUIFNBUJDBMGPSNVMBT PUIFSTBTHSBQIJDT JODMVEJOHCMPDLEJBHSBNT 'PSUIFFYBNQMFIFSF XFTFMFDUUIFEPNBJOPGDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH BOEBDPNQBOZPGDIFNJ DBMFOHJOFFSTUIBUIBTUIFUBTLPGEFTJHOJOHBOEEFWFMPQJOHBOFXDIFNJDBMQSPEVDU1FSSZTIBOE CPPLﬁSTUDPWFSTUIFOFDFTTBSZTVQQPSUJOHEPNBJOTFTQFDJBMMZNBUIFNBUJDT BOEQIZTJDTTVDIBT UIFSNPEZOBNJDT BOEUIFOFYQMBJOTUIFNBOZVOJUPQFSBUJPOT EJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS BOESFMBUFE BDUJWJUJFTIFBUUSBOTGFS ﬂVJEEZOBNJDT SFBDUJPOLJOFUJDT QSPDFTTDPOUSPM EJTUJMMBUJPO TFQBSBUJPO FUD*UUIFSFGPSFJTTFMGDPOUBJOFEJOUIFTFOTFUIBUJUJODMVEFTDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHLOPXMFEHFQMVT OFFEFENBUFSJBMGSPNTVQQPSUJOHBOEJOUFSBDUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT ThFXPSLTQBDFQPSUJPOJTXIFSFUIFDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHUFBNEFWFMPQTBOELFFQTUIFJSBSUJ GBDUTXIJMFEPJOHUIFOFDFTTBSZSFTFBSDI FYQFSJNFOUBUJPO EFWFMPQNFOU BOENBOBHFNFOUUPFOHJ OFFSBOFXDIFNJDBMQSPEVDUPSNPEJGZBOFYJTUJOHPOFThFTFBSUJGBDUTDPVMEJODMVEFEFTDSJQUJPOT PGUIFEFTJSFEQSPQFSUJFTPGUIFDIFNJDBMQSPEVDU EFTJHOEPDVNFOUBUJPO SFDPSETPGFYQFSJNFOUBM USJBMT BOEFRVJQNFOUVTFEJOUIFWBSJPVTBDUJWJUJFT BTXFMMBTNBOBHFNFOUBSUJGBDUTTVDIBTTUBﬀ JOHQMBOT CVEHFUT TDIFEVMFT BOETUBUVTSFQPSUJOHThFQSPDFTTXPVMEJODMVEFESBXJOHPOUIF LOPXMFEHFDPOUBJOFEJO1FSSZTIBOECPPLBOEUBJMPSJOHJUUPUIFJSTQFDJﬁDQSPEVDU ThBU JT B EFTDSJQUJPO PG UPEBZT JODBSOBUJPO PG B NPEFM TQBDF 8IBU JT UIF GVUVSJTUJD WJFX $POUJOVJOHUIF$IFNJDBM&OHJOFFST)BOECPPLFYBNQMF TVQQPTFXFUSBOTGPSNFEBOEQBSTFEUIF NBUFSJBM JO UIF IBOECPPL GSPN CPPL GPSN JOUP NPEFM GPSN JO B EBUBCBTF PS PUIFS NBDIJOF NBOJQVMBUFESFQPTJUPSZUIBUIBTBTFUPGNPEFMJOHBOEPUIFSSFQPTJUPSZNBOBHFNFOUUPPMT.VDI PG UIF NBUFSJBM JO UIF IBOECPPL BMSFBEZ DPOTJTUT PG NPEFMT ThF XPSL JOWPMWFE XPVME CF UP PSHBOJ[F UIF NPEFMT SFQSFTFOU UIFN JO BQQSPQSJBUF MBOHVBHFT TVDI BT NBUIFNBUJDBM NPEFMT 4ZTUFN.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 4ZT.-

6OJﬁFE.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 6.-

EFTDSJQUJPOMPHJDT DPOTUSBJOUMBOHVBHFT TDSJQUJOHMBOHVBHFT BOETPGUXBSFQSPHSBNNJOHMBOHVBHFTBOEBTTPDJBUF UIFBQQSPQSJBUFNFUBEBUBUPFOBCMFNBDIJOFNBOJQVMBUJPOBOEFOBCMFTFBSDICZUIFFOHJOFFST ThFWBSJBCMFTPSEJNFOTJPOTJOUSPEVDFEMBUFSJOUIJTDIBQUFSQSPWJEFBCBTJDPSHBOJ[JOHTUSVDUVSF "MMUIFGPSFHPJOHNPEFMTXPVMECFFOUFSFEJOUIFDPNNVOJUZLOPXMFEHFTQBDFQPSUJPOPGUIF NPEFMTQBDF "OETVQQPTFXFEJETPNFUIJOHTJNJMBSXJUIUIFDPNQBOZTQSPKFDUBOENBOBHFNFOUBSUJGBDUT BOEUIFQSPKFDUEPDVNFOUT EFTDSJQUJPOT QMBOT TDIFEVMFT CVEHFU TUBﬃOH BOESFQPSUT"MUIPVHI JOQSJODJQMF UIFNPEFMTQBDFBOENPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBMMPXQIZTJDBMNPEFMT BTXFMMBTDPODFQUVBM NPEFMT UIJTCPPLQSJNBSJMZGPDVTFTPODPODFQUVBMNPEFMTTVDIBTNBUIFNBUJDBMNPEFMT EFTJHOT SFRVJSFNFOUT DPOTUSBJOUT BOESVMFT*GXFTUBZFEXJUIJOUIFDPODFQUVBMNPEFMTQBDF XFXPVME FYDMVEFUIFQIZTJDBMFRVJQNFOUUIFFOHJOFFSTVTFECVUXFXPVMEQVUBMMPUIFSBSUJGBDUTJOUIFDPN QBOZQSPKFDUXPSLTQBDFQPSUJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF ThFNPEFMTQBDFXPVMEOPXDPOUBJOUIF#P,JOUIFGPSNPGHFOFSBMNPEFMTJOUIFLOPXMFEHF TQBDFUIBUBSFBDDFTTJCMFUPUIFXIPMFDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHDPNNVOJUZ BOEXPVMEDPOUBJOUIF XPSLTQBDFPGUIFDPNQBOZQSPKFDUJOUIFGPSNPGTQFDJﬁDNPEFMTGPSUIJTQSPEVDU XIJDIQFSIBQT XPVMECFLFQUQSJWBUFUPUIBUDPNQBOZPOMZ&BDIDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHPSHBOJ[BUJPOXPVMEUIFO IBWFBEJﬀFSFOUWJFXPGUIFDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHNPEFMTQBDFUIFQVCMJDDPNNPOLOPXMFEHF TQBDFBOEUIFJSPXOQSJWBUFXPSLTQBDF

SE Model Space

O

103

ThFGPSFHPJOHGVUVSJTUJDWFSTJPOPGUIFDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHNPEFMTQBDFSFQSFTFOUTUIFDPO DFQUPGBNPEFMTQBDFBTEFTDSJCFEJOUIJTDIBQUFSBOEUIJTCPPL*UJTBHFOFSBMDPODFQUUIBUDBOCF BQQMJFEUPBOZﬁFMEPGJORVJSZ TVDIBTBEPNBJO EJTDJQMJOF PSNVMUJEJTDJQMJOF UIBUTBUJTﬁFTUXP SBUIFSMPPTFDPOTUSBJOUT'JSTU UIBUJUJTBSFBTPOBCMZDPIFSFOUﬁFMEXJUIBDPNNVOJUZUIBUHFOFS BUFTBOEFWPMWFTB#P, BOETFDPOE UIBUUIF#P,DBOCFSFQSFTFOUFEBTNPEFMT#FDBVTFXFWJFX NPTU JGOPUBMM IVNBOLOPXMFEHFBTCFJOHSFQSFTFOUBCMFBTNPEFMT UIFTFDPOEDPOTUSBJOUJTNPSF PSMFTTSFEVOEBOUJUTTBUJTGBDUJPOCFJOHJNQMJFECZUIFﬁSTUDPOTUSBJOU)PXFWFS XFJODMVEFJU CFDBVTFTPNFNBZOPUTIBSFPVSWJFXPGLOPXMFEHFBTNPEFMT ThFSF BSF PUIFS QPTTJCMF WBSJBOUT PG UIF XPSLTQBDF QPSUJPO PG UIF NPEFM TQBDF 0OF JT BO PSHBOJ[BUJPOPSFOUFSQSJTFXPSLTQBDF#FDBVTFUIFNPEFMTQBDFJTEFTJHOFEUPJODMVEFNPEFMTPG FOUFSQSJTFTJOUIFGPSNPGQSPKFDUT JUDBOBMTPTVQQPSUNPEFMTPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBTBXIPMF BTB DPOUFYU JO XIJDI QSPKFDUT FYJTU PS DPNF BOE HP 0SHBOJ[BUJPOBM QMBOOJOH CVEHFUJOH TUBﬃOH BOEBMMGPSNTPGNBOBHFNFOU PSFOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOHNBOBHFNFOUBTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS

JODMVEJOHFOUFSQSJTFBSDIJUFDUVSFT DPVMECFDPOUBJOFEBOEVTFEJOBOFOUFSQSJTFXPSLTQBDF"OE CFDBVTFUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFJODMVEFTUIFLOPXMFEHFBOEQBUUFSOTPGNBOBHF NFOUJOHFOFSBMGSPNUIFNBOBHFNFOUTDJFODFDPNNVOJUZ UIFFOUFSQSJTFXPSLTQBDFDPVMEESBX GSPNUIFTFHFOFSBMNPEFMTBOEUBJMPSUIFNUPNBOBHFBTQFDJﬁDFOUFSQSJTFThJTUZQFPGXPSLTQBDF JTXJUIJOUIFTDPQFPGUIFFYQBOEFE4&PGUIFGVUVSF 0UIFSXPSLTQBDFWBSJBOUTBSFUFBNBOEQFSTPOBMXPSLTQBDFT"QSPKFDUNJHIUIBWFNVMUJQMF UFBNT FBDIPGXIJDIDPVMEIBWFUIFJSXPSLTQBDF BOEFBDINFNCFSDPVMEIBWFBQFSTPOBMXPSL TQBDFThFSFNJHIUCFDPIFSFODFXJUIJOUIFUFBNXPSLTQBDFCVUOPUZFUJOUIFQSPKFDUXPSLTQBDF .PEFMDPIFSFODFJTOPUOFDFTTBSZBUBMMMFWFMT*UTIPVMECFEFDJEFEXIBUQPSUJPOTPGUIFXPSLTQBDF BUFBDIMFWFMOFFEUPIBWFDPOTJTUFODZ DPIFSFODF DPOHSVFODF FUD $POTJEFSUIFQPTTJCJMJUZUIBUBMMJOGPSNBUJPOBWBJMBCMFPOUIF*OUFSOFUDPVMECFBLOPXMFEHF TQBDF*OPOFTFOTF XFNJHIUBSHVFUIBUUIJTCPEZPGJOGPSNBUJPONBQTJOUPBLOPXMFEHFTQBDFBT XFEFﬁOFJUJOUIJTDIBQUFS BMUIPVHIUIF*OUFSOFUJOGPSNBUJPOFYQMPJUTPOMZBGSBDUJPOPGUIFTUSVD UVSFBWBJMBCMFJOBLOPXMFEHFTQBDF6MUJNBUFMZ IPXFWFS XFXPVMETBZOP UIJTCPEZPGJOGPSNB UJPOEPFTOPUDPOTUJUVUFBLOPXMFEHFTQBDFCFDBVTFJUEPFTOPUTFQBSBUFUIFXIFBUGSPNUIFDIBﬀ "LOPXMFEHFTQBDFJTOPUBOPSHBOJ[FEQJMFPGNBUFSJBMJUJTBOPSHBOJ[FETFUPGNPEFMTUIBUSFQ SFTFOUTLOPXMFEHFBTEFUFSNJOFECZBOBTTPDJBUFEDPNNVOJUZ4QFDJﬁDXPSLTQBDFNPEFMTFJUIFS FWPMWFJOUPUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDF MFBWFUIFNPEFMTQBDFXIFOOPMPOHFSOFFEFE PSBSFBSDIJWFEJO UIFNPEFMTQBDFGPSIJTUPSJDBMQVSQPTFTThJTJTQBSUPGUIFPWFSBMMDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT UIBUXFEFTDSJCFJO$IBQUFS )PXEPFTBDPNNVOJUZEFUFSNJOFXIBUJTBDDFQUFEJOUPJUT#P, ThFUSBEJUJPOBMQSPDFTTGPS UIJTBDDFQUBODFPSWFUUJOHIBTCFFOQSJNBSJMZKPVSOBMPSDPOGFSFODFSFGFSFFJOHBOEVTBHFPGUFYU CPPLTBOEPUIFSNBUFSJBMBUJOTUJUVUJPOTPGMFBSOJOHThJTQSPDFTTJTFWPMWJOHUPSFﬂFDUNPSFPOMJOF QVCMJDBUJPOTBOENPSFNBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPOBOENBTTSFWJFX.04&4EPFTOPUEFﬁOFXIBUUIFWFU UJOHQSPDFTTNVTUCF&BDIDPNNVOJUZEFﬁOFTJUTPXOQSPDFTTBOETUBOEBSETThF4&PGUIFGVUVSF JTBDPNQPTJUFPGNVMUJQMFEJTDJQMJOFT BTJOEJDBUFEJO$IBQUFS BOEUIFSFGPSFUIF4&NPEFMTQBDF XJMMESBXGSPNNVMUJQMFDPNNVOJUJFT

5PUIFFYUFOUUIBU*OUFSOFUNBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPODPNNVOJUJFTQSBDUJDFTFMGNPOJUPSJOH SFWJFX BOEDPSSFDUJPOPG NBUFSJBM JUDPVMECFDPOTJEFSFEBDPNNVOJUZ#P,#VUXIBULFFQTUIF*OUFSOFUBTBXIPMFGSPNCFJOHBLOPXM FEHFTQBDFJTUIBUNBUFSJBMUIBUJTOPUBDDFQUFEJTTUJMMBWBJMBCMF BOEUIFSFJTOPEFNBSDBUJPOCFUXFFOBDDFQUFE NBUFSJBMBOEOPUBDDFQUFENBUFSJBM

104 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Scope of the SE Model Space *OUIFDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHFYBNQMF UIFIBOECPPLXBTBTJOHMFTPVSDFSFQSFTFOUJOHBQBSUJBMMZ TFMGDPOUBJOFE#P,UIBUJODMVEFEUIFTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT*OPUIFSEJTDJQMJOFT BOEQBSUJDVMBSMZ 4& OPTVDITJOHMFTPVSDFFYJTUTThFCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFPG4&JTTQSFBEBDSPTTNVMUJQMFTVQQPSUJOH EJTDJQMJOFTBOEBTTPDJBUFEEPNBJOT NPTUPGXIJDIIBWFUIFJSPXOEFﬁOFECPEZPGLOPXMFEHF #FDBVTFPGUIJT UIF4&NPEFMTQBDFNVTUCFNPEVMBSBOEDPNQPTBCMFGSPNUIFJOEJWJEVBMNPEFM TQBDFTPGJUTTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFTThF4&NPEFMTQBDFTIPVMEESBXGSPNUIFDPOTUJUVFOUPOFT SBUIFSUIBOEVQMJDBUJOHUIFN)PXFWFS UIFDPNQPTJUF4&NPEFMTQBDFNVTUJOUFHSBUFJUTDPOTUJUV FOUNPEFMTQBDFT BOEUIVTJUIBTJUTPXONPEFMTBTXFMMGPSFYBNQMF NPEFMTUIBUBSFDPNNPO PSHFOFSBMJ[FEBDSPTTNVMUJQMFDPOTUJUVFOUEJTDJQMJOFT (JWFOUIBUBQQSPBDI UIFTDPQFPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFXFEFTDSJCFJOUIJTCPPLJTUIFFYQBOEFE NVMUJEJTDJQMJOFPG4&BOEJUTTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT BTTLFUDIFEJO$IBQUFSTBOE*OQBSUJDV MBS UIJTTDPQFJODMVEFTCPUITZTUFNNPEFMTBOENBOBHFNFOUNPEFMTBTSFﬂFDUFEJO5BCMF ThSPVHIPVUUIFCPPL XIFOXFSFGFSUPUIFNPEFMTQBDF XFNFBOUIJT4&NPEFMTQBDFVOMFTT TQFDJﬁDBMMZEFTJHOBUFEPUIFSXJTF $POUFOUUZQFQSPWJEFTBOPUIFSBTQFDUPGUIFTDPQFThFNPEFMTQBDFDPOUBJOTPOMZNPEFMT UIJOHTUIBUBSFOPUNPEFMTBSFPVUTJEFUIFNPEFMTQBDF'PSFYBNQMF NPEFMQSPDFTTPSTBSFPVUTJEF UIFNPEFMTQBDF BOETZTUFNTUIBUJT UBSHFUTZTUFNTUIBUBSFOPUNPEFMTBSFPVUTJEFUIF NPEFMTQBDF*NQMJDJUQBSUTPGTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTBSFOPUJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF8FTIPVMEOPUF IPXFWFS UIBUFOUJUJFTUIBUBSFTPNFUJNFTDBMMFENFUBNPEFMTPSNFUBNFUBNPEFMTBSFJOUIFTDPQFPGUIF NPEFMTQBDF*O.04&4 UIFTFFOUJUJFTBSFNPEFMT

Context of the Model Space ThFCBTJDDPOUFYUPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF TIPXOJO'JHVSF JTBQSPCMFNTQBDFBOEBDPSSFTQPOE JOHTPMVUJPOTQBDF XIJDIDPWFSTUIFGVMMSBOHFPGQSPCMFNTGPSXIJDI4&QSPWJEFTTPMVUJPOTThF SFMBUJPOTBNPOHUIFFMFNFOUTBSFUIBUUIFNPEFMTQBDFEFﬁOFTNPEFMTPGQSPCMFNTPSOFFETJOUIF QSPCMFNTQBDF BOEEFﬁOFTNPEFMTPGTPMVUJPOT4PMVUJPOTTBUJTGZOFFETJOUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFThF ﬁHVSFEPFTOPUDPOTUSBJOUIFTFRVFODFPG4&BDUJWJUJFTUIBUUBLFQMBDFJOUIFDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[B UJPOTQBDF0OFTFRVFODFJTUIFUSBEJUJPOBMGPSXBSEFOHJOFFSJOHPSOFFEESJWFOQSPDFTTﬁSTUBOFFE JOUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFJTJEFOUJﬁFE UIFONPEFMTPGUIFQSPCMFNBOETPMVUJPO FH SFRVJSFNFOUT EFTJHO BSFEFﬁOFEUIBUFYJTUJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF BTPMVUJPOJTQSPEVDFEGSPNUIFTPMVUJPONPEFM BOEBQQFBSTJOUIFTPMVUJPOTQBDF BOd ﬁOBMMZUIFTPMVUJPOJTEFQMPZFEJOUIFQSPCMFNTQBDF 'PSFYBNQMF BOFFEJTJEFOUJﬁFEUPUSBOTQPSUQFPQMFBOEHPPETCFUXFFOMPDBUJPOTPOUIFMBOE TVSGBDFPGUIF&BSUI"OBJSDSBGUFOHJOFFSJOHPSHBOJ[BUJPOQFSGPSNT4&JOUIFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF BOEQSPEVDFTBMMUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT EFTJHOT ESBXJOHT TJNVMBUJPOT BOEPUIFSNPEFMTJOUIFNPEFM TQBDFGPSCVJMEJOHBUZQFPGBJSDSBGU"NBOVGBDUVSJOHQMBOUCVJMETNVMUJQMFBJSDSBGUCBTFEPOUIFTF NPEFMT BOEUIFBJSDSBGUFYJTUJOUIFTPMVUJPOTQBDF8IFOBOBJSMJOFCVZTBJSDSBGUBOEQVUTUIFN JOUPPQFSBUJPO UIFBJSDSBGUTBUJTGZUIFOFFEThFGPSFHPJOHBTTVNFTUIFOFDFTTBSZTVQQPSUJOHFOWJ SPONFOU TVDIBTBJSQPSUTBOEBJSUSBﬃc DPOUSPM"OPUIFSTFRVFODFJTUIFUSBEJUJPOBMUFDIOPMPHZ ESJWFOQSPDFTT"UFDIOPMPHZBQQFBSTCFGPSFBOFFEJTJEFOUJﬁFEThFBQQFBSBODFPGUIFUFDIOPMPHZ DBVTFTSFDPHOJUJPOPGBOFFEUIBUUIFUFDIOPMPHZTBUJTﬁFT "NFUBNPEFMJTBEFTDSJQUJPOPSDBUFHPSZPGBNPEFM*GBNPEFMJTBDBUFHPSZPGJOEJWJEVBMTZTUFNT UIFOBNFUB NPEFMJTBDBUFHPSZPGJOEJWJEVBMNPEFMT$IBQUFSEJTDVTTFTSFMBUFEDPODFQUTPGDPNNPOBMJUZ DBUFHPSZ DMBTT BOEJOTUBODF$IBQUFSEJTDVTTFTSFMBUFEDPODFQUTPGUBYPOPNZ DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO BOEPOUPMPHZ

SE Model Space

O

105

Collective Actualization Space Problem/environment space Model of need

Model/description space Model of solution

Deployment space

Satisfaction of need

Solution/system space

Problem space: Problem domain environments in which engineered systems are needed – and eventually used in the deployment space Model space: Models of problems and solutions, ranging from general models representing knowledge of multiple systems to speciﬁc models of a problem or solution Solution space: Solution engineered with the help of models and that satisﬁes one or more needs in problem environment; in the preponderance of cases, the solution is a system Collective actualization space: Engineering agents, self-organizing and managing agents, interaction, modeling/engineering/management processes and tools

Figure 5.1 SE model space interaction context.

5PHFUBNPSFDPNQMFUFQJDUVSFPGUIFDPOUFYUBOEBCFUUFSVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF XF OFFE UP DPOTJEFS UIF NVMUJEPNBJO OBUVSF PG UIF 4& QSPCMFN BOE TPMVUJPO TQBDFT 4ZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOHIBTBMXBZTTVQQPSUFENVMUJQMFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT TVDIBTBFSPTQBDF USBOTQPSUBUJPO BOEDPOTUSVDUJPO BOEJUJTFYQBOEJOHUPNPSFEPNBJOTBTXFIBWFEJTDVTTFEJOQSFWJPVTDIBQUFST &BDITPMVUJPO CZEFﬁOJUJPO OFFETUPQSPWJEFIFMQJOUIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOUIBUDPSSFTQPOETUP UIFQSPCMFN TPUIFTPMVUJPOOFFETUPBQQFBSJOVOEFSTUBOEBCMFGPSNUPUIBUEPNBJOThFSFGPSF UIFEPNBJODPOUFYUJTUIBUNVMUJQMFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTGFFEJOUPUIFNPEFMTQBDF BOEUIFNPEFM TQBDFGFFETTPMVUJPOT PSGFFETNPEFMTUPTPMVUJPOCVJMEFSTXIPCVJMETPMVUJPOT UIBUHPCBDLJOUP UIFTBNFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTThJTDPOUFYUJTJMMVTUSBUFEJO'JHVSF TIPXJOHCPUIQSPCMFNBOE TPMVUJPOTQBDFTEJWJEFEJOUPBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT Collective Actualization Space Problem space Application Domain 1

Deﬁne need

Model space

Produce solution

Solution space Application Domain 1

Application Domain 2

Application Domain 2

Application Domain 3

Application Domain 3

Application Domain 4

Application Domain 4

Application Domain n

Application Domain n

Problem space: SE problem space includes multiple application domains Model space: Models must address problems and produce corresponding solutions in each application domain Solution space: Each solution exists in the corresponding application domain

Figure 5.2

SE model space domain context.

106

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Table 5.1 SE Foundation Requirements Allocated to the Model Space No.

Requirement

5

Support scale-up and scale-down of systems, and multiple scales in a single system, to include both spatial and temporal scales. Be ﬂexible, adaptable, and extensible, and evolve as needed. Facilitate incorporation and use of knowledge and experience. Support multiple views and perspectives of a given system or class of systems. Support balance of commonality and variability: ﬁnd everything in common; but do not force one size ﬁts all; recognize imperative and beneﬁts of diversity. Support balance of stability and change: ﬁnd everything that is stable but do not force false stability; recognize imperative and beneﬁts of change. Support clear communication among all SE stakeholders, but recognize that not all clear communication is explicit; support both explicit and implicit communication. Support analysis of alternatives. Provide a uniﬁed approach to organizing and harnessing the knowledge from the array of disciplines supporting SE.

10 11 13 16 17 18 20 24

Requirements of the SE Model Space 5BCMFMJTUTUIF$IBQUFSSFRVJSFNFOUTPGBO4&GPVOEBUJPOUIBUXFSFBMMPDBUFEUPUIFNPEFMTQBDF #BTFEPOUIFDPOUFYUEJTDVTTJPOUIVTGBS UIFEFSJWFESFRVJSFNFOUTGPSUIF4&NPEFMTQBDFBSF UPSFDFJWFBOEVOEFSTUBOEQSPCMFNTJOBXJEFWBSJFUZPGBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT BOEQSPEVDFBOE QSPWJEFTPMVUJPOTGPSUIBUTBNFWBSJFUZPGEPNBJOTJOFBDIDBTF NBUDIJOHUIFQSPCMFNEPNBJO BOE UIF TPMVUJPO EPNBJO BOE NBUDIJOH UIF TQFDJﬁD TPMVUJPO UP UIF TQFDJﬁD QSPCMFN *O NBOZ DBTFT UIF TPMVUJPO XJMM CF BO FOHJOFFSFE TZTUFN 'VSUIFSNPSF JU NVTU EP UIJT JO B SFBTPOBCMZ FﬃcJFOU NBOOFS ThJT JNQMJFT UIBU UIF NPEFM TQBDF NVTU TVQQPSU UIF DBQUVSF BOE FYQMPJUBUJPO PGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOENPEFMTUIBUBSFDPNNPOBDSPTTBEPNBJO PSBDSPTTNVMUJQMFEPNBJOT UP NJOJNJ[FEVQMJDBUJPOPGXPSL

Model Space Design )PXTIPVMEUIF4&NPEFMTQBDFCFEFTJHOFEBOETUSVDUVSFEUPTBUJTGZUIFSFRVJSFNFOUT JOUIFDPO UFYUPGNVMUJQMFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTBOENVMUJQMFTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT ThJTTFDUJPOEFTDSJCFT ﬁSTUBTJNQMJTUJDEFTJHOUIBUXPVMEQBSUJUJPOUIFNPEFMTQBDFJOUPFBDIBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO BOE UIFOBNPSFSFBMJTUJDEFTJHOUIBUTVQQPSUTUIFHSFBUFSJOUFSSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT BOEFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOFT

Approaches Approach 1: Partition into Separate Application Domain Model Spaces 8FDPVMEIBWFBQBSUJUJPOFENPEFMTQBDF PSFRVJWBMFOUMZNVMUJQMFTFQBSBUFNPEFMTQBDFT POFGPS FBDIBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO TVDIBTBFSPTQBDF USBOTQPSUBUJPO DPOTUSVDUJPO NFEJDJOF PSPSHBOJ[B UJPOBMNBOBHFNFOU8FXPVMEIBWFEPNBJOTQFDJﬁDQSPCMFNT XIJDIXFEFTDSJCFJOUIFNPEFM TQBDFJOEPNBJOTQFDJﬁDNPEFMT GSPNXIJDIXFQSPEVDFEPNBJOTQFDJﬁDTPMVUJPOT XIJDITBUJTGZ

SE Model Space

O

107

UIFQSPCMFNJOUIBUEPNBJOThBUXPVMETBUJTGZUIFGVODUJPOBMSFRVJSFNFOUT BOETFFNTBUﬁSTU HMBODFUPCFBSFBTPOBCMFEFTJHO #VUJGXFMPPLBUUIFXPSMEPG4& UIJTTPMVUJPOJTWFSZJOFﬃcJFOUBOEOPUSFBMJTUJDCFDBVTFPG UIFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTBOEBMMUIFEJTDJQMJOFTBOETQFDJBMUJFTPG4&UIBUTVQQPSU TPMVUJPOT"OBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTFFTPOMZUIFFYUFSOBMWJFXPGFBDITPMVUJPOPSTZTUFN8IJMF UIBUFYUFSOBMWJFXMPPLTUPUIBUEPNBJOMJLFTPNFUIJOHUIBUﬁUTOJDFMZJOUPUIFEPNBJO UIFJOUFS OBMWJFXJTBOPUIFSXPSME UIFFOHJOFFSJOHXPSMEUIBUHPFTXFMMCFZPOEUIFQSPCMFNBQQMJDBUJPO EPNBJO'MZJOHPOBOBJSDSBGUGSPNUIFVTFSQFSTQFDUJWFJOWPMWFTHFUUJOHBUJDLFU CPBSEJOH BOE TJUUJOHJOBTFBUPOUIFQMBOFXIJMFJUﬂJFTGSPNPOFDJUZUPBOPUIFSThJTFYUFSOBMWJFXEPFTOPU OFFEUPTFFBMMUIFJOUFSOBMEPNBJOTPGQPXFSQMBOU BWJPOJDT FUDUIBUNBLFVQUIFNPEFMJOHBOE UIFPWFSBMMBJSDSBGUTPMVUJPOUPUSBOTQPSUBUJPO#VUUIFNPEFMTQBDFOFFETUPBEESFTTBMMUIFTFDPO TUJUVFOUNPEFMJOHEPNBJOTBOEEJTDJQMJOFT BOEUIFZBSFJODPSQPSBUFEPSBUMFBTUSFﬂFDUFEJOUIF TPMVUJPOUIBUJT UIFCVJMUBJSDSBGU 'VSUIFSNPSF JONBOZDBTFTUIFTBNFHFOFSBMNPEFMTBQQMZUPNVMUJQMFEJTDJQMJOFTBOEEPNBJOT ThBU IBT CFFO USVF PG 54& XJUI NBUIFNBUJDBM DPNQVUBUJPOBM BOE FOHJOFFSJOH NPEFMT JU JT FWFONPSFQSPOPVODFEXJUIUIFJODPSQPSBUJPOPG$4NPEFMT XIJDIIBWFCFFOFYQMJDJUMZJOWFTUJ HBUFEBDSPTTBWBSJFUZPGEPNBJOT.BOZJOUFSOBMNPEFMTBQQMZBDSPTTNVMUJQMFFYUFSOBMBQQMJDBUJPO EPNBJOT SFQSFTFOUJOHBNBOZUPNBOZSFMBUJPOThFSFGPSF UIJTBQQSPBDIPGLFFQJOHQSPCMFNT NPEFMT BOETPMVUJPOTQBSUJUJPOFEBMPOHBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOCPVOEBSJFTJOBPOFUPPOFSFMBUJPO EPFTOPUXPSL8FOFFEBOBQQSPBDIUIBUTVQQPSUTUIFSFMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFOJOUFSOBMNPEFMTBOE BQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT

Approach 2: One Common SE Model Space ThF TFMFDUFE BQQSPBDI JT POF DPNNPO NPEFM TQBDF GPS BMM EPNBJOT BOE EJTDJQMJOFT BT TIPXO HFOFSJDBMMZJO'JHVSF*OUIFDPOUFYUPGUIJTCPPLBOEPG4& XFJODMVEFBMMEPNBJOTBOEEJT DJQMJOFTUIBUBSFJOUIFOFX4&UIFDMBTTJDEPNBJOTPGUSBEJUJPOBM4&UIBUXFIBWFNFOUJPOFEUIF EPNBJOTPGFYUFOEFE4& TVDIBTPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBOEOBOPTZTUFNTBOEUIFTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT TVDIBT44 $44 BOENBUIFNBUJDTThFNPEFMTQBDFIBTWFSZHFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUDVUBDSPTTBMM EPNBJOTBOEIBTPUIFSHFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUBSFPSJFOUFEUPBTQFDJﬁDEPNBJO "SFJOUFSQSFUBUJPOPGUIFBJSDSBGUFYBNQMFHJWFOFBSMJFSDBOCFVTFEUPJMMVTUSBUFUIFNBOZUP NBOZSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTBOEJOUFSOBMNPEFMTPSEPNBJOT"TJNQMJﬁFEWJFX PGUIFTJUVBUJPOGSPNUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPG'JHVSFJTUIJTUIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOJTDPNNFSDJBM BJSUSBOTQPSUBUJPO"OFYUFSOBMWJFXPGUIFTPMVUJPOJTBOBJSDSBGUUIBUUSBOTQPSUTHPPETBOEQFPQMF UISPVHIUIFBJSGSPNPOFBJSQPSUUPBOPUIFS"OJOUFSOBMWJFXPGUIFTPMVUJPOJTBTFUPGTVCTZTUFNT SFQSFTFOUJOHNVMUJQMFEPNBJOT TVDIBTBJSGSBNFTUSVDUVSFTJODMVEJOHGVTFMBHFBOEXJOHT BQPXFS QMBOUJODMVEJOHPOFPSNPSFFOHJOFT BOEBWJPOJDTJODMVEJOHDPNNVOJDBUJPOT OBWJHBUJPO BOE ﬂJHIUDPOUSPMThFNPEFMTQBDFJODMVEFTNPEFMTGSPNBMMFOHJOFFSJOH TVQQPSUJOHTDJFODF NBUI FNBUJDT BOEDPNQVUBUJPOBMEPNBJOTOFFEFEUPFOHJOFFSUIFBJSDSBGU ThJTJMMVTUSBUFTUIFNBOZJOUFSOBMEPNBJOTSFMBUFEUPUIFPOFBJSUSBOTQPSUBUJPOEPNBJOThF PUIFSTJEFPGUIFNBOZUPNBOZSFMBUJPOTIJQJTUIBUNPTUPGUIPTFJOUFSOBMBOETVQQPSUJOHEPNBJOT DMFBSMZBMTPTVQQPSUNVMUJQMFPUIFSBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTThJTSFMBUJPOJTTVQQPSUFECZIBWJOHBMM EPNBJOTBOEEJTDJQMJOFTUPHFUIFSJOBTJOHMFNPEFMTQBDF"OZHJWFOBQQMJDBUJPOQSPCMFNDBOESBX POUIFGVMMTQFDUSVNBOEWBSJFUZPGNPEFMT "T JO UIF QSFWJPVT ﬁHVSF UIF TFRVFODF JT OPU DPOTUSBJOFE *O B USBEJUJPOBM GPSXBSE PS UPQ EPXO4&QSPDFTT UIFMJOFTBOEBSSPXTJO'JHVSFXPVMEBMMCFBSSPXTQPJOUJOHUPUIFSJHIU

108

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Collective Actualization Space Model space disciplines, domains

Appl’n Domain 1

Int Ext

Appl’n Domain 2

Int Ext

Appl’n Domain 3

Int Ext

Appl’n Domain 4

Int Ext

Appl’n Domain 5

Int Ext

Int Multiple disciplines

Problem space

Solution space Ext Appl’n Domain 1 Appl’n Domain 2 Appl’n Domain 3 Appl’n Domain 4 Appl’n Domain 5

Solution space: From an external view, each solution exists in the corresponding application domain; internally, each solution draws from multiple disciplines and domains Model space: Models exist in multiple application domains and multiple supporting disciplines — SS, CSS, mathematics, computing, biology, physics, etc.

Figure 5.3

SE model space multi-domain texture.

ThFNPEFMTPOUIFMFGUTJEFPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFXPVMECFUIFEFTJSFEPSiUPCFwNPEFMTEFﬁOFE VQGSPOUGPSBOZHJWFOTZTUFNJOFBDIEPNBJO TVDIBTSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUTThFNPEFMTPO UIFSJHIUTJEFXPVMECFUIFBDUVBMiBTCVJMUwNPEFMTEFﬁOFEBGUFSEFWFMPQNFOUPGUIPTFTZTUFNT*G XFBTTVNFUIBUUIFNPEFMTPOUIFMFGUBSFFYUFSOBMEFTDSJQUJPOTTVDIBTSFRVJSFNFOUTTQFDT UIFO UIFi&YUwPSFYUFSOBMNPEFMTPOUIFSJHIUBSFUIFiBTCVJMUwNPEFMTUIBUDBOCFDPNQBSFEUPUIF NPEFMTPOUIFMFGU *GOPDIBOHFTPDDVSSFEJOUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTEVSJOHUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGUIFTZTUFN UIFOUIF FYUFSOBMNPEFMTPOUIFSJHIUTIPVMECFJEFOUJDBMUPUIFNPEFMTPOUIFMFGU GPSBOZHJWFOTZTUFNJO FBDIEPNBJO*OUIJTDBTFUIFSFJTPOFEJﬀFSFODFPGJOUFSQSFUBUJPOCFUXFFOUIFMFGUBOESJHIUNPE FMT XIJDIBSFUIFTBNFNPEFM-FUTDBMMUIJTNPEFM. XIJDIDIBSBDUFSJ[FTGVODUJPOT\' ' z^ ThFMFGUJOUFSQSFUBUJPOJTQSFTDSJQUJWFUIFTZTUFNTIBMMEP.\' ' z^ThFSJHIUJOUFSQSFUBUJPO JTEFTDSJQUJWFUIFTZTUFNEPFT.\' ' z^ThFTFBSFUXPEJﬀFSFOUQJFDFTPGJOGPSNBUJPO SFQSFTFOUFEBTDPSSFTQPOEFODFTXJUIEJﬀFSFOUNPEBMJUJFT BOECPUIBSFJNQPSUBOUUPLOPX .BOZUJNFT TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTSFDFJWFEFTDSJQUJPOTPGTPMVUJPOT TVDIBTVTFSXSJUUFOSFRVJSF NFOUT EPDVNFOUT UIBU EP OPU BEFRVBUFMZ TPMWF UIF QSPCMFN BSF JODPOTJTUFOU BNCJHVPVT PS JODPNQMFUFThF.04&4TUBODFJTUIBUJUJTUIFSFTQPOTJCJMJUZPGUIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTUPVOEFS TUBOEUIFQSPCMFN UIFHBQ BOEUIFDPOUFYUTPUIFZDBOEFﬁOFBOBQQSPQSJBUFTPMVUJPO*OUFSNT PG'JHVSF TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTOFFEUPSFBDIJOUPUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFUPFOTVSFUIBUUIFNPEFMT POUIFMFGUTJEFPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFBSFBQQSPQSJBUFDIBSBDUFSJ[BUJPOTPGUIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO QSPCMFNUIFZOFFEUPTPMWF

Internal Model Space Structure #BTFEPOUIFEJTDVTTJPOBCPWF XFXBOUUPEFTJHOBTUSVDUVSFUIBUPSHBOJ[FTNPEFMTJOBXBZUIBU TBUJTﬁFTBMMUIFFYUFSOBMBOEEFSJWFESFRVJSFNFOUTJEFOUJﬁFEUPUIJTQPJOU3FDBMMUIBU4&EPNBJOT FYJTUBUUIFMFWFMPGXIPMFTZTUFNT BOEBMTPBUUIFMFWFMPGDPNQPOFOUT TPUIBUBTZTUFNJOPOF EPNBJOJODMVEFTDPNQPOFOUTGSPNNVMUJQMFEPNBJOT"MTPSFDBMMUIBUEPNBJOUBYPOPNJFTDBOCF

SE Model Space

O

109

TMJDFEJOEJﬀFSFOUXBZT0OFXBZPGTMJDJOHJUJTCFUXFFO54BOE$4 BTXFEJEJOUIF$IBQUFS UBYPOPNZ8FXBOUUIFNPEFMTQBDFUPCFDBQBCMFPGTVQQPSUJOHUIBUUBYPOPNZ )PXEPXFTBUJTGZUIFTFSFRVJSFNFOUT 0VSBQQSPBDIJTUPVTFCBTJDQSJODJQMFTTVDIBTNPEV MBSJUZ XIJDIBMMPXTVTUPEFﬁOFTNBMMQJFDFTUIBUXFDBODPNCJOFJONVMUJQMFXBZT XIJDIHJWFT VTDPOTJEFSBCMFﬂFYJCJMJUZ8FXBOUUPJEFOUJGZUIFNBKPSWBSJBCMFTUIBUEJTUJOHVJTIBOETUSVDUVSF NPEFMTThFWBSJBCMFTXFTFMFDUFE BMPOHXJUIBUSBDFUPSFRVJSFNFOUTBOEBHFOFSBMNPUJWBUJPOGPS FBDIPOF BSFBTGPMMPXT $PNQPTJUJPOThFXIPMFoQBSUDPODFQU BOEUIFSFRVJSFNFOUUPNPEFMNVMUJMFWFMTZTUFNT MFBEUPUIFOPUJPOPGDPNQPTJUJPOPGQBSUTJOUPXIPMFTThFWBSJBCMFJTDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFM JOBNVMUJMFWFMDPOUFYUThJTFMFNFOUSFTQPOETEJSFDUMZUPSFRVJSFNFOU4VQQPSUTDBMFVQ BOETDBMFEPXOPGTZTUFNT BOENVMUJQMFTDBMFTJOBTJOHMFTZTUFN (FOFSBMNPUJWBUJPOGPSDPNQPTJUJPOXIPMFT QBSUT BOEFOWJSPONFOUTIBWFCFFOB SFDPHOJ[FEQBSUPG4&BOEFOHJOFFSJOHBOENPEFMJOHJOHFOFSBMGPSEFDBEFT/PXXJUIUIF FYQBOEFETDPQFPG4& FTQFDJBMMZTDBMFVQBOEEPXO UIFFYUFOTJPOUPBMBSHFSOVNCFSPG MFWFMTSFRVJSFTFWFONPSFGPDVTPOBOETVQQPSUGPSXIPMFoQBSUTUSVDUVSFT $PNNPOJ[BUJPO "OPUIFS LFZ OFFE JT EJTUJOHVJTIJOH TJNJMBSJUJFT GSPN EJﬀFSFODFT XIBU JTVOJRVFGSPNXIBUJTDPNNPO GPSXIJDIXFJOWPLFUIFDPODFQUTPGDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOBOE HFOFSBMJ[BUJPOTQFDJBMJ[BUJPO$BUFHPSJ[BUJPOUFMMTVTXIBUJTDPNNPOBNPOHBTFUPGJOEJ WJEVBMT(FOFSBMJ[BUJPOUFMMTXIBUJTDPNNPOBNPOHBTFUPGDBUFHPSJFTPSLJOET8FDPN CJOFUIFTFJOUPUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOWBSJBCMF"UBCBTJDMFWFM UIJTFMFNFOUSFTQPOETEJSFDUMZ UPSFRVJSFNFOU4VQQPSUCBMBODFPGDPNNPOBMJUZBOEWBSJBCJMJUZ'JOEFWFSZUIJOHJO DPNNPOCVUEPOPUGPSDFPOFTJ[FﬁUTBMMSFDPHOJ[FUIFJNQFSBUJWFBOECFOFﬁUTPGEJWFS TJUZ"UBIJHIFSMFWFM JUEJSFDUMZTVQQPSUTSFRVJSFNFOU'BDJMJUBUFJODPSQPSBUJPOBOEVTF PGLOPXMFEHFBOEFYQFSJFODF (FOFSBMNPUJWBUJPOGPSDPNNPOJ[BUJPOHFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUBQQMZUPNVMUJQMFTZT UFNT DMBTTFT BOE DBUFHPSJFT IBWF CFFO B TJHOJﬁDBOU FMFNFOU JO MFBSOJOH BDDVNVMBUJOH LOPXMFEHF BOEPSHBOJ[JOHBOESFDBMMJOHLOPXMFEHFGPSNBOZZFBST FWFODFOUVSJFT/PX XJUIUIFFYQBOTJPOPG4& UIJTEJNFOTJPOUBLFTPOBEEFETJHOJﬁDBODFCFDBVTF$4CSJOHT NPSFEJTDJQMJOFTBOENPSFNPEFMTUPUIFUBCMF8FOFFEBXBZUPDBQUVSFBMMUIJTDPN NPOBMJUZ BOEBUUIFTBNFUJNFBXBZUPDBQUVSFUIFEJﬀFSFODFTUIBUFYJTU $PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO $PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO PG B EPNBJO IBT UP EP XJUI XIBU UIJOHT FYJTU JO UIBU EPNBJO IPX UIFZ BSF SFMBUFE XIBU UIFZ NFBO BOE IPX XF DPNNVOJDBUF BCPVU UIFN#ZJUTOBUVSF 4&JTNVMUJMJOHVBMBOEIBTNVMUJQMFPOUPMPHJFTBOEVOJWFSTFTPGEJT DPVSTF 6%T ThFWBSJFUZPGBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTSFﬂFDUTBWBSJFUZPGMBOHVBHFTBOEPOUPM PHJFT UZQJDBMMZFWFOXJUIJOUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGPOFTZTUFN ThFSFGPSF XFOFFEBNPEFM TQBDFTUSVDUVSJOHWBSJBCMFUIBUTVQQPSUTBOEIFMQTNPEFMUIJTUZQFPGIFUFSPHFOFJUZThJT FMFNFOU SFTQPOET EJSFDUMZ UP SFRVJSFNFOU 4VQQPSU DMFBS DPNNVOJDBUJPO BNPOH BMM 4&TUBLFIPMEFSTCVUSFDPHOJ[FUIBUOPUBMMDMFBSDPNNVOJDBUJPOJTFYQMJDJUTVQQPSUCPUI FYQMJDJUBOEJNQMJDJUDPNNVOJDBUJPOp (FOFSBMNPUJWBUJPOGPSDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOXFIBWFIBEUIFOPUJPOPGEJﬀFSFOUMBO HVBHFTBOE6%TUISPVHIPVUUIFIJTUPSZPGFOHJOFFSJOHBOENBUIFNBUJDT JODMVEJOHUIF 4PNF PG UIFTF EJNFOTJPOT BOE BTTPDJBUFE HSBQIJDT XFSF QSFTFOUFE CZ % )ZCFSUTPO JO *OGPSNBUJDB

o p "MUIPVHIUIFNPEFMTQBDFJODMVEFTPOMZNPEFMT BOEBMMNPEFMTBSFFYQMJDJU DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOFYJTUTJODPOUFYUPGUIF

NPEFMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOSFMBUJPOEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS BOEUIFSFGPSFJOEJSFDUMZTVQQPSUTJNQMJDJUDPNNVOJDBUJPO

110 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

MBOHVBHFTPGUIFFOWJSPONFOUWFSTVTUIPTFPGUIFJOUFSOBMTZTUFNBOEUIPTFPGNBUIFNBUJ DBMNPEFMTBOEFOHJOFFSJOHBSUJGBDUTThJTIBTCFFOBOJNQPSUBOUBSFBUIBUIBTJODSFBTFE JOTJHOJﬁDBODFXJUIUIFSJTFPGPOUPMPHJFTJOUIFFOHJOFFSJOHBSFOB&OHJOFFSTXIPEFﬁOF NPEFMTUIBUBQQMZUPNVMUJQMFEPNBJOTNVTUCFBCMFUPUSBOTMBUFUIPTFNPEFMTJOUPUIF MBOHVBHFT PG UIPTF TQFDJﬁD EPNBJOT /PX XJUI UIF FYQBOEFE TDPQF PG 4& UIF HSFBUFS OVNCFSPGEJTDJQMJOFT BQQMJDBUJPOT BOETVQQPSUJOHTDJFODFTNBLFUIJTEJNFOTJPOFWFO NPSFJNQPSUBOUJOUIF4&NPEFMTQBDFPGUIFGVUVSF 5JNF.PEFMTBOETZTUFNTIBWFBMJGFTQBOJOXIJDIUIFZBSFDSFBUFE FYJTU DIBOHF BOE UFSNJOBUF8FOFFEBUJNFWBSJBCMFUPBDDPNNPEBUFDIBOHFBOEUPBEESFTTQBTUBOEGVUVSF FWPMVUJPO EJﬀFSFODFTPWFSUJNF BOESBUFTPGWPMBUJMJUZBOETUBCJMJUZThJTFMFNFOUSFTQPOET EJSFDUMZUPSFRVJSFNFOU4VQQPSUTDBMFVQBOETDBMFEPXOPGTZTUFNTBOENVMUJQMFTDBMFT JO B TJOHMF TZTUFN UP JODMVEF CPUI TQBUJBM BOE UFNQPSBM TDBMFT BOE UP SFRVJSFNFOU 4VQQPSUCBMBODFPGTUBCJMJUZBOEDIBOHF'JOEFWFSZUIJOHUIBUJTTUBCMFCVUEPOPUGPSDF GBMTFTUBCJMJUZSFDPHOJ[FUIFJNQFSBUJWFBOECFOFﬁUTPGDIBOHF (FOFSBM NPUJWBUJPO GPS UJNF DPODFQUT PG UJNF BOE DIBOHF BOE UFNQPSBM BOE EZOBNJDNPEFMT IBWFBMXBZTCFFOBQSPNJOFOUBTQFDUPGFOHJOFFSJOHBOETZTUFNTFOHJ OFFSJOH ThF FYQBOEFE 4& BOE JUT JODSFBTJOHMZ EZOBNJD FOWJSPONFOU POMZ JODSFBTF UIF OFFEGPSUIJTEJNFOTJPOJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF 7JFX8FOFFEUPMPPLBUDSPTTDVUUJOHJTTVFT BOEUPIBWFUIF ﬂeYJCJMJUZUPDPNCJOFJOUP POFFOUJUZPSWJFXBOZDPMMFDUJPOPGJUFNTGSPNBOZXIFSFJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFThJTFMF NFOUSFTQPOETEJSFDUMZUPSFRVJSFNFOU4VQQPSUNVMUJQMFWJFXTBOEQFSTQFDUJWFTPGB HJWFOTZTUFNPSDMBTTPGTZTUFNT

Model Space

Universal model

C – omm K – in on Ca ds iz at te io go n rie s

Model of individual system or component

Problem/ user domain

m

Solution domain

e

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Ti

Indivisible unit

Composition

Highest level system

Conceptualization – Language/notation – Universe of discourse

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

Figure 5.4 SE model space internal structure. (Source: Hybertson, D. A uniform component modeling space. Informatica, 25(4):475–482. Published by Slovenian Society Informatika. 2001. Used with permission.)

SE Model Space

O

111

(FOFSBMNPUJWBUJPOGPSWJFX0OFJNQPSUBOUNPUJWBUJPOGPSWJFXTJTUIBUJOHFOFSBM XFDBOOPUTFFPSVOEFSTUBOEFWFSZUIJOHPGJOUFSFTUBCPVUBTZTUFNJOPOFWJTVBMJ[BUJPOPS SFQSFTFOUBUJPO"OPUIFSNPUJWBUJPO XIJDIJTDPOTPOBOUXJUIUIFﬁSTU JTUIBUNPTUPCTFSW FSTPSTUBLFIPMEFSTBSFOPUJOUFSFTUFEJOFWFSZUIJOHBCPVUBTZTUFN CVUSBUIFSUIFUIJOHTPS GFBUVSFTSFMBUFEUPUIFJSDPODFSO"UIJSENPUJWBUJPOJTUIFOFFEGPSBGSFFGPSNDPOTUSVDU UIBUIBTUIFVODPOTUSBJOFEﬂFYJCJMJUZUPDVUBDSPTTBMMPUIFSEJNFOTJPOTBOEEFﬁOFBOZ TVCTQBDFPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFGPSPCTFSWBUJPOBOEFOHJOFFSJOHQVSQPTFT ThFDPNCJOBUJPOPGUIFTFﬁWFWBSJBCMFTSFTQPOETUPSFRVJSFNFOU#FﬂFYJCMF BEBQUBCMF BOE FYUFOTJCMF BOEFWPMWFBTOFFEFEThFWBSJBCMFTMFBEUPGPVSEJNFOTJPOTUIBUTUSVDUVSFUIFNPEFM TQBDF QMVTPOFGSFFGPSNDPODFQU WJFX UIBUDBODVUBDSPTTUIFTUSVDUVSF BTTIPXOJO'JHVSF The ﬁHVSFBMTPJOEJDBUFTBSBOHFPSTQFDUSVNGPSFBDIWBSJBCMF

Conceptual and Physical Space Models of physical systems often include parameters that designate the position or movement of those systems in classical three-dimensional (3D) space. In that context, discussions of space and time, or time as the fourth dimension, are also based on 3D classical physical space. In this book, however, the term “space,” especially in the context of the model space, means conceptual space. The model space has three conceptual dimensions, with time as the fourth dimension. It is pure coincidence that the number of conceptual dimensions in the model space is equal to the number of dimensions in classical physical space, and that time is the fourth dimension for both. Those models that parameterize physical space are of course included in the envisioned SE model space. Does that pose a contradiction? No, because they are conceptual models of physical systems. That is, the models position physical systems in physical space dimensions, while the model space positions the conceptual models in conceptual space dimensions. The physical space position of the physical system is important to the model but irrelevant to the model space. The model space cares about where the model is, not about where the modeled system is. Therefore, unless otherwise noted, in this book all discussions of space, or space versus time, are referring to the model space conceptual dimensions.

#FGPSFEFﬁOJOHUIFTFWBSJBCMFTGVSUIFS XFOFFEUPBDLOPXMFEHFUIBUUIFSFBSFBMBSHFOVNCFS PGQPUFOUJBMWBSJBCMFTUIBUDIBSBDUFSJ[FNPEFMTBOEUIBUUIFSFGPSFDPVMECFVTFEUPTUSVDUVSFUIF NPEFMTQBDF8FIBWFBUUFNQUFEUPEFﬁOFBiQBOUIFPOwPGTUSVDUVSJOHWBSJBCMFTUIBUBSFEPNJ OBOU VOJWFSTBM GVOEBNFOUBM BOETUBCMFJOUIFNPEFMJOHBOEFOHJOFFSJOHPGTZTUFNT&BDIPGUIF WBSJBCMFTPSEJNFOTJPOTESBXTEJSFDUMZGSPNBWBSJFUZPGEJTDJQMJOFTPWFSBMPOHQFSJPEPGUJNF FBDIIBTBWFSZTUSPOHQFEJHSFF BOEFBDIJTBTJHOJﬁDBOUGBDUPSJONPEFMJOHTZTUFNT4UJMM XIJDI WBSJBCMFTCFMPOHJOUIFQBOUIFPOJTDFSUBJOMZBNBUUFSPGEFCBUF"MUIPVHIXFCFMJFWFUIFWBSJBCMFT XFTFMFDUFEIBWFQSPWFEUIFJSHSBWJUBT UIBUEPFTOPUNFBOOFDFTTBSJMZUIBUUIFSFJTDPOTFOTVTPO UIJTTFU PSUIBUPUIFSTXJMMOPUCFBEEFEPWFSUJNF

112

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThFDPODFQUPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFEPFTOPUEFQFOEPOUIJTTFUPGWBSJBCMFTThFNPEFMTQBDF BOE UIF.04&4BQQSPBDI DPVMETVSWJWFDIBOHFTJOUIFTFU#VUJOUIFTDPQFPGUIJTCPPL UIJTJTUIF TFUXFVTFGPSEJTDVTTJPO

Composition ThFEFﬁOJUJPOPGTZTUFNDPOUBJOTXJUIJOJUUIFDPODFQUPGDPNQPTJUJPO"TZTUFNJTTPNFUIJOHPG JOUFSFTUBTBXIPMFBOEBTBTFUPGJOUFSSFMBUFEPSJOUFSBDUJOHQBSUT*ONPTUTZTUFNT FTQFDJBMMZUIPTF PGJOUFSFTUUP4& UIFQBSUTBSFBMTPTZTUFNTUIBU JOUVSO IBWFQBSUTThVT TZTUFNTUZQJDBMMZFYIJCJU BXIPMFoQBSUIJFSBSDIZ BOEUIJTFYUFOEFETQFDUSVNPGXIPMFTBOEQBSUTGPSNTUIFDPNQPTJUJPO EJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFi4ZTUFNwBOEiDPNQPOFOUwDBOCFVTFEBTSFMBUJWFUFSNT"TZTUFN BUPOFMFWFMNBZCFBDPNQPOFOUPGBOPUIFSTZTUFNBUUIFOFYUIJHIFSMFWFM BOEUIFTBNFSFMBUJPOT SFQFBUBUFBDIMFWFMThFIPMPOTBOEIPMBSDIJFTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFSTBOESFTJEFJOUIJTEJNFO TJPOThVT CPUITUSVDUVSF XIPMFoQBSU BOEEZOBNJDCFIBWJPS JOUFSBDUJOHQBSUT BSFJNQPSUBOU FMFNFOUTPGUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPO ThF DPNQPTJUJPO EJNFOTJPO JT DIBSBDUFSJ[FE CZ B HFOFSBM SFDVSTJWF QBUUFSO PG DPNQPTJUJPO MFWFMTUIBUCSJOHTUIFJNQPSUBOU4&EJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOJOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBMJOUPQMBZ"UFBDI MFWFM BOFYUFSOBMWJFXPGBXIPMFJTEFDPNQPTFEJOUPBOJOUFSOBMWJFXUIBUJODMVEFTUIFFYUFSOBM WJFXTPGJUTQBSUT BTTIPXOJO'JHVSF*OUVSO FBDIPGUIFTFFYUFSOBMWJFXTJTEFDPNQPTFEJOUP BOJOUFSOBMWJFXThFQBUUFSOJTBOJOUFSUXJOJOHPGFYUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBMWJFXTThFFYUFSOBMWJFX

External = black box view Internal = clear box view

Internal model of A

A

The internal model of a system (A) includes the external model of each of its components (B, ...) - or The architecture of a system (A) includes the requirements of each of its components (B,...)

B

p2

r1

N1

p1

C

r3

p4

N3

N4

p3

r4

D

r5

N2

p5

E

r7

r6

External model of D B, N3, D, etc. are one level of composition lower than A; this intertwining relation supports scaling to all composition levels

Figure 5.5 Intertwining composition structure. (Source: Hybertson, D. Using a speciﬁcation approach to facilitate component testing. In Testing Commercial-off-the-Shelf Components and Systems, S. Beydeda and V. Gruhn, Eds. New York: Springer-Verlag, p. 213–237. 2005. Used with permission of Springer Science + Business Media.)

SE Model Space

O

113

DPSSFTQPOETOPNJOBMMZUPXIBUXFPGUFODBMMSFRVJSFNFOUT BOEUIFJOUFSOBMWJFXDPSSFTQPOETUP XIBUXFPGUFODBMMBSDIJUFDUVSFPSEFTJHO TheJOUFSUXJOJOHOBUVSFPGJOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBMNPEFMTJOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPOBMMPXT UIFTBNFUZQFTPGNPEFMTBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOJOGPSNBUJPOUPFYJTUBUFWFSZDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFM SBUIFS UIBOEFﬁOJOHBEJﬀFSFOULJOEBUFBDIMFWFMThJTSFQSFTFOUTBTJHOJﬁDBOUTJNQMJﬁDBUJPOPGTQFDJﬁDB UJPOUZQFTGSPNNVMUJQMFUSBEJUJPOBMUZQFTEPXOUPUXPUZQFTFYUFSOBMTQFDBOEJOUFSOBMTQFD

Commonization 8IFSFBTUIFQSJNBSZEJTUJODUJPOUIBUHFOFSBUFTDPNQPTJUJPOTUSVDUVSFTJTXIPMFWFSTVTQBSU UIF QSJNBSZEJTUJODUJPOUIBUHFOFSBUFTDPNNPOJ[BUJPOTUSVDUVSFTJTTJNJMBSJUZWFSTVTEJﬀFSFODF $PNNPOJ[BUJPOJTBDSJUFSJPOGPSBCTUSBDUJPOJOXIJDIUIFSFMFWBOUJOGPSNBUJPOJTXIBUJTDPN NPOBNPOHBTFUPGFOUJUJFT$PNNPOPSHFOFSBMNPEFMTBSFVTFGVMJONVMUJQMFFOWJSPONFOUT0OF FOWJSPONFOUJTUIFNPEFMTQBDFJUTFMGThJTEJNFOTJPOFOBCMFTUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDF BOEEJTUJO HVJTIFTCFUXFFOUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDF HFOFSBMNPEFMT BOEUIFXPSLTQBDF TQFDJﬁDNPEFMT (FOFSBMNPEFMTJODMVEFDPOWFOUJPOBMEFTJHOTJOFOHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLT DPNQMFYTZTUFNNPE FMTTVDIBTFWPMVUJPOBOEQSFEBUPSQSFZNPEFMTUIBUBQQMZUPNVMUJQMFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT EPNBJO UBYPOPNJFT BSDIJUFDUVSF GSBNFXPSLT FOHJOFFSJOH QBUUFSOT TUBOEBSET UFNQMBUFT BSDIJUFDUVSF TUZMFT SFGFSFODFBSDIJUFDUVSFT QSPEVDUMJOFT BCTUSBDUEBUBUZQFT BOEDMBTTFTJODMBTTIJFSBSDIJFT ThFJNQPSUBODFPGHFOFSBMNPEFMTJTUIBUUIFZNBLFFOHJOFFSJOHFﬃcJFOUBOEFﬀFDUJWF BOEUIFZ NBLFTDJFODFQPTTJCMF8JUIPVUUIFDPNNPOBMJUZDBQUVSFEBOEFYQMPJUFECZHFOFSBMNPEFMT XFXPVME CFGPSDFEUPDPOTJEFSFWFSZOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFN FWFSZQSPCMFNBOETPMVUJPO BTVOJRVF8F XPVMEIBWFOPTDJFOUJﬁDMBXT BOEOPDBUFHPSJFTPSUBYPOPNJFT CFDBVTFXFXPVMEIBWFUPUSFBUFBDI JOEJWJEVBM FBDIBUPN DFMM IVNBO USFF BOEQMBOFUBTVOJRVF XJUIJUTPXOQSPQFSUJFTBOECFIBWJPS &BDIFOHJOFFSJOHFﬀPSUXPVMETUBSUGSPNBDMFBOTMBUF8FDPVMEOPUMFBSOIPXUPEFTJHOBOECVJMEB OFXBJSDSBGUGSPNXIBUXFMFBSOFECZCVJMEJOHFBSMJFSBJSDSBGUCFDBVTFUIFZIBWFOPUIJOHJODPNNPO 'PSUVOBUFMZ B WFSZ MBSHF BNPVOU PG DPNNPOBMJUZ FYJTUT JO CPUI OBUVSBM TZTUFNT BOE FOHJ OFFSFETZTUFNT(FOFSBMNPEFMTDBQUVSFUIBUDPNNPOBMJUZThFHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVNBMMPXT NPEFMTPGWBSZJOHMFWFMTPGHFOFSBMJUZUPCFEFﬁOFE

Conceptualization &BDINPEFMJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFJTSFQSFTFOUFEJOTPNFOPUBUJPOPSMBOHVBHF PSDPNCJOBUJPOPG MBOHVBHFT BOESFQSFTFOUTBEPNBJOPSVOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTFThFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPO SBOHFTGSPNNPEFMTJOUIFMBOHVBHFTPSOPUBUJPOTPGQSPCMFNEPNBJOT TVDIBTCBOLJOHPSBJSDSBGU DPOUSPM UPNPEFMTJOUIFBCTUSBDUOPUBUJPOTPGNBUIFNBUJDT BOEJOUIFDBTFPGTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFS JOH MBOHVBHFTPGIBSEXBSFQSPDFTTPST$PSSFTQPOEJOHUPUIFSFQSFTFOUBUJPOEJﬀFSFODFTBSFEJﬀFS FODFTJODPODFQUTPSPOUPMPHJFT'PSFYBNQMF JOUIFCBOLJOHEPNBJO LFZDPODFQUTBSFBDDPVOU XJUIESBX EFQPTJU CBMBODF BOEUSBOTGFS*OUIFHFPTQBUJBMEPNBJO LFZDPODFQUTBSFNBQ DPOUPVS FMFWBUJPO GFBUVSF UIFNBUJD MBZFS BOE QSPKFDUJPO *O UIF BJSDSBGU DPOUSPM EPNBJO LFZ DPODFQUT BSFGSFRVFODZSFTQPOTF USBOTGFSGVODUJPO GFFECBDL BJSGSBNF FRVJMJCSJVN BOEWFIJDMFNPUJPO *OUIFDPNQVUFSQSPDFTTPSEPNBJO LFZDPODFQUTBSFMPBE TUPSF BEE CSBODI NFNPSZBEESFTT BOESFHJTUFSThFDPNQVUFSQSPDFTTPSVTFTUIJTCBTJDTFUPGDPODFQUTUPTPMWFQSPCMFNTJOCBOLJOH "NPSFDPNQMFUFNBQQJOHJTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS

114

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

HFPTQBUJBMJOGPSNBUJPO BJSDSBGUDPOUSPM BOEBMMPUIFSQSPCMFNEPNBJOT/PUFUIBUXFVOEFSTUBUFE UIFEJTUBODFCFUXFFOUIFDPNQVUFSBOEQSPCMFNEPNBJOTCFDBVTFXFEFTDSJCFEUIFDPODFQUTJOBMM UIFTFEPNBJOTVTJOHUIFTBNFMBOHVBHF&OHMJTICVUFWFOTP UIFDPODFQUVBMEJTUBODFCFUXFFO UIFNJTMBSHFThVT UXPNPEFMTDBOSFQSFTFOUUXPEJﬀFSFOUVOJWFSTFTPGEJTDPVSTFBOECFSFQSF TFOUFEJOUIFTBNFMBOHVBHF$POWFSTFMZ UXPNPEFMTDBOCFSFQSFTFOUFEJOEJﬀFSFOUMBOHVBHFT BOEEFTDSJCFUIFTBNFVOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTF 5XPQSJNBSZSFMBUJPOTCFUXFFONPEFMT XIJDIPGUFOPDDVSJOQBSBMMFM JOUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[B UJPOEJNFOTJPOBSF USBOTMBUJPOGSPNPOFMBOHVBHFUPBOPUIFSBOE USBOTGPSNBUJPOGSPNPOF VOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTFUPBOPUIFS"VOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTFJTUIFTFUPGDPODFQUTUPXIJDIUIFXPSET PGBMBOHVBHFSFGFS"DPNNPOFYBNQMFJTUSBOTMBUJPOBOEUSBOTGPSNBUJPOGSPNUIFMBOHVBHFBOE VOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTFPGVTFSTUPBEFTJHOMBOHVBHFTVDIBT4ZT.-PS4QFDJﬁDBUJPOBOE%FTDSJQUJPO -BOHVBHF 4%-

BOE UIFO UP B NBUIFNBUJDBM GPSN TVDI BT EJﬀFSFOUJBM FRVBUJPOT PS EJﬀFSFODF FRVBUJPOT"OFYBNQMFPGTPGUXBSFTZTUFNNPEFMUSBOTMBUJPOTQSPCMFNEPNBJOOPUBUJPOBOEDPO DFQUTUPGPSNBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOUP6.-UP+BWBUPCJOBSZNBDIJOFMBOHVBHF *OUIFNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZXPSMEPG4& FWFOEJﬀFSFOUDPNQPOFOUTPGUIFTBNFTZTUFNDBODPNF GSPNEJﬀFSFOUVOJWFSTFTPGEJTDPVSTF'PSBOFYBNQMFHJWFOFBSMJFS BDPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGU UIFBQQMJDB UJPOEPNBJOJTUSBOTQPSUBUJPO ThFJOUFSOBMQBSUTSFQSFTFOUEPNBJOTUIBUJODMVEFQPXFSTZTUFNT BJS GSBNFEFTJHO DPNNVOJDBUJPOT OBWJHBUJPO ﬂJHIUDPOUSPM DPNQVUFSIBSEXBSFBOETPGUXBSFTZTUFNT IZESBVMJDT BOENBOZPUIFST&BDIPGUIFTFIBTJUTPXOVOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTF "UIJSESFMBUJPOJTTFNBOUJDT XIJDIJTBNBQQJOHPSJOUFSQSFUBUJPOPGBNPEFMJOUPBOPUIFS NPEFMGPSFYBNQMF JOUFSQSFUJOHBGPSNBMNPEFMJOUPBOBQQMJDBUJPONPEFM"HJWFONPEFMDBO IBWFNVMUJQMFJOUFSQSFUBUJPOT 'JHVSFTIPXTUIFTFNBOUJDSBOHFPGDPODFQUTBOEVOJWFSTFTPGEJTDPVSTFPGTZTUFNTBOE NPEFMTJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFDPOUFYUThFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOIBTJUTVOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTFJOUIF QSPCMFNTQBDFThFTPMVUJPOTQBDFBOENPEFMTQBDFOFFEUPBEESFTTUIBUBQQMJDBUJPOVOJWFSTF BU MFBTUJOUFSNTPGFYUFSOBMWJFXTPGUIFTPMVUJPOThFNPEFMTBOEJOUFSOBMTPMVUJPOTJOUIFNPEFM TQBDFBOETPMVUJPOTQBDFUZQJDBMMZBEEPUIFSVOJWFSTFTPGEJTDPVSTFUIBUFYUFOEUIFTFNBOUJDSBOHF GBSCFZPOEUIFQSPCMFNTQBDF BTEFTDSJCFEBCPWF Semantic range Problem/environment space Model/description space External

Internal

Solution/system space

Problem space: Semantics of environments in which engineered systems are needed Model space: Semantics of models ranging from problem space (typically external models of the system) to solution models (typically internal models of the system) that are far removed from problem space Solution space: Semantics of solution/system ranging from problem space (typically externally visible) to elements of solution space that are far removed from problem space (typically internal)

Figure 5.6

Semantic range view of model space and its context.

SE Model Space

O

115

Time 8IJMFUIFPUIFSUISFFEJNFOTJPOTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFBSFSFHBSEFEBTTUSVDUVSBMPSTUBUJD UJNFJT UIFUFNQPSBMPSEZOBNJDEJNFOTJPOThFBTQFDUPGUJNFUIBUNPUJWBUFTUIJTEJNFOTJPOJTDIBOHF 8F CFMJFWF UIBU USBEJUJPOBM TZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH IBT HJWFO JOTVﬃcJFOU BUUFOUJPO UP DIBOHF JO TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTFTBOEJOUIFBTTVNQUJPOTBCPVUFOHJOFFSFETZTUFNTBOEUIFJSFOWJSPO NFOUT.04&4BTTVNFTDPOUJOVBMDIBOHFBTUIFOPSN OPUUIFFYDFQUJPOThJTTUBODFSFﬂFDUTUIF JODMVTJPOPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNTJO4&"OJNQPSUBOUGFBUVSFPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNTJTDIBOHF SFﬂFDUFE JOHSPXUI MFBSOJOH BEBQUBUJPO BOEBUBQPQVMBUJPOMFWFM FWPMVUJPO 0OFWJFXPGUIFUJNFEJNFOTJPOJTBSBOHFPGBCTPMVUFPSFMBQTFEUJNFThFDPODFQUPGMJGF TQBOFYJTUTJOUIJTWJFX'PSFYBNQMF BTZTUFNIBTBMJGFTQBO"NFDIBOJDBMTZTUFNJOUSBEJUJPOBM UFSNTIBTBQFSJPEPGEFWFMPQNFOU GPMMPXFECZPQFSBUJPO SFUJSFNFOU PSUFSNJOBUJPO"OPSHBOJD TZTUFNIBTBMJGFTQBOUIBUQSPDFFETGSPNCJSUIUPHSPXUIUPNBUVSJUZUPEFDMJOFUPEFBUI$IBQUFS TIPXTBDPNCJOFEMJGFTQBOWJFXDPOTJTUJOHPGGPSNBUJPO NBUVSBUJPO BOEGVMMGVODUJPOJOH"O BMUFSOBUJWFUPMJOFBSUJNFJTUIFDPODFQUPGDZDMFT BMTPEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS "OPUIFSWJFXPGUIJTEJNFOTJPOJTBSBOHFPSEFHSFFPGDIBOHF&MFNFOUTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF FYQFSJFODF B XIPMF TQFDUSVN PG DIBOHF BDSPTT NVMUJQMF UJNF TDBMFT GSPN WFSZ SBQJE DPOUJOVBM DIBOHFUPWFSZTMPXDIBOHFPS JOUIFFYUSFNF OPDIBOHFBUBMM " UIJSE WJFX JT DPODFSOFE XJUI EZOBNJD QSPDFTTFT .04&4 EFﬁOFT TFWFSBM DBUFHPSJFT PG EZOBNJD QSPDFTTFT JODMVEJOH EZOBNJD CFIBWJPS FYIJCJUFE CZ FOHJOFFSFE TZTUFNT DIBOHF BOE NBUVSBUJPOPGFOHJOFFSFETZTUFNT DIBOHFPGNPEFMT BOENPEFMTPGUIFQSPDFTTPGDPMMFDUJWFBDUV BMJ[BUJPOThFMBUUFSJTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFSThFPUIFSTBSFEJTDVTTFEBTMFWFMTPGDIBOHFJO $IBQUFS XIJDIEJTDVTTFTUIFUJNFEJNFOTJPOJONPSFEFQUI

View ThFDPODFQUPGWJFXJTBOJNQPSUBOUBOEﬂFYJCMFUPPMJO.04&4*OGPSNBMMZ BWJFXJTBQPSUJPOPG POFPSNPSFNPEFMT PSBOBTQFDUPGPOFPSNPSFTZTUFNTQFSDFJWFEBTCFJOHVTFGVMGPSTPNFQVSQPTF "WJFXEPFTOPUFYJTUJOJTPMBUJPO*UFYJTUTXJUISFTQFDUUPBUIJOHCFJOHWJFXFE XIJDIXFDBMMUIF UBSHFUPSPCKFDUPGUIFWJFX ThFUBSHFUDBOCFNPSFPSMFTTBOZPOUPMPHJDBMFMFNFOUJO4& JODMVEJOH BOPUIFSWJFX BSFHJPO PSBDPMMFDUJPOPGUIJOHTCVUNPTUPGUFOJOPVSEJTDVTTJPOTUIFUBSHFUXJMMCF BNPEFMPSBTZTUFN"WJFXJTBOBCTUSBDUJPOPG PSBTVCTFUPGJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVU JUTUBSHFU "MTPBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBWJFXJTBWJFXQPJOU XIJDIJTBQPJOUJOBQIZTJDBMPSDPODFQUVBMTQBDFUJNF SFHJPOGSPNXIJDIBWJFXJTPCTFSWFE7JFXQPJOUDBSSJFTXJUIJUBOJNQMJDBUJPOPGBOPCTFSWFSPSB TUBLFIPMEFS BOFOUJUZUIBUPCTFSWFTUIFWJFX5ZQJDBMMZ UIFJOGPSNBUJPOUIBUDPOTUJUVUFTUIFWJFXJT EFﬁOFEPOUIFCBTJTPGUIFJOUFSFTUTPSDPODFSOTPGBOPCTFSWFSPSTUBLFIPMEFS PSBDMBTTPGPCTFSWFST 5XPJNQPSUBOUSFRVJSFNFOUTGPSBWJFXBSF TFQBSBUJPOBOE JOUFHSBUJPOThFTFTPVOE TPNFXIBUDPOUSBEJDUPSZCVUCPUINVTUCFUSVF*UJTTFMGFWJEFOUUIBUBWJFXNVTUCFTFQBSBCMF GSPNUIFSFTUPGUIFJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUJUTUBSHFUThBUJT BGUFSBMM UIFQSJNBSZNPUJWBUJPOGPS EFﬁOJOHBWJFX#VUBWJFXNVTUBMTPCFJOUFHSBUFEXJUIUIFSFTUPGUIFJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUJUTUBS HFU*OBNJOJNBMTFOTF BHJWFOQJFDFPGJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUBUBSHFUNVTUCFDPOTJTUFOUJOBMMWJFXT UIBUJODMVEFJU*OBCSPBEFSTFOTF UIFJOGPSNBUJPOJODMVEFEJOBMMWJFXTPGUIFTBNFUBSHFUNVTU GPSNBDPOTJTUFOUJOUFHSBUFEDPIFSFOUXIPMFCFDBVTFUIFUPUBMTFUPGJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUUIFUBSHFU NVTUCFDPOTJTUFOUBOEDPIFSFOU ThFXBZWJFXTUSFBUTFQBSBUJPOBOEJOUFHSBUJPOJTPOFFYBNQMFPGBOJNQPSUBOUVTFPGWJFXT JO.04&4 OBNFMZUIBUPGTVQQPSUJOHBOESFDPODJMJOHDPOUSBTUT DPOUSBEJDUJPOT BOEEVBMJUJFT DPNNPOGFBUVSFTPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNT. ThJTBTQFDUPGWJFXTJTEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJO$IBQUFS

116

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

&YBNQMFTPGIPXWJFXTIBWFCFFOVTFEJOFOHJOFFSJOHBOECVJMEJOHBSDIJUFDUVSFJODMVEFESBX JOHTGSPNEJﬀFSFOUQFSTQFDUJWFT*OJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNT EBUBCBTFWJFXTBOEBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFXT BSFDPNNPOMZVTFE*O.04&4 UIFDPODFQUJTHJWFOJODSFBTFEFNQIBTJTBOESFHBSEFEBTBDPSF FMFNFOUThFBQQSPBDIJTUPEFﬁOFBDPNNPOTUBSUFSTFUPGWJFXTBOEEFﬁOFBOFYUFOTJCMFNFUIPE GPSEFﬁOJOHBEEJUJPOBMWJFXTBTOFFEFE 7JFXTBQQFBSJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFTUSVDUVSFJOTFWFSBMXBZT'JSTU FBDIEJNFOTJPOJTBEJﬀFSFOU WJFXThBUJT UIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGBTZTUFNJOWPMWFTFMFNFOUTPG DPNQPTJUJPO UIFVTFPGHFO FSBMBOETQFDJﬁDNPEFMT WBSJPVTMBOHVBHFTBOEVOJWFSTFTPGEJTDPVSTF BOE NPEFMTPGUJNF DIBOHF BOEQSPDFTTFT&BDIPGUIFGPVSEJNFOTJPOTJTBWJFXUIBUTVQQPSUTTFQBSBUFDPOTJEFSBUJPO PGPOFPGUIFTFBSFBTPGDPODFSO XIJMFBUUIFTBNFUJNFSFDPHOJ[JOHUIBUUIFGPVSBSFBTGPSNB VOJﬁFEXIPMF 4FDPOE XFDBOEFﬁOFWJFXTXJUIJOFBDIEJNFOTJPO'PSFYBNQMF JOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFO TJPO XFDBOGPDVTPOBTFMFDUFETFUPGMFWFMT XIJDIJTBWJFXPGUIFGVMMTFUPGDPNQPTJUJPOMFW FMT"LFZEJTUJODUJPOJOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPOJTUIBUCFUXFFOFYUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBMWJFXT XIPTFJOUFSUXJOJOHTUSVDUVSFHFOFSBUFTNVMUJMFWFMDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIJFT*OUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPO EJNFOTJPO XFDBOEFﬁOFBWJFXBTTFMFDUFEMFWFMTPGBDMBTTPSUBYPOPNZIJFSBSDIZ PSXFDBOGPDVT POBDMBTTTVCDMBTTWJFXWFSTVTBDBUFHPSZJOEJWJEVBMWJFX ThJSE BOEQFSIBQTNPTUJNQPSUBOUMZ XFDBOEFﬁOFWJFXTUIBUDVUBDSPTTUIFGPVSNPEFMTQBDF EJNFOTJPOT0OFDPNNPOFYBNQMFJTUIFTFUPGNPEFMTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBHJWFOTZTUFNThFTFNPE FMTDVUBDSPTTBMMGPVSEJNFOTJPOT"OPUIFSFYBNQMFJTBTQFDUT XIJDIBSFDSPTTDVUUJOHDPODFSOT UIBUBSFOBUVSBMMZEFﬁOFEJOUFSNTPGWJFXT&YBNQMFTPGBTQFDUTJODMVEFFSSPSIBOEMJOH TFDVSJUZ BOETBGFUZ

Relations among Dimensions 8F IBWF TFQBSBUFMZ JOUSPEVDFE FBDI EJNFOTJPO PG UIF NPEFM TQBDF XIJDI NFBOT XF IBWF EJT DVTTFEUIFTFQBSBUJPOBTQFDUPGFBDIEJNFOTJPOBTBWJFX8FOPXEJTDVTTTPNFPGUIFJOUFHSBUJPO BOEVOJﬁDBUJPOBTQFDUTPGUIFEJNFOTJPOT "OZHJWFONPEFMPDDVQJFTBQPJOU BMJOF PSBSFHJPO %PS% JOUIFNPEFMTQBDF JOUIBUJU JTQPTJUJPOFETPNFXIFSFBMPOHUIFTQFDUSVNPGFBDIEJNFOTJPO"NPEFMSFQSFTFOUTPOFPSNPSF DPNQPTJUJPO MFWFMT TPNFXIFSF JO UIF DPNQPTJUJPO EJNFOTJPO POF PS NPSF HFOFSBMJ[BUJPOT PS DBUFHPSJ[BUJPOMFWFMTTPNFXIFSFJOUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOBMBOHVBHFQPJOUPOUIFDPO DFQUVBMJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPO BOEPOFPSNPSFQPJOUTJOUJNFPOUIFUJNFEJNFOTJPO'VSUIFSNPSF XIJMFXFEPOPUDMBJNUIBUUIFGPVSEJNFOTJPOTBSFNVUVBMMZPSUIPHPOBM JF JOEFQFOEFOUPG FBDIPUIFS

XFEPDMBJNUIBUNPEFMTDBOWBSZTFQBSBUFMZBMPOHUIFGPVSEJNFOTJPOT'PSFYBNQMF UXPNPEFMTDBOCFBUUIFTBNFQPTJUJPOPOUISFFPGUIFEJNFOTJPOTBOEEJﬀFSPOUIFGPVSUIPOF 4PNFSFMBUJPOTBNPOHEJNFOTJPOTBSFDPNNPOMZSFDPHOJ[FE0OFSFMBUJPOJTUIBUBUSBOTGPSNB UJPOPGPOFNPEFMUPBOPUIFSPGUFOJOWPMWFTBTJNVMUBOFPVTUSBOTMBUJPOUPBEJﬀFSFOUMBOHVBHFBOE BEFDPNQPTJUJPOJOUPQBSUT"OPUIFSJTUIBUBHFOFSBMNPEFMJTPGUFOBUBIJHIDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFM BOEBTQFDJﬁDNPEFMJTPGUFOBUBMPXDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFM*OGBDU XFUFOEUPUIJOLUIBUEFTDSJQ UJPOTPGMBSHFTZTUFNTBSFOBUVSBMMZHFOFSBMBOEEFTDSJQUJPOTPGTNBMMDPNQPOFOUTBSFOBUVSBMMZ TQFDJﬁc 0UIFSSFMBUJPOTBNPOHEJNFOTJPOTBSFMFTTDPNNPOMZSFDPHOJ[FE0OFJTUIBUBNPEFMDBO CFHFOFSBMBOEBUBMPXMFWFMPOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOTQFDUSVN"OFYBNQMFJTUIFRVBOUVNNPEFM PGBUPNTUIBUEFTDSJCFTSVMFTDPODFSOJOHBUPNJDPSCJUBMTThJTNPEFMJTHFOFSBMCFDBVTFUIFTBNF SVMFT BQQMZ UP BUPNT PG BMM FMFNFOUT XIJDI NFBOT UIBU UIF SVMFT BQQMZ UP BMM BUPNT PO &BSUI BOE QSFTVNBCMZ UP BMM BUPNT JO UIF VOJWFSTF ThBU JT GBJSMZ HFOFSBM "OPUIFS MFTT DPNNPOMZ

SE Model Space

O

117

SFDPHOJ[FESFMBUJPOJTUIBUBNPEFMDBOCFTQFDJﬁDBOEBUBIJHIMFWFMPOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOTQFDUSVN 'PSFYBNQMF XFDBOTQFDJGZJOEFUBJMUIFJOUFSGBDFTPSQVCMJDBDDFTTQPJOUTPGBMBSHFPSHBOJ[BUJPO 8FEFMJCFSBUFMZDBMMPVUUIFTFUXPSFMBUJPOTCFDBVTFJO.04&4JUJTJNQPSUBOUUPFYQMPJUUIFBCJMJUZ UPIBWFCPUIHFOFSBMBOETQFDJﬁDNPEFMTBUBMMMFWFMTPGUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPO 3FMBUJPOTIJQTBNPOHUIFEJNFOTJPOTDBOCFEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJGXFMPPLCBDLBU'JHVSF*O UIFNPEFMTQBDFEPNBJOTCPY BTFUPGﬁWFNPEFMTPOUIFMFGUTJEFNBQTJOUPBTFUPGUISFFNPEFMT ThFOPOUIFSJHIUTJEF BTFUPGUISFFNPEFMTNBQTJOUPBTFUPGﬁWFNPEFMTThFﬁWFNPEFMTPOCPUI TJEFTDPSSFTQPOEUPNPEFMTPGQSPCMFNTBOE FYUFSOBM TPMVUJPOT SFTQFDUJWFMZ JOﬁWFDPSSFTQPOEJOH BQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTThJTNBQQJOHIBTNFBOJOHTJNVMUBOFPVTMZJOUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPO DPODFQ UVBMJ[BUJPO BOEDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPOTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF O *O UIF DPNNPOJ[BUJPO EJNFOTJPO JU SFQSFTFOUT UIF USBOTGPSNBUJPO PG SFMBUJWFMZ OBSSPXMZ EFﬁOFENPEFMTPGFBDISFMBUJWFMZIPNPHFOFPVTBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO XIFSFFBDINPEFMIBTB SFHJPOPGNPEFTUTJ[F UPUIFNPSFCSPBEMZEFﬁOFENVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZNPEFMTPGUIF4&NPEFM TQBDF XIFSFBUMFBTUTPNFNPEFMTIBWFBSFHJPOPGHSFBUFSTJ[F&YBNQMFTBSFNBUIFNBUJDBM FRVBUJPOT TPGUXBSFQSPHSBNT BOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNNPEFMT XFBSFOPUBTTVNJOHIFSFUIBU UIFTFBSFUISFFEJTKPJOUTFUT FH BHJWFODPNQMFYTZTUFNNPEFMNBZCFBNBUIFNBUJDBMFRVB UJPOSFQSFTFOUFEJOTPGUXBSF

BMMPGXIJDIDBOBQQMZUPNVMUJQMFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT O *OUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPO UIFNBQQJOHSFQSFTFOUTUSBOTMBUJPOGSPNBQQMJDBUJPO EPNBJOMBOHVBHFTUPNPEFMJOHEPNBJOMBOHVBHFT PSUSBOTGPSNBUJPOGSPNB6%PGUIF BQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOUPB6%PGUIFNPEFMJOHEPNBJO PSCPUI&YBNQMF'SPNBEFTJSFE CFIBWJPSNPEFMPGBOBJSDSBGUUPBTFUPGEJﬀFSFOUJBMFRVBUJPOTUIBUDIBSBDUFSJ[FTUIFNPWF NFOUBOEGPSDFPGSJHJECPEJFTUISPVHIBNFEJVN&YBNQMF'SPNBNPEFMPGCBOLJOH USBOTBDUJPOTUPBGPSNBMBOEHFOFSBMUSBOTBDUJPONPEFMJOBMPHJDMBOHVBHF O *OUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPO XFEFDPNQPTFUIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOQSPCMFNJOUPQBSUT .PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ XFEFﬁOFFYUFSOBMNPEFMTPGUIFEFTJSFETZTUFN BOEUIFOEFﬁOFJOUFS OBMNPEFMTPGUIFEFTJSFETZTUFN BOEFYUFSOBMNPEFMTPGFBDIQBSU

Model Space Implementation ThFJNQMFNFOUBUJPOEJTDVTTJPOJOUIJTTFDUJPODPOTJTUTPGUISFFQBSUT DPOUFOU NBOBHFNFOU BOE FYJTUJOHSFQPTJUPSJFT

Content: Models "OJNQPSUBOUQBSUJUJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFXBTEJTDVTTFEFBSMJFSUIFHFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUSFQSFTFOU UIF4&#P,WFSTVTUIFTFUPGNPEFMTPGTQFDJﬁDTZTUFNT XIFSFFBDIQSPKFDUJTDIBSBDUFSJ[FEBTB XPSLTQBDF5PIFMQVOEFSTUBOENPEFMTQBDFDPOUFOU XFﬁSTUEJTDVTTUIFWJTJPOPGUIF4&NPEFM TQBDFPGUIFGVUVSFBOEUIFOBTTFTTXIFSF4&JTSFMBUJWFUPUIJTWJTJPO

The Vision ThF NPEFM TQBDF DPOTJTUT PG NPEFMT BDSPTT UIF GVMM TDPQF PG 4& ThJT JODMVEFT BMM BQQMJDBUJPO EPNBJOTBOEFYUFSOBMTPMVUJPOEPNBJOTBMMJOUFSOBMTPMVUJPOEPNBJOTBMMTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT BUBMMMFWFMTPGDPNQPTJUJPOBOEDPNNPOJ[BUJPO JOBMMDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOTSFRVJSFE JOBWBSJFUZPG

118 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

MBOHVBHFTJODMVEJOHWJTVBM DPNQVUBUJPOBM BOENBUIFNBUJDBM BUBOZQPJOUJOUJNFPSBOZUJNF SBOHFBMMWJFXTQSPQFSUJFTPGNPEFMTBOETZTUFNTSFMBUJPOTBNPOHNPEFMTBOEJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVU NPEFMTThFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFGPSBOZBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOJODMVEFTUIFNPEFMTGSPNCPUIOBUVSBM BOEBSUJﬁDJBMTVQQPSUJOHTDJFODFTGPSUIBUEPNBJO 'PVS TUBUFT PG BﬀBJST FYJTU JO UIF QBUI GSPN UIF NPTU USBEJUJPOBM GPSN PG LOPXMFEHF UP UIF HPBMTUBUFPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF'JSTUJTLOPXMFEHFJOUIFGPSNPGQBQFS TVDIBTCPPLTBOEKPVSOBMT 4FDPOEJTUIFMPBEJOHPGUIFLOPXMFEHFJOUPBEJHJUBMSFQPTJUPSZ BMCFJUTUJMMJOUIFJNBHFPGUIF PSJHJOBMCPPLPSKPVSOBMBSUJDMFThJSEJTUIFQBSTJOHPGUIBULOPXMFEHFJOUPJOEJWJEVBMVOJUTBOE EFﬁOJOHSFMBUJPOTBNPOHUIFVOJUT'PVSUIUIFHPBMTUBUFJTFYQSFTTJOHUIFLOPXMFEHFJOUIF GPSNPGNPEFMTUIBUDBOCFFYFDVUFEPSTFNBOUJDBMMZBOBMZ[FE"OFYBNQMFPGUIFUIJSETUBUFJT UIF%0034 %ZOBNJD0CKFDU0SJFOUFE3FRVJSFNFOUT4ZTUFN UPPMGPSNBOBHJOHSFRVJSFNFOUT %0034TFQBSBUFTBOENBOBHFTFBDIJOEJWJEVBMSFRVJSFNFOUTUBUFNFOUBOEUIFSFMBUJPOTBNPOH UIFSFRVJSFNFOUT CVUUIFUFYUPGFBDISFRVJSFNFOUJTUSFBUFEBTBDIBSBDUFSTUSJOHXJUIOPTFNBO UJDTGPS%00344ZT.-JTBOFYBNQMFPGBMBOHVBHFUIBUUPBMBSHFEFHSFFSFQSFTFOUTUIFHPBM TUBUF CVUOPUFOUJSFMZThFUSFBUNFOUPGSFRVJSFNFOUTTUBUFNFOUTJO4ZT.-JTUIFTBNFBTUIBUJO %0034 JOUIBUBSFRVJSFNFOUTUBUFNFOUJTBDIBSBDUFSTUSJOHJOTUFBEPGBNPEFMXJUITFNBOUJDT "OJNQPSUBOUDPSPMMBSZPGUIFQSPHSFTTJPOPGTUBUFTJTUIFFWPMVUJPOPGDPOﬁHVSBUJPONBOBHFNFOU GSPNDPOUSPMMJOHQBQFSEPDVNFOUTUPDPOUSPMMJOHPSUSBDLJOHNPEFMTJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFSFQPTJUPSZ *OUIFHPBMTUBUFEPDVNFOUTXJMMTUJMMFYJTU CVUUIFZXJMMCFJOUIFGPSNPGSFQPSUT QSPKFDUJPOT PS WJFXTUIBUDPNFPVUPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF ThFNPEFMTJOUIFHPBMTUBUFSFﬂFDUUIFLJOETPGJOGPSNBUJPOFYQSFTTFEJO.04&4TQFDJﬁDB UJPOT BOEBSFNBDIJOFQSPDFTTBCMF BTQSFWJFXFEJOUIFDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLFYBN QMF JO UIF TFDUJPO FOUJUMFE i.PEFM 4QBDF $POUFYU BOE 3FRVJSFNFOUTw %FTJSBCMF QSPQFSUJFT PG MBOHVBHFT VTFE UP SFQSFTFOU NPEFMT JO UIF NPEFM TQBDF BTTPDJBUFE XJUI UIF DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO EJNFOTJPO BSF UIBU UIFZ CF NBDIJOF QSPDFTTBCMF DBQUVSF BQQSPQSJBUF TFNBOUJDT BOE DPMMFD UJWFMZ TVQQPSUUFYUVBM HSBQIJDBM BOENBUIFNBUJDBMGPSNT"DBOEJEBUFGBNJMZPGMBOHVBHFTGPS SFQSFTFOUJOHBMMUIFTFNPEFMTJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFXPVMECF&YUFOTJCMF.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF 9.- BOE WBSJPVT MBOHVBHFT CBTFE PO 9.- JODMVEJOH HSBQIJDBM MBOHVBHFT TVDI BT 4DBMBCMF 7FDUPS (SBQIJDT 47(

.BUIFNBUJDBM.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF .BUI.-

BOEPOUPMPHZMBOHVBHFTTVDIBT 08-"OPUIFSGBNJMZPGMBOHVBHFTJT6.-BOEJUTSFMBUFEMBOHVBHFT4ZT.-BOE0$- BOEJUT NFUBMBOHVBHF.FUB0CKFDU'BDJMJUZ .0' 9.-BOE6.-BSFJOUFHSBUFEUISPVHIUIF.0' DPNQMJBOU 9.- .FUBEBUB *OUFSDIBOHF 9.* TUBOEBSE " NPSF FYUFOTJWF EJTDVTTJPO PG UIFTF BOEPUIFSMBOHVBHFT JTHJWFOJO$IBQUFSThFRVFTUJPOPGXIBUMBOHVBHFTUPVTFUPSFQSFTFOU UIFNPEFMTJOUIF4&NPEFMTQBDF BOEUIFJOUFSDIBOHFTBNPOHUIFN OFFETDPOTJEFSBCMZNPSF JOWFTUJHBUJPO 8IFOVTJOHUIFNPEFMTQBDFUPTVQQPSUUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGBTQFDJﬁDTZTUFN UIFFOUSZQPJOU JTBTQFDJﬁDBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOQPSUJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF*OUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi.PEFM4QBDF $POUFYUBOE3FRVJSFNFOUT wXFTLFUDIFEBNPEFMTQBDFWJTJPOPGDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH'PS4& UIFTBNFBQQSPBDIXPVMECFVTFE4VQQPTFXFBSFFOHJOFFSJOHBOFXDPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGU8F TFUVQBQSPKFDUXPSLTQBDFGPSUIJTFﬀPSUBOECFHJOCZSFBDIJOHJOUPUIFHFOFSBMQVCMJDTQBDFJO UIFEPNBJOPGDPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGUJODMVEJOHNPEFMTPGQSFWJPVTTJNJMBSBJSDSBGUThFHFOFSBM NPEFMTIFSFIBWFMJOLTUPBMMUIFOFDFTTBSZQBSUTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF JODMVEJOHBMMUIFEPNBJOT UIBUQBSUJDJQBUFJOUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGBOBJSDSBGUThFNPEFMTSFﬂFDUSFRVJSFNFOUT EFTJHOT TJNVMB UJPOT TZTUFNPSDPNQPOFOUTUBUJDBOEEZOBNJDQSPQFSUJFT FUDJOBMMUIFTFEPNBJOTThFTFHFOFSBM NPEFMTBSFUBJMPSFEPSTQFDJBMJ[FEBTOFDFTTBSZBOEQVUJOUPUIFQSPKFDUXPSLTQBDFGPSUIJTTQFDJﬁD BJSDSBGU VTJOHQSPDFTTFTUIBUBSFEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS

SE Model Space

O

119

Current State 'PS4& UIFSFBSFUXPJTTVFTThFﬁSTUJTNBUVSJUZBOEDPNQMFUFOFTT*TUIF4&#P,NBUVSFBOE DPNQMFUFJOTPNFJNQPSUBOUTFOTF ThFTFDPOEJTTVFJTSFBEJOFTTGPSUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFQPSUJPO PGUIFNPEFMTQBDF*TUIFLOPXMFEHFJOBGPSNUIBUDBOCFDBQUVSFEJONPEFMT *OUIJTTFDUJPO UIFTFDPOEJTTVFJTBEESFTTFECFDBVTFUIFDPOUFYUJTUIFNPEFMTQBDFThFﬁSTUJTTVFJTEJTDVTTFEJO $IBQUFSJOUIFDPOUFYUPGUIF4&#P, ThF GPSN PG LOPXMFEHF UIBU FYJTUT JO B EPNBJO PS EJTDJQMJOF BﬀFDUT JUT TUBUF SFMBUJWF UP UIF NPEFMTQBDFWJFXPG#P,ThF4&LOPXMFEHFUIBUFYJTUTJTJOBQSFMJNJOBSZGPSNGPSUIFNPEFM TQBDF XJUITPNFNBUFSJBMNBDIJOFNBOJQVMBCMFCVUNVDIPGJUJOJOGPSNBMOBSSBUJWFBOESFRVJS JOHTJHOJﬁDBOUXPSLUPHFUJUJOUPNPSFVTBCMFNPEFMGPSN .PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ CFDBVTFUIF4&#P,JTNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZ JUJTOPUVOJGPSNMZSFBEZUPCFDBQUVSFE JONPEFMT8FCSJFﬂZEJTDVTTUIFSFBEJOFTTPGTPNFLFZTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFTBOEUIFO4&QSPQFS O 444ZTUFNTTDJFODF XIJMFOPUFOUJSFMZJONPEFMGPSN JTQBSUJBMMZJONPEFMGPSNBOEMFOET JUTFMG UP CFJOH FBTJMZ UVSOFE JOUP NPEFMT ThFSFGPSF 44 XPVME TDPSF GBJSMZ IJHI PO UIJT DSJUFSJPOPGSFBEJOFTTGPSBO4&NPEFMTQBDF O $4ThFLOPXMFEHFPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNTJTBMSFBEZJONPEFMGPSNUPBTJHOJﬁDBOUEFHSFF *OGBDU JSPOJDBMMZ CFDBVTFUIJTOFXFTUBSFBPG4&JTNPSFPSJFOUFEUPXBSETZTUFNNPEFMT UIBOFOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTNPEFMT $4LOPXMFEHFJTNPSFSFBEZGPSUIF4&NPEFMTQBDF UIBONVDIPGUIFUSBEJUJPOBM4&MJUFSBUVSF'SPNUIFWJFXQPJOUPGUIF4&#P, UIFMBSHFS JTTVFXJUI$4LOPXMFEHFJTUIBUJUIBTOPUCFFOJODPSQPSBUFEJOUPUIFPWFSBMM4&#P, BT EJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS8IFOJUJTJODPSQPSBUFE JUXJMMBMSFBEZCFJOUIFGPSNPGNPEFMT O .BUIFNBUJDT ThF NBUIFNBUJDT UIBU TVQQPSUT 4& SBOHFT GSPN EJﬀFSFOUJBM FRVBUJPOT UP MPHJD BOEJTJONPEFMGPSNBOESFBEZGPSUIF4&NPEFMTQBDF O 4PGUXBSFThFTPGUXBSFDPNNVOJUZIBTGPVSQFSTQFDUJWFTPOUIFJTTVFPGLOPXMFEHFUIBU JTSFBEZUPCFDBQUVSFEJOBNPEFMTQBDF'JSTU JUIBTEFﬁOFEB48&#P,HVJEF XIJDIJT CBTFEPOUIFFOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTBOEMJGFDZDMFBQQSPBDI BOEJTJOUIFTQJSJUPG54&NPSF UIBO$4ThJTLOPXMFEHFJTUBSHFUFENPSFUPUIFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDFUIBOUIFNPEFMTQBDF PG4&4FDPOE UIFTPGUXBSFDPNNVOJUZJOUIFMBTUEFDBEFIBTCFFOBMFBEFSJOCSJOHJOH NPEFMCBTFE BQQSPBDIFT UP UIF GPSFGSPOU BT NFOUJPOFE JO $IBQUFS ThJSE TPGUXBSF IBTDPEJﬁFEUPTPNFFYUFOUDFSUBJODPOWFOUJPOBMEFTJHOTJOUIFGPSNPGEFTJHOQBUUFSOT BSDIJUFDUVSFQBUUFSOT BOESFGFSFODFBSDIJUFDUVSFT'PVSUI TPGUXBSFIBTBTUSPOHUSBEJUJPO JOTJNVMBUJPONPEFMJOHThFDPNCJOBUJPOPGUIFNPEFMCBTFEFOHJOFFSJOHBQQSPBDI UIF DBQUVSFPGLOPXMFEHFJOQBUUFSOTBOESFGFSFODFNPEFMT BOEUIFTJNVMBUJPOLOPXMFEHF NFBOUIBUTPGUXBSFLOPXMFEHFJTUPUIJTFYUFOUSFBEZGPSUIFNPEFMTQBDF O .BJO4&4&QSPQFS BTEJTUJOHVJTIFEGSPNBMMUIFTVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT IBTQBSBMMFMT UPUIFTPGUXBSFTJUVBUJPO*UIBTUISFFQFSTQFDUJWFT'JSTU MJLFTPGUXBSF 4&IBTEFﬁOFEBO 4&#P,HVJEF XIJDIJTCBTFEPOUIFFOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTBOEMJGFDZDMFBQQSPBDI JOUIF TQJSJUPG54& BOEUBSHFUFENPSFUPUIFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDFUIBOUIFNPEFMTQBDFPG4& 4FDPOE 4&IBTSFDFOUMZCFHVOMFWFSBHJOHUIFXPSLPGUIFTPGUXBSFDPNNVOJUZJONPWJOH UPXBSEUIFNPEFMCBTFEBQQSPBDIUPFOHJOFFSJOH BMUIPVHIJUJTOPUBTGBSBMPOHBTTPGU XBSFJOUIJTSFHBSEThJSE 4&IBTBTUSPOHUSBEJUJPOJOTJNVMBUJPONPEFMJOH4&IBTEPOF NVDIMFTTXPSLUIBOTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHJOUIFBSFBPGDBQUVSJOHEFTJHOLOPXMFEHFJO UIFGPSNPGQBUUFSOTBOENPEFMT"TBXIPMF 4&QSPQFSIBTTPNFEFHSFFPGSFBEJOFTTCVU TUJMMIBTBDPOTJEFSBCMFBNPVOUPGXPSLUPEPUPCFSFBEZGPSUIF4&NPEFMTQBDF

120

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Management: Tools and Processors 8FCSJFﬂZEJTDVTTUPPMTUPNBOBHFUIFNPEFMTQBDFBTBNPEFMSFQPTJUPSZPSEBUBCBTF BOEQSP DFTTPSTUIBUNBOJQVMBUFUIFNPEFMT1SPDFTTPSTDBOCFIVNBOT TPGUXBSF DPNQVUFSIBSEXBSF PS NBZCFQIZTJDBMFOHJOFTPSBHFOUT 1SPDFTTPSTQFSGPSNDFSUBJOBDUJPOTPONPEFMT JODMVEJOHTUPSFNPEFMT USBOTGPSNPOFNPEFM JOUP BOPUIFS FYFDVUF B NPEFM BOE BOBMZ[F B NPEFM UP EFUFSNJOF JUT QSPQFSUJFT PS XIFUIFS JU NBUDIFTPSTBUJTﬁFTBOPUIFSNPEFM. ThFSFBSFTFWFSBMDMBTTFTPGQSPDFTTPST O .PEFMTUPSBHFBOENBOBHFNFOUUPPMTThFTFQSPDFTTPSTTUPSFBOELFFQUSBDLPGNPEFMT JO UIFNBOOFSPGUZQJDBMSFQPTJUPSZPSEBUBCBTFNBOBHFNFOUUPPMT O /BWJHBUPST RVFSZ UPPMT ThFTF QSPDFTTPST IFMQ B VTFS OBWJHBUF CSPXTF BOE TFBSDI UIF NPEFMTQBDF O "OBMZ[FST DPNQBSBUPST DIFDLFST WFSJﬁFST ThFTF QSPDFTTPST BOBMZ[F BOE IFMQ EFUFSNJOF QSPQFSUJFTBOERVBMJUJFTPGNPEFMT DPNQBSFNPEFMTGPSEJﬀFSFODFT BOEFWBMVBUFNPEFMT UPTFFJGUIFZTBUJTGZPUIFSNPEFMT O 5SBOTGPSNFST HFOFSBUPSTThFTFQSPDFTTPSTUSBOTGPSNBNPEFMJOUPBOPUIFSNPEFM PSHFOFS BUFOFXNPEFMT O 7JTVBMJ[FST WJFXFST SFQPSUHFOFSBUPST QSPKFDUPSTThFTFQSPDFTTPSTSFBENPEFMDPOUFOUTJO UIFNPEFMTQBDFBOEQSFTFOUUIFNUPVTFST

Existing Repository Approaches 8FBSFOPUBXBSFPGBOZSFQPTJUPSZUIBUDPSSFTQPOETJOBMMSFTQFDUTUPUIFNPEFMTQBDFEFTDSJCFE JO UIJT DIBQUFS )PXFWFS UIFSF JT DPOTJEFSBCMF BDUJWJUZ JO JNQMFNFOUJOH SFQPTJUPSJFT UIBU IBWF TPNFPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT JODMVEJOHWBSZJOHEFHSFFTPGDPOUFOUBOEUPPMT8FCSJFﬂZ JEFOUJGZBGFXPGUIFTFFﬀPSUT

IEEE 1220 The ﬁSTUFYBNQMFJTOPUBSFQPTJUPSZCVUSBUIFSUIFQSFTDSJQUJPOGPSBOJOUFHSBUFESFQPTJUPSZGPSBO 4&QSPKFDU BTEFﬁOFEJO*&&&4&4UBOEBSE *&&& ThFDPOUFOUDPSSFTQPOETDMPTFMZ UPUIFQSPKFDUXPSLTQBDFQPSUJPOPGUIF.04&4NPEFMTQBDFThFSFQPTJUPSZEBUBJODMVEFTQMBOT TDIFEVMFT EFTJHOT ESBXJOHT BOENBOZPUIFSJUFNTUIBUDPWFSUIFTPGUXBSF IBSEXBSF IVNBO JOUFSGBDFT NBOBHFNFOU BOEPWFSBMMTZTUFNThFTDPQFPGUIJTJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIFQSPKFDUXPSL TQBDFJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFThFEJﬀFSFODFJTUIBUJOUIF*&&&EFTDSJQUJPO UIFTFJUFNTBSFDPODFJWFE BTEBUB XIJMFJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFUIFZBSFDPODFJWFEBTNPEFMT.PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ UIFNPEFMTQBDF XPVMEIBWFBOJOUFHSBUFETFUPGVOEFSMZJOHNPEFMTUIBUXPVMEQSPEVDFNBOZPGUIFTFEBUBJUFNT BTSFQPSUTThJTJTBMFWFMPGJOUFHSBUJPOBOECVJMUJODPOTJTUFODZUIBUJTOPUFYQMJDJUMZDBMMFEGPSJO UIF*&&&SFQPTJUPSZPSPﬀFSFECZNPTUUSBEJUJPOBMSFQPTJUPSJFT "NPSFNPEFMPSJFOUFEFYBNQMFJTBQSPQPTFEDPOUFOUTUBOEBSEGPSDPNQVUBUJPOBMNPEFMT )JMM FU BM ThBU BSUJDMF JEFOUJﬁFT FMFNFOUT HSPVQFE JOUP UIF GPMMPXJOH DBUFHPSJFT JEFOUJﬁ DBUJPO JOGPSNBUJPO JOUFOEFE VTF EFTDSJQUJPO BDDFTT PS BWBJMBCJMJUZ TZTUFN SFRVJSFNFOUT JOQVU EBUBSFRVJSFNFOUT EBUBQSPDFTTJOH NPEFMPVUQVU DBMJCSBUJPOFﬀPSUTBOEWBMJEBUJPO BOENFUBEBUB TPVSDF

SE Model Space

O

121

Digital Library Reference Model ThF%&-04%JHJUBM-JCSBSZ3FGFSFODF.PEFM %-3. $BOEFMBFUBM IBTUIFBNCJUJPVT HPBMPGJEFOUJGZJOHUIFDPODFQUTBOESFMBUJPOTIJQTUIBUDIBSBDUFSJ[FUIFFTTFODFPGUIFEJHJUBMMJCSBSZ VOJWFSTF*UEFQJDUTUIJTVOJWFSTFBTBUISFFUJFSGSBNFXPSLPGEJHJUBMMJCSBSZ EJHJUBMMJCSBSZTZTUFN BOEEJHJUBMMJCSBSZNBOBHFNFOUTZTUFNThFBMMFODPNQBTTJOHUJFSJTUIFEJHJUBMMJCSBSZThFEJHJUBM MJCSBSZ TZTUFN JT BQQMJDBUJPO TPGUXBSF UIBU QSPWJEFT UIF MJCSBSZ GVODUJPOBMJUZ BOE UIF NBOBHF NFOUTZTUFNQSPWJEFTUIFVOEFSMZJOHTZTUFNTPGUXBSFTVQQPSUThFDPSFDPODFQUTPG%-3.BSF ﬁWFEJHJUBMMJCSBSZEPNBJOTVTFS DPOUFOU GVODUJPOBMJUZ RVBMJUZ BOEQPMJDZBOEPOFEJHJUBM MJCSBSZTZTUFNEPNBJOBSDIJUFDUVSF *OBEEJUJPOUPUIFEPNBJOT %-3.DPODFQUTUIBUSFMBUFUPUIFNPEFMTQBDFJODMVEFSFTPVSDFT WJFXT BOEPOUPMPHJFTThFMJCSBSZDPOUFOUTBSFDPODFJWFEBTSFTPVSDFT BOEBSFSFQSFTFOUFEJOWJFXT UIBUTFSWFUIFJOEJWJEVBMVTFST0OUPMPHZJTVTFEBTBCBTJTGPSUIFMJCSBSZDPODFQUTBOEUIFDPOUFOU DBUFHPSJFT/PUBMMUIFTUSVDUVSFBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOJOGPSNBUJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFJTWJTJCMFJOUIF SFGFSFODFNPEFMCVUUIFSFGFSFODFNPEFMTFFNTUPCFDMPTFFOPVHIUIBUJUDPVMETFSWFBTUIFCBTJT GPSUBJMPSJOHUPUIFNPEFMTQBDFBOE.04&4

Sample Repositories "QSPNJOFOU&VSPQFBOFYBNQMFPGBSFQPTJUPSZFﬀPSUJTUIF%3*7&3QSPKFDU %3*7&3

OPXJOUIF%3*7&3**QIBTF%3*7&3TUBOETGPS%JHJUBM3FQPTJUPSZ*OGSBTUSVDUVSF7JTJPOGPS &VSPQFBO3FTFBSDI*UJTBUUFNQUJOHUPQVUUPHFUIFSBDPOGFEFSBUJPOPGEJHJUBMSFQPTJUPSJFTUPTFSWF BTBLOPXMFEHFJOGSBTUSVDUVSFPG&VSPQFBOSFTFBSDISFTVMUT UPNBLFUIFSFTVMUTBDDFTTJCMFUPBXJEF BVEJFODF*O%3*7&3** UIFZBSFBEEJOHSFTFBSDIEBUBBTXFMMBTQBQFST 0QFO%0"3JTBEJSFDUPSZPGBDBEFNJDPQFOBDDFTTSFQPTJUPSJFT %0"3 *UDPOUBJOTB MJTUPGSFQPTJUPSJFTXPSMEXJEF ThF3FHJTUSZPG4UBOEBSE#JPMPHJDBM1BSUT PSiCJPCSJDLT wBU.*5UIBUXFJOUSPEVDFEJO$IBQUFS 3FHJTUSZ JTBUBTNBMMFSTDBMFCVUEPFTSFQSFTFOUBOPUIFSBTQFDUPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF "OJOEFYPGDPNNPODSZTUBMMBUUJDFTUSVDUVSFT XJUIBHSBQIJDBMSFQSFTFOUBUJPOBOEJOGPSNB UJPOBCPVUFBDIPOF JTBWBJMBCMFBU/BWZ ThFBWBJMBCJMJUZPG1FSSZT)BOECPPL XIJDIXBTEJTDVTTFEFBSMJFS PO$%30.JTBTNBMMOFYU TUFQUPXBSEBSFQPTJUPSZ"CJHTUFQGPSXBSEXPVMECFUPDBQUVSFBMMUIFNPEFMTJOUIJTIBOECPPL BTNPEFMT JOTUFBEPGBTUFYU #PFJOH BOE JUT QBSUOFST VTFE B DPNNPO EFWFMPQNFOU FOWJSPONFOU DBMMFE UIF (MPCBM $PMMBCPSBUJPO&OWJSPONFOUGPSUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPGUIFThJTDPOUBJOTBTIBSFESFQPTJUPSZPGBMM EPDVNFOUTBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOT BTXFMMBTBNFBOTPGJOUFSBDUJOH FH WJSUVBMDPOGFSFODFNFFUJOHT *U DPSSFTQPOETUPUIFXPSLTQBDFBSFBPGUIF.04&4NPEFMTQBDF DPOUBJOJOHUIFTQFDJﬁDNPEFMTGPSB HJWFOQSPKFDUTZTUFN*UJTHMPCBMJOUIFTFOTFUIBUUIJTQSPKFDUXBTBHMPCBMDPMMBCPSBUJPOFﬀPSU ThJTTNBMMTBNQMFTFUJMMVTUSBUFTBXJEFSBOHFPGSFQPTJUPSJFT BMMSFMBUFEJOTPNFXBZUPUIF4& NPEFMTQBDF

Some Model Space Literature Sources ThJTTFDUJPOOFFEPOMZCFSFBEJGUIFSFBEFSJTJOUFSFTUFEJOFYBNQMFTGSPNUIFMJUFSBUVSFPONPEFM TQBDFJEFBTBOEEJNFOTJPOT

122 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThFJEFBPGBNPEFMTQBDFJTOPUOFX8FCSJFﬂZSFWJFXIFSFBGFXTBNQMFEJTDVTTJPOTPGUIF DPODFQUJOUIFMJUFSBUVSF4PNFPGUIFMJUFSBUVSFJTGSPNTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH XIJDIIBTGPDVTFE IFBWJMZBOEJODSFBTJOHMZPONPEFMJOHThFﬁSTUQBSUPGUIJTTFDUJPOEJTDVTTFTUIFJEFBPGBNPEFM TQBDF BOEUIFTFDPOEQBSUEJTDVTTFTQPTTJCMFWBSJBCMFTPSEJNFOTJPOTJOTJEFJU

The Model Space Idea 4FWFSBMEJTDVTTJPOTPGDPODFQUTUIBUNBQXFMMUPUIFNPEFMTQBDFBSFSFWJFXFEIFSF

Christopher Alexander: Actual World, Pictures, and Patterns ThFJEFB*O $ISJTUPQIFS"MFYBOEFSQVCMJTIFEBCPPLFOUJUMFE/PUFTPOUIF4ZOUIFTJTPG'PSN "MFYBOEFS )F JOUSPEVDFE UISFF MFWFMT PG EFTJHO VOTFMGDPOTDJPVT TFMGDPOTDJPVT BOE GPSNBM)FEFTDSJCFTVOTFMGDPOTDJPVTEFTJHOBTMFBSOJOHBNBUVSFCVUJNQMJDJUBSDIJUFDUVSFBOE BQQMZJOHBOEBEBQUJOHUIFSFTVMUJOHTZTUFN TVDIBTBTJNQMFIPVTF UPNBJOUBJOUIFﬁUCFUXFFO GPSNBOEDPOUFYU "MFYBOEFS $IBQUFS ThFSFJTBEJSFDUDPSSFTQPOEFODFCFUXFFOBDUVBM XPSMEDPOUFYUBOEBDUVBMXPSMEGPSN4FMGDPOTDJPVTEFTJHOJTXIFSFUIFIVNBOGPSNTBOJOGPS NBMNFOUBMQJDUVSFPGUIFDPOUFYUBOEBUUFNQUTUPEFTJHOUPUIBUNFOUBMQJDUVSF "MFYBOEFS $IBQUFS

XIJDI"MFYBOEFSTBZTJTHFOFSBMMZXSPOH'PSNBMEFTJHOJTXIFSFUIFNFOUBMQJDUVSF JTGPSNBMJ[FEBOEUIFSFGPSFDBOCFFYBNJOFEBOEBOBMZ[FEBOENBEFDPSSFDU BOEEFTJHOJTUP UIBUGPSNBMQJDUVSFPSNPEFM"MFYBOEFSTUBUFTUIBUUIFFWPMVUJPOPGEFTJHOTUBSUTXJUIVOTFMGDPO TDJPVTEFTJHO BOEUIBUJTGPMMPXFECZTFMGDPOTDJPVTEFTJHO BOEUIFOCZGPSNBMEFTJHO XIJDI JTIJTEFTJSFENFUIPE*OFBDIDBTF IFEFTDSJCFTIPXGPSNﬁUTDPOUFYU PSIPXEFTJHOTBUJTﬁFT SFRVJSFNFOUT *OUIFT "MFYBOEFSFNQIBTJ[FEBEJﬀFSFOUBQQSPBDIQBUUFSOTGPSVTFJOUIFﬁFMEPGQIZTJ DBMCVJMEJOHBSDIJUFDUVSFBOEDPNNVOJUZQMBOOJOH "MFYBOEFSFUBM "MFYBOEFS " QBUUFSOJTBHFOFSBMNPEFMPSEFTJHOGPSFYBNQMF PGBSPPN BIPVTF PSBOFJHICPSIPPE UIBUJTCBTFEPOBDDVNVMBUFELOPXMFEHFBOEFYQFSJFODF BOEDBOCFBQQMJFEBOETQFDJBMJ[FEGPS BHJWFOFOWJSPONFOU*OUIFQBTUEFDBEF QBUUFSOTIBWFCFDPNFQPQVMBSJOUIFﬁFMETPGTPGUXBSF BOETZTUFNTEFTJHOBOEBSDIJUFDUVSF.PSFSFDFOUMZ UIFQBUUFSODPODFQUIBTCFFOVTFEUPEFTDSJCF CPUIEFTJSBCMFBOEVOEFTJSBCMF iBOUJQBUUFSOTw CFIBWJPSTBOETUSVDUVSFTJOBXJEFWBSJFUZPGPUIFS BSFBT JODMVEJOHNBOBHFNFOUBOECVTJOFTTPSJFOUFE ﬁFMET&YBNQMFTPGNBOBHFNFOUBOECVTJ OFTTPSJFOUFEQBUUFSOTJODMVEFDPOﬁHVSBUJPONBOBHFNFOUBOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTUSVDUVSF

Correlation with the Model Space O 6OTFMGDPOTDJPVTEFTJHOUBLFTQMBDFFOUJSFMZJOUIFQSPCMFNTQBDF iDPOUFYUw BOETPMV UJPOTQBDF iGPSNw /PNPEFMTQBDFFYJTUTCVUJUJOUSPEVDFTTPNFFMFNFOUTPG.04&4 DPNNPOBSDIJUFDUVSF BEBQUJWFOFTT BOECBMBODFPGTUBCJMJUZBOEDIBOHF8FXPVMEDBMM UIJTQSFFOHJOFFSJOH O 4FMGDPOTDJPVTBOEGPSNBMEFTJHOJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIQSPCMFNTQBDF NPEFMTQBDF TPMV UJPOTQBDFSFMBUJPOTIJQT$POUFYUNBQTUPQSPCMFNTQBDFNFOUBMQJDUVSFTNBQUPTQFDJﬁDB UJPOT BOE JGNBEFFYQMJDJU NPEFMTQBDFBOEGPSNNBQTUPTPMVUJPOTQBDF N *OUIFPWFSBMMNPEFMTQBDF UIF"MFYBOEFSEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOTFMGDPOTDJPVTBOEGPS NBMEFTJHO "MFYBOEFSDBMMTJUiUIFQSPHSBNw NBQTUPUIF.04&4EJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFO JOGPSNBMBOEGPSNBMNPEFMT

SE Model Space

O

123

N *OUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF UIFEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOTFMG DPOTDJPVTBOEGPSNBMEFTJHODBOCFDPODFJWFEBTNBQQJOHUPUIF.04&4EJTUJODUJPO CFUXFFOJOGPSNBMVTFSEFﬁOFESFRVJSFNFOUTSFQSFTFOUFEJOBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOUFSNT BOEBSFRVJSFNFOUTTQFDSFQSFTFOUFEJONPSFGPSNBMFOHJOFFSJOHUFSNT O "MFYBOEFSQBUUFSOTDPODFQUNBQTUPUIFNPEFMTQBDF BOENPSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZNBQTUPHFO FSBMNPEFMTJOUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOUIBUDBQUVSFLOPXMFEHFPGBDMBTTPGTPMV UJPOT UP B DMBTT PG QSPCMFNT JO BO BQQMJDBUJPO EPNBJO ThF BDUVBM "MFYBOEFS QBUUFSOT NBQUP.04&4NPEFMTPGPSHBOJDTZTUFNTBOEIZCSJE NJYPGPSHBOJDBOENFDIBOJTUJD TZTUFNTThFQBUUFSOMBOHVBHF "MFYBOEFSFUBM NBQTUPUIF.04&4DPODFQUTPG MBOHVBHFBOE6%JOUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF ThVT "MFYBOEFSﬁSTUFNQIBTJ[FEGPSNBMJUZJOEFTJHOBOEMBUFSFNQIBTJ[FELOPXMFEHFJOUIF GPSNPGQBUUFSOT.04&4VTFTJEFBTGSPNCPUI.04&4BEPQUTUIF)VNFEJTUJODUJPO )VNF CFUXFFONBUUFSTPGGBDU PSDPOUJOHFODJFT BOESFMBUJPOTPGJEFBT PSOFDFTTJUJFT ThF GPSNFSDBUFHPSZJODMVEFTTUBUFNFOUTTVDIBTiUIFTVOXJMMSJTFUPNPSSPXwBOE NPSFHFOFSBMMZ TDJFOUJﬁDUIFPSJFTThFMBUUFSDBUFHPSZJODMVEFTNBUIFNBUJDBMSFMBUJPOTBOEMPHJDBMQSPQPTJUJPOT ThFEJﬀFSFODFCFUXFFO"MFYBOEFSTTFNQIBTJTPOFYQFSJFODFCBTFEQBUUFSOTBOEIJT FNQIBTJTPOGPSNBMNPEFMTBMJHOTSBUIFSDMFBOMZUP)VNFTEJTUJODUJPO*OUIFNPEFMTQBDFDPO UFYU JGXFBTTVNFUIBUPOMZDPODFQUVBMNPEFMTFYJTUJOTJEFUIFNPEFMTQBDF UIFOUIFSFMBUJPOT UPJEFBTFYJTUJOUIFNPEFMTJOTJEFUIFNPEFMTQBDF BOEUIFDPOUJOHFOUSFMBUJPOUPNBUUFSTPGGBDU FYJTUTJOUIFJOUFSBDUJPOTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFXJUIUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFBOEUIFTPMVUJPOTQBDF &OHJOFFSJOH JO HFOFSBM JODMVEJOH 4& JODMVEFT CPUI DPOUJOHFOU GBDUT BOE OFDFTTBSZ JEFBT $POUJOHFOU GBDUT BSF QSFTFOU JO UIF QIZTJDBM DPOTUSBJOUT PO B TPMVUJPO BOE JO UIF RVFTUJPO PG XIFUIFSUIFFOHJOFFSFETPMVUJPOTPMWFTUIFQSPCMFN/FDFTTBSZJEFBTBSFQSFTFOUJOTPNFPGUIF SFMBUJPOTBNPOHWBSJPVTNPEFMT TVDIBTGPSNBMSFRVJSFNFOUTTQFDT EFTJHOT BOETJNVMBUJPOT

Bertrand Meyer: What Does Software Model ThFJEFB.FZFS o NBLFTUIFQPJOUUIBUBTPGUXBSFTZTUFNJTOPUBNPEFMPGSFBMJUZ JF BNPEFMPGUIFSFBMXPSMEJOUIFQSPCMFNTQBDF

CVUBNPEFMPGBEPNBJONPEFMPGUIFQSPC MFNTQBDF*OUFSNTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFDPOUFYU UIFSFJTXPSLEPOFJOUIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOJO EFﬁOJOHNPEFMTPGUIFSFBMXPSME IPXFWFSJOGPSNBM BOEUIPTFNPEFMTTFUUIFTUBHFGPSSFRVFTUJOH BOEJODPSQPSBUJOHBOFOHJOFFSFETPMVUJPO &YBNQMF4VQQPTFUIFSFBMXPSMEBUTPNFMPDBUJPOIBTBSJWFSXJUIQFPQMFMJWJOHPOCPUITJEFT PG UIF SJWFS CVU XJUI OP CSJEHF BDSPTT UIF SJWFS 4VQQPTF UIF BQQMJDBUJPO EPNBJO JT USBOTQPSUB UJPOThFMPDBMHPWFSONFOUQSPCBCMZIBTTPNFNPEFMTPGUIJTQPSUJPOPGUIFSFBMXPSME JODMVEJOH EFTDSJQUJPOTPGCPBUUSBﬃc BDSPTTUIFSJWFS CPBUUSBﬃc QBTTJOHUISPVHIVQBOEEPXOUIFSJWFS TQFFEBOEWPMVNFPGUIFSJWFS ﬂPPEMFWFMT OVNCFSPGQFPQMFPOCPUITJEFTPGUIFSJWFS FUDThFTF BSFNPEFMTJOUIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTBZ ". ". ". ". "./PXUIFHPWFSO NFOUEFDJEFTUIBUUIFZOFFEBCSJEHFBDSPTTUIFSJWFSThFZIJSFBOFOHJOFFSJOHﬁSNUPEFTJHOJU *O UIF EJTDVTTJPOT UIF HPWFSONFOU PﬀFST UIF NPEFMT UIFZ IBWF BOE UIF FOHJOFFSJOH ﬁSN TBZT UIFZXPVMEMJLFUPIBWFNPEFMT".BOE". XIJDIUIFHPWFSONFOUQSPWJEFTThFFOHJOFFS JOH ﬁSN UIFO FYBNJOFT UIFTF NPEFMT BOE EFDJEFT UIBU UIFZ DBO VTF ". JO UIFJS FOHJOFFSJOH FﬀPSU CVUOPU".CFDBVTFJUJTPVUPGEBUFPSJOTPNFXBZOPUBEFRVBUFGPSUIFJSFOHJOFFSJOH QVSQPTFTThFFOHJOFFSJOHﬁSNBMTPEFWFMPQTNPEFMT&. &. z &.JOUIFDPVSTFPGUIFJS FOHJOFFSJOHThFTFJODMVEFQSPKFDUFECSJEHFUSBﬃc FOWJSPONFOUBMNPEFMT SFRVJSFNFOUTTQFDJﬁDB UJPOT EFTJHO FUD(JWFOUIJTTJUVBUJPO XFXPVMETBZUIBUNPEFMT\". z ".^BSFBQQMJDBUJPO

124

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

EPNBJOQSPCMFNTQBDFNPEFMT BOENPEFMT\". &. z &.^BSF4&NPEFMTQBDFNPEFMT 0CWJPVTMZ NPEFM".FYJTUTJOCPUIUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFBOEUIFNPEFMTQBDF

Correlation with the Model Space .FZFSTJEFBBCPVUTPGUXBSFCFJOHBNPEFMUXJDFSFNPWFE BOEIJTEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOUIFSFBM XPSMEBOEUIFNPEFMTPGUIFSFBMXPSME HFOFSBMJ[FTUP4&ThFQSJNBSZDPOUSJCVUJPOJTUPIFMQ DMBSJGZUIFTDPQFPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFBOEUIFCPVOEBSZCFUXFFOUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFBOEUIFNPEFM TQBDFThFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOJODMVEFTUIFSFBMXPSMEBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIBUEPNBJO BTXFMMBTUIF EPNBJONPEFMTPGUIFSFBMXPSMEVTFEJOUIBUEPNBJO8FEPOPUGPDVTPOUIPTFNPEFMTJOUIJT CPPL8FGPDVTPOUIFNPEFMTJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFXIJDIJODMVEFNPEFMTPGUIFBQQMJDBUJPO EPNBJOBOENPEFMTUIBUBSFVTFEJOCPUIUIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOBOEJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF

Michael Jackson: The World and the Machine ThFJEFB.JDIBFM+BDLTPO B

EJTUJOHVJTIFTCFUXFFOUIFXPSMEBOEUIFNBDIJOF)FEFTDSJCFT NVMUJQMFPWFSMBQQJOHGBDFUTPSWJFXTPGUIFXPSMEBOENBDIJOF JODMVEJOHEFTDSJQUJPO QIFOPNFOB FOHJOFFSJOH BOEQSPCMFNGBDFUT%8EFTDSJQUJPOTUSVFPGUIFXPSME%.EFTDSJQUJPOTUSVF PGUIFNBDIJOFThFPWFSMBQDPOTJTUTPGEFTDSJQUJPOTUIBUBSFUSVFPGCPUI+BDLTPO C o o SFGFSTUPUIFXPSME UIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO BOEUIFNBDIJOF)FEFﬁOFTUIFBQQMJDBUJPO EPNBJOJOUXPTMJHIUMZEJﬀFSFOUXBZTﬁSTU BTUIFTQFDJﬁDFOWJSPONFOUJOXIJDIBTQFDJﬁDTZTUFN PQFSBUFTBOETFDPOE BTUIFJOUBOHJCMFDPODFQUTUIBUSFTJEFJOUIFNBDIJOF

Correlation with the Model Space 5PDMFBSMZEJTUJOHVJTI+BDLTPOUFSNTGSPN.04&4UFSNT XFTIPXUIFDPSSFMBUJPOPGDPODFQUTJO 5BCMF*OQBSUJDVMBS UIF.04&4EFﬁOJUJPOPGBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJONBQTUP+BDLTPOTXPSME DPODFQU OPUUP+BDLTPOTBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJODPODFQU

Bruce Blum: Models and Domains #SVDF#MVN o EFTDSJCFTUIFFTTFOUJBMTPGUXBSFQSPDFTTBTBTFSJFTPGUISFFUSBOTGPSNB UJPOTGSPNBOBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOOFFEUPDPODFQUVBMNPEFMTGSPNDPODFQUVBMNPEFMTUPGPSNBM Table 5.2 Correlation of Jackson and MOSES Model Space Concepts Jackson Concept World Machine Application domain: ﬁrst deﬁnition (environment) Application domain: second deﬁnition (concepts) DW DM Overlap (DW DM)

MOSES Concept General problem space of application domain Solution, system Speciﬁc system environment in application domain Application domain universe of discourse applied to speciﬁc system Model of application domain inclusive of speciﬁc system, (i.e., with the system operating in the application domain) External and internal models of the system External model of system

SE Model Space

O

125

NPEFMTGSPNGPSNBMNPEFMTUPBOJNQMFNFOUBUJPOEPNBJOTPGUXBSFQSPEVDU.PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ #MVNEFTDSJCFTUIFQSPDFTTUIJTXBZ O 'SPNBOFFESFDPHOJ[FEJOBOBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOJOUPBDPODFQUVBMNPEFMUIBUEFTDSJCFT UIFTPMVUJPOJOUFSNTPGUIFEPNBJOWPDBCVMBSZ O 'SPN UIF TPMVUJPO BT FYQSFTTFE JO UIF DPODFQUVBM NPEFM JOUP TPNF GPSNBM NPEFM UIBU EFﬁOFTXIBUUIFTPGUXBSFJTUPEPThFNPEFMJTDPOTJEFSFEGPSNBMJOUIBUJUEFﬁOFTXIBU UIFQSPEVDUJTUPEPBOEDBOEFUFSNJOFJGBOJNQMFNFOUBUJPOTBUJTﬁFTJUTEFﬁOJUJPO#MVN TBZTUIFGPSNBMTPMVUJPOJTEPDVNFOUFEJOBTPGUXBSFSFRVJSFNFOUTTQFD O 'SPNUIFGPSNBMNPEFMJOUPBTPGUXBSFQSPEVDUUIBUJTDPSSFDUXJUISFTQFDUUPUIBUNPEFM 8IBU#MVNUSFBUTBTUIFFTTFOUJBMTPGUXBSFQSPDFTT.04&4USFBUTBT UIFTPGUXBSFQBSUPG UIFDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF*O.04&4 UIFNPEFMTQBDFJTBTUSVDUVSF BOPSHBOJ[FENPEFM SFQPTJUPSZJOXIJDINPEFMTBSFTUPSFEBOEQSPDFTTFTBSFQFSGPSNFE 8FTIPXUIFDPSSFMBUJPOPG#MVNDPODFQUTXJUI.04&4DPODFQUTJO5BCMF

Jim Neighbors: Hierarchy of Domains +JN/FJHICPSTEFTDSJCFTBIJFSBSDIZPGEPNBJOTGPSTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHUIBUDPOTJTUTPGBQQMJDB UJPOEPNBJOT NPEFMJOHEPNBJOT BOEFYFDVUJPOEPNBJOT i8FEFﬁOFUIFMFWFMPGBCTUSBDUJPOPGPUIFSEPNBJOTXJUISFTQFDUUPBOFYFDVUBCMFEPNBJOUPCF UIFMPOHFTUBDZDMJDQBUIGSPNBOZPGUIFSFﬁOFNFOUTPGUIFEPNBJOTDPNQPOFOUTUPUIFFYFDVUBCMF EPNBJOThFEPNBJOTXJUIUIFIJHIFTUMFWFMTPGBCTUSBDUJPOBSFDBMMFEBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT XIJMF UIFEPNBJOTJOUIFBCTUSBDUJPOMFWFMTCFUXFFOUIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTBOEFYFDVUJPOEPNBJOTBSF DBMMFENPEFMJOHEPNBJOTw /FJHICPST "QQMJDBUJPO EPNBJO FYQFSUT DPOTUSVDU BQQMJDBUJPO EPNBJOT BOE NPEFMJOH EPNBJO FYQFSUT DPOTUSVDUNPEFMJOHEPNBJOT. ThFCBTJDQSPDFTTJTUSBOTGPSNBUJPO /FJHICPSTUISFFEPNBJODBUFHPSJFTNBQSFTQFDUJWFMZUP.04&4BQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTJOUIF QSPCMFNTQBDF UIFNPEFMTQBDF BOEUIFTPMVUJPOTQBDF

Wladislaw Turski: Speciﬁcations and Domains 5VSTLJBOE.BJCBVN o EJTDVTTUISFFFOUJUJFTBOEUIFJSSFMBUJPOT BQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO TQFDJﬁDBUJPO BOE QSPHSBNNJOHMBOHVBHFEPNBJOThFSFMBUJPOTBSFUIBUBTQFDJﬁDBUJPO Table 5.3

Correlation of Blum and MOSES Model Space Concepts

Blum Concept Application domain Need Conceptual model Formal model Software product

Implementation domain

MOSES Concept Application domain in problem space Application domain problem or gap model User requirements model in application domain terms Formal external system model Internal system model in programming language or computer processor language; exists both in the model space and in the solution space Solution space

126

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

BCTUSBDUTBOBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO BOEBQSPHSBNJOUIFQSPHSBNNJOHMBOHVBHFEPNBJOTBUJTﬁFTUIF TQFDJﬁDBUJPOThFTFDPODFQUTNBQUP.04&4UIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOJTUIFTBNFBTJO.04&4 ThFTQFDJﬁDBUJPONBQTUPBOFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGBTPMVUJPO BOEUIFDPNQVUFSQSPHSBNNBQT UPBOJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGBTPMVUJPO XIFSFUIFTPMVUJPOJTTPGUXBSFThFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBOEUIF DPNQVUFSQSPHSBNBSFCPUIJOUXPQMBDFTUIFNPEFMTQBDFBOEUIFTPMVUJPOTQBDFThJTGPSNVMB UJPOJTBDMFBSXBZUPNBLFUIFJNQPSUBOUQPJOUUIBUBOBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTFFTUIFFYUFSOBMWJFX PGBTPMVUJPO TPJOUIBUTFOTFUIFFYUFSOBMWJFXPSUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTUIFJOUFSNFEJBSZCFUXFFO UIFQSPCMFNTQBDFDPOUFYUBOEUIFJOUFSOBMTPMVUJPO UPTPNFEFHSFFIJEJOHCPUIGSPNFBDIPUIFS TFFUIFFODBQTVMBUJPOEJTDVTTJPOJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi$PNQPTJUJPOw ThJTQPJOUJTTJNJMBSUP +BDLTPOTDPODFQUPGPWFSMBQEJTDVTTFEBCPWF 5VSTLJ BMTPEJTDVTTFTUIFFTTFODFPGTPGUXBSF TBZJOHUIBUUIFFTTFODFPGTPGUXBSFMJFTJO JUTCFJOHBEFTDSJQUJPOPGUXPJOHFOFSBMEJﬀFSFOUTUSVDUVSFT BQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOBOE IBSE XBSFThJTMFBETUPBTQFDJﬁDTPGUXBSFWJFXPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFDPOUFYUUIBUJTQSFTFOUFEJONPSF EFUBJMJO$IBQUFS'PSUIFQVSQPTFTPGUIJTDIBQUFS 5VSTLJTNPEFMPGUIFFTTFODFPGTPGUXBSF NBQTUP.04&4JOUIBUUIFFYUFSOBMWJFXPGTPGUXBSFBEESFTTFTUIFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO XIJMFUIF JOUFSOBMWJFXPGTPGUXBSFJTSFQSFTFOUFEJOBMBOHVBHFUIFDPNQVUFSIBSEXBSFVOEFSTUBOET

Model Space Dimensions " DPOTJEFSBCMF MJUFSBUVSF FYJTUT UIBU EJTDVTTFT FBDI PG UIF WBSJBCMFT JO UIF NPEFM TQBDF " GFX FYBNQMFTBSFQSFTFOUFEIFSF

Philosophy, Especially Ontology "TJHOJﬁDBOUFMFNFOUPGPOUPMPHZJOQIJMPTPQIZJTUIFDBUFHPSJDBMTUSVDUVSFPGSFBMJUZ )POEFSJDI 1IJMPTPQIFSPOUPMPHJTUTBSHVFBCPVUXIBUPDDVQJFTUIFTFDPOETQPUPGUIFPOUPMPHZIJFS BSDIZPSUIFIJFSBSDIZPGCFJOHThFUPQJTiCFJOHwPSiFOUJUZwi4PNFTDIFNFTUBLFUIFEJWJTJPO CFUXFFOVOJWFSTBMTBOEQBSUJDVMBSTBTUIFOFYUTUFQJOUIFIJFSBSDIZ PUIFSTUIFEJWJTJPOCFUXFFO BCTUSBDUBOEDPODSFUFFOUJUJFTw )POEFSJDI 4JNPOT XSPUFBUSFBUJTFPONFSFPMPHZPSQBSUoXIPMFUIFPSZJOUIFDPOUFYUPGPOUPM PHZ1IJMPTPQIJDBMEFCBUFTBCPVUUIFDPODFQUPGFNFSHFODFIBWFPDDVSSFEPWFSUIFQBTUDFOUVSZ &NFSHFODFJTEJSFDUMZSFMBUFEUPQBSUoXIPMFTUSVDUVSFT ThFTF DPODFQUT GSPN POUPMPHZ JMMVTUSBUF TFWFSBM QPJOUT DPODFSOJOH .04&4 NPEFM TQBDF EJNFOTJPOT O ThFPOUPMPHZUSFBUNFOUPGUIFIJFSBSDIJDBMTUSVDUVSFPGDBUFHPSJFTPGCFJOHDMFBSMZJMMVT USBUFT BOEPDDVSTJO UIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF O ThFCBTJTPGUIFEFCBUFPWFSUIFTFDPOEPOUPMPHZMFWFMJTUIBUUIFSFJTPOFDPSSFDUTFDPOE MFWFMTFU BOEXFOFFEUPEFUFSNJOFXIBUUIBUJTThF.04&4QPTJUJPOPOUIJTJTTVFJTUIBU DBUFHPSJFTBOEHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOTBSFDSFBUFECZIVNBOTBOEUIFSFGPSFUIFSFJTOPUPOFJOIFS FOUMZDPSSFDUTFDPOEMFWFMThFSFNBZCFNPSFUIBOPOFTFDPOEMFWFMUIBUJTVTFGVMFBDI XPVMESFQSFTFOUBEJﬀFSFOUWJFXPGUIFIJFSBSDIZPGCFJOH BOEUIFSFGPSFUIFNPEFMTQBDF DPODFQUPGWJFXDBOJOGPSNBOEQPUFOUJBMMZSFTPMWFUIJTEFCBUFThFUXPTFUTNFOUJPOFE SFQSFTFOUUXPWJFXT O .FSFPMPHZ BOE FNFSHFODF JMMVTUSBUF BOE PDDVS JO UIF DPNQPTJUJPO EJNFOTJPO PG UIF NPEFM TQBDF

SE Model Space

O

127

Whitehead’s Discussion of Generalization and Stability/Change "MGSFE/PSUI8IJUFIFBE NBEFUIJTTUBUFNFOUi5PTFFXIBUJTHFOFSBMJOXIBUJTQBS UJDVMBSBOEXIBUJTQFSNBOFOUJOXIBUJTUSBOTJUPSZJTUIFBJNPGTDJFOUJﬁDUIPVHIUwThFRVPUFIBT UXPJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTJOUIJTCPPL*OUIFDPOUFYUPG$IBQUFS JUNFBOTUIBUBLFZHPBMPG.04&4 JTUPDBQUVSF4&DPODFQUTUIBUIBWFTPNFHFOFSBMJUZBDSPTTUIFCSPBETDPQFPG4&BOETPNFTUBCJM JUZBDSPTTUJNF*OUIJTDIBQUFS JUSFJOGPSDFTUIFJNQPSUBODFPGUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOBOE UIFUJNFEJNFOTJPOJOUFSNTPGBMPDVTGPSDBQUVSJOH4&SFMBUFELOPXMFEHFJOUIFGPSNPGHFOFSBM NPEFMTBOETUBCMFNPEFMT

Information Systems Engineering Sources *OGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHIBTNBEFTJHOJﬁ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ﬁDJBMJOUFMMJHFODF TFNBOUJDOFUXPSLT LOPXMFEHFSFQSF TFOUBUJPO BOEEBUBCBTFLOPXMFEHFCBTFNPEFMJOH"OFYBNQMFEJTDVTTJPOPGLOPXMFEHFSFQSFTFO UBUJPOJO.ZMPQPVMPTBOE-FWFTRVF JEFOUJﬁFTUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMBYFTPSEJNFOTJPOTPﬀFSFE CZTFNBOUJDOFUXPSLTGPSTUSVDUVSJOHBLOPXMFEHFCBTF. ThFTFJODMVEF O "HHSFHBUJPO XIJDISFMBUFTBOPCKFDU +PIO4NJUI UPJUTDPNQPOFOUTPSQBSUT DBOCFEJG GFSFOUWJFXTBTQIZTJDBMPCKFDU QBSUTBSFIFBE BSNT FUD

DBOCFBQQMJFESFDVSTJWFMZUP EFﬁOFQBSUTPGFBDIDPNQPOFOU FUD O $MBTTJﬁDBUJPO XIJDIBTTPDJBUFTBOPCKFDU +PIO4NJUI XJUIBHFOFSJDUZQF 1FSTPO TPNF UJNFTBQQMJFESFDVSTJWFMZUPEFﬁOFNFUBUZQFT O (FOFSBMJ[BUJPO XIJDISFMBUFTBUZQF 4UVEFOU UPBNPSFHFOFSJDUZQF 1FSTPO

SFDVSTJWFMZ PSHBOJ[FTUZQFTJOUPBHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOIJFSBSDIZ $MFBSMZ UIFBHHSFHBUJPOBYJTDPSSFTQPOETUPUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPOJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFThFDMBTTJﬁ DBUJPOBOEHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOBYFTDPSSFTQPOE SFTQFDUJWFMZ UPUIFDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOBOEHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOBTQFDUT PGUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFThFSFDVSTJWFGFBUVSFPGBMMUISFFBYFTBMTPDPS SFTQPOETEJSFDUMZUPUIFSFQFBUJOHNVMUJMFWFMIJFSBSDIJDBMTUSVDUVSFTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOT

Summary ThFEFTJHOPGUIF4&NPEFMTQBDFIBTCFFOQSFTFOUFE#FDBVTFUIFNPEFMTQBDFJTBEPNJOBOUGFB UVSFPG.04&4 FBDIPGUIFWBSJBCMFTJTGVSUIFSFMBCPSBUFEJO$IBQUFSTUISPVHI$PNQPTJUJPO $PNNPOJ[BUJPO $PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO 5JNF BOE7JFX

128

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

References "MFYBOEFS $/PUFTPOUIF4ZOUIFTJTPG'PSN$BNCSJEHF .")BSWBSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT "MFYBOEFS $ 4 *TIJLBXB . 4JMWFSTUFJO . +BDPCTPO * 'JLTEBIM,JOH BOE 4 "OHFM " 1BUUFSO -BOHVBHF5PXOTo#VJMEJOHTo$POTUSVDUJPO/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT "MFYBOEFS $The 5JNFMFTT8BZPG#VJMEJOH/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT "WBMMPOF & 5#BVNFJTUFS*** BOE"4BEFHI &ET.BSLT4UBOEBSE)BOECPPLGPS.FDIBOJDBM&OHJOFFST UIFE/FX:PSL.D(SBX)JMM #MVN #4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH")PMJTUJD7JFX /FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT $BOEFMB- %$BTUFMMJ /'FSSP :*PBOOJEJT (,PVUSJLB $.FHIJOJ FUBMThe %&-04%JHJUBM -JCSBSZ3FGFSFODF.PEFM'PVOEBUJPOTGPS%JHJUBM-JCSBSJFT W%&-04/FUXPSLPG&YDFMMFODF PO %JHJUBM -JCSBSJFT /PWFNCFS IUUQXXX.delos.info/ﬁles/pdf/RFGFSFODF.PEFM%&-04@%- 3FGFSFODF.PEFM@QEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

%0"3 The %JSFDUPSZ PG 0QFO "DDFTT 3FQPTJUPSJFT 0QFO%0"3 6OJWFSTJUZ PG /PUUJOHIBN IUUQXXXPQFOEPBSPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

%3*7&3%JHJUBM3FQPTJUPSZ*OGSBTUSVDUVSF7JTJPOGPS&VSPQFBO3FTFBSDIIUUQXXXESJWFSSFQPTJ UPSZFV "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

&ENBO * &E The 8PSLTPG1MBUP/FX:PSL3BOEPN)PVTF 0SJHJOBMDPQZSJHIU4JNPOBOE4DIVTUFS

(SFFO %BOE31FSSZ1FSSZT$IFNJDBM&OHJOFFST)BOECPPL UIFE/FX:PSL.D(SBX)JMM )JMM - 4$SPTJFS 54NJUI BOE.(PPEDIJME"DPOUFOUTUBOEBSEGPSDPNQVUBUJPOBMNPEFMT%-JC .BHB[JOF +VOF 7PM *TTVFIUUQXXXEMJCPSHEMJCKVOFIJMMIJMMIUNM "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

)POEFSJDI5The OYGPSE$PNQBOJPOUP1IJMPTPQIZ/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT )VNF % "O &ORVJSZ $PODFSOJOH )VNBO 6OEFSTUBOEJOH "OE 4FMFDUJPOT GSPN B5SFBUJTF PG )VNBO /BUVSF-B4alle, IL: The OQFO$PVSU1VCMJTIJOH$PNQBOZ )ZCFSUTPO %"VOJGPSNDPNQPOFOUNPEFMJOHTQBDF*OGPSNBUJDB oIUUQXXXNJUSF PSHXPSLCFTU@QBQFSTCFTU@QBQFST@IZCFSUTPO@TQBDF "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)ZCFSUTPO %5FTUJOH$PNFScial-oﬀ-the-SIFMG$PNQPOFOUTBOE4ZTUFNT 4#FZEFEBBOE7(SVIO &ET /FX:PSL4QSJOHFS7FSMBHQo *&&& *&&& 4UBOEBSE GPS "QQMJDBUJPO BOE .BOBHFNFOU PG UIF 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH 1SPDFTT *&&& 4UE /FX:PSL*&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ +BDLTPO .BThe XPSMEBOEUIFNBDIJOF JO1SPDUI*OU$POG48& *$4& o"QSJM 4FBUUMF"$. Qo +BDLTPO .C4PGUXBSF3FRVJSFNFOUT4peciﬁcations: "-FYJDPOPG1SBDUJDF 1SJODJQMFTBOE1SFKVEJDFT 8PLJOHIBN &OHMBOE"EEJTPO8FTMFZ .FZFS #0CKFDU0SJFOUFE4PGUXBSF$POTUSVDUJPO OEFE6QQFS4BEEMF3JWFS /+1SFOUJDF)BMM .ZMPQPVMPT + BOE ) -FWFTRVF "O PWFSWJFX PG LOPXMFEHF SFQSFTFOUBUJPO *O 0O $PODFQUVBM .PEFMMJOH1FSTQFDUJWFGSPN"Stiﬁcial *OUFMMJHFODF %BUBCBTFT BOE1SPHSBNNJOH-BOHVBHFT#SPEJF . +.ZMPQPVMPT BOE+4DINJEU &ET/FX:PSL4QSJOHFS7FSMBH Qo /BWZ$SZTUBM-BUUJDF4USVDUVSFT/BWBM3FTFBSDI-BCIUUQDTUXXXOSMOBWZNJMMBUUJDFJOEFYIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

/FJHICPST + %SBDP " NFUIPE GPS FOHJOFFSJOH SFVTBCMF TPGUXBSF TZTUFNT *O 4PGUXBSF 3FVTBCJMJUZ $PODFQUTBOE.PEFMT 7PM5+#iggerstaﬀ BOE"1FSMJT &ET3FBEJOH .""EEJTPO8FTMFZ"$. 1SFTT Qo 3FHJTUSZ3FHJTUSZPG4UBOEBSE#JPMPHJDBM1BSUT.*5IUUQQBSUTNJUFEVSFHJTUSZJOEFYQIQ.BJO@1BHF "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

4JNPOT 11BSUT"4UVEZJO0OUPMPHZ/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT 1BQFSCBDLFEJUJPO

5VSTLJ 8"OEOPQIJMPTPQIFSTTUPOF FJUIFS*O*OGPSNBUJPO1SPDFTTJOHA 1SPD*'*1$POHS )+ ,VHMFS &E %VCMJO o4FQUFNCFS"NTUFSEBN&MTFWJFS4DJFODF1VCMJTIFST#7 /PSUI)PMMBOE

Qo 5VSTLJ 8 BOE 5 .BJCBVN The 4peciﬁcation PG $PNQVUFS 1SPHSBNT 8PLJOHIBN &OHMBOE "EEJTPO8FTMFZ 8IJUFIFBE ""O*OUSPEVDUJPOUP.BUIFNBUJDT/FX:PSL)FOSZ)PMU$P 3FQVCMJTIFE/FX :PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT

Chapter 6

Composition Systems taxonomy 1

Modeling scope

SE Application Domains (D1...Dn)

Collective actualization space

D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn

Problem space

3a

TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b Traditional Complex

Characteristics of all systems

Highest level system

Deﬁne need

Complex 4 Traditional TS is special case 5 Characteristics of all SE systems Traditional and Complex 6

Model Space

All SE application domains...

Indivisible Unit Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Composition

TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b 2a Traditional systems Complex systems

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

$PNQPTJUJPO JT UIF EJNFOTJPO PG UIF .04&4 NPEFM TQBDF UIBU BEESFTTFT XIPMFT BOE QBSUT CBTFEPOUIFOPUJPOUIBUBTZTUFNDPOTJTUTPGUXP PSNPSFJOUFSBDUJOHQBSUTThJTDIBQUFSEJTDVTTFT DPNNPOTUBUJDBOEEZOBNJDNPEFMTPGDPNQPTJ UJPO JODMVEJOHTUBUJDTUSVDUVSFT EZOBNJDJOUFS BDUJPOT BOECPVOEBSJFT

Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

e

m

Ti

Produce solution

Deployment

Satisfy need

Solution/system space

Familiar Composition Elements and Characteristics Elements 8FTUBSUXJUIBDPNNPO4&TDFOBSJP OBNFMZBTJUVBUJPOJOXIJDIXFXBOUUPFOHJOFFSBDPNNFSDJBM BJSDSBGU8FXJMMDBMMUIJTPVSTZTUFNPGJOUFSFTU 40* "TTPDJBUFEXJUIPVS40*BSF ﬁWFFMFNFOUT PS UZQFTPGNPEFMT UIBUBSFDPNNPOMZEFﬁOFEJOUIFDPVSTFPGFOHJOFFSJOHUIF40*#FGPSFXFTUBUF XIBUUIFﬁWFBSF XFEJTDVTTUIFFYBNQMFTPUIBUXIFOXFJOUSPEVDFUIFﬁWFFMFNFOUT UIFZXJMMCF CFUUFSVOEFSTUPPE 8IFOXFBSFSFBEZUPEFTJHOBOECVJMEUIFBJSDSBGU XFDPOTJEFSTFWFSBMEJﬀFSFOUQFSTQFDUJWFT 0OF JT UIF TZTUFN BT B XIPMF 8IBU DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT TIPVME UIF BJSDSBGU IBWF XIBU QBTTFOHFS DBQBDJUZ XIBUSBOHF XIBUSFRVJSFEUBLFPﬀ aOEMBOEJOHEJTUBODFT XIBUTBGFUZGFBUVSFT FUD "OPUIFSQFSTQFDUJWFJTUIFTZTUFNBTQBSUTXIBUQBSUTTIPVMEUIFBJSDSBGUIBWFUPBDIJFWFUIF PWFSBMMDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT 8FBTTVNFUIBUXFBSFEFTJHOJOHBOECVJMEJOHBOFXBJSDSBGUFBSMZJOUIF UXFOUZﬁSTUDFOUVSZBOEXFIBWFTFWFSBMEFDBEFTPGFYQFSJFODFBWBJMBCMFUPVT TUBSUJOHXJUIUIF XFMMVOEFSTUPPEPQFSBUJOHQSJODJQMFPGﬁYFEXJOHBJSDSBGU'SPNUIJTXFIBWFFWPMWFEBDPNNPO DPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGUBSDIJUFDUVSFUIBUSFﬂFDUTUIFJOUFSOBMEPNBJOTBOETVQQPSUJOHEPNBJOTNFO UJPOFEQSFWJPVTMZ"QPXFSQMBOUDPOTJTUTPGBTFUPGUXPPSUISFFKFUFOHJOFTBOBJSGSBNFTUSVDUVSF QSPWJEFTUIFOFDFTTBSZTVSGBDFBOEBQSFTTVSJ[FEDBCJOGPSQBTTFOHFSTBDPNQVUFSTVCTZTUFNDPOTJTUT PGTPGUXBSF IBSEXBSF BOEOFUXPSLBOEBOBWJHBUJPOBOEﬂJHIUDPOUSPMTVCTZTUFNJODMVEFTTFO TPSTBOENFDIBOJDBMBDUVBUPSTBOEVTFTUIFDPNQVUFSTVCTZTUFN&BDITVCTZTUFNDBOCFEFTDSJCFE 129

130

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

TFQBSBUFMZBOECVJMUTFQBSBUFMZ*OGBDU NBOZPGUIFTVCTZTUFNTBSFEFTJHOFEBOECVJMUCZFOHJOFFST JOEJﬀFSFOUEPNBJOT"FSPOBVUJDBMFOHJOFFSTEFTJHOUIFBJSGSBNFTUSVDUVSFTBOEUIFKFUFOHJOFT TPGUXBSFBOEFMFDUSJDBMFOHJOFFSTEFTJHOUIFBWJPOJDTTVCTZTUFN BOENFDIBOJDBMFOHJOFFSTEFTJHO UIFOBWJHBUJPOBOEDPOUSPMBDUVBUPSTBOEIZESBVMJDT.BOZPGUIFTF TVDIBTUIFKFUFOHJOF NBZ CFEFTJHOFE CVJMU BOETVQQMJFECZBDPNQBOZTFQBSBUFGSPNUIFDPNQBOZCVJMEJOHUIFBJSDSBGU 4ZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTUBLFBMMUIFTVCTZTUFNTBOEQVUUIFNUPHFUIFSJOUPPOFDPIFSFOUTZTUFN *OUIJTEJTDVTTJPOPGTZTUFNBTQBSUT XFIBWFJNQMJDJUMZIJOUFEBUBOPUIFSBSDIJUFDUVSFQFSTQFD UJWFUIFSFMBUJPOTBOEJOUFSBDUJPOTBNPOHBMMUIFQBSUTPSTVCTZTUFNTThBUJT IPXEPBMMUIFQBSUT PSTVCTZTUFNTSFMBUFUPFBDIPUIFS BOEIPXEPUIFZJOUFSBDUTPUIBUUIFPWFSBMMGVODUJPOTPGBO BJSDSBGUBSFBDIJFWFE "OPUIFSQFSTQFDUJWFJTUIFBJSDSBGUFOWJSPONFOU XIJDIXFEFﬁOFBTUIFTFUPGFYUFSOBMFMFNFOUT UIBUJOUFSBDUEJSFDUMZXJUIUIFBJSDSBGU0OFFMFNFOUPGUIFFOWJSPONFOUJTUIFQIZTJDBMBUNPTQIFSF UIBUTVSSPVOETUIFBJSDSBGUXIJMFJUJTﬂZJOHBJSQSFTTVSF DMPVET UFNQFSBUVSF XJOE SBJO TVO FUD"OPUIFSFMFNFOUJTTFOEFSTBOESFDFJWFSTPGDPNNVOJDBUJPOTXJUIUIFBJSDSBGU TVDIBTBJSUSBG ﬁDDPOUSPMMFST"OPUIFSFMFNFOUJTUIFBJSQPSUSVOXBZTPOXIJDIUIFBJSDSBGUMBOETPSUBLFTPﬀ BOE UIFHBUFTBUXIJDIJUQBSLTGPSQBTTFOHFSTBOEGSFJHIUUPFOUFSPSFYJU"OPUIFSFMFNFOUJTUIFTFU PGPUIFSBJSDSBGUJOJUTWJDJOJUZ XIJDIJUXBOUTUPBWPJE"OPUIFSFMFNFOUJTUIFBJSMJOFUIBUPXOT UIFBJSDSBGU BOEUIFNFDIBOJDTBOETVQQPSUTUBﬀ XIPNBJOUBJOBOETFSWJDFJU%FQFOEJOHPOUIF QVSQPTFPGUIFNPEFM QBTTFOHFSTBOEDSFXNBZBMTPCFQBSUPGUIFFOWJSPONFOU "OPUIFSQFSTQFDUJWFJTUIFJOUFSBDUJOHFMFNFOUTPGUIFMBSHFSFODPNQBTTJOHTZTUFNPGXIJDI UIFBJSDSBGUJTBQBSUThJTJODMVEFTUIFSFMBUJPOTBOEJOUFSBDUJPOTBNPOHUIFTFFMFNFOUTUIFBJS DSBGU JUTFMG UIF BJSMJOF JOEVTUSZ UIF MBXT BOE SFHVMBUJPOT BOE MBXNBLFST BOE SFHVMBUPST UIBU HPWFSOBOEDPOTUSBJOUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOEVTBHFPGUIFBJSDSBGU BOEUIFFOUJSFJOGSBTUSVDUVSF UIBUFOBCMFTBJSUSBﬃc JODMVEJOHUIFTFUPGDPNNFSDJBMBJSQPSUT UIFBJSUSBﬃc DPOUSPMTZTUFN BMM UIFSPVUFTCFUXFFOUIFBJSQPSUT UIFFOFSHZDPNQBOJFTUIBUTVQQMZGVFM UIFTVQQMJFSTPGBJSDSBGU BOEBJSMJOFBOEBJSQPSUFRVJQNFOUBOETFSWJDFT UIFHMPCBMQPTJUJPOJOHTZTUFN DPNNVOJDBUJPOT OFUXPSLT BOEUIFMJLF*UDPVMEBMTPJODMVEFOBUJPOBMFOFSHZQPMJDZ CVTJOFTTUBYTUSVDUVSFBOE SBUFT UIFPWFSBMMOBUJPOBMFDPOPNJDIFBMUI BOEJOUFSOBUJPOBMDJSDVNTUBODFTUIBUDBOBﬀFDUFOFSHZ TVQQMJFTBOEQPTTJCMFEFTUJOBUJPOTUIBUUIFBJSMJOFDBOTFSWJDF

Characteristics ThFQFSTQFDUJWFTXFIBWFQSFTFOUFEBSFBMMSFMBUFEJOTPNFXBZUPUIFBJSDSBGUBTUIF40*ThFTF QFSTQFDUJWFTBSF UIF40*BTBXIPMF UIF40*BTQBSUT UIF40*BTBTFUPGSFMBUJPOTIJQTBOE JOUFSBDUJPOTBNPOHQBSUT UIFEJSFDUFOWJSPONFOUPGUIF40*BOEJUTJOUFSBDUJPOXJUIUIF40* BOE UIFJOUFSBDUJPOTBNPOHUIFFMFNFOUTPGUIFMBSHFSFODPNQBTTJOHTZTUFNPGUIF40* *OUIJTTFDUJPOXFEJTDVTTBOEFYUFOEUIFTFQFSTQFDUJWFTBOEUIFJSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT"QSPNJOFOU DIBSBDUFSJTUJDJNQMJFECZUIJTTFUPGﬁWFQFSTQFDUJWFTJTUIFDPODFQUPGNVMUJMFWFMDPNQPTJUJPOIJFS BSDIZ"OBJSDSBGUJTQBSUPGBMBSHFSTZTUFNPGBJSMJOFT BJSQPSUT FUD*OUVSO BOFOHJOFJTQBSUPGBO BJSDSBGU"MUIPVHIXFEJEOPUNFOUJPOJU FBDITVCTZTUFNDBOCFDPOTJEFSFEBXIPMFTZTUFNXJUI JUTPXOQBSUT"OFOHJOFJTBTZTUFNUIBUIBTQBSUTUIJTEFDPNQPTJUJPODBOCFDPOUJOVFEEPXOUP UIFOVUTBOECPMUTMFWFMPSFWFOEPXOUPUIFMFWFMPGBUPNTThFDPNQVUFSTVCTZTUFNJTBTZTUFN UIBUIBTQBSUTJUDBOCFEFDPNQPTFEJOUPDPNQVUFSIBSEXBSF TPGUXBSF BOEOFUXPSLJOH BOEFBDI 54&XPVMEWJFXEFDPNQPTJUJPOUPUIFMFWFMPGBUPNBTFYUSFNFBOEPVUPGTDPQFCVUCFDBVTF4&OPXJODMVEFT OBOPUFDIOPMPHZ JODMVEJOHGPSBJSDSBGU UIJTMFWFMXPVMEOPUCFFYUSFNF

Composition

O 131

PGUIPTFDBOCFGVSUIFSEFDPNQPTFEGPSFYBNQMF UIFTPGUXBSFEPXOUPJOEJWJEVBMMJOFTPGDPEF PSFWFOGVSUIFSUPJOEJWJEVBMTZNCPMMFWFM ThJTNVMUJMFWFMIPMBSDIZTUSVDUVSFNFBOTUIBUFOHJOFFSTPSPUIFSTUBLFIPMEFSTOFFEUPEFﬁOF UIFJSMFWFMBOETZTUFNPGJOUFSFTUThBUJTXIBU40*JTGPSUPEFTJHOBUFDMFBSMZXIBUTZTUFNJT CFJOHDPOTJEFSFEJOBNVMUJMFWFMBOENVMUJTZTUFNDPOUFYU8FEJTDVTTUIJTﬁSTUJOBUSBEJUJPOBM TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 54& TDPQF5PBQPMJDZNBLFS UIFFOUJSFBJSMJOFJOEVTUSZNJHIUCFUIF40* 5PBTZTUFNTFOHJOFFS UIFBJSDSBGUNJHIUCFUIF40*5PBDPNQVUFSTZTUFNTFOHJOFFS UIFTZTUFN PGDPNQVUFSIBSEXBSF TPGUXBSF BOEOFUXPSLTPOUIFBJSDSBGUNJHIUCFUIF40*5PBTPGUXBSF FOHJOFFS UIFTPGUXBSFNJHIUCFUIF40*"OEUPBOBFSPOBVUJDBMPSBKFUQSPQVMTJPOFOHJOFFS UIF QPXFSQMBOUPSBTJOHMFFOHJOF NJHIUCFUIF40* *OUIFTDPQFPGUIFFYUFOEFE4&EJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFSTBOE UIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSSPMFDBOCF FYQBOEFE'PSFYBNQMF JOBEEJUJPOUPUIFBJSDSBGU UIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSNBZCSJOHBOFOHJOFFSJOH BQQSPBDIUPUIFMBSHFSFODPNQBTTJOHTZTUFNUPBEESFTTJTTVFTTVDIBTBOBMZTJTPGBMUFSOBUJWFBJSMJOF SFHVMBUPSZBQQSPBDIFT FOFSHZQPMJDJFT BJSQPSUBOESPVUFQMBOOJOH BOEDPOTUSBJOUTCBTFEPOQSP KFDUFEJODSFBTFTJOBJSUSBﬃc PWFSUIFOFYUEFDBEFPSNBZCFIPXBMMUIFTFGBDUPSTBﬀFDUFBDIPUIFS "OPUIFSFYBNQMFJTTDBMFEPXONBZCFUIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSXJMMCFJOWPMWFEJOFYBNJOJOHIPX OBOPNBUFSJBMTDBOCFVTFEUPBDIJFWFEFTJSFENBDSPGFBUVSFTBUUIFBJSDSBGUMFWFM

Common Structure Models &BDIQFSTQFDUJWFPOUIFBJSDSBGU40*JOUIFQSFWJPVTTFDUJPOJTOPXHFOFSBMJ[FEUPBDPSSFTQPOEJOH TFUPGNPEFMTPSWJFXTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBO40*. ThFTFDPNNPOWJFXTBSF

4ZTUFNBTXIPMF8IBUBSFUIFQSPQFSUJFTBOECFIBWJPSPGUIFTZTUFNBTBXIPMF 4ZTUFNBTQBSUT8IBUBSFUIFQSPQFSUJFTBOECFIBWJPSPGFBDIQBSUPGUIFTZTUFN 4ZTUFNBTDPOOFDUJPOPGQBSUT)PXBSFUIFQBSUTSFMBUFE )PXEPUIFZJOUFSBDU 4ZTUFNFOWJSPONFOUDPOOFDUJPO8IBUFMFNFOUTJOUFSBDUXJUIPVS40* )PXEPFTPVSTZT UFNSFMBUFUPUIPTFFMFNFOUT &ODPNQBTTJOHTZTUFNDPOOFDUJPO8IBUMBSHFSTZTUFNFODPNQBTTFTPVS40* *OBEEJUJPOUP PVS40*BTBQBSU XIBUPUIFSQBSUTFYJTUJOUIFMBSHFSTZTUFN BOEIPXEPBMMUIFTFQBSUT SFMBUFBOEJOUFSBDU

0VS40*JTUZQJDBMMZBOFOEUBSHFUTZTUFN BTEFﬁOFEJO$IBQUFS5SBEJUJPOBM40*TJO4& JODMVEFPVSFYBNQMFPGBDPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGU BNBKPSNJMJUBSZXFBQPOTTZTUFN BQPXFSQMBOU FUD40*TPGUIFFYQBOEFE4&JODMVEFBNJMJUBSZDPBMJUJPO BOPSHBOJ[BUJPOTUSVDUVSF BUSBOTQPSUB UJPOTZTUFN BIFBMUIDBSFTZTUFN JODMVEJOHBSFTQPOTFUPQPUFOUJBMFQJEFNJDT

BQPXFSHSJE PSB TPDJFUBMTZTUFNTVDIBTBOPWFSBMMSFUJSFNFOUTZTUFN

Basic Model Types 4VQQPTFXFIBWFBO40*4UIBUIBTQBSUT4 4 4 BOE44JOUFSBDUTXJUI4BOE4 JOJUTFOWJSPONFOU BOE4JTQBSUPGTZTUFN4 XIJDIIBTQBSUT4 4 4 BOE4ThFﬁWFWJFXT BTTPDJBUFEXJUI4 MBCFMFE7UP7 BSFEFQJDUFEJO'JHVSF

7JFXTBSFEJTDVTTFEJOEFUBJMJO$IBQUFS'PSUIFQSFTFOUEJTDVTTJPO TJNQMZBTTVNFUIBUBWJFXJTBNPEFM

132

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

V5: Connection among parts of encompassing system S

S

S4

S2

V4: S1 environment connection

S3

S1

S1

S1

S11

S12

V2: S1 as parts

S13

S14

V3: Connection among S1 parts

V1: S1 as whole V1..V5 = Views 1–5 associated with system of interest S1 = Port; point of interaction or connection of a system with its environment = Connector; locus of relation, connection, interaction among systems or components

Figure 6.1

Common views associated with a system of interest.

*O.04&4 XIFOBNPEFMDPSSFTQPOETUPPSJTMJOLFEUPBUBSHFU JU JT JNQPSUBOU UP NBLF FYQMJDJUXIBUUIFUBSHFUJT UIBUJT XIBUBNPEFMJTNPEFMJOH. ThJTNBZTPVOEMJLFTPNFUIJOHUIBU JTUSJWJBMBOEPCWJPVTBOEUIBUDPVMECFMFGUJNQMJDJU#VUJOPVSFYQFSJFODF UIFUBSHFUPGBNPEFM JT TVSQSJTJOHMZ PGUFOOPUDMFBS PSJTBTTVNFECZEJﬀFSFOUPCTFSWFSTUPCFEJﬀFSFOUUBSHFUT 8FOPUFEUIBUUIFﬁWFWJFXTBSFBMMNPEFMTPSNPEFMUZQFT BOEXFDBOSFHBSEPVS40*4BT BUBSHFUTZTUFN#VUUIFSFJTBSFBTPOXFTBJE'JHVSFTIPXTWJFXTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBTZTUFNPG JOUFSFTU SBUIFSUIBOWJFXTPGBTZTUFNPGJOUFSFTU"O40*JTOPUUIFUBSHFUTZTUFNPGBMMUIFNPEFMT WJFXT BTTPDJBUFEXJUIJU7JFXT7BOE7BSFWJFXTPG4 TPUIFZBSFNPEFMTXIPTFUBSHFUTZTUFN JT JOGBDU UIF40*4 7DBOCFSFHBSEFEBTBWJFXPGUIFTFUPG4QBSUT \4 4 4 4^ JOXIJDIDBTF4JTUIF UBSHFUTZTUFNPGUIFNPEFM7#VU7DBOBMTPCFSFHBSEFEBTBTFUPGGPVSTFQBSBUFNPEFMT BO FYUFSOBMNPEFMPGFBDIQBSU 4 FUD

JOXIJDIDBTFFBDI7NPEFMIBTBEJﬀFSFOUUBSHFUTZTUFN BOEOPOFPGUIFNBSFUIF40*48IJDIJTUIFQSFGFSBCMFXBZUPSFHBSE7 8FMFBOUPXBSEUIF TFDPOEQFSTQFDUJWFUIBUJT 7BTBTFUPGGPVSNPEFMT BTFQBSBUFFYUFSOBMNPEFMPGFBDIQBSU0OF SFBTPOJTUIBUUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGBMMQBSUTDPOTJEFSFEUPHFUIFSJTBEESFTTFEBEFRVBUFMZJO7 UIF DPOOFDUJPOBNPOHBMMUIFQBSUT"TFDPOESFBTPOJTUIBUUIFTFGPVSTFQBSBUFNPEFMTBSFVTFGVMGPS TQFDJﬁDBUJPONBUDIJOHJOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOPGQSFCVJMUQBSUTThJTMBUUFSUPQJDJTCSJFﬂZEJTDVTTFE JOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi$PNQPTJUJPO3FMBUFE1SPDFTTFTwJOUIJTDIBQUFS BOEBEESFTTFEGVSUIFSJO $IBQUFS 7JTTUSBJHIUGPSXBSE*UJTBNPEFMPG4UIBUJT JUJTBNPEFMXIPTFUBSHFUTZTUFNJT47JT MJLF7 JOUFSQSFUBCMFJOUXPXBZT#FDBVTFJUJTEFﬁOFEGSPNUIFWJFXQPJOUPG4 BOEJUJTUIF FOWJSPONFOUPG4 POFDPVMEBSHVFUIBUUIFUBSHFUTZTUFNPG7JT4#VUXFBSHVFGPSBTFDPOE JOUFSQSFUBUJPO7JTOPUKVTUBNPEFMPG4JUJTBNPEFMPG4JOUFSBDUJOHXJUIJUTFOWJSPONFOU TP UIFUBSHFUJTUIFDPNCJOBUJPOPG4BOEJUTFOWJSPONFOU

Composition

O 133

Variations ThF CBTJD NPEFM UZQFT JO 'JHVSF SFQSFTFOU WBSJBUJPOT PG CPUI JOUFSOBM BOE FYUFSOBM NPEFM DBUFHPSJFT

Internal Model Variations ThFﬁSTUWBSJBUJPOJTUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFMXFKVTUEJTDVTTFE"GVMMJOUFSOBMNPEFMJODMVEFTBMMUIF QBSUTPGBTZTUFNBOEUIFJSDPOOFDUJPOT BTJO7 JOUFSOBMNPEFMPG4 PS7 JOUFSOBMNPEFMPG4 "OFOWJSPONFOUDPOOFDUJPONPEFMJTEFﬁOFEXJUISFTQFDUUP PSGSPNUIFWJFXQPJOUPG BHJWFO QBSUJUJODMVEFTPOMZUIFQBSUTUIBUDPOOFDUXJUIUIFHJWFOQBSU BOEJUJODMVEFTPOMZUIFDPOOFDUJPOT XJUIUIFHJWFOQBSU BTJO7XIFSFUIFHJWFOQBSUJT41BSUTBOEDPOOFDUJPOTOPUWJTJCMFJOUIF4 FOWJSPONFOU FWFOJGQSFTFOUJOBGVMMTZTUFNTVDIBT4 BSFFYDMVEFEGSPNUIFFOWJSPONFOUNPEFM /PUFUIBUBOFOWJSPONFOUNPEFMDBOCFEFﬁOFEXJUISFTQFDUUPFBDIQBSUThVT JO'JHVSFXF DPVMEIBWFEFﬁOFETFQBSBUFFOWJSPONFOUNPEFMTGPS4 4 BOE4 SFTQFDUJWFMZ8FDPVMEBMTP IBWFEFﬁOFEFOWJSPONFOUNPEFMTJOUFSOBMUP4GPS4 4 4 BOE4 SFTQFDUJWFMZ 8IBU IBQQFOT JG B HJWFO QBSU DPOOFDUT XJUI FWFSZ PUIFS QBSU PG B TZTUFN %PFT UIJT NFBO UIFFOWJSPONFOUNPEFMPGUIBUHJWFOQBSUJTFRVJWBMFOUUPUIFPWFSBMMDPOOFDUJPONPEFMGPSUIBU TZTUFN $POTJEFS4JO'JHVSF4VQQPTFXFBEEFEBDPOOFDUJPOCFUXFFO4BOE48PVME UIBUNBLFUIF4FOWJSPONFOUNPEFM7FRVJWBMFOUUPUIF4DPOOFDUJPONPEFM7 /PThF4 FOWJSPONFOUNPEFM7XPVMETUJMMOPUJODMVEFUIFDPOOFDUJPOTCFUXFFO4BOE4 BOECFUXFFO 4BOE4 CPUIPGXIJDIBSFQBSUPGUIFDPOOFDUJPONPEFM7

External Model Variations ThFTFDPOEWBSJBUJPOPGCBTJDNPEFMUZQFTJO'JHVSFJTBWBSJBUJPOPGFYUFSOBMNPEFMT TQFDJﬁ DBMMZNPEFM7PG4/PUJDFUIBU7QPJOUTUPUXPNPEFMJOTUBODFTPG4ThFTFBSFUIFWBSJBUJPOT ThFUPQPOFTIPXT7BTBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPG4JOUIFDPOUFYUPG4ThFCPUUPNPOFTIPXT7 BTBTUBOEBMPOFFYUFSOBMNPEFMPG4ThFUPQNPEFMEFﬁOFTBTQFDJﬁDFOWJSPONFOUGPS4BOE JTDBMMFEBDPOUFYUTQFDJﬁDFYUFSOBMNPEFMThFCPUUPNNPEFMEPFTOPUEFﬁOFBOZTQFDJﬁDFOWJ SPONFOUGPS4BOEJTDBMMFEBDPOUFYUHFOFSBMFYUFSOBMNPEFM"MUIPVHIJOTPNFJOTUBODFTUIF UXPWBSJBUJPOTNBZCFFRVJWBMFOU JOHFOFSBMUIJTJTBOJNQPSUBOUEJTUJODUJPO8FHJWFUISFFCSJFG FYBNQMFTBNPMFDVMF BTPGUXBSFDPNQPOFOU BOEBIVNBO 4NBMM NPMFDVMFT DBMMFE NPOPNFST DBO DPNQPTF UIFNTFMWFT JOUP MBSHF NPMFDVMFT DBMMFE QPMZNFST"OFYBNQMFJTTIPXOJO'JHVSF ,JSDIOFSTFFBMTP.JMMFS o 5XPBNJOPBDJENPOPNFST BOBMPHPVTUP4BOE4JO4JO'JHVSF BSFTIPXO JO UIFJS TUBOEBMPOF DPOUFYUHFOFSBM GPSN JO UIF VQQFS QBSU PG 'JHVSF BOE JO UIFJS DPNQPTFEcontext-speciﬁc GPSNPOUIFMPXFSQBSUThe UXPFOUJUJFTJOUIFTIBEFECPYJO UIFVQQFSQBSU 0)NPMFDVMFBOE)BUPN BSFSFNPWFE JOUIFGPSNPGBXBUFSNPMFDVMF XIFOUIFUXPNPOPNFSTDPNCJOFThis DIBOHFDPSSFTQPOETUP4JO'JHVSF XIFSFUIF UIJSEEPUPOUIFCPVOEBSZPG4JOJUTTUBOEBMPOFGPSNJTSFNPWFEXIFO4JTDPNQPTFE JO4*UJTBMTPBOFYBNQMFPGNVUBCMFDPNQPTJUJPO XIJDIJTEJTDVTTFECFMPXJOUIFTFDUJPO FOUJUMFEi$PNQPTJUJPO1SPQFSUJFTw 4VQQPTF4JO'JHVSFJTBTPGUXBSFDPNQPOFOUUIBUPﬀFSTUISFFGFBUVSFTPSTFSWJDFT TVDIBTJEFOUJﬁDBUJPO BVUIFOUJDBUJPO BOEBVUIPSJ[BUJPO SFQSFTFOUFECZUIFUISFFEPUTPO UIFCPVOEBSZPGDPOUFYUHFOFSBMJ[FE4"OETVQQPTFUIBUUIF4FOWJSPONFOUPOMZOFFET

134

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science H

H N H

C

O C

N H

N OH H

H H

H

H

O C OH

H

H

O

H

H

C

C

N

C

H

C

H

O C OH

Peptide Bond A molecule of water is removed from two glycine amino acids to form a peptide bond.

Figure 6.2 Example of context-speciﬁc and context-general external models. (Source: Kirchner, G. Self-Instructional on Biological Molecules: Organic Compounds. http://homepages.ius.edu/ GKIRCHNE/biomolec.htm. 2001. Used with permission.)

UXPPGUIFTFGFBUVSFT SFQSFTFOUFECZUIFUXPEPUTJOUIF4DPOUFYUThFHFOFSBMNPEFMPG 4TQFDJﬁFECZUIFDPNQPOFOUWFOEPSJODMVEFTBMMUISFFGFBUVSFT8IFOUIFDPNQPOFOUJT CSPVHIUJOUPUIF4DPOUFYU POMZUXPPGUIF4GFBUVSFTBSFVTFE TPUIPTFBSFUIFPOMZUXP JODMVEFEJOUIF4FYUFSOBMNPEFMJOUIF4DPOUFYU $POTJEFSBIVNBOCFJOHBT48IBUUZQFPGCFIBWJPSXJMMUIFQFSTPOFYIJCJU 8FDBO OPUTBZNVDILOPXJOHPOMZUIJTJOGPSNBUJPO#VUJGXFQVUBQFSTPOJOBTQFDJﬁDDPOUFYU PSSPMF TVDIBTBTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSPOBQSPKFDUUFBN BNFNCFSPGBQPLFSDMVC BQBS FOUPGBQSFTDIPPMDIJME PSBDPBDIPGBCBTFCBMMUFBN XFDBOCFNVDINPSFEFﬁOJUJWF BCPVUXIBUUZQFPGCFIBWJPSUIFQFSTPOXJMMFYIJCJUThFUISFFEPUTPOUIFTUBOEBMPOF4 CPVOEBSZSFQSFTFOUUIFNBOZQPTTJCMFCFIBWJPSUZQFTUIFQFSTPONJHIUFYIJCJU BOEUIF UXPEPUTPOUIF4CPVOEBSZJOUIF4DPOUFYUSFQSFTFOUUIFNPSFTQFDJﬁDTVCTFUEFﬁOFE JOUIBUDPOUFYUThBUJT 4NJHIUCFBOZPGUIFDPOUFYUTMJTUFEBCPWF TVDIBTBQSPKFDU UFBN *OHFOFSBM UIFHSFBUFSUIFWBSJFUZPGCFIBWJPSTBTZTUFNDBOFYIJCJU UIFCJHHFSUIFEJﬀFSFODF CFUXFFOBDPOUFYUTQFDJﬁDNPEFMBOEBDPOUFYUHFOFSBMNPEFM0GUIFUISFFFYBNQMFTHJWFOIFSF UIFIVNBOIBT CZGBS UIFMBSHFTUWBSJFUZPGQPUFOUJBMCFIBWJPST(SFBUFSWBSJFUZJNQMJFTBCJMJUZUP CFVTFGVMJONPSFFOWJSPONFOUT ThFMBSHFEJﬀFSFODFJOQSFEJDUBCJMJUZCFUXFFODPOUFYUHFOFSBMBOEDPOUFYUTQFDJﬁDCFIBWJPS PG IVNBOT TIPXT UIF JNQPSUBODF PG SPMFT JO OBSSPXJOH UIFJS CFIBWJPS BOE JODSFBTJOH UIFJS QSFEJDUBCJMJUZ "UBZ BOE +PTU EJTDVTT UIF UFOEFODZ UP DPOTJEFS B DPNQMFY TZTUFN BT FNFSHJOHGSPNWFSZTJNQMFQBSUT CVUUIFZQPJOUPVUBGBDUUIBUJTJNQPSUBOUUP4&BOEFTQF DJBMMZ UIF OFX DPNQMFY BTQFDUT PG 4& 3FBMXPSME DPNQMFY TZTUFNT UZQJDBMMZ IBWF DPNQMFY QBSUT'VSUIFSNPSF BOENPSFJNQPSUBOUMZ UIFCFIBWJPSPGBDPNQMFYQBSUJOBOVODPOTUSBJOFE FOWJSPONFOUJTEJﬃDVMUUPQSFEJDUCVUUIFCFIBWJPSPGUIBUQBSUJOBOFOWJSPONFOUJTIJHIMZ DPOTUSBJOFEBOENVDINPSFQSFEJDUBCMFThJTJTFTQFDJBMMZUSVFGPSDPNQMFYTZTUFNTUIBUBSF DPOTJEFSFEBVUPOPNPVTThJTQIFOPNFOPOJTXIBUNBLFTSFBTPOBCMFUIFQSPQPTJUJPOUIBUXF DBOTQFDJGZUIFCFIBWJPSPGIVNBOTBOEPUIFSBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUTBTDPNQPOFOUTPGBTZTUFN TFF$IBQUFS

Composition

O 135

Relation and Interaction Models ThJTTFDUJPOCVJMETPOUIFDPOOFDUJPOPOUPMPHZEFﬁOFEJO$IBQUFS*OUIFEJTDVTTJPOUIBUGPM MPXT JOUFSBDUJPOJTJOUFOEFEUPJODMVEFTUBUJDSFMBUJPOBOEEZOBNJDJOUFSBDUJPO5SBEJUJPOBMMZ UIF FNQIBTJTJOFOHJOFFSJOHEPDVNFOUBUJPOIBTBSHVBCMZCFFONPSFPOQBSUTBOEMFTTPOJOUFSBDUJPOT BNPOH QBSUT ThJT FNQIBTJT JT SFﬂFDUFE JO UIF MBSHF NBKPSJUZ PG EJBHSBNT PG CPYFT BOE MJOFT TVDIBTCMPDLEJBHSBNT OFUXPSLEJBHSBNT IJFSBSDIZDIBSUT BOEQSPDFTTEJBHSBNT ThFTFUZQJ DBMMZJEFOUJGZUIFCPYFTCVUOPUUIFMJOFT UIBUJT JEFOUJGZUIFDPNQPOFOUTCVUOPUUIFSFMBUJPOT PSJOUFSBDUJPOT)PXFWFS UIFMJUFSBUVSFPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNTTDJFODFIBTNBEFDMFBSUIFJNQPS UBODFPGJOUFSBDUJPOTPGUIFQBSUTPGBTZTUFNThFJOUFSBDUJPOTBSFPGUFOBUMFBTUBTJNQPSUBOUBT UIFQBSUTJOEFUFSNJOJOHUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGBTZTUFN#FDBVTFPGUIJT .04&4SFHBSETCPUI TZTUFNTBOEJOUFSBDUJPOTCFUXFFOTZTUFNTBTﬁSTUDMBTTFOUJUJFTJOUIFPOUPMPHZPGTZTUFNTBOE TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 8FﬁSTUEFWFMPQUIFCBTJDDPODFQUTPGJOUFSBDUJPOTBNPOHQBSUTPSDPNQPOFOUTVTJOHBCJOBSZ JOUFSBDUJPO UIBUJT BOJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOUXPDPNQPOFOUTThFOXFEFTDSJCFBEEJUJPOBMDPODFQUT GPS/BSZJOUFSBDUJPOT UIBUJT JOUFSBDUJPOTBNPOHNVMUJQMFDPNQPOFOUT *OPVSEJTDVTTJPOPGJOUFSBDUJPOTJOUIJTDIBQUFS XFTPNFUJNFTDBMMUIFJOUFSBDUJOHFMFNFOUT DPNQPOFOUTBOEPUIFSUJNFTTZTUFNT*OHFOFSBM XFSFHBSEDPNQPOFOUBOETZTUFNBTTZOPOZNT PSSPMFT JOUIFTFOTFUIBUCPUIBSFIPMPOTBTZTUFNJTBDPNQPOFOUPGBMBSHFSTZTUFN

Binary Relation and Interaction Model )PXEPXFNPEFMSFMBUJPOTBOEJOUFSBDUJPOTCFUXFFOUXPDPNQPOFOUTJOBXBZUIBUQSPWJEFTTPNF TVCTUBODFCVUBUUIFTBNFUJNFTVQQPSUTBXJEFWBSJFUZPGTJUVBUJPOT 'PSFYBNQMF XFXBOUPVS NPEFMUPTVQQPSUSFMBUJPOTBOEJOUFSBDUJPOTTVDIBT O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O

5XPBUPNTDPNCJOJOHJOUPBNPMFDVMF 5XPDFMMTJOUFSBDUJOH "EBNJOUFSBDUJOHXJUIBSJWFS "OBJSDSBGUJOUFSBDUJOHXJUIBOBJSUSBﬃc cPOUSPMTZTUFN "OBJSDSBGUPXOFECZBDPNQBOZ "OBJSDSBGUPQFSBUFECZBOBJSMJOF 5XPQFPQMFDPNNVOJDBUJOH WJBGBDFUPGBDFDPOWFSTBUJPO TJHOMBOHVBHF UBMLJOHPOUIF QIPOF FYDIBOHJOHFNBJM PSWJBB8FCTJUF 5XPQFPQMFIBWJOHUIFTBNFQBSFOUT JF UIFZBSFTJCMJOHT

5XPQFPQMFJOBDPOﬂJDU TVDIBTPQQPTJOHTPMEJFSTJOBCBUUMF 5XPQFPQMFDPNQFUJOHBOEDPPQFSBUJOH TVDIBTJOBDIFTTNBUDIPSJOPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTFUUJOHT 5XPDPVOUSJFTJOUFSBDUJOHBTUSBEFQBSUOFST 5XPDPVOUSJFTJOBSNFEDPOﬂJDUXJUIFBDIPUIFS 5XPDPVOUSJFTIBWJOHBUSFBUZXJUIFBDIPUIFS "QFSTPOJOUFSBDUJOHXJUIBNBDIJOF TVDIBTBDBS "QFSTPOJOUFSBDUJOHXJUIB8FCTJUFWJBB8FCCSPXTFS "QFSTPOPQFSBUJOHB8FCTJUF "QFSTPOJOUFSBDUJOHXJUIBOPSHBOJ[BUJPO TVDIBTBQQMZJOHGPSBKPC PSBDVTUPNFSXJUI BDPNQBOZ 4PGUXBSFJOUFSBDUJOHXJUIPUIFSTPGUXBSF TVDIBTTFOEJOHBNFTTBHFPSJOWPLJOHBTFSWJDF 4PGUXBSFDPOUBJOFEBTBNPEVMFXJUIJOPUIFSTPGUXBSF

136

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O "OPSHBOJ[BUJPOJOUFSBDUJOHXJUIBOBUVSBMTZTUFN TVDIBTUIF"SNZ$PSQTPG&OHJOFFST JOUFSBDUJOHXJUh a ﬂ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ﬀ JTFYDIBOHFE SPMFTUIBUFBDIQBSUZQMBZTJOUIFJOUFSBDUJPO BOEBQSPUPDPMPSTFUPGDPOTUSBJOUT POUIFJOUFSBDUJPO8FDBMMUIFFOEQBSUJFTUIFDPNQPOFOUT BOEXFDBMMUIFDPOOFDUPSQBSUZUIF DPOOFDUPS*OBEEJUJPO JOTPNFDBTFT BTFSWJDFJTQSPWJEFECZPOFDPNQPOFOUBOEDPOTVNFECZ UIFPUIFSDPNQPOFOU*OUIFTFDBTFT UIFDPNQPOFOUTQMBZUIFBEEJUJPOBMSFTQFDUJWFSPMFTPGTFSWJDF QSPWJEFSBOETFSWJDFDPOTVNFSThJTHFOFSBMDPNQPOFOUDPOOFDUPSNPEFMXBTEFWFMPQFEJOUIF T JO UIF TPGUXBSF BSDIJUFDUVSF SFTFBSDI DPNNVOJUZ TFF GPS FYBNQMF 4IBX BOE (BSMBO BOE"MMFOBOE(BSMBO ThFCBTJDCJOBSZJOUFSBDUJPONPEFMJTTIPXOJO'JHVSF VTJOHBTFSWJDFQSPWJEFSBOEDPO TVNFSQBUUFSO XIJDI BTTUBUFEJO$IBQUFS JTJOUFOEFEUPCFUIFHFOFSBMJOUFSBDUJPOUFSNJOPMPHZ ThJTNPEFMBQQMJFTUPBOZCJOBSZJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOTZTUFNT JODMVEJOHUIFJOUFSBDUJPOFYBNQMFT JOUIFMJTUHJWFOBCPWF *O UIF CJOBSZ JOUFSBDUJPO NPEFM FBDI PG UIF UXP FOE QBSUJFT 4 BOE 4 JT NPEFMFE BT BO FODBQTVMBUFETZTUFNXJUIEFﬁOFEBDDFTTQPJOUTJOJUTCPVOEBSZDBMMFEQPSUTThFJOUFSBDUJPOBMTP JODMVEFTUIFDPOOFDUPS/ UIFTUVﬀ FYDIBOHFE T

UIFQSPUPDPMPSDPOTUSBJOUTPOUIFJOUFSBDUJPO BOEUIFTZTUFNSPMFT4JTTFSWJDFDPOTVNFSBOE4JTTFSWJDFQSPWJEFS/PUFUIBUUIFSPMFQMBZFECZ BTZTUFNJOBOJOUFSBDUJPOJTEFﬁOFECZUIFDPOOFDUPS OPUCZUIFTZTUFNThJTSFﬂFDUTUIFGBDUUIBU

!

!

! !!%%

& #

!!%%

& !

p, r "# s#'$

# %

Figure 6.3 Basic binary interaction model. (Source: Hybertson, D. Using a speciﬁcation approach to facilitate component testing. In Testing Commercial-off-the-Shelf Components and Systems, S. Beydeda and V. Gruhn, Eds. New York: Springer-Verlag, p. 213–237, 2005. Used with permission of Springer Science + Business Media.)

Composition

O 137

JOHFOFSBM BOFOWJSPONFOUPGBTZTUFNEFﬁOFTUIFSPMFQMBZFECZUIFTZTUFNJOUIBUFOWJSPONFOU BTXFEJTDVTTMBUFSJOUIFDIBQUFS "MUIPVHI'JHVSFTIPXTBQSPWJEFEBOESFRVJSFETFSWJDF UIFDPODFQUTPGDPNQFUJUJPOBOE EJTTFSWJDFGSPN$IBQUFSBSFBMTPJNQMJDJUJOUIJTCBTJDNPEFM ThF 6OJﬁFE .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF 6.- EFﬁOFT UXP UZQFT PG DPOOFDUPST B EFMFHBUJPO DPOOFDUPSBOE BOBTTFNCMZDPOOFDUPS 0.( ThF6.-DPODFQUPGBTTFNCMZDPOOFDUPS DPSSFTQPOETUPUIF.04&4DPOOFDUPSJOUIFDBTFXIFSFBTFSWJDFJTJOWPMWFEJOBOJOUFSBDUJPO ThF 6.- EFMFHBUJPO DPOOFDUPS DPSSFTQPOET QBSUJBMMZ UP .04&4 EFMFHBUJPO BOE QSPQBHBUJPO XIJDIBSFEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi3FMBUJPOT#FUXFFO8IPMFTBOE1BSUTw ThFGPSFHPJOHEJTDVTTJPOIBTFNQIBTJ[FEGFBUVSFTUIBUBSFDPNNPOUPBMMJOUFSBDUJOHQBJSTPG BOZUZQF BMPOHXJUITPNFBEEJUJPOBMGFBUVSFTPGTFSWJDFJOUFSBDUJPOTThFHFOFSBMJOUFSBDUJPONPE FMTHJWFOJOUIJTTFDUJPO BTXFMMBTUIF/BSZNPEFMTPGUIFOFYUTFDUJPO BSFJOUFOEFEUPBQQMZUP CPUINBDIJOFTBOEIVNBOT8FEJTDVTTNFDIBOJTNTGPSEFTDSJCJOHdiﬀFSFODFTJOMBUFSDIBQUFST FTQFDJBMMZ$IBQUFSTBOE

N-ary Relation/Interaction Models 4ZTUFNTJOHFOFSBMIBWFNPSFUIBOUXPQBSUTPSDPNQPOFOUTThFCJOBSZNPEFMHJWFTVTNVDIJOGPS NBUJPOBCPVUJOUFSBDUJPOTJOHFOFSBMCVUXFBMTPOFFEUPMPPLBUSFMBUJPOTPSJOUFSBDUJPOTJOXIJDI POFPSNPSFDPOOFDUPSTMJOLNVMUJQMFDPNQPOFOUT"DPOOFDUJPOBNPOHNVMUJQMFDPNQPOFOUTDBO CFNPEFMFECZBOFUXPSL.PSFHFOFSBMMZ XFDBOVTFJEFBTGSPNUIFNBUIFNBUJDBM ﬁFMETPGHSBQI UIFPSZBOEUPQPMPHZUPNPEFMUIFTFSFMBUJPOTThFHSBQIDPODFQUTPGOPEF QPJOU BOEWFSUFYDPS SFTQPOEUPDPNQPOFOUT BOEUIFHSBQIDPODFQUTPGFEHFBOEMJOFDPSSFTQPOEUPDPOOFDUPST*OUIF HFOFSBMDBTF UIFMJOFTPSFEHFTPGBHSBQIBSFUPQPMPHJDBMFMFNFOUT XIJDITJNQMZNFBOT BNPOH PUIFSUIJOHT UIBUUIFZBSFVOEJSFDUFEBOEUIFDPODFQUPGMFOHUIEPFTOPUBQQMZThFMJOFTPSFEHFT NBZCFBTTJHOFEBEJSFDUJPO JOXIJDIDBTFUIFZBSFDBMMFEBSDT BSSPXT PSEJSFDUFEFEHFT BOEUIF HSBQIJTDBMMFEBEJSFDUFEHSBQIPSBEJHSBQI*OBEEJUJPO UIFFEHFTNBZCFBTTJHOFEXFJHIUT XIJDI NBZCFHJWFOJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTTVDIBTMFOHUI"EJHSBQIXJUIXFJHIUFEFEHFTJTBOFUXPSL /FUXPSLTFYUFOEUIFDPODFQUTJOUSPEVDFEJOUIFEJTDVTTJPOPGCJOBSZSFMBUJPOT"TJOHMFDPO OFDUPSPSOFUXPSLOPXDBODPOOFDUNVMUJQMFDPNQPOFOUT1SPUPDPMTBQQMZUPUIFFOUJSFOFUXPSL 4UVﬀ DBOCFFYDIBOHFEBNPOHNVMUJQMFDPNQPOFOUT.PTUPSBMMUIFFYBNQMFTMJTUFEVOEFSUIF CJOBSZJOUFSBDUJPOEJTDVTTJPODBOCFFYUFOEFEUPNVMUJQMFDPNQPOFOUT TVDIBTTFOEJOHBOFNBJM UPNVMUJQMFSFDJQJFOUT /FUXPSLT PQFO VQ NVMUJQMF JTTVFT BOE PQQPSUVOJUJFT ThSFF HFOFSBM JTTVFT BSF OFUXPSL TUSVDUVSFPSUPQPMPHZ OFUXPSLQFSGPSNBODFPSPQUJNJ[BUJPO BOE OFUXPSLTFDVSJUZ8JUI TVﬃcJFOU DPOOFDUJWJUZ PG OPEFT NVMUJQMF QBUIT BSF BWBJMBCMF CFUXFFO BOZ HJWFO QBJS PG OPEFT XIJDI DBO NBLF B OFUXPSL NPSF GBVMU UPMFSBOU BOE SPCVTU 0O UIF PUIFS IBOE UIF JOIFSFOU DPOOFDUJWJUZPGBOFUXPSLJODSFBTFTTFDVSJUZSJTLT'JHVSFJMMVTUSBUFTTPNFDPNNPOOFUXPSL UPQPMPHJFT "5*4 *OUIFCVTUPQPMPHZ BMMOPEFTBSFDPOOFDUFECZBTJOHMFDPOOFDUPSThFNFTIUPQPMPHZJTNVM UJQMZDPOOFDUFEUIBUJT BUMFBTUUXPOPEFTIBWFUXPPSNPSFDPOOFDUJPOQBUITCFUXFFOUIFN" OFUXPSLJOXIJDIFWFSZOPEFJTEJSFDUMZDPOOFDUFEUPFWFSZPUIFSOPEFJTBGVMMZDPOOFDUFENFTI .PTUOFUXPSLTPGBOZTJ[FEPOPUVTFBGVMMZDPOOFDUFEUPQPMPHZCFDBVTFJUEPFTOPUTDBMFVQXFMM )PXFWFS BDPNNPODPOOFDUPSMJLFBCVTDBOBMTPQSPWJEFBGVMMZDPOOFDUFEFﬀFDU BOEJTNVDI NPSFTDBMBCMF"DPNNPODPOOFDUPSBMTPTFFNTMJLFBNPSFOBUVSBMNPEFMPG/BSZPSNVMUJQBSUZ JOUFSBDUJPOTUIBOEPFTBNVMUJQMFQBJSXJTFUPQPMPHZ BMUIPVHIJOTPNFDBTFTUIFQBJSXJTFNPEFM HJWFTNPSFJOGPSNBUJPO.BOZOFUXPSLTBSFIZCSJETPGUXPPSNPSFPGUIFTFUPQPMPHJFT

138

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Star

Mesh

Ring

Figure 6.4

Bus

Tree

Common network topologies.

ThFSFDFOUJODSFBTFJOUIFTUVEZPSTDJFODFPGOFUXPSLTTIPVMECFOFﬁUUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPGDPN QMFYTZTUFNNPEFMT GPSUXPSFBTPOT'JSTU DPNQMFYTZTUFNTFNQIBTJ[FUIFSFMBUJPOTBNPOHQBSUT XIJDI OFUXPSL BOBMZTJT BEESFTTFT 4FDPOE UIF TBNF OFUXPSL NPEFMT TFFN UP BQQMZ UP NVMUJQMF EPNBJOT TVDIBTUSBOTQPSUBUJPOOFUXPSLT TPDJBMOFUXPSLT BOEDPNQVUFSOFUXPSLT.PSFCSPBEMZ UIFTUVEZPGOFUXPSLTBOEUIFSFTVMUJOHNPEFMTTIPVMEBMTPFODPVSBHFNPWFNFOUUPXBSEBNPEFM PSJFOUFEBQQSPBDI3FTFBSDIJOOFUXPSLNPEFMTJTﬁOEJOHDPNNPOQSPQFSUJFTPGOFUXPSLTTVDI BTiTDBMFGSFFwOFUXPSLT #BSBCÈTJBOE"MCFSU JOXIJDIBNJOPSJUZPGOPEFT DBMMFEIVCT BSF IFBWJMZDPOOFDUFE XIJMFUIFNBKPSJUZPGOPEFTBSFMJHIUMZDPOOFDUFE.BOZSFBMXPSMEOFUXPSLT SFﬂFDUUIJTQBUUFSO JODMVEJOHUIF*OUFSOFUBOETPNFBJSMJOFOFUXPSLT XIFSFBOPEFDPOOFDUJPOSFQ SFTFOUTBﬂJHIUUPGSPNBDJUZ ThFiTDBMFGSFFwUFSNDPNFTGSPNUIFPCTFSWBUJPOUIBUBTUIFOFUXPSL HSPXTJOTJ[F JUSFUBJOTUIFTBNFQBUUFSO UIFQSPQPSUJPOPGIVCTUPUPUBMOPEFTSFNBJOTTUBCMF BOE BQQBSFOUMZUIFQFSGPSNBODFJTOPUTJHOJﬁDBOUMZEFHSBEFEThFQFSGPSNBODF IPXFWFS NJHIUEFQFOE POUIFTJUVBUJPO PSFWFOUIFWJFXQPJOUThFVTFPGIVCTGPSBJSMJOFSPVUFTNJHIUQSPWJEFUIFCFTU QFSGPSNBODFGSPNUIFWJFXQPJOUPGUIFBJSMJOF CVUGPSBQBTTFOHFS ﬂZJOHIVOESFETPGNJMFTPVUPG UIFXBZUISPVHIIVCDJUZ$UP ﬂZGSPNDJUZ"UP#NJHIUOPUTFFNMJLFHPPEQFSGPSNBODF.VDIPG UIFSFTFBSDIJOUIJTFNFSHJOHTDJFODFPGOFUXPSLTBSFBJTDBQUVSFEJO/FXNBOFUBM ThF/BSZDPNQPOFOUDPOOFDUPSNPEFMJTBWFSZHFOFSBMPOF*UDBOCFTQFDJBMJ[FEJONBOZ XBZT4PNFPGUIFTMJHIUMZNPSFTQFDJBMJ[FEUZQFTPGJOUFSBDUJPONPEFMTBSFDPMMBCPSBUJPO DPPS EJOBUJPO PSDIFTUSBUJPO BOEDIPSFPHSBQIZ$PNNPOQSPUPDPMQBUUFSOTVTFEJOCPUICJOBSZBOE /BSZ JOUFSBDUJPO NPEFMT JODMVEF QFFSUPQFFS DMJFOUTFSWFS TFSWJDF QSPWJEFS BOE DPOTVNFS SFRVFTUSFTQPOTF NFTTBHFPSJFOUFE FWFOUESJWFOJOUFSBDUJPOTVDIBTJOUFSSVQUTPSQVCMJTIBOETVC TDSJCF BOETUSFBNJOHThFZDBOCFTZODISPOPVTPSBTZODISPOPVT*OTPNFUZQFTPGJOUFSBDUJPO TVDIBTPSDIFTUSBUJPO POFQBSUEJSFDUTUIFJOUFSBDUJPOThJTBMTPBQQMJFTUPNBOZTPDJBMTJUVBUJPOT XIFSFPOFQFSTPO JOUIFSPMFPGNBOBHFS MFBEFS DPBDI FUD JTEJSFDUJOHBHSPVQJOUFSBDUJPO0UIFS NPEFMT TVDIBTDPMMBCPSBUJPOBOEDIPSFPHSBQIZ EJTUSJCVUFJOUFSBDUJPOSFTQPOTJCJMJUZBNPOHUIF QBSUT BTJOBIFUFSBSDIZ"OBOUDPMPOZJTBOFYBNQMFPGUIFMBUUFSUZQFPGNPEFM "UPQPMPHZDBOCFNPEFMFEJOEJﬀFSFOUXBZT EFQFOEJOHPOUIFEFTJSFEFNQIBTJT4VQQPTFXF IBWFBDPNNPODPOOFDUPS TVDIBTUIF*OUFSOFU UISPVHIXIJDIQBJSXJTFJOUFSBDUJPOTUBLFQMBDF 'JHVSFTIPXTIPXXFDPVMENPEFMUIJTXJUIUIFFNQIBTJTPOUIFDPNNPODPOOFDUPS BTPOUIF ThFTDJFODFPGOFUXPSLTJTBDPNCJOFEOBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMTDJFODFCFDBVTFJUBCTUSBDUTQBUUFSOTGSPNCPUI OBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBMOFUXPSLT

O 139

Composition

S internal model p2

S1

S internal model S2

r3

p2

S1

r4

N1

p4

S2

r3

p4

r4 r6 N1 p6

r4

r6

p4

N1

N1

p6

r4

r6 S3

S4

(a) Common connector emphasis

Figure 6.5

r1

S3

p6

N1

r6

S4

r1

(b) Pairwise interaction emphasis

Two views of pairwise interactions via a common connector.

MFGU PSXJUIUIFFNQIBTJTPOUIFQBJSXJTFJOUFSBDUJPOT BTPOUIFSJHIU*OCPUIDBTFT TZTUFNT4 UISPVHI4JOUFSBDUUISPVHIPOFDPOOFDUPS / 0OFFYBNQMFPGUIJTDPOﬁHVSBUJPO4JTBQFSTPOBDDFTTJOHUIF*OUFSOFUPOUIFJSIPNFDPN QVUFS 4 JT B OFJHICPS EPXO UIF TUSFFU XJUI TJNJMBS BDDFTT 4 JT UIF OFBSCZ QJ[[B QMBDF CPUI QFPQMFPSEFSGSPN BOE4JTBOPOMJOFCPPLTFMMFSUIFZCPUIVTFThFNPEFMPOUIFSJHIUNBLFTUIF JOUFSBDUJPOTWJTVBMMZDMFBSFS4BOE4JOEFQFOEFOUMZJOUFSBDUXJUICPUIUIFQJ[[BQMBDF4BOE UIFCPPLTFMMFS4ThFUXPQFPQMF 4BOE4 EPOPUJOUFSBDUXJUIFBDIPUIFSBOEUIFUXPCVTJ OFTTFT 4BOE4 EPOPUJOUFSBDUXJUIFBDIPUIFS0OFXBZUIFTFUXPNPEFMTBSFVTFEUPHFUIFSJT UPEFﬁOFUIFDPNNPODPOOFDUPSNPEFMBTUIFQIZTJDBMTZTUFNNPEFM BOEUIFQBJSXJTFNPEFMBT BWJFXPGDFSUBJOJOUFSBDUJPOTUIBUVTFPSPWFSMBZUIFQIZTJDBMNPEFM /PUFUIBUCPUIBDPNQPOFOUBOEBDPOOFDUPSNBZCFBDPNQPTJUFPGDPNQPOFOUTBOEDPOOFD UPST&YBNQMFTBOFUXPSLPGDJUJFTBTDPNQPOFOUTBOEBUSBOTQPSUBUJPOOFUXPSLBTBDPOOFDUPS &BDI DJUZ IBT DPNQPOFOUT BOE DPOOFDUPST JOUFSOBMMZ GPS FYBNQMF DPNQPOFOUT CVJMEJOHT DPOOFDUPSTTUSFFUT USBOTQPSUJOHWFIJDMFT FUD"OEUIFUSBOTQPSUBUJPOOFUXPSLIBTDPOOFDUPST BOEDPNQPOFOUTGPSFYBNQMF DPOOFDUPSTSPBET BJSSPVUFT XBUFSXBZTDPNQPOFOUTUSVDLT BJSQMBOFT CPBUT HBUFXBZDJUJFTThVT BUSVDLDBOCFBTZTUFNJOJUTFMGPSBDPNQPOFOUJOBMBSHFS TZTUFN TVDIBTBﬂFFUPGUSVDLTPSBDPNQPOFOUJOBDPNQPTJUFDPOOFDUPS TVDIBTBUSBOTQPSUBUJPO OFUXPSL"DJUZDBOCFBTZTUFN PSBDPNQPOFOUJOBDPNQPTJUFDPOOFDUPSTVDIBTBUSBOTQPSUB UJPO OFUXPSLJOXIJDIUIFDJUZJTBHBUFXBZ CFUXFFO B TPVSDF BOE EFTUJOBUJPO .PSF FYUFOTJWF NVMUJMFWFMDPNQPTJUJPOTUSVDUVSFTXJMMCFFYQMPSFEJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi.VMUJMFWFM$PNQPTJUJPO 4USVDUVSFTBOE4DBMFTw 4PNFBEEJUJPOBMOPUFTPODPOOFDUPSTBOEDPNQPOFOUT O $POOFDUPSTBTXFMMBTDPNQPOFOUTDBOIBWFQPSUT&YBNQMFTBQPSUBMUPUIF*OUFSOFUB QPSUUPBMJNJUFEBDDFTTIJHIXBZ DBMMFEBOJOUFSDIBOHFBEPDLPSSBNQUIBUQSPWJEFTCPBU BDDFTTUPBSJWFSPSXBUFSXBZ O $POOFDUPST DBO CF FODBQTVMBUFE *O UIF QSFWJPVT CVMMFU NPTU PG UIF FYBNQMFT BSF OPU BDDFTTJCMFFYDFQUWJBUIFJSQPSUT O 4FSWJDFTDBOCFDPNQPOFOUTFSWJDFT UBYQSFQBSBUJPO 8FCTFSWJDFT PSDPOOFDUPSTFSWJDFT *OUFSOFU 'FE&Y ThJTJTBVTFGVMEJTUJODUJPOUIBUQFSIBQTTIPVMECFNBEFNPSFFYQMJDJU JOUIFTFSWJDFPSJFOUFEXPSME

140 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThFﬁSTUDMBTTTUBUVSFPGSFMBUJPOTPSDPOOFDUPSTJTTVDIUIBU JODPNQPOFOUoDPOOFDUPSCBTFE NPEFMTPGTZTUFNSFMBUJPOTPOQBSUT CPUIDPNQPOFOUTBOEDPOOFDUPSTNBZCFSFHBSEFEBTQBSUT 4PNFNPEFMTFNQIBTJ[FDPNQPOFOUTPWFSDPOOFDUPSTPUIFSNPEFMTFNQIBTJ[FDPOOFDUPSTPWFS DPNQPOFOUT%FQFOEJOHPOUIFDPOUFYUPSUZQFPGNPEFM QBSUNJHIUSFGFSUPDPNQPOFOUT PSDPO OFDUPST PSCPUI,MJS o o DIBSBDUFSJ[FENPEFMTUIBUBSFCBTFEPODFSUBJO LJOET PG DPNQPOFOUT XJUIPVU DPNNJUUJOH UP BOZ QBSUJDVMBS LJOE PG SFMBUJPO BT FYQFSJNFOUBMMZ CBTFE BOENPEFMTCBTFEPODFSUBJOLJOETPGSFMBUJPOT XJUIPVUDPNNJUUJOHUPBOZQBSUJDVMBSLJOE PGDPNQPOFOU BTUIFPSFUJDBMMZCBTFE3FMBUJPOTSFﬂFDUiTZTUFNIPPEwBOEBSFUIFGPDVTPGTZTUFNT TDJFODF XIJMFDPNQPOFOUTSFﬂFDUiUIJOHIPPEwBOEBSFUIFGPDVTPGNPSFEPNBJOTQFDJﬁDUSBEJ UJPOBMTDJFODFTTVDIBTQIZTJDTPSDIFNJTUSZ

Composition Properties 8F QSFTFOU UISFF DPNQPTJUJPO QSPQFSUJFT JO UIJT TFDUJPO FYDMVTJWJUZ NVUBCJMJUZ BOE TZNNFUSZThFTFQSPQFSUJFTTUSVDUVSF BOEUPTPNFEFHSFFNPUJWBUF PVSEJTDVTTJPOPGDPNQPTJUJPO NPEFMTThFFYDMVTJWJUZPGBQBSUJTUIFEFHSFFUPXIJDIJUJTFYDMVTJWFMZJOPOFXIPMFThFNVUBCJMJUZ PGBQBSUJTUIFEFHSFFUPXIJDIJUDIBOHFTJOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOQSPDFTTThFTZNNFUSZPGBDPNQPTJ UJPOJTUIFEFHSFFUPXIJDIJUDPNCJOFTQBSUTUPGPSNBXIPMF BTPQQPTFEUP GPSFYBNQMF BEEJOHB QBSUUPBXIPMF8FOPXEJTDVTTDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIFBDIPGUIFTFQSPQFSUJFT BOE UIFOCSJFﬂZEJTDVTTIPXUIFUISFFSFMBUF

Exclusivity ThFFYDMVTJWJUZEJTUJODUJPOJTCFUXFFOBQBSUUIBUJTJOPOMZPOFXIPMF FYDMVTJWF BOEBQBSUUIBU JT PSDBOCF JONVMUJQMFXIPMFT OPOFYDMVTJWF 0OFNJHIUUIJOLUIBUBQBSUDBOCFJOPOMZPOF XIPMF)PXDBOBOBUPNCFJONPSFUIBOPOFNPMFDVMF BDFMMJONPSFUIBOPOFPSHBO BCSJDLJO NPSFUIBOPOFIPVTF BOFOHJOFJONPSFUIBOPOFDBS BUSFFJONPSFUIBOPOFGPSFTU PSBQMBOFUJO NPSFUIBOPOFTPMBSTZTUFN *GBQBSUDBOFYJTUJOPOMZPOFXIPMF XFDBMMJUUIFDPOUBJOFEDPNQPTJ UJPONPEFM*OUIFNPTUFYUSFNFPSQVSFGPSNPGUIJTNPEFM UIFXIPMFPXOTUIFQBSUTUIFQBSUT EPOPUFYJTUTFQBSBUFMZGSPNUIFXIPMFBOEJGUIFXIPMFJTEFTUSPZFE UIFQBSUTBSFBMTPEFTUSPZFE *OMFTTFYUSFNFGPSNT BQBSUDBOOPUCFQBSUPGNVMUJQMFTZTUFNTTJNVMUBOFPVTMZ CVUDPVMECFQBSU PGPOFTZTUFNBUPOFUJNFBOEQBSUPGBOPUIFSTZTUFNBUBEJﬀFSFOUUJNFThJTJTUIFDPOTFDVUJWF NPEFMXFEFTDSJCFBUUIFFOEPGUIJTTVCTFDUJPO )PXFWFS JONBOZDBTFT BQBSUDBOCFDPODFQUVBMJ[FEBTFYJTUJOHJONVMUJQMFTZTUFNT*OUIJT DBTF XIJDIXFDBMMUIFTIBSFENPEFM BQBSUFYJTUTTFQBSBUFMZBOEDBOCFJONVMUJQMFXIPMFTBOE JGTPNFXIPMFTBSFEFTUSPZFE UIFQBSUTUJMMSFNBJOT"DPNNPOFYBNQMFPGUIFTIBSFENPEFMJTB TPGUXBSFDPNQPOFOUUIBUJTVTFECZBOEJTQBSUPGNVMUJQMFTPGUXBSFTZTUFNT5XPEPNJOBOUBSDIJ UFDUVSFTPGUIJTUZQFBSFMBZFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSF XIFSFFBDIMBZFSIBTQBSUTUIBUTVQQPSUNVMUJQMFQBSUT JOIJHIFSMBZFST BOEBTFSWJDFPSJFOUFEBSDIJUFDUVSF 40"

TVDIBT8FCTFSWJDFTUIBUBSFBDDFTTJCMF UPNVMUJQMFDPOTVNFSTThFTBNFDPNQVUFS $16 PQFSBUJOHTZTUFN ﬁMFTZTUFN BOENJEEMFXBSF QSPWJEFDPNNPOTFSWJDFTUPNVMUJQMFBQQMJDBUJPOT/FUXPSLTTVDIBTUIF*OUFSOFUBSFTIBSFEQBSUT PGNVMUJQMFTZTUFNT"NPSFSFDFOUUPQJDJOTFSWJDFPSJFOUBUJPOJTUIFDPODFQUPGDMPVEDPNQVUJOH XIFSFDPNQVUJOHQPXFSBOEPUIFSDPNQVUJOHSFTPVSDFTBSFBWBJMBCMFGSPNEBUBDFOUFSTPSDPNQVU JOHDFOUFSTPOUIF*OUFSOFU )BZFT (SVNBOBOE,OPSS 7BSJBUJPOTPOUIJTUIFNF BOEUIJTUFSNJODMVEFPOEFNBOEDPNQVUJOH TPGUXBSFBTBTFSWJDF 4BB4

VUJMJUZDPNQVUJOH QMBUGPSNBTBTFSWJDF *OUFSOFUBTQMBUGPSN NBOBHFETFSWJDFQSPWJEFS TFSWJDFDPNNFSDFQMBUGPSN BOE*OUFSOFUJOUFHSBUJPO XIFSFUIFMBUUFSJTJOUFHSBUJPOPGDMPVECBTFETFSWJDFT

Composition

O 141

4IBSFENPEFMTHPCFZPOETPGUXBSFBOEDPNQVUFSTZTUFNT$POTJEFSUIFTFQIZTJDBMTFSWJDFQSPWJE FSTUIFTBNFBHFOUTVDIBTBCPPLTFMMFS DBSEFBMFS NBJMDBSSJFS USBOTQPSUTFSWJDF 'FE&Y

EPDUPS UBYQSFQBSFS FUDTFSWFTNVMUJQMFDMJFOUT*OFBDIDBTF UIFBHFOUDMJFOUPSTFSWFSDMJFOUJOUFSBDUJPO DBOCFEFTJHOBUFEBTUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGBTZTUFN4PJGBEPDUPSIBTQBUJFOUT JUJTFOUJSFMZSFBTPO BCMFUPEFTJHOBUFUIBUUIFEPDUPSJTQBSUPGTZTUFNT QMVTTFWFSBMPUIFSTZTUFNT TVDIBTIJTDPMMFBHVFT BOEUIFPﬃDFTUBﬀJOIJTQSBDUJDF ThFXIPMFOPUJPOPGDPNNPOTFSWJDFJTWFSZTUSPOHBOEUSBEJUJPOBM JOUIFQIZTJDBMXPSMEDPNNPOTPGUXBSFTFSWJDFTIBWFOPUIJOHOFXPOUIJTDPODFQU0VUTPVSDJOH TVDIBTBDDPVOUJOH )3 FWFO*5 ﬁUTUIJTNPEFM4PUIFCBTJDTIBSFEDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMTFQBSBUFE MPPTFMZDPVQMFEJTWFSZTJNJMBSGPSQIZTJDBMTZTUFNTBOETPGUXBSFTZTUFNT ThFTIBSFENPEFMIBTUXPWBSJBOUT0OFJTXIFSFBTIBSFEQBSUPDDVSTPODFJOFBDITZTUFNThF FYBNQMFTHJWFOBCPWFBSFPGUIJTWBSJFUZ*OUIFTIBSFENPEFMTIPXOJO'JHVSF QBSU4 BTB QBSUPGTZTUFNT4BOE4 JMMVTUSBUFTUIJT ThFPUIFSWBSJBOUJTXIFSFBTIBSFEQBSUPDDVSTNVMUJQMFUJNFTJOBTJOHMFTZTUFN JMMVTUSBUFE JO'JHVSFCZUIFNVMUJQMFBQQFBSBODFTPGQBSU4JOTZTUFN4.PTUPGUIFTZTUFNTJOXIJDI UIJTPDDVSTBSFNPEFMT.BOZUBSHFUTZTUFNTIBWFNVMUJQMFQBSUTPGUIFTBNFUZQF UIBUJT UIFZ IBWFUIFTBNFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPSNPEFM'PSFYBNQMF BIPVTFIBTNBOZCSJDLTUIBUBSFTJNJMBS*GXF EFﬁOFEBNPEFMPGBIPVTFUIBUTIPXFEFWFSZCSJDL BOEXFXFSFVTJOHCSJDLTPGUZQF4 B DFSUBJOTJ[F DPMPS NBUFSJBM FUD NBZCFFWFOGSPNBDFSUBJOWFOEPS

PVSNPEFMXPVMEIBWFQBSU 4SFQFBUFEUJNFTThPTFQBSUTXPVMECFNVMUJQMFPDDVSSFODFTPGUIFTBNFQBSUJOUIF NPEFMTh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hFTIBSFENPEFMBMTPCSJOHTUPHFUIFSBOEFOBCMFTVOJﬁDBUJPOPGUIFDPODFQUPGDPOUSBDU" EFTJHOCZDPOUSBDU BO40"TFSWJDFDPOUSBDU BOPMEGBTIJPOFEDPOUSBDUCFUXFFOUXPPSHBOJ[BUJPOT PSQBSUJFT BOEJNQMJDJUDPOUSBDUTJOUIFUSBEJUJPOBMTFSWJDFJOEVTUSZBMMBMJHOJOUIFVOJﬁFETIBSFE

S1 S11

S12

S21

S22

S31

S14

S13

S14

S23

S14

S33

S14

S14

Figure 6.6

S3

S2

Shared composition model.

142 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

NPEFM*OBEEJUJPO .04&4BMJHOTBOEVOJﬁFTCPUIDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMTDPOUBJOFEBOETIBSFE XJUIUIFDPNNPODPOUSBDUTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDI BTEFTDSJCFEJONPSFEFUBJMJO$IBQUFS ThFSFBSFJOUFSNFEJBUFNPEFMTCFUXFFOGVMMZDPOUBJOFEBOEGVMMZTIBSFE0OFJTBDPOTFDVUJWF DPNQPTJUJPONPEFM JOXIJDIBQBSUDBOPOMZCFJOPOFTZTUFNBUBHJWFOUJNF CVUDBOCFQBSUPG BOPUIFSTZTUFNBUBOPUIFSUJNF*GJUJTEJﬃcVMUPSSBSFUPNPWFBQBSUGSPNPOFTZTUFNUPBOPUIFS JUJTDMPTFSUPUIFDPOUBJOFETJEF&YBNQMFTBSFNPWJOHBOFOHJOFGSPNPOFDBSUPBOPUIFS PSVTJOH BCSJDLJOPOFIPVTFBOEMBUFSVTJOHJUJOBOPUIFSIPVTF PSSFNPWJOHBIFBSUGSPNPOFIVNBOBOE QMBDJOHJUJOBOPUIFSIVNBO *GJUJTFBTZPSUZQJDBMUPNPWFBQBSUGSPNPOFTZTUFNUPBOPUIFS JUJTDMPTFSUPUIFTIBSFETJEF "DPNNPODBUFHPSZPGUIJTJTQBSUTUIBUDBOEPNVMUJQMFKPCTCVUDBOPOMZEPPOFPGUIFNBUB HJWFOUJNF&YBNQMFTBTJOHMFDPNQVUFSQSPDFTTPSTVQQPSUJOHNVMUJQMFQSPHSBNTWJBBUJNFTMJDJOH PQFSBUJOHTZTUFN PSBTJOHMFBDDPVOUBOUUIBUDBOIFMQNVMUJQMFQFPQMFQSFQBSFUIFJSUBYSFUVSOT CVUDBOPOMZXPSLPOPOFBUBHJWFONPNFOU*OUIFTFDBTFT UIFEJﬀFSFODFCFUXFFOUIFDPOTFDV UJWFNPEFMJOXIJDIXFBMMPXBQBSUUPCFDPOUBJOFEJONVMUJQMFTZTUFNTCVUDPOTUSBJOUPPOMZ POFTZTUFNBUBUJNF BOEBQBSBMMFMQSPDFTTJOHTIBSFEQBSUUIBUDBOCFQBSUPGNVMUJQMFTZTUFNT CFDPNFTWFSZTNBMM ThFGPSFHPJOHEJTDVTTJPOUIFSFGPSFSFQSFTFOUTUIFGPMMPXJOHDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMWBSJBOUT O "QVSFDPOUBJOFENPEFMBDPNQPOFOUJTQBSUPGPOMZPOFTZTUFN BOEDFBTFTUPFYJTUXIFO UIFTZTUFNDFBTFTUPFYJTU O "DPOTFDVUJWFDPOUBJOFENPEFMBDPNQPOFOUJTQBSUPGPOMZPOFTZTUFNBUBUJNFCVUNBZ NPWFUPBOPUIFSTZTUFNBUBMBUFSUJNF O "DPOTFDVUJWFWJFXPGBTIBSFENPEFMBDPNQPOFOUJTBQBSUPGNVMUJQMFTZTUFNTTJNVMUBOF PVTMZCVUDBOPOMZJOUFSBDUXJUIQBSUTPGPOFTZTUFNBUBUJNF BOEUIJTJOUFSBDUJPODPO TUSBJOUJTQBSUPGUIFNPEFM O "TJNVMUBOFPVTWJFXPGBTIBSFENPEFMBDPNQPOFOUJTBQBSUPGNVMUJQMFTZTUFNTTJNVMUBOF PVTMZXIFUIFSPSOPUUIFDPNQPOFOUDBOPOMZJOUFSBDUXJUIQBSUTPGPOFTZTUFNBUBUJNF JTOPUQBSUPGUIJTNPEFM ,FFQJONJOEUIBUUIFTFWBSJBOUTBOEWJFXTSFQSFTFOUQPJOUTPOBDPOUJOVVNUIBUSBOHFTGSPNQVSF DPOUBJOFEUPTJNVMUBOFPVTTIBSFE ThF6.- 0.( EFﬁOFTDPNQPTJUJPOUZQFTUIBUDPSSFTQPOEBQQSPYJNBUFMZUPPVS DPOUBJOFE QVSFPSDPOTFDVUJWF BOETIBSFE XIJDIUIFZSFGFSUP SFTQFDUJWFMZ BTDPNQPTJUFBHHSF HBUJPOBOETIBSFEBHHSFHBUJPO. ThFZEFTDSJCFUIFUZQFTUIJTXBZ i"HHSFHBUJPO,JOEJTBOFOVNFSBUJPOPGUIFGPMMPXJOHMJUFSBMWBMVFT N /POFJOEJDBUFTUIBUUIFQSPQFSUZIBTOPBHHSFHBUJPO N 4IBSFEJOEJDBUFTUIBUUIFQSPQFSUZIBTBTIBSFEBHHSFHBUJPO N $PNQPTJUFJOEJDBUFTUIBUUIFQSPQFSUZJTBHHSFHBUFEDPNQPTJUFMZ UIBUJT UIFDPN QPTJUFPCKFDUIBTSFTQPOTJCJMJUZGPSUIFFYJTUFODFBOETUPSBHFPGUIFDPNQPTFEPCKFDUT QBSUT w

Mutability *OUIFEJTDVTTJPOUIVTGBS XFIBWFVTFEFYBNQMFTXIFSFQBSUTBSFDPNQPTFEJOUPXIPMFTNPSFPS MFTTJOUBDU#VUJONBOZDBTFT UIFQBSUTDIBOHFXIFOUIFZBSFDPNQPTFEXJUIPUIFSQBSUT8F DBMMUIJTBNVUBCMFDPNQPTJUJPONPEFM$PNNPOUFSNTGPSUIJTUZQFPGDPNQPTJUJPOBSFCPOEJOH

Composition

O 143

GVTJPO BOENFSHJOH1SPNJOFOUFYBNQMFTBSFDIFNJDBMCPOEJOHBOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMNFSHFSTThF FYBNQMFJO'JHVSFTIPXFEUXPNPMFDVMFTDIBOHJOHXIFOUIFZNFSHFE5XPIZESPHFOBUPNT BOEBOPYZHFOBUPNXFSFSFNPWFEEVSJOHDPNQPTJUJPOBOEDPNCJOFEUPQSPEVDFXBUFSBTBTJEF FﬀFDUPGUIFDPNQPTJUJPO 8IFOUXPPSHBOJ[BUJPOTNFSHF UIFZVTVBMMZDIBOHFPSSFNPWFDFSUBJOFMFNFOUTTPUIFZEPOPU IBWFVOXBOUFEEVQMJDBUJPOPGDPNNPOGVODUJPOT

Symmetry "MMUIFDBTFTBOENPEFMTEJTDVTTFETPGBSBSFTZNNFUSJD JOUIBUUIFDPNQPTJUJPOTXFSFPGQBSUT JOUPBXIPMF"OBTZNNFUSJDNPEFMBMTPFYJTUT XIFSFBXIPMFBEETBQBSUUIBUJT BXIPMFBOE BQBSUBSFDPNQPTFEJOUPB SFWJTFE XIPMF.PTUPGUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJTDVTTJPOJOUIJTCPPLJT BCPVU TZNNFUSJD DPNQPTJUJPO &YBNQMFT PG BTZNNFUSJD DPNQPTJUJPO JODMVEF BEEJOH B TNBMM NPMFDVMF NPOPNFS UPBQPMZNFSDIBJOJODIFNJTUSZPSBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOIJSJOHBOFXFNQMPZFF BQFSTPOKPJOJOHBTPDJBMDMVC PSBOFUXPSLBEEJOHBOPEFThFSFDBOCFTPNFUIJOHPGBDPO UJOVVNCFUXFFOBTZNNFUSJDBOETZNNFUSJDDPNQPTJUJPOThFQBUUFSOPGDPNQBOZNFSHFSTBOE BDRVJTJUJPOTSFﬂFDUTTVDIBDPOUJOVVN(FOFSBMMZ JGUXPDPNQBOJFTNFSHF XFXPVMEDBMMJUTZN NFUSJDDPNQPTJUJPO XIJMFJGPOFDPNQBOZBDRVJSFTBOPUIFSDPNQBOZ XFXPVMEUZQJDBMMZSFHBSE JUBTBTZNNFUSJD

Relations among the Three Categories ThF NVUBCJMJUZ DPNQPTJUJPO DBUFHPSZ JT JOEFQFOEFOU PG UIF TZNNFUSZ DBUFHPSZ ThBU JT CPUI NVUBCMFBOEJNNVUBCMFDPNQPTJUJPODBOBQQMZUPTZNNFUSJDBOEBTZNNFUSJDNPEFMT *NNVUBCMFDPNQPTJUJPODBOBQQMZUPCPUITIBSFEBOEDPOUBJOFEDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMT.VUBCMF DPNQPTJUJPODBOBMTPBQQMZUPDPOUBJOFEDPNQPTJUJPO*GBQBSUJTVTFEPOMZJOPOFTZTUFN UIF QBSUDBOCFDIBOHFEXJUIPVUBﬀFDUJOHBOZPUIFSTZTUFN FTQFDJBMMZJGUIFQBSUJTFODBQTVMBUFE .VUBCMFDPNQPTJUJPOEPFTOPU JOHFOFSBM BQQMZUPTIBSFEDPNQPTJUJPO"TIBSFEQBSUNVTU SFUBJOJUTTFQBSBUFFYJTUFODFUPCFBWBJMBCMFUPPUIFSTZTUFNT TPUIBUJGPOFTZTUFNDIBOHFEUIFQBSU UIFDIBOHFXPVME JOHFOFSBM BﬀFDUBMMPUIFSTZTUFNTUIBUVTFEPSJODMVEFEUIFQBSU *UJTJNQPSUBOUUPEJTUJOHVJTICFUXFFONVUBCJMJUZBOEBEBQUBUJPOPSTZTUFNDIBOHF"NVUBCMF QBSUDIBOHFTEVSJOHDPNQPTJUJPO"EBQUBUJPOJOWPMWFTTZTUFNDIBOHFPWFSJUTPQFSBUJPOBMMJGF" QBSUDBOCFCPUIJNNVUBCMFBOEBEBQUBCMF"EBQUBUJPOBOEPUIFSGPSNTPGDIBOHFBSFEJTDVTTFE JO$IBQUFS

Relations between Wholes and Parts *OUIJTTFDUJPOXFEJTDVTTBWBSJFUZPGSFMBUJPOTUIBUFYJTUPSDBOCFEFﬁOFECFUXFFOXIPMFTBOE QBSUT8FPCTFSWFBUUIFTUBSUUIBUCFDBVTF4&JOHFOFSBMBOE.04&4JOQBSUJDVMBSTVQQPSUCPUI QIZTJDBMTZTUFNTBOEDPODFQUVBMTZTUFNT XFEPOPUDPOTUSBJOFJUIFSBXIPMFPSBQBSUUPCFDPO DSFUFPSBCTUSBDU ThFﬁSTUTFDUJPOQSFTFOUTTPNFCBTJDXIPMFoQBSUDPODFQUTGSPNTZTUFNTTDJFODF#FDBVTFUIF XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOJTXIFSFUIFDPODFQUPGFNFSHFODFBSJTFT XFCSJFﬂZEJTDVTTJOBTJEFCBSUIF DPODFQUPGFNFSHFODFBOEUIFTUBODFPG.04&4UPXBSEUIJTDPODFQUThFOXFEJTDVTTBCBTJDTFU BOEBOFYUFOEFETFUPGXIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOT

144

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThFEJTDVTTJPOPGXIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTJOUIJTTFDUJPOBOEDIBQUFSJTJOGPSNBMThFSFBSFGPSNBM USFBUNFOUTPGUIJTTVCKFDU4PNFPGUIFNBSFCBTFEPOTFUUIFPSZ BOEPUIFSTPONFSFPMPHZ PSUIF UIFPSZPGXIPMFTBOEQBSUT TFF FH 4JNPOT

"OPUIFSGPSNBMBQQSPBDIJTUIFUIFPSZPG HSBOVMBSQBSUJUJPOT #JUUOFSBOE4NJUI ThFMBUUFSIBTGFBUVSFTUIBUDPVMECFBQQMJFEUPUIF NPEFMTQBDF FTQFDJBMMZDPNQPTJUJPOBOEWJFXT0OFTVDIGFBUVSFJTUIFEFQJDUJPOPGDFMMTBOEUIFJS NBQQJOHUPSFBMJUZThJTSFMBUJPOJTBOBMPHPVTUPUIF.04&4EFQJDUJPOPGDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMTBOE UIFJSDPSSFTQPOEFODFXJUITZTUFNT #FGPSFXFQSPDFFEXJUIUIFEJTDVTTJPO XFOFFEUPSFNPWFBQPTTJCMFBNCJHVJUZGPSSFBEFSTXIP UFOEUPUIJOLJOGPSNBMUFSNT*OUIJTDIBQUFSBOECPPL QBSUJTNFBOUUPCFQSPQFSQBSU'PSNBMMZ BTZTUFNDBOCFQBSUPGJUTFMG BOBMPHPVTUPBTFUUIBUDBOCFBTVCTFUPGJUTFMG#VUBQSPQFSTVCTFU JTOPUUIFXIPMFTFU"TFUDBOOPUCFBQSPQFSTVCTFUPGJUTFMGUIFSFNVTUCFFMFNFOUTPGBTFU4UIBU BSFOPUFMFNFOUTPGBQSPQFSTVCTFUPG4-JLFXJTF BQSPQFSQBSUJTOPUUIFXIPMFTZTUFN"TZTUFN DBOOPUCFBQSPQFSQBSUPGJUTFMGHJWFOBQSPQFSQBSU1PGTZTUFN4 UIFSFNVTUCFBUMFBTUPOFQBSU PG4UIBUJTOPU11VSTVBOUUPUIJTEJTDVTTJPO VOMFTTPUIFSXJTFOPUFE FWFSZXIFSFJOUIJTCPPLUIBU XFTBZQBSU XFNFBOQSPQFSQBSU. ThJTDPOWFOUJPOIPMETGPSCPUIDPOUBJOFEBOETIBSFEQBSUT

Basic Whole–Part Concepts .VMUJQMFPWFSMBQQJOHTZTUFNEJTUJODUJPOTDBOCFEFﬁOFE FBDIPGXIJDIDBOHFOFSBUFTZTUFNUBY POPNJFT4PNFDPNNPOEJTUJODUJPOTBSFPQFOWFSTVTDMPTFEOBUVSBMWFSTVTBSUJﬁDJBMPSQIZTJDBM WFSTVT DPODFQUVBM &BDI EJTUJODUJPO PS UBYPOPNZ NBZ CF SFHBSEFE BT B WJFX PG UIF TQBDFUJNF SFHJPOPGBMMTZTUFNT 7JFXTBSFEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS

ThFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGBTZTUFNFYIJCJUBDPNNPOQBUUFSOJOCPUIBTQBUJBMBOEUFNQPSBMWJFX *OUIFTQBUJBMWJFX UIFQBUUFSOJTUIFSFMBUJPOPGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPSQSPQFSUJFTPGBXIPMFTZTUFNUP UIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGJUTQBSUT"TZTUFNIBTBTFUPGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGJOUFSFTU BOEFBDIPGJUTQBSUT IBTBTFUPGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGJOUFSFTUTh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hVT 1JTBQSPQFSUZPGPOMZ" *OUIFSFMBUJPOPG"XJUI"BOE" 1JTBQSPQFSUZPGUIFXIPMFPOMZ*OUIFSFMBUJPOPG"XJUI " 1JTBQSPQFSUZPGUIFQBSUPOMZ *OUIFUFNQPSBMWJFX UIFQBUUFSOJTUIFSFMBUJPOPGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPSQSPQFSUJFTPGBTZTUFNBU UJNF5UPJUTDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBUUJNF5"TZTUFNIBTBTFUPGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGJOUFSFTUBUBOZ HJWFOUJNF BOEUIFTFUNBZDIBOHFPWFSUJNFThFSFMBUJPOPGUIFTFTFUTBDSPTTUJNFJTJMMVTUSBUFE JO'JHVSFC4PNFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBQQMZBUCPUI5BOE5PUIFSTBQQMZPOMZBU5 OPUBU5 BOEPUIFSTPOMZBU5 OPUBU5ThFTFDBOCFSFGFSSFEUPJOUIFUFNQPSBMSFMBUJPO SFTQFDUJWFMZ BT QFSTJTUFOU FBSMJFS BOEMBUFSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT "OBMPHPVTUPUIFTQBUJBMWJFX UIFEFTJHOBUJPOPGQFSTJTUFOU FBSMJFS BOEMBUFSBSFOPUJOIFS FOUCVUSBUIFSBSFDPOUFYUEFQFOEFOU XIFSFUIFDPOUFYUJTUIFSFMBUJPOJOXIJDIUIFEFTJHOBUJPO JTNBEF'PSFYBNQMF JGBQSPQFSUZ1IPMETGPSTZTUFN4BU5BOE5CVUOPUBU5 UIFO1JTB QFSTJTUFOUQSPQFSUZPG4JOUIF5o5SFMBUJPOCVUJTOPUQFSTJTUFOUJOUIF5o5SFMBUJPO /PUFUIBUUIFEJBHSBNTJOUIFﬁHVSFBSFJOUFOEFEUPTIPXPOMZUIFFYJTUFODFPGUIFTFWBSJBUJPOT PGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT OPUUIFSFMBUJWFOVNCFSPSQSPQPSUJPOPGFBDIDIBSBDUFSJTUJD

Composition

Part Part only

Whole Shared

Whole only

(a) Spatial relation

Time 1 Earlier

Time 2 Persistent

Later

(b) Temporal relation

Figure 6.7

Relations of characteristics in space and time.

The Issue of Emergence When we consider the relations between wholes and parts, we encounter the potential relation of emergence. The vernacular form of emergence is “The whole is more than the sum of its parts.” A more formal deﬁnition of emergent properties, from Honderich (1995, 224), is: “A property of a complex system is said to be ‘emergent’ just in case, although it arises out of the properties and relations characterizing its simpler constituents, it is neither predictable from, nor reducible to, these lower-level characteristics.” A variety of deﬁnitions of emergence exists. See Emmeche et al. (1997) and O’Connor and Wong (2006) for discussion of some of the variants. In traditional systems engineering, emergence is often implicitly assumed but is rarely discussed as an explicit topic. Much of the complex systems literature includes emergence as a deﬁning characteristic of complex systems. For example, Boccara (2004, 3) states that “The appearance of emergent properties is the single most distinguishing feature of complex systems.” On the other hand, some researchers in complex systems call themselves reductionists — for example, Shalizi (2007). The MOSES approach is to focus on and characterize the relations between wholes and parts. For both TS and CS, the whole often has characteristics that parts do not have, which may be called emergence. But parts may also have characteristics that the whole does not have, which we might call submergence. We explore these and other relations in the sections that follow. While we occasionally use the term “emergence,” the primary MOSES depiction of the general situation for both TS and CS is to say that a whole and its parts have partially overlapping characteristics.

O 145

146

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Connection Among Parts Part a

Whole

c b

d

e g

f

a. Characteristic of part only b. Characteristic of part and connection c. Characteristic of connection only d. Characteristic of part, connection, and whole e. Characteristic of connection and whole f. Characteristic of part and whole g. Characteristic of whole only

Figure 6.8

Differing characteristics among system views.

ThFNPSFDPNQMFUFQJDUVSFBMTPJODMVEFTUIFDPOOFDUJPOBNPOHQBSUT TPUIBUUIFWJFXT7 7 BOE7GSPN'JHVSFDBOBMMFYIJCJUUIFTFSFMBUJPOT8FDBOTBZUIBUUIFXIPMF DPOOFD UJPOBNPOHQBSUT BOEUIFQBSUTIBWF JOHFOFSBM EJﬀFSFOUTFUTPGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT BTEFQJDUFEJO 'JHVSF"OFYBNQMFPG B

BDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGBQBSUPOMZ JTBXIFFMBTTFNCMZ JGXFDPOTJEFSJU BTQBSUPGBDBS*UIBTUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGSPVOEOFTT XIJDIUIFDBSEPFTOPUIBWF"OFYBNQMFPG H

BDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGUIFXIPMFPOMZ JTUIFUSBOTQPSUBUJPOGVODUJPOPGBDBSBTBXIPMF XIJDIJT OPUBDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGBOZQBSUPSPGUIFDPOOFDUJPOBNPOHQBSUT&YBNQMFTPG D

BDIBSBDUFSJTUJD PGUIFDPOOFDUJPOBNPOHQBSUTPOMZ JODMVEFBOZUPQPMPHZPGJOUFSBDUJOHOPEFT TVDIBTQBSBMMFMPS TFSJBMPSBOZPGUIFOFUXPSLUPQPMPHJFTEFQJDUFEJO'JHVSF"EEJUJPOBMFYBNQMFTPGUIFUZQFTJO 'JHVSFBSFHJWFOMBUFSJOUIJTDIBQUFS "DPODFQUDMPTFMZSFMBUFEUPUIFDPOOFDUJPOBNPOHQBSUTJTJOUFSOBMFOWJSPONFOUThFJOUFSOBM FOWJSPONFOU GPSFYBNQMF JTUIFMPDVTPGIPNFPTUBTJTPGBTZTUFNUIFQSPDFTTPGNBJOUBJOJOH JOUFSOBMTUBUFEFTQJUFQFSUVSCBUJPOTJOUIFFYUFSOBMFOWJSPONFOU *OUIJTDIBQUFSXFPOMZMPPLBUUIFXIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOT OPUBUIPXUIFZDBNFJOUPFYJTUFODF ThBUUPQJDJTBEESFTTFEJO$IBQUFS XIFSFXFEJTDVTTUFNQPSBMSFMBUJPOTCFUXFFOXIPMFTBOE QBSUT TVDIBTTFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPOBOEFWPMVUJPO8FCFMJFWFUIBUUIJTTFUPGTUSVDUVSBMBOEUFNQPSBM UPQJDTOPUPOMZBEESFTTFTUIFJTTVFTPGFNFSHFODFSFMFWBOUUP4& CVUUIBUJUEPFTTPJOBNPSFEJSFDU BOEDMFBSFSXBZUIBOXPVMEBEJTDVTTJPOCBTFEPOUIFUSBEJUJPOBMGSBNFXPSLPGFNFSHFODF

Span of Control *OUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNT UIFOVNCFSPGQBSUTJOBTZTUFNJTVTVBMMZTNBMM UIFPSEFSPGNBHOJUVEF SBOHJOHGSPNUFOTUPUIPVTBOET'PSIJFSBSDIJDBMPSHBOJ[BUJPOT UIFOVNCFSJTEFTDSJCFEJOUFSNT PGTQBOPGDPOUSPM(FPSHF.JMMFS JOUSPEVDFEUIFXFMMLOPXOOPSNPG CBTFEPOUIF BWFSBHFOVNCFSPGDIVOLTPGJOGPSNBUJPOBIVNBODBOSFNFNCFSVOEFSDFSUBJODPOEJUJPOT#VU DPNQMFYTZTUFNTPGUFOIBWFBNVDIMBSHFSQBSUTUPXIPMFSBUJP JF BNVDIﬂBUUFSIJFSBSDIZ

BOE UIFOVNCFSPGJOUFSDPOOFDUJPOTBNPOHQBSUTBMTPJODSFBTFT"OFYUSFNFFYBNQMFJTOFVSPOTJOUIF IVNBOOFSWPVTTZTUFNThFOVNCFSPGOFVSPOTJOUIFIVNBOCSBJOJTPOUIFPSEFSPG BOEUIF

Composition

O 147

OVNCFSPGJOUFSDPOOFDUJPOTPSTZOBQTFTBNPOHOFVSPOTJTPOUIFPSEFSPGBUMFBTU 1BLLFOCFSH BOE(VOEFSTPO1BLLFOCFSHFUBM "NBKPSSFBTPOGPSUIFMBSHFEJﬀFSFODFCFUXFFOUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNTJTBVUPOPNZ ThBUJT JOUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTBOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOT UIFBTTVNQUJPOJTUIBUPOFDPOUSPMMFS PSNBO BHFS DPOUSPMTUIFQBSUT TPUIBUDPOUSPMMFSIBTUPLFFQUSBDLPGFWFSZUIJOH*ODPNQMFYTZTUFNT UIF QBSUTDBOBDUPOUIFJSPXO/PPOFJTJODIBSHFPGUIFOFVSPOTJOUIFCSBJOPSUIFBOUTJOBOBOU DPMPOZ"VUPOPNPVTDPNQPOFOUTBSFTFMGBDUJOH TFMGPSHBOJ[JOH BOEDPPQFSBUJOHUIFZXPSLJU PVUBNPOHUIFNTFMWFT$POTFRVFOUMZ NBOZNPSFPGUIFNDBOJOUFSBDUJOTVDIBTZTUFN

Deﬁning the Set of Basic Relations 8JUIUIFGPSFHPJOHCBDLHSPVOEEJTDVTTJPO XFBSFSFBEZUPEFﬁOFUIFTFUPGSFMBUJPOTJOUIFDPN QPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPOThFGVMMTFUJTEJWJEFEIFSFJOUPXIBUXFDBMMBCBTJDTFUBOEBOFYUFOEFETFUPG XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOT*OUIJTTFDUJPOXFEFTDSJCFUIFCBTJDTFU 5XPPCWJPVTSFMBUJPOTCFUXFFOXIPMFTBOEQBSUTBSFDPNQPTJUJPOBOEEFDPNQPTJUJPOThFTF BQQFBSJOUVJUJWFMZUPCFBDPOKVHBUFQBJS PQQPTJUFWJFXTPGUIFTBNFSFMBUJPO

CVUJO.04&4UIFZ BSFOPU8FGPMMPXUIFBQQSPBDIEFTDSJCFEJO.FZFS o ThFSFBSFGPVSSFMBUJPOTUIBU GPSNUXPDPOKVHBUFQBJSTEFDPNQPTJUJPOFODBQTVMBUJPO BOEDPNQPTJUJPODPNQPOFOUJ[BUJPO*O BEEJUJPO TFWFSBMPUIFSXIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTFYJTU "MMSFMBUJPOTJOUIFCBTJDTFUBSFFYQMBJOFEJO5BCMF8FVTFBTNBMMFYBNQMFUPJMMVTUSBUFUIF SFMBUJPOTJOUIFUBCMF4VQQPTFXFIBWFBTZTUFN4XJUIBTFUPGQBSUTDPOTJTUJOHPGDPNQPOFOUT4 4 4 BOE4 BOEDPOOFDUPST/ / / BOE/ BTTIPXOJO'JHVSF%FﬁOFUIFFYUFSOBM NPEFMPG4BT4FYUBOEUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFMPG4 PSUIFDPOOFDUJPOBNPOHUIFQBSUTPG4 BT4JOU BMPOH XJUIFYUFSOBMNPEFMTPGFBDIQBSU BTTIPXOJOUIe ﬁHVSF 6TJOHUIFTFUFSNTBOEUIJTFYBNQMF 5BCMFJEFOUJﬁFTBOEFYQMBJOTUIFCBTJDTFUPGXIPMFoQBSU SFMBUJPOT$PMVNOOBNFTUIFSFMBUJPOBOENBQTJUUPUIFDPSSFTQPOEJOHDIBSBDUFSJTUJDUZQF B z H

S external model Sext p2

S

p6

r3 r1

S internal model Sint p2

S1

r4

S1ext

N1 p4 N1ext

r6

p2

Figure 6.9

S2ext

r7 r5

r3

N3ext N3

p6 S3ext S3

r3

p7

N2 N2ext p6

S2

N4ext N4 p5

Example of basic whole–part relations.

S4

r1 S4ext r1

148 O Table 6.1

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science Basic Whole–Part Relations

Relation Decomposition

Encapsulation Composition Componentization Inclusion

Delegation (char C(d,e)) Delegation (char C(b,d)) Delegation (char C(d,f)) Propagation (char C(d,e)) Propagation (char C(b,d))

Propagation (char C(d,f))

Non-delegation (char C(f,g)) Non-delegation (char C(c,e))

Non-delegation (char C(g,e))

Description Using Entities in Figure 6.9 Sint is a decomposition of Sext. In engineering, decomposition is the traditional design problem, i.e., Sint represents a design or architecture of a system. Sext is an encapsulation of Sint (conjugate of decomposition). Sint is a composition of {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4} {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4} is a componentization of Sint (conjugate of composition). Internal model of S (Sint) includes external model of each part (S1ext, S2ext, S3ext, S4ext, N1ext, N2ext, N3ext, N4ext); view of a whole as connection among parts includes view of each part as a whole; clear-box view of whole includes black-box view of each part. Sext delegates characteristics (properties, behaviors, functions, services) to Sint. Refers to an external characteristic of the whole (Sext) that is or becomes a characteristic of the connection among the parts (Sint). Sint delegates characteristics to {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4}. Refers to a characteristic of the connection among the parts that is or becomes a characteristic of one or more parts. Sext delegates characteristics to {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4}. Refers to an external characteristic of the whole that is or becomes a characteristic of one or more parts. Sint propagates characteristics to Sext. Refers to a characteristic of the connection among the parts that is or becomes a characteristic of the whole. {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4} propagates characteristics to Sint. Refers to a characteristic of one or more parts that is or becomes a characteristic of the connection among the parts. A model in which all characteristics of Sint are propagated in this way, and are dependent on the parts, is sometimes called reductionism. {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4} propagates characteristics to Sext. Refers to a characteristic of one or more parts that is or becomes a characteristic of the whole. A model in which all characteristics of the whole are propagated in this way, and are dependent on the parts, is sometimes called reductionism. Sext does not delegate to Sint. Refers to a characteristic of the whole that is not a characteristic of connection among parts. We call this a systemic characteristic. Sint does not delegate to {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4}. Refers to a characteristic of connection among parts that is not a characteristic of parts. We call this a composite characteristic. If there is a dependence on parts, this relation corresponds to what is sometimes called a form of emergence. Sext does not delegate to {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4}. Refers to a characteristic of the whole that is not a characteristic of parts. We call this a systemic characteristic. If there is a dependence on parts, this relation corresponds to what is sometimes called a form of emergence.

Composition Table 6.1

O 149

Basic Whole–Part Relations (Continued)

Relation Non-propagation (char C(b,c)) Non-propagation (char C(a,f)) Non-propagation (char C(a,b)) Trace

Description Using Entities in Figure 6.9 Sint does not propagate to Sext. Refers to a characteristic of connection among parts that is not a characteristic of the whole. {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4} does not propagate to Sint. Refers to a characteristic of parts that is not a characteristic of connection among parts. {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4} does not propagate to Sext. Refers to a characteristic of parts that is not a characteristic of the whole. Trace or mapping between characteristics of Sext and Sint, or Sint and {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4}, or Sext and {S1,S2,S3,S4,N1,N2,N3,N4}.

JO'JHVSF'PSFYBNQMF UIFEFMFHBUJPOSFMBUJPOGSPN4FYUUP4JOUDBOPDDVSGPSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTEBOE FJO'JHVSF "MMEFMFHBUJPO OPOEFMFHBUJPO QSPQBHBUJPO BOEOPOQSPQBHBUJPOSFMBUJPOTJOUIFUBCMFDBO QPUFOUJBMMZCFPGUXPUZQFTEFQFOEFOUPSJOEFQFOEFOU'PSFYBNQMF JOUIFQSPQBHBUJPOPG4JOU UP 4FYU UIF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PG 4FYU NBZ CF EFQFOEFOU PO PS JOEFQFOEFOU PG UIF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PG4JOU ThFDPOOFDUJPOBNPOHQBSUT 4JOU DMFBSMZQMBZTBDFOUSBMSPMFJOUIFTFUPGWJFXTPGBTZTUFNThF SFMBUJPOSFQSFTFOUTCPUIBEFDPNQPTJUJPOPGBXIPMFBOEBDPNQPTJUJPOPGBTFUPGQBSUT ThFDPOKVHBUJPOBOEEJSFDUJPOBMJUZPGUIFTFSFMBUJPOTOFFETBEEJUJPOBMFYQMBOBUJPO*OUIJTEJT DVTTJPOXFXJMMTJNQMJGZUIFUISFFQBSUXIPMFoDPOOFDUJPOBNPOHQBSUToQBSUTTUSVDUVSFBOE TJNQMZEJTDVTTXIPMFBOEQBSUTUIFBQQMJDBUJPOUPUIFGVMMTUSVDUVSFTIPVMECFDMFBS $IBSBDUFSJTUJDTJOEFMFHBUJPOBOEQSPQBHBUJPO CZEFﬁOJUJPO FYJTUGPSCPUIQBSUBOEXIPMF .PTU JGOPUBMM DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUQBSUJDJQBUFJOUIFEFMFHBUJPOBOEQSPQBHBUJPOSFMBUJPOTBSFOPU JOIFSFOUMZEJSFDUJPOBM8IFUIFSUIFZBSFNPEFMFEBTEFMFHBUJPO XIPMFUPQBSU PSQSPQBHBUJPO QBSUUPXIPMF JTBNBUUFSPGDIPJDFPSWJFXQPJOU0OFIFVSJTUJDGPSUIJTTFUPGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTJT UIBUBUPQEPXOFOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTUZQJDBMMZWJFXTUIFSFMBUJPOBTEFMFHBUJPO XIJMFBCPUUPNVQ QSPDFTTUZQJDBMMZWJFXTUIFSFMBUJPOBTQSPQBHBUJPO 8FVTFUIFQSPQFSUZPGNBTTUPJMMVTUSBUFUIFEJﬀFSFODFJOWJFX*OBQIZTJDBMTZTUFN UIFXIPMF TZTUFNIBTBNBTT FBDIQIZTJDBMQBSUIBTBNBTT BOEUIFSFMBUJPOJTUIBUUIFNBTTPGUIFXIPMFJT UIFTVNPGUIFNBTTPGFBDIQBSU8PVMEXFTBZUIBUUIJTQSPQFSUZJTQSPQBHBUFEGSPNUIFQBSUTUP UIFXIPMF PSUIBUJUJTEFMFHBUFEGSPNUIFXIPMFUPUIFQBSUT *ODBTFTXIFSFNBTTJTOPUBTFSJPVT DPOTUSBJOU XFXPVMETBZUIFQSPQFSUZJTQSPQBHBUFECFDBVTFUIFNBTTPGUIFXIPMFDPNFTEJSFDUMZ GSPNUIFNBTTPGFBDIQBSU0OUIFPUIFSIBOE TVQQPTFXFBSFCVJMEJOHBTQBDFWFIJDMFXIFSFUIF PWFSBMMNBTTJTBTJHOJﬁDBOUDPOTUSBJOU*OUIFEFTJHOQSPDFTT XFVTFUIFUPUBMDPOTUSBJOFENBTT BTBCVEHFUUIBUXFBQQPSUJPOUPUIFWBSJPVTQBSUTThFEFTJHOJOWPMWFTUSBEFPﬀTJGXFBMMPXPOF QBSUUPJODSFBTFNBTT XFNVTUSFEVDFUIFNBTTPGBOPUIFSQBSU'SPNUIJTWJFXQPJOU XFXPVME QSPCBCMZWJFXNBTTBTBEFMFHBUJPOGSPNUIFXIPMFUPUIFQBSU"MMPDBUJPOJTBDPNNPOUFSNGPS UIJTJODBTFT TVDIBTNBTT XIFSFUIFWBMVFPGUIFQSPQFSUZDBOCFTVCEJWJEFE "DPNNPOFYBNQMFPGBDIBSBDUFSJTUJDUIBUGPSNTPOFFOEPGBDPOKVHBUFSFMBUJPOJTUIFDBU FHPSZPGSFRVJSFETFSWJDFTBOEQSPWJEFETFSWJDFT BTTIPXOJO'JHVSF ThFDPOKVHBUFOBUVSFPG QSPWJEFEBOESFRVJSFETFSWJDFTJTTIPXOJOUIF4JOUFSOBMNPEFM'PSFYBNQMF 4SFRVJSFTTFSWJDF

150 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Propagate (internal to external) or delegate (external to internal)

S external model p2 p6

r3 S

r1

S internal model p2

p2

p6

S1

r4

N1

p4

S2

r6

p7

N2

N3

p6

r7

S3

r5

N4

p5

S4

r3 r3

r1

r1

Figure 6.10 Conjugate propagation and delegation relations. (Source: Hybertson, D. Using a speciﬁcation approach to facilitate component testing. In Testing Commercial-off-the-Shelf Components and Systems, S. Beydeda and V. Gruhn, Eds. New York: Springer-Verlag, p. 213– 237, 2005. Used with permission of Springer Science + Business Media.)

4QSPWJEFTTFSWJDF BOEJOUIF4DPOOFDUJPOBNPOHQBSUT 4PCUBJOTTFSWJDFGSPN4"U UIFOFYUIJHIFSDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFMJTXIFSFPOFFOEPGFBDIPGTFWFSBMDPOKVHBUFTJTFYQPTFEThF TZTUFN4QSPWJEFTTFSWJDFGPSBOZPUIFSTZTUFNUIBUSFRVJSFTJU BOE4SFRVJSFTTFSWJDFGSPN BOZPUIFSTZTUFNUIBUQSPWJEFTJU&YBNQMFTPGUIFEFMFHBUJPOQSPQBHBUJPOSFMBUJPOJOUIFﬁHVSF JODMVEFUIFQBSU4BOEUIFXIPMF4QSPWJEFTFSWJDF BOEUIFQBSU4BOEUIFXIPMF4SFRVJSF TFSWJDF 8IFUIFSXFWJFXUIFTFBTQSPQBHBUJPOPSEFMFHBUJPOBHBJOEFQFOETPOUIFTJUVBUJPO FTQFDJBMMZ GPSQSPWJEFETFSWJDFT*GXFBSFEPJOHUPQEPXOFOHJOFFSJOHBOETQFDJGZUIBUXFOFFEBTZTUFNUIBU QSPWJEFTTFSWJDF BOEUIFOBOFOHJOFFSEFTJHOTJUTPUIBUQBSU4QSPWJEFTUIBUTFSWJDF XFXPVME MJLFMZWJFXTFSWJDFBTBEFMFHBUFEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDGSPN4UP40OUIFPUIFSIBOE JG4XFSFBO FYJTUJOHTZTUFNBOEXFEFDJEFEUPDPNQPTF4BTBTZTUFNPGTZTUFNTUIBUUPPLBEWBOUBHFPG4 UPPﬀFSTFSWJDF XFXPVMEMJLFMZWJFXTFSWJDFBTBQSPQBHBUFEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDGSPN4UP4ThF SFRVJSFETFSWJDFT TVDIBTTFSWJDF BSFNPSFPGUFOWJFXFEBTQSPQBHBUFEUIBOBTEFMFHBUFE8IJMF TPNF SFRVJSFE TFSWJDFT BSF JOEFQFOEFOU PG UIF EFTJHO NBOZ EFQFOE PO UIF EFTJHO ThFSFGPSF BGVMMBDDPVOUPGTFSWJDFTSFRVJSFECZBTZTUFNBOETZTUFNEFQFOEFODJFTJOHFOFSBMNVTU BXBJUDPNQMFUJPOPGUIFEFTJHO XIJDIHJWFTUIFTFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTNPSFPGBCPUUPNVQQSPQBHBUJPO ﬂBWPS ThFOPOEFMFHBUJPOBOEOPOQSPQBHBUJPOSFMBUJPOT IPXFWFS BSFJOIFSFOUMZEJSFDUJPOBMGPSBMM DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUQBSUJDJQBUF*OOPOEFMFHBUJPO BDIBSBDUFSJTUJDFYJTUTJOUIFXIPMFCVUOPUUIF QBSUTBOEJOOPOQSPQBHBUJPO JUFYJTUTJOPOFPSNPSFQBSUTCVUOPUUIFXIPMF*OCPUIDBTFT XF IBWFOPTZNNFUSZBOEOPDIPJDFJOUIFSFMBUJPOEFTJHOBUJPO

Composition

O 151

Deﬁning the Set of Extended Relations /PXXFXJMMBEESFTTUIFFYUFOEFETFUPGSFMBUJPOTBMUFSOBUJWF DPOTFDVUJWF BOETIBSFEXIPMFo QBSU 4VQQPTF XF IBWF B TZTUFN 4 XJUI UISFF EJﬀFSFOU JOUFSOBM NPEFMT 4* 4* BOE 4* BO FYUFSOBMNPEFM4&BOEUISFFEJﬀFSFOUQPUFOUJBMFODPNQBTTJOHTZTUFNT4 4 BOE4 BTTIPXO JO'JHVSF ThJTFYBNQMFJTGSPNUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGPOFXIPMF UIBUJT BOFYUFSOBMWJFXPGTZTUFN46TJOHUIFTF UFSNTBOEUIJTFYBNQMF 5BCMFJEFOUJﬁFTBOEFYQMBJOTUIFFYUFOEFETFUPGXIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOT 'PSUIFDPOTFDVUJWFBOETJNVMUBOFPVTSFMBUJPOT NVUBCMFDPNQPTJUJPOEPFTOPUHFOFSBMMZBQQMZ CVUOFJUIFSJTJUQSFDMVEFE*UEPFTSBJTFUIFRVFTUJPOPGSFWFSTJCJMJUZ'PSFYBNQMF JG4NVTUCF NPEJﬁFEUPCFJOUFHSBUFEJOUP4 DBOJUCFiVONPEJﬁFEwPSSFUVSOFEUPJUTPSJHJOBMGPSNJGMBUFS SFNPWFEGSPN4 "OEDBOJt ﬁUPSCFNPEJﬁFEBHBJOUo ﬁUJOUP4 *O'JHVSF 4&JTBDPOUFYUHFOFSBMFYUFSOBMNPEFMPG44& 4& BOE4&BSFDPOUFYU TQFDJﬁDFYUFSOBMNPEFMTPG4ThFDPOUFYUHFOFSBMBOEDPOUFYUTQFDJﬁDNPEFMTDPSSFMBUF SFTQFDUJWFMZ XJUIUIFMPXFSBOEVQQFSFYUFSOBMNPEFMTPG4JO'JHVSF ThJTEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFODPOUFYUHFOFSBMBOEDPOUFYUTQFDJﬁDFYUFSOBMTQFDTBMTPJMMVTUSBUFTB GPSNPG(ÚEFMTJODPNQMFUFOFTTUIFPSFNThFBQQMJDBUJPOPSBOBMPHPGUIJTUIFPSFNGPSTZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOHDPNQPTJUJPOJTTPNFUIJOHMJLFUIJTThFVTFTPSSPMFTPGBTZTUFNDBOOPUCFEFUFSNJOFE CZPSGPSUIFTZTUFNTFQBSBUFGSPNBDPOUFYUPSFOWJSPONFOU"MBSHFSFOWJSPONFOUJTOFFEFEUP EFﬁOFUIFVTFTBOESPMFT. ThVT UIFFYUFSOBMNPEFM4&JO'JHVSFEPFTOPUEFﬁOFXIBUSPMFT4 QMBZT. ThFJOUFSOBMNPEFMT4 4 BOE4EFﬁOFUIFSFTQFDUJWFSPMFTPG4JOUIPTFFOWJSPONFOUT ThFSFJTBTUSPOHTFOTFJOXIJDIFBDITZTUFNFYJTUTJOJUTPXOXPSME.PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ UIF FYUFSOBMWJFXBOEWJFXQPJOUPGBHJWFOTZTUFNTIBSFBXPSMEXJUIUIFFOWJSPONFOUPGUIFTZTUFN BOEUIBUFOWJSPONFOUNBZTIBSFBXPSMEXJUIBMBSHFSTZTUFNPGXIJDIJUJTBQBSUCVUUIFJOUFSOBM BOEFYUFSOBMPGBTZTUFNBSFJONBOZSFTQFDUTEJﬀFSFOUXPSMETBOEUIFTBNFEJTUJODUJPOSFQFBUT BUFBDIDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFMBOEGPSFBDITZTUFNBUBHJWFOMFWFM%JﬀFSFODFTJOMBOHVBHF POUPMPHZ HFOFSBMJ[BUJPO DBUFHPSJ[BUJPO BOEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTDBOPDDVSJOFBDIXPSMEThFTFEJﬀFSFOUXPSMET BSFDMPTFMZSFMBUFEUPUIFDPODFQUTPGOPOQSPQBHBUJOHBOEOPOEFMFHBUJOHDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT

Encompassing System or Environment Space S1

S2

S3

S11

S12

S21

S22

S31

S32

S13

SE1

S23

SE2

S33

SE3

External model of S

SE

SI 1

SI 2

(context-general)

SI 3

SI11

SI12

SI21

SI22

SI31

SI32

SI13

SI14

SI23

SI24

SI33

SI34

Implementation space

Figure 6.11

Example of extended whole–part relations.

152

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Table 6.2 Extended Whole–Part Relations Relation

Description Using Entities in Figure 6.11

The following relations can exist in both contained composition models and shared composition models: Alternative Alternative

Alternative Consecutive

One whole to many alternative potential sets of parts: S could be decomposed into many alternative relations on parts — such as SI1, SI2, or SI3. One whole to many alternative “actual” sets of parts: S could be decomposed into many alternative views, where each view has different components; e.g., SI1 might be a functional view, SI2 a physical deployment view, SI3 a data view. One part to many alternative potential wholes: S could be a part of many alternative systems, such as S1, S2, or S3. One part to many wholes consecutively at different times, i.e., subject to the contained model constraint (but not the shared model constraint) that a part can only exist in one whole at a given point in time: S could consecutively be a part of multiple systems — ﬁrst S1, then S2, then S3.

These relations can exist only in shared composition models: Simultaneous One part to many wholes simultaneously. Simultaneous Network of many wholes to many parts.

Multilevel Composition Structures and Scales " WBSJFUZ PG NVMUJMFWFM DPNQPTJUJPO TUSVDUVSFT FYJTU JODMVEJOH SFQFBUJOH SFMBUJPOT TVDI BT IJFS BSDIJFTBOEOFUXPSLTThJTTFDUJPOEJTDVTTFTUIFTFTUSVDUVSFTBOEIPXUIFZWBSZGPSUIFEJﬀFSFOU DPNQPTJUJPONPEFMT

Multilevel Structures 8FTUBSUXJUIUIFCBTJDXIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOT BOEFTQFDJBMMZUIFCBTJDXIPMFo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hJTDBOCFSFQFBUFEBTNBOZMFWFMTBTOFDFTTBSZ#PUIDPNQPOFOUT BOEDPOOFDUPSTFYJTUBUFBDIMFWFMThFJOUFSUXJOJOHQBUUFSOXBTEJTDVTTFECZ%BWJT JOUFSNTPGXIBUWFSTVTIPXThFJOUFSOBMEFTDSJCFTUIFAIPXBUBHJWFOMFWFM BOEUIBUMFBETUPUIF FYUFSOBMPSUIFAXIBUPGUIFOFYUMFWFM 8FDBOHPCFZPOEUIJTTUSVDUVSFCZDPOTJEFSJOHUIFFYUFOEFETFUPGXIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTGSPN UIFQSFWJPVTTFDUJPOBOEFYUSBQPMBUJOHUPNVMUJQMFMFWFMTThFNVMUJMFWFMTUSVDUVSFTEFTDSJCFECFMPX BSFWBSZJOHJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTPGUIFWJFXTJO'JHVSF

Composition

S S1

S2

S3

S4

Whole of S External Connection among S parts Internal whole S4 part External Connection among S4 parts Internal whole S44 part External Connection among S44 parts Internal

Figure 6.12

O 153

At each level, whole = external model, connection among parts = internal model, part whole at next level down; = external model so the repeating pattern is an intertwining of external-internal-external-internal... S4 S41

S42

S43

S44

S4 S44 S441

S442

S443

S444

S44

Repeating whole–part contained composition structure.

$PNQPTJUJPOTUSVDUVSFTHFOFSBUFECZDPOUBJOFENPEFMTBOETIBSFENPEFMTJODMVEF )JFSBSDIZ SFQFBUJOHPOFUPNBOZSFMBUJPO PGPOFXIPMFUPNBOZQBSUT )JFSBSDIZPGPOFXIPMFUPNBOZBMUFSOBUJWFQPUFOUJBMTFUTPGQBSUT )JFSBSDIZPGPOFQBSUUPNBOZBMUFSOBUJWFQPUFOUJBMXIPMFT )JFSBSDIZPGPOFQBSUUPNBOZXIPMFTBUEJﬀFSFOUUJNFT UIBUJT TVCKFDUUPUIFDPOUBJOFE BOEDPOTFDVUJWFNPEFMDPOTUSBJOUUIBUBQBSUDBOPOMZFYJTUJOPOFXIPMFBUBHJWFOQPJOU JOUJNF

Composition level

Lower Higher

O O O O

Single

Parts hierarchy Wholes hierarchy Dual hierarchies

Views Interpreting these as alternatives: Single: One composition option, no alternatives Parts: From top down, multiple alternative sets of parts at each level—e.g., system can have multiple potential designs Wholes: From bottom up, multiple alternative encompassing wholes at each level—e.g., system can ﬁt in multiple potential environments Dual: From any intermediate point, dual hierarchies or holarchies: – Down = Alternative sets of parts – Up = Alternative encompassing wholes

Figure 6.13

Views of extended relations in multilevel compositions.

154 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

$PNQPTJUJPOTUSVDUVSFTHFOFSBUFEPOMZCZTIBSFENPEFMTJODMVEF O )JFSBSDIZPGPOFQBSUUPNBOZXIPMFTTJNVMUBOFPVTMZ O /FUXPSLPGNBOZXIPMFTUPNBOZQBSUT SFQFBUFEUPNVMUJQMFMFWFMT O -BZFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSFT ThFTFTUSVDUVSFT BOEFTQFDJBMMZUIFQFSWBTJWFEVBMIJFSBSDIJFT SFWFBMUIFGPSNPGUIFNBOZUP NBOZOFUXPSLTUSVDUVSFPGUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPOJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF

Multiple Levels of Living Systems +BNFT.JMMFS EFTDSJCFEJOEFQUIUIFBSDIJUFDUVSF GVODUJPOT FMFNFOUT BOEQSPDFTTFTPGMJW JOHTZTUFNTBUNVMUJQMFMFWFMT SBOHJOHGSPNBDFMMUPBTVQSBOBUJPOBMTZTUFN0OFNJHIUDBMMUIJT TUSVDUVSFBMJWJOHIPMBSDIZ'PSUIFQVSQPTFTPGUIJTDIBQUFS XFDPOTJEFSUIFTFMGTJNJMBSJUZPGUIJT TUSVDUVSFGSPNUXPWJFXQPJOUT BTFUPGGVODUJPOT .JMMFSDBMMFEUIFNTVCTZTUFNT JOFBDI TZTUFNUIBUBSFDPNNPOBDSPTTBMMMFWFMT BOE QIZTJDBMFMFNFOUTUIBUWBSZBDSPTTMFWFMT .JMMFSEFTDSJCFEFJHIUMFWFMTPGDPNQPTJUJPODFMM PSHBO PSHBOJTN HSPVQ PSHBOJ[BUJPO DPN NVOJUZ TPDJFUZ BOETVQSBOBUJPOBMTZTUFN"MUIPVHIIFDBMMFEUIFTFMJWJOHTZTUFNT NVDIPGUIF GPDVTJTIVNBODFOUSJD)FBTDFSUBJOFEGVODUJPOTUIBUFYJTUJOBMMMJWJOHTZTUFNTBUBMMUIFTF MFWFMT. Th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hFCPVOEBSZGVODUJPOJTQFSGPSNFEJOBDFMMCZ QMBTNBNFNCSBOFJOBOPSHBOJTNCZTLJOJOBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOCZHVBSETBUBCVJMEJOHFOUSBODFGPS NBUUFSFOFSHZ BOECZBOFUXPSk ﬁSFXBMMGPSJOGPSNBUJPO ThFSFJTBOPUIFSJNQPSUBOUQFSTQFDUJWFPOUIFGVODUJPOTOBNFMZUIBUUIFZDPVMETFSWFBT UIFFMFNFOUTPGBVOJWFSTBMBSDIJUFDUVSFThJTQPTTJCJMJUZ BMPOHXJUINPSFEFTDSJQUJPOPGUIFGVOD UJPOT JTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS "OPUIFSCJPMPHJDBMNPEFMPGNVMUJQMFMFWFMTJTUIFGSBNFXPSLGPSDPOﬂJDUBOEDPPQFSBUJPOHJWFO CZ 'VUVZNB ThF DPOﬂJDU BOE DPPQFSBUJPO SFMBUJPOT DPFYJTU JO WBSJPVT DPNCJOBUJPOT PG BUUSBDUJWFBOESFQVMTJWFGPSDFTJOUIFGPSNBUJPOPGBIJHIFSMFWFMFOUJUZGSPNMPXFSMFWFMVOJUT BOE UIJTDBOSFDVSBDSPTTNVMUJQMFDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFMT

Composition Scale Issue .04&4 DPOTJEFST SFQFBUJOH DPNQPTJUJPO TUSVDUVSFT BT PQFOFOEFE JO FJUIFS EJSFDUJPO VQ PS EPXO ThF TBNF QBUUFSO DBO CF SFQFBUFE BU BT NBOZ MFWFMT BT OFFEFE GPS UIF VOEFSTUBOEJOH BOE FOHJOFFSJOH PG BOZ TZTUFN ThF QIZTJDBM XPSME JT B HJBOU DPNQPTJUJPO IJFSBSDIZ PS IPMBS DIZUIBUSBOHFTGSPNTVQFSTUSJOHTVQUPHBMBYJFTBOEUIFFOUJSFLOPXOVOJWFSTFThJTJTBMBSHF SBOHFPGTDBMFTUIBUSFQSFTFOUTBTJ[FEJﬀFSFODFPGBCPVUPSEFSTPGNBHOJUVEF BDDPSEJOHUP

Composition

O 155

%ZTPO ThFTDBMFXIFSFIVNBOTFYJTUJTBQQSPYJNBUFMZJOUIFNJEEMFPGUIJTSBOHF 5SBEJUJPOBMMZ 4&IBTPQFSBUFEQSJNBSJMZBUUIJTTDBMFCVUJUJTOPXCFJOHFYUFOEFECPUIVQBOE EPXO/BOPUFDIOPMPHZUBLFTFOHJOFFSJOHEPXOUPUIFNPMFDVMBSPSBUPNJDTDBMFThFMBSHFSBOHF PGTDBMFTJTTPNFUJNFTHSPVQFEJOUPOBOPTDBMF NJDSPTDBMF NFTPTDBMF IVNBOT

BOENBDSP TDBMFMFWFMT#FDBVTFOBOPEFWJDFTXJMMVMUJNBUFMZOFFEUPCFVTFEJOUIFNBDSPXPSME 4&XJMM OFFEUPUSBWFSTFBOEJOUFHSBUFBMMUIFTFTDBMFT PSBUMFBTUGSPNBUPNJDVQUPTFWFSBMPSEFSTPGNBH OJUVEFBCPWFIVNBOT ThFSFIBTBMTPCFFODPOTJEFSBCMFEJTDVTTJPOJO4&BCPVUNFHBTZTUFNTBOETZTUFNTPGTZTUFNT XIJDI SFRVJSF TPNF EFHSFF PG TDBMFVQ 4ZTUFNT UIBU DSPTT PSHBOJ[BUJPOBM CPVOEBSJFT BOE FWFO OBUJPOBMCPVOEBSJFT TVDIBTDPBMJUJPOGPSDFT NPWFJOUPUIFDPNQMFYTZTUFNTBSFOBBOEQSFTFOU TJHOJﬁDBOUDIBMMFOHFT)PXFWFS JOUFSNTPGMFWFMTPGDPNQPTJUJPO 4&JTBSHVBCMZCFJOHTUSFUDIFE MFTTJOUIFTDBMFVQEJSFDUJPOCZUIFTFMBSHFTZTUFNTUIBOJOUIFTDBMFEPXOEJSFDUJPOCZOBOPUFDI OPMPHZ*OBOZDBTF UIFTFMGTJNJMBSDPNQPTJUJPOTUSVDUVSFTBOESFMBUJPOT BOESFQFBUJOHQBUUFSOT PG.04&4GBDJMJUBUFCPUITDBMFVQBOETDBMFEPXOThPTFTUSVDUVSFTDBQUVSFUIFTJNJMBSJUJFTBUBMM MFWFMTCVUXFTUJMMOFFEBXBZUPDBQUVSFUIFEJﬀFSFODFTCFUXFFOMFWFMTThF.04&4NFDIBOJTNT GPSDBQUVSJOHEJﬀFSFODFTBSFEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS ThF DPODFQU PG TDBMF JT BMTP DPOOFDUFE UP UIF .04&4 TVCKFDU PG WJFXT ThJT DPOOFDUJPO JT EJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS

Membrane Characteristics 8FOPXSFWJTJUUIFCPVOEBSZPSNFNCSBOFJTTVFUIBUXBTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFSThFSFBTPOJT UIBUDPNQPTJUJPOCSJOHTUIJTJTTVFTUSPOHMZJOUPQMBZ*OQBSUJDVMBS 4& JODMVEJOHCVUOPUMJNJUFE UPUIFTIBSFEDPNQPTJUJPONPEFM PGUFOSFRVJSFTFYQMJDJUBOEOPOUSJWJBMEFDJTJPOTPOXIFSFTZTUFN CPVOEBSJFTMJF BTXFMMBTPUIFSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT ThFQMBDFNFOUPGBNFNCSBOFPSCPVOEBSZNBZCFPCWJPVTJOTPNFTZTUFNT CVUJONBOZ TZTUFNTJUOFFETUPCFEFﬁOFECZTPNFPOF VTVBMMZCZUIFPCTFSWFSXIPEFﬁOFEUIFTZTUFN BTXF OPUFEJOPVS$IBQUFSEFﬁOJUJPOPGTZTUFN"LFZDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGUIFNFNCSBOFJTJUTQFSNF BCJMJUZ XIJDINBZSBOHFGSPNFOUJSFMZUSBOTQBSFOU OPFODBQTVMBUJPO UPFOUJSFMZPQBRVF GVMMPS FYUSFNFFODBQTVMBUJPO O &YUSFNFFODBQTVMBUJPOCPYPMPHZ TFFCFMPX

O /PFODBQTVMBUJPO JOWJTJCMFBOEOPOVUJMJUBSJBONFNCSBOFT JF JOBOPOFODBQTVMBUFE TZTUFNPGTFWFSBMDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFMT UIFUPQMFWFMTZTUFNJOFﬀFDUDPOTJTUTPGBMMUIFQBSUT BUUIFCPUUPNMFWFMBOEUIFPWFSBMMDPOOFDUJPOBNPOHUIFN

O 1BSUJBMFODBQTVMBUJPO TVDIBTFODBQTVMBUJPOPGTPNFQBSUTBOEOPUPUIFST PSQFSIBQTNBL JOHBQBSUWJTJCMFCVUOPUBDDFTTJCMF PSQFSIBQTNBLJOHTZTUFNTUBUFWJTJCMF O /POEFﬁOJUJWFNFNCSBOFTGV[[ZPSVODFSUBJONFNCSBOF N 'V[[ZNFNCSBOFTJUVBUJPOJOXIJDIBQBSUJTQBSUMZJOBOEQBSUMZPVUPGBTZTUFN JO BSBOHFPG FOUJSFMZPVU UP FOUJSFMZJO

N 6ODFSUBJONFNCSBOFTJUVBUJPOJOXIJDIJUJTVOLOPXOXIFUIFSBQBSUJTJOPSPVUPG BTZTUFN CVUJOHFOFSBMBMJLFMJIPPEPSQSPCBCJMJUZDBOCFFTUJNBUFEJOBSBOHFPG DFSUBJOMZPVU UP DFSUBJOMZJO ThFOFFEGPSGV[[ZBOEVODFSUBJOCPVOEBSZJTNJUJHBUFECZUIFGBDUUIBUBTZTUFNJTXIBUBO PCTFSWFS TBZT JU JT BOE UIFSFGPSF UIF PCTFSWFS DBO EFﬁOF UIF CPVOEBSZ UP JODMVEF BOE FYDMVEF

156 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

XIBUFWFSIFXBOUT/FWFSUIFMFTT UIFSFBSFTUJMMTJUVBUJPOTJOXIJDIGV[[JOFTTBOEVODFSUBJOUZBSF VTFGVM JOEFﬁOJOH CPVOEBSJFT $IBQUFS HJWFT NPSF EFUBJMT PO UIF TQFDJﬁDBUJPO PG GV[[Z BOE VODFSUBJOCPVOEBSJFTBOEUIFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOUIFN

Extreme Encapsulation: Boxology ThF EJTDVTTJPO JO UIJT TFDUJPO BTTVNFT PQFO TZTUFNT *U JT BMTP CBTFE QSJNBSJMZ PO B DPOUBJOFE DPNQPTJUJPONPEFM8FEFTDSJCFFYUSFNFFODBQTVMBUJPOJOUFSNTPGCPYFTJOTUFBEPGTZTUFNT UP FNQIBTJ[FUIBUUIFDPODFQUTBSFWFSZHFOFSBM*UBMTPTVNNBSJ[FTNBOZPGUIFQPJOUTUIBUIBWFCFFO NBEFJOUIJTDIBQUFS*OUIFEJTDVTTJPOUIBUGPMMPXT CPYNFBOTXIBUJTPGUFODBMMFECMBDLCPYThBU JT BCPYUIBUIJEFTXIBUJTJOTJEFJU O #PY TPNFUIJOH PG JOUFSFTU BT B XIPMF DPOUBJOT B TFU PG JOUFSBDUJOH QBSUT IBT B deﬁned CPVOEBSZUIBUTFQBSBUFTXIBUJTJOTJEFGSPNXIBUJTPVUTJEFIJEFTCPUIJOTJEFBOEPVUTJEF GSPNFBDIPUIFSBOEIBTQPJOUTJOUIFCPVOEBSZ DBMMFECPVOEBSZQPJOUT UIBUDBOCFJOUFS QSFUFEBTQPSUTPSBDDFTTQPJOUTPSJOUFSGBDFQPJOUT4tuﬀ DBOHPUISPVHIUIFCPVOEBSZBU UIFCPVOEBSZQPJOUT FJUIFSGSPNPVUTJEFJOPSGSPNJOTJEFPVU O ThF QBSUTPGBCPYBSFUIFNTFMWFTCPYFTBOEDPOOFDUPSTUISPVHIXIJDIUIFZJOUFSBDUWJB UIFJSFYQPTFECPVOEBSZQPJOUT O " CPY FYIJCJUT DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT XIJDI BSF TFQBSBUFE CZ JUT CPVOEBSZ JOUP FYUFSOBM BOE JOUFSOBMDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT N ThF FYUFSOBM CMBDLCPY DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGBCPYBSFFYUFSOBMMZWJTJCMFBUJUTFYQPTFE CPVOEBSZQPJOUT N Th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hFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOUIFUXPBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGBCPYJODMVEFTUIFFYUFSOBMNPEFMT PGJUTQBSUT N 0UIFSSFMBUJPOTCFUXFFOJOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBMNPEFMTFYJTU BTEFTDSJCFEJOUIJTDIBQ UFSJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi3FMBUJPOT#FUXFFO8IPMFTBOE1BSUT wCVUUIPTFBSFMFTT SFMBUFEUPFODBQTVMBUJPO

ThFFYQPTFECPVOEBSZQPJOUT PSQPSUT PGBTZTUFNBSFJONBOZDBTFTBMTPQBSUTPGUIFTZTUFN FH BDPOUSPM LOPCPOBOBQQMJBODF PSUIFTUFFSJOHXIFFMJOBDBS 8IFOXFEJTDVTTFYUSFNFFODBQTVMBUJPOPGTVDIBTZTUFN XFNFBOJUIJEFTBMMJOUFSOBMQBSUT OPUQPSUT1PSUTBSF CZEFﬁOJUJPO OPU GVMMZ FODBQTVMBUFE

Composition

O 157

O #PYFTBSFOFTUFEBCPYDPOUBJOTBMMCPYFTCFMPXJU.PEFMTPGCPYFTBSFOPUOFTUFEBNPEFM JTPOMZPOFMFWFMEFFQ O "CPYJTBWFSZHFOFSBMDPODFQUUIBUDBOCFJOUFSQSFUFEBTBOBUVSBMPSBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFN B USBEJUJPOBMPSDPNQMFYTZTUFN BDPNQPOFOU BQFSTPO BOPSHBOJ[BUJPOPSFOUFSQSJTF BHSPVQ PGQFSTPOT BDPMMFDUJPOPGBOZPGUIFGPSFHPJOHBOEBOZDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFM GSPNOBOPUP NBDSP

Partial or No Encapsulation 8IBUDIBOHFTJGBTZTUFNJTOPUFODBQTVMBUFE UIBUJT UIFTZTUFNCPVOEBSZJTUSBOTQBSFOUBOE DPNQMFUFMZ QFSNFBCMF 8F DPVME NPEFM UIJT TJUVBUJPO JO BU MFBTU UXP XBZT 0OF NPEFM JT UIBU UIFXIPMF UIFCPVOEBSZ 4FYUEPFTOPUFYJTU FYDFQUQFSIBQTJOTPNFWJSUVBMPSMPHJDBMTFOTFTh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hJTMBUUFSFYBNQMF JTBOBMPHPVTUPPUIFSUZQFTPGTZTUFNT TVDIBTJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTThFZNBZIBWFTPNFQBSUT XIPTFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTQSPQFSUJFT TFSWJDFT CFIBWJPSTBSFPQFOUPVTF BOEPUIFSQBSUTXIPTF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBSFFODBQTVMBUFEBOENVTUCFBDDFTTFEPOMZUISPVHIUIFTZTUFNCPVOEBSZ $POTJEFSBOPUIFSFYBNQMFUIF*OUFSOFUBOEUIFSFMBUFETUSVDUVSFPG3&45CBTFE8FCTFSWJDFT ThFTFBSFIVHFJOUFSDPOOFDUFEHSPVQTPGFOUJUJFTBOEMJOLTXJUIBEFFQOFTUFEPSDIBJOFETUSVDUVSF )JODIDMJﬀF DMBJNT UIBU UIFTF TUSVDUVSFT WJPMBUF FODBQTVMBUJPO BOE DBMM JOUP RVFTUJPO UIF FTUBCMJTIFEQSJODJQMFTPGFODBQTVMBUJPOBOEJOGPSNBUJPOIJEJOHThF.04&4JOUFSQSFUBUJPOPGUIFTF TUSVDUVSFTJTBTGPMMPXT*GXFBTTVNFBDPOUBJOFEDPNQPTJUJPONPEFM UIFOUIFTUSVDUVSFTMPPLBT JGUIFZCSFBLFODBQTVMBUJPOBOETIBSFUIFJSJOOFSTFDSFUTXJUIUIFXPSME#VUJGXFBTTVNFBTIBSFE DPNQPTJUJPONPEFM UIFOJUBQQFBSTUIBUNPEVMBSJUZBOEFODBQTVMBUJPOBSFTUJMMBMJWFBOEXFMM&BDI MJOLPS8FCTJUFJTFODBQTVMBUFECVUJUDBOCFTIBSFEJOUIFDPOUFYUPGNVMUJQMFMJOLDIBJOT

Composition-Related Processes Processes 1SJNBSZDPNQPTJUJPOSFMBUFEQSPDFTTFTJODMVEFDPNQPTF FODBQTVMBUF EFDPNQPTF DPNQPOFOUJ[F SFTUSVDUVSF BEE SFNPWF BOESFQMBDFThFTFJOWPMWFPUIFSTVCTJEJBSZQSPDFTTFTNBUDI ﬁU NVUBUF BOEJOUFHSBUFThFﬁSTUGPVSQSJNBSZQSPDFTTFTEFSJWFEJSFDUMZGSPNUIFSFMBUJPOTJEFOUJﬁFEJOUIF TFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi3FMBUJPOT#FUXFFO8IPMFTBOE1BSUTwThFMBUUFSGPVSQSJNBSZQSPDFTTFTBSFDPO DFSOFEXJUIQBSUT"EEJOH SFNPWJOH BOESFQMBDJOHBQBSUBSFJOUVJUJWFQSPDFTTFT3FTUSVDUVSJOH JOWPMWFTDIBOHJOHUIFJOUFSBDUJPOQBUUFSOPGXIBUQBSUTJOUFSBDUXJUIPUIFSQBSUT

158 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThFQSPDFTTFTUSBOTJUJPOBTFUPGQBSUTCFUXFFOUIFTFTUBUFTOPUDPNQPTFE QBSUJBMMZDPNQPTFE BOEDPNQPTFE /PUDPNQPTFE1BSUTFYJTU BSFJEFOUJﬁFE BSFBWBJMBCMFBOESFBEZGPSDPNQPTJUJPO CVUBSF OPUDPNQPTFETZTUFNEPFTOPUFYJTUBTBXIPMF $PNQPTFE1BSUTBSFJOBSFMBUJPOTZTUFNDBOPQFSBUFBTBXIPMF 1BSUJBMMZDPNQPTFE1BSUTBSFJOBSFMBUJPO CVUBUMFBTUPOFQBSUJTOPUJOUIFTZTUFN*OUIJT TUBUF BTZTUFNNBZCFBCMFUPPQFSBUFBTBXIPMFXJUIMJUUMFPSOPEFHSBEBUJPO PSXJUI TJHOJﬁ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hFQSPDFTTFTPG\QMVHPVUBOEQMVHJOPOFQBSU^BOE\QMVHPVUPME QMVHJOOFXBEBQUPS^CPUI DPSSFTQPOEUPUIFJNNVUBCMFUZQFPGDPNQPTJUJPONPEFM XIJMFNVUBUJOHPOFPSNPSFQBSUTDPS SFTQPOETUPUIFNVUBCMFUZQF 3FWFSTJCJMJUZ*OTPNFDBTFT DPNQPTJUJPOJTSFWFSTJCMFUIFQBSUTUIBUXFSFQVUUPHFUIFSDBOCF UBLFOBQBSUJOUPUIFJSPSJHJOBMTUBUF*OTPNFDBTFT EFDPNQPTJUJPOJTSFWFSTJCMFUIFXIPMFUIBUXBT EFDPNQPTFEJOUPQBSUTDBOCFDPNQPTFEBHBJOJOUPUIFXIPMF $PNQPTJUJPOQSPDFTTCPVOEBSZ"GUFSDPNQPTJUJPO CPUIXIPMFTBOEQBSUTDBOBEBQUBTBOPOHP JOH DIBOHF QSPDFTT ThJT JT OPU QBSU PG UIF DPNQPTJUJPO QSPDFTT #VU JO UIF NVUBCMF DPNQPTJ UJPONPEFM QBSUTDBOBMTPDIBOHFBOENVUBUFEVSJOHDPNQPTJUJPOUPﬁUJOUPBXIPMF4PXIFO EPFTDPNQPTJUJPONVUBUJPOTUPQBOEBEBQUBUJPOCFHJO "OEXIFSFEPFTUFNQPSBMFNFSHFODFﬁU ThJTNBZTFFNMJLFBUSJWJBMJTTVF CVUJUJTJNQPSUBOUJOBEBQUJWFBOETFMGPSHBOJ[JOHTZTUFNT*U JT BMTP OFFEFE UP EFﬁOF UIF CPVOEBSZ CFUXFFO TZTUFN DPNQPTJUJPO BOE TZTUFN DIBOHF XIJDI DPSSFTQPOETUPUIFCPVOEBSZCFUXFFOUIJTDIBQUFSBOE$IBQUFS0VSBOTXFSJTUIBUXIJMFXF BDLOPXMFEHFUIJTUPCFBGV[[ZCPVOEBSZ JUJTDPOWFOJFOUUPEFﬁOFJUBTPDDVSSJOHBUUIFﬁSTUQPJOU JOUJNFXIFOUIFTZTUFNJTBCMFUPPQFSBUFBTBXIPMF $PNQPTJUJPOBMTPJOWPMWFTNPSFTQFDJﬁDQSPDFTTFTPGNBUDIJOH ﬁUUJOH BOEJOUFHSBUJOHQBSUT UPHFUIFS "O FYBNQMF JT NBUDIJOH DPOUFYUEFQFOEFOU FYUFSOBM NPEFMT XJUI DPOUFYUHFOFSBMJ[FE FYUFSOBMNPEFMTThJTQSPDFTTEFQFOETIFBWJMZPOTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTPGDPNQPOFOUTBOEJTUIFSFGPSF EJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJO$IBQUFS "OPUIFS DPNQPTJUJPO WBSJBCMF JT UIF TFRVFODF JO XIJDI QBSUT BOE XIPMFT JO B DPNQPTJUJPO TUSVDUVSFBSFDSFBUFEXIPMF UIFOQBSUT UPQEPXO QBSUT UIFOXIPMFT CPUUPNVQ PSTJNVMUBOF PVT FH BOBUVSBMTZTUFNTVDIBTBEFWFMPQJOHIVNBO ThJTWBSJBCMFHFUTJOUPUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPS BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT XIJDIJTBEESFTTFEJO$IBQUFS

Agents "OBEEJUJPOBMFMFNFOUPGUIFDPNQPTJUJPOQSPDFTTJTUIFDPODFQUPGBHFOU"DPNQPTJUJPOBHFOUJT BOFOUJUZPSDPOEJUJPOUIBUJTJOTUSVNFOUBMJOCSJOHJOHBCPVUBDPNQPTJUJPO4PNFDPNQPTJUJPOT

Composition

O 159

POMZPDDVSUISPVHIUIFEJSFDUBDUJPOPGBOFYUFSOBMBHFOU0UIFSTPDDVSTQPOUBOFPVTMZPSUISPVHI UIFDIPJDFTPGBVUPOPNPVTDPNQPOFOUT

Examples of Direct Agent Composition *ODIFNJTUSZ DBUBMZTUTBOEJOJUJBUPSTBSFPGUFOVTFEBTBHFOUTJONBOZDPNQPTJUJPOT"OJOJUJBUPS IFMQTTUBSUBDPNQPTJUJPOBOEBDBUBMZTUJODSFBTFTJUTSBUF"UFNQFSBUVSFSBOHFNBZJOEVDFBDIFNJ DBMDPNQPTJUJPO"HFOUTJOFOHJOFFSJOHJODMVEFBSDIJUFDUT EFTJHOFST BOECVJMEFSTXIPEFTJHOBOE DPNQPTFBWBSJFUZPGTZTUFNT0UIFSBHFOUTJODMVEFGBDUPSZXPSLFSTXIPQSPEVDFQSPEVDUTSPCPUT UIBUQSPEVDFQSPEVDUTBOETPGUXBSFUIBUBTTJTUTJOQSPEVDJOH PSBVUPNBUJDBMMZQSPEVDFT BEFTJHO PSQSPEVDFTPUIFSTPGUXBSF.PTUPSBMMPGUIFTFBHFOUTDBOCFDIBSBDUFSJ[FEBTBMMPQPJFUJDTZTUFNT PSTZTUFNTPGPOFUZQFUIBUQSoduce a system of a diﬀerFOUUZQF

Examples of Non-Agent Compositions or Indirect or Virtual Agents $PNQPTJUJPOTPGNPTUOBUVSBMTZTUFNT GPSFYBNQMF GPSNBUJPOPGHBMBYJFT TPMBSTZTUFNT QMBOFUT NPVOUBJODIBJOT PDFBOT SJWFST IVSSJDBOFT PSHBOJTNT TPDJBMHSPVQT NPMFDVMFT PSCJPMPHJDBMDFMMT BSFPGUIJTUZQF4PNFPGUIFTFDPVMECFDIBSBDUFSJ[FEBTBVUPQPJFUJDTZTUFNT PSTZTUFNTUIBUNBJO UBJO PSHBOJ[F BOESFHFOFSBUFUIFNTFMWFT

Partial or Mixed Direct/Indirect Agents 4PNFDPNQPTJUJPOTBSFJOCFUXFFO XIFSFBOBHFOUIBTBQBSUJBMPSJOEJSFDUSPMF *OSFDFOUZFBST UIF*OUFSOFUIBTQSPWJEFEOFXPQQPSUVOJUJFTGPSJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNDPNQPTJ UJPO FTQFDJBMMZJOUIFDPOUFYUPGPQFOTPVSDFTPGUXBSF 40" 8FCTFSWJDFT BOE8FC"WBJMBCMF TPGUXBSFTFSWJDFTGSPNUIJSEQBSUJFTDBOCFDPNQPTFEWJBQVCMJDJOUFSGBDFTBOENBEFBWBJMBCMFPO 8FCTJUFTTh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hBUQBUUFSOJT JOEJDBUFECZUIF. NBDIJOF QBSUJO'JHVSF#VUUIF" BHFOU QBSUFYIJCJUTUIFTBNFQBUUFSO ThFIVNBOJTBQSFFYJTUJOHQBSU DPNJOHUPUIJTSPMFJOTZTUFN4XJUIBTFUPGDBQBCJMJUJFTBDRVJSFE UISPVHIHSPXUI FEVDBUJPO BOEFYQFSJFODF4PJOUIFTFOTFPGQVUUJOHQSFFYJTUJOHQBSUTJOUPB TZTUFN UIJTFYBNQMFJTOPUWFSZEJﬀFSFOUGSPNBGBNJMJBS4&QSPDFTT The signiﬁcant diﬀerFODFDPNFTJOUIFDPOUSJCVUJPOPGUIFBVUPOPNPVTTZTUFN"UPUIFGPS NBUJPO JOUFHSBUJPO BOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOPGUIFIZCSJETZTUFN4*OUIFuniﬁed 4&PGUIFGVUVSFUIBU BEESFTTFTCPUINBDIJOFTBOEBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUT XFIBWFBSHVFEUIBUUIFEPNJOBOUUZQFPGTZT UFNTXJMMCFIZCSJEThe DPNQPTJUJPOQSPDFTTPGIZCSJETZTUFNTJTBLFZQBSUPGUIFPWFSBMMDPMMFDUJWF BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT5BCMFTIPXFEUIFTZTUFNSPXXJUI4&BOE4"CPYFTBTQBSUPGDPMMFDUJWF BDUVBMJ[BUJPO.BQQJOHUIBUUP'JHVSF UIF4&QBSUPG5BCMFJTUIFSPMFUIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFS QMBZTJO'JHVSFJOQVUUJOHUPHFUIFSTZTUFN4 XIJDIJOWPMWFTCSJOHJOHJONBDIJOF.BOETPNF

160

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

S: Hybrid system M1

Figure 6.14

A1

M1

A1

Machine

Autonomous agent (e.g., human)

Mixed composition of hybrid systems.

QPSUJPOPGUIFJOUFHSBUJPOThe 4"QBSUPG5BCMFJTUIFSPMFUIFBHFOU"QMBZTJO'JHVSF JOQVUUJOHUPHFUIFSTZTUFN4 XIJDIJOWPMWFTBQPSUJPOPGUIFJOUFHSBUJPO POHPJOHDIBOHF BOE TFMGNBOBHFNFOU "TVNNBSZPGUIFUISFFUZQFTPGDPNQPTJUJPOJOUIJTTFDUJPOJOUIFDPOUFYUPG5BCMFBDUV BMJ[BUJPOJTBTGPMMPXT %JSFDUBHFOUBMM4& OP4" /POBHFOUOP4& BMM4" 1BSUJBMPSNJYFEBHFOUTPNF4& TPNF4"

References "MMFO 3BOE%(BSMBO"GPSNBMCBTJTGPSBSDIJUFDUVSBMDPOOFDUJPO"$.5SBOT4PGUXBSF&OHBOE .FUIPEPM o "UBZ ' BOE++PTU0OUIFFNFSHFODFPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNTPOUIFCBTJTPGUIFDPPSEJOBUJPOPGDPNQMFY CFIBWJPSTPGUIFJSFMFNFOUTTZODISPOJ[BUJPOBOEDPNQMFYJUZ$PNQMFYJUZ o4FQUFNCFS 1VCMJTIFE0OMJOF0DUPCFS%0*DQMY "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

"5*4 "5*4 5FMFDPN (MPTTBSZ 8BTIJOHUPO %$ "MMJBODF GPS 5FMFDPNNVOJDBUJPOT *OEVTUSZ 4PMVUJPOTIUUQXXXBUJTPSHHMPTTBSy/deﬁnition.aspx?id "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#BSBCÈTJ "-BOE3"MCFSU&NFSHFODFPGTDBMJOHJOSBOEPNOFUXPSLT4DJFODF o #JUUOFS 5BOE#4NJUI"UIFPSZPGHSBOVMBSQBSUJUJPOT*O'PVOEBUJPOTPG(FPHSBQIJD*OGPSNBUJPO4DJFODF . %VDLIBN .'(PPEDIJME BOE.'8PSCPZT &ET-POEPO5BZMPS'SBODJT#PPLT Qo #PDDBSB /.PEFMJOH$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT/FX:PSL4QSJOHFS7FSMBH %BWJT "4PGUXBSF3FRVJSFNFOUT"OBMZTJTBOE4peciﬁcation&OHMFwood Cliﬀs, NJ: PSFOUJDF)BMM %ZTPO '*nﬁnite in AMM%JSFDUJPOT/FX:PSL)BSQFSBOE3PX 1FSFOOJBM-JCSBSZFEJUJPO &NNFDIF $ 4,QQF BOE'4UKFSOGFMU&YQMBJOJOH&NFSHFODF5PXBSETBO0OUPMPHZPG-FWFMT +PVSOBM GPS (FOFSBM 1IJMPTPQIZ PG 4DJFODF IUUQXXXOCJEL_FNNFDIF DP1VCMF&,4FNFSHIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

'VUVZNB %&WPMVUJPO4VOEFSMBOE ."4JOBVFS"TTPDJBUFT

Composition

O 161

(SVNBO ( BOE & ,OPSS 8IBU DMPVE DPNQVUJOH SFBMMZ NFBOT *OGPXPSME "QSJM IUUQXXX JOGPXPSMEDPNBSUJDMF'&DMPVEDPNQVUJOHSFBMJUZ@IUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)BZFT #$MPVE$PNQVUJOH$PNNVO"$. o )inchcliﬀe, % Things :PV 4IPVME ,OPX BCPVU 3&45 BOE 80" http://hinchcliﬀe.org/ BSDIJWFBTQY "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)POEFSJDI5The OYGPSE$PNQBOJPOUP1IJMPTPQIZ/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT )PVTJOH.BQTIUUQXXXIPVTJOHNBQTDPN "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)ZCFSUTPO %5FTUJOH$PNNFSDJBMooﬀ-the-SIFMG$PNQPOFOUTBOE4ZTUFNT 4#FZEFEBBOE7(SVIO &ET/FX:PSL4QSJOHFS7FSMBHQo +JO )+BOE)$-FF8FC4FSWJDFT%FWFMPQNFOU.FUIPEPMPHZ6TJOHUIF.BTIVQ5FDIOPMPHZ*OU $POG4NBSU.BOVGBDUVSJOH"QQMJDBUJPO o"QSJMQo ,JSDIOFS (4FMG*OTUSVDUJPOBMPO#JPMPHJDBM.PMFDVMFT0SHBOJD$PNQPVOETIUUQIPNFQBHFTJVT FEV(,*3$)/&CJPNPMFDIUN "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

,MJS ("SDIJUFDUVSFPG4ZTUFNT1SPCMFN4PMWJOH/FX:PSL1MFOVN1SFTT ,MJS ('BDFUTPG4ZTUFNT4DJFODF OEFE/FX:PSL,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1MFOVN1VCMJTIFST .FZFS #0CKFDU0SJFOUFE4PGUXBSF$POTUSVDUJPO OEFE6QQFS4BEEMF3JWFS /+1SFOUJDF)BMM .JMMFS (The NBHJDBMOVNCFSTFWFO QMVTPSNJOVTUXPTPNFMJNJUTPOPVSDBQBDJUZGPSQSPDFTTJOH JOGPSNBUJPO1TZDIPMPH3FW o .JMMFS +-JWJOH4ZTUFNT-JXPU $06OJWFSTJUZ1SFTTPG$PMPSBEP 0SJHJOBMMZQVCMJTIFE

/FXNBO .JUDI "-#BSBCÈTJ BOE%+8BUUTThe 4USVDUVSFBOE%ZOBNJDTPG/FUXPSLT1SJODFUPO /+1SJODFUPO6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT 0$POOPS 5BOE)8POH&NFSHFOU1SPQFSUJFT4UBOGPSE&ODZDMPQFEJBPG1IJMPTPQIZIUUQQMBUP TUBOGPSEFEVFOUSJFTQSPQFSUJFTFNFSHFOU "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU .BOBHFNFOU (SPVQ 6niﬁed .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF 0.( 6.-

4VQFSTUSVDUVSF 7 0.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU 63- IUUQXXX PNHPSHTQFD6.-4VQFSTUSVDUVSF1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

1BLLFOCFSH # BOE ) (VOEFSTFO /FPDPSUJDBM OFVSPO OVNCFS JO IVNBOT eﬀect PG TFY BOE BHF +$PNQ/FVSPM o 1BLLFOCFSH # %1FMWJH -.BSOFS .+#VOEHBBSE )+((VOEFSTFO +3/ZFOHBBSE BOE-3FHFVS "HJOHBOEUIFIVNBOOFPDPSUFY&YQ(FSPOUPM o 4IBMJ[J $ &NFSHFOU 1SPQFSUJFT IUUQXXXDTDTVNJDIFEV_DSTIBMJ[JOPUFCPPLTFNFSHFOU QSPQFSUJFTIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

4IBX .BOE%(BSMBO4PGUXBSF"SDIJUFDUVSF1FSTQFDUJWFTPOBO&NFSHJOH%JTDJQMJOF6QQFS4BEEMF 3JWFS /+1SFOUJDF)BMM 4JNPOT 11BSUT"4UVEZJO0OUPMPHZ/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT 1BQFSCBDLFEJUJPO

8PPE + +%ZLFT "4MJOHTCZ BOE,$MBSLF*OUFSBDUJWFWJTVBMFYQMPSBUJPOPGBMBSHFTQBUJPUFNQP SBMEBUBTFUSeﬂections POBHFPWJTVBMJ[BUJPONBTIVQ*&&&5SBOT7JTVBMJ[BUJPO$PNQVUFS(SBQIJDT o ;PV +BOE$1BWMPWTLJ5PXBSETBDDPVOUBCMFFOUFSQSJTFNBTIVQTFSWJDFT*&&&*OU$POGF#VTJOFTT &OH o0DUPCFS Qo

Chapter 7

Commonization

Highest level system

Indivisible Unit

Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

Deﬁne need

Composition

Systems taxonomy Modeling scope $PNNPOJ[BUJPOJTUIFTUPSZPGTJNJMBSJUJFTBOE 1 SE Application Domains (D1...Dn) Collective actualization space EJﬀFSFODFT PG QBUUFSOT BNPOH NVMUJQMF TZT D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn Problem space Model Space diﬀerent in kind 2b All SE UFNT *O B DPMMFDUJPO PG TZTUFNT XIBU JT DPN 2aTraditionalTS/CS systems Complex systems application TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b domains... NPO UP BMM BOE XIBU WBSJFT "OE XIJDI PG UIF 3a Traditional Complex Complex 4 DPNNPOBMJUJFT BOE WBSJBCJMJUJFT EP XF XBOU UP Traditional TS is special case of all SE systems NPEFM #ZGPDVTJOHPONPEFMTPGDPMMFDUJPOTPG 5 Characteristics Traditional and Complex TZTUFNTSBUIFSUIBOJOEJWJEVBMTZTUFNT XFDBO 6 Characteristics of all systems Deployment Solution/system space DBQUVSF QBUUFSOT JO B HJWFO EPNBJO PS EJTDJ QMJOF BOE UIPTF QBUUFSOT SFQSFTFOU LOPXMFEHF $PNNPOJ[BUJPOJTUIFNPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOUIBUFOBCMFTLOPXMFEHFUPCFBDDVNVMBUFEJOUIF NPEFMTQBDF TIBSFE BOEVTFEJOUIFBQQMJDBUJPOPG4&ThFSFHJPOPGBNPEFMJTJNQPSUBOUJOUIJT EJNFOTJPO Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

e

m

Ti

Produce solution

Satisfy need

Basic Concepts: Similarities and Differences .VDIPGUIFEFQJDUJPOPGFOHJOFFSJOHNPEFMTJO$IBQUFSSFﬂFDUTIPXXFPGUFOUIJOLPGTVDI NPEFMTBTNPEFMTPGPOFTQFDJﬁ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he TBNFTJUVBUJPOFYJTUTJOPUIFSFOHJOFFSJOH EJTDJQMJOFT(FOFSBMQBUUFSOTPSNPEFMTIBWFUSBEJUJPOBMMZCFFOdeﬁned JOFOHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLT They FNQIBTJ[FXIBUJTDPNNPOGPSBMMTZTUFNTJOUIFEPNBJO&BDITZTUFNUIBUJTFOHJOFFSFEJTB SFBMJ[BUJPOPGNPEFMTUIBUBSFTQFDJBMJ[FEGSPNUIFHFOFSBMNPEFMT &WFOJOUIFOBTDFOUEPNBJOPGCJPOBOPTZTUFNT UIFSFBSFFﬀPSUTUPEFﬁOFTUBOEBSEQBSUTUPCF VTFEBTCVJMEJOHCMPDLT DBMMFE#JP#SJDLT BTNFOUJPOFEJO$IBQUFS 163

164

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

3FDBMMUIF$IBQUFSEJTDVTTJPOPGDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU XIJDIJTUIFKPJOTUSVDUVSFGPSTFQBSBUF MPPTFMZDPVQMFENPEFMTBOETZTUFNTThFDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUQBUUFSOJOUIJTDIBQUFSJTUIBU.JTBO JOEJWJEVBMNPEFMXIJMF4JTBTFUPGTZTUFNTUIBUDPSSFTQPOEUPUIBUNPEFM.PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ UIJT DIBQUFSBEESFTTFTUIFJOUFSTFDUJPOPGUXPJEFBT UIFBCTUSBDUJPOBTQFDUPGNPEFMTBOE UIF TJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTUIBUFYJTUBNPOHBTFUPGTZTUFNT .PEFMBCTUSBDUJPO"NPEFMPGBTZTUFNGPDVTFTPODFSUBJODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOEJHOPSFTUIFPUIFS DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PG UIF TZTUFN ThVT BOZ HJWFO NPEFM QBSUJUJPOT TZTUFN DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT JOUP UXP DBUFHPSJFTUIPTFUIBUNBUUFSBOEUIPTFUIBUEPOPUNBUUFS"TTPPOBTXFBCTUSBDUJOUIJTXBZ JUJOUSPEVDFTUIFQPTTJCJMJUZUIBUUIFNPEFMBQQMJFTUPNPSFUIBOPOFTZTUFNThBUJT UIFNPEFM NJHIUDBQUVSFXIBUJTDPNNPOUPBTFUPGTZTUFNT"OECFDBVTFBCTUSBDUJPOJTJOIFSFOUJOFWFSZ NPEFM HSPVQTPGDPSSFTQPOEJOHTZTUFNTBSFBOJOIFSFOUQPUFOUJBMPGFWFSZNPEFM 4JNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFT*OHFOFSBM UIFNFNCFSTPGBHJWFOTFUPGTZTUFNTBSFTJNJMBSJOTPNF XBZTBOEEJﬀFSJOPUIFSXBZT'VSUIFSNPSF JGUIFTFUJTEFﬁOFECZBNPEFM UIFOiTPNFXBZTwJO XIJDIUIFTZTUFNTBSFTJNJMBSBSFEFﬁOFECZUIFNPEFMThBUJT JGBNPEFMEFﬁOFTDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT " # BOE$ UIFOUIFTZTUFNTBMMFYIJCJUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT" # BOE$"IPNPHFOFPVTTFUIBTNPSF TJNJMBSJUJFTPSNPSFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTJODPNNPO BOEBIFUFSPHFOFPVTTFUIBTNPSFEJﬀFSFODFTPS NPSFWBSJBUJPOThJTGVOEBNFOUBMBOEVOJWFSTBMEJTUJODUJPOJTUIFCBTJTPGUIFBCJMJUZUPTPSUPVU BOEDBUFHPSJ[FUIFiGVSOJUVSFwPSUIFNPTBJDPGUIFXPSME BOEUIFSFGPSFUIFCBTJTPGNVDIPGPVS LOPXMFEHFPGUIFXPSME *OUFSTFDUJPO*GXFPWFSMBZUIFNPEFMBCTUSBDUJPOEJTUJODUJPOPOUIFTJNJMBSJUZEJﬀFSFODFEJT UJODUJPO XFPCUBJOGPVSDBUFHPSJFT BTTIPXOJO'JHVSF TJNJMBSJUJFTUIBUNBUUFS EJﬀFSFODFT UIBUNBUUFS TJNJMBSJUJFTUIBUEPOPUNBUUFS BOEEJﬀFSFODFTUIBUEPOPUNBUUFS*EFBMMZ BNPEFM BEESFTTFTPSTQFDJﬁFTFWFSZUIJOHUIBUNBUUFSTBOEJHOPSFTPSMFBWFTPQFOFWFSZUIJOHUIBUEPFTOPU NBUUFS GPSBHJWFOQVSQPTF *UJTJNQPSUBOUUPOPUFUIBUUIFDPMVNOEJTUJODUJPOJO'JHVSFCFUXFFOTJNJMBSJUJFTBOE diﬀerFODFT EFQFOET PO UIF TZTUFNT JOWPMWFE OPU PO UIF NPEFM JOWPMWFE "OE UIBU UIF SPX EJTUJODUJPOTCFUXFFOXIBUEPFTBOEEPFTOPUNBUUFSEFQFOETPOUIFQVSQPTFPGUIFNPEFM JOWPMWFE 0OFNJHIUUIJOLUIBUBNPEFMPOMZEFﬁOFTTJNJMBSJUJFTBNPOHDPSSFTQPOEJOHTZTUFNT OPUEJG GFSFODFT%PFTBNPEFMOPUEFTDSJCFBTFUPGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUIPMEGPSBMMPGUIFDPSSFTQPOEJOH

Figure 7.1

Modeling similarities and differences.

Commonization

O

165

TZTUFNT #VUBNPEFMJODMVEFTWBSJBCMFTBTXFMMBTDPOTUBOUTThFWBSJBCMFTEFﬁOFEJﬀFSFODFTPSWBSJ BCJMJUZUIBUNBUUFSTBOEJTXJUIJOUIFQVSWJFXPGUIFNPEFM"OFYBNQMFPGUIFBSFBTJO'JHVSF JTBNPEFMPGMJOFBSNPNFOUVNPGQIZTJDBMPCKFDUT8FVTFUIFDMBTTJDBMNPEFM.PNFOUVN .BTT¨7FMPDJUZ$POTJEFSUXPTZTUFNTBSFEBQQMFDNJOEJBNFUFSXJUIBNBTTPGHSBNT BOEBWFMPDJUZPGGUTFD BOEBSFECBMMDNJOEJBNFUFSXJUIBNBTTPGHSBNTBOEBWFMPDJUZ PGGUTFD O " #PUI BSF QIZTJDBM PCKFDUT BOE UIFSFGPSF IBWF QSPQFSUJFT PG NBTT BOE WFMPDJUZ ThPTF TJNJMBSJUJFTDMFBSMZNBUUFSUPNPNFOUVN O # ThF UXP IBWF EJﬀFSFOU WBMVFT PG NBTT WFSTVT HSBNT BOE WFMPDJUZ GUTFD WFSTVTGUTFD . ThPTFEJﬀFSFODFTBﬀFDUUIFNPNFOUVN O $#PUIIBWFSFEDPMPS. ThJTTJNJMBSJUZJTJNNBUFSJBMUPNPNFOUVN O %ThFZIBWFEJﬀFSFOUEJBNFUFST DNWFSTVTDN

BOEPOFJTOBUVSBMXIJMFUIFPUIFS JTBSUJﬁDJBM. ThFTFEJﬀFSFODFTBSFJNNBUFSJBMUPNPNFOUVN "BOE#BSFJODMVEFEJOUIFNPEFM*OUIJTDBTF CPUI"BOE#BSFSFQSFTFOUFEJOUIFWBSJBCMFT NBTTBOEWFMPDJUZThFTJNJMBSJUZ " JTQBSUJBMMZJNQMJDJUPOMZTZTUFNTUIBUIBWFQSPQFSUJFTPGNBTT BOEWFMPDJUZBSFJOUIFSFHJPOPGUIJTNPNFOUVNNPEFMThFEJﬀFSFODF # JTNPSFFYQMJDJUUIF SBOHFPGWBMVFTGPSNBTTBOEWFMPDJUZJTSFQSFTFOUFEJOUIPTFUXPWBSJBCMFT $BOE%BSFFYDMVEFEGSPNUIFNPEFMThFGBDUUIBUDPMPS $ BOEEJBNFUFS % EPOPUNBUUFS UPUIFNPNFOUVNNPEFMJTJNQMJDJUJOUIFJSBCTFODFGSPNUIFNPEFM*OHFOFSBM UIFFYDMVTJPOPG $BOE%GSPNBNPEFMDBOCFFYQMJDJUPSJNQMJDJUJOUIFNPEFM*NQMJDJU BTJOUIFFYBNQMFBCPWF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUEPOPUNBUUFSEPOPUBQQFBSJOUIFNPEFM BOEUIFJNQMJDBUJPOJTUIBUUIPTF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTIBWFOPFﬀFDUPOUIFNPEFM&YQMJDJUThFNPEFMTUBUFTUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDCVUPOMZ GPSUIFQVSQPTFPGNBLJOHFYQMJDJUUIBUUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDJTVODPOTUSBJOFEJOUIFNPEFM UIBUJT OPUPGJOUFSFTUJOUIFNPEFM4PNFUJNFTJUIFMQTUPCFFYQMJDJUUPDPVOUFSBTTVNQUJPOT.BOZPG UIFFYBNQMFTPGEFDPVQMJOHJO$IBQUFSXFSFPGUIJTTPSUThFEFDPVQMJOHBMMPXTVTUPFYQMJDJUMZ TFQBSBUFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUNBUUFS BTJO"BOE#JO'JHVSF GSPNUIPTFUIBUEPOPU BTJO$ BOE% 'PSFYBNQMF CZEFDPVQMJOHDPOUSPMGSPNIJFSBSDIZ XFDBOEFﬁOFBNPEFMUIBUTFQBSBUFT UIFPOFUPNBOZSFMBUJPO XIJDINBUUFSTUPIJFSBSDIZ GSPNBDPOUSPMSFMBUJPO XIJDIJTFYQMJDJUMZ VODPOTUSBJOFEJOUIFHFOFSBMIJFSBSDIZNPEFM &YQSFTTJOHTJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTJODPNNPONPEFMTJTUIFQSJNBSZNFDIBOJTNIVNBOT VTFUPDBQUVSFBOETIBSFLOPXMFEHF$PNNPONPEFMTJODMVEFTDJFOUJﬁDUIFPSJFT DPNQMFYTZTUFNT NPEFMT BOE USBEJUJPOBM FOHJOFFSJOH BSUJGBDUT TVDI BT DPOWFOUJPOBM EFTJHOT JO B HJWFO EPNBJO $PNNPONPEFMTBSFVTFEFYUFOTJWFMZJOBMMBSFBTPGFOHJOFFSJOH*OPMEFSUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFS JOHEJTDJQMJOFT DPNNPONPEFMTPGUFOUBLFUIFGPSNPGDPOWFOUJPOBMEFTJHOTPSDPNNPOTZTUFN QSPQFSUJFTFYQSFTTFEJOFOHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLT4PGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHNBLFTFYUFOTJWFVTFPGDPN NPONPEFMTp4ZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHNBLFTVTFPGNBOZPGUIFTFTBNFUZQFTPGDPNNPONPEFMT JODMVEJOHMBSHFTDBMFBSDIJUFDUVSFT CVUUIFSFIBTCFFOMFTTDPNNVOJUZDPEJﬁDBUJPOPG4&DPNNPO NPEFMT

'PSQVSQPTFTPGUIJTEJTDVTTJPO XFBEESFTTUIFTQFFEBTQFDUPGWFMPDJUZCVUJHOPSFUIFEJSFDUJPOBTQFDU p &YBNQMFTJODMVEFEBUBUZQFT DMBTTFTJODMBTTIJFSBSDIJFT DPNQPOFOUBOEDPOOFDUPSUZQFT NFUBNPEFMT HFOFSJDT

UFNQMBUFT SFGFSFODFNPEFMT BSDIJUFDUVSFTUZMFT EPNBJOBOEQSPEVDUMJOFBSDIJUFDUVSFT BOEEFTJHOQBUUFSOT

166

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

4DIJOEFM B C IBTEFTDSJCFEBO4&NFUIPEJOUFSNTPGNPEFMCBTFE4& .#4& BOE QBUUFSOTCBTFE4& 1#4& .#4&SFDPHOJ[FTUIFJNQPSUBODFPGEFTDSJCJOH4&BSUJGBDUT TVDIBT SFRVJSFNFOUTBOEEFTJHO BTTQFDJﬁDNPEFMT1#4&FYUFOETUIJTCZEFﬁOJOHQBUUFSOT XIJDIJO .04&4BSFHFOFSBMNPEFMT ,MJS o IBTJEFOUJﬁFEBOVNCFSPGBSFBTJOXIJDITZTUFNTTDJFODF BOEUIFTUVEZ PGDPNQMFYTZTUFNT IBTFYUFOEFEPVSDBQBCJMJUJFTGPSNPEFMJOHUISPVHIHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOTPGNBUI FNBUJDBMUIFPSJFT. ThFTFHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOTJODMVEF O O O O O O O

'SPNRVBOUJUBUJWFUPRVBMJUBUJWFUIFPSJFT 'SPNGVODUJPOTUPSFMBUJPOT 'SPNPSEJOBSZHFPNFUSZUPGSBDUBMHFPNFUSZ 'SPNMJOFBSUPOPOMJOFBSUIFPSJFT 'SPNDMBTTJDBMTFUUIFPSZBOEMPHJDUPGV[[ZTFUUIFPSZBOEMPHJD 'SPNJOUPMFSBODFPGJODPOTJTUFODJFTUPUIFMPHJDPGJODPOTJTUFODZ 'SPNTJOHMFPCKFDUJWFUPNVMUJQMFPCKFDUJWFDSJUFSJBPQUJNJ[BUJPO

#PUIUIFPSJHJOBMBOEFYUFOEFEFMFNFOUPGFBDIQBJSJOUIJTMJTUﬁUDPNGPSUBCMZJOUIFDPNNPOJ[B UJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIF.04&4NPEFMTQBDFThFFYUFOEFEFMFNFOUTBSFQBSUPGUIFDPNQMFYTZTUFN FYQBOTJPOPG4&

Category and Kind Structures 5XPWBSJFUJFTPGDPNNPOJ[BUJPOFYJTU8IJMFUIFZIBWFNVMUJQMFOBNFTJOUIFMJUFSBUVSF UIFZBSF PGUFODBMMFEDBUFHPSJFTBOELJOET5PVOEFSTUBOEUIFEJTUJODUJPO XFVTFUIFDPODFQUPGNFNCFSTPG BTFU"DBUFHPSZJTBTFUXIPTFNFNCFSTBSFWJFXFEBTJOEJWJEVBMT FBDIPGXIJDIJTBOJOTUBODFPG UIFDBUFHPSZ"LJOEJTBTFUXIPTFNFNCFSTBSFWJFXFEBTTFUT FBDIPGXIJDIJTBTVCLJOEPGUIF LJOE8IZEPXFVTFUIFQISBTFTiBSFWJFXFEBTJOEJWJEVBMTwBOEiBSFWJFXFEBTTFUTwJOTUFBEPG iBSFJOEJWJEVBMTwBOEiBSFTFUT wSFTQFDUJWFMZ #FDBVTF BTXFXJMMTFFTIPSUMZ DBUFHPSZ JOEJWJEVBM LJOE BOETVCLJOEBSFBMMSPMFTUIBUBTJOHMFFOUJUZDBOBTTVNFJOBHJWFODPOUFYUUIFZBSFOPU JOIFSFOUQSPQFSUJFTPGBOFOUJUZ $BUFHPSZBOELJOEIBWFUIFDPSSFTQPOEJOHSFMBUJPOTJOTUBODFPGBOELJOEPGThFTFSFMBUJPOT GPSNUXPTFQBSBUFIJFSBSDIJFTUIBUNBZCFDBMMFEDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOBOEHFOFSBMJ[BUJPO*OTPGUXBSF PCKFDUPSJFOUFEQBSMBODF iLJOEPGwJTBDMBTTIJFSBSDIZSFMBUJPO JF UIFSFMBUJPOPGBTVCDMBTTXJUI JUTQBSFOUDMBTT

BOEiJOTUBODFPGwJTUIFSFMBUJPOPGBOJOEJWJEVBMPCKFDUXJUIUIFDMBTTGSPNXIJDI JUXBTJOTUBOUJBUFE 5FSNTVTFEGPSUIFFMFNFOUTJOBLJOEPGSFMBUJPOJODMVEF O O O O O

,JOEoTVCLJOE 4VQFSLJOEoLJOE $MBTToTVCDMBTT 5ZQFoTVCUZQF 1BSFOUoDIJME

ThJTJTBNPEFMJOHSFMBUJPO OPUBCJPMPHJDBMPOF0GUFOVTFEJODPOKVODUJPOXJUIDMBTT#JPMPHJDBMMZ BDIJMEJT OPUBLJOEPGQBSFOU#VUJONPEFMJOHUFSNT BDIJMEDMBTTJTBLJOEPGBQBSFOUDMBTT

Commonization

O

167

O (FOFSBMNPEFMoTQFDJﬁDNPEFM O (FOFSBMJ[BUJPOoTQFDJBMJ[BUJPO 5FSNTVTFEGPSUIFFMFNFOUTJOBOJOTUBODFPGSFMBUJPOJODMVEF O O O O O

$BUFHPSZoJOTUBODF $MBTToPCKFDU 6OJWFSTBMoQBSUJDVMBS .PEFMoJOEJWJEVBM .FUBNPEFMoNPEFM

Th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hJTEJTUJODUJPOJTEJTDVTTFEJO#PSHJEBBOE#SBDINBO

XIFSFUIFZVTFUIFUFSNT iJOEJWJEVBMwBOEiDPODFQUwGPSXIBUXFIFSFDBMMiJOTUBODFwBOEiDBUFHPSZwThFSPMFPGBOFOUJUZ

Categorization Hierarchy Biological category Instance-of

Kingdom

Species

Class

Plant Animal {…Lassie, …} {all animals}

Bird Mammal Fish

Homo sapiens Dog Horse

{…Lassie, …} {all mammals}

{…Lassie, …} {all dogs}

Generalization Hierarchy Living thing Kind-of Animal Fungus

Plant Bird

Mammal

Homo sapiens

Kingdom Class Species Breed

Figure 7.2

Horse

Combined Hierarchies

Kind-of

Instance-of

Dog

Fish

Animal

Lassie

Mammal

Lassie

Dog

Lassie

Collie

Lassie

Roles of Dog: Category of Lassie Instance of Species Generalization of Collie Specialization of Mammal

Intersection of kinds and instances using biological taxonomy.

168

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science Table 7.1 Dog Roles and Relations in Two Domains Dog Role/Relation 1 Category 2 Instance 3 Generalization 4 Specialization 5 Instance 6 Instance 7 Instance 8 Instance

In Context of Lassie of Species of Collie of Mammal of Category of Instance of Generalization of Specialization

Domain Biological taxonomy Biological taxonomy Biological taxonomy Biological taxonomy Modeling domain Modeling domain Modeling domain Modeling domain

JOUFSNTPGDBUFHPSZPSJOTUBODF NBZWBSZCZUIFPQFSBUJPOQFSGPSNFEPOJU'PSFYBNQMF DPOTJEFS BCPPL TBZ%JDLFOT(SFBU&YQFDUBUJPOT*OUIFPQFSBUJPOPGXSJUJOHUIFCPPL (SFBU&YQFDUBUJPOT JTBOJOTUBODFPGUIFDBUFHPSZCPPL*OUIFPQFSBUJPOPGCVZJOHPSSFBEJOHJU (SFBU&YQFDUBUJPOTJT BDBUFHPSZBOENZDPQZJTBOJOTUBODFPGJU ,JOEPG JT B USBOTJUJWF SFMBUJPO *O UIF 'JHVSF HFOFSBMJ[BUJPO IJFSBSDIZ CFDBVTF EPH JT B LJOEPGNBNNBMBOENBNNBMJTBLJOEPGBOJNBM UIFOEPHJTBLJOEPGBOJNBM*OTUBODFPGJT OPUBUSBOTJUJWFSFMBUJPO*OUIFDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOIJFSBSDIZ -BTTJFJTBOJOTUBODFPGEPH BOEEPHJTBO JOTUBODFPGTQFDJFT CVUJUJTOPUUSVFUIBU-BTTJFJTBOJOTUBODFPGTQFDJFT ThFGPVSSPMFTPG%PHTIPXOJO'JHVSFBSFEFﬁOFEJOUIFDPOUFYUPGUIFCJPMPHJDBMUBY POPNZ#VU%PHBMTPIBTUIFSPMFPGJOTUBODFJOGPVSPUIFSSFMBUJPOTJOUIFNPEFMJOHEPNBJO #FDBVTF%PHJT JO'JHVSF BDBUFHPSZ BOJOTUBODF BTQFDJBMJ[BUJPO BOEBHFOFSBMJ[BUJPO JOB NPEFMJOHTFOTF%PHJTBOJOTUBODFPGBMMUIPTFNPEFMJOHDBUFHPSJFT"MMFJHIUSPMFTSFMBUJPOTBSF TIPXOJO5BCMF ThFTFDPOEHSPVQ o SFQSFTFOUTBDPNNPOJ[BUJPONPEFMJOHEPNBJOPGEJTDPVSTFThFﬁSTU HSPVQ o SFQSFTFOUTBDPOUFOUEPNBJO JOUIJTDBTFCJPMPHJDBMUBYPOPNZ UIBUJTSFQSFTFOUFEJO UIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPONPEFMJOHEPNBJO #BTFEPOUIJTEJTDVTTJPO XFDBOTBZUIBUBDBUFHPSZJTBNPEFMSPMFXIPTFUBSHFUTBSFJOTUBODF SPMFT"LJOEJTBNPEFMSPMFXIPTFUBSHFUTBSFLJOESPMFTPGHFOFSBMJ[BUJPO QBSFOU PSTQFDJBMJ[B UJPO DIJME 'JHVSFTIPXTBTJNJMBSBQQSPBDIUPDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOCZ"ULJOTPOBOE,àIOF "ULJOTPOBOE ,àIOF "ULJOTPO BOE ,àIOF BOE ,àIOF ThFZ VTF EJﬀFSFOU UFSNT JOTUFBE PG iCJPMPHJDBMEPNBJOw BOE iNPEFMJOH EPNBJO w UIFZ VTF UIF UFSNT iPOUPMPHJDBM JOTUBODFw BOE iMJOHVJTUJDJOTUBODFw O -BTTJFJTBOPOUPMPHJDBMJOTUBODFPG$PMMJF$PMMJFJTBOPOUPMPHJDBMJOTUBODFPG#SFFE O -BTTJFJTBMJOHVJTUJDJOTUBODFPG0CKFDU$PMMJFJTBMJOHVJTUJDJOTUBODFPG$MBTTCSFFEJTB MJOHVJTUJDJOTUBODFPG.FUBDMBTT 0VSUSFBUNFOUJTTJNJMBS CVUEJﬀFSTGSPNUIFJSTJOTFWFSBMXBZT O ThFZVTFBQSFEFﬁOFETFUPGBCTPMVUFNPEFMJOHDBUFHPSJFTCBTFEPO6.-PCKFDU DMBTT NFUBDMBTTXFVTFUXPJOUFSUXJOJOHSFMBUJWFNPEFMJOHDBUFHPSJFTJOTUBODFBOEDBUFHPSZ ThJTNBLFTJUNVDINPSFTDBMBCMF BOEJUTIPXTUIFSFQFBUJOHQBUUFSO

Commonization L0

O

169

L1

02 Represents

Breed

Linguistic instance-of

Metaclass Ontological instance-of

Ontological instance-of 01 Represents

Collie

Linguistic instance-of

Class Ontological instance-of

Ontological instance-of 00 Represents

Lassie

Linguistic instance-of

Object

Figure 7.3 Ontological metamodeling view. (Source: Atkinson, C. and T. Kühne. Model-driven development: a metamodeling foundation. IEEE Software, 20(5):36–41. Published by IEEE Computer Society, 2003. Used with permission.)

O ThFJSVTFPGBCTPMVUFDBUFHPSJFTPCTDVSFTUIFDPODFQUPGDPOUFYUEFQFOEFOUSPMF O 0VSDPOUFYUEFQFOEFOUSPMFBMTPBQQMJFTUPHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOJOBEEJUJPOUPDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOUIFZ TIPXUIFUXPEJNFOTJPOBMHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOWFSTVTDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOPGUIFCJPMPHJDBMUBYPOPNZ CVUUIFZEPOPUTIPXUIFSPMFT UIFGBDUUIBUFBDIFMFNFOUQMBZTNVMUJQMFNPEFMJOHSPMFT 'JHVSFTIPXTTPNFSFMBUJPOTCFUXFFODBUFHPSJ[BUJPOBOEHFOFSBMJ[BUJPO BOECFUXFFODPS SFTQPOEFODFBOEDBUFHPSJ[BUJPO"TTVNF"BOE#BSFTZTUFNT BOE.BOE.BSFNPEFMT XIFSF .JTBTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOPG.ThFDJSDMFTJOEJDBUFUIFSFHJPOTPG.BOE.UIBUJT BMMUIFTZT UFNTUIBUDPSSFTQPOESFTQFDUJWFMZUP.BOE."DPSSFTQPOETUP.CVUOPUUP. XIJMF# DPSSFTQPOETCPUIUP.BOE.'JHVSFTIPXTGPVSFYBNQMFTPGNPEFMT PSNPEFMOBNFT GPS CPUI.BOE.ThFFYBNQMFTBSFGSPNEPNBJOTBTTPDJBUFEXJUI4&BFSPOBVUJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH JOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH CJPMPHZ BOENBUIFNBUJDT&BDIJMMVTUSBUFTUIJTSFMBUJPO CFUXFFODPSSFTQPOEFODFBOEDBUFHPSJ[BUJPO"TZTUFNUIBUDPSSFTQPOETUPBNPEFM BOEUIFSFGPSF JTJOUIFNPEFMSFHJPO JTBOJOTUBODFPGUIFDBUFHPSZEFﬁOFECZUIBUNPEFM O *OUIFSFMBUJPOPG"UP.BOE. "JTBOJOTUBODFPGUIFDBUFHPSZEFﬁOFECZ.CVU JTOPUBOJOTUBODFPGUIFDBUFHPSZEFﬁOFECZ.'PSFYBNQMF "JTBTQFDJﬁDJOEJWJEVBM BJSDSBGUPGUZQF"JSCVT PSJTBTQFDJﬁDEBUBCBTFNBOBHFNFOUTZTUFNPGUZQFPCKFDU PSJFOUFE %#.4 PS JT B TQFDJﬁD NBNNBM PG TQFDJFT EPH TVDI BT -BTTJF PS JT B TQFDJﬁD TFDPOEPSEFSEJﬀFSFOUJBMFRVBUJPOTVDIBTY¦EZEY¦EZEY &BDIFYBNQMFHJWFOJT DMFBSMZJOUIF.SFHJPOCVUPVUTJEFUIF.SFHJPO

170 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science ) 12+ , % ! !)+ , ! )

.

)

.

,

Figure 7.4

#! ( ! ( ! !% ! ( (!&!"! $%%$'%$ ) / #! (,*** (0! ! !% ! (." (- !&!"! $(%$

Variation allowed in models.

O *OUIFSFMBUJPOPG#UP.BOE. #JTBOJOTUBODFPGUIFDBUFHPSZEFﬁOFECZ. BOEJT BOJOTUBODFPGUIFDBUFHPSZEFﬁOFECZ.'PSFYBNQMF #JTBTQFDJﬁDJOEJWJEVBMBJSDSBGU PGUZQF#PFJOH PSJTBTQFDJﬁDEBUBCBTFNBOBHFNFOUTZTUFNPGUZQFSFMBUJPOBM%#.4 PSJTBTQFDJﬁDNBNNBMPGTQFDJFTIVNBO PSJTBTQFDJﬁDﬁSTUPSEFSEJﬀFSFOUJBMFRVBUJPO TVDIBTY¦EZEY *OTVN BNPSFHFOFSBMNPEFMTVDIBT.EFﬁOFTBDBUFHPSZUIBUIBTNPSFJOTUBODFT BOEB SFHJPOUIBUIBTNPSFQPUFOUJBMDPSSFTQPOEJOHTZTUFNT UIBOEPFTBNPSFTQFDJﬁDNPEFMTVDIBT .'VSUIFSNPSF JGUIFNPSFTQFDJﬁDNPEFMJTBTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOPGUIFNPSFHFOFSBMNPEFM BT. JTBTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOPG. UIFOBMMTZTUFNTJOUIFSFHJPOPGUIFNPSFTQFDJﬁDNPEFMBSFBMTPJOUIF SFHJPOPGUIFNPSFHFOFSBMNPEFM 8FOPXDPOTJEFSUIFPWFSMBQPGTFMFDUFEDBUFHPSJFTPGOPOMJOFBSEZOBNJDBMTZTUFNT speciﬁcally DIBPUJDTZTUFNT MPHJTUJDNBQT BOEUIF-PSFO[BUUSBDUPS"MMUIFTFDBUFHPSJFTBSFCPUIOPOMJOFBSBOE EFUFSNJOJTUJD ThFSFJTBHFOFSBMNPEFMPGDIBPUJDTZTUFNT"MMDIBPUJDTZTUFNTBSFJOUIFSFHJPOPGUIJTNPEFM ThFNPEFMDBOCFFYQSFTTFEJOBOVNCFSPGXBZTThFFYQSFTTJPOXFVTFIFSFGPMMPXT #PDDBSB *UJTCBTFEPOUIFCFIBWJPSUSBKFDUPSZPGBTZTUFN FYQSFTTFEBTBTFU4 PGCFIBWJPST NBQQFEPOUPJUTFMG *G4JTBTFU UIFNBQQJOHG4l4JTDIBPUJDPO4JG 6OQSFEJDUBCMFGIBTTFOTJUJWFEFQFOEFODFPOJOJUJBMDPOEJUJPOT /POEFDPNQPTBCMFGJTUPQPMPHJDBMMZUSBOTJUJWF DBOOPUCFCSPLFOJOUPTFQBSBUFETVCTFUT 3FHVMBSGIBTQFSJPEJDQPJOUTUIBUBSFEFOTFJO4 ThFSFJTBHFOFSBMEZOBNJDBMTZTUFNNPEFMDBMMFEUIFMPHJTUJDNBQ .BSUFMMJ .BZ

PSJHJOBMMZEFTJHOFEGPSNPEFMJOHQPQVMBUJPOUSFOET*UTQFDJﬁFTUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGBDMBTT PGTZTUFNT JO.04&4UFSNTBSFHJPOPGTZTUFNT UIBUDPSSFTQPOEUPUIJTNPEFM.BUIFNBUJDBMMZ UIFMPHJTUJDNBQ BOPOMJOFBSEJﬀFSFODFFRVBUJPO JTXSJUUFOBT

YOBYO ¦YO

Commonization

O

171

XIFSF GPSQPQVMBUJPONPEFMJOH O YOJTBOVNCFSCFUXFFO[FSPBOEPOF BOESFQSFTFOUTUIFSBUJPPGFYJTUJOHQPQVMBUJPOUP TVTUBJOBCMFQPQVMBUJPOBUZFBSO BOEIFODFY SFQSFTFOUTUIFJOJUJBMQPQVMBUJPOSBUJP BU ZFBS BOEYO JTUIFQPQVMBUJPOSBUJPBUZFBSO O BJTBQPTJUJWFOVNCFS BOESFQSFTFOUTBOFUHSPXUISBUF "TVCTFUPGUIFTFTZTUFNT GPSDFSUBJOWBMVFTBOESBOHFTPGUIFQBSBNFUFSB BSFDIBPUJD "HFOFSBMNPEFMDBMMFEUIF-PSFO[FRVBUJPOTTQFDJﬁFTBSFHJPOPGTZTUFNTXJUIBWBSJFUZPG DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT JODMVEJOHCPUIDIBPUJDBOEOPODIBPUJD. ThFFRVBUJPOTBSF #PDDBSB

EYEUS Z¦Y

EZEUY R¦[ ¦Z

E[EUYZ¦B[

XIFSF UIF QBSBNFUFST PG UIJT TFU PG FRVBUJPOT S B BOE R BSF BMM HSFBUFS UIBO [FSP ThF QBSBNFUFSTDBOCFJOUFSQSFUFEBTTJNQMJﬁDBUJPOTPGBNPEFMPGUIFQIZTJDBMTZTUFNJOXIJDIBCPYJT ﬁMMFEXJUIBHBTSJTUIFSBUJPPGUIFﬂVJEWJTDPTJUZPGUIFHBTUPJUTUIFSNBMDPOEVDUJWJUZRSFQSF TFOUTUIFEJﬀFSFODFJOUFNQFSBUVSFCFUXFFOUIFUPQBOECPUUPNPGUIFHBTJOUIFCPY BOEBJTUIFXJEUI UPIFJHIUSBUJPPGUIFCPY"UMFBTUPOFPGUIFTFTZTUFNT JOXIJDIS B BOER JTDIBPUJD ThJTJTUIFGBNPVT-PSFO[iCVUUFSﬂZwTUSBOHFBUUSBDUPS TFF'JHVSFCFMPXGSPN8JLJQFEJB ThFMPHJTUJDNBQBOE-PSFO[FRVBUJPOTSFHJPOTBSFEJTKPJOUCVUCPUISFHJPOTIBWFBOJOUFSTFDUJPO

Figure 7.5

Plotted trajectory of Lorenz strange attractor. (Source: Wikipedia 2008.)

172

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Chaotic systems Logistic map Non-chaotic

Chaotic

Lorenz equations Non-chaotic

Figure 7.6

Chaotic

Lorenz strange attractor

Overlap of chaos, logistic map, and Lorenz equations.

XJUIUIFDIBPTNPEFMSFHJPOUIBUDPOTJTUTPGNVMUJQMFDIBPUJDTZTUFNTThF-PSFO[TUSBOHFBUUSBDUPS JOUFSTFDUJPOJTBQPJOU SFQSFTFOUJOHUIFDIBPUJDTZTUFNXJUIUIFQBSBNFUFSTEJTDVTTFEBCPWFThF PWFSMBQJTJMMVTUSBUFEJO'JHVSF

Intension and Extension The terms “intension” and “extension,” as terms of logic, are encountered in some of the disciplines supporting SE. This sidebar brieﬂy describes these concepts and how they relate to SE and MOSES. Intension and extension are two different ways of deﬁning a term. An intensional deﬁnition deﬁnes one or more properties. Those properties may apply to any number of individuals, from zero to many. An extensional deﬁnition deﬁnes a set of individual things by enumerating the individuals. Either of the two deﬁnitions can exist without the other. When both deﬁnitions exist for a term, then the extension (or the extensional deﬁnition) is the set of individuals whose properties match those of the intensional deﬁnition. A few examples will illustrate the difference. We will deﬁne a function, a model, and two speciﬁc concepts: the morning star and the evening star. 1. Function: intensional deﬁnition: y f(x) x2 in the domain of positive integers. Extensional deﬁnition: (x,y) {(1,1), (2,4), (3,9), z}. 2. Model: intensional deﬁnition: for stimulus T, response is R; response time a 2 sec; extensional deﬁnition: {S1, S2, S3, S4} (assuming S1, z, S4 are all systems that satisfy the model and no other systems satisfy it). 3. Morning star: intensional deﬁnition: bright star seen in the morning; extensional deﬁnition: {Venus} 4. Evening star: intensional deﬁnition: bright star seen in the evening; extensional deﬁnition: {Venus}

Commonization Often, one set of properties (intensional deﬁnition) corresponds to multiple individual things (extensional deﬁnition), as in the ﬁrst two examples given. On the other hand, many times a given individual thing corresponds to multiple intensional deﬁnitions. In examples 3 and 4, Venus is both the morning star and the evening star, although these terms have different intensional meanings. Taken together, these examples illustrate that the relation between intensional deﬁnitions and individual things is many-to-many. How do these concepts relate to SE? In MOSES and SE in general, models typically have multiple corresponding systems. In some cases, a model is deﬁned to correspond to one system only — for example, a biometric model intended to uniquely identify one individual human. In other situations, one system satisﬁes multiple models. One such situation is where a set of models describes the same system, for example, a requirements model of system S1, an architecture description of S1, and a design model of S1. A second situation is when a given system plays different roles in different environments, for example, a system has multiple features, and different environments use different features. Another example of the second situation is when a systems engineer plays multiple roles on a project such as team leader and chief designer. Team leader and chief designer are two different categories, two different intensions, but the extension is the same for both. More generally, in MOSES, the relation between intension and extension is the same as the relation between category and instance. This has implications: O

O O

Intensional and extensional deﬁnitions are at different levels of the categorization hierarchy. Intension deﬁnes the properties of a category of things, and extension enumerates the instances of that category — which is one level down. Intensional deﬁnition deﬁnes a model, and extensional deﬁnition deﬁnes the region of the model. Both provide pieces of information that the other does not provide. An extensional deﬁnition of a model provides information on what systems are in the region but it does not provide explicit information on the system characteristics of the model. An intensional deﬁnition of a model is the opposite; it provides information on the system characteristics of the model but not what systems are in the region.

Another distinction of the intension–extension duality is time invariance versus time variance. Let’s use the notation RI(W) to mean an intensional deﬁnition of a region in deﬁned world W, and RE(W) to mean the analogous extensional deﬁnition. Now consider this example: the employee database of ACME company is a region R that results from the model “is employee” applied to the deﬁned world W “ACME company.” Then RI(W) {S|S ACME employee}. This is abstract with respect to time; that is, it does not specify a point in time or a time period, and it does not change over time. RE(W), on the other hand, is the set of ACME employees as recorded in the employee database at any point in time, and it changes as employees are hired by or leave ACME. The concept of an employee database (RI(W)), which is stable, and the current set of employees (RE(W)) in that database, which changes, are both useful. And the relation between the two is equally

O

173

174

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science important. If all we see is a list of names, we do not know what it represents. If someone tells us that “This is the list of current ACME employees,” then we know what the list means. This approach of abstracting time is a very common use of the intension – extension distinction. Intension is the dominant way models are deﬁned in MOSES. One goal is to encourage deﬁning a set of characteristics and constraints on them; for example, give characteristics of a platform instead of simply saying “Windows XP.” Many things are deﬁned extensionally in TSE (platforms, connectors, components, etc.); this is one reason the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) changed its acquisition approach from deﬁning “requirements” to deﬁning “capabilities”: DoD customers (i.e., DoD managers and organizations that were requesting solutions) were deﬁning requirements extensionally, in terms of “I need System S” or “I need Product P” instead of intensionally, such as “I need a system that performs these functions and has these propertiesz” In addition, intensionally deﬁned models signiﬁcantly help deﬁne a body of knowledge, as opposed to a collection of individual systems. General models are essential to deﬁning and using knowledge. An appropriate combination of general intensional models that deﬁne the properties and rules, and speciﬁc extensional regions that serve as examples, is a good basis of knowledge.

Commonization Relations and Multilevel Structures ThFJOUFOTJPOoFYUFOTJPOSFMBUJPOJMMVTUSBUFTUIFNPSFHFOFSBMNBOZUPNBOZSFMBUJPOCFUXFFODBU FHPSZBOEJOEJWJEVBM ThFTBNFJTUSVFGPSLJOET"LJOEDBOIBWFNVMUJQMFTVCLJOET"JSDSBGUDBOCFTQFDJBMJ[FEJOUP SPUBSZBOEﬁYFEXJOHBJSDSBGU"LJOEDBOBMTPCFHFOFSBMJ[FEJONVMUJQMFXBZT"JSDSBGUDBOCF HFOFSBMJ[FEBMPOHXJUITQBDFWFIJDMFTJOUPWFIJDMFTUIBUﬂZBCPWFUIF&BSUI PSJUDBOCFHFOFSBMJ[FE BMPOHXJUIDBST CVTFT USBJOT BOEQBTTFOHFSTIJQTJOUPUSBOTQPSUBUJPOWFIJDMFT*OHFOFSBM BLJOE UIBUJTEFﬁOFECZBDFSUBJOOVNCFSPGQSPQFSUJFTPSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTDBOCFHFOFSBMJ[FECZSFNPW JOHTPNFPGUIPTFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT BOETQFDJBMJ[FECZBEEJOHUPUIPTFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT'PSFYBNQMF UIF LJOE i#PFJOH DPNNFSDJBM BJSDSBGUw JT EFﬁOFE CZ UIF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PG DPNNFSDJBM BJSDSBGU QMVTNBOVGBDUVSFS*UDBOCFHFOFSBMJ[FEUPDPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGUCZSFNPWJOHUIFNBOVGBDUVSFS DIBSBDUFSJTUJDGSPNUIFNPEFMBOEJUDBOCFTQFDJBMJ[FEUP#PFJOHBJSDSBGUCZBEEJOHUIFDIBS BDUFSJTUJDTUIBUEJTUJOHVJTIUIFGSPNPUIFS#PFJOHDPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGU Th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

Commonization

O

175

$BUFHPSJ[BUJPOJTUIFSFMBUJPOUIBUJOWPMWFTXIBUNBOZDBMMNFUBNPEFMT"NFUBNPEFMJTBDBU FHPSZPGXIJDIBNPEFMJTBOJOTUBODF4PNFNPEFMJOHTUSVDUVSFTdeﬁne GPVSTVDIMFWFMT0CKFDU JTBOJOTUBODFPGB.PEFM XIJDIJTBOJOTUBODFPGB.FUBNPEFM XIJDIJTBOJOTUBODFPGB.FUB NFUBNPEFM " DPSSFTQPOEJOH FYBNQMF GSPN 'JHVSF JT -BTTJF PCKFDU JT BO JOTUBODF PG %PH NPEFM

XIJDIJTBOJOTUBODFPG4QFDJFT NFUBNPEFM

XIJDIJTBOJOTUBODFPG#JPMPHJDBM$BUFHPSZ NFUBNFUBNPEFM "TPSJHJOBMMZdeﬁned, UIF0CKFDU.BOBHFNFOU(SPVQT 0.( .FUB0CKFDU 'BDJMJUZ .0' IBEUIJTGPVSMBZFSBSDIJUFDUVSF*O.04&4 BMMMFWFMTBSFNPEFMTNPEFMJTBSFMB UJWFUFSN"TEFTDSJCFEBCPWF FBDINPEFMJTdeﬁned BOEEJTUJOHVJTIFECZJUTSPMFTJOUIFDBUFHPSJ[B UJPOBOEHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOIJFSBSDIJFT.04&4EPFTOPUSFTUSJDUUPGPVSMFWFMT4UBSUJOHXJUI.0' 0.(

.0'IBTBMTPTXJUDIFEUPUIJTNPSe ﬂexible and extensible arDIJUFDUVSF (FOFSBMJ[BUJPOBMMPXTBSDIJUFDUVSFTPGWBSZJOHMFWFMTPGHFOFSBMJUZUPCFdeﬁned. 4peciﬁc BSDIJ UFDUVSFTDBOCFdeﬁned UIBUJODMVEFFYUFOTJWFEFUBJMBOEBENJUBTNBMMDMBTTPGDPSSFTQPOEJOHTZT UFNT (FOFSBM BSDIJUFDUVSFT DBO CF deﬁned UIBU JODMVEF MJUUMF EFUBJM BOE BENJU B MBSHF DMBTT PG DPSSFTQPOEJOHTZTUFNT&YBNQMFTPGUIFMBUUFSBSFSFGFSFODFBSDIJUFDUVSFTPSSFGFSFODFNPEFMT 6OEFSUIFDPOTUSBJOUUIBUFBDIMFWFMPOMZTQFDJBMJ[FTJUTQBSFOU BOEEPFTOPUNPEJGZXIBUJU JOIFSJUTGSPNJUTQBSFOU BOEUIFSFJTPOMZTJOHMFJOIFSJUBODF JF BLJOEJOIFSJUTGSPNBTJOHMFQBS FOU

UIFOBLJOEIJFSBSDIZIBTUIFGPMMPXJOHQBUUFSOUIFUPQ NPTUHFOFSBM NPTUJODMVTJWF LJOE JOUIFIJFSBSDIZJTSFMBUJWFMZIFUFSPHFOFPVT BOEFBDITVDDFTTJWFMFWFMCFMPXUIBUCFDPNFTSFMBUJWFMZ NPSF IPNPHFOFPVT &RVJWBMFOUMZ UIF UPQ PG UIF IJFSBSDIZ IBT UIF GFXFTU DPOTUSBJOUT BOE UIF CPUUPNPGUIFIJFSBSDIZIBTUIFNPTUDPOTUSBJOUTThe UPQIBTUIFMBSHFTUSFHJPOPSQPQVMBUJPOPG TZTUFNTBOEUIFCPUUPNIBTUIFTNBMMFTUSFHJPO*OIFSJUBODFJTEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJO$IBQUFS $BUFHPSJ[BUJPOJT BSHVBCMZ UIFNPSFGVOEBNFOUBMPGUIFUXPDPNNPOJ[BUJPOUZQFT,JOEPSHFO FSBMJ[BUJPOJTDSJUJDBMBOEVTFGVMCVUJUEFQFOETPODBUFHPSJ[BUJPO,JOEBEETBSFMBUJPO HFOFSBMJ[BUJPO CFUXFFODBUFHPSJFT$BUFHPSJFTDPVMEFYJTUXJUIPVULJOETCVULJOETDPVMEOPUFYJTUXJUIPVUDBUFHPSJFT (ÚEFMTJODPNQMFUFOFTTUIFPSFNBMTPBQQMJFT CZBOBMPHZ UPDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOThFDIBSBDUFSJ[B UJPOPSSPMFPGBNPEFMJTJODPNQMFUFXJUIJOUIFNPEFMJUTFMG"NPEFMDBOPOMZCFEFﬁOFEBTB DBUFHPSZPSBOJOTUBODFJODPOUFYU*UJTBDBUFHPSZJOJUTSFMBUJPOXJUIBOJOTUBODFJUJTBOJOTUBODF JOJUTSFMBUJPOXJUIBDBUFHPSZ

Example Tool: The Generic Modeling Environment ThF(FOFSJD.PEFMJOH&OWJSPONFOU (.& JTBUPPMLJUGPSDSFBUJOHEPNBJOTQFDJﬁDNPEFMJOH FOWJSPONFOUTUISPVHIUIFVTFPGNFUBNPEFMTUIBUTQFDJGZUIFNPEFMJOHMBOHVBHFPGUIFBQQMJDB UJPOEPNBJO (.&-FEFD[JFUBM *UJTCBTFEPO6.-BOEUIF0CKFDU$POTUSBJOU -BOHVBHF 0$- "UUIFNPTUHFOFSBMMFWFM UIFNPEFMJOHDPOTUSVDUTJODMVEFIJFSBSDIZ BTQFDUT TFUT SFGFSFODFT BOEDPOTUSBJOUT0UIFSﬁSTUDMBTTPCKFDUTJODMVEFNPEFMT BUPNT BOEDPOOFDUJPOT XIJDIFYQSFTTSFMBUJPOT"OFXNPEFMJOHMBOHVBHFDBOCFEFﬁOFEVTJOHUIF.FUB(.&GSBNFXPSL BOEJUTNFUBNPEFMJOHMBOHVBHF (.&IBTCFFOVTFEUPEFﬁOFEPNBJOTQFDJﬁDNPEFMJOHGSBNFXPSLTTVDIBTBOFOWJSPONFOU GPSNPEFMJOHQIZTJDBMTZTUFNT .BOEFSTFUBM BOEUIFNPEFMJOHMBOHVBHFGPSJOUFHSBUFE NPEVMBSBWJPOJDTEFTJHO .*."% (BNBUJÏFUBM

Leverage .04&4SFDPHOJ[FTBUSBEFPﬀ CFUXFFOHFOFSBMBOETQFDJﬁDTPMVUJPOT BOEBEESFTTFTJUUISPVHIB QSJODJQMFXFDBMMMFWFSBHF*OUIFDPOUFYUPGUIFPWFSBMMNPEFMTQBDF BOJNQPSUBOUHPBMJTUPEFWFMPQ BOFﬃcJFOUTFUPGiSFVTBCMFwNPEFMTUIBUXJMMTBUJTGZTQFDJﬁDQSPCMFNTBOESFTVMUJOTQFDJﬁDTZTUFNT

176

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

UIBUPQFSBUFJOHJWFOFOWJSPONFOUTThFSFVTBCMFHPBMJTBDIJFWFEJGUIFNPEFMDBQUVSFTXIBUJT DPNNPOBDSPTTNVMUJQMFTZTUFNT4BUJTGZJOHBTQFDJﬁDQSPCMFNJTBDIJFWFEJGUIFNPEFMBEESFTTFT XIBUJTEJﬀFSFOUPSVOJRVFBCPVUUIBUTQFDJﬁDQSPCMFNThFSFGPSF UIFSFVTBCMFHPBMBOEUIFTQF DJﬁDTBUJTGBDUJPOHPBMBSFJODPOﬂJDU4FWFSBMBQQSPBDIFTIBWFCFFOQSPQPTFEUPTBUJTGZUIFDPNNPO BOEVOJRVFDPOTUSBJOUT. ThFTFJODMVEF O $VTUPNTPMVUJPOBQQSPBDI$SFBUFDVTUPNTPMVUJPOTUPFBDIQSPCMFNJOFBDIEPNBJO JF UIFSBEJDBMEFTJHOBQQSPBDI *OHFOFSBM UIJTJTVOOFDFTTBSJMZBOEQSPIJCJUJWFMZFYQFOTJWF *UFNQIBTJ[FTVOJRVFBTQFDUTCVUEPFTOPUFYQMPJUUIFDPNNPOBTQFDUTPGQSPCMFNT O (FOFSBMTPMVUJPOBQQSPBDI%FﬁOFBPOFTJ[FﬁUTBMMTPMVUJPOUIBUDBQUVSFTXIBUJTDPNNPO BDSPTTBMMQSPCMFNTJOBMM4&BQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT*OTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH UIJTBQQSPBDIJT SFﬂFDUFEJOIJHIFSMFWFMHFOFSBMMBOHVBHFT UPFYUFOEBVUPNBUJPO. ThJTBQQSPBDIJTIJHIMZ SFVTBCMFCVUSFRVJSFTTJHOJﬁDBOUBVHNFOUBUJPOBOETQFDJBMJ[BUJPOGPSFBDIJOEJWJEVBMTPMV UJPO*OGBDU NPTUPGFBDITPMVUJPONVTUCFDVTUPNUBJMPSFETPBMUIPVHIUIJTBQQSPBDI MPPLTWFSZEJﬀFSFOUGSPNUIFDVTUPNTPMVUJPOBQQSPBDI UIFFﬀFDUJTWFSZTJNJMBS O "QQMJDBUJPO EPNBJO BQQSPBDI %FﬁOF B HFOFSBM TPMVUJPO XJUIJO BO BQQMJDBUJPO EPNBJO UIBU DBQUVSFTXIBUJTDPNNPOUPBMMTZTUFNTJOUIBUEPNBJOThFBQQSPBDIFYQMPJUTUIFGBDUUIBU QSPCMFNTBOETPMVUJPOTBOETZTUFNTXJUIJOBEPNBJOBSFUZQJDBMMZNVDINPSFIPNPHFOFPVT UIBOUIPTFBDSPTTEPNBJOTThFSFGPSF UIFHFOFSBMTPMVUJPODBQUVSFTBTJHOJﬁDBOUQPSUJPOPG QSPCMFNWBSJBCJMJUZXJUIJOUIFEPNBJO O &OUFSQSJTFBQQSPBDIThJTDSJUFSJPOXPVMESFTVMUJONBJOUBJOJOHFOUFSQSJTFTQFDJﬁDDPODFQUT UISPVHIPVUThJTBEESFTTFTFOUFSQSJTFTQFDJﬁDJTTVFTCVUEVQMJDBUFTEPNBJOBOENPSFHFO FSBMBTQFDUTPGQSPCMFNT &BDIPGUIFTFDSJUFSJBNBLFTBDPOUSJCVUJPOUPQSPCMFNTPMWJOH CVUXFOPXEFWFMPQBNPSF DPNQMFUFBOECBMBODFETPMVUJPO ThFDSJUFSJPOUIBUXFQSPQPTFJTNBYJNVNMFWFSBHF-FWFSBHF PG B NPEFM TFFO BT B TPMVUJPO JT EFﬁOFE BT UIF EFHSFF UP XIJDI JU TBUJTﬁFT UIF GPMMPXJOH UXP DSJUFSJB XIJDIBSF JOHFOFSBM DPOﬂJDUJOH OVNCFSPGQSPCMFNTJUVBUJPOTUPXIJDIJUBQQMJFT BOE FYUFOUUPXIJDIJUQSPWJEFTUIFDPNQMFUFTPMVUJPOOFFEFEGPSUIFTQFDJﬁDQSPCMFNTJUV BUJPOT UP XIJDI JU BQQMJFT &TTFOUJBMMZ MFWFSBHF JT UIF QSPEVDU PG UIFTF UXP DSJUFSJB ThFTF DSJ UFSJB SFQSFTFOU B HFOFSBM USBEFPﬀ JO QSPCMFN TPMWJOH HFOFSBMJUZ WFSTVT QPXFS JMMVTUSBUFE JO 'JHVSF /PUFUIBUMFWFSBHFJTQPTTJCMFQSJNBSJMZJONBUVSFPSOPSNBMEFTJHO BTPQQPTFEUP SBEJDBMEFTJHO CFDBVTFJUUBLFTUJNFBOEFYQFSJFODFUPEFUFSNJOFXIBUJTDPNNPOBOEXIBUJT VOJRVFBNPOHUIFQSPCMFNTBOETPMVUJPOTJOBHJWFOEPNBJO(FOFSBMJUZSFGFSTUPUIFOVNCFS PGQSPCMFNTBTPMVUJPOIFMQTTPMWF UIFﬁSTUDSJUFSJPOQPXFSSFGFSTUPUIFEFHSFFUPXIJDIBTPMV UJPO IFMQT TPMWF B HJWFO QSPCMFN UIF TFDPOE DSJUFSJPO *EFBMMZ POF TPMVUJPO XPVME DPNQMFUFMZ TPMWFBMMQSPCMFNT VQQFSSJHIUPGCPYJO'JHVSF )PXFWFS UIFSFJTBMJNJUFWFOXIFOBEJT DJQMJOF SFBDIFT NBUVSJUZ UIF USBEFPﬀ TUJMM FYJTUT *O BO JNNBUVSF EJTDJQMJOF UIF MJNJU JT OPU ZFUSFBDIFE BOEMFWFSBHFJTFWFONPSFSFTUSJDUFEThFDVSSFOUBOEVMUJNBUFUSBEFPﬀTBSFTIPXO CZ UIF EJBHPOBM EBTIFE MJOFT JO UIF ﬁHVSF ThVT UXP NPEFMT PG FRVBM MFWFSBHF NBZ EJﬀFS JO UIBUPOFNBZQSPWJEFBTNBMMQBSUPGUIFTPMVUJPOGPSBMBSHFOVNCFSPGQSPCMFNT TIPXOBTUIF BSFB MBCFMFE i-FWFSBHF PG HFOFSBM TPMVUJPOw JO UIF ﬁHVSF

XIJMF UIF TFDPOE NBZ QSPWJEF NPTU PGUIFTPMVUJPOGPSBTNBMMOVNCFSPGQSPCMFNT TIPXOBTi-FWFSBHFPGTQFDJﬁDTPMVUJPOwJOUIF ﬁHVSF ThFﬁSTUDSJUFSJPOSFﬂFDUTUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGUIFQFSTPOXJUIUIFTPMVUJPOUIFQSPEVDFS PSQSPWJEFS*IBWFBTPMVUJPOUIBUXJMMHJWFTPNFIFMQJOTPMWJOHFWFSZPOFTQSPCMFNT POFTJ[FﬁUT BMM ThFTFDPOEDSJUFSJPOSFﬂFDUTUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGUIFQFSTPOXJUIUIFQSPCMFNUIFDPOTVNFS PSDMJFOU*XBOUBTPMVUJPOUIBUDPNQMFUFMZTPMWFTNZTQFDJﬁDQSPCMFN

Commonization

O

177

!

Figure 7.7 Leverage metric. (Source: Hybertson, D. A uniform component modeling space. Informatica, 25(4):475–482. Published by Slovenian Society Informatika, 2001. Used with permission.)

-FWFSBHFUIVTFYQMPJUTDPNNPOBMJUZBOECBMBODFTJUXJUIUIFPUIFSTJEFPGQSPCMFNTPMWJOH QPXFSPGTPMVUJPO*UGPTUFSTBNVMUJNPEFMTUSBUFHZUIBUJTESJWFOCZUIFHPBMPGﬁOEJOHNPEFMTUIBU CFTUFYQMPJUUIFGVMMDPNNPOJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVNPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFThBUJT JUFYQMPJUTBOEDPNCJOFT UIFTUSFOHUITPGFBDIPGUIFGPVSBQQSPBDIFTBCPWFThFXBZUPBDIJFWFNBYJNVNMFWFSBHFJTUP GBDUPSPVUUIFDPNNPOBOEEPNBJOTQFDJﬁDQBSUTPGBTFUPGQSPCMFNTThFOPOFDBOﬁOEBHFOFSBM TPMVUJPOGPSUIFDPNNPOQBSUBOEBNPSFTQFDJBMJ[FETPMVUJPOGPSUIFEPNBJOTQFDJﬁDQBSU BOE JOUFHSBUFUIFNJOUPNPSFQPXFSGVMTPMVUJPOTUIBOFJUIFSQBSUTFQBSBUFMZ ThFGPVSBQQSPBDIFTEFTDSJCFEBCPWFDBOCFQPTJUJPOFEPO'JHVSFThFﬁSTUUXPSFQSFTFOU UIFFYUSFNFFOETPGUIFMJNJUTQFDUSVN BOEBDIJFWFMJUUMFMFWFSBHFThFDVTUPNTPMVUJPOBQQSPBDI JTSFQSFTFOUFECZBWFSZUBMMOBSSPXSFDUBOHMFBUUIFMFGUPGUIFCPY&BDIDVTUPNTPMVUJPOTPMWFT BMMPGPOFTQFDJﬁDQSPCMFN TPUIFUPQPGUIFSFDUBOHMFJTBUQSPQPSUJPOiBMMwBOEUIFSJHIUTJEFJT BUQSPCMFNThFHFOFSBMTPMVUJPOPOFTJ[FﬁUTBMMBQQSPBDIJTSFQSFTFOUFECZBWFSZTIPSU XJEF SFDUBOHMFBUUIFCPUUPNPGUIFCPYThFHFOFSBMTPMVUJPOTPMWFTBUJOZGSBDUJPOPGFWFSZTQFDJﬁD QSPCMFN TPUIFUPQPGUIFSFDUBOHMFJTKVTUBCPWFQSPQPSUJPOBOEUIFSJHIUTJEFJTBUiBMMwQSPC MFNT. ThFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOBOEFOUFSQSJTFTPMVUJPOTBSFJOCFUXFFOUIFTFFYUSFNFT ThFDPODFQUPGMBZFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSFJTBOFYFNQMBSPGUIFMFWFSBHFDPODFQUUIBUJT JUJTBOBSDIJUFDUVSF TUZMFEFTJHOFEUPBDIJFWFNBYJNVNMFWFSBHF'PSFYBNQMF BMBZFSFETPGUXBSFBSDIJUFDUVSF +BDPCTPO (SJTT BOE+POTTPO GBDUPSTPVUDPNNPOBMJUZBOEWBSJBCJMJUZGSPNUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGQSPCMFN EPNBJOT ThFVQQFSMBZFSTBSFNPSFQSPCMFNPSBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOTQFDJﬁD ThFNJEEMFMBZFSTDPOUBJO DPNQPOFOUTPGJOUFSNFEJBUFHFOFSBMJUZGSPNTVQQPSUJOHEPNBJOT TVDIBTEBUBCBTFNBOBHFNFOU EJT USJCVUFEPCKFDUDPNQVUJOH USBOTBDUJPOQSPDFTTJOH BOENFTTBHJOHThFMPXFSMBZFSTDPOUBJOUIFNPTU HFOFSBMFMFNFOUTUIBUBQQMZUPBMMQSPCMFNEPNBJOT TVDIBTTFSWJDFTQSPWJEFECZPQFSBUJOHTZTUFNTPS OFUXPSLT"EEJUJPOBMJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTPGMBZFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSFTBSFEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS ThFSFJTBTQBDFWFSTVTUJNFBTQFDUUPDPNNPOBMJUZBOEMFWFSBHF.VDIPGUIFNPUJWBUJPOGPS 1BSOBTJOGPSNBUJPOIJEJOH 1BSOBT XBTSFMBUFEUPUIFUJNFEJNFOTJPOJEFOUJGZBOETFQBSBUF UIFQBSUTPGBTZTUFNUIBUXJMMDIBOHFPSFWPMWFPWFSUJNFGSPNUIFQBSUTUIBUXJMMSFNBJOTUBCMF BOEIJEFPSFODBQTVMBUFUIFDIBOHJOHQBSUT#VUUIFTQBDFEJNFOTJPOJTQFSIBQTFWFONPSFTJHOJﬁDBOUCFDBVTFJUDBQUVSFTUIFDPNQPTJUFTZTUFNTTQBDFBOETVQQPSUTNPSFHFOFSBMSFVTF*EFOUJGZ BOETFQBSBUFUIFQBSUTUIBUBSFDPNNPOUPNVMUJQMFTZTUFNTGSPNUIFQBSUTUIBUBSFVOJRVFUPFBDI TZTUFN BOEFYQMPJUUIFDPNNPOQBSUT

178 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

"DIJFWJOHMFWFSBHFJTDSJUJDBMUPBOZDPNQPOFOUCBTFEEPNBJOJOUFSNTPGNBSLFUWJBCJMJUZ" DPNQPOFOUEFWFMPQFSNVTUQSPEVDFBDPNQPOFOUUIBUTJNVMUBOFPVTMZTBUJTﬁFTFOPVHIPGUIFTQF DJﬁDOFFET iQSPQPSUJPOPGTPMVUJPOw PGBTVﬃcJFOUOVNCFS iOVNCFSPGQSPCMFNTw PGJOEJWJEVBM TZTUFNDPNQPTFST UPFTUBCMJTIBNBSLFU"DPNQPOFOUCBTFEBSDIJUFDUVSFDBOCFFYQFDUFEUPIBWF B DPNCJOBUJPO PG QSPCMFN EPNBJOTQFDJﬁD DPNQPOFOUT BOE HFOFSBM DPNQPOFOUT " MBZFSFE PS UJFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSF BTEJTDVTTFEBCPWF TVQQPSUTUIJTDPODFQU 8JUIJOUIFQSPCMFNEPNBJODPOUFYU BOPUIFSMFWFSBHFNFDIBOJTNJTFOUFSQSJTFTQFDJﬁDNPE FMT TVDI BT QSPEVDU MJOF BSDIJUFDUVSFT &OUFSQSJTFT DBO FYQMPJU UIF EPNBJOCBTFE LOPXMFEHF GPVOEBUJPO BOE TQFDJBMJ[F EPNBJO NPEFMT GPS UIFJS PXO QVSQPTFT *U JT NVDI NPSF EJﬃcVMU UP DSFBUFFOUFSQSJTFNPEFMT DPNQPOFOUT BOEBSDIJUFDUVSFTXJUIPVUUIJTNPSFHFOFSBMGPVOEBUJPO 'PSFYBNQMF (FOFSBM.PUPSTXPVMEOPUIBWFCFFOJOBHPPEQPTJUJPOUPDSFBUFBOFX4BUVSOMJOF PGDBSTXJUIPVUUIFTPMJEGPVOEBUJPOPGBTIBSFELOPXMFEHFPGBVUPNPUJWFFOHJOFFSJOHUIBUUIFZ DPVMETQFDJBMJ[F*OUIFTPGUXBSFBSFOB JUCFDBNFNVDIFBTJFSGPSBOFOUFSQSJTFUPCVJMEBOFX DPNQJMFSBGUFSBTUBOEBSEBSDIJUFDUVSFXJUITUBOEBSEDPNQPOFOUTFNFSHFEBOEXBTVOEFSTUPPEJO UIFDPNQJMFSDPNNVOJUZ

Limits of Generality: Is a Universal Architecture Possible? 8IBUJTUIFQSBDUJDBMMJNJUPGHFOFSBMJUZPGBNPEFM The QSFWJPVTTFDUJPOPOMFWFSBHFXPVMETVHHFTU UIBUUIFMJNJUJTBNPEFMUIBUBQQMJFTUPBMMQSPCMFNTCVUoﬀers POMZNPEFTUIFMQJOTPMWJOHBOZ speciﬁc QSPCMFN#VUXIBUJGXFDPVMEQVTIUIBUMFWFSBHFMJNJUMJOFBTUFQPSUXPUPXBSEUIFVQQFS SJHIUJEFBM XIFSFBNPEFMBQQMJFTUPNPTUQSPCMFNTBOEoﬀers TVCTUBOUJBMIFMQJOTPMWJOHFBDIPOF PGUIFN 4VQQPTFXFEFﬁOFUIFTFUPGBMMTZTUFNTPGJOUFSFTUUP4&UIBUJT BMMTZTUFNTJOUIFUBYPOPNZ JO'JHVSF/PXDPOTJEFSJOUFSOBMNPEFMTPGUIFTFTZTUFNT TVDIBTBSDIJUFDUVSFT*TUIFSFPOF JOUFSOBMNPEFM POFBSDIJUFDUVSF UIBUXPVMEBQQMZUPBMM4&TZTUFNT 8FDPVMEEFﬁOFBNPEFMUIBU IBTUIFTFDPOTUSBJOUTOVNCFSPGDPNQPOFOUTJTBUMFBTUUXP BOEUIFZIBWFBWBSJBCMFOVNCFSPG DPOOFDUJPOTPSJOUFSBDUJPOTBNPOHUIFNThBUNPEFMXPVMEBQQMZUPBMM4&TZTUFNTJOGBDUUP BMMTZTUFNTCVUJUXPVMEOPUCFPGNVDIVTFJOTPMWJOH JF FOHJOFFSJOH BOZTQFDJﬁDTZTUFN #VUUIFSFJTBNPSFTVCTUBOUJBMDBOEJEBUFXFDPVMEDPOTJEFSBTBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMUIBUBQQMJFTUP BMM4&TZTUFNTBOEHJWFTVTTPNFIFGU TPNFUIJOHVTFGVMGPSBMMUIFTFTZTUFNTThBUDBOEJEBUFJTUIF TFUPGGVODUJPOTUIBU.JMMFS EFﬁ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

Commonization

O

179

1SPEVDFS 'PSNT TUBCMF BTTPDJBUJPOT UIBU FOEVSF GPS TJHOJﬁ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iQSJWBUFwDPEF "TTPDJBUPS$BSSJFTPVUUIFﬁSTUTUBHFPGUIFMFBSOJOHQSPDFTT GPSNJOHFOEVSJOHBTTPDJBUJPOT BNPOHJUFNTPGJOGPSNBUJPO .FNPSZ$BSSJFTPVUUIFTFDPOETUBHFPGUIFMFBSOJOHQSPDFTT TUPSJOHJOGPSNBUJPO BOE UIFOSFUSJFWJOHJU %FDJEFS&YFDVUJWFSFDFJWFTJOGPSNBUJPOJOQVUTGSPNBMMPUIFSTVCTZTUFNTBOEUSBOTNJUTUP UIFNHVJEBODF DPPSEJOBUJPO BOEDPOUSPMPGUIFTZTUFN &ODPEFS "MUFST UIF DPEF PG JOGPSNBUJPO JOQVU UP JU GSPN PUIFS JOGPSNBUJPO QSPDFTTJOH TVCTZTUFNT 0VUQVUUSBOTEVDFS1VUTPVUNBSLFSTCFBSJOHJOGPSNBUJPOGSPNUIFTZTUFN BOEDIBOHFT NBSLFSTXJUIJOUIFTZTUFN JOUPPUIFSNBUUFSFOFSHZGPSNT The GVODUJPOTEPOPUGPSNBDPNQPTJUJPOGSBDUBMThat JT UIFZEPOPUSFQSFTFOUBQBUUFSO JOXIJDIFBDIGVODUJPOTVCEJWJEFTJOUPUIFTBNFGVODUJPOTThe TJNQMZFYJTUSFQFBUFEMZBU FWFSZMFWFM JOFWFSZTZTUFN XIJDITVHHFTUTUIBUUIFTFUPGGVODUJPOTJTCPUIIJHIMZTDBMFBCMFBOE CSPBEMZCBTFE*GUIFZIPMEGPSBMMMJWJOHTZTUFNTGSPNDFMMUPTVQSBOBUJPOBMTZTUFN UIBUOBUVSBMMZ SBJTFTUIFRVFTUJPOPGXIFUIFSUIFZIPMEGPSBMMTZTUFNTPGJOUFSFTUUP4&)PXEPFTUIFTDPQFPG 4&TZTUFNTDPNQBSFUPMJWJOHTZTUFNT .JMMFSTEFQJDUJPOPGMJWJOHTZTUFNTJTUIBUUIFZBSFEJWJEFE JOUPGVODUJPOTUIBUQSPDFTTNBUUFSBOEFOFSHZWFSTVTUIPTFUIBUQSPDFTTJOGPSNBUJPO"ﬁrst QPT TJCJMJUZUIFOJTUIBUUIFGVODUJPOTDPWFSUISFFUZQFTPGTZTUFNT TZTUFNTUIBUQSPDFTTCPUI NBUUFSFOFSHZBOEJOGPSNBUJPO XIJDIVTFBMMGVODUJPOT JOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNT XIJDIVTF UIFGVODUJPOTUIBUQSPDFTTJOGPSNBUJPOBOE TZTUFNTUIBUQSPDFTTPOMZNBUUFSFOFSHZ XIJDI VTFUIFGVODUJPOTUIBUQSPDFTTNBUUFSFOFSHZThFTFUISFFDBUFHPSJFTXPVMETFFNUPDPWFSUIF TDPQFPG4&TZTUFNT )PXFWFS B DMPTFS MPPL BU JOGPSNBUJPO QSPDFTTJOH GVODUJPOT TIPXT UIBU UIFZ BSF EFﬁOFE JO UIF DPOUFYU PG B QIZTJDBM NBUUFSFOFSHZ TZTUFN XIFSF TPNF PG UIF GVODUJPOT USBOTEVDF TUVﬀ CFUXFFONBUUFSFOFSHZBOEJOGPSNBUJPOGPSNT5PTVQQPSUBQVSFJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFN UIFTFGVOD UJPOTXPVMEOFFEUPCFNPEJﬁFEPSSFQMBDFEXJUIDPSSFTQPOEJOHGVODUJPOTUIBUTJNQMZQSPDFTT

180

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

JOGPSNBUJPOBOFNJOFOUMZEPBCMFUBTLCBTFEPOUIFXPSL.JMMFSIBTEPOF"QBSUJBMBOBMZTJT TVHHFTUTUIFGPMMPXJOHDIBOHFTGPSBQVSFJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFN O 'VODUJPO 3FQSPEVDFS %PFT UIJT BQQMZ UP JOGPSNBUJPO TZTUFNT /PUF iQSPEVDF POF PS NPSF TJNJMBS TZTUFNTw ThJT TVHHFTUT UIF GVODUJPO JT BVUPQPJFUJD CVU QSPHSBNNFST BSF BMMPQPJFUJDJOUIFJSSPMFPGQSPEVDJOHDPEF&WFOTPGUXBSFDPEFHFOFSBUPSTXPVMEBQQFBS UPCFBMMPQPJFUJDUIFZEPOPUSFQSPEVDFUIFNTFMWFTUIFZQSPEVDFPUIFSEJﬀFSFOUDPEF 4FMGNPEJGZJOHTPGUXBSFNJHIUDPNFDMPTFTUUPUIFSFQSPEVDFSGVODUJPOBTJUTUBOETThJT GVODUJPOSFRVJSFTGVSUIFSBOBMZTJTCVUXPVMEQSPCBCMZOFFEUPCFNPEJﬁFEBCJUUPCFGVMMZ DPOTJTUFOUXJUIJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNT O 'VODUJPOT*OUFSOBMUSBOTEVDFSBOE%FDPEFS*OGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTXPVMEOPUOFFEUIF *OUFSOBM USBOTEVDFS GVODUJPO CFDBVTF BMM UIFZ IBWF JT JOGPSNBUJPO ThFZ KVTU OFFE UIF %FDPEFS BOBMPHPVTUPUIFNBUUFSFOFSHZ$POWFSUFS O 'VODUJPOT*OQVUUSBOTEVDFSBOE0VUQVUUSBOTEVDFSThFTFXPVMEOFFEUPCFDIBOHFE UP CF KVTU TJNQMF JOHFTUPST BOE FYUSVEFST BOBMPHPVT UP UIF NBUUFSFOFSHZ GVODUJPOT TP OBNFE ThFNBUUFSFOFSHZGVODUJPOTXPVMEBMTPOFFEUPCFBOBMZ[FEUPTFFJGUIFZXFSFBEFRVBUFGPS NBDIJOFTBTXFMMBTMJWJOHTZTUFNT*GXFBSFDPOTJEFSJOHUIJTBTBQPUFOUJBMVOJWFSTBMBSDIJUFDUVSF XFBMTPXBOUUPBMMPXGPSUXPWBSJBUJPOTJOTQFDJﬁDDBTFTTPNFPGUIFTFGVODUJPOTNJHIUOPUFYJTU JOTPNFDMBTTFTPGTZTUFNTBOETPNFBEEJUJPOBMGVODUJPOTOPUDPWFSFEJOUIFNJHIUFYJTUJO TPNFDMBTTFTPGTZTUFNT/FWFSUIFMFTT JUJTTUJMMBOJOUFSFTUJOHBOEQPUFOUJBMMZVTFGVMQPTTJCJMJUZUIBU UIFGVODUJPOTGPSNUIFFMFNFOUTPGBVOJWFSTBMGVODUJPOBMBSDIJUFDUVSFPGBMM4&TZTUFNT8FEP OPUQVSTVFUIFNBUUFSGVSUIFSJOUIJTCPPLCVUXFDPOKFDUVSFUIBU XJUIJOUIFDBWFBUTMJTUFEBCPWF UIFGVODUJPOTEPGPSNUIFFMFNFOUTPGTVDIBOBSDIJUFDUVSF BOEUIBUUIFQPTTJCJMJUZJTXPSUI JOWFTUJHBUJOHGVSUIFS "OPUIFSiVOJWFSTBMwNPEFMDBOEJEBUFJTUIFTFUPGDPNNPODSJUFSJBJOUIFEPNBJOPGTFDVSJUZ $$3" B C ThJTXPVMECFBOFYUFSOBMNPEFM SFMBUJOHNPSFUPSFRVJSFNFOUT BOEJU XPVMEOPUCFBTDPNQMFUFBTUIFVOJWFSTBMGVODUJPOBMBSDIJUFDUVSFCFDBVTFJUPOMZDPWFSTUIFTFDV SJUZSFRVJSFNFOUT PSUIFTFDVSJUZWJFX/FWFSUIFMFTT JUJTBOPUIFSQPUFOUJBMMZVTFGVMNPEFMUIBU IBTTJHOJﬁDBOUHFOFSBMJUZ

Knowledge, Body of Knowledge (BoK) *OBNBUVSFFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOFPSEPNBJO LOPXMFEHFPGUIFHFOFSBMDMBTTPSDMBTTFTPGQSPC MFNTBOETZTUFNTUIBUTPMWFUIPTFQSPCMFNTJTBDDVNVMBUFEBOEVTFEJOUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGOFX TZTUFNT'SPNUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPG.04&4 UIBULOPXMFEHFJTDBQUVSFEBOESFQSFTFOUFEJOHFOFSBM NPEFMTUIBUJODMVEFTJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTUIBUNBUUFSJOUIFEPNBJO"TNFOUJPOFEFBSMJFS UIFTFNPEFMTBSFJOUIFGPSNPGDPOWFOUJPOBMEFTJHOT QBUUFSOT DPNNPOSFRVJSFNFOUT SFGFSFODF BSDIJUFDUVSFT TUBOEBSET FUD.PEFMTDBOSFQSFTFOUSFMBUJWFMZTQFDJﬁDLOPXMFEHFPSHFOFSBMLOPXM FEHF *O QBSUJDVMBS TQFDJﬁD NPEFMT UIBU IBWF NBOZ EFUBJMT BOE TNBMM SFHJPOT SFQSFTFOU OBSSPX EFFQ LOPXMFEHF XIJMF HFOFSBM NPEFMT UIBU IBWF GFX EFUBJMT BOE MBSHF SFHJPOT SFQSFTFOU CSPBE TIBMMPXLOPXMFEHF#PUIUZQFTBSFVTFGVMUIFZSFQSFTFOUUIFFOETPGUIFMFWFSBHFTQFDUSVNBTEJT DVTTFEJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi-FWFSBHFw(FOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUDBQUVSFBCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFGPSN UIFDPOUFOUTPGUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFQPSUJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF BTEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS

Commonization

O

181

What is a BoK? "#P,JTBDPEJﬁFETFUPGJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUTPNFQSPGFTTJPOUIBUJTHFOFSBMMZBDDFQUFECZUIFDPN NVOJUZPGQSBDUJDFJOUIBUQSPGFTTJPOThFTFUPGJOGPSNBUJPOJTUZQJDBMMZPSHBOJ[FEPSDBUFHPSJ[FE JOBXBZUIBUJTVOEFSTUPPECZUIFQSBDUJUJPOFSTThF(VJEFUPUIF4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH#PEZPG ,OPXMFEHF "CSBOFUBM WJJJ TUBUFT i&WFSZ QSPGFTTJPO JT CBTFE PO B CPEZ PG LOPXMFEHF BOE SFDPNNFOEFE QSBDUJDFT BMUIPVHIUIFZBSFOPUBMXBZTEFﬁOFEJOBQSFDJTFNBOOFS*ONBOZDBTFT UIFTFBSF GPSNBMMZEPDVNFOUFE VTVBMMZJOBGPSNUIBUQFSNJUTUIFNUPCFVTFEGPSTVDIQVS QPTFTBTBDDSFEJUBUJPOPGBDBEFNJDQSPHSBNT EFWFMPQNFOUPGFEVDBUJPOBOEUSBJOJOH QSPHSBNT DFSUJﬁDBUJPO PG TQFDJBMJTUT PS QSPGFTTJPOBM MJDFOTJOH (FOFSBMMZ B QSPGFT TJPOBMTPDJFUZPSSFMBUFENBJOUBJOTDVTUPEZPGTVDIB<#P,>*ODBTFT XIFSFOPTVDIGPSNBMJUZFYJTUT UIFCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFBOESFDPNNFOEFEQSBDUJDFT BSFAHFOFSBMMZSFDPHOJ[FECZQSBDUJUJPOFSTBOENBZCFDPEJﬁFEJOBWBSJFUZPGXBZTGPS EJﬀFSFOUVTFTw "HVJEFUPB#P,NBZDPOUBJOQBSUPGUIF#P,CVUEPFTOPUDPOUBJOUIFDPNQMFUF#P,*OTUFBE B HVJEFQSPWJEFTBTUSVDUVSFUIBUPSHBOJ[FTBOETVNNBSJ[FTLFZBTQFDUTPGUIF#P,BOEDPOUBJOTBTFU PGSFGFSFODFTUPUIF#P,

Knowledge Categories #FDBVTF4&JTBOFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOF POFNJHIUBTLXIBULJOETPGLOPXMFEHFBSFDPOUBJOFEJO BOFOHJOFFSJOH#P, *OBNBUVSFFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOF NPTUFOHJOFFSJOHJOWPMWFTiOPSNBMwPS iSPVUJOFwEFTJHOThFFOHJOFFSJOHDPOUFOUJOBOZHJWFOEPNBJOFNCPEJFTUIFFTTFOUJBMLOPXMFEHF PGUIFQSPCMFNTBOETPMVUJPOTPGUIBUEPNBJOThJTLOPXMFEHFJTBOFWPMWJOHDPNCJOBUJPOPGQSBD UJDBMLOPXMFEHFBOEUIFPSZPSTDJFODFCBTFELOPXMFEHFThFHSPXUIPGTVDILOPXMFEHFSFEVDFT VODFSUBJOUZBOESJTLJOFOHJOFFSJOH " TFU PG DBUFHPSJFT PG LOPXMFEHF JT UBLFO GSPN 7JODFOUJT CPPL PO FOHJOFFSJOH LOPXMFEHF 7JODFOUJ

FTQFDJBMMZ $IBQUFS iThF "OBUPNZ PG %FTJHO ,OPXMFEHFw ThJT EFTDSJCFT NBUVSFFOHJOFFSJOHLOPXMFEHF BOEJTBHPPENPEFMGPSPVSEFQJDUJPOPGBO4&#P,5BCMF EFTDSJCFT7JODFOUJTLOPXMFEHFDBUFHPSJFT %PFTUIJTOPUJPOPG#P,BQQMZUPDPNQMFYTZTUFNT ThFBOTXFSJTZFT4PNFDMBJNTBSFNBEF UIBUXIJMFUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTGPMMPXQBUUFSOT FBDIDPNQMFYTZTUFNJTVOJRVFBOEDPOUJOVBMMZ DIBOHJOHJOSFTQPOTFUPJUTQBSUJDVMBSFOWJSPONFOU BOEUIVTEPFTOPUGPMMPXBDPNNPOTDSJQU PSEFTJHO ThFJNQMJDBUJPOXPVMECFUIBUOP#P,JTQPTTJCMFGPSDPNQMFYTZTUFNT8FBHSFFXJUI UIFQSFNJTFPGUIJTBSHVNFOUCVUOPUXJUIUIFDPODMVTJPO8IJMFDPNQMFYTZTUFNTJOHFOFSBMNBZ FYQFSJFODFNPSFVOJRVFOFTTBOENPSFDIBOHFUIBOUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNT XFCFMJFWFUIFGPMMPXJOH 'JSTU CPUIUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNT BUMFBTUBOBMPHPSQIZTJDBMPOFT BOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNTBSFVOJRVF FBDIPOFJTBMJUUMFCJUEJﬀFSFOU4FDPOE CPUIUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNTGPMMPXQBUUFSOT 8FDBOXSJUFBCPPLBCPVUUIFDPNNPOQBUUFSOTPGCSJEHFEFTJHOCVUXFDBOBMTPXSJUFBCPPL BCPVUDPNNPOQBUUFSOTPGIVNBOEFTJHO TVDIBTBOBUPNZ&WFOJGXFDPOTJEFSQTZDIPMPHJDBM BTQFDUTPGUIFCSBJO XFIBWFDPNNPOQBUUFSOTPGQFSDFQUJPO QFSTPOBMJUZUZQFT BOEEJTPSEFST $PVOUFSJOUVJUJWFMZ FWFODIBPTFYIJCJUTQBUUFSOT"UUSBDUPSTBOESFQFMMFSTDFSUBJOMZSFQSFTFOUQBU UFSOTPGCFIBWJPS4USBOHFBUUSBDUPSTBMTPSFQSFTFOUQBUUFSOTUIFZBSFDIBPUJDBUUSBDUPSTUIBUBSF

182

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Table 7.2 Vincenti’s Engineering Knowledge Categories Category 1.

Fundamental design concepts (standard models or design patterns)

Contents – Operational principle: how the system/component works; – Normal conﬁguration of the system or component: general shape and arrangement, characteristic parts, general design of the system or component

2. Criteria and speciﬁcations (system properties)

– Salient properties of the system or component; – Speciﬁed values for those properties – Applicable generally (e.g., regulated limits)

3. Theoretical tools (for design analysis)

– Mathematical tools, no physical content; – Mathematical tools, based on scientiﬁc theory; – Mathematical tools, based on engineering theory; – Mathematical tools, based on assumptions; – Intellectual concepts (variety)

4.

Data to input to the mathematical analysis tools: – Empirical data (applicable generally) – Theoretical data

Quantitative data (measurement and experimentation)

5. Practical considerations

Rules of thumb based on experience or convention

6. Design instrumentalities

Process of design

GSBDUBMT #PDDBSB ThF NPTU DPNQFMMJOH BSHVNFOU GPS UIF QPTTJCJMJUZ PG B DPNQMFY TZTUFNTTDJFODF#P,JTUIBUJUBMSFBEZFYJTUTThJTCPPLIBTDJUFESFQSFTFOUBUJWFQJFDFTPGUIJT#P, XIJDIIBTCFFOBDDVNVMBUJOHGPSTFWFSBMEFDBEFT.VMUJQMFEJTDJQMJOFTIBWFDPOUSJCVUFEUPUIF $4#P, JODMVEJOHQIZTJDT CJPMPHZ QTZDIPMPHZ TPDJPMPHZ PSHBOJ[BUJPOBMUIFPSZ BOETZTUFNT UIFPSZ

Value of BoK Guide *OHFOFSBM UIFWBMVFPGBHVJEFUPB#P,JTUXPGPME'JSTU JUQPJOUTUPUIFQSJNBSZFMFNFOUTPG LOPXMFEHF JO B EJTDJQMJOF PS ﬁFME PG TUVEZ 4FDPOE JU QSPWJEFT BO PSHBOJ[JOH GSBNFXPSL UIBU JOUFHSBUFTUIFFMFNFOUTBOEHJWFTBDPNQSFIFOTJPOPGUIFXIPMF"HVJEFUPBNBUVSF#P,SFﬂFDUT LOPXOFMFNFOUTBOEBDPNNPOPSHBOJ[JOHGSBNFXPSL"HVJEFUPBOJNNBUVSF#P, TVDIBTUIBU GPS$4& EPFTOPUIBWFBDPNQMFUFTFUPGLOPXMFEHFFMFNFOUTPSBDPNNPOPSHBOJ[JOHGSBNFXPSL *OUIJTDBTF BGSBNFXPSLDBOCFQSPQPTFE BOEXJMMIBWFTPNFFNQUZLOPXMFEHFTMPUT#VUJGUIF GSBNFXPSLJTXFMMDPODFJWFE JUDBOIFMQTIBQFUIFUIJOLJOHBCPVUUIFﬁFMEBOEJUTEFWFMPQNFOU JOUFSNTPGCPUIQSBDUJDFBOESFTFBSDI4VDIBGSBNFXPSLDBOQSFJOUFHSBUFUIFﬁFMEBOEJEFOUJGZ NJTTJOHFMFNFOUT BOETIPXXIFSFUIPTFFMFNFOUTﬁUJOUIFMBSHFSQJDUVSFThF#P,HVJEFDBOUIFO CFBOFOBCMFSPSGBDJMJUBUPSPGHPPEQSBDUJDFBOEGVSUIFSEFWFMPQNFOUPGUIe ﬁFME ThF4&#P,JTBNJYPGNBOZNBUVSFEJTDJQMJOFTBOEBGFXJNNBUVSFPOFTThFNBUVSJUZ PGUIFPWFSBMM4&#P,JTEJTDVTTFEJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi$VSSFOU4UBUFPG4&#P,w0OFHPBM PGUIFEFTJHOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFJTUPEFﬁOFBTUSVDUVSFUIBUBQQMJFTUPBMMUIF4&EJTDJQMJOFT BOE EPNBJOT FYQMPJUT UIF LOPXMFEHF PG NBUVSF EJTDJQMJOFT BOE IFMQT TIBQF UIF LOPXMFEHF PGJNNBUVSFEJTDJQMJOFTThFNPEFMTQBDFEPFTOPUDMBJNUPCFBUBMMDPNQMFUFJOUFSNTPGBO

Commonization

O

183

PSHBOJ[JOHTUSVDUVSFPGUIF4&CPEZPGLOPXMFEHFNPSFTUSVDUVSFDBOCFBOEOFFETUPCFBEEFE GPSUIBUQVSQPTFThFNPEFMTQBDFEPFTDMBJNUPQSPWJEFJNQPSUBOUFMFNFOUTPGBOPSHBOJ[JOH TUSVDUVSFPG4&NPEFMT BOEDMBJNTUIBUUIFCPEZPG4&LOPXMFEHFDBOCFDBQUVSFEJONPEFMT UIBUQPQVMBUFUIBUTUSVDUVSF4UBUFEEJﬀFSFOUMZ UIFNPEFMTQBDFJTDBQBCMFPGIPMEJOHUIFDPN QMFUF4&#P, BOEQBSUJBMMZTUSVDUVSJOHJUBTTVDI BOEQSPWJEFTUIFUPPMTGPSBEEJUJPOBM#P, TUSVDUVSFBTOFFEFE

Contributors to SE BoK 'JHVSFTIPXTIPXUIF#P,TPGWBSJPVTEJTDJQMJOFTDPOUSJCVUFUPBOFOWJTJPOFE4&#P,7BSJPVT TDJFODFTDPOUSJCVUFUPBOVNCFSPGFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOFT BOECPUIUIFTDJFODFTBOEFOHJOFFSJOH EJTDJQMJOFTDPOUSJCVUFUPUIF4&#P,ThFTDJFODFTTIPXOIFSFBSFBTVCTFUPGUIFNPSFDPNQMFUF MJTUPGEJTDJQMJOFTTIPXOJO5BCMF ThFEJTDVTTJPOJOUIJTTFDUJPOJTPO4&#P,SBUIFSUIBO4&4#P,CFDBVTFUIFVMUJNBUFHPBMJT UPIBWFBCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFUIBUTVQQPSUT4&ThFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFO4&4BOE4&JOUIJTDPOUFYU JTUIBUBMMUIFEJTDJQMJOFTUIBUTVQQPSUPSDPOUSJCVUFUP4&4 BTJEFOUJﬁFEJO5BCMF NBZCFTBJE UPDPOUSJCVUFUPUIF4&4#P,ThPTFBSFSFQSFTFOUFECZUIFEBTIFECPYFTJO'JHVSFThFEJTDJ QMJOFTUIBUDPOUSJCVUFUPUIF4&#P,JODMVEFUIF4&4#P, EBTIFEMJOFCPYFT BOEUIFFOHJOFFSJOH PSiBDUVBMJ[BUJPOwEJTDJQMJOFT TPMJEMJOFCPYFT

Current State of SE BoK $IBQUFSBTTFTTFEUIFSFBEJOFTTPG4&LOPXMFEHFUPCFJODPSQPSBUFEJOUPUIFNPEFMTQBDFThJT TFDUJPOCSJFﬂZBTTFTTFTUIFNBUVSJUZBOEDPNQMFUFOFTTPG4&LOPXMFEHF

Organization management BoK SWEBoK

SE BoK EABoK QMBoK

Computer science, discrete math, linguistics

PMBoK

CSBoK TSEBoK Physics, analytical math

Organizational theory, industrial engineering, operations research, economics, sociology, psychology, political science...

Complexity theory, chaos theory, dynamical systems, nonlinear systems, quantum theory, biology... Systems science; math, probability, statistics; modeling

Key: BoK = Body of Knowledge; CS = Complex Systems; EA = Enterprise Architecture; PM = Project Management; QM = Quality Management; SWE = Software Engineering; TSE = Traditional Systems Engineering

Figure 7.8

Contributing elements to SE BoK.

184

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

4&#P,JTMFTTNBUVSFUIBOUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOFT0OFDIBMMFOHFJTUIFFYUSFNF NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZOBUVSFPG4& XIJDINFBOTUIFLOPXMFEHFJTIJHIMZEJTUSJCVUFE"OPUIFSDIBM MFOHFJTUIFDVSSFOUFYQBOTJPOUP$4&BOEUPBMBSHFSSBOHFPGTDBMFTThFLOPXMFEHFJOUIFTFBSFBT UPEBUFIBTMJNJUFEWJTJCJMJUZUP4&QSBDUJUJPOFST BOEIBTOPUCFFOJODPSQPSBUFEPSJOUFHSBUFEJOUP UIF4&#P,*UBMTPJTUPTPNFFYUFOUJNNBUVSF FH OBOPUFDIOPMPHZ *OBEEJUJPO XJUIJO54& UIFSFJTBTJHOJﬁDBOUEJﬀFSFODFCFUXFFOUIFLJOEPGJOGPSNBUJPOJO USBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLTBOEUIBUJO4&IBOECPPLTPSiCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFwDPNQFO EJVNTTVDIBT*/$04&T4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH)BOECPPL */$04& BOEUIFJS(VJEFUPUIF 4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH#PEZPG,OPXMFEHF (4&#P, */$04& ThFEJﬀFSFODFJTCBTJDBMMZ UIBUUIFUSBEJUJPOBMEJTDJQMJOFTFNQIBTJ[FQSPQFSUJFTBOEDPOWFOUJPOBMEFTJHOTPGUIFTZTUFNTPS QSPEVDUTUIFZBSFFOHJOFFSJOH XIJMFUIFMBUUFSFNQIBTJ[FUIFQSPDFTTPGFOHJOFFSJOHThBUJT B USBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFHJWFTUIFNFTTBHFiThFTFBSFUIFDPOWFOUJPOBMEFTJHOT BOEEFTJHOQBSBNFUFSTGPSUIJTDMBTTPGTZTUFNTwXIJMFUIF54&CPEZPGLOPXMFEHFHJWFTUIFNFT TBHFiThFTFBSFUIFQSPDFTTTUFQTGPSDSFBUJOHBEFTJHOGPSBMM4&TZTUFNTw ThF.04&4NPEFMTQBDFIBTBQMBDFGPSNPEFMTPGBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTFTCVUUIFHPBMJTUP CFPSJFOUFENPSFMJLFUIFUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLUZQFPGNPEFMTHFOFSBMEFTJHOTBOE QSPQFSUJFTPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSFECZ4&ThJTHPBMSFﬂFDUTUIFCFMJFGUIBUUIFEJﬀFSFODFJOFNQIBTJT CFUXFFOUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOH NPEFMTPGQSPEVDFETZTUFNT BOE4& NPEFMTPGUIFFOHJOFFSJOH QSPDFTT JTOPUBSFﬂFDUJPOPGFTTFOUJBMEJﬀFSFODFTCFUXFFOUIFEJTDJQMJOFT CVUJTSBUIFSBSFﬂFDUJPO PGUIFNBUVSJUZMFWFMT8IFO4&CFDPNFTNPSFNBUVSF JUXJMMGPDVTNPSFPOTZTUFNNPEFMTBOE MFTTPOFOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTNPEFMT *OTVN DPOTJEFSBCMFLOPXMFEHFJOUIF4&TFUPGEJTDJQMJOFTEPFTFYJTU#VUQBSUTPGJUBSFJNNB UVSF BOEJUIBTOPUCFFODPMMFDUFEPSJOUFHSBUFE'SPNUIFWJFXQPJOUPGUIF4&PGUIFGVUVSF NVDI XPSLJTSFRVJSFEUPﬁOEBOEDPMMFDUUIF4&LOPXMFEHFJOBMMPGJUTEJTDJQMJOFTBOEJOUFHSBUFUIBUJOUPPOF DPNQPTJUF4&#P, JOQSFQBSBUJPOGPSUIFFRVBMMZDIBMMFOHJOHTUFQPGCSJOHJOHUIFLOPXMFEHFJOUPB GPSNTVJUBCMFGPSUIFNPEFMTQBDF0OFQSJNBSZHPBMPG.04&4BOEUIJTCPPLJTUPQSPWJEFBGPVOEB UJPOUIBUGBDJMJUBUFTUIFJOUFHSBUJPOPGUIFTFBSFBT BOEUPQSPWJEFBLOPXMFEHFDPOUBJOFSJOUIFGPSN PGUIFNPEFMTQBDFUIBUXJMMGBDJMJUBUFUIFJSVOJﬁDBUJPOJOUPPOFDPIFSFOU4&#P,PGUIFGVUVSF

Summary of Commonization-Related Processes ThFCBTJDQSPDFTTFTJOUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOBSFJOIFSJUBODF UPQEPXO CPUUPNVQ DBU FHPSJ[BUJPO JOTUBOUJBUJPO HFOFSBMJ[BUJPO BOETQFDJBMJ[BUJPO8FEJTDVTTFETPNFPGUIFTFFBSMJFS CVUTVNNBSJ[FFBDIPGUIFNIFSF *OIFSJUBODF1SPDFTTCZXIJDIBTVCLJOEPCUBJOTBMMUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGJUTQBSFOULJOE$BO BMTPIBWFWBSJBUJPOT TVDIBTNVMUJQMFJOIFSJUBODFTVCLJOEJOIFSJUTGSPNNVMUJQMFQBSFOU LJOET 5PQEPXO1SPDFTTJOXIJDIUIFIJHIFSMFWFMFOUJUZJTEFﬁOFEﬁSTU BOEUIFOUIFMPXFSMFWFM FOUJUZJTEFﬁOFE&YBNQMFTBSFJOTUBOUJBUJPOBOETQFDJBMJ[BUJPO #PUUPNVQ1SPDFTTJOXIJDIUIFMPXFSMFWFMFOUJUZJTEFﬁOFEﬁSTU BOEUIFOUIFIJHIFSMFWFM FOUJUZJTEFﬁOFE&YBNQMFTBSFDBUFHPSJ[BUJPOBOEHFOFSBMJ[BUJPO $BUFHPSJ[BUJPO1SPDFTTJOXIJDIBDBUFHPSZJTEFﬁOFECZBCTUSBDUJPOGSPNUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PGPOFPSNPSFJOEJWJEVBMT *OTUBOUJBUJPO1SPDFTTJOXIJDIBOJOEJWJEVBMJTEFﬁOFEGSPNUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGBEFﬁOFE DBUFHPSZ

Commonization

O

185

(FOFSBMJ[BUJPO1SPDFTTJOXIJDIBLJOEJTEFﬁOFECZBCTUSBDUJPOGSPNUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPG POFPSNPSFTVCLJOET 4QFDJBMJ[BUJPO1SPDFTTJOXIJDIUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGBLJOEBSFBEEFEUPPSTQFDJBMJ[FE *OTPNFDBTFT NVMUJQMFQSPDFTTFTBSFVTFEUPHFUIFS'PSFYBNQMF UIFGVMMEFﬁOJUJPOPGBTVCLJOE VTFTJOIFSJUBODFBOEUIFOTQFDJBMJ[BUJPO

References "CSBO " +8.PPSF 1#PVSRVF BOE3%VQVJT &ET (VJEFUPUIF4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH#PEZPG ,OPXMFEHF 7FSTJPO-PT"MBNJUPT $"*&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ1SFTT "ULJOTPO $BOE5,àIOFThe FTTFODFPGNVMUJMFWFMNFUBNPEFMJOH*O1SPDFFEJOHTPGUIFUI*OU$POG POUIF6niﬁed .PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF .(PHPMMBBOE$,PCSZO &ET

-FDUVSF/PUFTJO$PNQVUFS 4DJFODF o "ULJOTPO $BOE5,àIOF.PEFMESJWFOEFWFMPQNFOUBNFUBNPEFMJOHGPVOEBUJPO*&&&4PGUXBSF o #PDDBSB /.PEFMJOH$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT/FX:PSL4QSJOHFS7FSMBH #PSHJEB "BOE3#SBDINBO$PODFQUVBMNPEFMJOHXJUIEFTDSJQUJPOMPHJDT*OThe %FTDSJQUJPO-PHJD )BOECPPLTheorZ *NQMFNFOUBUJPO BOE"QQMJDBUJPOT #BBEFS ' %$BMWBOFTF %.D(VJOFTT % /BSEJ BOE11BUFM4DIOFJEFS &ET$BNCSJEHF 6,$BNCSJEHF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT $$3"$PNNPO$SJUFSJBGPS*OGPSNBUJPO5FDIOPMPHZ4FDVSJUZ&WBMVBUJPO1BSU*OUSPEVDUJPOBOE HFOFSBMNPEFM7FSTJPO3FWJTJPO$PNNPO$SJUFSJB3FDPHOJUJPO"HSFFNFOU4FQUFNCFS $$.# IUUQXXXDPNNPODSJUFSJBQPSUBMPSHUIFDDIUNM "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

$$3"B$PNNPO$SJUFSJBGPS*OGPSNBUJPO5FDIOPMPHZ4FDVSJUZ&WBMVBUJPO1BSU4FDVSJUZGVODUJPOBMDPNQP OFOUT4FQUFNCFS7FSTJPO3FWJTJPO$PNNPO$SJUFSJB3FDPHOJUJPO"HSFFNFOU4FQUFNCFS$$.# IUUQXXXDPNNPODSJUFSJBQPSUBMPSHUIFDDIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

$$3" C $PNNPO $SJUFSJB GPS *OGPSNBUJPO 5FDIOPMPHZ 4FDVSJUZ &WBMVBUJPO 1BSU 4FDVSJUZ BTTVS BODF DPNQPOFOUT 4FQUFNCFS 7FSTJPO 3FWJTJPO $PNNPO $SJUFSJB 3FDPHOJUJPO "HSFFNFOU 4FQUFNCFS $$.# IUUQXXXDPNNPODSJUFSJBQPSUBMPSHUIFDDIUNM "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

(BNBUJÏ " $#SVOFUUF 3%FMBNBSF 5(BVUJFS BOE+15BMQJO"NPEFMJOHQBSBEJHNGPSJOUF HSBUFE NPEVMBS BWJPOJDT EFTJHO 1SPD OE &630.*$30 $POG PO 4PGUXBSF &OHJOFFSJOH BOE "EWBODFE"QQMJDBUJPOT &630.*$304&""

Qo (.&The (FOFSJD.PEFMJOH&OWJSPONFOUIUUQXXXJTJTWBOEFSCJMUFEV1SPKFDUTHNF "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

)ZCFSUTPO %"VOJGPSNDPNQPOFOUNPEFMJOHTQBDF*OGPSNBUJDB o */$04&(VJEFUPUIF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH#PEZPG,OPXMFEHF(4&#P,*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PVODJM PO4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOHIUUQHTFCPLJODPTFPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

*/$04&*/$04&4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH)BOECPPL W4FBUUMF 8"*/$04& *OUFSOBUJPOBM$PVODJM PO4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH +BDPCTPO * .(SJTT BOE1+POTTPO4PGUXBSF3FVTF"SDIJUFDUVSF 1SPDFTTBOE0SHBOJ[BUJPOGPS#VTJOFTT 4VDDFTT/FX:PSL"$.1SFTT"EEJTPO8FTMFZ ,MJS ('BDFUTPG4ZTUFNT4DJFODF OEFE/FX:PSL,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1MFOVN1VCMJTIFST ,àIOF 56OEFSTUBOEJOHNFUBNPEFMJOH5VUPSJBM *OU$POG4PGUXBSF&OH o.BZ 4U-PVJT .0 -FEFD[J " ..BSPUJ "#BLBZ (,BSTBJ +(BSSFUU $ThPNBTPO (/PSETUSPN +4QSJOLMF BOE17PMHZFTJ The HFOFSJD NPEFMJOH FOWJSPONFOU *O 1SPD *&&& 8PSLTIPQ PO *OUFMMJHFOU 4JHOBM 1SPDFTTJOH IUUQXXXJTJTWanderbilt.edu/sites/default/ﬁles/GME2000OvFSWJFXQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

.BOEFST &+ (#JTXBT /.BIBEFWBO BOE(,BSTBJ$PNQPOFOUPSJFOUFENPEFMJOHPGIZCSJE EZOBNJDTZTUFNTVTJOHUIFHFOFSJDNPEFMJOHFOWJSPONFOU'PVSUIBOEThirE*OUFSOBUJPOBM8PSLTIPQ PO.PEFM#BTFE%FWFMPQNFOUPG$PNQVUFS#BTFE4ZTUFNTBOE.PEFM#BTFE.FUIPEPMPHJFTGPS1FSWBTJWF BOE&NCFEEFE4PGUXBSF

186

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

.BSUFMMJ .*OUSPEVDUJPOUP%JTDSFUF%ZOBNJDBM4ZTUFNTBOE$IBPT/FX:PSL8JMFZ .BZ 34JNQMFNBUIFNBUJDBMNPEFMTXJUIWFSZDPNQMJDBUFEEZOBNJDT/BUVSF 7PM +VOF .JMMFS +-JWJOH4ZTUFNT/JXPU $06OJWFSTJUZ1SFTTPG$PMPSBEP 0SJHJOBMMZQVCMJTIFE

0.( .FUB 0CKFDU 'BDJMJUZ .0' $PSF 4peciﬁcation, 7FSTJPO GPSNBM +BOVBSZ IUUQXXXPNHPSHEPDTGPSNBMQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

1BSOBT % 0O UIF DSJUFSJB UP CF VTFE JO EFDPNQPTJOH TZTUFNT JOUP NPEVMFT $PNNVO "$. o 4DIJOEFM #B3FRVJSFNFOUTTUBUFNFOUTBSFUSBOTGFSGVODUJPOTBOJOTJHIUGSPNNPEFMCBTFETZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH1SPD*/$04&4ZNQ +VMZ 4DIJOEFM # C 1BUUFSOCBTFE TZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH BO FYUFOTJPO PG NPEFMCBTFE 4& */$04& 4ZNQ 5FDIOJDBM*OGPSNBUJPO&YDIBOHF4FTTJPO +VMZ 7JODFOUJ 88IBU&OHJOFFST,OPXBOE)PXThey ,OPX*U"OBMZUJDBM4UVEJFTGSPN"FSPOBVUJDBM)JTUPSZ #BMUJNPSe, MD: The JPIOT)PQLJOT6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT 8JLJQFEJB -PSFO[ BUUSBDUPS IUUQFOXJLJQFEJBPSHXJLJ-PSFO[@BUUSBDUPS "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

Chapter 8

Conceptualization Coauthored by Leo Obrst

Highest level system

Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

Deﬁne need

Indivisible Unit

Composition

Systems taxonomy Modeling scope *OQSFWJPVTDIBQUFSTXFIBWFTBJEUIBUTZTUFNT 1 SE Application Domains (D1...Dn) Collective actualization space FOHJOFFSJOH 4& EFﬁOFTNPEFMTUIBUBSFJOUFSOBM D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn Problem space Model Space BOEFYUFSOBM BEESFTTNVMUJQMFMFWFMTPGDPNQPTJ 2a TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b All SE Traditional systems Complex systems UJPO BSFHFOFSBMPSTQFDJﬁD BOEEFﬁOFDBUFHPSJFT 3a TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b application domains... Traditional Complex PSJOEJWJEVBMT#VUIPXEPXFTUBUFPSSFQSFTFOU 4 Complex TS is special case TVDINPEFMT XIBUEPUIFNPEFMTNFBO BOEIPX 5Traditional Characteristics of all SE systems and Complex EPXFDPNNVOJDBUFBCPVUNPEFMTJOTVDIBDMFBS 6 Traditional Characteristics of all systems Deployment Solution/system space XBZUIBUXFBDIJFWFUIFTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHPG TQFDJﬁDBUJPOT ThFiXFwIFSFSFGFSTUPBMMBHFOU JOUFSBDUJPOT JOBOZDPNCJOBUJPOPGIVNBOTBOENBDIJOFT ThBUJTUIFGPDVTPGUIJTDIBQUFSThFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFJTDPO DFSOFEXJUIUIFDPOUFOU MBOHVBHFT BOENFBOJOHPGNPEFMT ThFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVNJODMVEFTMBOHVBHFT IPXBOEVMUJNBUFMZXIBUUPSFQSFTFOU BOEDPODFQUTPSSFGFSFOUTGSPNUIFQSPCMFNEPNBJO XIJDISBOHFTPWFSTVCKFDUBSFBTTVDIBTBFSP TQBDF USBOTQPSUBUJPO DPOTUSVDUJPO BOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOT*UBMTPJODMVEFTDPOTJEFSBUJPOTTVDIBTUIF EFTJHO BOBMZTJT PSNPEFMJOHDPOTUSVDUTUIBUXJMMCFOFDFTTBSZUPTPMWFUIPTFNPEFMJOHQSPCMFNT JOUIFTPMVUJPOTQBDF UPUIFEFHSFFPGWFSJTJNJMJUVEFOFDFTTBSZThFIFUFSPHFOFPVTTVCKFDUNBUUFS IJHIMJHIUTUIFDPNQMJDBUJOHGBDUUIBUUIFNPEFMTQBDFPG4&JTGVOEBNFOUBMMZNVMUJMJOHVBMBOE NVMUJPOUPMPHJDBM BOENVTUJNQMJDJUMZEFBMXJUIUIFOFDFTTBSZNBQQJOHGSPNUIFSFQSFTFOUBUJPO PGUIFQSPCMFNUPUIFSFQSFTFOUBUJPOPGUIFTPMVUJPOTQBDF ThFEJTDVTTJPOJOUIJTDIBQUFSVTFTDPODFQUTQSFTFOUFEJO$IBQUFSTBOEThFNVMUJMFWFM XIPMFoQBSUTUSVDUVSFTJO$IBQUFSBSFVTFEUPTIPXUIFTUSVDUVSBMDPOUFYUGPSNVDIPGUIFNVMUJ QMJDJUZPGPOUPMPHJFTBOEMBOHVBHFTJO4&ThFDBUFHPSZIJFSBSDIZDPODFQUJO$IBQUFSJTEJTDVTTFE JOUIJTDIBQUFSJOUFSNTPGIPXEPNBJODBUFHPSZIJFSBSDIJFTBSFHFOFSBUFEBOEVTFE Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

e

m

Ti

Produce solution

Satisfy need

187

188

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Concepts and Deﬁnitions ThFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFFNCPEJFTBOVNCFSPGSFMBUFEDPODFQUTUIBU OFFEUPCFVOEFSTUPPECFGPSFQSPDFFEJOHJOUPUIFTVCTUBODFPGUIFDIBQUFSThFUFSNTXFVTFGPS LFZDPODFQUTBSFEPNBJO VOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTF 6%

DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO POUPMPHZ MBOHVBHF BOE TFNBOUJDT$PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOJTBLFZDPODFQUUIBUXFDIPTFBTUIFPWFSBMMOBNFPGUIFDIBQUFS 8FEFﬁOFUIFUFSNTBOEIPXUIFZSFMBUFUPFBDIPUIFSBOEUPUIFQSFWJPVTMZEFﬁOFEDPODFQUT PGNPEFMBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOThFEFﬁOJUJPOTHJWFOIFSFBSFBOBNBMHBNPGEFﬁOJUJPOTGSPNTFWFSBM TPVSDFT JODMVEJOH%BDPOUB 0CSTU BOE4NJUI (VBSJOP

)POEFSJDI BOE .BTPMPFUBM %PNBJO"QQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOPSBSFBPGLOPXMFEHF PSTVCKFDUBSFB BTTPDJBUFEXJUI4&*OUIFQSFT FOUDPOUFYU UIFTBMJFOUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDJTUIBUBEPNBJOIBTBDPNNVOJUZPGBHFOUT QFPQMF TPGUXBSF FUD UIBUTIBSFTPNFEFHSFFPGLOPXMFEHFPGUIFEPNBJOXJUINPSFTIBSJOHJOBNBUVSFEPNBJO /PUF %PNBJOT JEFOUJﬁFE JO UIF BJSDSBGU FYBNQMF HJWFO CFMPX JO UIF TFDUJPO FOUJUMFE i4FUVQ &YBNQMFwJODMVEFDPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGUTZTUFNTBOEBMMUIFJOUFSOBMBOETVQQPSUJOHEPNBJOTEJT DVTTFEJO$IBQUFSTBOEBWJPOJDT FUDThJTMJTUJMMVTUSBUFTUIBUUIFTDPQFPGEPNBJOTBOEUIF SFMBUJPOTCFUXFFOUIFNBSFOPUTJNQMF'PSFYBNQMF EPNBJOTDBOPWFSMBQ BOEPOFEPNBJOTVDI BT4&DBOCFBDPNQPTJUFPGPUIFSEPNBJOT"EPNBJODBOBMTPCFWFSZHFOFSBM BTBDPOUFYUGPS HFOFSBMNPEFMTThFNPTUHFOFSBMEPNBJOTBTTPDJBUFEXJUI4&BSFQSPCBCMZTZTUFNTTDJFODFBOE NBUIFNBUJDTCFDBVTFUIFJSNPEFMTBCTUSBDUBXBZUIFEJﬀFSFODFTCFUXFFOPUIFSEPNBJOT 6OJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTF 6% 4FUPGFOUJUJFTPSPCKFDUTUIBUBSFEFFNFEUPFYJTUJOBEPNBJOThFTF DBOCFQIZTJDBM TVDIBTBJSGSBNFBOEFOHJOFFOUJUJFT PSDPODFQUVBM TVDIBTTPGUXBSFBOENBUI FNBUJDBMFOUJUJFTThFZDBOCFJOEJWJEVBMJOTUBODFT PSDBUFHPSJFT*OBMPHJDBMTFOTF UIFTFPCKFDUT BSFUIPTFUIBUDBOCFRVBOUJﬁFEPWFS2VBOUJﬁFSTBSFTJNQMZPQFSBUPSTUIBUCJOETQFDJﬁDLJOET PGWBSJBCMFT*GXFTBZi"MMXPNFOBSFIVNBO wUIBUJTEJﬀFSFOUGSPNi"MMIVNBOTBSFXPNFO w PSi"MMIVNBOTXPSLBU*#. wPSi4PNFIVNBOTBSFXPNFO wPSi4PNFIVNBOTXPSLBU*#.w ThPTFiTPNFwBOEiBMMwDPOTUSVDUTBSFRVBOUJﬁFSTUIFZBSFPQFSBUPSTUIBUCJOEWBSJBCMFTUIBUSBOHF PWFSEJﬀFSFOUTVCEPNBJOTPSDBUFHPSJFTTVDIBTIVNBOT NFO XPNFO FUD4PNFPGUIFTFTUBUF NFOUTXJUIRVBOUJﬁFSTBSFBQQSPQSJBUFCFDBVTFUIFZSFQSFTFOUUIFNFBOJOHPGUIFSFBMXPSMEFH i"MMIVNBOTBSFNPSUBMw4PNFBSFOPUi"MMXPNFOXPSLBU*#.w4PUIFVOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTF JOWPMWFTCPUIUIFJOTUBODFTBOEUIFDBUFHPSJFTPGUIPTFJOTUBODFTUIBUBSFBQQSPQSJBUFGPSUIFNPEFM XFBSFDSFBUJOH $PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO"OJOGPSNBMWJFXPGDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOJTEJTDVTTFEﬁSTU GPMMPXFECZEJTDVT TJPOPGBNPSFGPSNBMWJFX *OGPSNBM*OUIJTWJFX DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPONFBOTUIBUBQFSTPOIBTBOJOGPSNBMPSOBÕWFDPO DFQUJPOPGUIFQBSUPGUIFXPSMEUIBUIFTIFJTJOUFSFTUFEJONPEFMJOH'SPNUIBUJNQMJDJU iJO UIFIFBEw OPUJPOPGUIFQPSUJPOPGJOUFSFTUPGUIFXPSME POFUSJFTUPMBZEPXOTPNFUFOFUTPS TUBUFNFOUTBCPVUXIBUUIBUQPSUJPOPGUIFXPSMENFBOTUPUIFQFSTPO"OFYBNQMFJTGBNJMJBM SFMBUJPOT*OJUJBMMZ POFNJHIUDPOTJEFSQBSFOUT GBUIFST NPUIFST DIJMESFO TPOT BOEEBVHIUFST 1BSFOUTIBWFDIJMESFO'BUIFSTBOENPUIFSTBSFTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOTPSQBSUJDVMBSSPMFTPG1BSFOU $IJMESFO BSF TPOT PS EBVHIUFST JF TQFDJBMJ[BUJPOT PS SPMFTPG $IJME 8IFO XF UBML BCPVU iSPMFTwXFBSFGPDVTJOHJOQBSUJDVMBSPOSPMFTJOSFMBUJPOTIJQT TPNFPGXIJDIBSFQFSNBOFOU BOETPNFPGXIJDIBSFOPU"GBUIFSXJMMBMXBZTCFBGBUIFS BOEJOUIFGBUIFSSPMF UPIJTDIJME "DIJMEXJMMBMXBZTCFJOUIFDIJMESPMFJOUIFSFMBUJPOTIJQUPIJTIFSGBUIFS4PGBS TPHPPE#VU

Conceptualization

O

189

DPOTJEFSPUIFSTFNBOUJDOPUJPOTBCPVUUIFSFBMXPSMEPGUIFGBNJMZ TPNFPGXIJDIBSFTPPCWJ PVTUPIVNBOTUIBUUIFZBSFOPUFWFODPOTJEFSFE$BOBQBSFOUCFBQBSFOUPGIJNTFMG $BOB QBSFOUCFBDIJMEPGIJNTFMG $BOZPVCFZPVSPXOHSBOEQBSFOU *OUIFSFBMXPSME PSUIJTWFSZ TJNQMFTOBQTIPUPGUIFSFBMXPSME

PGDPVSTFUIFTFSFMBUJPOTIJQTEPOPUIPME 'PSNBMThFJOGPSNBMDPODFQUTEFTDSJCFEBCPWFDBOCFSFﬁOFEXIJMFTUJMMJNQMJDJU"NPSF GPSNBMDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPGBEPNBJOUZQJDBMMZJOWPMWFTDPOTJEFSBUJPOPGNPSFBTQFDUTPGUIF EPNBJO UPJODMVEFBOZPGUIFGPMMPXJOHUIFVOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTFPGBEPNBJO UIFSFMBUJPOT BNPOHUIFFOUJUJFTPGUIBUEPNBJOUIFQSPQFSUJFTBOEQSPQFSUZWBMVFTPGUIFFOUJUJFTUIFGVOD UJPOTPGBOEQSPDFTTFTJOWPMWJOHUIFFOUJUJFTBOEDPOTUSBJOUTPOBOESVMFTJOWPMWJOHUIFFOUJUJFT ThFDBUFHPSJ[JOHPGEPNBJOFOUJUJFTJTBDPNNPOFMFNFOUPGNPSFGPSNBMDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO /PUF0ODFBDBUFHPSZIBTCFFOFTUBCMJTIFECZUIFQSPDFTTPGDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO UIBUDBUFHPSZJT EFFNFEUPFYJTUJOUIFEPNBJOUIJTJTUIFSFBTPOB6%JODMVEFTDBUFHPSJFTBTXFMMBTJOTUBODFT 0OUPMPHZ%FTDSJQUJPOPSNPEFMPGBDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOEUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPGUFSNTVTFEJOUIF EFTDSJQUJPOThFTFBSFUIFTBNFFOUJUJFTBOESFMBUJPOTJOUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO CVUUIFZBSFNPEFMFE JOBNPEFMJOHMBOHVBHF BOEHJWFONPSFPSMFTTQSFDJTFMPHJDBMDIBSBDUFSJ[BUJPOJOUIBUMBOHVBHF*G UIFNPEFMJOHPSDPOUFOUMBOHVBHFJTCBTFEPOBGPSNBMMPHJD UIFOUIFSFTVMUJOHNPEFM POUPMPHZ JT NPSFMJLFMZUPBDDVSBUFMZSFﬂFDUUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPGUIFVTFSThBUJT JUJTTFNBOUJDBMMZDPSSFDU PSTFNBOUJDBMMZEFTDSJCFTUIFQPSUJPOPGUIFXPSMEUIBUUIFNPEFMFSJOUFOEFEUPEFTDSJCF ThFEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFODPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOEPOUPMPHZJTUIFSFGPSFUIBUDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO JTQBSUJBMMZJNQMJDJUJOUIFNJOETPGPOFPSNPSFQFPQMFJOUIFEPNBJOXIJMFPOUPMPHZJTGVMMZ FYQMJDJU BOE DBQUVSFE JO TPNF GPSN UIBU DBO CF DPNNVOJDBUFE ThF USBEJUJPOBM QIJMPTPQIJD OPUJPOPGPOUPMPHZJTDMPTFSUPUIFEFﬁOJUJPOIFSFPGDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO CVUUIFUSBEJUJPOBMOPUJPO EPFTOPUNBLFBEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOJNQMJDJUBOEFYQMJDJUThFEFﬁOJUJPOTIFSFBSFNPSFPSMFTT DPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIFOPUJPOTPGDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOEPOUPMPHZBTEFWFMPQFEBOEVTFEJOUIFFOHJ OFFSJOHDPNNVOJUZ pXIJDIUBLFTBNPSFGPSNBMBQQSPBDIJOPSEFSUPFOBCMFDPNQVUFSTUPNBOJQ VMBUFBOEJOUFSQSFUTFNBOUJDTBOEPOUPMPHJFT ThFSFBSFPUIFSEJTUJODUJPOTCFUXFFOPOUPMPHZBTVTFEJOUSBEJUJPOBMQIJMPTPQIZBOEBTVTFE JOFOHJOFFSJOH1PMJBOE0CSTU FYQMPSFUIFTFEJTUJODUJPOTThFZVTFUIFUFSNiPOUPMPHZ@Uw UPNFBOPOUPMPHZBTUFDIOJDBMPSFOHJOFFSJOHQSPEVDU TPNFUJNFTDBMMFEiMJUUMFPPOUPMPHZwBOE iPOUPMPHZ@DwUPNFBOPOUPMPHZJOUIFTFOTFPGQIJMPTPQIJDBMDBUFHPSJBMBOBMZTJT TPNFUJNFTDBMMFE iCJH0POUPMPHZw0OUPMPHZBOETDJFODFXPSLIBOEJOIBOE4DJFODFUSJFTUPﬁOEPVUXIBUJTSFBM BOEHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOTBCPVUXIBUJTSFBM BOEﬁOBMMZUIFPSJFTBCPVUXIBUJTSFBM0OUPMPHZPSHBOJ[FT BOEDMBTTJﬁFTUIFSFTVMUTGSPNUIBUXIJDITDJFODFEJTDPWFSTBCPVUSFBMJUZ0OUPMPHZ@UJTBOFOHJ OFFSJOHQSPEVDUUIBUVTFTPOUPMPHZ@D CVUBUUIFTBNFUJNFJUQSPWJEFTEPNBJONPEFMJOHUPJOGPS NBUJPOUFDIOPMPHZ0OUIFPUIFSIBOE POUPMPHZ@UNBZDSFBUFDBUFHPSJFTBCPVUDPNNPOTFOTF SFBMNTBCPVUXIJDIOFJUIFSTDJFODFOPSPOUPMPHZ@DIBTBTZFUBOZUIJOHUPTBZ -BOHVBHF 4ZTUFN PG TZNCPMT BOE SVMFT GPS DPNQPTJUJPO TUSVDUVSF BOE JOUFSQSFUBUJPO UIBU JT VTFEUPDPNNVOJDBUFCFUXFFOEJﬀFSFOUQBSUJFT*OHFOFSBM UIFTZNCPMTDBOCFWJTVBM BVEJP PS UBDUJMF7JTVBMTZNCPMTDBOCFUFYU HSBQIJDBM PSNBUIFNBUJDBMMPHJDBM"MMMBOHVBHFTIBWFCPUIB ThJTJTXIZ(SVCFS

GPSFYBNQMF JOJUJBMMZEFﬁOFEBOPOUPMPHZBT“BTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGBDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO” )FUIPVHIUUIBUJOGPSNBUJPOUFDIOPMPHJTUTJOUIFJSVTBHFHFOFSBMMZVOEFSTUPPEUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPG“TQFDJﬁcBUJPO” GSPNUIFQSBDUJDFPGTQFDJGZJOHEFTJHOT TDIFNBT FUD p8FTBZNPSFPSMFTTDPOTJTUFOUCFDBVTFUIFOPUJPOTPGDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOEPOUPMPHZBSFPOMZQBSUJBMMZNBUVSF BOETUJMMFWPMWJOHJOUIFFOHJOFFSJOHDPNNVOJUZ

190

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

TZOUBYBOEBTFNBOUJDTThFTZOUBYTQFDJﬁFTUIFTZNCPMTBOEGPSNBUJPOSVMFTUIBUQVUUIFTZNCPMT UPHFUIFSJOWBMJEXBZTThFTFNBOUJDT TFFCFMPX TQFDJﬁFTUIFNFBOJOHPGUIFTZNCPMTBOEUIF TZOUBDUJDBMMZWBMJEFYQSFTTJPOTCVJMUVQGSPNUIFTZNCPMT /PUF"MBSHFWBSJFUZPGMBOHVBHFTFYJTU JODMVEJOHOBUVSBM FH &OHMJTI

NBUIFNBUJDBM MPHJDBM TJNVMBUJPO QSPHSBNNJOH DPNQVUFS$16 TDSJQU NBSLVQ NPEFMJOH CVTJOFTTQSPDFTTJOH BSDIJUFD UVSF EFTJHO SFRVJSFNFOUT OFUXPSL GVODUJPOBM NVMUJQBSBEJHN EBUB LOPXMFEHFSFQSFTFOUBUJPO HFOFSBMQVSQPTF EPNBJOTQFDJﬁD FUDThFGPSFHPJOHDBUFHPSJFTBSFOPUNVUVBMMZFYDMVTJWFGPS FYBNQMF BQSPHSBNNJOHMBOHVBHFDBOCFBGVODUJPOBMMBOHVBHF"TFUPG4&SFMBUFEMBOHVBHFDBU FHPSJFTJTQSFTFOUFEBOEEJTDVTTFEJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi4BNQMFPG-BOHVBHFTUIBU4VQQPSU4&w 4FNBOUJDT*OUFSQSFUBUJPOPSNFBOJOHPGTJHOT FTQFDJBMMZPGXPSETBOETFOUFODFTPGMBOHVBHFT*O GPSNBMMBOHVBHFTBOEGPSNBMMZEFTDSJCFEOBUVSBMMBOHVBHFT TFNBOUJDTJTFYQSFTTFEBTJOUFSQSFUB UJPOTPGUIFTZNCPMT FYQSFTTJPOT JOUIFNPEFM XIFSFUIFNPEFMJTFJUIFSBGPSNBMNPEFMPGTFUUIF PSFUJDPCKFDUT FH SFMBUJPOT GVODUJPOT QBSUJBMMZPSEFSFETFUT MBUUJDFT FUD XIJDIBDUBTiTUBOEJOTw GPSUIFSFBMXPSMEPCKFDUT PSKVTUBNPEFMPGUIFXPSME XIFSFUSFFT QFPQMF FUD BSFJEFOUJﬁFE ThPTFPCKFDUTBSFUIFEFOPUBUJPOTPGUIFTZNCPMT FYQSFTTJPOT ThFTFUPGJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTPGUIF TZNCPMTDPOTUJUVUFTUIFNFBOJOHTFNBOUJDT BOEJTUZQJDBMMZDBMMFEiNPEFMUIFPSFUJDTFNBOUJDTw 4FNBOUJDTIBTJOUFOTJPOBMBOEFYUFOTJPOBMGPSNT DPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPGUIFTFUFSNT JO$IBQUFSThBUJT JOUFOTJPOBMTFNBOUJDTJTFYQSFTTFECZEFﬁOJOHQSPQFSUJFTPSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT XIJMFFYUFOTJPOBMTFNBOUJDTJTFYQSFTTFECZFOVNFSBUJOHJOTUBODFT UIBUIBWFUIPTFQSPQFSUJFTPS DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT JOTPNFXPSMEPS6% 3FMBUFEUPTFNBOUJDTJTUIFDPODFQUPGQSBHNBUJDTThFGPDVTPGQSBHNBUJDTJTPOIPXXPSET BOETFOUFODFTBSFVTFEJOBHJWFODPOUFYU4FNBOUJDTUIFSFGPSF DPSSFMBUFXJUIBDPOUFYUHFOFSBM FYUFSOBMNPEFMPGBTZTUFN BTEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS XIJDITUBUFTUIFCFIBWJPSPGUIFTZTUFNTFQB SBUFGSPNBOZHJWFOFOWJSPONFOUBOEQSBHNBUJDTDPSSFMBUFTXJUIBDPOUFYUTQFDJﬁDFYUFSOBMNPEFM PGBTZTUFN XIJDIEFﬁOFTIPXUIFTZTUFNJTVTFEJOBTQFDJﬁDFOWJSPONFOUXIBUJUTSPMFJT *OBDUVBMJUZ UIFCPVOEBSZCFUXFFOTFNBOUJDTBOEQSBHNBUJDTJTGV[[ZThFUXPEFUFSNJOFBTQFD USVN XJUIPOFCMFFEJOHJOUPUIFPUIFS

Deﬁning Categories in an Ontology ThFQSPDFTTPGEFﬁOJOHDBUFHPSJFTJOBEPNBJOJTBOJNQPSUBOUFMFNFOUPGDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOE POUPMPHZ*OEJWJEVBMTPSJOTUBODFTFYJTUJOBOZEPNBJO'PSFYBNQMF JOUIFBJSDSBGUEPNBJO UIFSF BSFJOEJWJEVBMBJSDSBGUUIBUXFDBOTFFBOEﬂZ UIFJSDPNQPOFOUT UIFJSDSFXT FUD$BUFHPSJFTTVDI BTﬁYFEXJOHBJSDSBGU DPNNFSDJBMBJSDSBGU PSQJMPUTBSFEFﬁOFEXIFODBUFHPSJ[JOHUIFEPNBJO "GUFSUIFDBUFHPSJFTBSFFTUBCMJTIFE UIFZCFDPNFQBSUPGUIFEPNBJO UIF6% ThFSFBSFUXPSFDFOUUSFOETJOUIFBSFOBPGEFﬁOJOHDMBTTJﬁDBUJPOTZTUFNTBOE NPSFHFOFSBMMZ EFﬁOJOHPOUPMPHJFT#PUIBSFUPTPNFEFHSFFJOSFTQPOTFUPUIFDIBMMFOHFTBOEPQQPSUVOJUJFTPG UIF*OUFSOFU0OFUSFOEJTCPUUPNVQ BOEUIFPUIFSJTUPQEPXOThFCPUUPNVQUSFOEJTQVCMJDMZ TIBSFEUBHHJOHCZVTFSTPG8FCTJUFTTVDIBT'MJDLSBOE%FMJDJPVTUPGPSNGPMLTPOPNJFTThFMBSHF OVNCFSPGUBHTDBUFHPSJ[FUIFNBUFSJBMPOUIF8FCTJUF BOEUIFMJOLTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIFUBHTTVQ QPSUJNQSPWFETFBSDIDBQBCJMJUZ)PXFWFS UIFNPEFMUIBUUIFZGPSNJTXFBL PGUFOXJUIPVUBOZ UBYPOPNJD TUSVDUVSF 'PMLTPOPNJFT SFQSFTFOU BOPUIFS FYBNQMF PG NBTT DPMMBCPSBUJPO B UPQJD UIBUXBTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFSThFVTFPGUIFGPMLTPOPNJFTBQQSPBDIJOTPNF4&EPNBJOT JTCFJOHFYQMPSFEGPSFYBNQMF TFF/BVNBOBOE)VTTBJO BOE-FFBOE:POH

Conceptualization

O

191

(SVOJOHFS FU BM SFQPSU PO UIF 0OUPMPHZ 4VNNJU XIJDI FYBNJOFE EJTUJODUJPOT BNPOHPOUPMPHZ UBYPOPNZ BOEGPMLTPOPNZ ThFUPQEPXOUSFOEJTUPJODSFBTFFNQIBTJTPOFYQMJDJUMZEFﬁOJOHBOEUPWBSZJOHEFHSFFTGPS NBMJ[JOHPOUPMPHJFT"LFZESJWFSPGUIJTUSFOEJTUIFEJﬃcVMUZPGDPNNVOJDBUJOHBDSPTTNVMUJQMF DPNNVOJUJFTBOEEPNBJOT FTQFDJBMMZJOUIFDPOUFYUPGUIF*OUFSOFUThF4FNBOUJD8FCJTBGPDBM QPJOUGPSNBOZPGUIFFﬀPSUT#FDBVTF4& BOEFTQFDJBMMZUIF4&PGUIFGVUVSF IBTTJNJMBSNVMUJ EPNBJOEJﬃcVMUJFT 4&TIPVMEMFWFSBHFUIFXPSLCFJOHEPOFJOUIJTBSFB"GUFSUIFJOUSPEVDUJPO PGBOFYBNQMFJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi4FUVQ&YBNQMF wUIFGPMMPXJOHUXPTFDUJPOTEJTDVTTGVSUIFS UIFNVMUJEPNBJODIBMMFOHFTBOETPNFPGUIFPOUPMPHZXPSLCFJOHEPOFThF.04&4PSJFOUB UJPOJTUIBUTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOTBNPOHUIFBHFOUTPGBDPNNVOJUZJTUIF QSJNBSZHPBM BOEPOUPMPHJFTDBOIFMQBDIJFWFUIBUHPBM "QSPKFDUUIBUDPVMECFDIBSBDUFSJ[FEBTBCSJEHFPSBNJEEMFHSPVOECFUXFFOUPQEPXOBOE CPUUPNVQJTDBMMFENZ0OUPMPHZ 4JPSQBFTFUBM ThJTQSPKFDUJTQSPEVDJOHBOPQFOPOUPM PHZ FOWJSPONFOU JOUFOEFE GPS 4FNBOUJD 8FCCBTFE F$PNNFSDF ThF CPUUPNVQ QBSU JT UIF 8JLJCBTFEDPNNVOJUZDPMMBCPSBUJPOBTQFDUThFUPQEPXOQBSUJODMVEFTBOVOEFSMZJOHNFUB NPEFMCBTFEPOBMJHIUXFJHIUTVCTFUPG08-%- 8FC0OUPMPHZ-BOHVBHFCBTFEPO%FTDSJQUJPO -PHJDT

BOEBMHPSJUINTUIBUSVOJOUIFCBDLHSPVOEUPDIFDLJODPOTJTUFODJFT *OBDUVBMQSBDUJDF PGDPVSTF XIFOPOUPMPHJTUTEFWFMPQBOPOUPMPHZ UIFZEPTPBDDPSEJOHUPQBSUJDV MBSVTFDBTFT SFﬁOFEUPTDFOBSJPT UIBUUIFPOUPMPHZJTCFJOHEFWFMPQFEUPBEESFTT"TQBSUPGUIJTQSPDFTT UIFPOUPMPHJTUMPPLTBUBOZFYJTUJOHEBUBPSLOPXMFEHFTPVSDFXIPTFTFNBOUJDT BTBTDFSUBJOFEWJBBOBMZ TJT UIFQSPQPTFEPOUPMPHZXJMMIBWFUPJODMVEFThJTJTMBSHFMZBCPUUPNVQBOBMZTJT#VUUIFPOUPMPHJTU BMTPIBTUPMPPLBUUIFSFﬁOFETDFOBSJPT EFWFMPQDPNQFUFODZRVFTUJPOT RVFTUJPOTUIBUUIFSFTVMUJOH POUPMPHZTIPVMEBOTXFS

BOEUIFOEFWFMPQBNPEFMPGUIFTFNBOUJDTUIBUBEESFTTFTUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTPG UIFVTFDBTFT*OBEEJUJPO UIPTFDPNQFUFODZRVFTUJPOTBMTPBDUBTDSJUFSJBGPSXIFOUIFPOUPMPHZJTSFBEZ UIBUJT XIFOUIPTFRVFTUJPOTDBOCFBEFRVBUFMZBOTXFSFEBUUIFSJHIUMFWFMPGHSBOVMBSJUZ BTKVEHFECZ BEPNBJOFYQFSU4PUIFVTVBMPOUPMPHZEFWFMPQNFOUQSPDFTTJOQSBDUJDFJODMVEFTCPUUPNVQBOEUPQ EPXOOPUJPOT6TJOHTPMFMZPOFPSUIFPUIFSXJMMSFTVMUJOBMFTTUIBOBEFRVBUFPOUPMPHZ

Set-up Example "CSJFGFYBNQMFJTJOUSPEVDFEJOUIJTTFDUJPOUPTFUVQBOEJMMVTUSBUFUIFEJTDVTTJPOJOMBUFSTFDUJPOT 3FDPOTJEFSUIFNPEFMTJOUSPEVDFEJO'JHVSFGPSBTZTUFNPGJOUFSFTU 40*

BOEUIFCBTJDDBUFHP SJFTPGJOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBMNPEFMT'JHVSFSFDBTUTUIFTFJOUPUISFFUZQFTJOUFSOBM FYUFSOBM BOE FOWJSPONFOU4VQQPTFXFIBWFBTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSXIPJTFOHJOFFSJOHTZTUFN4 TBZBDPNNFSDJBM BJSDSBGU"QBSUJBMMJTUPGJUTFOWJSPONFOUJODMVEFTQBTTFOHFST IVNBOQJMPUT BJSUSBﬃc DPOUSPM SVO XBZT BJSQSFTTVSF GPSDFPGHSBWJUZ GVFMTPVSDF BOEPUIFSBJSDSBGUBOEWFIJDMFTJOJUTWJDJOJUZThFTF BSFOPUJPOBMMZSFQSFTFOUFECZ4BOE4JOUIFﬁHVSF DMFBSMZ BOBJSDSBGUIBTNPSFUIBOUXPFOWJSPO NFOUFMFNFOUTXJUIXIJDIJUJOUFSBDUT 4JODMVEFTTFWFSBMQBSUT FBDIPGXIJDIJTEFTJHOFECZPUIFSFOHJOFFST5PHJWFBTJNQMJGZJOH FYBNQMF MFUTTBZUIFFOHJOFFSTBOEQBSUTBSFBTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSEFTJHOJOHUIFBWJPOJDTTPGUXBSF 4 BNFDIBOJDBMFOHJOFFSEFTJHOJOHUIFIZESBVMJDTTZTUFN4 BQSPQVMTJPOFOHJOFFSEFTJHOJOH UIFQPXFSQMBOU4 BOEBOBFSPOBVUJDBMFOHJOFFSEFTJHOJOHUIFBJSGSBNFTUSVDUVSF4. ThF40* GPSUIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJT4 XIJMFFBDITVCTZTUFNJTUIF40*GPSUIFFOHJOFFSEFTJHOJOHJUTPUIF 40*GPSUIFTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJT4'JHVSFTIPXTBEFDPNQPTJUJPOPGNPEFMTBOEWJFXTGSPN 0OUPMPHZ4VNNJUIUUQPOUPMPHDJNOFUDHJCJOXJLJQM 0OUPMPHZ4VNNJU

192 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science Environment: S1 environment relation S S4

Internal: Relation on S1 parts

S2 S1

S3

S1

S14

Environment: S11 environment relation S12

Internal: Relation on S11 parts S11

S13

S11

S1

External: S1 as whole S11

S114

S112

S113

S111

External: S11 as whole Three views of each system of interest (S1; and S11): Internal; External; and Environment = Port; point of interaction or connection of a system with its environment = Connector; locus of relation, connection, interaction among systems or components

Figure 8.1

SE context for multiple domains, languages, and ontologies.

UIFWJFXQPJOUﬁSTUPG4 UIFBJSDSBGU JOJUTFOWJSPONFOUBOEJUTDPNQPTJUJPO BOEUIFO4 UIF TPGUXBSF JOJUTFOWJSPONFOUBOEJUTDPNQPTJUJPO ThFGPVSQSJNBSZNPEFMTPGJOUFSFTUGPSFBDI40*BSF BOFOWJSPONFOUNPEFMPGUIFJOUFSBD UJPOPGUIF40*XJUIJUTFOWJSPONFOU BUZQFPGJOUFSOBMNPEFM BOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIF40* BOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIF40*BOE BOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPGFBDIQBSUPGUIF40* ThFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSNPEFMTIJTIFS40* 4 XJUIUIFTFNPEFMT

&OWJSPONFOUNPEFMPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPOPG4XJUIJUTFOWJSPONFOU 4BOE4 &YUFSOBMNPEFMPG4XIBUJUQSPWJEFT XIBUJUSFRVJSFT *OUFSOBMNPEFMPG4JUTQBSUT 4 4 4 4 BOEUIFJSJOUFSBDUJPOT &YUFSOBMNPEFMPGFBDIQBSU 4 4 4 4

ThFTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSNPEFMTIJTIFS40* 4 XJUIUIFTFNPEFMT &OWJSPONFOUNPEFMPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPOPG4XJUIJUTFOWJSPONFOU 4BOE4 XIJDI GPSNQBSUCVUOPUBMMPG4 BDDPSEJOHUPUIFﬁHVSF

&YUFSOBMNPEFMPG48IBUJUQSPWJEFT XIBUJUSFRVJSFT *OUFSOBMNPEFMPG4*UTQBSUT 4 4 4 4 BOEUIFJSJOUFSBDUJPOT'PSBWJ POJDTTPGUXBSF UIFTFNJHIUCFDPNNVOJDBUJPOT OBWJHBUJPO ﬂJHIUDPOUSPM BOEDPMMJTJPO BWPJEBODF GPSFYBNQMF &YUFSOBMNPEFMPGFBDIQBSU 4 4 4 4 ThFPWFSMBQPGUIFTFTFUTPGNPEFMTJTUIBUUIFFYUFSOBMNPEFMPG4 BOEUIFNPEFMPG4 JOUFSBDUJOHXJUIJUTFOWJSPONFOU4BOE4 BSFQBSUPGUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFMPG4ThFTZTUFNT

Conceptualization

O

193

FOHJOFFSEFWFMPQTBOVOEFSTUBOEJOHPG4QSPWJEFSTBOEDPOTVNFSTJOEFﬁOJOHUIFFYUFSOBMNPEFM PG4JOJUT4FOWJSPONFOUThFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJTUIFBSDIJUFDUPGUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFMPG4'SPN UIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGUIFTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSPG4 4BOE4BSFUIFQSPWJEFSTDPOTVNFSTPG4JO JUT4FOWJSPONFOU BOEUIFTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSOFHPUJBUFTUIFFYUFSOBMTQFDPG4XJUIUIFTZTUFNT FOHJOFFSBTUIFEFﬁOFSPGUIF4FOWJSPONFOU

Challenge of Multiple Domains "T EJTDVTTFE BCPWF B TZTUFN DBO FYJTU JO NVMUJQMF EPNBJOT FTQFDJBMMZ JG XF DPOTJEFS JUT GVMM EFDPNQPTJUJPO*UTFYUFSOBMFOWJSPONFOUNJHIUCFPOFEPNBJO TVDIBTDPNNFSDJBMBJSUSBOTQPS UBUJPO/PUPOMZDBOJUTJOUFSOBMQBSUTCFEJﬀFSFOUGSPNUIFFYUFSOBMEPNBJO CVUUIFQBSUEPNBJOT BMTPDBOEJﬀFSGSPNFBDIPUIFS*OUIFBJSDSBGUFYBNQMFBCPWF BUUIFTZTUFNJOUFSOBMMFWFM XF TBXBXJEFWBSJFUZPGEPNBJOT&BDIEPNBJODBOBOEUZQJDBMMZEPFTIBWFJUTPXOVOJWFSTFPGEJT DPVSTF DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO POUPMPHZ BOEMBOHVBHF T *O4& UIJTJTFTQFDJBMMZUSVFPGIJHIMFWFM TVCTZTUFNTJOUIJTFYBNQMFBWJPOJDT QPXFSQMBOU FUDThJTQSFTFOUTBOJOUFSFTUJOHDIBMMFOHFUP TZTUFNTFOHJOFFST UPCSJOHUPHFUIFSBOEJOUFHSBUFQBSUTGSPNBWBSJFUZPGEPNBJOTThF3PTFUUB 4UPOFFYBNQMF #BF[BOE4UBZ SFGFSFODFEJO$IBQUFSJMMVTUSBUFEUIFEJﬃcVMUJFTPGDPN NVOJDBUJOHBNPOHEJTDJQMJOFTFWFOJOUIFTJNQMJﬁFEDBTFXIFOUIFDPODFQUTBSFUIFTBNF 8FDBOVTFUIFFYBNQMFJOUIFQSFWJPVTTFDUJPOUPEJTDVTTQPTTJCMFEJﬀFSFODFTJOUIF6%BOE MBOHVBHFTCFJOHVTFEJOUIFTFWBSJPVTNPEFMT'JSTU UIFUISFFCPYFTJO'JHVSFMBCFMFE4 4 BOE4DPVMEFBDIIBWFBEJﬀFSFOUDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOEVTFEJﬀFSFOUMBOHVBHFTThFFYUFSOBM MBOHVBHFTBOEDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPG4DPVMECFEJﬀFSFOUGSPNUIFJOUFSOBMPOFTPG4 BOEMJLFXJTF UIFFYUFSOBMMBOHVBHFTBOEDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPG4DPVMEEJﬀFSGSPNUIFJOUFSOBMThFTFSWJDFT QSPWJEFEBOESFRVJSFECZ4BSFJOUIFMBOHVBHFTPGJOUFSOBM4 BOEUIPTFBSFUIFMBOHVBHFTPO XIJDIUIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSBOETPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSCBTFUIFJSEJTDVTTJPOTBOEOFHPUJBUJPOPG4 SFRVJSFNFOUTThFMBOHVBHFTPGJOUFSOBM4 IPXFWFS DPVMECFEJﬀFSFOUJOUIJTDBTF TPGUXBSF EFTJHOMBOHVBHFTTVDIBT6.-BOEPOFPSNPSFQSPHSBNNJOHMBOHVBHFT4FOTPSTDPVMEEFUFDU WBSJPVTBTQFDUTPGUIF4FOWJSPONFOUPSTUBUF GFFEDFSUBJOTUBUVTJOGPSNBUJPOUPUIFTPGUXBSFTZT UFN JOUIJTDBTF4

BOEUIFTPGUXBSFTZTUFNJOUVSODPVMEGFFEDPNNBOETUPBJSDSBGUBDUVBUPST 'VSUIFSFYBNQMFTPGJOUFSBDUJPOBSFHJWFOJOUIFOFYUTFDUJPO ThF'JHVSFFYBNQMFBOEEJTDVTTJPOBCPWFSFﬂFDUUIFNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZOBUVSFPG4&8F OPUFEJO$IBQUFSUIBU4&JTNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZJOTFWFSBMXBZT8FOPXFYQBOEBOEJOUFSQSFUUIF FBSMJFSJUFNJ[BUJPOJOUIFDPOUFYUPGMBOHVBHFTBOEPOUPMPHJFTThFJUFNTUIBUGPMMPXJMMVTUSBUFUIF FYUFOUPGUIFDIBMMFOHF O ThF TDPQF PG TZTUFNT UIBU 4& FOHJOFFST JODMVEFT NVMUJQMF iQSJNBSZw QSPCMFN EPNBJOT BFSPTQBDF EFGFOTF USBOTQPSUBUJPO DPOTUSVDUJPO PSHBOJ[BUJPOT FUD

FBDIXJUIJUTPXO TFUPGEPNBJOMBOHVBHFTBOEPOUPMPHJFT&YQBOTJPOUPDPNQMFYTZTUFNTBOETDBMJOHPOMZ BEETUPUIFFYJTUJOH54&EPNBJOT4&BOEEPNBJOJOUFHSBUJPOXPVMECFTJNQMJﬁFEJGUIFZ BMMVTFEUIFTBNFMBOHVBHF CVUUIBUTFFNTVOMJLFMZUPIBQQFO O *OEJWJEVBM TZTUFNT UIBU 4& FOHJOFFST JOWPMWF NVMUJQMF iTVQQPSUJOHw QSPCMFN EPNBJOT JOUIFJSTVCTZTUFNTPSDPNQPOFOUT DPNNVOJDBUJPOT JOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNT NFDIBOJDBM FMFDUSJDBM DPOUSPMTZTUFNT IVNBOT FUD &BDIPGUIFTFTVQQPSUJOHEPNBJOTIBTPOFPS NPSFEPNBJOMBOHVBHFTBOEPOUPMPHJFT O "TEJTDVTTFEBCPWFXJUI'JHVSF XIBUHPFTPOJOTJEFBTZTUFNJTPGUFOWFSZEJﬀFSFOU GSPN XIBU HPFT PO PVUTJEF UIF TZTUFN BOE MBOHVBHFT BOE DPODFQUTPGJOUFSOBMNPEFMT PGBTZTUFNDBOCFWFSZEJﬀFSFOUGSPNUIPTFPGFYUFSOBMPSFOWJSPONFOUNPEFMTPGUIF

194

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

1 Describe

Model space

2 Instruct

Problem space

Execution space

3 Interact 1. Describe: Model space entities describe problem space entities and behavior 2. Instruct: Models are interpreted by execution space entities as instructions and data 3. Interact: Problem space entities interact with execution space entities – Interaction is governed by models and problem space data – Entities operate within their own universe of discourse: problem vs. computer

Figure 8.2

Semantic range: architecture of software engineering.

TBNFTZTUFN0OFPGUIFEPNJOBOUUIFNFTPG.04&4JTUIFFNQIBTJTPOUIFEJTUJODUJPO CFUXFFOJOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBMWJFXTPSNPEFMTPGBTZTUFN&WFOEJﬀFSFOUWJFXTPGUIF TBNFJOUFSOBMPSFYUFSOBMNPEFMDBOVTFEJﬀFSFOUMBOHVBHFT O 8JUIJOUIFJOUFSOBMWJFXPGBTZTUFN FBDIDPNQPOFOUNBZIBWFBEJﬀFSFOU6%BOEMBO HVBHF BTJMMVTUSBUFEXJUIUIFBJSDSBGUFYBNQMF*OBEEJUJPO JOUIFFYQBOEFE4& TZTUFNT DBOJODMVEFIVNBOT HSPVQT BOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOT XIJDISFQSFTFOUEJﬀFSFOUEPNBJOT O 3FMBUFEUPUIFJOUFSOBMoFYUFSOBMEJﬀFSFODF EPNBJOTFNBOUJDTPGBTZTUFNSBOHFGSPNUIF QSPCMFNFOWJSPONFOUTQBDFUPUIFGVSUIFTUSFBDIFTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFBOETPMVUJPOTQBDFT ThJTSBOHFEFﬁOFTUIFTDPQFPGUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVN'PSUIFHFOFSBMDBTF JUJT JMMVTUSBUFEJO$IBQUFS 'JHVSF BOEGPSTPGUXBSF JO'JHVSFJOUIJTDIBQUFS (SFBUFSEJTUSJCVUJPOBOEIFUFSPHFOFJUZPGJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNT BTUIFZIBWFFWPMWFEGSPNTFMG DPOUBJOFE NPOPMJUIJD IPNPHFOFPVT TZTUFNT UP EFDPVQMFE NPEVMBS EJTUSJCVUFE IFUFSPHFOFPVT HMPCBMTZTUFNT IBWFBEEFEUPUIFNVMUJEPNBJONVMUJPOUPMPHZUSFOE TFF0CSTU ThFHMPCBM SFBDI CSJOHT OBUVSBM MBOHVBHF BOE DVMUVSF EJﬀFSFODFT QSPNJOFOUMZ JOUP QMBZ BT BO BEEJUJPOBM EJNFOTJPO JO UIF NVMUJMJOHVBM BOE NVMUJDVMUVSBM DIBMMFOHF 5SZJOH UP SFBDI B DPNNPO VOEFS TUBOEJOHJOUIJTFOWJSPONFOUSFRVJSFTNVDIHSFBUFSBUUFOUJPOUPFYQMJDJUTFNBOUJDT POUPMPHJFT BOE MBOHVBHFT BOEUIFZOFFEUPCFNBDIJOFSFBEBCMFBOENBDIJOFJOUFSQSFUBCMFThFHPBMXIFO4& JTNBUVSFJTOPUUPIBWFPOFVOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTF DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO POUPMPHZ BOEMBOHVBHF CVU SBUIFSUPSFDPHOJ[FBOETVQQPSUUIFJOEJWJEVBMEPNBJOTBOEPOUPMPHJFT BOEUIFJSJOUFHSBUJPOJOUP BDPIFSFOUXIPMFJOTVQQPSUPGUIFFYQBOEFE4&)PXEPFT4&NFFUUIJTDIBMMFOHF 4PNFJEFBT BSFQSFTFOUFEJOUIFOFYUTFDUJPO

Response to the Challenge Mitigation 0OFTJHOJﬁDBOUFMFNFOUPGUIFSFTQPOTFUPUIFDIBMMFOHFJTUIFNJUJHBUJPOBDIJFWFECZTFQBSBU JOHUIFJOUFSOBMXPSMEPGBTZTUFNGSPNJUTFYUFSOBMXPSMECZNFBOTPGJUTCPVOEBSZSFJOGPSDFE

Conceptualization

O

195

CZFODBQTVMBUJPOThBUJT UIFDPNQPTJUJPOTUSVDUVSFUIBUGPTUFSTUIFDIBMMFOHFPGEJﬀFSFOUMBO HVBHFTJOTJEFBOEPVUTJEFBTZTUFNJTBMTPQBSUPGUIFTPMVUJPO5PUIFEFHSFFUIBUUIFJOUFSOBM BOEFYUFSOBMBSFTFQBSBUFE JUEPFTOPUNBUUFSJGUIFZTQFBLEJﬀFSFOUMBOHVBHFT)PXFWFS UIBU JTOPUUIFDPNQMFUFTPMVUJPOCFDBVTF4&EFBMTQSJNBSJMZXJUIPQFOTZTUFNT JOXIJDITUVﬀHPFT JOBOEPVUPGUIFTZTUFN4PTPNFJOUFSBDUJPOGPSFYBNQMF USBOTMBUJPOPSUSBOTGPSNBUJPO NVTUPDDVSCFUXFFOUIFMBOHVBHFTPGUIFJOUFSOBMXPSMEBOEUIPTFPGUIFFYUFSOBM BOECFUXFFO UIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOT ThJT JOUFSBDUJPO JT QBSU PG UIF EFTJHO PG B TZTUFN 4ZTUFNT FOHJOFFST VTF UFDIOPMPHZ UP EFTJHOBOEEFWFMPQBTPMVUJPOPSTZTUFNXIPTFJOUFSOBMTUIFTZTUFNVTFSXIFUIFSNBDIJOFPS IVNBOEPFTOPUJOHFOFSBMLOPXPSDBSFBCPVU BOE iUSBOTMBUFwCFUXFFOUIFJOUFSOBMTBOE FYUFSOBMTPGUIFTZTUFNJOBXBZUIBUFOBCMFTUIFVTFSUPVOEFSTUBOE VTF BOEJOUFSBDUXJUIUIF TZTUFN*ONBOZDBTFT UIJTUSBOTMBUJPOJTJNQMJDJUPSCVJMUJOUPUIFTZTUFN'PSFYBNQMF BCSJEHF CVJMEFSEPFTOPUOFFEUPUSBOTMBUFBOZUIJOHUPBVTFSUIFCSJEHFTJNQMZOFFETUPQSFTFOUBﬂBU TVSGBDFUPTPNFPOFXBOUJOHUPESJWFPSXBMLBDSPTTUIFCSJEHF#VUJONPTUDBTFT TPNFDPNNV OJDBUJPOJTOFFEFE XIJDINFBOTUIBUUSBOTMBUJPOJTOFFEFEThFXIPMFﬁFMEPGIVNBONBDIJOF JOUFSGBDFIBTGPDVTFEPOUIFDPNNVOJDBUJPOBOEJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOIVNBOTBOENBDIJOFT BOE UIFSFBSFNBOZMFTTPOT QBUUFSOT BOEDPOTUSBJOUTUIBUIFMQJNQSPWFUIJTJOUFSBDUJPO 1FSIBQT UIF NPTU FYUSFNF diﬀerFODF CFUXFFO JOUFSOBM BOE FYUFSOBM 6% BOE MBOHVBHFT PDDVST JO DPNQVUFS TZTUFNT UIBU JOUFSBDU XJUI IVNBOT " MBSHF DPODFQUVBM EJTUBODF FYJTUT CFUXFFOUIFEPNBJODPODFQUTPGBDPNQVUFSQSPDFTTPS MPBE TUPSF FUD BOEUIPTFPGCBOLJOH HFPTQBUJBM TZTUFNT BOE BJSDSBGU DPOUSPM The TPGUXBSF FOHJOFFS JT SFRVJSFE CPUI UP USBOTMBUF CFUXFFOMBOHVBHFTBOEUPUSBOTGPSNCFUXFFOWFSZdiﬀerFOU6%T*OGBDU TPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH DPVME CF deﬁned BT UIF EJTDJQMJOF UIBU EFTJHOT TZTUFNT UIBU FOBCMF TVDDFTTGVM DPNNVOJDB UJPOCFUXFFOUXPBHFOUT OFJUIFSPGXIPNIBTBOZJEFBXIBUUIFPUIFSJTUBMLJOHBCPVU UIF UXP QBSUJFT CFJOH B QSPCMFN EPNBJO TQFDJBMJTU BOE B DPNQVUFS QSPDFTTPS The TJUVBUJPO JT JMMVTUSBUFE JO 'JHVSF 0OF LFZ TPMVUJPO BQQSPBDI JT UP FNCFE UIF TZNCPMT PG UIF QSPC MFNEPNBJOMBOHVBHFJOTJEFUIFDPNQVUFSQSPDFTTPSMBOHVBHF6OEFSDFSUBJODPOEJUJPOTUIBU UIFDPNQVUFSVOEFSTUBOET JUQSJOUTPVUi*OTFSUDBSEwVOEFSPUIFSDPOEJUJPOT JUQSJOUTPVU i%FQPTJUPS8JUIESBXBM wThese TZNCPMTBSFNFBOJOHMFTTUPUIFDPNQVUFSCVUUIFIVNBOVTFS VOEFSTUBOETXIBUUIFZNFBO 5XPBEEJUJPOBMNFDIBOJTNTBSFNFOUJPOFEIFSFThFZEPOPUEJSFDUMZTVQQPSUUIFVTFSDPNQVUFS DPNNVOJDBUJPOCFDBVTFUIFNFDIBOJTNTBSFIJEEFOGSPNCPUIIPXFWFS UIFZEPIFMQJNQSPWF UIFMJLFMJIPPEUIBUUIFTPGUXBSFJTDPSSFDU XIJDIEPFTGBDJMJUBUFVTFSDPNQVUFSDPNNVOJDBUJPO O ThFVTFPGIJHIMFWFMQSPHSBNNJOHMBOHVBHFTTVDIBT+BWB BOEUSBOTMBUPSTUSBOTGPSNFST DPNQJMFST PGTPGUXBSFGSPNIJHIMFWFMMBOHVBHFTBOEUIFJSDPODFQUTUPDPNQVUFSQSPDFT TPSMBOHVBHFTBOEUIFJSDPODFQUT#PUIUIFIJHIMFWFMMBOHVBHFBOEJUT6%BSFJOTVMBUFE GSPN UIPTF PG UIF DPNQVUFS BOE BSF DMPTFS UP IVNBO MBOHVBHF XIJDINFBOTUIFZBSF DMPTFSUPUIFQSPCMFNEPNBJOTUIBUIVNBOTVOEFSTUBOE O ThFVTFPGEPNBJOTQFDJﬁDMBOHVBHFT XIJDIBSFFWFODMPTFSUPUIFMBOHVBHFTBOE6%TPG UIFTQFDJﬁDQSPCMFNEPNBJOTGPSXIJDIUIFZBSFXSJUUFO

Ontology Efforts and Tools "TJHOJﬁDBOUCPEZPGXPSLJTCFJOHEPOFJOUIFFOHJOFFSJOHBOEGPSNBMJ[BUJPOPGPOUPMPHJFTThF PSJHJOTPGUIJTXPSLHPCBDLBUMFBTUTFWFSBMEFDBEFTThFBQQMJDBUJPOPGGPSNBMMPHJDUPMBOHVBHFT BOETFNBOUJDTIBTCFFOBTJHOJﬁDBOUFMFNFOUPGUIJTHFOFBMPHZ"OFYBNQMFJT$BSOBQ ThF

196

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

TUVEZPGMPHJDTJTTUJMMBDUJWFBOEJTBOJNQPSUBOUCBTJTGPSPOUPMPHJFTBOENPEFMJOHJO4&CFDBVTF PGUIFJSIJHIEFHSFFPGFYQSFTTJWFOFTTTFFUIFOFYUTFDUJPOPOPOUPMPHZTQFDUSVN "OPUIFSFMFNFOUPGUIFHFOFBMPHZJTUIFBSUJﬁDJBMJOUFMMJHFODFDPNNVOJUZ FTQFDJBMMZJOUIFBSFB PGLOPXMFEHFSFQSFTFOUBUJPOUFDIOJRVFTTVDIBTTFNBOUJDOFUXPSLT #BSSBOE'FJHFOCBVN *OTFNBOUJDOFUXPSLT UIFOPEFTUZQJDBMMZSFQSFTFOUPCKFDUTPSDPODFQUT BOEUIFBSDTSFQSFTFOU SFMBUJPOTCFUXFFOUIFPCKFDUTPSDPODFQUTThFTFUPGSFMBUJPOTJTPQFOFOEFECVUDPNNPOSFMBUJPOT JODMVEFJOTUBODFPG TVCDMBTTPG BOEQBSUPGThFTFSFMBUJPOTBSFDPNNPOOPUKVTUJOTFNBOUJDOFU XPSLT CVUBMTPJOBMMTFNBOUJD DPODFQUVBM BOEPOUPMPHZNPEFMJOHThFﬁSTUUXPPGUIFTFBSFUIF SFMBUJPOTJOUIF.04&4DPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPO BOEUIFUIJSEJTUIFSFMBUJPOJOUIF.04&4 DPNQPTJUJPOSFMBUJPO " UIJSE JNQPSUBOU BOE NPSF SFDFOU NPWFNFOU JT UIF WJTJPO PG UIF 4FNBOUJD 8FC BOE UIF MBOHVBHFTBOETUBOEBSETMFBEJOHUPJUThFHPBMPGUIF4FNBOUJD8FCJTUPDBQUVSFNPSFUZQFTPG DPOUFYUBOETFNBOUJDJOGPSNBUJPOGPS8FCEBUBBOEUIFSFCZNBLFJUNPSFVOEFSTUBOEBCMFBOE QSPDFTTBCMFCZDPNQVUFST %BDPOUB 0CSTU BOE4NJUI 4FNBOUJDTBOEPOUPMPHZFOHJOFFS JOH JODMVEJOHPOUPMPHZEFTJHOBOEBOBMZTJTUPPMT BSFNBKPSFMFNFOUTJOUIJTFﬀPSU"TFRVFODF PG NBDIJOFQSPDFTTBCMF MBOHVBHFT IBT CFFO VTFE JO UIF 4FNBOUJD 8FC FﬀPSU NBOZ PG UIFN EFWFMPQFEQSJPSUPPSTFQBSBUFGSPNUIFBEWFOUPGUIF4FNBOUJD8FCJEFBThFMBOHVBHFTJODMVEF 9.- &YUFOTJCMF.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF

3%' 3FTPVSDF%FTDSJQUJPO'SBNFXPSL

BOE08- 8FC 0OUPMPHZ-BOHVBHF

BTXFMMBTWBSJPVTMPHJDT 0OFPGUIFNPTUEJﬃDVMUJTTVFTUPTPMWFJTUIFJODPNQBUJCJMJUZCFUXFFONPEFMTCBTFEPOPOUPMPHJFT GSPNEJﬀFSFOUEPNBJOTThJTQPTFTBTFSJPVTDIBMMFOHFGPS4& XIFSFTZTUFNTGSPNEJﬀFSFOUEPNBJOT BOEPOUPMPHJFTNVTUJOUFSBDU4&OFFETPOUPMPHZNBUDIJOH NBQQJOH JOUFHSBUJPO JOUFSPQFSBCJMJUZ TIBSJOH BOENFSHJOHBDSPTTEPNBJOT8FOPXEJTDVTTTPNFPGUIFBQQSPBDIFTCFJOHUSJFE

Upper Ontologies 0OFBQQSPBDIJTUIFEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOEPNBJOTPGEJﬀFSFOUMFWFMTPGHFOFSBMJUZ"UUIFNPTUHFO FSBMMFWFMBSFVQQFSMFWFMPOUPMPHJFT PGXIJDIBSHVBCMZUIFSFXPVMECFBTJOHMFPOFUIBUXPVMEBQQMZ UPXIBUJTDPNNPOBDSPTTBMMEPNBJOT$BOEJEBUFTGPSUIFVQQFSMFWFMJODMVEF$ZD #BTJD'PSNBM 0OUPMPHZ #'0

%FTDSJQUJWF 0OUPMPHZ GPS -JOHVJTUJD BOE $PHOJUJWF &OHJOFFSJOH %0-$&

(FOFSBM'PSNBM0OUPMPHZ ('0

8PSE/FU BOE4VHHFTUFE6QQFS.FSHFE0OUPMPHZ 46.0 O $ZD -FOBUBOE(VIB-FOBU JTQFSIBQTUIFFBSMJFTUHFOFSBMPOUPMPHZFﬀPSU BOE POF PG UIF NPTU DPNQSFIFOTJWF *U JODMVEFT OPU POMZ BO VQQFS POUPMPHZ CVU BMTP EPNBJOPOUPMPHJFT BMBSHFOVNCFSPGCBTJDGBDUT BOEBTFUPGUPPMT JODMVEJOHUIFBCJMJUZ UPJOGFSOFXLOPXMFEHFGSPNFYJTUJOHGBDUT*UJTCSPBEMZUBSHFUFE BUUFNQUJOHUPDPWFSUIF TDPQFPGIVNBODPNNPOTFOTFJOGPSNBUJPO*UJTQSPQSJFUBSZCVUJUTPQFOTPVSDFWFSTJPO 0QFO$ZD 0QFO$ZD

DPOUBJOTUIFGVMM$ZDVQQFSPOUPMPHZ O #'0 #'0 JTBOVQQFSPOUPMPHZUIBUJTCBTFEPO#BSSZ4NJUITiSFBMJTUwBQQSPBDI UPPOUPMPHZ 4NJUI *UGPDVTFTPOUIFQIZTJDBMXPSME BOEJTJOUFOEFEUPTVQQPSU EPNBJOPOUPMPHJFTGPSQIZTJDBMTDJFODFSFTFBSDI QIZTJDT DIFNJTUSZ CJPMPHZ O %0-$& .BTPMPFUBM JTBOFYUFOTJPOBMPOUPMPHZUIBUJT JUTVOJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTF JODMVEFTPOMZJOEJWJEVBMT OPUDBUFHPSJFT*UJTOPUJOUFOEFEUPCFBVOJWFSTBMPOUPMPHZ CVU SBUIFSUIFﬁSTUJOBMJCSBSZPGGPVOEBUJPOBMPOUPMPHJFT*UTGPDVTJTPOOBUVSBMMBOHVBHFBOE IVNBODPNNPOTFOTF O ('0 )FSSF FU BM JT B GPVOEBUJPOBM POUPMPHZ UIBU FNQIBTJ[FT UIF GPSNBM BQQSPBDI*UJTBDPNQPOFOUPGUIF*OUFHSBUFE4ZTUFNPG'PVOEBUJPOBM0OUPMPHJFT *4'0

Conceptualization

O

197

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hFUPUBMQBDLBHFJODMVEFTUIF VQQFS POUPMPHZ B NJEMFWFM POUPMPHZ PG FOUJUJFT TVDI BT DPNNVOJDBUJPOT ﬁOBODF BOE HFPHSBQIZBOEBTFUPGEPNBJOPOUPMPHJFT*UBMTPMJOLT46.0XJUI8PSE/FUUPBTTPDJBUF OBUVSBMMBOHVBHFXPSETXJUIJUTDBUFHPSJFT

Domain Ontologies ThFSF BSF GFXFS NJEMFWFM POUPMPHJFT UIBO VQQFS MFWFM CVU UIFSF BSF B HSFBU OVNCFS PG EPNBJO POUPMPHJFT0OFBSFBUIBUIBTQVSTVFEPOUPMPHJFTWJHPSPVTMZJTCJPNFEJDJOF"XIPMFDBUBMPHPG PQFOCJPNFEJDBMPOUPMPHJFT 0#0 JTCFJOHNBJOUBJOFEBUUIF0#0GPVOESZ 0#0 ThF FWPMWJOHPOUPMPHJFTUIBUBSFGPVOESZDBOEJEBUFTBSFDBUFHPSJ[FEJOUPEPNBJOTUIBUJODMVEFBOBU PNZ CJPDIFNJTUSZ CJPMPHJDBMGVODUJPO FOWJSPONFOU IFBMUI QIFOPUZQF QSPUFJOT BOEUBYPOPNZ ThF0#0BOEUIFGPVOESZBSFEFTDSJCFEJO4NJUIFUBM 0OFFMFNFOUPGUIF0#0TFUPGPOUPMPHJFTQSPWJEFTBHPPEJMMVTUSBUJPOPGBDPODFQUUIBUJOUF HSBUFT.04&4JEFBTJODPNQPTJUJPO DPNNPOJ[BUJPO BOEDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOThFJOUFHSBUJOHDPO DFQUJTUIFVTFPGPOUPMPHZUPTIPXUIFTJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTPGDFSUBJODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBDSPTT EJﬀFSFOUDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFMTThF0#0FMFNFOUJTUIFCJPMPHJDBMQSPDFTTPOUPMPHZ TQFDJﬁDBMMZUIF EFWFMPQNFOUOPEFQBSUPGUIJTPOUPMPHZUIFJMMVTUSBUJPOJTUIFTUSVDUVSFGPSEFWFMPQNFOUUFSNT JOWPMWJOHGPVSDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFMTDFMMT UJTTVFT PSHBOT BOEPSHBOJTNT)FSFBSFUIFTUSVDUVSFBOE UFSNTBTTIPXOJO (0

XIFSFNFBOTQBSUPGUIFPWFSBMMQSPDFTTBOE<J>NFBOTiJTBwPS TQFDJBMJ[BUJPOPGUIFPWFSBMMQSPDFTT ThJT JT UIF TUSVDUVSF GPS EFWFMPQNFOU UFSNT JOWPMWJOH UJTTVFT PSHBOT BOE PSHBOJTNT <9> NFBOTUJTTVF PSHBO PSPSHBOJTN<:>NFBOTDFMM [X] development [p] [X] morphogenesis ---[p] [X] formation ------[p] [Y] cell differentiation ---[p] [X] structural organization [p] [X] maturation

ThJTJTUIFTUSVDUVSFGPSEFWFMPQNFOUUFSNTJOWPMWJOHDFMMT cellular process [i] cell differentiation ---[p] cell fate commitment ------[p] cell fate specification ------[p] cell fate determination

198

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

---[p] cell development ------[p] cellular morphogenesis during differentiation ------[p] cell maturation

ThFUIJOHUPOPUJDFBCPVUUIJTFYBNQMFJTUIBUUISFFMFWFMTPGDPNQPTJUJPOBSFTFMGTJNJMBSXJUISFHBSE UPEFWFMPQNFOU BOEUIFGPVSUIMFWFMJTEJﬀFSFOUThFEFWFMPQNFOUPGUJTTVFT PSHBOT BOEPSHBOJTNT BMMDPOTJTUPGNPSQIPHFOFTJT GPSNBUJPO FUD XIJMFDFMMEFWFMPQNFOUGPMMPXTBEJﬀFSFOUQSPDFTT "UBCSPBEFSMFWFM UIFTJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTFYQSFTTFEJOUIJTFYBNQMFJMMVTUSBUFBQSJO DJQMFPG.04&4NPEFMJOHBOEFOHJOFFSJOHTIPVMEBMMPXTZTUFNTJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTUP BTTVNFUIFJSOBUVSBMQMBDFJONPEFMT5PPPGUFOXFFJUIFSUSZUPGPSDFFWFSZTZTUFNUPCFEJﬀFSFOU PSGPSDFBMMTZTUFNTUPCFUIFTBNFThF0#0EFWFMPQNFOUFYBNQMFJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIF.04&4 QSJODJQMFJUDBQUVSFEUIFTJNJMBSJUJFTBUUIFUJTTVF PSHBO BOEPSHBOJTNMFWFM CVUBMMPXFEUIFDFMM UP CF EJﬀFSFOU BOE DBQUVSFE UIF EJﬀFSFOU DFMM EFWFMPQNFOU QSPDFTT ThJT QSJODJQMF BQQMJFT OPU POMZUPDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFMT BTJOUIJTFYBNQMF CVUUPBMMUZQFTPGTJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFT BT EJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS "OPUIFSFYBNQMFPGBEPNBJOPOUPMPHZPGJOUFSFTUUP4&JT(6.0(FOFSBM6TFS.PEFM 0OUPMPHZ )FDLNBOOFUBM *UJTBUBYPOPNZPGVTFSEJNFOTJPOT BOEFBDIEJNFOTJPOJTB DBUFHPSZUIBUIBTBOVNCFSPGJEFOUJﬁFEFMFNFOUT"GFXFOUSJFTGSPNUIFPOUPMPHZBSF O #BTJD6TFS%JNFOTJPOTDPOUBDUJOGPSNBUJPO EFNPHSBQIJDT BCJMJUZBOEQSPﬁDJFODZ QFS TPOBMJUZ FNPUJPOBMTUBUF FUD O $IBSBDUFSJTUJDTUBMLBUJWF BTTFSUJWF EPNJOBOU RVJFU SFTFSWFE TIZ FUD O 1FSTPOBMJUZFYUSBWFSU JOUSPWFSU UIJOLJOH GFFMJOH FUD 8FJODMVEFUIJTNPEFMGPSTFWFSBMSFBTPOT0OFJTUPTIPXFﬀPSUTUPCSJOHIVNBOTNPSFGVMMZ JOUPUIF4&BSFOBBOEEFﬁOFNPSFDPNQMFUFNPEFMTPGUIFN BTQBSUPGUIFFYQBOTJPOUP$4"TFD POESFBTPOJTUPTIPXBOFYBNQMFPGBOPOUPMPHZJOUIFFYQBOEFE4&ThF(6.0NPEFMFYUFOET CFZPOEUSBEJUJPOBMNPEFMTPGIVNBOTBTVTFST. ThJTNPEFMJTEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJO$IBQUFS

Bridging and Mapping Ontologies "O BSFB JNQPSUBOU UP 4& JT UIF XPSL UIBU BEESFTTFT NVMUJQMF EPNBJOT BOE POUPMPHJFT CSJEH JOH JOUFHSBUJOH NBQQJOH NFSHJOH BOE DPNQPTJOH 8F CSJFﬂZ EJTDVTT B GFX FYBNQMFT ThF 0OUP.BQQSPKFDU ,JSZBLPW 4JNPW BOE%JNJUSPW JTBOFﬀPSUUPQSPWJEFBHFOFSBMVQQFS MFWFMPOUPMPHZUIBUTFSWFTBTBDPNNPOMPDVTGPSNBQQJOHPOUPMPHJFT QSJNBSJMZVQQFSMFWFM UP JU BOEUIFSFCZUPFBDIPUIFS*UVTFTUIFHFOFSBMSFMBUJPOTXJUIJOJUTPOUPMPHZ QMVTBGFXDSPTT POUPMPHZSFMBUJPOT UPEFﬁOFFBDINBQQJOH*GUIFPOUPMPHJFTBSFGPSNBMMZEFﬁOFE UIJTQSPDFTT TIPVMECFBVUPNBUBCMF ThF $304* QSPKFDU $BQUVSJOH 3FQSFTFOUJOH BOE 0QFSBUJPOBMJTJOH 4FNBOUJD *OUFHSBUJPO ,BMGPHMPVFUBM JOWFTUJHBUFETFNBOUJDJOUFHSBUJPOUFDIOPMPHJFT JODMVEJOHBOFYUFOTJWFTVSWFZ PGFYJTUJOHUFDIOPMPHJFT GPSUIFQVSQPTFPGPOUPMPHZNBQQJOHThFZBMTPEFWFMPQFEBQSPUPUZQFPOUPM PHZNBQQJOHTZTUFN UIF$304*.BQQJOH4ZTUFN $.4

UIBUEFNPOTUSBUFTNBQQJOHUFDIOJRVFT 8PSLPODPNQPTJOHPOUPMPHJFTIBTCFFOEPOFCZ,BVTIJL 8JKFTFLFSB BOE"NNBOO ThFJSXPSLJTJOUIFDPOUFYUPGB4FNBOUJD8FCCBTFEFOWJSPONFOUJOXIJDINVMUJQMFPOUPMPHJFT BSFQSPQPTFECZEJTUSJCVUFEDPMMBCPSBUJWFDPNNVOJUJFTThFZIBWFEFﬁOFEBUZQFTZTUFNGPSUIF 3%' BOEBOBMHFCSBGPSDPNQPTJOHPOUPMPHJFTCBTFEPOTUSVDUVSBMDPNQBSJTPOTThFZIBWFBMTP DPNQBSFEUIFJSBQQSPBDIXJUIFYJTUJOHBQQSPBDIFT

Conceptualization

O

199

.PSFOBSSPXMZGPDVTFEMBOHVBHFNBQQJOHXPSLIBTCFFOEPOFCZ.BUVMFWJƦJVT )FZNBOT BOE0QEBIM ThFJSTDPQFJTHPBMPSJFOUFEMBOHVBHFT UIFJSJOUFSPQFSBCJMJUZXJUIFBDIPUIFS BOEXJUIPUIFSNPEFMJOHMBOHVBHFTThFBQQSPBDIJTUPNBQMBOHVBHFTPOUPUIFTBNFPOUPMPHZ XIJDIJTCBTFEPOUIF#VOHF8BOE8FCFS #88 SFQSFTFOUBUJPONPEFM 8BOEBOE8FCFS BOE ThFZJMMVTUSBUFJUVTJOHBHPBMPSJFOUFEMBOHVBHFDBMMFE,"04ThFZBSFBMTPBQQMZJOH UIFNFUIPEUPEFWFMPQBOFXWFSTJPOPGUIF6OJﬁFE&OUFSQSJTF.PEFMMJOH-BOHVBHF 6&.-

Storytelling 4UPSZUFMMJOHXBTNFOUJPOFEJO$IBQUFSTBOEBTBNFBOTPGDPNNVOJDBUJOHUIBUJTJODSFBTJOHMZ CFJOHVTFEJO4&"QSFMJNJOBSZPOUPMPHZNPEFMPGTUPSZUFMMJOHIBTCFFOEFﬁOFE /BLBTPOFBOE *TIJ[VLB ThFHPBMJTUPHFOFSBMJ[FNPEFMJOHPGTUPSZUFMMJOHUPBCSPBEFSMFWFM*UJTCBTFEPO SFMBUJPOTGSPNUIF3IFUPSJDBM4USVDUVSFThFPSZThFTUPSZUFMMJOHDMBTTFTJOUIFNPEFMJODMVEFDPO DFQU FWFOU SFMBUJPO BDU TDFOF BHFOU BOESPMF. ThF.PEFMEFﬁOFTSFMBUJPOTBNPOHUIFTFDMBTTFT

Automation .BOZPGUIFQSPKFDUTMJTUFEBCPWFIBWFEFWFMPQFEUPPMTUIBUNPWFUPXBSEBVUPNBUJOHUIFWBSJ PVTQSPDFTTFT3FDBMMUIBUBVUPNBUJPOJTPOFPGUIFLFZFMFNFOUTPG4&BTFOWJTJPOFECZ.04&4 .PEFMPSJFOUBUJPOGPTUFSTUIFBVUPNBUJPOPGFOHJOFFSJOHTZTUFNTThFXPSLUPNBLFPOUPMPHJFT FYQMJDJUBOEGPSNBM XJUIUIFHPBMPGBVUPNBUJOHUIFBOBMZTJTBOEVTFPGPOUPMPHJFT GPTUFSTUIF SFDPODJMJBUJPOBOEJOUFHSBUJPOPGNVMUJQMFPOUPMPHJFTGSPNEJTQBSBUFEPNBJOTThBUJTBLFZFOBCMFS PGUIF4&PGUIFGVUVSF

Spectrum of Semantics and Ontologies Used in SE Models 'SPNUIFWJFXQPJOUPGTFNBOUJDTBOEPOUPMPHJFT BWBSJFUZPGNFUIPETBOEBQQSPBDIFTIBWFCFFO EFWFMPQFEPWFSUIFQBTUGFXEFDBEFTJOUIFEBUBCBTF TPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH BOELOPXMFEHFSFQ SFTFOUBUJPODPNNVOJUJFT NBOZPGXIJDIXFSFOPUFEBCPWFThFSFBSFEFCBUFTDPODFSOJOHXIJDI PGUIFTFNFUIPETNBZQSPQFSMZCFDBMMFEPOUPMPHJFT4FWFSBMEJﬀFSFOUBVUIPSTIBWFJOEFQFOEFOUMZ EFﬁOFEBOPOUPMPHZTQFDUSVNPSTFNBOUJDTQFDUSVNUIBUSFﬂFDUTBSBOHFPGPOUPMPHZSFMBUFEDIBS BDUFSJTUJDT&BDIBVUIPSVTFETMJHIUMZEJﬀFSFOUUFSNTUPDIBSBDUFSJ[FUIFSBOHF O %BDPOUB 0CSTU BOE 4NJUI EFﬁOF B SBOHF GSPN MFTT UP NPSF FYQSFTTJWF XIFSF UIFMFTTFYQSFTTJWFJTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIXFBLTFNBOUJDTBOEUIFNPSFFYQSFTTJWFXJUITUSPOH TFNBOUJDT O 4NJUIBOE8FMUZ EFﬁOFBSBOHFGSPNMPXUPIJHIDPNQMFYJUZ XIFSFUIFIJHIFOE JTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBVUPNBUFESFBTPOJOHNFUIPET CVUOPUUIFMPXFOE O .D(VJOOFTT EFﬁOFTBSBOHFGSPNMPXUPIJHITQFDJﬁDBUJPOEFUBJMBOEFYQSFTTJWF OFTT XJUIJOUIFTDPQFPGPOUPMPHJFTFNFSHJOHPOUIF8FC O .D$PNC EFﬁOFTBSBOHFPGTFNBOUJDQSFDJTJPO GSPNBTJNQMFEBUBDBUBMPHBUUIF MPXFOEUPHFOFSBMMPHJDBMDPOTUSBJOUTBUUIFIJHIFOE O ,BMGPHMPVFUBM EFﬁOFBSBOHFPGTFNBOUJDJOUFOTJUZ XIFSFUIFMPXFOEJTDIBSBD UFSJ[FEBTTFNBOUJDBMMZQPPSBOEUIFIJHIFOEBTTFNBOUJDBMMZSJDI ThFTFNBOUJDTQFDUSVNQSFTFOUFEJO'JHVSFJTBTMJHIUNPEJﬁDBUJPOPGUIBUQSFTFOUFEJO %BDPOUB 0CSTU BOE4NJUI *UQPSUSBZTBSBOHFPGTFNBOUJDNPEFMTUIBUQPUFOUJBMMZ

200

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science Modal logic First order logic

ve

r

xp

e re

si es

o

o st

om

m

les

Fr

Logical theory Description logic DAML+OIL, LOW UML

Conceptual model RDF/S XTM Extended ER

Thesaurus ER

Relational model, XML

Is disjoint subclass of with transitivity property

Semantic interoperability

Has narrower meaning than

DB schemas, XML schema

Taxonomy

Is subclass of

Strong semantics

Structural interoperability

Is sub-classiﬁcation of Syntactic interoperability

Weak semantics

Figure 8.3 Semantic spectrum (Source: Daconta, M., L. Obrst, and K. Smith. The Semantic Web: A Guide to the Future of XML, Web Services, and Knowledge Management. Indianapolis, IN: Wiley Publishing, 2003. Used with permission.)

DIBSBDUFSJ[FPOUPMPHZThFFYBNQMFTBSFPSHBOJ[FEBSPVOEGPVSDPOTUSVDUTUBYPOPNZ UIFTBVSVT DPODFQUVBMNPEFM BOEMPHJDBMUIFPSZ PSMPHJDBMEPNBJOUIFPSZ "UBYPOPNZJTUBLFOUPNFBO UFSNTPSDPODFQUTXJUINJOJNBMIJFSBSDIJDPSQBSFOUDIJMETUSVDUVSF"UIFTBVSVTJODMVEFTUFSNT TZOPOZNT BOEUFSNUBYPOPNJFTCBTFEPOUIFCSPBEFSUIBOOBSSPXFSUIBOSFMBUJPOBOEBTTPDJB UJPOSFMBUJPO"DPODFQUVBMNPEFMTUSVDUVSFTDPODFQUTJOBTVCDMBTTIJFSBSDIZXJUIHFOFSBMJ[FE SFMBUJPOT QSPQFSUJFT BUUSJCVUFT BOEJOTUBODFT"MPHJDBMNPEFMPSUIFPSZDPNQSJTFTFMFNFOUTPG BDPODFQUVBMNPEFMGPDVTFEPOSFBMXPSMETFNBOUJDTBOEFYUFOEFEXJUIBYJPNTBOESVMFT BOEJT SFQSFTFOUFEJOBMPHJDBMMBOHVBHFFOBCMJOHNBDIJOFTFNBOUJDJOUFSQSFUBUJPO"DPODFQUVBMNPEFM DBOCFDPOTJEFSFEBXFBLPOUPMPHZBMPHJDBMUIFPSZDBOCFDPOTJEFSFEBTUSPOHPOUPMPHZThF JOUFSPQFSBCJMJUZ MBCFMT PO UIF SJHIU JOEJDBUF SPVHIMZ UIF FYQSFTTJWFOFTT PG UIF NPEFM SFRVJSFE UPBEESFTTFBDIMFWFMPGJOUFSPQFSBCJMJUZ9.-JTTVﬃcJFOUGPSTZOUBDUJDJOUFSPQFSBCJMJUZ 9.- 4DIFNB FOBCMFT TUSVDUVSBM JOUFSPQFSBCJMJUZ CVU B NJOJNVN PG 3%' JT OFDFTTBSZ GPS TFNBOUJD JOUFSPQFSBCJMJUZ 'SPNUIJTBOBMZTJT %BDPOUB 0CSTU BOE4NJUITUBUFUIBUBOPOUPMPHZJODMVEFTDMBTTFT HFOFSBM UIJOHT

JOTUBODFT JOEJWJEVBMUIJOHT

SFMBUJPOTBNPOHUIJOHT QSPQFSUJFTBOEQSPQFSUZWBMVFTPG UIJOHT GVODUJPOTPGBOEQSPDFTTFTJOWPMWJOHUIPTFUIJOHT BOEDPOTUSBJOUTPOBOESVMFTJOWPMWJOH UIPTFUIJOHT*O.04&4 XIBUJTJNQPSUBOUJTOPUUIFEFCBUFBCPVUXIBUDPOTUJUVUFTPOUPMPHZPS XIFUIFSBMMPGUIFJUFNTJO'JHVSFSFQSFTFOUBOPOUPMPHZ8IBUJTJNQPSUBOUJTUIBUUIPTFJUFNT DBOSFQSFTFOU4&NPEFMT JODMVEJOHEPNBJOPOUPMPHJFTThJTVTBHFJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIF.04&4 DPODFQUUIBUHFOFSBMNPEFMTDBQUVSFBOESFQSFTFOU4&LOPXMFEHF BOEDPMMFDUJWFMZGPSNBCPEZPG LOPXMFEHFPG4&8FBMTPOPUFUIFTJNJMBSJUZPGUIJTMJTUPGPOUPMPHZJUFNTXJUIUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPO JUFNTJEFOUJﬁFEJO$IBQUFS

Conceptualization

O

201

Sample of Languages That Support SE %BDPOUB 0CSTU BOE4NJUI EFTDSJCFUIFCFOFﬁUTPGVTJOHSFQSFTFOUBUJPOMBOHVBHFT UIBUBSFNPSFDMFBS QSFDJTF BOEVOBNCJHVPVTUIBOOBUVSBMMBOHVBHF"MUIPVHIOBUVSBMMBO HVBHFDBOCFVTFEUPEFﬁOFNPEFMT JUJTOPUUIFﬁSTUDIPJDF/VNFSPVTMBOHVBHFTBOESFQSF TFOUBUJPOBQQSPBDIFTBSFBWBJMBCMFJO4&8FMJTUBOECSJFﬂZEFTDSJCFTPNFPGUIFNIFSFThF MBOHVBHFDBUFHPSJFTSFQSFTFOUBOJOGPSNBMBOEBEIPDTFU BOEBSFOPUQSFTFOUFEJOBOZQBSUJDV MBSPSEFSThFDBUFHPSJFTBSFBMTPOPUNVUVBMMZFYDMVTJWFTPNFMBOHVBHFTCFMPOHUPNPSFUIBO POFDBUFHPSZ

Simulation Languages $POUJOVPVT4ZTUFN4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF $44- JTBOFWPMWJOHTFUPGMBOHVBHFTUIBUXBTJOJUJBMMZ EFﬁOFEJOBOEJTEFTJHOFEUPIFMQFOHJOFFSTBOETDJFOUJTUTNPEFMUIFEZOBNJDCFIBWJPSPG QIZTJDBMQIFOPNFOB'PSCSJFGFYBNQMFT TFF)VOUTJOHFS 0OFNFNCFSPGUIJTTFUJTUIF &VSPQFBO4QBDF"HFODZ &4" 4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF &4- $SPTCJFFUBM "OPUIFSNFNCFS JTUIF"EWBODFE$POUJOVPVT4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF "$4-

XIJDIJTUBSHFUFEUPUJNFEFQFOEFOU OPOMJOFBSEJﬀFSFOUJBMFRVBUJPOT %ZNPMBBMTPTJNVMBUFTEZOBNJDCFIBWJPSPGQIZTJDBMTZTUFNTCVUJUJTEFTJHOFEUPGPMMPXUIF DPOTFSWBUJPO QSJODJQMFT PG FOFSHZ BOE NPNFOUVN BOE OPU SFMZ TUSJDUMZ PO TUBUFTQBDF NPEFMT 3BD[ZOTLJ /FVSBM 4JNVMBUJPO -BOHVBHF /4- JT EFTJHOFE GPS MBSHFTDBMF HFOFSBM OFVSBM OFUXPSLT 8FJU[FOGFME "SCJC BOE"MFYBOEFS

System Modeling and Design Languages ThF4QFDJﬁDBUJPOBOE%FTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHF 4%-

EFﬁOFEBT*56TUBOEBSE; IBTFWPMWFE PWFSBZFBSQFSJPE*UJTBXJEFTQFDUSVNMBOHVBHFGSPNTZTUFNSFRVJSFNFOUTUPJNQMFNFOUB UJPO BOEJODMVEFTCPUIHSBQIJDBMBOEUFYUVBMFMFNFOUT*UJTEFTJHOFEUPTVQQPSUGPSNBMNPEFMT BOEJTTVJUBCMFGPSSFBMUJNFTZTUFNT"DDPSEJOHUP4%-

XIFO4%-JTVTFEGPSTZTUFNTFOHJ OFFSJOH JUJTVTVBMMZJODPNCJOBUJPOXJUIPUIFSMBOHVBHFT JODMVEJOH.FTTBHF4FRVFODF$IBSUT .4$

"4/ 55$/ BOE6.- 6.- 0.(B C JTBMTPVTFEFYUFOTJWFMZJOTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHNPEFMJOHBOEEFTJHO BOE JT UIF CBTJT GPS PUIFS QSPﬁMFT BOE MBOHVBHFT "O FYUFOTJPO PG 6.- DBMMFE 4ZT.- 0.( D IBTCFFOEFﬁOFEUPBEESFTTNPSFTZTUFNTPSJFOUFENPEFMTTVDIBTCMPDLEJBHSBNT"OPUIFS FYUFOTJPOPG6.-UIBUBEESFTTFTSFBMUJNFTZTUFNTJT."35&.PEFMJOHBOE"OBMZTJTPG3FBM 5JNFBOE&NCFEEFETZTUFNT %FNBUIJFVFUBM0.( ."35&TVQQPSUTNPEFMJOH BOEEFTJHOPGCPUIIBSEXBSFBOETPGUXBSFBTQFDUTPGUIFTFTZTUFNT ThF "SDIJUFDUVSF "OBMZTJT BOE %FTJHO -BOHVBHF ""%- XBT EFﬁOFE CZ UIF 4PDJFUZ PG "VUPNPUJWF&OHJOFFST 4"& UPCFBTUBOEBSEGPSNPEFMCBTFETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH*UTVQQPSUT GPSNBMNPEFMJOHBOETZTUFNTQFSGPSNBODFBOBMZTJT 'FJMFS (MVDI BOE)VEBL ."35&JT BMTPDPNQBUJCMFXJUI""%- 'BVHFSFFUBM *O UIF IBSEXBSF BSFOB UXP MBOHVBHFT IBWF CFFO VTFE FYUFOTJWFMZ 7)4*$ )BSEXBSF %FTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHF 7)%- BOE7FSJMPH)%-#PUIDPOUBJOIBSEXBSFNPEFMJOHDPOTUSVDUT TVDIBTUJNFDPODFQUTBOEQBSBMMFMQSPDFTTJOH UIBUBSFOPUGPVOEJOUZQJDBMTPGUXBSFQSPHSBNNJOH

202

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

PSNPEFMJOHMBOHVBHFT#PUIBMTPIBWFWBSJBOUTGPSBOBMPHBOENJYFETJHOBMBQQMJDBUJPOT DBMMFE SFTQFDUJWFMZ7)%-".4BOE7FSJMPH".4*O UIFUXPPSHBOJ[BUJPOT7)%-*OUFSOBUJPOBM BOE0QFO7FSJMPH*OUFSOBUJPOBMKPJOFEUPCFDPNF"DDFMMFSB "DDFMMFSB *O UIF*&&&JOJUJBUFEBOFXTUBOEBSEDBMMFE13PTFUUB4ZTUFN%FTJHO-BOHVBHF *)4 The HPBMJTUPQSPWJEFiBTZTUFNMFWFMBQQSPBDIGPSEFWFMPQJOH DPNQPTJOHBOEBOB MZ[JOH speciﬁcation NPEFMT GSPN NVMUJQMF EFTJHO EPNBJOT FBDI XJUI UIFJS PXO WPDBCVMBSZ BOE TFNBOUJDTwThis TIPVMECFPGJOUFSFTUUP4&XJUIUIFNVMUJEPNBJODIBMMFOHFTEJTDVTTFEFBSMJFSJO UIJTDIBQUFS

Architecture Description Languages (ADLs) *OUIFT BDPBMFTDFODFPGSFTFBSDIBDUJWJUZQSPEVDFEBWBSJFUZPGBSDIJUFDUVSFEFTDSJQUJPOMBO HVBHFT JODMVEJOH3BQJEF $ "$.& 8SJHIU "FTPQ BOE6OJDPO"TJHOJﬁDBOUQPSUJPOPGUIJT XPSLXBTGVOEFECZUIF%FGFOTF"EWBODFE3FTFBSDI1SPKFDUT"HFODZ %"31"

BOEUIFQSJNBSZ GPDVTXBTTPGUXBSFTZTUFNT"TVNNBSZPGUIJTXPSL BTXFMMBTBOBQQMJDBUJPO JTQSFTFOUFEJO 1FUUZ .D,FO[JF BOE2JOHXFO "NPSFSFDFOUVOJﬁDBUJPOBOEFYUFOTJPOPGUIJTXPSLJT QSFTFOUFEJO%BTIPGZ 7BOEFS)PFL BOE5BZMPS ThF"%-SFTFBSDIXBTUIFTPVSDFPGUIF HFOFSBMDPNQPOFOUDPOOFDUPSNPEFMUIBUDBOCFBQQMJFEUPBMMTZTUFNT OPUKVTUTPGUXBSFTZTUFNT BOEXIJDIJTUIFCBTJDTUSVDUVSFPGUIFCJOBSZJOUFSBDUJPONPEFMJO$IBQUFS

Software Languages "MBSHFOVNCFSPGQSPHSBNNJOHMBOHVBHFTTVDIBT+BWBBOE7JTVBM#BTJDIBWFCFFOEFWFMPQFEBOE VTFEPWFSUIFQBTUIBMGDFOUVSZ.BOZPGUIFFBSMZMBOHVBHFT JODMVEJOHUIFWFOFSBCMF'PSUSBO BOE FWFO$0#0- BSFTUJMMJOVTF BMUIPVHIUIFZIBWFFWPMWFEUPTPNFEFHSFF ThFSF BSF BMTP NBOZ TDSJQUJOH MBOHVBHFT TVDI BT 1FSM BOE 1ZUIPO .PEFMJOH MBOHVBHFT XF NFOUJPOFEFBSMJFSTVDIBT6.-BSFBMTPVTFEFYUFOTJWFMZJOTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH

Business Process Languages 84#1&- 8FC4FSWJDFT#VTJOFTT1SPDFTT&YFDVUJPO-BOHVBHF JTBOPSDIFTUSBUJPOMBOHVBHFGPS TQFDJGZJOHCVTJOFTTQSPDFTTCFIBWJPSCBTFEPO8FC4FSWJDFT 0"4*4 *UJTCBTFEPO9.- #1./ #VTJOFTT1SPDFTT.PEFMJOH/PUBUJPO JTBHSBQIJDBMNPEFMJOHMBOHVBHFGPSCVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFTPSJFOUFEUPXBSEXPSLﬂPXTThFOFYUWFSTJPO 7 JOUFOETUPJODPSQPSBUFUIFNFUB NPEFM HSBQIJDBMOPUBUJPO BOEJOUFSDIBOHFGPSNBUJOUPPOFQBDLBHF BOEUIFOBNFJTUIFSFGPSF DIBOHFEUPUIF#VTJOFTT1SPDFTT.PEFMBOE/PUBUJPO #1./ ThF9.-1SPDFTT%FﬁOJUJPO-BOHVBHF 91%- JTBOJOUFSDIBOHFMBOHVBHFGPS#1./ :"8- :FU"OPUIFS8PSLﬂPX-BOHVBHF XBTEFTJHOFEUPTVQQPSUBCBTJDTFUPGXPSLﬂPXQBU UFSOTPSWJFXTDPOUSPMQFSTQFDUJWF EBUBQFSTQFDUJWF SFTPVSDFQFSTQFDUJWF BOEFYDFQUJPOIBOEMJOH QFSTQFDUJWF*UBMTPQSPWJEFTTPNFTVQQPSUGPSIVNBOUBTLT )VNBOCVTJOFTTQSPDFTTFTIBWFCFFOHFUUJOHNPSFBUUFOUJPOSFDFOUMZ"OFYUFOTJPOPG#1&- DBMMFE#1&-1FPQMFIBTCFFOEFﬁOFEUIBUGPDVTFTPOIVNBOUBTLT "HSBXBMFUBM "GSBNF XPSLGPSEFﬁOJOHIVNBOTFSWJDFTBOEVOJGZJOHIVNBOBOETPGUXBSFTFSWJDFTJTEFTDSJCFEJO4DIBMM 5SVPOH BOE%VTUEBS )PMNFTFUBM IBWFEFﬁOFEBWJFXCBTFE NPEFMESJWFOGSBNFXPSLUIBUTVQQPSUTCPUI IVNBO BOE BVUPNBUFE CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT *U QSPWJEFT B IJHIFS MFWFM PG BCTUSBDUJPO UIBU BMMPXT

Conceptualization

O

203

CPUIBIVNBOWJFXBOEBUFDIOJDBMWJFXPGCVTJOFTTQSPDFTTFTThJTBQQSPBDIJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUI .04&4

Requirements/External Speciﬁcation Languages "MBSHFWBSJFUZPGTZTUFNSFRVJSFNFOUTPS FYUFSOBM TQFDJﬁDBUJPOMBOHVBHFTIBWFCFFOEFﬁOFEBOE VTFEPWFSUIFQBTUTFWFSBMEFDBEFT NBOZPGUIFNJOTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHThFZSBOHFGSPNOBUVSBM MBOHVBHFUPGPSNBMMBOHVBHFT BOEGSPNHFOFSBMQVSQPTFUPEPNBJOTQFDJﬁ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hFMBOHVBHF5 BDDPSEJOHUP4VOJL

JTBOPQFOOPOFYFDVUBCMFMBOHVBHFUIBUDBOCF VTFEUPNPEFMBXJEFWBSJFUZPGTZTUFNT JODMVEJOHTPGUXBSF IBSEXBSF UFDIOJDBMBQQMJBODFT CJPM PHZTZTUFNT BOELOPXMFEHFSFQSFTFOUBUJPOTZTUFNT 0OUIFPUIFSIBOE FYBNQMFTPGEPNBJOTQFDJﬁDMBOHVBHFTJODMVEFUIF(FPHSBQIJD.BSLVQ -BOHVBHF(.-UPTQFDJGZHFPHSBQIJDJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNT BOEBOVNCFSPGMBOHVBHFTGPSBHFOU TZTUFNT"HFOUMBOHVBHFTJODMVEFUIF$PHOJUJWF"HFOUT4QFDJﬁDBUJPO-BOHVBHF $"4- 4IBQJSP FUBM

UIF"HFOU.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF ".- 5SFODBOTLZBOE$FSWFOLB

BTQFDJﬁDB UJPOMBOHVBHFGPSDPPSEJOBUFEPCKFDUT $JPCBOVBOE-VDBOV

BOEUIF"VUPOPNJD4ZTUFN 4QFDJﬁDBUJPO-BOHVBHF "44- 7BTTFWBOE1BRVFU *OBEEJUJPO BWBSJFUZPGMPHJDTBSFVTFE UPNPEFMBOETQFDJGZBHFOUTBTSBUJPOBMFOUJUJFTThFTFJODMVEF#%* CFMJFG EFTJSF JOUFOUJPO MPH JDT 3BPBOE(FPSHFﬀ

BOEBEZOBNJDGSBNFXPSLCBTFEPO#%*DBMMFE,"30 LOPXMFEHF BCJMJUJFT SFTVMUT PQQPSUVOJUJFT WBO-JOEFS WBOEFS)PFL BOE.FZFS.FZFS WBOEFS)PFL BOEWBO-JOEFS)VTUBEFUBM "HFOUMBOHVBHFTBOEPOUPMPHJFTBSFJNQPSUBOUGPSUIF GVUVSFPG4&CFDBVTFUIFJSDPOTUSVDUTGPDVTPOBVUPOPNPVTCFIBWJPS XIJDIDBOCFBQQMJFEUPCPUI QFPQMFBOETPGUXBSFBHFOUT

XML, Markup Languages 9.- #SBZFUBM JTBUFYUMBOHVBHFEFTJHOFEUPCFVTFEPOUIF*OUFSOFUBOEUPCFSFBEBCMFCZ CPUIIVNBOTBOEDPNQVUFSTJOBWBSJFUZPGEPNBJOT*UJTBTVCTFUPSQSPﬁMFPGUIF4UBOEBSE(FOFSBMJ[FE .BSLVQ-BOHVBHF 4(.-*40 *UJTVTFEUPFYDIBOHFEBUBBNPOHNBDIJOFTCVUBSHVBCMZJUT NPTUTJHOJﬁDBOUSPMFJTBTBNFUBMBOHVBHFPSTQFDJﬁDBUJPOMBOHVBHFGPSNPSFTQFDJBMJ[FENBSLVQMBO HVBHFT"MBSHFOVNCFSPGMBOHVBHFTIBWFCFFOCBTFEPO9.-8FIBWFNFOUJPOFEBGFXPGUIFTFFBS MJFSJOUIJTTFDUJPO5PHJWFBTFOTFPGUIFWBSJFUZPGMBOHVBHFTCBTFEPO9.- IFSFJTBTNBMMTBNQMF O (SBQIJDBMMBOHVBHFTTVDIBT4DBMBCMF7FDUPS(SBQIJDT 47( 8$

O ThF.BUIFNBUJDBM.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF.BUI.- .BUI.-

O &MFDUSPOJD #VTJOFTT VTJOH &YUFOTJCMF .BSLVQ -BOHVBHF FC9.- GPS HMPCBM CVTJOFTT USBOTBDUJPOTPOUIF*OUFSOFU FC9.-

O )VNBO.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF )VNBO.- GPSEFTDSJCJOHIVNBODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOECSJEH JOHDVMUVSBMHBQT 1FMU[BOd ThVOHB

204

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O 4FSWJDF.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 4.- GPSNPEFMJOHTFSWJDFTPOUIF8FCBOEUIFJSDPOTUSBJOUT BOEQPMJDJFT 4.-

O ThF"SDIJUFDUVSF%FTDSJQUJPO.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF "%.-

BO9.-CBTFEFYUFOTJPOPG UIF"$.&BSDIJUFDUVSFEFTDSJQUJPOMBOHVBHF "%.-

O 7PJDF&YUFOTJCMF.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF 7PJDF9.- UPTVQQPSUTQFFDIFOBCMFEBQQMJDBUJPOT 7PJDF *O BEEJUJPO B OVNCFS PG SFMBUFE TUBOEBSET IBWF CFFO EFﬁOFE TVDI BT &YUFOTJCMF 4UZMFTIFFU -BOHVBHF 94-

9.-4DIFNB BOE9.-3FNPUF1SPDFEVSF$BMM 9.-31$ "HSPXJOHOVNCFS PG8FC4FSWJDFTTUBOEBSETBSFBMTPCVJMUPO9.- JODMVEJOH4JNQMF0CKFDU"DDFTT1SPUPDPM 40"1 6OJWFSTBM %FTDSJQUJPO %JTDPWFSZ BOE *OUFHSBUJPO 6%%* 8FC 4FSWJDFT %FTDSJQUJPO -BOHVBHF 84%- BOEBIPTUPGPUIFSTUBOEBSETGPSBEESFTTJOH QPMJDZ DIPSFPHSBQIZ DPPSEJOBUJPO TFDVSJUZ FUD4PNFTUBOEBSET TVDIBT3%'BOE08- BSFQBSUPGUIF4FNBOUJD8FCFﬀPSUUPFYQBOEGSPN IVNBOUPNBDIJOFJOUFSBDUJPOJO8FCUPNPSFNBDIJOFUPNBDIJOFJOUFSBDUJPOJO8FC

Knowledge Representation/Ontology Languages 3%'BOE08-DBOBMTPCFDBUFHPSJ[FEBTLOPXMFEHFSFQSFTFOUBUJPO ,3 PSPOUPMPHZMBOHVBHFT 0OFPGUIFFBSMZ,3MBOHVBHFTGPSFYDIBOHJOHLOPXMFEHFXBT,*' UIF,OPXMFEHF*OUFSDIBOHF 'PSNBU ,*' ,3 BOE POUPMPHZ MBOHVBHFT SBOHF GSPN OBUVSBM MBOHVBHF EJDUJPOBSJFT UP EFTDSJQUJPOPSIJHIPSEFSMPHJDTThJTTQFDUSVNPGPOUPMPHZSFQSFTFOUBUJPOTUSFOHUITBOEDBUFHPSJFT XBTEJTDVTTFEJOUIFQSFWJPVTTFDUJPO

Mathematics and Sciences, and Other Supporting Disciplines .BOZPGUIF4&TVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFTJEFOUJﬁFEJO$IBQUFSDPVMECFSFHBSEFEBTCFJOHPSIBWJOH UIFJSPXOMBOHVBHFTBOEVOJWFSTFTPGEJTDPVSTF4PNFPGUIFTF TVDIBTMPHJDT IBWFCFFOEJTDVTTFE IFSF ThFOVNCFSBOEWBSJFUZPGUIFTFEJTDJQMJOFTBOEMBOHVBHFT FTQFDJBMMZJOUIFGVUVSF4& BSFJO GBDUBNBKPSESJWFSGPSVTJOHPOUPMPHZUPJNQSPWFDPNNVOJDBUJPOBNPOHUIFNJOUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPG 4&TZTUFNT BOEBNBKPSJNQFUVTGPSUIJTDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIF.04&4NPEFMTQBDF

Natural Language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

Language Leverage ThFDPODFQUPGMFWFSBHFJOUSPEVDFEJO$IBQUFSBQQMJFTUPMBOHVBHFT XIJDISBOHFGSPNHFOFSBM QVSQPTFUPTQFDJﬁDUPBOBSSPXEPNBJO'JHVSFTIPXTUIFMFWFSBHFUSBEFPﬀ PGHFOFSBMBOE TQFDJBMJ[FEMBOHVBHFT3FMBUJPOTBOE0QFSBUJPOTJOUIF$PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO%JNFOTJPO

Conceptualization

O

205

! Leverage of specialized domain language

Figure 8.4

Leverage of general purpose language

General and specialized language leverage.

Relations of Conceptualization Dimension Relations between Models 3FMBUJPOTCFUXFFONPEFMTJOUIJTEJNFOTJPOJODMVEFUSBOTMBUJPOPGBNPEFMGSPNPOFMBOHVBHF UPBOPUIFS JOUFSQSFUBUJPOBOEBCTUSBDUJPOPGBNPEFM BOENBQQJOHDPODFQUTCFUXFFOEJﬀFSFOU POUPMPHJFT %BDPOUB 0CSTU BOE4NJUI o "OFYBNQMFPGJOUFSQSFUBUJPOJTBQQMZ JOHTFNBOUJDTUPBGPSNBMBCTUSBDUNPEFMUPQSPEVDFBEPNBJONPEFM XIJMFBCTUSBDUJPOJTUIF DPOKVHBUF UIBU JT SFNPWJOH UIF TFNBOUJDT GSPN B EPNBJO NPEFM BOE QSPEVDJOH B GPSNBM BCTUSBDUNPEFM ThFTFSFMBUJPOTBSFNBOZUPNBOZ.BOZMBOHVBHFTDBOCFUSBOTMBUFEUPNBOZPUIFSMBOHVBHFT BOENBOZPOUPMPHJFTDBOCFNBQQFEUPNBOZPUIFSPOUPMPHJFT"GPSNBMBCTUSBDUNPEFMDBOCF JOUFSQSFUFEJOUPNVMUJQMFEPNBJONPEFMT BOEBEPNBJONPEFMDBOCFBCTUSBDUFEJOUPNVMUJQMF GPSNBMBCTUSBDUNPEFMT

Relation to Commonization Dimension ThFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOVQQFSPOUPMPHJFT NJEMFWFMPOUPMPHJFT BOEEPNBJOPOUPMPHJFTNBQTEJSFDUMZ POUPUIFHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVNGSPNNPTUHFOFSBMUPNPTUTQFDJﬁDNPEFM*OBEEJUJPO UIFDBU FHPSZUPJOTUBODFSFMBUJPOJTDPNNPOUPNPTUHFOFSBMPOUPMPHJFT"OFYBNQMFGSPN+FﬀSFZ o JT UIF GPMMPXJOH QBUUFSO JO IJHIFSPSEFS MPHJD XIJDI JT DPOTJTUFOU XJUI UIF .04&4 DBUFHPSJ[BUJPOIJFSBSDIZQBUUFSO TQFDJﬁDFYBNQMFTIBWFCFFOBEEFE O *OTUBODFT TVDIBTCMVF IBWFDBUFHPSJFT TVDIBTDPMPS BUMFWFM O ThF DBUFHPSJFT BU MFWFM TVDI BT DPMPS CFDPNF JOTUBODFT PG MFWFM DBUFHPSJFT TVDI BT QSPQFSUZ O ThFDBUFHPSJFTBUMFWFMCFDPNFJOTUBODFTPGMFWFMDBUFHPSJFT O FUD "UBHJWFOMFWFMO UIFTUSVDUVSFJTDBMMFEOUIPSEFSMPHJD

206

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Relation to Composition Dimension &YUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBMNPEFMTPGBTZTUFNDBOCFEJﬀFSFOUXPSMET EJﬀFSFOUPOUPMPHJFT BOEEJG GFSFOUMBOHVBHFT BTUIJTDIBQUFSIBTEJTDVTTFEFYUFOTJWFMZThJTQBUUFSOFYUFOETVQBOEEPXOUIF DPNQPTJUJPOTQFDUSVN 8FIBWFQPTJUJPOFEDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBTBEJNFOTJPOJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF&BDIEJNFOTJPOSFQSF TFOUTBTQFDUSVN8IBUEJTUJOHVJTIFTPOFQPJOUPOUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVNGSPNBOPUIFS ThFBOTXFSJTUIBUXFQSPQPTFUIBUEJﬀFSFOUNPEFMTJOUIJTEJNFOTJPOBSFCBTFEPO6%TUIBU IBWFWBSZJOHEFHSFFTPGTJNJMBSJUZ BOEUIJTTJNJMBSJUZDBOQPUFOUJBMMZCFNFBTVSFECZBDPODFQUVBM EJTUBODFGVODUJPO(ÊSEFOGPST oBOE QSPWJEFTBOBQQSPBDIUPUIJT JOXIJDIIF EFﬁOFTEJTUBODFJOBDPODFQUVBMTQBDFBOEEFﬁOFTTJNJMBSJUZBTBOFYQPOFOUJBMMZEFDBZJOHGVODUJPO PGUIBUEJTUBODF$POTJEFSUIFEJTUBODFCFUXFFOUIFVOJWFSTFTPGEJTDPVSTFPGUXPNPEFMTTBZ UIF QSPCMFN TQBDF BOE UIF JOUFSOBM TPMVUJPO JT NFBTVSFE CZ UIF OVNCFS PG USBOTGPSNBUJPOT SFRVJSFEJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFUPSFBDIGSPNPOFUPUIFPUIFS*GXFTJNQMZTBJEUIFOVNCFSPGUSBOT GPSNBUJPOTSFRVJSFEUPSFBDIGSPNPOFUPUIFPUIFS UIFEJTUBODFDPVMEBMXBZTCFEFﬁOFEBTPOF VOJU GSPNFYUFSOBMUPJOUFSOBM )PXFWFS UIJTJTXIFSFUIFSFMBUJPOXJUIUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPODPNFTJOUPQMBZBOEMJN JUTUIFSFBDIPGBHJWFOUSBOTGPSNBUJPOThFSFJTBUMFBTUPOFUSBOTGPSNBUJPOCFUXFFOJOUFSOBMBOE FYUFSOBMNPEFMT8FUZQJDBMMZIBWFNVMUJQMFMFWFMTPGDPNQPTJUJPO BOEUIFSFJTPOFUSBOTGPSNB UJPOGPSFBDIMFWFMThFSFGPSF UIFDPODFQUVBMEJTUBODFCFUXFFONPEFMTJOUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO EJNFOTJPODPVMECFSFﬂFDUFEJOUIFOVNCFSPGMFWFMTPGDPNQPTJUJPOPGUIFTPMVUJPO)PXGBSEPXO XPVMEXFHPJOBQIZTJDBMTZTUFN "OTXFS5PUIFMPXFTUMFWFMUIBUBHFOUTNVTUEFBMXJUI"TXF IBWFTFFOJOQSFWJPVTDIBQUFST XJUIUIFFYUFOEFETDBMFTPG4& UIJTDPVMECFWFSZNBOZMFWFMT*O BOZDBTF JGUIJTOPUJPOIBTNFSJU UIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPODPVMEIFMQNFBTVSFUIFDPODFQUVBM PSTFNBOUJDEJTUBODFBDSPTTUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVN

References "DDFMMFSB"DDFMMFSBIPNFQBHFIUUQXXXBDDFMMFSBPSHIPNF "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ "%.-The 0QFO(SPVQ"SDIJUFDUVSF%FTDSJQUJPO.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF "%.- IUUQXXXPQFO HSPVQPSHBSDIJUFDUVSFBENMBENM@IPNFIUN "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

"HSBXBM " ."NFOE .%BT .'PSE $,FMMFS .,MPQQNBOO %,ÚOJH '-FZNBOO 3.àMMFS (1GBV ,1MÚTTFS 33BOHBTXBNZ "3JDLBZ[FO .3PXMFZ 14DINJEU *5SJDLPWJD ":JV BOE . ;FMMFS 84#1&- &YUFOTJPO GPS 1FPQMF #1&-1FPQMF

7FSTJPO +VOF IUUQ EPXOMPBECPVMEFSJCNDPNJCNEMQVCTPGUXBSFEXTQFDTXTCQFMQFPQMF#1&-1FPQMF@WQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#BF[ + BOE . 4UBZ 1IZTJDT 5PQPMPHZ -PHJD BOE $PNQVUBUJPO " 3PTFUUB 4UPOF5P BQQFBS JO # $PFDLF &E /FX4USVDUVSFTGPS1IZTJDT4QSJOHFSIUUQNBUIVDSFEVIPNFCBF[SPTFUUBQEG "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

#BSS "BOE&'FJHFOCBVNThe )BOECPPLPG"Stiﬁcial *OUFMMJHFODF 7PM-PT"MUPT $"8JMMJBN ,BVGNBOO #'0 #BTJD 'PSNBM 0OUPMPHZ *OTUJUVUF GPS 'PSNBM 0OUPMPHZ BOE .FEJDBM *OGPSNBUJPO 4DJFODF 4BBSMBOE 6OJWFSTJUZ 4BBSCSàDLFO (FSNBOZ IUUQXXXJGPNJTPSHCGPIPNF "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

#1./#VTJOFTT1SPDFTT.PEFMBOE/PUBUJPO #1./ 3'10.(IUUQXXXPNHPSHDHJCJO EPD CNJ "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#SBZ 5 +1BPMJ $.4QFSCFSH.D2VFFO &.BMFS ':FSHFBV BOE+$PXBO &ET9.- TFD POEFEJUJPO

8$3FDPNNFOEBUJPO "VHVTUIUUQXXXXPSH533&$YNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

Conceptualization

O

207

$BSOBQ 3*OUSPEVDUJPOUP4ZNCPMJD-PHJDBOE*UT"QQMJDBUJPOT/FX:PSL%PWFS $JPCBOV ( BOE % -VDBOV " 4peciﬁcation -BOHVBHF GPS $PPSEJOBUFE 0CKFDUT *O 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF$POGFSFODFPO4peciﬁcation BOE7eriﬁcation PG$PNQPOFOU#BTFE4ZTUFNT -JTCPO 1PSUVHBM 4FQUFNCFS 4"7$#4 A /FX :PSL "$. "WBJMBCMF WJB POMJOF "$. 4*(40'54PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH/PUFT

.BSDIIUUQQPSUBMBDNPSHDJUBUJPODGN JE DPMM"$.EM"$.JEY+QBSUOFXTMFUUFS8BOU5ZQF /FXTMFUUFSTUJUMF"$.4*(40'54PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH/PUFT$'*% $'50,&/ "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

$SPTCJF 3 4+BWFZ +)BZ BOE+1FBSDF&4-"OFX$POUJOVPVT4ZTUFN4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF 4JNVMBUJPO o %BDPOUB . - 0CSTU BOE , 4NJUI The 4FNBOUJD 8FC " (VJEF UP UIF 'VUVSF PG 9.- 8FC 4FSWJDFT BOE,OPXMFEHF.BOBHFNFOU*OEJBOBQPMJT */8JMFZ1VCMJTIJOH %BTIPGZ & "WBOEFS)PFL BOE3/5BZMPS"$PNQSFIFOTJWF"QQSPBDIGPSUIF%FWFMPQNFOUPG .PEVMBS4PGUXBSF"SDIJUFDUVSF%FTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHFT"$.5SBOT4PGUXBSF&OH.FUIPEPM o %FNBUIJFV 4 'Thomas, $"OESÏ 4(ÏSBSE BOE'5FSSJFS'JSTU&YQFSJNFOUT6TJOHUIF6.- 1Soﬁle for MAR5&UI*&&&*OU4ZNQPO0CKFDU0SJFOUFE3FBM5JNF%JTUSJCVUFE$PNQVUJOH *403$ Qo FC9.-FC9.-IUUQXXXFCYNMPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

'BVHFSF . 5 #PVSCFBV 3 %F 4JNPOF BOE 4 (FSBSE ."35& "MTP BO 6.- 1Soﬁle GPS .PEFMJOH""%-"QQMJDBUJPOTUI*&&&*OU$POG&OHJOFFSJOH$PNQMFY$PNQVUFS4ZTUFNT Qo 'FJMFS 1 %1 (MVDI BOE ++ )VEBL The "SDIJUFDUVSF "OBMZTJT %FTJHO -BOHVBHF ""%- "O *OUSPEVDUJPO 5FDIOJDBM /PUF $.64&*5/ IUUQXXXTFJDNVFEVQVC EPDVNFOUTSFQPSUTQEGUOQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

(ÊSEFOGPST 1$PODFQUVBM4paces: The GFPNFUSy of Thought. Cambridge, MA: BSBEGPSE.*51SFTT (0#JPMPHJDBM1SPDFTT0OUPMPHZ(VJEFMJOFT(FOF0OUPMPHZ$POTPSUJVNIUUQXXXHFOFPOUPMPHZ PSH(0QSPDFTTHVJEFMJOFTTIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

(SVCFS 5 " 5SBOTMBUJPO "QQSPBDI UP 1PSUBCMF 0OUPMPHZ 4peciﬁcations. ,OPXMFEHF "DRVJTJUJPO o (SVOJOHFS . 0#PEFOSFJEFS '0MLFO -0CSTU BOE1:JNThe 0OUPMPHZ4VNNJU+PJOU $PNNVOJRVÏ 0OUPMPHZ 5BYPOPNZ 'PMLTPOPNZ 6OEFSTUBOEJOH UIF %JTUJODUJPOT + "QQM 0OUPM o (VBSJOP /'PSNBM0OUPMPHZBOE*OGPSNBUJPO4ZTUFNT*O'PSNBM0OUPMPHZJO*OGPSNBUJPO4ZTUFNT 1SPDFFEJOHT PG '0*4 / (VBSJOP &E5SFOUP *UBMZ o +VOF "NTUFSEBN *04 1SFTT Qo )FDLNBOO % 5 4DIXBSU[ # #SBOEIFSN . 4DINJU[ BOE . WPO 8JMBNPXJU[.oellendorﬀ. (6.0The (FOFSBM6TFS.PEFM0OUPMPHZ JO1SPD6.*OU$POG6TFS.PEFMJOH +VMZ o &EJOCVSHI 6, )FSSF ) #)FMMFS 1#VSFL 3)PFIOEPSG '-PFCF BOE).JDIBMFL(FOFSBM'PSNBM0OUPMPHZ ('0 " 'PVOEBUJPOBM 0OUPMPHZ *OUFHSBUJOH 0CKFDUT BOE 1SPDFTTFT 1BSU * #BTJD 1SJODJQMFT 3FTFBSDI (SPVQ 0OUPMPHJFT JO .FEJDJOF 0OUP.FE

6OJWFSTJUZ PG -FJQ[JH7FSTJPO 0OUP .FE 3FQPSU /S IUUQXXXPOUPNFEEF"SDIJWPOUPNFEFOQVCMJDBUJPOT scientiﬁc-rFQPSUTPNSFQPSUOPQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)PMNFT 5 )5SBO 6;EVO BOE4%VTUEBS.PEFMJOH)VNBO"TQFDUTPG#VTJOFTT1SPDFTTFT" 7JFX#BTFE .PEFM%SJWFO"QQSPBDIIUUQXXX.infosys.tuwien.ac.at/staﬀ/tholmes/publications/ IVNBO@WCNQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)POEFSJDI5. 1995. The OxforE$PNQBOJPOUP1IJMPTPQIZ/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT )VOUTJOHFS 3$POUJOVPVT4ZTUFN4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHFT $44-T 1SPD8JOUFS4JNVMBUJPO$POG )VTUBEU 6 $%JYPO 3"4DINJEU .'JTIFS ++$.FZFS BOE8WBOEFS)PFL3FBTPOJOH BCPVU BHFOUT JO UIF ,"30 GSBNFXPSL *O 1SPD UI *OU 4ZNQ 5FNQPSBM 3FQSFTFOUBUJPO BOE 3FBTPOJOH 5*.&

$#FUUJOJBOE".POUBOBSJ &ET Qo*&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ IUUQDJUFTFFSJTUQTVFEVIVTUBEUSFBTPOJOHIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

208

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

*)4*&&&4UBSUT4UBOEBSEGPS3PTFUUB4ZTUFN%FTJHO-BOHVBHF*&&&1IUUQFMFDUSPOJDTJIT DPNOFXTJFFFSPTFUUBMBOHVBHFIUN "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

+eﬀrFZ 3'PSNBM-PHJD*UT4DPQFBOE-JNJUT/FX:PSL.D(SBX)JMM ,BMGPHMPV : # )V % 3FZOPMET BOE / 4IBECPMU $BQUVSJOH 3FQSFTFOUJOH BOE 0QFSBUJPOBMJTJOH 4FNBOUJD *OUFHSBUJPO $304* QSPKFDU ﬁnal SFQPSU IUUQFQSJOUTFDTTPUPOBDVL "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

,BVTIJL 4 %8JKFTFLFSB BOE1"NNBOO"O"MHFCSBGPS0OUPMPHJFT*OU$POG'PSNBM0OUPMPHZJO *OGPSNBUJPO4ZTUFNT '0*4 #BMUJNPSF .% o/PWFNCFS "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

,*',OPXMFEHF*OUFSDIBOHF'PSNBUESBGUQSPQPTFE"NFSJDBO/BUJPOBM4UBOEBSE EQ"/4 /$*54 5IUUQMPHJDTUBOGPSEFEVLJGEQBOTIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

,JSZBLPW " , 4JNPW BOE . %JNJUSPW 0OUP.BQ 1PSUBM GPS 6QQFS-FWFM 0OUPMPHJFT 1SPD 'PSNBM 0OUPMPHZ JO *OGPSNBUJPO 4ZTUFNT '0*4 o 0DUPCFS 0HVORVJU .& IUUQXXXPOUPUFYUDPNQVCMJDBUJPOTGPJTQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

-FF 4BOE)4:POH$PNQPOFOU#BTFE"QQSPBDIUP)BOEMF4ZOPOZNBOE1PMZTFNZJO'PMLTPOPNZ UI *&&& *OU $POG $PNQVUFS BOE *OGPSNBUJPO 5FDIOPM $*5 o 0DUPCFS Qo -FOBU % $:$ B MBSHFTDBMF JOWFTUNFOU JO LOPXMFEHF JOGSBTUSVDUVSF $PNNVO "$. o -FOBU %BOE3(VIB#VJMEJOH-BSHF,OPXMFEHF#BTFE4ZTUFNT3FQSFTFOUBUJPOBOE*OGFSFODFJO UIF$ZD1SPKFDU#PTUPO .""EEJTPO8FTMFZ .BTPMP $ 4#PSHP "(BOHFNJ /(VBSJOP BOE"0MUSBNBSJ8POEFS8FC%FMJWFSBCMF% 0OUPMPHZ-JCSBSZ(ﬁnal). -BCPSBUPSZ'PS"QQMJFE0OUPMPHZ*45$$/3 5SFOUP *UBMZIUUQ XXXMPBDOSJU1BQFST%QEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ .BUI.-.BUIFNBUJDBM.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF .BUI.- 7FSTJPOIUUQXXXXPSH53.BUI.- "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

.BUVMFWJƦJVT 3 1 )FZNBOT BOE "- 0QEBIM 0OUPMPHJDBM "OBMZTJT PG ,"04 6TJOH 4FQBSBUJPO PG 3FGFSFODF 1SPD UI $"J4& *OU 8PSLTIPQ PO &YQMPSJOH .PEFMJOH .FUIPET JO 4ZTUFNT "OBMZTJTBOE%FTJHO &..4"%

-VYFNCPVSH +VOF Qo .D$PNC %4FNBOUJDTJO#VTJOFTT4ZTUFNTThe 4BWWZ.BOBHFST(VJEFUIF%JTDJQMJOF6OEFSMZJOH 8FC4FSWJDFT #VTJOFTT3VMFT BOEUIF4FNBOUJD8FC4BO'SBODJTDP.PSHBO,BVGNBOO .D(VJOOFTT %0OUPMPHJFT$PNFPG"HF*O4QJOOJOHUIF4FNBOUJD8FC#SJOHJOHUIF8PSME8JEF8FCUP *UT'VMM1PUFOUJBM %'FOTFM +)FOEMFS )-JFCFSNBO BOE88BIMTUFS &ET$BNCSJEHF .".*5 1SFTT .FZFS ++$I 8WBOEFS)PFL BOE#WBO-JOEFS "MPHJDBMBQQSPBDIUPUIFEZOBNJDTPGDPN NJUNFOUT "Stiﬁcial *OUFMMJHFODF o IUUQDJUFTFFSJTUQTVFEVDIMPHJDBMIUNM "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

/BLBTPOF "BOE.*TIJ[VLB4UPSZUFMMJOH0OUPMPHZ.PEFMVTJOH3451SPDUIF*&&&8*$"$.*OU $PO*OUFMMJHFOU"HFOU5FDIOPMPHZ Qo /BVNBO . BOE ' )VTTBJO $PNNPO 4FOTF BOE 'PMLTPOPNZ &OHJOFFSJOH BO *OUFMMJHFOU 4FBSDI 4ZTUFN*OU$POG*OGPSNBUJPOBOE&NFSHJOH5FDIOPMPHJFT*$*&5o+VMZ Qo 0"4*48FC4FSWJDFT#VTJOFTT1SPDFTT&YFDVUJPO-BOHVBHF7FSTJPO0"4*44UBOEBSEIUUQEPDT PBTJTPQFOPSHXTCQFMXTCQFMWQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

OBO. 2008. The OQFO#JPNFEJDBM0OUPMPHJFTIUUQXXXPCPGPVOESZPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0CSTU - The 0OUPMPHZ 4QFDUSVN BOE 4FNBOUJD .PEFMT 1SFTFOUFE BU 0OUPMPHZ GPS UIF *OUFMMJHFODF $PNNVOJUZ5PXBSETEﬀectivF&YQMPJUBUJPOBOE*OUFHSBUJPOPG*OUFMMJHFODF3FTPVSDFT$PMVNCJB .% /PWFNCFSo%FDFNCFS63-IUUQODPSVTPJDPCSTUQQU "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU .BOBHFNFOU (SPVQ B 6niﬁed .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF 0.( 6.-

4VQFSTUSVDUVSF 7 0.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU 63- IUUQXXX PNHPSHTQFD6.-4VQFSTUSVDUVSF1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU .BOBHFNFOU (SPVQ C 6niﬁed .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF 0.( 6.-

*OGSBTUSVDUVSF 7 0.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU 63- IUUQXXX PNHPSHTQFD6.-*OGSBTUSVDUVSF1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

Conceptualization

O

209

0.( 0CKFDU.BOBHFNFOU(SPVQ D4ZTUFNT.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 0.(4ZT.-

70.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU 63- IUUQXXXPNHPSHTQFD 4ZT.-1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( The oﬃcial 0.( ."35& 8FC TJUF IUUQXXXPNHNBSUFPSH "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

0QFO$ZD0QFO$ZD'PSNBMJ[FE$PNNPO,OPXMFEHFIUUQXXXPQFODZDPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

1FMU[ +BZBOE3,Thunga. )VNBO.-The 7JTJPOIUUQXXXPBTJTPQFOPSHDPNNJUUFFTEPXO MPBEQIQ)VNBO.-3FQPSU8IJUF1BQFSQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

1FUUZ .% '% .D,FO[JF 9 2JOHXFO 6TJOH B TPGUXBSF BSDIJUFDUVSF EFTDSJQUJPO MBOHVBHF UP NPEFMUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFBOESVOUJNFQFSGPSNBODFPGBGFEFSBUF1SPD4JYUI*&&&*OU8PSLTIPQPO %JTUSJCVUFE4JNVMBUJPOBOE3FBM5JNF"QQMJDBUJPOT Qo 1PMJ 3BOE-0CSTUThe *OUFSQMBZ#FUXFFO0OUPMPHZBT$BUFHPSJBM"OBMZTJTBOE0OUPMPHZBT5FDIOPMPHZ $IBQUFS JO 1BSU 0OF 0OUPMPHZ BT5FDIOPMPHZ JO UIF CPPL 5"0 TheorZ BOE "QQMJDBUJPOT PG 0OUPMPHZ 7PMVNF The *OGPSNBUJPO4DJFODF 4UBODF . )FBMZ " ,BNFBT BOE 3 1PMJ &ET 'PSUIDPNJOH 4QSJOHFS 3BD[ZOTLJ 4.PEFMJOHBOE4JNVMBUJPO$PNQVUFS4DJFODFPG*MMVTJPO $IJDIFTUFS &OHMBOE+PIO8JMFZ 3BP "BOE.1(eorgeﬀ. .PEFMJOHSBUJPOBMBHFOUTXJUIJOB#%*BSDIJUFDUVSF*O1SPDFFEJOHTPG UIF4FDPOE*OUFSOBUJPOBM$POGFSFODFPO1SJODJQMFTPG,OPXMFEHF3FQSFTFOUBUJPOBOE3FBTPOJOH ,3 +"MMFO 3'JLFT BOE&4BOEFXBMM &ET4BO'SBODJTDP.PSHBO,BVGNBOO Qo IUUQDJUFTFFSJTUQTVFEVSBPNPEFMJOHIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

4DIBMM % )-5SVPOH BOE4%VTUEBS0OVOJGZJOHIVNBOBOETPGUXBSFTFSWJDFTGPSBEIPDBOE QSPDFTTDFOUSJDDPMMBCPSBUJPO*&&&*OUFSOFU$PNQVUJOH o 4%-8IBUJT4%- IUUQXXXTEMGPSVNPSH4%-JOEFYIUN "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

4IBQJSP 4 :-FTQÏSBODF BOE)+-FWFTRVFThe $PHOJUJWF"HFOUT4peciﬁcation -BOHVBHFBOE7eriﬁcation &OWJSPONFOUGPS.VMUJBHFOU4ZTUFNT""."4 o+VMZ #PMPHOB *UBMZ"$. 4JPSQBFT , . )FQQ " ,MPU[ . )BDLM BOE UIF NZ0OUPMPHZ $POTPSUJVN NZ0OUPMPHZ JO B /VUTIFMM 3FMFBTF 1SJNFS IUUQXXXNZPOUPMPHZPSHEPDTSFMFBTFQSJNFSNZPOUPMPHZLTJPSQBFT QEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

4NJUI ##FZPOE$PODFQUT0OUPMPHZBT3FBMJUZ3FQSFTFOUBUJPO*O1SPDThirE*OU$POGPO'PSNBM 0OUPMPHZJO*OGPSNBUJPO4ZTUFNT '0*4 "NTUFSEBN*041SFTT Qo 4NJUI #BOE$8FMUZ0OUPMPHZ5PXBSETB/FX4ZOUIFTJT*OUSPEVDUJPOUPUIF4FDPOE*OU$POG 'PSNBM0OUPMPHZBOE*OGPSNBUJPO4ZTUFNT'0M4M o0DUPCFS 0HVORVJU .& QJJJoJY 4NJUI # . "TICVSOFS $ 3PTTF + #BSE 8 #VH 8 $FVTUFST - (PMECFSH , &JMCFDL " *SFMBOE $ .VOHBMM UIF 0#* $POTPSUJVN / -FPOUJT 1 3PDDB4FSSB " 3VUUFOCFSH 4 4BOTPOF 3 4DIFVFSNBOO /4IBI 18IFU[FM BOE4-FXJTThe 0#0'PVOESZDPPSEJOBUFEFWPMVUJPO PGPOUPMPHJFTUPTVQQPSUCJPNFEJDBMEBUBJOUFHSBUJPO/BUVSF#JPUFDIOPM oIUUQ XXXOBUVSFDPNOCUKPVSOBMWOGVMMOCUIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

4.-4FSWJDF.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 7FSTJPO8$8PSLJOH%SBGU.BSDIIUUQXXXXPSH 53TNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

46.04VHHFTUFE6QQFS.FSHFE0OUPMPHZ*&&&IUUQXXXPOUPMPHZQPSUBMPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

4unik, B. 2005. The speciﬁcation language 5"$.4*(1-"//PUJDFT o 5SFODBOTLZ * BOE 3 $FSWFOLB "HFOU .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF ".- B DPNQSFIFOTJWF BQQSPBDI UP NPEFMJOH."4*OGPSNBUJDBo WBO -JOEFS # 8 WBO EFS )PFL BOE + .FZFS 'PSNBMJ[JOH BCJMJUJFT BOE PQQPSUVOJUJFT PG BHFOUT 'VOEBNFOUB*OGPSNBUJDBF o 7BTTFW &BOE+1BRVFU "44-"VUPOPNJD4ZTUFN4peciﬁcation -BOHVBHF1SPDTU"OOV*&&& /"4"4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH8PSLTIPQ 4&8

#BMUJNPSF .% o.BSDI Qo 7PJDF7PJDF9.-0WFSWJFXIUUQXXXWPJDFYNMPSHPWFSWJFXIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

8$ 4DBMBCMF 7FDUPS (SBQIJDT 47( 'VMM 4QFDJGJDBUJPO 8$ 8PSLJOH %SBGU "QSJM IUUQXXXXPSH5347( "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

210 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

8BOE 5BOE38FCFS0OUIFPOUPMPHJDBMFYQSFTTJWFOFTTPGJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTBOBMZTJTBOEEFTJHO HSBNNBST+*OGPSNBUJPO4ZTUFNT o 8BOE 5 BOE 3 8FCFS 0O UIF EFFQ TUSVDUVSF PG JOGPSNBUJPO TZTUFNT + *OGPSNBUJPO 4ZTUFNT o 8FJU[FOGFME " . "SCJC BOE " "MFYBOEFS The /FVSBM 4JNVMBUJPO -BOHVBHF " 4ZTUFN GPS #SBJO .PEFMJOH$BNCSJEHF .".*51SFTT 8PSE/FU 8PSE/FU " -FYJDBM %BUBCBTF GPS UIF &OHMJTI -BOHVBHF $PHOJUJWF 4DJFODF -BCPSBUPSZ 1SJODFUPO6OJWFSTJUZ 1SJODFUPO /+IUUQXPSEOFUQSJODFUPOFEV "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

Chapter 9

Time Systems taxonomy 1

Modeling scope

SE Application Domains (D1...Dn)

Collective actualization space

D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn

Problem space

3a

TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b Traditional Complex

Characteristics of all systems

Highest level system

Deﬁne need

Complex 4 Traditional TS is special case 5 Characteristics of all SE systems Traditional and Complex 6

Model Space

All SE application domains...

Indivisible Unit Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Composition

TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b 2a Traditional systems Complex systems

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

The DPODFQUPGUJNFJTBDSJUJDBMFMFNFOUJOTZT UFNTFOHJOFFSJOH*UMFBETEJSFDUMZUPUIFTVCKFDU PGDIBOHF BOEJOQBSUJDVMBS SBJTFTUIFGPMMPXJOH RVFTUJPO)PXEPXFBEFRVBUFMZBEESFTTDIBOHF JO TZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH This DIBQUFS EJTDVTTFT DPODFQUTPGUJNF UZQFTPGDIBOHF BOEFTQFDJBMMZ MFWFMTPGDIBOHF"SVOOJOHUIFNFJTUIFBQQMJ DBUJPOPGDIBOHFNPEFMTGSPNCJPMPHZ

Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

e

m

Ti

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

Produce solution

Deployment

Satisfy need

Solution/system space

Time and Change: An Introduction to Basic Concepts 1SFWJPVTDIBQUFST FTQFDJBMMZ$IBQUFS IBWFEJTDVTTFEUIFDPODFQUPGTJNJMBSJUJFTBOEdiﬀerFODFT*O UIJTDIBQUFSXFMPPLBUUIFUFNQPSBMBTQFDUTPGUIFTFDPODFQUT0OFXBZUPUIJOLBCPVUUIJTDIBQUFSJT UIBUUIFUJNFEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFJTBUFNQPSBMTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOPGTJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFT 8FUIJOLPGTJNJMBSJUZBDSPTTUJNFBTTUBCJMJUZ BOEdiﬀerFODFTPSWBSJBCJMJUZBDSPTTUJNFBTDIBOHF" CSJEHFCFUXFFOUIFUXPJTUIBUJOWBSJBOUTSFQSFTFOUXIBUJTDPNNPOBOETUBCMF BOEWBSJBOUTSFQSF TFOUXIBUdiﬀers BOEDIBOHFT*GFWFSZUIJOHXFSFTUBCMF UIFOUJNFDPVMECFBCTUSBDUFEBXBZ BOEXF XPVMEOPUOFFEUPJODMVEFUIJTDIBQUFS PSUIFUJNFEJNFOTJPOJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF)PXFWFS DIBOHF JTVCJRVJUPVTUIBUJT JUJTFWFSZXIFSFBOEJUJTDPOUJOVBMJOUIFOBUVSBMXPSMEBOEUIFFOHJOFFSJOH world. TherFGPSF DIBOHFJTUIFBTQFDUPGUJNFUIBUNPUJWBUFTBOEEPNJOBUFTUIJTDIBQUFS 8FCFMJFWFUIBUUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 54& IBTOPUHJWFOsuﬃcient BUUFOUJPOUPUFN QPSBMDIBOHFJOTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 4& QSPDFTTFTBOEJOUIFBTTVNQUJPOTBCPVUFOHJOFFSFETZT UFNTBOEUIFJSFOWJSPONFOUT"T%ÚSOFS QPJOUTPVU IVNBOTDBONPSFSFBEJMZEFUFDUGPSNT BOEQBUUFSOTJOTQBDFUIBOPWFSUJNF"LFZNFTTBHFPGUIJTDIBQUFSJTUIBU.04&4BTTVNFTDPO UJOVBMDIBOHFBTUIFOPSN OPUUIFFYDFQUJPO1BSBEPYJDBMMZ UIBUBTTVNQUJPOCFIPPWFTVTUPﬁnd TUBCJMJUZBUBQQSPQSJBUFQMBDFTJOUIFNPEFMTQBDFOPUUPGPSDFTUBCJMJUZPSUPQSFUFOEUIBUUIFSFJT TUBCJMJUZ CVUUPﬁnd OBUVSBMTUBCJMJUZXIFSFJUFYJTUTBOEXIFSFJUDBOQSPWJEFBDPOUFYUGPSDIBOHF" NBKPSBJNPGUIJTCPPLJTUPBSUJDVMBUFUIFTUBCJMJUJFTPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH.BKPSspeciﬁc FYBNQMFT 211

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

212 O

Figure 9.1

Differences within and across systems.

PGTUBCJMJUZBSFUIF4&TDJFODFDPODFQUTEFTDSJCFEUISPVHIPVUUIJTCPPLBOEHFOFSBMNPEFMTJOUIF DPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF EFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS

Differences within and across Systems %iﬀerFODFTJODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGTZTUFN4CFUXFFOUJNF5BOE5BSFOPUJOIFSFOUMZEJTUJOHVJTI BCMFGSPNdiﬀerFODFTCFUXFFODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGTZTUFNT4BOE4BUUJNF5'JHVSFTIPXT CPUIUZQFTPGdiﬀerFODFTThe BSSPXiBwSFQSFTFOUTUIFdiﬀerFODFCFUXFFO4BOE4BUBHJWFO UJNF BOEUIFBSSPXiCwSFQSFTFOUTUIFdiﬀerFODFPSDIBOHFPGTZTUFN4BDSPTTUJNF4BUUJNF5 NBZMPPLMJLF4BUUJNF5 TPUIFdiﬀerFODFTiBwBOEiCwNBZCFJOEJTUJOHVJTIBCMF%iﬀerFODFT SFQSFTFOUFECZiBwXFSFUIFTVCKFDUPG$IBQUFS*OUIJTDIBQUFSXFMPPLQSJNBSJMZBUdiﬀerFODFTPS DIBOHFTSFQSFTFOUFECZiCwUIBUPDDVSBDSPTTUJNF"OEUPTPNFEFHSFFXFBMTPMPPLBUUIFDPNCJOB tion of both types of diﬀerFODFT

Whether Something Is Static or Dynamic 8FNJHIUUIJOLUIBUUIFRVFTUJPOPGXIFUIFSBHJWFOTZTUFNPSNPEFMJTTUBUJDPSEZOBNJDJTUSJWJBM PSPCWJPVT CVUUIJTTFDUJPOEJTDVTTFTXIZJUJTTPNFUJNFTOFJUIFSUSJWJBMOPSPCWJPVT,FFQJONJOE UIBUJOUIFDPOUFYUPG.04&4 UIFQFSUJOFOURVFTUJPOJTOPUOFDFTTBSJMZXIFUIFSTPNFUIJOHJTTUBUJD PSEZOBNJDUIFRVFTUJPOJTIPXEPXFDIPPTFUPNPEFMUIFTJUVBUJPO $POTJEFSBOFOUJUZ BDIBSBDUFSJTUJD BOEBspeciﬁed UJNFSBOHFThe FOUJUZJTTUBUJDXJUISFTQFDU UPUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDBOEUIFUJNFSBOHFJGUIFWBMVFPGUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDEPFTOPUDIBOHFPWFSUIF DPVSTFPGUIFUJNFSBOHFThe FOUJUZJTEZOBNJDJOUIBUDPOUFYUJGUIFWBMVFPGUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDEPFT DIBOHFPWFSUIFDPVSTFPGUIFUJNFSBOHF /BOO QSPWJEFTBOFYBNQMFPGTDBMFJOUIFJOUFSQSFUBUJPOPGTUBUJDWFSTVTEZOBNJD ziEZOBNJDwNPEFMTBSFUIPTFUIBUBSFGSFRVFOUMZSFCVJMUPSSFUSBJOFEzi'SFRVFOUw JTdeﬁned BTXIFOFOPVHIIJTUPSJDBMEBUBIBTCFFOHBUIFSFEUPQSPWJEFJOGPSNBUJPO UIBUJTTUBUJTUJDBMMZSFMFWBOUUPUIFNPEFM*OUIFDPOUFYUPGUIJTBOBMZTJT iGSFRVFOUwXBT BQQSPYJNBUFMZFWFSZTJYUZEBZT

Time

O

213

)FSFJTBTDBMFJOXIJDIBNPEFMUIBUDIBOHFTFWFSZEBZTJTDPOTJEFSFEEZOBNJDTherFBSFNBOZ TDBMFTJOXIJDIBNPEFMUIBUEPFTOPUDIBOHFGPSEBZTJTDPOTJEFSFEBTUBUJDNPEFMThis JODMVEFT a deﬁned world of any time period within those 60 days. The EJTUJODUJPOJTSFMBUFEUPDZDMFT BTEJTDVTTFEJOUIJTDIBQUFS BOEUPWJFXTBTEJTDVTTFEJO $IBQUFS " NPEFM DBO CF TUBUJD PS EZOBNJD BOE JUT WJFX PG UIF TZTUFN DBO CF TUBUJD PS EZOBNJD " TUSVDUVSFEJBHSBNPSDMBTTEJBHSBNJTBOFYBNQMFPGBTUBUJDNPEFMXJUIBTUBUJDWJFXPGBTZTUFN &YBNQMFTPGTUBUJDNPEFMTXJUIEZOBNJDWJFXTPGBTZTUFNBSFBTUBUFNBDIJOFNPEFM 1FUSJOFU NPEFM diﬀerFOUJBMFRVBUJPOTPGBTZTUFNUSBKFDUPSZ TPGUXBSFTPVSDFDPEF BNVTJDTDPSF PSBGPPE SFDJQF*OFBDIPGUIFTFDBTFT UIFNPEFMJTBTUBUJDTFUPGTZNCPMTXIFOESJWFOPSBDUFEPOCZBO BQQSPQSJBUFBHFOU JUEFQJDUTEZOBNJDTZTUFNCFIBWJPS

Measuring Change )PXEPXFEFUFSNJOFJGBTZTUFNDIBOHFTBOEUIFOBUVSFPGUIPTFDIBOHFT The XBZXFNFBTVSF DIBOHFDBOsigniﬁcantly aﬀect UIFBOTXFSTXFPCUBJOBOEaﬀect PVSQFSDFQUJPOPGBQSPDFTT8F JMMVTUSBUFUIFNFBTVSement eﬀect with an example. 4VQQPTFBUFBNPGﬁvFFYUSBUFSSFTUSJBMTXBOUTUPDPOEVDUTPNFSFTFBSDIPODFSUBJODIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PGUIFi&BSUIwBOEUIFi4VO wBOEUIFZIBWFWFSZMJNJUFELOPXMFEHF8FTQFMMPVUFYBDUMZXIBUUIFZ LOPXBOETPNFLFZUIJOHTUIFZEPOPULOPX Their knoXMFEHFJTCBTFEPOBOPOUPMPHZUIBUDPOTJTUTPOMZPGUIFTFUFSNTBOENFBOJOHT O &BSUICJHSPDLﬂoating JOTQBDF JOPVSPOUPMPHZ JUJTFRVJWBMFOUUPPVSQMBOFU&BSUI XJUI JUTBUUFOEBOUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT O 'JYFE QPJOU PO TVSGBDF PG &BSUI QMBDF PO UIF CJH SPDL XIFSF UIFZ XJMM DPOEVDU UIFJS SFTFBSDI O 4VOCSJHIUPCKFDUPWFSIFBE WJTJCMFGSPNﬁxFEQPJOU JOPVSPOUPMPHZ JUJTFRVJWBMFOUUP PVS4VO XJUIJUTSPMFJOUIFTPMBSTZTUFN O 0SJFOUBUJPOOPSUI TPVUI FBTU XFTU XJUIPVSVTVBMNFBOJOHPGUIFTFEJSFDUJPOT O .FBTVSFNFOUDPMMFDUJPOPGJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUMPDBUJPOBOEPSJFOUBUJPOPG4VOSFMBUJWFUP ﬁxFEQPJOU O 5JNFQPJOUBOEUJNFJOUFSWBMUIFZIBWFPVSVTVBMNFBOJOHPGUIFTFDPODFQUT FYDFQUUIBU UIFZEPOPUVTFPVSVOJUTPGUJNFJOUFSWBMT TFDPOE IPVS EBZ XFFL NPOUI ZFBS They VTFUIFJSPXOJOUFSWBMT XIJDIUIFZDBMM/ / / / BOE/The SFMBUJPOPGUIFJS JOUFSWBMTUPPVSTJTHJWFOCFMPX O /VNCFST DPVOUJOHThey VTFPVSOVNCFSTZTUFN BOEUIFZDBOBMMDPVOU BUMFBTUVQUP TJY Their HFOFSBMLOPXMFEHFEPFTOPUJODMVEFPVSDPODFQUTPGTPMBSTZTUFNT SPUBUJPOPGBQMBOFU SFWPMVUJPOPGBQMBOFUBSPVOEBTVO PSUIFSPMFTQMBZFECZUIFTVOJOBTPMBSTZTUFN5PUIFN 4VO JTTJNQMZBXPSEUIBUSFGFSTUPUIBUCSJHIUPCKFDUWJTJCMFGSom the ﬁxFEQPJOU 1VSQPTFPGSFTFBSDI6TJOHGBJSMZQSFDJTFNFBTVSFNFOUT EFUFSNJOFXIFUIFS4VODIBOHFTQPTJUJPO SFMBUJWFUPﬁxFEQPJOUBOEPSJFOUBUJPO BOEJGTP XIBUUIPTFDIBOHFTBSF.FUIPE5BLFQFSJPEJD TBNQMFNFBTVSFNFOUTPGQPTJUJPOPG4VOGSPNﬁxFEQPJOUBOEﬁxFEPSJFOUBUJPO&BDISFTFBSDIFS XJMMUBLFTJYTBNQMFTBUBdiﬀerFOUSBUF JOUFSWBMTDPSSFTQPOEJOHSFTQFDUJWFMZUP/UISPVHI/ UP NBLFTVSFUIFZHFUHPPEDPWFSBHFPGDIBOHFJGBOZFYJTUTThey BMMTFMFDUBDPNNPOTUBSUUJNFBUB DPNNPOﬁxFEMPDBUJPO XIJDIUVSOPVUUPCF JOPVSUFSNT OPUUIFJST OPPOMPDBMTUBOEBSEUJNF

214 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

PO.BSDIBUBQPJOUUIBUJTOPUOFBSFJUIFSUIF/PSUIPS4PVUI1PMF0VSBTTVNQUJPOGPSUIJT SFTFBSDIQSPKFDUUIF4VOXJMMOPUCFIJEEFOCZDMPVETGSPNUIFﬁxFEQPJOUXIFOFWFSUIFZXBOUUP UBLFBTBNQMFNFBTVSFNFOU The ﬁvFSFTFBSDIFSTBSFidentiﬁed BT&5UISPVHI&5&BDIPGUIFJSFYQFSJNFOUTJTdeﬁned BT GPMMPXT O &5TBNQMFTBUBSBUFPGPODFFWFSZ/UJNFJOUFSWBM XIJDIUVSOTPVUUPCF JOPVSUFSNT PODFFWFSZNJOVUFT TPUIFﬁrst TBNQMJOHQFSJPEJTIPVST GSPNOPPOUPQN PO.BSDI O &5TBNQMFTBUBSBUFPGPODFFWFSZ/UJNFJOUFSWBM XIJDIUVSOTPVUUPCFPODFFWFSZ IPVST TPUIFTFDPOETBNQMJOHQFSJPEJTOFBSMZEBZT OPPOPO.BSDI BN PO.BSDI FUD O &5TBNQMFTBUBSBUFPGPODFFWFSZ/UJNFJOUFSWBM XIJDIUVSOTPVUUPCFPODFFWFSZ XFFLT TPUIFUIJSETBNQMJOHQFSJPEJTXFFLT O &5TBNQMFTBUBSBUFPGPODFFWFSZ/UJNFJOUFSWBM XIJDIUVSOTPVUUPCFPODFFWFSZ NPOUIT TPUIFGPVSUITBNQMJOHQFSJPEJTNPOUIT O &5TBNQMFTBUBSBUFPGPODFFWFSZ/UJNFJOUFSWBM XIJDIUVSOTPVUUPCFPODFFWFSZ ZFBS, so the ﬁfth sampling period is 5 yFBST BUOPPOPO.BSDIFBDIZFBS &BDISFTFBSDIFSXSJUFTVQBSFQPSUBUUIFFOEPGUIFQSPKFDUTheir FYFDVUJWFTVNNBSJFT FBDIFYQSFTTFE JOUFSNTPGXIFUIFSBOEIPX4VONPWFTXJUISespect to the ﬁxFEQPJOUBOEPSJFOUBUJPO BSF O O O O O

&54VONPWFTBDZDMJDBMMZGSPNFBTUUPXFTU &54VONPWFTBDZDMJDBMMZGSPNXFTUUPFBTU &54VONPWFTBDZDMJDBMMZGSPNOPSUIUPTPVUI &54VONPWFTDZDMJDBMMZ OPSUIUPTPVUIUPOPSUIUPTPVUI &54VOEPFTOPUNPWF

The committee that sponsorFEUIJTSFTFBSDIDPODMVEFTUIBUGVSUIFSSFTFBSDIJTOFFEFE

Types of Change The FBSMZ8FTUFSODPODFQUPGUJNFXBTOPUBOBSSPX BPOFEJSFDUJPOBMMJOFBSﬂoXXJUIXIJDIXF PGUFODPODFQUVBMJ[FUJNFJUXBTUIFDPODFQUPGDZDMFFWFSZUIJOH EBZOJHIU MVOBSDZDMF TFBTPOT FUD DPNJOHCBDLUPUIFTBNFTUBUFQFSJPEJDBMMZ /PWJLPW *O4&XFNBLFFYUFOTJWFVTFPG CPUINPEFMUZQFTBDZDMJDBOEDZDMJDﬂoXThis TVCTFDUJPOEJTDVTTFTTFWFSBMBTQFDUTPGDZDMJDBOE BDZDMJDDIBOHFNPEFMT

Cyclic Models The cyDMJDNPEFMUZQFIBTTFWFSBMWBSJBUJPOT TPNFPGXIJDIBSFTIPXOJO'JHVSF O 7BSJBOU SFQFBUJOH FYBDUMZ UIF TBNF DZDMF DBO CF NPEFMFE CZ B DJSDMF &YBNQMF TUBUF NBDIJOFJNQMFNFOUFEJOTPGUXBSF4BZJUIBTSFQFBUJOHTFRVFOUJBMTUBUFT"#$%"#$ %"#z&WFSZDZDMFSFQFBUTFYBDUMZUIFTBNFTUBUFTBTUIFQSFWJPVTDZDMF O 7BSJBOUSFQFBUJOHDZDMFTCVUdiﬀers TMJHIUMZJOBNPSFPSMFTTVOJGPSNXBZ*UDBOCFNPE FMFECZBTQJSBM&YBNQMFHSBEVBMXFBSJOHPVUPGQIZTJDBMNBDIJOF GPSBQFSJPEPGUJNF QSJPSUPXIFOJUFYQFSJFODFTESBTUJDESop-oﬀ or stops worLJOH

Time

1. Same cycle: Model = Circle

2. Similar cycle: Model = Spiral

O

215

3. Non-repeating cycles: Model = Strange attractor

Figure 9.2 Cyclic model variations. (Source: Wikipedia 2008.)

O 7BSJBOU 3FQFBUJOH DZDMFT CVU OP DZDMF SFQFBUT FYBDUMZ UIF QBUI PG BOZ QSFWJPVT DZDMF BOENBZDIBOHFCBDLBOEGPSUICFUXFFOdiﬀerFOUDZDMFT*UDBOCFNPEFMFECZBTUSBOHF BUUSBDUPSTVDIBTUIF-PSFO[TUSBOHFBUUSBDUPS JOUIFﬁgurF TUSBOHFBUUSBDUPSJNBHFJTGSPN 8JLJQFEJB &YBNQMF#FIBWJPSPGQFSTPOBDUJOHJOUXPBMUFSOBUJOHSPMFTUIBUNBQUP the two diﬀerFOUDZDMFT TVDIBTFNQMPZFFBOEQBSFOU TherFBSFBMTPBUMFBTUUXPWJFXTPGBOZDZDMJDNPEFM BTUBUFTJNJMBSJUZWJFXBOE BUJNFMJOF WJFX The UISFF WBSJBOUT BCPWF XFSF EFTDSJCFE BOE JMMVTUSBUFE JO UIF TUBUFTJNJMBSJUZ WJFX 6TJOH 7BSJBOUGSPN'JHVSF UIFUXPWJFXTBSFJMMVTUSBUFEBOEDPOUSBTUFEJO'JHVSFThe TUBUF TJNJMBSJUZWJFX DJSDMF POMZTIPXTUIFSFQFBUJOHTUBUF OPUUIFUJNFXIFOFBDIPDDVSTThe UJNFMJOF WJFXTIPXTUIFUJNFQPJOUXIFOFBDITUBUFJTSFWJTJUFE

Scale Effects on Acyclic and Cyclic Models $ZDMFTFYIJCJUBIVHFUJNFTDBMFSBOHFGSPNCJMMJPOTPGDZDMFTQFSTFDPOEGPSDFSUBJOBUPNT VQUP CJMMJPOTPGZFBSTGPSHBMBYJFT5JNFTDBMFTJOUSPEVDFJOUFSFTUJOHSFMBUJPOTBOEWJFXTPGBDZDMJDBOE DZDMJDNPEFMT $POTJEFSUIBUBOZHJWFOTZTUFNDIBOHFWFDUPSDBOCFEFTDSJCFEJOUFSNTPGCPUIWBSJBCMFTJUT DZDMJDDIBOHFBOEJUTBDZDMJDDIBOHFXIFSFPOFPSCPUIPGUIFTFWBSJBCMFTNBZCF[FSPGPSBHJWFO UJNFQFSJPE4VQQPTFBTZTUFNIBTBDZDMFPGIPVS/PXMFUTFYBNJOFJUTDIBOHFBUBUJNFTDBMFPG TFDPOET IPXJUDIBOHFTPWFSUIFDPVSTFPGTFDPOE

BUBTDBMFPGIPVST IPXJUDIBOHFTPWFSUIF DPVSTFPGPSBGFXIPVST

BOEBUBTDBMFPGNPOUIT IPXJUDIBOHFTPWFSUIFDPVSTFPGBNPOUI 'JHVSFJTBOPUJPOBMWJFXPGBMMUISFFTDBMFT BTXFMMBTUIFNBQQJOHCFUXFFOUIFTDBMFT

State-similarity view

Figure 9.3

Timeline view

State-similarity and timeline views of cycles.

216 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Scale 1: Small portion of one cycle. Change is acyclic at this scale.

Scale 2: Cycle. Change is cyclic at this scale. But a modest number of cycles collectively show repeating cycles (circle on left) or an acyclic overall trend (spiral on right).

Scale 3: Large number of cycles. Only see constant (dot on left) or acyclic trend (line on right) at this scale.

Figure 9.4

Scale effects on views of cyclic and acyclic change.

O 4DBMF FH TFDPOE The DIBOHFPGUIFTZTUFNBQQFBSTUPCFBDZDMJDBUUIJTTDBMFThe DZDMJD DIBOHFXPVMECFSFHBSEFEBT[FSPThe BDZDMJDDIBOHFJTFJUIFS[FSPPSBTNBMMJODSFNFOU PWFSUIFDPVSTFPGUIJTTFDPOE O 4DBMF FH IPVS The DIBOHFPGUIFTZTUFNBQQFBSTUPCFDZDMJDBUUIJTTDBMFThe BNQMJ UVEFPGUIFDJSDMFPSTQJSBMJTWJTJCMFBOEJTUIFBNPVOUPGDZDMJDDIBOHF*GUIFTZTUFNJTTFFO BTSFUVSOJOHUPFYBDUMZUIFTBNFTUBUF UIFDJSDMFPOUIFMFGU

UIFBDZDMJDDIBOHFJTTFFOBT [FSP O 4DBMF FH NPOUI The DIBOHFPGUIFTZTUFNBQQFBSTUPCFBDZDMJDBUUIJTTDBMFThe DZDMJD DIBOHFXPVMECFJOWJTJCMFBOESFHBSEFEBT[FSPThe BDZDMJDDIBOHFJTFJUIFS[FSP JGUIF TZTUFNGPMMPXTFYBDUMZUIFTBNFDJSDMFBU4DBMF PSBOBDZDMJDUSFOEJGUIFTZTUFNGPMMPXT UIFTQJSBMBU4DBMF This NBZBQQFBSUPCFBOFTPUFSJDPSVOVTVBMDBTFCVUJUSFQSFTFOUTBMBSHFOVNCFSPGTJUVBUJPOT JODMVEJOHUIFMJGFPGNBOZTZTUFNT XIJDIHPUISPVHIUIFTBNFSPVUJOFDZDMFTFBDIEBZPSTPNF PUIFSQFSJPEJDJUZ BOEPWFSUJNFBMTPFYQFSJFODFBDZDMJDDIBOHF TVDIBTBHJOHPSHSPXJOH BTJMMVT USBUFEJOUIFUISFFDZDMJDWBSJBOUTBCPWFBOEUIFMFWFMTPGDIBOHFUIBUXJMMCFEJTDVTTFEMBUFSJOUIJT TFDUJPO8FOPw brieﬂy discuss human and organization examples frPNUIFTDBMFQFSTQFDUJWF &YBNQMF)VNBO&BDIDZDMFJO4DBMFSFQSFTFOUTBEBZJOUIFMJGFPGBIVNBODPSSFMBU JOHXJUIUIFDJSDBEJBOSIZUIN*OUIJTDBTF UIF4DBMFNPEFMJTUIFTQJSBMPOUIFSJHIUCFDBVTF BIVNBOJTBCJUdiﬀerFOUGSPNPOFEBZUPUIFOFYU4DBMFSFQSFTFOUTDIBOHFPWFSUIFMJGF TQBOPGBIVNBO"U4DBMF TBZBGFXNJOVUFT XFDBOOPUPCTFSWFUIFEBJMZDZDMF &YBNQMF0SHBOJ[BUJPO&BDIDZDMFJO4DBMFSFQSFTFOUTBZFBSJOUIFMJGFPGBOPSHBOJ[BUJPO XJUITFBTPOBMWBSJBUJPOT TPJUIBTBOBOOVBMDZDMFPGﬂuctuating TJ[F4DBMFSFQSFTFOUTDIBOHF PWFSNVMUJQMFZFBSTPGUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOGPSFYBNQMF JUHSPXTJOTJ[FQFSZFBSGPSZFBST "U4DBMF TBZBXFFL XFDBOOPUPCTFSWFUIFBOOVBMDZDMF

Time

O

217

Change of Interest *OQSFWJPVTDIBQUFSTXFEJTDVTTFEUIFDPODFQUPGTZTUFNPGJOUFSFTU*OUIJTDIBQUFSUIFDPODFQUPG DIBOHFPGJOUFSFTUJTVTFGVM"OPCTFSWFSJTJOUFSFTUFEJOTPNFDIBOHFTUIBUPDDVSBOEOPUJOPUIFS DIBOHFTUIBUPDDVSThe DIBOHFPGJOUFSFTUNBZCFspeciﬁed JOUFSNTPGTUBUFT DPOEJUJPOT QFSJPET PCTFSWBUJPO QPJOUT PS WJFXT 8F EJTDVTT UISFF PG QPUFOUJBMMZ NBOZ WJFXT PG DIBOHF PG JOUFSFTU JOWBSJBOUWJFX TDBMFWJFX BOEIJEJOHWJFX

Invariant View "OJOWBSJBOUJTBNPEFMBEFTDSJQUJPOPSBTTFSUJPOPGBTZTUFNDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPSSFMBUJPOUIBU JTQSFTFSWFEJOBMMPCTFSWBCMFTUBUFT TFF.FZFS GPSBHPPEEFTDSJQUJPOPGJOWBSJBOUT 8IBU JTPGJOUFSFTUJTUIFDIBOHF PSJOUIJTDBTFUIFMBDLPGDIBOHF JOUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPSSFMBUJPOJOUIF PCTFSWBCMFTUBUFT8IBUJTOPUPGJOUFSFTUJTBOZDIBOHFJOUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDJOOPOPCTFSWBCMFTUBUFT 0OFJNQMJDBUJPOPGUIJTJTUIBUBOJOWBSJBOUEFQFOETPOXIBUJTPCTFSWFE XIJDIHFOFSBMMZJTdeﬁned CZUIFWJFXQPJOUGSPNXIJDIPCTFSWBUJPOTBSFNBEF*GBDIBSBDUFSJTUJDUIBUJTUPCFJOWBSJBOUJT DPOUJOVPVTMZPCTFSWBCMFGSPNWJFXQPJOU BOEJTPCTFSWBCMFPODFBZFBSGSPNWJFXQPJOU UIFO UIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDNVTUIPMEDPOUJOVPVTMZJOWJFXQPJOU CVUPOMZOFFETUPIPMEBUFBDIBOOVBM PCTFSWBUJPOGSPNWJFXQPJOU*OUIFMBUUFSDBTF UIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDDPVMEDIBOHFUISPVHIPVUUIF ZFBSCVUJGJUIBEUIFTBNFWBMVFBUUIFPCTFSWBUJPOQPJOUFBDIZFBS JUXPVMECFDPOTJEFSFEJOWBSJ BOUCZBOPCTFSWFSBUWJFXQPJOU &YBNQMFT *O NBUIFNBUJDT BO JOWBSJBOU JT TPNFUIJOH UIBU EPFT OPU DIBOHF VOEFS BO PQFSB UJPOPSUSBOTGPSNBUJPO*OTPGUXBSF BOJOWBSJBOUJTBOFYQSFTTJPOUIBUJTUIFTBNFCFGPSFBOEBGUFS FYFDVUJPO PG B QJFDF PG PCTFSWFE TPGUXBSF The CFGPSF BOE BGUFS WJFXQPJOU DPVME SBOHF GSPN B TJOHMF MJOF PG DPEF UP B TDSJQUFE TFRVFODF PG NVMUJQMF QSPHSBNT *O B DBS UIF DPOTUSBJOU UIBU B UJSFNVTUCFNPVOUFEBUBMMUJNFTXIJMFUIFDBSJTJOPQFSBUJPODPVMECFDPOTJEFSFEBOJOWBSJBOU The PCTFSWBCMFTUBUFTGPSUIFNBUIFNBUJDTBOETPGUXBSFFYBNQMFTBSFDPOWFOJFOUMZdeﬁned JOUFSNT PGQSFBOEQPTUDPOEJUJPOT"RVBOUJUZPSFYQSFTTJPONVTUCFUIFTBNFBUUIFFOEPGUSBOTGPSNBUJPO PSFYFDVUJPOBTJUXBTQSJPSUPUSBOTGPSNBUJPOPSFYFDVUJPO8FEPOPUDBSFJGJUDIBOHFEJOUIF DPVSTFPGUIFPQFSBUJPO BTMPOHBTJUTTUBUFBUUIFFOEXBTUIFTBNFBTUIFTUBUFBUUIFCFHJOOJOH4P UIFDIBOHFPGJOUFSFTUJTdeﬁned BUUIFTUBSUBOEFOEPCTFSWBUJPOQPJOUT BOEBOJOWBSJBOUdeﬁnes UIBU DIBOHF UP CF [FSP The TJUVBUJPO XJUI UIF DBS BOE UJSF PO UIF PUIFS IBOE JT DPOUJOVPVTMZ PCTFSWFEThe UJSFNVTUCFNPVOUFEPOUIFDBSQFSTJTUFOUMZBDSPTTUIFTQBOPGUJNFEVSJOHXIJDI JUJTPQFSBUJOH"OPUIFSFYBNQMFJTBTBGFUZEFQPTJUCPYThe DPOEJUJPOPGUIFNBUFSJBMXIFOJUJT QMBDFEJOUIFTBGFUZEFQPTJUCPYNVTUCFUIFTBNFBTUIFDPOEJUJPOXIFOJUJTSFNPWFEGSPNUIF CPY*UDPVMECFJOBOZDPOEJUJPOPSLFQUBOZXIFSFEVSJOHUIFJOUFSWBMCFUXFFOQMBDJOHJUJOUIF CPYBOESFUSJFWJOHJUGSPNUIFCPY BTMPOHBTJUJTJOUIFTBNFDPOEJUJPOBUCPUIPGUIPTFPCTFSWB UJPOUJNFT

Scale View $IBOHFTPGJOUFSFTUPGUFOWBSZCZTDBMF'JHVSFJMMVTUSBUFTPOFFYBNQMFPGUIJT"OPCTFSWFSXIP DIPPTFTTDBMFJTJOUFSFTUFEJOUIFNPEFTUBDZDMJDDIBOHFPOBTNBMMQBSUPGXIBUJTBDZDMFBUTDBMF "OPCTFSWFSBUTDBMFJTJOUFSFTUFEJOUIFDZDMFPGDIBOHF"OPCTFSWFSBUTDBMFEPFTOPUTFFBOE JTOPUJOUFSFTUFEJODZDMFT CVUJTJOUFSFTUFEJOUIFMPOHFSUFSNDIBOHFPGUIFTZTUFN XIJDIJTFJUIFS OPDIBOHF JGTDBMFJTUIFSFQFBUJOHDJSDMF PSBUSFOE JGTDBMFJTUIFNPWJOHTQJSBM The NFBTVSF NFOUFYBNQMFJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi8IFUIFS4PNFUIJOH*T4UBUJDPS%ZOBNJDwJMMVTUSBUFEUIBU

218 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

NFBTVSFNFOUTDBOCFNJTMFBEJOHBUdiﬀerFOUTDBMFTPSGSPNdiﬀerFOUWJFXTThe NFBTVSFNFOUNVTU NBUDIXIBUJTPGJOUFSFTU "OPUIFS TDBMF FYBNQMF JT TUFQXJTF SFWPMVUJPO UIBU JT B TZTUFN TVDI BT BO PSHBOJ[BUJPO UIBU USBOTGPSNTJUTFMGCVUEPFTTPWJBBTFSJFTPGHSBEVBMTUFQTSBUIFSUIBOBTVEEFOCJHCBOHDIBOHFThis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he UJNFTQBO CFUXFFO5BOE5NBZCFIVOESFETPGUIPVTBOETPSNJMMJPOTPGZFBSTThe GPTTJMSFDPSETIPXT4 BU5BOE4BU5CVUJUEPFTOPUDBQUVSFUIFJOUFSWFOJOHQFSJPE5JTGPMMPXFEJNNFEJBUFMZCZ 5This WJFXTIPXTUIFTQFDJFT4BQQFBSJOHTVEEFOMZBU5This JTPOFPGUIFdiﬃculties PGUSZJOH UPPCUBJOUIFIJTUPSJDBMEFUBJMTPGCJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPO BOEFTQFDJBMMZTQFDJBUJPO

Hiding View The CBTJDFOHJOFFSJOHQSJODJQMFPGFODBQTVMBUJPOPSJOGPSNBUJPOIJEJOHGBDJMJUBUFTNPEVMBSEFTJHO 1BSOBT FOVODJBUFEUIJTBTBDSJUFSJPOGPSEFTJHOJOHBTZTUFN FTQFDJBMMZGPSEFDPNQPTJOHB XIPMFTZTUFNJOUPQBSUTThe CBTJDJEFBJTUIBUFBDIQBSUIJEFTBEFTJHOEFDJTJPOUIBUJTMJLFMZUP DIBOHFThe HPBMJTGPSFBDIQBSUUPFYQPTFJOGPSNBUJPOUIBUJTFYQFDUFEUPCFSFMBUJWFMZTUBCMF BOE UPIJEFJOGPSNBUJPOUIBUJTFYQFDUFEUPCFSFMBUJWFMZWPMBUJMFGSPNBEFTJHOQFSTQFDUJWFThe DPODFQU PGDIBOHFPGJOUFSFTUSFMBUFTUPJOGPSNBUJPOIJEJOHJOUIFGPMMPXJOHXBZ4VQQPTFXFIBWFUXPQBSUT PGBTZTUFNDBMMFE1BOE1 BOE1EFQFOETPO1This NFBOTUIBUDIBOHFTUP1QPUFOUJBMMZ IBWFBOJNQBDUPO1/PXTVQQPTFUIBUXFTFQBSBUFQPUFOUJBMDIBOHFTJO1JOUPUXPHSPVQT FYUFSOBMDIBOHFTWJTJCMFUP1BOEJOUFSOBMDIBOHFTIJEEFOGSPN1*OUIJTTUSVDUVSF DMFBSMZUIF 1DIBOHFTPGJOUFSFTUUP1BSFUIFFYUFSOBMWJTJCMFDIBOHFT BOEUIF1DIBOHFTOPUPGJOUFSFTUUP 1BSFUIFJOUFSOBMIJEEFODIBOHFTThis TUFQIBTNBEFMJGFFBTJFSGPS1GSPNBDIBOHFQFSTQFD UJWF*GJOBEEJUJPO1BSSBOHFTUPIJEFJOUFSOBMMZUIFUIJOHTNPTUMJLFMZUPDIBOHF BOEUPFYQPTF FYUFSOBMMZUIFUIJOHTMFBTUMJLFMZUPDIBOHF UIJTbeneﬁts 1FWFOGVSUIFS#VU1 BOEBMMPUIFSQBSUT PGUIFTZTUFNUIBUEFQFOEPO1 BSFOPUUIFPOMZbeneﬁciaries PG1JOGPSNBUJPOIJEJOH1JUTFMG beneﬁts CFDBVTFJGJULFFQTNPTUDIBOHFTJOUFSOBM JUSFEVDFTJUTXPSLMPBEPGPWFSDPNJOHSFTJTUBODF UP DIBOHF BOE Sedeﬁning BOE SFOFHPUJBUJOH JOUFSBDUJPOT BOE BHSFFNFOUT XJUI UIPTF QBSUT UIBU EFQFOEPOJU *OUIFJOWBSJBOUWJFX UIFDIBOHFTPGJOUFSFTUBSFIFMEUP[FSP XIJMFUIFDIBOHFTOPUPGJOUFS FTUBSFVODPOTUSBJOFEFYDFQUCZUIFCPVOETPGUIFMBSHFSJOWBSJBOUDPOTUSBJOU*OUIFTDBMFWJFX UIFDIBOHFTPGJOUFSFTUBSFOPUOFDFTTBSJMZDPOTUSBJOFE CVUUIFZBSFBsimpliﬁed TVCTFUPGUIFUPUBM QJDUVSFCZWJSUVFPGUIFGBDUUIBUUIFZBSFUIFPOMZPOFTWJTJCMFBUBHJWFOTDBMF*OUIFIJEJOHWJFX UIFDIBOHFTPGJOUFSFTUBSFNJOJNJ[FE BOEUIFDIBOHFTOPUPGJOUFSFTUBSFVODPOTUSBJOFEFYDFQU CZUIFCPVOETPGUIFFYUFSOBMWJFX%FTDSJCFEJOUIJTXBZ BMMUISFFQBUUFSOTPSWJFXTBSFUPPMTGPS ThFSF JT BOPUIFSJNQPSUBOUQFSTQFDUJWFJOXIJDIUIFIJEJOHEFTDSJCFE IFSF JT OPU EFTJSBCMF NPOJUPSJOH BOE USBDLJOHTUBUVTPGBTZTUFNThFHPBMJOUIJTQFSTQFDUJWF GPSFWFSZUIJOHGSPNCSJEHFTUPOFUXPSLTUPIVNBO IFBMUI JTUPFYQPTFWPMBUJMFJOGPSNBUJPOUPNPOJUPSTZTUFNTUBUVT

Time

O

219

NBOBHJOHDIBOHFCZSFEVDJOHUIFBNPVOUPGDIBOHFXFNVTUEFBMXJUIJOBHJWFOWJFXThese BSF UIFSFGPSFQBSUPGUIFNPSFHFOFSBMUPQJDPGEFBMJOHXJUIDIBOHFJOUIFDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSP DFTTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS These UISFFQBUUFSOTPSWJFXTJOWBSJBOU TDBMF BOEIJEJOHBSFOPUOFDFTTBSJMZEJTUJODUPS TFQBSBUF'PSFYBNQMF XFDPVMESFBTPOBCMZDPODFQUVBMJ[FBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPGBTZTUFNBTIJE JOHDIBOHFTFYIJCJUFECZUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFM PSBTBOJOWBSJBOUUIBUEFTDSJCFTXIBUJTUSVFPGUIF FYUFSOBMMZWJTJCMFCFIBWJPSPSEBUB XIJMFOPUCFJOHJOUFSFTUFEJODIBOHFTJOUIFJOUFSOBMCFIBWJPS PSEBUB

Other Concepts: Persistence and Duality This TFDUJPOEJTDVTTFTFYBNQMFTPGTUBUFBOESPMFQFSTJTUFODF GPMMPXFECZUIFDPODFQUTPGEVBMJUZBOE DPOUSBTUJOUIFUJNFEJNFOTJPO

State and Role Persistence 4PNFTUBUFTBOESPMFTBSFQFSDFJWFEBTQFSTJTUJOHBDSPTTNVMUJQMFDZDMFMFWFMT&YBNQMFTPGCPUIBSF QSFTFOUFE 4UBUF *O B UJNFTMJDJOH DPNQVUFS PQFSBUJOH TZTUFN DPOTJEFS B TPGUXBSF QSPHSBN 1 UIBU JT MPBEFEBOEFYFDVUJOH BOEJTUJNFTMJDFEXJUIPUIFSQSPHSBNT0OFDZDMFJTUIFPOFUJNFQSPDFTTPG CFJOHMPBEFEBUUJNF5 FYFDVUJOH BOEUIFOﬁnishing BOECFJOHVOMPBEFEBUUJNF5The PUIFS DZDMFJTUIFUJNFTMJDFTTVQQPTFUIFQFSJPE5UP5JTEJWJEFEJOUPTMJDFTidentiﬁed BTU U z UBOEUIBU1JTBMMPDBUFEPOFPGFWFSZTMJDFTTBZ U U z U/PXXF BTLBRVFTUJPO8IFOJT1FYFDVUJOH $MFBSMZJUJTFYFDVUJOHEVSJOHTMJDFU#VUJTJUFYFDVUJOH EVSJOHTMJDFU The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i"SFZPVB-JUUMF-FBHVFCBTF CBMMDPBDI w XIFOJTUIFBOTXFSZFT 4VQQPTFUIFRVFTUJPOJTBTLFE POB4BUVSEBZNPSOJOHJO +VOF POB5VFTEBZFWFOJOHJO+VOF JO4FQUFNCFSBOE TPNFUJNFJO *OHFOFSBM UIFBOTXFSXPVMEQSPCBCMZCFZFTGPSBMMFYDFQU #PCXPVMEDPOTJEFSIJNTFMG JOUIFSPMFPGCBTFCBMMDPBDIFWFOJOUIFoﬀ-season VOUJMIFTUPQQFECFJOHBDPBDIThis FYBNQMF JMMVTUSBUFT UISFF MFWFMT PG DZDMF XFFLMZ HBNFT BOOVBM TFBTPOT BOE UIF MJGF TQBO PG IJT DPBDIJOH DBSFFS 'VSUIFSNPSF BTTVNJOH#PCXBTBOFNQMPZFFBOEIVTCBOEGSPNUP UIFOBUBOZ HJWFONPNFOUEVSJOHUIBUQFSJPE IFXPVMETBZ*BNBIVTCBOE *BNBOFNQMPZFF BOE*BNB CBTFCBMMDPBDI#VUUIFRVFTUJPOPGXIFOIFJTBDPBDIDPVMEBMTPEFQFOEUPTPNFEFHSFFPOUIF DPOUFYUPGUIFRVFTUJPO*GUXPCPZTPOIJTCBTFCBMMUFBNHPUJOUPBﬁght BOETPNFPOFBTLFEJGIF

220

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

XBTUIFJSDPBDI UIFSFJTBdiﬀerFODFCFUXFFOXIFUIFSUIFﬁght PDDVSSFEPO B4BUVSEBZNPSOJOH JO+VOFPS B5VFTEBZFWFOJOHJO+VOF#PCIBEsigniﬁcantly NPSFSFTQPOTJCJMJUZGPS their behavior in the ﬁrst case than the second. TherFBSFGPVSSFMBUFEQPJOUTUPCFNBEFIFSFSFHBSEJOHUIFRVFTUJPOPGXIFUIFSBHJWFOTUBUF of aﬀairs exists: *t may exist in diﬀerent senses at diﬀerFOUDZDMFT 8IFUIFSJUFYJTUTBUBHJWFOUJNFJOBHJWFODZDMFNBZEFQFOEPOQFSTQFDUJWF The TUBUFJTPGUFOQFSDFJWFEUPQFSTJTUBDSPTTMPOHFSDZDMFTFWFOXIFOJUEPFTOPUIPMEBU UJNFTJOBTIPSUFSDZDMF .VMUJQMFdiﬀerFOUTUBUFTPGaﬀairs PGUIFTBNFJOEJWJEVBM FTQFDJBMMZSPMFT BSFPGUFODPO DFJWFEBTFYJTUJOHTJNVMUBOFPVTMZ

Duality, Tension, and Paradox in Time Variables 8FNFOUJPOFEUIFDPODFQUPGEVBMJUZBOEUFOTJPOJO$IBQUFSBTBDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGDPNQMFYTZT UFNTThe UJNFEJNFOTJPODPOUBJOTBGFXPGUIFTFUFOTJPOT'JSTU TUBCJMJUZBOEDIBOHFBSFJODPO TUBOUUFOTJPOJOTZTUFNTBOEFOWJSPONFOUT"TVNNBSZPGFWPMVUJPOUIBUSeﬂects UIJTJTGSPN5BOH BOE &QTUFJO i&WPMVUJPO PG CJPMPHJDBM DPNQMFYJUZ JOWPMWFT BO FOWJSPONFOUBMMZ SFHVMBUFE CBMBODFCFUXFFOHFOFUJDDPOTFSWBUJPOBOEWBSJBUJPOw 4FDPOE DZDMJDBOEBDZDMJDDIBOHFSeﬂect BCBMBODFBOEUFOTJPOUIBUTIPXTVQJOdiﬀerFOUWJFXT TDBMFT BOEUJNFT BTJMMVTUSBUFEJOFBSMJFSEJTDVTTJPOTBOE'JHVSFThirE DZDMJDDIBOHFJUTFMGJTB UFOTJPOPSQBSBEPYPGDPOTUBODZBOEDIBOHFJUDPOUJOVBMMZDIBOHFT CVUBUUIFTBNFUJNFJUSFQFBUT JUTFMGJOBDPOTUBOUSFQFUJUJPO "OPUIFSTPNFXIBUTFQBSBUFUFOTJPOJTQMBOOJOH8FOFFEUPTFUHPBMTBOEdeﬁne QMBOTUPSFBDI UIPTFHPBMT CVUXFSBSFMZGPMMPXBQMBOThe HPBMNBZDIBOHFPSFWFOJGUIFHPBMTUBZTUIFTBNF UIFQMBOUPHFUUIFSFVTVBMMZDIBOHFTThe CBMBODFBOESFTPMVUJPOPGUIJTUFOTJPOJTEFTDSJCFEJO $IBQUFS

Modeling Levels of Process and Change 8e deﬁne thrFFMFWFMTPGQSPDFTTBOEDIBOHF O -FWFMXIBUBTZTUFNEPFTUIBUJT DIBOHFBDDPNNPEBUFEPSWBSJBUJPOTVQQPSUFEXJUIJO UIFSBOHFPGCFIBWJPSPGBHJWFOTZTUFN O -FWFMXIBUBTZTUFNJTUIBUJT DIBOHFJOWolving modiﬁcation of the system (parUT O -FWFMDIBOHFJOIPXXFWJFXBTZTUFNUIBUJT DIBOHFJOWPMWJOHmodiﬁcation PGTZTUFN NPEFMTTVDIBTDIBOHJOHUIFEFTJHOPSSFRVJSFNFOUTPGBTZTUFN *OTPNFDJSDVNTUBODFT DIBOHFDBOPDDVSJOBOZPOFPGUIFTFMFWFMTXJUIPVUDIBOHJOHUIFPUIFSUXP MFWFMT*OPUIFSDJSDVNTUBODFT JGPOFMFWFMDIBOHFT POFPSCPUIPGUIFPUIFSMFWFMTBMTPDIBOHFT "DBSBOEBQFSTPODBOCFVTFEUPJMMVTUSBUFUIFMFWFMT'PSBDBS -FWFMSFQSFTFOUTOPSNBMQSP DFTTFTPSDIBOHFTJOCFIBWJPS TVDIBTUIFFOHJOFCFJOHPOPSoﬀ, PSUIFDBSDIBOHJOHEJSFDUJPOPS TQFFE-FWFMJODMVEFTSFQMBDJOHPSSFQBJSJOHFOHJOFQBSUT UJSFT FUD-FWFMDPVMEJODMVEFDIBOH JOHJOUFSOBMPSFYUFSOBMNPEFMT TVDIBTDIBOHJOHUIFFOHJOFUZQF PSBQFSGPSNBODFSFRVJSFNFOU 'PSBDBS XFVTVBMMZDPOTJEFS-FWFMBOE-FWFMUPCFDMFBSMZTFQBSBUFEDIBOHJOHCFIBWJPSTFFNT DMFBSMZEJTUJODUGSPNSFQMBDJOHBQBSU FWFOUIPVHI-FWFMDIBOHFPGUFOSFTVMUTJO-FWFMDIBOHFT

Time

O

221

/PXDPOTJEFSBQFSTPO-FWFMSFQSFTFOUTUIFDIBOHJOHCFIBWJPSPGUIFQFSTPO GSPNPOFNJO VUFUPUIFOFYU PSGSPNPOFSPMFTVDIBTFNQMPZFFUPBOPUIFSTVDIBTQBSFOU -FWFMJTBDIBOHFJOUIFQFSTPOThis DPVMECFBUBOFYUSFNFMFWFMPGQBSUTSFQMBDFNFOU TVDI BTBIFBSUUSBOTQMBOUPSSFQMBDJOHLOFFKPJOUTXJUIBStiﬁcial POFT*UDPVMECFBUBMFTTFYUSFNFMFWFM PGQBSUTSFQBJSTVDIBTWBSJPVTUZQFTPGTVSHFSZ#VUIVNBOTBMTPDIBOHFDPOUJOVBMMZJOBUMFBTUUISFF DBUFHPSJFT 'JSTU UIFZ JNQSPWF QIZTJDBMMZ NFOUBMMZ BOE TPDJBMMZ UISPVHI EFWFMPQNFOU HSPXUI MFBSOJOH BOE BDDVNVMBUFE FYQFSJFODF 4FDPOE UIFZ EFUFSJPSBUF JO WBSJPVT XBZT UISPVHI BHJOH ThirE UIFZDIBOHFJOSFTQPOTFUPUIFJSJOUFSBDUJPOXJUIUIFFOWJSPONFOUUISPVHIPVUUIFJSMJGFUJNF This NFBOTUIBU-FWFMBOEDIBOHFTPDDVSDPOUJOVBMMZBOETJNVMUBOFPVTMZ BOEJONBOZDBTFT EJSFDUMZinﬂuence FBDIPUIFS*OIVNBOT BOECZFYUFOTJPODPNQMFYTZTUFNT $4 JOHFOFSBM UIF EJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOXIBUBQFSTPOEPFT -FWFM BOEXIBUUIFQFSTPOJT -FWFM JTOPUTPDMFBS #BTFEPOUIJTEJTDVTTJPO XFDBOSFDPOTJEFSUIFDBS*UHSBEVBMMZEFUFSJPSBUFTXJUIVTF'SPN UIJTQFSTQFDUJWF XIBUUIFDBSJTTFFNTNPSFDMPTFMZDPOOFDUFEUPXIBUJUEPFTBTJUCFIBWFT -FWFM

JUHSBEVBMMZEFUFSJPSBUFT -FWFM /PUFUIBUDPODFQUVBMTZTUFNTTVDIBTTPGUXBSFQSPHSBNTEP OPUJOHFOFSBMEFUFSJPSBUFUISPVHIVTF TPUIFJS-FWFMDIBOHFTTFFNDMFBSMZEJTUJODUGSPNUIFJS -FWFMDIBOHFT)PXFWFS UIFPWFSBMMTPGUXBSFTZTUFNQFSGPSNBODFNBZEFUFSJPSBUF GPSFYBNQMF UISPVHIBDDVNVMBUJPOPGSFHJTUSZFOUSJFTPSEJTLGSBHNFOUBUJPO'VSUIFSNPSF TFMGNPEJGZJOHTPGU XBSFDMPTFMZDPOOFDUT-FWFMDIBOHFTBOE-FWFMDIBOHFTCZNPEJGZJOHJUTFMGXIJMFJUJTPQFSBUJOH EVFUPDPOEJUJPOTPGJUTPQFSBUJPO -FWFMDPWFSTDIBOHFTJONPEFMTPGIVNBOT'PSFYBNQMF PVSNPEFMPGIVNBOBOBUPNZNBZ CFGBJSMZNBUVSFBOETUBCMFBUUIFDVSSFOUUJNF CVUPVSNPEFMPGIVNBOHFOFTIBTFWPMWFETJH niﬁcantly JOSFDFOUZFBSTCFDBVTFPGsigniﬁcant JODSFBTFTJOLOPXMFEHFUIBUIBWFMFEUPJNQSPWFE ﬁdelity of the model. "GBJSDPODMVTJPOPGUIFGPSFHPJOHEJTDVTTJPOPG-FWFMBOE-FWFMDIBOHFTJTUIBUGPSTZTUFNT JOHFOFSBM JUNJHIUCFVTFGVMUPIBWFUXPWJFXTPOFJOXIJDI-FWFMDIBOHFTBSFDMFBSMZEJTUJO HVJTIFEGSPNMFWFMDIBOHFT BOEPOFJOXIJDIUIFZBSFOPUDMFBSMZEJTUJOHVJTIFE 1SPDFTTPSDIBOHFNPEFMTSFQSFTFOUJOHUIFTFUISFFMFWFMT BOEDPNCJOBUJPOTPGMFWFMT BSFEJT DVTTFE JO UIF TFDUJPOT UIBU GPMMPX 'JHVSF DPNQBSFT UIF MJGF TQBO PG QSPDFTTFT BU FBDI MFWFM The ﬁgur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his JT PGDPVSTF Bsimpliﬁcation. 'PSFYBNQMF UIFMJOFCFUXFFONBUVSBUJPOBOEGVMMGVODUJPOJOH JTWFSZGV[[Z*OBMMUISFFMFWFMT QSPDFTTFTBOEDIBOHFTUPQBUSFUJSFNFOUp*OUIFDBTFPGUIFNPEFM -FWFM

UIFMJGFTQBOTIPXOJTUIFMJGFTQBOPGUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFPGUIFNPEFMXJUIBTZTUFN This DPOUFYUGPDVTFTNPSFPOspeciﬁc NPEFMTBOEMFTTPOHFOFSBMNPEFMT*OUIFFYUSFNF Bspeciﬁc NPEFMNBZCFdeﬁned GPS BOEPOMZDPSSFTQPOEUP UIJTTZTUFN JOXIJDIDBTFJUTMJGFTQBOJTUIF FYUFOUPGUIFMJOFGPS-JO'JHVSF#VUJOUIFHFOFSBMEFDPVQMFEDBTF BNPEFM BOEFTQFDJBMMZB HFOFSBMNPEFM IBTJUTPXOJOEFQFOEFOUMJGFTQBO XIJDIJTOPUTIPXOJOUIFﬁgurFCVUJTEJTDVTTFE 7JFXTBSFEJTDVTTFEJONPSFEFUBJMJO$IBQUFS pThJTJTCZEFﬁOJUJPO3FUJSFNFBOT“FOEPGPQFSBUJPOBMQFSJPEPGJOUFSFTU ”XIJDIGPSBQFSTPODPVMECFSFUJSF NFOUGSPNUIFXPSLGPSDF PSBOFBSMJFSQPJOU PSBMBUFSQPJOU EFQFOEJOHPOXIBUJTCFJOHNPEFMFE

222 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Conceived Level

Planning

Born/IOC Reach adulthood/FOC Retire

Formation

Maturation

Full function

System behavior: L1

Retirement Range = System Versatility = Extent of phase portrait

System change: L2

Range = System adaptability

Model change: L3

Range = Model adaptability

IOC = Initial Operational Capability; FOC = Full Operational Capability

Figure 9.5

Process and change levels during system life span.

MBUFSJOUIFDIBQUFS"TZTUFNDBOEFBMXJUIFOWJSPONFOUBMDIBOHFBU-FWFMCZCFJOHWFSTBUJMF UIBU JT IBWJOHBCSPBESBOHFPGCFIBWJPSJOJUTSFQFSUPJSFXJUIPVUDIBOHJOHPSCFJOHDIBOHFEBOEBU -FWFMCZCFJOHBEBQUBCMF UIBUJT CFJOHBCMFUPDIBOHFUPCFUUFSﬁt UIFFOWJSPONFOU"NPEFMDBO BMTPEFBMXJUIDIBOHFCZCFJOHBEBQUBCMF

Models of Level 1 Change -FWFMQSPDFTTFTDPSSFTQPOEUPTZTUFNCFIBWJPS"MBSHFOVNCFSPGNPEFMTPGUIFTFQSPDFTTFTFYJTU JOCPUI54&BOE$4BSFOBT.BOZPGUIFTFBSFUSBEJUJPOBMMZDBMMFEEZOBNJDNPEFMT8FMJTUBOE brieﬂy describe a feXPGUIFN 6niﬁed .PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 6.- 0.(B C The HFOFSBMDBUFHPSZJTCFIBWJPSEJB HSBNT BTPQQPTFEUPTUSVDUVSFEJBHSBNT TherFBSFGPVSUZQFTBDUJWJUZEJBHSBN JOUFSBDUJPOEJB HSBN TUBUFNBDIJOFEJBHSBN BOEVTFDBTFEJBHSBNThe JOUFSBDUJPOUZQF JOUVSO IBTGPVSUZQFT TFRVFODFEJBHSBN JOUFSBDUJPOPWFSWJFXEJBHSBN DPNNVOJDBUJPOEJBHSBN BOEUJNJOHEJBHSBN "OBDUJWJUZEJBHSBNTIPXTUIFDPPSEJOBUJPOBOEﬂoXPGDPOUSPM EBUB PSPCKFDUTCFUXFFOOPEFT "TFRVFODFEJBHSBNTIPXTJOUFSDIBOHFPGNFTTBHFTCFUXFFOUXPPSNPSFFOUJUJFT DBMMFEMJGFMJOFT "DPNNVOJDBUJPOEJBHSBNBMTPTIPXTNFTTBHFJOUFSDIBOHFCVUGPDVTFTPOUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFPGUIF JOUFSOBMTUSVDUVSF"UJNJOHEJBHSBNTIPXTJOUFSBDUJPOTJOBXBZUIBUTVQQPSUTSFBTPOJOHBCPVU UJNF*UJODMVEFTDIBOHJOHDPOEJUJPOTBMPOHBUJNFBYJT"TUBUFNBDIJOFEJBHSBNNPEFMTTUBUFTBOE USBOTJUJPOTCFUXFFOTUBUFT"VTFDBTFJTBDPNCJOBUJPOPGTUBUJDBOEEZOBNJDNPEFMUIBUJTVTFEUP deﬁne the rFRVJSFECFIBWJPSPGBTZTUFNBOEJUTJOUFSBDUJPOXJUIBOFOWJSPONFOU 4ZT.-VTFTBTVCTFUPGUIF6.-CFIBWJPSEJBHSBNTBDUJWJUZEJBHSBN TFRVFODFEJBHSBN TUBUF NBDIJOFEJBHSBN BOEVTFDBTFEJBHSBN 0.(D "OPUIFSDBUFHPSZJOTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHJTBMHPSJUINT TDSJQUT BOEQSPHSBNTThese TJNJMBS NPEFMUZQFTBMMFYQSFTTQSPDFTTFTPGTFRVFOUJBM PSTPNFUJNFTQBSBMMFM BDUJPOTUPCFUBLFOCZBO BHFOU6TVBMMZUIFBHFOUJTBDPNQVUFSFTQFDJBMMZJOUIFDBTFPGTDSJQUTBOEQSPHSBNT "MMUIFBCPWFEJBHSBNTBOEBSUJGBDUTNBQUPJOUFSOBMNPEFMTJO.04&4The VTFDBTFEJBHSBN DBOBMTPCFVTFEUPFYQSFTTBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMJOUIFTFOTFPGEFTDSJCJOHUIFSFRVJSFECFIBWJPSPG UIFTZTUFNPGJOUFSFTU

Time

O

223

0UIFSUSBEJUJPOBMNPEFMTJODMVEF1FUSJOFUTThese BSFNBUIFNBUJDBMMZCBTFEHSBQIJDBMNPEFMT PGEJTDSFUFCFIBWJPSPGTZTUFNTThe LFZFMFNFOUTBSFQMBDFT BSDT BOEUSBOTJUJPOT XIFSFBOBSDDPO OFDUTQMBDFTXJUIUSBOTJUJPOT&YUFOTJPOTUPUIFCBTJD1FUSJOFUTIBWFJODMVEFEDPMPSFE1FUSJOFUTBOE IJFSBSDIJDBM1FUSJOFUTUIBUBMMPXTVCOFUT (JSBVMUBOE7BML %ZOBNJDBMTZTUFNNPEFMTJODMVEFUIFQIBTFTQBDFPSCJUTPSUSBKFDUPSJFTPGTZTUFNT#PUIBUSB KFDUPSZBOEBOPSCJUBSFUIFTFRVFODFPGTZTUFNTUBUFTPWFSUJNF5ZQJDBMMZUIFUFSNiPSCJUwJTVTFE JGUIFCFIBWJPSTFRVFODFJTDZDMJD XIJMFiUSBKFDUPSZwJTVTFEJGUIFCFIBWJPSJTBDZDMJD%iﬀerFOUJBM FRVBUJPOTBSFVTFEUPNPEFMTZTUFNCFIBWJPSPOBDPOUJOVPVTUJNFTDBMF BOEdiﬀerFODFFRVBUJPOT PSPUIFSUPPMT TVDIBT1FUSJOFUT BSFVTFEUPNPEFMTZTUFNCFIBWJPSPOBEJTDSFUFUJNFTDBMFThese NPEFMTUFOEUPNBQNPSFUP.04&4FYUFSOBMNPEFMTCFDBVTFUIFZDIBSBDUFSJ[FUIFCFIBWJPSPGUIF TZTUFNBTBXIPMF JODMVEJOHGPSQIZTJDBMTZTUFNTUIFJSQPTJUJPOBOEWFMPDJUZ GPSFYBNQMF"TVCTFU PGUIFEZOBNJDBMTZTUFNNPEFMTDIBSBDUFSJ[FTCFIBWJPSPGDIBPUJDTZTUFNT JODMVEJOHPSCJUTBSPVOE TUSBOHFBUUSBDUPST This DPOUFYUQSPWJEFTBOBEEJUJPOBMWJFXPGUIFMBXPGSFRVJTJUFWBSJFUZ $IBQUFS "TTVNFB TZTUFNIBTTJYEFHSFFTPGGSFFEPN PSTJYWBSJBCMFTPGCFIBWJPSThen JUTQIBTFTQBDFIBTTJYEJNFO TJPOT"TTVNFUIBUJUTQPTTJCMFCFIBWJPSUSBKFDUPSJFTBSFDBQUVSFEJOBTJYEJNFOTJPOBMQIBTFQPS USBJU/PXBTTVNFBSFHVMBUPSOFFETUPSFHVMBUFUISFFPGUIFTFWBSJBCMFTThen UIFSFHVMBUPSOFFET UPIBWFBUISFFEJNFOTJPOBMQIBTFQPSUSBJUUIBUJTUIFTBNFBTUIFUISFFEJNFOTJPOBMTVCTQBDFPG UIFTZTUFNTQIBTFQPSUSBJU XIFSFUIFTVCTQBDFJTCBTFEPOUIFUISFFWBSJBCMFTUPCFSFHVMBUFEThe QPJOUJTUIBUBNPSFQSFDJTFTUBUFNFOUPGUIFMBXJTUPTVDDFTTGVMMZSFHVMBUFBTZTUFN UIFWBSJFUZPG UIFSFHVMBUPSNVTUCFBUMFBTUBTMBSHFBTUIFWBSJFUZPGJOUFSFTUPGUIFSFHVMBUFETZTUFNThe WBSJFUZPG JOUFSFTUUPUIFSFHVMBUPSJOUIJTFYBNQMFJTUISFFPVUPGUIFTJYWBSJBCMFTThis JTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIF i(PPE3FHVMBUPSwUIFPSFN EJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS UIBUQPTJUTBSFHVMBUPSPGBTZTUFNBTBNPEFM PGUIBUTZTUFN

Models of Level 2 Change -FWFMQSPDFTTNPEFMTTIPXIPXBTZTUFNJUTFMGDIBOHFT BTPQQPTFEUPIPXJUCFIBWFT"TTIPXOJO 'JHVSF -FWFMDIBOHFTPDDVSEVSJOHTZTUFNGPSNBUJPO NBUVSBUJPO BOEGVMMGVODUJPOJOHThis TFDUJPOEJTDVTTFTDIBOHFNPEFMTGPSUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT JODMVEJOHCJPMPHJDBMNPEFMT PGDIBOHF BOEUIFOEJTDVTTFT-FWFMCPVOEBSZDSPTTJOHDIBOHF

Traditional and Complex System Change Models 5BCMFTIPXTDPNNPOUFSNTGPSDIBOHFJOCPUIUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT TVDI BTIVNBOT.BOBHJOHDIBOHFJTBMTPJODMVEFEJOUIFUBCMF #JPMPHZIBTNVMUJQMFNPEFMTBQQSPQSJBUFGPS-FWFMQSPDFTTFT5BCMFTVNNBSJ[FTBOVNCFS PGCJPMPHJDBMNPEFMTPGDIBOHF*OFBDIDBTF UIFJOGPSNBUJPOJODMVEFTUIFDIBOHFNPEFMBOEUIF VOJUPGDIBOHF1SJNBSZTPVSDFTPGNBUFSJBMJOUIJTUBCMFBSF'VUVZNB BOE.BZS .PSFHFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUVTFTPNFPGUIFBCPWFQSPDFTTFTBSFJOIFSJUBODFBOESFQSPEVDUJPO %FWFMPQNFOUPDDVSTPWFSNVDIPGUIFMJGFPGBOJOEJWJEVBMThe PUIFSQSPDFTTFTMJTUFEUFOEUP PDDVSNPSFTVEEFOMZ/PUFUIBUUIFEFTJHOBUJPOPGTVEEFODIBOHFWFSTVTDIBOHFPWFSUJNFJTOPU JOIFSFOUPSBCTPMVUF*ODBTFTXIFSFUIFUJNFTDBMFJTWFSZﬁne HSBJOFE BMMUIFDIBOHFTJO5BCMF DPVMECFSFHBSEFEBTPDDVSSJOHPWFSUJNF "OPUIFSTPVSDFPGCJPMPHJDBMQSPDFTTFTJTUIFPQFOCJPMPHJDBMPOUPMPHZ 0#0

BOEspeciﬁcally UIFCJPMPHJDBMQSPDFTTPOUPMPHZ 0#0

224 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Table 9.1 Level 2 Change and Change Management Change in Phase System Type

Formation

TS

Development

CS (humans)

Gestation

Maturation Improvement, refactoring Growth, learning

Full Functioning Sustainment (External) Adaptation (Self)

Managing Change Conﬁguration mgt Feedback, peer pressure, homeostasis

Boundary Crossing Change .PTUPGUIFDIBOHFEJTDVTTFEJOUIJTTFDUJPOJTDIBOHFPGBOFOUJUZXJUIJOJUTFMGUIBUJT DIBSBD UFSJTUJDTDIBOHFCVUUIFFOUJUZSFUBJOTJUTJEFOUJUZPSUIFDBUFHPSJFTJUJTJOPSUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODF UPNPEFMT4PNFUJNFT IPXFWFS DIBOHFJTTPsigniﬁcant UIBUBOFOUJUZCFDPNFTBOPUIFSFOUJUZPS NPWFTUPBdiﬀerFOUDBUFHPSZ BTJMMVTUSBUFEJO'JHVSF'PSFYBNQMF BTZTUFNDIBOHFTUPUIF QPJOUUIBUJUOPMPOHFSsatisﬁes JUTSFRVJSFNFOUTNPEFM TPJUDSPTTFTUIFCPVOEBSZPGUIFNPEFM SFHJPOGSPNJOTJEFUPPVUTJEF"MUFSOBUJWFMZ BTZTUFNDPVMEDIBOHFPSCFDIBOHFETPJUOPXEPFT TBUJTGZJUTSFRVJSFNFOUTJUNPWFTGSPNPVUPGUIFSFHJPOUPJOUIFSFHJPO GSPNOPUDPSSFTQPOEJOH UPDPSSFTQPOEJOHUPUIFNPEFM"OFWFONPSFESBTUJDDIBOHF GSPNUIFTZTUFNTQPJOUPGWJFX JTB DIBOHFUPUIFQPJOUXIFSFJUCFDPNFTBdiﬀerFOUTZTUFN*OBEEJUJPO UIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFDIBOHFT DBOBMTPCFBDIJFWFEJGUIFNPEFM FH UIFSFRVJSFNFOUT DIBOHFTBOEUIFTZTUFNEPFTOPUDIBOHF That JTB-FWFMUZQFPGDIBOHFCVUJUJTJODMVEFEIFSFUPQSFTFOUBNPSFDPNQMFUFTFUPGCPVOEBSZ DSPTTJOHDIBOHFUZQFT

Comparison of Selected Engineering Models 8FDPNQBSFUISFFFOHJOFFSJOHNPEFMTCJHCBOHNPEFM JODSFNFOUBMNPEFM BOEFWPMVUJPONPEFM They BSFJMMVTUSBUFEBOEDPOUSBTUFEJO'JHVSF"TTVNFBTJUVBUJPOJOXIJDI VTFSTdeﬁne UIFJS OFFETBUBQPJOUJOUJNF TBZ5 BTZTUFNJTEFWFMPQFEPWFSUJNFUPTBUJTGZUIFVTFSOFFETBOE VTFSOFFETDIBOHFXIJMFUIFTZTUFNJTCFJOHEFWFMPQFE*OUIFﬁgurFUIFGVMMUJNFQFSJPEJOXIJDI UIJTPDDVSTTUBSUTBUUJNF5BOEFOETBU5The SFMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFODIBOHJOHVTFSOFFETBOEUIF DIBOHJOHTZTUFNWBSJFTBDDPSEJOHUPUIFUISFFFOHJOFFSJOHNPEFMTThe CJHCBOHNPEFMEFWFMPQT Table 9.2 Biological Models of Change Change Model Development/growth Mutation Recombination Division Replacement Birth Death

Unit of Change Individual organism DNA/RNA DNA Cell Cell Individual organism Individual organism

Time

O

225

Change correspondence System change

Model change

A

Time 1

Time 2

A

A

A A

B Time 1

Figure 9.6

B

Model change

A

A

A

A

Effect: -------- In to out --------

Change to different system

System change

A

-------- Out to in -------

Change A into different system Replace A with different system

Time 2

Boundary crossing change examples.

UIFFOUJSFTZTUFNUPTBUJTGZUIFGVMMTFUPGSFRVJSFNFOUTThe TZTUFNJTEFWFMPQFEBOESFBEZUPVTF BU5 BOEJUsatisﬁes UIFVTFSOFFETdeﬁned BU5 UIFTZTUFNJTEFTJHOBUFEBT4#JOUIFVQQFSMFGU QBSUPGUIFﬁgurF #FDBVTFVTFSOFFETIBWFDIBOHFECFUXFFO5BOE5 UIFSFJTBsigniﬁcant HBQ CFUXFFOUIFTZTUFNDBQBCJMJUZBOEXIBUUIFVTFSTOPXOFFEBU5

Changing user needs over time

Changing system over time

Needs at T1

Needs at T2

SI5

System at T4

SI4

System at T3

SI3

System at T2

SI2, SE2

Figure 9.7

T1

Needs at T4

Needs at T5

SE5

System at T5 SB5

Start

Needs at T3

SE4

SE3

T1 .. T5 = Time 1 .. Time 5 or = User needs S B5= System at T5, developed using big bang model S I2 .. S I5= System at T2 .. T5, developed using incremental model S E2 .. S E5= System at T2 .. T5, developed using evolution model

Comparison of Engineering Models

226 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

The JODSFNFOUBMNPEFMEFWFMPQTUIFTZTUFNJOTFWFSBMJODSFNFOUT XJUIBMMSFRVJSFNFOUTdeﬁned BOEBMMPDBUFEUPJODSFNFOUT 4* 4* 4* 4* BU5The ﬁrst JODSFNFOUIBTNJOJNBMDBQBCJMJUZ BOEFBDIJODSFNFOUBEETUPJU VOUJM4*SFQSFTFOUTUIFGVMMTZTUFN)PXFWFS MJLF4# UIFJODSFNFO UBMMZEFWFMPQFETZTUFN4*JTTUJMMUBSHFUFEUPUIFVTFSOFFETBU5 TPUIFSFJTBTJNJMBSHBQCFUXFFO UIFTZTUFNBOEUIFVTFSOFFETBU5 The FWPMVUJPONPEFMEJWJEFTUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPGUIFTZTUFNJOUPQJFDFT BTJOUIFJODSFNFOUBM NPEFM CVUUIFFWPMVUJPONPEFMBTTVNFTDIBOHFBOEEPFTOPUDPNNJUUPBﬁnal HPBM"UFBDIJUFSB UJPO JUSFWJTJUTVTFSOFFET BOEPOMZdeﬁnes EFUBJMFESFRVJSFNFOUTGPSUIFOFYUTUFQ UPXBSEUIF updated user needs at that point). Thus, for example, at 5 UIFFWPMVUJPONPEFMEFMJWFST4& BOE SFBTTFTTFTVTFSOFFETBU5#BTFEPOUIBUSFBTTFTTNFOU JUdeﬁnes UIFOFYUJUFSBUJPOBT4& XIJDIJT UIFOFYUTUFQUPXBSEUIFOPXSFWJTFEVTFSOFFET The CJHCBOHBOEJODSFNFOUBMNPEFMTBSFCBTFEPOBDPNNJUNFOUUPﬁxFEOFFETBOESFRVJSF NFOUTUIBUEPOPUDIBOHFPWFSUJNFThe FWPMVUJPONPEFM IPXFWFS JTEFTJHOFEUPFYQFDUBOEBEBQU UPDIBOHF"TBSFTVMU UIFTZTUFN4&FOETVQDMPTFSUPVTFSOFFETBU5UIBOUIFTZTUFNTEFWFMPQFE CZFJUIFSPGUIFPUIFSUXPFOHJOFFSJOHNPEFMT "DUVBMMZ XIBUUIFﬁgurFEPFTOPUTIPXJTUIBUUIFFWPMVUJPONPEFMDPOUJOVFTUPMPPLGVSUIFS JOUPUIFGVUVSFBUFBDIJUFSBUJPO CFZPOE5 UPUSBDLUIFDIBOHJOHMPOHUFSNEJSFDUJPOThis BTQFDU PG UIF 4& FWPMVUJPO QSPDFTT JT EJTDVTTFE JO $IBQUFS FTQFDJBMMZ JO UFSNT PG UIF SPMMJOH XBWF NPEFM

Models of Level 3 Change This TFDUJPODPODFSOTIPXNPEFMTDIBOHF"EJTUJODUJPOJTNBEFCFUXFFODIBOHFPGspeciﬁc NPEFMT BOEDIBOHFPGHFOFSBMNPEFMT

Change of Speciﬁc Models 4peciﬁc NPEFMTUFOEUPFYJTUNPSFJOUIFXPSLTQBDFQPSUJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFUIBOJOUIFLOPXM FEHFTQBDFQPSUJPO*OUIJTTFDUJPOXFEFTDSJCFUIFDIBOHFPGBspeciﬁc NPEFMBTTPDJBUFEPOMZXJUI a speciﬁc system; that is, it exists only in the context of a speciﬁc correspondence set. The life span PGTVDIBNPEFMJTUJFEDMPTFMZUPUIFTZTUFNMJGFTQBO 'PSNBUJPOPGBspeciﬁc NPEFMPDDVSTEVSJOHUIFTZTUFNQMBOOJOHQIBTF*UJTGPSNFEUISPVHI DSFBUJPO PSUISPVHIUBJMPSJOH .BUVSBUJPOPGBspeciﬁc NPEFMPDDVSTEVSJOHTZTUFNGPSNBUJPO BOENBUVSBUJPO QIBTF'PS FYBNQMF SFRVJSFNFOUTPGUFODIBOHFBOENBUVSFJOUIFDPVSTFPGEFWFMPQJOHUIFTZTUFNBOEBSF EFWFMPQFEBOESeﬁned furUIFSXIJMFUIFTZTUFNJTHBJOJOHJUTGVMMGVODUJPOBMJUZ 'VMMGVODUJPOJOHPDDVSTEVSJOHTZTUFNGVMMGVODUJPOQIBTF#PUITZTUFNBOENPEFMBSFGVMMZ GVODUJPOBMJOUIJTQIBTF CVUCPUINBZDIBOHF

Change of General Models (FOFSBMNPEFMTUFOEUPFYJTUNPSFJOUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFQPSUJPOPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFUIBOJOUIF XPSLTQBDFQPSUJPO"-FWFMDIBOHFPGBHFOFSBMNPEFMSFQSFTFOUTBDBUFHPSZDIBOHFUIBUJTEFDPV QMFEGSPNPSEPFTOPUSFMZPOJOEJWJEVBMDIBOHF(FOFSBMNPEFMDIBOHFTUIBUBSFBTTPDJBUFEXJUI JOEJWJEVBM - DIBOHFBSFDBMMFE-DIBOHFTBOEBSFEJTDVTTFEJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi.PEFMTPG $IBOHF*OWPMWJOH-FWFMTBOEw

Time

O

227

(FOFSBMNPEFMTUFOEUPCFSFMBUJWFMZTUBCMF BOEUIFJSSPMFJTUPQSPWJEFBHVJEFGPSPUIFSDIBOHFT TVDIBT-speciﬁc NPEFMDIBOHFPS-JOEJWJEVBMDIBOHFThey UZQJDBMMZSFQSFTFOUUFDIOPMPHJFT UIFPSJFT NFUBNPEFMT SFGFSFODFNPEFMT BOEQBUUFSOT$IBOHJOHBHFOFSBMNPEFMUFOETUPCFB DPNNVOJUZeﬀorUCFDBVTFJUJTQBSUPGUIFFWPMVUJPOPGUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDF"OFYDFQUJPOJTUIF DBUFHPSZPGHFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUSFQSFTFOUUIFBCTUSBDUWJTJPOPSHPBMPGBspeciﬁc TZTUFNThat DBU FHPSZPGNPEFMTUFOETUPCFJOUIFXPSLTQBDF

Models of Change Involving Levels 1 and 2 This section discusses prPDFTTFTBOEDIBOHFTUIBUDPWFSCPUI-FWFMBOE-FWFM

Autopoiesis "VUPQPJFTJT .BUVSBOBBOE7BSFMB JTUIFQSPDFTTPGTFMGDSFBUJPOPSTFMGQSPEVDUJPOThe LFZ DPODFQUJTNBJOUBJOJOHJUTPXOPSHBOJ[BUJPO QSFTFSWJOHUIFSFMBUJPOBMOFUXPSLUIBUdeﬁnes JUBT BTZTUFNJDVOJUZ .BUVSBOB The TZTUFNUIBUHBWFSJTFUPUIJTUFSNXBTUIFCJPMPHJDBMDFMM The UFSNJTDPOUSBTUFEXJUIBMMPQPJFTJT XIJDIJTBQSPDFTTJOXIJDIBTZTUFNPGPOFUZQFQSPEVDFT BOPUIFSUZQF TVDIBTBGBDUPSZQSPEVDJOHBDBS#ZPVSdeﬁnitions, BVUPQPJFTJTJTB-FWFMCFIBWJPS UIBUIBTB-FWFMeﬀect, XIFSFBTBMMPQPJFTJTJTTUSJDUMZB-FWFMCFIBWJPS/PUF IPXFWFS UIBUUIF eﬀect PGUIFBVUPQPJFUJDCFIBWJPSJTJOUIFEJSFDUJPOPGNBJOUBJOJOHTUSVDUVSFJOUIFGBDFPGDIBOHF SBUIFSUIBODIBOHJOHTUSVDUVSF

Phase Space Concepts Phase Trajectories, Orbits, Portraits 8FJOEJDBUFEFBSMJFSUIBUQIBTFUSBKFDUPSJFTPSPSCJUTSFQSFTFOUEZOBNJDCFIBWJPSTFRVFODFTPGB TZTUFN XIJDINBLFTUIFN-FWFMQSPDFTTFT)PXFWFS XFDPVMEBMTPDPODFJWBCMZdeﬁne BQIBTF USBKFDUPSZPGXIBUBTZTUFNJT UIBUJT IPXUIFTZTUFNJUTFMGDIBOHFTPWFSUJNF BTPQQPTFEUPJUT CFIBWJPS. This would be a LevFMQSPDFTT TherFJTBMTPDPODFJWBCMZUIFOPUJPOPGUIFQIBTFTQBDFBOEQIBTFUSBKFDUPSZPGBNPEFM XIJDI deﬁnes IPXUIFNPEFMDIBOHFTPWFSUJNFThis XPVMECFB-FWFMQSPDFTT*OGBDU UIF4&NPEFM TQBDFNBZQFSIBQTCFWJFXFEBTUIFQIBTFTQBDFPGNPEFMTPG4&TZTUFNT

Phase Transition *OUIFSNPEZOBNJDT QIBTFUSBOTJUJPOJTUIFTVEEFODIBOHFJOBTZTUFNGSPNPOFQIBTFUPBOPUIFS DMBTTJDBMMZUSBOTJUJPOJOHCFUXFFOTPMJE MJRVJE BOEHBTGPSNT*ODIBOHFUFSNT QIBTFUSBOTJUJPOJTB -FWFMDIBOHF JOTUBUF UIBUSFTVMUTJOB-FWFMDIBOHF JOGPSN

Self-Organizing Processes Self-Organization 4FMGPSHBOJ[BUJPOJTBQSPDFTTJOXIJDIUIFJOUFSOBMTUBUFPSTUSVDUVSFPGBTZTUFNUFOETUPCFDPNF NPSF PSHBOJ[FE XJUIPVU FYUFSOBM EJSFDUJPO PS DPOUSPM The DPODFQU IBT CFFO BQQMJFE UP B WBSJ FUZ PG EJTDJQMJOFT BOE TZTUFNT CPUI OBUVSBM BOE BStiﬁcial. The JTTVF PG NFBTVSJOH UIF EFHSFF PG

228

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

PSHBOJ[BUJPOJTOPUFOUJSFMZSFTPMWFE1PMBOJ BSHVFTUIBUJUDBOOPUCFNFBTVSFEBTBOJOUSJOTJD DIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGBTZTUFNBOEOFFETUIFBEEJUJPOPGBOPCTFSWFSBOBMPHPVTUPUIFDBTFGPSFNFS HFODF XIJDIJTPGUFOBTTPDJBUFEXJUITFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPO

Self-Organized Criticality 4FMGPSHBOJ[FEDSJUJDBMJUZ 40$ #BL 5BOH BOE8JFTFOGFME JTJOPOFTFOTFSFMBUFEUPCPUI QIBTFUSBOTJUJPOBOETFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPOThe DSJUJDBMJUZDPSSFTQPOETUPUIFDSJUJDBMQPJOUPGBQIBTF USBOTJUJPO*GUIJTDSJUJDBMQPJOUJTBOBUUSBDUPS JOUIFEZOBNJDBMTZTUFNTTFOTF UIFOUIFTZTUFNJT ESBXOUPUIJTQPJOUJOBTFMGPSHBOJ[JOHNBOOFS)PXFWFS UIFSFJTTPNFEFCBUFPOUIFEFHSFFUP XIJDI40$SFQSFTFOUTTFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPO 7FTQJHOBOJBOE;BQQFSJ 40$JTDPOUSBTUFEXJUIIJHIMZPQUJNJ[FEUPMFSBODF )05 BTBMUFSOBUFWJFXTJO$IBQUFS

Panarchy 1BOBSDIZ (VOEFSTPOBOE)PMMJOH JTBDPNQSFIFOTJWFQSPDFTTJOUFOEFEUPTDBMFVQUPSFTJM JFODFBOETVTUBJOBCJMJUZBUUIFMFWFMPGJOUFSBDUJOHFDPTZTUFNT FDPOPNJFT BOETPDJFUJFTThe CSPBE TVCKFDUBSFBJTUIFJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOQFPQMFBOEOBUVSFThe XPSEQBOBSDIZXBTQJDLFEUPDPO USBTUXJUIDPOUSPMIJFSBSDIJFTBOEUPJODPSQPSBUFUIFDPODFQUPGUJNFBOEDZDMFTThrFFUIFNFTBSF CSPVHIUUPHFUIFSJOUIJTQSPDFTT 4UBCJMJUZ DIBOHF BOESFTJMJFODF $SPTTTDBMFJOUFSBDUJPOTBDSPTTBXJEFSBOHFPGTDBMFT JODMVEJOHUIFUJNFTDBMFBOEBMTPNPTU PGUIFTDBMFWJFXTXFEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS "EBQUJWFDIBOHFBOEMFBSOJOHTMPXDZDMFTJOUFSTQFSTFEXJUISBQJEDIBOHFDZDMFT This QSPDFTTFNCSBDFTUIFUFOTJPOTBOEQBSBEPYFTPGFYQMPJUBUJPOBOEDPOTFSWBUJPO EFTUSVDUJPO BOE CJSUI SFMFBTF BOE SFPSHBOJ[BUJPO BOE TUBCJMJUZ BOE DIBOHF The JOUFHSBUFE FMFNFOUT PG UIJT QSPDFTTBSFGVMMZDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIF.04&4BQQSPBDIUPFYUFOTJPOBOEuniﬁcation PGUSBEJUJPOBM BOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNTThe QBOBSDIZNPEFMDPVMECFBsigniﬁcant DPOUSJCVUPSUPUIF4&QSPDFTTFT PGUIFGVUVSF

Models at Runtime "NPWFNFOUBEESFTTJOHNPEFMTBUSVOUJNFIBTFNFSHFE"QSJNBSZUIFNFJTFYUFOEJOHNPEFM JOH JOUP SVOUJNF FYFDVUJPO PG TPGUXBSF BOE JOGPSNBUJPO TZTUFNT The NPUJWBUJPO JT UIF DIBOHF PDDVSSJOH JO SVOUJNF FYQFDUBUJPOT PG TPGUXBSF 4PGUXBSF JT NPSF EZOBNJD BOE NPSF EFDJTJPOT BOEDIBOHFTBSFNBEFBUSVOUJNF*O.04&4UFSNT UIJTJTQBSUPGUIFCMFOEJOHPG-FWFMBOE DIBOHFTXIFSFUIFTZTUFNDIBOHFTEVSJOHPQFSBUJPO 4PGUXBSFOFFETUPCFBEBQUBCMF ﬂexible, BOESeconﬁgurable OPUKVTUJOUIFEFTJHOFOWJSPONFOU CVU JO UIF SVOUJNF FOWJSPONFOU *O BEEJUJPO NPSF TPGUXBSF BVUPOPNZ BT JO TFMGNBOBHJOH PS BVUPOPNJDGVODUJPOT JTFYQFDUFE4FMGBXBSFOFTTBOESeﬂection BSFBMTPJNQPSUBOUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT .PEFMESJWFOBQQSPBDIFTIBWFTUSFOHUIFOFEEFTJHOBOEQSPEVDUJPOPGTPGUXBSF CVUNPEFMJOHTVQ QPSUEVSJOHSVOUJNFJTXeak. That is what this moWFNFOUJTBUUFNQUJOHUPSFNFEZ 4VNNBSJFTPGUIFﬁrst UXPXPSLTIPQTPGUIJTHSPVQBSFJO#FODPNP #MBJS BOE'SBODF BOE#FODPNP 'SBODF BOE#MBJS

Time

O

229

Models of Change Involving Levels 2 and 3 Example -FWFMDIBOHFJOWPMWFTDIBOHFJOBNPEFM - UIBUJTJOUJNBUFMZBTTPDJBUFEXJUIDIBOHFJOJOEJ WJEVBMTZTUFNT - The NPEFMQMBZTUIFSPMFPGDBUFHPSZBOEUIFJOEJWJEVBMTZTUFNTQMBZUIFSPMF PGJOTUBODFTPGUIBUDBUFHPSZ-DIBOHFJTUIFMPDVTPGCJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPO"OFYBNQMFXJMMIFMQ SFWFBMUIFTJNQMJDJUZPGUIF-DPODFQU -FUTDPOTJEFSUIFGPMMPXJOHTDFOBSJPPGNPEFMTBOEQPQVMBUJPOTJOUIFEPNBJOPGIVNBOBOBUPNZ 'JSTU BTTVNFUIBUFTTFOUJBMBOBUPNZPGIVNBOTPO&BSUIIBTOPUDIBOHFEEVSJOHUIFNJMMFOOJVN CFUXFFOZFBSTBOE"TTVNFBMTPUIBUIVNBOTXJMMTVSWJWFJOTPNFGPSNGPSUIFOFYUNJM MJPOZFBST BOEFTTFOUJBMDIBOHFTUPIVNBOBOBUPNZXJMMPDDVSPWFSUIBUQFSJPE UIBUJT CFUXFFOZFBST BOE'VSUIFSBTTVNFUIBUUIFBDUVBMQSPDFTTPGCJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPOPGQPQVMBUJPOTPO &BSUIJTTVTDFQUJCMFUPDIBOHF CVUUIBUEVSJOHUIFQFSJPEUPJUEPFTOPUDIBOHF /Pw deﬁne four models: "UIFNPEFMPGIVNBOBOBUPNZdeﬁned CZUIFDPNNVOJUZPGIVNBOBOBUPNJTUTBUBOZ HJWFOQPJOUJOUJNF '"UIFhigh-ﬁdelity NPEFMPGIVNBOBOBUPNZBUBOZHJWFOQPJOUJOUJNF UIBUJT UIF NPEFMUIBUSeﬂects actual human anatomy at that time. $UIFNPEFMPGCJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPOdeﬁned CZUIFDPNNVOJUZPGFWPMVUJPOBSZCJPMPHJTUT PSUIFFRVJWBMFOU BUBOZHJWFOQPJOUJOUJNF '$ the high-ﬁdelity model of biological evPMVUJPOBUBOZHJWFOQPJOUJOUJNF 5BCMFTIPXTUIFTFNPEFMTBUTFWFSBMQPJOUTJOUJNF (JWFOUIFBTTVNQUJPOTBCPWF XIBUDBOXFTBZBCPVUUIFdiﬀerFODFTCFUXFFOUIFTFNPEFMTBOE XIBUMFWFMTUIFZSFQSesent? The rFMFWBOUQPJOUTJODMVEF '" '" BOE'"BSFBMMUIFTBNFCVU'"JTdiﬀerFOUCFDBVTFFWPMVUJPOPGBOBUPNZ PDDVSSFEJOUIFIVNBOQPQVMBUJPOGSPNUP*UJTBO-DIBOHFCFDBVTFJU JTBNPEFMDIBOHF - CBTFEPODIBOHFJOUIFQPQVMBUJPOPGJOEJWJEVBMT - " " BOE"BSFBMMTPNFXIBUdiﬀerFOUUIBUJT BMUIPVHIBDUVBMIVNBOBOBUPNZEJEOPU DIBOHFEVSJOHUIJTQFSJPE PVSVOEFSTUBOEJOHBOENPEFMPGJUEJEThese DIBOHFTUIFSFGPSF SFQSFTFOU-DIBOHFJONPEFMCVUOPUJOTZTUFNT "diﬀers GSPN"GPSUXPSFBTPOT'JSTUBOBUPNJTUTQSFTVNBCMZMFBSOFENPSFBCPVUBOBU PNZ XIJDIJT-DIBOHF4FDPOE BOBUPNJTUTUSBDLFEUIFDIBOHFJOIVNBOBOBUPNZPWFS UIFDPVSTFPGUIFNJMMJPOZFBST TPUIBUDIBOHFJTBO-DIBOHF

Table 9.3 Sample Model Changes across Time Year Model FA A FC C

Change Level

1009

1909

2009

1002009

L2-3 L3 (L2-3) L2-3 L3

FA1 A1 FC1 C1

FA2 A2 FC2 C2

FA3 A3 FC3 C3

FA4 A4 FC4 C4

230 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

'$ '$ '$ BOE'$BSFBMMUIFTBNF/PDIBOHFJOUIFFTTFOUJBMFWPMVUJPOQSPDFTT PDDVSSFEBDSPTTUIJTUJNFQFSJPE $ $ $ BOE$BSFBMMdiﬀerFOU$XBTUIFNPEFMPGDIBOHFJOIVNBOBOBUPNZJO XIJDI XBT TPNFUIJOH MJLF UIJT IVNBO BOBUPNZ EPFT OPU DIBOHF PWFS UJNF JU JT DPOTUBOU$SFQSFTFOUTFTTFOUJBMMZ%BSXJOTUIFPSZPGFWPMVUJPO$SFQSFTFOUTUIFDVSSFOU UIFPSZPGFWPMVUJPO XIJDIJTNPSFPSMFTTUIFNPEFSOTZOUIFTJTUIBUclariﬁed UIFHFOFUJD SPMFJOWBSJBUJPO 'VUVZNB $XJMMSeﬂect XIBUFWFSBEEJUJPOBMMFBSOJOHUBLFTQMBDF PGUIFQSPDFTTPGFWPMVUJPOPWFSUIFOFYUNJMMJPOZFBST"MMUIFTFDIBOHFTBSFUPUIFNPEFM POMZ -

OPUUPUIFFWPMVUJPOQSPDFTTJUTFMG XIJDIXFBTTVNFEPFTOPUDIBOHFEVSJOHUIJT QFSJPE The DIBOHFGSPN$UP$XBTQSPCBCMZHSFBUFSUIBOUIFDIBOHFGSPN"UP"CFDBVTF BMUIPVHIPVSLOPXMFEHFPGBOBUPNZJODSFBTFEsigniﬁcantly UIFDIBOHFQSPCBCMZXBTOPUBT SBEJDBMBTUIBUSFQSFTFOUFECZ%BSXJOTUIFPSZ This FYBNQMFJMMVTUSBUFTUIFEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOBO-NPEFMDIBOHF XIJDIJTOPUBTTPDJBUFE XJUI TZTUFN DIBOHF BOE BO - DIBOHF XIJDI JT NPEFM DIBOHF CBTFE PO TZTUFN DIBOHF *O UIJTDBTF -DIBOHFXBTCBTFEPOMFBSOJOHNPSFBCPVUUIFTZTUFNTCFJOHNPEFMFE UIBUJT BCPVU JODSeasing ﬁdelity of the model.

Applying Biological Evolution &WPMVUJPOIBTCFFOBEPNJOBOUBOEHSPXJOHUPQJDJO4&JOSFDFOUZFBST NVDINPSFUIBOPUIFS CJPMPHJDBMNPEFMTPGDIBOHF8FFYQMPSFJOUIJTTFDUJPOBdeﬁnition PGCJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPOBOEIPX UIFUFSNiFWPMVUJPOwJTVTFEJO4&

Evolution: Deﬁnition and Introduction #iological deﬁnition: #JPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPO BDDPSEJOHUP'VUVZNB BOE

JT iDIBOHFJOUIFQSPQFSUJFTPGHSPVQTPGPSHBOJTNTPWFSUIFDPVSTFPGHFOFSBUJPOTThe EFWFMPQNFOU PS POUPHFOZ PG BO JOEJWJEVBM PSHBOJTN JT OPU DPOTJEFSFE FWPMVUJPO *OEJWJEVBMPSHBOJTNTEPOPUFWPMWF(SPVQTPGPSHBOJTNT XIJDIXFNBZDBMMQPQV MBUJPOT VOEFSHP EFTDFOU XJUI modiﬁcation z The DIBOHFT JO QPQVMBUJPOT UIBU BSF DPOTJEFSFE FWPMVUJPOBSZ BSF UIPTF UIBU BSF QBTTFE WJB UIF HFOFUJD NBUFSJBM GSPN POF HFOFSBUJPOUPUIFOFYU#JPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPONBZCFTMJHIUPSTVCTUBOUJBMJUFNCSBDFT FWFSZUIJOHGSPNTMJHIUDIBOHFTJOUIFQSPQPSUJPOTPGdiﬀerFOUGPSNTPGBHFOFXJUIJO BQPQVMBUJPOUPUIFBMUFSBUJPOTUIBUMFEGSPNUIFFBSMJFTUPSHBOJTNUPEJOPTBVST CFFT PBLT BOEIVNBOTzThe AHFOFUJDBMUIFPSZPGOBUVSBMTFMFDUJPOzJTUIFLFZTUPOFPG DPOUFNQPSBSZFWPMVUJPOBSZUIFPSZz/BUVSBMTFMFDUJPOJTOPUUIFTBNFBTFWPMVUJPO &WPMVUJPOJTBUXPTUFQQSPDFTTUIFPSJHJOPGHFOFUJDWBSJBUJPOCZNVUBUJPOPSSFDPNCJ OBUJPO GPMMPXFECZDIBOHFTJOUIFGSFRVFODJFTPGBMMFMFTBOEHFOPUZQFT DBVTFEchieﬂy CZHFOFUJDESJGUPSOBUVSBMTFMFDUJPOw &OHJOFFSJOHdeﬁnitions:*ODPOUSBTUUPCJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPO JOFOHJOFFSJOHBDPNNPONFBOJOHPG FWPMVUJPOJTDIBOHFJOBHJWFOJOEJWJEVBMTZTUFN SBUIFSUIBOJOBQPQVMBUJPO*O.04&4UFSNT UIJT UZQFBQQMJFTUPUIF-FWFMDIBOHFPGBOJOEJWJEVBMTZTUFNThis NFBOJOHPGFWPMVUJPOJTSeﬂected JO QISBTFTTVDIBT“This TZTUFNFWPMWFTPWFSUJNFw#JPMPHZVTFTUFSNTTVDIBTiBEBQUBUJPO wiHSPXUI w

Time

O

231

iEFWFMPQNFOU wBOEiNBUVSBUJPOwGPSUIJTUZQFPGJOEJWJEVBMDIBOHF#FDBVTFUIJTVTBHFPGFWPMVUJPO JTFTUBCMJTIFEJOFOHJOFFSJOH UIFHPBMBUUIJTQPJOUJTUPQSPNPUFSFDPHOJUJPOPGCPUINFBOJOHTPG UIFUFSNBOENBLJOHUIFEJTUJODUJPOTFYQMJDJU FWPMVUJPOJTHSBEVBMDIBOHFJOBOJOEJWJEVBMTZT UFNPSFOUJUZ BOE FWPMVUJPOJTHSBEVBMDIBOHFJOBQPQVMBUJPOPGJOEJWJEVBMTZTUFNTPSFOUJUJFT Which deﬁnition is being used in a givFOTJUVBUJPOTIPVMECFNBEFDMFBS The remainder of this subsection discusses deﬁnition (2). .04&4QFSTQFDUJWFPOdeﬁnition *OUIFDPOUFYUPG4&BOEUIFJTTVFPGDIBOHF UIF.04&4 QPTJUJPOJTUIBUJUNBLFTTFOTFUPEFTJHOBUFBQPQVMBUJPOBTBDBUFHPSZ XJUIJUTNFNCFSTBTJOTUBODFT PGUIFDBUFHPSZ&BDICJPMPHJDBMQPQVMBUJPOIBTBdeﬁned TFUPGDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUIBUIPMETGPSBMM JUTJOTUBODFT4P FWPMVUJPOPGBQPQVMBUJPOJTDIBOHFJOBDBUFHPSZ XIJDIJTBDIBOHFJOBHFOFSBM NPEFMB-FWFMDIBOHF"OECFDBVTFJUJTJOUJNBUFMZBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIFDIBOHFPGUIFQPQVMB UJPOJOEJWJEVBMT JUJTEFTJHOBUFEBT-

Deﬁne the Unit of Selection &WPMVUJPODBOCFBQQMJFEUPBOZEPNBJOJOXIJDIVOJUTPGTFMFDUJPOBSFdeﬁned BOEUIFZFYIJCJU WBSJFUZPOXIJDITFMFDUJPOPQFSBUFT#BMEXJOBOE$MBSL EJTDVTTUIFBQQMJDBUJPOPGFWPMV UJPOJOUIJTTFOTFUPUIFHFOFSBMBSFBPGEFTJHO6OJUTPGTFMFDUJPOJOEFTJHOFWPMVUJPODBOJODMVEF BSUJGBDUT TZTUFNT EFTJHOT BOEUBTLTUSVDUVSFT6OJUTPGTFMFDUJPOJOJOEVTUSZFWPMVUJPODBOJODMVEF FOUFSQSJTFTBOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOT*ONPEVMBSTZTUFNT UIFVOJUPGTFMFDUJPOEPFTOPUIBWFUPCFUIF XIPMFTZTUFN*UDBOCFBTVCTZTUFNPSDPNQPOFOUBOZXIFSFJOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZThis QSPWJEFTHSeater granularity in selecting ﬁt elements oWer unﬁt. *OTPNFBQQMJDBUJPOT UIFVOJUPGTFMFDUJPOJTBCFIBWJPSPGBTZTUFNThe CFIBWJPSTSFQSFTFOUB WBSJFUZ BOEDFSUBJOCFIBWJPSTBSFTFMFDUFEBOEPUIFSTBSFOPU*GXFDPOTJEFSUIFJOEJWJEVBMCFIBWJPST UPDIBOHF PSUIFGSFRVFODZPGCFIBWJPSTUPDIBOHFJOUIFQPQVMBUJPOPGCFIBWJPST UIFOXFDPVME DBMMUIJTBO-DIBOHF8FTIPVMEOPUFUIBUXIJMFUIJTJTBSFBTPOBCMFBQQMJDBUJPOPGFWPMVUJPO JUJTOPUDMFBSUIBUUIJTJTNPSFVTFGVMUIBOUIFTJNQMFSCJPMPHJDBMNPEFMTUIBUFYJTUBU- TVDIBT BEBQUBUJPOPSNBUVSBUJPOPGUIFTZTUFN PSFWFO-CFIBWJPSPGUIFTZTUFN

Applications 0OFDMFBSBOEBQQSPQSJBUFXBZUPBQQMZFWPMVUJPOUP4&JTUPVTFHFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUSFQSFTFOU DBUFHPSJFT"QSPNJOFOUFYBNQMFJTUZQFTPSHFOFSBUJPOTPGUFDIOPMPHJFT"QFSTQFDUJWFUIBUIFMQT FYQMBJOUIJTUZQFPGBQQMJDBUJPOJTUIBUPGFWPMVUJPOJOBDIBOHJOHFOWJSPONFOU*GUIFFOWJSPONFOU DIBOHFTUPPSBQJEMZ UIFQPQVMBUJPODBOOPUFWPMWFRVJDLMZFOPVHIBOEJUEJFTPVU *OUFDIOPMPHZBOE4& UIFFOWJSPONFOUTPNFUJNFTDIBOHFTRVJDLMZ8IFOUIF*OUFSOFUFNFSHFE JOUIFT JUXBTBSBUIFSSBQJEBOEsigniﬁcant DIBOHFGPSJOEJWJEVBMT BOEBTPNFXIBUNPSF HSBEVBMDIBOHFGPSPSHBOJ[BUJPOT.BOZJOEJWJEVBMTRVJDLMZBEBQUFEBOEFYQMPJUFEUIFOFXFOWJ SPONFOU CVUTPNFEJEOPU"GUFSBQFSJPEPGUJNF JGPSHBOJ[BUJPOTEJEOPUBEBQU UIFZXFSFQSPC BCMZBUBEJTBEWBOUBHF/PXUIFSFJTBOPUIFSHFOFSBUJPOPGUFDIOPMPHJFTDBMMFE8FC TVDIBT CMPHTBOEXJLJT*OUIFDPOUFYUPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOT TPNFDBMMUIJT&OUFSQSJTFThis DPODFQUJTOPU HBJOJOHUSBDUJPOJOPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBTGBTUBTFYQFDUFE $IVSDI #BTFEPOBOFDEPUBMFWJEFODF UIFSFJTBHFOFSBUJPOBMdiﬀerFODFJOBDDFQUBCJMJUZPG&OUFSQSJTFUFDIOPMPHJFTUIFPMEFSHFOFSB UJPOPGQFPQMFJTNPSFDPOUFOUUPTUBZXJUIﬁrst-generation *OUFSOFUUFDIOPMPHJFTTVDIBTFNBJM XIJMFUIFOFXFSHFOFSBUJPOJTVTJOHUIFOFXUFDIOPMPHJFTNPSF *O4& FWPMVUJPOJOQPQVMBUJPOTTVDIBTPSHBOJ[BUJPOTDBOPDDVSJOTFWFSBMXBZT0OFJTCZBEBQ UBUJPOPGUIFJOEJWJEVBMNFNCFSTUPBOFXFOWJSPONFOU XIJDIJTXIBUIBQQFOFE UPBMBSHFFYUFOU

232 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

XJUI UIF *OUFSOFU "OPUIFS JT CZ SFQMBDFNFOU FH UISPVHI SFUJSFNFOU BOE IJSJOH PG NFNCFST XIPIBWFOPUBEBQUFECZOFXNFNCFSTXIPBMSFBEZﬁt UIFOFXFOWJSPONFOU XIJDIBQQBSFOUMZJT IBQQFOJOHUPTPNFEFHSFFXJUI&OUFSQSJTF"deﬁned QSPDFTTPGBQQMZJOHFWPMVUJPOUPPSHBOJ[B UJPOTJTQSFTFOUFEJO"YFMSPEBOE$PIFO BOEEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJO$IBQUFS The TBNFQBUUFSOFYJTUTXJUINPSFUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNT*GUIFFOWJSPONFOUPGBTZTUFNDIBOHFT JOBXBZUIBUSFRVJSFTsigniﬁcant DIBOHFTUPUIFTZTUFN BOBOBMZTJTOFFETUPCFEPOFUPDPNQBSF UIFPQUJPOTPGDIBOHJOH BEBQUJOH UIFTZTUFNUPUIFOFXFOWJSPONFOU PSSFQMBDJOHJUXJUIBOFX system that has a better ﬁt. The NPSF HFOFSBM QBUUFSO JT UIBU HFOFSBUJPOT PG UFDIOPMPHZ SFQSFTFOU QPQVMBUJPOT BOE TZT UFNTVTJOHPSSFQSFTFOUJOHUIPTFUFDIOPMPHJFTBSFJOEJWJEVBMT5FDIOPMPHJFTFWPMWFWJBTFMFDUJPOPG TZTUFNT 4DJFOUJTUTBOEscientiﬁc UIFPSJFTIBWFFYIJCJUFEUIFTBNFUFOTJPO UIFTBNFQBUUFSO.BY1MBODL FYQSFTTFEUIFQBUUFSOUIJTXBZJO "OJNQPSUBOUscientiﬁc JOOPWBUJPOSBSFMZNBLFTJUTXBZCZHSBEVBMMZXJOOJOHPWFSBOE DPOWFSUJOHJUTPQQPOFOUT8IBUEPFTIBQQFOJTUIBUJUTPQQPOFOUTHSBEVBMMZEJFPVU BOEUIBUUIFHSPXJOHHFOFSBUJPOJTGBNJMJBSJ[FEXJUIUIFJEFBGSPNUIFCFHJOOJOH *OGBDU UIFQBUUFSOJOTDJFODFJODMVEFTUIFQIFOPNFOPOXIFSFFWFOBTDJFOUJTUXIPQSPQPTFTBOFX UIFPSZDBOOPUBDDFQUJU XIJMFUIFOFXFSHFOFSBUJPOJOUIFﬁFMEFNCSBDFTJU"XFMMLOPXOFYBNQMFJT &JOTUFJO XIPNBEFTVCTUBOUJBMDPOUSJCVUJPOTUPRVBOUVNUIFPSZCVUDPVMEOPUBDDFQUNBOZBTQFDUT PGUIFUIFPSZ JODMVEJOHTPNFPGIJTPXOJNQMJDBUJPOT *TBBDTPO 4UPOF

Distinctions, Differences 4PNFEJTUJODUJPOTCFUXFFOUIFFWPMVUJPOQSPDFTTJOCJPMPHZBOEJO4&BSFEJTDVTTFEIFSF *OIFSJUBODFBOEJUTSPMFJOFWPMVUJPO*OCJPMPHZ UIFSFJTBTUSPOHHFOFUJDMJOLGSPNUIFPMEUPUIF OFXUISPVHIUIFJOIFSJUBODFDIBJO/PJOEJWJEVBMTZTUFN PSHBOJTN JTTJNQMZDSFBUFEXJUIBXIPMF diﬀerFOUTFUPGHFOFT&WFSZUIJOHJTMJOLFEUISPVHIDPNNPOEFTDFOU#VUJOFOHJOFFSJOH UIFSFJT BNVDIDMFBOFSCSFBLJONBOZDBTFTGSPNPOFUFDIOPMPHZHFOFSBUJPOUPUIFOFYUTher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

Time

O

233

*OCJPMPHZ NVUBUJPOTPDDVSXIFODPQZJOHUIFHFOPNF XIJDIJTPOFTPVSDFPGUIFWBSJBUJPO OFDFTTBSZGPSFWolution. The counterparUJOTPGUXBSFJTHFOFUJDQSPHSBNNJOH "Stiﬁcial FWPMVUJPOTherFJTBSFTFBSDIDPNNVOJUZFYQMPSJOHBStiﬁcial FWPMVUJPO XIJDIJTSFMBUFE UPBStiﬁcial MJGFThis ﬁeld deﬁnes BOEVTFTNPEFMTPGBHFOUT ﬁtness MBOETDBQFT TFMFDUJPODSJUFSJB FUD"DDPSEJOHUP%VDPVMPNCJFSBOE4FCBH

BStiﬁcial FWPMVUJPOVTVBMMZDPOTJEFSTﬁxFEFOWJ SPONFOUTPSﬁtness MBOETDBQFT'PSBQQMJDBUJPOUPUIFGVUVSFPG4& UIJTMJNJUBUJPOXPVMEOFFEUP CFSFWJTJUFE

Conclusions: Needed Change Models This TFDUJPObrieﬂy DIBSBDUFSJ[FTUIFTVJUFPGDIBOHFNPEFMTOFFEFECZUIFGVUVSF4& CVJMEJOHPO UIFQSFDFEJOHTFDUJPOT'JSTU JUJTFYUSFNFMZJNQPSUBOUUPJODMVEFNPEFMTPGDIBOHFJOUIFBSTFOBM PG4&PGUIFGVUVSF8FCFMJFWFUIJTBSFBJTRVJUFXFBLJOUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH#JPMPHJDBM FWPMVUJPOJTPOFPGBOVNCFSPGCJPMPHJDBMNPEFMTPGDIBOHF4&OFFETUPFYBNJOFPUIFSTBTXFMM The BQQSPQSJBUFTFMFDUJPOPGCJPMPHJDBMNPEFMTPGDIBOHF BOEBQQSPQSJBUFXBZTUPBQQMZUIFNBOE UBJMPSUIFNUP4&BUWBSJPVTMFWFMT JTBTVCKFDUGPSGVSUIFSSFTFBSDI 8FDBO IPXFWFS EFTDSJCFDFSUBJODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGUIFOFFEFETVJUFPGDIBOHFNPEFMTGPS4& The TVJUF JODMVEFT NPEFMT BU BMM SBUFT GSPN WFSZ HSBEVBM DIBOHF PWFS UJNF UP TVEEFO DIBOHF *U JODMVEFTNPEFMTPGTFMGDIBOHF TVDIBTTFMGBEBQUJOH TFMGNPEJGZJOH TFMGPSHBOJ[JOH FH )PMMBOE Kauﬀman

HSPXUI EFDMJOF BOE UFSNJOBUJPO PS EFBUI *U BMTP JODMVEFT NPEFMT PG DIBOHFJOEVDFECZBOFYUFSOBMBHFOU TVDIBTBEFTJHOFSPSDPOUSPMMFSPSVQHSBEFSPSUFBDIFS*U includes purposeful change, accidental change, and inﬂuenced change. *U BMTP JODMVEFT EFTJSFE DIBOHF BOE VOEFTJSFE DIBOHF BT TIPXO JO5BCMF *O HFOFSBM B HJWFOTJUVBUJPOIBTCPUIGPSDFTGPSDIBOHFBOEGPSDFTGPSTUBCJMJUZ4PNFUJNFTXFEFTJSFDIBOHFBOE TPNFUJNFTXFEFTJSFTUBCJMJUZ'PSFYBNQMF JGXFBSFFOHJOFFSJOHBOFXTZTUFN XFPSUIFQFSTPO SFRVFTUJOHUIFOFXTZTUFNEFTJSFDIBOHFPGTPNFUZQF*GXFEFTJSFDIBOHF XFTIPVMEFYQMPJU UIFGPSDFTGPSDIBOHFBOEDPVOUFSUIFGPSDFTGPSTUBCJMJUZ*ONBOZDBTFTPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMDIBOHF TPNFQFPQMFEFTJSFUIFDIBOHF XIJMFPUIFSTEPOPUThose EFTJSJOHDIBOHFXJMMFYQMPJUUIFGPSDFT GPSDIBOHF TVDIBTUIFdiﬃculties DBVTFECZUIFDVSSFOUTJUVBUJPO BOEUIPTFPQQPTFEUPDIBOHFXJMM FYQMPJUUIFGPSDFTGPSTUBCJMJUZ, such as cost, diﬃculty of change, inerUJB *OLFFQJOHXJUIUIFNPEVMBSOBUVSFPG.04&4 JUJTJNQPSUBOUUPFNQIBTJ[FUIBUDIBOHFJT EFDPVQMFEGSPNUIFWBMVFPSEFTJSBCJMJUZPGUIFDIBOHF BTTUBUFEJO$IBQUFSThe BOBMZTJTBOE NPEFMJOHPGDIBOHFJTPOFBDUJWJUZ"TFQBSBUFBDUJWJUZJTUIFEFTJHOBUJPOUIBUUIFDIBOHFSFQSFTFOUT QSPHSFTTPSEFDMJOF PSJTEFTJSFEPSVOEFTJSFE5BCMFSFQSFTFOUTBTUBUFJOXIJDITVDIBEFTJHOB UJPOIBTCFFONBEF&WPMVUJPOJTEFDPVQMFEGSPNWBMVBUJPOPGUIFDIBOHFUIBUPDDVST

Table 9.4 Actions

Desired and Undesired Change

Forces Desired

Change

Stability

Change Stability

Exploit Counter

Counter Exploit

234

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

*O TFMFDUJOH NPEFMT GPS TZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH BOE FTQFDJBMMZ JO UIF DPOUFYU PG .04&4 XF FNQIBTJ[FBQPJOUNBEFJOFBSMJFSDIBQUFSTXFXBOUNPEFMTUIBUBSFVTFGVMXFBSFOPUTPDPO DFSOFEXJUIXIFUIFSUIFZBSFUSue. This should be kept in mind when wFBSFFYBNJOJOHCJPMPHJDBM NPEFMTGPSUIFJSVTFGVMOFTTUP4&The DPODFSOPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTJTBCPVUUIFﬁdelity PGCJPMPHJ DBMUIFPSJFTPSNPEFMTUPUIFTPDJPUFDIOJDBMTZTUFNTXFCVJME "OJNQPSUBOUBTQFDUPGUIJTBSHVNFOUJTUIBUCJPMPHJDBMNPEFMT BOE$4NPEFMTJOHFOFSBM PGUFO IBWFHSFBUFSﬁdelity UPNBOZUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTUIBOEPNFDIBOJTUJDNPEFMT BTBSHVFEJO$IBQUFS 4. That claim is an element of MOSES uniﬁcation.

Time and Change Related to Other Dimensions 8FIBWFNFOUJPOFETPNFDPOOFDUJPOTPGUJNFXJUIPUIFSEJNFOTJPOTJOFBSMJFSTFDUJPOTJOUIJT DIBQUFS)FSFBSFBGFXNPSFDPOOFDUJPOT

Dual Hierarchy ThFDPODFQUPGEVBMIJFSBSDIZIBTCFFOEJTDVTTFEJOTFWFSBMQMBDFT JO UIF CPPL *U PDDVST JO UIF DPNQPTJUJPO DPNNPOJ[BUJPO BOE DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPOTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF*TUIFSFBOBOBMP HPVTEVBMJUZJOUIFUJNFEJNFOTJPO The BOTXFSJTZFT BOE4UFQIFO )BXLJOH $IBQUFS IBTQSPWJEFEBQIZTJDTWFSTJPOPGJU UIBUXFXJMMVTFBTUIFCBTJTGPSPVSNPSFHFOFSBM4&WFSTJPO 'JHVSFTIPXTUIFCBTJDTUSVDUVSFPGUIFEVBMIJFSBSDIZThe QSFTFOUJTUIFQPJOUJOUJNFUIBUDPOOFDUTBOETFQBSBUFTUIFQBTU BOE GVUVSF TQBDFT .PSF speciﬁcally UIF QSFTFOU JT UIF DVSSFOU TUBUFPGBTZTUFN UIFQBTUJTUIFTFUPGTUBUFTUIBUDPVMEMFBEUP UIFDVSSFOUTUBUF BOEUIFGVUVSFJTUIFTFUPGTUBUFTUPXIJDIUIF DVSSFOUTUBUFDPVMEMFBE"MMPUIFSTUBUFTMJFJOUIFiFMTFXIFSFwPG UIFDVSSFOUTZTUFNTUBUFUIFZDBOOPUMFBEUPUIFDVSSFOUTUBUF BOEUIFDVSSFOUTUBUFDBOOPUMFBEUPUIFNThe ﬁgurFDPVMEIBWF TFWFSBMJOUFSQSFUBUJPOT5XPPGUIFNBSF

ABSOLUTE FUTURE

PRESENT ELSEWHERE ELSEWHERE ABSOLUTE PAST

Figure 9.8 Dual hierarchies of time. (“Interior illustration” by Ron Miller, ©1988 by Ron Miller, from A Brief History of Time by Stephen W. Hawking. Used with permission from Bantam Books, a division of Random House, Inc.)

5SBKFDUPSZ QPUFOUJBM WJFX The QBTU QSFTFOU BOE GVUVSF SFQSFTFOU B TOBQTIPU PG UIF DPO TUSBJOFEQIBTFTQBDFPGUIFTZTUFN XIFSFUIFDPOTUSBJOUJTUIFDVSSFOUTUBUF N 1BTU BMMQPTTJCMFQSFWJPVTTUBUFTBOEUSBKFDUPSJFTPGTZTUFNUIBUMFBEUPUIFQSFTFOU TUBUF N 'VUVSFBMMQPTTJCMFGVUVSFTUBUFTBOEUSBKFDUPSJFTPGTZTUFNSFBDIBCMFGSPNUIFQSFTFOU TUBUF This JOUFSQSFUBUJPOJTUIFWJFX BMPOHXJUIUIFDPNQMFUFQIBTFTQBDF JOXIJDIXF deﬁne and analyzFNPEFMTPGTZTUFNCFIBWJPS 5SBKFDUPSZLOPXMFEHFWJFX N 1BTUBDUVBMQSFWJPVTTUBUFTBOEUSBKFDUPSZPGTZTUFN N 1SFTFOUDVSSFOUTUBUFPGTZTUFN )BXLJOHTEFTDSJQUJPO iThFBCTPMVUFGVUVSFPGJTUIFSFHJPOJOTJEFUIFGVUVSFMJHIUDPOF PG1*UJTUIFTFUPGBMMFWFOUTUIBUDBOQPTTJCMZCFBﬀFDUFECZXIBUIBQQFOTBU1w

Time

O

235

N 'VUVSFBDUVBMGVUVSFTUBUFTBOEUSBKFDUPSZPGTZTUFN The DPOTUSBJOUIFSFJTUIFBNPVOUPGLOPXMFEHFPGQBTU QSFTFOU BOEGVUVSFXIBU EPXFLOPXBCPVUUIFBDUVBMQBTUTUBUFTBOEUSBKFDUPSZUIBUMFEUPUIFQSFTFOUTUBUFBOE BCPVUUIFQSFTFOUTUBUFBOEBCPVUUIFBDUVBMTUBUFTBOEUSBKFDUPSZUIBUMFBEGSPNUIF QSFTFOUTUBUFUPUIFGVUVSF This JTUIFWJFXJOXIJDIXFdeﬁne BOEBOBMZ[FTZTUFNTJOUFSNTPGBDUVBMQBTU TUBUFT BOE QSFEJDUFE GVUVSF TUBUFT *U XPVME CF SFBTPOBCMF UP TVQQPTF UIBU XF IBWF LOPXMFEHFPGUIFQBTUBOEDFSUBJOMZPGUIFDVSSFOUTUBUFPGBTZTUFN CVUJOHFOFSBMXF POMZIBWFQBSUJBMLOPXMFEHFPGCPUIUIFQBTUUSBKFDUPSZBOEUIFDVSSFOUTUBUF BTXFMMBT UIFGVUVSF FTQFDJBMMZPGMBSHFPSDPNQMFYTZTUFNT"GFXFYBNQMFT N 1BTU )JTUPSJBOTBOBMZ[FJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUUIFQBTU GPSMBSHFTZTUFNTTVDIBT TPDJFUJFT UP EFUFSNJOF UIF QBTU TUBUFT BOE UIF USBKFDUPSZ UIBU MFE UP UIF DVSSFOU TUBUF %FUFDUJWFTBOEKVSZUSJBMTBOBMZ[FQBTUTUBUFTUPEFUFSNJOFJGBEFGFOEBOU BDUVBMMZDPNNJUUFEBDSJNF*GUIFEFGFOEBOUDBOQSPWJEFDPOWJODJOHFWJEFODFUIBU IFXBTJOUIFFMTFXIFSFPGUIFDSJNFFWFOUGPSFYBNQMF IFXBTJOBQIZTJDBM MPDBUJPOdiﬀer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

Other Relations "MM UIF EJNFOTJPOT IBWF TPNF WBSJBUJPO PG TUBUJD WJFXT BOE EZOBNJD WJFXT *O UIF DPNQPTJUJPO EJNFOTJPO BTUBUJDWJFXJTUIBUBDPOUBJOFEQBSUDBOPOMZCFJOPOFXIPMFBEZOBNJDWJFXJTUIBUB DPOUBJOFEQBSUDBOCFJONVMUJQMFXIPMFTDPOTFDVUJWFMZ BUdiﬀer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speciﬁcation $IBQUFS

FTQFDJBMMZWeriﬁcaUJPO BOEJOBVUPNBUJPO"WJFXUIBUJTJNQPSUBOUUP4&BOE.04&4JTUIBUUFNQPSBMMPHJDJTB

236 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

TVCTFUPGNPEBMMPHJD5FNQPSBMMPHJDTBOEUIFJSVTFTJODMVEFMJOFBSUFNQPSBMMPHJDGPSTQFDJGZJOH BOE WFSJGZJOH TFSJBM QSPDFTTFT BOE DPNQVUBUJPOBM USFF MPHJD GPS TQFDJGZJOH BOE WFSJGZJOH QBSBMMFM QSPDFTTFT

References "YFMSPE 3BOE.$PIFO)BSOFTTJOH$PNQMFYJUZ0SHBOJ[BUJPOBM*NQMJDBUJPOTPGBScientiﬁc 'SPOUJFS /FX:PSL#BTJD#PPLT #BL 1 $5BOH BOE,8JFTFOGFME4FMGPSHBOJ[FEDSJUJDBMJUZBOFYQMBOBUJPOPGGOPJTF1IZT3FW -FUU o #BMEXJO $BOE,$MBSL%FTJHO3VMFT7PMVNFThe 1PXFSPG.PEVMBSJUZ$BNCSJEHF .".*5 1SFTT #FODPNP / (#MBJS BOE3'SBODF4VNNBSZPGUIF8PSLTIPQ.PEFMT!SVOUJNFBU.P%&-4 IUUQXXXDPNQMBODTBDVL_CFODPNP."35NPEFMTBUSVOUJNF4VNNBSZQEG "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

#FODPNP / 3'SBODF BOE(#MBJSOE*OUFSOBUJPOBM8PSLTIPQPO.PEFMT!SVOUJNF JO-FDUVSF /PUFTJO$PNQVUFS4DJFODF 4BUFMMJUF&WFOUTBUUIF.0%&-4$POGFSFODF 4QSJOHFS7FSMBHIUUQ XXXDPNQMBODTBDVL_CFODPNP.35NPEFMTBUSVOUJNF'JOBMQEG "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

$IVSDI ;&OUFSQSJTF0O*UT8BZCVU)BSEMZTherFIUUQTFBSDIDJPNJENBSLFUUFDIUBSHFUDPN OFXTBSUJDMF TJE@HDJ IUNM USBDL/-BEBTSD&.@ 64$@VJE "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

%ÚSOFS % The -PHJD PG 'BJMVSF 3FDPHOJ[JOH BOE "WPJEJOH &SSPS JO $PNQMFY 4JUVBUJPOT (FSNBOZ 3PXPIMU7FSMBH &OHMJTIUSBOTMBUJPO/FX:PSL.FUSPQPMJUBO#PPLT

%VDPVMPNCJFS "BOE.4FCBH$POUJOVPVTNJNFUJDFWPMVUJPO1SPD&VS$POG.BDIJOF-FBSOJOH &$.-

o 'VUVZNB %&WPMVUJPO4VOEFSMBOE ."4JOBVFS"TTPDJBUFT (BMUPO "5FNQPSBM-PHJD4UBOGPSE&ODZDMPQFEJBPG1IJMPTPQIZIUUQQMBUPTUBOGPSEFEVFOUSJFTMPHJD UFNQPSBM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

(JSBVMU $ BOE 3 7BML 1FUSJ /FUT GPS 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH " (VJEF UP .PEFMJOH 7eriﬁcation, BOE "QQMJDBUJPOT#FSMJO4QSJOHFS7FSMBH (VOEFSTPO - BOE $ )PMMJOH 1BOBSDIZ 6OEFSTUBOEJOH 5SBOTGPSNBUJPOT JO )VNBO BOE /BUVSBM 4ZTUFNT8BTIJOHUPO %$*TMBOE1SFTT )BXLJOH 4"#SJFG)JTUPSZPG5JNF'SPNUIF#JH#BOHUP#MBDL)PMFT/FX:PSL#BOUBN#PPLT )PMMBOE +)JEEFO0SEFS)PX"EBQUBUJPO#VJMET$PNQMFYJUZ#PTUPO .""EEJTPO8FTMFZ *TBBDTPO 8&JOTUFJO)JT-JGFBOE6OJWFSTF/FX:PSL4JNPOBOE4DIVTUFS1BQFSCBDLT Kauﬀman, 4The 0SJHJOTPG0SEFS4FMG0SHBOJ[BUJPOBOE4FMFDUJPOJO&WPMVUJPO/FX:PSL0YGPSE 6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT .BUVSBOB )The PSHBOJ[BUJPOPGUIFMJWJOHBUIFPSZPGUIFMJWJOHPSHBOJ[BUJPO *OU+.BO.BDIJOF 4UVEJFT o .BUVSBOB ) BOE '+ 7BSFMB TU FEJUJPO "VUPQPJFTJT BOE $PHOJUJPO The 3FBMJ[BUJPO PG UIF -JWJOH*O3PCFSU4$PIFOBOE.BSY88BSUPGTLZ &ET

#PTUPO4UVEJFTJOUIF1IJMPTPQIZPG4DJFODF %PSESFDIU%3FJEFM1VCMJTIJOH$P .BZS & The (SPXUI PG #JPMPHJDBM Thought: %JWFSTJUZ &WPMVUJPO BOE *OIFSJUBODF $BNCSJEHF ." )BSWBSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT .FZFS #0CKFDU0SJFOUFE4PGUXBSF$POTUSVDUJPO&OHMFwood Cliﬀs, NJ: PSFOUJDF)BMM /BOO #4UBUJDWT%ZOBNJD.PEFM*NQBDUPO1SFEJDUJWF1FSGPSNBODFJO&BSMZ4UBHF$PMMFDUJPOT'BJS *TBBD8IJUF1BQFS /PWJLPW *The RivFSPG5JNF$BNCSJEHF 6,$BNCSJEHF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT 0#0#JPMPHJDBM1SPDFTT0OUPMPHZ(VJEFMJOFT0QFO#JPNFEJDBM0OUPMPHJFTIUUQXXXHFOFPOUPM PHZPSH(0QSPDFTTHVJEFMJOFTTIUNM BMM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

Time

O

237

0.( 0CKFDU .BOBHFNFOU (SPVQ B 6niﬁed .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF 0.( 6.-

4VQFSTUSVDUVSF 7 0.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU 63- IUUQXXX PNHPSHTQFD6.-4VQFSTUSVDUVSF1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU .BOBHFNFOU (SPVQ C 6niﬁed .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF 0.( 6.-

*OGSBTUSVDUVSF 7 0.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU 63- IUUQXXX PNHPSHTQFD6.-*OGSBTUSVDUVSF1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU.BOBHFNFOU(SPVQ D4ZTUFNT.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 0.(4ZT.-

70.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU 63- IUUQXXXPNHPSHTQFD 4ZT.-1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

1BSOBT %0OUIFDSJUFSJBUPCFVTFEJOEFDPNQPTJOHTZTUFNTJOUPNPEVMFT$PNNVO"$. o 1MBODL . The 1IJMPTPQIZ PG 1IZTJDT RVPUFE JO IUUQXXXDBMSFTDPPSHMVDBTDBTIUN "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

1PMBOJ %.FBTVSJOHTFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPOWJBPCTFSWFST JO8#BO[IBGFUBM &ET

"EWBODFTJO"Stiﬁcial -JGF UI&VSPQFBO$POGFSFODF &$"-

Qo 4UPOF "%&JOTUFJOTVOLOPXOJOTJHIUBOEUIFQSPCMFNPGRVBOUJ[JOHDIBPUJDNPUJPO1IZTJDT5PEBZ oIUUQXXXFOHZBMFFEVTUPOFHSPVQQVCMJDBUJPOTQIZT@UPEBZQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

5BOH $BOE3&QTUFJO"4USVDUVSBM4QMJUJOUIF)VNBO(FOPNF1-P40/& FEPJ KPVSOBMQPOFIUUQXXXQMPTPOFPSHBSUJDMFGFUDI"SUJDMFBDUJPO BSUJDMF63*JOGP"EPJ ''KPVSOBMQPOF "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

7FTQJHOBOJ "BOE4;BQQFSJ)PXTFMGPSHBOJ[FEDSJUJDBMJUZXPSLTBuniﬁed mean-ﬁeld QJDUVSF1IZT 3FW& o 8JLJQFEJB -PSFO[ "UUSBDUPS IUUQFOXJLJQFEJBPSHXJLJ-PSFO[@BUUSBDUPS "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

Chapter 10

Views <1SPHSFTT>IBTCFFONBEFSFDFOUMZJOﬁOEJOHiEVBMJUJFTwPSDPSSFTQPOEFODFTCFUXFFO BQQBSFOUMZEJﬀFSFOUUIFPSJFTPGQIZTJDT ThFTFDPSSFTQPOEFODFTBSFBTUSPOHJOEJDBUJPO UIBUUIFSFJTBDPNQMFUFVOJﬁFEUIFPSZPGQIZTJDT CVUUIFZBMTPTVHHFTUUIBUJUNBZOPU CFQPTTJCMFUPFYQSFTTUIJTUIFPSZJOBTJOHMFGVOEBNFOUBMGPSNVMBUJPO*OTUFBE XFNBZ IBWFUPVTFEJﬀFSFOUSFﬂFDUJPOTPGUIFVOEFSMZJOHUIFPSZJOEJﬀFSFOUTJUVBUJPOTzThJT XPVMECFBSFWPMVUJPOJOPVSWJFXPGUIFVOJﬁDBUJPOPGUIFMBXTPGTDJFODFz 4UFQIFO)BXLJOH 'PSFXPSE, ThF*MMVTUSBUFE"#SJFG)JTUPSZPG5JNF Systems taxonomy 1

Modeling scope

SE Application Domains (D1...Dn)

Collective actualization space

D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn

Problem space

3a

TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b Traditional Complex

Characteristics of all systems

Highest level system

Deﬁne need

Complex 4 Traditional TS is special case 5 Characteristics of all SE systems Traditional and Complex 6

Model Space

All SE application domains...

Indivisible Unit Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Composition

TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b 2a Traditional systems Complex systems

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

ThFDPODFQUPGWJFXJTBHFOFSBMBOEJNQPSUBOU UPPM JO FOHJOFFSJOH JO HFOFSBM BOE .04&4 JOQBSUJDVMBS"WJFXBMMPXTVTUPGPDVTPOBO BSFB PG DPODFSO BOE JHOPSF FWFSZUIJOH FMTF ThJT DIBQUFS HJWFT B EFﬁOJUJPO FYBNQMFT BOEUZQFTPGWJFXT BOEEFTDSJCFTTPNFBSFBT PGGVSUIFSSFTFBSDI

Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

e

m

Ti

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

Produce solution

Deployment

Satisfy need

Solution/system space

Introduction: Intuitive Concepts *OTPNFJNQPSUBOUSFTQFDUT UIFJEFBPGBWJFXBTDPNNPOMZVOEFSTUPPEJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIJUTVTF JO.04&4"WJFX BDDPSEJOHUPUIFEJDUJPOBSZ JTUIFFYUFOUPSSBOHFPGWJTJPO BNBOOFSPGMPPL JOHBUPSSFHBSEJOHTPNFUIJOH*OGPSNBMMZ BWJFXJTEFﬁOFEJO.04&4BTBTVCTFUPGJOGPSNBUJPO PCTFSWFEPGPOFPSNPSFFOUJUJFTThFFOUJUJFTBSFDPMMFDUJWFMZDBMMFEUIFUBSHFUPSPCKFDUPGUIFWJFX ThFQIZTJDBMPSDPODFQUVBMQPJOUGSPNXIJDIBWJFXJTPCTFSWFEJTUIFWJFXQPJOU XIJDIDBOCF NPUJWBUFECZPOFPSNPSFPCTFSWFSDPODFSOT%JﬀFSFOUWJFXTPGUIFTBNFUBSHFUDBOCFPCTFSWFE GSPNEJﬀFSFOUWJFXQPJOUT ThFTFOPUJPOTBSFEFﬁOFENPSFGPSNBMMZMBUFSJOUIFDIBQUFS 239

240 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThFDPODFQUTPGWJFXBOENPEFMIBWFNVDIJODPNNPO4P JGWJFXJTDPNNPOMZVOEFSTUPPE BOETJNJMBSUPNPEFM XIZEPXFOFFEBDIBQUFSPOWJFXTJOUIJTCPPL ThFBOTXFSJTUIBUXF CFMJFWFUIFQPUFOUJBMCFOFﬁUPGUIFDPODFQUPGWJFXJO4&HPFTXFMMCFZPOEXIBUIBTCFFOFYQMPJUFE UPEBUF BOEXFXBOUUPFODPVSBHFNPSFGPDVTPOUIJTJNQPSUBOUDPODFQU 8FCFMJFWFWJFXJTBCBTJD VOJWFSTBMDPODFQUUIBUJTTJNQMF QPXFSGVM BOEﬂFYJCMF5PTPNF EFHSFFJUJTBTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHTDJFODFBOBMPHPGUIFDPODFQUPGTFUJONBUIFNBUJDT BTBHFOFSBM GPVOEBUJPOBMUPPMThFUSBEJUJPOBMBSDIJUFDUVSFQSPGFTTJPOIBTMPOHCFFOVTJOHWJFXTJOEFTJHOJOH CVJMEJOHT TFQBSBUJOHBTQFDUTTVDIBTﬂPPSQMBOT FMFDUSJDBMTZTUFNT QMVNCJOHTZTUFNT IFBUJOH DPPMJOHTZTUFNT BOEUIFMJLF*OUIFQBTUGFXEFDBEFT UIFJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTDPNNVOJUZIBT FNCSBDFEUIFDPODFQUPGWJFXT GPSFYBNQMFJO$"%$".UPPMT TPGUXBSFBSDIJUFDUVSF FOUFS QSJTFBSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLT BOETPGUXBSFBTQFDUT.04&4DPOTJEFSTUIFDPODFQUPGWJFXTUPCF BQQMJDBCMFUPUIFGVMMTDPQFPG4& JODMVEJOHUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT OBUVSBMBOEBSUJﬁDJBM TZTUFNT BOETVQQPSUJOHTDJFODFTBOENBUIFNBUJDT ThFEFﬁOJUJPOJOEJDBUFTUIBUBWJFXEPFTOPUFYJTUJOJTPMBUJPO*UFYJTUTXJUISFTQFDUUPXIBU JTQPUFOUJBMMZWJFXFE JUTUBSHFUPSPCKFDU BOEJUJTFOWJTJPOFEBTPOFPGQPUFOUJBMMZNVMUJQMFWJFXT PGUIFTBNFUBSHFUThFUBSHFUDBOCFNPSFPSMFTTBOZPOUPMPHJDBMPSDPODFQUVBMFMFNFOUJO4& JODMVEJOHBOPUIFSWJFX BSFHJPO BTQFDJﬁDBUJPO PSBDPMMFDUJPOPGUIJOHT CVUNPTUPGUFOJOPVS EJTDVTTJPOTUIFUBSHFUXJMMCFBNPEFMPSBTZTUFN BOBMPHPVTUPUIFOPUJPOUIBUBNPEFMIBTBUBSHFU TZTUFN"WJFXJTBOBCTUSBDUJPOPGJUTUBSHFU"WJFXDBOCFFJUIFSBNPEFMPSBTQFDJﬁDBUJPO BOE IFODFDBOCFFJUIFSFYQMJDJUPS QBSUJBMMZ JNQMJDJU 0OFJNQPSUBOUNPUJWBUJPOGPSWJFXTJTUIBU JOHFOFSBM XFDBOOPUTFFPSVOEFSTUBOEFWFSZ UIJOHPGJOUFSFTUBCPVUBTZTUFNJOPOFWJTVBMJ[BUJPOPSSFQSFTFOUBUJPOThJTJTUIFTFOTFJOXIJDI )BXLJOH EJTDVTTFEUIFDPOTUSBJOUTPOIPXBVOJﬁFEUIFPSZPGQIZTJDTNBZFWFOUVBMMZCF FYQSFTTFE TFFRVPUFBUUIFTUBSUPGUIJTDIBQUFS "OPUIFSNPUJWBUJPO XIJDIJTTFSFOEJQJUPVTXJUI UIFﬁSTU JTUIBUNPTUTUBLFIPMEFSTBSFOPUJOUFSFTUFEJOFWFSZUIJOHBCPVUBTZTUFN CVUSBUIFSUIF UIJOHTPSGFBUVSFTSFMBUFEUPUIFJSDPODFSOThFﬁSTUNPUJWBUJPOJOUSPEVDFTUIFOFFEUPTFQBSBUFUIF JOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUBTZTUFNJOUPWJFXTUIFTFDPOENPUJWBUJPOTVHHFTUTIPXUPTFQBSBUF UIBUJT UIFDSJUFSJBGPSFBDIWJFX 8FTIPVMETUSFTTUIBUTFQBSBUJOHJOGPSNBUJPOJOUPWJFXTDBSSJFTOPDPOTUSBJOUUPQBSUJUJPOUIF JOGPSNBUJPOJOUPNVUVBMMZFYDMVTJWFTFUT%JﬀFSFOUWJFXTPGUIFTBNFUBSHFUUZQJDBMMZPWFSMBQUIF TBNFQJFDFPGJOGPSNBUJPONBZBQQFBSJONVMUJQMFWJFXT*OGBDU UIFSFBSFWFSZGFXDPOTUSBJOUTPO XIBUWJFXTDBOCFEFﬁOFEPSUIFDPOUFOUTPGBOZHJWFOWJFXThFPOMZUIFPSFUJDBMDPOTUSBJOUJTUIBU UIFWJFXCFBOBCTUSBDUJPOPGUIFUBSHFUThFPOMZQSBDUJDBMDPOTUSBJOUJTUIBUUIFWJFXJODMVEFTUIF JOGPSNBUJPOSFMBUFEUPUIFDPODFSOUIBUNPUJWBUFEJUTEFﬁOJUJPO 5XPJNQPSUBOUSFRVJSFNFOUTGPSBWJFXBSFTFQBSBUJPOBOEJOUFHSBUJPOThFTFTPVOETPNFXIBU DPOUSBEJDUPSZ CVUCPUINVTUCFUSVF*UJTTFMGFWJEFOUUIBUBWJFXNVTUCFTFQBSBCMFGSPNUIFSFTU PGUIFJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUJUTUBSHFUThBUJT BGUFSBMM UIFQSJNBSZNPUJWBUJPOGPSEFﬁOJOHBWJFX )PXFWFS BWJFXNVTUBMTPCFJOUFHSBUFEXJUIUIFSFTUPGUIFJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUJUTUBSHFU7JFX JOUFHSBUJPOSFRVJSFTBCJUNPSFEJTDVTTJPO ThF DPODFQU PG WJFX JOUFHSBUJPO JT TMJHIUMZ EJﬀFSFOU GSPN XIBU XF UZQJDBMMZ UIJOL PG BT JOUFHSBUJPO PG B TZTUFN PS PG NVMUJQMF TZTUFNT ThBU JT JOUFHSBUJOH UIF WJFXT PG B TZTUFN JT EJﬀFSFOUGSPNJOUFHSBUJOHUIFQBSUTPGBTZTUFN0OFEJﬀFSFODFJTUIBUQBSUTBSFEJTUJODUBOE JOUFSBDUJOH XIJMF WJFXT BSF PWFSMBQQJOH BOE MBSHFMZ OPOJOUFSBDUJOH *O B NJOJNBM TFOTF B HJWFOQJFDFPGJOGPSNBUJPONVTUCFDPOTJTUFOUJOBMMWJFXTUIBUJODMVEFJU /PUOFDFTTBSJMZUIF TBNF CVUDPOTJTUFOU4PNFUJNFTBHJWFOQJFDFPGJOGPSNBUJPOBQQFBSTJOBEJﬀFSFOUGPSNJO EJﬀFSFOUWJFXT

Views O

241

*OBCSPBEFSTFOTF UIFJOGPSNBUJPOJODMVEFEJOBMMWJFXTNVTUGPSNBDPOTJTUFOUJOUFHSBUFE DPIFSFOUXIPMFCFDBVTFUIFUPUBMTFUPGJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUUIFUBSHFUTZTUFNNVTUCFDPOTJTUFOU BOEDPIFSFOUThFSFGPSF JOBTFOTF UIFJOUFHSBUJPOPGWJFXTJTNPSFBCPVUUIFJOUFHSBUJPOPGUIF UBSHFUJOGPSNBUJPOJODMVEFEJOUIPTFWJFXTUIBOJUJTBCPVUUIFEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOBNPOHUIFWJFXT 7JFXJOUFHSBUJPOJTOPUBOJTTVFXIFOUIFTZTUFNJOGPSNBUJPOJTEFﬁOFEﬁSTU BOEUIFOWJFXTBSF EFﬁOFECBTFEPOUIBUJOGPSNBUJPOWJFXJOUFHSBUJPOJOUIBUDBTFJTBVUPNBUJD"DMBTTJDFYBNQMFPG UIBUDBTFJTBWJFXEFﬁOFEJOBEBUBCBTFNBOBHFNFOUTZTUFN JOUIFEPNBJOPGJOGPSNBUJPOTZT UFNTFOHJOFFSJOH#VUPGUFOBTZTUFNJTEFﬁOFECZBTFUPGWJFXT UIBUJT UIFWJFXTBSFUIFWFIJDMF GPSEFﬁOJOHUIFTZTUFNThBUDBTFJTXIFSFWJFXJOUFHSBUJPOJTBOJTTVF BOEDBSFNVTUCFUBLFOUP FOTVSFUIFJOUFHSBUJPOBOEDPIFSFODFPGUIFGVMMTFUPGJOGPSNBUJPO "GUFSEJTDVTTJOHGFBUVSFTPGWJFXT XFSFUVSOUPUIFDPNQBSJTPOPGWJFXBOENPEFM"WJFXJT MJLFBNPEFM JOUIBUCPUIBSFBCTUSBDUJPOT*OGBDU GPSNBMMZBWJFXJTBNPEFM'VSUIFS BNPEFM DBOIBWFNVMUJQMFWJFXT BOEBWJFXDBOIBWFNVMUJQMFNPEFMT#VUCZDPOWFOUJPOUIFSFBSFEJTUJOD UJPOTJOIPXXFVTFUIFN BTXFIBWFCFFOEJTDVTTJOH"WJFXJTQPUFOUJBMMZBNFNCFSPGBTFU BO BDLOPXMFEHNFOUUIBUJUSFQSFTFOUTPOMZQBSUPGUIFTUPSZ OPUUIFXIPMFTUPSZ BOEUIBUJUNVTUCF TJNVMUBOFPVTMZTFQBSBUFEGSPNUIFSFTUPGUIFTUPSZBOEJOUFHSBUFEXJUIUIFXIPMFTUPSZ"NPEFM IBTNPSFPGBTFOTFPGBTUBOEBMPOFFOUJUZ ThFSFNBJOEFSPGUIFDIBQUFSCVJMETPOUIFTFQSFMJNJOBSZDPODFQUTXJUIOVNFSPVTFYBNQMFT BMPOHXJUIGVSUIFSDPODFQUEFWFMPQNFOUBOEEFﬁOJUJPOThFTDPQFJODMVEFTBHFOFSBMDPOUFYUPG4& BMPOHXJUICPUIUSBEJUJPOBMBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT

Variety: Engineering and Beyond ThJTTFDUJPOQSPWJEFTFYBNQMFTPGWJFXT ﬁSTUJOBCSPBEFSDPOUFYUBOEUIFOXJUIJO4&ThFFYBN QMFTBSFVTFEUPEFWFMPQBOEJMMVTUSBUFDBUFHPSJFTPGWJFXTBOEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGWJFXT

Views in Broader Context ThJT TFDUJPO QSFTFOUT TPNF WJFXT UIBU HP CFZPOE USBEJUJPOBM FOHJOFFSJOH ThF SFBTPO UIFZ BSF JODMVEFEIFSFJTUXPGPME'JSTU UIFZJMMVTUSBUFUIFCSFBEUIBOEVTFGVMOFTTPGUIFDPODFQUPGWJFX 4FDPOE NBOZPGUIFTFFYBNQMFTJOTPNFXBZTVQQPSUUIFTDPQFPG.04&4 XIJDIHPFTCFZPOE USBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHUPJODMVEFUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNT TZTUFNTPGTZTUFNT PSHB OJ[BUJPOT BOEFOUFSQSJTFT BTXFMMBTBTQFDUTPGTDJFODF

A Universal Issue: Addressing the Hierarchy Problem )JFSBSDIZJTBOJNQPSUBOUBOEVTFGVMDMBTTJﬁDBUJPOTUSVDUVSFCVUFﬀPSUTUPEFﬁOFBIJFSBSDIZFODPVO UFSBDPNNPOQSPCMFNNVMUJQMFDPNQFUJOHIJFSBSDIJFTBSFQPTTJCMF8IBUJTUIFSJHIUPOF $PNNPOQSPQPTFETPMVUJPOTJODMVEF QJDLPOFIJFSBSDIZBOEVTFJUPS EPOPUVTFB IJFSBSDIJDBMTUSVDUVSF*ONBOZTJUVBUJPOT OFJUIFSPGUIFTFJTBTBUJTGBDUPSZTPMVUJPOThFQSPCMFN XJUI TPMVUJPO JT UIBU OP TJOHMF IJFSBSDIZ TBUJTﬁFT BMM TJUVBUJPOT ThF QSPCMFN XJUI TPMVUJPO JTUIBUIJFSBSDIZJTBOJNQPSUBOUNPEFMJOHTUSVDUVSFEFQSJWJOHPVSTFMWFTPGUIJTUPPMJTOPUB HPPEJEFB 4PXIBUEPXFQSPQPTFJOTUFBE ThFBOTXFSJTWJFXTThBUJT BMMPXBTFUPGIJFSBSDIJFTUPCF EFﬁOFE XIFSFFBDIPOFTFSWFTTPNFQVSQPTFPSBEESFTTFTTPNFDPODFSO5SFBUFBDIPOFBTBEJG GFSFOUWJFXThJTTPMVUJPOBEESFTTFTCPUIQSPCMFNTNFOUJPOFEBCPWF0OFPGUIFQSJNBSZFMFNFOUT

242 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

PGUIFWJFXTTPMVUJPOJTUIBUJUSFNPWFTDPOUFOUJPOBCPVUXIJDIJTSJHIU BOEBCPVUJTTVFTPGDPOUSPM ThFSFBSFUXPWBSJBOUTPGUIFWJFXTTPMVUJPOThFﬁSTUWBSJBOUJTXIFSFBMMWJFXTBSFUSFBUFEFRVBMMZ OPOFJTEPNJOBOUThFTFDPOEWBSJBOUJTXIFSFPOFWJFXJTEFTJHOBUFEBTUIFQSJNBSZTUSVDUVSFBOE UIFPUIFSWJFXTBSFDPOTJEFSFETFDPOEBSZPSTVQQMFNFOUBM 5XPFYBNQMFTBSF 1IJMPTPQIFSPOUPMPHJTUTEFCBUFXIBUPDDVQJFTUIFTFDPOETQPUPGUIFPOUPMPHZIJFSBSDIZPS UIFIJFSBSDIZPGCFJOHThFUPQJTiCFJOHwPSiFOUJUZwi4PNFTDIFNFTUBLFUIFEJWJTJPO CFUXFFOVOJWFSTBMTBOEQBSUJDVMBSTBTUIFOFYUTUFQJOUIFIJFSBSDIZ PUIFSTUIFEJWJTJPO CFUXFFOBCTUSBDUBOEDPODSFUFFOUJUJFTw )POEFSJDI ThFBSHVNFOUJTCBTFEPO UIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBUUIFSFJTPOFSJHIUBOTXFSBOEXFOFFEUPﬁOEPVUXIBUJUJT7JFXTIFMQ SFTPMWFUIJT*OTPNFDPOUFYUT UIFVOJWFSTBMTWFSTVTQBSUJDVMBSTEJTUJODUJPOJTBQQMJDBCMF XIJMFJOPUIFST BCTUSBDUWFSTVTDPODSFUFJTNPSFBQQMJDBCMFThFUXPDBOCFTFFOBTBMUFSOB UJWFWJFXT 0SHBOJ[BUJPOBMTUSVDUVSFT8FUZQJDBMMZUIJOLPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOTTVDIBTDPNQBOJFTPSHPW FSONFOU BHFODJFT BT SFRVJSJOH B EPNJOBOU WJFX VTVBMMZ DBMMFE UIF MJOF PSHBOJ[BUJPO 5SBEJUJPOBMMZUIJTIBTCFFOIJFSBSDIJDBM0UIFSWJFXT TVDIBTQSPKFDUNBOBHFNFOUTUSVD UVSFT UFNQPSBSZUFBNT PSJOGPSNBMJOUFSBDUJPOTUSVDUVSFT BSFEFﬁOFEJODPOUSBTUUPUIF EPNJOBOUMJOFPSHBOJ[BUJPO BOEBSFJOJNQPSUBOUSFTQFDUTTVCTFSWJFOUUPJU

Scientiﬁc Disciplines &BDITDJFODFPﬀFSTBEJﬀ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ﬀFSFOUWJFXPGUIFTBNFEFﬁOFEXPSME XIJDIJT NPSFPSMFTTQMBOFU&BSUIBTTFFOBOEVOEFSTUPPECZIVNBOCFJOHTPOUIFQMBOFUPWFSUIFQBTU GFXUIPVTBOEZFBSTThFXPSMEJTBOJOUFHSBUFEXIPMFXFIBWFTFQBSBUFEPVSVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGJU JOUPEJﬀFSFOUWJFXTPSEJTDJQMJOFTUPHFUNPSFUSBDUJPOJOFBDIWJFX"QSPNJOFOUNPUJWBUJPOGPS TZTUFNT TDJFODF XBT UIF JODSFBTJOH TQFDJBMJ[BUJPO BOE TFQBSBUJPO PG EJTDJQMJOFT BOE UIF MBDL PG JOUFHSBUJPOPGLOPXMFEHFJOUPBVOJﬁFEXIPMF

Are Science and Mathematics Rational and Logical? 0WFSUIFQBTUGFXEFDBEFTUIFSFIBWFCFFOEFCBUFTBCPVUUIFCBTJTPGNBUIFNBUJDBMQSPPGTBOETDJ FOUJﬁDUIFPSJFT JODMVEJOH,VIOT TDJFOUJﬁDSFWPMVUJPOT "SHVNFOUCPUIGPMMPXBSBUJPOBM QSPDFTTCBTFEPOMPHJD QSPPGT PSFNQJSJDBMFWJEFODF TDJFODF "SHVNFOUCPUIGPMMPXBTPDJBM QSPDFTTXIFSFUIFSFTVMUJTBDDFQUFEPSSFKFDUFECZQPQVMBSDPOTFOTVT OPUSBUJPOBMUIPVHIUFSSPST PDDVSBOEJGUIFFYBNJOBUJPOBOEEJTDVTTJPOJTBDUJWF UIFFSSPSTBSFEJTDPWFSFEBOEDPSSFDUFEPWFS UJNF

Views O

243

ThF.04&4QPTJUJPOJTUIBUUIFUXPBSHVNFOUTBSFOPUNVUVBMMZFYDMVTJWF CVUSBUIFSBSFEJﬀFS FOUWJFXT CPUIPGXIJDIBSFDPSSFDUBOEJODPNQMFUFThFZFNQIBTJ[FEJﬀFSFOUBTQFDUTPGUIFEJTDJ QMJOFT#PUITDJFODFBOENBUIFNBUJDTBSFBIVNBOQSPDFTT BOEUIFSFGPSFTVCKFDUUPQTZDIPMPHJDBM TPDJBM BOEQPMJUJDBMDPOTJEFSBUJPOT#PUIBSFBMTPUIFQSPEVDUPGSBUJPOBMBOEMPHJDBMUIPVHIUThF DPNQMFUFQJDUVSFJTBOJOUFSQMBZCFUXFFOUIFUXPWJFXT BOEQPTTJCMZBEEJUJPOBMWJFXT

Courtroom Trial "UMFBTUUISFFWJFXTBSFQSFTFOUFEJOBDPVSUSPPNUSJBMBOFWJEFODFWJFXBOEUXPEJﬀFSFOUWJFXT PGUIFFWJEFODFWJFXThFUFTUJNPOZBOEFYIJCJUTQSFTFOUFEJOBUSJBMDPOTUJUVUFBOBCTUSBDUJPO PGBOFWFOUBOFWJEFODFWJFXPGUIFFWFOUThFEFGFOTFPﬀFSTPOFWJFXPSJOUFSQSFUBUJPOPG UIFFWJEFODFWJFXJOOPDFOU ThFQSPTFDVUPSPﬀFSTUIFPQQPTJUFWJFXPGUIFTBNFFWJEFODFWJFX HVJMUZThFKVSZEFMJCFSBUFTBOEEFDJEFTXIFUIFSUPBHSFFXJUIUIFEFGFOTFWJFXPSUIFQSPTFDVUPS WJFX $MFBSMZ UIFUXPDPOﬂJDUJOHWJFXTBSFTFQBSBUFEThFQSPTFDVUPSWJFXJTHFOFSBUFECZTFMFDUJOH BOEFNQIBTJ[JOHUIFQBSUTPGUIFFWJEFODFUIBUNPTUTUSPOHMZTVHHFTUHVJMU BOEUIFOBEEJOHJOUFS QSFUBUJPOUPUIBUFWJEFODFUPSFJOGPSDFUIFHVJMUZWJFXThFEFGFOTFWJFXJTHFOFSBUFECZTFMFDUJOH BOEFNQIBTJ[JOHUIFXFBLFTUQBSUTPGUIFFWJEFODF BOEUIFOBEEJOHJOUFSQSFUBUJPOUPUIBUXFBL OFTTUPSFJOGPSDFUIFJOOPDFOUWJFX#VUBSFUIFUXPPQQPTJUFWJFXTJOUFHSBUFE :FT UIFJOUFHSBUJPO JTUIFFWJEFODFWJFXPOXIJDICPUIBSFCBTFE

Universal Distinction between Discrete and Continuous Phenomena 5PTUBSUXJUI UIFEJTUJODUJPOJTJUTFMGBWJFXPGUIFXPSME JOUIBUPGBMMUIFQSPQFSUJFTBOEDIBSBD UFSJTUJDTPGUIJOHTJOUIFXPSME JUTFMFDUTPOMZPOFUPMPPLBUXIBUUIJOHTBSFEJTDSFUF BOEXIBU UIJOHTBSFDPOUJOVPVT 8FCFMJFWFUIFQBSUPGUIFXPSMEXFBSFJOUFSFTUFEJOJTPOFPSUIFPUIFS BOETPNFUJNFTXFEFCBUFXIJDIJUJT"GUFSBMM BHJWFOUIJOHDBOPOMZCFEJTDSFUFPSDPOUJOVPVT OPUCPUI SJHIU *ONBOZDBTFT IPXFWFS JUJTVTFGVMUPJHOPSFUIFRVFTUJPOPGXIFUIFSUIFQBSUPGUIFXPSMEXF BSFFYBNJOJOHJTEJTDSFUF PSDPOUJOVPVT PSCPUI BOETJNQMZDPOTJEFSXIFUIFSJUJTVTFGVMUPWJFX UIJTQBSUPGUIFXPSMEBTEJTDSFUF PSUPWJFXJUBTDPOUJOVPVT PSUPBMMPXFJUIFSWJFX EFQFOEJOH POUIFDJSDVNTUBODFTPSPVSQVSQPTFThJTJTGVMMZDPOTJTUFOUXJUIBCBTJDUFOFUPGNPEFMJOHXF EJTDVTTFEJOFBSMJFSDIBQUFSTUIFDSJUFSJPOPGBHPPENPEFMJTOPUXIFUIFSJUSFﬂFDUTUIFXPSMEBTJU JT CVUXIFUIFSUIFNPEFMXPSLT UIBUJT JTVTFGVMGPSJUTQVSQPTFT *OQIZTJDT BDMBTTJDFYBNQMFPGJODMVEJOHCPUIEJTDSFUFBOEDPOUJOVPVTJTXBWFoQBSUJDMFEVBM JUZ*TUIFXPSMEDPOUJOVPVT XBWFT PSEJTDSFUF QBSUJDMFT *UBQQFBSTUPCFCPUI EFQFOEJOHPOUIF QVSQPTFPSWJFXQPJOU'SPN)BXLJOH iThFUIFPSZPGRVBOUVNNFDIBOJDTJTCBTFEPOBOFOUJSFMZOFXUZQFPGNBUIFNBUJDTUIBU OPMPOHFSEFTDSJCFTUIFSFBMXPSMEJOUFSNTPGQBSUJDMFTBOEXBWFTJUJTPOMZUIFPCTFSWB UJPOTPGUIFXPSMEUIBUNBZCFEFTDSJCFEJOUIPTFUFSNT ThFSFJTUIVTBEVBMJUZCFUXFFO XBWFTBOEQBSUJDMFTJORVBOUVNNFDIBOJDTGPSTPNFQVSQPTFTJUJTIFMQGVMUPUIJOLPG QBSUJDMFTBTXBWFTBOEGPSPUIFSQVSQPTFTJUJTCFUUFSUPUIJOLPGXBWFTBTQBSUJDMFTw *O PUIFS XPSET XBWFT BOE QBSUJDMFT BSF EJﬀFSFOU NPEFMT PS WJFXT BOE CPUI BSF JNQPSUBOU JO VOEFSTUBOEJOHUIFPWFSBMMQJDUVSFThJTFYBNQMFQSFWJFXTUIFEVBMJUZDPODFQUEJTDVTTFEGVSUIFSJO UIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi%VBMJUZ %FﬁOJUJPOT $BUFHPSJFTw

244 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Basic SE Related "OVNCFSPGWJFXTIBWFCFFOQSFWJPVTMZFODPVOUFSFEJOUIJTCPPL*OUIFNPEFMTQBDF FBDIPGUIF EJNFOTJPOTPGDPNQPTJUJPO DPNNPOJ[BUJPO DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO BOEUJNFDBOSFQSFTFOUBWJFX 'PSFYBNQMF XFDPVMEWJFXBTZTUFNBTBNVMUJMFWFMDPNQPTJUJPOTUSVDUVSFPGSFQFBUJOHXIPMFo QBSU SFMBUJPOT 8F DPVME EFﬁOF B WJFX PG UIF TZTUFN BU B TQFDJﬁD DPNQPTJUJPO MFWFM 8F DPVME EFﬁOFBWJFXPGBMUFSOBUJWFDPNQPTJUJPOTPGBHJWFOXIPMF PSBWJFXPGBMUFSOBUJWFFOWJSPONFOUT PGBHJWFOXIPMF 4UBUJD BOE EZOBNJD DBUFHPSJFT PG WJFXT PG B TZTUFN IBWF B MPOH USBEJUJPO JO FOHJOFFSJOH 4UBUJDWJFXTBSFBDIJFWFEFJUIFSCZIPMEJOHUJNFDPOTUBOUPSCZTFMFDUJOHFMFNFOUTUIBUEPOPU DIBOHFPWFSUIFUJNFQFSJPEJOXIJDIUIFWJFXJTEFﬁOFE%ZOBNJDWJFXTSFﬂFDUDIBOHFPWFS UJNF 'SPNBEJﬀFSFOUQFSTQFDUJWF UXPDBUFHPSJFTPGWJFXTBSFBTTPDJBUFE SFTQFDUJWFMZ XJUIJOUFSOBM BOEFYUFSOBMNPEFMT"OJOUFSOBMNPEFMSFQSFTFOUTBOJOUFSOBMWJFXPGBTZTUFN PSPGBDMBTTPG TZTUFNT 'VSUIFS BO JOUFSOBM NPEFM PS WJFX DBO CF SFQSFTFOUFE JO UIF GPSN PG NVMUJQMF WJFXT "SDIJUFDUVSFWJFXT EJTDVTTFEJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi7BSJFUZ"SDIJUFDUVSF3FMBUFE wBSFFYBNQMFT -JLFXJTF BOFYUFSOBMNPEFMSFQSFTFOUTBOFYUFSOBMWJFXPGBTZTUFNPSDMBTTPGTZTUFNT*GUIBUJT BMMXFDPOTJEFSFEJOUIFTFDBUFHPSJFT WJFXTXPVMEHJWFVTOPUIJOHJOBEEJUJPOUPNPEFMT#VUBO FYUFSOBMNPEFMDBOBMTPCFSFQSFTFOUFEJOUIFGPSNPGNVMUJQMFWJFXT'PSFYBNQMF QPTTJCMFWJFXT PGBOFYUFSOBMNPEFM PSQPTTJCMFFYUFSOBMWJFXTPGBTZTUFN JODMVEF O O O O O O O O

ThFTFUPGBMMTUVﬀ TVDIBTHPPET QFPQMF DVSSFODZ PSJOGPSNBUJPO UIBUHPFTJOUPUIFTZTUFN ThFTFUPGBMMTUVﬀ tIBUDPNFTPVUPGUIFTZTUFN ThFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOUIFTUVﬀ tIBUHPFTJOBOEUIFTUVﬀ tIBUDPNFTPVU &YUFSOBMMZPCTFSWBCMFQSPQFSUJFTBOEBUUSJCVUFTPGUIFTZTUFN &YUFSOBMMZPCTFSWBCMFCFIBWJPSPGUIFTZTUFN 4FSWJDFTUIFTZTUFNPﬀFSTJUTFOWJSPONFOU QSPWJEFETFSWJDFT

%FQFOEFODJFTPGUIFTZTUFNPOJUTFOWJSPONFOU SFRVJSFETFSWJDFT

$IBSBDUFSJTUJDT TUVﬀ QSPQFSUJFT QSPWJEFEBOESFRVJSFETFSWJDFT PGBTQFDJﬁDJOUFSBDUJPO QPJOUPGUIFTZTUFNCPVOEBSZ JF BQPSU

O "OZPGUIFBCPWFTFUTPGJOGPSNBUJPOSFQSFTFOUFEJOPOFMBOHVBHFPSSFQSFTFOUBUJPO WFSTVT BEJﬀFSFOUMBOHVBHFPSSFQSFTFOUBUJPO XIJDIDPVMEDPOTUJUVUFBEJﬀFSFOUWJFX

O "OZPGUIFBCPWFTFUTPGJOGPSNBUJPODPVMECFJOUFSQSFUFEEJﬀFSFOUMZJOEJﬀFSFOUFOWJSPO NFOUTJOXIJDIUIFTZTUFNNJHIUFYJTUFBDIJOUFSQSFUBUJPODPVMECFBEJﬀFSFOUFYUFSOBM WJFXPGUIFTZTUFN

0OUIFTVCKFDUPGFOWJSPONFOUTBOEJOUFSQSFUBUJPO BOPUIFSFYBNQMFPGWJFXTJTUIFEJﬀFSJOH JOUFSQSFUBUJPOTPGBOPOUPMPHZJOEJﬀFSFOUDPOUFYUT4FF0CSTUBOE/JDIPMT ThFMBOHVBHFBOEJOUFSQSFUBUJPOFYBNQMFTBSFJOUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPO7JFXTBMTPFYJTU JOUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPO'PSBHJWFOFOUJUZ4 BWJFXDBOCFEFﬁOFEPGQPTTJCMFHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOT PG4BOPUIFSWJFXDBOCFEFﬁOFEPGQPTTJCMFTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOTPG4 ThFCJPMPHJDBMUBYPOPNZFYBNQMFJO $IBQUFSTIPXFEGPVSSPMFTPG%PHBTBDBUFHPSZPG-BTTJF BTBOJOTUBODFPGTQFDJFT BTBHFOFSBMJ[BUJPO PG$PMMJF BOEBTBTQFDJBMJ[BUJPOPGNBNNBM&BDIPGUIFTFSPMFTJTBEJﬀFSFOUWJFXPG%PH 7JFXTBSFPGUFOEFﬁOFEBDSPTTNVMUJQMFEJNFOTJPOT"DPNNPOWJFXEFﬁOFTUIFQPTJUJPOPG BHJWFONPEFMJOUIFNPEFMTQBDF XIJDI DPOTJEFSJOHUJNFBTUIFGPVSUIEJNFOTJPOPGUIFNPEFM TQBDF DPVMECFSFHBSEFEBTBGPVSEJNFOTJPOBMWJFX

Views O Table 10.1

245

Potential Targets of Nested Views Potential Targets

View

S

V1

V2

V3

V4

C1

V1: A(S) V2: static(V1) V3: structure(V2) V4: components(V3) V5: ext C1(V4)

√ √ √ √ √

√ √ √ √

√ √ √

√ √

√

√

#FDBVTFUIFUBSHFUPGBWJFXDBOCFBWJFX WJFXTDBOCFOFTUFE/FTUFEWJFXTBSFUSBOTJUJWF JGUIFSFMBUJPOPOXIJDIUIFOFTUJOHJTCBTFEJTUSBOTJUJWFThBUJT GPSBUSBOTJUJWFSFMBUJPO JG7JT BWJFXPG7 BOE7JTBWJFXPG7 UIFO7JTBMTPBWJFXPG7*OTVDIDBTFT UIFUBSHFUPGB OFTUFEWJFXDBOCFBOZPGUIFWJFXTPSTZTUFNTJOUIFiUSBOTJUJWFDMPTVSFwPGUIFOFTUFEWJFX"O FYBNQMFXJMMJMMVTUSBUFUIJT4VQQPTFXFIBWFBTZTUFN4BOEBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMUIBUXFDBMMUIF BSDIJUFDUVSF"PG4 " 4 %FﬁOFUIFTFWJFXT O O O O O

7" 4

7TUBUJDBTQFDUTPG7 7MPHJDBMDPNQPOFOUDPOOFDUPSTUSVDUVSFPG7 7TFUPGDPNQPOFOUTJO7 7FYUFSOBMWJFXPGDPNQPOFOU$JO7

ThFOUIFTFUPGQPUFOUJBMUBSHFUTPGFBDIWJFXJTTIPXOJO5BCMF&BDIDIFDLNBSLGPSB WJFXNFBOTUIBUUIFWJFXDBOCFBWJFXPGUIFJUFNJOUIBUDPMVNOThVT 7DBOCFQPUFOUJBMMZCF BWJFXPGDPNQPOFOU$ PSBWJFXPGTZTUFN4 PSBWJFXPGBOZPGUIFWJFXTJOCFUXFFO4ZTUFN 4JTBQPUFOUJBMUBSHFUPGBMMﬁWFWJFXT4FMFDUJOHBUBSHFUGSPNNVMUJQMFQPUFOUJBMUBSHFUTJTUIFSF GPSFBNBUUFSPGDIPJDF VTVBMMZJOEJDBUFECZUIFQVSQPTFPGUIFWJFXThJTQPTTJCJMJUZPGNVMUJQMF QPUFOUJBMUBSHFUTJTPOFPGUIFSFBTPOT.04&4BEWPDBUFTDMFBSMZJEFOUJGZJOHUIFUBSHFUPGFWFSZ EFﬁOFEWJFX

Views of Humans ThFFYBNQMFPGUIFHFOFSBMVTFSNPEFMPOUPMPHZ (6.0 )FDLNBOOFUBM XBTJOUSPEVDFE JO$IBQUFS BOEJTOPXBQQSPQSJBUFJOUIJTi7JFXTwDIBQUFS ThF$IBQUFSWJFXXBTPG(6.0 BTBOPOUPMPHZThFWJFXPGUIJTDIBQUFSJTUIBU(6.0QSFTFOUTBEJﬀFSFOUQFSTQFDUJWFPOQFPQMF OPUKVTUFYUFSOBMVTFST CVUOPXBOJOUFHSBMQBSUPGBTZTUFN"TOPUFEJOQSFWJPVTDIBQUFST UIFNPTU DPNNPO54&WJFXPGBQFSTPOXBTBTBVTFSFYUFSOBMUPBTZTUFNThBUWJFXQSPWJEFEJOGPSNBUJPO POIPXBQFSTPOXPVMEVTFUIFTZTUFNCVUJODMVEFEMJUUMFPSOPQTZDIPMPHJDBMPSTPDJBMJOUFSBD UJPODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTThFSFMBUFEBSFOBTPGNBONBDIJOFJOUFSGBDF BOEIVNBODPNQVUFSJOUFSGBDF )$*

BOEFSHPOPNJDTIBWFDPOUJOVFEUPNPEFMIVNBOTBTFYUFSOBMUPUIFTZTUFN CVUIBWFGVSUIFS FYQMPSFEIVNBOOPSNTBOEWBSJBODFTJOQIZTJDBMDPNGPSU WJTVBMJ[BUJPO BOEQFSDFQUJPODBQBCJMJ UJFT UPNBLFNBDIJOFTNPSFIVNBOGSJFOEMZ TJNQMFS DMFBSFS BOETBGFS4PUIFTFBSFOBTIBWFUBLFO BOJNQPSUBOUTUFQUPXBSEFYQBOEJOHNPEFMTPGIVNBOTThFFYUFOTJPOPG4&UPJODMVEFDPNQMFY

246 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

TZTUFNT FOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOH BOETZTUFNTPGTZTUFNTCSJOHTIVNBOTJOTJEFUIFTZTUFNBOETJH OJﬁDBOUMZFYQBOETPVSWJFXPGIVNBOT8FOPXNPEFMBGVMMFSSBOHFPGIVNBOQTZDIPMPHJDBMBOE TPDJBMDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTCFDBVTFUIFZBSFGBDUPSTJOUIFCFIBWJPSPGIVNBOTWJFXFEBTDPNQMFYTZTUFNT JOUIFJSPXOSJHIUBOEBTDPNQPOFOUTPGMBSHFSFOUFSQSJTFTBOEQBSUJBMMZBVUPNBUFETZTUFNT "UﬁSTUHMBODF UIF(6.0FYBNQMFTFFNTUPCFBWFSZHFOFSBMQFSTPONPEFMUIBUHPFTCFZPOE UIFOFFETPGFOHJOFFSJOH)PXFWFS UIFGPSFHPJOHEJTDVTTJPOJOEJDBUFTIPX4&IBTCSPBEFOFEJUT TDPQFUPXIFSFUIF(6.0GFBUVSFTBSFOPXJOQMBZ&YQBOEFE4&$4&&OUFSQSJTF&OHJOFFSJOH UIBUJT UIFTDPQFPG.04&4 OPXUBLFTJOUPBDDPVOUIPXPSHBOJ[BUJPOT TPDJBMJOUFSBDUJPO QPMJ UJDT BOEQTZDIPMPHJDBMTUBUFTBﬀ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hFQVSQPTFPGEJTDVTTJOHUIJTFYBNQMFBUTPNFMFOHUIJT UPJMMVTUSBUFIPXWJFXTPGUIFTBNF UBSHFU IVNBOTJOUIJTDBTF DBODIBOHFPWFSUJNF FWFOJGUIFUBSHFUEPFTOPUDIBOHFBOE UP SFJOGPSDFUIFTVCTUBODFBOETDPQFPGIPX.04&4WJFXTBOENPEFMTIVNBOT0GDPVSTFUIJTJT OPUUIFPOMZXBZ.04&4WJFXTIVNBOT*OTPNFWJFXT BOBHFOUDBOSFQSFTFOUFJUIFSBIVNBO PSBNBDIJOFTVDIBTBTPGUXBSFQSPHSBNUIFEJTUJODUJPOJTEFMJCFSBUFMZBCTUSBDUFEBXBZGPSUIF QVSQPTFTPGTVDIBWJFX

Development versus Operation of a System $IBQUFSEJTDVTTFEUISFFMFWFMTPGQSPDFTTFTBOEDIBOHF BOE'JHVSFTIPXFEUIFMJGFTQBO PGFBDIMFWFM'SPNUIFTUBOEQPJOUPGWJFXT XFBSFJOUFSFTUFEJOMFWFM TZTUFNCFIBWJPS BOE MFWFM TZTUFNDIBOHF 54&BOE$4IBWFEJﬀFSFOUWJFXTPGUIFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOUIFTFUXP MFWFMT *O54& EFWFMPQNFOUBOEPQFSBUJPOBSFQBSUJUJPOFEBOEVTVBMMZUSFBUFEBTTFQBSBUFMJGFDZDMF QIBTFT'PSFYBNQMF UIFDMBTTJDBMiCJHCBOHwNPEFMJTGVMMEFWFMPQNFOUGPMMPXFECZGVMMGVODUJPO PQFSBUJPO*O'JHVSF UIJTSFQSFTFOUT-DIBOHFEVSJOH'PSNBUJPO GPMMPXFECZ-CFIBWJPS EVSJOH'VMMGVODUJPO UIVTTLJQQJOHPWFSUIF.BUVSBUJPOQIBTF"NPEFMDPNNPOMZVTFECZBU UIF 64 %FQBSUNFOU PG %FGFOTF %P% JODMVEFT JOJUJBM PQFSBUJPOBM DBQBCJMJUZ *0$ BOE GVMM PQFSBUJPOBMDBQBCJMJUZ '0$

XIJDIBEETBNBUVSBUJPOQIBTFEVSJOHXIJDIUIFTZTUFNPQFSBUFT CVUBMTPDIBOHFT*OCPUIDBTFT -DIBOHF NBJOUFOBODF TVTUBJONFOU DBOPDDVSJOBQIBTFXIFO UIFTZTUFNJTPQFSBUJPOBM CVUUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPGUIFDIBOHFJTTUJMMLFQUTFQBSBUF BOEUIFTZTUFN TUPQTPQFSBUJPO - XIJMFUIFDIBOHFJTCFJOHJOTUBMMFE - *O $4 DIBOHF EVSJOH GPSNBUJPO JT TUJMM TFQBSBUF GSPN PQFSBUJPO CFDBVTF PQFSBUJPO IBT OPU TUBSUFE )PXFWFS EVSJOH NBUVSBUJPO BOE GVMM GVODUJPO - BOE - CFIBWJPS BOE DIBOHF BSF PGUFO JOUFSUXJOFE BOE JO TPNF SFTQFDUT BSF JOEJTUJOHVJTIBCMF ThF TZTUFN GPS FYBNQMF B IVNBOMFBSOT HSPXT BOEBEBQUTXIJMFJUJTPQFSBUJPOBM#VUUIFSFJTTUJMMBVTFGVMEJTUJODUJPO CFUXFFO-CFIBWJPSBOE-DIBOHFGPSBMMUZQFTPGTZTUFNTNFDIBOJTUJD PSHBOJD BOEIZCSJE TZTUFNT*O.04&4 UIFEJTUJODUJPOJTCFTUNPEFMFEBTWJFXTThF-CFIBWJPSWJFXJTDPODFSOFE XJUIXIBUUIFTZTUFNEPFTBUBOZQPJOUJOUJNFThF-DIBOHFWJFXJTDPODFSOFEXJUIDIBOHFTJO

Views O

247

UIFTZTUFNIBWJOHUPEPXJUIHSPXUIPSSFQBJSThPTFDIBOHFTDBOCFEJTDSFUFPSDPOUJOVPVT BOE TFMGJOEVDFE TVDIBTHSPXUIPSMFBSOJOHPSFYUFSOBMMZJOEVDFE TVDIBTBOFOHJOFFSSFQMBDJOHB QBSUPOBNBDIJOF5ZQJDBMMZ TFMGJOEVDFEDIBOHFTBSFNPSFDPOUJOVPVT XIJMFFYUFSOBMMZJOEVDFE DIBOHFTBSFEJTDSFUFBOEQFSJPEJD. ThF-BOE-WJFXTDPFYJTU

Deﬁned Worlds "EFﬁOFEXPSMEJTBWJFX*UTUBSHFUDBOCFUIFTFUPGBMMQPTTJCMFXPSMET PSTPNFNPSFDPOTUSBJOFE TFU"GFXFYBNQMFTPGEFﬁOFEXPSMET TPNFPGXIJDIIBWFBQQFBSFEJOFBSMJFSDIBQUFST JODMVEF O 6OJWFSTFPGEJTDPVSTF 6% BEFﬁOFETFUPGDPODFQUTPSFMFNFOUTSFGFSSFEUPCZBMBOHVBHF PSTFUPGUFSNTDBOCFUIFCBTJTPGPOFPSNPSFPOUPMPHJFT O "TZTUFNPGJOUFSFTU 40* $IBQUFSEFﬁOFd ﬁWFWJFXTNPEFMTJOUIFDPOUFYUPGUIJTXPSME O /BNFTQBDFBOBNFTQBDFJTBEFﬁOFEXPSMEPGOBNFTPSJEFOUJﬁFSTThFSFRVJSFNFOUGPS VOJRVFOFTTIPMETXJUIJOUIFOBNFTQBDFThBUJT BOBNFEPFTOPUIBWFUPCFVOJRVFJOBMM QPTTJCMFXPSMET POMZXJUIJOJUTEFﬁOFEOBNFTQBDF O "OZ EFﬁOFE TQBDFUJNF SFHJPO TVDI BT B QFSJPE PG UJNF JO B HJWFO MPDBUJPO PS B HJWFO PSHBOJ[BUJPO

Views of Interacting Systems 4VQQPTFXFIBWFBTFUPGJOUFSBDUJOHTZTUFNTBTTIPXOJO'JHVSF.VMUJQMFWJFXTPGUIJTTJUVB UJPOBSFQPTTJCMF8FXBOUUPEJTDVTTBOEDPOUSBTUUXPUZQFTPGWJFXT O 7JFX*OQVUoQSPDFTToPVUQVUWJFXPGBHJWFOTZTUFN TVDIBT4JOUIFﬁHVSFThJTWJFX JTDPNNPOJOBQJQFMJOFPSTFSWJDFDIBJOTUZMFXIFSFUIFJOQVUTDPNFGSPNPOFPSNPSF QSPWJEFSTZTUFNTBOEUIFPVUQVUTHPUPPOFPSNPSFDPOTVNFSTZTUFNTUIBUEJﬀFSGSPN UIFQSPWJEFSTZTUFNT&YBNQMFTTVQQMZDIBJOTVDIBTBVUPNBOVGBDUVSFS DPOTVNFSHPPET SFUBJMFSTVDIBT8BM.BSU UIFCJPMPHJDBMGPPEDIBJO BEBUBQSPDFTTJOHQJQFMJOF FUD

Examples of input

r1

S1

p1

N1

Output view; e.g., pipeline model

r2

S2

p2

N2

r3

S3

Examples of interaction view; e.g., client-server model

Figure 10.1

Contrasting views of components in interaction.

p3

248 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O 7JFX*OUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOUXPPSNPSFTZTUFNTWJBBDPOOFDUPS TVDIBTCFUXFFO4 BOE4JO'JHVSF. ThJTWJFXJTDPNNPOJOBSFRVFTUSFQMZTUZMFPSQSPUPDPMXIFSFUIF TFSWJDFQSPWJEFSHFUTUIFJOQVUTJUOFFETGSPNUIFTBNFTZTUFNUPXIJDIJUQSPWJEFTJUTPVU QVU&YBNQMFTDMJFOUTFSWFSJOUFSBDUJPO UBYQSFQBSFSDVTUPNFSJOUFSBDUJPO BOETPGUXBSF NPEVMFUIBUDBMMTBOPUIFSNPEVMF$IBQUFSQSFTFOUFEBOVNCFSPGQBUUFSOTPSDBUFHPSJFT PGUIJTWJFX 7JFXGPDVTFTPOBTZTUFN BOEMPPLTBUPVUQVUTBTBGVODUJPOPGJOQVUT7JFXGPDVTFTPOBO JOUFSBDUJPO BOEMPPLTBUIPXBTZTUFNSFTQPOETUPBSFRVFTUGSPNBOPUIFSTZTUFN

SOI and Relative Holarchy 3FDBMMUXPDPODFQUTEJTDVTTFEJOQSFWJPVTDIBQUFST'JSTU XFTBJEUIBUBIPMBSDIZJTBSFQFBU JOHTUSVDUVSFPGXIPMFTBOEQBSUT4FDPOE XFEJTDVTTFEUIFJEFBPG40* BOEﬁWFNPEFMTPS WJFXTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIB40*/PXXFDPNCJOFUIFTFDPODFQUTJOUPUIFOPUJPOPGBCPVOEFE IPMBSDIZBTBWJFX CBTFEPOSFMBUJWFCPUUPNBOEUPQ'PSUIJTXFVTFUIFDPODFQUPGBUPNJD GSPNUIFGPVOEBUJPOTQBSUPGUIF3FGFSFODF.PEFMPG0QFO%JTUSJCVUFE1SPDFTTJOH 3.0%1 BOFOUJUZJTBUPNJDBUBHJWFOMFWFMPGBCTUSBDUJPOJGJUDBOOPUCFTVCEJWJEFEBUUIBUMFWFM PGBCTUSBDUJPO 4VQQPTFXFIBWFBTZTUFNPGJOUFSFTU4UIBUFYJTUTBTBIPMPOJOBIPMBSDIZ BOFODPNQBTTJOH TZTUFN&PGXIJDI4JTBQBSU BOE4IBTQBSUT4BOE4"MTPBTTVNFFODBQTVMBUJPOPGBMMIPMPOT JOUIFIJFSBSDIZ. ThFOGSPNUIFWJFXQPJOUPG4 UIFGPMMPXJOHWJFXTFYJTU O 'SPNUIFFYUFSOBMWJFXQPJOUPG4 4WJFXT&BTBDMPTFETZTUFN JOUIFTFOTFUIBU4POMZTFFT UIFJOTJEFPG&&JTUIFUPQPGUIFIPMBSDIZUIBU4DBOTFF O 'SPNUIFJOUFSOBMWJFXQPJOUPG4 4WJFXT4BOE4BTBUPNJDVOJUT JOUIFTFOTFUIBU4POMZ TFFTUIFPVUTJEFPG4BOE44BOE4BSFUIFCPUUPNPGUIFIPMBSDIZUIBU4DBOTFF *OUIJTXBZ UIFWJFXPGBIPMBSDIZGSPNBIPMPO40*JOUIFIJFSBSDIZJTBSFMBUJWFBOECPVOEFE IPMBSDIZUIBUFYUFOETPOMZPOFMFWFMVQBOEPOFMFWFMEPXOGSPNUIF40*

Example of Perspective: Alexander’s Architecture Patterns $ISJTUPQIFS "MFYBOEFS BOE EFﬁOFE B TFU PG BSDIJUFDUVSF QBUUFSOT JO UIF T GPS FWFSZUIJOHGSPNBSPPNJOBIPVTFUPBUPXOUPBSFHJPO BTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS"OFOUIVTJ BTUJDBVEJFODFPG"MFYBOEFSTBQQSPBDIUPQBUUFSOTIBTCFFOUIFTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHDPNNVOJUZ XIJDIIBTBQQMJFEIJTDPODFQUTJOUIFGPSNPGTPGUXBSFEFTJHOQBUUFSOTThFSFBSFTFWFSBMSFBTPO BCMFWJFXTPG"MFYBOEFSTQBUUFSOTXPSL JODMVEJOH O 7JFXNPEFMGPSTPGUXBSFEFTJHOThFQBUUFSOTBSFBNPEFMGPSTPGUXBSFEFTJHOQBUUFSOT FBDIPGXIJDIJTBQSPCMFNTPMWJOHBOEHFOFSJDEFTJHOUFNQMBUFGPSTPGUXBSFEFTJHOFSTUP VTFJOUBJMPSJOHBTQFDJﬁDEFTJHO O 7JFXFOHJOFFSJOHDPNQMFY TPDJBM TZTUFNT6TJOHLOPXMFEHFPGIVNBOBOETPDJBMQBU UFSOT BOE QSPDMJWJUJFT UP BSSBOHF BOE JOﬂVFODF IPNFT OFJHICPSIPPET BOE UPXOT UP FODPVSBHF OBUVSBM PSHBOJ[BUJPO JOUFSBDUJPO BEBQUBUJPO BOE EFWFMPQNFOU PG B IFBMUIZ MJWJOHiPSHBOJTN wTPNFUIJOHUIBUJTBMJWFThJTJTDMFBSMZJOUIFBSFOBPGDPNQMFYBEBQUJWF TFMGPSHBOJ[JOH TZTUFNT XIJDI JT BO BSFB PG JODSFBTJOH JOUFSFTU BOE SFTFBSDI JO UIF 4&

Views O

249

DPNNVOJUZ"NPSFTVCUMFBTQFDUPGUIJTWJFXJTUIBUUIFTFQBUUFSOTBSFBCTUSBDUJPOTUIBU DBQUVSF PSBUMFBTUBUUFNQUUPDBQUVSF TUBCJMJUZJOUIFGBDFPGDPOUJOVBMDIBOHFThFSVMFT PGUIFQBUUFSOTBSFTUBCMFUIFZGPTUFSUIFFWPMVUJPOBOEHSPXUIPGTZTUFNT UPXOT FUD UIBU TVQQPSUOBUVSBMIVNBOQSFGFSFODFTBOEJOUFSBDUJPOT O 7JFXVOJﬁDBUJPOPGFOHJOFFSJOH"MFYBOEFSTBQQSPBDIXPSLTGPSCPUI$4BOE547JFX JTNPSFPSMFTTBOBQQMJDBUJPOUP547JFX "MFYBOEFSTBQQMJDBUJPO XBTB$4&BQQSPBDI UPBSDIJUFDUVSFBOEQMBOOJOH*UBMTPSFQSFTFOUTNVMUJTDBMFPSNVMUJMFWFMFOHJOFFSJOHUIBU XFUIJOLXPSLTGPSCPUI54BOE$4ThFTBNFQBUUFSOUFNQMBUFBOEBQQSPBDIJTVTFEBU BMMTDBMFT SPPN IPVTF TUSFFU OFJHICPSIPPE UPXO SFHJPO

CVUUIFDPOUFOUTBSFEJﬀFSFOU BUFBDIMFWFMPSTDBMFThJTNVMUJTDBMFBTQFDUIBTOPUCFFOFYQMPJUFECZUIFTPGUXBSFDPN NVOJUZ 7JFX

Miscellaneous ThF TFU PG QPTTJCMF WJFXT JT WJSUVBMMZ VOMJNJUFE )FSF BSF B GFX PUIFS NJTDFMMBOFPVT QPUFOUJBM 4& WJFXT O "O JOUFOTJPOBM EFﬁOJUJPO PG B GVODUJPO SFQSFTFOUT B EJﬀFSFOU WJFX GSPN BO FYUFOTJPOBM EFﬁOJUJPOPGUIFTBNFGVODUJPO O %JﬀFSFOUTDBMFTDBOSFQSFTFOUEJﬀFSFOUWJFXT O *OUFSOBMDPNQPOFOUUZQFT TVDIBTMPHJDBMWFSTVTQIZTJDBM DBOSFQSFTFOUWJFXT O "TUSVDUVSFPGMBZFSTDBOCFBWJFXPGBOBSDIJUFDUVSFPSFBDIMBZFSDBOCFBWJFX O 4JNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTDBOCFWJFXTJOTPNFWJFXTXFXBOUUPGPDVTPOXIBUJTDPN NPOXIJMFJOPUIFSWJFXTPOXIBUJTEJﬀFSFOU

Variety: Architecture Related ThFFOHJOFFSJOHDPNNVOJUZIBTEFﬁOFEWBSJPVTTFUTPGWJFXTJOUIFDPOUFYUPGEFTJHOBOEBSDIJ UFDUVSFThFDPMMFDUJPOPGWJFXTUIBUIBWFCFFOEFﬁOFEBSFPGTPNFJNQPSUBODFUP4&CFDBVTFUIFZ JMMVTUSBUFBWBSJFUZUIBUDBOTFSWFBTBTUBSUFSTFUPGDPNNPOWJFXTGPSUIFGVUVSFPG4&ThFSFGPSF XFJODMVEFBGBJSOVNCFSPGFYBNQMFTJOUIFTVSWFZUIBUGPMMPXT"UUIFTBNFUJNFXFOPUFUIBUUIF TUBODFPGNPTUPGUIFFYBNQMFTJTUIBU UPWBSZJOHEFHSFFT UIFEFﬁOFSTBOEQSPQPOFOUTSFHBSEUIFJS TFUPGWJFXTBTiDPNQMFUFw.04&4IBTBNVDINPSFFYQBOTJWFDPODFQUPGWJFX XIJDIGPTUFSTB NPSFPQFOFOEFEBOEﬂFYJCMFBQQSPBDIUPWJFXTBOEBTJHOJﬁDBOUMZJODSFBTFESPMFGPSWJFXTJOUIF GVUVSFPG4&ThFSFGPSF PVSQPTJUJPOPOUIFFYBNQMFTUIBUGPMMPXJTUIBUUIFZQSPWJEFBOJNQPSUBOU TUBSUPOﬁMMJOHUIFTQBDFPGQPUFOUJBMWJFXT CVUUIF4&DPNNVOJUZIBTCBSFMZCFHVOUPFYQMPSFUIJT TQBDFBOEJUTIVHFQPUFOUJBM

Composition Views 54&UFOETUPGPDVTPOEJﬀFSFODFTCFUXFFODPNQPTJUJPOMFWFMTThJTJTSFﬂFDUFEJOEJﬀFSFOUTQFDJﬁD OBNFTGPSFBDIMFWFM&YBNQMFTBSF O *&&& *&&& EFﬁOFTUIFIJFSBSDIZPGTZTUFNoQSPEVDUoTVCTZTUFNo BTTFNCMZoDPNQPOFOUo TVCBTTFNCMZ oTVCDPNQPOFOUoQBSU

250 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O ,PTTJBLPﬀ BOE4XFFU o "DLOPXMFEHFTUIBUTZTUFNDBOBQQMZUPBOZMFWFM CVU UIFOEFﬁOFTBNPEFMPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNTXJUIUIFTFMFWFMT TZTUFNPGTZTUFNT oTZTUFNo TVCTZTUFNoDPNQPOFOUoTVCDPNQPOFOUoQBSU O */$04& )BOECPPL */$04& 4ZTUFN o &MFNFOU o 4VCTZTUFN o "TTFNCMZ o 4VCBTTFNCMZo$PNQPOFOUo1BSU .04&4 PO UIF PUIFS IBOE EFTDSJCFT JO $IBQUFS B SFQFBUJOH QBUUFSO PG \XIPMFoQBSU^ PS \TZTUFNoDPNQPOFOU^BTNBOZMFWFMTBTOFDFTTBSZThFFNQIBTJTJTPOXIBUJTDPNNPOBUBMMMFWFMT XIJMFBDLOPXMFEHJOHUIBUUIFSFBSFBMTPEJﬀFSFODFT*UTDBMFTVQPSEPXOUPBOZOVNCFSPGMFWFMT *O$IBQUFS HFOFSBMNFDIBOJTNTBSFEFﬁOFEGPSEFTDSJCJOHEJﬀFSFODFT /PXJOUIFDPOUFYUPGUIJTDIBQUFS UIFGVMM.04&4QPTJUJPOPOUIJTDPOUSBTUJTEFTDSJCFE 4&OFFETUPBMMPXBOETVQQPSUCPUITJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTBUEJﬀFSFOUDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFMT 8FOFFEUPFYQMPJUXIBUJTDPNNPOCZOPUEVQMJDBUJOHJUBUFWFSZMFWFM BOEXFOFFEUPBDDPVOU GPSXIBUJTEJﬀFSFOUCZDBQUVSJOHUIPTFEJﬀFSFODFTBUFBDIMFWFMThFNFDIBOJTN PGDPVSTF JT WJFX"MMDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIJFTBSFBDPNCJOBUJPOPGUXPWJFXT*OPOFWJFXSFTJEFBMMDIBS BDUFSJTUJDTUIBUBSFDPNNPOUPPSUIFTBNFBUBMMMFWFMTPGBHJWFODPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZ*OUIF PUIFSWJFXSFTJEFBMMUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDEJﬀFSFODFTCFUXFFOMFWFMT ThF WJFX XJUI UIF DPNNPO JOGPSNBUJPOJTBOBMPHPVTUPBIPMBSDIZPSBGSBDUBMThFUXPWJFXTDPVMEQFSIBQTCFDBMMFEUIF BVUPQPJFUJD WJFX PG DPNQPTJUJPO TJNJMBSJUJFT BOE UIF BMMPQPJFUJD WJFX PG DPNQPTJUJPO EJﬀFS FODFT "MUFSOBUJWFMZ UIFZDPVMECFDBMMFEUIFTJNJMBSJUJFTWJFXPGDPNQPTJUJPOBOEUIFEJﬀFSFODFT WJFXPGDPNQPTJUJPO ThFSFBTPOGPSJODMVEJOHUIJTTFDUJPOJTOPUUIBUJUJTEJﬃcVMUUPNPEFMUIFTJNJMBSJUJFToEJG GFSFODFTEJTUJODUJPOPSUPDBQUVSFUIFJOGPSNBUJPOThFSFBTPOJTUPFNQIBTJ[FUIFJNQPSUBODFPG DPOTJEFSJOH BOENBLJOHFYQMJDJU UIFFYJTUFODFPGCPUITJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTJODPNQPTJUJPO IJFSBSDIJFT*UMFOETDMBSJUZBOEFﬃcJFODZUPDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMJOH ThJT BQQSPBDI PG TJNJMBSJUZ BOE EJﬀFSFODF WJFXT BMTP JT VTFGVM JO BEESFTTJOH B TQFDJﬁD UPQJD UIBU IBT SFDFJWFE BUUFOUJPO PWFS UIF QBTU EFDBEF BOE UIBU XF IBWF NFOUJPOFE JO UIF CPPL OBNFMZ UIFDPODFQUPGTZTUFNPGTZTUFNT 4P4 4BHFBOE$VQQBO FNQIBTJ[FE UIFEJﬀFSFODFTCFUXFFO4P4BOETZTUFN TUBUJOHUIBUBO4P4FYJTUTXIFOUIFNBKPSJUZPGUIF GPMMPXJOHDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBSFQSFTFOUPQFSBUJPOBMBOENBOBHFSJBMJOEFQFOEFODF HFPHSBQIJD EJTUSJCVUJPO FNFSHFOU CFIBWJPS BOE FWPMVUJPOBSZ EFWFMPQNFOU 7BMFSEJ 3PTT BOE 3IPEFT OPUFUIBUUIFSFBSFUISFFTDIPPMTPGUIPVHIUPOUIFDPODFQUPG4P4ThFQSPEJﬀFSFODF TDIPPMDMBJNTGVOEBNFOUBMEJﬀFSFODFTCFUXFFOTZTUFNTBOE4P4UIFTFDPOETDIPPMCFMJFWFT BO 4P4 JT TJNQMZ B TZTUFN BOE UIFSF JT OP OFFE GPS UIF UFSN XF NJHIU DBMM UIJT UIF QSP TJNJMBSJUZ TDIPPM BOE UIF UIJSE TDIPPM JT BHOPTUJD OPU DPNNJUUJOH UP B QPTJUJPO VOUJM B DMFBSFSBOTXFSFNFSHFT ThF.04&4QPTJUJPOJTUIBUUIFMFWFMPG4P4 MJLFBMMMFWFMTPGDPNQPTJUJPO QPUFOUJBMMZFYIJCJUTCPUI TJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFT BOEUIFBQQSPBDIPGDBQUVSJOHCPUIJOWJFXTBTEFTDSJCFEBCPWFBEESFTTFT UIFJTTVFThFQSPEJﬀFSFODFBOEQSPTJNJMBSJUZTDIPPMTBSFCPUIQBSUJBMMZDPSSFDUCVUUIFXIPMFQJDUVSF OFFETCPUIBTQFDUTThFSFNBZXFMMCFNPSFEJﬀFSFODFTXIFOUIF4BHF$VQQBODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBSF QSFTFOUCVUUIFWJFXTBQQSPBDIUPUIJTJTTVFJs ﬂFYJCMFFOPVHIUPIBOEMFUIPTFEJﬀFSFODFT

Design Views "OFBSMZFYBNQMF PSJHJOBMMZQVCMJTIFEJO JTUIF*&&&3FDPNNFOEFE1SBDUJDFGPS4PGUXBSF %FTJHO %FTDSJQUJPOT *&&& TIPXO JO 5BCMF *O .04&4 UFSNT UIF ﬁSTU UISFF

Views O

251

Table 10.2 Recommended Design Views Design View

Scope

Entity Attributes

Decomposition

Partition of the system into design entities

Dependency

Description of the relationships Identiﬁcation, type, among entities and system purpose, resources dependencies, resources List of everything a designer, Identiﬁcation, programmer, or tester needs to function, interfaces know to use the design entities that make up the system Description of the internal Identiﬁcation, design details of an entity processing, data

Interface description

Detail description

Identiﬁcation, type, purpose, function, subordinates

Example Representations Hierarchical decomposition diagram, natural language Structure charts, data ﬂow diagrams, transaction diagrams Interface ﬁles, parameter tables

Flowcharts, N-S charts, PDL

Source: IEEE. IEEE Recommended Practice for Software Design Descriptions. IEEE 1016-1998. New York: IEEE Computer Society, 1998. Used with permission.

WJFXT EFDPNQPTJUJPO EFQFOEFODZ BOEJOUFSGBDF BSFEJﬀFSFOUWJFXTPGBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPG BTZTUFNJODMVEJOHFYUFSOBMNPEFMTPGFBDIDPNQPOFOUXIJMFUIFGPVSUI EFUBJM JTBO JOUFSOBMNPEFMPGFBDITZTUFNDPNQPOFOU

Enterprise Architecture Frameworks "SHVBCMZ UIF NPTU JNQPSUBOU DBUFHPSZ PG FYUBOU WJFXT GPS 4& JT UIBU PG FOUFSQSJTF BSDIJ UFDUVSF &" GSBNFXPSLT ThF QVSQPTF PG UIF TVSWFZ UIBU GPMMPXT JT UP GPDVT PO UIF WJFXT EFﬁOFECZPSJMMVTUSBUFEJOUIFTFGSBNFXPSLT OPUBDPNQSFIFOTJWFEFTDSJQUJPOPSBTTFTTNFOU PGUIFGSBNFXPSLTThFPOFTTVSWFZFEJODMVEF;BDINBO 3.0%1 UIF64%FQBSUNFOUPG %FGFOTF"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSL %P%"' 6,.JOJTUSZPG%FGFOTF"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSL .0%"' /"50 "SDIJUFDUVSF 'SBNFXPSL /"' GBNJMZ ThF 0QFO (SPVQ "SDIJUFDUVSF 'SBNFXPSL 50("'

UIF'FEFSBM &OUFSQSJTF "SDIJUFDUVSF '&"

BOE UIF 4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE .PEFMJOH'SBNFXPSL 40.'

Zachman EA Framework ThF ;BDINBO &OUFSQSJTF 'SBNFXPSL ;BDINBO 4PXB BOE ;BDINBO ;BDINBO *OUFSOBUJPOBM JTTVNNBSJ[FEJO'JHVSF*UJTBDPODFQUVBMIJHIMFWFMGSBNFXPSLDBQ UVSFE JO POF NBUSJY PG TJY SPXT BOE TJY DPMVNOT ThF SPXT BSF DBUFHPSJFT PG NPEFMT UIBU IBWF USBEJUJPOBMMZCFFOBTTPDJBUFEXJUIQIBTFTPGBTZTUFNJOBOFOUFSQSJTFXIJMFUIFDPMVNOTBSFDSPTT DVUUJOHDBUFHPSJFTPGNPEFMTUIBUDPSSFTQPOESFTQFDUJWFMZUP8IBU )PX 8IFSF 8IP 8IFO BOE8IZ&BDIDFMMJTBNPEFMPSTFUPGNPEFMTUIBUDPSSFTQPOETUPCPUIJUTSPXBOEDPMVNO'PS FYBNQMF SPXDPMVNODFMMJTBCVTJOFTTFOUJUZNPEFM

Figure 10.2 Zachman enterprise framework. (Source: Published by Zachman International, 2008. http://www.zachmaninternational.com/ index.php/the-zachman-framework.)

252 O Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Views O

253

Zachman Correspondence to MOSES Model Space ThF;BDINBOSPXTIBWFTPNFDPSSFTQPOEFODFXJUIDPNQPTJUJPOMFWFMT3PXTBMTPDPSSFTQPOEUP UIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOTQFDUSVN SBOHJOHGSPNUIFQSPCMFNEPNBJOJOUIFUPQUXPSPXTUPUIF JNQMFNFOUBUJPO EPNBJO JO UIF CPUUPN SPX *O .04&4 UFSNT UIF DPMVNOT BSF DSPTTDVUUJOH WJFXT'SPNUIF.04&4WJFXQPJOU UIF;BDINBOGSBNFXPSLJODMVEFTNVMUJQMFWJFXT O &BDISPXJTBWJFX'PSFYBNQMF UIFUPQUXPSPXTBSFWJFXTPGBOFOUFSQSJTFUIFCPUUPN UISFFSPXTBSFWJFXTPGBTZTUFNPSTZTUFNQBSU O &BDIDPMVNOJTBWJFX BTUIFGSBNFXPSLJEFOUJﬁFT O &BDIDFMMJTBWJFX JOPVSUFSNT OPU;BDINBOT *GXFMPPLNPSFDMPTFMZBUUIF;BDINBOGSBNFXPSL XFTFFUIFGPMMPXJOH O &BDI DFMM FTQFDJBMMZ JO SPXT UISPVHI SFQSFTFOUT POF PS NPSF JOUFSOBM NPEFMT *O DPNNPOQBSMBODF ;BDINBODFMMTSFQSFTFOUBSDIJUFDUVSFJOGPSNBUJPO OPUSFRVJSFNFOUT JOGPSNBUJPOThBUJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIJUTPSJHJOBMOBNF'SBNFXPSLGPS&"#VUFYUFSOBM NPEFMTBSFJNQMJDJUMZJOUFSUXJOFEUISPVHIPVUUIFTUSVDUVSF NPTUOPUBCMZJOUIFGBDUUIBU BMMJOUFSOBMNPEFMTJODMVEFUIFFYUFSOBMNPEFMTPGUIFJSQBSUT O 8FDPVMEBSHVFUIFSFJTBNJTTJOHSPXCFUXFFOSPX UIFCVTJOFTTNPEFMT BOESPX UIFTZTUFNNPEFMT3PXJTBOJOUFSOBMCVTJOFTTWJFXPGBHJWFOFOUFSQSJTF3PXJTBO JOUFSOBMWJFXPGBHJWFOTZTUFNJOUIFHJWFOFOUFSQSJTF8IBUJTNJTTJOHCFUXFFOUIFTFUXP JTBTZTUFNWJFXPGUIFFOUFSQSJTF JOXIJDIUIFFOUFSQSJTFDPNQPOFOUTBSFTZTUFNT BOE UIFJOUFSOBMNPEFMTIPXTBOFYUFSOBMWJFXPGUIFTZTUFNTXJUIJOUIFFOUFSQSJTFBOEIPX UIFZJOUFSBDU ThBUWJFXXPVMEDPOOFDUSPXXJUISPX BOEQSPWJEFBNPSFFYQMJDJUMJOL CFUXFFOUIFUXP ThFSF JT OP JOUFOEFE DPSSFTQPOEFODF PG ;BDINBO UP UIF .04&4 DPNNPOJ[BUJPO EJNFO TJPO;BDINBOQPSUSBZTNPEFMTXIPTFJOUFOEFEUBSHFUJTBHJWFOFOUFSQSJTFPSBHJWFOTZTUFN BT PQQPTFEUPSFGFSFODFBSDIJUFDUVSFTPSQBUUFSOTUBSHFUFEUPBXIPMFDMBTTPSDBUFHPSZPGTZTUFNT

RM-ODP Framework ThF 3.0%1 JT BO *40*&$ TUBOEBSE GPS PQFO EJTUSJCVUFE QSPDFTTJOH TZTUFNT *U EFﬁOFT B GSBNFXPSL DPOTJTUJOH PG GPVOEBUJPOT BSDIJUFDUVSF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT BOE BSDIJUFDUVSBM TFNBOUJDT 3.0%1 ThFBSDIJUFDUVSFQBSUEFﬁOFTBTFUPGWJFXQPJOUT XIJDIXFXPVMEDBMMWJFXTPS WJFXUZQFTFOUFSQSJTF JOGPSNBUJPO DPNQVUBUJPOBM FOHJOFFSJOH BOEUFDIOPMPHZ&BDIWJFXQPJOU IBTBMBOHVBHFUIBUEFﬁOFTDPODFQUTBOESVMFTGPSTQFDJGZJOH0%1TZTUFNTGSPNUIBUWJFXQPJOU ThFFOUFSQSJTFWJFXQPJOUBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBO0%1TZTUFNJTBTFUPGSVMFTBCPVUUIFTZTUFNBOE JUTJOUFSBDUJPOTXJUIJUTMBSHFSFOWJSPONFOUThFGPDVTJTPOUIFQVSQPTF TDPQF BOEQPMJDJFTGPS UIBUTZTUFN BOEUIFQPMJDJFTBOESPMFTPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPOT"SPMFJTEFﬁOFEVTJOHEFPOUJDMPHJD UIBUJT JOUFSNTPGQFSNJTTJPOT PCMJHBUJPOT QSPIJCJUJPOT BOECFIBWJPSPGBOFOUJUZGVMﬁMMJOHUIF SPMFThFFOUFSQSJTFWJFXQPJOUDPSSFTQPOETJO.04&4UPBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPOPGB TZTUFNXJUIUIFPUIFSQBSUTPGBMBSHFSTZTUFNUIBUJT WJFX7JO'JHVSFJO$IBQUFS ThFGPVOEBUJPOTQBSUPGUIF3.0%1TUBOEBSEJTBXFMMDSBGUFE HFOFSBMPOUPMPHZGPSTZTUFNNPEFMT UBSHFUFE UPEJTUSJCVUFEJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTCVUJONBOZSFTQFDUTBQQMJDBCMFUPTZTUFNTJOHFOFSBM

254

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThFJOGPSNBUJPOWJFXQPJOUEFﬁOFTUIFJOGPSNBUJPOUIBUJTFYDIBOHFECFUXFFOBTZTUFNBOEJUT FOWJSPONFOU BOEUIFTFNBOUJDTPGUIFJOGPSNBUJPOBOEJUTQSPDFTTJOHThFJOGPSNBUJPOWJFXQPJOU DPSSFTQPOETJO.04&4UPBNPEFMPGUIFTUVﬀ FYDIBOHFEJOUIFJOUFSBDUJPOPGBTZTUFNXJUIUIF PUIFSQBSUTPGBMBSHFSTZTUFN XIFSFJOUIJTDBTFTUVﬀ iTMJNJUFEUPJOGPSNBUJPO ThFDPNQVUBUJPOBMWJFXQPJOUJTBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGBTZTUFNUIBUEFﬁOFTUIFQBSUTPSPCKFDUT UIFJSFYUFSOBMJOUFSGBDFT BOEUIFJSJOUFSBDUJPOT*UJTBMPHJDBMWJFXJOUIBUJUIJEFTUIFEJTUSJCVUJPO PGUIFPCKFDUTBOEGPDVTFTPOMZPOUIFJSJOUFSGBDFTBOEJOUFSBDUJPOTThJTWJFXQPJOUDPSSFTQPOETJO .04&4UPBOJOUFSOBMWJFXPGBTZTUFN WJFX7JO'JHVSF XIFSFUIFDPNQPOFOUTBOEDPO OFDUPSTBSFMPHJDBMFOUJUJFTUIBUIJEFUIFJSEJTUSJCVUJPO ThFFOHJOFFSJOHWJFXQPJOUJTBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGBTZTUFNUIBUEFﬁOFTUIFQBSUTPSPCKFDUT UIFJSFYUFSOBMJOUFSGBDFT BOEUIFJSJOUFSBDUJPOT*UJTBQIZTJDBMEJTUSJCVUFEWJFXJOUIBUJUGPDVTFT POUIFEJTUSJCVUJPOPGUIFPCKFDUTBUEFﬁOFEOPEFTThJTWJFXQPJOUDPSSFTQPOETJO.04&4UPBO JOUFSOBMWJFXPGBTZTUFN WJFX7JO'JHVSF XIFSFUIFDPNQPOFOUTBOEDPOOFDUPSTBSFFOUJUJFT UIBUFYIJCJUUIFJSEJTUSJCVUJPO ThFUFDIOPMPHZWJFXQPJOUJTBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGBTZTUFNUIBUEFﬁOFTUIFQBSUTPSPCKFDUT UIFJS FYUFSOBMJOUFSGBDFT BOEUIFJSJOUFSBDUJPOT*UJTBQIZTJDBMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOWJFXJOUIBUJUGPDVTFT POUIFUFDIOPMPHJFTPGUIFPCKFDUTBOEQSPWJEFTJOGPSNBUJPOGPSJNQMFNFOUFSTThJTWJFXQPJOUDPS SFTQPOETJO.04&4UPBOJOUFSOBMWJFXPGBTZTUFN WJFX7JO'JHVSF XIFSFUIFDPNQPOFOUT BOEDPOOFDUPSTBSFFOUJUJFTUIBUTQFDJGZUIFJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUIBUJT BQSPEVDUUPCVZPSCVJME #FDBVTF3.0%1JTUBSHFUFEUPEJTUSJCVUFETZTUFNT JUdeﬁnes BOVNCFSPGBTQFDUTPGEJTUSJCV UJPOUIBUDBOCFIJEEFOThese BSFDBMMFEEJTUSJCVUJPOUSBOTQBSFODJFT&YBNQMFTJODMVEFNJHSBUJPO USBOTQBSFODZ XIJDIIJEFTUIFDIBOHFPGMPDBUJPOPGBOPCKFDUGSPNPUIFSPCKFDUTBOEGBJMVSFUSBOT QBSFODZ XIJDIIJEFTGSPNBOPCKFDUUIFGBJMVSFBOEQPTTJCMFSFDPWFSZPGPUIFSPCKFDUT UPFOBCMF GBVMUUPMFSBODF*OUIJTXBZ FWFOUIFQIZTJDBMMZJNQMFNFOUFETZTUFNDBOIJEFDFSUBJOJOGPSNBUJPO UPQSPNPUFWBSJPVTEFTJSBCMFQSPQFSUJFTGBDJMJUBUFﬂexibility FOBCMFGBVMUUPMFSBODF BOEMJNJUUIF JNQBDUPGDIBOHF&BDIPGUIFUSBOTQBSFODJFTdeﬁnes, JO.04&4UFSNT BOPUIFSWJFXPGBEJTUSJC VUFETZTUFN

DoDAF, MODAF, NAF Frameworks and UPDM ThF%P%"' JTBOFWPMWJOHBSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLEFTJHOFEUPBQQMZUPTZTUFNTBOEPSHB OJ[BUJPOTJOWPMWFEJO%P%BDRVJTJUJPOT*UIBTCFFOUIFCBTJTGPSBUMFBTUUXPPUIFSGSBNFXPSLTThF 6,.JOJTUSZPG%FGFOTF"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSL .0%"' BOEUIF/"50"SDIJUFDUVSF 'SBNFXPSL /"' )BHFOCP/"' ThFMBUUFSUXPIBWFBEEFETPNFDPODFQUTTVDI BTTVQQPSUGPSTFSWJDFPSJFOUFEBSDIJUFDUVSF 40"

BOEBSFOPXJOﬂVFODJOHUIFGVSUIFSFWPMVUJPO PG%P%"'ThF6OJﬁFE1SPﬁMFGPS%P%"'BOE.P%"' 61%. HSPVQXBTGPSNFEUPEFﬁOF B DPNNPO NPEFMJOH TUBOEBSE UP TVQQPSU UIFTF GSBNFXPSLT FTQFDJBMMZ %P%"' BOE .0%"' 61%. ThF61%.QSPﬁMFJTJOUFOEFEUPCFTVCNJUUFEUPUIF0CKFDU.BOBHFNFOU(SPVQ 0.( GPSTUBOEBSEJ[BUJPO *OUIFEJTDVTTJPOUIBUGPMMPXT XFVTFUIFUFSNTPGFBDIGSBNFXPSL8IFSFBQQSPQSJBUF XF JOEJDBUFNBQQJOHPGUIFJSUFSNTUP.04&4 8FOPXTVNNBSJ[FUIFWJFXTPGUIFTFGSBNFXPSLT%P%"'EFﬁOFTUISFFCBTJDBSDIJUFD UVSFWJFXTUIBUXFNJHIUDBMMGBNJMJFTPGWJFXTPSWJFXUZQFTPQFSBUJPOBM TZTUFNTBOETFSWJDFT BOEUFDIOJDBMTUBOEBSET QMVTBOA"MM7JFXUIBUEFTDSJCFTUIFPWFSBMMTDPQFBOEWPDBCVMBSZ PG BO BSDIJUFDUVSF &BDI WJFX IBT B OVNCFS PG QSPEVDUT UIBU DPVME CF EFTDSJCFE BT WJFXT PS NPEFMT .BOZ PG UIF QSPEVDUT BSF DPOTJTUFOU XJUI UIF UZQFT PG NPEFMT JO UIF ;BDINBO 'SBNFXPSL

Views O

255

ThF PQFSBUJPOBM WJFX EFTDSJCFT UIF PQFSBUJPOBM OPEFT BDUJWJUJFT BOE JOGPSNBUJPO FYDIBOHFT SFRVJSFEThFTZTUFNTBOETFSWJDFTWJFXEFTDSJCFTTZTUFNT TFSWJDFT BOEJOUFSDPOOFDUJPOTUIBUTVQ QPSUUIFBDUJWJUJFTJOUIFPQFSBUJPOBMWJFXThFUFDIOJDBMTUBOEBSETWJFXJTBTFUPGUFDIOJDBMTUBO EBSET JNQMFNFOUBUJPODPOWFOUJPOT BOESVMFTHPWFSOJOHUIFTUSVDUVSFBOEJOUFSBDUJPOPGTZTUFN QBSUTPSFMFNFOUT ThF %P% NBOEBUFT DPNQMJBODF XJUI UIJT GSBNFXPSL PO BDRVJTJUJPO QSPHSBNT UP BDIJFWF B DPNNPOBQQSPBDIUPBSDIJUFDUVSFJO%P%Th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hFZBEEFEBTFU PG40"WJFXTJOUPUIFJSBSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSL O O O O O O

/40"7JTTFSWJDFUBYPOPNZIJFSBSDIZPGTFSWJDFT /40"7JTTFSWJDFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJOUFSGBDFT QBSBNFUFST /40"7JTTFSWJDFDPNQPTJUJPOTFSWJDFTDPNQPTFEPGPUIFSTFSWJDFT /40"7JTTFSWJDFPSDIFTUSBUJPOIPXTFSWJDFTTVQQPSUPQFSBUJPOT /40"7JTTFSWJDFCFIBWJPSGVODUJPOT TUBUFNBDIJOFT JOUFSBDUJPOT /47JTTFSWJDFQSPWJTJPOXIJDITZTUFNTQFPQMFQSPWJEFTFSWJDFT

TOGAF 50("' EFﬁOFTGPVSBSDIJUFDUVSFT XIJDIXFXPVMEDBMMBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFXT #VTJOFTTBSDIJUFDUVSFBEESFTTFTVTFSDPODFSOT EFTDSJCFTCVTJOFTTJOGPSNBUJPn ﬂPX %BUBBSDIJUFDUVSFGPDVTFTPOEBUBCBTFDPNQPOFOUTPGTZTUFNBOEUIFDPODFSOTPGEBUBCBTF EFTJHOFSTBOETZTUFNTFOHJOFFST "QQMJDBUJPOTBSDIJUFDUVSFGPDVTFTPOBQQMJDBUJPOTPGUXBSFDPNQPOFOUTPGTZTUFNBOEUIF DPODFSOTPGTZTUFNTTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFST 5FDIOPMPHZ BSDIJUFDUVSF GPDVTFT PO UIF IBSEXBSF BOE TPGUXBSF BOE UIF DPODFSOT PG UIF BDRVJTJUJPOBOEQSPDVSFNFOUQFSTPOOFM "EJﬀFSFOUJBUPSPG50("'JTUIBUJUBMTPEFﬁOFTBEFWFMPQNFOUBMBQQSPBDI XIFSFBTNPTUPG UIF PUIFS GSBNFXPSLT BSF EFWFMPQNFOUBMMZ BHOPTUJD ThJT EJﬀFSFODF JT TJHOJﬁDBOU BT UIF WJFXT QSPEVDUTEFﬁOFECZPUIFSGSBNFXPSLTDBOCFDPOTUSVDUFEVTJOHUIF50("'NFUIPEPMPHZ MFWFS BHJOHCPUIHPWFSONFOUBOEJOEVTUSZTUBOEBSET

FEA ThF'&"QSPHSBNJTEJSFDUFECZUIF640ﬃcFPG.BOBHFNFOUBOE#VEHFU 0.# '&" *UGPDVTFTPOBCVTJOFTTESJWFOBQQSPBDIJOUFOEFEUPGBDJMJUBUFHPWFSONFOUXJEFJNQSPWFNFOUJO TFWFSBMBSFBTTVDIBTCVEHFUBMMPDBUJPOBOEJOGPSNBUJPOTIBSJOH*UEFﬁOFTUIFHPWFSONFOUMJOFT PG CVTJOFTT BOE TFSWJDFT JO B TFU PG SFGFSFODF NPEFMT 1FSGPSNBODF 3FGFSFODF .PEFM #VTJOFTT

256

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

3FGFSFODF.PEFM 4FSWJDF$PNQPOFOU3FGFSFODF.PEFM 5FDIOJDBM3FGFSFODF.PEFM BOE%BUB 3FGFSFODF.PEFM8FXPVMEDBMMFBDIPGUIFTFBWJFXPGUIF'&"CVUUIFﬂBWPSBOETDPQFPGUIF WJFXTBOEPG'&"BTBXIPMFEJﬀFSGSPNUIFPUIFSGSBNFXPSLT'&"JTNPSFBSFGFSFODFBSDIJUFD UVSFUIBOBGSBNFXPSLJUJTBHFOFSBMNPEFMPSDBUFHPSZXIPTFSFHJPOJODMVEFTUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFTPG BMMUIFBHFODJFTBDSPTTUIFGFEFSBMHPWFSONFOU ThF#VTJOFTT 4FSWJDF BOE5FDIOJDBM3FGFSFODF.PEFMTBSFUBYPOPNJFT FBDIEFDPNQPTFEJOUP IJFSBSDIJFT'PSFYBNQMF UIF#VTJOFTT3FGFSFODF.PEFMJTEJWJEFEJOUPCVTJOFTTBSFBT FH TFS WJDFTGPSDJUJ[FOT

FBDIPGXIJDIIBTMJOFTPGCVTJOFTT FH MBXFOGPSDFNFOU FEVDBUJPO

BOEFBDI PGUIPTFIBTTVCGVODUJPOT FH DSJNJOBMJOWFTUJHBUJPO IJHIFSFEVDBUJPO ThF4FSWJDF3FGFSFODF .PEFMIBTTFSWJDFEPNBJOT FH CVTJOFTTNBOBHFNFOUTFSWJDFT

FBDIPGXIJDIIBTTFSWJDFUZQFT FH TVQQMZDIBJONBOBHFNFOU

BOEFBDIPGUIPTFIBTDPNQPOFOUT FH QSPDVSFNFOU "HFODZ BSDIJUFDUVSFTBOEBDRVJTJUJPOTBSFNBQQFEUPUIFSFGFSFODFNPEFMT " EJTDVTTJPO PG NBOZ PG UIFTF BOE PUIFS FOUFSQSJTF BSDIJUFDUVSF GSBNFXPSLT JT QSPWJEFE JO 4DIFLLFSNBO BOEJO-BOLIPSTU

SOA and Other Treatments SOA Frameworks 40"IBTSFDFJWFENVDIBUUFOUJPOJOUIFQBTUGFXZFBST*OHFOFSBM UIFSFBSFUXPTFUTPGWJFXTUIBU FYJTUJONPTUBQQSPBDIFTUP40"*OUIFFOUFSQSJTFDPOUFYU UIFCVTJOFTTWJFXJTUIFESJWFSGPSXIBU TFSWJDFTBSFOFFEFEBOEIPXUIFZBSFVTFE XIJMFUIFUFDIOPMPHZPS*5WJFXJTXIFSFUIFTFSWJDFT BSFJNQMFNFOUFE*OUIFTFSWJDFJOUFSBDUJPODPOUFYUBSFUIFUXPDPNQMFNFOUBSZWJFXTPGTFSWJDF QSPWJEFSBOETFSWJDFDPOTVNFS4UBOEBSETIBWFCFFOEFﬁOFEGPSTFSWJDFPSJFOUBUJPO OPUBCMZUIF 0"4*440"SFGFSFODFNPEFM 0"4*4 BOEBTJHOJﬁDBOUOVNCFSPG8FCTFSWJDFTTUBOEBSET TPNFPGXIJDIXFSFJEFOUJﬁFEJO$IBQUFS ThSFFBQQSPBDIFTUIBUDPVMECFDBMMFEGSBNFXPSLTBSFCBTFEPOTFSWJDFPSJFOUFENPEFMJOH *#.T4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOHBOE"SDIJUFDUVSF 40." VTFTBNPEFMJOHBQQSPBDIUP BMJHOUIFCVTJOFTTQSPDFTTNPEFMXJUI40" "STBOKBOJ ThF4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH'SBNFXPSL 40.' EFﬁOFEJO #FMM

FNQIBTJ[FT NPEFMJOHBDSPTTBMMFOWJSPONFOUT GSPNUIFXPSMEJOXIJDIUIFTFSWJDFTXJMMCFVTFEUPUIF TFSWJDFTUIFNTFMWFT*UJODMVEFTBTVCTUBOUJBMOVNCFSPGCVTJOFTTBSDIJUFDUVSFQFSTQFDUJWFT PSWJFXTJOUXPDBUFHPSJFTDPODFQUVBMBOETUSVDUVSBM*UBMTPJODMVEFTTFSWJDFPSJFOUFE DPODFQUVBM MPHJDBM BOEQIZTJDBMBSDIJUFDUVSFT $#%* IBT EFﬁOFE B NFUB NPEFM PS GSBNFXPSL DBMMFE UIF $#%*4"& .FUB .PEFM GPS 40"7FSTJPOPGUIJTNFUBNPEFM $#%* JTEFﬁOFEBTBTFUPGSFMBUFEQBDLBHFT BT JO6.-QBDLBHF 8FKVEHFFBDIQBDLBHFUPCFBWJFX BOEUIFSFGPSFJOUIFMJTUCFMPXXF VTFUIFUFSNWJFXUPEFTDSJCFFBDIQBDLBHF O ThF4FSWJDFWJFXEFﬁOFTBOPUJPOBMTFSWJDF XIJDIJODMVEFTBOBNF BOFYJTUFODF BOE QPTTJCMZBGFXBUUSJCVUFTThF4FSWJDFWJFXDPSSFTQPOETUPBHFOFSBMNPEFMPGBTFSWJDF JOUIJTCPPL O ThF #VTJOFTT.PEFMJOHWJFXEFﬁOFTCVTJOFTTNPEFMFMFNFOUTDBMMFE#VTJOFTT4FSWJDF 4VCKFDUT XIJDI JO 7FSTJPO JODMVEF CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT DBQBCJMJUJFT UZQFT FWFOUT SVMFT BOEQPMJDJFT O ThF 4QFDJﬁDBUJPO WJFX EFﬁOFT GPS FBDI OPUJPOBM TFSWJDF BU MFBTU POF TFSWJDF JOUFS GBDF XIJDI TQFDJﬁFT UIF PQFSBUJPOT PG UIF TFSWJDF ThF PQFSBUJPOT DBO CF EFﬁOFE

Views O

O

O

O O

O

257

EFDMBSBUJWFMZ WJBQSFBOEQPTUDPOEJUJPOT JOXIJDIDBTFUIFZBSFDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIF JOUFSGBDFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDIEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFSPGUIJTCPPL ThF*NQMFNFOUBUJPOWJFXEFﬁOFTJNQMFNFOUBUJPOJOUFSNTPG"VUPNBUJPO6OJUT FBDI PGXIJDIJNQMFNFOUTPSBVUPNBUFTPOFPSNPSFTFSWJDFT PSFWFOOPOTFSWJDFTPGUXBSF TVDIBTMFHBDZTZTUFNT ThF%FQMPZNFOUBOE3VOUJNFWJFXNPEFMTTFSWJDFEFQMPZNFOUBOESVOUJNFCFIBWJPS ThF QSJNBSZ DPODFQUT BSF B EFQMPZNFOU XIJDI SFQSFTFOUT BO JOTUBMMFE BVUPNBUJPO VOJU BOEBOFOEQPJOU XIJDIIBTBOBTTPDJBUFEQSPUPDPMBOESFDPHOJ[FTBDPMMFDUJPO PGPQFSBUJPOT ThF 4PMVUJPO.PEFMJOHWJFXEFﬁOFTMJOLTCFUXFFOTFSWJDFTBOETPMVUJPOTXJUINPEJ ﬁFEVTFDBTFTFBDIVTFDBTFTUFQDBOCFBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBTFSWJDFPQFSBUJPO ThF 0SHBOJ[BUJPOWJFXJTCBTFEPOUIFHFOFSBMDPODFQUTPGQBSUZ XIJDIJUTQFDJBMJ[FT JOUPPSHBOJ[BUJPOVOJUT QFSTPOT BOEQPTUTBOESPMF&BDIQBSUZDBOQMBZNVMUJQMF SPMFT ThF 1PMJDZWJFXEFﬁOFTQPMJDJFT XIFSFBQPMJDZJTBSVMFPSDPOTUSBJOU XIJDINJHIU SBOHFGSPNTJNQMFUPDPNQMFY"QPMJDZHPWFSOTBOFOUJUZPSTFUPGFOUJUJFTJOBEFﬁOFE TDPQF TVDIBTBOFOUJSFFOUFSQSJTFPSBTQFDJﬁDPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMVOJU BOENBZBQQMZUP CVTJOFTTFMFNFOUTPSTFSWJDFT

Additional Treatments of Architecture Views ,SVDIUFO WJFXT ,SVDIUFO EFﬁOFE ﬁWF WJFXT PG TPGUXBSF BSDIJUFDUVSF BOE UIFO EFTDSJCFEUIFJSVTFJOUIF3BUJPOBM6OJﬁFE1SPDFTT ,SVDIUFO . ThFZBSF O -PHJDBMWJFXBEESFTTFTGVODUJPOBMSFRVJSFNFOUT JODMVEFTNBKPSEFTJHOQBDLBHFT TVCTZT UFNT BOEDMBTTFT O *NQMFNFOUBUJPO WJFX PSHBOJ[BUJPO PG TUBUJD TPGUXBSF NPEVMFT TVDI BT TPVSDF DPEF BOE EBUa ﬁMFT JOUIFEFWFMPQNFOUFOWJSPONFOU O 1SPDFTTWJFXSVOUJNFQSPDFTTFTPGTZTUFNTBOEUIFJSJOUFSBDUJPOT O %FQMPZNFOUWJFXNBQPGSVOUJNFDPNQPOFOUTUPVOEFSMZJOHQMBUGPSNT O 6TFDBTFWJFXTDFOBSJPTPSVTFDBTFTJMMVTUSBUFTIPXUIFPUIFSWJFXTXPSL ThJTTFUJTDBMMFEWJFXT SBUIFSUIBOﬁWFWJFXT CFDBVTFUIFVTFDBTFWJFXJTQPTJUJPOFEBTMJOL JOHUIFPUIFSGPVSUPHFUIFS .BJFSBOE3FDIUJOWJFXT.BJFSBOE3FDIUJO EFTDSJCFUIFTFBTNBKPSTZTUFNTPS BSDIJUFDUVSBMWJFXT O O O O O O

1VSQPTFPCKFDUJWFXIBUUIFDMJFOUXBOUT 'PSNXIBUUIFTZTUFNJT #FIBWJPSBMPSGVODUJPOBMXIBUUIFTZTUFNEPFT 1FSGPSNBODFPCKFDUJWFTPSSFRVJSFNFOUTIPXFﬀFDUJWFMZUIFTZTUFNEPFTJU %BUBUIFJOGPSNBUJPOSFUBJOFEJOUIFTZTUFNBOEJUTJOUFSSFMBUJPOTIJQT .BOBHFSJBMUIFQSPDFTTCZXIJDIUIFTZTUFNJTDPOTUSVDUFEBOENBOBHFE

4&*WJFXTBOEWJFXUZQFT"UFBNBUUIF4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH*OTUJUVUF 4&* $MFNFOUTFUBM EJTDVTTWJFXTJOUIFJSCPPLPOTPGUXBSFBSDIJUFDUVSFThFZSFDPHOJ[FUIFTFQBSBUJPOPGWJFXT

258 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

CVUJOTUFBEPGJOUFHSBUJPO UIFZEJTDVTTDPNCJOJOHPSDPMMBQTJOHWJFXTJOUPPOFWJFXThFZEFﬁOF UISFFWJFXUZQFT BOETFWFSBMTUZMFTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIFBDIWJFXUZQF. ThFZBSF O .PEVMFWJFXUZQFIBTEFDPNQPTJUJPO VTFT HFOFSBMJ[BUJPO BOEMBZFSFETUZMFT O $PNQPOFOUBOEDPOOFDUPSWJFXUZQFIBTQJQFBOEﬁMUFS TIBSFEEBUB QVCMJTITVCTDSJCF DMJFOUTFSWFS QFFSUPQFFS BOEDPNNVOJDBUJOHQSPDFTTFTTUZMFT O "MMPDBUJPOWJFXUZQFIBTEFQMPZNFOU JNQMFNFOUBUJPO BOEXPSLBTTJHONFOUTUZMFT .BOZ PG UIFTF 4&* DPODFQUT BSF JO .04&4 CVU GBDUPSFE JO EJﬀFSFOU XBZT .04&4 DPO TJEFSTUIFDPNQPOFOUBOEDPOOFDUPSTUZMFTUPCFEJﬀFSFOUJOUFSBDUJPOQSPUPDPMTJOUIFDPNQPTJ UJPOEJNFOTJPO BOEUIFiVTFTwSFMBUJPOJTUIFEFQFOEFODZSFMBUJPOJOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPO %FDPNQPTJUJPOBOEHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOBSFEJﬀFSFOU.04&4NPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOT%FQMPZNFOU JTBQIZTJDBMWJFXJO.04&4*NQMFNFOUBUJPOBOEXPSLBTTJHONFOUBSFDPOTJEFSFENBOBHFNFOU WJFXTJO.04&4 The OPUJPOPGWJFXUZQF IPXFWFS JTBOJNQPSUBOUFMFNFOUJO.04&4*UJTFYQBOEFEIFSFGSPN UIF$MFNFOUTOPUJPOPGCSPBEDBUFHPSJFTPGWJFXTPGTUZMFTUPUIFBQQSPBDIUIBUFWFSZWJFXJTDPOTJE FSFEBOJOTUBODFPGBWJFXUZQFTherFBSFBOVOMJNJUFEOVNCFSPGQPUFOUJBMWJFXUZQFT JODMVEJOH UZQFTGPSBMMUIFiJOTUBODFwWJFXTXFIBWFDJUFEJOUIJTTFDUJPO'PSFYBNQMF BOJOGPSNBUJPOWJFX deﬁning BMMUIFJOGPSNBUJPOFYDIBOHFEJOBTZTUFN NBZCFVTFGVMGPSNBOZQSPKFDUTBOETZTUFNT TPJUDBOCFdeﬁned BTBOJOGPSNBUJPOWJFXUZQF XIJDI3.0%1IBTEPOF FYDFQUUIFZDBMMFEJU BOJOGPSNBUJPOWJFXQPJOU Then JGBTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSEFTDSJCFTUIFJOGPSNBUJPOWJFXPGBTZTUFN UIBUJOGPSNBUJPOWJFXJTBOJOTUBODFPGUIFJOGPSNBUJPOWJFXUZQF *&&&"SDIJUFDUVSFEFTDSJQUJPOThF*&&&SFDPNNFOEFEQSBDUJDFGPSBSDIJUFDUVSFEFTDSJQ UJPO *&&& o EFﬁOFTUIFDPODFQUPGWJFXBOEWJFXQPJOUCVUEPFTOPUEFﬁOFBTFUPG WJFXT. ThFEFﬁOJUJPOTBSF O 7JFXBSFQSFTFOUBUJPOPGBXIPMFTZTUFNGSPNUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGBSFMBUFETFUPGDPODFSOT O 7JFXQPJOUBTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGUIFDPOWFOUJPOTGPSDPOTUSVDUJOHBOEVTJOHBWJFX"QBUUFSO PSUFNQMBUFGSPNXIJDIUPEFWFMPQJOEJWJEVBMWJFXTCZFTUBCMJTIJOHUIFQVSQPTFTBOEBVEJ FODFGPSBWJFXBOEUIFUFDIOJRVFTGPSJUTDSFBUJPOBOEBOBMZTJT ThF*&&&EFﬁOJUJPOPGWJFXJTMBSHFMZDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIF.04&4DPODFQUPGWJFX BMUIPVHI .04&4BMMPXTUIFUBSHFUPGBWJFXUPCFBOFOUJUZPUIFSUIBOBTZTUFNGPSFYBNQMF BNPEFM SFHJPOThFEFﬁOJUJPOPGWJFXQPJOUJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIF.04&4DPODFQUPGWJFXUZQF BTEJT DVTTFE BCPWF "T EJTDVTTFE BU UIF TUBSU PG UIJT DIBQUFS .04&4 EFﬁOFT WJFXQPJOU NPSF JO UIF USBEJUJPOBMTFOTF BTBQPJOUPSMPDVTGSPNXIFSFBWJFXJTPCTFSWFEThF*&&&TUBOEBSEJT UIFTUBSUJOHQPJOUGPSBO*40*&$BSDIJUFDUVSFEFTDSJQUJPOTUBOEBSE UIBUJTCFJOHEFWFM PQFE " GSBNFXPSL UIBU JT JOﬂVFODJOH EFWFMPQJOH *40 TUBOEBSET BOE JT DBMMFE UIF (FOFSBMJ[FE &OUFSQSJTF 3FGFSFODF "SDIJUFDUVSF BOE .FUIPEPMPHZ (&3". .BOZ (&3".DPODFQUTBSFDPOTJTUFOUXJUI.04&4 JODMVEJOHUIFBSFBTPGFOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOHBOE NBOBHFNFOU NPEFMJOH BOEWJFXT $PNNFOUTPOUIFGSBNFXPSLBOESFMBUFEFYBNQMFTThe DPNNFOUTIFSFBQQMZUPUIFFYBNQMFT JOUIFTFDUJPOTFOUJUMFEi&OUFSQSJTF"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSLTwBOEi40"BOE0UIFS5SFBUNFOUTw The EPNJOBOUNBQQJOHPGEFTJHOBOEBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFXTJTUP.04&4JOUFSOBMNPEFMT XIJDIJT BQQSPQSJBUF)PXFWFS UIFJOUFSUXJOJOHOBUVSFPGFYUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBMNPEFMTJOUIFDPNQPTJUJPO ThFZVTFUIFTJOHMFUFSN“WJFXUZQF”XFTQMJUJUJOUP“WJFXUZQF”

Views O

259

IJFSBSDIZJTOPUDBQUVSFEJOUIFTFWJFXT*ONPTUDBTFT UIFQMBDFPGFYUFSOBMWJFXTJTOPUBSUJDVMBUFE The FYUFSOBM WJFX JT JOWJTJCMF CFUXFFO UXP DPNQPTJUJPO MFWFMT PG JOUFSOBM WJFXT JO NBOZ PG UIF GSBNFXPSks. That is a general wFBLOFTTUIBUOFFETUPCFSFNFEJFE 4PNFWJFXT FTQFDJBMMZ%P%"'WJFXTBOEQSPEVDUT DBOTQBONVMUJQMFMFWFMTPGDPNQPTJUJPO XJUIPVUNBLJOHUIFMFWFMTDMFBSBOEEJTUJODUThJTDBOSFTVMUJONPOPMJUIJDNPEFMTSBUIFSUIBO NPEVMBSNPEFMT /FWFSUIFMFTT NBOZJNQPSUBOUBOEVTFGVMWJFXTBSFBWBJMBCMF BTTFFOGSPNUIFFYBNQMFT0WFS UJNF TPNFWJFXUZQFTNBZBDIJFWFTVﬃcJFOUDPOTFOTVTUPXIFSFJUJTBQQSPQSJBUFUPJODMVEFUIFN JOBTUBOEBSETVDIBT*&&&PS*40*&$#VUJOBOZDBTF UIFTFUPGEFﬁOFEWJFXTBOE WJFXUZQFTTIPVMEBMXBZTCFPQFOFOEFE

Layered Architecture ThJTTFDUJPOEJTDVTTFTUIFWFOFSBCMFDPODFQUPGMBZFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSFGSPNUISFFQFSTQFDUJWFTUIBU EJﬀFSTPNFXIBUGSPNUIFOPSNUIFJOﬁOJUFMPPQ MFWFSBHF BOEEVBMIJFSBSDIJFT

The Inﬁnite Loop "LFZESJWFSPGMBZFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSFJTUIFWJSUVBMNBDIJOFDPODFQU#VUBQSJNBSZbeneﬁt PGWJSUVBM NBDIJOFT QPSUBCJMJUZ JTQSFEJDBUFEPOBSBUIFSTVCUMFDPOTUSBJOUPSBTTVNQUJPOThat BTTVNQUJPO JTUIBUUIFSFJTPOMZPOFWJSUVBMNBDIJOFBOENVMUJQMFSFBMNBDIJOFT PSBUMFBTUUIBUUIFOVNCFSPG WJSUVBMNBDIJOFTPOXIJDIUIFIJHIFSMFWFMEFTJSFTUPSVOJTsigniﬁcantly TNBMMFSUIBOUIFOVNCFS PGSFBMNBDIJOFTPOXIJDIUIFIJHIFSMFWFMEFTJSFTUPSVO4VQQPTFBQSPHSBN1XBOUTUPSVOPO UISFFSFBMNBDIJOFTBOEUIFSFJTPOFWJSUVBMNBDIJOF*OUIJTDBTF XSJUJOH1UPVTF EFQFOEPO UIF TFSWJDFTPGUIFPOFWJSUVBMNBDIJOFJODSFBTFTJUTQPSUBCJMJUZUPSFBMNBDIJOFT BOE)PXFWFS TVQQPTFUIFSFBSFUISFFdiﬀerFOUWJSUVBMNBDIJOFT BOE1OFFETUPSVOPOBMMUISFF/PXUIFWJSUVBM NBDIJOFTIBWFOPUNBEF1NPSFQPSUBCMF*OTUFBEPGXSJUJOHUISFFWFSTJPOTUPSVOSFTQFDUJWFMZ PO SFBM NBDIJOFT 3. 3. BOE 3. UIF 1 QSPHSBNNFS NVTU XSJUF UISFF WFSTJPOT UP SVO SFTQFDUJWFMZPOWJSUVBMNBDIJOFT7. 7. BOE7.*GUIFSFBSFﬁvFWJSUVBMNBDIJOFTUIBU1 OFFETUPSVOPO UIFO1JTOPXMFTTQPSUBCMFUIBOTJNQMZXSJUJOHUPSFBMNBDIJOFT3. 3. BOE3.4POPXXFOFFEUPEFﬁOFBOFXWJSUVBMNBDIJOFPOUPQPG7.ToPSoUPNBLF 1QPSUBCMFThis JTXIBUIBTIBQQFOFEPWFSUIFQBTUGFXEFDBEFT8FXSPUFPQFSBUJOHTZTUFNTBT WJSUVBMNBDIJOFTUIBUIJEIBSEXBSFdiﬀerFODFT BOEUSJFEUPTUBOEBSEJ[F FH 104*9 #VUXFIBE UPPNBOZPQFSBUJOHTZTUFNT4PXFDBNFVQXJUINJEEMFXBSF#VUUIFOXFDPVMEOPUTUBOEBSEJ[F PONJEEMFXBSF4PUIBUJTXIBUQSPNQUFE0.(JOUIFJS.PEFM%SJWFO"SDIJUFDUVSF .%" UP DPNFVQXJUIQMBUGPSNJOEFQFOEFOUNPEFMT 1*.T

XIJDIXFSFUPCFBWJSUVBMNBDIJOFPOUPQ PGNJEEMFXBSF ThJTTVDDFTTJPOPGFWFOUTSFﬂFDUTUIFIJTUPSZPGQMBUGPSNJOEFQFOEFODFJOUIFGPSNPGBSFQFBU JOHQBUUFSOPGQMBUGPSNIJEJOH#BTFEPOUIFIJTUPSZPGUIFTFFﬀPSUT POFDPVMESPVHIMZEFﬁOFB iQMBUGPSNIJEJOHJOﬁOJUFMPPQwBMHPSJUINUIBUXPSLTTPNFUIJOHMJLFUIJT 1SPCMFN 4PGUXBSF TIPVME CF BWBJMBCMF UP BMM CVU NVMUJQMF TQFDJﬁD QMBUGPSNT FYJTU ThJT NBLFTJUUPPFYQFOTJWFUPCVJMEBOENBJOUBJOTPGUXBSFCFDBVTFPGUIFNVMUJQMFWBSJBUJPOT OFFEFE 4PMVUJPO3BJTFUIFMFWFM4UBOEBSEJ[FPSIJEFUIFQMBUGPSNWBSJBOUTCFIJOEPOFDPNNPO WJSUVBMNBDIJOFBUUIJTOFXMFWFM (PBM(FUFWFSZPOFUPVTFUIJTWJSUVBMNBDIJOF

260

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

1SPCMFNThFXPSMEEPFTOPUCFIBWFBTXFXBOU.VMUJQMFDPNQFUJOHJOUFSGBDFTBSFEFﬁOFE BUUIJTWJSUVBMNBDIJOFMFWFMThFTFDPNQFUJOHJOUFSGBDFTOPXMPPLBMPUMJLFTQFDJﬁDQMBU GPSNTThFNPEFMTUIBUBDDFTTUIFTFDPNQFUJOHWJSUVBMQMBUGPSNTBSFOPMPOHFSQPSUBCMF CFDBVTFUIFZIBWFUPCFQPSUFEUPFBDIPOF (PUP ThJTMPPQXPVMEQSFTVNBCMZTUPQ BU4UFQ JGFWFSZPOFBHSFFEPOPOFWJSUVBMNBDIJOFBUTPNFMFWFM )PXFWFS FWFOXJUIUIJTTJUVBUJPOPWFSSFDFOUEFDBEFT XFIBWFDPOUJOVFEUPVTFMBZFSFEBSDIJ UFDUVSFT TP B WJSUVBM NBDIJOF NVTU OPU CF UIF EPNJOBOU ESJWFS GPS MBZFSFE BSDIJUFDUVSFT 8F TVHHFTUJOTUFBEUIBUUIFQSJNBSZCFOFﬁU BOEUIFSFGPSFUIFQSJNBSZESJWFS BMUIPVHIUBDJUUPUIJT QPJOU

JTMFWFSBHF

Leverage 8FBSHVFUIBUUIFQSJNBSZCFOFﬁUPGBMBZFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSFJTUIBUJUBDIJFWFTTJHOJﬁDBOUMFWFSBHF BTEFﬁOFEJO$IBQUFS CZDPNCJOJOHDPNQPOFOUTSBOHJOHGSPNWFSZTQFDJﬁDUPWFSZHFOFSBM ThJTDPNCJOFTUIFUZQFTPGMFWFSBHFTPUIBUUIFMFWFSBHFPGCPUIBTQFDJﬁDTPMVUJPOBOEBHFOFSBM TPMVUJPO BMPOHXJUIWBSJPVTMBZFSTJOCFUXFFO BSFFYQMPJUFEThFFﬀFDUTBSFUPTPNFEFHSFFDVNV MBUJWF BOEUIFSFTVMUJTUIBUNPTUPGUIFMFWFSBHFTQBDFCFMPXUIFUSBEFPﬀ MJNJUMJOFJTVTFEPS FYQMPJUFE'PSFYBNQMF TVQQPTFUIFUISFFMBZFSBSDIJUFDUVSFJO'JHVSFJTBQQMJDBUJPOMBZFS NJEEMFXBSFMBZFS BOEQMBUGPSNMBZFSThFOUIFUPUBMMFWFSBHFBWBJMBCMFGSPNUIJTBSDIJUFDUVSF JTUIFVOJPOPGUIFBSFBTPOUIFMFGUJOUIF## $$ BOE%%CPYFT

Dual Hierarchies 'JHVSFTIPXTUIBUXIBUMBZFSTBSFHFOFSBMBOEXIBUBSFTQFDJﬁDPSVOJRVFEFQFOETPOUIF WJFXQPJOU'SPNUIFUPQMBZFSQSPCMFNWJFXQPJOUUPQMBZFSJTNPTUTQFDJﬁD JF BTQFDJﬁDBQQMJ DBUJPOEPNBJO BOEUIFCPUUPNMBZFSJTNPTUHFOFSBM JF JUDBOSVOPOBOZQMBUGPSN 'SPNUIF

!

Figure 10.3

Combined leverage of layered architecture.

Views O Problem Domain Uniqueness

Unique to problem domain

261

Platform Uniqueness

Layer 4

Common across platforms; platform independent

Layer 3

Layer 2

Common across problem domains

Figure 10.4

Layer 1

Unique to platform

Basis of dual hierarchies in layered architecture.

CPUUPNMBZFSQMBUGPSNWJFXQPJOUCPUUPNMBZFSJTNPTUTQFDJﬁD JF JUJTBTQFDJﬁDQMBUGPSN BOE UIFUPQMBZFSJTUIFNPTUHFOFSBM JF JUDBOTVQQPSUBOZBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO ThJTJTBOPUIFSWBSJBUJPOPGUIFEVBMIJFSBSDIJFTTIPXOJO'JHVSF8FBMSFBEZIBWFUIF ﬁSTUUXPQJFDFTUIFIJFSBSDIJFTFNBOBUJOHGSPNUPQBOECPUUPN SFTQFDUJWFMZThFUIJSEQJFDF JTUIFEVBMIJFSBSDIJFTFNBOBUJOHGSPNUIFNJEEMF'SPNUIFWJFXQPJOUPGUIFNJEEMFMBZFSPGUIF BSDIJUFDUVSF FH TPNFUZQFPGNJEEMFXBSF

JUJTTQFDJﬁD*UTVQQPSUTNVMUJQMFBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT BOEDBOSVOPONVMUJQMFQMBUGPSNT TPGSPNUIJTWJFXQPJOUCPUIUIFUPQ BQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO BOE CPUUPN QMBUGPSN MBZFSTBSFNPSFHFOFSBM

Aspect-Oriented Development ThFBTQFDUPSJFOUFETPGUXBSFEFWFMPQNFOU "0% DPNNVOJUZIBTFYQMPSFEJOEFQUIUIFUPQJDPG BTQFDUT XIJDIJO.04&4UFSNTBSFBUZQFPGWJFX OBNFMZ UIFDSPTTDVUUJOHTPGUXBSFUZQF7JFXT JO.04&4DBOCFDSPTTDVUUJOHPSOPU BOEDBOUBSHFUBOZUZQFPGTZTUFN OPUKVTUTPGUXBSF "TQFDU PSJFOUBUJPO TUBSUFE JO UIF QSPHSBNNJOH BSFOB ESJWFO CZ JOFﬃcJFODJFT PG EVQMJDBU JOHDSPTTDVUUJOHJTTVFTJONBOZDPEFNPEVMFT ,JD[BMFTFUBM 'VODUJPOTTVDIBTMPHHJOH EJTQMBZ BOEBVEJUTPGUFOBSFSFQFBUFEJONBOZPSBMMDPEFNPEVMFTPGBTPGUXBSFTZTUFNThFHPBM PGBTQFDUPSJFOUFEQSPHSBNNJOHXBTUPGBDUPSPVUFBDIPGUIFTFDPNNPODSPTTDVUUJOHDPODFSOT BTBOBTQFDU DPEFJUJOBTFQBSBUFNPEVMF BOEUIFOVTFUPPMTUPJOUFHSBUFPSiXFBWFwUIFBTQFDU DPEF JOUP BMM UIF OFDFTTBSZ QMBDFT JO UIF CBTF QSPHSBN ThF TDPQF PG UIJT BQQSPBDI IBT HSPXO PWFS UIF QBTU EFDBEF JO TFWFSBM XBZT ThF DPODFSOT CFJOH JOWFTUJHBUFE IBWF FYUFOEFE UP EFTJHO BOESFRVJSFNFOUT BOEUPNPSFOPOGVODUJPOBMJTTVFT JODMVEJOHQFSGPSNBODF TFDVSJUZ BOEPUIFS RVBMJUJFTThF8FCTJUFIUUQXXXFBSMZBTQFDUTOFUJTEFWPUFEUPFBSMZBTQFDUT XIJDIGPDVTPO DSPTTDVUUJOHQSPQFSUJFTJOSFRVJSFNFOUTFOHJOFFSJOHBOEBSDIJUFDUVSFEFTJHOThF8FCTJUFIUUQ XXXBTQFDUNPEFMJOHPSHJOEFYIUNMJTEFWPUFEUPBTQFDUPSJFOUFENPEFMJOH BDPODFQUUIBUIBT CSPVHIUUPHFUIFS"0%BOETPGUXBSFNPEFMJOHDPNNVOJUJFTJOBTFSJFTPGXPSLTIPQT *OBEEJUJPO BTZNNFUSJDBQQSPBDIIBTFNFSHFE.PTU"0%BQQSPBDIFTIBWFCFFOBTZNNFU SJD XIFSFBTQFDUTBSFDPNQPTFEPSXPWFOJOUPDPNQPOFOUTPGBCBTFNPEFMPSTZTUFN"TQFDUT

262 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

BOEDPNQPOFOUTBSFEJﬀFSFOU*OBTZNNFUSJDBQQSPBDITVDIBTNVMUJEJNFOTJPOBMTFQBSBUJPOPG DPODFSOT .%40$ 5BSSFUBM

OPEJTUJODUJPOFYJTUTCFUXFFOBTQFDUTBOEDPNQPOFOUT JOGBDU UIFSFJTOPCBTFNPEFM"MMDPODFSOT JODMVEJOHGVODUJPOBMJUZ BSFGBDUPSFEJOUPTFQBSBUF NPEVMFT XIJDIBSFUIFODPNQPTFEPSXPWFOJOUPBTZTUFN4FF)BSSJTPOFUBM GPSGVSUIFS EJTDVTTJPOPGUIFBTZNNFUSJDBOETZNNFUSJDBQQSPBDIFTThF"0%DPNNVOJUZPGUFOUBMLTBCPVU UIFUZSBOOZPGUIFEPNJOBOUIJFSBSDIZThFBTZNNFUSJDBQQSPBDIBMMFWJBUFTUIFUZSBOOZUIFTZN NFUSJDBQQSPBDIQSFTVNBCMZSFNPWFTJU ThFNPWFNFOUPG"0%IBTCFFOUPXBSEJODSFBTJOHNPEVMBSJUZThFCFMJFGJTUIBUFWFSZDPODFSO DBOCFTFQBSBUFEJOUPJUTPXONPEVMFPSDPNQPOFOU BOEUIVTUIBUFWFSZDPNQPOFOUXJMMSFQSFTFOU POMZPOFDPODFSO JODBUFHPSJFTTVDIBTGVODUJPOBMJUZ QFSGPSNBODF DPSSFDUOFTT PSTFDVSJUZ

Assessment ThF"0%DPNNVOJUZIBTEPOFJNQPSUBOUXPSLJOFYBNJOJOHIPXUPTFQBSBUFDPODFSOTBOENJOJ NJ[FEVQMJDBUJPOBOEFYUFOEJOHUIFTDPQFBDSPTTUIFEFWFMPQNFOUDZDMFJTHPPE#VUUIFSFTFFNUP CFUXPDPOTUSBJOUTPOBDIJFWBCMFTFQBSBUJPO'JSTUJTTFQBSBUJPOOPUFWFSZDPODFSODBOCFBMMPDBUFE UP DPEF UIBU POMZ BEESFTTFT UIBU DPODFSO 4FDPOE JT JOUFHSBUJPO UIF DIBMMFOHF PG JOUFHSBUJPO JT JODSFBTFEJOSFMBUJPOUPJODSFBTFTJOTFQBSBUJPO8FEJTDVTTUIFTFDPOTUSBJOUTJOUVSO -JNJUTPGTFQBSBUJPOThF"0%HPBMJTUPEJWJEFNPEVMFTVOUJMFBDIQSJNJUJWFSFTVMUJOHDPEF NPEVMFSFQSFTFOUTKVTUPOFBTQFDUPSDPODFSOThJTXPSLTGPSTPNFDPODFSOTCVUOPUPUIFST0GUFO UXPPSNPSFEJﬀFSFOUDPODFSOTJOTFQBSBCMZQFSNFBUFBHJWFOFOUJUZPSNPEVMF$POTJEFSUIFFYBN QMFPGTPGUXBSFDPEFThFDPEFUPDPNQVUFUIFCBTJDGVODUJPOJTOPUTFQBSBUFGSPNUIFDPEFUIBU BDIJFWFTQFSGPSNBODFPSSFMJBCJMJUZPSPUIFSRVBMJUJFTThFTBNFDPEFDPNQVUFTUIFGVODUJPOBOE BDIJFWFTTPNFMFWFMPGQFSGPSNBODF*GXFXBOUUPJNQSPWFQFSGPSNBODFJOUIJTGVODUJPO XFEP OPUXSJUFBEEJUJPOBMDPEFSBUIFS XFNPEJGZUIFGVODUJPOBMDPEF8FDBO IPXFWFS EFﬁOFBOE EJTUJOHVJTICFUXFFOBGVODUJPOBMWJFXBOEBQFSGPSNBODFWJFXPGUIFTBNFDPEF &YUFOEJOHUIFDPODFQUCFZPOETPGUXBSF DPOTJEFSUIFFYBNQMFPGBIVNBOCFJOHQMBZJOHEJG GFSFOUSPMFTJOEJﬀFSFOUDPOUFYUT TVDIBTQBSFOU TQPVTF FNQMPZFF CBTFCBMMQMBZFS FUD8FNJHIU TBZUIBUFBDISPMFSFQSFTFOUTBEJﬀFSFOUBTQFDUPSDPODFSOPGUIFIVNBO$MFBSMZ XFDBOOPUEJWJEF BIVNBOJOUPNPEVMFTUIJTQBSUPGUIFQFSTPOJTBQBSFOU UIBUQBSUPGUIFQFSTPOJTBOFNQMPZFF FUDThFDMFBSNPEFMJOHBQQSPBDIJTUIBUUIFXIPMFQFSTPOJTBQBSFOU BOEUIFXIPMFQFSTPOJTBO FNQMPZFF FUDBOEFBDISPMFJTBEJﬀFSFOUWJFXPGUIFXIPMFQFSTPO8IBUFWFSBQQSPBDIUIFDPN NVOJUZEFWFMPQTPWFSUJNFUPEFBMXJUIDSPTTDVUUJOHPSPWFSMBQQJOHBTQFDUTBOEWJFXT JUTJNQMZ DBOOPUEFQFOEPOTVCEJWJEJOHTZTUFNTUPUIFQPJOUXIFSFFBDIQBSU DPNQPOFOU PSNPEVMFPOMZ SFQSFTFOUTPOFWJFX8FXJMMIBWFUPDPNFVQXJUITPNFUIJOHUIBUSFDPHOJ[FTBOEFNCSBDFTUIF GBDUUIBUBTQFDUT BOENPSFHFOFSBMMZWJFXT DPFYJTUJOBXBZUIBUDBOPOMZCFTFQBSBUFEDPODFQUV BMMZ OPUTFQBSBUFECZNPEVMBSEFDPNQPTJUJPOThFQPJOUJTOPUUIBUFYUSFNFNPEVMBSEFDPNQPTJ UJPOPGTZTUFNTOFWFSXPSLTUIFQPJOUJTUIBUFOPVHITJUVBUJPOTFYJTUXIFSFJUEPFTOPUXPSLUIBU JUDBOOPUCFBHFOFSBMTPMVUJPO $IBMMFOHFPGJOUFHSBUJPO&WFOXJUIJOUIFMJNJUTPGIPXNVDIXFDBOTFQBSBUF UIF"0%DPN NVOJUZIBTUBLFOTFQBSBUJPOUPUIFQPJOUPGIBWJOHTNBMMDPNQPOFOUGSBHNFOUT XIJMFBTTVNJOH UIBUBTZTUFNDBOCFDPNQPTFEJOBTUSBJHIUGPSXBSENBOOFSThe "0%UFSNJOPMPHZPGXFBWJOH KPJOJOH BOE NFSHJOH JT B diﬀerFOU DPODFQU GSPN DPOTJEFSBUJPOT PG JOUFSBDUJPO BOE JOUFHSBUJPO (JWFOUIFIJTUPSJDBMdiﬃculties PGJOUFHSBUJPO XIZTIPVMEDPNQPTJOHGSBHNFOUTJOUPBXIPMFTZT UFNCFFBTJFSPSNPSFTUSBJHIUGPSXBSEUIBODPNQPTJOHUSBEJUJPOBMDPNQPOFOUT 8FXPVMEFYQFDUJU JOTUFBEUPCFNPSFdiﬃcult CFDBVTFUIFSFBSFNBOZNPSFQJFDFTUPCSJOHUPHFUIFS*OUFSBDUJPOTBOE side eﬀects and sequencing eﬀects can have a signiﬁcant impact on integration.

Views O

263

'VSUIFSNPSF UIFXIPMFBSFBPGFNFSHFOUQSPQFSUJFTBOECFIBWJPSXPVMETFFNUPCFNBEFNPSF QSPCMFNBUJDCZUIFFYUFOTJWFTFQBSBUJPOTh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hFZGBDJMJUBUFDPODFQUVBMBOEWJTVBMTFQBSBUJPO PGBMMDPODFSOT BOETVQQPSUQIZTJDBMTFQBSBUJPOXIFSFBQQSPQSJBUF O 7JFXTXPSLJODSPTTDVUUJOHDBTFTXIFSF"0%GBJMT OBNFMZ XIFSFQIZTJDBMTFQBSBUJPOJT OPUQPTTJCMF O 7JFXT EP OPU SFTVMU JO GSBHNFOUBUJPO ThF VTF PG WJFXT BMMPXT JOUFHSBUJPO UP CF BO JOWBSJBOUUIBUJT UIFTZTUFNDBOSFNBJOJOUFHSBUFEBUBMMUJNFTFWFOXIFOXFBSFDPO DFQUVBMMZBOEWJTVBMMZTFQBSBUJOHDPODFSOTThF.04&4UFSNGPSBTZTUFNJOXIJDIBMM DPODFSOTDPFYJTUJTBOJOUFHSBUFETZTUFN"0%DBMMTTVDIBTJUVBUJPOiUBOHMFEDPODFSOTw O 7JFXTHPCFZPOEUIFTDPQFPGDSPTTDVUUJOHDPODFSOTUPBEESFTTBMMDPODFSOTXJUIUIFTBNF TFBNMFTTBOEIPMJTUJDBQQSPBDI"0%BEESFTTFTPOMZDSPTTDVUUJOHDPODFSOT TPBOFOUJSFMZ EJﬀFSFOUNFUIPEJTOFFEFEUPBEESFTTPUIFSDPODFSOT %PNJOBOUWJFXTherFJT IPXFWFS BOJNQPSUBOURVFTUJPOUIBU"0%IBTSBJTFEXJUIUIFTZN NFUSJDoBTZNNFUSJDJTTVF BRVFTUJPOUIBUBQQMJFTUPWJFXTBTXFMMThe RVFTUJPOJT4IPVMEBOZWJFX CFDPOTJEFSFEBTUIFEPNJOBOUPSCBTFWJFX This JTBOBSFBUIBUOFFETGVSUIFSSFTFBSDI BOEJTEJT DVTTFEJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi/FFEGPS%PNJOBOU4USVDUVSFPS7JFXw*OUIFNFBOUJNF .04&4 EPFTOPUUBLFBQPTJUJPOPOJU FYDFQUBVUJMJUBSJBOPOFJGBNPEFMJOHTJUVBUJPOXPSLTCFUUFSXJUIB EPNJOBOUWJFX deﬁne POFJGJUXPSLTCFUUFSXJUIPVUBEPNJOBOUWJFX EPOPUdeﬁne BOZWJFXBT EPNJOBOU

Did Parnas Anticipate Features of Aspects? Parnas, in his famous decomposition criteria paper (1972, 1057), may have presaged or foreshadowed concepts that later became key elements of aspect-oriented programming. In his discussion of performance issues with his KWIC information hiding design (because it would cause many calls to the same Line Storage module), he said: “To save the procedure call overhead, yet gain the advantages that we have seen above, we must implement these modules in an unusual way. In many cases the routines will be best inserted into the code by an assembler; in other cases, highly specialized and efﬁcient transfers would be inserted. To successfully and efﬁciently make use of the second type of decomposition will require a tool by means of which programs may be written as if the functions were subroutines, but assembled by whatever implementation is appropriate. If such a technique is used, the separation between modules may not

264

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science be clear in the ﬁnal code. For that reason additional program modiﬁcation features would also be useful. In other words, the several representations of the program (which were mentioned earlier) must be maintained in the machine together with a program performing mapping between them.” We suggest that this description contains concepts that have some resemblance to weaving and other processes that were deﬁned 25 years later as features of aspect-oriented programming.

Duality, Deﬁnitions, Categories Yin and Yang: Duality, Contrast, Harmony $IBQUFS JOUSPEVDFE UIF QSJODJQMF PG SFDPODJMFE UFOTJPOT EVBMJUJFT DPOUSBTUT BOE QBSBEPYFT XIFSFPQQPTJOHBOETFFNJOHMZNVUVBMMZFYDMVTJWFDPODFQUTIBSNPOJPVTMZBOEFWFOTZOFSHJTUJDBMMZ DPFYJTUJOUIFTBNFFOUJUZThFDPOUSBTUJOHDPODFQUTSFUBJOUIFJSTFQBSBUFJEFOUJUJFTBOEDIBSBDUFS JTUJDTJOUIFFOUJUZ CVUCPUIDPOUSJCVUFUPVOJUZBOECBMBODFThJTTJUVBUJPOJTVCJRVJUPVTJOUIF XPSME JODMVEJOHJOUIFXPSMEPGTDJFODFBOEFOHJOFFSJOH5SBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHIBTFODPVOUFSFE BOEEFBMUXJUITVDIDPOUSBTUT CVUNPSFPGUFOJNQMJDJUMZUIBOFYQMJDJUMZThFOFFEGPSTDJFODFBOE NBUIUPEFBMXJUIDPNQMFYTZTUFNTPWFSUIFQBTUDFOUVSZIBTMFEUPVOBWPJEBCMFSFDPHOJUJPOPG NBOZ DPOUSBTUT BOE DPOUSBEJDUJPOT BOE UIFZ IBWF CFFO NBEF FYQMJDJU CVU OPU TP NVDI JO FOHJOFFSJOH "UPPMGPSSFDPODJMJOHDPOUSBTUT UFOTJPOT BOEQBSBEPYFTJTUIFDPODFQUPGWJFXTThJTIBTOPU CFFOSFDPHOJ[FEBTBUPPMGPSEFBMJOHXJUIDPOUSBEJDUJPOTJOFJUIFSTDJFODFPSFOHJOFFSJOH CVUXF QSPQPTFUIBUJUJTBOBUVSBMUPPMGPSCPUI$PNQMFYTZTUFNTBSFBMPDVTOPUPOMZGPSNBOZDPOUSBTUT BOEQBSBEPYFT CVUBMTPGPSUIFJSSFTPMVUJPOThJTTFDUJPOEJTDVTTFT XJUIBGFXFYBNQMFT IPXWJFXT BSFBOJNQPSUBOU FWFODSVDJBM UPPMJOUIFIBSNPOJ[JOHPGDPOUSBTUTBOEEVBMJUJFT *OFBDIDPOUSBTUJOUIFGPMMPXJOHMJTU UIFDPOUSBTUJOHJUFNTDBOCFSFQSFTFOUFEBTWJFXTPGB DPNNPOXIPMF O 5PQEPXOBOECPUUPNVQ O %JTDSFUF BOE DPOUJOVPVT EJTDVTTFE JO UIJT DIBQUFS JO UIF TFDUJPO FOUJUMFE i7JFXT JO #SPBEFS$POUFYUw

O 4JNQMJDJUZBOEDPNQMFYJUZ NVDIIBTCFFOXSJUUFOBCPVUUIJTDPOUSBTU XIJDIJTBHSFBU JMMVTUSBUJPOPGUIFZJOBOEZBOHQSJODJQMFTGPSFYBNQMF TFF$PIFOBOE4UFXBSU<>

O 0SEFSBOEEJTPSEFS DIBPTJTUIFSFDPODJMFSIFSF

O %FUFSNJOJTUJDBOEQSPCBCJMJTUJD O 3BOEPNBOEQSFEJDUBCMF O $POUSPMMFEBOEBVUPOPNPVTPSTFMGPSHBOJ[JOH O )PNFPTUBUJDBOEBEBQUJWF O 4UBCJMJUZBOEDIBOHF TFFEJTDVTTJPOPGQBOBSDIZJO$IBQUFS

O 6OJUZBOEWBSJFUZ O 0OFBOENBOZ XIPMFBOEQBSUBTZTUFNJTPOF BOEJTNBOZQBSUT O 3FMBUJWFBOEBCTPMVUF O (FOFSBMBOETQFDJﬁD O *OTUBODFBOEDBUFHPSZ O "CTUSBDUBOEDPODSFUF

Views O

265

O "CTUSBDUBOEJOUFSQSFUFE O $POUFYUTFOTJUJWFBOEDPOUFYUHFOFSBMJ[FE O 1VSFBOEJNQVSFOBUVSF BOEBSUJﬁDJBMTZTUFNT OFFETJNQVSJUJFT'SPN.FSLMF .BLJOHDPNQVUFSTIJHIMJHIUTBOPUIFSQSPCMFN*UTOPUFOPVHIUPNBLFBQVSFDSZTUBM JU NVTUBMTPIBWFBOFYUSFNFMZQSFDJTFBOEDPNQMFYQBUUFSOPGJNQVSJUJFT O 3PCVTUBOEGSBHJMF $BSMTPOBOE%PZMF iThJTASPCVTUZFUGSBHJMFGFBUVSFJTDIBSBD UFSJTUJDPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNTUISPVHIPVUFOHJOFFSJOHBOECJPMPHZw O 1SBDUJDFBOEUIFPSZ O 0CTFSWBUJPOBOEUIFPSZ O &TTFODFBOEBDDJEFOUPOQVSQPTFBOEBDDJEFOUBMPSSBOEPNEBNBHJOHBDDJEFOUTPSFSSPST BOETFSFOEJQJUPVTBDDJEFOUTPSFSSPST FH NVUBUJPOJOBEBQUBUJPO FWPMVUJPO

O 4UBOEBMPOFBOEJOUFSBDUJWF O /FWFSFOEJOHDIBOHFBOEDZDMFCJSUIEFBUI TUBSUFOEFWPMVUJPOFNCSBDFTCPUIBUWBSJ PVTTDBMFT ThFDMBTTJDQSPUPUZQJDBMFYBNQMFPGUIFDPODFQUPGTJNVMUBOFPVTMZFNCSBDJOHDPOUSBTUTJTZJO BOEZBOH"MUIPVHIUIFDPOUSBTUJOHDPODFQUT ZJOBOEZBOH BSFPQQPTJUFT UIFZDPFYJTUJOIBS NPOZ BSFJOUFSEFQFOEFOU BOEDPOUJOVBMMZDIBOHFGSPNPOFJOUPUIFPUIFSJOBXBZUIBUNBJOUBJOT PWFSBMMCBMBODFThFQSJODJQMFTPGZJOBOEZBOHBQQFBSUPCFBHPPENPEFMPGUIFDPOUSBTUTUIBU FYJTUJODPNQMFYTZTUFNT )BSNPOJ[JOHJTBOBQQSPBDIUIBUPOPOFIBOEBDLOPXMFEHFTBOENPEFMTUIFPQQPTJOHDIBS BDUFSJTUJDTJOBOFOUJUZ BOEPOUIFPUIFSIBOENPEFMTUIFJSNVUVBMJUZBOESPMFJOUIFVOJUZPG UIFFOUJUZ5BCMFTIPXTBGFXFYBNQMFTXIFSFDPNQMFYTZTUFNTBSFTPNFUJNFTEFTDSJCFEBTB TJNQMFDPOUSBTUXJUIUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNT CVUUIFNPSFDPNQMFUFBOTXFSJTBIBSNPOZBOECBMBODF PGUIFUXPPQQPTJUFT "OFYBNQMFUIBUSFﬂFDUTTFWFSBMDPOUSBTUTJOPOFQBDLBHFJTUIFDPNQBSJTPOPGTFMGPSHBOJ[FE DSJUJDBMJUZ 40$ XJUI IJHIMZ PQUJNJ[FE UPMFSBODF )05 HJWFO JO $BSMTPO BOE %PZMF 4PNFPGUIFDPOUSBTUJOHWBSJBCMFTJOUIFDPNQBSJTPOQSPﬁMFTBSFSPCVTUOFTT UIFDSJUJDBMQPJOUJT TUBCMFJO40$ CVUTZTUFNTJOUIF)05NPEFMBSFiSPCVTU ZFUGSBHJMF wBNBKPSUIFNFJO)05 UIFOVNCFSPGEFTJHOEFHSFFTPGGSFFEPN TNBMMJO40$ WFSZMBSHFJO)05 BOEUIFNFDIBOJTN GPSQPXFSMBXT JO40$ QPXFSMBXTBSFBTJHOBUVSFPGBOJOUFSOBMTFMGTVTUBJOJOHDSJUJDBMTUBUFJO )05 QPXFSMBXTBSFBTZNQUPNPGUIFSPCVTUGSBHJMFDPOEJUJPOSFTVMUJOHGSPNUVOJOHNVMUJQMF WBSJBCMFT ThFBSUJDMFBEWPDBUFT)05PWFS40$BOEDMBJNTUIBUSFBMTZTUFNTNBUDIUIF)05 QSPﬁMFSBUIFSUIBO40$ 0VSQVSQPTFJTOPUUPXFJHIJOPOUIFEFCBUFEJSFDUMZCVUSBUIFSUPDPOKFDUVSFUIBU40$ BOE)05SFQSFTFOUUXPEJﬀFSFOUBOEDPNQMFNFOUBSZNPEFMJOHWJFXT BUMFBTUGPSTPNFPGUIF WBSJBCMFTVTFEGPSDPNQBSJTPO8FEJTDVTTUIJTQPJOUVTJOHPOFWBSJBCMFUIFTJNJMBSJUZPGQBSUT JOUIFJOUFSOBMDPOﬁHVSBUJPOThF40$WJFXJTUIBUQBSUTBSFIPNPHFOFPVTBOETFMGTJNJMBSBU EJﬀFSFOU TDBMFT ThF )05 WJFX JT UIBU QBSUT BSF FYUSFNFMZ IFUFSPHFOFPVT BOE TFMGEJTTJNJMBS FTQFDJBMMZBDSPTTTDBMFT8FIBWFQPJOUFEPVUJOUIFCPPLUIBUCPUIWJFXTBSFOFFEFEJOUIFUPUBM QJDUVSF4&TFFLTUPFYQMPJUTJNJMBSJUJFTXJUIJOBOEBDSPTTTDBMFT XIJMFSFDPHOJ[JOHBOEBDDPVOU JOHGPSEJﬀFSFODFT ,PTLP BEWPDBUFT GV[[Z UIJOLJOH BT B UPPM GPS EFBMJOH XJUI DPOUSBEJDUJPOT BOE QBSB EPYFT8FXJMMJMMVTUSBUFXJUIBGPSNPGUIFMJBSTQBSBEPY4UBUFNFOU"iThJTTUBUFNFOUJTGBMTFw "DDPSEJOHUPUIFMBXPGUIFFYDMVEFENJEEMF FJUIFS"JTUSVFPSJUJTGBMTF8IJDIJTJU *GXFBTTVNF JUUPCFUSVF UIFOJUUVSOTPVUUPCFGBMTF*GXFBTTVNFJUUPCFGBMTF UIFOJUUVSOTPVUUPCFUSVF )PXEPXFSFTPMWFUIJT

266

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Table 10.3 Examples of Harmonizing Traditional and Complex Dualities Traditional

Complex

Harmony/Balance

Order Simple Top down Control

Disorder Complex Bottom up Autonomy, laissez faire

Avoid change

Encourage change

Both coexist Both coexist Both: back and forth, opportunistic Both: arrangement, inﬂuence, higher-order patterns Both: ﬁnd and exploit stability, ﬁnd and exploit change, use stability to guide change Analyze both whole and parts

Reductionism: Analyze Emergence: Analyze parts whole Pure dictatorship/ Pure democracy/ one over all everyone is equal Avoid risk, even if it Embrace opportunity, arises from signiﬁcant even if it entails opportunity signiﬁcant risk Do what we know Try something new

Everyone has a voice, but leadership arises, emerges, sanctioned by the group; a few are leaders, many are followers Risk and opportunity; evaluate appropriate balance Explicitly trade off the two; or sometimes do a combination of both; or do both in parallel and see which works out better. In situations where a binary choice must be made, having the perspective, the sense, the awareness, the gestalt, to know which to pick is an important kind of knowledge or intuition. This is a universal trade-off.

O ThFGV[[ZBOTXFS3FNPWFUIFMBXPGUIFFYDMVEFENJEEMF BOEBMMPX"BOEOPU"5BLF UIJTGVSUIFSBOETBZ"OPU" XIJDISFTVMUTJOUIFBOTXFS"JTIBMGUSVFBOEIBMGGBMTF O ThFZJOZBOHBOTXFS3FNPWFUIFMBXPGUIFFYDMVEFENJEEMF BOEBMMPX"BOEOPU"" JTCPUIUSVFBOEGBMTF O ThFWJFXTBOTXFSBOBVHNFOUFEZJOZBOHBOTXFSThFRVFTUJPOJTOPUIBSNPOJ[FEJO BOJOUFHSBUFETFOTFJUSFNBJOTBQBSBEPY#VUJUJTSFTPMWFEJOBTFQBSBUFETFOTF"JTDPN QMFUFMZUSVFJOPOFWJFX BOEDPNQMFUFMZGBMTFJOBOPUIFSWJFX The .04&4QPTJUJPOJTUIBUGV[[ZUIJOLJOHBOEGV[[ZMPHJDIBWFBOJNQPSUBOUQMBDFJOTZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH FTQFDJBMMZJOTQFDJGZJOHDPOUJOVPVTSBOHFTJOTUFBEPGEJTDSFUFEJTUJODUJPOTThat NFBOT UIBU GV[[Z NFBTVSFT NBZ IBWF B SPMF JO BEEJUJPO UP WJFXT JO BEESFTTJOH NBOZ PG UIF DPOUSBTUT MJTUFEBCPWFCFDBVTFGFXPGUIFNBSFQBSBEPYFT#VUSFTPMWJOHQBSBEPYFTJTOPUBOBQQSPQSJBUFSPMF GPSGV[[ZUIJOLJOH5PTBZUIBUBQBSBEPYJDBMTUBUFNFOUJTIBMGUSVFBOEIBMGGBMTFJTOPUBTBUJTGZJOH SFTQPOTFJOUIFXBZUIBUMFHJUJNBUFBQQMJDBUJPOTPGGV[[ZNFBTVSFTBSF GPSFYBNQMF TBZJOHUIBU TPNFPOFJTIBMGUBMMBOEIBMGTIPSU PSBHMBTTJTIBMGGVMMBOEIBMGFNQUZ $POUSBEJDUJPOTBOEEVBMJUJFTFYJTUOPUPOMZJO$4 CVUBMTPJO54)FSFJTBOFYBNQMFPGB54 EVBMJUZ"TTVNFUIBUUIFXIFFMIBTOPUZFUCFFOJOWFOUFE BOEXFXBOUUPXSJUFBSFRVJSFNFOUT

Views O

267

TQFD GPS UIF XIFFM *U DPVME SFBTPOBCMZ MPPL TPNFUIJOH MJLF UIJT BTTVNJOH XF deﬁned iSPBEw TVJUBCMZ 8IFFMTIBMMNPWFSFMBUJWFUPSPBE 8IFFMTIBMMOPUNPWFSFMBUJWFUPSPBE *GUIFFOHJOFFSTPGUIFEBZIBEMPPLFEBUUIJT UIFZQSPCBCMZXPVMEIBWFTBJEiThJTJTPCWJPVTMZ JNQPTTJCMFwThJTTQFDDPVMEIBWFEFMBZFEUIFJOWFOUJPOPGUIFXIFFMCZDFOUVSJFT'PSUVOBUFMZ UIPTFXIPEJEJOWFOUUIFXIFFMEJEOPUSFBMJ[FUIFZXFSFEPJOHTPNFUIJOHUIBUXBTJNQPTTJCMF /PXBTXFMPPLCBDLPOUIFXIFFMBOEJUTEFTJHO XFDBOFYQMBJOUIFJNQPTTJCMFSFRVJSFNFOUTJO BXBZUIBUSFTPMWFTUIFDPOUSBEJDUJPO 8IFFMTIBMMNPWFSFMBUJWFUPSPBEUIFXIFFMSPUBUFT NPWFTBTBXIPMF ThFJOOFSIVC PGUIFXIFFMTBUJTﬁFTUIJTSFRVJSFNFOU NPWJOHJOBMJOFQBSBMMFMXJUIUIFHSPVOE XIJDI JTXIFSFUIFBYMFﬁUTBOEDPOOFDUTUPUIFXIFFMPOUIFPUIFSTJEF BOEUIJTTVQQPSUTUIF WFIJDMF XIJDINPWFTBMPOHUIFSPBE 8IFFMTIBMMOPUNPWFSFMBUJWFUPSPBEThFXIFFMTIPVMEOPUTMJEFPOUIFSPBEUIFSFNVTU CFGSJDUJPO HSJQThFPVUFSFEHFPGUIFXIFFMTBUJTﬁFTUIJTSFRVJSFNFOUFBDIQPSUJPOPGUIF FEHF XIFOJODPOUBDUXJUIUIFSPBE HSJQTUIFSPBEBOEEPFTOPUNPWF

Deﬁnitions 8FIBWFJOGPSNBMMZEFﬁOFEWJFXBOESFMBUFEDPODFQUTFBSMJFSJOUIFDIBQUFS/PXXFQSFTFOUUIF GVMMTFUPGEFﬁOJUJPOT8FQSPQPTFUIBUUIFGPMMPXJOHFMFNFOUTFYJTUJODPOOFDUJPOXJUIFWFSZWJFX \WJFXQPJOU PCKFDUPSUBSHFU PCTFSWFSPSBHFOU TFMFDUPSPSJOUFSQSFUFSPSBCTUSBDUPS BCTUSBDUJPOPS WJFX^8FOPXFYQMBJOFBDIFMFNFOU O 7JFXQPJOUBTQBDFUJNFSFHJPO OPUKVTUBQPJOUDBOCFQIZTJDBMPSDPODFQUVBM UIBUSFQSF TFOUTBQPTJUJPOGSPNXIJDIUIFUBSHFUJTPCTFSWFE&YBNQMFFYUFSOBMWJFXPG%CMPDLJT PCTFSWFEGSPNWJFXQPJOU\JOTJEFB%TQIFSFTVSSPVOEJOHUIFCMPDLJOBUJNFSBOHFPS UJNFQPJOU^ O 5BSHFUTZTUFNPSPUIFSFOUJUZUIBUJTCFJOHPCTFSWFEPSWJFXFEThFUBSHFUNBZUBLFUIF GPSNPGBEFﬁOFEXPSMEThFSFDBOCFNVMUJQMFWJFXTPGBUBSHFU5XPDPNNPOUBSHFUTBSF BTQFDJﬁDTZTUFNUIBUFYJTUTPSUIBUXFQMBOUPCVJME BOE BMMQPTTJCMFTZTUFNTUIBU DPSSFTQPOEUPUIFNPEFM JF UIFNPEFMSFHJPO O 0CTFSWFSQFSTPOPSPUIFSBHFOUUIBUPCTFSWFTUIFUBSHFU QPTTJCMZXJUIUIFBJEPGTVQQPSU JOHUPPMTPSBHFOUTTVDIBT GPSQIZTJDBMUBSHFUT UFMFTDPQF NJDSPTDPQF UIFSNPNFUFS TFO TPS QSPCF DBNFSB N 7JFXPCTFSWFSTBHFOUTEPNPSFUIBOKVTUTFFUIFWJFXThFZEFﬁOFUIFWJFX UIFWJFX QPJOU UIFPCKFDU BOETFSWFBTTFMFDUPS JOUFSQSFUFS PSBCTUSBDUPS4PWJFXPCTFSWFST HPCFZPOE BOEBSFNPSFBDUJWFUIBO TZTUFNPCTFSWFSTEFﬁOFSTThFZBSFBTBDUJWFBT NPEFMEFﬁOFSTPCTFSWFST N *UJTTPNFUJNFTVTFGVMUPEJTUJOHVJTIBOBDUJWFBHFOUTVDIBTBIVNBOGSPNBQBTTJWF PCTFSWFSTVDIBTBTFOTPS FH BUIFSNPNFUFS N 4PGUXBSFDBOCFBOBHFOU BOEDBOSBOHFGSPNQBTTJWFUPBDUJWF

268

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O "CTUSBDUPSBGVODUJPOUIBUTFMFDUTJOGPGSPNUIFUBSHFUUPJODMVEFJOUIFWJFX PSEFﬁOFT IPXUBSHFUJOGPSNBUJPOJTJOUFSQSFUFEJOUIFWJFX O "CTUSBDUJPOPSWJFXXIBUUIFPCTFSWFSiTFFTwCZBQQMZJOHBCTUSBDUPSUPUBSHFUGSPNWJFXQPJOU 0UIFSFMFNFOUTFYJTUJOUIFDPOUFYUPGBWJFX"OJNQPSUBOUPOFJTWJFXUZQF*OUIF.04&4 SFDPNNFOEFE BQQSPBDI UIF WJFX JO UIF TFU PG FMFNFOUT BCPWF JT BO JOTUBODF PG B WJFX UZQF )PXFWFS XFEJEOPUJODMVEFJUJOUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPGWJFXCFDBVTFJUJTOPUQBSUPGBOZJOEJWJEVBM WJFX7JFXUZQFJTQBSUPGUIFTVQQPSUJOHDPOUFYU

Categories of Views 8FIBWFEJTDVTTFEBTJHOJﬁDBOUOVNCFSPGFYBNQMFTPGWJFXTJOUIJTDIBQUFS*TUIFSFBXBZXFDBO DMBTTJGZUIFN "QSFMJNJOBSZTFUPGDBUFHPSJFTJTTIPXOJO'JHVSF ThFTFQBSBUFDPNQPOFOUDBUFHPSZJTPOFJOXIJDIXFGPDVTPOPOFFMFNFOUPGBHSPVQPGFMF NFOUT TVDIBTBTZTUFNPGJOUFSFTUThFDPNQPOFOUUZQFWJFXJTXIFSFUIFTBNFTQBDF TVDIBTBO JOUFSOBMNPEFMPGBTZTUFN DBODPOTJTUPGEJﬀFSFOUDPNQPOFOUTBOEDPOOFDUPSTPSEJﬀFSFOUMFWFMT PGBCTUSBDUJPO TVDIBTQIZTJDBMBOEMPHJDBMWJFXT PSUIF3.0%1DPNQVUBUJPOBMWFSTVTFOHJOFFS JOHWJFXQPJOUT PSBMUFSOBUJWFEFDPNQPTJUJPOT EFTJHOT PGBTZTUFN ThF DSPTTDVUUJOHQBSU DBUFHPSZ JT B EPNJOBOU UZQF BOE NPUJWBUPS PG UIF OFFE GPS WJFXT *U SFQSFTFOUTTJUVBUJPOTTVDIBTXIFSFDPNNPOFMFNFOUTFYJTUJOHJOEJﬀFSFOUDPNQPOFOUTPSTZTUFNT BSF CSPVHIU UPHFUIFS JOUP B WJFX " DMBTTJD FYBNQMF PG UIJT UZQF JT BO BTQFDUJOBTQFDU PSJFOUFE

System

Separate component

Component type (diﬀerent internal system models)

Cross-cutting–part of each component (aspect)

Cross-cutting–emergent

Subset = in view

Figure 10.5

Categories or types of views.

Component

Views O

269

EFWFMPQNFOUThFDSPTTDVUUJOHFNFSHFOUDBUFHPSZJTXIFSFBWJFXPCTFSWFTBOFNFSHFOUQSPQFSUZ PSPUIFSDIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGBXIPMF TFQBSBUFGSPNUIFQBSUTGSPNXIJDIJUDBNFThFTVCTFUWJFXJT BWFSZTJNQMFDBUFHPSZFYFNQMJﬁFECZBEBUBCBTFWJFX.PSFSFTFBSDIJTOFFEFEPOWJFXDBUFHPSJFT BTEJTDVTTFEJOUIFTVCTFRVFOUTFDUJPO

Areas for Additional Research Integration ThFOFFEFESFTFBSDIJTPONBUIFNBUJDBMSFQSFTFOUBUJPOTBOENBOJQVMBUJPOTPGWJFXTUIBUTVQQPSU JOUFHSBUJPOPGWJFXT0OFQPTTJCMFBQQSPBDIJTUPVTFUIFNBUIFNBUJDBMNPEFMPGVOMJNJUFEEJNFO TJPOTDBMMFEBQPMZUPQF4PNFXPSLIBTCFFOEPOFUPDBQUVSFEJﬀFSFOUWJFXTBTQBSUPGUIJTEBUB TUSVDUVSF #BLFS . ThJTDPVMECFBWFIJDMFGPSJOUFHSBUJOHWJFXT

Need for Dominant Structure or View Th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diﬀerFOUTUSVDUVSFTPSWJFXT BOEOPOFPG UIFWJFXTJTEPNJOBOU *GTP JTBOZPOFJODIBSHF %PFTBOZPOFOFFEUPCFJODIBSHF

View Categories 8FJEFOUJﬁFETPNFQPTTJCMFDBUFHPSJFTPGWJFXT#VUBMBSHFOVNCFSPGQPTTJCMFWBSJBCMFTDPVMECF VTFEJOEFDJEJOHDPNNPODBUFHPSJFTThFSFJTBOFFEGPSSFTFBSDIUIBUFYQMPSFTXIBUDBUFHPSJFTBSF HPPEDBOEJEBUFTGPSDPNNPOWJFXUZQFTUIFDPNNVOJUZXPVMEﬁOEVTFGVM BOEUIFXBZTJOXIJDI WJFXUZQFTDPVMECFFYUFOEFE4PNFPUIFSWBSJBCMFTBOEBTQFDUTUPCFDPOTJEFSFEJOEJﬀFSFOUJBUJOH WJFXTJODMVEFMFWFMT TDBMFT GPDVT SFTPMVUJPO NPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOT JOUFSQSFUBUJPO SFQSFTFOUB UJPO ﬁFMEPGWJFX SPMFPGPCTFSWFSBHFOUJOTIBQJOHXIBUJTTFFO UIFQPTTJCJMJUZPGBEEJOHJOGPSNB UJPO OPUKVTUTVCUSBDUJOH BCTUSBDUJOH JU BOENFUBJOGPSNBUJPOJOBWJFX

Summary ThFGPMMPXJOHGFBUVSFTPGWJFXTXFSFEJTDVTTFEJOUIJTDIBQUFS O ThFDPODFQUPGWJFXJTIJHIMy ﬂFYJCMFBOEIBTTJHOJﬁDBOUQPUFOUJBMGPSGVUVSF4& O 7JFXTDBOFYJTUXJUIJOBNPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOPSDVUBDSPTTEJNFOTJPOT O *O B DPNQPTJUJPO IJFSBSDIZ WJFXT DBO GPDVT PO TJNJMBSJUJFT PG MFWFMT PS PO EJﬀFSFODFT CFUXFFOMFWFMT O 7JFXTDBOCFOFTUFE

270 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O 4ZTUFNCFIBWJPSBOETZTUFNDIBOHFDBOCFSFHBSEFEBTEJTKPJOUBDUJWJUJFT BTJO54&PSBT UXPWJFXTPGBTZTUFN BTJO$4 O %FﬁOFEXPSMETBSFWJFXT O "O40*JTBWJFXBOEIBTTFWFSBMDPNNPOMZBTTPDJBUFEWJFXT O %JﬀFSFOUBSFBTPGTDJFODFDPOTJEFSEJﬀFSFOUWJFXTPGUIFTBNFPWFSBMMXPSME O 7JFXTDBOIFMQSFTPMWFUIFDPNQFUJOHIJFSBSDIJFTQSPCMFN O "SDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLTIBWFQVUGPSXBSEBWBSJFUZPGWJFXT"T4&NBUVSFT DPOWFOUJPOBM TFUTPGWJFXTXJMMMJLFMZFNFSHF O ThFDPODFQUPGMBZFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSFDBOCFJMMVNJOBUFECZWJFXTBOEUIFJEFBPGMFWFSBHF O 7JFXTDBOIFMQBEESFTTUIFMJNJUTPGNPEVMBSJUZGBDJOHUIFBTQFDUPSJFOUFEEFWFMPQNFOU DPNNVOJUZ O 7JFXTBSFBOBUVSBMXBZPGEFBMJOHXJUIEVBMJUJFTBOEDPOUSBTUTUIBUBSFBQSPNJOFOUDIBS BDUFSJTUJDPG$4BOEUPTPNFFYUFOU54 O " QSFMJNJOBSZ TFU PG DBUFHPSJFT PS UZQFT PG WJFXT JT PﬀFSFE CVU B NPSF NBUVSF TFU XJMM FNFSHFGSPNBDPNCJOBUJPOPGSFTFBSDIBOEQSBDUJDF

References "MFYBOEFS $The 5JNFMFTT8BZPG#VJMEJOH/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT "MFYBOEFS $ 4 *TIJLBXB . 4JMWFSTUFJO . +BDPCTPO * 'JLTEBIM,JOH BOE 4 "OHFM " 1BUUFSO -BOHVBHF5PXOTo#VJMEJOHTo$POTUSVDUJPO/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT "STBOKBOJ "4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOHBOE"SDIJUFDUVSF)PXUP*EFOUJGZ 4QFDJGZ BOE3FBMJ[F4FSWJDFT GPS ZPVS 40" *#. /PWFNCFS IUUQXXXJCNDPNEFWFMPQFSXPSLTXFCTFSWJDFTMJCSBSZXTTPB EFTJHO "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#BLFS 4.BUI8JMM3PDL:PVS8PSME#VTJOFTT8FFL+BOVBSZIUUQXXXCVTJOFTTXFFLDPNQEG .BUIFEVDBUJPOBMFQSJOUQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#FMM .4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH4FSWJDF"OBMZTJT %FTJHO BOE"SDIJUFDUVSF)PCPLFO /++PIO8JMFZ 4POT $BSMTPO +BOE+%PZMF)JHIMZPQUJNJ[FEUPMFSBODFBNFDIBOJTNGPSQPXFSMBXTJOEFTJHOFETZTUFNT 1IZT3FW &o $#%*$#%*4FSWJDF"SDIJUFDUVSF&OHJOFFSJOH.FUB.PEFMGPS40"IUUQXXXDCEJGPSVNDPN QVCMJDNFUB@NPEFM@WQIQ "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

$MFNFOUT 1FUBM%PDVNFOUJOH4PGUXBSF"SDIJUFDUVSFT7JFXTBOE#FZPOE#PTUPO .""EEJTPO8FTMFZ $PIFO +BOE*4UFXBSUThe $PMMBQTFPG$IBPT%JTDPWFSJOH4JNQMJDJUZJOB$PNQMFY8PSME/FX:PSL 1FOHVJO1SFTT %P%"'%FQBSUNFOUPG%FGFOTF %P%"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSL 7FSTJPOWPMVNFT"QSJM '&"'FEFSBM&OUFSQSJTF"SDIJUFDUVSF0.#IUUQXXXBSNZNJMBSNZ#5,$FOBCMFSTQNGFBIUN "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

(&3".(&3".(FOFSBMJ[FE&OUFSQSJTF3FGFSFODF"SDIJUFDUVSFBOE.FUIPEPMPHZ 7FSTJPO ª*'*1*'"$5BTL'PSDFPO"SDIJUFDUVSFTGPS&OUFSQSJTF*OUFHSBUJPO .BSDI )BHFOCP . The /"50 BSDIJUFDUVSF GSBNFXPSL 40" 4FSWJDF 0SJFOUFE "SDIJUFDUVSF WJFXT "QSJMIUUQXXXBGFJPSHCSPDIVSFBEPDVNFOUT)BHFOCP@QQU "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)BSSJTPO 8 ) 0TTIFS BOE 15BSS "TZNNFUSJDBMMZ WT 4ZNNFUSJDBMMZ 0SHBOJ[FE 1BSBEJHNT GPS 4PGUXBSF$PNQPTJUJPO*#.3FTFBSDI3FQPSU3$ *#.3FTFBSDI%JWJTJPO :PSLUPXO)FJHIUT /: %FDFNCFS IUUQEPNJOPXBUTPOJCNDPNMJCSBSZDZCFSEJHOTGBFE DGDBEBD 0QFO%PDVNFOU "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)BXLJOH 4"#SJFG)JTUPSZPG5JNF'SPNUIF#JH#BOHUP#MBDL)PMFT/FX:PSL#BOUBN#PPLT )BXLJOH 4The IMMVTUSBUFE"#SJFG)JTUPSZPG5JNF6QEBUFEBOEFYQBOEFEFE/FX:PSL#BOUBN#PPLT )FDLNBOO % 5 4DIXBSU[ # #SBOEIFSN . 4DINJU[ BOE . WPO 8JMBNPXJU[.oellendorﬀ. (6.0 The (FOFSBM 6TFS .PEFM 0OUPMPHZ JO 1SPDFFEJOHT PG 6. *OU $POG PO 6TFS .PEFMJOH +VMZo &EJOCVSHI 6,

Views O

271

)POEFSJDI 5 FE The OYGPSE$PNQBOJPOUP1IJMPTPQIZ/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT *&&&*&&&3FDPNNFOEFE1SBDUJDFGPS4PGUXBSF%FTJHO%FTDSJQUJPOT*&&&/FX:PSL*&&& $PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ *&&&*&&&3FDPNNFOEFE1SBDUJDFGPS"SDIJUFDUVSBM%FTDSJQUJPOPG4PGUXBSF*OUFOTJWF4ZTUFNT *&&&4UE 4FQU /FX:PSL*&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ *&&&*&&&4UBOEBSEGPS"QQMJDBUJPOBOE.BOBHFNFOUPGUIF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH1SPDFTT *&&&4UE /FX:PSL*&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ */$04& */$04& 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH )BOECPPL W 4FBUUMF 8" */$04& *OUFSOBUJPOBM $PVODJMPO4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH ,JD[BMFT (FUBMi"TQFDU0SJFOUFE1SPHSBNNJOH w1SPDPG&VS$POG0CKFDU0SJFOUFE1SPHSBNNJOH &$001

-/$4 4QSJOHFS Qo ,PTLP #'uzzy Thinking: The NFX4DJFODFPG'V[[Z-PHJD/FX:PSL)ZQFSJPO ,ossiakoﬀ, " BOE8/4XFFU4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH1SJODJQMFTBOE1SBDUJDF)PCPLFO /++PIO8JMFZ 4POT ,SVDIUFO 1. 1995. The 47JFX.PEFMPG"SDIJUFDUVSF *&&&4PGUXBSF o ,SVDIUFO 1The RBUJPOBM6niﬁed PSPDFTT SEFE#PTUPO ."1FBSTPO&EVDBUJPO ,VIO 5The 4USVDUVSFPGScientiﬁc 3FWPMVUJPOT OEFEFOMBSHFE$IJDBHP *-6OJWFSTJUZPG$IJDBHP 1SFTT -BOLIPSTU . &OUFSQSJTF "SDIJUFDUVSF "U8PSL .PEFMJOH $PNNVOJDBUJPOT BOE "OBMZTJT /FX:PSL 4QSJOHFS .FSLMF 3 .PMFDVMBS .BOVGBDUVSJOH "EEJOH 1PTJUJPOBM $POUSPM UP $IFNJDBM 4ZOUIFTJT 9FSPY $PSQIUUQXXX[ZWFYDPNOBOPUFDI$%"BSUJDMFIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

.0%"' .0%"' .FUB .PEFM 7 IUUQXXXNPEBGPSHVLN "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

/"'/"50"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSL7FSTJPO/"50&"1$+VMZ 0"4*43FGFSFODF.PEFMGPS4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE"SDIJUFDUVSF0"4*44UBOEBSE0DUIUUQEPDT PBTJTPQFOPSHTPBSNW "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0CSTU - BOE % /JDIPMT $POUFYU BOE 0OUPMPHJFT $POUFYUVBM *OEFYJOH PG 0OUPMPHJDBM &YQSFTTJPOT .*53&5FDIOJDBM1BQFS +VMZIUUQXXXNJUSFPSHXPSLUFDI@QBQFSTUFDI@QBQFST@@ JOEFYIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

1BSOBT %0OUIFDSJUFSJBUPCFVTFEJOEFDPNQPTJOHTZTUFNTJOUPNPEVMFT$PNNVO"$. o 3.0%1 0QFO %JTUSJCVUFE 1SPDFTTJOH 3FGFSFODF .PEFM 1BSU 'PVOEBUJPOT *OUFSOBUJPOBM 4UBOEBSE *565 3FDPNNFOEBUJPO 9 1BSU "SDIJUFDUVSF *OUFSOBUJPOBM 4UBOEBSE *5653FDPNNFOEBUJPO9 4FQU 4BHF "BOE$$VQQBO0OUIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHBOENBOBHFNFOUPGTZTUFNTPGTZTUFNTBOEGFE FSBUJPOTPGTZTUFNT*OGPSNBUJPO ,OPXMFEHF BOE4ZTUFNT.BOBHFNFOUo 4DIFLLFSNBO +)PXUP4VSWJWFJOUIF+VOHMFPG&OUFSQSJTF"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSLT$SFBUJOHPS$IPPTJOH BO&OUFSQSJTF"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSL7JDUPSJB #$5raﬀorE1VCMJTIJOH 4PXB +BOE+;BDINBO&YUFOEJOHBOEGPSNBMJ[JOHUIFGSBNFXPSLGPSJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTBSDIJUFD UVSF*#.4ZTUFNT+ o 5BSS 1 ) 0TTIFS 8 )BSSJTPO BOE 4 4VUUPO +S / %FHSFFT PG 4FQBSBUJPO .VMUJ%JNFOTJPOBM 4FQBSBUJPOPG$PODFSOT*O1SPDTU*OU$POGPO4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH Qo .BZ 50("'The 0QFO(SPVQ"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSL7FSTJPO &OUFSQSJTF&EJUJPOIUUQXXX PQFOHSPVQPSHBSDIJUFDUVSFUPHBGEPDBSDI "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

61%.61%.(SPVQIUUQVQENHSPVQPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

7BMFSEJ 3 "3PTT BOE%3IPEFT"GSBNFXPSLGPSFWPMWJOHTZTUFNPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH $SPTT5BML The +PVSOBMPG%FGFOTF4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH 0DUPCFSQoIUUQXXXTUTDIJMMBGNJM$SPTTUBM L7BMFSEJ3PTT3IPEFTIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

;BDINBO +"GSBNFXPSLGPSJOGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTBSDIJUFDUVSF*#.4ZTUFNT+ o

;BDINBO*OUFSOBUJPOBMThF;BDINBO&OUFSQSJTF'SBNFXPSLIUUQXXX[BDINBOJOUFS OBUJPOBMDPNJOEFYQIQUIF[BDINBOGSBNFXPSL "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

Chapter 11

Speciﬁcation Information Systems taxonomy 1

Modeling scope

SE Application Domains (D1...Dn)

Collective actualization space

D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn

Problem space

3a

TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b Traditional Complex

Characteristics of all systems

Highest level system

Deﬁne need

Complex 4 Traditional TS is special case 5 Characteristics of all SE systems Traditional and Complex 6

Model Space

All SE application domains...

Indivisible Unit Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Composition

TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b 2a Traditional systems Complex systems

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

ThFBQQSPBDIUPTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTBTJHOJﬁDBOU FMFNFOUPG.04&4 BOEJTUIFTVCKFDUPGUIJT DIBQUFS,FZUPQJDTJODMVEFUIFDPNQMFYTZT UFNT FYQBOTJPO PG USBEJUJPOBM DBUFHPSJFT PG FYUFSOBM TQFDJﬁDBUJPOT UIF MJTU PG JOGPSNB UJPOUZQFTGPSFYUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDB UJPOTBOEUIFVTFPGQSPCBCJMJUZJOTQFDJGZJOH VODFSUBJOUZ

Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

e

m

Ti

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

Produce solution

Deployment

Satisfy need

Solution/system space

Introduction: Speciﬁcation Types and Structure *OQSFWJPVTDIBQUFST FTQFDJBMMZ$IBQUFS XFEJTDVTTFEFYUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBMNPEFMT BOEUIFJS JOUFSUXJOJOHTUSVDUVSFUIBUTVQQPSUTTDBMFVQBOETDBMFEPXOUISPVHIBSFQFBUJOHTFMGTJNJMBSQBU UFSO8FIBWFBMTP FTQFDJBMMZJO$IBQUFSTBOE EJTDVTTFEUIFDPODFQUTPGNPEFMWFSTVTTQFDJ ﬁDBUJPO EFDPVQMJOH BOEDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU*OUIJTDIBQUFSXFCVJMEPOUIFTFDPODFQUTBOEESJMM EPXOJOUPUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOUZQFTUPEFﬁOFUIFJOGPSNBUJPODPOUFOUPGFBDIUZQF ThJTDIBQUFSJTFOUJUMFEi4QFDJﬁDBUJPO*OGPSNBUJPOwJOTUFBEPGi.PEFM*OGPSNBUJPOwGPSUIF GPMMPXJOHSFBTPOJUBUUFNQUTUPEFﬁOFNPSFEFUBJMTPGUIFUZQFTPGJOGPSNBUJPOOFFEFEGPSTIBSFE VOEFSTUBOEJOHCFUXFFOQBSUJFTCVUJUEPFTOPUNBLFBOZTUBUFNFOUPSDPOTUSBJOUPOIPXNVDIPG UIJTJOGPSNBUJPOJTFYQMJDJUMZTUBUFEJOBNPEFM.VDIPGUIFJOGPSNBUJPOTQFMMFEPVUJOUIJTDIBQ UFSXJMMCFJNQMJDJUBOEXJMMOPUTIPXVQJONPEFMT FTQFDJBMMZBT4&CFDPNFTNPSFNBUVSF #FGPSFQSPDFFEJOHGVSUIFSPOUIJTQBUI XFNFOUJPOBOBMUFSOBUJWFEFﬁOJUJPOPGTQFDJﬁDBUJPO BTIBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGBDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU XIJDIJTBNPEFM. BNPEBMJUZ.1 BEFﬁOFE XPSME8 BOEBTZTUFN4 BTEFﬁOFEJO$IBQUFSThJTJTBVTFGVMEFﬁOJUJPOJODBTFTXIFSFBDPSSF TQPOEFODFTFUJTEFﬁOFE BOEUIFNPEBMJUZ UIFEFﬁOFEXPSME PSUIFTZTUFNJTTVCKFDUUPEJﬀFSJOH ThFFYQMJDJUJOGPSNBUJPONVTUCFHSFBUFSUIBO[FSP IPXFWFS*GJUJT[FSP UIFSFJTOPNPEFMXJUIXIJDIUPBTTPDJ BUFUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPO. ThFQSBDUJDBMNJOJNVNJTBOFYQMJDJUNPEFMOBNF

273

274

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

JOUFSQSFUBUJPOT*OUIFEJTDVTTJPOTJOUIJTDIBQUFSBOEUIJTCPPL XFVTFUIFﬁSTUEFﬁOJUJPOBTUIF EFGBVMU "CSJFGSFDBQPGUIFDPODFQUTGSPNQSFWJPVTDIBQUFSTUIBUXFVTFJOUIJTDIBQUFSTQFDJﬁDBUJPO UZQFT BOEUIFJSJOUFSUXJOJOHSFMBUJPO BSFEFSJWFEQSFEPNJOBOUMZGSPNUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFO TJPOThFUXPHFOFSBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOUZQFTBSFJOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBM"OJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGB TZTUFNJTBTFUPGSVMFTBCPVUUIFQBSUT DPNQPOFOUTBOEDPOOFDUPST UIBUBSFXJUIJOUIFTZTUFN UIFJSTUSVDUVSFBOEJOUFSBDUJPO BOEUIFTUVﬀ UIFZFYDIBOHF TVDIBTJOGPSNBUJPOPSHPPET"O FYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGBTZTUFNPSDPNQPOFOUJTBTFUPGSVMFTBCPVUUIFFYUFSOBMMZPCTFSWBCMF WJFXPGUIBUTZTUFNPSDPNQPOFOUThJTJODMVEFTPCTFSWBCMFTUVﬀ CFIBWJPS QPSUTPSJOUFSGBDFT BOE TFSWJDFT BTXFMMBTUIFJSPCTFSWBCMFQSPQFSUJFTPSRVBMJUJFT*OUIJTDIBQUFSXFFYQPTFUIFEFDPV QMJOHPGFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTGSPNUIFJOUFSGBDFTUIBUBSFBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIFN BTEFTDSJCFEJO $IBQUFSThFSFGPSF XFEFTDSJCFUISFFTFUTPGTQFDJﬁDBUJPODPOUFOUJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT FYUFS OBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT BOEJOUFSGBDFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT "T TIPXO JO 'JHVSF UIF SFMBUJPO CFUXFFO UIF UXP NBKPS TQFDJﬁDBUJPO UZQFT JT UIBU BO JOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGBTZTUFNJODMVEFTUIFFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTPGJUTDPNQPOFOUTBOEDPO OFDUPSTThFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTBOEJOUFSGBDFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTJTNBOZUPNBOZ XIJDIJTXIZUIFZBSFEFDPVQMFEBOFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOIBTNVMUJQMFJOUFSGBDFT BOEBOJOUFSGBDF TQFDJﬁDBUJPODBOCFVTFECZPSPﬀFSFECZNVMUJQMFFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT'JHVSFBMTPTIPXT BOPUIFSDPOWFOUJPOUIBUXFIBWFVTFEUISPVHIPVUNPTUPGUIFCPPLBOEXIJDIXFOPXNBLFNPSF FYQMJDJU*OUIFDPOOFDUJPOPOUPMPHZJO$IBQUFS XFEJTDVTTFEUIFFYDIBOHFPGTUVﬀ BOEUIFQPT TJCMFQFSGPSNBODFPGBTFSWJDF XIJDIBMTPJOWPMWFTBOFYDIBOHFPGTUVﬀThFUFSNJOPMPHZXFIBWF VTFE BOEDPOUJOVFUPVTFJOUIJTDIBQUFS JTUIBUPGUIFNPSFDPNQMJDBUFEDBTFPGBTFSWJDFCFJOH QFSGPSNFEBOETUVﬀ CFJOHFYDIBOHFEThFTIPSUIBOEUFSNT GSPN$IBQUFS iQSPWJEFTBTFSWJDFw

External = Black box view Internal = Clear box view

Internal speciﬁcation of A

A The internal speciﬁcation of a system (A) includes the external speciﬁcation of each of its components (B, ...) –or–

B r3

The architecture of a system (A) includes the requirements of each of its components (B, …)

N3

r1

N1

p1

Interface speciﬁcations of D

p3

p2

D

C

r7

p4 N4 r4

r5

N2

p5

E

r6

External speciﬁcation of D B, N3, D, etc. are one level of composition lower than A; this intertwining relation supports scaling to all composition levels

Figure 11.1 Internal, external, and interface speciﬁcations. (Source: Hybertson, D. Using a speciﬁcation approach to facilitate component testing. In Testing Commercial-off-the-Shelf Components and Systems, S. Beydeda and V. Gruhn, Eds. New York: Springer-Verlag, p. 213–237. 2005. Modiﬁed with permission of Springer Science + Business Media.)

Speciﬁcation Information

O 275

BOEiSFDFJWFTBTFSWJDFwSFGFSUPUIFTFBDUJPOTBOEFYDIBOHFT*ODBTFTXIFSFOPTFSWJDFJTCFJOH QFSGPSNFE UIFNFBOJOHEFGBVMUTTJNQMZUPUIFTUVﬀ CFJOHFYDIBOHFEThFTFSWJDFTUFSNJOPMPHZ JTOPUNFBOUUPJNQMZBSFTUSJDUJPOJOUIJTDIBQUFSPSCPPLUPTZTUFNTUIBUBEIFSFUPUIFTFSWJDF PSJFOUFEBSDIJUFDUVSF 40" TUZMF*UJT JOTUFBE NFBOUUPBQQMZUPUIFNPEFMTBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOT PGBMM4&TZTUFNT

Elements and Background of Approach A general source for the speciﬁcation approach described here is Szyperski (1998), as well as the general SOA approach to service speciﬁcations. An important element of achieving precision in speciﬁcation is a clear understanding of dependencies. Traditional systems speciﬁcations deﬁne what services or stuff are provided but not what are required. Luckham, Vera, and Meldal (1995) describe an “object connection architecture” as an architecture of a system in which component interfaces deﬁne services provided but not services used or required. They suggest, instead, “interface connection architectures” that specify both services provided and services required. An approach that supports this concept is Design by Contract (DBC), deﬁned by Meyer (1997). DBC originally emphasized contract provisions in the code itself, and the focus was primarily on behavioral or functional — as opposed to non-functional or performance — issues. Other inputs to the approach deﬁned here include UML (OMG 2007a, b), SysML (OMG 2007c), and RealTime Object-Oriented Modeling (Selic, Gullekson, and Ward 1994). The component-based development community has embraced the DBC concept and extended it for component use. First, the concept of trusted components has come into play. Meyer (2003) deﬁnes a trusted component as a reusable software element possessing speciﬁed and guaranteed property qualities. In the same paper, Meyer deﬁnes a high road and a low road toward establishing high-quality components. The low road is to start with today’s COTS or open-source components and move to certiﬁcation based on contracts. The high road is to produce new components with correctness proofs by deﬁning correctness properties based on contracts. Second, DBC has been extended to include nonfunctional information (performance, QoS) as well as cost. QoS in general has been deﬁned and researched extensively over a period of time. Common metrics include performance, such as message throughput and reliability, as well as security. See, for example, Wang et al. (2004). Aagedal and Ecklund (2002) describe an approach to QoS modeling that features the notion of QoS proﬁle. A proﬁle deﬁnes a QoS region in which a component operates. Multiple different QoS proﬁles may be deﬁned for a given component — for example, one proﬁle deﬁned for a PDA platform and another for a desktop platform. De Miguel, Ruiz, and Garcia (2002) adopt a similar idea in deﬁning a QoS model using UML extensions and applying it to component frameworks. Urting et al. (2002) also use contracts to model nonfunctional constraints for embedded software. A metric that has emerged more recently is quality of experience (QoE), which is the ultimate effect experienced by a consumer or user; for example,

276 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science see Kilkki (2008) and Gallo, Siller, and Woods (2007). An earlier variation of QoE is work done on task-technology ﬁt (TTF). Goodhue and Thompson (1995) proposed that for information technology to have a positive impact on individual performance, the technology must be utilized and it must be a good ﬁt with the task that it supports. They measured the ﬁt based on user perception and evaluation, which is what makes it a form of QoE. QoE is positioned at the user end of the interaction, in contrast to quality of direct output of system, and QoS of the connection or medium between system and user. Although the QoE value of a service or transaction is deﬁned by the user, it can be included in a system speciﬁcation in terms of a QoE response level that is received from the user or consumer. The cost might be the initial purchase of the component, the purchase of ongoing maintenance updates, or the cost of “renting” the component as a service on a pay-per-use basis. Cost may also be speciﬁed at a more granular level for each service. Brucker and Wolff (2001) and Paige and Ostroff (2001) discuss different approaches to increasing formal support for contracts in UML and OCL. The speciﬁcation approach described here incorporates these extended contract concepts. It does not require formal speciﬁcation or automation but it is fully consistent with these ideas. The well-developed area of reliability, with various metrics such as dependability, MTBF, etc., addresses much of the concept of probability of normal and abnormal characteristics. This provides a sound foundation for extending the approach of probabilistic speciﬁcations to autonomous agents and complex systems (CS). One basic theme: MOSES does not require any particular language or method of speciﬁcation; many can be used. On the other hand, most current speciﬁcation languages and methods have some deﬁciencies as viewed from the MOSES deﬁned approach. For example, adequate semantics, and making explicit the dependencies in an external speciﬁcation are often lacking, although in recent years more attention has been given to semantics.

Expand External Behavior Categories 5SBEJUJPOBMMZ XF IBWF UXP DBUFHPSJFT PG TZTUFN CFIBWJPS OPSNBM BOE BCOPSNBM 8F TBZ UIJT TZTUFNCFIBWFTOPSNBMMZPGUIFUJNFBOEBCOPSNBMMZPGUIFUJNF PSCFIBWFTQSPQFSMZ PG UIF UJNF BOE JNQSPQFSMZ PG UIF UJNF 8F BMTP XBOU UP CF BCMF UP TQFDJGZ BOE QSFEJDU NPSF UIBO UIBU #FDBVTF B TZTUFN JO HFOFSBM JT DBQBCMF PG FYIJCJUJOH NBOZ CFIBWJPST CPUI QSPQFSBOEJNQSPQFS XFXBOUUPLOPXXIBUQSPQFSCFIBWJPSJUXJMMFYIJCJU BOEFTQFDJBMMZXIBU JNQSPQFSCFIBWJPSJUXJMMFYIJCJU0OUIFJNQSPQFSTJEF XIBUBSFUIFUZQFTPGUIJOHTUIBUDBOHP XSPOH 4ZTUFNGBVMUTBOEGBJMVSFTDBOWBSZTJHOJﬁDBOUMZ GSPNDBVTJOHBNJOPSUFNQPSBSZJODPO WFOJFODFUPDBVTJOHEFBUIBOEEFTUSVDUJPO8FXBOUUPLOPXUIFMJLFMJIPPEPGJUDBVTJOHEFBUI BOEEFTUSVDUJPO PSBOZMFTTFSPVUDPNFPGJNQSPQFSCFIBWJPS BOEJGQPTTJCMFXIBUUIFDPOEJUJPOT BSFUIBUXJMMSFTVMUJOUIJTCFIBWJPS"MTP XFXBOUUPLOPXJGXF UIFVTFS XJMMFWFOLOPXJGB TZTUFNCFIBWFEJNQSPQFSMZ 8IBU BMM UIJT NFBOT JT UIBU XF OFFE UP NBQ CPUI UIF FYQFDUFE PS OPSNBM CFIBWJPS TQBDF BOEUIFVOFYQFDUFE PSBCOPSNBM CFIBWJPSTQBDF %BWJE1BSOBTDBMMFEUIFMBUUFSTQBDFiVOEFTJSFE

Speciﬁcation Information

O

277

FWFOUTw 8FOFFEUPMBZPVUUIFWBSJPVTCFIBWJPSTBTNVDIBTXFDBO UIFDPOEJUJPOTUIBUXJMMMFBE UPFBDIPGUIFN BOEUIFQSPCBCJMJUZUIBUFBDIPGUIFNXJMMPDDVS8FIBWFEPOFUIJTJOUIFQBTU JOTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHBOEUPTPNFEFHSFFJOTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHThFEFTJSFETQBDFJTUIFCBTJD TQFDJﬁDBUJPO BOEUIFVOEFTJSFETQBDFJTUIFEFMJOFBUFEFYDFQUJPO )PXFWFS OPSNBMBOEBCOPSNBMCFIBWJPSPOMZDPWFSQBSUPGUIFFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTQBDF XIFOXFJODMVEFDPNQMFYTZTUFNT TVDIBTQFPQMFBOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOTJOPVSTDPQFPGTZTUFNT 'JSTUDPOTJEFSOPSNBMCFIBWJPS/PSNBMFYQFDUBUJPOTBSFEJﬀ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ﬂFDUFEJOUSBEJUJPOBMNFDIBOJTUJDNPEFMT DBOOPUEP"OJOUFMMJHFOUBHFOUDBOMFBSO BEBQUJUTFMG HSPX JNQSPWF CFGBVMUUPMFSBOUPGWBSJ PVTLJOETPGGBVMUTBOEFSSPSTBOEBCOPSNBMCFIBWJPS CPUIJOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBMCFTFMGIFBMJOH DIBOHFHPBMT BOENBLFEFDJTJPOTCBTFEPOJODPNQMFUFPSVODFSUBJOJOGPSNBUJPO*OUFMMJHFOUBHFOUT BSFDBQBCMFPGDPNJOHVQXJUITPMVUJPOTUIBUBSFOPUKVTUCFUUFSUIBOFYQFDUFE CVUPGBDPNQMFUFMZ EJﬀFSFOUUZQF PVUPGSBOHFPGXIBUXBTFOWJTJPOFE'PSFYBNQMF JGBQFSTPOJTTVQQPTFEUPQSP EVDFUFOXJEHFUTBEBZ UIFZNJHIUJNQSPWFUPXIFSFUIFZDBOQSPEVDFﬁGUFFOXJEHFUTBEBZ#VU UIFZNJHIUBMTPDPNFVQXJUIUIFJEFBUIBUUIFGBDUPSZTIPVMECFNBLJOHEJﬀFSFOUXJEHFUTThJTJT OPUTPNFUIJOHZPVSUZQJDBMNBDIJOFJTDBQBCMFPG0OUIFPUIFSIBOE BQFSTPOJTDBQBCMFPGPVU PGSBOHFOFHBUJWFCFIBWJPSBTXFMM DBVTJOHTJHOJﬁDBOUEBNBHFBOEEFTUSVDUJPO ThFSFTVMUJTUIBUUIFOPSNBMCFIBWJPSDBUFHPSZOFFETUPIBWFBCSPBEFSEFﬁOJUJPOUPDPWFS CPUINBDIJOFTBOEBHFOUT BOEUIFDBUFHPSJFTPGQPTTJCMFCFIBWJPSPGBTZTUFNOFFEUPCFFYQBOEFE CFZPOEUIFUXPUSBEJUJPOBMDBUFHPSJFTPGOPSNBMBOEBCOPSNBM"HFOUTBEEUISFFBEEJUJPOBMDBU FHPSJFTCFUUFSUIBOFYQFDUFEPVUPGSBOHFHPPEPVUPGSBOHFCBE *GXFBEESFTTUIFEFDPVQMFETJUVBUJPOEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS XIFSFWBMVBUJPOJTEFDPVQMFE GSPNCFIBWJPS UIFOUIJTFYQBOEFETFUDPOTJTUTPGUISFFDBUFHPSJFT/PSNBM OPUOPSNBM PVUPG SBOHFp*GXFBQQMZWBMVBUJPOUPUIJT XFPCUBJOUIFTe ﬁWFDBUFHPSJFT

0VUPGSBOHFHPPE *OSBOHF CFUUFSUIBOFYQFDUFE 8IBUJTFYQFDUFE OPSNBM *OSBOHF MFTTUIBOFYQFDUFEBCOPSNBM 0VUPGSBOHFCBE

0OMZDBUFHPSJFT BOEBSFBEESFTTFEJOBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPSspeciﬁcation. $BUFHPSJFTBOE DBOOPUCFBOUJDJQBUFEUIFZBSFPVUPGSBOHF PVUTJEFUIFﬁeld PGWJTJPOPGUIFFYUFSOBMspeciﬁcation. *UJTJNQPSUBOUUPOPUF IPXFWFS UIBUJOUFSOBMNPEFMTBOEspeciﬁcations EPOPUIBWFUIJTSFTUSJD UJPO4ZTUFNTEFTJHOJOUIFFSBPGUIFGVUVSFFYQBOEFE4&OFFETUPFNQIBTJ[FSPCVTUOFTTBUMFBTUBT 5PTPNFFYUFOU54&BSHVBCMZBEESFTTFTUIFDBUFHPSZ“PVUPGSBOHFCBE”UISPVHINFUIPETTVDIBTGBJMVSFBOBMZ TJTBOEGBJMVSFNPEFT JODMVEJOHDBUBTUSPQIJDGBJMVSF#VUUIJTDBUFHPSZJTJOUFOEFEUPFNQIBTJ[FEJﬀFSFOUUZQFT PGXJMMGVMPSQVSQPTFGVMBDUTCZIVNBOT p *GXFSFBMMZHFUTUSJDUBCPVUSFNPWJOHWBMVBUJPO UIFOXFDBOOPUTBZTPNFUIJOHJTOPSNBMBOETPNFUIJOHFMTFJT OPUOPSNBMXFKVTUJEFOUJGZOFVUSBMDBUFHPSJFTPGCFIBWJPS" # $ %

278

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

NVDIBTDPSSFDUOFTT+FO BEESFTTFTSPCVTUEFTJHOJOTZTUFNTBDSPTTUIFSBOHFPGCJPMPHZ FDPM PHZ BOEFOHJOFFSJOH BOEspeciﬁcally NFOUJPOT Q FOHJOFFSTFYQMJDJUMZEFTJHOJOHGPSSPCVTUOFTT CFZPOEUIFSBOHFPGUIF FYUFSOBM speciﬁcations, CFZPOEXIBUJTBOUJDJQBUFEThe HFOFSBMUPQJDPG FOHJOFFSJOHPSBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTFTGPSUIFFYQBOEFE4&JTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS ThFWBSJPVTDBUFHPSJFTBSFOPUJOIFSFOUThFZBSFSFMBUJWFJOTPNFDBTFTUPUIFTZTUFNT NBDIJOFT BHFOUT JOWPMWFECFDBVTFFYQFDUBUJPOTDIBOHFOPUPOMZBDSPTTUJNF CVUBMTPGPSEJﬀFSFOUSPMFTPS DJSDVNTUBODFT&YBNQMFTJODMVEF O ThSFFFNQMPZFFTPGEJﬀFSJOHDBQBCJMJUZPOFJTDVSSFOUMZDBQBCMFPGQSPEVDJOHXJEHFUT QFSEBZ UIFTFDPOE UIFUIJSEThFFNQMPZFSTFUTEJﬀFSFOUMFWFMTBTBEFRVBUFCFIBW JPSGPSUIFFNQMPZFFT QFSIBQTJODSFBTJOHBDSPTTUJNF

BOEQBZTUIFNBDDPSEJOHMZ O "DPNQBOZQSPEVDFTXJEHFUTPGUZQF:The DPNQBOZDIBMMFOHFTJUTFNQMPZFFTUPUIJOLPG OFXDPNQBOZHPBMTBOEXBZTUIFDPNQBOZDBOJNQSPWFBOEHSPX*UBMTPIJSFTBDPOTVMUBOU UPDPNFJOBOEIFMQUIFDPNQBOZTUSBUFHJ[F SFFOHJOFFS BOEUIJOLPVUTJEFUIFCPY8IBUJT FYQFDUFECFIBWJPSGPSUIFDPOTVMUBOUXPVMECFPVUPGSBOHFUIJOLJOHGPSBKVOJPSFNQMPZFF /PSNBMCFIBWJPSGPSUIFKVOJPSFNQMPZFFNJHIUCFThe DPNQBOZTIPVMEIJSFNPSF QFPQMFBOEXFDPVMEQSPEVDFNPSFXJEHFUT/PSNBMCFIBWJPSGPSUIFDPOTVMUBOUNJHIU be: The company should switch frPNNBLJOHXJEHFUTPGUZQF:UPNBLJOHXJEHFUTPGUZQF; ThFEJTDVTTJPOUIVTGBSIBTBTTPDJBUFEWBMVBUJPOXJUIFBDICFIBWJPSUZQF$IBQUFSEJTDVTTFE UIFEFDPVQMJOHPGCFIBWJPSBOEWBMVBUJPOCFDBVTFBHJWFOCFIBWJPSNBZCFHJWFOEJﬀFSFOUWBMVFT HPPE PS CBE CZ EJﬀFSFOU PCTFSWFST PS BU EJﬀFSFOU UJNFT 4PNFUJNFT JU NBLFT TFOTF UP DPVQMF UIFNPUIFSUJNFTOPU "EJﬀFSFOUQFSTQFDUJWFPOWBMVBUJPOBOEUIFSFMBUJPOCFUXFFOOPSNBMBOEBCOPSNBMDIBSBD UFSJTUJDTJTHJWFOJO%BZBOBOE8JMMJBNT *OUIFJSEJTDVTTJPOPGDPNQVUBUJPOBMBOENBUI FNBUJDBM NPEFMT JO OFVSPTDJFODF UIFZ FNQIBTJ[F UIF QPJOU UIBU BO BEFRVBUF VOEFSTUBOEJOH PG EJTFBTFSFRVJSFTOPUKVTUNPEFMTPGEJTFBTF CVUBMTPBDPOUFYUPGNPEFMTPGOPSNBMGVODUJPOJOHBOE IPXJUJTEJTUVSCFEJOEJTFBTF*OHFOFSBMUFSNT XFOFFEUPTQFDJGZCPUIOPSNBMBOEBCOPSNBM DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTUPVOEFSTUBOEBOEBEFRVBUFMZBEESFTTBCOPSNBMDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT

Speciﬁcation Content Types ThJTTFDUJPOJOGPSNBMMZTQFMMTPVUUIFUZQFTPGJOGPSNBUJPOUIBUGPSNUIFDPOUFOUPGTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT 8FSFJUFSBUFUIBUUIFJOGPSNBUJPONVTUCFNVUVBMMZVOEFSTUPPEUPCFBTQFDJﬁDBUJPO CVUOPUBMMPG JUNVTUCFNBEFFYQMJDJUJOBNPEFMThFﬁSTUTVCTFDUJPOQSPWJEFTBMJTUTFHNFOUFEJOUISFFUBCMFT JOUFSOBM FYUFSOBM BOEJOUFSGBDFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTThFSFNBJOJOHTVCTFDUJPOTBEEFYQMBOBUJPOBOE EJTDVTTJPO PG UIF UBCMFT 4PNF PG UIF JUFNT JEFOUJﬁFE IFSF BOE UIFJS SBUJPOBMF BOE PSJHJO XFSF EFTDSJCFEJOUIFTJEFCBSFBSMJFSJOUIFDIBQUFS

Content List 5BCMFT BOETIPXUIFUZQFTPGJOGPSNBUJPOJOBOJOUFSOBMTZTUFNTQFDJﬁDBUJPOThFZ SFﬂFDUUIFSFMBUJPOTTIPXOJO'JHVSFOBNFMZ UIBUBOJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJODMVEFTUIF FYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTPGJUTDPNQPOFOUTBOEDPOOFDUPST BOEBOFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJODMVEFTUIF TQFDJﬁDBUJPOTPGJUTJOUFSGBDFT5BCMFQSFTFOUTSVMFTUIBUEFTDSJCFUIFSFRVJSFEJOGPSNBUJPOGPS "OFBSMJFSWFSTJPOPGUIFTFUBCMFTXBTQSFTFOUFEJO)ZCFSUTPO

Speciﬁcation Information

O 279

Table 11.1 Internal Speciﬁcation Content Rules Identiﬁer of the model: unique in a deﬁned namespace Version of the model, if appropriate Mapping between views (if more than one view deﬁned)

UML/OCL Interaction name Interaction stereotype or attribute Associations, OCL, stereotypes, annotations

For each view in the model (if only one, model view): Identiﬁer of view Interaction or class name Identiﬁcation of external models of system parts (components and Interaction, component, connectors) in this view (may be general or speciﬁc models) deployment diagrams (or simple list) Roles that may be assumed by parts in this view Role in association end or interaction Class/object deﬁnition; Rules about stuff visible in this view: information, goods stereotype deﬁnitions, invariants, initialization, states, relations etc. Process or behavior rules: ﬂow of stuff, synchronization of parallel Interaction diagrams; processes, interactions, state transitions etc. state charts Types of components allowed Annotations, stereotypes, OCL Types of connectors allowed (e.g., Internet-based; distributed Associations specialized types: signal, operation, ﬂow (RM-ODP 1996); software types: via stereotypes procedure call, data access, linkage, stream, event, arbitrator, adaptor, distributor (Mehta, Medvidovic, and Phadke 2000) Attachment of connector interfaces to component interfaces Interaction diagrams Protocol speciﬁcation: format, sequence, error checking, Associations, OCL or properties stereotype or annotation System-wide constraints on supporting environment Annotations, stereotypes, (e.g., physical or information technology infrastructure) OCL Implementation rules (e.g., use certain suppliers of material, Annotations, stereotypes, or certain vendor products, or follow certain standards) OCL Creation, use, and deletion of resources in system Annotations, stereotypes Other constraints the system places on each component, Annotations, stereotypes, or on each connector (e.g., security constraints or policies) OCL For each component and connector: whether shared Annotations, stereotypes, or contained OCL For each component and connector: If inclusion in system is Annotations, stereotypes, uncertain, probability of inclusion OCL For each component and connector: if inclusion in system Annotations, stereotypes, is partial, fuzzy measure of inclusion OCL External speciﬁcation of each part (by inclusion or reference Class or object name or hyperlink)—See Table 11.2 Optional information—e.g., architecture style, view type, Annotations, stereotypes, explanatory notes, correspondence information OCL Source: Hybertson, D. Using a speciﬁcation approach to facilitate component testing. In Testing Commercial-off-the-Shelf Components and Systems, S. Beydeda and V. Gruhn, Eds. New York: Springer-Verlag, p. 213–237. 2005. Modiﬁed with permission of Springer Science + Business Media.

280

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Table 11.2 External Speciﬁcation Content Rules Identiﬁer of the model: unique in a deﬁned namespace Version of the model, if appropriate Mapping between views (if more than one view deﬁned) Cost of system (e.g., purchase, maintenance upgrades, cost-per-use) For each view in the model (if only one, model view): Identiﬁer of view Identiﬁers of interfaces that provide a service Version of provider interface Identiﬁers of interfaces that require a service Version of receiver interface System invariant over all provided services and all required services (e.g., policies or other constraints) System externally observable properties Service or feature interactions among the interfaces of this system (sequence constraints, how one affects others, z) Speciﬁcation of each interface (by inclusion or reference or hyperlink)—See Table 11.3 Optional information—e.g., view type, explanatory notes, correspondence information

UML/OCL Class or object name Class stereotype or attribute Associations, OCL, stereotypes, annotations Interface annotation or stereotype1 Package or class name Interface name Interface stereotype or attribute Interface2 Interface stereotype or attribute Interface invariant in OCL or annotation Interface attributes in OCL or annotation Interface invariant in OCL or annotation Interface Annotations, stereotypes, OCL

1

This assumes a cost is associated with the system; if cost is instead associated only with each interface, then this item will not apply.

2

For all cases where Interface appears in the table, an additional mapping to UML for systems in a connector role is Association or Association End.

Source: Hybertson, D. Using a speciﬁcation approach to facilitate component testing. In Testing Commercial-off-the-Shelf Components and Systems, S. Beydeda and V. Gruhn, Eds. New York: Springer-Verlag, p. 213–237. 2005. Modiﬁed with permission of Springer Science + Business Media.

BOJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPO5BCMFTIPXTUIFSVMFTGPSBOFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPO BOE5BCMF TIPXTUIFSVMFTGPSBOJOUFSGBDFTQFDJﬁDBUJPO "HJWFOTQFDJﬁDBUJPOIBTBEFﬁOFETDPQFBOEQVSQPTF TPJONBOZDBTFTPOMZBTFMFDUTVCTFUPG UIFJOGPSNBUJPODBMMFEGPSJOUIFTFUBCMFTXJMMCFOFFEFEJOUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPO.PSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZ BO BHFOUUIBUHFOFSBUFTBNPEFMUZQJDBMMZJOUFOETUPMFBWFDFSUBJOTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJUFNTVODPOTUSBJOFE TPUIPTFJUFNTXPVMEOPUIBWFSVMFTEFﬁOFEThJTNFBOTUIBUUISFFOFTUFETFUTPGJUFNTFYJTU'SPN NPTUUPGFXFTUJUFNT UIFZBSF ThFGVMMTFUPGDPOTUSBJOBCMFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJUFNT5BCMFTUISPVHI ThF TVCTFU PG DPOTUSBJOFE JO B HJWFO TQFDJﬁDBUJPO UIF TFU PG EFﬁOFE SVMFT NVUVBMMZ VOEFSTUPPE ThFTVCTFUPG NBEFFYQMJDJUJOUIFNPEFMBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOUIFTFUPG SVMFTFYQSFTTFEJOPOFPSNPSFHJWFOMBOHVBHFTBOEOPUBUJPOT

Speciﬁcation Information

O

281

Table 11.3 Interface Speciﬁcation Content Rules Identiﬁer of the interface: unique in a deﬁned namespace Version of the interface, if appropriate Service if provided through this interface: Access method Semantics: What it requires of its users: precondition What it provides its users Part of invariant associated with service Provided post-condition Provided properties, QoS (performance, precision, reliability, throughput, capacity…) Policies or other constraints under which it operates Provided QoE (quality of experience) assessed by user Probability of meeting expectations (post-conditions, QoS, QoE) Ways of exceeding expectations and probability of each Ways of failing to meet expectations and probability of each Cost of service (CoS) Service if received through this interface: What it offers its providers: precondition What it requires of its providers: usage dependencies Part of invariant associated with service Required post-condition Required properties, QoS (performance, precision, reliability, throughput, capacity…) Required QoE (quality of experience) Probability of meeting expectations (post-conditions, QoS, QoE) Cost of service (CoS) constraints Optional information—e.g., explanatory notes, correspondence information

UML/OCL Class or object name Class stereotype or attribute Interface operation Interface operation in OCL or stereotype or annotation

Interface operation in OCL or stereotype or annotation Interface operation in OCL or stereotype or annotation Interface operation in OC or stereotype or annotation Interface operation in OCL or stereotype or annotation Interface operation in OCL or stereotype or annotation Interface operation in OCL or stereotype or annotation

Interface operation in OCL or stereotype or annotation Interface operation in OCL or stereotype or annotation Annotations, stereotypes, OCL

Source: Hybertson, D. Using a speciﬁcation approach to facilitate component testing. In Testing Commercial-off-the-Shelf Components and Systems, S. Beydeda and V. Gruhn, Eds. New York: Springer-Verlag, p. 213–237. 2005. Modiﬁed with permission of Springer Science + Business Media.

282

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

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his JUFNJTJODMVEFEQSJNBSJMZCFDBVTF UIFBMUFSOBUJWFdeﬁnition PGspeciﬁcation BMMPXTJUUPCFBQQMJFEUPDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUTJOTPNF DBTFT8IFOJUJTTPBQQMJFE UIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFDBOTIPXVQJOUIFspeciﬁcation CVUTUJMMTIPVME OPUBQQFBSFYQMJDJUMZJOUIFNPEFMVOMFTTUIFJOUFOUJTUPIBSEXJSFUIFNPEFMUPBHJWFOTZTUFNPS DBUFHPSZPGTZTUFNT

Internal Speciﬁcation Content Discussion *OHFOFSBM BOJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOEFﬁOFTUIFSVMFTGPSTZTUFNQBSUT UIFJSTUSVDUVSFBOEJOUFSBD UJPOT BOEUIFTUVﬀUIFZFYDIBOHF*UDPWFSTDPODFQUTTVDIBTQSPUPDPMT PSDIFTUSBUJPO DPPSEJOB UJPO TFRVFODFDPOTUSBJOUT DPNQFUJUJPO TUBUFUSBOTJUJPOT CVTJOFTTQSPDFTTFT TFSWJDFJOUFSBDUJPO BHFOUJOUFSBDUJPO BOEHSPVQTPDJBMEZOBNJDT BTXFMMBTQBUUFSOTPSTUZMFTTVDIBTTFSWJDFQSPWJEF DPOTVNFTUZMF QFFSUPQFFS DMJFOUTFSWFS DPOUSPMMFSTMBWF QVCMJTITVCTDSJCF BOEQVTIQVMM .VDIPGUIFCBTJTGPSBOEEFUBJMTPGJOUFSOBMNPEFMTBOEJOUFSBDUJPOTXFSFQSFTFOUFEJO$IBQUFS ThJTTFDUJPOEJTDVTTFTTPNFPGUIFFMFNFOUTJO5BCMFUIBUOFFEGVSUIFSFMBCPSBUJPO

Internal Speciﬁcation Views 4BNQMFWJFXTPGBOJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBSFTVNNBSJ[FEJO'JHVSFThFUZQFTPGWJFXTBSF EJﬀFSFOUTFUTPSUZQFTPGQBSUT MBOHVBHF BOENPEFMTQFDJﬁDJUZ"EEJUJPOBMFYBNQMFTPGJOUFSOBM WJFXT TVDIBTBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFXT XFSFEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS

Internal Model or Speciﬁcation Views

/

/

/

+#"#$&%-$!&!&$!()%"&!(-$!&&+#%"#$&% * #% '!&"!(%#+%$&&'$() "$!!&$#$%$&&'$ "&&%! "$!,&"!()!!"$ &"!*!()'&()!! %+%& () !' !!&$! "!)$&&!!-$!&!'%"$" !%" %"'$% * #%! &" #'&&"!!' !!$!!'&!""+!' "%#.&+ !!&$! "!)$&&!&-$!&(%"%#.&+ * # &)$&&!&!$()$&#$&%$!$&"$% !&%#.()$&#$&%$%#.%+%& %

Figure 11.2

Sample internal speciﬁcation view types.

Speciﬁcation Information

O

283

Internal Interaction Involving Agents .PSFMBOHVBHFTBOENFUIPETBSFCFJOHEFWFMPQFEUPTVQQPSUUIFNPEFMJOHBOEFOHJOFFSJOHPG JOUFSBDUJPOTJOWPMWJOHIVNBOTBOEPUIFSBHFOUT4PNFFYBNQMFTJODMVEF O "HSBXBMFUBM B IBWFEFWFMPQFEB8FCTFSWJDFTIVNBOUBTLTQFDJﬁDBUJPOUIBUEFﬁOFT IVNBOUBTLTJOBXBZUIBUDBOCFQBSUPGBCVTJOFTTQSPDFTTNPEFMPSBTFSWJDFJOUFSBD UJPOThFTBNFHSPVQ "HSBXBMFUBMC IBTJODPSQPSBUFEUIFIVNBOUBTLTQFDJﬁDB UJPO DPODFQUT BT B QSPQPTFE FYUFOTJPO PG UIF 8FC 4FSWJDFT #VTJOFTT 1SPDFTT &YFDVUJPO -BOHVBHF 84#1&-

DBMMFE#1&-1FPQMF O )PMNFTFUBM FYUFOEUIF#1&-BQQSPBDIUPBNPSFHFOFSBMWJFXCBTFE NPEFM ESJWFOBQQSPBDIUIBUEFﬁOFTIVNBOCVTJOFTTQSPDFTTFTBUEJﬀFSFOUMFWFMTPGBCTUSBDUJPO O 4DIBMM 5SVPOH BOE %VTUEBS IBWF EFﬁOFE B IVNBOQSPWJEFE TFSWJDFT )14 GSBNFXPSL UIBU FOBCMFT UIF JOUFHSBUJPO PG TPGUXBSF BOE IVNBO TFSWJDFT JO 8FCTDBMF DPMMBCPSBUJPOT O 4PNFPGUIFBHFOUTQFDJﬁDBUJPOMBOHVBHFT $IBQUFS BSFRVJUFSFMFWBOUUPUIJTEPNBJO 'PSFYBNQMF UIF$PHOJUJWF"HFOUT4QFDJﬁDBUJPO-BOHVBHF $"4- TVQQPSUTTQFDJﬁDBUJPO PGXIBUBOBHFOULOPXTPSCFMJFWFT BOEXIBUUIFJSHPBMTBSF 4IBQJSP -FTQÏSBODF BOE -FWFTRVF $JPCBOVBOE-VDBOV EFTDSJCFBTQFDJﬁDBUJPOMBOHVBHFGPSDPPS EJOBUJPOPGBVUPOPNPVTPCKFDUT

External Speciﬁcation Content Discussion External Speciﬁcation Views $PNNPOWJFXTPGFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁcBUJPOTBSFJMMVTUSBUFEBOEFYQMBJOFEJO'JHVSFThFWBSJBOUT BSF DPOUFYU TQFDJﬁDJUZ MBOHVBHF BOE NPEFM TQFDJﬁDJUZ 8F OPX CSJFﬂZ FYQMPSF UIF EJTUJODUJPO JOUIFﬁHVSFCFUXFFOUIFUXPFOHJOFFSJOHSPMFTCFDBVTFUIFZJMMVTUSBUFUIFNBUDIJOHPGDPOUFYU TQFDJﬁcJUZWJFXT4VQQPTFBTZTUFNBSDIJUFDUMPPLTGPSBDPNQPOFOUUPGVMﬁMMBOFFEJOIJTTZTUFN ThJTDPVMEBQQMZUPDPNQPOFOUCBTFEEFWFMPQNFOU PSUPBTZTUFNCFJOHJOUFHSBUFEBTBDPNQP OFOU JOUP B MBSHFS TZTUFN PG TZTUFNT 4JNQMJTUJDBMMZ POF DPVME BTTFSU UIBU UIFSF JT POF FYUFSOBM DPNQPOFOUTQFDJﬁcBUJPOPGJOUFSFTUUPBDPNQPOFOUVTFSOBNFMZ UIFPOFEFﬁOFEJOUIFTZTUFN BSDIJUFDUVSFThFBSDIJUFDUVTFSTJNQMZﬁOETBDPNQPOFOUXIPTFFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁcBUJPONBUDIFT UIFBSDIJUFDUVSFDPNQPOFOUTQFDJﬁDBUJPO UIBUJT TFMFDUTBOBWBJMBCMFDPNQPOFOUJGBOEPOMZJG TQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGBWBJMBCMFDPNQPOFOUFRVBMTTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGEFTJSFEDPNQPOFOU#VUTFWFSBMGBDUPST NPUJWBUFBNPSFSFBMJTUJDDSJUFSJPO'JSTU UXPTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTBSFSBSFMZ JGFWFS FRVBM8FOFFEUP UIJOLPGiTBUJTﬁFTwSBUIFSUIBOiFRVBMT wBOEXFOFFEUPEFﬁOFXIBUJUNFBOTGPSPOFTQFDJﬁDB UJPOUPTBUJTGZBOPUIFSTQFDJﬁDBUJPO;BSFNTLJBOE8JOH BOE)FNFSBOE-JOETBZ EJTDVTTJTTVFTJOTQFDJﬁcBUJPONBUDIJOHGSPNBGPSNBMQFSTQFDUJWF4FDPOE DPNQPOFOUTFWPMWF PWFSUJNFBT$054WFOEPSTQSPEVDFOFXWFSTJPOTThFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDIOFFETUPTVQQPSUB DPNQPOFOUVTFSJOEFUFSNJOJOHXIFUIFSBOFXDPNQPOFOUWFSTJPOTUJMMNFFUTUIFTZTUFNSFRVJSF NFOUTThJSE TZTUFNTBMTPFWPMWF BOEUIFTZTUFNSFRVJSFNFOUTGPSBDPNQPOFOUNBZDIBOHFThF BSDIJUFDUOFFETUPBTTFTTXIFUIFSUIFFYJTUJOHDPNQPOFOUNFFUTUIFSFWJTFETZTUFNSFRVJSFNFOUT

Interface Speciﬁcation Content Discussion "MM UIF FMFNFOUT PG QSPWJEFE BOE SFRVJSFE TFSWJDFT JO BO JOUFSGBDF TQFDJﬁDBUJPO DBO CF EFﬁOFE TUBUJDBMMZ PS BT B GVODUJPO PG UJNF 'PS USBEJUJPOBM NBDIJOFT UIF FMFNFOUT BSF UZQJDBMMZ TUBUJD

284

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science 6 #1 81

#/

7

!/

%#$!

!1

!0

8/

80

#5

!2 82 #2

EA #3

!3

#4

)%#$! %)% $ % $#'!4 !3

%)%$!-%*#"&#%$$% # $&$ - #$!-'# % $&$$ ($ #- ##+ '# %$ ($ )! # % ( &(#% $*$%#%% ( &(#% &#"&#%$$%(#%% ,#%&$ # %% $ # #$ )! %(#%%&$#%#$( % (#%%#%#$$&$ $!-%*#"&#%$$%(#%%% ,#%'$ $!-%* )! %# # %(#%%%#'$&$!%$ #$#'$ #%$!-'$&$% #"&#%$$%%%$ #!#! $% % $

#4

Responsible role EG

#2 !4 for EA spec: Architect of A 9'#%$. #9#+ %)%.)%#$!

Figure 11.3

Responsible role for EG spec: Requirements engineer of E

Common external speciﬁcation view types.

EFﬁOJUJPOT CVUGPSPSHBOJDTZTUFNTTVDIBTQFPQMF PSHBOJ[BUJPOT FDPOPNJFT FUD UIFFMFNFOUT NBZCFEFﬁOFEBTBGVODUJPOPGUJNFThFSFBSFNBOZXBZTDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT JODMVEJOHCFIBWJPS DBO DIBOHFPWFSUJNF5XPQSPNJOFOUPOFTBSFBEBQUBUJPOBOEHSPXUIThFOPSNBMFYQFDUBUJPOJTUIBU PSHBOJDTZTUFNTXJMMHSPXBOEMFBSOBOEJNQSPWF BTXFMMBTBEBQU PWFSUJNF BOEUIBUFYQFDUBUJPO DBOCFSFﬂFDUFEJOUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOThFNPEFMTVTFEUPFYQSFTTMFBSOJOHBOEHSPXUIDBOSBOHF GSPNTJNQMFMJOFBS PSOPOMJOFBS GVODUJPOTPGUJNFUPNPSFTPQIJTUJDBUFEIVNBOPSBHFOUMFBSOJOH NPEFMT.PEFMTPGBEBQUBUJPODBOSBOHFGSPNUSBEJUJPOBMGFFECBDLNPEFMTUPNPSFTPQIJTUJDBUFE NPEFMTPGBHFOUBEBQUBUJPO"OFYBNQMFPGUIFMBUUFSJT;IBOHBOE$IFOH

XIPUPPLB UFNQPSBMMPHJDMBOHVBHFDBMMFE-5- MJOFBSUFNQPSBMMPHJD BOEBEEFEBOBEBQUBUJPOPQFSBUPSUPJU UPGPSNBMMZNPEFMBEBQUBUJPO ThFSFRVJSFETFSWJDFJUFNJTJOUFOEFEUPJODMVEFBMMEFQFOEFODJFT FWFOJGUIFJOUFSGBDFJTWJSUVBM PSJOEJSFDU"OFYBNQMFJTUIFEFQFOEFODZPGBTPGUXBSFTZTUFNPOBDPNQVUFSQSPDFTTPSThFTPGU XBSFEPFTOPUIBWFBOJOUFSGBDFUIBUDBMMTPSJOWPLFTBDPNQVUFSQSPDFTTPSTFSWJDFUIFXBZJUDBMMT PSJOWPLFTPSTFOETNFTTBHFTUPPUIFSTPGUXBSFNPEVMFT#VUUIJTEFQFOEFODZOFFETUPCFJEFOUJ ﬁFEJOBOJOUFSGBDFJOB.04&4TQFDJﬁDBUJPO 3FNFNCFSUIBUUIJTEPFTOPUNFBOJUOFFETUPCF FYQMJDJUJOUIFNPEFMCVUJUEPFTOFFEUPCFVOEFSTUPPECZBMMQBSUJFTUPUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPO

6ODFSUBJOUZ JO UIF TQFDJﬁDBUJPO PG DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT XIFUIFS USBEJUJPOBM TZTUFN PS BHFOU JT BDDPVOUFEGPSJOUIFQSPCBCJMJTUJDJUFNT. ThBUUPQJDJTUIFTVCKFDUPGUIFOFYUTFDUJPO

Uncertainty: Probabilistic Speciﬁcations 5P JOUSPEVDF PVS EJTDVTTJPO PG QSPCBCJMJTUJD TQFDJﬁDBUJPOT XF XJMM BTL UIJT RVFTUJPO )PX EP UIF OPUJPOT PG EFUFSNJOJTUJD QSPCBCJMJTUJD DFSUBJOUZ LOPXMFEHF QSFEJDUBCJMJUZ BOE SBOEPN OFTTSFMBUFUPFBDIPUIFSBOEUPTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTPGTZTUFNCFIBWJPS *TUIFSFBCJOBSZEJTUJODUJPO

Speciﬁcation Information

O 285

CFUXFFOEFUFSNJOJTUJD DFSUBJOUZ LOPXMFEHF BOEQSFEJDUBCJMJUZPOPOFIBOE BOEQSPCBCJMJTUJD BOESBOEPNPOUIFPUIFS *GDFSUBJOUZJNQMJFTBQSPCBCJMJUZPG UIFOXIBUEPFTVODFSUBJOUZ PSSBOEPNOFTTJNQMZ "QSPCBCJMJUZPG 0S 5PBOTXFSBMMUIFTFRVFTUJPOTSFRVJSFTTPNF BEEJUJPOBMEJTDVTTJPOCVUXFDBOBOTXFSUIFCJOBSZRVFTUJPOOPX8FUBLFEFUFSNJOJTUJDUPCF CJOBSZ4ZTUFNCFIBWJPSDBOOPUCFiTPSUPG wEFUFSNJOJTUJDJUFJUIFSJTPSJTOPUEFUFSNJOJTUJD"OE JGJUJTOPUEFUFSNJOJTUJD JUJTQSPCBCJMJTUJDBOEJODMVEFTUIFFMFNFOUPGSBOEPNOFTT#VUUIFPUIFS DPODFQUTBSFGV[[Z8FDBOCFiTPSUPG wDFSUBJOBOEIBWFQBSUJBMLOPXMFEHFXJUITPNFEFHSFFPG QSFEJDUBCJMJUZ ThFSFBSFTFWFSBMXBZTPGDIBSBDUFSJ[JOHVODFSUBJOUZ*OUIJTCPPL UIFSBOHFPGDFSUBJOUZBOE VODFSUBJOUZJTSFﬂFDUFEXJUIQSPCBCJMJUZ1SPCBCJMJUZWBMVFTSBOHFGSPNUP*GXFBSFBTTFTTJOH UIFQSPCBCJMJUZ1UIBUBDFSUBJODPOEJUJPOIPMET UIFO1NFBOTUIBUUIFDPOEJUJPODFSUBJOMZ EPFTOPUIPME 1NFBOTUIBUJUDFSUBJOMZEPFTIPME BOE1NFBOTUIFSFJTBDIBODFJU IPMET1BOE1CPUISFQSFTFOUDFSUBJOUZUIFSBOHFJOCFUXFFOBOESFQSFTFOUTWBSZJOH EFHSFFTPGVODFSUBJOUZ " OPUF PO SBOEPNOFTT JO UIF DPOUFYU PG QSPCBCJMJTUJD TQFDJﬁDBUJPOT BOE VODFSUBJOUZ PVS BTTVNQUJPOJTUIBUTPNFVODFSUBJOUZFYJTUTJOPVSLOPXMFEHFPGUIFCFIBWJPSPGBMMTZTUFNTThF VODFSUBJOUZ NBZ CF WFSZ TNBMM GPS FYBNQMF CVU JU JT TPNFUIJOH HSFBUFS UIBO [FSP #BTFEPOUIFVODFSUBJOUZBTTVNQUJPO XFDMBJNUIBUUIFBQQSPQSJBUFXBZUPNPEFM BOEUIFSFGPSF TQFDJGZ UIFCFIBWJPSPGBMMTZTUFNTJTUIBUUIFZSFﬂFDUTPNFEFHSFFPGVODFSUBJOUZ BOEUIBUUIFZ CFIBWFSBOEPNMZThBUNJHIUTPVOEPEEUPNPEFMBTZTUFNUIBUFYIJCJUTOFBSDFSUBJOCFIBWJPS BTCFIBWJOHSBOEPNMZCVUBGUFSXFFYQMBJO JUXJMMTPVOERVJUFSFBTPOBCMF ThFTVCTFDUJPOTUIBUGPMMPXEJTDVTTTFWFSBMBTQFDUTSFMBUFEUPQSPCBCJMJTUJDTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT'JSTUJT BEJTDVTTJPOPGUIFQSPCBCJMJUZNBTTBOEQSPCBCJMJUZEFOTJUZGVODUJPOTUIBUBSFVTFEUPDIBSBDUFSJ[F SBOEPN WBSJBCJMJUZ BOE VODFSUBJOUZ ThJT JT GPMMPXFE CZ BO FOHJOFFSJOH FYBNQMF VTJOH DPOEJ UJPOBMQSPCBCJMJUJFTThFMBTUUXPTVCTFDUJPOTCSJFﬂZEFTDSJCFUIFJTTVFPGFTUJNBUJOHQSPCBCJMJUZ EJTUSJCVUJPOEFOTJUZGVODUJPOT 1%'T PGIVNBOCFIBWJPS BOEMJTUPUIFSVODFSUBJOUZNFUIPET

Probability Distribution/Density Function 5PBSSJWFBUBOVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIFBCPWFJTTVFTBOEEJTUJODUJPOTSFRVJSFTBCSJFGCVUSFBTPOBCMZ JOUVJUJWFGPSBZJOUPUIFDPODFQUPGQSPCBCJMJUZEFOTJUZBOEQSPCBCJMJUZNBTTGVODUJPOT"SBOEPN WBSJBCMF9DBOCFDIBSBDUFSJ[FEJOUFSNTPGUIFQSPCBCJMJUZPGUIFWBMVFTJUDBOUBLF*OUIFDBTFPG BEJTDSFUFWBSJBCMF UIFQSPCBCJMJUZNBTTGVODUJPOBTTJHOTUPFBDIEJTDSFUFWBMVFBQSPCBCJMJUZUIBU9 XJMMUBLFUIBUWBMVF*G9DBOUBLFBOZPGOWBMVFTY Y z YO UIFOUIFQSPCBCJMJUZNBTTGVOD UJPOBTTJHOTBQSPCBCJMJUZGPSFBDIWBMVF1 Y

1 Y

z1 YO ThFTQFDJBMDBTFXIFSFBMMQSPCBCJMJUJFTBSFUIFTBNFUIBUJT 1 Y 1 Y z1 YO JT DBMMFEBVOJGPSNQSPCBCJMJUZEJTUSJCVUJPO JOXIJDIDBTFXFBMTPLOPXUIBUUIFQSPCBCJMJUZPGFBDI WBMVFO*ONBOZDBTFT XFVTFVOJGPSNQSPCBCJMJUZNBTT PSEFOTJUZ XIFOXFIBWFOPFWJ EFODFVQPOXIJDIUPKVEHFUIBUPOFPVUDPNFJTNPSFMJLFMZUIBOBOZPUIFS1FSIBQTUIFUXPNPTU DPNNPOFYBNQMFTBSFﬂJQQJOHBDPJOBOESPMMJOHBEJF"TTVNJOHUIFDPJOJTOPUJNCBMBODFE UIF QSPCBCJMJUZPGBDPJOﬂJQSFTVMUJOHJOIFBETJTBOEUIFQSPCBCJMJUZPGSFTVMUJOHJOUBJMTJTBMTP 4JNJMBSMZ UIFQSPCBCJMJUZPGBSPMMPGPOFEJFJTPSBQQSPYJNBUFMZGPSFBDIPGUIFTJYQPTTJCMF SFTVMUT POFUISPVHITJYEPUT #VUJOUIFHFOFSBMDBTF UIFEJTUSJCVUJPOGVODUJPOJTOPUVOJGPSN$POTJEFSUIFDBTFPGSPMMJOH UXPEJDF JOXIJDIUIFSFTVMUJTUIFUPUBMPGUIFUXP BOEUIFSFGPSFUIFTFUPGQPTTJCMFSFTVMUT JT\ ^ThFQSPCBCJMJUZPGUIFSFTVMUTWBSJFTCFDBVTFUIFOVNCFSPGXBZT

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

1.0 0.5 0

Probability(X)

O

Probability(X)

Probability(X)

286

1.0

0.17

T

0.001 X: Normal Abnormal

X: 1 2 3 4 5 6

(d) System with 0.999 reliability

(b) Roll of one die

Probability

(a) Coin toss

Probability(X)

0.5 0

0 X: H

0.999

1.0

0.20 0.15 0.10 0.05 0 X: 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 (c) Roll of two dice

Figure 11.4

Wikipedia 2008

(e) Normal (Gaussian) density function

Examples of probability mass/density functions.

PGPCUBJOJOHUIFWBSJPVTSFTVMUTEJﬀFST ThFSFJTPOMZPOFXBZUPPCUBJOBSFTVMUPG CPUIEJDF TIPX PS CPUIEJDFTIPX

CVUUIFSFBSFTJYXBZTUPPCUBJOBSFTVMUPG UIFﬁSTUTIPXT UIFTFDPOETIPXTPSUIFﬁSTUTIPXTBOEUIFTFDPOETIPXT FUD ThFSFGPSF UIFQSPC BCJMJUZPGPCUBJOJOHBSFTVMUPGGSPNSPMMJOHUXPEJDFJTTJYUJNFTUIFQSPCBCJMJUZPGPCUBJOJOH BSFTVMUPGThFQSPCBCJMJUJFTBSFTIPXOWJTVBMMZJO'JHVSFCVUUIFJNQPSUBOUQPJOUPGUIJT FYBNQMFJTUIBUJUTIPXTBOPOVOJGPSNQSPCBCJMJUZNBTTGVODUJPO ThFSFBTPOUIJTJTJNQPSUBOU JTUIBUJUTFUTUIFTUBHFGPSTQFDJGZJOHUIFCFIBWJPSDBUFHPSJFTPGBTZTUFN*GXFIBWFBTZTUFN UIBUFYIJCJUTOPSNBMTQFDJﬁFECFIBWJPSXJUIQSPCBCJMJUZBOEVOTBUJTGBDUPSZPSBCOPSNBM CFIBWJPSXJUIQSPCBCJMJUZ UIFOXFDBODIBSBDUFSJ[FJUBTBIJHIMZOPOVOJGPSNQSPCBCJMJUZ EJTUSJCVUJPOGVODUJPO *OUIFDBTFPGBDPOUJOVPVTWBSJBCMF UIFQSPCBCJMJUZEFOTJUZGVODUJPOBTTJHOTUPBOJOUFSWBMUIFQSPCBCJMJUZUIBUUIFWBMVFPG9JTJOUIFJODMVTJWFSBOHFPGBUPC PS1 Ba9aC ThFUFSN iEJTUSJCVUJPOGVODUJPOwSFGFSTUP1 9aY

XIJDIJTUIFEFﬁOJUFJOUFHSBM PSTVN PGUIFEFOTJUZ NBTT GVODUJPOPWFSBMMWBMVFTPG9MFTTUIBOYThFNPTUQSPNJOFOUFYBNQMFPGBDPOUJOVPVT EFOTJUZGVODUJPOJTUIFOPSNBMPS(BVTTJBOEJTUSJCVUJPO PGUFODBMMFEUIFCFMMDVSWFCFDBVTFPGJUT TIBQF*UJTDIBSBDUFSJ[FECZBNFBOMBOEBWBSJBODFS BOEJTUIFSFGPSFBGBNJMZPGGVODUJPOT BDUVBMMZBOJOﬁOJUFTFUPGGVODUJPOTCFDBVTFUIFNFBODBOCFBOZSFBMOVNCFSBOEUIFWBSJBODF DBOCFBOZQPTJUJWFOVNCFS . ThFEFOTJUZGVODUJPOG Y PGBOPSNBMWBSJBCMFYJT ¤ Y M ³ FYQ ¥ S ´µ ¦ S P

XIFSFMJTUIFNFBO SJTUIFWBSJBODF BOESJTUIFTUBOEBSEEFWJBUJPO

Speciﬁcation Information

O 287

'JHVSFTIPXTUIFNBTTPSEFOTJUZGVODUJPOGPSUIFDBTFTKVTUEJTDVTTFE B POFDPJOUPTT C SPMMPGPOFEJF D SPMMPGUXPEJDF XIFSFUIFPVUDPNFJTUIFUPUBMPGUIFUXP E TZTUFNXJUI SFMJBCJMJUZ UIBUJT TZTUFNXJUIOPSNBMCFIBWJPSPGUIFUJNFBOEVOTBUJTGBDUPSZCFIBW JPSPGUIFUJNF BOEJUJTOPULOPXOXIFOUIFVOTBUJTGBDUPSZXJMMPDDVS F OPSNBMPS (BVTTJBOEJTUSJCVUJPO UBLFOGSPN 8JLJQFEJB ThFTFEJTUSJCVUJPOGVODUJPOTBSFDIBSBDUFS J[FEBTGPMMPXT B BOE C BSFCPUIVOJGPSNBOEEJTDSFUF D BOE E BSFCPUIEJTDSFUFCVUOPU VOJGPSNBOE F JTOFJUIFSVOJGPSNOPSEJTDSFUF *GBTZTUFNIBTBOBOBMPH PSPUIFSDPOUJOVPVT JOQVUTUSFBNBOEBOBOBMPH PSPUIFSDPO UJOVPVT PVUQVUTUSFBN XFDBODIBSBDUFSJ[FPSTQFDJGZUIFCFIBWJPSPGUIFTZTUFNJOUFSNTPGB DPOUJOVPVTQSPCBCJMJUZEFOTJUZGVODUJPO#VUNBOZPGUIFTZTUFNCFIBWJPSTXFTQFDJGZJOTZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH FWFO DPNQMFY TZTUFNT BSF EJTDSFUF BOE UIFSFGPSF XF DIBSBDUFSJ[F UIF CFIBWJPS JO UFSNTPGBEJTDSFUFQSPCBCJMJUZEJTUSJCVUJPOGVODUJPO *GXFIBWFNPSFJOGPSNBUJPO XFDBOTQFDJGZUIFQSPCBCJMJUJFTNPSFspeciﬁcally"OFYBNQMFJT BMJHIUCVMC*GUIFSFMJBCJMJUZPGBMJHIUCVMCJT XFEPOPUBTTVNFUIBUUIFGBJMVSFIBTFRVBM QSPCBCJMJUZPGPDDVSSJOHBUBOZUJNF'JSTU UIFMJHIUCVMCPOMZCVSOTPVUXIFOJUJTPO TPEVSJOH QFSJPETXIFOJUJToﬀ, UIFQSPCBCJMJUZPGGBJMVSFEVSJOHUIPTFUJNFTJT[FSPBTTVNJOHUIFSFJTOP PUIFSEFTUSVDUJWFBDUJPO TVDIBTUIFMJHIUCVMCCFJOHQIZTJDBMMZTNBTIFE 4FDPOE UIFQSPCBCJM JUZPGGBJMVSFJTsigniﬁcantly IJHIFSGPSBTIPSUJOUFSWBMPGUJNF BTFDPOEPSMFTT BGUFSUIFMJHIUJT UVSOFEPOFBDIUJNF"GUFSUIBU UIFQSPCBCJMJUZEFDSFBTFTDPOTJEFSBCMZUPBMPXMFWFMVOUJMUIFMJHIU JTUVSOFEoﬀ. ThirE PWFSUJNF UIFQSPCBCJMJUZPGGBJMVSFJODSFBTFTTMPXMZBTUIFCVMCBQQSPBDIFT JUTFYQFDUFEMJGFTQBO#FDBVTFPGUIFTFGBDUPST XFDBOTQFDJGZUIFQSPCBCJMJUZEJTUSJCVUJPOJOBXBZ UIBUIBTIJHIFSﬁdelity UPUIFTZTUFNUIBOUIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBUBUBMMUJNFTJUIBTBQSPCBCJMJUZPG PGGBJMVSF 8FBSFOPXJOBQPTJUJPOUPBOTXFSUIFRVFTUJPOTQPTFEBCPWF(JWFOUIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBU EFUFSNJOJTUJDJTBCJOBSZDPODFQUUIBUNFBOTDPNQMFUFDFSUBJOUZBOEBQSPCBCJMJUZPG XFDIBS BDUFSJ[FUIFCFIBWJPSPGBMMiSFBMwTZTUFNTUIJTXBZ O O O O

/POFJTEFUFSNJOJTUJD "MMCFIBWFJOBQSPCBCJMJTUJDNBOOFS "MMCFIBWFSBOEPNMZ JOUIFTFOTFUIBUXFEPOPULOPXXIBUUIFJSOFYUCFIBWJPSXJMMCF /POFJTDPNQMFUFMZQSFEJDUBCMF*UJTOFDFTTBSZUPGSBNFUIFDPODFQUPGiQSFEJDUBCJMJUZw XJUIBSBOHFUIBUXFDBODMBJNUPJODMVEFUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDJORVFTUJPOXJUIBTQFDJﬁD QSPCBCJMJUZ FH UIFWBSJBCMF9XJMMGBMMJOUIFJOUFSWBM B C XJUIQSPCBCJMJUZPG TVDI FYQSFTTJPOTBSFDBMMFEiDPOﬁEFODFJOUFSWBMTwThFTJ[FPGUIFSBOHFXJMMCFEFUFSNJOFECZ CPUIUIFGPSNPGUIFEJTUSJCVUJPOVTFEBOEJUTQBSBNFUFST SFﬂFDUJOHPVSTUBUFPGLOPXM FEHF$POTFRVFOUMZ TZTUFNTXJUIUIFMFBTUQSFEJDUBCMFCFIBWJPSBSFEFTDSJCFECZVOJGPSN EJTUSJCVUJPOT XJUIFRVBMQSPCBCJMJUZPWFSBMMQPTTJCMFCFIBWJPSTNPSFQSFEJDUBCMFTZTUFNT BSFEFTDSJCFECZQSPCBCJMJUZEJTUSJCVUJPOTUIBUBSFDPOTJTUFOUXJUIPVSEFUBJMFELOPXMFEHF PGUIFWBSJBCJMJUZPGTZTUFNCFIBWJPS O #FDBVTFXFSBSFMZLOPXUIFBDUVBMQSPCBCJMJUZEJTUSJCVUJPO XFTBZUIBUTZTUFNTFYIJCJUBOFTUJ NBUFESBOHFPGQSFEJDUBCJMJUZCBTFEPOBOFTUJNBUFEEJTUSJCVUJPO4ZTUFNCFIBWJPSSFﬂFDUTUIF BDUVBMEJTUSJCVUJPOPWFSUJNF OPUUIFFTUJNBUFEEJTUSJCVUJPOCVUUIFHPPEOFXTJTUIBUUIFFTUJ NBUFEEJTUSJCVUJPODBOCFVQEBUFECZSFDPSEJOHPSTBNQMJOHBDUVBMCFIBWJPS BOEUIBUTIPVME MFBEUPUIFFTUJNBUFNPWJOHDMPTFSUPUIFBDUVBMBTTVNJOHUIFBDUVBMSFNBJOTTUBCMF O .PSFLOPXMFEHFPGBTJUVBUJPOPSDPOUFYUMFBETUPCFUUFSFTUJNBUFTPGQSPCBCJMJUZEJTUSJCV UJPOTGPSUIFTJUVBUJPOPSDPOUFYU

288

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Probability, PDF, and Knowledge We discuss two small examples. The ﬁrst is a case where we have a good estimate of the PDF but do not know the outcome of an event in the past. In the second case, we do not know about the occurrence of an event and we also do not have a solid basis for a PDF. The discussion in Chapter 9 pointed out that uncertainty exists about past and present events as well as future events. Based on that, we can deﬁne probabilities about any uncertainties — past, present, or future. Suppose a friend of mine is on the phone at time T1 and says he is about to ﬂip a coin, and asks what the probability is that the result will be heads. I have a good estimate of the PDF of the possible outcomes: Both heads and tails have a probability of .5. Therefore, my estimate of the probability that the outcome of this speciﬁc toss is heads is .5; that is what I tell him, and he agrees. Now he tosses the coin, and at time T2 he observes that it comes up heads but does not tell me the result. This observation changes his knowledge of the event, but not mine. Now he asks me again: “What is the probability that the result was heads?” I repeat my answer: “The probability is .5 that it was heads.” For him at this time T2, the probability that it was heads is 1.0, and the probability of it being tails is 0. Then at time T3 he tells me the result was heads. Now we both agree that the probability that it was heads is 1.0.* The estimated probabilities were based on knowledge of the PDF and presence or absence of knowledge of the event outcome. Probabilities do not have an independent or inherent existence in a situation; they depend on the knowledge of the observer. The second topic is PDF: Assume that today is April 17 and we want to estimate the probability that it will it rain a month from now, on May 17, in Hong Kong; and we also assume that we know nothing about the climate or rain patterns in Hong Kong. How do we estimate the probability? Because we know nothing about the PDF, we could assume a uniform PDF of rain or not rain, and estimate the probability of rain on May 17 (or any other day for that matter) to be .5. That is a very weak basis for estimating. Now suppose we obtain a better basis for the PDF. We ﬁnd out the following two items of information: 1. Rainy days as a proportion of all the days of the past century in Hong Kong is .37 2. Rainy days as a proportion of all the days in May of the past century in Hong Kong is .47 We interpret (1) as an estimate for the PDF of rain on a randomly selected day of the year in Hong Kong; and (2) as an estimate for the PDF of rain on a random day in May in Hong Kong. Which of these two PDF estimates gives a better basis for estimating the probability that it will rain on May 17? The ﬁrst is

*OUFOUJPOBMMZJHOPSFEBSFDFSUBJOPUIFSQSPCBCJMJUJFTUIBUXPVMESFEVDFJUGSPN TVDIBT)FEJEOPUﬂJQBDPJO BUBMMPSIFNJHIUIBWFOPUTFFOUIFPVUDPNFDPSSFDUMZPSIFNJHIUOPUCFUFMMJOHNFUIFDPSSFDUPVUDPNF

Speciﬁcation Information

O

289

a larger sample, which generally means a better basis; note that in this case, the data are from two distinctly different distributions. However, the second indicates that there are cyclic seasons and May is a rainy month, so we would select (2) over (1) as our estimate of the PDF because it is the more speciﬁc population of which our event is a member. That is, our estimate of the PDF of the variable M rain on a day in May is: P(rain) .47; P(not rain) .53. Based on all this, we would estimate that the probability that it will rain in Hong Kong on May 17 is .47. If the only PDF estimate we had was (1), and we had no knowledge of Hong Kong rain cycles, we would estimate that the probability is .37. The collective point of the two examples is that our estimates of probabilities in system speciﬁcations are themselves relative and uncertain. That is, we make uncertain estimates of the uncertain behavior of systems. Does that mean the method is weak? No, it is still a useful method in specifying the uncertainty of behavior in systems.

Example Using Conditional Probabilities ThFFYBNQMFTIPXOJO'JHVSFTIPXTUIFSPMFUIBUDPOEJUJPOBMQSPCBCJMJUJFTDBOQMBZJONPEFM JOHBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPO*OUSPEVDUPSZJOGPSNBUJPOJODMVEFT O 4ZTUFN$SFRVJSFTBTFSWJDF S UIBUTZTUFN#QSPWJEFT Q 5PQSPWJEFQ TZTUFN#EFQFOET POUXPTFSWJDFT SBOES UIBUNVTUCFQSPWJEFE QBOEQ CZTPNFTFSWJDFQSPWJEFS O $POOFDUPST/ / BOE/XJMMCFVTFEUPEFMJWFSUIFTFSWJDFTBTTIPXOJO'JHVSF O 4JUVBUJPOJTQSFBSSBOHFETFSWJDFQSPWJTJPOTZTUFN#IBTJEFOUJﬁFETFSWJDFQSPWJEFST4 GPSQBOE4GPSQUIBUJT 4BOE4BHSFFUPUIFSBOESSFTQFDUJWFDPOUSBDUSFRVJSF NFOUTGPSQBOEQ O 4JUVBUJPOJTEZOBNJDKVTUJOUJNFTFSWJDFQSPWJTJPOTZTUFN#IBTOPUJEFOUJﬁFETFSWJDF QSPWJEFST GPS Q PS Q CVU FTUJNBUFT UIBU QSPWJEFST XJMM CF GPVOE XIFO OFFEFE XJUI QSPCBCJMJUZ1 ﬁOE Q Q

*NQMJFEJOiﬁOEJOHwJTUIBUUIFQSPWJEFSTXJMMBHSFFUPUIFS BOESSFTQFDUJWFDPOUSBDUSFRVJSFNFOUTGPSQBOEQ *OCPUITJUVBUJPOT TBUJTGBDUJPOPGCPUIFOETPGBMMDPOUSBDUTBOEUIFQSFTFODFBOEQSPQFS GVODUJPOJOHPGBMMDPOOFDUPSTBSFVODFSUBJO8FOPXEFWFMPQBOFYBNQMFUIBUBTTVNFT4JUVBUJPO BOE JHOPSFT UIF DPOOFDUPST UIBU JT NBLFT UIF GBMTF BTTVNQUJPO UIBU UIF DPOOFDUPST XJMMCFQSFTFOUBOEGVODUJPOJOHQSPQFSMZXJUIQSPCBCJMJUZ*UXPVMECFBTUSBJHIUGPSXBSE

N2 C

Figure 11.5

r1

N1

p1

B

p2

S2

p3

S3

r2 r3

N3

Example structure for conditional probability.

290

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

FYUFOTJPOUPBEEDPOOFDUPSVODFSUBJOUZUPUIJTFYBNQMF*OQSPDFFEJOHXJUI4JUVBUJPO8IBU JTUIFEFHSFFPGDFSUBJOUZUIBU$TSFRVJSFETFSWJDFSXJMMCFPCUBJOFEPSTBUJTﬁFE "OEIPX EPFT JU SFMBUF UP BMM UIF VODFSUBJOUJFTJO UIF TFSWJDF DIBJO 8F VTF QSPCBCJMJUZ BT BNFBTVSF PGDFSUBJOUZBOEUIFDPODFQUPGDPOEJUJPOBMQSPCBCJMJUZUPIFMQBOTXFSUIFTFRVFTUJPOT'JSTU TPNFOPUBUJPO O 1 Y 1SPCBCJMJUZUIBUYJTTBUJTﬁFE O 1 Y\E $POEJUJPOBM QSPCBCJMJUZ UIBU Y JT TBUJTﬁFE HJWFO UIBU BMM Y EFQFOEFODJFT BSF TBUJTﬁFE O 1 E 1SPCBCJMJUZUIBUBMMYEFQFOEFODJFTBSFTBUJTﬁFE 0CTFSWBUJPOT O 1 Y 1 Y\E r1 E 1 Y\E r1 E

XIFSFiEwEFOPUFTiOPUEw BOEirwEFOPUFTUIF NVMUJQMZPQFSBUPS O 1 Y a1 Y\E 1 Y 1 Y\E POMZJG YIBTOPEFQFOEFODJFT PS BMMYEFQFOEFODJFTBSF TBUJTﬁFE UIBUJT 1 E ThFﬁSTUPCTFSWBUJPOJTUSVFCFDBVTF1 Y 1 Y\E r1 E 1 Y\E r1 E CZ#BZFTUIFPSFN UIFFWFOUTiEwBOEiEwCFJOHDPMMFDUJWFMZFYIBVTUJWFBOENVUVBMMZFYDMVTJWFThFﬁSTUQBSUPGUIF TFDPOEPCTFSWBUJPOJTUSVFCFDBVTFBMMQSPCBCJMJUJFTNVTUCFHSFBUFSUIBOPSFRVBMUP[FSPUIFSFGPSF 1 Y a1 Y\E ThFTFDPOEQBSUJTUSVFCFDBVTF 1 Y 1 Y\E JTUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPGJOEFQFOEFODF BOE JG1 E UIFO1 E BOE1 Y 1 Y\E r1 E 1 Y\E r1 E 1 Y\E r 1 Y\E 1 Y\E *O TJUVBUJPO

UIF TFSWJDF DIBJO EFQFOEFODJFT BSF DMFBS JHOPSJOH UIF DPOOFDUPST / FUD TBUJTGZJOHSTFSWJDFEFQFOETPOUIFDPOUSBDUFOETS Q S S Q BOEQCFJOHTBUJTﬁFE *OHFOFSBM DPOEJUJPOBMQSPCBCJMJUJFT 1 Y\E

BSFJTPMBUFE XIJMFOPODPOEJUJPOBMQSPCBCJMJUJFT 1 Y

1 E

BSFBHHSFHBUFEBOEFODBQTVMBUJOH8FXJMMEFWFMPQUIFFYBNQMFBOEVTFJUUPFYQMBJO UIFTFQSPCBCJMJUJFTBOETIPXIPXUIFZBSFVTFGVM The equations that folloXSeﬂect an assumption that all identiﬁed prPCBCJMJUJFTBSFJOEFQFOEFOU 1 S 1 S\E r1 ES 1 S\ES r1 ES CVU1 S\ES CFDBVTFXFBTTVNF UIBUSDBOOPUCFTBUJTﬁFEJGES TP1 S 1 S\E r1 ES

1 ES 1 Q CFDBVTFUIJTFYBNQMFJHOPSFTDPOOFDUPSVODFSUBJOUZ

1 Q 1 Q\E r1 EQ TBNFSFBTPOBT

1 EQ 1 S r1 S

1 S 1 S\E r1 ES

1 ES 1 Q

1 S 1 S\E r1 ES

1 ES 1 Q

ThFSFGPSF1 S 1 S\E r1 Q\E r1 S\E r1 S\E r1 Q r1 Q

8IPIBTDPOUSPM $# $IBTDPNQMFUFDPOUSPMPG1 S\E

BOE#IBTDPNQMFUFDPOUSPMPGUIFUISFFDPOEJUJPOBMQSPCBCJMJ UJFTTIPXOUIFTFBSFJTPMBUFEGSPNUIFFﬀFDUPGEFQFOEFODJFTCZUIFJSEFﬁOJUJPOT

Speciﬁcation Information

O 291

/PXMFUVTQSPDFFEXJUIBOVNFSJDBMJMMVTUSBUJPOPGUIFFYBNQMF O (JWFO1 S]E 1 Q]E 1 S]E 1 S]E 1 Q 1 Q %FUFSNJOF1 S BOE1 Q

ThFFRVBUJPOTBSFMJTUFEJOUIFPSEFSUIFZBSFDPNQVUFE

1 ES 1 Q

1 S 1 S\E r1 ES

1 ES 1 Q

1 S 1 S\E r1 ES

1 EQ 1 S r1 S

1 Q 1 Q\E r1 EQ

1 ES 1 Q

1 S 1 S\E r1 ES

)PXBSFQSPCBCJMJUJFTBOEFRVBUJPOTMJLFUIJTVTFE "DPVQMFPGBQQMJDBUJPOTBSFCSJFﬂZEFTDSJCFE "QQMJDBUJPO "TTVNF B TFSWJDFPSJFOUFE BSDIJUFDUVSF JO XIJDI # QSPWJEFT TFSWJDF Q UP UIF TFSWJDF DPOTVNFS $ XIP SFRVJSFT TFSWJDF S *O UIJT DBTF # BTTVNFT SFTQPOTJCJMJUZ GPS TBUJTGZJOHJUTEFQFOEFODJFTSBOES5IFSFGPSF #QVCMJTIFTJUTTFSWJDFXJUIBTQFDJGJFE2P4 PG1 Q "QQMJDBUJPO "TTVNF B DPNQPOFOUCBTFE TZTUFN JO XIJDI UIF BSDIJUFDU JT BTTFNCMJOH DPN QPOFOUT $ # 4 BOE 4 *O UIJT DBTF UIF BSDIJUFDU BTTVNFT SFTQPOTJCJMJUZ GPS TBUJTGZJOH #T EFQFOEFODJFTSBOESJOUIJTFOWJSPONFOUThFSFGPSF UIFWFOEPSPGDPNQPOFOU#QVCMJTIFTJUT DPNQPOFOUTQFDJﬁDBUJPOXJUIB2P4PGDPOEJUJPOBMQSPCBCJMJUZ1 Q\E 8IZUIFEJﬀFSFODF "O40"TFSWJDFQSPWJEFSNVTUQSPWJEFUIFTFSWJDF XIJDINFBOTJUNVTU BDDPVOUGPSUIFVODFSUBJOUZJOJUTSVOUJNFFOWJSPONFOU"DPNQPOFOUWFOEPSEPFTOPUQSPWJEFB TFSWJDF CVUSBUIFSQSPWJEFTBDPNQPOFOUUIBUDBOCFJOTUBMMFEJONVMUJQMFFOWJSPONFOUTUPQSPWJEF BTFSWJDFThFDPNQPOFOUWFOEPSDBOOPUTQFDJGZUIFQSPCBCJMJUZUIBUJUTEFQFOEFODJFTXJMMCFTBUJT ﬁFEUIBUWBSJFTCZFOWJSPONFOUBOENVTUCFTQFDJﬁFECZFBDIBSDIJUFDUUIBUVTFTUIFDPNQPOFOU *U TFFNT UIBU QSPCBCJMJUJFT BOE UIF DPOEJUJPOBMVODPOEJUJPOBM EJTUJODUJPO QSPWJEF B SBUIFS FMFHBOUBOEQSFDJTFXBZPGNBLJOHUIJTVTFGVMEJTUJODUJPO /PXBTTVNFUIBU"DBOQBSUJBMMZDPNQFOTBUFGPS#OPUQSPWJEJOHUIFQSPNJTFETFSWJDFGPS FYBNQMF #JTEFHSBEFE PSJTOPUQFSGPSNFEBUBMM#ZiQBSUJBMMZDPNQFOTBUFwXFNFBOUIBU 1 "\# 1 "\# <XIFSF 1 "\# NFBOT QSPCBCJMJUZ PG " HJWFO iOPU #w JF HJWFO MFTT UIBO FYQFDUFETFSWJDFGSPN#>. ThFSFBSFUXPEJﬀFSFOUTUBUFNFOUTNBEFJOUIJTFYQSFTTJPO O 1 "\# TBZT UIBU " JT OPU EFBE JO UIF XBUFS CFDBVTF PG UIF EFHSBEFE PS MPTU # TFSWJDF*ODMBTTJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH "XPVMEOPUCFBCMFUPQFSGPSNJUTGVODUJPOJGJUTEFQFO EFODZXBTOPUTBUJTﬁFE TPUIFTUBUFNFOUXPVMECF1 "\# O 1 "\# 1 "\# TBZTUIBU"DBOOPUGVMMZDPNQFOTBUFGPSUIFEFHSBEFEPSMPTU#TFSWJDF *G"DPVMEGVMMZDPNQFOTBUFGPSJU "XPVMEOPUEFQFOEPO# BOEUIFTUBUFNFOUXPVMECF 1 "\# 1 "\#

XIJDIJTBOPUIFSXBZPGTBZJOHUIBU"JTJOEFQFOEFOUPG# *Oeﬀect, UIFDPNCJOFETUBUFNFOUTBZTUIBUJG#EPFTOPUEPJUTKPC "DBOTUJMMGVODUJPO CVU OPUBTXFMM/PUFUIBUPVSTUBUFNFOUBCPVUDMBTTJDBMFOHJOFFSJOHBTTVNFTOPGBVMUUPMFSBODFPSFSSPS SFDPWFSZ$MFBSMZ NVDIXPSLIBTCFFOEPOFJOGBVMUUPMFSBODFBOEFSSPSSFDPWFSZGPSNBOZZFBST JONPTUBSFBTPGFOHJOFFSJOHBOETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH8FBSFOPUUSZJOHUPJHOPSFUIBUXPSL0O

O

292

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

UIFDPOUSBSZ XFBSFUSZJOHUPSFDPHOJ[FJUNPSFFYQMJDJUMZJOUIF.04&4BQQSPBDIUPspeciﬁcaUJPO BOECVJMEPOJUBTBQQSPQSJBUFJOUIFBSFBTPGTFMGIFBMJOHBOETFMGBEBQUBUJPOUIBUUIFMBSHFS TDPQFPGBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUTBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNTCSJOHJOUPUIJTBSFOBThe BCPWFGPSNVMBUJPOPG UIFQSPCBCJMJUJFTPGBOBHFOUDPNQFOTBUJOHGPSBCOPSNBMCFIBWJPSPVUTJEFJUTDPOUSPMJTBﬁrst TUFQ UPXBSEUIBUHPBM #FOFﬁUTPGUIJTBQQSPBDIUPTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPGVODFSUBJOUZJODMVEF O 6OJﬁFTTQFDJﬁ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ﬂFYJCMFDBOTVQQPSUBMBSHFOVNCFSBOEWBSJFUZPGWJFXTBOETUBLFIPMEFST BOEBMMUIF WJFXTXJMMCFDPOTJTUFOUCFDBVTFUIFZBSFCBTFEPOUIFTBNFGSBNFXPSL O 1SPWJEFTBXBZUPJODPSQPSBUFVODFSUBJOUJFTPGGBVMUUPMFSBODF TFMGIFBMJOH BOETFMGBEBQ UBUJPOUIBUDIBSBDUFSJ[FUIFMBSHFSTDPQFPGBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUTBOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT

Other Uncertainty Methods "MJTUPGVODFSUBJOUZNFUIPETXBTQSFTFOUFECZ3BKBCBMMZFUBM ThFZJODMVEFUIFGPMMPX JOHGPSNBMJTNT

1SPCBCJMJUZUIFPSZ#BZFTJBOCFMJFGOFUXPSLT *OUFSWBMBOBMZTJT 3VMFCBTFETZTUFNTDFSUBJOUZGBDUPST &WJEFOUJBMSFBTPOJOH%FNQTUFS4IBGFSUIFPSZ 1PTTJCJMJUZUIFPSZGV[[ZMPHJD

"OPUIFS BQQSPBDI UP VODFSUBJOUZ JT NPEBM MPHJD PS UIF WBSJPVT MPHJDT PG QPTTJCJMJUZ ThF 4UBOGPSE&ODZDMPQFEJBPG1IJMPTPQIZJEFOUJﬁFTTPNFPGUIFNPEBMSFMBUFEMPHJDT 4&1

Logic Modal Logic Deontic Logic

Symbols

Expressions Symbolized

It is necessary that z

O P F

It is obligatory that z It is permitted that z It is forbidden that z

It is possible that z

Speciﬁcation Information

O 293

Temporal Logic

G F H P

It will always be the case that z It will be the case that z It has always been the case that z It was the case that z

Doxastic Logic

Bx

x believes that z

ThF.04&4BQQSPBDIVTFTTPNFPGUIFTFJOEJﬀFSFOUXBZT'JSTU BTUIJTDIBQUFSTIPXT JUVTFT QSPCBCJMJUZ UIFPSZ FYUFOTJWFMZ BT UIF QSJNBSZ UPPM GPS TQFDJGZJOH VODFSUBJOUZ 4FDPOE JU VTFT NPEBMMPHJDQSJNBSJMZJOFYQSFTTJOHSFMBUJPOTCFUXFFONPEFMBOETZTUFNJOBDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU CVUBMTPVTFTJUJONPEFMTBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOTUIFNTFMWFTThJSE JUDPOTJEFSTGV[[ZMPHJDUPCFBCPVU QBSUJBMOFTT OPUVODFSUBJOUZ. ThJTJTBEESFTTFEJOUIFOFYUTFDUJPO

Partialness: Fuzzy Speciﬁcations 'V[[ZTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTNBLFVTFPGGV[[ZMPHJDBOEGV[[ZTFUUIFPSZThFCBTJDDPODFQUJTUIBUDPO DFQUTUIBUXFOPSNBMMZUIJOLPGBTCFJOHEJTDSFUFTVDIBTXIFUIFSBOFMFNFOUJTBNFNCFSPGB TFU XIFUIFSTPNFUIJOHJTUSVFPSGBMTF PSXIFUIFSBQFSTPOJTJOBSPPNBSFJOTUFBEDPODFJWFE BTCFJOHBNBUUFSPGEFHSFF XJUIBSBOHFGSPNUP4PBOFMFNFOUDBOCFIBMGXBZJOBTFU PSBQSPQPTJUJPODBOCFIBMGUSVF *O .04&4 GV[[Z TQFDJﬁDBUJPOT DBO CF VTFE GPS B OVNCFS PG QVSQPTFT &YBNQMFT JODMVEF UIFEFHSFFUPXIJDIBDPNQPOFOUJTJOBTZTUFNPSUIFEFHSFFUPXIJDIBTZTUFNJTJOBNPEFM SFHJPOUIBUJT UIFEFHSFFUPXIJDIBTZTUFNTBUJTﬁFTBTQFDJﬁDBUJPOPSQFSIBQTUIFEFHSFFUP XIJDIBTZTUFNJTFODBQTVMBUFE 'V[[ZTFUUIFPSZJTTPNFUJNFTJODMVEFEBMPOHXJUIQSPCBCJMJUZJOUIFTFUPGUFDIOJRVFTGPSSFQ SFTFOUJOHVODFSUBJOUZ BTJOUIFQSFWJPVTTFDUJPO"TTIPXOJO'JHVSF JOEJDBUPSTPGGV[[JOFTT BOEPGVODFSUBJOUZCPUIIBWFBSBOHFGSPNUP)PXFWFS UIFNFBOJOHJTEJﬀFSFOU1SPCBCJMJUZ JTBOJOEJDBUPSPGVODFSUBJOUZBCPVUXIFUIFSTPNFUIJOHJTUSVF TVDIBTXIFUIFSUIFOFYUDPJOﬂJQ XJMMCFIFBETPSUBJMT'V[[JOFTTJTBOJOEJDBUPSPGQBSUJBMOFTTPSHSBEVBMJTN*G*BNTUBOEJOHJOUIF EPPSXBZBOEBNIBMGJOUIFSPPNBOEIBMGPVU UIFGV[[JOFTTNFBTVSFEPFTOPUSFﬂFDUVODFS UBJOUZBCPVUXIFUIFS*BNJOUIFSPPNSBUIFS JUSFﬂFDUTUIFQBSUJBMOFTTPGNFCFJOHJOUIFSPPN *BNDFSUBJOMZIBMGXBZJOUIFSPPNThFSFGPSF GV[[JOFTTJO.04&4JTOPUVTFEBTBOVODFSUBJOUZ NFDIBOJTN

Examples )FSFXFHJWFTPNFWFSZCSJFGTLFUDIFTUIBUJMMVTUSBUFBTQFDUTPGUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPODPOUFOUQSPWJEFE JOUIJTDIBQUFS

A Human Performance Example ThJTFYBNQMFTQFDJﬁFTIVNBOQFSGPSNBODFBTBNFNCFSPGBOPSHBOJ[BUJPO )PXFWFS GV[[JOFTTDBOCFVTFEJODPOKVODUJPOXJUIVODFSUBJOUZ"TJUVBUJPODBOCFNPEFMFEBTTJNVMUBOFPVTMZ GV[[ZBOEVODFSUBJO

294

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science Universe of Systems

Region boundary interpreted as not certain: Probabilistic

Region boundary interpreted as not discrete: Fuzzy

Degree F to which systems are in region

Probability P of systems being in region P(A) = 0.0

A

C

B

D

E

F(A) = 0.0 F(B) = 0.4

P(B) = 0.4 P(C) = 1.0

F(C) = 1.0

P(D) = 0.6

F(D) = 0.6 F(E) = 0.0

P(E) = 0.0 P=0

P=1

Gradient from P = 0 to 1

F=1

F=0

Gradient F = 1 to 0

Figure 11.6 Fuzzy speciﬁcations use same gradient measure as probabilistic speciﬁcations but with different meaning.

8FIBWFEJTDVTTFEIPXEFﬁOJOHBSPMFIFMQTOBSSPXUIFTQBDFGPSTQFDJGZJOHIVNBOCFIBW JPS*OGBDU BQSBDUJDBMBTTVNQUJPOXIFOBQQMZJOHUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDIJOUIJTDIBQUFSUP B IVNBO PS PUIFS BHFOU JT UIBU UIF BHFOU JT BDUJOH JO B TQFDJﬁFE SPMF i1FSTPOw IBT BO BMNPTU VOMJNJUFE BOE IBSEUPEFﬁOF PVUDPNF TQBDF #VU SPMF CFIBWJPS JT USBDUBCMF QBSFOU FNQMPZFF TPMEJFS GBDUPSZXPSLFS TPGUXBSFBHFOUJO99EPNBJOPSDPOUFYU HFPTQBUJBMBOBMZTU SFTFBSDIFS DPNQMFYTZTUFNTSFTFBSDIFS DPNQMFYTZTUFNTSFTFBSDIFSBU4BOUB'F*OTUJUVUF 4'*

DPNQMFYTZT UFNTSFTFBSDIFSBU4'*JOFWPMVUJPOBSZEZOBNJDTThFFYBNQMFDPVMECFTPNFUIJOHMJLFBGBDUPSZ XPSLFSXJUIBXFMMEFﬁOFEKPCCVUUPTIPXUIFSBOHFPGUIFBQQSPBDIJONPSFDPNQMFYTJUVBUJPOT XFDIPPTFUPTQFDJGZBSFTFBSDIFS XIJDIUZQJDBMMZJTBMFTTDJSDVNTDSJCFEBDUJWJUZGPSXIJDIJUJT EJﬃcVMUUPTQFDJGZQFSGPSNBODFThFTQFDJﬁDSPMFGPSXIJDIXFXJMMTLFUDIBOFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPO PGFYQFDUFEGVUVSFCFIBWJPSJTUIFMBTUPOFNFOUJPOFE UIBUJT DPNQMFYTZTUFNTSFTFBSDIFSBU4'* JOFWPMVUJPOBSZEZOBNJDT ThFFYQFDUFECFIBWJPSDPVMECFEFﬁOFEBTHFUUJOHBQBQFSQVCMJTIFEJOFWPMVUJPOBSZEZOBN JDT2P4POFQBQFSBDDFQUFECZBSFGFSFFEKPVSOBMJOFWPMVUJPOBSZEZOBNJDTJOPOFZFBS PS POFPSNPSFQVCMJDBUJPOTQPTUFEPOUIF4'*QVCMJD8FCTJUFUIBUDPMMFDUJWFMZHFU)IJUTJOUIF OFYUZFBSPS%EPXOMPBETJOUIFOFYUZFBSXJUIQSPCBCJMJUZPG8FEPOPUTQFDJGZXIBUUIF DPOUFOUPGUIFQVCMJDBUJPOXJMMCF POMZUIFEPNBJOPGFWPMVUJPOBSZEZOBNJDT XJUIQSPCBCJMJUZ TJODF DPNQMFY TZTUFNT SFTFBSDIFST BSF PGUFO NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZ

BOE TPNF NFBTVSBCMF 2P4 BTTVHHFTUFEBCPWF4'*NBZJOGBDUOPUDBSFXIBUUIFTQFDJﬁDDPOUFOUTBSF CVUPOMZJO BEWBODJOHUIJTﬁFMEBOEHFUUJOHSFDPHOJUJPOBOEDPOUJOVFEGVOEJOH4PUIJTSFRVJSFNFOUTQFDJ ﬁDBUJPOPGUIFSFTFBSDIFSiTZTUFNwJTBUUIFBQQSPQSJBUFMFWFMPGHFOFSBMJUZThFQSFDPOEJUJPOTPS ThJTFYBNQMFJTVTFEIFSFUPJMMVTUSBUFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOFMFNFOUTThFFYBNQMFJTSFWJTJUFEJO$IBQUFSBOEQBSTFE JOBEJﬀFSFOUXBZ JOUFSNTPGNBQQJOHUPUIFFYUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBMUZQFNPEFMTBOEUPUSBEJUJPOBMBSUJGBDUTTVDI BTBSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOU

Speciﬁcation Information

O 295

Table 11.4 Possible Researcher Behavior in Each Category #

Category

1

Out of range — interpreted as good

2

In range, better than expected

3 4

What is expected In range, less than expected

5

Out of range — interpreted as bad

Possible behavior Researcher discovers or initiates whole new area of research Researcher publishes two or three papers instead of one Researcher publishes one paper; satisﬁes QoS Researcher does not write paper, or paper is published but not in a refereed journal Researcher destroys lab

EFQFOEFODJFTJODMVEFHFUGVOEJOHGPSSFTFBSDI TUBZBU4'* SFUBJOIFBMUI FUD/PUFUIBUHFUUJOH GVOEJOHGPSSFTFBSDINBZCFBQSFDPOEJUJPOJG4'*BTTVNFTSFTQPOTJCJMJUZGPSGVOEJOH PSNBZ JOTUFBECFQBSUPGUIFFYQFDUFECFIBWJPSPGUIFSFTFBSDIFSJGFBDISFTFBSDIFSJTFYQFDUFEUPﬁOE UIFJSPXOGVOEJOH /PX DPOTJEFS QPTTJCMF CFIBWJPS EVSJOH UIF OFYU ZFBS PG UIF SFTFBSDIFS JO FBDI PG UIF ﬁWF CFIBWJPSDBUFHPSJFT4FF5BCMF/PUFUIBUUIFTFCFIBWJPSTBSFOPUBMMNVUVBMMZFYDMVTJWFThF SFTFBSDIFSDPVME JOJUJBUFBOFXSFTFBSDIBSFB QVCMJTIBQBQFS BOEUIFO HFUBOHSZBOE EFTUSPZUIFMBC

Other Sketches ThSFFCSJFGTLFUDIFTBSFHJWFOUPJOEJDBUFUIFBQQMJDBCJMJUZSBOHFPGUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDI

Organization 4VQQPTFXFXBOUUPTQFDJGZDFSUBJODIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOPSFOUFSQSJTFJOJUTDVSSFOU TUBUFBOEJUTEFTJSFETUBUF &YUFSOBMNPEFM-FUTBTTVNFUIFQSFDPOEJUJPOJTUIFDVSSFOUBDUVBMDPOEJUJPO4UBUF UJNFJT OPXGVODUJPOPSQSPWJEFETFSWJDFQSPEVDFTXJEHFUTQSPQFSUJFTDVSSFOUQSPﬁU TJ[F SFQVUBUJPO JONBSLFUQPTJUJPO OPUJOCFTUDPNQBOJFTUPXPSLGPS FUD "TTVNF QPTUDPOEJUJPO JT EFTJSFE DPOEJUJPO 4UBUF UJNF JT NPOUIT GSPN OPX TBNF GVODUJPONPSFQSPﬁU MBSHFSPSTNBMMFSTJ[F CFUUFSSFQVUBUJPO JONBSLFUQPTJUJPO JO CFTUDPNQBOJFTUPXPSLGPS FUD /PXUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOKVTUIBTUPSFEFTJHOJUTFMG UIBUJT EFﬁOFBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMUIBUXJMM FOBCMFJUUPTBUJTGZUIFFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPO&YBNQMFSFQMBDFDFSUBJODPNQPOFOUT TVDIBTUIF $&0. ThBUUBTLXJMMOPUCFQVSTVFEJOUIJTTLFUDI

Army $POTJEFSBOJOTVSHFODZoDPVOUFSJOTVSHFODZTJUVBUJPO *OUFSOBM NPEFM ThF DPNQPOFOUT JODMVEF BO PDDVQZJOH BSNZ UIF IPTU OBUJPO MFBEFST IPTU OBUJPOBSNZ JOTVSHFOUT BOEMPDBMQPQVMBUJPO%FﬁOFBDVSSFOUJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGJOUFSBDUJPOJO XIJDIUIFJOTVSHFODZJTDBVTJOHTJHOJﬁDBOUIBWPDBOEEFTUSVDUJPO IBTUIFTZNQBUIZPGNVDIPG

296 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

UIFMPDBMQPQVMBUJPO BOEUIFIPTUOBUJPOBSNZJTXFBLThFOEFﬁOFUIFHPBMJOUFSOBMNPEFM XIFSF UIFMPDBMQPQVMBUJPOJTPQQPTFEUPUIFJOTVSHFOUTBOETVQQPSUTUIFIPTUOBUJPOMFBEFSTBOEBSNZ BOEUIFJOTVSHFOUTBSFPOUIFEFDMJOF ThFOEFﬁOFBQMBOBOBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTUPNPWFGSPNDVSSFOUNPEFMUPHPBMNPEFM "O FYBNQMF DPVME CF UBJMPSJOH UIF 64 "SNZ DPVOUFSJOTVSHFODZ NBOVBM 64 "SNZ

XIJDIJTBHFOFSBMDPVOUFSJOTVSHFODZEPNBJONPEFMUIBUDPOUBJOTNVMUJQMFQBUUFSOTBOEJODPSQP SBUFT$4GFBUVSFTPGJOTVSHFODJFT

Everyday Example: Safety Deposit Box *OBTBGFUZEFQPTJUCPYTJUVBUJPO BTFSWJDFDPOTVNFS4$HJWFTBTFSWJDFQSPWJEFS41JUFN T .JO DPOEJUJPO$BUUJNF541SFUVSOTUIFJUFNTJOUIFTBNFDPOEJUJPOBUBMBUFSUJNF5UIBUXJMMCF DIPTFOCZ4$The DIBSHFGPSUIJTTFSWJDFJT9NPOUIThe LFZspeciﬁcation JUFNTPGUIFQSPWJEFE TFSWJDFBSF O 1SFDPOEJUJPO.JODPOEJUJPO$BUUJNF5 $JTiBTJTwJUJTOPUDPOTUSBJOFECZ41CVUJT SBUIFSBCFODINBSLGPSUIFJOWBSJBOU

O *OWBSJBOUDPOEJUJPO$PG.BU5DPOEJUJPOBU5 O 1PTUDPOEJUJPO.BWBJMBCMFUP4$BU5 O 2P4SFTQPOEPOEFNBOEBUVOLOPXO5XJUIQSPCBCJMJUZ1q.XJMMCFJODPOEJUJPO $BU5XJUI1q O $PTUPGTFSWJDF9UJNFT /VNCFSPGNPOUITCFUXFFO5BOE5

/PUJODMVEFEJOTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTUPSF.JOBTBGFQMBDFTUPSFJOESZQMBDFTUPSFJOUFNQFSBUVSFSBOHF CFUXFFOUFNQBOEUFNQMJNJUOVNCFSPGFNQMPZFFTXJUINBTUFSLFZz

Scaling down the Approach for Software 8FDMBJNUIBUUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDIEFTDSJCFEJOUIJTDIBQUFSTDBMFTCPUIVQBOEEPXOUPBOZ MFWFMEFTJSFE. ThJTTLFUDITIPXTIPXJUTDBMFTEPXO $POTJEFSBGFXMJOFTPGTPGUXBSFDPEF x y a z r

3; y 1; x2; sqrt(x2 y2); z – 7;

&BDI MJOF PG DPEF PS TUBUFNFOU DBO CF DPOTJEFSFE B TZTUFN BOE UIF UZQFT PG TQFDJﬁDBUJPO EFﬁOFEJOUIJTDIBQUFS TQFDJﬁDBMMZBOFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPO DBOCFBQQMJFEUPFBDIThJTBQQSPBDI XBTFTTFOUJBMMZEFﬁOFEZFBSTBHPCZ)PBSF JOXIBUCFDBNFLOPXOBTUIF)PBSFUSJQMF 1 \2^ 3 XIFSF 1 JT UIF QSFDPOEJUJPO 2 JT UIF TUBUFNFOU \2^ SFQSFTFOUT UIF FYFDVUJPO PG UIF TUBUFNFOU BOE3JTUIFQPTUDPOEJUJPO0OFXBZPGDIBSBDUFSJ[JOHUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDIPG .04&4JTBTBMBSHFFYUFOTJPOPG)PBSFTNFUIPEUPBMMUZQFTPGTZTUFNTBUBMMTDBMFT *O BEEJUJPO UIF DPMMFDUJWF TFU PG TPGUXBSF TUBUFNFOUT MJTUFE BCPWF DBO CF DPOTJEFSFE BT UIF JOUFSOBMNPEFMPGBMBSHFSTZTUFN XIFSFUIFTUVﬀ FYDIBOHFEBNPOHUIFJOUFSBDUJOHDPNQPOFOU TUBUFNFOUTDPOTJTUTPGEBUBBOEDPOUSPM

Speciﬁcation Information

O 297

References "BHFEBM +BOE&&DLMVOE.PEFMMJOH2P4UPXBSETB6.-QSoﬁle. *O1SPDFFEJOHTPG6.- %SFTEFO (FSNBOZ 0DUPCFS "HSBXBM " ."NFOE .%BT .'PSE $,FMMFS .,MPQQNBOO %,ÚOJH '-FZNBOO 3.àMMFS ( 1GBV ,1MÚTTFS 33BOHBTXBNZ "3JDLBZ[FO .3PXMFZ 14DINJEU *5SJDLPWJD ":JV BOE. ;FMMFSB8FC4FSWJDFT)VNBO5BTL 84)VNBO5BTL

7FSTJPO+VOFIUUQEPXOMPBE CPVMEFSJCNDPNJCPOMQVCTPGUXBSFEXTQFDTXTCQFQFPQMF84)VNBO5BTL@WQEG "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

"HSBXBM " ."NFOE .%BT .'PSE $,FMMFS .,MPQQNBOO %,ÚOJH '-FZNBOO 3.àMMFS (1GBV (,1MÚTTFS 33BOHBTXBNZ "3JDLBZ[FO .3PXMFZ 14DINJEU *5SJDLPWJD ":JV BOE.;FMMFSC84#1&-&YUFOTJPOGPS1FPQMF #1&-1FPQMF

7FSTJPO+VOFIUUQ EPXOMPBECPVMEFSJCNDPNJCNEMQVCTPGUXBSFEXTQFDT84CQFQFPQMF#1&-1FPQMF@ WQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#SVDLFS "BOE#8olﬀ. $IFDLJOH0$-$POTUSBJOUTJO%JTUSJCVUFE4ZTUFNT6TJOH+&&&+#5FDIOJDBM 3FQPSU "MCFSU-VEXJHT6OJWFSTJUÊU 'SFJCVSH +VMZ IUUQXXXCSVDLFSDICJCMJPHSBQIZ EPXOMPBEUSQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

$JPCBOV ( BOE % -VDBOV " 4peciﬁcation -BOHVBHF GPS $PPSEJOBUFE 0CKFDUT *O 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF $POGFSFODF PO 4peciﬁcation BOE 7eriﬁcation PG $PNQPOFOU#BTFE 4ZTUFNT -JTCPO 1PSUVHBM 4FQUFNCFS 4"7$#4A/FX:PSL"$. "WBJMBCMFWJBPOMJOF "$. 4*(40'5 4PGUXBSF &OHJOFFSJOH /PUFT

.BSDI IUUQQPSUBMBDNPSHDJUBUJPO DGN JEDPMM"$.EM"$.JEY+QBSUOFXTMFUUFS8BOU5ZQF /FXTMFUUFSTUJUMF"$.4*(40'54PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH/PUFT$'*% $'50,&/ "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

%BZBO 1 BOE + 8JMMJBNT 1VUUJOH UIF DPNQVUBUJPO CBDL JOUP DPNQVUBUJPOBM NPEFMJOH 1IBSNBDPQTZDIJBUSZ 4VQQM 4o4 %F .JHVFM . + 3VJ[ BOE . (BSDJB 2P4BXBSF DPNQPOFOU GSBNFXPSLT *O 1SPD 5FOUI *OU 8PSLTIPQPO2VBMJUZPG4FSWJDF (BMMP & .4JMMFS BOE+8PPET"OPOUPMPHZGPSUIFRVBMJUZPGFYQFSJFODFGSBNFXPSL1SPDFFEJOHT *&&&*OU$POGPO4ZTUFNT .BOBOE$ZCFSOFUJDTo0DUPCFS Qo (PPEIVF % BOE 3 Thompson. 5BTLUFDIOPMPHZ ﬁt BOE JOEJWJEVBM QFSGPSNBODF .*4 2VBSUFSMZ o )FNFS %BOE1-JOETBZ4VQQPSUJOHDPNQPOFOUCBTFESFVTFJO$"3&*O1SPDFFEJOHTPGUIFUI "VTUSBMBTJBODPOGFSFODFPO$PNQVUFSTDJFODF7PMVNF .FMCPVSOF 7JDUPSJB "VTUSBMJB )PBSF $"3"O"YJPNBUJD#BTJTGPS$PNQVUFS1SPHSBNNJOH$PNNVOJDBUJPOTPGUIF"$. o )PMNFT 5 5SBO ) ;EVO 6 BOE%VTUEBS 4.PEFMJOH)VNBO"TQFDUTPG#VTJOFTT1SPDFTTFT"7JFX #BTFE .PEFM%SJWFO"QQSPBDIUI&VSPQFBO$POGFSFODFPO.PEFM%SJWFO"SDIJUFDUVSF'PVOEBUJPOT BOE"QQMJDBUJPOT oIUUQXXX.infosys.tuwien.ac.at/staﬀ/tholmes/publications/human_ WCNQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)ZCFSUTPO %6TJOHBspeciﬁcation BQQSPBDIUPGBDJMJUBUFDPNQPOFOUUFTUJOH4#FZEFEBBOE7(SVIO &ET 5FTUJOH$PNNFScial-oﬀ-the-SIFMG$PNQPOFOUTBOE4ZTUFNT/FX:PSL4QSJOHFS7FSMBH QQ +FO &3PCVTU%FTJHO"3FQFSUPJSFPG#JPMPHJDBM &DPMPHJDBM BOE&OHJOFFSJOH$BTF4UVEJFT/FX:PSL 0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT ,JMLLJ ,2VBMJUZPG&YQFSJFODFJO$PNNVOJDBUJPOT&DPTZTUFN+6OJWFSTBM$PNQVUFS4DJ o -VDLIBN % +7FSB BOE4.FMEBMThrFFDPODFQUTPGTZTUFNBSDIJUFDUVSF5FDIOJDBM3FQPSU$4-o 53oo $PNQVUFS4ZTUFNT-BC 4UBOGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ +VMZIUUQDJUFTFFSDPNQOVTFEV THDBDIFQBQFSTDTIUUQ[4[[4[OFOZBNTmﬀDVOJD[[4[UIFHSPVQ[4[SFM@XPSL[4[-7.QEG UISFFDPODFQUTPGTZTUFNQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

.FIUB / /.FEWJEPWJD BOE41IBELF5PXBSETBUBYPOPNZPGTPGUXBSFDPOOFDUPST*O1SPDOE *OU$POG4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH -JNFSJDL *SFMBOE .FZFS #0CKFDU0SJFOUFE4PGUXBSF$POTUSVDUJPO OEFE1SFOUJDF)BMM

298

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

.FZFS #The HSBOEDIBMMFOHFPGUSVTUFEDPNQPOFOUT*O1SPDUI*OU$POGPO4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH .BZ 0.( 0CKFDU .BOBHFNFOU (SPVQ B 6niﬁed .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF 0.( 6.-

4VQFSTUSVDUVSF 70.(%PDVNFOU/VNCFSGPSNBM4UBOEBSEEPDVNFOUIUUQXXXPNHPSH TQFD6.-4VQFSTUSVDUVSF1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU .BOBHFNFOU (SPVQ C 6niﬁed .PEFMJOH -BOHVBHF 0.( 6.-

*OGSBTUSVDUVSF 70.(%PDVNFOU/VNCFSGPSNBM4UBOEBSEEPDVNFOUIUUQXXXPNHPSH TQFD6.-*OGSBTUSVDUVSF1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

0.( 0CKFDU.BOBHFNFOU(SPVQ D4ZTUFNT.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 0.(4ZT.-

70.( %PDVNFOU /VNCFS GPSNBM 4UBOEBSE EPDVNFOU IUUQXXXPNHPSHTQFD4ZT.- 1%' "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

1BJHF 3BOE+0TUSoﬀ. "QSPQPTBMGPSBMJHIUXFJHIUSJHPSPVT6.-CBTFEEFWFMPQNFOUNFUIPEGPS SFMJBCMFTZTUFNT*O1SPD8PSLTIPQPO1SBDUJDBM6.-#BTFE3JHPSPVT%FWFMPQNFOU.FUIPET DP MPDBUFEXJUI6.-

5PSPOUP $BOBEB 0DUPCFS 3BKBCBMMZ & 44OBQF 48IJUUMF BOE14FO"DLOPXMFEHJOH6ODFSUBJOUZJOUIF1SPWJTJPOPG%FGFODF $BQBCJMJUZ*OTJHIUTGSPN-JUFSBUVSF*/$04& 3.0%1 0QFO %JTUSJCVUFE 1SPDFTTJOH 3FGFSFODF .PEFM 1BSU 'PVOEBUJPOT *OUFSOBUJPOBM 4UBOEBSE *565 3FDPNNFOEBUJPO 9 1BSU "SDIJUFDUVSF *OUFSOBUJPOBM 4UBOEBSE *5653FDPNNFOEBUJPO9 4FQU 4DIBMM % )5SVPOH BOE4%VTUEBS0O6OJGZJOH)VNBOBOE4PGUXBSF4FSWJDFTGPS"EIPDBOE 1SPDFTTDFOUSJD$PMMBCPSBUJPO*&&&*OUFSOFU$PNQVUJOH o 4FMJD # ((VMMFLTPO BOE18BSE3FBM5JNF0CKFDU0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH /FX:PSL+PIO8JMFZ4POT 4&1 4UBOGPSE&ODZDMPQFEJBPG1IJMPTPQIZ .PEBM-PHJD 4IBQJSP 4 : -FTQÏSBODF BOE ) -FWFTRVF The $PHOJUJWF "HFOUT 4peciﬁcation -BOHVBHF BOE 7eriﬁcation EOWJSPONFOUGPS.VMUJBHFOU4ZTUFNT""."4 o+VMZ #PMPHOB *UBMZ 4[ZQFSTLJ $$PNQPOFOU4PGUXBSF#FZPOE0CKFDU0SJFOUFE1SPHSBNNJOH"EEJTPO8FTMFZ 6SUJOH % :#FSCFST 47BO#BFMFO 5)PMWPFU :7BOEFXPVEF BOE13JHPMF"UPPMGPSDPNQPOFOU CBTFE EFTJHO PG FNCFEEFE TPGUXBSF *O 1SPD UI *OU $POG PO5PPMT 1aciﬁc: 0CKFDUT GPS *OUFSOFU .PCJMFBOE&NCFEEFE"QQMJDBUJPOT 7PM 'FCSVBSZ 64"SNZ$PVOUFSJOTVSHFODZ'..$818BTIJOHUPO %$)FBERVBSUFST %FQBSUNFOU PGUIF"SNZIUUQXXXGBTPSHJSQEPEEJSBSNZGNQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

8BOH ( "$IFO $8BOH $'VOH BOE46D[FLBK*OUFHSBUFERVBMJUZPGTFSWJDF RPT NBOBHF NFOUJOTFSWJDFPSJFOUFEFOUFSQSJTFBSDIJUFDUVSFT1SPDUI*&&&*OU&OUFSQSJTF%JTUSJCVUFE0CKFDU $PNQVUJOH$POGQo 8JLJQFEJB/PSNBMEJTUSJCVUJPOBOETDBMFTIUUQFOXJLJQFEJBPSHXJLJ*NBHF/PSNBM@EJTUSJCVUJPO@ BOE@TDBMFTHJG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

;BSFNTLJ "BOE+8JOH4peciﬁcation NBUDIJOHPGTPGUXBSFDPNQPOFOUT"$.5SBOT4PGUXBSF&OH .FUIPEPM

0DUPCFS ;IBOH +BOE#)$$IFOH6TJOHUFNQPSBMMPHJDUPTQFDJGZBEBQUJWFQSPHSBNTFNBOUJDT+4ZTUFNT BOE4PGUXBSF o

Chapter 12

Mapping and Uniﬁcation Systems taxonomy 1

Collective actualization space

D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn

Problem space

3a

TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b Traditional Complex

Highest level system

Deﬁne need

Complex 4 Traditional TS is special case 5 Characteristics of all SE systems Traditional and Complex Characteristics of all systems

Model Space

All SE application domains...

Indivisible Unit Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Composition

TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b 2a Traditional systems Complex systems

6

Obvious Mappings

Modeling scope

SE Application Domains (D1...Dn)

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

ThJT DIBQUFS EJTDVTTFT UIF NBQQJOH PG USBEJ UJPOBMBSUJGBDUTBOEDPODFQUTUPBSFBTPG.04&4 EFTDSJCFEJOQSFWJPVTDIBQUFST BTXFMMBTQSPWJE JOHBTVNNBSZPGUIFVOJﬁDBUJPOSFQSFTFOUFEJO .04&4

Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

e

m

Ti

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

Produce solution

Deployment

Satisfy need

Solution/system space

4FWFSBMPGUIFNBQQJOHTJOUIJTDIBQUFSSFGFSCBDLUPWJFXTJO'JHVSF5PNBLFUIFDPOOFDUJPO FBTJFS XFEVQMJDBUFUIBt ﬁHVSFIFSFBT'JHVSF. ThFQSFWJPVTDIBQUFSTJOUIJTCPPLEJEOPUTBZ NVDIBCPVUUIFNBQQJOHPGUSBEJUJPOBMBSUJGBDUTUPUIFFYUFSOBMJOUFSOBMNPEFMTUSVDUVSF8IFO UIFZIBWFNFOUJPOFEUIFSFMBUJPOTIJQ JUJTBMPOHUIFMJOFTPGUIFNBQQJOHHJWFOIFSF *OUIFDPOUFYUPGUIFNPEFMTTIPXOJO'JHVSF UIFPCWJPVTNBQQJOHTJODMVEF O "$PODFQUPG0QFSBUJPOT $0/014 EPDVNFOUBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBTZTUFN4NBQTUPBO JOUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPOTPG4XJUIUIFFMFNFOUTPGJUTFOWJSPONFOUThJTJTWJFX 7JO'JHVSF O "SFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUPG4NBQTUPBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPG4 FJUIFSBTBDPOUFYUHFO FSBMNPEFMPSBTBDPOUFYUTQFDJﬁDNPEFM CPUIPGXIJDIBSFJOEJDBUFEBT7JO'JHVSF *O NBOZ DBTFT UIF SFRVJSFNFOUT EPDVNFOU EFﬁOFT UIF DPOUFYUHFOFSBM NPEFM BOE UIF DPOUFYUTQFDJﬁDNPEFMJTEFﬁOFEBTQBSUPGUIF$0/014 O "OBSDIJUFDUVSFEFTDSJQUJPOPG4NBQTUPBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPG 4 JOEJDBUFEBT7JO 'JHVSF O ThF SFRVJSFNFOUT PG TVCTZTUFNT TVDI BT 4 JO 'JHVSF JOEJDBUFE BT 7 DBO CF EFTDSJCFE BOBMPHPVTMZ UP UIF SFRVJSFNFOUT PG TZTUFN 4 'PS FYBNQMF B SFRVJSFNFOUT EPDVNFOUDBONBQUPBDPOUFYUHFOFSBMFYUFSOBMNPEFMPG4 OPUTIPXOJOUIFﬁHVSF

BOEUIFDPOUFYUTQFDJﬁDFYUFSOBMNPEFMPG4DBOCFNBQQFEUPQBSUPGUIFBSDIJUFDUVSF EFTDSJQUJPOPG4 7 299

300

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

V5: Connection among parts of encompassing system S

S

S4

S2

V4: S1 environment connection

S3

S1

S1

S1

S11

S12

S13

S14

V2: S1 as parts

V3: Connection among S1 parts

V1: S1 as whole V1..V5 = Views 1–5 associated with system of interest S1 = Port; point of interaction or connection of a system with its environment = Connector; locus of relation, connection, interaction among systems or components

Figure 12.1

Common views associated with a system of interest.

5IF TBNF SFRVJSFNFOUTBSDIJUFDUVSF EFTJHO JOUFSUXJOJOH QBUUFSO SFQFBUT BMM UIF XBZ EPXOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZPG4#VUUIJTTJNQMFNBQQJOH BMUIPVHIDMFBOBOEFMFHBOU JT OPU TVGGJDJFOU UP DBQUVSF FJUIFS UIF SFBM XPSME PG 54& SFRVJSFNFOUT EPDVNFOUT PS UIF FYQBOEFEXPSMEPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNT5IFTFDUJPOTUIBUGPMMPXEFWFMPQBNPSFDPNQSFIFOTJWF BQQSPBDI

Exploring an Environmental View of Requirements ThJTTFDUJPOQSFTFOUTNPSFSFBMJTUJDBOEDPNQSFIFOTJWFNBQQJOHTPGTZTUFNSFRVJSFNFOUTUPUIF JOUFSUXJOJOHJOUFSOBMFYUFSOBMNPEFMTUSVDUVSF5PBMMPXFYQMPSJOHPGUIFNBQQJOH XFEFDPVQMF USBEJUJPOBMSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUTGSPNFYUFSOBMJOUFSOBMNPEFMTBOEUIFOTIPXXIBUUIFNBQ QJOHJT0VSBOBMZTJTBMTPJODMVEFTEFQFOEFODJFTCFDBVTFUIBUJTBOJNQPSUBOUFMFNFOUPGUIFNBQ QJOH CVUJTPGUFOJNQMJDJUJOUSBEJUJPOBMEPDVNFOUTBOETQFDJﬁDBUJPOTThFQVSQPTFPGUIJTTFDUJPO JTUPJNQSPWFDMBSJUZCZTIPXJOHBSFBMJTUJDNBQQJOHPGSFRVJSFNFOUTUPNPEFMT BOECZNBLJOHUIF BTTPDJBUFEEFQFOEFODJFTFYQMJDJU

Examples 8FQSFTFOUGPVSFYBNQMFTPGSFRVJSFNFOUTJOUIFDPOUFYUPGUIFJOUFSUXJOJOHTUSVDUVSF"CSJFG BOBMZTJTPGUIFNBQQJOHQBUUFSOJMMVTUSBUFECZUIFTFFYBNQMFTJTHJWFOJOUIFOFYUTFDUJPO8FTUBSU XJUIBTJNQMFUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNBDBSThJTJTGPMMPXFECZUXPFYBNQMFTJOWPMWJOHQFPQMF BOECZ BEJTDVTTJPOPGUIFTBNFQBUUFSOBQQMJFEUPRVBMJUZNFUSJDT

Mapping and Uniﬁcation

O 301

Car Example 8FOPSNBMMZUIJOLPGUIFSFRVJSFNFOUPGBDBSXIBUBDBSJTSFRVJSFEUPEPBTQSPWJEJOH USBOTQPSUBUJPOGPSBGFXQFPQMFGSPNMPDBUJPO"UPMPDBUJPO#ThFBTTVNQUJPOJTUIBUUIFDBSBOE QFPQMFBSFBUMPDBUJPO" BOEUIFQFPQMFEFTJSFUPCFBUMPDBUJPO##VUMFUTFYBNJOFUIJTNPSF DMPTFMZ-FUTTFQBSBUFJUJOUPBDUVBMDBSCFIBWJPS XIBUFﬀFDUUIFDBSCFIBWJPSIBTJOJUTEJSFDUJOUFS BDUJPOXJUIUIFFOWJSPONFOU BOEXIBUJUTJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOJTXJUIUIFVTFS'PSFBDIPGUIFTF XFBMTPTQFMMPVUUIFEFQFOEFODJFT O #FIBWJPSPGDBSXIFFMTUVSOSJHIUPSMFGUPSTUSBJHIUXIFFMTSPUBUFDMPDLXJTFPSDPVOUFS DMPDLXJTFXIFFMTJODSFBTFPSEFDSFBTFSBUFPGSPUBUJPO8IBUJUEFQFOETPOGPSUIJTCFIBW JPSGVFM PSPUIFSFOFSHZTPVSDF TVDIBTCBUUFSZ BJS BTTVNJOHBOJOUFSOBMDPNCVTUJPO FOHJOF ESJWFS O %JSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUDBSNPWFTSFMBUJWFUPBTVSGBDFTVDIBTBSPBESJHIU MFGU TUSBJHIU GPSXBSE CBDLXBSEDPOTUBOUTQFFE BDDFMFSBUF EFDFMFSBUFUJSFTEPOPUNPWFSFMBUJWFUP SPBE GSJDUJPO HSJQ UJSFTNPWFSFMBUJWFUPSPBE SPUBUF NPWFBTBXIPMF 8IBUJUEFQFOET POGPSEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOEFQFOEFODJFTGPSCFIBWJPSQMVTFYJTUFODFPGBTVSGBDFTVJUBCMFGPSB DBS JODMVEJOHTVQQPSUJOHGSJDUJPOGPSDFQVMMJOHDBSBOETVSGBDFBHBJOTUFBDIPUIFS XJUIJO TPNFBDDFQUBCMFSBOHFTUSPOHFOPVHIGPSGSJDUJPOBOEHSJQUPFNFSHFCVUOPUTPTUSPOH UIBUUIFDBSJTTNBTIFEBHBJOTUUIFTVSGBDF TPVSDFTPGFOFSHZSFOFXBM FH HBTTUBUJPOTPS CBUUFSZSFDIBSHJOHTUBUJPOT BSFQPTJUJPOFEBMPOHUIFSPBEQFSJPEJDBMMZ O *OEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUUSBOTQPSUPOFUPﬁWFQFPQMFGSPN"UP#8IBUJUEFQFOETPOGPS JOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPO%FQFOEFODJFTGPSEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUQMVT4VSGBDFFYUFOETDPO UJOVPVTMZGSPN"UP#oQBTTFOHFSTBSFPOCPBSEThPTFXIPXBOUUIFDBSUPQSPWJEF UIFNXJUIBUSBOTQPSUBUJPOTFSWJDFNVTUHFUJOUPUIFDBS

Evolutionary Researcher Example 3FDBMM UIF TQFDJﬁDBUJPO PG CFIBWJPS PG UIF 4BOUB 'F SFTFBSDIFS JO FWPMVUJPOBSZ EZOBNJDT JO $IBQUFS8FNPEJGZUIFFYBNQMFTMJHIUMZUPTIPXJUTSFMBUJPOUPUIFQSFTFOUNBQQJOH4VQQPTF UIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJT (FOFSBMIBWFBOJNQBDUPOUIFDPNQMFYTZTUFNTDPNNVOJUZ 4QFDJﬁDQVCMJTIBQBQFSPOFWPMVUJPOBSZEZOBNJDTJOBSFGFSFFEKPVSOBMUIJTZFBS XIPTF RVBMJUZBOEJNQPSUJTTVDIUIBUPWFSUIFOFYUZFBST UIFQBQFSJTDJUFECZBUMFBTUUFO QBQFSTJOUIJTBOEPUIFSQSPGFTTJPOBMKPVSOBMTBOEDPOGFSFODFT PSJO$4CPPLT O #FIBWJPSPGUIFTZTUFNSFBET UBMLT MJTUFOT NBOJQVMBUFTSFTFBSDIFRVJQNFOU BOBMZ[FT XSJUFTQBQFS8IBUJUEFQFOETPOGPSUIJTCFIBWJPSBEFRVBUFIFBMUI SFTFBSDIGVOEJOH PﬃcF FRVJQNFOU LOPXMFEHFPGUIFEPNBJO BDDFTTUPMJUFSBUVSFBOEQSPGFTTJPOBMDPM MFBHVFTJOUIFEPNBJO BDDFTTUPSFTFBSDITVCKFDUT O %JSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOeﬀect:TVCNJUTQBQFSUPSFGFSFFEKPVSOBM QBQFSJTBDDFQUFEBOEQVC MJTIFE8IBUJUEFQFOETPOGPSEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOCFIBWJPSEFQFOEFODJFTQMVTFYJTUFODF BOEBWBJMBCJMJUZPGSFGFSFFEKPVSOBMXJUIJOGSBTUSVDUVSFGPSSFWJFXJOH BDDFQUJOH BOE QVCMJTIJOHQBQFSTBDDFQUBODFPGQBQFSCZUIFKPVSOBM O *OEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUIBWFBOJNQBDUPOUIF$4DPNNVOJUZ NFBTVSFECZQVCMJTIFE QBQFSSFDFJWJOHBUMFBTUUFODJUBUJPOTCZQBQFSTJOQSPGFTTJPOBMKPVSOBMTBOEDPOGFSFODFT

302

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

PSJO$4CPPLT8IBUJUEFQFOETPOGPSJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOEFQFOEFODJFTGPSEJSFDUJOUFS BDUJPOFﬀFDUQMVTBDPNNVOJUZPGFWPMVUJPOBSZEZOBNJDTBOECSPBEFS$4QSPGFTTJPOBMT FYJTUTBOESFBETUIJTKPVSOBMBOEQVCMJTIFTQBQFSTBOECPPLTNFNCFSTPGUIJTDPNNV OJUZBSFNPUJWBUFEUPDJUFUIJTQBQFSJOUIFJSQVCMJDBUJPOTGPSFYBNQMF UIFZSFDPHOJ[F UIFJNQPSUBODFPGUIFTFSFTFBSDISFTVMUTBOECVJMEPOUIFNJOUIFJSSFTFBSDI /PUFUIBUXIBUJTJOFBDIDBUFHPSZPSMFWFMEFQFOETUPTPNFEFHSFFPOXIBUUIFHPBMJT*OUIJT DBTF JGUIFHPBMIBECFFOUPTJNQMZHFUUIFQBQFSQVCMJTIFEJOBSFGFSFFEKPVSOBM UIFOUIFEJSFDU FﬀFDUXPVMECFUPXSJUFBOETVCNJUUIFQBQFS BOEUIFJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUXPVMECFUPIBWF UIFQBQFSBDDFQUFEBOEQVCMJTIFE

Employee Intervention Example 3FDBMMUIFFYBNQMFJO$IBQUFSXIFSF.JUDIQMBOOFEUPﬁSF&ECVU&MMFOJOUFSWFOFEBOEDPO WJODFE.JUDIOPUUPﬁSF&E8FDIBSBDUFSJ[FUIFJOJUJBMBDUJPOTJOUIBUFYBNQMFThFTZTUFNPG JOUFSFTUJOUIJTDBTFJT&MMFO O #FIBWJPSPGUIFTZTUFN&MMFOTQFBLTUP.JUDI8IBUJUEFQFOETPOGPSUIJTCFIBWJPSBCJMJUZ UPTQFBL O %JSFDU JOUFSBDUJPO FﬀFDU .JUDI DIBOHFT IJT NJOE BOE EFDJEFT OPU UP ﬁSF &E 8IBU JU EFQFOETPOGPSEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOCFIBWJPSEFQFOEFODJFTQMVTUIFBCJMJUZPG.JUDIUPIFBS BOEVOEFSTUBOE&MMFOTBSHVNFOU"OPUIFSMJLFMZEFQFOEFODZJTUIBU&MMFOIBTFTUBCMJTIFE BEFHSFFPGDSFEJCJMJUZXJUI.JUDI O *OEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDU&EJTOPUﬁSFE8IBUJUEFQFOETPOGPSJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPO.JUDI SFGSBJOTGSPNUBLJOHUIFQMBOOFEBDUJPOUo ﬁSF&E ThF FNQMPZFF JOUFSWFOUJPO FYBNQMF JMMVTUSBUFT UIBU UIF EJSFDU PSJOEJSFDU FﬀFDUT PG B TZTUFN CFIBWJPSDBOCFUIFBCTFODF OPUKVTUUIFQSFTFODF PGBOBDUJPOPSFWFOUThFFNQMPZFFJOUFSWFO UJPOFYBNQMFBTEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFSBMTPJOEJDBUFTUIBUUIFJOUFSQSFUBUJPOPGFﬀFDUTDBODIBOHF TJHOJﬁDBOUMZBDSPTTPCTFSWFSBOEBDSPTTUJNF TVDIUIBUUIFCFIBWJPS JTDPOTJEFSFEBTFSWJDFPSB EJTTFSWJDF

Quality Metrics "TJNJMBSQBUUFSODBOCFJMMVTUSBUFEXJUINFUSJDTTFMFDUFEGSPNUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJUFNTEFﬁOFEJO $IBQUFSThJTFYBNQMFJOWPMWFTBNPEFMPSWJFXPGRVBMJUZNFUSJDTUIBUDBOCFEFﬁOFEGPSFBDI PGUIFUISFFMFWFMT O #FIBWJPS PG TZTUFN RVBMJUZ IFSF JT PGUFO DBMMFE TZTUFN RVBMJUZ PS FOHJOFFSJOH NFUSJDT &YBNQMFTJODMVEFSFTQPOTFUJNFBOESFMJBCJMJUZPGUIFTZTUFNJUTFMG BOEBDDVSBDZPGTZTUFN PVUQVU O %JSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUBSFQSFTFOUBUJWFNFUSJDGPSUIJTJTRVBMJUZPGTFSWJDF 2P4 CFDBVTF JU JODMVEFT NFUSJDT UIBU BSF VOEFSTUPPE CZ BOE WJTJCMF UP CPUI TFSWJDF QSPWJEFS BOE DPOTVNFS O *OEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDU BOBQQSPQSJBUFNFUSJDIFSFJTRVBMJUZPGFYQFSJFODF 2P& CFDBVTF JUJTBNFBTVSFPGXIBUUIFVTFSBDUVBMMZFYQFSJFODFT UIFJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUPGXIBU BTZTUFNEPFT

Mapping and Uniﬁcation

O

303

Analysis ,VKBXTLJBOE.JMMFS BSHVFUIBUSFRVJSFNFOUTPGBTZTUFNOFFEUPHPCFZPOEFOHJOFFSJOH QSPQFSUJFT TVDI BT SFTQPOTF UJNF BDDVSBDZ BOE SFMJBCJMJUZ ThFZ NVTU BMTP JODMVEF PQFSBUJPOBM PVUDPNFT PS FﬀFDUT "T UIF BQQMJDBUJPO EJTDVTTFE JO UIFJS QBQFS XBT NJMJUBSZ DPVOUFSUFSSPSJTN TZTUFNT UIFZEFTDSJCFEFﬀFDUTTVDIBTOVNCFSPGPQQPTJOHXFBQPOTOFVUSBMJ[FEPSSFEVDUJPOJO UIFDBTVBMUJFTPGPVSGPSDFTGSPNUIFTFXFBQPOT ThFFYBNQMFTHJWFOBCPWFTIPXUIBUUIFQBUUFSOBQQMJFTNPSFHFOFSBMMZ"MMGPVSFYBNQMFT TIPXUIBUPVSJOUVJUJWFDPODFQUPGSFRVJSFNFOUTJTTQSFBEBDSPTTUISFFMFWFMTGSPNUIFTZTUFN JUTFMG UP EJSFDU JOUFSBDUJPO UP JOEJSFDU JOUFSBDUJPO XJUI UIF VTFS ThF FYBNQMFT BMTP FNQIBTJ[F EFQFOEFODJFT XIJDIWBSZXJUIUIFMFWFMT5SBEJUJPOBMMZ OPDMFBSEJTUJODUJPOIBTCFFONBEFBNPOH UIFTFMFWFMTPSUIFJSEFQFOEFODJFT XIJDITPNFUJNFTMFBETUPQPPSDPNNVOJDBUJPOBOENJTVOEFS TUBOEJOHThFVTFPGUIFFYUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBMNPEFMTPGUIFTZTUFNBOEFOWJSPONFOUIFMQTPSU CPUIUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTBOEBTTPDJBUFEEFQFOEFODJFTJOUPUIFUISFFMFWFMTBOEEJTUJOHVJTICFUXFFO UIFNThFEFQFOEFODJFTBDDVNVMBUFGSPNUIFTZTUFNCFIBWJPSMFWFM XIJDIIBTUIFGFXFTUEFQFO EFODJFT UPUIFJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOMFWFM XIJDIIBTUIFNPTU ThFNBQQJOHPGUIFTFSFRVJSFNFOUTMFWFMTUP.04&4JOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBMNPEFMTJTGBJSMZ TUSBJHIUGPSXBSEThFTZTUFNCFIBWJPSNBQTUPBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFTZTUFNThFEJSFDUJOUFS BDUJPOXJUIUIFFOWJSPONFOUNBQTUPBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPOPGUIFTZTUFNXJUIJUT FOWJSPONFOU XIJDIJTBMTPUIFQSPWJODFPGBUSBEJUJPOBM$0/014ThFJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOXJUI UIFVTFSNBQTUPBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFVTFS EFTDSJCFEBTBDPOTVNFSPGUIFJOEJSFDUFﬀFDU The FYUFSOBMspeciﬁcation JODMVEJOHUIFJOUFSGBDFspeciﬁcation) JO$IBQUFSJODMVEFETPNF JUFNTUIBUDBOHPCFZPOEUIFCFIBWJPSPGUIFTZTUFNJUTFMG speciﬁcally 2P4BOE2P&These JUFNT DBO EJSFDUMZ TVQQPSU UIF CSPBEFS TDPQF PG B SFRVJSFNFOUT WJFX UIBU FYUFOET JOUP UIF EJSFDU BOE JOEJSect eﬀects. )PXFWFS UIFSFJTBNPSFTQFDJﬁDBOETVCUMFNBQQJOHPGUSBEJUJPOBMSFRVJSFNFOUTUPFYUFSOBM NPEFMT BOEUIBUJOWPMWFTEFQFOEFODJFTThFFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTEJWJEFEJOUPUXPDBUFHPSJFT XIBUJUQSPWJEFTBOEXIBUJUSFRVJSFTUIBUJT JUTEFQFOEFODJFT5SBEJUJPOBMSFRVJSFNFOUTGPDVT POMZPOXIBUUIFTZTUFNQSPWJEFT)PXFWFS UIFSFRVJSFNFOUTDBOCFTBUJTﬁFEPOMZJGUIFEFQFO EFODJFT BSF TBUJTﬁFE ThBU JT XIZ UIF .04&4 FYUFSOBM TQFDJﬁDBUJPO FNQIBTJ[FT XIBU B TZTUFN EFQFOETPOBTXFMMBTXIBUJUQSPWJEFT ThFVQTIPUJTUIJTUPCFDPNQMJBOUXJUI.04&4 BOZ SFRVJSFNFOUTWJFX OPNBUUFSIPXGBSJOUPJOEJSFDUFﬀFDUTJUFYUFOET NVTUJEFOUJGZEFQFOEFODJFT UIBUIBWFCFFOFTUBCMJTIFEUPTVQQPSUUIFTFSWJDFTJUQSPWJEFT*OBEEJUJPO JUJTHPPEQSBDUJDFUP QSPWJEFBNBQPGEFQFOEFODJFTUPQSPWJEFETFSWJDFT JOUFSNTPGUIFUISFFDBUFHPSJFT BTXFIBWF TIPXOJOPVSFYBNQMFTTZTUFNCFIBWJPS EJSFDUFﬀFDU BOEJOEJSFDUFﬀFDU ThFMJOLCFUXFFOTFSWJDFTPﬀFSFEBOEEFQFOEFODJFT BMPOHXJUIUIF.04&4BEWJDFUPVTF QSPCBCJMJTUJDTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT UPHFUIFSMFBEUPUIFOPUJPOPGDPOEJUJPOBMQSPCBCJMJUJFTGPSFBDIMFWFM PG SFRVJSFNFOUT CFJOH TBUJTﬁFE ThF TIPSUFTU DIBJO PG DPOEJUJPOBM QSPCBCJMJUJFT XIJDI IBT UIF GFXFTUEFQFOEFODJFT JTSFﬂFDUFEJOUIFTZTUFNCFIBWJPSBOEUIFMPOHFTUDIBJO XJUIUIFNPTU EFQFOEFODJFT JT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI UIF JOEJSFDU JOUFSBDUJPOT 8F XJMM OPU EFﬁOF UIF DPOEJUJPOBM QSPCBCJMJUJFTPGUIFFYBNQMFTIFSFCVUUIFZDPVMECFMBJEPVUBMPOHUIFMJOFTPGUIFDPOEJUJPOBM QSPCBCJMJUZFYBNQMFJO$IBQUFS TFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi&YBNQMF6TJOH$POEJUJPOBM1SPCBCJMJUJFTw 4VDIBOBQQSPBDIMFOETJUTFMGUPBTTFTTJOHSJTLT JODMVEJOHUIFSJTLPGTQFDJﬁDEFQFOEFODJFTOPU CFJOHTBUJTﬁFE ThFUISVTUPGUIF,VKBXTLJBOE.JMMFS QBQFSXBTPONFUIPETPGBTTFTTJOHSJTLTPGWBSJPVT PVUDPNFTThFJSQSPCBCJMJTUJDBQQSPBDIIBTTPNFGFBUVSFTJODPNNPOXJUIUIFBCPWFBQQSPBDICVU XFHPGVSUIFSJOJEFOUJGZJOHBOEEJTUJOHVJTIJOHEFQFOEFODJFTBUUIFEJﬀFSFOUMFWFMTThFJOEJSFDU

304 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

FﬀFDUTJOPVSBQQSPBDIDPSSFMBUFBUMFBTUQBSUJBMMZXJUIUIFDPODFQUPGSFBMXPSMEFﬀFDUTPGBTFSWJDF BTEFﬁOFEJOUIF0"4*440"SFGFSFODFNPEFM 0"4*4 $PSSFTQPOEJOHUFSNTUIBUDBOCFVTFEGPSCFIBWJPSPGTZTUFN EJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPO BOEJOEJSFDU JOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUBSFCFIBWJPS SPMF BOEJNQBDU SFTQFDUJWFMZ

Opposite End of the Telescope: User Viewpoint 4VQQPTFXFDPOTJEFSBUPQEPXOTFRVFODFPGUIFUISFFMFWFMT TUBSUJOHXJUIUIFJOEJSFDUJOUFSBD UJPOFﬀFDUMFWFMThJTJTBDPNNPOQSPDFTTXIFOJEFOUJGZJOHBTJHOJﬁDBOUOFXOFFEThFHFOFSJD TFRVFODFPGMFWFMTJT O ThFJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUJTﬁSTUEFﬁOFEJOUFSNTPGBQSPCMFN BVTFSPQFSBUJPOBM OFFE BHBQCFUXFFODVSSFOUBOEEFTJSFETUBUFThJTMFWFMIBTUIFMBSHFTUQPUFOUJBMTPMVUJPO TQBDFOPTQFDJﬁDTPMVUJPOJTJEFOUJﬁFEZFU.VMUJQMFBMUFSOBUJWFTPMVUJPOTNBZFYJTU O ThFEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUJTUIFOEFﬁOFEJOUFSNTPGPQFSBUJPOBMSFRVJSFNFOUT"TPMV UJPOTZTUFNJTJEFOUJﬁFEThFEFTDSJQUJPOJTJOUFSNTPGSFRVJSFEJOUFSBDUJPOPGUIFTZTUFN XJUIUIFVTFSPS NPSFHFOFSBMMZ UIFFOWJSPONFOUThJTXPVMENBQBQQSPYJNBUFMZUPBO JOUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFFOWJSPONFOUPS$0/014 O 'JOBMMZ UIFBDUVBMCFIBWJPSPGUIFTZTUFNJTEFﬁOFE UIBUJT XIBUUIFTZTUFNDBOEPJGJUT EJSFDUEFQFOEFODJFTBSFTBUJTﬁFE ThFDBSFYBNQMFXJMMCFEFWFMPQFEGSPNUIJTWJFXQPJOU. ThFTFRVFODFJTBTGPMMPXT $VSSFOUTJUVBUJPOQFSTPO1JTBUMPDBUJPO" %FTJSFETJUVBUJPO1JTBUMPDBUJPO# 3FRVJSFNFOUT3BTPMVUJPOTIBMMDIBOHFUIFDVSSFOUTJUVBUJPOJOUPUIFEFTJSFETJUVBUJPO UIBUJT TIBMMUSBOTQPSU1GSPN"UP#p 4PNFQPTTJCMFTPMVUJPOBQQSPBDIFTGPS3 B 1XBMLTGSPN"UP# C 1SJEFTCJDZDMFGSPN"UP# D 1UBLFTQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUBUJPOTVDIBTBTVCXBZPSCVTGSPN"UP# E P ﬂJFTJOBOBJSQMBOFGSPN"UP# F 1UBLFTBCPBUGSPN"UP# G 1UBLFTBUBYJGSPN"UP# H 1SJEFTJOBQFSTPOBMDBSGSPN"UP# " USBEF TUVEZ JT EPOF UIBU DPOTJEFST WBSJBCMFT TVDI BT EJTUBODF GSPN " UP # UJNF DPO TUSBJOUT PO HFUUJOH GSPN " UP # BWBJMBCJMJUZ PG QPUFOUJBM TPMVUJPOT DPTU SFMJBCJMJUZ BOE GSFRVFODZ JTUIJTBPOFUJNFOFFE PSXJMMUIJTOFFESFDVSEBJMZPSXFFLMZ #BTFEPOUIFBOBMZTJT H JTTFMFDUFEBTUIFTPMVUJPOBQQSPBDI4GPS3 XIJDIDBOOPXCF TUBUFENPSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZBT3BQFSTPOBMDBSTIBMMUSBOTQPSU1GSPN"UP#JOUPUBMFMBQTFE UJNFa5 BTTVNJOHUIFEFQFOEFODJFTBSFTBUJTﬁFEThFTFUPGEFQFOEFODJFTIFSFDPSSFTQPOET UPUIFJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUEFQFOEFODJFTHJWFOQSFWJPVTMZJOUIFDBSFYBNQMF %FQFOEFODJFTBSFNFOUJPOFEJOUIJTMJTU CVUBSFOPUJOEJWJEVBMMZSFQFBUFEThFTFUPGEFQFOEFODJFTXBTJUFNJ[FE JOUIFFBSMJFSDBSFYBNQMFEFTDSJQUJPO p 3FDBMMGSPNUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUEJTDVTTJPOJO$IBQUFSUIBU“TPMVUJPO”NFBOTUIFTPMVUJPOJTVOJEFOUJﬁFE

PSVODPOTUSBJOFE

Mapping and Uniﬁcation

O 305

"GVSUIFSUSBEFTUVEZJTEPOFUPEFUFSNJOFXIFUIFSUPCPSSPX CVJME MFBTF PSCVZBDBS ThFTFMFDUFEBQQSPBDIJTUPCVZBDBS/PX3DBOCFTQFDJBMJ[FEGVSUIFSJOUP3B QVSDIBTFEDBSTIBMMUSBOTQPSU1GSPN"UP#JOUPUBMFMBQTFEUJNFa5 BTTVNJOHUIFHJWFO EFQFOEFODJFTBSFTBUJTﬁFE B %FQFOEFODJFTTBNFBTJO QMVTPOFBDBSUIBUTBUJTﬁFT3JTBWBJMBCMFGPSQVSDIBTF /PXXFEFSJWFBSFRVJSFNFOU3UIBUDPOTUSBJOTXIBUUIFDBSNVTUCFBCMFUPEPPO UIFSPBECVZBDBSUIBUTBUJTﬁFTUIFTFDPOTUSBJOUTXJUIQSPCBCJMJUZq BTTVNJOHUIF EFQFOEFODJFTBSFTBUJTﬁFEThFTFUPGEFQFOEFODJFTIFSFDPSSFTQPOETUPUIFEJSFDUJOUFSBD UJPOFﬀFDUEFQFOEFODJFTHJWFOQSFWJPVTMZJOUIFDBSFYBNQMF B $BOUVSOBUTUSFFUDPSOFST GSPNBTUSFFUJOUPBESJWFXBZ BOEJOUPBQBSLJOHTQBDFJOB QBSLJOHMPU BOENBLFB6UVSOPOBGPPUXJEFTUSFFU C $BOHPGPSXBSEPSCBDLXBSEPOBSPBE D $BOQSPWJEFTVﬃcJFOUGPSDFPOXIFFMTUPBDIJFWFBDDFMFSBUJPOq"POSPBEXJUIHSBEF VQUPJODMJOFXIFODPFﬃcJFOUPGGSJDUJPOq' E $BOQSPWJEFTVﬃcJFOUGPSDFPOXIFFMTUPBDIJFWFEFDFMFSBUJPOq%POSPBEXJUIHSBEF VQUPEFDMJOFXIFODPFﬃcJFOUPGGSJDUJPOq' F $BOHFOFSBUFBOETVTUBJOTVﬃDJFOUTQFFEUPESJWFUIFTQFFEMJNJU "TTVNQUJPOUIJT DBQBCJMJUZFOBCMFTUIFDBS GPSFYBNQMF UPUSBWFSTFUIFSPVUFGSPN"UP#JOUPUBMFMBQTFE UJNFa5

G )BTPQFSBUJOHSBOHFqNJMFT FH SBOHFCFUXFFOTUPQTOFFEFEUPﬁMMGVFMUBOL PSSFDIBSHFCBUUFSJFT /PXXFEFSJWFBSFRVJSFNFOU3UIBUDPOTUSBJOTXIBUUIFDBSNVTUCFBCMFUPEP POJUTPXO XIJDIJTFTTFOUJBMMZUPUVSOJUTXIFFMTCVZBDBSUIBUTBUJTﬁFTUIFTFDPOTUSBJOUT XJUIQSPCBCJMJUZq BTTVNJOHUIFEFQFOEFODJFTBSFTBUJTﬁFEThFTFUPGEFQFOEFODJFT IFSFDPSSFTQPOETUPUIFDBSCFIBWJPSEFQFOEFODJFTHJWFOQSFWJPVTMZJOUIFDBSFYBNQMF B )BTUVSOJOHSBEJVTa3 C $BODBVTFBUMFBTUUXPPGJUTXIFFMTUPSFWPMWFJOFJUIFSBDMPDLXJTFPSDPVOUFSDMPDLXJTF EJSFDUJPO XJUIUIJTDPOTUSBJOUBMMUIFXIFFMTUIFDBSDBVTFTUPSPUBUFNVTUSPUBUFJOUIF TBNFEJSFDUJPOBUBHJWFOUJNFUIBUJT UIFDBSJTQSPIJCJUFEGSPNDBVTJOHPOFXIFFMUP SPUBUFDMPDLXJTFBOEBOPUIFSXIFFMUPTJNVMUBOFPVTMZSPUBUFDPVOUFSDMPDLXJTF D $BOBQQMZGPSDF'"POXIFFMTUPBDIJFWFBDDFMFSBUJPO E $BOBQQMZGPSDF'%POXIFFMTUPBDIJFWFEFDFMFSBUJPO F 'VFMUBOLIBTDBQBDJUZ$ JOHBMMPOT BOEFYQFDUFENJMFBHFJT3 JOOVNCFSPGXIFFM SFWPMVUJPOTQFSHBMMPO

TVDIUIBU$r3q8XIFFMSFWPMVUJPOTPSCBUUFSZDIBSHFJT TVﬃcJFOUUPMBTUq8XIFFMSFWPMVUJPOT 8JTDBMDVMBUFEUPZJFMENJMFTJGUIFDBS UJSFTNPVOUFEPOUIFXIFFMTBSFJODPOUBDUXJUIBSPBEXIJMFUIFZBSFSFWPMWJOH

*UFN EFﬁOFTUIFJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUBT3 USBOTQPSU1GSPN"UP# *UBMMPXTBMBSHF OVNCFSPGQPUFOUJBMTPMVUJPOT BTUIFQBSUJBMMJTUJOJUFN TIPXTThFJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDU JTJMMVTUSBUFEXJUIJODSFBTJOHTQFDJﬁDJUZBT3JOJUFN QFSTPOBMDBS BOE3JOJUFN QVSDIBTFEQFSTPOBMDBS 3JOJUFN EFﬁOFTUIFEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOCFIBWJPSPGUIFDBSPO BSPBE'JOBMMZ 3JOJUFN EFﬁOFTUIFTZTUFNCFIBWJPSUVSOJUTXIFFMT 8IZEJEXFOPUKVTUSFEFﬁOF3BUFBDIQPJOU JOTUFBEPGHJWJOHJUBEJﬀFSFOUNPSFTQFDJBMJ[FEJEFOUJUZ 3 FUD BU FBDI QPJOU ThF BOTXFS JT UIBU XF XBOU UP QSFTFSWF UIF NPSF HFOFSBM NPEFMT BT XFMM BT USBEF TUVEZ JOGPSNBUJPO CFDBVTFDJSDVNTUBODFTNBZDIBOHFJOUIFGVUVSFUIBUDBVTFVTUPHPCBDLVQUPBNPSFHFOFSBM SFRVJSFNFOUBOd ﬁOEBEJﬀFSFOUTPMVUJPO8FXBOUUPSFUBJOBMMPQUJPOTBOEBMMBOBMZTFT

306

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThVT UIFDBSDBOPOMZUVSOJUTXIFFMTGPSXBSE CBDLXBSE PSTJEFUPTJEF*GJUJTUPNPWFPOB SPBE PSUSBOTQPSUQFPQMF NVMUJQMFBEEJUJPOBMEFQFOEFODJFTNVTUCFTBUJTﬁFEThJTNFBOTUIBUBO FYUFSOBMNPEFMPGBDBSDBOPOMZEFTDSJCFCFIBWJPSPGJUTXIFFMTBOEUJSFT'PSFYBNQMF BOFYUFSOBM NPEFMDBOEFTDSJCFUIFOVNCFSPGUJSFSPUBUJPOTQFSCBUUFSZDIBSHFPSQFSUBOLPGGVFM CVUJUDBOOPU EFTDSJCFNJMFTQFSHBMMPOThBUNFUSJDFYJTUTJOUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPOPGBDBSXJUIJUT FOWJSPONFOU)PXFWFS BSFRVJSFNFOUTNPEFMDBOJODMVEFNJMFTQFSHBMMPOBOE JOGBDU BOZPGUIF JUFNTGSPN3UP3 BOEFWFOCFZPOEUIJTUPJUFNTJOUFSOBMUPUIFDBS BTXFEJTDVTTMBUFS TherFJTBOPUIFSJNQPSUBOUNBQQJOH JMMVTUSBUFE JO UIF BCPWF FYBNQMF OBNFMZ VTFS SFRVJSF NFOUTWFSTVTUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHTQFD5SBEJUJPOBMMZ XFUIJOLPGVTFSTdeﬁning XIBUUIFZXBOU JOUIFJSUFSNT BOEUIFOFOHJOFFSTQFSGPSNJOHTZTUFNTBOBMZTJTBOESFRVJSFNFOUTBOBMZTJT JODMVEJOH USBEFTUVEJFT UPQSPEVDFBOFOHJOFFSJOHspeciﬁcation PGXIBUUIFTZTUFNNVTUEPThat TFRVFODF JTPOFWJFXPGUIFBCPWFFYBNQMFUIFVTFSSFRVJSFNFOUTBSFdeﬁned JOJUFNT

BOEo UIFUSBEFBMUFSOBUJWFTBOEUSBEFTUVEJFTBSFQSFTFOUFEJOJUFNT UISPVHI BOEUIFFOHJOFFS JOHspeciﬁcation JTTVNNBSJ[FEJOJUFN 5SBEJUJPOBMMZ JUFN XPVMEBMTPCFJODMVEFEJOUIF engineering speciﬁcation. 8F NVTU BDLOPXMFEHF UIBU UIF OPSNBM QSPDFTT PG B QFSTPO CVZJOH B DBS XPVME OPU JOWPMWF BMMUIFGPSFHPJOHBOBMZTJTPSBMMUIFEJTUJODUJPOT"DBSJTBDPNNPEJUZXIPTFCBTJDGVODUJPOTBOE EFQFOEFODJFTBSFBTTVNFEBOEBMNPTUBMXBZTMFGUJNQMJDJU8FBDUVBMMZGPDVTPOBFTUIFUJDTTVDIBT DPMPSBOETUZMF BOEJUFNTTVDIBTVQHSBEJOHUIF$%QMBZFSThJTFYBNQMFIBTGPDVTFETUSJDUMZPO UIFFOHJOFFSJOHBTQFDUTPGUIFGVODUJPOBMCBTJDTPGBDBS ThFQPJOUJTUPVTFUIFTUSVDUVSFQSPWJEFE JOUIFNPEFMTQBDF BOEJOUIJTDPOUFYUFTQFDJBMMZUIFDPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPO UPIFMQTPSUPVUBOE DMBSJGZUIFDPOUFOUTPGBUSBEJUJPOBMBSUJGBDUTVDIBTBSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUBOECSJOHEFQFOEFO DJFTNPSFTUSPOHMZJOUPUIFQJDUVSFThFUFDIOJRVFJTPWFSLJMMGPSCVZJOHPSFWFOFOHJOFFSJOHBDBS #VUJGTPNFUIJOHBTNVOEBOFBOEXFMMVOEFSTUPPEBTBDBSIBTUIJTNVDIUFYUVSFBOEUIJTNBOZ EJTUJODUJPOT UIFONPSFDPNQMFYTZTUFNTPSEPNBJOTUIBUBSFOPUXFMMVOEFSTUPPENJHIUCFOFﬁU GSPNUIFUFDIOJRVF

Indirect Effect Requirements and Correspondence Set ThFUSBEJUJPOBMSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUJTWJSUVBMMZBMXBZTDPVQMFEXJUIBTZTUFNPSDBUFHPSZPG TZTUFNT BOEXJUIBOFOWJSPONFOUPSDBUFHPSZPGFOWJSPONFOUTThJTNFBOTUIBUUIFDPSSFTQPO EFODFTFU\. .1 8 4^IBTCFFOEFﬁOFEBUUIFDPODFQUJPOPGUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOU FWFO JGJNQMJDJUMZ XIFSF.JTUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOU UIFNPEF.1JTiTIBMMw 8JTUIFJOUFOEFE FOWJSPONFOU BOE4JTUIFJOUFOEFETZTUFNXIJDIPGUFOEPFTOPUFYJTUXIFOUIJTDPSSFTQPO EFODFTFUJTDPODFJWFE )PXFWFS SFRVJSFNFOUTJOUIFGPSNPGVMUJNBUFVTFSOFFETBOEFﬀFDUTBSFVTVBMMZEFﬁOFEJO UFSNTPGUIFVTFS OPUJOUFSNTPGBTZTUFNTBUJTGZJOHUIPTFOFFETPSBDIJFWJOHUIPTFFﬀFDUTThF VTFSOFFEJTUPCFUSBOTQPSUFEGSPN"UP#)PXUIBUJTBDIJFWFEJTOPUQBSUPGUIFVTFSFﬀFDUT NPEFM8IBUEPFTDPSSFTQPOEFODFNFBOJOUIJTTJUVBUJPO BOEXIBUEPSFRVJSFNFOUTNFBO 8FOPXEFTDSJCFUIFDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUTGPSUIFUSBOTQPSUBUJPOBOEFWPMVUJPOBSZSFTFBSDIFS FYBNQMFT BOEVTFUIPTFUPBOTXFSUIFGPSFHPJOHRVFTUJPOT 5SBOTQPSUBUJPOFYBNQMF6TFSOFFEFﬀFDUVTFS6OFFETUPHFUGSPNMPDBUJPO"UPMPDBUJPO# N . 1SFDPOEJUJPO6JTBU"UJNF51PTUDPOEJUJPO6JTBU#BUUJNF5 XIFSF "w# BOE5o5a1 BOE1JTBUJNFQFSJPE TVDIBTNJOVUFTPSIPVSTPS EBZT *UNJHIUCFUIBU"BOE#BSFOPUTJOHMFﬁYFEQPJOUTUIFZNBZSFQSFTFOUTFUT PGMPDBUJPOT BOEBTJOHMFFMFNFOUGSPNFBDINBZCFTFMFDUFEFBDIEBZPSFBDIIPVS

Mapping and Uniﬁcation

O

307

N .1TIBMM TBUJTGZ.

N 8XPSMEJOXIJDI6 " BOE#FYJTUBU5 N $BTF4OPTPMVUJPOIBTCFFOJEFOUJﬁFE N $BTF44BOJEFOUJﬁFETZTUFN TVDIBTBDBS &WPMVUJPOBSZSFTFBSDIFSFYBNQMF6TFS6FWPMVUJPOBSZEZOBNJDTDPNNVOJUZ6TFSFﬀFDU 6 QVCMJTIFT BU MFBTU UFO QVCMJDBUJPOT UIBU SFGFSFODF UIF SFTFBSDIFST QBQFS JO UIF OFYU ZFBST N .1SFDPOEJUJPOQBQFSJTQVCMJTIFEBUUJNF5OPPOFJO6IBTDJUFEJU1PTUDPOEJUJPO BUMFBTUUFO6QVCMJDBUJPOTIBWFDJUFEUIFQBQFSBUUJNF5 XIFSF5o5aZFBST N .1TIBMM TBUJTGZ. N 8XPSMEJOXIJDI6BOEUIFQBQFSFYJTUEVSJOHUIFQFSJPEGSPN5UP5 BOE6 QSPEVDFTQVCMJDBUJPOTEVSJOHUIFQFSJPEGSPN5UP5 N $BTF4 N $BTF4 4BOJEFOUJﬁFETZTUFN TVDIBTBSFTFBSDIFSDBQBCMFPGQSPEVDJOHB QBQFSUIBUBDIJFWFTUIJTFﬀFDUTQFDJﬁDBMMZUIF4BOUB'FSFTFBSDIFS ThFTFDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUTMPPLMJLFiOPSNBMwDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUTCVUUIFZEJﬀFSJOBUMFBTU POFXBZThFNPEFM.JOBDPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUVTVBMMZJTTFFOBTBNPEFMPGUIFTZTUFN4JOUIF DPSSFTQPOEFODFTFU#VUJOUIJTDBTF UIFNPEFM.JTBNPEFMPGUIFFﬀFDUPOUIFVTFSPGBOJNQMJFE TPMVUJPO"TTUBUFEQSFWJPVTMZJOUIFBOBMZTJTTFDUJPO .JTUIFSFGPSFBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFVTFS OPUBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFTPMVUJPOPSTZTUFN The SFRVJSFNFOUTBSFBTPMVUJPO XIFUIFSidentiﬁed PSOPU TIBMMEPTPNFUIJOHUPDBVTFPS inﬂuence UIFVTFSeﬀects UPIBQQFOHJWFOUIBUUIFQSPQFSEFQFOEFODJFTPGUIFTPMVUJPOUP BDIJFWFUIFTFeﬀects BSFsatisﬁed. *OUIFDBTFXIFSFBTPMVUJPO4IBTCFFOidentiﬁed, BMMVTFS eﬀects DBO CF BMMPDBUFE BT SFRVJSFNFOUT PG 4 #VU BT TUBUFE QSFWJPVTMZ JG UIF EFDJTJPO JT UP JODMVEFVTFSFﬀFDUTJOBTZTUFNSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOU UIFEPDVNFOUNVTUCFVOBNCJHVPVT BOEDMFBSBCPVUUIFEFQFOEFODJFTPG4POUIFVTFSBOEPUIFSFMFNFOUTPGUIFFOWJSPONFOUJO PSEFSUPBDIJFWe the eﬀects.

CS Actualization *U UVSOT PVU UIBU UIF 4& JOTUJODUT UIBU TFQBSBUF UIF SFRVJSFNFOUT PG B TZTUFN BOE FYUFOE UIFN JOUP EJSFDU PS JOEJSFDU JOUFSBDUJPO FﬀFDUT XJUI UIF FOWJSPONFOU TFSWF VT XFMM XIFO XF DPOTJEFS FOHJOFFSJOHDPNQMFYTZTUFNT%VFUPBVUPOPNZ TVDITZTUFNTSFRVJSFNPSFFOWJSPONFOUTIBQJOH UIBOEJSFDUTZTUFNFOHJOFFSJOH TPUIFJOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPOJTBQQSPQSJBUFGPSUIBUThFFYBNQMFPG UIFFWPMVUJPOBSZSFTFBSDIFSHJWFOBCPWFJMMVTUSBUFTUIFBQQSPBDI8FEPOPUUFMMBQFSTPOPSPUIFS BVUPOPNPVTBHFOUXIBUCFIBWJPSUIFZTIPVMEFYIJCJUXFUFMMUIFNXIBUFﬀFDUXFXPVMEMJLFUIFN UPBDIJFWF PSUIFZEFDJEFXIBUFﬀFDUUIFZXPVMEMJLFUPBDIJFWF

Other Engineering Mappings Exploring Requirements by Looking Inward "USBEJUJPOBMSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUDBOJODMVEFOPUPOMZSFRVJSFNFOUTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIFFOWJ SPONFOUPGUIFTZTUFN CVUBMTPSFRVJSFNFOUTBOEDPOTUSBJOUTPOUIFJOUFSOBMEFTJHOPSBSDIJUFD UVSFPGUIFTZTUFN$PNNPOFYBNQMFTJODMVEFBSFRVJSFNFOUUIBUBHJWFOTUBOEBSENVTUCFVTFE

308 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

JOUIFTZTUFNPSUIFTZTUFNJTDPOTUSBJOFEUPVTJOHBDFSUBJOUFDIOPMPHZPSJOUIFDBTFPGTPGUXBSF BMMUIFTPGUXBSFNVTUCFXSJUUFOJOBDFSUBJOMBOHVBHF 8IJMFUIJTJTBDDFQUFEBOEUPTPNFFYUFOUMFHJUJNBUFQSBDUJDFJOUIFDPOUFYUPG54& JUOFFETUP CFSFWJTJUFEJOUIFCSPBEFSDPOUFYUPGUIFGVUVSF4&BOEFTQFDJBMMZGPS$4ThFEBOHFSJOPWFSDPO TUSBJOJOH$4JOUFSOBMTJTUIBUJUUFOETUPJOUFSGFSFXJUIBVUPOPNPVTBDUJWJUJFTMJLFTFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPO BOEUIFHFOFSBUJPOPGFNFSHFOUQSPQFSUJFTBOECFIBWJPS

Resulting Requirements Mapping Spectrum 8FIBWFMPPLFEBUUXPTFQBSBUFDPOUJOVVNTSFHBSEJOHIPXBSFRVJSFNFOUTTQFDFYUFOETBOFYUFS OBMTQFD8FMPPLFEFYUFOTJWFMZBUUIFPVUXBSENBQQJOH BOECSJFﬂZBUUIFJOXBSENBQQJOH O 0VUXBSEPOFDPOUJOVVNJTBOFYUFOTJPOJOUPUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIF TZTUFNFOWJSPO NFOU JODMVEJOH UIF FYUFSOBM NPEFM PG UIF VTFS UP EFﬁOF DPOTUSBJOUT BOE FﬀFDUT 0OF FYUSFNF FOE PG UIJT TQFDUSVN JT B QVSF FYUFSOBM TZTUFN TQFD XIJDI JODMVEFT POMZ TZT UFN CFIBWJPS EFQFOEFODJFT BOE TQFDJﬁFT POMZ XIBU HPFT JO BOE DPNFT PVU PG UIF TZT UFNCPVOEBSJFTQPSUTThFPUIFSFYUSFNFEFﬁOFTUIFDPNQMFUFFOWJSPONFOU UIFJOEJSFDU JOUFSBDUJPOFﬀFDUTPOUIFVTFS O *OXBSEUIFPUIFSDPOUJOVVNJTUIFQSFWJPVTMZBDLOPXMFEHFEFYUFOTJPOJOUPUIFJOUFSOBM NPEFMPGUIFTZTUFN UPQMBDFDPOTUSBJOUTPOJU0OFFYUSFNFFOEPGUIJTTQFDUSVNJTBQVSF FYUFSOBMTQFD XIJDIQMBDFTOPJOUFSOBMDPOTUSBJOUTThFPUIFSFYUSFNFJTXIFSFUIFFOUJSF EFTJHOPSJOUFSOBMNPEFMJTTQFDJﬁFEJOUIFFYUFSOBMNPEFM BOEUIFJOUFSOBMPGFBDIQBSU BOETPPOBMMUIFXBZEPXOUPUIFCPUUPNPGUIFDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZ &MFNFOUTBDSPTTUIJTFOUJSFTQFDUSVNDBOCFJODPSQPSBUFEJOUPBSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOU)PXFWFS BTNFOUJPOFEBCPWF FYUFOEJOHPVUXBSEJTJONBOZDBTFTCFUUFSQSBDUJDFUIBOJTFYUFOEJOHJOXBSE FTQFDJBMMZGPSDPNQMFYTZTUFNT

Mapping Interaction Artifacts ThF$0/014EPDVNFOUNBQTGBJSMZDMFBOMZUPUIFFOWJSPONFOUSFMBUJPONPEFM7JO'JHVSF BMUIPVHIJUDPVMENBOEBUFPUIFSDPOTUSBJOUTPOUIFTZTUFNBSDIJUFDUVSF ThFBSDIJUFDUVSFEFTDSJQUJPONBQTTJNQMJTUJDBMMZUPUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFMPG4 XIJDIJT7JO 'JHVSF/PUFUIBUUIJTJOUFSOBMNPEFM BTBMMJOUFSOBMNPEFMT JODMVEFTUIFFYUFSOBMNPEFMT PGJUTQBSUT JOEJDBUFEJO'JHVSFBT7ThJTJTXIFSFJUTUPQT)PXFWFS UIFSFBMJTUJDNBQQJOH PGBOBSDIJUFDUVSFDBOESJWFEPXOBMMUIFXBZUPUIFCPUUPNPGUIFDPNQPTJUJPOTUBDLCZJNQPT JOHDPOTUSBJOUTPOBMMFMFNFOUTPGUIFTZTUFN BOBMPHPVTUPUIFJOXBSEMPPLJOHFYUFOTJPOPGUIF SFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOU

Signiﬁcance of the Overall Engineering Mapping ThFFOHJOFFSJOHNBQQJOHFYBNQMFTBOEBOBMZTJTQSFTFOUFEJOUIJTTFDUJPOIBWFTIPXOUIBU.04&4 DMBSJﬁFTDFSUBJOBTQFDUTPGUSBEJUJPOBMBSUJGBDUT BOEQMBDFTTPNFDPOTUSBJOUTPOUIFNCVUBMTPBMMPXT DPOTJEFSBCMFﬂFYJCJMJUZJOUIFN4FWFSBMTJHOJﬁDBOUGFBUVSFTPGUIFNBQQJOHDBOCFJEFOUJﬁFE&BDI JTQSFTFOUFEBOECSJFﬂZEJTDVTTFEJOUIFGPMMPXJOHTVCTFDUJPOT

Mapping and Uniﬁcation

O 309

The Mapping Makes Dependencies Clear 8FTUBUFEUIBUUIFiQSPWJEFTwBOEiSFRVJSFTwTUSVDUVSFPGBOFYUFSOBMJOUFSGBDFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOHPFT CFZPOEUSBEJUJPOBMSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUTUPTQFDJGZEFQFOEFODJFT3FRVJSFNFOUTUIBUDPNQMZ XJUI.04&4NVTUNBLFUIFEFQFOEFODJFTDMFBSJOUIFTQFDJﬁDBUJPO XIFUIFSUIFZBSFUIFNJOJ NBMEFQFOEFODJFTPGTZTUFNCFIBWJPSPSUIFNBYJNVNEFQFOEFODJFTPGJOEJSFDUFﬀFDUT ,OPXMFEHFPGUIFTFEFQFOEFODJFTBOEIPXUIFZBSFBMMPDBUFEBSFFTTFOUJBMGPSBEFRVBUFUFTUJOH *UJTSFMBUJWFMZTJNQMFUPEFﬁOFUFTUTGPSTZTUFNCFIBWJPSCFDBVTFUIFEFQFOEFODJFTBSFNJOJNBM#VU EFQFOEFODJFTPGJOEJSFDUFﬀFDUTDBOCFTVCTUBOUJBM BOEJGUIFZBSFOPUVOEFSTUPPE UFTUJOHDBOCF WFSZDPNQMJDBUFEBOEVOGPDVTFE BOEUIFSFTVMUTIBSEUPJOUFSQSFU $PNQMJBODFJTBDUVBMMZCBTFEPOFTUBCMJTIFEEFQFOEFODJFTThJTSFGFSTUPUIFGBDUUIBUJOTPNF WJFXT OPEFQFOEFODJFTIBWFCFFOFTUBCMJTIFE*OUIF3SFRVJSFNFOUTWJFXPGUIFDBSFYBNQMFJO UIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi0QQPTJUF&OEPGUIF5FMFTDPQF6TFS7JFXQPJOU wOPTPMVUJPOJTJEFOUJﬁFE POMZUIFJOEJSFDUFﬀFDU/PEFQFOEFODJFTBSFFTUBCMJTIFEJOUIJTWJFX8IFOTPMVUJPOTBSFJOUSP EVDFE BTJO B UISPVHI H

FBDIPGUIFNJOUSPEVDFTJUTPXOTFUPGEFQFOEFODJFTThFUSBEFPﬀ BOBMZTJTDPOTJEFSTCPUIXIBUFBDITPMVUJPOQSPWJEFTBOEXIBUJUTEFQFOEFODJFTBSF

All Artifacts Are Views of the Model Space Structure #FDBVTFUSBEJUJPOBMBSUJGBDUTDBOSBOHFBDSPTTUIFDPNQPTJUJPOTQFDUSVN CPUIVQBOEEPXOGSPN UIFQPJOUPGJOUFSFTU XIBUNFDIBOJTNDBOXFVTFUPNPEFMUIFN ThFBOTXFSJTWJFX"MMBSUJGBDUT JODMVEJOH$0/014 SFRVJSFNFOUT BSDIJUFDUVSF BOEEFTJHO BSFWJFXTPGUIFJOUFSUXJOJOHDPN QPTJUJPOTUSVDUVSFUIBUDBOFYUFOEXFMMCFZPOEBOPNJOBMJOUFSOBMPSFYUFSOBMNPEFMThFNBQ QJOHBMTPNBLFTUIFUBSHFUPGUIFWJFXDMFBSJUJTOPUBMXBZTUIFTZTUFNPGJOUFSFTU*OBEEJUJPO UIF FYUFSOBMJOUFSOBMTUSVDUVSFPG.04&4DPNQPTJUJPONBLFTDMFBSFBDIPGUIFFMFNFOUTPGUIFWJFX BSUJGBDU BOEIPXUIFZSFMBUFUPFBDIPUIFS /PUFUIBUUIFUSFBUNFOUPGUSBEJUJPOBMBSUJGBDUTBTWJFXTJTSFJOGPSDFECZUIFGBDUUIBUUIFBSUJ GBDUTDBOBMTPWBSZBDSPTTPUIFSNPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOT'PSFYBNQMF BOZPGUIFBSUJGBDUTDBOWBSZ JOTQFDJﬁDJUZ XIJDIJTTVQQPSUFEJOUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOEJNFOTJPO ThFMBUJUVEFHJWFOUIFBSUJGBDUTSBJTFTQPUFOUJBMPWFSMBQTBOEDPOﬂJDUTCFUXFFOUIFEPDVNFOUT PSWJFXT(PPEQSBDUJDFJTUPEFﬁOFCPVOEBSJFTCFUXFFOUIFNTPOPPWFSMBQTFYJTU#VUJGPWFSMBQT BSFBMMPXFE UIFZNVTUCFBEKVEJDBUFEUPCFDPOTJTUFOU PSCFUUFSZFU UPEFDJEFGPSFBDISVMFPS DPOTUSBJOUXIJDIWJFXJTUIFPXOFS BOEUIFPUIFSTSFGFSFODFJUThFPXOFSJTSFTQPOTJCMFGPSDPO ﬁHVSBUJPONBOBHFNFOUPGUIFSVMF'PSFYBNQMF JGUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOUEFﬁOFTFOWJSPO NFOUFﬀFDUT XIJDIJTUSBEJUJPOBMMZUIFQSPWJODFPGUIF$0/014 BOBHSFFNFOUTIPVMECFNBEF POXIJDIJTUIFPXOFSPGUIJTSVMF&WFONPSFPWFSMBQDBOPDDVSPOUIFJOXBSETJEFJGCPUIUIF SFRVJSFNFOUTWJFXBOEUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFXXBOUUPDPOTUSBJOBMMUIFXBZEPXOUIFDPNQPTJUJPO IJFSBSDIZ'PSFYBNQMF CPUINBZNBOEBUFUIBUBDFSUBJOTUBOEBSECFVTFEBUBMMMFWFMT"EFDJTJPO TIPVMECFNBEFBTUPXIFUIFSUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTWJFXPSUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFXPXOTUIJTSVMF

SE General Problem Solving 4PNFSFRVJSFNFOUTBSFTUBUFEBTBNPEFMPGBVTFSSBUIFSUIBOBTBNPEFMPGBTZTUFN"TZTUFNT FOHJOFFS NVTU EFﬁOF BOE BTTFTT QPTTJCMF TPMVUJPOT BOE EFUFSNJOF XIFUIFS UIF TPMVUJPO TIPVME JOWPMWFBO4&TZTUFN5BCMFTIPXTUIFQBUUFSOThFBOBMZTJTPG B JODMVEFTBWBSJFUZPGQPT TJCMFTPMVUJPOT NBOZPGUIFNOPU4&TZTUFNTThFDBSFYBNQMFJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi0QQPTJUF &OEPGUIF5FMFTDPQF6TFS7JFXQPJOUwMJTUFEBWBSJFUZPGTPMVUJPOT4VQQPTFUIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFS

310 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Table 12.1

Pre-Systems Problem Solving

Traditional Artifact

Level

a. Need or gap

Indirect effect

b. CONOPS

Direct effect

c. Requirements speciﬁcation

System behavior

MOSES Model External model of user (but not a requirement of the user) Internal model of interaction of system with its environment External model of system

BTTFTTFE UIF QPTTJCMF TPMVUJPOT BOE CBTFE PO UIF TJUVBUJPO SFDPNNFOEFE B XBML *G UIJT TPMVUJPOXFSFBEPQUFE JUXPVMEQSPCBCMZOPUCFDPOTJEFSFEBO4&TZTUFN%FDJEJOHXIFUIFSBO 4&TZTUFNJTOFFEFEBTUIFTPMVUJPOUPBQSPCMFNJTQBSUPG4& BOEJUJODMVEFTUIFNPEFMUZQFJO SPX B JO5BCMF*OSPX B

OPTZTUFNPSTPMVUJPOJTJEFOUJﬁFEJOSPX C BOE D

BTZTUFNJT JEFOUJﬁFEBTUIFTPMVUJPO ThFQPJOUJTUIBUQBSUPGUIFXPSLPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTJTHFOFSBMQSPCMFNTPMWJOH BTPQQPTFE UPFOHJOFFSJOHPSBDUVBMJ[JOHBTZTUFNQFSTFThFHFOFSBMQSPCMFNTPMWJOHXPSL IPXFWFS EPFT PDDVSJOUIFDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF

Autonomous Systems without External Models *ODBTFTXIFSFBOBVUPOPNPVTTZTUFNEFDJEFTUPBDIJFWFUIFJOEJSFDUFﬀFDUPSUIFEJSFDUFﬀFDU OP FYUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIJTTZTUFNJTOFFEFE ThFTZTUFNJTGSFFUPEFDJEFXIJDIFYUFSOBMCFIBWJPSXJMM BDIJFWFUIFEFTJSFEFﬀFDU3FRVJSFNFOUTBSFTUBUFEJOUFSNTPGUIFEJSFDUPSJOEJSFDUFﬀFDUNPEFMT ThJTNBZCFFYUFOEFEUPTPNFEFHSFFUPNPSFUSBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNT'PSFYBNQMF UIFHPWFSO NFOU NBZ EFDJEF UP EFﬁOF EJSFDU FﬀFDUT PO UIF FOWJSPONFOU BOE BMMPX B DPOUSBDUPS UP CF UIF BVUPOPNPVTBHFOUUIBUEFDJEFTXIBUUIFTZTUFNCFIBWJPS FYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPO OFFETUPCFUP BDIJFWFUIPTFFﬀFDUT*OUIPTFDBTFT UIFHPWFSONFOUOFFETUPNBLFDMFBSUIFEFTJSFEFﬀFDUTBOE UIFFOWJSPONFOUBMDPOTUSBJOUT BOEUIFDPOUSBDUPSOFFETUPNBLFDMFBSUIFEFQFOEFODJFTPGUIF TPMVUJPO

Adaptation and Versatility ThFBOBMZTJTUIVTGBSJTPOMZQBSUPGUIFTUPSZ'PSBHJWFOTZTUFNUIBUJTSFBMJ[FE XFEFﬁOFUIF FﬀFDUTBOEUIFTZTUFNQFSGPSNTJOBXBZUIBUBDIJFWFTUIPTFFﬀFDUT'JSTU EFQMPZNFOUPGBTZTUFN JOWPMWFT NPWJOH DPQZJOH PS JOTUBOUJBUJOH UIF TZTUFN GSPN UIF TPMVUJPO TQBDF JOUP B EFQMPZFE TUBUFJOPOFPSNVMUJQMFQSPCMFNTQBDFFOWJSPONFOUT TVDIBTBGBDUPSZQSPEVDJOHNVMUJQMF#PFJOH BJSDSBGUUPTFOEUPEJﬀFSFOUBJSMJOFT PSBTPGUXBSFTZTUFNCFJOHEJTUSJCVUFEUPNVMUJQMFVTFST 1BSU PG UIF EFQMPZNFOU NBZ CF DPOﬁHVSJOH DVTUPNJ[JOH PS BEBQUJOH UP UIF TQFDJﬁD FOWJSPO NFOUEVSJOHJOTUBMMBUJPO BOEDPOUJOVJOHUIFSFBGUFS ThFTPMVUJPOTQBDFTZTUFNBOEUIFBTTPDJ BUFEEFQMPZFETZTUFN T DPSSFTQPOEUP.BSUJOT JOUFSWFOUJPOTZTUFNBOEEFQMPZFETZTUFN SFTQFDUJWFMZ 4FDPOE XIFOUIFTZTUFNJTEFQMPZFE JUOPUPOMZFOUFSTUIFQSPCMFNTQBDF CVUJUBMTPCFDPNFT QBSUPGUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFBOEUIFSFCZDIBOHFTUIFQSPCMFNTQBDF8FOPXIBWFUPDPOTJEFSUIBU UIFTZTUFNBOEJUTFOWJSPONFOUBSFNVUVBMMZBEBQUJOHFOUJUJFTXJUIJOUIFQSPCMFNTQBDF"TTPPO BTUIFTZTUFNJTTVDDFTTGVMJOBDIJFWJOHJUTFﬀFDUT UIFFOWJSPONFOUDIBOHFTThPTFDIBOHFTPGUFO

Mapping and Uniﬁcation

O 311

NFBOUIBUUIFEFQMPZFETZTUFNOFFETUPDIBOHFJOTPNFXBZ"OETPPOJOBSFQFBUJOHDZDMF5PEP UIJTNFBOTUIBUUIFEFQMPZFETZTUFNDBOOPUCFEFWFMPQFEJOUIFPMESFHJNFPGTBUJTGZJOHBﬁYFETFU PGSFRVJSFNFOUTThFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTNVTUBOUJDJQBUFUIFDIBOHFTUIFTZTUFNNJHIUJOEVDF JOJUTFOWJSPONFOUBOEUIFDIBOHFTUIFOFXFOWJSPONFOUSFRVJSFTPGUIFTZTUFN BOEUIFSFTVMUJOH TZTUFNNVTUCFBCMFUPEFBMXJUIUIPTFDIBOHFTJOBOPOHPJOHQSPDFTT *OUIFDPOUFYUPGUIJTSFQFBUJOHDZDMFJOXIJDITZTUFNBOEFOWJSPONFOUDIBOHFBOEBEBQUUP FBDIPUIFSJOBTFSJFTPGJOUFSBDUJPOTPSNPWFT UIFPSJHJOBMTZTUFNJOHFOFSBMOFFETUXPGFBUVSFTCVJMU JO JUNVTUIBWFBOJOIFSFOUDBQBCJMJUZUPDIBOHFJUTCFIBWJPS JUNVTUCFTVﬃDJFOUMZBEBQUBCMF UPDIBOHF FJUIFSCFDIBOHFECZUIFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSPSBVUPOPNPVTMZDIBOHFJUTFMG TPUIBUJUDBO SFTQPOEUPDIBOHFTUIFFOWJSPONFOUQSFTFOUTUPJUThFTFUXPGFBUVSFTSFﬂFDU SFTQFDUJWFMZ DIBOHF MFWFMT- SBOHFPSWFSTBUJMJUZPGCFIBWJPS BOE- BEBQUBCJMJUZPGTZTUFN BTEFﬁOFEJO$IBQUFS 54& IBT CFFO EPJOH UIJT JO DFSUBJO BSFOBT OPUBCMZ JO UIF TFDVSJUZ BSFB 0OHPJOH NVUVBM BEBQUBUJPOPGTFDVSJUZNFDIBOJTNTBOEQFPQMFUSZJOHUPCSFBLUIFNFDIBOJTNTIBTCFFOBMPOH TUBOEJOHQBUUFSOThFCBDLBOEGPSUIBEBQUBUJPOCFUXFFO*OUFSOFUIBDLFSTBOEBOUJWJSVTTFDVSJUZ TQFDJBMJTUTIBTCFDPNFSJUVBMJ[FEUPUIFFYUFOUUIBUXFOPXHFUWJSVTEFﬁOJUJPOﬁMFVQEBUFTBMNPTU FWFSZEBZUPQSPUFDUBHBJOTUOFXWJSVTFTUIBUBQQFBS*OUIFBSFBPG$4 UIFTFNVUVBMBEBQUBUJPO QBUUFSOT BSF FWFO NPSF EPNJOBOU ThF EFWFMPQNFOU PG DPNQMFY BEBQUJWF TZTUFNT DPODFQUT IBT SFTVMUFEJONPEFMTPGUIFTFQBUUFSOTBDSPTTBCSPBESBOHFPGTZTUFNTBOEFOWJSPONFOUT .04&4 QSPWJEFT TFWFSBM GPVOEBUJPOBM FMFNFOUT UIBU TVQQPSU UIF GFBUVSFT JEFOUJﬁFE BCPWF JODMVEJOH O ThFSFQFBUJOHBOEJOUFSUXJOJOHTUSVDUVSFPGJOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTQSPWJEFT B DMFBS QJDUVSF PG UIF EJTUJODUJPO CFUXFFO TZTUFN CFIBWJPS EJSFDU FﬀFDUT BOE JOEJSFDU FﬀFDUT O ThFJOIFSFOUFYQFDUBUJPOPGDPOUJOVBMDIBOHF BOENPEFMTPGDIBOHF TVQQPSUTBEBQUBCJM JUZBOEWFSTBUJMJUZ O ThFNPEVMBSJUZBOEEFDPVQMJOHBTQFDUTPG.04&4BMTPTVQQPSUBEBQUBCJMJUZ O ThFﬂFYJCJMJUZPGHFOFSBMNPEFMTFOBCMFTUIFCPVOEJOHBOENPEFMJOHPGUIFBEBQUBUJPO TQBDFPGTZTUFNBOEFOWJSPONFOU BTXFMMBTTZTUFNWFSTBUJMJUZ O ThFJODMVTJPOPGTPDJBMBOEQTZDIPMPHJDBMNPEFMTUIBUEFQJDUNPUJWBUJPOBOEHPBMEJSFDUFE CFIBWJPSIFMQJOGPSNUIFDPOUFOUPGUIFHFOFSBMNPEFMTPGUIFBEBQUBUJPOTQBDF JOFﬀFDU ZJFMEJOH CFUUFS NPEFMT PG UIF QIBTF TQBDF BOE USBKFDUPSJFT PG UIF NVUVBM HBNF UIBU JT QMBZFECFUXFFOTZTUFNBOEFOWJSPONFOU

Deﬁnitions of Traditional Artifacts (JWFOUIFNBUFSJBMQSFTFOUFEUIVTGBSJOUIFCPPL XFBSFJOBQPTJUJPOUPEFﬁOFUSBEJUJPOBMBSUJ GBDUTJO.04&4UFSNT8FIBWFHJWFOCSJFGEFﬁOJUJPOTJOTFWFSBMQMBDFTCVUOPXXFDBOHJWFNPSF DPNQMFUFEFﬁOJUJPOT$PODFQUPGPQFSBUJPOT SFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOU BSDIJUFDUVSF BOEEFTJHOBSF EFﬁOFE3FDBMMUIBU JO.04&4 FBDIPGUIFTFJTSFHBSEFEBTBNPEFM BOENPSFTQFDJﬁDBMMZBTB WJFXUIBUDVUTBDSPTTUIFNPEFMTQBDF "DPODFQUPGPQFSBUJPOTPS$0/014FYJTUTJOBDPOUFYUJOXIJDIBTZTUFN4IBTCFFOJEFOUJ ﬁFEBOEBOFOWJSPONFOU&IBTCFFOJEFOUJﬁFEBTUIFFOWJSPONFOUPG4&DPOTJTUTPGBMMFOUJUJFT UIBUBSFSFMBUFEUP4PSJOUFSBDUXJUI4'VSUIFSNPSF UIF$0/014JTSFHBSEFEBTUIF$0/014 PG 4 JO & UIBU JT B DPSSFTQPOEFODF IBT CFFO FTUBCMJTIFE UIBU BTTPDJBUFT UIF TZTUFN 4 XJUI UIF $0/014NPEFMJOUIFXPSME& QFSIBQTXJUIBNPEBMJUZTVDIBTiTIBMMwPSiEFTJSFEwThFWJFX QPJOUJOXIJDIUIF$0/014WJFXJTEFﬁOFEJTUIFMPDVTPGBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPO

312

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

PG4XJUI&/PSNBMMZ UIFJOUFSBDUJPOTBNPOHFMFNFOUTPG& JF JOUFSBDUJPOTOPUJOWPMWJOH4 BSFFYDMVEFEGSPNUIF$0/014CVUTVDIJOUFSBDUJPOTBSFOPUQSPIJCJUFEGSPNBQQFBSJOHJOUIF $0/014ThBUJT JO'JHVSF 7XPVMEOPSNBMMZCFUIF$0/014 CVU7DPVMEBMTPCF UIF$0/014 ThFDPOUFOUTPGUIF$0/014WJFXJODMVEFBMMJOGPSNBUJPOJOUIFJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOUBCMF JO$IBQUFSTFMFDUFEUPCFNBEFFYQMJDJUJOUIFNPEFM XIFSFUIFDPNQPOFOUTBSF4BOEUIF& FOUJUJFT BOEUIFDPOOFDUPSTBSFUIFWFIJDMFTPGJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFO4BOEUIF&FOUJUJFT#FDBVTF QBSUPGUIFJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTPGFBDIDPNQPOFOUBOEDPOOFDUPS UIPTF TQFDJﬁDBUJPOTBSFBMTPQBSUPGUIF$0/014 UPTPNFMFWFMPGEFUBJMThJTNFBOTUIBUUIF$0/014 XJMMJODMVEFBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPG4BOEPGFBDIFMFNFOUPG&*OBEEJUJPO UIF$0/014WJFXNBZ TQFDJGZBEEJUJPOBMSVMFTBOEDPOTUSBJOUTUIBUXPVMEOPSNBMMZCFJODMVEFEJOUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFM PG4 PSFWFOGVSUIFSEPXOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZPG4#FDBVTFUIJTQSBDUJDFUFOETUPCSFBL NPEVMBSJUZ JUJTOPUHFOFSBMMZFODPVSBHFECVUJUJTTPNFUJNFTBQQSPQSJBUF "SFRVJSFNFOUTEPDVNFOU PSSFRVJSFNFOUTWJFX VTVBMMZFYJTUTJOBDPOUFYUJOXIJDIBTZTUFN 4IBTCFFOJEFOUJﬁFE BOETPNFUJNFTBOFOWJSPONFOU&IBTCFFOJEFOUJﬁFE BUMFBTUJOBHFOFSBM XBZ BTUIFFOWJSPONFOUPG4'VSUIFSNPSF UIFSFRVJSFNFOUTWJFX3JTSFHBSEFEBTUIFSFRVJSF NFOUTPG4UIBUJT BDPSSFTQPOEFODFIBTCFFOFTUBCMJTIFEUIBUBTTPDJBUFTUIFTZTUFN4XJUIUIF SFRVJSFNFOUTNPEFM3XJUINPEBMJUZiTIBMMw PSPUIFSQSFTDSJQUJWFNPEBMJUZ

QFSIBQTJOUIFXPSME &ThFWJFXQPJOUJOXIJDI3JTEFﬁOFEJTUIFMPDVTPGBOFYUFSOBMNPEFMPG4*G3BTTVNFT& JU JTBDPOUFYUTQFDJﬁDFYUFSOBMNPEFMJG3BTTVNFTOPTQFDJﬁDFOWJSPONFOU JUJTBDPOUFYUHFOFSBM FYUFSOBMNPEFMThFDPOUFOUTPG3DBOWBSZDPOTJEFSBCMZJOUFSNTPG4 & BOEUIFJOUFSOBMTPG4"T EJTDVTTFEJOUIJTDIBQUFS 3DBOEFﬁOFUIFFﬀFDUTPOFMFNFOUTPG&SFTVMUJOHGSPN4 PSUIFCFIBW JPSPG4JUTFMG3DBOBMTPDPOTUSBJOUIFJOUFSOBMTPG4EPXONVMUJQMFMFWFMTJOTJEFUIF4DPNQPTJUJPO IJFSBSDIZ*G3EFﬁOFTUIFFﬀFDUTPOFMFNFOUTPG& UIFOJUJODMVEFTFYUFSOBMNPEFMTPGUIPTFFMF NFOUTThVT 3DBOJODMVEFBSBOHFPGNPEFMTCPUIFYUFSOBMBOEJOUFSOBM BOEUIFDPOUFOUTJODMVEF UIFFMFNFOUTJOUIFDPSSFTQPOEJOHUBCMFTJO$IBQUFSUIBUBSFDIPTFOUPCFFYQMJDJU "OBSDIJUFDUVSFEFTDSJQUJPO PSBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFX FYJTUTFJUIFSBTBTUBOEBMPOFNPEFM PSJOB DPSSFTQPOEFODFDPOUFYUJOXIJDIBTZTUFN4IBTCFFOJEFOUJﬁFEPSBDMBTTPGTZTUFNT$IBTCFFO JEFOUJﬁFE*OUIFMBUUFSDBTF UIFBSDIJUFDUVSF"JTSFHBSEFEBTUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFPG4PSPG$UIBU JT BDPSSFTQPOEFODFIBTCFFOFTUBCMJTIFEUIBUBTTPDJBUFT4PS$XJUI" QFSIBQTXJUIBNPEBMJUZ TVDIBTiTIBMMwThFWJFXQPJOUJOXIJDIUIF"WJFXJTEFﬁOFEJTUIFMPDVTPGBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPG 4PS$ThFDPOUFOUTPGUIF"NPEFMJODMVEFTBMMJOGPSNBUJPOJOUIFJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOUBCMF JO$IBQUFSTFMFDUFEUPCFNBEFFYQMJDJUJOUIFNPEFM XIFSFUIFDPNQPOFOUTBOEDPOOFDUPST BSFQBSUTPG4PS$#FDBVTFQBSUPGUIFJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOJTFYUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTPGFBDI DPNQPOFOUBOEDPOOFDUPS UIPTFTQFDJﬁDBUJPOTBSFBMTPQBSUPGUIF"WJFX UPTPNFMFWFMPGEFUBJM *OBEEJUJPO UIF"WJFXNBZTQFDJGZBEEJUJPOBMSVMFTBOEDPOTUSBJOUTUIBUXPVMEOPSNBMMZCF JODMVEFEJOUIFJOUFSOBMNPEFMTPGQBSUTPG4 PSFWFOGVSUIFSEPXOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZPG 45ZQJDBMMZ UIF"WJFXXJMMDPOTJTUPGNVMUJQMFBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFXT BTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS ThBUJT UIF"WJFXXJMMCFBDPNQPTJUFWJFXPSBNVMUJWJFXNPEFM/PUFBMTPUIBU4PS$NBZ CFBOZDBUFHPSZPG4&TZTUFN'PSFYBNQMF BOBSDIJUFDUVSFPGBTZTUFNTVDIBTBDPNNFSDJBM BJSDSBGUJTBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIFBJSDSBGU"OFOUFSQSJTFBSDIJUFDUVSFJTBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPGUIF FOUFSQSJTFPSPSHBOJ[BUJPO#PUIDPOTJTUPGNVMUJQMFWJFXT ThFMPDVTPGBEFTJHOPGBTZTUFN4JTBMTPBOJOUFSOBMNPEFMPG44PIPXEPFTUIJTEJﬀFSGSPN BOBSDIJUFDUVSFPG4JO.04&4 'PSNBMMZ .04&4EPFTOPUEJTUJOHVJTICFUXFFOBSDIJUFDUVSFBOE EFTJHOCPUIBSFJOUFSOBMNPEFMT*OUIJTQFSTQFDUJWF UIFEFﬁOJUJPOPSEFTDSJQUJPOPGBSDIJUFDUVSF HJWFOBCPWFBQQMJFTUPEFTJHOBTXFMM)PXFWFS BSDIJUFDUVSFBOEEFTJHOVTVBMMZEJﬀFSCZDPOWFO UJPO"SDIJUFDUVSFJTPGUFOUBLFOUPNFBOBHFOFSBMJOUFSOBMNPEFMXIJMFEFTJHOJTBNPSFTQFDJﬁD

Mapping and Uniﬁcation

O 313

JOUFSOBMNPEFM'PSFYBNQMF BSDIJUFDUVSFNBZEFﬁOFUIFNPEFMQBSBNFUFST XIJMFEFTJHOEFﬁOFT UIFTQFDJﬁDWBMVFTPGUIFQBSBNFUFST"SDIJUFDUVSF CZJOUFOUPSCZEFGBVMU PGUFOEFTDSJCFTBDMBTT PGTZTUFNT XIJMFBEFTJHOUFOETUPCFNPSFTZTUFNTQFDJﬁD

Mapping Enterprise Management Elements 5SBEJUJPOBM4&BTHFOFSBMMZDPODFJWFEJODMVEFTOPUKVTUFOHJOFFSJOH CVUBMTPNBOBHFNFOU1BSUMZ GPSUIBUSFBTPO UIFFYUFOTJPOBOEVOJﬁDBUJPOHPBMTPG.04&4JODMVEFCPUITZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH BOEFOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOHNBOBHFNFOUFMFNFOUTThJTTFDUJPOSFﬂFDUTUIFFOUFSQSJTFQPSUJPOPG 5BCMFJO$IBQUFS*UIBTUXPCPYFTFOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOHNBOBHFNFOU &&. BOEFOUFS QSJTFBVUPOPNZ &" .BQQJOH USBEJUJPOBM NBOBHFNFOU UP &&. BOE &" SFWFBMT UXP TJHOJﬁDBOU EJﬀFSFODFT ThF ﬁSTUJTUIFBEEJUJPOPGBOFOHJOFFSJOHBQQSPBDI JODMVEJOHNPEFMPSJFOUFENBOBHFNFOUThJTJT QSJNBSJMZSFﬂFDUFEJO&&.ThFTFDPOEJTUIFBEEJUJPOPGBVUPOPNPVTCFIBWJPSPGFOUFSQSJTFDPN QPOFOUT TVDIBTTFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPOPSTFMGNBOBHFNFOU. ThJTJTQSJNBSJMZSFﬂFDUFEJO&"

Enterprise Engineering/Management (EEM) 5SBEJUJPOBMNBOBHFNFOUJTNPTUMZBOBSUUIBUEFQFOETIFBWJMZPOUIFFYQFSJFODFBOEJOTUJODUT PGFBDINBOBHFS8IBU&&.CSJOHTUPUIFQJDUVSFJTTPNFTDJFODFCBTFEFOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOH JODMVEJOHNPEFMPSJFOUFENBOBHFNFOU8IBUEPFTUIBUNFBO 8FFYQMBJOXJUIBOFYBNQMFPSHB OJ[BUJPOBMTUSVDUVSF 4VQQPTFXFBSFJOWFOUJOHPSSFJOWFOUJOHBOPSHBOJ[BUJPO0OFPGUIFEFDJTJPOTUPCFNBEFJT UIFiPSHDIBSU wXIJDISFﬂFDUTUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTUSVDUVSF5SBEJUJPOBMMZ UIFIFBEPGUIFPSHB OJ[BUJPOPSBOBQQPJOUFEDPNNJUUFFXPVMEEFﬁOFUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTUSVDUVSFCBTFEPOQFSTPOBM QSFGFSFODFTPSTJNQMZVTFUIFPOMZTUSVDUVSFUIFZLOPX /PXTVQQPTFXFSFHBSEUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOBTBOFOUFSQSJTFTZTUFNBOEUIFPSHDIBSUBTBOJNQPS UBOUWJFXPGUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFPGUIJTTZTUFN'VSUIFS TVQQPTFUIBUBCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFFYJTUTJO UIFNPEFMTQBDF TVDIBTPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMUIFPSZPSNBOBHFNFOUTDJFODF DPOﬁSNFEUISPVHIDPM MFDUJWFFYQFSJFODF UIBUJOEJDBUFTXIJDIPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTUSVDUVSFTXPSLCFTUGPSEJﬀFSFOUUZQFTPG PSHBOJ[BUJPOT TVDIBT3% HPWFSONFOUBHFODJFT DPNNFSDJBMDPNQBOJFT NBOVGBDUVSJOHDPN QBOJFT FUDPSNBZCFﬁOFSHSBJOFEDBUFHPSJFT *GUIBUCPEZPGLOPXMFEHFJTBQQMJFEBOEQPTTJCMZ UBJMPSFEUPUIJTQBSUJDVMBSPSHBOJ[BUJPO UIFOXFDMBJNUIBUUIJTPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTUSVDUVSFEFDJTJPO IBTNPWFEGSPNUIFQSBDUJDFPGUSBEJUJPOBMNBOBHFNFOUUPUIFQSBDUJDFPG&&. ThFTDPQFPGNPEFMTJOUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFHPFTCFZPOEFOUFSQSJTFTUSVDUVSFTUPJODMVEFQMBO OJOH SFTPVSDFNBOBHFNFOU CVEHFUJOH DPTUBOBMZTJT TDIFEVMFT BOETUBﬃOHNPEFMT"MMPGUIFTF UZQFTDBOFYJTUGPS BOECFBQQMJFEUP PSHBOJ[BUJPOTBOEQSPKFDUTBTXFMMBTPUIFSFOUFSQSJTFUZQFT

Enterprise Autonomy (EA) .FNCFST PG BO FOUFSQSJTF PGUFO IBWF UIFJS PXO JEFBT BCPVU FOUFSQSJTF EFDJTJPOT BOE BDUJWJUJFT $POUJOVJOHUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOTUSVDUVSFFYBNQMFGSPNUIF&&.EJTDVTTJPO NFNCFSTPGUIFPSHBOJ [BUJPOQBSUJDJQBUFJOEFDJTJPOTBCPVUUIFTUSVDUVSFBOEBMTPGPSNUIFJSPXOBVUPOPNPVTTUSVDUVSFT ThFTFBDUJWJUJFTSFQSFTFOUUIF&"CPYJO5BCMF 0UIFSNPEFMTPGFOUFSQSJTFTJOUIFNPEFMLOPXMFEHFTQBDFBSFESBXOGSPNUIF$4DPNNVOJUZ ThFTFNPEFMTQPSUSBZTFMGPSHBOJ[JOHBOETFMGNBOBHJOHFOUFSQSJTFTThFFﬀFDUUIFTFNPEFMTIBWF

314 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

PO&&.JTUPDBVTFFOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSTBOENBOBHFSTUPSFDPHOJ[FUIFSPMFPG&"JOTIBQJOHUIF PSHBOJ[BUJPOTUSVDUVSF BOEIFODFUPTIBSFXJUI&"UIFSFBMJ[BUJPOPGUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOTUSVDUVSF BOEUPFODPVSBHF&"QBSUJDJQBUJPOJOUIFBDUJWJUZ ThFQSPQPSUJPOPGUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOTUSVDUVSFEFUFSNJOFECZ&&.WFSTVT&"JTBWBSJBCMFUIBU SBOHFTBDSPTTBTQFDUSVNGSPNBMM&&. USBEJUJPOBMUPQEPXONBOBHFNFOU UPBMM&" DPNQMFUFMZ TFMGPSHBOJ[JOH 5BLFOUPHFUIFS UIJT&&.&"QJDUVSFSFQSFTFOUTUIF.04&4BQQSPBDIUPJODPS QPSBUJOHBOEFYUFOEJOHUSBEJUJPOBMNBOBHFNFOUJOUPUIFMBSHFSDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDFPG UIFGVUVSF4&

Summary of MOSES Features and Uniﬁcation Areas of MOSES Uniﬁcation ThJT TFDUJPO EJTDVTTFT BSFBT XIFSF .04&4 QSPNPUFT BOE FOBCMFT VOJﬁDBUJPO PG UIF FYQBOEFE 4&PGUIFGVUVSF5PTPNFFYUFOU UIJTMJTUSFQSJTFTBSFBTUIBUXFSFJOUSPEVDFEJO$IBQUFSBOE EJTDVTTFEJOUIFWBSJPVTJOUFSWFOJOHDIBQUFST5BCMFTVNNBSJ[FTFMFNFOUTPG.04&4BOE XIBUBSFBTPG4&FBDIFMFNFOUVOJﬁFT&BDITIBEFEDFMMJOEJDBUFTXIJDIBSFBTBSFVOJﬁFEThFTF BSFOPXEJTDVTTFE "HMBODFBU5BCMFSFWFBMTUIBUNPTUPGUIFFMFNFOUTPG.04&4TVQQPSUUIFVOJﬁDBUJPOPG 54&BOE$4&ThJTJTOPUBDDJEFOUBM"TUIFCPPLIBTFNQIBTJ[FEUISPVHIPVU BQSJNBSZESJWFS PG.04&4JTUPFYUFOE4&UPJODMVEFDPNQMFYTZTUFNT BOEUPVOJGZUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGUSBEJUJPOBM BOEDPNQMFYTZTUFNT .PEFMPSJFOUBUJPO UIFNPEFMTQBDF TJNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFT BOEUIFFYQBOEFETZTUFNT UBYPOPNZVOJGZ54&BOE$4&CZCSJOHJOHUIFNJOUPBDPNNPOUBYPOPNZGSBNFXPSLUIBUJT

Table 12.2 Areas of SE Uniﬁed by MOSES

Model orientation Whole systems modeling Model space Self-similarity patterns Common speciﬁcation approach Agents Use of systems science Similarities and differences Expanded systems taxonomy Collective actualization Opportunistic process Support for change

Composite SE BoK

DevelopmentOperations

ManagementEngineering

Disciplines

MOSES Element or Concept

TSE-CSE

What SE Areas It Uniﬁes

Mapping and Uniﬁcation

O 315

CBTFEPOBMMBSUJGBDUTCFJOHDPOTJEFSFEBTNPEFMT BOEUIBUJODPSQPSBUFTJOUPUIFNPEFMTTJNJMBSJ UJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTPG54BOE$4*OBEEJUJPO NPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOEUIFNPEFMTQBDFVOJGZUIF TDPQFPG4& JODMVEJOHBMMBTTPDJBUFEBOETVQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT NBOBHFNFOUBOEFOHJOFFSJOH BOEUIFDPNQPTJUF4&CPEZPGLOPXMFEHF CZDPOTJEFSJOHUIFBSUJGBDUTPGBMMUIFTFEJTDJQMJOFTBT NPEFMT BOEJODPSQPSBUJOHBMMHFOFSBMNPEFMTJOUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFQBSUPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF 4FMGTJNJMBSJUZQBUUFSOTBSFQBSUPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFCVUBSFJNQPSUBOUFOPVHIUPDBMMPVUTFQB SBUFMZ ThFZ TVQQPSU VOJGZJOH BMM BSFBT UIBU UIF NPEFM TQBDF VOJﬁFT CFDBVTF UIF WBSJBCMFT BOE EJNFOTJPOTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFBSFTFMGTJNJMBS 8IPMF TZTUFNT NPEFMJOH IFMQT VOJGZ UIF BTTPDJBUFE EJTDJQMJOFT CZ JODMVEJOH BMM TQBDFT JO 'JHVSFQSPCMFNTQBDF NPEFMTQBDF TPMVUJPOTQBDF BOEBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDFThFDPNNPO TQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDITVQQPSUTXIPMFTZTUFNTNPEFMJOHUISPVHIJUTVOJﬁDBUJPOPG54&BOE$4& EJTDJQMJOFT NBOBHFNFOUBOEFOHJOFFSJOH EFWFMPQNFOUBOEPQFSBUJPOT BOEDPNQPTJUF4&#P,ThF TBNFFYUFSOBMJOUFSOBMTQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDIBOEJOGPSNBUJPOUZQFTBSFVTFEGPSBMMUIFTFBSFBT ThFSFNBJOJOHBSFBTBSFTVNNBSJ[FEBTGPMMPXT O ThFDPODFQUPGBHFOUTVOJﬁFT54&BOE$4&CZUSFBUJOHIVNBO TPGUXBSF BOEPUIFSUZQFT PGBHFOUTUIFTBNFXBZ O ThFVTFPG44IFMQTVOEFSTUBOEXIBUJTDPNNPOBDSPTTBMMTZTUFNT CPUI54BOE$4 BOE BMMTZTUFNSFMBUFEEJTDJQMJOFT BOEBMM4&#P, XIJDIIFMQTVOJGZBMMUIFTFBSFBT O 4JNJMBSJUJFTBOEEJﬀFSFODFTJTBWFSZCSPBEFMFNFOUUIBUIFMQTVOJGZBMMBSFBTPG4&CZGBD UPSJOHDPNNPOBMJUJFTPVUPGUIFEJﬀFSFODFT O $PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOJTBCSPBEFSUFSNUIBUVOJﬁFT54&BOE$4&CZDPWFSJOHUIFFOHJ OFFSJOHPSDPOUSPMPG54& BTXFMMBTUIFJOﬂVFODFPG$4& BOEJODMVEFTNBOBHFNFOU O 0QQPSUVOJTUJDQSPDFTTBOEUIFFNQIBTJTPOTVQQPSUJOHDIBOHFIFMQVOJGZ54&BOE$4& BOEBMTPTUSFOHUIFOBXFBLBSFBPG54&

Summary of Key MOSES Features ThFLFZGFBUVSFTPG.04&4BSF O %FﬁOFTBOETVQQPSUTBOFYQBOEFEBOEVOJﬁFEUBYPOPNZPGTZTUFNT O %FﬁOFTBVOJﬁFEBOETJNQMJﬁFETQFDJﬁDBUJPOBQQSPBDIUIBUSFRVJSFTPOMZUXPCBTJDUZQFT JOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBM O &YQBOETUIFDPODFQUPGFOHJOFFSJOHUPUIFCSPBEFSDPODFQUPGBDUVBMJ[BUJPOJODPSQPSBUFT NBOBHFNFOUBTQBSUPGBDUVBMJ[BUJPO O &NCSBDFTUIF$4DPODFQUTPGUFOTJPO EVBMJUZ QBSBEPY CBMBODF O %JTDJQMJOFTVTFTDMBTTJDVOJWFSTBMNPEFMJOHDPODFQUT O .PEFMTQFDUSVNSFWFBMTBOEFYQMPJUTTFMGTJNJMBSJUZPGNPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOT UIVTTVQ QPSUJOHTDBMBCJMJUZ O 'PVOEBUJPOJTXFMMHSPVOEFEJO44BOEPUIFSTDJFODFT O $BQUVSFTUIFCFTUQBUUFSOTBOEQSBDUJDFTBOEQSJODJQMFTPG54& O %PFTOPUEJTSVQUDVSSFOUCFTUQSBDUJDF O &YQMJDJUMZBMMPXTQBSUJBMMZJNQMJDJUTQFDJﬁDBUJPOT WJBUIFEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFONPEFMBOE TQFDJﬁcBUJPO O *TBQQMJDBCMFUPNVMUJQMFUFDIOPMPHJFTCVUEPFTOPUEFQFOEPOBOZPGUIFN O %PFTOPUOFFEUPJOWFOUUIFTPMVUJPOQJFDFTUIFZBMSFBEZFYJTUJOUIFCSPBEFS4&BOETVQ QPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT

316

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

O 'VMMZTVQQPSUTUIFCMVSSJOHPGMJOFTUIBUPDDVSTCFUXFFOBSUJﬁDJBMBOEOBUVSBMTZTUFNT O 4VQQPSUTUIFIZCSJETZTUFNTUIBUTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTBDUVBMMZBEESFTT O &OBCMFTJODSFBTJOH4&TDPQFPGNPSFBNCJUJPVTBSFOBT

References ,VKBXTLJ & BOE ( .JMMFS 2VBOUJUBUJWF SJTLCBTFE BOBMZTJT GPS NJMJUBSZ DPVOUFSUFSSPSJTN TZTUFNT */$04&+4ZTUFNT&OH o .BSUJO +The TFWFO4BNVSBJPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHEFBMJOHXJUIUIFDPNQMFYJUZPGJOUFSSFMBUFE TZTUFNT 1SFTFOUFE BU UIF UI "OOV *OU 4ZNQ *OU $PVODJM PO 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH */$04& 5PVMPVTF 'SBODFo+VOF 0"4*4 3FGFSFODF .PEFM GPS 4FSWJDF 0SJFOUFE "SDIJUFDUVSF 0"4*4 4UBOEBSE 0DUPCFS IUUQEPDTPBTJTPQFOPSHTPBSNW "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

Chapter 13

SE Actualization Processes

Highest level system

Indivisible Unit

Model of Individual system or component

Universal model

Common speciﬁcation approach: Repeating internal/external structure

Solution domain

CCoo m - -KK m m m - -CC inindd oonniz aatete ss izaati go tioon n rrieies s

Deﬁne need

Composition

Systems taxonomy Modeling scope ThFUJUMFPGUIJTDIBQUFSSFﬂFDUTUIFCSPBEFSTDPQF 1 SE Application Domains (D1...Dn) Collective actualization space D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 Dn PG UIF GVUVSF 4& BOE NPEFM PSJFOUBUJPO ThF Problem space Model Space DPNQPTJUF.04&4NBQJO$IBQUFSEFQJDUFEB 2a TS/CS diﬀerent in kind 2b All SE Traditional systems Complex systems TQBDFDBMMFEUIFDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDFThF 3a TS/CS diﬀerent in degree 3b application domains... Traditional Complex TUSVDUVSF BOE FMFNFOUT PG UIJT TQBDF BSF EFﬁOFE 4 Complex Traditional TS is special case JO 5BCMF JO $IBQUFS *O .04&4 BOE UIF 5 Characteristics of all SE systems and Complex FYQBOEFE 4& UXP DIBOHFT PDDVS 'JSTU NPEFM 6 Traditional Characteristics of all systems Deployment Solution/system space PSJFOUBUJPO VOJﬁFT FOHJOFFSJOH BOE NBOBHFNFOU JOUPBDPNNPONPEFMJOHBQQSPBDI4FDPOE UIF FYQBOTJPO UP $4 MFBET UP SFJOUFSQSFUBUJPO PG UIF DPNQMFYJPO PG FOHJOFFSJOH NBOBHFNFOU BOE NPEFMJOHGSPNBOPSJFOUBUJPOPGEFﬁOJUJWFDPOUSPMBOEDFSUBJOUZUPPOFPGJOﬂVFODF TIBQJOH BOE BDUVBMJ[BUJPOJOUIFDPOUFYUPGBDLOPXMFEHFEVODFSUBJOUZBOEBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUTThFSFGPSF UIF UFSNiDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOwJOUIJTCPPLBOEUIJTDIBQUFSJTUIJTSFJOUFSQSFUFEGPSNPGFOHJOFFS JOH NBOBHFNFOU NPEFMJOH BOEBVUPOPNZ Th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ﬃcVM UJFTDBVTFECZDVSSFOU4&QSPDFTTFT BOEUPQPJOUUPNPSFOBUVSBMQSPDFTTFTBOEBNPSFCBMBODFE GPDVT #BTFEPOUIJT SBUJPOBMF UIFTFDUJPOT PG UIF DIBQUFS EJTDVTT SFTQFDUJWFMZ 54& NFUIPET BOE WBSJBODFTXJUI.04&4 $4&NFUIPET NPEFMPSJFOUFENFUIPET BOEDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPG.04&4 VOJﬁFEQSPDFTTFT JODMVEJOHDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPO Problem/ user domain

Conceptualization Conceptualization -- Language/notation Language/notation -- Universe Universe of ofdiscourse discourse

Views exist within and across all the dimensions

e

m

Ti

Produce solution

Satisfy need

317

318 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Traditional Processes ThJTTFDUJPOEJTDVTTFT54&QSPDFTTFT JODMVEJOHTPNFQSPNJOFOUHFOFSBMMJGFDZDMFNPEFMT TUBO EBSET BOEBGFXSFMBUFETPVSDFT*UUIFOTVNNBSJ[FTTPNFPGUIFXFBLOFTTFTPGUIF54&QSPDFTTFT

General Models 4FWFSBMQSPDFTTNPEFMTDBNFPVUPGUIFTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHDPNNVOJUZThFDMBTTJDQSPDFTTNPEFM UIBUIBTJOﬂVFODFECPUITPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHBOE4&GPSGPVSEFDBEFTJTUIFXBUFSGBMMNPEFM 3PZDF 3PZDFTSFDPNNFOEFENPEFMUIBUJODMVEFEBOJOJUJBMGVMMQSPUPUZQFFﬀPSU IFDBMMFEJUiTJNV MBUJPOw IBTCFFOMBSHFMZJHOPSFEBOEGPSHPUUFO)JTTJNQMFTUBOENPTUMJOFBSNPEFM SFRVJSFNFOUT BOBMZTJTEFTJHODPEFUFTU

UIFPOFIFTBJEXBTiSJTLZBOEJOWJUFTGBJMVSF wXBTXJEFMZBEPQUFE #PFIN JOUSPEVDFEUIFTQJSBMNPEFMBTBOJUFSBUJWFEFWFMPQNFOU CVUOPUEFQMPZNFOU BQQSPBDIUIBUGPDVTFEPOSJTLSFEVDUJPOUISPVHIBTFSJFTPGQSPUPUZQFTGPMMPXFECZUIFﬁOBMQSPE VDU &BDI TQJSBM SFBTTFTTFT SJTL BOE HPFT UISPVHI B RVJDL EFWFMPQNFOU BDUJWJUZ UIBU QSPEVDFT B QSPUPUZQFUIBUSFEVDFTBSJTLBOEJNQSPWFTVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIe ﬁOBMQSPEVDU 'PSTCFSHBOE.PP[ JOUSPEVDFEUIF7FF PSi7w NPEFMPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH GPDVTFE POUIFUFDIOJDBMBTQFDUTPGBQSPKFDU*UTOBNFEFSJWFTGSPNUIFTIBQFPGUIFHSBQIJD XIJDIJT TIPXOJOTJNQMJﬁFEGPSNJO'JHVSF*UJTDPSSFMBUFEXJUIUXPEJNFOTJPOTPGUIFNPEFMTQBDF DPNQPTJUJPOBOEUJNF*UTUBSUTXJUIVTFSOFFETJOUIFVQQFSMFGU EFDPNQPTFTGSPNTZTUFNUP TFHNFOUUPIBSEXBSFBOETPGUXBSFDPOﬁHVSBUJPOJUFNTUPDPNQPOFOUTBOEBTTFNCMJFTBOEVOJUT UIFO JNQMFNFOUBUJPO TPGUXBSF EFWFMPQNFOU BOE IBSEXBSF GBCSJDBUJPO

BOE ﬁOBMMZ DPNQPTFT VOJUTJOUPDPNQPOFOUTBOETPPOCBDLVQUPUIFGVMMTZTUFNThFBDUJWJUJFTDPNJOHEPXOUIFMFGU TJEFPGUIF7FFBSFNPEFMJOHBOEEFTJHO XIJMFUIPTFHPJOHVQUIFSJHIUTJEFBSFJOUFHSBUJPOBOE UFTUThFIPSJ[POUBMMFWFMTPOPQQPTJUFTJEFTPGUIF7FFBSFMJOLFEJOUIFTFOTFUIBUUIFZBSFBUUIF TBNF DPNQPTJUJPO MFWFM BOE UIFZ SFQSFTFOU UIF ﬂJQ TJEFT PG EFTJHO BOE JOUFHSBUJPOUFTU BU UIBU MFWFM*OUFSNTPGTFSWJDFTQSPWJEFEBOESFRVJSFE EFQFOEFODJFT JO.04&4TQFDJﬁDBUJPOT UIF7FF

Veriﬁcation and validation

Concept of operations Project deﬁnition

Operations and maintenance System veriﬁcation and validation

Requirements and architecture

Integration, test, and veriﬁcation

Detailed design

Project test and integration

Implementation

Time

Figure 13.1 SE Vee model. (Source: Clarus Concept of Operations, Federal Highway Administration, 2005.)

SE Actualization Processes

O

319

NPEFMJMMVNJOBUFTPOFTFRVFODFDPOTUSBJOUThFSFJTOPDPOTUSBJOUJO.04&4POUIFTFRVFODFPG EFﬁOJOHTFSWJDFTQSPWJEFECVUUIFSFJTPOFPOEFﬁOJOHTFSWJDFTSFRVJSFEThBUDPOTUSBJOUJTUIBU UIFGVMMTFUPGEFQFOEFODJFTPGBHJWFOMFWFMPGTZTUFNJOUIFDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZDBOOPUCF EFﬁOFEVOUJMUIFEFQFOEFODJFTBUUIFOFYUMPXFSMFWFMBSFEFﬁOFEThJTDPOTUSBJOTUIFTFRVFODF PGEFﬁOJOH PSBUMFBTUDPNQMFUJOHUIFEFﬁOJUJPOPG EFQFOEFODJFTUPHPGSPNUIFCPUUPNPGUIF 7FFVQUIFSJHIUTJEF 8IZ EPFT UIJT DPOTUSBJOU FYJTU JO .04&4 ThF SFBTPO JT UIBU EFTJHO EFDJTJPOT DBO BﬀFDU FYUFSOBMEFQFOEFODJFT'PSFYBNQMF JUJTQPTTJCMFUPEFﬁOFUIFTFSWJDFTUIBUBDBSQSPWJEFTXJUIPVU LOPXJOHUIFJOUFSOBMEFTJHO TVDIBTUIFUZQFPGFOHJOF#VUUPGVMMZTQFDJGZUIFEFQFOEFODJFTPG UIFDBS XFOFFEUPLOPX GPSFYBNQMF XIBUUZQFPGFOHJOFJUIBTPSXJMMIBWF BOEXIFUIFSJUJT BVUPNBUFE*GUIFDBSIBTBOJOUFSOBMDPNCVTUJPOFOHJOF JUEFQFOETPOBJSBOEGVFM XIJMFJGJUJT CBUUFSZQPXFSFE JUEPFTOPUEFQFOEPOFJUIFSBJSPSGVFM CVUEPFTEFQFOEPOBXBZUPSFDIBSHFUIF CBUUFSJFT*GJUJTOPUBVUPNBUFE JUEFQFOETPOBESJWFSJGJUJTBVUPNBUFE JUEPFTOPUEFQFOEPOB ESJWFSThJTDPOTUSBJOUJTXIZ$IBQUFS JOUIFEJTDVTTJPOPGTQFDJGZJOHEFQFOEFODJFT TBJEUIBU UIFFTUBCMJTIFEEFQFOEFODJFTNVTUCFTQFDJﬁFE /HVZFO PCTFSWFEUIBUNPTU4&NFUIPETBTTVNFBCMBOLTMBUF FOHJOFFSJOHBTZTUFN GSPNTDSBUDI SBUIFSUIBONPEJGZJOHBOFYJTUJOHTZTUFN)FEJTDVTTFEBEBQUJOHUIF7FFNPEFMUP BEESFTTTZTUFNNPEJﬁDBUJPO "OPUIFSBQQSPBDIJTJUFSBUJWFBOEJODSFNFOUBMEFWFMPQNFOU **% Th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o ﬁUUIFBHJMFQBSBEJHN

Standards IEEE and ISO ThFSF BSF UXP SFMFWBOU TUBOEBSET GSPN UIF *&&& BOE *40*&$ *&&& *&&& C JT UIF*&&&4UBOEBSEGPS"QQMJDBUJPOBOE.BOBHFNFOUPGUIF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH1SPDFTT*40 *&$ *40*&$

XIJDIXBTBEPQUFEBT*&&& *&&&B

JTUIF4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH4ZTUFN-JGF$ZDMF1SPDFTTFTTUBOEBSE *40*&$IBTBNPEVMBSEFTJHO*UEFﬁOFTBTFUPGQSPDFTTNPEVMFTCVUEPFTOPUSFRVJSF BOZTQFDJﬁDTFRVFODF)PXFWFS JUEPFTSFRVJSFUIFFTUBCMJTINFOUPGBTFRVFODFJOXIJDIUIFDPNQP OFOUTBSFUIFQSPDFTTNPEVMFT*UEFﬁOFTGPVSHSPVQTPGQSPDFTTFT FOUFSQSJTF UIFFOUFSQSJTFBOE NBOBHFNFOUFOWJSPONFOU

QSPKFDU UFDIOJDBM BOE BHSFFNFOU BDRVJTJUJPOBOETVQQMZ

INCOSE: Handbook and Guide to BoK ThF *OUFSOBUJPOBM $PVODJM PO 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH */$04& IBT EFWFMPQFE B IBOECPPL */$04& UIBU BMTP JT QBUUFSOFE BGUFS *40*&$ *U BEESFTTFT UIF GPVS HSPVQT PG QSPDFTTFTGSPN*40*&$ BOEBMTPFOBCMJOH4&BDUJWJUJFTTVDIBTSJTLBOEPQQPSUVOJUZNBO BHFNFOU BEEJUJPOBMMJGFDZDMFBDUJWJUJFTTVDIBTDPOﬁHVSBUJPONBOBHFNFOUBOESFTPVSDFNBOBHF NFOU BOETQFDJBMUZFOHJOFFSJOHBDUJWJUJFTTVDIBTMPHJTUJDTBOEIVNBOGBDUPST

320

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

ThF*/$04&HVJEFUPUIF4&CPEZPGLOPXMFEHF */$04& QSPWJEFTEJTDVTTJPOPGBOE QPJOUFSTUPNBOZPGUIFQSPDFTTFTBOETUBOEBSETJEFOUJﬁFEJOUIJTTFDUJPO JODMVEJOHUIF*/$04& )BOECPPL UIF 7FF 4& NPEFM 1MPXNBOT TZOUIFTJT TFF CFMPX

BOE UIF 64 %FQBSUNFOU PG %FGFOTFMJGFDZDMF

U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) Acquisition ThFHFOFSBMBQQSPBDIPGUIF%P%UPTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHJTEFTDSJCFEJO%P% ThFSFJT BMTPBOFYUFOTJWFTFUPGTUBOEBSET SFHVMBUJPOT BOEJOTUSVDUJPOTUIBUEFﬁOFUIFTZTUFNTBDRVJTJUJPO QSPDFTT DBMMFEUIF%P%TFSJFT.VDIPGUIJTJOGPSNBUJPOJTEFTDSJCFEJO%"( 3FMBUFEUPUIF%P%BDRVJTJUJPOQSPDFTTJTUIFJSDBQBCJMJUJFTCBTFEBTTFTTNFOU $#" QSPDFTTBT EFTDSJCFEJOUIF+PJOU$BQBCJMJUJFT*OUFHSBUJPOBOE%FWFMPQNFOU4ZTUFN +$*%4 ThFLFZ$#" DPODFQUPGOPUFGPS.04&4JTUIFVQGSPOUBOBMZTJTPGBQSPCMFNUIBUEPFTOPUBTTVNFUIBUBNBDIJOF PSBNBUFSJFMTZTUFNXJMMCFUIFTPMVUJPOThFBOBMZTJTFYBNJOFTBMUFSOBUJWFTPMVUJPOT XIJDINJHIU JODMVEFUSBJOJOH DIBOHFJOEPDUSJOF PSQFSTPOOFM BTXFMMBTPSJOTUFBEPGNBUFSJFMTZTUFNT ThJTJTBO JNQPSUBOUFMFNFOUJO.04&4 EJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFSBTUIFHFOFSBMQSPCMFNTPMWJOHBTQFDUPG4&

Other Sources .BOZ PUIFS HFOFSBM BOE TQFDJﬁD 4& QSPDFTTFT BOE NFUIPEPMPHJFT BSF EFTDSJCFE JO B WBSJFUZ PG TPVSDFT JODMVEJOH DPNNPOMZ VTFE CPPLT TVDI BT ,PTTJBLPﬀ BOE 4XFFU BOE 4BHF BOE "SNTUSPOH 8FCSJFﬂZNFOUJPOPOFFYBNQMF)JUDIJOT’ ﬁWFMBZFSNPEFM )JUDIJOT IBTEFﬁOFd a ﬁWFMBZFS4&QSPDFTTNPEFM. ThFMBZFSTBSF O -BZFS4PDJPFDPOPNJD UIFTUVﬀ oGSFHVMBUJPOBOEHPWFSONFOUDPOUSPM O -BZFS*OEVTUSJBM4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH PSFOHJOFFSJOHPGDPNQMFUFTVQQMZDIBJOTDJSDMFT .BOZJOEVTUSJFTDPOTUJUVUFBTPDJPFDPOPNJDTZTUFN O -BZFS#VTJOFTT4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOHNBOZCVTJOFTTFTDPOTUJUVUFBOJOEVTUSZ"UUIJT MBZFS TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHTFFLTUPPQUJNJ[FQFSGPSNBODFTPNFXIBUJOEFQFOEFOUPGPUIFS CVTJOFTTFT O -BZFS1SPKFDUPS4ZTUFNMBZFS.BOZQSPKFDUTDPOTUJUVUFBCVTJOFTT O -BZFS1SPEVDUMBZFS.BOZQSPEVDUTDPOTUJUVUFBTZTUFNThFUBOHJCMFBSUJGBDUMBZFS.BOZ FOHJOFFSTBOEUIFJSJOTUJUVUJPOTDPOTJEFSUIJTUPCFUIFPOMZiSFBMwTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH ThFMBZFSTGPSNBDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIZUIBUFYUFOECFZPOEUIFOPSNBMTDPQFPG54&BOE JODMVEFBUMFBTUQBSUPGUIFOFXFYQBOEFETDPQFPG4&)PXFWFS UIFEFTDSJCFEQSPDFTTFTBOE DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PG UIF MBZFST FNQIBTJ[F UIF EJﬀFSFODFT CFUXFFO UIFN BOE OPU TP NVDI UIF DPNNPOBMJUJFT JOUIFNBOOFSPG54&.04&4XPVMEFNQIBTJ[FUIFDPNNPOBMJUJFT BTXFMM BTUIFEJﬀFSFODFT

Problems with Traditional Processes ThFGPMMPXJOHDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPG54&QSPDFTTFTBSFPCTFSWFEBTQSPCMFNTGSPNUIFQFSTQFDUJWF PG.04&4 O 'PDVTPOQSPDFTT O 1SPCMFNTPMWJOHFOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTJTiEJTDJQMJOFEwUPCFMJOFBSBOEVOOBUVSBM O %PFTOPUEFBMXJUIDIBOHFIFBWZXFJHIUPWFSDPOTUSBJOFEDIBOHFJTBOFHBUJWF

SE Actualization Processes

O

321

O .ZUIPGUIFCMBOLTMBUF O .ZUIPGSFRVJSFNFOUTESJWFO &BDIJTCSJFﬂZEFTDSJCFECFMPX

Focus on Process ThJTJTTVFPSXFBLOFTTDPNFTGSPNBQFSTQFDUJWFUIBUJTCSPBEFSUIBOUIFTDPQFPGUIJTDIBQUFS" DPNQBSJTPOPGUIFQSJNBSZEPDVNFOUTPGUIF4&EJTDJQMJOFJODMVEJOHUIFNPTUVTFEUFYUCPPLT UIFCPEZPGLOPXMFEHF BOEUIFTUBOEBSETXJUIUIFQSJNBSZEPDVNFOUTPGBNBUVSFEJTDJQMJOF TVDIBTDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH TIPXTUIFXFBLOFTTBTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS.BUVSFFOHJOFFSJOH EJTDJQMJOFTIBWFNPEFMTPGTZTUFNT XIJMF4&IBTNPEFMTPGEFWFMPQNFOUQSPDFTTFTThFCFMJFGUIBU NPEFMTPGTZTUFNTBSFNPSFIFMQGVMUPTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSTUIBONPEFMTPGEFWFMPQNFOUQSPDFTTFTJT BNBKPSSFBTPOXIZ.04&4JTEFﬁOFEJOUFSNTPGBNPEFMTQBDFBOEHFOFSBMNPEFMT

Problem Solving: Engineering Process Is “Disciplined” to be Linear and Unnatural ThFCBTJD54&QSPDFTTFTBTXJEFMZQSBDUJDFEBSFTUJMMWBSJBUJPOTPGUIFXBUFSGBMMNPEFM UPBMBSHF EFHSFFThFPCWJPVTXFBLOFTTJTUIFMJOFBSTFRVFOUJBMOBUVSFPGUIFXBUFSGBMMThFTFRVFODFJTGSPN TUBUJOHUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTUPEFTJHOJOHBOECVJMEJOHUIFTPMVUJPO8IZJTUIJTBQSPCMFN #FDBVTF UIFOBUVSFPGQSPCMFNTPMWJOHJOHFOFSBM BOEFOHJOFFSJOHBTZTUFNJOQBSUJDVMBS EPFTOPUGPMMPX BMJOFBSTFRVFODF'JSTU UIFOBUVSBMQSPDFTTPGEFTJHOJTOPUMJOFBSJUJTNPSFMJLFDIBPT JOBUFDI OJDBMTFOTF

BTXFEJTDVTTJOUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi"6OJﬁFE"DUVBMJ[BUJPO1SPDFTTw4FDPOE UIF GPSDFTUIBUTIBQFQSPEVDJOHBTZTUFNEPOPUPDDVSJOTFRVFODFUIFZBSFVTVBMMZDPODVSSFOU4FF UIFTJEFCBSJOUIJTDIBQUFSPOUIFIJTUPSZPGQSPDFTT

Does Not Adequately Deal with Change 1PTTJCMZUIFNPTUTJHOJﬁDBOUXFBLOFTTPG54&NFUIPETJTUIFEJﬃcVMUZPGEFBMJOHXJUIDIBOHF ThJTJTQBSUJBMMZSFMBUFEUPUIFSJHJEBQQMJDBUJPOPGUIFXBUFSGBMMNPEFMTh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

Myth of the Blank Slate ThJTXFBLOFTTJTBOBTTVNQUJPOUIBUXFBSFFOHJOFFSJOHBOFXTZTUFNGSPNTDSBUDI PSGSPNB CMBOLTMBUF0WFSUIFEFDBEFTPG4&QSBDUJDF BOETPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHQSBDUJDF

JUIBTCFDPNFUIF FYDFQUJPOSBUIFSUIBOUIFSVMFUIBUXFDSFBUFXIPMFOFXTZTUFNTJOQSBDUJDF XFNVDINPSFPGUFO NPEJGZFYJTUJOHPOFT"OEFWFOXIFOXFEPDSFBUFOFXTZTUFNT UIFJSSFRVJSFNFOUTBOEEFTJHOT BSFOPUPGUFOFOUJSFMZOFXUIFZBSFVTVBMMZWBSJBUJPOTPGFYJTUJOHPOFTThJTJTUPCFFYQFDUFEJO BOZEJTDJQMJOFPSBQQMJDBUJPOEPNBJO8IFOBEPNBJOJTOFX NBOZPSNPTUPGUIFTZTUFNTCVJMU BSFOFXEFTJHOTCVUBTUIFEPNBJOHBJOTTPNFNBUVSJUZ NPSFPGUIFEFTJHOTQBDFPGUIJTEPNBJO

322

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

IBTCFFOFYQMPSFEBOETZTUFNTCVJMU&BDIOFXQSPKFDUUIBUDPNFTBMPOH FBDIOFXTZTUFNEFTJSFE JTNPSFMJLFMZUPCFTJNJMBSUPPOFPSNPSFTZTUFNTUIBUIBWFBMSFBEZCFFOCVJMU$MBTTFTPGTJNJMBS TZTUFNTOPXIBWFDPNNPOBSDIJUFDUVSFNPEFMTBOEPUIFSHFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUDBOCFTQFDJBMJ[FE GPSUIJTTZTUFN JOTUFBEPGIBWJOHUPTUBSUGSPNTDSBUDIThFQSPCMFNJO4& BOEJOTPGUXBSFFOHJ OFFSJOH JTUIBUPVSQSPDFTTFTIBWFOPUDBVHIUVQXJUIPVSQSBDUJDFJOUIJTSFHBSE0VSQSPDFTTFT DPOUJOVFUPCFPSJFOUFEUPXBSEFOHJOFFSJOHBXIPMFOFXVOJRVFTZTUFNGSPNTDSBUDI

Myth of Requirements Driven "DPNNPOBTTVNQUJPOJTUIBUUIFQSJNBSZQFSIBQTFWFOUIFPOMZGPSDFUIBUEFUFSNJOFTXIBU BTZTUFNEPFTJTUIFOFFETPGUIFVTFS BOEUIFTFBSFJOTPNFTFOTFBQSJPSJPSQSFPSEBJOFEThBUJT B SFRVJSFNFOUTESJWFOQSPDFTTJTBTTVNFE)PXFWFS UIFSFBMJUZJTUIBUJONPTUDBTFT UIFOFFETPGUIF VTFSBSFPOMZBMJNJUFEESJWFSPGXIBUBTZTUFNEPFTThFMBSHFTUESJWFSJTXIBUUFDIOPMPHZFYJTUTPS JTXJUIJOSFBDI(FPSHF8BTIJOHUPODPVMEIBWFXSJUUFOEPXOBMMUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTIFXBOUFEGPS BFSJBMCPNCJOHJOUIF3FWPMVUJPOBSZ8BS BOEPﬀFSFEBMBSHFBNPVOUPGNPOFZ CVUJUXPVMEOPU IBWFEPOFIJNBOZHPPECFDBVTFOPCPEZLOFXIPXUPCVJMEBOBJSQMBOF5FDIOPMPHZBUBOZQPJOU JOUJNFEFﬁOFTBTQBDFPGQPTTJCJMJUJFTPGTZTUFNCFIBWJPS BOEVTFSTBSFDPOTUSBJOFEUPEFﬁOFUIFJS SFRVJSFNFOUTXJUIJOUIBUTQBDFThFCPVOEBSZPGUIBUTQBDFJTGV[[ZThFGV[[JOFTTSFQSFTFOUTUIFGBDU UIBUUIFOFFETPGVTFSTDBOQVTIUIFTUBUFPGUIFBSUNPEFTUMZCFZPOEJUTDVSSFOUTQBDF CVUOPUNVDI CFZPOE4P SFRVJSFNFOUTPGTZTUFNTBSFQFHHFEFJUIFSUPFYJTUJOHUFDIOPMPHZPSTMJHIUMZCFZPOEJU *OBEEJUJPOUPBWBJMBCMFUFDIOPMPHZBOEVTFSOFFET UIFUIJSETJHOJﬁDBOUESJWFSPGUIFDBQBCJMJ UJFTPGBTZTUFNJTSFTPVSDFDPOTUSBJOUT XIJDIJODMVEFDPTU TDIFEVMF BOETUBﬃOH BTXFMMBTPQFSB UJPOBMSFTPVSDFT$PTUJTUIFEPNJOBOUSFTPVSDFDPOTUSBJOUThFPSEFSPGUIFUISFFCJHESJWFSTGSPN NPTUUPMFBTUDPOTFRVFOUJBMJTQSPCBCMZBWBJMBCMFUFDIOPMPHZ SFTPVSDFDPOTUSBJOUT BOEﬁOBMMZVTFS OFFETThBUJT JGUFDIOPMPHZEFﬁOFTBTQBDFPGQPTTJCJMJUJFT SFTPVSDFDPOTUSBJOUTGVSUIFSSFEVDF UIBUUPBNPSFMJNJUFETQBDF BOEVTFSTEFﬁOFPSOFHPUJBUFUIFJSSFRVJSFNFOUTXJUIJOUIBUMJNJUFE TQBDF BMUIPVHISFTPVSDFDPOTUSBJOUTBSFTPNFUJNFTBMTPOFHPUJBCMF "MMUISFFESJWFSTDBODIBOHFPWFSUJNF FWFOXJUIJOPOFTZTUFN*OHFOFSBM UIFUFDIOPMPHZ DIBOHFTUIFMFBTU XIJMFUIFVTFSOFFETBOESFTPVSDFTDBODIBOHFTJHOJﬁDBOUMZ ThFGPSFHPJOHEJTDVTTJPOPGESJWFSTJMMVTUSBUFTXIZBMJOFBSSFRVJSFNFOUTESJWFOQSPDFTTJTOPU SFBMJTUJDGPSUXPSFBTPOT UIFEPNJOBOUFﬀFDUPGBWBJMBCMFUFDIOPMPHZ BOE UIFDPOUJOVJOH DIBOHFPGBMMESJWFSTThFVQTIPUPGUIFMJOFBSQSPDFTTFWBMVBUJPOJTUIBUBMJOFBSQSPDFTTJTOPUUIF OBUVSBMXBZUIBUTZTUFNEFTJHOFSTXPSL BOEJUJTOPUBSFBMJTUJDXBZGPSBO4&QSPKFDUUPQSPDFFE

Offbeat History of Process Context This sidebar presents a view of process based on an examination of how process has been treated in several SE-related disciplines. The view, and the discussion that follows it, explain the role that process plays in MOSES.

The View Historical practice in several disciplines shapes the view presented here. The two primary historical examples are traditional architecture and science, especially the scientiﬁc method.

SE Actualization Processes Architecture. An evolution of the design process in the traditional architecture ﬁeld in the 1960s and 1970s, especially in Britain, is described by Jones (1963), Hillier, Musgrove, and O’Sullivan (1972), Rittel (1972), and Broadbent (1979). In the 1960s, the people who studied the methods of architectural design decided that the process needed to become more systematic and more quantiﬁed. Architects needed to clear their mind of preconceptions. They needed a rationalized process of analysis then synthesis, with more emphasis on user requirements, and more open-ended designs and options as opposed to a standard set of built-in requirements. This approach, called Analysis-SynthesisEvaluation, has been designated a “First Generation” design method. (The way architectural design was done during the thousands of years prior to this period does not seem to deserve any name or generation number; perhaps we could call it Generation 0. Apparently, process was not a focus. In his ten books on architecture written in the ﬁrst century BCE, for example, Vitruvius (1914) focused on designs and not so much on the process of creating them.) The result of this ﬁrst-generation process, according to Hillier, Musgrove, and O’Sullivan (1972), was deterioration in user acceptability of buildings that were built. The problem seemed to be that designs did not incorporate the built-in knowledge of requirements they previously relied on and instead they relied too heavily on speciﬁed user requirements. A second generation then emerged, containing elements of political consideration; it was a rebellion against the notion that an expert designer was more knowledgeable than other stakeholders about how to design the system. The approach was more like design by committee, in which it was politically incorrect to think that anyone knew more than anyone else about design. The designer acted as coordinator. Also included were some legitimate ideas such as an argumentative approach in which each idea was to be open to discussion and challenge, rather than accepted as a pronouncement from an expert at face value. This approach resulted in buildings that were not quite usable because amateur designers on the committee wanted exotic features that were not workable, but the architect was not in a position to overrule them, and could not persuade them of the folly of their ideas until after the building was built. The third-generation process that followed owes much to the philosophy of Karl Popper (1965), and is called the conjecture-refutation model. It has these characteristics: it returns to the notion of an expert designer proposing a design in the form of a conjecture, which is then examined and opened up to refutation. The process also portrays deﬁnition of the problem and development of the solution(s) as simultaneous activities that support each other. The argument is that the old sequence view (deﬁne problem, design, implement) is inappropriate because problem and solution emerge together. The third generation seems to be the application of problem solving to design. That is, it seems to be an explication of how architecture was done before all these “generations” began, with perhaps the added value of explicit recognition of refutation and debate on proposed designs. Science. Medawar (1969), Weinberg (1994), and Bauer (1994) discuss the process of science and the scientiﬁc method. The basic argument of Medawar

O

323

324 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science and Bauer is that scientists have for the most part ignored the discussion about process and are able to be successful despite ignoring it. They are not really aware of what process they use, and are unable to accurately describe it if they are asked to do so. Furthermore, the people who have tried to deﬁne the scientiﬁc method, such as philosophers and methodologists, describe a process that is not what scientists actually follow. The physicist Weinberg (1994) relates that many physicists puzzle over two phenomena: the unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics, and the unreasonable ineffectiveness of philosophy, in supporting the scientiﬁc enterprise. The general pattern that seems to apply in architecture, science, mathematics, and traditional engineering is that practitioners do not pay much attention to process, but methodologists and philosophers do. We would say that practitioners in all these disciplines apply the human problem-solving process. It is a natural, messy, trial-and-error, opportunistic, iterative, intuitive process that is part creative insight, part rational reasoning, part hard grinding work, and part social interaction with its attendant emotional and non-rational elements. The results, when successful, give the illusion of resulting from a clean, straightforward process. Philosophers, however, try to capture the illusion and prescribe it as the process to follow. That process is unnatural, clean, sequential, rationalized, and objective, and does not square with the practice of human problem solving.

Applying the View We have mentioned in several places in the book that TSE (and software engineering) has focused on process. We have also mentioned that the heritage of MOSES lies more in the orientation of traditional engineering handbooks and less in the process focus of software and systems engineering. More speciﬁcally, the heritage is a combination of the conventional designs of traditional engineering handbooks and the complex systems emphasis on ultimate effects, versatility, and adaptability. The structure and emphasis of the overall book reﬂects this heritage. The heart of the book, Chapters 5 through 11, is directed to models and the model space — the actual designs etc. The process chapter is last, and from the view presented above, one might wonder why we include it at all. It is included for two related reasons. First, the extended and uniﬁed SE of the future as depicted in this book has some implications for the SE process, and it is important to spell out those implications. Perhaps the most important general implication is to reduce the emphasis on process. Other implications are spelled out in this chapter. Second, the point of presenting this view is not to say that process does not matter. The point is that the history of process in SE-related disciplines, and the over-reliance on process in recent decades in software and systems engineering, both indicate that the future SE needs to ﬁnd a more appropriate balance between product and process, or in MOSES terms, between models and modeling or actualization. Part of the needed balance is the recognition of CS and actualization processes.

SE Actualization Processes

O

325

Candidate CSE Expansion Processes ThJTTFDUJPOCSJFﬂZJOUSPEVDFTTFWFSBMDBOEJEBUFQSPDFTTFTGPSFOHJOFFSJOHDPNQMFYTZTUFNTThF TDPQFPGUIFTFDUJPOEPFTOPUJODMVEFUSBEJUJPOBMPSIZCSJETZTUFNTPOMZDPNQMFYTZTUFNT

Garbage Can Model *GPOFUBLFTBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOUPCFBDPNQMFYPSHBOJDIVNBOCBTFETZTUFN UIFOJUJTSFBTPOBCMF UPDPOTJEFSUIFFOHJOFFSJOHPGBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOUPCFTJNJMBSJONBOZXBZTUPPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMEFDJ TJPO NBLJOH QSPQFSMZ DPODFJWFE #Z QSPQFSMZ DPODFJWFE XF NFBO BO PSHBOJ[BUJPOBM EFDJTJPO NFUIPEPSNPEFMUIBUSFHBSETPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBTPSHBOJDTZTUFNT OPUBTNFDIBOJTUJDTZTUFNT0O UIBUCBTJT UIFHBSCBHFDBONPEFM ($. PGPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMDIPJDF $PIFO .BSDI BOE0MTFO JTBDBOEJEBUFNFUIPEBUMFBTUGPSFOHJOFFSJOHPSHBOJ[BUJPOT BOEQPTTJCMZGPSBCSPBEFS DMBTTPG$4 ThF($.XBTEFTJHOFEUPNPEFMiPSHBOJ[FEBOBSDIJFT wEFﬁOFEBTPSHBOJ[BUJPOTPSEFDJTJPO TJUVBUJPOTUIBUIBWFUISFFQSPQFSUJFT*UTHPBMTPSQSFGFSFODFTBSFJODPOTJTUFOUBOEJMMEFﬁOFEJUT QSPDFTTFTBSFOPUVOEFSTUPPECZJUTNFNCFSTBOEQBSUJDJQBUJPO CPUIBVEJFODFBOEEFDJTJPO NBLFSTJONBLJOHDIPJDFTJTIJHIMZﬂVJE'PVSTUSFBNTﬂPXUISPVHIUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPO BOE UIFJSJOUFSBDUJPOHFOFSBUFTEFDJTJPOTJUVBUJPOTThFGPVSTUSFBNTBSFQSPCMFNT TPMVUJPOT QBSUJDJ QBOUT BOE DIPJDF PQQPSUVOJUJFT %FDJTJPONBLJOH TUZMFT BSF EFﬁOFE BT SFTPMVUJPO QSPCMFN JT SFTPMWFE

PWFSTJHIU DIPJDFJTNBEFRVJDLMZ

BOd ﬂJHIU OPQSPCMFNJTSFTPMWFE ThFBVUIPSTTJNVMBUFEUIFTFTUSFBNTVTJOHBWBSJFUZPGﬂPXSBUFTBOEPUIFSDPOEJUJPOT"NPOHUIF SFTVMUTPCUBJOFEXBTUIBUUIFPWFSTJHIUBOd ﬂJHIUEFDJTJPOTUZMFTXFSFNPSFDPNNPOUIBOSFTPMVUJPO 'JPSFUUJBOE-PNJ EFWFMPQFEBOBHFOUCBTFENPEFMUIBUTJNVMBUFTUIF($.BOESFQSP EVDFTNBOZPGJUTQSPQFSUJFTThFZBMTPTUBUFUIBUUIF($.IBTCFFOIJHIMZWJTJCMFBOEJOﬂVFOUJBM JOPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMUIFPSZTJODFJUXBTJOUSPEVDFE BOESFNBJOTTP

Goal-Oriented Methods (PBMPSJFOUBUJPOJOSFRVJSFNFOUTFOHJOFFSJOHIBTBOFYUFOTJWFIJTUPSZ 7BO-BNTXFFSEF CVUUIFQSJNBSZSFBTPOGPSJODMVEJOHUIFUPQJDJOUIJTTFDUJPOJTUIBU SFDFOUMZ NFUIPETBOEMBO HVBHFTGPSHPBMPSJFOUFENPEFMJOHPGBHFOUTBOEBEBQUJWFTZTUFNTIBWFFNFSHFE#SPXOFUBM EFTDSJCFUIFVTFPGUIF;IBOHBOE$IFOH BEBQUBUJPOFYUFOTJPOUP-5-UIBUXBT NFOUJPOFEJO$IBQUFS UPEFWFMPQHPBMPSJFOUFEBEBQUBUJPOSFRVJSFNFOUTVTJOHUIF,"04 NFUIPEPMPHZ,"04QSPWJEFTBTQFDJﬁDBUJPOMBOHVBHFGPSDBQUVSJOHSFRVJSFNFOUTJOUFSNTPG HPBMT DPOTUSBJOUT BDUJPOT BOEBHFOUT %BSJNPOUFUBM *UTVQQPSUTSFﬁOFNFOUPGSFRVJSF NFOUTBOEBTTJHONFOUBTBHFOUSFTQPOTJCJMJUJFT /BLBHBXB ,BSVCF BOE)POJEFO

CAS Organizational Framework "YFMSPEBOE$PIFO IBWFEFﬁOFEBDPNQMFYBEBQUJWFTZTUFNT $"4 GSBNFXPSLGPSPSHB OJ[BUJPOBM BDUJPOT BOE EFDJTJPOT UIBU BEBQUT NPEFMT TVDI BT CJPMPHJDBM FWPMVUJPO UP FOUFSQSJTFT "O FOUFSQSJTF JT DPODFQUVBMJ[FE BT B QPQVMBUJPO PG NPSF PS MFTT BVUPOPNPVT BHFOUT PG WBSJPVT UZQFTThFLFZQSPDFTTFTBSFWBSJBUJPO JOUFSBDUJPO BOETFMFDUJPO7BSJBUJPOJOWPMWFTNFDIBOJTNT GPSDPQZJOH XJUIFSSPS PSSFDPNCJOJOHJEFBTPSJOGPSNBUJPOThFHPBMJTUPBDIJFWFBCBMBODF CFUXFFOWBSJFUZBOEVOJGPSNJUZ*OUFSBDUJPOQBUUFSOTGPSNBNPOHUIFBHFOUTUIBUJOﬂVFODFUIFJS

326

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

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ﬀTQSJOH ThFJS GSBNFXPSL FNQIBTJ[FT CPUUPNVQNBOBHFNFOU BOEUIVTDPSSFTQPOETTVCTUBOUJBMMZUPUIFFOUFSQSJTFBVUPOPNZ &" FMF NFOUPG.04&4DPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPO

CASE 8IJUF IBTEFﬁOFEBNFUIPEPMPHZDBMMFE$PNQMFY"EBQUJWF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH $"4& EFTJHOFEUPTVQQPSUDPNQMFYTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHBTXFIBWFEFﬁOFEJUJOUIJTCPPL XJUIBGPDVT POBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMTFUUJOH. ThFNFUIPEPMPHZMBZTPVUBTFUPGFJHIUBDUJWJUJFT $SFBUFDMJNBUFGPSDIBOHFJOBOPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMDPOUFYU UIJTJOWPMWFTDPOWJODJOHNBOBHF NFOUUPTIJGUGSPNIJFSBSDIJDBMDPOUSPMUPBNPSFOFUXPSLFENPEFM "SDIJUFDUBTUSBUFHZEFUFSNJOFIPXUPFOHJOFFSUIFFOWJSPONFOUTVDIUIBUJUXJMMJOﬂVFODF UIFTZTUFNUPFWPMWFBOEBEBQUJOUIFEFTJSFEEJSFDUJPO 5BSHFUPVUDPNFTQBDFTJO.04&4UFSNT UIJTJTBEFTDSJQUJPOPGJOEJSFDUFﬀFDUTPOUIFVTFS PSUIFFOWJSPONFOUUPCFBDIJFWFECZUIFTZTUFN 3FXBSESFTVMUTEFﬁOFBOEHJWFSFXBSETUPUIFTZTUFNGPSBDIJFWJOHUIFUBSHFUFEPVUDPNFT 'PSNVMBUF EFDJTJPONBLJOH IFVSJTUJDT EFﬁOF JOEJDBUPST UP IFMQ NBOBHFST JNQSPWF UIFJS EFDJTJPONBLJOHBCJMJUJFTJOUIFDPOUFYUPGUIFTZTUFNBOEUIFFOWJSPONFOU 4UJNVMBUFOBUVSBMQSPDFTTFTFYQMPJUUIFOBUVSBMJOJUJBUJWFBOEQSPCMFNTPMWJOHBCJMJUZPGUIF TZTUFNEFWFMPQFSTUPBDIJFWFTZTUFNJOOPWBUJPOBOEJOUFHSBUJPO %FWFMPQJOPQFSBUJPOBMFOWJSPOTJNQSPWFBOEBEBQUUIFTZTUFNXIJMFJUJTPQFSBUJOH "TTFTT MFBSO BOESFQMBOMFBSOGSPNUIJTDZDMFBOEQMBOUIFOFYUPOF ThFDPSFQSPDFTTJTBDZDMFPGBDUJWJUJFTooooBOECBDLUPThFﬁSTUUXPBDUJWJUJFTFOHJ OFFSUIFFOWJSPONFOU XIJMFBDUJWJUJFTBOEFOHJOFFSUIFTZTUFNJUTFMG#FUXFFOPSJOQBSBMMFM XJUIBDUJWJUJFTBOE BDUJWJUJFT BOEDBOCFQFSGPSNFE ThFTFBDUJWJUJFTSFﬂFDUUIF.04&4$4&UIFNFTPGJOﬂVFODJOHUIFFOWJSPONFOUBOEFYQMPJU JOHUIFBVUPOPNZBOEJOJUJBUJWFPG$4TVDIBTQFPQMFUIFSFEVDFEDPOUSPMPWFS$4 UIFJOEJSFDU FOWJSPONFOUFﬀFDUTPGBTZTUFN UIFTJNVMUBOFPVTPQFSBUJPOBOEEFWFMPQNFOUPGTZTUFNT BOEUIF BEBQUBUJPOEVFUPMFBSOJOHBOEGFFECBDL

Joint Cognitive SE Process )PMMOBHFMBOE8PPET EFTDSJCFUIFDPHOJUJWFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHBQQSPBDIUPTPDJPUFDIOJ DBMTZTUFNT"KPJOUDPHOJUJWFTZTUFN +$4 JTBTZTUFNUIBUJODMVEFTCPUIIVNBOTBOENBDIJOFT XIJDI.04&4DBMMTIZCSJETZTUFNTThFGPDVTPGDPHOJUJWF4&JTOPUPOUIFIVNBOBOENBDIJOF

SE Actualization Processes

O

327

BTTFQBSBUFJOUFSBDUJOHDPNQPOFOUT CVUSBUIFSPOUIFFYUFSOBMGVODUJPOTPG+$4BTBTJOHMFTZTUFN ThFIVNBONBDIJOFSFMBUJPOJTWJFXFEBTDPBHFODZSBUIFSUIBOJOUFSBDUJPO

Agile Processes "HJMFQSPDFTTFTBSFBOJNQPSUBOUBTQFDUPGBEESFTTJOHTPNFPGUIF54&XFBLOFTTFTThJTBQQSPBDI IBTCFFOVTFENPTUMZJOTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH SFQSFTFOUFEJONFUIPETTVDIBT91 FYUSFNFQSP HSBNNJOH #FDL BOE "OESFT BOE 4DSVN 4DIXBCFS ThF NBKPS UISVTU JT B MJHIU XFJHIU BQQSPBDI UIBU FNQIBTJ[FT TNBMM BOE GBTU BT JO TNBMM UFBNT TNBMM EFMJWFSJFT BOE SBQJE EFWFMPQNFOUBOEGSFRVFOUEFMJWFSJFT (FOFSBMEJTDVTTJPOTPGUIFBQQSPBDIJODMVEFUIPTFCZ$PDLCVSO BOE-BSNBO 1SPQPOFOUTPGUIFBQQSPBDIIBWFGPSNFEBO"HJMF"MMJBODF "HJMF ThFZBEIFSFUPUIFBHJMF NBOJGFTUP .BOJGFTUP

XIJDITUBUFTUIFGPMMPXJOHWBMVFT O O O O

*OEJWJEVBMTBOEJOUFSBDUJPOTPWFSQSPDFTTFTBOEUPPMT 8PSLJOHTPGUXBSFPWFSDPNQSFIFOTJWFEPDVNFOUBUJPO $VTUPNFSDPMMBCPSBUJPOPWFSDPOUSBDUOFHPUJBUJPO 3FTQPOEJOHUPDIBOHFPWFSGPMMPXJOHBQMBO

ThFCBTJDUFOFUTPGBHJMFQSPDFTTFTBSFBQJFDFPGUIFPWFSBMMVOJﬁFE.04&4QSPDFTTDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT

Enterprise Engineering ThF DPODFQU PG FOUFSQSJTF FOHJOFFSJOH BQQFBSFE CSJFﬂZ JO BOE TFF FH -JMFT BOE 1SFTMFZ CVUJUOFWFSHPUUSBDUJPO3FDFOUMZBTJNJMBSCVUFYQBOEFEJEFBIBTSFBQQFBSFEJOUIF DPOUFYUPGDPNQMFYTZTUFNT BOEJTTPNFUJNFTDBMMFEFOUFSQSJTFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 4XBS[BOE%F3PTB EFﬁOFBGSBNFXPSLGPSFOUFSQSJTFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTFT ThFZEFTDSJCFFOUFSQSJTFBTBEJﬀFSFOULJOEPGFOUJUZUIBUHPFTCFZPOEBCVTJOFTTFOUJUZPSBMBSHF TZTUFNJUJTBDPMMFDUJPOPGTZTUFNTUIBUJODMVEFTQFPQMF QSPDFTTFT BOEUFDIOPMPHZIBTJNQSF DJTFCPVOEBSJFTBOEJTDIBSBDUFSJ[FECZFNFSHFOUCFIBWJPSBOEFOWJSPONFOUEFQFOEFODJFTTheir GSBNFXPSLBEESFTTFTOPUKVTUUIFTFTZTUFNTCVUBMTPUIFMBSHFSFOWJSPONFOUJOXIJDIUIFZFYJTU BOE UIF GBDUPST TIBQJOH UIF DIBOHF PS FWPMVUJPO PG UIF TZTUFNT They deﬁne ﬁvF QSPDFTTFT GPS BEESFTTJOH TVDI TZTUFNT 5FDIOPMPHZ 1MBOOJOH $BQBCJMJUZ#BTFE &OHJOFFSJOH "OBMZTJT &OUFSQSJTF "SDIJUFDUVSF 4USBUFHJD 5FDIOJDBM 1MBOOJOH BOE &OUFSQSJTF "OBMZTJT BOE "TTFTTNFOU 3FCPWJDI EFﬁOFTFOUFSQSJTFJOBTJNJMBSNBOOFSBOEBEESFTTFTTPNFPGUIFTBNF UIFNFT )F CSJOHT JO DPODFQUT PG FWPMVUJPOBSZ CJPMPHZ BOE TPDJBM TZTUFNT BOE IJT GPDVT JT PO UIFOPUJPOTPGBDUVBMJ[BUJPOBOEJOﬂVFODFPGFOUFSQSJTFTBTPQQPTFEUPUIFDMBTTJDBMTQFDJGZBOE CVJMEBQQSPBDIPG54&ThFMJNJUFEDPOUSPMPGFOUFSQSJTFTBTDPNQMFYTZTUFNTOFDFTTJUBUFTNPWJOH UPXBSETIBQJOHBOEJNQSPWJOHPVUDPNFTSBUIFSUIBOFOHJOFFSJOHTQFDJﬁDSFTVMUTThFBQQSPBDIJT JOUFOEFEUPDPNQMFNFOUDMBTTJDBM4&CZTIBQJOHUIFFOWJSPONFOUPGUIPTFTZTUFNT

Bricolage and Muddling Through ThSFFDPODFQUTEJTDVTTFEJOUIFCPPLBSFOPXCSPVHIUUPHFUIFSUP GPSNBDBOEJEBUF$4&QSP DFTT UIBU DBO BQQMZ UP UIF DSFBUJPO PG XIPMF OFX UFDIOPMPHZ BSFBT OPU KVTU UIF FOHJOFFSJOH PG

328

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

JOEJWJEVBMTZTUFNTThFDPODFQUPGDPOUJOVBMDIBOHFBOEFWPMVUJPOXBTEJTDVTTFEJO$IBQUFS BOEJTBOVOEFSMZJOHUIFNFPGUIJTDIBQUFS"VUPOPNZBOETFMGBDUVBMJ[BUJPO XIJDICSJOHJOB CPUUPNVQﬂBWPS XFSFJOUSPEVDFEJO$IBQUFSBOEBSFBNBKPSUIFNFPGUIJTDIBQUFSThFUIJSE DPODFQUJTDPMMBCPSBUJPO BMTPJOUSPEVDFEJO$IBQUFS "TJHOJﬁDBOUQPSUJPOPG4&FﬀPSUGPDVTFTPOMBSHFTZTUFNTUIBUUFOEUPHSPXBOEFWPMWFPWFSBO FYUFOEFEQFSJPEPGUJNF8FIBWFTVHHFTUFEUIBUFWPMVUJPOBOEBVUPOPNZ BTXFMMBTDPMMBCPSBUJPO XJMMQMBZBMBSHFSBOENPSFWJTJCMFSPMFJOUIFTFUZQFTPGTZTUFNTJOUIFGVUVSF4& #VUEPUIFTFQSPDFTTFTBMTPBQQMZUPUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPGBXIPMFOFXUFDIOPMPHZBSFB 8FNFO UJPOBDBTFTUVEZBOEUXPSFMBUFEQSPDFTTFTUIBUJNQMZUIFBOTXFSJTZFTThFDBTFTUVEZJTBDPN QBSJTPOPGUIFBQQSPBDIFTUPUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPGXJOEUVSCJOFUFDIOPMPHZVTFEJO%FONBSLBOEUIF 6OJUFE4UBUFTGSPNUIFNJETJOUPUIFT EFTDSJCFEJO(BSVEBOE,BSOF ThFZDIBS BDUFSJ[FUIF%BOJTIBQQSPBDIBTCSJDPMBHF NFBOJOHSFTPVSDFGVMOFTTBOEJNQSPWJTBUJPOPGNVMUJQMF DPMMBCPSBUJOHBHFOUTBOETUBLFIPMEFSTJODPTIBQJOHUIFUSBKFDUPSZPSQBUIPGUIFUFDIOPMPHZUIFZ TVNNBSJ[FUIJTBTiFNFSHFOUDPTIBQJOHw ThF"NFSJDBOBQQSPBDIJTDIBSBDUFSJ[FEBT CSFBLUISPVHI NFBOJOHBHFOUTBUUFNQUUPQSPEVDFTVEEFOESBNBUJDPVUDPNFTThF"NFSJDBOCSFBL UISPVHIBQQSPBDIJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUSBEJUJPOBMFOUSFQSFOFVSTIJQMJUFSBUVSFUIBUBTTPDJBUFTTVDDFTT BOEGBJMVSFPGJOJUJBUJWFTXJUIJOEJWJEVBMTThF%BOJTICSJDPMBHFBQQSPBDIJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIBTDIPPM PGUIPVHIU BOEMJUFSBUVSF SFGFSSFEUPBTTPDJBMDPOTUSVDUJPOPGUFDIOPMPHJDBMTZTUFNT 4$05

XIFSF UIFPVUDPNFSFTVMUTGSPNBQSPDFTTUIBUJTNPSFEJTUSJCVUFEBDSPTTBHFOUTBMPOHUIFUFDIOPMPHZQBUI ThF%BOFTEJEOPUQVSTVFBEFTJHOJOUFOTJWFSFTFBSDIBQQSPBDICVUJOTUFBEUPPLEFTJHOTBOE NBUFSJBMTUIBUXFSFBWBJMBCMFBOETUBSUFEQSPEVDJOHTJNQMFQSPUPUZQFTThFZMFBSOFEOPUKVTUGSPN UIFJSJOEJWJEVBMFYQFSJNFOUTBOEQSPUPUZQFT CVUBMTPUIFWBSJPVTﬁSNTXPSLJOHUIJTBSFBDPNNV OJDBUFEXJUIBOEMFBSOFEGSPNFBDIPUIFS BOEGPSNFEBOBTTPDJBUJPOUPGVSUIFSUIFDPMMBCPSBUJPO ThFZBMTPIBEFYUFOTJWFJOWPMWFNFOUXJUIVTFST BOEUIFJSTDBMFVQPGUIFEFTJHOXBTCBTFEPO MFBSOJOHGSPNUIFQSPUPUZQFTBOEUIFVTFST ThF"NFSJDBOT POUIFPUIFSIBOE GPDVTFEPOEFWFMPQJOHUIFCFTUEFTJHOBOEPOEFﬁOJOHB LOPXMFEHFCBTFPGCBTJDFOHJOFFSJOHTDJFODFJOXJOEQPXFS BOEUIFZEFFNQIBTJ[FEﬁFMEUFTUJOH ThFMFBSOJOHQSPDFTTXBTCBTFENPSFPOBUFDIOPMPHZQVTINPEFMPGSFTFBSDISFTVMUTGSPNUIFMBCT UPJOEVTUSZEFWFMPQFSTThFQPMJDZNBLFSTBMTPIBEBCSFBLUISPVHINFOUBMJUZ BUUFNQUJOHUPKVNQ TUBSUUIFUFDIOPMPHZ BOEUIFOMBUFSBCSVQUMZSFNPWJOHTVCTJEJFT 8FXPVMETVNNBSJ[FUIF%BOJTICSJDPMBHFBQQSPBDIBTHSPXUIBOEPQQPSUVOJTUJDMFBSOJOHJOB VTFSFOWJSPONFOU BOEUIF"NFSJDBOCSFBLUISPVHIBQQSPBDIBTEFUFSNJOJOHUIFPQUJNVNBOTXFS JOBSFTFBSDIFOWJSPONFOUThFSFTVMUXBTUIBU EFTQJUFBOBMNPTUPSEFSPGNBHOJUVEFBEWBOUBHFPG UIF6OJUFE4UBUFTPWFS%FONBSLJO3%GVOEJOHBOETVCTJEJFT UIF%BOFTCFDBNFUIFXPSMEMFBE FSTJOXJOEQPXFS JODMVEJOHNBSLFUTIBSF XIJMFUIF64FﬀPSUEJEOPUBDIJFWFWJBCJMJUZ "SFMBUFEQSPDFTTJTPOFUIBUEFWFMPQFEJOUIFTBOEJTNPSFBTTPDJBUFEXJUIFOUFSQSJTFT FTQFDJBMMZPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBOETPDJFUJFTThJTQSPDFTT DBMMFEiNVEEMJOHUISPVHIwPSJODSFNFOUBM JTNCZ-JOECMPN

JTBMTPDMPTFMZBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIFCPVOEFESBUJPOBMJUZPG)FSCFSU 4JNPOJOIJTTUVEZPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOT#PUIBSHVFBHBJOTUUIFQSPQPTJUJPOUIBUEFDJTJPONBLFSTJO PSHBOJ[BUJPOTBOETPDJFUJFTDBO BOEUIFSFGPSFTIPVME NBLFEFDJTJPOTVTJOHBiTDJFOUJﬁDwBQQSPBDI CBTFEPODPNQMFUFJOGPSNBUJPOBOEPQUJNJ[BUJPOPGBMMGBDUPSTBOEUSBEFPﬀTJOWPMWFE*OTUFBE UIFBWBJMBCMFJOGPSNBUJPOBOEPQUJNJ[BUJPO SBUJPOBMJUZ BSFCPUIMJNJUFE4JNPOVTFEUIFUFSN iTBUJTﬁDJOH wNFBOJOHTBUJTGBDUPSZ JODPOUSBTUXJUIUIFHPBMPGPQUJNJ[JOH ThFTFDMPTFMZSFMBUFEQSPDFTTFTJOEJDBUFUIBUGPSDPNQMFYTZTUFNT BOEGPSUIFNBKPSJUZPG4& TZTUFNT USZJOHUPHFUFWFSZUIJOHiSJHIUwBOEDPNQMFUFBUUIFTUBSU BOESFMZJOHPOBCSFBLUISPVHI JTOPUSFBMJTUJD"NPSFWJBCMFBQQSPBDIJTUPTUBSUTNBMMBOEMFBSO HSPX TDBMF BEBQU BOEFWPMWF ThBUJTBNPSFOBUVSBMQSPCMFNTPMWJOHQSPDFTT

SE Actualization Processes

O

329

Modeling Approaches 8FNFOUJPOFETFWFSBMNPEFMJOHBQQSPBDIFTJO$IBQUFSXIFSFUIFWJFXXBTUIBUUIFZXFSFQBSU PGUIFSBUJPOBMJ[FEHFOFBMPHZPG.04&48FNFOUJPOUIFNIFSFJOBEJﬀFSFOUWJFXUIFZBSFBMTP QPUFOUJBMBQQMJDBUJPOTPGUIF.04&4DPODFQUTThBUJT UIFZBSF GPSUIFNPTUQBSU OPUBTDJFODF PG NPEFMPSJFOUFE TZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH CVU SBUIFS B NFUIPE GPS BQQMZJOH JU 5P UIF FYUFOU UIBU UIFZBSFDPOTJTUFOUXJUI.04&4BTEFﬁOFEJOUIJTCPPL UIFZDBOCFDPOTJEFSFE.04&4BQQMJFE NFUIPET*OUIFDPOUFYUPGUIJTDIBQUFS UIJTDBUFHPSZPGNFUIPETGPDVTFTMFTTPOUIFEJTUJODUJPO CFUXFFO54&BOE$4&BOENPSFPOUIFVOEFSMZJOHGPVOEBUJPOPGNPEFMJOH XIJDIFOBCMFTCPUI 54&BOE$4&*OUIBUTFOTF UIFZSFQSFTFOUBTFHVFUPUIFTFDUJPOFOUJUMFEi"6OJﬁFE"DUVBMJ[BUJPO 1SPDFTT wXIJDITQFMMTPVUUIF.04&4VOJﬁFEQSPDFTTFT

Object Process Methodology %PSJ IBT EFWFMPQFE B NFUIPE DBMMFE 0CKFDU 1SPDFTT .FUIPEPMPHZ 01. BWBJMBCMF BT B CPPL %PSJ BOEB8FCTJUF 01. 01.TVQQPSUTNPEFMJOHTZTUFNTUIBUJODMVEFIVNBOT BHFOUT

NBDIJOFT BOEJOGPSNBUJPO*UJODMVEFTBMBOHVBHFDBMMFEUIF0CKFDU1SPDFTT-BOHVBHF 01-

XIJDIIBTBGPSNBMCBTJTCVUJTEVBMQVSQPTFJOUIBUJUJTJOUFOEFEUPCFCPUINBDIJOF SFBEBCMFBOEIVNBOSFBEBCMF*UVTFTBDPOTUSBJOFETVCTFUPG&OHMJTIUPBDIJFWFUIFMBUUFS*UDBO CFWJFXFEBTBOBMUFSOBUJWFUP6.-PS4ZT.- ThFDPOUFOUPG01.JODMVEFTBSFBTUIBUNBQEJSFDUMZUPTFWFSBM.04&4NPEFMTQBDFEJNFO TJPOT EZOBNJDT NBQT UP 5JNF TUSVDUVSF BOE BHHSFHBUJPO $PNQPTJUJPO HFOFSBMJ[BUJPO BOE JOTUBOUJBUJPO $PNNPOJ[BUJPO TZTUFNT UIFPSZ BOE NPEFMJOH OBUVSBM BOE BSUJﬁDJBM TZTUFNT 4ZTUFNTTDJFODF 01.JTBNFUIPEUIBUJTMBSHFMZDPOTJTUFOUXJUI.04&4BOEJTBQPUFOUJBMBQQMJDBUJPOPGJUBT B.04&NFUIPE

Service-Oriented Modeling Framework ThF4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH'SBNFXPSL 40.' EFﬁOFECZ#FMM XBTDJUFEJO$IBQUFS BTBOFYBNQMFPGBO40"GSBNFXPSLThJTDIBQUFSWJFXT40.'BTBOFYBNQMFPGBNPEFM JOHBQQSPBDIUIBUGPMMPXTUIF40"TUZMF*UBEESFTTFTCPUICVTJOFTTBOEUFDIOJDBMNPEFMJOH BOE FODPVSBHFTHFOFSBMJ[BUJPOPGTFSWJDFDPODFQUTGPSNPSFHFOFSBMVTF*UEFﬁOFTUISFFNPEFMJOHFOWJ SPONFOUT DPODFQUVBMFOWJSPONFOU BOBMZTJTFOWJSPONFOU BOE MPHJDBMFOWJSPONFOU*U BMTPFNQIBTJ[FTUIFBCJMJUZUPEFBMXJUIiNFUBNPSQIPTJTwPSUIFDPOUJOVBMMZDIBOHJOHCVTJOFTT FOWJSPONFOU.PEFMJOHOPUBUJPOTBSFEFﬁOFEGPSBOBMZTJT CVTJOFTTJOUFHSBUJPO EFTJHO DPNQPTJ UJPOTUZMFT BOEBSDIJUFDUVSF

Others 0UIFS NPEFMPSJFOUFE BOE NPEFMCBTFE BQQSPBDIFT EFTDSJCFE JO $IBQUFS JODMVEF UIF NBUI FNBUJDBMMZPSJFOUFE NPEFMCBTFE4&PG8ZNPSF

XIJDIJTCFJOHSFWJTJUFEBU*/$04&BTB GPVOEBUJPOPGUIF.#4&FﬀPSUUIFSF&TUFGBO NFOUJPOTTFWFSBM.#4&SFMBUFEBQQSPBDIFT JODMVEJOH 01. BOE NPEFMCBTFE BSDIJUFDUJOH BOE FOHJOFFSJOH .#"4& PG #PFIN BOE 1PSU 0UIFSTJHOJﬁDBOUFﬀPSUTBU0.(BOE*/$04&BSFBMTPSFMFWBOUIFSF0OUIF$4&TJEF #PDBSSB IBTCFFONFOUJPOFEJOWBSJPVTQMBDFTBTBTPVSDFPG$4NPEFMT0OUIF54&TJEF 4BHFBOE"SNTUSPOH DPVMESFBTPOBCMZCFDIBSBDUFSJ[FEBTBNPEFMCBTFE54&CPPL

330 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

A Uniﬁed Actualization Process ThJTTFDUJPOEJTDVTTFTBTQFDUTPGBVOJﬁFEDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTUIBUJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUI .04&4BOEUIFFYQBOEFETDPQFPGUIFGVUVSF4&ThFTFDUJPOEPFTOPUMBZPVUBDPNQMFUFQSPDFTT PSTFUPGQSPDFTTFTCVUJUEPFTJEFOUJGZDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT QSPDFTTUZQFT BOEFYBNQMFQSPDFTTFTThF ﬁSTUTVCTFDUJPOMJTUTBTFUPGFTTFOUJBMDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOEEFQJDUTBTFUPGCBTJDQSPDFTTUZQFTJOUIF BDUVBMJ[BUJPO TQBDF ThF SFNBJOJOH TVCTFDUJPOT UIFO EJTDVTT WJFXT BOE FYBNQMF QSPDFTTFT UIBU SFﬂFDUUIFTFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOEUZQFT

Characteristics and Types &TTFOUJBMDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGUIFDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTJODMVEFUIFGPMMPXJOH "MMPXOBUVSBMPQQPSUVOJTUJDQSPCMFNTPMWJOHJOUIFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF &YQFDU NBOBHF BOEFYQMPJUDIBOHFBUWBSJPVTMFWFMT 3FDPHOJ[FBOEEJﬀFSFOUJBUFFMFNFOUTUIBUBSFWPMBUJMFWFSTVTTUBCMFVTFUIFTUBCMFUPBODIPS BOEHVJEFUIFWPMBUJMFPOFJNQPSUBOUTPVSDFPGTUBCJMJUZJTEPNBJOLOPXMFEHF DBQUVSFE JOUIFHFOFSBMNPEFMTLOPXMFEHFTQBDFPGUIFNPEFMTQBDFBOPUIFSTPVSDFJTUIFHFOFSBM NPEFMTUIBUSFﬂFDUUIFWJTJPOPGUIFTZTUFNCFJOHFOHJOFFSFE 'SFRVFOUGFFECBDLBOEMFBSOJOHIJOETJHIUJTVTVBMMZCFUUFSUIBOGPSFTJHIU .PEFTUQMBOOJOHSFDPHOJ[FUIBUQMBOTBSFOFFEFECVUUIFZBMXBZTDIBOHF TPUJNFTQFOU POQMBOEFUBJMTJTXBTUFE 3FDPHOJ[F BOE TVQQPSU B SBOHF PG DPOUSPM GSPN DPOUSPMMFE FOHJOFFSJOH PG USBEJUJPOBM NBDIJOFTUPTFUUJOHHPBMTCBTFEPOJOEJSFDUFﬀFDUPOUIFFOWJSPONFOUUPJOEJSFDUJOﬂV FODFWJBFOWJSPONFOUTIBQJOH ThFTFUPGBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTFTEFTDSJCFEJOUIJTDIBQUFSBQQMZUPCPUISBEJDBMEFTJHO BOEOPSNBMEFTJHO3BEJDBMEFTJHOJTNPSFMJLFSFTFBSDIPS3%OPSNBMEFTJHOJTNPSF MJLFUBJMPSJOH. ThFZFNQIBTJ[FEJﬀFSFOUQBSUTPGUIFQSPDFTTFT 'JHVSFTIPXTBWJFXPGUIFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDFUIBUFNQIBTJ[FTQSPDFTTUZQFTBOEEF FNQIBTJ[FTTVCTQBDFT FTQFDJBMMZUIFQSPCMFNTQBDFBOETPMVUJPOTQBDF XIJDIBSFOPUWJTJCMFJO UIJTWJFXThFQSPDFTTUZQFTJODMVEFDSFBUJWFQSPDFTT SFQFBUBCMFQSPDFTT BOEBVUPOPNPVTQSPDFTT ThFﬁHVSFBMTPDPOUSBTUT.04&4XJUIUSBEJUJPOBMFNQIBTJTPGTFMFDUFEEJTDJQMJOFTUIBUJODMVEF TPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH 4& BOEUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHEJTDJQMJOFTTVDIBTDIFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH BOENFDIBOJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH*UTIPVMECFOPUFEUIBUCPUIDSFBUJWFBOESFQFBUBCMFQSPDFTTFTBSF QBSU PG .04&4 BT XFMM BT QBSU PG TPGUXBSF BOE TZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH ThF EJﬀFSFODF JT POF PG FNQIBTJT.04&4 GPMMPXJOHUSBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLT SFMJFTNPSFPOFYJTUJOHNPEFMT BOELOPXMFEHF UIFNPEFMTQBDF

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

SE Actualization Processes MOSES Manifestation

Figure 13.2

Creative Process

331

Traditional Emphasis

View of Collective Actualization Space

Tailoring, specializing, creating

O

Software and systems engineering

Repeatable Process

Self-actualizing

Autonomous Process

–

Body of knowledge portion of model space

Existing Models and Knowledge

Traditional engineering handbook focus

Process view of actualization space.

O &YBNQMFTPGFBDICPY N $SFBUJWFTQFDJBMJ[JOHBEFTJHOQBUUFSODSFBUJOHBSBEJDBMOFXEFTJHO N 3FQFBUBCMFDPOﬁHVSBUJPONBOBHFNFOUBGBDUPSZPSQSPEVDUJPOMJOFQSPDFTT N "VUPOPNPVTTFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPO N &YJTUJOHDPOWFOUJPOBMEFTJHOPSEFTJHOQBUUFSO

Opportunistic Process View ThFﬁSTUTUFQJOBEESFTTJOHFYJTUJOHQSPDFTTFTJTUPJOWFTUJHBUFUIFBDUVBMQSPDFTTUIBUDPNQFUFOU FOHJOFFSTVTFJOFOHJOFFSJOHTZTUFNT BTPQQPTFEUPUIFQSPDFTTUIFZBSFUPMEUPVTF'JHVSF TIPXTUIFSFTVMUTPGFYQFSJNFOUTJOUSBDLJOHUIFBDUJWJUJFTPGFYQFSJFODFEEFTJHOFST $POLMJO ThFBDUVBMQSPDFTTJTUIFKBHHFEMJOF HPJOHCBDLBOEGPSUICFUXFFOQSPCMFNBOETPMVUJPO CFUXFFO

Linear method Designer/subject process

Gather data Problem Analyze data

Formulate solution

Solution

Implement solution Time

Figure 13.3 Pattern of cognitive activity of one designer: the “jagged” line. (Source: Conklin, J. Dialogue Mapping: Building Shared Understanding of Wicked Problems, Chichester, England: John Wiley. 2006. Used with permission.)

332 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

UPQBOECPUUPNThFTUSBJHIUFSMJOFJTUIFXBUFSGBMMNPEFM*UJTBOVOOBUVSBMBDUGPSBOFOHJOFFS UPUSZUPFOHJOFFSJOBMJOFBSXBUFSGBMMTFRVFODFThJTDPODMVTJPOJTCBTFEOPUPOMZPOUIFSFTVMUPG UIJTPOFTUVEZ CVUBMTPPODPOTJEFSBCMFFYQFSJFODFUIBUJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIJTTUVEZ$POLMJODBMMT JUPQQPSUVOJUZESJWFOQSPDFTTThFPQQPSUVOJTUJDCFIBWJPSQBUUFSOPGEFTJHOFST VQBOEEPXO JO UFSNTPGUPQMFWFMBOECPUUPNMFWFM JTUIFTBNFQBUUFSOBTUIFCFIBWJPSPGDFSUBJODIBPUJDEZOBNJ DBMTZTUFNT"OFYBNQMF UBLFOGSPN.BSUFMMJ o

JTUIFEJﬀFSFODFCFUXFFOUXPPSCJUT PGUIFEZOBNJDBMTZTUFNYO YO ¦YO ThFUXPPSCJUTIBWFJOJUJBMWBMVFTYBOEZ "QMPUPGUIFJUFSBUJPOOVNCFSOBHBJOTUUIFBCTPMVUFEJﬀFSFODF]YO¦ZO]TIPXTBQBU UFSOTJNJMBSUPUIFKBHHFEMJOFJO'JHVSF*UBQQFBSTUIBUUIFSFBMEFTJHOQSPDFTTJTDIBPUJD JOTUFBEPGMJOFBSBOEiEJTDJQMJOFEwThJTJOEJWJEVBMPQQPSUVOJTNJTBMTPDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIFDPM MBCPSBUJWFPQQPSUVOJTNFWJEFOUJOUIFCSJDPMBHFQSPDFTTNFOUJPOFEFBSMJFSJOUIFDIBQUFS 8IZJTUIJTJNQPSUBOU *OHFOFSBM UIFOBUVSBMIVNBOQSPCMFNTPMWJOHQSPDFTTJTOPUMJOFBS JUJTPQQPSUVOJTUJD BOENPWFTCBDLBOEGPSUIUPEJﬀFSFOUQBSUTPGUIFQSPCMFNCFJOHTPMWFEBOE UP EJﬀFSFOU BTQFDUT PG UIF TPMVUJPO ThF DPOTUSBJOU PG B MJOFBS TUFQCZTUFQ FOHJOFFSJOH QSPDFTT JTVOOBUVSBMBOEDPVOUFSQSPEVDUJWF*OFOHJOFFSJOH UIFSFTVMUJOHNPEFMTBOESFMBUJPOTCFUXFFO NPEFMT BOECFUXFFONPEFMTBOETZTUFNT BSFJNQPSUBOUThFTFRVFODFJOXIJDIUIFNPEFMTXFSF EFﬁOFEJTOPUJOJUTFMGJNQPSUBOUThJTJTOPUFYBDUMZBOFXJEFBTFF1BSOBTBOE$MFNFOUT )PXFWFS JUT JNQPSUBODF IBT OPU CFFO VOEFSTUPPE CZ UIF UPQEPXO MJOFBS FOHJOFFSJOH QSPDFTT NPWFNFOUPG54& "OPUIFSWJFXPGUIFOBUVSBMQSPDFTTJTUIFQV[[MFNFUBQIPS1VUUJOHUPHFUIFSBKJHTBXQV[[MFPS BDSPTTXPSEQV[[MFJOWPMWFTKVNQJOHBSPVOEUPXIFSFWFSXFDBONBLFQSPHSFTTOFYU ThJTSBJTFTBRVFTUJPO*GFOHJOFFSJOHBOEBDUVBMJ[BUJPOBDUJWJUJFTBSFVODPOTUSBJOFEBOEBMMPXFE UPKVNQBSPVOEJOBDIBPUJDGBTIJPO IPXBSFQSPKFDUTUPCFNBOBHFE ThFQSFMJNJOBSZBOTXFSJT JOUXPQBSUT ThFZBSFOPUVODPOTUSBJOFE4FRVFODFDPOTUSBJOUTBSFSFNPWFECVUOPUUIFSFBMDPOTUSBJOUT XIJDIBSFUIFDPOUFOUPGUIFNPEFMTBOEUIFJSSFMBUJPOT BTNFOUJPOFEBCPWF ThFPQQPSUVOJTUJDQSPDFTTJTPOFWJFXPGUIFPWFSBMMBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT0UIFSWJFXTBSF EFQJDUFEJOUIFTVCTFDUJPOTUIBUGPMMPX &YBNQMFTPG *OUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPGBHJWFOTZTUFN SFNPWFUIFDPOTUSBJOUUIBUBDPNQMFUF TFUPGSFRVJSFNFOUTNVTUCFTQFDJﬁFEBOEBHSFFEPOCFGPSFXFTUBSUUIJOLJOHBCPVUBSDIJUFDUVSF *OTUFBE DPOTUSBJO UIF BSDIJUFDUVSF BOE UIF SFRVJSFNFOUT UP CF DPOTJTUFOU UIJT NVTU CF USVF XIFUIFSUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTXFSFEFﬁOFEﬁSTU PSUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFXBTEFﬁOFEﬁSTU PSUIFZXFSF EFﬁOFEJOQBSBMMFM3FNPWFUIFDPOTUSBJOUUIBUBOBSDIJUFDUVSF XIJDIEFﬁOFTJOUFSBDUJOHDPN QPOFOUT CFTQFDJﬁFECFGPSFFBDIDPNQPOFOUJTTQFDJﬁFEBOECVJMU*OTUFBE DPOTUSBJOUIFSFMBUJPO UPCFUIBUUIFDPNQPOFOUTNBUDIUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFThJTNVTUCFUSVFXIFUIFSUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFJT EFﬁOFEﬁSTU BTJOUPQEPXO54&PSUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFBOEUIFDPNQPOFOUTXFSFTQFDJﬁFEJOQBSBM MFMPSUIFDPNQPOFOUTXFSFTQFDJﬁFEBOECVJMUCFGPSFUIFBSDIJUFDUVSFXBTEFﬁOFE BTBMMPXFEJO TZTUFNPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH SFWFSTFFOHJOFFSJOH DPNQPOFOUCBTFEEFWFMPQNFOU PS40"

Change Process View ThFMFWFMTPGDIBOHFXFSFJEFOUJﬁFEBOEEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS*OUIJTTVCTFDUJPOXFCSJFﬂZOPUF IPXBOBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTUIBUJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUI.04&4XPVMEVTFUIFTFMFWFMT -FWFMJTUIFWBSJBUJPOJOTZTUFNCFIBWJPSBOBQQSPBDIUPBOUJDJQBUJOHDIBOHFBUUIJTMFWFMJT UPEFTJHOTZTUFNTUPCFBTWFSTBUJMFBTQPTTJCMF UPIBWFBCSPBESBOHFPSSFQFSUPJSFPGCFIBWJPS BOE

SE Actualization Processes

O

333

QPTTFTTUIFBCJMJUZUPQMBZEJﬀFSFOUSPMFT)PXFWFS UIJTNVTUCFCBMBODFEXJUIDPOTJEFSBUJPOTPG TJNQMJDJUZBOEGPDVT -FWFMJTDIBOHFTJOUIFTZTUFNJUTFMGThFBQQSPBDIUPBOUJDJQBUJOHDIBOHFBUUIJTMFWFMJTUP EFTJHO TZTUFNT UP CF CPUI BEBQUBCMF BOE SPCVTU .PEVMBSJUZ BOE FODBQTVMBUJPO BSF UXP DMBTTJD FOBCMJOHQSJODJQMFTUIBUTUJMMBQQMZJOUIFOFX4&"TPVSDFPGNBUFSJBMPOSPCVTUEFTJHOPGDPNQMFY TZTUFNTJOUIFFYQBOEFETQBDFPGUIFOFX4&JODMVEJOHCJPMPHZ FDPMPHZ BOEFOHJOFFSJOHJT UIFDPMMFDUJPOPGDBTFTUVEJFTJO+FO "SFMBUFEBDUVBMJ[BUJPOEJTDVTTJPOPGDPOUSPMMJOHDIBPT JTJO&SEJ -FWFMJTWBSJBUJPOTBOEDIBOHFTJONPEFMT0OFQSJNBSZQSPDFTTPOBHJWFOQSPKFDUJTUBJMPSJOH HFOFSBMNPEFMTJOUPTQFDJﬁDNPEFMTGPSUIJTTZTUFN UIBUJT TQFDJBMJ[JOHGSPNUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDF UPUIFQSPKFDUXPSLTQBDF8JUIJOUIFXPSLTQBDF UIFTQFDJﬁDNPEFMTNBZBMTPDIBOHFUISPVHIPVU UIFMJGFUJNFPGUIFTZTUFN

Collective Actualization ThJTTFDUJPOEFTDSJCFTDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGUIFDPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT BTEFQJDUFEJO5BCMF BDDPVOUJOHGPSUIFWJFXTEFTDSJCFEUIVTGBSThFJEFBTJOUIJTTFDUJPOBSFBCMFOEPGDPODFQUTGSPN NBUFSJBMJOQSFWJPVTDIBQUFST BOEGSPN$4&BOENPEFMJOHNFUIPETJOUIJTDIBQUFS BMPOHXJUI JEFBTGSPN#PFINBOE5VSOFS

#PFINBOE-BOF

4DIFJO

BOETPNFPGUIF $VUUFS$POTPSUJVNMJUFSBUVSFPOBHJMFNFUIPETJODMVEJOH4QBOO

The Challenge "TJHOJﬁDBOUUFOTJPOFYJTUTJO4& JODMVEJOHNBOBHFNFOU CFUXFFOUIFDPNQMFYJUZBOETJ[FPGNBOZ 4&QSPKFDUTBOEUIFOFFEUPBEBQURVJDLMZUPDIBOHF$PNQMFYJUZBOETJ[FSFRVJSFTJHOJﬁDBOUGVOE JOH TUBﬃOH PSHBOJ[JOH BOEQMBOOJOHUPNBOBHFJOBXBZUIBUXJMMQSPEVDFUIFEFTJSFETZTUFN0O UIFPUIFSIBOE DIBOHFJOQSPKFDUWBSJBCMFTSFRVJSFTUIFBHJMJUZUPSFTQPOEUPUIFDIBOHF .FUIPETFYJTUTFQBSBUFMZGPSCPUIPGUIFTFOFFET5SBEJUJPOBMQMBOESJWFO4&NFUIPETBSFUBS HFUFEUPMBSHFDPNQMFYQSPKFDUTThFZFNQIBTJ[FEJTDJQMJOF QMBOOJOH DPOUSPM DPNQMJBODF TUBCJM JUZ IFBWZXFJHIUQSPDFTTFT FYUFOEFEUJNFQIBTFT EPDVNFOUBUJPO BOEDPOUSBDUT"NBKPSRVBMJUZ JOEJDBUPSJTDPNQMJBODFUPQSPDFTT "HJMFNFUIPETBSFUBSHFUFEUPTNBMMTJNQMFSQSPKFDUTThFZFNQIBTJ[FSFTQPOTJWFOFTTUPDIBOHF JOUFSBDUJPO BOE UBDJU TIBSFE LOPXMFEHF TIPSU DZDMFT MJHIUXFJHIU QSPDFTTFT BOE JUFSBUJPO ThF NBKPSRVBMJUZJOEJDBUPSJTDVTUPNFSTBUJTGBDUJPO ThFDIBMMFOHFJTUIBU4&QSPKFDUTEPOPUOFDFTTBSJMZBMJHOXJUIFJUIFSPOFPGUIFTFUXPFYUSFNFT ThF JODSFBTJOH DPNQMFYJUZ BOE BEBQUBCJMJUZ SFRVJSFNFOUT PG QSPKFDUT JOEJDBUF UIBU QMBOESJWFO NFUIPETBOEBHJMFNFUIPETXJMMOFFEUPCFDPNCJOFEJOTPNFGBTIJPOPONPSFQSPKFDUT #PFINBOE 5VSOFS (JWFOUIFTJHOJﬁDBOUEJﬀFSFODFTCFUXFFOUIFN IPXDBOUIJTCFBDDPNQMJTIFE

Concepts of the Actualization Process Balance and Focus "LFZQBSUPGUIFBOTXFSGSPN#PFINBOE5VSOFSJTUPEFWFMPQBCBMBODFPGUIFUXPBQQSPBDIFT ThFZQSPWJEFTPNFFYBNQMFTPGQSPKFDUTUIBUIBWFXPSLFEUPXBSEUIJTCBMBODF1SPKFDUTOFFEUIF FOUFSQSJTF DPOUFYU PG QMBOOJOH GVOEJOH BOE SFTPVSDF NBOBHFNFOU ThF QMBOESJWFO BQQSPBDI

334 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

QSPWJEFTUIJTDPOUFYU BOETVQQPSUTTDBMFVQUPMBSHFSQSPKFDUT0OUIFPUIFSIBOE UIFTBNFQSPK FDUTNVTUQSPEVDFSFTVMUTJOBUJNFMZGBTIJPOBOENVTUCFSFTQPOTJWFUPDIBOHFThFBHJMFBQQSPBDI DBOTVQQPSUUIJTBTQFDU #PFINBOE5VSOFSQSFTFOUFETFWFSBMDPODMVTJPOTPOUIJTJTTVFGSPNUIFJSTUVEZ8FEJTDVTT UISFF PG UIFN 0OF DPODMVTJPO JT UIBU DPNCJOFE NFUIPET TIPVME CF UBJMPSFE VQ GSPN BO BHJMF TUBSUJOHQPJOUSBUIFSUIBOUBJMPSFEEPXOGSPNBGVMMQMBOESJWFONFUIPEThBUXBZ BOZBEEJUJPOT OFFEUPCFKVTUJﬁFE5BJMPSJOHEPXOUFOETUPOPUIBQQFOJOQSBDUJDFGPSBOVNCFSPGSFBTPOT8F XPVMETVQQPSUUIJTSFDPNNFOEBUJPOCZOPUJOHUIBUUIFUSBEJUJPOBMUBJMPSJOHBQQSPBDIXJUIHPW FSONFOUQSPKFDUTJTNPSFPGUFOUIFPQQPTJUFBUBJMPSJOHEPXONFUIPE'PSFYBNQMF BSDIJUFDUVSF GSBNFXPSLTBSFHJWFOUPDPOUSBDUPSTXJUIUIFQPTTJCJMJUZPGUBJMPSJOHUIFNEPXO*OQSBDUJDF UIF SFTVMUJTPGUFOOPUBJMPSJOHCFDBVTFUIFHPWFSONFOUNBOBHFSXBOUTUPCFDPOTFSWBUJWFBOEBTLGPS FWFSZUIJOH BOEUIFDPOUSBDUPSJTOPUJODMJOFEUPEJTBHSFF "TFDPOEDPODMVTJPOPG#PFINBOE5VSOFSJTBDPSPMMBSZPGUIFﬁSTUTPNFCBMBODFENFUIPETBSF CFHJOOJOHUPFNFSHF BOENPTUPGUIFTFBSFNFUIPETCVJMUVQGSPNBHJMFNFUIPET"NPSFSFDFOUCBM BODFENFUIPEJTUIF*ODSFNFOUBM$PNNJUNFOU.PEFM *$. EFﬁOFECZ#PFINBOE-BOF ThF*$.CVJMETPOTFWFSBMQSFWJPVTNPEFMTJODMVEJOHBHJMF DPODVSSFOUFOHJOFFSJOH BOETQJSBM4PNF PGUIFLFZ*$.GFBUVSFTXFJODPSQPSBUFJOUPUIF.04&4DPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTJODMVEFUIF JODSFNFOUBM FWPMVUJPOBSZ BOEJUFSBUJWFTZTUFNEFﬁOJUJPOBOEEFWFMPQNFOUBOETUBLFIPMEFSDPNNJU NFOU*$.NBQTUPUIFMJGFTQBOTUBHFTPGGPSNBUJPOBOENBUVSBUJPO'PSNBUJPOJTUIF*$.TUBHF* JODSFNFOUBMEFﬁOJUJPOQMVTUIFﬁSTUTUFQJOTUBHF**JODSFNFOUBMEFWFMPQNFOU XIJDIQSPEVDFTUIFﬁSTU PQFSBUJPOBMJODSFNFOU'SPNUIBUQPJOUPOJTBTVDDFTTJPOPGTDIFEVMFEQFSJPETJOXIJDIEFWFMPQNFOU PGUIFOFYUSFMFBTFJTQSPDFFEJOHDPODVSSFOUMZXJUIQMBOOJOHBOEBSDIJUFDUJOHGVUVSFDBQBCJMJUJFT " UIJSE DPODMVTJPO JT UIBU XIJMF NFUIPET BSF JNQPSUBOU NBKPS HBJOT BSF NPSF MJLFMZ UP CF BDIJFWFE CZ NPSF GPDVT PO QFPQMF BOE FYQFDUBUJPOT NBOBHFNFOU 8F XPVME DIBSBDUFSJ[F UIJT BTQVUUJOHNPSFGPDVTPOPVUDPNFTBOEMFTTGPDVTPOQSPDFTTThFQFOEVMVNPWFSUIFQBTUGFX EFDBEFTJOCPUI4&BOETPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHQSPDFTTFTIBTNPWFEGSPNUIFPVUDPNFTTJEFUPUIF QSPDFTTTJEFThJTUSFOEIBTUXPSFTVMUT'JSTU UIFFOEHPBM QSPEVDJOHBXPSLJOHTZTUFN MPTFT TPNFPGJUTVSHFODZPOBQSPKFDU BOETFDPOE UIFQSPDFTT BTUIFPCKFDUPGBUUFOUJPO HSBEVBMMZ CFDPNFTMBSHFS5PHFUIFSUIFTFSFTVMUTDPOTQJSFUPTMPXFWFSZUIJOHEPXO8FOFFEUPSFHBJOCBM BODF VSHFODZ BOEGPDVTPOUIFFOEHPBMThFEJTDVTTJPOJO$IBQUFSPOPVUDPNFTBOEVMUJNBUF FﬀFDUTJTBCBTJTGPSUIJTBTQFDUPGUIFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT *OEJTDVTTJOHBHJMFBEBQUJWFNBOBHFNFOU 4QBOO EFTDSJCFTUIFUSBEJUJPOBMNBOBHFNFOU WJFXPGUIFXPSMEBTDPOTUSBJOFEThJTWJFXMFBETNBOBHFSTUPQVTIQFPQMFIBSEBOEUPGPDVTPO DPOUSPM#ZDPOUSBTU BHJMFBEBQUJWFNBOBHFNFOUWJFXTUIFXPSMEBTGVMMPGPQUJPOTThFQSJNBSZ GFBUVSFJTUIFWJFXUIBUQFPQMFBSFJOOPWBUJWFCFDBVTFUIFZBSFESBXOUPUIFQVSQPTFBOEQPUFOUJBM PVUDPNFTPGBQSPKFDU OPUCFDBVTFUIFNBOBHFSQVTIFTUIFNUPJU4DIFJO OPUFTUIBU QFPQMFBUEJﬀFSFOUMFWFMTPGNBOBHFNFOUIBWFEJﬀFSFOUUJNFIPSJ[POTBOEQMBOOJOHDZDMFT)JHIFS MFWFMNBOBHFSTIBWFBMPOHFSDZDMFTFWFSBMZFBSTPVUXIJMFMPXMFWFMNBOBHFSTBOEXPSLFST IBWFTIPSUFSDZDMFT TVDIBTXFFLT. ThFTFEJﬀFSFODFTDBOCFFYQMPJUFE BTXFEJTDVTTCFMPX

Radical and Normal Design 3BEJDBMEFTJHOJTSFRVJSFEJOBTJUVBUJPOXIFSFBOFXUZQFPGTZTUFNJTOFFEFEUIBUJTOPUXFMM VOEFSTUPPE(FOFSBMNPEFMTEPOPUFYJTUJOUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFGPSUIJTUZQFPGTZTUFN*USFQSF TFOUTBIJHIMFWFMPGSJTLThFGPDVTJTPOUIFPQQPSUVOJTUJDQSPDFTT SFTFBSDI BOEFYQFSJNFOUBUJPO

SE Actualization Processes

O

335

/PSNBMEFTJHOJTVTFEJOTJUVBUJPOTXIFSFUIFHFOFSBMQSPCMFNBOETZTUFNUZQFBSFVOEFSTUPPE UIBUJT XIFSFHFOFSBMNPEFMTEPFYJTUJOUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFThFGPDVTJOUIJTDBTFJTNPSFPO UBJMPSJOHBOETQFDJBMJ[JOHUIFHFOFSBMNPEFMTGPSUIJTTQFDJﬁDDBTF CVUXJUIJOUIBUGSBNFXPSLUIF PQQPSUVOJTUJDQSPDFTTBMTPBQQMJFT

Maintaining and Verifying Fidelity of Models 7FSJGZJOHPGNPEFMTOFFETOPUPOMZUPCFBOJOEFQFOEFOUBDUJWJUZCVUBMTPBOPOHPJOHBDUJWJUZ #FDBVTFPGDPOUJOVBMDIBOHFPGTZTUFNBOEFOWJSPONFOU XFDBOOPUBTTVNFUIBUCFDBVTFBNPEFM IBEHPPd ﬁEFMJUZTPNFUJNFJOUIFQBTU JUIBTHPPd ﬁEFMJUZOPXPSXJMMIBWFJOUIFGVUVSF ThFNBJOUFOBODFPGNPEFMTJTBMTPBOJTTVF(FOFSBMNPEFMTJOUIFLOPXMFEHFTQBDFBSFQSF TVNBCMZNBJOUBJOFEBOEDPOEJUJPOFECZUIFDPNNVOJUZBUMBSHF WJBNBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPOBOEVTF 4QFDJﬁDNPEFMTJOUIFQSPKFDUTQBDFBSFNBJOUBJOFECZUIFQSPKFDU 1BSUPGUIFDPOEJUJPOJOHPGNPEFMTJTSFQMJDBUJPO3FQMJDBUJPOPSBMJHONFOUPGNPEFMTBOE UFTUJOHFRVJWBMFODFPGNPEFMTJTBXBZPGBDDSFUJOHBCPEZPGLOPXMFEHF"YUFMMFUBM EFﬁOFEBQSPDFTTGPSUIJT$IFOFUBM EJTDVTTFEBMJHOJOHDPNQVUBUJPOBMNPEFMTUPTFFJG UIFZDBOQSPEVDFFRVJWBMFOUSFTVMUT

Applying the Concepts Considerations 6TJOHDPODFQUTGSPNUIFCPPL XFCVJMEPOUIFBCPWFJEFBTXJUIBGFXPUIFSBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT DPOTJEFSBUJPOT'JSTU XFDBOVTFUIFDPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOEUJNFEJNFOTJPOTJOEFBMJOHXJUIDIBOHF 8FDBOﬁOETUBCJMJUZCZEFﬁOJOHNPEFMT JODMVEJOHCPUINBOBHFNFOUNPEFMTTVDIBTTDIFEVMFT BOEFOHJOFFSJOHNPEFMTTVDIBTSFRVJSFNFOUT BUBIJHIFSMFWFMPGHFOFSBMJUZ BOEBEEEFUBJMGPS OFBSUFSNNPEFMTThJTBQQSPBDIﬁUTOBUVSBMMZXJUIUIFEJﬀFSFOUIPSJ[POTBOEGPDVTPGEJﬀFSFOU MFWFMTPGNBOBHFNFOU)JHIMFWFMNBOBHFSTTFFUIFHFOFSBMNPEFMTUIBUBSFNPSFTUBCMFBOEDBO QSPKFDUGVSUIFSJOUPUIFGVUVSF-PXMFWFMNBOBHFSTTFFUIFTQFDJﬁDNPEFMTUIBUBSFNPSFWPMBUJMF BOEXJMMCFVTFEJOUIFOFBSUFSNIPSJ[PO 4FDPOE SFGFSSJOHCBDLUP5BCMF XFDBOFYQMPJUUIFTFMGPSHBOJ[BUJPO TFMGHPWFSOBODF BOEBVUPOPNZPGUIF&"BOE4"TJEFPGUIFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTThJTJTDPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIF BHJMFBEBQUJWFNBOBHFNFOUEJTDVTTFEBCPWF BOEGBDJMJUBUFTUIFOBUVSBMJOOPWBUJWFCFIBWJPSPG QFPQMF ThJSE XFDBOFYQMPJUUIFDPODFQUPGWJFXTJOUIFUFOTJPOCFUXFFOQMBOESJWFONFUIPETBOE BHJMFNFUIPET8IJMFUIFCBMBODFCFUXFFOQMBOESJWFOBOEBHJMFSFDPNNFOEFECZ#PFINBOE 5VSOFSJTBSFBTPOBCMFTPMVUJPOUPUIFQSPCMFN XFTVHHFTUUIBUWJFXTHJWFFWFONPSFMFWFSBHFPG CPUIUIFQMBOESJWFOBOEBHJMFBTQFDUTThBUJT UIFTFQBSBUJPOPGWJFXTBMMPXTBQSPKFDUUPBQQMZ UIFQMBOESJWFOBQQSPBDIUPUIFNPSFTUBCMFBOEMPOHUFSNBTQFDUTTVDIBTSFTPVSDFBOECVEHFU QMBOOJOH SFTFBSDI BOEHFOFSBMBSDIJUFDUVSF BTXFMMBTCFOFﬁUJOHGSPNJOUFSBDUJPOXJUIUIFMBSHFS FOUFSQSJTFDPOUFYUBOEUPBQQMZUIFBHJMFBQQSPBDIUPTIPSUUFSNBDUJWJUJFT FTQFDJBMMZSFMFBTFTPG DBQBCJMJUZJOUIFJUFSBUJWFEFWFMPQNFOUPGBTZTUFNBOESFBDUJPOUPSBQJEDIBOHFTThFJOUFHSBUJPO PGWJFXTBMMPXTBUXPXBZUSBOTGFSBOEGFFECBDLPGMFBSOJOHCFUXFFOUIFUXPQSPKFDUWJFXT-POH UFSNEJSFDUJPOBOEFWPMVUJPODPOUJOVBMMZHVJEFTUIFTIPSUUFSNBDUJWJUJFT XIJMFUIFDIBOHFTPDDVS SJOHJOUIFTIPSUUFSNBDUJWJUJFTGFFEJOUPBOEJOﬂVFODFUIFMPOHUFSNEJSFDUJPO

336

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Near term: speciﬁc, detailed, small, agile

Long term: abstract, not detailed, strategic, trends

High Degree of Abstraction

Just in time detail Low Now

Future Planning horizon

Figure 13.4

Unifying planning and agility.

Visualizations #BTFEPOUIFTFDPOTJEFSBUJPOT XFQSFTFOUTPNFWJTVBMQFSTQFDUJWFTPGIPXDPOUSBTUJOHWJFXTDBO BEESFTTCPUIUIFQMBOOJOHOFFETBOEBHJMFOFFETBOECSJOHUIFNUPHFUIFSJOUPBXPSLBCMFGSBNF XPSLThFBQQSPBDIDPNCJOFTEJﬀFSFOUMFWFMTPGBCTUSBDUJPO NPSFPSMFTTEFUBJM XJUIEJﬀFSFOU QMBOOJOH IPSJ[POT TIPSUFS PS MPOHFS UFSNT 'JHVSF JMMVTUSBUFT B HSBEJFOU PG UIF QMBOOJOH IPSJ[POTQFDUSVNGSPNOPXUPUIFGVUVSFThFMPOHFSUFSNGVUVSFJTUIFNPTUBCTUSBDUBOEHFOFSBM OPXJTUIFNPTUTQFDJﬁDBOEDPODSFUF 'JHVSFTIPXTBQMBOOJOHQSPDFTTBUBQPJOUJOUJNFUIBUSBOHFTGSPNEFWFMPQNFOUBOE QMBOOJOHEFUBJMTGPSUIFDVSSFOUQFSJPEPSZFBSUPTVDDFTTJWFMZGFXFSEFUBJMT UIBUJT IJHIFSMFWFMT PGBCTUSBDUJPO GPSGVUVSFZFBST"OBSCJUSBSZTFUPGGPVSMFWFMTPGEFUBJMBSFEFﬁOFE SBOHJOHGSPN -FWFM UIFNPTUEFUBJMFE UP-FWFM UIFNPTUBCTUSBDU -FWFMEFUBJMTBSFQMBOOFEGPSDVSSFOU ZFBSNBOBHFNFOUBOEEFWFMPQNFOU JOUIFﬁHVSF -FWFMQMBOTBSFEFﬁOFEGPSUIFOFYU ZFBS

BOETPPOVQUP-FWFMQMBOTGPSUIFGVSUIFTUPVUZFBST3FTFBSDIBOEFYQFSJNFOUBUJPO BSFQMBOOFEGPSBTGBSPVUBTOFDFTTBSZThFDIPJDFPGPOFZFBSQMBOOJOHQFSJPETJTBMTPTPNFXIBU BSCJUSBSZJUDPVMECFBOZBQQSPQSJBUFMFOHUITVDIBTNPOUIPSNPOUIQFSJPET 'JHVSFTIPXTIPXUIF'JHVSFQSPDFTTJTSFQFBUFEFBDIZFBS JOBSPMMJOHXBWFUIBUﬁMMT JONPSFEFUBJMTGPSUIFOFYUZFBSBOEQVTIFTUIFMFWFMPGBCTUSBDUJPOHSBEJFOUPVUPOFNPSFZFBS POUIFQMBOOJOHIPSJ[PO'PSFYBNQMF JGAOPXJT -FWFMQMBOTBSFEFﬁOFEGPSDVSSFOUZFBS

-FWFMGPSOFYUZFBS

FUD*GAOPXJT -FWFMQMBOTBSFEFﬁOFEGPSDVSSFOUZFBS

-FWFMGPSOFYUZFBS

FUD 'JHVSFTIPXTBSFMFBTFWJFXPGUIFSPMMJOHXBWF"UUIFCPUUPNJTMPOHUFSNQMBOOJOHBOE SFTFBSDI BOEBUUIFUPQBSFUIFSFMFBTFT XIJDINBZCFQFSZFBSPSBTIPSUFSQFSJPEBTNFOUJPOFE BCPWF&BDISFMFBTFJTBTNBMMDPNQMFUFSBQJETZTUFNEFWFMPQNFOUDZDMFUIBUﬁMMTBHBQCFUXFFO MPOHUFSNWJTJPOBOEDVSSFOUTUBUFThFMPOHUFSNBOETIPSUUFSNNPEFMTBOEBDUJWJUJFTCPUIJOGPSN FBDIPUIFSThFMPOHUFSNPSHFOFSBMNPEFMTHVJEFUIFOFBSUFSNSFMFBTFEFWFMPQNFOU BOEUIF MFBSOJOHGSPNEFWFMPQJOHSFMFBTFT BTXFMMBTUIFVTFSGFFECBDLGSPNUIPTFSFMFBTFT DBONPEJGZ UIFMPOHUFSNEJSFDUJPOThFPUIFSFYUFSOBMGPSDFTTIPXOJO'JHVSF JODMVEJOHFOWJSPONFOU

4PNFPGUIFDPODFQUTBOEﬁgurFTJOUIJTBQQSPBDIXFSFEFWFMPQFEJODPMMBCPSBUJPOXJUI%BWJE$SBJH B.*53& DPMMFBHVF

SE Actualization Processes Viewpoint ‘Now’ is 2009

Projection View 2008 2009 review of 2008 performance 2009 as is models

O

337

: What can we see from viewpoint; what is produced or projected 2009 2010 2011 2012 2009 current 2009 plan for 2009 plan for 2009 plan for actualization 2010 2011; Level 3 2012; Level 4 activities; actualization; models models Level 1 Level 2 detailed models models

Plan actualization activities for three years out, 2012, but general: Level 4 models Plan actualization activities for two years out, 2011, but with even less detail: Level 3 models Plan actualization activities for next year, 2010, but with less detail: Level 2 models Current year, 2009, collective actualization activities: Define detailed Level 1 models – both enterprise and system models Review performance of previous year, 2008, and update the “as is” state Viewpoint: In the current year, 2009, participants in collective actualization perform these activities

Figure 13.5

Short and long term actualization.

Viewpoint ‘Now’ is 2009

‘Now’ is 2010

‘Now’ is 2011

2008 2009 review of 2008 performance; 2009 as is models

Projection View : What can we see from viewpoint; what is produced or projected 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2009 current 2009 plan for 2009 plan for 2009 plan for actualization 2010 2011; Level 3 2012; Level 4 activities; actualization; models models Level 1 Level 2 detailed models models 2010 review of 2009 performance; 2010 as is models

2010 current actualization activities; Level 1 detailed models

2010 plan for 2010 plan for 2010 plan for 2011 2012; Level 3 2013; Level 4 actualization; models models Level 2 models

2011 review of 2010 performance; 2011 as is models

2011 current actualization activities; Level 1 detailed models

2011 plan for 2011 plan for 2011 plan for 2012 2013; Level 3 2014; Level 4 actualization; models models Level 2 models

2012 review of 2011 performance; 2012 as is models

2012 current actualization activities; Level 1 detailed models

‘Now’ is 2012

Figure 13.6 Rolling wave model.

2015

2012 plan for 2012 plan for 2012 plan for 2013 2014; Level 3 2015; Level 4 actualization; models models Level 2 models

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

Stable General

…

Feedback

Goal

Feedback

Goal

Feedback

Goal

Feedback

Goal

Feedback

Goal

Goal

Speciﬁcity

Stability

Agile Detailed

Releases: Each release ﬁlls a gap between current and vision Rel. n+1 Rel. n+2 Rel. n+3 Rel. n+4 Rel. n+5 Release n (2.1) (2.2) (3.0) (1.1) (2.0) (1.0)

Feedback

338 O

Update high level goals, needs, technologies, architecture, research as needed Continuing research, technology assessment, prototyping

Forces on the process: User needs; environment volatility; legacy systems; available technology; budget; resources Figure 13.7

Release view of rolling wave.

WPMBUJMJUZ CVEHFUBOESFTPVSDFMJNJUT BOEBWBJMBCMFUFDIOPMPHZ DBOJOEVDFDIBOHFJOCPUIMPOH UFSNBOETIPSUUFSNNPEFMTBOEHPBMT

References "HJMF"HJMF"MMJBODFIUUQXXXBHJMFBMMJBODFPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

"YFMSPE 3BOE.$PIFO)BSOFTTJOH$PNQMFYJUZ0SHBOJ[BUJPOBM*NQMJDBUJPOTPGBScientiﬁc 'SPOUJFS /FX:PSL#BTJD#PPLT "YUFMM 3 3"YFMSPE +.&QTUFJO BOE.%$PIFO"MJHOJOHTJNVMBUJPONPEFMT"DBTFPGTUVEZ BOE SFTVMUT $PNQVUBUJPOBM .BUIFNBUJDBM 0SHBOJ[BUJPO TheorZ o IUUQXXXFDPO JBTUBUFFEVUFTGBUTJ%PDLJOH4JN.PEFMTQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#BVFS ) Scientiﬁc -JUFSBDZ BOE UIF .ZUI PG UIF Scientiﬁc .FUIPE 6SCBOB *- 6OJWFSTJUZ PG *MMJOPJT 1SFTT #FDL ,BOE$"OESFT&YUSFNF1SPHSBNNJOH&YQMBJOFE&NCSBDF$IBOHF TFDPOEFEJUJPO"EEJTPO8FTMFZ #FMM .4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH4FSWJDF"OBMZTJT %FTJHO BOE"SDIJUFDUVSF)PCPLFO /++PIO8JMFZ 4POT #PDDBSB /.PEFMJOH$PNQMFY4ZTUFNT/FX:PSL4QSJOHFS7FSMBH #PFIN #"TQJSBMNPEFMPGTPGUXBSFEFWFMPQNFOUBOEFOIBODFNFOU$PNQVUFS .BZ Qo #PFIN #BOE+-BOF6TJOHUIFJODSFNFOUBMDPNNJUNFOUNPEFMUPJOUFHSBUFTZTUFNBDRVJTJUJPO TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH BOETPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH$SPTT5BML+%FGFOTF4PGUXBSF&OH 0DUPCFS Qo #PFIN #BOE%1PSU.PEFM#BTFE"SDIJUFDUJOHBOE&OHJOFFSJOH .#"4& IUUQTVOTFUVTDFEV SFTFBSDI.#"4& "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

#PFIN #BOE35VSOFS#BMBODJOH"HJMJUZBOE%JTDJQMJOF"(VJEFGPSUIF1FSQMFYFE#PTUPO ." "EEJTPO8FTMFZ #SPBECFOU (The EFWFMPQNFOUPGEFTJHONFUIPETBSFWJFX%FTJHO.FUIPETTheories o 3FQSJOUFEJO$SPTT

#SPXO ( #$IFOH )(PMETCZ BOE+;IBOH(PBMPSJFOUFEspeciﬁcation PGBEBQUBUJPOTFNBOUJDT JOBEBQUJWFTZTUFNT*O1SPDPGUIF*$4&8PSLTIPQPO4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOHGPS"EBQUJWFBOE 4FMG.BOBHJOH4ZTUFNT 4&".4

4IBOHIBJ $IJOB

SE Actualization Processes

O

339

$IFO -$ ,. $BSMFZ # ,BSSJOTLZ 5 5VNNJOP & $BTNBO % 'SJETNB BOE " :BIKB "MJHOJOH4JNVMBUJPO.PEFMTPG#JPMPHJDBM"UUBDLTIUUQXXXDBTPTDTDNVFEVQVCMJDBUJPOTQBQFST DIFO@@BMJHOJOHCJPMPHJDBMQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

$PDLCVSO ""HJMF4PGUXBSF%FWFMPQNFOUThe $PPQFSBUJWF(BNF OEFEJUJPO#PTUPO .""EEJTPO 8FTMFZ1SPGFTTJPOBM $PDLCVSO "6TJOHCPUIJODSFNFOUBMBOEJUFSBUJWFEFWFMPQNFOU$SPTTUBML+%FGFOTF4PGUXBSF&OH .BZ Qo $PIFO . +.BSDI BOE+0MTFO"HBSCBHFDBONPEFMPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOBMDIPJDF"ENJOJTUSBUJWF4DJ 2VBSU o $POLMJO + %JBMPHVF .BQQJOH #VJMEJOH 4IBSFE 6OEFSTUBOEJOH PG 8JDLFE 1SPCMFNT $IJDIFTUFS &OHMBOE8JMFZ $SPTT / &E %FWFMPQNFOUTJO%FTJHO.FUIPEPMPHZ$IJDIFTUFS &OHMBOE+PIO8JMFZ %"(%FGFOTF"DRVJTJUJPO(VJEFCPPLIUUQTBLTTEBVNJMEBH "DDFTTFE+VOF

%BSJNPOU 3 &%FMPS 1.BTTPOFU BOE"WBO-BNTXFFSEF(3"*-,"04BOFOWJSPONFOUGPS HPBMESJWFOSFRVJSFNFOUTFOHJOFFSJOH*O1SPDUI*OU$POG4PGUXBSF&OH o.BZ Qo %P% %FQBSUNFOU PG %FGFOTF 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH 'VOEBNFOUBMT 'PSU #FMWPJS 7" %FGFOTF "DRVJTJUJPO6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT %PSJ %0CKFDU1SPDFTT.FUIPEPMPHZ#FSMJO4QSJOHFS7FSMBH &SEJ 1$PNQMFYJUZ&YQMBJOFE#FSMJO4QSJOHFS7FSMBH &TUFGBO + 4VSWFZ PG .PEFM#BTFE 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH .#4& .FUIPEPMPHJFT +FU 1SPQVMTJPO -BCPSBUPSZ $BMJGPSOJB*OTUJUVUFPG5FDIOPMPHZ 1BTBEFOB $" 'JPSFUUJ (BOE"-PNJ"OBHFOUCBTFESFQSFTFOUBUJPOPGUIFHBSCBHFDBONPEFMPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOBM DIPJDF+"Stiﬁcial 4PDJFUJFTBOE4PDJBM4JNVMBUJPO IUUQKBTTTTPDTVSSFZBDVLIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

'PSTCFSH ,BOE).PP[The SFMBUJPOTIJQPGTZTUFNFOHJOFFSJOHUPUIFQSPKFDUDZDMF+PJOU$POGFSFODF TQPOTPSFECZUIF/BUJPOBM$PVODJMPG4ZTUFN&OHJOFFSTBOEUIF"N4PD&OH.BOBHFNFOU $IBUBOPPHB 5/ 0DUPCFS (BSVE 3BOE1,BSOF#SJDPMBHFWFSTVTCSFBLUISPVHIEJTUSJCVUFEBOEFNCFEEFEBHFODZJOUFDIOPM PHZFOUSFQSFOFVSTIJQ3FT1PMJDZo )JMMJFS # +.VTHSPWF BOE104VMMJWBO,OPXMFEHFBOEEFTJHO*O&OWJSPONFOUBM%FTJHO3FTFBSDI BOE1SBDUJDF 8+.JUDIFMM &E-PT"OHFMFT6$-" QUISPVHI 3FQSJOUFEJO$SPTT

)JUDIJOT %8PSME$MBTT4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOHThe -BZFS.PEFMIUUQXXXIJUDIJOTOFUMBZFS IUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

)PMMOBHFM &BOE%8PPET+PJOU$PHOJUJWF4ZTUFNT'PVOEBUJPOTPG$PHOJUJWF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH#PDB 3BUPO '-$3$1SFTT *&&&B"EPQUJPOPG*40*&$4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH4ZTUFN-JGF$ZDMF1SPDFTTFT*&&& /FX:PSL*&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ *&&&C*&&&4UBOEBSEGPS"QQMJDBUJPOBOE.BOBHFNFOUPGUIF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH1SPDFTT *&&&4UE /FX:PSL*&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ */$04&(VJEFUPUIF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH#PEZPG,OPXMFEHF(4&#P,*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PVODJM PO4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOHIUUQHTFCPLJODPTFPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

*/$04&*/$04&4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH)BOECPPL W4FBUUMF 8"*/$04& *OUFSOBUJPOBM$PVODJM PO4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH *40*&$4ZTUFNTBOE4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH4ZTUFN-JGF$ZDMF1SPDFTTFT*40*&$ OEFE.BSDI +$*%40QFSBUJPOPGUIF+PJOU$BQBCJMJUJFT*OUFHSBUJPOBOE%FWFMPQNFOU4ZTUFN$+$4.$ %P%+PJOU$IJFGTPG4taﬀ. MBZ +FO &3PCVTU%FTJHO"3FQFSUPJSFPG#JPMPHJDBM &DPMPHJDBM BOE&OHJOFFSJOH$BTF4UVEJFT/FX:PSL 0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT +POFT +"NFUIPEPGTZTUFNBUJDEFTJHO*O$POG%FTJHO.FUIPET +$+POFTBOE%(Thornley &ET /FX:PSL.BDNJMMBO$PNQBOZ 3FQSJOUFEJO$SPTT

340

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

,ossiakoﬀ, " BOE8/4XFFU4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH1SJODJQMFTBOE1SBDUJDF)PCPLFO /++PIO8JMFZ 4POT -BSNBO $"HJMFBOE*UFSBUJWF%FWFMPQNFOU".BOBHFST(VJEF#PTUPO ."1FBSTPO&EVDBUJPO -BSNBO $ BOE 7 #BTJMJ *UFSBUJWF BOE JODSFNFOUBM EFWFMPQNFOU B CSJFG IJTUPSZ $PNQVUFS o -JMFT %BOE"1SFTMFZ&OUFSQSJTFNPEFMJOHXJUIJOBOFOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOHGSBNFXPSL1SPD 8JOUFS4JNVMBUJPO$POG Qo -JOECMPN $The TDJFODFPGiNVEEMJOHUISPVHIw1VCMJD"ENJOJTUSBUJPO3FW oIUUQ XXXKTUPSPSHTUBCMF "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

-JOECMPN $ 4UJMM NVEEMJOH OPU ZFU UISPVHI 1VCMJD "ENJOJTUSBUJPO 3FW o IUUQ XXXKTUPSPSHTUBCMF "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

.BOJGFTUP"HJMF.BOJGFTUPIUUQXXXBHJMFNBOJGFTUPPSH "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

.BSUFMMJ .*OUSPEVDUJPOUP%JTDSFUF%ZOBNJD4ZTUFNTBOE$IBPT/FX:PSL+PIO8JMFZ4POT .FEBXBS 1*OEVDUJPOBOE*ntuition in Scientiﬁc Thought1IJMBEFMQIJB"NFSJDBO1IJMPTPQIJDBM4PDJFUZ /BLBHBXB ) 5,BSVCF BOE4)POJEFO"OBMZTJTPGNVMUJBHFOUTZTUFNTCBTFEPO,"04NPEFMJOH 1SPDUI*OU$POG4PGUXBSF&OH o.BZ 4IBOHIBJ $IJOB /HVZFO -"EBQUJOHUIF7FFNPEFMUPBDDPNQMJTITZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHPODIBOHFQSPKFDUT/%*" *OUI"OOV4ZTUFNT&OH$POG'PDVTJOHPO*NQSPWJOH1FSGPSNBODFPG%FGFOTF4ZTUFNT1SPHSBNT 4BO %JFHP $" o 0DUPCFS IUUQXXX.dtic.mil/ndia/2006systems/Thursday/ngut. QEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

01.0CKFDU1SPDFTT.FUIPEPMPHZIUUQXXXPCKFDUQSPDFTTPSH4FFBMTPIUUQXXXFSCZVFEV FSTMJEFT&315%PSJQEG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

1BSOBT %BOE1$MFNFOUT"SBUJPOBMEFTJHOQSPDFTTIPXBOEXIZUPGBLFJU*&&&5SBOT4PGUXBSF &OH o 1PQQFS ,$POKFDUVSFTBOE3FGVUBUJPOTThe (SPXUIPGScientiﬁc ,OPXMFEHF OEFE/FX:PSL#BTJD#PPLT 3FCPWJDI (4ZTUFNTThinking GPSUIF&OUFSQSJTF/FXBOE&NFSHJOH1FSTQFDUJWFT1SPD*&&& 4.$*OU$POG4ZTUFNPG4ZTUFNT&OH -PT"OHFMFT $" "QSJM 3FCPWJDI (&OHJOFFSJOHUIFFOUFSQSJTFTU"OOV*&&&4ZTUFNT$POG 8BJLJLJ#FBDI )POPMVMV )* o"QSJM 3JUUFM )4POPG3JUUFMUIJOL)PSTU3JUUFMPOUIFTUBUFPGUIFBSUJOEFTJHONFUIPET*OThe %.(UI "OOJWFSTBSZ3FQPSU%.(0DDBTJPOBM1BQFS/P Qo 3FQSJOUFEJO$SPTT BTi4FDPOE (FOFSBUJPO%FTJHO.FUIPETw

3PZDF 8 .BOBHJOH UIF %FWFMPQNFOU PG -BSHF 4PGUXBSF 4ZTUFNT 1SPD UI *OU $POG 4PGUXBSF &OH *&&&$PNQVUFS4PDJFUZ Qo 0SJHJOBMMZQVCMJTIFEJO1SPD*&&&8&4$0/ o

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oIUUQDJUF TFFSJTUQTVFEVWBOMBNTXFFSEFHPBMPSJFOUFEIUNM "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

7JUSVWJVT1PMMJP .The 5FO#PPLTPO"SDIJUFDUVSF.PSSJT)JDLZ.PSHBO USBOTMBUPS $BNCSJEHF ." )BSWBSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT0SJHJOBM-BUJO TU$FOUVSZ#$&"WBJMBCMFBT1SPKFDU(VUFOCFSH&#PPL %FD IUUQXXX.gutenberg.org/ﬁles/20239/20239-h/29239-h.htm. "DDFTTFE +BOVBSZ

8FJOCFSH 4%SFBNTPGB'inal TheorZ/FX:PSL7JOUBHF#PPLT 8IJUF #0O$PNQMFY"EBQUJWF4ZTUFN&OHJOFFSJOH $"4& 1BQFSQSFTFOUFEBUUI6OEFSTUBOEJOH $PNQMFY4ZTUFNT4ZNQ 6OJWFSTJUZPG*MMJOPJTBU6SCBOB$IBNQBJHO o.BZ

SE Actualization Processes

O

341

8JLJQFEJB 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH 1SPDFTT IUUQFOXJLJQFEJBPSHXJLJ*NBHF4ZTUFNT@&OHJOFFSJOH@ 1SPDFTT@**HJG "DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

8ZNPSF 8.PEFM#BTFE4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH#PDB3BUPO '-$3$1SFTT ;IBOH +BOE#)$$IFOH6TJOHUFNQPSBMMPHJDUPTQFDJGZBEBQUJWFQSPHSBNTFNBOUJDT+4ZTUFNT BOE4PGUXBSF o

Acronyms ""%- ""4 "$. "$4- "%- "%.- ".- ".4 "0% "3$ "44- "5. #%* #'0 #P, #1./ #4" #88 $*43 $"4 $"4& $"4- $#" $#%* $&0 $&4' $*..4 $*0 $.4 $0/014 $P4

"SDIJUFDUVSF"OBMZTJTBOE%FTJHO-BOHVBHF "EWBODFE"VUPNBUJPO4ZTUFN '""

"TTPDJBUJPOGPS$PNQVUJOH.BDIJOFSZ "EWBODFE$POUJOVPVT4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF "SDIJUFDUVSF%FTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHF "SDIJUFDUVSF%FTDSJQUJPO.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF "HFOU.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF "OBMPHBOE.JYFE4JHOBM "VEJPPO%FNBOE "VTUSBMJBO3FTFBSDI$PVODJM "VUPOPNJD4ZTUFN4QFDJﬁDBUJPO-BOHVBHF "VUPNBUFE5FMMFS.BDIJOF #FMJFG %FTJSF *OUFOUJPO #BTJD'PSNBM0OUPMPHZ #PEZPG,OPXMFEHF #VTJOFTT1SPDFTT.PEFMJOH/PUBUJPO #VTJOFTT4FSWJDFT"SDIJUFDUVSF #VOHF8BOE8FCFS $PNNBOE $POUSPM $PNNVOJDBUJPOT $PNQVUFST *OUFMMJHFODF 4VSWFJMMBODF BOE 3FDPOOBJTTBODF $PNQMFY"EBQUJWF4ZTUFNT $PNQMFY"EBQUJWF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH $PHOJUJWF"HFOUT4QFDJﬁDBUJPO-BOHVBHF $BQBCJMJUJFT#BTFE"TTFTTNFOU $PNQPOFOU#BTFE%FWFMPQNFOUBOE*OUFHSBUJPO $IJFG&YFDVUJWF0ﬃcFS $FOUFSGPS&OHJOFFSJOH4ZTUFNT'VOEBNFOUBMT $FOUFSGPS*OUFHSBUJWF.VMUJTDBMF.PEFMJOHBOE4JNVMBUJPO $IJFG*OGPSNBUJPO0ﬃcFS $304*.BQQJOH4ZTUFN $PODFQUPG0QFSBUJPOT $PTUPG4FSWJDF 343

344

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

$054 $16 $304* $4 $4$4 $4& $44 $44- %"31" %#$ %- %-3. %P% %P%"' %0-$& %3*7&3 &" &$4". && &4" &4- '&" '0$ ($. ('0 (.& (.- (054& (14 (6.0 )$* )05 )14 *#. *&$ *&&& **% */$04& *0$ *4'0 *40 *444 +$*%4 +$4 ,"04 ,"30 ,*'

$PNNFSDJBM0ﬀ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ﬁDBUJPO ,OPXMFEHF "CJMJUJFT 3FTVMUT 0QQPSUVOJUJFT ,OPXMFEHF*OUFSDIBOHF'PSNBU

Acronyms

,3 ,8*$ -5- ." ."35& .BUI.- .#"4& .#4& .%" .%40$ .& .*5 .0 .P%"' .0' .04& .04&4 .4$ .5#' /"' /"50 /3$ /4- 0"4*4 0#0 0$- 0.# 0.( 01- 01. 03 08- 1#4& 1%' 1*. 104*9 2P& 2P4 3% 3%' 3.0%1 4" 4"& 4%- 4& 4&4 4'*

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ﬃcFPG.BOBHFNFOUBOE#VEHFU 0CKFDU.BOBHFNFOU(SPVQ 0CKFDU1SPDFTT-BOHVBHF 0CKFDU1SPDFTT.FUIPEPMPHZ 0QFSBUJPOT3FTFBSDI 8FC0OUPMPHZ-BOHVBHF 1BUUFSOT#BTFE4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH 1SPCBCJMJUZ%JTUSJCVUJPO'VODUJPO 1MBUGPSN*OEFQFOEFOU.PEFM 1PSUBCMF0QFSBUJOH4ZTUFN*OUFSGBDFGPS6OJY 2VBMJUZPG&YQFSJFODF 2VBMJUZPG4FSWJDF 3FTFBSDI%FWFMPQNFOU 3FTPVSDF%FTDSJQUJPO'SBNFXPSL 3FGFSFODF.PEFMGPS0QFO%JTUSJCVUFE1SPDFTTJOH 4ZTUFN"VUPOPNZ 4PDJFUZPG"VUPNPUJWF&OHJOFFST 4QFDJﬁDBUJPOBOE%FTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHF 4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH 4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH4DJFODF 4BOUB'F*OTUJUVUF

O

345

346

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

4(.- 4(43 4.- 40" 40"1 40$ 40* 40." 40.' 4P4& 44 46.0 47( 4ZT.- 50("' 54 54& 55' 6% 6%%* 6&.- 6.- 61%. 7)%- 7*/ 7. 84#1&- 84%- 9.* 9.- 91%- 94- :"8-

4UBOEBSE(FOFSBMJ[FE.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF 4PDJFUZGPS(FOFSBM4ZTUFNT3FTFBSDI 4FSWJDF.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE"SDIJUFDUVSF 4JNQMF0CKFDU"DDFTT1SPUPDPM 4FMG0SHBOJ[FE$SJUJDBMJUZ 4ZTUFNPG*OUFSFTU 4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOHBOE"SDIJUFDUVSF 4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH'SBNFXPSL 4ZTUFNPG4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH 4ZTUFNT4DJFODF 4VHHFTUFE6QQFS.FSHFE0OUPMPHZ 4DBMBCMF7FDUPS(SBQIJDT 4ZTUFN.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF ThF0QFO(SPVQ"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSL 5SBEJUJPOBM4ZTUFNT 5SBEJUJPOBM4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH 5BTL5FDIOPMPHZ'JU 6OJWFSTFPG%JTDPVSTF 6OJWFSTBM%FTDSJQUJPO %JTDPWFSZ BOE*OUFHSBUJPO 6OJﬁFE&OUFSQSJTF.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 6OJﬁFE.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 6OJﬁFE1SPﬁMFGPS%P%"'BOE.P%"' 7)4*$)BSEXBSF%FTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHF 7FIJDMF*EFOUJﬁDBUJPO/VNCFS 7JSUVBM.BDIJOF 8FC4FSWJDFT#VTJOFTT1SPDFTT&YFDVUJPO-BOHVBHF 8FC4FSWJDFT%FTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHF 9.-.FUBEBUB*OUFSDIBOHF &YUFOTJCMF.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF 9.-1SPDFTT%FﬁOJUJPO-BOHVBHF &YUFOTJCMF4UZMFTIFFU-BOHVBHF :FU"OPUIFS8PSLﬂPX-BOHVBHF

Index f indicates ﬁgurFTUJOEJDBUFTUBCMFT WJFXT BJSDSBGUQSPKFDU o

A ""%-4FF"SDIJUFDUVSF"OBMZTJTBOE%FTJHO-BOHVBHF ""44FF"EWBODFE"VUPNBUJPO4ZTUFN "COPSNBMCFIBWJPS o "CTPMVUFUJNF "CTUSBDUJPO DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE deﬁned as vieX MBXPGSFRVJTJUFQBSTJNPOZBOE MFWFMTPG SFMBUJPOTCFUXFFONPEFMTBOE UJNFBOE o "bstractors, deﬁned, 268 "DDFMMFSB "ckoﬀ, RVTTFMM "DRVJTJUJPOWJFX BSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLTBOE "$4-4FF"EWBODFE$POUJOVPVT4JNVMBUJPO -BOHVBHF "ctions, deﬁned, 71 "DUJWJUJFT o "DUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT 4FFBMTP$PMMFDUJWF BDUVBMJ[BUJPO$PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF "DUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF4FF$PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF "DUVBUPST BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE "DZDMJDDIBOHFNPEFMT o G4FFBMTP$ZDMJD DIBOHFNPEFMT "EBQUBCJMJUZ G o4FFBMTP7FSTBUJMJUZ "EBQUBUJPO "%-4FF"SDIJUFDUVSFEFTDSJQUJPOMBOHVBHFT "%.-4FF"SDIJUFDUVSF%FTDSJQUJPO.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF "EWBODFE"VUPNBUJPO4ZTUFN ""4

"EWBODFE$POUJOVPVT4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF "$4-

"HFOU.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF ".-

"HFOUCBTFETZTUFNT "HFOUT DPNQPTJUJPOBOE o deﬁned, 73–74 JOUFSOBMJOUFSBDUJPOTBOE MBOHVBHFTGPS uniﬁcation and, 315 "HHSFHBUJPO "HJMF"MMJBODF "HJMFNFUIPET o "HSFFNFOU TDJFODFBOE "JSMJOFTFYBNQMF DPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUTBOE o "MFYBOEFS $ISJTUPQIFS o o "MHPSJUINT "MJHONFOU "MMPDBUJPOWJFXUZQF "MMPQPJFTJT "MUFSOBUJWFSFMBUJPOT U "NJOPBDJET G ".-4FF"HFOU.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF "OBMZTJTNFUIPE NPEFMUZQFTBOE U "OBMZTJT4ZOUIFTJT(FOFSBUJPO "OBSDIJFT PSHBOJ[FE "OUPOZNT "0%4FF"TQFDUPSJFOUFEEFWFMPQNFOU "QQMJDBUJPO EFSJWBUJPOWT o "QQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT o 4FFBMTP 1SPCMFNTQBDF "QQMJDBUJPOTBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFX 50("'BOE "SDIJUFDUVSF IJTUPSZPGQSPDFTTBOE o MBZFSFE o G

347

348

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

QBUUFSOTPG o WJFXTBOE o U G "SDIJUFDUVSF"OBMZTJTBOE%FTJHO-BOHVBHF ""%-

"SDIJUFDUVSFEFTDSJQUJPOMBOHVBHFT "%-

"SDIJUFDUVSF%FTDSJQUJPO.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF "%.-

"SDT "SFBTPGLOPXMFEHF4FF%PNBJOT "SNZ, speciﬁcation apprPBDIBOE o "SUJGBDUT o o "Stiﬁcial evPMVUJPO "Stiﬁcial intelligence, 196 "Stiﬁcial science, 34–37. 4FFBMTP/BUVSBMTDJFODF4DJFODF "TQFDUPSJFOUFEEFWFMPQNFOU "0%

o "TQFDUPSJFOUFENPEFMJOH "TTFNCMZDPOOFDUPST "TTFTTNFOU BTQFDUPSJFOUFEEFWFMPQNFOUBOE o "44-4FF"VUPOPNJD4ZTUFN4peciﬁcation Language "TTPDJBUPST "TZNNFUSJDJOUFSBDUJPOT o "TZODISPOZ JOUFSBDUJPONPEFMTBOE "UPNJDCPNC EFWFMPQNFOUPG "UPNJTN "VEJFODFTPG.04&4 o "VUPNBUFEBVUPOPNPVTBHFOUT "VUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMF o "VUPNBUJPO "VUPOPNJDDPNQVUJOH "VUPOPNJD4ZTUFN4peciﬁcation Language (ASSL), 203 "VUPOPNZ4FFBMTP&OUFSQSJTFBVUPOPNZ BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTBOE DPNQMFYTZTUFNTBOE deﬁned, 20t, 21 FOUFSQSJTFTBOE FYUFSOBMNPEFMTBOE NJYFEDPNQPTJUJPOBOE o G USBEJUJPOBMWTDPNQMFYTZTUFNTBOE "VUPQPJFTJT

B #BMBODF BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTBOE o #BTJD'PSNBM0OUPMPHZ #'0

#BTJDPCKFDUQBUUFSOT #BTJMJ 7JD #%* CFMJFG EFTJSF JOUFOUJPO NPEFM #FIBWJPSEJBHSBNT #FIBWJPSPGTZTUFN 4FFBMTP%JSFDUJOUFSBDUJPO eﬀects; IOEJSect interaction eﬀects #FMJFG o #FMJFGT EFTJSFT BOEJOUFOUJPOT4FF#%*NPEFM #'04FF#BTJD'PSNBM0OUPMPHZ #JHCBOHNPEFM o G #JOBSZJOUFSBDUJPONPEFMT o G

#JP#SJDLT 4FF3FHJTUSZPG4UBOEBSE#JPMPHJDBM1BSUT #JPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPO4FFBMTP&WPMVUJPO BOBMPHZPGTDJFODFUP deﬁnitions of o JOIFSJUBODFBOE NPEFMEFSJWBUJPO BQQMJDBUJPOBOE NPEFMTPGDIBOHFBOE o UJNFBOE o #JPMPHJDBMQSPDFTTPOUPMPHZ #JPMPHJDBMWJFXQPJOU TDBMFBOE #JPMPHZ DPNQMFYTZTUFNTNPEFMTBOE NPEFMJOHPGGFSUJMJ[BUJPOBOE NPEFMTPGMFWFMDIBOHFBOE o U NVMUJMFWFMTUSVDUVSFTBOE WJFXTBOE #JPNFEJDT POUPMPHJFTBOE #JSds, modeling ﬂight and, 87–88 #MBOLTMBUF NZUIPG o #MVN #SVDF U #PEJFTPGLOPXMFEHF #P,

DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE o U G DPNNVOJUZ deﬁned, 181 HVJEFTUP o NPEFMTQBDFBOE o #PFIN #BSSZ #PFJOH #P,4FF#PEJFTPGLOPXMFEHF #POEJOH o #PUUPNVQQSPDFTTFT o #PVOEBSJFT4FFBMTP.FNCSBOFT BSUJGBDUTBOE DIBOHFBOE G DPNQPTJUJPOBOE DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOE o MJWJOHTZTUFNTBOE NFNCSBOFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOE o G NZUIPGSFRVJSFNFOUTESJWFOBOE TZTUFNTBOE o #PVOEBSZQPJOUT #PVOEFESBUJPOBMJUZ #PYPMPHZ o4FFBMTP&ODBQTVMBUJPO #1&-1FPQMF #1./4FF#VTJOFTT1SPDFTT.PEFMBOE/PUBUJPO #SJDPMBHFBQQSPBDI #SJEHJOH o #SJEHJOHPOUPMPHJFT o #SPPLT 'SFE #VOHF8BOE8FCFS #88 SFQSFTFOUBUJPONPEFM #VTUPQPMPHZ G #VTJOFTTBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFX 50("'BOE #VTJOFTTNPEFMJOHWJFX 40"GSBNFXPSLTBOE #VTJOFTTQSPDFTTMBOHVBHFT o #VTJOFTT1SPDFTT.PEFMBOE/PUBUJPO #1./

Index #VTJOFTT3FGFSFODF.PEFM #VTJOFTT4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH #88SFQSFTFOUBUJPONPEFM4FF#VOHF8BOE8FCFS SFQSFTFOUBUJPONPEFM

C $BQBCJMJUJFTCBTFEBTTFTTNFOU $#"

$BQUVSJOH 3FQSFTFOUJOH BOE0QFSBUJPOBMJTJOH4FNBOUJD *OUFHSBUJPO $304* QSPKFDU $BSCPOOBOPUVCFT4FF/BOPUVCFT $BST o o $"4GSBNFXPSL4FF$PNQMFYBEBQUJWFTZTUFNT GSBNFXPSL $"4&4FF$PNQMFY"EBQUJWF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH $"4-4FF$PHOJUJWF"HFOUT4peciﬁcation Language $BUBMZTJT $BUFHPSJFT4FFBMTP,JOET DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE o G U G G G G deﬁning in ontologies, 190–191 NPTBJDTBOE U QPQVMBUJPOTBT $BUFHPSJ[BUJPOIJFSBSDIJFT G $#"4FF$BQBCJMJUJFTCBTFEBTTFTTNFOU $#%*4"&.FUB.PEFMGPS40" $FMMVMBSBVUPNBUB U $FMMVMBSQSPDFTTFT $FOUFSGPS*OUFHSBUJWF.VMUJTDBMF.PEFMJOHBOE 4JNVMBUJPO $*..4

$IBMMFOHFTPGTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH PWFSWJFX PG o $IBOHF4FFBMTP"DZDMJDDIBOHFNPEFMT$ZDMJD DIBOHFNPEFMT5JNF CJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPOBOE o CPVOEBSZDSPTTJOH G DPNQMFYTZTUFNTBOE EFTJSFEWTVOEFTJSFE o U PGJOUFSFTU o NPEFMJOHMFWFMTPG o G U G U OFFEFENPEFMTPG o U TDJFODFBOE UJNFBOE o XFBLOFTTFTPG54&BOE $IBOOFMBOEOFU $IBPT $IBPUJDTZTUFNT Characteristic, deﬁned, 64–65. 4FFBMTP$PNQMFYTZTUFNT DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT5SBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT CPYPMPHZBOE $IFNJDBMCPOET $IFNJDBMFOHJOFFSJOH $IFNJTUSZ WJFXTBOE $IPJDF4FF.PEFMJOHDIPJDF $IPSFPHSBQIZ BTJOUFSBDUJPONPEFM

O

349

$*..44FF$FOUFSGPS*OUFHSBUJWF.VMUJTDBMF.PEFMJOH BOE4JNVMBUJPO $JWJMFOHJOFFSJOH o $MBTTFT 4FFBMTP,JOET $MPDLT DIBPTBOE $.44FF$304*.BQQJOH4ZTUFN $PHOJUJWFBHFOUT $PHOJUJWF"HFOUT4peciﬁcation Language (CASL), 203, $PHOJUJWFTZTUFNT 4FFBMTP+PJOUDPHOJUJWF TZTUFNT $PME8BS o $PMMBCPSBUJPO o o4FFBMTP.BTT DPMMBCPSBUJPO $PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPO DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGQSPDFTT o G G G NJYFEDPNQPTJUJPOBOE PWFSWJFXPG U o U uniﬁcation and, 315 uniﬁed prPDFTTGPS o G $PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF4FFBMTP1SPCMFNTQBDF 4PMVUJPOTZTUFNTQBDF NPEFMTQBDFBOE G G PWFSWJFXPG G G $PNNPONPEFMT Common speciﬁcation apprPBDI $PNNPOJ[BUJPO4FFBMTP%iﬀerFODFT4JNJMBSJUJFT BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTBOE CBTJDDPODFQUTPG o G DBUFHPSZ LJOEBOE o G U G G G G (FOFSJD.PEFMJOH&OWJSPONFOUBOE JOUFOTJPO FYUFOTJPOBOE o LOPXMFEHF CPEJFTPGLOPXMFEHFBOE o U G MFWFSBHFBOE o MJNJUTPGHFOFSBMJUZBOE o NPEFMTQBDFBOE NPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOTBOE NPEFMTQBDFTUSVDUVSFBOE G NVMUJMFWFMTUSVDUVSFTBOE o SFMBUJPOUPDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO TVNNBSZPGQSPDFTTFTSFMBUFEUP o UJNFBOE $PNNVOJDBUJPOEJBHSBNT $PNNVOJUZ .JMMFSTMJWJOHTZTUFNTBOE $PNQFUJUJWe interactions, deﬁned, 73 $PNQMFUFOFTT NPEFMTQBDFBOE $PNQMFY"EBQUJWF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH $"4&

$PNQMFYBEBQUJWFTZTUFNT $"4 GSBNFXPSL o $PNQMFYTZTUFNT $4

CPEJFTPGLOPXMFEHFBOE DBOEJEBUFQSPDFTTFTGPSFOHJOFFSJOHPG o DIBOHJOHQFSTQFDUJWFTPO DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPG o

350

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

DPMMBCPSBUJPOBOE o deﬁned, 37 FOHJOFFSJOHBOE FYBNQMFTPG o mapping and uniﬁcation and, 307 NPEFMUSFOETBOE o OFUXPSLTBOE WJFXTBOE o $PNQMFYTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH $4&

o G o $PNQMFYTZTUFNTTDJFODF $44

o $PNQMFYJUZ $PNQMJBODF EFQFOEFODJFTBOE $PNQPOFOUBOEDPOOFDUPSWJFXUZQF $PNQPOFOUCBTFETZTUFNT $PNQPOFOUDPOOFDUPSNPEFM $PNQPOFOUT o U $PNQPTJUJPO BHFOUTBOE DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPG o FMFNFOUTPG o MJWJOHTZTUFNTBOE NFNCSBOFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOE o G NPEFMTQBDFBOE o G NPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOTBOE NPEFMTQBDFTUSVDUVSFBOE G NVMUJMFWFMTUSVDUVSFTBOE o G QSPDFTTFTBOE o QSPQFSUJFTPG o G SFMBUJPOUPDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO TDBMFBOE o TZNNFUSJD UJNFBOE o 7FFNPEFMBOE o G XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTBOE U ;BDINBO&OUFSQSJTF'SBNFXPSLBOE $PNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIJFT $PNQPTJUJPOWJFXT o $PNQSJTF $PNQVUBUJPO U $PNQVUFSTDJFODF $4

NPEFMTQBDFBOE $PNQVUFST o4FFBMTP4PGUXBSF $PODFQUT QSedeﬁned rVMFT MFBSOJOHBOE o $PODFQUTPGPQFSBUJPOT $0/014

o U o $PODFQUVBMNPEFMT TFNBOUJDTQFDUSVNBOE $PODFQUVBMTQBDF $PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO deﬁning ontology categories and, 190–191 EFTJHOBOE GPSNBMBOEJOGPSNBMWJFXTPG o NJUJHBUJPOBOE o NPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOE NPEFMTQBDFBOE o G o G

NVMUJQMFEPNBJOTBOE o G ontology eﬀorUTBOEUPPMTBOE o POUPMPHZWT PWFSWJFw and deﬁnitions of o SFMBUJPOTPG o UJNFBOE WJFXTBOE o $POEJUJPOBMQSPCBCJMJUJFT o Conﬂict, cooperation and, 154 $POKFDUVSFSFGVUBUJPONPEFM $POKVHBUFSFMBUJPOT XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTBOE o G $POOFDUJPOT o o4FFBMTP*OUFSBDUJPOT 3FMBUJPOT $POOFDUPSQBSties, deﬁned, 71 $POOFDUPST o G4FFBMTP*OUFSBDUJPOT 3FMBUJPOT $0/0144FF$PODFQUTPGPQFSBUJPOT $POTFDVUJWFDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMT $POTFDVUJWFSFMBUJPOT U $POTUSBJOFEBDUJPOT $POTVNFST 4FFBMTP1SPEVDFST1SPWJEFST $POUBJOFEDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMT o $POUFYU PGNPEFMTQBDF o G $POUFYUHFOFSBMFYUFSOBMNPEFMT o G G Context-speciﬁc external models, 133–134, 134f $POUJOVJUZ NPEFMUZQFTBOE U $POUJOVPVT EJTDSFUFWT $POUJOVPVT4ZTUFN4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF $44-

$POUJOVVN TDJFODFBT $POUSBDUT DPOUBJOFEBOETIBSFEDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMT BOE o $POUSBEJDUJPO DPNQMFYTZTUFNTBOE $POUSBTUT o4FFBMTP%VBMJUZ1BSBEPYFT5FOTJPOT $POUSPM NPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOE o $POUSPMGVODUJPOT $POUSPMIJFSBSDIJFT $POWFSUFST Cooperation, conﬂict and, 154 $PPQFSBUJWe interactions, deﬁned, 73 $PPSEJOBUJPO BTJOUFSBDUJPONPEFM $PSSFTQPOEFODF o G o $PSSFTQPOEFODFTFUT o o o $PTU BTSFTPVSDFDPOTUSBJOU $PVSUSPPNUSJBMT $304*.BQQJOH4ZTUFN $.4

$304*QSPKFDU4FF$BQUVSJOH 3FQSFTFOUJOH BOE 0QFSBUJPOBMJTJOH4FNBOUJD*OUFHSBUJPOQSPKFDU $SPTTDVUUJOH o G $44FF$PNQMFYTZTUFNT$PNQVUFSTDJFODF $4&4FF$PNQMFYTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH $444FF$PNQMFYTZTUFNTTDJFODF

Index $44-4FF$POUJOVPVT4ZTUFN4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF $VTUPNTPMVUJPOBQQSPBDIFT $ZCFSOFUJDT $ZD $ZDMFT $ZDMJDDIBOHFNPEFMT o G G4FFBMTP "DZDMJDDIBOHFNPEFMT

D %"31"4FF%FGFOTF"EWBODFE3FTFBSDI1SPKFDUT"HFODZ %BUBBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFX 50("'BOE %BUB3FGFSFODF.PEFM %BWJT (& %#$4FF%FTJHOCZ$POUSBDU %FDJEFST %FDJTJPONBLJOH FOUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOH FOUFSQSJTF BVUPOPNZBOE %FDPEFST %FDPNQPTJUJPO U U4FFBMTP $PNQPTJUJPO %FDPVQMJOH o %FGFOTF"EWBODFE3FTFBSDI1SPKFDUT"HFODZ %"31"

%FGFOTJWFESJWJOH %eﬁned worlds, 247 %FMFHBUJPO XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTBOE U o G %FMFHBUJPODPOOFDUPST %&-044FF%JHJUBM-JCSBSZ3FGFSFODF.PEFM %FQFOEFODJFT EFTJHOWJFXTBOE U NBQQJOHBOE NBQQJOHUPFYUFSOBMNPEFMTBOE speciﬁcation apprPBDIBOE 7FFNPEFMBOE %FQMPZNFOU %FQMPZNFOUTQBDF G %FSJWBUJPO BQQMJDBUJPOWT o %FTDSJQUJWFNPEFMT %FTDSJQUJWF0OUPMPHZGPS-JOHVJTUJDTBOE$PHOJUJWF &OHJOFFSJOH %0-$&

%FTJHO o %FTJHOCZ$POUSBDU %#$

%FTJHOWJFXT o U %FUBJMT EFTJHOWJFXTBOE U %FUFSNJOJTN U4FFBMTP1Sobabilistic speciﬁcations %FWFMPQNFOU PQFSBUJPOWT o %JDUJPOBSJFT NBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPOBOE o %iﬀerFODFT o G 4FFBMTP 4JNJMBSJUJFT %JHJUBM-JCSBSZ3FGFSFODF.PEFM %-3.

%JHJUBM3FQPTJUPSZ*OGSBTUSVDUVSF7JTJPOGPS&VSPQFBO 3FTFBSDI4FF%3*7&3QSPKFDU %JNFOTJPOBMSFMBUJPOT NPEFMTQBDFBOE o

O

351

%JNFOTJPOT %JSect interaction eﬀects, 301–302, 304–305, 310t. 4FFBMTP#FIBWJPSPGTZTUFN*OEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPO eﬀects %JSect interactions, deﬁned, 73 %JTDJQMJOFT4FFBMTP4peciﬁc disciplines DPOUSJCVUJOHUP4&4 o U G MBOHVBHFTBOE NPEFMTQBDFBOE G NVMUJQMFEPNBJOTBOE o uniﬁcation and, 314–315, 314f uniﬁcation of o U U WJFXTBOE %JTDSFUF DPOUJOVPVTWT %JTPSEFSWTPSEFS U %JTTFSvice consumers, deﬁned, 72 %JTTFSvice initiators, deﬁned, 72 %JTTFSWJDFQSPviders, deﬁned, 72 %JTTFSWJDFT 4FFBMTP4FSWJDFT %JTUSJCVUJPO NPEFMUZQFTBOE U %JTUSJCVUJPOGVODUJPOT %JTUSJCVUJPOUSBOTQBSFODJFT %JTUSJCVUPST %-3.4FF%JHJUBM-JCSBSZ3FGFSFODF.PEFM %PDVNFOUBUJPO BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE %P%TFSJFT %P%"SDIJUFDUVSBM'SBNFXPSL %P%"'

o %P%"'4FF%P%"SDIJUFDUVSBM'SBNFXPSL %PHT DBUFHPSZ LJOEBOE o G G %0-$&4FF%FTDSJQUJWF0OUPMPHZGPS-JOHVJTUJDTBOE $PHOJUJWF&OHJOFFSJOH %PNBJOPOUPMPHJFT o %PNBJOT4FFBMTP"QQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT.VMUJQMF EPNBJOT BStiﬁcial science and, 35 DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPGNPEFMTQBDFBOE IJFSBSDIJFTPG NPEFMTQBDFBOE G o U U %PNJOBODF %0034 %ZOBNJD0CKFDU0SJFOUFE3FRVJSFNFOUT 4ZTUFN

%3*7&3QSPKFDU %VBMIJFSBSDIJFT G o G %VBMJUZ4FFBMTP$POUSBEJDUJPO$POUSBTUT1BSBEPYFT 5FOTJPOT UJNFBOE o G WJFXTBOE o U XBWFQBSUJDMF %ZNPMB %ZOBNJD TUBUJDWT o %ZOBNJDNPEFM U o o4FFBMTP 4UBUJDNPEFMT %ZOBNJD0CKFDU0SJFOUFE3FRVJSFNFOUT4ZTUFN4FF %0034 %ZOBNJDBMTZTUFNT U o

352 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

E &"4FF&OUFSQSJTFBVUPOPNZ &"GSBNFXPSLT4FF&OUFSQSJTFBSDIJUFDUVSF GSBNFXPSLT &BSMZBTQFDUT FC9-.4FF&MFDUSPOJD#VTJOFTTVTJOH&YUFOTJCMF.BSLVQ -BOHVBHF &DPMPHZ, deﬁned, 59 &DPOPNJDT G &DPTZTUFNT &$4".4FF&NCFEEFE$PNQVUFS4ZTUFN"OBMZTJT BOE.PEFMJOH &EHFT /BSZSFMBUJPOJOUFSBDUJPONPEFMTBOE &&.4FF&OUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOHBOENBOBHFNFOU Eﬀects deﬁned, 72 EJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPO o U JOEJSFDUJOUFSBDUJPO o U JOUFOEFEBOEVOJOUFOEFE TJEF o &MBQTFEUJNF &MFDUSPOJD#VTJOFTTVTJOH&YUFOTJCMF.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF FC9.-

&NCFEEFE$PNQVUFS4ZTUFN"OBMZTJTBOE.PEFMJOH &$4".

&NFSHFODF 4FFBMTP3FEVDUJPOJTN &NFSHFOUDPTIBQJOH &NFSHFOUQSPQFSUJFT &ODBQTVMBUJPO BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTBOE DIBOHFTPGJOUFSFTUBOE o DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOE o DPOOFDUPSTBOE NFNCSBOFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOE o XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTBOE U &ODPEFST &OEQPJOUQBSties, deﬁned, 71 &OHJOFFSJOH BSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLTBOE BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE o DPNQMFY IZCSJETZTUFNTBOE DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPG deﬁned, 37 TDJFODFBOE o U G uniﬁcation of &OHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLT 4FFBMTP )BOECPPLT &OUFSQSJTF &OUFSQSJTFBQQSPBDIFT &OUFSQSJTFBSDIJUFDUVSF &" GSBNFXPSLT o G &OUFSQSJTFBVUPOPNZ &"

U o &OUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOH &OUFSQSJTFFOHJOFFSJOHNBOBHFNFOU &&.

U o

&OUFSQSJTFTFMGPSHBOJ[JOHBDUJWJUZ &OUFSQSJTFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH &OUFSQSJTFXPSLTQBDFT &OUFSQSJTFT o &OUJUJFT o4FFBMTP.PTBJDT4ZTUFNT8PSMET &OWJSonments, deﬁned, 59 &4-4FF&VSPQFBO4QBDF"HFODZ4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF &VSPQFBO4QBDF"HFODZ4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF &4-

&WFOJOHTUBS JOUFOTJPOWTFYUFOTJPOBOE o &WPMVUJPO4FFBMTP#JPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPO BOBMPHZUPCJPMPHJDBM BStiﬁcial, 233 BStiﬁcial and natural science and, 36 DIBOHFBOE o FOHJOFFSJOHBOE o FOUFSQSJTFDPODFQUBOE mapping and uniﬁcation and, 301–302, 307 TPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHBOE UJNFBOE o &YDMVTJWJUZ BTDPNQPTJUJPOQSPQFSUZ o G &YFDVUBCJMJUZ NPEFMUZQFTBOE U &YFDVUBCMFNPEFMT G &YFDVUJPOEPNBJOT &YQBOTJPO &YQFDUFECFIBWJPS o4FFBMTP/PSNBMCFIBWJPS &YQMJDJUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT o &YUFOEFEXIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOT U &YUFOTJCMF.BSL6Q-BOHVBHF 9.-

o &YUFOTJPO o 4FFBMTP*OUFOTJPO &YUFOTJPOBMPOUPMPHJFT &YUFSOBMNPEFMT o 4FFBMTP*OUFSOBM NPEFMT &xternal speciﬁcation languages, 203 &xternal speciﬁcations, 274, 274f U G 4FFBMTP*nternal speciﬁcations &YUFSOBMWJFXT o4FFBMTP*OUFSOBMWJFXT &YUSFNFFODBQTVMBUJPO4FF#PYPMPHZ &YUSFNFQSPHSBNNJOH 91

&YUSVEFST

F 'BJMVSF SFBTPOTGPS 'BJMVSFUSBOTQBSFODZ '&"QSPHSBN o 'FSUJMJ[BUJPO NPEFMJOHPG 'JEFMJUZ o 'lammable, inﬂammable vs., 9 'MJHIU NPEFMJOHPG o 'MPXJOHXBUFS NPEFMTFMFDUJPOBOE o '0$4FF'VMMPQFSBUJPOBMDBQBCJMJUZ 'PMLTPOPNJFT o 'PSNBMEFTJHO 'PSNBUJPO DIBOHFTBOE G U 'PVOEBUJPOT

Index WJFXT 'SBDUBMT 'SBNFXPSLT4FF&OUFSQSJTFBSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLT 4peciﬁc frBNFXPSLT 'VMMGVODUJPOJOH DIBOHFTBOE G U 'VMMPQFSBUJPOBMDBQBDJUZ '0$

'VODUJPOT 'VTJPO 'VUVSF EVBMIJFSBSDIJFTBOE 'VUVZNBNPEFM 'V[[JOFTT NZUIPGSFRVJSFNFOUTESJWFOBOE 'V[[Z QSPCBCJMJUZWT G 'V[[ZCPVOEBSJFT 'V[[ZMPHJD 'V[[ZTFUUIFPSZ 'uzzy speciﬁcations, 293, 294f 'V[[ZUIJOLJOH o

G (4&#P,4FF(VJEFUPUIF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH#PEZ PG,OPXMFEHF (BNJOH (BSCBHFDBONPEFM ($.

($.4FF(BSCBHFDBONPEFM (FOFSBM'PSNBM0OUPMPHZ ('0

o (FOFSBMNPEFMT4FFBMTP$PNNPOJ[BUJPO4peciﬁc NPEFMT CPEJFTPGLOPXMFEHFBOE DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE NBJOUFOBODFPG speciﬁc models vs., 226–227 USBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHBOE o G (FOFSBM3FMBUJWJUZ o (FOFSBMTPMVUJPOBQQSPBDIFT (FOFSBM6TFS.PEFM0OUPMPHZ (6.0

o (FOFSBMJUZ o (FOFSBMJ[BUJPO (FOFSBMJ[BUJPOIJFSBSDIJFT DPODFQUVBMNPEFMJOHBOE JOIFSJUBODFBOE NPEFMTQBDFTUSVDUVSFBOE (FOFSJD.PEFMJOH&OWJSPONFOU (.&

(FPHSBQIJD.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF (.-

('04FF(FOFSBM'PSNBM0OUPMPHZ (JFSF 3POBME (MPCBM$PMMBCPSBUJPO&OWJSPONFOU (lobal plant ﬂoor (MPCBM1PTJUJPOJOH4ZTUFNT (14

(.&4FF(FOFSJD.PEFMJOH&OWJSPONFOU (.-4FF(FPHSBQIJD.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF (PBMTUBUF NPEFMTQBDFBOE (PBMPSJFOUFEMBOHVBHFT (ÚEFMTJODPNQMFUFOFTTUIFPSFN

O 353

i(PPE3FHVMBUPSwUIFPSFN (144FF(MPCBM1PTJUJPOJOH4ZTUFNT (SBEBUJPO MBXPG (SBEVBMJTN GV[[JOFTTWT (SBWJUZ o (SFBU&YQFDUBUJPOT %JDLFOT

(SPXUI (VJEFUPUIF4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH#PEZPG,OPXMFEHF (4&#P,

(6.04FF(FOFSBM6TFS.PEFM0OUPMPHZ

H )BDLFST )BOECPPLT o o4FFBMTP &OHJOFFSJOHIBOECPPLT )BSEXBSFNPEFMT BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE )BSNPOZ WJFXTBOE o )BXLJOH 4UFQIFO o )FVSJTUJDT )JFSBSDIJDBM1FUSJOFUT )JFSBSDIJFT4FFBMTP%VBMIJFSBSDIJFT DBUFHPSZ LJOEBOE o G DPNQPTJUJPO PGEPNBJOT IPMPOTBOE NPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOE o NVMUJMFWFMDPNQPTJUJPO o WJFXTBOE o )JHIMZPQUJNJ[FEUPMFSBODF )05

)JHIMZPQUJNJ[FEUPMFSBODF TFMGPSHBOJ[FEDSJUJDBMJUJFT WT )JUDIJOs ﬁvFMBZFSNPEFM )PBSFUSJQMF )PMBSDIJFT )PMJTN TZTUFNTTDJFODFBOE o )PMPOT )054FF)JHIMZPQUJNJ[FEUPMFSBODF )14GSBNFXPSL4FF)VNBOQSPWJEFETFSWJDFT GSBNFXPSL )VCT TDBMFGSFFOFUXPSLTBOE )VNBO.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF )VNBO.-

)VNBO.-4FF)VNBO.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF )VNBOQSPWJEFETFSWJDFT )14 GSBNFXPSL )VNBOT4FFBMTP)ZCSJETZTUFNT BOBUPNZFYBNQMFBOE o DPNQMFYTZTUFNTNPEFMTBOE TDBMFBOE WJFXTPG o )VNFEJTUJODUJPO )ZCSJETZTUFNT o G o

I *$.4FF*ODSFNFOUBM$PNNJUNFOU.PEFM *&&&TUBOEBSE

354

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

*&&&4UBOEBSE **%4FF*UFSBUJWFBOEJODSFNFOUBMEFWFMPQNFOU *NQMFNFOUBUJPO *NQMJDJUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT o4FFBMTP&YQMJDJU DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT.PEFMJOH *NQMJDJUDPODFQUT FYQMJDJUDPODFQUTWT *ODMVTJPO XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTBOE U *ODPNQMFUFOFTT */$04&4FF*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PVODJMPO4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH *ODSFNFOUBM$PNNJUNFOU.PEFM *$.

*ODSFNFOUBMNPEFMT *ODSFNFOUBMJTN *OEJSFDUDPNQPTJUJPOBHFOUT o *OEJSect interaction eﬀects, 301–302, 304–305, o U *OEJSect interactions, deﬁned, 73 *OEJWJEVBMT U *OEVTUSJBM4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH *nﬁnite loops, 259–260 *nﬂammable, ﬂammable vs., 9 *nﬂuence, complex systems and, 221, 233, *OGPSNBUJDT TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHTDJFODFBOE U *OGPSNBUJPO 4FFBMTP4tuﬀ *OGPSNBUJPOIJEJOH 4FFBMTP&ODBQTVMBUJPO *OGPSNBUJPOTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH *OHFTUPST *OIFSJUBODF o *OJUJBMPQFSBUJPOBMDBQBDJUZ *0$

*OQVUUSBOTEVDFST *OTUBODFT TFNBOUJDTQFDUSVNBOE *OTUBOUJBUJPO DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE *OUFHSBUFE4ZTUFNPG'PVOEBUJPOBM0OUPMPHJFT *4'0

*OUFHSBUJPO4FFBMTP4FQBSBUJPO BTQFDUPSJFOUFEEFWFMPQNFOUBOE o DPSSFTQPOEFODFTFUTBOE o NPEFMTQBDFBOE o QBOBSDIZBOE WJFXTBOE o *ntended eﬀects, 73. 4FFBMTP6nintended eﬀects *OUFOTJPO o 4FFBMTP&YUFOTJPO *OUFSBDUJPOEJBHSBNT *OUFSBDUJPONPEFMT CJOBSZSFMBUJPOTBOE o G /BSZSFMBUJPOTBOE o G G *OUFSBDUJPOPWFSWJFXEJBHSBNT *OUFSBDUJPOT4FFBMTP"DUJPOT BTZNNFUSJD o CJOBSZ o G G DPNQFUJUJWF DPNQMFYBEBQUJWFTZTUFNTGSBNFXPSLBOE o DPPQFSBUJWF deﬁned, 71

EJSFDUBOEJOEJSFDU o o o U JOUFSOBMBOEFYUFSOBM o NBQQJOHBSUJGBDUTPG TFSWJDF TZNNFUSJD WJFXTPG o G *OUFSFTU DIBOHFPG o *OUFSGBDFDPOOFDUJPOBSDIJUFDUVSFT *OUFSface speciﬁcations, 281t, 283–284 *OUFSGBDFT EFTJHOWJFXTBOE U *OUFSNFEJBSZQBSties, deﬁned, 71 *OUFSNFEJBUFESJWJOHQBUUFSOT *OUFSOBMFOWJSPONFOUT G *OUFSOBMNPEFMT 4FFBMTP&YUFSOBMNPEFMT *nternal speciﬁcations, 274, 274f U o G 4FFBMTP&xternal speciﬁcations *OUFSOBMUSBOTEVDFST *OUFSOBMWJFXT 4FFBMTP&YUFSOBMWJFXT *OUFSOBUJPOBM$PVODJMPO4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH */$04&

o *OUFSOBUJPOBM4PDJFUZGPS4ZTUFNT4DJFODFT *444

*OUFSOFU o *OUFSQSFUBUJPO *OUFSSVQUDBQBCJMJUZ *OUFSTFDUJPOT DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE *OUFSUXJOJOHSFMBUJPOT *OWBSJBOUT *OXBSENBQQJOH *0$4FF*OJUJBMPQFSBUJPOBMDBQBCJMJUZ *POJDMJRVJET *SSFHBSEMFTT SFHBSEMFTTWT *4'04FF*OUFHSBUFE4ZTUFNPG'PVOEBUJPOBM 0OUPMPHJFT *TPNPSQIJDNPEFMT *4444FF*OUFSOBUJPOBM4PDJFUZGPS4ZTUFNT4DJFODFT *UFSBUJWFBOEJODSFNFOUBMEFWFMPQNFOU **%

J +BDLTPO .JDIBFM U +BWB +$44FF+PJOUDPHOJUJWFTZTUFNT +PJOUDPHOJUJWFTZTUFNT +$4

o4FFBMTP)ZCSJE TZTUFNT

K ,"04 ,"304FF,OPXMFEHF BCJMJUJFT SFTVMUT PQQPSUVOJUJFT ,*'4FF,OPXMFEHF*OUFSDIBOHF'PSNBU ,JOET4FFBMTP$BUFHPSJFT$MBTTFT DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE o G U G G G G NPEFMTQBDFTUSVDUVSFBOE G

Index ,OPXMFEHF4FFBMTP#PEJFTPGLOPXMFEHF%PNBJOT DBUFHPSJFTPG o U DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE o U G UBDJU WJFXTPG o ,OPXMFEHF BCJMJUJFT SFTVMUT PQQPSUVOJUJFT ,"30

,OPXMFEHF*OUFSDIBOHF'PSNBU ,*'

,OPXMFEHFSFQSFTFOUBUJPO ,3 MBOHVBHFT ,OPXMFEHFTQBDFT NPEFMTQBDFBOE o ,3MBOHVBHFT4FF,OPXMFEHFSFQSFTFOUBUJPOMBOHVBHFT ,SVUDIFOWJFXT ,8*$JOGPSNBUJPOIJEJOHEFTJHO o

L -BOHVBHF BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE -BOHVBHFMFWFSBHF G4FFBMTP-FWFSBHF -BOHVBHFT DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPGNPEFMTQBDFBOE o HPBMPSJFOUFE NBTTDPMMBCPSBUJPOBOE o NPEFMTQBDFBOE NPEFMTQBDFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOE o 4FNBOUJD8FCBOE TVQQPSUJOHTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH o G VTFSDPNQVUFSDPNNVOJDBUJPOBOE -BXPGHSBEBUJPO -BXPGSFRVJTJUFQBSTJNPOZ -BXPGSFRVJTJUFWBSJFUZ o -BZFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSF o G -FBSOJOH BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE o -FWFMTPGBCTUSBDUJPO -FWFSBHF o o G G -JBSTQBSBEPY o -JCSBSJFT 4FFBMTP.PEFMTQBDF3FQPTJUPSJFT -JGFDZDMFT4FF-JGFTQBOT -JGFTQBOT G -JNJUTPGNPEFMJOH o -JNJUTPGTFQBSBUJPO BTQFDUPSJFOUFEEFWFMPQNFOUBOE -JOFPSHBOJ[BUJPOT -JOFBSNPEFM -JOFBSUFNQPSBMMPHJD -5-

-JOFBSJUZ U -JOFT /BSZSFMBUJPOJOUFSBDUJPONPEFMTBOE -JOHVJTUJDJOTUBODFT o G -JOVY -JUFSBUVSF JOTZTUFNTTDJFODF o -JWJOH4ZTUFNT .JMMFS

-JWJOHTZTUFNT DPNNPOGVODUJPOTPG o -PHJD o o -PHJDBMNPEFMT TFNBOUJDTQFDUSVNBOE -PHJDBMWJFXT -PHJDT o -PHJTUJDNBQT o -PSFO[BUUSBDUPS G G

O 355

M .BDIJOFNFUBQIPS o .BJFSBOE3FDIUJOWJFXT .BJOUFOBODFPGNPEFMT .BOBHFNFOU o .BQQJOH PGFOUFSQSJTFNBOBHFNFOUFMFNFOUT o FOWJSPONFOUBMWJFXPGSFRVJSFNFOUTBOE o FYBNQMFTPG o PWFSWJFXPG o G SFMBUJPOTCFUXFFONPEFMTBOE uniﬁcation and, 314–316, 314f .BQQJOHPOUPMPHJFT o .BSLT4UBOEBSE)BOECPPLGPS.FDIBOJDBM&OHJOFFST "WBMMPOFFUBM

.BSLVQMBOHVBHFT o ."35&4FF.PEFMJOHBOE"OBMZTJTPG3FBM5JNFBOE &NCFEEFETZTUFNT .BTIVQT .BTT XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTBOE .BTTDPMMBCPSBUJPO 4FFBMTP$PMMBCPSBUJPO .BUIFNBUJDBM.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF .BUI.-

.BUIFNBUJDT DPNQMFYTZTUFNTNPEFMTBOE JOWBSJBOUTBOE MBOHVBHFTBOE NPEFMTQBDFBOE SBUJPOBM MPHJDBMBOE o TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHTDJFODFBOE U .BUI.-4FF.BUIFNBUJDBM.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF .BUUFSFOFSHZTUPSBHF o .BUVSBUJPO G U .BUVSFFOHJOFFSJOH G o .BUVSFTDJFODF G .BUVSJUZ NPEFMTQBDFBOE .#"4&4FF.PEFM#BTFE"SDIJUFDUJOHBOE4PGUXBSF &OHJOFFSJOH .#4&4FF.PEFMCBTFETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH .D$BSUIZ +PIO .%"4FF.PEFM%SJWFO"SDIJUFDUVSF .FDIBOJTUJD 4FFBMTP0SHBOJD .FHBTZTUFNT .FNCSBOFT o G4FFBMTP#PVOEBSJFT &ODBQTVMBUJPO .FNPSZ .FSFPMPHZ .FSHJOH .FSSJBN8FCTUFSEJDUJPOBSZ .FTIUPQPMPHZ G .FTTBHF4FRVFODF$IBSUT .4$

.FTTFT .FUB0CKFDU'BDJMJUZ .0'

.FUB(.&GSBNFXPSL .FUBNPEFMT .FUBNPSQIPTJT

356 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

.FUB0CKFDU'BDJMJUZ .0'

.FUBQIPST NBDIJOF o QV[[MF TZTUFNBTPSHBOJTN o .FUSJDT RVBMJUZ .FZFS #FSUSBOE o .JEEMFXBSF .JHSBUJPOUSBOTQBSFODZ .JMMFS +BNFT .JMMT )BSMBO .*."%4FF.PEFMJOHMBOHVBHFGPSJOUFHSBUFENPEVMBS BWJPOJDTEFTJHO .JOJNBMJTN .JOJTUSZPG%FGFOTF"SDIJUFDUVSBM'SBNFXPSL .0%"'

o .JSSPST MJRVJE .JTTJMFHVJEBODF o G .JUJHBUJPO DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOE o .0%"'4FF.JOJTUSZPG%FGFOTF"SDIJUFDUVSBM'SBNFXPSL .PEBMJUZ o .PEFM%SJWFO"SDIJUFDUVSF .%"

.PEFMPSJFOUBUJPO CBTJDDPODFQUTPG o U DPNQMFYTZTUFNNPEFMTBOE o DPOUSPM IJFSBSDIZBOE o EFSJWBUJPO BQQMJDBUJPOBOE o MJNJUTPGNPEFMTBOE o NPEFMTQBDFBOE o NPEFMJOHDIPJDFBOE o NPEVMBSJUZPG.04&4BOE o PWFSWJFXPG o U speciﬁed behavior WBMVBUJPOBOE TZTUFNT NPEBMJUZBOE o VTFGVMOFTT USVUIBOE o .PEFMSFHJPOT 4FFBMTP4ZTUFN SFHJPOT .PEFMTQBDF4FFBMTP1SPCMFNTQBDF4PMVUJPOTZTUFN TQBDF DPMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDFBOE G G DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE DPNQPTJUJPOBOE o G DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOE o G DPOUFYUPG o G deﬁned, 17f G o G G EFTJHOPG o G EJNFOTJPOBMSFMBUJPOTBOE o EPNBJOTBOE o U U JNQMFNFOUBUJPOPG o JOUFSOBMTUSVDUVSFPG o G MJUFSBUVSFPO o U U NBOBHFNFOUPG NPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOE o PWFSWJFXPG SFQPTJUPSJFTBOE o

SFRVJSFNFOUTPG U TDPQFPG TPGUXBSFTZTUFNTBOE UJNFBOE WJFXTBOE o .PEFMTZTUFNT UBSHFUTZTUFNTWT .PEFM#BTFE 4ZTUFNT "SDIJUFDUJOHBOE4PGUXBSF &OHJOFFSJOH .#"4&

.PEFM#BTFE4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH 8ZNPSF

.PEFMCBTFETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH .#4&

.PEFMJOH BQQSPBDIFTGPSDPNQMFYTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHBOE BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE o CPYPMPHZBOE MBXPGSFRVJTJUFWBSJFUZBOE o MJNJUTPG o PWFSWJFXPG o TDJFODF FOHJOFFSJOHBOE o G TDPQFPG G G UZQFTPG U .PEFMJOHBOE"OBMZTJTPG3FBM5JNFBOE&NCFEEFE TZTUFNT ."35&

.PEFMJOHDIPJDF NPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOE o .PEFMJOHEPNBJOT .PEFMJOHMBOHVBHFGPSJOUFHSBUFENPEVMBSBWJPOJDT EFTJHO .*."%

.PEFMPSJFOUFETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHTDJFODF4FF.04&4 .PEFMT deﬁned, 63 JOUFOTJPOWTFYUFOTJPOBOE speciﬁcation and, 67–70, 68f TZTUFNTBOE o WJFXTBOE .PEFMTBUSVOUJNF .PEVMBSEFDPVQMFEDPODFQUT o .PEVMBSJUZ o .PEVMFWJFXUZQF .0'4FF.FUB0CKFDU'BDJMJUZ.FUB0CKFDU'BDJMJUZ .POPNFST G .PPO USBWFMUP .PSOJOHTUBS JOUFOTJPOWTFYUFOTJPOBOE o .PTBJDT o U .04&4 NPEFMPSJFOUFETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHTDJFODF

BTQFDUEFTDSJQUJPOTPG o U U PWFSWJFXPG o G QPUFOUJBMBVEJFODFTPG o SBUJPOBMFGPS o TDPQFPG o .PUPSDZDMFJOEVTUSZ .PUPST .4$4FF.FTTBHF4FRVFODF$IBSUT .VEEMJOHUISPVHI .VMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJUZ .VMUJEJTDJQMJOBSZOBUVSFPG5SE, need for uniﬁcation BOE o G

Index .VMUJMFWFMDPNQPTJUJPOTUSVDUVSFT o G .VMUJMFWFMIJFSBSDIJFT o .VMUJMFWFMTUSVDUVSFT DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE o .VMUJQMFEPNBJOT DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOE o .VMUJTDBMFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH o4FFBMTP4DBMF .VUBCJMJUZ G o .VUBCMFDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMT o .VUBUJPOT NZ0OUPMPHZQSPKFDU .ZUIT o

N /"'4FF/"50"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSL /BNFTQBDFT /BOPUFDIOPMPHZ /BOPUVCFT /"50"SDIJUFDUVSF'SBNFXPSL /"'

o /BUVSBMMBOHVBHFT /BUVSBMTDJFODF o4FFBMTP"Stiﬁcial science /BUVSBMTZTUFNBVUPOPNZ U /FFET VTFS o G G /eighborhoods, deﬁned, 59 /FJHICPST +JN /FTUFEWJFXT U /FTUJOH CPYPMPHZBOE /FUXPSLUPQPMPHJFT G /FUXPSLT o4FFBMTP4DJFODFPGOFUXPSLT /FVSBM4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF /4-

/FXUPOJBOHSBWJUZ o /PEFT /POEFMFHBUJPO XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTBOE U o /POQSPQBHBUJPO XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTBOE o U /PSNBMCFIBWJPS o4FFBMTP&YQFDUFECFIBWJPS /PSNBMEFTJHO /PSNBMQSPCBCJMJUZEJTUSJCVUJPO o G /PSNBMTDJFODF /PUFTPOUIF4ZOUIFTJTPG'PSN "MFYBOEFS

/4-4FF/FVSBM4JNVMBUJPO-BOHVBHF

O 0CKFDUDPOOFDUJPOBSDIJUFDUVSFT 0CKFDU$POTUSBJOU-BOHVBHF 0$-

0CKFDU.BOBHFNFOU(SPVQ 0.(

0CKFDU1SPDFTT.FUIPEPMPHZ 01.

0CKFDUJWJUZ TDJFODFBOE 0CKFDU1SPDFTT-BOHVBHF 01-

0CKFDU1SPDFTT.FUIPEPMPHZ 01.

0#04FF0QFO#JPMPHJDBMPOUPMPHZ0QFOCJPNFEJDBM POUPMPHJFT 0CTFSWBUJPOCBTFEMFBSOJOH o 0CTFSWers, deﬁned, 267 0$-4FF0CKFDU$POTUSBJOU-BOHVBHF 0OUPMPHJDBMJOTUBODFT o G

O 357

0OUPMPHJDBMNFUBNPEFMJOHWJFX o G 0OUPMPHJFT4FFBMTP$PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO%PNBJO POUPMPHJFT CSJEHJOHBOENBQQJOH o DBUFHPSJFTJO o DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOWT deﬁned, 189 EPNBJO o eﬀorUTBOEUPPMTPG o VQQFSMFWFM o VTFEJO4&NPEFMT o G 0OUPMPHZ NPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOTBOE 0OUPMPHZFOHJOFFSJOH o 0OUPMPHZ4VNNJU 0OUP.BQQSPKFDU 0QFO#JPMPHJDBMPOUPMPHZ 0#0

0QFOCJPNFEJDBMPOUPMPHJFT 0#0

0QFO%0"3 0pen systems, deﬁned, 59 0QFO7FSJMPH*OUFSOBUJPOBM 0QFO$ZD 0QFOTPVSDFNPWFNFOU 0QFSBUJPO %FWFMPQNFOU WT o 0QFSBUJPOBMPVUDPNFT 0QFSBUJPOBMWJFX BSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLTBOE o 0QFSBUJPOTSFTFBSDI 03

o4FFBMTP $PODFQUTPGPQFSBUJPOT6OJUPQFSBUJPOT 01-4FF0CKFDU1SPDFTT-BOHVBHF 01.4FF0CKFDU1SPDFTT.FUIPEPMPHZ0CKFDU1SPDFTT .FUIPEPMPHZ 0QQPStunism, uniﬁcation and, 315 0QQPSUVOJTUJDQSPDFTT 0QUJNJ[BUJPO OFUXPSLTBOE 0QUJPOBMJOGPSNBUJPO 034FF0QFSBUJPOTSFTFBSDI 0SCJUT4FF1IBTFTQBDFT 0SDIFTUSBUJPO BTJOUFSBDUJPONPEFM 0SEFSWTEJTPSEFS U 0SHBOJD 4FFBMTP.FDIBOJTUJD 0SHBOJTNNFUBQIPS o 0SHBOJ[BUJPO 40"GSBNFXPSLTBOE 0SHBOJ[BUJPOXPSLTQBDFT 0SHBOJ[BUJPOBMDIPJDF4FF(BSCBHFDBONPEFM 0SHBOJ[BUJPOBMNFSHJOH 0SHBOJ[BUJPOBMWJFXQPJOU TDBMFBOE 0SHBOJ[BUJPOT 0SHBOJ[FEBOBSDIJFT 0VUQVUUSBOTEVDFST 0VUXBSENBQQJOH 08- 0YGPSE$PNQBOJPOUP1IJMPTPQIZ, The )POEFSJDI

P 1BOBSDIZ 1BOUIFPOT

358 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

1BSBEPYFT o4FFBMTP$POUSBEJDUJPOT $POUSBTUT%VBMJUZ5FOTJPOT 1BSOBT %BWJE o o 1BSTJNPOZ4FF3FRVJTJUFQBSTJNPOZ MBXPG 1BSUJBMOFTT G4FFBMTP'V[[Z 1BSUJDMFT EVBMJUZBOE 1BSUJFT 1BSUJUJPOJOH NPEFMTQBDFEFTJHOBOE o 1BSUT SFMBUJPOTIJQPGXJUIXIPMFT o G G G oU 1BTU EVBMIJFSBSDIJFTBOE 1BUUFSOT o o o 1BUUFSOTCBTFETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 1#4&

1#4&4FF1BUUFSOTCBTFETZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 1%'4FF1SPCBCJMJUZEFOTJUZGVODUJPO1SPCBCJMJUZ EJTUSJCVUJPOGVODUJPO 1FPQMFBTTZTUFNDPNQPOFOUT o o 1FSDFQUJPO TDJFODFBOE o 1FSGPSNBODF OFUXPSLTBOE 1FSGPSNBODF3FGFSFODF.PEFM o 1FSJPEJDUBCMFPGDIFNJDBMFMFNFOUT 1FSM 1FSNFBCJMJUZ NFNCSBOFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOE 1FSSZT$IFNJDBM&OHJOFFST)BOECPPL (SFFOBOE1FSSZ

1FSTJTUFODF UJNFBOE o 1FSTPOBMXPSLTQBDFT 1FUSJOFUT 1IBTFTQBDFUSBKFDUPSJFT 1IBTFTQBDFT 1IBTFUSBOTJUJPOT 1IBTFT G 1IJMPTPQIZ 1hysical space, deﬁned, 111 1IZTJDBMWJFXQPJOU TDBMFBOE 1IZTJDT 1IZTJPNFQSPKFDU 1*.4FF1MBUGPSNJOEFQFOEFOUNPEFMT 1MBDFT 1FUSJOFUTBOE 1MBODL .BY 1MBOOJOH UJNFBOE G 1MBUGPSNJOEFQFOEFOUNPEFMT 1*.

1PJOUT /BSZSFMBUJPOJOUFSBDUJPONPEFMTBOE 1PMJDJFT 40"GSBNFXPSLTBOE 1PMZNFST G 1PMZUPQFT 1PQQFS ,BSM 1PQVMBUJPOT CJPMPHJDBMFWPMVUJPOBOE o 1PXFS MFWFSBHFBOE 1PXFSPGTPMVUJPO MFWFSBHFBOE 1SBHNBUJDT 1SFDJTJPO 1Sedeﬁned rVMFT o 1SFEJDUBCJMJUZ o 1SFSFRVJTJUFMBXTPGTDJFODF o

1SFTDSJQUJWFNPEFMT 4FFBMTP%FTDSJQUJWFNPEFMT .PEBMJUZ 1SFTFOU EVBMIJFSBSDIJFTBOE 1SJNJUJWFESJWJOHQBUUFSOT o 1SPCBCJMJTUDPTUNPEFMT4FF.PEFM#BTFE"SDIJUFDUJOH BOE4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH 1Sobabilistic speciﬁcations, 284–289, 286f 1SPCBCJMJUZ GV[[JOFTTWT G 1SPCBCJMJUZEFOTJUZGVODUJPO 1%'

o 1SPCBCJMJUZEJTUSJCVUJPOGVODUJPO 1%'

o G 1SPCMFNEPNBJOT NPEFMTQBDFTUSVDUVSFBOE G 1SPCMFNTQBDF G G G G4FFBMTP "QQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT$PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPO TQBDF.PEFMTQBDF4PMVUJPOTZTUFNTQBDF 1SPDFTT4FFBMTP"DUJWJUJFT$PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPO 4FMGPSHBOJ[JOHQSPDFTTFT DPNQPTJUJPOSFMBUFE o GPDVTPOBTXFBLOFTTPG54& IJTUPSZPG o NPEFMJOHMFWFMTPG o G U G U scientiﬁc method and, 323–324 1SPDFTTPST 1Soduced systems, deﬁned, 20, 20t 1SPEVDFST 4FFBMTP$POTVNFST 1SPEVDUMBZFST 1SPHSBNNJOHMBOHVBHFEPNBJOT o 1SPHSBNT 1SPKFDUMBZFST 1SPQBHBUJPO XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTBOE U o G 1SPQFSUJFT TFNBOUJDTQFDUSVNBOE 1Sosumers, deﬁned, 8 1SPUPUZQFT BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE 1SPWJEFST 4FFBMTP$POTVNFST 1TFVEPTDJFODF 1TZDIPMPHZ WJFXTBOE 1VODUVBUFEFRVJMJCSJVN 1VSQPTFGVMBDUJWJUZ o 1V[[MFNFUBQIPS 1ZUIPO

Q 2P&4FF2VBMJUZPGFYQFSJFODF 2P44FF2VBMJUZPGTFSWJDF 2VBMJUBUJWFNPEFMT 2VBMJUZNFUSJDT 2VBMJUZPGFYQFSJFODF 2P&

o 2VBMJUZPGTFSWJDF 2P4

o

R 3BEJDBMEFTJHO o 3BOEPNOFTT VODFSUBJOUZBOE

Index 3BUJPOBM6niﬁed PSPDFTT 3%' 3FBMJUZ TPGUXBSFTZTUFNTBOE o 3FBMJ[BUJPOTZTUFN4FF$PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF 3FBM5JNF0CKFDU0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH 3FDPNCJOBUJPO o 3FEVDUJPOJTN o4FFBMTP&NFSHFODF 3FGFSFODF.PEFMPG0QFO%JTUSJCVUFE1SPDFTTJOH 3.0%1

o 3FHBSEMFTT JSSFHBSEMFTTWT 3FHJPOT4FF.PEFMSFHJPOT4ZTUFNSFHJPOT 3FHJTUSZPG4UBOEBSE#JPMPHJDBM1BSUT 3FMBUJPOT G 4FFBMTP*OUFSBDUJPONPEFMT 3FMBUJWFIPMBSDIJFT 4FFBMTP)PMBSDIJFT 3FMBUJWJUZ o 3FQMJDBUJPO PGNPEFMT 3FQPTJUPSJFT o4FFBMTP.PEFMTQBDF 3FQSFTFOUBUJPO G 4FFBMTP $PODFQUVBMJ[BUJPO7JFXT 3FQSPEVDFST 3FRVJSFNFOUT EFQFOEFODJFTBOE o FYUFSOBMNPEFMTBOE o o 3FRVJSFNFOUTESJWFO NZUIPG 3FRVJSFNFOUTGPSGPVOEBUJPOPGGVUVSF U 3FRVJSFNFOUTMBOHVBHFT 3FRVJTJUFQBSTJNPOZ MBXPG 3FRVJTJUFWBSJFUZ MBXPG o 3FTFNCMBODFUIJOLJOH 3FTJMJFODF QBOBSDIZBOE 3FTPVSDFDPOTUSBJOUT 3FTPVSces, deﬁned, 74 3FWFSTJCJMJUZ 3FWolutions, scientiﬁc, 31 3IFUPSJDBM4USVDUVSe TheorZ 3JFNBOOJBOHFPNFUSZ 3JOHUPQPMPHZ G 3JTL DPNQMFYTZTUFNTBOE 3JTLBTTFTTNFOU o 3.0%1'SBNFXPSL4FF3FGFSFODF.PEFMPG0QFO %JTUSJCVUFE1SPDFTTJOH 3PCVTUEFTJHO o 3PMFT o G o 3PMMJOHXBWFNPEFM o G G i3PTFUUB4UPOFw TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHTDJFODFBOE o 3PTFUUB4ZTUFN%FTJHO-BOHVBHF 3PVUFQBUUFSOT 3PVUFQMBOOJOHQBUUFSOT 3VMFT o 3VOUJNF NPEFMTBU

S 4"4FF4ZTUFNBVUPOPNZ 4BGFUZEFQPTJUCPYes, speciﬁcation apprPBDIBOE 4atisﬁcing, 328

O 359

4DBMBCMF7FDUPS(SBQIJDT 47(

4DBMF BDZDMJD DZDMJDNPEFMTBOE o G DIBOHFTPGJOUFSFTUBOE o DPNQPTJUJPOBOE o MBXPGHSBEBUJPOBOE TUBUJDWTEZOBNJDBOE 4DBMFGSFFOFUXPSLT 4DBMJOH4FFBMTP.VMUJTDBMFTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH EPXO NVMUJTDBMF o VQ o WJFXQPJOUTBOE 4DFOBSJPT POUPMPHZEFWFMPQNFOUBOE 4DJFODF4FFBMTP4ZTUFNTTDJFODF DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPG o FOHJOFFSJOHBOE o U G MBOHVBHFTBOE MBXTPG o .04&4DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOE o OBUVSBMBOEBStiﬁcial, 34–37, 36f SBUJPOBM MPHJDBMBOE o 4IBXBOE'JODIIJTUPSJDBMQBUUFSOBOE 4DJFODFPGOFUXPSLT 4DJFODFQBUUFSOT4FF1BUUFSOT 4DJFODFT U o o Scientiﬁc method, 323–324 4DPQF o o 4$054FF4PDJBMDPOTUSVDUJPOPGUFDIOPMPHJDBM TZTUFNT 4DSJQUT 4%-4FF4peciﬁcation and DFTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHF 4&#P,HVJEF 4FDVSJUZ 4&*4FF4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH*OTUJUVUF 4FMFDUJPO VOJUTPG 4elf-conﬁguration, 12 4FMGDPOTDJPVTEFTJHO 4FMGDSFBUJPO4FF"VUPQPJFTJT 4FMGIFBMJOH 4FMGPQUJNJ[BUJPO 4FMGPSHBOJ[BUJPO o o 4FMGPSHBOJ[FEDSJUJDBMJUJFT 40$

4FMGPSHBOJ[JOHQSPDFTTFT o 4FMGQSPUFDUJPO 4FMGTJNJMBSJUZ 4FNBOUJDOFUXPSLT 4FNBOUJDTQFDUSVN G 4FNBOUJD8FC 4FNBOUJDT BSDIJUFDUVSFPGTPGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOHBOE G DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPGNPEFMTQBDFBOE NPEFMTQBDFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOE G VTFEJO4&NPEFMT o G 4FOTPST BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE 4FQBSBUFDPNQPOFOUDBUFHPSJFT G

360

O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

4FQBSBUJPO BTQFDUPSJFOUFEEFWFMPQNFOUBOE o DPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOBOE o NPEBMJUZBOE o VODFSUBJOUZBOE WJFXTBOE 4FQBSBUJPOPGDPODFSOT4FF.PEVMBSJUZ 4FRVFODFEJBHSBNT 4FSWJDF$PNQPOFOU3FGFSFODF.PEFM 4FSvice consumers, deﬁned, 72 4FSvice initiators, deﬁned, 72 4FSvice interactions, deﬁned, 73 4FSWJDF.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 4.-

4FSWJDFPSJFOUFEBSDIJUFDUVSF 40"

o 4FSWJDFQSPviders, deﬁned, 72 4FSWJDFPSJFOUFEBSDIJUFDUVSF 40"

4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOHBOE"SDIJUFDUVSF 40."

4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH'SBNFXPSL 40.'

4FSWJDFT o 4FFBMTP4FSWJDF DPOTVNFST 4&44FF4ZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHTDJFODF 4(.-4FF4UBOEBSE(FOFSBMJ[FE.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF 4(434FF4PDJFUZGPS(FOFSBM4ZTUFNT3FTFBSDI 4IBSFEDPNQPTJUJPONPEFMT G 4IBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOH o G G 4FFBMTP4peciﬁcations 4IBSFEXIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOT U 4IBXBOE'JODIIJTUPSJDBMQBUUFSO 4ide eﬀects, unexpected, 4–5 4JNJMBSJUJFT o G 4FFBMTP %iﬀerFODFT 4JNPO )FSCFSU 4JNQMJDJUZ 4JNVMBUJPOMBOHVBHFT 4JNVMBUJPOMFBSOJOH 4JNVMBUJPONPEFMT 4NJUI #BSSZ 4.-4FF4FSWJDF.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 40"4FF4FSWJDFPSJFOUFEBSDIJUFDUVSF 40"SFGFSFODFNPEFM 40$4FF4FMGPSHBOJ[FEDSJUJDBMJUJFT 4PDJBMDPOTUSVDUJPOPGUFDIOPMPHJDBMTZTUFNT 4$05

4PDJBMQSPDFTTFT 4PDJBMTDJFODFT 4PDJBMTZTUFNT QFSTQFDUJWFBOE o 4PDJFUZGPS(FOFSBM4ZTUFNT3FTFBSDI 4(43

4PDJPMPHZ 4PGUXBSF MBOHVBHFTPG .FZFSPO o QFSTQFDUJWFBOE SPMFTPG o

speciﬁcation apprPBDIBOE USBOTGPSNBUJPOTBOE U 5VSTLJPO 4PGUXBSFFOHJOFFSJOH 4PGUXBSF&OHJOFFSJOH*OTUJUVUF 4&*

o 4PGUXBSFNPEFMT BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE 40*4FF4ZTUFNTPGJOUFSFTU 4PMVUJPOEPNBJOT NPEFMTQBDFTUSVDUVSFBOE G 4PMVUJPONPEFMJOH 40"GSBNFXPSLTBOE 4PMVUJPOTZTUFNTQBDF G G G G 4FFBMTP"QQMJDBUJPOEPNBJOT$PMMFDUJWF BDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF.PEFMTQBDF1SPCMFNTQBDF 40."4FF4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOHBOE"SDIJUFDUVSF 40.'4FF4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE.PEFMJOH'SBNFXPSL 4QBDF4FF$PMMFDUJWFBDUVBMJ[BUJPOTQBDF.PEFMTQBDF 1IBTFTQBDF1SPCMFNTQBDF4PMVUJPOTZTUFN TQBDF 4QBDFUJNFSFHJPOT 4QBOPGDPOUSPM o 4QFDJBMJ[BUJPO DPNNPOJ[BUJPOBOE 4QFDJBMJ[BUJPOIJFSBSDIJFT 4peciﬁc models, 180, 226–227, 335. 4FFBMTP(FOFSBM NPEFMT 4peciﬁcation and DFTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHF 4%-

4peciﬁcation apprPBDI DPOEJUJPOBMQSPCBCJMJUJFTFYBNQMFPG o G DPOUFOUUZQFTBOE o U U U FMFNFOUTBOECBDLHSPVOEPG o FYBNQMFTPG o U FYUFSOBMCFIBWJPSDBUFHPSJFTBOE o external speciﬁcations and, 280t, 283, 284f JOUFSface speciﬁcations and, 281t, 283–284 internal speciﬁcations and, 279t, 282–283, 282f QBSUJBMOFTTBOE G QSobabilistic speciﬁcations and, 284–289, 286f UZQFTBOETUSVDUVSFPG o G VODFSUBJOUZNFUIPETBOE o G G 4peciﬁcations, 67–70, 68f o 4peciﬁed behavior 4QFDUSB o o 4QJSBMNFUIPE 444FF4ZTUFNTTDJFODF 4UBCJMJUZ DIBOHFBOE 4UBOEBSE(FOFSBMJ[FE.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF 4(.-

4UBOEBSET o 4UBOGPSE&ODZDMPQFEJBPG1IJMPTPQIZ 4UBSUPQPMPHZ G 4UBST JOUFOTJPOWTFYUFOTJPOBOE o 4UBUFNBDIJOFEJBHSBNT 4UBUFT QFSTJTUFODFBOE 4UBUJD EZOBNJDWT o 4UBUJDNPEFM U 4UFQXJTFSFWPMVUJPO 4UPSZUFMMJOH

Index 4USBUFHJDWJFX BSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLTBOE 4USVDUVSF OFUXPSLTBOE 4USVDUVSFEJBHSBNT 4USVDUVSFNPEFM o 4tuﬀ, 71, 74 4VHHFTUFE6QQFS.FSHFE0OUPMPHZ 46.0

46.04FF4VHHFTUFE6QQFS.FSHFE0OUPMPHZ 4VQQPSUFST 4VQQPSUJOHEJTDJQMJOFT4FF%JTDJQMJOFT 4VTUBJOBCJMJUZ QBOBSDIZBOE 47(4FF4DBMBCMF7FDUPS(SBQIJDT 4XBNQT 48&#P,HVJEF 4ymmetric interactions, deﬁned, 73 4ZNNFUSZ o 4ZODISPOZ JOUFSBDUJPONPEFMTBOE 4ZOPOZNT 4FFBMTP4ZOTFUT 4ZOTFUT 4ZOUIFTJT 4ZOUIFUJDCJPMPHZ 4ZT.-4FF4ZTUFNT.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 4ZTUFNBVUPOPNZ 4"

U 4ZTUFNCFIBWJPS o o 4ZTUFNDPNQPTJUJPOIJFSBSDIJFT 4ZTUFNMBZFST 4ZTUFNNPEFMJOHBOEEFTJHOMBOHVBHFT TFNBOUJD TQFDUSVNBOE o 4ZTUFNPGTZTUFNT 4P4

o 4ZTUFNSFHJPOT o G4FFBMTP.PEFMSFHJPOT 4ZTUFNTQBDF4FF4PMVUJPOTZTUFNTQBDF 4ZTUFNBTPSHBOJTNNFUBQIPS o 4ZTUFNT CPVOEBSJFTBOE o DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPG o DPSSFTQPOEFODF SFHJPOBOE o G deﬁned, 60 EFWFMPQNFOUWTPQFSBUJPOPG o diﬀerFODFTXJUIJOBOEBDSPTT G NPEFMPSJFOUBUJPOBOE o NPEFMTBOE o NPTBJDTBOE o U SFHJPOTBOE o G UBYPOPNZPG o G UFSNJOPMPHZPG o 4ZTUFNTBOETFSWJDFTWJFX BSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLTBOE o 4ZTUFNTCJPMPHZ 4ZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 4& 4FFBMTP$PNQMFYTZTUFNT FOHJOFFSJOH5SBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH CPEJFTPGLOPXMFEHFBOE o G GV[[ZUIJOLJOHBOEMPHJDBOE MBOHVBHFTTVQQPSUJOH o G NPEFMTQBDFBOE U QSPCMFNTPMWJOHBOE o U TFNBOUJDTBOEPOUPMPHJFTVTFEJONPEFMT o G

O 361

uniﬁcation and, 314–316, 314f WJFXTBOE o U G 4ZTUFNT&OHJOFFSJOH)BOECPPL */$04&

4ZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHTDJFODF 4&4

o U G 4ZTUFNT.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 4ZT.-

4ZTUFNTPGJOUFSFTU 40*

4ZTUFNTPGTZTUFNT 4P4

4ZTUFNTTDJFODF 44

DPNQMFYTZTUFNTTDJFODFBOE o IPMJTNBOE JOMJUFSBUVSF o NPEFMTQBDFBOE NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJUZ HFOFSBMJUZBOE TZTUFNTUBYPOPNZBOE o G UIFNFTPG o uniﬁcation and, 315 VOJUZ, uniﬁcation and, 45 4ZTUFNTUBYPOPNZ o G

T 5 MBOHVBHF

5BDJULOPXMFEHF 5BHHJOH 5BJMPSJOHVQWTUBJMPSJOHEPXO BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTT BOE 5BSHFUTZTUFNT 5argets, deﬁned, 267 5ask-technology ﬁt (55'

5BYPOPNJFT4FFBMTP4ZTUFNTUBYPOPNZ BStiﬁcial and natural science and, 36–37 CJPMPHJDBM '&"QSPHSBNBOE (6.0BOE IJFSBSDIJFTBOE G JOIFSJUBODFBOE TFNBOUJDTQFDUSVNBOE TZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOHBOE o G 5FBNXPSLTQBDFT 5FDIOJDBM3FGFSFODF.PEFM 5FDIOJDBMTUBOEBSEWJFX BSDIJUFDUVSFGSBNFXPSLT BOE o 5FDIOPMPHZ o 5FDIOPMPHZBSDIJUFDUVSFWJFX 5FMFTDPQFT 5FNQPSBMMPHJD o 5FOTJPOT o4FFBMTP$POUSBEJDUJPO $POUSBTUT%VBMJUZ1BSBEPYFT 5FTUJOH4FF7eriﬁcation of model ﬁdelity ThesaurVT TFNBOUJDTQFDUSVNBOE 5JNF BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTBOE DIBOHFBOE o

362 O

Model-Oriented Systems Engineering Science

DIBOHFPGJOUFSFTUBOE o DPNQPTJUJPOEJNFOTJPOBOE o diﬀerFODFTXJUIJOBOEBDSPTTTZTUFNTBOE G EVBMIJFSBSDIJFTBOE G FWPMVUJPOBOE o MFWFMTPGQSPDFTTBOEDIBOHFBOE o G U G U MFWFSBHFBOE NFBTVSFNFOUPG o NPEFMTQBDFBOE NPEFMTQBDFTUSVDUVSFBOE G OFFEFEDIBOHFNPEFMTBOE o U QFSTJTUFODF EVBMJUZBOE o TDBMFBOE TUBUJDWTEZOBNJDBOE o UZQFTPG o G G 7FFNPEFMBOE o G 5JNFJOWBSJBODFWTUJNFWBSJBODF o 5JNFST 5JNJOHEJBHSBNT 50("' 5PQEPXOQSPDFTTFT o 5PQPMPHJFT /BSZSFMBUJPOJOUFSBDUJPONPEFMTBOE o 5PSWBMET -JOVT o 5SBDF XIPMFoQBSUSFMBUJPOTBOE U 5rade-oﬀs. 4FF-FWFSBHF 5SBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHTQBDF VTFSSFRVJSFNFOUTWT 5SBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNT 54

DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPG EVBMJUJFTJO o 5SBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 54&

HFOFSBMNPEFMTBOE o G QSPCMFNTXJUI o o TJNVMBUJPOBOE o TUBOEBSETBOE o UFNQPSBMDIBOHFBOE uniﬁcation and, 314–315, 314f 5SBKFDUPSJFT o4FFBMTP1IBTFTQBDF USBKFDUPSZ 5ransactions, deﬁned, 74 5SBOTEVDFST 5SBOTGPSNBUJPOT U 5SBOTJUJPOT 4FFBMTP1IBTFUSBOTJUJPOT 5SBOTMBUJPO 5SBOTQBSFODZ 5SFFUPQPMPHZ G 5SJBMT 5SVUI o 54&4FF5SBEJUJPOBMTZTUFNTFOHJOFFSJOH 55'4FF5ask-technology ﬁt 5VSCJOFT 5VSTLJ 8MBEJTMBX o 5ZQFT4FF$MBTTFT,JOET

U 6%T4FF6OJWFSTFTPGEJTDPVSTF 6&.-4FF6niﬁed EOUFSQSJTF.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 6.- 4FF6niﬁed MPEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 6ODFSUBJONFNCSBOFT 6ODFSUBJOUZ o G 6OEFSTUBOEJOH4FFBMTP4IBSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOH 4peciﬁcations 6OFYQFDUFECFIBWJPS o4FFBMTP&YQFDUFE CFIBWJPS 6niﬁcation BTBEWBOUBHFPG.04&4 BTHFOFSBMDIBMMFOHF o G NPEFMTQBDFBOE o QFSTQFDUJWFBOE QSPNPUJPOPGCZ.04&4 o G TZTUFNTTDJFODFBOE 6niﬁed EOUFSQSJTF.PEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 6&.-

6niﬁed MPEFMJOH-BOHVBHF 6.-

o 6niﬁed PSoﬁle for DP%"'BOE.P%"' 61%.

6niﬁed speciﬁcation apprPBDI o 6OJGPSNQSPCBCJMJUZEJTUSJCVUJPO 6nintended eﬀects, 73. 4FFBMTP*ntended eﬀects 6OJUPQFSBUJPOT 6OJUTPGTFMFDUJPO 6OJUZPGTDJFODF 6OJWFSTBMBSDIJUFDUVSF 6OJWFSTFTPGEJTDPVSTF 6%T

o 6/*9PQFSBUJOHTZTUFN 5PSWBMETBOE o 6OQSFEJDUBCJMJUZ DPNQMFYTZTUFNTBOE 6OTFMGDPOTDJPVTEFTJHO 61%.4FF6niﬁed PSoﬁle for DP%"'BOE.P%"' 6TFDBTFWJFXT 6TFGVMOFTT o 6TFMFTT"SJUINFUJD 1JMLFZ

o 6TFSOFFET o G G 6TFSSFRVJSFNFOUT USBEJUJPOBMFOHJOFFSJOHTQBDFWT

V 7BMVBUJPO 7BSJBCJMJUZ NPEFMUZQFTBOE U 7BSJBCMFT JNQPSUBODFPGTFMFDUJOHDPSSFDU 7BSJBUJPOT o 7BSJFUZ -BXPGSFRVJTJUF o 7FFNPEFM o G 7eriﬁcation of model ﬁdelity 7FSJMPH)%- o 7FSTBUJMJUZ G o4FFBMTP"EBQUBCJMJUZ 7FSUFY /BSZSFMBUJPOJOUFSBDUJPONPEFMTBOE 7)%-4FF7)4*$)BSEXBSF%FTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHF 7)4*$)BSEXBSF%FTDSJQUJPO-BOHVBHF 7)%-

o 7JFU/BN8BS

Index 7JFXQPJOUT 7JFXT BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTBOE BEEJUJPOBMSFTFBSDIBOE o BSDIJUFDUVSFSFMBUFE o U G BSUJGBDUTBOE CBTJDDPODFQUTPG o CBTJDTZTUFNFOHJOFFSJOHSFMBUFE o U G DBUFHPSJFTPG o G PGDPNNPOTUSVDUVSFNPEFMT o G DPVSUSPPNUSJBMTBOE deﬁned, 84, 268 EJTDSFUFWTDPOUJOVPVTBOE IBSNPOJ[JOHEVBMJUJFTBOE o U IJFSBSDIZBOE o NPEFMTQBDFBOE G o NPEFMTQBDFEJNFOTJPOTBOE PGQSPDFTTFT o TDJFODFTBOE o speciﬁcation apprPBDIBOE o G G UJNFBOE WJFXQPJOUTBOE 7JHOFUUFT BVUPNBUFEDBSFYBNQMFBOE 7JODFOUJTFOHJOFFSJOHLOPXMFEHFDBUFHPSJFT o U 7JSUVBMNBDIJOFT MBZFSFEBSDIJUFDUVSFBOE 7JTVBM#BTJD 7JTVBMJ[BUJPO BDUVBMJ[BUJPOQSPDFTTBOE o G 7JUSVWJVT 7PJDF&YUFOTJCMF.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF 7PJDF9.-

7PJDF9.-4FF7PJDF&YUFOTJCMF.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF

O 363

8FC0OUPMPHZ-BOHVBHFCBTFEPO%FTDSJQUJPO-PHJDT 80-%-

8FC4FSWJDFT#VTJOFTT1SPDFTT&YFDVUJPO-BOHVBHF 84#1&-

8IJUFIFBE "MGSFE/PSUI 8IPMFTZTUFNTNPEFMJOH 8IPMFT4FFBMTP)PMPOT1BSUT4ZTUFNT 8IPMFT SFMBUJPOTIJQPGXJUIQBSUT o G G G oU G G 8JDLFEQSPCMFNT G 8JLJOPNJDT 8JLJQFEJB 8JOEUVSCJOFUFDIOPMPHZ 80-%-4FF8FC0OUPMPHZ-BOHVBHFCBTFEPO %FTDSJQUJPO-PHJDT 8PSE/FU 8PSLTQBDFT NPEFMTQBDFBOE o 8PSME8BS** o 8orlds, deﬁned, 59–60, 247 84#1&-4FF8FC4FSWJDFT#VTJOFTT1SPDFTT&YFDVUJPO -BOHVBHF 8ZNPSF 8BZOF o

X 9.-4FF&YUFOTJCMF.BSL6Q-BOHVBHF 9.-.FUBEBUB*OUFSDIBOHF 9.* TUBOEBSE 9.-1SPDFTT%eﬁnition Language (XPDL), 202 914FF&YUSFNFQSPHSBNNJOH 91%-4FF9.-1SPDFTT%eﬁnition Language

Y W 8BSHBNJOH 8arﬁeld, JPIO 8BUFSGBMMQSPDFTT G 8BWFT EVBMJUZBOE 8FBLOFTTFTPG54& o

:FU"OPUIFS8PSkﬂoX-BOHVBHF :"8-

:JO:BOH o U

Z ;BDINBO&OUFSQSJTF'SBNFXPSL o G

Architecture and Principles of Systems Engineering (CRC Complex and Enterprise Systems Engineering)

Read more

Designing Complex Systems: Foundations of Design in the Functional Domain (Complex and Enterprise Systems Engineering)

Read more

Complex Systems

Read more

Complex Systems

Read more

Complex Time-Delay Systems: Theory and Applications (Understanding Complex Systems)

Read more

Complex Time-Delay Systems: Theory and Applications (Understanding Complex Systems)

Read more

Transforming Organizations: Strategies and Methods (Complex Systems Engineering and Management)

Read more

Modeling and Control of Complex Systems (Automation and Control Engineering)

Read more

Biological Networks (Complex Systems and Interdisciplinary Science)

Read more

Testing Complex and Embedded Systems

Read more

Complex and Adaptive Dynamical Systems

Read more

Complex systems and applied linguistics

Read more

Complex Systems and Binary Networks

Read more

Approximation algorithms for complex systems

Read more

Approximation Algorithms for Complex Systems

Read more

Equilibrium Analysis Complex Systems

Read more

Superconductivity in Complex Systems

Read more

Modeling complex systems

Read more

Foundations of Complex Systems

Read more

Complex Systems Concurrent Engineering: Collaboration, Technology Innovation and Sustainability

Read more

Philosophy of Complex Systems

Read more

Modeling Complex Systems

Read more

Systems of Systems Engineering: Principles and Applications

Read more

Complex Systems in Biomedicine

Read more

Intelligent Complex Adaptive Systems

Read more

Life: An Introduction to Complex Systems Biology (Understanding Complex Systems)

Read more

Simulating Complex Systems by Cellular Automata (Understanding Complex Systems)

Read more

Complex and adaptive dynamical systems. A primer

Read more

Complex and Adaptive Dynamical Systems: A Primer

Read more

Complex and adaptive dynamical systems: A primer

Read more

Recommend Documents

Architecture and Principles of Systems Engineering (CRC Complex and Enterprise Systems Engineering)

ARCHITECTURE AND PRINCIPLES OF SYSTEMS ENGINEERING COMPLEX AND ENTERPRISE SYSTEMS ENGINEERING Series Editors: Paul R....

Designing Complex Systems: Foundations of Design in the Functional Domain (Complex and Enterprise Systems Engineering)

DESIGNING COMPLEX SYSTEMS Foundations of Design in the Functional Domain COMPLEX AND ENTERPRISE SYSTEMS ENGINEERING S...

Complex Systems

Complex Systems This book explores the exciting field of complexity. It features in-depth coverage of important theoret...

Complex Systems

Université Joseph Fourier Les Houches Session LXXXV 2006 Complex Systems Lecturers who contributed to this volume J...

Complex Time-Delay Systems: Theory and Applications (Understanding Complex Systems)

Springer Complexity Springer Complexity is an interdisciplinary program publishing the best research and academic-level...

Complex Time-Delay Systems: Theory and Applications (Understanding Complex Systems)

Springer Complexity Springer Complexity is an interdisciplinary program publishing the best research and academic-level...

Transforming Organizations: Strategies and Methods (Complex Systems Engineering and Management)

TRANSFORMING ORGANIZATIONS Strategies and Methods TRANSFORMING ORGANIZATIONS Strategies and Methods Timothy G. Kotno...

Modeling and Control of Complex Systems (Automation and Control Engineering)

Modeling and Control of Complex Systems AUTOMATION AND CONTROL ENGINEERING A Series of Reference Books and Textbooks ...

Biological Networks (Complex Systems and Interdisciplinary Science)

BIOLOGICAL NETWORKS 6459 tp.indd 1 10/1/07 4:43:00 PM Complex Systems and Interdisciplinary Science (ISSN: 1793-454...

Testing Complex and Embedded Systems

Saunder November 10, 2010 10:35 © 2011 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC K11134˙C000 Saunder November 10, 2010 1...