Modifying flavour in food
Related titles: Flavour in food (ISBN 978-1-85573-960-4) The flavour of a food is one of its most important qualities. Edited by two leading authorities in the field, and with a distinguished international team of contributors, this important collection summarises the wealth of recent research on how flavour develops in food and is then perceived by the consumer. The first part of the book reviews ways of measuring flavour. Part II looks at the ways flavour is retained and released in food. It considers the way flavour is retained in particular food matrices, how flavour is released during the process of eating, and the range of influences governing how flavour is perceived by the consumer. Flavour in food guides the reader through a complex subject and provides the essential foundation in both understanding and controlling food flavour. Taints and off-flavours in foods (ISBN 978-1-85573-449-4) Taints and off-flavours are a major problem for the food industry. Part I of this important collection reviews the major causes of taints and off-flavours, from oxidative rancidity and microbiologically derived offflavours, to packaging materials as a source of taints. Part II discusses the range of techniques for detecting taints and off-flavours, from sensory analysis to instrumental techniques, including the development of new rapid, on-line sensors. Colour in food – Improving quality (ISBN 978-1-85573-590-3) The colour of a food is central to consumer perceptions of quality. This important collection reviews key issues in controlling colour quality in food, from the chemistry of colour in food to measurement issues, improving natural colour and the use of colourings to improve colour quality. Details of these books and a complete list of Woodhead’s titles can be obtained by: • •
visiting our web site at www.woodheadpublishing.com contacting Customer Services (e-mail: sales@woodhead-publishing. com; fax: +44 (0) 1223 893694; tel.: +44 (0) 1223 891358 ext. 130; address: Woodhead Publishing Ltd, Abington Hall, Abington, Cambridge CB21 6AH, England)
Modifying flavour in food Edited by Andrew Taylor and Joanne Hort
Cambridge, England
Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Abington Cambridge CB21 6AH, England www.woodheadpublishing.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC, 6000 Broken Sound Parkway, NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton, FL 33487, USA © 2007, Woodhead Publishing Limited The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-074-8 (book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-336-7 (e-book) CRC Press ISBN 978-1-4200-4389-1 CRC Press order number WP4389 The publishers’ policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elementary chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publishers ensure that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Typeset by SNP Best-set Typesetter Ltd., Hong Kong Printed by TJ International Limited, Padstow, Cornwall, England
Contents
Contributor contact details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
2
3
Modifying flavour: an introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. J. Taylor and J. Hort, University of Nottingham, UK 1.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Baines, Baines Food Consultancy Ltd, UK 2.1 The importance of olfaction in the appreciation of flavour. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 Flavouring substances in foods. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 Flavouring substances legislation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Acknowledgement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Extraction of flavourings from natural sources. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G. Cravotto, University of Turin, Italy and P. Cintas, University of Extremadura, Spain 3.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 General overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Supercritical fluid extraction: SC-CO2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Continuous subcritical water extraction (CSWE) . . . . . . . 3.5 Ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
x 1 1 9
10
10 12 25 36 37 37 41
41 42 50 52 53
vi
Contents 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9 3.10 3.11
4
Microwave-assisted extraction (MAE) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Extraction in the analysis of flavours. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Drying methods and solvent distillation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
From fermentation to white biotechnology: how microbial catalysts generate flavours . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . R. G. Berger, Leibniz University of Hannover, Germany 4.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Flavour formation along known pathways . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 Flavours from complex substrates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4 White biotechnology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5 Future trends. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6 Sources of further information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
54 56 58 59 59 59
64 64 67 78 81 83 85 86
5
New developments in yeast extracts for use as flavour enhancers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 B. Noordam and F. R. Meijer, DSM Food Specialties, The Netherlands 5.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 5.2 Developments in yeast extracts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 5.3 Materials and methods. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 98 5.4 Results and discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 100 5.5 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 5.6 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106
6
Chiral chemistry and food flavourings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . S. Serra, C.N.R. Milano, Italy 6.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2 Chiral flavour – synthesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3 Chiral flavour . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4 Key flavour compounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5 Sources of further information and advice . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.6 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
7
Formulating low-fat food: the challenge of retaining flavour quality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J. Hort and D. Cook, University of Nottingham, UK 7.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2 Lowering the fat content of food: what happens to the flavour? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3 Strategies for replacing fat in foods and the implications for flavour . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
107 107 108 115 121 127 128
131 131 132 134
Contents
vii
Why is fat so hard to replace? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Representation of fat in the brain . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Future trends. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
138 140 142 143
New pungent and cooling compounds for use in foods. . . . . . . . . C. C. Galopin, Givaudan Flavors Corporation, USA 8.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2 History . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3 Fundamental differences between chemesthetics and flavours . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4 Physiology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5 Common pungent chemicals and their activity . . . . . . . . . 8.6 Common cooling compounds and their activity. . . . . . . . . 8.7 Future trends. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.9 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
146
Controlled release of flavour in food products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G. Reineccius, University of Minnesota, USA 9.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2 Industrial approaches for protecting flavourings from deterioration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3 Industrial approaches to achieve controlled release of flavourings. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.4 Needs in flavour encapsulation/controlled release . . . . . . 9.5 Advice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.6 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
169
7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 8
9
10
11
Developments in sweeteners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . S. Kemp, Cadbury Schweppes, UK and M. Lindley, Lindley Consulting, UK 10.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2 Mechanism of sweetness perception . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3 Novel sweeteners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4 Sweetness potentiators. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.5 Sweetness inhibitors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.6 Future trends. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.7 Sources of further information and advice . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.8 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
146 146 147 151 154 157 162 163 163
169 170 174 181 182 182 185
185 187 189 195 197 197 198 199
Enhancing umami taste in foods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 202 J. B. Marcus, Kendall College, USA 11.1 Umami: what it is, what it does and how it works. . . . . . . 202 11.2 Culinary history of umami in flavour enhancement . . . . . 203
viii
Contents 11.3 11.4 11.5 11.6 11.7 11.8 11.9 11.10 11.11 11.12 11.13 11.14 11.15 11.16 11.17 11.18 11.19 11.20
12
13
Scientific background of umami in flavour enhancement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . How the culinary aspects and science of umami interact . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Asian condiments that impart umami taste and tasteactive components . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Western foods that impart umami taste and tasteactive components . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Other umami taste-activators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Taste-active components and umami synergy . . . . . . . . . . Umami formed in ripening, drying, curing, ageing and fermenting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practical aspects of umami in consumer acceptance . . . . . Consumer applications of umami. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Food technology applications of umami . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Umami applications that maximise flavour, food acceptance and food preference. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Umami applications for the development and enhancement of recipes and products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . US umami initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . European umami initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Future trends. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sources of further information and advice . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
203 204 205 205 206 207 207 208 209 210 210 215 216 217 217 218 218 220
Bitter blockers in foods and pharmaceuticals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . R. McGregor, Linguagen Corporation, USA 12.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.2 Why reduce bitterness in foods and pharmaceuticals? . . . 12.3 Current approaches to reducing bitterness. . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.4 Advantages to bitter blocked pharmaceutical formulations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.5 The science of taste perception . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.6 Identifying compounds that decrease the perception of bitterness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.7 Future trends. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.8 Sources of further information and advice . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.9 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
221
Masking agents for use in foods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M. Gascon, Wixon Inc., USA 13.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.2 How masking agents work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.3 Ingredients used to formulate masking agents. . . . . . . . . .
232
221 221 223 224 225 228 230 230 230
232 233 235
Contents 13.4 13.5 13.6 13.7 14
ix
What to consider when working with masking agents . . . Masking agents: when to use or not to use. . . . . . . . . . . . . Outlook and perspectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
239 240 240 241
Selecting the right flavourings for a food product . . . . . . . . . . . . . K. B. de Roos, Givaudan Nederland B.V., The Netherlands 14.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.2 Creation of the desired flavour profile . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.3 Stability of the flavouring . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.4 Solving flavour release problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.5 Solving flavour stability problems in products . . . . . . . . . . 14.6 Future trends. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.7 Sources of further information and advice . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.8 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
243
Index
243 244 247 249 253 265 267 267
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 275
Contributor contact details
Chapter 1
Chapter 2
A. J. Taylor Professor of Flavour Technology Division of Food Sciences University of Nottingham Sutton Bonington Campus Loughborough LE12 5RD UK
D. Baines Baines Food Consultancy Ltd 22 Elizabeth Close Thornbury Bristol BS35 2YN UK e-mail:
[email protected]
e-mail: Andy.Taylor@nottingham. ac.uk and J. Hort Lecturer in Sensory Science Division of Food Sciences University of Nottingham Sutton Bonington Campus Loughborough LE12 5RD UK e-mail: joanne.hort@nottingham. ac.uk
Chapter 3 Giancarlo Cravotto* Dipartimento di Scienza e Tecnologia del Farmaco University of Turin Via P. Giuria 9 I-10125 Torino Italy e-mail:
[email protected] and
Contributors Pedro Cintas Departamento de Química Orgánica Facultad de Ciencias University of Extremadura Avenida de Elvas s/n e-06071 Badajoz Spain e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 4 R. G. Berger Leibniz University of Hannover Centre of Applied Chemistry Institute of Food Chemistry Wunstorfer Strasse 14 D-30453 Hannover Germany e-mail:
[email protected]. de
Chapter 5 B. Noordam and F. R. Meijer DSM Food Specialties R&D/FTD/Application PO-box 1 2600MA Delft The Netherlands e-mail:
[email protected] [email protected]
xi
Chapter 6 S. Serra C.N.R. Istituto di Chimica del Riconoscimento Molecolare, presso Dipartimento di Chimica Materiali ed Ingegneria Chimica del Politecnico Via Mancinelli 7 20131 Milano Italy e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 7 J. Hort* and D. Cook Division of Food Sciences University of Nottingham Sutton Bonington Campus Loughborough LE12 5RD UK e-mail: joanne.hort@nottingham. ac.uk
Chapter 8 C. C. Galopin Givaudan Flavors Corporation Research and Development 1199 Edison Drive Cincinnati OH 45216 USA e-mail: christophe.galopin@pmusa. com
xii
Contributors
Chapter 9
Chapter 11
G. Reineccius Dept. Food Science and Nutrition University of Minnesota 1334 Eckles Ave St. Paul MN 55108 USA
J. B. Marcus Kendall College School of Culinary Arts 900 N. North Branch Street Chicago Illinois 60622 USA
e-mail:
[email protected]
e-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Chapter 10 S. Kemp Head of Global Sensory and Consumer Guidance Global Science Centre Cadbury Schweppes The Lord Zuckerman Research Centre Pepper Lane Reading RG6 6LA UK e-mail:
[email protected] and M. G. Lindley Lindley Consulting 17 Highway Crowthorne Berkshire RG45 6HE UK e-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 12 R. McGregor Linguagen Corp. 2005 Eastpark Boulevard Cranbury NJ 08512-3515 USA e-mail: richard.mcgregor@ linguagen.com
Chapter 13 M. Gascon Wixon Inc. 1390 East Bolivar Avenue St Francis WI 53235 USA e-mail: mariano_gascon@wixon. com
Chapter 14 K. B. de Roos De Eelinkes 37 7101 PZ Winterswijk The Netherlands e-mail:
[email protected]
1 Modifying flavour: an introduction A. J. Taylor and J. Hort, University of Nottingham, UK
1.1
Introduction
Modifying the flavour of foods by adding other materials is an ancient practice. The use of salt as a preservative, and as a flavour enhancer, has been practised for hundreds, if not thousands, of years. Similarly, the use of heat to cook food has its roots in antiquity and presumably made the food easier to eat (compare the texture of cooked meat versus raw) and more digestible (native starch is hard to digest compared with gelatinised). It also reduced the load of food poisoning organisms on the food and increased food safety while adding more volatile compounds to the flavour profile through chemical reactions such as caramelisation and the Maillard reaction. Today, we cook foods for all these reasons but we are more interested in the flavour aspect, as the other issues are no longer of primary importance, at least for that part of the world that has an adequate supply of food. Chefs routinely use herb and spice flavourings to complement the natural flavours of staple foods such as meat, fish and cereal products, and many popular dishes owe their characteristic flavour, not to the major ingredients, but to the minor added flavours. Thus modifying food flavour is a longstanding practice that has developed in response to various human factors, starting with our initial attempts to ensure survival of the human race but now focused more on the hedonics of food. Food production and consumption patterns have changed markedly in Western society over the past few decades, with a move away from home cooking using basic ingredients, to mass-produced foods that can be ‘cooked’ at home simply by reheating in an oven. Convenience foods and preprepared meals form much of the average person’s diet and the scale and scope of food manufacture create different preparation techniques
2
Modifying flavour in food
compared with traditional cooking in the home, or restaurant cooking, both of which serve only a relatively small number of people. For example, scaling up the dishes prepared by development chefs is notoriously difficult as the whole time and temperature conditions of cooking can change. A good example is sauce manufacture where the come-up time (the time to reach the desired temperature) of a 2 tonne batch cooker is of the order of 60 min. This is followed by a cooking time and then further holding times during packing, meaning that products can be held at elevated temperatures for several hours. This change in thermal processing has a significant effect on the chemistries that produce or destroy flavour compounds, with the result that the flavour of a 2 tonne batch will not necessarily resemble the flavour of the 200 g sample from the development kitchen. One way of addressing this situation is to use the flavourings produced by flavour houses. They can be added to the batch late in the cook and the level of dosage can be varied to produce the desired flavour intensity. Another example of a mass manufacture challenge, is the necessity to maintain the flavour of foods during shelf-life and/or during the reheating cycle. The flavour industry has developed special forms of flavour to address the shelflife issue (e.g. encapsulated flavours) and has the knowledge to select flavour compounds that will perform better in reheating scenarios than the naturally occurring flavours. Added flavourings are also essential ingredients in the production of goods such as confectionery, beverages, cakes, biscuits and snack foods. In all these examples, the flavour of the base composition is modified in some way to deliver the desired properties to the foods. Although mass-produced foods are very popular, in some parts of the world, the food and flavour industry is facing a new challenge as consumer organisations raise questions about the quality of the mass-produced products. In an open society, this is a valid topic that should be debated in an open way. However, the tone taken by many of the consumer groups (and the media) is quite aggressive and is based on the premise that the food and flavour industries are providing unhealthy food and that they are only out to make money. In the United Kingdom, at least, rational discussion is largely missing from the newspaper and television coverage and, in these authors’ opinion, the interviewers rarely challenge the representatives of the consumer groups as to their credentials and their motives since, after all, many of these people are also making money and creating careers out of the situation. The message that consumers receive from these sources is that any food component considered synthetic must be bad and that anything natural must be good. Although irrational, this is a deeply rooted belief and is illustrated by a recent UK government pronouncement that ‘natural’ remedies can make health claims without going through the extensive testing procedures required for synthetic drugs (MHRA 2004). Although the issues described above are non-technical and, although the assertion about unhealthy food and profit making is largely untrue, these issues have had a major effect on the attitude of consumers and also the
Modifying flavour: an introduction
3
approach taken by food and flavour manufacturers. Some companies are changing product formulation so that all ingredients can be declared as natural. Other companies are exploring an approach that decrees that their products will be made using only ingredients that could be found in ‘the kitchen store cupboard’. Additives are thus excluded and only ingredients recognised by the consumer (e.g. salt, wheat flour, butter) can be used. These consumer-driven changes impact on the flavour industry in two ways. First, they are required to produce greater quantities of natural flavourings and, second, the debate about whether mass-produced natural flavourings will be considered as ‘kitchen store cupboard’ ingredients (and therefore accepted by consumers) remains to be settled. In this latter case, maybe the common domestic usage of flavourings such as vanilla extract will lead to a certain level of acceptance. Another current, associated concern is the problem of obesity in many Western countries. There is considerable pressure on food manufacturers to produce foods with reduced amounts of fat, salt and sugar to address the nutritional guidelines issued by governments. However, the new products have to taste just as good as the originals or the population will not consume them and therefore will gain no nutritional benefit. The paragraphs above largely describe the market factors that influence flavour production and marketing, commonly called ‘market pull’. There is also a complementary, research-led ‘push’ which influences flavour production and it is interesting to examine how research findings have influenced the way that flavours are developed commercially. Such an examination is subjective and the following topics are the editors’ interpretation of research progress since 1995. The most notable development is our increased understanding of the flavour receptors in the nose and mouth. Buck and Axel received the 2004 Nobel prize in Physiology and Medicine for their work on olfactory receptors, an award that raised the profile of flavour research worldwide. Parallel work on the taste receptors, and the associated transduction mechanisms, have increased our knowledge of the way tastants act on the system. These advances have resulted in some direct applications, for example, the Senomyx and Linguagen companies in the United States are using knowledge of the taste receptors, coupled to molecular biology techniques, to screen compounds for various taste activities, such as the ability to block bitterness or to enhance flavour. Other potential applications will need more knowledge on the systems biology of the taste and smell systems. Examples of these applications are an understanding of aroma interactions at the receptor level (i.e. how does one odour molecule affect the binding of a different odour), the dynamics of binding, the potential interactions between neural signals as they are processed at the different levels in the brain and, the ultimate goal, an understanding of why a particular mixture of aroma and taste compounds produces such strong emotions when sensed.
4
Modifying flavour in food
Knowledge of the mechanisms and kinetics of the Maillard reaction have also advanced, thanks to the application of new analytical and data processing tools. The pathways of reactants can be followed using labelling techniques such as CAMOLA (Schieberle, 2005) while on-line monitoring of the process can be achieved (Channell and Taylor, 2005; Pollien et al., 2003). Models of the Maillard reaction, which predict the products from different reactant levels and different processing conditions, are also being developed (Martins and Van Boekel, 2005). There are obvious applications for these techniques in optimising thermal flavour production or in controlling the amounts of undesirable products such as acrylamide and 3-chloro-propan1,2-diol (MCPD). The way in which flavour components modify the perceived flavour of foods has also advanced from a stage where we were simply aware of the situation, to an understanding of the interactions involved at a qualitative and quantitative level. Many examples exist in the literature but the observation that the perceived flavour of a solution decreases as viscosity increases, illustrates the point well (Pangborn and Szczesniak, 1974). One of the original explanations for this behaviour was that viscosity hindered the release of aroma from the sample when eaten and caused a decrease in aroma signal. This hypothesis was disproved (Hollowood et al., 2002) and, coupled with work from other laboratories, reinforced the idea that flavour was a multi-modal construct in which cross-modal interactions were significant. The seminal work of Dalton et al. (2000) who showed that subthreshold levels of benzaldehyde and sweetener interacted cognitively to produce a perception, has been complemented by data from our laboratory on taste – aroma and taste – viscosity – aroma interactions in sweet and savoury flavour (see for example Davidson et al., 1999; Pfeiffer et al., 2005). We now know that tastant release is altered in viscous solutions and the change in sensory properties is caused by a reduced taste–aroma interaction. Commercial examples of this knowledge are now evident, such as the recently launched chewing gum in the United States with the ‘ridiculously long-lasting flavour’ (Cadbury Adams, Stride gum). The prolonged flavour sensation seems to work by delivering sugar over a longer time period to enhance the sensation of mintiness as suggested previously (Davidson et al., 1999). Other, not so obvious, applications are in confectionery and reduced fat foods. The result is that the principles of multi-modal flavour perception have been established through fundamental research and are now being used by industry to address real needs; this is the ultimate goal of applied scientific research and is gratifying to see the loop being closed. With the ready availability of analytical methods to monitor flavour release in vivo (Linforth and Taylor, 2003) and for brain imaging to investigate cognitive interactions between taste and aromas (Verhagen and Engelen, 2006), further progress in our understanding is envisaged. For the reasons outlined above, the manufacture, development and uses of flavourings are driven by a very wide range of economic, scientific, legal
Modifying flavour: an introduction
5
and social factors. The current needs for modifying flavour are therefore different from those experienced by the industry in the mid-1990s and the content of this book attempts to address some of the issues that are relevant at the current time. The flavouring industry has used technology to develop a range of pleasant flavours with high flavour potency that can be used to modify the overall flavour of a product. The development of those technologies has formed the basis for R&D in flavour houses across the world and has led to novel and improved ways of modifying the flavour of foods to meet the needs of industry and consumers. The book starts with an account of how the flavour industry has developed its technology over the past century or so (Chapter 2; Baines). The initial focus on chemical synthesis of the flavour compounds found in nature created an innovative industry which improved the flavour, and the general quality, of foods from the turn of the 20th century. This was followed by the adoption of the newly discovered separation and identification techniques in the 1960s to extract new flavour compounds from natural materials and then synthesise analogues to overcome the problems associated with natural sources, such as seasonality and variations in flavour content. The current trend is for ‘natural’ flavours and ingredients and, in some countries, this is being pursued to a very high level. Baines finishes his chapter by pointing out that the current EU legislation is likely to favour the development of new flavours in markets outside the EU, owing to the costs and complications of clearing new flavouring compounds for use in the EU. With the consumer pressure for natural food ingredients, the next two chapters tackle the production of natural flavours (Chapters 3 and 4). This could be considered as modifying the form in which the flavour is delivered, i.e. using natural means to manufacture the flavours rather than organic chemical syntheses. Chapter 3 is concerned with the extraction of natural flavourings from plant materials and how the new extraction techniques can provide high-quality materials while also meeting the additional needs of protecting the environment and ensuring sustainability. The use of solvents such as supercritical carbon dioxide and pressurised water has many environmental attractions as they are natural and non-toxic agents. Like many potential solutions to the problems of energy and environment, the full impact of these techniques has not been fully considered, e.g. although CO2 is environmentally friendly, how much extra energy do we spend extracting, compressing, transporting and applying CO2 in the extraction of flavours? It will need a bigger book than this to fully discuss these issues but the adverse energy requirements of bioethanol production have already shown the potential problems of these ‘green’ technologies. Chapter 4 describes new advances in biotechnology to produce natural flavours in a vast array of microorganisms, using our advanced knowledge of metabolic pathways which can now be expressed in most any organism through genetic modification. It is ironic that while genetically modified food is not acceptable to
6
Modifying flavour in food
some sections of Europe, drugs and flavours produced by these means are totally acceptable. The extraction of tastants from yeast is described in Chapter 5. Yeast extracts are well known for their meaty and savoury (bouillon) flavour properties but new methodology delivers yeast extracts with little or no savoury flavour and with very interesting enhancing properties. This is an exciting development as the components of these yeast extracts seem to exert a cross-modal effect on some unexpected sensory attributes, e.g. the mouthfeel of a low-fat dairy product. The next set of chapters represents some of the more fundamental research work that will provide the future scientific knowledge for further innovations by the flavour industry. Chapter 6 describes fundamental work on the chirality of flavours and it has long been recognised that stereoisomers of certain compounds have different odours, with menthone being the classic example (Fisher and Scott, 1997). However, with the consumer demand for natural flavours, there is also a drive to mimic as closely as possible the form in which flavours are found in nature. The authors of Chapter 6 remark that although consumers apparently want their flavours to be natural, the costs of delivering flavour enantiomers that match the natural state will have to be accepted by the consumer first; then the industry will need to establish the feasibility of the current laboratory-scale methods for large-scale production. This chapter neatly illustrates how the development of technologies depends very much on the potential markets and is an example of an area where technology is available at a fundamental level but where the ‘market pull’ is not yet established. In Chapter 7, the role of fat in food flavour is discussed from the fundamental point of view. The basic tenet is that fat has many roles in our appreciation of flavour quality. We know of its role in the partition (and therefore the release) of aromas, in the viscosity of the food as well as the all-important, but difficult to define, aspect of mouthfeel. Thus, if fat content in a food is changed, we can expect a host of effects on sensory quality and we will need not just a single fat replacer but a range of adjustments to recreate the many properties contributed by fat to a food’s overall flavour and acceptance. Indeed, the authors of this chapter question whether manufacturers will ever be able to replace fat successfully considering how adept the sensory mechanisms of the human body are at detecting fat. Therefore, applying this knowledge to the commercial situation, it seems that if we want to make a low-fat analogue of an existing product, we need to add a range of materials to fully replace fat in foods. While this may create a technical solution, it is unlikely to meet the consumer demands for ‘additive-free’ food products. The alternative solution is to create new food products with lower fat levels and a different flavour from conventional products. There are signs of both types of activity in the food area. New microstructures patented by Unilever (see, for example, Appelquist et al. 2000) were designed to decrease fat content while maintaining effective
Modifying flavour: an introduction
7
flavour delivery and demonstrate the development of new food structures. The development of new low-fat products can be seen in many supermarkets where clearly identified product ranges have been developed and marketed using words such as ‘lite’ or ‘low-fat’ to differentiate them from conventional products. The next chapter in this section (Chapter 8), addresses the subject in a fundamental way by considering how pungent and cooling sensations are perceived by humans. With this knowledge, methods for manipulating the sensation by using appropriate structures and delivery mechanisms can be postulated and trialled. Linked to this is the concept of controlling flavour delivery to elicit optimum and novel flavours. Although flavour delivery can be easily controlled in model systems to study fundamental aspects of flavour perception (Hort and Hollowood, 2004), controlling delivery in real foods is much more difficult. Factors such as cooking and oral processing (e.g. mastication and hydration) can remove the effects of some delivery systems and cancel out any potential advantage. Reineccius (Chapter 9) reviews the methods currently available to modify the delivery of flavours through encapsulation techniques and gives examples of applications where encapsulation offers advantages. The next group of chapters (Chapters 10–13) describes methods and materials to modify flavours, by masking or enhancement. One of the main applications for these techniques is the result of food reformulation to reduce fat, salt and sugar in our diet or to add components considered as nutritionally beneficial such as fibre or antioxidants which have inherent poor taste properties. Despite the simplistic view of some government agencies that meeting nutritional requirements is simply a question of adding or removing components from food, manufacturers and flavour houses who want to satisfy consumers’ flavour expectations know differently. Changing food formulations in this way creates flavour imbalance, and sensory analysis often identifies flavour defects such as bitterness or poor mouthfeel, which adversely affect the overall flavour of foods. The first topic to be addressed is the use of sweeteners in food. Although considerable advances have been made in identifying alternatives to sucrose, the economic manufacture of foods with the same clean taste quality and temporal sweetness as sucrose eludes researchers. Chapter 10 reviews a range of compounds that have been investigated for their sweet taste. Some mention is also given to those compounds that may suppress sweetness, enabling the use of sucrose for its other functional properties without adding sweetness. Although only recently recognised as the fifth taste, umami with its flavour-enhancing capability has been recognised in culinary circles for centuries. In Chapter 11, Marcus summarises what is known about the compounds and sensory mechanisms involved in umami sensation. She catalogues the presence of umami compounds in a wide range of foods and illustrates particular ingredients that are used in cooking that make use of
8
Modifying flavour in food
umami to optimise flavour. The information in this chapter complements some of the material presented in Chapter 5 on the flavour-enhancing properties of yeast extracts. The next two chapters investigate the use of blocking or masking agents to modify the flavour of foods. In Chapter 12, McGregor reviews the current approaches taken to reduce bitterness and highlights how an increased understanding of taste receptor mechanisms can, and will continue to, advance the identification of suitable bitter blockers. In Chapter 13 Gascon outlines some of the masking agents available in the industry’s ‘toolbox’. However, more importantly, he highlights the fact that every product is likely to need its own unique ‘masking’ solution and that the use of blends of masking agents is more likely to be the solution. Without doubt, masking bitterness is a major challenge to both the food and pharmaceutical industry. Many of the previous chapters of the book have addressed modifications to the production of flavours to meet the needs of consumers or to modify flavours as a result of reformulation. However, combining these flavour ‘raw materials’ into successful commercial flavours that will function in a wide variety of foods is a major task. In Chapter 14, the science behind the design of flavours that will function in the different food matrices is explained from the commercial angle by de Roos. Our understanding of how flavour is released from foods, before eating and during eating has advanced considerably over the last 10 years and it is satisfying to see these basic principles being applied and further developed to improve food flavours. This is an area in which one of the editors has had a significant interest and it is interesting to see how much the field has changed since an early review (Taylor, 1996). Besides introducing the current work on modifying flavour to meet market and consumer needs, the chapters collectively demonstrate the breadth of scientific disciplines used in flavour production and application. Extraction involves principles of chemical engineering, physical and organic chemistries, bioprocessing brings together biochemistry and molecular biology, while chirality needs sophisticated analyses coupled to organic syntheses. The development of the various agents used to enhance or mask flavours requires knowledge of flavour perception at a receptor and cognitive level, coupled with the ability to produce compounds and materials that can deliver the necessary properties at an economic price. Moving on to the later chapters, we see that the role of human physiology during the eating of food also needs to be considered. For many researchers in the food area, it is this diversity that makes the field so interesting and, at times, so difficult. The diversity of sciences involved also reinforces the widely held view (see summary in Section 9.5) that significant advances in flavour will only be made through multi-disciplinary teams where all members have some awareness of other scientific disciplines.
Modifying flavour: an introduction
1.2
9
References
appelquist, i. a. m., brown, c. r. t., homan, j. e., jones, m. g., malone, m. e., norton, i. t., appleqvist, i. a. and brown, c. r. (2000), ‘Low-fat food emulsions for e.g. spreads, dressing or mayonnaise, have gel particles for delaying the release of the flavor molecules’, Patents WO200007462-A, EP1102548-A, WO200007462-A1, EP1102548-A1, EP1102548-B1. channell, g. a. and taylor, a. j. (2005), ‘On line monitoring of the Maillard reaction using a film reactor coupled to ion trap mass spectrometry’. Process and reaction flavors. Weerasinghe, D. K. and Sucan, M. K. Washington, DC, American Chemical Society. 905, 181–191. dalton, p., doolittle, n., nagata, h. and breslin, p. a. s. (2000), ‘The merging of the senses: Integration of subthreshold taste and smell.’ Nature Neuroscience, 3 (5), 431–432. davidson, j. m., hollowood, t. a., linforth, r. s. t. and taylor, a. j. (1999), ‘The effect of sucrose on the perceived flavour intensity of chewing gum.’ Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 47, 4336–4340. fisher, c. and scott, t. r. (1997), Food Flavours: Biology and Chemistry. Cambridge, Royal Society of Chemistry. hollowood, t. a., linforth, r. s. t. and taylor, a. j. (2002), ‘The effect of viscosity on the perception of flavour.’ Chemical Senses, 27, 583–591. hort, j. and hollowood, t. a. (2004), ‘Controlled continuous flow delivery system for investigating taste–aroma interactions.’ Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 52, 4834–4843. linforth, r. s. t. and taylor, a. j. (2003), ‘Direct mass spectrometry of complex volatile and non-volatile flavour mixtures.’ International Journal of Mass Spectrometry, 223–224, 179–191. martins, s. i. f. s. and van boekel, m. a. j. s. (2005), ‘Kinetics of the glucose/glycine Maillard reaction pathways: influences of pH and reactant initial concentrations.’ Food Chemistry, 92 (3), 437–448. mhra (2004), Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency, http://www. mhra.gov.uk/home. pangborn, r. m. and szczesniak, a. s. (1974), ‘Effect of hydrocolloids and viscosity on aromatic flavour compounds.’ Journal of Texture Studies, 4, 467–482. pfeiffer, j., hort, j., hollowood, t. a. and taylor, a. j. (2005), ‘Temporal synchrony and integration of sub-threshold taste and smell signals.’ Chemical Senses, 30, 1–7. pollien, p., lindinger, c., yeretzian, c. and blank, i. (2003), ‘Proton transfer reaction mass spectrometry, a tool for on-line monitoring of acrylamide formation in the headspace of Maillard reaction systems and processed food.’ Analytical Chemistry, 75 (20), 5488–5494. schieberle, p. (2005), ‘The carbon module labeling (camola) technique: a useful tool for identifying transient intermediates in the formation of Maillard-type target molecules.’ Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1043, 236–248. taylor, a. j. (1996), ‘Volatile flavor release from foods during eating.’ Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 36 (8), 765–784. verhagen, j. v. and engelen, l. (2006), ‘The neurocognitive bases of human multimodal food perception: sensory integration.’ Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 30 (5), 613–650.
2 Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation D. Baines, Baines Food Consultancy Ltd, UK
2.1
The importance of olfaction in the appreciation of flavour
The appreciation of flavour is realised through our chemical senses of olfaction and gustation and, to a lesser extent, through certain molecules that interact with trigeminal nerves located in the mouth, throat and nasal cavity. The trigeminal effect, or chemesthesis, is a minor but integral part of the flavour sensation involving the pain receptors that sense, for example, the heat from chillies, the cooling from peppermint and the burning from horseradish.
2.1.1 Gustation Gustation, or the sense of taste, is experienced through five types of interaction in the mouth; sweetness, sourness, bitterness, saltiness and ‘umami’, the latter being the Japanese word for succulence or deliciousness and elicited by the salts of glutamic acid, ribonucleotides and a few other taste active chemicals (Bell and Watson, 1999; Dewis, 2005). Taste responds primarily to non-volatile, water-soluble or saliva-soluble flavouring substances and serves a number of purposes. It monitors the quality of food through the sweet and umami taste receptors which respond to the presence of sugars and glutamate respectively. Detecting sugars determines carbohydrate quality and the supply of energy, and the detection of glutamate determines protein quality and the supply of essential amino acids for healthy metabolic functioning. The bitter and sour receptors serve a protective role and defend the body from noxious and poisonous substances and the regulation
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
11
of sodium chloride in the bloodstream is facilitated by the salty taste receptor.
2.1.2 Olfaction Our real ability to appreciate flavour, and to discriminate and understand the subtleties and nuances of foods and drinks, lies mainly with olfaction and is due to a quite amazing organ, the olfactory epithelium, which detects volatile organic chemicals in the environment and flavouring substances in food. This organ, located high in the nasal cavity, is a forward projection of the brain that interfaces with the outside world. It would have been one of the first organs to develop, even before the brain, and its original function would have been to detect chemical nutrients in an aqueous environment necessary for the survival of the organism. The olfactory epithelium has therefore had a very long time to evolve (Stoddart, 1999) and its ability to detect volatile organic chemicals is highly developed and tuned into the flavouring substances that are important in the foods we eat. It is estimated that the olfactory epithelium can detect and discriminate around 10 000 different smells through around 6 million receptor cells which are replaced by the body every 4–10 weeks (Mackay-Sim and Kittel, 1991; Key, 1999). These olfactory receptor cells each possess several hair-like structures called cilia which protrude into a mucous layer covering the olfactory epithelium. The cilia act as ‘docking ports’ for the volatile flavour substances that evaporate from the tongue and throat into the nasal cavity and absorb into the olfactory mucus during the process of eating and drinking. The flavour chemicals absorbing in the mucous layer couple with specialised olfactory binding proteins located in the ciliary membrane (Buck and Axel, 1991). A signal then passes to the olfactory bulb where it is amplified and the ‘signal to noise’ ratio minimised before being relayed to the olfactory cortex in the limbic brain where it is interpreted. The limbic system is the most ancient part of the brain and is also involved with emotion, mood, sexual behaviour, reproductive control and fear. Smells play a number of important roles through the limbic system such as neonatal bonding, flight response from prey, the selection of a mate and the monitoring of food. Smells can evoke memory and emotions, trigger fear, influence mood and are important for our enjoyment when eating. The ability of the olfactory epithelium to detect and interact with flavouring substances varies by many orders of magnitude and compared with gustation it is highly developed. If we compare the sensitivities of aroma and taste, our ability to detect sweetness through sugar is of the order of 3400 parts per million, the threshold level at which ordinary people start to detect sugar in water. If we relate this to time, which is easier to conceptualise, it is equivalent to approximately 1 second in an hour. By comparison, our ability to detect volatile flavouring substances is many orders of magnitude more sensitive and the flavouring substance with the lowest recorded
12
Modifying flavour in food
threshold, maple furanone, has a threshold in water of 0.00001 parts per billion, which equates to a time scale of 1 second in 3.2 million years. Humans have an extraordinary ability to perceive and discriminate between thousands of volatile organic compounds and an astonishing sensitivity to certain molecules that in evolutionary terms have been an important aspect in the survival of the species. Such is the amazing chemistry, biochemistry and neurobiology of the olfactory epithelium; nanotechnology in action initiated by flavouring substances in food and other volatile organic chemicals in the environment. Our flavour senses are more complex than the simplistic overview described above and recent research has revealed that flavour perception is multisensory in nature, where one sensory input can modify the perception of another, showing that olfaction, gustation and chemesthesis are strongly interactive. A number of excellent texts are available describing olfaction, gustation and the multimodal relationship that exists between the senses in more detail, and the reader is directed to these for further information (Bell and Watson 1999; Taylor and Roberts 2004).
2.2
Flavouring substances in foods
Enormous progress has been made since the 1960s with the identification of volatile organic compounds in foods. In 1965 approximately 700 had been found but today the number of discrete volatile organic compounds detected in foods stands at over 7670; these are listed in the Nutrition and Food Research Institute of the Netherlands (TNO) publication website Volatile Compounds in Foods (VCF) (http://www.vcf-online.nl). The VCF register is the recognised world authority on the occurrence of volatile compounds in food and the latest version, 9.1, lists over 680 food sources in which flavouring substances have been identified. The compounds listed in the VCF have only been included if the validity of the identification has been authenticated by two methods of analysis, usually a retention time and a mass spectrum, and more than 105 700 individual occurrences are now registered in the database. Over 1000 discrete volatiles have been found in coffee and nearly the same number in beef. Many organic volatiles are ubiquitous across foods, while others are specific to a particular food group or even an individual food. It is this that makes the subject so fascinating and challenging for flavour chemists to identify which of the volatile organic compounds in foods are actually creating the flavour signals in the human brain that allow us to recognise the flavour of the food we eat. Not all volatile compounds found in food can be classified as flavouring substances because some do not possess distinctive aromas, while others have very high odour thresholds and are not detected among other lower threshold flavouring substances present in foods. Others may have undesirable aroma profiles and some volatile compounds found in food cannot be
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation CHO
13
O OH
OR OH (I): R = Me (II): R = Et
Fig. 2.1
O
R
(III): R = Me (IV): R = Et
Vanillin and maltol and their artificial homologues.
used as flavouring substances because they are toxic. For example, benzene, which is a carcinogen, is listed in 90 food products in the TNO register, including major foods such as apples, oranges, beef, chicken, pork and cheese. Conversely, not all flavouring substances are found in food. These are the artificial flavouring substances of which there are now relatively few but some are very useful such as ethyl vanillin (II) which has a sweet, warm, creamy, vanilla-like flavour (Arctander, 2000) and is four times the flavour strength of vanillin (I) and ethyl maltol (IV) which has a sweet, fruity, jamlike, slightly bready flavour (Arctander, 2000) and is four to six times the tenacity of its methyl analogue, maltol (III), which is widely distributed in nature (Fig. 2.1). By definition, therefore, flavouring substances are volatile organic compounds, not necessarily present in foods that are useful in the formulation of food flavourings.
2.2.1 Flavouring substances – a historical perspective The first flavouring substance of commercial use was vanillin (I), which was extracted from vanilla beans (Gobey, 1858) and synthesised by Tiemann and Haarmann (1874). The structure was subsequently proved by Riemer (1876) who synthesised vanillin from guaiacol. This heralded the beginning of modern flavour chemistry and the discovery of new and interesting flavouring substances through organic synthesis. It also gave birth to the world’s first synthetic flavour and fragrance factory, Haarmann & Reimer, which was founded in 1874 and in which perfumery and flavouring substances were produced. In 2003, Haarmann & Reimer was merged with Dragoco to form the world’s fourth largest flavour company, Symrise.
2.2.2 The synthetic era Quite a number of flavouring substances were discovered first by synthesis and then later found in the food product which represented their aroma character. Raspberry ketone (V) is a notable example, which was first synthesised by Japanese workers (Nomura and Nozawa, 1919). It has a sweet,
14
Modifying flavour in food
fruity and warm odour resembling raspberry preserve (Arctander, 2000) and was used extensively as a raspberry flavouring substance well before its discovery in the berry (Schinz and Seidel, 1957). Raspberry flavouring is an example of the forces driving flavour companies in the early decades of the 20th century, competing to secure market share and satisfy the needs of food companies to provide ever more appealing food products for consumers. The synthesis and patenting of a novel flavour chemical gave a flavour company the exclusive rights to that chemical during the lifetime of the patent and the sale of improved flavourings containing the novel compound gave the company a significant commercial benefit over its competitors. The major flavour houses were investigating new synthetic routes to flavour compounds that could help them create improved raspberry flavours and a large number of closely related derivatives of raspberry ketone (V) were synthesised and their olfactory properties evaluated (Winter, 1961) in the laboratories of Firmenich. Winter concluded that the naturally occurring ketone, raspberry ketone, had the strongest and finest organoleptic properties although the methoxy derivative was also reported to be useful as a raspberry flavouring substance. Considerable interest was shown in the ability of synthetic derivatives of the ionones to impart fresh raspberry notes to various flavour formulations. Both α-ionone (VI) and β-ionone (VII) had been found in raspberry and although they make an important contribution to the flavour they do not give the character of raspberry required to create authentic raspberry flavours. The flavour companies Givaudan and Firmenich filed patents (Helmlinger et al., 1972; Ohloff and Sundt, 1973) on compounds derived from the ionone nucleus indicated by the general formula (VIII) and a subsequent Givaudan patent (Helmlinger et al., 1975) named 4-(1,1,3trimethyl-3-cyclohexen-2-yl)-4-acetylmercapto-butan-2-one (IX) as useful for generating raspberry aromas in foodstuffs. International Flavours and Fragrances (IFF) investigated methods of modifying the ionone structure and patented the compounds 4-(1,1,3-trimethyl-2,4-cyclohexadien-2-yl)-2butanol (X) and 4-(1,1-dimethyl-3-methylene-4-cyclohexen-2-yl)-2-butanol (XI) (Mookherjee et al., 1975) and their corresponding acetates and βcylohomocitral (XII), a fragment of the ionone structure, which they claimed ‘rounded out’ and contributed to a very natural fresh aroma and taste as found in full ripe raspberries (Pittet et al., 1976). Another compound, 2-(4hydroxy-4-methylpentyl)norbornadiene (XIII), was patented for use in raspberry flavours by IFF (Sanders and Vock, 1976) and was reported to give the full aroma of ripened raspberries with the taste of ripe raspberry and its seedy kernel note. A compound with this structure is unlikely to be found in nature but it is interesting to note the structural similarities of both artificial and naturally occurring flavouring substances exhibiting raspberry character, a factor that would not have gone unnoticed to synthetic chemists attempting to create the flavour of raspberry. Subsequently damascenone
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation O
15
O
HO (V)
(VI) SR
O
O
R' R = H or Ac R′ = H or Me (VII) SAc
(VIII) O
OH
(X)
(IX) OH
CHO
(XI)
(XII) OH
(XIII)
Fig. 2.2
O
(XIV)
Flavouring substances used in raspberry flavourings.
(XIV) was found in raspberries and this contributes a natural sweet fruity rose plum raspberry sugar type of character and makes a valuable contribution to raspberry flavourings (Fig. 2.2). Strawberry flavour also presented another major challenge for the flavour industry being one of the most popular consumer flavours, especially in ice cream and, for many decades, two synthetic compounds, ethyl-3-phenylglycidate (EPG) (XV) and ethyl-3-methyl-3-phenyl glycidate (EMPG) (XVI) also known as ‘strawberry aldehyde’, formed the basis of strawberry flavourings (Fig. 2.3). EMG has a warm caramellic-fruity odour reminiscent of cooked strawberries with a strawberry jam taste and EMPG
16
Modifying flavour in food COOC2H5
O
HO
O
O
R
R (XV): R = H (XVI): R = Me
Fig. 2.3
(XVII): R = Me (XVIII): R = H
Flavouring substances used in strawberry flavouring.
is described as having a sweet, fruity, candy-like warm odour with a similarity to strawberry juice and a sweet distinctly fruity taste with good resemblance to strawberry and other berry fruits (Arctander, 2000). The discovery of 4-hydroxy-2,5-dimethyl-3-(2H)furanone, known as furaneol (XVII), in strawberries (Willhalm et al., 1965) in the laboratories of Firmenich with its fruity, strawberry, pineapple character gradually replaced the use of the glycidates which have never been identified in nature. Furaneol (XVII) turned out to be one of the most versatile flavouring substances ever discovered and has a distinct flavour-enhancing effect in addition to contributing its own flavour notes. Shortly after its discovery in strawberry, it was found in pineapple and it is now known to play a key role in raspberry, guava, mango, passionfruit, tomato, arctic bramble and others. Not only does it contribute an important sweet fruity flavour character to many fruits and other food products, it also has a very important role in cooked products such as coffee, malt and roasted almonds. It has been identified as one of the flavouring substances of importance in beef (Tonsbeek et al., 1968) and other meat products along with its homologue 4-hydroxy-5-methyl-(2H)furan-3-one, known as norfuraneol (XVIII) and for two decades furaneol was protected by patents from Firmenich for its use in fruit flavours and from Unilever for its use in meat and savoury flavours. The latter was filed because furaneol furnishes an important flavour character to beef and chicken but also because both furaneol and norfuraneol were also found to be the precursors of a number of highly potent sulphur compounds that are formed during the cooking of beef and chicken and that occupy a pivotal role in meat flavour. Furaneol is truly the chameleon of flavouring substances.
2.2.3 The analytical era The synthetic era gradually gave way to the analytical era, as analytical techniques developed and became increasingly capable of detecting and identifying the flavouring substances in foods that actually cause the flavour. The fact that these flavouring substances could be called nature identical in Europe gave them a considerable commercial advantage over synthetic artificial compounds as consumer trends shifted towards a demand for
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
17
natural additives and ingredients in food products. The discovery of βdamascenone (XIV) in rose by workers in Firmenich in 1970, then its subsequent discovery in raspberry, grape and wine, and its use in combination with α- and β-ionone, raspberry ketone and other nature identical flavouring substances, gradually obviated the need for artificial synthetic chemicals in the creation of raspberry flavourings. The analytical era gathered momentum in the mid-1970s as analytical methods became more sophisticated and nature could be ‘peeled open’ to uncover new, naturally occurring flavouring substances. This became an important strategic goal for the researchorientated flavour companies that had invested heavily in the new analytical methods. The discovery of a new flavouring substance clearly had significant commercial benefits for flavour companies but it was the consumer who was the eventual beneficiary through improvements in flavours which contributed significantly to the increasing quality of foodstuffs. The advent of gas chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry and odour port assessment of gas chromatograms was a leap forward (Karasek and Clement, 1988) but the real advance was the link-up of the computer to the mass spectrometer which made an enormous difference to the quality and speed of information available to the flavour chemist. From analysing UV-sensitive chart paper impregnated by the ion pattern from the source of the mass spectrometer, followed by reconstruction of chemical structures from fragmentation patterns, the flavour chemist found that, with the aid of the computer, the information was readily available and much easier to interpret. As mass spectrometry libraries developed, known compounds could be instantly identified and valuable data associated with unknown flavouring substances became more accessible. Important new data previously buried in the enormous amount of information generated by the mass spectrometer could be collected and analysed. Specific detectors for elements such as sulphur, the advent of chemical ionisation mass spectrometry, quadrupole mass spectrometry and more recently tandem mass spectrometry and time-of-flight mass spectrometry have made further inroads into the identification of volatile organic chemicals in food. Likewise extraction techniques became increasingly capable of removing flavour chemicals from the matrix of a food product without damaging or rearranging the critical flavouring substances. Relatively crude solvent extraction techniques gave way to headspace analysis as analytical methods became more sensitive. In the 1970s very large quantities of a food product had to be extracted to concentrate enough of the flavouring substances to allow their detection by mass spectrometry. More sophisticated solvent extraction methods such as solvent-assisted flavour evaporation (SAFE) (Engel et al., 1999) have been developed to protect flavouring substances during the extraction and concentration process but probably the greatest advance came from the water industry in Canada with the development of the headspace technique, solid phase micro-extraction (SPME) (Berlardi
18
Modifying flavour in food
and Pawliszyn, 1989), which has had widespread application in flavour research. As more and more flavouring substances were found in food products, it became a challenge to identify which flavouring substances were making the greatest contribution to the characteristic flavour of an individual food. Two elegant methods were developed that enabled research chemists to single out the key flavouring substances; CHARM analysis (Acree, 1993) and aroma extraction dilution analysis (Ullrich and Grosch, 1987). Both methods evaluate the contribution that each individual flavouring substance is making by sniffing the effluent of the gas chromatograph in a series of dilutions of the original flavour extract. Several injections are needed to reach a dilution of the flavour extract where the odour detection threshold of most flavouring substances present has been exceeded and only those making the greatest contribution to the flavour remain.
2.2.4 The importance of model reactions As extraction and analytical techniques developed, many new compounds were identified in foods such as fruits, vegetable products, herbs and spices where the flavouring substances contributing to flavour are formed by biogenetic processes occurring in the plant. Conversely, the flavouring substances generated in foods during cooking processes and formed by the Maillard reaction presented a new challenge to analytical chemists. This was due to the incredibly low flavour thresholds exhibited by some of the important character impact compounds in foods such as meat and bread and beverages such as coffee – the techniques available then were not sufficiently sensitive to detect then. It was also because many of the flavouring substances involved contained sulphur and early methods of extraction and analysis were notorious for degrading these compounds. The discovery of compounds of importance in cooked foods was facilitated through the study of model reaction systems where flavour precursors such as reducing sugars and amino acids were reacted to form concentrated mixtures containing higher levels of the flavouring substances than in the cooked foods. The compounds now recognised as being of importance to meat flavour (Fig. 2.4) were reported in a model system (Evers et al., 1976) in which thiamine hydrochloride, cysteine hydrochloride and a hydrolysed vegetable protein were reacted together. Among the compounds formed was a thiol, 2-methyl-3-furanthiol (XIX) and its related disulphide (XX), which had been patented by the author prior to the publication (Evers, 1970). The compounds were subsequently found in other model systems such as the reaction between 4-hydroxy-5-methyl-3(2H)-furanone and hydrogen sulphide (van den Ouweland and Peer, 1975), the reaction of cysteine and ribose (Farmer and Mottram, 1990), the heat degradation of thiamine (van der Linde et al., 1979) and in a model system containing cysteine, thiamine, glutamate and ascorbic acid (Werkhoff et al., 1990). It was
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation SH
O (XIX)
S
SMe
S
O
O (XX)
19
O (XXI)
Fig. 2.4 Character impact compounds of meat flavour.
not until 1986 that 2-methyl-3-(methylthio)furan (XXI) was found in cooked beef (MacLeod and Ames, 1986) and shortly after that when 2-methyl-3furan thiol (XIX) was identified along with its corresponding disulphide, bis-(2-methyl-3-furyl) disulphide (XX), as the major contributors to the aroma of cooked beef, chicken and pork (Gasser and Grosch, 1988). This latter compound is reported to possess a rich aged-beef, prime rib aroma (Rowe, 2000) and this, and the other furan thiols, play an important role as the character impact compounds of meat flavour. Since then, many related sulphur-substituted furans and thiophenes have been discovered in the volatiles of cooked meat (Mottram, 1998). Without the knowledge gained through the study of model systems, it would have taken considerably longer to identify the character impact compounds of many cooked and baked foods.
2.2.5 High-impact flavouring substances – threshold values The compound bis-(2-methyl-3-furyl) disulphide found in beef has one of the lowest threshold levels ever detected. It has been measured at 0.00002 ppb in water or, translating this to a time scale, is approximately equivalent to 1 second in 1.6 million years. Grapefruit mercaptan discovered in the fruit in 1982 also has an incredibly low threshold. Its two enantiomers, (S)-(−)-1-p-menthen-8-thiol (XXII) and (R)-(+)-1-p-menthen8-thiol (XXIII), have thresholds of 0.00008 ppb and 0.00002 ppb respectively (Lehmann et al., 1995) and the (S)-(−) enantiomer possesses a more fruity and less sulphury flavour profile, demonstrating how the human olfactory epithelium can distinguish between chiral compounds even at ppb levels (Fig. 2.5). One can postulate that this interaction between a flavouring substance in a fruit and the human olfactory epithelium may have had a purpose – that natural selection has resulted in a plant in which a flavouring substance, 1-p-menthen-8-thiol, had been selected because it is attractive to fruit-eating primates. Is it at all possible, as it is with other species, that a symbiotic relationship existed between early hominids and the plants they consumed; the plant deriving the benefit of successful propagation and the primate a source of nutrients and an enjoyable and an attractive flavour? Have some of the flavour chemicals that we most enjoy been designed by plants for us and is this one of the reasons why we smell what we smell?
20
Modifying flavour in food
SH
SH
(XXII)
Fig. 2.5
(XXIII)
Enantiomers of 1-p-menthen-8-thiol.
OH
O (XXIV)
O
Fig. 2.6 Maple furanone.
That would infer that some flavouring substances, possibly low threshold compounds and character impact compounds, have had a special role to play in human evolution. The lowest odour threshold ever recorded is associated with the flavouring substance 5-ethyl-3-hydroxy-4-methyl-2(5H)-furanone (XXIV), also called ‘maple furanone’ (Fig. 2.6), which has a maple and caramel aroma with a sweet, burnt, caramel taste and a threshold in water of 0.00001 ppb. This compound was first identified in soy sauce where it makes an important flavour contribution and interestingly has recently been found in raspberry (Klesk et al., 2004).
2.2.6 The discovery of new flavouring substances There are many flavouring substances in food products that have not yet been discovered. Flavour scientists have concentrated their attention on identifying the flavour chemicals in the most commercially important food products such as meat, coffee, fruits, etc., and many foods have not been subjected to the rigors of analysis. Cheese, for example, has been extensively studied but roasted cheese used as a topping on products such as pizza and lasagne or cheese used in sauces has received very little attention. Another example is duck, which is consumed worldwide and is a major source of protein in China but is not one of the 680 food sources listed in the VCF and hence no flavour chemicals for this important meat have been recorded. Food products such as meat, fish, vegetables and spices, are cooked as blends to create dishes such as stews, soups, burgers and casseroles, and the
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
N
N
(XXV)
21
N
(XXVI)
(XXVII)
N (XXVIII)
Fig. 2.7
New flavouring substances discovered in roasted spotted shrimp.
many flavour precursors generated by each raw material can interact to produce new flavouring substances that create some of the unique and characteristic flavours of many dishes. A recent study of the flavour volatiles present in a cooked mixture of beef and onion, a relatively common food combination, is a case in point (Dewis and Kendrick, 2002). Two compounds, furfurylpropyldisulphide and 3-(allylthio)propanal, were identified in the cooked mixture that could not be found in either cooked beef or sautéed onion. Another example of a recent discovery of some interesting new flavouring substances is from a study of the volatile compounds of roasted spotted shrimp by workers in Japan (Tachihara et al., 2005). A number of related pyrrolidine compounds were found (Fig. 2.7, XXV–XXVII), which possessed both roasted seafood and seafood flavour character. When the two stereoisomers of N-(2-methylbutyl)pyrrolidine (XXVI) were synthesised and evaluated, they demonstrated a chiral flavour effect where one had a roasted seafood aroma and the other a seafood aroma. The same study also found a range of new butylidine compounds such as 2-methyl-N-(2methylbutylidine)butan-1-amine (XXVIII) possessing dried seafood flavour characters. A recent paper from Firmenich reported the discovery of two new monoterpenes in honey (Fig. 2.8): 4-isopropenylcyclohexa-1,3-diene-1-carboxylic acid (XXIX) and 4-(hydroxyl-1-methylethyl)cyclohexa-1,3-diene-1-carboxylic acid (XXX) (Naef et al., 2005). Roasted shrimp and honey have received relatively little attention from flavour chemists and these discoveries demonstrate that there are many interesting and potentially commercial flavouring substances yet to be found. It is also quite extraordinary that, after over a hundred years of detailed and extensive research into the monoterpenes, that two new compounds from these genera have been recently discovered.
22
Modifying flavour in food
Fig. 2.8
COOH
COOH
(XXIX)
OH (XXX)
New flavouring substances discovered in linden honey.
2.2.7 The classification of flavouring substances Flavouring substances can be classified through their functional groups such as acids, esters, alcohols and aldehydes, but this is relatively meaningless for the flavourist. Attempts have been made to group flavouring substances by their organoleptic properties and a number of flavour companies have developed quite complex systems. Recently, Oxford Chemicals has developed a flavour wheel (Rowe, 2002) for high-impact flavouring substances (Fig. 2.9). The criteria set for qualification of a flavouring substance for inclusion on the wheel are: • Low odour threshold: <10 ppb. • Character impact: the flavouring substance has a recognisable character. The character also needs to be a desirable one at the level of use – many chemicals have powerful aromas but would not be used as flavouring substances. • Available to the flavourist: the flavouring substance is permitted, is stable and is economically viable. The compounds on the wheel are potent flavouring substances used by the industry in compounding commercial flavourings. Examples of high-impact flavouring substances for each organoleptic sector of the wheel are depicted as their chemical formulae in Fig. 2.9. Clockwise around the wheel from ‘mushroom’ to ‘vegetable’, the materials are formed by biogenesis in plants and the remaining nine sectors, from ‘nutty’ to ‘rancid and cheesy’, are formed in the Maillard reaction during the cooking of foods or in fermentation processes. Combinations of different sectors can be used to create a flavour. For example, coffee flavour can be formulated by combinations of burnt/roasted, smoky, caramel, nutty, blackcurrant/cassis, earthy/mushroom and beefy.
2.2.8 Flavour delivery systems Liquid blends of flavouring substances are dispersed in solvent carriers but the number available is quite limited and includes ethanol, propylene glycol,
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation Green, grassy
Onion N
Garlic
Herbaceous
S
Spicy
S
S
Truffle
S
S
S
O
S
Mushroom, earthy
CH3
HO
S
S S
23
O
O
CH3
Fruity, ester-like
O
SH
Rancid, cheesy
O S
S
CH3 H
Tropical
SH O
Fatty
O
O
SH
Blackcurrant, cassis
CH3 S
Savoury, bouillon
O
CH3 S
OH N
S
Pork, OH lamb, chicken
O
SH S
O
Beefy
O
S
Burnt, roasted
Fig. 2.9
Vegetable
N
OH OCH3
Nutty
O
Caramel Smoky
A flavour wheel for high impact chemicals (reproduced by kind permission of Oxford Chemicals, Hartlepool, UK).
glycerol, isopropyl alcohol (IPA), diacetin, triacetin, triethyl citrate and medium chain triglycerides (MCT). Internationally, the number is reduced for technical and cultural reasons; ethanol is not permitted in Muslim countries, glycerol is a poor solvent, IPA is banned in the EU and the United States and diacetin and triacetin are easily hydrolysed. This leaves propylene glycol and MCT as the universally accepted flavouring solvents. Powder flavours are mainly produced by spray drying and the carriers in greatest use are the maltodextrins and gum arabic or combinations of both. In combination with a maltodextrin, gum arabic performs the function of an encapsulating agent and the flavour is locked into the dried particle until it is added to water, when flavour release is instant. The flavour industry has invested considerably in the development of encapsulating agents, which not only lock-in and protect the flavour but can
24
Modifying flavour in food
also be used to control the delivery of the flavour into a food matrix. The main encapsulating technologies used by the industry are: •
•
•
• •
Spray cooling: a variation of spray drying in which ambient or chilled air is used to solidify a molten drop (usually a fat) containing a flavour. Coacervation: encapsulation in a protein, usually gelatin, by precipitating the protein in the presence of a flavour at the isoelectric point of the protein. Melt extrusion: converts a liquid flavouring into a durable, free-flowing amorphous glassy particulate through extrusion of the flavouring with a carrier – usually a sugar. Molecular encapsulation: formation of inclusion complexes between a flavouring substance and β-cyclodextrin. Yeast encapsulation: the technology involves trapping a flavouring inside the walls of a yeast cell.
For more information on encapsulation and delivery systems, the reader is referred to Baines and Knights (2005).
2.2.9 Creating flavours The creative skills of the flavourist take many years to hone and the creation of new flavours is one that is surrounded in mystery. ‘Putting nature back together’ is a skill that is more complex now than it was 50 years ago because of the increased number of raw materials available. Flavourists have to familiarise themselves with an enormous number of flavouring substances, understand their flavour profiles at different concentrations and their chemical and sensory interactions with other flavour substances, flavour carriers and other ingredients used in flavourings. It not only requires experience, judgement, flair and intuition but an extra spark of creativity to produce commercially successful flavours. Very little has been written about the training of flavourists but the reader is directed to Wright (2004), a book that gives a comprehensive coverage of this subject. As well as creating flavours, the flavourist is involved with matching flavours. The analytical technology used to discover the flavouring substances in foods can also be used to analyse the flavouring substances in a competitor’s flavours and the mass spectrometers of the flavour industry are being used more and more for this purpose. The cost of the technology is now within the grasp of the smallest of flavour companies; matching has become standard practice in the industry and is eroding flavour margins and profitability. The industry has moved from the heady days of high-quality, almost ivory tower, flavour research to an industry driven by matching and this is reducing the potential for flavour companies to indulge in the type of flavour research that was so productive in the latter part of the twentieth century.
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
2.3
25
Flavouring substances legislation
2.3.1 European legislation Flavour substances have been regulated in the European Union since the late 1980s (EC, 1988) by a negative list system in which restrictions have been placed upon certain flavouring substances that have been found to be deleterious to health. The list is small, containing 12 substances, and the industry has been free to use all other flavouring substances in the food supply. In addition to flavouring substances, the Directive also covers flavouring preparations, process flavourings, smoke flavourings and mixtures of these flavour groups. Flavours Directive 88/388/EEC (EC, 1988) defines a flavouring substance as ‘a defined chemical substance with flavouring properties’, which is obtained: (i)
by appropriate physical processes (including distillation and solvent extraction) or enzymatic or microbiological processes from material of vegetable or animal origin either in the raw state or after processing for human consumption by traditional food-preparation processes (including drying, torrefaction and fermentation). (ii) by chemical synthesis or isolated by chemical processes and which is chemically identical to a substance naturally present in material of vegetable or animal origin described in (i), (iii) by chemical synthesis but which is not chemically identical to a substance naturally present in material of vegetable or animal origin as described in (i).
The legislation has set the tone for the supply of flavourings in Europe for almost two decades and the industry has been providing natural, nature identical and artificial flavours for use in the food supply based around the definitions above. Hence flavourings containing flavouring substances exclusively from category (i) are referred to as ‘natural’. Flavourings containing one or more flavouring substances from category (ii) and no substances from category (iii) are classed as ‘nature identical’ and flavourings containing one or more flavouring substances from category (iii) are artificial. Natural flavourings in Europe have been produced from category (i) flavouring substances and from flavouring preparations or combinations of both. Flavouring preparations are produced from natural food sources, examples are: essential oils, oleoresins, solvent extracts and even concentrated fruit juices used for their flavouring properties. This legislative system has been very open and has given impetus to research with the result that flavour companies have been actively searching for new flavouring substances in foods, which they have been free to use in confidence without disclosure or the need for regulatory authorisation. This has had considerable commercial benefits for the companies investing in research and making the discoveries and, for a period of time, especially between the 1970s and 1990s, companies were competing to find and use
26
Modifying flavour in food
new nature identical compounds to establish market position. Consequently, Europe led the way in the search for new flavouring substances and this resulted in significant improvements in the quality and authenticity of flavourings being supplied to the food industry and, thus, of benefit to the consumer.
2.3.2 The Flavouring Substances Register Incorporated into Council Directive 88/388/EC is the provision to lay down a list of flavouring substances which may be used in or on foodstuffs. The process was initiated in 1996 (EC, 1996) and subsequent Commission Decisions (EC, 1999, 2000, 2002a, b, 2005, 2006a) with the objective of establishing a list of flavouring substances ‘the use of which is authorised to the exclusion of all others’. This, in effect, changes the regulation of flavouring substances in the EU from a negative list system to a positive list system. The flavour industry in Europe, through the European Flavours and Fragrances Association, was mandated to provide a list of flavouring substances in use in the EU to the European Commission and this list has been compiled into the Flavouring Substances Register and contains approximately 2650 discrete flavour chemicals. The list is currently being evaluated by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). Its remit is to consider the safety in use of each flavouring substance and to establish that they present no risk to the health of the consumer. To undertake this enormous task, a group-based approach has been adopted and the register has been divided into 34 groups of substances of structurally related compounds which are expected to show some metabolic and biological behaviour in common. The groups adopted are listed in Table 2.1 and their complexity underlines the difficulties in attempting to classify flavouring substances. The information considered essential for the evaluation of each flavouring substance includes its purity, chemical specification, natural occurrence in food, total amount added to foods and results of toxicological and metabolic studies. The evaluation process should be completed by the end of 2008 when the register will be published and, at some stage after that, will become a binding positive list on the industry. As the list is evaluated, substances that do not meet the safety criteria set by the EFSA are deleted from the register or restrictions are placed on their usage. To date, the substances that have been deleted on safety grounds are methyleugenol, estragole, capsaicin and pentan-2,4-dione.
2.3.3 New flavouring substances Special provisions were requested by industry for the evaluation of new ‘confidential’ flavouring substances. It had been recognised that a number of flavour companies invest considerable resources in research to identify
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
27
Table 2.1 Chemical groups for flavouring substances in the EU Group 1
Straight chain primary aliphatic alcohols/aldehydes/acids, acetals and esters with esters containing saturated alcohols and acetals containing saturated aldehydes. No aromatic or heteroaromatic moiety as a component of an ester or acetal.
Group 2
Branched-chain primary aliphatic alcohols/aldehydes/acids, acetals and esters with esters containing branched-chain alcohols and acetals containing branched-chain aldehydes. No aromatic or heteroaromatic moiety as a component of an ester or acetal.
Group 3
α,β-Unsaturated (alkene or alkyne) straight-chain and branchedchain aliphatic primary alcohols/aldehydes/acids, acetals and esters with esters containing α,β-unsaturated alcohols and acetals containing α,β-unsaturated alcohols or aldehydes. No aromatic or heteroaromatic moiety as a component of an ester or acetal.
Group 4
Non-conjugated and accumulated unsaturated straight-chain and branched-chain aliphatic primary alcohols/aldehydes/acids, acetals and esters with esters containing unsaturated alcohols and acetals containing unsaturated alcohols or aldehydes. No aromatic or heteroaromatic moiety as a component of an ester or acetal.
Group 5
Saturated and unsaturated aliphatic secondary alcohols/aldehydes/ acids, acetals and esters with esters containing secondary alcohols. No aromatic or heteroaromatic moiety as a component of an ester or acetal.
Group 6
Aliphatic, alicyclic and aromatic saturated and unsaturated tertiary alcohols and esters with esters containing tertiary alcohols. Esters may contain any acid component.
Group 7
Primary alicyclic saturated and unsaturated alcohols/aldehydes/acids, acetals/esters with esters containing alicyclic alcohols. Esters/acetals may contain aliphatic acyclic or alicyclic acids or alcohol component.
Group 8
Secondary alicyclic saturated and unsaturated alcohols/ketones/ ketals/esters with ketals containing alicylic alcohols or ketones and esters containing secondaryalicylic alcohols. Ester may contain aliphatic acyclic or alicyclic acid components.
Group 9
Primary aliphatic saturated and unsaturated alcohols/aldehydes/acids, acetals/esters with a second primary, secondary or tertiary oxygenated functional group including aliphatic lactones.
Group 10
Secondary aliphatic saturated and unsaturated alcohols/ketones/ ketals/esters with a second secondary or tertiary oxygenated functional group.
Group 11
Alicyclic and aromatic lactones.
Group 12
Maltol derivatives and ketodioxane derivatives.
Group 13
Furanones and tetrahydrofurfuryl derivatives.
Group 14
Furfuryl and furan derivatives with and without additional side-chain substituents and heteroatoms.
Group 15
Phenylethyl alcohols, phenylacetic acids, related esters, phenoxyacetic acids and related esters. (Continued)
28
Modifying flavour in food
Table 2.1
Continued
Group 16
Aliphatic and alicyclic ethers.
Group 17
Propenylhydroxybenzenes.
Group 18
Allylhydroxybenzenes.
Group 19
Capsaicin-related substances and related amides.
Group 20
Aliphatic and aromatic mono- and di-thiols and mono- and di-, triand polysulphides with or without additional oxygenated functional groups.
Group 21
Aromatic ketones, secondary alcohols and related esters.
Group 22
Aryl-substituted primary alcohol/aldehyde/acid/ester/acetal derivatives, including saturated ones.
Group 23
Benzyl alcohols/aldehydes/acids/esters/acetals. Benzyl and benzoate esters included. May also contain aliphatic acyclic or alicyclic ester or acetal component.
Group 24
Pyrazine derivatives.
Group 25
Phenol derivatives containing ring-alkyl, ring alkoxy and side-chains with an oxygenated functional group.
Group 26
Aromatic ethers including anisole derivatives.
Group 27
Anthranilate derivatives.
Group 28
Pyridine, pyrrole and quinoline derivatives.
Group 29
Thiazoles, thiophene, thiazoline and thienyl derivatives.
Group 30
Miscellaneous substances.
Group 31
Aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons.
Group 32
Epoxides.
Group 33
Aliphatic and aromatic amines.
Group 34
Amino acids.
new flavour chemicals in food and disclosure could significantly harm their competitive position. Coupled to this, there is the new requirement to submit a great deal of information about new flavouring substances to the Commission, including toxicology and metabolic studies, which adds further to the cost, and the discovering company does need time to recoup its investment through the sale of flavours containing the new flavouring substance. It was recognised that, without some form of protection, the future of flavour research in Europe could be seriously impaired and an arrangement was made to protect the identities of confidential flavour chemicals for a period of 5 years from the date of submission. Around 100 flavouring substances were placed on this list. However, this decision has been revoked
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
29
and it is proposed that flavour companies will now be required to divulge the identity of any new flavouring substances on submission to the register. Representations are being made to develop a new legislative system to protect intellectual property. 2.3.4 The new European Directive It was recognised by legislators in Brussels, that Council Directive 88/388/ EC (EC, 1988) needed to be substantially amended to take into account technological and scientific developments in flavourings and it will be replaced by a new European Directive (EC, 2006b). The European Commission was aware that large numbers of flavouring substances were being used by the industry without regulatory control. Consequently the Flavouring Substances Register, and their conditions of use, will be annexed to the new Directive which will be called the ‘Food Improvement Agents Directive’ and will contain legislation on flavourings, food additives, enzymes and authorisation procedures. Six categories of flavourings will be included: flavouring substances, flavouring preparations, thermal process flavourings, smoke flavourings, flavour precursors and ‘other flavourings’. The latter is a ‘catch all’ to include all flavourings not covered by the previous categories and new developments in flavours. The definition of flavouring substances will change and the nature identical and artificial categories will disappear. The proposed new wording is: • ‘Flavouring substance’ shall mean a chemically defined substance with flavouring properties. • ‘Natural flavouring substance’ shall mean a flavouring substance obtained by appropriate physical, enzymatic or microbiological processes from material of vegetable, animal or microbiological origin either in the raw state or after processing for human consumption by one or more of the traditional food preparation processes listed in Annex II.
The ‘traditional processes’ defined for the production of natural flavouring substances are outlined in Table 2.2. Three new categories for natural flavourings are proposed in the draft Directive: 1.
The term ‘natural’ may only be used in combination with a reference to a food, food category or a vegetable or animal flavouring source, if at least 90% [by w/w] of the flavouring component has been obtained from the source material referred to.
For example, a raspberry flavour containing 90% of a natural raspberry extract along with flavouring preparations and natural flavouring substances from other sources may be called ‘natural raspberry flavour’.
30
Modifying flavour in food
Table 2.2 List of traditional food preparation processes by which natural flavouring substances and natural flavouring preparations are obtained (Annox II) Chopping Cooking, baking, frying (up to 240 ºC) Cutting Drying Evaporation Fermentation Grinding Infusion Microbiological processes Peeling Pressing Roasting/grilling Steeping
Coating Cooling Distillation/rectification Emulsification Extraction, including solvent extraction Filtration Heating Maceration Mixing Percolation Refrigeration/freezing Squeezing
2. ‘Natural << food(s) or food category or source(s) >> flavouring with other natural flavourings’ may only be used if the flavouring component is partially derived from the source material referred to and can be clearly recognised.
For example, a raspberry flavour containing 60% of a natural raspberry extract along with flavouring preparations and natural flavouring substances from other sources may be called ‘natural raspberry flavour with other natural flavourings’ if it is clearly recognisable as raspberry. 3. The term ‘natural flavouring’ may only be used if the flavouring component is derived from different source materials and where a reference to the source materials would not reflect their flavour or taste.
This category applies to flavours that are well recognised but where their names do not reflect their flavouring components such as barbecue, cola and tutti frutti flavours. The labelling of flavourings in the EU will be limited to ‘flavouring’, ‘smoke flavouring’ and natural flavours as defined above. Smoke flavourings are singled out to control the levels of the carcinogen, 3,4-benzopyrene, and other polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons produced during the pyrolysis of wood in the production of smoke flavourings.
2.3.5 Implications for the flavour industry in Europe The removal of the nature identical and artificial categories of flavouring substances has a number of implications for industry. From a risk assessment perspective, it is irrelevant whether flavouring substances are natural, nature identical or artificial but whether they are safe and this, on the face of it, is an eminently sensible approach to take. However, the consumer sees
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
31
it very differently and regards natural as desirable, familiar, safe, wholesome, etc., a myth that is continuously reinforced by the media, by food advertising, multiple retailers and pressure groups. The consumer does not understand the concept of ‘nature identical’ and, when it is explained, considers it to be artificial. Nature identical has held a pseudo-natural status and operated as a bridge between the undesirable ‘artificial’ and the desirable ‘natural’ and its removal is likely to increase the demand for natural flavourings. Nature identical flavouring substances produced by synthetic techniques will, more and more, be regarded as artificial. This will increase the demand for natural flavouring substances but, considering the current make-up of the flavouring substances register, this will be very difficult to achieve in the short term as the vast majority of flavour chemicals on the register are synthetic nature identicals. Considerable research is being expended to provide natural equivalents of nature identical flavouring substances using extraction processes, distillation techniques, enzyme technology, microbial transformations, fermentation technology, plant cell culture and other biotechnological developments. However, it will be very difficult in the short term, to reproduce, by natural processes, the many hundreds of nature identical flavouring substances that are formed in cooked foods by the Maillard reaction. It is likely therefore that there will be a considerable gap between what the consumer and the food industry want in terms of natural flavours and what the flavour industry can provide. In the short term, it is anticipated that this gap will be filled by natural flavourings produced as flavouring preparations but these are considerably weaker in flavour strength than flavourings produced by blends of flavouring substances and this will have a distinct bearing on quality and cost. There will also be implications on the costs of flavours because flavouring substances produced by processes deemed to be natural, are considerably more expensive than their synthetic counterparts and these costs will be eventually borne by the consumer. It will also be impossible, in some cases, to cost-effectively produce natural equivalents of synthetic flavouring substances. Another implication of the removal of the nature identical and artificial status is that the consumer deception of the phrase ‘contains no artificial flavours’, used by some food companies in their advertising, will no longer be able to be used to mislead the consumer into imagining that the flavour used is natural. One very contentious aspect of the new legislation is a requirement on industry to report to the Commission the annual amounts of flavouring substances added to foods in the EU and the usage level for each food category in the EU. Member States are additionally required to establish systems to monitor the consumption and use of flavourings and flavouring substances and report them to the Commission and EFSA each year. While it is appreciated that the motivation for these controls is to monitor food safety and the Commission and EFSA should have knowledge about flavour
32
Modifying flavour in food
usage in Europe, the measures they are proposing place an enormous burden on the industry and are considered neither practical nor appropriate. The flavour manufacturer will have to divulge details about his or her formulation to the customer and the food manufacturer will have to divulge usage levels to the supplier. This dissemination of proprietary commercial information is likely to have severe economic consequences and is a prime example of how over-zealous legislation can interfere with normal business activities. The major impact of the Directive, however, on the flavour industry is the move to a positive list system and the rejection of an industry request for a 5 year moratorium on the disclosure of new flavouring substances. This is likely to have a detrimental effect on research and the discovery of new flavouring substances by companies in Europe, and European industry will most probably lose its leading position in the global flavourings market.
2.3.6 Flavouring substances legislation in the United States The United States has been using a positive list system for flavouring substances since 1965 when the first FEMA GRAS list was published in response to the Food Additives Amendment (US, 1958). FEMA is the US Flavor and Extract Manufacturers Association and GRAS substances are ‘generally recognised as safe’ under conditions of intended use following evaluation by an independent panel of experts and, as such, are exempt from the definition of food additives. The FEMA expert panel, known as FEXPAN, consists of ‘experts qualified by scientific training and experience to evaluate the safety of flavouring ingredients’ and includes toxicologists, pharmacologists and biochemists. For most of the lifetime of the GRAS programme, they have concentrated on the evaluation and re-evaluation of 1900 chemically identified flavouring substances but their brief has been widened to cover natural flavouring complexes such as essential oils and oleoresins and chemical substances with non-flavour functions used in the compounding of flavourings such as antioxidants, emulsifiers and flavour modifiers. A series of GRAS reports have been produced since 1965 and the most recent, number 22 (Smith et al., 2005), added a further 185 flavouring substances bringing the FEMA GRAS list to just below 2100. Many of the additions to the FEMA GRAS list were as a direct result of European food analytical research which, with the new EU regime, will not be economically viable. Nature identical is not a term that is recognised in the United States, where all synthetic flavouring substances, whether they have been found in a natural product or not, are regarded as artificial and labelled as such. Flavours containing a mixture of natural and artificial flavouring substances are labelled as natural and artificial depending on the relative quantities and natural flavourings fall into three categories (Knights, 2002):
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
33
• FTNF: ‘From the named fruit’, which includes extracts, distillates and condensates derived exclusively from the named fruit and can include flavouring substances providing that they are also derived from the named fruit. Flavours from this category tend to be weak and expensive but are in increasing demand. • WONF: ‘With other natural flavourings’. Flavours in this category must contain 51% of the flavour from the named source but can also contain other natural materials and natural flavouring substances, • Natural Flavour: Flavours that contain all natural ingredients and/or flavouring substances but the source is not defined.
Unlike Europe, the United States is well advanced in the evaluation and approval of flavouring substances and the FEMA GRAS list provides quite comprehensive information on the use of flavouring substances in various food products. However, the regulation of flavouring substances has restricted research into the identification of new flavouring substances in the United States, which has been moving forward at pace whereas in Europe positive list regulation is a recent phenomenon. The approval of new flavouring substances onto the FEMA GRAS list has been streamlined and is efficient compared to the cumbersome system being evolved in the EU. However, it is anticipated that the positive list systems adopted in the United States and the EU will stimulate research into the identification of new flavouring substances in India and China where the results of research are not so hamstrung by bureaucracy. This will be driven by the enormous emerging markets for flavourings in South East Asia where the regulatory control of flavourings has not evolved to any extent.
2.3.7 Flavour substances legislation in Japan Japan operates a positive list system for flavouring substances under the auspices of the Food Sanitation Law No. 233 (Japan, 2004a). Flavouring substances are listed in the Specifications and Standards section (Japan, 2004b) and it is surprisingly large, containing over 2600 discrete flavour chemicals and new compounds are being frequently added. The list is subdivided into 18 structural groupings: aliphatic higher alcohols, aliphatic higher aldehydes, aliphatic higher hydrocarbons, aromatic alcohols, aromatic aldehydes, esters, ethers, fatty acids, furfural and its derivatives, indole and its derivatives, isothiocyanates, ketones, lactones, phenols, phenol ethers, terpene hydrocarbons, thioethers and thiols. The list can be quite confusing because some of the flavouring substances are listed under their chemical names and others under their trivial names, such as raspberry ketone, and a number of flavouring substances that are in international use, such as the alkyl pyrazines, were not included until quite recently because they did not fit into any of the structural groups. Limiting aliphatic alcohols and aldehydes to ‘higher’ also excluded common flavour chemicals such as acetaldehyde and isoamyl alcohol but these omissions have now been rectified as
34
Modifying flavour in food
a result of an effort by the International Organisation of the Flavour Industry (IOFI) Science Board to achieve acceptance in Japan of substances that are used internationally. Chemicals ‘generally regarded as highly toxic’ are excluded from the Japanese structural groups and there is no distinction between nature identical and artificial but there is a definition of natural (Japan, 2000b): ‘Natural flavouring agent means additives intended for use for flavouring food which are substances obtained from animals or plants or mixtures thereof’.
2.3.8 Flavour substances legislation in Australasia In 2002, Australia and New Zealand developed the Food Standards Code (FSANZ, 2002a) which is a joint set of food labelling and composition rules for the two countries to allow free trade without technical obstruction. A user guide (FSANZ, 2002b) has also been published, providing information on the regulation of flavourings and flavour enhancers. The two countries now operate a ‘mixed list’ system where both natural and nature identical flavouring substances are recognised and are controlled by a negative list system, i.e. they can be used unless specifically regulated, and artificial flavouring substances are controlled by positive list system, i.e. they can only be used if they are on the positive list. The Flavour and Fragrance Association of Australia and New Zealand has compiled a list of 381 artificial flavouring substances and this is appended to the user guidelines. The definitions of the three groups of flavouring substances used are (FSANZ, 2002a): • Natural flavouring substances means flavouring substances obtained from plant or animal raw materials by physical, microbiological or enzymatic processes. They can be either used in their natural state or processed for human consumption but cannot contain any nature-identical or artificial flavouring substances. • Nature identical flavouring substances means flavouring substances that are obtained by synthesis or isolated through chemical processes which are chemically identical to flavouring substances naturally present in products intended for human consumption. They cannot contain any artificial flavouring substances. • Artificial flavouring substances means flavouring substances not identified in a natural product intended for human consumption, whether or not the product is processed.
Food products containing flavourings are labelled with the words ‘flavouring’ or ‘flavour’ or with a specific name or description of the flavouring. The artificial flavouring substance, ethyl maltol can be labelled either as a ‘flavour enhancer’ or as a ‘flavouring’ depending on the function it is judged to be performing in the food. This regulatory system bears some resemblance to the existing European legislation and the ‘mixed list’ system which operated in Germany prior to 1988.
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
35
2.3.9 Flavour substances legislation in South America A new technical regulation (MERCOSUR, 2006) on flavouring additives was adopted in June 2006 by Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay. The harmonisation of the technical regulations on flavours is aimed at eliminating barriers to trade created between prevailing national regulations. Under the new regulations flavourings are defined as natural and synthetic, and flavouring substances fall into the following categories with synthetic flavouring substances being further subdivided into nature identical and artificial (MERCOSUR, 2006): • Natural flavouring substance are chemically defined substances obtained by physical, microbiological or enzymatic processes from natural aromatic raw materials or from natural flavourings. • Synthetic flavouring substances are chemically defined compounds obtained by chemical processes and include: 1. Nature identical flavouring substances; chemically defined substances obtained by synthesis and/or isolated by chemical processes from raw materials of animal, vegetable or microbial origin, which present a chemical structure identical to the substances present in the reference natural materials (either processed or not). 2. Artificial flavouring substances; chemical substances obtained by synthesis, as yet not identified in products of animal, vegetable or microbial origin, when used in their primary state or after preparation for human consumption.
This new regulation and the new regulations in Australasia recognise the category of ‘nature identical’ whereas in the northern hemisphere the US regulations, the new EU Directive and the Japanese regulations no longer recognise this term. This new regulation in South America also introduces the concept of ‘synthetic’ flavourings into legislation, a term that is not likely to be very consumer friendly. Elsewhere in the world, extensive use is made of the FEMA GRAS list as a means to control the supply of flavours, to ensure food safety and protect commercial interests. Countries that have just entered, or are seeking entry, into the EU are adopting the EU system.
2.3.10 Global harmonisation of flavouring legislation Flavour legislation is failing to keep pace with the acceleration of globalisation in the food supply. The above sections demonstrate that where flavour legislation has developed there are significant differences between the regulatory systems in the control of flavouring substances which could impede global trade. Some inroads are being made by IOFI to counter this and it is important that where positive lists exist there is coordination to ensure that they correlate with each other. Better still would be the adoption of a global system to harmonise the control of flavourings and the systems are there to achieve this through
36
Modifying flavour in food
Table 2.3 Summary of evaluations performed by the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives on 4-(p-hydroxyphenyl)-2-butanone COE No.: FEMA No.: JECFA No.: Chemical names: Synonyms: Functional class: Latest evaluation: ADI: Comments: Report: Specifications: Tox monograph:
755 2588 728 4-(4-Hydroxyphenyl)butan-2-one p-Hydroxybenzylacetone; 1-p-hydroxyphenyl-3-butanone; raspberry ketone; rastone; oxyphenylon; oxanone Flavouring agent 2000 Acceptable No safety concern at current levels of intake when used as a flavouring agent TRS 901-JECFA 55/44 Compendium addendum 8/FNP 52 Add.8/172 FAS 46-JECFA 55/165
JECFA, the Joint Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations/ World Health Organization Expert Committee on Food Additives, the Codex Alimentarius Commission (CAC) and the World Trade Organization (WTO). JECFA serves as the scientific advisory body to the CAC on all matters relating to food additives and Codex standards carry legal significance with all countries signed up to the WTO Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures (WTO/GATT, 1994). The SPS agreement encourages nations to develop regulatory controls based around the international standards developed by CAC and those that differ from the Codex standards may be challenged as trade barriers. JECFA was formed in 1956 and since then has evaluated over 1750 flavouring substances. It has made recommendations on their safe level of use by elaborating specifications for their identity and purity and by evaluating toxicological data and estimating acceptable intakes for humans. The evaluation status of each flavouring substance is reported in a format as shown for raspberry ketone in Table 2.3. Codex has not yet considered the regulation of flavourings in the draft General Standard for Food Additives but this may not be appropriate as many countries regard flavourings as exempt from food additive status. A separate Codex standard for flavourings utilising the evaluation work of JECFA, and drawing from the experience of FEXPAN and EFSA, could form the basis of a globally harmonised regulatory system.
2.4
Conclusions
Approximately one-third of all volatile organic chemicals found in food are useful as flavouring substances and these have made significant improvements to the quality of the global food supply. Most of these flavouring substances are synthetic ‘nature identical’ flavour chemicals and there will
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
37
be a growing need to develop natural equivalents through biotechnology and by isolation from natural source materials as the consumer demand for natural flavourings increases. Consumers will require more information about what is added to food, including flavourings, and the industry should be ready to supply this in a balanced and informed manner. The consumer desire for new flavour sensations and new eating experiences will continue unabated and the sales of flavourings will increase accordingly, as they have done since the flavour industry began. New opportunities will be created for flavour companies as food manufacturers expand worldwide, adopting core supplier policies and trading with flavour companies with global capabilities. To meet the challenge, flavour companies will have to be highly innovative, offering a wide portfolio of added value flavouring solutions and excellence in customer service. Legislation will need to catch up with the process of globalisation, by the adoption of an international system to harmonise the regulation of flavourings and facilitate free trade and this can be achieved through JECFA, Codex and the WTO, supported by IOFI. However, positive list legislation will inhibit research into the discovery of new flavouring substances in the West, especially the regulatory system being developed in the EU. More efficient and less costly procedures, which still take into account public safety, should be adopted for the approval of new flavouring substances. It is also envisaged that research into the discovery of new flavouring substances will find a home in South East Asia where the regulatory control of flavourings has not developed to any extent and where large emerging markets and new centres of technical excellence will stimulate research into culturally important foods. The flavouring substances in use, numbering around 2700, represent the chemicals that are important in the food we eat and some have played a key role in the survival of our species. The knowledge, understanding and use of these flavouring substances is therefore of great importance to mankind for the supply of palatable foods in a world of increasing population growth, climate change and the consequential pressures that this will place on the food supply.
2.5
Acknowledgement
The author would like to thank Jack Knights, Northampton, UK, for his valuable advice in reviewing this chapter.
2.6
References
acree, t. e. (1993), ‘Gas chromatography – olfactometry’, in Ho C T and Manley C H, Flavour Measurement, New York, Marcel Dekher, 77–94.
38
Modifying flavour in food
arctander, s. (2000), Perfume and Flavour Chemicals, Caral Stream, IL, Auured Publishing Corp. baines, d. and knights, j. (2005), ‘Applications I: Flavors’, in Rowe J D Chemistry and Technology of Flavors and Fragrances, Oxford, Blackwell, 274–304. bell, g. a. and watson, a. j. (1999), Tastes and Aromas: The Chemical Senses in Science and Industry, Sydney, UNSW. berlardi, r. and pawliszyn, j. (1989), ‘The application of chemically modified fused silica fibers in the extraction of organics from water matrix samples and their rapid transfer to capillary columns’, Water Pollution Res J Canada, 24 (1), 179–191. buck, l. and axel, r. (1991), ‘A novel multigene family may encode odorant receptors: a molecular basis for odor recognition’, Cell, 65 (1), 175–187. dewis, m. l. (2005), ‘Molecules of taste and sensation’, in Rowe J D Chemistry and Technology of Flavors and Fragrances, Oxford, Blackwell, 199–243. dewis, m. l. and kendrick, l. (2002), ‘Creation of flavors and the synthesis of raw materials inspired by nature’, in Swift K A D, Advances in Flavours and Fragrances, Cambridge, Royal Society of Chemistry, 147–160. ec (1988), Council Directive 88/388/EEC on the approximation of the laws of the Member States relating to flavourings for use in foodstuffs and to source materials for their production, Off J European Communities, L184, 61. ec (1996), Council Regulation (EC) No. 2232/96 laying down a Community procedure for flavouring substances used or intended for use in or on foodstuffs, Off J European Communities, L299, 1. ec (1999), Commission Decision 1999/217/EC of 23 February 1999 adopting a register of flavouring substances used in or on foodstuffs drawn up in application of Regulation (EC) No. 2232/96 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 28 October 1996, Off J European Communities, L84, 1. ec (2000), Commission Decision 2000/489/EC of 18 July 2000, Off J European Communities, L197, 53. ec (2002a), Commission Decision 2002/113/EC of 23 January 2002, Off J European Communities, L49, 1. ec (2002b), Commission Decision 2004/357/EC of 7 April 2004, Off J European Communities, L113, 28. ec (2005), Commission Decision 2005/389/EC of 18 May 2005, Off J European Communities, L128, 73. ec (2006a), Commission Decision 2006/252/EC of 27 March 2006, Off J European Communities, L91, 48. ec (2006b), Regulation No. 2006/0147 (COD), COM(2006)0427 on flavourings and certain food ingredients with flavouring properties for use in and on foods and amending Council Regulation (EEC) No. 1576/89, Council Regulation (EEC) No. 1601/91, Regulation (EC) No. 2232/96 and Directive 2000/13/EC. engel, w., bahr, w. and schieberle, p. (1999), ‘Solvent assisted flavour evaporation – a new and versatile technique for the careful and direct isolation of aroma compounds from complex food matrices’, Eur Food Res Tech, 209 (3/4), 237–241. evers, w. j. (1970), Sulphur-containing compounds, a process for their preparation and compositions containing them, GB1256462. evers, w. j., heinsohn, h. h., mayers, b. j. and sanderson, a. (1976), ‘Furans substituted in the three position with sulphur’, in Charalambous G and Katz I, Phenolic, Sulphur and Nitrogen Compounds in Food Flavors, Washington DC, American Chemical Society, 184–193. farmer, l. j. and mottram, d. s. (1990), ‘Recent studies on the formation of meat aroma compounds’, in Bessiere Y and Thomas A F, Flavour Science and Technology, Chichester, Wiley, 113–116.
Flavouring substances: from chemistry and carriers to legislation
39
fsanz (2002a), The Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code, Food Standards Australia New Zealand. fsanz (2002b), The Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code User Guide, Flavourings and Flavour Enhancers, Food Standards Australia New Zealand. gasser, u. and grosch, w. (1988), ‘Identification of volatile flavour compounds with high aroma values from cooked beef’, Z Lebensm Unters Forsch, 186, 489–494. gobley, m. (1858), ‘Recherches sur le principe odorant de la vanilla’, J Pharm Chim, 34 (1), 401–405. helmlinger, d., lamparsky, d., schudel, p. and wild, j. (1972), Bezeichnung: Neue Jonon- und Ironderivate, German Patent 2159924. helmlinger, d., lamparsky, d., schudel, p., sigg-grutter, t. and wild, j. (1975), Novel mercaptoderivatives of ionones and irones, US3883572. japan (2004a), Law no. 233, Chapter 1; Food, Food Additives, Apparatus, and Containers/Packages, Article 12, Food Sanitation Law in Japan (2004). japan (2004b), Specifications and Standards for Foods, Food Additives, etc, Part III, Food Additives, Section 4, Food Additives with Standards of Use, Flavorings, Food Sanitation Law in Japan, 158. karasek, f. w. and clement, r. e. (1988), Basic Gas Chromatography–Mass Spectrometry, London, Elsevier. key, b. (1999), ‘Anatomy of the peripheral chemosensory systems: how they grow and age in humans’, in Bell G A and Watson A J, Tastes and Aromas, Sydney, UNSW, 138–148. klesk, k., qian, m. and martin, r. r. (2004), ‘Aroma extract dilution analysis of cv. Meeker red raspberries from Oregon Washington’, J Agric Food Chem, 52 (16), 5155–5161. knights, j. (2002), ‘Flavour Legislation’, in Taylor, A J, Food Flavour Technology, Sheffield, CRC Press, 276–295. lehmann, d., dietrich, a., hener, u. and mosandl, a. (1995), ‘Stereoisomeric flavour compounds LXX, 1-p-menthene-8-thiol: separation and sensory evaluation of the enantiomers by entioselective gas chromatography/olfactometry’, Phytochem Anal, 6, 255–257. mackay-sim, a. and kittel, p. w. (1991), ‘On the life-span of olfactory receptor neurons’, Eur J Neurosci, 3 (3), 209–215. macleod, g. and ames, j. m. (1986), ‘2-methyl-3-(methylthio)furan: a meaty character impact aroma compound identified from cooked beef’, Chem & Ind, 3 March, 175–177. mercosur (2006), MERCOSUR/GMC/RES No. 10/06, Mercado Común del Sur Technical Regulation Concerning Flavouring Additives. mookherjee, b. d., vock, m. h., benaim, c. and shuster, e. j. (1975), Altering raspberry flavored foodstuffs with 4-(2,6,6-trimethyl-1,3-cyclohexadien-1-yl)-2-butanol and/or 4-(6,6-dimethyl-2-methylene-3-cyclohexen-1-yl)-2-butanol, and/or acetates thereof, US3899597. mottram, d. s. (1998), ‘The chemistry of meat flavour’, in Shahidi F, Flavor of Meat, Meat Products and Seafoods, 2nd Edition, London, Blackie Academic & Professional, 5–26. naef, r., jaquier, a., velluz, a. and bachofen, b. (2005), ‘From the linden flower to the linden honey – volatile constituents of linden nectar, the extract of bee stomach and ripe honey’, in Kraft P and Swift K A D, Perspectives in Flavor and Fragrance Research, Zürich, Wiley-VCH, 31–40. nomura, h. and nozawa, f. (1919), Chem Abs, 13, 118. ohloff, g. and sundt, e. (1973), Utilisation de composes carbonyls soufrés comme agents aromatisants, CH531313.
40
Modifying flavour in food
pittet, a. o., klaiber, e. m., vock, m. h., shuster, e. j. and vinals, j. (1976), Food or flavor containing 2,6,6-trimethyl-1-cyclohexen-1-ylacetaldehyde US3940499. reimer, k. (1876), ‘Ueber eine neue Bildungsweise aromatischer Aldehyde’, Berichte der deutschen chemischen Gesellschaft, 9 (1), 423–424. rowe, d. j. (2000), ‘More fizz for your buck: high-impact aroma chemicals’, Perfumer & Flavourist, 25 (5), 1–19. rowe, d. j. (2002), ‘High impact aroma chemicals’, in Swift K A D, Advances in Flavours and Fragrances, Cambridge, Royal Society of Chemistry, 202–226. sanders, j. m. and vock, m. h. (1975), Foodstuffs containing 2-(4-hydroxy-4methylpentyl) norbornadiene, US3886289. schinz, h. and seidel, c. (1957), ‘Untersuchungen über Aromastoffe 1. Mitteilung. über das Himbeeraroma’, Helv Chim Acta, 40 (6), 1839–1859. smith, r. l., cohen, s. m., doull, j., feron, v. j., goodman, j. i., marnett, l. j., portoghese, p. s., waddell, w. j., wagner, b. m. and adams, t. b. (2005), ‘GRAS flavoring substances 22’, Food Tech, 59 (8), 24–62. stoddart, d. m. (1999), ‘The senses: meeting biological needs’, in Bell G A and Watson A J, Tastes and Aromas, Sydney, UNSW, 1–10. tachihara, t., ishizaki, s., ishikawa, m. and kitahara, t. (2005), ‘Studies on the volatile compounds of roasted spotted shrimp’ in Kraft P and Swift K A D, Perspectives in Flavor and Fragrance Research, Zürich, Wiley-VCH, 197–206. taylor, a. j. and roberts, d. d. (2004), Flavor Perception, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing. tiemann, f. and haarmann, w. (1874), ‘Ueber das Coniferin und seine Umwandlung in das aromatische Princip der Vanille’, Ber, 7 (1), 608–623. tonsbeek, c. h. t., plancken, a. j. and v. d. weerdhof, t. (1968), ‘Components contributing to beef flavour: isolation of 4-hydroxy – 5-methyl-3(2H)furanone and its 2,5-dimethyl homolog from beef broth’, J Agric Food Chem, 16 (6), 1016–1021. ullrich, f. and grosch, w. (1987), ‘Identification of the most intense volatile flavour compounds formed during autoxidation of linoleic acid’, Z Lebensm Unters Forsch, 184 (4), 277–282. van den ouweland, g. a. m. and peer, h. g. (1975), ‘Components contributing to beef flavour. Volatile compounds produced by the reaction of 4-hydroxy-5-methyl3(2H)-furanone and its thio analog with hydrogen sulphide’, J Agric Food Chem, 23 (3), 501–505. van der linde, l. m., van dort, j. m., de valois, p., boelens, h. and de rijke, d. (1979), ‘Volatile compounds from thermally degraded thiamine’, in Land D G and Nursten H E, Progress in Flavor Research, London, Applied Science, 219–224. us (1958), Food Additives Amendment to the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetics Act, Public Law 85–929, 72 Stat 1784. werkhoff, p., bruening, j., emberger, r., guentert, m., koepsel, m., kuhn, w. and surburg, h. (1990), ‘Isolation and characterisation of volatile sulphur-containing meat flavour components in model systems’, J Agric Food Chem, 38 (3), 777–791. willhalm, b., stoll, m. and thomas, a. f. (1965), ‘2,5-Dimethyl-4-hydroxy-2,3 dihydrofuran-3-one’, Chem & Ind, 18 September, 1629–1630. winter, m. (1961), ‘Odeur et constitution XIX. Sur des homologues et analogues de la p-hydroxyphényl-1-butanone-3 (“cétone de framboise”)’, Helv Chim Acta, 44 (7), 2110–2121. wright, j. (2004), Flavor Creation, Carol Stream, IL, Allured Publishing Corporation. wto/gatt (1994), Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures, GATT Doc MTN/FA li-A1A-4, in Final Act Embodying the Results of the Uruguay Round of Multilateral Trade Negotiations, GATT Doc MTN/FA 33 I.L. M. 9.
3 Extraction of flavourings from natural sources G. Cravotto, University of Turin, Italy and P. Cintas, University of Extremadura, Spain
3.1
Introduction
Because food flavourings strongly influence food evaluation and consumer satisfaction, they have always received great attention from the food industry. As far as records can be traced to ancient civilisations, people tried to obtain flavours and perfumes from natural sources by empirical extraction methods. For a long time, plant tissues were the only sources of flavour compounds. Three main difficulties were encountered in isolating these volatile molecules: the compound under consideration may be present in low quantities or in a bound form; the chemical complexity of the source may require elaborate procedures of extraction/purification; and, finally, the natural plant material may be seasonal or not easily available. Natural flavours have simple chemical structures and low toxicities, and are effective at very low concentrations, resulting in very low levels of human exposure or consumption. Naturalness of flavours became an increasingly important requirement for the food market from the mid1980s: nowadays more than 65% of all flavouring ingredients used in Europe and the United States are labelled as natural. This development is putting enormous pressure on the industrial production of natural flavours and stressing its capacity to an extent that can no longer be met by traditional recovery processes. Hence the need to develop new, more efficient extraction methods; biotechnology may also provide new techniques for the microbial and enzymatic production of food flavourings (Dufosse et al., 2002). Commercial enzyme preparations are already being used to improve quality and yield in the processing of fruit juices (Speiser, 1993).
42
Modifying flavour in food Regulation valve
CO2 pressure 90–500 bar
Evaporator
Plant material
40–70 bar Separator -
Extractor
Condenser -
-
CO2 reservoir
Extract (
(
Heater
CO2 pump
Fig. 3.1
3.2
Chiller
Scheme of supercritical CO2 extraction.
General overview
Current techniques of solid – liquid extraction (SLE) are essentially based on diffusion and osmosis. The usual ways to shorten extraction times and improve yields are to increase the temperature of the treatment and/or to repeat it several times with fresh solvent. The simplest and cheapest technique is maceration, where the surface area of a solid matrix is increased and then the material is soaked in a liquid to which it releases its soluble components. As the extraction process is chiefly diffusion controlled, it may take so long that putrefaction sets in before it is completed. At any rate, if local saturation is to be avoided at the matrix surface, stirring must also be used so that diffusion may work more efficiently. In the production of essential oils and, generally, of volatile compounds, steam distillation often proves very useful, although it involves an exposure to heat that may cause degradation of thermally labile molecules. The same drawback affects Soxhlet extraction, the usual preliminary step in the processing of solid samples according to many official methods of analysis. Industrial plants, where large amounts of extract must be produced in a short time, resort to percolation, in which the solvent drips through large cylinders packed with up to several cubic metres of solid matrix. As a single pass would yield but a limited amount of extract, the effluent is enriched by returning it several times to the top of the column. Because efficiency limits are ultimately set by diffusion rates that increase with temperature, the above-mentioned principles can be applied to speed up diffusion, for example by working with hot solvents. A more recent technique (SFE, supercritical fluid extraction) replaces common organic solvents with a gas (e.g. CO2) that, under supercritical conditions, behaves like a non-polar solvent (Fig. 3.1).
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
Fig. 3.2
43
Supercritical CO2 extractors (Burgundy – ARKOPHARMA, France).
At the end of the process the gas is easily removed at low temperatures and extracted materials are recovered in a dry form. Despite the large outlay for apparatus, this method is used in the food and beverage industries (Raventos et al., 2002; Brunner, 2005). Many industrial plants (Fig. 3.2) use it for decaffeinating coffee and tea (Peker et al., 1992), extracting beer flavouring agents from hops or nicotine from tobacco and separating oils or oleoresins from spices (Kerrola, 1995). The use of ultrasound to extract active principles and flavours from plants carries great advantages because it both saves time and improves the quality of extracts (Povey and Mason, 1998; Vinatoru et al., 1999; Toma et al., 2001; Vinatoru, 2001). Since extraction time depends mainly on diffusion rates, ultrasound greatly speeds up the process by breaking cell walls and disrupting tissues. If the matrix has been previously dried, ultrasound accelerates its rehydration and swelling. In the laboratory, one can employ either simple ultrasound baths or the more efficient probe systems. On the industrial scale one can use either large tubs resembling a giant ultrasound bath, with transducers applied underneath, or mechanically stirred
44
Modifying flavour in food
Fig. 3.3
A 400 litre ultrasound-extractor (Martin Bauer Spa, Nichelino, Italy).
cylindrical reactors with transducer plates mounted on the lower part of the wall (Fig. 3.3). Microwave heating of fresh plant material is a simple way to achieve direct distillation of essential oils (Lucchesi et al., 2004) (Fig. 3.4). It also can strongly enhance extractions with organic solvents (Pare et al., 1994). Liquid-phase extraction (often used to isolate essential oils from plants) is based on the different absorbance of microwaves by materials with different dielectric constants. The matrix to be extracted (usually water-rich) is mixed with a solvent having a low dielectric constant, so that most of the heating effect will be concentrated in the plant material. Ganzler et al. (1986) were the first to report that this method had many advantages over conventional techniques for the extraction of natural compounds. Microwave-assisted extraction (MAE) requires less solvent and less time, yielding better products at lower costs. Many flavours have been obtained in this way, e.g. glycosylated flavour precursors from grape juice and grapes (Bureau et al., 1996), rosemary, peppermint and other essential oils (Chen and Spiro, 1994; Collin et al., 1991). All the above-mentioned extraction techniques have also been exploited in various combinations, e.g. mechanical stirring combined with ultrasound or SFE with ultrasound. We studied ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE) and MAE of soybean germ using several sorts of ultrasound apparatus (cup horn, immersion horn, cavitation tube) working at different frequencies (19, 25, 40 and 300 kHz); we also combined two transducers by inserting an immersion horn in the cavitation tube. In a newly developed apparatus, we achieved simultaneous ultrasound and microwave irradiation by inserting a Pyrex horn in the multimode oven (Fig. 3.5). Optimum extraction times were determined and yields were compared with those obtained with MAE (open and closed vessel) and with conventional methods. The best
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
Fig. 3.4
45
Microwave promoted dry-distillation of fresh plants (Milestone Spa, Sorisole – BG, Italy).
oil yield was obtained with the cavitation tube (19 kHz) and with a double sonication (Fig. 3.6) employing an additional immersion horn (25 kHz) (Table 3.1). Compared with conventional extraction methods, much higher yields were achieved with closed-vessel microwave at 120 ºC and with simultaneous ultrasound/microwave irradiation (Fig. 3.5). Extraction times were reduced by up to 10-fold and yields increased by 50–120%. Gas chromatography (GC) analyses showed only slight or negligible differences in the methyl ester profiles of oils extracted under high-intensity ultrasound and those in Soxhlet.
46
Modifying flavour in food
Fig. 3.5
(a)
Reactor for simultaneous ultrasound/microwave irradiation (Prof. Cravotto’s laboratories, University of Turin).
(b)
Fig. 3.6 Double ultrasound irradiation: (a) the titanium horn is inserted in the cavitation tube; (b) top view of the cavitation tube (a hollow titanium cylinder) (Prof. Cravotto’s laboratories, University of Turin).
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
47
Table 3.1 Extraction of soybean germ: optimal extraction times and oil yields as percentage of matrix weight Extraction method
Separation funnel (static) Soxhlet Immersion horn 25.0 kHz, 80 W Immersion horn 40.0 kHz, 80 W Cup horn 300 kHz, 70 W Cavitation tube 19.0 kHz, 80 W Cavitation tube 19.0 kHz, 65 W and immersion horn 25.0 kHz, 60 W Combined ultrasound/ microwave (Pyrex horn) 50 W Microwave open-vessel† Microwave† under pressure
Soybean germ (g)
Solvent* (ml)
Temperature (ºC)
15 15 8
50 100 50
Ambient Reflux 40
8 4 1
3.5 8.6 9.5
8
50
40
1
8.3
8 8
40 50
40 40
1 1
6.4 17.7
8
50
40
0.5
17.9
8
40
40
1
14.1
3 2
40 35
Reflux 120
1 0.5
10.0 16.5
Time (h)
Yield (%)
* Solvent = petroleum ether. † Milestone magnetic stirrer (P/N 86116) and weflon button for apolar solvents (P/N WO1703).
There are several ways to extract essential oils from plants and the molecular composition of the product will depend to some extent on the method used, although many oils can be extracted by only one method: •
Solvent extraction – this method is not suitable for flavouring oils because solvent residues will taint flavours. Besides maceration and percolation, we can also list boiling with water (infusion), extraction with cold fat (enfleurage) and extraction with hot fat. • Cold pressing (expression) – probably the most desirable method for flavouring oils, it is normally used only for citrus oils. Terpenes are extracted from the plant material by this method and a subsequent process, such as distillation or counter-current extraction, is required to make a terpene-free oil. • Distillation – direct essential oil distillation, water and steam distillation and steam distillation. This is probably the most common extraction method. Steam is used to break down the plant material and the essential oils, released as vapour, are then condensed. This method is not recommended if an alternative is at hand, because insoluble terpenes are extracted and more terpenes may be produced when the plant material is heated. Moreover, some of the more volatile flavour molecules may
48
Modifying flavour in food be lost. Terpenes may be removed from the oil by a subsequent distillation process, which will, however, entail a further loss of volatile flavour components.
Non-conventional extraction techniques (Luque de Castro et al., 1999) include: • • • • • •
vortical- or turbo-extraction (high-speed mixing) (List and Schmidt, 1990); UAE; pressurised solvent extraction (PSE); MAE; extraction by electrical energy; SFE – liquid CO2 at 10 ºC and a very high pressure is used as a solvent to remove essential oils from plant material. Once atmospheric pressure is restored, CO2 rapidly escapes, leaving no residue. As this process does not remove terpenes, it results in a terpene-free oil.
Volatile aroma compounds can be recovered by pervaporation, a vapourphase separation process based on selective permeation through a dense organophilic membrane (Baudot and Marin, 1997). Essential oils are widely used in the perfume and food industries. They are complex mixtures that basically consist of two fractions, the more abundant one (90–95%) being made up of volatiles (monoterpenes, sesquiterpenes, hydrocarbons and their oxygenated derivatives, along with aliphatic aldehydes, alcohols and esters). The non-volatile residue, amounting to 5– 10% of the whole oil, contains hydrocarbons, fatty acids, sterols, carotenoids, waxes, coumarins, psoralens and flavonoids (Luque de Castro et al., 1999). Terpenes, ranging from approximately 99% of the volatile fraction in grapefruit oil to 60% in bergamot oil, make little contribution to the flavour or fragrance of the oil. Moreover, as they are mostly unsaturated compounds, they are decomposed by heat, light and oxygen to produce undesirable compounds that can be detrimental to flavour and aroma. The oxygenated fraction is highly odoriferous and is mainly responsible for the characteristic flavour. The isolation, concentration and purification of essential oils have been important processes for centuries, as a consequence of the widespread use of these compounds. Commonly used methods to this day are mainly based on solvent extraction and steam distillation. The drawbacks to these techniques have led to a search for new alternative extraction processes. Another important goal in the extraction industry is to improve the quality of the oil. As essential oils used in the food and perfume industries are commonly isolated by cold pressing, they contain more than 95% of monoterpene hydrocarbons, mainly limonene. The industrial practice of deterpenation or ‘folding’ removes some of the limonene along with other unstable terpenes, and thus concentrates the oxygenated fraction. This process aims to improve product stability, to increase the
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
49
solubility of the oil in low-proof alcohol, food solvents and water, besides reducing storage and transportation costs. The commercial methods currently used for ‘folding’ are fractional vacuum distillation, selective solvent extraction and chromatographic separation. All these methods have serious drawbacks, such as low yields, formation of by-products (owing to exposure to heat) and the presence in the extracts of potentially toxic organic residues. In this context the adoption of new techniques is an urgent issue. Extraction with supercritical CO2 (SC-CO2) and especially with subcritical water are effective methods to isolate high-quality essential oils. Many authors have compared conventional techniques (including discontinuous, continuous and hybrid approaches) with SC-CO2, subcritical water extraction, UAE and MAE. Pressurised liquid extraction (PLE) is another competitive technique for flavour extraction that has grown in recent years. Superheated water extraction (SWE) used in essential oil extractions (Ollanketo et al., 2002; Gogus et al., 2006) also belongs to this group of techniques. The crucial features of SWE are temperature, pressure, flow rate and extraction time. In many SWE studies, a flow rate of 2 ml/min, moderate pressure (enough to keep water in the liquid state) and various temperatures have been used. By appropriate temperature programming it is possible to modify, in a certain range, the polarity of water. In other words, under SWE, the solvent may behave like water or like methanol. The advantages and drawbacks of each method have to be considered before they can be applied commercially. The use of non-toxic extracting solvents such as carbon dioxide and water is highly attractive as they carry great economic and environmental benefits and deliver products that are likely to be better accepted by consumers. The enormous demand for flavourings has been met mostly by chemical synthesis that produces the desired flavour compounds from readily available sources. Today this approach is markedly declining because of new regulations concerning food additives (see Chapter 2) and because of consumer aversion to chemicals. For these reasons in the past ten years the bio-production of natural flavours has risen from 5–10% to 75–80% of the total output. Microorganisms have been identified as potential sources of natural flavours, and interest in new fermentation processes, as well as in enzymatic conversions, is now growing. Organic solvent extraction must be used with caution on fermentations because they may exert toxic effects on microorganisms. One way to overcome this problem might be extraction with SC-CO2, one of the new techniques for recovering molecules such as aromas from dilute fermentation broths (Fabre et al., 1999). Owing to its good solvent properties and good transport properties (low viscosity and high diffusivity), this approach appears very promising for the extraction of natural compounds. Moreover, CO2 is non-toxic, non-flammable and a physiological molecule, a favourable aspect in the food industry. Numerous studies highlighted that SC-CO2 efficiently removed terpenes, limonene, eugenol and thymol from plant tissues (Kerrola, 1995); it also made it
50
Modifying flavour in food
possible to obtain aromatic extracts from lilac and rose, from vanilla, ginger, rosemary, sage, wild rose and clove. These studies highlighted the good conservation of the organoleptic properties of the extracts (Quirin, 2004). One of the most common flavours is natural vanillin (4-hydroxy-3methoxybenzaldehyde), which is used in a broad range of food products. In the vanilla bean, it makes up 0.2% of the dry weight and is associated with many other compounds. Approximately 12 000 tonnes of vanillin are consumed annually, of which only 20 are extracted from vanilla beans (Ramachandra Rao and Ravishankar, 2000). Beside the relatively high cost of conventional vanilla cultivation, the common extraction methods used to obtain the flavour from the cured bean lack efficiency and speed. Percolation (ethanol/water) takes from 48 to 72 h, while the oleoresin method consists of circulating ethanol over the pulverised whole beans under vacuum (45 ºC) and takes about 8–9 days. However, by the latter process, an approximately 10-fold stronger vanilla extract may be obtained. Commercially, natural vanillin is sold as a dilute ethanolic extract. High-pressure techniques have found application in food industry. This technology, referred to as ultra-high pressure (UHP) and high hydrostatic pressure (HHP), may replace the conventional pasteurisation treatment of food. Thermally pasteurised fruit juices often suffer from a loss of fresh flavour notes. Organoleptic alterations in a juice mixture composed of orange, lemon and carrot (OLC) were analysed as a function of high pressure treatment and storage time (up to 21 days at 4 ºC). In standard pasteurised juices, odour and flavour quality decreased significantly during storage. In OLC juice treated at 500 MPa for 5 min, the changes in odour and flavour were but slight (Butz and Tauscher, 2002). HHP treatment was advantageous for strawberry flavour because β-glucosidase was significantly inactivated at 600–800 MPa (Zabetakis et al., 2000). The following sections present the innovative extraction techniques in greater detail, with a brief survey of published studies in which a comparison was made of several extraction methods of flavours from natural sources (Luque de Castro et al., 1999; Szentmihalyi et al., 2002).
3.3
Supercritical fluid extraction: SC-CO2
Supercritical CO2, the sole supercritical fluid used in the food industry, exists when carbon dioxide is heated under pressure (>31 ºC, >74 bar) (Fig. 3.7). The supercritical phase exhibits a very low viscosity and excellent solvent properties, and its use to extract natural matrices generally yields products of better quality than those obtained using organic solvents, whose residues, even if present as traces, are objectionable. SFE offers some important advantages, as it can be performed at low temperatures, avoiding
Pressure, P
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
51
Supercritical phase Liquid phase Solid phase
Tc = 31.1 °C Pc = 73.8 bar Critical point
Triple point (–56.6 °C, 5.19 bar)
Gaseous phase
Temperature, T
Fig. 3.7
CO2 phase diagram.
the degradation of thermolabile compounds and limiting hydrolytic phenomena that lead to loss of water-soluble compounds. One of the greatest hurdles besetting supercritical fluid extraction of plant raw materials is the very slow kinetics of the process (Brunner, 1994). The classical way to accelerate the process is via the application of a mechanical agitation system. As the high pressures required by SFE do not allow it, an alternative must be considered. The use of ultrasound (both high and low intensity) has been applied in food technology, especially to modify the texture of food products. In particular, the use of high-intensity ultrasound (18–100 kHz) has been suggested to enhance heat and mass transfer, dehydration processes, inactivation of enzymes and de-gasification of liquids. The use of acoustic waves in SFE can effectively accelerate the process, owing to the high density of the solvent (the velocity of propagation increases with density) (Riera et al., 2004). The literature reports a plethora of applications of supercritical CO2 to extraction processes in food technology, such as decaffeination of green coffee beans, production of hop extracts, recovery of aromas and flavours from spices and herbs, extraction and fractionation of edible oils and removal of contaminants. Yonei et al. (1995) extracted ginger flavour in a two-step separation procedure working in a certain range of pressure and temperature (7.9–29.5 MPa, 288–353 K); in this way they concentrated 6-gingerol to produce a highly pungent ginger flavour. Volatile extracts of marjoram leaves (Majorana hortensis Moench) obtained by hydrodistillation (HD) and SFE were compared (El-Ghorab
52
Modifying flavour in food
et al., 2004). The antioxidant power of the latter was markedly greater than that of the former, possibly because it had a higher content of γ-terpinene, terpinolene and thymol. Since 1995, several reviews have comprehensively covered extraction methods for flavours and essential oils, comparing SFE with other techniques (Quirin, 2004). Beside affording high extraction yields, supercritical CO2 can achieve a better degree of selectivity (Senorans et al., 2003; Pourmortazavi et al., 2005; Bhattacharjee et al., 2005).
3.4
Continuous subcritical water extraction (CSWE)
The use of water in a dynamic mode, at temperatures between 100 and 374 ºC (the critical point of water lies at 221 bar and 374 ºC) and pressures high enough to maintain the liquid state, is emerging as a powerful alternative method for the extraction of solids (Luque de Castro and JimenezCarmona, 1998). Its outstanding feature is the easy manipulation of the dielectric constant (er), that can be made to vary over a wide range just by changing the temperature. Thus, at room temperature and pressure, water has a dielectric constant of ca. 80, which makes it an extremely polar solvent. This value can be drastically lowered by raising the temperature under moderate pressure. For instance, subcritical water at 250 ºC and a pressure just over 40 bar has an er value of 27, which is close to that of ethanol, and is suitable for the leaching of low-polarity compounds. The recent application of this technique to the isolation of essential oils is very promising. The extraction rate is determined by compound partition between the matrix and water, rather than by the diffusion rate of a compound out of the matrix. Superheated water under pressure between 125 and 175 ºC has been shown to rapidly extract the oxygenated fragrance and flavour compounds from Rosmarinus officinalis, while the monoterpenes are extracted slowly, and only very small amounts of the sesquiterpenes, waxes and lipids are removed. The yields of oxygenated compounds are higher than those obtained by steam distillation and the organoleptic properties are better preserved. Although larger amounts of water are needed for extraction by superheated water, the energy costs are competitive because it is not necessary to vaporise the water and most of the heat required can be recycled (Basile et al., 1998). Similar results are reported for the isolation of marjoram essential oil with water at 50 bar and 150 ºC. An in-depth study of the variables affecting the process showed that temperature was a key variable. In the range between 100 and 175 ºC the optimum temperature was 150 ºC, providing essential oil of the best quality (Jiménez-Carmona et al., 1999). Subcritical water extraction has also been shown to be a promising technique for the deterpenation of lemon oil, removing approximately 96% of the monoterpenes.
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
3.5
53
Ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE)
Techniques have been developed to obtain valuable products from plant sources on an industrial scale. Recent trends in extraction techniques are largely focused on finding solutions that minimise, or even dispense with, the use of solvents (Chemat et al., 2004b). The application of ultrasound to enhance extraction yields began in the 1950s at the laboratory level (Mason, 1997). It has been recently shown to improve the extraction from plant materials containing polysaccharides and essential oils, mainly through the phenomenon of cavitation (Hromàdkovà et al., 1999).The mechanical effect of ultrasound accelerates the release of organic compounds contained within the plant body by disrupting cell walls, by enhancing mass transfer and facilitating solvent access to the cell content. This effect is much stronger at low frequencies (18–40 kHz), and practically negligible at 400–800 kHz, assuming of course the same wave intensity. UAE has proved to be a versatile technique that can be scaled up to the great benefit of industrial production. Studies on the UAE of the main constituents of sage (Salvia officinalis) showed that the recovery of cineole, thujone and borneol was better when sonication was carried out with a probe system rather than in an ultrasonic cleaning bath or with conventional techniques. The use of ultrasound afforded purer extracts in better yields, in shorter times and working at lower temperatures (Povey and Mason, 1998; Vinatoru et al., 1999; Toma et al., 2001; Vinatoru, 2001). A comparative study of aqueous ethanol extracts obtained from Salvia officinalis (see Table 3.2) and valerian roots by conventional and UAE also showed the latter to be more efficient. Vinatoru et al. (1997) showed that the main advantage of UAE is the enhanced hydration process that takes place simultaneously with matrix fragmentation without any appreciable chemical degradation. In the last few years low-intensity ultrasound, a non-destructive technique, has been put to more extensive use in the food industry, whether for analysis and production control, or for processing and modifying foods. High-intensity ultrasound has been combined with other extraction Table 3.2 Extraction of Salvia officinalis components (mg/kg) under various conditions Method Stirring Ultrasound bath Stirring Ultrasound bath Ultrasound + stirring Horn (20 kHz) * Average temperature.
t (h)
T (ºC)
Cineole
Thujone
Borneol
3 3 3 3 3 2
20 20 30 30 20 20*
10.3 13.0 10.0 16.5 22.7 24.3
63.6 81.6 71.7 118.1 141.9 167.2
3.8 4.3 3.0 3.6 6.3 5.8
54
Modifying flavour in food
techniques. One of the drawbacks of SFE, one that sets limits for some industrial applications, is that it is not compatible with mechanical agitation systems, such as are commonly used to increase mass transfer (Riera et al., 2004). On the other hand, high-intensity ultrasound causes heating of the medium, precipitation of some dissolved materials, degasification of liquids by bubble collapse and formation of acoustic micro-currents, phenomena that all concur to an interface shrinking, that is, to enhance mass transfer coefficients during the extraction. Rice-bran oil (Cravotto et al., 2004) and soybean-germ oil (Li et al., 2004) (SG) (see Table 3.1) were obtained in higher yield under UAE with only minimal degradation of thermosensitive components (Cravotto et al., 2005). Sonication of sunflower oil did not cause significant changes; however, some off-flavour compounds such as n-hexanal and limonene resulting from its ultrasonic degradation were identified by gas chromatography – mass spectrometry (GC-MS) (Chemat et al., 2004a). Acoustic cavitation induced by ultrasonic cutting devices which are used for food packaging, may also induce changes on edible oil composition (Schneider et al., 2006). UAE and MAE (Section 3.6) were compared in sample preparation for the determination in a traditional Chinese medicine composed of three water-soluble bioactive constituents (danshensu, puerarin and ferulic acid) (Jiantao et al., 2004). MAE worked very fast: using 30% EtOH as solvent (pH 2.5) the extraction was complete in 2 min at 750 W, while UAE took 30 min for the same result working however at a lower temperature. A good chemical tally was found between the two extracts. The literature reports several examples of UAE of flavours, e.g. the extraction of volatile compounds from citrus flowers and citrus honey (Alissandrakis et al., 2003) and that of filbertone from hazelnut oil (Ruiz del Castillo and Herraiz, 2003).
3.6
Microwave-assisted extraction (MAE)
The use of dielectric heating in analytical laboratories started in the late 1970s (Yeo and Shibamoto, 1991; Parliment et al., 1994). Ten years later, MAE was used for the first time to prepare samples for chromatographic determination of natural products and pesticides in foods and soil matrices (Sanghi and Kannamkumarath, 2004). In continental Europe microwave generators usually work at 2450 MHz but, in the United Kingdom and the United States, 915 MHz is the operating frequency. The lower frequency confers greater penetration but requires bigger generators and apparatus. Microwave dielectric heating depends on the ability of the solvent or the plant material to absorb microwave energy and convert it to heat. Unlike conductive heating, microwaves heat the whole sample volume simultaneously. Microwaves also disrupt weak hydrogen bounds by promoting the rotation of molecular dipoles, an effect that is opposed by the viscosity of the medium. Furthermore, the movement of dissolved ions increases solvent
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
55
penetration into the matrix and thus facilitates analyte solvation. The resulting friction with the medium releases heat by Joule effect. This phenomenon depends on the size and charge of the ions present in the solution. The effect is strongly dependent on the nature of both the solvent and the solid matrix. Commonly used solvents cover a wide range of polarities, from heptane to water. In most cases, the chosen solvent has a high dielectric constant and strongly absorbs microwaves; however, the ability of the medium to interact with microwaves and the selectivity of extraction can be modulated by using mixtures of solvents. Sometimes the matrix itself interacts with microwaves while the surrounding solvent, having a low dielectric constant, remains relatively cold. This set-up, which presents obvious advantages when dealing with thermosensitive compounds, has been successfully used for the extraction of essential oils (Kaufmann and Christen, 2002). In fact, microwaves interact selectively with the polar molecules present in glands, trichomes or vascular tissues. Localised heating causes the expansion of cells and rupture of their walls, followed by the release to the solvent of essential oils (Craveiro et al., 1989). This situation also occurs when a dry sample has been rehydrated before extraction (Pare et al., 1994). Moisture content is essential in MAE because water locally superheats and promotes the release of analytes into the surrounding medium; control of the matrix water content also leads to more reproducible results. The recent literature shows that usually MAE works better than conventional methods, as it saves time and solvent, accomplishes a more thorough extraction and yields better products (Cesare et al., 1995; Sides et al., 2000). While the Soxhlet method usually takes hours, up to 20 or more, MAE only takes a few minutes, using at least 10-fold less solvent. Although for the time being MAE has not proceeded beyond the small pilot scale, the apparatus is simpler and cheaper than is required by SFE and can be built to higher capacities. The method can be used for a greater variety of analytes and with less limit of the polarity of the solvent. Two types of instruments are commercially available, using different approaches. The most common involves working in a closed vessel under controlled pressure and temperature; the other uses an open vessel under atmospheric pressure. There is a series of commercial microwave reactors, operating at either single-mode or multimode conditions, enabling accurate and reproducible results. Large-scale industrial equipment is also available (Singh, 1993; Stuerga and Delmotte, 2002). In the MAE of essential oils, if samples are suspended in an apolar solvent such as hexane, MW will heat almost exclusively the inner glandular and vascular systems of the fresh plant material owing to their high moisture content. The resulting disruption of cell membranes releases the analytes to the solvent. These applications, together with the direct distillation of volatile oils from plants and other biological material have been patented by Paré at the beginning of the 1990s. The latter procedure was applied by
56
Modifying flavour in food
Fig. 3.8
Microwave-promoted dry-distillation of fresh plants under nitrogen stream (Prof. Cravotto’s laboratories, University of Turin).
many authors to obtain essential oils (e.g. Cuminum cyminum L. and Zanthoxylum bungeanum M. (Wang et al., 2006) or Rosmarinus officinalis (Lo Presti et al., 2005). After microwave extraction, scanning electron micrographs of the leaves showed structural changes in the oil-containing glands: most of them were collapsed and some completely disintegrated. Two explanations of these facts are plausible, one involving diffusion of the essential oil across the gland wall and the other a rupture of the wall and liberation of the constituents into the solvent. Either may apply, depending on the maturation stage of the gland. Using a domestic microwave oven, MAE has been compared with classical hydrodistillation for the extraction of essential oils from 10 different plant species (Lucchesi et al., 2004). The yields were generally similar, but the chromatographic profiles varied dramatically, especially in the ratios between different peaks. Microwave irradiation of fresh leaves promotes the distillation of volatiles and an air or nitrogen stream passing through it facilitates the stripping (Fig. 3.8). The yields obtained after a few minutes were comparable to those obtained after 60–90 min of steam distillation, and both qualitative and quantitative results were superior to conventional method.
3.7
Extraction in the analysis of flavours
This field is widely covered by many reviews dealing with modern techniques for the extraction and quantitative analysis of flavours (Modey et al., 1996; Wilkes et al., 2000; Chaintreau, 2001; Werkhoff et al., 2002). Traditional methods
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
57
for isolating volatile components have been complemented by solid-phase microextraction (SPME), GC combined with head-space volatile-compound sampling, high-pressure extraction with supercritical CO2, solvent-assisted flavour evaporation, stir-bar sorptive extraction and GC-MS. Simultaneous distillation–extraction (SDE) stretches over 50 years of history in organic synthesis, but its original use was in analytical applications when Likens and Nickerson (1964) designed the original device. This onestep isolation–concentration of flavour constituents allowed a dramatic time saving and a great reduction of treated liquid volumes because of continuous recycling. SDE remains one of the most frequently used isolation methods for recovering a wide range of compounds from a non-volatile matrix without further clean-up. This does not mean that it is a universal technique; yet, when properly used, i.e. taking into account its possibilities and limitations, it often achieves the highest recoveries. Modelling of the distillation–extraction process and computer-simulated operation enables the analyst to optimise conditions. New improvements are at hand, such as preparative and analytical isolations carried out at room temperature that minimise the risk of artefact formation. For heat-sensitive products, vacuum simultaneous distillation– solvent extraction (V-SDE) and headspace sampling play complementary roles and are conceivably the most selective techniques for the separation of volatiles from non-volatiles. Used in combination, and without submitting the sample to heat, they can produce extracts of almost all the volatile flavours and fragrances. An interesting application of SDE is the recovery of water-soluble constituents from aqueous solutions obtained during rose oil production (Eikani et al., 2005). The most common perfumed extracts from the flowers are rose oil and rose water, derived from steam distillation. The water which forms the major portion of the distillate may hold in solution an appreciable amount of the valuable part of the oil; by SDE the rose oil components may be identified and quantified from the aqueous phases obtained in both small- and large-scale rose oil production. Conventional Soxhlet extraction of vegetal solid matrices for analytical sample preparation was compared with extraction under ultrasound and under microwave (Rashmi and Kannamkumarath, 2004). Although recovery of standard pesticides was more efficient with MAE, this method has to be re-optimised whenever a new matrix is analysed. The efficiency of ultrasound-assisted extraction can often be related to the power, frequency and type of instrument used, e.g. frequencies higher than 45 kHz are less efficient than 18–25 kHz. Pressurised hot water extraction, also called subcritical water extraction, is a novel approach for the extraction of a wide variety of substances, as pressurised water at higher temperatures becomes progressively less polar. Fundamental and practical aspects of this technique have been reviewed (Eskilsson et al., 2004).
58
Modifying flavour in food
All reported applications have shown that pressurised hot water extraction is a viable alternative to conventional techniques (Soxhlet and/or standard solvent extraction procedures). There is also evidence suggesting that it may compete favourably with other recent extraction techniques such as SFE and PLE with organic solvents. Early work with subcritical water demonstrated its ability to selectively extract different classes of compounds, the more polar organics being extracted at lower temperatures and the less polar ones (phenols, hydrocarbons) at higher temperatures. Thus, the selectivity of subcritical water extraction (a preference for more polar organics at milder conditions) runs contrary to that of supercritical CO2 (preferring non-polar over polar organics). Recently, solubilities of oxygenated flavour and fragrance components were measured in subcritical water and found to be substantially higher than non-oxygenates. For example at 100 ºC (ca. 65 bar), the oxygenates, carvone and eugenol, have solubilities two orders of magnitude higher than the non-oxygenated compound d-limonene. These solubility trends correspond to studies demonstrating high recoveries of oxygenated flavour in solvents. The analysis of essential oils may combine adsorption on inert material and desorption by a supercritical fluid. To increase the ratio of oxygenated flavour compounds to terpene hydrocarbons in orange oil, this is fractionated on porous silica gel, then further purified by desorption into SC-CO2 (Shen et al., 2002).
3.8
Drying methods and solvent distillation
Most drying methods are known to affect volatiles (Coumans et al., 1994). For instance, oven-drying at 30 ºC did not deplete volatiles in sage (Salvia officinalis L.) and thyme (Thymus vulgaris L.) significantly but drying at 60 ºC caused a marked loss (Venskutonis, 1997). Air-drying preserved more volatiles of parsley (Petroselinum crispum L.) compared with oven-drying at 45 ºC and freeze-drying. The volatiles lost through the latter methods were the monoterpenes that make up the most of parsley aroma (p-mentha1,3,8-triene and apiole) (Diaz-Maroto et al., 2002, 2003). Freeze-drying generally has the most pronounced effect and consistently fails to preserve the volatile profile of the fresh plant, usually to the detriment of the compounds that give the plant its unique aroma (Abascal et al., 2005). Several flavour components of blueberries (Vaccinium spp.) are lost, including 1,8-cineole which gives this fruit its characteristic aroma. On the other hand, freeze-drying preserved more of the aroma volatiles of dill (Anethum graveolens) than hot air drying but both methods failed to capture over 80% of benzofuranoids, the most important fraction (Huopalahti et al., 1985). Over 50% of the total volatiles in dried and freeze-dried samples consisted of secondary aroma compounds (mostly phytadienes) formed
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
59
during processing. In the final analysis, the freeze-dried sample preserved only 25% of the total primary aroma compounds found in fresh dill. Freezedrying preserved fairly well total volatiles in sage but increased the absolute thymol content by 33%, indicating a change in the volatile profile of the plant. Both oven- and freeze-drying increased the percentage in the headspace of unknown volatiles, presumably degradation products. Sometimes, drying procedures have a favourable effect on aroma, e.g. all drying methods increase the characteristic minty odour of spearmint which may be a plus for some uses, such as in herbal teas. The behaviour of volatile compounds of banana during dehydration was determined during air-drying (AD), during vacuum microwave-drying (VMD) and during freeze-drying. The process that yielded the most crisp banana chips with significantly higher volatile levels and sensory ratings was the combination of AD and VMD (Mui et al., 2002). A comparison between microwave heating and conventional roasting of cumin seeds (Cuminum cyminus L.) showed that microwave-heated samples better retained the characteristic flavour compounds, such as typical aldehydes (Behera et al., 2004).
3.9
Conclusion
Conventional extraction processes for flavours and essential oils are timeconsuming, laborious, involve large amounts of solvents and ultimately cause some thermal decomposition of the target molecules and partial loss of volatiles. Great improvements may be in the offing with the new techniques and their combinations; each matrix, however, will need careful optimisation of operating conditions.
3.10
Acknowledgements
This work has been carried out within the European Union COST Action D32 (Working Group D32/006/04: Microwave and high-intensity ultrasound in the synthesis of fine chemicals). Financial support from MIUR-COFIN (Italy) and the Spanish Ministry of Education and Science (grant CTQ200507676/BQU) are also acknowledged.
3.11
References
abascal, k., canora, l. and yarnell, e. (2005), ‘The effect of freeze-drying and its implications for botanical medicine: a review’, Phytother Res, 19, 655–660. alissandrakis, e., daferera, d., tarantilis, p. a., polissiou, m. and harizanis, p. c. (2003), ‘Ultrasound-assisted extraction of volatile compounds from citrus flowers and citrus honey’, Food Chem, 82 (4), 575–582.
60
Modifying flavour in food
basile, a., jimenez-carmona, m. m. and clifford, a. a. (1998), ‘Extraction of rosemary by superheated water’, J Agric Food Chem, 46, 5205–5209. baudot, a. and marin, m. (1997), ‘Pervaporation of aroma compounds: comparison of membrane performances with vapor–liquid equilibria and engineering aspects of process improvement’, Food Bioprod Processing, 75, 117–142. behera, s., nagarajan, s. and mohan rao, l. j. (2004), ‘Microwave heating and conventional roasting of cumin seeds (Cuminum cyminus L.) and effect on chemical composition of volatiles’, Food Chem, 87, 25–29. bhattacharjee, p., kshirsagar, a. and singhal, r. s. (2005), ‘Supercritical carbon dioxide extraction of 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline from Pandanus amaryllifolius Roxb’, Food Chem, 91 (2), 255–259. brunner, g. (1994), Gas Extraction: An Introduction to Fundamentals of Supercritical Fluids and the Application to Separation Processes, New York, Springer, 1994. brunner, g. (2005), ‘Supercritical fluids: technology and application to food processing’, J Food Eng, 67, 21–33. bureau, s., razungles, a., baumes, r. and bayonove, c. (1996), ‘Glycosylated flavor precursor extraction by microwaves from grape juice and grapes’, J Food Sci, 61 (3), 557–559. butz, p. and tauscher, b. (2002), ‘Emerging technologies: chemical aspects’, Food Res Int, 35 279–284. cesare, l. f., diriva, m. and schiraldi, a. (1995), ‘Microwave extraction of basil aroma compounds’, Develop Food Sci, 37, 857–868. chaintreau, a. (2001), ‘Simultaneous distillation-extraction. From birth to maturity. Review’, Flavour Fragr J, 16 (2), 136–148. chemat, f., grondin, i., costes, p., moutoussamy, l., sing, a. s. c. and smadja, j. (2004a), ‘High power ultrasound effects on lipid oxidation of refined sunflower oil’, Ultrason Sonochem, 11, 281–285. chemat, s., lagha, a., ait-amar, h., bartels, p. v. and chemat, f. (2004b), ‘Comparison of conventional and ultrasound-assisted extraction of carvone and limonene from caraway seeds’, Flavour Fragr J, 19, 188–195. chen, s. s. and spiro, m. (1994), ‘Study of microwave extraction of essential oil constituents from plant materials’, J Microwave Electromagn Energy, 29, 231–241. collin, g. j., lord, g., allaire, j. and gagnon, d. (1991), ‘Huiles essentielles et extraits microondes’, Parfums Cosmèt Arômes, 97, 105–112. coumans, w. j., kerkhof, p. and bruin, s. (1994), ‘Theoretical and practical aspects of aroma retention in spray drying and freeze drying’, Drying Technol, 12 (1–2), 99–149. craveiro, a. a., matos, f. j. a., alencar, j. w. and plumel, m. m. (1989), ‘Microwave oven extraction of an essential oil’, Flavour Fragr J, 4 (1), 43–44. cravotto, g., binello, a., merizzi, g. and avogadro, m. (2004), ‘Improving solventfree extraction of policosanol from rice bran by high-intensity ultrasound treatment’, Eur J Lipid Sci Techn, 106, 147–151. cravotto, g., robaldo, b., viola, f., oliaro-bosso, s. and avogadro, m. (2005), ‘Soybean-germ oil inhibits oxidosqualene cyclase in 3T3 fibroblasts’, Eur J Lipid Sci Technol, 107 (10), 701–705. diaz-maroto, m. c., perez-coello, m. s. and cabezudo, m. d. (2002), ‘Effect of drying method on the volatiles in bay leaf (Laurus nobilis L.)’, J Agric Food Chem, 50 (16), 4520–4524. diaz-maroto, m. c., perez-coello, m. s., gonzalez viñas, m. a. and cabezudo, m. d. (2003), ‘Influence of drying on the flavor quality of spearmint (Mentha spicata L.)’, J Agric Food Chem, 51 (5), 1265–1269. dufosse, l., blin-perrin, c., souchon, i. and feron, g. (2002), ‘Microbial production of flavors for the food industry. A case study on the production of
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
61
gamma-decalactone, the key compound of peach flavor, by the yeasts Sporidiobolus sp.’, Food Sci Biotech, 11 (2), 192–202. eikani, m. h., golmohammad, f., rowshanzamir, s. and mirza, m. (2005), ‘Recovery of water-soluble constituents of rose oil using simultaneous distillation–extraction’, Flavour Fragr J, 20, 555–558. el-ghorab, a. h., mansour, a. and el-massry, k. f. (2004), ‘Effect of extraction methods on the chemical composition and antioxidant activity of Egyptian marjoram (Majorana hortensis M.)’, Flavour Fragr J, 19, 54–61. eskilsson, c. s., hartonen, k., mathiasson, l. and riekkola, m.-l. (2004), ‘Pressurized hot water extraction of insecticides from process dust – comparison with supercritical fluid extraction’, J Sep Sci, 27, 59–64. fabre, c. e., condoret, j.-s. and marty, a. (1999), ‘Extractive fermentation of aroma with supercritical CO2’, Biotech Bioeng, 64 (4), 392–400. ganzler, k., salgo, a. and valko, k. (1986), ‘A novel sample preparation method for chromatography’, J Chromatogr, 371, 299–305. gogus, f., oze, m. z. and lewis, a. c. (2006), ‘Extraction of essential oils of leaves and flowers of Achillea monocephala by superheated water’, Flavour Fragr J, 21 (1), 122–128. hromàdkovà z., ebringerovà a. and valachovic, p. (1999), ‘Comparison of classical and ultrasound-assisted extraction of polysaccharides from Salvia officinalis L.’, Ultrason Sonochem, 5, 163–168. huopalahti, r., kesaelahti, e. and linko, r. (1985), ‘Effect of hot air and freeze drying on the volatile compounds of dill (Anethum graveolens L.) herb’, J Agric Sci Finl, 57 (2), 133–138. jiantao, h., zhihong, s. and wenbao, c. (2004), ‘Comparison of microwave-assisted and ultrasound-assisted extraction for determination of main water-soluble bioactive constituents in traditional Chinese medicinal preparation tongmaichongji by HPLC-DAD’, J Liq Chrom Rel Technol, 27 (11), 1769–1784. jimenez-carmona, m. m., ubera, j. l. and luque de castro, m. d. (1999), ‘Comparison of continuous subcritical water extraction and hydrodistillation of marjoram essential oil’, J Chromatogr A, 855 (2), 625–632. kaufmann, b. and christen, p. (2002), ‘Recent extraction techniques for natural products: microwave-assisted extraction and pressurised solvent extraction’, Phytochem Anal, 13, 105–113. kerrola, k. (1995), ‘Literature review: isolation of essential oils and flavor compounds by dense carbon dioxide’, Food Rev Int, 11 (4), 547–573. li, h., pordesimo, l. and weiss, j. (2004), ‘High intensity ultrasound-assisted extraction of oil from soybeans’, Food Res Int, 37, 731–738. likens, s. t. and nickerson, g. b. (1964), ‘Detection of certain hop oil constituents in brewing products’, Am Soc Brewing Chemists Proc, 5, 5–13. list, p. h. and schmidt, c. c. (1990), Phytopharmaceutical Technology, Cleveland, CRC Press. lo presti, m., raqusa, s., trozzi, a., dugo, p., visinoni, f., fazio, a., dugo, g. and mondello, l. (2005), ‘A comparison between different techniques for the isolation of rosemary essential oil’, J Sep Sci, 28 (3), 273–280. lucchesi, m. e., chemat, f. and smadja, j. (2004), ‘Solvent-free microwave extraction of essential oil from aromatic herbs: comparison with conventional hydrodistillation’, J Chromatogr A, 1043, 323–327. luque de castro, m. d. and jimenez-carmona, m. m. (1998), ‘Potential of water for continuous automated sample-leaching’, Trends Anal Chem, 17 (7), 441–447. luque de castro, m. d., jimnez-carmona, m. m. and fernandez-pèrez, v. (1999), ‘Towards more rational techniques for the isolation of valuable essential oils from plants’, Trends Anal Chem, 18 (11), 708–716.
62
Modifying flavour in food
mason, t. j. (1997), ‘Ultrasound in synthetic organic chemistry’, Chem Soc Rev, 26, 443–451. modey, a., mulholland, w. k., dulcie, a. and raynor, m. w. (1996), ‘Analytical supercritical fluid extraction of natural products’, Phytochem Anal, 7 (1), 1–15. mui, w. w. y., durance, t. d. and scaman, c. h. (2002), ‘Flavor and texture of banana chips dried by combinations of hot air, vacuum, and microwave processing’, J Agric Food Chem, 50, 1883–1889. ollanketo, m., peltoketo, a., hartonen, k., hiltunen, r. and riekkola, m. l. (2002), ‘Extraction of sage (Salvia officinalis L.) by pressurized hot water and conventional methods: antioxidant activity of the extracts’, Eur Food Res Technol, 215, 158–163. pare, j. r. j., belanger, j. m. r. and stafford, s. s. (1994), ‘Microwave-assisted process (MAP(TM)) – a new tool for the analytical laboratory’, Trends Anal Chem, 13, 176–183. parliment, t. h., morello, m. j. and mcgorrin, r. j. (1994), Thermally Generated Flavors: Maillard, Microwave, and Extrusion Processes, Washington, DC, ACS Symposium Series 543. peker, h., srinivasan, m. p., smith, j. m. and mccoy, b. j. (1992), ‘Caffeine extraction rates from coffee beans with supercritical carbon dioxide’, AIChE J, 38 (5), 761– 770. pourmortazavi, s. m., ghadiri, m. and hajimirsadeghi, s. s. (2005), ‘Supercritical fluid extraction of volatile components from Bunium persicum Boiss. (black cumin) and Mespilus germanica L. (medlar) seeds’, J Food Comp Anal, 18 (5), 439–446. povey, m. and mason, t. j. (1998), Power Ultrasound in Food Processing – The Way Forward, London, Blackie Academic & Professional. quirin, k. w. (2004), ‘SFE: The best technology for high grade essential oils’, Innov Food Technol, 22, 40–43. ramachandra rao, s. and ravishankar, g. a. (2000), ‘Vanilla flavour: production by conventional and biotechnological routes’, J Sci Food Agric, 80, 289–304. rashmi, s. and kannamkumarath, s. s. (2004), ‘Comparison of extraction methods by Soxhlet, sonicator, and microwave in the screening of pesticide residues from solid matrices’, J Anal Chem, 59 (11), 1032–1036. raventos, m., duarte, s. and alarcon, r. (2002), ‘Application and possibilities of supercritical CO2 extraction in food processing industry: an overview’, Food Sci Technol Int, 8 (5), 269–284. riera, e., golas, y., blanco, a., gallego, j. a., blasco, m. and mulet, a. (2004), ‘Mass transfer enhancement in supercritical fluids extraction by means of power ultrasound’, Ultrason Sonochem, 11 (3–4), 241–244. ruiz del castillo, m. l. and herraiz, m. (2003), ‘Ultrasonically assisted solid-phase extraction and GC analysis of filbertone in hazelnut oil’, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 80 (4), 307–310. sanghi, r. and kannamkumarath, s. s. (2004), ‘Comparison of extraction methods by soxhlet, sonicator, and microwave in the screening of pesticide residues from solid matrices’, J Anal Chem, 59 (11), 1032–1036. schneider, y., zahn, s., hofmann, j., wecks, m. and rohm, h. (2006), ‘Acoustic cavitation induced by ultrasonic cutting devices: a preliminary study’, Ultrason Sonochem, 13, 117–120. senorans, f. j., ruiz-rodriguez, a., ibanez, e., tabera, j. and reglero, g. (2003), ‘Isolation of brandy aroma by countercurrent supercritical fluid extraction’, J Supercrit Fluids, 26 (2), 129–135. shen, z., mishra, v., imison, b., palmer, m. and fairclough, r. (2002), ‘Use of adsorbent and supercritical carbon dioxide to concentrate flavor components from orange oil’, J Agric Food Chem, 50, 154–160.
Extraction of flavourings from natural sources
63
sides, a., robards, k. and helliwell, s. (2000), ‘Developments in extraction techniques and their application to analysis of volatiles in foods’, Trends Anal Chem, 19 (5), 322–329. singh, k. p. (1993), ‘Challenges and opportunities in essential oil processing industries’, Res Ind, 38 (2), 83–89. speiser, w. (1993), ‘Enzymes and the fruit juice industry – a love affair?’, Fruit Process, 2, 8–39. stuerga, d. and delmotte, m. (2002), ‘Wave-material interactions, microwave technology and equipment’, in Loupy A, Microwaves in Organic Synthesis, Weinheim, Wiley-VCH, 22–31. szentmihalyi, k., vinkler, p., lakatos, b., illes, v. and then, m. (2002), ‘Rose hip (Rosa canina L.) oil obtained from waste hip seeds by different extraction methods’, Biores Technol, 82 (2), 195–201. toma, m., vinatoru, m., paniwnyk, l. and mason, t. j. (2001), ‘Investigation of effects of ultrasound on vegetal tissues during solvent extraction’, Ultrason Sonochem, 8 (2), 137–142. venskutonis, p. r. (1997), Effect of drying on the volatile constituents of thyme (Thymus vulgaris L.) and sage (Salvia officinalis L.), Food Chem, 59 (2), 219– 227. vinatoru, m. (2001), ‘An overview of the ultrasonically assisted extraction of bioactive principles from herbs’, Ultrason Sonochem, 8 (3), 303–313. vinatoru, m., toma, m., radu, o., filip, p. i., lazurca, d. and mason, t. j. (1997), ‘The use of ultrasound for the extraction of bioactive principles from plant materials’, Ultrason Sonochem, 4 (2), 135–139. vinatoru, m., toma, m. and mason, t. j. (1999), ‘Ultrasonically assisted extraction of bioactive principles from plants and their constituents’, in Mason T J, Advances in Sonochemistry, Mason Stamford, CT, JAI Press Inc., 209–247. wang, z., ding, l., li, t., zhou, x., wang, l., zhang, h., liu, l., li, y., liu, z., wang, h., zeng, h. and he, h. (2006), ‘Improved solvent-free microwave extraction of essential oil from dried Cuminum cyminum L. and Zanthoxylum bungeanum Maxim, J Chromatogr A, 1102 (1–2), 11–17. werkhoff, p., brennecke, s., bretschneider, w. and bertram, h. j. (2002), ‘Modern methods for isolating and quantifying volatile flavor and fragrance compounds’, Food Sci Technol, 115, 139–204. wilkes, j. g., conte, e. d., kim, y., holcomb, m., sutherland, j. b., miller, d. w. (2000), ‘Sample preparation for the analysis of flavors and off-flavors in foods’, J Chromatog A, 880, 3–33. yeo, h. c. h. and shibamoto, t. (1991), ‘Chemical comparison of flavours in microwaved and conventionally heated foods’, Trends Food Sci Technol, 2, 329–332. yonei, y., ohinata, h., yoshida, r., shimizu, y. and yokoyama, c. (1995), ‘Extraction of ginger flavor with liquid or supercritical carbon dioxide’, J Supercrit Fluids, 8, 156–161. zabetakis, i., koulentianos, a., orruño, e. and boyes, i. (2000), ‘The effect of high hydrostatic pressure on strawberry flavour compounds’, Food Chem, 71, 51–55.
4 From fermentation to white biotechnology: how microbial catalysts generate flavours R. G. Berger, Leibniz University of Hannover, Germany
4.1
Introduction
4.1.1 Microbial generation of flavour Volatile flavours are long-range chemical signals. Fruits, vegetables and other plants produce them to attract pollinators, birds or other animals, or to repel microbial and animal invaders trying to feed on them. The recent interest in functional properties of food constituents has shown that many flavour compounds possess additional bioactivities (Berger, 1995): bipolar terpenes of essential oil plants and some carbonyls are antimicrobial, antifungal, anti-inflammatory or even antiviral; some volatile phenols are strong antioxidants; some volatile aldehydes inhibit the production of nitric oxide, a factor contributing to the regulation of blood pressure. Both the signalling properties and other functional properties are usually associated with one distinct form of two or more stereo-forms of the flavour compound (Berger, 1995). The recent example of the (±)-massoilactones, the (R)-isomer exhibiting a butter-coconut odour and the (S)-isomer being weaker and less specific (Watanabe, 2005), adds to a long list of structure–activity relationships of flavours. The biochemical precursors of flavours, mainly fatty and amino acids, isoprene units and phenylpropanoids, are ubiquitous in nature. Microorganisms modify these substrates along efficient and selective enzymatically accelerated pathways, similar to those operating in plant cells which, in the form of intact tissues, are called ‘food’. Still, the perception that microorganisms may deliver ‘edible’ food constituents is causing scepticism among consumers. Reasons may be that microorganisms are more associated with dangerous diseases and food spoilage than with fermented food and vital events during human digestion. Today, the microbial production
How microbial catalysts generate flavours
65
of flavours has developed into one of the most rapidly emerging areas of industrial biotechnology. More than 100 compounds are on the market, or are used for in-house flavour compositions, among them volatile aliphatic and aromatic alcohols (such as fusel alcohols and cinnamyl alcohol), acids and esters (such as 2-phenylethyl acetate and methyl jasmonate), aldehydes (such as hexenals and vanillin), ketones and methyl ketones, a series of 4and 5-alkanolides, and a few terpenoids (such as perillyl alcohol and nootkatone) (Berger, 1995).
4.1.2 Substrates, biocatalysts and naturalness of flavours Although many flavours and fragrances are easily produced through chemical synthesis, natural plant sources continue to provide most of the materials used in the food industry in the EU and the United States. Often natural flavours are more efficient and useful as building blocks. Microbial production of flavours benefits from the high selectivity and reaction rate of many microbial enzymes, as well as from the possibility of conducting multi-step syntheses in intact cells. The mild reaction conditions and the possibility of using renewable substrates are other, important advantages. In contrast to conventional agricultural production of plant material, none of these bioprocesses requires ecologically problematic fertilisers or pesticides, and they are not adversely affected by climate, weather, soil, trade barriers, sociopolitical instability and the like. The label ‘natural’, which is assigned if the precursor substrates used are of natural origins, carries positive connotations. Most consumers equate ‘natural’ with ‘unadulterated’ and ‘fresh’, and prefer such a food product over a competing product. As there is simply no other labelling option for food manufacturers, apart from the flavour ingredient used, they have to fall back on ‘natural’ flavours, if they want the magic word to appear on the tag. The high demand for ‘natural’ flavours is reflected by market prices up to 11000 per kg and higher, which is asked for popular flavours such as vanillin, raspberry ketone (II), 2,6-(E,Z)-nonadienal (cucumber; V) or nootkatone (grapefruit; I) (Fig. 4.1). This explains the plethora of research efforts in both the flavour industry and in academia. The world’s largest flavour producer, International Flavors and Fragrances, has recently published some fine examples of bioprocesses from its own labs (Kim & Eckert, 2003), and the CEO of Symrise, Germany’s leading flavour house, has stated that they ‘plan to grow mainly in the area of biotechnology’ (Hannoversche Allgemeine Zeitung, 2006). All kinds of microorganisms from small prokaryotic bacilli to complex eukaryotic fungi have been used for flavour modification and generation. Organisms generally recognised as safe (GRAS) (Schallmey et al., 2004) as classified by the US Food and Drug Administration are preferred, but numerous other species and even pathogens, such as Enterobacter or Serratia, have been patented for food flavour production. This sounds
66
Modifying flavour in food O
O HO O (II): Raspberry ketone (raspberry) (I): (+)-Nootkatone (grapefruit) O
(III): Perillene (rose)
O (V): (2E,6Z)-Nonadienal (cucumber)
O
HO
O (IV): Methyl jasmonate (lemon)
Fig. 4.1
O
O (VI): α-Sinensal (orange)
O
(VII): Furaneol (strawberry jam)
Some of the most sought-after natural flavours.
peculiar at first glance, but volatile flavours generally are small and hydrophobic molecules, hence, a large number of extraction, distillation and adsorption methods can be applied to separate a perfectly safe product from the by-products of fermentation. Because of the universal biochemical pathways, several microbial species can produce a certain flavour chemical. Roughly more than 20 different species were shown, for example, to produce 4-decanolide. It does matter, however, which strain is chosen, whether in concerted biotransformations or in traditional fermentations: large differences in the flavour profiles were recurrently observed when different strains were used (Estevez et al., 2004; Leclercq-Perlat et al., 2004; Paraggio & Fiore, 2004). As a result, the development of a successful bioprocess is inseparably linked to an extended screening of strains, substrates and nutrient media. This first, tedious phase of manual work often deters industrial researchers, but opportunities missed at this stage cannot be compensated by any means at a later stage of process development. Microorganisms can be used to carry out single-step reactions (biotransformation), sequential reactions (bioconversion), or de novo syntheses; they can likewise produce (Coghe et al., 2004) or eliminate (Blagden & Gilliland, 2005; Hambraeus & Nyberg, 2005) off-flavours. Indirect applications of microbial catalysts, not detailed in this chapter, are the hydrolytic disruption of polysaccharide walls in waste fruit or in barks, seeds and rhizomes (Galkina et al., 2004) for increasing the extraction yields and the treatment of plant tissues or extracts with glycosidases to liberate flavours from acetal precursors (Sarry & Gunata, 2004). The microbial formation of flavours will be presented, according to increasing levels of biochemical complexity and biotechnological effort, ranging from a single precursor to complex food substrates. Molecular engineering will be discussed as a tool for making genes related to flavour formation function on a larger technical scale. Finally, the biotechnological achievement of flavour production, the concept of ‘white biotechnology’
How microbial catalysts generate flavours
67
and future prospects in the field will be outlined using some examples from the most recent literature.
4.2
Flavour formation along known pathways
4.2.1 Isoprenoids Essential oils of higher plants contain numerous mono- and sesquiterpene hydrocarbons and an even larger number of oxyfunctionalised derivatives. The hydrocarbons dominate quantitatively, but are prone to autoxidation, resulting in the formation of turbidity and off-flavours and are therefore distilled off. Many of the oxyfunctionalised minor and trace constituents are valuable flavours, but the low concentrations often make isolation uneconomic. As early as the 1950s, this situation stimulated attempts to microbially transform or convert the waste hydrocarbons to more valuable flavour compounds. The common procedure starts with one of the readily available limonenes or pinenes as the precursor substrate, a local microbial isolate from a terpene-rich plant material, such as citrus peel, and a shake flask incubation in a standard medium (Kaspera et al., 2005b; Divyashree et al., 2006). Pseudomonas are the preferred bacterial strains, while fungi of the genus Aspergillus appear to be the eukaryotic strains of choice. Most yeasts, and particularly the common wine yeasts, are sensitive to higher concentrations of these monoterpenes and are thought to be useful only for esterifications to yield compounds such as geranyl and citronellyl acetate (King & Dickinson, 2003). Recently it was shown that microaerobic conditions combined with higher levels of nitrogen in the medium favoured the de novo synthesis of monoterpeneols by a strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Carrau et al., 2005). It was speculated that the actual concentrations of linalool, a monoterpenol with a low odour threshold in water, could be sensorially relevant. Oxygen insertion at the menthadiene skeleton regularly occurs at allylic positions resulting in the predominant formation of verbenol, verbenones, carveols, carvones and related compounds (Nazhat-ul-Ainn et al., 2002; de Carvalho & da Fonseca, 2005). In rare cases, an attack on nonactivated carbons was observed (Fig. 4.2) (Park et al., 2003; Krings et al., 2005). Typical problems encountered with this approach are the formation of mixtures of volatiles (and non-volatiles), cytotoxicity of both precursor and products (some flavours are antimicrobials!), and loss of both through the gas phase. Several options exist to overcome these drawbacks: screening for better strains, fed-batch addition of substrate, intermittent or continuous removal of product, use of tolerant or resting cells, immobilisation of the biocatalyst and genetic manipulation. An intriguing idea to overcome the poor water solubility of the substrate is to use a terpene alcohol as a precursor (Hrdlicka et al., 2004), but the primary (di-oxo) product is usually too polar to still possess flavour
68
Modifying flavour in food 1
(VIII)
O
OH
9
(X)
(IX)
O
OH (XI)
(XII)
Fig. 4.2 Unusual non-allylic transformation of γ-terpineol (VIII) by Stemphylium botryosum yielded p-mentha-1,4-dien-9-ol (IX), p-cymene-9-ol (XI), and the corresponding aldehydes (X,XII) (Krings et al., 2005).
properties. If, however, one of the oxo-functions is eliminated in a second step, a new flavour compound (here α-sinensal (VI) from nerolidol) can result. Another way to circumvent cytotoxicity, the use of isolated enzymes, was patented for the laccase catalysed conversion of valencene to nootkatone (Hitchman et al., 2005). This reaction is perhaps the ‘holy grail’ of flavour biotechnology, as the target compound is one of the most soughtafter character impact compounds (Fig. 4.1) (Kaspera et al., 2005a). Many papers and patents describing the reaction have been published, but attempts to reproduce the results have often failed. Even green algae (Chlorella fusca and Ch. pyrenoidosa) conduct this transformation with excellent yields (Furusawa et al., 2005), but the enzyme(s) behind its (their) regulation remain a mystery. The source of the relatively cheap ‘natural’ nootkatone that entered the market recently is unknown. The detection of the existence of two independent pathways to isopentenyl diphosphase was a great surprise for the biochemical community. In plants it appears that monoterpenes are generated through the novel plastidial DOXP/MEP (1-deoxy-d-xylulose/2-C-methyl-d-erythritol-4phosphate) pathway, while sesquiterpenes are formed along the classical cytosolic mevalonate and the novel pathway (Hampel et al., 2004). Both pathways show different discrimination of 13C. Thorough analyses of linalool enantiomers in strawberry have shown that the (R)-enantiomer was formed through the DOXP/MEP pathway, whereas the opposite enantioform was only found labelled after administration of [5,5-2H2]-mevalonic acid lactone (Hampel et al., 2006). These data will help in mapping quantitative trait loci (QTL) responsible for flavour properties of edible plants
How microbial catalysts generate flavours
69
(Sevini et al., 2004). A number of geranyl and farnesyl diphosphase cyclases have been identified on the cDNA level and have been cloned (Guterman et al., 2002; El Tamer et al., 2003; Sharon-Asa et al., 2003; Pechous & Whitaker, 2004, 2005), and first patents in the field have appeared (Aharoni et al., 2004, 2002; Green et al., 2004). Recombinant over-expression in homologous and heterologous plant hosts, for example in tobacco or in Arabidopsis, has not always been successful, but transcript analysis or antibody testing has sometimes proven the principle. The expression of valencene cyclase in Citrus was shown, among other factors, to be regulated by ethene, although citrus fruits are non-climacteric (Sharon-Asa et al., 2003). This result calls for a closer look at the various stages of fruit ripening and the role of ethene. While still little is known on the genetic basis of the introduction of oxygen in essential oil plants, some genes coding for redox enzymes are under investigation (Davis et al., 2005). It is believed that sets of genes can be transferred to microbial hosts such as Escherichia coli (Keasling et al., 2004). A metabolically engineered E. coli strain could combine the rapid growth and straightforward bioprocessing of a prokaryont with the complex flavour-producing capabilities of a higher plant. First examples of a functional over-expression of sesquiterpene cyclases (Keasling et al., 2004) and polyketide complexes (Wenzel & Mueller, 2005) have demonstrated the feasibility of this idea. Some members of the C-13 norisoprenoid family (ionones, damasc(en)ones) belong to the most potent flavours on earth. Several lines of evidence (structural similarities, co-occurrence in non-heated fruit tissues, correlation of pigmentation and pattern of volatiles; Zhou et al., 2004; Lewinsohn et al., 2005a, b) suggested their formation through an oxidative cleavage of the 9,10 double bond of tetraterpenoid precursor molecules, the carotenoids (Fig. 4.3). However, the existence of competing chemical degradation pathways (autoxidation, photo-oxidation, thermal degradation and combinations of the pathways; Nonier et al., 2004; Baldermann et al., 2005) complicated the assessment of an enzymatic contribution. The final proof was missing until the identification of the maize enzyme VP14 (Schwartz et al., 1997). VP14 cleaves 9-(Z)-epoxy carotenoids specifically at the 11,12 double bond. Today, a set of regiospecific carotenoid degrading enzymes from plant and animal sources has been well characterised, for example from tomato (Simkin et al., 2004a). A circadian regulation of a carotenoid dioxygenase was identified in petunia flowers, and the lightinduced expression of the coding gene was followed on the transcription level (Simkin et al., 2004b). Biotic carotenoid degradation by microorganisms, however, is less explored, although some 100 million tonnes of carotenoids are synthesised annually in nature and obviously disposed subsequently. Mixed cultures of Trichosporon asahii and Paenibacillus amylolyticus degraded lutein extracted from marigold flowers (RodriguezBustamante et al., 2005). The presence of both species was required for the formation of the norisoprenoid flavours, with 7,8-dihydro-β-ionol as the
70
Modifying flavour in food
1
1
1
O
O O
O (XIV): β-Cyclocitral
(XIII): Isophorone
9
1
(XV): Dihydroactinidiolid
(XVI)
(HO)
O
O 1
9
(XVII): β-Ionone
1
(XVIII): β-Damascenone
1
(XIX): (E,E)-Megastigma-4,6,8-triene
Fig. 4.3 β,β-carotene and other carotenoids are precursors of norisoprenoid flavours.
main compound. The same researchers have found another community composed of a Geotrichum species capable of cleaving lutein, while a Bacillus species further converted the primary product, β-ionone, to the above ionol and the corresponding ketone (Maldonado-Robledo et al., 2003). An extracellular, so-called ‘versatile’ peroxidase of the edible fungus Pleurotus eryngii (previously erroneously classified as Lepista irina) degraded β, β-carotene to β-ionone, β-cyclocitral, dihydroactinidiolide and 2-hydroxy-2,6,6-trimethylcyclohexanone (Zorn et al., 2003a). β-Apo-10′carotenal was identified as a non-volatile degradation product using APcI+LC-MS (atmospheric pressure chemical ionisation (positive mode)–liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry). A similar enzyme, also capable of asymmetric carotenoid cleavage, was isolated from Marasmius scorodonius (Zorn et al., 2003b). Versatile peroxidases are a novel class of peroxidases which combine the catalytic properties of lignin peroxidase and manganese peroxidase. Basidiomycetes are obviously forming them in a response to their versatile chemical environment. As saprophytic organisms they depend on an exo-proteome with a broad substrate specificity to survive in their natural habitat: they live and feed on wood (Zorn et al., 2005). The first specific carotenoid cleaving enzymes, however, probably coevolved with the first phototrophic organisms, the cyanobacteria (blue algae), because carotenoids are accessory pigments of the photosynthetic
How microbial catalysts generate flavours O
O
Carboxylation
O
O
HO
O
Hydrogenation
O
(XX)
O
HO
O
HO SCoA
(XXV)
OH
Dehydratisation
O
CoA-transfer
O (XXII)
(XXI)
O
OH
HO
OH
OH
71
(XXIV)
Hydrogenation
O O
HO
OH
(XXIII)
OH
Isomerisation (B12)
O HO
O
Decarboxylation SCoA
(XXVI)
Fig. 4.4
O
O
CoA-re-transfer SCoA
OH
(XXVII)
(XXVIII)
The methyl malonyl-CoA pathway of Propionibacterium starts with lactate oxidation to pyruvate.
apparatus. The occurrence of several norisoprenoids in freshwater contaminated by cyanobacteria suggests that similar cleavage enzymes must be present (Hockelmann and Jüttner, 2005). As in lipoxygenase-initiated oxidation reactions, some of the volatiles are generated after disintegration of the cells, perhaps as allelopathic signals. Aquatic nematodes which feed on cyanobacteria perceive these volatiles and respond to single or multicomponent stimuli. As ultra-traces of some norisoprenoids are also perceived by humans, the abundant occurrence of cyanobacteria in eutrophic waters (‘water bloom’) regularly evokes consumers complaints.
4.2.2 Lipid metabolites, esters and alcohol acyltransferases There are several pathways leading to short-chain carboxylic acids: ester hydrolysis (E.C. 3.1.1.1 and 3.1.1.11), lipolysis (E.C. 3.1.1.3 and phospholipases) followed by β-oxidation, oxidation of fermentation alcohols or of Strecker aldehydes, or carboxylation of pyruvate through methylmalonylCoA to eventually yield propanoate. Lipases and the β-oxidation multienzyme complex are ubiquitous, but the oxidation of methanol, ethanol, other alcohols or short-chain aliphatic aldehydes is a pronounced trait of strains of Acetobacter, Gluconobacter, lactococci and lactobacilli (Ganesan et al., 2004; Tungjaroenchai et al., 2004). The methyl malonyl-CoA pathway operates in coryneform bacteria of the genus Propionibacterium and contributes much to the typical sensory character of Swiss cheese (Fig. 4.4)
72
Modifying flavour in food
(Thierry et al., 2005). The same pathway operates in the reverse direction to degrade branched chain skeletons as in l-valine, l-isoleucine and oddchain fatty acids. Lipoxygenases (E.C. 1.13.11.12) catalyse the regio- and stereoselective introduction of molecular oxygen into unsaturated fatty acids. In the microbial world, the occurrence of active lipoxygenases is typical of many fungi. Strains of the genera Aspergillus (Hall et al., 2004) and Penicillium (Husson et al., 2004; Hall et al., 2005) were the focus of interest. The main products were 10-hydroperoxides with (S)-oriented chiral carbon. Cleavage of these hydroperoxides yields 1-octen-3-(R)-ol, (Z)-1,5-octadien-3-(R)-ol, and corresponding ketones (plus a non-volatile oxo-acid), compounds that determine the typical ‘mushroom’ odour of edible fungi and the surfaces of Camembert cheese and mould-ripened sausages. Supplementation of submerged cultures of Penicillium camemberti with soybean oil enhanced the concentration of 1-octen-3-ol (Husson et al., 2004). Much better investigated are the isoforms of lipoxygenases in plants. The antisense technique was used to show the contribution of TomloxC to the flavour formation of tomato fruit. The chloroplastidal association of the isoform was confirmed using a TomloxC-green fluorescent protein fusion product and imaging of recombinant tobacco leaves (Chen et al., 2004). Esters of short-chain carboxylic acids and alcohols impart a large variety of delicious fruity flavour notes and are not only important in fruit and all sweet flavours, but also in alcoholic beverages and dairy products (Liu et al., 2004; Stewart, 2005). Direct ester condensation is unlikely to occur in most foods, but may play a limited role in low water activity systems stored over extended periods of time, such as Parmesan cheese (Holland et al., 2005). In the field of industrial flavour biotechnology, however, the same reaction (reverse hydrolysis) using lipases isolated from yeasts, such as Candida rugosa (Bezbradica et al., 2006) or Candida antarctica (Larios et al., 2004) in organic solvents, has become one of the biggest success stories. Numerous esters including those possessing aryl or isoprenoid moieties are amenable to reverse hydrolysis through a simple, one-pot reaction. Sometimes, the alkyl moiety may serve as the solvent; removal of the reaction water from the equilibrium is mandatory and can be achieved by condensation, molecular sieve, distillation or a membrane technique. If both acyl and alkyl moieties were derived from natural sources, the ester thus obtained is classified as ‘natural’. In line with this mechanism, a sake yeast was constructed by transferring the gene of an isoamyl acetate hydrolysing enzyme from Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Fukuda, 2004). Most esters in food, however, owe their formation to thermodynamically preferred alcohol acetyltransfer reactions (AAT, E.C.2.3.1.84) (Fig. 4.5). Saccharomyces cerevisiae contains at least three alcohol acetyltransferases (Verstrepen et al., 2003b). Deletion and over-expression experiments have established functional correlations (Van Laere et al., 2005). Factors found to affect the enzyme activity in the living cell are oxygen partial pressure,
How microbial catalysts generate flavours O
R'
O
OH
+ R
SCoA (XXIX)
AAT
73
R
OR'
HSCoA
(XXX)
Fig. 4.5 Alcohol acetyltransferases catalyse the microbial formation of flavour esters.
presence of unsaturated fatty acids, and glucose concentration (Verstrepen et al., 2003a; Fujiwara, 2004). Low substrate affinity of a purified AAT indicated that the formation of volatile esters may be just a side-aspect of an unknown physiological role (Van Laere et al., 2005). As the enzyme is located in lipid particles, a specific function in the cell’s lipid or sterol metabolism was suggested (Verstrepen et al., 2004b). To counteract the public concern about genetically engineered organisms, a ‘self-cloning’ sake yeast was constructed (Hirosawa et al., 2004). The yeast contained a constitutive promoter from the glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase gene fused to the transferase gene, and produced increased concentrations of isoamyl acetate. The authors claimed that this was the first example of an expression-controlled industrial yeast. Heterologous expression of AAT genes from yeast and strawberry in E. coli was also successful, as proven again by increased levels of isoamyl acetate (Vadali et al., 2004; Horton and Bennett, 2006). Such strains will neither replace reverse lipolysis nor brewer’s yeast in traditional fermentations, because they depend on supplementation of exogenous substrate. They present, however, valuable genetic models to estimate the specificity and efficiency of the various isoenzymes, and to study means of enhancing CoA or acetyl-CoA levels in the cell. AATs of melon (Yahyaoui et al., 2002), strawberry and banana (Beekwilder et al., 2004), apple (Souleyre et al., 2005) and grape (Wang & De Luca, 2005) have now been characterised on the protein or nucleic acid level. These are all candidate genes for studies in prokaryotic hosts. Availability of the alkyl precursor moiety was limiting in the E. coli system (Beekwilder et al., 2004), as well as in ripe apple fruit (Echeverria et al., 2004). This agrees with earlier experiments which showed a strong increase of ethyl ester concentrations in apples stored in an atmosphere containing ethanol vapours (Berger & Drawert, 1984). The common β-oxidation of fatty acids proceeds, as the name suggests, via 3-hydroxy acyl-CoA intermediates. If hydroxylation of the acyl chain occurs in the γ- or δ-position instead, CoA-esters are formed which easily cyclise upon hydrolysis of the thioester bond to form five or six membered lactone rings. The resulting alkanolides are potent flavours imparting fruity, nutty, buttery or coconut-like notes. As with the open-chain esters, decreasing water activity, as occurs for example during ripening of Gouda cheese, favours lactone formation (Alewijn et al., 2005). It has not been unambiguously determined if the hydroxy function is derived from a microbial
74
Modifying flavour in food
activity or from an autoxidative side reaction. The primrose pathway to high yields of lactones has turned out to be due to the presence of large amounts of exogenous γ- or δ-hydroxy fatty acid. Castor oil and Massoia oil contain the required precursors. Geotrichum fragrans and other Geotrichum species accumulated γ-decalactone after enzymatically hydrolysed Castor oil was supplemented (Neto et al., 2004). The alkane-assimilating yeast Yarrowia lipolytica is particularly suited for the uptake, transport and oxidation of hydrophobic moieties and produced significant amounts of γ-decalactone from methyl ricinoleate (Fickers et al., 2005). To increase the actual precursor concentration in the aqueous medium, surfactants were added (Aguedo et al., 2004). It turned out, however, that some of the surfactants tested were toxic themselves, and the availability of methyl ricinoleate was not limiting the conversion rate, as was shown by zeta potential measurements (Aguedo et al., 2005). A Yarrowia lipolytica that lacked one of the five acyl-CoA oxidase isoforms was constructed and showed 10 times increased lactone levels (Groguenin et al., 2004). This finding not only provided evidence for the involvement of this enzyme in lactone degradation, but also revealed that microbial flavour compounds, which have been target compounds in the past, have often been erroneously considered as end products of the metabolism. Labelling studies, performed using Sporobolomyces odorus, another lactone-producing yeast, demonstrated an enzymatic Bayer–Villiger oxidation and provided a sound experimental basis on which to develop a bioprocess (Garbe & Tressl, 2006). If the rate of degradation is in the same order of magnitude as the rate of formation, accumulation of product will never reach anything like an attractive level. Blocking of the degrading enzymes by metabolic engineering is one option; selective in situ recovery of the target product is another one (Dufosse et al., 2002).
4.2.3 Phenolics After the structural elucidation of benzaldehyde, coumarin, vanillin and other aroma compounds was accomplished towards the end of the nineteenth century, the early natural product chemists believed that flavour properties were linked to the presence of an ‘aromatic’ ring. Today we know that volatile flavours may carry all kinds of functional groups, and the above benzene derivatives and many others, such as phenylethyl and cinnamyl derivatives, have been described from many microbial cultures. The most popular phenolic flavour of the world, vanillin, has attracted a lot of research. Genuine vanillin is obtained from Vanilla planifolia Andrews by solvent extraction (Stockfleth & Fiebig, 2004). The epiphytic orchid is difficult to grow and to pollinate (Havkin-Frenkel et al., 2005), and the pods need a multi-step treatment called curing (hot water scalding, sweating, drying, conditioning; Havkin-Frenkel et al., 2004) so that endogenous glycoside precursors can make contact with glycosidases located in the outer fruit wall region to achieve the full flavour (Setyaningsih et al., 2005). Isolation
How microbial catalysts generate flavours HO
O
HO
O
HO
OCH 3 OH (XXXI)
Fig. 4.6
HO O
OCH3 OH (XXXII)
O – Acetate
O
OCH3 OH (XXXIII)
75
OCH3 OH (XXXIV)
Ferulic acid is the most common precursor of biotech vanillin.
and extraction may be improved by treating the pods with cellulases (Ponzone et al., 2004). All together, these obstacles limit the supply of vanillin ex Vanilla, resulting in small market and a high price (up to $4000 per kg in years of poor harvest). Biotechnology offers alternative solutions. More than 20 bioprocesses have been described to produce vanillin, from the use of isolated enzymes, to complex plant cell cultures as catalysts. Recent work has concentrated on the bioconversion of phenylpropanoid precursors, such as ferulic, pcoumaric or cinnamic acid or coniferyl aldehyde which contain a pre-formed vanillin structure and are readily available from agricultural wastes, such as rice or oat bran (Fig. 4.6). Haematococcus pluvialis (Tripathi et al., 2002), E. coli (Torre et al., 2004) or Streptomyces halstedii and many other Actinomycetes (Brunati et al., 2004) formed vanillin and related volatiles in submerged culture and also when immobilised and operated in a fixed-bed column (Torre et al., 2004). Transient accumulation and low peak concentrations indicated a further conversion of the target compound, an observation also made with suspension cultures of Capsicum annuum L. fed with ferulic acid (Kang et al., 2005). Some of the phenolic intermediates are prone to one or two electron oxidation reactions, yielding stable radicals and phenolic acids. They are funnelled to lignin biosynthesis and reappear in plant cell walls in bound and free forms (Suresh et al., 2003). One may recall that alkaline hydrolysis of corn hulls started chemical vanillin production and industrial flavour production in Germany. The construction of a Pseudomonas strain, which has vanillin oxidase activity blocked, results in a yield of several grams of vanillin per litre and has solved the problem of catabolism (Priefert et al., 2001). Chemical losses due to reactions of the aldehyde group with constituents of the nutrient medium or with itself may be reduced by application of an adsorbent or another appropriate in situ technique.
4.2.4 Amino acids and derivatives Some amino acids are important precursors in microbial flavour syntheses, especially in lactic acid bacteria (Ardoe, 2006). Acetoin and diacetyl in
76
Modifying flavour in food L-Ile
O
C
or L-Leu COOH
L-Glu
O
C
COOH
O
C
COOH
or COOH
(XXXVI)
(XXXVII)
(XXXV) – CO 2 O
O
C
C
or (XXXVIII)
Fig. 4.7
(XXXIX)
Typical fermentation flavours from α-ketoglutarate assisted transaminations.
lactobacilli are derived from aspartate (Kieronczyk et al., 2004), while the synthesis of the branched-chain amino acids (Val, Leu, Ileu) yields 2methylpropanol, n-butanal, 2- and 3-methylbutanal and related redox derivatives as side products. The analogous volatiles derived from the aromatic (Phe, Tyr, Trp) and the sulphur-containing amino acids (Cys, Met) are also contributors to many plant and fermentation flavours. The addition of blends of amino acids to alcoholic or lactic fermentations must therefore lead to intensified or modified flavours (Capelle, 2004; Herranz et al., 2005). Enzymatic hydrolysis of endogenous proteins by added endo- or exopeptidases is an obvious alternative (Blinkovsky et al., 2004; Jin et al., 2004; Kania & Stasinska, 2004). More recently, peptidases and transpeptidases with improved substrate specificity were discovered for treating dough (Edens & Hille, 2005), dry sausage (Benito et al., 2005a), cocoa nibs (Sousa de Brito et al., 2004), or to elevate the levels of the umami compounds glutamic and aspartic acid (Sakamoto et al., 2004) and theanine (Suzuki & Kumagai, 2004). Many of the novel peptidases are from filamentous fungi, typically from Aspergillus strains such as A. oryzae (‘Flavorzyme®’ from Novo Nordisk Bioindustrials). Solid-state fermentation appears to be the most efficient way for their production (Nampoothiri et al., 2005). The metabolic driving force in lactic fermentations appears to be regeneration of α-ketoglutarate (Fig. 4.7) (Helinck et al., 2004; Tjener et al., 2004a). As a general amino group acceptor, the keto acid is key to the formation of other keto acids from amino acids. These are then either converted to acyl-CoA intermediates or decarboxylated and the resulting aldehydes are reduced or oxidised to typical fermentation volatiles. A diverse microflora of the genera Lactococcus, Lactobacillus, Streptococcus, Leuconostoc, Bifidobacterium, Propionibacterium, Brevibacterium, Corynebacterium and Arthrobacter is found in fermented dairy products,
How microbial catalysts generate flavours
77
but a broader screening has indicated that only a few of these strains possessed high decarboxylase activity (B. A. Smit et al., 2004a). Pronounced metabolic differences were found between various strains of lactobacilli (Thage et al., 2005), between non-starter strains (Williams et al., 2004a) and between strains of the smear population (Williams et al., 2004b). Genetic work in this area has been initiated, for example, the cloning of a decarboxylase gene of Lactococcus lactis (B. A. Smit et al., 2005). Volatile breakdown products of amino acids also control the overall sensory quality of dry sausages (Tjener et al., 2004a). Pediococcus pentosaceus and Staphylococcus carnosus or S. xylosus dominate the microflora. High inoculation levels of S. carnosus stimulated the formation of the methyl-branched acids and aldehydes, phenylacetaldehyde, dimethylsulphide, and dimethyltrisulphide (Tjener et al., 2004b). Studies using isotopelabelled leucine showed that α-ketoglutarate was a less efficient amino group acceptor than α-keto-β-methylvaleric acid and α-ketoisovaleric acid (Beck et al., 2004), and that the concentration of 3-methylbutanoic acid was lowered and α-hydroxyisocaproic acid was increased by adding nitrate or nitrite (Olesen et al., 2004). It was concluded that the sensorially important compounds are intermediates on a route leading to branched-chain fatty acids, as they constitute the major fraction in cell wall lipids.
4.2.5 Thio-compounds The large sulphur atom is easily polarised and interacts rapidly with electrophilic compounds and Lewis acids. This explains why trace concentrations of many volatile thio-compounds are sufficient to change receptor protein conformation and to trigger the cascade of sensory perception. The only immediate metabolic sources of sulphur are l-cysteine and l-methionine. Brevibacteria are often cited for their pronounced ability to form volatile sulphur compounds, as they possess a lyase converting l-methionine to methanethiol, α-ketobutanoate and ammonia (Amarita et al., 2004). The lyase gene of B. linens was recently cloned (Amarita et al., 2004), and transformation of the same species using common plasmids from lactic acid bacteria was demonstrated (Nardi et al., 2005). The degradation of methionine by yeasts usually starts with transamination yielding 4-methylthio2-oxo-butanoic acid (Bondar et al., 2005). Yeasts can also transform cysteine–carbonyl conjugates to release volatile thiols (Fig. 4.8). This reaction was applied for the concerted production of furfurylthiol, a coffee flavour compound (Huynh-Ba et al., 2003), but also plays a role in the formation of 4-mercapto-4-methylpentan-2-one and 2-methyltetrahydrothiophen-3-one in wine (Howell et al., 2005). Similar thio-ether bond cleaving activities of Eubacterium limosum and E. coli were used for the enantioselective liberation of 3-mercaptohexanol (Wakabayashi et al., 2002). Wild yeasts isolated from the surface of truffles (Buzzini et al., 2005a) and basidiomycetous yeasts (Buzzini et al., 2005b), when grown on
78
Modifying flavour in food
O
+
COOH
HS
O
RT
H N O
NH2
(XL)
(XLI) SH
+
b-Lyase
COOH
S (XLII)
NH3 + Pyruvate
O (XLIII)
Fig. 4.8
Thiazolidine ‘conjugates’ can be enzymatically converted to potent thiol flavours.
methionine as the sole nitrogen source, produced numerous volatile thiocompounds. As soon as the respective genes have been identified, cloning and overexpression into more convenient hosts are expected.
4.3
Flavours from complex substrates
4.3.1 Fermentations dominated by lactic acid bacteria The starting materials of traditional food fermentations, such as milk, butter, cereals, soybean, meat, fruit musts and vegetables (cabbage, olives), contain all of the above substrates for microbial flavour modification pathways. In the presence of complex isoprenoids, lipids, phospholipids and peptides, a broad spectrum of volatiles is formed, even by simple prokaryotics. Some recent highlights in this field of flavour modification are presented. The secondary or malolactic fermentation of (red) wine by Oenococcus or Lactobacillus strains not only converts malate to the less acidic lactate (plus CO2), but is also known to alter the composition of amino acids and volatile flavours (Pozo-Bayon et al., 2005). The known sensory changes have not been analytically substantiated for a long time. Recently, it was found that the concentration of ethyl esters from butanoate to octanoate and 3-methylbutyl acetate increased (Ugliano & Moio, 2005). Glycosidases of lactobacilli were able to hydrolyse flavour precursors of wine, a trait that was formerly supposed to be more associated with fungi (Grimaldi et al., 2005). Analogous findings were reported for malt whisky fermentations. Lactic acid bacteria formed esters and led to increased concentrations of flavours, such as damascenone (Priest & Cachat, 2004), a potent norisoprenoid compound known to occur in the glycoside fraction of many fruits. Microbial decarboxylation of coumaric and ferulic acid to 4-vinylphenol and 4-vinylguaiacol was beneficial to the flavour of the distilled beverage. The contribution of Lactobacillus frucivorans and Lactobacillus sanfranciscensis to the flavour modification of sourdough has been established in a thorough study (Czerny et al., 2005). Among the key volatiles were 2,4-(E,E)-decadienal, (2E)-nonenal, 2- and 3-methylbutanal, ethyl butanoate and acetic acid.
How microbial catalysts generate flavours
79
These data will support future screenings for other lactobacilli with a stronger flavour formation potential. The important transformation of arginine to ornithine, the precursor of the key volatile acetylpyrroline in bread, has also been investigated (Ganzle et al., 2005).
4.3.2 Fermentations dominated by yeasts Hundreds of yeast strains have been selected and deposited in culture collections over the last decades for the optimum fermentation of beer wort and grape must. Still, a need for strains with novel properties appears to exist, for example, to release glycosidically bound flavours (Alexandre et al., 2004) or to produce icewine (Erasmus et al., 2004). If a satisfactory result cannot be achieved with a Saccharomyces strain, another yeast may be applied. Pichia membranaefaciens, long regarded as one of the undesirable ‘wild’ yeasts, converted Chardonnay and Pinot noir musts into products with a sparkling wine flavour (Mamede et al., 2004), and other wild strains gave Cachaças (a sugarcane spirit) with acceptable flavour (Oliveira et al., 2005). Even a member of the subdivision Basidiomycotina, the edible fungus Pleurotus ostreatus, was successfully used in rice fermentations to produce a ‘high flavour’ alcoholic beverage (Takizawa et al., 2005). As in alcoholic fermentations, wild yeast are regarded as undesirable in cheeses, but artisanal products in particular are rich in Debaromyces, Kluyveromyces, Geotrichum and Candida strains (Fadda et al., 2004). The flavours generated by Debaromyces have been evaluated in more detail (Flores et al., 2004; Andrade et al., 2005). Ethyl esters and the above discussed volatiles from branched-chain amino acids were most prominent. Enhanced proteolysis, as was achieved in ham with purified fungal peptidases (Benito et al., 2004, 2005a), was also the main motive for suggesting the addition of a nontoxigenic strain of Penicillium chrysogenum to dry-cured sausage (Benito et al., 2005b), while the role of Penicillia occurring as the surface flora on Salami-type sausages is obviously limited to the protection of meat lipids from autoxidation (Hierro et al., 2005).
4.3.3 Sequential and combined fermentations Advanced proteolysis of (milk) proteins bears the risk of generating bitter peptides. Microbial communities may remedy the situation, as they provide an integrative set of complementing peptidolytic activities. Lactic fermentations were improved by Leuconostoc strains isolated from artisanal cheese (Sanchez et al., 2005), by wild heterofermentative lactobacilli (Ortigosa et al., 2005), or by a combination of three lactic acid bacteria (Garde et al., 2006). Increased levels of free amino acids and decreased bitterness due to lower concentrations of hydrophobic peptides were found. The close association of some yeasts and lactic acid bacteria in nature was imitated in dairy fermentations using wild yeasts combined with lactic acid bacteria and
80
Modifying flavour in food
Brevibacterium linens (Arfi et al., 2004), or combinations of yeasts with starter cultures (De Wit et al., 2005). The effect of the yeast may be indirect, by raising the pH value of the fermentation, or direct, for example, by transforming methanethiol accumulated by the bacterium to S-methylthioacetate (Arfi et al., 2005). When curd was sequentially treated with proteolytic and lipolytic enzymes, an improved enzyme-modified cheese flavour was obtained (Kilcawley et al., 2006). A synthetic combination of five species comprising yeasts, lactic acid and acetic acid bacteria mimicked the regular fermentation of cocoa and resulted in a good quality chocolate (Schwan & Wheals, 2004). Amylomyces rouxii, a mould and S. cerevisiae in the form of starter granules, worked together in rice wine brewing (Dung et al., 2005). The European counterpart to this idea was the use of Pichia fermentans in a first must fermentation to produce flavours, and of S. cerevisiae in a second step to increase ethanol levels to the required 12–13%vol (ClementeJimenez et al., 2005).
4.3.4 Progress through molecular engineering Saccharomyces cerevisiae has developed into the eukaryotic workhorse of the molecular biologists. Now that the entire genome is known, concerted improvements of bioprocesses are possible. Common malo-lactic fermentation, for example, was replaced by a transfer of the malo-ethanolic genes from Schizosaccharomyces pombe to S. cerevisiae. To this end, malate permease and malic enzyme genes were put under regulation elements from the 3-phosphoglycerate kinase and heterologously expressed in S. cerevisiae. The marker gene was removed so that the final recombinant construct contained yeast genes only. An efficient malo-ethanolic pathway without negative side effects was hence achieved in a GRAS organism (Volschenk et al., 2004). The genes of amino acid degradation are at the centre of interest. It was observed that lowering the standard fermentation pH of 5 to 3 was followed by maximum formation of 3-methylbutanol (Schoondermark-Stolk et al., 2006). A genome-wide expression analysis using a cDNA microarray showed that more than 700 genes were induced or repressed by the pH shift, among them 7 genes related to the 3-methylbutanol pathway. However, the constitutive expression of the only decarboxylase gene which was transcriptionally up-regulated when leucine, methionine or phenylalanine was the only source of nitrogen, did not lead to any 2-oxoacid decarboxylase activity in a wild strain grown on ammonia (Vuralhan et al., 2005). It was concluded that an unknown second protein or transcriptional regulation accounted for this unexpected result. A single base exchange in a structural gene can completely alter metabolic equilibria. Yeast mutants with enhanced leucine uptake produced significantly more isoamyl alcohol and isoamyl acetate (Abe & Horikoshi, 2005). For one of these mutants, a defect of the LEU4 gene (coding for α-isopropylmalate synthase) caused by the exchange of
How microbial catalysts generate flavours
81
just one amino acid was found (Matsuta et al., 2004). These experiments have also confirmed the causal correlation of amino acid synthesis and fusel alcohol formation. The substitution of Met for Thr-62 in a farnesyl diphosphase synthase produced a mutant with an altered accumulation of higher terpenoids (Watanabe et al., 2002). The accumulating volatile terpenols imparted a Muscat-like aroma to sake produced with this strain. The transfer of glucosidase genes from Saccharomycopsis fibuligera increased terpenol levels by a more efficient hydrolysis of the glucoside precursors present in wine musts (van Rensburg et al., 2005). A more exploratory study transferred a methyl transferase of Antirrhinum majus (an ornamental plant) into S. cerevisiae (Farhi et al., 2006). Using benzoic acid as the substrate, small amounts of (antifungal) methyl benzoate were formed. Until recently, this kind of biotransformation relied on enzymes present in the selected strain. The novel tools of molecular biology now open access to any metabolite, not only flavours, in a host microorganism, although experimental hurdles have often been observed.
4.4
White biotechnology
4.4.1 Flavours from renewable substrates and agro-industrial wastes The steadily increasing price of crude oil is a clear signal of the limited resources of the planet. Alarming reports, such as the one issued by the Club of Rome, have eventually pricked the political consciousness. The European Commission has decided to support white biotechnologies; these are biocatalyst-based, sustainable processes of high ecological compatibility, i.e. using renewable resources, little energy and water, no toxic solvents or processing aids, and producing less waste streams than conventional production plants. A recent survey stated that the chemical industry in Germany produces more than 2 million tonnes of raw materials (equal to 12% of the total demand) from renewable sources (www.chemische-industrie.de/). The most familiar biotransformations in the flavour field start from renewables; simple hydrolyses of oils, proteins, starch, or of whole cells yield peptides, amino acids, nucleotides, fatty acids and small saccharides. Formation of volatile esters by reverse hydrolysis and some redox reactions on carbonyls starting from renewable compounds, such as fatty and amino acids or terpenes, were developed in the 1980s and found industrial application. The ‘green chemistry’ approach in combination with the ancient dream of the alchemists – production of gold from base metals – has resulted in a new look at agro-industrial waste streams. Side-streams of food processing, such as flavour condensates, and waste streams of traditional fermentations, such as starter culture distillates and wine lees oil are still used as flavouring materials. Modern biotechnology offers new options: fish waste was hydrolysed to a fish sauce containing more than 100 volatiles (Shih et al., 2003), and similarly squid skin (Huang et al., 2004) and a by-product of snow crab
82
Modifying flavour in food
processing (Baek et al., 2003) were treated enzymatically to yield flavour. Refined processes for the improvement of yeast (Komorowska et al., 2003) and gluten (Romero & Ho, 2005) hydrolysates are under development. A novel aspect is heating the hydrolysates to generate thermal flavours (Huang et al., 2004; Baek et al., 2003; Romero & Ho, 2005), and also the reverse approach, to first react a solution of Maillard precursors by heating and then to ferment them using baker’s yeast has been reported (Ota, 2005). Lactic acid bacteria growing in a semi-solid corn-based medium produced a flavour rich in diacetyl (Escamilla-Hurtado et al., 2005), and cassava bagasse, a large-scale agro-waste in Brazil, was fermented in packed-bed reactors using Kluyveromyces marxianus to generate volatile flavours (Medeiros et al., 2001). Fruity flavours, mainly smaller esters, were produced by Ceratocystis fimbriata grown on coffee husks in a solid-state fermentation (Medeiros et al., 2006). Today, attention is directed towards elucidating unusual substrates (Santos et al., 2003) and novel species, such as Basidiomycetes (Jang et al., 2004). The cold synthesis of thermal flavours (Rungsardthong & Noomhoom, 2005) and the highly enantioselective synthesis of both enantiomers of a given compound (Cappaert & Larroche, 2004) have presented challenging research goals. Not all of the suggested processes will find their way into industry, but the ubiquitous occurrence of flavour precursors and the universal biochemical pathways will facilitate future developments.
4.4.2 Advances in bioprocessing After a stable and productive microorganism or enzyme has been identified, it is the role of the bioengineer to select the most appropriate physical working conditions, to install peripheral devices for process monitoring and product recovery, and to scale-up the process. In the past, attempts to produce flavours through biotechnology have often neglected these aspects. Flavour precursors and products are special: often unstable, cytotoxic, usually hydrophobic, and easily lost through the off-gas stream of an aerobic cultivation. The status of a bioprocess is monitored on-line by measuring pH value, dissolved oxygen and cell density. These data are thought to correlate with metabolic activity and events, but are obviously not very meaningful. Adverse effects of cultivation parameters on flavour accumulation and the phase of maximum product concentration may well be missed. Fibre optic and fluorescence probes are available to measure intra- and extracellular metabolite concentrations (Hagedorn et al., 2004), and electronic noses to monitor, for example, wine fermentation, even in the presence of excess ethanol (Pinheiro et al., 2002). Genotypes of lactobacilli were distinguished using a mass spectrometer as a particularly efficient ‘electronic nose’ (Marilley et al., 2004). Our insufficient knowledge of the microbial pathways leading to volatile flavours is often reflected by trial-and-error approaches. Labelling studies
How microbial catalysts generate flavours COOH
COOH
NH2
OH
OAc
O
TA
(XLIV)
O
83
DC
(XLV)
Red
(XLVI)
AAT
(XLVII)
(XLVIII)
Fig. 4.9 Conversion of l-phenylalanine through transamination, decarboxylation, hydrogenation and esterification (TA, transaminase; DC, decarboxylase; Red, reductase; AAT, alcohol acyltransferase).
are still rare (Beck et al., 2004; Hampel et al., 2004; Zorn et al., 2004). After fundamental biochemical data on the metabolism of phenylalanine were discovered (Wittmann et al., 2002), a yeast-based process for the generation of gram per litre concentrations of 2-phenylethanol and 2-phenylethylacetate was successfully developed (Etschmann et al., 2004, 2005) (Fig 4.9). Both a hydrophobic precursor (edible oil, terpene hydrocarbon) and a flavour product may exert toxic effects on the biocatalyst. As the established separation technologies of the flavour industry (distillation, extraction, squeezing) inevitably harm the biocatalyst, other processing strategies have been developed. Fed-batch application of precursor and variants of in situ product recovery, such as adsorption and membrane techniques, were introduced. Organophilic pervaporation is the method of choice if the precursor, as in the above case of phenylalanine (Etschmann et al., 2005), is a compound highly soluble in water. On the other hand, reaction water was withdrawn from the esterification reactions leading to 3-methylbutylacetate or bornyl acetate, using hydrophilic membranes to drive the equilibrium towards the product side (Ehrenstein et al., 2005; Izak et al., 2005). A white biotechnology process is well complemented by such cold separation techniques. A tremendous number of experiments are required to determine the most appropriate biological, chemical and physical parameters of a bioprocess, with many of the variables being interdependent. Statistical methods, such as response surface methodology, accelerate bioprocess development by selecting a set of most relevant experimental parameters. The syntheses of butyl butanoate (Kumar & Rao, 2004), l-menthyl butanoate (Shih et al., 2007) and citronellyl esters (Melo et al., 2005) were optimised in that way.
4.5
Future trends
Large-scale application of a microorganism in an empirical food fermentation is an excellent motive for a genome sequencing project. The complete genomes of Lactobacillus sakei (1.88 Mbp), Lactobacillus plantarum
84
Modifying flavour in food
(3.7 Mbp) and Staphylococcus carnosus (2.56 Mpb) have been sequenced. One of the most recent examples is Oenococcus oeni (1.8 Mbp) which contained 1701 open reading frames, of which 75% were assigned to a metabolic function (Mills et al., 2005). On our way to the individual human genome new micro-methods are expected to increase the speed of genome sequencing (the so-called ‘$1000 genome’). Various promising methods are currently under development. Automated reading of base-specific fluorescence markers, combinations of specific primers and labelled stencils, or moving a single DNA strand through a nanopore driven by an electric field have been proposed. The sequence data will have to be linked to physiological properties and key metabolites to become really relevant (‘metabolomics’), but they still represent a big step forwards in understanding the metabolism of a GRAS organism and potential flavour producer. Nowadays it appears that large amounts of genetic information are rapidly acquired, whereas knowledge on physiological networks is growing more slowly. Only a few recent studies have dealt with this complicated matter (Passoth et al., 2006), and more efforts including labelling studies will be needed in the future. Progress in molecular biology is usually discussed in terms of improved biocatalysts: new substrates, new traits, new conversion capabilities and the like. Enzymes coupled to redox pairs with co-factor regeneration have been published, but even more elegant would be to couple desired enzymes in a recombinant microorganism, assuring regeneration not only of the cofactor, but also of the flavour-forming enzymes. Some other, already existing techniques, such as microsatellite polymerase chain reaction (PCR) (Howell et al., 2004) or 16S rRNA analyses (Zhang et al., 2005) will facilitate monitoring population dynamics. Multidimensional fast protein liquid chromatography (FPLC) methods for protein separation and particularly DNA microarray techniques (Kondo et al., 2003) will support expression analysis. Commercial microarray chips of S. cerevisiae will detect the expression of thousands of genes during fermentation. A human two-chip genotyping set with 500 000 DNA sequences (single nucleotide polymorphisms, SNPs) for medical diagnostics is now available for less than 1200. The microarray (or PCR)-based search for genes in environmental samples without cultivating the source microorganism (‘metagenome’ technique; Streit et al., 2004) is supposed to lead to novel catalysts with exciting properties. Databases of millions of amino acid and nucleobase sequences are electronically searchable, and everyone can identify functional properties of a gene or enzyme by homology studies, compare gene families and develop novel enzymes in silico (Martin & Bohlmann, 2004). Some established procedures and well-accepted beliefs will have to be critically re-examined. Is it physiologically reasonable to feed a flavour producer with excess glucose or sucrose, just because these carbon sources are readily catabolised (Verstrepen et al., 2004a)? Is it reasonable cost-wise to work in dilute aqueous solutions, or could unusual reaction media such as supercritical gases provide an alternative (Kumar et al., 2005)? Will mag-
How microbial catalysts generate flavours
85
netic beads replace the present techniques of enzyme immobilisation and facilitate enzyme recovery (Gomes et al., 2005), or will foam fractionation of enzymes provide an alternative (Gerken et al., 2005; Linke et al., 2005)? Will the surprising observation of an enhanced reaction rate in the presence of an electric current through a bioreactor be confirmed and explained (Mustacchi et al., 2005)? Will high-throughput measurement of volatile metabolites accelerate the selection and improvement of flavour producing strains (B. A. Smit et al., 2004b)?
4.6
Sources of further information
The chemical properties and industrial applications of flavours can be taken from recent editions of classical books (Burdock, 2004; Surburg and Panten, 2006). A collection of odour thresholds and other books on flavours are offered at www.thresholdcompilation.com and at dfa.leb.chemie.tu muenchen.de/DBuecher.html. More specifically, an overview on the biocatalytic generation and modification of flavours up to 1994 can be found in a monograph (Berger, 1995). Progress achieved during the last decade is covered by some comprehensive reviews (Ehrenstein, 2005; Etschmann et al., 2004; Frey, 2005); more specific topics, as addressed above, have also been reviewed (Table 4.1).
Table 4.1 Recent reviews covering a single topic as mentioned in this chapter Main subject
Reference
Sources of natural flavours Glycoside hydrolases Esters in beer and dairy products Fungal cultures, low-cost substrates, downstream processing Fungi with emphasis on Ceratocystis, volatile terpenes Biotransformation, vanillin, monoterpenes, non-volatiles Enzymes and dairy flavour
Frey (2005) Sarry and Gunata (2004) Liu et al. (2004), Stewart (2005) Divyashree et al. (2006)
Flavour of sourdough Grape and wine flavour Flavours from plant cell culture Scale-up of natural product formation Lipase from Candida antarctica in oxidation reactions Lipoxygenase, cytochrome P450, recombinant enzymes
Hanssen (2002) Suresh et al. (2006) G. Smit et al. (2004, 2005), Wilkinson and Kilcawley (2005) Gul et al. (2005), Hansen and Schieberle (2005), Katina (2005) Swiegers et al. (2005), Pretorius and Hoj (2005) Hrazdina (2006) Berger et al. (2005) Gatfield et al. (2005, 2006a,b) Casey and Hughes (2004)
86
Modifying flavour in food
Most flavour producers are organised in national associations, and these fused in 1969 to form the International Organization of the Flavor Industry (IOFI)(//iofi.org/). IOFI is focusing on activities revolving around consumer safety and provides links of general interest on its web page. How the director of research of a flavour company is looking at the term ‘natural’ can be found at www.chemsoc.org/chembytes/ezine/1998/sine.htm. The site of Leffingwell & Associates provides numerous links to other flavour sites, for example, to updates of the GRAS lists and properties of chiral flavours (www.leffingwell.com/links.htm). An interactive tool for the calculation of logP and logW data is provided by www.logp.com/. A wealth of information on enzymes is presented at //brenda.bc.uni-koeln.de/, www.expasy.ch/ enzyme/, and www.rcsb.org/pdb/. Nucleotide sequences and much more can be searched at the web site of the European Bioinformatics Institute at srs6. ebi.ac.uk/. One of the bioinformatics tools for metabolome analysis can be downloaded at mzmine.sourceforge.net/.
4.7
References
abe, f. and horikoshi, k. (2005), Cellular & Molecular Biology Letters, 10, 383–388. aguedo, m., wache, y., coste, f., husson, f. and belin, j.-m. (2004), Journal of Molecular Catalysis B: Enzymatic, 29, 31–36. aguedo, m., wache, y., belin, j.-m. and teixeira, j. a. (2005), Biotechnology Letters, 27, 417–422. aharoni, a., jongsma, m. a., verhoeven, h. a. and bouwmeester, h. j. (2002, 2004) US Pat. Appl. Publ. 2004, Cont.-in-part of WO 2002 64,764 US 2004161819 A1 20040819. alewijn, m., sliwinski, e. l. and wouters, j. t. m. (2005), International Dairy Journal, 15, 733–740. alexandre, h., charleux, p., lavesvre, a., nedjma, m. and chassagne, d. (2004), Revue Francaise d’Oenologie, 205, 9–11. amarita, f., yvon, m., nardi, m., chambellon, e., delettre, j. and bonnarme, p. (2004), Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 70, 7348–7354. andrade, m. j., casado, e., rodriguez, m. m., cordoba, j. j., martin, a., perez, f. and cordoba, m. g. (2005), Alimentacion Equipos y Tecnologia, 198, 42–47. ardoe, y. (2006), Biotechnology Advances, 24, 238–242. arfi, k., leclercq-perlat, m.-n., baucher, a., tache, r., delettre, j. and bonnarme, p. (2004), Lait, 84, 435–447. arfi, k., leclercq-perlat, m. n., spinnler, h. e. and bonnarme, p. (2005), International Dairy Journal, 15, 883–891. baek, h. h., jang, j. t. and park, g. h. (2003), Repub. Korean Kongkae Taeho Kongbo. KR 2003028089 A 20030408. baldermann, s., naim, m. and fleischmann, p. (2005), Food Research International, 38, 833–836. beck, h. c., hansen, a. m. and lauritsen, f. r. (2004), Journal of Applied Microbiology, 96, 1185–1193. beekwilder, j., alvarez-huerta, m., neef, e., verstappen, f. w. a., bouwmeester, h. j. and aharoni, a. (2004), Plant Physiology, 135, 1865–1878. benito, m. j., rodriguez, m., martin, a., aranda, e. and cordoba, j. j. (2004), Meat Science, 67, 497–505.
How microbial catalysts generate flavours
87
benito, m. j., rodriguez, m., cordoba, m. g., andrade, m. j. and cordoba, j. j. (2005a), Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 85, 273–280. benito, m. j., nunez, f., cordoba, m. g., martin, a. and cordoba, j. j. (2005b), Food Microbiology, 22, 513–519. berger, r. g. (1995), Aroma Biotechnology, Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York. berger, r. g. and drawert, f. (1984), Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 35, 1318–1325. berger, r. g., scheper, t. and schuegerl, k. (2005), Molecular Nutrition & Food Research, 49, 732–743. bezbradica, d., karalazic, i., ognjanovic, n., mijin, d., siler-marinkovic, s. and knezevic, z. (2006), Journal of the Serbian Chemical Society, 71, 31–41. blagden, t. a. d. and gilliland, s. e. (2005), Journal of Food Science, 70, M186–M189. blinkovsky, a., brown, k., golightly, e. and byun, t. (2004), US 6800467 B1 20041005. bondar, d. c. t., beckerich, j.-m. and bonnarme, p. (2005), Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 71, 4585–4591. brunati, m., marinelli, f., bertolini, c., gandolfi, r., daffonchio, d. and molinari, f. (2004), Enzyme and Microbial Technology, 34, 3–9. burdock, g. a. (2004), Fenaroli’s Handbook of Flavor Ingredients, 5th edn. CRC Press, Washington, DC. buzzini, p., gasparetti, c., turchetti, b., cramarossa, m. r., vaughan-martini, a., martini, a., pagnoni, u. m. and forti, l. (2005a), Archives of Microbiology, 184, 187–193. buzzini, p., romano, s., turchetti, b., vaughan, a., pagnoni, u. m. and davoli, p. (2005b), FEMS Yeast Research, 5, 379–385. capelle, s. (2004), PCT Int. Appl. WO 2004043153 A1 20040527 WO 2003-BE197 20031114. cappaert, l. and larroche, c. (2004), Biocatalysis and Biotransformation, 22, 291–296. carrau, f. m., medina, k., boido, e., farina, l., gaggero, c., dellacassa, e., versini, g. and henschke, p. a. (2005), Seccion Enologia, FEMS Microbiology Letters, 243, 107–115. casey, r. and hughes, r. k. (2004), Food Biotechnology, 18, 135–170. chen, g., hackett, r., walker, d., taylor, a., lin, z. and grierson, d. (2004), Plant Physiology, 136, 2641–2651. clemente-jimenez, j. m., mingorance-cazorla, l., martinez-rodriguez, s., las heras-vazquez, f. j. and rodriguez-vico, f. (2005), International Journal of Food Microbiology, 98, 301–308. coghe, s., benoot, k., delvaux, f., vanderhaegen, b. and delvaux, f. r. (2004), Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 52, 602–608. czerny, m., schieberle, p., brandt, m. and hammes, w. (2005), Getreidetechnologie, 59, 15–19. davis, e. m., ringer, k. l., mcconkey, m. e. and croteau, r. (2005), Plant Physiology, 137, 873–881. de carvalho, c. c. c. r. and da fonseca, m. m. r. (2005), Food Chemistry, 95, 413– 422. de wit, m., osthoff, g., viljoen, b. c. and hugo, a. (2005), Enzyme and Microbial Technology, 37, 606–616. divyashree, m. s., george, j. and agrawal, r. (2006), Journal of Food Science and Technology, 43, 73–76. dufosse, l., blin-perrin, c., souchon, i. and feron, g. (2002), Food Science and Biotechnology, 11, 192–202.
88
Modifying flavour in food
dung, n. t. p., rombouts, f. m. and nout, m. j. r. (2005), Innovative Food Science & Emerging Technologies, 6, 429–441. echeverria, g., graell, j., lopez, m. l. and lara, i. (2004), Postharvest Biology and Technology, 31, 217–227. edens, l. and hille, j. d. r. (2005), PCT Int. Appl., WO 2005117595 A1 20051215. ehrenstein, u., hennig, t., kabasci, s., kreis, p. and gorak, a. (2005), Chemie Ingenieur Technik, 77, 1551–1556. el tamer, m. k., smeets, m., holthuysen, n., lucker, j., tang, a., roozen, j., bouwmeester, h. j. and voragen, a. g. j. (2003), Journal of Biotechnology, 106, 15–21. erasmus, d. j., cliff, m. and van vuuren, h. j. j. (2004), American Journal of Enology and Viticulture, 55, 371–378. escamilla-hurtado, m. l., valdes-martinez, s. e., soriano-santos, j., gomez-pliego, r., verde-calvo, j. r., reyes-dorantes, a. and tomasini-campocosio, a. (2005), International Journal of Food Microbiology, 105, 305–316. estevez, p., gil, m. l. and falque, e. (2004), International Journal of Food Science and Technology, 39, 61–69. etschmann, m. m. w., sell, d. and schrader, j. (2004), State-of-the-Art in Flavour Chemistry and Biology, Proceedings of the 7th Wartburg Symposium on Flavour Chemistry and Biology, Eisenach, Germany, 21–23, April Editors: Hofmann, T., Rothe, M., Schieberle P 248–253. etschmann, m. m. w., sell, d. and schrader, j. (2005), Biotechnology and Bioengineering, 92, 624–634. fadda, m. e., mossa, v., pisano, m. b., deplano, m. and cosentino, s. (2004), International Journal of Food Microbiology, 95, 51–59. farhi, m., dudareva, n., masci, t., weiss, d., vainstein, a. and abeliovich, h. (2006), Journal of Biotechnology, 122, 307–315. fickers, p., benetti, p.-h., wache, y., marty, a., mauersberger, s., smit, m. s. and nicaud, j.-m. (2005), FEMS Yeast Research, 5, 527–543. flores, m., dura, m.-a., marco, a. and toldra, f. (2004), Meat Science, 68, 439–446. frey, c. (2005), Natural Flavors and Fragrances ACS Symposium Series no. 908, 3–19. fujiwara, d. (2004), Abstracts of Papers, 228th ACS National Meeting, Philadelphia, PA, United States, 22–26 August, AGFD-066. ACS, Washington, DC. fukuda, k. (2004), Seibutsu Kogaku Kaishi, 82, 50–55. furusawa, m., hashimoto, t., noma, y. and asakawa, y. (2005), Chemical & Pharmaceutical Bulletin, 53, 1513–1514. galkina, g. v., illarionova, v. i. and gorbatova, e. v. (2004), Proizvodstvo Spirta, i Likerovodochnyh Izdelii, 2, 21–23. ganesan, b., seefeldt, k., koka, r. c., dias, b. and weimer, b. c. (2004), International Dairy Journal, 14, 237–246. ganzle, m. g., thiele, c., vermeulen, n. and vogel, f. (2005), Getreidetechnologie, 59, 148–152. garbe, l.-a. and tressl, r. (2006), Chemistry & Biodiversity, 1, 900–915. garde, s., avila, m., gaya, p., medina, m. and nunez, m. (2006), Journal of Dairy Science, 89, 840–849. gatfield, i., hilmer, j.-m. and bertram, h.-j. (2005), Perfumer & Flavorist, 30, 46–49. gatfield, i. l., hilmer, j.-m. and bertram, h.-j. (2006a), Advances in Food Science, 28, 139–141. gatfield, i. l., hilmer, j.-m., lorenz, s. and bertram, h.-j. (2006b), Advances in Food Science, 28, 142–145. gerken, b. m., wattenbach, c., linke, d., zorn, h., berger, r. g. and parlar, h. (2005), Analytical Chemistry, 77, 6113–6117.
How microbial catalysts generate flavours
89
gomes, c. s. g., petersen, t. l., hobley, t. j. and thomas, o. r. t. (2005), 7th World Congress of Chemical Engineering, Glasgow, United Kingdom, 10–14 July, 86907/1–86907/10. green, s. a., friel, e. n., beuning, l. l. and macrae, a. e. (2004), PCT Int. Appl. 2004, WO 2004035791 A1 20040429. grimaldi, a., bartowsky, e. and jiranek, v. (2005), Journal of Applied Microbiology, 99, 1061–1069. groguenin, a., wache, y., garcia, e. e., aguedo, m., husson, f., ledall, m.-t., nicaud, j.-m. and belin, j.-m. (2004), Journal of Molecular Catalysis B: Enzymatic, 28, 75–79. gul, h., ozcelik, s., sagdic, o. and certel, m. (2005), Process Biochemistry, 40, 691– 697. guterman, i., shalit, m., menda, n., piestun, d., dafny-yelin, m., shalev, g., bar, e., davydov, o., ovadis, m., emanuel, m., wang, j., adam, z., pichersky, e., lewinsohn, e., zamir, d., vainstein, a. and weiss, d. (2002), Plant Cell, 14, 2325–2338. hagedorn, a., levadoux, w., groleau, d. and tartakovsky, b. (2004), Biotechnology Progress, 20, 361–367. hall, c. e., husson, f. and kermasha, s. (2004), Journal of Molecular Catalysis B: Enzymatic, 29, 201–209. hall, c. e., husson, f. and kermasha, s. (2005), Flavour and Fragrance Journal, 20, 690–702. hambraeus, g. and nyberg, n. (2005), Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 53, 8714–8721. hampel, d., mosandl, a. and wuest, m. (2004), State-of-the-Art in Flavour Chemistry and Biology, Proceedings of the 7th Wartburg Symposium on Flavour Chemistry and Biology, Eisenach, Germany, 21–23 April, Editors: Hofmann, T., Rothe, M., Schieberle P 267–273. hampel, d., mosandl, a. and wuest, m. (2006), Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 54, 1473–1478. Hannoversche Allgemeine Zeitung. (2006), 26 May, 2006 (in German) (www.haz.de). hansen, a. and schieberle, p. (2005), Trends in Food Science & Technology, 16, 85–94. hanssen, h.-p. (2002), Pharmazeutische Zeitung, 147, 38, 40. havkin-frenkel, d., french, j. c., graft, n. m., joel, d. m., pak, f. e. and frenkel, c. (2004), Acta Horticulturae, 629, 93–102. havkin-frenkel, d., french, j., pak, f. e. and frenkel, c. (2005), Perfumer & Flavorist, 30, 36–43, 46–55. helinck, s., le bars, d., moreau, d. and yvon, m. (2004), Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 70, 3855–3861. herranz, b., de la hoz, l., hierro, e., fernandez, m. and ordonez, j. a. (2005), Food Chemistry, 91, 673–682. hierro, e., ordonez, j. a., bruna, j. m., pin, c., fernandez, m. and hoz, l. (2005), European Food Research and Technology, 220, 494–501. hirosawa, i., aritomi, k., hoshida, h., kashiwagi, s., nishizawa, y. and akada, r. (2004), Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, 65, 68–73. hitchman, t., robertson, d. e., hiraiwa, m., phillips, y. and gray, k. a. (2005), PCT Int. Appl., WO 2005021714 A2 20050310. hockelmann, c. and jüttner, f. (2005), Flavour and Fragrance Journal, 20, 387– 394. holland, r., liu, s.-q., crow, v. l., delabre, m.-l., lubbers, m., bennett, m. and norris, g. (2005), International Dairy Journal, 15, 711–718. horton, c. e. and bennett, g. n. (2006), Enzyme and Microbial Technology, 38, 937–943.
90
Modifying flavour in food
howell, k. s., bartowsky, e. j., fleet, g. h. and henschke, p. a. (2004), Letters in Applied Microbiology, 38, 315–320. howell, k. s., klein, m., swiegers, j. h., hayasaka, y., elsey, g. m., fleet, g. h., hoj, p. b., pretorius, i. s., de barros, l. and miguel, a. (2005), Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 71, 5420–5426. hrazdina, g. (2006), Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 54, 1116–1123. hrdlicka, p. j., sorensen, a. b., poulsen, b. r., ruijter, g. j. g., visser, j. and iversen, j. j. l. (2004), Biotechnology Progress, 20, 368–376. huang, g., jiang, j. and ying, y. (2004), Zhongguo Tiaoweipin, 1, 27–29, 37. husson, f., krumov, k. n., cases, e., cayot, p., bisakowski, b., kermasha, s. and belin, j.-m. (2004), Process Biochemistry, 40, 1395–1400. huynh-ba. t., matthey-doret, w., fay, l. b. and rhlid, r. b. (2003), Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 51, 3629–3635. izak, p., mateus, n. m. m., afonso, c. a. m. and crespo, j. g. (2005), Separation & Purification Technology, 41, 141–145. jang, i.-h., kang, m.-s. and chae, h. j. (2004), Han’guk Eungyong Sangmyong Hwahakhoeji, 47, 49–54. jin, z., xu. j., niu, s., ma. c., cheng, w. and wang, q. (2004), Shipin Kexue, 25, 45– 48. kang, s.-m., jung, h.-y., kang, y.-m., min, j.-y., karigar, c. s., yang, j., kim, s.-w., ha, y.-r., lee, s.-h. and choi, m.-s. (2005), Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 53, 3449–3453. kania, m. and stasinska, b. (2004), Biotechnologia, 3, 260–270. kaspera, r., krings, u., nanzad, t. and berger, r. g. (2005a), Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, 67, 477–483. kaspera, r., krings, u., pescheck, m., sell, d., schrader, j. and berger, r. g. (2005b), Z Naturforsch.C, 60c, 459–466. katina, k. (2005), Sourgough:. A Tool for the Improved Flavour, Texture and Shelf-life of Wheat Bread, VTT Publications no. 569, 1–176. keasling, j. y. d., martin, v., pitera, d., withers, s., yoshikuni, y., newman, j., reiling, k., renninger, n. s. and marshall, j. (2004), Abstracts of Papers, 228th ACS National Meeting, Philadelphia, PA, United States, 22–26 August, 2004. kieronczyk, a., skeie, s., langsrud, t., le bars, d. and yvon, m. (2004), International Dairy Journal, 14, 227–235. kilcawley, k. n., wilkinson, m. g. and fox, p. f. (2006), Food Research International, 39, 619–627. kim, a. y. and eckert, m. (2003), Abstracts of Papers, 226th ACS National Meeting, NY, United States. king, a. j. and dickinson, j. r. (2003), FEMS Yeast Research, 3, 53–62. komorowska, a., sieliwanowicz, b., mrowka, e., stecka, k. and halasinska, a. (2003), Electronic Journal of Polish Agricultural Universities, 6. kondo, h., yomo, h., takatani, t., izumi, t., hatanaka, h., fujita, a. and fukui, n. (2003), Proceedings of the Congress – 29th European Brewery Convention, 49/1–49/13. krings, u., brauer, b., kaspera, r. and berger, r. g. (2005), Biocatalysis and Biotransformation, 23, 457–463. kumar, g. v. and rao, m. n. (2004), Journal of Food Science and Technology, 41, 560– 562. kumar, r., modak, j. and madras, g. (2005), Biochemical Engineering Journal, 23, 199–202. larios, a., garcia, h. s., oliart, r. m. and valerio-alfaro, g. (2004), Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, 65, 373–376.
How microbial catalysts generate flavours
91
leclercq-perlat, m.-n., latrille, e., corrieu, g. and spinnler, h.-e. (2004), Journal of Dairy Research, 71, 355–366. lewinsohn, e., sitrit, y., bar, e., azulay, y., ibdah, m., meir, a., yosef, e., zamir, d. and tadmor, y. (2005a), Trends in Food Science & Technology, 16, 407–415. lewinsohn, e., sitrit, y., bar, e., azulay, y., meir, a., zamir, d. and tadmor, y. (2005b), Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 53, 3142–3148. linke, d., zorn, h., gerken, b., parlar, h. and berger, r. g. (2005), Lipids, 40, 323–327. liu, s.-q, holland, r. and crow, v. l. (2004), International Dairy Journal, 14, 923– 945. maldonado-robledo, g., rodriguez-bustamante, e., sanchez-contreras, a., rodriguez-sanoja, r. and sanchez, s. (2003), Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, 62, 484–488. mamede, m. e. o., cardello, h. m. a. b. and pastore, g. m. (2004), Food Chemistry, 89, 63–68. marilley, l., ampuero, s., zesiger, t. and casey, m. g. (2004), International Dairy Journal, 14, 849–856. martin, d. m. and bohlmann, j. (2004), Phytochemistry, 65, 1223–1229. matsuta, y., ishigaki, h. and koseki, t. (2004), Nippon Jozo Kyokaishi, 99, 127–133. medeiros, a. b. p., pandey, a., christen, p., fontoura, p. s. g., de freitas, r. j. s. and soccol, c. r. (2001), World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology, 17, 767– 771. medeiros, a. b. p., pandey, a., vandenberghe, l. p. s., pastore, g. m. and soccol, c. r. (2006), Food Technology and Biotechnology, 44, 47–51. melo, l. l. m. m., pastore, g. m. and macedo, g. a. (2005), Process Biochemistry, 40, 3181–3185. mills, d. a., rawsthorne, h., parker, c., tamir, d. and makarova, k. (2005), FEMS Microbiology Reviews, 29, 465–475. mustacchi, r., knowles, c. j., li. h., dalrymple, i., sunderland, g., skibar, w. and jackman, s. a. (2005), Biotechnology and Bioengineering, 89, 18–23. nampoothiri, k. m., nagy, v., kovacs, k., szakacs, g. and pandey, a. (2005), Letters in Applied Microbiology, 41, 498–504. nardi, m., sextius, p., bonnarme, p., spinnler, h. e., monnet, v. and irlinger, f. (2005), Journal of Dairy Research, 72, 179–187. nazhat-ul-ainn, r., premanath and agrawal, r. (2002), Asian Journal of Microbiology, Biotechnology & Environmental Sciences, 4, 265–269. neto, r. s., pastore, g. m. and macedo, g. a. (2004), Journal of Food Science, 69, C677–C680. nonier, m.-f., de gaulejac, n. v., vivas, n. and vitry, c. (2004), Comptes Rendus Chimie, 7, 689–698. olesen, p. t., stahnke, l. h. and talon, r. (2004), Meat Science, 68, 193–200. oliveira, e. s., cardello, h. m. a. b., jeronimo, e. m., souza, e. l. r. and serra, g. e. (2005), World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology, 21, 707–715. ortigosa, m., arizcun, c., torre, p. and izco, j. m. (2005), Journal of Dairy Research, 72, 168–178. ota, m. (2005), Jpn. Kokai Tokkyo Koho JP 2005304377 A2 20051104. paraggio, m. and fiore, c. (2004), World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology, 20, 743–747. park, y. j., kim, i. c. and chang, h. c. (2003), Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology, 13, 636–639. passoth, v., fredlund, e., druvefors, u. a. and schnurer, j. (2006), FEMS Yeast Research, 6, 3–13. pechous, s. w. and whitaker, b. d. (2004), Planta, 219, 84–94.
92
Modifying flavour in food
pechous, s. w. and whitaker, b. d. (2005), Acta Horticulturae, 682 (Proceedings of the 5th International Postharvest Symposium, 2004, Volume 1), 395–402. pinheiro, c., rodrigues, c. m., schäfer, t. and crespo, j. g. (2002), Biotechnology and Bioengineering, 77, 632–640. ponzone, c., d’adago, v. and bertani, m. (2004), PCT Int. Appl., WO 2004091316 A1 20041028 WO 2003-EP14702 20031222. pozo-bayon, m. a., g-alegria, e., polo, m. c., tenorio, c., martin-alvarez, p. j., calvo de la banda, m. t., ruiz-larrea, f. and moreno-arribas, m. v. (2005), Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 53, 8729–8735. pretorius, i. s. and hoj, b. (2005), Australian Journal of Grape and Wine Research, 11, 83–108. priefert, h., rabenhorst, j. and steinbüchel, a. (2001), Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, 56, 296–314. priest, f. g. and cachat, e. (2004), Proceedings of the 28th Convention of the Institute & Guild of Brewing, Asia Pacific Section, Hanoi, 21–26 March, 102–105. rodriguez-bustamante, e., maldonado-robledo, g., ortiz, m. a., diaz-avalos, c. and sanchez, s. (2005), Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, 68, 174–182. romero, m., villafuerte and ho, c.-t. (2005), Abstracts of Papers, 230thACS National Meeting, Washington, DC, 28 Aug.–1 Sept. 2005. rungsardthong, v. and noomhoom, a. (2005), Flavour and Fragrance Journal, 20, 710–714. sakamoto, t., nakamura, n., kodera, t., nio, n., yamada, n. and wakabayashi, h. (2004), PCT Int. Appl. WO 2004105503 A1 20041209. sanchez, j., ignacio, m. b. and rodriguez, a. (2005), International Journal of Food Microbiology, 105, 377–387. santos, a. s., pereira, n. jr, da silva, i. i., sarquis, m. i. and antunes, o. a. c. (2003), Applied Biochemistry and Biotechnology, 105–108, 649–657. sarry, j.-e. and gunata, z. (2004), Food Chemistry, 87, 509–521. schallmey, m., singh, a. and ward, o. p. (2004), Canadian Journal of Microbiology, 50, 1–17. schoondermark-stolk, s. a., jansen, m., veurink, j. h., verkleij, a. j., verrips, c. t., euverink, g.-j. w., boonstra, j. and dijkhuizen, l. (2006), Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, 70, 237–246. schwan, r. and wheals, a. (2004), Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 44, 205–221. schwartz, s. h., cai tan, b., gage, d. a., zeevaart, j. a. d. and mccarty, d. r. (1997), Science, 276, 1872. setyaningsih, d., apriyantono, a. and suhartono, m. t. (2005), Food Flavor and Chemistry Special Publication – Royal Society of Chemistry, 300, 145–155. sevini, f., marino, r., grando, m. s., moser, s. and versini, g. (2004), Acta Horticulturae, 652 (Proceedings of the 1st International Symposium on Grapevine Growing, Commerce and Research, 2003), 439–446. sharon-asa, l., shalit, m., frydman, a., bar, e., holland, d., or, e., lavi, u., lewinsohn, e. and eyal, y. (2003), Plant Journal, 36, 664–674. shih, i.-l., chen, l.-g., yu, t.-s., chang, w.-t. and wang, s.-l. (2003), Enzyme and Microbial Technology, 33, 154–162. shih, i.-l., hung, s.-h., chen, f.-y. and shieh, c.-j. (2007), Food Chemistry, 100, 1223– 1228. simkin, a. j., schwartz, s. h., auldridge, m., taylor, m. g. and klee, h. j. (2004a), Plant Journal, 40, 882–892. simkin, a. j., underwood, b. a., auldridge, m., loucas, h. m., shibuya, k., schmelz, e., clark, d. g. and klee, h. j. (2004b), Plant Physiology, 136, 3504–3514. smit, b. a., engels, w. j. m., wouters, j. t. m. and s