Molecular Adhesion and Its Applications The Sticky Universe
Molecular Adhesion and Its Applications The Sticky Universe Kevin Kendall The University of Birmingham Birmingham, England
KLUWER ACADEMIC PUBLISHERS NEW YORK, BOSTON, DORDRECHT, LONDON, MOSCOW
eBook ISBN: Print ISBN:
0-306-48406-4 0-306-46520-5
©2004 Kluwer Academic Publishers New York, Boston, Dordrecht, London, Moscow Print ©2001 Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers New York All rights reserved
No part of this eBook may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, recording, or otherwise, without written consent from the Publisher
Created in the United States of America
Visit Kluwer Online at: and Kluwer's eBookstore at:
http://kluweronline.com http://ebooks.kluweronline.com
I wish I could derive all phenomena of nature, by some kind of reasoning, from mechanical principles; for I have many reasons to suspect that they all depend on certain forces by which the particles of bodies are either mutually attracted and cohere in regular figures or are repelled and recede from each other I. NEWTON, 1687
FOREWORD
At the beginning of the twentieth century, engineers and technologists would have recognized the importance of adhesion in two main aspects: First, in the display of friction between surfaces — at the time a topic of growing importance to engineers; the second in crafts requiring the joining of materials — principally wood—to form engineering structures. While physical scientists would have admitted the adhesive properties of glues, gels, and certain pastes, they regarded them as materials of uncertain formulation, too impure to be amenable to precise experiment. Biological scientists were aware also of adhesive phenomena, but the science was supported by documentation rather than understanding. By the end of the century, adhesion and adhesives were playing a crucial and deliberate role in the formulation of materials, in the design and manufacture of engineering structures without weakening rivets or pins, and in the use of thin sections and intricate shapes. Miniaturization down to the micro- and now to the nano-level of mechanical, electrical, electronic, and optical devices relied heavily on the understanding and the technology of adhesion. For most of the century, physical scientists were aware that the states of matter, whether gas, liquid, or solid, were determined by the competition between thermal energy and intermolecular binding forces. Then the solid state had to be differentiated into crystals, amorphous glasses, metals, etc., so the importance of the molecular attractions in determining stiffness and strength became clearer. Cross-linked rubbers and composites designed at the macro- and micro-level were developed to extend the range of materials available for engineering purposes. Adhesion at the molecular scale, at surfaces and interfaces, was recognized to be a vital factor determining performance. Biological sciences were not excluded from this explosion of knowledge. The study of cell structure and cell behavior, including material transport across membranes, cell division, and cell adhesion, raised aspects of adhesion already familiar in physical colloid systems. Then the rise of molecular biology in the last
vii
viii
Foreword
30 years has brought adhesion into prominence at all levels of organization in biological systems. Certainly there is a vast literature, and especially a voluminous research canon, associated with the science of adhesion. However, the literature is fragmented and diffuse because adhesion is involved in all areas of endeavor. The engineering literature is somewhat more ordered because of the need to agree good practice and safety protocol. It is nevertheless compartmentalized. Even so, it is not easy to align scientific knowledge with engineering practice in many fields of application. One possible exception is computer modeling, which is at the cutting edge of advances both in science and engineering though the emphasis is rather different. No doubt, in the future, we shall see adhesion modeled at the molecular level and tracked through to engineering practice with the aid of computers. Remarkably, there is no scientific monograph covering the state and current knowledge of adhesion. Nor is there an engineering treatise to take the reader onto a representative range of applications. This is not because we have lacked leading scientists or engineers or gifted teachers in the twentieth century. Presumably, they have been too busy in a field of rapid progress. Now the challenge of promoting a unified account of molecular adhesion, extending it to basic laws and technical practice and onto applications has been taken up by Kevin Kendall. His enthusiasm for the subject and his experience in academe and industry shines through this comprehensive treatise. It is a book that can be read from cover to cover, or a laboratory and design manual to be dipped into as work demands. It benefits enormously from the distillation of a vast subject through a single mind. Sir Geoffrey Allen FRS
PREFACE
Molecular adhesion is one of the most fundamental concepts in science. Molecules tend to be stuck together to form crystals, liquids, composite materials, assembled structures, colloids, rocks, pastes, living cellular creatures, and so forth. Our universe may be expanding against the force of gravity, but each local bit of the universe is firmly stuck together by molecular adhesion. Explaining this across the interdisciplinary boundaries of chemistry, physics, engineering, and bioscience is the objective of this book. The argument is at undergraduate teaching level, but the specific examples and references are geared for research specialists. The laws we remember from school are the laws of motion. Movement is interesting whereas stasis is boring. Newton made the gravitational law of adhesion exciting by using it to explain the movement of planets and satellites. Yet our Earth is largely static; stuck together by molecular adhesion. Our bodies lie in the tenuous skin of mobile material at the Earth’s surface, which explains our fascination with movement, leading to Newton’s Laws of Motion. To suggest laws of adhesion is almost a joke, rather like one of those Andy Warhol movies where nothing happens. But molecular adhesion is interesting precisely because it limits the movement we want; the movement of a car on a road, the movement of cornflakes onto our plates. Laws of adhesion must exist and should be revealed. Four centuries ago, Galileo famously said “It moves”; this century we are saying “It sticks”. Previously, we could only detect adhesion by this limit of movement. The single way to test for adhesion was by breaking the bond. Now nondestructive tests are becoming possible using the new technique of atomic force microscopy at the molecular level. Thus adhesion can be distinguished from, then related to, fracture. We have to understand both making the joint and breaking it to obtain a rational picture of adhesion as a whole. A second major advance is in computer modeling which enables us to describe the interactions of the many thousands of ix
x
Preface
atoms which participate in adhesion events. Adhesion is cooperative; the adhesion of 1000 atoms is different from the adhesion of 1 atom. Roughly 6000 articles are written each year on adhesion but these are in widely varying disciplines which may not be immediately accessible. This book cannot quote all these papers, nor can it present a comprehensive critique of the documents, but it can provide a skeleton of logic and a common agreed language for describing adhesion phenomena in those different areas, together with an assessment of the pivotal contributions in the literature. Individual researchers should find, in the framework provided here, a place to fit their own observations. Many books on surface chemistry contain a short chapter on adhesion. But such accounts are seldom satisfactory. Clearly, adhesion stems from the strong attractive forces between molecules. However, the connections between molecular forces and phenomena seen in soiling, cements, adhesives, corrosion, catalysis, or slime mold reproduction are not normally made explicit. Similarly, there are several texts on adhesion for engineers, though most engineers, following Coulomb and Hertz, have ignored adhesion. In a typical book on Contact Mechanics, only 1% deals with adhesion. Engineering books tend to be dominated by mathematical derivations and hardly acknowledge that molecules exist. But without molecular force, there is no adhesion. In this book I have emphasized the observations of phenomena based on adhesion, keeping the mathematical description to a minimum, concentrating on useful results rather than analytical manipulations, trying to show the connection between molecules and mechanics. The book is in three parts. The first introduces the background and lays the fundamental tenets of the subject which really go back to Isaac Newton. He experimented on the contact of glass lenses, trying to interpret the results in terms of molecular adhesion long before the idea of molecules existed. The second part of the book seeks to establish the laws and mechanisms of adhesion, and the third to explain the applications and benefits of molecular adhesion in the practical world. In the first part, the aim is to unravel the many ideas and theories which have been proposed to account for adhesion phenomena, to pin down the key observations which have led to our current state of thinking, and to establish three “laws of adhesion” which account for the phenomenology. The second part then goes on to establish the three laws on a more quantitative and theoretical level which can be tested by new theories of computer modeling and by new measurements such as Atomic Force Microscopy. Finally, in the third part, this theory of molecular adhesion is applied to eight important areas of technology, where the effects of intermolecular forces are dominant. These areas will be familiar in most industries. They include adhesion of particles, colloids, pastes, gels and cells, the adhesion of nanomaterials, of films and coatings, the fracture
Preface
xi
of adhesive joints, and composite materials. A concluding chapter points to the future of molecular adhesion science. My hope is that the adhesive gulf between chemists, engineers, and biologists can be joined, while simultaneously helping those materials scientists, dentists, powder technologists, cancer specialists, etc., who are fascinated by adhesion effects. If so, thanks are due to my wife for her constant support, to Professor Mai for allowing me to work in his department on a sabbatical in 1997, to Professor Tabor who gave me the stimulus to think about the issues in this book, and to many colleagues who have debated, theorized and experimented on this subject with me over the past 30 years. If not, please email me on
[email protected], fax me with your comments on +44 (0) 121 414 5377, or write me at the Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
CONTENTS
Part I 1.
BACKGROUND AND FUNDAMENTALS
Introduction to Molecular Adhesion and Fracture: the Adhesion Paradox
1.1. 1.2. 1.3. 1.4. 1.5. 1.6.
The Adhesion Paradox Adhesion at the Molecular Level Theory of Adhesion Adhesive Technologies Adhesion in Nature Interdisciplinary Nature of Adhesion; Purpose of this Book 1.7. Review of Adhesion Literature 1.8. References
2.
Phenomenology of Adhesion Effects: Fracture Stranger than Friction
2.1. 2.2. 2.3. 2.4. 2.5. 2.6. 2.7. 2.8. 2.9.
Adhesion Phenomena Friction Gravitational Attraction Electrostatic and Magnetic Attractions Adhesion between Nuclear Particles Demonstration of the Molecular Adhesion Force Probing Molecular Adhesion: the Range of Molecular Attractions Definition of Molecular Adhesion References
3 6 8 9 12 15
20 22 22
25 26 28 29 30 32 34 37 39 40 xiii
CONTENTS
xiv
3.
Theories and Laws of Molecular Adhesion: All Molecules Adhere
3.1. 3.2. 3.3. 3.4. 3.5. 3.6. 3.7. 3.8. 3.9. 3.10.
PART II 4.
5.
Three Adhesion Fallacies Critical Observations of Adhesion The Laws of Molecular Adhesion From Molecules, through Mechanisms, to Mechanics Jumping into Contact Cracking Molecules Apart Adhesion Is Really Three Things: Making, Equilibrium, and Breaking Adhesion in the Scanning Probe Microscope The Atomic Force Microscope References
41 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 56 57 60
LAWS AND MECHANISMS
Evidence for the First Law of Adhesion: Surfaces Leap into Contact
63
4.1. 4.2. 4.3. 4.4. 4.5. 4.6. 4.7. 4.8. 4.9. 4.10.
64 65 68 70 72 73 75 77 79 80
The Problem of Obtaining Reliable Adhesion Obreimoff ’s Experiment Tabor and Winterton’s Experiment Extension by Israelachvili and Tabor Finer Means Smoother Bradley’s Adhesion Rule The Significance of Bradley’s Rule The New Science of Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) How Smooth Is an Atom References
Intermolecular Forces: the New Geometry of Computer Modeling
5.1. 5.2. 5.3. 5.4. 5.5. 5.6. 5.7. 5.8. 5.9. 5.10.
The Two Parameter Model of Atomic Forces Experimental Evidence for Models of Molecular Forces Direct Measurement of Molecular Forces Intermolecular Forces from Bulk Properties The New Geometry of Computer Modeling Structuring of Hard Spheres Experiments on Spherical Polymer Particles Computer Model of the Crystallization Process Effect of Adhesion on the Structuring Process References
83 84 86 88 89 91 93 95 96 100 101
xv
CONTENTS
6.
Evidence for the Second Law of Adhesion: Contamination Reduces Adhesion
6.1. 6.2. 6.3. 6.4. 6.5. 6.6. 6.7. 6.8. 6.9. 6.10. 6.11.
7.
Experiments to Show that Adhesion Is Reduced by Contamination Polymer Adhesion Affected by Contaminants Studies of Surface Species by the Adhesion Method Surface Forces Measured in Liquids Jumping in Steps as Molecules are Squeezed Out Adhesion with Water Present at Surfaces Adhesion of Wet Surfaces in the Atomic Force Microscope Influence of Polymers on Wet Adhesion Restructuring of Surfaces and Interfaces The Nanoscale Fountain Pen References
Influence of the Adhesion and Fracture Mechanism: The Third Law
7.9.
Problem of the Wide Range of Adhesion Energy Values Hierarchy of Mechanisms Controlling Adhesion The Simplest Failure of Adhesion Chemical Breakage of Adhesive Joints Brownian Adhesion The Cracking Mechanism Fracture Mechanics: Thermodynamic Theory of Cracking Experimental Proof that Stress does not Cause Cracking of Adhesive Joints Consistency of the Brownian Mechanism with Fracture
7.10. 7.11. 7.12.
Elasticity in the Adhesion Mechanism Roughness as a Strong Mechanism References
7.1. 7.2. 7.3. 7.4. 7.5. 7.6. 7.7. 7.8.
Mechanics
8.
More Intricate Mechanisms: Raising and Lowering Adhesion
8.1. 8.2. 8.3.
Roughness and Contamination as Hysteresis Mechanisms Dwell-time Effect Adhesive Drag
103 104 106 108 112 114 116 118 122 126 128 130
133 134 135 136 138 139 141 143
145 147 149 151
153 155 156 158 160
CONTENTS
xvi
8.4. 8.5. 8.6. 8.7. 8.8. 8.9. 8.10. 8.11.
PART III 9.
Adhesive Drag and Hysteresisr Measurements Crack Stopping Rolling, Tack and Adhesive Hysteresis Adhesive Dislocations Stringing or Crazing Aggregation Mechanisms Charge Separation and Electrical Effects References
163 165 167 170 171 173 176 177
APPLICATIONS AND BENEFITS
Adhesion of Particles: Deformation, Friction, and Sintering
181
9.1. 9.2. 9.3. 9.4. 9.5. 9.6. 9.7. 9.8. 9.9. 9.10. 9.11.
182 184 187 188 191 193 197 200 203 205 209
Contact of Spheres The JKR Contribution The Nature of Adhesive Contact Roughening the Surfaces Effect of Roughness on Particle Adhesion Friction of Fine Particles Elastic Sintering of Fine Particles Hysteresis and Drag in the Contact of Spheres Plastic Contact of Particles Sintering of Particles by Diffusion Mechanisms References
10. Adhesion of Colloids: Dispersion, Aggregation, and Flocculation
10.1. 10.2. 10.3. 10.4. 10.5. 10.6. 10.7. 10.8. 10.9. 10.10. 10.11.
Ubiquity of Colloids Colloids as Adhesion Sensors Electrical Stabilization of Particle Dispersions Point of Zero Charge; Adhesion Dominates Secondary Minimum and Further Complex Interactions Effect of Dissolved Polymer on Colloid Adhesion Particles with Strongly Bonded Polymer Growing Crystals Comminution of Colloids Growing Uniform Colloidal Particles References
213 214 215 219
223 226 229 231 232 235 238 242
CONTENTS
11.
12.
xvii
Pastes and Gels: Effects of Adhesion on Structure and Behavior
245
Importance of Pastes and Gels 11.1. Different Structures of Sols, Pastes, and Gels 11.2. Structure and Properties of a Gel 11.3. Elastic Modulus of Silica Gels 11.4. Shrinkage of Gels 11.5. Ultimate Structure of a Gel Product 11.6. Origin of Defects in Pastes 11.7. Fracture of Gels, Especially Cements 11.8. Paste Structure and Rheology 11.9. 11.10. Controlling the Sol Gel Transition 11.11. References
246 248 249
Adhesion of Biological Cells: the Nature of Slime
275
Introduction and Importance Models of Cell Contact: The Polymer Coating Cell Membrane and Cytoplasm: Effects on Contact Spot Roughness and Cell Surfaces 12.4. Cell Adhesion by Probe Methods 12.5. Cell Adhesion by Flow Methods 12.6. Cell Counting Methods 12.7. New Approach to Cell Adhesion 12.8. Experimental Results 12.9. 12.10. Application to Practice 12.11. Problematic Theories of Cell Adhesion 12.12. References
275 277
12.1. 12.2. 12.3.
13. Nano-adhesion: Joining Materials for Electronic Applications
13.1. 13.2. 13.3. 13.4. 13.5. 13.6. 13.7.
The Size Effect in Adhesion: Small Is Beautiful Adhesion of Plastic Contacts Adhesion of Single Atoms Stretching Single Molecules in the Atomic Force Microscope Adhesion Strength of Small Features Cleaning Particles from Wafers Adhesion in Electrophotography
252 254 257
260 263 266 268
272
279 281 284 287 290 291 293 296
299 301
305 306 309 310 311 313 315 317
xviii
CONTENTS
13.8. 13.9. 13.10. 13.11. 14.
Polymer Synthesis for Coating Silicon Wafers Molecular Control of Nano-adhesion Visualizing Adhesion Using Micro-focus X-rays References
Films and Layers: Adhesion of Coatings
327
Complexity of Films and Coatings Ideal Experimental Arrangement Testing Methods for Adhesion of Films Wedging of Films: Direct Linkage with Zero Friction Elastic Linkage during Wedging Change in Elastic Linkage as the Crack Progresses Elastic Linkages Easing Failure of Film Adhesion Ultimate Adhesion: Pull-off and Indentation Deforming the Substrate: Pull-off, Stretching, and Indentation; Elastic, Plastic 14.10. Amplifying Mechanisms: Roughness, Elastic Arrest, Deflection, Losses 14.11. References
328 330 331 333 334 336 338 340
Fracture and Toughness of Engineering Adhesive Joints
353
Importance of Bonded Structures A Model of Bridge Collapse Definition of Joint Toughness History of the Failure of Lap Joint Theory The Correct Theory of Lap Joint Strength Consequences of this Theory of Lap Joint Failure Strengthening of a Lap Joint by Prestressing More Complex Overlapping Joints Various Adhesive Joint Geometries Summary of Engineering Adhesive Joints References
354 355 356 358 361 362 364 366 369 372 373
14.1. 14.2. 14.3. 14.4. 14.5. 14.6. 14.7. 14.8. 14.9.
15.
319 321 323 325
15.1. 15.2. 15.3. 15.4. 15.5. 15.6. 15.7. 15.8. 15.9. 15.10. 15.11.
16. Composite Materials: Held Together by Adhesion at Interfaces
16.1. Particulate Composites 16.2. Effect of Interfaces 16.3. A Crack Meeting an Interface 16.4. Delamination at the Interface
343 347 350
375 375 377 380 384
CONTENTS
16.5. 16.6. 16.7. 16.8. 16.9. 16.10. 16.11.
xix
Tough Laminates Healing the Interface Crack: Interfacial Dislocations The Overall Picture: Crack Stopping, Deflection and Healing The Problem with Composites: Bending and Compression Adhesion of Fibers in Composites Adjusting the Interface Adhesion in Fiber Composites References
17. The Future of Molecular Adhesion and the Sticky Universe
389 392 395 397 400 403 405
409
Adhesion Problems Solved Interesting Mechanisms Does Adhesive Strength Exist ? Adhesion at the Nanometer Level and Molecular Scale 17.5. Improved Theory of Adhesion by Computer Calculation 17.6. New Adhesion Applications 17.7. References
410 412 415
Index
423
17.1. 17.2. 17.3. 17.4.
416 419 420 421
1 INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE: THE ADHESION PARADOX
For we must learn from the Phaenomena of Nature what Bodies attract one another and what are the Laws and Properties of the Attraction ISAAC NEWTON, Opticks,1 p. 376
Isaac Newton was obsessed with the attractions between the objects which we see about us. His work is perhaps the finest illustration of the curious paradox which is addressed in this book; that the bodies around us are strangely schizophrenic. Sometimes things stick together with remarkable strength, for example, a jumbo jet hangs together in mid-air despite the fact that it is made of 2 million separate parts. At other times, things fall apart very easily, for example, the drug particles in an asthmatic’s inhaler flow readily into the mouth and lungs to prevent dangerous attacks. How is it that things sometimes stick very well and at other times hardly at all? Newton could see this problem but could not understand it. He first compiled his famous Laws of Motion, which completely ignored attraction or adhesion between bodies. His outlandish postulate, originally developed by Galileo, was that bodies should travel in straight lines at constant velocity. This represented a force of inertia. In other words Newton assumed for the purpose of his theory of motion that there was no attraction or adhesion between objects. This is a stunning theoretical idea, which goes against all our everyday experience. On Earth, adhesion is a most common thing. However, once space travel became possible, and rockets could escape from the Earth’s pull, it became 3
4
CHAPTER 1
clear that spaceships as shown in Fig. 1.1(a) would obey Newton’s laws, and go straight, if they could get far enough away from the planets. To explain the fact that ordinary earthbound objects do not travel in straight lines at constant speed, like the cannon ball in Fig. 1.1(b), Newton had to produce two further ideas; gravity, which turned out to be extremely convincing; and friction or viscosity, which we have been fudging and striving to explain ever since. Gravity was the first adhesive force to be understood, mainly because of Newton’s pioneering insight. He proposed that a unifying attractive force acts between all objects in the universe. This all-pervading gravitational force has two interesting properties; first it is proportional to the masses of the objects; secondly it seems to act from the center of the objects and decreases with the square of separation. Thus, in the simple case of a small sphere like the Earth attracted to a large sphere like the Sun, the motion of the Earth can be predicted by combining Newton’s two laws; the law of inertia which assumes zero attraction plus the gravitational law of universal attraction. Both these laws conserve energy, so the planets can be viewed as a clockwork mechanism in which energy is converted without loss between the motion (i.e. inertia) and the attraction (i.e. gravitation), as shown in Fig. 1.2.
INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE
5
This theory of gravitational adhesion was instantly successful and allowed the motions of planetary bodies to be predicted accurately. It was immediately clear that cannonballs on Earth should travel in parabolic paths and that planets like the Earth should move in elliptical curves around the Sun, as shown in Fig, 1.2, because this followed from a combination of the two forces, one the inertial force from the law of motion, and the other the gravitational adhesion force acting towards the center of the Sun. Of course, Newton recognized that the clockwork universe must be gradually running down. Energy is lost in tidal movements, and also as the planets plough through cosmic dust. This is a process which must eventually result in the planets sticking together, as observed2 in the finding of strange shaped asteroids (Fig. 1.1(c)). Of the 100 million asteroids larger than 1 km, there should be many thousands sticking together in a peanut shape, like asteroid Toutatis which was imaged by radar in 1992, and asteroid Castalia observed in 1989. This energy loss happens more obviously on Earth, where you can see tea leaves in a stirred cup of tea gradually slowing down and sticking together. Newton invented the idea of viscosity to explain this. Viscosity is the resistance which a body experiences when it falls through a molecular medium. For example, the Titanic, when it sank, did not fall to the ocean floor very quickly. The water resisted the downward movement of the ship, since the water molecules had to be swept out of the way, giving a viscous resistive force. In space, there are very few molecules to sweep out of the way, so Newton’s theory of inertia and gravitation works very well, and the planets do not slow down perceptibly. On Earth, molecules are abundant and their viscous resistance cannot be ignored. Thus, on Earth, we have to consider the combination of three forces; inertia, gravity and viscosity, as shown in Fig. 1.3. To use a political analogy, the forces are of two types: the first type is represented by inertia and gravity, which are conservative because they exchange energy between classes without loss; viscosity is more of a socialist force, because it stirs things up to spread the energy equally between all bodies.
6
CHAPTER 1
1.1. THE ADHESION PARADOX This book is about a paradox, the adhesion paradox, which is just as challenging as Newton’s ideas about motion and gravity. In fact, the adhesion paradox can be visualized in a similar way. Common experience tells us that ordinary objects do not stick together easily. A cup does not stick to its saucer; your foot does not adhere to the floor. Cathedrals were designed on the basis that the stones do not stick together but are simply held in place by gravity.3 Engineers have therefore been able to predict the behavior of structures, bearings, and cars by presuming that adhesion is zero. Yet it is evident that the small component parts of the cup, i.e. the grains and ultimately the atoms and molecules, stick together extremely well. Otherwise the cup would crumble to dust or would evaporate into the gas phase. Similarly your car would fall apart very easily, as my cars often do. Therefore we have to decide what is the most fundamental nature of matter. Does it stick or not? We can short-cut to the answer given in Chapter 3. The first Law of Adhesion is that “All atoms adhere with considerable force.” This is as strange and surprising as the law of motion enunciated by Newton. How could our world operate if all the atoms were stuck fast and immobilized? Cars would not work because the tires would stick to the road. Indeed, the car engine parts would all seize together and stop moving. The paradox is that the car is made up of thousands of parts, most of which do stick together rather well. But some do not. This book sets out to explain this paradox. First imagine what would happen to our planet if this first law of adhesion were taken at face value. The sands and soils which we grow our food on would stick together to form strong solid rocks. Sand grains would adhere so strongly that the beach would resemble sandstone. Soil would transform into mudstone, so tough that plants would not be able to push their roots through it and would perish. Any particles blown out of volcanoes would float around in the air until they touched a surface. Then they would stick immediately to that surface, making windows opaque and clogging machinery. The Earth’s atmosphere would be as clear and transparent as that on Mars. We know from the fossil record that
INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE
7
sand beds can transform into sandstone and mud into mudstone, but this only happens over long times under extremes of pressure, temperature, or chemical modification. Clearly, something is retarding this adhesion under normal earthly conditions. A clue to this problem comes from experiences of space travel.4 When the first lunar modules landed, dust did leap onto the windows, making them opaque. Furthermore, the solar panels became obscured by detritus which stuck firmly to the surfaces. Also, the hinges on the spacecraft doors did tend to seize up. This proved the idea that clean surfaces in the vacuum of space were much more adhering than the dirty, wet, oxygen-covered surfaces here on Earth. Thus we conclude that contamination of the surfaces is very important in reducing the atomic adhesion to low values, well below what we should expect from the first law of adhesion. The second clue came from the study of electrical contacts and friction of bearings in the 1930s, as illustrated in Fig. 1.4. Holm5 and Bowden and Tabor6 realized that bodies apparently in contact were not truly touching over the geometric contact area. This was confirmed later by attempts to pass ultrasonic waves through contacts.7 The waves were inhibited at the contact, suggesting that only a small area of the bodies was really in molecular contact. It became clear that a design for an electrical contact could not be made on the basis of apparent
8
CHAPTER 1
geometry. Perhaps one square centimeter of metal appeared to be in contact, whereas measurements revealed that only one square millimeter was actually passing electrical current. In the same way, the frictional force required to shear the contact was much smaller than expected. The ultrasonic transmission was also reduced. Thus the paradox of adhesion being unpredictably large or small can be explained by these two complexities of contact at the molecular level; contamination and roughness.
1.2. ADHESION AT THE MOLECULAR LEVEL Consider the adhesion of two bodies on the Earth’s surface, as shown in Fig. 1.5. However much we clean or polish the surfaces to make them smooth and free from contamination, we realize that the contact between the bodies cannot be made easily at the molecular level. Magnifying a small portion of the contact region, by a factor of one hundred million, to observe the atomic structure of the material, it is evident that the atoms of the material do not make contact at all. In the first place, the surfaces are covered with layers of foreign atoms like oxygen and also by contaminating molecules such as water, which prevent true atomic contact between the solid bodies. Secondly, the surfaces are not smooth at the atomic scale, but are rough and jagged, like mountain ranges placed on top of
INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE
9
each other,6 so that large gaps exist to reduce the surface interaction down to an even lower value. Thus, the picture of adhesion developed in Fig. 1.5 very much resembles the ideas generated by Newton about the laws of motion, (remember Fig. 1.3). The first law of adhesion, that all atoms adhere, is true in space when solid surfaces are smooth at the 0.1 nm dimension. However, in the Earth’s environment, we have to account for contaminant molecules, which reduce adhesion considerably. This is the second law of adhesion, described in more detail in Chapter 3. Both these effects are conservative, in that no energy need be lost. But there is another problem, that of surface roughness which reduces true contact enormously and which therefore diminishes adhesion even more. Roughness is an example of a mechanism, rather like viscosity in Newton’s theory, which is complex, variable, and capable of energy losses. Thus it is cannot be explained easily and must be debated at length. In addition to roughness, many other lossy mechanisms such as hysteresis, restructuring, etc., can be found, leading to a rich variety of adhesion phenomena. These are described in Chapter 7 onwards. Grouping all these mechanisms together, we conclude that there is a third law of adhesion: “the mechanism has a large influence on the macroscopic adhesion, even though the molecular adhesion remains constant.” Summing up these arguments, it is evident that molecular adhesion has several layers of complexity leading to the adhesion paradox. Our macroscopic world of ordinary experience is seen to be false at the molecular level. All atoms and molecules adhere. The moral we draw from this is clear: we must distrust all artificial ideas which are glibly produced to explain adhesion. Ideas such as keying, adhesives, suction, and so forth are utterly unnecessary. Atoms stick together naturally. It is the most fundamental property of atoms to adhere. The odd and unexpected conclusion is that our ordinary experience of adhesion is close to zero, even though we theoretically expect the adhesion of atoms to be large. This brings us to ask the question, “How large should adhesion be in theory?”
1.3. THEORY OF ADHESION Because of the variable and unpredictable nature of adhesion, it has been a common practice through the centuries to adopt a safe approach and design structures with the worst possible scenario in mind. In other words, engineers have traditionally adopted a theory of zero adhesion. This was certainly true of medieval bridge and cathedral builders who desired that only compression forces existed in their constructions, ensuring there were no tensions at the mortar joints to open up cracks. Figure 1.6(a) shows a brick lintel which gives a tension, causing a crack in the mortar adhesive. By devising first the corbelled arch and
10
CHAPTER 1
then the curved arch, these tensions could be overcome through the compressions acting from the ends, as shown in Fig. 1.6(b), relieving any cracking stresses in the mortar.3 Similarly, the dentist does not rely on adhesion when he fills a tooth, but prefers to undercut the cavity, so that the filling is held by mechanical locking of the mercury amalgam or dental cement, as shown in Fig. 1.7. The tooth would thus have to break to release the filling material, which can become detached from the tooth by shrinkage, cracking, or chemical attack. By the same argument, the designer of a retaining wall to hold back a soil mass does not presume that the soil has any internal adhesion between the particles, but instead designs the structure on the basis that the soil mass can slide freely on the plane shown by the dotted line. He knows by experience that the soil can have a considerable strength when dry. Dried clay and soil bricks are still
INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE
11
widely used for building houses in developing countries. However, he also knows that, if the soil is wetted or changed in acidity, then the soil can be enormously weakened and can fail disastrously. All these practices illustrate the lack of theoretical knowledge about adhesion over the centuries. Newton’s gravitational theory had suggested that universal forces existed holding masses together. Unfortunately, although gravitation can hold a rock onto the Earth’s surface, it is much too small a force to account for the observed values of adhesion between two cemented rocks. The next important step in understanding molecular adhesion forces arose from the kinetic theory of matter, which was developed towards the end of the 19th century. Strangely, like Newton’s laws of motion, this theory was developed on the crazy assumption that no adhesion existed between the atoms or molecules of a gas. The need for a kinetic theory of matter arose from microscopic study of particles immersed in liquids.8 In 1827, a botanist called Brown had been observing, through his microscope, tiny pollen grains swimming in water. The water prevented the pollen grains from sticking together, giving a close approximation to zero adhesion. Brown could see that each grain of pollen was dancing in the watery suspension as though bombarded by invisible impacts, randomly hitting the particle from all directions. He concluded that the liquid was composed of very small atomic or molecular particles, too tiny to be visible in his microscope, in constant motion. The collisions of the invisible particles on the pollen grains were causing the dancing movement, as shown in Fig. 1.8.
12
CHAPTER 1
This was an amazing breakthrough in understanding the nature of molecules. It has still not been fully absorbed into our consciousness after two centuries. Most of us still believe that material is almost continuous and nearly static, whereas in reality it is always molecular and continually moving. This is the model of matter which led eventually to the theory of intermolecular adhesion. But the immediate effect of Brown’s observation was to stimulate theoretical argument about the properties of gases which, to a first approximation, behaved as though there was no adhesion between their constituent atoms. On this assumption, Clausius, Maxwell, Boltzmann, and their co-workers generated the mathematical theory describing the behavior of perfect gases.9 The speed of the moving molecules was then recognized to be the measure of temperature. Van der Waals in 1873 was the first to consider that molecules must have attraction for each other, and that such attraction can be seen in a deviation from the perfect gas equations.9 This idea, that all bodies attract each other with a considerable adhesive force, was the beginning of a logical theory of adhesion, providing the first law, an idea which will be studied in much more detail in Chapters 3 and 5. Van der Waals’ model explained how a gas would condense into a liquid or solid as a result of the attractive forces, once the temperature was reduced to slow the Brownian motion. This cooling of a material to form an adhering solid is one of the most powerful adhesive processes, that of thermoplastic adhesion. The idea of a “van der Waals” adhesive force accounting for the effects of adhesive processes has been a potent one, allowing the well-known empirical adhesive technologies to be explained to some extent.
1.4. ADHESIVE TECHNOLOGIES Although theories of adhesion have only been developed over this past century, the technological arts of adhesion processes have existed since prehistoric times. Man’s inventiveness in finding ways of sticking objects together to fashion beautiful structures is perhaps the finest illustration of human intelligence. There is a wide range of products and processes, shown in Table 1.1, which utilize adhesion. Most of these processes and products have grown empirically from primitive beginnings which are now almost forgotten. Perhaps the earliest and most striking example is the cave paintings discovered at Altamira in Spain and Lascaux in France in the nineteenth century.10 These paintings of bison and horses date from the last ice age, some 12,000–17,000 years ago, and illustrate the strong adhesion of fine pigments to the cave wall (see Fig. 1.9). Presumably, the ancient artists had ground up the
INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE
13
colored minerals and plants to make a dispersion of fine particles in water to produce a paint which adhered successfully to the surface. Another powerful invention was that of Indian Ink, a suspension of carbon black which, after drying became waterproof. Such inks came originally from China some 5000 years ago.11 Lampblack was prepared by burning pine wood and collecting the soot in a furnace container. The fine black powder from the top of the furnace was mixed with glue made by boiling animal skins, together with other additives like crushed pearl, egg white and musk, pounded 30,000 times to break up aggregates, then strained through cloth to produce a fine ink. This was a superb example of the interaction of the collagen polymer solution with the carbon particle surface, to give entirely new properties. Of similar vintage was the discovery of the sintering process to make clay bricks which were weather-resistant. Mud and clay have been used as building materials for millenia. Clay in particular was important because of its mould-
14
CHAPTER 1
ability when wet; it could be plastically formed into elegant and large shapes. After drying, the clay was very strong but suffered from the disadvantage that it became weak again on rewetting. This problem was cured by heating the clay articles to high temperatures such that the particles adhered more strongly together. Temperatures of 700° C were sufficient to prevent rapid degradation by water. But above 1100°C, the material became totally resistant to moisture.11 Such technology has been extended over the past century to produce ceramic materials of all kinds, from electronic packaging, to magnets for electric motors, to nuclear fuel pellets. A somewhat later technology, the manufacture of paper, was created about 2000 years ago by the Egyptians, who found that beating papyrus reed stems together, then drying them, gave a matted fibrous surface which was ideal for writing.12 The cellulose fibers in the reed stems made good contact which hardened and strengthened as water was removed (see Fig. 1.10). Again, the problem was to waterproof the paper, and this can now be done by using synthetic polymer to stick the fibers more permanently. Later, mineral fibers like asbestos were used, but these proved to be a health risk when ingested. Now, there is a huge fibers industry, making polymer, glass and carbon textiles which can be adhered to give beautiful structures, such as fishing rods, cars, yachts, and the Millenium Dome. Other ancient examples of the use of natural earths and minerals include the application of bitumen as a hot melt adhesive to stick rocks together, known in
INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE
15
biblical times, and that of volcanic ash as a cement which would harden and remain strong in the presence of water. The Romans wished to build durable seawalls and found that a certain ash from the region of Pozzuoli, so-called pozzolanic material, would harden after mixing with water and would not be weakened by further immersion in sea water. Some of the sea defences built with this material are surviving to this day. Interestingly, the pozzolanic cement has lasted better than the rocks in the original walls. It was not until 1824 that Joseph Aspdin managed to make such a cement synthetically by heating clay and limestone together in a furnace, then grinding the product to a fine powder which he called Portland cement. This has now been developed to be the largest synthetic material on the planet.13 A more recent adhesive technology which has only come to fruition in the 20th century is that of synthetic polymer latex. When Columbus travelled for the first time to the New World five hundred years ago, he found that the natives played games with a rubber ball, which they had made by gathering the natural latex from certain trees. This milky fluid exuding from the tree-bark could be dried and used in several interesting ways: as a glue to stick things together; as a waterproof coating for fabrics; or as an elastic material for ball games. The natural latex was somewhat unstable and putrescible, but once the trick of adding ammonia as a stabiliser was discovered, the latex could be stored, transported, and used for many applications. The secret of artificially making such milky rubber dispersions was found by Hofmann 14 and co-workers at Bayer in 1913. There was a need at that time to find substitutes for natural rubber for the manufacture of tires. By taking a synthetic rubber precursor, for example butadiene, which is an organic liquid, adding it to water in the presence of a dispersing agent such as blood serum, then shaking, a milky fluid like the natural polymer latex could be produced, as shown in Fig. 1.11. This has been enormously successful for producing the polymer materials which lie at the heart of our modern civilization. Typical applications are adhesives, paints, condoms, tires, window frames, clothes and shoes. Essentially, we have found a synthetic replacement for the natural sticky latex adhesive material we see in nature.
1.5. ADHESION IN NATURE Long before people made their investigations into adhesion technologies, natural phenomena were occurring on the Earth’s surface, illustrating the processes of adhesion which we now understand to some degree. For example, volcanic ash was deposited over many regions. This could cement together when wet to produce the porous rock which encapsulates the ruins of Pompeii, for example. Similarly, solid particles were deposited in seas and river estuaries. These adhered together under the influence of chemistry,
16
CHAPTER 1
temperature, and pressure to form sandstones, mudstones and ultimately metamorphic rocks. Sandstone-like products can be made synthetically by heating compacted sand at alkaline pH around 13 under 100 atmosphere pressure of steam. A peculiar type of silica rock which has obviously been formed by adhesion of small particles, is opal. Its structure was only seen in detail when it was inspected by electron microscopy in the 1960s by Saunders and Murray,15 as shown in Fig. 1.12. It became clear that the structure was regular at the level, near the wavelength of light, because opals gave colorful light scattering patterns. Microscopy proved that this coloring effect was caused by the opaline structure of uniform spherical silica particles arranged in almost perfect order. It seems likely that the perfect spheres were precipitated from silicic acid solution in some ancient sea. Over a long time, the spheres would sediment together, causing the regular structure to appear. Then the water dried out to leave the spheres in contact, which would then give substantial adhesion by the effects of pressure, temperature, and water vapor. Synthetic opal can be made by this route. Another example of the variation of adhesion in natural rocks is that of fossils. When rocks are formed by the adhesion of the fine particles of a mineral,
INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE
17
any embedded creatures will influence the structure and give variations in the adhesive strength. Thus, when such a rock is fractured, the cleavage tends to follow the weak interface between the rock and the fossil, thus revealing the mark of ancient organisms in the Earth’s crust, as shown in Fig. 1.13. However, living things provide the most interesting examples of adhering structures. The earliest fossils indicate that primitive living cells were sticking to rock surfaces to form clumps. These fossils are the stromatolites,16 some 2000
18
CHAPTER 1
million years old, which were found in the siliceous chert rocks near Lake Superior. The algal cells could also secrete limestone, calcium carbonate, which could cement to form larger structures on which the living cells could proliferate. The huge coral reefs which abound in tropical seas show clearly the change in living matter which became possible when cells evolved beyond the slimy, filmforming stage to build substantial rocky structures from excreted minerals. In certain organisms, such as the diatoms, this adhesive growth has a fascinating beauty, as shown in Fig. 1.14. Extraordinary architectures are organized by the cells, somehow by templating the adhesion of the silica nanoparticles. About 500 million years ago, the most successful adhesive skeleton structure evolved in the mollusc, with superb properties: mother of pearl (Fig. 1.15). There are about 60 000 species of mollusc living today, each one depositing a shell material for protection from predators. This shell is excreted from the organism, but builds up in an organized lamellar form, with each crystal of the shell separated from its neighbor by a thin film of protein. The structure of such kinds of mother of pearl has been linked with the remarkable toughness of the shells. They are a hundred times more crack-resistant than the inorganic limestone material itself.17 Some of these molluscs, like the limpet, also secrete protein to glue themselves to the rocks below. Many investigations have been carried out to determine the nature of this wonderful, water-resistant adhesive. This secretion of adhesive glue reached its perfection in the spider, which evolved some 300 million years ago. Although the structure of spiders’ webs may
INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE
19
look obvious, there are still questions about how the silk interacts with the watery adhesive droplets condensed on them (see Fig. 1.16). For example, in certain webs the silk is pulled into the droplets and this provides the silk with more give.18 Obviously, one of the most compelling reasons for studying adhesion is the fact that our bodies are grown and held together by these forces. From the moment that the sperm cell attaches itself to the egg, and the egg adheres to the wall of the womb, we live by the attractive forces of adhesion. Of course, we would end up as mere blobs of jelly without the strong adherence of the calcium
20
CHAPTER 1
phosphate bone particles to build our skeleton. Our skin would be weak and soggy if platelets of polymer had not adhered sufficiently to provide elasticity. Our brains could not work if the nerve cells had not made adhering communicating contacts. On the other hand, it is a blessing that our red blood cells do not stick together because capillary flow would then be impossible. Unfortunately, some cancer cells are not sticky enough and spread because the malignant cell adhesion is too low to prevent migration. The conclusion is that we wish to understand and control both high and low adhesion within our bodies.
1.6. INTERDISCIPLINARY NATURE OF ADHESION; PURPOSE OF THIS BOOK It is evident from this brief overview of adhesion technology, nature, and science that many different specialists have an interest in the definition of what adhesion is, in the observing and measurement of the adhesive forces, in the chemical modification of surfaces to control adhesiveness, in improving adhesion so that aircraft do not fall apart, and in reducing adhesion so that cars do not seize up. In other words, adhesion is an interdisciplinary subject. Indeed, it connects many different subjects because of its common function and value. We set out to address these issues, attempting to build a bridge of adhesion between the different disciplines. In the next chapter, the old debates about the phenomena and theories of adhesion are rehearsed. This allows us to focus on acceptable definitions of molecular adhesion. Then the logical theory of adhesion is expounded by defining the ideas, the terms, and symbols more carefully in order to work out the connections between them in Chapter 3. Thus, the laws of adhesion begin to be recognizable in a general form. Two new sciences are developing now to enlarge our ideas about the laws of adhesion: Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM), which for the first time has allowed us to measure molecular forces; and computer modeling (CM), which has pushed the theory of molecular adhesion onto a new level. These new arguments are described in Chapters 3 and 5 to give an overview of the three laws of adhesion. Having defined our framework of adhesion theory and measurement, it is then possible to cover the different application areas of adhesion science in Chapters 9–16. Starting with the adhesion of particles, which is fundamental to a molecular argument, we move on to colloids, pastes, and cells. Then the industrial areas are covered in electronics, films, adhesive joints, and composite materials (see Fig. 1.17). Finally, there is a discussion of the future of adhesion and how the description of adhesion phenomena may develop in the years to come. There is a problem that in some areas, such as fracture of joints, the mathematical analysis has become so detailed that it is incomprehensible to the
INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE
21
chemist. Yet this mathematics often does not take into account the fact that molecules exist, whereas the chemist starts his theoretical argument from the molecular premise. This gulf of assumptions has to be crossed. Chemists are fascinated by adhesion because they know that different molecules will provide different levels of tackiness; physicists are challenged by the fact that adhesion is very difficult to measure; material scientists see that all substances contain a multiplicity of interfaces which dominate the properties; geologists recognize that the soils and sands of the Earth’s crust are controlled by adhesion; biologists see adhesion as the connection between cells and living structures. And engineers of all kinds, from dentists, to cement constructors, through aircraft designers, computer scientists, chemical engineers, powder technologists, and pharmacists, see adhesion as a common thread in their subjects. Unfortunately, there is a lack of common language and methodology across the boundaries of these disciplines. Would an aircraft designer understand what the parasitologist is talking about in a discussion of adhesion molecules like integrin? At present, the word “adhesion” itself means different things in separate
22
CHAPTER 1
subject areas. Some authors have gone so far as to say that molecular adhesion does not exist, and that the phenomena of sticky objects can be described by other mechanisms.19 This book is needed to rationalize the science and technology of molecular adhesion across the whole range of specialisms. It is important that we all agree what the word “adhesion” means, with a definition acceptable to both dentists and rocket engineers. A blood cell adheres one million times less than a sticky label, and that label sticks one million times less than an aircraft wing. The several scales at which adhesion operates are illustrated in Fig. 1.17 which shows molecules adhering to a cell surface, cells adhering to paint, paint on a wing and the wing on an aircraft. We have to solve the problems of measuring over such widely ranging scales and of finding suitable units and standards.
1.7.
REVIEW OF ADHESION LITERATURE
A large number of books and journals deal with molecular adhesion. Hirschfelder20 edited a fine work on Intermolecular forces, and Israelachvili21 considered the application of such forces to interfaces, and to colloidal and biological systems. Surface chemistry books have been written by Bikerman,19 Gregg,22 and Adamson.23 A number of excellent books on colloids exist, including those by Myers,24 Everett,25 Shaw26 and Hunter.27 A good book on surface forces in relation to catalysis was produced by Somorjai.28 Journals on molecular adhesion are rare. There is the Journal of Adhesion which has been edited by Lou Sharpe for more than 30 years. And there is the Journal of Adhesion and Adhesives, published by Butterworth. Colloid journals are more common because of their great industrial significance. These include the Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, Advances in Colloid and Interface Science, Colloids and Surfaces, Surface and Colloid Science, Colloid Polymer Science, and Progress in Surface and Membrane Science. Books on the applications of adhesion are much more common. Kinloch’s book on adhesion and adhesives29 is very interesting. Newer books have emerged recently on structural adhesives30, on particle adhesion,31 and on the energetics of adhesion mechanics.32 This is the first book on adhesion to attempt to give an overall picture.
1.8. REFERENCES 1. Newton, I., Opticks, Smith and Walford, London, 1704 (reprinted Dover, New York, 1952, p 376). 2. Kowal, C.T., Asteroids: Their Nature and Utilisation (2nd edn.) Wiley, London, 1996, pp 100–3. 3. Gordon, J.E., Structures, Penguin, London, 1978.
INTRODUCTION TO MOLECULAR ADHESION AND FRACTURE
23
4. Lee, L-H., In Fundamentals of Adhesion and Interfaces, eds. Rimai, D.S., DeMejo, L.P. and Mittal, K.L., VSP, Utrecht, 1995, pp 73–94. 5. Holm, R., Electrical Contacts, Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1967. 6. Bowden, F.P. and Tabor, D.T., Friction and Lubrication of Solids, Clarendon Press, Oxford, Part I 1950, Part II 1964. 7. Kendall, K. and Tabor, D., Proc. R. Soc A 323, 321–40 (1971). 8. Perrin, J.B., Atoms, Constable, London, 1923. 9. Maxwell, J.H., Theory of Heat, Longman Green, London, 1871. Brush, S.G., Statistical Physics and the Atomic Theory of Matter, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 1983. van der Waals, J.H. PhD Thesis, University of Leiden, 1873. 10. Gombrich, E.H., The Story of Art, Phaidon, London, 1998, p 40. 11. Needham, J., Science and Civilisation in China, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1985, pp 239–47. 12. Allen, K., Int. J. Adhesion Adhesives 16, 47–51 (1996). 13. Bye, G.C., Portland Cement, 2nd edn, Thomas Telford, London, 1999, ch. 1. 14. Hofmann, German Patent 250690 to Bayer Farbenfabriken, 1913. 15. Sanders, J.V. and Murray, M.J., Nature, 275, 201–3 (1978). 16. Attenborough, D., Life on Earth, Collins, London, 1980, pp 18–23. 17. Currey, J.D., Proc. R. Soc. B 196, 443–63 (1977). 18. Dawkins, R., Climbing Mount Improbable, Penguin, London, 1997, p 34. 19. Bikerman, J.J., Physical Surfaces, Academic Press, New York, p. 119. 20. Hirschfelder, J.O. (ed.) Intermolecular Forces, Wiley Interscience, New York, 1967. 21. Israelachvili, J.N., Intermolecular and Surface Forces, Academic Press, New York, 1985. 22. Gregg, S.J., Surface Chemistry of Solids, Reinhold, New York, 1961. 23. Adamson, A.W., Physical Chemistry of Surfaces, 5th edn. Wiley Interscience, New York, 1990. 24. Myers, D., Surfaces, Interfaces and Colloids, VCH, New York, 1990. 25. Everett, D.H., Basic Principles of Colloid Science, Royal Society of Chemistry, London, 1988. 26. Shaw, D.J., Introduction to Colloid and Surface Chemistry, Butterworth, London, 1970. 27. Hunter, R.J., Foundations of Colloid Science, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1987. 28. Somorjai, G.A., Introduction to Surface Chemistry and Catalysis, Wiley Interscience, New York, 1994. 29. Kinloch, A.J., Adhesion and Adhesives: Science and Technology, Chapman & Hall, London, 1987. 30. Adams, R.D., Comyn, J. and Wake, W.C., Structural Adhesive Joints in Engineering, Chapman & Hall, London, 1997. 31. Podczeck, F., Particle-Particle Adhesion in Pharmaceutical Powder Handling, Imperial College Press, London, 1998. 32. Maugis, D., Contact, Adhesion and Rupture of Elastic Solids, Springer, Berlin, 1999.
2 PHENOMENOLOGY OF ADHESION: FRACTURE STRANGER THAN FRICTION
Two polish’d marbles, . . . by immediate contact stick together ISAAC NEWTON, Opticks1
Newton was convinced that bodies brought into close contact should adhere strongly. However, the experimental demonstration of this phenomenon was not so readily achieved. Newton reasoned that the imperfection of surfaces was the most important factor inhibiting contact, as described in Chapter 1. Therefore he developed better methods for polishing glass lenses to upgrade their quality. This was the work that brought him to famous recognition in 1671 when he first displayed at the Royal Society his marvelous new reflecting telescope lenses for improved observation of the stars and planets. However, glass and hard substances like metals are the worst substances for revealing adhesion phenomena. That is why such materials are excellent in ball bearings, which last for years and rarely stick or seize up. So Newton only observed adhesion sporadically. He could not get reliable adhesion between the glass lenses. It turns out that Newton would have been much more successful in proving his ideas on adhesion if he had used the rubbery material which Columbus had brought back from the New World. Such soft material sticks far better than glass. Also, it has become evident that large bodies, like Newton’s glass lenses, are less likely to show adhesion than small ones. If Newton had done his experiments on fine glass fibers, which are easily drawn down from the melt to in thickness, five times finer than a human hair, then he would have quickly seen the reliable adhesion he was expecting from his theoretical arguments. The 25
CHAPTER 2
26
conclusion is that molecular adhesion is observed best on small, smooth, soft objects. Let us review some of these well-known adhesion phenomena.
2.1. ADHESION PHENOMENA Many phenomena lead us to believe that molecular adhesion exists. We recognize that, just as a small solid particle sticks to a surface, so a droplet of water adheres to glass, and we realize, as Young and Laplace did in the early 1800s, that this can be explained by attractions between the water molecules and the glass. It is evident that this is an intensely local and short-range attraction, because changing the size of the droplet to make it very small does not influence the adhesion, as shown in Fig. 2.1. Using liquids in this way, it is also very easy to show that the two major resisting effects mentioned in Chapter 1, surface contamination and roughness, are readily observable. Figure 2.1(b) shows that, when a thin, single layer of wax molecules is laid on the glass surface, then the water drop will not spread easily. Similarly, when the surface is roughened, the droplet is even more resistant to spreading. But it is evident that the roughness effect is different from the wax, which weakens both adhesion and detachment; the roughness weakens adhesion but strengthens detachment of the water from the glass. In other words it resists both processes of adhesion and detaching: it is hysteretic, in other words a process rather like viscosity in Newton’s theory of forces.
PHENOMENOLOGY OF ADHESION
27
The problem with adhesion is that we often use the same word to describe quite different situations. For example, when we split a log with an axe, as in Fig. 2.2(a), we can see the cellulose fibers separating by fracture within the wood, and we conclude that the wood is made up of cellulose fibres strongly adhering together. This is a valid description. However, when one describes the adhesion of a tire to a road surface2 or of a railway wheel to a steel rail, as in Fig. 2.2(b), this means something entirely different. In fact, there is no significant adhesion force in this case as one tries to lift the wheel from the track. Instead, the writer is referring to the force required to make the wheel skid along the surface. This phenomenon should be called friction and not adhesion. If the railway was built on the surface of the Moon, however, there could well be significant adhesion then between wheel and rail because the surfaces are much cleaner, giving improved contact. Friction would then also increase. In another example, Velcro fabric or a zip fastener is said to produce adhesion between two pieces of material as shown in Fig. 2.2(c). But such devices operate on a hook and eye principle, in which the hooks of one piece becomes entangled with the loops of another. The separation of such Velcro joints requires friction to slide the fibers across each other, plus deformation of the curved hooks to obtain release. No adhesion between the materials is necessarily needed. Similarly, a book on the “Adhesion of piles in stiff clays”3 is more about frictional sliding of the pile as it is pulled out of the clay, rather like the fiber pullout test described in Chapter 16. However, once the pile is removed, clay may then be seen adhering to the steel surface. Clearly, both friction and adhesion can be observed simultaneously in this case, as shown in Fig. 2.2(d). The conclusion from this discussion is that word “adhesion” should be used only to describe those phenomena in which a normal force is needed to separate
CHAPTER 2
28
materials, e.g. by fracture, and not to describe frictional effects where sliding or shear is the force.
2.2. FRICTION Friction is therefore different from adhesion. It is worth considering the differences in more detail because the friction problem is as old as that of adhesion,4 becoming known as tribology after the Greek word “tribos” meaning rubbing, during the celebrated studies of Bowden and Tabor.5 Friction had obviously been important in producing fire during ancient times, and preventing friction was valuable in construction and in chariot building, as shown by Egyptian wall-paintings which showed lubricant being poured in front of a moving stone slab about four thousand years ago. Friction was known to be similar to adhesion because it was affected by surface contamination and also by time of contact. Leonardo da Vinci had demonstrated the two laws of friction, which were rediscovered later by Amontons and Coulomb, and wrote in his notebooks Codex Atlanticus and Codex Arundel that “friction produces double the amount of effort if the weight be doubled” and “friction... will be... equal... although the contact may be of different breadth and length.” This last is extremely surprising at first glance and is illustrated by Leonardo’s diagram shown in Fig. 2.3. An engineer would surely expect the force to rise if the area of contact was larger. But this was not so for most cases. The explanation of these old laws was put forward by Bowden and Tabor following Holm’s studies6 of electrical conduction through metal contacts. It was demonstrated by elegant theoretical and practical arguments that the molecular contact between two metal blocks was very much smaller than expected from the simple geometrical appearance. But as the load increased, the molecular contact increased in proportion to load, as shown in Fig. 2.3(b), because the pressure was so high at the small points of contact with the material flowed plastically. Thus the friction also rose proportionally to the normal load. The difficulty with this theory was that no adhesion was usually observed after the normal load was removed. If the materials had been in molecular contact, causing cold-welding at the high pressure points, then surely some residual adhesion would be noticed when it came to separating the objects. The ingenious explanation put forward was that the elastic recovery of the materials would be sufficient to break the adhesive joints as the load was lifted. In fact, with clean metals, adhesion was generally observed, and transfer of metal fragments from one surface to the other could be detected, thus proving that strong adhesion had occurred in small localized contact regions.
PHENOMENOLOGY OF ADHESION
29
2.3. GRAVITATIONAL ATTRACTION In addition to friction, which is often confused with adhesion, there are several other phenomena which give attractions between bodies. These phenomena can therefore mix up the issues of molecular adhesion. As Newton wrote: “the attractions of Gravity, Magnetism and Electricity reach to very sensible distances, and so have been observed by vulgar Eyes, and there may be others which reach to so small distances as hitherto escape observation.”1 Gravity is an ever-present attractive force between bodies which must contribute to the adhesion between objects. This gravitational adhesion can be calculated from Newton’s famous law. Consider two spheres, 10 mm in diameter, mass 1 g each, in contact as shown in Fig. 2.4. The force of attraction is readily calculated from Newton’s gravitation law to be a very small force, so small that it can normally be neglected when compared with molecular adhesion. One chemical bond is typically 1 nN in force, a thousand times larger than the gravity force between two 10 mm diameter spheres. The conclusion is that we can usually neglect Newton’s gravitation in comparison to molecular forces. Although it appears from this calculation that we can ignore the gravitational force, there is a subtle influence of gravity which has a large adhesive effect,
30
CHAPTER 2
which can also be confused with molecular adhesion. This effect arises from the gravity of the Earth which pulls the atmospheric gases (nitrogen, oxygen, argon) etc. down onto the planet’s surface. This creates an atmospheric pressure which can act to give suction pad adhesion. Imagine a rubber suction pad sitting on a surface, as shown in Fig. 2.5(a). This seals around the rim so that gas cannot get in. When a force is applied to pull the suction pad off the surface, as in Fig. 2.5(b), a vacuum is created and the pressure of the Earth’s atmosphere resists this pull to give an apparent adhesion. Since the atmospheric pressure is l00 kPa, i.e. l00 kN per square meter, this is a surprisingly large adhesive effect which arises solely from gravitation. A pad only 40 mm in diameter can support a 10kg weight. It is obvious that this suction effect is not true molecular adhesion. Suction pads work better as you dive beneath the ocean where the gravitational pressure increases. But they get worse as you climb a mountain, eventually becoming useless in space. Molecular adhesion should remain the same, at the bottom of the sea or out in space, independent of gravitational effects.
2.4. ELECTROSTATIC AND MAGNETIC ATTRACTIONS Yet another confusing adhesive influence is that of electricity and magnetism. Adhesion of bodies as a result of electrical charging was known to the Greeks. Rubbing glass or amber with cloth would make the material attract small
PHENOMENOLOGY OF ADHESION
31
pieces of dust or paper. A particularly eerie sensation is when your hair stands up as a result of electrical fields. The same effect is obtained by rubbing a balloon. The rubber material picks up an electrical charge, allowing the balloon to stick to a window. It is evident that such adhesion is different from true molecular adhesion because moisture, or nuclear radiation, allows the charge to leak away and the balloon drops off. Priestley7 described such phenomena in 1767 in his book History and Present State of Electricity and suggested that the law of electrical attraction should be the same as Newton’s gravitational principle. This allowed Cavendish to provide an experimental proof four years later, but he did not publish his work and it was not found again for more than a century.8 Meanwhile, Coulomb in 1785 had constructed a mechanical balance for measuring the repulsive forces between two equally charged pith balls, showing that Newton’s law of inverse squares was indeed operating. The electrical force seemed to act from the center of the ball, and decayed with the square of the distance from the center. Thus such forces act over considerable distances and are easily distinguished from molecular adhesion forces, which act only a few nanometers from a surface. Coulomb then showed by means of his mechanical balance that the inverse square law operated also for magnets. It later became clear that magnetism resulted from flowing electrical charges and that the inverse square law applied also to electrical currents, i.e. electrons flowing in wires. Thus, the field of electromagnetism became systematically understood in terms of Coulombic interactions, caused by very small charged particles, i.e. electrons and their flow. Electrons were shown to be ubiquitous in all known atoms and also to be responsible for chemical reactions.9 For example, the intense and fiery reaction of sodium with chlorine was shown to be the transfer of a single electron from one sodium atom to its neighboring chlorine atom, as shown schematically in Fig. 2.6. The main problem with electrons is that they are much smaller than atoms, so they cannot be treated by our ordinary concepts of particles. Instead, they have properties of both waves and particles and so must be described by quantum theory.9 The other problem is that electrons are negatively charged and therefore
CHAPTER 2
32
repel each other. If electrons repel, and atoms are bunches of electrons, how then can atoms be attracted towards each other? The answer to this question is complex and is rooted in the quantum theory proposed by London10 in 1937, and summarized in several books on intermolecular forces. 11,12 The principle can be understood by thinking of the outer electron in the sodium atom rotating rapidly around its nucleus, as shown in Fig. 2.7. Because the electron is negative and the nucleus is positive, at any instant there is a separation of negative and positive charge, even though the average charge separation is zero over a period of time. This is an instantaneous dipole, like a tiny magnet, which can line up a similar sodium atom at a distance. This gives an instantaneous dipole–dipole interaction which is always attractive. Such a “London” force is the cause of the general attractive adhesion between all atoms. London showed that this force was very different from simple electrostatic interactions because it dropped off with distance more rapidly, with separation to the power of 7. This explains why molecular forces are short range, and only operate when bodies are in close contact. The conclusion from this brief discussion is that molecular adhesion is caused by electromagnetic forces, but not the simple forces that operate in electric motors or between magnets. Those Coulombic forces can be either attractions or repulsions and obey Newton’s inverse square law. By contrast, molecular adhesion is caused by London forces which are always attractive and which fall off extremely rapidly with separation. In other words, molecules are made up of both electrons and protons which balance their charges exactly to give zero Coulombic adhesion. But the slight separation of charges in the molecules gives overall attractive London adhesion. The sub-atomic particles themselves adhere in quite a different way as described below.
2.5. ADHESION BETWEEN NUCLEAR PARTICLES Electrons (very small sub-atomic particles) are therefore the fundamental cause of molecular attractions. These were the first elementary particles to be
PHENOMENOLOGY OF ADHESION
33
discovered, identified, and measured, for example in the classic experiments of J. J. Thomson more than a century ago. It was evident from those studies that an electron is much smaller than an atom, almost 2000 times less massive than a hydrogen atom. We can therefore view molecular adhesion as the bringing together of electron clouds. The other fundamental particles (the proton and neutron) were found later, as the model of the atomic nucleus was developed. They stick together in an entirely different way. It was apparent that in the nuclei of all the elements there exists a bunch of protons and neutrons sticking together. This adhesion of the nuclear particles has been theoretically defined in terms of the strong interaction, one of the three distinct forces in nature. The strong nuclear force hold the protons and neutrons together. This strong nuclear adhesive force plays no part in molecular adhesion, which we know to be dominated by the second force, electromagnetic interaction. Finally, the third force of nature is gravitation, which is too weak to account for molecular adhesion. The simplest way to view the three forces of nature is in terms of density. Newton’s weak gravitational force dominates our Solar System where the average density is around On Earth, where the density is about electromagnetic forces are dominant and these are the main topic of this book. However, in the densest stellar objects, neutron stars, the strong force is dominant because the density is that of nuclear particles, around The adhesion between such particles must be immense. Although this strong adhesion between nuclear particles is not evident on Earth, except within atomic nuclei, it controls neutron stars, which were originally proposed as a theoretical idea in 1934.13 This was not supported by experimental observations until the pulsars were discovered in 1967.14 These seemed to be rotating neutron stars, a concept which is accepted today. A neutron star has a mass around kg and a radius near 10 km, leading to the huge density mentioned above. The star is compressed by the large gravitational
34
CHAPTER 2
attraction of the mass and is supported by the outward thrust of the neutrons, to give the structure shown in Fig. 2.8. Because of the variety of these forces acting in the universe, it is rather important to define molecular adhesion in a careful and simple way so that there is no confusion between the three known forces: strong nuclear, electromagnetic, and gravitational.
2.6. DEMONSTRATION OF THE MOLECULAR ADHESION FORCE Consider now an experiment which demonstrates molecular adhesion simply and unequivocally. Take a sample of very fine, pure solid powder, say 4 g of diameter grains of titanium dioxide. This powder can be poured into a hard steel pelleting die, as shown in Fig. 2.9(a). Coulombic forces can be prevented by the presence of a radioactive source to ionise the air and leak away any stray electrons. After pressing the powder with a force, say l00 kN, the pellet can be ejected from the die in one piece. The powder particles then stick together with considerable strength. Of course, the tablet is porous because the titanium dioxide grains are so hard that they cannot squash together plastically. But where the powder particles touch each other, the molecules of titanium oxide are in close proximity as a result of the large force which has urged them into molecular contact. Then, the short-range adhesion forces discussed above can act to pull the particles strongly together, thereby resisting external stresses. By testing the pellet in bending or tension, it is easy to find that the compacted pellet has the properties of a porous titania ceramic. It is strong, elastic, and brittle, but not so strong as dense transparent titania which has no pores to weaken it. Typically, the pellet contains 50% by volume of air cavities,
PHENOMENOLOGY OF ADHESION
35
which make the pellet crack readily. Further evidence of molecular adhesion is obtained by heating the pellet in a furnace. At temperatures around 1200°C, the particles begin to diffuse, and the molecular adhesion within the pellet is so powerful that the pellet gradually shrinks to exclude the pores and become dense. The molecular adhesion forces are sufficient to pull the grains into complete and perfect contact. This process is the sintering phenomenon. William Hyde Wollaston15 first described this type of adhesion experiment in 1829. He was interested in making dense and strong wires from platinum and other rare metals, such as palladium and osmium, which he had just discovered. Platinum is so hard and refractory that it is extremely difficult to work by ordinary melting and casting techniques. Wollaston prepared the platinum in fine particle form by precipitating the metal from an acid solution which had been used to remove impurities. This produced a muddy mixture of water and particles which were cleaned by washing, then dispersed by milling in a wooden mortar and pestle. Wood was used to limit contamination since it would burn out later. The difficulty was converting the fine metal powder into a dense block. To achieve this, Wollaston needed to get the particles sticking together in a dense packing. First, he constructed a mechanical press, shown in Fig. 2.10, consisting of a brass cylinder into which fitted an iron piston around 25 mm diameter. The barrel of the cylinder was tapered so that the pellet could be ejected after compaction. After placing the platinum mud in the barrel, then covering it with blotting paper to allow the water to soak out, and greasing the piston with lard, Wollaston pressed on the ram to apply a force of about 30 tonnes weight to the powder mass. This force was sufficient to increase the packing of the fine particles under the ram from a loose state of 20% packing to a porous pellet near 50% dense. This pellet was ejected in one adherent piece and was “hard and firm” suggesting that each platinum particle was adhering to its neighbors by molecular forces.
36
CHAPTER 2
Heating of the pellet with burning charcoal was sufficient to remove moisture and organic lubricant. Then the pellet was raised to white heat in a Staffordshire coke furnace. This caused the pellet to contract as the particles sintered together. Pounding the hot pellet with a hammer produced a material which was 99% dense and which produced platinum wire of the “highest tenacity.” Of course, platinum is not as hard as titanium oxide and so the deformation of the particles during the compaction is more plastic. The adhesion between plastic particles during compaction is even more striking than that between elastic oxide grains. This is readily demonstrated by compressing potassium bromide powder in a steel die, as routinely done for infrared analysis. During the compression of the grains, the pressure at the contact points becomes larger than the yield pressure and consequently the contact spots enlarge until all the porosity has been excluded, as indicated schematically in Fig. 2.11. On removal from the die, the compacted pellet is seen to be fully transparent and completely dense. The pellet is also very strong, elastic, and brittle, comparable to a piece of solid potassium bromide made by other methods. Thus the conclusion is that the compaction force has brought the grains into molecular contact, generating adhesion. Further force has sheared the material close to the contacts, allowing more intimate molecular contact until all the particle surfaces are adhering strongly. The lessons we learn from such demonstrations are fourfold: all bodies can be made to adhere together; finer particles stick more easily; force is usually required to push the bodies into molecular contact; and deformation, especially plastic or diffusive flow, allows more extensive contact to give maximal adhesion.
PHENOMENOLOGY OF ADHESION
37
Skeptics may say that the adhesion developed in the above experiment can be explained by other well-known ideas. These sorts of argument leveled against molecular adhesion phenomena can be listed. There is first the suction argument, which says that the particles are acting as rubber suction pads, and merely sealing around the edges; this is easily shown to be false because the pellets are just as strong in vacuum, where suction pads fall apart. Secondly, there is the mechanical keying argument, which suggests that the particles behave like Velcro, with little hooks and eyes to cause adhesion. This is easily answered because when you look at the surfaces by electron microscopy, the particles are often extremely smooth and shiny. There are no hooks and eyes. Moreover, the smoother particles show stronger adhesion than rough particles. A third argument is that the particles are electrically charged, to give electrostatic attractions. This is readily disproved by doing the experiment in the presence of ionizing radiation to leak away the electrons. The adhesion is not affected. The fourth argument is moisture; a critic will say that the particle surfaces are damp and this is like the adhesion of wet sand, which sticks more than dry sand. Again this can be disproved by evacuation; in fact, the dryer the particles, the better they adhere. Finally, a desperate argument is Newton’s gravitation. But a rapid calculation shows that this is much too small to cause the adhesion observed. So the conclusion must be that molecular adhesion is the most rational explanation of the experiments described above. There is obviously a force of molecular adhesion which draws bodies together; as a consequence there must therefore be an energy of adhesion, because energy is the summation of force acting over a distance. The experiments above define the force; to understand the energy we must now look at the range of action of the adhesion.
2.7. PROBING MOLECULAR ADHESION: THE RANGE OF MOLECULAR ATTRACTIONS A simple way to distinguish molecular adhesion from electrostatic, gravitational, or liquid bridge adhesion is to observe the range of action of the force. Newton knew of the long-range action of those forces and was tantalized by the much shorter range of molecular adhesion. The two most easily distinguishable forces of attraction are suction and liquid bridge adhesion. The suction pad, as explained in Fig. 2.5, relies on atmospheric pressure to hold the bodies together. This pressure remains constant as the pad is pulled away from its substrate. The same is true of a liquid droplet acting to glue two balls together; the force of adhesion is constant as the balls separate, as shown schematically in Fig. 2.12. Thus these two types of adhesion
38
CHAPTER 2
are tough; the force stays high with distance and so a great deal of energy is required to pull the bodies apart. The energy is the area under the line. Electrostatic adhesion is not so tough because now the force falls off with the square of distance from the centers. But the force is still of long range and can be measured with distance on a large scale. You can measure the distance with a meter ruler, for example. Newton’s gravitation force also follows this curve but the force is very small. However, molecular adhesion is very different. This falls off in a very short distance of separation. As a consequence, these molecular adhesion forces cannot be measured with a meter ruler, but need a nanometer scale. The adhesion force may be high when the molecules are touching, but even a separation of one nanometer causes the force to drop almost to nothing. Thus the surfaces snap apart in a brittle fashion, totally different from the other types of adhesion force. The area under the curve is very small. In other words, the energy of molecular adhesion may be negligible. Taking this energy for one square metre of joint, we define the work of adhesion W in Joules per square metre. The other feature of molecular forces which is evident from this comparison is seen when the balls are brought back together. The suction pad and the liquid drop make contact again very easily. Also the electrostatic bond is readily renewed as the balls touch again, to give the same strength as before. But the molecular adhesion is not easily regained. The smallest speck of dust, or contamination by a single layer of foreign molecules, can prevent the molecular
PHENOMENOLOGY OF ADHESION
39
bonding. In other words, the surfaces cannot be replaced in exactly the same position to reinstate the original bond. That is the fundamental cause of the adhesion paradox discussed in Chapter 1. Molecular adhesion is not reliable or easily repeatable, because molecules cannot easily be put back in exactly the same position. As Newton recognized, this short range of action of molecular forces has made the force measurement extremely difficult. Only in the past few years or so has it been possible to make the necessary measurements at the nanometer level to prove these ideas. Two problems have been overcome. The first one was the measurement technique. Optical methods, such as multiple beam interferometry and laser optical levers, have been developed to measure atomic distances. Piezoelectric actuators were invented to control nanomovements. The second issue was surface smoothness. Smooth surfaces of oxides such as mica, silica or alumina have been found. Also tiny smooth probes have been made on a large scale by electronic wafer fabrication routes. These new techniques have allowed a new and proper definition of molecular adhesion.
2.8. DEFINITION OF MOLECULAR ADHESION Consider a definition of molecular adhesion which allows it to be distinguished from all the other known forms of attractions between bodies: molecular adhesion is the force experienced when bodies make contact at the molecular level, with gaps near molecular dimensions. This definition raises a number of questions which will be addressed in the following chapters. The obvious question relates to the origins and laws of molecular adhesion. How can one measure and interpret such phenomena? Clearly, molecular adhesion forces have the same origins as the forces of cohesion which hold solids and liquids together. These can be understood in terms of the heats of melting or evaporation, the elastic stiffnesses, or the chemical reactivities of materials, as described in Chapter 5. A second question concerns the tools which we can use to observe molecular adhesion more directly. New methods, such as Atomic Force Microscopy and Computer Simulation, have emerged over the past 30 years to play a large part in our understanding of the effects, as covered in Chapters 5 and 6. Finally there is the frontier of adhesion. The further our study of adhesion penetrates, the richer the mechanisms and the applications, as described from Chapter 7 onwards. Eventually we must ask in the final chapter “What is the future of molecular adhesion?”
40
CHAPTER 2
2.9. REFERENCES 1. Newton, I., Opticks, Smith and Walford, London, 1704 (reprinted Dover, New York, 1952, p 376). 2. Walters, M.H. and Smith, J.G., In: Adhesion II ed K.W. Allen, Applied Science, London, 1978, pp 145-66. 3. Tomlinson, M.J., Adhesion of Piles in Stiff Clays, London Construction Industry Research and Information Association, London, 1970. 4. Dowson, D., History of Tribology, Longman, New York, 1979. 5. Bowden, F.P. and Tabor, D., Friction and Lubrication, Methuen, London, 1967. 6. Holm, R., Electrical Contacts, Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1967. 7. Priestley, J., History and Present State of Electricity, J. Dodsley, London, 1767. 8. Singer, C., A Short History of Scientific Ideas, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1959, p 354. 9. Pauling, L., The Nature of the Chemical Bond, 3rd edn., Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY, 1960. 10. London, F., Trans. Faraday Soc. 33, 8–26 (1937). 11. Mahanty, J. and Ninham, B.W., Dispersion Forces, Academic Press, New York, 1976. 12. Margenau, H. and Kestner, N.R., Theory of Intermolecular Forces, Pergamon, Oxford, 1971. 13. Baade, W. and Zwicky, F., Phys. Rev. 45, 138 (1934). 14. Shapiro, S.L. and Teukolsky, S.A., Black Holes, White Dwarfs and Neutron Stars, Wiley Interscience, New York, 1983, pp 241–66. 15. Wollaston, W.H., Phil. Trans. R. Soc. 119, 1–8 (1829).
3 THEORIES AND LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION: ALL MOLECULES ADHERE
I found the place in which they touched to become absolutely transparent, as if they had there been one continued piece of glass ISAAC NEWTON,1 Opticks, p. 194
The ideas that Newton developed about the sticking together of bodies were quite advanced compared with those of Galileo who had died just a few years earlier. Although Galileo,2 from his observations of the planets, had come to the conclusion that “all parts of the Earth do congregate… ever striving… at union”, and thus had a vision of adhesion as a general property of matter, he had only produced a vague and shadowy theory of this notion. He speculated that there were two causes: one was the abhorrence that nature had for the vacuum created as bodies were separated; the other was the viscous resistance needed to deform the materials. Galileo was wrong on both these matters. In contrast, Newton pressed glass lenses together and considered that the fundamental particles of the glass should become intimately bonded at the transparent contact area (see Fig. 3.1). He found adhesion in some cases. From the observations, he could address the common fallacies of the time, including the idea that vacuum was necessary, and the other common notions that the bodies require glue or have to key together to produce an adhesive effect. Let us consider these fallacies first before going on to state the laws that follow from Newton’s logic. 41
42
CHAPTER 3
3.1. THREE ADHESION FALLACIES The first fallacy, that vacuum causes adhesion, was understandable because of Galileo’s influential statement above and also because vacuum was invented by Newton’s contemporary, Galileo’s pupil and secretary Torricelli, who built the original mercury barometer around the time of Newton’s birth, generating the first artificial vacuum in the closed tube above the mercury column. The great force of vacuum on the Earth’s surface was later demonstrated by von Guericke when Newton was 13 years old. It was a tremendous demonstration, where two teams of 8 horses failed to separate the “Magdeburg hemispheres” after the air was withdrawn by von Guericke’s air pump. We can dismiss the vacuum theory of adhesion easily today, as in Chapters 1 and 2, because astronauts have found that, in space, suction does not give adhesion, whereas the molecular adhesion of particles in space is better than on Earth. We know therefore that the adhesion due to vacuum is only an indirect form of gravitational adhesion, varying from planet to planet. The suction effect cannot explain molecular adhesion. The second fallacy is more difficult because it arises from the adhesion paradox; that if we break a cup, the parts do not stick together merely by putting the pieces back in contact. Usually, we have to insert some adhesive or glue to join and stick the fragments of pottery back. So we presume that materials do not naturally adhere but require an adhesive layer in between. Similarly, when building a house, we find that the bricks will only stick together if we put mortar in between to make a strong joint, as shown in Fig. 3.2. The same sort of argument is put forward to explain why you cannot make sandcastles from dry sand. You need to use damp sand because the water acts as a glue to hold the sand grains together. This was the question that Newton puzzled over. If you could get the bricks or the sand grains into molecular contact, he mused, then they should stick. We now know that this is true, because when you take small particles with smooth surfaces, then bring them into close proximity, typically within 10 nm of each other, then the particles leap into contact. All known particles, whether rubber,
THEORIES AND LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION
43
gold, mica, or gelatin, do this. It seems that molecular adhesion is a very general and universal phenomenon. Thus the adhesion paradox is really caused by the problem of getting the bodies close enough together in the first place. The molecular adhesion forces are of such short range that they cannot act even over micrometer gaps. What is more, it has been shown quite clearly that putting water or adhesive on the particles reduces the molecular adhesion.3 Molecular adhesion works best in the vacuum of space. Already on Earth, the atmosphere of oxygen, moisture and organic contamination is known to reduce molecular adhesion by orders of magnitude. The conclusion is inescapable; adhesives reduce the adhesion between clean bodies. The third fallacy is insidious because it stems again from our common-sense knowledge of making furniture and building cars. It is universally obvious that wooden chairs are best assembled using mortise and tenon joints, as shown in Fig. 3.3(a). A male key is made from one piece of wood and this fits snugly into the female slot in the other piece. If the joint is finely made, then glue is
44
CHAPTER 3
unnecessary. The artisan inserts glue anyway for a belt and braces solution. A cruder example is the nailed wood, illustrating the old adage of adhesive technology: “When all else fails, use whopping great nails.” Finally, the jigsaw convinces us as infants that mechanical keying is the source of adhesion. This keying idea has been applied to particles; for example, Evans4 stated, “strength of (powder) compacts results mainly from the interlocking of irregularities on the particle surfaces.” This concept is totally false. The same idea has also been applied to the binding of antigens to antibodies.5 It is a macroscopic idea which we have presumed is also true at the nanometer level. However, it is an idea which cannot be correct. There are no Velcro hooks and eyes at the molecular level. Newton knew this and dismissed the notion of “hook’d atoms.” He found that the smoother he polished his glass marbles, the better they adhered. Atomically smooth surfaces stick best of all. These conceptual problems have arisen because we assume that macroscopic behavior applies to molecules. Some critical observations show this to be a false premise.
3.2. CRITICAL OBSERVATIONS OF ADHESION The problem of extrapolating down to molecular dimensions from macroscopic experience can be seen in two simple cases.6 First, consider the macroscopic task of sieving pebbles in the garden, as shown in Fig. 3.4(a). If the mesh size is 20mm, then the 10mm pebbles can easily be shaken through the holes. Each pebble shows no adhesion to the mesh, nor to its neighboring pebbles. But imagine trying the same experiment with l00 nm diameter pigment particles. First of all, the pigment particles tend to stick together to form clumps, as shown in Fig. 3.4(b). Secondly, the small particles stick to the sieve and clog up the mesh, even when the holes are l000 nm, far larger than the particle size. Sieving such tiny particles is impossible unless the adhesion is reduced, say by adding surface contaminant molecules.
THEORIES AND LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION
45
In the same way, consider the problem of getting a molecular size key into its receptor lock (Fig. 3.5(a)). The key sticks prematurely to the lock before it can enter, so the mechanism cannot work, as shown in Fig. 3.5(b), unless the molecular adhesion is reduced, by coating the receptor with contaminant atoms. A second example of the difference between macroscopic and molecular behavior is seen in the designing of machines. We know how to design machines like cars. To make a clutch mechanism between two rotating shafts, we have to press the two shafts together to get them both to rotate synchronously, as illustrated in Fig. 3.6(a). Alternatively, we could glue the shafts together to make a solid joint between the two shafts. The case of two rotating shafts in a molecular, nanoscale machine is quite the opposite. The shafts adhere spontaneously, leaping into contact, and provide
CHAPTER 3
46
the clutch mechanism naturally. The problem here is getting the nanoscale shafts apart again. Either a force must be applied to separate the shafts or debonding molecules must be inserted at the junction to separate them. These examples demonstrate the fallacy of extrapolating our macroscopic experiences down to the molecular level. The commonsense macromodels of suction, of adhesives, and of keying are not applicable at the nanoscale and lead us to error when interpreting molecular adhesion. It is useful to plot a logarithmic scale showing the boundary between the macro and nano worlds (Fig. 3.7). At the macroscopic engineering scale to the right of the diagram, above adhesion is not normal, and we need adhesives, keys and friction to get things to stick together. By contrast, to the left of the diagram, below l00 nm, adhesion is dominant and it is difficult to keep things apart. Everything is adhesive at this molecular scale unless we insert contaminant molecules to reduce adhesion. In between, from l00 nm to we have the transition zone, where adhesion is variable. Sometimes things adhere and sometimes not, depending critically on the mechanism. It is interesting that many technological materials like latex, butter, cosmetics, paper, ink, cements, etc., together with living things like diatoms, viruses, bacteria, algae, and so forth, inhabit this transition zone. Here, adhesion is highly sensitive to chemical influences and to physical conditions. So sticking may be finely controlled, may vary enormously, and may also evolve over time. Having defined the main adhesion fallacies, and determined where adhesion can always be found and predicted at the nanometer level, it is now possible to summarize the laws of adhesion which we believe to be universal.
3.3. THE LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION The laws of molecular adhesion are:
1. All atoms and molecules adhere with considerable force. More simply, if two solid bodies approach to nanometer separations, then they will jump
THEORIES AND LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION
47
into contact as a result of molecular adhesion. This behavior differs from our ordinary engineering experience. 2. The effect of contaminant “wetting” molecules is to reduce adhesion, or even to make the bodies repel each other. In other words, adhesives reduce molecular adhesion. 3. Molecular adhesion forces are of such short range that various mechanisms can have large effects. Examples of such mechanisms are surface roughness, Brownian motion, cracking, viscous deformation, etc. These mechanisms lead to a rich variety of adhesion phenomena which may cause macroscopic adhesion to vary, even though the molecular adhesion remains the same. These laws at first sight seem to go against our common experience. Indeed, they may seem to be incorrect when seen for the first time. Rather like Newton’s laws of motion, the above statements strip away the interference of other effects such as gravity, friction, viscosity and geometry which dominate our everyday experience. They reveal the chemical reality of natural electronic forces between atoms. The best analogy is with Brownian motion.7 Before Robert Brown in 1827 observed the incessant spontaneous movement of pollen grains in water, it was believed that bodies were static. The breakthrough that Brown, and later Perrin, made was to recognize that this static appearance is false at the nanometer level. Molecular motion affects every particle in the universe. Whereas engineers had believed (and, in many cases, still believe) that objects stay put, we now know that all bodies in the cosmos are moving with an energy 3kT/2 where k is Boltzmann’s constant and T is the absolute temperature. This idea of perpetual particle motion is quite foreign to most people, and engineers can usually ignore it without too much error, because the energy of movement is very small, around J under ordinary conditions, too small to influence a car, for example, which would require perhaps 100 J of energy to give reasonable movement, 1022 times larger than the Brownian energy. However, designers of nanoscale machines must take this movement into account because objects below 100 nm in size are moving significantly. Just as Perrin concluded that a fluid’s “apparent repose is merely an illusion” because the fluid molecules are in a state of eternal and spontaneous motion, so must we believe that all molecules adhere strongly, even though macroscopic objects appear nonsticky. The apparent lack of adhesion we see in engineering situations is really an illusion because adhesion is universal at the molecular level, according to the first law of adhesion above. However, there is a serious conundrum here because it seems impossible that particles can be in constant Brownian movement, where it is necessary for particles to collide and bounce off each other, yet also sticking together, which would cause agglomeration and
48
CHAPTER 3
ultimate static behavior. That is the problem addressed in Chapter 5. There has to be a balance between Brownian movement and sticking, as illustrated in Fig. 3.8. The conclusion is that, within a Brownian system of moving objects, there must always be some adhering particles. In other words, a Brownian system cannot be fully dispersed in reality.8 Here then is a mechanism, Brownian motion, which has an enormously strong influence on adhesion phenomena. There are many other mechanisms which must also be accounted for. For example, why do the pages of this book not stick together to form a solid cellulose mass. This is not a ridiculous question. Goodyear, the inventor of rubber crosslinking, was producing waterproof mail bags 180 years ago by coating them with rubber. Unfortunately, the sheets did stick together completely and Goodyear went bankrupt. By chemically crosslinking the rubber to make it more elastic, removing the tacky contact mechanism of the polymer, he was able to solve this adhesion problem. The laws of adhesion have stripped away all the interfering mechanisms to get at the underlying reality. Now we must add the mechanisms back in one by one to understand the ultimate complex mechanics of adhesion phenomena.
3.4. FROM MOLECULES, THROUGH MECHANISMS, TO MECHANICS We normally observe adhesion at the macroscopic level, say by peeling a film from a surface as in Fig. 3.9. In order to understand the force which is necessary to pull the film off, we have to connect this mechanical picture with the molecular adhesion forces which we know to be universal at the nanometer level. The macroscopic mechanism looks simple, because we grip the film and pull it off by applying a force (Fig. 3.9(a)). However, it is obvious that the applied force is not acting directly at the contact. The film has to bend and apply leverage to the adhesive region. So there is a complex mechanical system operating. To understand this we need mechanics. In particular, we apply the continuum mechanics theory in Chapter 14.
THEORIES AND LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION
49
If one looks closer, using a microscope, at the point where the polymer film is detaching from the oxide surface, at the micrometer level (Fig. 3.9(b)), then it is evident that there is a crack traveling along the interface between the polymer and the glass. This crack is the mechanism by which the polymer material detaches from the surface. All brittle adhesive joints fail by cracking. This is a mechanism which involves elastic deformations and creation of new surfaces. It can be analyzed by the energy balance theory described in Chapter 7. Looking even closer at the precise point of detachment of the polymer, we begin to resolve the oxide molecules in the substrate, vibrating but not bodily moving from their crystalline positions. By contrast, the polymer chains are moving bodily in a liquid-like motion, and the ends of the chains are continually and rapidly making contact with the oxide, then breaking away. So the molecular picture is one of Brownian movement, where the molecules only stick onto the surface periodically. Thus, an equilibrium of molecular adhesion can be established, such that the point of detachment is where the rate of making contact is equal to the rate of breaking. This is the kinetic theory of molecular adhesion which will be discussed in Chapter 5. The conclusion from these arguments is that adhesion needs to be seen at three distinct levels. Adhesion is a molecular phenomenon, so we must first examine closely the molecular behavior. But it is not possible generally to apply forces directly to the molecules. The forces are usually acting through a mechanism, often a cracking mechanism. Cracks can easily be observed in adhesive joints and the detailed nature of the mechanisms have been established.9 Finally, the forces are applied to the crack through a particular system of mechanics, in this case a peeling system. The way in which the peeling is carried out can have a large influence on the adhesion forces observed, even though the molecular picture remains the same. Thus we need to study adhesion on three levels: from molecules, through mechanisms, to mechanics. This overview explains why there have been enormous problems of communication between adhesion scientists in different applications. Engineers
50
CHAPTER 3
tend to be concerned with the gross macroscopic mechanics and produce lengthy mathematical explanations which do not normally mention molecules. At the other extreme there are chemists who synthesize molecules which alter the adhesion at the atomic level. But these behave differently in the different macroscopic tests. In between are the material scientists who study the microscopic cracking behavior, desperately trying to reconcile the test protocols with the molecular reality. In this book, the objective is to study these three views of adhesion together, starting with molecules, going on to the mechanisms and finally understanding the mechanics.6 First, the molecular behavior becomes evident because molecules jump into contact.
3.5. JUMPING INTO CONTACT The skeptical engineer is wary of the idea that molecules leap into contact with their surrounding surfaces. After all, car parts on an assembly line do not suddenly jump together and adhere strongly to fashion the finished vehicle. However, at the molecular level it is quite obvious that such events occur naturally, and a nanoscale car could be self-assembled by these normal adhesive forces. The problem is that the nano-engine would not work because all its parts would seize together. Proof of this is found in three simple experiments. The first experiment is the one interpreted by Thomas Young10 in 1805 and shown in Fig. 3.10. A droplet of water is lowered towards a plastic surface. As the drop approaches the polymer, very little happens until the gap between water and solid is extremely thin, around 1000 nm. This shows that the molecular adhesion forces do not extend far out from the surfaces. But at a certain separation, the water suddenly jumps onto the plastic and spreads rapidly across it. The final angle of contact is a measure of the molecular attractions, small angle indicating strong adhesion, large angle showing small adhesion. In this example, it is clear that the water molecules are in constant motion, because small particles of pollen within the droplet can be seen dancing with the
THEORIES AND LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION
51
Brownian movement. Thus, the equilibrium of the droplet can be viewed as the rapid wetting and dewetting of the polymer surface by each individual molecule of water. If a force is applied to the drop, by tilting the plate, then the water can detach from the surface quite easily, while making new contact on the other side as the droplet rolls down the surface. Molecular adhesion at equilibrium is clearly only small in this instance, because the water does not strongly adhere to the polymer. The second experiment showing molecular adhesion onto surfaces was described by Daniell in 1839.11 He took a piece of hot charcoal, which is composed of very fine strands of carbon with a large surface area, and showed how, on cooling, the charcoal would absorb large quantities of gas. He wrote of “a force of heterogeneous adhesion” which was causing the gas molecules to stick to the solid charcoal surface. The same effect can be observed in the famous BET12 apparatus in which a sample of porous material like charcoal is cleaned by heating to 200°C in a nitrogen gas stream, then cooled to liquid nitrogen temperatures (see Fig. 3.11). The nitrogen absorbs onto the charcoal, as can be seen from the reduction in pressure of the gas in the closed vessel. This is such a well-understood effect that it is used to measure the molecular surface area of powders by the number of nitrogen molecules adhering to the surface. In this case, the adhesion is again reversible and the gas molecules can be removed by heating the sample. A third experiment which shows unequivocally that molecules leap into adhesive contact was performed by Johnson, Kendall and Roberts in 1970.3 This experiment was similar to Newton’s original test on glass telescope lenses (Fig. 3.1) but used rubber surfaces because they adhere much more reliably than glass. Roberts had developed a way of moulding rubber in concave glass lenses to produce remarkably smooth elastomeric spherical surfaces as shown in Fig. 3.12. The rubber composition was mixed and then pressed hot into the glass lens. After
52
CHAPTER 3
cooling, the rubber lenses could be peeled out of the moulds and then brought into contact (Fig. 3.12(b)). As the two smooth spherical surfaces approached each other, within a few micrometers of contact, the familiar Newton’s ring pattern could be seen in the narrow gap between the smooth surfaces. Then, as the rubber lenses were moved still nearer, a sudden jump of the rubber was observed and the black contact spot grew rapidly to a large size as the rubber deformed and spread under the influence of molecular adhesion (Fig. 3.12(c)). The appearance of this was very similar to the liquid drop spreading over a glassy polymer surface. To get the rubber lenses apart, a tensile force had to be applied to overcome this molecular adhesion. It is this cracking apart of adhering surfaces which we consider next.
3.6. CRACKING MOLECULES APART The adhesion of the rubber spheres is revealed unequivocally by their leaping into contact. However, the precise nature of this contact needs to be understood if the adhesion of the spheres is to be well defined. Consider the two rubber surfaces magnified so the contact region in the equilibrium contact shows up more clearly, as in Fig. 3.13(a). The rubber, after jumping into contact, has spread to form a flat circular contact spot about one millimeter in diameter. This flattening is a general mechanism of adhesion, similar to the spreading of the liquid droplet described previously in Fig. 3.10. However, the rubber cannot spread far because it is elastic and not liquid like the droplet. The flattening and spreading of the rubber causes an elastic resistance to build up in the rubber, storing energy, much as an elastic band does when stretched. This stored energy can be seen in the change in shape near the contact, from spherical to neck-like. Eventually, this elastic resistance
THEORIES AND LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION
53
stops the spreading and the equilibrium contact is attained. The size of the contact spot at this stage is a measure of the molecular adhesion. A large spot is a measure of large adhesion. This spreading and equilibrium is an example of the third law of adhesion. The molecules jump into contact with a particular energy, but that energy has to be absorbed into the system by a mechanism which can be quantified. This mechanism is hugely important because it affects the forces of adhesion enormously. For example, if the rubber is not perfectly elastic when flattened, then the contact spot size is different. The same molecules can be in contact, yet a slight change in the mechanism can raise or lower macroscopic adhesion by orders of magnitude, as we will see later in Chapters 7 and 8. In Fig. 3.13, the mechanism for separation of the particles is seen to be elastic cracking. The neck-like shape is precisely what would be expected of a crack. This can be shown by applying a tensile force as in Fig. 3.13(b). As the force is applied, the neck extends, the crack opens, and the contact spot shrinks as the crack penetrates the interface. If the tension force is small, then the contact will not break completely, but reaches a new equilibrium position, at a smaller contact size. This is an equilibrium crack of the kind first described by Griffith in 1920.13 He showed that such cracks can be described by an energy balance theory, in which the surface energy of the crack is held apart by the elastic energy in the rubber, plus the potential energy of the tensile force. This theory is a concept of pure mechanics which does not require any molecular interpretation, but is expressed in mathematical terms as a continuum theory. So we conclude that the molecules jump into contact, but they are impeded by the crack mechanism, which can be explained by fracture mechanics. Thus we follow the argument from molecules, through mechanism, to mechanics.
54
CHAPTER 3
As a larger and larger tensile force is applied to pull the rubber spheres apart, the contact gets smaller and smaller in diameter. However, the contact spot does not shrink gradually down to zero. Instead, a point of instability is reached where the crack speeds up suddenly and the spheres rapidly come apart. This is shown diagrammatically in Fig. 3.14. The crack can be in equilibrium over a certain range of forces, but above a particular tension, i.e. the pull-off force, the spheres catastrophically jump apart as the crack moves suddenly through the contact spot. This pull-off force is another measure of the molecular adhesion between the spheres. A large force indicates large adhesion.
3.7. ADHESION IS REALLY THREE THINGS: MAKING, EQUILIBRIUM, AND BREAKING After examining the way in which a particle sticks to a surface, as above, it becomes apparent that adhesion is not a single process, but one which we can separate into three different but related actions: jumping into contact, achieving a certain black spot size, then cracking apart as a tensile force is applied. The first adhesion phenomenon is the most convincing: all particles leap spontaneously onto surfaces, showing that the molecular attractions do not
THEORIES AND LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION
55
depend on any extraneous influences, such as adhesive molecules or surface keying. Thus adhesion can be measured by looking at the distance covered by the leap. A long jump means strong adhesion. This ingenious method of quantifying adhesion was first applied systematically by Tabor and Winterton in the late 1960s and will be described in detail in Chapter 4. The second phenomenon, the achievement of a black spot resulting from adhesion forces, was the idea mentioned by Newton as a measure of true molecular contact, but this was not measured sensibly until 1971.3 This black spot should really be the equilibrium size which balances the molecular adhesion forces trying to enlarge the black spot, in competition with the elastic forces in the rubber trying to force the particles apart. This balance defines the size of adhesion. A large spot means large adhesion. Clearly, this is a dynamic equilibrium at the molecular level, even though the black spot seems to be static when viewed macroscopically with a magnifying glass. The third phenomenon, that of detachment of the particles from each other by applying a pull-off force, is the test of adhesion which is most familiar to us. We increase the tension force applied to the particles until they just come apart, and define that force as the adhesion force. A large force means large adhesion. However, this is a very difficult experiment to carry out because the final detachment is an instability which is hard to reproduce exactly each time. Thus, many different values of adhesion can be found for the same samples in such tests, depending on the rate of loading, the precise moment of detachment, etc., leading to considerable unreliability in such measurements. These three adhesion measures of molecular adhesion, in the contact makeand-break process, also allow us to test the second law of adhesion, that contaminant molecules always decrease the attraction between bodies. Consider immersing the rubber spheres in water and repeating the adhesion experiment. The results show that all three indicators of molecular adhesion: (the jumping into contact, the size of the contact spot, and the pull-off force) are diminished by the presence of the water molecules. Adhesives reduce adhesion! When the rubber spheres are brought together under water, they can approach much closer before the jumping occurs. This suggests that the attractive force pulling the spheres together is reduced. Once the spheres have leaped into contact, the contact spot can be seen expanding to its equilibrium value. But now in wet conditions, the contact spot size is much smaller, indicating that the adhesion is less. Similarly, when the spheres are pulled apart under water, the force required is about ten times less than in dry conditions, showing a much reduced adhesion (see Fig. 3.15). Thus it is evident that the presence of the water molecules on the rubber surfaces has diminished the molecular adhesion, in accordance with the second law. These reductions in adhesion produced by contaminants become obvious when studied in the atomic force microscope.
56
CHAPTER 3
3.8. ADHESION IN THE SCANNING PROBE MICROSCOPE The macroscopic demonstrations described above, repeating Newton’s original tests on the adhesion of glass lenses, give an insight into the laws of adhesion. Newton had seen two of the three indicators of molecular adhesion: the black, flattened contact spot, and the pull-off force. But he had not seen the spontaneous jumping into contact. The reason was that, with large hard spheres, the adhesion could not be established reproducibly because surface roughness and dust particles prevented true molecular contact. Rubber spheres get over that problem to a certain extent because they are softer. The other approach is to make the spheres smaller and smaller. For small particles, roughness is less of a problem and adhesion is then always observable, even between the hardest surfaces. As particles are made very small, they begin to approach the size of single molecules, or ultimately single atoms, which always adhere. It would be a superb experiment if two molecules could be gripped, brought together, and then pulled apart to measure their molecular adhesion. Unfortunately no-one has yet found a way to do this (see Chapter 13). And the very act of gripping the molecules would change their character by preventing Brownian motion, and also distorting their electronic attractive fields of influence. A much more practical experiment became possible with the invention of the atomic force microscope by Binnig, Quate and Gerber14 in 1986. This device
THEORIES AND LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION
57
followed from Binnig and Rohrer’s work at IBM on the contact between a fine metal probe and a very flat surface, such as a silicon wafer used in electronic chips. Binnig, Rohrer and colleagues15 were working in the tradition of Ragnar Holm on the electrical conduction through metal contacts. Holm had seen that only a small part of an electrical contact actually conducts electrons, and concluded that the true molecular contact was small. Binnig and co-workers used finer and finer metal probes to show that the ultimate contact between a wire and a surface was a single atom. When the sample was moved beneath the tip, using a piezoelectric scanner, it received electrons from each atom in turn and produced an atomic picture of the surface, as shown in Fig. 3.16. This was the first time that the strange diamond patterned arrangement of adatoms on the surface of a silicon wafer had been seen directly, although it had been suspected from previous spectroscopic measurements of silicon surfaces. For this remarkable instrument, now called the scanning tunneling microscope, Binnig and Rohrer received the Nobel Prize in 1986.
3.9. THE ATOMIC FORCE MICROSCOPE (AFM) Around that time, there was a sudden realization that many different kinds of probe could give atomic resolution at surfaces. Electrical conduction, heat conduction, or acoustic transmission could all be used in principle. The scanning tunneling microscope, based on electron conduction, was immediately successful because it was so simple. A probe could be made by taking a metal wire and cutting it with scissors to give a pointed end. An atomically smooth surface could be prepared by pulling graphite flakes apart with sticky tape. Then a picture of the
58
CHAPTER 3
carbon atoms on the surface could be obtained using the piezoelectric scanner. But electron conduction was only one way in which atoms could be detected. That could only be used on electrical conductors, thus preventing measurements on polymers, oxides, biological materials, etc. Therefore, Binnig, Quate and Gerber14 devised the atomic force microscope (AFM) shown schematically in Fig. 3.17. The probe was now much smaller and lighter so as to detect the molecular adhesion forces. These forces caused a slight movement of the probe which could be observed by several different sensor methods. However, laser detection, as shown in Fig. 3.17, turned out to be most convenient. Small silicon cantilever probes were made by etching a silicon wafer. Laser light was reflected from the top of the silicon cantilever probe, and entered a detector where any deflection could be registered. A typical adhesion experiment using the AFM was performed by raising the sample towards the probe while observing the cantilever deflection. When the probe was distant from the sample, nothing happened, but as the probe came within range of the adhesion forces, the probe was attracted and pulled down, as shown by the result of Fig. 3.18. As the sample is pushed nearer to the probe, the attractive force increases rapidly and the probe then jumps into contact with the sample. This appears as a sudden deflection of the cantilever. Then, once the probe is stuck to the sample surface, the movement of sample and cantilever are equal, as shown by the linear contact deflection in Fig. 3.18. Moving the sample in the opposite direction can then be used to pull the probe off the surface. This result is shown in Fig. 3.19. The deflection of the cantilever is reversed along the same linear path as the probe sticks to the sample at first. Then, at a certain deflection of the cantilever, the probe jumps off the
THEORIES AND LAWS OF MOLECULAR ADHESION
59
surface. This separation of the probe usually occurs at a different point from the attractive jumping into contact. Thus, there is a hysteresis in the adhesion process; the making of contact is not reversible during the breaking stage. It is evident from these results that two of the adhesion processes (making contact and breaking contact) can be observed in the atomic force microscope. The size of the contact spot can also be detected if some additional technique for sensing contact spot size is used, for example, electrical contact or thermal contact. Thus the three stages of adhesion can be found in the AFM. It has become clear from such measurements that all materials adhere in this test, verifying the first law of adhesion. These results will be considered in more detail in Chapter 4. Another great benefit of the AFM is that the sample and probe can be immersed in liquid, so that adhesion can be tested in a wide range of environments. The immediate conclusion from such tests is that the adhesion is reduced by such immersion, thus verifying the second law of adhesion. Finally, the curious phenomena of time dependence, of irreversibility, and of hysteresis have
60
CHAPTER 3
been observed generally in these nanoscale experiments. Consequently, it is clear that the mechanism of adhesion is complex, as stated in the third law. It is now necessary in the following chapters to deal with these laws in greater depth.
3.10. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
Newton, I., Opticks, Smith and Walford, London, 1704 (reprinted Dover, New York, 1952, p 194). Galileo, Dialogue on the Two Chief Systems of the World, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1632. Johnson, K.L., Kendall, K. and Roberts, A.D., Proc. R. Soc. A 324, 301–13 (1971). Evans, C., Metals Handbook, 9th edn. vol.7, Powder Metallurgy, Am. Soc. Metals, OH, 1984, p 288. Bettelheim, F. A. and March, J. General, Organic and Biochemistry, Harcourt Brace, London, 1998, p 785. Kendall, K., Science, 263, 1720–5 (1994). Perrin, J.B., Atoms (translated by D.L. Hammick), Constable, London, 1923. Kendall, K., Liang, W. and Stainton, C., Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A454, 2529-33 (1998). Kendall, K., J. Adhesion Sci. Technol. 8, 1271–84 (1994). Young, T., Miscellaneous Works, vol 1, Murray, London, 1805, p 418. Daniell, J.F., An Introduction to Chemical Philosophy, J.W. Parker, London, 1839. Brunauer, S., Emmett, P.H. and Teller, E. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 60, 309 (1938). Griffith, A.A., Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 221, 163–98 (1920). Binnig, G., Quate, C.F. and Gerber, C. Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 930 (1986). Binnig, G., Rohrer, H., Gerber, D. C. and Weibel, E. Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 120–3 (1983).
4 EVIDENCE FOR THE FIRST LAW OF ADHESION: SURFACE LEAP INTO CONTACT
For by pressing such Glasses together their parts easily yield inwards, and the Rings thereby become sensibly broader ISAAC NEWTON, Opticks,1 p. 201
The quest for molecular adhesion started with Newton’s two fundamental ideas; that polishing glasses smoother would allow more intimate contact, and that the small movements of the surfaces towards each other could be measured by the interference patterns formed by light waves in the narrow gaps between the bodies. Newton had seen the black spot and the colored rings at the contact of two telescope lenses, though he deferred to Robert Hooke in his earlier observations of “ye apparition of a black spot at ye contact of two convex glasses,”2 when he made his famous statement about seeing further “by standing on ye shoulders of Giants.” Of course, Newton did not know about molecules, nor about molecular forces and their influence on elastic deformation. So he could not find the simple connection between the black spot size, the applied force, and the molecular adhesion. Two hundred years were to elapse before these relations could emerge. However, Newton’s idea of seeking out smooth surfaces and of measuring their very small movements in contact through interference methods persisted and ultimately led to the successes described in this chapter. The first experimenters, for example Tomlinson and Bradley, followed Newton by working on glass and this work reached its peak in the measurements of Derjaguin and Sparnaay in the early 1950s. However, glass was too rough and was replaced by smooth mica which had been first studied in 1930 by Obreimoff. Using mica allowed 63
64
CHAPTER 4
molecular contact to be studied in depth by Tabor, Winterton and Israelachvili. Polymer surfaces were also smooth enough to give reliable adhesion, as defined initially by Rivlin, leading eventually to the currently accepted theory of molecular adhesion.
4.1. THE PROBLEM OF OBTAINING RELIABLE ADHESION The first law of adhesion states that all atoms adhere. Therefore we would expect that blocks of material placed in good contact should stick together. This idea had been studied by Tyndall in 1875 and investigated further by Budgett in 1911.3 The objective was to show that adhesion between flat plates could be larger than that expected from atmospheric pressure. Steel blocks used as gauges in the metal working industries were highly polished to produce flatness much less than the wavelength of light, i.e. less than 100 nm. Tyndall placed these in contact by “wringing.” In other words he pressed and twisted them together in a sliding motion (see Fig. 4.1). The adhesion between the plates was then considerable and not affected much by placing the plates in a vacuum, demonstrating that atmospheric pressure was not the cause of the adhesion. However, it was clear to Budgett, when he repeated Tyndall’s observations, that the surface condition of smoothness and contamination was also vital (see Fig. 4.2). He showed that, when the surfaces were contaminated with dust, then the adhesion was reduced. More importantly, Budgett demonstrated that, when the surfaces were cleaned with solvent to remove grease and water, the blocks fell apart easily. Thus, the adhesion force was due mainly to the pulling apart of the contaminant film. McBain and Lee showed later that thin films of many materials could give a large adhesion, with strengths up to 40 MPa, when used as glue between smooth metal plates.4
EVIDENCE FOR THE FIRST LAW OF ADHESION
65
It was clear that measuring adhesion of “flat, clean” surfaces was doomed to failure. Budgett showed especially that the steel plates were reactive and that the contaminant moisture could generate rust-like reaction products which would also stick the plates together with large adhesion. This effect will be described in Chapter 11. Hardy and his colleagues also showed that long chain acids could give stronger adhesion, especially if time was allowed for ordering to occur.5 But the main advance came by changing the material from steel or glass to mica.
4.2. OBREIMOFF'S EXPERIMENT Obreimoff,6 working in the Physics Institute of Leningrad, where large sheets of a perfect type of Muscovite mica were available from the White Sea area near Chupa, knew of the problems of putting polished flat surfaces together, and recognized that optical contact could produce adhesion, but not satisfactorily. “Perfect” optical contact still contained gaps up to 100 atoms wide. However, he had observed that freshly split mica foils could be put back together to adhere with considerable force and set out to investigate this unique effect. His paper was most significant because it identified for the first time the three processes involved in adhesion; the jumping into contact, the equilibriation of the joint, and the pulling apart of the mica sheets. In addition, Obreimoff saw that evacuating the apparatus improved the adhesion, and also found electrical discharges which proved that adhesion was essentially an electromagnetic phenomenon. The mica was cut using a razor blade into 2 × 20 × 50 mm blocks, and a glass wedge with a smooth and rounded end was used to split a foil 0.1 mm thick from the top surface. The experiment was placed in an evacuated tube and a glass hammer containing an iron mass was moved with a magnet to press the wedge into the mica to promote splitting (Fig 4.3). The region at which separation occurred was viewed under a microscope and Newton’s interference fringes were seen in the narrow gap between the split surfaces. By measuring the positions of
66
CHAPTER 4
the interference fringes, Obreimoff was able to determine the shape of the mica strip which was being wedged from the block, as shown in Fig. 4.4. The point of separation of the mica foil from the block, that is the crack line, could not be seen directly because this kind of interference experiment only detects gaps down to about 50 nm. But the shape of the bent mica foil could be accurately measured and was shown to be parabolic. In other words, the strip was behaving as a simple leaf spring and its shape was not affected by the molecular adhesion forces. This was an important observation because it proved that the molecular forces were only acting across the small gap near the line of separation. Thus the molecular forces could be neglected in terms of the large scale behavior of the system. Engineers therefore safely ignore such forces when calculating the shapes of machinery. The mathematics of these calculations is given in Chapter 14, essentially employing the energy conservation method of Obreimoff.
EVIDENCE FOR THE FIRST LAW OF ADHESION
67
By carrying out a series of splitting experiments on different mica samples, Obreimoff was able to show by balancing energies that, in air at ordinary pressure, the energy required to fracture the material was After splitting the mica, Obreimoff found that the surfaces would spontaneously jump back together when he removed the glass wedge. He measured the energy of this spontaneous adhesion and it was about substantially less than the original adhesion energy. Then he pushed the wedge back in to measure the adhesion formed between the foil and the block by the jumping process and found the adhesion energy was around so it was taking more energy to split the adhering mica than was recovered on the jumping together. Thus he found some energy loss or adhesive hysteresis in this process. He also realized that it took some time for the splitting to reach equilibrium; the fringes moved for quite a time after the wedge was fixed, around 15 s. This was the first observation of the rate effect on adhesion. Perhaps of most significance was the result obtained when the air was evacuated from the vessel around the mica. Adhesion was increased as the air was pumped out. This observation supports the second law of adhesion; that adhesion is reduced by air molecules which contaminate the mica surfaces (see Chapter 6). As these contaminant molecules were removed by evacuation, the energy of adhesion was then increased to and impressive electrical discharges were seen around the mica samples at 1 nb pressure. This proved that the adhesion was connected with electromagnetic forces between the atoms in the mica crystal. However, it did not seem possible for the bonds themselves to have such a high energy, so the conclusion was that huge energy dissipation was occurring during this high vacuum adhesion test. Further development of this cleavage technique was made by Gilman while he was at the General Electric Research Laboratory in Schenectady, New York. He attempted to measure the surface energy of a wide range of crystals by the Obreimoff method.7 He made two main changes to the experiment: first, he worked in liquid nitrogen to avoid any plasticity effects; second he found the wedge method to be too frictional and used direct tension applied to the split ends of the crystal to drive the crack. The rig is shown in Fig. 4.5. Gilman concentrated on separation of the crystal planes by the crack; he did not make any observations of the crack healing to produce adhesive joining of the cleaved surfaces. So he did not fully demonstrate reversibility. However, he restricted plasticity to low levels and obtained surface energies comparable with those estimated from elastic modulus, as shown in Table 4.1. The next improvement came from the strict control of the separation of the surfaces, to show the jumping into contact in the most dramatic way, as demonstrated by Tabor and Winterton.
68
CHAPTER 4
4.3. TABOR AND WINTERTON'S EXPERIMENT Tabor and Winterton8 followed Obreimoff’s idea but made several advances in the method, which allowed the jumping to contact to be quantified more centimetres in size. This smoothness allowed repeatable and reliable molecular because this was atomically smooth over large areas, up to several square perfectly. First they recognized that it was essential to use Muscovite mica contact. Previous experiments by Deryagin and Abrikosova,9 later followed by Kitchener and Prosser,10 then Black et al, 11 had all used polished silica or silicate glass, but these were too rough to obtain true molecular contact, although the jumping due to the attractive forces had been seen. However, Tabor and Winterton decided to locate the contact of the mica more precisely by gluing thin foils of mica onto glass cylinder formers, such that the crossed cylinder contact gave a circular contact spot, reminiscent of the Newton black spot. The arrangement is shown in Fig. 4.6. Second, the movement of the foils towards each other to forge the contact was controlled precisely using a piezoelectric actuator. This was simply a strip of piezoceramic which moved when an electric field was applied to electrodes on each face. By this means the movement could be dialed in electrically with subnanometer precision while retaining high stiffness. This allowed the compliance of the system to be adjusted by suspending the upper foil on a spring steel strip. The stiffer this spring steel was, the nearer the surfaces could approach before jumping was observed. The schematic arrangement is drawn in Fig. 4.7.
EVIDENCE FOR THE FIRST LAW OF ADHESION
69
The third innovation was to use multiple-beam interferometry rather than Newton’s rings. This technique had been much developed by Tolansky12 in the 1940s to be ten times more sensitive than Newton’s fringes, and was therefore capable of resolving single-atom steps on a mica surface. To obtain the sharper fringes, it was merely necessary to evaporate a thin metal layer on the back surface of the mica foils before gluing them in position. The multiple reflections of white light between these half-silvered surfaces gave fine fringes which could resolve very small movements of about 0.3 nm. For example, in the laboratory conditions, air of 50–80% relative humidity was used. This caused a thin layer of moisture to be adsorbed on the mica. By measuring the fine multiple beam fringes before and after moisture adsorption, it was deduced that the total thickness of water between the two foils was 0.7 nm.13 In order to perform an adhesion experiment using this apparatus, two precautions had to be taken: the apparatus had to be protected from vibrations so the work was done at night on vibration isolators; also, the surfaces had to be
70
CHAPTER 4
exposed to ions and moisture to relieve any free charges clinging to the mica. The bottom foil could then be raised to meet the top foil, while noting the position by means of the interference fringes. As the surfaces got nearer, deflection of the steel spring was noticed and at a critical separation, the mica leaped into contact. This jump distance depended on the spring stiffness as expected, stiffer springs being necessary to allow close approach. The results are shown in Fig. 4.8. For jump distances between 5–15 nm, the results fitted the Hamaker theory which states that the attractive van der Waals force is proportional to cylinder diameter and inversely proportional to the square of the gap. The Hamaker constant was found to be These experiments were the first to reveal the true van der Waals forces at close approach. Previous tests had only shown the weaker, retarded forces which apply for gaps larger than 20 nm. These theories will be considered in Chapter 5.
4.4. EXTENSION BY ISRAELACHVILI AND TABOR After this stunning piece of work, Winterton joined the Nuclear Laboratories of the Electricity Generating Board at Berkeley, eventually becoming a lecturer at Birmingham University, while Tabor continued with a new PhD student, Jacob Israelachvili, who continued to develop the mica “surface force apparatus” as it was soon to become known. His immediate contribution was to push the jump distance from 5 nm down to 1.5 nm and then to measure the effect of stearic acid monolayers on the mica surfaces.14,15
EVIDENCE FOR THE FIRST LAW OF ADHESION
71
This incremental advance was achieved with better designed equipment, especially in relation to the spring support and the piezotransducer. The main problem with the earlier kit was that the spring had to be removed in each experiment. By making the spring a double-leaf and by adjusting its stiffness with a movable clamp, a whole series of tests could be carried out without dismantling the apparatus. Essentially the same results were obtained as before, but to closer approaches, and with less scatter. Stearic acid also did not affect the jump distances much, showing that the mica and acid have roughly similar Hamaker constants. So Israelachvili’s contribution at this point was to verify and extend Winterton’s measurements. However, the redesign paved the way for work on adhesion of mica when immersed in liquids, which will be described in detail in Chapter 6. Although the stearic acid coating did not affect the jump distance, it did change the attractive forces at separations less than 2 nm. Stearic acid-coated mica surfaces obeyed the Hamaker equation down almost to molecular contact, essentially giving a work of adhesion around Mica surfaces under damp atmospheric conditions are known to have a work of adhesion nearer , and it is evident therefore that the attractive forces increase greatly at separations below 2 nm for normal mica.16 The surface force apparatus cannot measure such forces. Moreover, the surfaces begin to deform substantially under these large forces and the theory is no longer valid. A plot of the results is given
72
CHAPTER 4
in Fig. 4.9 to show the development of these large forces compared to the results above. This graph is plotted with the attractive force as negative by convention. The mica apparatus thus only covers a small part of the force range.
4.5. FINER MEANS SMOOTHER Mica is unusual in its remarkable smoothness over large areas. However, many crystals and glasses are smooth over micrometer sized regions, so another approach to smoothness is by making finer test samples. This was the idea adopted by Tomlinson17 in 1928, to contribute to the lively debate at that time about the rate of change of molecular attractions with separation, which will be considered in detail in Chapter 5. Tomlinson heated and drew fresh fibers of fused silica to perform adhesion experiments, bringing the crossed fibers together to observe the contact point, which he estimated to have a black spot size less than and measuring the force of adhesion by elastic deflection of the fiber, as shown in Fig. 4.10. He also formed spherical blobs on the ends of the fibers and tested these in the same way. Tomlinson was careful to release electric charges by ionising the air, and also made sure that the silica was dry to avoid questions about surface moisture. The best adhesion was observed immediately on cooling from red heat. Also marked damage was seen after adhesion of the surfaces, proving that the forces of adhesion were large enough around the black spot to crack the glass material. A typical fiber was in diameter, about the same as a human hair, and the adhesion force measured was This force was readily determined by the 5 mm deflection of the fibre just before detachment. The interesting feature of the experiment reported by Tomlinson was the sudden attachment of the fibers when contact was approached. The surfaces leaped into contact! He took trouble to apply no force pushing the surfaces together, and concluded that “the molecular
EVIDENCE FOR THE FIRST LAW OF ADHESION
73
attractions acting at the instant of geometrical contact are sufficient to draw the fibres together.” The adhesion force seemed to be in proportion to the diameter of the bodies. This was the strange result which was not at all expected, and which was explained a few years later by Bradley.
4.6. BRADLEY'S ADHESION RULE Bradley18 had read Tomlinson’s paper and developed an improved method of measuring the adhesion, together with a better theory based on London’s wave mechanics theory of the forces between molecules. By adding up the London forces for all the molecules in two rigid spheres, Bradley came to the conclusion that the adhesive force required to separate them should be proportional to the sphere diameter, as shown in Fig. 4.11. He also showed that the force should be proportional to the work of adhesion W of the spheres, that is the energy required to separate one square meter of interface reversibly. Thus he produced his famous equation for adhesion of spheres shown in Fig. 4.11. Bradley then constructed an apparatus for measuring the force required to separate two silica spheres from adhesive contact (see Fig. 4.12). The rig could be evacuated to remove moisture and other contamination. Heaters were used to bake the glass and a radioactive source ionized the gas to leak away any stray charges. The silica balls were heated to incandescence immediately before the measurements. A deflection was applied to the bottom sphere until it detached from the upper sphere, giving the results shown in Fig. 4.13. Bradley found that the adhesion remained constant as gas was evacuated, so water was obviously not the cause of the adhesive force. However, the spheres were probably too large to give the molecular contact which Tomlinson had observed on his ten times smaller fibers. The force was proportional to diameter which fitted the theory, but the force was several times smaller than expected, and smaller than Tomlinson observed. This problem became evident when Bradley
74
CHAPTER 4
attempted to use sodium borate spheres instead of fused silica. Although adhesion was seen, it was variable and Bradley suggested the surfaces were rough as a result of reaction with water. The conclusion was that these spheres were still too large and insufficiently smooth to obtain reliable molecular adhesion. Another significant issue was the deformation and flattening of the spheres at the point of contact. Newton had stated that this occurred as the spheres were
EVIDENCE FOR THE FIRST LAW OF ADHESION
75
pulled together by adhesion forces. Tomlinson worked out from the well-known Hertz equations of elasticity, described in Chapter 9, that the contact spot diameter should be around for the contact of his silica fibers. Bradley took no account of this idea and his theory was based on the assumption of rigid spheres. This cannot be correct for elastic particles. Derjaguin19 attempted a solution of this question in 1934 by combining the Hertz and Bradley ideas, but his answer was not quite right. The final solution was obtained in 1971, showing that Bradley’s equation requires only slight numerical modification, by about a factor of 2, to when elastic deformation is taken into account (see 20 Chapter 9). So elastic stiffness hardly affects adhesion, and therefore it should not matter whether we stick stiff diamond or compliant rubber spheres together, we should get the same adhesion force for the same work of adhesion. This is something of a shock. The most surprising conclusion from these arguments is that the adhesion of particles is in proportion to their diameters. This result is of outstanding importance because it means that adhesion dominates all other forces at dimensions below particle size.
4.7. THE SIGNIFICANCE OF BRADLEY' S RULE The discovery that solid bodies jump into adhesive contact under the influence of the molecular attractions was enormously significant. This experiment was certainly known to Tomlinson17 in 1928 and was studied both by Obreimoff6 and Derjaguin and Abrikossova9 some time later. Once you see this phenomenon, you become convinced that molecular adhesion exists. When you observe it in different situations (on mica, on glass, on metals, on polymers) then you realise it is a universal observation that applies to all bodies when there are no contaminant molecules to stop the adhesive interaction of the particles. In a sense, although it came 100 years after Brown, this observation stands with Brownian motion as a critical breakthrough. Before Brownian motion was seen, engineers thought that matter was continuous and static. Suddenly they were aware that it was molecular and moving, though this molecularity and movement could often be ignored at the macroscopic level because the atoms and energies were so small. In a similar vein, engineers normally treat objects as nonadhering. Wheels roll and particles flow macroscopically without sticking. But it turns out that this is an illusion brought about by the small values of the work of adhesion, and by Bradley’s rule. Bodies should always stick but this depends greatly on size. Size is important. Consider the wheel of a truck, which is one meter in diameter. This does not adhere significantly to the road surface, and can be lifted up without significant sticking. However, applying Bradley’s rule that the adhesion force should be the
76
CHAPTER 4
product of the diameter and the work of adhesion, which we know to be about then the adhesion force should be 0.1 N. This is the theoretical prediction shown in Fig. 4.14 on the Bradley’s rule line. It is a small force, as can be seen by the logarithmic scales in the diagram. Compared to the gravity force acting on the truck tire, this theoretical adhesion force is a million times smaller. But we also know that the tire is so rough that it does not make perfect molecular contact with the road surface, so the measured adhesion is another million times less, as shown on the dotted curve. Thus it is clear that the adhesion at the engineer’s level is very much smaller than the weight, and can normally be neglected. Racing car tires are an exception to this because they are made much smoother to obtain better grip. In this case the adhesion is small but measurable. The interesting thing about Fig. 4.14 is the way the forces change as the size of the body becomes smaller. The force of gravity falls with the cube of diameter and so drops rapidly for smaller bodies, whereas the adhesion falls more slowly. Thus for smooth particles, there is a transition around 1 mm diameter, where gravity and adhesion are equal. Thus 1 mm dust particles should cling to the ceiling if they are smooth enough to obey Bradley’s rule. Fortunately, the surfaces are rough and so the bottom curve applies and the transition is near Thus, when we are dusting, we tend to find particles which are just about visible. However, geckoes and lounge lizards can use Bradley’s rule, and can stick to ceilings by improving their smoothness.
EVIDENCE FOR THE FIRST LAW OF ADHESION
77
Consider now a bacterium which is in diameter. This now behaves in a completely different way to the truck tire, as seen in Fig. 4.14. Because of the rapid decline in gravitational force with diameter, the weight of a bacterium is now extremely small, less than 1 pN, or less than a single weak chemical bond force. But adhesion, according to Bradley’s rule, has not declined so fast and is around for a smooth bacterium or 1 nN for a rough surface contact. Thus a bacterium in dry conditions will always stick to a surface and cannot behave like a truck tire which exhibits zero adhesion. A key problem with dry bacteria is releasing them from surfaces. When wet, the adhesion is decreased substantially, as described in Chapter 6, but bacteria can still show strong adhesive behavior even under that condition (see Chapter 12). The conclusion from this argument is that Bradley’s rule can explain the transition from the macroscopic engineering world, where nothing sticks, to the nanoworld where everything sticks.21 The transition for smooth spheres is 1 mm. Larger than 1 mm, ball bearings roll around and behave as we expect from our common experience. Below this they should stick. However, roughness introduces another dimension into this argument because true molecular contact is not achieved. This shifts the transition down to smaller particles, around in size. Thus there is a gray area of transition where particles can behave in a schizoid way, depending on surface roughness, sometimes sticking, sometimes not, between one micrometer and one millimeter in particle size Therefore we must consider more carefully what we mean by surface roughness as we move down from the engineering to the molecular scale. The best way to do this experimentally is by atomic force microscopy.
4.8. THE NEW SCIENCE OF ATOMIC FORCE MICROSCOPY (AFM) In the atomic force microscope, a fine pointed probe, typically l00nm diameter, is brought into close proximity with a smooth sample, which is controlled in position by a piezotube. The overall scheme was described in Chapter 3. Here the objective is to describe adhesion experiments as the probe is brought into adhesive contact with dry surfaces. Figure 4.15 shows the probe as it nears the sample. On the right is an atomic model of the near-contact region showing how the tip is from 10–100 nm diameter under normal circumstances, though the shape varies from tip to tip.22 One of the key problems in the AFM is the fact that the movement of the piezotube and tip must be added together. Clearly it is desirable to have as stiff a cantilever as possible so that most of the displacement is governed by the piezotube. Then the jumping of the tip onto the surface of the sample can be studied. It is important to remove all moisture in such experiments; otherwise, condensed capillary films obscure the results.
78
CHAPTER 4
One of the issues is to provide a realistic theory for the summing of London forces over the geometry of a probe tip. This has been carried out by various groups, and found to differ from the standard Hamaker expressions for sphere approaching flat, especially when the probe was very fine, e.g. less than l0nm diameter at the tip. The results obtained for the force on the tip as a function of separation could then be explained, and the Hamaker constant determined. Alternatively, a small sphere could be glued to the cantilever, in which case the
EVIDENCE FOR THE FIRST LAW OF ADHESION
79
standard equation applied. The results shown in Fig. 4.16 were obtained by Larson et al.23 All experiments in the AFM gave attractive jumping behavior in vacuum or air. In water and other liquids, jumping behavior could be observed as in Fig. 4.16, but could be stopped by stiffening the cantilever. The other question to be asked relates to the effect of surface roughness on such tests. Ultimately, the AFM probe can sense the different force curves across a surface, which then appears bumpy in force terms, even though it is perfectly flat in molecular terms.
4.9. HOW SMOOTH IS AN ATOM? This begs the question of what an atom is. Especially we have to ask whether the atom itself can be rough. The atomic hypothesis, that all matter could be divided into its ultimate constituents, whose shape and movement dictated the properties of the material, can be traced back to the Greek philosophers Leucippus and Democritus.24 Epicurus thought that the atoms could stick together because of hooks, sticks and holes which provided a mechanical bond, but that idea has been rejected through the centuries, largely because it is illogical to think of the ultimate particles of matter having extra, smaller bits attached. In particular, Newton thought the idea of “hook’d atoms” to be ridiculous and instead postulated the idea of forces acting from atom to atom, though generally he called the atoms “particula” or “corpuscula.” Of course it was known that atoms packed to form certain geometrical shapes of crystals, and this had stimulated Newton’s contemporary, Robert Hooke, to suggest that the atoms were spheres that were packing in regular order, rather as Plato had earlier conceived that atoms filled space as regular geometrical bodies, e.g. cubes, tetrahedra, octahedra, and icosahedra, as shown in Fig. 4.17. When Dalton invented the idea of atoms as participants in chemical reactions, he had the problem of how to stick atomic models together.25 He instructed his friend, Peter Ewart, to prepare a set of wooden balls, drill holes into the balls and insert wooden pegs to hold the model in place. These models appeared around 1810, about the same time that Wollaston was postulating the structuring of atoms into regular shapes to form molecules,26,27 the word first
80
CHAPTER 4
used by Avogadro in 1811. This idea, that atoms adhere to fill space, has been a very successful one and has led us to the idea of an atomically smooth surface, that is the idea of a plane filled with atoms. We then easily conceive of a rough surface because it has steps, vacancies, protruberances and so forth. So roughness is readily defined at this level, as shown in Fig. 4.18. The problem comes when we try to see roughness in the atoms themselves. With the scanning probe microscope, we can now distinguish features on the atomically smooth surface. But these are essentially variations in the force fields emanating from the atoms. The force field stretches some distance from the surface; it has a range of action which is quite large. The atom is smooth, and the plane of atoms is smooth, but the forces which act from the atoms vary significantly, and it is these forces which determine adhesion. So we must distinguish carefully what is the smooth plane of the atoms and what is the varying extent of the forces exerted by the atoms. Quantum effects must also be taken into account ultimately, but can be ignored to a first approximation.28 Once we have overcome this problem of definition, it is then possible to specify in detail what the forces are and how they act with Brownian motion to give adhesion. That is the purpose of the next chapter.
4.10. REFERENCES l. Newton, I., Opticks, Smith and Walford, London, 1704 (reprinted Dover, New York, 1952, p 201). 2. Newton, I. In: Turnbull, H.W. The Correspondence of Isaac Newton, vol I, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press 1959. 3. Budgett, H.M., Proc. R. Soc. A 86, 25–35 (1912). 4. McBain, J.W. and Lee, W.B., Proc. R. Soc. A 113, 606–620 (1927). 5. Hardy, W.B. and Nottage, M.E., Proc. R. Soc. A 112, 62 (1926). 6. Obreimoff, J.W., Proc. R. Soc. A 127, 290–297 (1930). 7. Gilman, J.J., J. Appl. Phys. 31, 2208–2218 (1960).
EVIDENCE FOR THE FIRST LAW OF ADHESION 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28.
81
Tabor, D. and Winterton, R.H.S., Proc. R. Soc. A 312, 435–450 (1969). Deryagin, B.V and Abrikosova, I.I., Disc. Faraday Soc. 18, 33 (1954). Kitchener, J.A. and Prosser, A.P., Proc. R. Soc. A 242, 403 (1957). Black, W., de Jongh, J.G.V, Overbeek, J.T.G. and Sparnaay, M.J., Trans. Faraday Soc. 56, 1597 (1960). Tolansky, S., Multiple Beam Interferometry of Surfaces and Films, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1948. Bowden, F.P. and Tabor, D., The Friction and Lubrication of Solids, part II Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1964, p 413. Israelachvili, J.N. and Tabor, D., Nature 236, 106 (1972). Israelachvili, J.N. and Tabor, D., Proc. R. Soc. A 331, 19–38 (1972). Bailey, A.I. and Kay, S.M., Proc. R. Soc. A 301, 47–56 (1967). Tomlinson, G.A., Phil. Mag. 6, 695–712 (1928). Bradley, R.S., Phil. Mag. 13, 853–62 (1932). Derjaguin, B.V., Kolloid Zeits 69, 155–64 (1934). Johnson, K.L., Kendall, K. and Roberts, A.D., Proc. R. Soc. A 324, 301–13 (1971). Kendall, K., Science, 263, 1720–25 (1994). Drummond, C.J. and Senden, T.J., Colloids Surfaces A 87, 217–34 (1994). Larson,I., Drummond, C.J., Chan, D.Y.C. and Grieser, F., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 115, 11885 (1993). Raos, N., Chem. Britain, February, 31-3 (1997). Rouvray, D.H., Chem. Indust., 4, 587–90 (1997). Wollaston, W.H., Phil. Trans. R. Soc. 98, 96 (1808). Wollaston, W.H., Phil. Trans. R. Soc. 103, 62 (1813). Von Baeyer, H.C., Taming the Atom: The Emergence of the Visible Microworld, Random House, New York 1992, p 980.
5 INTERMOLECULAR FORCES: THE NEW GEOMETRY OF COMPUTER MODELING
Where Attraction ceases, there a repulsive virtue ought to succeed ISAAC NEWTON, Opticks,1 p. 395
Isaac Newton almost certainly had in his mind the idea that adhesive attractions exist between the smallest parts of bodies, that is between the atoms and molecules. He had no way of measuring the size of these atoms nor of defining the way in which the forces vary with distance, although he predicted that “microscopes may at length be improved to the discovery of the Particles of Bodies”2, a kind of prophesy of the invention of electron and atomic force microscopes 300 years later. However, Newton was equally certain that the attraction could not be continuous, but must eventually be opposed by a repulsion as the atoms made contact, as indicated by the quote at the start of this chapter. The equilibrium between atoms must then be at the balance point where the force of attraction equals the force of repulsion, as suggested in Fig. 5.1. The purpose of this chapter is to consider the theory of these two forces between atoms: the attractive force which gets stronger as the atoms approach and the repulsion which acts when the atoms make contact. This leads us to a model of adhesion which has two parameters in the simplest case. Having established the forces, a computer model can then be defined to take into account the incessant motion of the atoms. This argument leads to the concept of a new geometry: the natural molecular adhesive geometry of the universe. Adhesion is shown to have a remarkably sensitive action on this geometry. 83
84
CHAPTER 5
5.1. THE TWO-PARAMETER MODEL OF ATOMIC FORCES The idea that there were two terms in the expression for the force between atoms and molecules was recognized by Newton, but really began to take shape this century when a number of theorists, like Mie for example, started to formulate mathematical equations to describe both an attractive term and a repulsive term,3 as shown in Fig. 5.2. In this diagram, the potential energy between two atoms is plotted on the vertical axis as the atoms are separated a certain distance, shown horizontally. Conventionally, the attraction is viewed as a negative potential given by the first term of the theory, and the repulsion is seen as positive, i.e. the second term. The two terms added together gave the total picture of the energy as shown in Fig. 5.2. From this energy, the force F between the atoms can readily be calculated by taking the gradient of the curve at any point, as shown on the top curve. Thus the force is zero at the minimum of the energy curve. The minimum of the force curve is where the bond breaks as the atoms are pulled apart. This is the maximum tension which can be supported by the attraction. The top curve shows that there is a minimum in the energy at a separation This is the equilibrium point, that is the point at which the repulsion and attraction balance. It is an “energy well” by analogy with a water well. Thus the atoms sit at the bottom of the energy well. Lennard-Jones4 applied this two-parameter model in the 1920s and early 1930s when there was much activity in trying to understand the quantum nature of the atom. Lennard-Jones, who was 30 years old and only called Jones when he suggested his memorable potential while at Trinity College Cambridge, foresaw the future, becoming Professor of Physics at Bristol before moving to be
INTERMOLECULAR FORCES
85
Professor of Chemistry at Cambridge. At the atomic bond level, there is no difference between physics and chemistry. Lennard-Jones, with his colleagues Taylor and Dent,5,6 realized that all known intermolecular forces are electromagnetic in nature. They range from the Coulombic forces between ions, to dipole forces between polar molecules, to the weak van der Waals forces which act between all atoms and which are responsible for adhesion. These adhesive forces, sometimes called London, London–van der Waals or dispersion forces, are always attractive because they result from instantaneous dipoles in one atom and their induced dipoles in a neighboring atom. The Lennard-Jones equation can be written
giving the energy w of the interaction as a function of the two parameters, the bond energy and the bond length. By inserting values of these two parameters into the equation, Lennard-Jones could calculate the properties of the atomic
86
CHAPTER 5
bond, especially confirming the measured viscosity of the gas, its equation of state, the spacing of atoms in a crystal, and the compressibility of the solid. The power of the repulsive term was between 9 and 20 and was typically 12. When this power was high, e.g. 20, then it approximated to a “hard-sphere” potential, such that the repulsion was very much like a hard wall, as we will see under Section 5.5 in the computer modeling. Later it was found that a whole range of two-parameter models could be used to describe the experimental information. For example, Morse7 fitted an exponential curve to both the attractive and the repulsive potentials. Buckingham had a power law attraction and an exponential repulsion. However, the power law expression of Lennard-Jones was most memorable because the attractive term corresponded very neatly with the London derivation of the van der Waals, force between two nonpolar molecules. London8 was working on a way to calculate the interaction between two atoms by solving Schrödinger’s equation of quantum mechanics,9 starting from the known atomic structure and the fundamental constants. In practice this approach is too complex, so approximations and compromises are necessary. Generally there are three types of approximation to solving the quantum theory: ab initio calculations semiempirical calculations, and model calculations. Ab initio calculations are available for only the simplest systems e.g. H–H, the bonding between two hydrogen atoms. Semiempirical calculations are used most because they combine quantum theory with some experimental results to give a good approximation to the truth. Model calculations replace the atoms or molecules with a more tractable model. For example, London replaced the molecule with a harmonic oscillator, allowing much simpler mathematical analysis to give his attractive behavior which fitted van der Waals experiments. It is this fit to experiment which we consider next.
5.2. EXPERIMENTAL EVIDENCE FOR MODELS OF MOLECULAR FORCES The data required to support and verify the above theories is remarkably sparse and largely specific to certain systems, such as the noble gases He–He and Ar–Ar, helium and argon molecules. Essentially there are four methods for determining the parameters in the atomic and molecular models. The first and most primitive one is the geometrical approximation which describes atoms as hard spheres with a certain radius. For example, you can determine the dimensions of the argon atom by measuring the spacing of the crystal lattice of solid argon, for example by X-ray diffraction. The second method is based on spectroscopic measurements to find the vibrational frequencies of the bonds. The third and most direct method is the scattering of molecular beams. Finally, there are the methods based on the bulk properties of the materials, for example
INTERMOLECULAR FORCES
87
gas law deviations such as viscosity used by Lennard-Jones, heats of sublimation, elastic properties, etc. The ordinary chemist’s view of atoms filling space like rigid balls is a reasonable approximation in many cases, despite the fact that quantum theory does not lead to a precise dimension of an atom. For example, the molecular model of the double helix of DNA was built by Crick and Watson assuming rigid geometric shapes for the atoms. Electrons around an atom do not, in fact, have a definite envelope, but are fuzzy according to quantum theory, with their effect dropping off exponentially as you move away from the atom. But the values of the range parameter in the Lennard-Jones equation are reasonably predictable and have been tabulated,9 as shown in Table 5.1, assuming hexagonal close packing of the spherical entities. This follows our expectations that atoms get larger as we go down a group, for example from Li to Cs. The atoms are accumulating more electrons and so should occupy more space. It is also easy to understand why the atomic radius should decrease as you move across a period, say from Li to F. The extra electrons are going into the same shell, but the added protons in the nucleus pull the shell in to give a more compact atom. Of course, ionization makes a large difference to these atomic radii. A cation such as is only half the size of the original sodium atom, having lost a bulky electron shell. Anions like are twice the size of their precursor fluorine atoms, having gained an electron. Molecules can also be constructed from these geometrical ideas.10 A molecule is a bunch of atoms bonded together, such that it behaves as a single unit, only connecting weakly to its neighboring molecules. Thus, methane can be considered to be a spherical molecule with a diameter of 400 pm. Decane is nothing like spherical and so can be considered as a cylindrical molecule 1.54 nm long and 400 pm diameter, but with possibilities of bending and rotating at each carbon linkage as illustrated in Fig. 5.3.
88
CHAPTER 5
The question then arises, “how do these molecules interact in terms of the forces between their constituent atoms?”
5.3. DIRECT MEASUREMENT OF MOLECULAR FORCES The most direct information on intermolecular forces has been obtained from scattering experiments on molecular beams. In particular, the repulsive forces have been elucidated by the neutral beam measurements of Amdur11 and his co-workers. The depth of the energy well and its bond length have been measured for many atoms and molecules using the “rainbow scattering effect” and interference phenomena below the “rainbow angle.” Typical results are shown in Fig. 5.4 for the potential well between potassium and the noble gases argon, krypton, and xenon.12
INTERMOLECULAR FORCES
89
The information gleaned by these techniques for a wide range of atomic and molecular interactions is contained in computer modeling packages, such as MSI13 which are now widely used in drug design and in many other applications. Much information can be gathered on web sites such as that at the Royal Institution in London.14 This information can then be used to put together molecular models.15,16
5.4. INTERMOLECULAR FORCES FROM BULK PROPERTIES Intermolecular forces are important because they dictate many of the macroscopic properties of the bulk material, for example the behavior of the gas and liquid phases, the crystalline structure, the elastic modulus, the ultimate strength, the heat of sublimation, and the chemical reactivity. Of course, the intermolecular forces are also responsible ultimately for the adhesion between bodies. Table 5.2 illustrates some of the properties which have been predicted from a knowledge of intermolecular forces. But the properties of gases are easiest to understand. In 1873, van der Waals was the first person to show how intermolecular forces must be introduced to explain the properties of gases. Gases exist because each atom has so much kinetic energy that the adhesion between the atoms is relatively insufficient to cause the atoms to stick together. Thus the compression of a volume V of atoms by a pressure P is dominated by the kinetic energy of the atoms as shown in Fig. 5.5. The kinetic energy of each atom is 3kT/2 where k is Boltzmann’s constant and T is the absolute temperature. As the gas is compressed at constant temperature, the energy of the atoms remains constant and so the perfect gas law, PV= constant, is obeyed for a perfect gas.
90
CHAPTER 5
Van der Waals could see two things wrong with this argument. The first objection was that the atoms have a certain volume which restricts the total compression. Once the piston is pressed to this atomic volume then the law must fail. Secondly, the atoms have a certain attraction to each other, resulting from the atomic adhesion, and if this becomes comparable to the kinetic energy of the atoms, then the perfect gas law must be inadequate. These two effects are illustrated in Fig. 5.6. At low packing, the gas law is extremely accurate, but as the atoms are pressed closer together, the PV rises because the volume of the atoms is no longer negligible. When the adhesion between the atoms increases towards kT then there is an extra deviation from the perfect gas behavior because the adhesion between
INTERMOLECULAR FORCES
91
the atoms also increases the pressure. Eventually, when the atomic attraction gets above about 10kT, the gas condenses into a compact phase because of the strong adhesion between the atoms. This is the sort of behavior we must now consider in terms of computer modeling techniques.
5.5. THE NEW GEOMETRY OF COMPUTER MODELING Originally, Greek philosophers thought that the universe was continuous and that the world could be described by lines, areas, and volumes, according to the geometry (literally “earth-measurement”), set down by Euclid, for example, around 300 BC. It became evident a few centuries ago that shapes are not continuous but are composed of similar but smaller shapes as they become more magnified. Thus a tree looks more complex the more it is studied on a finer scale, as shown in Fig. 5.7. This concept is the basis of fractal geometry which has been described by Mandelbrot.17 However, there must be a limit to this process as we approach atomic dimensions. At the atomic level, matter begins to look absolutely uniform, so that a crystal of argon is composed of exactly equal spheres arranged in a regular manner. However, this is not a valid picture according to the ideas we have been developing earlier in this book. Following van der Waals, we must conclude that the true geometry of the universe is not just affected by shape and size. It is also greatly affected by the random motion of the atoms and also by the adhesive forces of interaction between them. Unfortunately van der Waals only had the crudest mathematical tools to describe these additional features, and so could not formulate a realistic model. But now, with the emergence of computers, it has become possible to put the three elements of a realistic atomic model together: the spherical atoms, the random motions, and the attractive forces, to give a new vision of the world.
92
CHAPTER 5
The pioneering studies of this type of model, now known as molecular dynamics, were carried out by Alder and Wainwright in 1957 and the following decade.18 Wood and Jacobson, at the same time, obtained similar results by a slightly different approach.19 Berni Alder was working at the Lawrence Radiation Laboratories in California trying to bounce theoretical, nonadhering spheres around inside a computer. Since computers were rather limited in power at that time, a million times less potent than today’s machines, he could only model small numbers of spheres from 4 to 32 up to a maximum of 500. He found that, when the spheres had a lot of space to move around, then the motion was disordered like a gas, as in Fig. 5.8(a). But at high packing, as shown in Fig. 5.8(b), the spheres jostled together to produce an ordered structure which was crystalline in nature, although the spheres were still essentially fluid in their ability to move freely without any adhesion. This structuring was eventually proved to be a “first-order phase transition” and happens to be one of the few discoveries made by computer. Carl Stainton20 has repeated those early computer calculations of Alder and Wainwright using a modern desktop machine to show the detailed nature of the phase transition. Like Alder, he used periodic boundaries so that the spheres did not encounter obstacles in the model (Fig. 5.9(a)). As a particle left the cell during the calculation, it was assumed to re-enter from the other side. The particles obeyed Newton’s laws of motion in three dimensions and bounced perfectly off one another with no energy loss. When the particles were reduced in diameter to lower the packing density in the cell, the phase transition shown in Fig. 5.9(b) was found. The phase transition appeared suddenly, as the close-packed sphere structure was being diluted by shrinking each sphere diameter, when the spheres occupied 49% of the volume, i.e. at 0.49 packing fraction. The pressure was calculated by working out the impacts of the spheres on one square meter of the cell in one second. As the volume of the spheres was reduced during the computation, the
INTERMOLECULAR FORCES
93
pressure was seen to drop steadily in the structured phase. However, at 0.49 packing fraction, the pressure rose and the spheres were then seen to be in random, rather than ordered, positions. It is important now to consider this phase behavior in more detail.
5.6. STRUCTURING OF HARD SPHERES The computer study of this phase transition in the 1960s and 1970s led rapidly to a keen understanding of how hard, nonadhering spheres behaved as they were compacted towards the dense state. There were two outstanding problems: what was the range of the transition between random and fully structured packings and what was the ultimate stable form of the structured material? The first question was soon answered by Hoover and Ree,21,22 who looked at the upper transition at 0.55 packing fraction, above which the structure should be completely structured, called the melting transition because that is where melting (i.e. randomizing) first started to occur as the structured material was diluted. In the early computations, this upper transition did not appear because there were too few spheres to obtain random and structured phases together in the sample. Only when computing power had increased was it possible to see both transitions easily. These are shown in Fig. 5.10. The lower transition at 0.495 volume fraction became known as the freezing transition because that was where the random fluid first began to structure during compaction.
94
CHAPTER 5
The second problem, that of the preferred geometry in the structured state, was much more difficult because there were three possible candidate structures, and all of them were rather similar in energy. The crux of the problem was finding the lowest energy structure because this should be the one most stable and eventually dominant. Alder and his colleagues23 had considered this problem for a long time, but had not come up with the answer. The nature of the different possible structures can be seen by packing tennis balls in a box, as shown in Fig. 5.11. The bottom layer, marked A, goes down as a hexagonal close-packed bed, as shown by the solid circles. Putting the next layer on top gives the structure with the sphere centers in positions B, shown by the broken circle, marked B. The next ball to go on top of this layer, shown as a dotted circle, is then very important because it determines the structure. If it goes in the position marked C then the structure is face-centred cubic i.e. fcc, whereas if it goes back to A, then the structure is hexagonal close-packed, i.e. a hcp structure. This structure goes ABABAB, in contrast with fcc which goes ABC ABC ABC. If the layers are random, for example ABCACBCA..., then the packing is random hexagonal close-packed i.e. rhcp. All the three hexagonal structures go to 74% packing at the maximum limit. However, the energies of the packings are different at the close-packing levels, leading to a preference for the lower energy state. Alder had considered this question and predicted fcc would win. Woodcock demonstrated this result by computation in 1997 and the conclusion has been verified by several groups since then. 24–27 The energy difference was extremely small, about kT/1000, but this was still sufficient to force the fcc structure to dominate the hcp. These ideas could be checked in practice by comparing the computer results with experiments on polymer latex particles.
INTERMOLECULAR FORCES
95
5.7. EXPERIMENTS ON SPHERICAL POLYMER PARTICLES Of course, it is impossible to find particles with zero adhesion to confirm the theoretical argument that spheres should form a face-centered cubic structure above 0.49 volume fraction. However, certain types of polymer latex can be made to approximate to the theoretical nonadhesion conditions above. Polymethyl methacrylate particles were polymerized in a dispersion and polymer molecules were grafted to the surface to provide a steep repulsive force on close approach. The solvent was chosen to reduce the van der Waals force to a low level, by matching the refractive index to the spheres, obtaining an almost transparent suspension from the milky preparation. Pusey and van Megen28 prepared dispersions over a range of volume fractions and looked at light scattering from structures forming in the suspensions. Sedimentation occurred as the heavy polymer particles sank slowly to the bottom of the sample tubes. They observed the phase transition predicted from the computer theory. Crystalline regions could be seen as opalescent patches above 0.5 packing fraction. Above 0.58, the suspension seemed to be too viscous to form the crystals and this was interpreted as a glassy regime. Pusey and his colleagues29 then investigated the detailed structure of the crystalline regions by examining the diffraction patterns of the scattered light to distinguish fcc from hcp and rhcp structures. Under dilute conditions of slow
96
CHAPTER 5
sedimentation, they observed fcc structuring, but at higher concentrations found a mix of fcc and hcp. This suggests that equilibrium was not fully established, or that gravity was having a large influence on the results. The theory of hard spheres ignored gravity. Since that time, a large number of experimental tests have been carried out on polymer spheres,30–32 and also on silica spheres which simulate the opalescent patterns in natural opal.33,34 Generally, the broad predictions of the hard-sphere theory were verified but the fcc structure was not totally dominant. In order to distinguish the small forces acting on the suspensions, a number of experiments were carried on the Space Shuttle Columbia.35 There in the microgravity of space, it should be possible to compare the experiments with the computer predictions more realistically, since the computations assumed zero gravity. The spheres were 508 nm diameter polymer particles with a grafted surface layer. Packing fractions from 0.5–0.6 were examined over several days. The experiment consisted of stirring the suspension to randomize it, then observing the light scattering pattern to look for structural peaks. The diffraction patterns are so different, as shown in Fig. 5.12, that the result is unequivocal; fcc occurs on Earth but rhcp occurs in space. It was a surprise to find that a sample of packing 0.537 did not give fcc packing in space, but rhcp instead, whereas it gave fcc on earth. Also, samples crystallized quicker in space than on earth. For example, a glassy packing of 0.619 volume fraction remained random for a year on Earth whereas it crystallized in space in 4 d. Some of these odd effects require further investigation. One possible cause of these problems is the time required for the crystallization process, which is considered next.
5.8. COMPUTER MODEL OF THE CRYSTALLIZATION PROCESS As spheres bounce off each other without any adhesion or loss of energy, they exist most naturally in a random state, like a gas. But as the spheres are
INTERMOLECULAR FORCES
97
compacted together above a packing fraction of 0.55 they become constrained to form hexagonally packed regions. If the number of spheres is small, say 32 in Berni Alder’s early simulations, then the switch from random to structured is rapid and occurs equally for every single sphere. All the spheres cooperate in forming a single crystal structure, as shown in Fig. 5.13(a). This cannot happen for a large number of particles. With very large numbers, it is more likely that the structuring starts at several nucleation points, which leads to a polycrystalline structure in the final state, as shown in Fig. 5.13(b). This is what we see in opal, where there are many different regions of color, signifying crystallites usually a few millimetres in size, at different orientations to their neighbors, spread throughout the large gemstone. This problem has not been studied by computer modeling previously. The task we set ourselves was to increase the number of spheres and to observe these different crystalline regions forming in the zero adhesion model, while observing the structure of each crystal. Carl Stainton set up 12000 spheres in his desktop computer, started them buzzing around in a three-dimensional box with periodic boundaries, and then compacted them to 0.57 packing fraction, where structuring was then observed. The structures were picked out on the computer by their particular signatures, and then followed as they grew with time. Obviously, the growth of structure is random and is different in each simulation, depending on the position of all the spheres at the starting point. In other words, structuring is a random process. However, the general pattern of the structural growth can be observed to form some overall average conclusions about the ultimate geometry. Although the face-centered cubic crystal is the one that is most stable, having the lowest energy, it was surprising to find that this phase was not the first to be nucleated. In fact, the body-centered cubic, i.e. bcc lattice, was the one that
98
CHAPTER 5
tended to grow first in the simulation, closely followed by fcc and hcp. This suggests that Ostwald’s step rule is being followed. Ostwald found that the stable crystal does not emerge first in crystallization experiments. The phase closest in energy to the random phase appears first and then mutates with time into the stable crystal structure. This happens because the random phase more quickly adapts to the bcc rather than fcc even though the bcc is less stable. The bodycentred cubic structure is less well packed than fcc, having 0.68 packing fraction rather than 0.74, as is shown in Fig. 5.14. As the model was observed, small regions of bcc structure were seen appearing. These crystals were unstable and readily transformed into a faulted mixture of fcc and hcp structures by a slip of the lattice. Thus fcc regions closely followed the appearance of bcc material, with hcp lagging behind. The nuclei were not rounded or symmetrical but percolated through the surrounding random lattice. Thus, the conventional picture of spherical nuclei shown in many textbooks was proved false in these simulations. Slow conversion and growth of the nuclei occurred, but with an unpredictable path, giving differing amounts of fcc and hcp. There seemed to be no one single pathway through to the final stable fcc structure. As the crystal regions began to dominate, with the random phase disappearing, the development of fcc structure became spasmodic as sudden conversions of material took place. These jumps are seen in the simulation of 64,000 particles shown in Fig. 5.15. The final structure of the particles after a long period of computing is shown in Fig. 5.16. It was evident that the structure was dominated by fee shown as dark spheres, while most of the random material shown as light had disappeared. But there were still significant regions of bcc and hcp. The fcc was not all in the same orientation but had typically formed 3 crystallites in this size of packing. This suggests that 20 000 particles are required for each crystallite when nucleation is spontaneous and not dependent on any outside stimulation. Obviously, artificial
INTERMOLECULAR FORCES
99
100
CHAPTER 5
nuclei could be added to promote fcc crystallization. This should lead to fewer polycrystalline regions in the final body.
5.9. EFFECT OF ADHESION ON THE STRUCTURING PROCESS The computer model described above is significant because it shows that the crystalline face-centered cubic geometry of our planet can arise from two simple rules: random movement of spheres together with compaction pressure to pack the spheres together past the 0.55 packing fraction. Thus a gas of nonadhering moving spherical molecules must structure in this way as it is compressed to a high density. Structure arises from randomness, not from solidity, and can arise in the gas phase. However, if the molecules adhere to each other, then this adhesion must pull the spheres together in addition to the compaction pressure, perhaps changing the structure. This is the question now addressed: how does the attractive potential of the atoms influence the structuring of the spheres? Alder had attempted to answer this question in the late 1950s but computing power was insufficient and he could not resolve it. But by following Alder’s lead, adopting a two-parameter model of adhesion, we have found it possible to show that adhesion has an enormous effect on the structuring process. This idea was tested by Carl Stainton in the model of 64,000 spheres. He applied the simplest possible potential model, the square well shown in Fig. 5.17, for comparison with the hard sphere case considered before. The two cases were run on the computer one after the other, with identical starting configurations, but with adhesion introduced in the second run.36 The adhesion was first inserted at a low level, less than kT, and was then gradually increased to show its effect. The results showed that a small amount of adhesion strongly influenced the crystal growth phenomenon. In the first place the nuclei became more rounded, whereas in the hard-sphere case they had been percolating. Secondly, the crystals grew at different rates in the presence of adhesion.
INTERMOLECULAR FORCES
101
A typical picture showing these two effects is given in Fig. 5.18. Adhesion of less than 1 kT had little effect on the model, but adhesion of 2 kT slowed down the crystallization, leaving a lot of random material, which is shown as light colored spheres in Fig. 5.18. It was noticable too that the nuclei were more rounded in this case, as expected, because there was now an interfacial energy between random and structured phases, arising from the adhesion force. The conclusion is that adhesion between atoms is enormously important to structure. An incredibly small energy of attraction between spheres can cause them to structure in a different way, starting from the same initial conditions. The energy of a typical chemical bond is around per atom. We are seeing here that an adhesion 100 times less than this is sufficient to cause structure change. Thus the slightest adhesion can be of great significance, much greater than previously realized.
5.10. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
REFERENCES
Newton, I., Opticks, Smith and Walford, London, 1704 (reprinted Dover, New York, 1952, p 395). Newton, I., Opticks, Smith and Walford, London, 1704 (reprinted Dover, New York, 1952, p 261). Israelachvili, J.N., Intermolecular and Surface Forces, Academic Press, London, 1985, p 8. Lennard-Jones, J.E., Proc. R. Soc. A 106, 441–77, 709–18 (1924). Lennard-Jones, J.E. and Taylor, P.A., Proc. R. Soc., A 109, 476–508 (1925). Lennard-Jones, J.E. and Dent, B.M., Proc. R. Soc., A 112, 230–4 (1926). Morse, P.M., Phys. Rev. 34, 57 (1929). London, F., Trans. Faraday Soc. 33, 8–26 (1937). Shriver, D.F. and Atkins, P.W., Inorganic Chemistry 3rd Edition, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1999, p 24. 10. Israelachvili, J.N., Intermolecular and Surface Forces, Academic Press, New York, 1985, chapter 7. 11. Amdur, I. and Jordan, J.E., In: Molecular Beams (Advances in Chemical Physics Vol 10) ed. J Ross, Interscience, New York 1966, chapter 2.
102
CHAPTER 5
12. Bernstein, R.B. and Muckerman, J.T., In: Intermolecular Forces ed. J.O. Hirschfelder, Interscience, New York, 1967, pp 389–486. 13. MSI, Molecular Simulations Inc, USA. 14. www.Ri.ac.uk/potentials/, S Woodley, Royal Institution, London. 15. Leach, A.R., Molecular Modeling: Principles and Applications, Longmans, Harlow, 1996. 16. Gans, W., Fundamental Principles of Molecular Modeling, Plenum, New York, 1996. 17. Mandelbrot, B.B. and Evertsz, C.J.G., Nature 348, 143 (1990). 18. Alder, B.J. and Wainwright, T.E., J. Chem. Phys. 27, 1208–9 (1957). 19. Wood, W.W. and Jacobson, J . D . , J Chem. Phys. 27, 1207–8 (1957). 20. Stainton, C., PhD Thesis, University of Keele, 2000. 21. Hoover, W.G. and Ree, F.H., J. Chem. Phys. 47, 4873–8 (1967). 22. Hoover, W.G. and Ree, F.H., J. Chem. Phys. 49, 3609–17 (1968). 23. Alder, B.J., Carter, B.P. and Young, D.A., Phys. Rev. 183, 831–3 (1970). 24. Woodcock, L.V., Nature 385, 141–3 (1997). 25. Bolhuis, P.G., Frenkel, D.. Mau, S.C. and Huse, D.A., Nature 388, 235–6 (1997). 26. Bruce, A.D., Wilding. N.B. and Ackland, G.J., Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 3002–5 (1997). 27. Speedy, R.J., J. Phys. Condens. Mater. 10, 4387–91 (1998). 28. Pusey, P.N. and van Megen, W., Nature 320, 340–2 (1986). 29. Pusey, P.N., van Megen, W., Bartlett, P., Ackerson, P.J., Rarity, A.G. and Underwood, S.M., Phys. Rev. Lett. 63,2753–6(1989). 30. Rutgers, M.A., Dunsmuir, J.H., Xue, J.Z., Russel, W.B. and Chaikin, P.M., Phys. Rev. B 93, 5043–6 (1996). 31. Elliot, M.S., Bristol, B.T.F. and Poon, W.C.K., Physica A 235, 216–23 (1997). 32. Dux, C. and Versmold, H., Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 1811–4 (1997). 33. Miguez, H., Meseguer, F., Lopez, C., Mifsud, A. Moya, J.S. and Vazquez, L., Langmuir 13, 6009– 11 (1997). 34. Van Blaaderen, A., Science 282, 887–8 (1998). 35. Zhu, J., Min, L., Rogers, R., Meyer, W, Ottewill, R., STS-73 Space Shuttle Crew, Russel, W.B. and Chaikin, P.M., Nature 287, 883–5 (1997). 36. Stainton, C., van Swol, F., Kendall, K. and Woodcock, L.V., submitted (2001).
6 EVIDENCE FOR THE SECOND LAW OF ADHESION: CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
The Attraction of the Glass is almost balanced and rendered ineffectual by the contrary Attraction of the liquor ISAAC NEWTON, Opticks,1 p. 371
Newton found that dry glass lenses stuck together best when he “took two Object glasses,... pressed them slowly together . . . and then slowly lifted the upper Glass from the lower”.2 As soon as water was introduced, the glass lenses, which would stick together strongly in dry conditions, were less adhesive. We are very familiar with these effects; paper starts to come apart when wet, paint begins to fall off surfaces after immersion in water, and fibreglass yachts are weaker as water penetrates along the interface between the fibres and the polymer matrix. A typical test of adhesive reliability is to boil a joint in water for a couple of hours to see if it fails. It usually does. Since ancient times we have cleaned our clothing by washing in water. This releases the dirt particles more readily from the cloth fibers. Although it is possible to suck dirt particles out of cloth by vacuuming or shaking, washing is much more effective. In addition, when we add detergent, the dirt comes off even more easily. So water, and additives such as polymers which make water wetter, are very important in reducing adhesion. The problem, shown in Fig. 6.1, is that liquids also seem to act as adhesives under certain conditions. For example, wet sand sticks together better than dry sand. If we wish to agglomerate powder, we add water and stir the powder to compact it. Similarly, the best way to make an adhesive joint is to wet the 103
104
CHAPTER 6
adherends with a liquid adhesive, then to solidify the adhesive; the familiar thermoplastic glue method. Also, when sticking a rubber suction pad to a surface, it is best to wet it first. How can we explain these seemingly opposite effects of contamination on adhesion?
6.1. EXPERIMENTS TO SHOW THAT ADHESION IS REDUCED BY CONTAMINATION The problem of showing that adhesion is reduced by contamination is largely one of finding clean surfaces in the first place. On Earth, all surfaces rapidly become contaminated by layers of foreign molecules such as oxygen, water or oil. Thus, clean surfaces do not normally exist in our terrestrial environment. In space, on the other hand, there are fewer contaminants and so things naturally stick together better. Thus early experimenters like Bradley evacuated their apparatus to simulate space conditions. Obreimoff3 in 1930 first did this by cleaving mica under vacuum. He showed that the energy required was much greater than in air, as described in Section 4.2, obtaining values up to The cleavage energy dropped by a factor of 13 when the experiment was carried out in air. He also observed that the time needed for debonding was different in different atmospheres. For example, some days were needed at low pressure whereas only a few seconds were required in the laboratory conditions. This suggested that time was necessary for the molecules to move onto the surfaces to cause contamination, and reduce adhesion. About the same time, there was a controversy in England about the effect of liquids on adhesion of glass. Stone4 reported to the Philosophical Magazine that
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
105
glass beads would only stick together when damp. As the beads dried, they fell apart, much as dry sandcastles weaken. This observation was not accepted by Tomlinson5 of the National Physical Laboratory who suggested that the beads were not smooth, thus confusing the results. He carried out further experiments on the quartz fibers he had used previously to demonstrate molecular adhesion in 1928,6 as described in Section 4.5. In the first experiment, Tomlinson sealed fused silica fibers in a brass cylinder, heated them to about 1000°C, and observed their adhesion as he manipulated them inside the chamber. The adhesion was substantial. To prove that dry air had no effect on the adhesion, he circulated air through sulfuric acid, calcium chloride towers, phosphorus pentoxides and roasted pumice to remove all moisture. He then found that the adhesion remained high for six weeks. But when the fibers were exposed to damp air, the adhesion was reduced to almost nothing in a few hours. His conclusion was that smooth silica adheres when dry but not much when wet. The reason for Stone,s misleading observations, that the surfaces of glass beads are rough and become filled with water, will be explained later in Chapter 7, as illustrated in Fig. 6.2. Bailey and Kay7 followed up these phenomena by showing that the work of cleavage of mica was in dry air, dropping to in hexane, at 50% relative humidity, and to in water. In other words, the presence of foreign molecules, either gas or liquid, was sufficient to reduce adhesion considerably. These experiments have been further pursued in great depth by Israelachvili and his co-workers, by taking atomically smooth flakes of mica and bringing them together in controlled conditions, as described later in Sections 6.4, 6.5 and 6.6. More recently, many adhesion experiments have been carried out in the atomic force microscope, showing most convincingly that adhesion falls when contamination is present. These are described in Section 6.7. Oxide surfaces such as mica are high energy surfaces and hence are very sensitive to contaminants. By contrast, polymer surfaces are lower in energy and show more constrained and reproducible effects. For example, the energy of adhesion of hydrocarbon polymers to surfaces is generally around too low to give the huge changes in adhesion seen with mica. However, contamination
106
CHAPTER 6
still reduces adhesion significantly. This effect is used in practice when molding thermoplastic objects. Mold release agents, typically stearic acid or similar molecules, are added to polymers before injection moulding to allow them to release easily from the metal tools, as shown in Fig. 6.3. The release agent adheres strongly to the metal tool, thus reducing the adhesion of the polymer, which can then be demolded with ease.8,9 The acid molecule is drawn as having two parts, the long tail hydrocarbon chain, and the adhesive head, which reacts and sticks strongly to the metal surface, to remain after the polymer is peeled off. Rubber adhesion experiments, performed in 1971,10 were the first quantitative demonstration of adhesion reduction by contaminants wetting the surfaces. These experiments are very readily reproducible and are described in detail next.
6.2. POLYMER ADHESION AFFECTED BY CONTAMINANTS A simple test of polymer adhesion is to take a table tennis bat and cover it with a smooth layer of rubber, as shown in Fig. 6.4. A ping-pong ball then adheres to the smooth surface sufficiently to support its own weight. The rubber surface is so smooth that it looks shiny and liquid-like, seeming to wet the ball as it makes molecular contact, but in reality there is no fluid present. When the rubber is immersed in water, alcohol or other liquid, the ball drops off.11 An apparatus for studying this effect in more detail was described by Roberts and Tabor12 in 1971, as shown in Fig. 6.5. They had been particularly interested in the effect of lubricant films under car tires or beneath windshield wipers. Previously, Blok had tried to study these thick contaminant layers by placing a smooth plastic sheet on the tire rubber surface.13 But Roberts showed that this was unnecessary. If the rubber was molded against an optical glass surface, then the rubber itself acted as a mirror and enabled Newton’s rings to be
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
107
seen. The movement of the rings allowed the shape of the deforming rubber to be calculated. The rubber and glass surfaces were brought into close proximity through the water and the interference fringes were seen. Then the rubber jumped into contact with the glass, at first trapping some water islands within the contact region. But these water globules gradually disappeared as the water diffused out to the edge of the contact, suggesting that a very thin layer of water was remaining between
108
CHAPTER 6
rubber and glass. In particular, after equilibrium was reached, the size of the black contact spot could be measured accurately. This was seen to be much less than the size of the contact under dry conditions, proving that the surface energy of the glass and rubber in contact was reduced by the presence of water, approximately by a factor of ten. Chapter 9 shows the proportionality between work of adhesion and the cube of black spot diameter. In an experiment on equal rubber surfaces under dry conditions,7 the black spot diameter was 1.37 mm, equivalent to a work of adhesion of which is twice the surface energy of each individual surface. Thus the rubber surface energy was But when the surfaces were immersed in water, the black spot fell to 0.63 mm in diameter, suggesting a work of adhesion reduced to corresponding to a wet surface energy of Thus the presence of water at the adhesive contact diminished adhesion by a factor of nearly ten. This agreed satisfactorily with the wetting contact angle of 66° measured for water on the rubber surface, the first time that the famous Young equation for wetting of a solid by a liquid had been verified directly. However, this work was soon repeated in the USA.
6.3. STUDIES OF SURFACE SPECIES BY THE ADHESION METHOD Chaudhury and his colleagues at Dow Corning Corp and Lehigh University in Pennsylvania followed up these early results, especially looking at the surface treatment of the rubber to give a variety of surface species.14,15 The polymer selected was polydimethyl siloxane elastomer (PDMS or silicone rubber) which was made by crosslinking a liquid polymer to give a very elastic rubbery network. This is similar to the polymer once used in breast enhancement surgery. Because this polymer does not go glassy until its temperature is reduced to – 120°C, it is exceptionally resilient at room temperature and displays almost complete elastic behavior, making it ideal for measurement of polymer adhesion when contamination is present. In the first experiments, the adhesion of the PDMS rubber to itself was measured to give a work of adhesion of significantly smaller than the ordinary hydrocarbon rubbers used previously. Then a number of liquids were used to wet the rubber/rubber contact and the black spot size was measured under contaminated conditions. The results depended very much on how the contaminant liquid wetted the rubber surface, as shown in Fig. 6.6. The wetting liquid caused the black spot to decrease whereas the nonwetting liquid caused the black spot to increase in size. For example water, which does not wet PDMS rubber but has a contact angle of 102° as shown in Fig. 6.5(b), gave a work of adhesion of In this case the liquid makes the
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
109
rubber adhere more strongly. But methanol, which wets the rubber, as in Fig. 6.5(a), gave a work of adhesion of thus reducing adhesion. We can begin to understand these phenomena in terms of work of adhesion by considering the following thought experiment,16 shown diagrammatically in Fig. 6.7. Imagine two cubes of solid which are pulled apart in a liquid. This requires a work of adhesion where the subscripts SL correspond to the solid/liquid interface. However, the process can be done another way, by first separating the blocks to give a vapor bubble, which requires a work corresponding to solid/vapor (SV) interfaces, then allowing the liquid meniscus to wet the surfaces to give fully immersed bodies. This wetting gives back energy where is the surface tension of the liquid/vapor (LV) interface. Since these two processes reach the same end-point, the two energy changes must be equal, so we can add energies, leading to the relation shown in the figure. In conclusion, the wettability is vital to the adhesion.
110
CHAPTER 6
When the contact angle is 90° and the liquid droplet forms a little hemisphere on the surface, then no work is done by the wetting, and the work of adhesion in liquid is the same as in vapor. But if the liquid wets the surface then adhesion must be reduced. This is equivalent to Young’s original theory of 1805, which he did not express in symbols but only in words.16 All the results above were consistent with this equation. Thus the second law of adhesion is true for wetting liquids. To check this law out more rigorously, Chaudhury and Whitesides15 made 11 different mixtures of methanol and water, ranging from 5% methanol to 100%, and used them to verify Young’s equation. First they measured the surface tension of each mixture, then they measured the contact angle of each mixture on a flat surface of the PDMS rubber. This enabled them to calculate the term cos in the equation of Fig. 6.7. Plotting this as the vertical axis in Fig. 6.8 allowed a comparison with the work of adhesion of the rubber measured in the 11 methanol/water mixtures. This graph shows the straight line plot expected from Young’s equation, together with the experimental points which fall squarely on the theoretical line. This experiment was a convincing proof that the equilibrium work of adhesion could be measured over a wide range of chemical conditions. The solid rubber was found to have a surface energy very similar to the high molecular weight liquid, suggesting that the methyl groups are sticking outwards at the surface. Then Chaudhury and Whitesides found a way of modifying their silicone rubber surface to change its chemical character. The PDMS polymer was exposed to an oxygen plasma for a short period, as shown in Fig. 6.9, creating a thin layer of silica on the surface, about 3 nm thick. By treating this silica layer with molecules of siloxane, single molecular layers, i.e. monolayers of particular structures, could be formed at the rubber surface.
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
111
The method of applying the organic monolayer to the surface was very easy. A solution of the silane molecule was made in paraffin oil, at a concentration of between 1–2%. This was evacuated in a desiccator containing the silica-surfacedrubber samples. After a short time, the surfaces were found to be covered with a monolayer. Five long chain silane compounds were studied, as shown in Table 6.1. In each case, the chlorine atoms reacted with the hydroxyl groups on the silica to bond the long chains to the surface, as indicated in Fig. 6.9(b). These values show the remarkably sensitive changes in adhesion levels brought about by the changing chemical groups at the surface. The work of adhesion of the fluorinated surface was only half that of a typical hydrocarbon rubber. Moreover, the hysteresis exhibited by these surfaces was very small, indicating that the systems were near equilibrium, with little frictional energy loss. In addition, the results were consistent with contact angle measurements.
CHAPTER 6
112
The overall conclusion was that adhesion energetics in liquids could be readily understood by this technique. However, the adhesion forces varying with separation were not easy to measure by this method, because of the large deformations across the contact. Force measurement required the surface force apparatus of Israelachvili, to maintain the surfaces in rigid cylindrical form and to keep a known gap between the surfaces.
6.4. SURFACE FORCES MEASURED IN LIQUIDS The attractive forces between smooth mica surfaces immersed in liquids have been much measured over the past 30 years by Israelachvili and his colleagues. Israelachvili joined the staff at the Australian National University in Canberra during 1973 and started to do the unthinkable by carrying out experiments in the Mathematics Department. He began to work with Adams in modifying the surface force apparatus previously built in Cambridge.17 The idea was to fill it full of water and other liquids. A schematic of the equipment is shown in Fig. 6.10. Two flakes of mica, about thick, were cleaved and glued onto curved glass formers to give the crossed cylinder geometry described in Section 4.3. These mica surfaces could be brought together by a three-stage mechanism: an upper coarse screw which positioned the lower mica surface; a bottom screw which adjusted the mica to 1 nm distance, and the piezotube which controlled the movement to 0.1 nm. Light was passed through the mica via a microscope
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
113
objective to give the multiple beam interference fringes for measuring the gap between the mica surfaces. The lower mica flake was suspended on a cantilever spring of stiffness so that the forces between the surfaces could be determined by the deflection. Special precautions had to be taken to purify the water to stop particles getting between the mica, inhibiting molecular contact. The early experiments showed that the attraction between the mica was much reduced by the presence of water. Results displayed in Fig. 6.11 show that adhesion dropped by an order of magnitude compared to previous measurements in air.18 The benefit of this smaller force was that measurements could be made at smaller gaps. The main difference between air and liquid is that other forces start to intrude, especially double-layer forces at long range and solvation forces at ranges less than a nanometer. The double-layer forces can be seen quite easily in the surface force apparatus. At pH around 6 in potassium nitrate solutions of various concentrations, the force was a repulsion which increased exponentially as the gap closed. For higher concentrations of salt, the slope increased as expected from DLVO theory (see Chapter 10). Results are shown in Fig. 6.12 for several concentrations of ranging from to The results were found to fit the DLVO theory over a wide range of separations above l0 nm, when the Hamaker constant was taken as At closer approach the repulsion increased faster. There was no clear-cut evidence of the primary minimum of attraction which should be
114
CHAPTER 6
expected below 5 nm when van der Waals forces should dominate. However, it is known that, with siliceous surfaces, the repulsion is continuous up to close contact, as a result of hydration layers.
6.5. JUMPING IN STEPS AS MOLECULES ARE SQUEEZED OUT The key question about adhesion of surfaces in the presence of contaminating molecules is what happens as the last few molecules are squeezed out from between the surfaces. It has been known since Langmuir’s time19 that certain contaminant molecules can stick very strongly to a surface in a monolayer and that further multilayers can build up with progressively weaker bonds as shown in Fig. 6.13. Bowden studied this for 30 years especially to find the conditions for removing the final tenacious bonded layer.20 In one of the last papers before he died, Bowden21 described experiments to clean-up surfaces of diamond, sapphire, quartz and other oxides. This was important for space exploration because the harsh clean conditions of space could cause bearings to seize up. Bowden and his
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
115
co-workers showed that heating the surfaces in a vacuum of bar would remove much contamination. Alternatively, rubbing the surfaces together in a vacuum about 1000 times was sufficient to dislodge the molecules. Then strong adhesion and seizure could be observed. Horn and Israelachvili22 addressed this problem using smooth mica surfaces immersed in an inert liquid whose molecules were approximately spherical and of diameter 0.9 nm, octamethylcyclotetra siloxane or OMCTS. The idea was that this would not bond strongly to the mica surfaces (which anyway were contaminated with water and gas molecules), but would gradually be squeezed out of the way by the surfaces as they adhered together on close approach. The results shown in Fig. 6.14 indicate that the force of adhesion fluctuates significantly as each molecular layer is removed, revealing how the ordinary van der Waals forces are modulated by the molecular nature of the contamination. In conclusion, the surfaces cannot now jump together in one leap down the van der Waals curve; instead, the surfaces jump together in a number of steps which depend on the size of the contaminant molecules. In this case, the ultimate adhesion of the mica surfaces was weak, with an adhesion energy of This was beneficial because no damage was then seen on the mica surfaces and the experiment could be repeated time and time again. However, this low adhesion most likely was due to contaminant water molecules strongly bonded to the mica in the first mololayer. But the most significant result of this experiment, and of subsequent work by Horn and his colleagues23,24 on other solvent molecules, was the demonstration that the system could now sit stably at several different stages of adhesion, shown by the zero force points in Fig. 6.14. In other words, there is not just one single
CHAPTER 6
116
adhesive state between two surfaces. Several different states of adhesion can exist depending on how many layers of molecules have been squeezed out from the gap. This was a suggestion first put forward in 1973.25 Obviously, the primary and strongest adhesion will exist when the surfaces are in intimate molecular contact. One layer of foreign contaminant molecules will diminish adhesion by an order of magnitude. Further contaminant layers will diminish adhesion even more. It is clear from Fig. 6.14 that the size of the contaminant molecule is the most important factor in this argument, since the periodic jump distance was roughly equal to molecular diameter, larger molecules producing weaker adhesion. These results were confirmed on a number of other solvent systems, including benzene, cyclohexane and carbon tetrachloride, which all behave as fairly rigid spheres.26 Oscillations of attraction and repulsion were observed for up to ten molecular layers. With more flexible molecules, such as n-octane and 2,2,4-trimethyl pentane, the oscillations died faster, after about four molecular layers. Polar molecules, e.g. propylene carbonate or methanol, gave oscillations plus double-layer repulsions. But water was the most interesting solvent, which must be considered in more detail.
6.6. ADHESION WITH WATER PRESENT AT SURFACES Pashley and Israelachvili27,28 carried out a detailed study of mica surfaces approaching each other through water and dilute electrolyte solutions in an attempt to find “hydrate crystal layers.” These layers had been inferred from the structure of damp clay, which is known to swell in water and to have a distinct lubricious surface, quite different from normal oxides. In the 1930s such clay had been investigated by the X-ray diffraction method,29 which showed that the clay plates moved apart in water to distances of 0.25 and 0.55 nm, about the diameter of one or two layers of water molecules, as shown schematically in Fig. 6.15.
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
117
Thus water appeared to be “structured” near the surface of the oxide plates. However, this structuring of water was not easy to study and became a particularly controversial subject, especially when “polywater” was suggested around 1967 by Derjaguin and his followers,29 who found that water in silica capillaries became solidified, supposedly by long-range hydration structure forces. This spurious idea, which was supported by a number of research groups,30 was ultimately shown to be related to sodium and silica impurities dissolving through solution near the glass surfaces to give a gelling phenomenon in the water. Pashley found that the structural forces only extended about 1 nm from the surface and not the micrometer distances suggested by Derjaguin. Pashley at first could not see any structuring forces in his 1981 paper using 1 M KCl solutions. However, this was because of the behavior of his spring system in bringing the mica surfaces together. Once he investigated the gaps below 1 nm more closely, especially with dilute KCl, e.g. then he found the stepwise jumping of the surfaces corresponding to removal of water molecular layers, as shown in Fig. 6.16. Similar experiments on pure silica surfaces showed the same sort of repulsion near contact but there was no sign of the stepwise jumping effect.31 The measurements of force could only be conducted in the regions shown by the black lines in Fig. 6.16. These measurements showed steep repulsions. If too great a force of compression was applied, then the mica jumped closer by removing one layer of water molecules, onto the next black line, which was again steeply repulsive. Eventually, the mica surfaces made contact to give a work of adhesion of In addition to this molecular contact state, there were two other stable points of adhesion corresponding to one and two molecular layers of water between the mica, respectively. In Fig. 6.16, these stable states are pointed
118
CHAPTER 6
out by arrows. These were located at gaps which agreed reasonably with the hydrated layers found in clays, around 0.25 and 0.55 nm. When the mica plates were well separated, i.e. more than 2 nm apart, the results fitted the DLVO theory of double-layer repulsions corresponding to a potential of – 78 mV, which amounts to 40% coverage of the mica with positively charged potassium ions. These long-range forces were those previously measured by Adams and Israelachvili.17,18 Thus there appeared to be three types of force acting between the mica surfaces: the long-range DLVO forces acting from 5 nm out, to be considered in more detail in Chapter 10; intermediate range repulsion acting from 2–5 nm; and finally the oscillatory jumping behavior operating from contact out to 1.7 nm gaps. These close-in oscillatory forces in water have only been detected with extended mica surfaces. They do not seem to have been observed in the atomic force microscope studies which we consider next. 6.7. ADHESION OF WET SURFACES IN THE ATOMIC FORCE MICROSCOPE The presence of water at the contact between probe and substrate in the atomic force microscope (AFM) makes life easier by reducing adhesive force and preventing the vicious jumping together of the surfaces. This allows simple measurement of adhesion, together with the prospect of atomic resolution of the surfaces. One particular reason for studying surfaces under water is to observe the growth and dissolution of the crystal defects and growth spirals on the surface. This has been much addressed by Hansma and his associates at Santa Barbara who looked especially at calcite surfaces.32,33 They attached a fluid flow cell to the AFM as shown in Fig. 6.17 and then placed freshly cleaved “Iceland Spar,” pure calcium carbonate, under the tip.
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
119
The nature of the surface was observed as liquid was circulated continuously through the cell. The flow velocity had no effect on crystal growth, confirming that the growth was not diffusion limited at the flow rate employed. The crystal plane observed was the (1014) face which does not cross any of the strong covalent bonds, i.e. the C–O bonds, in the material. The images revealed the flat terraces of the crystal with spiral step patterns standing out from the surface, as shown below in Fig. 6.18. The terraces were flat at the molecular scale and growth occurred by movement of the steps outwards across the surface as described originally in the Burton, Cabrera and Frank model.34 The start of the spiral was seen to be a small pit in the surface, which was generally a screw dislocation. The spirals rotated as the steps grew and this rotation rate governed the growth rate. Measurements could readily be made of the step movement with time, Fig. 6.19(a) and of the effect of the supersaturation of the solution, Fig. 6.19(b). Typically the steps were monomolecular, i.e. 0.3 nm, and grew linearly with time at a few nm per second. The speed was independent of step spacing, showing that the adsorption on the terraces was not very influential, with a diffusion length < 2.5 nm. As the supersaturation increased, the step velocity rose rapidly, in proportion to the concentration. Dissolution of the spirals was also seen as the solution concentration was lowered. If the steps of the spiral were curved, they straightened as dissolution took place. This showed that the step velocity depended on orientation, with the slowest speed dominating. Any monomolecular islands on the surface disappeared very quickly, suggesting that growth on the terraces was not favorable without steps.
120
CHAPTER 6
In this wet calcite system, it was also possible to obtain atomic resolution using the AFM.33 This observation was followed up in detail by Ohnesorge and Binnig in 1993.35 They showed that the force on the probe tip was important if such atomic resolution was to be achieved. If the force exceeded 0.1 nN, then the tip would wipe away the steps and leave a perfectly flat and ordered crystal. To show the effect of the force on the atomic imaging, they moved the tip very sensitively towards the surface and produced scans showing the surface atoms as the tip position was changed above the surface. The first force could be detected at a separation of 1.2 nm between tip and crystal surface, when the cantilever force constant was A sharp tip of diameter 20 nm was used, giving a typical force curve as shown in Fig. 6.20. The zero point was chosen as the switchover from attraction to repulsion. Approach was seen to be slightly different from retraction, as shown by the
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
121
broken line, but there was no jumping instability and little hysteretic behavior. The force sensitivity of the cantilever was around 1 pN. This meant that the tip could be positioned to about 0.3 nm, where the maximum van der Waals attraction was 45 pN as expected between two single atoms at equilibrium separation. Therefore, only one or two atoms could have contributed to this force curve. This allowed the atomic resolution which was seen on scanning the tip across the sample. When the gap z was initially 1 nm, the scanning showed dark spots corresponding to the attractions of oxygen atoms protruding slightly from the crystal plane. These spots corresponded to the known positions of oxygen atoms in the crystal structure of calcium carbonate, shown in Fig. 6.21. As the tip was scanned nearer to the surface, gradually closing the gap, the oxygen atoms appeared as larger rounded blobs, which eventually lost contrast as the tip began to pick up forces from the other atoms. The initial contrast was as good as that obtained by scanning tunneling microscopy. The conclusion was that adhesion of wet calcite was small and well controlled, such that reversible adhesion curves could be obtained with a sharp AFM probe tip, giving atomic resolution of the surface oxygen atoms.
122
CHAPTER 6
6.8. INFLUENCE OF POLYMERS ON WET ADHESION Polymers in solution have an enormous effect on the adhesion between surfaces. Such polymers are used as lubricants, as thickeners, as colloid stabilisers, as binders, glues, and inks. Also they are ubiquitous in biological systems. Their practical significance is large but understanding their effects remains to be explored to a great extent. This section describes some experimental observations of the adhesion forces and draws a schematic theoretical picture of the effects. There are three kinds of polymer to be found dispersed in liquids; the first is the insoluble polymer colloid found in a latex dispersion, for example polyvinyl acetate used in latex glues, Fig. 6.22(a). This is essentially a suspension of plastic beads of very small size. If the polymer is slightly soluble, then the solvent penetrates into the polymer beads and swells them up, as shown in Fig. 6.22(b), so that the polymer chains begin to interact slightly with neighbouring chains. For very soluble polymers, the swelling is complete, as in Fig. 6.22(c), such that the chains intermingle fully and the solution thickens or gels. Polymers can be converted from highly soluble to slightly soluble by adding salt, by increasing polymer concentration, or by changing the temperature such that the solution “clouds.” This means that the polymer chains are balling up and expelling solvent. This occurs at the theta temperature. Polymers are therefore molecules whose size can change enormously as this swelling or shrinking occurs. The insoluble polymer bead may be l0 nm in diameter, but on swelling it can grow to 30 nm, while on full dissolution it can extend to 100 nm. This means that when the polymer molecules sit on a surface, the adhesive force can also vary substantially. An example of this effect was described by Klein36 who, in 1980, used the Israelachvili apparatus to measure polystyrene molecules at mica surfaces. At a temperature of 24° C where the polymer was not very soluble, the results shown in Fig. 6.23 were seen.
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
123
The high molecular weight polystyrene started to show an attraction between the surfaces just above one molecular diameter. As the molecules were compressed together a repulsion was then observed at a gap of about 20 nm. The lower molecular weight material behaved in somewhat similar fashion but with a repulsion at 8 nm gap. When the temperature was raised to 35°C, to give improved solvation of the polystyrene, the attraction was reduced by half. The results can be understood in terms of the forces between rubbery swollen polystyrene. As the layers approach, there is a van der Waals attraction, but the adsorbed particles then press into each other to give the repulsion (Fig. 6.24). The polymer is too strongly adherent for the adsorbed layer to be squeezed out by the compressive force. A key feature of long-chain polymer adsorption is the length of time needed to reach equilibrium. This was shown by Luckham and colleagues37 by studying the force of adhesion with time as the mica surfaces sat in a high molecular weight (1,120,000) polymer solution, polyethylene oxide in water. After 2–3 h in the solution, the mica showed a clear attraction, starting at a gap of l00 nm and
124
CHAPTER 6
reaching a maximum adhesion at 50 nm gap, as shown in Fig. 6.25. Smaller gaps gave a strong repulsion. After a longer period in the polymer solution, 6–8 h, the attraction disappeared and only repulsion was seen. After 48 h, the repulsion was strong and started at a gap of 200 nm. It was evident that equilibriation in the presence of a long-chain polymer was a lengthy business. A more practical way to study the interactions between oxide surfaces in polymer solutions is to use the Atomic Force Microscope (AFM). Milling, with his colleagues, has performed a series of experiments using a diameter silica sphere glued to the silicon nitride AFM cantilever, gradually brought towards a flat silica surface in solutions of polyelectrolyte, for example sodium polystyrene sulfonate or sodium polyacrylate. Well defined polymer samples were used to make sure all the molecules were of similar length, and the effects of polymer concentration and salt content were investigated.38–40 There was little hysteresis in these measurements under dilute conditions. A Nanoscope AFM from Digital Instruments was used because of its convenient wet cell arrangement. The spring constant of the cantilever, was measured by the resonance method as different known masses were added. The silica was cleaned by brief boiling in ammoniacal hydrogen peroxide solution, followed by washing in ultrapure water. Several molecular weights of sodium polyacrylate were used from 33 000 to 99 000. As expected, the higher molecular weight gave similar behaviour but at somewhat longer length scales. At a low polymer concentration of 39 ppm, there was an attraction with a minimum around separation, together with a repulsion at smaller gaps. However, at high concentrations, the minimum collapsed to a gap near with a much stronger attraction, followed by oscillatory behavior at larger separations (See Fig. 6.26). This oscillating behavior was very reminiscent of that observed with structured hydration layers described in Sections 6.5 and 6.6. It seemed like the polymer molecules were becoming compressed as the
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
125
concentration was increased (Fig. 6.27), and the oscillations represented the force required to squeeze each layer of molecules out from the gap. Putting electrolyte into the polymer solution had the same effect of collapsing the polymer molecules, again showing the oscillatory behavior. The theory of these effects has been considered by a number of authors. Early work41,42 suggested that rigid rod-like molecules could be excluded from between charged surfaces. More recently, a number of theorists have suggested structuring mechanisms in polymer solutions to explain the oscillatory forces.43,44 None of these seems entirely adequate to describe polyelectrolytes though some agreement has been reached on uncharged, nonadsorbing polymer solutions.45
126
CHAPTER 6
In conclusion, it is evident that the interface can easily be restructured by polymer molecules adhering to it in a rich variety of ways. This restructuring of surfaces is a general phenomenon which must be discussed next.
6.9. RESTRUCTURING OF SURFACES AND INTERFACES We are rather familiar with the effects that small amounts of additives can have on surfaces. For example, one part per million of carbon monoxide in a gas stream can poison a platinum catalyst surface and inhibit oxidation reactions. Similarly, five parts per million of potassium ferricyanide can stop the crystallization of sodium chloride from brine solution. The example given in the previous section is another illustration of such surface effects; a few parts per million of sodium polyacrylate can produce a repulsion between oxide surfaces, thus inhibiting adhesion. In adhesion studies, the first demonstration of this effect was by Lord Rayleigh, who showed in 1899 that a single layer of fatty acid at a surface could reduce surface tension, adhesion, and friction.46 Since that time there has been enormous effort to study the structure of surfaces and interfaces to understand these substantial phenomena. It has become clear over the past 50 years that clean solid surfaces have a different structure from the bulk, and that this difference in structure must depend on any impurities or adhering bodies brought down onto the surface. Several examples are described in Somorjai’s book.47 Consider the surface of a solid shown schematically in Fig. 6.28. There are two simple reconstructions that can take place: the first is a simple shrinking of the clean surface atoms into the bulk, as they are pulled in by the unbalanced atomic forces, rather like the surface tension effect in a liquid; the second is a reordering that can occur if the surface atoms can move from side to side, as in the (100) crystal face of silicon. Here the surface atoms are loosely packed and move both down and sideways in the two top layers, as shown in Fig. 6.28(b). So, clean surfaces tend to restructure to satisfy the unbalanced atomic forces. When foreign atoms adsorb onto such surfaces, further reconstruction is possible. For example, the chemisorption of contaminant atoms can destroy the clean surface reconstructions described above. Alternatively, new structures may form, as when carbon is chemisorbed on nickel (100) surfaces.47 If such carbon-coated surfaces were brought together in an adhesion experiment, the carbon would have to diffuse out before full Ni–Ni adhesion could be attained. Such diffusion and restructuring effects could explain the observed changes of adhesion with time. Also, hysteresis in adhesion values could then be accounted for. The importance of these interface structuring phenomena stems from the large number of possible adhesion states that could exist as different molecules are arranged at the surfaces. Little is known about the possible triggering or
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
127
switching mechanisms that could arise from these structures. Two simple examples are shown in Fig. 6.29. In the first example, surfactant molecules are placed on a surface but at low concentration. The surfactant is van der Waals bonded and so sits flat on the surface. However, when the concentration of the molecules is increased, the molecules are forced to stand upright and so reduce the adhesion significantly by separating the surfaces by the extra chain length. In the second example, reported by Joyce and colleagues,48 molecules were adsorbed onto a gold surface. As the
CHAPTER 6
128
molecular layer was probed with the AFM, there was a gradual change in the apparent length of the molecule. This was interpreted as a restructuring of the surfactant at the surface. Such effects may allow us to control adhesion at interfaces artificially in future, by writing controlled structures.
6.10. THE NANOSCALE FOUNTAIN PEN Writing or painting is one of the oldest adhesive technologies known to man, dating back 4000 years.49 It involves dipping a stick or brush in an ink, then transferring the ink to paper by capillary forces. Until recently, the finest writing tips and nibs have been hundreds of micrometers in diameter. But now a method for writing with nano-tips has been developed, enabling lines to be drawn at the 30 nanometre scale.50,51 Thus it becomes possible to restructure real surfaces artificially at the molecular level. The principle is shown in Fig. 6.30, illustrating how the invention arose from the perennial problem of capillary condensation in the fine gap between tip and surface. An atomic force microscope (AFM) tip is positioned close to a flat gold substrate. If the air is damp, then moisture appears in the very fine capillary gap and this strongly influences the probe, causing imaging problems.52 But this water can also be useful in allowing organic molecules to move from the tip onto the substrate. In a typical experiment,53 a silicon nitride tip was dipped into a solution of 1-octadecanethiol in acetonitrile for 1 min, followed by blow drying with difluoroethane. The tip was then brought down onto the substrate at 45% relative humidity, where a meniscus is known to form, and left in contact for 2 min. The substrate was made by evaporating 30 nm of polycrystalline gold onto a cleaved mica sheet. After removing the tip, the image could be scanned by lateral force microscopy, detecting the change in frictional conditions on the substrate where
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION
129
the organic molecules were deposited. It was evident that some of the octadecanethiol had migrated onto the gold, forming a disc about 400 nm in diameter, as shown in Fig. 6.3l (a). At longer times, the discs got bigger as more molecules transferred. By moving the tip along the surface, a line 100 nm wide was formed, allowing a grid to be traced out, Fig. 6.31(b). To obtain good shapes it was important for the substrate to be as smooth as possible. Therefore, the gold film was annealed for 3 h at 300°C to give (111) planes of gold on the mica substrate. The molecules of octadecanethiol were then found to adhere strongly to this substrate in an ordered monolayer with spacing of 0.5 nm, in good agreement with previous studies.53 The ink was then stable on the surface and was not damaged as the lateral force probe moved across it to measure the pattern. The finest line width achieved was 15 nm from a l0 nm probe tip. In a further development of this novel writing process, Mirkin and his colleagues went on to produce a “two color” writing process at the nanometer level.54 This process depended on the fact that the layer of molecules adhered strongly to the gold and was not washed off by a second pass of the probe with its water meniscus. 16-mercaptohexadecanoic acid was chosen as the first ink. This was drawn into polygon shapes on a gold surface, and could be seen as a high friction track by lateral force AFM. The probe was then changed to an octadecanethiol coated tip and this was used to overwrite the first pattern in a square raster. Finally the surface was scanned to show that the two patterns had not interacted during the writing, as indicated in Fig. 6.32. The mercaptohexadecanoic acid gave a white contrast due to high friction, showing the polygon shapes, whereas the octadecanethiol gave a low friction shown as a dark square background. Gold itself gave intermediate friction. The conclusion was that nanostructures could be produced by AFM probes writing
CHAPTER 6
130
with molecular inks, to form ordered monolayer patterns. These could be used to control adhesion very finely.
6.11. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27.
Newton, I., Opticks, Smith and Walford, London 1704 (reprinted Dover, New York, 1952, p 371). Newton, I., Opticks, Smith and Walford, London 1704 (reprinted Dover, New York, 1952, p 197). Obreimoff, J.W., Proc. R. Soc. A 127, 290–97 (1930). Stone, W., Phil. Mag. 9, 610–14 (1930). Tomlinson, G.A., Phil. Mag. 10, 541–4 (1930). Tomlinson, G.A., Phil. Mag. 6, 695–8 (1928). Bailey, A.I. and Kay, S.M., Proc. R. Soc. A 301, 47–56 (1967). Owen, M.J. and Jones, D., In: Polymer Materials Encyclopaedia, ed. J.C. Salamone, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL 1996, p 7688. Release agents In: Encyclopaedia of Polymer Science and Engineering, 2nd Edn, Wiley Interscience, New York, 1988, vol 14, p 4 1 1 . Johnson, K.L., Kendall, K. and Roberts, A.D., Proc. R. Soc. A 324, 301–313 (1971). Kendall, K., Contemp. Phys. 21, 277–97 (1980). Roberts, A.D. and Tabor, D., Proc. R. Soc. A 325, 323–45 (1971). Blok, H. and Koens, H.J., Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. 180, 221 (1965). Chaudhury, M.K. and Whitesides, G.M., Science 255, 1230–2 (1993). Chaudhury, M.K., and Whitesides, G.M., Langmuir 7, 1013–25 (1991). Kendall, K., Sci. Prog. Oxf. 72, 155–71 (1988). See also Young, T., Phil. Trans. R. Soc 95, 65–87 (1805). Israelachvili, J.N. and Adams, G.E., Nature 262, 774–6 (1976). Israelachvili, J.N. and Adams, G.E., J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 74, 975–1001 (1978). Langmuir, I., Science 88, 430–2 (1938). Bowden, F.P. and Hughes, T.P., Proc. R. Soc. A 172, 263–9 (1939). Bowden, F.P. and Hanwell, A.E., Proc. R. Soc. A 295, 233–43 (1966). Horn, R.G. and Israelachvili, J.N., J. Chem. Phys. 75, 1400–11 (1981). Christenson, H.K. and Horn, R.G., Chem. Phys. Lett. 98, 45–8 (1983). Horn, R.G., Biochim. Biophys. Acta 778, 224–8 (1984). Kendall, K., J Adhesion 5, 179–202 (1973). Israelachvili, J.N., Intermolecular and Surface Forces, Academic Press, London 1985 pp 198–201. Pashley, R.M. and Israelachvili, J.N., J. Colloid Interface Sci. 101, 511–23 (1984).
CONTAMINATION REDUCES ADHESION 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47.
48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54.
131
Israelachvili, J.N. and Pashley, R.M., Nature 306, 249–50 (1983). Derjaguin, B.V and Churaev, N.V., Nature 244, 430–1 (1973). Lippincott, E.R., Stromberg, P.R., Grant, W.H. and Cessac, G.L., Science 164, 1482–7 (1969). Grabbe, A. and Horn, G.R., J. Colloid Interface Sci. 157, 375–83 (1993). Gratz, A.J., Hillner, P.E. and Hansma, P.K., Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 57, 491–5 (1993). Hillner, P.E., Manne, S., Gratz, A.J. and Hansma, P.K., Ultramicroscopy 42–44, 1387–93 (1992). Burton, W.K., Cabrera, N. and Frank, F.C., Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 243, 299–358 (1951). Ohnesorge, F. and Binnig, G., Science 260, 1451–6 (1993). Klein, J., Nature 288, 248–250 (1982). Luckham, P.F. and Klein, J., J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 86, 1363–8 (1990). Milling, A.J., J. Phys. Chem. 100, 8986–93 (1996). Milling, A.J. and Vincent, B., J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 93, 3179–83 (1997). Milling, A.J. and Kendall, K., in press (2000). Hoagland, D.A., Macromolecules 23, 2781 (1990). Scheujens, J.M.H.M. and Fleer, G.J., J. Phys. Chem. 84, 178 (1980). Chattellier, X. and Joanny, J-F., J. Physique II 6, 1990 (1996). Dahlgren, M.A.G. and Leermakers, F.A.M., Langmuir 11, 2996 (1995). Fleer, G.J., Scheutjens, J.M.H.M., Cohen-Stuart, M.A., Cosgrove, T. and Vincent, B., Polymers at Interfaces, Chapman and Hall, London (1993). Strutt, W. (Lord Rayleigh), Phil. Mag. 48, 331–5 (1899). Somorjai, G.A., Introduction to Surface Chemistry and Catalysis, John Wiley, New York, 1994, chapters 2 and 6. Joyce, S.A., Thomas, R.C., Houston, J.F., Michalske, T.A. and Crooks, R.M., Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 2790 (1992). Ewing, A.C., The Fountain Pen: A Collectors Companion, Running Press, Philadelphia, PA 1997. Hong, S., Zhu, J. and Mirkin, C.A., Science 286, 523–5 (1999). Jackman, R.J., Wilbur, J.L. and Whitesides, G.M., Science 269, 664–5 (1995). Binggeli, M. and Mate, C.M., Appl. Phys. Lett. 65, 415 (1994). Piner, R.D., Zhu, J., Xu, F., Hong, S. and Mirkin, C.A., Science 283, 661–6 (1999). Alves, C.A., Smith, E.L. and Porter, M.D., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 114, 1222 (1992).
7 INFLUENCE OF THE ADHESION AND FRACTURE MECHANISM: THE THIRD LAW
The Attractions of Gravity, Magnetism and Electricity reach to very sensible distances and so have been observed by vulgar Eyes, and there may be others which reach to so small distances as hitherto escape Observation ISAAC NEWTON, Opticks,1 p. 376
We have seen in the previous chapters that adhesion phenomena can be explained generally by two fundamental laws: the first is that all objects jump together as a result of universal atomic and molecular attractions; the second is the effect of intervening contaminant atoms which reduce the molecular attraction, often causing ‘jumping in steps’ as each contaminating molecular layer is squeezed out. However, there is still a significant problem of understanding adhesion effects, because the adhesive forces are so short-range, as Newton recognized above, that the two basic laws of adhesion may be obscured by other mechanisms such as Brownian motion, cracking, elastic deformation, roughness, energy dissipation, etc. which can alter the adhesion by many orders of magnitude. For example, a surface roughness of only ten nanometers may be sufficient to stop bodies adhering. Such roughness has no effect on gravitational, magnetic, or electrostatic attraction; indeed, such surfaces look highly smooth and polished to the unaided eye. The purpose of this chapter is to describe some of these adhesion mechanisms, especially starting with the Brownian and cracking mechanisms, then leading on to a whole range of subsidiary mechanisms which make adhesion 133
134
CHAPTER 7
science so interesting. The conclusion is that the mechanism can alter the measured adhesion value by an enormous amount, even though the atomic or molecular adhesion remains the same. This is the third law of adhesion.
7.1. PROBLEM OF THE WIDE RANGE OF ADHESION ENERGY VALUES The fundamental problem of adhesion measurement is that the measured energies required to break interfaces apart are too wide-ranging when compared to theory. If adhesion energy R is defined as the experimental energy measured to break 1 of interface, then measurements show that this adhesion energy can range from negative values, where joints fail spontaneously when immersed in liquid, to very small values when colloidal particles remain separate and stable for long periods, to the very large values of needed in engineering adhesive joints which hold aircraft together. The values of the theoretical molecular bond energies, i.e. equilibrium work of adhesion W, occupy only a small range from and cannot possibly explain the full scale of measured adhesion. These values are plotted in Fig. 7.1, and we can see immediately that we need two logarithmic scales to describe the results, one for attractions and another for repulsion. How can this extraordinary range of values be explained?2,3 It is evident from this diagram that the adhesive world would be very boring if simple atomic or molecular bonding under clean conditions were the only thing that could happen. The fact is that simple, clean chemical bonding can only explain the range of adhesion energies from around Contamination of the surfaces by foreign molecules can then explain reductions in adhesion as shown in Chapter 6. Further contamination can also be the source of negative, in other words repulsive, adhesion which pushes joints apart spontaneously, again described in Chapter 6 and also later in Chapter 10. To explain the wide adhesion variations shown in Fig. 7.1 we have to introduce some other mechanisms, giving us the third law of adhesion. Some of these are very obvious and have been mentioned earlier, for example, roughness
INFLUENCE OF THE ADHESION AND FRACTURE MECHANISM
135
which creates gaps between atoms on the surface, thereby reducing adhesion immensely; cracking which allows joints to break easily; and elastic deformations which cause atoms to be pushed closer to each other as forces are applied during compaction, thus increasing atomic contact and adhesion. However, there is a severe problem explaining the high values of adhesion which are necessary for engineering applications. These high values are described in more detail in Chapters 13–16. We have to introduce some amplification mechanisms if we are to explain such values rationally. These amplification mechanisms can operate at the molecular scale or at the macroscopic level. It is the variety of these subtle mechanisms which makes the subject of adhesion so fascinating, both to chemists who wish to consider molecules, and to engineers who think in terms of continuum mechanics. Thus the third law of adhesion, that mechanisms can change the measured adhesion enormously, even though molecular adhesion remains constant, is a most significant and ill-understood law.
7.2. HIERARCHY OF MECHANISMS CONTROLLING ADHESION To obtain a convincing picture of adhesion phenomena, it is important to construct a hierarchy of mechanisms, with the most fundamental effects at the top, leading to the additional mechanisms below. This is shown in Fig. 7.2. In this diagram, it becomes easier to identify the fallacious arguments which are often produced to explain adhesion effects. For example, chemists are prone to explain joint strengths in terms of strong chemical bonding and are puzzled by the difficulties encountered in sticking strongly bonded substances like diamond together. The problem with strong covalent bonding is that the joint is brittle and fails readily by cracking, thus making it appear fragile. By contrast, weak bonding of chewing gum to a carpet can lead to persistent and tough adhesion because of
CHAPTER 7
136
the large plastic deformation needed to stretch the viscoelastic gum. So strong or weak bonding in themselves cannot explain adhesion phenomena satisfactorily; we need to invoke the hierarchy of mechanisms. At the top of the hierarchy is the most basic cause of adhesion, i.e., the energy required to break molecular bonds. This can be overcome most simply by heating the joint to melt or vaporize the bonds; or the energy can be provided by dissolving the bond chemically; or it can be done by applying a force to break the bond mechanically. In second place in the hierarchy is the effect of contamination in reducing adhesion energy. As shown in Chapter 6, contamination of the surfaces by wetting liquids and other adhering molecules must reduce adhesion. If wetting is complete, then repulsive forces may be observed. Third place down the hierarchy belongs to the well-known mechanisms of Brownian debonding and cracking failure. Lower still are elastic deformation and roughness effects. These are the mechanisms to be considered in this chapter. All these illustrate the third law, that the mechanism can strongly influence adhesion, while keeping the molecular situation constant. Finally we come to the more complex mechanisms which will be considered in Chapter 8, the inelastic effects, the nonequilibrium phenomena, and plasticity of surfaces leading to observations of stringing, aggregation, etc. Clearly, these mechanisms and sub-mechanisms can then be further combined to give even greater complexity and richness of effects. First, let us consider the basic mechanisms and work our way down this hierarchy.
7.3. THE SIMPLEST FAILURE OF ADHESION Consider the simple melting failure of an adhesive joint as shown in Fig. 7.3. The joint was made by taking a plate of smooth glass, placing a large drop of water upon it, then laying a strip of polyethylene polymer onto the surface of the
INFLUENCE OF THE ADHESION AND FRACTURE MECHANISM
137
water. The contact angle of water on the polymer surface was about 90° so that no adhesive capillary forces were observed. The joint was then reduced in temperature so that the water froze. The polythene adhered to the ice below the freezing point, giving a peeling force of about 100 mN for a strip width of 10 mm. However, above the melting point, the polymer was released from the water easily with little resistance, about 1 mN. This idea, that a liquid can be frozen onto a solid surface to produce a useful adhesive bonding, is one of the most powerful in adhesion technology; it is the thermoplastic adhesive method. It is worth considering the mechanism of this change in adhesion as the joint melts. The magnified view of the breaking point is shown in Fig. 7.4. When the water is liquid, the contact angle is almost 90° and as the plastic film is pulled, the water rolls back to leave a clean polymer surface. This process has very little viscous resistance and so the force required to pull the film from the liquid is all being used to create a new water surface. In other words the force is equivalent to the surface energy (i.e. surface tension) of water which is giving 0.72 mN for a 10 mm wide strip, a very small force. When the water is frozen, this process is not possible, and now the adhesion fails by propagation of a crack which can be seen moving to separate the ice and the plastic film. There is now quite a bit of resistance to this crack propagation and this is the cause of the increase in force. The energy changes which apply in this case are somewhat different and are treated later in Section 7.7. This process of freezing and melting the joint was quite reversible. It was obvious that mechanical forces did not play any part in destroying the adhesion between the pieces as the joint was melted. Clearly, therefore, mechanical stresses are not the most fundamental cause of adhesion failure in this instance. Adhesive joints fail when the molecular bonding is reduced by melting.
CHAPTER 7
138
7.4. CHEMICAL BREAKAGE OF ADHESIVE JOINTS In another simple test of adhesion shown in Fig. 7.4, a thin film of epoxy resin was polymerized onto a glass surface, and the adhesion was good. The film required considerable force to wedge it off the glass surface. However, when water was placed at the contact edge between epoxy and glass, the adhesion between epoxy and glass was soon reduced to a very low value, such that the epoxy film floated away from the glass surface. Observation in the optical microscope showed that a film of water intruded at the interface between epoxy and glass, moving inwards from the outside edge, and gradually lifting off the polymer. Essentially, the adhesive bond between epoxy and glass had been dissolved by the water without the application of any external force. Again, it is evident that mechanical force is not always the main cause of breakage for adhesive joints. In this case, the joint is separated by a chemical process. In terms of energies, this is quite easy to understand. The work of adhesion of the fluid epoxy to the glass under “dry” conditions is approximately This is large enough for the liquid epoxy to wet the glass when forming the joint to make molecular contact. Then the polymerization process solidifies the resin, thus forming a solid bond with the glass. Of course, the glass surface at the molecular level is not truly dry because it has reacted with any water vapor around in the atmosphere to form a thin surface layer of hydroxyl groups. However, when liquid water is allowed near the glass surface, the water molecules strongly wet the glass to form a thick layer of water, as described in Section 6.6, and this produces repulsive forces which push the epoxy off the glass. The work of adhesion between epoxy and glass is negative under these conditions and so the adhesive bond falls apart spontaneously. Expressed in terms of the equation given in Fig. 6.7,
INFLUENCE OF THE ADHESION AND FRACTURE MECHANISM
139
where we now distinguish the wetting angles of the two different surfaces of the joint. The work of adhesion of the dry joint, is now exceeded by the wetting energy of the water on the glass, and so the wet joint has a negative energy, and so must come apart. This shows that adhesive joints must be treated with great caution where contamination with wetting molecules is possible, because such contaminants can essentially dissolve the adhesive bond. In practice, treatments of the glass to make it less reactive to water are applied and these can then give good moisture resistance, as described in Section 16.10. From these arguments, we see that adhesion is essentially a chemical process where the bonds can be broken by heating or chemical attack. The bonds pull themselves apart by Brownian motion, without the need for mechanical force.
7.5. BROWNIAN ADHESION The idea that molecules are involved in the adhesion process tells us that Brownian movement must be important. All molecules are in random motion. In fluids, the molecules wander around at great speeds in all directions, whereas in solids, the motion is tethered but the localized vibrations are still important. This means that an adhesive contact must not be viewed as a statical concept but as a dynamic one. Unfortunately, most books on adhesion fail to mention Brownian movement.4 A useful exercise is to compare the situation in which a liquid drop sits on a polymer surface with that of a smooth rubber sphere adhering to a glass plate, as in Fig. 7.6. Figure 7.6(a) shows a liquid drop which, to the naked eye, looks static and in a stable wetting equilibrium. However, microscopic examination of the liquid
140
CHAPTER 7
near the contact, where we can insert some tiny latex spheres as markers, reveals a seething motion of the liquid molecules as they evaporate, diffuse across the surface, and leap back into the droplet, moving randomly in all directions. The situation in the rubber sphere, Fig. 7.6(b) is similar in that the rubber molecules are all waving around in continuous motion. However, the molecules in this rubber case are linked together to form an elastic body rather than a liquid one. But each rubber molecule, as depicted in Fig. 7.6(c), can continually make and break contact with the glass. So, although the contact appears to be constant in size, it is actually expanding and contracting very rapidly, attaining a thermal equilibrium in which the rate of expansion of the contact is equal to the rate of contraction. This is the equilibrium model of contact which we established in Sections 3.3 and 3.4. Of course, for this to be valid, the adhesion bond energies of the molecules have to be around kT, in other words rather weakly adhering. Brownian adhesion occurs at very small dimensions, from 0.1–1000 nm, where thermal diffusion is dominant. Because of the small sizes, Brownian adhesion is difficult to observe experimentally, but it can be seen with small dispersed particles such as colloids and blood cells, for example (see Chapters 10 and 12). One result from this theory is that fine particles will stick together to form doublets whose number depends on the interparticle adhesion.5,6 Consider a number of fine particles immersed in dispersing fluid and undergoing Brownian motion in a box as in Fig. 7.7(a). With zero adhesion, no doublets should form. However, adhesion causes doublets to develop, as in Fig. 7.7. The number of doublets divided by the total number of particles is related to the adhesion in a definite way, according to statistical mechanics.7 In a dilute system, the ratio of doublets to singlets can be calculated if simplifying
INFLUENCE OF THE ADHESION AND FRACTURE MECHANISM
141
assumptions are made about the two-parameter model of adhesion forces, as defined in Chapter 5. This theory gives a straight line dependence of doublets on packing fraction of particles, as in Fig. 7.7(b). As the adhesion increases, more doublets must be observed. This fits experimental results.5 One conclusion of this theory is that adhesive bonds between bodies are not permanent but are random, depending on parameters such as adhesion energy, range of forces, temperature, and concentration. You do not need to pull things apart to test their adhesion. In the Brownian example, adhesive bonds are being made continually, and at equilibrium they are being broken equally fast. By altering the conditions we merely push the equilibrium one way or the other. For example, more particles could be made to adhere by putting more particles into the box, thus increasing the concentration. Conversely, the doublets could also be fractured by taking particles out of the box. This dilution must break doublets apart, as shown in Fig. 7.7(b).
7.6. THE CRACKING MECHANISM When we first think of adhesion experiments, we imagine that we can carry out the sort of tests shown schematically in physical chemistry textbooks, as shown in Fig. 7.8(a), in order to measure the surface forces as the bodies approach and begin to adhere. This was the experiment of Tabor and Winterton, and of Israelachvili.8,9 In fact, they could only obtain gaps down to around 20 nm by this means. Remembering that 99% of adhesion energy is below 1 nm, we know that full molecular adhesion was not being measured in those tests. In practice, this idealized experiment is impossible because, when the surfaces get close together, the adhesion force increases very rapidly and an instability occurs such that the surfaces jump into contact. Essentially, the adhesion force is so strong that it overcomes the elastic resistance of the materials. So the situation shown in Fig. 7.8(b) cannot exist; instead, the system goes to the position shown in Fig. 7.8(c), however much we try to control the positions of the surfaces. This is the crack geometry. Molecular contact is made over part of the surface, and there is no contact over the rest of the bodies.
142
CHAPTER 7
This elastic cracking mechanism is very common in adhesion studies, except when adhesion is much weakened by contamination. It allows us to make two excellent advances: the first is the experimental one of seeing the adhesion experimentally by optical interference; the second is the theoretical approximation that adhesion is perfect on one side of the crack line and zero on the other. This is the fundamental premise of fracture mechanics explained in the next section, allowing the use of a one parameter model. Almost all our knowledge of adhesion, in the days before atomic force microscopes, has been derived from the optical study of cracks at adhesive interfaces. From Newton onwards, through Obreimoff, Tabor and his followers, the direct viewing of the contact spot and its surrounding crack has been the key to adhesion measurement. Figure 7.9 shows the basic measurement technique. The upper part shows the light rays being reflected from the crack surfaces as first explained by Newton, while the lower part shows the appearance looking down at the crack front. Cracks have been seen in this way from ancient times as beautiful colored regions inside glass, for example, by Vitruvius. 10 The reason for the visibility of cracks is seen in Fig. 7.9. A light source shining on an adhesive joint is not much reflected at the adhesive interface, because the difference in refractive index at the interface is not large. Therefore, in reflection the adhered interface looks dark