Molecular Systematics of Fishes
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Molecular Systematics Fishes Edited by
Thomas D...
246 downloads
2768 Views
25MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Molecular Systematics of Fishes
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Molecular Systematics Fishes Edited by
Thomas D. Kocher Department of Zoology University of New Hampshire Durham, New Hampshire
Carol A. Stepien Department of Biology Case Western Reserve University Cleveland, Ohio
Academic Press San Diego London Boston New York Sydney Tokyo Toronto
This book is printed on acid-free paper. ( ~
Copyright 9 1997 by ACADEMIC PRESS All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. A c a d e m i c Press a division o f Harcourt Brace & Company
525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, California 92101-4495, USA http://www.apnet.com Academic Press Limited 24-28 Oval Road, London NW 1 7DX, UK http://www.hbuk.co.uk/ap/ Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Molecular systematics of fishes / edited by Thomas D. Kocher, Carol A. Stepien. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-12-417540-6 (alk. paper) 1. Fishes--Phylogeny. 2. Fishes--Molecular aspects. I. Kocher, Thomas D. II. Stepien, Carol A. QL618.2.M65 1997 96-49199 597.13'8--dc21 CIP
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 97 98 99 00 01 02 EB 9 8 7 6 5
4
3
2
1
Contents
Contributors Preface xi
ix
CHAPTER
3 CHAPTER
1 Molecules and Morphology in Studies of Fish Evolution Carol A. S tepien and Thomas D. Kocher
I. II. III. IV.
Introduction 1 History of Molecular Techniques 2 Controversy over Analytical Methods 5 Achievements and Failures of Molecular Systematics 7 V. Eight Promising Directions for Future Research 8 VI. A New Age of Synthesis 9 References 9
Molecular Systematics of a Rapidly Evolving Species Flock: The mbuna of Lake Malawi and the Search for Phylogenetic Signal Irv Kornfield and Alex Parker
I. Introduction 25 II. Molecular Investigations 26 III. Mitochondrial DNA and Ancestral Polymorphisms 26 IV. Alternate Molecular Approaches 27 V. Microsatellite Loci 28 VI. A Test of the Phylogenetic Potential of Microsatellites 29 VII. Materials and Methods 31 VIII. Results 32 IX. Discussion 33 X. Summary 35 References 35
CHAPTER
2
CHAPTER
Base Substitution in Fish Mitochondrial DNA: Patterns and Rates
4
Thomas D. Kocher and Karen L. Carleton
Reconstruction of Cichlid Phylogeny Using Nuclear DNA Markers
I. II. III. IV.
Introduction 13 Simple Models of Substitution 13 Evolution of Real Sequences 15 Implications for Phylogenetic Reconstruction 19 V. Conclusions 23 References 24
Holger S~iltmann and Werner E. Mayer I. Introduction 39 II. Methods Used for Reconstructing Cichlid Phylogeny 40 III. Random Amplification of Polymorphic DNA (RAPD) 41
vi
CONTENTS
IV. Allele Size Frequencies at Dinucleotide Microsatellite Loci 45 V. Critical Evaluation Using RAPD and Microsatellite Allele Frequencies for the Reconstruction of Cichlid Fish Phylogeny References 49
CHAPTER
7 47
Phylogeographic Patterns in Populations of Cichlid Fishes from Rocky Habitats in Lake Tanganyika Christian Sturmbauer, Erik Verheyen, Lukas R~iber and Axel Meyer
CHAPTER
5 Biogeographic Analysis of Pacific Trout
(Oncorhynchusmykiss) in California and Mexico Based on Mitochondrial DNA and Nuclear Microsatellites Jennifer L. Nielsen, Monique C. Fountain and Jonathan M. Wright
I. Lake Tanganyika and Its Cichlid Species Flock 97 II. Speciation and DNA 98 III. From Patterns toward an Understanding of Processes 105 IV. Conclusions 109 References 109
CHAPTER
8 Fish Biogeography and Molecular Clocks: Perspectives from the Panamanian Isthmus
I. II. III. IV.
Introduction 53 Materials and Methods Results 57 Discussion 64 References 66 Appendices 70
Eldredge Bermingham, S. Shawn McCafferty and Andrew P. Martin
55
I. Introduction 113 II. Temporal Scaling: The Panama Isthmus and Molecular Clocks 114 III. Geographic Scaling: The Panama Isthmus and Caribbean Fish 119 IV. Geographic Scaling: The Panama Isthmus and the Circumtropical Abudefduf (Teleostei: Pomacentridae) Species Group 121 V. Geographic Scaling: The Panama Isthmus and Neotropical Freshwater Fishes 123 VI. Concluding Remarks 125 References 126
CHAPTER
6 Mitochondrial DNA Sequence Variation among the Sand Darters (Percidae: Teleostei) E. O. Wiley and Robert H. Hagen
I. II. III. IV. V. VI.
Introduction 75 Systematics of Sand Darters Methods and Materials 78 Results 78 Discussion 91 Summary 94 References 94 Appendices 96
76
CHAPTER
9 The Utility of Mitochondrial DNA Control Region Sequences for Analyzing Phylogenetic Relationships among Populations, Species, and Genera of the Percidae Joseph E. Faber and Carol A. S tepien
I. Introduction 129 II. Materials and Methods
131
CONTENTS
III. Results 133 IV. Discussion 137 V. Material Examined References 140
140
vii
III. IV. V. VI. VII.
Allozymes and DNA 191 Fish Samples 191 DNA Sequences 191 Phylogenetic Relationships Conclusion 195 References 195
193
CHAPTER
10 Phylogenetic Relationships among the Salmoninae Based on Nuclear and Mitochondrial DNA Sequences Ruth B. Phillips and Todd H. Oakley
CHAPTER
13 Interrelationships of Lamniform Sharks: Testing Phylogenetic Hypotheses with Sequence Data Gavin J. P. Naylor, Andrew P. Martin, Erik G. Mattison and Wesley M. Brown
I. Introduction 145 II. Conclusions 158 References 159
CHAPTER
11
I. Introduction 199 II. Materials and Methods III. Results and Discussion References 216 Appendix 218
Combining Molecular and Morphological Data in Fish Systematics: Examples from the Cyprinodontiformes
CHAPTER
14
Alex Parker
I. II. III. IV. v. VI. VII. VIII. IX.
Introduction 163 Analysis of Combined Data: Justification 164 Analysis of Combined Data: Methods 165 Consensus Approaches: Justification 166 Consensus Methods 166 Analysis of Cyprinodontiform Data 167 Methods 167 Results and Discussion 170 Conclusions 181 References 182 Appendices 184
202 204
Radiation of Characiform Fishes: Evidence from Mitochondrial and Nuclear DNA Sequences Guillermo Ortf
I. Introduction 219 II. Materials and Methods III. Results and Discussion References 240 Appendix 242
222 222
CHAPTER
15
CHAPTER
12 Molecular Phylogeny of the Fundulidae (Teleostei, Cyprinodontiformes) Based on the Cytochrome b Gene Giacomo Bernardi
I. Introduction 189 II. Morphology
190
The Evolution of Blennioid Fishes Based on an Analysis of Mitochondrial 12S rDNA Carol A. Stepien, Alison K. Dillon, Meriel J. Brooks, Kristen L. Chase and Allyson N. Hubers
I. II. III. IV.
Introduction 245 Materials and Methods Results 253 Discussion 258
250
viii
CONTENTS
V. Summary 267 References 268
VII. Conclusion 279 References 281
CHAPTER
CHAPTER
16
17
Major Histocompatibility Complex Genes in the Study of Fish Phylogeny
The Phylogenetic Utility of the Mitochondrial Cytochrome b Gene for Inferring Relationships among Actinopterygian Fishes
Jan Klein, Dagmar Klein, Felipe Figueroa, Akie Sato and Colin O'hUigin I. Introduction 271 II. Major Histocompatibility Complex (Mhc) Structure and Function 271 III. Mhc as a Source of Systematic Information 273 IV. Sequences as a Source of Phylogenetic and Systematic Information 273 V. Cladistic Analysis with Macromutations 275 VI. Mhc Gene Frequencies in Populations Undergoing Adaptive Radiation 276
Charles Lydeard and Kevin J. Roe I. Introduction 285 II. Materials and Methods III. Results and Discussion References 300 Taxonomic Index 305 Subject Index 311
288 289
Contributors
Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors' contributions begin.
Allyson N. Hubers (245) Department of Biology, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio 44106.
Eldredge Bermingham (113) Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, Balboa, Republic of Panama.
Dagmar Klein (271) Department of Microbiology and
Immunology, University of Miami School of Medicine, Miami, Florida 33136.
Giacomo Bernardi (189) Department of Biology, University of California, Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz, California 95064.
Jan Klein (271) Max-Planck-Institut ftir Biologie, Ab-
teilung Immungenetik, D-72076 Ttibingen, Germany and Department of Microbiology and Immunology, University of Miami School of Medicine, Miami, Florida 33136.
Meriel J. Brooks (245) Department of Science, Notre Dame College, South Euclid, Ohio 44121. Wesley M. Brown (199) Department of Biology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109.
Thomas D. Kocher (1,13) Department of Zoology, University of New Hampshire, Durham, New Hampshire 03824.
Karen L. Carleton (13) Department of Zoology, University of New Hampshire, Durham, New Hampshire 03824.
Irv Kornfield (25) Department of Zoology and School of Marine Sciences, University of Maine, Orono, Maine 04469.
Kristen L. Chase (245) Department of Biology, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio 44106.
Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio 44106.
Charles Lydeard (285) Aquatic Biology Program, University of Alabama, Department of Biological Sciences, Tuscaloosa, Alabama 35487.
Joseph E. Faber (129) Department of Biology, Case
Andrew P. Martin (113,199) Smithsonian Tropical Re-
Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio 44106.
search Institute, Balboa, Republic of Panama and Department of Biological Sciences, University of Nevada Las Vegas, Las Vegas, Nevada 89154.
Alison K. Dillon (245) Department of Biology, Case
Felipe Figueroa (271) Max-Planck-Institut ftir Biologie, Abteilung Immungenetik, D-72076 Ttibingen, Germany.
Erik G. Mattison (199) Department of Biology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109.
Monique C. Fountain (53) USDA Forest Service, Pa-
cific Southwest Research Station and Hopkins Marine Station, Department of Biology, Stanford University, Pacific Grove, California 93950.
Werner E. Mayer (39) Max-Planck-Institut ftir Bio-
Robert H. Hagan (75) Department of Entomology, University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas 66045.
S. Shawn McCafferty (113) Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, Balboa, Republic of Panama.
logie, Abteilung Immungenetik, D-72076 Ttibingen, Germany.
ix
x
CONTRIBUTORS
Axel Meyer (97) Department of Ecology and Evolution, State University of New York at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, New York 11794.
Kevin J. Roe (285) Aquatic Biology Program, University of Alabama, Department of Biological Sciences, Tuscaloosa, Alabama 35487.
Gavin J. P. Naylor (199) Department of Biology, Osborn Memorial Laboratory, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520.
Lukas Riiber (97) Zoological Museum of the University of Zfirich, Switzerland.
Jennifer L. Nielsen (53) USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station and Hopkins Marine Station, Department of Biology, Stanford University, Pacific Grove, California 93950.
Akie Sato (271) Max-Planck-Institut ftir Biologie, Abteilung Immungenetik, D-72076 Ttibingen, Germany. Carol A. Stepien (1,129,245) Department of Biology, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio 44106.
Colm O'hUigin (271) Max-Planck-Institut ffir Biologie, Abteilung Immungenetik, D-72076 Tfibingen, Germany.
Christian Sturmbauer (97) Department of Zoology, University of Innsbruck, A-6020 Innsbruck Austria.
Todd H. Oakley (145) Department of Biological Sciences, University of Wisconsin- Milwaukee, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53201.
I-Iolger Siiltmann (39) Max-Planck-Institut ftir Biologie, Abteilung Immungenetik, D-72076 Tfibingen, Germany.
Guillermo Orti (219) Department of Genetics, University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia 30602.
Erik Verheyen (97) Royal Belgium Institute of Natural Sciences, B-1000 Brussels, Belgium.
Alex Parker (25,163) Department of Zoology and School of Marine Sciences, University of Maine, Orono, Maine 04469.
E. O. Wiley (75) Museum of Natural History and Department of Systematics and Ecology, University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas 66045.
Ruth B. Phillips (145) Department of Biological Sciences, University of Wisconsin - Milwaukee, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53201.
Jonathan M. Wright (53) Marine Gene Probe Laboratory, Department of Biology, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia B3H 4J1, Canada.
f , ce
ber, Allyson N. Hubers, Mark D. Chandler, Rachel A. Bartholomew, Rachael A. Callcut, and Gary R. Kutsikovich reviewed the entire volume at various stages. We owe special thanks to Rachel A. Bartholomew and Rachael A. Callcut for helping to prepare the indices, Karen L. Carleton for work on the references, and Craig Albertson for the artwork on the cover jacket. Our work on the molecular systematics of fishes has been generously funded by grants from the National Science Foundation, the Alfred Sloan Foundation, the National Geographic Society, the National Research Council, and the NOAA Sea Grant Program. We especially thank our families and students for their patience and understanding during the many periods that our work has required us to be elsewhere--in body or in thought. This volume is dedicated to our mentors (especially Richard Rosenblatt, David Hillis, Allan Wilson, and Jeff Mitton) who encouraged, critiqued, and shaped our ideas in molecular systematics. We hope that this volume will contribute to the preservation of fish species so that future generations will be able to wonder at the beauty and diversity of fishes in their natural habitats.
Fishes are the most diverse group of extant vertebrates, and yet our knowledge of the evolutionary relationships among them is largely incomplete. Over the past few years, molecular genetic methods, particularly PCR amplification and DNA sequencing, have become widely used to study the evolutionary history of fishes. Because of the strong tradition of morphological systematics of fishes, this group is uniquely suitable for testing and evaluating the efficacy of different approaches to elucidating the relationships among taxa. This book surveys the use of these new methods at many taxonomic levels, from the structure of local populations to the relationships among the deepest branches of the piscine family tree. The authors bring a diversity of experience and approaches to their analyses, and the result is a collective evaluation of the utility of these techniques for understanding evolutionary patterns and processes. Although this book focuses on fishes, the conclusions should be broadly applicable to the molecular systematics of other groups. We thank the authors for seeing this project through to completion. We are indebted to a host of anonymous individuals for constructive critical reviews of each chapter in manuscript form. In an increasingly busy world, it was a delight to see that many careful reviewers are still willing to take the time to coax a higher quality manuscript from their colleagues. In addition to these reviewers, Raymond R. Wilson, Joseph E. Fa-
Thomas D. Kocher, University of New Hampshire Carol A. Stepien, Case Western Reserve University
xi
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
C H A P T E R
1 Molecules and Morphology in Studies ofFish Evolution CAROL A. STEPIEN
T H O M A S D. KOCHER
Department of Biology Case Western Reserve University Cleveland, Ohio 44106
Department of Zoology University of New Hampshire Durham, New Hampshire 03824
I. I n t r o d u c t i o n
Fishes are the most diverse group of living vertebrates, with more than 24,600 extant species currently known (Nelson, 1994). For more than a century, systematists have sought to organize this diversity by studying aspects of their external and internal morphology. Their patient counting and dissection have achieved remarkable success in identifying groups of evolutionarily related species and provide the foundation and starting point for all current work on the systematics of fishes (for summaries of present status of morphological systematics of fishes see Nelson, 1994; Stiassny et al., 1996). The development of molecular techniques has helped invigorate studies of fish systematics. The realm of methods developed for molecular systematics (Hillis, et al., 1996; Ferraris and Palumbi, 1996) offer new suites of characters for analyzing relationships among fishes (Carvalho and Pitcher, 1995) and have been effectively applied from the level of populations to orders. It is hoped that this book illustrates the broad utility of molecular approaches for addressing fish systematic questions. Morphological studies have been especially successful in defining species and in organizing these species into genera. These groupings have usually been confirmed when examined with molecular approaches. Molecular characters have revealed some cryptic species (reviewed by Avise, 1994) and identified some inMOLECULAR SYSTEMATICS OF FISHES
correctly split groups (e.g., species in the clinid kelpfish genus Gibbonsia by Stepien and Rosenblatt, 1991; Stepien et al., Chapter 15). In general, the overall concordance between morphological and molecular studies has been good. Testing for congruence of relationships derived from independent data sets is a particularly robust approach to systematic problems (Miyamoto and Fitch, 1995). Although morphological studies have generally been successful in defining genera, it is rare to find studies which present a hypothesis of relationship above the level of the species comprising a genus, primarily due to a lack of congruence of characters. Fortunately, this is one of the strengths of molecular data, and inter- and intrageneric relationships are now being rapidly tested and elucidated. Molecular data are also the primary means used to assess the phylogeographic relationships among populations, examining questions of zoogeographic subdivision and relationships among areas (see Chapter 5 by Nielsen et al., Chapter 8 by Bermingham et al., and Chapter 9 by Faber and Stepien). Studies at these lower systematic levels are shedding more light on the mechanisms underlying the diversity of fishes. Both morphological and molecular studies have had particular difficulty discerning higher-level relationships. In both types of data, the central problems are identifying homologous characters and finding a sufficient number of synapomorphies to identify lineages with statistical confidence. Although great strides have Copyright 9 1997 by Academic Press. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
2
CAROL A. STEPIEN A N D THOMAS D. KOCHER
been made in identifying appropriate molecules and refining analytical techniques, interpreting relationships among the deepest clades of the piscine phylogeny are still problematic. This book is arranged in approximate order of primary phylogenetic problems addressed, ranging from lower (relationships among populations and closely related species) to higher-level systematic questions. The first set of chapters primarily focus on discerning population and species level problems in relation to phylogeography and include Chapter 3 by Kornfield and Parker (mbuna species flock), Chapter 4 by S~iltmann and Mayer (cichlid adaptive radiation), Chapter 5 by Nielsen et al. (Pacific trout Oncorhynchus), Chapter 6 by Wiley and Hagen (sand darters Ammocrypta), Chapter 7 by Sturmbauer et al. (cichlids), and Chapter 8 by Bermingham et al. (biogeographic patterns involving fishes of the Panamanian Isthmus). The next set of chapters address resolution of DNA for testing middle-level systematic problems (species through family-level questions) and discriminating among morphology-based hypotheses, including Chapter 9 by Faber and Stepien (Percidae), Chapter 10 by Phillips and Oakley (Salmoninae), Chapter 11 by Parker (Cyprinodontiformes), and Chapter 12 by Bernardi (Fundulidae, Cyprinodontiformes). The final set of chapters focus on the resolution power of genes to address higher-level systematic questions and evaluating the level of maximum phylogenetic utility. These include Chapter 13 by Naylor et al. (lamniform sharks), Chapter 14 by Orti (Characiformes), Chapter 15 by Stepien et al. (Blennioidei), Chapter 16 by Klein et al. (Cichlidae), and Chapter 17 by Lydeard and Roe (Actinopterygii).
II. History of Molecular Techniques An increasingly sophisticated realm of techniques has been developed since the mid-1970s to study the molecular similarities of organisms. Although preceded by protein sequencing and immunology, the widespread use of molecular techniques in fish systematics really began with the discovery of allozyme polymorphisms. A. A l l o z y m e S t u d i e s
Allozyme/isozyme studies involve identifying protein polymorphisms by comparing their similarities and differences in net electric charge. Allozyme and isozyme studies have been one of the most popular approaches in examining population genetic and stock
divergence questions in fishes. They have also been especially useful in identifying cryptic species and in testing biogeographic hypotheses. Allozyme/isozyme electrophoresis has the advantage of being relatively rapid, cost effective, and efficient. Another advantage is that the sampling is spread over a variety of presumably independent gene loci. The chief disadvantage of using an allozyme approach is that bands (alleles) that have the same electric charge and migrate to the same point in the gel may not be homologous (i.e., evolutionary convergence). The scoring of gels is often somewhat subjective and bands are difficult to interpret when weak or close together. Variants have traditionally been assumed to be selectively neutral, enabling hypotheses of separation time to be tested. However, several studies have shown that some allozyme variants are not neutral markers and are under selection (Avise, 1994; Pogson et al., 1995; Powers and Shulte, 1996). Our view is that increasing evidence shows that most (if not all) "neutral" genetic markers, including allozymes, mtDNA, and microsatellites, are indeed subject to varying amounts of selective constraint. The possibility that loci are under selection does not eliminate their utility in systematics, however. For example, morphologists regularly utilize characters that are the products of selection. In this volume, Nielsen et al. (Chapter 5; Salmonidae) and Stepien et al. (Chapter 15; Blennioidei) examine the congruence of hypotheses derived from allozyme data with other molecular data sets. B. M i t o c h o n d r i a l D N A
The mitochondrial (rot) genome has many properties that make it useful for reconstructing recent phylogenetic history (reviewed by Wilson et al., 1985; Avise, 1994; Simon et al., 1994). The most important feature is its clonal inheritance. Fish mitochondrial genomes are haploid and apparently nonrecombining. The evolution of the molecule therefore corresponds exactly to the model of bifurcating evolutionary trees. Second, mtDNA evolves more quickly than most nuclear genes, allowing the identification of informative phylogenetic characters among even closely related species and populations. Two other features of mtDNA are typically listed as advantages for phylogenetic analysis. First, mtDNA is maternally inherited. Although it is true that mtDNA is predominantly maternally inherited, several instances of heteroplasmy of distinct mitochondrial lineages suggest that this is not strictly, or universally correct (Magoulas and Zouros, 1993). Second, it may no longer be appropriate to consider that substitutions in mtDNA accumulate according to a strictly neutral process.
1. Molecules and Morphology in Studies of Fish Evolution
Patterns of sequence differentiation suggest that selective sweeps may be common (Ballard and Kreitman, 1994), and laboratory experiments have suggested competitive differences among mitochondrial haplotypes (Hutter and Rand, 1995). Whether these departures from neutral evolution invalidate the concept of molecular clocks remains to be seen. Many studies of mtDNA have analyzed restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs). Whole mtDNA can be digested with specific endonucleases, and the products are then separated by size using gel electrophoresis. In the most comprehensive studies, restriction sites are mapped and their presence or absence (rather than mere sharing of fragment lengths) is scored (Dowling et al., 1990). RFLP studies have been a popular approach in quantifying the degree of divergence within and among populations. In applying this approach to species and higher-level systematic questions, the homology of restriction site characters becomes less certain. A better approach for these comparisons involves direct analysis of DNA sequences.
C. Polymerase Chain Reaction and DNA Sequencing Until the development of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) (Saiki et al., 1988), sequencing of genes for phylogenetic analysis was rarely performed because of the huge investment required to clone homologous genes from multiple samples. The introduction of primer sequences with wide phylogenetic utility ("universal primers"; e.g., Kocher et al. 1989) allowed the rapid amplification of particular sequences from a large number of samples and helped create an explosion of studies using DNA sequences to examine phylogenetic questions. DNA sequence data have a number of inherent advantages over other kinds of systematic data. First, an essentially unlimited number of sequence characters are potentially available. Fish genomes typically contain on the order of a billion nucleotide pairs, each of which is potentially informative for phylogenetic analysis. Second, these characters are useful for studying relationships among both close and distant relatives. Each gene, as well as individual sites within a gene, evolves at a unique rate because of variation in the level of functional constraint. Slowly evolving genes such as nuclear 18S rDNA may be useful for discerning relationships among highly divergent groups (Hillis and Dixon, 1991). More rapidly evolving areas, such as the mtDNA control region, may be useful for discerning lower-level systematic relationships, such as among populations and species, as shown for percid relationships in the study by Faber and Stepien
(Chapter 9). In coding regions, the variation in DNA sequences may be evaluated among first, second, and third codon positions and at the amino acid level in order to increase potential phylogenetic utility at higher systematic levels. The relative strength of the phylogenetic signal with codon position and between the nucleotide and amino acid levels are critically evaluated by Naylor et al. (Chapter 13) and Lydeard and Roe (Chapter 17).
D. Mitochondrial DNA Sequence Regions Mitochondrial DNA regions have been well studied in fishes, and knowledge of universal primer sequences (e.g., Kocher et al., 1989; Meyer ef al., 1990, Simon et al., 1994; Palumbi, 1996) for amplification by PCR and sequencing has made them very accessible. As illustrated in this volume, they can be effectively used to address many different levels of taxonomic questions, depending on the region sequenced and the use of various correction factors for types and positions of substitutions. Silent sites of mitochondrial protein-coding genes and the nontranscribed control region are shown to be particularly useful for analyzing relationships of recently diverged taxa, such as among populations, species, and genera. In the case of higherlevel systematic questions, silent sites and rapidly evolving regions may have experienced multiple substitutions, obscuring phylogenetic signal. At higher taxonomic levels, more slowly evolving regions, such as the 12S and 16S ribosomal RNA genes may be useful. Alternatively, because substitutions in nonsynonymous nucleotide sites (which alter the encoded amino acids) occur more rarely, these changes may provide a higher signal/noise ratio for deep comparisons. The sequence evolution of mtDNA has been relatively well studied in fishes. Base substitution events occur relatively rapidly. MtDNA structure, gene order, and secondary structure are largely conserved in fishes, as well as in other vertebrates. It is inherited as a single unit and thus has been characterized as sampling a single gene, which is a possible disadvantage that may particularly affect population genetic studies. Because the evolutionary history of a single gene can be different from the average history of an entire genome (discussed by Avise, 1994), caution must be used in interpreting mitochondrial gene trees as reflecting the history of populations. The cytochrome b gene is probably the best-studied mitochondrial gene in fishes (e.g., Kocher et al., 1989; Meyer et al., 1990; Carr and Marshall, 1991; Block et al., 1993; Zhu et al., 1994; Carr et al., 1995). Like most mitochondrially encoded proteins, it is a transmembrane protein important in the respiratory chain of cellular
4
CAROL A. STEPIEN AND THOMAS D. KOCHER
metabolism. Although it has been widely used, some have questioned the ability of this sequence (especially short subsets of the gene) to resolve phylogenies (Martin et al., 1990; Graybeal, 1993; Meyer, 1994). In this volume, mtDNA sequences from the cytochrome b gene are used to analyze a variety of levels of relationships ranging from population genetics to higher-level systematics. For example, Bermingham et al. (Chapter 8) use cytochrome b data to assess population genetic and phylogeographic questions in tropical damselfishes of the Abudefduf saxatilis species group. Cytochrome b sequences are used to analyze relationships among species and groups of sand darters (family Percidae) (Wiley and Hagen, Chapter 6), among species of salmonids (Phillips and Oakley, Chapter 11), among members of the family Fundulidae (Cyprinodontiformes) (Bernardi, Chapter 12), and among lamniform sharks (Naylor et al., Chapter 13). At higher taxonomic levels, Lydeard and Roe (Chapter 17) test the use of cytochrome b to analyze relationships among actinopterygian fishes, revealing strong phylogenetic signal. By examining their data using different codon positions, Lydeard and Roe achieve greater utility at higher taxonomic levels than does Bernardi (Chapter 12). Mitochondrial ribosomal genes (12S and 16S rDNA subunits) are often used to study more distantly related taxa. Substitutions in the small subunit (12S) accumulate relatively slowly, approximating the average for the entire mitochondrial genome, whereas those in the large subunit (16S) evolve even more slowly (Simon et al., 1994). The 12S rDNA gene is used by Stepien et al. (Chapter 15) to examine relationships among species, genera, tribes, families, and suborders of blenniiform fishes, showing strong utility at these different levels and congruence with morphological-based hypotheses. Stepien (12S; Chapter 15), Orti (12S and 16S, Characiform fishes; Chapter 14), and Parker (16S, Cyprinodontiformes; Chapter 11) evaluate differences in the amount of phylogenetic signal among stem and loop regions of the ribosomal genes, reporting a greater retention of the phylogenetic signal at higher taxonomic levels in the more slowly evolving stem regions and more useful characters at lower taxonomic levels in the more rapidly changing loop regions. The mtDNA control region is involved in the control of mtDNA replication and RNA transcription. It is also called the displacement loop (D-loop) because one of the two strands of the helix is displaced by the synthesis of a new strand during replication. The highly variable left domain region has been believed to be largely selectively neutral, which may account for its very rapid rate of variation. In fishes, the control region is usually long (e.g., 888 to 1223 bp in percids; Faber and Stepien, Chapter 9) and often contains tandemly repeated segments. There is a set of conserved se-
quence blocks that are probably involved in controlling mtDNA replication and transcription, which may be useful for some systematic studies (see Attardi, 1985; Lee et al., 1995; Faber and Stepien, Chapter 9). The highly variable control region has thus been a popular sequence for examining population structure and relationships among closely related species of fishes (e.g., Meyer et al., 1990; Arnason and Rand, 1992; Sturmbauer and Meyer, 1992, 1993; Brown et al., 1993; Stepien, 1995; Lee et al., 1995). In this volume, Sturmbauer et al. (Chapter 7) employ sequence data from the control region to address phylogenetic questions and models of adaptive radiation and biogeography of cichlid fishes in Lake Tanganyika, Africa. Nielsen et al. (Chapter 5) utilize control region variation to discern patterns of geographic structure in the Pacific trout Oncorhynchus mykiss. The utility of control region sequences for discerning higher-level relationships is critically evaluated by Phillips and Oakley (Chapter 11) and by Faber and Stepien (Chapter 9). Although some areas of this rapidly evolving sequence are alignable even among distantly related fishes (see Lee et al., 1995), the high rate of evolution of this sequence appears to preclude analyses beyond the level of closely related species and perhaps genera. E. N u c l e a r
DNA Sequences
Several nuclear DNA regions have been used to address systematic questions among fishes. One of these is the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) used by Klein et al. (Chapter 16) to examine evolutionary hypotheses of the haplochromine flock of cichlids in Lake Victoria, East Africa. MHC molecules are believed to play a central role in the vertebrate immune system by presenting peptides to T lymphocytes, thereby initiating immune response cascades. Because MHC molecules are well known due to their role in the immune system and are highly variable, they also offer a wealth of potential systematic information. There are two classes of MHC molecules (I and II), which each consist of two polypeptide chains (a and b), but differ in structure and function (Bjorkman and Parham, 1990). Klein et al. (Chapter 16) use examples from classes I and II to test phylogenetic utility among recently diverged fish species as well as at higher phylogenetic levels. They also address whether selection causes sequence and allele frequency convergence in MHC genes. Stepien et al. (Chapter 15) compare sequence-based trees of blennioid fishes derived from the nuclear internal transcribed spacer (ITS)-1 region of the ribosomal array (Stepien et al., 1993) with trees produced from mitochondrial 12S rDNA gene sequences. A much greater number of variable characters is obtained using mtDNA 12S gene than was found from the nuclear
1. Molecules and Morphology in Studies ofFish Evolution
ITS-1 region (Stepien et al., 1993), suggesting that nuclear ITS sequences are best used for studying deeper divergences. In contrast, Phillips and Oakley (Chapter 10) find nuclear rDNA spacers to be most useful at lower taxonomic levels (interspecific and subspecific levels). These results suggest that the ITS-1 region may evolve at different rates in different fish groups. Other chapters explore the utility of new genes for phylogenetic analysis. Parker (Chapter 11) tests the relative degree of phylogenetic signal among first, second, and third codon positions of the nuclear tyrosine kinase gene X-src sequences for resolving relationships among the cyprinodontid killifishes. Orti (Chapter 14) compares nuclear DNA sequences from the protein-coding gene ependymin (a major glycoprotein component of the extracellular fluid in the brain of fishes) with mitochondrial 12S and 16S rDNA sequences to test the evolution of characiform fishes at various hierarchical levels. Much work remains in identifying a standard set of nuclear genes for phylogenetic analysis of fishes. F. O t h e r N u c l e a r Techniques
The introduction of PCR opened other avenues for the analysis of genome sequences. We touch here on two popular methods: randomly amplified polymorphic DNAs (RAPDs) and microsatellite polymorphisms. The RAPD method primarily detects sequence changes within the annealing sites of PCR primers, resulting in the presence or absence of amplification products from a particular locus. RAPD polymorphisms usually have a pattern of dominant inheritance (Williams et al., 1990) and can be used to screen for differences among individuals, populations, and species. Sultmann and Mayer (Chapter 4) employ RAPDs to identify polymorphic loci in cichlid groups, followed by locus-specific DNA amplification and sequence determination of the fragments. In this way, they avoid problems with determining homology of fragments among species. They find a large number of insertions and deletions (some of which are species specific) that can be treated as characters along with nucleotide substitutions. Their phylogenies show considerable congruence with morphological hypotheses and other molecular studies. They conclude that RAPDs are able to detect polymorphisms among closely related taxonomic groups, ranging from populations to genera. Microsatellite DNAs are highly variable, tandemly repeated DNA sequences with unit repeats one to six bases in length. Length polymorphisms arising from variation in the number of repeats are quantified by sizing PCR-amplified copies of the locus on a polyacrylamide gel. Microsatellites are abundantly distrib-
5
uted throughout the nuclear genome and are highly polymorphic. They follow a Mendelian codominant inheritance pattern. Microsatellites have been widely used to analyze mating systems and population genetic structure (Queller et al., 1993), despite the fact that their pattern of mutation is still poorly understood (Jarne and Lagoda, 1996). In Chapter 5, Nielsen et al. examine the biogeographic variation of nuclear microsatellite repeats in Pacific trout, O. mykiss, in comparison with mtDNA control region sequences. Although their mtDNA data show significant latitudinal and longitudinal correlations, microsatellite data are only weakly associated with longitude (and not at all with latitude). These differences suggest that the evolutionary processes resulting in phylogeographic patterns of genetic variation differentially affect the mitochondrial and nuclear genomes. Kornfield and Parker (Chapter 3) test the utility of microsatellite loci for examining relationships within a rapidly evolving species flock (the mbuna of Lake Malawi), in comparison with results from allozyme, mtDNA RFLP, mtDNA sequence, nuclear DNA sequence, and RAPDs data sets. They conclude that microsatellites are the first class of molecular markers to possess sufficient power to elucidate that level of evolutionary history. Sultman and Mayer (Chapter 4) compare microsatellite allele size frequencies among cichlid species from Lake Victoria. In total, these results suggest that microsatellite loci are applicable to species- and population-level work in rapidly evolving groups, as exemplified by the adaptive radiations of the Cichlidae. G. A L o o k to the Future
Although new kinds of polymorphisms will be identified as we come to understand the structure of genomes, there is some hope that the techniques used to study these polymorphisms have stabilized. Most investigators are now directly examining DNA sequence polymorphisms, the most fundamental unit of molecular variation. PCR and DNA sequencing will likely be the primary tools of molecular systematics in the foreseeable future. We anticipate that the major differences will be increases in length of sequence examined and the number of genetic loci scored.
III. Controversy over Analytical Methods Systematic biology is well known for its vigorous and highly polarized methodological debates. Although much of the acrimony has subsided, strong proponents of distance and cladistic approaches remain. This polarization is strongly correlated with the type of
6
CAROL A. STEPIEN A N D THOMAS D. KOCHER
data sets studied by individual scientists. Morphologists have generally rejected distance approaches. Molecular systematists appear relatively flexible in the approaches taken to recover phylogenetic relationships from their data and have found that the evolution of sequences is often most easily modeled with distance methods. Still, character-state analyses of molecular data abound, and we should be careful not to equate molecular studies with distance analyses or morphological studies with cladistic analyses.
A. Cladistic Approaches The rise of cladistic methodology, as proposed by Hennig (1950, 1966) and popularized by Wiley (1981), has greatly contributed to the development of systematics from a collection of ad hoc procedures to a respectable science. Cladistics has markedly increased objectivity for interpreting the evolutionary history of characters and testing the relative strength of competing systematic hypotheses. This standard methodology has facilitated the comparison of hypotheses proposed by various investigators and support for different types of data sets. Examples of such comparisons occur in almost every chapter of this volume.
B. Distance Approaches Along with the development of molecular techniques, such as allozyme-isozyme electrophoresis, emerged the use of genetic distances and clustering algorithms which describe the degree of similarity or genetic relatedness among pairs of taxa and summarize this information in a "tree." Distance methods differ from cladistics in that they reduce the difference among each pair of taxa to a single number. Some workers argue that distance methods lose information inherent in the character-state matrix. Others argue that distance methods allow the evolution of the sequence to be more easily modeled. This allows accurate correction for unobserved multiple substitutions (homoplasy) in sequence data that is not possible with other methods. Like character-state methods, distance methods can be bootstrapped to evaluate the internal consistency of data. Recent theoretical work has focused on the calculation of standard errors of distances and branch lengths. Most types of distance trees are constructed with branch lengths that are proportional to the amount of divergence, making it possible to estimate relative times of separation.
C. Distance Corrections, Weighting,
and Clustering Genetic distances may be corrected for the effects of multiple substitutions per site. Methods for correcting
these include the Jukes-Cantor equation (Jukes and Cantor, 1969), which uses a Poisson model to calculate the probabilities of multiple substitutions, assuming equal probability of the type of substitution, no nucleotide bias (same proportions of G, A, T, and C), and that all sites along a sequence have an equal probability of change. Because some or all of these assumptions are violated by most DNA sequence data sets, additional correction factors are often used. The Kimura twoparameter method (Kimura, 1980) allows differential weighting of transition and transversion probabilities. Tamura and Nei's (1993) distance correction is based on the gamma distribution and corrects for nucleotide frequency differences, transition:transversion biases, and variation of substitution rate among different sites. Gamma distances are discussed at length by Kocher and Carleton (Chapter 2). Kumar et al. (1993) suggest that if various distance correction methods give similar results, then the simplest possible model should be used in order to minimize variance of the estimates. They suggest using the Jukes-Cantor or simple pairwise distances in cases when genetic distances are low, as long as substitution rates do not vary among lineages. Differential weighting of characters has been widely discussed (Wheeler, 1986; Swofford et al., 1996). It is clear that data for different nucleotide positions in coding regions, i.e., first, second, and third codon positions, should be analyzed separately because of their distinct patterns of selective constraint. Weighting is a relatively crude way to correct for the variation in rate among sites in noncoding sequences, especially as the pattern of selective constraint for these sequences is poorly understood. Weighting has also been used to model the relative frequency of different types of nucleotide substitution in parsimony analyses (Fitch and Ye, 1991). The advantage of this approach relative to the use of an appropriate distance method is not clear. Clustering algorithms have greatly improved in recent years. Neighbor joining (Saitou and Nei, 1987) is a widely used distance clustering algorithm that allows unequal rates of divergences among lineages. It is no longer necessary (or desirable) to assume that rates of sequence change are constant throughout a phylogeny.
D. Molecular Clocks Use of molecular characters has also been associated with the assumption of a "molecular clock," i.e., that mutations arise at relatively regular, predictable rates (Zuckerkandl and Pauling, 1962, 1965). Today, it is unlikely that any proponents of a universal clock, that ticks at a regular rate across all taxa, remain. Still, most workers accept the idea of local clockswthat rates of evolution within a particular group are relatively
1. Molecules and Morphology in Studies ofFish Evolution
similar. Clocks may be calibrated based on comparisons with taxa having known divergences, using wellcorroborated geological events (such as the linkage of the Isthmus of Panama as a barrier between the Atlantic and Pacific aquatic fauna; see Vawter et al, 1980; Grant, 1987; Stepien and Rosenblatt, 1996; Chapter 8 by Bermingham et al.), or with the fossil record. Dating divergences to the fossil record is complicated by the fact that the actual divergence usually predates its first fossil appearance by an unknown amount of time. Problems with clock calibration are discussed by Bermingham et al. (Chapter 8) and by Stepien et al. (Chapter 15).
E. Combining Data and Testing f o r Congruence There are two primary schools of thought among systematic biologists regarding combining morphological and molecular data. The first is the "total evidence" approach (Mickevich and Johnson, 1976; Kluge and Wolf, 1993) which states that phylogenetic analysis should be performed on a combined data set using all possible evidence. The null hypothesis for this approach is that there are no significant differences or partitions within the data set, i.e., that there is only one evolutionary history for the clade in question. Huelsenbeck et al. (1996) raise the point that estimates from total evidence have less sampling error as separate analyses of data partitions are based on fewer characters. It is advocated that total evidence tests should examine whether different sets of data have significantly different signals and these possible partitions should be tested against the combined data set (de Queiroz, 1993; Bull et al., 1993, Ballard, 1996). The other school of thought states that data sets should be analyzed separately (see Bull et al., 1993; Miyamoto and Fitch, 1995). Relationships among taxa that are congruent in separate analyses are regarded as strongly supported. In other words, the congruence of data from separate sources (such as separate analyses using different genes, or between morphological and molecular data sets) indicates increased support that the relationships are likely to be true. Miyamoto and Fitch (1995) suggest that relationships among taxa that are supported by different independent data sets are particularly robust, equivalent to obtaining independent verification of an experimental hypothesis from a different experimental source. This independent type of verification may be lost in combining data sets. An explicit assessment of congruence versus total evidence approaches is discussed in Chapter 11 by Parker. Parker analyzes problems in systematics of the Cyprinodontiformes by combining morphological characters from Parenti (1981, 1984) along with mo-
7
lecular data, including the nuclear tyrosine kinase gene X-src (Meyer and Lydeard, 1993) and mt16S rDNA sequences (Parker and Kornfield, 1995). He evaluates the methodology for combining data sets and comparing trees, including T-PTP (Faith, 1991) and bootstrap tests (Rodrigo et al., 1993). His conclusions argue for the utility of both combination and congruence approaches. Many of the authors in this volume compare taxonomic congruence between molecular-based and morphological-based hypotheses (e.g., Chapter 9 by Faber and Stepien, Chapter 10 by Phillips and Oakley, Chapter 12 by Bernardi, and Chapter 17 by Lydeard and Roe). Phillips and Oakley (Chapter 10) compare results from morphological and molecular studies of salmonid relationships and conclude that morphological traits suggesting one clade are unreliable. Bernardi (Chapter 12) discerns considerable concordance between molecular data and the definition of subgenera, but is unable to resolve higher-level relationships within the family. Lydeard and Roe (Chapter 17) also find greatest concordance of the two types of data at the lowest levels of the taxonomic hierarchy.
IV. Achievements and Failures of Molecular Systematics The greatest achievement of molecular systematics is the consistent and large set of characters generated for the analysis of phylogenies. The availability of these data has allowed the resolution of many intrageneric phylogenies that had not been previously addressed. Molecular studies have been spectacularly successful at the lowest taxonomic levels, particularly the analysis of relationships among populations or intraspecific phylogeography (Avise et al., 1987; see Chapters 3 through 9 of this volume). Molecular data offer an abundance of characters for studies at this level. Molecular studies have not yet fulfilled their promise for resolving deep relationships. There are two problems holding up progress in this area. First, it can become difficult to identify homology in highly diverged sequences. Alignments of characters becomes more difficult as the sequences diverge, particularly for hypervariable regions of rDNA genes. Hillis and Dixon (1991) have suggested that rDNA sequences beyond about 30% sequence difference should be discarded as unalignable. A better understanding of the relationship between rRNA structure and function would help in the identification of homologous sites. The second problem is "saturation": the equilibrium value of sequence difference that is reached when mul-
8
CAROL A. STEPIEN A N D T H O M A S D. KOCHER
tiple substitutions erase the record of previous substitutions at a site. For DNA sequence data there are only four nucleotide character states, G, A, T, and C, thus base substitutions at single nucleotide sites are often obscured by multiple substitutions at sites (multiple hits). As with morphological data sets, apparent synapomorphies may be the result of homoplastic convergence rather than shared common ancestry. Saturation is apparent in many molecular systematic studies. Claims that a group of taxa radiated rapidly at some time in the past should be scrutinized. It may be that molecular data are saturated and therefore uninformative as to the timing of particular branching events. This problem may be lessened either by examining more slowly evolving sites or by considering the codon as the character (rather than the individual nucleotides; Goldman and Yang, 1994; see Chapter 13 by Naylor et al. and Chapter 17 by Lydeard and Roe). Further studies of mutational processes, and the selective forces underlying variation in rate among sites, are needed. Alternatively, new kinds of data, such as the analysis of positional data, may be needed. Patterns of SINE insertion (Murata et al., 1993) or the order of homologous loci (Boore et al., 1995) provide another approach for resolving deep relationships. Molecular studies have also failed to resolve the phylogeny of some rapidly speciating groups. Even an accurate phylogeny of a gene may not be informative as to the relationships of the species under study. If the gene pools are isolated more rapidly than polymorphisms can be fixed in a lineage, then the reconstructed gene trees may not parallel the evolution of the species (Moran and Kornfield, 1993; Parker and Kornfield, 1997; Chapter 3 by Kornfield and Parker; Chapter 7 by Sturmbauer et al.). Instead, the polymorphisms may be carried through the speciation event and be randomly fixed in the descendant populations (see discussion by Avise, 1994). The solution of this problem may require brute force; the construction of many independent gene trees may uncover the relationships among populations.
1. Integration of Intraspecific Biogeographic Patterns with Studies of Speciation The study of the phylogenetic histories of populations in relation to biogeography has been termed "intraspecific phylogeography" (Avise et al., 1987). Several chapters in this volume specifically address testing these types of phylogeographic questions using fishes. Specifically, Wiley and Hagen (Chapter 6) test geographic distribution and likely histories of vicariance in a southeastern United States percid group, the sand darters. Faber and Stepien (Chapter 9) test for geographic relationship among spawning populations of walleye, Stizostedion vitreum, addressing whether gene flow is decreased due to natal homing. The evolution of species flocks, models of adaptive radiation, and biogeographic barriers are tested by Sturmbauer et al. (Chapter 7) for the cichlids of Lake Tanganyika, Africa. In studies of Panamanian freshwater fishes, Bermingham et al. (Chapter 8) describe very high levels of genetic divergence among populations, postulating that very high levels of phylogeographic structuring may be common in species exhibiting distributions that span large distances across physically isolated drainages. These studies are beginning to shed light on the role of geographic processes in speciation.
2. Reconstruction of Phylogenies among Congeners The now standard methodology of sequencing short stretches of the mitochondrial genome will continue to bear fruit in the analysis of relationships within genera. As outlined by Kocher and Carleton in Chapter 2, these efforts will be most successful for divergences within the last 5 million years. The steady accumulation of these sequences will allow the construction of intrageneric phylogenies for many groups of fishes and will lay the groundwork for studies attempting to understand relationships further back in time.
3. Reconstruction of Higher-Level Relationships Using Longer Sequences V. Eight Promising Directions for Future Research Molecular systematists have been working with DNA sequences for most of the last decade. The basic techniques of PCR and DNA sequencing are firmly established, but how will they be applied in the future? The following areas of molecular systematics may prove especially rewarding in the future.
Continuing advances in DNA sequencing technology suggest that it will be practical to analyze increasingly longer segments of DNA. Up to a point, longer sequences will allow the resolution of more ancient divergences. Hillis (1996) has suggested that sequences only 5000 bp long may be sufficient to accurately reconstruct even complex phylogenies. This seems a good intermediate goal, although additional complete mitochondrial sequences and many more nuclear sequences would be useful for some questions.
1. Molecules and Morphology in Studies ofFish Evolution
4. Analysis of Developmental Homologies at the Molecular Level Developmental biologists are beginning to focus on the analysis of fish development. A recent mutant hunt resulted in the isolation of more than 1500 mutations affecting development of the zebrafish (Haffter et al., 1996; Driever et al., 1996). We suspect that the genetic basis for many morphological differences will be revealed in the near future. Although the impact on the systematics of fishes is difficult to predict, the elucidation of molecular mechanisms generating morphological differences is sure to have an impact on the analysis of such characters. Where it is possible to cross species, it may be possible to identify the number of genes responsible for morphological differences (e.g., Doebley, 1992), quantifying for the first time the number of characters scored in morphological analyses.
5. Interpretation of Hybridization and Species Boundaries Using Abundant Nuclear Markers Habitat disturbance and continued introductions of exotic species will create new opportunities for the hybridization of species. The analysis of introgression in such hybrid swarms will be facilitated by the abundance of new genetic markers now available. Where the taxonomy of natural species has been in debate, these markers will provide new data on the extent of differentiation across the whole genome. The analysis of hybrids may also shed light on selective constraints and the interaction of genes (Kilpatrick and Rand, 1995; Rieseberg et al., 1996).
6. Analysis of the Evolution of Repetitive DNA Families Although most systematic analyses have focused on sequence variation in single-copy genes, there is some indication that repetitive DNA families offer new and useful tools for identifying relationships (Franck et al., 1994; Elder and Turner, 1994). Sequence variation in tandem and dispersed repetitive DNA may provide new insights in some groups.
9
8. Genomic Organization The increasing availability of genome maps, and even complete DNA sequences, is creating opportunities for the analysis of new characters. For example, Boore et al. (1995) used the pattern of gene arrangements in arthropod m t D N A to study arthropod relationships. O'Brien et al. (1993) proposed the use of a standard set of reference loci in the analysis of genomes, which would make it easy to identify such rearrangements in the nuclear genome. These types of characters may offer the best hope for resolving relationships among ancient lineages and need to be comprehensively addressed in fishes.
VI. A N e w Age of Synthesis Although morphological and molecular traditions have frequently collided in the past, we argue for a more synergistic approach that recognizes the peculiarities and limitations of each kind of data and in which there is an interplay between morphological and molecular studies. All inherited morphological characters have their origin in molecular characters. A record of the history of evolutionary change can be found in both the structure and the genes of organisms. At this point, analytical methods are rapidly increasing in sophistication, enabling us to better quantify rates of evolution and constraints on molecular changes through time. This understanding will lead to more accurate and consistent phylogenetic analyses. When combined with traditional approaches, these data promise to reveal much about the evolutionary forces that have produced the great diversity of modern fishes. This volume illustrates the beginning stages of this process, which is sweeping the field of fish systematics and paving the way to a new understanding of the interplay of genes, development, and selection. This new age of synthesis promises to continue to revolutionize systematics in the 21st century. References
7. Studies of the Molecular Clock in Fishes The mechanisms governing the speed and regularity of molecular clocks are poorly understood. The great diversity of habitat and life history among fishes, coupled with their excellent fossil record, makes this an excellent group with which to study molecular clocks. New insights will arise as rigorous accountings of substitution rate are made in groups of fishes varying in population size, environment, and life history.
Amason, E., and Rand, D. M. 1992. Heteroplasmy of short tandem repeats in mitochondrial DNA of Atlantic cod, Gadus morhua. Genetics 132:211- 220. Attardi, G. 1985. Animal mitochondrial DNA: An extreme example of genetic economy. Int. Rev. Cytol. 93:93-145. Avise, J. C. 1994. "Molecular Markers, Natural History, and Evolution." Chapman and Hall, New York. Arise, J C., Arnold, J., Ball, R. M., Bermingham, E., Lamb, T., Neigel, J. E., Reeb, C. A., and Saunders, N. C. 1987. Intraspecific phylogeography: The mitochondrial DNA bridge between population genetics and systematics.Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 18: 489-522.
10
CAROL A. STEPIEN AND THOMAS D. KOCHER
Ballard, J. W. O., and Kreitman, M. 1994. Unraveling selection in the mitochondrial genome of Drosophila. Genetics 138: 757-772. Ballard, J. W. O. 1996. Combining data in phylogenetic analysis. Trends Ecol. Evol. 11:334. Bjorkman, P.J., and Parham, P. 1990. Structure, function, and diversity of class I major histocompatibility complex molecules. Annu. Rev. Biochem. 59:253-288. Block, B. B., Finnerty, J. R., Stewart, A. F. R., and Kidd, J. 1993. Evolution of endothermy in fish: Mapping physiological traits on a molecular phylogeny. Science 260:210- 214. Boore, J. L., Collins, T. M., Stanton, D., Daehler, L. L., and Brown, W. M. 1995. Deducing the pattern of arthropod phylogeny from mitochondrial DNA rearrangements. Nature 376:163-165. Brown, J. R., Beckenbach, A. T., and Smith, M. J. 1993. Intraspecific DNA sequence variation of the mitochondrial control region of white sturgeon (Acipenser transmontanus). Mol. Biol. Evol. 10: 326-341. Bull, J. J., Huelsenbeck, J. P., Cunningham, C. W., Swofford, D. L., and Waddell, P. J. 1993. Partitioning and combining data in phylogenetic analysis. Syst. Biol. 42:384-397. Carr, S. M., and Marshall, H. D. 1991. Detection of intraspecific DNA sequence variation in the mitochondrial cytochrome b gene of Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) by the polymerase chain reaction. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 48:48-52. Carr, S. M., Snellen, A. J., Howse, K. A., and Wroblewski, J.S. 1995. Mitochondrial DNA sequence variation and genetic stock structure of Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) from bay and ofshore locations on the Newfoundland continental shelf. Mol. Ecol. 4:79-88. Carvalho, G. R., and Pitcher, T. J. (eds.) 1995. "Molecular Genetics in Fisheries." Chapman and Hall, New York. de Queiroz, A. 1993. For consensus (sometimes). Syst. Biol. 42: 368-372. Doebley, J. 1992. Mapping the genes that made maize. Trends Genet. 8: 302- 307. Dowling, T. E., Moritz, C., and Palmer, J.D. 1990. Nucleic acids. II. Restriction site analysis. In "Molecular Systematics" (D. M. Hillis and C. Moritz, eds.), pp. 250-317. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, MA. Driever, W., Solnica-Krezel, L., Schier, A. F., Neuhauss, S. C. E, Malicki, J., Stemple, D. L., Stainier, D. Y. R., Zwartkruis, F., Abdelilah, S., Rangini, Z., Belak, J. and Boggs, C. 1996. A genetic screen for mutations affecting embryogenesis in zebrafish. Development 123: 37-46. Elder, J. F., Jr., and Turner, B. J. 1994. Concerted evolution at the population level: Pupfish HindIII satellite DNA sequences. Proc. Nat. Acad. Science USA 91:994-998. Faith, D. P. 1991. Cladistic permutation tests for monophyly and nonmonophyly. Syst. Zool. 40:366-375. Ferraris, J. D., and Palumbi, S. R. (eds.) 1996. "Molecular Zoology." Wiley-Liss, New York. Fitch, W. M., and Ye, J. 1991. Weighted parsimony: Does it work? In "Phylogenetic Analysis of DNA Sequences" (M. M. Miyamoto and J. Cracraft, eds.), pp. 147-154. Oxford University Press, New York. Franck, J. P. C., Kornfield, I., and Wright, J. M. 1994. The utility of SATA Satellite DNA sequences for inferring phylogenetic relationships among the three major genera of tilapiine cichlid fishes. Molec. Phyl. Evol. 3:10-16. Goldman, N., and Yang, Z. 1994. A codon-based model of nucleotide substitution for protein-coding DNA sequences. Mol. Biol. Evol. 11: 725- 736. Grant, W. S. 1987. Genetic divergence between congeneric Atlantic and Pacific Ocean fishes, In "Population Genetics and Fishery Management" (N. Ryman and F. Utter, eds.), pp. 225-246. Univ. Washington Press, Seattle, WA.
Graybeal, A. 1993. The phylogenetic utility of cytochrome b: Lessons from bufonid frogs. Mol. Phyloget. Evol. 2:256-269. Hafter, P., Granato, M., Brand, M., Mullings, M. C., Hammerschmidt, M., Kane, D. A., Odenthal, J., Van Eeden, F. J. M., Jiang, Y.-J., Heisenberg, C.-P., Kelsh, R. N., Furutani-Seiki, M., Vogelsang, E., Beuchle, D., Schach, U., Fabian, C., and N~issleinVolhard, C. 1996. The identification of genes with unique and essential function in the development of the zebrafish, Danio rerio. Development 123:1-36. Hennig, W. 1950. "Grundzuege einer Theorie der phylogenetischen Systematik." Deutscher Zentralverlag, Berlin. Hennig, W. 1966. "Phylogenetic Systematics." University of Illinois Press, Urbana, IL. Hillis, D. M., and Dixon, M. T. 1991. Ribosomal DNA: Molecular evolution and phylogenetic inference. Quart. Rev. Biol. 66: 411-453. Hillis, D. M., 1996. Inferring complex phylogenies. Nature 383: 130-131. Hillis, D. M., Moritz, C., and Mable, B. K. (eds.) "Molecular Systematics," 2nd. ed. Sinaver Assoc., Sonderland, Massachusetts. Huelsenbeck, J. P., Bull, J. J., and Cunningham, C. W. 1996. Combining data in phylogenetic analysis. Trends Ecol. Evol. 11(4): 152-158. Hutter, C. M., and Rand, D. M. 1995. Competition between mitochondrial haplotypes in distinct nuclear genetic environments: Drosophila pseudoobscura vs. D. persimilis. Genetics 140(2):537-548. Jarne, P., and Lagoda, P. J. L. 1996. Microsatellites, from molecules to populations and back. Trends Ecol. Evol. 11(10):424-429. Jukes, T. H., and Cantor, C. R. 1969. Evolution of protein molecules. In "Mammalian Protein Metabolism" (H. N. Munro, ed.), pp. 21132. Academic Press, New York. Kilpatrick, S.T., and Rand, D.M. 1995. Conditional hitchhiking of mitochondrial DNA: Frequency shifts of Drosophila melanogaster mtDNA variants depend on nuclear genetic background. Genetics 141:1113-1124. Kimura, M. 1980. A simple method for estimating evolutionary rate of base substitutions through comparative studies of nucleotide sequences. J. Mol. Evol. 16:111-120. Kluge, A. G., and Wolf, A. J. 1993. Cladistics: What's in a word? Cladistics 9:183 - 199. Kocher, T. D., Thomas, W. K., Meyer, A., Edwards, S. V., Paabo, S. E, Villablanca, E X., and Wilson, A. C. 1989. Dynamics of mtDNA evolution in animals: Amplification and sequencing with conserved primers. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86:6196-6200. Kumar, S., Tajura, K., and Nei, M. 1993. "MEGA: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis, Version 1.0." Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA. Lee, W., Conroy, J., Howell, W. H., and Kocher, T. D. 1995. Structure and evolution of teleost mitochondrial control regions. J. Mol. Evol. 41:54-66. Magoulas, A., and Zouros, E. 1993. Restriction-site heteroplasmy in anchovy (Engraulis encrasiocholus) indicates incidental biparental inheritance of mitochondrial DNA. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10(2):319-325. Martin, A. P., Kessing, B.D., and Palumbi, S. R. 1990. Accuracy of estimating genetic distance between species from short sequences of mitochondrial DNA. Mol. Biol. Evol. 7:485-488. Meyer, A. 1994. Shortcomings of the cytochrome b gene as a molecular marker. Trends Ecol. Evol. 9:278-280. Meyer, A., Kocher, T. D., Basasibwaki, P., and Wilson, A. C. 1990. Monophyletic origin of Lake Victoria cichlid fishes suggested by mitochondrial DNA sequences. Nature 347:550-553. Meyer, A., and Lydeard, C. 1993. The evolution of copulatory organs, internal fertilization, placentas, and viviparity in killifishes (Cyprinodontiformes), as inferred from a DNA phylogeny of the tyrosine kinase gene X-src. Proc. Royal. Soc. Lond. B 254:153-162.
1. Molecules and Morphology in Studies ofFish Evolution
Mickevich, M. F., and Johnson, M. S. 1976. Congruence between morphological and allozyme data in evolutionary inference and character evolution. Syst. Zool. 25:260-270. Miyamoto, M. M., and Fitch, W. M. 1995. Testing species phylogenies and phylogenetic methods with congruence. Syst. Biol. 44: 64-76. Moran, P., and Kornfield, I. 1993. Were population bottlenecks associated with the radiation of the Mbuna species flock (Teleostei: Cichlidae) of Lake Malawi. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10:1015-1029. Murata, S., Takasaki, N., Saitoh, M., and Okada, N. 1993. Determination of the phylogenetic relationships among Pacific salmonids by using short interspersed elements (SINEs) as temporal landmarks of evolution. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90:6995-6999. Nelson, J. S. 1994. "Fishes of the World," 3rd. ed. Wiley, New York. O'Brien, S. J., Womack, J. E., Lyons, L. A., Moore, K. J., Jenkins, N. A., and Copeland, N. G. 1993. Anchored reference loci for comparative genome mapping in mammals. Nat. Genet. 3:103-112. Palumbi, S. R. 1996. Nucleic acids II. The polymerase chain reaction. In "Molecular Systematics" (D. M. Hillis, C. Moritz, and B. K. Mable, eds.), pp. 205-221. Sinauer Assoc., Sunderland, MA. Parenti, L. R. 1981. A phylogenetic and biogeographic analysis of cyprinodontiform fishes. Bull. Am. Mus. Nat. Hist. 1658:341-557. Parenti, L. R. 1984. A taxonomic revision of the Andean killifish genus Orestias. Bull. Am. Mus. Nat. Hist. 178:110-214. Parker, A., and Kornfield, I. 1995. A molecular perspective on evolution and zoogeography of cyprinodontid killifishes. Copeia 1995:8-21. Parker, A. and Kornfield, I. 1997. Evolution of the mitochondrial DNA control region in the mbuna (Cichlidae) species flock of Lake Malawi, East Africa. J. Mol. Evol. in press. Pogson, G. H., Mesa, K. A., and Boutilier, R. G. 1995. Genetic population structure and gene flow in the Atlantic cod Gadus morhua: A comparison of allozyme and nuclear RFLP loci. Genetics 139: 375-385. Powers, D. A., and Schulte, P. M. 1996. A molecular approach to the selectionist/neutralist controversy. In "Molecular Zoology" (J. D. Ferraris and S. R. Palumbi eds.), pp. 327-352. Wiley-Liss, New York. Queller, D. C., Strassmann, J. E., and Hughes, C. R. 1993. Microsatellites and kinship. Trends Ecol. Evol. 8:285-288. Rieseberg, L. H., Sinervo, B., Linder, C. R., Ungerer, M. C., and Arias, D. M. 1996. Role of gene interactions in hybrid speciation: Evidence from ancient and experimental hybrids. Science 272: 741-745. Rodrigo, A. G., Kelly-Borges, M., Bergquist, P. R., and Bergquist, P. L. 1993. A randomisation test of the null hypothesis that two cladograms are sample estimates of a parametric phylogenetic tree. New Zeal. J. Bot. 31:257-268. Saiki, R. K., Gelfand, D. H., Stoffel, S., Scharf, S. J., Higuchi, R., Horn, G. T., Mullis, K. B., and Erlich, H. A. 1988. Primer-directed enzymatic amplification of DNA with a thermostabile DNA polymerase. Science 239: 487-491. Saitou, N., and Nei, M. 1987. The neighbor-joining method: A new method reconstructing phylogenetic trees. Mol. Biol. Evol. 4: 406-425. Simon, C., Frati, F., Beckenbach, A., Crespi, B., Liu, H., and Flook, P. 1994. Evolution, weighting, and phylogenetic utility of mitochondrial gene sequences and a compilation of conserved polymerase chain reaction primers. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 87(6): 651-701.
11
Stepien, C. A. 1995. Population genetic divergence and geographic patterns from DNA sequences: Examples from marine and freshwater fishes. In "Evolution and the Aquatic Ecosystem: Defining Unique Units in Population Conservation" (J. Nielsen, ed.), pp. 263-287. American Fisheries Soc. Symposium, Bethesda, MD. Stepien, C. A. and Rosenblah, R. H. 1991. Patterns of gene flow and genetic divergence in the Northeastern Pacific Clinidae (Teleosteii Blennioidei), based on allozyme and morphological data. Copeia. 1991(4): 873-896. Stepien, C. A., Dixon, M. T., and Hillis, D. M. 1993. Evolutionary relationships of the blennioid fish families Clinidae, Labrisomidae, and Chaenopsidae: Congruence between DNA sequence and allozyme data. Bull. Mar. Sci. 52(1): 873-513. Stepien, C. A., and Rosenblatt, R. H. 1996. Genetic divergence in antitropical pelagic marine fishes (Trachurus, Merluccius, and Scomber) between North and South America. Copeia 1996(3): 586-598. Stiassny, M. L. J., Parenti, L. R., and Johnson, G. D. (eds.) 1996. "Interrelationships of Fishes." Academic Press, San Diego. Sturmbauer, C., and Meyer, A. 1992. Genetic divergence, speciation and morphological stasis in a lineage of African cichlid fishes. Nature 358:578-581. Sturmbauer, C., and Meyer, A. 1993. Mitochondrial phylogeny of the endemic mouthbrooding lineages of cichlid fishes of Lake Tanganyika, East Africa. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10: 751-768. Swofford, D. L., Olsen, G. J., Waddell, P. J., and Hillis, D. M. 1996. In "Molecular Systematics" (D. M. Hillis, C. Moritz, and B. K. Mable, eds.). 2nd Ed., pp. 407-514. Sinauer Assoc., Sunderland, MA. Tamura, K., and Nei, M. 1993. Estimation of the number of nucleotide substitutions in the control region of mitochondrial DNA in humans and chimpanzees. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10:512-526. Vawter, A. T., Rosenblatt, R. H., and Gorman, G. C. 1980. Genetic divergence among fishes of the Eastern Pacific and the Caribbean: Support for the molecular clock. Evolution 34: 705m711. Wheeler, W. C. 1986. Character weighting and cladistic analysis. Syst. Zool. 35:102-109. Wiley, E. O. 1981. "Phylogenetics: The Theory and Practice of Phylogenetic Systematics." Wiley Interscience, New York. Williams, J. G. K., Kubelik, A. R., Livak, K. J., Rafalski, J. A., and Tingey, S. V. 1990. DNA polymorphisms amplified by arbitrary primers are useful as genetic markers. Nucleic Acids Res. 18: 6531-6535. Wilson, A. C., Cann, R. L., Carr, S. M., George, M., Jr., Gyllensten, B., Helm-Bychowski, K., Higuchi, R. C., Palumbi, S. R., Prager, E. M., Sage, R. D., and Stoneking, M. 1985. Mitochondrial DNA and two perspectives on evolutionary genetics. Biol. J. Linnean Soc. 26: 375-400. Zhu, D., Jamieson, B. G. M., Hugall, A., and Moritz, C. 1994. Sequence evolution and phylogenetic signal in control region and cytochrome b sequences of rainbowfishes (Melanotaeniidae). Mol. Biol. Evol. 11:672-683. Zuckerkandl, E. and Pauling, L. 1962. Molecular disease, evolution and genic heterogeneity. In "Horizons in Biochemistry" (M. Kasha and B. Pullman, eds.), pp. 189-225. Academic Press, New York. Zuckerkandl, E. and Pauling, L. 1965. Evolutionary divergence and convergence in proteins. In "Evolving Genes and Proteins" (V. Bryson and H. J. Vogel, eds.), pp. 97-166. Academic Press, New York.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
C H A P T E R
2 Base Substitution in Fish Mitochondrial DNA: Patterns and Rates THOMAS D. KOCHER and KAREN L. CARLETON Department of Zoology University of New Hampshire Durham, New Hampshire 03824
I. Introduction
differences can be observed in comparisons among species. Probably more is known about evolutionary patterns in animal mitochondrial genomes than for any other DNA sequence. Although some aspects of the substitutional pattern (e.g., the high proportion of transitions) are unique to animal mtDNA, this molecule is still an excellent model system to illustrate the analytic method needed to reconstruct phylogenies from DNA sequence data. This chapter focuses on patterns of mtDNA evolution in cichlid fishes. Examples are drawn from continuing studies of the sene encoding NADH dehydrogenase subunit 2 (ND2) in East African cichlids (Kocher et al., 1995). This data set is particularly useful because it includes a large number of closely related molecules which provide insights into the pattern of substitution usually obscured in comparisons among more highly diverged sequences.
Many of the authors in this volume use mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequences because they are easily accessible, have high rates of evolution, and generally follow a clonal pattern of inheritance well suited to phylogenetic reconstruction (Wilson et al., 1985). This chapter is about the natural history of these sequences. Just as morphological systematists strive to analyze characters for which the pattern of development and effects of the environment are well known, so molecular systematists should begin by understanding the biology underlying the characters they use for inferring phylogenies. By understanding how changes accumulate in sequences, accurate models of substitution can be developed for use in phylogenetic inference. Molecular sequences are deceptively simple in structure. There are just four bases common in DNA. These bases appear to be freely interchangeable, but in fact, mutation interconverts some nucleotides more frequently than others. Selection and drift then act on this spectrum of mutations in such a way as to prevent most substitutions from becoming fixed in the population. Neither mutation nor selection is homogeneous along a sequence of nucleotides; close examination reveals important differences in the pattern of mutation and selective constraint among nucleotide sites. Additional
MOLECULAR SYSTEMATICS OF FISHES
II. S i m p l e M o d e l s of Substitution A. M u t a t i o n a l Models At the core of most phylogenetic reconstruction algorithms is a simplified mutational model of the sub-
13
Copyright 9 1997 by Academic Press. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
14
THOMAS D. KOCHER A N D KAREN L. CARLETON
A
C
~
G
Purines
T Pyrimidines
FIGURE 1 The substitution model of Kimura (1980) in which the rate of transitions (or) is usually higher than the rate of transversions (13).
stitution process. The simplest model (Jukes and Cantor, 1969) assumes an equal probability of interconversion among all four nucleotides. A consequence of this model is a twofold excess of transversional change (purine ~ pyrimidine) because there are twice as many paths for transversions as for transitions. This model is not adequate for animal mtDNA because a much larger excess of transitions, relative to transversions, is typically observed. Kimura (1980) introduced a two parameter model to accommodate the higher rate of transitions (Fig. 1). This model is also inadequate, as it predicts that sequences at equilibrium will contain equal frequencies of all four nucleotides. A modified Kimura model (Felsenstein, 1986) adjusts the relative rates of transitions or transversions to accommodate the unequal frequency of bases seen in real sequences. More complex models are possible, but the need for a fully elaborated model, with a separate rate parameter for each of the 12 possible kinds of substitution, has not yet been demonstrated (but see Rzhetsky and Nei, 1995).
B. Multiple Hits and Saturation As mutations occur over time, a pair of homologous sequences will become increasingly different. The observed number of differences between these sequences accumulates almost linearly at first. Gradually, however, as some nucleotide sites experience more than one substitution, the observed sequence difference becomes a poor indicator of the actual divergence which has occurred. Eventually, the rate at which new differences arise is equal to the rate at which identical nucleotides arise by multiple substitution. At this point the sequences cannot display greater sequence difference (the sequences have reached "saturation"), even
though additional substitutions continue to occur. The true evolutionary rate is hidden by the occurrence of multiple substitutions at a site. Appropriate statistical corrections can be applied to transform the observed differences into a measure of the total number of changes that have occurred (total divergence, or evolutionary distance). These corrections can be derived for any of the mutational models, but are accurate only in the early stages of differentiation, before saturation has been closely approached. Furthermore, these corrections are accurate only if all of the nucleotide sites are evolving according to the same substitutional model.
C. Selectional Filter Although mutational models have been widely used to describe the process of substitution, they ignore the influence of selection, which may be the dominant force regulating change in real sequences. It is easy to show, by comparison of nucleotide substitution rates at silent and amino acid replacement sites, that selection filters out more than 90% of all mutations which occur in mtDNA. Any concordance between the predictions of mutational models and the evolution of real sequences is therefore fortuitous. Most simple models assume that substitutions occur randomly among sites following the Poisson distribution. Numerous demonstrations of the inadequacy of this model have been published (Fitch and Markowitz, 1970; Uzzell and Corbin, 1971; Kocher and Wilson, 1991). Substitutions do not occur with equal probability at each site. Instead, selection resists substitution at some sites, while allowing mutations at other sites to become fixed. A better model of this process uses a gamma distribution (Bliss and Fisher, 1953; Tamura and Nei, 1993), or a covarion model (Fitch and Markowitz, 1970; Miyamoto and Fitch, 1995), to allow rates of substitution to vary among nucleotide sites. The gamma distribution models have been mathematically formulated so that it is straightforward to correct distances for multiple hits (Tamura and Nei, 1993), but this is not yet possible for the covarion model. Few studies have attempted to estimate either the gamma parameter or the size and exchange rate of the covarion. It is important to remember that estimates of these parameters must be made from close relatives, as they provide the best information to quantify the process of substitution, free from the effects of multiple substitution. For protein-coding sequences, it is possible to classify sites a priori according to the known selective constraints of the coding function. At the very least, it is recognized that first, second, and third positions of co-
2. Base Substitution in Fish mtDNA dons evolve at different rates, because of the redundant structure of the genetic code, and the grouping of functionally similar amino acids according to the second base of the codon. Because the functional constraints on rRNA sequences are poorly understood, it is more difficult to assign sites to particular rate classes a priori. Models of evolution for these genes typically resort to a purely statistical representation of the sites.
III. Evolution of Real Sequences To evaluate which theoretical models provide the most appropriate basis for phylogenetic reconstruction, the evolution of real sequences must be quantified. Here we examine a set of 56 mitochondrially encoded NADH subunit 2 (ND2) sequences (348 codons) obtained from 45 species of cichlid fish, mostly from East Africa. The most divergent comparisons involve New World species which presumably diverged from the African lineages more than 60 million years (MY) ago. The most closely related sequences are intraspecific polymorphisms differing by just a few nucleotides. Those sequences not already reported in Kocher et al. (1995) are deposited in GenBank. Ideally, we would plot the divergence of molecules with respect to geologic times of divergence. For these fishes, however, few reliable divergence times are available. Instead we will use the proportion of third position sites which have experienced a transversion as a measure of divergence. Transversions occur relatively rarely and in a nearly Poisson fashion (Irwin et al., 1991). These divergences are corrected for multiple substitution using a two-state model [d = -0.5 in (1-2Q), where Q is the observed proportion of transversions].
A. Changes in the Third P o s i t i o n o f C o d o n s Many substitutions at the third positions of codons are synonymous (i.e., do not change the amino acid sequence of the encoded protein) and thus escape selection on protein structure. These sites therefore provide the most direct view of the mutational process. Although these sites are often thought to evolve according to a purely mutational model, some selective constraint does exist (Perna, 1996; Xia et al., 1996). While it would be inappropriate to equate substitutions at third positions with mutation, these sites approximate the underlying mutational spectrum more closely than the first or second positions. The dominant feature of mtDNA evolution is the high rate of transition substitutions relative to transver-
15
sions. At third positions the ratio of transition: transversion differences is at least 5:1 initially (Fig. 2), consistent with a strong transition bias in the underlying mutation process. As transitions begin to occur repeatedly at the same sites, the ratio of transitions: transversions observed in pairwise comparisons drops. At a 10% transversion difference, the ratio is only 2.5:1, and in the deepest comparisons it drops to 1:1. At a 10% transversion difference, the actual number of transition substitutions that have occurred is at least twice as great as the observed number of differences. The transition: transversion ratio is thus one way to quantify the degree of multiple substitution that has occurred since the common ancestor of two sequences. Base composition influences the maximum observed difference. Figure 3 shows the accumulation of the two kinds of transitions possible: those involving the purines (A and G) and those involving the pyrimidines (C and T). It is interesting to note that the initial rate of transitions is the same for the two types of nucleotides. The purines, however, show saturation at a lower level of divergence than the pyrimidines. This pattern arises because the frequencies of A and G are much more unequal than the frequencies of C and T. At third positions the proportions are A,G,C,T: 0.32, 0.05, 0.38, 0.26. The maximum divergence of two sequences is calculated as I - probability of chance identity. For the purines described earlier, where only two states are possible (e.g., A or G), this is calculated as
(f6)2 (fA) 2 dma x
-
1 -
fc +fA
fC +fA
o
(1)
The very unequal frequencies of A and G allow a maxim u m difference of just 23% instead of the 50% that would be expected given equal frequencies of the two nucleotides. For C and T, the maximum difference is higher, about 48% (Kocher et al., 1995). These differences explain why the purine transitions reach saturation before the pyrimidine transitions. These mitochondrial sequences approach saturation rapidly. Evidence of multiple substitutions is quite apparent at only 2% transversion difference. The mammalian fossil record suggests that this corresponds to about 2 MY of divergence (Irwin et al., 1991). The fossil record of cichlids is more difficult to interpret, but a similar rate does correlate well with the geologic history of East Africa (Kocher et al., 1995). The fact that saturation effects begin to arise after just 2 MY of divergence underscores the importance of corrections for multiple substitution when constructing phylogenies of more distantly related taxa.
16
THOMAS D. KOCHER AND KAREN L. CARLETON 30 ~e~
9
9
9
-
~o
9 o9 9
"#-
9
~Z --
i n m i n e
r~ tO
9
9
9 9
GO
Gig 9O ; ~ 9 9
9
9
8o
9
9
9
9
9149
9
9
9 ~
9
~
9
9
e
OO
9 O OOOO
9
9
-00O N ~ O O ~ I
9O
9
O ~ ~ m . gOB ~ O ~ go ~ ~ ~ 9~ ~ ~
20-
~1761769
mOO
9 0 9 ooo H a D O9 9~ O ~ O O O ~ ~ O O O O~ ~ ~ U~ O o
o~
alJo ~176176
9
%
9
9 9
9 Oo
9
9
~
iSiSlX~
~ 9 O N B
~ i o
i i
o
~o~o
o
o ~~ , o ooo~9
r.f) t-
m0 U
0
o 9
9 1 4 9 aBOO 9
z..
,~o"
tO
o~ooO 9 ~IN~OO
U) 0
gmmB
"0
o')
m O0~O
10-
9
080
.o 9 So 9 4, 8, o% 9 m
T ;O O R
o #B m o m D
o o
I
I
~ c~
Corrected
I
~ c~
3rd
~ d
position
I
~. 6
d
transversions
FIGURE 2 The accumulation of transition differences at the third position of codons in the ND2 gene. The pairwise differences among 56 sequences representing 4 5 species of cichlid fish are plotted. The x axis is the observed proportion of third position differences corrected for multiple hits according to a Poisson model [(x = - 0 . 5 l n ( 1 - 2(proportion of differences))].
B. Changes in First and Second Positions and Amino Acid Substitution At the first and second position of codons, selection dominates the substitution process. This is apparent from the rate of transition substitution, which is 6and 15-fold slower at first and second positions, respectively, than the rate at third positions (Fig. 4). Because there is no reason to suspect a slower mutation rate at these sites, the difference must arise because selection prevents fixation of most mutations. Selection also constrains the maximum amount of difference that is observed between two sequences. Second positions plateau at approximately 3% transition differ-
ence, while first positions plateau at about 8%. The comparable value at third positions is 25%. Selective constraint has a strong effect on base composition, which differs among the three codon positions. First positions are relatively rich in GC because of the high leucine and alanine content of the ND2 protein. Second positions show a high proportion of T and C (37.9 and 30.4%, respectively), probably because hydrophobic amino acids required for this membranespanning protein are encoded by either C or T at the second position (Naylor et al., 1995). Probably the most important characteristic of selective constraint is that it varies from site to site along the molecule according to the structural function of the
0.45
0
0 ~ ~176176176 o @ o o o o
0.35 + 0 ~ 0 0
0
0.3 r~
= 0.25
o TC
r~
r..,
9 AG
0.2
0.15
9 *~ p-w.,,.
0.1
~
9
0.05
04 0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
0.4
0.45
Corrected T v FIGURE 3 Differences in the accumulation of transition differences involving purines ( 0 ) and pyrimidines ( 0 ). Because the frequencies of A and G are very unequal, saturation for sequence difference occurs earlier, and at a lower value, than for C and T.
0.15
0.08
E
.2 o C x_.
o
0.10 1 o
E
o
.2 m
0
E . 01 "~ E t~ x_
0.06-
C
0.04 -
0 ~0
0
O~
013
I O ~0
m:) aD CD~OO O Or ~300 O CXD~I31D OD OQ3 Or O(D O D O O3~UU30 O ~3
0
O O O O OCDO
O
ID Ol1~
0.05 O r'~
0 r'~
0.02- 1 D O
"O c"
0.00 - ~
o
o
,
CM I
I
0.00
I
3rd
position
transversions
3rd
0.I00
I
I
/
position
transversions
0.04
.2
C 0
o
o
X--
0.075 -
> r c
oo
Or
0.03 -
0 C~330 0
C. . . . . . . . . . ~ 0
0
0.02 C . n0 .n
0
0.025
o
0 GI.
0
0 0 ~ 0
L.
0.050 C 0 .I 0
I
o
C
> o'} c
- '"~ ' v " ' ~
o
0
O0
~
0
C~ O
O0
0
l
0.01 -
I O 0
o
O0 0
0.000
I
3rd
position
I
I
transversions
0.00
i
3rd
I
position
I
I
transversions
FIGURE 4 Accumulation of sequence difference at the first and second codon positions. The rate of accumulation of transition substitutions is 6- and 15-fold slower, respectively, than at the third positions.
18
THOMAS D. KOCHER AND KAREN L. CARLETON
.
4 2
Position
in
ND2
FIGURE 5 Proportion of variable sites in each segment of the ND2 protein. An index of probable helical structure is presented above the graph. Variable sites are clustered in the membrane-spanning helices of the protein.
encoded protein. Some positions in the protein can accept substitution relatively easily, whereas selection acts to prevent substitution at others. In ND2, this pattern of constraint can be visualized by plotting the proportion of variable sites along the molecule (Fig. 5). For many mitochondrially encoded proteins, the membrane-spanning helices of the protein experience high levels of substitution, whereas the turns between these helices appear relatively conserved (e.g., Irwin et al., 1991). The structure of ND2 is less well known, but it appears that regions of the protein outside the membrane may be constrained by selection for appropriate contacts with other proteins. If selection did not alter substitutional probabilities among sites we might expect to model the occurrence of multiple hits using a Poisson distribution. In fact, real molecules rarely fit a Poisson. Table I shows the number of changes per site estimated by parsimony over a tree for 10 closely related cichlids. The 72 inferred substitutions are distributed among just 53 of the 348 positions in the sequence. These data do not fit a model in which substitutions occur randomly along the sequence. Rather, the significant deviation from Poisson expectation demonstrates that the substitutions are clustered at a relatively small number of sites. It appears that selection is preventing substitutions at a large fraction of sites. Because the magnitude of selective constraint is likely to be a continuously distributed variable, it is most appropriate to model this variation as a gamma distribution. The gamma distribution uses an additional parameter to quantify the variance in rate among sites. Most real sequences can be modeled rather well with this distribution.
Fitch and Markowitz (1970) coined the term covarion to describe the set of "concomitantly variable codon positions." In their view, only a small proportion of the codons for a protein can experience an amino acid substitution at any given instant (the covarion). Substitution is thought to slowly alter the selective constraints so that the sites making up the covarion change over time (Fitch, 1971). The data in Table I can be made to fit a Poisson model, if it is assumed that the covarion con-
TABLE I Estimated Distribution of the N u m b e r of A m i n o Acid Substitutions per Site Estimated over a Parsimony Tree of 10 East African Cichlid Taxa a,b N u m b e r of changes per site over tree
Assuming 348 variable sites Observed Poisson expectation ,u = 22.32, p << 0.001 Assuming 100 variable sites Observed t ,2 = 0.1713, p > 0.9
0
1
2+
295 282.96
37 58.54
16 6.48
47 48.68
37 35.05
16 16.28
aThe 10 species and their assumed relationships are (((((Rhamphochromis sp., (Lethrinops aurita, Pseudotropheus zebra)), Gnathochromis pfefferi), (((Callochromis macrops, Opthalmotilapia ventralis) , Xenotilapia flavipinnus), Perissodus microlepis)), Limnochromis auritus), and Paracyprichromis brieni). bThe total length of the tree was 72 substitutions, including three sites that experienced at least 3 substitutions. Data fit a Poisson distribution of substitutions among sites, if it is assumed that only 100 of the 348 sites can accept a substitution.
2. BaseSubstitution in Fish mtDNA sists of only 100 of the amino acid sites. Selection may be acting to prevent subsitutions at the other 48 sites in the molecule. Miyamoto and Fitch (1995) demonstrate that the covarion model is more biologically correct than models based on the gamma distribution. It remains to be seen whether the difference between the covarion and the gamma models is important to phylogenetic analysis and whether the covarion model can be mathematically formulated for convenient use.
IV. Implications for Phylogenetic Reconstruction A. Choosing a Model There are two important decisions to be made when attempting to recover phylogenetic information from an analysis of molecular sequences. First, a substitutional model must be chosen which accurately models the evolution of the molecule under study, including whether rates vary among sites. Second, a particular tree-building algorithm must be selected. Although much has been written about the accuracy of various tree-construction algorithms, the choice of a substitutional model probably has a far greater impact on the phylogenetic conclusions. Since the pattern of evolution varies among genes (e.g., nuclear versus mitochondrial), it is important to adjust the substitution model for each analysis. Some tree-building algorithms allow this modeling more easily than others because the assumptions are more explicit or the model more easily adjusted. In general, it is easier to adjust the evolutionary model using methods which first calculate a distance statistic. Probably the best is the gamma distance developed by Tamura and Nei (1993), which incorporates transition/transversion bias, compositional inequalities, and variance in rate among sites. Once accurate distances are calculated, almost all tree algorithms will yield the correct topology (Huelsenbeck and Hillis, 1993). The neighborjoining algorithm (Saitou and Nei, 1987), for example, can construct trees from distance matrices calculated according to many different models. There are several advantages to focusing on the development of a distance matrix prior to initiating tree construction. First, calculation of the distance matrix focuses attention on the model of sequence evolution to be used. Second, it is usually more efficient to estimate topologies from a distance matrix than by searching for minimum evolution trees among a universe of possible topologies.
19
Third, it is easier to calculate standard errors for each divergence than to evaluate the support for nodes using a bootstrap approach. This is particularly true for sequences that are near saturation.
B. Power A n a l y s i s for m t D N A Phylogenetics Because of the heterogeneous nature of evolution along a DNA sequence, sites differ in the amount of information they carry about a particular phylogenetic relationship. It is important to determine which sites and classes of change give the greatest signal/noise ratio for testing a particular phylogenetic hypothesis. Characters must be chosen to match the time scale of the divergences being studied. An analysis using third position transitions to evaluate basal (60-80 MYBP) relationships in the Cichlidae would be fundamentally flawed, since these substitutions are completely saturated after about 10 MY of divergence (Fig. 2). Neither would it be appropriate to focus exclusively on third position transversions to recover relationships among close relatives because of the large amount of information that would be lost by not including transitions. We wish to know which characters from the ND2 sequence give the greatest power for resolving relationships among cichlids at various divergences. First, we must specify the model for the evolution of bases in the sequence. Because of the importance of both base composition and variance in rate among sites, the TamuraNei gamma-distance model is the most appropriate for these data. This model describes how sequences diverge through time by calculating the expected proportion of transitional differences for purines (P1) and pyrimidines (P2) and the expected proportion of transversional differences (Q). The mean values of these expected differences are used, assuming that rates vary among sites according to a gamma distribution [Tamura and Nei (1993) Eqs. (12-14)]:
12gAgG{ XR
gR --
[
a
q- gy ( ~2
]
__ a a + 2(gR ~1 + gy~)t a )a} a + 2~t
2gwgc{ _ [ a ] gy gY a + 2(gy a 2 -~-gR~)t
a
-Jr-XR( a + a2~t )a} I (a + a2~t )al'
-- 2gRgY 1 --
(2)
(3)
(4)
20
THOMAS D. KOCHER AND KAREN L. CARLETON
mulating during a time interval, At, from
~dPl dP2~ aP = \
B
C
1,
~
2,
3, or
(8)
dt + dt / a t
dQ A Q = -d-~ At .
IOMY
X
FIGURE 6 Hypothetical phylogeny used in the power analysis, Taxa B and C share a period of common ancestry (1, 2, 5, or 10 MY) after their divergence from taxon A. Subsequent analyses examine the power of different classes of mtDNA character to resolve this relationship after different periods of terminal divergence (x).
(9)
Typical parameters for vertebrate evolution can be obtained from the cichlid ND2 sequences as follows. Gene frequencies are determined from the sequence data. If we assume m
n
m
we can solve for a and fl using Eq. (5) plus Eq. (6) and Eq. (7) to get the following equations: where gA, go, gc, and gT are the nucleotide frequencies, a is the g a m m a parameter, C~l and ~2 are the rates for transitional changes for purines or pyrimidines, and fl is the rate for transversional change. These equations give the t i m e - d e p e n d e n t differences between two sequences. We use the equations for P and Q rather than s and v as they clearly represent data regarding the saturation of sequence differences resulting from multiple substitutions. We consider the power of the first, second, or third position transitions or transversions to identify a 1 MY period of shared ancestry between sequences B and C, after their divergence from sequence A (see Fig. 6), at various times in the past. This is done by first calculating the n u m b e r of sequence differences accumulating in that 1 MY interval, at various times in the past. In order to calculate the n u m b e r of differences, AP or AQ which accumulate within some time interval we need to calculate the derivatives of the previously described equations:
m
4gAge f ~(XR~I 4- gyfl) gR [
dP1 dt
[
a
a + 2(gR~l
]a+l
+ gyfl)t
_ -
[
gwfl
dt
a a + 2(gy~2 4- gR-fi)t
dQ dt = 4gRgYfl
--gRfl
[
a a 4- 2fit
a ]a+l} a + 2-fit
]al
"
and
Using Figs. 2 through 4, we can estimate d P / d t and d Q / d t at time t = 0. The parameters determined from the ND2 data are given in Table II. G a m m a values are taken from an analysis of m a m m a l i a n cytochrome b genes (Irwin et al., 1991). Figure 7 plots the n u m b e r of sequence differences accumulating in the 1 MY interval of interest at various times in the past. We have calculated the average value of Ap or AQ over the I MY time interval. Clearly, third position transitions contribute the greatest n u m b e r of changes in the first few million y e a r s m m o r e than all the other characters combined. With time and the effects of saturation, the accumulation of third position transition differences decreases. After only 5 MY, the combination of changes at first and second positions with third position transversions
a + 2 f- i t
__ [
]a+X
4(gAga + gwgc)
TABLE H
__ 4XTXCxy{(XY~2 4- XR~) [
=
dQ _ dt ( t = O) fl = . 4gRgY
Parameters for the Estimation of Expected Sequence Divergence and Associated Errors a
]a+l}a
(5) dP2
dP d t ( t = O)
(6) (7)
Based on these derivatives, we can calculate the n u m ber of transitional or transversional differences accu-
Parameter freq A, gA freq G, ga freq C, gc freq T, XT gamma, a dP/dt (t = 0) dQ/dt (t = 0) ]~
First position
Second position
Third position
0.295 0.196 0.331 0.178 0.4 1.7 0.5 3.64 0.50
0.160 0.113 0.354 0.373 0.25 0.7 0.2 1.17 0.25
0.318 0.048 0.377 0.257 5 10 1 22.3 1.08
aIn accordance with the Tamura-Nei gamma distance model discussed in the text.
2. Base Substitution in Fish mtDNA
netic signal uniting taxa B and C will be hidden by the variance associated with the long terminal branches. These crossing points have been calculated for various periods of common ancestry (1, 2, 5, and 10 MY) for data sets of various sizes (102 codons representing typical cytochrome b fragment data, 348 codons representing the cichlid ND2 data set, 1000 codons representing approximately three mitochondrial genes, and 3754 codons representing the complete coding regions for human mitochondrial DNA) as a function of the terminal branch length. Figure 9 summarizes the calculations in a format useful for planning phylogenetic studies. To use the figure, first determine the approximate time of divergence for the taxa under study (either through fossil evidence or by estimating third position transversion difference from a pilot study). Next, identify the curve associated with the desired degree of resolution (1, 2, 5, or 10 MY between divergences). Finally, read the number of codons which must be sequenced from the y-axis.
9 Total
<> l A P 9 1AQ 2AP | 2AQ 3AP
9
9 3AQ
15
Z 9
9 9
9
9
9
"".,-.:;;.......... 9
o
"
9
9
9
*"
|
~''
:
:
5
~ 10
15
21
20
40
--
35
--
30
--
Time (MYA)
FIGURE 7 The number of sequence differences accumulating in a 1 MY interval at various times in the past and observed at time zero. Third position transitions contribute the greatest n u m b e r of differences over the recent past, but the sum of transitions and transversions at first and second positions soon dominates.
AP
-"
G(P)
contributes a greater number of differences in a 1 MY interval than do third positions transitions. This plot represents only the signal, however. There will also be variability in the differences between the sequences resulting from the variance contributed by the differences estimates from the long terminal branches of the tree. This variability will contribute noise which, if large enough, will obscure the signal we hope to observe. The noise is determined from the standard deviation which is simply related to the variance. The binomial variance and standard deviations for P and Q are given by var(P) = var(Q) -
P(1
-
P)
Q(1 - Q)
o-(P) = )nP(1
-
25
t,., o
20
15
10
P) o
tr(Q) = )nQ(1 - Q)
~
0
I
I
I
I
J
2
4
6
8
10
Time(MYA)
Figure 8 plots both the number of changes contributed in a I MY interval at various times in the past and the standard deviation associated with differences accumulated on the terminal branches. The crossing points of the curves give an indication of when the phyloge-
FIGURE 8 The number of differences attributable to a 1 MY period of common ancestry ( 9 compared with the standard error associated with the changes on the terminal branches (el). The noise accumulated on the terminal branches will s w am p the signal arising from shared ancestry after only 2.5 MY. Plotted is 1.96 times the standard error for third position transition differences.
22
T H O M A S D. KOCHER A N D K A R E N L. C A R L E T O N
o //~
IT o
:
3000
e
;
" :"
l
' ;
I
:J
i
;I
:
:
i
;
;'
/
"
:
.~
"
-: .9
i ,'
i
i
"
,
,'
...
.:"
~
I
,
:"'"
'
I
i
.
2000
/
'
~
o
,
;
/
l
I
/
:9 I
,,:
i
/
I
I
I
i
"
0
i
I
/"
;
/
/
/'
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
4000
~
3000
II! ,~0
:
.:i
-
,
i :
2000
//
9
I
1
: '
!
/
/ ,
;
:
/
I
I..~: /
~a...~ ~
2P
O l
I
I
I
,a" I
I
.,,
2000
lil
_.~,~
:I
1ooo
I
! :i
0 O
I O
I O
r
I O
Oh
I O
~l"
I O
~
I O
~
I O
I~
Terminal
I ~
O0
3" I I O
O~
I 0
0
branch
5
/ 6
O
,-~
10
/
:tti I I O
I
9
2
l
". : ::,l
-
I
9
"::
3000
2Q
I
I O r
length
'
. ,a
:
I O
O~
I O
~
I O ~
' I O
~
I O
I~-
I' ~
O0
0
O~
(MY)
FIGURE 9 Power analysis for mitochondrial sequence data. The situation considered is shown in Fig. 6. The n u m b e r of codons required to detect 1, 2, 5, or 10 MY periods of c o m m o n ancestry, at v a r i o u s times in the past. The base composition and rates of evolution of the cichlid ND2 gene (Table II) are assumed. The curves represent the n u m b e r of codons required so that I SD of the estimate of terminal branch length is equal to the m e a n n u m b e r of differences arising along the internal branch of the tree. Data are shown for transitions (AP) and transversions (AQ) in first (1), second (2), and third (3) positions. The x axis assumes a transversion divergence of 1% per million years. A spreadsheet is available from the authors for calculating crossing values for taxa with radically different base compositions or rate matrices.
2. Base Substitution in Fish mtDNA Several findings can be gleaned from these graphs. First, it is quite surprising that, even with the complete ND2 sequence, none of the characters have power to resolve a 1 MY difference beyond about 2.5 MY (only transitions at third positions are effective over this period). More slowly accumulating differences (e.g., changes at first and second positions), although not saturated (Fig. 4), are not effective in resolving the relationship because of the large variance associated with the small number of substitutions. Second, the greatest statistical power, even for deeply divergent lineages, is found in the third position transversion data. This is because third position transversions accumulate relatively rapidly and do so in a nearly Poisson fashion. The slower rates, and greater variation in rate among sites for other characters, sharply reduce their power. The third surprising finding is that mtDNA data have the potential to resolve rather deep divergences. Complete mitochondrial coding sequences should be able to resolve a 10% difference in divergence times, even 75 MY in the past. However, 100 codons give only coarse resolution for very recent events. We expect that this figure will be accurate for most vertebrate mtDNAs. Our preliminary examination of other taxa suggests that base composition is an important determinant of the power for resolving short time periods of shared ancestry. However, it is clear that a variation in rates among sites is the single most important factor affecting the performance of a given sequence in phylogenetic analysis. Differences in the assumed gamma parameter can have a dramatic effect on the accuracy of distance estimation.
V. Conclusions A. Choice o f m t D N A Sequence Characters It is well known that third position transitions, although useful for recent divergences, saturate rapidly. It is somewhat surprising that transversions at the third position outperform changes (both transitions and transversions) at the first and second codon positions. The advantage seems to arise because third position transversions approximate a Poisson distribution, whereas strong selection at first and second positions creates a large variance in substitution probability among sites.
B. Power Analysis Poor resolution of branching order deep in the tree is a common result in phylogenetic analyses. Investi-
23
gators frequently attribute this result to rapid radiation of the taxa in question. The alternative, that data are simply insufficient to resolve even moderately spaced speciation events, is rarely considered objectively. The graphs in Fig. 9 are a good tool for gauging the power of a particular data set to resolve closely spaced bifurcations. The steep slopes of the curves suggest that many published studies may have failed to gather sufficient data to detect even a 10% difference in divergence times.
C. A d e q u a c y o f M u t a t i o n a l Models Selection dominates the substitution process at almost all sites in the mitochondrial genome. It is therefore surprising that the models of sequence evolution most often used in phylogenetic analysis still focus on the mutation process. Use of mutation-based models is probably not appropriate for anything but third position transitions (Xia et al., 1996). Approaches that explicitly model the selection filter should be pursued, as they may allow modeling of sequence divergence further back in time.
D. Reality of Rate Variation Suggestions have been made that the rate of mitochondrial DNA evolution varies among lineages (e.g., Martin et al., 1992; Bermingham et al., 1997). Attention has begun to shift toward identifying physiological correlates which might account for this rate variation (Martin and Palumbi, 1993; Rand, 1994). While rate variation may well exist, the search for the causes of such variation may be premature. The rate of substitution is the result of a delicate interplay of forces, including mutation, selective constraints arising at both molecular and organismal levels, and population-level events. We should be careful not to jump from poorly supported correlations to hypotheses of causation. It is hoped that this chapter will promote the development of a consistent set of evolutionary rate estimates, incorporating corrections for both unequal base composition and patterns of selective constraint. When used in relative-rate tests, or well-substantiated absolute calibrations of evolution rate, these estimates may lead to new hypotheses on both the generality of mitochondrial clocks and the forces which regulate their ticking. A further benefit is that the refinement of substitution models will improve our ability to reconstruct phylogenetic relationships among species.
Acknowledgments Many thanks to those who helped focus our thinking, including N. Perna, and several classes of Zoology 715. This work was supported in part by NSF Grant BSR-9007015.
24
THOMAS D. KOCHER A N D KAREN L. CARLETON
References Bermingham, E., McCafferty, S. S., and Martin, A. P. 1997. Fish biogeography and molecular clocks: Perspectives from the Panamanian Isthmus. In "'Molecular Systematics of Fishes'" (T. D. Kocher and C. A. Stepien, eds.). Academic Press, San Diego. Bliss, C. I., and Fisher, R. A. 1953. Fitting the negative binomial distribution to biological data. Biometrics 9:176-200. Felsenstein, J. 1986. DNAML-DNA Maximum Likelihood Program. PHYLIP Manual, version 3.2. Department of Genetics, University of Washington, Seattle. Fitch, W. M. 1971b. The nonidentity of invariable positions in the cytochromes c of different species. Biochem. Genet. 5:231-241. Fitch, W. M., and Markowitz, E. 1970. An improved method for determining codon variability in a gene and its application to the rate of fixation of mutations in evolution. Biochem. Genet. 4:579-593. Huelsenbeck, J.P., and Hillis, D. M. 1993. Success of phylogenetic methods in the four-taxon case. Syst. Biol. 42:247-264. Irwin, D. M., Kocher, T. D., and Wilson, A. C. 1991. Evolution of the cytochrome b gene of mammals. J. Mol. Evol. 32:128-144. Jukes, T. H., and Cantor, C. R. 1969. Evolution of protein molecules. In "Mammalian Protein Metabolism" (H. N. Munro, ed.), Vol. III, pp. 21-132. Academic Press, New York. Kimura, M. 1980. A simple method for estimating evolutionary rate of base substitution through comparative studies of nucleotide sequences. J. Mol. Evol. 16:111-120. Kocher, T. D., Conroy, J. A., McKaye, K. R., Stauffer, J. R., and Lockwood, S. F. 1995. Evolution of the ND2 gene in East African cichlids. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 4: 420-432. Kocher, T. D., and Wilson, A. C. 1991. Sequence evolution of mitochondrial DNA in humans and chimpanzees: Control region and a protein-coding region. In "Evolution of Life: Fossils, Molecules, and Culture" (S. Osawa and T. Honjo, eds.), pp. 391-413. Springer-Verlag, Tokyo.
Martin, A. P., Naylor, G. J. P., and Palumbi, S. R. 1992. Rates of mitochondrial DNA evolution in sharks are slow compared with mammals. Nature 357:153-155. Martin, A. P., and Palumbi, S. R. 1993. Body size, metabolic rate, generation time, and the molecular clock. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90: 4087-4091. Miyamoto, M. M., and Fitch, W. M. 1995. Testing the covarion hypothesis of molecular evolution. MoI. Biol. Evol. 12:503-513. Naylor, G. J., Collins, T. M., and Brown, W. M. 1995. Hydrophobicity and phylogeny. Nature 373:565-566. Perna, N. T. 1996. Patterns of base composition within and between animal mitochondrial genomes. Ph.D. Thesis, University of New Hampshire. Rand, D. M. 1994. Thermal habit, metabolic rate and the evolution of mitochondrial DNA. Trends Ecol. Evol. 9:125-131. Rzhetsky, A., and Nei, M. 1995. Tests of applicability of several substitution models for DNA sequence data. Mol. Biol. Evol. 12: 131-151. Saitou, N., and Nei, M. 1987. The neighbor-joining method: A new method for reconstructing phylogenetic trees. Mol. Biol. Evol. 4: 406 -425. Tamura, I., and Nei, M. 1993. Estimation of the number of nucleotide substitutions in the control region of mitochondrial DNA in humans and chimpanzees. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10:512-526. Uzzell, T., and Corbin, K. W. 1971. Fitting discrete probability distributions to evolutionary events. Science 172:1089-1096. Wilson, A. C., Cann, R. L., Carr, S. M., George, M., Jr., Gyllensten, U. B., Helm-Bychowski, K. M., Higuchi, R. G., Palumbi, S. R., Prager, E. M., Sage, R. D., and Stoneking, M. 1985. Mitochondrial DNA and two perspectives on evolutionary genetics. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 26:375-400. Xia, X., Hafner, M. S., and Sudman, P. D. 1996. On transition bias in mitochondrial genes of pocket gophers. J. Mol. Evol. 43:32-40.
C H A P T E R
3 Molecular Systematics of a Rapidly Evolving Species Flock: The mbuna of Lake Malawi and the Search for Phylogenetic Signal IRV KORNFIELD and ALEX PARKER Department of Zoology and School of Marine Sciences University of Maine Orono, Maine 04469
I. I n t r o d u c t i o n
Lake Malawi, an ecologically diverse assemblage of approximately 300 species, most still to be formally described. Geological studies (Scholz and Rosendahl, 1988; Gasse et al., 1989; Owen et al., 1990) and comparative molecular analyses (Kornfield, 1978; see later) strongly suggest that the mbuna are of extremely recent vintage. This chapter briefly describes the natural history of this endemic fauna, reviews previous molecular studies designed to understand relationships within the group, considers microsatellite markers, and evaluates their utility for exploration of mbuna interrelationships. Initial recognition of the special nature of the mbuna was made by Regan (1921) and Trewavas (1935), who defined numerous genera based on earlier collections made by Christy. The mbuna are a diverse assemblage of lithophilous, algae-grazing fishes, currently allocated among 13 genera (Moran and Kornfield, 1993). A general overview of the unique trophic attributes of some of these species was provided by Fryer (1959a,b) and later expanded by Fryer and Iles (1972) to include the first integrated evolutionary treatment of the fauna. Numerous workers have subsequently described new taxa, occasionally discussing variation within particular lineages (e.g., Marsh et al., 1981; Lewis, 1982; Rib-
One of the most difficult problems in phylogenetic analysis is the reconstruction of rapid radiations involving large numbers of taxa. If sequential speciation events occur quickly, even assuming that divergence occurs solely via bifurcation (versus, e.g., hybridization), only minimal signals or synapomorphic traces will be present. Given sufficient time, of course, independent lineages so created will become recognizable due to the acquisition of divergent character states. However, although derived diagnostic characters may be of taxonomic utility, as autapomorphies they are phylogenetically uninformative. Most difficult are those systems in which rapid radiation has occurred very recently; in such cases, even autapomorphies may be absent. Reconstruction of the phylogenetic history of several of the species flocks (Mayr, 1984) of Old World haplochromine cichlids presents precisely such a challenge. This chapter considers the mbuna 1 cichlid fauna of 1The Malawi rockfishes are known as mbuna (Chichewa) in the territorial waters of Malawi and Mozambique,and as vindongo (Swahili) in Tanzanianwaters.
MOLECULAR SYSTEMATICS OF FISHES
25
Copyright 9 1997 by Academic Press. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
26
IRV KORNFIELD A N D A L E X PARKER
bink et al., 1983a; Reinthal, 1990a). General understanding of evolutionary dynamics and ecology followed the detailed field studies of Ribbink et al. (1983b) who, for the first time, described the extent of lakewide variation present in putative conspecifics. Subsequent descriptive accounts by Konings (1990) and DeMason (1993) have suggested the presence of numerous additional taxa in previously unexplored regions of the lake. Although it is clear that they form a monophyletic group (Moran et al., 1994), few detailed phylogenetic hypotheses regarding relationships among mbuna have been articulated (Fryer and Iles, 1972; Oliver, 1984; Reinthal, 1987). The principal reasons for the absence of such hypotheses are the paucity of morphological synapomorphies (Reinthal, 1987) and the general propensity for convergent and/or parallel evolution among cichlids (Eccles and Trewavas, 1989; Lazzaro, 1991). A statistically robust phylogeny is critical to meaningful discussion of patterns of species diversification and ecological radiation in the mbuna; without such a phylogeny, all evolutionary patterns, and the mechanisms suggested to have engendered them (Liem, 1980; Dominey, 1984; Greenwood, 1984; Mayr, 1984; Turner, 1994), remain hypothetical. For example, homogeneity of coloration is taken by some authors to imply conspecificity among allopatric populations (see Lewis, 1981; Ribbink et al., 1983b); coloration, however, may be a convergent characteristic (Eccles and Trewavas, 1989; McElroy et al., 1991) or may be constrained by species packing in isolated communities (D. McElroy and I. Kornfield, unpublished observations). Similarly, many morphological correlates of trophic specialization (Reinthal, 1990a,b) may be convergent.
II. Molecular Investigations Reconstructing the evolutionary history of the mbuna by molecular means (Kornfield, 1991) has proved extremely difficult, due principally to the recency of their radiation. Isozyme analyses have provided compelling evidence of reproductive isolation among extremely similar forms (Kornfield, 1978; McKaye et al., 1982, 1984), but for a variety of reasons, allozymes cannot be used to reconstruct evolutionary relationships. In particular, the degree of variation present at individual loci is limited; most exhibit only a few electromorphs and no taxon-specific (diagnostic) alleles are present. Importantly, the limited number of characters provided by allozymes (as either loci or alleles) severely constrains objective statistical evaluation of these data.
III. Mitochondrial D N A and Ancestral Polymorphisms With the advent of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) analysis in evolutionary studies (reviewed in Avise, 1994), it was hoped that basic problems of cichlid phylogenetics would be resolved. This hope was founded on properties of mtDNA that were expected to allow greater resolution than previously achieved in molecular systematic studies; particularly important are high mutation rates (Brown et al., 1979) and selective neutrality or near-neutrality of many nucleotide positions (see Niki et al., 1989; Rand et al., 1994). Indeed, some systematic problems, intractable using allozyme analysis, yielded solutions with mtDNA (Avise et al., 1986; Seyoum and Kornfield, 1992a). Comparative studies of relationships within the Malawi cichlid fauna by restriction (Moran et al., 1994) and sequence analysis (Meyer et al., 1990) of mtDNA provided an unambiguous definition of portions of the endemic radiation. In particular, the basic dichotomy between mbuna and most of the remaining haplochromines was supported, as were the affinities of a few well-differentiated lineages (summarized in Meyer, 1993). Additionally, previously unsuspected relationships between the mbuna and some taxa of very divergent morphology and habitat (e.g., Alticorpus and Lethrinops) were revealed (Moran et al., 1994). Despite these successes, resolution of relationships within the mbuna remained problematic. Two major mtDNA lineages (or and/3), differing by 1.5% sequence divergence, were identified within the mbuna, but the affinities of the taxa involved appeared aberrant; several species were more closely related to taxa in other genera than to congeners. The solution to this problem was obtained when sample sizes were increased: the mbuna retained an ancestral mtDNA polymorphism (Moran and Kornfield, 1993). Comprehensive mtDNA restriction analysis demonstrated that both c~ and/3 mtDNA haplotypes were present in geographically defined populations of a number of common mbuna species. Thus, the relationships among these taxa based on mtDNA (Moran et al., 1994) represent a gene tree (Pamilo and Nei, 1988) in which lineage sorting (Avise et al., 1984) is incomplete; clearly these data should not be interpreted as a species tree. The extent of this polymorphism among the mbuna has been examined using sequence analysis of the dloop region (Parker and Kornfield, 1997). This study confirms the existence of the polymorphism and defines several divergent gene lineages based on site-specific transitions (Table I). With a few interesting exceptions (see later), most mbuna species are polymorphic. It is instructive to consider what the consequences
3. Molecular Systematics of mbuna Polymorphic Nucleotide Positions in the mtDNA Control Region of Six mbuna Species a
TABLE I.
Nucleotide position b
Pseudotropheus zebra "BB" 1 P. zebra "BB" 2 P. zebra "black dorsal" Labeotropheus trewavasae L. fuelleborni I L. fuelIeborni 2 Melanochromis auratus M. parallelus I M. parallelus 2
1
2
2
3
7 9
4 7
7 0
4 2
T C C C T C C C C
T C C C C C C T C
C T T T C T T C C
C T T T C T T C C
aFrom Parker and Kornfield, 1997. bN u m b e r i n g of nucleotide positions follows Bowers et al. (1994).
of complete lineage sorting would be for phylogenetic analysis of this fauna. Two species of mbuna possess only one of the major haplotype lineages: all studied individuals (n = 30) of Pseudotropheus zebra "black dorsal," an undescribed species endemic to the Maleri Islands, exhibit the ]~3 mtDNA haplotype (Moran and Kornfield, 1995; Parker and Kornfield, 1997, as do all individuals (n = 99) of Melanochromis auratus (Bowers et al., 1994; Parker and Kornfield, 1997). Both cr and ]~J3 mtDNA lineages are present in populations of Pseudotropheus tropheops "black" (Moran and Kornfield, 1993). If P. tropheops "black" were to lose the ]3 lineage, perhaps by genetic drift (Moran and Kornfield, 1995), subsequent mtDNA comparisons would unite M. auratus and P. zebra "black dorsal" to the exclusion of P. tropheops "black," resulting in a phylogenetic hypothesis entirely at odds with available morphological and ecological data. Thus, if lineage sorting was complete in the mbuna, the reconstructed tree would provide completely misleading results. McMillan and Palumbi (1995) reached a similar conclusion regarding Pacific butterflyfishes, suggesting that the random assortment of shared ancestral lineages may blur the evolutionary history of newly formed species. Additionally, variation in rates of population growth can generate significant differences in lineage diversity among taxa (Penny et al., 1995). For mtDNA to be phylogenetically informative in such cases, lineages must independently acquire new mutations in addition to simple reduction, via genetic drift, of the number of ancestral haplotypes present. Given the recent derivation of this fauna, and presumed rates of mtDNA mutation, such differentiation is unlikely within the mbuna.
27
IV. A l t e r n a t e M o l e c u l a r A p p r o a c h e s
If mtDNA cannot provide sufficient information to resolve relationships within the mbuna, are there other molecular systems that can be exploited? It is important, of course, that such alternate approaches provide information useful beyond simple taxonomic discrimination. At least three classes of molecular markers might potentially be so employed. Variation in randomly amplified polymorphic DNAs (RAPDs) (Williams et al., 1990) has been exploited to identify subspecies of Oreochromis niloticus by Bardakci and Skibinski (1994). These taxa can not be differentiated by allozyme analysis, but do possess diagnostic mtDNA restriction profiles (Seyoum and Kornfield, 1992a,b). Although both RAPDs and mtDNA provide diagnostic markers for subspecies, neither data set provides unambiguous statistical support for relationships among the taxa. The extent of sequence divergence between subspecies (Seyoum and Kornfield, 1992a) is about half of that observed between a and ~ lineages in the mbuna; it is thus possible that RAPDs could be used to infer relationships among mbuna species. This approach is compelling from a statistical perspective because the products of a large number of random primers can be characterized. However, the extent of RAPD variation within natural populations of cichlids has not yet been examined and may be considerably greater than that seen in the inbred aquaculture strains examined to date. Further, the technical problems associated with RAPD analysis (e.g., Ellsworth et al., 1993), as well as ambiguity of locus homology between more distantly related taxa, suggest a cautious approach to the use of such data. As an alternative, DNA sequences associated with individual RAPD primers can be characterized. However, an initial examination of such data suggests that the phylogenetic signal thus obtained may be limited in very closely related taxa such as mbuna (Sultmann et al., 1995). Extensive sequence variation has been demonstrated in mbuna at major histocompatibility complex (Mhc) loci (Klein et al., 1993; Ono et al., 1993). This extremely variable system has been useful in the population genetic analysis of mammalian taxa (Klein, 1986). Significant impediments exist, however, in applying this system to mbuna phylogenetics. As in mtDNA, some portion of Mhc variation can be thought of as a retained ancestral polymorphism; allelic variants are shared by multiple taxa and predate speciation. More importantly, because much of this variation may be maintained by selection (Hughes and Nei, 1989), polymorphism will be retained. Finally, sequence variation
28
IRV KORNFIELD A N D ALEX PARKER
will be evolutionarily interpretable only if Mhc loci can be distinguished individually; previous studies have identified up to eight alleles per individual (Klein et al., 1993; Ono et al., 1993), indicating coamplification of a minimum of four loci. Assuming identification of individual loci and examination of only selectively neutral (fourfold degenerate) codon positions, rates of substitution must still have been sufficiently high to outpace speciation, if they are to allow discrimination of mbuna interrelationships. At this time it is unknown whether the Mhc system will fulfill all of the necessary criteria. More generally, sequence variation in other portions of the nuclear genome could potentially provide information sufficient for phylogenetic analysis; mutational mechanisms and methods for analysis of DNA sequences are well understood for nuclear genes. Variation at protein coding genes would, in general, be expected to provide insufficient sensitivity for the examination of closely related species, given selective constraints on molecular function and the paucity of variation in structural gene products revealed by electrophoretic studies. Although exon sequences are thus expected to be conservative, intron sequences may potentially exhibit more informative variation. Phylogenetic examinations of intron sequences are few in number to date, but interspecific differentiation in introns may be limited among closely related taxa. For example, comparisons of intron variation among humpback whale populations, which have very distinctive mtDNAs, were noninformative (Palumbi and Baker, 1994). In Old World cichlids, sequence comparison of the second intron of the growth hormone gene in Old World cichlids enabled discrimination of the three major tilapiine genera, but provided no information relevant to relationships among congeners (I. Kornfield and R. Mulrenin, unpublished observations). Use of anonymous single-copy DNA markers constitutes an additional approach to capturing genetic variation (Karl et al., 1992). However, observed allelic variation has been limited, even in extensively studied populations (Karl and Avise, 1993), and substantial methodological difficulties (Hare et al., 1996) may compromise their routine application. More generally, it is not clear whether introns (or exons) of other nuclear genes possess the high rates of mutation required for successful phylogenetic analysis of closely related taxa like the mbuna. Indeed, because mbuna mtDNA retains ancestral polymorphisms as described earlier, it seems unlikely that autosomal nuclear loci, with fourfold greater effective population sizes (Avise, 1994), would have undergone allelic fixation within lineages. Various classes of repetitive DNA (Charlesworth et al., 1994) have been examined in cichlids to assess
their phylogenetic potential. In tilapiines, several families of minisatellite repeats make up a considerable portion of the nuclear genome (Wright, 1989) and exhibit sequence variation both within and among lineages (Franck et al., 1992). Again, however, the phylogenetic signal appears limited to lineages that are demonstrably divergent by conventional molecular methods (Franck et al., 1994). It would therefore seem improbable that this class of markers will offer sufficient sensitivity for phylogenetic analyses within the mbuna.
V. Microsatellite Loci More promising is variation at microsatellite loci. Such loci can exhibit extremely large numbers of alleles, differing in the number of a simple nucleotide repeat unit present (Queller et al., 1993). Allelic variation is thought to be generated by intraallelic polymerase slippage during DNA replication (Bruford and Wayne, 1993), but details of the exact mechanism are not well understood. The fundamental appeal of microsatellite loci for systematic studies of the mbuna is that mutation rates are extremely high, in the range of 10 -3-10-4 per locus per generation (Dallas, 1992; Edwards et al., 1992). Consequently, variation in microsatellite allele frequencies is strongly influenced by mutation, in addition to genetic drift. Thus mutation-driven variation in population allele frequencies can greatly augment that engendered by genetic drift. In contrast, mutations in other classes of polymorphic nuclear markers, such as allozymes or Mhc alleles, occur by the relatively slow process of nucleotide substitution, whereas interpopulation variation in allele or electromorph frequencies occurs principally as a result of genetic drift. In light of the fact that insufficient time has passed for genetic drift to produce complete lineage sorting in mtDNA and the fourfold larger effective population size of diploid, biparentally inherited nuclear genes (versus haploid, maternally inherited mtDNA), the potential for informative variation in these markers may be limited. Mutation of microsatellite alleles has been modeled as a stepwise process, in which an allele consisting of a given number of repeat units may change by either loss or gain of a single repeat (Valdes et al., 1993). This model implies that pairs of alleles differing by a small number of repeats share a more recent common ancestor than those which differ greatly in repeat number; this potential information on relatedness of alleles is utilized by a novel, microsatellite-specific metric of ge-
3. Molecular Systematics of mbuna
netic distance (see later). The stepwise mutation model (SMM) also illustrates the potential for convergent evolution of alleles, as there is no obvious way to determine whether an allele of a given size is descended from an ancestor possessing a greater or lesser number of repeat units. More recent studies, however, suggest that the SMM incompletely describes the mutational process at microsatellite loci. Using data on the human population of Sardinia, DiRienzo et al. (1994) demonstrated that observed allele frequency distributions are better explained by a two-phase model, incorporating infrequent mutational changes of two or more repeat units, than by a model including only single-step mutation. If multistep mutations are common, and microsatellite alleles are therefore often dissimilar in size to their immediate ancestors, than the infinite alleles model (IAM) may be more appropriate. A result consistent with this possibility was obtained by Estoup et al. (1995), who found that observed heterozygosities and allelic diversities in honeybee populations agreed more closely with IAM expectations than with the stepwise model. In contrast to the conclusions of DiRienzo et al. (1994), however, Estoup et al. (1995) suggested that their data deviated from stepwise expectations because most of the loci they studied consisted of complex repeats, whereas the SMM assumes that microsatellite loci are unbroken tracts of a single sequence motif. Determination of which model better describes variation at microsatellite loci has important implications for analysis. If the IAM is superior, then use of a classical measure of genetic distance, such as Nei's distance (Nei, 1987), would be appropriate. If the SMM realistically approximates microsatellite evolution, however, the implication is that there may be more information available in microsatellite data than is embodied in simple allele frequencies. Because closely related alleles are similar in repeat number under the SMM, it follows that the mean number of repeats at a locus should be more similar in recently isolated species or populations than in more distantly related ones. This observation motivated development of the delta-# distance statistic (Goldstein et al., 1995), which incorporates repeat number as well as frequency of alleles. Goldstein et al. (1995) showed analytically that an increase in delta-/~ is linear with time and independent of populations size, as long as populations are in mutation-drift equilibrium. They also empirically evaluated the behavior of delta-#, Nei's distance, and allele sharing in analysis of both human and primate relationships. Their results indicated that delta-/~ is superior for reconstruction of more distant evolutionary patterns (e.g., h u m a n chimpanzee-gorilla relationships), probably because it
29
remains linear over a greater range of divergence, but that the classical distance metrics better reconstructed more recent relationships [e.g., among human populations; see e.g., Bowcock et al. (1994)]. Regardless of the method employed, several characteristics of microsatellite loci may complicate analysis. Most importantly, because microsatellite loci appear to be bounded in size, exhibiting an upper limit in repeat number (Bowcock et al., 1994), any genetic distance metric will eventually reach an asymptote. For the human data considered by Goldstein et al. (1995), the average time to asymptotic distance was estimated to be approximately 20,000 generations; for any particular locus, the duration of linearity prior to the asymptote is proportional to the range of repeat numbers present. Additionally, Rubensztein et al. (1995) suggest that comparison of human microsatellite data to that for other primates reveals the presence of directional mutation pressure at some loci. Ellegren et al. (1995), however, have argued convincingly that this result instead reflects biases in sampling of loci. Finally, the potential presence of null (nonamplifying) alleles (Paetkau et al., 1995; Pemberton et al., 1995) may be problematic, although investigators who are aware of this possibility can take steps to minimize its influence (see later). Two studies have demonstrated the enormous utility of microsatellite variation for analysis of population biology of individual mbuna species (Kellogg et al., 1995; Parker and Kornfield, 1996). In these studies, genotypes at hypervariable microsatellite loci were used to examine the magnitude of polyandry in several species. Although allelic distributions can be used to discriminate among mbuna species (A. Parker and I. Kornfield, unpublished observations), it has not yet been experimentally demonstrated that microsatellite variation can be used for phylogenetic reconstruction in cichlid fishes. This idea is evaluated next.
VI. A Test of the Phylogenetic Potential of Microsatellites Before initiating investigations, it is critical to provide, a priori, a fair test of the ability of microsatellites to provide phylogenetic data relevant to the mbuna. Evolutionary trees can be generated using virtually any data set, so unless relationships among the taxa examined have previously been defined, any result might be viewed as a positive outcome. However, given the rapid mutation rate of this class of markers, it is improbable that their performance could be validated us-
30
IRV KORNFIELDAND ALEX PARKER
ing comparisons among taxonomic groups that have been successfully discriminated using other molecular methods. For example; significant divergence between the mbuna and the other major haplochromine clade of Lake Malawi is recognizable with mtDNA (Moran et al., 1994); these groups would be expected to also differ in microsatellite allele frequencies. However, a simple demonstration of differences does not constitute evidence of phylogenetic information, as microsatellite primers often amplify across very wide taxonomic spectra (Schl6tterer et al., 1991; Levin et al., 1995; P6pin et al., 1995; see later); the major Malawian haplochromine clades are likely far too divergent to retain signal in the form of differences in microsatellite allele frequency or composition. Similarly, comparisons between the major tilapiine lineages, or among species of Oreochromis with previously defined relationships, would probably provide diagnostic allele distributions but not phylogenetic information.
H y p o t h e s i s Formulation A conservative test is used to assess the potential significance of microsatellite variation for phylogenetic reconstruction in the mbuna. Although no explicit phylogeny is available, a number of lineages are unambiguously distinctive. Such lineages were originally recognized on the basis of substantive morphological differences and define the endemic genera (Regan, 1921; Trewavas, 1935). Three distinctive genera which have received considerable morphological and ecological study have been selected (Trewavas, 1935; Ribbink
et al., 1983a,b; Reinthal, 1990a,b): Labeotropheus Ahl, 1926; Melanochromis Trewavas, 1935; and Pseudotropheus Regan, 1921. The major features of these genera are summarized in Table II; representative species are illustrated in Fig. 1 (see color plate). In addition to dentition and osteological characters, note the well-defined differences in color patterns among these taxa; such characters are viewed as central in defining haplochromine lineages (Eccles and Trewavas, 1989). Given that these genera of mbuna are well defined, all contained species should be more similar to congeners than to species of any other mbuna genus. This forms the basis for our test of phylogenetic information content. From each of the three genera, two species were chosen for study: Labeotropheus fuelleborni Ahl, 1926; L. trewavasae Fryer, 1956; Melanochromis auratus (Boulenger, 1899); M. parallelus Burgess and Axelrod, 1976; Pseudotropheus zebra "BB" (Boulenger, 1899), and P. zebra "black dorsal." The two species of Melanochromis belong to the same infrageneric complex (Ribbink et al., 1983b). The genus Pseudotropheus contains a number of well-defined infrageneric complexes, some of them certainly worthy of generic rank (Ribbink et al., 1983b); the species of Pseudotropheus examined here are both members of the P. zebra species complex. P. zebra "BB" is the blue-barred form collected from Thumbi Island West, whereas P. zebra "black dorsal" is an undescribed taxon endemic to the Maleri Islands in southern Lake Malawi (Ribbink et al., 1983b; Konings, 1990). The null hypothesis tested is that all six taxa are equidistant from each other and form a "star" phylogeny (Fig. 2A). This situation would obtain if microsatellite
TABLE H Morphological and Ecological Characteristics of Three mbuna Genera a,b Pseudotropheus Regan, 1921 Oral dentition Ethmovomer Orientation Relative width Gut length (relative to SL) Mouth position Color pattern Feeding posture c Mean niche breadth (algae) Depth distribution Territoriality
Melanochromis Trewavas, 1935
Labeotropheus Ahl, 1927
Bicuspid
Bicuspid
Tricuspid
Horizontal Medium 4.5 + 0.8 Terminal Vertical b a r s Perpendicular 4.21 3-25 m Continuous
Horizontal Small 3.5 + 0.6 Terminal Horizontal stripes Acute 6.65 4-35 m Weak/intermittent
Vertical Medium 5.2 + 0.8 Subterminal Vertical bars Parallel 6.05 0-18 m Variable
The genus Pseudotropheus as currently defined includes a variety of morphologically distinct clades; several are worthy of generic status. Characters typical of the clade are presented, including P. zebra [see Reinthal (1987)for discussion]. bData compiled from Trewavas (1935),Fryer (1959b),Ribbink et al. (1983b),Reinthal (1987),I. Kornfield (personal observations). cBodyposition relative to rock surface when grazing on epilithic algae. a
3. Molecular Systematics of mbuna
A
maximum information content; clearly weaker alternatives could also be constructed.
R zebra 'black dorsal'
L. fuelleborni
31
R zebra "BB'
VII. Materials and Methods L. trewavasae
M. auratus M. parallelus
B
R zebra 'black dorsal'
L. fuelleborni
R zebra "BB'
L. trewavasae
M. auratus M. parallelus
C
R zebra 'black dorsal' R zebra "BB'
L. fuelleborni
L. trewavasae
M. auratus M. parallelus
FIGURE 2 Hypothetical and actual relationships among three congeneric pairs of mbuna. (A) The null hypothesis (H0): no definable relationships exist among the taxa. (B) The stringent alternative hypothesis (H1): all congeners unite in lineages distinct from other genera. (C) The relationships among six mbuna species based on neighbor-joining analysis of genetic distances inferred from two hypervariable microsatellite loci. Numbers indicate the percentage of bootstrap replicates (out of 100) in which associations were supported.
mutation rates are either excessive or insufficient to provide phylogenetic information. Alternatively, if a phylogenetic signal is present in microsatellite data, each pair of congeneric species should cluster to the exclusion of other tested taxa (Fig. 2B). This formulation of the alternative hypothesis is consistent with
Microsatellite Characterization
All specimens used were wild-caught fishes. Tissue samples of P. zebra "black dorsal" and P. zebra "BB" were collected in August 1988 and December 1990 and field frozen in liquid nitrogen (Moran and Kornfield, 1995); nuclear and mitochondrial DNAs were prepared by density gradient ultracentrifugation (Dowling et al., 1990). All other species were collected in September (L. fuelleborni, M. auratus; Chipoka) or November 1994 (L. trewavasae, M. parallelus; Nkhata Bay) and preserved in ethanol. DNA was prepared from muscle tissue of these specimens using proteinase K digestion followed by phenol/chloroform extraction and ethanol precipitation. Two microsatellite loci were examined in all individuals: UME002 and UME003 (GenBank accessions U14396 and U14397); these loci had been isolated previously from a P. zebra "gold" genomic library using conventional methods (Parker and Kornfield, 1996). These two loci are composed of complex repeats [allele 280 at locus UME002: (GT)12(93bp)(TCTA)19; allele 195 at locus UME003:(AT)6AAA(AT)2ACA(TG)6 (GCGT)13] and are hypervariable, each exhibiting greater than 23 alleles even in small population samples (see later discussion). Microsatellite genotypes for all individuals were determined from 32 P-labeled polymerase chain reaction products separated on 6% polyacrylamide sequencing gels; a 35S-labeled M13 sequencing ladder was used as a size standard on all gels. Allelic compositions for all species were examined for fit to Hardy-Weinberg expectations using a modified version of BIOSYS (Swofford and Selander, 1981; P. Moran, personal communication). Tests of genotypic homogeneity were conducted using the resampling programs of Zaykin and Pudovkin (1993). Genetic distances were calculated using the delta-/_t distance of Goldstein et al. (1995), allele sharing, and Nei's distance; all distance calculations were performed using MICROSAT vl.4 (Minch, 1995). Phylogenetic relationships were inferred from these distances using the neighbor-joining method (Saitou and Nei, 1987), implemented by PHYLIP v3.5 (Felsenstein, 1993); statistical support for elements of the resultant phylogenetic tree was estimated by resampling across individuals (Van Dongen, 1995).
32
IRV KORNFIELD A N D ALEX PARKER
VIII. Results Extensive variation was uncovered for all species at both loci. At UME002, samples of individual taxa possessed approximately 25 alleles, with 64 alleles detected in total (Fig. 3A); UME003 was almost as variable, with each species exhibiting approximately 21 of the total of 48 alleles observed (Fig. 3B). Frequency distributions were multimodal, with extensive gaps separating some size classes of alleles. Heterogeneity of genotypic frequencies among taxa was highly significant for both loci. After adjustment of significance criteria for multiple tests (Rice, 1989), two species deviated significantly from Hardy-Weinberg expectations at UME002 (M. parallelus and L. trewavasae), as did one at UME003 (M. parallelus). In M. parallelus, a null al-
mately 0.398 in M. parallelus. No presumptive homozygous null genotypes were observed at this locus for L. trewavasae, although the sampled population exhibited a large heterozygote deficiency. Although it is possible that this taxon also possesses a null allele, apparent heterozygote deficiencies are not implausible given the sample sizes employed (see later). The topology of the neighbor-joining tree obtained using the delta-/z statistic (Fig. 2C) allows the null hypothesis to be rejected and suggests that phylogenetic
signal is present in the microsatellite data. The pattern of relationship among species was neither a star nor a random combination of taxa. The Labeotropheus lineage was the most supported; the Pseudotropheus lineage had significant definition, but the two species of Melanochromis were not consistently united to the exclusion of other taxa. The same topology was recovered
lele(s) is suspected to be present at locus UME002; a number of individuals showed no amplification at
using allele sharing, but with reduced bootstrap support for both the Pseudotropheus and the Labeotropheus
UME002, but simultaneously expressed genotypes at UME003. Assuming Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, the overall null allele frequency at UME002 is approxi-
clades. Using Nei's distance, only the Labeotropheus clade received bootstrap support in excess of 50% of replications. In light of the results of Goldstein et al.
0.2I
i}
N=36
Melanochromis paraflelus
!
,, ,, ~
,ihl,h,, ,
,lh,.
i
i ,,,
i
i
i
0.20.H_ 1
,
,
,,,,,,,,iI,,I,, 1I,1II,,
,
i
i-it
'
oo~
i
,
, ,,I,
~
'
~,
~
'
,
,
.,, ,,,...,l,li,l.,,.,..,,, ,
,
,
-
I
i
,
,
Jl
,,
I I I I I l l
I,I,I, ,
,, ,
,
, ,
,
,
,
N=44
i
,, II,I,l,,I i,I ,,I,,, o
Allele
o
size (basepairs)
,
,I,
i
,
,
i
,
I .hd..ll.l,llll.,,, i
,1,
,..
I
i
, .,,II .,I
N=47
JlllJ,,ll., ,
,
,
,
. . . . .
II, ,
,5
f
,
j
,
,, i,l,li,i,,i,,l,hl ,, ,
,
,
'BB'N=26
Psuedotropheus zebra
,
.,
'blackdorsal'N=25
Psuedotropheus zebra
'BB'N=26
,
i
~. I,
2
t ....................... ,,,i e
'blackdorsal'N=25
,
Psuedotropheus zebra
,,I,
i
,,11,,,,, ~
Labeotropheus trewavasae
,
Psuedotropheus zebra
,,
i
Melanochromis auratus
N=47
Labeotropheus trewavasae
o o~
,
,,,,, ll,,,lll, I
,
~
i
o..,
o
,
o
,,,I,1,,, ,,,,li,liI,, ,
Allelesize(basepairs)
FIGURE 3 Allele frequency distributions at two hypervariable microsatellite loci in six mbuna species. Dashed lines enclose saltines separated by large gaps (see text). (A) Distribution of alleles at locus UME002. (B) Distribution of alleles at locus UME003.
i
,
3. Molecular Systematics of mbuna
(1995; see earlier), this suggests that the intergeneric comparison may be at the outer limit of phylogenetic utility for microsatellite data.
33
zygote deficiencies are observed in the absence of null homozygotes.
A. Sampling Considerations IX.
Discussion
This chapter has provided evidence that hypervariable microsatellite loci contain phylogenetic information potentially capable of resolving relationships within the mbuna. This is the first class of molecular markers shown to possess sufficient power to elucidate the evolutionary history of that fauna. The successful definition of relationships clearly depends on the number of loci studied; neither UME002 nor UME003 alone provided resolution equal to that obtained from the two loci considered together. This is consistent with the recommendations of Pamilo and Nei (1988) and with the results obtained by Bowcock et al. (1994), who produced a tree of human racial groups using 30 microsatellite loci; reanalysis using small subsets of these data does not result in consistent resolution (A. Parker and I. Kornfield, unpublished observations). Because the number of loci characterized was small, and the number of mbuna species examined was limited, it is not yet clear at what taxonomic level microsatellites will prove most useful in this assemblage, i.e., microsatellite loci may be of value for defining relationships among congeners or allopatric populations of conspecifics rather than relationships among genera. The current debate over appropriate models of microsatellite evolution (Shriver et al., 1993; Valdes et al., 1993) should not be viewed as a significant impediment to the phylogenetic application of these loci. For example, even if rate heterogeneity is present in the production of different classes of alleles, the relative relationships among taxa should be resolvable, even if absolute distances are biased. Further, the lack of consensus regarding appropriate methods to quantify divergence (Queller and Goodnight, 1989; Goldstein et al., 1995; Shriver et al., 1995; Van Dongen, 1995), and construct evolutionary trees (Swofford and Berlocher, 1987; Crother, 1990), should not proximately inhibit the use of microsatellite variation for phylogenetic study of the mbuna. The presence of null alleles at some loci should not compromise the validity of evolutionary inferences if data analysis is based on genotypic rather than allelic frequencies. When presumptive null homozygotes are observed, null allele frequencies may be estimated by maximum likelihood methods (Raymond and Rousset, 1995); it is at present unclear how allele frequencies should be estimated when hetero-
Of great practical importance is the number of microsatellite loci and individuals that must be sampled to provide reliable resolution of phylogenetic relationships. It is obvious from theoretical considerations (Pamilo and Nei, 1988; Weir, 1990) that resolution is improved as greater numbers of loci are examined; this is particularly true if loci exhibit only moderate levels of allelic diversity (and thus lower information content). The number of individuals that must be sampled depends principally on the number of alleles present at each locus. In addition, large sample sizes may be essential for the detection of outliers (see later). When allelic diversity is low, relatively few individuals need be examined. However, informative variation may exist principally at hypervariable loci, and it is here that large sample sizes are essential to the determination of allele frequencies with statistical confidence (Fig. 4). For example, with an average of 25 alleles per population at UME002 (Fig. 3A), simulations suggest that approximately 115 individuals should be examined from each population (A. Parker, unpublished data; see Fig. 4). These simulations involved iterative sampling of alleles with replacement from randomly generated frequency distributions, with sample-population identity (Nei's unbiased genetic identity; Nei, 1987) calculated after each additional allele was sampled. As individuals were added, sample-population identity was observed to increase rapidly to a value of approximately IN = 0.97, beyond which point improvement in identity was extremely gradual; thus this value (IN = 0.97) was inter-
600
. ~N
9 400
. 9
00
~. E cf)
;
2oo! .4
9 : . .,..:" 9
| ! ] O i 0
9
" ",.:;,., . . . . .
9"
~ .
. 1: |~ q l i ' ! : :~: o - e i.,|,!:..-.,: ;:
9
:"
, . ~ : .
"
" 1 1 1 . " 9
.~-:-,: .-.
.
:....: : : ';~"
9 9" . 0 , , , 0 8 " : ~ .. 0' ,
, ~ "
9
":
|
" "t
~
, : .:: " : " .~
~
9
9 .
. . . . .
"'.
9
9
20
40
60
N u m b e r of Alleles
Simulation of sample size required to produce allele frequency estimates of similarity IN -->0.97 [Nei's unbiased genetic identity; Nei (1987)] to actual population allele frequencies (A. Parker, unpublished data). The empirical relationship derived from these simulations is: Sample Size = 1.5(N alleles)135. FIGURE 4
34
IRV KORNFIELD AND ALEX PARKER
preted to represent the point beyond which additional sampling effort is no longer worthwhile. In the present case, however, only 25 to 47 individuals were sampled per taxon. Thus, the resolution of relationships based on these two loci may be incomplete.
0.t3
0.25
0.15
~ ~t
B. Evolutionary Signals in Microsatellites
011 0.05
There are three independent classes of phylogenetic information that can potentially be gleaned from microsatellite loci. The authors anticipate that these classes will be appropriate for examining relationships at different taxonomic levels. First, allele frequency distributions may be compared using genetic distance metrics based on the stepwise mutation model of microsatellite evolution (Slatkin, 1995; Goldstein et al., 1995). A second class of phylogenetic information, however, may be present in microsatellite allele frequency distributions. Major gaps in allele size distributions may signify unique mutational events. For example, in M. parallelus, alleles of size 150-180 bp are recognized at locus UME002 as representing expansion, via stepwise mutation, from a single allele produced by a distinct, saltatory mutational process (Fig. 3A). This class of alleles is separated from the next smallest allele by 75 bp; it thus conforms to the two-phase mutation model presented by DiRienzo et al. (1994), wherein divergent repeat classes are generated by infrequent large jumps. Machado-Joseph disease also conforms to this model; this pathology appears when a trinucleotide repeat increases by at least 75 bp to form a new allelic class (Maciel et al., 1995). As Maciel et al. (1995) noted, "clustering of expanded repeat sizes is also suggestive of a unique ancient founder mutation." A cladistic perspective, recognizing such novel classes of alleles as discrete characters, is adopted here; in light of the saltatory nature of the mutational events hypothesized to generate them, such characters are called saltines to distinguish them from standard patterns of microsatellite allele variation. Thus, the allelic class centered at 178 bp for UME002 in M. parallelus constitutes an autapomorphic saltine; if shared among independent lineages, saltines may be treated as synapomorphies. In this manner, some aspects of microsatellite allele distributions can be analyzed by standard cladistic methods (Swofford, 1990) rather than by distance approaches. Indeed, if a large number of loci were examined, it would be anticipated that saltines would permit construction of robust phylogenetic trees. However, like ancestral mtDNA polymorphisms, saltines can be retained or lost in multiple lineages. For example, in the human microsatellite data analyzed by Bowcock et al. (1994), locus ms164 has two
0
,
o
-
I
.
I
9
- -
.
Allelesize(bp) FIGURE 5 Distribution of alleles at human microsatellite locus
ms164 (E. Minch, personal communication);this locus was included in the study of Bowcocket al. (1994).The two divergentallelicclasses depicted are shared by a number of diverse human lineages. Aggregate sample size is 250.
allelic classes separated by 16 bp which are present in diverse human lineages (Fig. 5). Inspection of allele distributions at UME003 (Fig. 3B) reveals the presence of two major expansion classes centered around 149 and 201 bp; the smaller expansion class has probably been lost from both M. auratus and P. zebra. Genetic drift may play a major role in molding the distribution of rare expansion classes. If drift were to eliminate relatively infrequent alleles associated with major allelic clusters, e.g., the class centered around 300 bp at locus UME002 (Fig. 3A), such alleles could be regenerated rapidly by mutation. In contrast, if eliminated by drift, variation embodied in saltines would not be regenerated. For example, the absence of the saltatory class centered at 178 bp at UME002 from M. auratus could be due to drift. Indeed, mtDNA diversity is observed to be relatively low in this taxon (Bowers et al., 1994), consistent with the possibility of a recent population bottleneck. Note that it is critical that sample sizes be large enough to reliably detect the presence of saltines that occur at low absolute frequencies in some populations. To date, no one has exploited this class of information to construct phylogenetic trees. Finally, similar to saltines, the ability (or inability) of a given microsatellite primer pair to amplify DNAs from certain taxa can be treated as a cladistically informative binary character and forms a third potential information class. Again, such characters may constitute synapomorphies and can thus be used to infer relationships from a cladistic perspective, although no empirical information about the prevalence of these characters in cichlid fishes can be found. If null alleles are to be employed in this fashion, it is imperative that new flanking primers be designed and used to dem-
3. Molecular Systematics of mbuna
onstrate, by sequencing, that all observed null alleles are due to homologous changes in the original priming sites.
X. Summary The classical methods of molecular phylogenetic investigation, allozyme electrophoresis and mtDNA restriction or sequence analysis, have failed to resolve relationships among members of rapidly evolving species flocks such as the mbuna (Cichlidae) of Lake Malawi. Several classes of nuclear DNA markers may, however, provide greater resolution; most promising are microsatellite markers. The extremely high mutation rates at these loci render them fundamentally different from other nuclear DNA polymorphisms, as changes in allele frequency are influenced by mutation as well as genetic drift. Analysis of two microsatellite loci in three congeneric pairs of mbuna species strongly suggests that these markers can provide phylogenetic information relevant to these recently diverged taxa.
Acknowledgments We are exceedingly grateful to S. Grant, Salima, Malawi, for providing specimens and supporting our research. L. DeMason also supplied critical logistical support. E. Minch kindly shared unpublished human microsatellite data and provided a copy of his program to calculate delta-/z. A. Konings generously permitted reproduction of his mbuna photographs. M. Stiassay is inspirational. We are grateful to the editors and two anonymous referees who provided comments which helped improve this manuscript. This work was supported by NSF EHR91-08766 and NOAA Sea Grant NA36RG0110.
References Avise, J. C. 1994. "Molecular Markers, Natural History and Evolution." Chapman and Hall, New York. Avise, J. C., Helfman, G. S., Saunders, N. C., and Hales, L. S. 1986. Mitochondrial DNA differentiation in North Atlantic eels: Population genetic consequences of an unusual life history pattern. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 83:4350-4354. Avise, J. C., Neigel, J. E., and Arnold, J. 1984. Demographic influences on mitochondrial DNA lineage survivorship in animal populations. J. Mol. Evol. 20:99-105. Bardakci, F., and Skibinski, D. O. F. 1994. Application of the RAPD technique in tilapia fish: Species and subspecies identification. Heredity 73:117-123. Bowcock, A. M., Ruiz-Linares, A., Tomfohrde, J., Minch, E., Kidd, J. R., and Cavalli-Sforza, L. L. 1994. High resolution of human
35
evoutionary trees with polymorphic microsatellies. Nature 368: 455 -458. Bowers, N., Stauffer, J. R., Jr., and Kocher, T. D. 1994. Intra- and interspecific mitochondrial DNA sequence variation within two species of rock-dwelling cichlids (Teleostei: Cichlidae) from Lake Malawi, Africa. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 3:75-82. Brown, W. M., George, M. Jr., and Wilson, A. C. 1979. Rapid evolution of mitochondrial DNA. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 76:19671971. Bruford, M. W., and Wayne, R. K. 1993. Microsatellites and their application to population genetic studies. Curr. Opin. Genet. Dev. 3: 939-943. Charlesworth, B., Sniegowski, P., and Stephan, W. 1994. The evolutionary dynamics of reptitive DNA in eukaryotes. Nature 371: 215-220. Crother, B. I. 1990. Is "some better than none" or do allele frequencies contain phylogenetically useful information? Cladistics 6:277-281. Dallas, J. F. 1992. Estimation of microsatellite mutation rates in recombinant inbred strains of mouse. Mamm. Genome 5: 32- 38. DeMason, L. 1993. Into Africa: Exporting the Tanzanian coast of Lake Malawi. Cichlid News 2: 22- 23. DiRienzo, A., Peterson, A. C., Garza, J. C., Valdes, A. M., Slatkin, M., and Freimer, N. B. 1994. Mutational processes of simple-sequence repeat loci in human populations. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 91: 3166-3170. Dominey, W. J. 1984. Effects of sexual selection and life history on speciation: Species flocks in African cichlids and Hawaiian Drosophila. In "Evolution of Fish Species Flocks," (A. A. Echelle and I. L. Kornfield, eds.), pp. 231-249. University of Maine Press, Orono, ME. Dowling, T. E., Moritz, C., and Palmer, J. D. 1990. Nucleic acids. II. Restriction site analysis. In "Molecular Systematics" (D. M. Hillis and C. Moritz, eds.), pp. 250-317. Sinauer, Sunderland, MA. Eccles, D. H., and Trewavas, E. 1989. "Malawian Cichlid Fishes: The Classification of Some Haplochromine Genera." Lake Fish Movies, Herten, West Germany. Edwards, A., Hammond, H. A., Jin, L., Caskey, C. T., and Chakraborty, R. 1992. Genetic variation at five trimeric and tetrameric tandem repeat loci in four human population groups. Genomics 12:241-253. Ellegren, H., Primmer, C. R., and Sheldon, B. C. 1995. Microsatellite "evolution": Directionality or bias? Nat. Genet. 11:360-362. Ellsworth, D. L., Rittenhouse, K. D., and Honeycutt, R. L. 1993. Artifactual variation in randomly amplified polymorphic DNA banding patterns. Biotech. 14:214-217. Estoup, A., Garnery, L., Solignac, M., and Cornuet, J. M. 1995. Microsatellite variation in honeybee (Apis mellifera L.) populations: Hierarchical genetic structure and test of the infinite allele and stepwise mutation models. Genetics 140:679-695. Felsenstein, J. 1993. "PHYLIP v3.5 (Phylogenetic Inference Package, computer software) Ver. 3.2." University of Washington, Seattle, WA. Franck, J. P. C., Wright, J. M., and McAndrew, B. 1992. Genetic variability of a family of satellite DNAs from tilapia (Pisces: Cichlidae). Genome 35:719-725. Franck, J. P. C., Kornfield, I., and Wright, J. M. 1994. The utility of SATA satellite DNA sequences for inferring phylogenetic relationships among the three major genera of tilapinne cichlid fishes. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 3:10-16. Fryer, G. 1959a. Some aspects of evolution in Lake Nyasa. Evolution 13: 440-451. Fryer, G. 1959b. The trophic interrelationships and ecology of some littoral communities in Lake Nyasa with special references to
36
IRV KORNFIELD AND ALEX PARKER
the fishes, and a discussion of the evolution of a group of rockfrequenting Cichlidae. Proc. Zool. Soc. Lond. 132:153-281. Fryer, G., and Iles, T. D. 1972. "The Cichlid Fishes of the Great Lakes of Africa." Oliver Boyd, Edinborough. Gasse, F., Ledee, V., Massault, M., and Fontes, J.-C. 1989. Water level fluctuations of Lake Tanganyika in phase with oceanic changes during the last glaciation and deglaciation. Nature 342:57-59. Goldstein, D. B., Linares, A. R., Cavalli-Sforza, L. L., and Feldman, M. W. 1995. Genetic absolute dating based on microsatellites and the origin of modern humans. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 92:67236727. Greenwood, P. H. 1984. African cichlids and evolutionary theories. In "Evolution of Fish Species Flocks." (A. A. Echelle and I. L. Kornfield, eds.), pp. 141-154. University of Maine Press, Orono, ME. Hare, M. P., Karl, S. A., and Avise, J. C. 1996. Anonymous nuclear DNA markers in the American oyster and their implications for the heterozygote deficiency phenomenon in marine bivalves. Mol. Biol. Evol. 13:334-345. Hughes, A. L., and Nei, M. 1989. Nucleotide substitution at major histocompatibility complex class II loci: Evidence for overdominant selection. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86:958-962. Karl, S. A., Bowen, B. W., and Avise, J. C. 1992. Global population structure and male-mediated gene flow in the green turtle (CheIonia mydas): RFLP analyses of anonymous nuclear loci. Genetics 131:163-173. Karl, S. A., and Avise, J. C. 1993. PCR-based assays of mendelian polymorphisms from anonymous single-copy nuclear DNA: Techniques and applications for population genetics. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10:342-361. Kellogg, K. A., Markert, J. A., Stauffer, J. R., Jr., and Kocher, T. D. 1995. Microsatellite variation demonstrates multiple paternity in lekking cichlid fishes from Lake Malawi, Africa. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 260:79-84. Klein, J. 1986. "Natural History of the Major Histocompatibility Complex." Wiley, New York. Klein, D. H., Ono, H., O'Huigin, C., Vincek, V., Goldschmidt, T., and Klein, J. 1993. Extensive Mhc variability in cichlid fishes of Lake Malawi. Nature 364: 330-332. Konings, A. 1990. "Koning's Book of Cichlids and All the Other Fishes of Lake Malawi." TFH Publications, Inc., Neptune City, NJ. Kornfield, I. 1978. Evidence for rapid speciation in African cichlid fishes. Experientia 34: 335-336. Kornfield, I. 1991. Genetics. In "Cichlid Fishes: Behavior, Ecology and Evolution." (M. Keenleyside, ed.), pp. 103-128. Chapman and Hall, London. Lazzaro, X. 1991. Feeding convergence in South American and African zooplanktivorous cichlids Geophagus brasilensis and Tilapia rendalli. Environ. Biol. Fishes 31:283-293. Levin, I., Cheng, H. H., Baxter-Jones, C., and Hillel, J. 1995. Turkey microsatellite DNA loci amplified by chicken-specific primers. Anim. Genet. 26:107-110. Lewis, D. S. C. 1981. "Problems of Species Definition in Lake Malawi Cichlid Fishes (Pisces, Cichlidae)." J. L. B. Smith Inst. Ichthy. Spec. Publ. 23:1-5. Lewis, D. S. C. 1982. A revision of the genus Labidochromis (Teleostei: Cichlidae) from Lake Malawi. Zool J. Linn. Soc. 75:189-265. Liem, K. F. 1980. Adaptive significance of intra- and interspecific differences in the feeding repertoires of cichlid fishes. Am. Zool. 20: 295-314. Maciel, P., et al. 1995. Correlation between CAG repeat length and clinical features in Machado-Joseph disease. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 57:54-61. Marsh, A. C., Ribbink, A. J., and Marsh, B. A. 1981. Sibling species complexes in sympatric populations of Petrotilapia Trewavas (Cichlidae, Lake Malawi). Zool. J. Linn Soc. 71:253-264.
Mayr, E. 1984. Evolution of fish species flocks: A commentary. In "Evolution of Fish Species Flocks." (A. A. Echelle and I. Kornfield, eds.), pp. 3-11. University of Maine Press, Orono, ME. McElroy, D. M., Kornfield, I., and Everett, J. 1991. Coloration in African cichlids: Diversity and constraints in Lake Malawi endemics. Neth. J. Zool. 41:250-268. McKaye, K. R., Kocher, T., Reinthal, P., Harrison, R., and Kornfield, I. 1984. Genetic evidence for allopatric and sympatric differentiation among morphs of a Lake Malawi cichlid fish. Evolution 36: 658-664. McKaye, K. R., Kocher, T., Reinthal, P., and Kornfield, I. 1982. Sympatric sibling species complex of Petrotilapia Trewavas analyzed by enzyme electrophoresis (Pisces: Cichlidae). J. Linn. Soc. 76:9196. McMillan, W. O., and Palumbi, S. R. 1995. Concordant evolutionary patterns among Indo-West Pacific butterflyfishes. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 260: 229- 239. Meyer, A. 1993. Phylogenetic relationships and evolutionary processes in East African cichlid fishes. Trends Ecol. Evol. 8:279-284. Meyer, A., Kocher, T. D., Basasibwaki, P., and Wilson, A. C. 1990. Monophyletic origin of Lake Victoria cichlid fishes suggested by mitochondrial DNA sequences. Nature 347:550-553. Minch, E. 1995. "MICROSAT vl.4 (computer software)." Stanford University, Stanford, CA. Moran, P., and Kornfield, I. 1993. Retention of an ancestral polymorphism in the mbuna species flock (Pisces: Cichlidae) of Lake Malawi. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10:1015-1029. Moran, P., and Kornfield, I. 1995. Were population bottlenecks associated with radiation of the mbuna species flock (Teleostei: Cichlidae) of Lake Malawi? Mol. Biol. Evol. 12:1085-1093. Moran, P., Kornfield, I., and Reinthal, P. 1994. Molecular systematics and radiation of the haplochromine cichlids (Teleostei: Perciformes) of Lake Malawi. Copeia 1994:274-288. Nei, M. 1978. Estimation of avaerage heterozygosity and genetic distance from a small number of individuals. Genetics 89:583-590. Nei, M. 1987. "Molecular Evolutionary Genetics." Columbia University Press, New York. Niki, Y., Chigusa, S. I., and Matsuura, E. T. 1989. Complete replacement of mitochondrial DNA in Drosophila. Nature 341:551-552. Oliver, M. K. 1984. "Systematics of African Cichlid Fishes: Determination of the Most Primitive Taxon, and Studies on the Haplochromines of Lake Malawi (Teleostei: Cichlidae). Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Yale University, New Haven, CT. Ono, H., O'Huigin, C., Tichy, H., and Klein, J. 1993. Major histocompatibility complex variation in two species of cichlid fishes from Lake Malawi. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10:1060-1072. Owen, R. B., Crossley, R., Johnson, T. C., Tweddle, D., Kornfield, I., Davison, S., Eccles, D. H., and Engstrom, D. E. 1990. Major low levels of Lake Malawi and implication for speciation rates in cichlid fishes. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 240:519-553. Paetkau, D., Calvert, W., Stirling, I., and Strobeck, C. 1995. Microsatellite analysis of population structure in Canadian polar bears. Mol. Ecol. 4: 347-354. Palumbi, S. R. and Baker, C. S. 1994. Contrasting population structures for nuclear intron sequences and mtDNA of humpback whales. Mol. Biol. Evol. 11:426-435. Pamilo, P., and Nei, M. 1988. Relationships between gene trees and species trees. Mol. Biol. Evol. 5:568-583. Parker, A., and Kornfield, I. 1996. Polygynandry in Pseudotropheus zebra, a cichlid fish from Lake Malawi. Environ. Biol. Fish., 47:345352. Parker, A., and Kornfield, I. 1997. Evolution of the mitochondrial DNA control region in the mbuna (Cichlidae) species flock of Lake Malawi, East Africa. J. Mol. Evol., in press. Pemberton, J. M., Slate, J., Bancroft, D. R., and Barrett, J. A. 1995. Non-
3. Molecular Systematics of mbuna amplifying alleles at microsatellite loci: A caution for parentage and population studies. Mol. Ecol. 4:249-252. Penny, D., Steel, M., Waddell, P. J., and Hendy, M. D. 1995. Improved analyses of human mtDNA sequences support a recent african origin for Homo sapiens. Mol. Biol. Evol. 12:863-882. P6pin, L., Amigues, Y., Le'Pringle, A., Berthier, J.-L., Bensaid, A., and Vaiman, D. 1995. Sequence conservation of microsatellites between Bos taurus (cattle), Capra hircus (goat) and related species: Examples of use in parentage testing and phylogenetic analysis. Heredity 74:53-61. Queller, D. C., and Goodnight, K. F. 1989. Estimating relatedness using genetic markers. Evolution 43:258-275. Queller, D. C., Strassmann, J. E., and Hughes, C. R. 1993. Microsatellites and kinship. Trends Ecol. Evol. 8:285-288. Rand, D. M., Dorfsman, M., and Kan, L. M. 1994. Neutral and nonneutral evolution of Drosophila mitochondrial DNA. Genetics 138: 741-756. Raymond, M., and Rousset, F. 1995. GENEPOP ver. 1.2 a population genetics software for exact tests and ecumenicism. J. Hered. 86: 248-249. Regan, C. T. 1921. The cichlid fishes of Lake Nyasa. Proc. Zool. Soc. Lond. 1921: 675- 727. Reinthal, P. N. 1987. "Morphology, Ecology, and Behavior of a Group of the Rock-Dwelling Fishes (Cichlidae: Perciformes) from Lake Malawi, Africa. Unpublished Ph.D dissertation, Duke University, Durham, NC. Reinthal, P. N. 1990a. Morphological analysis of the neurocranium of a group of rock-dwelling cichlid fishes (Cichlidae: Perciformes) from Lake Malawi, Africa. Zool. J. Linn. Soc. 98:123-139. Reinthal, P. N. 1990b. The feeding habits of a group of herbivorous rock-dwelling cichlid fishes (Cichlidae: Perciformes) from Lake Malawi, Africa. Environ. Biol. Fishes. 27:215-233. Ribbink, A. J., Marsh, A. C., Marsh, B. A., and Sharp, B. J. 1983a. The zoogeography, ecology and taxonomy of the genus Labeotropheus Ahl, 1927, of Lake Malawi (Pisces: Cichlidae). Zool. J. Linn. Soc. 79: 223- 243. Ribbink, A. J., Marsh, A. C., Ribbink, C. C., and Sharp, B. J. 1983b. A preliminary survey of the cichlid fishes of rocky habitats in Lake Malawi. S. Afr. J. Zool. 18:149-310. Rice, W. R. 1989. Analyzing tables of statistical tests. Evolution 43: 223-225. Rubensztein, D. C., Amos, W., Leggo, J., Goodburn, S., Jain, S., Li, S. H., Margolis, R. L., Ross, C. A., and Ferguson-Smith, M. 1995. Microsatellite evolution: Evidence for directionality and variation in rate between species. Nat. Genet. 10:337-343. Saitou, N., and Nei, M. 1987. The neighbor-joining method: A new method for reconstructing phylogenetic trees. Mol. Biol. Evol. 4: 406 -425. Schl6tterer, C., Amos, B., and Tautz, D. 1991. Conservation of polymorphic simple sequence loci in cetacean species. Nature 354: 63-65.
37
Scholz, C. A., and Rosendahl, B. R. 1988. Low lake stands in Lakes Malawi and Tanganyika, East Africa, delineated with multifold seismic data. Science 240:1645-1648. Seyoum, S., and Kornfield, I. 1992a. Taxonomic notes on the Oreochromis niloticus subspecies complex (Pisces: Cichidae), with a description of a new subspecies. Can. J. Zool. 70:2161-2165. Seyoum, S., and Kornfield, I. 1992b. Identification of the subspecies of Oreochromis niloticus (Pisces: Cichlidae) using restriction endonuclease analysis of mitochondrial DNA. Aquaculture 102:29-42. Shriver, M. D., Jin, L., Boerwinkle, E., Deka, R., Ferrell, R. E., and Chakraborty, R. 1995. A novel measure of genetic distance for highly polymorphic tandem repeat loci. Mol. Biol. Evol. 12:914920. Shriver, M. D., Jin, L., Chakraborty, R., and Boerwinkle, E. 1993. VNTR allele frequency distributions under the stepwise mutation model: A computer simulations approach. Genetics 134:983-993. Slatkin, M. 1995. A measure of population subdivision based on microsatellite alleles. Genetics 139:457-462. Sultmann, H., Mayer, W. E., Figueroa, F., Tichy, H., and Klein, J. 1995. Phylogenetic analysis of cichlid fishes using nucler DNA markers. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 12:1033-1047. Swofford, D. L. 1990. "PAUP: Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony, ver. 3.1.1." Computer program distributed by the Illinois Natural History Survey, Champaign, IL. Swofford, D. L., and Berlocher, S. H. 1987. Inferring evolutionary trees from gene frequency data under the principle of maximum parsimony. Syst. Zool. 36:293-325. Swofford, D. L., and Selander, R. B. 1981. BIOSYS-I: a FORTRAN program for the comprehensive analysis of electrophoretic data in population genetics and systematics. J. Hered. 72:281-283. Trewavas, E. 1935. A synopsis of the cichlid fishes of Lake Nyasa. Ann. Mag. Nat. Hist. 10:65-118. Turner, G. F. 1994. Speciation mechanisms in Lake Malawi cichlids: A critical review. Arch. Hydrobiol. 44:139-160. Valdes, A. M., Slatkin, M., and Freimer, N. B. 1993. Allele frequencies at microsatellite loci: The stepwise mutation model revisited. Genetics 133:737-749. Van Dongen, S. 1995. How should we bootstrap allozyme data? Heredity 74: 445-447. Weir, B. S. 1990. Sampling strategies for distances between DNA sequences. Biometrics 46:551-560. Williams, J. G. K., Kubelik, A. R., Livak, K. J., Rafalski, J. A., and Tingey, S. V. 1990. DNA polymorphisms amplified by arbitrary primers are useful as genetic markers. Nucleic Acids Res. 18:65316535. Wright, J. M. 1989. Nucleotide sequence, genomic organization and evolution of a major repetitive DNA family in tilapia Oreochromis mossambicus/hornorum. Nucleic Acids Res. 17:5071-5079. Zaykin, D. V., and Pudovkin, A. I. 1993. Two programs to estimate /~,2 values using pseudo-probability tests. J. Hered. 84:152-153.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
C H A P T E R
4 Reconstruction of Cichlid Fish Phylogeny Using Nuclear DNA Markers ~176
H O L G E R S U L T M A N N and WERNER E. MAYER
Max-Planck-Institut fiir Biologie Abteilung Immungenetik D-72076 Tiibingen, Germany
some of which gave rise to more recent groups in lakes Malawi (Kocher et al., 1993) and Victoria. A comparatively large genetic divergence between species of the genus Tropheus from Lake Tanganyika was found to be accompanied by small morphological changes (Sturmbauer and Meyer, 1992). However, high morphological plasticity was found within the single New World species Cichlasoma managuense (Meyer, 1987). In addition, although some cichlid species from different lakes resemble each other morphologically, molecular data indicate that this similarity is due to convergent evolution (Kocher et al., 1993). Most of the cichlid species of Lakes Malawi and Victoria are endemic (Kornfield, 1978; Meyer et al., 1990; Greenwood, 1991) and monophyletic (Meyer et al., 1990; Meyer, 1993). Taking into account the estimated ages of 2 MY for Lake Malawi and less than 1 MY for Lake Victoria (Fryer and Iles, 1972), questions arise as to the speed and mode of speciation leading to hundreds of different species. It has been shown by allozyme variation that speciation in Lake Malawi occurred rapidly (Kornfield, 1978). Allopatric speciation might have been promoted by considerable fluctuation in the water levels of Lakes Malawi and Victoria (Livingstone, 1980; Owen et al., 1990). However, microallo-
I. I n t r o d u c t i o n
The family Cichlidae constitutes a monophyletic group in the order Perciformes (Kaufman and Liem, 1982). Monophyly of the cichlid family is indicated by the presence of at least nine synapomorphic morphological characters (Stiassny, 1991; Zihler, 1982; Gaemers, 1984). Since the distribution of cichlids ranges from South and Central America and Mexico to tropical Africa, Madagascar, southern India, and Sri Lanka (Ribbink, 1991), the cichlid family must have arisen before the separation of Africa, South America, and India by continental drift more than 100 million years (MY) ago. The morphology of cichlid species has been studied for almost 100 years and various classification schemes have been proposed (e.g., Pellegrin, 1904; Regan, 1906; Vandewalle, 1971; Trewavas, 1973, 1983; Poll, 1986; Greenwood, 1987; Cichocki, 1976; Stiassny, 1987, 1991; Oliver, 1984). The cichlid taxa in the Great Lakes of East Africa (Lakes Victoria, Malawi, and Tanganyika) are of special interest, having undergone recent explosive adaptive radiations leading to hundreds of different species. Lake Tanganyika, which is approximately 12 MY old (Cohen et al., 1993), provides an ancient reservoir of polyphyletic taxa (Nishida, 1991),
MOLECULAR SYSTEMATICS OF FISHES
39
Copyright 9 1997 by Academic Press. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
40
HOLGER SLILTMANN AND WERNER E. MAYER
patric or even sympatric speciation cannot be ruled out, particularly because habitats and niches are quite restricted for most of the species (Ribbink, 1991; Meyer, 1993). Before hypotheses regarding the speciation process can be postulated, the phylogenetic relationships among the various cichlid taxa must be elucidated. Two main difficulties have, however, hampered the reconstruction of cichlid phylogenies from morphological characters: paucity of synapomorphic characters, which hinders the recognition of taxonomic groups, and abundant parallelism, which makes it difficult to ascertain whether shared characters are synapomorphies or homoplasies. To circumvent these problems, molecular analyses have been initiated and used for the construction of phylogenies for cichlid species and species flocks (i.e., monophyletic groups of closely related species coexisting in the same area; Greenwood, 1984; Nishida, 1991; Sage et al., 1984).
II. Methods Used for Reconstructing Cichlid Phylogeny The present taxonomy of cichlids in the east African lakes is largely based on morphological characters, particularly the shape of the jaws and teeth as well as the trophic behavior (Greenwood, 1979, 1980). For a variety of allozymes, allelic frequencies have been estimated from the electrophoretic mobility patterns (Sage and Selander, 1975; Kornfield, 1978; Kornfield et al., 1979; McKaye et al., 1982; McAndrew and Majumdar, 1983, 1984; Sage et al., 1984; Nishida, 1991) and used to calculate genetic distances between sister groups of cichlids. These data allowed the subdivision of cichlids into genera and species flocks. For the Lake Victoria cichlids, however, despite their considerable morphological differences, genetic distances were too small (0.006 substitutions per locus; Sage et al., 1984) to evaluate interspecies relationships. The substitution rate at the mitochondrial control region and adjacent loci (cytochrome b and tRNA genes) has been shown to be higher than that of most nuclear DNA loci (Brown et al., 1979). Sequence analyses of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) (Meyer et al., 1990; Sturmbauer and Meyer, 1992, 1993; Kocher et al., 1993, 1995; Sturmbauer et al., 1994; Moran and Kornfield, 1993; Schliewen et al., 1994; Bowers et al., 1994) have extended the phylogenetic trees of the Lake Tanganyika and Malawi lineages and confirmed the monophyly of the Lake Victoria species flock. Discrep-
ancies between the restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) pattern of mtDNA and the species tree based on morphological characters, however, led Moran and Kornfield (1993) to suggest an ancestral polymorphism in the founding populations of the Lake Malawi flocks, which hinders an accurate determination of their phylogenetic relationships. In addition to this problem of polymorphism predating species divergence, the low number of mtDNA markers available is a limiting factor. In contrast to the low genetic diversity among cichlids as revealed by allozyme data is the finding of high polymorphism at the Mhc (major histocompatibility complex) loci (Klein et al., 1993; Ono et al., 1993). Although some of this polymorphism is ancient (predating species divergence), the high number of different Mhc groups (loci) and alleles in cichlids might make the Mhc a useful genetic tool for studying cichlid phylogeny (Klein et al., 1997). The detection of a family of tandemly repeated satellite DNA elements in tilapia (Wright, 1989; Franck et al., 1992) has enabled Franck and co-workers (1994) to provide evidence for a close relationship of the mouthbrooding tilapiine genera Oreochromis and Sarotherodon in contrast to the substrate spawning genus Tilapia. In this report, nucleotide differences between the satellite consensus sequences for each genus were used for the construction of a phylogenetic tree. Using the molecular methods just described, the aim of elucidating the evolutionary history of cichlid species within the monophyletic groups of Lakes Malawi and Victoria has been achieved only partially, either because of the poor resolution achievable by the methods or because of the low number of polymorphic loci found. Thus, using more polymorphic nuclear DNA markers is the only means for making further progress in this field of research. The search for such new markers was greatly facilitated by the discovery of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) (Saiki et al., 1988). This chapter describes and discusses the application of two PCR-based methods. First, S~iltmann et al. (1995) used the random amplification of the polymorphic DNA (RAPD) technique (Williams et al., 1990; Welsh and McClelland, 1990) to identify polymorphic genomic loci, followed by locus-specific DNA amplification and sequence determination of the fragments. In a second (unpublished) approach, locus-specific PCR primers were used to amplify microsatellite repetitive elements to determine allele size frequencies among cichlid species from Lake Victoria. Nucleotide substitutions and allele frequency differences between species were then used to calculate genetic distance matrices and to construct phylogenetic trees.
4. Reconstruction of Cichlid Phylogeny
III. Random Amplification of Polymorphic DNA (RAPD) The RAPD procedure (Welsh and McClelland, 1990; Williams et al., 1990) was originally developed as a method for fingerprinting genomes. PCR amplification is performed using a single oligonucleotide, typically a 10-mer primer, at low annealing temperatures (35-40 ~ Fig. 1A). Depending on its sequence, the primer randomly anneals to an unknown segment on one of the DNA strands. In some cases, another annealing site will be present on the complementary strand not too distant from the first site and amplification will occur. When two species, strains, or individuals are compared, polymorphism between them will be revealed on agarose or polyacrylamide electrophoresis gels by the presence or absence of an amplification product. This method has been applied to the discovery of genetic markers for mapping studies (Serikawa et al., 1992; Postlethwait et al., 1994) and to elucidate phylogenetic relationships between bacterial species and strains (Welsh and McClelland, 1990; Smith et al., 1994) and tilapiine cichlid species (Bardakci and Skibinski, 1994). In the latter case, three species of the genus Oreochromis and four subspecies of Oreochromis niloticus could be distinguished. However, analyses of the reaction conditions (Ellsworth et al., 1993; Muralidharan and Wakeland, 1993; Smith et al., 1994; Bowditch et al., 1994) have shown that RAPD is highly sensitive to a wide range of factors: the quality of the template DNA, minute contaminations of RNA, the primer/template ratio, and small changes of the magnesium concentration. In addition, it is prone to producing spurious fragment variation (as shown, for example, by comparison of F1 hybrid DNA with parental DNA; Ayliffe et al., 1994) and other artifacts. Therefore, the procedure has been supplemented by sequencing the differential RAPD fragment and designing primers for locus-specific amplification in standard PCR. Although the RAPD polymorphism is presumed to be located at the annealing site of the 10-mer primer, it has been shown that the primer-binding sites are often identical between two samples showing polymorphic bands (Bowditch et al., 1994). The most likely explanation for this is that the formation of different secondary structures of the DNA templates, due to nucleotide substitutions outside the annealing sites, affects the accessibility of the annealing sites. To examine variation at the RAPD primer annealing site, the "vectorette" technique described by Riley and co-workers (1990) was also applied. Genomic DNA was digested with restriction endonucleases, and so-
41
called vectorette linkers were ligated to all fragments (Fig. 1B). The vectorette linkers consisted of two oligonucleotides that were complementary to each other at their 5' and 3' ends, but contained a central mismatched region. In the subsequent PCR, the firststrand DNA synthesis primed by a locus-specific oligonucleotide was essential for the generation of the binding site of the so-called vectorette primer that specifically annealed to the complementary strand of the mismatched region of the vectorette linker. Thus, specific exponential amplification of the flanking region occurred. The PCR products were then cloned and sequenced by standard methods. Using two DNA samples (shown to be devoid of RNA by ethidium bromide staining) from Pseudotropheus zebra and Melanochromis auratus, the RAPD conditions that yielded the most reproducible results were determined and then these were kept constant in subsequent experiments. The conditions were as follows: 50-60% G +C content for the 10-mer primer (see Stiltmann et al., 1995), which was used at a concentration of 4/xM in the PCR (a combination of two 10-mer primers can also be used for the amplification); 100/xM each of dATP, dCTP, dGTP, and dTTP; 2.5 units of Taq polymerase; and 100 ng of template DNA in a total reaction volume of 25 #1 in 1• reaction buffer containing 1.5 mM magnesium chloride. The PCR program consisted of 45 sec at 93~ 15 sec annealing at 35-42~ and 10 min primer extension at 72 ~ followed by 35 to 45 cycles, each 15 sec at 93 ~ 15 sec annealing at 35 ~ 42~ and 3 min primer extension at 72~ The reaction was completed by a final primer extension step for 10 min at 72~ Only those cases which gave concordant banding patterns for two individuals of each species were examined further. Figure 2 shows an example of a typical result of the RAPD reaction where a polymorphic band of about 400 bp in size is present in P. zebra but absent from M. auratus. The fragments were subcloned in pUC18 or M13 vectors and sequenced (Sanger et al., 1977). From three of these sequences, specific primers for amplification were constructed. The corresponding loci were called DXTU1, DXTU2, and DXTU3 (for details, see Stiltmann et al., 1995). In the specific PCR, the following observations were made: 1. Polymorphism of locus-specific PCR products was frequently observed. The proportion of polymorphic versus monomorphic loci obtained by this procedure was estimated to be higher than 50%. 2. The applicability of the specific primers varied depending on the locus examined. At DXTU1, products were obtained from neotropical as well as from
42
HOLGER SfdLTMANN A N D WERNER E. M A Y E R
B
A
R
R
R
X
genomicDNA
10mer primer(X)
Restriction digest of genomic DNA
~ Denaturing, annealingat low stringency X
X
Species A
Species B
~
~
(RAPD) PCR underlow stringencyconditions
X
Ligation of vectorette linker containing a central mismatched segment
./"
Heat denaturation
no exponentialamplification fromspeciesA exponentiallyamplifiedDNA fragment from species B
~ Subcloning, Sequencing, Constructionof specific primersY andZ
1 st strand synthesis with target primer
~ StandardPCRusing manyspecies'DNA as templates
PCR with target and vectorette primers
"~LLLUdz
/
|
/
no priming
Z
~ Subcloning, Sequencing Phylogeneticanalysis
FIGURE I (A) Schematic outline of the RAPD method. See text for details. (B) Schematic outline of the vectorette approach. Genomic DNA is digested with a restriction enzyme (R). A vectorette linker, composed of two oligonucleotides that are complementary only at the ends and leave a central mismatched part, is ligated to the DNA fragments. In a PCR the synthesis of first-strand DNA is primed by an oligonucleotide specific for the target segment of a known sequence (shown as black box) and extended into the flankingparts and vectorette linker. This strand is used as a template in subsequent PCR cycles by the vectorette primer, which is located in the mismatched segment of the linker.
west and east African cichlid species, whereas at DXTU2, no products were found in cichlid species outside the Lake Victoria and Lake Malawi regions. These results are most likely due to different extents of conservation at the primer-binding sites. 3. Another notable feature of the specific PCR was the appearance of several by-products in addition to the band of the expected size. Since the possibility of amplification from multiple related loci (e.g., diversified repeats) could not be excluded in some cases, a third primer was used to prove the singularity of the amplified region in the cichlid genome. Sequence variability in the D N A fragments resulting from specific PCR can also be examined using single-stranded conformation polymorphism (SSCP;
Orita et al., 1989a,b) analysis. In this approach, distinct banding patterns of PCR products from different species indicate sequence differences between species at a single locus. The polymorphic locus DXTU1 was selected for a detailed sequence analysis using the GCG software package (Devereux and Haeberli, 1991) or the Clustal V program (Higgins et al., 1992). The following analysis of representative sequences at the DXTU1 locus is shown (contact author for raw data): 1. It is remarkable that insertions or deletions (indels) constitute about one-quarter of the total number of polymorphic sites found at the DXTU1 and the other genomic loci. Although nucleotide substitutions are commonly used in phylogenetic tree construction, in-
4. Reconstruction of Cichlid Phylogeny
12345
1358 bp 1078 bp 872 bp
-.91~
603 bp v
FIGURE 2 Products obtained by RAPD PCR with the 10-mer primer TU984 (5' GTGTGCCCCA3'). Products from Pseudotropheuszebra (lanes 1 and 2) and Melanochromisauratus (lanes 3 and 4) were separated on a 2% agarose gel. The left arrow indicates a 400-bp band present only in lanes I and 2. Lane 5 contains DNA size marker. The arrows on the right denote marker sizes.
(~ (~f
dels are normally excluded, yet the n u m b e r of possible ways by which nucleotides can be inserted, deleted, or rearranged is nearly unlimited, in contrast to the three possibilities by which nucleotides can be substituted at a single site. Thus, data could be analyzed by two different methods: the standard tree construction m e t h o d based on genetic distances and the neighbor-joining algorithm of Saitou and Nei (1987), and the cladistic analysis with the PAUP p r o g r a m version 3.1.1. (Swofford, 1993), in which shared indels were treated as synapomorphies. 2. There is considerable agreement between the distance tree (Fig. 3) and the cladogram (Fig. 4) based on the DXTU1 sequences. Although the evolutionary forces acting on the single loci m a y vary, the topologies of the neighbor-joining trees constructed for other loci than DXTU1 were congruent with the DXTU1 tree (see Stiltmann et al., 1995). However, low bootstrap values with respect to certain branching patterns in the neighbor-joining tree (e.g., the position of haplochromines in Lake Malawi, Fig. 3) suggest that longer sequences or more loci are required for a more precise
|
Cyphotilapia frontosa-143 L_ Cyphotilapia frontosa- 144
" ~ L a k e Tanganyika
~J
Cyphotilapia
Melanochromis auratus-1 Tyrranochromis macrostoma-1
~
Lake Malawi Haplochromis
Haplochromis xenognathus-ll4 Haplochromis velifer-602 ~'L-Hapl~176
~
Lake Victoria
~
~ _~ .
43
[ILCyrtocaramoorii-ZR216 L Pseudotropheus zebra- 1
Haplochromis ~
Lake Malawi
I,[
Haplochromis
(~ "-"
Lake Tanganyika genera
[ Neolamprologus brevis-63 ~ f Neolamprologus leleupi-135 ~ Julidochromis regani-60 Neolamprologus tretocephalus- 140 - - Astatoreochromis alluaudi-771 Alcolapia alcalicus-462 Oreochromis niloticus-LS7 Oreochromis urolepis-LSl O
Tylochromis leonensis-PR2 Thorichthys meeki-#55 Cichla-#15
non-endemic species Tilapiines from rivers and Lake Natron West African species ~
Neotropical species
Genetic distance I ! I I ! I I I 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0 0.01 FIGURE 3 Neighbor-joining tree (Saitou and Nei, 1987) of the sequences at the DXTU1 locus. Genetic distances were calculated using Kimura's (1980) two-parameter method. The numbers at each node represent percentage recovery of the particular node in 1000 bootstrap replications.
44
HOLGER SCILTMANN AND WERNER E. MAYER
[
Melanochromis auratus-1 Pseudotropheus zebra- 1 Lake
Malawi
Haplochromis
Tyrannochromis macrostoma- 1 Cyrtocara moorii-ZR216 Haplochromis xenognathus-114
Lake Victoria
Haplochromis velifer-602
Haplochromis Haplochromis nigricans-268
Astatoreochromis alluaudi-771
non-endemic species
Cyphotilapia frontosa-143
Lake Tanganyika
Cyphotilapia frontosa-144
Cyphotilapia
Julidochromis regani-60
Lake Tanganyika
Neolamprologus leleupi-135
Julidochromis, Neolamprologus
Neolamprologus tretocephalus-140 Neolamprologus brevis-63 Alcolapia alcalicus-462
Oreochromis niloticus-LS7
Tilapiines
Oreochromis urolepis-LS l O
West African species
Tylochromis leonensis-PR2 Thorichthys meeki#55
~
Neotropicalspecies
Cichla#15 FIGURE 4 Cladogram of 20 representative taxa based on presence or absence of indels and substitutions at the DXTU1 locus. The tree resulted from 500 bootstrap replications using the heuristic search option of the PAUP program version 3.1.1 (Swofford, 1993). The numbers at each node represent percentage recovery of the particular branching order. Cichla No. 15 was used as an outgroup.
determination of species relationships. The trees (Figs. 3 and 4) of the DXTU1 sequences led to the following conclusions. First, the neotropical cichlid species Cichla sp. and Thorichthys meeki form a sister group to the African cichlids. The position of neotropical cichlids indicated by the molecular analysis is consistent with the results of morphological analysis (Cichocki, 1976; Oliver, 1984; Stiassny, 1991), which has revealed a set of derived characters uniting African cichlids (with the exception of Heterochromis) into a monophyletic group. Second, in the phylogram, the west African species Tylochromis leonensis is in a sister-group relationship with the east African species (the tilapiines, represented here by the genus Oreochromis from east African rivers and the Alcolapia alcalicus from Lake Natron; the Lake Tanganyika genera Neolamprologus, Julidochromis, and Cyphotilapia; and the Lake Malawi and Lake Vic-
toria species). In contrast, in the cladogram, Tylochromis appears as a sister group to the tilapiines. Third, the monophyly of the considered east African cichlids (tilapiines, haplochromines, and the Neolamprologus and Cyphotilapia genera of Lake Tanganyika) is indicated both by nucleotide substitution and by indel patterns. This branching order is also supported by mitochondrial DNA data (Meyer, 1993). Fourth, the tilapiines form a monophyletic sister group to the remaining east African Great Lake species and genera (haplochromines, Cyphotilapia, Astatoreochromis, and lamprologines). This result is concordant with morphological analyses (Regan, 1920; Trewavas, 1983) and other molecular studies (Kornfield et al., 1979; McAndrew and Majumdar, 1984; Seyoum, 1989; Sodsuk and McAndrew, 1991; Franck et al., 1994). Fifth, the species Astatoreochromis alluaudi, which is not endemic to Lake Victoria but is also found in other east African lakes and rivers, is a sister group of the
4. Reconstruction of Cichlid Phylogeny included east African lake genera. This result, as well as the sister-group placement of Julidochromis and Neolamprologus with respect to the Lake Malawi and Lake Victoria flocks, is also supported by mitochondrial DNA sequence data (Meyer et al., 1990). Sixth, the sister-group relationship of the Tanganyikan species Cyphotilapia frontosa to Lake Malawi haplochromines suggested by the NJ tree (Fig. 3) supports allozyme data (Kornfield, 1991), according to which Cyphotilapia is more closely related to the haplochromines of Lake Malawi than to those of Lake Tanganyika. This result further supports the polyphyletic structure of the Lake Tanganyika flocks. However, the cladogram (Fig. 4) favors Cyphotilapia in a sister group position to the Lake Malawi and Lake Victoria species on the one hand and the Lake Tanganyika Julidochromis and Neolamprologus genera on the other hand, thus supporting the sister group relationship of Cyphotilapia with other Lake Tanganyika cichlid flocks by using mtDNA control region data (Kocher et al., 1993). Finally, the monophyly of the endemic Lake Victoria haplochromines, as suggested by both trees, is consistent with the results of morphological studies (see Greenwood, 1978; Trewavas, 1983) and mitochondrial DNA analyses (Meyer et al., 1990; Sturmbauer and Meyer, 1992; Meyer, 1993; Moran and Kornfield, 1993). The finding of several indels, which are probably species specific, suggests that it may be possible to elucidate the relationships within species flocks using RAPD markers.
IV. Allele Size Frequencies at Dinucleotide Microsatellite Loci Microsatellites are tandemly repeated DNA sequences with repeat units of I to 6 bp in length and 10 to 100 units per locus (Charlesworth et al., 1994). They have been used for the construction of genetic maps in humans (Hearne et al., 1992; LeBlanc-Straceski et al., 1994) and other species. Variable repeat numbers have also been implicated in disease and cancer susceptibility (Wooster et al., 1994). The rate of mutations generating microsatellite repeat number variation is highest among all nuclear DNA markers; estimations for dinucleotide repeats range from 10 -2 to 10 -4 per generation (Jeffreys et al., 1988; Weber and Wong, 1993). This high mutation rate makes microsatellites a promising tool for population genetic analyses. Consequently, a number of studies have made use of microsatellites for determining relationships among populations of humans (Bowcock et al., 1994; Deka
45
et al., 1995), wolves (Roy et al., 1994), sheep (Buchanan et al., 1994), and toads (Scribner et al., 1994). Variability is believed to occur by the stepwise addition or subtraction of single repeat units after mispairing of the two DNA strands during the replication process (stepwise mutation model, SMM; Levinson and Gutman, 1987; Schl6tterer and Tautz, 1992). It has been shown, however (DiRienzo et al., 1994), that the SMM does not fully explain observed allele frequency distributions within populations: although allelic variation at dinucleotide repeat loci is predominantly due to single step mutations, rare changes of more than one repeat unit may occur as well. Furthermore, unequal crossing-over during meiosis may also contribute to the generation of polymorphism at the microsatellite loci. In cichlids, microsatellites have been used to study the mating behavior of Lake Malawi species (Kellogg et al., 1995). Cichlid fish phylogenies based on microsatellite data have not yet been published. However, the determination of allele size frequency distributions in distinct species from Lake Malawi and Lake Victoria, followed by the calculation of distance matrices, may provide the most promising means for reconstructing their phylogenies. In order to generate allele size data, subgenomic libraries with small insert sizes (200-1000 bp) from P. zebra (Lake Malawi) and Haplochromis nigricans (Lake Victoria) in the A gtl0 phage vector were constructed. The libraries were screened with the CA dinucleotide repeat-specific oligonucleotide (Ca)lsC, and hybridizing clones were isolated and sequenced (Sambrook et al., 1989). The clones contained stretches of CA(GT)repeated DNA with repeat numbers ranging from 8 to 90. Sequence-specific primers flanking the entire repetitive element at the particular locus were then taken for PCR amplification using genomic DNA from Lake Victoria cichlids as templates. One of the primers was labeled with fluorescein at its 5' end. The PCR products obtained from polymorphic loci were separated on a denaturing polyacrylamide gel in an automated sequencing apparatus. Bands were detected as fluorescence intensities of the labeled DNA strands, and their sizes were automatically determined by comparison with a size standard. From several microsatellite loci typed, this chapter shows the example of the DXTUCA15 locus. This locus was amplified from haplochromine genomic DNA with the primers MS16 (5' GCTGTGTAATCCCAAACTCC 3') and MS17 (5' GTATTTAGcTTTCCTCTG TGCT 3') by PCR with one 45-sec cycle at 93~ 15 sec at 55 ~ and 10 min at 72 ~ followed by 35 cycles, each 15 sec at 93~ 15 sec at 55~ and 1 min at 72~ The reaction was completed by a final primer extension
46
HOLGER S~ILTMANN AND WERNER E. MAYER
step for 10 min at 72~ As templates, genomic DNA samples from the Lake Victoria (and minor adjacent lakes like Lake Nabugabo, Kayugi, and Kayania) Haplochromis species H. beadlei (number of individuals, n = 12), H. cinctus (n = 19), H. laparogramma (n = 12),
H. nigricans (n = 15), H. nyererei (n = 40), H. plagiodon (n = 19), H. pyrrhocephalus (n = 43), H. sauvagei (n = 17), H. velifer (n = 81), and H. xenognathus (n = 29) were used. Individuals from each species were captured at two to six different locations in the wild. In the PCR, the primers amplified DNA fragments with sizes ranging from 75 to 93 bp. Size differences were due to variation of the number of CA repeat units, as determined by subcloning and sequencing random clones (data not shown). Although data are still preliminary, some interesting results have already been obtained from the specific amplification of cichlid microsatellite loci. First, in most of the amplifications, one or two products were visible (corresponding to homo- or heterozygosity of the individual at the particular locus). However, additional artifactual bands often appeared
Haplochromis beadlei
Haplochromislaparograrnrna
n=12
due to amplification at other loci. These by-products sometimes interfered with the precise determination of microsatellite size. Second, the size determination was also hampered by the occurrence of so-called "shadow bands" flanking the highest peak in a cluster of products. In the case of dinucleotide repeats, shadow bands usually differ by 2 bp in size. This observation suggests that they may have been generated by the insertion or deletion of repeat units during PCR amplification (Litt et al., 1993). Assuming that a similar mechanism generated shadow bands in different reactions, the largest peak area within a peak cluster for the determination of the allele size was used. Third, inhomogeneities within the polyacrylamide gel may lead to incorrect measurement of product sizes. In order to assess this possibility, the allele sizes at certain loci determined by gel electrophoresis were compared with those obtained by subcloning and sequencing of the same PCR products. From these data it was concluded that the error was no larger than one repeat unit. The summary of the allele size determination for each species is shown in Fig. 5. Allele frequencies (y
Haplochromis cinctus
n=12
Haplochromisnigricans
n=19
HapIochromis nyererei
n=15
n=40
0.4
g O.4 0.3
--e 0.3
0.3
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.3
0.2
o.111 I
0.1 o.,
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 repeat units
O.0
~
8
Hsplochromisplagiodon
~a 0.3
O 0
8
Hsplochromispyrrhocephalus
n=19
o>, 0.4 c
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 repeat units
0"0
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 1G 17 repeat units
8
Haplochromissauvagei
n=43
=-~. 04
o.,
-~ 0.3
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
O0
.
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 repeat units
8
Haplochromisvelifer
n=17
=~ o s]
.
0.1
Haplochromisxenognathus
n=81
n=29
~
0.41
Imi 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 repeat units
0.6
~0.5"
_== 0.4"
0.3 0.2 0.2 0.1
0.1
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 repeat units
0.0
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 repeat units
0.0
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 repeat units
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 repeat units
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 repeat units
FIGURE 5 Allele frequency distributions for 10 Haplochromis species from the Lakes Victoria, Kayugi, Kayania, and Nabugabo at the microsatellite locus DXTUCA15. Frequencies (y axis) are plotted against the number of repeat units (x axis) found in the fragment analysis (see text for details). The number of individuals included in each sample is given by n.
4. Reconstructionof Cichlid Phylogeny axis) are tabulated against the number of repeat units (x axis) calculated from the PCR product size by subtraction of the number of unique nucleotides in the fragment. Differences in frequency distributions between species are indicated by shape variations between the individual plots. Frequency data were used as the input for the microsat 1.4 computer program (written by Eric Minch; Goldstein et al., 1995), which calculates various distance measurements on the basis of allele frequencies (e.g., average squared difference in repeat numbers, Nei's identity; proportion of shared alleles). The basic assumption of the program is the validity of the stepwise mutation model (see also Valdes et al., 1993; Slatkin, 1995). It is important to note, however, that the algorithm is not dependent on the distribution of allele sizes within the species. Nei's identity method (Nei, 1972) was used for the calculation of a distance matrix (Fig. 6) which was then applied for the construction of a phylogenetic tree by the PHYLIP software package (Felsenstein, 1986-1993). The tree is shown in Fig. 7. It can be divided into two major branches, one of which is constituted by the Haplochro-
mis nyererei, H. nigricans, H. plagiodon, H. pyrrhocephalus, and H. laparogramma species, whereas H. beadlei, H. cinctus, H. sauvagei, and H. xenognathus appear on the second major branch. Haplochromis velifer is located at an intermediate position. An obstacle for a test of the reconstruction of the true phylogeny based on microsatellite allele frequencies in the closely related cichlid species from Lake Victoria is the low abundance of synapomorphic morphological characters. Most of the available studies have focused on the feeding habits, jaw morphology, and dentition (Greenwood, 1974, 1979, 1980; Witte and van Oijen, 1990). On the basis of these data, the species included in the phylogenetic tree (Fig. 7) can be subdivided into two major trophic groups (Witte and van Oijen, 1990), one of which is the planktivorous/algaeeating group Haplochromis cinctus (phytoplankton), H. laparogramma, H. pyrrhocephalus, H. nyererei (zoo-
i0
Habe Haci Hala Hani Hany Hapl Hapy Hasa Havl Haxe
-0.086 -0.030 -0.016 0.030 -0.050 0.088 -0.095 -0.008 0.072
0.051 0.088 0.158 0.024 0.117 -0.015 0.124 0.234
-0.078 -0.013 -0.079 -0.023 0.017 -0.018 0.248
-0.046 -0.078 0.040 0.009 -0.034 0.152
47
plankton), and H. nigricans (epilithic algae grazer). The other trophic group consists of the oral shell/mollusc crashers H. plagiodon, H. sauvagei, and H. xenognathus as well as H. beadlei, which is considered to be a sister species of Haplochromis plagiodon (Greenwood, 1980). In the phylogenetic tree generated by microsatellite data, this grouping is roughly reflected in the major branching pattern. The exceptions to this are H. plagiodon and cinctus, which are unexpectedly located on the opposite branches. Thus, data suggest that microsatellite data can be used to make a rough subdivision of some Lake Victoria cichlid species which corresponds to their feeding habits. Whether the congruence between phylogenetic position and trophic grouping is a rule for haplochromines in general remains to be examined. Certainly, multiple microsatellite loci will have to be analyzed in order to generate more reliable and independent data sets.
V. Critical Evaluation Using RAPD and Microsatellite Allele Frequencies for the Reconstruction of Cichlid Fish Phylogeny The recent adaptive radiation of cichlid fishes in Lake Malawi and Lake Victoria has produced closely related species flocks. The reconstruction of their phylogeny requires new methods capable of resolving genetic distances generated within short time spans. Because the available markers (mtDNA, allozymes, morphology) have achieved the goal of clarifying the Lake Victoria and Lake Malawi cichlid phylogeny only marginally, two different approaches that are both based on nuclear DNA markers were studied. The goal was to test the validity of current hypotheses on cichlid fish relationships. The RAPD-based sequence comparison requires relatively few samples from the species under consideration, and data collection and analysis are compara-
-0.029 0.157 0.023 -0.006 0.083
0.036 -0.024 -0.022 0.141
0.168 0.141 0.547
-0.001 0.033
0.i01
FIGURE 6 Distance matrix obtained with microsatellite allele frequency data for the 10 Haplochromis species shown in Fig. 5. Nei's identity method (Nei, 1972) was used for the generation of the matrix with the program microsat 1.4 (Goldstein et al., 1995).
48
HOLGER SfflLTMANN AND WERNER E. MAYER
Haplochromis laparogramma Haplochromis pyrrhocephalus Haplochromis plagiodon Haplochromis nigricans Haplochromis nyererei Haplochromis velifer I Haplochromis beadlei [ Haplochromis cinctus [ Haplochromis sauvagei
I I
I
Haplochromisxenognathus I
0 0.05 0.1 Relative length
I
0.15
FIGURE 7 Neighbor-joining tree (Saitou and Nei, 1987) constructed using the distance matrix from Fig. 6 as input data for the PHYLIP distance algorithm (Felsenstein, 1986 - 1993 ).
tively easy to carry out. The chance of finding interspecies variation in the set of random sequences is high. A prerequisite of the method as described here, however, is complete lineage sorting of the particular RAPD marker. To distinguish young species, therefore, frequency data are necessary. Subcloning and sequencing can be performed by established methods, but are time-consuming. Sequence data provide two types of characters, substitutions and indels, both of which can be used in separate phylogenetic analyses. The results obtained thus far agree well with previously reported molecular data and support the use of this method for molecular evolutionary studies of cichlid fishes. Yet, because some conflicting hypotheses (e.g., the position of Cyphotilapia with respect to the other east African Lake cichlids) could not be clearly resolved, the number of RAPD markers has to be increased in order to obtain phylogenetic trees with higher bootstrap support values. The likelihood of detecting synapomorphic characters between related species increases with the time that has passed since species separation. In this respect, the evolutionarily young (less than 2 MY) species flocks from Lake Malawi and Lake Vic-
toria, which are the interesting ones regarding the speciation process, will require many more nuclear DNA loci and sequencing. For the Lake Victoria haplochromines, the feasibility of obtaining such markers has been shown with the RAPD approach. The microsatellite approach makes use of the high mutation rate of short tandemly repeated sequences. Therefore, this method is more suitable for the determination of relationships between closely related species like the haplochromines of Lake Malawi and Lake Victoria. Once the polymorphic loci have been identified and the variation has been shown to be due to the repeat numbers, allele typing can be performed much quicker as compared to sequencing approaches. However, because the method employs frequency data, the requirement for large sample sizes per species may be a major obstacle to generating reliable data sets. It has been shown for di- to hexanucleotide microsatellite loci that the variance of the stepwise-weighted genetic distance does not change significantly when more than 25 individuals per species are used (Shriver et al., 1995). This number thus defines the preferred sample size. Two limiting factors hinder the use of microsatellite
4. Reconstruction of Cichlid Phylogeny
allele size typing: First, at oligomorphic loci the allele frequency distributions are similar in all species because the time for generation of variability has been too short or polymorphism has predated the speciation process. Second, in the case of convergence the allele frequency distributions of the species are similar because the process of generation of variability has reached an equilibrium state in all the species. In addition, to use the microsatellite approach effectively, several theoretical considerations have to be resolved: First, there is still uncertainty concerning the mechanism generating the variability (Schl6tterer and Tautz, 1992; DiRienzo et al., 1994). Thus, the available models might have to be refined once the mechanism of generation of repeat number variation has been elucidated. Second, the possibility of selection acting on microsatellite repeat number cannot be excluded and may lead to inconsistent results when loci are compared. Third, ignorance of interspecific hybridization events introduces a high degree of uncertainty concerning the topology of the phylogenetic tree. Fourth, errors due to inadequate sample size and possible kinships between cichlid fish taxa are difficult to evaluate and may bias the observed genetic distances between species. In general, RAPD and the microsatellite approach are both able to detect polymorphism between closely related taxonomic groups. With respect to cichlid phylogeny, RAPD can be primarily applied to genera under comparison. In contrast, the microsatellite method should be applied to the species and population level. Despite the unresolved problems with microsatellites, it is the authors' opinion that they are the best tool so far among all the available methods for studying cichlid phylogeny. Nonetheless, the search for additional polymorphic nuclear DNA markers should be continued because these will provide excellent markers for testing the validity of phylogenetic hypotheses.
Acknowledgments We thank Jan Klein for critical reading of the manuscript and helpful suggestions, Herbert Tichy for discussions on the cichlid species and providing the samples, Eric Minch from the Department of Genetics, Stanford University, for the microsat 1.4 program and help in getting it started, and Lynne Yakes for editorial assistance.
References Ayliffe, M. A., Lawrence, G. J., Ellis, J. G., and Pryor, A. J. 1994. Heteroduplex molecules formed between allelic sequences cause nonparental RAPD bands. Nucleic Acids Res. 22:1632-1636. Bardakci, F., and Skibinski, D. O. F. 1994. Application of the RAPD technique in tilapia fish: Species and subspecies identification. Heredity 73:117-123. Bowcock, A. M., Ruiz-Linares, A., Tomfohrde, J., Minch, E., Kidd, J. R., and Cavalli-Sforza, L. L. 1994. High resolution of human
49
evolutionary trees with polymorphic microsatellites. Nature 368: 455 -457. Bowditch, B. M., Albright, D. G., Williams, J. G. K., and Braun, M. J. 1994. Use of randomly amplified polymorphic DNA markers in comparative genome studies. Meth. Enzymol. 224:294-309. Bowers, N., Stauffer, J. R., and Kocher, T. D. 1994. Intra- and interspecific mitochondrial DNA sequence variation within two species of rock-dwelling cichlids (Teleostei: Cichlidae) from Lake Malawi, Africa. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 3(1):75-82. Brown, W.M., George, M., Jr., and Wilson, A.C. 1979. Rapid evolution of animal mitochondrial DNA. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 76: 1967-1971. Buchanan, F. C., Adams, L. J., Littlejohn, R. P., Maddox, J. F., and Crawford, A. M. 1994. Determination of evolutionary relationships among sheep breeds using microsatellites. Genomics 22: 397-403. Charlesworth, B., Sniegowski, P., and Stephan, W. 1994. The evolutionary dynamics of repetitive DNA in eukaryotes. Nature 371: 215-220. Cichocki, F. P. 1976. "Cladistic History of Cichlid Fishes and Reproductive Strategies of the American Genera Acarichthys, Biotodoma and Geophagus," Vol. 1. Ph.D. thesis, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI. Cohen, A. S., Soreghan, M. J., and Scholz, C A. 1993. Estimating the age of formation of lakes: An example from Lake Tanganyika, East African rift system. Geology 21:511-514. Deka, R., Jin, L., Shriver, M. D., Yu, L. M., Decroo, S., Hundrieser, J., Bunker, C. H., Ferrell, R. E., and Chakraborty, R. 1995. Population genetics of dinucleotide (dC-dA)n 9(dG-dT)n polymorphisms in world populations. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 56:461-474. Devereux, J., and Haeberli, P. 1991. "Genetics Computer Group, Program manual for the GCG package, Version 7," April 1991, Madison, WI. DiRienzo, A., Peterson, A. C., Garza, J. C., Valdes, A. M., Slatkin, M., and Freimer, N. B. 1994. Mutational processes of simple-sequence repeat loci in human populations. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 91: 3166-3170. Ellsworth, D. L., Rittenhouse, K. D., and Honeycutt, R. L. 1993. Artifactual variation in randomly amplified polymorphic DNA banding patterns. Biotechniques 14:214-217. Felsenstein, J. 1986-1993. "PHYLIP: Phylogenetic Inference Package Version 3.5c." University of Washington. Franck, J. P. C., Kornfield, I., and Wright, J. M. 1994. The utility of SATA satellite DNA sequences for inferring phylogenetic relationships among the three major genera of tilapiine cichlid fishes. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 3:10-16. Franck, J. P. C., Wright, J. M., and McAndrew, B. J. 1992. Genetic variability in a family of satellite DNAs from tilapia (Pisces: Cichlidae). Genome 35: 719-725. Fryer, G., and Iles, T. D. 1972. "The Cichlid Fishes of the Great Lakes of Africa." Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh. Gaemers, P. A. M. 1984. Taxonomic position of the Cichlidae as demonstrated by the morphology of their otoliths. Neth. J. Zool. 34: 566-595. Goldstein, D. B., Linares, A. R., Cavalli-Sforza, L. L., and Feldman, M. W. 1995. An evaluation of genetic distances for use with microsatellite loci. Genetics 139: 463-471. Greenwood, P. H. 1974. Cichlid fishes of Lake Victoria, East Africa: The biology and evolution of a species flock. Bull. Br. Mus. Nat. Hist. (Zool.) Suppl. 6:1-134. Greenwood, P. H. 1978. A review of the pharyngeal apophysis and its significance in the classification of African cichlid fishes. Bull. Br. Mus. Nat. Hist. (Zool.) 33:297-323. Greenwood, P. H. 1979. Towards a phyletic classification of the 'genus' Haplochromis (Pisces, Cichlidae) and related taxa. Bull. Br. Mus. Nat. Hist. (Zool.) 35:265-322.
50
HOLGER SCILTMANN A N D WERNER E. MAYER
Greenwood, P. H. 1980. Towards a phyletic classification of the 'genus' Haplochromis (Pisces, Cichlidae) and related taxa. II. The species from Lakes Victoria, Nabugabo, Edward, George, and Kivu. Bull. Br. Mus. Nat. Hist. (Zool.) 39:1-101. Greenwood, P. H. 1984. What is a species flock? In "Evolution of Fish Species Flocks" (A. A. Echelle and I. Kornfield, eds.), pp. 13-20. University of Maine at Orono Press, Maine. Greenwood, P. H. 1987. The genera of pelmatochromine fishes (Teleostei, Cichlidae). A phylogenetic review. Bull. Br. Mus. Nat. Hist. (Zool.) 53:139-203. Greenwood, P. H. 1991. Speciation. In "Cichlid Fishes: Behavior, Ecology and Evolution" (M. H. A. Keenleyside, ed.), pp. 86-102. Chapman and Hall, London. Hearne, C. M., Ghosh, S., and Todd, J. A. 1992. Microsatellites for linkage analysis of genetic traits. Trends Genet. 8:288-294. Higgins, D. G., Bleasby, A. J., and Fuchs, R. 1992. CLUSTAL V: Improved software for multiple sequence alignment. Cabios 8: 189-191. Jeffreys, A. J., Royle, N. J., Wilson, V., and Wong, Z. 1988. Spontaneous mutation rates to new length alleles at tandem-repetitive hypervariable loci in human DNA. Nature 332:278-281. Kaufman, L., and Liem, K. F. 1982. Fishes of the suborder Labroidei (Pisces: Perciformes): Phylogeny, ecology and evolutionary significance. Breviora 472:1-19. Kellogg, K. A., Markert, J. A., Stauffer, J. R., Jr., and Kocher, T. D. 1995. Microsatellite variation demonstrates multiple paternity in lekking cichlid fishes from Lake Malawi, Africa. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 260:79-84. Kimura, M. 1980. A simple method for estimating evolutionary rate of base substitutions through comparative studies of nucleotide sequences. J. Mol. Evol. 16:111-120. Klein, D., Ono, H., O'Huigin, C., Vincek, V., Goldschmidt, T., and Klein, J. 1993. Extensive MHC variability in cichlid fishes of Lake Malawi. Nature 364: 330-334. Klein, J., Klein, D., Figueroa, F., and O'Huigin, C. 1997. Major histocompatibility complex genes in the study of fish phylogeny. In "Molecular Systematics of Fishes" (T. D. Kocher and C. A. Stepien, eds.). Academic Press, San Diego. Kocher, T. D., Conroy, J. A., McKaye, K. R., and Stauffer, J. R. 1993. Similar morphologies of cichlid fish in Lakes Tanganyika and Malawi are due to convergence. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 2:158-165. Kocher, T. D., Conroy, J. A., McKaye, K. R., Stauffer, J. R., and Lockwood, S. F. 1995. Evolution of NADH dehydrogenase subunit 2 in east African cichlid fish. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 4(4): 420-432. Kornfield, I. L. 1978. Evidence for rapid speciation in African cichlid fishes. Experientia 34: 335- 336. Kornfield, I. L. 1991. Genetics. In "Cichlid Fishes: Behavior, Ecology and Evolution" (M. H. A. Keenleyside, ed.), pp. 103-150. Chapman and Hall, London. Komfield, I. L., Ritte, U., Richler, C., and Wahrman, J. 1979. Biochemical and cytological differentiation among cichlid fishes of the Sea of Galilee. Evolution 33:1-14. LeBlanc-Straceski, J. M., Montgomery, K. T., Kissel, H., Murtaugh, L., Tsai, P., Ward, D. C., Krauter, K. S., and Kucherlapati, R. 1994. Twenty-one polymorphic markers from human chromosome 12 for integration of genetic and physical maps. Genomics 19:341349. Levinson, G., and Gutman, G. 1987. Slipped-strand mispairing: A major mechanism for DNA sequence evolution. Mol. Biol. Evol. 4(3):203-221. Litt, M., Hauge, X., and Sharma, V. 1993. Shadow bands seen when typing polymorphic dinucleotide repeats: Some causes and cures. BioTechniques 15(2):280-284. Livingstone, D. A. 1980. Environmental changes in the Nile head-
waters. In "The Sahara and the Nile" (M. A. J. Williams and H. Faure, eds.), pp. 339-359. Balkema, Rotterdam. McAndrew, B. J., and Majumdar, K. C. 1983. Tilapia stock identification using electrophoretic markers. Aquaculture 30: 249- 261. McAndrew, B. J., and Majumdar, K. C. 1984. Evolutionary relationships within three Tilapiine genera (Pisces: Cichlidae). Zool. J. Linn. Soc. 80:421-435. McKaye, K. R., Kocher, T., Reinthal, P., and Kornfield, I. 1982. Genetic analysis of a sympatric sibling species complex of Petrotilapia Trewavas (Cichlidae, Lake Malawi). Zool. J. Linn. Soc. 76:91-96. Meyer, A. 1987. Phenotypic plasticity and heterochrony in Cichlasoma managuense (Pisces, Cichlidae) and their implications for speciation in cichlid fishes. Evolution 41(6): 1357-1369. Meyer, A. 1993. Phylogenetic relationships and evolutionary processes in East African cichlid fishes. Trends Ecol. Evol. 8:279-284. Meyer, A., Kocher, T. D., Basasibwaki, P., and Wilson, A. C. 1990. Monophyletic origin of Lake Victoria cichlid fishes suggested by mitochondrial DNA sequences. Nature 347:550-553. Moran, P., and Kornfield, I. 1993. Retention of an ancestral polymorphism in the Mbuna species flock (Teleostei: Cichlidae) of Lake Malawi. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10(5):1015-1029. Muralidharan, K., and Wakeland, E. K. 1993. Concentration of primer and template qualitatively affects products in randomamplified polymorphic DNA PCR. BioTechniques 14(3):362-364. Nei, M. 1972. Genetic distance between populations. Am. Nat. 949: 283-292. Nishida, M. 1991. Lake Tanganyika as an evolutionary reservoir of old lineages of East African cichlid fishes: Inferences from allozyme data. Experientia 47:974-979. Oliver, M. K. 1984. "Systematics of African Cichlid Fishes; Determination of the Most Primitive Taxon, and Studies on the Haplochromines of Lake Malawi (Teleostei: Cichlidae)." Ph.D. thesis, Yale University, New Haven, CT. Ono, H., O'Huigin, C., Tichy, H., and Klein, J. 1993. Major-histocompatibility-complex variation in two species of cichlid fishes from Lake Malawi. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10:1060-1072. Orita, M., Iwahana, H., Kanazawa, H., Hayashi, K., and Sekiya, T. 1989a. Detection of polymorphisms of human DNA by gel electrophoresis as single-strand conformation polymorphism. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86:2766-2770. Orita, M., Suzuki, Y., Sekiya, T., and Hayashi, K. 1989b. Rapid and sensitive detection of point mutations and DNA polymorphisms using the polymerase chain reaction. Genomics 5:874-879. Owen, R. B., Crossley, R., Johnson, T. C., Tweddle, D., Kornfield, I., Davison, S., Eccles, D. H., and Engstrom, D. E. 1990. Major low levels of Lake Malawi and their implications for speciation rates in cichlid fishes. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 240:519-553. Pellegrin, J. 1904. Contribution a l'6tude anatomique, biologique et taxonomique des poissons de la famille des cichlid6s. M~m. Soc. Zool. Fr. 16: 41-402. Poll, M. 1986. Classification des Cichlidae du lac Tanganyika: Tribus, genres et esp~ces. M~m. Acad. R. Belg. CI. Sci. 45: 5-163. Postlethwait, J. H., Johnson, S. L., Midson, C. N., Talbot, W. S., Gates, M., Ballinger, E. W., Africa, D., Andrews, R., Carl, T., Eisen, J. S., Home, S., Kimmel, C. B., Hutchinson, M., Johnson, M., and Rodriguez, A. 1994. A genetic linkage map for the zebrafish. Science 264: 699- 703. Regan, C. T. 1906. A revision of the fishes of the South American cichlid genera Cichla, Chaetobranchus and Chaetobranchopsis, with notes on the genera of the American Cichlidae. Ann. Mag. Nat. Hist. 7: 230-239. Regan, C. T. 1920. The classification of the fishes of the family Cichlidae. I. The Tanganyikan genera. Ann. Mag. Nat. Hist. 9:33-53. Ribbink, A. J. 1991. Distribution and ecology of the cichlids of the
4. Reconstruction of Cichlid Phylogeny
African Great Lakes. In "Cichlid Fishes: Behavior, Ecology and Evolution" (M. H. A. Keenleyside, ed.), pp. 36-59. Chapman and Hall, London. Riley, J., Butler, R., Ogilvie, D., Finniear, R., Jenner, D., Powell, S., Anand, R., Smith, J. C., and Markham, A. F. 1990. A novel rapid method for the isolation of terminal sequence from yeast artificial chromosome (YAC) clones. Nucleic Acids Res. 18:2887-2890. Roy, M. S., Geffen, E., Smith, D., Ostrander, E. A., and Wayne, R. K. 1994. Patterns of differentiation and hybridization in North American wolflike canids, revealed by analysis of microsatellite loci. Mol. Biol. Evol. 11(4):553-570. Sage, R. D., Loiselle, P. V., Basasibwaki, P., and Wilson, A. C. 1984. Molecular versus morphological change among cichlid fishes of Lake Victoria. In "Evolution of Fish Species Flocks" (A. A. Echelle and I. Kornfield, eds.), pp. 185-197. University of Maine at Orono Press. Maine. Sage, R. D., and Selander, R. K. 1975. Trophic radiation through polymorphism in cichlid fishes. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 72: 46694673. Saiki, R. K., Gelfland, D. H., Stoffel, S., Scharf, S. J., Higuchi, I. G., Horn, G. T., Mullis, K. B., and Erlich, H. A. 1988. Primer directed enzymatic amplification of DNA with a thermostable DNA polymerase. Science 239: 487-491. Saitou, N., and Nei, M. 1987. The neighbor-joining method: A new method for reconstructing phylogenetic trees. Mol. Biol. Evol. 4: 406-425. Sambrook, J., Fritsch, E. F., and Maniatis, T. 1989. "Molecular Cloning: A Laboratory Manual." Cold Spring Harbor Press, Cold Spring Harbor, NY. Sanger, F., Nicklen, S., and Coulson, A. R. 1977. DNA sequencing with chain-terminating inhibitors. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 74: 5463-5467. Schliewen, U. K., Tautz, D., and P~i~ibo, S. 1994. Sympatric speciation suggested by monophyly of crater lake cichlids. Nature 368:629632. Schl6tterer, C., and Tautz, D. 1992. Slippage synthesis of simple sequence DNA. Nucleic Acids Res. 20(2):211-215. Scribner, K. T., Arntzen, J. W., and Burke, T. 1994. Comparative analysis of intra- and interpopulation genetic diversity in Bufo bufo, using allozyme, single-locus microsatellite, minisatellite, and multilocus data. Mol. Biol. Evol. 11(5):737-748. Serikawa, T., Montagutelli, X., Simon-Chazottes, D., and Gu6net, J.-L. 1992. Polymorphisms revealed by PCR with single, shortsized, arbitrary primers are reliable markers for mouse and rat gene mapping. Mamm. Genome 3:65- 72. Seyoum, S. 1989. "Stock Identification and the Evolutionary Relationship of the Genera Oreochromis, Sarotherodon and Tilapia (Pisces: Cichlidae) Using Allozyme Analysis and Restriction Endonuclease Analysis of Mitochondrial DNA." Ph.D. thesis, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada. Shriver, M. D., Jin, L., Boerwinkle, E., Deka, R., Ferrell, R. E., and Chakraborty, R. 1995. A novel measure of genetic distances for highly polymorphic tandem repeat loci. Mol. Biol. Evol. 12(5): 914-920. Slatkin, M. 1995. A measure of population subdivision based on microsatellite allele frequencies. Genetics 139: 457-462. Smith, J. J., Scott-Craig, J. S., Ledbetter, J. R., Bush, G. L., Roberts, D. L., and Fulbright, D. W. 1994. Characterization of random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) products from Xanthomonas campestris and some comments on the use of RAPD products in phylogenetic analysis. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 3(2):135-145.
51
Sodsuk, P., and McAndrew, B. J. 1991. Molecular systematics of three tilapiine genera Tilapia, Sarotherodon and Oreochromis using allozyme data. J. Fish Biol. 39:301-308. Stiassny, M. L. J. 1987. Cichlid familial interrelationships and the placement of the neotropical genus Cichla (Perciformes, Labroidei). J. Nat. Hist. 21:1311-1331. Stiassny, M. L. J. 1991. Phylogenetic intrarelationships of the family Cichlidae: An Overview. In "Cichlid Fishes: Behavior, Ecology and Evolution" (M. H. A. Keenleyside, ed.), pp. 1-35. Chapman and Hall, London. Sturmbauer, C., and Meyer, A. 1992. Genetic divergence, speciation and morphological stasis in a lineage of African cichlid fishes. Nature 358:578-581. Sturmbauer, C., and Meyer, A. 1993. Mitochondrial phylogeny of the endemic mouthbrooding lineages of cichlid fishes from Lake Tanganyika in Eastern Africa. Mol. Biol. Evol. 10:751-768. Sturmbauer, C., Verheyen, E., and Meyer, A. 1994. Mitochondrial phylogeny of the Lamprologini, the major substrate spawning lineage of cichlid fishes from Lake Tanganyika in Eastern Africa. Mol. Biol. Evol. 11:691-703. S(iltmann, H., Mayer, W. E., Figueroa, F., Tichy, H., and Klein, J. 1995. Phylogenetic analysis of cichlid fishes using nuclear DNA markers. Mol. Biol. Evol. 12(6): 1033-1047. Swofford, D. L. 1993. "PAUP: Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony, Version 3.1.1." Computer program distributed by the Illinois Natural History Survey, Champaign, Ill. Trewavas, E. 1973. On the cichlid fishes of the genus Pelmatochromis with a proposal of a new genus for P. congicus; on the relationship between Pelmatochromis and Tilapia and the recognition of Sarotherodon as a distinct genus. Bull. Br. Mus. Nat. Hist. (Zool.) 26: 331-419. Trewavas, E. 1983. Tilapiine fishes of the genera Sarotherodon, Oreochromis and Danakilia. Br. Mus. (Nat. Hist.) Lond. Valdes, A. M., Slatkin, M., and Freimer, N. B. 1993. Allele frequencies at microsatellite loci: The stepwise mutation model revisited. Genetics 133: 737- 749. Vandewalle, P. 1971. Comparaison ost6ologique et myologique de cinq Cichlidae Africains et Sud-Americains. Ann. Soc. R. Zool. Belg. 101:259-292. Weber, J. L., and Wong, C. 1993. Mutation of human short tandem repeats. Hum. Mol. Genet. 2:1123-1128. Welsh, J., and McClelland, M. 1990. Fingerprinting genomes using PCR with arbitrary primers. Nucleic Acids Res. 18:7213-7218. Williams, J. G. K., Kubelik, A. R., Livak, K. J., Rafalski, J. A., and Tingey, S. V. 1990. DNA polymorphisms amplified by arbitrary primers are useful as genetic markers. Nucleic Acids Res. 18: 6531-6535. Witte, F., and van Oijen, M. J. P. 1990. Taxonomy, ecology and fishery of Lake Victoria haplochromine trophic groups. Zool. Verh. Leiden 262:1-47. Wooster, R., Cleton-Jansen, A.-M., Collins, N., Mangion, J., Cornelis, R. S., Cooper, C. S., Gusterson, B. A., Ponder, B. A. J., Von Deimling, A., Wiestler, O. D., Cornelisse, C. J., Devilee, P., and Stratton, M. R. 1994. Instability of short tandem repeats (microsatellites) in human cancers. Nat. Genet. 6:152-156. Wright, J. M. 1989. Nucleotide sequence, genomic organization and evolution of a major repetitive DNA family in tilapia (Oreochromis mossambicus/hornorum). Nucleic Acids Res. 17:5071-5079. Zihler, F. 1982. Gross morphology and configuration of digestive tracts of Cichlidae (Teleostei, Perciformes): Phylogenetic and functional significance. Neth. J. Zool. 32:544-571.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CHAPTER
5 Biogeographic Analysis of Pacific Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) in California and Mexico Based on Mitochondrial DNA and Nuclear Microsatellites JENNIFER L. NIELSEN and MONIQUE C. FOUNTAIN USDA Forest Service Pacific Southwest Research Station and Hopkins Marine Station Department of Biology Stanford University Pacific Grove, California 93950
rainbow trout). Genetic and morphological characters reported in many studies have confirmed the Pacific trout as true members of Oncorhynchus (PJehnke, 1968; Utter et al., 1973; Kendall and Behnke, 1984; Thomas et al., 1986; Stearley and Smith, 1993; Utter and Allendorf, 1994; see also Phillips and Oakley, 1997). The popular terms "salmon" and "trout" are now generally thought to refer to a flexibility in life history pattern .that has evolved independently among separate monophyletic groups, the Pacific Oncorhynchus [i.e., anadromous steelhead and freshwater rainbow trout O. mykiss; anadromous sockeye salmon (O nerka) and resident kokanee; sea-run and resident cutthroat trout O. clarki], and the Atlantic Salmo (i.e., anadromous and landlocked Atlantic salmon, S. salar; anadromous and resident brown trout, S. trutta). Similar trade-offs in life history traits are also found within Salvelinus (i.e., lacustrine and anadromous char, S. alpinus), suggesting that this flexibility in life history may
I. Introduction At the turn of the century, the Pacific basin trout were traditionally classified as members of the Atlantic lineage Salmo, based on analyses of morphology, life history characteristics, and iteroparity in the Pacific trout that were lacking in other Pacific salmon (Oncorhynchus spp.) The current reclassification of Pacific steelhead, cutthroat, and rainbow trout into the genus Oncorhynchus was based on new morphological characters and associations drawn from molecular genetic data (Smith and Stearley, 1989). As early as 1914, Regan had suggested that the Pacific trout were more closely related to the Pacific salmon (Oncorhynchus) than to the European Salmo. Based on osteological characters, Vladykov (1963) recognized that Pacific basin trout were separable from Atlantic basin Salmo, and Behnke (1965) first reported the near morphological identity of O. mykiss (Asiatic trout) and S. gairdnerii (North American
MOLECULAR SYSTEMATICS OF FISHES
JONATHAN M. WRIGHT Marine Gene Probe Laboratory Department of Biology Dalhousie University Halifax, Nova Scotia Canada B3H 4J1
53
Copyright 9 1997 by Academic Press. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
54
JENNIFER L. NIELSEN et al.
be a characteristic with roots ancestral to the split between Salmo and Oncorhynchus (Stearley and Smith, 1993; Foote et al., 1994). Genetic studies have revealed cryptic population structure due to behavior or life history variation that was not obvious from other types of analyses (Bowen et al., 1993; Bowcock et al., 1994). The reclassification of all Pacific anadromous steelhead and resident rainbow trout as O. mykiss has, therefore, led to significant controversy over the taxonomic status and genetic identity of the many subgroups of trout found throughout western North America (Behnke, 1992). Specific interest has evolved around the position of the California golden trout, the McCloud rainbow trout, Baja rainbow trout, the Eagle Lake rainbow trout, and the interior "redband" trout in the lineage of O. mykiss. The first genetic data used to support biogeographic separation of western trout into two major subgroups came from a study of allozymes via electrophoresis analyses conducted by Allendorf (1975). This study documented the geographical separation of western trout around the Cascade Crest (Pacific Crest), dividing O. mykiss into "inland" and "coastal" populations. Allendorf (1975) showed that allozyme allelic frequency differences separated inland and coastal groups of O. mykiss longitudinally over a broad geographic area throughout the western United States. Subsequent molecular studies conducted on the North American coastal distributions of O. mykiss supported genetic similarities between both resident (rainbow trout) and anadromous (steelhead) forms of coastal Pacific trout within geographically proximate locations (Utter et al., 1973; Okazaki, 1984; Parkinson, 1984; Currens et al., 1990; Gall et al., 1990; Reisenbichler et al., 1992). DNA analyses of the intraspecific genetic diversity in coastal O. mykiss confirmed the genetic similarity of resident and anadromous life history forms of trout from proximate geographic areas (Wilson et al., 1985; Thomas and Beckenbach, 1989)and have shown significant biogeographic structure at the southern extent of the range (Nielsen et al., 1994b). The latter study used mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and nuclear microsatellites to demonstrate a high degree of population differentiation and levels of genetic diversity that were unprecedented for this species. This unique level of genetic diversity found in southern steelhead has been confirmed by allozyme analyses of California coastal stocks by the National Marine Fisheries Service for their scientific status review resulting from a petition for Federal listing of the Pacific steelhead under the Endangered Species Act (Dr. R. Waples, personal communications, National Marine Fisheries Service, Seattle, WA).
DNA studies of Pacific salmonids initially concentrated on mitochondrial DNA markers due to the relatively rapid rate of evolution in this maternally inherited molecule, the ease of extraction and amplification of mtDNA, and a significant literature on the theory and application of mtDNA sequence analyses available to researchers by the end of the 1980s (Avise et al., 1987, and literature therein). Controversy has evolved over the degree and level of phylogenetic resolution available with mtDNA markers due to demonstrated variability in mutation rates for individual parts of the molecule among different taxa and possible saturation of base-point mutations in highly polymorphic regions (Avise et al., 1987, 1994b; Hillis, 1995). Despite such arguments, this molecule has played an important role in high-resolution analyses of population structure in closely related vertebrate groups (Moritz et al., 1987; Stoneking et al., 1991; Avise, 1994 and references therein; Avise et al., 1994a; Moritz et al., 1995). The development of simple protocols for the detection and amplification of short repetitive DNA sequences (i.e., microsatellites; Miklos, 1985; Tautz, 1989; Weber and May, 1989; Moore et al., 1991) provides access to new molecular tools derived from the nuclear genome with unusually high levels of intraspecific polymorphism. Short repetitive DNAs are common throughout the eukaryotic genome, have exceptionally high mutation rates, and generally provide large numbers of alleles useful for the reconstruction of closely related phylogenetic groups (Kelly et al., 1991; Henderson and Petes, 1992; Queller et al., 1993; Estoup et al., 1993; Bowcock et al., 1994). Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of microsatellites has provided an alternative molecular approach for the analysis of groups sharing recent evolutionary divergence (Burke et al., 1989; Bruford and Wayne, 1993; Queller et al., 1993; Ellegren, 1995). Nuclear microsatellite loci have, in general, provided a degree of analysis not previously available at the intraspecific level from mtDNA or allozymes (Bowcock et al., 1994; Goldstein et al., 1995; FitzSimmons et al., 1995; Nielsen, 1996). The function and biochemical mechanisms underlying mutation of simple sequence repeat loci, however, remain unknown and controversial (Long and David, 1980; Di Rienzo et al., 1994). One theoretical mechanism of mutation has been proposed for the microsatellite class of tandem repeats: a stepwise mutation process in which an allele mutates up or down by a small number of nucleotide repeat units (Schlotterer and Tautz, 1992). Variations on the stepwise mutation model underlie two recently developed genetic distance measures designed specifically for microsatellite loci (Goldstein et al., 1995; Slatkin, 1995). These dis-
5. mtDNA and Nuclear Microsatellites in Trout
tance measures are closely related in their analytical techniques, but are based on different conceptual interpretations of the stepwise mechanisms leading to repeat polymorphisms. Goldstein et al. (1995) used a strict (single-step) stepwise mutation model to analyze variation in the number of repeats found within a simple DNA sequence. Slatkin (1995), however, developed a two-phase mutation model introduced by Di Rienzo et al. (1994), which allows replication or deletion of more than one repeat unit as a single mutation event. Under the two-phase model, single-step mutations (involving only one repeat unit) are thought to be the most common elements of change, but events involving larger groups of repeat units, inserted or deleted as a single mutational element, are possible (Di Rienzo et al., 1994). Despite the fact that mutational mechanisms in repetitive DNA remain an open question, microsatellite markers have proven useful in many vertebrate population studies (Bruford and Wayne, 1993; Wright, 1993; Bowcock et al., 1994; Morin et al., 1994a,b; Nielsen et al., 1994b; Wright and Bentzen, 1994; Spencer et al., 1995; Gerloff et al., 1995). To date, however, no empirical studies have looked at the implications of the different analytical approaches to microsatellite distance data. Phylogenies based on single genes or short sequence loci, especially among closely related taxa, can be discordant with organismal phylogenies (Weller et al., 1994). Discrepancies between an individual gene tree and the true phylogeny of an organism can arise from lineage-sorting processes or allelic introgression between closely related groups (Neigel and Avise, 1986; Pamilo and Nei, 1988). The degree of phylogenetic congruence available among independent genetic markers has become an important issue in the interpretation of gene trees in relationship to organismal phylogenies (Birky et al., 1989; Bernatchez and Danzmann, 1993; Avise et al., 1994b; Bernatchez, 1995; Moritz et al., 1995). Phylogenetic results derived from several independent DNA regions provide a more robust perspective on the genetic history of an individual group or population than any one gene or nucleotide sequence alone (Avise, 1994; Cummings et al., 1995). It is important, however, that the chosen gene or sequence data used to test congruence among phylogenetic information are appropriately matched to the level or degree of phylogenetic divergence in question (Graybeal 1994). This chapter compares genetic diversity for mtDNA and three independent, highly polymorphic nuclear microsatellite markers in putative wild trout and steelhead populations from California and Mexico. DNA data on trout populations from interior as well as coastal locations are presented, and the intraspecific biogeographic resolution available for O. mykiss in
55
California and Mexico using both mtDNA and nuclear markers is addressed. Inferences available from these molecular data concerning the status of various populations of trout and steelhead are discussed.
II. Material and Methods A. Sampling Protocol
Coastal steelhead and interior trout (O. mykiss) were sampled noninvasively by taking fin clips (2-mm 2) from 354 live fish captured within riverine habitats in California and Mexico (Fig. 1). Tissues were sent as frozen or dried samples to the authors' laboratory from 1990 to 1995 and stored at -70~ until DNA extraction and amplifications were performed. O. mykiss were sampled from stream locations where wild stocks of steelhead and trout have been reported to have received a minimum of hatchery introductions since the mid-1930s [California Department of Fish and Game (CDFG) unpublished records and personal communications; Swift et al., 1993; Gall, 1995; Titus et al., in press]. Streams and rivers included in these analyses were divided into six general geographic localities to aid in the graphic depiction of data (see Appendix I). The northern and southern regions of California were separated at the San Francisco Bay and the interior and coastal populations were separated by the western boundary of the Klamath mountains and the great valley region in the north, the Sierra Nevada range throughout central California, and the transverse range in the south. All coastal steelhead and trout in California are currently classified as O. mykiss
Steelhead Eel River
/
Steelhead northcoast Eagle Lake
/.-~,.,~on,,~,~,,.,,,~/
rainbow~~~ ~~
Upper SacramentoRiver rainbow Steelhead RussianRiver
McCIoudRiver rainbow GoldenTroutCreek
Steelhead SF Bay
SF KernRivergoldentrout
Little Kerngoldentrout
Kern River rainbow
Central coast steelhead
Southern steelheadBig Sur Southern steelheadSanta YnezR.
/
Southern steelhead Malib~Cr.eek
Bajatrout
(,(~~___~tL./Rio Yaquitrout /.../~A~Mexico ,~,,,,
FIGURE 1 General location of DNA-sampling sites for steelhead and trout in California and Mexicoused in this study.
56
JENNIFERL. NIELSENet al.
irideus (after Behnke, 1992). The north interior collection of California trout included two putative subspecies of trout, the Eagle Lake trout (O. mykiss aquilarum) and the McCloud River redband trout (O. mykiss stonei), but probably contained a diverse mixture of populations with redband and coastal rainbow ancestry (Behnke, 1992). The south interior California trout collection was made up of three reported subspecies: the Kern River rainbow trout (O. mykiss gilberti), Little Kern River rainbow trout (O. mykiss whitei), and California golden trout from the South Fork Kern River (O. mykiss aquabonita). Mexican trout from Baja California Norte (O. mykiss nelsoni) were collected by G. Ruiz-Campos (Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Aut6noma de Baja California). Fin clips taken from trout from the Rio Yaqui basin (an undefined subspecies of O. mykiss, R. R. Miller, personal communications) were sent to the authors' laboratory by B. L. Jensen (U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Dexter National Fish Hatchery and Technology Center, Dexter, NM) and by Jose Campoy Favela (Centro Ecologico de Sonora, Hermosillo, Sonora, Mexico). These samples were collected from a headwaters tributary of the Rio La Cueva, a tributary of the Rio Bavispe, which is a tributary of the Rio Yaqui. B. M i t o c h o n d r i a l DNA Total genomic DNA was extracted from fin clips using Chelex-100 resin (BioRad) following the methods of Nielsen et al. (1994a). Primers used in this study (S-phe and P2) were developed by W. K. Thomas (University of Missouri, Kansas City) in the late Allan Wilson's laboratory using the methods given in Kocher et al. (1989). These primers are known to amplify a highly variable segment of the mtDNA control region in salmonids. These primers permit amplification and sequencing of a segment containing 188 bp of the O. mykiss mtDNA control region and 5 bp of the adjacent phenyalanine tRNA gene. Primer sequences, amplification and sequencing protocols, and sequence of the entire region amplified by these primers in this species can be found in Nielsen et al. (1994a).
C. Microsatellites Three microsatellite loci [Omy77, Morris et al. (1996); Omy207, M. O'Connell, Marine Gene Probe Laboratory (MGPL), Dalhousie University, personal communications; and Ssa289, McConnell et al. (1995)] were chosen for this study based on their level of polymorphism in O. mykiss. Omy77 and Omy207 were developed specifically for O. mykiss at MGPL, Dalhousie
University. Ssa289 was developed by MGPL for Atlantic salmon. The sequence for primers amplifying these microsatellite loci appears in the respective literature or is available by request from MGPL. For each locus, primer B was labeled according to protocols given in Nielsen et al. (1994b). The methods of Nielsen et al. (1994b) were used except that each PCR reaction contained 3.75 ~1 doubledistilled H20, 0.625 #1 10• PCR buffer (670 ~1 1 M Tris, 67 #1 1 M MgCI2, 83 ~1 2 M AmSo4, 7/.~1 14 M ]3-mercaptoethanol, and 173 Izl double-distilled H20), 0.625 #1 10 mM dDNTPs, 0.625 #1 10/~M primer A, 0.32 ~1 1 #M primer B, 0.32/~1 labeled B primer, and 0.03 ~1 (0.15 units) Taq polymerase. PCR conditions were 30 cycles of 94 ~ for 40 sec, 50~ for 1 min, and 72~ for 2 min. Microsatellites were run out on a 6% polyacrylamide gel. Prior to loading the gel, 5/~1 of loading buffer [94% formamide, 4% 0.5 EDTA, 0.025% (w/v) both bromphenol blue and xylene cyanol FF) was added to each sample. The size of each microsatellite allele was determined by reference to the M13mp18 sequence, known DNA samples that were rerun on each gel, and a doublestranded reference marker showing the common alleles available for each microsatellite locus. Only unambiguous bands were scored, and in the case of multiple (shadow) bands, the darkest band was scored as the allele. The appearance of stutter bands which overlap between alleles was resolved by comparing the intensity and number of stutter bands for each individual at each locus (O'Reilly and Wright, 1995). To ensure consistency in both the PCR reactions and the scoring of microsatellites, 3.5% of all samples were rerun separately on different gels and scored independently by two people.
D. A n a l y t i c a l A p p r o a c h A pairwise distance matrix was constructed for sequences from the mtDNA control region segment amplified by S-Phe and P2, based on the two-parameter model of Kimura (1980). Phylogenetic analysis was performed on mtDNA data using the unrooted neighbor-joining (NJ) tree procedure from PHYLIP (Felsenstein, 1991) with 1000 bootstrap replicates (Felsenstein, 1985) to assess reproducibility of the NJ mtDNAbranching pattern. Previous studies have documented the biogeographic concordance associated with the mtDNA haplotypes in coastal steelhead (Nielsen et al., 1994b; Neeley, 1995). To test for differences in biogeographic distribution of genotypes using nuclear microsatellites, microsatellite data were pooled for individual trout by
5. mtDNA and Nuclear Microsatellites in Trout
known mtDNA haplotype and capture location, where the parenthetical mtDNA haplotype designation refers to the most common haplotype found in that particular geographic population (Appendix II). These geographic-haplotype groups then served as sample units for microsatellite genetic distance analyses and tree development for comparison with the mtDNA NJ tree, allowing the authors to discuss results available from microsatellite data in individual populations with documented mtDNA phylogeographic structures. The trees depicted in these analyses were not intended to reflect historic evolutionary associations among trout populations, but rather to test for genetic congruence in biogeographic data drawn from two independent molecular markers with potentially different evolutionary histories among these populations. Observed and expected values of heterozygotes were calculated for microsatellite data, and a test for Hardy-Weinberg (HW) equilibrium was performed for all populations combined according to the Fisher method described by Louis and Dempster (1987), which provided an estimate of the probability of rejecting the null hypothesis, i.e., HW equilibrium. A pairwise genetic distance matrix was calculated for allelic diversity using both the Slatkin (1995) and the Goldstein et al. (1995) methods for the three microsatellite loci combined. For the Goldstein et al. (1995) distance analyses, the authors used the program available from Dr. E. Minch, Department of Genetics, Stanford University. Rst analyses were performed using a Pascal program developed by M. C. F. that implemented Slatkin's stepwise model for distance analyses. Both distance measures assume a linear expectation of the average-squared distance for each locus (assuming no correlation between mutation rate and repeat score) and use the arithmetic average of mutation rates across loci. Statistics in both methods are equivalent to a general analysis of variance. Both methods compute an average sum of squares of the differences in allelic size within each population [Sw in Slatkin (1995); Do in Goldstein et al. (1995)] and the average squared difference between all possible pairs of populations (SB and D1 respectively) to obtain an estimate of variance in allele size in the total population. The basic difference between the two methods involves how they interpret the parameters of the mutation process. Slatkin's Rst [developed under the assumptions of the infinite allele model, Slatkin (1991)] used a ratio of combinations of the mean squared distance which cancels out all parameters of the mutation process [see formula 12 in Slatkin (1995)]. Goldstein et al. (1995) maintain an estimate of the mutation process under the expectation of a strict, single-step (one
57
repeat unit) shift for each mutation event. Distance data from both methods were used to generate a consensus neighbor-joining tree (PHYLIP, Felsenstein, 1991). One thousand bootstrap replicate trees were generated to assess the reproducibility of branching patterns found in each consensus tree. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) and factor analysis using principal components (PCA) were used to describe biogeographic associations between genotype (mtDNA or microsatellite allelic diversity) and sample location (longitude and latitude). Each factor represented a linear combination of actual mtDNA haplotype or microsatellite allelic frequencies (weighted for sample size) over all genotypes. Factor analyses were based on the variance-covariance matrix for all sampled populations such that the range of components was associated with the proportion of total variance over all locations. The first component was, therefore, associated with the greatest portion of the total variance for all genotypes over all locations, the second component had the second greatest proportion, etc. Least-squares multiple regression analyses were then used to regress the first principal component on latitude or longitude by genotype to graphically depict the correlation between sampling locality and genotype distributions.
III. Results A. Mitochondrial
DNA
Three previously unpublished mtDNA controlregion haplotypes, containing novel single base mutations, were found in this survey of trout populations from California and Mexico (MYS15, MYS16, and MYS18; Table I). MYS15 was found only in golden trout from Golden Trout Creek in the Kern River basin and in Taylor Creek, a tributary to the South Fork Kern River. MYS16 was found in two tributaries of the South Fork Kern River (Fay Creek, Manter Creek), in Ramshaw Meadows on the South Fork Kern River, in Golden Trout Creek, and in Eagle Lake rainbow trout. MYS18 was unique to the trout of the Rio Yaqui basin of northwestern Mexico. Twenty-seven trout from the San Pedro M~rtir basin in Baja California were monomorphic for mtDNA haplotype MYS1. All other mtDNA haplotypes found in freshwater trout samples taken from interior California rivers and streams carried identical control-region haplotypes to those previously reported in coastal anadromous populations (Nielsen et al., 1994b). The frequency distribution of the
58
JENNIFER L. NIELSEN et al.
TABLE I Mitochondrial Control Region Variable Sites and Nucleotide Changes Found in California Steelhead and Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) in 1990-1995 and in Two Populations of Mexican Trout from Baja California and the Rio Yaqui Base pair no.a mtDNA type
No.
1021
MYS1 MYS2 MYS3 MYS5 MYS6 MYS8 MYS12 MYS13 MYS15 MYS16 MYS18
99 17 108 20 7 25 7 8 7 45 11
T C T T T T T T T T T
1050
1086
1103
1104
1106
1109
1147
1149
T T T C C C C C T T T
A A A G G A A G A A A
G G G G G G G G A G G
A A A C C C C C A A A
G A A G G G G G A G G
G G G A A A G G G A G
C C C C C C C C C T C
T T T T C T T T T T C
"Base pair numbers follow those published by Digby et al. (1992). The number of fish sequenced for this study is given for each mtDNA type. Mitochondrial haplotypes MYS1-14 are equivalent to haplotypes ST1-14 previously reported in Nielsen et al. (1994b). ST4, ST7, ST9, ST10, ST11, and ST14 were represented by less than five confirmed samples each and were, therefore, not included in these analyses.
s o u t h e r n extent of the range, i.e., s o u t h of Point Conc e p t i o n (MYS5, MYS6, MYS8, a n d MYS13), a n d one n o r t h e r n California h a p l o t y p e (MYS12) s h o w e d significant u n i t y w i t h b o o t s t r a p v a l u e s > 50%. A 68% bootstrap v a l u e s u p p o r t e d u n i t y b e t w e e n coastal s t e e l h e a d (MYS3) a n d r e s i d e n t t r o u t f r o m the S a c r a m e n t o River (MYS3), the Little K e r n River (MYS3), a n d t w o g o l d e n t r o u t h a p l o t y p e p o p u l a t i o n s (MYS3 a n d MYS15). Genetic u n i t y b e t w e e n the Eagle Lake t r o u t a n d Califor-
11 u n i q u e m t D N A h a p l o t y p e s f o u n d in this s t u d y is g i v e n b y g e n e r a l g e o g r a p h i c location in Fig. 2. A n u n r o o t e d n e i g h b o r - j o i n i n g tree for controlr e g i o n m t D N A s e q u e n c e data s u m m e d for h a p l o t y p e p o p u l a t i o n s is d e p i c t e d in Fig. 3. This tree d i v i d e d the t r o u t - s t e e l h e a d a s s e m b l a g e into four g r o u p s supp o r t e d w i t h b o o t s t r a p v a l u e s > 50%, w h e n c o n s i d e r e d in r e l a t i o n s h i p to the Rio Yaqui trout. Steelhead m t D N A h a p l o t y p e s f o u n d m o s t f r e q u e n t l y at the
1
-
mtDNA Control Region
0.9 0.8 9 North Coast
0.7 o~
[ ] North Interior
0.6
Nil South Coast
0.s
L~ South Interior
~" 0.4
[ ] Mexico Coast
0.3
I~ Mexico Interior
0.2 O'
o
,' i 1
: 2
'," 3
I ' = =
5
6
l
', 8
12
13
15
16
18
mtDNA haplotype
Frequency distribution of Oncorhynchus mykiss mtDNA haplotypes given for six general geographic locations. Haplotype numbers are given by streams and geographic areas in Appendix I.
FIGURE 2
5. mtDNA and Nuclear Microsatellites in Trout
59
Sacramento rainbow trout (3) Little Kern R. golden trout (3) Kern River rainbow trout (3) CA steelhead (3)
35 68
CA golden trout (3) CA golden trout (15)
17 Rio Santo Domingo trout (1)
17
CA steelhead (1)
541 I
99
McCloud rainbow trout (1) CA steelhead (2)
83
Eagle Lake trout (16) CA golden trout (16) CA steelhead (6)
84 1 34
57 51
70
I I
I
CA steelhead (5) CA steelhead (13) CA steelhead (8) CA steelhead (12) Rio Yaqui trout (18)
FIGURE 3 Unrooted phylogenetic tree for a 188-bp mtDNA control region segment inferred from neighbor-joining analysis (PHYLIP) of pairwise distances calculated for 11 mtDNA haplotypes found in anadromous steelhead and resident trout in California and Mexico (19901995). For these analyses, parenthetical mtDNA haplotype designations represented the most common haplotype found in each particular population. Bootstrap (1000 replicates) probability values are given in percentages on the tree branches; values >50% are indicated in bold type.
nia golden trout, which shared identical m t D N A haplotypes (MSY16), was supported by a bootstrap value of 83%. B. N u c l e a r M i c r o s a t e l l i t e s
The three microsatellite loci used in this study contained dimeric repeats [Omy207 and Ssa289 poly(CA)poly(GT), and Omy77 poly(CT)-poly(GA)], found in tracts up to 74 repeat units long, with 10-33 alleles expressed per locus (Appendix II). Frequency distributions for microsatellite alleles are given by locus and geographic area in Fig. 4. The combined allelic distribution for the three loci was found to be in H a r d y Weinberg equilibrium over the total sample population (Fisher's exact p = 0.013). The microsatellites developed specifically for O. mykiss, i.e., Omy77 (27 alleles; range 77-141 bp) and Omy207 (33 alleles; range
76-148 bp), were significantly more polymorphic in California and Mexican trout and steelhead than the Ssa289 locus developed for Atlantic salmon (10 alleles; range 89-109 bp). All three loci conformed to the expectation of a single-step allele model, with gaps in the two-base repeat sequence occurring only in the largest alleles for Omy77 and Omy207. Genetic distance measures for the three microsatellite loci combined as calculated by Slatkin (1995) and Goldstein et al. (1995) are given by the haplotype population in Table II. Derived distance measures showed similar m e a n values for both models across all populations. Slatkin's m e a n Rst value was 0.207, whereas the m e a n Fst of Goldstein et al. was 0.205. The r of Goldstein et al. (expected duration of linearity of distance for the three loci combined) equaled 299,058 + 14,732 generations. Neighbor-joining trees developed from microsatellite distance data using both methods were
1
-r-
Locus - Omy77
0.9
i
0.8
North Coast
~] North Interior
0.7
I
0.6
South Coast South Interior
= 0.5 O"
[ ] Mexico Coast
n m
[ ] Mexico Interior
0.4 0.3 i
0.2 0.1
-
i
77-85
87-95
=
97-107
109-117
121-131
L
135-148
allele size range (bp)
0.9
Locus - O m y 2 0 7
0.8 0.7 0.6
i i
North Coast
[ ] North Interior
0.5
I
South Coast South Interior
0.4
[ ] Mexico Coast
0.3
E~ Mexico Interior 0.2 0.1 0 76-84
86-94
96-104
ii[
106-114
116-124
126-134
136-148
allele size range (bp)
Locus-
0.9
Ssa289
_.=
0.8
__=
0.7
i
-=
0.6
_=
___=
= 0.5 O" L
-
0.4
i
North Coast
[]
North Interior
i
South Coast
[ ] South Interior
~iiiii
[ ] Mexico Coast
0.3
I~ Mexico Interior
0.2
i
--=
0.1
1 89
91
93
9 95
97
~n 101
103
105
m 107
109
allele size (bp)
FIGURE 4 Frequency distributions of Oncorhynchus mykiss alleles from Omy77 (A),
60
Omy207 (B), and Ssa289 (C) microsatellite loci given by geographic area (see Appendix I for sample locations). Frequencies have been pooled by size class (each bin includes five sequential alleles) to aid in graphic resolution.
TABLE H
Genetic Distance Measures for Three Microsatellite Loci (Omy77, Omy207, Ssa289) from California and Mexican Trout Populations a
Population (haplotype) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.
Rio Yaqui (18) CA steelhead (1) M c C l o u d (1) Rio Santo D o m i n g o (1) CA steelhead (2) CA g o l d e n (3) CA steelhead (3) Kern r a i n b o w (3) Little Kern River golden (3) Sacramento (3) CA steelhead (5) CA steelhead (6) CA steelhead (8) CA steelhead (12) CA steelhead (13) CA g o l d e n (15) CA golden (16) Eagle Lake (16)
1
2
3
m 23.10 41.05 94.92 25.96 32.10 35.46 22.46 56.43 7.28 44.09 11.68 42.67 28.43 55.70 13.39 10.00 11.53
0.40 m 4.93 109.53 0.25 15.32 7.79 45.41 64.87 36.89 8.51 3.64 10.00 1.22 34.91 12.20 11.70 31.80
0.42 0.04 ~ 91.92 3.19 11.36 2.96 47.06 53.29 50.56 3.24 9.03 3.61 3.21 21.37 14.44 16.64 37.19
4 0.90 0.59 0.59 ~ 106.21 73.58 69.52 35.31 6.08 79.73 84.11 81.47 73.11 108.65 29.47 60.25 68.54 45.57
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
0.33 0.03 0.04 0.59 ~ 12.67 6.67 44.46 62.38 37.98 7.52 3.89 8.75 0.48 32.46 11.51 11.45 31.85
0.63 0.22 0.09 0.71 0.07 -15.47 21.32 38.83 25.16 22.56 9.55 20.02 9.81 27.98 5.34 6.57 18.31
0.42 0.03 0.05 0.52 0.03 0.16 ~ 38.37 37.27 46.73 1.15 8.22 0.43 8.52 10.63 12.22 15.21 29.26
0.17 0.21 0.28 0.40 0.24 0.02 0.20 -15.21 9.56 52.65 23.75 46.01 44.15 32.80 10.79 11.83 1.98
0.59 0.40 0.34 0.34 0.34 0.41 0.26 0.02 m 46.23 49.41 43.24 41.12 64.09 13.24 28.12 34.02 20.42
0.30 0.27 0.29 0.60 0.21 0.32 0.28 0.04 0.36 ~ 60.04 18.94 56.06 37.59 59.33 12.16 9.29 5.48
0.44 0.05 0.05 0.57 0.04 0.17 0.00 0.27 0.31 0.33 ~ 12.77 0.40 9.87 15.12 20.01 23.17 41.30
0.00 0.10 0.14 0.63 0.10 0.14 0.14 0.18 0.26 0.11 0.13 ~ 12.11 4.80 26.95 3.01 2.63 13.94
0.43 0.03 0.05 0.50 0.05 0.20 0.00 0.23 0.27 0.30 0.02 0.20 ~ 10.95 10.75 17.24 20.78 36.31
0.11 0.07 0.01 0.59 0.03 0.31 0.00 0.23 0.22 0.05 0.00 0.00 0.06 -34.92 11.36 11.25 32.52
0.41 0.16 0.17 0.37 0.19 0.04 0.07 0.20 0.00 0.24 0.09 0.19 0.12 0.18 ~ 22.48 28.72 30.81
0.05 0.01 0.09 0.46 0.04 0.38 0.02 0.04 0.02 0.12 0.06 0.00 0.09 0.04 0.11 m 0.43 5.73
0.13 0.14 0.18 0.60 0.12 0.08 0.15 0.06 0.25 0.06 0.19 0.02 0.20 0.02 0.18 0.08 ~ 5.83
0.19 0.27 0.30 0.54 0.25 0.16 0.25 0.04 0.19 0.06 0.30 0.10 0.28 0.16 0.20 0.05 0.05
Distance measures (Rst) obtained according to the Slatkin (1995) m e t h o d using a stepwise m u t a t i o n process are given above the diagonal. Distance m e a s u r e s calculated according to Goldstein et al. (1995) using a one-step mutation model are given below the diagonal. a
62
JENNIFER L. NIELSEN et al. McCIoud r a i n b o w trout (1)
9
34 29
I
22 I
I
36
I
, C A steelhead (8) C A steelhead (5) C A steelhead ( 1 2) C A steelhead (