Lecture Notes in Physics Editorial Board R. Beig, Wien, Austria W. Beiglböck, Heidelberg, Germany W. Domcke, Garching, Germany B.-G. Englert, Singapore U. Frisch, Nice, France P. Hänggi, Augsburg, Germany G. Hasinger, Garching, Germany K. Hepp, Zürich, Switzerland W. Hillebrandt, Garching, Germany D. Imboden, Zürich, Switzerland R. L. Jaffe, Cambridge, MA, USA R. Lipowsky, Potsdam, Germany H. v. Löhneysen, Karlsruhe, Germany I. Ojima, Kyoto, Japan D. Sornette, Nice, France, and Zürich, Switzerland S. Theisen, Potsdam, Germany W. Weise, Garching, Germany J. Wess, München, Germany J. Zittartz, Köln, Germany
The Lecture Notes in Physics The series Lecture Notes in Physics (LNP), founded in 1969, reports new developments in physics research and teaching – quickly and informally, but with a high quality and the explicit aim to summarize and communicate current knowledge in an accessible way. Books published in this series are conceived as bridging material between advanced graduate textbooks and the forefront of research and to serve three purposes: • to be a compact and modern up-to-date source of reference on a well-defined topic • to serve as an accessible introduction to the field to postgraduate students and nonspecialist researchers from related areas • to be a source of advanced teaching material for specialized seminars, courses and schools Both monographs and multi-author volumes will be considered for publication. Edited volumes should, however, consist of a very limited number of contributions only. Proceedings will not be considered for LNP. Volumes published in LNP are disseminated both in print and in electronic formats, the electronic archive being available at springerlink.com. The series content is indexed, abstracted and referenced by many abstracting and information services, bibliographic networks, subscription agencies, library networks, and consortia. Proposals should be send to a member of the Editorial Board, or directly to the managing editor at Springer: Dr Christian Caron Springer Heidelberg Physics Editorial Department I Tiergartenstrasse 17 69121 Heidelberg / Germany
[email protected]
Nishina Memorial Foundation (Ed.)
Nishina Memorial Lectures Creators of Modern Physics
Editor Nishina Memorial Foundation 2-28-45 Honkomagome Bunkyo-Ku, Tokyo, Japan
[email protected]
Nishina Memorial Foundation (Ed.), Nishina Memorial Lectures, Lect. Notes Phys. 746 (Nishina Memorial Foundation, 2008), DOI 10.1007/ 978-4-431-77056-5
Library of Congress Control Number: 2007940477 ISSN 0075-8450 ISBN 978-4-431-77055-8 Nishina Memorial Foundation Japan This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springer.com c Nishina Memorial Foundation 2008 The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typesetting: by the authors and Integra using a Springer LATEX macro package Cover design: eStudio Calamar S.L., F. Steinen-Broo, Pau/Girona, Spain Printed on acid-free paper
SPIN: 12184644
543210
Yoshio Nishina (1890 – 1951)
Chronology of Yoshio Nishina December 6, 1890 July, 1918 August, 1920 April, 1921 1921 – 1922 1923 – 1928 1928 December, 1928 1937 1937 1940 1944 February, 1946 November, 1946 August, 1948 January 10, 1951 December, 1955
Born in Satosho, Okayama Prefecture, Japan Graduated from the Imperial University of Tokyo (Electrical Engineering Department) Entered the Institute of Physical and Chemical Research (RIKEN) in Tokyo Left Tokyo for Europe Research under E. Rutherford at the Cavendish Laboratory; attended lectures at G¨ottingen Universiy Research under Niels Bohr in Copenhagen Derivation of the Klein-Nishina formula Returned to RIKEN Discovery of a new particle Constructed a small cyclotron Discovery of 237 U and symmetric fission Costructed a large cyclotron Awarded the Order of Cultural Merit, Japan President of RIKEN Elected a member of the Japan Academy Died in Tokyo Nishina Memorial Foundation was established
Preface
Yoshio Nishina, referred to in Japan as the Father of Modern Physics, is well known for his theoretical work on the Klein–Nishina formula, which was done with Oskar Klein in the 6 years he spent in Copenhagen under Niels Bohr during the great era of the development of quantum physics. As described by Professor Ryogo Kubo in Chap. 2 of this volume, Nishina returned to Tokyo in 1929, and started to build up experimental and theoretical groups at RIKEN. His achievements there were many and great: (1) Encouraging Hideki Yukawa and Sin-itiro Tomonaga to tackle a new frontier of physics, leading eventually to their making breakthroughs in fundamental theoretical physics that won them Nobel prizes; (2) the discovery of “mesotrons” (the name for Yukawa particles at that time, now called muons) in 1937, which was published in Phys. Rev., parallel to two American groups; (3) construction of small and large cyclotrons and subsequent discoveries of an important radioisotope 237 U and of symmetric fission phenomena by fast neutron irradiation of uranium (1939 – 40), published in Phys. Rev. and Nature; and (4) creation of a new style of research institute, open to external reseachers, an idea inherited from Copenhagen. During World-War-II his laboratory was severely damaged, and also his cyclotrons were destroyed and thrown into Tokyo Bay right after the end of the war. Nishina devoted all his strength to re-establishing his scientific activities from scratch, but passed away in 1951 with many unfinished attempts left behind. We can say that what Japan is now owes a great deal to Nishina’s major contributions to science and the scientific community. Shortly after his death, in 1955, the Nishina Memorial Foundation (NMF) was established to commemorate the great contributions of Yoshio Nishina and to stimulate scientific development in the field of modern quantum physics. This was made possible by all the efforts of his successors, collaborators, friends, and influential people even outside science, who respected and loved Yoshio Nishina. These included Nishina’s best friend, Ernest O. Lawrence, a Nobel Laureate in 1933, who wrote the following to Sin-itiro Tomonaga as early as 1952:
vii
viii
Preface Dear Dr. Tomonaga, I am glad to hear that you are establishing a research fund in memory of Dr. Nishina. He was truly a great man of science for not only did he himself make fundamental contributions to knowledge, but also he was an inspiring and generous leader whose beneficent influence was felt the world over. Therefore, the establishment of a fund for scientific research would constitute a particularly fitting memorial and I would count it a privilege and an honor to be associated with this worthy undertaking, Cordially yours, Ernest O. Lawrence
Fig. 1 Letter of E. O. Lawrence to Sin-itiro Tomonaga in 1952
Preface
ix
It is to be noted that a substantial amount of the initial funding was donated by 44 distinguished scientists from foreign countries, including E. Amaldi, P.W. Anderson, J. Bardeen, C. Bloch, N. Bloembergen, N. Bohr, R.M. Bozorth, A.H. Compton, F.C. Frank, H. Froehlich, M. Levy, R.E. Marshak, H.W. Massey, M.G. Mayer, N.F. Mott, R.S. Mulliken, L.E.F. Neel, L. Onsager, A. Pais, R.E. Peierls, I.I. Rabi, L.I. Schiff, F. Seitz, J.C. Slater, C.H. Townes, J.H. Van Vleck, I. Waller, G. Wentzel, J.A. Wheeler, and C.N. Yang. This list bears witness to the admiration felt throughout the world for Yoshio Nishina and the appreciation of his warm and noble character. Among the missions of the Nishina Memorial Foundation is (i) to award the Nishina Memorial Prize to promising young scientists. Already 154 scientists have received the prize. Many of them have gone on to win further prestigious prizes, both national and international, the most notable being the two Nobel Prizes awarded to Leo Esaki and Masatoshi Koshiba. The other missions are (ii) to send young scientists to foreign countries, (iii) to invite distinguished scientists from foreign countries, (iv) to give young scientists from developing countiries the chance to engage in research work in Japan, (v) to explore and record uncovered historical events and documents related to Nishina’s life and work, and, last but not least, (vi) to deliver a series of public lectures. Sin-itiro Tomonaga, the second president of the Foundation, emphasized this last aspect, and promoted a series of public lectures, the Nishina Memorial Lectures (NML), by inviting distinguished scientists from abroad as well as from Japan. During the first 50 years the number of the NML has exceeded 100 and about 30% of them were delivered by foreign guests. A list of NML is given in the appendix. Many of the NML have been documented, albeit irregularly, in individual booklets, but these are not easily accessible to the public. Thus, on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the Foundation, we decided to publish the collected lecture documents which have been accumulated over the past five decades. The entire documentation of the NML in Japanese has recently been published by Springer Japan in three volumes, bearing the subtitle of ’Creation of Contemporary Physics’. The present volume, part of the Springer Lecture Notes in Physics, reproduces the documented lectures given in English in their original print versions. I would like to thank Prof. Masatoshi Namiki for the valuable editorial work. We hope that this volume will help young readers to grasp and enjoy the progress of modern physics, as described in these first-hand records of lectures given by its creators.
September 2007
Toshimitsu Yamazaki President of the Nishina Memorial Foundation
x
Preface
Fig. 2 Photograph of a Wilson chamber track of a new cosmic-ray particle with a mass of 1/7 to 1/10 of the proton mass, reported by Nishina, Takeuchi and Ichimiya in Phys. Rev. 52 (1937) 1198, taken from Kagaku 7 (1937) 408
Fig. 3 Papers on experiments using fast neutrons, reporting the discovery of symmetric fission of uranium, Nature 146 (1940) 24, and the discovery of 237 U, Phys. Rev. 57 (1940) 1182
Preface
xi
Fig. 4 A happy reunion of Yoshio Nishina with his friend, Isidol Rabi (a Nobel Laureate in 1944)
Contents
Chronology of Yoshio Nishina . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vi Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii Toshimitsu Yamazaki 1
Abstraction in Modern Science . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Werner Karl Heisenberg
2
Yoshio Nishina, the Pioneer of Modern Physics in Japan . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 Ryogo Kubo
3
Tomonaga Sin-Itiro : A Memorial – Two Shakers of Physics . . . . . . . . . 27 Julian Schwinger
4
The Discovery of the Parity Violation in Weak Interactions and Its Recent Developments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43 Chien-Shiung Wu
5
Origins of Life . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71 Freeman J. Dyson
6
The Computing Machines in the Future . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 Richard P. Feynman
7
Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics . . . . 115 Ben R. Mottelson
8
From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137 Kai Siegbahn
9
Theoretical Paradigms for the Sciences of Complexity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 229 Philip W. Anderson
1
xiii
xiv
Contents
10 Some Ideas on the Aesthetics of Science . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 235 Philip W. Anderson 11 Particle Physics and Cosmology: New Aspects of an Old Relationship . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 245 Leon Van Hove 12 The Experimental Discovery of CP Violation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 261 James W. Cronin 13 The Nanometer Age: Challenge and Change . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 281 Heinrich Rohrer 14 From Rice to Snow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 297 Pierre-Gilles de Gennes 15 SCIENCE — A Round Peg in a Square World . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 319 Harold Kroto 16 Are We Really Made of Quarks? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 349 Jerome I. Friedman 17 Very Elementary Particle Physics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 371 Martinus J.G. Veltman 18 The Klein-Nishina Formula & Quantum Electrodynamics . . . . . . . . . . 393 Chen Ning Yang A
List of Nishina Memorial Lectures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 399
1
Abstraction in Modern Science Werner Karl Heisenberg
Abstract This lecture was presented by Werner Karl Heisenbergr as the Nishina Memorial Lecture at Asahi Lecture Hall (Tokyo) on April 26, 1967.
May I – before I start my lecture – express my deep gratitude for the invitation to this country, to those who have made this invitation possible, for the greatest hospitality which my wife and I enjoy in this beautiful country. And also I would like to thank Professor Tomonaga for his very kind words and to Dr. Yanase for all the labor he has taken to translate this lecture.
Development of Natural Sciences and Tendency toward Abstraction
Werner Karl Heisenberg c NMF
So the lecture will be on abstraction in modern science. When the present state of natural sciences is compared with that of an earlier period, it is often asserted that the sciences have become more and more abstract in the course of their development and that they have reached at present in many areas a downright strange character of abstractness, which is only partially compensated as a huge practical success which the physical sciences have exhibited in their technological applications. I do not wish to enter here into the value question, which is often raised at this point. We shall not discuss, therefore, whether the physical sciences of an earlier period Werner Karl Heisenberg (1901 – 1976). Nobel Laureate in Physics (1932) W. K. Heisenberg: Abstraction in Modern Science, Lect. Notes Phys. 746, 1–15 (2008) c Nishina Memorial Foundation 2008 DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-77056-5 1
2
Werner Karl Heisenberg
were more gratifying in the sense that they through their devoted thoroughness to the details of the natural phenomena had given a living picture of the relationships which we find in nature, or whether on the contrary the enormous expansion of the technical possibilities which is based upon modern research has irrefutably proven the superiority of our present conception of the natural sciences. This question of value will for now be completely bypassed. Instead, the attempt will be made to examine more closely the process of abstraction in the development of sciences. We shall examine insofar as this is possible in such a short lecture what really happens when the sciences obviously following and in a necessity rise from one level of abstraction to the next higher one for the sake of what goals of knowledge does this laborious ascent generally proceed? In so doing, it will become apparent that very similar processes are going through in the different branches of the scientific field, which through their very comparison become more comprehensible. When, for instance, a biologist traces specks of metabolism and propagation of living organisms to chemical reactions; when the chemist replaces the detailed description of the properties of a substance with a more or less complicated chemical formula; finally, when the physicist expresses the laws of physical nature in mathematical equations, there is always effected here a development whose basic type is perhaps most clearly recognizable in the development of mathematics, and whose necessity must be investigated.
Case of Mathematics We can begin with the question what is abstraction and what role does it play in conceptional thinking. The answer could be formulated perhaps so. Abstraction denotes the possibility of considering one object or a group of objects from just one viewpoint while disregarding all other properties of the object. The isolating of one characteristic, which in a particular relationship is looked upon as especially important in contrast to all other properties, that constitutes an essence of abstraction. As it is easily comprehended, all concept formation is based upon this process of abstraction. For the formation of a concept piece of process that one can recognize similarity, homogeneity. But since total equality practically never occurs in the phenomenal world, the homogeneity arises out of similarity only through the process of abstraction, so the isolating of one characteristic while omitting all others. In order to form, let us say, the concept tree, one must perceive that there are certain common characteristic about birch trees and fir trees, which one through abstraction can isolate and thereby grasp. The filtering out of common features can under circumstances be an act of knowledge of a greater significance. It must have been recognized very early in the history of mankind that there is for example inter-comparison of let us say three cows and three apples, the common feature, which is expressed by the word ”three.” The formation of the concept of number is already a decisive step from the sphere of the immediately given sensible word into the framework of rationally graspable thought
1 Abstraction in Modern Science
3
structures. The sentence that two nuts and two nuts yield together four nuts remains also correct when one replaces the word nut with bread or with reference to any other object. We could therefore generalize this and close it in the abstract form two and two make four. That was the most important discovery. The peculiar ordering power of this concept of number was probably recognized already very early and contributed to the fact that the individual numbers then were taken or interpreted to be important symbols. From the standpoint of present day mathematics, the individual number is however less important to be sure than the basic operation of counting. It is the latter operation, which enables the procession, depositing of the series of natural numbers and produces implicitly with it all the effects, which are studied for instance in the mathematical theory of numbers. With counting, a decisive step is obviously taken in abstraction through which the entrance way opened into mathematics and into the mathematically formulated physical sciences. At this point we can now already study one phenomenon with which we shall meet time and again in the various levels of abstraction in mathematics or in the modern sciences and which for the development of abstract thinking and science can be referred to almost as a kind of fundamental phenomenon. This is a term used by the German poet and scientist Goethe, although Goethe would not have used this expression, Urph¨anomen or fundamental phenomenon, in this special connection. One can define it perhaps as the unfolding of the abstract structures. The notions, which are first formed through abstraction from individual effects or from manifold experiences, gain their own independent existence. They show themselves to be much richer and much more fruitful than they look when they were first considered. They manifested their lethal development and independent power of ordering insofar as they give rise to the formation of new forms and notions, negate the comprehension of the relation to one another, and somehow they prove themselves successful in their attempt to understand the world of phenomena. From the notion of counting and its related simple arithmetic operations was developed later for example, partly in ancient and partly in modern times, a complicated arithmetic and theory of numbers, which really only uncovered that, which was presented from the very beginning in the number concept. Further number and the theory of number relations, which developed from it, offered the possibility of comparing lines by measuring. From here, a scientific geometry could be developed, which already extends conceptually beyond number theory. In the attempt to establish geometry or number theory this way, the Pythagoreans, early Greek philosophers, ran up against the difficulties of the irrational ratios between the lengths of lines and they were forced to enlarge their class of numbers. They had to invent so to speak the notion of irrational number. Preceding a step further from here, the Greek mathematicians arrived at the notion of the continuum and the well known paradoxes, which Xeno, the philosopher studied. But on this point, we shall not enter into these difficulties in the development of mathematics but only point out the abundance of forms, which implicitly already contained the notion of number and which can be as I said unfolded from it.
4
Werner Karl Heisenberg
The following then can be said to resolve the process of abstraction. The notion, which has formed the process gains its own existence and enables an unexpected abundance of forms or all the structures to be derived from it, which forms can later prove their value in some way or other in understanding the phenomena surrounding us.
Mathematical Truth is Valid on Other Planets It is well known from this basic phenomenon that heated discussion arose as to what the object of mathematics really is. The mathematics is concerned with genuine knowledge that can hardly be doubted, but knowledge of what? In mathematics, are we describing something objectively real, which exists in some sense independently for us or is mathematics only a capacity of human thinking? Are the laws, which we derive in mathematics only statements concerning the structure of human thinking? I do not really wish here to unravel this difficult problematic but only to make one remark, which underlines the objective character of mathematics. It is not improbable that there is there also something similar to life on other planets. Let us say in Mars but in any case in other solar systems probably. And the possibility must be reckoned with throughout that there are on some other heavenly body living beings in whom the ability for abstract thinking is so far developed that they have found the concept of number. If this is so and if these living beings have followed up their concept of number with a scientific mathematics, they would arrive at exactly the same statements on number theory as we human beings have. Arithmetic and number theory could not appear basically any different to them as it does to us and their results would have to agree with ours. If mathematics is to hold true statements about human thinking, then it would hold true in any case not only for human thinking but for thinking as such. No matter how many types thinking beings there are, mathematics must be the same in all cases. This statement could be compared with other scientific statements. No doubt exactly the same laws of nature hold true on other planets or on other heavenly bodies lying still much farther distance as we find here on the earth. This is now not only a theoretical supposition, rather we can look through our telescopes and observe that there are the same chemical elements on the stars as here on the earth and that they enter into the same chemical compounds and emit light from the same spectral bands. But whether this scientific statement, which is based on observation, has anything to do with the statements made earlier about mathematics and further what it has to do with it shall not be investigated at this point. Let us for a moment turn back to mathematics before we look at the development of the physical sciences. In the course of its history, mathematics has again and again formed new and more comprehensive notions and has thus risen to continually higher levels of abstraction. The class of numbers was extended through to the irrational numbers and to the complex numbers. The concept of function gave access to the realms of higher analysis and differential and integral calculus. The no-
1 Abstraction in Modern Science
5
tion of group proved itself equally applicable in algebra, geometry, in the theory of functions, and suggested the idea that it should be possible on the higher level of abstraction and to comprehend entire mathematics with its many different disciplines and the one unifying point of view. Group theory was developed as such an abstract foundation of entire mathematics. The difficulties encountered in group theory finally necessitated the step from mathematics to mathematical logic, which was affected in 20s, especially by David Hilbert and his associates in G¨ottingen. Each time, the step from one level of abstraction to the next higher one had to be taken because problems could not be solved and not really be understood in the narrow sphere in which they first were posed. The connection with other problems in wider fields first provided the possibility for new mode of understanding and provided the inducement for concept formation or further more comprehensive concepts. For instance when it was realized that the action of parallels in Euclidean geometry could not be demonstrated, the nonEuclidean geometry was developed but the true understanding was first reached when much more general question was posed – within a particular action system, can it be proven that there are no inherent contradictions involved? When the question was so posed, then the core of the problem had been reached. At the end of this development, mathematics exist at present in such a form that its foundation can only be discussed in exceptionally abstract terms whose relation to anything in our experience seems to have totally disappeared. The following statement is said to have been expressed by the mathematician and philosopher Bertrand Russell. “Mathematics is concerned with objects about which nothing is known as to what they are and it consists of statements about which it is not known whether they are true or false”. As a commenter into the second part of this statement, it is known namely only that they are formally correct but not whether they are object in reality to which they can be related. But the history of mathematics should serve you only as an example in which the necessity and the development to abstraction and to unification can be recognized.
In Physical Sciences? - Development of Biology The question shall now be raised whether something similar took place in the physical sciences. In so doing I wish to begin with a science, which according to object is closest to life and therefore perhaps least abstract, namely biology. In its former classification into zoology and botany, it was to a large extent a description of many forms of life, which we meet here on our earth. The science compared these forms with an aim of bringing some sort of order into that first almost incalculable multiplicity of living phenomena and seeking further consistency of natural law in the field of living beings. In so doing the question arose of itself according to what aspects could the various living beings be compared? What, therefore, let’s say, were the common characteristics, which could serve as a basis of comparison? Already the investigations of the German poet and scientist, Goethe, into the metamorphosis
6
Werner Karl Heisenberg
of plants were for example already directed towards such a goal. At this point, the first step towards abstraction had to follow. Individual living beings were no longer primarily investigated but rather the biological functions as such, such as growth, metabolism, propagation, breathing, circulation, and so on, which characterized life. These functions provided the points of view according to which very different living beings could be well compared. They prove themselves like the mathematical concepts of which I spoke as unexpectedly fruitful. They developed to a certain extent their own power of ordering very broad areas of biology. Thus they arose out of the study of the processes of heredity, the Darwinian Theory of Evolution, which for the first time promised to explain the abundance of various forms of organic life on earth within one extensive unified viewpoint. The research into breathing and metabolism on the other hand led off itself to the question of the chemical processes in living organisms. It gave rise to the comparison of these processes with the chemical processes, which takes place in the laboratory and with this the bridge was laid between biology and chemistry. At the same time, the question was raised whether the chemical process in living organism and those in inanimate meta proceed according to the same natural laws. Thus by itself the question shifted from the biological functions to the further question as to how these biological functions where materialized in nature. As long as the sites were kept on the biological functions themselves, the point of view still fits entirely into the intellectual world of say the poet Goethe and his friend and philosopher Carlos who referred to the close connection between the biological functions of organs and to unconscious cyclical processes. But with the question of material actualization of the functions, the sphere of biology in its proper sense was forced out for it now became evident that one could only then really understand the biological processes when one also had scientifically analyzed and explained the corresponding chemical and physical processes. On this next level of abstraction then, all biological relationships are at first disregarded and the only question is what physical and chemical processes as correlates to biological process actually take place in the organism. Proceeding along this line, we have arrived at present at the knowledge of very general relationships, which appear to define all living processes on earth as an essential unity and which can be most easily expressed in terms of atomic physics. As a special example, we can name the hereditary factors whose continuity from organism to organism is regulated by the well known Mendel laws. These hereditary factors are apparently given materially through the arrangement of a larger quantity of four characteristic molecule fragments in the two chains of chain molecule, which is called deoxyribonucleic acid and which plays a decisive role in the foundation of cell nucleus. The extension of biology into chemistry and atomic physics allows therefore the unified interpretation of basic biological phenomena for the entire realm of living objects on earth. Whether existing life on say other planets would be based on the same atomic and chemical structures cannot be decided at the moment but it is possible that we will know the answer to this question in a not too distant future.
1 Abstraction in Modern Science
7
In the Domain of Chemistry A development similar to that in biology then took place in chemistry and I wish to select from the history of chemistry only one episode, which is characteristic of the phenomenon abstraction and unification, namely, the development of concept of valency. Chemistry has to do with the properties of substances and investigates a question how substances with certain given properties can be transformed into those with other properties. How substances can be combined, separated, altered? When one began to quantitatively analyze the compounds of substances and to ask how much of the different chemical elements is present in the compound in question, then integer number ratios were discovered. Now the atomic representation had already been previously employed as a suitable illustration by which the compound of elements could be considered. In so doing, one proceeded always from the following known comparison or picture. If one mixes, let us say white sand and red sand, the resulting sand whose red color is lighter or darker depending on the ratio of the mixture. The chemical compound of two elements was also thus envisaged. Instead of the grains of the sand, one thought of atoms. Since the chemical compound is more varied in its properties from the elements of which it is formed that the sand mixture from both types of sand, the picture had to be improved. Assuming that the different atoms first arrange themselves together into atomic groups, which then as molecules applied basic units of the compound. The integer number ratios of the basic matter could then be interpreted and could be the reason for the rational ratios of the number of atoms in the molecule. The experiments of various kinds supported such intuitive interpretation and allowed more of a further assigning of the so-called valence number to the individual atom, which symbolizes the possibility of combining it with other atoms. In so doing, it remained that at any rate, and this is point with which we are concerned here, completely unclear at first whether one should visualize the valency as a directional force or as a geometric quality of the atom or as something else. Whether the atoms are themselves real material structure or only helpful geometrical pictures suitable for the mathematical representation of their chemical event? That had to remain undecided for a rather long time. A mathematical representation is here understood that assembles in the rules for combination. Therefore here for example, the valency and rules for valency are isomorphic with the phenomena in the same sense in which, let us say, if it were expressed in the mathematical language of group theory, the linear transformations of a vector are isomorphic to the rotation in three-dimensional space. Returning now to practical problems and omitting the language of mathematics, this means the following. One can use the valence representation in order to predict, which chemical compounds are possible between the elements in question but whether the valency is more of something real in the same sense in which say a force or geometrical form can be said to be real, this question could remain unanswered for a long time. Its decision was for chemistry not especially important. While the attention was focused on the complicated process of the chemical reaction and especially on the quantitative mixture ratio and all other aspect were disregarded, that’s
8
Werner Karl Heisenberg
to say through the process of abstraction, the notion was gained, which allowed for the unified interpretation and partial comprehension of the various chemical reactions. It was only much later in modern atomic physics, namely that it was first learned what type of reality stands behind the valency concept. Indeed we cannot even now correctly say whether valency is really a force or an electronic orbit or a change in the electric charge density of an atom or only the possibility of something of such kind. But today’s physics that means after Bohr’s theory of atom and after quantum mechanics, this uncertainty is no longer related to the thing itself but only to its formulation in language whose imperfection we cannot basically improve or remove. It is only a short way from the valency concept to the formal abstract language of today’s chemistry, which enables a chemist to understand the contents and results of his work in all areas of his science.
History of Physics The stream of information, which the observing biologist or chemist gather, flows therefore through the gradient of questions aiming at unified comprehension and thereby leading to abstract contents finally of itself into the broad field of atomic physics. It appears accordingly as though atomic physics with central procession must already be comprehensive enough in order to supply the basic structure for all natural phenomena, a structure to which all phenomena can be related and according to which all phenomena can be ordered. But even in the case of physics, which appears here as a common basis for biology and chemistry, this is in no way self evident since there are so many different physical phenomena whose interrelationship is at first unrecognizable. Therefore the development of physics is also still to be dealt with and we want indeed to cast the glance first at its earliest beginnings. At the beginning of the ancient Greek science, there existed as it’s well known, the theory of Pythagoreans that as we know from Aristotle things are numbers. Now if one tries to interpret in a modern sense the description of this Pythagorean theory according to Aristotle, the meaning is probably the following that the phenomena can be so ordered and understood as they are related through mathematical forms and only so they can be ordered. But this relationship is not thought of as an arbitrary act of our known faculty of our mind but rather as something objective. It is said for instance that the numbers are the substantial essence of things or the entire heavens is harmony and number. But this at first probably meant simply the order of the world. For the ancient philosophers, the world was a cosmos with ordered thing and not chaos. The understanding thus gained appears not yet all too abstract. For instance, the astronomical observations are interpreted according to the notion of orbit. The stars move in circles, the circle is the course of its high degree of symmetry and especially perfect figure, so orbital motion is therefore evident as such. For the more complicated mo-
1 Abstraction in Modern Science
9
tion of planets, however, several orbital motions, cycles, and epicycles had to be combined in order to represent the observations correctly, but this was complete enough for then attainable degree of exactitude. The sun and the moon’s eclipse could be a rather well predicted using Ptolemy astronomy. The modern period beginning with Newton’s physics opposed now this classical concept with a question, has not the motion of the moon about the earth something in common with the motion of a falling stone or with a motion of the stone that is thrown. The discovery that there is something common present here upon which one can concentrate while disregarding all other multiplying differences belongs to the most momentous events in the history of natural sciences. The common element was uncovered through the formation of the concept of force, which caused the variations in the quantity of motion of a body. Here especially that of gravity. Although this concept of falls originates from sensible experience, let’s say from the sensation of lifting a heavy weight, yet the notion is already defined abstractly in Newton’s axioms, mainly through the variation of the quantity of motion and without reference to the sensation. With the few simple notions like mass, velocity, quantity of motion, or as we now say momentum and force, a close system of axioms was formulated by Newton, which while disregarding all other properties of the bodies, was now sufficient to handle all the mechanical processes of motion. As it is well known, this axiomatic system, similar to the concept of number in the history of mathematics, proved itself exceptionally fruitful during the following period. For over 200 years mathematicians and physicist have derived new and interesting conclusions from Newtonian starting point, which we learnt in school in the simple form mass times acceleration is equal to force. The theory of planetary motion was begun by Newton himself and developed and refined by the later astronomy. The motion of the spinning top was studied and explained. Fluid mechanics, elastic bodies were developed. The analogy between mechanics and optics was worked out mathematically. All the time two aspects had to be especially emphasized in this process. First, when one asks only about the pragmatic side of science, let’s say when one compares Newtonian mechanics and its performance of astronomical predictions with that of classical astronomy, then what Newtonian physics in its beginnings in this case hardly be distinguished from classical astronomy. Basically the motion of the planets could be represented as exactly as is desirable through a superimposition of cycles and epicycles. The convincing power of Newtonian physics then did not primarily originate from its practical applicability, but it is rather based on its ability of synthesizing, its unifying explanation of very different phenomena on the power of systematizing, which proceeds from Newtonian starting point. From this basis new fields of mechanics, astronomy physics, were opened up in the following centuries, if there still was a need for significant scientific accomplishments of series of researchers; however, the result already rests even if it was not first recognizable on Newton starting point, exactly as a concept of number already contains implicitly the entire number theory. Also if beings are dealt with reason, other planets were to make the Newtonian basis the starting point for their own scientific considerations, they could obtain only the same answer to the same
10
Werner Karl Heisenberg
questions. In this respect the development of the Newtonian physics is an excellent example for that unfolding of abstract concepts, which had been discussed already at the beginning of this talk. First in the 19th century it appeared then nevertheless that the Newtonian starting point was not rich enough to produce the corresponding mathematical formulation of all observable phenomena. The electrical phenomena for example, which especially since the discoveries of Galvani, Volta, and Faraday held the main center of interest for the physicists, did not fit correctly into the picture of the concept of mechanics. Faraday therefore leaning on the theory of elastic bodies invented the notion of field of force whose time changes were investigated and explained independent of the motion of the bodies. From such a starting point, the Maxwell theory of electromagnetic phenomena later developed out of which came Einstein’s theory of relativity and finally his general field theory, which Einstein hoped could be developed into the foundation for the entire field of physics. We shall not enter into the details of this development. What is important here for our concentration is only the fact that even at the beginning of the present century, physics was, as a consequence of such development, still in no way uniform. The material bodies whose motion was studied in mechanics were acted upon by something distinctly different, namely the forces, which caused their motion and which as fields of force represented their own reality according to their own laws of nature. The different fields of force stood unrelated next to one another. To the electromagnetic forces and to those of gravity, which had already been known for a long time and to the chemical valency forces were added in recent decades the forces in the atomic nucleus and in the actions responsible for radioactive decay. As a result of this various coexisting intuitive descriptions and separate types of force, a question was posed, which science could not avoid. I did convince the nature ultimately is uniformly ordered, that all phenomena proceed finally from the same uniform laws of nature. Therefore it must be possible in the end to uncover the underlying structure common to all the different areas of physics.
Unification by the Concept of “Potential Reality” Modern atomic physics has approached this goal through the means of abstraction and through the formation of more comprehensive concepts. The seemingly contradictory description by waves and particles, which arose in the interpretation of atomic research, led first to the formation of the concept of possibility of a near potential reality as a nucleus of the theoretical interpretation. With this the antithesis was dissolved between the material particles of Newtonian physics on the one hand and the field of the force of Faraday-Maxwell physics. Both are possible forms of appearance of the same physical reality. The contrast between force and matter has lost its prime significance, although the very abstract notion of a mere potential reality proved itself as exceptionally fruitful. So the atomic interpretation of biological and chemical phenomena first became possible. But the search after connections
1 Abstraction in Modern Science
11
between the various types of field of forces arose in recent decades simply out of new experiment. To each type of field of force, there corresponds, in the sense of the aforementioned potential reality, a definite type of elementary particle. So light quantum or photon corresponds to the electromagnetic field, the electrons correspond to certain extent to valency force in chemistry. The mesons correspond to the nuclear force that has been first pointed out by Yukawa. In recent experiments with elementary particle, it became apparent that new such particles may be created in collision of very high speed elementary particles and it seems indeed that if there is availability of sufficient impact energy for the formation of the new particles, then elementary particles of every desired type can be generated. The different elementary particles are therefore so to say all made out of the same substance, and we call these substances as simply energy or matter, they can all be converted into one another. With this the fields of force can also be transformed into each other. The inner relationship is directly recognizable through experimentation. There stills remains for the physicist, a task of formulating the natural laws according to which the transformation of elementary particles takes place. These laws should represent or describe in a precise and therefore necessarily abstract mathematical language what can be seen in the experiments. The completion of this task should not be too difficult considering the growing amount of information, which experimental physics working with the greatest technical means furnishes us. Next to the concept of a potential reality related to space and time, the requirement of relativistic causality, namely that effect cannot be transmitted more quickly than the speed of light, this seems to play a special role. For the mathematical formulation, there is a left over finally a group theoretical structure, a totality of symmetry requirements, which can be represented through rather simple mathematical statements. Whether this structure is finally sufficient for the complete representation of experiment can again first become apparent through the process of unfolding, which has been repeatedly spoken off, but the details are not important for the considerations here. One can say the relation of the various fields of physics seems to be already explored through the experiments during the recent decades. Therefore we believe that the uniform physical structure of nature is already now recognizable in its contours. At this point the limits of arriving at an understanding of nature found in the very essence of abstraction itself must be referred to. If at first many important details are disregarded in favor of the one characteristic by which the ordering succeeds, then one limits oneself necessarily to the working out of a structure only a type of skeleton, which could first become a true representation through the addition of a great number of further details. The relationship between the phenomena and the basic structure is in general so intricate that it can hardly be followed everywhere in the details. Only in physics has the relation between the concepts with which we directly describe the phenomena and those which occur as the formulation of the natural laws really been worked out. In chemistry, this has only succeeded to a considerably more limited extent and biology is first beginning in a few places to understand how the notions, which originate from our immediate knowledge of life and which retain unrestrictedly their values can fit together with that basic struc-
12
Werner Karl Heisenberg
ture. Still in spite of this, the understanding gained through abstraction mediates to a certain extent a natural coordinate system through which the phenomena can be related and according to which they can be ordered. The understanding of the universe gained in this manner is related to the basically hoped for and continually striven after knowledge like say the recognizable plan of a landscape scene from a very high flying airplane is to the picture which one can gain by wandering and living in such a landscape.
Don’t be Afraid of the Limitlessness Let us now return to the question, which I posted at the beginning. The tendency towards abstraction in the science rests therefore ultimately on the necessity of continually questioning after uniform understanding. The German poet and scientist Goethe deplores this once in relation to his notion of Urph¨anomen – primary phenomenon, which he invented. He writes in his theory of color when that fundamental phenomenon is found still the problem would remain that it would not be recognized as such. That we would search for something further over and beyond it when we should here confess the limits of immediate experience. Goethe felt clearly that to step to abstraction could not be avoided if one continues to question. What he means to say with the words is beyond it that is precisely the next higher level of abstraction. Goethe wants to avoid it. We should acknowledge limits of experience and not try to pass beyond them because beyond these limits, immediate experience is impossible and the realm of constructive thinking detached from sensible experience begins. This realm remained almost strange and sinister for Goethe, most of all because the limitlessness of this realm probably frightened him. Only thinkers of an entirely different mentality than Goethe could be attracted to the limitless expanse, which is here conspicuous. It was for instance a German philosopher Nietzsche who stated that abstract is many a hardship, for me on a good day a feast and an ecstasy. But human being so reflective upon nature, do question further because they grasp the world as unity and they want to comprehend its uniform structure. They formed for this purpose, more and more comprehensive notions whose relationship with direct sensible experience is only difficult to recognize but the existence of such a relationship is the unconditional piece of precision that abstraction mediates at all the understanding of the world.
In Fine Arts and Religion After one has been able to survey this process in the area of today’s natural sciences over such a wide extent, one can add the conclusion of such a consideration only with difficulty-resisted temptation of casting a view on other areas of human thought
1 Abstraction in Modern Science
13
and life on art and religion and asking whether similar processes have taken place or still take place there. In field of fine arts for instance, a certain similarity is conspicuous between that which occurs in the case of the development of an art style from simple basic forms and that which was here named as unfolding of abstract structures. As in the sciences, one has the impression that with the basic forms, for example in Romanic architecture, the architecture of early medieval times in Europe, the semicircle and the square, the possibilities for shaping them into assuming for the richer forms of later period, they are already extensively co-determined. We see that the development of the style is concerned therefore more with unfolding than with newly creating. A very important common characteristic consist also in the fact that we cannot invent such basic forms but only discover them. The basic forms possess a genuine objectivity. In the physical sciences, they must represent reality. In art one has to express the spirit of life in the period in question. One can discover under favorable circumstances that there are forms which can perform this task but one cannot simply construct them. More difficult to judge is the occasionally expressed opinion that the abstractness of modern art has causes similar to those of the abstractness of modern science, that is somehow related to the latter contents. If the comparison on this point should be justified, it means that modern art has gained the possibility of representing and making visible further comprehensive relationships not expressible by earlier periods of art by renouncing the direct connection with sensible experience. Modern art, this would then be the statement, can reproduce the unity of the world better than classical arts. But whether this interpretation is correct or not, I am not able to decide. Often the development of modern art is also differently interpreted. The disintegration of old orders, for example of religious bonds, is reflected in our time but is dissolving of the traditional forms and art of which then only a few abstract elements remain. If the latter is the correct interpretation, then there exists no relationship with abstractness of modern science. For in the case of abstractness of science, actually new understanding is gained into more far reaching relationships. Perhaps here it is permissible to mention one more comparison from the field of history that abstractness arises out of the continuous questioning and out of striving for unity that can be clearly recognized from one of the most significant events in the history of the Christian religion. The notion of god in the Jewish religion represents the higher level of abstraction compared to the concept of the many different cases of nature whose operation in the world can be directly experienced. Only on this higher level of abstraction is the unity of divine activity recognizable. The struggle of the representatives of the Jewish religion against Christ was, if we may here follow Martin Buber, a struggle centered around the maintaining of the purity of abstraction around the assertion of the higher level already once gained. Contrary to this, Christ had to insist upon the requirement that abstraction may not detach itself from life. The human being must directly experience the activity of the god in the world even when there is no more intelligible representation of the god. The use of comparison that the main difficulty of all abstraction is here as characterized that is only too familiar to us also in the history of sciences. Every natural
14
Werner Karl Heisenberg
science would be worthless whose assertions could not be observationally verified in nature and every art would be worthless, which was no longer able to move to affect human being, no longer able to enlighten for them the meaning of existence. But it would not be reasonable at this point to allow our view to go too far distance, where we have only concerned ourselves towards making more understandable the development of abstraction in modern science. We have to limit ourselves then here to the statement that modern science integrates itself in a natural way into a very wide system of understandable connections, a system which arises with effect that man is continuously questioning and that this continual questioning is a form in which man responds to the world surrounding him in order to recognize its intrinsic relationships and to enable himself to live there.
Fig. 1.1 Professor and Mrs. Heisenberg on their visit to the Nishina Memorial Foundation (1967)
1 Abstraction in Modern Science
Fig. 1.2 Professor Heisenberg (center) and Professor Yanase (interpreter, left) on the stage
Fig. 1.3 An unusual long queue formed in front of Asahi Lecture Hall
15
2
Yoshio Nishina, the Pioneer of Modern Physics in Japan Ryogo Kubo
Abstract This address was presented by Ryogo Kubo as the Nishina Centennial Symposium at the Japan Medical Association(Tokyo), December 5, 1990.
We are gathered here today to celebrate the centennial anniversary of Dr. Yoshio Nishina [1]. He was born one hundred years ago in 1890 in a small village called Satosho near the city of Okayama as the eighth child of a respected family. His grandfather was the local governor of that area. There still remains the old house where he spent his childhood with his parents and family. The house is now restored and is open to the public as a museum to commemorate the great man of whom the village can rightly be proud. I visited the place and was very much impressed by his notebooks, R. Kubo handwritings, and drawings of his schooldays. All are very NMF c beautifully done proving that he was extremely bright and was regarded as a genius. After finishing the local elementary school and the middle school, he entered the sixth national high school at Okayama. The national high school at that time was completely different from high school of today. It was an elite school corresponding to junior college for students proceeding to imperial universities. Nishina must have enjoyed his youth there. He liked to study by himself but was also a sportsman. After this, Nishina went to Tokyo to have his undergraduate education in the Engineering School of the Tokyo Imperial University. He elected electrical engineering
Ryogo Kubo (1920 – 1995). Nishina Memorial Foundation (Japan) at the time of this address R. Kubo: Yoshio Nishina, the Pioneer of Modern Physics in Japan, Lect. Notes Phys. 746, 17–26 (2008) c Nishina Memorial Foundation 2008 DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-77056-5 2
18
Ryogo Kubo
as his major and graduated from the Electrical Engineering Department with honors receiving a silver watch from the Emperor. But Nishina did not want to work in industry as an electrical engineer. He wanted to do something more useful than just engineering and more attractive and worth devoting his unusual talent. He considered electrical engineering as more or less a finished discipline. He thought electrochemistry was more attractive. So he accepted an invitation from Professor Kujirai, who had just started his new laboratory at RIKEN, a newly established research institute for physics and chemistry. This institute was planned taking the Kaiserliche Institut of Germany as a model. So Nishina became a research fellow at RIKEN and concurrently he registered at the graduate school of physics of the the Tokyo Imperial University to study physics under the guidance of Professor Hantaro Nagaoka, who was concurrently a chief researcher at RIKEN holding a laboratory there. Professor Nagaoka was the most influential person in the scientific community of Japan at that time. After three years of studying physics, fortune smiled on him. In the spring of 1921 he was ordered by RIKEN to go to Europe to study physics. This must have been a great encouragement for him. New physics was just being born in Europe. Europe was boiling with expectation of new ideas and new discoveries. This lucky event matched his talent and ambition. Fate made him stay in Europe for seven years, which he himself probably did not originally plan. This transformed him into a first rate physicist, which would not have been really possible if he had remained in Japan. Nishina went first to Cambridge because Nagaoka introduced him to Rutherford. He stayed at the Cavendish Laboratory and performed some experiments on Compton scattering, which were not so successful but gave him valuable experience for his later studies. Nishina eagerly wished to work with Niels Bohr at Copenhagen and asked Bohr if this was possible. Bohr was kind enough to accept him at his Institute. So Nishina was able to move to Copenhagen in 1923. There Nishina started working on the X-ray spectroscopy of atoms under Hevesy’s guidance, and soon was able to publish his first scientific paper [2] on the X-ray absorption spectra in the L-series of the elements La(57) to Hf(72) with the co-authorship of Coster and Werner. He continued the X-ray work after both Hevesy and Coster left Copenhagen and became the leader of the X-ray spectroscopy group. Indeed, Nishina made significant contributions in this field [3]. This was from 1923 to 1926, just the period when new quantum mechanics was rapidly developing. Copenhagen was the center of the revolution. Niels Bohr was the leader at revolution surrounded by its stars. There was great excitement every day. How happy Nishina was to be at the very center of this great revolution and close to the great leader and brilliant young pioneers. This excitement is vividly seen in Nishina’s notes kept in the archives of the Nishina Memorial Foundation. However, Nishina had already stayed in Copenhagen for quite a long time. The grant from RIKEN was already discontinued. His expenses were supported by his relatives at home. Also, Bohr was kind enough to arrange a grant from the Danish Government which lasted for three years. It was about time for Nishina to return home. But he wanted to do something significant in theoretical physics which he could bring back to Japan after staying so many years at the center of theoretical
2 Yoshio Nishina, the Pioneer of Modern Physics in Japan
19
physics of the world. Indeed, Nishina had been interested in theoretical physics ever since the time he turned to physics. Before coming to Copenhagen, he attended in Goettingen the lectures by Born and Hilbert. Now he wished to study theory more seriously. So he went to Hamburg in February of 1928 to study under Pauli and there he worked out a theoretical paper in collaboration with Rabi [4]. Coming back to Copenhagen he decided to take up a new problem. He thus chose the theory of Compton scattering for which he had kept a great interest for many years. The new theory is based on the Dirac theory of relativistic quantum mechanics. The method of calculation had not been so well established at that time, so the calculation was by no means easy. He started working on this problem in cooperation with Oscar Klein from the spring of 1928, and was able to finish the work [5] in the summer. The Klein-Nishina formula thus obtained is really a gem of quantum mechanics to be remembered in history. I do not dwell on this topic any further, because Professor Ekspong will talk on this subject. So Nishina finally left Copenhagen in October, 1928, cherishing the happy memory of the time spent at Copenhagen with Niels Bohr and many physicists who were fated to carry on the further revolution of modern science. He returned home in December of that year after making visits to several places in the United States. Having returned to Japan, he joined Nagaoka’s group at RIKEN. He must have felt like Urashima Taro or like Rip Van Winkle after so many years of absence from his mother country. There tooOokouchi , science had been progressing, but the atmosphere of the society was not yet as mature as in advanced countries. He had to be patient to realize his ambitions. It took a few more years until he was promoted to a chief researcher in RIKEN and in 1931 he started to build his own laboratory.
Fig. 2.1 Nishina at Copenhagen, with his friends. 1925. From left to right : Nishina, Dennison (USA), Kuhn (Switzerland), Kronig (Holland), Ray (India)
20
Ryogo Kubo
It was very fortunate that in 1929 he was able to invite Heisenberg and Dirac who accepted the invitation to come to Japan on their way back to Europe from America. Their visit gave great excitement to Japanese physicists, particularly to the younger generation. Nishina made a great effort to arrange their visit, to help the audience to understand their lectures. All of this made Nishina’s presence more impressive among his Japanese colleagues. He was invited to the universities at Kyoto and Hokkaido to lecture on the new quantum mechanics. At Kyoto he met two young physics students, who regarded Nishina as their teacher and later became to play the role of his successor and to lead modern physics in Japan. They were Hideki Yukawa and Sin-itiro Tomonaga. In 1931, Nishina started his laboratory. As the subjects of his research program he chose (1) (2) (3) (4)
quantum mechanics, nuclear physics, studies of atoms and molecules by X-ray spectroscopy, use of spectroscopy for chemical analysis and its applications.
The list was revised the following year. The items (3) and (4) were replaced by (5) study of cosmic rays, (6) generation of high energy proton beams. This list shows what Nishina intended to develop in Japan, in order to bring its science from the state of an undeveloped country to that of advanced societies like Europe and America. It was fortunate for Nishina that he was able to build up his laboratory in a relatively short time. This was only possible because RIKEN at that time was a unique institution. It was very young, less than fifteen years old, and was an entirely new system independent of the government and existing universities. Originally it was planned to raise money for research from industry, which naturally turned out to be unsuccessful. Dr. M. Ookouchi, the third president of RIKEN was an eminent administrator. He created a number of companies to use the inventions made by RIKEN researchers. Many of these companies were very successful and brought a considerable amount of research money back into RIKEN laboratories. Dr. M. Ookouchi used to tell his researchers not to worry about money but only about their work. Therefore RIKEN had an extremely active atmosphere and it was called the paradise of researchers. It is said that Nishina’s spending was always much more than his budget. Universities at that time were extremely poor regarding research money. Thus we see Nishina’s projects progressed unusually fast with the strong support of RIKEN. Nishina was able to recruit brilliant young researchers so that his laboratory grew up very fast. The number of researchers at its maximum exceeded one hundred. A laboratory of this size was never possible in a university or in any other institute. Let us now survey briefly how Nishina actually proceeded to achieve his objectives. Apparently he greatly emphasized theoretical physics. Fortunately, he was
2 Yoshio Nishina, the Pioneer of Modern Physics in Japan
21
able to invite very able young researchers to his group. They were Sin-Ichiro Tomonaga, Shoichi Sakata, Minoru Kobayashi, Hidehiko Tamaki and others. Yukawa was not in this group for he joined the new science faculty of Osaka University, but he kept up good contact with Nishina’s group. Nishina himself was not able to do theoretical work as much as he probably wished, because his main efforts turned soon to experimental work. But in collaboration with Tomonaga and Sakata he studied pair creation probabilities by photons [6]. As Prof. Kobayashi recollects, Nishina guided the research work in much the same way as that in Copenhagen. Namely, discussions between researchers were regarded as most important. This style of work was new among the Japanese researchers at that time. Like Bohr, Nishina was able to encourage and train younger researchers. Tomonaga writes in one of his recollections, that he often became pessimistic about whether he was talented enough to do theoretical physics and it would be better to quit. But every time, Nishina warmly encouraged him to recover confidence in his ability. Yukawa also recalls Nishina being like his loving father. When Yukawa got the idea of the meson mediating the nuclear forces [7], Nishina was one of the few who immediately recognized its importance and gave the strongest support. Although the theoretical group of Nishina’s laboratory was not so big, it was the most active in Japan and was influential in developing the quantum theory in Japan. Nishina regarded cosmic ray research as the key subject to start new experimental physics. With a few members of the laboratory he was able to improve the counters and cloud chambers and set up observatories at various places like the top of Mt. Fuji, Shimizu Tunnel and so forth. Great excitement occurred with the finding [7] of a track in 1938 a little later than that made by Anderson, and Neddermeyer which was supposed to be the evidence of a Yukawa particle but later was proved to be another kind of new particle now called a muon. Nishina’s group conducted a considerable amount of work in cosmic ray physics and laid the foundation of a strong tradition of cosmic ray research in Japan [8]. However, the greatest effort of Nishina was related to starting up nuclear physics in Japan, and in particular to the construction of cyclotrons. From 1930, the frontier of physics had shifted to nuclear physics with the use of various kinds of accelerators. In 1935, RIKEN decided to start a nuclear physics program with the cooperation of Nishina and Nishikawa Laboratories. A small cyclotron with a 23 ton electromagnet was successfully constructed by the Nishina group in 1937 [9]. Using this, the researchers irradiated all kinds of elements by fast neutrons. This was important work in nuclear physics. Beside this, radio-biological studies were initiated in Nishina’s group by a team of biologists in cooperation with physicists and chemists [10]. This belongs to the earliest work of radio-biology. Thus, Nishina is regarded as one of the pioneers in this field. The small cyclotron was successful, but it did not satisfy Nishina’s ambition. He wanted to build a large cyclotron, about ten times as large as the small one. Through Dr. Sagane, the son of Prof. Nagaoka, a young member of the Nishina laboratory, Nishina learned that Lawrence at Berkeley was considering a project similar to his idea. So cooperation began between Nishina and Lawrence with a deep friendship between two physicists who had never seen each other before. By this cooperation,
22
Ryogo Kubo
Nishina was able to buy a big electromagnet from an American company, which was the same make as that used by Lawrence. Unfortunately, however, the construction thereafter met great difficulties. It took much longer than Nishina expected. The difficulties were even bigger, since Japan was in the war by this time. Nishina did not give up the project. After great effort, the beam finally came out of the big cyclotron in February 1944. Although it was behind Lawrence by more than three years, this cyclotron was the second biggest in the world when it started to operate, of which Nishina had a right to be proud. When he left home for Europe in 1923, there was no nuclear physics at all in Japan, which was far behind in modern physics. But now he was happy to have put his country in second place, behind the United States. However, the story of the large cyclotron was a tragedy, to which I shall come back later.
Fig. 2.2 Nishina standing in front of the ”large cyclotron”, 1943
In 1937, Niels Bohr visited Japan with his family in response to Nishina’s longstanding invitation, and gave great encouragement to Japanese scientists. It was almost the last days of the happy time, because Japan was becoming internationally isolated by her militaristic policies, finally rushing into the reckless war. During the wartime, Nishina’s group had to engage in the project to develop the nuclear bomb. The scale of the project was nothing compared to the Manhattan project and the
2 Yoshio Nishina, the Pioneer of Modern Physics in Japan
23
researchers concluded that it was impossible to produce a nuclear bomb within fifty years. Japan was already losing the war then, and finally there came the disasters of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Nishina was sent there to investigate if the bombs were really atomic. His report must have been a decisive factor in the political leaders’ final decision to surrender. When the war came to an end, there was almost nothing left of Nishina’s ten years’ work. His laboratory at RIKEN was bombed and the small cyclotron was burnt. The big cyclotron fortunately escaped the damage. A few months after the surrender, the American occupation army came into Nishina’s laboratory unexpectedly, broke the machine and sank it in the Tokyo Bay. Later the Secretary of War admitted that the destruction was a mistake by the War Department of the US Government. Even if it was an unfortunate accident, it still discouraged Nishina from resuming his scientific activities. However, this was just the beginning of the disaster.
Fig. 2.3 Professor N. Bohr and Mrs. Bohr, visiting Japan, 1937, at a garden party at Takamine’s home
The following year, in 1946, RIKEN itself was ordered by the Occupation Force to dissolve. The RIKEN family of companies supporting RIKEN, namely the RIKEN CONCERN was considered as something similar to zaibatu, undesirable for demilitarization of the Japanese economy. So RIKEN had to seek some way of living by itself. Since Nishina was the most distinguished among the remaining senior researchers, he had to take the full responsibility for reconstructing RIKEN from its fragments. Thus he had to give up science to become an administrator to earn money for the researchers, pay their salaries, and research money. In the postwar economy in complete social disorder, the task was difficult beyond our imagination.
24
Ryogo Kubo
After a great struggle and great efforts, he managed to create a company with the name of RIKEN Co. He managed to construct a production line of penicillin within RIKEN, which was fairly successful at supporting financially the research activities at RIKEN. He became the president of the RIKEN company. Thus he saved RIKEN from collapse. If there were no Nishina, RIKEN would not have survived. The great effort of Nishina to reconstruct RIKEN out of disaster was a part of his sacrifice to save his country . He felt very strongly his responsibility as the most influential leader in science. Building up of science and technology was the slogan of the Japanese to reconstruct the country from ashes. So he was obliged to extend his activities beyond RIKEN to the problems of the whole country. When the Science Council of Japan started in 1948, he was elected a member of the Council and then took up the responsibility of Vice-Presidency. In order to restore scientific international cooperation, he was sent by the Science Council to the General Assembly of ICSU which took place in Copenhagen in 1949. Reunion with Niels Bohr and his family was the greatest pleasure after such terrible years. The year of 1950 brought him happy news. Through the good will of American scientists, particularly Dr. Harry C. Kelly, who was a science adviser at the General Head Quarters of the Occupation Army doing his best to encourage Japanese scientists, the import of radioactive isotopes was made possible. Although the cyclotrons were lost by the war, Nishina now was able to start radio-isotope work, to encourage his fellow researchers to start working in many important fields of physics, chemistry, medicine and biology. Unfortunately, his health was already deteriorating through overwork. It was January 10th of 1951 when he closed his 60 years’ life of dedication to science and his beloved country. Dr. Nishina died too early. In the forty years after his death, Japan has changed greatly. If not to our own satisfaction, modern science and technology have made enormous progress in Japan. Even though the number of Nobel laureates is still too small among the Japanese, the basic level of its modern science is ranked highly with the most advanced countries. And Japan’s advanced technology in application to modern industries is very remarkable. What would Nishina say, if he was still alive and saw today’s Japan? Nishina lived a life in a transient era of history that was most drastic and dramatic. It was the time when quantum theory cast off the older skin of classical physics, and atomic physics shifted to nuclear physics. Older concepts were revolutionized by new concepts. When Nishina started studying physics, Japan was only a developing country in the far east, far apart from the center of western civilization and the center of science revolution. Although Japan’s physics was steadily progressing before Nishina’s homecoming, as is shown by some significant achievements by Japanese physicists in the 1920’s, for instance, in X-ray crystallography, atomic spectroscopy, and electron diffraction experiments, the geographic distance and still backward technological level were great barriers hindering its ability to catch up with physics in the advanced West. Nishina was the right person with the destiny to bridge the gap between the older Japan before 1920 and the modern Japan after 1930. His role could
2 Yoshio Nishina, the Pioneer of Modern Physics in Japan
25
be compared to that of Rabi and Oppenheimer in the United States. In fact, the growth of Japanese science and technology in the 1930’s was remarkable. Industries were growing. National universities were created. Higher education was leveling up. Nishina was destined to lead modern science in Japan. As he might have foreseen when he chose physics after studying electrical engineering, he was successful in his pursuit of his objectives. If it had not rushed into the reckless war, Japan would have been able to attain a reasonably advanced level of modern sciences by the 1950’s before Nishina’s untimely death. It is useless to talk about a historical if. But I only mentioned this to remember the great man with unusual talent who devoted his whole life to science and to his country. Thank you very much for your attention.
Fig. 2.4 Professor Ryogo Kubo giving an opening address at the Yoshio Nishina Centennial Symposium in Tokyo (1990)
References 1. Special Issue for the Centennial Anniversary of Yoshio Nishina Buturi (Physical Society of Japan) October 1990. 2. D.Coster, Y.Nishina and S.Werner : Z.Phys. 18 (1923) 207.
26
Ryogo Kubo
3. Y.Nishina : Phil. Mag. 49 (1925) 521. Y.Nishina and B.Ray : Nature 117 (1926) 120. S.Aoyama, K.Kimura and Y.Nishina : Z.Phys. 44 (1927) 810. 4. Y.Nishina and I.I.Rabi : Verhandl.Deutsch.Phys. Gesell. 3. Reihe 9. Jahrg (1928) 6. 5. O.Klein and Y.Nishina : Z.Phys. 52 (1929)853. 6. Y.Nishina and S.Tomonaga : Proc. Phys-Math.Soc. Japan Third Series 15 (1933) 248. Y.Nishina, S.Tomonaga and S.Sakata :Suppl.Sci.Pap. I.P.C.R. 17 (1934) 1. 7. H.Yukawa : Proc.Phys.-Math Soc. Japan 17 (1935) 48. 8. Y.Sekido, in Early History of Cosmic Ray Studies, ed. Y.Sekido and H.Elliot (D.Reidel Dordrecht 1985) p.187. 9. Y.Nishina, T.Yasaki, H.Ezoe, K.Kimura, and M.Ikawa : Nature 146 (1940) 24. Y.Nishina , T.Yasaki, K.Kimura and M.Ikawa : Phys.Rev. 58 (1940) 660 ; ibid 59 (1941) 323, 677 ; Z.Phys. 119 (1942) 195. 10. Y.Nishina and H.Nakayama : Sci.Pap. I.P.C.R. 34 (1938) 1635. Y.Nishina, Y.Sinoto and D.Sato : Cytologia, 10 (1940) 406, 458 ; ibid 11 (1941) 311.
3
Tomonaga Sin-Itiro : A Memorial – Two Shakers of Physics Julian Schwinger
Abstract This address was presented by Julian Schwinger as the Nishina Memorial Lecture at the Maison Franco-Japanese (Tokyo), on July 8, 1980.
Minasama: I am deeply honored to have the privilege of addressing you today. It is natural that I should do so, as the Nobel prize partner whose work on quantum electrodynamics was most akin in spirit to that of Tomonaga Sin-Itiro. But not until I began preparing this memorial did I become completely aware of how much our scientific lives had in common. I shall mention those aspects in due time. More immediately provocative is the curious similarity hidden in our names. The Japanese character —the kanji— shin (振) has, among other meanings those of ‘to wave’, ‘to shake’. The begin- Julian Schwinger ning of my Germanic name, Schwing, means ‘to swing’, ‘to NMF c shake’. Hence my title, “Two Shakers of Physics”. One cannot speak of Tomonaga without reference to Yukawa Hideki and, of course, Nishina Yoshio. It is a remarkable coincidence that both Japanese Nobel prize winners in physics were born in Tokyo, both had their families move to Kyoto, and also both were sons of professors at Kyoto Imperial University, both attended the Third High School in Kyoto, and both attended and graduated from Kyoto Imperial University with degrees in physics. In their third and final year at the university, both learned the new quantum mechanics together (Tomonaga would later remark, Julian Schwinger (1918 – 1994). Nobel Laureate in Physics (1965) University of California, Los Angeles (USA) at the time of this address J. Schwinger: Tomonaga Sin-Itiro : A Memorial – Two Shakers of Physics, Lect. Notes Phys. 746, 27–42 (2008) c Nishina Memorial Foundation 2008 DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-77056-5 3
28
Julian Schwinger
Fig. 3.1 Memorial lecture of Professor Julian Schwinger for Professor Sin-itiro Tomonaga (July 8, 1980, Tokyo)
3 Tomonaga Sin-Itiro : A Memorial – Two Shakers of Physics
29
about this independent study, that he was happy not to be bothered by the professors). Both graduated in 1929 into a world that seemed to have no place for them, (Yukawa later said “The depression made scholars”). Accordingly, both stayed on as unpaid assistants to Professor Tamaki Kajyuro; Yukawa would eventually succeed him. In 1931, to Nishina comes on stage. He gave a series of lectures at Kyoto Imperial University on quantum mechanics. Sakata Shoichi, then a student, later reported that Yukawa and Tomonaga asked the most questions afterward. Nishina was a graduate in electrical engineering of the Tokyo Imperial University. In 1917 he joined the recently founded Institute of Physical and Chemical Research, the Rikagaku Kenkyusho —– RIKEN. A private institution, RIKEN, was supported financially in various ways, including the holding of patents on the manufacture of sake. After several years at RIKEN, Nishina was sent abroad for further study, a pilgrimage that would last for eight years. He stopped at the Cavendish Laboratory in Cambridge, England, at the University of G¨ottingen in Germany, and then, finally, went to Denmark and Niels Bohr in Copenhagen. He would stay there for six years. And out of that period came the famous Klein-Nishina formula. Nishina returned to Japan in December, 1928, to begin building the Nishina Group. It would, among other contributions, establish Japan in the forefront of research on nuclear and cosmic ray physics —– soryushiron. There was a branch of RIKEN at Kyoto in 1931 when Nishina, the embodiment of the ‘Kopenhagener Geist’, came to lecture and to be impressed by Tomonaga. The acceptance of Nishina’s offer of research position brought Tomonaga to Tokyo in 1932. (Three years earlier he had traveled to Tokyo to hear lectures at RIKEN given by Heisenberg and Dirac.) The year 1932 was a traumatic one for physics. The neutron was discovered; the positron was discovered. The first collaborative efforts of Nishina and Tomonaga dealt with the neutron, the problem of nuclear forces. Although there were no formal publications, this work was reported at the 1932 autumn and 1933 spring meetings that were regularly held by the RIKEN staff. Then, in the 1933 autumn meeting the subject becomes the positron. It was the beginning of a joint research program that would see the publication of a number of papers concerned with various aspects of electron-positron pair creation and annihilation. Tomonaga’s contributions to quantum electrodynamics has begun. While these papers were visible evidence of interest in quantum electrodynamics, we are indebted to Tomonaga for telling us, in his Nobel address, of an unseen but more important step — he read the 1932 paper of Dirac that attempted to find a new basis for electrodynamics. Dirac argued that “the role of the field is to provide a means for making observations of a system of particles”, and therefore, “we cannot suppose the field to be a dynamical system on the same footing as the particles and thus something to be observed in the same way as the particles”. The attempt to demote the dynamical status of the electromagnetic field, or, in the more extreme later proposal of Wheeler and Feynman, to eliminate it entirely, is a false trail, contrary to the fundamental quantum duality between particle and wave, or field. Nevertheless, Dirac’s paper was to be very influential. Tomonaga says, “This paper of Dirac’s attracted my interest because of the novelty of its philosophy and the beauty of its form. Nishina also showed a great interest in this paper and suggested that I
30
Julian Schwinger investigate the possibility of predicting some new phenomena by this theory. Then I started computations to see whether the Klein-Nishina formula could be derived from this theory or whether any modification of the formula might result. I found out immediately. however, without performing the calculation through to the end, that it would yield the same answer as the previous theory. The new theory of Dirac’s was in fact mathematically equivalent to the older Heisenberg–Pauli theory and I realized during the calculation that one could pass from one to the other by a unitary transformation. The equivalence of these two theories was also discovered by Rosenfeld and Dirac–Fock–Podolsky and was soon published in their papers.”
I graduated from a high school that was named for Townsend Harris, the first American consul in Japan. Soon after, in 1934, I wrote but did not publish my first research paper. It was on quantum electrodynamics. Several years before, the Danish physicist Møller had proposed a relativistic interaction between two electrons, produced through the retarded intervention of the electromagnetic field. It had been known since 1927 that electrons could also be described by a field, one that had no classical, counterpart. And the dynamical description of this field was understood, when the electrons interacted instantaneously. I asked how things would be when the retarded interaction of Møller was introduced. To answer the question I used the Dirac–Fock–Podolsky formulation. But now, since I was dealing entirely with fields, it was natural to introduce for the electron field, as well, the analogue of the unitary transformation that Tomonaga had already recognized as being applied to the electromagnetic field in Dirac’s original version. Here was the first tentative use of what Tomonaga, in 1943, would correctly characterize as “a formal transformation which is almost self-evident” and I, years later, would call the interaction representation. No, neither of us, in the 1930’s, had reached what would eventually be named the Tomonaga–Schwinger equation. But each of us held a piece which, in combination, would lead to that equation: Tomonaga appreciated the relativistic form of the theory, but was thinking in particle language; I used a field theory, but had not understood the need for a fully relativistic form. Had we met then, would history have been different? The reports of the spring and autumn 1936 meetings of the RIKEN staff show something new — Tomonaga had resumed his interest in nuclear physics. In 1937 he went to Germany — to Heisenberg’s Institute at Leipzig. He would stay for two years, working on nuclear physics and on the theory of mesons, to use the modern term. Tomonaga had come with a project in mind: treat Bohr’s liquid drop model of the nucleus, and the way an impinging neutron heats it up, by using the macroscopic concepts of heat conduction and viscosity. This work was published in 1938. It was also the major part of the thesis submitted to Tokyo University in 1939 for the degree of Doctor of Science — Rigakuhakushi. Heisenberg’s interest in cosmic rays then turned Tomonaga’s attention to Yukawa’s meson. The not yet understood fact, that the meson of nuclear forces and the cosmic ray meson observed at sea level are not the same particle, was beginning to thoroughly confuse matters at this time. Tomonaga wondered whether the problem of the meson lifetime could be overcome by including an indirect process, in which the meson turns into a pair of nucleons — proton and neutron — that annihilate to produce the final electron and neutrino. The integral over all nucleon pairs, resulting
3 Tomonaga Sin-Itiro : A Memorial – Two Shakers of Physics
31
from the perturbation calculation, was — infinite. Tomonaga kept a diary of his impressions during this German period. It poignantly records his emotional reactions to the difficulties he encountered. Here are some excerpts: “It has been cold and drizzling since morning and I have devoted the whole day to physics in vain. As it got dark I went to the park. The sky was gray with a bit of the yellow of twilight in it. I could see the silhouetted white birch grove glowing vaguely in the dark. My view was partly obscured by my tired eyes: my nose prickled from the cold and upon returning home I had a nosebleed. After supper I took up my physics again, but at last I gave up. III-starred work indeed!”
Then, “Recently I have felt very sad without any reason, so I went to a film. Returning home I read a book on physics. I don’t understand it very well. Meanwhile I comprehensible?”
Again, “As I went on with the calculation, I found the integral diverged — was infinite. After lunch I went for a walk. The air was astringently cold and the pond in Johanna Park was half frozen, with ducks swimming where there was no ice. I could see a flock of other birds. The flower beds were covered with chestnut leaves against the frost. Walking in the park, I was no longer interested in the existence of neutron, neutrino.”
And finally, “I complained in emotional words to Professor Nishina about the slump in my work, whereupon I got his letter in reply this morning. After reading it my eyes were filled with tears. — He says: only fortune decides your progress in achievements. All of us stand on the dividing line from which the future is invisible. We need not be too anxious about the results, even though they may turn out quite different from what you expect. By-and-by you may meet a new chance for success.”
Toward the close of Tomonaga’s stay in Leipzig, Heisenberg suggested a possible physical answer to the clear inapplicability of perturbation methods in meson physics. It involved the self-reaction of the strong meson field surrounding a nucleon. Heisenberg did a classical calculation, showing that the scattering of mesons by nucleons might thereby be strongly reduced, which would be more in conformity with the experimental results. About this idea Tomonaga later remarked, “Heisenberg, in this paper published in 1939, emphasized that the field reaction would be crucial in meson-nucleon scattering. Just at that time I was studying at Leipzig, and I still remember vividly how Heisenberg enthusiastically explained this idea to me and handed me galley proofs of his forthcoming paper. Influenced by Heisenberg, I came to believe that the problem of field reactions far from being meaningless was one which required a “frontal attack”. Indeed, Tomonaga wanted to stay on for another year, to work on the quantum mechanical version of Heisenberg’s classical calculation. The growing clouds of war made this inadvisable, however, and Tomonaga returned to Japan by ship. As it happened, Yukawa who had come to Europe to attend a Solvay Congress, which unfortunately was cancelled, sailed on that very ship. When the ship docked at New York, Yukawa disembarked and, beginning at Columbia
32
Julian Schwinger
University, where I first met him, made his way across the United States, visiting various universities. But Tomonaga, after day’s sightseeing in New York that included the Japanese Pavilion at the World’s Fair, continued with the ship through the Panama Canal and on to Japan. About this Tomonaga said, “When I was in Germany I had wanted to stay another year in Europe, but once I was aboard a Japanese ship I became eager to arrive in Japan”. He also remarked about his one day excursion in New York that “I found that I was speaking German rather than English, even though I had not spoken fluent German when I was in Germany”. Tomonaga had returned to Japan with some ideas concerning the quantum treatment of Heisenberg’s proposal that attention to strong field reactions was decisive for understanding the meson-nucleon system. But soon after he began work he became aware, through an abstract of a paper published in 1939, that Wentzel was also attacking this problem of strong coupling. Here is where the scientific orbits of Tomonaga and myself again cross. At about the time that Tomonaga returned to Japan I went to California, to work with Oppenheimer. Our first collaboration was a quantum electrodynamic calculation of the electron-positron pair emitted by an excited oxygen nucleus. And then we turned to meson physics. Heisenberg had suggested that meson-nucleon scattering would be strongly suppressed by field reaction effects. There also existed another proposal to the same end — that the nucleon possessed excited states, isobars, which would produce almost cancelling contributions to the meson scattering process. We showed, classically, that the two explanations of suppressed scattering were one and the same: the effect of the strong field reaction, of the strong coupling, was to produce isobars, bound states of the meson about the nucleon. The problem of giving these ideas a correct quantum framework naturally arose. And then, we became aware, through the published paper, of Wentzel’s quantum considerations on a simple model of the strong coupling of meson and nucleon. I took on the quantum challenge myself. Not liking the way Wentzel had handled it, I redid his calculation in my own style, and, in the process, found that Wentzel had made a mistake. In the short note that Oppenheimer and I eventually published, this work of mine is referred to as “to be published soon”. And it was published, 29 years later, in a collection of essays dedicated to Wentzel. Recently, while surveying Tomonaga’s papers, I came upon his delayed publication of what he had done along the same lines. I then scribbled a note: “It is as though I were looking at my own long unpublished paper”. I believe that both Tomonaga and I gained from this episode added experience in using canonical-unitary-transformations to extract the physical consequences of a theory. I must not leave the year 1939 without mentioning a work that would loom large in Tomonaga’s later activities. But, to set the stage, I turn back to 1937. In this year, Block and Nordsieck considered another kind of strong coupling, that between an electric charge and arbitrarily soft — extremely low frequency — light quanta. They recognized that, in a collision, say between an electron and a nucleus, arbitrarily soft quanta will surely be emitted; a perfectly elastic collision cannot occur. Yet, if only soft photons, those of low energy, are considered, the whole scattering process goes on as though the electrodynamic interactions were ineffective. Once this was understood, it was clear that the real problem of electrodynamic field reaction begins
3 Tomonaga Sin-Itiro : A Memorial – Two Shakers of Physics
33
when arbitrarily hard — unlimited high energy — photons are reintroduced. In 1939 Dancoff performed such a relativistic scattering calculation both for electrons, which have spin 1/2, and for charged particles without spin. The spin 0 calculation gave a finite correction to the scattering, but, for spin 1/2, the correction was infinite. This was confusing. And to explain why that was so, we must talk about electromagnetic mass. Already in classical physics the electric field surrounding an electrically charged body carries energy and contributes mass to the system. That mass varies inversely as a characteristic dimension of the body, and therefore is infinite for a point charge. The magnetic field that accompanies a moving charge implies an additional momentum, and additional electromagnetic, mass. It is very hard, at this level to make those two masses coincide, as they must, in a relativistically invariant theory. The introduction of relativistic quantum mechanics, of quantum field theory, changes the situation completely. For the spin 1/2 electron-positron system, obeying Fermi–Dirac statistics, the electromagnetic mass, while still infinite, is only weakly logarithmically, so. In contrast, the electromagnetic mass for a spin 0 particle, which obeys Bose–Einstein statistics, is more singular than the classical one. Thus, Dancoff’s results were in contradiction to the expectation that spin 0 should exhibit more severe electromagnetic corrections. Tomonaga’s name had been absent from the RIKEN reports for the years from 1937 to 1939, when he was in Germany. It reappears for the 1940 spring meeting under the title “On the Absorption and Decay of Slow Mesons”. Here the simple and important point is made that, when cosmic ray mesons are stopped in matter, the repulsion of the nuclear Coulomb field prevents positive mesons from being absorbed by the nucleus, while negative mesons would preferentially be absorbed before decaying. This was published as a Physical Review Letter in 1940. Subsequent experiments showed that no such asymmetry existed: the cosmic ray meson does not interact significantly with nuclear particles. The RIKEN reports from autumn of 1940 to autumn of 1942 trace stages in the development of Tomonaga’s strong and intermediate coupling meson theories. In particular, under the heading “Field Reaction and Multiple Production” there is discussed a coupled set of equations corresponding to various particle numbers, which is the basis of an approximation scheme, now generally called the Tamm–Dancoff approximation. This series of reports on meson theory was presented to the Meson Symposium — Chukanshi Toronkai — that was initiated in September 1943, where also was heard the suggestion of Sakata’s group that the cosmic ray meson is not the meson responsible for nuclear forces. But meanwhile there occurred the last of the RIKEN meetings held during the war, that of spring 1943. Tomonaga provides the following abstract with the title “Relativistically Invariant Formulation of Quantum Field Theory”: “In the present formulation of quantum fields as a generalization of ordinary quantum mechanics such nonrelativistic concepts as probability amplitude, canonical commutation relation and Schr¨odinger equation are used. Namely these concepts are defined referring to a particular Lorentz frame in space-time. This unsatisfactory feature has been pointed out by many people and also Yukawa emphasized it recently. I make a relativistic generalization of these concepts in quantum mechanics such that they do not refer to any particular
34
Julian Schwinger coordinate frame and reformulate the quantum theory of fields in a relativistically invariant manner.”
In the previous year Yukawa had commented on the unsatisfactory nature of quantum field theory, pointing both to its lack of an explicit, manifestly covariant form and to the problem of divergences — infinities. He wished to solve both problems at the same time. To that end, he applied Dirac’s decade earlier suggestion of a generalized transformation function by proposing that the quantum field probability amplitude should refer to a closed surface in space-time. From the graphic presentation of such a surface as a circle, the proposal became known as the theory of maru. Tomonaga’s reaction was to take one problem at a time, and he first proceeded to “reformulate the quantum theory of fields in a relativistically invariant manner”. And in doing so he rejected Yukawa’s more radical proposal in favor of retaining the customary concept of causality — the relation between cause and effect. What was Tomonaga’s reformulation? The abstract I have cited was that of a paper published in the Bulletin of the Institute, RIKEN–Iho. But its contents did not become known outside of Japan until it was translated into English to appear in the second issue, that of August–September, 1946, of the new journal, Progress of Theoretical Physics. It would, however, be some time before this issue became generally available in the United States. Incidentally, in this 1946 paper Tomonaga gave his address as Physics Department, Tokyo Bunrika University. While retaining his connection with RIKEN, he had, in 1941, joined the faculty of this university which later, in 1949, became part of the Tokyo University of Education. Tomonaga begins his paper by pointing out that the standard commutation relations of quantum field theory, referring to two points of space at the same time, are not covariantly formulated: in a relatively moving frame of reference the two points will be assigned different times. This is equally true of the Schr¨odinger equation for time evolution, which uses a common time variable for different spatial points. He then remarks that there is no difficulty in exhibiting commutation relations for arbitrary space-time points when a non-interacting field is considered. The unitary transformation to which we have already referred, now applied to all the fields, provides them with the equations of motion of non-interacting fields, while, in the transformed Schr¨odinger equation, only the interaction terms remain. About this Tomonaga says, “... in our formulation, the theory is divided into two sections. One section gives the laws of behavior of the fields when they are left alone, and the other gives the laws determining the deviation from this behavior due to the interactions. This way of separating the theory can be carried out relativistically”. Certainly commutation relations referring to arbitrary space-time points are four-dimensional in character. But what about the transformed Schr¨odinger equation, which still retains its single time variable? It demands generalization. Tomonaga was confident that he had the answer for, as he put it later, “I was recalling Dirac’s many-time theory which had enchanted me ten years before”. In the theory of Dirac, and then of Dirac–Fock–Podolsky, each particle is assigned its own time variable. But, in a field theory, the role of the particles is played by the small volume elements of space. Therefore, assign to each spatial volume element an independent time coordinate. Thus, the “super many-time theory”. Let me be more
3 Tomonaga Sin-Itiro : A Memorial – Two Shakers of Physics
35
precise about that idea. At a common value of the time, distinct spatial volume elements constitute independent physical system, for no physical influence is instantaneous. But more than that, no physical influence can travel faster than the speed of light. Therefore any two space-time regions that cannot be connected, even by light signals, are physically independent; they are said to be in space-like relationship. A three-dimensional domain such that any pair of points is in space-like relationship constitutes a space-like surface in the four-dimensional world. All of space at a common time is but a particular coordinate description of a plane space-like surface. Therefore the Schr¨odinger equation, in which time advances by a common amount everywhere in space, should be regarded as describing the normal displacement of plane space-like surface. Its immediate generalization is to the change from one arbitrary space-like surface to an infinitesimally neighboring one, which change can be localized in the neighborhood of a given space-time point. Such is the nature of the generalized Schr¨odinger equation that Tomonaga constructed in 1943, and to which I came toward the end of 1947. By this time the dislocation produced by the war became dominant. Much later Tomonaga recalled that “I myself temporarily stopped working on particle physics after 1943 and was involved in electronics research. Nevertheless the research on magnetrons and on ultra-short wave circuits was basically a continuation of quantum mechanics”. Miyazima Tatsuoki remembers that “One day our boss Dr. Nishina took me to see several engineers at the Naval Technical Research Institute. They had been engaged in the research and development of powerful split anode magnetrons, and they seemed to have come to a concrete conclusion about the phenomena taking place in the electron cloud. Since they were engineers their way of thinking was characteristic of engineers and it was quite natural that they spoke in an engineer’s way, but unfortunately it was completely foreign to me at the beginning. Every time I met them, I used to report to Tomonaga how I could not understand them, but he must have understood something, because after a month or so, he showed me his idea of applying the idea of secular perturbation, well-known in celestial mechanics and quantum theory, to the motion of the electrons in the cloud. I remember that the moment he toll me I said ‘This is it’. Further investigation actually showed that the generation of electromagnetic oscillations in split anode magnetrons cannot be essentially understood by applying his idea”. When Tomonaga approached the problem of ultra-shortwave circuits, which is to say, the behavior of microwaves in waveguides and cavity resonators, he found the engineers still using the old language of impedance. He thought this artificial because there no longer are unique definitions of current and voltage. Instead, being a physicist, Tomonaga begins with the electromagnetic field equations of Maxwell. But he quickly recognizes that those equations contain much more information than is needed to describe a microwave circuit. One usually wants to know only a few things about a typical waveguide junction: if a wave of given amplitude moves into a particular arm, what are the amplitudes of the waves coming out of the various arms, including the initial one? The array of all such relations forms a matrix, even then familiar to physicists as the scattering matrix. I mention here the amusing episode of the German submarine that arrived bearing a dispatch stamped Streng Geheim —
36
Julian Schwinger
Top Secret. When delivered to Tomonaga it turned out to be — Heisenberg’s paper on the scattering matrix. Copies of this Top Secret document were soon circulating among the physicists. Tomonaga preferred to speak of the scattering matrix as the characteristic matrix, in this waveguide context. He derives properties of that matrix, such its unitary character, and shows how various experimental arrangements can be described in term of the characteristic matrix of the junction. In the paper published after the war he remarks, concerning the utility of this approach, that “The final decision, however, whether or not new concept is more preferable to impedance should of course be given not only by a theoretical physicist but also by general electro-engineers”. But perhaps my experience is not irrelevant here. During the war I also worked on the electromagnetic problems of microwaves and waveguides. I also began with the physicist’s approach, including the use of the scattering matrix. But long before this three year episode was ended, I was speaking the language of the engineers. I should like to think that those years of distraction for Tomonaga and myself were not without their useful lessons. The waveguide investigations showed the utility of organizing a theory to isolate those inner structural aspects that are not probed under the given experimental circumstances. That lesson was soon appllied in the effective range description of nuclear forces. And it is this viewpoint that would lead to the quantum electrodynamics concept of selfconsistent subtraction or renormalization. Tomonaga already understood the importance of describing relativistic situations covariantly — without specialization to any particular coordinate system. At about this time, I began to learn that lesson pragmatically, in the context of solving a physical problem. As the war in Europe approached its end, the American physicists responsible for creating a massive microwave technology began to dream of high energy electron accelerators. One of the practical questions involved is posed by the strong radiation emitted by relativistic electrons swinging in circular orbits. In studying what is now called synchrotron radiation, I used the action of the field created by the electron’s motion. One part of that reaction describes the energy and momentum lost by the electron to the radiation. The other part is an added inertial effect characterized by an electromagnetic mass. I have mentioned the relativistic difficulty that electromagnetic mass usually creates. But, in the covariant method I was using, based on action and proper time, a perfectly invariant form emerged. Moral: to end with an invariant result use a covariant method and maintain covariance to the end of the calculation. And, in the appearance of an invariant electromagnetic mass that simply added to the mechanical mass to form the physical mass of the electron, neither piece being separately distinguishable under ordinary physical circumstances, I was seeing again the advantage of isolating unobservable structural aspects of the theory. Looking back at it, the basic ingredients of the coming quantum electrodynamic revolution were now in place. Lacking was an experimental impetus to combine them, and take them seriously. Suddenly, the Pacific War was over. Amid total desolation Tomonaga reestablished his seminar. But meanwhile, something had been brewing in Sakata’s Nagoya group. It goes back to a theory of M}oller and Rosenfeld, who tried to overcome the nuclear force difficulties of meson theory by proposing a mixed field theory, with
3 Tomonaga Sin-Itiro : A Memorial – Two Shakers of Physics
37
both pseudoscalar and vector mesons of equal mass. I like to think that my modification of this theory, in which the vector meson is more massive, was the prediction of the later discovered — meson. Somewhat analogously, Sakata proposed that the massless vector photon is accompanied by a massive scalar meson called the cohesive or C-meson. About this, Tomonaga said, “in 1946, Sakata proposed a promising method of eliminating the divergence of the electron mass by introducing the idea of a field of cohesive force. It was the idea that there exists an unknown field, of the type of the meson field, which interacts with the electron in addition to the electromagnetic field. Sakata named this field the cohesive force field, because the apparent electromagnetic mass due to the interaction of this field and the electron, though infinite, is negative and therefore the existence of this field could stabilize the electron in some sense. Sakata pointed out the possibility that the electromagnetic mass and the negative new mass cancel each other and that the infinity could be eliminated by suitably choosing the coupling constant between this field and the electron. Thus the difficulty which had troubled people for a long time seemed to disappear insofar as the mass was concerned”. Let me break in here and remark that this solution of the mass divergence problem is, in fact, illusory. In 1950, Kinoshita showed that the necessary relation between the two coupling constants would no longer cancel the divergences, when the discussion is extended beyond the lowest order of approximation. Nevertheless, the C-meson hypothesis served usefully as one of the catalysis that led to the introduction of the self-consistent subtraction method. How that came about is described in Tomonaga’s next sentence: “Then what concerned me most was whether the infinities appearing in the electron scattering process could also be removed by the idea of a plus-minus cancellation.” I have already referred to the 1939 calculation of Dancoff, on radiative corrections to electron scattering, which gave an infinite result. Tomonaga and his collaborators now proceeded to calculate the additional effect of the cohesive force field. It encouragingly gave divergent results of the opposite sign, but they did not precisely cancel Candoff’s infinite terms. This conclusion was reported in a letter of November 1, 1947, submitted to the Progress of Theoretical Physics, and also presented at a symposium on elementary particles held in Kyoto that same month. But meanwhile parallel calculations of the electromagnetic effect were going on, repeating Dancoff’s calculations, which were not reported in detail. At first they reproduced Dancoff’s result. But then Tomonaga suggested a new and much more efficient method of calculation. It was to use the covariant formulation of quantum electrodynamics, and subject it to a unitary transformation that immediately isolated the electromagnetic mass term. Tomonaga says, “Owing to this new, more lucid method, we noticed that among the various terms appearing in both Dancoff’s and our previous calculation, one term had been overlooked. There was only one missing term, but it was crucial to the final conclusion. Indeed, if we corrected this error, the infinities appearing in the scattering process of an electron due to the electromagnetic and cohesive force fields cancelled completely, except for the divergence of vacuum polarization type.”
A letter of December 30, 1947, corrected the previous erroneous announcement.
38
Julian Schwinger
But what is meant by “the divergence of vacuum polarization type”? From the beginning of Dirac’s theory of positrons it had been recognized that, in a sense, the vacuum behaved as a polarizable medium; the presence of an electromagnetic field induced a charge distribution acting to oppose the inducing field. As a consequence the charges of particles would appear to be reduced, although the actual calculation gave a divergent result. Nevertheless, the effect could be absorbed into a redefinition, a renormalization, of the charge. At this stage, then, Tomonaga had achieved a finite correction to the scattering of electrons, by combining two distinct ideas: the renormalization of charge, and the compensation mechanism of the C-meson field. But meanwhile another line of thought had been developing. In this connection let me quote from a paper, published at about this time, by Taketani Mitsuo: “The present state of theoretical physics is confronted with difficulties of extremely ambiguous nature. These difficulties can be glossed over but no one believes that a definite solution has been attained. The reason for this is that, on one hand, present theoretical physics itself has logical difficulties, while, on the other hand, there is no decisive experiment whereby to determine this theory uniquely.”
In June of 1947 those decisive experiments were made known, in the United States. For three days at the beginning of June, some twenty physicists gathered at Shelter Island, located in a bay near the tip of Long Island, New York. There we heard the details of the experiment by which Lamb and Retherford had used the new microwave techniques to confirm the previously suspected upward displacement of the 2S level of hydrogen. Actually, rumors of this had already spread, and on the train to New York, Victor Weisskopf and I had agreed that electrodynamic effects were involved, and that relativistic calculation would give a finite prediction. But there was also a totally unexpected disclosure, by Isador Rabi: the hyperfine structures in hydrogen and deuterium were larger than anticipated by a fraction of a percent. Here was another flaw in the Dirac electron theory, now referring to magnetic rather than electric properties. Weisskopf and I had described at Shelter Island our idea that the relativistic electron-positron theory, then called the hole theory, would produce a finite electrodynamic energy shift. But it was Hans Bethe who quickly appreciated that a first estimate of this effect could be found without entering into the complications of a relativistic calculation. In a Physical Review article received on June 27, he says, “Schwinger and Weisskopf, and Oppenheimer have suggested that a possible explanation might be the shift of energy levels by the interaction of the electron with the radiation field. This shift came out infinite in all existing theories, and has therefore always been ignored. However, it is possible to identify the most strongly (linearly) divergent term in the level shift with an electromagnetic mass effect which must exist for a bound as well as a free electron. This effect should properly be regarded as already included in the observed mass of the electron, and we must therefore subtract from the theoretical expression, the corresponding expression for a free electron of the same average kinetic energy. The result then diverges only logarithmically (instead of linearly) in non-relativistic theory. Accordingly, it may be expected that in the hole theory, in which the main term (self-energy of the electron) diverges only logarithmically, the result will be convergent after subtraction of the free electron expression. This would set an effective upper limit of the order of mc to the frequencies
3 Tomonaga Sin-Itiro : A Memorial – Two Shakers of Physics
39
of light which effectively contribute to the shift of the level of a bound electron. I have not carried out the relativistic calculations, but I shall assume that such an effective relativistic limit exists.”
The outcome of Bethe’s calculation agreed so well with the then not very accurately measured level shift that there could be no doubt of its electrodynamic nature. Nevertheless, the relativistic problem, of producing a finite and unique theoretical prediction, still remained. The news of the Lamb–Retherford measurement and of Bethe’s non-relativistic calculation reached Japan in an unconventional way. Tomonaga says, “The first information concerning the Lamb shift was obtained not through the Physical Review, but through the popular science column of weekly U.S. magazine. This information about the Lamb shift prompted us to begin a calculation more exact than Bethe’s tentative one.”
He goes on: “In fact, the contact transformation method could be applied to this case, clarifying Bethe’s calculation and justifying his idea. Therefore the method of covariant contact transformations, by which we did Dancoff’s calculation over again, would also be useful for the problem of performing the relativistic calculation for the Lamb shift.”
Incidentally, in speaking of contact transformations Tomonaga is using another name for canonical or unitary transformations. Tomonaga announced his relativistic program at the already mentioned Kyoto Symposium of November 24–25, 1947. He gave it a name, which appears in the title of a letter accompanying the one of December 30 that points out Dancoff’s error. This title is ‘Application of the SelfConsistent Subtraction Method to the Elastic Scattering of an Electron’. And so, at the end of 1947 Tomonaga was in full possession of the concepts of charge and mass renormalization. Meanwhile, immediately following the Shelter Island Conference I found myself with a brand new wife, and for two months we wandered around the United States. Then it was time to go to work again. I also clarified for myself Bethe’s nonrelativistic calculation by applying a unitary transformation that isolated the electromagnetic mass. This was the model for a relativistic calculation, based on the conventional hole theory formulation of quantum electrodynamics. But here I held an unfair advantage over Tomonaga, for, owing to the communication problems of the time, I knew that there were two kinds of experimental effects to be explained: the electric one of Lamb, and the magnetic one of Rabi. Accordingly, I carried out a calculation of the energy shift in a homogeneous magnetic field, which is the prediction of an additional magnetic moment of the electron, and also considered the Coulomb field of a nucleus in applications to the scattering and to the energy shift of bound states. The results were described in a letter to the Physical Review, received on December 30, 1947, the very same date as Tomonaga’s proposal of the self-consistent subtraction method. The predicted additional magnetic moment accounted for the hyperfine structure measurements, and also for later, more accurate, atomic moment measurements. Concerning scattering I said “· · · the finite radiative correction to the
40
Julian Schwinger
elastic scattering of electrons by a Coulomb field provides a satisfactory termination to a subject that has been beset with much confusion”. Considering the absence of experimental data, this is perhaps all that needed to be said. But when it came to energy shifts, what I wrote was, “The values yielded by our theory differ only slightly from those conjectured by Bethe on the basis of a non-relativistic calculation, and are, thus, in good accord with experiment.”
Why did I not quote a precise number? The answer to that was given in a lecture before the American Physical Society at the end of January, 1948. Quite simply, something was wrong. The coupling of the electron spin to the electric field was numerically different from what the additional magnetic moment would imply; relativistic invariance was violated in this non-covariant calculation. One could, of course, adjust that spin coupling to have the right value and, in fact, the correct energy shift is obtained in this way. But there was no conviction in such a procedure. The need for a covariant formulation could no longer be ignored. At the time of this meeting the covariant theory had already been constructed, and applied to obtain an invariant expression for the electron electromagnetic mass. I mentioned this briefly. After the talk, Oppenheimer told me about Tomonaga’s prior work. A progress report on the covariant calculations, using the technique of invariant parameters, was presented at the Pocono Manor Inn Conference held March 30 — April 1, 1948. At that very time Tomonaga was writing a letter to Oppenheimer which would accompany a collection of manuscripts describing the work of his group. In response, Oppenheimer sent a telegram: “Grateful for your letter and papers. Found most interesting and valuable mostly paralleling much work done here. Strongly suggest you write a summary account of present state and views for prompt publication in Physical Review. Glad to arrange.” On May 28, 1948, Oppenheimer acknowledges the receipt of Tomonaga’s letter entitled “On Infinite Field Reactions in Quantum Field Theory”. He writes, “Your very good letter came two days ago and today your manuscript arrived. I have sent it on at once to the Physical Review with the request that they publish it as promptly as possible· · · I also sent a brief note which may be of some interest to you in the prosecution of higher order calculations. Particularly in the identification of light quantum self energies, it proves important to apply your relativistic methods throughout. We shall try to get an account of Schwinger’s work on this and other subjects to you in the very near future”. He ends the letter expressing the “hope that before long you will spend some time with us at the Institute where we should all welcome you so warmly”. The point of Oppenheimer’s added note is this: In examining the radiative correction to the Klein–Nishina formula, Tomonaga and his collaborators had encountered a divergence additional to those involved in mass and charge renormalization. It could be identified as a photon mass. But unlike the electromagnetic mass of the electron, which can be amalgamated, as Tomonaga put it., into an already existing mass, there is no photon mass in the Maxwell equations. Tomonaga notes the possibility of a compensation cancellation, analogous to the idea of Sakata. In response, Oppenheimer essentially quotes my observation that a gauge invariant relativistic
3 Tomonaga Sin-Itiro : A Memorial – Two Shakers of Physics
41
theory cannot have a photon mass and further, that a sufficiently careful treatment would yield the required zero value. But Tomonaga was not convinced. In a paper submitted about this time he speaks of the “somewhat quibbling way” in which it was argued that the photon mass must vanish. And he was right, for the real subtlety underlying the photon mass problem did not surface for another 10 years, in the eventual recognition of what others would call ‘Schwinger terms’. But even the concept of charge renormalization was troubling to some physicists. Abraham Pais, on April 13, 1948, wrote a letter to Tomonaga in which, after commenting on his own work parallel to that of Sakata, he remarks, “it seems one of the most puzzling problems how to ‘renormalize’ the charge of the electron and of the proton in such a way as to make the experimental values for these quantities equal to each other”. Perhaps I was the first to fully appreciate that charge renormalization is a property of the electromagnetic field alone, which results in a renormalization, a fractional reduction of charge, that is the same for all. But while I’m congratulating myself, I must also mention a terrible mistake I made. Of course, I wasn’t entirely alone — Feynman did it too. It occurred in the relativistic calculation of energy values for bound states. The effect of high energy photons was treated covariantly: that of low energy photons in the conventional way. These two parts had to be joined together, and a subtlly involved in relating the respective four- and three-dimensional treatments was overlooked for several months. But sometime around September, 1948, it was straightened out, and, apart from some uncertainty about the inclusion of vacuum polarization effects, all groups, Japanese and American, agreed on the answer. As I have mentioned, it was the result I had reached many months before by correcting the obvious relativistic error of my first non-covariant calculation. In that same month of September, 1948, Yukawa, accepting an invitation of Oppenheimer, went to the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton, New Jersey. The letters that he wrote back to Japan were circulated in a new informal journal called Elementary Particle Physics Research — Soryushiron Kenkyu. Volume 0 of that journal also contains the communications of Oppenheimer and Pais to which I have referred, and a letter of Heisenberg to Tomonaga, inquiring whether Heisenberg’s paper, sent during the war, had arrived. In writing to Tomonaga on October 15, 1948, Yukawa says, in part, “Yesterday I met Oppenheimer, who came back from the Solvay Conference. He thinks very highly of your work. Here, many people are interested in Schwinger’s and your work and I think that this is the main reason why the demand for the Progress of Theoretical Physics is high. I am very happy about this”. During the period of intense activity in quantum electrodynamics, Tomonaga was also involved in cosmic ray research. The results of a collaboration with Hayakawa Satio were published in 1949 under the title “Cosmic Ray Underground”. By now, the two mesons had been recognized and named: π and μ. This paper discusses the generation of, and the subsequent effects produced by, the deep penetrating meson. Among other activities in that year of 1949, Tomonaga published a book on quantum mechanics that would be quite influential, and he accepted Oppenheimer’s invitation to visit the Institute for Advanced Study. During the year he spent there he turned in a new direction, one that would also interest me a number of years later. It is
42
Julian Schwinger
the quantum many-body problem. The resulting publication of 1950 is entitled “Remarks on Bloch’s Method of Sound Waves Applied to Many-Fermion Problems”. Five years later he would generalize this in a study of quantum collective motion. But the years of enormous scientific productivity were coming to a close, owing to the mounting pressures of other obligation. In 1951 Nishina died, and Tomonaga accepted his administrative burdens. Now Tomonaga’s attention turned toward improving the circumstances and facilities available to younger scientists, including the establishment of new Institutes and Laboratories. In 1956 he became President of the Tokyo University of Education, which post he held for six years. Then, for another six years, he was President of Science Council of Japan, and also, in 1964, assumed the Presidency of the Nishina Memorial Foundation. I deeply regretted that he was unable to be with us in Stockholm on December 10, 1965 to accept his Novel Prize. The lecture that I have often quoted today was delivered May 6, 1966. Following his retirement in 1970, he began to write another volume of his book on quantum mechanics which, unfortunately, was not completed. Two other books, one left in an unfinished state, were published, however. To some extent, these books are directed to the general public rather than the professional scientist. And here again Tomonaga and I found a common path. I have recently completed a series of television programs that attempt to explain relativity to the general public. I very much hope that this series, which was expertly produced by the British Broadcasting Corporation, will eventually be shown in Japan. Just a year ago today, our story came to a close. But Tomonaga Sin-Itiro lives on in the minds and hearts of the many people whose lives he touched, and graced.
4
The Discovery of the Parity Violation in Weak Interactions and Its Recent Developments Chien-Shiung Wu
Abstract This address was presented by Chien-Shiung Wu as the Nishina Memorial Lecture at the University of Tokyo, March 31, 1983
It is a great honor and privilege for me to deliver the Nishina Commemorative Lecture. Dr. Yoshio Nishina made not only fundamental and important contributions to various scientific fields; his great leadership, inspiration and dedication to scientific research and higher education in this country is a most moving and inspiring story to commemorate. The topic of my talk today on the Discovery of the Parity Violation in Weak Interactions and Its Recent Developments is already twenty-six years old. On January 16, 1957, the world of Physics was suddenly shocked by the news that Chien-Shiung Wu c parity is not conserved. The Jackson Professor Otto Frisch NMF of Cambridge University described the announcement as “the obscure phrase ‘parity is not conserved’ circled the globe like a new gospel.” Why has the news caused such excitement? What is the real meaning of the law of Conservation of Parity? What are the implications and consequences of the overthrow of the law of parity on Physics? Put in the simplest language, it means that the results of this discovery unequivocally proved that many natural phenomena, and also the objects of the microscopic world, are not necessarily symmetrical with respect to left and right. Now, one must be even more puzzled and want to understand why people should be so shocked by the discovery in which things turned out not necessarily left-right symmetrical. Chien-Shiung Wu (1912 – 1997). Columbia University (USA) at the time of this address C.-S. Wu: The Discovery of the Parity Violation in Weak Interactions and Its Recent Developments, Lect. Notes Phys. 746, 43–69 (2008) c Nishina Memorial Foundation 2008 DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-77056-5 4
44
Chien-Shiung Wu
Part I: Symmetry and Is Parity Conserved in Weak Interactions? (1) Symmetry and Bilateral Symmetry: The general concept of symmetry has a much broader meaning and it has occupied a very important position in the history of human civilization. The left–right symmetry is a bilateral symmetry and also a very prominent one. When the well known mathematician Professor Herman Weyl retired from Princeton University only a few years before the question of parity became the focal point in the theory of particle physics; he gave a series of four beautiful lectures to expound on the subject of symmetry and presented their forms, meanings and corresponding in variance elements (‘Symmetry’ [1], Princeton University Press, 1952). In the limited time permitted for this lecture, only a selected few illustrations will be shown which may give you some ideas that symmetry is indeed present everywhere in nature as well as in works of art or architecture. From such popular consensus and conviction, it is not difficult to imagine how one’s ancestors came to appreciate the idea of symmetry, particularly, the simple bilateral symmetry.
(2) A Few Illustrations of Various Forms of Symmetry : (Fig. 4.1–Fig. 4.8) It seems not an unreasonable conjecture that the concept of symmetry has something to do with these beautiful objects and phenomena existing in nature and also in the works of art and architecture developed with time.
(3) Symmetry in Sciences: Since symmetry occupies such an important position in the history of human civilization, philosophers and scientists have naturally attempted to make use of this idea, but the attempts met with little success. For instance, in 1595, Kepler tried to use the symmetry of geometrical structure to explain the ratio of the diameters of planetary orbits (see Fig. 4.9). The six spheres correspond to the six planets, Saturn, Jupiter, Mars, Earth, Venus, Mercury, separated in this order by cube, tetrahedron, dodecahedron, octahedron, icosahedron. This unsuccessful way of seeking harmony in static forms such as in regular solids by Kepler was long before his famous discovery of the three dynamic laws now bearing his name. Later, scientists no longer sought this harmony in static forms but in dynamic laws. By the 19th century, the idea of symmetry had become the central theme in a number of modern scientific disciplines; the obvious ones are
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
45
Fig. 4.1 Snowflakes or little marvels of frozen water are the best known specimens of hexagonal symmetry. They were the delight of old and young
Fig. 4.2 This figure shows cyclic symmetry of 5 of echinoderma from Ernest Haeckel’s ‘Kunstformen der Natur.’ Their larvae are organized according to the principle of bilateral symmetry
46
Fig. 4.3 This figure of a Greek sculpture of a noble praying boy can be used to illustrate bilateral symmetry
Chien-Shiung Wu
Fig. 4.4 A bronze statue from Northern Wei dynasty (385–534) in China also represents bilateral symmetry
Fig. 4.5 The Sumerians seem to have been particularly fond of strict bilateral symmetry. Alas! in this picture the two eagle-headed men are nearly but not quite symmetry (look at their arms)
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
47
Fig. 4.6 (left) Bronze wall “Gui,” Shang dynasty Fig. 4.7 (right) The rear view of the Romanesque cathedral in Mainz. Here shows repetition in the round arcs of the friezes, octagonal central symmetry in the small rosette and the three towers, while bilateral symmetry rules the structure as a whole as well as almost every detail
Fig. 4.8 The Palace of the Doges in Venice may stand for translational symmetry in architecture
48
Chien-Shiung Wu
crystallography (see Fig. 4.10), then molecular, atomic, nuclear, particle physics, chemistry and so forth. The importance of symmetry principles eventually dictated the types of fundamental interactions among various elementary particles.
(4) Conservation Laws and Symmetry: The first and perhaps the most important concept of symmetry is that space and time are isotropic and homogeneous. All points and all directions in space are equivalent so that there is no real distinction of absolute location in time and space. These are known as symmetry principles or equivalently invariance principles. The basic laws of conservation of momentum and energy are the direct consequences of the invariance of physical laws under space and time displacements. In other words, “Symmetry and Conservation Laws are really one and the same thing.” (See Fig. 4.11)
(5) The Conservation of Parity and Right-Left Symmetry: The symmetry between the left and right was debated at length by philosophers in the past. The laws of physics have always shown complete symmetry between the left and the right, that is, in all physics, nothing has appeared which would indicate intrinsic differences between left and right. Left and right being a discrete symmetry, therefore the law of right-left symmetry did not play any great important part in classical physics. It came to its eminence with the introduction of quantum mechanics. In fact, the conservation of parity is the direct consequence of the law of left-right symmetry. The Law of Parity Invariance states that for any atomic or nuclear system, no new physical law should result from the construction of a new system differing from the original by being a mirror image. That is, there is no absolute distinction between a real object (or event) and its mirror image. In other words, two worlds, one based upon a right-handed system (say, real object) and one based upon a left-handed system (say, mirror image) obey the same laws of physics. This law has been built into all physical theories from the 1920’s to 1957 and has severely restricted the predicted behavior of elementary particles.
(6) The “Tau” and “Theta” Puzzle: Up to about 1956 all theoretical physicists accepted the validity of parity conservation, and no experimentalists ever thought of devising tests to challenge its validity. Then, the big puzzle in K-meson decay [2] came onto the scene to stun the experts. K-mesons are unstable particles which were discovered in 1952–1953. Some
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
49
Fig. 4.9 Kepler made an attempt to deduce the distances in the planetary system to regular bodies which are alternatingly inscribed and circumscribed to spheres. This figure was published in 1595 in his ‘Mysterium Cosmographicum,’ by which he believed he had penetrated deeply into the secrets of the Creator
Fig. 4.10 Crystal structure is closely related to symmetry and invariance elements. A crystal lattice has a large number of invariance elements such as displacing to the right by one unit, or upwards by one unit, etc
50
Chien-Shiung Wu
Fig. 4.11 Symmetry and conservation laws are really one and the same thing. After the introduction of quantum mechanics in discussing the structure of atoms or molecules, we must refer to their quantum numbers, the idea of which has its roots in symmetry principles
K-mesons decay into two π-mesons, others into three π-mesons. The K-mesons yielding two π-mesons are called “Theta”; those yielding three π-mesons are called “Tau.” “Tau” and “Theta” are identical twins of same mass and same lifetime. θ −→ 2π τ −→ 3π The decays into two or three π-mesons are permitted by theory and therefore, it is nothing startling. But the two decay modes cannot be reconciled with the law of conservation of parity. “Tau” decays to an odd number of π-mesons of odd parity; “Theta” to an even number of π-mesons of odd parity. If one of them observes the conservation of parity, the other must violate it. So deeply rooted was this conception of parity that the physicists involved in the K-meson problem were greatly puzzled by this riddle. To recapture the atmosphere of that frustrating period, I might quote Dr. C. N. Yang [3] who said that ‘the physicist at that time was like a man in a dark room groping for a way out. He is aware of the fact that in some direction there must be a door which will lead him out of his predicament. But in which direction?’ After the parity experiment in polarized 60 Co nuclei showed definitely that both parity and charge conjugation in beta decay were violated, Yang telegraphed the news to J. R. Oppenheimer, who was vacationing in the Virgin Islands. He cabled back “Walked through door. . .” referring to Yang’s above comment.
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
51
(7) The Question of Parity Conservation in Weak Interactions: By April of 1956, various participants in the sixth Rochester Conference began to express their doubt of the Universal Validity of parity. Lee and Yang immediately plunged into a systematic investigation of the status of experimental knowledge concerning the parity conservation and were surprised that although parity was conserved in strong interactions, no experiments had ever been designed specifically to test such an invariance in weak interactions. The weak interactions include β-decay, π-meson and μ-meson decay and strange particle interaction. So, the anxiety that began with a single isolated puzzle in “Tau” and “Theta” cases is now applied to a broad and pressing question: “Is Parity Conserved in All Weak Interactions? [4]
Part II: Conservation of Parity Operation in Radioactive Decays To use “Tau” and “Theta” particles themselves in these tests is impractical. However, the beta decays of radioisotopes are perfectly suited for this experimentation. To understand the meaning of the experiment on polarized nuclei, one must first examine the meaning of conservation of parity in radioactive decays.
Fig. 4.12 The mirror reflection of a spinning ball. The image and the real object could not be distinguished because the top right one looks just like the real ball turned upside down. Reflection can be detected if there is a preferred direction
The law of parity dictates that the physics phenomena of atomic or nuclear systems in the original and its mirror twin should be indistinguishable. Fig. 4.12 shows the mirror reflection of a spinning ball. If the ball ejected particles equally in both
52
Chien-Shiung Wu
directions along its axis, the image and the real object could not be distinguished because the top right one looks just like the real ball turned upside down. However, if there is a preferred direction for the ejection of particles, then the reflection can be detected. The image at bottom cannot be mistaken for the real thing, as they have reversed handedness. σ · p changes sign under Mathematically, it states that a pseudoscalar term σ space inversion where p is the electron momentum and σ the spin of the nucleus. If the distribution of emitted electrons from polarized nuclei is asymmetrical (see σ · p of the radioactive decay is not identically Fig. 4.13) the pseudoscalar term σ σ · p 0 will change sign under space inverequal to zero. The pseudoscalar term σ sion therefore the parity is not conserved.
Fig. 4.13 σ the spin of the nucleus; p e the electron momentum. σ · p e ≡ 0. If parity conservation is valid; the expectation value of σ σ · p e ) ≡ drr ψ∗ (rr )[σ σ (rr ) · p e (rr )]ψ(rr ) (σ If parity invariance is valid; then P-operation gives Pψ(rr ) = ψ(−rr ) = ±ψ(r r) σ · p e ) = drr ψ∗ (rr ))[σ σ(−rr ) · p e (−rr )]ψ(rr ) then P(σ σ(rr ) · p e (rr )]ψ(rr ) = − drr ψ∗ (rr )[σ σ · p e ) = −(σ σ · p e ) ≡ 0, the expectation value ( ) of pseuIf parity invariance is valid, (σ doscalar quantity must be identically zero
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
53
Part III: Experimental Discovery of Parity Non-Conservation in Weak Interactions During the years 1945 to 1952, I was completely submerged in the experimental studies of beta decay [5]. It was an exciting period, indeed for all who worked in this field. Although from 1952 on my interest was gradually turning away from beta decay, to me, β-decay was still like a dear old friend; there would always be a place in my heart especially reserved for it. This feeling was rekindled when, one day in the early spring of 1956, my colleague T. D. Lee came up to my office on the thirteenth floor of Pupin Physics Lab. He asked me a series of questions concerning the status of the experimental knowledge of beta decay. Unfortunately, I could not supply him with any information on the pseudoscalar σ · p from experimental results of β-decay. All the previous β-decay exquantity σ periments investigated were essentially “only” scalar quantities, for example, the shape of the β-spectrum and the intensities or half lives, etc. Before T. D. Lee left my office, I asked him whether anyone had any ideas about doing this test. He said some people had suggested using polarized nuclei produced in nuclear reactions or using a polarized slow neutron beam from a reactor. Somehow I had great misgivings about using either of these two approaches. I suggested that the best bet would be to use a 60 Co β-source polarized by the adiabatic demagnetization method, by which one could attain a polarization as high as 65%. Dr. Lee was very much interested in the possibility of such a strongly polarized 60 Co β-source and asked me to lend him a reference book on the method.
(1) Polarized 60 Co Experiment—Adiabatic Demagnetization: In this Demagnetization Method the principle of polarization is based upon the fact that in certain paramagnetic salts there are large magnetic fields (∼ 105 –106 gauss) at the nuclei of the paramagnetic ions due to unpaired electrons and, at temperatures of the order of 0.01◦K, the nuclear magnetic moments become oriented with respect to these electron magnetic fields. Since the electron magnetism is easily saturated at low temperature, a field of a few hundred gauss suffices. Nuclear orientation will automatically follow. Because of my familiarity with the capability and limitations of this technique, it was only natural that the first thought which came to my mind was to use the polarized 60 Co source.
54
Chien-Shiung Wu
(2) My Decision to Go Ahead: Following Dr. Lee’s visit, I began to think things through. This was a golden opportunity for a beta ray physicist to perform a crucial test, and how could I let it pass? Even if it turned out that the conservation of parity in beta decay was actually valid, the experimental result would, at least, set a reasonably upper limit on its violation and thus stop further speculation that parity in β-decay is substantially violated.
(3) Two Major Difficulties: As an experimentalist, I was also challenged by two techniques which had never been tried before and were difficult. One was to put an electron detector inside a cryostat at a liquid helium temperature and to make it function as a β-spectrometer; the other was to fabricate a β-source located in a very thin surface layer and have it stay polarized for a time period long enough to obtain sufficient statistics. That spring, my husband and I had planned to make a lecture tour to Europe and the Far East. Our passages were booked. I suddenly realized that I had to do the experiment immediately, so I asked Chia-Liu to let me stay and told him to go without me. Fortunately, he fully appreciated the importance of the time element and finally agreed to go alone. In order to do the demagnetization method, one needs very complicated ultralow temperature equipment. There were only two or three low temperature labs in the United States which were equipped to do nuclear orientation experiments. Dr. Ernest Ambler, a pioneer in the nuclear orientation field, had moved from Oxford University to the Low Temperature Lab. at The National Bureau of Standards years earlier. I decided to contact him by phone to determine whether he would be interested in a collaboration. Although we had never met before, it was on June 4, 1956 that I called and put the proposition directly to him. He accepted immediately and enthusiastically.
(4) On the Long Road to Planning: As soon as the spring semester ended in the last part of May, 1956, I started to work in earnest in preparation for the experiment. From the beginning of June until the end of July, two solid months were spent on testing our beta particle detectors. What type of scintillator would be best for this purpose? What shape should the head of the light-guide be? How could we bring the long lucite pipe (4ft) with a small diameter (1in) out of the cryostat? Could one leave the scintillator or the photomultiplier inside the helium cryostat? Would the polarizing magnetic field affect the counting rates? The thorough preparation was worth all the effort. The 4ft long, 1 inch diameter lucite light pipe gave the 137 Cs conversion line (624keV) a fine resolution of
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
55
17%, this excellent resolution was due mostly to the careful selection of a clear lucite rod, the machining of the lucite head to a logarithmic spiral for maximum light collection, above all, Mrs. Marion Biavati’s personal attention to its surface polish played a major role. In the middle of September, I finally went to Washington D. C. for my first meeting with Dr. Ambler. He was exactly as I had imagined from our numerous telephone conversations; soft-spoken, capable, and efficient. He has been the Director of the National Bureau of Standards since the late seventies. He took me to his lab and introduced me to Dr. R. P. Hudson, who was his immediate supervisor at that time. The two of them had been working closely together. Hudson’s subsequent decision to join our exciting experiment was indeed welcome. In the beta particle counting and the gamma ray anisotropy measurements, we required a great deal of electronics. Dr. R. W. Hayward of the National Bureau of Standards had offered us the use of his 10-channel pulse height analyser and other equipment. The eventual joining of Dr. Hayward and his research assistant D. D. Hoppes, greatly strengthened our group, particularly during the exasperating days and nights when we had hardly any sleep. We wished we could have more such able collaborators. By the time of my third trip to Washington, D. C., I had grown two 60 Co specimens. One was made by taking a good single crystal of CMN (cerium magnesium nitrate) and growing on the upper surface only an additional crystalline layer containg 60 Co. The thickness of the radioactive layer used was about 0.002 inches and contained a few micro curies of activity. The others had the 60 Co evenly distributed throughout the CMN crystal for the study of the anisotropy of the 60 Co gamma rays.
(5) Our Fear Confirmed: The polarization of the thick 60 Co γ-ray source was obtained with no difficulty. But we had no such luck for the thin surface 60 Co source. The polarization lasted no more than a few seconds, then completely disappeared. What we had feared all along finally happened: the polarization of a thin layer on the surface did not last long enough for actual observation. The reason for this disappearance of nuclear polarization on the surface was probably due to its sudden rise in temperature caused by heat that reached the surface of the specimen by means of radiation conduction or condensation of the He-exchange gas. The only remedy was to shield the thin CMN crystal in a cooled CMN housing. But where could one obtain many large single CMN crystals in a hurry? I decided to return to Pupin Laboratory at Columbia University and try to find ways to grow some CMN crystals.
56
Chien-Shiung Wu
(6) Beautiful Sight of Those Large Single CMN Crystals: I consulted some professional crystallographic experts and, unfortunately, they confirmed my fear that professional care would be needed to grow large-size CMN crystals (1 inch diameter). Both elaborate equipment and plenty of patience were required and we had neither the funds nor the time. Purely relying on ingenuity determination and luck. three of us: an enthusiastic chemist (Herman Fleishman), a dedicated student (Marion Biavati), and I worked together uninterruptedly to grow about ten large, perfect, translucent CMN single crystals at the end of three weeks. The day I carried these precious crystals with me back to Washington, I was the happiest and proudest person in the world. To fabricate a housing out of these CMN crystals, one has to carve a large hole in each of these thin, brittle crystals without causing it to crack. We were so happy when a crystallographer suggested to us that we borrow a dentist’s drill (which is designed in such a way so that it exerts pressure inwardly only). The CMN crystal is known to have a highly anisotropic g-values : g⊥ > g// . In making the housing, one must line up the crystal axis perpendicular to the demagnetization field and glue the CMN pieces together (see Fig. 4.14). Dr. Ambler applied the DuPont cement as it was frequently used in room temperature. This time, we indeed saw an unmistakably asymmetrical effect on the counting rates when the polarization field was turned on. However, the effect was not only eminently clear but also irreversible! The counting rates never returned to their
Fig. 4.14 A schematic diagram showing the demagnetization cryostat used in the measurement of the angular distribution of the electrons from the β-decay of oriented 60 Co nuclei. The 60 Co nuclei were polarized parallel to the axis of the cylindrical cryostat. The electrons were detected by an anthracene scintillation counter. Two NaI γ-ray scintillation counters are also shown
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
57
original values even when the source was warmed up. The shielding CMN house had caved in. Then the cryostat was warmed up and opened, we saw that was exactly what had happened. As already mentioned, the CMN crystal has a highly anisotropic gvalue. The axis of the crystal had not been set exactly parallel to the magnetic field, a strong torque developed, the ultra-low temperature caused the DuPont cement to completely lose its adhesive property; and the CMN housing under the torque came tumbling down!
(7) Genuine Asymmetry Effect Observed: The second time the housing was put together, fine nylon threads were used to tie the pieces together and, for the first time, we finally saw a genuine asymmetry effect which coincided exactly with the γ-ray anisotropy effect (see Fig. 4.15). That was already in the middle of December, 1956. One half year after the beginning of our planning. I remember the mood then was more cautious and subdued. The discovery would be big if our observation was real, but we cautioned ourselves that more rigorous experimental checks must be carried out before announcing our results to outsiders. Between experimental runs in Washington, I had to dash back to Columbia for teaching and other research activities. One Thursday morning, as I was hurrying to the seminar room (Room 831) at Pupin, I passed Dr. Lee’s office; the door was open and both Lee and Yang were there. As I stuck my head in to say hello, they inquired about the 60 Co experiment. I casually mentioned that it seemed there was a huge asymmetry effect. Upon hearing this they were excited and pleased. As I passed their room again, after the seminar, they wanted to know more. I told them the effect was large and reproducible, but it must be regarded as preliminary because some systematic checks were not yet completed. I remember on that occasion, Yang also wanted to know whether anyone had calculated the interference term between the G-T and Fermi interaction. I told him that Dr. Masato Morita had carried out these calculations in detail and the interference term might be destructive, depending on the signs between C A and CV . I said I was pleased that the beta transition in 60 Co was a pure G-T transition. We know now that the observed asymmetry parameter A in 60 Co (5 −→ 4) is nearly −1, but it is much reduced in mixed transitions such as in Table 4.1. Table 4.1 β
Ii −→ If Asymmetry Parameter A 60 Co 5 −→ 4 −1 1 n 1/2 −→ 1/2 −0.11 19 Ne 1/2 −→ 1/2 −0.057
58
Chien-Shiung Wu
Fig. 4.15 Results of β asymmetry and γ anisotropy from polarized 60 Co experiment. The disappearance of the γ asymmetry coincides exactly with the time of disappearance of γ anisotropy. The measured asymmetry indicates that the emission of electrons is preferred in the direction opposite to that of the nuclear spin
I was thoroughly pleased that I had selected the pure (G-T) transition β-decay in 60 Co for the crucial test of parity.
(8) Rigorous Experimental Checks: One week later, after some modifications on the glass dewar were completed, we began to follow through intense experimental checks on the asymmetry effects observed. First, we had to prove that this asymmetry effect was not due to the strong magnetic field of the CMN crystals produced at extremely low temperatures. We also needed to show that this effect was not due to the remnant magnetization in the sample induced by the strong demagnetization field. The most clear-cut control ex-
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
59
periment would be one in which a beta activity would be introduced into the CMN crystal, but in which the radioactive nucleus would be known not to be polarized; thus no asymmetry effect should be detected. To carry out all these experiments would take several weeks. On Christmas Eve I returned to New York on the last train as the airport was closed because of heavy snow. I told Dr. Lee that the observed asymmetry was reproducible and huge, but we had not exhausted all experimental checks yet. When I started to make a quick rough estimate of the asymmetry parameter A, I found it was nearly −1. The asymmetry parameter A was estimated as follows: The electron angular distribution is W(θ) = 1 + A
Iz v cos θ I c
“θ” is the angle between the nuclear spin and electron momentum direction. The actually observed asymmetry is ∼ 25% W(0) − W(π) Iz v = −0.25 = A W(0) + W(π) I c I
where Iz = 0.65 calculated from observed γ anisotropy, cv 0.6 from the calibrated pulse height analysis. The back scattering of the electrons from the CMN crystal was found in a magnetic spectrometer to be 30–35. Therefore A −0.25 × (0.65 × 0.60)−1 × 32 −1. The result of A = −1 was the first indication that the interference between parity conserving and parity non-conserving terms in the G-T interaction Hamiltonian was close to maximum or, C A = C A This result is just what one should expect for a two component theory of the neutrino in a pure Gamow-Teller transition. It also implies that, in this case, the charge conjugation is also non invariant. Dr. Lee realized it then and said that this was very good. He told me that during the summer of 1956, when he and Yang worked together, they had not only entertained the idea of the two-component theory of the neutrino, but had also worked out some details of the theory [9]. However, they felt it was too rash to publish it before the violation of the law of parity was experimentally observed. Confronted by the clear evidence of the two-component theory of the neutrino, we discussed possible experiments one could do. One of them was the measurement of electron polarization; the other was the π-μ-e parity experiments. All these possible experiments were soon carried out in various laboratories the world over. The(9 correct interpretation of our very first pioneer experiment on parity non-conservation and charge-conjugation noninvariance played a decisive effect. It also suggested the combined “CP” invariance. This combined operation CP was examined by Landau [9], Wick [10], and Yang [11] even before the parity was overthrown.
60
Chien-Shiung Wu
(9) Law of Parity Overthrown: On January 2nd, I went back to the Bureau to continue with our experimental checks. The atmosphere in the period between January 2nd and 8th was probably the most tense in our whole experimental venture. Our cryostat at the NBS was made of glass and the glass joints were put together with low temperature vacuum grease which was concocted by melting together glycerine and Palmolive soap (later on we changed to Ivory soap). The trouble which plagued us repeatedly was the super-fluid leak below the lambda point (T = 2.3K). Each time this happened, it took at least 6 – 8 hours to warm up, regrease and then cool the cryostat down again. To save time, Hopper slept on the ground near the cryostat in a sleeping bag. Whenever the cryostat reached liquid helium temperature he would telephone each of us to go to the lab, no matter what time of the night it was. During the week of January 7th, rumors started to come in fast about the Nevis πμ-e parity experiments. Very much alarmed and excited, the director and the high administration officials of the NBS came to call on us and wanted to know more about our experiment which was rumored to be as important as the Michelson-Morley one. We were as vigilant as ever. Even after the muon decay had shown the violation of the law of parity, we still did not relax. We, ourselves, had to be totally convinced! After we had finished all the experimental checks which we had set out to do, we finally gathered together around 2 o’clock in the morning of January 9th to celebrate the great event. Dr. Hudson smilingly opened his drawer and pulled out a bottle of wine which turned out to be actually a Chateau Lafite-Rothschild, Vintage 1949. He put it on the table with a few small paper cups. We finally drank to the overthrow of the Law of Parity. I remember vividly several research workers in other sections of the low temperature laboratories stopping by our lab the next morning and being surprised by the silent and relaxed atmosphere. They suddenly turned around to take a look at our waste paper basket and nodded to themselves “All right, the law of parity in beta decay is dead.” I hurried back to the Pupin Laboratories on the night of January 10th and on the morning of the 11th, a Saturday, there was a meeting in Room 831. Lee, Yang, the Nevis group and I were all there. The discussion led by the two theorists was enthralling. Before that meeting our results had already been written up to be submitted to Physical Review [6]. What a great shock to the world of physics! On the afternoon of January 15th, the Department of Physics at Columbia University called a press conference to announce the dramatic overthrow of a basic law of physics, known as the conservation of parity, to the public. The next day, the New York Times carried a front page headline “Basic Concept in Physics Reported Upset in Tests.” The news burst into public view and quickly spread around the world. As Professor O. R. Frisch of Cambridge University described it in a talk at that time, “The obscure phrase ‘parity is not conserved’ circled the globe like a new gospel.” As usual, following an important discovery, we were asked to give symposia, colloquia, and lectures on our experiments. Finally, the American Physical Society held its annual meeting in New York around the end of January. A post-deadline
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
61
paper session was assigned to the topic of the non conservation of parity. Later, Dr. K. K. Darrow recorded the event with his lively and witty pen in the Bulletin of the American Physical Society 2 (1956–57): “On Saturday afternoon to boot—the largest hall normally at our disposal was occupied by so immense a crowd that some of its members did everything but hang from the chandeliers.”
The sudden liberation of our thinking on the basic laws of the physical world was overwhelming. Activities along these lines advanced at an unprecedented pace. First, the non-conservation of parity was also observed in the π± → μ± → e± decays [7] and other weak interactions [8] not restricted to nuclear beta-decays. Thus the parity non-conservation is a fundamental characteristic of the weak interactions and the weak interaction has since manifested into one of the four fundamental interactions in Nature. The (v/c) dependence of the asymmetry parameter A of the beta particles from the polarized 60 Co was also used to examine the validity of the Time Reversal “T” and it was found, in general, sound. If the Time Reversal was still intact; it suggested the Combined CP Invariance based on the CPT Invariance.
Part IV: Recent Improvements on Parity Experiments on Polarized Nucle Refinement in Experimentation: Ever since the pioneer Fparity experiment on polarized 60 Co reported in 1957; practically all the beta-distribution measurements on polarized nuclei were limited to only two directions. One is in parallel and the other, anti-parallel to the nuclear spin axis (i.e. θ = 0◦ and 180◦). It was the goal of our research group in Nuclear Physics at Columbia to improve the cryogenic condition and magnetic field shielding of the parity experiments so that more reliable and precision results could be derived from asymmetry measurements.
a) Utilization of 3 He/4 He Dilution Refrigeration In 1960, London [12] suggested the 3 He/4 He Dilution Refrigeration method to cool the 3 He/4 He mixing. Within a decade, the development of this method already showed remarkable success. We initiated the build-up of the ultra-low temperature Nuclear Physics Lab in Pupin Basement around 1972. The major cryogenic equipment was procured from SHE Co. It could deliver and maintain an ultra-low temperature as low as 11mK at the mixing chamber indefinitely and kept within 1% of fluctuation.
62
Chien-Shiung Wu
b) Minimization of the stray magnetic fields surrounding the β source. Furthermore, we developed two intersecting closed magnetic loops which carried the magnetic flux to the permendur source foil (see Fig. 4.16). This design and arrangement greatly minimized the magnetic fields in the region between the source and the β± detector and permitted using a wide range of polarization angle θ.
Fig. 4.16 Detailed drawing of the magnetic loop system and the beta source tail assembly. The detailed double magnetic loop system is shown in the insert to illustrate the three-dimensional arrangement of the two magnetic loops used to rotate the polarization of the 60 Co nuclei. The permendur cross containing the radioactive 60 Co source is clamped to the double magnetic loops in the region when the “open gap” is shown in the insert drawing
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
63
c) Determination of the hyperfine field The magnetic hyperfine field at the Co nucleus in the permendur foil was measured using the NMR/ON technique and found to be 285kG. d) The β-detector The β-particles were detected using a Si(Li) crystal (10mm diameter, 5mm thick) mounted inside the dewar vacuum of the dilution refrigerator.
(2) Experimental Requirements: This experimental arrangement satisfied the following requirements: a) The β-detector was held in a fixed position but the polarization angle θ can be varied continuously over as much of a 0◦ to 360◦ range as possible. b) The β-detector was placed inside the cryostat and operated at 100K and had a good energy resolution and c) The ferromagnetic host of the β-source could be magnetized to near saturation. However, the magnetic field outside the source foil diminishes rapidly away from the surface to reduce any magnetic effects on the β-trajectories.
(3) 60 Co Sources: Two different 60 Co sources were prepared. Both source hosts were 25 micron thick permendur foils. a) In one of them, 15μCi of 60 Co were thermally diffused into the foil so that 2/3 of the activity lying within 10 microns of the front surface of the foil. b) In the second source, 15μCi of 60 Co were thermally diffused so that 2/3 of the activity lying within one micron of the front surface of the foil. Since the angular distribution of β-particles e− from 60 Co → 60 Ni + e− + νe based on the two component theory of the neutrino: Wth (θ) = 1 + AP cv cos θ; where, “P” is the polarizations≡ IIz , “A” the asymmetry coefficient. v velocity of β-particle = c speed of light
64
Chien-Shiung Wu
(4) Excellent Agreements Between Experiments and Theory The β-spectrum of 60 Co has an endpoint energy of 315keV and consequently, the region between 100keV and 200keV was chosen for analysis of the data. In the 100 to 200keV region, the data had the predicted energy dependence. v W(θ) − 1 −→ Aexp P cos θ W(θ) − 1 ∼ c v/c The numerical values of Aexp for the two different 60 Co sources were obtained by least-square fitting the quantity 1 + PA cos θ to the data shown in Fig. 4.17. For the “thin” source, where internal scattering is small, the experimental results are not only in excellent agreement with the form of the directional distribution, but the experimental asymmetry parameter Aexp = −1.01 ± 0.02 also in splendid agreement with the theoretical value Atheory = −1.
β±
(5) The Allowed but Isospin-Hindered β-Transitions:(I π −→ I π ; T −→ T ± 1, ΔT 0) The β transitions in these nuclei are of particular interest for studies of isospin conservation of nuclear forces and the Time-Reversal Invariance (TRI) tests of the weak interactions. (1) Allowed Fermi transitions require ΔT = O, and consequently, a non-zero value of the Fermi to Gamow-Teller mixing ratio y ≡ CV MF /C A MGT , in ΔT 0 nuclei violates isospin conservation. (2) In TRI tests in nuclear β-decay, the magnitude of T -odd correlations are proportional to y. Consequently, precise measurements of y for these β transitions are of fundamental importance. The mixing ratio, y, can be determined by two rather different methods. One is by measuring the asymmetry of the angular distribution of β particles from oriented nuclei (NO), and the other is the asymmetry of the β-γ circular polarization correlation methods (CP). Both experimental methods are difficult and require extreme care to possible systematic errors. The reported results in the past have been in very poor agreements. Recently, we used our 3 He/4 He ultra-low temperature (T 0.012K) nuclear orientation equipment Fig. 4.16 in determining the value y in isospin-hindered allowed beta transaction. β+ 58 8 Co −→ 31 27 26 Fe32
ΔT 0
β+ 56 56 27 Co29 −→ 26 Fe30
ΔT 0
The directional distribution of beta particles can be written as
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
65
Fig. 4.17 Directional distribution of β-particles from polarized 60 Co. The open circles are data taken with the thick source foil and the solid circles are data taken with the “thin” source foil. P is the nuclear polarization obtained from the analysis of the gamma spectra taken with the Ge(Li) detectors. The curves shown for the “thin” source and for the “thick” source are plots of (1 + Aexp P cv cos θβ ) versus θβ
− (vel. of β /the speed of light) Wβ (θ, v) = 1 + Aβ P cv cos θ Y H * H 6 asymmetry the angle between β-particle and parameter nuclear polarization axis. the nuclear polarization
66
Chien-Shiung Wu
The relations between Aβ and y are 56
Co :
58
Co :
0.3333 − 1.6333y 1 + y2 0.2000 − 1.789y Aβ = 1 + y2 Aβ =
From our Aβ (56 Co) = +0.359 ± 0.009 and Aβ (58 Co) = +0.341 ± 0.013 we find 56
Co :
y = −0.091 ± 0.005
58
Co :
y = −0.005 ± 0.008
It is interesting to note that 58 Co has a rather significant mixing y = 0.091 ±0.005. In a previous TRI test, using 56 Co (β-γ correlation on polarized 56 Co), Calaprice et al. [17] found 2|y| sin φ/(1+|y|2) = −0.011±0.022 where y = |y|eCφ . Using our results
Fig. 4.18 Fermi/Gamow-Teller Mixing Ratio Results for the Beta Decay of 56 Co Reading from left to right, the references for experimental points are: (Am 57b), (Da 61), (Ma 62), (Be 67), (Bh 67), (Pi 71), (Ma 82), (Gr 82). Am 57b E. Ambler et al.,: P. R., 108, 503 (1957) Da 61 H. Daniel et al.,: Z. Naturforsch, 160, 118 (1961) Ma 62 L.G. Mann et al.,: P. R., 128, 2134 (1962) Be 67 H. Behrens: Z. Phys., 201, 153 (1967) Bh 67 S. K. Bhattacherjes et al.,: N. P., A96, 81 (1967) Pi 71 O. Pingot: N. P., A174, 627 (1971) Ma 82 J. Markey: Private Comm. Gr 82 J. Groves: P. R. L., 49, 109 (1983) y ≡ CV MF /C A MGT = 0.09l ± 0.005
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
67
Fig. 4.19 Fermi/Gamow-Teller Mixing Ratio Results for the Beta Decay of 58 Co Our results on “y” of 56 Co and 58 Co are compared with previous workers in Fig. 4.18 and Fig. 4.19. For 56 Co, except for those of Ambler et al. (NO) and Pingot (CP), satisfactory agreements were obtained as compared to all other 5 results by CP methods. For 58 Co, the vanishing small value of y is strongly suppressed in the positron decay of 58 Co consistent with isospin selection rules. Solid circles represent nuclear orientation beta-asymmetry method. Open circles represent beta-gamma circular polarization method. The last point represents Columbia’s nuclear polarization result. y ≡ CV MF /C A MGT = −0.005 ± 0.008
for y, we obtain φ = 183 ± 7◦ consistent with non-evidence on T non-conservation. This is indeed a very sensitive method for “TRI” test in weak interaction. So the polarized nuclear experiments gave strong evidences to all Non Parity-Conservation, Non Charge-Conjugation Invariance but still nearly intact Time Reversl Tests. The overthrow of the Parity Law drives home once again the idea that science is not static but ever growing and dynamic. It involves not just the addition of new information but the continuous revision of old knowledge. It is the courage to doubt what has long been established and the incessant search for its verification and proof that pushes the wheel of sciences forward. It is my great pleasure and privilege to be able to share some of my exciting memories with you. These were moments of exaltation and ecstasy. A glimpse of
68
Chien-Shiung Wu
this wonder can be the reward of a lifetime. I often wonder, could it be that excitement and ennobling feeling in scientific research has unfailingly kept us scientists dedicating our lives to it contentedly.
Fig. 4.20 Scene of the lecture room of Professor Wu, at University of Tokyo, 1983
References 1. “Symmetry” by Hermann Weyl, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey (1952) 2. R. H. Dalitz: Phil. Mag., 44, 1068 (1953) 3. C. N. Yang: Selected Papers 1945–1980 with Commentary, Freeman Publishers (1982) 4. T. D. Lee and C. N. Yang: Phys. Rev., 104, 254 (1956) 5. C. S. Wu: Rev. Mod. Phys., 22, 386 (1950) 6. C. S. Wu, E. Ambler, R. W. Hayward, D. D. Hopper and R. F. Hudson: Phys. Rev., 105, 1413 (1957) 7. R. L. Garwin, L. M. Lederman and M. Weinrich: Phys. Rev., 105, 1415 (1957); (in counter experiments) J. I. Friedman and V. L. Telegdi: Phys. Rev., 105, 1681 (1957) (in nuclear emulsions) 8. R. H. Dalitz: Rev. Mod. Phys., 31, 823 (1959); Lecture Notes From Varenna Summer School (1959)
4 The Discovery of the Parity Violation
9.
10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17.
69
J. Steinberger: “Experimental Survey of Strange Particle Decays”, Varenna Summer School (1964) T. D. Lee and C. N. Yang: Phys. Rev., 105, 1671 (1957) L. Landau: Nuclear Physics, 3, 127 (1957) A. Salam: Nuovo Cimento, 5, 299 (1957) It is interesting to recall that in 1929 Weyl (Z. Phys., 56, 330, 1929) proposed the mathematical possibilities of such a two-component massless relativistic particle of spin one-half. It was rejected by Pauli (Handbuch der Physik, Vol. 24, 226– 227) because it violated the law of parity. G. C. Wick, A. S. Wightman and E. P. Wigner: Phys. Rev., 88, 101 (1952) C. N. Yang: Proc. Seattle Congress, Sept. (1956), Rev. Mod. Phys., 29, 231 (1956) H. London: Proc. Int. Conf. on Low Temp Phys. Oxford, p. 157 (1951) H. London, C. R. Clarke and E. Mendoza: Phys. Rev., 128, 1992 (1962) L. M. Chirovsky, W. P. Lee, A. M. Sabbas, J. L. Groves and C. S. Wu: Nuclear Inst. and Methods, will be published soon. L. M. Chirovsky, W. P. Lee, A. M. Sabbas, J. L. Groves and C. S. Wu: Phys. Lett., 948, 127 (1980) J. L. Groves, W. P. Lee, A. M. Sabbas, M. E. Chen, P. S. Kravitz, L. M. Chirovsky and C. S. Wu: Phys. Rev. Lett., 49, 109 (1982) W. P. Lee, A. M. Sabbas, M. E. Chen, P. S. Kravitz, L. M. Chirovsky, J. L. Groves and C. S. Wu: Phys. Rev. C, 28, 345 (1983) F. P. Calaprice, S. J. Freedman, B. Osgood and W. C. Thomlinson: Phys. Rev. C, 15, 381 (1977)
5
Origins of Life Freeman J. Dyson
Abstract This address was presented by Freeman J. Dyson as the Nishina Memorial Lecture at the University of Tokyo, on October 17, 1984, and at Yukawa Institute for Theoretical Physics, on October 23, 1984.
I. Illustrious Predecessors First I would like to express my thanks to the Nishina Memorial Foundation, and to Professor Kubo in particular, for inviting me to give this lecture and making it possible for me to visit Japan. Unfortunately I never met Professor Nishina, and I knew him only by reputation, as the discoverer of the Klein-Nishina formula in quantum electrodynamics. That formula had tremendous importance in the history of physics. It was the first quantitative prediction of quantum electrodynamics in the relativistic domain to be verified experimentally. It gave the physicists of the Freeman J. Dyson c 1930’s and 1940’s confidence that relativistic field theories NMF were not total nonsense. Relativistic field theories described at least one experimental fact correctly. This confidence was the essential foundation on which Professor Tomonaga in Japan and Schwinger and Feynman in America built the structure of quantum electrodynamics as it now exists. All physicists who have taken part in the building of quantum electrodynamics, and later in the building of quantum chromodynamics, not only in Japan but all over the world, owe a great debt of gratitude to Professor Nishina. But I did not come here today to talk about physics. Like other elderly physicists, I stopped some time ago to compete with the young people who are inventing new Freeman J. Dyson (1923 – ). Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton(USA) at the time of this address F. J. Dyson: Origins of Life, Lect. Notes Phys. 746, 71–97 (2008) c Nishina Memorial Foundation 2008 DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-77056-5 5
72
Freeman J. Dyson YOSHIO NISHINA ¨ ERWIN SCHRODINGER MANFRED EIGEN LESLIE ORGEL LYNN MARGULIS MOTOO KIMURA
Fig. 5.1 Illustrious Predecessors
models every day to explain the intricate hierarchy of hadrons and leptons. I admire what the young people are doing, but I prefer to work in a less fashionable area where the pace is slower. I turned my attention to biology and in particular to the problem of the origin of life. This is a problem of chemistry rather than of physics, but a physicist may hope to make a modest contribution to its solution by suggesting ideas which chemical experiments can test. It would be absurd to imagine that the problem of the origin of life can be solved by theoretical speculation alone. Theoretical physicists entering the field of biology must behave with proper humility; our role is not to answer questions but only to ask questions which biologists and chemists may be able to answer. Here (Fig. 5.2) is a short list of references for people who are not expert in biology. The Schr¨odinger book is a wonderful introduction to biology for physicists. I will come back to it presently. The Miller-Orgel book is a good general survey of the state of knowledge about the origin of life, written ten years ago but still useful. The authors are both chemists, and they do particularly well in explaining the details of the chemistry out of which life is supposed to have arisen. The article by Eigen and his collaborators is twice as long as a standard Scientific American article. It contains a full account of the experiments which Eigen and his group have done during the ten years since the Miller-Orgel book was written. These experiments started the “New Wave” in our thinking about the origin of life. The last reference is my own modest contribution to the subject. It contains a mathematically precise account of a model which I shall describe in a less formal fashion in this lecture. S. L. Miller and L. E. Orgel: “The Origins of Life on the Earth” (Prentice-Hall, 1974) M. Eigen, W. Gardiner, P. Schuster and R. Wikler-Oswatitsch: “The Origin of Genetic Information,” Scientific American, 244, 88–118 (April, 1981) F. Dyson: “A Model for the Origin of Life,” J. Molecular Evolution, 18, 344–350 (1982) E. Schr¨odinger: “What is Life? The Physical Aspect of the Living Cell,” (Cambridge University Press, 1944) Fig. 5.2 References
“What is Life?” is a little book, less than a hundred pages long, published by the physicist Erwin Schr¨odinger forty years ago, when he was about as old as I am now. It was extraordinarily influential in guiding the thoughts of the young people who created the new science of molecular biology in the following decade. The book
5 Origins of Life
73
is clearly and simply written, with less than ten equations from beginning to end. It is also a fine piece of literature. Although Schr¨odinger was exiled from his native Austria to Ireland after the age of fifty, he wrote English far more beautifully than most of his English and American colleagues. He also knew how to ask the right questions. The basic questions which he asked in his book are the following: What is the physical structure of the molecules which are duplicated when chromosomes divide? How is the process of duplication to be understood? How do these molecules succeed in controlling the metabolisom of cells? How do they create the organization that is visible in the structure and function of higher organisms? He did not answer these questions. But by asking them he set biology moving along the path which led to the epoch-making discoveries of the last forty years, to the double helix, the triplet code, the precise analysis and wholesale synthesis of genes, the quantitative measurement of evolutionary divergence of species. Schr¨odinger showed wisdom not only in the questions which he asked but also in the questions he did not ask. He did not ask any questions about the origin of life. He understood that the time was ripe in 1944 for a fundamental understanding of life’s origin. Until the basic chemistry of living processes was clarified, one could not ask meaningful questions about the possibility of spontaneous generation of these processes in a prebiotic environment. He wisely left the question of origins to a later generation.
Fig. 5.3 Biebricher-Eigen-Luce Experiment. Replication of RNA in a test-tube(1981)
Now, forty years later, the time is ripe to ask the questions which Scho¨odinger avoided. The questions of origin are now becoming experimentally accessible, just as the questions of structure were becoming experimentally accessible in the nineteen-forties. Manfred Eigen is the chief explorer of the new territory. He is, after all, a chemist, and this is a job for chemists. Eigen and his colleagues in Germany have done experiments which show us biological organization originating spontaneously and evolving in a test-tube (Fig. 5.3). More precisely, they have
74
Freeman J. Dyson
demonstrated that a solution of nucletide monomers will under and competes with its progeny for survival. From a certain point of view, one might claim that these experiments already achieved the spontaneous generation of life from non-life. They bring us at least to the point where we can ask and answer questions about the ability of nucleic acids to synthesize and organize themselves. Unfortunately, the conditions in Eigen’s test-tubes are not really pre-biotic. To make his experiments work, Eigen put into the test-tubes a polymerase enzyme, a protein catalyst extracted from a living bacteriophage. The synthesis and replication of the nucleic acid is dependent on the structural guidance provided by the enzyme. We are still far from an experimental demonstration of the appearance of biological order without the help of a biologically-derived precursor. Nevertheless, Eigen has provided the tools with which we may begin to attack the problem of origins. He has brought the origin of life out of the domain of idle speculation and into the domain of experiment. I should also mention at this point three other pioneers who have done the most to clarify my thinking about the origin of life. One is the chemist Leslie Orgel who originally kindled my interest in this subject twenty years ago, one is the biologist Lynn Margulis and one is the geneticist Motoo Kimura here in Japan. Leslie Orgel is, like Manfred Eigen, an experimental chemist. He taught me most of what I know about the chemical antecedents of life. He has done experiments complementary to those of Eigen. Eigen was able to make RNA grow out of nucleotide monomers without having any RNA template for the monomers to copy, but with a polymerase enzyme to tell the monomers what to do. Orgel has done equally important experiments in the opposite direction. Orgel demonstrated that nucleotide monomers will under certain conditions make RNA if they are given an RNA template to copy, without any polymerase enzyme. Orgel found that zinc ions in the solution are a good catalyst for the RNA synthesis. It may not be entirely coincidental that many modern biological enzymes have zinc ions in their active sites. To summarize, Eigen made RNA using an enzyme but no template, and Orgel made RNA using a template but no enzyme. In living cells we make RNA using both templates and enzymes. If we suppose that RNA was the original living molecule, then to understand the origin of life we have to make RNA using neither a template nor an enzyme (Fig. 5.4). Neither Eigen nor Orgel has come close to achieving this goal. Their experiments have given us two solid foundations of knowledge, with a wide river of ignorance running between them. Since we have solid ground on the two sides, it is not hopeless to think of building a bridge over the river. A bridge in science is a theory. When bridges are to be built, theoretical scientists may have a useful role to play. Lynn Margulis is one of the chief bridge-builders in modern biology. She built a bridge between the facts of cellular anatomy and the facts of molecular genetics. Her bridge was the idea that parasitism and symbiosis were the driving forces in the evolution of cellular complexity. She did not invent this idea, but she was its most active promoter and systematizer. She collected the evidence to support her view that the main internal structures of eucaryotic cells did not originate within the cells but are descended from independent living creatures which invaded the cells from outside like carriers of an infectious disease. The invading creatures and their hosts then gradually evolved into a relationship of mutual dependence, so that
5 Origins of Life
75 1. Biebricher, Eigen and ⎫ Luce (1998) ⎪ Nucleotides ⎪ ⎪ ⎬ Replicase Enzyme ⎪ → RNA ⎪ ⎪ ⎭ No template 2. Lohrmann, Bridson and Orgel (1980) ⎫ Nucleotides ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ Template RNA ⎬ → RNA ⎪ Zinc (or Magnesium) ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎭ No enzyme 3. Biological Replication ⎫ in vivo ⎪ Nucleotides ⎪ ⎪ ⎬ Template RNA → RNA ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ Replicase Enzyme ⎭ 4. Hypothetical ⎫ Pre-biotic Synthesis Nucleotides ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎬ No template ⎪ → RNA ⎪ ⎪ No enzyme ⎭
Fig. 5.4 RNA Experiments
the erstwhile disease organism became by degrees a chronic parasite, a symbiotic partner, and finally an indispensable part of the substance of the host. This Margulis picture of early cellular evolution now has incontrovertible experimental support. The molecular structures of chloroplasts and mitochondria are found to be related more closely to alien bacteria than to the cells in which they have been incorporated for one or two billion years. But there are also general philosophical reasons for believing that the Margulis picture will be valid even in cases where it cannot be experimentally demonstrated. A living cell, in order to survive, must be intensely conservative. It must have a finely tuned molecular organization and it must have efficient mechanisms for destroying promptly any molecules which depart from the overall plan. Any new structure arising within this environment must be an insult to the integrity of the cell. Almost by definition, a new structure will be a disease which the cell will do its best to resist. It is possible to imagine new structures arising internally within the cell and escaping its control, like a cancer growing in a higher organism. But it is much easier to imagine new structures coming in from the outside like infectious bacteria, already prepared by the rigors of independent living to defend themselves against the cell’s efforts to destroy them. The last on my list of illustrious predecessors is the geneticist Motoo Kimura. Kimura developed the mathematical basis for a statistical theory of molecular evolution, and he has been the chief advocate of the neutral theory of evolution. The neutral theory says that, through the history of life from beginning to end, random statistical fluctuations have been more important than Darwinian selection in causing species to evolve. Evolution by random statistical fluctuation is called genetic drift. Kimura maintains that genetic drift drives evolution more powerfully than natural selection. I am indebted to Kimura in two separate ways. First, I use Kimura’s mathematics as a tool for calculating the behavior of molecular populations. The mathematics is correct and useful, whether you believe in the neutral theory of evo-
76
Freeman J. Dyson
lution or not. Second, I find the neutral theory helpful even though I do not accept it as dogma. In my opinion, Kimura has overstated his case, but still his picture of evolution may sometimes be right. Genetic drift and natural selection are both important, and there are times and places where one or the other may be dominant. In particular, I find it reasonable to suppose that genetic drift was dominant in the very earliest phase of biological evolution, before the mechanisms of heredity had become exact. Even if the neutral theory is not true in general, it may be a useful approximation to make in building models of pre-biotic evolution. We know almost nothing about the origin of life. We do not even know whether the origin was gradual or sudden. It might have been a process of slow growth stretched out over millions of years, or it might have been a single molecular event that happened in a fraction of a second. As a rule, natural selection is more important over long periods of time and genetic drift is more important over short periods. If you think of the origin of life as slow, you must think of it as a Darwinian process driven by natural selection. If you think of it as quick, the Kimura picture of evolution by statistical fluctuation without selection is appropriate. In reality the origin of life must have been a complicated process, with incidents of rapid change separated by long periods of slow adaptation. A complete description needs to take into account both drift and selection. In my calculations I have made use of the theorist’s privilege to simplify and idealize a natural process. I have considered the origin of life as an isolated event occurring on a rapid time-scale. In this hypothetical context, it is consistent to examine the consequences of genetic drift acting alone. Darwinian selection will begin its work after the process of genetic drift has given it something to work on.
II. Theories of the Origin of Life There are three main groups of theories about the origin of life. I call them after the names of their most famous advocates, Oparin, Eigen and Cairns-Smith. I have not done the historical research that would be needed to find out who thought of them first (Fig. 5.5). The Oparin theory was described in Oparin’s book “Proiskhozhdenie Zhizni” in 1924, long before anything was known about the structure and chemical nature of genes. Oparin supposed that the order of events in the origin of life was: cells first, enzymes second, genes third. He observed that when a suitably oily liquid is mixed with water it sometimes happens that the two liquids form a stable mixture called a coacervate, with the oily liquid dispersed into small droplets which remain suspended in the water. Coacervate droplets are easily formed by non-biological processes, and they have a certain superficial resemblance to living cells. Oparin proposed that life began by the successive accumulation of more and more complicated molecular populations within the droplets of a coacervate. The physical framework of the cell came first, provided by the naturally occurring droplet. The enzymes came second, organizing the random population of molecules within the droplet into self-sustaining metabolic cycles. The genes came third, since Oparin
5 Origins of Life
77
Fig. 5.5 Theories of Origin of Life
had only a vague idea of their function and they appeared to him to belong to a higher level of biological organization than enzymes. The Oparin picture was generally accepted by biologists for half a century. It was popular, not because there was any evidence to support it, but rather because it seemed to be the only alternative to biblical creationism. Then, during the last twenty years, Manfred Eigen provided another alternative by turning the Oparin theory upside-down. The Eigen theory reverses the order of events. It has genes first, enzymes second and cells third. It is now the most fashionable and generally accepted theory. It has become popular for two reasons. First, the experiments of Eigen and of Orgel use RNA as working material and make it plausible that the replication of RNA was the fundamental process around which the rest of biology developed. Second, the discovery of the double helix showed that genes are structurally simpler than enzymes. Once the mystery of the genetic code was understood, it became natural to think of the nucleic acids as primary and of the proteins as secondary structures. Eigen’s theory has self-replicating RNA at the beginning, enzymes appearing soon afterwards to build with the RNA a primitive form of the modern genetic transcription apparatus, and cells appearing later to give the apparatus physical cohesion. The third theory of the origin of life, the theory of Cairns-Smith, is based upon the idea that naturally occurring microscopic crystals of the minerals contained in common clay might have served as the original genetic material before nucleic acids were invented. The microcrystals of clay consist of a regular silicate lattice with a
78
Freeman J. Dyson
regular array of ionic sites, but with an irregular distribution of metals such as magnesium and aluminum occupying the ionic sites. The metal ions can be considered as carriers of information like the nucleotide bases in a molecule of RNA. A microcrystal of clay is usually a flat plate with two plane surfaces exposed to the surrounding medium. Suppose that a microcrystal is contained in a droplet of water with a variety of organic molecules dissolved in the water. The metal ions embedded in the plane surfaces form irregular patterns of electrostatic potential which can adsorb particular molecules to the surfaces and catalyze chemical reactions on the surfaces in ways dependent on the precise arrangement of the ions. In this fashion the information contained in the pattern of ions might be transferred to chemical species dissolved in the water. The crystal might thus perform the same function as RNA in guiding the metabolism of amino-acids and proteins. Moreover, it is conceivable that the clay microcrystal can also replicate the information contained in its ions. When the crystal grows by accreting silicate and metal ions from the surrounding water, the newly accreted layer will tend to carry the same pattern of ionic charges as the layer below it. If the crystal is later cut along the plane separating the old from the new material, we will have a new exposed surface replicating the original pattern. The clay crystal is thus capable in principle of performing both of the essential functions of a genetic material. It can replicate the information which it carries, and it can transfer the information to other molecules. It can do these things in principle. That is to say, it can do them with some undetermined efficiency which may be very low. There is no experimental evidence to support the statement that clay can act either as a catalyst or as a replicator with enough specificity to serve as a basis for life. Cairns-Smith asserts that the chemical specificity of clay is adequate for these purposes. The experiments to prove him right or wrong have not been done. The Cairns-Smith theory of the origin of life has clay first, enzymes second, cells third and genes fourth. The beginning of life was a natural clay crystal directing the synthesis of enzyme molecules adsorbed to its surface. Later, the clay and the enzymes learned to make cell membranes and became encapsulated in cells. The original living creatures were cells with clay crystals performing in a crude fashion the functions performed in a modern cell by nucleic acids. This primæval clay-based life may have existed and evolved for many millions of years. Then one day a cell made the discovery that RNA is a better genetic material than clay. As soon as RNA was invented, the cells using RNA had an enormous advantage in metabolic precision over the cells using clay. The clay-based life was eaten or squeezed out of existence and only the RNA-based life survived. At the present time there is no compelling reason to accept or to reject any of the three theories. Any of them, or none of them, could turn out to be right. We do not yet know how to design experiments which might decide between them. I happen to prefer the Oparin theory, not because I think it is necessarily right but because it is unfashionable. In recent years the attention of the experts has been concentrated upon the Eigen theory, and the Oparin theory has been neglected. The Oparin theory deserves a more careful analysis in the light of modern knowledge. For the rest of this lecture I shall be talking mostly about my own attempt to put the Oparin theory into a modern framework using the mathematical methods of Kimura.
5 Origins of Life
79
Another reason why I find the Oparin theory attractive is that it fits well into the general picture of evolution portrayed by Lynn Margulis. According to Margulis, most of the big steps in cellular evolution were caused by parasites. I would like to propose the hypothesis that nucleic acids were the oldest and most successful cellular parasites. I am extending the scope of the Margulis picture of evolution to include not only eucaryotic cells but procaryotic cells as well. I propose that the original living creatures were cells with a metabolic apparatus directed by protein enzymes but with no genetic apparatus. Such cells would lack the capacity for exact replication but could grow and divide and reproduce themselves in an approximate statistical fashion. They might have continued to exist for millions of years, gradually diversifying and refining their metabolic pathways. Amongst other things, they discovered how to synthesize ATP, adenosine triphosphate, the magic molecule which serves as the principal energy-carrying intermediate in all modern cells. Cells carrying ATP were able to function more efficiently and prevailed in the Darwinian struggle for existence. In time it happened that cells were full of ATP and other related molecules such as AMP, adenosine monophosphate, GMP, guanine monophosphate, and so on.
Fig. 5.6 ATP and AMP
80
Freeman J. Dyson
Now we observe the strange fact that the two molecules ATP and AMP, having almost identical chemical structures, have totally different but equally essential functions in modern cells (Fig. 5.6). ATP is the universal energy-carrier. AMP is one of the nucleotides which make up RNA and function as bits of information in the genetic apparatus. GMP is another of the nucleotides in RNA. To get from ATP to AMP, all you have to do is replace a triple phosphate group by a single phosphate radical. I am proposing that the primitive cells had no genetic apparatus but were saturated with molecules like AMP and GMP as a result of the energy-carrying function of ATP. This was a dangerously explosive situation. In one cell which happened to be carrying an unusually rich supply of nucleotides, an accident occurred. The nucleotides began doing the Eigen experiment on RNA synthesis three billion years before it was done by Eigen. Within the cell, with some help from pre-existing enzymes, the nucleotides produced an RNA molecule which then continued to replicate itself. In this way RNA first appeared as a parasitic disease within the cell. The first cells in which the RNA disease occurred probably became sick and died. But then, according to the Margulis scheme, some of the infected cells learned how to survive the infection. The protein-based life learned to tolerate the RNA-based life. The parasite became a symbiont. And then, very slowly over millions of years, the protein-based life learned to make use of the capacity for exact replication which the chemical structure of RNA provided. The primal symbiosis of protein-based life and parasitic RNA grew gradually into a harmonious unity, the modern genetic apparatus. This view of RNA as the oldest and most incurable of our parasitic diseases is only a poetic fancy, not yet a serious scientific theory. Still it is attractive to me for several reasons (Fig. 5.7). First, it is in accordance with our human experience 1. This is extension of Margulis view, proved correct for eucaryotic cells, back into the procaryotic era. 2. Hardware (protein) should come before Software (nucleic acids). 3. Amino-acid synthesis is easier than nucleotide synthesis. 4. Nucleotides might have been by-product of ATP metabolism. 5. The hypothesis may be testable. Fig. 5.7 Arguments Supporting Origin of RNA as Cellular Parasite
that hardware should come before software. The modern cell is like a computercontrolled chemical factory in which the proteins are the hardware and the nucleic acids are the software. In the evolution of machines and computers, we always developed the hardware first before we began to think about software. I find it reasonable that natural evolution should have followed the same pattern. A second argument in favor of the parasite theory of RNA comes from the chemistry of aminoacids and nucleotides. It is easy to synthesize amino-acids, the constituent parts of proteins, out of plausible pre-biotic materials such as water, methane and ammonia. The synthesis of amino-acids from a hypothetical reducing atmosphere was demonstrated in the classic experiment of Miller in 1953. The nucleotides which make up
5 Origins of Life
81
nucleic acids are much more difficult to synthesize. Nucleotide bases such as adenine and guanine have been synthesized by Or´o from ammonia and hydrocyanic acid. But to go from a base to a complete nucleotide is a more delicate matter. Furthermore, nucleotides once formed are less stable than amino-acids. Because of the details of the chemistry, it is much easier to imagine a pond on the pre-biotic earth becoming a rich soup of amino-acids than to imagine a pond becoming a rich soup of nucleotides. Nucleotides would have had a better chance to polymerize if they originated in biological processes inside already existing cells. My third reason for liking the parasite theory of RNA is that it may be experimentally testable. If the theory is true, living cells may have existed for a very long time before becoming infected with nucleic acids. There exist microfossils, traces of primitive cells, in rocks which are more than 3 billion years old. It is possible that some of these microfossils might come from cells older than the origin of RNA. It is possible that the microfossils may still carry evidence of the chemical nature of the ancient cells. For example, if the microfossils were found to preserve in their mineral constituents significant quantities of phosphorus, this would be strong evidence that the ancient cells already possessed something resembling a modern genetic apparatus. So far as I know, no such evidence has been found. I do not know whether the processes of fossilization would be likely to leave chemical traces of nucleic acids intact. So long as this possibility exists, we have the opportunity to test the hypothesis of a late origin of RNA by direct observation.
III. The Error Catastrophe The central difficulty confronting any theory of the origin of life is the fact that the modern genetic apparatus has to function almost perfectly if it is to function at all. If it does not function perfectly, it will give rise to errors in replicating itself, and the errors will accumulate from generation to generation. The accumulation of errors will result in a progressive deterioration of the system until it is totally disorganized. This deterioration of the replication apparatus is called the “error catastrophe.” Manfred Eigen has given us a simple mathematical statement of the error catastrophe as follows (Fig. 5.8). Suppose that a self-replicating system is specified by N bits of information, and that each time a single bit is copied from parent to daughter the probability of error is ε. Suppose that natural selection operates to penalize errors by a selection factor S . That is to say, a system with no errors has a selective advantage S over a system with one error, and so on. Then Eigen finds the criterion for survival to be Nε < log S (3.1) If the condition (3.1) is satisfied, the selective advantage of the error-free system is great enough to maintain a population with few errors. If the condition (3.1) is not satisfied, the error catastrophe occurs and the replication cannot be sustained. The meaning of (3.1) is easy to interpret in terms of information theory. The left side Nε
82
Freeman J. Dyson
of the inequality is the number of bits of information lost by copying errors in each generation. The right side (log S ) is the number of bits of information supplied by the selective action of the environment. If the information supplied is less than the information lost in each generation, a progressive degeneration is inevitable. In Eigen quasi-species model of RNA replication. Good molecules can survive the multiplication of errors only if Log (Selective advantage) (Error rate) × (Gene length). Error rate must be 10−2 if genes carry useful amount of information. In Eigen-Biebricher experiment average RNA length was 120 nucleotides. This is consistent with error-rate 10−2 in presence of Qβ replicase enzyme. Question: Is error-rate 10−2 possible in pre-biotic soup without enzymes? Fig. 5.8 The Error Catastrophe
The condition (3.1) is very stringent. Since the selective advantage of an errorfree system cannot be astronomically large, the logarithm cannot be much greater than unity. To satisfy (3.1) we must have an error-rate of the order of N −1 at most. This condition is barely satisfied in modern higher organisms which have N of the order of 108 and ε of the order of 10−8 . To achieve an error-rate as low as 10−8 the modern organisms have evolved an extremely elaborate system of double-checking and error-correcting within the replication system. Before any of this delicate apparatus existed, the error-rates must have been much higher. The condition (3.1) thus imposes severe requirements on any theory of the origin of life which, like Eigen’s theory, makes the replication of RNA a central element of life from the beginning. All the experiments which have been done with RNA replication under abiotic conditions give error-rates of the order of 10−2 at best. If we try to satisfy (3.1) without the help of pre- existing organisms, we are limited to a replication-system which can describe itself with less than 100 bits of information. 100 bits of information is far too few to describe any interesting protein chemistry. This does not mean that Eigen’s theory is untenable. It means that Eigen’s theory requires an informationprocessing system which is at the same time extraordinarily simple and extraordinarily free from error. We do not know how to achieve such low error-rates in the initial phases of life’s evolution. I chose to study the Oparin theory because it offers a possible way of escape from the error catastrophe. In the Oparin theory the origin of life is separated from the origin of replication. The first living cells had no system of precise replication and could therefore tolerate high error-rates. The main advantage of the Oparin theory is that it allows early evolution to proceed in spite of high error-rates. It has the first living creatures consisting of populations of molecules with a loose organization and no genetic fine-tuning. There is a high tolerance for errors because the metabolism of the population depends only on the catalytic activity of a majority of the molecules. The system can still function with a substantial minority of ineffective or uncooperative molecules. There is no requirement for unanimity. Since the statistical fluctuations in the molecular populations will be large, there is a maximum opportunity for genetic drift to act as driving force of evolution.
5 Origins of Life
83
IV. A Toy Model of the Oparin Theory I now stop talking about general principles. Instead I will describe a particular mathematical model which I call a Toy Model of the Oparin Theory. The word Toy means that the model is not intended to be realistic. It leaves out all the complicated details of real organic chemistry. It represents the processes of chemical catalysis by a simple abstract mathematical formula. Its purpose is to provide an idealized picture of molecular evolution which resembles in some qualitative fashion the Oparin picture of the origin of life. After I have described the toy model and deduced its consequences, I will return to the question whether the behavior of the model has any relevance to the evolution of life in the real world. The model is an empty mathematical frame into which we may later try to fit more realistic descriptions of pre-biotic evolution. My analysis of the model is only an elementary exercise in population biology, using equations borrowed from Fisher and Kimura. The equations are the same, whether we are talking about a population of molecules in a droplet or about a population of birds on an island. To define the model, I make a list of ten assumptions (Fig. 5.9). The list begins with general statements, but by the time we get to the end the model will be uniquely defined. This makes it easy to generalize the model by modifying only the more specific assumptions. 1. Cells came first, enzymes second, genes much later (Oparin). 2. A cell is an inert droplet containing a population of monomer units combined into polymer chains. 3. No death of cells. No Darwinian selection. Evolution by genetic drift. 4. Population changes by single substitution mutations. 5. Each of N monomers mutates with equal probability (1/N). 6. Monomers are either active (correct) or inactive (incorrect). 7. Active monomers are in sites where they catalyze correct placement of other monomers. Fig. 5.9 Assumptions of the Toy Model
Assumption 1 (Oparin Theory). Cells came first, enzymes second, genes much later. Assumption 2. A cell is an inert droplet containing a population of polymer molecules which are confined to the cell. The polymers are composed of monomer units which we may imagine to be similar to the amino-acids which make modern proteins. The polymers in the cell contain a fixed number N of monomers. In addition there is an external supply of free monomers which can diffuse in and out of the cell, and there is an external supply of energy which causes chemical reactions between polymers and monomers. Assumption 3. Cells do not die and do not interact with one another. There is no Darwinian selection. Evolution of the population of molecules within a cell proceeds by random drift.
84
Freeman J. Dyson
Assumption 4. Changes of population occur by discrete steps, each step consisting of a single substitution mutation. A mutation is a replacement of one monomer by another at one of the sites in a polymer. This assumption is unnecessarily restrictive and is imposed only for the sake of simplicity. At the cost of some complication of the mathematics, we could include a more realistic variety of chemical processes such as splitting and splicing of polymer chains or addition and subtraction of monomers. Assumption 5. At every step, each of the N sites in the polymer population mutates with equal probability (1/N). This assumption is also unrealistic and is made to keep the calculation simple. Assumption 6. In a given population of polymers, the bound monomers can be divided into two classes, active and inactive. This assumption appears to be uncontroversial, but it actually contains the essential simplification which makes the model mathematically tractable. It means that we are replacing the enormous multidimensional space of molecular configurations by a single Boolean variable taking only two values, one for “active” and zero for “inactive.” Assumption 7. The active monomers are in active sites where they contribute to the ability of a polymer to act as an enzyme. To act as an enzyme means to catalyze the mutation of other polymers in a selective manner, so that correct species of monomer is chosen preferentially to move into an active site. Assumption 8 (Fig. 5.10). In a cell with a fraction x of monomers active, the probability that the monomer inserted by a fresh mutation will be active is φ(x). The function φ(x) represents the efficiency of the existing population of catalysts in promoting the formation of a new catalyst. The assumption that φ(x) depends on x means that the activity of catalysts is to some extent inherited from the parent population to the newly mutated daughter. The form of φ(x) expresses the law of inheritance from parent to daughter. The numerical value of φ(x) will be determined by the details of the chemistry of the catalysts. Assumption 8 Mean-field approximation. In a cell with a fraction x of units active, the probability of a mutated unit being active is φ(x). This reduces the multi-dimensional random walk of the molecular populations to the one-dimensional random walk of the single parameter x. Assumption 9 Triple-crossing assumption. The curve y = φ(x) is S -shaped, crossing the line y = x at three points x = α, x = β, x = γ, between 0 and 1. Fig. 5.10
5 Origins of Life
85
Assumption 8 is a drastic approximation. It replaces the average of the efficiencies of a population of catalysts by the efficiency of an average catalyst. I call it the “mean field approximation” since it is analogous to the approximation made in the Curie-Weiss mean-field model of a ferromagnet. In physics, we know that the mean-field approximation gives a good qualitative account of the behavior of a ferromagnet. In population biology, similar approximations have been made by Kimura. The effect of the mean-field approximation is to reduce the multidimensional random walk of molecular populations to a one-dimensional random walk of the single parameter x. Both in physics and in population biology, the mean-field approximation may be described as pessimistic. It underestimates the effectiveness of local groupings of molecules in forming an ordered state. The mean-field approximation generally predicts a lower degree of order than is found in an exact theory. Assumption 9 (Fig. 5.11). The curve y = φ(x) is S -shaped, crossing the line
Fig. 5.11 The S -shaped Curve
y = x at three points x = α, β, γ between zero and one. This assumption is again borrowed from the Curie-Weiss model of a ferromagnet. It means that the population of molecules has three possible equilibrium states. An equilibrium state occurs whenever φ(x) = x, since the law of inheritance then gives a daughter population with the same average activity x as the parent population. The equilibrium is stable if the slope of the curve y = φ(x) is less than unity, unstable if the slope is greater than unity. Consider for example the lowest equilibrium state x = α. I call it the disordered state because it has the smallest average activity. Since φ (α) < 1, the equilibrium is stable. If a parent population has average activity x a little above α, the daughter population will tend to slide back down toward α. If the parent popu-
86
Freeman J. Dyson
lation has x a little below α the daughter population will tend to slide up toward α. The same thing happens at the upper equilibrium state x = γ. The upper state is also stable since φ (γ) < 1. I call it the ordered state because it has the largest catalytic activity. A population with activity x close to γ will move closer to γ as it evolves. But the middle equilibrium point x = β is unstable since φ (β) > 1. If a population has x slightly larger than β, it will evolve away from β toward the ordered state x = γ, and if it has x slightly smaller than β it will slide away from β down to the disordered state x = α. The equilibrium at x = β is an unstable saddle-point. We have here a situation analogous to the distinction between life and death in biological systems. I call the ordered state of a cell “alive,” since it has most of the molecules working together in a collaborative fashion to maintain the catalytic cycles which keep them active. I call the disordered state “dead” since it has the molecules uncoordinated and mostly inactive. A population, either in the dead or in the alive state, will generally stay there for a long time, making only small random fluctuations around the stable equilibrium. However, the population of molecules in a cell is finite, and there is always the possibility of a large statistical fluctuation which takes the whole population together over the saddle-point from one stable equilibrium to the other. When a “live” cell makes the big statistical jump over the saddle-point to the lower state, we call the jump “death.” When a “dead” cell makes the jump up over the saddle-point to the upper state, we call the jump “origin of life.” When once the function φ(x) and the size N of the population in the cell are given, the probabilities of “death” and of the “origin of life” can easily be calculated. We have only to solve a linear difference equation with the appropriate boundary conditions to represent an ensemble of populations of molecules diffusing over the saddle-point from one side or the other. Assumption 10 (Fig. 5.12). Here we make a definite choice for the function φ(x), basing the choice on a simple thermodynamic argument. It will turn out happily that the function φ(x) derived from thermodynamics has the desired S -shaped form to produce the three equilibrium states required by Assumption 9. Thermodynamics. Assume every perfect catalyst lowers activation-energy for correct placement of a newly-placed unit by U. In a population with fraction x of units active, each catalyst is assumed to lower activation-energy by xU. This implies 1 φ(x) = , (5.1) 1 + ab−x (1 + a) is the number of species of monomer, b = exp(U/kT ) is the discrimination factor of catalysts. Fig. 5.12 Assumption 10
We assume that every catalyst in the cell works by producing a difference between the activation energies required for placing an active or inactive monomer into a mutating molecule. If the catalyst molecule is perfect, with all its monomer
5 Origins of Life
87
units active, then the difference in activation energies will be a certain quantity U which we assume to be the same for all perfect catalysts. If a catalyst is imperfect, in a cell with a fraction x of all monomer units active, we assume that it produces a difference xU in the activation energies for correct and incorrect mutations. We are here again making a mean-field approximation, assuming that the average effect of a collection of catalysts with various degrees of imperfection is equal to the effect of a single catalyst with its discrimination reduced by the average activity x of the whole population. This is another approximation which could be avoided in a more exact calculation. We assume that the monomers belong to (1 + a) equally abundant species. This means that there is one right choice and a wrong choices for the monomer to be inserted in each mutation. The effect of the catalysts is to reduce the activation energy for the right choice by xU below the activation energy for a wrong choice. Thus the probability of a right choice is increased over the probability of each wrong choice by the factor bx (4.1) where b = exp (U/kT )
(4.2)
is the discrimination factor of a perfect catalyst at absolute temperature T , and k is Boltzmann’s constant. We have a wrong choices with statistical weight unity compared to one right choice with statistical weight b x . The function φ(x) is the probability of a right choice at each mutation, and therefore φ(x) =
1 1 + ab−x
(4.3)
the same S -shaped function which appears in the mean-field model of a simple ferromagnet. The formula (4.3) for φ(x) completes the definition of the model. It is uniquely defined once the three parameters N, a, b are chosen. The three parameters summarize in a simple fashion the chemical raw material with which the model is working. N defines the size of the molecular population, a defines the chemical diversity of the monomer units, and b is the quality-factor defining the degree of discrimination of the catalysts. We have now a definite three-parameter model to work with. It remains to calculate its consequences, and to examine whether it shows interesting behavior for any values of N, a, b which are consistent with the facts of organic chemistry. “Interesting behavior” here means the occurrence with reasonable probability of a jump from the disordered to the ordered state. We shall find that interesting behavior occurs for values of a and b lying in a narrow range. This narrow range is determined only by the mathematical properties of the exponential function, and is independent of all physical or chemical constants. The model therefore makes a definite statement about the stuff out of which the first living cells were made. If the model has anything to do with reality, then the primaeval cells were composed of molecules having values of a and b within the calculated range.
88
Freeman J. Dyson
It turns out that the preferred ranges of values of the three parameters are Fig. 5.13: a from 8 to 10, b from 60 to 100,
(4.4) (4.5)
N from 2000 to 20000.
(4.6)
For good behavior of model. Transition from disorder to order possible with reasonable probability. 8 ≤ a ≤ 10 60 ≤ b ≤ 100 2000 ≤ N ≤ 20000 Fig. 5.13 Range of a, b, N
These ranges also happen to be reasonable from the point of view of chemistry. (4.4) says that the number of species of monomer should be in the range from 9 to 11. In modern proteins we have 20 species of amino-acids. It is reasonable to imagine that about 10 of them would provide enough diversity of protein function to get life started. On the other hand, the model definitely fails to work with a = 3, which would be the required value of a if life had begun with four species of nucleotides polymerizing to make RNA. Nucleotides alone do not provide enough chemical diversity to allow a transition from disorder to order in this model. The quantitative predictions of the model are thus consistent with the Oparin theory from which we started. The model decisively prefers protein to nucleic acid as the stuff from which life arose. The range (4.5) from 60 to 100 is also reasonable for the discrimination factor of primitive enzymes. A modern polymerase enzyme typically has a discrimination factor of 5000 or 10000. The modern enzyme is a highly specialized structure perfected by three billion years of fine-tuning. It is not to be expected that the original enzymes would have come close to modern standards of performance. On the other hand, simple inorganic catalysts frequently achieve discrimination factors of 50. It is plausible that a simple peptide catalyst with an active site containing four or five amino-acids would have a discrimination factor in the range preferred by the model, from 60 to 100. The size (4.6) of the population in the primitive cell is also plausible. A population of several thousand monomers linked into a few hundred polymers would give a sufficient variety of structures to allow interesting catalytic cycles to exist. A value of N of the order of 10000 is large enough to display the chemical complexity characteristic of life, and still small enough to allow the statistical jump from disorder to order to occur on rare occasions with probabilities which are not impossibly small. The basic reason for the success of the model is its ability to tolerate high errorrates. It overcomes the error catastrophe by abandoning exact replication. It neither
5 Origins of Life
89
needs nor achieves precise control of its molecular structures. It is this lack of precision which allows a population of 10000 monomers to jump into an ordered state without invoking a miracle. In a model of the origin of life which assumes exact replication from the beginning, with a low tolerance of errors, a jump of a population of N monomers from disorder to order will occur with probability of the order of (1 + a)−N . If we exclude miracles, a replicating system can arise spontaneously only with N of the order of 100 or less. In contrast, our nonreplicating model can make the transition to order with a population a hundred times larger. The error-rate in the ordered state of our model is typically between twenty and thirty percent when the parameters a and b are in the ranges (4.4), (4.5). An error-rate of 25% means that three out of four of the monomers in each polymer are correctly placed. A catalyst with five monomers in its active site has one chance out of four of being completely functional. Such a level of performance is tolerable for a non-replicating system, but would be totally unacceptable in a replicating system. The ability to function with a 25% error-rate is the decisive factor which makes the ordered state in our model statistically accessible, with populations large enough to be biologically interesting.
V. Consequences of the Model
Time required for transition from disorder to order T = τ exp(ΔN) τ =mutation time per site N =population of monomers Δ = U(β) − U(α) Time available for transition: 1010 cells for 105 mutation-times, so T/τ ≤ 1015 Maximum population for transition Nc ∼
30 Δ
(within a factor of 3) Fig. 5.14 Critical Populations
I will not describe in this lecture the mathematical details of the model. The main result of the mathematical analysis is a formula (Fig. 5.14) T = τ exp(ΔN),
(5.1)
90
Freeman J. Dyson
for the time T required on the average for a cell to make the transition from disorder to order. Here τ is the average time-interval between mutations at each site, N is the total number of monomers, and Δ is a number which we can calculate, depending only on the parameters a and b. If Δ were of the order of unity, then the exponential in (5.1) would be impossibly large for N greater than 100. We would then be in the situation characteristic of error-intolerant systems, for which the transition to order is astronomically improbable for large N. However, when the parameters a and b are in the ranges (4.4) (4.5), which correspond to models with high error-tolerance, it turns out that Δ is not of the order of unity but lies in the range from 0.001 to 0.015. This is the feature of the model which makes transition to order possible with populations as large as 20000. Although (5.2) is still an exponentially increasing function of N, it increases much more slowly than one would naively expect. According to (5.1) there is a critical population-size Nc such that populations N of the order of Nc or smaller will make the disorder-to-order transition with reasonable probability, whereas populations much greater than Nc will not. I choose to define Nc by 30 (5.2) Nc = , Δ so that the exponential factor in (5.1) is e30 ∼ 1013
for
N = Nc
(5.3)
The coefficient 30 in (5.2) is chosen arbitrarily. We do not know how many droplets might have existed in environments suitable for the origin of life, nor how long such environments lasted, nor how frequently their molecular constituents mutated. The choice (5.2) means that we could expect one transition to the ordered state to occur in a thousand mutationtimes among a collection of 1010 droplets each containing Nc monomers. It is not absurd to imagine that 1010 droplets may have existed for a suitably long time in an appropriate environment. On the other hand, if we considered droplets with molecular populations three times larger, that is to say with N = 3Nc , then the exponential factor in (5.1) would be 1039 , and it is inconceivable that enough droplets could have existed to give a reasonable probability of a transition. The critical population Nc thus defines the upper limit of N for which transition can occur, with a margin of uncertainty which is less than a factor of three. The critical population-sizes given by (5.2) range from 2000 to 20000 when the parameters a and b lie in the ranges 8 to 10 and 60 to 100 respectively. The properties of our model can be conveniently represented in a two-dimensional diagram Fig. 5.15 with the parameter a horizontal and the parameter b vertical. Each point on the diagram corresponds to a particular choice of a and b. Models which satisfy the triple-crossing condition (assumption 9) and possess disordered and ordered states occupy the central region of the diagram, extending up and to the right from the cusp. The cusp at a = e2 = 7.4,
b = e4 = 54.6,
(5.4)
5 Origins of Life
91
Fig. 5.15 Variety of Models
marks the lower bound of the values of a and b for which a disorder-order transition can occur. The critical population-size Nc is large near to the cusp and decreases rapidly as a and b increase. The biologically interesting models are to be found in the part of the central region close to the cusp. These are the models which have high error-rates and can make the disorder-order transition with large populations. To illustrate the behavior of the model in the interesting region near to the cusp, I pick out one particular case which has the advantage of being easy to calculate exactly. This is the case Fig. 5.16 a = 8,
b = 64,
(5.5)
which has the three equilibrium states 1 α= , 3
1 β= , 2
2 γ= . 3
(5.6)
The error-rate in the ordered state is exactly one-third. The value of Δ for this model turns out to be Δ = log 3 − (19/12) log2 = 0.001129, (5.7) which gives a satisfactorily large critical population-size Nc = 26566.
(5.8)
92
Freeman J. Dyson a = 8,
b = 64.
This case is easy to solve exactly. Symmetrical because b = a2 . Three equilibrium states: 1 1 2 α= , β= , γ= . 3 2 3 Error-rate 1/3 in ordered state. Δ = log 3 −
19 log 2 = 0.001129, 12
equal to difference between perfect fifth and equi-tempered fifth in musical scale. Critical population size Nc = 26566. Fig. 5.16 Special Case of Model
My friend Christopher Longuet-Higgins, who happens to be a musician as well as a chemist, pointed out that the quantity Δ appearing in (5.7) is well-known to musicians as the fractional difference in pitch between a perfect fifth and an equitempered fifth. On a logarithmic scale of pitch, a perfect fifth is (log 3 − log 2) and an equi-tempered fifth is seven semitones or (7/12) log2. The smallness of the difference is the reason why the equi-tempered scale works as well as it does. The smallness of Δ is also the reason why this model of the origin of life worked as well as it does. Old Pythagoras would be pleased if he could see this example, justifying his doctrine of a universal harmony which embraces number, music and science. After this digression into Pythagorean mysticism I return to the general properties of the model shown in Fig. 5.15. The region below and to the right of the central strip represents models which have only a disordered state and no ordered state. These models have a too large (too much chemical diversity) and b too small (too weak catalytic activity) to produce an ordered state. Droplets in this region are dead and cannot come to life. I call the region “Cold Chicken Soup” because this phrase has been used to describe the composition of the Earth’s ocean in prebiotic times. The region above and to the left of the central strip represents models which have only an ordered state and no disordered state. These models have a too small (too little chemical diversity) and b too large (too strong catalytic activity) to produce a disordered state. Droplets in this region are frozen into the ordered state and cannot die. I call the region “Garden of Eden” because this phrase has been used to describe an alternative theory of the origin of life. It is possible to imagine cells evolving by random accretion of molecular components so that they drift into the central transition region either from the cold chicken soup or from the Garden of Eden. Once they reach the central region, they are capable of both life and death, and the evolution of biological complexity can begin. One striking feature of our model which is absent in modern organisms is the symmetry between life and death. In the model, the curve
5 Origins of Life
93
y = φ(x) = [1 + ab−x]−1
(5.9)
is invariant under the transformation x → 1 − x,
y → 1 − y,
a → (b/a)
(5.10)
In particular, the model with b = a2 has complete symmetry about the unstable saddle-point at x = y = 1/2. The ordered state and the disordered state are mirrorimages of each other. The probability of a transition from disorder to order is exactly equal to the probability of a transition from order to disorder. In the symmetrical model with b = a2 , death and resurrection occur with equal frequency. The origin of life is as commonplace an event as death. How did it happen that, as life evolved, death continued to be commonplace while resurrection became rare? What happened was that the catalytic processes in the cell became increasingly fine-tuned and increasingly intolerant of error. The curve y = φ(x) remained S -shaped but became more and more unsymmetrical as time went on. The shape of the curve in a modern cell is shown in Fig. 5.17, to be
Fig. 5.17 Application to Modern Cell
contrasted with the symmetrical curve in our hypothetical primitive cell shown in Fig. 5.11. In the primitive cell the three equilibrium states might have been α = 0.2,
β = 0.5,
γ = 0.8,
(5.11)
with an error-rate of 20% in the ordered state. In the modern cell the curve is pushed over far to the right and the equilibrium states are typically
94
Freeman J. Dyson
α = 0.05,
β = 0.999,
γ = 0.9999.
(5.12)
This position of the ordered state γ means that the error-rate in the metabolic apparatus of a modern cell is about 10−4 . The position of the saddle-point β means that an environmental insult such as a dose of X-rays which increases the error-rate to 10−3 will disrupt the fine-tuned apparatus and cause the cell to die. Death is easy and resurrection is difficult, because the saddle-point has moved so close to the ordered state and so far from the disordered state. For life to originate spontaneously it was essential to have an ordered state with a high error-rate, but when life was once established the whole course of evolution was toward more specialized structures with lower tolerance of errors. I have said enough, or perhaps too much, about the properties and the consequences of my model. You may have noticed that in talking about the model I have fallen into a trap. I have fallen in love with my model. I begin to talk about it as if it were historic truth. It is of course nothing of the kind. It is not a description of events as they really happened. It is only a toy model, a simple abstract picture which will rapidly be superseded by better models incorporating some of the chemical details which I have ignored.
VI. Questions and Implications
1. Were the first creatures made of proteins or nucleic acids or a mixture of both? 2. When did random genetic drift give way to natural selection? 3. Does the model contradict the Central Dogma of molecular biology? 4. How did nucleic acids originate? 5. How did the modern genetic apparatus evolve? 6. How late was the latest common ancestor of all living species? 7. Can we find a concrete realization of the model, for example a population of 2000 amino-acids in polypeptides which can catalyze each other’s synthesis with 80% accuracy? 8. Can such a population maintain itself in homeostatic equilibrium? Fig. 5.18 Questions
I have drawn up a list of questions suggested by my model (Fig. 5.18). These questions refer not to the model itself but to the implications of the model for the subsequent course of biological evolution. I will comment briefly on each question in turn. After another twenty years of progress in biological research we may perhaps know whether my tentative answers are correct. 1. Were the first living creatures composed of proteins or nucleic acids or a mixture of the two? This is the central question in all our thinking about the origin of life. I have already stated my reasons for preferring proteins. I prefer proteins, partly because my
5 Origins of Life
95
model works well with ten species of monomer and works badly with four species, partly because amino-acids fit better than nucleotides the requirements of pre-biotic chemistry, and partly because I am attracted by the Margulis vision of parasitism as a driving force of early evolution and I like to put nucleic acids into the role of primaeval parasites. None of these reasons is scientifically compelling. The question can be answered, in the end, only by chemical experiment and paleontological observation. 2. At what stage did random genetic drift give way to natural selection? The model has life originating by neutral evolution according to the ideas of Kimura. A population crosses the saddle-point to the ordered state by random genetic drift. The model does not allow natural selection to operate, because it does not allow the island populations to grow or to reproduce. So long as there is no birth and death of cells, there can be no natural selection. However, once a cell has reached the ordered state as defined in the model, it can go beyond the model and pass into a new phase of evolution by assimilating fresh monomers from its environment. A cell which increases its population N by assimilation will quickly become stabilized against reversion to the disordered state, since the life-time of the ordered state increases exponentially with N. It can then continue to grow until some physical disturbance causes it to divide. If it divides into two cells, there is a good chance that both daughter populations contain a sufficient assortment of catalysts to remain in the ordered state. The processes of growth and division can continue until the cells begin to exhaust the supply of nutrient monomers. When the monomers are in short supply, some cells will lose their substance and die. From that point on, evolution will be driven by natural selection. 3. Does the model contradict the Central Dogma of molecular biology? The Central Dogma says that genetic information is carried only by nucleic acids and not by proteins. The dogma is true for all contemporary organisms, with the possible exception of the parasites responsible for scrapie and kuru and a few other diseases of the central nervous system of humans and other mammals. Whether or not the scrapie parasite turns out to be a true exception to the dogma, my model implies that the dogma was untrue for the earliest forms of life. According to the model, the first cells passed genetic information to their offspring in the form of enzymes which were probably proteins. There is no logical reason why a population of enzymes mutually catalyzing each other’s synthesis should not serve as a carrier of genetic information. 4. How did nucleic acids originate? I remarked earlier on the curious fact that nucleic acids are chemical cousins to the ATP molecule which is the chief energy-carrier in the metabolism of modern cells. I like to use this fact to explain the origin of nucleic acids as a disease arising in some primitive cell from a surfeit of ATP. The Margulis picture of evolution converts the nucleic acids from their original status as indigestible by-products of ATP metabolism to disease agents, from disease agents to parasites, from parasites to symbionts, and finally from symbionts to fully integrated organs of the cell. 5. How did the modern genetic apparatus evolve?
96
Freeman J. Dyson
The modern genetic apparatus is enormously fine-tuned and must have evolved over a long period of time from simpler beginnings. Perhaps some clues to its earlier history will be found when the structure of the modern ribosome is explored and understood in detail. The following sequence of steps (Fig. 5.19) is a possible pathway to the modern genetic apparatus, beginning from a cell which has RNA established as a self-reproducing cellular parasite but not yet performing a genetic function for the cell, (a) Non-specific binding of RNA to free amino-acids, activating them for easier polymerization, (b) Specific binding of RNA to catalytic sites to give them structural precision, (c) RNA bound to amino-acids becomes transfer RNA. (d) RNA bound to catalytic sites becomes ribosomal RNA. (e) Catalytic sites evolve from special-purpose to general-purpose by using transfer RNA instead of amino-acids for recognition, (f) Recognition unit splits off from ribosomal RNA and becomes messenger RNA. (g) Ribosomal structure becomes unique as the genetic code takes over the function of recognition. This is only one of many possible pathways which might have led to the evolution of the genetic code. The essential point is that all such pathways appear to be long and tortuous. In my opinion, both the metabolic machinery of proteins and the parasitic selfreplication of nucleic acids must have been in place, before the evolution of the elaborate translation apparatus linking the two systems could begin. Origin of modern genetic apparatus. Possible pathway. 1. Nucleotides couple to amino-acids to make them more reactive (Katchalsky) 2. Nucleotides couple to catalysts to give them more precise structure 3. Nucleotides coupled to amino-acids grow into transfer RNA 4. Nucleotides coupled to catalysts grow into ribosomal RNA 5. Transfer RNA becomes specific to particular amino-acids (beginning of code) 6. Catalysts use transfer RNA instead of amino-acids for recognition 7. Catalysts become general-purpose with a supply of alternative recognition sequences 8. Recognition sequences split off and become messenger RNA, leaving the ribosome as a general-purpose catalyst with unique structure. Fig. 5.19 Questions
6. How late was the latest common ancestor of all living species? The universality of the genetic code suggests that the latest common ancestor of all living creatures already possessed a complete genetic apparatus of the modern type. The geological record tells us that cells existed very early, as long as 3 eons ago. It is generally assumed that the earliest cells which are preserved as microfossils already possessed a modern genetic apparatus, but this assumption is not based on concrete evidence. If the Oparin theory of the origin of life is true, cells came before enzymes and enzymes before genes. It is possible that the evolution of the modern genetic apparatus, as described in the discussion of questions 4 and 5, took eons to complete. The ancient microfossils may date from a time before there
5 Origins of Life
97
were genes and ribosomes. The pace of evolution may have accelerated after the genetic code was established, allowing the development from ancestral procaryote to eucaryotic cells and multicellular organisms to be completed in less time than it took to go from primitive cell to ancestral procaryote. It is therefore possible that the latest common ancestor came late in the history of life, perhaps as late as half-way from the beginning. 7. Does there exist a chemical realization of my model, for example a population of a few thousand amino-acids forming an association of polypeptides which can catalyze each other’s synthesis with 80 percent accuracy? Can such an association of molecules be confined in a droplet and supplied with energy and raw materials in such a way as to maintain itself in a stable homeostatic equilibrium? These are the crucial questions which only experiment can answer. But before embarking on experiments, it would be wise to explore the territory by studying computer models of molecular populations with realistic chemical reaction-rates. Computer simulations could tell us which chemicals to use in a droplet experiment with some hope of success. Computer simulations are not only cheaper and quicker than real experiments. They are also easier to interpret. The understanding of the origin of life will require a collaboration of many techniques, computer simulations of hypothetical primitive cells, molecular analyses of modern cellular structures, and experiments with chemical populations in real droplets. Each of these techniques will point the way for the others to make progress. Our quest for understanding is based solidly on the work of our distinguished predecessors, Oparin, Schr¨odinger, Eigen, Orgel, Margulis and Kimura. We have made a good beginning, even if the end is not yet in sight. In conclusion I would like to ask one more question. What will happen to my little toy model when the problem of the origin of life is finally solved? This question was answered nearly two hundred years ago by my favorite poet, William Blake : “To be an Error and to be Cast out is a part of God’s design.”
Fig. 5.20 Lecture room at University of Tokyo with Professor Freeman Dyson and Professor Ryogo Kubo in 1984
6
The Computing Machines in the Future Richard P. Feynman
Abstract This address was presented by Richard P. Feynman as the Nishina Memorial Lecture at Gakushuin University (Tokyo), on August 9, 1985.
It’s a great pleasure and an honor to be here as a speaker in memorial for a scientist that I have respected and admired as much as Prof. Nishina. To come to Japan and talk about computers is like giving a sermon to Buddha. But I have been thinking about computers and this is the only subject I could think of when invited to talk. The first thing I would like to say is what I am not going to talk about. I want to talk about the future computing machines. But the most important possible developments in the future, are things that I will not speak about. For exam- Richard P. Feynman ple, there is a great deal of work to try to develop smarter NMF c machines, machines which have a better relationship with the humans so that input and output can be made with less effort than the complex programming that’s necessary today. This goes under the name often of artificial intelligence, but I don’t like that name. Perhaps the unintelligent machines can do even better than the intelligent ones. Another problem is the standardization of programming languages. There are too many languages today, and it would be a good idea to choose just one. (I hesitate to mention that in Japan, for what will happen will be that there will simply be more standard languages; you already have four ways of writing now and attempts to standardize anything here result apparently in more standards and not fewer.) Another interesting future Richard P. Feynman (1918 – 1988). Nobel Laureate in Physics (1965) California Institute of Technology (USA) at the time of this address R. P. Feynman: The Computing Machines in the Future, Lect. Notes Phys. 746, 99–113 (2008) c Nishina Memorial Foundation 2008 DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-77056-5 6
100
Richard P. Feynman
problem that is worth working on but I will not talk about, is automatic debugging programs; debugging means to fix errors in a program or in a machine. It is surprisingly difficult to debug programs as they get more complicated. Another direction of improvement is to make physical machines three dimensional instead of all on a surface of a chip. That can be done in stages instead of all at once; you can have several layers and then many more layers as the time goes on. Another important device would be a way of detecting automatically defective elements on a chip, then this chip itself automatically rewiring itself so as to avoid the defective elements. At the present time when we try to make big chips there are flaws, bad spots in the chips, and we throw the whole chip away. But of course if we could make it so that we could use the part of the chip that was effective, it would be much more efficient. I mention these things to try to tell you that I am aware of what the real problems are for future machines. But what I want to talk about is simple, just some small technical, physically good things that can be done in principle according to the physical laws; I would like in other words to discuss the machinery and not the way we use the machines. I will talk about some technical possibilities for making machines. There will be three topics really. One is parallel processing machines which is something of the very near future, almost present, that is being developed now. Further in the future are questions of the energy consumption of machines which seems at the moment to be a limitation, but really isn’t. Finally I will talk about the size; it is always better to make the machines smaller, and the question is how much smaller is it still possible to make machines according to the laws of Nature, in principle. I will not discuss which and what of these things will actually appear in the future. That depends on economic problems and social problems and I am not going to try to guess at those.
1. Parallel Computers First about parallel programming, parallel computers, rather. Almost all the present computers, conventional computers, work on a layout or an architecture invented by von Neumann, in which there is a very large memory that stores all the information, and one central location that does simple calculations. We take a number from this place in the memory and a number from that place in the memory, send the two to the central arithmetical unit to add them and then send the answer to some other place in the memory. There is, therefore, effectively one central processor which is working very very fast and very hard while the whole memory sits out there like a vast filing cabinet of cards which are very rarely used. It is obvious that if there were more processors working at the same time we ought to be able to do calculations faster. But the problem is that some one who might be using one processor may be using some information from the memory that another one needs, and it gets very confusing. And so it has been said that it is very difficult to work many processors in parallel. Some steps in that direction have been taken in the larger conventional machines, what they call “vector processors”. When sometimes you want to do ex-
6 The Computing Machines in the Future
101
actly the same step on many different items you can do that perhaps at the same time. The ordinary hope is that the regular program can be written, and then an interpreter will discover automatically when it is useful to use this vector possibility. That idea is used in the Cray and in the super-computers in Japan. Another plan is to take what is effectively a large number of relatively simple (but not very simple) computers, and connect them all together in some pattern. Then they can all work on a part of the problem. Each one is really an independent computer, and they will transfer information to each other as one or another needs it. This kind of a scheme is in a machine for example called Cosmic Cube, and is one of the possibilities; many people are making such machines. Another plan is to distribute very large numbers of very simple central processors all over the memory. Each one deals with just a small part of the memory and there is an elaborate system of interconnections between them. An example of such a machine is the Connection Machine made at M.I.T. It has 64,000 processors and a system of routing in which every 16 can talk to any other 16 and thus 4000 routing connection possibilities. It would appear that scientific questions like the propagation of waves in some material might be very easily handled by parallel processing, because what happens in this part of space at a moment can be worked out locally and only the pressures and the stresses from the neighbor needs to be known for each section can be worked out at the same time, and communicate boundary conditions across. That’s why this type of design is built for such a thing. But it has turned out that very large number of problems of all kinds can be dealt with in parallel. As long as the problem is big enough so that a lot of calculating has to be done, it turns out that a parallel computation can speed this up enormously, not just scientific problems. And what happened to the prejudice of 2 years ago, which was that the parallel programming is difficult? It turns out that what was difficult, and almost impossible, is to take an ordinary program and automatically figure out how to use the parallel computation effectively on that program. Instead, one must start all over again with the problem, appreciating that we have parallel possibility of calculation, and rewrite the program completely with a new attitude to what is inside the machine. It is not possible to effectively use the old programs. They must be rewritten. That is a great disadvantage to most industrial applications and has met with considerable resistance. But, the big programs belong usually to scientists or others, unofficial intelligent programmers who love computer science and are willing to start all over again and rewrite the program if they can make it more efficient. so what’s going to happen is that the hard programs, vast big ones, will first be programmed by experts in the new way, and then gradually everybody will have to come around, and more and more programs will be programmed that way, and programmers will just have to learn how to do it.
102
Richard P. Feynman
2. Reducing the Energy Loss The second topic I want to talk about is energy loss in computers. The fact that they must be cooled is the limitation apparently to the largest computers; a good deal of the effect is spent in cooling machine. I would like to explain that this is simply a result of very poor engineering and is nothing fundamental at all. Inside the computer a bit of information is controlled by a wire which either has a voltage of one value or another value. It is called “one bit”, and we have to change the voltage of the wire from one value to the other and have to put change on or take charge off. I make an analogy with water: we have to fill a vessel with water and get one level or to empty it to get to the other level. It’s just an analogy. If you like electricity better you can think more accurately electrically. What we do now is analogous, in the water case, to filling the vessel by pouring water in from a top level (Fig. 6.1), and lowering the level by opening the valve at the bottom and letting it all run out. In both cases there is a loss of energy because of the drop of the water, suddenly, through a height say from top level where it comes in to the low bottom level when you start pouring it in to fill it up again. In the cases of voltage and charge, there occurs the same thing. It’s like, as Mr. Bennett has explained, operating an automobile which has to start and stop by turning on the engine and putting on the brakes, turning on the engine and putting on the brakes; each time you lose power. Another way with a car would be to connect the wheels to flywheels. Stop the car and speed up the flywheel saving the energy, which can then be reconnected to start the car again. The analogy electrically or in the water would be to have a U-shaped tube with a valve at the bottom in the center connecting the two arms of the U (Fig. 6.2). When it is full here on the right but empty on the left with the valve closed, if we open that valve the water will slip out to the other side, and we close it just in time to catch it. Then when we want to go the other way we open the valve again and it slips to the other side and we catch it. There is some loss and it doesn’t climb as high as it did before, but all we have to do is to put a little water in to correct the little loss, a much smaller
Fig. 6.1
6 The Computing Machines in the Future
103
Fig. 6.3 Fig. 6.2
energy loss than the direct fill method. But such a thing uses the inertia of the water and the analogue in the electricity, is inductance. However it is very difficult with the silicon transistors that we use today to make up inductance on the chips. So this is not particularly practical with the present technology. Another way would be to fill the tank by a supply which stays only a little bit above the level lifting the water supply in time as we fill it up (Fig. 6.3), because then the dropping of water is always small during the entire effort. In the same way, we could use an outlet to lower it but just taking off the top and lowering the tube, so that the heat loss would not appear at the position of the transistor, or would be small; it will depend on how high the distance is between the supply and the surface as we fill it up. This method corresponds to changing the voltage supply with time (Fig. 6.4). So if we would use a time varying voltage supply, we could use this
Fig. 6.4
104
Richard P. Feynman
method. Of course, there is energy loss in the voltage supply, but that is all located in one place, that is simple, and there we can make one big inductance. This scheme is called “hot clocking”, because the voltage supply operates also as the clock which times everything. And don’t need an extra clock signal to time the circuits as we do in conventional designs. Both of these last two devices use less energy if they go slower. If try to move the water supply level too fast, the water in the tube doesn’t keep up with it and I have a big drop. So to work I must go slowly. Again. the U-tube scheme will not work unless that central valve can open and close faster than the time it takes for the water in the U-tube to slip back and forth. So my devices are slower. I’ve saved an energy loss but I’ve made the devices slower. The energy loss multiplied by the time it takes for the circuit to operate is constant. But nevertheless, this turns out to be very practical because the clock time is usually much larger than the circuit time for the transistors, and we can use that to decrease the energy. Also if we went, let us say, three times slower with our calculations, we could use one third the energy over three times the time, which is nine times less power that has to be dissipated. Maybe it is worth it. Maybe by redesigning using parallel computations or other devices, we can spend a little longer than we could do at maximum circuit speed, in order to make a larger machine that is practical and from which we could still get the energy out. For a transistor, the energy loss multiplied by the time it takes to operate is a product of several factors (Fig. 6.5): (1) the thermal energy proportional to temperature, kT; (2) the length of the transistor between source √ and drain, divided by the velocity of the electrons inside (the thermal velocity 3kT/m); (3) the length of the transistor in units of the mean free path for collisions of electrons in the transistor; and finally (4) the total number of the electrons that are inside the transistor when it operates. All of these numbers come out to tell us that the energy used in the transistor today is somewhere around a billion or ten billions or more times the thermal energy kT. When it switches we use that much energy. It is very large amount of
Fig. 6.5
6 The Computing Machines in the Future
105
energy. It is obviously a good idea to decrease the size of the transistor. We decrease the length between source and drain, and we can decrease the number of the electrons, and use much less energy. It also turns out that a smaller transistor is much faster, because the electrons can cross it and make their decisions to switch faster. For every reason, it is a good idea to make the transistor smaller, and everybody is always trying to do that. But suppose we come to a circumstance in which the mean free path is longer than the size of the transistor, then we discover that the transistor doesn’t work right any more. It does not behave the way we expected. This reminds me, years ago there was something called the sound barrier. Airplanes cannot go faster than the speed of sound because, if you design them normally and try to put them in that speed, the propeller wouldn’t work and the wings don’t lift and nothing works correctly. Nevertheless, airplanes can go faster than the speed of sound. You just have to know what the right laws are under the right circumstances, and design the device with the correct laws. You cannot expect old designs to work in new circumstances. But new designs can work in new circumstances, and I assert that it is perfectly possible to make transistor systems, that is, that is to say more correctly, switching systems, computing devices in which the dimensions are smaller than the mean free path. I speak of course in principle and I am not speaking about actual manufacture. Therefore, let us discuss what happens if we try to make the devices as small as possible.
3. Reducing the Size So, my third topic is the size of computing elements and now I speak entirely theoretically. The first thing that you would worry about when things get very small, is Brownian motion; everything is shaking and nothing stays in place, and how can you control the circuits then? And if the circuits did work, it has a chance of accidentally jumping back. But, if we use two volts for the energy of this electric system which is what we ordinarily use, that is eighty times the thermal energy (kT = 1/40 volt) and the chance that something jumps backward against 80 times thermal energy is e, the base of the natural logarithm, to minus eighty power, or 10−43 . What does that mean? If we had a billion transistors in a computer (which we don’t have, we don’t have that many at all), working all of them 1010 times a second, that is, tenth of a nanosecond switching perpetually, operating for 109 seconds, which is 30 years, the total number of switching operations in that machine is 1028 and the chance of one of them going backward is only 10−43 ; there will be no error produced by thermal oscillations whatsoever in 30 years. If you don’t like that, use 2.5 volts and then it gets smaller. Long before that, the real failure will come when a cosmic ray accidentally goes through the transistor, and we don’t have to be more perfect than that. However, much more is in fact possible and I would like to refer you to an article in a most recent Scientific American by Bennett and Landauer. It is possible to make
106
Richard P. Feynman
a computer in which each element, each transistor, can go forward and accidentally reverse and still the computer will operate. All the operation in succession in the computer go forward or backward. The computation proceeds for a while this way and then it undoes itself, uncalculates, and then goes forward again and so on. If we just pull it along a little, we can make it go through and finish the calculation by making it just a little bit more likely that it goes forward than backward. It is known that all the computations can be made by putting together some simple elements like transistors; or, if we be more logically abstract, a thing for instance called NAND gate (NAND means NOT-AND). It has two “wires” in and one out (Fig. 6.6). Forget the NOT first. What is AND? AND is: The output is 1 only if
Fig. 6.6
both input wires are 1, otherwise the output is 0. NOT-AND means the opposite. The output wire reads 1 (i.e. has the voltage level corresponding to 1) unless both input wires read 1, if both input wires read 1 then the output wire reads 0 (i.e. has the voltage level corresponding to 0). Here is a little table of inputs and outputs. A and B are inputs and C is the output. Unless A and B are both 1, the output is 1 otherwise 0. But such a device is irreversible. Information is lost. If I only know the output, I cannot recover the input. The device can’t be expected to flip forward and then come back and compute correctly anymore. Because if we know for instance that the output is now 1, we don’t know whether it came from A=0, B=1 or A=1, B=0 or A=0, B=0 and it cannot go back. Such a device is an irreversible gate. The great discovery of Bennett and, independently, of Fredkin is that it is possible to do computation with a different kind of fundamental gate unit, a reversible gate unit. I have illustrated their idea — with this unit which I could call a reversible NAND or whatever. It has three inputs and three outputs (Fig. 6.7). Of the outputs, two, A and B , are the same as two of the inputs, A and B, but the third input works this way: C is the same as C unless A and B are both 1. Then it changes whatever C is.
6 The Computing Machines in the Future
107
Fig. 6.7
For instance, if C is 1 it is changed to 0, if C is 0 it is changed to 1 only if both A and B are 1. If you put two in succession, you see A and B will go through, and if C is not changed in both it stays the same or if C is changed twice it stays the same. So this gate reverses itself. No information has been lost. It is possible to discover what went in if you know what went out. A device made entirely with such gates will make calculations if everything moves forward, but if things go back and forth for a while and then eventually go forward enough it still operates correctly. If the things flip back and then go forward later it is still all right. It’s very much the same as a particle in a gas which is bombarded by the atoms around it, usually goes nowhere, but with just a little pull, a little prejudice that makes a chance to move one way a little higher than the other way, the thing will slowly drift forward and reach from one end to the other, in spite of the Brownian motion that is made. So our computer will compute provided we apply a force of drift to pull the thing more likely across the calculation. Although it is not doing the calculation in a smooth way, but calculating like this, forward and backward, it eventually finishes the job, As with the particle in the gas, if we pull it very slightly, we lose very little energy, but it takes a long time to get to one side from the other. If we are in a hurry, and we pull hard, then we loose a lot of energy. And the same with this computer. If we are patient and go slowly, we can make the computer operate with practically no energy, even less than kT per step, any amount as small as you like if you have enough time. But if you are in a hurry, you must dissipate energy, and again it’s true that the energy lost to pull the calculation forward to complete it multiplied by the time you are allowed to make the calculation is a constant.
108
Richard P. Feynman
With these possibilities how small can we make a computer? How big must a number be? We all know we can write numbers in base 2 as strings of “bits” each a one or a zero. But how small can I write? Surely only one atom is needed to be in one state or another to determine if it represents a one or a zero. And the next atom could be a one or a zero, so a little string of atoms are enough to hold a number, one atom for each bit. (Actually since an atom can be in more states than just two we could use even fewer atoms, but enough is little enough!) So now for intellectual entertainment we consider whether we could make a computer in which the bits writing is of atomic size, in which a bit is for example whether the spin in the atom is up for 1 or down for 0. And then our transistor changing the bits in different places would correspond to some interaction between some atoms, which will change their states. The simplest would be a kind of 3-atom interaction to be the fundamental element or gate in such a device. But again, it won’t work right if we design it with the laws appropriate for large objects. We must use the new laws of physics, quantum mechanical laws, the laws that they are appropriate to atomic motion. And so we have to ask whether the principles of quantum mechanics permit an arrangements of atoms so small in number as a few times the number of gates in a computer that could still be put together and operate as a computer. This has been studied in principle, and such an arrangement has been found. The laws of quantum mechanics are reversible and therefore we must use the invention of reversible gates, that principle, that idea of Bennett and Fredkin, but we know that’s alright now. When the quantum mechanical situation is studied it is found that quantum mechanics adds no further limitations to anything that Mr. Bennet has said from thermodynamic considerations. Of course there is a limitation, the practical limitation anyway, that the bits must be of the size of an atom and a transistor 3 or 4 atoms; the quantum mechanical gate I used has 3 atoms. (I would not try to write my bits on to nuclei, I’ll wait till the technological development reaches the atoms before I need to go any further!) That leads us just with (a) the limitations in size to the size of atoms, (b) the energy requirements depending on the time as worked out by Bennett, (c) and the feature that I did not mention concerning the speed of light; we can’t send the signals any faster than the speed of light. Those are the only physical limitations that I know on computers. If we make an atomic size computer, somehow, it would mean that the dimension, the linear dimension is a thousand to ten thousands times smaller than those very tiny chips that we have now. It means that the volume of the computer is 100 billionth, 10−11 of the present volume, because the transistor is that much smaller 10−11 , than the transistors that we make today. The energy requirement for a single switch is also about eleven orders of magnitude smaller than the energy required to switch the transistor today, and the time to make the transitions will be at least ten thousands times faster per step of calculation. So there is plenty of room for improvement in the computer and I leave you, practical people who work on computers, this as an aim to get to. I underestimated how long it would take for Mr. Ezawa to translate what I said, and I have no more to say that I have prepared for today. Thank you! I will answer questions if you’d like.
6 The Computing Machines in the Future
109
4. Questions and Answers Q: You mentioned that one bit of information can be stored in one atom, and I wonder if you can store the same amount of information in one quark. A: Yes. But we don’t have control of the quarks and that becomes a really impractical way to deal with things. You might think that what I am talking about is impractical, but I don’t believe so. When I am talking about atoms, I believe that someday we will be able to handle and control them individually. There would be so much energy involved in the quark interactions it would be very dangerous to handle because of the radioactivity and so on. But the atomic energies that I am talking about are very familiar to us in chemical energies, electrical energies, and those, that I am speaking of, are numbers that are within the realm of reality, I believe, however absurd it may seem at the moment. Q: You said that the smaller the computing element is the better. But, I think equipments have to be larger, because.... A: You mean that your finger is too big to push the buttons? Is that what you mean? Q: Yes, it is. A: Of course, you are right. I am talking about internal computers perhaps for robots or other devices. The input and output is something that I didn’t discuss, whether the input comes from looking at pictures, hearing voices, or buttons being pushed. I am discussing how the computation is done in principle, and not what form the output should take. It is certainly true that the input and the output cannot be reduced in most cases effectively beyond human dimension. It is already too difficult to push the buttons on some of the computers with our big fingers. But with elaborate computing problems that take hours and hours, they could be done very rapidly on the very small machines with low energy consumption. That’s the kind of machine I was thinking of. Not the simple applications of adding two numbers but the elaborate calculations. Q: I would like to know your method to transform the information from one atomic scale element to another atomic scale element. If you will use a quantum mechanical or natural interaction between the two elements then such a device will become very close to Nature itself. For example, if we make a computer simulation, a Monte Carlo simulation of a magnet to study critical phenomena, then your atomic scale computer will be very close to the magnet itself. What are your thoughts about that? A:. Yes. All things that we make are Nature. We arrange it in a way to suit our purpose, to make a calculation for a purpose. In a magnet there is some kind of relation, if you wish, there are some kind of computations going on just like there is in the solar system in a way of thinking. But, that might not be the calculation we want to make at the moment. What we need to make is a device for which we can change the programs and let it compute the problem that we want to solve, not just its own magnet problem that it likes to solve for itself. I can’t use the solar system
110
Richard P. Feynman
for a computer unless it just happens that the problem that someone gave me was to find the motion of the planets, in which case all I have to do is to watch. There was an amusing article as a joke. Far in the future the “article” appears discussing a new method of making aerodynamical calculations: Instead of using the elaborate computers of the day, the author invents a simple device to blow air past the wing. (He reinvents the wind tunnel.) Q: I have recently read in an newspaper article that operations of the nerve system in a brain are much slower than present day computers and the unit in the nerve system is much smaller. Do you think that the computers you have talked about today have something in common with the nerve system in the brain? A: There is an analogy between the brain and the computer in that there are apparently elements that can switch under the control of others. Nerve impulses controlling or exciting other nerves, in a way that often depends upon whether more than one impulse comes in; something like an AND or its generalization. The amount of energy used in the brain cell for one of these transitions? I don’t know the number. The time it takes to make a switching in the brain is very much longer than it is in our computers even today, never mind the fancy business of some atomic computer. But, interconnection system is much more elaborate. Each nerve is connected to thousand other nerves, whereas we connect transistors to two or three others. Some people look at the activity of the brain in action and see that in many respects it surpasses the computer of today, and in many other respects the computer surpasses ourselves. This inspires people to design machines that can do more. What often happens is that an engineer makes up how the brain works in his opinion, and then designs a machine that behaves that way. This new machine may in fact work very well. But, I must warn you that that does not tell us anything about how the brain actually works, nor is it necessary to ever really know that in order to make a computer very capable. It is not necessary to understand the way birds flap their wings and how the feathers are designed in order to make a flying machine. It is not necessary to understand the lever system in the legs of a cheetah, that is an animal that runs fast, in order to make an automobile with wheels that goes very fast. It is therefore not necessary to imitate the behavior of Nature in detail in order to engineer a device which can in many respects surpass Nature’s abilities. It is an interesting subject and I like to talk about it. Your brain is very weak compared to a computer. I will give you a series of numbers, one, three, seven, oh yes, ichi, san, shichi, san, ni, go, ni, go, ichi, hachi, ichi, ni, ku, san, go. I want you to repeat them back. But, a computer can take ten thousands numbers and give me them back in reverse every other one, or sum them or lots of things that we cannot do. On the other hand, if I look at a face, in a glance I can tell you who it is if I know that person, or that I don’t know that person. But, we do not know how to make a computer system so that if we give it a pattern of a face it can tell us who he is, even if it has seen many faces and you try to teach it. We do not know how to make computers do that, yet. Another interesting example is chess playing machines. It is quite a surprise that we can make machines that play chess better than almost everybody in the room. But, they do it by trying many many possibilities. If he moves here, then I could
6 The Computing Machines in the Future
111
move here and he can move there and so forth. They look at each alternative and choose the best. Now, millions of alternatives are looked at. But, a master chess player, a human, does it differently. He recognizes patterns. He looks at only thirty or forty positions before deciding what move to make. Therefore, although the rules are simpler in Go, machines that play Go are not very good, because in each position there are too many possibilities to move and there are too many things to check and the machines cannot look deeply. Therefore the problem of recognizing patterns and what to do under the circumstances is the thing that the computer engineers (they like to call themselves computer scientists) still find very difficult, and it is certainly one of the important things for future computers, perhaps more important than the things I spoke about. Make a machine to play Go effectively. Q: I think that any method of computation would not be fruitful unless it would give a kind of provision on how to compose such devices or programs. I thought the Fredkin paper on conservative logic was very intriguing, but once I came to think of making a simple program using such devices I came to a halt because thinking out such a program is far more complex than the program itself. I think we could easily get into a kind of infinite regression because the process of making out a certain program would be much more complex than the program itself and in trying to automate the process the automating program would be more complex and so on. Especially in this case where the program is hard wired rather than being separated as a software, I think it is fundamental to think of the ways of composition. A: We have some different experiences. There is no infinite regression; it stops at a certain level of complexity. The machine that Fredkin ultimately is talking about and the one that I was talking about in the quantum mechanical case are both universal commuters in the sense that they can be programmed to do various jobs; this is not a hard-wired program; they are no more hard-wired than an ordinary computer that you can put information in, that the program is a part of the input, and the machine does the problem that it is assigned to do. It is hard-wired but it is universal like an ordinary computer. These things are very uncertain but I found a minimum. If you have a program written for an irreversible machine, the ordinary program, then I can convert it to a reversible machine program by a direct translation scheme, which is very inefficient and uses many more steps. Then in real situations, the number of steps can be much less. But at least I know that I can take a program with 2 steps where it is irreversible, convert it to 3n steps of a reversible machine. That is many more steps. I did it very inefficiently; I did not try to find the minimum. Just a way. I don’t really think that we’ll find this regression that you speak of, but you might be right. I am uncertain. Q: Won’t we be sacrificing many of the merits we were expecting of such devices, because those reversible machines run so slow? I am very pessimistic about this point. A: They run slower, but they are very much smaller. I don’t make it reversible unless I need to. There is no point in making the machine reversible unless you are trying very hard to decrease the energy enormously, rather ridiculously, because with only 80 times kT the irreversible machine functions perfectly. That 80 is much
112
Richard P. Feynman
less than the present day 109 or 1010 , so I have at least 107 improvement in energy to make, and can still do it with irreversible machines! That’s true. That’s the right way to go, for the present. I entertain myself intellectually for fun, to ask how far could we go in principle, not in practice, and then I discover that I can go to a fraction of a kT of energy and make the machines microscopic, atomically microscopic. But to do so, I must use the reversible physical laws. Irreversibility comes because the heat is spread over a large number of atoms and can’t be gathered back again. When I make the machine very small, unless I allow a cooling element which is lots of atoms, I have to work reversibly. In practice there probably will never come a time when we will be unwilling to tie a little computer to a big piece of lead which contains 1010 atoms (which is still very small indeed), making it effectively irreversible. Therefore I agree with you that in practice, for a very long time and perhaps forever, we will use irreversible gates. On the other hand it is a part of the adventure of science to try to find a limitations in all directions and to stretch a human imagination as far as possible everywhere. Although at every stage it has looked as if such an activity was absurd and useless, it often turns out at least not to be useless. Q: Are there any limitations from the uncertainty principle? Are there any fundamental limitations on the energy and the clock time in your reversible machine scheme? A: That was my exact point. There is no further limitation due to quantum mechanics. One must distinguish carefully between the energy lost or consumed irreversibly, the heat generated in the operation of the machine, and the energy content of the moving parts which might be extracted again. There is a relationship between the time and the energy which might be extracted again. But that energy which can be extracted again is not of any importance or concern. It would be like asking whether we should add the mc2 , rest energy, of all the atoms which are in the device. I only speak of the energy lost times the time, and then there is no limitation. However it is true that if you want to make a calculation at a certain extremely high speed, you have to supply to the machine parts which move fast and have energy but that energy is not necessarily lost at each step of the calculation; it coasts through by inertia. A (to no Q): Could I just say with regard to the question of useless ideas? I’d like to add one more. I waited, if you would ask me, but you didn’t. So I answer it anyway. How would we make a machine of such small dimension where we have to put the atoms in special places? Today we have no machinery with moving parts whose dimension is extremely small or atomic or hundreds of atoms even, but there is no physical limitation in that direction either. And there is no reason why, when we lay down the silicon even today, the pieces cannot be made into little islands so that they are movable. And we could arrange small jets so we could squirt the different chemicals on certain locations. We can make machinery which is extremely small. Such machinery will be easy to control by the same kind of computer circuits that we make. Ultimately, for fun again and intellectual pleasure, we could imagine machines tiny like few microns across with wheels and cables all interconnected by wires, silicon connections, so that the thing as a whole, a very large device, moves
6 The Computing Machines in the Future
113
not like the awkward motion of our present stiff machines but in a smooth way of the neck of a swan, which after all is a lot of little machines, the cells all interconnected and all controlled in a smooth way. Why can’t we do that ourselves?
Fig. 6.8 Scenes of the lecture of Professor Richard Feynman at Gakushuin University in Tokyo in 1985
7
Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics Ben R. Mottelson
Abstract This address was presented by Ben R. Mottelson as the Nishina Memorial Lecture at Science Council of Japan (Tokyo), on November 9, 1985.
It is a great privilege for me to be able to join with you in this celebration of Niels Bohr, scientific revolutionary, and foresighted thinker on questions bearing on science and on the human condition as well as being our common teacher. This is indeed an occasion on which scientists in both Japan and in Denmark can feel pride and inspiration. I think especially of the early decades of this century when Nishina participated so effectively in the work at Niels Bohr’s institute and then returned to Japan to set in motion the development of modern physics in Japan that has produced so Ben R. Mottelson many marvelous results. I wish to thank very warmly the NMF c Science Council of Japan, the Japanese Physical Society, and the Nishina Foundation for their kindness in providing this opportunity. In preparing for this occasion, I quickly realized that any attempt to report systematically on Niels Bohr’s many very different contributions to modern science is more than I am competent to do and would inevitably be a program too rich and diverse to be compressed into a single lecture; I therefore decided to confine my report to a discussion of Niels Bohr’s profound contributions to the understanding of atomic nuclei and even here, as you will see, I have been forced to drastically abbreviate some parts in order to properly describe the general background of the Ben R. Mottelson (1926 – ). Nobel Laureate in Physics (1975) NORDITA (Copenhagen, Denmark) at the time of this address B. R. Mottelson: Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics, Lect. Notes Phys. 746, 115–135 (2008) c Nishina Memorial Foundation 2008 DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-77056-5 7
116
Ben R. Mottelson
development and to include a little of the subsequent impact and evolution of the ideas initiated by Bohr. Let us begin at the beginning: Niels Bohr was eleven years old when Becquerel discovered the first hint of the existence of atomic nuclei in the occurrence of natural radioactivity, a kind of faintly glowing ashes left from the violent nuclear phenomena that created the heavy elements from which our solid earth and living bodies are made. Fifteen years later Rutherford used the natural radioactivity as a marvelous probe which established the profound distinction between the open, planetary structure of the atomic electrons surrounding the small, dense, enigmatic atomic nucleus in the center. This discovery made possible Bohr’s analysis of the dynamics of the electrons in the atom which lead to the discovery of quantum mechanics. However, the understanding of properties of atomic nuclei in terms of a dynamics of nuclear constituents had to wait for more than 20 years, until after Chadwick’s discovery of the neutron (1932). At last one could begin a rational theory of the structure of atomic nuclei. Immediately after the discovery of the neutron, it was Heisenberg who took the first step in developing a theory of nuclear structure by recognizing that (i) a nucleus of charge Z |e| and mass AM can be considered as a composite system built out of A protons and (A-Z) neutrons; (ii) a new force of nature (later called the ’strong’ interaction of ’nuclear’ force) is required to hold this system together. From the available evidence on nuclear masses and stability, Heisenberg, Wigner and Majarana were able to derive some basis features of this new force. The fact that the nuclear volume and binding energy are approximately proportional to the total number of neutrons and protons (in contrast to atomic binding energies that go as Z 7/3 ) implies that the nuclear forces saturate. The magnitude of the nuclear binding energies imply that the nuclear forces are much stronger than the electric forces even when one takes account of the 1/r dependence of the latter and the fact that nuclei are 104 times smaller than atoms. A comparison of the binding of the deuteron and 4 He nucleus shows that the forces are of short range (a few times 10−13 cm) (Wigner 1933). It was, of course, this last feature that Hideki Yukawa recognized as the crucial point in formulating a fundamental theory of these interactions based on the exchange of massive bosonic quanta. Yukawa’s insight was a major turning point in the whole development. For nuclear physics it provided the first insight into the microscopic origin of nuclear cohesion, and at the same time it provided a fundamental scale of length and energy at which one must expect major corrections to the picture of nuclei as built out of neutrons and protons. Especially this last point can be seen as the opening of the great development of elementary particle physics which reveals that the proton itself, when examined on a fine enough scale, has a rich and fascinating composite structure. But, now I have gotten far ahead of my story and so I must go back to the period around 1932-34 when, at last, it became possible to begin the detailed discussion of the structure of nuclei based on a picture of the nuclei as composite systems built
7 Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics
117
out of neutrons and protons. It is at this juncture that the first nuclear accelerators begin to provide evidence on nuclear reactions produced by protons and deuterons (Cockcroft and Walton 1932, Lawrence and Livingstone 1932). However the energies available in these early machines were only sufficient to produce reactions in the lightest elements. At this point, Fermi (who had done theoretical work up to this time) realized that the recently discovered neutron afforded a powerful tool for producing reactions in even the heaviest nuclei. The difficulty with neutrons was that they had first to be produced by bombarding Be with natural alpha particles and thus there were not too many of them; in the experiments in Rome the sources produced of order 107 neutrons/sec. This disadvantage was however compensated by the fact that the neutron, having no charge, can reach the nuclei of all atoms without having to overcome the repulsive electric potential barrier that surrounds the nucleus. Fermi and his collaborators took up the program of irradiating all the elements of the periodic table with neutrons; they started at the beginning of the periodic table and by March 25, 1934 they had reached 9 F and observed their first new radioactivity F(n, α)16 N(β− )16 O). With the heavier elements they soon discovered that in al(19 9 7 most every case new radioactive species were produced. It was an enormous expansion of the material available for studying nuclear processes. They showed that in most cases the radio-activity was produced by radiative capture (A Z+n → A+1 Z+γ). Having found this wealth of new activities the Rome workers began studying the relative efficiency with which the different activities were produced, i.e. establishing relative cross sections for the neutron reactions with different substances. In the course of this work one day Fermi, in an apparently unpremeditated act, inserted a piece of paraffin, between the source and the sample (Ag) and immediately observed a marked increase in the rate of activation. The same day he had interpreted the effect as resulting from the slowing down of the neutrons in their collision with hydrogen in the paraffin, the slow neutron apparently having a larger cross section for capture than the fast neutrons (which had energies extending up to about 8 MeV) coming directly from the source. These developments stimulated theoretical analysis of the interaction of slow neutrons with nuclei and soon papers were published by Beck and Horsley (1935), Bethe (1935), Fermi (1935), and Perrin and Elsasser (1935). All of these authors based their analysis on the interaction of the incident neutron with a nuclear potential that was assumed constant inside the nuclear volume. These investigations provide valuable insight into the prevailing prejudices as well as the tools available for the analysis of the nuclear problem at this time and therefore the analysis is briefly recapitulated in Table 7.1. The description in terms of a single particle potential in these investigations was borrowed directly from the successful use of this description for the scattering of electrons by atoms. We may wonder whether the practitioners had other reasons of theoretical or experimental nature for believing in the appropriateness of this description. Apparently such evidence or arguments was quite lacking, as indicated by a remark in Bethe’s paper, “It is not likely that the approximation made in this paper, i.e. taking the nucleus as a rigid body and repre-
118
Ben R. Mottelson
Table 7.1 Analysis of slow neutron reactions (1935) Beck + Horsley; Bethe; Elsasser + Perrin; Fermi I wave lengths outside nucleus: En ∼ kT ∼ 0.025eV out = h¯ /(2ME)1/2 ∼ 3 × 10−9 cm inside nucleus: En ∼ V0 ∼ 50MeV in ∼ 0.6 × 10−13 cm II residence time for neutron in nucleus, tin a) traversal time, τ0 τ0 =
2R 10−12 cm = 10−22 sec ∼ vin 1010 cm/sec
b) reflection at nuclear surface TR = 1 − R in ∼ 10−4 out c) residence time
tin = τ0 (T R )−1 ∼ 10−18 sec
III gamma radiation P = radiation probability/time 4 1 Eγ = |P0 |2 Eγ = γ − ray energy 3 h¯ h¯ c ∼ 7MeV P0 = ”dipole momemt” ∼ 1017 sec−1
∼ eR ∼ 10−12 cm · e
IV Cross sections (a) tin ⇒ En ∼ thin¯ ∼ keV thus, cross sections are smooth and universal for En keV (b) σnγ ∝ tin ∝ (En )−1/2 σnγ (c) σscat = P · tin < 1
7 Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics
119
senting it by a potential field acting on the neutron, is really adequate ... . Anyway, it is the only practicable approximation in many cases ...” The analysis in Table 7.1 implies that the (n, γ) capture cross sections should depend on the neutron energy as (En )−1/2 over a considerable range of energies and thus one obtained a direct explanation for the observed increase in activation produced by slowing down the neutrons in paraffin. However, almost immediately the theory began to run into difficulties. The capture cross sections of some elements for slow neutrons were found to be unexpectedly large (in some cases as much as 100 times the geometrical cross section of the nucleus) and the elastic scattering cross section in these cases was not exceptionally large.
Fig. 7.1 Arrangement used by the Rome group for studying the absorption cross sections of slow neutrons (Amaldi 1984). S = neutron source, P = paraffin block, A = absorber, D = detector
And then came the remarkable discovery of “selective absorption” (Bjerge and Westcott (1935); Moon and Tilman (1935)) which was quite outside the theoretical expectation of a smooth energy dependence of the cross section. The experimental set up for the observation of this effect is the very essence of simplicity and elegance (Fig. 7) and consists of a neutron source (Be + Ra), a paraffin moderator, the material whose absorption is being measured and a detector directly above the absorber. The amount of neutrons removed by the absorber was monitored by the amount of radioactivity produced in the material of the detector. The first measurements with this set-up confirmed, as expected, that the substances with large cross sections for activation also were especially efficient in attenuating the source. But, then it was noticed that the amount of the attenuation depended on the material being used as the monitor in the detector position. In every case it was found that when the detector was the same substance as the absorber, the observed attenuation was the greatest (see Table 7). This was the “selective absorption” interpreted in terms of the broad energy distribution of the neutron sources and the occurrence of narrow energy absorption bands characteristic of each substance. By ingenious arrangements involving the slowing down of the neutrons between absorber and detector it was possible to order the absorption bands of the different substances and even to get measures of the widths of the bands. The observed sharpness of the absorption bands implies that
120
Ben R. Mottelson abs. detector Mn Br Rh Ag I
Mn Br Rh Ag I 73 81 88 86 79
92 61 96 91 84
59 79 54 68 91
59 79 67 45 70
98 86 97 89 55
Table 7.2 Evidence for selective absorption, Amaldi and Fermi (1935)
the slow neutrons residence time in the nucleus is an order of magnitude longer than the estimate given in Table 7.1. It was Niels Bohr who saw first and most clearly that these experimental discoveries concerning the interactions of neutrons with nuclei demanded a radical revision in the basic picture of nuclear dynamics. He recognized that the assumed single particle motion, copied from atomic physics, was being falsified and he suggested in its stead an idealization which focused on the many body features and the strong coupling of all the different degrees of freedom of the nuclear system - the compound nucleus. There are two dramatic accounts (one by Frisch and one by Wheeler) of a colloquium in Copenhagen that appears to mark a decisive turning point in the development of these ideas. First, as reported by Frisch (1968) “According to what was then believed about nuclei a neutron should pass clean through the nucleus with only a small chance of being captured. Hans Bethe in the USA had tried to calculate that chance, and I remember the colloquium in 1935 when some speaker reported on that paper. On that occasion, Bohr kept interrupting and I was beginning to wonder with some irritation why he didn’t let the speaker finish. Then in the middle of a sentence, Bohr suddenly stopped and sat down, his face completely dead. We looked at him for several seconds, getting anxious. Had he been taken unwell? But then he got up and said with an apologetic smile, “Now. I understand it all”, and he outlined the compound nucleus idea.”
Wheeler’s account appears to refer to the same occasion (Wheeler, 1979): “The news hit me at a Copenhagen seminar, set up at short notice to hear what Christian Miller had found out during his Eastertime visit to Rome and Fermi’s group. The enormous cross sections that Miller reported for the interception of a slow neutron stood at complete variance to the concept of the nucleus then generally accepted. In that view, the nucleons have the same kind of free run in the nucleus that electrons have in an atom, or planets in the solar system. Miller had only got about a half hour into his seminar account and had only barely outlined the Rome findings when Bohr rushed forward to take the floor from him. Letting the words come as his thoughts developed, Bohr described how the large cross sections led one to think of exactly the opposite idealizations: a mean-free path for the individual nucleons, short in comparison with nuclear dimensions. He compared such a collection of particles with a liquid drop. He stressed the idea that the system formed by the impact of the neutron, the “compound nucleus”, would have no memory of how it was formed. It was already clear before Bohr finished and the seminar was over, that a revolutionary change in outlook was in the making. Others heard his thoughts through the grapevine before he gave his first formal lecture on the subject, before the Copenhagen Academy on January 27th, 1936, with a subsequent written account in Nature.”
7 Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics
121
These recollections give a lively picture of the style of discussion at the Institute in the mid 1930’s, but I should warn you that there is rather strong evidence that the two accounts cannot refer to the same occasions and thus it is impossible that both can describe the moment of conception of the compound nucleus. This question has been carefully considered by Peierls (1985), exploiting the extensive letters and unpublished manuscripts in the Niels Bohr Archives, who has concluded that Bohr had in fact been developing his ideas about nuclear dynamics for some time. The two colloquia reported by Frisch and Wheeler are then to be seen as occasions on which Bohr saw some additional significant piece of information fall into place. Significant support for the assumption of a long gestation period for the compound nucleus ideas is contained in several letters quoted by Peierls. In a letter to Gamow (26. Feb. 1936) Bohr writes, “As you will see from the enclosed article which will soon appear in “Nature”, this is a development of a thought which I already brought up at the last Copenhagen conference in 1934 immediately after Fermi’s first experiment about the capture of fast neutrons, and which I have taken up again after the latest wonderful discoveries about the capture of slow neutron”. Similarly Rutherford writes to Max Born (22. Feb. 1936) reporting on Bohr’s new ideas, “The main idea is an old one of Bohr’s, viz. that it is impossible to consider the movements of the individual particles of the nucleus as in a conservative field, but that it must be regarded as a “mush” of particles of unknown kind, the vibrations of which can in general be deduced on quantum ideas. He considers, as I have always thought likely, that a particle on entering the nucleus remains long enough to share its energy with the other particles”. Let us now turn more directly to the consideration of the new ideas initiated by Bohr’s article in “Nature” (1936). The core of Bohr’s thinking is the recognition that the densely packed nuclear system being studied in the neutron reactions forces one to place the collective, many body features of the nuclear dynamics at the center of attention. To illustrate these ideas I do not know of any better figures than those prepared by Niels Bohr in connection with lectures which he gave at this time and which were published in the same issue of “Nature” (as a news item) that contains his famous article. The first (Fig. 7.2) draws attention to the far reaching consequences for the course of a nuclear reaction of the assumption of a short mean free path for the nucleons. If we imagine the balls removed from the central region of the figure, the ball entering from the right will be accelerated as it enters the central depression, but just this acceleration ensures that after running across to the opposite side the ball will have enough energy to surmount the barrier on that side and run out of the nuclear region. A very different dynamical history results if we restore the balls to the central region. Now, the entering ball (nucleon) will soon collide with one of the balls of the target and, sharing its energy with the struck ball, will no longer be able to leave the confining potential. Being reflected back it will collide and share its remaining energy with still other balls and these struck balls will also collide and ultimately the total energy will be distributed among all the balls in a distribution of the type described by the equilibrium distribution of the kinetic theory of gases. In this situation the only possibility for one of the balls to escape from the central
122
Ben R. Mottelson
Fig. 7.2
region requires the occurrence of a fluctuation in which almost all of the energy is again concentrated on a single ball which will then be able to surmount the confining potential. The unlikelihood of such an extreme fluctuation implies that the duration of the reaction phase is enormously increased (as compared with the first situation considered with only a static potential acting). This increase of the reaction time makes it possible to explain both the observed large ratio of capture to scattering cross sections for slow neutrons as well as the narrowness of the selective absorption bands. Perhaps even more important, the intermediate stage representing a kind of thermal equilibrium from which the final decay represents a rare fluctuation, ensures that the relative probability of different final states will be governed by statistical laws and is independent of the mode of formation of the compound system. Fig. 7.3 shows Bohr’s sketch of a schematic nuclear level system. The study of radioactivity had shown that the lowest excited states in heavy nuclei are of order a fraction of 1 MeV, and Bohr assumed that these excitations represent some sort of collective vibration of the whole nucleus. With increasing excitation energy an increasing number of different vibrational modes can be excited and the different possibilities for partitioning the total excitation energy between these different modes leads to an enormous increase in the total number of excited states. (Note the similarity to the mathematical problem of counting the number of ways of partitioning a given integer n into a sum of smaller integers - a problem that had been solved by Hardy√and Ramanujan who found an exponential increase in the number of partitions (n 48 )−1 − exp π(2n/3)1/2). All of these quantum states can be resonantly excited by an incoming neutron thus accounting for the dense spacing and narrowness of the levels observed in the selective absorption phenomena. The dotted line in the magnifying glass at about 10 MeV indicates the neutron separation energy, but the level scheme above and below this line are not significantly different; indeed, the neutron escape probability is much less than the γ-emission probability for levels slightly above this energy as a result of the extreme improbability of the
7 Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics
123
Fig. 7.3
fluctuation required to concentrate all of the excitation energy on a single particle. Only at higher energies will the neutron emission probability contribute appreciable to the width of the individual levels and lead to a broadening and eventually the overlapping of the level (indicated in the upper magnifying glass at about 15 MeV). Bohr contrasts this picture of densely spaced many particle levels in the nucleus with the spectrum of atoms excited in collisions with electrons where the incident electron will at most collide with one of the atomic electrons causing it to change its binding state from one orbit to another; the resulting spectrum contains relatively few, widely spaced, resonances. The profound reordering of the picture of nuclear dynamics implied by Bohr’s ideas was, apparently, rapidly and widely accepted in the nuclear physics community; within months the literature is completely dominated by papers applying, testing, and extending the ideas of the compound nucleus. It would take us much too far to include within the framework of this lecture a discussion of the many significant ideas and discoveries which went into this development; as a very anemic substitute for such a discussion I have attempted in Table 7.3 to list some of main landmarks in the expanding development of the subject. Each of these developments involves many deeply interesting ideas that significantly extended and exploited the general picture that Bohr had sketched. There is much too much to tell about here, so let me take a single example to illustrate the
124
Ben R. Mottelson
Fig. 7.4
flavour of this development - I take as an example the first steps in the interpretation of the fission process. The story begins already in 1934; Fermi and his collaborators had in their systematic studies irradiated Th and U with neutrons and had found induced activity. However, the results were difficult to interpret since for these elements (and for them alone) it appeared that many different activities were being produced simultaneously (compound decay curves). Four years later Fermi referred to these ex-
7 Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics
125
periments which were being interpreted in terms of the production of “transuranic” elements in his Nobel lecture (December, 1938), but the picture was still confusing. Just a month after Fermi’s Nobel lecture, Hahn and Strassmann published the startling news that among the activities produced by neutron irradiation of U there was an isotope chemically indistinguishable from Ba (Z = 54). They say in their publication that as chemists they have to call it Ba, but as nuclear chemists a field with close connection to physics they cannot take this step since it would be in conflict with all previous experience in nuclear physics. Table 7.3 Major developments bearing on compound nucleus (1936–48) 1. Resonance formula; Breit and Wigner (1936) Γγ Γn σn (E) = πλ2 2
1 2 (E−E 0 ) + 2 Γtot
2. Level density and thermodynamic concepts Bethe; Bohr and Kalckar (1936-37) entropy α ln ρ 1 dρ ρ de 3. Nuclear decay as evaporation temperature: T−1 =
Weisskopf (1937) reciprocity arguments 4. Cross sections for “black” nucleus Bethe (1940); Feshback, Peaslee, and Weisskopf (1947) 5. Semi-empirical mass formula Weizsacher (1935) Bulk energies (volume, surface, symmetry) pairing energy 6. Collective vibration of nucleus shape oscillations density fluctuations electric dipole mode
Bohr and Kalckar (1937) Migdal (1940) Baldwin and Klaiber (1947) Goldhaber and Teller (1948)
7. Fission: The compound nuleus’ finest hour! Hahn and Strassmann (1939) Meitner and Frisch (1939) Bohr and Wheeler (1939)
On hearing of Hahn and Strassmann’s work, Frisch and Meitner immediately recognized that the experiments were revealing a new type of nuclear reaction, which could be directly’ understood in terms of Bohr’s ideas on the compound nucleus.
126
Ben R. Mottelson
Indeed, all nuclei heavier than Zr are exothermic for a reaction that divides the nucleus into two approximately equal fragments. This instability is the result of the Coulomb energy which increases as Z 2 e2 /R ∼ Z 2 /A2/3 and thus eventually overwhelms the surface energy (4πR2 ∼ A2/3 ) which holds the nucleus united and approximately spherical. For the heaviest nuclei the energy release can be estimated from the known masses and is of order 200 MeV. Thus Frisch and Meitner envisioned a process in which a heavy nucleus, acting like a charged liquid drop, divides itself, going through a sequence of more and more elongated shapes until finally the Coulomb forces take over and drive the two nascent droplets apart. When Frisch told Bohr about these ideas, Bohr was enthusiastic. As told by Frisch, he had only a brief chance to tell Bohr of their ideas before Bohr was to leave for a trip to the United States: ‘When l reached Bohr, he had only a few minutes left; but I had hardly begun to tell him, when he struck his forehead with his hand and exclaimed: Oh, what idiots we all have been! Oh, but this is wonderful! This is just as it must be! Have you and Lise Meitner written a paper about it?’
As is well known, Bohr and Wheeler took up, with great energy and breadth of scope, the problem of elucidating the various aspects of the fission reactions, building on and extending the concepts of the compound nucleus. Of this very great development I can only remind you of a single little nugget, as told in the words oft Leon Rosenfeld, who accompanied Bohr on that famous trip to the USA following immediately after the interview with Frisch which I quoted above. Rosenfeld tells of a morning in Princeton shortly after their arrival: ‘Some time in January Placzek, who had just come over from Europe, came to see us as we were sitting at Breakfast at the Faculty Club, The conversation soon turned to fission. Bohr casually remarked: ‘It is a relief that we are now rid of those transuranians’. This elicited Placzek’s protest: ‘The situation is more confused than ever’, he said, and he explained to us that there was a capture resonance at about 10 volts both in uranium and thorium showing, apparently, that transuranians were produced concurrently with fission. Bohr listened carefully; then he suddenly stood up and, without a word, headed towards Fine Hall, where we had our office. Taking a hasty leave of Placzek, l joined Bohr, who was walking silently, lost in a deep meditation which I was careful not to disturb. As soon as he entered the office, he rushed to the blackboard, telling me: ‘Now listen: I have it all’ And he started - again without uttering a word - drawing graphs on the blackboard. The first graph looked like this (Fig. 7.5a). Clearly, the idea was to show, for thorium, the capture cross section, with its resonance at about 10 volts, and the fission cross section starting at a much higher threshold. Then he drew exactly the same graph, mentioning 238 U instead of Th, and he wrote the mass number 238 with very large figures - he broke several pieces of chalk in the process. Finally, he drew quite a different picture which he labelled 235 U. This was intended to show the fission cross section, with non-vanishing values over the whole energy range (Fig. 7.5c). Having drawn the graph, he started developing his argument; obviously, the resonance capture must belong to the abundant uranium isotope, otherwise its peak value would exceed the limit set by wave theory. For the same reason, the fast neutron fission must also be ascribed to the abundant isotope, whose behaviour is thus entirely similar to that of thorium. Consequently, the observed slow-neutron fission must be attributed to the rare isotope 235 U: This is a logical necessity. The next step was to explain the similarity between the two
7 Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics
127
Fig. 7.5
even-mass nuclei Th and 238 U and the essential difference respecting fissility between the even-mass and the odd-mass uranium isotope’.
The difference results from the well-known pairing effect in the nuclear masses. A neutron added to a system with an odd number of neutrons forms a compound system with an additional neutron pair, and therefore with about 1 MeV more binding energy than when the neutron is added to an already paired system. In retrospect, we may have the impression that this was fairly obvious conclusion from the facts. However, at the time it was far from obvious, and very few physicists accepted Bohr’s explanation. Fermi, in particular, was highly skeptical. The application, and deeper understanding of these ideas has undergone an enormous development in the fortyfive years since that time, and it would be quite beyond the scope of this lecture to even attempt an enumeration of all the important ideas that have, through the development, enriched the compound nucleus concept. However, there are two chapters in the post war development that I think I really must include; the reconciling of the compound nucleus with the occurrence of shell structure and as a second point the random matrix models. If we continue the story chronologically, the next step is the analysis in 1948 of the vastly expanded data on the systematics of nuclear binding energies by Maria Goepert Mayer, showing the unmistakable effects of nuclear shell structure. The correct independent particle model, based on strong spin orbit forces, was found by Mayer and independently by Haxel, Jensen, and Suess about one year later. This development, at first sight, seemed to disastrously undermine the arguments that had
128
Ben R. Mottelson
Fig. 7.6
been employed to justify the compound nucleus concept - the mean free path of a neutron in the nucleus is long (for low energy neutrons λc ∼ 14fm) - not short, as assumed in arguing for the compound nucleus. But still the compound nucleus idea had been enormously successful. The resolution of this paradox is provided by considering the different time scales involved in single particle motion, in scattering, and in compound nucleus formation (see Fig. 7.6). The strong reflection of slow neutrons at the nuclear surface implies that the residence time of the neutron is much longer than the traversal time (see also Table 7.1). If the collision time is short compared with this residence time, the compound nucleus will be formed and Bohr’s ideas will be applicable. This is not at all in conflict with the occurrence of shell structure and single particle motion which is a major effect under the much weaker condition that the collision time is comparable to or longer than the traversal time. If we now look back over the development of nuclear physics in the period 193352 we see, besides the great discoveries of different types of nuclear reactions and processes, a gradual clarification of the nature of that fascinating new form for matter encountered in nuclei. A deep understanding of the dynamics of this matter could not be built until one had settled on the correct starting point; is one to start from something like the localized highly correlated picture of a solid or from the delocalized orbits of particles quantized in the total volume of the nucleus? The question is, of course, intimately linked to the strength of the nuclear forces (measured in units
7 Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics
129
of the Fermi energy which is a measure of the energy required to localize particles at the equilibrium separation). From this point of view one may feel that from the start there were strong arguments for believing that the forces are rather weak - in the two body system there is only one very weakly bound state for T = 0 and no bound state at all for T = 1 - and thus unable to produce the localization necessary for a quantum solid. We must, however, remember that in assessing this question today we are exploiting the results of a long development in which the analysis of nuclear matter could be compared with a variety of quantal systems encountered in condensed matter physics and that even with this advantage the answers are not very simple (see, for example, the necessary uncertainty in discussing the deconfinement transitions for quarks and gluons, as well as the question of a possible solid phase in the interior of neutron stars). We are here forcefully reminded that despite the impressive development of the powers of formal analysis, the important many body problems of nature have repeatedly revealed the deepseated limitations of straightforward reductionism. Each rung of the quantum ladder has revealed marvelous structures the interpretation of which has required the invention of appropriate concepts which are almost never discovered as a result of purely formal analysis of the interactions between the constituents. The recognition of single particle motion in the average nuclear potential provided a basis for developing a very detailed understanding of the nuclear dynamics, an understanding that reveals a fascinating tension between the concepts relating to independent particle motion and those referring to collective features associated with the organized dynamics of many nucleons. The compound nucleus ideas have effected this development in many and far reaching ways but I shall here confine my discussion to a single example, the remarkable development of the statistical theory of quantal spectra. The experimental impetus for this development is again the neutron resonances which played such a role in the original inspiration of the compound nucleus. It is impossible for me to think about these resonances without a sense of awe at the profound generosity of nature in providing a window in the nuclear spectra at a point where the level densities are about a million times greater than those of the fundamental modes, where the quantal levels are still beautifully sharp in relation to their separation, and where the slow neutrons provide an exquisitly matched tool with which to resolve and measure the detailed properties of each resonance. The effective exploitation of this tool has provided complete spectra comprising hundreds of individually resolved and measured neutron resonances, (Fig. 7.7) while corresponding developments in charged particle spectroscopy have lead to the measurement of similar spectra for proton resonances. It was Wigner (1955) who initiated thinking about this material in terms of random matrices. The idea is to provide a detailed characterization of the wavefunctions and spectra describing the quantal spectrum of the compound nucleus. The compound nucleus idea implies that the quantal states are complicated mixtures involving all the available degrees of freedom of the many-body-system (the quantal equivalent of ergodic motion in classical mechanics). Wigner suggested that significant features of these quantal spectra might be modeled by considering, for some
130
Ben R. Mottelson
Fig. 7.7
region of the spectrum, an expansion of the Hamiltonian matrix on an arbitrarily chosen finite set of basis states. The strong mixing of different degrees of freedom and the randomness of the compound nucleus is expressed by chosing the matrix elements of the Hamiltonian matrix independently and randomly from an appropriate ensemble. We may then ask whether there are significant features in the eigenvectors and eigenvalues which reflect the strong coupling of the different parts but are otherwise universal in the sense of being the same for almost all of the matrices generated by such a process. It turns out that the answer to this question is yes; indeed, as shown by Thomas and Porter, Mehta, Dyson, and French and co-workers, the fluctuations in level widths and spacings are just such universal properties (see Table 7.4 and the review article by Brody et al. (1981). The extensive evidence from nuclear resonances referred to above, has in recent years been shown to agree in striking detail with the prediction concerning these fluctuations based on random matrices (see Fig. 7.8) and thus to confirm the applicability of this characterization of quantal states of the compound nucleus in the regions to which it has been applied. (These ideas have also played an important role in the interpretation of experiments on laser excitation of polyatomic molecules (Stanholm; Fields) and have been invoked in the discussion of electronic properties of small metalic particles (Kubo, Gorkov and Eliashberg).) While the original formulation of this model was based on random matrices, current developments have made it possible to relate these characteristic features of quantal chaotic motion to more physical models (first to a model of electron motion
7 Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics
131
Table 7.4 Microscopic structure of Compound Nucleus = Random Matrix 1. object of study N×N real orthogonal matrix, H constrained average and dispension of eigenvalues otherwise, maximize “entropy” = chose “most typical” matrix 2. joint probability of eigenvalues E1 −− EN P(E1 – EN ) = (norm)
N Eα − Eβ exp −C E2α
α<β
1
C - constant related to level spacing note (Dyson, 1962) complete analogy to partition function for classical electron gas in 1-d with interaction V12 ∼ ln |x1 − x2 | and harmonic confining potential 2 2 Z(x1 −− xN ) = exp − ae2 T x2i + eT Ln |xC − xi | 3. electrostatic analogy “explains” almost crystaline order of the eigenvalues a) nearest neighbors P(E) ≈
π 2D2
2 E E exp − π4 D
Wigner distribution b) number of eigenvalues in interval2L PL ≈ (2πρ)−1/2 exp − 2σ1 2 n − DL σ2 =
2 π2
ln DL + O(1)
Fig. 7.8
in a disordered medium (Efetov (1983)) and quite recently to direct semi-classical
132
Ben R. Mottelson
quantization of the classical chaotic motion based on the (unstable) periodic orbits (Berry 1985). The current questions are concerned with issues such as: how can one characterize the transition between the low energy spectrum with its many conserved quantum numbers (classically multiply periodic motion) and the compound nucleus region, exhibiting quantal chaos? and how to characterize the limitations on the random matrix model that are associated with the existence of a finite relaxation time for the nuclear configurations? In attempting to understand questions such as these nuclear physicists are joining with workers in many other areas of physics in attempting to understand more deeply the significance of classical chaos in quantal spectra and, at least for the nuclear physicists, Niels Bohr’s idea of the compound nucleus provides the crucial point of entry.
Fig. 7.9 Professor Ben Mottelson during the lecture (1985)
7 Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics
133
Appendix. An Introduction to Prof. Mottelson’s Address (This was presented by Ryogo Kubo as the introduction for Prof. Mottelson’s address at Science Council of Japan (Tokyo), on November 9, 1985.) I am not quite sure if the name of Niels Bohr appears in physics textbooks for Japanese high schools, but I am sure that everyone knows his name if he has ever been interested in modern science. Niels Bohr was born one hundred years ago in Copenhagen, Denmark. To commemorate this, there have been meetings and symposia in various countries in the world. At the Niels Bohr Institute in Copenhagen, there have been several symposia in last few months, and the highlight was the Niels Bohr Centenary Symposium held through October 4 to 7 with attendance of over three hundred scientists from all over the world. Fortunately I was able to participate this symposium, which was very successful with important review lectures on physics, chemistry, and biology of the present day to commemorate the great man who paved the way to these modern sciences. The Centenary Lecture Meeting today is not covering so wide fields of sciences as that symposium in Copenhagen, but we are very happy that Professor Mottelson kindly accepted our invitation to give a memorial lecture on Niels Bohr and the modern physics. I imagine that one focus of the lecture would be Bohr and nuclear physics, on which Niels Bohr spent most of the latter half of his life to study. I think there is no much need to introduce the speaker today, but let me make a brief introduction. Professor Mottelson was born in Chicago, obtained PhD at Harvard, and came to Copenhagen in 1950. He has remained there most of the time since then. His cooperation with Professor Aage Bohr, the fourth son of Niels Bohr, started in 1951 and has been continued to the present. In 1975, both Professor Aage Bohr and Professor Mottelson shared the Nobel Prize with Rainwater for their remarkable achievements on the structure of nuclei. The subject of the work is the relationship between the individual motion and the collective motion in atomic nuclei. This problem in general is a central one not only in nuclear theory but also in other fields of physics of the present day. In fact, the idea of collective motion in the assembly of protons and neutrons was initiated by Niels Bohr as the famous liquid drop model of nuclei. The idea of competitive existence of individual and collective modes is an excellent example of the complementarity which Niels Bohr stressed throughout his life. In this sense also, the subject of Professor Mottelson’s lecture is most appropriate for commemoration of Niels Bohr. Some people maintain that the scientific achievement is only the important matter and it is immaterial who did this or that. It is true that science as an objective existence does not belong to any individual. However, scientific work is done by individuals and its evolution cannot be separated from the life of the man who did it. Scientific revolution always is ignited by some individuals and the way it evolves greatly depends on who did it. Even if there was no Einstein, the relativity might have been discovered by someone before 1915. Even if there was no Niels Bohr,
134
Ben R. Mottelson
the quantum theory of hydrogen atom might have been formed by someone before 1920. Indeed, there were A. Haas and J. W. Nicolson who thought something about the hydrogen atom, but Niels Bohr did it in an extremely unique way. The breakthrough Bohr achieved was not only the theory of a hydrogen atom but it was the guide which illuminated the way to the new horizon through the year of struggle to the birth of quantum mechanics. Mankind never forget this history. Copenhagen Geist penetrated the new physics and it gave birth of the new science of the new era. The Niels Bohr Institute became the center of international cooperation. Young ambitious scientists gathered here from all over the world. From Japan, which had experienced only a half century since she opened the door to the west, came Takamine, Nishina, Hori, Kimura, Sugiura, Ariyama and some others. These scientists played very important roles after they came back to Japan to create active atmosphere of research in Japan. Among these Japanese scientists who were in Copenhagen at that time, Dr. Nishina had most deep relations with Niels Bohr and the Institute. Dr. Nishina studied electrical engineering at Tokyo University and entered the Institute of Physical and Chemical Research after graduation. He went to Europe in 1921 and stayed at Copenhagen from 1923 to 1928 to work with Niels Bohr. He did much of experimental studies as well as theory. The most well-known of his work is the derivation of the Klein-Nishina formula, for scattering of gamma rays by electron using Dirac’s relativistic quantum theory. Dr. Nishina was liked very much by Bohr’s family. Children used to call him Onkel Nishina. After coming back to Japan, Dr. Nishina started the work on nuclear and cosmic ray physics at the Institute of Physical and Chemical Research. He also invited young theoreticians such as Tomonaga. His laboratory soon became the center of Japan for the study of modern physics. At that time most of the imperial universities were slow to change, so that the efforts of Nishina was really important for the development of modern physics in Japan. The effect was great indeed. In 1935, there was Yukawa who put forward the revolutionary idea of mesons. In several laboratories including Nishina’s laboratory and that in Osaka University, experimental studies on nuclear physics started very actively. So we expected that the day was approaching when the Japanese physics might catch up the level of Europe. It is very sad to reflect the disaster of the Second World War which completely crushed down our hope. Nevertheless, after fourty years since the war, we must not forget the fact that we owe a great deal to the valuable efforts done in 1930’s by these predecessors. In this sense also we realize deeply with great appreciation how much we owe today’s Japan to Niels Bohr. After the war, during the past few decades there have been a great number of our colleagues who went Copenhagen to study at the Niels Bohr Institute. They are now the leaders at various universities and institutions. Thus, there are great number of Bohr’s pupils, grandpupils, and grand grandpupils in Japan. Niels Bohr was always very warm and kind to Japanese scientists. He came to Japan only Once in 1937. The memory of the visit was talked about repeatedly in Bohr’s family. Unfortunately I have had no chance to meet him, but once had a chance to see Mrs. Niels Bohr who told me about those Japanese scientists at Copenhagen and her visit to Japan. In the hall outside of this auditorium there are
7 Niels Bohr and the Development of Concepts in Nuclear Physics
135
exhibitions of photographs of Niels Bohr which show us something about Bohr and Japan. If you have not seen them, I hope you pay a look after the lecture. The Nishina Memorial Foundation was established to commemorate Dr. Nishina and so it has kept a close relationship with Niels Bohr Institute. Some years ago when Professor Tomonaga was the President, he invited Professor Aage Bohr to Japan. Also Professor Tomonaga and his associates did much efforts to support the activity of the Institute through a financial grant from the EXPO Foundation. At the present moment, two young scientists are studying at the Niels Bohr Institute by the grants given by the Nishina Memorial Foundation. Some time ago, the idea of doing something to commemorate Niels Bohr centenary here in Japan came naturally to the minds of those who have ever studied at Copenhagen. The Nishina Memorial Foundation decided to take up this idea and this Lecture is one of the outcome. Since there have been several such meetings here and there in the world, we worried very much if this can ever be realized. So, we are very grateful to Professor Mottelson for his kind acceptance of our invitation. The Science Council of Japan and the Physical Society of Japan have agreed to cosponsor this Niels Bohr Centenary Lecture Meeting, which I think very appropriate to express our everlasting esteem and gratitude to the great father of modern science, Niels Bohr. Thank you for your attention.
8
From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy Kai Siegbahn
Abstract This address was presented by Kai Siegbahn as the Nishina Memorial Lecture at the University of Tokyo, on April 4, 1988.
1. Historic Background R¨ontgen’s surprising discovery in November 1895 can be regarded as the great break-through from classical physics to a new era, which developed into modern atomic physics. Hittorf, Lenard and Crookes made important preliminary work in this field, a fact that R¨ontgen pointed out in his report on the discovery “Uber eine neue Art von Strahlen”. He and many other scientists must have been strongly stimulated by the almost science-fiction like picture, that Crookes called forth at a meeting in Royal Society in London in 1878: “The phenomena in these exhausted tubes reveal to Kai Siegbahn physical science a new world—a world where matter may NMF c exist in a fourth state, where the corpuscular theory of light may be true, and where light does not always move in straight lines, but where we can never enter, and with which we must be content to observe and experiment from the outside.” Many of the scientists at that time worked intensely in this field and had certainly also used fluorescence screens and had by those means the conditions for the discovery of the radiation. It is, however, interesting to note how R¨ontgen at his sensational discovery investigated with scientific thoroughness the properties of the new radiation. Quickly and with superior experimental skilfulness R¨ontgen attained order in a field, that before had been completely outside human experience. It would Kai Siegbahn (1918 – 2007). Nobel Laureate in Physics (1981) University of Uppsala (Sweden) at the time of this address K. Siegbahn: From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy, Lect. Notes Phys. 746, 137–228 (2008) c Nishina Memorial Foundation 2008 DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-77056-5 8
138
Kai Siegbahn
last almost 17 years until any essentially new properties of this radiation were being added to those which R¨ontgen himself had found. One of R¨ontgen’s early observations, which would be significant in the medical use, was that when the cathode radiation in the tube scattered against platinum it appeared a harder radiation than when it scattered against aluminium, glass or other light materials. The most essential novelty for atomic physics in general was that one had found a radiation that could find its way through every kind of material and, in particular, could penetrate the before hidden interior part of the atom. In that way the necessary conditions had been created for a first analysis of the inner structure of the atom. The next break-through in the scientific field came first with the discovery of the diffraction of this radiation in crystals by von Laue, Friedrich and Knipping in 1912. Somewhat before, however, Barkla and others had with simple means furnished proofs of some properties of the R¨ontgen radiation, which had significance for the further development of atomic physics. After the penetration of aluminium foils the “soft” part of the radiation was quickly absorbed. Left behind was a rather homogeneous radiation. Allowing this “hard” radiation to strike an arbitrary plate, one could in the scattered radiation find three different components (Fig. 8.1). The
Fig. 8.1 The interaction of X-radiation with matter. One component is the scattered X-radiation with the same energy as the primary radiation from the X-ray tube. The second component is characteristic of the material being studied. In optical terminology this is the fluorescence radiation which developed into X-ray emission spectroscopy. The third component consists of electrons and is the basis for modern electron spectroscopy
first component consisted of scattered radiation of the same kind as the impinging one. The second component was secondary X-radiation which was softer than the impinging one and characteristic of the irradiated material. From the study of this characteristic radiation Barkla could distinguish between two series of radiation, which he called K- and L-fluorescence radiation. For a certain element the penetration of the K-radiation was 300 times higher than for the L-radiation. From these early observations X-ray spectroscopy was generally developed by means of the more and more refined X-ray diffraction methods. X-ray spectroscopy made possible an atomic analysis of different materials and led to the discovery of new elements like hafnium and rhenium. The shell structure of the atoms (Fig. 8.2) could be inves-
8 From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy
139
Fig. 8.2 X-ray emission spectrum (in Å) from the elements showing the three series K, L and M
tigated by X-ray spectroscopy, a field in which my father was deeply involved [1] and atomic physics was put on solid grounds. The third component of the scattered radiation was found to consist of electrons, which were expelled from the irradiated material. What happened in this field of spectroscopy? For a very long time it was shadowed by the successful study of X-ray spectroscopy. In the twenties spectroscopic investigations of the secondary electrons, the “photoelectrons”, were started by e.g. H. Robinson in England and M. de Brogue in France. They showed by means of magnetic deflection of the electrons, that also this component contained information on the shell structure of the atom and that one could obtain approximate values of the binding energies for the electrons in the different shells. This field turned out to be much more difficult to master and the accuracy was small. My interest in this third component began early in the fifties. For some time I had been concerned with techniques to investigate electrons, emitted in radio-active β decay. A suitable way to investigate the γ radiation was to cover the radioactive sample by a thin lead foil and to record the expelled photoelectrons from the foil by an electron spectrometer. This work gradually led to improved resolution in nuclear spectroscopy [2]. I was finally able to observe and measure the inherent widths of conversion-electron lines due to the finite widths of the atomic levels involved in the internal conversion process during the nuclear decay. In order to observe such phenomena a resolution of 1 : 104 at these energies, around 100 keV, was required. The investigations were performed by means of a magnetic double focussing iron
140
Kai Siegbahn
Fig. 8.3 ThB F- and I-lines. Internal conversion in the K and LI shells, respectively. At this high resolution one can notice the different inherent widths of these β-lines
free spectrometer with large dispersion (R = 30 cm). Fig. 8.3 shows the different internal widths of the F- and I-conversion lines in the decay of radioactive ThB, the former line converted in the K shell the latter in the LI shell. Most of the high resolution work in my laboratory during that period of time was performed with a large double focussing magnetic spectrometer with iron yoke (R = 50 cm) which was specially designed for studying complicated decay schemes of radioactive isotopes. The most complex of these was Au194 . It contained more than 100 γ-transitions, the conversion electron spectrum contained some 350 detectable lines. By means of a double counter operated in coincidence it was possible to detect lines of an intensity of 10−5 times that of the strongest lines. Fig. 8.4 shows a limited part of that spectrum. In these investigations both internal and external photoelectron spectra were taken and the final decay scheme, further checked by coincidence studies from selected nuclear levels, is reproduced in Fig. 8.5. My interest to investigate finer details in nuclear spectra continuously tempted me to go back to R¨ontgen’s original discovery and, more precisely, to the third component mentioned before and to see if new methods could be applied to atoms, molecules and solids using an X-ray tube instead of nuclear y radiation. For this purpose the above mentioned iron free double focusing instrument was constructed and adopted to investigating electron energies some orders of magnitude less than in nuclear decay. Robinson and some other scientists around 1925 had been able to establish that electrons expelled from metals by means of the photoelectric effect exhibited an energy distribution that was consistent with the shell structure of atoms which had been studied in much more detail by X-ray emission and absorption spectroscopy. During the thirties and forties much of the interest in atomic physics shifted to nuclear physics. Partly because of this and partly because of the lack of adequate methods for handling the experimental problems associated with electron spectroscopy the field had waited for its development and exploration.
8 From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy
141
Fig. 8.4 Part of the internal conversion β spectrum of Au194 . There are altogether 350 observable β lines in this complex decay, with intensity variations of 1 − 10−5
Fig. 8.5 Decay scheme of Au194 based on the internal conversion electron line and external photoelectron line spectra
142
Kai Siegbahn
The mentioned early period is represented by the top of Fig. 8.6 which shows a photographic recording of the photoelectron spectrum of gold by Robinson [3] in 1925. The various levels in gold are distinguished in Robinson’s spectrum and also in the corresponding photometric recording. The well-known NVI , NVII doublet, extensively used for calibrations in modern electron spectroscopy, is not observed in this early spectrum, however, and obviously the electron distributions rather resemble X-ray absorption distributions than true lines. At the later part of the fifties the work in my laboratory had led to the development of an electron spectroscopy which was characterized by narrow electron lines from solid materials excited by X-radiation. The recorded electron lines were well defined by widths set by the inherent atomic widths themselves. The state of the art during this period is illustrated by the recordings of the gold spin doublet made during the early 60’s in my laboratory (to the right of Robinson’s spectrum). The same spectrum taken some years later is shown in the middle of the figure on an energy scale expanded by a factor 600 compared to Robinson’s spectrum. The improvement in resolution between the two later spectra is due to the introduction of X-ray monochromatization by means of crystal diffraction of the AlKα radiation. This made it possible to pass beyond the previous limit set by the inherent width of the X-ray line. The lowest part of the figure illustrates one particularly important feature of electron spectroscopy. The difference between the middle and the lowest part of the figure demonstrates the surface sensitivity of this spectroscopy. A fingerprint on the gold foil completely wipes out the gold lines and replaces them by other lines dependent on what elements happened to be on the surface layer of that finger. Electron spectroscopy is nowadays an independent alternative to X- ray and other spectroscopies and contributes with much new information about the properties of matter. In particular surface science and technology makes use of electron spectroscopy as a convenient tool to characterize surface conditions and reactions. Applications are found in many other areas in the border lines between physics and chemistry. To emphasize these aspects the acronym ESCA (electron spectroscopy for chemical analysis) was introduced [4], [5]. The historical background is covered in several more recent works [6], [7], [8], [9].
2. Some Basic Features of Electron Spectroscopy In photoelectron spectroscopy the sample is introduced into vacuum and radiated with soft X-rays, ultra-violet light or synchrotron radiation. In addition, an electron beam can supplementary be used to excite Auger electron spectra by electrons and, if properly monochromatized, for electron scattering spectroscopy. A certain number of the electrons which are expelled from their atomic bindings may leave the surface layer without energy losses, the scanning depth being set by the energy dependent mean free paths. An electrostatic lens system collects and focusses the electrons onto the slit of the electron analyser. An extended detector is situated in the focal plane where the different electrons are simultaneously being recorded. These
8 From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy
143
Fig. 8.6 Some steps in the development of photoelectron spectroscopy excited by X- radiation. Upper figure to the left: the recording of gold as obtained by Robinson in 1925 with its photometer curve. To the right: the “gold doublet” photoelectron lines around electron binding energies of EB∼ 85 eV as observed after that photoelectron line spectroscopy had been developed at the end of the fifties. These and any of the other lines cannot be seen in the previous spectrum. The middle spectrum shows the same spectrum when X-ray monochromatization of AlKα at 1486.6 eV (Δhν = 0.2 eV) had been introduced. The gold doublet is inserted in this figure in an expanded scale ∼ 600 times that of the Robinson spectrum. The lower figure shows the surface sensitivity of electron spectroscopy. A fingerprint has wiped out the gold lines and produced new lines
144
Kai Siegbahn
Fig. 8.7 Scope of electron spectroscopy
events appear on the screen of a computer as a fence of separate electron lines (see Fig. 8.7). These lines characterize the examined substance, the elemental composition and the chemical bindings. Lid materials with elements over the whole periodic system can be examined and also gases down to low pressures ∼ 1 − 10−5 torr. The spectroscopy has been applied also to liquids and solutions. Extensions of electron spectroscopy are under way by using LASER radiation for citation (in particular resonance enhanced multiphoton ionization, MPI). Fig. 8.8 illustrates an atom which is bound to other atoms in molecular valence bondings, alternatively adsorbed or chemically bound to a rface. In order to eject electrons from the inner part of an atom he “core” region) harder radiation is required than for the external valance electron region. When an electron is emitted a hole is created the electron shell. This is immediately followed by a relaxation the other electrons which thereby adjust themselves to the new potential by means of a “shrinkage” and flow in the surrounding electron cloud. The hole has a certain very short lifetime (< 10−14 s) fore it is filled by an electron from some externally situated ell. The atom can dispose of the released energy either in the form of an X-ray photon or by emitting another (Auger) electron. In such a case three levels are involved (e.g. LMM etc.). Such electrons are recorded together with the primary emitted photoelectron spectrum. One advantage to excite Auger electrons by X-rays compared
8 From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy
145
Fig. 8.8 Citation of core and valence electron spectra
to electrons is the great improvement in signal to background. These conditions are further discussed later in this survey. When a chemical compound between two or more atoms is formed a redistribution of the external valence electrons of the atoms occurs which are responsible for the chemical bonds. The electric potential around a certain atom in the molecule will then be changed, to an extent which is dependent on the specific nature of the chemical bond in the different cases (e.g. at different “states of oxidation”). This new electric potential influences the bond strength of the inner electrons which surrounds the atomic nucleus and the consequence of this is a “chemical shift” in the recorded electron spectrum. This information is exceedingly important in electron spectroscopy. One can for example easily distinguish, even at modest resolution, between metallic atoms and those which have been oxidized at the surface layer. Fig. 8.9 shows such a case [10]. It concerns the surface of a silicon crystal and one observes in the electron spectrum taken at modest resolution two main lines which are due to the electrons from the 2s and 2p levels, respectively, from silicon. The spectrum also contains some satellites which are due to discrete energy losses of electrons. The difference between the lower and upper figure is that the crystal surface has been tilted so that the electrons in the latter case leave the sample at a small angle from the surface. Those electrons which come from below, from the “bulk”, are then absorbed to a larger extent than those from the outer surface layer. The surface layer is favoured. One can notice how the slightly oxidized silicon layer
146
Kai Siegbahn
Fig. 8.9 Spectrum of a slightly oxidized silicon surface. By tilting the crystal the oxide surface layer is emphasized. Plasmon lines are also observed
on the surface shows up strongly in the form of SiO2 lines to the left of the Si lines. They were only barely visible in the other spectrum. At improved resolution (Fig. 8.10) much more detailed information is obtainable concerning the depth composition at the oxidation [11]. This is a simple and commonly used method to distinguish between bulk and surface. The surface sensitivity is a small fraction of a single atomic layer, under certain conditions less than a percent of an atomic layer. The spectral resolution can be pushed much further than what is shown in Fig. 8.9 and Fit. 8.10. Fig. 8.11 gives a highly resolved spectrum of the Si2p1/2,3/2 doublet excited by means of monochromatized AlKα rays [12]. Here the doublet is completely resolved in two components instead of the unresolved one in the previous figure. The background is also very small, essentially zero. Small intensity structures can then be observed slightly above background. An increasing number of ESCA instruments are now in operation which are provided with X-ray monochromators for high resolution work. To a much less extent these are combined with a rotating anode. Still it is this combination which offers the best advantages for high resolution at high intensities. Ultimately, the recorded electron linewidths are set by the inherent levels widths. The use of an X-ray monochro-
8 From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy
147
Fig. 8.10 A study of the oxidation of a silicon surface taken at higher resolution by meas of the “tilting” method
Fig. 8.11 Well resolved 2p1/2 and 2p3/2 core lines of Si(111) at T=300 K and θ = 45◦ by means of monochromatized AlKα 1486.6 eV (Δhν = 0.2 eV) Observe the low background
148
Kai Siegbahn
mator significantly improves the conditions for accurate deconvolutions at the analysis of the spectra, since the lines are getting narrower and the signal to background ratio is enhanced. The electron lines due to X-ray satellites situated close to the real line structures are eliminated and so is the background due to bremsstrahlung. In photoelectron spectroscopy the recorded linewidths are lifetime and vibration limited. As an example carbon lines from polymers are usually rather broad by nature (> 1 eV). If the sample is an insulator one always has to take precautions to avoid charging of the sample surface. Methods have been developed to eliminate or greatly reduce such artifacts in the spectra. Usually an electron flood gun with very low energy electrons is used to flooding the sample or one may simply use the degraded flux of electrons from the X-ray electron production at the sample by surrounding the sample by a cavity with two holes, one for the X-rays and one for the expelled photoelectrons in the direction of the slit of the analyzer. A more recent arrangement, is to use an unfocused electron gun with electrons in the 1 keV region. Another recently developed method is to use a wire net at a defined potential fairly closely situated to the sample surface. A further possibility which will be further studied would be to rotate the samples during the exposure. These methods are convenient to apply when the X-ray beam is strongly focussed onto the sample. As a general rule the samples should be made as thin as possible and be deposited on a conducting backing. Some electron spectra will demonstrate the state of the art at good resolution [13]. Fig. 8.12 shows the electron spectrum of copper. One observes the core levels with their different widths and intensities. Close to zero binding energy the conduction band (3d4s) is recorded. This structure and similar ones from metals and alloys etc. can be separately studied in much more detail at larger dispersion (see e.g. Fig. 8.35 and Fig. 8.36). In the spectrum one also observes the Auger electron lines due to LMM transitions in the region excited by the same Alkα radiation. Fig. 8.13 shows the electron spectrum of an ionic crystal, KCl. The L and M sublevels for both elements are recorded and their linewidths are given in the figure. In the valence region (lower part) some energy loss and “shake-up” lines are shown. The shake-up line situated 5–6 eV from the Cl3s is due to a configurational interaction between the 3s2 2S ionic ground state and the 3p2 4s∗ , 3p2 4s∗ , 3p2 4p∗ and 3p2 3d∗2 S states. A strong shake-up structure situated 14 eV from the K3s is due to a configuration interaction between the 3s2 S ionic ground state and the 3p2 4s∗ , 3p2 4p∗ and 3p2 3d∗2 S states. The energy difference between the two outer bands of the cation and the anion, K3p adn Cl3p, respectively, is according to the figure 12.11 eV. This can be used to assign an ionicity for such binary crystals. Some examples of ESCA chemical shifts will be given here. The first one concerns Na2 S2 O3 , Fig. 8.14. There are two different sulphur atoms here which, according to classical chemical language, could be asso- ciated with oxidation numbers 6+ (central) and 2− (ligand). The ESCA chemical shift between the central S-atom (to the left) and the ligand S-atom (to the right) for the 2p1/2,3/2 doublet is 6.04 eV. This is evidently a large chemical effect, even larger than the atomic spin-orbit splitting, which is
8 From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy
149
Fig. 8.12 The copper spectrum showing core photoelectron lines, Auger electron lines and the conduction band
just resolved in the spectrum. The lower part of the figure shows the corresponding shift between the 2s levels. One observes here the larger inherent linewidths of the s-levels. The chemical shift is almost the same, 5.82 eV, but may give room for a small second order effect. The second example (Fig. 8.15) concerns the MgKLL Auger electron spectrum excited with AlKα radiation at different stages of oxidation. The upper curve is a clean metal surface, the lower is the oxide (with only a trace of metal) and the middle at intermediate oxidation. Series of volume plasmons (metal plasma collective oscillations) for each Auger line are observed, some of which nearly coincide with other Auger electron lines. The MgO peak, when growing up, happens to coincide with the second Auger electron peak of the metal. For comparison, the NeKLL Auger electron spectrum is given below. This spectrum contains a great number of satellites, which can alternatively be recorded in separate experiments in the gas phase by means of electron excitation. Inserted in the figure is the Mg2p photoelectron line and the chemical shift of this during oxidation. The chemical shift effect is frequently used in polymer technology for characterization of such materials. Fig. 8.16 shows the C1s core line splitting in five components in the case of Viton. The relative intensities between the lines depend on the branching ratio in the polymer chain. From the spectrum in Fig. 8.16 one can in this way distinguish between Viton 65 and Viton 80. Fig. 8.17 is a commonly used ‘test’ sample in ESCA, namely PMMA (polymethylmethacrylate). It is a polymer with wide-spread applications, e.g. in the pro-
150
Kai Siegbahn
Fig. 8.13 The spectrum of an ionic crystal, KCl. The different linewidths for this insulator are given in the spectrum. The ionicity is related to the energy difference 12.11 eV
Fig. 8.14 ESCA chemical shifts for S2p and S2s in Na2 S2 Q3
8 From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy
151
Fig. 8.15 MgKLL Auger electron lines at different stages of oxidation. Volume plasmons for each electron line are also observed. The chemical shift of the Mg2p line is inserted. The Ne Auger electron spectrum excited by electrons is inserted for comparison with Mg. This spectrum contains a great number of well resolved satellites [5]
duction of semiconductor chips by means of lithography. The polymer chain consists of the group indicated in the figure. A good instrument, e.g. one with well focussed X-rays, should be able to resolve sufficiently well the different carbon atoms in this group [14]. It is an insulator and therefore subject to charging if not the correct precautions have been taken to eliminate this effect. The inherent widths of the photo lines are partly set by internal vibrations in this case. It is therefore not possible to distinguish all the lines completely. However, with good statistics (high intensity, low background and monochromatic X-radiation) a reliable deconvolution can be made showing four carbon components on the ‘right’ places, which is good enough for a characterization of this polymer.
152
Kai Siegbahn
Fig. 8.16 ESCA spectra of the polymers Viton 65 and Viton 80 with different branchings in agreement with the measured intensities
Fig. 8.17 ESCA spectrum of the polymer PMMA, polymethylmethacrylate. The deconvolution into components and their positions characterizes the polymer
8 From X-Ray to Electron Spectroscopy
153
3. Monochromatization of the Exciting X-radiation. Instrumental Arrangements An ultimate factor in reaching high resolution is the monochromacy of the e