This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
where
+ ...+Bn
cos
rc#,
(2.47)
Bo = ±- f *G(R cos *)dtf, 2 T JO
Bi=-
1 T JO
f2n
G{R cos * ) cos j * d * ,
* = 1,2,3,...,
or Z
52 =
Y^
+
O
2~^
+
ID
3266^
+
--'
and so on. Since in the course of the analysis it is convenient to seek the solution at nominal frequency, Eq.(2.44) is presented in the form
g
+ fPy = ^ (y, ^ , r ) + (/?2 - \)y = ^L (y, £, r ) ,
where j32 — 1 is the relative detuning of the system.
(2.48)
60
way:
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications Obviously the ,,reverse" transition to real time t can take place in the following
t= f G(y)d* = ^ * + § - s i n * + § s i i i 2 * + ... + ^ s i i i n * . Jo P P 2/3 n(3 The oscillation period at time r is r0 = 2TT, and at the initial normalized time 2-KBQ
t it is respectively to = —7,— • The coefficient /?, which is close to one, is determined in the following way: P = —So , where uje is the frequency of the external action, uTO is the respective n
ujro
resonance frequency of the system when the oscillations are infinitesimal, m and n are integers taking into account the possible frequency division and multiplication regimes. The resonance frequency, conditioned by the non-isochronous character of the system, is determined as tor = ——. 0
The amplitude R and the phase ip in the solution of (2.46) are determined by the system of shortened equations ^ dW
i dV
= --H—
f
2/Kp
JQ
= -TJk^[
L[iJcostf,-/?i?sin¥,e(tf- ¥ >)]sintfdtf,
L[Rcoa9,-pR8ixi*,e(9-tp)]co8*d9,
(2.49)
(2.50)
ZTrp^K Jo
where e(* —
i,tr), synchronizing the oscillations. The input signal is
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
61
Fig. 2.12. Equivalent circuits of a non-autonomous oscillator with a negative resistance (a) and negative conductance (b) presented by an external oscillator of current is = I's cos(u>s£r +
^
+ f(x) = I, cos(fiai +
I. Here and henceforth BQ \BO J Bo +£, L . = ju-C0(U-
i r2* Bn = "• Jo
G{a cos*) cos n * d * ,
n=l,2
(2.67)
Using the Exps.(2.65) and (2.66), Eqs.(2.58), (2.59) and (2.60) can be written in the following complex matrix form:
[l
^ 0l
•j(r-i)
o
o
c
3
0
jT
0
—
1
o i ( r + i)J
o
3
Sa
i(r-i) —
3
f ' "T » ] x - ~ 6
I
[ « - f iJ
[
o
o
o
;T
0
o j ( r + i)_
f 1 T "1
-% \Y{lF)} + ~ 6
0
P
^
6
1 ^ 6
i • f '\
IY(SF)\
66
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications ff
Hia
^2LL
Fi(r-i) o o 1 ° 2 2 -\ o ;r o Ell Ho *il [r(^)] P[ 0 0 ;(r + l)J ^ ^ 2
L"2
r ff° -I
r i -sio ]
= £ "T L o
"T W '
1
-
i j
T
[ ! ^ °1 r [U{6F)]=fl
•
5a
-
1
3
sa
5a ^
-
o
r
^ a
[y(^)]- ^
5a
L o
^ - 1 ) 0
I
I
~T 1 -f
1
x -f
5a ^
(2-68)
0 jT
0 0
° i(r + i). H2a-
° ~2" ~2~ Ho ?£ [Y(6F)\,
F2a
(2.69)
fflfl
i j [^ ^o j ^ / = [ ^ ( l - r ) | ^ 1l-{l+ r)f-}[U{8F)}, T
(2.70)
where Ayr-il
i
Ayr
[ym\=
^ - , [um]=
r^T- 1 !
i
uT - ^ .
Determining [F(JF)] in Eq.(2.68) and substituting the Eq.(2.69) in Eq.(2.70) and after a series of mathematical transformations, the following expression for the low-frequency ,,input" impedance of the injection-locked oscillator is obtained: ZLf = (H0+jT)P, ,. where P = i1 + v n
(Sa)2
v
3
(2.71)
?r.
-*(t)
It is evident that the Eq.(2.71) can be presented as a real and an imaginary part: ZLf=R + jB. (2.72)
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
67
Fig.2.13 a, b shows the theoretical dependencies of the components of the -n
effective impedance - the resistance R (a) and the inductance —- (b) - on the detuning of the frequency v at Ho = 0,02, F = 0, 01 and for different values of the parameter Sa. It is obvious that the values of R and — depend essentially on the detuning in the oscillator locking bandwidth. At a certain degree of nonlinearity of the inductance in the oscillator resonance circuit (parameter 5), the effective low-frequency resistance R and inductance — can take negative values in a wide video frequency band of the input signals.
''s
Fig. 2.13. Theoretical dependences of the equivalent resistance R (a) and equivalent r> inductance — (b) of an oscillator one-port on the frequency detuning v \\s The experimental set-up includes a two-transistor model of a p — n—p — n-type device with a falling sector in the V/A characteristics and a nonlinear inductance (See Fig.2.14) Fig.2.15 exhibits the experimental dependence of the equivalent (effective) low-frequency inductance —— of an injection-locked self-oscillator with negative 0
resistance and nonlinear inductance on the locking frequency (detuning v) at different levels of the locking current If, and a fixed low test-signal frequency (Ibl>Ib2>Ib3)The theory and the experiment described above present an effective method of using the reversibility of the modulation parametric interactions to control the equivalent impedances of radiophysical circuits. It is evident that injection-locked oscillators can be considered, in relation to signals in a wide video frequency bandwidth, as one-ports with controllable parameters.
68
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 2.14. A two-transistor model o f a p - n - p - n type device with a falling sector in the Volt-Ampere characteristics and nonlinear inductance
Fig. 2.15. Experimental dependence of the effective (equivalent) low-frequency inductance of a synchronized oscillator on the frequency detuning of the synchronizing action, Ibl > h2 > h3 The phenomena associated with a change in the effective low-frequency impedance of an injection-locked oscillator with a nonlinear capacitance, or an oscillator working in a regime of synchronous frequency division and multiplication, in the respective locking bandwidths, have analogous qualities. The considered effects of alteration of the effective impedances of injectionlocked oscillators brought about by the locking conditions highlight on a number of low-frequency instabilities observed in oscillator systems with modern semiconductor devices, particularly in a SHF range (for example the spontaneous low-frequency excitations and the defects occurring in the active element in SHF oscillators with avalanche-drift diodes).
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
69
2.2.4- Analysis of the conversion properties of a one-port presented by a non-autonomous oscillator The conversion properties of a one-port presented by an injection-locked oscillator will also be considered on the basis of Fig.2.12a. The current of frequency Q,s is the input signal, while the voltage of frequency Afi = |fij — ils\ is the output signal, flj is the oscillating frequency of the injection-locked oscillator, £ls ~ Q&. We shall consider two cases: a) Q.s < Q,i (lower-sideband, main channel) b) fis > fij (upper-sideband, image channel) We shall account for the following spectral components: an output conversion frequency Aft = |ftj — fts| and combined frequencies (ftj, + ft,,) and (2ftj — ft,,). The selected spectrum helps account for the influence of the second harmonic of the time-varying impedance of the injection-locked oscillator. O R As the denotation a = —-— is introduced, the spectrum under consideration can be presented in the form: i) for the main channel: {SF} = F, 1 + F, 2 - F ii) for the image channel: {6F} = F, 1 - F, 2 + F, where F = (1 — a) is the output conversion frequency in a nondimensional (reduced to one) form, 1 ± F = 2 — a and 2 ^ F = 1 + a. Here and henceforth the upper sign corresponds to the spectrum of the main channel, and the lower one to the spectrum of the image channel. The matrices [I] and [E(6F)] are determined by using the following direct and inverse transformations: cos(fts< +
= Re { [-I1(6)c--'T* - Ii(fc)e-''(1±r>* + JitfOe*2^*] e^} , cos * F = cos[Afti + Tip] + high-frequency components, 1 H cos ^(1 ± F) = — ( 1 ± F)-=- cos[Afit + Tip] + high-frequency components, 2 £>o 1 B2 cos *(2 =F F) = - ( 2 ^ F)—— cos[Afl< + F^>] + high-frequency components, 2 2BQ
(2.73)
fi.Bi Q,SB2 where ^ = — — , ^2 = —^g~> & = >ps - atp.
Since the main purpose of the study is to determine the output voltage of conversion frequency Aft, the HF components in (2.73) should be neglected.
70
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications Equations (2.57)-(2.59) can be written as follows: 0
' j T O
1
o j(i±r) o 0 0 ;(2Tr)J 5a
L
— ,J x2
- ^
1
0
W
o
i
i[^T - -
P[o
J
°
0
x
- y ( L
^ 6
Sa ~T 1 0
-«
4
o 1 ^
i(l±T)
\u{6F)] = p
^
•
0
^
i(2Tr)J
r
Sa
(Sa)2 i
1
0
0
x
(j)2
[—
Sa
(Sa)4 "
4~~
1
0
o
i
g2a"
T
T
0
0
[Y(SF)} J
[Y(8F)\
^o J
~ T ~e~~ r-zi(^)-
- f (^«)2
—
^
J(2TT)
T
#ia
Fo
o
0
o
J
x
L
0
o j(i±r) [0 0
r
1
1
o
[Y(6F)} + -
=^
r
i
(5a) 2 "I
6
g
(Sa)2 6 hT
L-V- °
~T x
5a 3
5a
(5a)2 -
3 i
6 o
L0
6 (5a) 2 "I r ~6~ *" 0 [Y(6F)]~ ^f
L
Z(-).(+)=[i - I ( i ± r ) | i
^ z
o o
0
^ a ~2 Ho 0
;(2 T r)J
£T2a ] 2~ 0 [r(tff)],
[U(SF)]=
(2.75)
//0
i(2 T r)^|[t/(,5 J F)],
where Ayr 1 i [y(«F)]= Ay 1±r y-^, .Ay 2T rJ h t
(2.74)
r;r o o i(i±r)
Q
1
-/i(fe) , Uii(6)-
. ^ 1 Ui±r y ^ [U2WT\
S
(2.76)
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
71
As [Y(SF)] is determined from (2.74) and substituted in (2.75) and (2.76), the following expressions for the transmission impedance of frequency conversion are obtained: a) for the main (lower-sideband) channel Z<-> =R(-s>+jB(-~\
(2.77)
where
fo,(i-r-4,) _ -
R
i2(g)'r + 2(g)' ( 2 + 5r-u,)
^
_
Ho,
(2.77a)
-r fl(-)
8 ( f ) 5 r + 4 (T)^ 5 r + 9^
=-L-Ali
li;
;
(2776)
b) for the image (upper sideband) channel i<+)=,R(+)+jB<+\
(2.78)
where ^(+)
=
_ ^ _ _
Ho, (2.78a)
^r
8f^)5(r-,)-36(^)7(r-,)
B(+> = - | - - ^ z?1=i + 2 ^ )
^
^
V
3
;
,
(2.786)
r-4,/, zj2 = [-2(r + , / ) - 2 ^ y ( i - r - 9 I / ) ] 2 y j fl-0(i + r-9i/)]2, i?3 = [2(r-i/)
-2(Y)
(l-3r-8^)]2 + [ ( l - r - 8 ^
0
-2^
ffo(l-3r-8^)]2.
The analysis shows that the first terms in Eqs. (2.77a,b) and (2.78a,b) are conditioned by the action of the first harmonic in the time-varying impedance of
72
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
the injection-locked oscillator, while the second terms are mostly conditioned by the action of its second harmonic. Fig.2.16 shows the theoretical dependances of the transmission impedance of frequency conversion by main (solid line) and image (dotted line) channel on the detuning v. They are calculated by using formulae (2.77) and (2.78) at Hg = 0, 04, F = 0,01 and different values of the parameter 5a. For comparison, the dashdot lines show the value of the transmission impedance of frequency conversion of an autonomous oscillator. It can be seen that the oscillator conversion properties change considerably in the locking bandwidth. The low-sideband conversion (main channel) can be carried out with a signal amplification, whereas the upper-sideband conversion (image channel) can be suppressed.
Fig. 2.16. Theoretical dependence of the modulus of the transmission impedance of conversion on the detuning at Ho = 0.04 and T = 0.01 for different values of the parameter Sa: l(-),l(+), 1-0,1; 2("),2(+), 2 - 0,2; 3("),3<+), 3 - 0,3; 4(~),4(+), 4 - 0,4 Fig.2.17 presents the theoretical dependances of the maximum ratio of the transmission impedances of frequency conversion by main and image channel (|^'~^|/|Z' + )|) m a x , reached at certain detuning, on the oscillation amplitude of the injection-locked oscillator at F — 0, 01 and for different values of the parameter Ho- The pronounced extremum manifests the specificity of the oscillator-based frequency conversion - the typical dependence of the conversion properties on the oscillation amplitude.
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
73
Fig. 2.17. Theoretical dependence of the maximum values of the ratio of the transmission impedances of conversion by main and image channel on the oscillation amplitude in the non-autonomous oscillator at F = 0.01
Fig. 2.18. Theoretical dependence of the maximum values of the ratio of the transmission impedances of conversion by main and image channel on the output converted frequency at 5a = 0.3 The theoretical dependence of the maximum ratio (|Z^~^|/|Z^ + ^|) max on the output converted frequency for Sa = 0,3 and for different values of the parameter H o is plotted in Fig.2.18. Figs.2.17 and 2.18 show that within the locked bandwidth the ratio (|.Z^1~)|/|.Z(+)|)max can exceed 20 dB in the frequency bandwidth of the output converted (intermediate frequency) signal from 0 Hz to the borderline frequency, which represents 10-15% of the oscillation frequency of the non-autonomous generator. The conversion properties of the non-autonomous generator have been studied by using the experimental oscillator shown in Fig.2.14. Fig.2.19 shows the experimental dependence of the transmission impedances of frequency conversion |.Z(~")| and |.Z^ + '| on the locking frequency at signal frequency and current of fs = 3 kHz and Is = 50 nA respectively, and bias current Io = 0,11 mA. The dash-dot line shows the autonomous oscillator conversion level. The experiment corroborates the possibility of frequency conversion on the basis of an injection-locked oscillator with main channel amplification and simultaneous image channel suppression. The experimental dependence of the maximum ratio of the transmission
74
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 2.19. Experimental dependence of the transmission impedances of conversion in the frequency bandwidth of synchronization of the generator impedances of frequency conversion, achieved at a definite frequency of the locking action, on the output converted (intermediate) frequency is shown in Fig.2.20.
Fig. 2.20. Experimental dependence of the ratio of the transmission impedances of conversion on the output (intermediate) frequency Figs.2.21 and 2.22 illustrate the dependence of the conversion properties of the non-autonomous generator on the operating mode. By way of comparison, Fig.2.21 displays the experimental V/A characteristic Uo(Io) and the dependence of the oscillating voltage in the non-autonomous generator Ug on the bias current. Fig.2.22 shows the experimental dependence of the maximum ratio of the transmission impedances of frequency conversion and of the transmission impedances of conversion by the main channel on the bias current. It can be observed that the ratio (|2^~^|/|Z^|)inax reaches its maximum at a voltage amplitude in the self-oscillator considerably lower than the maximum value. The fact that the position of the maximum values of the dependencies (|Z'~'|/|Z' + '|) m a x and | ^ ^ ' | on the bias current coincide is characteristic, i.e. the conditions for attaining the maximum of the transmission impedances of frequency conversion through the main
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
75
Fig. 2.21. Experimental Volt-Ampere characteristic U0{I0) and dependence of the amplitude of the oscillating voltage in the generator Ug on the bias current 7o
Fig. 2.22. Experimental dependence of the maximum ratio of the transmission impedances of conversion and of the transmission impedances of conversion by main channel on the bias current channel overlap with the conditions for providing maximum suppression of the image channel. Qualitatively analogous changes occur in the transmission impedances of conversion by the main and image channel in the respective locking bandwidths in the cases when the oscillator operates in a mode of synchronous frequency multiplication or division. 2.2.5. Selective properties of an oscillator with asynchronous action The theoretical and experimental results of a study on the effect of a selective change (with respect to an external signal) in the effective impedance of a one-port, represented by an oscillator with weak asynchronous external action are outlined. Unlike the case considered above, now the frequency of the external action does not fall within the effective frequency bandwidth of synchronization, i.e. the external
76
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
impact is asynchronous. The effect related to a drastic change in the effective impedance of the oscillator one-port is manifested, when the frequency of the external signal is equal to the absolute difference between the own frequency of the oscillations in the generator and the frequency of the external asynchronous action. The analysis shows that the mechanism of the effect is of a regenerativeparametric character and that it is related to the appearance of a very characteristic peculiarity - synchronization of the oscillations in the generator with a combined tone, whose frequency is equal to the sum or difference between the frequencies of the external asynchronous action and the signal. As a result of this synchronization, the oscillations in the system acquire the necessary phase for the occurrence of regenerative parametric effects. The effect is manifested in a very narrow frequency bandwidth, where the above mentioned synchronization and the favourable phase are realized. This conditions the high selectivity of the system, which is actually a highly selective electrically tunable filter with a very high qualitative factor. A filter obtained in such a way is controlled by changing the frequency of the external asynchronous action. A detailed theoretical analysis of the effect has been carried out in [192] on the basis of a circuit equivalent to that in Fig.2.12a and Eq.(2.51), studied by the procedure presented above. The following expression for the equivalent impedance of the one-port, represented by an oscillator with asynchronous action with respect to the signal [192] has been obtained:
i = -[(r + i)^o+;(-r 2 + 2r-i)(i + 0]i r _ 1 + | 2 ( f ) 2 - i H0 + ;T(l + 0}i r +[(r-l)^H o -Kl-r) 2 (l + 0^]ir + 1 ,
(2.79)
where
(i-,Xr-D^+ft Ar-i
AT =
.
=
7 u\ + r(2-r)-j(r-i)(i--)ff0
c 2 [(i-,)(r-i)f + d -
-°i
= £(1 - v)e^--'\
'
n Dl
(1-,0-Cxr^
—H i-r 2 -ir(i--)i7 0
(^f)c2[(i-u)-c1rf'\ D>
Cl
>(r-i)(i-!).£*[i-,- Cl r£] w-v)(r
+ i)%
°2
(i-,)(r + i ) f r(2 + r)+j(r + i)(i--)ff0
C2 = jT (l - | ) 2^H0,
—
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
Dx = r ( i - r 2 )(2
- T ) -
3
( I -
77
| ) ffo(-2r3 + 3r 2 + r - 1 ) ,
D2 = T(v2 - 1 ) ( 2 + r ) + j (1 - 1 ) j? 0 (2r 3 + 3r 2 - r - 1 ) .
\z\
Fig.2.23 shows the theoretical dependencies of the impedance ratio —:—•—, l^lmax at calculated according to the formula (2.79), on the detuning v = ^—^ Ho = 0,02 and different values of the parameter Sa. The substantial change in the equivalent impedance of the oscillator with asynchronous action within a narrow frequency bandwidth can be clearly seen.
Fig. 2.23. Theoretical dependence of the impedance ratio -J—^— of a one-port, represented |Z|max
by an oscillator with asynchronous action, on the frequency detuning; Ho = 0,02 Fig.2.24 reveals the experimental dependence of the same impedance ratio \Z\ (i.e. dependence of the relative change in the impedance) on the signal —. l^lmax frequency fs. The oscillator used in the experiment has a two-transistor p—n—p — n structure (Fig.2.14) and its own generation frequency fg = 200 kHz, while the frequency of the external asynchronous action is /j = 151 kHz. A pronounced change in the equivalent impedance of the oscillator one-port in relation to external signals with frequency fs = 49 kHz is observed. The impedance of the oscillator with asynchronous action alters within a very narrow frequency bandwidth of the input signals f3, which can shift, within a wide range, along the frequency axis by simply changing the frequency of the external asynchronous action /&. The effect of the selective change (with respect to external signals) in the effective impedance of a one-port representing an oscillator with asynchronous action is manifested in a broad class of generator systems with modern semiconductor devices, particularly in the SHF range and is widely applicable. Some applications, important for special purposes, are presented in 2.4.
78
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
|2| Fig. 2.24. Experimental dependence of the same impedance ratio —J—•— of a one-port, [Z|max
represented by an oscillator with asynchronous action, on the signal frequency /„; generation frequency fa = 200 kHz, frequency of the asynchronous action fb = 151 kHz
2.3. Converting properties of receiving and transmitting SHF oscillator modules 2.S.I. Short-range self-detecting Doppler radars (autodyne systems) described by differential equations of the second order The generation of the oscillations to be transmitted, the high-frequency amplification of the received signal reflected by a moving object, the frequency conversion and low-frequency amplification of the Doppler component are all carried out by using one active element in the autodyne systems. The signal with Doppler frequency uio is received directly in the LF circuit of the autodyne (AD) Fig.2.25. In the case of a homodyne scheme of construction of the facilities for shortrange Doppler radars (Fig.2.26) the oscillations to be transmitted are generated by an oscillator (G), while the reflected signal is transmitted through a circulator to an external converter (CV) without amplification. Improved characteristics of the autodyne facilities for short-range Doppler radars can be obtained, if the generation and HF amplification of the reflected signal are carried out by using one active element, while the Doppler component is separated by means of an external converter - Fig.2.27.
Fig. 2.25. Classical short-distance Doppler radar (autodyne); AD - autodyne
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
79
Fig. 2.26. A homodyne Doppler scheme for the construction of a system of short-distance Doppler radars; G — oscillator, CV - frequency converter
Fig. 2.27. A Doppler autodyne system with external converter; G - oscillator, CV - frequency converter The systems in Fig.2.25, 2.26 and 2.27 are studied in the works [111, 196-205]. The autodyne and heterodyne processing of the reflected Doppler signal (Fig.2.25 and Fig.2.26) are compared in [201] and it is concluded that autodyne processing ensures a higher conversion coefficient than heterodyne handling. [202] indicates that from the viewpoint of its energy potential (the ratio between the dynamic range and the sensitivity of the system) the autodyne method is in no way inferior to the heterodyne one, while [203] specifies that the potential of the system, where the oscillator and the converter are coupled with a circulator, exceeds - by 20 dB - the potential of the autodyne, where the generation of the oscillations to be transmitted, the conversion and amplification of the small reflected signal are conducted by using a single active element. This section provides a detailed analysis and comparison of the conversion characteristics of the systems in Figs. 2.25 and 2.27. The analysis is carried out on the basis of the equivalent circuit of the autodyne system, including an oscillator with negative resistance - Fig.2.28, where GD_ is negative differential conductance characterizing the falling section of the voltampere characteristic io(U) and of the active nonlinear element. LpCp represents the resonator of the oscillator, Co and Lo($) are reactive parameters of the active device, $ is a total magnetic flux, Ri is the equivalent load of the generator, ib = Ib cos(ujbtr +
80
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 2.28. An equivalent circuit of an autodyne system containing an oscillator with negative resistance differential equation: if*
i
rfif,
$
LD($)
(2.80)
+ LP
U = -r~ is the voltage of the oscillator circuit. dtr We use the following approximating expressions:
where Gn, L'n are coefficients, Lo is the inductance at the operating point. As non-dimensional parameters and symbols are introduced - x =
——, U oo
(Uoo is normalizing voltage), t = iorotr, wT0 = —•.• =., C = Co + Cp, / LOLP
Q=uroCRL, f(x)=x (l+J2Lnxn),Ln \
t^\
)
= -^f- f^-Y, ^=nb, ^ = n 0 , Lo + Lp \UroJ
Uro
iOro
Us = ~ ^ , Ub = ^ - , Eq.(2.80) takes the form L>oo
Uoo
d%x
_•_ ft \
l
tr
R
^\dx
R l
X^r
n™-1
+ -£ cos(ttat + Vs) + -£ cos(ttbt + tph).
(dxY (2.81)
In accordance with the analytical approach developed in 1.4, we shall present the solution of Eq.(2.81) in the form x = i o + A i , where Ax is a small perturbation conditioned by the action of the reflected signal. Then Eq.(2.81) is expressed in the
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
81
form of two equations concerning the major generator oscillations xg and the small variation in these oscillations Ax: i a
d2xo
s
1( r
^dxo
p
RL
\ ^
r TTn-i
fdxo\"
+ -^cos(fi 0 *+ ¥>,),
ax
at2
Q
(2.82)
at
~ f E G^o~ln ( ^ ) " " ^
+ | cos(n6t + Vl ).
(2-83)
The nonlinear transformation of the variables [185] and the respective denotations, described in 1.4, are used to rewrite Eqs.(2.82) and (2.83) as follows: „
d2Vo
—
+ yo=2vy0
1
( r
o
udyQ
RL ^
!
+ —(G1RL-l)—-—}^GnU00
2
/dyo\n
P ^—J
+ ^ G ( y o ) c o 8 ( f i o * + V.),
^ -^E
G
^
^
»^""
l n
^ '
8 n
"
2
^ (^)
B
^
(2.84)
-
^
'
^
1^[G(yo)Ay] + ^ G ( y 0 ) c o s ( ^ i + ^ ) ,
(2-85)
where Ay ~
, 1v = /32 — 1 = — — - relative detuning in the case of a G(y0) _ _ wro non-autonomous regime in the oscillator system of the autodyne, / i < l . We shall characterize the converting properties of the autodyne systems by using the conversion coefficients y±o 0 ±o D , „ V±aD (n Q(,^ f7 a n d K±QD = ———, (Z.iSb) Ub Ub where V±no±nD is the voltage of the combined frequencies (±fio i &D) fed at the external converter (Fig.2.27); V±QD is the output converted voltage with Doppler frequency fi = — (Fig.2.25). „ K±ao±nD
LJro
=
82
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
In (2.80) and further on in the text the sign ,,±" before fto corresponds to a relative moving away or approaching of an object in relation to the autodyne system, while the sign ,,±" coming before the own frequency fio of the oscillator determines the respective sum or difference combined frequencies (±f2o i fl/j)For the purpose of determining V±QO±QD, we derive an expression for the relative change of the voltage of the oscillating circuit of the generator under the action of the reflected signal (Fig.2.28): (2.87)
As a certain spectral volume {6F} of the generator oscillations, conditioned by the action of the reflected signal, is set, (2.85) and (2.87) will be rewritten in a complex matrix form: [D(6F)][Gr}[D(SF)}[G}[Y(SF)] + ±[K][Y(SF)]
-
+ Y/tnf3n-2[D(6FW-1[Y}"-1lD(6F)}[G}lY(6F)]
8-[D{6F)][G}[Y{8F)}
= ^[G][T],
[U(6F)] = P\Gr}[D(8F)}[G}[Y(8F)}, where 6 = ^(GiRi ^
- 1), 6n = ?±nGnVn0~\
-* [Gn, [G(y0)}^
coS(nbt + 9b) -> [/]; ^
(2.88) (2.89)
n = 2,3,...; G(y) -> [G],
- [A1; A , - . [Y(SF)}- ±
-+ [D(SF)};
-» [ [ / ( ^ ) ] ; y0 - [^]-
The output voltage of frequencies (±fio ± ^ n ) is V±no±nD - [f?(«F)][I/(«F)],
(2.90)
where [E(SF)] is the matrix of the reciprocal conversion to the output variables, accounting for the contribution of each spectral component from the selected spectrum {SF} in the output signal at frequency (±fto ± &D)In the absence of a reflected signal (it = 0) (2.84) yields a solution for the basic oscillations in the system 2/0 = acos(/3r + tp) = a cos*,
(2.91)
where the equations concerning the amplitude a and the phase (p are written in a way analogous to (2.62).
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
83
The analysis shows that when the output signal of the system presented in Fig.2.27 is taken off at the level of combined frequencies (±fto ± ^ D ) , the largest contribution comes from the spectral components ±ft/), (±fto±ftzj), (±2ft o ±^£>), which also constitute the selected range of the oscillation spectrum. The latter can be presented in the form {AF} = ± r , ± l ± I \ ± 2 ± I\ where T = D °. If we restrict the approximating polynom of the function f{x) = x + Lx2 to the second power, we can derive the following approximating expressions:
Lx2 y= z+ ^-,
[G(y)]2d^
2 G(x) = l--Lx,
G(y) =
2 l--Ly,
(2.92)
= l + lLy.
When determining matrixes [/] and [E(SF)], the following direct and inverse transformations are made:
cos(fi6t
+ n) = Re UTh f(±i ± r ) | i ] e^(±r)* + c;(±i±n* ± h f(±i ± r) J-l ei(±2±n J ey[*..-(±i±r)V]|)
[
B 1 ± r - ^ cos[(±fi0 ± «D)< + (=Fl ± F)VJ] + HF components,
cos[(±l ± r ) * ] = cos[(±fi0 ± ^D)< + (±1 ± T)tp] + HF components,
coS[(±2 ± r)*] = T h [(±2 ± r ) y | cos[(±ft0 ± no)* + (±1 ± T)tp] + HF components, (2.93) f-T
where Ii is a modified Bessel function, t = I G(acos^)dr
B1
J°
— s i n * + ..., Bo and Bj are determined by (2.47) and (2.67).
D
= —(\I> — y>) +
^
As (2.91) - (2.93) are taken into account, the square matrixes in (2.88) and
84
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
(2.89) can be specified for the case under consideration as follows: r
r±r [D(6F)]=
0
I°
o
o
j(±l±r)
0
°
La
1
i(±2±r)J
,
[G]= - ^
^
L [
i
^1
f
[cn=
(La)2 1
["
La
,
3
3 (La)2 -
-
4 ' (2-94)
(La)2 La
TJi[(±l±r)-J-]
W =
- ~
_^
i 4 ' [AI= T '
(La)2
3
1
3 l±
:
(La)2 -
~3
2
^ °,<53/5P(^)]2[r]2=
o 2
L [E(6F)}=^h[(±T)^]
1
"
2
^
o 2
, .
T/1[2±2±r)^]].
As (2.94) is taken into account and Eq.(2.88) is used as a starting point, the following is determined: [Y(6F)] = [A]-^[G][I],
(2.95)
where [A] = [D(6F)][Gr}[D(6f)][G} + ^{K]-S-{D(6F)}[G}
+ 63p[D(6F)]2[Y}2[D(6F)}[G].
Then (2.89) yields [U(6F)} = [V(SF)}[Y(SF)}=Ub
' V±T ' V± 1 ± r .
(2.96)
V±2±T _
As (2.96) is substituted in (2.90) and (2.94) is taken into account, an expression for the conversion coefficient is obtained:
K±no±nD =
V±n£UD
=V±i±r ± ^ {±rV ±r + [±2 - (±2v) ± r]^ ± 2 ± r } . (2.97)
Fig.2.29 reveals the theoretical dependence of \KQO+QD | on the parameter S, reflecting the regeneration degree in the oscillating circuit of the generator at v — 0
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
85
and F = 10~7. A common parameter of the dependence is La, characterizing both the nonlinearity of the reactive characteristic of the active element and the level of the oscillations in the generator. As the value of 8 goes up, the conversion coefficient \Kno+sir> I falls, furthermore, the degree of the decrease depends on the amplitude a of the own oscillations of the generator. Given a constant 6, the coefficient |7^n0+nD | tends to its maximum value, when the amplitude of the oscillations in the generator tends to zero - this is one of the characteristic peculiarities of the system in Fig.2.27.
Fig. 2.29. Theoretical dependence of the conversion coefficient up to the sum combined frequency on the regeneration degree in the oscillating circuit of the autodyne oscillator; v = 0, T = 10~7 The analysis shows that the expressions obtained for K±QO±QD (2.97) display certain symmetry, where the following conversion coefficients are identical: K+na+nD
= K*_aa_nD,
K+a0-^D
=
K*_na+nD,
where „*" is a symbol of a complex conjugate quantity. Owing to this property, the total conversion coefficient of the system in the case of an approaching object is identical to the total coefficient in the case of an object moving away, all other conditions being equal. This is another essential peculiarity of the system in Fig.2.27. Fig.2.30 presents the theoretical dependence of the module of the conversion coefficient of the system in Fig.2.27 to the total combined frequency (Q,o + fie): |-ft'f20+nD| ( o r l-K"-fio-nD I)) o n t n e non-dimensional Doppler frequency F and various detunings in the locking frequency bandwidth (non-autonomous mode of the autodyne generator), 6 = 10~7 and La = 10~3. In the case of zero detuning [y = 0) the coefficient \KQO+HD | is at its maximum, when F —> 0 and it drops as the Doppler frequency increases. When the detunings in the locking frequency bandwidth are negative [y = —10~3, v = —10~5), high selectivity with respect to the Doppler frequencies, approximately equal to the respective detunings, F = u, is observed. There is no such selectivity in the case of positive detunings.
86
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 2.30. Theoretical dependence of the conversion coefficient up to the sum combined frequency on the reduced non-dimensional Doppler frequency at various detunings (non-autonomous mode of the autodyne generator); S = 10~7, La = 10~3 Fig.2.31 presents the theoretical dependence of the coefficient |_Kjjo_(jD| (or \K-no+nD\) on r for S = 1(T 7 , La = lO" 3 . At v = 0 the coefficient \Ka^aB may have considerable values for small magnitudes of F. Monotonic decrease of \Kflo-£lD | is observed in the cases of both negative and positive detunings: there is no selectivity to the Doppler frequency.
Fig. 2.31. Theoretical dependence of the conversion coefficient up to the difference combined frequency on the reduced non-dimensional Doppler frequency at various detunings (non-autonomous mode of the autodyne generator); S = 10~7, La = 10~3 The dependence in Fig.2.29 reveals the contradiction in the requirements concerning the choice of the amplitude and oscillations in the autodyne generator presented in Fig.2.27. As the amplitude decreases, the conversion coefficient is increased but parallel with that the level of the reflected signal Ub = ja drops. It should be expected that there is an optimal amplitude aopt, at which the sensitivity of the system reaches its peak. Fig.2.32 presents the theoretical dependence of —|A'_n o _n D | on the 7
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
87
parameter La. Curve 1 illustrates the case of v = ±10~ 3 , F = 1CP7. A pronounced extremum at relatively high amplitudes is observed {La = 0 , 1 . . . 0,3). For v =• 0, or in a selection mode v = F, when the conversion coefficient \K-ua-nD | soars, the extremum is shifted to the area of small values of the parameter La (curve 2 in Fig.2.32, F = 10~7). The effective realization of these modes is highly dependent on the level of the system's own fluctuation noises.
Fig. 2.32. Theoretical dependence of the reduced conversion coefficient up to the difference combined frequency on the parameter La at 8 = 10-7, curve 1 - v - ±10~3, T = 10"7, curve 2 - v = 0, T = 10"7 It can be concluded that for the purpose of a most comprehensive utilization of the mode set by a high conversion coefficient at zero detunings, or of the mode of selective amplification, the functions of generating the probing signal and receiving the reflected signal should be separated and that two different oscillators should be used - a powerful and a low-powered one. In the system shown in Fig.2.27 the oscillation spectrum of the autodyne (fto ± ^ D ) , f^o, (—^0 ± &D) is communicated to an external converter CV. The conversion coefficients of a passive frequency converter with respect to the sum and difference frequencies are determined as K+ = - ^ -
and
K- =
- ^ ~ ,
where V±QD is the Doppler frequency voltage at the exit of the converter CV. Then, as (2.86) is accounted for, the cumulative transmission coefficient of the autodyne system presented in Fig.2.27 is K-z =
VD
p-
Ob
= K+Kn0±nD
+
K-K~na±n
The coefficients K+ and K-. reflect the losses in the specific passive converter.
88
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
The conversion coefficient of the system in Fig.2.25 can be determined in a way analogous to the one recounted above. Since a similar problem was solved in section 2.2 we shall abstain from deriving expressions for the coefficients K±aD here. The dependence of K±QD on the parameter S characterizing the degree of regeneration is qualitatively analogous to the respective dependence in the case of a system with an external converter - Fig.2.29. However, within a certain range of the locking frequency bandwidth, the conversion coefficients of an object that is moving away (K+fiD) may differ substantially from those of an approaching one (A""_nD). This is a disadvantage of the short-range self-detecting Doppler radar system with an injection-locked oscillator shown in Fig.2.25 as compared to the system in Fig.2.27 under an analogous mode of operation. It is also essential that the dependence of the conversion coefficient K±QD on the amplitude of the self-oscillator exhibits a pronounced extremum at La = 0 , 1 . . . 0,3. An important distinction in this case is that when the amplitude of the oscillations in the generator tends to zero, K±nD also tends to zero. The above-described analytical approach based on the method of a phase plane with nonlinear conversion of the variables and the perturbation method allows to conduct an effective analysis of autodyne, conversion, modulation-parametric and other processes and modes in autonomous and non-autonomous oscillator systems, experiencing the action of small external signals. 2.3.2. Short-range self-detecting Doppler radar systems described by differential equations of the third order The analysis will be carried out on the basis of the equivalent circuit of the short-range self-detecting Doppler radar system (autodyne system) presented in Fig.2.33, containing an oscillator with negative resistance. The bias circuit will be accounted for as it sets the mode of the active device, and parallel with that, it serves as a load in a mode of immediate Doppler frequency output (Fig.2.25). The active device in the circuit is represented by the active G and reactive (capacitive) element linked with a parallel connection and described by the characteristics i(U) and C(q), where i(U) is an active component of the current, U is the voltage of the generator oscillating circuit, C(q) is the nonlinear capacitance of the active device, q is the flowing charge. The influence of the bias circuit is accounted for by introducing the pair RTC into the equivalent circuit; it is assumed that RTC
and RTC 3> —, CJ is the
frequency of the oscillations in the autodyne generator. The equivalent HF load is represented by the resistance R, the signal reflected by a moving object is given through the voltage source Er. The processes occurring in the circuit in Fig.2.33 can be described by a system
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
89
Fig. 2.33. Equivalent circuit of an autodyne system containing an oscillator with negative resistance and accounting for the direct current load circuit of three differential equations of the first order — = -i(U) - iL - iR ET
=
-
1 R R +
^ )
(2-98)
U C
where Uc is the voltage of the circuit RTC, tr is real time. The characteristics of the nonlinear active device are presented in the form (2.99)
t(U) = -G1U + G2U2, C(q)=-^r,
where G\, G2, C[ are coefficients, Co is the capacitance at the operating point. The following non-dimensional parameters and notations are introduced: x =
— (Uoo is normalizing voltage), t = tTujQ: f = CoU00
is a relative detuning, U!
to0 = — = is a resonance frequency of oscillation with an infinitesimal amplitude, \/LCQ
C1 1 1 Q = UJQRCO, C = "77> ^1 = —,-,„ , 6 = 7r(Gi-R— 1) is a parameter characterizing O
UIQCHT
Q
the degree of regeneration in the generator oscillation circuit. As (2.99) and the notations introduced above are accounted for, (2.98) is reduced to the following equation of the third order: d^
+
{l-i)^{ax-8f{x)
+
P[f{xf}
+ (l-O2jt{Cx + xf(x) + a0[f^)}2}
+ (1 -O 3 {T/(-)+cm-)?} =
l-^d^+(1-^%
(2-10°)
90
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
where f(x) =
q
= x(l - C n ) , d = C[UooC0, a = <5x + £ , f3 = v
<->oo'~'\
^Uoo, y
The solution of equation (2.100) is presented in the form x = xo + Ax,
(2.101)
where xo is a function, corresponding to the basic oscillations in the autodyne generator, given the absence of an external signal (£r = 0), Ax is the variational spectrum of the oscillations under the action of a small reflected signal £T. As (2.101) is substituted in (2.100) and the fact that Ax is a small variation of XQ is taken into account, the following are obtained: — an equation for the basic oscillations
^ r + (i - O ^ H - 6f(Xo) + /?[/(z0)]2} + (1 - 0 2 ^{C*o + x/(z 0 ) + «/?[/(zo)]2} + (1 - f)3(7/(^0) + C/?[/(*o)]2} = 0;
(2.102)
— an equation concerning the variational spectrum
4£ + o-o£{H^ + w^H
+ u-^{[c + .^ + **/(,)^H
+ (l-0'{[7 + 2OT(I.)]%^Ai}
-^<'-o"!f"
(2.103)
As the resonance nature of the system is accounted for, the solution for the basic oscillations is presented in the form xQ = Do cos(i + Q)-E.
(2.104)
If Eq.(2.102) is written out in the form —— + -7- = pF ( ~7Y' "J~' •E' * ) '
wnere
[x
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
91
equations concerning the amplitude Do, the phase 0, and the additional small charge E, appearing in (2.104) can be presented in the form
dE dt
1 f2* 2TT JO
P
(d2x \dt2'
dx dt'
\ )
For the purpose of solving Eq.(2.103) we need to set a certain volume of a spectrum accounting for {SF}. The already familiar two cases are considered again - first, when the initial signal has a Doppler component e = (Fig.2.25), CO
and second, when the initial signal has a sum or difference combined frequency (±1 +e). As we take into account the possibility for the occurrence of modulationparametric regenerative phenomena in the case of mutually reversible conversion of the frequencies e and (±1 +e), as well as the conversion of the latter in the presence of the second harmonics in the spectrum of the pulsatory nonlinear elements G(U) and C(q) of the active device (2.99), we determine the following spectrum: {6F}=e,
1+e,
-1+e,
2 + e, - 2 + e.
(2.105)
As (2.105) is taken into account, the variational spectrum of the basic oscillations in the autodyne generator can be presented in the form of a matrix column [Ax] = colon[z2+£, xi+e, xe, x_i + £ , x_ 2 + £ .
(2.106)
Given conditions (2.105) and (2.106), Eq.(2.103) is written in a complex matrix form: [D]3[Ax] + (1 - OID}2{{* ~ S[DF] + 2P[FDF)][Ax}} + (1 - 02{D}{[( + *[DF} + 2aP[FDF}}[Ax}} + (1 - £)3{[y[DF\ + 2(l3[FDF}}[Ax}}
= l^i[D]2[E^]
+ (1 - £ ) 2 | [ £ P ( ± ) ] ,
(2.107)
where , — ->• [Z?] =
•j(2+e) 0 0 0 0
0 0 j ( l + e) 0 0 je 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 j(-l+e) 0
0 0 0 0
"
j(-2 + e).
,
(2.108)
92
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications •
df(x )
1
-CiA)
~ClDo
-^-^->[DF}
0 0 0
=
,,, f{Xo)d^
k12
~* [FDF]
=
ATH
kl2 =
£r-+[E{+]]
o£T —> [^~^] = fo[-Eo
0 ] = ^o 0 1 .0.
h i u
0 -CXDO 1
,
(2.109)
'
(2'110)
k12
k14: k13 fci2 fcn.
k13 = -3-ClDl
0" 1 0 0 .0.
"
&12 ^ 1 3 A;14
^ 12 ^ " h2 fci4 ki3 k12 k
^(l+3-ClDl),
= £0[E(0+)] = £0
0
°
fcl3
. 0
ku=-3-ClDl
0
°
1 -dDo -CiDo 1 0 -Ci-D0 fci2 A;13 A;i4 0
-dDo 0 0 "fcn
-.
0
~ClD°
1
kli= -\clDl-
- for an approaching object,
(2.111)
- for an object that is moving away, (2.112)
El
£o =
Uoo
is a relative amplitude of the signal reflected by a moving object.
As (2.108) - (2.112) are taken into account, Eq.(2.107) is presented in the form + (1 - 0^{D}}[E(o±}l
[A][Ax] = £o^{[Df
(2-113)
where [A] is a common matrix of the coefficients on the left-hand side of (2.107), [A] = [ a ; , m ] ,
i,m =
l,...,5.
After denoting Wu = (1 - 0 ( - « + 6 + 3^dZ?02), W12 = (1 - 0(7 " KPC^Dl), W13 = (1 - 0(( + "- ZctPCDl), W 21 = (1 - 0 A > ( - « C ! - /?5), W 23 = (1 - 02Do(-"Ci
S = 1 + |c 2 i? 0 2 ,
VF22 = (1 - O 3 -Do(-7<^i + C/SS1),
+ <*PS), W31 = |/3(1 - OCiDg,
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems W32 = -W31CU " 0 \
W33 = -totPCiDlil
W41 = - | / 9 ( 1 - OClDl
W42 = -W41((l
-
93
i)\
- 02,
( (2 + e) n ) W43 = -W41a(l
- 0\
{Zn}={
en
},
n = 1,2,3,
( - l + e)n (-2 + £)n J we obtain the following expressions for the elements a;]7n of matrix [A]: an ' 0.22
!
a33 a 44 ass •
= Wn{Z2} + W12 + j(W13{Z1} -
{Z3}),
ai2 • 032, a 3 3 > = W 2 i { Z 2 } + W 2 2 + i T y 2 3 { Z 1 } , •243, <245
a 54
f
al3
1
I a 3 l, a 35 V = W 3 l { Z 2 } + W 3 2 + j W 3 3 { Z 1 } , ^
«42 O53 ^
) Zl \=W^Z2} ^a52
+
W^+JWA3{Z1},
)
ai5 = as 1 = 0. Using (2.111) and (2.112) we arrive at equations concerning the variational spectrum of the oscillations in the autodyne: — for an approaching object 1_£ [Ax] = —±(l + e)[A]-1£0 V
0 -{l+e)+jS1(l-0 0 0 0
;
94
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications — for an object that is moving away 0
1-f [Ax} = —±(-l+e)[A)-1£0 V
° 0 -(-l+e)+j 6,(1-0 0
The conversion properties of the systems in Fig.2.25 and Fig.2.27 will be characterized through the conversion coefficients determined, respectively, by the variation of the voltage AUc of the low-frequency load RTC and the variation of the voltage AJ7 of the autodyne generator oscillating circuit. The coefficient of conversion into Doppler frequency e in the system shown in Fig.2.25 is
_AUC XLIQ
_ I AUC _ I C j to
Uoo
n
t-o oi (_
f,dAx
at
+ [-1(1 - SQ) + 2)9/(xo)] ^ A x } £ .
(2.114)
The coefficient of conversion into combined frequencies from the spectrum (±1 + e) in the system shown in Fig.2.27 is
fe,4
-fro
= H«A.} to I
ill
J (±i+E)
.
(2.15)
As the inverse matrix [A]""1 is presented in the form [A]^ = [
I
K(±l + c = ^ ? T (X
+ e ) [ - C l j D ° ( 9 « + 2«32
+ «52) + 922 + 942]62;
(2.116) (2.117)
— for an object that is moving away
A'f-) = ^ ( - 1 + e)bS{j(l Q b\
- 0^934 + ^ ( 1 - &Q)[CxDa{q2i + qAi) Q
- 934] + 2/?[fc13(9i4 + 2g34 + 954) + ^12(924 + 944)]},
(2.118)
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
^±T+« = ^Tri-1
+ e)[~CiD0(q14 + 2q34 + q5i) + g24 + q4i]k,
95
(2.119)
where 62 = - ( 1 + e) + j6i(l - £)> ^ = - ( - 1 + e) + J«i(l - 0A numerical experiment has been the transmission characteristics of the described by differential equations of numerical example has been conducted
made on the basis of (2.116) - (2.119) and autodyne systems in Fig.2.25 and Fig.2.27, the third order, have been studied. The for the typical properties of the parameters:
e = l(T 7 ,6 = 10- 7 , <Si = 1(T 7 , D o = HT 2 , £ = 0, ft = 0,1, G2 = 0,01, Q = 50, in addition, the influence of each parameter within a set range of alteration of its values has been examined. The illustrations presented here cover mainly the case of an approaching object. The dependencies for the case of an object that is moving away are described on a comparative basis only when presenting the selectivity effect of the autodyne, related to the detuning of the oscillations with respect to the resonance frequency U>Q . In practice the detuning of the oscillation frequency is achieved by communicating the respective synchronizing signal. The dependence of the conversion coefficients JQ and K±±+e on the parameter 8 characterizing the degree of regeneration in the autodyne generator is qualitatively analogous to that in Fig.2.30. An interesting point in the case under consideration is the influence of the load in the bias circuit on the conversion properties. Fig.2.34 a, b presents the dependencies of the conversion coefficients iQ and K±1+£ on the parameter Si, which is inversely proportional on the time constant RTC. The figure shows clearly that the conversion properties of the autodyne system in Fig.2.25 can be controlled by changing the load RT in the bias circuit. The dependence of the conversion coefficient K±1+£ of the system in Fig.2.27 on ^i is by far smaller.
Fig. 2.34. Theoretical dependence of the conversion coefficients in an autodyne system on the time constant of the direct current load circuit The dependence of the conversion coefficients on the amplitude of the oscillations Do in the autodyne oscillator is illustrated in Fig.2.35. As with the autodyne system of the second order, the conversion properties in the case of an
96
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
immediate output at a Doppler frequency (Fig.(2.25)) have an optimum by the value of the amplitude Do, while the conversion coefficient K±{+c of the system in Fig.2.27 is the larger, the smaller the value of D o is. As the regeneration degree of the circuit in the system presented in Fig.2.25 grows, the extremum of the dependence shown in Fig.2.35 is shifted in the direction of the larger values of Do. This is clear, bearing in mind that the system is quite sensitive for small values of 6 and, respectively, small values of Do, when the oscillations do not essentially cover nonlinear sections of the characteristics of the active element. As the system gets ,,tougher" when 6 increases, there should be a corresponding increase in the pulsations of the impedance of the active element, which is achieved by increasing D.
Fig. 2.35. Theoretical dependence of the conversion coefficients in an autodyne system on the oscillation amplitude in the autodyne oscillator Fig.2.36 a,b demonstrates the ,,thin structure" of the dependence of the conversion coefficients Ke in the area of zero detuning. For the sake of comparison we have provided the coefficients of the dependencies both for an approaching object (JQ ) and for an object that is moving away (/Q ). The plots in Fig.2.36a have been built for relative values of the Doppler frequency e — 10~7, while the plots in Fig.2.36b - for e = 10~4. As in the case of an autodyne of the second order, the dependencies are characterized by pronounced selectivity at e = |£|. The extreme values of the coefficients Kg and Kl are determined by the sign of the detuning - in the case of negative detunings the coefficient Kl reaches the corresponding extreme value, and in the case of positive detuning the coefficient K\ does so. When each of the coefficients is at its extreme value, the value of the other coefficient is substantially lower. In principle we can imagine that the existence of such a peculiarity as the ,,thin structure" of the dependence of the coefficients K.\ and Ke on the sign of the detuning can be used for determining the direction in which the object moves by way of periodical detuning of the oscillations in the autodyne within a certain narrow bandwidth with the help of an external swept-frequency synchronizing generator. While accounting for the relatively small values of the Doppler frequencies in comparison with the frequency of the signal emitted by the autodyne, in practice one should primarily consider the possibility to change the
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
97
coefficient of conversion due to the unstable frequency of the self-oscillator within the range of deviations comparable to the range of the Doppler frequencies. This should also be taken into consideration in the cases when the performance of the autodyne generator is stabilized through an external synchronizing action, which shifts the frequency of the emitted signal insignificantly. The striking selectivity already demonstrated in Fig.2.36 is only manifested for relatively small values of the regeneration parameter 8.
Fig. 2.36. Illustration of the ,,thin structure" in the dependence of the conversion coefficients in an autodyne system in the area of zero detuning: a - s = 10~7; 6 - e = 10~4 The dependence of the coefficients Ke and K±\+e on the value of the Doppler shift of the frequency e is qualitatively analogous to that in Fig.2.31, and it is substantially reduced as the value of 8 increases. The dependence of the conversion coefficient K±i+e on the parameter C\, characterizing the degree of nonlinearity of the capacitive characteristic of the active device is illustrated in Fig.2.37. When the values of 6 are small (for example 5 = 10~7), the role of C\ in the process of the initial spectrum formation (±1 + e) is relatively limited. The extreme value of the dependence corresponds to the relatively small values of Ci; and then as C\ goes up, the coefficient K±i+E goes down. As the parameter 8 increases (the case that is interesting from a practical point of view), the coefficient K±1+e drops significantly, and its increase can be secured only by a more powerful ,,switching on" of the modulation-parametric mechanism that forms the initial spectrum (±1 + e), conditioned by the nonlinear capacitance of the reactive element. In addition, as Fig.2.37 shows, the higher the value of 8, the more the extreme value of the dependence shifts in the direction of higher values for C\, i.e. the more significant is the role of the modulationparametric mechanism using a power accumulating parameter. The nonlinear active conductance, which is characterized by the parameter G2, also exerts considerable influence on the conversion properties of the autodyne systems (Fig.2.38). The coefficient A'i (a system presented in Fig.2.25) is highly dependent on G 2 . The dependence is determined by the important general regularity that in the case of modulation-parametric interactions, the ,,upward" conversion of the frequency is more effective when nonlinear reactance is used, while the ,,downward" conversion is more effective when carried out with a nonlinear
98
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 2.37. Theoretical dependence of the conversion coefficients in an autodyne system on the degree of nonlinearity of the capacitive characteristic of the active device active element. That is why the coefficient Ki' is highly dependent on G2, and for a broad range of values K\ goes up as G2 increases. The dependence shown in Fig.2.38a has its extreme values but in practice the values of the coefficients G2 for the modern SHF semiconductor devices generally correspond to the left-hand slope of the graph.
Fig. 2.38. Theoretical dependencies of the conversion coefficients in an autodyne system on the degree of nonlinearity of the conductance of the device In accordance with the general regularity, the frequency conversion conditions related to the system in Fig.2.27 deteriorate as the value of G2 goes up (the dependence of K^1'+e in Fig.2.38b). This is due to the fact that as G2 increases, the role of the modulation-parametric conversion, effected with the aid of a power accumulating element, weakens. The analysis of two basic autodyne systems, illustrated in Fig.2.25 and Fig.2.27, allows to detect the general potential for controlling and optimizing their conversion properties. In practice, the possible area of parameter variation is normally narrower by far than the broad range of alteration considered above. That is why the optimization task should be viewed in mini-max terms. At the same time, the already conducted general analysis of the conversion properties can also prompt qualitatively different solutions in designing short-range radar systems. For instance, one of the major conclusions of the theoretical analysis presented above is the fact that the conversion properties are strongly influenced by the parameter 6
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
99
characterizing the degree of regeneration of the autodyne oscillating circuit. Since for the purpose of achieving high amplitudes of the emitted signal the value of the parameter 6 should grow, which, in turn, would cause a drop in the conversion coefficient and in the sensitivity of the system with respect to the reflected signal, one readily arrives at the conclusion that the function of generating and emitting a probing signal should be separated from the function of receiving, amplifying and transforming the signal reflected by a moving object. Under these conditions, two generators should be used - a high powered and a low-powered one (Fig.2.39).
Fig. 2.39. A system of a short-distance Doppler radar with two oscillators The analysis indicates that the autodyne systems can be highly sensitive receiving and transmitting modules among the short-range radar facilities. It is noteworthy that the attainment of the potential sensitivity, as well as the realization of the frequency selectivity effects, can be limited by the natural fluctuation processes. Publication [207] analyzes a short-range self-detecting Doppler radar system with focusing the emitted field in the short-range zone. Such a system has a large resolution. Moreover, it is selective with respect to the parameter of distance to a certain object. The latter is of considerable interest with a view to some special applications. As a moving object passes through the focal spot zone, the phase of the incoming reflected signal is further shifted by w radians. While the object passes through this zone, the frequency of the reflected signal grows in a leap-like manner. It is interesting that Adler's equation [208], describing the behaviour of the phase difference between the external action and the natural oscillations of the autodyne generator has no solution. The analysis shows that self-synchronization in the autodyne systems in the classical sense is impossible. Under definite conditions, however, certain relaxation instability may occur as a result of a peculiar ,,instantaneous" self-synchronization. The issue regarding the possibility for self-synchronization in such a peculiar radiophysical system as the short-range self-detecting Doppler radar with delaying self-action has been debated in the published sources for years on end. We shall refer to this issue once again in Chapter 4, where we shall address the problem
100
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
from a different angle by applying the general criteria of oscillation chaotization in generator systems. Works [205, 206, 247] analyze the oscillation spectrum in short-range selfdetecting Doppler radar systems described by differential equations of the second and third order. The investigation has been carried out by taking into account both the amplitude and the phase modulation of the oscillations in the autodyne generator under the action of a signal reflected by a moving object. It has been established that in such a system the amplitude of the basic oscillations in the autodyne generator and their detuning, as well as the spectral components of the amplitude and the phase modulation conditioned by the action of a reflected signal, CO n change slowly in time at a frequency ~ , where u)£> is the Doppler shift of frequency, and uio is the frequency of the unperturbed oscillations in the autodyne generator. A number of other unexpected effects concern the dependence of the amplitudes and phases of the first and second harmonic in the spectrums of the amplitude and phase modulation on the parameters of the oscillating system, the time constant of the bias circuit, the load, the coefficient of the reflection by a moving object and the length of the signal lag, the motion parameters of the object (speed and direction). It is indicated in what cases the phase of the second harmonics in the spectra can be reliably informative with respect to the direction in which the object moves. 2.4. Application of the principle of reversibility of the modulationparametric interactions in radiophysical systems with external pumping In this section we shall outline some of the possibilities for applying the modulation-parametric systems for the purpose of increasing the sensitivity of radiophysical systems. The expediency of using four-frequency parametric systems with negative parameters to increase the sensitivity of radiophysical systems can be assessed on the basis of the general noise parameters of the system. 2.4-1. Noise parameters and•propertiesof one-ports with negative parameters built up on the basis of four-frequency parametric systems As already shown in 2.1, the reversibility of the modulation-parametric interactions allows using the four-frequency parametric systems successfully to create one-ports with wide-band negative G_, C_ and i?_, L- (conductance, capacitance and resistance, inductance), applicable in the cases of regenerative amplification and frequency correction. A statement valid for all these applications is that the load noises cannot be referred to the next stage of the system, since, just as the noise in the signal circuit, they are regenerated by the parametric system. The circuit of the parametric one-port with negative parameters, coupled with the
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
101
next amplifying stage, make up an overall system. It would be expedient to consider this system as a single (joint) stage. Having taken these considerations into account, we have presented in Fig.2.40 the equivalent circuit of a video frequency regenerative modulation-parametric amplifier and frequency corrector, which accounts for the respective noise sources [210, 211]. The signal circuit is represented by the conductance Y3 = G3 +jBs. Respectively, the circuit of the load (the next amplifying stage) is represented by the equivalent input admittance Yj- = GT+JBTThe noise properties of the signal circuit and the amplifying two-port of the load are characterized by the effective values of the noise currents \ A N S I \AJVT> ^ n e n ° i s e voltage V u2 and the noise correlation Ycor, which are determined by the expressions [106, 209]: ^2— 1NS
^
AT
~ GSN,
"^
n
AT- ~1.—
izNT = GNTN,
u%T =
r.
AT
RNTN,
v
y^NTVuNT
Ycor = -±
==L=
,
\UNT\
where N = 4fcTA/, k is Boltzmann's constant, T is the absolute temperature, A / is the frequency bandwidth, GNT and RNT are, respectively, the equivalent noise conductance and the equivalent noise resistance of the load two-port. Both here and further on, the sign „*" will mean a complex conjugate value. The fourfrequency modulation-parametric system (MPS) is represented by an equivalent circuit analogous to that in Fig. 1.1a. The natural noises of MPS have been taken into account by including the equivalent generators of noise current i2Nn = NReYn, reflecting the thermal noises, as well as equivalent generators i2Dn = 2qIoAfn, representing the current fluctuation noises of the complex parametric element, n —> 1) +i ""> 9 i s the electron charge, /o is the direct current flowing through the parametric element. Regardless of the fact that there is just one source of shot noise (the complex parametric element), there is no correlation between the equivalent noise generators i2Dn, since they are spread along the frequency axis. And the only parameter accounted for with respect to them is the frequency bandwidth fn, determined by the filtering circuits. Parallel to that, it should be pointed out that both the signals and the noises in the MPS are mutually converted in the three spectral bandwidths tos, UJ+, W_ as a result of the action of the pulsatory parametric element and as a consequence of the reversivility of the modulationparametric interaction. The flicker noises (of the type of „—") can be ignored and it can be considered that their relative weight is negligibly small, since in the parametric complex systems they are manifested only in the frequency area from one to several scores of Hz [108]. The given system is considered with regard to a broad video frequency bandwidth of the input signals, which is substantially influenced by the other sources of noise. As shown in 2.1, as a consequence of the reversibility of the modulationparametric interaction, the input admittance of MPS in Fig.2.40 can be presented
102
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 2.40. Equivalent circuit of a video-frequency regenerative modulation-parametric amplifier and frequency corrector, which accounts for the signal source, the load and all noise sources in the form Y{n = Y\ +Yg, where Yg = —Gg — jBg is the negative admittance introduced into the input circuit of MPS. The case when \Yg\ ^> |Yi| is considered. Along with that certain additional current i2N is introduced into the input circuit. As the ideas recounted above are taken into account, the equivalent circuit in Fig.2.40 can be presented in the form given in Fig.2.41.
Fig. 2.41. Generalized equivalent circuit for the noise sources of the system ,,sensor-modulation parametric one-port-amplifying two-port (load)" Since there is no impedance match in the system, the noise coefficient of the
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
103
circuit in Fig.2.40 can be defined as
F=§^,
(2.120)
PNS
where PNS is the total power of the noises emitted in the load, PNS is the power of the noises in the load conditioned only by the noises of the signal circuit under normal temperature To = 300 K. As the denotations in Pig.2.40 are accounted for, the expression for the noise coefficient can be presented in the form F=l
(2.121)
+ J!M, lNS
2 l
~-2
^7
i ~^1
i ^2
i ^9
i
~)
where iNE = iN1 + ilm + iN + iNT + uNT + Yin)\
~2uN^\Ycor{Ys
2
•
lT
•
*T\*s
I
Yin)
. " T + *s + Yin
•
The Exp.(2.121) can also be rewritten as f
=
1 +
^
+
where u2N, = — N1
^+^"' :
2 +
7 f []Y.+Yin\'-2\Ye.r(Y.+Yi.)\] , (2.122)
•—- is the noise voltage introduced at the input clamps
|y s + y T + y m p
1-1 of MPS (Fig.2.40). The employment of MPS as a one-port with negative differential conductance will be expedient under the condition that (2.123) M < FNf - 1, where M is the noise number of the system including the signal circuit of MPS and the amplifying two-port (the load); -F/v/ is the noise figure of the same circuit but in the absence of MPS. The noise number, in its general form, is defined by the expression [106]
M = l—1-, 1 -
K
where K is the coefficient of amplification by power.
(2.124)
104
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
As a result of the presence of MPS, there is a realization of a coefficient of amplification by power
(2.125) It should be pointed out that in reality the MPS under consideration is used in the conditions of overall offsetting of the system reactances through the introduced broad-band negative reactive conductance Bg, i.e. 53 + 5 1 + S T - B 3 ~ 0 .
(2.126)
As (2.121) and (2.124) are substituted in (2.123), and (2.126) is taken into consideration, we obtain
M = L N T + UUGs^Jl~G>9f J_ X
+ RNT[(GS - G'gf - 2\Ycor(Y3 + * B ) | ] |
7(G3 + g T )
Gs ( 7 - 1)(G. + GT) + G'g •
{
•
'
It is not difficult to show that the noise coefficient FN/ is defined by the expression FNf = 1 + ^ 1 + ^[Gl
(2.128)
- 2\YcorY3\).
As (2.127) and (2.128) are combined, the condition (2.123) concerning the expedience of using MPS as a one-port with negative differential conductance, when estimated on the basis of a complex indicator including the amplifying and noise properties, acquires the form sr
A. MAfi(G" +°T-
{GNT-\
4kTAf
+ Yin)\]h
$r'trT\
G'f
2
\-tiNT[{Gs ~Gg)
+ r.
< GNT
+ RNT[G*
* -1\YCOT{YS
~ 2\Y°°*Y.\}- (2-129)
( 7 - l)(£s + GT) + G'g If the noise coefficient of MPS is defined as „
GMPS
__ 'ATI MPS
FMPS = - y - -
4kTAfG,^
ro-\-m\
(2-130)
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
105
where i2N1 MPS ~ *NI ~l~*JVgi GMPS is the equivalent noise conductance of MPS, the term containing u2N1 in (2.129) can be written as
— = FMPsG'g-
Then the final condition (2.129) will be presented in the form {GNT
x
+ FMpsG'g + RNT[(GS
-h-w
$%)+,K
- G'g)2 - 2\Ycor(Ys + Yin)\]}
(2-131)
- 2]Y-U
GNT+RNT[G1
The noise coefficient FMPS will be determined from the matrix equation (1.26) reflecting the processes in MPS. For the case under consideration it is in the form
h
Yx
1+
Giei^
I-
Gxt-i^
d e * + jujsCxt^
Ux
G2ej^ +JLJ+C2ei^
U+
+JLosCie-^1
+JLJ+C1e^
Y+
Gxe-ii* - ju-de-i+i-
G2e~^^
- jw-.C2e-j2^
Y-
U(2.132)
As the currents 7i, 7+, /_ and the voltage U\ in the matrix equation (2.132) are presented as noise currents I\ —> y i ^ l l ; = \ATVI + *Di' A- ~* y^N+s = yi2N+
+ i2D+, I- -> \J«if_E = yi2N- + *D_ and noise voltage Ut -> ^U2N1, we
obtain T\
TJ2
_ ,-2
2
±11
T-j
2
T-J
, ,'2
±1±
. ,-2
2
f±l
/O1 ocA
where D is the determinant of the matrix in (2.132) and Dx, D+, and Z?_ are the respective algebraic adjuncts. Taking into account the fact that the input conductance of MPS is expressed by the matrix equation (2.132) as Yin = — — —— (See 1.3), the following expression for the total input noise current i2N1 MPS of MPS is arrived at: .
*N1 MPS
=
D
^JVll^'nl
=*NlS
+ *Af+i; ~^~
2
D
+ *iV-S ~^~
2
i
(2.134)
i.e. the inserting by MPS additional noise current is £) *Ng
=
' N + S ~JJ~
2
£) + *JV-E ~jy
'
(2.135)
106
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications On the basis of (2.134) we obtain the following expression for the product
FMPSG'9:
c<
F
FMPsGo =
^7^P~S
^kfAT
r
°+r(
D+
= Gl+G{'D;
2
+
+
D-
2\+
qI°
(i +
D+
D7 ) + 2kf{1+ ^
2
+
D-
2
\
DT J '
+
(2.136) where G is the conductance of the MPS oscillating circuit (See 2.1). From (2.132) we obtain the following expressions for the reciprocal conversion coefficients in (2.136) at # x = - ^ , * 2 = 0:
_D+_M1-m1^Q(l+2M2)+j2Q[m1g(0-0-M1((0+m2-0} + D, l + 2M2+4Qi(eo+(om2-e) K
"
D-_ M1+m1iQ(l+2M2)+j2Q[m1^0+0+M1{(o+m2+0] D1 l + 2M 2 +4Q2(£2 + £ o m 2 _£2)
'
{'
•
r ? n
I-
' ^ i
Expressions for the negative parameters Gg and Bg introduced by MPS were obtained in 2.1. In reality the coefficient of power amplification is considerable as a result of the regenerative action of MPS. This is achieved at G'g —> Gs + GT and 7 —> 1. Under these conditions (2.131) is reduced to
FMPS
<
G*+TGT[G2S
~ 2 \ Y °°J'K-
( 2 - 139 )
Given that the conductance of the signal circuit Gs is by far larger than the conductance of the noise correlation |KCOr| and the noise conductance of the load two-port G T , the condition (2.139) assumes the form FMPS < RNTGS.
(2.140)
The inequality (2.140) is convenient for an initial practical engineering estimate. It shows that from the viewpoint of noise, it is most convenient to work with low-resistant signal circuits or input oscillating circuits with a low qualitative factor (and this is most frequently encountered in the practical applications). The analysis shows that in the case of quadrature pumping of the reactive (C(t)) and active (G(t)) part of the parametric element, i.e. when * i = — j and 4*2 = 0, MPS has the property of unidirectional transmission of the signals, and the reciprocal transmission coefficients K+ and K- (formulae (2.137) and (2.138)) can be negligibly small. The numerical estimates of real MPS parameters, where (2.132) - (2.137) are used, indicate that FMpsG'g~\,S(?{. (2.141)
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
107
Taking into account that MPS has been designed to create negative active conductance, whose absolute value exceeds by far the natural input conductance, G° i.e. -—
108
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 2.42. Equivalent circuits of a capacitive (a) and inductive (b) sensor and video amplifier where, respectively, for Fig.2.42a: TCL = RcCc, F = A, SCL = Cc, DCL — D and for Fig.2.42b: TCL = GLLL, F = B, SCL - Lc, DCL = R- It is assumed that RcGin < 1, GLRin < 1. The module of K, as a function of the frequency at different degrees of compensation n is presented in the form of a graph in Fig.2.43. The value of \K\ in the middle of the frequency bandwidth at \i = 0 has been accepted as a zero level. It can be seen that within a broad frequency range the signal is amplified at — 1 < fi < 0, at that the general transmission coefficient of the ,,reactive video sensor - parametric video amplifier" system has increased times.
Fig. 2.43. Dependence of the generalized transmission coefficient of a capacitive or inductive sensor operating jointly with a parametric video amplifier 2-4-3. Inductive sensor Inertia systems, which lack in reactive element changes in time with HF oscillations excited in the system, but have a possibility for modulation action on a reactive element on the part of an external, determined or fluctuation signal, display modulation-parametric interactions analogous to those in the inertia-free case (this
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
109
issue is elaborately analyzed in the publication [150]). The electromechanical analogues of the four-frequency parametric systems - the highly sensitive capacitive [154, 213] and inductive (Fig.2.44) [214] sensor of small mechanical oscillations - are also referred to these systems. The latter sensor (Fig.2.44) consists of a mechanical oscillator with mass m, elasticity coefficient KM and friction coefficient HM- The mass m is the mobile core of a high frequency coil, which forms an electric oscillating circuit with a linear capacitor C. The resistance r reflects the active losses of the circuit, where forced electric oscillations are excited by an external high-frequency source of current I'm cos tot. The core with mass m can oscillate freely around its point of equilibrium under the action of external mechanical vibrations (external periodic forces). Using the principle of reversibility of the modulation-parametric interactions, we can analyze the processes in the system. The response of the electric oscillating circuit with respect to the mechanical oscillations in the system is manifested in the introduction of effective additional friction and additional elasticity in the mechanical oscillator.
Fig. 2.44. Inductive sensor and analyzer of small mechanical vibrations The processes in the electromechanical system (Fig.2.44) are described by the following system of differential equations:
(2.142) d 2x TT dx m~dt2+~dt+
„
_ '
where L{x) is the coil inductance depending on the position of the ferromagnetic core, Fei = ALI\ is electric power, Ai - a coefficient accounting for the geometric dimensions of the coil, the type of winding, the diameter of the wire and the number of the windings. The motion in the mechanical oscillation around the equilibrium xo state can be presented as + <po), (2.143) x=XeSMtco$(ttMt
where SM = ^
~
= 6M0 + 6'e,fiM= yj!£it^
=
y/^+^l-
The additional friction coefficient He (corresponding to the additional damping S'e) and the additional differential elasticity coefficient Ke (corresponding to the
110
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
change in the natural resonance frequency Qe) determined by the response of the electric oscillating circuit to the oscillations of the mechanical oscillator should be determined. For small deviations from the equilibrium state, the inductance of the coil can —-, where E < 1 and x is normalized by the XQ 1 + e|a;| coordinate. Then the system of equations (2.142) can be written in the following form:
be presented in the form L =
~~dJT
+ 2cee~dF
cPx
dx
+ w o(l+£|a ; l)JL = Imcoaujt (2'M4)
r 1 /' where 2a e = — , u\ = ——, Lo = L(x0), Im = -f-. The solution of the first equation of the system (2.144) is presented in a series by the small parameter *L = h
0
+ E J L ! + e 2 i L 2 + •••
(2.145)
As (2.145) is substituted in the second equation of the system (2.144) and certain transformations are made, the following expressions are obtained for the parameters sought: °M =
HM+He r
= oMo +oe = bMo + -—WA
2m 2
^AuaeAell . , —TTT
8UJO[(ALJ)2
KM + Ke
2
O
2_O2
.
(2.146)
+al)3
±AuAJl
O-IAJ^
where Aw is the absolute frequency detuning of the electric circuit (the upper sign corresponds to positive detunings and the lower one to negative detunings), wo and ae are the resonance frequency and damping of the oscillating electric circuit, Im is the amplitude of the source current. It can be seen from (2.146) and (2.147) that the damping decrement and the resonance frequency of the mechanical oscillator depend on the current amplitude and on the oscillation detuning in the oscillating electric circuit. When the circuit is tuned to the right-hand slope of the resonance curve (positive values for Aw), an equivalent negative damping decrement S'e and negative elasticity are introduced in the mechanical oscillator (the resonance frequency of the mechanical oscillator increases by Qe). The parameters Se and fle reach their maximum values at detunings corresponding to the maximum slope of the resonance characteristic of the circuit [6eJmax~
AeQ\Pm Ae (QeV 4w05 " 4 w 0 W
2 m'
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
l"eJmax"
AeQlIj
K
Ae (Qe\3
"^Ui
111
2
where Qe is the quality factor of the electric circuit. A potential for controlling the parameters of the mechanical oscillating system through electric means is created. The amplitude of the source current I'm is changed to regulate the input of effective positive or negative elasticity (altering the resonance frequency of the mechanical oscillator) and of effective positive or negative friction in the mechanical oscillating system. It is also possible to excite continuous mechanical oscillations if the following condition is satisfied: Im > F = \
V
—-.
AeQ3e
At Im < F the mechanical oscillator is in a state of rest, yet it is regenerated, i.e. its quality factor is much higher and this conditions the higher sensitivity of the inductive sensor to external mechanical influences. Given a periodic sweeping of I'm within definite boundaries, the system in Fig.2.44 can be used as a sensitive sensor - a spectrum analyzer of mechanical oscillations in a relatively broad frequency bandwidth [215]. Devices of this kind can be applied when studying the oscillation spectrum of aircraft and other objects tested in aerodynamic tunnels, the vibrations of the body and other elements of diferent machines, etc. 2.4-4- Capacitive sensor An analogous compensation of the elasticity of a mechanical oscillator creates additional potential for enhancing the sensitivity of receiving systems of the ,,capacitive sensor - video amplifier" type. Thus, for example, when tackling the impressive scientific task of practically discovering and proving the existence of the gravitation waves predicted by A. Einstein's General theory of relativity, a high-quality capacitive sensor in combination with a four-frequency parametric system in an optimal noise mode can be used. In this case the compensation of the sensor elasticity through a parametric system can ensure a frequency-independent transmission coefficient of the sensor in a broad frequency bandwidth without any deterioration in its sensitivity (this issue is elaborately examined in [215, 216]). The gravitation receivers (the gravitational resonance bar detectors) that are currently in a process of development in the USA, France, Italy, Germany, Russia and other countries, have input sapphire oscillators with a Q-factor in the order of 108 — 1010. Therefore they have an extremely narrow reception frequency bandwidth - to the order of 10~7 — 10~8 Hz, i.e. it is believed that the frequency of the unknown space gravitation waves will coincide ,,absolutely precisely" with the tuning frequency of the gravitation sensor. To put it a different way, the response of an arbitrary gravitation wave signal will be a sinusoid with the resonance tuning frequency of the mechanical oscillator. So the question is whether the energy of this narrow spectral range will be sufficient to detect the signal in a reliable manner.
112
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Let us show the way in which the high sensitivity of the capacitive sensor (Fig.2.45) to small mechanical oscillations [109] is brought about. The mechanical oscillator consists of mass M, suspended on a spring with elasticity K. The sensor is an oscillating circuit made up of an inductive coil L and capacitance C, one of whose plates is connected to the mass M. The resistance R reflects the energy losses in the oscillating circuit. The damper h represents the energy losses in the mechanical oscillating system. There is an inductive connection between the coil L and the generator e, which excites forced oscillations in the oscillating circuit. Their frequency is close to the resonance frequency of the circuit. As the mass M oscillates, the capacitance C changes. Such oscillation retunes the oscillating circuit, altering the amplitude and the phase of its forced oscillations. In this way the mechanical oscillation is converted into amplitude and phase modulation of a variable electric signal. Combined frequencies also occur, i.e. wp ± nfi,s, where u>p is the frequency of the generator, fts is the oscillation frequency of the mass M, n = 0,1,2,... Given a small amplitude of the mass M, the combined components with frequency wp ± fls show the highest intensity. Besides, at fis
Fig. 2.45. Equivalent scheme of a capacitive sensor of small mechanical vibrations If the oscillation of the mass M is governed by a harmonic law x = XQ COS Q,st, the capacitance of the circuit changes as C = Co(l + 2mcosQ,st), where m = 7-^—, , Co is the value of the capacitance, if the distance between its plates is
x= do do-
The voltage and the charge of the capacitor can be presented as Uc = Up cosuipt + U- cos(ui_t + y>_) + £/+ cos(a;+£ + ip+), qc = UcCo(l +2mcosfi s t),
where w± = u>v ± fls. Then the combined components of the load and the complex amplitudes of the respective currents flowing through the capacitor at frequencies
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
113
ui— and a)-), are determined in the form: q^_ = CQU- cos(u)_t + (p_) + ComUp
cosuj-t,
qu+ = CoU+ cos(o;+< +
L+ = JOJ+C0(U+
+ mUp),
+ mUp).
Using as our starting point the condition that for each of the frequencies w± the sum of the currents flowing through R and L should be zero, we can write down the following two equations: -pF + —^T + J"-Co(U-
+ mUp) = 0 (2.148)
^ T + - ^ j + ]OJ+CO{U+ xl
ju>-\-Li
+ mUp) = 0
The complex combined amplitudes are determined from (2.148) •
-jui-mCoRUp
•
-ju+mC0RUp
(OTAQ^
where £0 = —
, w0 = ——-, (, = — , Q = UJ0C0R. Up \/LCo vp For the purpose of calculating the amplitude and phase change, it is convenient to present the combined components in (2.149) in the following form: {/_ = U-a + U-ph,
(2.150)
U+ = U+a + U+Ph,
where •
-2Q2m(0Up ~a
•
(l-2;OO 2 +4Q 2 e 0 2 '
-2Q2mj»Up +a
•
{l + 2jQif+AQHV
-jQmUp(l ""
. +"h
- 2jQQ
(l-2jg02+4Q^o2'
-jQmUp(l
(2.151)
+ 2jQQ
(l + 2jQO2+4Q2e02'
Further on we put down the following sum of voltages UpeiuP* + \U-a\el(u-t+ifi-^
+ \U+a\eiiw+t+v+")
= [[/p + 2|[/ +a |cos(ft s i + ^ + a ) ] e ^ \
=
(2.152)
where v+a
= _ ^ _ a = - arctg 1_4Q2(,+4Q2&-
(2-153)
114
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Therefore, the voltage components of combined frequencies with complex amplitudes U-a and U+a cause only amplitude modulation of the voltage in the oscillating circuit; furthermore it is obvious from (2.152) that the change in the voltage amplitude 6A(t) is
SA(t) = 2\U+a\ cos(ft3i + ip+a)
(2.154)
Drawing an analogy with (2.151), the following can be written (taking into account that |J7_| < Up and \U+\ < Up) Upe^P* + \U-pk\ej{u-t+lfi-P^ ~ Upej[urt
2\U+
+
\U+ph\e^+t+v+P^
h\
D 5 -co.(n.«+ v+J(h )] j
where
1
(2 155)
4Q£ _ ±Q2(2 + 4 Q 2< C2 •
It follows from (2.155) that the voltage components of the combined frequencies with complex amplitudes U-Ph and U+Ph, in a first approximation, cause only phase modulation of the voltage in the oscillating circuit, where, given an oscillating mass M, the change in the phase 8<&(t) is determined from the relation
«*(*) = - & ^ c o s ( J U + ?+„*). Up
In practice the motion of the mass M can be registered by considering the amplitude or phase deviations of the voltage in the oscillating circuit. Let us estimate the minimum shift of the mass M that can be registered, for instance, on the basis of the voltage amplitude change in the oscillating circuit. As (2.151) and (2.153) are substituted in (2.154), the following is obtained for the deviation f A m l I of the amplitude from the average value (2Q£ < 1 ) : r>n2f TJ *X° ij4m"-|(l
-MI2/:
+ 2jQ0 2 +4Q 2 £o 2 r
TJ
x^°
l+4^o
•
(
}
In (2.156) Xo is the oscillation amplitude of the mass M, <5Amax has the meaning of an envelope amplitude of the voltage in the oscillating circuit, which reaches its maximum value under the condition 2Q£0 = 1- The latter condition corresponds to the steepest slope point on the resonance curve of the oscillating circuit. Under this condition, (2.156) can be written in the form
|Xo1
-
*QUP
•
(2-15?)
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
115
r-i
For the parallel-plate capacitor x — — — . For example, given the trivial do conditions do=lO~1 cm, Q=102, Up=10 V and assuming that the sensitivity of the voltage deviation meter is SAmm = 10~6 V (which is also an elementary condition), (2.157) yields the average value of the threshold of sensitivity - Xomin = 2.10~10 cm. This is a rather small value, yet, in reality, it is absolutely attainable. It should be stressed here that if such high sensitivity is to be realized in practice, special actions should be taken to protect the capacitive sensor against mechanical vibrations and acoustic noise. The mechanical oscillators used to solve the problem of identifying space gravitation waves should have sapphire monocrystals, they should be cooled down to helium temperatures (4.2 K) and kept in special shielded premises. These conditions have yielded record-setting threshold sensitivities Xomin = 10~17 cm. Let us consider the response of the capacitive sensor as a consequence of the reversibility of the modulation-parametric interactions. The force T of attraction between the plates of the capacitive sensor is T = \Eq, where E is the intensity of the electric field in the gap, q is the charge of the capacitor. For the parallel-plate capacitor E = ^ and q = CU, where U is the voltage of the capacitor, d is the distance between its plates and C is its capacitance. Then the force T is expressed as
T
~
2d •
Using the expressions C = Co(l + 2m cos £l3t), d = do + Xo cos £}st, U = [Up + SA(t)] cos[upt + 6(t)] m this formula and calculating the average for a period of high-frequency voltage in the circuit I — I, we obtain the average value of the force J- in the form:
T=
Co(1 + 2 ^ C O S ^ V P +
4do(l--j^cosfi,i) do
^)12.
As we retain only the small terms of the first order in this expression and take into account (2.154), we obtain
J = To + W, where To =
C Z72 p
2uo capacitor plates,
is the constant component of the force of attraction of the W=^-Up\U+a\cos(nst "0
+
(2.158)
116
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
is the variable component of the force of attraction of the capacitor plates. Let us assume that the motion of the mass in the mechanical oscillator is caused by the action of a periodic external force /(<) = F$e3 '*. Then the equation regarding the motion of the mass M is of the form
M^ + h^ + at1 at
kx^Foe^+W.
We use the method of complex amplitudes to present the solution of this equation in the form x = Xoe^'*. Then, as we take into account (2.158), we obtain the following expression for the complex amplitude Xo: jr
=
0
-MQ2s+jn3(h
^
+ 6h) + k + 6k'
where the effective additions 5h and 8k can be expressed, after taking into account the inequality UJS
QjoxUl
c s 4(l+4Q^ 02 ) 2 '
do(l + 4Q^g)-
As a result of the reversibility of the modulation-parametric interactions effective (equivalent) additions 8h and 6k occur, which are dually analogous to those of the inductive capacitor considered above. In the case of £o = —
< 0, 8k < 0, Sh > 0 and the resonance frequency
of the mechanical oscillator also decreases effectively, while the damping goes up. When £o > 0, respectively, 6k > 0, 6h < 0 and the mechanical frequency of the mechanical oscillator increases effectively, while the damping goes down. In practice, the modulation-parametric interaction between mechanical and electric oscillations, considered above, should be taken into consideration quite often. An example that can be cited here is the gravimeter - an apparatus for relative measurement of the acceleration of the weight force used in gravimetric surveys for ores and minerals. A gravity meter with a capacitive shift sensor is a particular case of the device in Fig.2.45 and the results of the analysis presented above are fully applicable to it. The practical conclusion is that the satisfaction of the condition £o = 0 should be strictly controlled for each measurement. Let us once again discuss the mechanism of excitation of mechanical oscillations in a capacitive sensor related to the emergence and interaction of combined frequencies by using the more general and visual approach close to that used under 2.4.3. above during the analysis of the inductive sensor.
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
117
The equations of the system under consideration (Fig.2.45) are of the form: C U q + 2Siq+ -~—Q,lq = ~- cos vt O yx J
Li
x + 282x +u>lx =
m
F(x,q),
where q is the charge on the capacitor, C(x) = Co ( 1 -\
V
fio
=
)
is its capacitance,
doj
is the own resonance frequency of the electric oscillating circuit
I
for a value of the mechanical coordinate x = 0, do is the initial distance between the plates of the capacitor in the case of undeformed spring, LOQ is the own resonance frequency of the mechanical oscillating unit, 8\ and 82 are the dissipation coefficients, Co and L are constants, [70 is the amplitude of the acting voltage, C 2
2
F(x,q) =
— = ———— is the force of attraction between the plates 2C/!(x)(do + x)z 2Codo of the capacitor, m is the mass (Fig.2.45). (All conclusions and derivations are laid out under the condition that a flat capacitor is considered). In the case of zero-order approximation the solution of the system of equations concerning the mechanical coordinate x can be written down in the form x — B cos(uit + ipi). After substitution, the short equations for the amplitude B and phase
+
KQl-piB2,
"
2 "yv 2 "' \ 'Uo, A=u-uo,K, fc and fo are 2mLdfs, \(v2 - fig)2 + 4ojv2]3 coefficients depending on the parameters of the system, Qm is the amplitude of the alternating charge on the capacitor. It can be seen that the excitation of oscillations is possible mostly when v > fioj i-e-; o n the right-hand slope of the resonance curve. Therefore, the
condition for exciting self-oscillations is w~ftoH—7= and its corresponding threshold V5 1 f +k u 1-4. A • value tor the voltage amplitude is: TT UQ m ; n =
o ^ /"6mL52\1/2 =• . This voltage 5 V fioV5 / of the electric source has the following corresponding voltage on the capacitor:
Uc = 12doi
o
2 4 d
n
y "0<"0 J The analysis of the non-linearity coefficient fa indicates that the excitation of the oscillations is a ,,soft excitation" (without any special requirements to the initial conditions).
118
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
An analogous effect of self-excitation of mechanical oscillations is observed in the optic sensors of small shifts, where self-oscillations occur at the expense of light pressure. The same effect was also observed experimentally during the action of a SHF field on a rotating pendulum. An analogous mechanism is that leading to oscillations in the resonators used in the powerful accelerators of counter flows. The emergence of a generation of elastic waves in dielectric resonators pumped with a high frequency electromagnetic field is also described. 2.4.5. Implementation and utilization of modulation-parametric one-ports with negative conductance (negative resistance) The devices with negative conductance (negative resistance) are regarded as functional, since due to the negative conductance they can perform the functions of amplifiers, generators, converters, etc. The Introduction to this work provided a short classification of the negative resistances used in science and technology. The negative resistances, obtained on the basis of parametric systems, where the pulsation of an energy accumulating (reactive) parametric element leads, under certain conditions, to the input of energy in the signal circuit, occupy a particular position from a theoretical point of view. This property of the parametric system is described through a negative resistance introduced into the signal circuit and occurring only in a dynamic mode. Section 2.1 indicated in theoretical terms that the usage of RC four-frequency parametric systems, where the pumping of the reactive parametric element goes with a phase shift of with respect to the pumping of the active parametric element, allows of implementing one-ports with broad-band negative resistance. This section describes practical methods and devices for obtaining one-ports with broadband negative resistances [217, 218]. Fig.2.46 shows a circuit of a parametric device for obtaining broadband negative conductance. The oscillating circuit is formed by the inductance L and a reactive parametric element represented by ,,capacitive" diodes D\ and Z?2, connected in a balanced two-cycle circuit. The diodes operate in a turned-off condition, they are pumped by the pumping generator PG. The diodes (D3) and (D4), representing the active parametric element, are connected in parallel with the diodes (Di) and (D2) a l s o m a balanced two-cycle circuit. The diodes D3 and D^ have a negligibly small natural capacitance, and they work in a mode with direct currents of the order of scores of hundreds of fiA. Their pumping is effected by a PG with a phase shift of —. The frequency of the change in the parametric elements is equal to the resonance frequency of the oscillating circuit. The negative conductance, together with a parallel negative capacitance, is implemented on the clamps of the load ZL- Depending on the mode, it is possible to get negative conductance with an absolute value of 10~8 — 10~2 fi"1. As the frequency of the
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
119
Fig. 2.46. Parametric device for obtaining broadband negative conductance pumping voltage is changed, the upper boundary frequency of negative parameter existence can also be altered from single-digit Hz to hundreds of MHz. Fig.2.47 displays modified variants of the circuit in Fig.2.46 for obtaining broadband negative conductance, where FET transistors are used as active parametric elements. These circuits allow ensuring a lower level of the natural (own) fluctuation noises.
Fig. 2.47. Modified variants of a parametric device for obtaining broadband negative conductance, wherefield-effecttransistors are used The implementation of a broad-band negative conductance can be effectively applied in the development of new types of parametric devices - regenerative parametric video amplifiers without conversion of the signal frequency. The development of such devices can contribute substantially to the solution of current modern problems of amplifying signals from video sensors with infinitesimal power, such as: high-ohm T.V. camera tubes of the type of ,,vidicon", ,,plumbicon", etc. used in reconnaissance and security systems; vidicons for infra-red radiation used for reconnaissance, cancer diagnostics, electronic circuit control, fire extinguishing, in industry, etc.; in pyroelectric receivers used in spectral flame fire-warning
120
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
systems; impulse photosensors, special encephalographs recording the impulse activeness of neurons, semiconductor particle detectors registering narrow-band lines in cases of radiation reconnaissance, etc. The implementation of a broad-band negative capacitance in parallel with the negative conductance allows of a substantial increase in the sensitivity of video systems by offsetting the parasitic capacitance of the signal source. The level of the useful signal in the T.V. camera tubes can be raised by 10 - 20 dB compared to the case of no compensation for the parasitic capacitance of the tube. For example, if the conductance of the signal C source is Ys = Gs + JUJC3 = G3^!, where * = 1 + jui—f-, the coefficient of the signal attenuation caused by the existence of the capacitance Cs is equal to
f
Cs\2
\4>\2 = 1 + [ujg-pr I , even when the conductance is matched by the maximum of the transmitted power. For T.V. tubes with Ca ~ 20 pF, Ga ~ 10" 7 fi"1 and frequency UJS = 10~5 s" 1 the coefficient of attenuation is |4"| ~ 400. 2.4-6. Implementation and utilization of modulation-parametric one-ports with negative capacitance A consequence of the theoretical analysis carried out in 2.1 is that the major problem related to the implementation of one-ports with negative capacitance on the basis of four-frequency parametric systems is compensation for the action of the second harmonic in the spectrum of the capacitive parametric element. A practical solution of this problem can be achieved by using ,,circuit" compensation or nonharmonic pumping. This section recounts methods and devices for obtaining lownoise broad-band negative capacitances [150, 217, 218]. A broad-band low-noise negative capacitance can be realized by employing the circuit in Fig.2.46, with the only difference that both the diodes D\ and D2, and the diodes £)3 and D4 are ,,capacitive" and operate in a turned-off state. In this case the pumping of the diodes D3 and D4 with a phase shift of — allows of compensating the action of the second harmonic from the spectrum of the parametric element. The maximum absolute value of the negative capacitance is obtained in the case of a positive relative detuning of the oscillating circuit equal to ——, where Q is the Q-factor of the circuit. The action of the second harmonic can be compensated by using two multiple harmonic voltages of pumping - Fig.2.48. The first harmonic of the pumping voltage is obtained through double division of the frequency of the pumping generator PG. The advantage of the circuit in Fig.2.48 in comparison with the circuit in Fig.2.46 is the fact that the operation of the device is independent of the load. Fig.2.49 shows yet another circuit of a device for an implementation of a lownoise broad-band negative capacitance with circuit compensation of the action of the second harmonic in the spectrum of the parametric element. The parametric
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
121
Fig. 2.48. Parametric device for obtaining broadband low-noise negative capacitance by using non-harmonic pumping to compensate for the second harmonic in the spectrum of the parametric element diodes are connected in a bridge-balanced circuit. For the purpose of reducing the noise coming from the pumping generator, low-noise parametric generators are used for pumping.
Fig. 2.49. Device for obtaining broadband low-noise negative capacitance with circuit compensation of the action of the second harmonic in the spectrum of the parametric element. It is used to measure the capacitance of biological membranes, for frequency corrections, etc. A major peculiarity of the implemented negative capacitances, besides the frequency bandwidth liable to regulation and control, is the rather low level of the natural fluctuation noise (the equivalent input noise voltage changes from 5.10~3 /uV at / = 20 Hz to 5.10"4 /iV at / = 104 Hz). Realization of absolute values of the negative capacitance from single-digit pF to 106 pF is achieved by selecting the parametric diodes with natural capacitance from single-digit pF to 104 pF, for which a parallel connection of single-digit and even scores of diodes is also used. Moreover, the employment of bridge and balanced circuits allows of increasing, the respective number of times, the absolute value of the negative capacitance introduced into the signal circuit.
122
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
The low-noise broad-band negative capacitances implemented on the basis of four-frequency parametric systems are effectively applied in the following cases: for broad-band frequency correction seeking to increase the sensitivity of receiving systems of the types of capacitive video sensors, photosensors with video amplifiers, piezoelectric converters, pyroelectric receivers for thermal radiation, etc.; in seismic station receivers, also for the purposes of special reconnaissance; in cases of indication of slight mechanical shifts; in precise medical equipment; when simulating physical, biological and other objects. For example, if we seek to achieve the sensitivity of photodetectors to be limited only by the thermal noise of the current IT flowing in an unlit state, the capacitance of the photodiode Cph should meet the requirement: Cph < .
IT
. , [219]. In practice the reduction of the capacitance
ZiKA. L \ J
Cph to the admissible values is possible only through its compensation in the video frequency bandwidth A / . The sensitivity of the photodetector can be increased by using a photoparametric amplifier permitting the realization of threshold sensitivity in the order of 10" 14 - 10" 15 A (See Fig.2.50).
Fig. 2.50. Photoparametric amplifier Negative capacitances can also be applied in biological membrane research [220]. Biological membranes have natural capacitance, which plays the part of an indicator of their filtering functions, hence its non-destructive measurement evokes considerable scientific interest on the part of bio-cybernetics and microbiologists. Any measurement of such capacitance in a harmonic mode is undesirable due to the inevitable side effect on the biological object and the detecting properties of some membranes, while an obstacle to impulse measurements is the sizable time constant of the circuit. The compensation of membrane capacitance with negative capacitance allows determining, quickly and precisely, its value, as well as the conductance of the membrane in an arbitrary direction. Fig.2.49 illustrates the method of measuring the capacitance of biological membranes by using microelectrodes [220]. The general principles recounted above are used as a basis for increasing the sensitivity of a sensor for interplanetary plasma (solar wind) - a multielectrode
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
123
modulation measurer of the differential energy spectrum of solar wind [221, 222]. Measurements of the parameters of interplanetary plasma allow forecasting a large number of phenomena in the ionosphere and magnetosphere of the Earth. As the fine structure of the solar wind is studied, the precision of the weather forecasts is improved substantially. It is a widely known fact that the sensitivity of the interplanetary plasma sensor is highly restricted by the inevitable capacitance of its collector. The reduction of the modulating frequency is undesirable due to the rapid increase in the flicker noise. Neither is it possible to enhance the sensitivity by increasing the area of the collector, due to the proportional increase in the shunting capacitance. The sensitivity of the multielectrode modulation solar wind measurer rises considerably as its natural capacitance and the conductance of the electrometric preamplifier are compensated by using parametric one-ports with low-noise broadband C_ and G-. The electric circuit of the solar wind sensor is shown in Fig.2.51a [221]. The main pumping channel ensures a wide range time-dependent change in the diode capacitances, while the additional pumping channel is necessary for eliminating the action of the second harmonic in the spectrum of the parametric element.
Fig. 2.51. Multielectrode modulation trap of interplanetary plasmas (solar wind) using a modulation-parametric system: a) fundamental scheme; b) equivalent electric circuit The equivalent electric circuit of the sensor is presented in Fig.2.51 b, where ic and Cc are, respectively, the current and the capacitance of the collector of the trapping input module, C_ and G_ are the broad-band low-noise negative
124
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
capacitance and conductance implemented by a four-frequency modulationparametric system (MPS), Ca and Ga are the input conductance and capacitance of the electrometric preamplifier, U^' is the input voltage of the preamplifier without and with MPS regenerative action (the index „-" is used for the regenerative case, when MPS introduces equivalent negative C_ and G_, while the index „+" is used for the ordinary case without MPS). As the regeneration coefficients /IQ = -p,
-p,
~pr~
and
fJ-G = 75
7;—
are introduced, one can obtain an expression for the coefficient of the gain in the resultant input voltage at the clamps of the preamplifier in the form r-
t/(~)
Vc
—
where Tca =
\(
2 2 , ^CV
1 2 2 (Pc
iV
is the time constant of the system without regeneration, u>s
is the respective spectral frequency of the collector current. In the case of complete compensation of the collector capacitance Cc, i-e- when fie —» co, the coefficient K takes the form
It is easy to see that the regeneration effectiveness increases as the initial value of rca increases. The integral effect of using MPS can be expressed and analyzed on the basis of the mean values of the input voltage of the electrometric preamplifier Ua% , obtained by averaging the modulation period To:
(_) _ icm (1 Ga \2 because
Cc + Ca HcGal-o
y( + ) Ua'° where
Cc + Ca [1 ncGgTo I) ic / . c G a T 0/iG [2 2liG(Cc + Ca)\j-2GafiG'
=
LIG < 1,
jC f l _ C c + C . r i _ - a ^ f e r y i i ic Ga\2 GaT0 [2 J j -4(CC + Ca)10'
Cc + Ca „ — >• JoGa
The ratio of these expressions yields the coefficient indicating the effectiveness of using MPS:
„ _ Utj
2(CC + Ca)
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
125
For all practical cases Ka S> 1. The effect of sensitivity promotion due to the employment of MPS can be proved even more thoroughly as the noise properties are analyzed. As shown above, the signal/noise ratio TV does not deteriorate as an MPS is added. In this case the value N can be expressed as: — for the regeneration case: w(-) _
^°i°
~
-
icflG
nSc
_
— for the non-regeneration case: N(+) = U'V
„
y/Ufa
lcT°
4(CC + Ca)y/Ufa
=
nSc
4(CC + Ca)yf0fa'
where i — nSc<j>(Wp)i n is the plasma concentration, 5c is the area of the collector of the plasma trapper, (j>{Wp) is a function characterizing the distribution of the charged particles by energy, ?72JV£ is the common quadratic mean of the noise voltage in the regenerative case (when an MPS is in place), U2Ma is the quadratic mean of the noise voltage of the preamplifier. This can be used as a starting point to obtain expressions for the minimum plasma concentration and minimum collector current of the plasma trapper, which can be registered in each of the cases: (_} nmin
2iV(->Ga^: VGSC(WP)
4 J V W ^ ' "min
27v(+>(Cc + C a ) / =
(+)
,_)
Sc4>(w0)
'
_ 2JV(-)Ga
j =
The noise voltage values UN-£ and Ufja are determined in accordance with the method detailed above (See Exps.(2.121) - (2.138)). The estimates made there can be used to show that there is reliable satisfaction of the following conditions for effectiveness of the utilization of MPS in a solar wind sensor: iv
> JV
,
n m i n <. n m i n ,
i C m i n < «cmin-
Works [222] contains an elaborate theoretical study of the noise properties of the ,,ampliner-MPS-electrometric amplifier" system.
126
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
2.4-7. Implementation and utilization of modulation-parametric one-ports with negative inductance A one-port with broad-band negative inductance can be implemented in accordance with the theory presented in 2.1 and on the basis of a four-frequency inductive parametric system [153, 217, 218]. There, the maximum absolute value of the negative inductance is equal to | i 9 - | m a x = Lejf
——j-, where Q is the 1 + Qm,2 Q-factor of the oscillating circuit of the inductive parametric modulator, m\ = Leff I-/2 and 77i2 = — are modulation coefficients of the parametric inductance (Li and eff
L2 are the first and second coefficient of the harmonic expansion of the parametric inductance, see (1.25)), Leff is the effective inductance of the parametric element, which is determined as *, 12/-* = ~ = -— / *(<)cosuy d(upt),
Leff
(2.159)
where \&i is the amplitude of the first harmonic of the magnetic flux, which runs through the parametric inductance - $(<) = o + S^Li "^T cosnujpt: Ip is the amplitude of the pumping current flowing through the parametric inductance ip — Io + IP coswpi, Up is the pumping frequency. 9 9* 9* 9* Taking into account that —— = -^7- and -^— = 7—- cosu!pt and using (2.159), 01 dip dip 9/o we can write down
=—I
p
dlp
-—(t)cos2wpt
d(u>pt), which yields
"K Jo dip
Leff + IP?jfL = L0+L2,
(2.160)
where 1 Ln = -
/•7r dty — (t) cos nupt d(upt), n = 0,1,2,... (2.161) •K Jo dip Using (2.159) as a point of departure and taking into account (2.160) and (2.161), we determine Ip ' = 2Li- Ultimately the following formula is obtained p
for the effective inductance of the parametric element: Leff = L^ — Li- The result is rather interesting in that the acting resonance inductance of the parametric element (i.e. the equivalent inductance determining the resonance properties of the pumping oscillating circuit) is equal to the average inductance at the operating point LQ minus the amplitude of the second harmonic in the spectrum of the parametric element L2 • The effective inductance determining the resonance properties of the
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
127
parametric modulator is highly dependent on the amplitude of the pumping current and on the degree of non-linearity of the parametric inductance. Moreover, this dependence is realized mostly through the properties of the second harmonic in the spectrum of the parametric element. The characteristic of the ferromagnetic element in the absence of constant external magnetization can be approximated through the polynomial L = Y^=o anl2n [108]; / - current, an - coefficients. In the presence of an external magnetizing current la, the approximating polynomial assumes the form oo
LIQ = J2 hrr, r=0
oo
Where
br
= Yl a«C2Jon~T-
(2.162)
n=r
(2.162) can be used to express the average inductance at the operating point and the amplitude of the second harmonic as: oo
oo
r=0 n=2r
oo
oo
«r_l
r=l n=2r
The formulae obtained above are used to estimate the possible values of the negative inductance, which is implemented on the basis of a specific inductive parametric element. Fig.2.52 shows a circuit of a device for obtaining broad-band negative inductance by using ferromagnetic parametric elements [218]. The pumping circuit consists of the capacitance C and the inductive parametric element, represented by two inductances V and L", connected in parallel, with ferromagnetic cores in a quasi-saturated condition and coils in parallel planes. The controlling winding Lp of the pumping generator PG is situated in a perpendicular plane with respect to the inductances L' and L". A significant reduction of the hysteresis and linearization of the characteristic of the ferromagnetic core as a result of the orthogonal polarization are realized in the direction of the signal field [108]. Negative inductance is obtained at clamps 1-1 of the load, and its equivalent noise voltage is 2-3 orders down from the equivalent noise voltage of a negative inductance obtained with the aid of an impedance converter with vacuum tubes or transistors, and its absolute value is frequency-independent in a broad video-frequency band. A miniature ferromagnetic toroid can be used for implementation of an inductive parametric element. Owing to the orthogonal polarization of the ferromagnetic toroid with respect to the signal field, a substantial suppression of the Barkhausen noise occurs and so does an almost harmonic change in the inductance of the parametric element. Fig.2.53 shows a circuit of a device for obtaining broad-band negative inductance, where the parametric element i s a p - n - p - n structure simulated by a complementary pair of bipolar transistors [218]. The circuit differs from that in Fig.2.14 in that the capacitance used in the pumping oscillating circuit
128
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 2.52. Parametric device for obtaining broadband negative inductance by using ferromagnetic parametric elements is a semiconductor diode with automatic bias meant ,,to rectify" the amplitude frequency characteristic of the circuit and thereby to improve considerably the conditions for introducing energy into the signal circuit. (This issue is tackled theoretically in 3.2.) The volt-ampere characteristic of the p — n — p — n structure and the dependence of its natural differential inductance on the mode current are shown in Fig.2.54. The system as a whole is a one-port with a broad-band negative inductance, whose absolute inductance exceeds many times the natural effective inductance of the generating system in an even frequency band from ~ 0 Hz to the maximum frequency equal to 5 - 10% of the pumping frequency. The circuit in Fig.2.53 is also marked, first, by the fact that due to the existence of a negative differential resistance of the p — n — p — n structure a high Q-factor of the oscillating circuit, hence a sizable absolute value of the obtained negative inductance can be ensured, and, second, by the possibility to build the device by employing microelectronic means and uniform technology.
Fig. 2.53. Parametric device for obtaining broadband negative inductance by using a two-transistor p - n - p - n structure as a parametric inductive element Fig.2.55 shows the experimental frequency characteristic of the negative inductance introduced into the input circuit (in series with the load ZL) of the fourfrequency parametric system from Fig.2.53 at different relative detunings v. The frequency independence of the negative inductance in a broad frequency bandwidth of the input signals can be seen. The maximum absolute value can be achieved at positive detuning v = ^-rr.
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
129
Fig. 2.54. Experimental volt-ampere characteristic of the p - n - p - n structure shown in Fig.2.53 and dependence of its natural differential inductance on the mode current
Fig. 2.55. Experimental frequency characteristic of the implemented negative inductance obtained by using the device in Fig. 2.53 The obtained broad-band negative inductances can be applied in various electronic and magnetic devices for broad-band frequency correction. As the input inductances of receiving systems of the type of the inductive video sensor are compensated, the sensitivity of these systems can be increased only as a result of the compensation by 10 to 20 dB and the transmission frequency bandwidth of the system can be expanded by 1 to 2 orders. The sensitivity of these systems can be additionally increased, if the four-frequency parametric system is simultaneously used for low-noise parametric amplification. 2.5. Application of self-oscillating one-ports with controllable parameters The possibility to control the effective impedances in a non-autonomous generator, presented in 2.2 and 2.3, can be applied in the development of a number of methods and original devices for signal conversion and processing. The established effect of conversion of a frequency with a different conversion coefficient through main and image channel can be used to develop a method of frequency conversion with image channel suppression. The input signal is communicated to a generator with a non-linear oscillating circuit, whose generation frequency has been shifted with the help of an external synchronizing source of
130
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
electric oscillations in a definite section of the equivalent synchronization band. The initial converted signal is removed from the generator. Fig.2.56 shows an electric circuit of a frequency converter with image channel suppression.
Fig. 2.56. Generator frequency converter with image channel suppression A frequency converter with image channel suppression, whose circuit is provided in Fig.2.57, can be applied in the SHF centimeter and millimeter range.
Fig. 2.57. SHF generator frequency converter with image channel suppression The properties of a non-autonomous generator are used to develop a method and offer original devices for the implementation of parametric elements, for modulation and frequency correction, which can be applied in parametric video amplifiers, in modulators of electric signals in broad frequency bandwidth, for broad-band frequency correction seeking to increase the sensitivity of receiver systems of the type of a capacitive or inductive video sensor, etc. A generator with a nonlinear oscillating circuit is used. A signal, coming from a local source of electric oscillations, is transmitted to it . The frequency of the signal is either close to the frequencies of the self-oscillations or a variable one (frequency-modulated signal) and the signal intensity is sufficient to synchronize the oscillations in the generator.
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
131
Fig.2.58 exhibits a circuit of a device for parametric capacitance implementation consisting of a transistor generator with a tapped-coil coupling. The natural generation frequency is determined by the inductance L and the effective capacitance of a balanced bridge circuit including four semiconductor diodes D\ — D2, operating in a turned-off condition. When the local source sets a voltage that is frequency-modulated in accordance with a sinusoid law (with inconsiderable modulation depth), with a carrier frequency close to the natural frequency of the generator en9uring its synchronization, a capacitance changing in accordance with a sinusoid law occurs at the input clamps of device 1-2 with respect to an external low-frequency signal. As the equivalent capacitance can assume negative values as well, the major indicator of the parametric element the modulation depth of the parameter - can assume quite high values, and it can even be higher than unity. When the external source of alternating voltage is not frequency modulated, but synchronizes the oscillations in the generator, its frequency can be controlled so as to retune the equivalent capacitance of the device in a broad range and thereby to effect frequency correction of the characteristics of receiving systems of the type of a capacitive video sensor. In practice the equivalent AC capacitance can undergo a relative change in the range —— — 2 -f- 5, where Co is Co the capacitance at the operating point.
Fig. 2.58. Device for implementation of parametric capacitance with considerable modulation depth As the parametric element obtained in this way is used with familiar circuits, low-frequency parametric amplifiers with considerable sensitivity and high amplifying coefficient in the video frequency bandwidth can be realized. If the proffered device is used as a modulator of electric signals, it may result in high values of the modulation depth, practically restricted only by the requirement that there should be no self-excitation in the general circuit. It is noteworthy that a parametric element of one type can serve as a basis for obtaining a parametric element of the opposite type. This possibility is illustrated in Fig.2.59, which shows how a non-autonomous generator with a double transistor simulation oi a p — n— p — n structure can be used to obtain a capacitive parametric
132
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 2.59. Non-autonomous generator with a double transistor simulation of a p — n - p - n structure used to obtain a capacitive parametric element element. The equivalent capacitance at clamps 1 - 2 changes in step with the alteration of the equivalent inductance at clamps 3 - 4 . The presentation under 2.2 can serve as a basis for developing a method of converting and amplifying frequency modulated signals, consisting in the following. The frequency modulated signal is fed to a generator with a nonlinear oscillating circuit. The generator also receives a signal from a local source of alternating electric oscillations. The initial amplitude-modulated signal, already converted and amplified, is removed from the same nonlinear oscillating circuit of the generator; besides, its carrier frequency corresponds to the frequency of the local source of alternating electric oscillations. The advantages of the offered method of conversion and amplification of frequency modulated signals are: first, provision of high sensitivity to the level of the frequency modulated signal subject to conversion; second, a possibility for a substantial downward shift of the carrier frequency along the frequency axis; and third, amplification of the signal with a simultaneous transformation of its spectrum. Fig.2.60 shows an electric circuit of a generator converting frequencymodulated signals into amplitude-modulated ones. The circuit is designed by using the two-transistor model of a p — n — p — n structure (Fig.2.14). Here the input frequency modulated signal plays the part of a synchronizing action, while the lowfrequency signal, with respect to which the generator changes its impedance, is the carrier oscillation of the output amplitude-modulated signal. The practically equivalent inductance of the p — n — p — n structure can change within a 5% frequency bandwidth of synchronization from —2 mH to +7 mH. Since the signal fed to the input clamps 1 - 2 is frequency-modulated, the equivalent impedance of the p — n — p — n structure changes in step with the changes in the frequency of the input signal. The amplitude-modulated signal occurring at clamps 3 - 4 has a carrier frequency equal to the frequency of the external source of electric low-frequency oscillations. The high sensitivity and amplification of the signal are realized and ensured as a consequence of the high sensitivity and drastic change
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
133
Fig. 2.60. Generator converter of frequency-modulated signals with a double transistor p - n — p - n structure in the equivalent impedance of the p — n — p — n structure in the synchronization bandwidth. Fig.2.61 displays another circuit of the converter of frequency-modulated signals. The generator is built by using a tunnel diode. The nonlinear oscillating circuit of the generator is made up of the inductance L and the effective capacitance of the balanced bridge circuit consisting of four ,,capacitive" semiconductor diodes D\ —Di) functioning in a turned-off state. For example, when semiconductor diodes with C(0) = 400 pF are used, the equivalent capacitance of the generator with respect to the voltage of the high-frequency signal can vary within the 5% frequency bandwidth of synchronization, for example from —250 pF to +1300 pF.
Fig. 2.61. Generator converter of frequency-modulated signals with a tunnel diode and a four-diode bridge balanced circuit The established effect of frequency selectivity in the case of equivalent impedance changes in a generator one-port with asynchronous action, is used as a basis for proposing a method of spectral selectivity, a method of processing Doppler signals and spectrums, and for developing analyzers of the speed of moving objects. The spectral selectivity method consists in that the electromagnetic signal with frequency (spectral) shift from a given carrier frequency, which is under investigation, is mixed with a base monochromatic electromagnetic signal with the same carrier frequency, and simultaneously the two signals are mixed with a
134
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
third harmonic electromagnetic signal, whose frequency changes in accordance with a sawtooth law within the frequency range of the expected frequency (spectral) shift of the electromagnetic signal under examination. Additionally, the instant intensity of the third electromagnetic signal is indicated and compared with its instant frequency. The method of Doppler spectrum processing renders the spectral selectivity method concrete in its applications to Doppler systems. The Doppler spectrum can be studied by acting on a SHF generator with a swept low-frequency signal in the frequency area of the expected Doppler frequencies. This method is visually presented in Fig.2.62, showing an autodyne analyzer of the speed of moving objects [223]. Let us assume that in this case u>g is the frequency of the signal emitted by the autodyne, and W& is the frequency of the signal reflected by a moving object. The sweep-frequency generator sets a signal with alternating frequency uis in the range of the expected Doppler shifts of the SHF probing signal. At the moment, when the condition LO3 = \ug — a;&| is realized, i.e. when the instant frequency of the swept-generator coincides with the Doppler frequency, a considerable change occurs in the equivalent impedance of the active element of the autodyne (in Fig.2.62 - SHF avalanche-drift diode), which causes a negative output voltage impulse. The latter is recorded by an cathode-ray indicator, to whose horizontal plates a sweep from the swept-generator is fed. The cathoderay indicator can be graduated directly in Doppler frequencies, so as to reflect the input Doppler spectrum. Owing to the high frequency selectivity of the effect, there is reliable reflection of each spectral Doppler component on the screen. This is a way to realize a tunable Doppler frequency filter with an equivalent quality factor Q > 1000.
Fig. 2.62. Autodyne analyzer of the speed of moving objects Fig.2.63 presents an analogous autodyne analyzer of the speed of moving objects but it indicates the Doppler frequency in a digital way [224]. For the purpose of actual modeling, tuning and testing of Doppler autodyne analyzers of the speed of moving objects and of other Doppler signals and systems, a one-band SHF modulator was invented. Its schematic diagram is shown in Fig.2.64 [225]. At this point we shall illustrate the fact of frequency bands separation from modulation products and the second harmonic suppression.
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
135
Fig. 2.63. Autodyne analyzer of the speed of moving objects with digital indication
Fig. 2.64. Single-sideband SHF modulator
If we assume that the carrier SHF oscillation reaching signal arm 1' (Fig.2.64) is sintjo^ (the amplitude is of no importance for this analysis, so it is omitted), the oscillations at the different points marked on the diagram in Fig.2.64 will be as follows: Point 1 - sinu>o£; point j? - sin I u>ot
j - a consequence of the properties of
the slot bridge hybrid. Points Mi and M2 of one of the T-bridges are subjected to the following oscillations: _ . , I sin (u;o<—n— — ) - As a consequence of the T-bridge properties; Point Mi < V It I smujjyt - The low-frequency modulating voltage;
136
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications sin (uJot— — J - A s a consequence of the T-bridge properties; sin(wjr>< + ft) - The low-frequency modulating voltage with a !
phase shift of IT compared to that of point Mi.
As a result of the modulation, the following oscillations occur at points Mi and M2: COS \U>ot — LOot — ft — ~ ) (
{
ft\
cos I wo< + wDt —ft— -r J 5 /
ft\
COS I Wot — Wjjt — ft — -Z I
cos ( wot + wDt - — + 7T1 ; Analogously for points M3 and M4: They are subjected to the following oscillations: sin(wo< — ft) ('sino^oi
{
/ TT\ ; Point M4 < / TT\ . [ sin ^u;Dt + - J sin (wDt - - J As a result of the modulation, oscillations of the following type occur at points M3 and M4.
{
ft\
(
COS ( WOt - UJflt - 7T + — j
cos I w o t + wot — ft - — j ; cos (w o i
-WD<
- - I
COS I W0< + W£>< + — 1 .
The frequency consistent oscillations in the If-arms of the T-bridges are summed up and at the output there is no phase shift:
{
/
7T\
cos lwot — wDt + — I
{
cos \wot + wDt + - J ; (
ft\
modulation .ff-planes A We Output separation shall of band the 12 show - output cos cos(o;o isof cossuppressed in the (u>o (w V— an T-bridge: ofrequency t+wo)t wo)t. + -w analogous wDDt tby H— + - the bands f)2- /);way .single-band takes that place themodulator: second at the (parasitic, output in the undesired) E- and
Controlling equivalent impedances of radiophysical systems
137
sin I Wot — 7T — — ) \ 2>
sin(2a;D<);
{
As an outcome of the modulation: t
{
COS I U)Ot - 2(jJDt
- -K -
/
7T\
sin ujot - — J V 2/ sin(2w o i + 2TT).
7:\
— I
cos fwo< + 2WD< - 7r - —J ; { c o s ( i ^ o * — 2(jj£>t
2TT J
cos ^wot + 2uDt - ^ + 27rj . Analogously sin(a;o< — 7r)
{
fsinwoi
sin(2aiD* - T) As a result of the modulation:
Point M4 < I sin(2w£)t + 2TT).
] COs(tiJot — 2tj£)t — 7T + 7r)
Point M3 < (^ cos(o;oi + 2ut)t — -n — ?r); f cosfwo* — 2u)ot — 7r) Point Mi { y cos(a;oi + 2w£>t + it). In the 5-arms of the T-bridges: cos f toot — 2u>Dt + — J + cos (wo< — 2uj£)t — — j = 0
!
if
w
cos (woi + 2wDt + 0 + cos (u;o< + 2u>Dt - 0 = 0 ;
C cos(w0t — 2uiot) + cos(o;ot — 2tJDt — TT) = 0 Point ^ < y cos(o;oi + 2tojjt — 2TT) + cos(u;oi + 2woi + TT) = 0. It is evident from the presentation above that there are no parasitic oscillations from the second modulation band that penetrate the if-arms of the T-bridges (Point 3 and Point 4), and, respectively, there are none that pass on to the output T-bridge. The experimental study indicates that in practice the interpenetration between the separate frequency bands has suppression in the order of 40 - 60 dB. The suppression of the parasitic second frequency modulation band in comparison with its intensity when it originates in the modulator is of the same order. The single-band modulator can be used in special Doppler trainers, in special single-band radars, in the systems for radio counteraction, etc.
CHAPTER 3.
NONLINEAR RESONANCE IN RADIOPHYSICAL SYSTEMS. IMPLEMENTATION OF PARAMETRIC ONE-PORTS. PECULIARITIES OF THE UTILIZATION OF SEMICONDUCTOR STRUCTURES IN RADIOPHYSICAL SYSTEMS 3.1. Nonlinear resonance in an oscillating circuit with a p-n junction of a semiconductor diode Nonlinear circuits where the role of a nonlinear reactance is played by a semiconductor diode are widely applied in various radiophysical devices: low-noise parametric amplifiers and converters, generators, highly stable frequency multipliers and dividers, frequency modulators, receivers with electronic tuning, trigger circuits, parametrons, for creating non-autonomous phase-impulse multistable elements, etc. [25, 68, 78, 85, 107, 168, 223]. Nonlinear resonance in an oscillating circuit with a p — n junction in a mode of forced external negative bias has been widely studied and properly described in the literature [51, 78, 227]. This section will dwell on the peculiarities of the nonlinear resonance in an oscillating circuit with a p — n junction in an automatic bias regime, i.e. when the negative constant bias is obtained automatically with the assistance of a RC-filter at the expense of inconsiderable direct currents flowing through the diode (Fig.3.1) [78, 228, 230]. This type of an oscillating circuit is frequently used in practice for a number of reasons - stable characteristics of the radiophysical devices, compact design, energy and noise optimization, expansion of the functional capacities, etc.
Fig. 3.1. Series oscillating circuit containing a semiconductor diode in an automatic bias regime Usually, when nonlinear resonance is studied, only the barrier (layer) capacitance is taken into account, and in the case of automatic bias only the static differential capacitance at the operating point is accounted for, but this holds only for infinitesimal voltage amplitudes. Moreover, the volt-ampere and volt-coulomb 138
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
139
characteristic of the p — n junction is approximated with a polynomial including a small number of terms, which, in this case, provides rather a crude approximation. This section will present a qualitative investigation of the peculiarities of a nonlinear resonance in a series oscillating circuit as shown in Fig.3.1. The equivalent linearization method will be used [97]. This method is convenient for the case under review, since we shall account for both the barrier capacitance and the diffusive one by employing the major expressions stemming from the fundamental diffusion theory and reflecting, in a most comprehensive way, the real properties of the p — n junction. As we generalize the equivalent linearization method, we shall study the influence of the higher harmonics on the nonlinear resonance. We shall note that in qualitative and quantitative terms the peculiarities of the nonlinear resonance in a series and parallel oscillating circuit are fully identical with an accuracy to the extent of small quantities of the second gradation order. 3.1.1. Effective (equivalent) parameters of the nonlinear oscillating circuit It is assumed that the voltage at the semiconductor diode changes in accordance with a harmonic law U = UdmZOSCOt. (3.1) The analysis is based on the idea that for a given amplitude of the alternating voltage Udm a n d invariable other conditions, the resonance frequency of the circuit is determined by the effective (equivalent) capacitance of the diode, defined as C «/=#".
(3-2)
where Qi is the amplitude of the first harmonic of the charge ir. the circuit. The equivalent circuit of the semiconductor diode is shown in Fig.3.2, where Rs is the resistance of the semiconductor volume, while the other components are expressed in accordance with the fundamental diffusion theory [168] in the following manner:
Fig. 3.2. Equivalent circuit of a semiconductor diode active differential conductance of the junction
e(i + i3) v T T + z ^ + i
(3.3)
140
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
diffusive capacitance Cd=e(I
+ I3) mkT
y/2y/y/l+^2T2
(3.4)
+ l'
barrier capacitance of the junction (3.5)
\
9k)
where e is the electron charge, m is a coefficient reflecting the influence of the generation-recombination processes of the carriers in the p — n junction [231], C(0) is the value of the barrier capacitance at zero bias, I is the direct current, I3, (fk, and r are respectively saturation current, contact difference of potentials and lifetime of the minor carriers, 7 = 1, - or - [168]. (3.4) and (3.5) are used for obtaining an expression for the charge at the p— n junction
C(0W(y t + Ui0)1-' \
(
U
V" 7 "
+ ^f (eaU* - 1) ,
(3.6)
where
a = ~ 4 ^ , CD = -^=
Ud = -Udo + Udm cos(wi).
As (3.6) is expanded harmonically and (3.2), (3.4) and (3.5) are taken into account, the effective capacitance is determined in the following form C e / = Co-<7 2 + - ^ e - a ^ o J 1 ( Q [ / d m ) ,
(3.7)
where Co and C2 are the constant component and the amplitude of the second harmonic in the Fourier spectrum of the barrier capacitance (3.5), expressed in the general case as
2n J_n \
(3.8)
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
141
Ji(aUdm) is a modified Bessel function of the first order (the designation normally accepted in the literature is In(x), but here we use the symbol In for the amplitudes of the spectral current components). The constant bias of the p — n junction is determined by the transcendental equation Udo = RIse-aU
KD = p-,
(3.10)
and tends to unity, which entails a reduction in the angle of the segment 0 (Fig.3.3). At the same time, however, there is an increase in the amplitude of the direct current impulse, whose constant component maintains the level of the automatic bias. Nonbasic carriers, conditioning an effective modulation of the diffusion capacitance of the p—n junction, are injected in the base of the diode. In this way, as the amplitude of the alternating voltage at the diode increases, the "participation" of the diffusion capacitance of the p-n junction also goes up, which, as we shall see later, results in a number of peculiarities.
Fig. 3.3. Volt-farad characteristic of a p - n junction In an automatic bias mode the semiconductor diode represents not only a pulsative capacitance, but a pulsative conductance as well. The effective (equivalent) resistance of the p — n junction in this mode is defined as R def
V2 RUdmJo(aUdm) V V l + u ; ^ + l Wd0J,{aUim) •
. {6Al)
142
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
S.I.2. The influence of higher harmonics on nonlinear resonance The analysis will be conducted in a more general form. Let us assume that there is a resonance system containing a nonlinear capacitive element with a volt-coulomb characteristic (3.12)
q = f(U).
It can be assumed that in the first approximation, the voltage at the nonlinear capacitive element is in the form U = Umcosujt.
(3.13)
As (3.13) is substituted in (3.12) and a harmonic expansion is carried out, the following is obtained: oo
oo
q = Qo + J2 in = Q° + ] C Qn cos(nujt)> n=l
( 3 - 14 )
n=l
where **• J-K
K J-7T
The effective capacitance in the first approximation can be determined by using a formula analogous to (3.2). The following is done for the purpose of determining the second approximation: As (3.14) is taken into account, the expression for the voltage at the capacitive element is specified
Un = Um cos(wt) - ^2 "Jf z(™),
(3-15)
n=2
where Z{nio) is the impedance of the entire remaining (linear) part of the resonance system. This leads to a criterion for the applicability of the recounted method. The term Um cos(wi) is basic among the variable components in a system with a sufficiently high quality factor, while the remaining terms are only of a correcting character. Hence the applicability of the method is subject to the following sufficient condition: nLjQn\Z(nio)\ < Um, (n = 2 , 3 , . . . ) . (3.16) Further on, expression (3.15) will be used for specifying the functional dependence (3.12), given the condition provided by (3.13). We have qiI
= f[Um cos( W t) - £ ] ~ f(U) - t f ( U ) ,
(3.17)
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems oo
where ( = ^
143
,
—^Z(nuj), f'(U) is a derivative of the charge function (3.12) with
n=2
respect to the voltage U at U = Um coswi. As a harmonic expansion is conducted, the function f'(U) is expressed in the following way: oo
f'{U) = Aa + Y,
An
cos(nwi),
(3.18)
n=l
which results in oo
,
I"
oo
L
n=l
u\u) = J2 ^ ( ™ ) \A° + E A» co
oo
oo
"]
J
= J2 In\Z(nu>)\ sin[(nwt) +
A n cos(nwt)],
(3.19)
n=l
where (3.20)
In = nuQn,
|Z(no;)| and ip(nu) are, respectively, the module and the phase of the impedance of the linear part of the resonance system. After certain transformations, the expression (3.19) is presented in the following way: oo
1
W)
f oo
= o E \ E In+kAn\Z[{n +fc)w]|sh#(n + fc)w] fc=l
l"=l
oo
^
+ ^ J n A n+jt |Z(nu;)|sin[v?(nw)] > cos(ktot) J n=2 ^
oo
( oo
+ o E \ E ^»+t^n|^[(»» + *)w]| cos^n + k)u] k=l oo
Kn=l \
- J ^ / n A n+ /b|Z(ww)| cos[ip(nu)] > sin(fca;<) + harmonics. 71=2
(3.21)
J
Now we can determine the effective capacitance of the resonance system in the second approximation. As (3.14) and (3.21) are taken into account, the following is obtained C{) = ^-^F^~G\ (3.22) where
^
oo
^ - Q i - j E In\Z{nto)\ Bin[^(nw)](An_i + A n + i), m—2
(3.22a)
144
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications 1 °°
G = - J2 In\Z(nto)\ cos[¥)(no;)](An_1 + An+1).
(3.226)
n—2
Hence, it follows that the influence of the higher harmonics of the capacitive current is manifested in that the effective capacitance of the system becomes a complex quantity, G VCef = a r c t g - , (3.23) even though it is assumed that the nonlinear element in the system is of a purely capacitive nature and there are no losses in it. The nonlinear element ,,transfers" energy from the basic tone to the higher harmonics and thus it acts as a generator of harmonics, which is taken into account in the second approximation. The response of the system, as the active losses of the higher harmonic frequencies are accounted for, consists in a reverse action on the effective parameter of the system, which is demonstrated by the appearance of a phase in the effective capacitance. This effect can be qualified as one of the realizations of the general principle of reversibility of the modulation parametric interactions formulated in 1.1. One can see from Exp. (3.23), after taking into account (3.22a) and (3.22b), that the condition fcec > 0 is always satisfied in real systems. Let us use the methods stated above to identify the respective relations for the effective capacitance of a p — n junction of a semiconductor diode. The following expression is obtained for the amplitudes of the harmonics of the charge Qn from (3.6): Q = ^HL (C n _! - C n + 1 ) + — e-aUdoJn(aUdm), n a
n = l,2,...,
(3.24)
where C n are coefficients in the harmonic expansion of the barrier capacitance (3.8). The amplitudes of the harmonics of current In can be determined from (3.20) by using (3.24). The only unidentified elements needed for the calculation of Cef are the coefficients An in (3.18). The first derivative from the charge function (3.12), when taking into account (3.6), is the sum of the barrier and diffusion capacitance of the p-n junction. As a harmonic expansion is carried out, the result is oo
f(JJd) = Co + CDe-aUA° J(aUdm) + 2 ^ [ C n + CDt~alJ^ Jn(aUdm%
(3.25)
n=l
that is
TT
Ao = Co + CDe-aU
J0(aUdm), Jn(aUdm)}.
(3.26)
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
145
3.1.3. Numerical analysis of the resonance properties of the oscillating circuit and experimental illustrations The numerical example will be simplified if the effective capacitance is defined in the form:
Cef = - £ - ,
(3.27)
where I\ is the amplitude of the first harmonic in the current spectrum. The calculation will be made in accordance with the equivalent circuit of a serial oscillating circuit - Fig.3.4. We take as a given the amplitude of the sine voltage (the basic harmonic) Udm at the nonlinear capacitance of the diode Cd, shunted by the linear part of the circuit (L and r), the effective active resistance of the p — n junction Rdef and the spurious capacitance of the diode body and the wiring Cp (moreover it should be pointed out that as the calculations indicate, the pulsative active conductance of the p—n junction in the conditions of a resonance circuit takes a negligibly small part in the energy conversion between the harmonics, hence Rdef can be referred to the linear part of the circuit). For the purpose of determining Rdef, the voltage is averaged with respect to the first harmonic Udm cos(u)t) (3.11) but the specific characteristic of the family Rdef (for example Fig.3.5), which is averaged with respect to a preset higher harmonic, is determined by the frequency of this harmonic. The latter is accounted for by substituting LO in (3.11) with nui.
Fig. 3.4. Equivalent circuit, by the alternating signal, of a series oscillating circuit The capacitive current is written down in the following way:
W(<^(0)(^)\cD^]f.
,3, 8 ,
As the voltage is presented as Ud = — Uda + Udm cos wt, ic in (3.28) is expressed in the form of an infinite sum of harmonics oo
ic = ^2,In sm{nwt).
(3.29)
n=l
The specified expression of the voltage at the diode is oo
Ud = -Udo + Udm cos(wi) - Y^ In\Z(nui)\ sin[nuit +
(3.30)
146
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 3.5. Experimental dependence of the active differential resistance of a p - n junction of a semiconductor diode of the D208 type on the constant voltage applied (the measurement signal has a frequency of 10 kHz) where the module and the impedance phase of the linearized (by taking into account Rdef) part of the circuit is put down as: |Z(nw)| = VH2+N2,
v>(nw) = arctg ^ , n
rRdefjr + Rdef) +
(3.31)
u2LRief '
(r + Rdef)2 + (wLy (r + Rdef)2 + (wLf •
The expression for the capacitive current assumes the form (3.32)
Iccf(Ud)^-U"(Ud)d^, where
oo
£ = y2 In\Z(nw)\ sin[nLjt +
The second derivative of the charge function can be subjected to series expansion as follows All °°
r\Vi)~
= Y,V« "inC^O. n=l
(3-33)
which leads to . . .
U"{Ud)^-
CO
OO
= Y, In\Z(nw)\ sin[nWi + p(na;)] ^ Vn sin(nwt). n=2
n=\
(3.34)
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
147
After the respective transformations, the expression (3.34) takes the form ,JJ
U"{Ud)a-^
..
OO (
=^E
OO
- E VnIn+k\Z[(n + k)v]\ sin^[(n + fc)w]
h=l I n=\ + E Vn+kIn\Z(nuj)\sinip(nu>) > sin(fcu>i) J n=2 ..
OO
f CX!
+ I E i E VnIn+k\Z[(n + kMcos[(n + k)io]
k=\ l n = l oo >j + y Vn+kIn\Z{nu)\ cosip(nuj) > cos(ktjt) + harmonics. (3.35) n=2 J The module and the phase of the effective capacitance are determined as
Cef = -^VS2
where
(3.36)
+ W*,
W <^c e / =arctgy,
(3.37)
S = h + ^ E In\Z(nu)\sin
(3.37a)
I oo
n=2
1 °° W= -Y^In\Z{nu)\coSV{nuj){Vn-
j +K+i).
rc=2
(3.376)
Computation requires working formulae for the coefficients and parameters. Equation (3.28) yields ic = uUdm [
C(0) ( ** V (1 \
^ — ) ¥k + Ud0;
7
+ <7Dea^
Binwt J
=w^«im ^E LfC(°) \
(3.38)
where the expressions for the coefficients Bn are of the form
^^i + ^^ + ^- 1 ) ( ;- 2 ) ^- 3 V + ..., __
7
2^
7(7-l)(7-2) 16
3 P
7(7 ~ 1)(7 ~ 2)( 7 - 3)(7 ~ 4) a 426 P
•'•' (3.39)
148
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
etc.,
0=
(3.40)
%T-
In order to determine Cef, we should also disclose the coefficients Vn in (3.33) and (3.34). The second derivative of the load function is expressed in the following way: rlTl
°°
a t
71=1
/"(tM5r = £Ksin(n^)
00
r
n=1
L
=uUdm V
7g(0),
G37
ic
i
Udm
J
JTk .+1Dn + —^e-aU-ionJn(aUdm)\
\}t>k-rUd0)'
sin(n^). (3.41)
The coefficients Dn in (3.41) are determined in a way analogous to that used for the coefficients B (3.39), if 7 in the latter is substituted by 7 + 1. Fig.3.6 presents the results of the computation of the effective capacitance Cef of the oscillating circuit with a semiconductor diode in an automatic bias regime without accounting for the influence of the higher harmonics (dot-and-dash lines) and by taking into consideration the influence of the second and third harmonic (the solid line) for four different values of the resistance R in the iZC-filter of the automatic bias (See Fig.3.1). The chart in Fig.3.6 shows that given relatively small amplitudes of the voltage, Cef falls as Udm increases. In the case of high amplitudes the rate of C e / decline goes down not only because the operating point projects on a flatter section of the volt-coulomb characteristic (See Fig.3.3), but also at the expense of the considerable growth in the effective diffusive capacitance (the hatch-dotted section of Fig.3.6 singles out only the dependence of the effective diffusive capacitance on the amplitude of the alternating voltage at the diode). The strong influence of the higher harmonics on the effective capacitance of the diode in the case of a low Q-factor of the oscillating circuit (curves 3 and 4 in Fig.3.6) can be explained by the response of the overtones to the high modulation of the diffusive capacitance at the moments of passage into the area of direct currents through the p — n junction. The dots in Fig.3.6 indicate the experimental data obtained by measuring the effective capacitance of a semiconductor diode. Fig.3.7 shows the dependence of the phase of the effective capacitance
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
149
Fig. 3.6. Dependence of the effective (equivalent) capacitance on the amplitude of the circuit voltage without accounting for the influence of the higher harmonics (dotted lines), while accounting for the influence of the second and third harmonic (solid line) for four values of the resistance R in the iJC-filter of the automatic bias. I1, 1" - 30 Mfl (Q ~ 50); S!, 2" - 18 MS! (Q ~ 25); 31, 3" - 3 MQ (Q ~ 15); 4', 4" - 0,33 Mfi (Q ~ 7). Dots are used to denote the experimental data
Fig. 3.7. Dependence of the phase of the effective (equivalent) capacitance on the amplitude of the oscillating circuit voltage for four values of the resistance R in the RC-filter of the automatic bias: 1 - 30 MQ (Q ~ 50); 2 - 18 MO (Q ~ 25); 3 - 3 MQ (Q ~ 15); J, - 0,33 MS! (Q ~ 7) oscillations: ^"»
rj dm
~ y/(l-U,2LCef)*+(u>CefR,)*'
ro i
^ '
150
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
^ = -axctg / ^ f f i ,
(3.43)
1 — u!zLCef
where Rdef (3.44) 1 + (ujRdefCef)2 The computation of the resonance characteristic of the oscillating circuit has been carried out by using equation (3.42) and by accounting for the expressions (3.36) - (3.41). The computation error does not exceed 5% due to the substitution of the coefficients Cn (3.8) with series with a finite number of terms. In the calculations, the modified Bessel functions are replaced with asymptotic series. The roots of equation (3.42) are sought in the amplitude range 0, lUm -r- (Q + 10)Um, where Q is the Q-factor of the circuit defined as
Rp = r + R.+
^ = 5 - + ?T'
(3 - 45)
Ql is the Q-factor of the linear part of the circuit, Qd is the Q-factor of the diode for a given amplitude Udm, Qd =
R
"C
l +^
.
(3.46)
+ RsRdefu2C2ef
•tidef
A simple iteration procedure is used, and the change in the sign of the difference between Udm and the right-hand side of equation (3.42) means that a root has been passed over. The value of this root, with preset accuracy (1%), is determined through successive approximations at ,,half a step". At each stage of the root search, the respective value of the automatic bias Ud0 is calculated through an iteration cycle of equation (3.8). Two ,,external" circles set the variation of the amplitude of the exciting generator Um and the frequency w. Fig.3.8 presents the results of the calculation of the resonance characteristic of an oscillating circuit with automatic bias. It can be seen that as the voltage amplitude increases, the resonance frequency of the circuit keeps growing and an unstable hysteretic section appears on the right-hand slope. As the voltage amplitude goes further up, the growth rate of the resonance frequency decreases and at a certain amplitude the increase stops, the resonance curve ,,straightens out". The decrease in the value of the resistance R in the i?C-filter of the automatic bias leads to a shift of the family of amplitude-frequency characteristics in the direction of smaller frequencies, furthermore the hysteretic instability on the right-hand slope disappears at lower values of the amplitude, while the effect of ,,straightening out" of the resonance curve is more pronounced. The analysis stated above shows that, as the diffusive capacitance is accounted for, the nonlinear resonance acquires a number of peculiarities. The typical
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
151
Fig. 3.8. Resonance characteristics of an oscillating circuit with a semiconductor diode in an automatic bias regime for two different values of the resistance R in the .RC-filter of the automatic bias: dotted lines - R = 0,33 Mfi, solid lines - R = 30 MQ. Dots are used to denote the experimental data hysteretic instability disappears from the right-hand slope of the resonance characteristic. Such a behaviour of the amplitude-frequency characteristic can be applied in the detectors for reducing intermodulation distortions, in the creation of highly effective modulation-parametric amplifiers, etc. The presented approach for obtaining equations concerning the higher approximations on the basis of the method of equivalent linearization, allows conducting a sufficiently precise quantitative study of resonance phenomena in nonlinear systems, particularly of those with a relatively low quality factor. Even the second approximation reveals the complex nature of the effective parameter of the resonance system with a nonlinear reactive element, which is determined by the influence of the active losses at the frequencies of the higher harmonics. Given a sufficiently high Q-factor (Q > 100), the influence of the higher harmonics on the effective parameter is insignificant and the quantitative analysis of the oscillating
152
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
processes in the case of a nonlinear resonance can be effected only by accounting for the basic tone. As the Q-factor goes down, the influence of the overtones leads to a considerable reduction in the values of the effective parameters, compared with the value estimates with respect to the first harmonic, and it is imperative that they should be taken into account. 3.I.4. Excitation of periodic oscillations on the basis of a nonlinear oscillating circuit with a pronounced hysteretic area on the resonance characteristic In this section we shall demonstrate how a typically radiophysical effect can be used to create a method for exciting periodic mechanical motion and to develop the respective facilities. The idea is to use the hysteretic area of the resonance curve of a nonlinear oscillating circuit for an effective energy input in a mechanical motion. This can be achieved by creating the useful acceleration at high resonance amplitudes, while the inevitable reaction against the motion occurs at low amplitudes as a result of a relevant leap within the hysteretic area of the resonance curve. 3.I.4.I. An inductive case (asynchronous inductive motor) The basic idea formulated above will be illustrated by using the system shown in Fig.3.9 [155]. The latter is a radiophysical oscillating circuit periodically interacting with a physical pendulum. We shall demonstrate that it is possible to excite continuous oscillations or rotary motion of the pendulum in such a system. The power supply for the oscillating circuit is a source of alternating voltage E. The pendulum is a freely suspended ferromagnetic disk, which experiences the action of the magnetic field of the solenoid L. Simultaneously, there is also ,,reverse" action manifested in periodic modulation of the equivalent inductance of the solenoid.
Fig. 3.9. Electric oscillating circuit interacting with a physical pendulum
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
153
Fig.3.10 shows the qualitative dependence of the inductance of the solenoid on the angle of pendulum deviation y from the equilibrium position y = 0. The periodic change in the inductance of the solenoid during the motion of the pendulum results in a substantial nonlinearity of the resonance characteristic of the electric oscillating circuit. Fig.3.11 is a qualitative demonstration of the dependence of the voltage U at the electric oscillating circuit on the same angle of deviation y. As the pendulum moves, the characteristics with a pronounced hysteretic zone (known as ,,beak-like" characteristics), typical of nonlinear resonance and symmetric with respect to the point y = 0, occur. Since an alternating current is flowing through the solenoid, a ponderomotive attractive force F is acting on the ferromagnetic disk of the pendulum, which always points at the equilibrium position of the pendulum. The outcome is a very specific interaction.
Fig. 3.10. Dependence of the inductance of the solenoid on the position of the ferromagnetic disk
Fig. 3.11. Resonance characteristics of the oscillating circuit in the case of periodic motion of the ferromagnetic disk over the solenoid The solenoid attracts the ferromagnetic disk, which, as it draws closer to it, changes its inductance in such a way that the electric oscillating circuit ,,tends" to resonance. As a result of this motion towards resonance, the voltage in the oscillating circuit increases, which causes an increase of the current in the solenoid and a stronger attraction of the disk. When the body draws close to the resonance position y — 0, the system Jumps over" the resonance and as a result of the nonlinearity the amplitude at the oscillating circuit changes in a leap-like manner and its value experiences a multiple decline. When the disk leaves the area y = 0, the solenoid already exerts a retarding influence on it, but the amplitudes of the voltage at the oscillating circuit are by far lower. Thus a positive energy input
154
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
occurs for a period. The process exposed above is also illustrated by Fig.3.12. For example, when the pendulum moves from the left to the right (Fig.3.12a) up to y = 0, the force F will exert accelerating action, and further on, for y > 0, its action will be retarding. It can be seen from Fig.3.11 that the pendulum is accelerated at high amplitudes of the voltage (up to J7 max ) on the solenoid, and that its motion is retarded at relatively small amplitudes, which do not exceed U\. The correspondence between the amplitudes of the voltage U and the acting force F can be established by comparing Fig.3.11 and Fig.3.12a. As the pendulum moves from right to left (Fig.3.12b), the process is completely analogous - the acceleration exceeds by far the retarding action, since due to the symmetry, on the one hand, and the dynamic ambiguity, on the other, the dependence of the force on the coordinate is turned into its mirror image. In the case of oscillating motion of the pendulum, the useful acceleration is twice per period, while in the situation of rotary motion of the pendulum the useful acceleration is realized only once per period. Thus the effect is an effective input of energy in the pendulum motion, which compensates for its own losses due to friction. The energy input is proportional to the area of the hysteretic section of the resonance curve (the hatched part in Fig.3.11). Asynchronous excitation of stationary oscillations or a rotary motion of the pendulum are realized. It is obvious that the physical mechanism of the described effect is related to the reversibility of the modulation-parametric interactions in the system (See Chapter 1).
a)
b)
Fig. 3.12. Dependence of the acting ponderomotive attracting force in the case of left-to-right (a) and right-to-left (b) pendulum motion The analytical study of the effect stated will be conducted on the basis of the following equation describing the mechanical motion in the system:
y + 2^ + W o 2 S i n y ^ ^ { ^ ( y
+
,o) + ^ % - y o ) } ,
(3.47)
where /? is a coefficient characterizing the energy losses of the pendulum due to friction, u>0 is the frequency of small natural oscillations of the pendulum, ml2 is the inertia moment of the pendulum, I is the length of the pendulum, m is the mass of the ferromagnetic disk, Lg and y0 are elucidated through Figs 3.10, 3.11
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
155
and 3.12, Jo is the average effective value of the power of the electric current, k is a coefficient accounting for the width of the ponderomotive impulse of the acting force, 8(y ±2/0) is Dirac's delta-function. The solution of equation (3.47) can be presented in the first approximation as follows: y = a s i n 0 , 0 = uit + a. (3.48) As (3.48) is substituted in (3.47) and given the assumptions x = acjcosG, — sin© -f- a—— cos© = 0, and a > yo, the following shortened equations for the at at amplitude and phase of the pendulum oscillations are obtained: (3.49)
^=w(a)-2BJ£,
(3.50)
where w(a) is the frequency of the pendulum oscillations, which depends on its kL0J$ ,., , n amplitude, B = ——-^-. da
(3.49) yields the following solutions for the stationary oscillations (— = 0 and at
a?=2-f I1 - v ^ I 5 ]
4=j£-[i+fi-&*\-
-
(3-5i) (3-52)
The stability analysis shows that solution (3.51) is unstable, while solution (3.52) is stable. Hence, when continuous oscillations are excited, the pendulum should receive such an initial impulse that its amplitude should be bigger than ai. A possible application of the effect of asynchronous excitation of stationary oscillations presented above is the development of a linear reciprocating electric motor [232]. An experimental version of such a motor is shown in Fig.3.13. It is made up of two oscillating systems - electrical and mechanical. The electrical one is a series oscillating circuit consisting of a series connection of an electromagnetic coil (1) of the stator (2), a capacitor (3) and a power source of electric oscillations (4). The mechanical system consists of a steel ball (5) with a diameter of 5 mm, freely positioned in a guiding groove (6) bounded by supports, (7) and (8) with limiting springs (9) and (10) attached to them. The resonance frequency of small
156
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 3.13. Experimental structure of a linear reciprocating electric motor oscillations in the electrical oscillating system (given a symmetric positioning of the steel ball (5) in the stator (2)) is approximately 5 kHz. The interaction of the stator with the secondary element of the motor is due to the dynamic ambiguity of the force acting on the secondary element, which is manifested in the dependence on the coordinate and the direction in which the steel ball moves. The magnetic field of the coil acts on the secondary element the steel ball. Simultaneously, as the ball passes through the opening of the stator, periodic modulation of the coil inductance occurs. The process is analogous to that described for the system in Fig.3.9. In accordance with the position of the steel ball as related to the stator, certain dependencies analogous to those in Figs.3.10, 3.11, 3.12 are realized. In this case y is the linear coordinate of the steel ball motion in relation to the stator. The frequency of the mechanical oscillations of the steel ball is determined by its mass and the other parameters of the oscillating system (elasticity of the limiting springs, friction coefficient, etc.) as well as by the voltage of the power supplying generator 4 in Fig.3.13. At a definite tuning, the oscillations occur at generator voltage 7 -=- 22 V. When the voltage is less than 7 V no mechanical oscillations are observed due to the lack of a pronounced hysteretic zone at the characteristic (Fig.3.11) required for an energy input exceeding the respective threshold value. When the voltage exceeds 22 V, the left-hand and right-hand hysteretic zones of the characteristic (Fig.3.11) overlap, which violates the conditions for effective energy input in the secondary element. It is worth noting that certain tuning can be applied to shift the range of power supplying voltages in the direction of higher values, which increases the power of the linear motor. The only condition is that the dependence of the voltage of the electric oscillating system on the coordinate along which the steel ball moves should be of the type shown in Fig.3.11. The dynamic ambiguity and the symmetric nature of the characteristics with respect to the motion coordinate allow creating a linear reciprocating electric
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
157
motor, which requires no special control systems - commutators, contacts, feedback circuits, hence this is a way to boost its reliability, useful life and efficiency and to reduce its mass per unit of power. The asynchronous nature of the energy input, when the excitation mechanism acts independently of the frequency of periodic motion, enables the attainment of a reciprocating motion of the secondary element with a frequency by far lower than the frequency of the power supplying grid, without any use of additional equipment to convert the frequency of the power supplying current and to exercise control. In practice the described effect and the basic configuration in Fig.3.9 can serve as a basis for the development of various linear reciprocating motors. For the sake of completeness, we shall consider here yet another system, which converts high frequency electric energy into low frequency mechanical energy Fig.3.14 [139].
Fig. 3.14. A dynamic system transforming high-frequency electric power into low-frequency mechanical energy The system is an electromechanical vibrator and the power circuit of its electromagnet includes an oscillating circuit. The oscillation frequency of the mechanical part of the vibrator is by far lower than the frequency of the power source voltage. Under certain conditions the vibrator performs undamping oscillations with a frequency close to its own, whereat the amplitude and frequency of these oscillations are weakly dependent on the frequency of the feeding voltage. This fact, unlike the previous case discussed above, will be explained on the basis of the combined interaction of the frequency of the power supply current v and the frequency of the mechanical vibrations u>. A similar approach was used in Section 2.4.3. in the analysis of an inductive sensor. The equations of the system under consideration are of the following form:
^lL{x)I\+Rdl
+
-L =
UoV^vt
m~ + a-£ + Kx=F(x,t),
158
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
where L(x) is the inductance of the coil with a magnetic core depending on the 1 d$ slot between the plate with mass m and the core, F(x,I) = x~r~, ^ = IL(x) is a magnetic flux, I is the current strength, R, Co, m, a. and K are coefficients made d$ dL clear by Fig.3.14. With a sufficient degree of accuracy we can set — = I ——, [1391. ax ax For small values of x the inductance L(x) can be approximated by means of a polynomial: L(x) = L0(l + a1x - s2x2).
Then F(x,I)
— Lo = (y
Let us set I=y+Asin(vt+
- a2x) I2.
. ^R2v2C2+(L0CQv2
=, - 1)2
tg ip =
r^ , XQ = = is the constant shift of the plate caused by LoCov2 — 1 2 K-\- L0a2I2 the average square of the current strength I2. The equations regarding the variables y and z, given sufficiently small y, z, A, R and a, can be presented in the following form:
jj + Q?y = -nfiSty - 2ftAi;/ + ( ^ - a2x0 - a2z)(x0 + z)(y - Av2 sin *) + 2(ai - 2a2x0 - 2a2z)z(y - Av cos *) + (ai'z - 2a2z2 - 2a2x0z - 2a2zz')(y + Asin^)} z+u*z=-fi[26az-2w&2z+—Pz-—
(^-a2x0-a2z)
(y+Asin*)2-!2},
where, in this case, fi is a small parameter, which should be set as equal to unity in the final expressions; 8X = ——, 82 = - — , ft0 = /T ~- is the own frequency ZL/Q Zm yLoC/o of the oscillating circuit, when x - 0; LO0 = \ — is the own frequency of the V m mechanical system; \? — vt + ip, ft is the frequency of the variable component of
n2-Q20 .
the current y; w is the frequency of the mechanical oscillations; Ai = — — — is the detuning between the frequency of the oscillations Q, and the own resonance frequency fto; A 2 = o> — Wo is the detuning between the frequency w and the own resonance frequency too (A2 is a small quantity). With regard to the unknown frequencies ft and w, we shall impose the condition: ft + w = v. Setting y = B cosfwi + (^1), z = C cos(wt +
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
159
using the averaging method [97] yields the following equations for B, C,
.
ya;j45cost)
2a2 ^2 = - A 2 + ^ 7 (A 2 + 5 2 ) - ° 1 " 2 a 2 J ° f a , 7 ^ sin,,, Z
,
where 7 =
/GO2
ioa 2
ai
(,J(A2+52)
- , v = tp - ifi -
For the sake of simplicity in any further calculations it is assumed that 7(A2 + B2)
4 / 0,6162 a2 •—A -—5—— to + vV 2u>a{jA2
a; — w 0 = 6-2 t g w
a2<52(« + w ) 2
Olii 2
\
W
W
ZO2 W
/
where A = Ai + A 2 . It follows from the conditions for the existence of the stationary solutions, |cos0| < 1, B2 + 0 , that: alujjv+ujf^A2 8£l8i62a2
> 1
~
A>^tgv--^-fi7A2. 4a2 Since 7^42 depends on the frequency v, the first condition out of those listed above, establishes a top limit to the detunings, while the second condition sets a bottom limit.
160
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Let us now examine the stability of the obtained solution. The equations regarding the deviations from the stationary condition B - B^ = &, C - C (s<) = &, i> - */ s() = ?? are of the following form: 6 =h [-(.i + V u
»7 = «i
[\
tg^ + — ^ 7 S 2 26i a 2
^+
/ -B
^-Btgvrj) /
r r
- p 5 - t g « 1^-17
\ 6 2 ( w + v)' !
/ C7
J
•
It is established from the characteristic equation that the solution is stable in the case of tg v > 0. The analysis indicates that the obtained solution can exist and can be stable within a broad range of the detunings A. This range is determined by the conditions derived above. Moreover, the frequency of the mechanical oscillations hardly cross the boundary of the band S2, corresponding to the resonance curve, while the frequency of the oscillations of the component y of the current in the circuit can differ substantially from the own one. The amplitude of the mechanical fluctuations within a broad range detunings may be weakly dependent on the frequency of the power source v. By way of illustration, Fig.3.15 shows the dependencies of the amplitude C on — for the following values of the parameters: — = 100, — = 10, a2 — = 1, fl0 > wo, "fA0 = a2
jU2
= 1 (curve 1) and 7^0 = 0 , 3 (curve 2). The value
R2
C in the figure is related to |Co|, which is the absolute value of C in the case of A = 0 (it follows from the solution obtained above that at A = 0 the value C is imaginary, i.e. such a regime cannot exist). As it can be seen from Fig.3.15, the reduction in the amplitude of the power source voltage entails a substantial shrinkage of the existence area of the oscillations under consideration. It is not difficult to determine the condition of self-excitation of oscillations in the system, which is of the following form: 2m J Lo[(« 2 -^) 2 +4S 1 2 7 2 ] 3
" 2"
This condition determines the critical value of the amplitude of the power source UotCr as dependent on the frequency v and the other parameters of the system. The dependence UoiCr(x) is of a non-monotonous nature and it is represented in Fig.3.16. for two private cases: a) fi0 > ^1 and b) flo <8C 8\. In both cases, for a certain value of the frequency v — vm, the quantity UOlCr reaches its
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
161
Fig. 3.15. Amplitude frequency characteristic of excited mechanical oscillations in the case of -yA^ = 1 (curve 1) and jAl = 0 , 3 (curve 2)
Fig. 3.16. Dependence of the critical amplitude of the pumping voltage on its frequency, when the other parameters of the system are given minimum level. If fio -C <5i, then ujm = v 8 ^ i ; in the opposite case, when fto 3> f>\, the result is ujm = Q.Q H y=.
The frequency of oscillations u> is close to the own frequency wo • The correction A2 of the own frequency in a stationary regime is determined by the last equation in the system of equations, given (^2 — 0. It should be pointed out that the mechanism of excitation of mechanical oscillations described above is manifested in various systems: for example, excitation of elastic oscillations of resonators filled in with high-frequency electromagnetic radiation, occurrence of negative friction in mechanical constructions situated in electromagnetic fields (phenomena kindred to the inductive and capacitive sensor considered above - See Sections 2.4.3. and 2.4.4.).
162
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
3.1-4-2. A capacitive case (an asynchronous capacitive motor) Another possibility is to excite rotary motions (in accordance with the mechanism described above) in a dual circuit - a nonlinear capacitive oscillating circuit with a rotating secondary ,,capacitive" element - Fig.3.17. The oscillating circuit with a semiconductor diode referred to above is used in an automatic bias regime, which creates the required nonlinearity and dynamic ambiguity. The lower plate of the ,,whirligig" is immobile, while the upper one is mobile. The dependence of the voltage U in the oscillating circuit on the angle a between the two plates of the ,,whirligig" is analogous to the dependence in Fig.3.11, i.e. there is a ,,beaklike" characteristic with a broad hysteresis section. There are forces of attraction between the plates of the ,,capacitive motor". They try to bring the mobile plate to a position, when a = 0, i.e. to a position of complete overlapping with the immobile plate. During this motion there is a drive towards resonance and the amplitude in the oscillating circuit increases, and, respectively, the attraction force between the plates also goes up drastically. When the mobile plate passes through the a = 0 position as a consequence of the inertia in its motion, the attraction force already acts as a brake. At that moment, however, a leap has occurred in the hysteresis section of the characteristic, and the amplitude in the oscillating circuit has experienced a multiple decline. Respectively, the braking action is by far weaker than the preceding accelerating action and there is effective energy input in the system, which takes an average of one rotation period of the mobile plate. Thus asynchronous excitation of rotary motion takes place. Its frequency is not directly related to the frequency of the electric oscillations in the circuit (which may fall in the kilohertz or megahertz range). Instead it is determined by the most favourable conditions for optimal energy input in the mechanical motion.
Fig. 3.17. Basic diagram of an asynchronous capacitive motor Let us present analytically the possibility of effective energy input into the asynchronous capacitive motor described above. Let q be the charge on the capacitor plates. The torque, conditioned by the electric forces and applied to the mobile plate (in this case playing the part of a motor rotor), can be expressed as M =
dW
—--, da.
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
163
2
where W = —pq is the energy accumulated in the capacitor, a is the angle of rotation. The voltage between the capacitor plates changes in accordance with a periodic law U = Acos(a;£ +
/
£(~j
——, we can determine the dt
We shall approximate the amplitude of the voltage at the capacitor by using the expression ,
A
, -Amax ~~ -<4.mjn
A —Amili H
7.
,
, AA
a = Anin + "^— a.
We shall proceed to approximate, in an analogous way, the law of capacitance alteration taking into account the fact that it falls in the range 0 < a < TT, and, respectively, goes up when ~K < a < 2ir (a = 0 corresponds to the situation, when the two capacitor plates overlap completely - Fig.3.17). The following expression is obtained for the total capacitance energy:
W = W^ + W<-> = \\(AA)2 + i(A^)A min l AC, / where W^
AA \2
,2ir I -4mm + ~^Ta I — / —^ —ACda J-K
is the energy obtained by the rotor
4TT
/
AA V
,TT ( A m i n + — a I as the capacitance increases, W^ = —/ — —ACda is the energy Jo 4n dissipated as the value of the capacitance decreases as a result of the braking action of the coulomb forces of attraction, AC is the capacitance change in the oscillating circuit. It is obvious that W > 0, i.e. the energy input takes place for one period of high-frequency oscillations. Simultaneously, the energy is dissipated due to friction,
Wf= I Mfda, Jo
164
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
where Wf is the energy dissipated because of the action of the moment Mf of the friction force. Let us assume that My = £ft, where £ is the proportionality factor, while ft is the angular rotational frequency of the rotor (ft
Wf=
f £Q,da= f £ft 2 dt = £ft^T = 27r£ftst, Jo Jo
where ftst is the stationary angular rotational frequency of the rotor. The factor £ can be determined from the equation:
/f+£ft = 0, where J is the moment of the inertia of the rotor. If at t = 0 the rotor turns with frequency fto, the solution of this equation can be written down as ft = ftoe~At, where A = — is the damping decrement. From here we can determine the time Te over which ft falls e times - ATe = 1, therefore £ = — . The ultimate result that we get for the energy dissipation due to friction is Wf = 2 ^ f t s ( . e
In order to determine the stationary rotational speed, we equalize the accumulated and dissipated energy over one period W = Wf. We obtain TeW
TeAC\l,...2
1
/ A
, , ,
1
Since the parameters AC and AA are related to the width of the hysteretic area on the characteristic (Fig.3.11), we can draw the obvious conclusion that the effect of asynchronous excitation of stable stationary motions is determined by the hysteresis area of the highly nonlinear amplitude-frequency and phase-frequency characteristics of the electric oscillating circuit in the system. It is worth noting that the area of the hysteretic section is not dependent on the angular rotational frequency of the rotor, when satisfying the inequality
ft«^, 20 where TR = — is the relaxation time of the oscillation amplitude in the resonance circuit, Q is the Q-factor of the oscillating circuit. The average moment of rotation under this condition is Xr ACA2
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
165
while the average power obtained by the rotor from the electric field is determined w_ACOQWl
4TTCOJ '
= ^ ~ . This yields the efficiency of the motor in the form
w h e r e Wf
C , , ACOQ 77 = 7—7, where ( = —. It is important to note that when the conditions referred to above are satisfied, the power of such a capacitive motor can exceed by far the limit set by ManleyRow's energy relations (See 1.2). This was an illustration of the possibilities for extensive utilization of the peculiarities of nonlinear radio engineering oscillating circuits in the case of excitation of periodic mechanical motions. It can be shown that the same peculiarities of radio engineering oscillating circuits can also be used on the ,,molecular" level for exciting specific precession in ensembles of molecules, which will contribute to the acceleration of other processes, for example specific chemical interactions. 3.2. Nonlinear and parametric resonance in a generalized oscillating circuit Many modern resonance systems can be represented as oscillating circuits with two opposite nonlinear reactive elements: thin-film contacts of superconductors with semiconductors [140], SHF transistor resonance amplifiers, resonance systems tunable by means of JIG spheres, LC systems with complex nonlinear circuits and niters [78], etc. These systems can be used to construct different radiophysical amplifiers, generators and transformers. The investigation of such systems is therefore of theoretical and practical significance. However, great difficulties arise in the theoretical analysis of such systems. The presence of two opposite nonlinear reactive elements considerably complicates the respective calculations. The examination concerns the most general case of a resonance system with nonlinear inductance, nonlinear resistance, nonlinear capacitance and nonlinear conductance. An example of such a system is a two-transistor model of a p—n—p—n inductive structure, complemented to a resonance oscillating circuit by a self-bias p — n junction - Fig.3.18 [233, 234]. The system is compared with oscillating circuits containing but one nonlinear reactive element. For the sake of brevity, the circuit with nonlinear capacitance is conventionally termed circuit of type I, while the circuit with nonlinear inductance is called circuit of type II.
166
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 3.18. Complex oscillating circuit represented by a double transistor simulation of a p — n — p-n structure with nonlinear inductance and negative resistance, and p-n junction with automatic bias representing nonlinear capacitance and nonlinear conductance
3.2.1. Equivalent circuit and approximation of the nonlinear characteristics The equivalent circuit of the resonance system under consideration is shown in Fig.3.19, where R(i) and L(J$f) are the nonlinear negative resistance and the nonlinear negative inductance of the p — n — p — n structure, Cd(q) and Gd(q) are the nonlinear capacitance and nonlinear conductance of the self-biased p — n junction, r is the resistance of the losses, U — Um cos(Wr — V9) l s the external harmonic voltage exciting oscillations in the system.
Fig. 3.19. Equivalent circuit of a complex oscillating system with negative resistance and four nonlinear elements The characteristics of the elements used in the system in Fig.3.19 are represented as polynomial functions: Ud = d'iq-d'2q2-d'3q3, id = g[q-gW-9'zq\
LW
= i + vy + vw
+ £'# 3 '
U(i) = —k[i + k'2i2 + k'3i3, where Ud and q are the voltage and the charge on the diode D (Fig.3.18), * is the magnetic flux, L'n and k'n (n = 0,1,2,3) are constant coefficients. The coefficients d'n and g'n:
dl
~
Co
'
3
"
2CUk
''3"
6C-V2
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
g[ = ahe-Z'd',,
167
g<2 = *Ise-E° U - ^f\
,
are determined by using the dependence of the p — n junction capacitance on the applied voltage and V/A characteristics given by
V
4>k)
where U — Ud — EQ and EQ = Eo(Qm) is the constant self-bias, which depends on the charge amplitude Qm, (f>k is the contact potential and 7 = 1, - or - . A
o
Fig.3.20 presents the analytical and experimental dependence Eo(Qm) of a semiconductor stabilizer diode at R — 0,33 MQ. and C = 0,1 //F (See also Fig.3.18). It is clear that in the case of small Qm the dependence is approximated as Eo = -(xiQm + *2#m), and when Qm is large as Eo = —x(Qm - Qc), where xi, X2, X3, and Qc are constant coefficients.
Fig. 3.20. Analytical and experimental dependences of the constant automatic bias of a p - n junction on the amplitude of theflowingalternating charge Further on, the polynomials approximating the characteristics are used in the nondimensional form: /i(xi) = Ud(x) = zi(l - d2Xi - d3x\), H{x1) = id{xi) = zi(si - g2X\ /2(a;2) =
-j-,—r — 2:2(1 + L\xi + ^2^2); 50^0 L{x2)
U{x2) = -^3/2(^2) + h[f2(x2)]2 + k3[f2{x2)]\
g3x\),
168
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
where
Xl
q =— =
*
q JJ-^
, x2 =
1 —, OJ0 =
(1+*)T
= ,
i¥W
Ua and q are, respectively, normalizing voltage and normalizing charge, ,
4 Co go
9i = — ,
d'sCogp
2
9 2 = 3 2 — i 93 = 3 3 — > 7^— = —j-,fa
= k2—,h
= k'3——.
3.2.2. Equations The differential equations of the system in Fig.3.19 are
dfr + Ud + rL{¥) _*_
K¥)=ld{q) where
+ u{l) = u'm cos{ujtr
~^
• , , , dq
+
dTr>cr
= i, tT is a real time.
Using dimensionless parameters, the equations can be rewritten: ^=Mx2)-H(Xl) 1
dx2
w h e r e t = ai o
r ~ i ^"> =
9
m r
/w
\
(3'53)
•
y Wo-^o <^o<7o-ko T h e essence of t h e m e t h o d applied ([185], See 2.2) is t h e introduction of new variables r
«,
-1I/2
t/i = 2 / fi(x1)dx[\ L io J
signal,
r
yx 2
and a new nonlinear time variable r,
=
-11/2
y2 = 2 / /2(x2)
/i(si)/2(s2)= 1 1 2/i 1/2 Gi(yi) G2(y2)
signa;2
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
169
In terms of the newly introduced quantities, Eqs.(3.53) can be rewritten: ~f-t + P2yi = /J-F1{yi,y2,yi,y2,T] (3-54) - ^ | - + /322/2 =
pF2[yi,y2,yi,y2,T]
where Fi[yi,y2,yi,y2,r] = -yi + - \ \-U(x2)-
7^/2(^2)
+ Um cos (^-t - ^ ] G,(yi) - ±[H(Xl)G2(y2)] J , ^2^1,2/2,^1, 2/2,T] = -j/2 + -H(a;i)G2(y2) + - - T - f t - ^ O ^ ) fl
- ^f2(x2) jz
=
2—^ UJT
/J,
fj, CLT
+ Um cos ( — t - y> ) ] G i ( y i ) } ,
= /? — 1, LOT is the resonance frequency, ujn — — u , m,n = 1, 2, 3 . . . n
fi
The functions Gi(yi) and G2(j/2) can be represented as polynomials: Gi(yi) = bi + b[y + ... + bnyn,
G2(y2) = b1,1 + 6{Jy + . . . + bInlyn.
An analogous procedure is applied to obtain — for the circuit of type I d ^ + /32y1=fiF11(y1,y1,T), where ^ ( y ^ y j . r ) = ^
_ I - g - + LH(y1)G1(y1)
— for the circuit of type II
(3.55) + ^[H{yi)}
q°{1 +
^ ~ + P2y2 = vF22(y2,2/2, r ) ,
^J (3.56)
170
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
where fj,F22(y2,y2,T) = uy2 - — \-^f(x2) at [y
n -
WjL°
<•» —
TJ > <-'m —
r
+ U{x2) - Um cos ( — t -
)j
u>m 2
r
•
vfjqoLo
3.2.S. Forced oscillations The solution of Eqs.(3.54) can be represented as yx = Rcosf3r = Rcos<£>, — = - / ? i ? s i n * y2 = Rsin/3r = i?sin*,
'
dyl
-p-=/?iJcos* or
( 3 - 57 )
where the differential equations for the establishment of the amplitude R and the phase ip of the oscillations are: 2/3-7- = - - / dr n Jo = ( - ^ i
-Pi [yi,y2,2/1,2/2, r] sin*c?* + 2fc2/o/i + 3fc3i?/i - Um amp) B'o - ^ - , (3.58)
d* a [2* 2/3-— = - - / Fi[yi,i/2,2/i,2/2,r]cos*d*
= -uR - ^-IoBi + k2[llB[ + hI2Bl\ + h[I30B{ + ZhhBl] - Um c o s ^ + SoBi1, J_ _ 1
1
(3.58) takes into account the following equalities, obtained under condition (3.57): H(yi) = So + Si cos * + S2 cos 2 * + . . . , /2G/2) =Io~Ii
s i n * + h sin2* + . . . ,
Gi(i/i) = Bi + B[ cos * + B{ cos 2 * + . . . , G 2 (y 2 ) = Bl1 - S [ 7 sin * + 5 7 / sin 2 * + . . . An analogous procedure is applied to obtain — for the circuit of type I
dR R „ 2 — = - — - bi - Umsin(p dr Q
;
(3.59)
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
171
— for the circuit of type II 2 — = ~^- + 2k2loh + 3fc3/02/i + Um cos^> dT
(3.60)
9 E
The amplitude-frequency and phase-frequency characteristics of the complex oscillating circuit are derived from (3.58)
v=v« ± U(UmBl)*- ^~-^I1+2k2I0I1+U3P0I?j 1
/ x ( - Q - J l + 2kM
^=arcts^I w h e r e VQ = 2 ( " - " » • » ) , ^
\ + 3fc3/ 0 J l ) B0 -
I^BT^R =
1
v.
5o-^|^]
(3-61) S*B"
'
= - ^ . ( ^ 0 " - 1) + ~
\-~IoB[
woo y/LCo ^oo -K (_ y s +Jc 2 [/^B( + hI2B[] + h[llB{ + ZIohB^] + SgBl1} is the equation of the so called ,,skeleton curve" [51]. The condition for the ,,linearization" of the amplitude-frequency characteristics is (o2 + &2) + 6 i 7F"o" + T + T ~ J -R = o-7^r = 2 c(/f [ woo VVE ^ ^ ^ /J In this case the condition for the absolute stability of the complex resonance system is
(^*)(I+4?)+(^+-'+"¥)('+^)>» The analysis of these inequalities shows that the lack of a slope on the skeleton curve I —— = 0 I is a sufficient condition for the absolute stability of the stationary \dR / oscillations. An analogous procedure is applied to obtain
172
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications — for the circuit of type I _1_
S^
.. = ,., ± / ^ ) ' - ( i + §)2, ,= — tg |lf, <«2) where i/Os =
(5^ - 1) +
—
;
— for the circuit of type II
•»'" "£<*'" :) * i f e ) ' - 5 (&-*'•'•-*""•)' ^f^V^-D V = arctg
x
^
(3-63) ;-.
To determine the area of bistable work - for example of a circuit of type I, equation (3.62) is written in an implicit form
F(R, uo) = (~ + S1)2 [ML+^lM _ VoR _ ^LR{Bi W
/
L
W
^oo
_J
J
2
_ Vl
= 0.
The boundaries of the area with bifurcational instability is determined by the condition dv0 _ dF(R,vo)ldR _ dF(R,v0) ~dR ~ dF{R,vo)/dv dR ~ ' After certain transformations the following parabola, delineating the area of bifurcational instability, is obtained
U { Q - l/0){2blb3
+b
*)Q+3{QJ
+
^--
h2V°
(3.64)
where the coefficients bn (n = 1,2,3,...) are obtained from the characteristic of the nonlinear capacitance Cd(q) by using the method presented in [185].
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
173
Fig. 3.21. Theoretical amplitude-frequency characteristic of a complex oscillating circuit (continuous curves 1, 2, 3) and types I and II oscillating circuits (dotted curves I1, 21, I11, 2n). Curves 41 and 411 delineate the bifurcational area of instability
Fig. 3.22. Experimental volt-ampere characteristic o f a p - n - p - n structure and dependence of its natural differential inductance on the regime current Fig.3.21 shows the theoretical amplitude-frequency characteristics of the complex oscillating circuit (curves 1, 2, 3) and of the circuits of types I and II (respectively curves I1,2T,& and l / 7 , 2 7 / , 3 7 / ), calculated according to formulae (3.61), (3.62) and (3.63) for three values of the exciting voltage. The following elements have been taken into account during the computation: the real characteristics of the nonlinear elements used in the experiment, a quadratic law governing the change in the differential capacitance of the diode with Co =430 pF and the
174
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
characteristics of the p—n—p—n structure R(i) and L(ty) for iZ/j=l,5 kfi and 2,7 kfi (See Fig.3.22); — = — = 0,02, R = 3,0 Mfi and 0,33 Mft. It is clear that it is possible ,,to straighten" the resonance curves in such a system, i.e. to eliminate the area of bifurcational instability. The parabola (3.64) describing the area of bifurcational instability of the circuit of type I is given by the dash-line curve 4 7 in Fig.3.21.
Fig. 3.23. Experimental amplitude-frequency characteristic of a complex oscillating circuit (continuous curves 1 and 2) and of types I and II oscillating circuits (dotted curves I7 and I11) Fig.3.23 presents the respective experimental amplitude-frequency characteristics for the parameters given above. There is no area of bifurcational instability on the resonance curve of the complicated oscillating circuit, whose type is close to that of a linear oscillating circuit. 3.2.4- Parametric resonance The differential equations for parametric resonance in a complex oscillating circuit (to ~ 2o>o) are:
2/3^
= (--^-h + 2k2hh + 3*3^-0 Bo + VmB[ [1
+ 2/3^
(|g)] siw -^[ 1+ (|)]f» s ,-^, (3.65)
= -vR - -^-IoBl + k2[llB[ + hI2Bl\
dr
QY,
\
/Bn\2
+ kz [llB[ + SIohhBi] + UmB[ 1 + \-±jj \
/-B J \ 2 1 Bu
cos v
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
175
The amplitude-frequency characteristics for this mode are presented as
—^44 + (f)T + (WHf)T)"~ +^ ^ \ ,
-\(-^I1+2k2IoIl+3k3III1^BIo
(3.66)
where Voh
= -—{BlB» - 1) - -i-Joflf + | [ / X + hI2Bl\ + ^{llB[ + ZhhhBl}. K
For the resonance of the third subharmonic (w ~ 3to0) one obtains CD/J
I
f / 2 7 \ 2 F'i R7 / R 7 \ 2
^+[if(-l|)]>[(-^ +^
7? 7 / R J / l 2
+
^)B«-^]2
(3.67) An analogous procedure can be applied to examine the parametric phenomena in oscillating circuits of types I and II. For example, the amplitude-frequency characteristic of the parametric resonance and the third subharmonic resonance for the circuit of type I is obtained in the following form: — for w ~ 2wo
l(ZUmBl\2
(ISA2
„ _
— for u ~ 3a>o
i * =i "« ± >|[4xU>)J where i/oc =
(B'o - 1) + Woo
ipr^ V-K
"U+^J'
(3-69)
.
Figs.3.24 and 3.25 show the theoretical (Eqs.(3.66) and (3.68)) and the experimental amplitude-frequency characteristics of the parametric resonance in
176
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 3.24. Theoretical amplitude-frequency characteristics of parametric resonance in a complex oscillating circuit (continuous curves 1, 2) and in types I and II oscillating circuits (dotted curves I 7 , 27 and I 7 ', 277)
Fig. 3.25. Experimental amplitude-frequency characteristics of parametric resonance in a complex oscillating circuit (continuous curve 1) and in types I and II oscillating circuits (dotted curves I7 and I77) a complicated oscillating circuit (curves 1 and 2) and in circuits of types I and II (respectively curves I 7 , 21 and I11, 2n). Equations (3.66) and (3.68) yield formulas for the critical amplitudes necessary for the excitement of parametric resonance: — for the complicated oscillating circuit
PL =
=
^
Si [1 + U v J +V
^~2
—^,
(3-70)
B» ) 1 + U v J
— for the circuit of type I (3.71)
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
177
The dependencies (3.70) and (3.71) on the detuning v$ are shown in Fig.3.26 (for the complicated oscillating circuit - solid-line curve, for the circuit of type I - dashed line). The conclusion is that the excitation threshold of parametric oscillations in a complicated oscillating circuit can be considerably lower than in a circuit possessing one nonlinear reactive element. This fact can be explained by the improved conditions for parametric energy accumulation in the circuit of two parametric elements. The best conditions for parametric energy input are realized for equal depth of the capacitive and inductive parametric element modulation. If, \
nl
nil
/
•fc>0
-°0
\UmcrJ
TTI
for example, B& = B» and - } = - ^ = 0,8, then ( ^
2
) ~ 5Bf.
Fig. 3.26. Theoretical dependencies of the critical amplitudes of parametric excitation on the detuning for a complex oscillating circuit (continuous line) and type I circuit (dotted line) The analytical expressions obtained provide opportunities to examine the influence of each element on the resonance and parametric phenomena in a complicated oscillating circuit. The complicated oscillating circuit considered can be applied in various amplifiers, generators and convertors, active quality filters. Their construction using microelectronic technology is of great importance. The analytical approach outlined above can be used to examine the characteristics of any device (particularly those possessing the resonance systems listed in the beginning of the section), which can be presented in the form of a complicated oscillating circuit with two nonlinear reactive elements of antipodal nature.
3.3. Generalized modified method of complex amplitudes for analyzing processes in nonlinear oscillating systems Consider a nonlinear oscillating system of second order described by two nonlinear differential equations, which can be presented in the following vector form: —x = A(x)x + f(r),
(3.72)
178
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
A(x) = {a o -(x)}, •,; = 1,2,
x
=[^]'
(3.73)
f(r)= H f ^ c o s ^ r + ^t)L -I Jb=o
System (3.72) can be solved by using the method of successive approximations presented below, where, for the sake of expediency, it will be rewritten as
jU(" = A^'- 1 V > + f(r),
(3.74)
x"" 1 ), x ^ are the solutions of system (3.72), respectively in the (/— l)-th and l-th. approximation. Initially we shall determine x^'' assuming that x''" 1 ) is given. During the analysis we shall use a special version of the method of complex amplitudes. Some major transformations related to this method were explained in section 1.2, while its overall presentation is given in section 5.1 of the book. It follows from some general considerations that the solutions concerning approximations of arbitrary order can be presented in the form x('-1)=
oo
oo
£ x('-1)COs(^r + ^'- 1) )^x('- 1 )= J2 x ^ V * " k= — oo
k= — oo
oo
oo
k= — oo
k= — oo
x«>= >T x<0cos(*«/T + p<0) «-*<'> = J T 4 ° e ^ r .
(3.75) v
'
Since it is regarded that x^'"1) is a given quantity, as we substitute it, in the capacity of an argument, in matrix (3.73), we linearize the latter. Now matrix (3.73) can be regarded as directly dependent on time. oo
A(x<'- 1 ))-A('- 1 )(r)= J2 2A<'-1)cos[fcI/r + V>(t~1)]-
(3-76)
fc=-oo
In this case the periodic matrix function A is represented in a harmonic Fourier series. Using (3.75) and (3.76) we rewrite equation (3.74) oo
(;M-Ar')40- E M-M^k n= — oo
k = 0, ±1, ± 2 , . . . , ±oo, for negative k h = 0. In this case I is a unit matrix of the second order.
(3.77)
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
179
A compact presentation of the latter system can take a matrix form: -L-C-l) •
A
-
x = f.
(3.78)
The bar above the symbols means that the infinite matrices and column vectors are of a block type, i.e. that their elements consist, respectively, of matrixes and column vectors of the second order. The matrix of system (3.78) is of the following type:
-]vl-ktl)
-A^1}
~-A(_j-1}
-A|'-x>
-A<'-1}
-A^l)
-At'- 1 )
-A*'' 1 *
(3.79)
juI-At"
The frequency multipliers of the first terms in the main diagonal of the matrix are of the type jkv, k = 0, ±1, ± 2 , . . . , ±oo. The infinite algebraic system (3.79) can be solved approximately by using the method of reduction. A system of three equations can be solved in the first approximation, five equations in the second one, etc. Continuing this process we obtain the g-th approximation as a result of solving a system of 2q + 1 equations,
4° = E 4° *'•""• k=-q
(3-8°)
The approximate solution of the initial equation is obtained from (3.80):
s<° = Rex(ol) = J2 4 ° c°
(3-81)
k=-q
The l-th. approximate solution can be estimated in terms of the scalar square of the solutions in the /-th and (/ — l)-th approximations:
A!=(x«-«r I I < o -« ( i - i ) ) = I f l*P + 4'-1'2 - 2 : « - » coe^W -rf-1 ')]• k=-q
The inequality A;
180
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
If one knows nothing about the solution of Eq.(3.72), he should start with the zero approximation. It should be assumed that in (3.72) k = 0. For this quantity system (3.72) is integrated without difficulty. Then, following the procedure described above, the first approximation is obtained, then the second one, and so on until the l-th. approximation is obtained with the required precision. It is worth noting that the problems for obtaining all approximations of the solution of system (3.74), except the zero one, are of one and the same type. Coupled with numerical (computation) methods, the proposed approach can ensure a virtually arbitrary preset precision of the solution. The analytical approach proposed allows examining systems of nonlinear differential equations of an arbitrary type. We shall apply the analytical approach exposed above to the investigation of a serial resonance circuit with nonlinear capacitance C =
—— excited by sine 1 -(- Xq voltage U = U cos Lot. This is a typical problem, which appears whenever one uses semiconductor parametric diodes (varactors, varicaps), ferroelectric variconds, etc. as well as in the air capacitor cases, when a powerful source of electric energy is used for excitation purposes. Enormous forces undergoing periodic time-dependent changes with a double charge-altering frequency are applied to the capacitor plates. Such a phenomenon occurs, for example, at the output stages of the powerful radio transmitters for special purposes. The oscillating circuit equation concerning the capacitor charge is ^
(3.82)
+ 2a^+Lo20(l + \q2)q=jcosuJt,
where a is a damping decrement, LOO = y/LCo
, A is a small number, Xq2
Equation (3.82) is a particular case of Eq.(1.27) under section 1.4, if a = 0, A= UL-1, n = to. In our case the approximation we have used presupposes that the coefficient before q changes at frequency 2w, i.e. Q, = 2w. This yields the spectral composition of the charge in the form w + Ml = io{2k + 1),
fc=0,±l,±2,...,±oo,
i.e. in a stationary regime the charge can contain only odd harmonics of the frequency to. The solution of Eq.(3.82) and its transform are given in the form oo
q=
Y,
oo
Q2k+lCOs[(2k + l)L0t +
k= — co
£) k= — co
Q2k+i = Q 2 *+ie^ 2 f e + 1 ,
k = 0, ± 1 , . . . , ±oo.
Q2k+iej(2k+1),
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
181
The oscillating circuit equation concerning the charge transform is
g
+ 2 t ,J + u S ( 1 + A i±i),=
^.,
(3.83,
where q is the time function that is complex-conjugate with respect to q. For A = 0 the result is a zero approximation of Eq.(3.83): ^
« ^
+ 2
+
^
= ^»',
(3.84)
The precise solution of (3.84) is £(0) _
Q(0)e]Ljt^
Q(°>=
,
°> = - a r c t g ^ - .
U
As we know the zero approximation of the solution, we obtain the first approximation of Eq.(3.84):
+ *Q(°)eJ2«A q(D =
(3.85)
V-ei^
(the sign „*" denotes the complex-conjugate quantity). The precise solution of this equation can be presented in the form of an infinite sum. We shall limit our presentation to only four terms, which allow us to estimate the first and the third harmonic: » 1
( 1 )
-VO,n,e'
( 2 W ) u i
— /—I V2A:+l e it=-2
O (1)
e jV "+i
-O{1)
i V2fc+1 — V2ifc+le
T
•
As (f^> is substituted in (3.85) and the terms with equal frequencies are selected, a system of four equations is obtained, which is conveniently represented in the following matrix form.
|~0~
a-3-3 I a-3-i I 0 I 0 1 1 Q(±l I a-i-3
0
a-i-i
a-n
0
Q-i
I 0 I a 3 i [ q 33 1 [ Q^ I
_
_^_
[o
(»
a*\
182
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
where a _ 3 - 3 = - 9 w 2 - w02 (l + | < 5 ( 0 ) 2 ) A W 2 *«»
Au,2.(0) 1
a-3-1 = —7-Q
-j6au,
a-i-3
=
-~A~Q
'
a . , - ! = -a; 2 + «02 ( l + ^ Q ( o ^ ) - j2a W ,
Aw2"'0) a-11 = ~T~V
Aa,g,(0) 1
ai-i
~A~^
=
>
a n = -<^ 2 + w02 U + ^<5 (0)2 J + J2aw, a 13 = ^ - Q , a31 = ^ Q ( 0 ) , ass = -9a, 2 +u,02 ( l + ^ Q ( 0 ) 2 ) + j6aa,. In order to solve system of Eqs. (3.86), we obtain the general D and particular determinants: D = a_3_ 3 a33(a_i_ian — o_uOi_i) — a_i_3a_ 3 _i(aiia 3 3 — 013031) —0-3-30-11013131, D-3 = f7L~1o_3_ia_na33, D-i
= —[/X~ 1 a_ 3 _ia_iia 3 3,
Di = f/L~1a33(a_3_3a_i_i - a_3_ia_!_3), D3 = -UL^1 a 3 i(a_ 3 _ 3 a_i_i - a_3_ia_!_ 3 ).
The complex amplitudes of the solution are expressed as Q-3 - - Q - . v - i -
£ , Vi - £ . y 3 - £ •
The transform of the first and third harmonics of the solution are obtained by means of the complex amplitudes:
^
= <# V** + Q%-3«\
f^ = Q^e'3ut +
Q-3e-^.
As the transforms are known, the harmonics themselves can be put down
gW = R4? = ReKQ^ + Q^y"1} = Qi1' cos(a;i + ^ 11) ), f3(l) = Ret] = ReKQ^ + Q^)^ 3 -'] = Q^ cos(3ut + ^ 31) ), where
Oi1' = y/tf?
coe„<» + 0 ^ COS/.W + (Q?rin^- Q ^ sm^j') 2 ,
tf," = ^ ( Q W COS VW + Q(i] c o s ^ ) ' + (Q^} sin^ 1 ' - Q™ s i n ^ ,
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
183
_(1) _ Q ^ s i n ^ - Q ^ W i ] *Vl "gWcos^ + Q^cos^r _(1) _ Qi"rin y ;"-qWri.^ **' C^cos^ + Q ^ W . T In the case of small values of A in (3.82) this can be the end of the analysis. Otherwise a second approximation equation is drafted with respect to the transforms
+£
(V + ^ ^ ) e 3 2 u t + V + ^ *» ) e ' 3 2 u t
^(1)^.(1) +
^(1)^(1)
Qi Qz e,-4u,« + Qi Q3 Z
Z
1\ e-j4Mt
( -(2) = ^ e J W t I
(387)
lj
The approximate solution of this equation is obtained by using the methods presented above. Approximations of a higher order can be obtained in an analogous manner. It is notable that the coefficients of Eq.(3.87) and the following approximations do not change the sign and that they are perfectly smooth. It follows from the theory of Fourier series that in this case the amplitude value of the harmonics desreases as the order increases, i.e. the sum of the Fourier series displays absolute and uniform convergence. In such cases it is not necessary to provide special evidence on the convergence in the solution of the infinite system of equations.
3.4. Implementation of parametric one-ports Parametric one-ports with a high-frequency change in the parameter are implemented mostly through the action of voltage or high-intensity current on nonlinear reactive and resistive elements and devices [78, 109]. Parametric oneports are obtained mainly by using nonlinear capacitive and active conductance of a p-n junction of a semiconductor (parametric) diode. Varicond and reactance valve capacitances, nonlinear inductances of ferrite cores and thin magnetic films, tunnel diode, Gunn diode, avalanche transit time diode conductances and transistor collector junction [78, 85, 235] are used less frequently. Surface semiconductor capacitances, ferroelectric structures, impedance converters with modulation in the
184
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
reactive feed-back circuit, Josephson superconductor contacts, special capacitors with a light-beam controller capacitance, etc. [109] can also be used as parametric reactances. The major difference between reactive and active elements consists in that oscillation energy in an electric and magnetic form is accumulated and exchanged in reactive elements; at the same time resistances (positive or negative) are elements, which serve as a means of dispersing or increasing the energy in the system. The reactive and active one-ports with time-dependent parameters (parametric oneports) have both common and distinctive features. For example, the ability to generate harmonics is proper both to nonlinear and parametric capacitances and inductances, and to nonlinear and parametric resistances. A nonlinear element is also required, when alternating current is converted into direct current, but in this case the nonlinear element can only be a nonlinear resistance. A generalization of the basic properties of nonlinear reactive elements is provided by the theorem formulated by M. D. Karasev [236]: ,,It is not possible to obtain direct current from alternating current with the aid of a purely reactive element, even if this element is nonlinear. It is not possible to convert direct current into periodic alternating current by using a system consisting of an arbitrary combination of nonlinear reactive elements and constant resistances." A direct consequence of these principles is the postulate that it is impossible to design a negative reactance, which, having only its internal feedbacks and devoid of external sources of alternating electromotive force could impart energy to an external circuit. Negative resistance can be obtained artificially at the expense of a direct current source and a feedback controlling the conductance only under the condition that the total energy, which can be communicated by the negative resistance sector, exceeds the energy needed to control the feedback. The nonlinear capacitance of the p — n junction has become particularly common as a nonlinear reactive element in semiconductor parametric systems owing to its simplicity of design, compactness, low natural losses and the actual inertia-free barrier capacitance up to 1012 Hz [85]. It is a well-known fact already used in section 3.2, that the barrier capacitance complies with the following law of external voltage alteration [168]: C(0)
dq V
(3.88)
9k)
where C(0) is the differential capacitance at external voltage equal to zero, 7 = 1 , or — is a coefficient depending on the type of the p — n junction, and
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
185
which the current flowing through the diode is virtually zero. In the case of silicon diodes the values of Uf can fall in the range from 0.2 to 0.5 V, while in the case of gallium arsenide diodes Uf has higher values. From the viewpoint of the realization of parametric one-ports, the voltage Uf can be regarded as one of the parameters of the semiconductor diode.
Fig. 3.27. Volt-farad and volt-ampere characteristics of a semiconductor diode of the D817A type The parameter Uf, together with the parameter Ef, (the inverse voltage of p — n junction break-down) determine the possible maximum amplitude of the voltage Um at the diode in the absence of direct currents. We shall term the relation ay = coefficient of utilization of the (fk - Eo
characteristic of the semiconductor diode. The maximum value of the coefficient ay for a given negative bias Eg in the absence of direct currents is: a Vm
_Uf~E°
The coefficient avm grows with the increase of the negative bias to the maximum possible value (m)
_
Uf - Eb
Zifik - Uf - Eb
Fig.3.27 shows a regime of pumping with harmonic voltage (HVP). The other extreme case is harmonic current pumping (HCP). This regime requires a dependence of the diode barrier capacitance on the charge applied. As (3.88) is integrated at initial conditions U = 0 and 5 = 0, the following expression is obtained for the volt-coulomb characteristics of the parametric diode
9=Q*[l-(l-^)17],
(3.89)
186
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
, _ C(0)y t where Qk = — ^ — . 1-7 As U in (3.89) is expressed through q and substituted in (3.88), the required relationship is obtained: —1
C(q) = C(0) (l - J - )
^
.
(3.90)
Fig.3.28 provides examples of a coulomb-farad and volt-coulomb characteristic of a semiconductor diode corresponding to (3.89) and (3.90).
Fig. 3.28. Coulomb-farad and volt-coulomb characteristic of a semiconductor diode of the D817A type There is a peculiar aspect that is worth mentioning. It follows from the voltcoulomb characteristic shown in Pig.3.28 that additional constant voltage should appear as a result of the nonlinearity of this characteristic. But in accordance with M.D. Karasev's general theorem [236], it is impossible to achieve detection (rectification) by using a nonlinear reactive (in this case capacitive) element. This apparent paradox is resolved by assuming that the high-frequency pumping results in the occurrence of an additional constant charge on the nonlinear capacitor that meets the requirement of zero additional constant voltage. The diode retains only the external constant bias EQ , while the constant charge at its capacitance changes
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
187
to Qo + AQo, where AQo is the additional charge caused by the action of the high frequency pumping. An analogy can be drawn with the HVP regime, when identifying the maximum value of the factor characterizing the utilization of the parametric diode characteristic in the HCP regime, i.e. (3.91)
Vfc - Vo
It follows from the expressions for a y m and agm, that at Uf =
(3.92)
Analogously for the opposite (inverse) capacitance (that is elastance) S(t) =
--^—(l-avcoSu;pt)\
Similarly, for the HCP mode we set q = —QE0 + Qm coso>pi in (3.90) to obtain C(t) = S{t) =
C(QEJ(1
- aq
cosujpt)^
x ^_ . -——{\-aqcosu}pty-i
(3.93)
188
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Regardless of the power supply mode of the diode, its capacitance and elastance can be presented through the following Fourier series (See also (1.25)): oo
C(t) = Co + 2 ^
Cn cos nupt (3.94)
"^ S(t) — So + 2 y Sn cos nu)pt.
The coefficients of the series (for example in (3.94)) will differ at ay = ctq, as follows from (3.92) and (3.93), hence the energy transformation in the devices employing nonlinear reactances will depend on the power-supply mode of the diode. Some studies show that at high pumping levels the HVP mode ensures more effective energy conversion in the broad-band modulation-parametric converters. In a mode of a partially forward-biased p — n junction, the sum total of the diffusion current and the current of the barrier capacitance flows through the diode. The diffusion theory of the flat p — n junction developed by Shokly is mostly applicable to lab germanium diodes. The distinctions from this model can be explained by the generation-recombination processes in the space charge layer, which can be actually accounted for by introducing a coefficient m in the analytical expression of the p — n junction volt-ampere characteristic [78, 231]: / qu \ I = IS f e^T - l j ,
(3.95)
where Is is the saturation current, U is the external voltage applied to the p — n junction, q is the electron charge, k is Boltzmann's constant, T is the absolute temperature. In addition, the components of the parallel equivalent circuit of the p — n junction are expressed in the following way: — differential conductance g (J
G
+ Js)yVl+a;27-' + l
= ~^kf
^
(3 - 96)
;
— diffusion capacitance Cd = q(* + Is">
-
•
mkT vVv'l + ^ + l '
(3 97)
— barrier capacitance
Ce = - r ^ T7 =Cofl-^lnff-l)l" 7> V
fkj
(3.98)
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
189
where r is the life-time of the minority carriers in the diode base, u is the circular frequency of the small alternating signal. Figs.3.29 and 3.30 present, in a double logarithmic scale [78, 231], some typical experimental dependencies of a p — n junction conductance and capacitance for a silicon and geranium diode in the current range of 1 - 100 fiA and a frequency range of 5 - 500 kHz. The solid lines show the theoretical dependence of the conductance G and the sum of capacitances C = Cd + Ce. For the sake of convenience during the comparison, there are additional entries along the x-axis: the direct voltage for the qU silicon diodes and the direct diffusion current Idif = IsemkT for the germanium diodes.
Fig. 3.29. Experimental (with different dots) and theoretical (continuous lines) dependencies of the conductance (a) and capacitance (b) of a silicic semiconductor diode of the D208 type: 1 - 500, 2 - 200, 3 - 100, 4 - 50, 5 - 15, and 6 - 5 kHz; m = 1,39, T = 14 //s
Fig.3.31 provides an answer to the logical question of how the dependencies of the capacitance C and conductance G of the p - n junction are going to change, given a further increase in the direct current. Fig.3.31 provides a clear picture of the values of the inverse currents /;, for which the capacitive nature of the differential reactance is changed to inductive. The dotted line shows the value of the ,,negative" capacitance obtained experimentally, while the dash-dot line indicates the equivalent inductance of the diode at frequency 500 kHz. kT When working with high pumping voltage amplitudes (3> ) and periodic
190
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 3.30. Experimental (with different dots) and theoretical (continuous lines) dependencies of the conductance (a) and capacitance (b) of a germanium semiconductor diode of the D7J type (m = 1,45 r = 14 /is); 1 - 500, 2 - 200, 3 - 100, 4 - 50, 5 - 15, and 6 - 5 kHz forward-conducting of the p — n junction, one should bear in mind the following typical aspects: 1. In the case of low frequencies
I w < — I, the small signal differential
V rJ characteristics G(/,w) and Crf(/,w) can be used, e.g. those shown in Fig.3.29 and 3.30, and as the frequency dependencies are taken into account a spectral analysis of the pulsative complex one-port can be made.
2. In the case of higher frequencies ( w >• — I, the effect of accumulating quasistationary charge of minority carriers in the diode base should be taken into account. Indeed, within the action time of the positive half-wave of the current, a charge of minority carriers is accumulated in the diode base. It fails to attain T . complete recombination over that time - t = — (T is the period of the highT frequency pumping voltage). Therefore, at time t = — the diode is in imbalance, i.e. it is a source of voltage AU(t), which causes the emergence of an additional current component, whose value is not set by an external source - it depends on the diode parameters, on the circuit, operation mode and frequency of the signal. The presence of a residual charge in the base is equivalent to a reduction of the
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
191
Fig. 3.31. Experimental dependencies of the differential capacitance (a) and conductance (b) of a silicic diode of the D208 type in the case of high injection levels: 1 - 500, 2 - 200, 3 - 100, 4 - 50, 5 - 15, and 6 - 5 kHz equilibrium potential difference of the p — n junction by AU(t). This results in a change in the constant current component both in value and in time, as well as in a bias shift. The influence of the effect of accumulation and establishment of a quasistationary charge of minority carriers on the performance of the semiconductor diodes in radio physical systems will be considered in detail in the following section. When the semiconductor diode operates in a direct current mode, its nonlinear differential conductance, rendered pulsative under the action of the pumping voltage, can be presented in terms of the small signal theory through a Fourier series (See also 1.25): 00
Gd = G0 + 2^G n cosnwt,
(3.99)
n=l
where
1 r
Gn — — / Gd cos nuitd(ujt). If the high-frequency voltage at the diode is relatively high, for example several volts, then in practice it is often sufficient to present the volt-ampere characteristic in the following simplified way: (3.100)
192
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
The operation mode of the nonlinear conductance can also be convincingly described by using the concept ,,line segment angle":
n
U°
<3om = arccos — , where UQ is the direct voltage at the load connected in the circuit of the nonlinear conductance, Um is the amplitude of the alternating pumping voltage. In this case, the convenience stems from the fact that the line segment angle is unambiguously set by the ratio of the load resistance at the signal frequency (RT) and the internal (natural) resistance of the diode (Ri = —) through the formula: Gi tgQom-Qom _ Ri__ Yj_ 7r RT Gi
The real values of the ratio -=^— 0, 2 > —— > 0,001 encountered in practice RT
RT
have the following corresponding range of values for the line segment angle: 45° > e o m > i5°. As regards the parametric diode with external bias, the line segment angle is related to the parameter ay in the following way: cos0 o m =
-,
TpZ\-
a* i1 + i)
The concept of ,,line segment angle" can also be used when the parametric diode operates in an automatic bias mode. In this case, in order to determine the line segment angle, one has to measure the direct current Jo, which can be related to the amplitude of the alternating pumping voltage Um and 0 o m in the following way: h = —^-(sin0 r a - 0 o m c o s 0 ) , hence
j3irRjI0 Worn - y TJ V
um
The Fourier coefficients in (3.99) can be expressed through the angle of the line segment 0 o m in the following manner: G G C Go = T- L 20 om , Gi = - 1 2 s i n 0 o m , G2 = — L sin0 o m , 2TT
etc.
Z7T
Z7T
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
193
For the purpose of ensuring a high Q-factor in the resonance radiophysical systems, one usually uses a mode of inconsiderable transition into the direct current range of the diode characteristic. In this case the approximation of the volt-ampere characteristic (3.100) is quite crude, so the analytical expression (3.95) will be used. In this case the Fourier coefficients in (3.99) can be expressed as follows: Go = cJse-aE° J0(aUm) = alo, tri = -alse 2 2 = -alse 2
°Ji(aUm) = -al0 2 Jo{aUm) atf">J2(aUm)
= -alo 2
T}
[, Jo(aUm)
etc., where Jn(x) are the modified Bassel functions of the ra-th order. Studies of Josephson's quantum-mechanical effect conducted in recent years have shown that the Josephson element has nonlinear inductance, which can be considered as a parametric element [140]. As first shown by Josephson, the phase difference if of the wave functions describing superconductive electrodes is related to the junction voltage V through the relation -y- = -^-V, 4>Q - ~— = 2.0710"15 Vb, qe is the electron charge, h is Planck's at
cpo
2qe
constant. The junction current may have a ,,superconductive" component (supercurrent) I3, which depends on the phase
L = \jnt,
(f>0
where L has the dimensions of an inductance: — = — cos<^, Lc = -——. L
Lc
2TT1C
With respect to small external signals the occurring supercurrent with its properties is equivalent to a reactive element with differential inductance L. The inductances that we are aware of are divided into geometric and kinetic according to the type of the energy stored. The geometric (magnetic) inductances are characterized by the capacity of current carriers to accumulate magnetic energy. Kinetic inductance has to do with the inertia of the current carriers. In reality, kinetic inductance does not occur in ordinary metals as a consequence of a relatively large dispersion of the current carriers.
194
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
In the case of the Josephson effect, the inductance of the contacts is of a kinetic nature. Its nonlinearity is associated with a quantum-mechanical interferential effect of the wave functions. The typical dependence of the Josephson contact inductance on the phase ip determines the two basic modes of its utilization in parametric systems: with external pumping and with self-pumping. A major peculiarity of the Josephson supercurrent as a parametric element is the possibility to achieve considerable depth of parametric modulation. The Josephson inductance can take negative values for certain phases. On this basis a generic presentation of the effect of single-frequency non-degenerate parametric regeneration has been attempted [189]. The occurrence of this effect is associated with the possibility for the reactive parametric element to take negative values periodically in the process of its alteration. Section 2.1 has shown that similar phenomena are observed in modulation-parametric systems, where strong regeneration effects are manifested as a result of the reversibility of the interactions. Given a greater modulation depth, as in the case of a Josephson inductance with periodic transition to the area of negative values, there is no further need for a resonance circuit and the regenerative effects are also manifested in an aperiodic system. 3.5. Influence of the effect of accumulation of a minority carrier charge on the performance of semiconductor diodes in radiophysical systems The classical p — n junction diffusion theory developed by Shokli [168] assumes that the p — n junction has no resistive losses. Moreover, as diffusive conductance is calculated, it is regarded that the p — n junction is connected to a voltage source with zero internal resistance. Given this formulation of the problem, the charge of minority carriers in the diode base is ,,obliged" to follow the voltage applied, since the recharge of the diffusive capacitance conditioned by this charge should take place ,,instantly" through the zero resistance of the source. Consequently, this charge is always equal to zero at the beginning of each subsequent period of high frequency voltage and it is not accumulated at the diode base. Since the real diode always has finite resistance of losses, the mechanism of signal detecting and frequency dependence of the diffusive conductance of the p-n junction should be determined by the accumulation process. In addition, the wellknown definitions of ,,quadratic" and ,,linear" signal detection become meaningless. Usually, when the inertia properties of the semiconductor diodes are analyzed in the written sources, the transient characteristics, for which a voltage impulse is taken as an initial signal, are considered. But in the case of such radiophysical devices as detectors, rectifiers, frequency multipliers, parametric systems with semiconductor diodes in a direct current mode, etc., a quasi-harmonic signal is fed at the input and the issue of the choice of a diode cannot be unequivocally resolved on the basis of its transient characteristic, for in this case there is no unambiguous correspondence between the transient and the frequency characteristic.
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
195
Both theory and practice indicate that the semiconductor diodes in the resonance circuits of radiophysical devices can operate within quite a broad frequency range, and that they are also used at frequencies for which WT3>1, where r is the life-time of the minority carriers at the diode base. This possibility is mostly conditioned by the actual lack of inertia of the barrier capacitance of the p — n junction, up to frequencies of 1012 Hz, and the ,,top" limit is necessitated by the resistance of the semiconductor volume Rs. As the semiconductor diode operates in a transfer mode, for a part of the period the inertia of the diffusive capacitance and active conductance influence tangibly the frequency dependence of the detected voltage in the direct current area. In this connection, there arises a number of questions concerning, first, the legitimacy of using small signal differential parameters of the impedance and quasi-static voltampere characteristic of the p-n junction, when carrying out the computations in the kT conditions of high frequencies and considerable amplitudes of the voltage (^> — , q q is the charge of the electron), and, second, the peculiarities of using partially forward-biased p — n junctions in resonance circuits of radiophysical devices: the influence of the accumulation of a minority carrier charge on the nonlinear resonance in the oscillating circuit with a p — n junction in a direct current mode and on the exchange, in the parametric modulator, between the pumping circuit and the signal one in the situation of a parametric complex one-port, which shows inertia with respect to the pumping but is liable to modulation by the signal, etc. At this point we shall examine the process of accumulation and establishment of a quasi-stationary minority carrier charge at the diode base given a different nature of the load, the peculiarities of the diffusive detection mechanism at high kT 1 amplitudes of the alternating voltage (^> ) and higher frequencies (a; 3> —), and the influence of the effect on the diffusive conductance of the semiconductor diode. 3.5.1. Phenomenological model of the process of charge accumulation As we build a phenomenological model by using the charge method [78], we shall use as a basis the equations describing the behaviour of the carriers in the base area of the diode and providing a mathematically adequate description of the accumulation process. We shall carry out the calculations for the well-known model of a semiconductor diode with a plane p — n junction, subject to certain limiting conditions [168, 237]. Fig.3.32 shows the form of the current and the voltage at a semiconductor diode operating in a mode with an active load at high frequencies (w 3> —). We shall divide the task into two parts: the first one - from the beginning of the sine up to point £,r (Fig.3.32), as long as the current has a sine form, and the second one - from point £„• up to the beginning of the next positive period.
196
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 3.32. Form of the current (/) and of the voltage (U) on a semiconductor diode operating in a regime with an active load at high frequency (UJT = 50) Taking into account the familiar limiting conditions [168, 237], we can write an equation concerning the diffusion of the holes, the boundary and initial conditions in the following form: (3.101)
P(x,0) = 0,
P(oo,T c ) = 0,
^ ( 0 , T c ) = -sinfiT c at ^ OX
< T c < T
Si
^
+
^
;
il
P(0,Tc) = 0 a t ^ + T ; r < T c < ^ ± l ) , n = 0,l,2,... In Eq.(3.101) the concentration of the holes P is normalized to Pg = — , where j m is the amplitude of the current density, the time Tc and the coordinate x are taken in dimensionless units, Si = 2TTF, F is the frequency in units —. The boundary conditions are changed at moment TV, corresponding to £n (Fig.3.32). Equation (3.101) is solved by using a grid method and an implicit scheme, (Ax)2 with a step of Ax = 0,01 along the coordinate and a time step ATC = —-—, which differentiates the optimal speed of convergence. The calculation error has been established and it does not exceed 5%. Fig.3.33 reveals the dependencies of the charge concentration at the diode base at different points in the course of the first period. Curves 1, 2 and 3 correspond to different moments during the action of the positive half-wave. In the case of a negative half-wave the holes ,,collapse" back through the p — n junction, with a part of them recombinating. At the boundary of the p — n junction (x = 0 ) , the concentration falls to zero but a certain charge remains to be accumulated at the base in depth. Curve 6 illustrates the distribution of the concentration at the end of the first period. Fig.3.34 presents the dependencies of the residual charge at the diode base during the non-stationary accumulation process at the end of 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 16
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
197
Fig. 3.33. Distribution of the concentration of the non-basic charge in the base of the diode at different moments in the course of the first period (o>r = 50) and 40 periods for frequency F = 8 (wr = 50). The process of accumulation and establishment of a quasi-stationary charge of minority carriers at the diode base is clearly seen.
Fig. 3.34. Distribution of the residual charge from non-basic carriers at the base of the diode in the case of non-stationary accumulation process (wr = 50) The dependence of the non-dimensional quasi-stationary charge QQ on the reduced frequency 9 = LOT is represented in Fig.3.35. The charge Qo reaches
198
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 3.35. Dependence of the non-dimensional quasi-stationary accumulated charge in the base of the diode on the reduced frequency maximum value at frequency 9 = 12. At a further increase of the frequency, Qo falls gradually and at u> —> oo it tends to zero asymptotically. Later on it will be shown that the charge method can serve as a basis for conducting a sufficiently thorough study of the frequency detection characteristic and the diffusive admittance of a semiconductor diode in an extreme mode - high kT 1 amplitudes ( > — ) and higher frequencies (w > —). The process of accumulation and establishment of a quasi-stationary charge at 27 the base of a semiconductor diode occurs at u> > —^— in the following way [237]. The charge left over at the base after the first period at zero initial condition 0(0) = 0 is Qi=Q*e~*-Qir, where QK is the unbalanced charge at time ut = n, Q\r is the charge that has run out during the negative half-wave of the first period, 9 = WT is the frequency reduced in accordance with the lifetime T of the minority carriers. After the second period, the charge left over at the base Q2 = Qi ( l + e - n r ) - ( Q 2 r - O i r ) . Analogous reasoning is applied to obtain the following recurrent formula for the n-th period:
_| or
Vnr
Qnr
^inr
J
_a
Qn = q ' e " T " a ? W - ( l - e - " » ) ,
(3-102)
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems where QK =
m
199
(1 + e~~8 J , Im is the current amplitude.
It follows from (3.102) that the process of establishing quasi-stationary charge Qo at the diode base is determined by the lifetime of the minority carriers r according to the law (1 — t~r j . At n —> oo (3.102) yields
Qo =
Qne~f
-Qr 2^—\-e~S-
(3.103)
3.5.2,. Frequency characteristics of detection The rate of change in the detected current Jo, corresponding to the change in the frequency —— , is proportional to the charge Qo accumulated by the diffusive aw capacitance of the semiconductor diode [238, 239, 240]. In the general case dlo _dImK(6)
"fa -l^~7~
+
1
Imr
dK{9)
~
~M~ =2^°'
(3 - 104)
where K(6) = 1—
r is the frequency characteristic of detection, Qw = / I{t)dt Qw Jo is the charge of minority carriers injected into the base of the positive half-period, 1 [2T -*-O Qr{9) = — I I{r))e e dr\ is the part of this charge, which runs back through w Jo the p — n junction during the negative half-period, T is the period. If the diode operates with an active charge R, Im = —— and —-p- = 0. Then it dui
Q
0
=2/
r|^|.
m
(3.105)
In the case of a complex charge yL, the following can be written: ^
^ du
^
1
n
•K
dd
2TT
(3.106)
In the particular case of an automatic bias, the load represents a RC filter, and Eq.(3.106) takes the form K\d)
+V
JQ
~
orTT
= 7j—,
(3.107)
200
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
where Qw = ^f-
= 2CUm, Um = ^ .
As (3.103) and (3.105) are equated and the denotation —— = ZR is introduced, Qw the following equation is obtained 1
dZR
6{e-e+e-o)
6(l-e-2-f)
d6
2(l + * ) ( l - H F ) "
R
Its solution is of the form
^R = —j— / —
where / ( ( ? ) = / '
^
7
^FV-^'
(3-108)
2
For the case of external forced bias E, the charge equation ( ——I
= I(t) )
yields: ^ 1-e T
QO=QVW-Q^
where <5T_2¥> =
7 m 7 -^ d2
/
I1+e
i +W V
7r-2yA
r
^ 1— e
« I cos
[
,
(3.109)
7r-2y"
e
^ 7
1 + e e~_
is t h e
charge at
moment wt = TT — 2y> for a zero initial condition, the angle
ZE = ^ ^ — / H{6)eF^de, 2 Jo where
F(6) = [cos
(3.110)
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
6)
/
7r+2y3
2TT\
e—9-+C-T
r
cos-0/?
i
H{6) =
1-e
j-1
201
7T—2^"
5~
^ ^
1.
For the case of an automatic bias mode the following is obtained for the relation between the direct and inverse charge ZRC(3.111)
where Vw "
i _)_ e
5—
The expressions (3.108), (3.110) and (3.111) are used to obtain analytical expressions for the frequency characteristic of detection and the quasi-stationary accumulated charge Qo for the different modes in the form
K{8) = 1 - Z(9), Qo{9) = - ^ ^ f ^ e - f - Z{9)\ . Fig.3.36 shows the theoretical characteristics of detection in a circuit with a semiconductor diode at different external negative biases. The dots indicate the experimental data.
Fig. 3.36. Theoretical frequency characteristics of detection with a semiconductor diode in an external negative bias regime. The experimental data are plotted by means of dots It is clear from the analysis shown that at high frequencies the detection mechanism is associated with the accumulation of additional quasi-stationary charge at the diode base. The emerging direct current /* = —- flowing along the active resistance of the load R, creates an automatic negative bias —Rig., which leads to the reduction of the potential difference of the p — n junction.
202
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Let us estimate the relation between the constant voltage u0, corresponding to Jg, and the amplitude of the variable component of the voltage Uj at the p — n junction itself. The direct voltage at the p — n junction is obtained from the voltampere characteristic:
- = M ^ + i ) ' -—*-£• <""> The amplitude of the variable component of the voltage at the p — n junction is Uj = Im\Zd\, where \Zd\ is the module of the diode resistance at high frequency,
,*,-[ w (*^ + 1 )vf. Then
^W^lnf Uj
IK
(3. 113 )
Is
V
'
The latter ratio shows that Uj does not depend on the amplitude of the alternating current Im and that it falls off as the frequency increases. At -f = 102, Q = 3 and KR(0) = 0,8, (3.113) yields ~ ~ 1,17, i.e. starting ls
Uj
at frequencies Q = 2, 7, the ratio — > 1 increases as the frequency goes up. 1' . It is obvious that at high frequencies Uj < UQ, and the diode is virtually always ,,forward-biased" for both half-waves (positive and negative) of the alternating signal. The analytical expressions for KRC{0) and KE(6), corresponding to the mode of automatic and forced external bias, can be checked through a numerical solution of the diffusive equation (3.101) for the adopted model of a p — n structure and for the conditions of a stationary regime. To this end, however, the overall transition process should be calculated many times, which, apart from the error accumulation, will require too much computer time. In order to avoid these inconveniences, we can work out an equation on the function of distribution of the minority carriers ip(x) at the diode base in a stationary regime. We present the solution at moment Tn (corresponding to moment £n in Fig.3.32) as a sum: 1) of the solution with initial zero condition and boundary conditions corresponding to the sine current h(x), where x is once again a coordinate determining the distance in depth of the diode base, and 2) a solution with homogeneous boundary conditions and an initial condition coming from the previous moment of switching H(x).
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
203
The expression for h(x) is obtained by solving the diffusive equation (3.101) at zero initial conditions by using an operator method on the basis of the CarsonLaplace transformations: k(x, T,) = _ _ /
V71" JO
sin[fi(Tw - Z2)]e
+
^ dZ,
(3.114)
where fl = 2nF, z is the impedance, which is external with respect to the diode. The following can be written for H(x) at the switching point T^:
H(x,Tn) = J™ G2(x,V) jjf%(OGi(«,£)#} dr,,
(3.115)
where ¥>(£) is the distribution of the minority carriers at the base and at the moment of previous switching, Gi(r/,£) and G 2 (z,'?) are Green's functions for the first and second boundary-valu problems [96, 100, 104]. The multiplier in the figure brackets represents the distribution of the holes at the end of the previous period determined on the basis of the certain distribution at moment T* of the same period. (3.115) is rewritten in the following way:
(3.116)
H(x,T,e)= n
where G(x, £) can be defined as Green's function for the problem with conditions switching at moment Tn. After certain transformations, the following is obtained
for(x,0:
lyJitlQ
V.
\Z\/1-Kl2-Lo /
\Zy/llrl2-L0/
I J
where To is the voltage period in units r , T2 = TQ — T^. For the stationary process the solution obtained for the switching moment Tff is identical with the distribution
V(x) = h(x)+
f°°
v(QG{x,Z)dt.
(3.117)
The expression (3.117) is Fredholm's equation of the second order, which can be used to establish
204
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
In order to obtain the solution in the case of an automatic bias mode, it is sufficient to simply transform the function h(x):
h{x,Tn) = ^=f V ^ Jo
7r{sm[n{Tn-z2)+
(3.118)
The current at an arbitrary moment after TK is determined according to the formula e-Tc
Q
_j2
/-oo
I(Tc) = -7rP(x,Tc)x=0=
(3.119)
T'c = Tc — I Tn + 27T— ), S = 1, 2, 3,. . . , Tc is the current time in units r. The harmonics of the current can be calculated by simply using the Fourier formulae. Knowing the charge at the base of the diode Qrn at moment Tn, we can resort to the charge equation ~+= I(Tc), dlc T to determine the charge at an arbitrary moment as Q(TC) = Qe-T'
(3-120)
+ e~T< f ° e'/(v)di7, Jo
where C; is determined by the equation Cl
=
QTweT*-
Jo
e^sini^*?-
For the purpose of calculating the charge harmonics, a relation can be established between them and the current harmonics. Multiplying the left-hand and right-hand parts of Eq.(3.120) by sinnft and cos nft successively, and averaging for a period, we obtain Qna~
_ Inc - nQ,Ins Ins + nillnc l + n2fi2 ' W»«=- i + n 2 ft 2 '
,,.„., y6AZl>
where Inc, Qnc are the cosine and /„„, Qns the sine components of the current and the charge, n = 1, 2, 3 , . . . is the number of the harmonic. Equation (3.117) has been investigated via numerical methods and its error does not exceed 5%.
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
205
Fig. 3.37. Distribution of the non-basic carriers in the base of the diode at the moment of switching TT in the case of a stationary process, for frequencies: 1 - F = 0, 03; 2 - 0,1; 3 - 0,3; 4 - 0,7; 5 - 1; 6 - 3; 7 - 8 and 8 - 12 Fig.3.37 shows the distribution of the minority carriers at the diode base at the moment of switching TV for a stationary process and for different frequencies. The charge reaches its maximum at frequency F = 0,3 ( 0 = LOT ~ 2). At F = 0,7 ( 0 ~ 4) the maximum concentration of the minority carriers is higher but the charge is smaller than in the case of F = 0,3. When the frequency increases, the charge decreases, and the switching current remains virtually unchanged. The dotted lines in Fig.3.37 indicate the distribution of the minority carriers at frequency F = 3 and 8 at the moment of switching during the first period. Fig.3.38 shows the calculated reverse current of the diode in a stationary regime for different frequencies. There is a reverse current impulse even at F = 0,01 ( 0 ~ 0, 06) but, as the Figure reveals, the accumulation of additional charge from period to period begins only at frequency F = 0,45 (0 ~ 2, 7). The experimental study is fully in concord with these conclusions [239]. It is worth noting that the theoretical frequency characteristics of detection, obtained on the basis of a numerical solution of Eq.(3.117) and by using the analytical expressions (3.103), (3.108), (3.109), and (3.110) (Fig.3.36) coincide with at least 5% precision. 3.5.3. Diffusive impedance of the p — n junction at high signal amplitudes and higher frequencies In order to determine the diffusive components of the impedance of the p — n junction in the situation of accumulated quasi-stationary charge, we shall express the amplitude Uj of the alternating voltage at the p — n junction in the following
206
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 3.38. Reverse current of the diode in stationary mode; / without bias, / / - in t h e case of external forced bias pE = 0,75, for frequencies: 1 - F = 0,03 ( 0 sa 0,2); 2 - 0,3 (2); 3 - 3 (20); 4 - 8 (50) way [241]:
JJ. 3
hn
=
[ff ( e)£ + j.]AV5
~
^
AV5tf(e)(go+j.r)'
(3 122)
where A = — , K(Q) and Qo are the frequency characteristic of detection and the quasi-stationary charge for the different modes considered above, Is is the reverse conductance current of the diode. It can be seen from (3.122) that the charge at the base of diode Qo is related to the voltage at the p - n junction by a relationship different from that known in the classical diffusion theory [168]. The diffusive capacitance of the p — n junction is determined as
CfP-n = ^T = I.TAK(Q)VQ— dUi Given UjV&K(e)-
-r*.
,r[i-tf,Vetf(e)£]
(3.123)
< 1, i.e., when if < 1, where 7® = — , the diffusive
capacitance of the p - n junction is Cfp_n = I s Ar
\/Q and it does not depend
on the amplitude of the alternating voltage Uje (for example at 0 = 50, Is — 10~5 A and r = 10~5 s we determine Cfp_n ~ 280 pF).
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems When Im > L^QZ,
207
ie. / oe > / „
,-. = HrK^^l.
(3.124)
In this way, in the case of high signals, Cf n depends on Im as ~ J^, and it goes up quickly as the amplitude of the current increases. The frequency dependence of Cfp_n is not identical with the classical (Cd ~ -7=) and, as follows from (3.123) and (3.124), it is more complex in V0 character: in the case of small signals C® n ~ K(Q)y/Q = a&2 -\- 6 0 ~ I , and at higher signals Cfp_n ~ K3(e)Ve = (a0S + 60"f) . In an analogous way, the diffusive resistance of the p — n junction can be determined as R%-n = | ^ = 7
^ 2
•
(3-125)
If /m < t-KWyLe-tf « \then ^ - = ijjsObviously, at small signals, Rjp_n coincides exactly with the classical formula for differential resistance for an ideal p — n junction.
Given J m > ^ ^ y , ie- I® > L, R%-n = j 4 j 0 A / Q ' a n d t h e
f r e q. u e n c y
resistance of R®p_n is retained within the classical framework (Rj ~ -7=), while Ie the absolute value goes down —r- times, which is indicative of the existence of strong s modulation of the conductance at the expense of the accumulated charge. The dependencies obtained yield an expression for the diffusive time constant at high frequencies (Rdp-n^dp-n) =
r>
(3.126)
while the classical diffusion theory gives (RdCd) — —, which does not depend on r. When the p — n junction is used in an automatic bias mode as a capacitor in oscillating resonance systems, as the analysis shows, the diffusive capacitance Cf n largely determines the characteristic bifurcational peculiarities of the nonlinear resonance at high amplitudes and higher frequencies u ;§> —. T
Fig.3.39 shows the dependence of the effective capacitance of a semiconductor diode in an automatic bias mode (the experimental data are marked with different
208
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 3.39. Dependence of the effective capacitance of a semiconductor diode (D208) on the voltage amplitude at a high frequency (© = ur = 120) for the values of the resistance R of the iJC-filter automatic bias, as follows: 1 - 30 Mfi; 2 - 3 MQ; 3 - 0,33 Mfi dots). A comparison of the diagram in Fig.3.39 with the dependencies of Cef at low frequencies ( u < — I - for example Fig.3.6 - shows their qualitative similarity. V TJ
As shown in Chapter 1 and Chapter 2, when the purpose is to promote the effectiveness and expand the functional capacities, the parametric diodes operate in a partially forward-conducting regime with small direct currents. At first glance it
may seem that when the pumping frequency wp > —, the p—n junction cannot play the part of a complex parametric one-port, since the conductance (as well as the diffusive capacitance) fail to change in accordance with the pumping frequency. It is not difficult to show, however, that the modulation of the quasi-stationary charge with signal frequency (in the modulation-parametric systems the signal frequency is much smaller than the pumping frequency) provides a possibility for obtaining all functional regularities typical of the four-frequency parametric systems with inertia-free complex parametric elements (See Chapter 1 and Chapter 2). Thus, for example, the charge of the signal frequency can be defined as a variation of the constant component of the charge at the p-n junction. We have qi
= 6{QE + Qo) =
Wo
ft
+ —gff^
SUP,
(3.127)
where QE is the constant term in the Fourier expansion of the barrier capacitance charge, UQ is the constant voltage at the p — n junction, Um is the amplitude of the pumping voltage, 6UP is the variation of the pumping voltage, which is essentially the sum of the voltages of the combined frequencies.
Nonlinear resonance in radiophysical systems
209
The expression (3.127) can be rewritten as qi
= (CE + C°)U^ + (Ci + Cf)6Up,
(3.128)
where CE and C\ are the constant terms and the first coefficient in the Fourier expansion of the barrier capacitance, which is subjected to the action of the pumping voltage, C® = -T7— is an addition to the average capacitance conditioned by the Uo accumulated charge QQ, Cf=-jr—— is the diffusive capacitance of the semiconductor diode at high amplitudes of the pumping voltage and higher frequencies. In an analogous way, the diffusive current of the signal frequency can be presented through the variation of the constant components of the current
e
11 = 6I° =
dl*
MUl
dl?
+
duZ6Up'
or (3.129)
i = G°U1+G%6Up,
O dl® where G® = ——- is the average conductance of the p — n junction, G? = ° TUQ _ oUm is the diffusive conductance of the semiconductor diode at high amplitudes of the pumping voltage and at higher frequencies. Taking into account the active losses in the oscillating circuit of the pumping section expressed as series active resistance Rp, as well as the formula for the impedance module of the p — n junction \Zd\, the amplitude of the pumping voltage can be determined as
„
P., (£+'•)*>** + '
In the case of a high-frequency pumping corresponding to the condition wp > —, the conductance of the forward-biased p — n junction virtually fails to change with the pumping frequency and its harmonics, so the coefficients Gi and G2 in the matrix equation of the parametric modulator (1.26) can be regarded as equal to zero. Taking into account (3.127) and (3.129), the parametric modulator in this case can be described by the following matrix equation [231]:
j, 0 0
j/! =
i^+Ci -jw-Ci
Gf + jUl(d y+ -ju-C2
+ Cf) Gf + jWl(Ci + Cf) U, ju+C2 V-
U+ . U-
(3.130)
210
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
If we conduct a study of the input impedance of the parametric modulator in a way analogous to that developed in 2.1 — and if we use (3.130), we obtain for the conductance (G®) and susceptance (-B®) introduced in the input circuit:
,n2re , 4Q2(mx + m ^ 2 + Md[l + Q2(*' - 4£2)] Gg = -AQ G rmio [1 + Q2{H,_4e)]2 + i m y
re
R0
, ,(™i + md)[l + Q V - 4£2)] - AMd
,nzrenl
where md =^,Md
= | | , Coe = CE + Co - C2, G@ = Gf +
m _ (3-13D
(3.132)
G0-G2,
*' = 4(e02 + tom2). The effective (equivalent) negative capacitance introduced into the signal circuit, will obviously be written as C9 = -AQ m^C0
[1 + Q2{H,_Ae)]2+m)2
,
(3-133)
In the bandwidth (x' ~^> 4^ m , ^ m is the upper boundary spectral component of the signal) (3.134) C9 = - 4 g m^oCo
(1 + Q2X)2
•
(3.135)
The maximum value G® and Cf realize at detuning £o = j§:
,
| a
r
e
c *- max
_
nrn
r&
"
QmiC°
(3.I36)
=9^Mi,
max
1 + Qmi
\mi+md
2Md
1
[ T T o ^ " (i + Qm2y\'
(3-137)
hence, at m2 ^ ^o G®
(m)
= QG@miMd,
(3.138)
max (m)
Cf
= g^miCm! +md- 2Md).
(3.139)
max
Dependencies G® and C® from (3.131) and (3.133) repeat qualitatively the respective dependencies (2.6) and (2.10) - Fig.2.5. This result shows that owing to the effect of accumulation and establishment of a quasi-stationary charge at the base of the parametric diode it is possible to use a parametric one-port, which is of an inertia type as regards pumping but liable to modulation as regards the signal, for modulation-parametric amplification.
CHAPTER 4.
CHAOTIC OSCILLATIONS IN RADIOPHYSICAL SYSTEMS
4.1. Radiophysical systems with natural complex dynamics. Research methods 4-1.1. Major concepts: bifurcations, chaos, strange attractor, fractal dimension. Conditions for the manifestation of chaotic behaviour in radiophysical systems The introduction of the concept ,,chaos" and its discovery and investigation in a broad class of dynamic systems, including those in Mechanics, Radiophysics and Electronics, has been one of the major achievements of the physics of nonlinear oscillations in recent years [3-31]. A dynamic system usually implies a physical object, a mathematical model or a process, whose condition is determined by the totality of some quantities at the initial moment; furthermore, the state of the system at an arbitrary point of time, set in advance, can be established with the help of a given functional operator. The chaotization of oscillations can be defined as the occurrence of peculiar non-homogeneous (irregular) motions in absolutely determined oscillating systems. The describing equations have limited non-periodic solutions of a random nature even though there are no random parameters in these equations. Apart from the heuristic nature of the problems related to the investigation of chaotic oscillations, the latter is important for the engineering and research practice due to a number of other reasons as well. First, the chaos or noise in the radiophysical systems impedes the prediction of the length of their operation and their reliability, since the exact dependencies of the voltages and currents on time prove to be unknown. Second, realizing that the ,,ordinary" nonlinearities can lead to the development of chaotic modes, we are faced with issues related to the value and authenticity of the numerical modeling of nonlinear radiophysical systems in general. It is usually believed that the more powerful supercomputers are used, the more precisely the behaviour of the system can be predicted. In nonlinear problems involving chaotization, however, the behaviour of the system is highly sensitive to the initial conditions and the precise calculation of the future behaviour may prove impossible even in the case of periodic modes. Mechanics, Radiophysics and Electronics are those areas of human knowledge where the phenomena of complex dynamics are most widespread. At the same time, these scientific areas provide the best possibilities for complex analytical, numerical and experimental research. Besides their general scientific and world-outlook value, the investigations of the chaotic oscillations in the mechanical, radiophysical and electronic systems specifically are of great practical significance in the analysis 211
212
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
of regime stability and reliability in generators, amplifiers, SHF and Josephson systems, bistable dynamic systems, in the development of sources of stochastic and noise signals, etc. While the possibility for chaotic behaviour in the absence of external fluctuational (random) action is regarded as more or less obvious for the systems with a large number of degrees of freedom, in the case of systems with a small number of degrees of freedom (for example with 1.5 degrees of freedom) this possibility has proved to be unexpected for the researchers. Hence, the most extensively studied issue in recent years has been the chaotic behaviour of systems with an ultimately small dimension of the phase space TV = 3 (both autonomous systems described by differential equations of the third order and non-autonomous systems with one degree of freedom, subjected to external determined periodic action). Until recently, it was believed that the behaviour of the simple systems of the type of a radiophysical nonlinear oscillating system or a generator of radiophysical signals is completely predictable for a given arbitrary time interval by virtue of the determinateness of the equations that describe them. It turns out that chaotic oscillations may occur in such systems without external random action as a result of complex natural behaviour of the system brought about by the instability of the phase trajectories. The chaotic oscillations can be qualified as non-homogeneous motions characterized by irregularity, unpredictability and randomness. A well-known fact from the Theory of nonlinear oscillations [44-48] is that the dynamics of oscillating systems is reflected through the totality of phase trajectories in the phase space determining the phase portrait of the system. Each attracting or repelling set in the phase space is called an attractor. Such attractors can be the stable and unstable peculiar points, limit cycles, separatrices and other sets. In the case of chaotic oscillations, certain phase trajectories prove to be unrealizable as a consequence of a peculiar type of instability but the totality of phase trajectories as a whole is realized in a definite limited area of the phase space. Since it is not simple for one to imagine all this, the geometrical image, consisting of such a totality of phase trajectories, has been termed a ,,strange attractor" a strange attracting set. Phase trajectories are internally unstable, the proximity between them, typical of determined systems, is not retained, most frequently they ,,diverge" exponentially. Yet, for an arbitrarily long interval of time the totality of phase trajectories ,,shrinks" in the direction of the set that attracts it - the strange attractor. A strange attractor can be defined as a geometrical object in the phase space, where all phase trajectories of the system are tending to, and which, at the same time, repels them as a result of their instability in the area of this geometrical object. Obviously it is not possible to realize simultaneously exponential instability and ,,return" of the phase trajectories typical of chaotic oscillations, on the phase plane, since the phase trajectories do not cross each other on this plane. That is why the minimum dimension N of the phase space at which chaotic oscillations
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
213
can exist is N = 3, which corresponds to an oscillating system with 1.5 degrees of freedom. Chaotic oscillations can also be excited in an ordinary passive nonlinear oscillating circuit with 1.0 degree of freedom, when the circuit is subjected to the action of an external determined periodic signal. In this case it is also regarded that the system has three-dimensional phase space, with time playing the part of a third coordinate. The behaviour of the systems with chaotic dynamics is sensitive to the precision of setting the initial conditions and this is indeed one of the reasons for its unpredictability, i.e. regardless of the fact that the description of the system is fully determined, it is not possible to predict its evolution in time. It is necessary to develop a special statistic theory of the dynamic systems with a strange attractor. A typical concept of the Theory of nonlinear oscillations is bifurcation denned as a change (most often leap-like) in the equilibrium state and stability of the system, or a change in the number and stability of the solutions of the describing equation. Bifurcation is a typical nonlinear phenomenon. In the classical Theory of probability, the existence of randomness and respective probabilities is postulated and the issue of their origin is not raised. The canonized axiomatics of the classical Theory of probability operates with the concept of stochasticism and it is accepted that the latter is engendered in open dynamic systems in a fluctuating medium. Until recently it was accepted that all phenomena in our surrounding world were divided into determined and random ones. The former were studied by the Theory of differential equations, classical Electrodynamics, Mechanics and Mathematical Physics, while the latter were considered by the Theory of probability, the Theory of random processes, Statistical Physics and Quantum Mechanics. Such a strict division seemed indisputable and raised no doubts. At present, views are radically changing. Moreover, the development of the Theory of nonlinear oscillations and the Theory of dynamic systems naturally leads to the issue of the origin of randomness and the essence of probability, and to the design of respective new methods for resolving the emerging problems. At present, stochastics in continuous dynamic systems is mostly associated with the impossibility to achieve an exact repetition of the same initial conditions and the considerable influence that can be exerted even by the smallest perturbation. In this sense we can maintain that the stochastic and chaotic motions of determined dynamic systems are the ,,real" randomness in our surrounding world. These new ideas are taking shape only due to the discovered possibility for stochastization and chaotization of the motions in determined dynamic systems. Obviously, this is a colossal set of problems, whose elaboration has just been initiated. Every day, the modern scientific world is flooded by a huge amount of new facts and events in this area. The mechanisms of the occurrence of stochastic behaviour in the simplest determined dynamic systems are subjected to particularly precise and comprehensive consideration, and new initial paradigms affecting our deepest intuitive notions are worked out. The term ,,chaotic", as used in modern publications, applies to those motions in determined mechanical, physical and
214
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
mathematical systems, in which lack random or unpredictable forces or parameters, while at the same time their phase trajectories demonstrate great dependence on the initial conditions. In order to grasp more profoundly the meaning of the stochastic behaviour of oscillating systems, one should first answer the question in what way chaotic motion, i.e. a random process, may arise in systems without fluctuations and with a minimum number of freedom degrees, described by determined differential equations. It follows from the theorem of the existence and uniqueness of the solution, that in a set of strictly given initial conditions the differential equation has a definite determined solution. It is not possible to obtain random function after solving the equation. It turns out that the answer lies in the instability of all or almost all solutions. But even if all solutions of the equation are unstable, for each specific initial condition one invariably obtains a solution in the form of a determined function. Then how can the instability of the solutions cause stochasticism? The point is how one understands stochasticism. Currently the concept ,,determinism" is rationalized in the following aspect. It is believed that the state of the system cannot be specified with infinite accuracy, hence the initial conditions will contain certain indeterminacy e. It is clear that the solution of the differential equation will also contain indeterminacy (finite dispersion) depending on e and on the time t. If initially e is set as tending to zero and then the equation is solved, this will imply that it will be solved under initial conditions set rigorously, identified with infinite accuracy. In this case, the result is always utmost predictability. From all appearences, this track is not practicable and should be replaced with the following rule: first, given a set e, identify the behaviour of the trajectories and areas of finite dispersion for an arbitrary t, and then set e as tending to zero. In addition, the change in the final dispersion at t —* oo should be traced. If at e —• 0 the extreme dispersion tends to zero (and such will be the case whenever the solution is stable), the behaviour of the system will be determined. If, on the other hand, at e —> 0 the dispersion of the trajectories does not tend to zero for t —> 0 (and this is observed, if there are unstable solutions), the behaviour of the system will be ,,unpredictable" and it will be described by a random temporal function. This understanding of determinedness differs from the traditional one in that the order of the limit transitions e —> 0 and t —• 0 is changed. Since the evolution in chaotic systems is unpredictable, the question whether it is relevant even to talk about any dynamic structures stands out. The answer to the question on dissipative systems is affirmative: chaotic motions have a new geometric property called fractal structure. A definite internal order has been discovered in the chaotic dynamics. It conditions the possibility to predict, study, and, when necessary, suppress the chaotic noises in radiophysical and other systems. It is believed that just as dynamics, the new science of the 17th century, called to life differential calculus, nowadays nonlinear dynamics calls forth such new ideas from the areas of geometry and topology as fractals which should a 21th century
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
215
researcher fail to grasp them, he would remain unable to understand the subject of his own investigations comprehensively. Currently there are two most popular qualitative indicators of the existence of chaos: a positive exponential indicator of Lyapounov and a fractal structure of the orbit in the phase space. The peculiarities characteristic of the chaotic oscillations can be most readily observed by using the cross section of Poincare. It provides a picture of the cross section of the attractor in whose area the motion in the phase space is focused. When the motion is chaotic, a complex labyrinth-like multi-leaf structure occurs. The set of points delineating definite lines have a more subtle structure as well, which can be analyzed given a greater magnification of a certain local section. Such Poincare cross sections are said to have fractal structure. What is known as fractal dimension is used to characterize the strange attractors and measure the fractal boundaries in the areas of initial data and parameters. Currently, there are a number of fractal dimension definitions: capacitive (or geometric), mean score, correlational, informational, Lyapounov dimension. In all cases, the calculation of the fractal dimension is based on digitalization of the signals in equal time intervals. The fractal dimension is meaningful only with respect to dissipative systems. It is typical of them that orbits tend to fill only a part of the phase space. Fractal dimension is a measure of the extent to which, a certain space is filled by the orbit. In a more general perspective, the dimension determines the amount of information necessary for setting the coordinates of a point belonging to the attractor. In the case of classical (regular) attractors, the dimension is an integer: the dimension of a fixed point is zero, that of the limit cycle is unity, while that of the two-dimensional torus is two, etc. The existence of a fractional (non-integer) dimension is indicative of the presence of a strange attractor. The general cause for the occurrence of chaotic motion in dynamic systems is the loss of stability and the exponential ,,scattering" of the close phase trajectories combined with their general limitation and general shrinkage. The exponential increase in the deviation followed by shutting down can serve as the simplest model of instability coupled with general shrinkage. One can imagine that there is an area in the phase space G, where the phase trajectories diverge and as a result leave the area. When the phase trajectories leave the area G, the nature of the motion changes in such a way that the phase trajectories go back to the initial area G. This return to the area G is the very phase of ,,shutting down", when the deviations that have occurred are restored. This cycle is repeated many times. It is noteworthy that the controversy between these two tendencies - instability with a rapid process of increase in the oscillations and a limitation of that increase - is also typical of the strictly periodic oscillations (in resonance or generator systems). The causes for the instability and the increase in the oscillations may be the same in both cases of determined and chaotic oscillations as well. The difference lies in the nature of the limitation: in the first case, this is gradual slowing down and restriction of the oscillations, most frequently leading to the formation of a stable limit cycle in the phase space, while in the second case it is the ,,abrupt" shutting down.
216
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
4-1-2. Basic mechanisms of transition from determined to chaotic oscillations As far back as the end of the 19th century, the great French researcher A. Poincare suggested [91] that randomness (indeterminacy) may occur as a consequence of the instability of the very motion in the system. In such an unstable system, ,,an absolutely trifling cause, escaping our notice due to its insignificance, can bring about actions that we cannot predict in advance". Chaotic oscillations were first discovered in 1963 in the Lorentz system, already regarded as classical. The latter describes the thermal convection in a horizontal liquid layer heated from below. Lorentz's work, whose significance is generally acknowledged today, was hardly known for many years after its publication (till 1975). Today the system of equations examined by Lorentz is called ,,the Lorentz model". Nowadays it has been shown that the system of Lorentz equations describes a number of radiophysical generator and converting systems, where analogous phenomena occur. Chaotic behaviour of systems, described by means of a strange attractor, has been encountered in numerous radiophysical and electronic systems, as well as in mechanics and biology, in economy and in the organization of society, in ecology, hydrodynamics and many other areas of science and technology. Several models of bifurcations [17, 19] are known for their ability to cause, for example, the emergence of chaotic oscillations in a radiophysical nonlinear resonance system. The first mechanism has been proposed by Reuel and Takens and it consists in a three-dimensional dynamic system (described in a three-dimensional phase space) that passes from a state of stable equilibrium through three successive bifurcations: a limit cycle - a two-dimensional torus - a three-dimensional torus. There is a considerable probability that a strange attractor (chaos) will occur afterwards. The second mechanism has been developed by Feigenbaum. When a certain bifurcation parameter, K, is changed, the limit cycle becomes unstable. A new, two-revolution stable cycle appears. Given a further change in K, the following bifurcation occurs: the two-revolution limit cycle loses its stability and a new fourrevolution cycle comes about. If parameter K is changed further, such a critical value, K = Kcrj is reached, beyond which an infinite number of unstable cycles with different periods emerge in a limited area of the phase space. Besides, it has been established that in spite of the specific peculiarities of the system and, in many cases, despite the dimension of the phase space, the value of the bifurcation parameter is governed by the Feigenbaum relation l\n - l\n-\
o
where n is the number of the bifurcation. The third mechanism can be called an intermittency mechanism. The stability of the limit cycle is lost as a consequence of its merger with the unstable one.
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
217
Periodic oscillations gradually disappear as a result of their interception by chaotic ones. A lasting laminar process, alternating with chaotic oscillations, is observed under this mechanism. The fourth mechanism is associated with firm occurrence of chaos around a stable singular point. Such a bifurcation is termed ,,reverse Hopf bifurcation". Its essence consists in that the unstable limit cycles, which occur around the stable singular point, penetrate into these points during the next bifurcation. It is in such a way, for instance, that the chaotic oscillations emerge in the classical Lorentz system. We can also imagine that a complex, non-homogeneous motion, can be caused to happen by resonance overlapping. If an external force, p(t), with a period -tracts on a linear oscillating system, and if it is described by x+u>lx=p(t),
(4.1)
where UJQ is the natural resonance frequency, then, as it is well known, the solution of the homogeneous equation is x0 = A cos(o;oi) + B sin(o>0t).
(4-2)
If the external periodic force is presented in a Fourier series, oo
p(t) = — + Jjfan cos(nflt) + bn sin(nfit), then, as we carry out a harmonic expansion of the particular solution of the describing equation (4.1) as well, we obtain for the nth. term
n =
an cos(n£lt) + bn sin(refti) ^ - n2ft2 '
Given WQ ~ n2Q,2, there are resonances causing the increase in the amplitudes of the respective spectral components. If the oscillating system is nonlinear, all harmonics, multiple to the base frequency, WQ, will be present in the homogeneous solution (4.2). In this case resonance effects appear whenever the ratio — is a rational number, thus a dense system of resonances emerges. Since the natural frequency of the oscillations in nonlinear systems is a function of their amplitude, while the resonance phenomena change this amplitude and, therefore, the frequency of the spectral components, a peculiar counteracting process of violating the conditions of resonance manifestation occurs. This intricate interdependence obviously changes the nature of the phase trajectories and causes a complex nonhomogeneous (irregular) motion in the system.
218
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Jf.1.3. Methods and criteria for identifying chaotic oscillations A number of methods are used for investigating the nature of the motion in specific oscillation systems for the purpose of establishing the presence or absence of a strange attractor. 1. Numerical integration of the differential equation describing the system except for the transient process. The result is the picture of the time-dependent change of one or several variables - x(t), x(t), etc. 2. Investigation of the Fourier spectrum of the oscillations, most frequently by using a quick Fourier transformation. It is possible to trace, for example, the evolution of the oscillations in a radiophysical system from periodic to chaotic ones, when changing one or several controlling parameters, such as amplitude and frequency of the external action, coefficient of nonlinearity, damping decrement (increasing increment), etc. Initially an increase in the level of the harmonics is observed in the spectrum, then subharmonic components appear (bifurcation of the period of oscillations). A continuous spectrum takes shape in the chaos, and only several characteristic frequencies of the system can be discerned. 3. Investigation of the correlation functions of the chaotic oscillations. Given a continuous spectrum, the correlation function for an arbitrary phase variable Xi(t) is of a declining nature by virtue of the Wiener-Hinchin theorem. The correlation function can be calculated directly from the formula k(r) = < XiXi+r - m2 > , where m is the average of the variable Xj (rn = of;). 4. One of the criteria for the existence of chaos is the positive sign of the entropy K of the dynamic system, which is characterized by the average speed of divergence of the phase trajectories in the strange attractor, _, .. .. M(e,t) K = lim lim —-—- , £—•0 t—»OO
t
where e is the inaccuracy of the measurements, t is the time of observation, M(e, t) is the maximum number of trajectories the distance between which is larger than e. If the trajectories are stable according to Lyapounov's criteria, i.e. the close initial representing points do not diverge considerably, then K = 0. 5. Another widely applied criterion for the existence of a state of chaos is Lyapounov's characteristic index A, which also characterizes the average speed of exponential divergence of close trajectories: A = lim
-\n\x(t)\.
t—>oo t
The fact that the parameter A is positive implies that the phase trajectories are diverging, while the value A characterizes the chaos depth.
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
219
6. Determination of the dispersion D2 = (x — x)2 and plotting of histograms on the basis of process realization. As the strange attractor cuts across a plane known as Poincare plane, the dimension of the phase space can be reduced by unity and a picture of the evolution of the oscillations from periodic to chaotic when changing the controlling parameter (two-dimensional map of the shift) can be obtained on the plane. As an example, we shall present the evolution of the map of the Van-der-Paul equation with nonlinear reactance (also known as Van-der-Paul - Duffing equation): x - e(l - x2)x + x + -yx3 = /9cos(w1<).
Fig. 4.1. Two-dimensional Poincare map given an amplitude increase of an external harmonic signal acting upon a Van-der-Paul generator with nonlinear reactance (Van-der-Paul - Duffing equation)
(4.3)
220
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
In the case of small values of p (0 < p < 1, 7 at {e,7,u>} = {0.33; 0.7; 2.46}), equation (4.3) may have a periodic or quasi periodic solution. The periodic solution corresponds to a closed limit cycle at the phase plane (x, x). The Poincare section, represented by a stroboscopic sample x(tn) with an interval tn =
is represented
by a single point on the same plane. When there are substantial distinctions between the frequency of the external acting signal ui\ and the frequency of the natural oscillations in the system, wo; almost periodic oscillations are realized x =b\ cost^ii + 62 coso^t , where the frequency u>2 may differ from UJQ as a consequence of the non-isochronous nature of the oscillations. Respectively, the following can be written out for the stroboscopic sample xn = "i + o2 cos
2imu>2
,
. 2TTO
xn = — LO2O2 sin
.
Figure 4.1 shows the Poincare section (two-dimensional map) for the case of almost periodic oscillations and finite n. When n —* 00, the set of points {xn,xn} fill in the closed curve completely. As the amplitude p increases, there is a transition to a seven-stroke cycle (Fig.4.1 b, c), which is stable at 1,9 < p < 2,65. Given a further increase in p, the seven-stroke cycle is disrupted (Fig.4.1 d, e), and in the case of p > 2,75, chaotic oscillations occur. When p = 5, developed chaos can be observed in the system (Fig.4.1 f) 4-1.4- Experimental and numerical methods for investigating chaotic oscillations The experimental investigation of determined and stochastic oscillations in radiophysical systems can be conducted by using standard measuring equipment for analyzing time-dependent, spectral and statistical characteristics of signals [17]. The time-dependent characteristics include the very realization of the oscillation process, the phase portraits of the system obtained by feeding in signals from various points of the system under investigation - Xi, as well as their derivatives, at the inputs of an oscillograph. By choosing different variables {xi,xt} or {xi,ij} different projections of the phase portrait of the system can be obtained. Different orientation of the phase portraits is achieved by turning the respective axes, while adding phase shifts along the coordinates. Data storing oscillographs are particularly useful, when studying complex signals, including chaotic ones. The time-dependent realizations and particularly the phase portraits of the system recorded by means of them not only make it possible to establish the
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
221
existence of a non-periodic oscillation process, but also reflect the general structure of the attractors emerging in the phase space of the system (e.g. Fig.4.1). For the purpose of obtaining statistical information concerning the motion of a certain dynamic system, such as the distribution function, the correlation function, the power spectrum, etc. standard measures of correlation characteristics, spectrum analyzers, including panoramic spectrum analyzers and the like, can be used. One of the fundamental methods of studying chaotic oscillations in a system with a small number of degrees of freedom is to obtain the Poincare map. Experimentally this is achieved by raising the level of brightness and presenting, on the screen of the data storing oscillograph, only certain points of the phase trajectories {xi,Xj} at preset points of time (Fig.4.2). The brightness of the oscillograph beam is changed by communicating the respective strobing impulses to input z.
Fig. 4.2. Block diagram of set-ups for visualization of Poincare map: a. Map of a radio engineering system with iV-dimensional phase space; b. Map of a non-autonomous radio engineering system In the general case, when investigating a radiophysical system with phase space dimension N, a two-dimensional projection of the Poincare map is obtained as a two-dimensional section of the phase portrait with a hyperplane with dimension
222
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
N — 1, presented through a linear equation N 1=1
For the purpose of registering the Poincare map, the signals xi, with weight coefficients a; are conveyed to an adder (Fig.4.2a). The moment of the crosssection with the hyperplane is determined by the condition J2aixi = P- At that point of time, a certain voltage comes in from the generator of strobing impulses, which increases the brightness of the respective point of the phase trajectory. A secant hyperplane is selected by choosing the weight coefficients a{ and the level /? of operation of the discriminator. This methodology makes it possible to plot projections of maps corresponding to the maximum values of an arbitrary coordinate - x;. In this case, the discriminator determines the maximum value of the coordinate under the condition i ; = 0, while two other arbitrary coordinates of the process {xj,Xk} are brought up on the oscillograph screen. When studying non-autonomous radiophysical systems, it is convenient for the Poincare map to be presented by those points of the phase trajectory which are separated in time by the period T of the external action (Fig.4.2b). As in the previous case, the brightness of the oscillograph beam is modulated by the generator of a series of strobing impulses with period T. One of the major issues arising in the course of investigating the oscillation systems is connected with the nature of the evolution of the dynamic regimes, when a set (controlling) parameter is changed. Visualization of single-parametric bifurcational diagrams on an oscillograph screen can be achieved, for example, in the experimental set presented in Fig.4.3. When the evolution of the dynamic regime is examined in its dependence on the amplitude of the external harmonic signal, the following steps should be undertaken (Fig.4.3a). The signal X{ is fed at input OY of the oscillograph and saw-tooth voltage is supplied at input OX, which also helps modulate the amplitude of the external harmonic signal. The synchronization of the map on the screen is carried out with the assistance of the generator of strobing impulses in a way analogous to that in Fig.4.2b. Yet another type of bifurcation diagrams comes about, when investigating the frequency properties of the oscillating systems. When visualizing such a type of diagrams, one can use a standard device for analyzing amplitude-frequency characteristics (Fig.4.3b). The bifurcational diagram obtained in this way reflects the response of the system to an external action with a constant amplitude, depending on its frequency. The change in the amplitude of the output signal makes it possible to trace the dynamism in the development of the chaotic regimes. When analyzing the dynamics of nonlinear radiophysical systems, it is hard to give preference to either solely experimental or exclusively numerical methods of investigation. In the course of an experiment, it is simpler and faster to conduct
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
223
Fig. 4.3. Block diagram of set-ups for visualization of the evolution of dynamic systems (development of bifurcational diagrams): a. depending on the amplitude of the external harmonic signal, b. depending on the frequency of the external harmonic signal the analysis in the event of variance of the parameters of the system; there is a higher degree of visualization involved in experimental studies, and frequently they are less costly. Yet, when altering the parameters of the system, there is a risk of disrupting the adequacy between the natural and the mathematical model, hence, in all cases it is necessary to control the results numerically, at least with respect to certain typical modes. The latter is also linked with the important circumstance of the dependence, as a matter of principle, of the realizations on the initial conditions. During the experiment, it is by far harder to control the initial conditions of the process under investigation, when a realization may lose stability and be replaced by another one. The experimenter may fail to notice all this and it may lead to wrong conclusions. The numerical investigations of chaos require special algorithms and software, but as a rule they build upon well-known methods of numeric integration of systems of ordinary differential equations. The important aspect with the numeric investigations is the possibility to analyze regular unstable solutions that are not realized in the natural experiment, but whose evolution under changing parameters may result in the occurrence of structurally stable modes, which can be observed experimentally.
224
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Research practice has shown that the investigation of the dynamics of the radiophysical systems under laboratory conditions is normally conducted by applying the experimental and numeric approaches in parallel. Research software packages have been developed, mainly orientated towards personal computers, which make it possible to analyze the basic characteristics of the radiophysical oscillating systems in both stochastic and determined modes. There are algorithms for calculating the oscillation process, the phase portraits and their projections, the spectral power of the process, the spectrum of the Lyapounov characteristic exponents, the Lyapounov dimension of the attractors, the Poincare map, the singleparameter bifurcational diagrams. The realization of the oscillation process is the simplest, but sufficiently informative characteristic. The Rhunge-Kutta methods of numerical integration of the systems of ordinary differential equations are the most frequently used methods. The phase portraits and their projections provide a visual idea of the stream of trajectories of the system in the phase space and make it possible to identify such important phenomena as the emergence of the limit cycle, the doubling of the period of the limit cycle, the appearance and character of two-dimensional tori, etc. The spectrum of the process power is one of the basic and universal characteristics of the multi-frequency and stochastic oscillations in radiophysical systems. It determines the distribution of the dispersion (the value of the average variance) of the time-dependent realization by frequencies. A quick Fourier transformation followed by an averaging of the set of spectrograms is most frequently used. The spectrum of the Lyapounov characteristic indices and the Lyapounov dimension are among the most important characteristics of the attractor. The Lyapounov indices determine the average stability of the orbit of the attractor in quantitative terms. The concept of Lyapounov dimension is introduced in the following way. Let us arrange the Lyapounov indices as follows: Ai > A2 > ... > Xp. A typical feature of strange attractors is the divergence of the trajectories in accordance with an exponential law. Hence, at least one of the Lyapounov indices is positive. This introduces quantitative understanding in the concept sensitivity to the initial conditions, which exists in the different attempts to define the strange attractor. Currently a Lyapounov dimension is taken to mean a value defined as:
DL=j+\£r\tXi' where j is the maximum integer, for which A + ... + Ay > 0. The correlational dimension along with the Lyapounov dimension is an accessible characteristic from the viewpoint of the volume of computations required to estimate the fractal dimension of the attractor. The correlational dimension
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
225
is estimated on the basis of the correlations between the random points of the attractor. Consider the set of attractor points {x{}, i = 1 , . . . , n, obtained from the time series, i.e. Xi — x(t + ir), r is a constant time interval between the measurements. Due to the exponential divergence of the trajectories, most of the point couples (xi,Xj) at i ^= j will be dynamic uncorrelated couples of essentially random points. These points, however, lie on the attractor. Hence, they will be spatially correlated. This spatial correlation is measured with the help of the integral of the correlation C(l), defined as [17] „,.. _ .. 1 ( number of point couples {i,j} the distance between! n->oo n 2 \ which (\\xi — XJ\\) is less than / J' The link between the correlational integral C(l) and the correlational dimension Dv is subject to the relation C(l) ~ eP", which makes it possible to define Du on the basis of C(l). The Poincare map is a universal informative characteristics of the oscillations in the different dynamic systems, which is convenient thanks to its visual nature and the possibility to identify a broad range of dynamic processes. In order to obtain it, however, one needs a relatively large volume of computer time. The one-parameter bifurcational diagram yields the dependence of the extreme points in the oscillating process for one of the components in the case of an adiabatically slow change in a parameter. These dependencies create possibilities to identify oscillating modes with multiple periods, as well as quasi-periodic, synchronized and chaotic oscillations. A major advantage of this method of identifying oscillating modes is its efficiency from the viewpoint of the necessary computer resources. 4.2. Chaotic oscillations in non-autonomous radiophysical systems with nonlinear reactance and parametric systems A classical paradigm of the Theory of oscillations is the oscillating circuit (linear or nonlinear). The theory of nonlinear resonance (including that exposed in Chapter 3) is usually built on the assumption that a periodic action evokes a periodic response. The new theory of chaotic oscillations precludes this postulate. One of the principles of chaotic oscillations is connected with the appearance of a broad continuous frequency spectrum, when a harmonic signal is used to act on a system. An important class of systems, playing an essential role in radiophysics, is that of the systems of second order, and in particular the non-autonomous oscillating systems with nonlinear reactance. These are mostly amplifiers, converter and generator resonance systems, Josephson superconductive SHF systems and quantum interferometers, semiconductor and ferroelectric resonator systems, parametric resonance filters and the like.
226
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
A major problem when examining the stability of radiophysical systems with respect to the development of chaotic oscillations is the identification of the areas of their emergence in the parameter space of the system. Chaos occurs in nonautonomous radiophysical systems with nonlinear reactance given certain parameter combinations determining the type of the reactive nonlinearity and the nature of the external periodic signal. At this point, we shall focus on the non-autonomous systems most widely used in radiophysics and described by nonlinear differential equations of the second order. When investigating the nonlinear oscillating and generator systems in the previous chapters, we assumed that only strictly periodical oscillations existed in them. It stands to reason that since these systems are described by three independent variables (the third coordinate is time) and since as a rule these systems are nonlinear, chaotic oscillations can be expected to occur in them given certain correlations of the amplitude and frequency of the external force, the damping decrement (growth increment), the coefficient of nonlinearity, etc. Let us consider nonlinear radiophysical oscillating systems influenced by an external harmonic signal, whose motion is described by the following equations [51, 242]: x + 28x + x + x3 = p cos wt, (4.4) x + 26x + x - x3 + jx5 = p cos ut,
(4.5)
x + 26x - x + x3 = p cos ut.
(4.6)
Equations (4.4) - (4.6) represent a very broad class of radiophysical systems, as well as optical and mechanical systems, etc. Equations (4.4) - (4.5) are known in the literature as Duffing equations [51]. Equation (4.6) describes systems with ,,a deep potential well" that have a broad declining sector in the characteristic of the nonlinear reactive element corresponding, for example, to a system with a negative differential capacitance. Fig.4.4 shows characteristics of the nonlinear reactances in equations (4.4 - 4.6). A general picture of the areas of chaotic and periodic motions obtained through a numeric analysis of Eqs.(4.4) - (4.6) is shown in Fig.4.5, Fig.4.6 and Fig.4.7, at 26 = 0,1 and 7 = 0,1. The same figures also show the bifurcational areas characterized by multiplication of the period of oscillations. A complex picture of the location of the different areas can be seen. A more powerful magnification reveals the fine structure of the various areas presented in these figures. Both the chaotic and the periodic areas are sloping to the right, i.e. in the direction of the skeleton curve of the radiophysical system (See sections 3.1 and 3.2). The stationary mode of both periodic and chaotic oscillations is established within an interval in the order of 20 periods of the acting external signal (for Eq.(4.4)), and within approximately 400-600 periods for equations (4.5) and (4.6). The relative share of the plane of parameters {p,a>}, which corresponds to chaotic oscillations, is the smallest in the case of Eq.(4.4): 13%, and the largest in the situation described by Eq.(4.5): 49%. According to this indicator, Eq.(4.6) occupies an intermediate position: 28%.
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
Fig. 4.4. Plots of the nonlinear reactances in equations (4.4), (4.5), (4.6): 1- y = x + x 3 , 2 - y = x - x3 + 0, lx5, 3 - y = - x + x3
Fig. 4.5. A picture of the position of the areas of chaotic oscillations (double hatching), of periodic oscillations (blank areas), and of periodic oscillations with the respective bifurcation of period multiplication (2, 3, 4, 5 ....) in the plane of parameters {p,u>}. Equation (4.4).
227
228
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 4.6. A picture of the position of the areas of chaotic oscillations (double hatching), of periodic oscillations (blank areas), and of periodic oscillations with the respective bifurcation of period multiplication (2, 3,....) in the plane of parameters {P,LO}. Equation (4.5). By way of an example of a non-autonomous resonance system, we shall quote the data of an experimental study of a radiophysical oscillating circuit containing a varactor diode: Fig.4.8a. In line with the presentation in Chapter 3 the processes in the circuit are described by the following system of equations: L— = -Ri-U at
+ Uasinujt
±[C(U)U} = i C(U) = C0(l-aU)-1. After an experimental study of the behaviour of the system, the areas of subharmonic and chaotic response are identified on the plane of parameters { Uo, u>}: Fig.4.8b. The magnified section of the diagram discloses that islands of chaotic behaviour can exist in the plane of parameters {Uo, w}. We shall consider yet another example - a parametric amplifier with a Josephson junction described by the following equation:
(4.7)
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
229
Fig. 4.7. A picture of the position of the areas of chaotic oscillations (double hatching), of periodic oscillations (blank areas), and of periodic oscillations with the respective bifurcation of period multiplication (2, 3,....) in the plane of parameters {p,u>}. Equation (4.6). where tp is the Josephson phase difference, p and u> are the amplitude and frequency of the acting SHF signal, f3c is a parameter equal to the external frequency normalized with respect to the plasma frequency. The numeric analysis of equation (4.7) shows that chaos occurs and the amplification in the parametric amplifier with a Josephson contact is enhanced at an approximately equal correlation of the parameters. This prompts the conclusion that the growing noise observed in almost all experiments with Josephson parametric amplifiers with external pumping is due to the chaotic oscillations occurring in the system. Fig.4.9 reveals the spectrum evolution in the system at /3C = 25. It can be seen (curve 1) that in a mode of periodic oscillations the noise background is 15 orders lower than the desired signal. As the amplitude of external action increases (curve 2) the background noise grows inconsiderably. As chaotic oscillations occur, the background noise soars by some 14 orders (curve 3), so the desired signal exceeds this noise by only 1-2 orders. The areas of periodic and chaotic oscillations in the system depending on the parameters p and w are shown in Fig.4.10.
230
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 4.8. Oscillating circuit with a varactor diode (a) and a diagram of the subharmonic and chaotic oscillations in the plane of the parameters {f7o,^o} (b) It is noteworthy that the existence of reactive nonlinearity is a necessary condition for the development of chaotic oscillations in the parametrically excited oscillating systems as well. For example, developed chaos can be observed in the ,,ordinary" nonlinear parametric oscillating circuit described by the equation x + 2Sx + (1 + bcosilt)x + x3 = 0. It is amazing that this relatively simple radiophysical system displays regularities of transition to chaos that are absolutely identical to those in the
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
231
Fig. 4.9. Evolution of the spectrum in a parametric amplifier with a Josephson junction; 1,2- periodic oscillation mode, 3 - chaotic oscillation mode
Fig. 4.10. A picture of the position of the areas of chaotic oscillations (double hatching), of periodic oscillations (1), and of periodic oscillations with the respective bifurcation of period multiplication (2, 3,....) in the plane of parameters {p,w}- Equation (4.7). classical Lorentz system describing the processes occurring in a heated volume of liquid by means of equations in partial derivatives. This phenomenon is conditioned
232
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
by the fact that as the bifurcational point of transition to chaos is approached, the multidimensional (and even infinitely dimensional) dissipative system behaves as a small-sized one. This mechanism is another illustration of the unity of the dynamic laws in nature. 4.3. Chaotic oscillations in generator radiophysical systems and SHF short-range self-detecting Doppler radars (autodyne systems) for close radiolocation 4-3.1. Conditions for chaotization of the oscillations in generator systems From the perspective of the new ideas of chaos and stochastization of the oscillations, the following classification of the generator systems widely used in Radiophysics emerges: 1. Radiophysical systems, where oscillations are excited by compensating own losses with negative resistance, or through positive feedback. 2. Resonance radiophysical systems with forced excitation achieved through the action of an amplified signal that has passed through an inertia unit. 3. Resonance radiophysical systems where parametric excitation takes place at the expense of an inertia action of a signal from the resonance system upon elements of this resonance system. There are models of stochastic dynamics in each of the three subclasses. For example, the first subclass can be represented by a modified LC-generator with inertia type of nonlinearity described by the following equations: di L— + Ri + U - Ecosut, at l = z1+l2, ii = C ^ , ii = f(U), at where i, i\, 12 are currents, U is voltage, f(U) is a nonlinear function. The second subclass is represented by a model described by the equations x + 2/3x + x = rj, r) =
fll{x)
and the third one by a mathematical model in the following form: y + 2ey + y3 + zy = 0, z = -eaz + e/3y. The first dynamic system, where chaotic oscillations have been numerically established and investigated, is the following system of Lorentz equations: x = -a(x-y),
y = rx -y - xz, z = -bz + xy.
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
233
The Lorentz equations describe a system of the second subclass. The system of Lorentz equations can be presented in a form more relevant to radiophysics as follows: x + 26x + u\x = -ky + f(x, x, y), y + jy - ax + tp(x,x,y), where 6 is the friction coefficient, 7 is an inertia parameter, k and a are coefficients of the linear relation between the variables, / and tp are nonlinear functions containing no linear terms. In this case the variable y has been excluded from the system of Lorentz equations and the following substitutions have been made:
x = x- Vb(^T),
y = °\z-
~X2 - (r -1) (1 - ^ j ,
28 = a + 1, LO2 = b{r - 1), k = ^Jb{r - 1), 7 = 6, a = (2a-b)uj0,
f(x,y)
/3 = ~[-uox
\Z
x2 + — +
l
\ y\x,
J
e > 0,
(this equation was first used to describe the classical valve generator) owing to the lack of reactive nonlinearity. A series of studies demonstrates that the emergence of developed chaos is possible in a system with weak nonlinearity [243]. An interesting point that deserves to be mentioned is the fact that it is possible to suppress the chaotic behaviour of a radiophysical generator by means of external synchronizing action. In this case the strange attractor that describes it is converted to a limit cycle. Furthermore, as different from the phenomenon synchronization of determined generators, when there is no threshold value for its occurrence as regards the intensity of the synchronizing action, in the case of synchronization of chaotic oscillations, the amplitude of the external action should exceed a certain threshold value. In stochastic generator systems, the amplitude threshold of synchronization is directly related to the average positive Lyapounov index characterizing the speed of divergence of closely lying trajectories in the phase space of the system. By
234
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
virtue of this fact, the amplitude threshold of synchronization can serve as a quantitative measure of chaos in the stochastic generator system, which is of particular importance in the experimental investigation of such radiophysical systems. As two generators, respectively of periodic and chaotic oscillations, interact, the possible outcome is either periodization or chaotization of the oscillations. The different modes, all other conditions being equal, depend on the coefficient of the relation between the generators. An interesting point worth mentioning is that the oscillations in a Van-der-Paul generator, which are generally determined in an autonomous mode, can be rendered chaotic given a definite coefficient of a relation with a generator of chaotic oscillations. Interesting phenomena are also observed when two generators of chaotic oscillations interact. This is first and foremost the effect of stochastic synchronization. The latter consists in the following: when a dissipative coupling is established between stochastic generators demonstrating qualitatively different stochastic behaviour, the generators can be synchronized. Given a sufficiently powerful coupling, they start generating chaotic realizations that are identical in their average characteristics (entropy, dimension, spectrum). Moreover, it turns out that even the topology of the strange attractors in the respective partial phase spaces is the same. 4-3.2. Bifurcations and chaos in autonomous and non-autonomous generator systems So far bifurcational phenomena and the conditions for rendering oscillations chaotic have been studied in a large number of diverse radiophysical generator systems operating practically in all the frequency bands available. The main R&D thrust is made into generator systems with a feedback lag, models of a stochastic generator with a tunnel diode, an avelanch-drift diode, bipolar transistors etc., models of a generator with an inertia type of nonlinearity and circular structure, models of a generator with nonlinear resistance [17, 19, 25]. Some of the major methods of analysis were described in the foregoing sections. At this point, we shall use some more typical examples to demonstrate various research approaches. Let us consider the generator of chaotic oscillations shown in Fig.4.11 [20, 25, 67]. The generator is an LC oscillating circuit with a tunnel diode (TD) in a series connection and a negative conductance in a parallel connection, constituting the active element (for example an amplifying triode in the respective regime). The capacitance Ci, in a parallel connection with the TD, upgrades the freedom degree of the system up to 1.5. The oscillating process in the system is described by the following system of equations: x = y-Sz,
y = -x + 2^y + az + /?, pi - x - f(z),
(4.8)
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
235
Fig. 4.11. Basic diagram of a generator of chaotic oscillations
f{z) reflects the iV-shaped volt-ampere characteristic (VAC) of the TD in nondimensional parameters, Ug and IQ determine the coordinates of the central point in the falling section of VAC. At fi
Fig. 4.12. Phase space of a generator of chaotic oscillations described by equation (4.8)
236
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Due to the exponential instability of the system, the deviation of the initial conditions entails both a shift of the unstable foci and an indefinite phase of the transition from one plane to the other, hence, an indefinite number of the oscillations in the voltage trains generated by such a system. Indeed, two arbitrary close phase trajectories around the leap boundary may behave quite differently. The trajectories that remain within the area limited by the tangent to the straight line \x\ = ± 1 , remain in the slow motions plane to perform almost another entire loop unlike those that happen to be beyond that area and, therefore, move to the symmetrical unstable equilibrium of the other plane. It can be shown that the voltage values generated by the system at discrete points of time represent a series of independent random quantities. Since these oscillations occur under the action of non-random energy sources and, within certain finite ranges, are independent of the initial conditions, it is natural that they should be termed stochastic selfoscillations (on the analogy of the regular self-oscillations, whose map is the limit cycle). One of the typical configurations of stochastic generators with a delayed feedback can be presented as a closed circle consisting of a nonlinear element, a linear amplifier, a low-frequency iJC-filter, an ALC-filter. Various nonlinear elements with a falling VAC section are used in the different frequency ranges - SHF devices of the O-type, dinistors, thyristors, unijunction avalanche-and-injection transistors, tunnel diodes, avalanche thermo- and photo-transistors, etc. P—n—p—n structures are particularly promising with respect to the creation of circular generator systems with stochastic behaviour. Fig.4.13a shows the structure of two coplanar field-effect transistors, which, due to its VAC (Fig.4.13b), has been called a A-diode. A p - n - p - n structure (Fig.4.14), where one of the transistors is an MOS-transistor with an induced channel, is used to create a possibility for electronic control of the VAC parameters and for extending the range of the dynamic negative resistance. The structure is used in frequency ranges, where it is an inertiafree element. As the structure is formed in a common semiconductor crystal, it can be applied not only in the low-frequency and radio range, but in the SHF range as well.
Fig. 4.13. Basic diagram of a A-diode (a) and its typical Volt-Ampere characteristic (b) Given two varying parameters in the stochastic generator system with a delayed feedback (e.g. the time constant TRC of the low-frequency i?C-filter and
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
237
Fig. 4.14. Diagram of a nonlinear element (a) and its Volt-Ampere characteristic for different values of the gate voltage Ua: -15 V (1), -12 V (2) and -5 V (3) the constant voltage Ur, applied at the input of the nonlinear element - Fig.4.14a and determining the position of the operating point of the falling VAC section - Fig.4.14b) the result is a two-parameter diagram of the oscillating modes in the generator system - Fig.4.15. The diagram has been obtained by a top-down alteration of the parameter Ur for each fixed value of TRC- There are one-revolution limit cycles in area 1 of the diagram. As the boundary between areas 1 and 3 is transcended, the oscillations lose stability and a two-revolution limit cycle occurs. A transition to this oscillating mode can also be made via area 2, characterized by a definite blurring of the phase portrait of the output one-revolution limit cycle. This blurring is conditioned by the appearance of a very slow modulation of the limit cycle. A further development of the oscillation process in the system, provided that Ur goes down, is related to the loss of stability of the two-revolution limit cycle (passage across the boundary between areas 3 and 4 in the diagram). Area 5 corresponds to four-stroke cycles based on a two-revolution cycle. And finally, an oscillating mode with a strange attractor is realized in the area CA\. A transition from stochastic motion to a three-revolution stable limit cycle takes place at the boundary between areas CA\ and 6. The transition from the three-revolution cycle to chaos CA2, given a further decrease in the parameter Ur, also begins with bifurcation of doubling of the period (area 7). Area p is characterized by stable equilibrium positions. A number of radiophysical and electronic tasks entail the establishment of generator systems with an external harmonic signal acting on them. The nonautonomous generator system also serves as a simple model of generator interaction. This model is used as a basis to study the response, to an input signal, of amplifiers prone to self-oscillation, as well as the processes in superregenerative receiver systems. We have already discussed the classical model of a generator with external harmonic action (4.3) described by a Van-der-Paul's equation with nonlinear reactance. The interest in Van-der-Paul's non-autonomous equation as in a system possible with stochastic behaviour is due to several reasons. Firstly, this equation serves as a model for a large number of phenomena and processes occurring not only in radiophysical systems but in other areas of science and
238
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 4.15. Two-parameter diagram of the oscillating modes in a stochastic circular generator system technology as well. Secondly, this very equation has provided the foundation for the development and improvement of the major analytical methods of the Theory of nonlinear oscillations: the asymptotic methods, the small parameter methods, the perturbation methods, etc. However, chaotic oscillations require nonlinear reactance. Hence, the reactive term of the equation is modified to yield an equation of Van-der-Paul - Duffing (4.3). 4-3.3. Creating chaotic oscillations in generator systems with a delayed feedback In this section we shall discuss, from a phenomenological perspective, the creation of stochastic oscillations in a generator with an additional delayed feedback [244]. We shall analyze the mechanisms of chaos appearance both in the case of a constant delay and, in the typical autodyne mode of slow change, when a delay occurs in the additional feedback. The analysis will be conducted on the basis of the following differential equation describing the generator with a delayed feedback from a phenomenological perspective: x-a(lx2)i + Lo2Qx + f(x) = kx[t - r{t)}, (4.9) where f(x) is a nonlinear function, a > 0, k is a coefficient of the additional delayed feedback, r(t) is the delay in the feedback, which can also be time dependent, UJ0 is the ,,linear" part of the own frequency of the generator. Equation (4.9) may also describe a Doppler autodyne system, and in this case 97
2V
CL
CI
r = T0 + at, where r 0 = — , a = —-. Moreover, Eq.(4.9) may characterize one-
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
239
mode generation in a gas laser with an additional resonator, one of whose mirrors moves at a definite speed. Equation (4.9) is studied by means of numerical methods at f(x) = Gx3, UJO — 1 and a = 0,1 in two cases: r = To = const and r — To + at. The numerical experiment shows that Eq.(4.9) predetermines stochastic modes in a broad space area of parameters. In this case of stochastic oscillation investigation, the researcher's interest is aroused by the mechanism of chaos generation, given a change in the determining parameters of the system - the feedback coefficient, the nonlinearity coefficient, and the time of the delay. Let us consider the case of an invariable delay (a = 0), which corresponds to a stationary object in the autodyne model (Fig.2.25) and to a stationary mirror in the model of a laser with an additional resonator. We assume G — 0,1 and To = 30. At low feedback factors (0 < k < ko = 0,09) periodic oscillations are excited in the system (4.9). Their frequency / 0 is close to its natural frequency f0 — 0,17 = —. As the feedback factor goes up, the limit cycle of the phase plane, corresponding to the periodic oscillations, loses stability. A two-dimensional torus emerges in the phase space of the system. It is consistent with quasi-periodic oscillations with two basic frequencies: /o and /i = 0,029 ~ — (Fig.4.16a). This torus is stable for values of the feedback factors in the range ko < k < ki, ki = 0,42. As the feedback factor is increased further, two pronounced bifurcations of doubling of the torus quasi-period can be observed (Fig.4.16b): at k = k\ = 0,42 and k = ki = 1,2 respectively. At k = k$ = 1,3 a third, less pronounced bifurcation of doubling of the torus quasi-period can be observed, since the subharmonics are already comparable with the level of the background noise. As the factor k goes further up (k > k± = 1,7), the background noise augments and the individual spectral frequencies (/i, —, —, —,.••) become indiscernible (Fig.4.16c). This 2 4 8 moment can be regarded as the birth moment of chaos. It is worth noting that as the feedback factor k changes, the frequencies /o and /i experience inconsiderable alterations. The dependence of the frequency f\ on the time of the delay To, all other parameters being fixed, is shown in Fig.4.17. The specific values of the feedback factor at which bifurcations of torus birth and doubling of its period occur, depend largely on the value of the constant delay T0 and the nonlinearity G. As the time of the delay increases, the bifurcational values of the feedback delays decrease. Fig.4.18 shows the dependencies of the coefficients fco(l) and ki(2) corresponding to a torus birth and the first bifurcation of doubling on the time delay To (G = 0,1). As the nonlinearity increases, the bifurcational values of the feedback factor also decrease, i.e. chaos occurs at smaller quantities of k. For example, when To = 40, G = 0.1 the following bifurcational values are obtained: ko = 0.03, k\ = 0.3, and
240
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 4.16. Spectrum of the process x(t) described by the model equation of a generator with an additional delay feedback (4.9) at k: 0.4 (a), 0.75 (b) and 1.75 (c)
Fig. 4.17. Dependence of the bifurcational frequency on the time of the delay in a generator system with an additional delay feedback ata = 0,G = 0,fc = l when r0 = 40, G — 1, respectively k0 = 0.003, k\ = 0.025 and there is chaos at k > 0.09. The nature of the transition to chaos remains invariable, if the time delay To or the nonlinearity coefficient G is taken as a controlling parameter, rather than k. The difference consists in that fact that as T0 changes, the frequency f\ — — is modified substantially, while a change in G entails mainly an alteration of the frequency f0. For the purpose of establishing the influence of the speed on the reflecting object Eq.(4.9) is examined for a = 0.01. The rest of the parameters are fixed: G = 0.1 and TQ = 20. In this case the transition to chaos is quite different from that
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
241
Fig. 4.18. Dependence of the bifurcational values of the delay feedback coefficients k0 (1) and ki (2), corresponding to a torus birth and its first bifurcation of doubling, on the time of delay in the a = 0 mode. Even at infinitesimal values of k, quasi-periodic oscillations with two basic frequencies are generated in the system: /o =0.17 and fo = 0.002 ~ af0 (ID - Doppler frequency), i.e. there is a two-dimensional torus in the phase space. As k goes up (k > ki = 0.3), the two-dimensional torus loses stability and a three dimensional torus occurs, i.e. quasi-periodic oscillations with three basic frequencies: /o, fo, and / x = 0.05. The frequency f\ is close to the frequency /i in the case of a = 0. A further increase in the feedback factor boosts the background noise and the result is chaos in the system. The observed transitions to chaos can be characterized by means of the attractor dimension. Here, seeking to assess the dimension of the attractor, we use the correlational index u, which is calculated in the following way. The temporary realization of the process x{t) is used as a basis to establish a sample a;,- = x(t + iT), i = 0 , . . . , N and to build
M(e)
lnC7(£) , vd = rl i m —•
e^°
lne
where C(e) = lim ^ , M(e) is the number of the point pairs (Ci,Cj)> * ¥" j \ the distance between which is less than e. As d increases, initially v
242
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 4.19. Dependence of the dimension of the attractor on the additional feedback coefficient
4.3.4. Chaos in SHF short-range self-detecting Doppler radars Autodyne systems can be defined as a specific class of systems with a delayed self-action. Since, as a rule, these systems operate at short distance, given the different varying conditions in the range, the intensity of the reflected signal can change by several orders. The reflected signals obtained in practice are often very strong, their intensity being comparable to that of the emitted probing SHF electromagnetic oscillations. In this case, typical relaxation instabilities may emerge in the master oscillator of the autodyne system. Under certain conditions they convert it into chaos with a total loss of its informative qualities. At this point we shall investigate, from the perspective of the stochastic conversion of determined oscillations, the possibilities for the occurrence of instabilities of a fundamental nature that can be observed in modern SHF semiconductor autodyne systems with negative resistance [245-248]. The conditions for the emergence of chaos in autodyne systems described by a differential equation of the third order (2.100) are compared with such described by a differential equation of the second order (2.81). For the sake of convenience, we shall hereinafter call them Type I systems and Type II systems. The controlling parameter selected for the investigation is the coefficient of reflection of the signal by a moving object k. The closest reflection of the processes in the real autodyne systems is provided by the differential equations (2.100) and (2.81). To make the numerical analysis more convenient, we present equation (2.100) in the form of the following system of first-order equations:
(4.10)
where x = -^—, y =
'L
, z = ^f, F(i) = /(i)|-G, +G,f(x) + G,f2(x)},
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
243
xT = x(t - r), zT = z(t - r), f(x) = x(l - dx), (See Figs.2.33 and 2.3). As for the coefficients in system (4.10) and equation (2.81), we take typical values, characterizing respectively the SHF Gunn oscillators and the SHF avalanche-and-drift (IMPATT) oscillators. The time of the delay r is assumed to be r0 = 30. For the purpose of achieving more general analysis, values for k > 1 are also considered. The latter is also of practical significance, bearing in mind the potential of special applications to exert radio counteraction by receiving the probing signal of the autodyne system, amplifying it coherently and emitting it back to it for the purpose of disturbing its operation. The major numeric results are grouped in Table 4.1, which presents the obtained typical bifurcational values of the reflection factor k. Table 4.1 Bifurcational values of the coefficients of reflection from a moving object Koefficients fcj, i = 0,1,2, ...,4
&o
&i
&2
&3
&4
System I
0^07
0^19
0^43
0^47
0^53
System II
0^17
M3
0^97
1/11
M9
/o,/i
/o>/i
^
|- ^
Characteristic spectral
/„
/o,/i
CHAOS
frequencies In this case, the technique of chaos generation is absolutely analogous to that of a generator with an additional delayed feedback, considered above from a phenomenological point of view. Given a relatively small increase in the time of delay to the value To = 40 and all other conditions unchanged, the bifurcational values of the coefficient k change respectively to k£ = 0.015, k[ = 0.11 and k^1 = 0.025, k{T - 0.27. In the case of an increase in the nonlinearity of the function f(x) the bifurcational values of the reflection factor also go down, i.e. chaos occurs at lower values for k. For example, at T0 = 40 and one degree higher values of the coefficients C2 and L2 preceding the cubic term in f(x), the following are obtained: kg = 0.0015, k\ = 0.01 and kl1 = 0.0023, k[* = 0.025. The numeric investigation that has been conducted (Table 4.1) shows that the bifurcational values for k are by far lower for the system (4.10) than for the system (2.81). This is obviously due to the fact that the system (4.10) has an extra half a degree of freedom. From a physical point of view, this phenomenon can be explained by the regenerative action of the direct-current circuit RLC in the system shown in Fig.2.33 which leads to a potential relaxation (bifurcational) instability. For the sake of verifying this conclusion, the system in Fig.2.33 (the system of equations
244
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
(4.10)) was examined for the same values of the parameters but in the absence of the RiC circuit. In this case the system of equations assumes the form:
!~p-o[i-> + .-!H-& f-a-o/w
(4n)
The results of the numeric experiment indicate that the bifurcational values for k (ki, k2,k$) of the system (4.11) are close to those for a system of type II with no influence of the direct current circuit (k(T^k!,1 jk^1). This confirms the hypothesis of the regenerative influence of the RLC circuit in the system of Fig.2.33 leading to the establishment of more favourable conditions for the occurrence of chaos. The process of chaos occurrence and the gradual disappearance of the Doppler component LOQ from the spectrum of the autodyne system (loss of the informative qualities of the system) was studied through an experiment involving the set-up shown in Fig.4.20, where: AD - an autodyne, PM - a measure of power, RA - a SHF reflective generative amplifier, DL - delay line, DFI - a simulator of a Doppler frequency shift utilizing a mechanically rotating capacitive pin in a waveguide, 5^4 a spectrum analyzer. The time of signal delay is set either by using a high-frequency cable of the respective length or through a couple of receiving and emitting aerials positioned at a certain distance from each other. The damping is offset by the reflective regenerative amplifiers. The experiment with an autodyne system based on a SHF Gunn oscillator and a SHF avalanche-and-drift (IMPATT) oscillator shows that for parameter r = 20e = 10~6 the bifurcational values of the reflection factor at which developed chaos occurs and the Doppler frequency u>r> disappears from the spectrum, are respectively k{ = 0, 35 and k\T = 0,95.
Fig. 4.20. Diagram of an experimental set-up for investigating the chaotic behaviour of a SHF autodyne system The results that have been obtained are of heuristic significance for the more comprehensive characteristics of the behaviour of short-range self-detecting Doppler radars, which constitute a specific class of radio systems of self-action. Taking into account the peculiarities of the operation of these systems at close distances, it
Chaotic oscillations in radiophysical systems
245
follows from the analysis of the numerical experiment that certain conditions (signal delay plus relatively high values of the reflection factor) can be realized, that are sufficient for the occurrence of instabilities as a result of the oscillation chaotization. From the perspective of engineering practice, it should be borne in mind that these instabilities are of fundamental nature and that they are not the outcome of stray feedbacks, defects or other instabilities in the equipment. In certain cases the acquired stochastic behaviour of the oscillations may entail partial or total loss of the informative properties of the radio system.
CHAPTER 5.
ELEMENTS OF RADIOPHYSICAL SYSTEMS
5.1. Generalization of the method of complex amplitudes for linear oscillating systems with periodic parameters and nonlinear systems
A variant of the complex amplitudes method, specially adapted for analyzing linear periodic and nonlinear oscillating systems, is described below (See also 1.2 & 4.3 and [187, 188]). Let us set four different sine functions and construct their transforms in the complex plane through the following correspondence: en = Ai cos(wi* + vi) <- oi = AiejUlt
=
AiejVlejUlt,
a2 = A2 cos(w2t + <^2) ^ a2 = i 2 e ^ 2 ' =
A2ejV2ejU2t,
a3 = A3 cos(oj3t + ip3) <- a3 = A3ejU3t
=
A3e3V3ejoJ3t,
a 4 = Ai cos(w4t + (fii)*-a4=
=
A4e3V<e^*1.
The arrow, correspondence.
A4ejulit
(5.1)
pointing at the original above, stands for the relative
Several mathematical operations typical of the method will be presented. They need no comment: ai
+ 0,2 <— 0,1 + &2i kai <— khi,
dai dai . _ — < — = jwiai,
at
dt
k = const,
f f . hy / aid* *- / aidt = - — .
J
J
(5.2)
J^i
When the classical method of complex amplitudes is used, it is rare to come across products and quotients of harmonic functions, and, in such cases, they are specially regulated (for example, when computing instantaneous powers or modules of the Umov-Pointing vector). Products and quotients of harmonic functions are widely used when analyzing linear periodic and nonlinear systems. That is why their symbols have to be formalized. For this purpose we introduce mathematical operations suitable for such cases: symbolic multiplication "o" and symbolic division " |—", whose meaning 246
Elements of radiophysical systems
247
is revealed by the following examples: a!.a 2 <— ax o a 2 =
a\ + a\ „
a 2 or
hi + a2 „
d .a 2 .a 3 .a 4 <— ax o a 2 o a 3 o a 4 =
ai,
«i + ai a2 + a2 a3 + a3 „
z
z
z
a4
a4 + a4 ai + ai a2 + a2 _ or — ^ — a3) ai
ai
(5.3)
2
— «— [r^ = 7 —ai, a2 02 a 2 + 62
aia 2 a3a4
pi o a2 a 3 o a4
2 2 ai + h\ . a3 + a3 a 4 + a 4 2
Mutually conjugated functions are used here, such as h\ and a^, where aiAjc"'" 1 ' = aie- j ( w i < + ¥ ! l ), Ai = A j e " ^ 1 is a complex conjugate amplitude. It follows from (5.3) that several transforms correspond to the original of the product of harmonic time functions. These transforms differ from each other only with respect to their imaginary parts. It is typical of the symbolic method recounted here that the imaginary functions existing in the intermediate transformations can influence only the imaginary part of the finally achieved transform, which is rejected when the final solution of the problem is obtained. If the original is the sum of harmonic functions, symbolic multiplication and division follow the same rules. For example, if ai 2 = a,\ + a2 and a34 = a3 +
«12 + «i2 . ~ O34,
ai2
,ai2 <— fcr~ = "
2 T^
«12-
2 a34 a34 a34 + a34 The proposed variant of the complex amplitudes method is convenient for studying the processes in linear periodic systems and non-linear systems with polynomial nonlinearity. 5.2. Linear periodic and almost periodic elements of radiophysical systems 5.2.1.Periodic and almost periodic resistance and conductance The objects to be considered are linear temporally periodic and almost periodic resistances and conductance. Let us assume that there is resistance R = Ro[l + mRcos(Slt + tpR)],
(5.4)
248
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
linked up to an ideal source of harmonic voltage Ug = Ug cos(ujt + ip). When Ohm's law is applied, the following equation is obtained: -Ro[l + mR cos(fi< + tpR)]i = Ug cos(o;t +
(5.5)
In order to make use of the complex amplitudes method, we should set the type of the current as a function of time. It is not difficult to verify that Eq.(5.5) will be correct (with the required correspondence between the frequencies in the left-hand and right-hand parts of the equation) only when the current is set as an infinite series oo
oo
i = Y, !k cos[(w + kfyt + Vk] •- » = Y k~ — oo
h = he'*". (5.6)
ikejiui+kn)t,
k= — oo
By using (5.6) Eq.(5.5) can be ,,moved" in the complex plane following the method of complex amplitudes: oo
Ro^
oo
Y ike*u+lk+1W + Ro Y k= — oo
k= — cx> oo
*
+ i ? 0
he^+W
^
Y
(5.7)
he^+^-^^tl^.
The sign * is used here and further on to denote a complex-conjugate amplitude, for instance m. Any equation of the type of (5.7) is of great importance when analyzing radiophysical systems by applying the complex amplitudes method, so we shall term such equations determining equations. Determining Eq.(5.7) can be presented in the following extended matrix form:
i i 1 r2« [ I
\
I
2
rhR_
2
1
[
^
i i L2 I i i ; ; '
2
I !
'
/ x
; ; _
I I
'
'
;
'
'
(5.8)
!
| : j
™R I
2
\ m n 2
mR I | ^ I j
2 | ;
!
; I I
l
' : . i ; '
'
i
;
l
l
or in brief R I = U.
(5.9)
Elements of radiophysical systems
249
Matrix boxes with zero elements are left empty both here and further on in our presentation. Bold symbols will be used to denote matrixes or vectors, and the dot above will be a reminder that the respective matrix or vector contains complex elements. The matrix in Eq.(5.8) has only three non-zero diagonals, the elements of each of the diagonals are moreover identical. This allows obtaining a result of a unique nature - a precise solution of the infinite system (5.8). Indeed, let us present the system in the following way: 1-2 _ I-i
1
mR
ii -
rhR
h
2
rn-R 1-3
2
1 mR 1-2 '
i
Roio
u"
j_i
(5-10)
~1 + H±*.i=L + ™*k 2
™~R
j0
+
2 j0
ii -
i
^
rhR
1 :
l+!H^h. 2 jfi
mRI3 2 i2
Equations (5.10) yield the following dependence:
rhR L , 2
j
0
=
mR I,
=
mR -4-
2 Jo
(5.11)
m| '
The right-hand side of Eq.(5.11) has turned out to be an infinite continuous fraction with equal elements which is denoted as K. It is known that such a fraction m2 is convergent and has an estimate of |A'| < ——, where mR < 1. Observing that K = - — ~ , we can determine the values of the continuous fraction as: 1+A - 1 ± y/\ - mR '2 = 2 " Some physical considerations obviously require the satisfaction of the condition that given mR = 0, there should be K = 0, which allows of dropping the „-" sign in front of the radical and finally determining: K =
—
—.
250
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
This result allows obtaining the following expressions as regards the complex amplitudes of all spectral harmonics of the current. f
V*
1
(5.12)
/t=(-i)4-^(
^ . y , .=1,2,...,00.
The vector diagrams of the voltages and currents are plotted in Fig.5.1. The vector diagram in Fig.5.la is trivial for the case when R = const. Fig.5.1b and 5.1c correspond to expressions (5.12). Fig.5.1b shows vectors IQ; I\, I—\\ 1%, 1-2, etc. which turn, in the respective different directions, with frequency Q,. The symmetric character of the diagram in Fig.5.1b allows presenting it in a more compact form - Fig.5.1c - by using the complex function I(t) that changes in time in compliance with a complex periodic law with a period of 2ir/Q,.
Fig. 5.1. A vector diagram of the voltage and currentflowingthrough a resistance connected to a source of voltage: a) a case of constant resistance; b) and c) time-dependent periodic linear resistance with a harmonic variable part Given that the periodic resistance contains two harmonics R(t) = RQ[1 + mi cos(fit + ipi) + m2 cos(2fi< + y>2)],
(5.13)
a matrix equation of the following type can be obtained in an analogical manner
Elements of radiophysical systems
i
; i
m
i
™L
i
1
I ~r \ "hi
^ —
I
mj
!^l
i
m2
~ ™i
i
m
! 1
2 rh2
2 rhx
[ ~2 \
! i /_ ; ! ;
•
-
;
!
i
i f
i
i
i
'
I > -1 • i i % ;. I /0 1=1 ilg I (5-14) mi
—
2
\
[
2
T ~
! ; !
I ^_ 1
2
251
~Y [
i
! ;
'
•'
'
i
i
i
i
,
; \
; \
; • \ •2 i
| \
; \
\ :
ii
:
i
If the periodic resistance is expressed by k harmonics, then the respective matrix R will contain 2k+ 1 non-zero diagonals situated symmetrically with respect to the main diagonal. In the general case of a periodic function R(t), represented by an infinite harmonic series, matrix R will not contain zero elements. The matter is much more complex when the function is almost periodic. In this case instead of (5.14), the resulting systems are multidimensional and infinite, and they are not specifically studied by the Theory of oscillations. The multidimensional systems of algebraic equations below are used for classifying the respective radiophysical systems. Let us assume that resistance changes in time according to the law R(t) = RQ[1 + mi cos(fti< +
(5-15)
where fii and SI2 are incommensurable frequencies, i.e. R(t) is an almost periodic function, whose branching is equal to two (we introduce the concept of ,,branching", which is related to the number of incommensurable frequencies; obviously, a periodic function has a branching equal to one). The equation concerning the current flowing through the resistance, given an ideal source of voltage, can be written down in a form analogical to that of (5.5): Ro[l + mi(fl]t + ifi) +m,2 cos(fM + tP2)]i = Ug cosuit.
(5.16)
The analysis indicates that Eq.(5.16) will be correct only if the current is given in the form of a double sum i=
00
00
^2
^2
Ikicos[(u) + fcfii + l&2)t +
k=—00 / = —00 00
*-"i=
E
k=~OO
00
E
I *' c '' ( ' iH "* ni+ma) ''
I—— OO
ikl =
hie^'.
252
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications In this case the determining equation is obtained in the form oo
*o E
/ .
oo
.
*
*
\
E (^,«-i + ^ - i , . + i , i + ^ , . + ^ , i + i )
k= — oo(= — oo \
xej(w+kn1+in2)t
=
/
(5.17)
jjgeiut.
When the components of equal frequencies are selected, an infinite linear algebraic system of an extraordinary form is obtained. Since we are not in a position to write it out in full, we shall confine ourselves to the following short presentation: R..i = U.
(5.18)
The two horizontal dots in (5.18) denote a peculiar double-index multiplication of matrixes; I and U are infinite square matrixes with respective indices (k, 1) and (i,j) and with the following structures:
__1
1
1^-2,-2^-2,-1 1-2,0 1-2,1 I-2,2\ k
i-f-1,-2-^-1,-1 I—lfi
I = ; /o,-2 ^0,-1
^0,0
-f-1,1 -^-1,2;
j
j
j ,j
I
^0,1 h,2 | , U = |
Ug
| ,
I h,-2 h,-i h,o h,i
h,2 ;
I
I
j ^2,-2 h,-i
h,2 ;
I
;
h,o
h,\
H—{Ritj:k,i} is a four-dimensional infinite matrix, z, j ,fc,/= — o o , . . . , — 1 , 0 , 1 , . . . , oo. In the case under consideration, matrix R. has proved to be quite sparse, since its non-zero elements are only the following ones: Rk,l,k,l = Ro, Rk,i,k-i,i = ~miRo,
Rk,i,k,i-i = ^rh2Ro,
(5.19)
Rk,i,k+i,i = 2 m i-Ro, Rk,i,k,i+i = -m2RoLet us explain the product of matrixes Ft, I, U in (5.18) as compared to the ordinary product of matrixes. Let us assume that we have three ordinary (twodimensional) rectangular matrixes: A={oi,j}, B={6iit},
i = l,2,...,p k = l,2,...,r,
,
j = l,2,...,q, C = {<:,•,*}.
Elements of radiophysical systems
253
If these matrixes are related through the ordinary product A.B = C, this implies that cik = YJ)=I aijbjkThe ordinary product of matrices can be termed single-index product since it leads to a summing by a single index (in this case by j). Let us assume now that the first matrix is four-dimensional, i.e. A = {aStllilik} , e = l , 2 , . . . , s , /* = 1,2,... ,t, B = {&,-,*}, C = {<:«,„}. In this case the relation between the matrices is realized through a peculiar product A • »B = C, where p
i
«=i 7=1
Obviously this product differs from the ordinary one by the existence of a double sum. It is natural to qualify such multiplication as a two-index one. If another harmonic component with incommensurable frequency is added to (5.15), the equation complying to the generalized Ohm's law will acquire the following form R . . . I = U,
(5.20)
where three-index multiplication appears. Moreover, the matrix of the system is six-dimensional, while the other matrixes are three-dimensional. Following this logic, a whole family of multidimensional matrixes can be introduced: two-index, three-index, four-index ones, etc. They are all of practical importance. As a rule, the matrix of the system has an even number of dimensions, while the other matrixes have half the dimensions of the system one. Let us now consider the other typical problem - the variable resistance is attached to an ideal source of harmonic current ig = Ig cos(a;£ +
(5.21)
The same two cases tackled above will be considered here (See (5.13) and (5.15)): 1/ R = R0[l + m-i. cos(flt + ipi) + m2 cos(2fi< +
+ ip{) + m2 cos(9,2t + ^2)]-
In the first case the voltage symbol is obtained in the form of a finite sum U=
E
k=~2
t/*e^+ M )< ,
Ui = \rhxRoig 1
*
,
(5-22)
U2 = lrh2R0ig,
•
U-i = -miRoIg
U0=R0Ig,
•
,
U-2 =
1 *
•
-m2R0Ig.
254
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
This sum can be regarded as an almost periodic time function with a branching equal to one. In the second case we obtain:
U= E k--\
E Uk,eX"+ka*+m*
J=-l
Ui,o = -miRoig ^-1,0 = -^Rgig
,
, Uoo = R0Ig, Uo,i = -m2R0ig,
,
)7o,_i =
(5-23)
-rn,2R0ig.
The sum written down in (5.21) is an almost periodic function with a branching equal to two. Obviously the considered problem with supply from a source of current is incomparably simpler than that with supply from a source of voltage. It is not difficult to be convinced that the problems related to the investigation of the properties of periodic or almost periodic conductance are analogical to the problems related to periodic and almost periodic resistance considered above. Indeed, if a linear periodic conductance, presented as G = Go[l + mGcos(£lt + ipG)],
(5.24)
is linked up to an ideal voltage source Ug cos(cot + tp), then the determining equation will be i = G 0 [l + mG cos(fii +
(5.26)
Comparing (5.25) and (5.26) with (5.21) and (5.5), we become convinced that these equations are equivalent to an approximation of the denotations. In practice it may be relevant to make use of the choice of a source (current or voltage) and of the value (resistance or conductance) for simplifying the analysis. 5.2.2. Periodic inductance and magnetic susceptibility When a periodic inductance of the type L = Lo[l + mLcos(Q,t +
(5.27)
is attached to an ideal source of harmonic voltage Ug, the following determining equation is obtained oo k= — oo
oo k= — oo
Elements of radiophysical systems *
oo
+ju>L0?± T 1
255
h+^+k^
(5.28)
= Uge^.
k=-oo
This equation is analogous to Eq.(5.7) - the difference is that here multiplier .Ro is replaced with JUILQ. Hence, all conclusions concerning (5.8) will be applicable here as well. In this case, the vector diagram differs from that in Fig.5.1 only in that vectors IQ and Ug are moved apart from each other at an angle of —. When the periodic inductance is connected to an ideal source of harmonic current ig = Ig cos(art +
, Uo = juLoIg, (5.29)
U! = j(u + fl)£o^/9 , ZJ
U-i = j(w -
n)L0^ig. A,
This case is analogous to the one considered above, where a periodic resistance is connected to a source of current, with the important difference that here U-i ^ U\. This difference can be visualized in the vector diagram - Fig.5.2, plotted in correspondence with (5.29). It is obvious that the instantaneous complex voltage amplitude U(t) leads the complex current amplitude with an angle, which is periodically either larger or smaller than 90°, but its average is equal to 90°. If vector Ig is regarded as motionless, then vector U(t) will periodically change its module and direction with angular frequency ft, constantly remaining in a definite sector wide la (See Fig.5.2b). By way of visualization, one can imagine that U{t) is a harmonic oscillation modulated both by amplitude and by phase with a modulation frequency ft. As a rule, the ,,modulation frequency" ft in modulationparametric systems is much higher than the ,,carrier" frequency w, i.e. ft ^> u>.
Fig. 5.2. A vector diagram of the voltage of a linear periodic inductance with a harmonic variable part connected to a source of harmonic current: a) in full form, b) in compact form The considered case of connection of periodic inductance to a source of current is characterized by this specific peculiarity - the appearance of phase modulation. Such phase modulation fails to appear when a periodic inductance is connected to a source of ideally harmonic voltage.
256
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
If the inductance changes in time in accordance with an almost periodic law, then the modulation that comes about is characterized by an almost periodic law and a multidimensional quality emerges. Then sector 2a is defined in multidimensional space. Consider a periodic magnetic susceptibility (a value opposite to inductance) F — Fo[l + mrcos(nt + ipr)]- In the case of a connection to an ideal source of harmonic voltage Ug, the following complex form of an expression is obtained for the flowing current
i = L^-v* T _ roUg This case difference that When the current ig, the
_T
+ ioe^ + iie^+v\ f _ rhr V0Ut
•
_ mr T0Ug
(5.30)
is close to the one considered above (See (5.29)), with the onlyno phase modulation emerges here. magnetic susceptibility is linked up to an ideal source of harmonic following determining equation is obtained
V" [
Uk
xej(u+kn)t^
I ^r
^k~l
™T ^k+1 1
jgeiut^
( 5 3 1 )
which describes an infinite system of the type
: i I
i iw-n ;;
™L
2
-JTO i ^ i ik 11 '
m r
~2~
i I
I
I
x
'
'
I
I
ii
a,
iil,i i i ; j •' j
i M=nn. i
i
1
L
_
i
i
i
J
L
J
Lo + n\ ; Ui. I i
(5-32)
I
or in brief: f (jw)" 1 !! = I, where u — diag(..., w — kil,... ,w - fi, w, w + Q,..., u + kQ,,...) is an infinite diagonal matrix of frequencies. The emergence of a matrix of frequencies is indicative of the existence of phase modulation. Phase modulation appears when the inductance or magnetic susceptibility are tied to a source of harmonic current and fails to appear when they are connected to a source of harmonic voltage. This is obvious, since in the first case an infinite sum of voltage harmonics appears and each term is divided into its frequency with the respective phase shift. As a result, a matrix frequency multiplier appears which conditions an angular modulation.
Elements of radiophysical systems
257
5.2.3. Periodic capacitance and electric elastance When a variable capacitance C(t) = CQ[1 + me cos(fi£ +
i = i-ns*"-0*
+ ioejult + iie^+V\
Io = JLOCOU,,,
U = j(w - n ) c o ^ u g .
h = j{w + n)co^u9,
(5 ' 33)
The vector diagram for this case is presented in Fig.5.3. This case is dual to the case of inductance with a source of current (Fig.5.2).
Fig. 5.3. A vector diagram of the voltage and currents flowing through periodic capacitance with a harmonic variable part connected to a source of harmonic voltage: a) in full form, b) in compact form When the capacitance is connected to an ideal source of harmonic current, the following determining equation is obtained oo
/ .
;<"Co E
*
y t , + ^ + ylJW
k= — oo \
\
e* +ffi "=V'-
(5.34)
/
which structurally coincides with (5.7), given the substitution jwCo-^>R,'mc-*mRWhen a periodic electric elastance S(t) = SQ[1 -f ms cos(Q,t -f- Vs)] ( a quantity opposite to capacitance) is connected up to an ideal source of harmonic voltage, the result is a determining equation oo
_ •s 3
°u
f
S^ \
f
\oJ + kn+
. ms
j
2 uj + (k-l)Q+
* m s
"|
f +1
2 uj + (k + l)Q\
x c ^ + * " ) * = U-,e^ t , (5.35) which differs from (5.31) only by the denotations. The respective infinite system is of the type
258
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
r
1
: I j
!Zli _2
I
-js0 i ^ : 2 I i
1
i!
*
i
1
I
I
i
r
' I
: './_!'' : \j • '<
* _ _
I
r
I !
: iw-ft | ; _ _
!^ ! I 2 :': rhs j| ~9~ ii
I
"i
!
i
' ;
!
\ io = u, ;j | | j ' ii• i ! i w + ^ i i -fI i ; i I
L
J
L
^ 5 - 36 )
J
or in brief: S^'w)" 1 ! = U. Given a linkage of the electric elastance to an ideal source of harmonic current, the result is
U = E Uke*»+k0» , Uo = ^ , (5-37) jT
rhs So •
•
_msSOf
The general conclusion is that the capacitance and the electric elastance linked up to an ideal source of harmonic voltage yield a current modulated by amplitude and phase, while their connection to an ideal source of harmonic current results only in amplitude modulated voltage. 5.2-4- Power consumed by periodic elements of the radio circuits An instantaneous power consumed by a periodic resistance connected to an ideal source of harmonic voltage is represented as 7T
p=Ugl^P=El±Ei.l
I 7T
1
=
°°
L £
k= — oo
1
°°
uaJtCi(2uH-*n)* + 1 £
u,ike*a*. (5.38)
k= — oo
In the special case when one can find such k = ka < 0, where the equation 2w + kail = 0 would be fair, the average power is equal to
Pav = Re (^
+^
j = \u9h + \uglka cos(^ +
(5.39)
Fig.5.4 shows a typical vector diagram of the symbol of instantaneous power p plotted on the basis of expression (5.38), as well as the qualitative time dependence of the instantaneous power p(t) consumed by a periodic resistance.
Elements of radiophysical systems
259
Fig. 5.4. Illustration of the instantaneous power consumed by periodic resistance connected to an ideal source of harmonic voltage: a) A typical vector diagram of the symbol of the instantaneous power; b) Quality dependence on the time of the instantaneous power The vector diagram of the symbol of instantaneous power in dynamics (Fig.5.4a) can be explained by using the vector diagram in Fig.5.1c. It follows from (5.38) that the ,,lying" vector
1
*=-oo
is always situated in the direction of the real axis and that it undergoes modular changes with frequency Q, according to a periodic law, and its value cannot be negative. The ,,rotating" vector
Pr = 1 J2
U9he^+k^
Jb=-oo
turns regularly, with an angular speed 2a;, round the end of vector P; undergoing modular changes analogous to vector P/. Fig.5.4b is a consequence of Fig.5.4a. The almost periodic function p(t) is built on the basis of two frequencies: frequency Q,, at which modules Pi and Pr change in synchronism, and frequency u>, when vector Pr turns round the end of vector Pi with angular speed 2a;. Given fixed frequencies u> and il, the form of function P(£) may be changed in a wide range by changing the initial phases
p = il+ku = \ j ^ i.VuJ<**m* + \ J2 I,Uke>™. *=-i
it=-i
(5.40)
260
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
All qualitative peculiarities of the previous case are preserved (Fig.5.4). The matter with the two regimes of linkage to periodic conductance stands analogically by virtue of the obvious duality of the systems. From a formal point of view, the expression of the instantaneous power consumed by a periodic inductance connected to an ideal source of harmonic voltage does not differ from that of a periodic resistance (5.38). But as the phase relations between voltage and current are taken into account, the result is a vector diagram of the power symbol and a graph of the instantaneous power as a function of time, as shown in Fig.5.5. In this case the ,,standing" power vector is
Ps = \ £ U9he^\ k= — oa
while the ,,rotating" power vector is
k= — oo
The instantaneous power, as in the previous case, is a periodic function of the time with fixed interval between the zeroes. Yet, unlike the previous case, this function has a zero average value only for a large time interval. An exception from the general rule is the case when the condition that 2OJ + kSl = 0 is met. Then the average power consumed by the periodic inductance depends on the sign of cos((/>+ ?&) and can be both positive and negative. From a physical point of view, this fact is easy to explain, bearing in mind the generalization of the Manley-Row energy relations (See section 1.2) for the case of linear periodic reactance, as well as the effect of the single-frequency non-degenerate parametric regeneration considered in section 2.1 from the position of the four-frequency modulation-parametric systems.
Fig. 5.5. Illustration of the instantaneous power consumed by periodic inductance connected to an ideal source of harmonic voltage: a) A typical vector diagram of the symbol of the instantaneous power; b) Quality dependence on the time of the instantaneous power
Elements of radiophysical systems
261
In the case of a periodic inductance linked up to an ideal source of harmonic current, the instantaneous consumed power is expressed by an equation analogous to (5.35). Then the first term yields no constant component, while the second one can yield such a component provided that 2oj + kD, = 0 and Pav = -UgIk cos(ip+tpk)Obviously, the constant component can be both larger than zero and smaller than zero. Fig.5.6 displays a vector diagram of the power symbol and the qualitative dependence of instantaneous power on time in such a case. The difference from Fig.5.5a consists in that instead of the ,,standing" vector Ps we have an oscillating ,,suspended" vector - P^, that changes its direction but remains, in the average, turned opposite to the direction of the imaginary axis. As a consequence of the modulation of components U\ and U-\ not only by amplitude but by phase as well, as a rule, the interval between the zeros in the diagram shown in Fig.5.6b differs from — , but its average over a long time interval is equal to that quantity.
Fig. 5.6. Illustration of the instantaneous power consumed by periodic inductance connected to an ideal source of harmonic current: a) A typical vector diagram of the symbol of the instantaneous power; b) Quality dependence on the time of the instantaneous power The cases of the two possible linkages of periodic magnetic susceptibility are dual to the periodic inductance cases considered above. Essentially new versions fail to appear when a periodic capacitance and periodic elastance are connected to ideal sources of harmonic voltage and currency, too. Periodic reactance, unlike constant reactance, extends the signal spectrum to infinity, thus imparting a completely definite structure to it - furthermore, at some spectral components the active power can be absorbed, analogically to the case of positive resistances, while at other spectral components this power can be generated and transmitted to the circuit, as is the case with negative resistances. The consumption and generation of active power is a peculiarity of the periodic reactances.
262
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
By way of comparison, we shall consider the power consumed by a constant capacitance C. The instantaneous power and its transform are presented as
P = iU= ^CU> sin(2^ + 2*.) - P = ^ z
= j^U*
+ j^tfV™.
The original P is an oscillating power changing in time according to a harmonic law with double frequency. The transform P is presented by the sum of a constant component and a complex-valued periodic time function. The constant component Po = j-r~U2 is conditioned by the complex amplitudes method and it is a convenient object of study. It is an analogue of the average power absorbed by an active resistance. From the perspective of the complex amplitudes method, a capacitor, like an active resistance, ,,absorbs" power, but this ,,absorbed" power is imaginary, reactive. The ,,absorbed" power Po provides important information on the oscillating power since its module is equal to the latter. In the case of periodic capacitance, the constant ,,absorbed" power is expressed through the following infinite matrix
Po = 2UJWCU = j p t , } ,
(5.41)
where C is an infinite square three-diagonal matrix of the type of matrix R in (5.8), given the following substitutions: mR —y me, w — diag(... ,LJ — kQ.,... ,ui — Q,,to, u + a,...,u + ka,...),V = dia&(...,U-k,...,U-1,U0,Ui,...,Uk,---), Pk,k = \j(u + kn)C0U2k, P M _ ! = j(u + kSl)^-C0UkUk-i, Pk,k+i = i(w + kn)^-c0UkUk+iIt is convenient to present Exp.(5.36) in the form Po = wK,
(5.42)
where K = {kpq} is a complex energetic coefficient of the capacitance represented by an infinite slanting Hermitian matrix, which, in the case under consideration, consists, similarly to C, of three diagonals K,p = J2C°UP> kp,p+i =
kP,p-i
=
J-^-CoUpUp-i,
j-£-CoUPUp+1.
Unlike Po, matrix Po is not an imaginary one and consists of complex elements. This implies that, as it changes in time, the capacitance absorbs a certain part of
Elements of radiophysical systems
263
the source energy. In the case under consideration, the exchange of energy is by far more complicated and involves three objects: the signal source, the source of capacitance change in time, and the capacitance. If a definite harmonic component is considered, it may happen that the power is absorbed at this component and a part of the absorbed power is transformed into generated power at other harmonics, while another part is directed into the source of capacitance change. The opposite transformation may also take place, i.e. power is generated at a certain harmonic component due to the fact that a part of this power is obtained from other harmonics, while another part has come from the source of capacitance change. These two opposite tendencies are combined in a complex way and in a stationary state the energy of the two sources is balanced against the infinite set of spectral components of the capacitance current and voltage. In all cases, the linear periodic capacitance consumes active power which is lacking in the constant capacitance. Thus matrix Po is a characteristic of the complex power of the capacitor with periodically changing capacitance. The real part of this matrix - P ^ = i?ePo can be defined as a characteristic of the active power consumed or transmitted by all harmonic components of the capacitance. Obviously, it is correct to write Pyl = wKj}, where HJJ — i?eK is the real energetic coefficient of the power. This is an infinite real slanting symmetric matrix. In the case under consideration, it has the following structure !
fc-2,-1
!
;-fc_ 2 ,-i
&_i |0
!
KD = - C o ! Zi
-fc-1,0
'
fco.i
!
I
—&o,i
^1,2 !
i 1
i>
^^^^^^^^™
i
~kl'2 *
*
•
•
1
*
where kPtP+1 = -CaRe(jmcUPUp+1), &p,p-i = -C0Re(jmcUPUp-\). The real energy coefficient KJJ allows creating a clear mental picture of the exchange of energy between the individual harmonics, the signal source and the source of capacitance change. Indeed, it is correct to write the following expressions for matrix PA = | p ; , m } : P M _ ! = (w + /ft)£,,,-i, P,-hi = [w + (/ - l)ft]fc,_ v = -[w + (/-l)fi]Jb M _ 1 . Let us assume that &/,/_! > 0, I > 1. Then P/,;_i > 0, Pi-i:i < 0. The power PJ ( J_I is directed from the signal source to the capacitance by the harmonic component with frequency (UJ + IQ,); the capacitance, on its part, transmits power Pj_i,i to the harmonic component with frequency [w + (I — 1)0], which
264
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
brings this power back to the signal source. The algebraic sum of these powers P;,;_i + P;_i,z = £}£(,/_! is absorbed by the capacitance, i.e. it is transmitted to the source of capacitance change. In the more general case of periodic linear capacitance (or nonlinear capacitance with harmonically varying argument), its parameter is presented by an infinite Fourier series: C(t) = Co [1 + YlT=i m * cos(k£lt + <£>*)]. In this case matrix C is completely full, and its major diagonal consists of unities, while all other diagonals parallel to the major one are made up of identical elements. The diagonals above the * * * major one consist, respectively, of the elements , -—,... , , . . . , while those mi rh2 rhk , ., under it encompass , ,..., ,.... Zi
Zi
Zi
The theory recounted here is generalized for any linear reactive circuits whose elements change periodically in time with equal periods. In all cases the infinite complex matrix Po and the complex matrix energy coefficient K are characteristics of the complex powers of the reactances with periodically changing parameters and they determine the energy balance. The real matrix energy coefficient Kjp reveals the mechanism of converting active power through periodic reactance. The results give an idea of the transformation dynamism of the active power by periodic reactance and provide an algorithm for calculating the average absorbed or generated power of the individual harmonics. 5.3. Nonlinear elements of radiophysical systems The nonlinear elements of radiophysical systems are usually given in the following forms: R(U) and R(i), C(U) and C(q), L(i) and L($). In most of the practical cases, the radiophysical systems with nonlinear elements can be considered as systems with periodic time parameters, since voltage U, current i, charge q and magnetic flow $ are periodic time functions. When analyzed, nonlinear characteristics are most often presented in a Taylor's series, such as for example oo
R=Y,RkUk
(5.43)
while in the process of problem solving they appear in a Fourier series, for example oo
R = Ro + 2 ] T Rn cos(nLot + tpn).
(5.44)
n=l
Let us consider a resistance with the following dependence on voltage R = R0 + R1U,
(5.45)
Elements of radiophysical systems
265
linked up to an ideal source of harmonic voltage Ug = UQ + U\ cos(W + ip). The determining equation of the system is written in the form R°
2^
\ l + Tr)Ik
+
9TrIk-1
+
oTrIk+1
= uo + Uiej ,
e
where Uoo = TT" an< i corresponds to the following infinite system of algebraic Hi equations i i i
1 7 7
; i , iii. : Uo° i
1
1
i Ui 2c/oo
2 Uoo
uoo
i
lUi
i
2t^
:
I
2 J7Oo
r
1
i i
r
i
i i
i i
' \ i : :
\ 'n ; ;
\ ;
'
II
I
i i
*
i i
(5.46)
I^o i i • i i r> i
1 +
t^
; ; 1
h
L
\ \Ui • j
L
j
or R(U).I = U. It is obvious that the infinite system (5.46) has much in common with the infinite system (5.8) in the case of a periodic resistance. Here the infinite matrix R is obtained on the basis of the functional dependence Ug(t) which is typical for nonlinear systems. The infinite system (5.46) is solved with the help of the infinite chain fraction K, which, in this case, yields a precise solution:
The solution of system (5.46) is presented in the form (5.47)
i(t) = Io + h + i2 + • • • + ik + • • •, where ij = Re (Jiejult
+ i - i e ^ " " ) = Re(h + l _ i ) e J W * =
i2 = Rel2ei2"\ 7i=ii+i-i,i2
...,»*= = i2 + i-2,.-.,ik
Re7ejut,
Re7ke>kut,..., = ik + i-k,
•••,
266
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
fe /
J-1 =
62 \
b*2
7 *y
' a = jRo l 1 + ^ J ' 6 = T c ^ -
( a -^J -b2
The rest of the complex amplitudes are calculated by applying the following recurrent ratios: Z*±I_ .
h
— —
h_
,
k-1
23
oo
K — ± , Z , 6, . . . , OO,
aK
*
J-(*+i) — _ J —, _ ftt _ —j _ nu, 1i , z2, o3 , . . . , (so oo.
If instead of (5.45) the square term of Taylor's series is taken into account, matrix R will contain not three but five non-zero diagonals. In the general case, if the non-linear resistance (5.43) contains k terms from Taylor's series, the matrix of the system will contain 2k + 1 non-zero diagonals. An analogical result is obtained if we use resistance of the type of (5.45) but the input voltage U is a periodic function represented by a Fourier series. If we use the first k harmonics of the harmonic expansion of U, then the system matrix R will contain 2k + 1 non-zero diagonals. In the most general case, when the nonlinear resistance (5.43) contains k terms of Taylor's series and the forcing voltage has n harmonic terms with commensurable frequencies, the system matrix R will have 2(k + n) + l non-zero diagonals and the vector column will have respectively n + 1 non-zero elements. If the forcing voltage is an almost periodic time function, the resultant system (5.46) will be multi-dimensional. If the almost periodic function has branching k, the current and voltage matrixes in (5.46) will be A:-dimensional and the resistance matrix will be 2«-dimensional; the multiplication of the resistance matrix and current matrix will be fc-index. Let us consider yet another generalization for the case when the nonlinear resistance explicitly depends on time according to the law R = Ro + i?i U + R(1) cos(nt + *!)
(5.48)
and is connected up to an ideal source of harmonic voltage with frequency w.
Elements of radiophysical systems
The current symbol is presented in the form i =
oo
^
267 oo
J2 Ifc;e J ^ w+;n '*, while
k=~oo / = —oo
a system of the type of (5.46) is written in the following succinct way: R(U) . «i = U, where R-(U) is a four-dimensional matrix, I and U are two-dimensional matrixes, while the two horizontally located dots denote double-index multiplication. If the explicit dependence on time is almost periodical with a ^-branched almost periodic function, the current and voltage matrices will be k -f 1-dimensional, while the resistance matrix will be 2(k + l)-dimensional. There is a more general case when nonlinear resistance with almost periodic and explicit dependence on time, containing m basic (incommensurable) frequencies is connected to a source of almost periodic voltage characterized by n basic frequencies. Out of the m + n set of frequencies, p basic frequencies are identified so that max(m, n) < p < m + n. Here the current and voltage matrices are (p + 1)dimensional, while the resistance matrix is, respectively, 2(p + l)-dimensional. It is worth noting that analyses such as that presented above are also typical of the cases when C(U) and L(
J i 4 £>-•-<+^--4 ! > - • +
V 77
= h + \hJut
W I
k+
9772" 2^ Uk+i+iU-i + ^fj-Uk+i e?
+ \li
(5.49)
268
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications p
p
where Un = — , ?702 = -=— Equation (5.49) determines an infinite system of ito -fio nonlinear algebraic equations which can be written in the following concise vector form
G(t,C0.U = i,
(5.50)
where U = colon(..., U_k,..., U-i, Uo, f / i , . . . ,
Uk,...),
i = colon(...,0,...,0, -7i,/o,-7i,O,...,O,...). Matrix G(i, U) = {gi,j} ,i,j = — 0 0 , . . . , —1, 0 , 1 , . . . , 00 contains no non-zero elements, all of its elements depend on the complex amplitudes of both current and voltage:
1 Ho
h fOi h
1 / Ufa y
, 1 (TT-T
hu-i + iiuA 2 J ,hV-2+hVa\
gk,k+i = -^fj- + jfr J o t 7 -i + 0 > J 2Uoi U02 \ h , 1 / . . - . , iiU-2 + iiUo\ , 9k,k-i = TTT- + Ypr I0U1 H 2Uoi U02 y 2 J
1 (TTT L/02
9k'k~l =
, J 1 t7- ; - 1 +l 1 t/_, + 1 > \
\
Vh {°Ul
/
+
2
J'
The specificities and exacerbated analytical difficulties that go with the second type of problems are evident. 5.4. The law of energy conservation in oscillating systems The general law of energy conservation was first used by Manley and Row, in their classical articles [172, 173], for analyzing radiophysical systems while accounting for their specificity. In section 1.2 Manley-Row's classical energy relations were developed and generalized for an infinite number of forcing generators in the case of linear periodic reactance or nonlinear reactance with explicit dependence on time. The resultant relations are used for investigating parametric systems with several pumping generators. In systems of this type it is possible to suppress the detrimental influence of the second harmonic from the spectrum of the parametric element
Elements of radiophysical systems
269
(See section 2.3), to achieve a high degree of unidirectional (not reciprocal) signal transfer, to promote reliability by transmitting one and the same message via different frequency channels with following transformation into one and the same intermediate frequency at the receptor point, to increase the signal/noise ratio of radiophysical receiving systems, etc. The Manley-Row relations can be viewed as one of the bridges thrown between the radiophysical macroscopic and quantum systems [78, 249]. For example, if all terms in Manley-Row's relations are divided by Planck's constant ft, then the expression in the denominator of each term of the sum will be the energy of the oscillations quantum with the respective frequency. In this case, the first ManleyRow relation assumes the following form:
V
V
%f mW-
m=l n=—oo
^ = 0.
(5.51)
'
v
The quantity — obviously determines the number of the quanta with ftw0 pumping frequency UJQ sent by the pumping generator to the nonlinear capacitance per unit of time. mW Let us consider one of the terms of the sum (5.51), for example: ——: — . h(\n\wi—mu>o)
It is evident that n quanta with frequency Ui are required for producing one quantum of combined frequency (|ra|u>i — muo). Besides, this process yields m quanta with frequency u>o. It is obvious that relation (5.51) can be interpreted as a law of conservation of the number of quanta with pumping frequency. Similarly, the second of ManleyRow's relations, oo
TT7 -
oo
2-"ft(mw0+nux)~
m——oo n = l
x
'
'
can be viewed as a law of conservation of the number of quanta with the frequency of the signal. It is worth noting that Manley-Row's general energy relations can be applied in an infinite number of ways and this will bring about changes in the relative weight of the different harmonic components in the respective sums. The distribution of power by combined frequencies is determined by the magnitude and sign of the combined frequencies, as well as by the nonlinearity of the reactance and the type of the energy consumer. W If we introduce the denotation Nmn = — — where Nmn is the h(mujo + nu>i)
number of the power quanta absorbed by the reactance at frequency mto0 + nu>1, then Manley-Row's relations can be written as follows: oo
oo
^2 ]C mNmn = 0,
m = 0 n = —oo
270
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications oo
oo
m = — oo n = 0
Using these relations for describing the energy transformation in a quantummechanical system with four working levels, we obtain N13 + N2i + Nu +N23 = 0
.
N12 + N34 + iV14 - iV23 = 0.
^
Z )
If we take into account that WOi = (iV13 + N2i)huQ, W10 = (iV12 + ^ 3 4 ) ^ 1 , W\\ = N\\htx)+, W-\\ = NIZTIOJ-, we can use (5.52) to derive Wio
h
Wu
h
W-n
_
f- ~
Win ^ Wu ^ W_n _
n
The resultant system presents Manley-Row's energy relations for the fourfrequency parametric system considered in section 1.3. Therefore, from an energy point of view, the quantum mechanical system with four working levels is equivalent to a four-frequency parametric modulator. The classical and quantum-mechanical presentation of Manley-Row's energy relations have proved to be equivalent. Viewed as a consequence of the general law of energy conservation, ManleyRow's energy relations have clear physical meaning. Yet, they treat the transformations of energy by an ideal nonlinear or parametric reactive element. An interesting point worth mentioning is that the issue of the conversion of active power in the parametric reactances is analogical to that of the transformation of reactive power in the parametric active elements. If complex power is set as S = W + jX, the active power flow W will obviously be directed to the points where it will be converted into other types of energy, while the reactive power flow X will either be channelled towards elements accumulating reactive energy or derive from such elements. On the whole, a just condition for the active element in stationary mode is W T^ 0, X — 0, while for the reactances it is vice versa: W = 0, X ^ 0. These conditions are indeed just as a whole, and they may not be satisfied for certain separate combined frequencies. In the case of nonlinear reactance, the active power at certain combined frequencies mu>0 + nuii may be absorbed, i.e. Wmn > 0, while that at others may be transferred to the circuit, i.e. Wmn < 0. Yet, as a whole, the average active power of all combined frequencies is zero. It can be shown that the situation with the energy aspect of the parametric active element is the same - at some combined frequencies the average reactive power is directed towards the active element, i.e. Xmn > 0, while at others it is driven off it, i.e. Xmn < 0. One could say that the parametric active element stores electric energy at certain frequencies, but only instantaneously, and then transfers it to the circuit at other frequencies. This perspective can be employed when explaining specific
Elements of radiophysical systems
271
phenomena. For example, let us assume that a nonlinear active element is linked up to a source of harmonic voltage. There will be currents and voltages of the upper harmonics in the circuit. From the viewpoint of the stored energy, their appearance may be explained in the following way: the nonlinear active element ,,stores" electric power with basic frequency, which is immediately transferred to the circuit at the frequencies of the upper harmonics. It is evident that while there is definite awareness of the distinctions between the constant (linear) active and reactive elements, the boundary between the active and reactive parametric (or nonlinear) elements is quite blurred. Manley-Row's relations for the case of a nonlinear resistor can be written in the form: oo
oo
Y, Y,
m=cT="r
mXm,n=0
Y ^2 nX™," = ° >
(5.53)
m= — oo n = 0
where Xmn is the reactive power consumed by the nonlinear resistor at frequency mo»o + nu>\. The nonlinear resistor absorbs energy continuously, while at the same time a part of the energy of the main harmonic is transformed into upper harmonics and vice versa. While active power is the amount of energy absorbed per unit of time, reactive power characterizes the amount of energy involved in these transformations per unit of time. It is obvious that in the stationary regime the reactive power is stored in the resistor, since in this regime the relative weight of the basic and upper harmonics remains unchanged. This condition is met only when the power of the basic harmonic, which is converted into upper harmonics, is equal to the power of the upper harmonics, which is converted into the basic frequency component, i.e. the total reactive power of the resistor is equal to zero. Hence, there is an evident analogy between the reactive power of the parametric (nonlinear) resistor and the active power of the parametric (nonlinear) reactance. The energy relations for a nonlinear resistor (5.53) can be generalized in an analogical way, similar to that used in section 1.2 for nonlinear reactance, for the case of explicit dependence on time under the action of an arbitrary number of generators.
CHAPTER 6.
OSCILLATING CIRCUIT WITH CONSTANT PARAMETERS Before analyzing the properties of resonant systems with periodic parameters, it would be logical from a methodological point of view to consider the processes occurring in an oscillating circuit with constant parameters [78, 250]. Despite the widely popular view that oscillating circuits with constant parameters have been studied in detail, our analysis has shown that a number of their properties have escaped the notice of researchers. This chapter presents a theory of a generalized oscillating circuit with constant parameters. The relevant equations are derived, the phenomenon resonance is considered elaborately, the energy balance in a resonant circuit is investigated, a number of tuning characteristics are presented. 6.1. Free and forced oscillations in a generalized oscillating circuit The oscillating circuit shown in Fig.6.1. will be termed a generalized oscillating circuit. Given ig = 0, this is a generalized series circuit, while in the case of ig = 0 and G = 0 it is an ordinary series circuit. Analogously, when Ug = 0, the outcome is a parallel oscillating circuit, and when Ug = 0 and R = 0 it is an ordinary parallel circuit.
Fig. 6.1. Equivalent circuit of a generalized oscillating circuit The processes taking place in the generalized oscillating circuit (Fig.6.1) are described by the following basic system of differential equations: G
dq dt d
C
1, L
. (6.1)
RA^TT
l
where ig and Ug are current and voltage sources, q stands for charge and cj> for magnetic flow. The unknown quantity in system (6.1) is the two-dimensional vector-function colon[g(i),^)]. 272
Oscillating circuit with constant parameters
273
System (6.1) can be transformed into two independent differential equations of second order: d\
(R
G\dg
l + RG
U9
Rig
dig
(6.2)
(6.3) It is evident t h a t t h e left-hand parts of equations (6.2) a n d (6.3) are identical, while t h e right-hand ones are dually symmetrical with a n accuracy u p t o t h e signs. As we pass on t o non-dimensional parameters x\ =
, z 2 = -7—, r = —, 9oo 0oo to where 900,
£ Xi
-to°c
dr
ho 9oo , "77" "POO ^
I
X2
1
~ ^ o " ^ X± , ^ _ R —tOQ-f L
'
X2
'
*oo TJ 1 U9 tpoo
((.,,
'
[°^>
or written in a succinct vector form — x = Ax + f(r).
(6.5)
For the purpose of analyzing free processes we shall make use of the scalar Eq.(6.2) in the case of ig = 0 and Ug = 0: (6.6) 1 (R
G\
1 + RG
Under initial conditions t — 0, q — q0 and — = io the free process is described by the expression q = e~atqmcos(uft
- if0),
(6.7)
where qm = Jql + ~^{i0 + aq0)2, tgi^o = — ( — + a ), w/ = Ju% - f32, V wj OJf \qo ) V \
R
\ R
G
The expressions given above highlight a very typical property of the generalized oscillating circuit: given arbitrary losses in the circuit, the resonance frequency of
274
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Fig. 6.2. Generalized tuning characteristic of an oscillating circuit the free oscillations will be exactly equal to the natural resonance frequency of the circuit, provided that the following condition is met:
!=§•
^
The established property can be successfully used in measuring practices for instance, when measuring the natural frequency of an oscillating circuit with a relatively low quality factor by applying the kick-excitation method. Let us consider the forced oscillations in the generalized resonance circuit. We ,,shift" Eq.(6.2) to the complex plane and, taking into account the denotations introduced above, in the case of Ug = U cos(u>t + x) and ig = 0 we obtain
s M + °"«-!*•*"•
We substitute q = qm^ut amplitude and phase:
< 69 >
in (6.9) to obtain expressions for the charge
qm = jW2o-u2)2+4aW}-12,
^
= H
-
a x c t e
-^-..
(6.10)
Discussions usually focus on a ,,resonance adjusted oscillating circuit". Strictly speaking this is quite inaccurate. The resonance concept does not refer to the circuit but instead to the physical quantity determining the process in the oscillating circuit. One could talk about resonance of a capacitor charge, or of the magnetic flux permeating the coil, about resonance of the voltage at a certain resistance, etc. Hence, each generalized oscillating circuit has a definite family of tuning characteristics which can be divided into four groups: a) resonance characteristics determined by the frequency of the excitation source; b) capacitance tuning characteristics; c) inductance tuning characteristics; d) active tuning characteristics. Fig.6.2 provides a generalized tuning characteristic and its typical parameters. Variable x can be the frequency of the external source, capacitance, inductance or active resistance, while function y can be the physical quantity determining the process in the circuit.
Oscillating circuit with constant parameters
275
As regards the charge of the generalized series oscillating circuit, we have the following (we use (6.10)): x = to, y = qm, y0 = 9m(0) = ^rjy, j/oo = 9m(oo) = 0, I 1 (R2 ij, = u r = o ; o W i - - [ y yx=qmr =
2 +
p
2\
) '
p =
,
[L y c '
, a;i i2 =wi i2 = y fto ~
2a
( Q ± V ^ 2 - a 2 )-
u,0(R+P^G)Jl-~ (j-pG) The frequency bandwidth of the oscillating circuit is 2Au = ui2 — wi. The resonance characteristic of the generalized series oscillating circuit is asymmetrical, i.e. u>2 — u>r ^ LOr — ujy. The typical parameters of the capacitance tuning characteristic of the charge are as follows: x = c, y = qm, y0 = qm(0) - 0, U
= —,„_ , 9r9, io\/R2 +U>2L2
yoo = qm{°°)
2/l
_J7_r "9mr"W2L[
G f f l 4- EG)^
xy = CT = — U L
1
- — - ! - + UJLG] , WLG J
1 R2 1~* (1 + i?G)2 + W2L2G2 + w 2jr 2 J '
i = ^ - ( T T ^ ^ I ^ I1 ± \/G W ) [(i+^)2+.2L2G2]-i}. The width of the tuning curve is: 2AC = C2 — C\. The inductive tuning characteristic of the charge is characterized by the following parameters: x = L, y = qm, 2/o = qm(0) = CU[(l + RG)2+Lo2L2R2r?,
xt = Lr = C(GP+u,*C*)-\ y^^^CU^l Xl-2
= Ll'2
=
G2 + ^ 2 C 2
Voo
= qm(oo) = 0,
+^ ^ l
+ RG +
! T y ^ j ( 1 + -RG)2 + 2RG{1 + /?G) + ^C2R?
^ ^ y ,
2 A i = L2 — L\ is the width of the tuning curve. The active tuning characteristic of the charge is characterized by the following parameters: x = R, y = qm, yx = gm(oo) = 0,
1
,
276
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications _ Vx - qmr -
U_ ,
^
G
Xli2
- Rli2 - ~G2+oj2C2
,
c
(
C
\
T w [G2+ij2c2
- LJ •
The expression for xy shows that in the case of the active tuning characteristic, the charge amplitude reaches its maximum when the active resistance and the conductance have different signs. This gives rise to a problem related to the stability of the oscillating circuit in the respective frequency bandwidth 2Ax = R2 — R\. The following differential equations for the free oscillations in the generalized oscillating circuit are obtained for the three typical points xy: x\ and x2 respectively: G (C 1 C\LG2+co2C2
d2q dt2 d2q
(G
1
\(C
\ dg u2C2 1 ) dt + G2 + LO2C2 LCq \dq
\1 1
\iirifioC^fG
The upper sign in the second equation refers to xi, while the lower one refers to x2.
Provided that G < 0, the sufficient conditions for asymptotic stability of the oscillating circuit can be derived from the differential equations referred to in the following form: |G| >LOC !r2,,2r2,L
"C
2
2
2
L
u£
(6.11)
The active tuning characteristic of the charge can also be determined by the conductance. Then: x = G, y = qm, t/oo = 9m(°°) = 0, yo
=qm(0) = CU{{\ - u2LCf
yx
= qmr = cU^l
x^
+ ^-2[l
+ UJ2C2R2]~K - j(R2
xy = Gr =
-R(R2+u2L2)-\
+ a, 2 ! 2 )]" 1 ,
= G^ = - W ^ T U { w T ^ - c ) t 2 ^
= X2~Xl-
Provided that we opt in this case for R < 0, the sufficient conditions for asymptotic stability of the oscillating circuit will take the following form: |.R| >UJL 2, 2J2,C
( R
UL
2
2r2sC_
^
(6.12)
Oscillating circuit with constant parameters
277
The tuning characteristics brought forth are of both cognitive and practical significance. For example, when a negative conductance is connected up to an oscillating circuit for the purpose of increasing its quality factor, it is expedient to perform fine tuning with the help of variable resistance. It is worth noting that a considerable number of tuning characteristics, concerning the different physical quantities that determine the processes in an oscillating circuit, can also be obtained. These include capacitance current and voltage, conductance current, resistance voltage, magnetic flux of inductance, inductance current and voltage, as well as the numerous combinations of these quantities. Some tuning characteristics differ from each other only by a constant multiplier. Such is, for example, the capacitance tuning characteristic related to capacitor charge and current, since the charge amplitude differs from the current amplitude by multiplier w. At the same time, there is an essential distinction between the capacitance tuning characteristics related to capacitor charge and voltage. For instance, if x - C, y — Um we obtain xy = Cr = -55 P
yx = Umr = .
r-^ and , which differ from the above quoted
+
GVR2+LO2L2
s/R2+w2L2 parameters xy = Cr and yx = qmT, when x = C and y = qm. When real experimental investigations are carried out, one should bear in mind the peculiarities of the measuring system. For example, when identifying the capacitance or inductance tuning characteristics, it is necessary to take into account the changes in the value of G and R respectively. The methods mentioned above with respect to the generalized series oscillating circuit can be used for establishing in an analogous way the parameters of the tuning characteristics of the generalized parallel oscillating circuit. To conclude this section, we should point out that as a rule capacitors and inductance coils in real systems have distributed volume losses. This fact can be accounted for in first approximation through a respective complication of the equivalent scheme of the generalized oscillating circuit, as shown in Fig.6.3.
Fig. 6.3. Equivalent circuits of a generalized oscillating circuit accounting for the additional losses of capacitance (a) and inductance (b)
278
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
The differential equations and the free oscillation frequencies in these two cases are written down as follows: A \RL dt2 +[ L
1 1+GRc (
il+
\Gc i
1
(G_ RcX\ dg 1 1+GRL \C L ) \ dt LCl+GRcq Uo
\
1r
2
^ + ^ 1 dq\
1
1 /^s_^i • \ l + GRc\dt L ' 9 ) '
(Re
1 1+RGc
rft2+ [ C l+i?GL V C L)\ dt LCI+RGL
G\
RL12
1
T^-r
1+RGL\L
L
^
dt ) '
When Re = 0 and G i = 0, the resultant equations and expressions are similar to those derived above for the generalized oscillating circuit in Fig.6.1. 6.2. Energy balance in a generalized oscillating circuit The generalized oscillating circuit in Fig.6.1. is considered as one-port an in the case of ig = 0 and Ug = Um cos cot [251]. The complex input resistance of the oscillating circuit is of the following type:
^=
G
(
C
\
iJ+G2+w2C2+^(^-G2+w2C72J-
There are two possible varieties of the resonance in the one-port oscillating circuit: a) phase resonance, when the phases of the input current and voltage coincide; b) amplitude resonance, when the amplitude of the input current is maximal. The respective resonance frequencies are equal:
n G^ , \j\+2G{R+7^j UF = \LC~Ci ^ UA = V LC
G^ [I C*' P = ic-
We shall limit our consideration to the phase resonance, and for that purpose we shall write the complex current and voltage amplitudes for all circuit elements:
Oscillating circuit with constant parameters
279
With the help of these formulae, we identify expressions for the instantaneous power consumed by the circuit elements:
PR=w^wu2(1+cos2u}Ft)' (6.13)
P^APT^U2^> PCL
= PC + PL = PXI+
iGy
U2 COS(Pc cos(2ivFt + | -
The power in the active elements consists of two components: a constant component (average power) and a harmonic component with frequency 2cjp (oscillating power), so that the average power is equal to the amplitude of the oscillating power. The active elements consume power in a kick-like way at double frequency. The power in the reactive elements is oscillating, i.e. reactances both receive and transmit electric energy. It is worth noting that for the ordinary series oscillating circuit PCL = 0, i.e. in a resonance situation, reactances have peculiar autonomy and exchange energy without ,,noticing" either any losses or the excitation source. Both excitation source and losses are involved in the generalized series oscillating circuit and the bigger the losses, the more considerable the involvement (in a loss-free circuit ipc = "r)The instantaneous energies accumulated in the reactances are as follows: Wc =
WL WCL
1(RT7W[1
= ^(R?7Wil
+ cos2{L0Ft + ¥>c)]>
(6'14)
+ cos2lfFt)'
L U2 = WC + WL = - ^ _ —
[l - cos
The instantaneous energies in the reactances are related to the instantaneous consumed power through the following dependencies: „
dWc at
_
dWL at
dWcL dt
280
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
i.e. the power received by the reactances is expended for increasing their energy reserve. The major conclusion from the analysis is that the instantaneous power generated by the source is not equal to the instantaneous power absorbed by the active elements of the generalized oscillating circuit. Such equality is observed only with respect to average power: Pa = (PGR + Pch)a = PGR«- Indeed, using (6.13) we obtain:
PGR=PG+PR=2,R^'
[l+V1-4P2RG(R+P2G)~2 sin2
a~~R
P2G sin 2ipc + p2Gcos2
In conclusion, we shall mention yet another interesting particular case, when G = —. Then the following conditions are met: up = 0, tpc = 0, a = 0. In p this case the resonance tuning can be conducted by changing the conductance. Moreover, there is a possibility for ,,resonance" tuning even with respect to an external generator of constant voltage.
CHAPTER 7.
GENERAL ANALYSIS OF THE PARAMETRIC PHENOMENA IN LINEAR OSCILLATING SYSTEMS WITH PARAMETERS CHANGING IN TIME The analysis of linear oscillating systems with variable parameters, and particularly of such with parameters that remain periodical in time, is of fundamental importance for the investigation of oscillating systems in a general form. The parameters of nonlinear oscillating systems depend on the voltage applied and on the currents that flow through them, and these, in their turn, are functions of time. Thus, in the long run, nonlinear systems are also systems with variable parameters. In this connection, a principle of linear linkage is formulated in mathematics [112]. It is related to the idea that the phenomena and properties of nonlinear systems can be realized (in the sense of simulated) for each specific (particular) case in the respective linear systems with variable parameters. This chapter reveals a general method for analyzing linear systems with periodic and almost periodic parameters [78, 252-258]. Qualitative analysis assumes considerable importance in the investigation of complex oscillating systems, since it allows of identifying the most general features of system behavior. The most essential qualitative analysis task is to establish the degree of stability of the system. Here we formulate theorems, as well as differential equations specifying the structure of the system, on the basis of a sufficient number of conditions ensuring stability and asymptotic steadiness of a generalized oscillating circuit with periodic parameters. 7.1. Qualitative analysis of the free processes in a generalized linear oscillating circuit with periodic parameters The generalized linear oscillating circuit (of the type of the one shown in Fig.6.1) with periodic parameters is called to play an important part in the Theory of nonlinear oscillations and in Radiophysics. Its direct significance is that it is used in Radiophysics as a single oscillating circuit parametric amplifier or generator, in the process of oscillation modulation in generator systems, etc. Its indirect significance is conditioned by the fact that it is a heuristic model of nonlinear autonomous and non-autonomous second-order systems employed in the analysis of process stability in such systems. This section provides an analysis of the free processes in an oscillating circuit from the point of view of their bounded or unbounded nature, or, in other words, it studies issues of the stability and instability of the oscillating circuit. The difficulty of the task is predetermined by its most general set-up, which requires the 281
282
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
application of complex mathematical techniques. Yet such a general perspective of the task makes it interesting from a practical point of view, since the parametric oscillating circuit is quite rich in particular cases, but in principle no specific particular case can reveal the overall diversity of possibilities for the oscillating circuit. Further down, we have quoted a basic system of two linear differential equations of the generalized parametric oscillating circuit, as well as some particular cases derived from the basic system through variable substitution. The attention is mostly focused on the canonical second-order system, to which the basic system of circuit equations is reduced. Mathieux's equation is equivalent to a rather particular case of a canonical system with periodic coefficients. It is well-known that Mathieux's various equations can be classified within a definite set of classes by zones of stability and instability. These zones can be presented in a twodimensional plane as areas with sufficiently complex form which intertwine and overlap in a complex way. It turns out that the canonical systems of a general type have analogous properties but the respective stability and instability areas are fixed in cylindrical space obtained by rotating the plane round an axis lying in this plane. The respective results are obtained by employing incomparably more complex methods than in the case of Mathieux's equation and a broader system of mathematical concepts. 7.1.1. Structure of the differential equations describing linear oscillating systems with positive parameters Linear oscillating circuits can be described by applying a first-order vector linear differential equation jZ
= A(t)Z + f(t),
(7-1)
where Z is a n-dimensional vector, whose elements can represent capacitor charges, magnetic flux running through inductances, etc., A(t) is an n x n-dimensional matrix with elements that can be expressed by circuit parameters (inductances, capacitances, resistances), f(t) is a free n-dimensional vector, whose components are determined by the electromotive forces connected to the circuit and by the parameters of the system. In order to identify the structure of equation (7.1), we shall initially analyze the following equation of the free processes with ,,frozen" (time-independent) parameters:
JtX
= AX '
(7 - 2)
where A = const. If all the parameters of the system are positive, the solution will satisfy the condition: limj—xx, x(i) — 0. It is obvious that the latter equation meets the condition that SpA < 0 (SpA is the sum total of the main diagonal terms of matrix A).
General analysis of parametric phenomena
283
Lemma 7.1. Any radiophysical system with constant positive parameters, containing active resistances with currents flowing through them, is described by a system of differential equations with constant coefficients, whose matrix includes non-positive main diagonal elements, at least one of which is negative. Lemma 7.2. The main diagonal in the matrix of the first-order vector differential equation of a radio circuit with constant positive parameters, containing only real reactances (with losses), consists only of negative elements. The condition that SpA = 0 and the following Lemma are valid for circuits made up of ideal reactances with constant positive parameters. Lemma 7.3. The matrix of the vector differential equation of a radio circuit containing only ideal reactances with constant positive parameters has a zero main diagonal. The Lemmas formulated above are also valid for a certain subclass of linear radio circuits (we shall term it a structurally stationary one) with variable positive parameters. They are characterized by the fact that matrix A(t) in (7.2) contains no derivatives of the circuit parameters with respect to the time. The following theorem can be formulated in this connection. Theorem 7.1. Any radio circuits with variable parameters containing no capacitive loops or inductive nodes are structurally stationary. The proof of Theorem 7.1 is based on Kirchhoff 's laws. It demonstrates that the derivatives of the circuit parameters with respect to time emerge only after excluding one of the charges in a capacitive loop, or one of the magnetic fluxes in an inductive node. With a view to extending the scope of action of the Lemmas on structurally stationary circuits considered above, the latter can be reformulated as separate theorems. Two coupled oscillating circuits with intrinsic capacitive coupling can serve as an example of a structurally stationary circuit. Two connected oscillating circuits with external capacitive coupling cannot be regarded as a structurally stationary circuit, since in this case the three capacitances form a capacitive loop. 7.1.2. Vector differential equation describing a linear oscillating circuit with timedependent parameters The free process in a linear generalized oscillating circuit with changing parameters (of the type shown in Fig.6.1) is described by a linear vector differential equation ^ x = A(t).x, x = colon(xi,X2), xi —
<2oo
normalized charge of the capacitor,
(7.3)
284
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications xi =
normalized magnetic flux of the inductance,
A(t) = {«„(<)}, ij = 1,2, a n ( i ) = - * o o ^ < 0, a12(t) = _ - ^ 2 °
4>00C{t)
<
L(t)
If X2 is excluded from system (7.3), the result will be a scalar differential equation with regard t o i l . A scalar equation with respect to Xi can be obtained in an analogous way. These are equations of the type d2x , .dx .. * r + »iW * +<*(*)* = 0,
, (7.4)
where: — in the case of x = xx, ax (t) = — In L(t) + t00 -p^r- + —— , dt [C{t) L(t)\ a2{t)
= Jt [~cW\
~cW~dtlnL{t)
+
mc(t)[
m
m
— in the case of x = x2, respectively a\ (t) = — In C(t) + t00 -~r-r + -prr-r , dt [L(t) C(t)\ d [tooii(t)] t0QR(t) d tg0 rmmt)] A substitution of variable (7.4) x = exp — - / ai(S)dS\ y yields L ^+P(t)y
2
Jo
1 (7.5)
= 0, P{t) = a2(t)-\al(t)-l-d^l.
Given the assumption that in (7.4) x = xi, then [W
Pit)
=
/too / ' \G(S)
LC{l+RG)+2d~t{~C t00R\ d
1( d
T) \
2
R(S)]
\
+2\~C~
1 ftOoG
t00R\2
1 d2L
General analysis of parametric phenomena
285
In the case of x = x2 in (7-4), it follows that [C(t)
p(f\ - ' " " n - i - r R U 1 ^ ftooR
d
\(d
C~)
+2{-T-
1 ft00R
V
--^r)dilnC+4{7tlnC)
1 ftppR
tooG\
Pit)-CL{l+GR)+2Jt{~2
t00G\
, G(S)] J
(too ['[IKS)
tOoG\2
-i\rr
+ ^r)
1 (PC ~2CIF-
Equation (7.3) can be reduced to a vector equation of a canonical type analogous to (7.5) by carrying out the following substitution:
X = Z e x p | i j [au(t) + O22(t)]dt\ . We obtain jZ Z = colon(Z 1 ) Z 2 ),
= B(i)Z,
(7.6)
B(t) = {bi3(t)} , t , i = l , 2
611 = -&22 = ^ ( « n - «22), bi2 = a12, 62i = a2\. The condition that SpQ(t) = 0 is indicative of the canonical character of equation (7.6). In the case under consideration, it is in a rather simple form. If we introduce a Hamiltonian function, i.e. square form of the system H(t,ZuZ2) = \b^{t)Zl - hi{t)ZiZ2 - \b12(t)Zl
(7.7)
Equation (7.6) can be written in the form of the following system dZ1=_dH_ dt dZ2
dZ1=0H_ dt dZi'
{
J
Let us compare the canonical system (7.6) with the equation of a general type (7.3). It is evident that the elements of the second diagonal of the matrixes are identical, while the elements of the main diagonals differ. They are presented in an extended form: ,
1/
Geqv
Oil - -toO—fT, 0
_
022 — —tOO
Reqv Z Li
R\
<^eqv - X ( Or Z
\
I ,
P J
2
,
-tieqv — — P <^eqv,
L(t) P~ \ /~,r.\U U[l)
286
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Hence the conclusion that the necessary and sufficient condition for the oscillating circuit to be described by a canonical equation is z-> Heqv
_ —
_r2/~l P ^eqV'
It is obvious that any conservative oscillating circuit (R = 0, G = 0) is described by a canonical vector differential equation. It is not difficult to verify that if a Hamiltonian oscillating circuit is described by Eq.(7.8), the coefficient of the first derivative has an average value equal to zero, since a\ — — lnL or a\ = — l n C at at Let us express the Hamiltonian function of system (7.8) by using the circuit parameters
?>ooO
£
y/LC
\
I /
(7.9)
When analyzing the canonical system, it is important to identify the nonnegative condition, H(t, Z\,Z 0, for all values of the arguments, for which the solutions of equations Z\ and Z2 are unknown. The bracketed middle term in (7.9) is a serious impediment to such an estimate. That is why we use the inequality 2,2 -i- Z2 Z2 -\- Z2 ^—-—- < Z\ Z2 < 1 — - to obtain the following bilateral estimate ^ 2, ~o~ I 1 " 9 2 V 2 <00 / < —
J I T~rZl P / \
pG
1
„
R
( I T — pCr
" 2 V
2F
F Z 2 ^ H(t,Zi,Z2) qooL j
H
\ \ { gOO rj2 1 ^00 I I -—T;Z,
p \ ) V^ooC
x
< (7.10)
V2\
£1^ I .
-\
q00L
V
As a result of these inequalities, in the absence of any dissipative losses (G = 0, R = 0), the following equation is obtained
h{t,Z1,Z2)
- — I ~j—^Z1 +
-Z2
.
This is the normalized instantaneous energy accumulated in the reactances of the oscillating circuit. Canonical systems and their equivalent equations can be either stable or unstable, but they cannot be asymptotically stable. Let us consider some other forms of the canonical vector system (7.4), for example the following one: ^ Z = JHZ,
(7.11)
General analysis of parametric phenomena
(
toogoo
287 t 00 \G(t)
fl(t)j
\
^ooC(t) 2 [C(O L{t)\ too [G(t)_.R(*)l too^oo 2 [C(t) L(t)\ qooL(t) I where H is a symmetrical matrix of the Hamiltonian function H(t, j?i, Z 2 )Since J - 1 = —J, Eq.(7.11) can also be written in the form: J-^Z=HZ. (7.12) Sometimes it is convenient to present the initial system (7.3) in the form of an integral system of equations. If, for instance, X(t) = {Xij(t)}, i,j — 1,2 is a fundamental system of solutions to (7.3), it will satisfy the integral equation X(t) = X(t 0 ) + /
A(S)X(S)dS,
where X(to) is the matrix of the initial conditions. This form of the oscillating circuit equation is convenient when using the successive approximations method, in the case of seeking a solution in the form of X(t) = X(t 0 ) + ZT=! Xk(t), where = / A(5)X t _i(5)d5, fc = l , 2 , . . . ,
Xk(t)
X0=X(t0).
This recurrent formula allows of consistently identifying all series terms in the solution. It would not be difficult to show that this series is absolutely and evenly convergent over an arbitrary finite interval. Further on we shall demonstrate a multistage transformation approach. If the variables in (7.3) are substituted in the following way
x = B(t)y, B(t) = ( ^ W
V 0
° ),
(7.13)
1/
the equation will assume the form = C(*)y,
jty
V
1
«22(*)
/
(7.14)
\dt
) a2i
A comparison between (7.14) and (7.3) shows that Eq.(7.14) describes an oscillating circuit with constant capacitance or constant inductance, while all other respective parameters vary in time.
288
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
Let us continue the transformation by performing the following substitution in (7.14)
y = Zexp 1 1 jf" [Cu(S) + a22(S)]ds\ . The result is | z = D(t)Z, V
!
-«n('J
/
(7.15) 2 \
dt a2i J
Obviously (7.15) is a simplified canonical system, since one of the matrix elements is constant. Finally, if we carry out the following substitution in Eq.(7.15),
Z(t) = R(i)U(i), R ( t ) = ( d » ( * ) J ) , we shall obtain
| U =MWU, M W = ( r ( ° t )
j ) ,
(7.16)
r(i) = a 12 a 2 i + d n - -jrdn. at System (7.16) describes an oscillating circuit without losses, which contains one time-dependent reactance. System (7.16) is much simpler than the initial system (7.3), and the solutions of both equations are related in the following way: (7.17)
x{t) = k(t,to)N(t)U, where
MM.)=«p{i/;[« llM+ ^) + ^^]*}, / TVT/ x
N(t) =
1 /
I ^
V
1 d a
2a 2 i V
H ~ fl22 H
1
3Ia21
\
«2i rf< /
1 \ I
a.21 .
0/
The investigation of the free processes in linear oscillating circuits with time dependent parameters of a general type is connected with enormous mathematical difficulties conditioned by the general character of the problem. Indeed, it is necessary to examine a huge number of equations (7.3) characterized by four functions - the elements of the matrix a{j, i,j = 1, 2. The canonical systems lend themselves to a sufficiently accurate and clear classification by the boundedness or boundlessness of their solutions. The possible canonical systems make up a set that can be visualized as a set of points in a threedimensional cylindric space. The cylindric space breaks down into a set of alternating areas of stability and instability. Certain investigations have been carried out
General analysis of parametric phenomena
289
and they have yielded a sufficiently comprehensive picture of the general properties of the free processes in a linear oscillating circuit with periodic parameters. T.I.3. Classification of the free processes in Hamiltonian oscillating circuits Again, the canonical systems lend themselves to a sufficiently distinct and clear classification by the boundedness or boundlessness of their solutions. It is possible to create a comprehensive picture of the general regularities governing the free processes in a linear oscillating circuit with periodic parameters. For the sake of visualization, we shall use a three-dimensional cylindric space which is broken down into a set of alternating areas of stability and instability. Consider a canonical system with periodic coefficients in the following vector form jZ
= JHZ.
(7.18)
The fundamental matrix of the solutions of the vector equation (7.18), given the initial conditions Z(0) = I, where I is a unit matrix, is presented as Z(t) = P(t)eKt.
(7.19)
The properties of the matrixes in (7.19) are as follows: a) P(£) is a real matrix-function, which is either periodic, i.e. P(i+T) = P(t) or anti-periodic P(i + T) = —P(t), T - period, P(0) = I, — P is piece-wise continuous, at i.e. it exists almost everywhere and is summable; b) DetP(t) = 1; c) K is a real square matrix with constant elements, SpK. = 0. The investigation of the properties of matrix K is of crucial importance in the stability analysis. If the matrix function of the vector equation (7.18) is known, matrix K will be determined in the following way: K=iln[±Z(T)].
(7.20)
The alternative sign in (7.20) is chosen in such a way as to secure a real matrix K. Let us dwell more elaborately on matrix sets {K} and {P(i)}. For the sake of visualization we shall use geometrical terms. 1) Structure of the set {K}. We shall present the set of various constant second-order matrixes K with zero spur in the following form
f -x y - z \
290
Nonlinear and parametric phenomena: theory and applications
where x,y,z are various values along the axes of the Cartesian coordinate system Oxyz. This presentation yields an ordinary three-dimensional (Euclidean) space. A completely defined matrix K corresponds to each point in this space. The characteristic equation of this matrix, Det(K - AI) = 0,
(7.21)
has the following form: A2 = x2 + y2 — z2. Given a real A, this characteristic equation represents a single-band hyperx2
y2
z2
boloid, whose canonical equation is in the following form: — + — — — = 1. The graphic representation of the single-band hyperboloid is s