This page intentionally left blank
OVID'S FASTI
This page intentionally left blank
Ovid's Fasti Historical Readin...
37 downloads
1649 Views
32MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
This page intentionally left blank
OVID'S FASTI
This page intentionally left blank
Ovid's Fasti Historical Readings at its Bimillennium
Edited by GERALDINE HERBERT-BROWN
OXPORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
This book has been printed digitally and produced in a standard specification in order to ensure its continuing availability
OXJFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford OX2 6DP Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University's objective ofexcclen.ee in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi New Delhi Shanghai Taipei Toronto With offices in Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan South Korea Poland Portugal Singapore Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam
Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York © Oxford University Press 2002 The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) Reprinted 2007 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover And you must impose this same condition on any acquirer ISBN 978*0-19-815475-4
PREFACE
THAT nearly 5,000 lines of a poem on the Roman calendar should survive for 2,000 years is reason enough for celebration; that that same poem should generate ever-increasing comment and spirited controversy at its bimiUennium is double cause for celebration. This volume of papers on Ovid's Fasti was conceived for that dual purpose. The exact date of the poem's inception of course cannot be known, but it can be narrowed down to the early years of the first decade of our era. Book 4 refers to Augustus' restoration of the temple of Cybele in AD 3, so the poem was in progress after that. Ovid himself claimed that its composition was interrupted by his exile to Tomis in AD 8. He also claimed in the same breath that the entire 12 books existed (Jr. 2. 549-52). Nevertheless he subsequently revised sections of the first six in the period between the death of Augustus in. AD 14 and his own in 17. It is these first six books, covering January to June, which have lived to see their third millennium. This volume is also a tribute to the expanding readership of Ovid's Fasti and the increasingly varied ways of looking at it. During the last two decades of the twentieth century readerresponse criticism, which focuses upon the active engagement of the reader with a text, has developed alongside the more traditional quest for authorial intent and target audience as a valid basis of literary interpretation. The meaning of the text is created by the reader, which makes it open to the play of innumerable meanings and the creating of tension between conflicting yet equally valid interpretations. The advantage of this approach is that it makes the text larger than the personality of the poet and the strictures of his culture, and thus provides a variety of exciting new observation points. As a demonstration of that advantage I have invited Fasti scholars representing a range of different approaches: traditionalist, reader-response,
VI
PREFACE
and eclectic, to offer a reading on a subject of shared interest: the Fasti as a sign of its times. Ovid's Fasti is the product of a period for which extant contemporary evidence is scarce. Yet even now, despite its growing popularity, the poem has still to make an impact outside the small circle of Ovid devotees. Not enough historians are appreciating the poem as a mine of information about Roman culture in the late Augustan and early Tiberian Principates. The essays here are an attempt to redress the balance. I wish to express my gratitude to all the contributors who have joined in the spirit of this project. Some scholars are well established and internationally known, others are high achievers with a lower profile. Others again are new to the field, but no less insightful for that. They all bring their considerable but diverse talents and interests to bear in trying to reconstruct the value-systems which informed the poem. This project did not arise from a conference and some contributors have not seen all papers. Cross-referencing of subjects and themes is to be found in the index: the calendar, politics, women, mime, myth, cult, religion, astronomy, astrology, intertextuality, gender, speech, time, and space are among such topics discussed. Some papers, while different in approach, may complement each other; others, similar in approach, may contradict each other. There is overlap in some of the passages discussed, but where this occurs, there is no repetition of construction. There is no party line in this collection, no neat tying up of themes. The tension arising from the discrepancy in interpretation and approach is an apt reflection of the tension arising from the contradictory and elusive nature of the Fasti itself. Yet whatever colour lens one chooses to use we are all still, as modern readers trying to make sense of an ancient culture, a sign of our times. The history of interpretation of a text constantly shifts and evolves. The reader-response critic, in constructing either the anonymous 'Augustan reader' working inside the ideological system, or the 'disembodied reader' stationed outside it, always risks imposing a modern western Judaeo-Christian frame of reference upon the poem, or reading a democratic distaste for totalitarianism into what is being said. The same applies to the seeker of authorial intent. Many of Ovid's 'intentions' can be found to be compatible with
PREFACE
vii
the ideology of animal liberationists, social critics, Marxists, feminists, anti-fascists, or environmentalists, to make the poet come across as a thoroughly modern man. This, of course, is no bad thing in itself, as it simply adds a universal dimension to his work. But whether we focus on the author or the reader, a distorted view of his culture will be inevitable, despite our best intentions. There is no need to despair, however. It is the continued quest, the constant debate, which is keeping the Fasti—and our cultural past—alive. It is hoped that this volume will play its part to that end by inspiring its own readers with the desire to join in the dialogue. So who will those readers be? Everyone who is interested in the early Roman Principate. The undergraduate student or first-time reader of the Fasti, however, would be advised to seek essential background details about Ovid and his environment elsewhere, as there is not the space to include them here. Literature on the subject is vast, but the introduction by Peter Green to his translations of the Erotic Poems (1982), and to the Poems from Exile (1994), and by Elaine Fantham to her commentary to the Fasti Book IV(1998), are especially recommended for that purpose. And as a survey of recent work on the Fastihas been conducted no less than three times in the last decade-by Miller (1992
viii
PREFACE
literature throughout his life. He himself, as patron and dedicatee, received learned commentaries on the Alexandrian epigoni poets, Valerius Maximus* Facto, et Dicta Memorabilia, Apollonides' commentary on the Silli (Lampoons) of Timon, Getmanieus' translation of the Phaenomena of Aratus, and Manilius' Astronomica. As Pontifex Maximus he should have received the revised version of Ovid's Fasti, but Ovid bypassed him in favour of his heir, Germanicus. Tiberius Caesar was a discerning reader, but not only with regard to quality. During Augustus' lifetime he was more sensitive than Augustus to the way in which the Princeps was portrayed in literature (Suet. Aug. 51. 3). As Princeps himself he became notorious for burning literature which he found politically offensive, and having the authors prosecuted for treason.. Cassius Severus, Cremutius Cordus, L(R)abienus, Clutorius Priscus, Votienus Montanus, Sextus Paconianus, and Mamercus Aemilius Scaurus are some of the unfortunates whose names Seneca, Tacitus, Suetonius, and Dio have handed down. The climate of oppression was such that it was said that a poet was charged with having slandered Agamemnon in a tragedy (Suet. Tib. 61. 3). There could be no better-informed, more sensitive, or more suspicious reader of Ovid's poetry, no reader with a greater vested interest, than Tiberius Caesar. So what did he think of it? His panegyrist, Velleius Paterculus (2. 36. 3), claims that Ovid ranked as one of the most important poets of the age for having achieved perfection in his art. The list excludes Propertius and Horace. Written in a period of book burning and purging, Velleius' testimony to the imperial endorsement of Ovid's poetry is revelatory. Are there other indicators to the truth of it? Despite the charge of immorality for his erotic elegies, Ovid was never silenced in exile, before or after the death of Augustus. In AD 8 the ATS Amatoria was banned from the three public libraries in Rome, but the work was not destroyed. Nothing attracts more attention to a work than a public ban. Meanwhile, in the epistolatory corpus from exile, the Ars Amatoria is present, implicitly or explicitly, in every poem. There could have been no better or more protracted advertisement for the carmen whose pernicious influence was supposed to have; upset Augustus so much. If it was not. already
PREFACE
IX
so beforehand, the Ars Amatoria must have become the most sought-after and discussed literary work in Rome upon receipt of the exilic poems. Why, then, was Ovid allowed to publicize his didactic work on adultery so blatantly, so relentlessly? Why were his audacious taunts to 'Caesar' that the Ars was not the real cause of his exile allowed to be made public? Was he not jeopardizing its survival by constantly harping upon it? History has shown that using a work of literature as a justification for condemning its author was characteristic more of Tiberius than of Augustus. So, too, was a long-delayed retribution against the perpetrator of an unofficial, offence (Herbert-Brown 1998). In 1 BC, the year the Ars Amatoria was published, Tiberius was out of favour with Augustus, his tribunician power lapsed, and his ostensible retirement was suddenly transformed into involuntary exile. Ovid was safe. In the summer of AD 8, following the death of Messalla, the downfall ofjulia II, and in command of a large army, Tiberius was de facto the most powerful man in the world. Augustus was diminished in the process. A noticeable decline in the freedom of speech and literature begins from this period. Ovid was on his way to Tomis by the end of that year. Yet. the sequel reveals that it was not Ovid's poetry that was the problem, for Tiberius did not allow his animosity for the man to impinge upon his assessment of his work. Perhaps Ovid knew that if he never divulged the nature of the error he could entrust to Tiberius the fate of his art. It certainly seems he had no concerns on that score, because Ms personal disgrace did nothing to diminish his confidence in his posthumous reputation as a poet. On the contrary, the last nine lines of the Metamorphoses are, to the modern mind at least, the greatest challenge imaginable to a Princeps as paranoid as Tiberius, who sought subversion in every written word. Yet it was Tiberius who was prepared to grant that which the poet desired far more than his personal survival: fama. We know how Augustus needed the poets to immortalize his achievements. But it was a two-way thing. Writers also needed the Princeps, as so many under his successor discovered to their cost. The disgraced Ovid, especially, needed Tiberius' endorsement to secure his future glory. He got it, and it seems he never doubted that he would. To understand why, when
X
PREFACE
Tiberius denied it to so many others, presents a hefty challenge to all students of this period. Tiberius Caesar, then, is the most important reader Ovid, (has) ever had. For this reason it would seem appropriate to dedicate this bimillennial celebration of the Fasti to the memory of the imperial literary critic, in recognition of his ability to separate the carmen from the error, the artist from the man, and for his willingness to allow the artist to live. Immortality for Ovid meant eternal recognition of the god in him, his creative genius, his meliorpars. It was the dour, vindictive autocrat who gave truth to the prophecy of the bard: 'perque omnia saecula fama, ... vivam'. It was Tiberius Caesar who allowed Ovid's melior pars safe passage through his own era to begin its journey through time, beyond the stars and down the ages, so that we, at the 2,000th anniversary of its composition, can celebrate the Fasti, the poem that was not rededicated to him. I trust Ovid would not begrudge him this latter-day dedication. G.H-B. Macquarie University Kal. Ian. MM.
CONTENTS
List of Contributors List oflllustrations 1. Martial Arts. Mars Ultor in the Forum Augustum: A Verbal Monument with a Vengeance ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI 2. The Fasti as a Source for Women's Participation in Roman Cult ELAINE FANTHAM 3. Vaga Signa: Orion and Sirius in Ovid's Fasti EMMA GEE 4. Varro's Three Theologies and their Influence on the Fasti C. M. C, GREEN 5. Ovid and the Stellar Calendar GERALDI NE HERBERT-BROWN 6. Seen, not Heard: Feminea Lingua in Ovid's Fasti and the Critical Gaze PETER MARK KEEGAN 7. Representing the Great Mother to Augustus PETER E. KNOX 8. imperil pignora certa: The Role of Numa in Ovid's Fasti
xiii xv
1
23
47 71
101 129
155
175
R.J, LlTTLEWOOD
9. Ovid's Liberalia JOHN F. MILLER 10. Contesting Time and Space: Fasti 6. 637-48 CAROLE E. NEWLANDS 11. Added Days: Calendiical Poetics and the JulioClaudian Holidays M. PASCO-PRANGER 1.2. Ovid and the Stage T, P. WISEMAN
199 225
251
275
Xll
References Index Locomm General Index
CONTENTS
300 315 319
LIST
OF
CONTRIBUTORS
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI, Professor of Latin literature at the University of Siena at Arezzo, works especially on Augustan poetry and the interaction between Classics and contemporary theory. He has published in English on Virgil, Horace, and Ovid, including The Poet and the Prince (1997), Speaking Volumes (2001), and has co-edited Ovidian Transformations (1999) and Iambic Ideas (2001), ELAINE FANTHAM was Giger Professor of Latin at Princeton University from 1986 until her retirement in 2000. Her scholarly output includes Comparative Studies in Republican Latin Imagery (1972), Seneca's Troades: A Literary Commentary with Introduction, Text and Translation (1982), commentaries on Lucan de Bello Civili 77(1992) and Ovid: Fasti 7F(1998), Roman Literary Culture (1996, 1999) and (with Foley, Kampen, Pomeroy, and Shapiro), Wom.en in Classical Antiquity: Image and Text (1994, 1995), She has been writing about Ovid's Fasti since 1983, EMMA GEE is Lecturer in Classics at the University of Exeter and is author of Ovid, Aratus and Augustus: Astronomy in Ovid's Fasti (2000). Her current research interests are Cicero's Aratea and the Roman reception of Greek science, C. M. C. GREEN is Associate Professor of Classics at the University of Iowa, and author of numerous articles on Varro, Ovid, and Roman religion. She is in the process of completing a monograph on the evolution of the cult of Diana in Italy. GKRAUHNK HERBERT-BROWN is research fellow in Roman Histoiy at Macquarie University. She is author of Ovid and the Fasti: A Historical Study, and articles on Roman Republican and early Principate history.
XIV
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
PETER MARK KEEGAN is a postgraduate student at Macquarie University and is working on a gendered rescript of the epigraphic corpora of Rome and its environs. He is the editor of Stele, vol. 5 and has been invited to sit on a panel of the 12th Berkshire Conference for Women's History in 2002. PETER E. KNOX is Professor of Classics at the University of Colorado. He is the author of Ovid's Metamorphoses and the Traditions of Augustan Poetry (1986) and a commentary on Ovid's Heroides(1995}. He has published a number of articles on Latin literature and Hellenistic poetry. R. J. LITTLEWOOD has written a number of articles on Tibullus and Ovid's Fasti Following eighteen years teaching, mainly history, in Oxfordshire, she has now returned to research and is working on historical and iconographic aspects of the Fasti JOHN F. MILLER teaches at the University of Virginia, where he is chairman of the Department of Classics. He is the author of Ovid's Elegiac Festivals: Studies in the Fasti (1991) and numerous articles on various Latin authors. CAROLE E, NEWLANDS is Professor of Classics at the University of Wisconsin at Madison. She is author of Playing with Time: Ovid and the Fasti (1995), of Statius' Silsae and the Poetics of Empire (2002), and many articles on Latin poetry and medieval literature. M. PASCO-PRANGER is Assistant Professor at the University of Puget Sound in Tacoma, Washington. She is presently writing a book treating the relationship between poetics, calendrics, and politics in the Fasti. T. P. WISEMAN is Professor Emeritus of Classics and Ancient History in the University of Exeter, and a Fellow of the British Academy, His most recent books are Remus: A Roman Myth (1995) and Roman Drama and Roman History (1998).
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
1, Plan of the Forum Augustum and the temple of Mars Ultor (after Degrassi in Zanker 1968) 2, Aeneas veiled for sacrifice, Ara Pacis Augustae, Rome (photographer Singer) 3, Statue of Augustus, Termi Museum, Rome (photographer Koppermann)
177 191 193
This page intentionally left blank
1
Martial Arts Mars Ultor in the Forum Augustum: A Verbal Monument with a Vengeance ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
In the late Augustan and early Tiberian age, the position of the emperor was defined as a static principis. Being a sentinel, the Princeps mans and controls boundaries, one being that of Roman space of course, but there is also a double temporal boundary: he is the one who stands between the old Republic and a new order, and between the present and a potential return of the civil wars. Ready to attack foreign enemies, he is also ready to stifle the return of internal discord. This is presumably the reason why, so many years after Philippi (and Actium), the Senate in the Senatus Consultum de On. Pisone Patre (46-7), addresses the emperor as the one who has buried the evils of the civil wars, 'iam pridem numine divi August! virtutibusque Tiber! Caesaris August! omnibus civilis belli sepultis malls' ('when all the evils of civil wars had long since been buried through the numen of the divine Augustus and the virtues of Tiberius'),1 This implies that the presence of the civil wars is both hidden and memorialized, precisely the way burial, sepultura, operates on dead people in order to make death acceptable to the community: concealing the corpse, but keeping memory visible. One might say that the civil, wars lie 'beneath' the Augustan order just as the image of universal peace and victory defines its borderlines. 1 See Potter {1998} 70- \; 'my point is to suggest that the specific virtues that are adduced in connection with, the damns Augusta offer a reading of the history of the late Republic that is intended to show how the damns stands between the Roman state and the chaos of Cicero's generation*.
2
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
This official language of burial collides, almost through a visual-verbal pun, with Ovid's image of the battlefield of Philippi, strewn with white bones (3. 707-8): morte iacet merita: testes estate, Philippi, et quorum sparsis ossibus albet humus, , , , lies dead as he deserves. Bear witness, Philippi, and the battlefield white with their scattered bones,2
We return later to the striking style of this passage (sigmatism, assonance, archaic forms). At present, I only need to say that in this moment of his poem, one attached to the Ides of March, Ovid is stretching the tradition of elegy to cover a spectacle that had been an impossible bet to Propertius, In the recusatio of Propertius 2. 1. 27, the image of Philippi-'civilia busta, Philippos*—was clearly presented as the ultimate non-elegiac subject, and one should not underrate the paradox of 'busta*. If Philippi had been the burial site of the civic community of Rome, as well as the funerary monument of the civil wars, it was precisely because of the horror of unburied corpses or mass burials without names.3 Moreover, Ovid is here discarding what ought be the obvious approach to the subject for an elegiac poet: the austere language of witness and punishment surprises the reader, if one considers the familiar patterns of lament and sympathy in Greek epigrams and elegies about great horrors of the past, such as the following example by Polystratos about the destruction of Corinth and its chilling memory (API, 297. 3-4): 'and just one mound keeps together the heap of bones frightened by the spear , , ,'.4 The white bones of Philippi almost have the lasting quality of a memorial. The image, fifty years after the battle, guarantees that there was no death ritual, not even a hasty cremation on the battlefield; nor are we in the healing moment anticipated, in Virgil's Georgics, when the corpses have fattened with '' Translations from the Fasti UK Nagle's (1995), with slight adaptations. All other translations are my own. •' On Roman anxieties about bodies, and the link between the politics of proscription and the treatment of bodies and corpses, see Hinard (1.984). '' The meaning1 of doriptoieta is controversial: 1 suspect ft bold variation on the typology of f/erp-compounds that normally define conquest, and captivity as regular military practice, cf. Ducrey (1J)68) 20-1,
MARS ULTOR IN THE FORUM AUGUSTUM
3
their blood the dusty plains of Thessaly, land of Mars, and the ploughman marvels at huge bones from another generation (Georg. I. 497):s grandiaque effossis mirabitur ossa sepulcris.
The Virgilian 'sepulcra' are at least a hint of possible reconciliation, but readers of Virgil also know that bones can generate revenge (Aen. 4. 625 'ex ossibus ultor'). The denial of sepultura at Philippi had also defied the basic Roman notion that citizens were different from outsiders in death: Ovid's language recalls Horace's description of a dump for slaves, executed criminals, and dropouts (Sat. 1. 8. 15-16: 'tristes | albis informem spectabant ossibus agram', 'a field made repulsive by white bones, a gloomy panorama, is what they used to see'). Statius will readapt the image to Lucan's project of an accursed epic of Roman self-destruction (Silt), 2. 7. 65-6: "albos ossibus Italis Philippos et Pharsalica bella cletonabis', 'you shall thunderously rehearse Philippi, white with Italian bones, and Pharsalian wars'), and the savage victory of Philippi will be a manifesto for the wicked emperor Nero in Ps.-Seneca's Octavia (515-16): 'pavere volucres et saevas feras diu tristes Philippi', 'for a long time, gloomy Philippi has offered food to birds and wild animals'. Literary studies of texts about public art have paid increasing attention to the fact that monuments can speak their own language. The new, powerful rise of cultural studies stresses ideas like shared response and communal ideology in a way that is unprecedented from the Romantic age onwards. And of course there is no history of a society without some degree of similar assumptions. Here, for example, is Robin Osborne (1987: 102) writing on the Parthenon frieze: 'No Athenian, man or woman, who visited the Parthenon, followed the frieze and absorbed the sculptural programme, could go away without having been compelled to contemplate seriously his or her individual and collective identity' (my tendentious italics). So the reading of the monument in a. cultural context is about the intended reading produced by the figurative programme in a community of viewers. The meaning of the monument '-' For similar dynamics in Ovid's use of the Georgia, see Gee in this volume.
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
4
is the thing itself plus its collective reception as directed by the thing itself. This is fine with me, but most people would agree that ideology plays some part in this process of turning images into meanings. And once ideology is perceived in terms of a discourse, there is no way of keeping the discourse simple and monolithic. The meaning of the monument could also be located in the multiple and divergent reactions of a pluralistic community of viewers—more pluralistic than traditional images of the Athenian body politic perhaps allow. The main problem, for a classicist, is how to find evidence of those readings. My discussion is about a poetic text which, being about a monument, is becoming popular among cultural historians. The text is a passage in Ovid, Fasti 5, and the monument is the Forum Augustum. Ovid's description is so detailed, and ideologically loaded, that many interpreters'1 are perfectly happy with it as a source—an authorized version of the intended reception of this giant architectural signifier. The monument is described under the spotlight of a divine epiphany (5. 549-52): Pallor, an anna sonant? Non faUimur, arma sonabant: Mars venit ct venicns bellica signa tleclit. Ultor ad ipse suos caclo descends.! honores templaque in Augusta conspicienda foro. Am I wrong, or are weapons clashing? I'm not wrong, they were clashing. Mars is coming, giving a warlike signal. The Avenger himself is descending from heaven for his own celebration, to his eye-catching temple in the Forum of Augustus.
The clashing arms are, for a moment at least, an alarming signal. They could be identified as the signature soundtrack of Roman Mars through the ritual of the Salii, true, but the sound of arms within a city can also reverberate less positive messages. This is the threatening sound that typically starts, in the Livian strategy of annual prodigy lists, a narrative about danger and crisis, especially civil wars; metallic resonance and arms in the sky mark the onset of civil/social wars in Aeneid 8. The b
Important discussions are banker (1968, 1989); Scheid (1992«); Cresci Marrone (1993); Herbert-Brown (1994); Ncwlands (199.5); Galinsky (1996); Flower (1996); Klodt (1998); Rich (1998).
MARS ULTOR IN THE FORUM AUGUSTUM
5
Greek king of Rome had just mentioned that Aeneas would be the leader of the Etruscan army that seeks revenge against Mezentius 'praesenti Marte' (8. 495) and the clash of arms in the sky soon announces the first global war in Italian history (8. 520-40).7 The Trojans had lost their city for not listening to the sound of arms in the belly of the Horse (Aen. 2. 243: 'sonitum quater arma dedere'). The urban space of Rome is not a traditional dwelling-place for Mars. But Ovid soon clarifies that Mars the Avenger is a protector in the city of Romulus, not a menace (5, 553-68): Et deus est ingens et opus; debebat in urbe non aliter nati Mars habitare sui. Digna Giganteis haec sent delubra tropaeis: hinc8 fern Gradivum be.Ua movere decet, sen quis ab Eoo nos impius orbe lacesset, sen quis ab occiduo sole domandus eril. Perspicit amtpotens opens fastigia summi, et pnbat invictos sumrna tenere decs; penpicit in foribus diversae tela figurae, armaque terrarum milite victa suo. Hinc videt Aeoean oneratum pondere caro et tot luleae nobilitatis avos; Hinc videt Iliaden urneris duds arma ferentem, claraque dispositis acta subesse viris. Special et Augusta praetextum nomine templum, et visum lecto Caesare maius opus. The god and the structure are both impressive, just the way Mars should dwell in his son's city. This shrine is fit for housing spoils taken from the Giants. From here it suits the Marcher to start fierce wars, whether someone from the Eastern world treacherously provokes us, or someone from the land of sunset must be subdued. The patron of war surveys the gables of his tall building, and approves the presence of Victories at the top. He surveys the weapons of various shapes on the doors, and armour of the world which his troops have won. From here he sees Aeneas loaded with a priceless burden and so many ancestors of the noble Julian line. From here he sees Romulus '" Ou the simultaneous interpretation of the prodigy as a 'Homeric* sign of divine support and as a catastrophic precursor of the civil wars, see Barchiesi (1084) ch. 3. " The line elegantly demonstrates that a war god whose cultic name is Cradtvus (from gradior 'walk', already glossed in. 550; 'Mars veuil et veuiens'), needs a place to start from, and this is the function of the new temple—the function previously assigned by Virgil to lanus Geniiuus, see Aen, 7. 601 ff. and infra, pp. 19f.
6
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
shouldering the spoils of a general, and exploits inscribed beneath a row of statues. He examines the name of Augustus lining the temple. From reading 'Caesar', he thinks the structure even greater.
The importance of Mars' visit to the new Forum is particularly clear if we stop for a moment pretending that we already know how people felt about the monument in Ovid's times. We simply cannot account for the wide range of meanings that were mobilized and circulated by a new monument in Augustan Rome. And we cannot even invoke authorial intention with the same cogency that one attributes to it in literature. But this is different from assuming that those readings do not matter. Can we presume, for example, that, some reactions were arbitrary and eccentric? How many marginal readers of the monument were steeped enough in the counter-cultures and subcultures of love magic and amatory elegy to notice that the association of Mars, Venus, and Eros had a precise function in the private discourse of erotic charms?0 Others, or perhaps the same people, were familiar enough with the Empedoclean theory of Aphrodite-Love and Ares-Strife and ready to make interesting comments on a precinct for Mars intersecting a precinct for Venus, the Forum of Caesar. Others again, or perhaps the same people, will have offered lewd interpretations. We cannot tell. But the problem is an interesting one. If we accept that there is no simple and straightforward 'meaning' attached to the monument, and that every reading is a reduplication of an act of understanding, we can shift our emphasis from the result of the reception to the process of reception and its problems. As we shall see, Ovid's approach 9 Faraone (1999) 52 (my italics): 'a series of Roman-era gemstones from various parts of the Mediterranean ... These gems depict either a fully armed Ares leading a naked Aphrodite whose hands are bound behind her back or the reverse, a, fully clothed Aphrodite who is leading Ares, who is naked {except fm his hairnet), while Eros stands to the side holding Ares' sword and shield': those are persuasive mythological images accompanied by voces magicae, spells of vowels typical of magical texts; the pictures with Aphrodite dominating Ar^s would be for women to use against m0n. On the Algiers relief, Mars is fully armed and dressed, except for the sword, but Cupid is offering a small-sized sword to Venus. It is less likely that some viewers actually perceived the phallic design of the Forum as discussed by Kellum (UW6), because that would require an aerial perspective (although Qvid's Mars^ while landing irom his residence iu the sky, had the appropriate vantage point).
MARS ULTOR IN THE FORUM AUGUSTUM
J
to the monument implies that the monument cart be seen as a supplement and interpretation of a text, Virgil's Aeneid. The words italicized in my quotation express a relationship between Mars, as the viewer, the language of weapons, and the lexical register of heroic epic. In a moment, I will point out that here, from the viewpoint of a literary critic, intertextuality performs the task of political appropriation of visual art. My approach is made easy by the critical tropes already applied to the Ovidian text by the religious historianJohn Scheid: 'We are in the presence of an exegesis quoting another exegesis. This is a complex relationship of intertextuality'.1" As we shall see, the word 'intertextuality' is even more true than Scheid demonstrates; and, far from using literature as an escape, I am going to take quite seriously issues like: celebratory meaning, seeing celebration in, the monuments, teaching" through poetry how to see visual meaning, making art a textual phenomenon. My intention is not to weaken the political meaning of Augustan poetry in order to assert the poet's independence from, or resistance to, Augustan ideology. On the contrary, I want to deepen our understanding of the nexus 'politics and poetry', exactly because I do not believe in a peaceful relationship of 'the thing itself—ideology as separated from and mirrored by artistic expression—and its 'representation' in poetic language. But first of all let me note, episodically, that Scheid is assuming that Augustan poets put their poetry to the service of a public exegesis of the monument: 'We can see that Ovid, reproduces in his own style the decoration of the Forum, Mars himself perspicit, special, conspicit, videt, he contemplates.'11 This approach begs the question of viewpoint and point of view, exactly like Zanker's brief assessment (1989: 122): 'La descrizione ovidiana del nuovo edificio e come una guida alia lettura, e pud dare un'idea di come il grande pubblico reagisse a quelle sollecitazioni visive.' Both Scheid and Zanker understand the poet's function as a 'teaching to view' the Augustan artefact, and I have found much that is useful in this approach when it wrenches the study of poetiy from pure formalism. But they seem unaware that Mars (the god who 'perspicit', 'spectat', 'conspicit', 'videt', and finally 'legit', 'reads'} is 10
Scheid (WMa) 12S,
u
Scheid (!i»i»2a) 128,
8
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
not a random choice as a focalizer. The poet wants us to see the sanctuary through the eyes of its dedicatee, the Augustan god of war. In Ovid's Fasti, in general, divine informants cannot be lightly dismissed: there is a multiplication of points of view, and even a power struggle, whenever the poet asks the gods to explain the cults in which they are involved. We are taking the exegesis of the temple as a sort of'orthodox' interpretation precisely because the text constructs the monument through the gaze of this particular god; the text is not simply shaped by a particular viewpoint, it actually says that it is shaped by a viewpoint; Rome seen from Mars, This is not just 'Ovid's own style'; this is the god's own imprint on the style of the elegiac poem. There were, of course, other ways of reading the topography of the place: as Geraldine Herbert-Brown reminds me, there is no allusion, to the intersecting structure of the Forum lulium, or to Mars' architectural connection with Venus. The epiphany of Mars in the Fasti can be seen as a revenge in more than one sense. The god had been, rather surprisingly, excluded from an active role in Virgil's Aeneid—a. poem dominated by the idea of revenge in all its versions and transformations12—and now in Ovidian elegy he can appropriate the entire epic tradition of Rome. His name is the last word of the spurious and dispensable pre-proemium of the Aeneidy before the unforgettable 'authentic' beginning 'arma virumque'; the god tends to merge with 'war* and only sneaks in through a shady mos and an acrostic when the war begins (7, 601-4).B In his works, Ovid tends to relegate Mars to the antique store of Ennian epic: both in the Metamorphoses and in the Fasti it is the god, not the narrator, who quotes Ennius by heart (Met, 14, 814 = Fast. 2, 487), and in the Iristia he is to Ennius' Annales what Ares is to Aeschylus' Septem (2, 423). Now the god, precisely when he is entering his new Roman house, demonstrates the changes that he can make to Roman poetry. Accepting his point of view, Ovid identifies Romulus with the lofty and Homeric-sounding matronymic Iliades, and views the inscription on the temple like the purple stripe of a solemn toga praetexla (565-7 'hinc videt Iliaden ... spectat et n 13
The fundamental study is Quint (1993), Now also Spannagel (1999). See Fowler (1983) and" (2000) 182-3.
MARS ULTOR IN THE FORUM AUGUSTUM
Q
Augusto praetextmn nomine templum'), the official garment that was the generic marker of scenic celebrations of victory and communal salvation (fabulae pmetextae or praetextatae).H Of course, if we remember the exercise of visual power in Propertius 2, 31, where the poet-flaneur appropriates both the Augustan monument of Apollo Palatinus and the visibility of women, but denies to Apollo the power to speak, Ovid's achievement must appear a spectacular surrender: this elegiac poet—insofar as the Fasti are still elegy—delivers to the owner of the monument the power to see. If it is true that Augustan monuments are feasts for the eyes, and create a new type of spectator, insatiable and dazzled, then the god himself is the ideal viewer: 'perspicit', 'probat', 'spectat', 'conspicit', Videt'. Yet this way of representing Mars is also suggesting a communication problem between the divine guest and the author of the poem: it is unusual for a god to enter the world of the Fasti without participating in a dialogue with the narrative voice. Both Ovid and Mars will remain silent, in this poem of Callimachean dialogue, and the only voice to speak is that of the princeps (570). Mars is not only the viewer and the silent focalizer: he is also the recipient of a vow made by Augustus, a vow that the poet's voice recuperates as the focal point for the celebration: the temple has a birthday to be commemorated, but the conception goes all the way back to Philippi (5. 569-77): Vbverat hoc iuvenis, turn cum pia sustulit arma; a tantis princeps incipiendus erat. Ille manus tendens, hinc stand milite iusto, hinc conmratis, talia dicta dedit: 'S! MIHF BBLLAND! PATER EST VESTAEQUE SACERDOS AUCTOR, ET ULCISCt KUMEN UTRUMQUE PARC, MARS, ADESETSATIA SCELEMTO SANGUINE
FEKRIJM,
STETQUE FAVOR CAUSA PRO MEL1ORE TUUS. TUMPLA FERKS KT; ME VICTORIi, VOCABfcRIS ULTOR"
The young man vowed this temple when he dutifully took up aims; he had to make such a start as our loading citizen. Gesturing to the loyalist forces 14 The expression is particularly elegant; presumably the letters of the inscription were in colour (golden, purple?), hence the visual analogy wilh the stripe on the toga, On the other hand the proetextum ... templum turns into a celebration analogue to the tradition Q[ fobulti praelextor, see infra.
1O
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
standing on one side, the conspirators on the other, he made this vow: 'If my father, Vesta's priest, is my inspiration for going to war, and if I intend to avenge the divinity of them both, be with me, Mars, glut the sword with the criminals' blood, and back the better cause with your support. If I am victorious, you'll get a. temple and be called the Avenger.'
At this point we realize again that we are reading a text as well as a monument. Students of Augustan poetry have very few occasions to hear the living voice of the prince, so I suggest that we read carefully the text, of Octavian's promise: 'Mars ades el satia scelerato sanguine ferrum.*
The short narrative functions as a miniature analogue to the dramatic genre known as fabula praetexta. The generic name alludes, through the idea of ritual clothing, to the sacral nature of imperatorial power, and connects the victorious general to a sacrificer. Not only military victory, but more specifically vow, supplication, deootio, thanksgiving, and ludi seem to have been crucial to this production:15 Romulus, Brutus, Decius, Marcellus, Fulvius Nobilior, and Aemilius Paulus are attested as heroes of praetextae, and some of the Republicans who fought against Octavian at Philippi may have been interested in reviving the tradition,16 In response to the mid-Republican habit of representing military leaders in critical moments, when vow and prayer become crucial and are recuperated through the celebration of victory, and especially in the context of ludi votivi and ludi for the dedication of a temple, Ovid has created for the prince a very specific tone of voice, marked as different in the elegiac context: the prayer sounds old-fashioned, even archaic (talia dicta dedit", the triple alliteration sa-/sc-/sar), and harsh (the density of unpleasant sigmatism and rhotacism). The scanty fragments of Republican praetextae are enough to to
The best accounts of those aspects arc Zorzetti (1980) and Flower {15)95}. '* We know that Brutus tried to have Accius* Brutus performed after the death of Caesar, and there is controversial information on a Bruins composed by Cassius of Parma (see Zurzelti 1980: 104 nn, 5 and 6, with bibliography), lu connection with AogBstus* vow at Philippi and with Ovid's memory of the dedication of the temple in 2 lie, cf, the summing up of Flower (1995) 190 on what made Republican praelextae so precarious as a genre; '[they] were pieces written for a particular patron on a specific occasion, probably special ludi, whether ludi niagni volivi or games celebrating the dedication of a temple ... Their purpose was precise and directly connected with explaining a vow taken by a general in battle.'
MARS ULTOR IN THE FORUM AUGUSTUM
1I
suggest that this style was appropriate to recreate the programmatic moment before a crucial battle (Ace. Pmet 4 R.: Aeneadae sive Decius): 'lue patrium hostili fusum sanguen sanguine' ("expiate through the enemy's blood the paternal blood that was shed'). Mars, who is not going to receive theatrical games (cf. 5. 598: 'non visa est fortem scaena decere deum', and infra, p. 13), has many reasons to be happy with this prayer: Augustus, with his interest in the Arvales cult, knows how to please the god. Mars is traditionally insatiable (NisbetHubbard on Horace, Odes 1. 2. 37 satiate), and the famous and mysterious (and alliterating) litany of the Arvales was (Carm. An. 7-9 Courtney): satur fu, fere Mars . . . satur fu, fere Mars . . . satur fu, fere Mars . . .
Augustas' battle-cry against the murderers of Caesar recalls Romulus' famous words to Remus (Enn. Ann. 95 Sk.):'7 *nam mi calido dabis sanguine poenas' ("you shall give me revenge in hot blood'), as well as Aeneas' revenge on Turnus, itself based on the Ennian fratricide (12, 949): 'poenarn scelerato ex sanguine sumit' ('takes revenge from the criminal blood'). The alliterative and sigmatic style links the three passages with standard patterns in early Roman poetry about celebrations of Republican victory, yet the tradition of praelexlae could also issue a warning about the crucial distinction—domi militiae— between a triumph and a civil war victory. In what was possibly one of the greatest self-reflective moments in the history of Roman literature, Ennius' Sabine women (Enn. Praet. 5 R,: Sabinae) asked: 'when you have taken the spoils from your own sons-in-law, what kind of inscription will you use?' Since a pmetexla is fundamentally a performance sanctioning a victory, Ennius was teaching the Romans how problematic the concept of victory could be. The Ovidian version of Philippi blurs the crucial Republican distinction between war and civil war. As a god of war and of national epic, Mars will, appreciate an Augustus who echoes Ennius and Virgil at their most fierce !
' The construction and the clausula 'sanguine poeuas' is echoed mure precisely at Fasti 4. 239 fmeritas do sanguine poenas1; not very tactfully, in an account of Attis' emasculation).
12
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
and warlike. Seeing Augustus' performative name on the temple, Mars had already perceived the monument as a 'maius opus' a 'grander work' [5. 568), and of course the very name Augustus implies a process of growing bigger. But Galinsky (1996:211-12) is also right in noting that'maius opus' is Virgil's own label for the second, militarized half of his epic poem (Aen. 7. 45). On the other hand, the initial label of the temple as 'ingens opus' (5. 5,53) is the formula that will be used by Eumolpus to introduce an epic on Roman civil war (Petmn. Sat. 118. 6): 'belli civilis ingens opus'. Ovid is certainly no stranger to the idea that the great subject of the Aeneid, the topic that makes Aeneid 7-12 so special, is the underlying idea of civil war. In his short summary of the plot of Aeneid 7—12 in the Metamorphoses, he offers a pre-Lucanian 'worst-case scenario of the Aeneid and of the Roman history that it seeks symbolically to represent' (14. 568-72):"* . . . habetque deos pars utraque, quodque deorum est instar, habent anitnos: nee jam dotalia regna, nee sceptrum soceri, nee te, Lavinia virgo, sed vicisse petunt, deponendique pudore bella gerunt... both sides had the gods to aid them, and what is as good as gods, they had courage too. And now not even a kingdom given in dowry, nor the sceptre of a father-in-law, nor you, virgin Lavinia, did they seek, but only victory, and they kept on warring through sheer shame of giving up.
The experiment is clear. Take the programmatic statement of the Virgilian Nisus, uttered right before the first blood of the war action, in Latium, that either it is the gods who inspire violence and heroism, or it is just a 'dira cupido' (Aen. 9. 185) that becomes a divine inspiration to the individual; then choose the second alternative; a radical rereading of the plot will end up very near to the calm assessment by Mettius Fufetius before the military confrontation between Rome and Alba (Livy 1. 23. 7); 'I know that the war is said to be about violations of a treaty and the intention to recover things (res .,. repetilae), and I do not doubt that the Roman king is able to show similar good reasons; but if we care more about truth than about sounding 18
Quint {1993} 82,
MARS ULTOR IN THE FORUM AUGUSTUM
13
attractive, 'cupido imperil duos cognates vicinosque populos ad arma stimulat' ('greed for empire is what spurs to war two consanguineous and neighbouring nations'). The process of growth and expansion that culminates in the word Augustus had begun in the previous episode of the Fasti Born in a lowly hut, from origins both divine and unspeakable (532: 'pudor est ulteriora loqui'; the gods squirt bodily fluid on an oxhide), Orion grows up, and up (537: 'creverat immensum'), until the spacious giant is brought to the sky by a catasterism. Ovid must have decided to compose Fasti 5 as a book dominated by ideas of rise and increase, thus slyly suggesting a fourth etymology after the triad explored in the proemium: as the month develops, May is being derived not from 'maiestas', 'maiores' ('elders'), or Maia, but simply from 'mains' (bigger), Carole Newlands must be right that the theme of growth links Orion with Mars Ultor, and perhaps astronomy is a further link,19 but one wonders why continuity of imagery should be automatically linked to subversive irony. The entire episode is bracketed by a reference to Orion facing the Scorpion (5, 537-43) (they are 'frozen in the chase before they could do one another any damage, and become constellations in that position for ever'),20 and by a final reference to Games held for Mars in the Circus (5. 597-8). Ovid points out that the Games are not theatrical because Mars is not just the average god, ready for an honorific stage festival ('non visa est fortern scaena decere deum'). They were therefore held in the Circus. The location is confirmed by inscriptional calendars, and by Dio Cassius (56. 27, 4), who, interestingly, mentions horse races and a wild beast hunt.21 Is Orion, the gigantic hunter facing the monster Scorpio, a celestial precursor of those wild animal shows? If we accept that the continuity of the text enhances the domination of Mars over Rome, however, we should also account for the unreconciled lament of the bloody ghost of Remus (5. 457: 'umbra cruenta Remi'). In fact his bitter question (5, 465: 'heti, ubi Mars pater est? si 111 See Gee in this volume, quoting arid discussing Newlands; and Hannah (IIW7) on the transition between the absence of Orion, the 'descent' of Mars, and the topography of the Augustan forum. *' Gee in this volume (p. 51). 21 For the evidence see Hannah (1997) 528.
14
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
vos modo vera locuti...', 'oh where is my father Mars? unless what you said is false ..,') cannot be easily papered over, since this is the episode that precedes directly the Martial career of the giant Orion, and the text of the poem does not offer secure boundaries between the various thematic units.22 To come back to the effect of 'intertextuality' suggested by Scheid: I think we can enhance it even more. When we recognize Ennius' Romulus and Virgil's Aeneas in Octavian's utterance at Philippi, we should not forget that we are not only 'reading* a text but also a monument. All the actors in the triangulations of poetic intertextuality are also physically 'there', represented in the figurative programme of the Forum: Mars, Augustus, Romulus, and Aeneas, If Mars, the viewer, is looking (from the pediment? where 'he', his image, dominates the Forum) to Augustus, the victor on his quadriga in the middle of the square, then the viewer, and model reader of Ovid's text, will also learn very quickly to glance sideways: and she will discover, on the two sides of the Forum, a Romulus and an Aeneas, united by a second axis,23 perpendicular to the main axis that runs between Mars and Augustus (see Fig. 1). Poetic intertextuality recapitulates and substitutes the architectural meaning created by the intersection of perspectives. Ovid's re-creation of the monument is also the construction of a viewing subject, someone who knows how to construct visual meanings. But, once again, if we identify this exegesis as 'orthodox', exemplary, shared, we minimize the poet's contribution. On the one hand, the narrative on Philippi may be seen as completing the visual impact of die monument: Ovid's Callimachean poetry provides an aetiology for the real thing, a Caesaris ultor for the Mars Ultor complex. The question, on. the other hand, is whether this aetiology is explicitly required by the figurative programme. It could be at least as reasonable to insist that Mars Ultor is a giant signifier of removal: the civil ~"1 The simple life of Faustulus, adoptive father of the twins, is paralleled by the modest lifestyle of Hyrieus, -3 Zaiiker (1068) and (1S)8S)) 215-18, For a salutary reminder of how much remains conjectural and uncertain see la Rocca (2001); on the fascination and danger in Zanker's reconstruction, itself based on Ovid's text, and on its influence on a, scholarship that seems unaware of the limits of material evidence, -see the provocative comments in Beard and Henderson (2001),
MARS ULTOR IN THE FORUM AUGUSTUM
15
wars are conspicuously absent from the complex of images, and only a statue of Julius Caesar in the cella could serve as a reminder of Octavian's revenge; triumph ideology, the Parthian revenge, and the continuity of Roman military history from Aeneas and Romulus to Augustus, all contribute to the shared representation of Mars Ultor as the link between the Roman army and the prince as a triumphal leader and protector against foreign opposition; all contribute to efface or perhaps to 'trope* the memory of fratricide, set in a recent past. The architectural opposition between external and internal could be read as a key to the relationship between past and present. (Again, Augustan discourse is not something 'simple and straightforward' as opposed to the poet's monopoly of tensions, innuendoes, ambiguity, and rhetorical flexibility.) This is how recent interpreters imagine the rhetoric of the civil wars in the figurative programme: Putnam (1995: 8 n. 7): Tor Augustus the monumentalizing of revenge in the temple of Mars Ultor may have marked a sense of stabilization, a victory over revenge that publicizes it while at the same time announcing its demise'; Cresci Marrone (1993: 171): 'regular triumphal tradition commanded a vow before the battle and a dedication ex manubiis as a closure, but private ultio does not fit the princeps any more ... so private ultio and civil conflict are camouflaged by a foreign ultio'. Yet of course we cannot really conjecture, without having fully excavated a monument so complex, rich in iconography, and also in writing, how many visual and verbal messages may have been available for a more or less direct 'civil war' interpretation. Absence of evidence is not evidence for absence. What is important is that both the programme of the monument and the programme of the Fasti partake in a discussion which is about the collective past, a discussion which alternates between the concepts of dementia and revenge. CMmentia, and revenge are 'strategies for overcoming the past, the first by forgetting, the second by undoing: the first sees repetition of the past as regressive, the second sees in such repetition the possibility of mastery ... the poem, like the regime, has it both ways, but in the process it discloses the contradictions in the regime's ideology: its promise to pardon and avenge at the same time'. David Quint's important comment on the Aeneid (1993: 78)
l6
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
can be applied to the Fasti as soon as we realize that the poem is an important contribution to Augustan ideology, not just propaganda. We have the same problem with Ovid's re-creation of the Ides of March with which this paper began (Fasti 3. 699-710). Memoiy of Caesar's assassination is doubtless important for the 'Augustan' meaning of the day; but when Ovid mentions the plain of Philippi strewn with whitening bones, I arn not sure that this is simply an official exegesis of the calendar. True, we have seen that images of civil strife are not extraneous to the ideology of the Principate: the Danaid myth at Apollo Palatinus—the very vision which stimulates Aeneas to kill the suppliant Turnus—could be relevant here. But Ovid connects Octavian's revenge with the two most unpleasant aspects of the tradition of Philippi: all prisoners put to the sword, and no proper burial even for the Roman aristocrats. This is the (disturbing) image that the calendrical poet inscribes in Ms version of the Ides of March, to be re-performed every year. This rotating image of revenge helps Ovid's readers to understand the new ideology of the Principate, one that juggles dementia and ultio, but this is only the visible part of its strategy of selective oblivion. The post-traumatic repetition of Philippi is not a neutral exercise if one remembers alternative reconstructions where Antony would have been the protagonist, not Octavian. However shocking the focus on the killing fields may be, it directs our attention away from the problem of who exactly won that battle. Fifty years after the event, in hindsight, Augustus could be less bloodthirsty and more ecumenical24 (and say something like 'The time of universal peace is near'). But the main problem remains that we are not reading an autonomous poem on Mars Ultor, but a section from a continuous poetic text. Scholars eager to reconstruct a holistic meaning for a monument are sometimes less worried when they extract a poetic segment from a context, to use it as a commentary on their monument. But Ovid's readers—like Mars Ultor's viewersneed to have a knowing eye. Mars, the dedicatee and focalizer ~* Even fifty years later the language of 'fuso ... ab hoste' (5. 578) is not tactful, as it lays bare the problem of representing Philippi as a mstum bettttm.
MARS ULTOR IN THE FORUM AUGUSTUM
17
in the description of this temple, is also a poetic problem in the Fasti: a difficult god to approach for a poem of peaceful elegiacs,2-5 The poet's voice measures its distance from the epic war god in the address which opens Book 3 of the Fasti: Bellice, depositis clipeo paulisper et hasta Mars ad.es et oitidas casside solve comas. Warlike Mars, put down your shield and spear awhile, remove your helmet from your shiny hair, and. be with me.
Ovid was trying a compromise with the god of March: Mars ades, and put down your arms. This is echoed in May (or is it vice versa?) when the emperor prays '"Mars ades, and bring about a bloodbath.' If we take the fabric of the text by those two extremes, the compromise between the poet and the prince splits apart. Romulus may carry the spolia opima, and Aeneas the burden of Anchises, but in the end it is Remus and Turnus that matter the most to the construction of Roman history. The visual intertextuality that ties Octavian to Romulus celebrating a triumph, and to Aeneas rescuing Anchises, is an effective reading of the texture of images and space created by the Augustan temple, and this is the symmetric arrangement that Mars teaches us to enact in the Forum, looking askance to see Aeneas the pious (5. 563): hinc videt Aenean oneratum pondere caro
and Romulus the military leader (5. 565): hinc videt Iliaden unieris ducis arma ferenlem.
The verbal repetition 'hinc videt . . . hinc videt' is a telling commentary on the sense of political authority created by the geometrical sightlines in the new Forum.26 Yet the events involved in the poetic intertextuality—killing a brother to found a city, killing a suppliant to start an empire—pose a problem for many viewers of Mars Ultor if they try to use Ovid's text as a help towards a shared and communal reading of the architectural complex. The Ovidian synthesis confronts head-on traditional w
Sec Hinds (1<»2). * On the possibility that those two statues were highlighted not only by their pos }sitiotiiug but also by au oversize effect, see Flower (1S)96) 234, 7
l8
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
Republican ideas about the ideal leader, the one who stops internal strife and triumphs over foreign enemies: the story of Augustus is about civil bloodshed and bloodless triumph over the Parthians. This is related to the main argument that I was trying to develop in my book The Poet and the Prince, that reading Ovid's poem in historical context does not equal reading it only as conformistic. However much we disagree on individual readings, and on the role of audience response, my work converges with Herbert-Brown (1994) in reading the Fasti as an important text about what it feels like to be a Roman in the Augustan age, and in not accepting the usual disparagement of the Fasti as a frivolous exercise in rococo Hellenism. This volume will further the discussion in many ways. I just need to add that precisely when we try to make the text more serious and respectable in order to reconstruct a political context, we should not forget how swiftly the register can change. Students of Augustan ideology are happy to refer to the lines about Augustus' Parthian triumph that close the Mars Ultor entry as an example of straightforward propaganda (5. 593): Parthe, refers acjuilas, victos quoque ponigis arcus! you return the eagles and also surrender, Parthian, your vanquished bows,
and it is nice that at least one official image, a coin of 16 BC, shows a triumphal monument with a Parthian holding both a bow and a legionary eagle and submitting to Augustus.27 The figure of the Parthian was probably an addition to the triple triumphal arch offered to Augustus after Actium ('the main sculptural additions were doubtless figures of Parthians offering standards above the side-arches, as shown on the coins'},'* The arch was a revolutionary monument, the first monument of that kind set up at Rome by public decree, and this is precisely the time when the elevated vocable arcus supplants the more prosaic Republican fornix.la If the Parthian in Ovid is the Parthian as seen in a refurbished, or brand new, Triumphal '"' See B&KRK 77. On the iconography ol" the kneeling Barbarian see the important study of Schneider (15)86). 28 Rich (1998) JQ9; cf. his reproductions of the coins at 99. 29 See Wallace-Hadrill (1990*) and Rich (1998) 114,
MARS ULTOR IN THE FORUM AUGUSTUM
1Q
Arch, the text comments on the monument by disclosing a self-reflective quality, a visual-verbal pun that complements the image management of the emperor: 'Parthe, porrigis arcus* 'you offer to the emperor the Arch/Bow'. It is also important not to restrict our questionnaire to the polarity between consensus and subversion. Two significant effects of the Ovidian creation of a 'verbal monument' could easily go unnoticed if we simply look for propaganda or opposition. The first is the idea that Mars Ultor is the symptom of an increasing 'militarization' of urban landscapes and public architecture, a crucial aspect of the discourse of the early Principate. One great innovation of the Forum, the idea that after a prolonged absence Mars has a house in central Rome now, is accordingly a main focus of Ovid's guided tour. The second is that the emphasis on military power is embedded not only in the textual strategy of the Fasti, but also in the lifestyle of" a generational elite group which is de facto excluded, for the first time in Roman history, from direct and even indirect participation in the military. The estrangement of the poet is not just about Augustus, it is about Mars. Mars is absent in the Aeneid as a divine character because he melts directly into the military action of the poem, and because his figure is loaded with contemporary anxieties; Mars had been on the side of Augustus' just revenge in Philippi but there is also the alternative view that, as a god of violence and a patron god of Thessaly, he is turning the Roman civil wars into pleasure and spectacle in his favourite theatre of operations. Even more primary and insoluble is the duplicity that Mars represents for every soldier: the god inspires the fighting spirit that guarantees victory and, most importantly, survival, then steps aside and allows humans to contemplate war as it were from the outside. In other words, Ovidian ambiguities about Mars as the Augustan war and civil war god cannot be easily separated from collective ambiguities about Mars as the god, who controls the transition from peace to violence, and back. The Aeneid had sought to reorder this useful ambiguity through a striking reinvention of the war ritual: the war in Latium already needs the Gates of War, the institution that activates 'regular' war in. the 'Republican' tradition (i.e. the one
2O
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
that Augustus had reinvented)—yet in the narrative the mos is completely perverted by Juno, and Mars is only present in the 'regular' mos through a striking acrostic.3' By smashing open the Gates, Juno had authorized the war in the Aeneid as an exception to the kind of war that Rome will use institutionally, yet of course this is the war that will make possible the invention of Rome. So the ambiguity is represented but also controlled, just as the temple of Janus in Aeneid 1. 293-6 has control over Furor Impius in chains. The image can be seen both as propaganda for Imperial peace and as a talisman, the former because victory is a triumph achieved through war and over war, the latter because of the Spartan tradition of keeping an image of Enyalios in chains (Pans. 3. 5. 7): a prisoner harmless to the community but ready to be unleashed against the enemy. The Ovidian representation, of Mars Ultor is a response to the Imperial politics of supplementing the Aeneid through a monument: the Ovidian Mars is a Virgilian 'missing god' recuperated by Augustus, and the reception of the monument cannot get rid of all the ambiguities entailed by this recuperation. If Servius is right, the image that lies beneath the Furor of Aeneid I can be safely identified with a painting that was visible to all visitors to the Forum Augustum, a triumph of Alexander that included fiellurn, hands tied behind, and Furor sitting over arms, all tied up31 (Virg. Am, I. 294-6):' claudentur Belli portae: Furor Irapfas intus saeva sedens super arroa et centum vinctus aenis post tergum nodis fremot horridus ore cruento, the Gates of War will be closed. The accursed Rage, inside, sitting on a heap of savage arms, hands tied behind by a hundred bronze knots, will roar, frightening, with his gory mouth.
This was situated to your left as you pass the main entrance, we are told. A visual supplement toJupiter's promise in the Aeneid, one might add. By the year 2 BC, the visitors to the new Forum were probably familiar enough with the Aeneid to realize that the prestigious image (by Apelles!) had been relocated, not from another sacred space in Rome, but from the Virgilian text itself, and from the Greek culture that had influenced 30
Fowler (MJ.H3).
31
Stewart (1993) 28 and 33.
MARS ULTOR IN THE FORUM AUGUSTUM
21
it. This painting was probably a spoil from Alexandria, and that adds a nice complexity, later destroyed by Claudius' decision to substitute the face of Augustus for the face of Alexander. The Augustan image now represents the original victory of Alexander over war plus the victory of Octavian over Alexander's memorial metropolis—a double triumph over war, except that this Roman victory is also inextricable from a memory of civil wars. In the new location, the heaps of arms on which Furor is sitting could have directed attention to the arms reproduced on the closed doors of the temple of Mars, and vice versa (5. 561-2). When the language of images achieves this level of complexity and irony, it will not do to juxtapose 'power of images' to poetic allusion and to imply that one is a circulation of straightforward propaganda, the other a texture of innuendo and irony. The containment image in Virgil's prophecy was complemented by the material inclusion of the image within the Belli Portae: the relocation of the painting in the Forum Augustum creates a shift in the reference. Furor Impius is now regulated not by the 'traditional' institution of the Belli Portae, but by the new blend of triumphal ideology and Julian monopoly that dominates the Forum.32 The Julian' rereading of Roman history that Jupiter had offered to Venus in book 1 of the Aeneid is now the master plan of the Forum. The triumphal ideology that dominates the complex lends a new significance to Alexander's triumph in the painting. Since every new triumph will belong to the emperor and to the family, it makes eminent sense that the Greek/Eastern triumph of Alexander is being recontextualized with the decisive help of Virgil It is up to individual readers to decide whether the representation of the monument in the Fasti is complementing the Augustan programme or bringing it to breaking point. The verbalization of the monument scores the self-serving point that poetry is needed even when monuments are able to speak volumes: because only the poetic aetiology can spell out in the form of narrative the re-enactment/atonement of the 3
~ Ou the Forum complex as 'the public atrium of the Juiii* see Flower (liftM)) 226 (her entire book bears witness to the force of this metaphor). See also the breakthrough discussion in Rowell( 1940) 141.
22
ALESSANDRO BARCHIESI
civil wars that is implicated in the Mars Ultor complex as well as in Augustan ideology. (The importance of narrative and diachrony was at least in part a legacy of the strikingly parallel evolution of Apollo Palatinus: a monument vowed and projected in the civil war atmosphere of the Naulochus years, inaugurated and received as a memorial of Actium and Alexandria, The generation of Propertius had learned how to deal with the metamorphosis of civil war into 'Eastern' triumph (i.e. Cleopatra more than Antony), precisely when confronting the monument for Apollo; Ovid capitalizes on this experience, and narrates—over a much longer time gap—the metamorphosis of civil war into Eastern 'triumph'.) But then poetry is also able to defer the closural stabilization suggested by Augustan ideology, and teaches readers of the monument to beware of the Avenger exactly when they accept his martial protection. In so doing they were accepting the challenge offered by the Princeps himself: he had declared in an edict, almost a priere d'inserer for the monument, that the statues in the galleries had been set up 'so that both he, while he lived, and the principes of future ages should be evaluated by the citizens according to the standards fixed by the lives of those men' (Suet. Aug. 31. 5). We do not. know whether the memorial proudly placed at the centre of the new Forum was an image of Augustus riding a chariot, or even an empty chariot (a revolutionary choice for a Roman monument and a striking signifier of modesty and superMa), a riderless chariot with a mise en abyme of Augustus as a triumphal chariot-driver as a bas-relief on the chariot itself.33 Either of these possible choices would have created a vertical link with the image of Jupiter Capitolinus on the apex of his temple, while the arrangement of the new Forum guaranteed a horizontal alignment with Romulus and Aeneas. In any case, Ovid's readers have to decide which image of Aeneas and which image of Romulus are most helpful in imagining or inteipreting the contours of the absent-present driver of this dynamic memorial.34 They are still arguing as I write. .M por j^jjj possibility see Rich (1998) 123-5; compare the amount of viewercooperation required by the absence of a straightforward personification of Peace on the Ara Pads in Settis, Kalatog Berlin (1.988), 423-4. •M I thank Emma Oce, Ann Kuttner, Maud Reydellet, and the editor, for comments. Now mdi, Spanuagel (1999), an important study of the art of revenge in the forum.
2 The Fasti as a Source for Women's Participation in Roman Cult ELAINE FANTHAM
In the (g)olden days of the early nineteenth century, scholars turned to Ovid's Fasti as a precious source for Roman cult and religious practice: it was the primary source for W, Warde Fowler's great Roman Feslivak of the Period of the Republic (1899) and naturally attracted the anthropological learning of SirJames Frazer, who went on to his monumental edition after his commentaries on the Greeks Pausanias and Apollodorus.1 It is ironic that their learning has since made it easier for more sceptical generations to look at Ovid's great poem less as evidence than as rhetoric, whether operating as panegyric or subversion. But is Ovid so worthless as evidence for Roman cult practice? He was neither uninterested nor uninformed. We can even deduce whose calendar researches he consulted: those of Verrius Flaccus, former tutor to the imperial princes Gaius and Lucius Caesar. This can be confirmed directly from the remains of the inscribed public calendar composed by Verrius for his home city of Praeneste, and from excerpts on calendar topics preserved in Pompeius Festus' abridgement of Verrius' lost De Verborum Signifaatu.The problem is more one of Ovid's purposes in composing the poem, both literary and ideological. Certainly Ovid did not write his calendar poem in order to remind Roman readers, still less to instruct posterity, about the duties and ' Frazer began his classical commentaries with Pausanias (1898), then the Loeb Classical Library Apollodorus (1921), then the five volumes of Fasti in 1929. 2 On Verrius* calendar sec references cited in this author's Ovid: Fasti Book IV
(mm'j 29-30.
24
ELAINE FANTHAM
privileges of participation in different cults. With rare exceptions like the women's cult of Bona Dea, Ovid's readers knew what laymen and priests were expected to do on feast days or temple anniversaries.3 Nor, of course, did he set out to provide a representative portrait of specifically female participation in cult. Women's rites find their way into the Fasti because they are good elegiac material, offering colourful or emotionally appealing vignettes. As an imaginative and erudite poet Ovid aimed to enrich the essential calendar structure with aetiological legends from Greek myth and Roman prehistory, diversifying his text with the rising and setting of constellations, and evoking ceremonies through picturesque details. From a more 'political' point of view he also aimed, I believe, to please (or appease?) Augustus by honouring the new Imperial and dynastic anniversaries and assimilating them into the traditional Republican calendar. Indeed it is debatable whether the dead Callimachus4 or the living and later deified Augustus was more present as a source of authority to the poet engaged in his partly aetiological and partly encomiastic elegiac poem, Thus what can be learned about the role of laymen, let alone laywomen, in contemporary cult is incidental to Ovid's purpose. Readers will best judge his reliability on women's participation in Roman cults by comparing the passages discussed in this chapter with information about women's religious activities in comprehensive studies like the new history and sourcebook, Religions of Rome (1998), or John Scheid's authoritative chapter on 'The Religious Roles of Roman Women'.5 Ovid's first reference to any woman in Fasti comes on the Carmentalia of 11 January with his pious prophecy of the future godhead of Augusta Julia.6 'Who?' you may ask. Certainly not the first Julia, daughter of Augustus, publicly damned and exiled in 2 uc. Let me provide another clue; the same Augusta J
On this cult see most recently Staples (199ft) 11 -54. Fen: the influence of Callimachus in the Fasti tite discussion in Fantham (1998) 7-18 owes much to Miller (1982) 371-417; set- also Miller (1991) 7-19, •' Beard, North, Price (1998). Scheid (1992*) 377-408. For a more general investigation of Ovid's credibility a,<s a source for religion see Schilling (1968) 9-24. c> Fasli 1. 536: 'sic Augusta novuin lulia uuineti erit'. 4
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
25
appears again on 16 January, as 'tua genetrix' and restorer of the altar of Concordia,7 This is Livia herself, adopted in Augustus' will as Julia Augusta, so both passages originate in Ovid's remodelling after AD 14. Livia of course was unique, and no other Augustan lady, not even Augustas' sister Octavia, who shared her extraordinary religious status as 'sacrosanct',8 had any prospect either of becoming a deity or of dedicating an altar. Just as Ovid himself returns to Livia Augusta towards the end of the extant poem, so this discussion will need to return at the end to the woman extraordinary, Livia, and her contribution to Roman cult. Perhaps these two honorific references are sufficient to explain why Ovid does not again mention Livia on 30January, her own birthday, and the commemorative anniversary of the Ara Pads Augustae. Instead he follows his brief tribute to the altar by turning" to the deity Pax herself: at the imagined moment of sacrifice he addresses her priests with a request that they ask the favourable gods for the perpetuation of both Peace and the imperial dynasty: (1. 721): ' u t , . . domus quae praestat earn cum pace perennet'. Where Ovid is silent, however, we can turn to one of Rome's best-preserved monuments to see Livia with other women of the imperial family in the procession of dedication depicted on either of the long sides of the Ara Pacis: there, Livia,9 Augustas' sister Octavia,10 his married daughterJulia," and his ' 1. 649: 'hanc tua constituit genetrix et rebus etara'. In this revised section of Book 1, Ovid's addressee is Germanicus, Livia's grandson, adopted by her son and his uncle Tiberius to be joint heir with Tiberius' natural son Drusus. Appropriately, the most recent authorities to cite I jvia's interest in Concordia. are women: Flory (1984) and Herbert-Brown (1JW4) ch. 4, esp. 162-7. Both treatments build on Levick (1078). * On their early elevation to sacrosanctity in 36 tic:, and Livia's subsequent preeminence in Roman secular and religious life, see Purcell (1986), 9 Livia is surely the woman wearing a laurel wreath over her head, veiled like that of Augustus, perhaps because of her role as 'regina sacrorum'. She follows Agrippa and the 'flamioes* on the relief of the right long waif; see Simon (1SM>8} 16 and pi. 13. For other, more controversial identilications, see following notes. 19 Simon (1968) 21, ps. 15 suggests that the matronly woman on the left long wall could be Octavia, u Simon (1!)68) 21 (ps, 17, 1, ID, I) identifies as Julia the 'heavily veiled young woman ... wearing a thin diaphanous veil through which the folds of her garment are visible*, in the procession of the left long wall. She is wearing the widow's fringed garment, the 'ricinium', but the figure is damaged, and faceless, so Simon bases her deduction on the figure's position in the procession. By an ironic twist her figure has
26
ELAINE FANTHAM
daughter-in-law, Antonia Minor,12 proceed with their children to make offerings in thanks for the Augustan peace at the altar's dedication in 9 BC, just as Horace describes them in Odes 3. 14.3-12: Caesar Hispana repetlt penates victor ab ora. unico gaudens mulier niarito prodeat iustis operata sacris et soror clari duds et decorae supplice vitta iarn virginum mates, iuvenumque nuper sospitum. vos o pueri et puellae iam virum expertae, male nominatis parcite verbis, Caesar is returning to his household gods as victor from the Spanish shore. Let his wife, rejoicing in her exceptional husband come forth, after performing the due rites, with the sister of the glorious leader and adorned with suppliant headband the mothers of maidens and the young men newly restored. As for you, boys and girls innocent of a man, avoid ill-named [or 'ill-omened': the text is contested] words.
But these women of the imperial family are still laypersons, 'profani', and would normally be expected, to stop short of either altars or temples at a moment of public sacrifice. Apart from Livia13 none of them is 'iustis operata sacris': like the boys and girls, their contribution to the cult occasions will have been only to abstain from words of ill omen, and any sacrifices they have made will be private and domestic.14 It is rather their male kinsmen, many of them augurs, priests, been replaced in plaster on the Altar itself, but the original has found its way to the Louvre, (I like to think of Julia escaping from the dynasty to end up in Paris,} 12 Simon (1968} 19 and pi. 15 notes that the figures behind Livia and Tiberius on the right long wall have been generally identified as Dnisus and his wife Antonia Minor. ^ If she is *opefata' it will he in her special capacity as 'regina sacroruni*, who is known to have performed sacrifices on the Kalends oi each month, 14 To quote Beard, North, Price (1998) i, 297; 'In general, however, although the eiMsndMnce \$i(\ of women at most religious occasions (including ludi] was not prohibited, they had little opportunity to take any active religious role hi stale cute . . . niuch more fundamentally (although the evidence is not entirely clear) they may have been banned... from carrying out animal sacrifice; and so prohibited from any officiating role in llw central defining ritual of civic religious activity.1 On the ancient tradition excluding women from blood sacrifice, see de Cazenove (1987),
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
2J
15
and flamines, who would be officiating. Certainly women were encouraged to supplicate the gods, and to give them thanks—also referred to by the same word 'supplicatio'. The married women of the Roman elite were even authorized after the Gallic sack of Rome in 390 to ride to the temples in thanksgiving in their special covered wagons (carpenta, pilenta). This is how Vulcan in Aeneid 8 depicts the ladies on the shield of Aeneas, riding in their wagons arnid the rejoicing Salii after the Gauls had been driven off in defeat.1'1 In the alarms and triumphs of the Hannibalic War the Senate decreed on several occasions that women and children should go together in procession as suppliants or in thanksgiving. But their participation in thanksgiving can be and often is taken for granted by ancient writers. We more often hear of such processions—found also in the heroic world of Homer—in times of emergency when supplication is a desperate appeal: thus Virgil describes the Latin women, led by Queen Amata and her daughter Lavinia, riding to supplicate the goddess Athena to restore her favour and victory, just as Hecuba and the Trojan women had supplicated in Iliad 6, This is so typical of women's role in cult that the only scene in which women are represented on the reliefs of Dido's temple in Aeneid 1 is the Homeric supplication of Hecuba and the women to Athena.17 When the women supplicated, it was, of course, for the whole community, not just for themselves, and we should also imagine their private devotions as being made on behalf of their whole household, rather than just their personal needs. The ordinary woman seems to have been free to visit temples privately to make a personal offering of incensew or flowers, even if Ovid in another less devout poem ironically 1/1 Simon (1968) 18 distinguishes Livia, perhaps in the role as 'regitia sacrorum' (the altar was even dedicated on her birthday), together with Augustus, Agrippa, and the flamines from 'the latter part of the procession, which also includes women and children*. She suggests that, this, like the procession of the opposite wall, is of a less official nature, "' Aen. 8. 66,5-6: 'castae ducebant sacra per urbem pifentis mattes in mollibus'. '' See Aen. 1. 479-82 (the relief showing Trojan suppliants) and II. 477-82 for the Latin queen riding to the temple escorted by the matrons 'nee mm ad tumplum surnrnasque ad Palladia arces I subvehitur magria matrum regina catcrva dona ferens.,, succedunt matres et lemptuin lure vaporaut | et maestas alto fimduut de limine voces.* " Cf. Aen. II. 481 quoted n. 17 above,
28
ELAINE FANTHAM
suggests to Augustus (Tristia 2, 287-300) that visits to the temples of Venus or Jupiter Optimus Maximus or Mars Ultor, or even the virgin Pallas, might provoke respectable matrons with dangerous or envious thoughts about the mythical sexual adventures of the gods. But when women's role in public religion at Rome is raised for discussion we probably think first of the special category of the Vestals, those six selected women of noble birth who were taken up before puberty (usually aged 10) to give thirty years of service to the virgin goddess of generation and the hearth: they naturally feature at Ovid's celebration of the Vestalia,19 but he also mentions their ritual acts at the Fordicidia, when the chief Vestal burned the embryos of the sacrificial pregnant heifers, and six days later, when the people celebrated the Parilia with a compound based on. the ash from, these embryos.a" But Vestals lie outside the limited religious role of ordinaiy women. Their special status as neither wife nor maiden, female nor male, has received two full scholarly treatments in recent years.21 The calendar brings Ovid to some of the most important aspects of religion in women's lives in the books of February and March, Books 2 and 3. I am talking about marriage, chastity, fertility, and childbirth. Chastity naturally appealed less to Ovid than the positive aspects of sexuality. But he gives prominence, like his older contemporary Livy, to the great Roman foundation myth of chastity, the voluntary suicide of the raped victim Lucretia.22 Lucretia's vindication of her honour supposedly caused the fall of the monarchy and origin of the Republic, just as the chastity of another woman, the girl Virginia, caused the revolution that ended the powers of the Decemviri in the fifth century. Livy is also the primary source for the original patrician cult of Pudicitia, chastity, or better fidelity in marriage, attested from the early Republic, and the >y On !) June Ovid explains Vesia's choice of virgin attendants because of her own choice of virginity in 6. 283-90. M For the Fordicidia. see Fasti 4. 629-4-0; Ovid's commemoration of the Parilia mentions Vesta rather than her human ministers, the Vestals: 4. 725-34. 21 See Beard 1980, 1995. Staples (1!)96) 129-56 does not really advance beyond Beard. 22 Fasti'2, 721-852. But Lucretta's last words (82.5-30) omit her mural message to the women of Rome as celebrated by Livy 1. 59: 'no woman henceforth will be immoral hecaase of my ex*t0ip!0**.
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
5>Q
foundation of a rival cult of Pudicitia Plebeia in the late fourth century.23 But fertility was even more vital to society and to the woman's self-respect than fidelity. In his account of the festival of the Lupercalia in February Ovid turns to the Roman bride who wants to become pregnant, urging her to welcome the fertile blows from the goatskin whips of the Luperci, and so gratify her father-in-law.24 The poet's account of the origin of this practice conveys the urgent need for fertility in those days of heavy infant mortality. According to his aetiology, after Romulus had procured wives for his Romans by the rape of the Sabines he found that there was still a dearth of pregnancies, so he sent husbands and wives to the sacred grove of Juno on the Esquiline.25 There husbands and wives alike prayed to the goddess and her voice was heard to order with oracular ambiguity 'Italidas matres sacer hircus inito' ('let the sacred he-goat penetrate the Italian mothers'). The suppliants were naturally shocked, until an augur, guessing the riddle, slew and skinned a he-goat so that women could offer their backs to be lashed with strips of its hide: as Ovid tells it, in ten lunar months the 'vir' and 'nupta' of 437 became a father and mother (2. 445-8): ille cuprum mactat; iussae sua terga puellae pellibus exsectis percutienda dabant. luna resumebat decimo nova cornua rnotu, virque pater subito nuptaque mater erat.
K> See Livy 10. 23. Virginia, daughter of a patrician, had married a, plebeian and was excluded from the patrician cult ol Pudicitia. She retaliated by founding her own cult of 'Pudicitia Plebeia*. However, as we will see below, there is good reason to identify the cult of Fortmia discussed by Ovid in Fasti 6. 561) f. (the 'Aedes Forlunae in foro Boario') with 'Fortuna Virgo', also identified with the original 'Pudicitia Patricia*. 24 2, 427-8: 'excipe fecundae patienter verbera dextrae, | iam socer optaturn nomen babe-bit avi*. Women are usually seen in terms of male interests; when a man has no sons, he must hope that his daughter will, give him a grandson. As for his daughter-inlaw, unless she conies from an important family with whuni a political bond is desired, she has no other function. '^ 2, 4-25—52. Mote that concern for fertility is used as a,n alternative fiiiion for the feast ol" Carmenla in L 619-3b. According to this talc- the matrons were so angry when deprived of the use of their padded vehicles (an etymological pun on Carmenta/Carpenta) that they refused to carry their babies full term (i.e. aborted them}-. So the Senate restored their privilege and instituted two rites, one for boys and one for girls, to Carmetila and the midwife goddesses Porrima and Postverta.
go
ELAINE FANTHAM
He ends his account with a choice of etymologies for Juno Lucina, protectress of childbirth, either because she was goddess of the 'lucus' or because she controlled the child's first experience of the light ('lucis').28 This tale of barrenness must surely be Ovid's own fiction. Certainly from at least the time of Ennius* historical drama The Sabine Women, the legend was canonical at Rome that when the parents of the Sabine women 'raped' by Romulus attacked Rome in retaliation, the new brides rushed onto the battlefield clutching their babies to stop the fighting between their fathers and husbands: and Ovid himself had exploited the tale in An Amatoria, 1. 101-32. The women's infertility cannot be reconciled with their legendary role as intercessors, yet Ovid has woven the battlefield reconciliation scene into his double celebration, of 1 March, when the anniversary of the dedication of Lucina's temple coincides with the Matronalia. March was the month of Mars and Ovid opens the book by addressing the god and retelling the story of his son Romulus. He passes from the god's rape of Silvia and fathering of Romulus and Remus, to their adolescence and Romulus' establishment of the Roman calendar, in which he made his divine father patron of the first month. All this is leading up to a puzzle based on a paradox: 'since you are so fitted to manly activities', Ovid asks the god, 'why do the married women observe your feast day?' (3, 169-70): cum sis officiis, Gradive, virilibus aptus, die mihi matronae cur lua festa colant.
Unfortunately for our concerns, although Mars offers a full and vivid narrative of both the rape and the reconciliation—neither of which were supposed to have occurred on 1 Marchhe adds nothing to the understanding of women's rites at the Matronalia. Instead, the god's speech offers both rape and reconciliation as unlikely explanations for the women's celebration: 'The wives of Italy have no frivolous duty in celebrating my Kalends, either because they terminated the wars of Mars by their tears, or in thanks for Ilia's successful -'' Forjuno Lucina and her connection with the moon, see Plutarch, Roman Questitms 77, which may also derive from the learning of Ovid's chief source, Verrius Flaccus.
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
31
motherhood.' Through a hymn to the fertility of spring, season of their service as childbearers,27 Ovid glides back to Lucina, and the anniversary of her temple at the site of the Esquiline grove. The women should bring her flowers and pray for ease in labour. As a nice instance of the merging of religion and magic he adds an injunction: if any woman is already pregnant when she prays to Lucina, she should unbind her hair so as to release her child with ease.28 How literally can Ovid's language be interpreted? He claims that Lucina's temple was dedicated (or given to the people) by the Latin 'daughters-in-law': 'a nuribus lunoni templa Latinis | hac sunt... publica facta die' (3. 247-8). But there were strict controls in Rome of the historical period over who could vow or dedicate a temple—it required official authorization from the Senate—and very few instances of any woman being associated with this honour.*" And when are they supposed to have done this? The poet has already reported the new mothers assembling in this temple ('conveniunt nuptae dictam lunonis in aedem': 3. 205) before the battle in the year after their rape. The tale is neatly told, but it is no use looking to Ovid for a historical record. We have seen that Ovid tends to pass over what women actually do on public festivals, but he does describe a women's custom on the Ides of March at the popular festival of Anna Perenna—a goddess associated with the renewal of the year. At this early spring festival couples went picnicking at Anna's shrine by the Tiber setting up tents, dancing, singing songs ^ 3, 243—4; 'Ternpora itirts coiuni Laiiae lucunda parentes | cruarurn niiMtiam votaque partus hahet', formally answers 170 'cur tua festa, colant?' hut glosses several questions. Spring is fertile, but not necessarily Ihe human breeding season. On the other hand it is a fair analogy to present childbirth as woman's 'militia'> national service, and so time for the making and fulfilment of vows: one is reminded of Medea's boast in Euripides that she would rather fight three times in battle line than bear one child, "^ 3, 255—8: 'dicite "tu uobis lucetn, Lueina, dedistT': [ ditlie "iu votu parturientis ades." | siqua tamen gravida est, resolute crine precetur ut solvat partus molltter ilia suos'. Unbinding was normal before attempting to perform prayers and spells. For the negative corollary—deliberate binding to delay an enemy's childbirth—compare the gesture of Juno crossing her arms to hold back the birth of Hercules in Alemene's tale of her labour at Met. 9. 281-315. ^ See below for the legendary dedication by women of the temple of Fortuna Publica in the 5th cent.
32
ELAINE FANTHAM
from the theatre, and praying for long years as they drink abundantly (3. 523-40). All this sounds more like a party than a cult act, but the poet adds that he should explain (3. 675-6): 'cur cantent... obscena puellae ... | . . . certaque probra' ('why girls sing dirty songs and traditional abuse'). This is his pretext to tell a comic tale about old Anna's deception and frustration of the lecherous Mars, but there is surely something more specific here than the general partying; there must have been some kind of fescennine song, mocking men and wishing or forecasting the frustration of misplaced lust. More than that we cannot say.3" Since the month of April is so rich in festivals of goddesses— for Venus (Veneralia, 1 April, and Vinalia, 23 April), for Cybele (4-10 April), and for Ceres (12-19 April), there is rather more evidence for women's cult activities in Ovid's fourth book. Ovid gives the fullest attention to the major festivals of Cybele and Ceres, each including" public games which both men and women attended. He opens his account of Cybele's festival with the goddess's ritual procession and the games in theatre and circus—all part of her public celebrations, but of no specific concern to women. Then he introduces two mythical narratives, for the Greek origin of the cult of Cybele as Rhea when she saved Zeus by deceiving Kronos, and for the Phrygian origin of Attis worship. But the largest part of his attention is given to the coming of the goddess to Rome, as a frame for a miracle performed by the goddess on behalf of a woman. Ovid 's account agrees with that of Livy in many respects. When the Senate formally decreed the invitation to the goddess, it was delivered by a distinguished group of envoys to her shrine at Pessinus in Asia Minor. The temple kingdom gave them an aniconic symbol of the goddess, a meteoric stone, which they escorted on shipboard from the Asian coast to the seaport of Rome at Ostia. But once the ship arrived at Ostia Ovid's and Livy's narratives diverge. According to Livy the elite women of Rome collectively proceeded to Ostia to welcome the sacred symbol of the goddess; it was * See now the chapter on 'The Poet, the Plebs, aud the Chorus Girls' in Wiseman (1998). Cf. Miller (1991) 138; 'the word certa makes it clear that the obscene verses were traditional in a "fixed" form, like other religious formulae'.
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
33
taken from the ship by the most virtuous man in Rome, young Scipio Nasica, and then passed to the matrons, who reverently passed it from hand to hand until it reached the city some ten miles inland,35 But the version Ovid tells is far better known, and was known even before him. Propertius alludes in his last elegy to the miracle of Claudia Quinta pulling the sacred barge: Ovid gives a full narrative in which the sacred ship sticks at the shallow mouth of the Tiber until it is dislodged when Claudia prays to the goddess to vindicate her chastity32 by following her as she towed the barge. This timely miracle was probably a Claudian family legend, and Ovid himself claims that it was staged in the theatre. Peter Wiseman has argued cogently that it was part of a drama regularly offered to the goddess at the theatre games of the Megalesia.33 But near the end of Ovid's more or less historical account of Claudia escorting Cybele to Rome he introduces a diversion for a cult ceremony by the little river Almo, where the image and ritual equipment of Cybele were washed under Claudia's supervision. Ostensibly only the report of what happened on this first occasion, the washing of the goddess, relates awkwardly to what we know of the full ritual in imperial times. By the time of the emperor Claudius, there was a whole long festival of Attis and Cybele held in March, at which amongst other things, the goddess's image was washed in the pure running water of the river. This may well have happened in Ovid's time too; it is not marked in the calendar, but as John Scheid has convinced me, religious acts would not be listed in any calendar unless they were a public responsibility, and such an act by women, and women who were not public priestesses,34 31 See Livy 29. 14, 10-14 and Fantharn (1998) with introductory note on Fasti 4. 255-349 for more detail, J ** Prop. 4. 11.51 -2. Claudia Quinta is a matron in Livy and Ovid, but seems to have been thought of by Propertius, as by several, later sources, as a Vestal virgin {'minislra deae'); for a Vestal the issue would be suspicion, not of adultery, but of *ineest'—any sexual contact at all. 33 See Wiseman (W85) 36; (1979) !»4~1J; (1SWH) 3, 23. ^ Unlikt' the Greek cities Rome had no priestesses for her native cults. Apart from the Greek priestesses of Ceres/Dcrnetcr mentioned below, we know priestesses only of Cybele and Dionysus: the Bacchanalia banned in the, early '2nd cent, had originally been women's rituals conducted by women priests; the scandal arose from the inclusion of men as priests and votaries. But there were women priests of Dionysus like
34
ELAINE FANTHAM
would not be recorded: if this is so, Ovid's only distortion is to report in April a cult act which was normally performed by the women in late March.35 But this is not the only ritual washing ascribed by Ovid to this month. Partly as homage to Augustus, Ovid has made Venus patron of the whole month of April as Venus Genetrix, ancestress of the Julian imperial family. But 1 April is a festival of not one but two Venuses, In the thirty lines that celebrate the religious activities of the day Ovid uses these two rites for different aspects of Venus to frame another women's rite in honour of a most unlikely deity—Fortuna Virilis, or Manly Fortune, His account of the day's rituals is framed by an address to the women of Rome ('Latiae matresque nurusque': 133) and a parting request to Venus to protect the women in their capacity as her daughters-in-law ('tuas . , , nurus': 162), and descendants of Aeneas/* To recall Mars' approving" explanation of women's cult in the previous book he begins this whole section with an echo of 3. 234 'rite colunt matres sacra diemque rneum'. 'Rite deam colitis', the poet affirms at 4. 133-4, 'Latiae matresque nurusque | et vos, quis vittae longaque vestis abest.' 'You are acting properly to worship the goddess, both you mothers and daughters-in-law, and you others who go without the vittae and long stola.."1 So there are two kinds of women, the respectable ones, brides and their mothers-in-law, wearing the formal ribbons binding their hair and long over-gown, and the others. The poet exploits this group address and his speech of instruction in the successive rituals to blur asocial issue; did all women perform each of the three rituals he will describe, or were they socially stratified? First he honours the Veneralia by giving instructions (4. 135-8: 'dernite, lavanda est, reddite, danda est') for the AgrippiniUa, leader of a thiasus of over 400 recorded on a 2nd-cent. AD inscription south'of Rome. (See Beard, North, Price {1.998} i. 271, 298.) 35 See, however, Forte (ii)84a). at> Since 'Aencadae' in Latin is the regular m. plural echoing the Greek patronymic, ^Aeneadas* ace- in 151 must come from Greek V^oeadejs'. W^ note again 'nums\ dciughiers-in-law, where Ovid could have distinguished ihc young brides as I0upta€\ He may have had in mind the foreign origin of Rome's first Sabine wives, hut since he cells the women 'descendants of Aeneas' it is more likely that lie thinks of the 'nurus' as under the authority of their dowager mothers-in-law. 'Matres* is commonly used as a synonym of 'inatronae', and can be applied to all but the newest brides.
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
35
ritual washing of the goddess's cult image. The women must remove the golden necklaces of the goddess and all her jewellery so that she can be washed all over. Once she is dry, they are to replace her golden necklace, and give her fresh flowers and a new supply of roses. And the women must wash themselves too, but clutching myrtle branches, 'because she once had to hide from peeping satyrs and used the myrtle to cover her body; that is why you must repeat her action now'.37 So Ovid describes two different rituals of washing a goddess's image in this single book-one of them not attested in any other Roman source. And he seems to be inviting all the women to join in bathing the image, though this kind of ritual was usually only performed by a few attendants, often indeed by virgins. We noted in connection with the washing of Cybele's image that women's rituals would not be listed in public calendars, because they were not required of public officials. But what makes the washing of Venus suspect is less the lack of corroborating evidence than Ovid's close imitation in the consciously stylized artificial language of his instructions of a famous literary model-Callimachus' elegiac hymn called 'the Bathing of Pallas' which celebrates an equally unattested ritual in which women bathe the image of Pallas Athene in Argos. Could he have invented the whole episode as a pretext to imitate the famous Hellenistic hymn? At 145 fdiscite nunc') Ovid begins a new set of instructions to the women. He explains why they give incense to Fortuna Virilis (Manly Fortune), *in a place moist with hot water'.38 What is he talking about? The inscribed Fasti Praenextini of Ovid's expert source, Verrius Flaccus, though damaged, reports this offering to Fortuna Virilis on 1 April: 'women supplicate in crowds to Fortuna Virilis, and the humbler ones even do so in the baths'. When I attempted my own interpretation of these rituals in rny recent commentary,39 I tried to resolve the conflicting implications of Ovid's notice and that of his learned friend Verrius by stressing the normality of women J7 There are other festivals on which women should particularly practise washing themselves, notably 15 Aug.; cf. Hut. Roman Questions 100, '* Here 1 tentatively read 'calida' with Fra/er and Bomer, against the variant 'gclida' adopted by Castigtioni Landi and most recently Alton el at. (1988). 39 There I have ventured to differ from the simpler account given by Sdieict (19924).
36
ELAINE FANTHAM
using public baths in Ovid's time. But of course this fits Ovid better than Verrius. It was indeed normal for women to use the public baths, but Verrius obviously envisages his 'humiliores' as doing something too daring for their respectable sisters. I have now been persuaded by Charnpeaux's specialized study of Roman Fortuna40 that we must divide the rites offered to Fortuna Virilis—essentially a fertility deity—so that the respectable women do indeed bathe in the public baths, but at a time set aside for women, while the 'lower' kind of women uninhibitedly bathed along with the men: hence the explanatory footnote in the Fasti Praenestini: 'for this is where men are attracted to the women'. Ovid's last instalment of instructions to the women, marked by a new imperative 'nee pigeat' (151) bids them take a ritual drink of milk, honey, and poppy seeds," because this is what Venus herself drank on her bridal night. When they drink they must pray to Venus, because she preserves beauty and good behaviour and reputation. This surely introduces the third ritual, performed as worship of the aspect of Venus called Verticordia, 'the Changer of Hearts'.42 The phases of this cult are clearly recorded by Ijvy and other sources. As Ovid indicates (4. 157-60), the cult was created in response to a decline in morality 'proavorum ternpore' (more likely towards the end of the third century): one of those lapses which happened periodically in Rome, and which the authorities used to counter *' Cb.ampea.ux (1987) j, ch. 6, 375-409, here 384. She sees the old. cull of Fortuna Virilis in which all the women would have bathed together, probably in the Tiber itself, gradually being displaced by the mid-Republican cult of Verticordia, to which the myrtle and the drinking of the ritual cocetutn belong. By the time of Plutarch (Nianii 19. 3), then Macrobius (Sat 1. 12. 15} and John I.ydus (4, f»5) the cult of Fortuna Virilis is no longer observed and the rituals are fused into homage to Venus Verticordia alone. On the larger issue of why Virile Fortune should apparently be worshipped only by women, Champeaux uses the analogous Fortuna Barbata to argue for an originally masculine cult in which women came to share because of its benefit of fertility: this would then have been abandoned by the men, when the feminine cult of Venus was assigned to the same date. 41 The so-called cocetum, not unlike the Attic kukeon (on which see N. J. Richardson 1974), consumed as part of the cult of Demeter. 'ij 1 have translated as it Venus' new epithet denoted her power to change the hearts or attitudes of others (the women), since this moral improvement was what the Roman elite needed. Ovid himself derives it from Venus' change of her own heart 'verso... corde', that is, her softening of heart towards Rome. I suspect him of deliberate reinterpretatiou, but can offer no conclusive argument.
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
37
43
by establishing yet another cult of Venus. The issue was of course keeping the women under control: there were few limits on male sexual activity. This time the Sibylline Books ordered the Roman Senate to give new honours to Venus, and as a result Venus relented towards them and was named after this change of heart. Here our knowledge of the phases of this cult can be supplemented from Valerius Maximus and Plutarch. When the statue of Venus Verticordia was authorized, the affair was put into the hands of the elite women, who devised a way to choose who would dedicate it. First a hundred married ladies were chosen, then ten out of these were selected by lot, from whom finally the consul's wife Sulpicia was appointed to dedicate the statue for her meritorious chastity.44 A century later, in 114 BC, the Vestal virgin Licinia—herself later accused of unchastity—gave Verticordia, a temple for her worship.4"5 So did all the women observe all these rituals? Hardly. Only a very few women could be involved in washing the goddess's image in the river's running water, but surely anyone could frequent the baths, and do so without loss of respectability: recent studies seem to have established that women did have their own public baths at this time, and so might bathe in respectable circumstances. But would the women who wanted to appeal sexually to men also be concerned to protect their good reputation? It seems that Ovid has deliberately wrapped the three different celebrations together so as to confuse the women's roles in association with each cult or offering. What is he up to? My own suspicion is that he is reacting against the bourgeois insistence on distinguishing honest women from elegiac mistresses, ladies of the night, or even simple working women,. By addressing all the women together with, the same imperatives for each cult in turn he can associate all women together in what may well have been practised by only some of them. We can measure his indulgence for the less respectable ladies in, the care with which he celebrates that other Venus festival, 43 Compare Ijvy's account (10, 31. 9) of Fabius Gurges' new shrine of Venus erected with the proceeds offings for worn^ivs immorality in 29f> BC. 44 See Valerius Maximus 8. IS. 12 and Faolham (1998) on 155-62. 45 See Plutarch, Roman Questions $'& and Fautham (I1W8) on 155-62,
38
ELAINE FANTHAM
of Erycina by the Colline Gate, on 23 April.46 For this the street women (volgares paellae) are to honour Venus, who is well disposed to the earnings of licensed ladies (professarum quaestibus). There was only one 'profession' for women in those days: 'profited' means to declare yourself on a public list, and the only public list for women was the aedile's register of public prostitutes. According to the reformed poet of love, 23 April is the day when these loose-living ladies offer incense and garlands of myrtle and mint and roses, and pray for beauty and popular favour and seductive gesture and language. To my mind Ovid has carefully balanced the two feast days of Venus and their celebration within his poetic book, designing the objects of their prayers on 1 and 23 April as complementary; while the well-born ladies ask Verticordia for 'mores' and 'bona lama', the others ask for the seductive airs and graces that are far more to the point and will ensure their continued popularity. I have postponed treating the Cerialia, or feast of Ceres. This was one of Rome's oldest festivals, consisting of a day of cult and sacrifice, followed by three to four days of theatrical performances and a final day of chariot races in the Circus. In Athens the Thesmophoria, one of the major festivals of Ceres' counterpart, Demeter, was exclusively for women, and concerned with the fertility of crop and woman. And women could share with men initiation into the rites at Eleusis, in which, as far as we know, the loss and recovery of Persephone was enacted, at least in symbolic form. Rome had imported a plebeian cult of Ceres with Libera (Proserpina) and Liber (Bacchus or lacchus), as early as the fifth century, giving them a temple on the Aventine. Because of Ceres' association with the grain crop and the later public dole of wheat, she was a favourite image on Republican coins, which may show her wearing a crown of wheat or holding an ear of wheat: some celebrate the games of Ceres, and others illustrate two phases from her search for Proserpina: a myth so significant for cult and so popular that it was told twice by Ovid. In the longer version in 4tl Erycina is Aphrodite of Ml Eryx in Sicily, a cult employing sacred prostitutes, which was brought to Rome by Fabius Maximus during the Hannibalic war as a political gesture towards Sicily.
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
39
Metamorphoses 5 the muse Calliope recounts Ceres' adventures in Sicily as she searched for her daughter. But it is Fasti that tells the version truer to the Greek narrative as we know it from the Homeric hymn.*7 Here Ceres first searches in Sicily by night and day, taking up torches which she kindles from Etna, then flies in her chariot drawn by serpents to Eleusis in Greece, where she is welcomed to the home of young Triptolemus and forecasts his role as inventor of the plough.48 Only after her stay at Eleusis, according to Ovid's version as told here in Fasti, does Ceres discover that Jupiter has agreed to give her daughter to his brother Dis in the underworld. Both here in the Fasti and in Ovid's other version, however, Ceres is given powerful arguments against Jupiter, justifying her right to share in deciding on the choice of her daughter's husband. It is these arguments, rather than,, as in Ovid's other version, the damage inflicted by Ceres on the crops on earth, which determine Jupiter's bargain that Proserpina shall spend part of each year on earth with her mother.49 The symbolic meaning of the myth is taken to be the sowing and spring growth of the grain, but the narrative of Ceres' search and complaints would have a more literal significance for women, who would almost all know the time when they had to lose their daughters to marriage, when they would no longer control their access to a beloved child. Oddly, however, the only references to contemporary ritual acts within Ovid's Proserpina narrative are to Greek practices.-™ Stranger still, our poet has actually anticipated in April the divine narrative which Roman women celebrated much later, after midsummer—the 'sacrum Anniversarium Cereris'.51 This 47
This has been established in detail by Hinds (1998). The bulk of the narrative in Metamorphoses is concerned with Ceres' wanderings in Sicily before she learns of Proserpina's rape and approaches Jupiter to demand her daughter's restoration. Her visit to Attica, and gift of the plough to Triptolemos is only reported parenthetically at the end in Met. 5. 642-56. 4!j Cf. Fasti*. 587-618 with Met. 5. 514-71. '''" The lighting of torches (4. 493) and the breaking of fast at evening (4. 535-6). We might add the ritual drink kukfon which seems to be described by Ovid at 4. 547-8. 51 OB this occasion, which occurs at a point in the calendar, after the six months covered by Ovid, see Spaeth (1996) 12, 13, 105-7, and Fantham (1998) 393 n. This was a night vigil, and the only one expressly approved in Cicero's religions law code of De Leg. 2. 21 and 36. But he also allows for 'those made on behalf of the people in proper form". This category would include the uoctural 'sellistenuuni* of Juno offered 48
4-O
ELAINE FANTHAM
was a specifically women's cult, and Cicero, who calls it a Greek ritual, confirms elsewhere that its priestesses had to be Greeks and were imported from the Greek cities of Velia or Naples.-52 On this summer vigil the Roman matrons re-enacted the loss of Proserpina, crying out to her repeatedly at the street intersections of the city. The Greek practices—of lighting torches at evening, of the ritual drink of milk, honey, and barley—would belong not to the April Cerialia but to this women's summer ritual. In another poem, Amores 3. 10, Ovid throws more light on the ritual. After honouring Ceres for her benefactions he reproaches her because Ms girl is obliged to sleep away from him: 'a feast day calls for sex and song and wine! These are the offerings men should bring to the gods.'53 So the women's vigil probably entailed abstinence from wine as well as from sexual intercourse. Propertius complains about similar sexual abstinence by Ms mistress in honour of Isis, and an earlier passage in the Fasti reports the same 'secubitus' in preparation for the worship of Bacchus.54 It was understood at Rome as in most cultures that men were impure for religious purposes after intercourse, but there is so little interest in women's religion that this seems to be our only evidence for prohibitions affecting them. This is perhaps the best place to mention another restriction on women's sexual activity which Ovid highlights and even personalizes. As he approaches the June Vestalia he claims that he was about to give his own daughter in marriage, and so made inquiries about the right time to do so: (6. 221-2: 'tempera taedis | apta... quaeque cavenda forent'}. Women apparently should not many between 6 and 13 June (the Ides) during the period, when Vesta's shrine was being spring-cleaned, and Ovid's authority is no less than the wife of the flamen Dialis, who confirms that she herself cannot even at the Ludi Saeculares of 17 BC and AD 204, Nocturnal rituals had been part of the indictment against the Bacchanalia in 186 ne. 32
Cic. Verr. 2. 4. 115, Bath, 55. ~'f On tltts poem and distich see Miller (1.991) 4-5—6. '''' Sleeping apart to be pure for Isis, Prop. 2. 31; for Bacchus, fasti 2. 328-30: *p0sitls iuxta secubuere tons J causa, repertory vitis qtsia sacra parabant, | quae facerent pure, cum foret orte dies'.
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
41
consort with her wedded husband, the flamen, at that time.55 Given that Plutarch cites other such restrictions, how many of these taboos on marrying, or married intercourse, may have gone unmentioned in our sources?56 Ovid's half-year of festivals marks one other day which was specially celebrated by women, and this for two different but related cults. On 11 June women gathered to celebrate the Matralia in honour of Mater Matuta, but it was also the day for honouring the shrine of Fortuna in the Forum Boarium: indeed the temples of the two goddesses were adjacent, and both cults were associated with the same legendary king, Servius Tullius. As Ovid expresses it after he has told the legend of the goddess's coming to Rome (6. 569): 'The same day and founder and location are yours, Fortuna', 'lux eadem, Fortuna, tua est, auctorque locusque'. There is evidence in other elders and contemporaries of Ovid, in Varro, Livy, and Festus' epitome of Verrius Flaccus, that associates the two female deities more closely.57 But Ovid treats their cults separately and serially; first he summons the women to worship on this anniversary of Servius' temple to Mother Matuta
55 Why does Ovid use the 'flaminica' as his informant? The flaminica' and her husband the 'ilamen DiahV were subject to multiple taboos, (According to Gellius 10, 1.5 and Plutarch, Roman Questions 40 and 109-13, he would forfeit office on her death.) Besides other taboos affecting her (cf. Gellius 10. 15. 26-7), Plutarch, Roman Questions 86, reports that the 'flaminica' may not bathe or adorn herself during the period of the rite of the Argei in May, a time in which other women may not many; hence perhaps the other requirement mentioned by Plutarch, that she must adopt a stern demeanour ('skuthropazein'). ft is part of Ovid's search for variety that he should not mention this restriction in his discussion of the Argei in May, but introduce it only in one of the two periods concerned. •"' Plutarch actually implies a much wider taboo in stating (Roman Questions 105} that it is not customary for maidens to marry on a public holiday, only for widows. This would seem to exclude even Kalends, Nones, and Ides; see Macrobius, Sat. I . 15. 21, :ii Livy 5. 19, (> confirms Servius as founder of the temple of Mater Matuta: Varro ap. Nonius 189 reports that the Fortuna of the Forum Boariurn was also called * Fortuna Virgo'; who, according to Festus 282 L, was also construed as 'Pydicilia': 'Pudicitiae signum in foro Boario est uhi Aemiliana aedis est Herculis. F.am tjuidam Fortututni esse existimani. Item via Latina ad milliarium 1111 Fortunae Muliebris, nelas est attingi, nisi ab ea quac seme! nupscrit.' It is not clear to what aspect of the two cults 'Hera* applies. As Wissowa (1912) 207 argues, this is also the 'Fudicilia Patricia' from which Virginia was excluded in the narrative of Livy 10. 23. 3f. (see n. 23 above).
42
ELAINE FANTHAM
(6. 475-80): Ite bonae matres (vestrum Matralia festum) flavaque Thebanae reddite liba deae: pontibus et magno iuncta est celeberrima Circo area quae poslto de bove nomen habet. hac ibi luce ferant Matutae sacra parent! sceptriferas Servi templa dedisse maims. Go then, good mothers (the Matralia is your feast day), and offer golden honeycakes to the Theban goddess. There is a much-frequented area near the bridges and the great Circus which takes its name from the statue of an ox; men say that there in this day the sceptre-bearing hands of Servius dedicated a holy temple for Mother Matata,
Matuta is called 'Thebana dea' because she was equated with Ino, nurse of her nephew Dionysus. Cicero, who reports the Identification of Matuta with Leucothea, the deified form of the Theban queen Ino, does not try to explain the equation,58 In Greek myth Hera vindictively maddened Ino so that she threatened her children: Phrixus and Helle escaped on the golden ram, but she caught up Melicertes and jumped with him into the sea. Together they were saved from drowning by being transformed into the sea deities Leucothea and Palaemon. Building on this Ovid confects a mythical coming of mother and child to Rome in the time of Evander: persecuted by Roman Bacchantes, Ino is rescued by Hercules and heralded as the Roman goddess Matuta by Evander's prophet mother Carmenta.-59 The poet thus incorporates into his fiction two types of female religiosity—Maenadic worship and prophetic inspiration—more acceptable in the heroic period than in the late Republic and his own time.60 However, Ovid is also more informative than usual on the form of cult observed. He notes the ritual practice of driving ;8 ' See ND 3. 39 and 48: 'Ino dea ducctur et Leucothea a Graecis, a nobis Matuta dicetur, cum sit Cadmi filia?' See now Smith (2000). 59The persecution is instigated by a disguised Junu (6, 507—22/; lor Carrnenta's prophetic frenzy (she swells with inspiration like Virgil's Sibyl "sanctior et tanto, quam inodo, maior') see 6. 541-8 at 545: 'Leucothea Grais, Matuta vocabere nostris*; Ovid echoes Cicero's distinction. w) qppg Maenadic cult of Bacchus was banned throughout Italy by decree of the Senate in 186 BC, though individual worship remained licit, Prophecy too wass restricted to official consultation of the written texts attributed to the Sibyl and controlled by the .Docenivifi,
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
43
out a slave girl from the celebration, and another anthropologically interesting feature: the women do not pray to Matuta for their own child, but for their sisters' children. This is probably a trace of an older matrilineal element in Italic society, but Ovid associates both practices with Ino's mythical biography (6. 551-62): she was nurse to her sister's son, and she hated slave girls because a slave girl informed on her to her husband. The poetic narrative is fantasy, but the ritual taboos are also discussed in Plutarch's Roman Questions 16 and 17; indeed Plutarch cites the local Greek practice of banning slaves (and Aetolians too) from the shrine of Leucothea. Who was Matuta and what did she do for women? Dumezil has argued from the root 'matutinus' that she was a Dawn goddess,t!l but the Romans themselves did not know her origin, and saw her only as a protecting goddess like Fortuna. And even Fortuna was a deity they preferred to particularize by defining genitives or adjectives,'1" Wissowa lists along with Fortuna Virilis, whom we met in the women's baths, a number of Fortunes associated with a particular family or college, Fortune the Favourer or Watcher ('Obsequens, Respiciens'), and two Fortunes associated with women: the Fortune of the temple attributed to King Servius Tullius in the Forum Boarium, probably Fortuna Virgo, and Fortuna Muliebris.63 The distinctive feature of the Forum Boarium temple was its cult statue, heavily veiled in a toga of mysterious weave. Ovid identifies this as King Servius himself (6. 571 'hoc constat enim'),"4 but reports that others construed it as Fortuna or Pudicitia. Ovid relishes alternatives, and provides not one but three explanations why the statue was veiled: Fortune herself t!1 Dumezil {1970} i. 50-5. For other sources see Beard, North, Price (1998) 62 i, 51 n. 157. Cf. Dumezil (11)70) i. 42. (3 ' See Wissowa (1912) 208-12. Are these complementary? Did the girl pas from the cult of Fortutia Virgo as she niarried to come under the protection of Fortuna Muliebris? Both female fortunes are listed by Plutarch, Roman Questions 74 in a discussioin of Servius' many foundations for the goddess that is expanded in On the Fortune of the Romans 10. But he does not include the cult of Fortuna Muliebris there, perhaps because he has already reported the legend of its foundation (on which see below) in On the Fortune of the Romam 5. 1)4 Ovid's view is shared by Dionysius 4. 40. 7, Valerius Maximus 1. 8. 11, and Pliny, Nil 8, 194. But in 8. 197 Pliny reports a contradictory claim that the statue was Fortuna, herself.
44
ELAINE FANTHAM
covered the king's face in shame (573-80); or the Roman people did so to put an end to their grief after his assassination (581-4); or Servius covered his own head before death to avoid looking his murderous daughter in the face (584-620). The poet has devoted attention to this oddity in order to justify a women's cult practice or taboo: married women must not touch the statue's drapery, because the day on which Servius' face is exposed will bring the abandonment of all modesty (620): 'haec [sc. lux] positi prima pudoris erit'. Did women come collectively to pray here on this anniversary? Or was this a general warning to any woman who might come alone? Understanding the various cults of Fortuna is one of the most baffling problems in approaching Roman cult. But that of the Fortune of women (Fortuna Muliebris), though not considered in Ovid's calendar poem,'" is known to have been, founded by and for women, and inaugurated at least by an officiating priestess. According to Dionysius 8. 55-6, when Coriolanus' stern mother led the matrons of Rome to confront him and shame him from attacking the city in 493, the Senate honoured them by erecting an altar and temple to Fortuna Muliebris at the point where he was turned back. The married women were authorized to nominate a priestess and chose a woman, Valeria, who had helped to organize the deputation to Coriolanus.™ Dionysius reports that she officiated at the sacrifice, uniquely on this occasion performed by the women on behalf of the Roman people. Indeed the goddess's statue actually spoke her approval of the women's act, saying, in language we have also read in Ovid: 'you have dedicated me in proper fashion'."7 Why did they need divine confirmation? Since, properly speaking, women had no property, they were not in a position to dedicate anything beyond their personal effects-such as the
' •' Ovid's calendar does not go beyond 30 June. The temple anniversary falls in July and ihe feast day on 1 December, '* This detail suggests that Dionysius* source was Valerius Aulias. See uow 'Valerius Antias and the Palimpsest of History' in Wiseman (I!)98) 88. But leaving aside her name, the story of the priestess is authenticated by Livy, Valerius Maximus, and Plutarch in On Ihe Fortune of the Romans 5. '"' The same miraculous speech is reported in Val. Max. 1. 8. 14 'Rite me, matronae, vidistis, rileque dedicastis.'
WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN ROMAN CULT
45
maiden clothes which the bride would dedicate to Fortuna Virgo.68 This temple, set outside Rome, provides a link back to my point of departure through Livia, who restored it, because of its association with chastity and marital respectability: only 'univirae' might enter the temple of Fortuna Muliebris,69 and it spoke for Livia's concern for marital harmony. So too did the dedication that follows immediately after the story of Fortuna and Servius Tullius, as Ovid brings the Fasti towards its early closure: we saw Livia restore the temple of Concord and enrich it with an altar in January (1. 650-1), an act marking her worthiness of her unique husband.70 In June again (6. 637-4-4) he describes how she presented Concord with a glorious temple and portico on the site of Vedius Pollio's scandalous mansion; it now became her offering to her husband: 'te quoque magnifies, Concordia, dedicat aede Livia, quam caro praestitit ipsa viroV1 As Nicholas Purcell (1986) has shown, Livia set herself up as a model for the women of Rome, and the embodiment of Augustus' moral policies, Ovid has skilfully distributed the record of her actions over the calendar to make her stand for women's religious role at both his beginning and as nearly as possible his ending. As he declares of Augustus' actions, so we may say of Livia's pointed choice of shrines to set a noble ''* Wissowa's evidence for this practice (1912) 207 is partly Virginia's reference in Livy I0S 23 to her own dedication to Pudicitia on marriage, and partly irotn the" Christian Arnobius 2. fi7, who refers to the goddess as Fortuna Virginalis. <>!) Cf. Festus 282 quoted n. 57 above. Livia's act of restoration is known from the fragmentary inscription; Purcell (1986) 88 and n. 58, /a i. 650; 'sola tero reagni digna reperta lovis* lavishes on Augustus an honorific Ovid might have withheld when he wrote the first draft of Fasti bk. 1. See HerbertBrown (1994) 1.62-7 for a full discussion of this passage. '•'• On this portico see Herbert-Brown (1994) 145-56. She rightly insists on the coherence of this passage with the preceding passages honouring the women's cute of Matuta and Fortuna, but points out that according lo Dio 55. 8, ) the Porticua was dedicated in January and jointly with her son Tiberius, Thus Ovid has taken a gesture of family concord between mother and son and reinterpreted it as a confirmation of concord between husband and wife, reinforcing this message by associating the event with Che women's festivals oi Mater Matuta and Fortuua. As she points out (148), Ovid out of tact towards Livia passes over the normal requirement that no one except 'uuivirae* should participate in the Matralia (also true of the cult of Fortuna Muliebris}, By linking these three cults Ovid can focus attention on wifely virtue and I jvia's role in providing the model of that virtue,
46
ELAINE FANTHAM
example: 'sic exempla parantur'.78 If Ovid tells us less than we would like about the ordinary woman's religious life and practice, one woman at least has been given credit for all her public religious acts, and her religious roles and honours reflect the cults and ideals set before elite women in the days of poet and emperor. 72 pjQjy (1984) made this the title of her excellent study.
3
Vaga Signa; Orion and Sirius in Ovid's Fasti EMMA GEE
(i) Introduction In this chapter two episodes of the Fasti will be studied, both of which contain astronomy: the Robigalia of fasti 4. ,901—42, where Sirius, the Dog-Star, is present, and the part of Fasti 5 in which Orion and Mars Ultor are juxtaposed, lines 493-598.' Although, these two pieces of text may at first seem dissimilar in structure, content, and programme, it will become clear that they share elements, and that these common features can help to shed light on the way in which astronomical material functions in its immediate context in the Fasti, and on the place of astronomy in the work as a whole. Orion and Sirius are astronomical entities with credentials which go back as far as the beginnings of epic and didactic poetry in Greece.2 They belong also in the tradition of the agricultural calendar, as it is found in Hesiod's Works and Days, Aratus' Phaenomena, Virgil's Georgics, Varro's De Re Rmtica, Columella's ResRusticae, and Pliny the Elder's Naluralis Historia, book 18.3 In particular, the first two couplets in Ovid's record of the strange festival of Mildew (the Robigalia) at Fasti-i. 901-4, in which Sirius occurs, reflect this tradition; they look like advice on astronomy and meteorology addressed to
' Thanks to John Henderson, Elaine Faotha.ni, Geraldine Herbert-Brown, and Michael Reeve. 2 Sirius: Homer, A 22. 29, Hesiod, WD 582-96; Orion: Homer, //. 18. 486, Hesiod, TO598, filS. 3 On the Fasti and the agricultural calendar, see Gee (2000; 9-20).
48
EMMA GEE
the watchful farmer: Sex ubi, quae restant, luces Aprilis habebit, In medio cursu tempora veris erunt, Et frusta, pecudem quaeres Athamantidos Helles, Sigiiaque dant imbres, exoriturque Canis. When April has only six days remaining. Springtime will be in mid-course, And your search for the Ram of Athamantic Helle will fail. The signs bring rain, and the Dog, Canis, rises.4
Both in their injunction to the second person addressee and in their astronomical content, these opening lines of the Robigalia may be likened to Georgics 1. 219-21: At si triticeam in messern robustaque farra exercebis humum solisque imtabis aristis, ante tibi Eoae Atlantides abscondantur. But if for a wheat harvest or crop of hardy spelt You work your land, and are keen on bearded corn alone, Let first the Aflantid Pleiads come to their morning setting.s
The idea of observing the Signs which indicate a particular kind of meteorological phenomenon ('signaque dant imbres', Fasti 4, 904) is part of the agricultural tradition, as exemplified at Georgics 1. 351-5: atque haec ut certis possemus discere signis, aestusque pluviasque et agentis frigora ventos, ipse pater statuit quid menstrua luna tnoneret, quo signo cadercnt Austri, quid saepc videntes agricolae propius stabulis annenta tenerent. So that we might be able to predict from manifest signs These things—heatwaves and. rain and winds that bring cold weather, The father himself laid down what the moon's phases should mean, The cue for the south wind's dropping, the sign that often noted Should warn a fanner to keep his cattle near the shippon.
The similarity in tone of the beginning of the Robigalia to Virgil's agricultural calendar situates the Ovidian festival in the agricultural calendrical tradition. If we explore this tradition, 4 Translations of the Fasti in this chapter are from Boyle and Woodard (2000), except where otherwise noted. 3 All translations of the Georgics ui this chapter axe from Day Lewis (W83).
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI
49
through Pliny, NH18, for example, it can help us to shed light on problems of astronomical accuracy in the Fasti. Exploration of issues of astronomical accuracy in the Fasti can at the same time help us gain a better understanding of the nature of Ovidian 'ingenium' as it manifests itself through principles of linking, selection, and construction. If his astronomical references are inaccurate in relation to the Julian calendar, either Ovid must be excused on the grounds of his astronomical ignorance, and the reader must pass over these astronomical oversights and concentrate on other material, or we must make room for the theoiy that the astronomical references are arranged as they are not purely as a result of error, but in order to fit in with their surrounding context, and perhaps comment on it. Exploration of thematic links between the stars and the material with which they are juxtaposed becomes a possible methodology once it has become apparent that such juxtaposition is not an arbitrary result of date, but is a device achieved at the expense of chronological accuracy. The question of astronomical accuracy cannot therefore be divorced from the question of whether we should treat the different kinds of material in the Fasti in isolation, or whether the reader should look for thematic links across the different parts of the poem.* This chapter exemplifies the latter methodology. The Ovidian episodes containing Sirius and Orion are related to the agricultural calendar, but are also parts of the complex organism that scholarship and close reading show the Fasti to be. In exploring the importance of the agricultural calendar, and in particular Virgil's Georgics, as model for the Fasti, one cannot ignore the status of the Georgics as literature of the most complex kind; if Ovid alludes to such a model, we must also explore the literary complexity of his poem. So I shall also consider allusion to the Georgics as a programmatic marker in the Fasti, and in this line of inquiry I shall be indebted to Elaine Fantham for clearing the undergrowth, in her splendid article on the Fasti and the Georgics.7 6
A debate exemplified by Herbert-Brown (1997).
7
Fanthain (1392),
EMMA GEE 5° Much can be gained in our understanding of the text by applying to the astronomical material the same techniques regarding intertextuality and allusion as have been practised on the rest of the poem. This is not, however, to ignore historical context. Once it is apparent that patterns of allusion to the Georgics extend to both of the episodes under exploration, linking them thematically, these patterns of allusion may be seen to allow Ovid, here as elsewhere in the Fasti, to develop and reapply the political themes of his early Augustan predecessor to his own situation in the later Principate.
(ii) Stars and Gods Both of the episodes to be considered here contain bizarre pairings of stars with deities: Robigo, the goddess of Mildew, and Sirius, the Dog-Star; Orion and Mars. How can we reconcile these gods with their accompanying celestial entities? The problem is more crucial for the Robigalia, where the festival seems somehow contingent on a connection with a star, rather than, just concomitant with it, as in the case of Orion and Mars. Let us begin by looking at both stories in brief, taking first the pairing of Robigo and Sirius in Fasti 4. The Robigalia begins with the meteorological and astronomical indications mentioned above (Fasti 4, 901-4). What follows is surprising if one expects agricultural advice: Ovid's narrator recounts his own experience of the festival (Fasti 4. 905-10), substituting a Callimachean aetiological voice for the persona of Hesiodic and Virgilian didactic. At Fasti4. ,911-32, the 'flamen Oj.iirinaJ.is' (Priest of Quirinus) prays to Robigo to leave the corn to grow ripe. The priest carries out the ritual of expiation of Robigo, which involves the sacrifice of a dog and a sheep at Fasti 4. 933-6. In response to a question from the narrator, he explains that the sacrifice is for the propitiation of Sirius, the Dog-Star (Fasti 4. 937-42). FastiS. 493-598 juxtaposes Orion and Mars Ultor. At Fasti5. 493-544, the aition for the constellation Orion is given, as follows. Mercury, Jupiter, and Neptune visit a pious old man, Hyrieus, who entertains them with rustic hospitality. In due course the gods reveal their identity and grant Hyrieus' wish
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI
5I
to have a son despite the death of his wife. This son they conceive jointly, by urinating on an oxhide, from which Orion is eventually born. His life, death, and eatasterism are briefly described in 537-44. Of the versions of the giant's death, Ovid chooses that most favourable to Orion as a catasterized hero:s he became Latona's bodyguard and protected her from a scorpion sent by Tellus. The scorpion and Orion were frozen in the chase before they could do one another any damage, and became constellations in that position forever. Next,9 an astronomical transition (545-8) is made to the games for the anniversary of the foundation of the temple of Mars Ultor. There follows the epiphany of Mars and description of the temple to which he descends (549-68). In 569-78 there is a flashback to the battle of Philippi, at which Octavian, under the patronage of Mars, avenged Caesar's murder. Line 579 brings us to the Parthian campaign of Augustus, and Mars as the Avenger of the massacre of Crassus' army in 53 BC. In 595-8 the god's temple, title, and games are summed up, and in 599 we return to astronomy, with the rising of the Pleiades and Taurus, the latter of which generates the myth of the catasterized Europa (603-20). In both episodes, Robigo/Sirius and Orion/Mars, there are 'errors' of date and puzzles of progression. The illogicality of the Robigalia inheres in two problems: Ovid's astronomical error—the Dog-Star in fact rises in August, rather than April— and the fact that the poet's aetiology of dog-sacrifice by the Dog-Star does not appear to answer the question posed in line 937, why the priest of Quirinus sacrifices a dog to Robigo. These problems were isolated as long ago as 1899, by Warde Fowler: 'Sirius does not rise, but disappears on 25 April, at sunset, and it is almost certain that the sacrifice of the dog has nothing to do with the star.'10 Why does Ovid choose to connect the two at the cost of astronomical error? Elaine Fantham calls this 'the strangest of Ovid's astronomical inaccuracies'." We shall 8 For the different versions of Orion's death (most far less flattering to the hunter), see Hygittus, Astr, 2, 26 and 34, On Ovid's selectivity, see Newlaods (19S)5) 110-15. 9 We should remember that the date markings which break up Ovid's text as we 10 have it are editorial. Warde Fowler (181)9} 90, " Fantham (1998) ad Fasti 4. 904. Her explanation of Ovid's error is that he has confused the rising of Sirius with its evening setting. She comments, 'This is all the
52
EMMA GEE
attempt an explanation in a moment, but let us first outline the problems of the Orion/Mars passage. Here the situation is, if anything, more complex. At Fasti 4, 387f. Ovid has the setting of Orion on 9 April, just before the Games of Ceres. In Book 5 the setting of the constellation may be dated to 11 May. The astronomical dates here, surprisingly, are fairly accurate, since Orion, as a very large constellation, takes some time to set, and does in fact set at this time of the year.12 The problem in this case is that the reader's aetiological expectations are tinkered with in several respects. First, Orion in lines 493 f. is a 'non-constellation'. The constellation is no longer visible in the sky; none the less, Ovid goes on to expound its origin. The paratactic structure typical of astronomical didactic is odd here, considering that the second idea is a. non sequitur: 'You won't find Orion: I'll tell you his cause.'13 If Orion is not there in the first place, what is he doing hurrying to set before the Games of Mars in Fasti 5. 545? The question is an astronomical one; the ensuing passage, however, is the aetiology, not of astronomical material, but of the anniversary of the founding of the temple of Mars Ultor. The anniversary itself is not unproblematic, as scholars ha,ve shown.14 Ovid is the first to record the vow of Octavian at Philippi, but also records a tradition of Mars as avenger of the Roman people over the Parthians: that is, over a foreign enemy, rather than over fellow Romans. As Zanker put it, 'Identifying Mars Ultor with this later occasion, as well as with other deeds of Augustus' armies and generals, was a convenient way of forgetting the association with the civil war,'14 Why does more surprising as Virgil Geo. 1. 217-18 clearly marks the entrance of the sun into Taurus in late April as the time when the Dog Star sets.' Similarly, Ovid's dating of the evening getting of Aries diverges from the true evening setting of that star by about three weeks, and. the apparent evening setting by about a month. Fanthatn leaves the reasons for Ovid's inaccuracy open, saying merely, 'While Ovid's intermittent astronomical references are both inaccurate and arbitrary, he does try to note either rising {real or apparent) or setting of most signs of the zodiac,* '" Although Ideier (1825} 161-3 suggested that he may have used two different parapegniato. H On parataxis as a stylistic marker in astronomical didactic, see Sa.nti.nt (197,5). 14 On the problems, see (for example) Bonier (1957-8) ad Fasti 5. 550, and Herbertt5 Brown (1994) 95-108. Zanker (1988) 194,
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI
53
16
Ovid include the Philippi vow at all? Let us now take a closer look at our two passages, exploring the problems further, and trying to see how the different elements in them can be fitted together into an interpretable whole.
(iii) Mildew and the Dog-Star The agricultural theme of Fasti 4. 901—42 fits the predominantly agricultural nature of Book 4. Robigo nestles happily in her surrounding context. The problem, as we have noted, is that Ovid combines the celebration of a rustic rite with the (incorrect) rising of a star. Why is a dog sacrificed to Robigo? Why is it important that Sinus should be present rather than absent at this date? We may attempt an explanation of this problem by consulting the agricultural calendar. Evidence for the association of dogs with the Robigalia conies from Pliny. Discussing diseases of crops at NH18. 154, Pliny describes Blight as a 'caeleste rnalum' which affects both corn and grapes. The Robigalia is among the festivals instituted by men of old to cope with periods of agricultural danger (NH 18. 284), which also include the Vinalia and Floralia (as we have them in Fasti 4 and 5). The Robigalia was instituted by Numa in the eleventh year of his reign, and falls on 25 April, because at about that time the crops are subject to mildew ('quondam tune fere segetes robigo occupat'). But the true cause is the setting of Canis and Canicula at this time: Vera causa est quod post dies undetriginta ab aequinoclio verno per id quatriduum varia gentium observatione in IV Kal. Mai. Canis occidit, sidus et per se vehemens et cui praeoccidere caaiiculam 16 According to Herbert-Brown (1994) 107: 'The absence of any real justification for Mars Ultor is Ovid's challenge as he celebrates the dedication of the temple in the fasti after the death of Gaius, For all his profession to stick to peaceful themes at the outset, of his work (Fasti I. 13} he is DOW obliged to adopt a military tone. Yet all that he is left to work with is the settlement of 20 nc and die memory of Augustus' determination to celebrate the occasion as a military triumph. Or was it after the death ot Gaius, and during a possible upsurge ot popularity tor the memory ol Julius that the vow at Philippi for the revenge of Julius was invented to refurbish the inadequate camouflage of Augustus* peaceful settlement in 20 BC? If this is so, it is not surprising that Ovid, composing his calendar in the years AD 4-8, should he the first Roman to report the vow at Philippi,'
54
EMMA GEE
necesse sit' (NH18. 285), From this it seems that propitiation of the setting Dog-Star, at the time when the wheat was about to come into ear (i.e. spring), coincided with the Robigalia, the purpose of which was also the protection of the crescent corn. At Fasti 4. 901-4 Ovid gives the rising of the Dog for Pliny's setting, possibly to make a stronger connection between the sacrifice of a dog to Robigo, and the Dog-Star. The cause of the dog sacrifice, like the constellation, is present in the Fasti', but Ovid neglects to tell the aition of the sheep sacrifice which also takes place at Fasti 4. 935, nor does the constellation of the Ram preside over the ceremony (Fasti 4. 903). It is the Dog that Ovid seerns to want us to concentrate on here.17 The agricultural calendar is important not only for explaining apparent logical anomalies in Ovid's Robigalia, but also in trying to determine the moral thrust of the passage. Broadly speaking, this might be defined as the celebration of rural peace. One might see Ovid's Robigalia as indicative of nostalgia for the virtuous state of rustic early Rome, a sort of Golden Age in which the arms of war are the only entities subject to corruption, as the priest prays they will be at Fasti 4. 921-30: Parce, precor, scabrasque manus a messibus aufer, Neve noce cultis; posse nocere sat cst. Nee teneras segetes, sed durum amplectere ferrum, Quodque potest alios perdere perde prior, Utilius gladios et tela nocentia carpes: Nil opus est illis; otia mundus agit. Sarcula nunc durusque bidens et vonier aduiicus, Ruris opes, niteant; inquinet arma situs, Conatusque aliquis vagina ducere terrain Adstrictum longa sentiat esse mora. 'Spare us, I pray, keep scabrous hands from the harvest. Harm no crops. The power to harm is enough, '7 He has the priest, taking for a moment the role of mythographer, allude to the mythology of the Dog-i>tar at Fasti 4, 1)3!); 'cst Cairo, Icariuin dicunl.,.'. In this version of the myth, the Dog-Star is the dog Maera, who discovered the body of his niasler Icarus, murdered by drunken shepherds to whom he had given wine, a gilt from Dionysus to mankind through him. The dog wasted away beneath the feet of Icarus' daughter Erigoue, who had hanged herself with grief at her father's death, until they were all eatasterized hy Zeus, Icarus becoming Bootes or Arctophylax, Erigone Virgo, and Icarus' dog Canieula (Hyginua, Astr, 2. 4).
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI
55
Do not grip the delicate corn, but hard iron. And destroy what is destructive, first. It is better to devour swords and lethal spears. They have no use: the world practises peace, Now let the hoe, hard fork and arcing plow shimmer; They are the field's wealth. Let neglect rust amis; And let any attempt to unsheathe the sword Feel the iron clogged from long disuse.'
The theme of rural peace is consonant with the Pax Augusta of the established Principate. Ovid's 'otia mundus agit' at Fasti 4. 926 recalls the post-civil war scene of Virgil's first Eclogue'. *deus nobis haec otia fecit' (line 6).18 Successful agriculture was an important indicator of the success of Roman institutions, and indeed Pliny, in the agricultural book 18 of his Naturals Historia, asserts that agricultural life is the foundation of Roman institutions (NH18. 6). The work which best exemplifies the morality and sociology of Roman agriculture in the generation before Ovid is of course Virgil's Georgia. Ovid's prayer to Robigo brings to mind a passage of Virgil's Georgia in which a similar combination of agricultural and military imagery occurs, Georg. 1. 160—70: Dicendum el quae srint duris agrestibus arum quis sine nee potuere sen nee surgere messes: vomis et inflexi primum grave robur aratri, tardaque Eleusinae matris volventia plaustra, tribulaque traheaeque et iniquo pondere rastri; virgea praeterea Celei vilisque supellex, arbuteae crates et mystica vannus lacchi. omnia quae multo ante memor provisa repones, si te digna manet divini gloria runs. continue) in silvis magna vi flexa domatur in burim et curvi formam aceipit ulmus aratri. I'll tell you too the armoury of the tough countryman, For without (his the harvest would never be sown nor successful: The ploughshare Erst and heavy timbers of the curving plough, 18 See also Pastil. 08,28,5-8, 701-4; 'lr. '2.224,235. Elaine Fanlham points out (1998 ad Fasti 4. 926) that "otium* was a panegyrical theme in Roman poetry since Horace, noting especially Odes 4, 15. 17-19, 'custode rerun) Caesare nou furor j civilis aut vis cxiget otium, non ira, f|uae ptocudit enses*. On 'otium' as an Augustan concept, see also Galinsky (UWti) 243, 258 f.
56
EMMA GEE
The ponderous-moving waggons that belong to the Mother of harvest, Threshers and harrows and the immoderate weight of the mattock; Slight implements, too, of osier, Arbutus hurdles, the Wine-god's mystical winnowing-fan. Be provident, lay by a stock of them long beforehand If you wish to remain worthy of the land and its heaven-sent honour. Early in woods the elm, by main force mastered, is bent Into a share-beam and takes the shape of the curving plough.
At Fasti 4, 927 Ovid gives an abbreviated version of Virgil's list of agricultural implements. In, particular, Ovid's 'vomer aduncus' might recall Georg, I. 162, Vomis et inflexi grave robur aratri'. In both passages 'arma' are mentioned. In Virgil 'arma* is a military metaphor applied to the tools of the fanner, reinforced by words such as 'gloria' and 'domatur'. The violence of war is transferred by Virgil to agricultural endeavour, which becomes a battle with natural forces, in which, the farmer strives for militaristic triumph. This imagery is appropriate for a description of agriculture which belongs to the generation which had seen the civil wars. By appropriating the terminology of war for agricultural activity, Virgil at once indicates how agriculture might eclipse war, but also how the cultivation of the land in the Age of Jove partakes of the aggression of war. However, as we saw above, Ovid's is a new Golden Age. In the Robigalia, Ovid keeps the two separate, referring to agricultural tools as 'ruris opes' and saving 'arma' for weapons of war (Justi 4.928). Agriculture in this passage of the Fastil&cks the element of aggression it has in Virgil's theodicy of 'labor', and is perhaps more suited to the world of the later Principate, in which agricultural peace is an established fact, and battle imagery is less relevant to all spheres of human activity.
(iv) Orion and Mars But the god of war is not altogether absent from Ovid's aetiological didactic poem: he is addressed in the Proem to Fasti 3,"' and has his own episode at Fasti 5. 545 ff., following 19
On which see Hinds (1992).
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI
57
the story of Orion, told at Fasti 5. 493 ff. Let us now consider in more detail Orion and Mars in Fasti 5, The story of Orion is similar in tone and moral thrust to the Robigalia. At Fasti5. 497 f. the reader is plunged into a pastoral world: Tempus erat quo versa iugo referuntur aratra, Et pronus saturae lac bibit agnus ovis, It was the time when yokes bring back the upturned plough And stooping lambs milk their bursting ewes.
Here Ovid may allude to Virgil, Eclogue 2. 66, 'aspice, aratra iugo referunt suspensa iuvenci' ('Look, the bullocks bring back the hanging ploughs with the yoke'}. This story is not going to be the wider campus of epic, but a small piece of pastoral territory. Homely details are present, like the pots of beans and cabbage in Fasti 5, 509, Here again, a key model is Virgil's Georgics. The poor but horticulturally successful old Corycian man in Georgics 4, 125-46 also has cabbage ('holus', Georg. 4. 130). Like the worthy old man in the Georgics, Hyrieus is 'angusti cultor agelli' (499), 'cultorem pauperis agri' (515): compare the 'pauca iugera' of Georgics 4. 127 f. The poverty of the fare in Fasti 5 may remind us of Georg. 4. 132 £, 'seraque revertens | nocte domum dapibus mensas onerabat inemptis' ('He could go indoors at night | To a table heaped with dainties he never had to buy'). In the Georgia, the simple lifestyle of the old man renders him worthy to keep fruitful bees (who are given divine characteristics in what follows); in the Fasti the implication is that the rustic simplicity of Hyrieus, as well as his piety, is what makes the gods disposed to grant his wish for a son. A connection between Ovid and Virgil is the topos of agricultural simplicity as generating virtue. Continuing the theme of virtue, Ovid chooses the version of Orion's death which marks him out as virtuous. In most cases, Orion's death was a result, not of his pittas, but of his hubris.™ The fact that Ovid chooses to manufacture a different version of the giant's death here would indeed seern to indicate that he wished to continue the theme of virtue set up in the episode of Hyrieus and the gods. 7 " See Hyginus, Astr. 1, 26 (Orion boasts that he can kill every beast on the face of the earth), and CaUimachuti, Hymn 3. 2641*. (an attempt by Orion to seduce Diana).
58
EMMA GEE
Newlands comments on the Orion passage: 'The reference to Hyrieus' straitened circumstances makes clear that Ovid is not stretching elegy's bounds with serious Roman themes like Augustus' reform of religion and revision of history', and on Ovid's version of Orion's death: 'Whereas the Temple of Mars Ultor provides official sanction for revenge as a noble expression of filial or patriotic duty, in the Greek myth of Orion Ovid presents revenge as a brute, unintelligent force that can be exaggerated and unjust.'21 This scholar sees a disparity between the martial nature of Mars and the pacific nature of the surrounding episodes, including Orion: 'Read in isolation, the passage on Mars Ultor presents itself as a totalizing discourse, providing a positive view of war and revenge and reproducing the concept of national identity as proudly male and martial. Read in relation to the myth of Orion , , , the exegesis of the cult of Mars Ultor becomes one possible view of Roman identity only, and not a canonical one. Thus, although this passage celebrates Rome's military successes, the ideology enshrined in the Forum Augustum is questioned by the invitation of other perspectives that prioritize the arts of peace rather than the art of war.'22 The implication is that one would expect the passage on Mars Ultor to be very different from both the Orion passage which precedes it, with allusions to the Georgics, for example, being excluded from Fasti 5. 545 ff., but not from the preceding passage on Orion. Following Newlands's reasoning, one would expect a clash between the tone and moral thrust of 21
Newlands (Was) ll'l, ~* Newiands (1995) 20, l°his vitvw is ill tune with Nt'wlaods's broad assertion thai the stars often introduce material which undercuts that presented by the Roman religious calendar, staled in several places in her monograph, e.g. (1995) 25: "within this poem Greek myth and astronomical lore in particular often run counter to the ideals emblematized by the monuments and festivals whose origin and character Ovid attempts to explain'. I have argued elsewhere (Gee 2000: 126-53) that there is not an obvious disparity between astronomy and panegyric, rather the reverse: Hellenistic astronomical writing such as Aralus* PhtmunnaM and Callimacfaus' Lock of Berenice could he seen as to some degree a product of the desire of the Hellenistic monarchies to insert themselves into the cosmos and to dominate it, &$ well as their earthly realm, by their scientific knowledge- If this is the ca.se, it was appropriate to his time that Ovid should attempt its synthesis with archaic and contemporary Roman cult, the festivals of which were devised or revived by the monarch Augustus in his role as Rome's second founder, who also tried to insert himself into the cosmos (see Hardie 1986/Kira'm; Herbert-Brown 1997),
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI
59
the Orion episode and that of the Mars Ultor passage which follows it. Is this true? Let us explore further. It may prove possible to modify to some extent Newlands's stark dichotomy between Orion and Mars, and to come up with a different kind of reading of the passage, especially if it can be tied in with the Robigalia also. Certainly, the Mars Ultor passage is predominantly epic in tone. In epic contrast to the predominantly agricultural treatment of Orion in the preceding episode, the heavenly bodies, including the invisible Orion, hasten their course at Fasti 5. 545 to make way for the epiphany of Mars, and for commemoration of the deeds of his victorious descendant Augustus, the anniversary of whose imperium Ovid has already prefaced with the same cosmological conceit (Fasti 4. 673-6): hanc quondam Cytherea diem properanlius ire iussit et admissos praecipitavit equos, ut titulum imperil cum pritnum luce sequenti Augusto iuveni prospera bella darent. Cytherea once commanded this day to rush, And quickly sank its galloping horses, So the next day's triumph might more quickly name The young Augustus as imperator.
Ennius, in the longest extant fragment of his Scipio, used a similar image:23 mundus caeli vastus constitit silentio et Neptunus saevus undis aspens pausani dedit, Sol equis iter repressit ungulis volantibus, constitere amnes perennes, arbores vento vacant. The huge dome of the heavens stood still in silence and harsh Neptune checked die rough waves, the Sun held back the course of his horses with their winged hooves, the ever-iowing rivers stopped, the trees are devoid of wind.
Programmatic value may be ascribed to Fasti 5. 545-98, where the epiphany of Mars generates martial and patriotic subjects meriting epic treatment.24 Line 575 in particular 23
Vahlen (1928) 214, Varia fr. 6. (My translation.) Barchictii (1997) 126: 'Ovid shows us that when he wants to he is perfectly able to write in the antique style used by Virgil in his epic.* 74
6o
EMMA GEE
supports this view, where Octavian prays at Philippi, 'Mars, ades et satia scelerato sanguine ferrum.'25 The sigmatic nature of the verse imparts added solemnity, reminiscent of the speech of Aeneas in Aeneid VI. 948 f., 'Pallas ... poenam scelerato ex sanguine sumit,' The motif of vengeance in Ovid seems to fit; Augustus, the new Aeneas, exacts revenge as a prelude to his re-foundation of Rome. The Princeps has donned for Ovid the mask of an epic hero, and his temple to Mars contains the gateway to epic poetry. At Fasti 5. 567 f., the god looks down on his temple, which the name of Caesar renders greater: special et Augusta praetextum nomine templutn, et visum lecto Caesare nmius opus. He gazes at the temple fringed with Augustus' name, And thinks the work greater when Caesar's read.
Maius opus can also signal a move towards Iliadic subject matter, as it does in the second proem of the Aeneid (Aen. 7. 44 £, 'maior rerum mihi nascitur ordo, mains opus moveo'). The wars which follow fulfil this programme; the temple, itself a 'maius opus', acts as a metaphor for Ovid's attempt at a 'maius opus' in the poetic sense. Here, however, we run into a possibility which begins to break down Newlands's strict opposition between Mars and Orion. If one were to think of a model for a temple as metaphor for epic poetry, as the temple of Mars Ultor in the Fasti may be, the one that springs to mind iinrnediately is again from the Georgia: the proem to Georgia 3, where Virgil projects an imaginary work of art, a temple which is a metaphor for an epic with Caesar as its centrepiece. It is interesting to ponder the relationship between Virgil's metaphorical temple and its 'real' counterpart in Ovid. At first sight, the general structure of the passages is dissimilar. The Ovidian passage is ternary in form [constellation Orion/Games of Mars/constellation of Pleiades), with the two introductory couplets forming a miniature 'cosmic setting*-1' for Ovid's record of historical events and their contemporary 25 26
On this speech, see Barchiesi (1997) 126-HO. Bardie (198ft) 64 for the term.
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI
61
associations; in Virgil the temple begins a book, and is an extended development of the divine invocation with which each book of the Georgia begins. Initially, the function of each passage seems different also: the proem to Georgics 3 is programmatic, while the Ovidian passage records the advent of the Games of Mars in the Roman year. But we have already seen the programmatic nature of Ovid's temple in the Fasti; and allusion to the proem of Georgics 3 is particularly appropriate at this point in the Fasti, since the proem to Georgics 3 represents the intersection of epic and didactic poetry, the presence of a projected epic (incorporating epic subjects and language in microcosm) in a didactic poem. There are individual similarities too. For example, Caesar's victories occupy the centre of each tableau. In Fasti 5. 557 L conquest of the East is a step towards total domination, of East and West; in Georg. 3, 22—33, the Britons woven into the curtains of Virgil's festal stage, and the figures on the temple doors cover between them East and West, in the context of domination by Rome. The stock motif of fleeing Parthian archers occurs in both authors (Fasti 5, 581, 591; Georg, 3. 31). The real Parthian wars in the Fasti, which led to the foundation of the temple there commemorated, parallel the wars which act as decorative elements in Virgil's temple. Likewise, the statues in Ovid's temple parallel the imaginary" ancestral statues of Georg, 3. 34-6, Martial games occur in both passages (Fasti 5. 597 f., Georg. 3, 17-22), Ovid's are real games, Virgil's metaphorical. The division, however, is blurred, for, as Mynors points out in his commentary, Virgil may have had in mind the Ludi victoriae Caesaris, or the games for the dedication of the Aeries Veneris Genetricis in 46 BC, or the five-yearly Actian Games inaugurated at Augustus' augmentation of the temple of Apollo at Actium and founding of the town of Nicopolis.27 In Virgil there is a blurring between ekphrasis and history. Virgil's symbolic temple and precinct have other features which might be recognizable from edifices in Rome. The structure of the temple may be loosely based, according to Mynors, on Julius Caesar's temple, of which Virgil may have 27
Mynors (1990) ad Georg. 3.
62
EMMA GEE
seen the dedication in August 29 DC, or on that of the Palatine Apollo, dedicated in October 28 BC, the doors of which, as in Georgics 3. 26, were decorated in gold and ivory ('et valvae, Libyci nobile dentis opus', Propertius 2. 31. 12).28 Thus poetic fabrication in Virgil takes its inspiration from reality. Conversely, if Ovid has this passage of Virgil in mind, his vision of the temple of Mars Ultor is inspired by poetic art. Ovid and Virgil are united here by slippage between poetic imagery and Roman topography. But there is one difference between Ovid's temple of Mars Ultor and Virgil's temple of Octavian. Virgil mentions the Parthian wars only; Ovid couples them with Philippi, making Mars twofold avenger (Fasti 5. 595), Virgil did not count Philippi among the subjects for his military panegyric of Octavian.-8 In fact, Philippi in the Georgics belongs in quite a different run of imagery, the portents at the end of Georgia I (461-97; the passage is quoted in full as the Appendix to this chapter). This passage develops out of Virgil's explication of sun-signs, aimed at the watchful farmer, and culminates, via portents for the murder of Caesar and the battle of Philippi, in a scene of farmers in a later time of peace unearthing rusty weapons and greater-than-human bones. Here is the Philippi sequence at Georg. 1. 487-92: non alias caelo ceciderunt plura sereno fulgura nee diri totiens arsere cometae. ergo inter sese paribus concurrere telis Rotnanas acies itcrutn videre Philippi; nee fuit indignum superis bis sanguine nostro Emathiam et latos Haemi pinguescere campus. Never elsewhere have lightnings flickered so constantly In a clear sky, or baleful comets burned so often. Thus it ensued that Philippi's field saw Roman armies Once again engaged in the shock of civil war; And the High Ones did not think it a shame that we should twice Enrich with our blood Emathia and the broad plains of Haemus. 2 * On the possible relationship of the temple in Georgia 3 with the Palatine temple of Apollo, see also Hardie (1986) 123. *"' lliis might support the argument of Herbert-Brown (1994) 107 that the vow at Philippi was invented after the death of Gains in 2 Be (see n. Mi above),
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI
63
There is nothing glamorous about the Philippi which follows Virgil's set of portents: the weapons come from the same side ('paribus telis'), and the blood is Rome's own ('sanguine nostro'). Mars, the 'deo ... bis ulto' of Fasti 5, 595, is also the god who, in Virgil, presided over the twofold shedding of Roman blood by Romans in Macedonia in 42 Bc.3<> In fact, Virgil's Mars is impius, the reverse of Ovid's Mars Ultor, and instead of bringing about agricultural peace, he deprives the fields of their rightful occupants, as the bellicose corruption of Rome spreads across the world in the apocalypse of Georg. 1. 505-11: tot bella per orbem, Tarn multae scelerum fades, non ullus aratro Dignus honos, squalent abductis arva colonis, E(, curvae rigidurn ("alecs conflantur in ensem. Hint movet Euphrates, illinc Germania bcllum; Vicinae ruptis inter se legibus urbes Arma ferunt; saevit toto Mars impius orbe. There's so much war in the world, Evil has so many faces, the plough so little Honour, the labourers are taken, the fields untended, And the curving sickle is beaten into the sword that yields not. There the East is in arms, here Germany marches: Neighbour cities, breaking their treaties, attack each other: The wicked war-god runs amok through all the world.
In the Mars Ultor passage, Ovid runs into a problem: for whatever reason, he wants the Philippi vow as one reason for the dedication of the temple of Mars Ultor, but at the same time, his didactic predecessor, whom the astronomical passage which forms the 'cosmic setting' for the temple evokes, presented Philippi in a profoundly negative light. Not only that, but if one reads the Mars Ultor passage with the VirgiMan sequence from the end of Georgi.cs 1, we are reminded that war must be seen as a profoundly damaging influence on agriculture. There is another point at which the end of Georgics 1 may underlie Ovid's Mars episode, and this may help us to show how the passages we have looked at in Fasti 4 and 5 are M>
'Bis' in the Virgilian context refers to the battles of 27 Oct. 42 IK: and 16 Nov. 42 BC, in which Cassius and Brutus were defeated.
64
EMMA GEE
linked with one another by a common model and a common ethical concern, a concern present throughout the Fasti but particularly evident through study of astronomy and agriculture. At Fasti 5. 549-50, the sound of Mars' arrival is the thunder-like clash of arms, 'bellica signa': Fallor, an arma sonant? Non fallimur, arma sonabant: Mars venit et veniens bellica signa cledit, Am I deceived, or is there a sound of arms? 1 aim not deceived: arms did sound. He has come, and has given the signs for war,"
The iunctura of signum and dare occurs twice in this passage from the end of the first book of Virgil's Georgics (Georg. 1. 463, 'sol tibi signa dabit', and 470 f., 'obscenaeque canes importunaeque volucres signa dabant'}, A heavenly clash of arms, like Mars' 'bellica signa* in the Fasti, also occurs in this passage of the Georgics, After the death of Caesar, which led to the civil wars, the clash of arms was heard over Germany: 'armorum sonitum toto Germania caelo | audiit', Georg. 1, 474 f. This is like the clash of arms which precedes the advent of Mars in Fasti 5. Does Fasti 5, in which Philippi is turned into a triumphant episode in the consolidation of the Principate, serve to update Virgilian pessimism in the light of the security of the later Augustan period? Or, by recalling Virgil's Philippi, must we see Augustus' patron Mars in a less positive light? One would expect martial imagery in the Mars Ultor passage, whether or not it rings alarm bells in relation to Philippi; one might also expect such imagery to differentiate the Mars passage, not only from the Orion passage which precedes It, but also from agricultural passages such as the Robigalia. In fact, this may not be the case. The same Virgilian passage may be present at a substrate level in Ovid's Robigalia, an episode we have previously thought of as being, straightforwardly, about agricultural peace. The iunctura of signum and dare also occurs in the Robigalia: 'signaque danl imbres, exoriturque Cards' (Fasti 4. 904). This alone would not be enough to make the reader recall Virgil's '*' My translation.
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI
65
32
apocalypse; but there may be more. Compare Fasti 4. 936, 'turpiaque obscenae (vidimus) exta cants' ('the disgusting entrails—I saw them—of a filthy dog'), with Georgia I. 471-2, ^obscenaeque canes importunaeque volucres [ signa dabanf ('Filthy dogs and birds of ill omen gave the signs'). In Fasti 4. 92330 the flamen prays that Robigo will attack weapons, not tools; but, having read the end of the first book of the Georgia we know that rusty weapons are only bought at the price of internecine carnage at the battle of Philippi (Georg. 1. 493-5): scilicet et tempus veniet cum finibus illis, agricola incurvo terrain molitus aratro exesa inveniet scabra robigine pila. Surely the time will come when a farmer on those frontiers Forcing through die earth his curved plough Shall find old spears eaten away with flaky rust,
Ovid ties us in very closely at the end of the fourth book of the Fasti with the end of the Erst book of Virgil's Georgics. In Virgil, the transition through meteorological signs and heliological portents of Caesar's murder to civil war leads to the apocalyptic end of the first book of the Georgics, What is the effect of this on the interpretation of the Robigalia? The Robigo episode may be related to the agricultural aftermath of civil war at the end of the first book of the Georgicy, does this serve to reinforce the rhetoric of peace, or to fracture the idyll? Is Newlands in fact right to postulate a clash between pastoral Orion and warlike Mars, and is Mars also in opposition to the pastoral peace of the Robigalia? Or does a Virgilian vision of the fragility of agricultural peace underlie Mars, Orion, and the Robigalia together? It would be possible to argue that war in fact unites the passages we have studied from Fasti 4 and Fasti 5. Astronomy can prove helpful here too. Is there, for a start, such an opposition between Orion and Mars as Newlands postulates? Certainly Ovid's version of the Orion tale may underplay Orion's warlike aspects, but in fact the huge constellation is a fitting analogue for the martial Augustus who follows in the Mars ;
'~ The iunctuniis probably common in prognostic literature in the Aratean tradition; see also Cicero, Anita 190, for example.
66
EMMA GEE
Ultor episode. Epic credentials can be found for Orion. He expresses the size and might of Mezentius entering battle at Aeneid 10. 762-5; he is described in the Virgilian epic as 'magnus, saevus, ninibosus, aquosus', and—like Mars—he carries weapons, being 'armatus'.*3 Manilius, Astronomica 1. 501-5, written perhaps at the same time as the revision stage of the Fasti and therefore reflecting astrological beliefs roughly contemporary with Ovid, M may hint at Orion presiding over the Trojan War: iara turn, cum Graiae verterunt Pergama gentes, Arctos et Orion adversis frontibus ibant, haec contenta suos in vertice flectere gyros, ille ex diverse vertentem surgere contra obvius et toto semper decurrere mundo. Already when the Greeks overthrew Troy the Bear and Orion moved with fronts opposed, she content to describe her gyrations at the pole, he rising to i'ace her in opposition as she wheels on the other side and to traverse forever the whole sky,8'5
Manilius (Astron. 5. 12) describes Orion as 'magni pars maxima caeli* (the greatest part of the great heaven). In Fasti 5. 537, "creverat immensum', the giant's size is the only piece of information we are given about his life. It is enough, however, to enable us to see a continuity between his episode and the Mars Ultor passage which follows, in which the size of the temple matches the size of the god: 'et deus est ingens et opus* ('Both the god and the work are massive', Fasti 5. 553). Orion is the 'dux* ('general') of all the other stars at Astronomica 1. 395: 'hoc duce per totum decurrunt sidera mundum'. Perhaps this shows why he might also be an. appropriate celestial analogue for Augustus, mention of whom just precedes Orion in the Astronomical and follows Orion in the Fasti. 3-3 Aen. 7. 71.9 f.: 'saevus ubi Orion hiberois conditur undis, | vel cum sole novo densae torrentur'; Aen, 1. 535: 'nimbosus Orion'; Aen, 4. 52t: 'dura peiago desaevit hierns et aquosus Orion, | quassataeque rates, dorn non tractabile caelum'; Aen, 3. .517 f,; 'Hyadas geminosque Triones, | armaluinqut; auru eireumspidl Oriona.' 44 On the comparability of Manilius arid Ovid, see Herbert-Brown in this volume. :w Trans. Goold( 1977)." •to Manilius, Astron. 1. 385 f,: 'Augusto, sidus nostro qui contigit orbi, legurn nunc terris post caelo maximus auctor' ('Augustus, who like ft star has fallen to the fortune of our world: greatest lawgiver is h<» now on earth, in heaven will be hereafter*). For Orion's natives, see Ast. 5, 57 IT.
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI
67
The huge, armed constellation of Orion is a good one to precede martial subjects. Orion is an epic constellation, introducing Mars, an epic god. Both are savage, although Mars is more successful in being so. The opposition between Orion and Mars is weakened if one takes a more holistic view of the astronomical material in the poem, comparing astronomical material with other astronomical texts of a kind that Ovid and his readers may have been able to bring to bear on the Fasti Sirius too has epic credentials, appearing in a martial simile at Aeneid 10. 269-75, for example. Here Sirius is a plaguebringer, on a par with portentous comets, and suitable for describing a wrathful warrior. Indeed, his astrological significance is related to war: he causes war and brings back peace ('bella facit pacemque refert': Manilius 1. 405). He is thus also an appropriate constellation in the context in, which he is placed in the Fasti, in a passage which involves an opposition between agricultural peace and war, an opposition not as clear as it might be. The 'otium* of Fasti 4. 926, a celebration of the Pax Augusta which follows the catastrophe of civil war, may be complicated by the opening and closing motif of the passage, the violent and vacillating star Sirius.
(v) Conclusion The stars point us toward the Georgics as a model for the Fasti Virgil's work provides a didactic subtext that unites Mars, Orion, and the Robigalia. But there are two ways of interpreting the relation between Ovid and his agricultural didactic model: either Ovid is presenting a sequel to the Georgics which modifies Virgilian pessimism in the light of Augustan peace, or the Geofgic subtext to the passages of the Fasti we have studied forces on the reader the fragility of that peace. The associations of both of the constellations we have studied might seem to give war the upper hand. Astronomical 'errors', such as Ovid's note of the rising of the Dog-Star when it actually sets, might help us to interpret the poem, insofar as they could be considered as evidence that Ovid intended to create certain effects in his poem, choosing
68
EMMA GEE
and positioning stars and even festivals according to the dictates of theme and allusive potential rather than of technical accuracy. In the case of both Sirius and Orion, it is notable that an absent star is made to be present, although in two different ways: in Fasti4, Ovid has Sirius rise instead of set, and in Fasti 5 Ovid notes that Orion sets, but gives the aetiology of the constellation anyway. This may be because in both instances the constellation adds to our understanding of Ovid's programme in the respective episodes, and in the Fasti as a whole. For example, as we have seen, in the Robigalia Ovid chooses to emphasize the Dog rather than the Rani. This may be because the Dog had warlike associations, whereas the Ram did not;37 and Ovid may have wished to bring warlike associations to the otherwise peaceful Robigalia, which, when, read also with Virgil's Georgics in mind, can function as a moral commentary on the Pax Augusta,
Appendix: Virgil, Georgics L 461-97, with translation (C. Day Lewis) Denique, quid Vesper serus vehat, uncle serenas ventus agat nubes, quid cogitet urnidus Auster sol tibi signa dabit. solem quis dicere falsum aucteat? ille etiam caecos instare tumultus saepc tnonet fraudemque ct operta turnescere bclla. ille etiam exstincto miseratus Caesare Ronuun, cum caput obscura nitidutn ferrugine texit itnpiaque aetcrnam timucrunt saccula noctcni. lernpore quarnquam illo tellus quuquc el aequora ponli obscenaeque caees importunaeque volucres signa dabant. quotiens Cyclopum effervere in agros vidimus undantcm ruptis fornacibus Aetnam, flammarumquc globos liquefaetaque volvere saxa! armorurn sonitnin tolo Germania caelo audiit, insolitis tremuerunt motibus Alpes,
46.5
470
47,5
;w Unlike Sirius and Orion, who appear at Aeneid 10. 269-75 and 10. 762-5, he does not seem to figure in the astronomical repertoire of Vtrgiliaa epic. His natives in Manilius, Astron. 4. 124-39 are skilled in crafts like wool-working (unsurprisingly) and other peaceful pursuits.
ORION AND SIRIUS IN OVID'S FASTI vox quoque per lucos vulgo exaudita silentis ingens, et simulacra modis pallentia miris visa sub obscurum noctis, pecudesque locutae (infandum!); sistunt amnes terraeque dehiscunt et maestum inlacrimat tempiis ebur aeraque sudant. proluit insano contorquens vertice silvas fluviorum rex Eridanus camposque per omnis cum stabulis armenta tulit. nee tempore eodem tristibus ant extis fibrae apparere minaces aut puteis manare craor cessavit, et altae per nocteni resonare lupis ululantibus urbes, non alias caelo ceciderunt plura sereno fulgura nee diri totiens arsere cometae. ergo inter sese paribus concurrere telis Rotnanas acies iterum videre Philippi; nee fuit indignum superis bis sanguine nostro Ematbiatn el lalos Haemi pinguescere campus. scilicet et tempus veniet cum finibus illis agricola incurvo terrain molitus aratro exesa inveniet scabra robigine pila, aut gravibus rastris galeas pulsabit inaois, grandiaque eflbssis mirabitur ossa sepulchris,
69
480
485
490
495
Lastly, what the late evening conveys, from whence the wind drives Fine-weather clouds, and what damp south wind is brooding. The sun discloses. Who dares call the sun a liar? Often too he warns you of lurking immanent violence. Of treachery, and wars that grow in the dark like a cancer, 46,5 The sun, when Caesar fell, had sympathy for Rome— That day he hid the brightness of his head in a rusty fog And an evil age was afraid his night would last for ever: Though at that time the earth as well, the waves of the sea, 470 Mongrels and birds morose Gave tongue to the doom. How often we saw Mount Aetna deluge The fields of the Cyclops with lava from her cracked furnaces, Rolling up great balls of flame and molten rocks! In Germany they heard a clash of fighting echo Through the whole sky: the Alps shook with unnatural shudders, 475 Likewise in stilly woods a voice was heard by many— A monster voice, and phantoms miraculously pale Were met at the dusk of night, and cattle spoke—an omen Unspeakable! Rivers stopped, the earth gaped, and ivories In temples wept sad tears and brazen images sweated, 480 Po, the king of rivers, in maniac spate whirled round
JO
EMMA GEE
Forests, washed them away, swept all over the plains Herds and their byres together, A time it was when the guts of Woe-working victims never failed to reveal the worst Nor wells to seep with blood 485 Nor high-built cities to sound all night with the wolves' howling, Never elsewhere have lightnings flickered so constantly In a clear sky, or baleful comets burned so often. Thus it ensued that Philippi's field saw Roman armies Once again engaged in the shock of civil war; 490 And. the High Ones did not think it a shame that we should twice Enrich with, our blood Emathia and the broad plains of Haemus. Surely the time will come when a farmer on those frontiers Forcing through the earth Ms curved plough 495 Shall find old spears eaten away with flaky rust, Or hit upon, helmets as he wields the weight of his mattock And marvel at the heroic bones he has disinterred.
4
Varro's Three Theologies and their Influence on the Fasti C. M. C. GREEN
This chapter is an attempt, based on a re-examination of Varro's Rerum Divinamm, to reconstruct the religious thought that lies behind Ovid's Fasti, a work which, despite the sensitive and complex readings of the most recent scholarship,1 nevertheless remains difficult, because its true subject, Roman religion, has not been adequately engaged as such (Johnson 1992; Phillips 1992: 73). It is my contention that, even from the relatively few surviving fragments of the RD, we can derive at least part of a recognizable Roman theology—that is, a ratio, an accounting of the divine from a specifically Roman perspective—and that this theology underlies Ovid's elegiac poem on the calendar. Educated men (and not a few of the uneducated) had long ceased to believe in the anthropomorphic gods; but that did not mean that they ceased to find significance in the religious phenomena of inherited cult, ritual, and prayer. The Hellenistic tradition on which Varro based his work maintained to a great extent, and in a multiplicity of ways, the significance of these phenomena, most often through rationalization or by metaphorical transference to serve the higher needs of philosophy. The result was that while gods and cults retained their place in Rome's widening physical and intellectual world, just how that divine element was understood kept constantly changing (Beard 1987: 3). In Roman, religion, the coexistence of competing", contradictory narratives and rituals inherited from both Italic and Greek 1
In particular, the monographs of Miller (1991), Herbert-Brown (1994), Newlands (1995), and Barchiesi (1997).
72
C, M. C, GREEN
cultural tradition did not inspire the need to organize, or privilege, on any absolute rational basis (Beard 1987: 7; Feeney 1998: 137—43), Roman religion to an extraordinary degree was, and always had been, a religion of interpretation, as the competition of auguries between Romulus and Remus dramatizes so well: is the sign given to the one who is first, with six vultures, or to the one who, though second, has twelve? The virtue of each interpretation remains strictly relative to its use (Scheid 1992a: 129), being determined by the function a philosopher like Varro, a poet like Ovid, or a politician like Augustus will assign to it. There is also in the RD, as we shall see, a critical theory, which, though rudimentary, surely guided a poet like Ovid when treating the cult and religion of his ancestors. Homer, Hesiod, and the tragedians had always been considered sources of religious knowledge. Poets therefore had a necessary, if often uncomfortable, part in any discourse on religion. To see how Ovid assumes this poet's approach to religion, I will take Book 4, covering the month of April, to demonstrate how this Varronian theology fed Ovid's vision. In particular, I will demonstrate how it guided his selection of narratives, and his choice of poetic imagery within those narratives, with the object of creating a unified poetic vision of Roman religion. I
Varro himself was not concerned with the calendar as such,2 but with a presentation of the grand scheme of Roman religious life (Cic. Acad. post. fir. 22 Miiller; Cardauns, Testimonia 1 j: Turn ego, 'Sunt', inquam, 'ista, Varro; nam BOS in nostra urbe peregrinantis errantisque tamquara hospites tui libri quasi domura reduxerunt, ut possemus aliquando qui et obi esserous agnoscere. Tu aetatem patriae, tu discriptioues temporiitn, lu sacrorurn iura, tu saterdotuni, tu dotneslic.ain, tu bellicam disciplinam, lu sedeni regionum, locorum, tu omnium divinarum humanarumque rerum nomina, genera, ofiicia, causas aperuisti.' * The arrangement oi the 1U) has been preserved by Atigusline. There wt'tc tour subjects, each treated in three books: the first triad dealt with the men involved, the second with the places, the third with the times, the fourth with the actual rites, The last three books treated the gods themselves with a separate hook as the introduction (August. CD (), 3).
VARRO'S THREE THEOLOGIES
73
Then I said: 'These are the [important] things, Va.no: your books have led us as it were home, when we were wandering and going astray like new arrivals, so that we 'were able to recognize who we were and where we were. You have revealed to us the life of our fatherland, the descriptions of the seasons, the laws of sacred rituals, die disciplines of the priests, the conduct of domestic and military affairs; you have clariied the position of the regions and districts, as well as the names, kinds, functions, and causes of all divine and human matters.'3
Cicero's estimation of Varro's work, though perhaps effusive, is supported by the evidence. This was no mere written rehearsal of the details of cult and priesthood, Varro provided a new way of looking at Rome and her gods. In some way he had the effect of revealing their world to the Romans, and presenting Rome itself as a city both divinely distinguished, and marked out by sacred spaces which had meaning and purpose in both the micro- and the macrocosm (Cancik 1985-6). Varro's work, moreover, as well as looking back to the religion of the past, looked forward to the new rulers rising from the chaos of civil war. Varro had been born a few years after the death of Gaius Gracchus; he served Pompey in the war against the pirates (Pliny, NH16. 3); he opposed and satirized the triumvirate (Men. 556, TpiKapavos, ['The Three-Headed Monster']), and served Pompey in the civil war (Caes. BC 2. 17-22). Although Caesar pardoned him, Antony remained bitter, possibly because of Varro's satirical attacks, and after Caesar's death had him proscribed (Cic. Phil 2. 102-5). This was not the life of a man who despised politics. The books of the Antiquitates Rerum.were dedicated to the Pontifex Maximus, Julius Caesar.1 He and Augustus were without question the benefactors of Varro's creation: a theological, concept of Rome grounded in her inherited civic, intellectual, and religious traditions.5 ' All translations are aw own, unless otherwise noted. 4 The Antiquilntei is conventionally dated to the period allt'r Pharsalus. Jocelyn {1982} 164—74 prefers a date between 58 and 55, and sees Varro as a detached cynic; conlro, Boissier (1861) and Zauker (1!)88) 103, supported now by Lehmann (1997), who makes the case for Varro with clarity. •'Johnson (1978) 13 is correct in calling Augustas 'the Roman Ptolemy', and in perceiving thai Augustan religion was 'in fact the old religion of the Ptolemies made new for Rome and her renewed empire' (14, with notes). He errs greatly, however, as do most scholars, in supposing that this sort of religion was cynically political {16).
74
C, M. C, GREEN
Varro's understanding of divinity was what we would have expected from so deeply educated and civilized a man. Anthropomorphism, like so many other aspects of religion as practised in his world, was a survival which, he acknowledged, encouraged contempt as often as respect (Cardauns 12): non se ilia iudicio stio sequi, quae civitatem Romanam instituisse... si earn civitatem novam constitueret, ex naturae potius formula deos nominaque eoruni se fuisse dedicaturum.,. sed iam quoniam in vetere populo esset, aeceptam ab antiquis nominurn et cognoniinum historiam tenere, ut tradita est, debere se... et ad eum finera ilia scribere ac perscrutari, ut potius eos magis colere quam despicere vulgus velit, [He said] his own judgement did not concur with the institutions the Roman state had established... if he were to found a new state, he would have dedicated the gods and their names rather from a formula of nature... but since it already existed for people in antiquity, he ought to retain the traditional history of the names and titles received from antiquity, as handed down,... and to that end wrote up and assessed these matters in such a way that the common people might prefer to cultivate them [the gods] rather than despise them.
Varro, however, wrote for men like himself, and thus assumed that intellectual history from Xenophanes to Posidonius would be reasonably familiar to them (Cardauns 8). Furthermore, he expected his readers to be guided by a philosophic rationale like his own, which took it for granted that gods, cults, ritual, and all their artistic and interpretative offshoots were human constructs. The Antiquitateswere organized so that human affairs were treated first, and divine affairs second, both being centred on Rome (Cardauns 5). There is no mistaking the importance he attached to the connection between the state—Rome—and divinity. His intention in writing the RD was to rescue the inherited sacred structure—gods, ritual, and priesthood—from the indifference of the people (Cardauns 2a): se timere ne pereant \sc. dei], non incursu hostili, sed civium neglegentia, de qua illos velut ruina libcrari a se jdicit] et in mcmoria bonorum per eius modi libros recondi atque servari utiliore cura, quam (qua) Metellus de ineendio sacra Vestalia et Aeneas de Troiano excidio penates liberasse praedicatur. He said that he feared that the gods might perish, not through hostile encroachment, bat because of negligence on the part of the citizens, from
VARRO'S THREE THEOLOGIES
75
which (he says) they were rescued by him as from a collapsing building, and refounded in the memory of good men through his books and preserved by a more practical kind of care than that by which Metellus is said to have rescued the sacred items of the Vestals from the fire, and Aeneas when saving the Penates from Troy's destruction.6
Yet it would be a serious error to suppose that Varro was writing in the hope of somehow persuading the 'vulgus' to embrace religion: his work was for the 'boni', the men of his own class. His intention, in terms of religion, was one recognized by most natural philosophers: ocu^ew rd tj>aiv6(j^va, 'to save the appearances'.7 The appearances, after all, were where one began.8 His more immediate purpose, drawing on philosophy, comparative anthropology, and the work of poets and artists, was to explain to the Romans themselves what they did, and how it made sense in the greater scheme of things. To a great extent he must have achieved his purpose. The accumulated remnants of an old (therefore provincial, primitive and, probably, embarrassing), non-Greek (therefore barbarian), and non-philosophical (therefore not capable of logical explication) religious tradition, now had ratio, that untranslatable hallmark of Roman respectability, one key part of which was, precisely, systemization. Varro organized his source material into three categories: the poetic, the civic, and the philosophical (Cardauns 7/August CD6. 5): tria genera theologian,,. esse, id est rationis, quae de diis explicate, eommque unum mythicon appellari, alterum physicon, tertium civile... rnythicon appellant, quo roaxime utuntur poetae; physicon, quo philosophi; civile, quo populi. [He said) there are three kinds of theology, that is, of a logic seeking to explicate the gods. Of these one is called 'mythic', the second, 'natural', and " Reading Hoffmann's emendation quam (tjun), which is necessary to the meaning. This passage i n itself refutesjocelyn's view of Varro and the RD (cf. above, n. 4). Varro here casts himself in the heroic mould proper to saviours of Roman 'sacra'. These are not the words of a detached cynic. 7 Lloyd's observations (1978; repr. 1991) 251-2, on the methodology of scientific philosophy, are equally applicable to religious philosophy. * Contemporary with Ovid, or perhaps a little later, is the mysterious Heraditus, who assembled the rationalizing explanations for Homer's gods (Buffiere 1!M>2).
76
C, M. C, GREEN
the third, 'civic'... the one they call 'mythic' is that most especially used by poets; the 'natural', by the philosophers; and the 'civic', by the people.
In particular, he seems to have been concerned that literature and art—the theology of myth—undermined the 'dignitas' of the gods, and provided a representation contrary to the 'natura' of the divine (Cardauns 7), Varro's concern is old: it can be traced back at least as far as Xenophanes, who vigorously criticized the immorality of Homer and Hesiod (Kirk and Raven 1971: 169). Plato too had banished poets from the polis because of the baleful effect on the people (Rep. 10. 605-8). Certainly Varro's concern to mitigate the apparent immorality of the gods as found in literature and art would have appealed to Augustus, even if it did not actively shape his opinions on the matter. Nevertheless, despite the fact that he disapproved of the 'theology of the poets' and placed a higher value on philosophical explanations than, on inherited ritual or practice, he excluded no material arbitrarily. There is one other aspect of Varro's view of the gods and their presentation in the management of the state that we must consider, before we turn to the use Ovid made of the AD (Cardauns 20f): Utile esse dvitatibus . . . ut se viri fortes, etiarasi faLsum sit, diis gcnitos esse credant, ut eo modo animus humanus velut divinae stirpis fiduciam gerens res magnas adgrediendas praesuraat audacius, agat vehementius et ob hoc impleat ipsa securitate felicius. |He said| it is useful for states thai strong men should—even if it is untrue— believe that they are descended from gods, so that in this way the human spirit, bearing, as it were, the guarantee of divine ancestry, might the more daringly anticipate great deeds that are worthy to be done, perform them with greater determination, and thus carry them out the more successfully by reason of their own confidence.
So, although Varro held no brief for the anthropomorphism of the gods—on which single premiss any political argument for divine descent must rest-and despite the fact that he regarded human claims to divine ancestry as patently false, he readily acknowledged the advantages inherent in both these concepts for promoting the well-being of the state. This adaptiveness was part of the legacy the Romans received from the historians of
VARRO'S THREE THEOLOGIES
77
the Pharaohs and the Persian kings, supported by Euhernerism (which held that the gods were originally men who had benefited their people) and the self-deification of Alexander the Great, all filtered down in terms of practical politics through the ruler-cults of the Ptolemaic and other, lesser, Hellenistic dynasties. That Varro, a Republican through and through, could take this stand is very important for our understanding of Augustus, his much-touted Julian descent from Venus, and the ways in which men from the ruling class—of whom Ovid was one—were expected to deal with it" Thus there are three things that we can be reasonably certain Ovid found in Varro, First, a tripartite classification which divided the material on the divine into the theology of the poets (including Homer, the tragedians, and the rest of Greek as well as Latin poetry), the theology of the state, and the theology of the philosophers."' Second, some sort of arrangement of" those theologies in a system primarily intended to explicate Roman religion for the benefit of Rome and its ruling class. Finally, an underlying tension, acknowledged by Varro, between the immoralities of poetic theology and the moral needs of civic theology, on the one hand, and on the other, between the philosophers' explication of the divine, and the combined peculiarities of civic theology and the theology of the poets (Cardauns 228): De diis... populi Roman! publicis, quibus aedes dedicaverunt eosque pluribus signis omatos notaverunt-, in hoc libro seriham, scd ut Xenophanes Colophonios scribit, quid putern, non quid contendam, ponatn, Horninis est enim haec opinari, dei scire. In this book I will write about the public gods of the Roman people, to whom they have consecrated temples and whom they have distinguished by the setting up of numerous statues, but, as Xenophanes of Colophon writes, I will put down what I think is the case, not what I would argue for [ ? The distinction between, conclusions drawn from the evidence and the logical argument of philosophy?]. It is for man to have opinions, and for god to know. w Varro is thus proposing to the ruling class that they practise collusion with Viri fortes' in a mild but necessary deception. Alexander is clearly in his mind, as are men like Scipio Africaitus, 10 Schilling rightly claimed (1954: 152} that Ovid frequently presents a 'triple point of view'; but has missed the Varronian source, and its implications.
78
C, M. C, GREEN
How Varro himself resolved these tensions is unrecoverable; but by now it should at least be clear that Ovid did not undertake to write the Fasti without a generic model for dealing with them: Varro's tripartite system, well known among his educated readers, and already established as acceptable to the Princeps. II
The fragments of the Remm Dwinarum concerning specific deities and rituals are frustratingly sparse, but those we do possess, backed up with the Lingua Latino and the Res Rusticae, at least permit us to ascertain something about Varro's treatment of the goddess Venus and several of the other deities whose festivals fall in April, and to observe the influence of this material on the Fasti11 First, the most important revelation offered by Varro's discussion of Venus is the fact that he clearly performed a kind of structural analysis of the gods, equating divinities with similar qualities. This is an extension of common Roman practicerecognizing that Zeus, for instance, andJupiter were 'the same'. The 'mother goddesses'—Cybele, Ceres, and Venus—were commonly linked, and it would be no surprise if these goddesses were on his list. Varro's equations, however, are in fact far less predictable. The fragments tell us that he equated Venus and Libera (Cardauns 93); Venus and Luna (Cardauns 179); and Venus and Vesta (Cardauns 283). Libera, he said, is Ceres (Cardauns 260, where Ceres is named, instead of Libera, as the female aspect of Liber); Ceres is Terra, the Earth (Cardauns 270); Tellus, the Earth, is Magna Mater (Cardauns 167, 268), Proserpina, and Vesta (Cardauns 268). We know from the LL that Varro connected the etymology of Venus with Victory through the root 'vincire', in their common sense of 'to bind', and he says that Tellus is called Victory (LL 5. 61-2). Victory and a Sabine goddess Vacuna are the same (Cardauns 1; Vacuna means 'goddess of free time'), and the context of this fragment supports the supposition that Victory 11 Throughout I use the text of Faiitbam (1SW8). Her commentary is a paradigm of the best kind of scholarship, a thoughtful guide through the maze of previous exegesis, and an encouraging aid to the development of one's own.
VARRO'S THREE THEOLOGIES 12
7Q
and Venus were equated in the RD as well. Rightly did he say 'sed potest... fieri ut eadem res et una sit, et in ea quaedam res sint plures' (Cardauns 268) ('but it can happen that a thing is unitary, while at the same time certain things in it are multiple'). Thus we can see at once that several of the deities whose festivals fall in the month of April are identified with Venus by Varro. We must in particular notice the inclusion in this group of Proserpina, Vesta, and Victoria—all unexpected, but to be important for Ovid's narrative. Since Vesta is included, we have to recognize further that in Varro's system the 'mother' goddess and chastity/virginity are not mutually exclusive: or rather, that our category of 'mother goddess' is not Varro's, and therefore, not Ovid's. Mother and daughter (Ceres and Proserpina) are aspects of the same goddess, and here we see the effect of Varro's rejection of anthropomorphism—it is their function, rather than their quasi-human relationship, that determines the analysis. This, then, was the paradigm for Ovid when he began working on the month of April. Venus, Ceres, Cybele, Tellus, Proserpina, Vesta, and Victory are equated. These several identities are the Many contained in the One, which we can, at least for now, call 'Venus', Next, we know how Varro defined the essence of Venus, that is, the philosophical nature he assigned to her. The most elaborate explanation, deriving ultimately from Presocratic cosmologies, is found in the LL, and there is enough in the RD to make us confident Varro was consistent in this view (Cardauns 280). Venus is born from fire and water, through the conjunction of fire, the highest of the four elements, and water, the lowest (LL 5, 61), She, Venus, is the force of conjunction that leads to generation. This very Pythagorean/Empedoclean notion belongs, of course to the 'theology of the philosophers'. The poetic theology, Varro says, holds that the fiery semen of Zeus fell on the sea, and Venus was then born from the foam, by the conjunction of fire and water (LL 5. 63). Thus when Ovid says (4. 61-2): *Sed Veneris mensem Graio sermone notatum auguror' ('but I surmise/auspicate that the month of Venus is named from the Greek language'), he signals to us with the verb 'auguror' what he is doing. As poetic augur, '- Of. the apparatus crUicus to Cardauns 1,
80
C, M. C, GREEN
he is taking the auspices, and choosing the signs for the month that he will interpret. As a poet, Ovid very properly selects the poetic theology of Venus, thus defining the paramount value of his religious interpretation. This does not mean he rejects alternative views—it is clear he does not—but that he employs them only when and as they serve his purpose. He is selecting from the same cornucopia of source-material as Varro, but since his purpose is different, his selections differ too. Furthermore, Greek derivation allows him to connect his poetic interpretation with philosophic/scientific theology: Zeus is fire/semen, while Earth as water provides the nurturing fluid. Ovid can thus utilize both the poetic ancestry of Venus and the philosophical/scientific tradition associated with the imagery of fire and water. He also accuses those who, like Varro, preferred, an etymology deriving from the Latin 'aperire' ('to open', LL 6. 33) of envy and a desire to deny Venus the honour of the month's name (4. 85-6). Implicitly, of course, he is portraying his own motivations—he intends to honour Venus-but he is also affirming, here as elsewhere, what we have learned from Varro: the decisive factor governing choice of narrative is not 'the truth'.13 Venus, the name of the month, and its nature—that of generation from fire and water—are closely linked in Ovid's chosen etymology. It is important, then, that he still rehearses the Varronian etymology from 'aperire' (87—90), which (as we shall see) he will use as a significant subsidiary imagistic theme, to mark the process ('opening') through which generation occurs. He therefore Integrates it, after restating the principal idea of generation in its most natural form (91-114), into his description of Venus' month (125-8). Having thus identified the month's natural signs—that is, the elements characteristic of that month that will provide Ovid's linking imagery—let us now see how he reports and interprets these signs when shaping his account. The principle of generation, and its ultimate cosmological source, the conjunction of fire and water, as well as the secondary process of'opening', are 13 As Newlands (1995) 69 sees. Herbert-Brown (1994) 89-91 argues for a specific attack on Cincius and Varro. She is right to recognize that Ovid does iii fact accept the conceptual connection between Venus, AptO, and 'aperire', 'The language of growth is replaced by the language of openness* (Fantham 19518 ad 11, 87-8).
VARRO'S THREE THEOLOGIES
8l
both readily discernible in the text once they are recognized as signs. To begin with, once Ovid has asked for Venus' blessing (15-16), he turns immediately to Augustus, and recalls his descent from Venus, that is, the generation that led to Augustus (19-24). An elegant nod backwards to the month of March and Mars (25-6) connects April with its immediate predecessor. Ovid takes the opportunity, in passing, to touch on generation again by showing Romulus in the act of creating the calendar, which he decides to begin with March, Mars being 'sibi nascendi proxima causa' ('the immediate cause of his own birth': 26). This tactful depiction of the calendar as a record of Romulus' piety—a son honouring his divine fatherhas a very Roman colour. We can almost see it as a tableau, or a scene in a relief or wall-painting: in one frame Romulus turns back, to honour his father and make the (visual, gestural, intellectual) connection to the previous month; in the next he turns forward, toward Venus and the month of April. Venus, Lucretius' 'Aeneadum genetrix' (Lucr. 1. 1), of course is the principle of generation. So we watch Romulus seeking out and finding the beginning of his race (29), a minor dramatization of a primitive search for first causes, as Ovid leads his readers back to beginnings, to the generative source, and traces the (Greek epic) genealogy to Venus, Anchises, and Aeneas (31-8), followed by their Latin descendants (39-56). He closes with the assertion that Romulus always claimed Mars and Venus as his ancestors (though Ovid uses the more intimate word, 'parentes'), and that his words deserve 'fides' (57-8). This statement, of course, calls attention to the existence of its opposite, the potential lack of *fides' in such a statement (and, indeed, in the existence of Romulus himself, or, supposing" he did exist, in the likelihood of his having said anything of the sort). Ovid's allusive inclusion of disbelief both acknowledges the nature of the poets' theology, and finesses it, since while allowing Romulus to affirm the morally questionable relationship of Venus and Mars—the account in Homer (Od, 8. 267—366) being the 'locus classicus' of the sort of immorality disseminated by poets—he also takes advantage of that other weakness inherent in poetic treatment of the divine, the sheer unbelievability of it. He then interprets the mythic story as being there to assure the 'Romuli nepotes' that they are indeed
02
C, M. C, GREEN
descended from the gods (59-60). Thus, I would argue, Ovid turns the whole question of the Julian house's divine ancestry back to Varro. Augustus, Germanicus, are the *viri fortes' of whom so much is expected that they are, as it were, from the creation of the calendar, entitled to appropriate divinity to themselves.14 Having thus dealt with the generations from Mars and Venus, Ovid arrives at the point where he assigns the etymology of April to the foam from which Venus/Aphrodite was mythically born. This is another kind of generation, that of words and names, and they are the creation of humankind. In this case, since the original word for foam (a(f>p6s) is Greek, the hurnans must be Greek too; and after the interesting statement that Italy was a Greater Greece, the Greekness of Italy likewise gets its genealogy, by way of the Greek heroes—Hercules, Odysseus—who visited Italy, and the mythic Greek and Trojan founders who created the Italian city states: Evander (Rome), Telegonus (Tusculum), the Argives (Tibur), Halaesus (Falerii), Antenor (Patavium), Aeneas (Rome), and the mysterious Solymus, the eponymous founder of Sulmo. Solymus and Sulmo allow Ovid—'auctor' as 'actor'—to place himself in the genealogy, slipped in, neatly, if somewhat unexpectedly, between Aeneas and Germanicus.15 Ovid then proceeds to demonstrate the conceptual connection between 'aperire' (which comes from natural philosophy, the theology of the 'physici') and the month of Venus. He defines 'opening' as the opening for, the revealing of, generation (87-90): Nam, quia ver aperit tune omnia densaque cedit Frigoris asperitas fetaque terra patet, Aprilem memorant ab aperto tempore dictum Quern Venus iniecta vindicat alma manu.
14 Zankcr (1988) 195-201 well summarizes the difficulties that the adulterous relationship between Venus and Mars presented to the moral and dynastic aims of Augustus, and the ways in which those difficulties were resolved. l:> Scythia is indeed a long way away from all of that—it has no place in the traditional genealogies. We notice, as a result, how elegantly Ovid calls attention to his proper place (in his view) in the order of things, and the utter marginalization and disconnectedness inflicted by his exile,
VARRO'S THREE THEOLOGIES
8g
For, because at that time spring opens everything and the dense harshness of cold yields and the breeding earth lies open, they say that April is named from the aperient season, which nourishing Venus claims as her own by placing her hand on it.
The process is threefold: spring 'opens' everything; the dense harshness of cold yields, and the teeming earth is revealed. This is the pattern for what follows, a descriptive 'ratio' of generation in nature (95—132). Ovid takes us from the creation of the gods to the generation of trees (95-6), further elaborating the idea that Venus' power lies in the process of creation through the transformation of 'asperitas', moving from the cold force of 'contractere' (97), to the gentler 'iungere' (98), then to Voluptas' (99), and finally to 'amor' (100). The transition is from the act ('iungere') to the emotion ('amor'). Venus teaches males to modify their innate combativeness (101-4) for the sake of attracting a female, the consequence being abundance of life (105-6). She likewise improves the uncultivated character of human males (106-7), and this produces poetry and a thousand other 'antes', hidden before but now discovered—that is, 'opened' and thus revealed (108-14). The introduction to Book 4 is a statement of the month's major themes. After the proem (1-18), there follow three parts: the Roman generations descended in Greek epic tradition from Venus (19-60); the creation of Italian place-names and 'civitates' by Greeks (61-84); and Venus' power of generation in the natural world (85-114). That is, we have the three Varronian theologies; that of the poets (epic, Homer, and Virgil particularly); that of the state (foundation myths); and that of the natural philosophers. These theologies are not rigid, much less are they rigidly separated from each other: "cui bono' is the criterion for choosing one over the other. In the restatement, Ovid begins with Venus and the state, that is, Rome, moving thence to the epic tradition, Venus' defence of Aeneas, and her wound received before, and on behalf of, Troy (117-22). He then reiterates the line of descent from Venus to the Caesars (123-4). The introduction is concluded with a harking back to the natural theology of Venus and spring (125-8), the third of the three theologies. The closing couplet reminds us that Venus is the one who softens the harshness of the cold (131-2).
04
C, M. C, GREEN III
There are, as Fantliara (1998: 37) observes, three major panels in Book 4: the festivals of Cybele, Ceres, and the Parilia, Once we understand how Ovid deals with the elements of these festivals in relation to the themes he has established, we will be in a better position to understand his treatment of the lesser festivals, and his inclusion of other, apparently irrelevant, accounts such as that of the foxes of Carseoli. We have also seen how complex is the list of goddesses whom Varro equates with Venus: Liber a, Luna, Vesta, Ceres, Terra (and Tellus), Magna Mater, Proserpina,Vesta, Victory, and Vacuna. Varro argued, that one concept could have many aspects contained in it (Cardauns 268), a statement clearly true of this goddess. Ovid is thus working in an intellectual tradition that had already incorporated most of the divinities in Book 4. Let us begin with Cybele. Ovid's account of the Great Mother and Attis is clearly adapted from Catullus 63 (223-44). We notice immediately that it is Erato, the Muse, who tells this tale, and the Muses, mythologically speaking, are, from Homer on, the interpreters par excellence of the theology of the poets. Erato is particularly appropriate, because her name links her both (by false, but very poetic, etymology) to Venus, as Ovid says (195-6), and also to the character of Attis' story, which is a tale of love and devotion gone wrong. The second part of this account, belonging also to the theology of the poets, is the retelling of the play in which the Great Mother vindicates Claudia Quinta's chastity after Claudia has rescued, the ship carrying the Magna Mater up the Tiber to Rome (291-336)."* This is a tale of devotion rewarded. Ovid acknowledges that the story might raise doubts (326); improbability is again acknowledged as a characteristic flaw of the theology of the poets, The stories of Attis and of Claudia form the two outer frames of a triptych. On the one side is Attis, who swears fidelity and chastity to the Great Mother, but lies and violates his vow, 1(1
Cf. Wiseman (1995) 129-50 on the use of the theatre to create as well as commemorate a Roman mythology.
VARRO'S THREE THEOLOGIES
85 On the other is Claudia Quinta, a virgin, bound to chastity by her devotion to Roman social mores. Yet she is suspected of Attis' crime of unchastity. She tells the truth, and is lied about. The castration of Attis, the paradigm of the eastern cult of Cybele, is the punishment for his infidelity. Claudia, the paradigm of the Roman cult of Cybele, has her fidelity publicly vindicated by her miraculous power to tow the goddess's ship. Between these two figures we find an inner narration of Cybele's translation from Asia Minor to Rome (249-78). This comes under the theology of the state, with its own interwoven poetics—a process replicating Varro's claim that he appropriated many things from philosophy and poetry to the civic theology (Cardauns 11). For any Roman, of course, there is a shadow discourse going on. behind Ovid's account. His triumphant statement (2.55-6) that Rome raised her head over the conquered world at the time (205-204 BC) when Cybele was brought to Rome must instantly have called up a very different image, that of Rome after more than a decade of war, desperate for the final defeat of Hannibal. There is not one word about the conflict which drove the priests to consult the Sibylline Books. As a result, the state myth seems strikingly truncated. There Is a reason. What is missing is war; and war, of course, is the proper sphere of Mars, who was left behind in the previous month, but not of Venus. The opening line of this book, with its emphasis on nurturing and love, establishes the fact clearly. Venus is nourishing, and she is the source of beneficence for mankind. The absence of war is the necessary predicate of fertility and abundance, as Augustan iconography amply testifies,17 The absence of the Hannibalic War creates a vivid and direct characterization of Cybele, portrayed here in accordance with the theology of the philosophers, for, as a mother goddess, she is one icon of the peace and fertility that 'Venus' represents. Thus the particular importance of Claudia18 is that she exemplified a Roman standard of chastity based on 'fides', '' Cf. /.anker (1988) 172-7 Cor a discussion of the figure of fertility on the Ara Pads. 18 Contra, Boyle (1997) 13-14, who argues that Claudia's virtues have little or nothing to do with the religious aspect of the cult of Cybele.
86
C, M. C, GREEN
that very quality on which Romans particularly prided themselves, and thought everyone else notably lacked. Attis represents the potential for faithlessness and destruction in the world the Great Mother rules; Claudia represents the worship of the Mother through 'fides', which is a concomitant of peace. Thus she symbolizes the new, Roman, worship of Cybele, The importation of the "xoanon' from Mt Ida is in fact a repatriation of the goddess (272), and her journey from Phrygia to Rome (277-94), by way of Sicily, Africa, 'Ausonia* (alluding to Aeneas), and, finally, the Tiber, is a poetic voyage. The mention of Sicily looks forward, as Fantham says (1998; 287-90 ad loc.), to Ceres and her journey; but it also connects Cybele, Ceres, and Venus—whose island, Cyprus, Cybele also visits (285-6), and who of course will be herself brought to Rome from her famous shrine at Eryx, in Sicily. The second major panel is that of Ceres (393-620). Ceres' cult is easily adaptable to the theology of Venus, and Ovid reinforces this with his claim that Ceres is responsible for teaching men how to cultivate natural crops by instructing them on opening up the earth (401-4). 'Opening', we remember, is a principal part of the process of which Venus is the representation. Fertility and abundance are possible in the absence of war. Farmers are particularly called upon to pray to Ceres for perpetual peace and a pacific leader (407—8). Peace and fertility are linked, as is implicit in Ovid's account of Cybele, and Ceres is so intertwined with, peace that 'pax' itself, or its derivation, occurs three times in the couplet. Between the lines which identify Ceres as the divinity responsible for teaching" men, cultivation, and those which praise her as a goddess who rejoices in peace, there is a couplet which, introduced by the image of Ceres teaching men to break the ground open in order to plant (404), shifts to the mining of precious metals, bronze and iron (405-6). These two metals—bronze, which feeds greed, and iron, which provides weapons—between them bring about war. The very act, then, of cultivation, of learning how to open the earth, brings out into the open what ought to be hidden: the generation-denying possibility of death and destruction, Death, like ground-breaking, has more than one visage, and opening the earth is going to
VARRO'S THREE THEOLOGIES
87
reveal another road to death (449-50): panditur interea Dili via, namque diurnum lumen inadsueti vix patiuntur equl. In the meantime the way is laid open for Dis; for his horses, being unaccustomed to the light of day, can scarcely endure it,
The rape of Persephone by Dis, the taking of Persephone to the Underworld through an opening In the earth, and the triumph of life over death when she is returned for part of the year, form an integral part of the religious meaning of Ceres' cult,19 which, among other things, introduces death and sexuality into Ovid's narrative. Yet while Persephone's chastity is violated, her 'fides' is not in question. Just as the Cybele panel introduced the theme of chastity and fidelity, so the Ceres panel will take on this theme, and reintroduce violence, though in a different form from Attis' 'furor' and his resultant castration. The Persephone passage brings out the pain associated with the loss of innocence and chastity. But it also defines the essential union of male and female by violence. That too is an integral meaning of Ceres' cult—and Venus', as Varro makes clear (Cardauns 155): 'Venus... ab hoc etiam dicitur nuncupata, quod sine vi femina virgo esse non desinat' ('Venus, they say, is thus invoked also because of the fact that a woman does not cease to be a virgin without violence'). Ceres' journey is not to rejoin her lost people, as Cybele's was, but to find her lost daughter. In that journey she wanders all across Sicily (467-94) and comes to Greece, to Attica (502). In Attica occur the events that must have formed part of the Eleusinian mysteries. Ceres (Demeter) disguises herself as an old woman, and as such, is taken in by Celeus, a shepherd whose son is dying. The goddess saves his life, and at night tries to burn away his mortality in the fire. The child's mother foolishly interrupts the process out of fear of the loss of her son; as a result the child, who is Triptolemus, remains mortal, but with a divinely assigned destiny, to be the first to practise I!) There was a goddess Panda or Pantica, 'The Opening/Open One' (Cardanns 221), who was thought to be a, form of Ceres, Once again the ingenious false etymologies confirm the underlying perception that Ceres and the idea of opening were intimately connected.
88
C, M. C, GREEN
cultivation (507-60), the first to perform for the human race an art equivalent to the rape of Persephone. Thus, on the one side of Ceres' tale we find the lost divine daughter, Persephone, and on the other, the saved mortal boy, Triptolemus. These are the reverse images of Attis (the lost beloved divine boy) and Claudia (the discovered, mortal girl, who saves and is saved). Moreover, the story has moved from Attis as a symbol of failed male chastity, through the constant (and mortal) female chastity of Claudia, to the violent rape of Persephone, and thence to the cultivation pioneered by Triptolemus, through whom the act of rape is transformed into the nurturing art of agriculture. The mortality and beneficence of Triptolemus parallel Claudia's: the opening of the earth and the softening of cold, death-bringing masculine violence are both successfully accomplished. Ceres then goes on another journey, still searching for her daughter (563-74). Her wandering over the entire earth leads her at last to the Tiber (572), whence she ascends the sky (575). From the stars and the sun she is directed to Jupiter, who is called Tonans (585), This evidence, taken as a whole, clearly relocates Ceres in the (divine) vicinity of Rome. Thus, indirectly, Ovid has her travel to Rome, like Cybele, to find what she needs. There, on Jupiter's command, Persephone, who has eaten three seeds of the pomegranate in the Underworld, is restored to her mother for twice three months (613—14), and the productivity of the earth is assured as death (Dis) and life (Persephone) are united, Our earlier analysis of the Cybele panel allows us to make two farther observations about that of Ceres, First, there is no state theology for Ceres included in Ovid's account, and the reference to Rome, while implied by the Tiber (so significant in Cybele's account) and Jupiter Tonans, remains oblique. This has to be a conscious choice on Ovid's part. The temple of Ceres, founded and dedicated in the earliest years of the Republic, was the symbolic centre of plebeian, power in, Rome. It had burned down in 31 uc, and Augustus, at the end of his life, began its restoration, but. did not live to dedicate it, an act which fell to Tiberius in AD 17. Because of the Cerialia, and because of her intimate connection with the principle of generation, Ceres could hardly have been passed over, but that aspect of
VARRO'S THREE THEOLOGIES
89
her worship which appertained to the state clearly could be. Ovid seems here to be respecting the intentions of the Princeps, who declined either to rebuild the temple himself, or to allow it to be rebuilt by others, until the very end of his reign. What we have left is a magnificent recasting of the Hymn to Demeter (Hinds 1987s: 51-71}—the theology of the poetsenriched by thematic connections to the other mother goddesses provided by the theology of the philosophers. And this leads us to a second important observation. Ovid has introduced a new element into the theme, that of fire, which first appears as hearth fire and torches (409-12): farra deae micaeque licet salientis honorem detis et in veteres turea grana focos; et, si tura aberunt, unetas accendite taedas; You may give the goddess spelt and the honour of spitting sail and grains of incense on old hearths, and if there is no incense, kindle torches smeared with pitch.
Fire reappears in the red-hot Sicilian volcanoes (473); again as torches which Ceres lights by means of Aetna's volcanic flames (492-3); and once more as the hearth fire in which Ceres attempts to burn away Triptolemus' mortal substance to make him immortal (509-54). Further, winding in and around these fires are the waters of Earth's rivers and seas. The vale where Persephone gathers flowers is wet with the spray of a waterfall (427-8); Ceres searches for her daughter through Sicily's rivers and springs (467-70) to the Sicilian sea (472), to the Mediterranean and 'two-sea'd Corinth* (498-501). After she has left Triptolemus she travels the Aegean and the Hellespont (563-7); and after the dry lands of Arabia, India, and Libya, she turns to the great rivers of Gaul and northern Italy (571), arriving, at last, at the Tiber (572). From there, as we have seen, she ascends the sky, finds Jupiter, and is finally rewarded with the return of her daughter for six months of eveiy year. Fire and water are thus both pervasive elements in Ovid's narration of Ceres' cult. Yet, intertwined though they are, they never actually come together, to unite in the moment of creation. For that, we must move forward to the third panel, that of the Parilia.
go
C, M. C, GREEN
The interconnection between the various aspects of the divinities of April is made clear once again as Ovid summons Pales (721—4) in virtually the same language as that in which he addressed Venus in the opening of Book 4. Pales is twice characterized as 'alma'; and 'faveo' also appears twice in two lines, recalling the first two words of the first lines devoted by Ovid to April, "Alma fave', there addressed to Venus. Ovid here repositions himself as the poet-singer of sacred things for Pales as well. We cannot tell if there was a poetic ancestor to Ovid's account of the Parilia. The ritual, described as a humble one for shepherds, is important precisely because to all appearances it is not a state ritual such as we might expect for Rome's birthday. The only mention of what could be the state ritual as Ovid describes it is the use of the ashes of the October Horse mixed with those from the Fordicidia, the sacrifice of the unborn calf, both preserved by the Vestals (731-3). This raises an important question. Why, on a most sacred day for the Roman state, is there no mention whatsoever of a ritual celebration of the birthday of Rome? Varro (Schol. Pers. 1. 72) confirms, as we would expect, that there was a state ritual on this day and he says that the Parilia is as much a private festival as a public one.ai How do the two rituals differ? Why does Ovid virtually ignore the public celebration, which surely involved the Vestals, the sacred ashes carried by designated citizens (such as Ovid claims to have been once), and the other religious colleges, in favour of a private, rural, festival? Of course Ovid is throughout the poem concerned with the aetiology of ritual; but, in a month symbolized by generation, origins have even greater importance. Over and above this, I would suggest, Ovid expects his audience to recognize a set of allegorical connections between the shepherds and Rome that are not obvious to us. The first link between the state festival and a rural festival involving the purification of herds and family is of course to be discovered in the character of Rome's founders. Romulus and Remus were both shepherds themselves, and the leaders of those men who became the first Romans: that is, they 20
Beard (1987) is crucial as the foundation for the following part of my argument.
VARRO'S THREE THEOLOGIES
gi
were the shepherds of their people. There were also actually sheep-pens in Rome itself, critical to the city's ritual and civic existence. These were the 'ovilia', located by the Villa Publica on the Campus Martius, the pens where Romans voted as the 'comitia centuriata', Varro makes telling use in the RR of the Villa Publica and its sheep-pens as allegorical figures for Rome of the Republic (Green 1997). Here Rome itself figures as a homestead, a villa, in which the governing class are both the bailiffs and the animal inhabitants.21 This could have been merely an amusing conceit, but in book 3 Varro turns it into a powerful critique of Octavian's Rome, there allegorized as a beautiful aviary where the birds have everything, a fine home, bread, and circuses—everything in fact, except their freedom. It is worth noting, further, that as a naval commander against the pirates, Varro has himself addressed as Trot/xeVa Aawv (RR 2. 5. 1), summoning up all the power of the Homeric allusion to apply to his office—appropriately, of course, since pirates raid ships and coastal settlements just as predators such as wolves raid flocks. The symbolism of the shepherd as leader of the people' is older than Homer and can hardly have been ignored in traditional accounts of Romulus and Remus, the quintessential shepherds. This allegorical connection, by transforming a rural ritual for herds into the paradigm of a civic ritual for Rome's citizens, would have given depth and meaning to both. Yet the description of the ritual (both private and public) is only the beginning, and the aetiologies (783-806) make Ovid's narratological focus clear, demonstrating that he is most directly concerned with water and fire as they appear in the ritual. The first aetiology Ovid presents is a philosophical explanation for the use here both of fire (harking back to Ceres' attempt to purge Triptolemus' 'human burden') and of water (785-90). He then refers to two other rituals: first one where the exile is denied fire and water, a