Ozonation of Organic & Polymer Compounds
Authors: Gennady E. Zaikov and Slavcho K. Rakovsky
Ozonation of Organic and ...
59 downloads
1851 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Ozonation of Organic & Polymer Compounds
Authors: Gennady E. Zaikov and Slavcho K. Rakovsky
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
Gennady E. Zaikov and Slavcho K. Rakovsky
iSmithers – A Smithers Group Company Shawbury, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, SY4 4NR, United Kingdom Telephone: +44 (0)1939 250383 Fax: +44 (0)1939 251118 http://www.rapra.net
First Published in 2009 by
iSmithers Shawbury, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, SY4 4NR, UK
©2009, Smithers Rapra
All rights reserved. Except as permitted under current legislation no part of this publication may be photocopied, reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means or stored in a database or retrieval system, without the prior permission from the copyright holder. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Every effort has been made to contact copyright holders of any material reproduced within the text and the authors and publishers apologise if any have been overlooked. Every effort has been made to contact copyright holders of any material reproduced within the text and the authors and publishers apologise if any have been overlooked.
ISBN: 978-1-84735-143-2 (hardback) 978-1-84735-142-5 (softback) 978-1-84735-144-9 (ebook)
Typeset by Argil Services Printed and bound by Lightning Source Inc.
C
ontents
Introduction....................................................................................................1 1
Kinetics and Mechanism of Ozone Reactions with Organic and Polymeric Compounds in the Liquid Phase........................................9
1.1
Reaction mechanisms .........................................................9 1.1.1
1.2
2
Thermochemical analysis ..............................................11
Structural-kinetic investigations ........................................12 1.2.1
Normal paraffins and isoparaffins ................................12
1.2.2
Cycloparaffins ..............................................................20
1.2.3
Method for estimation of reaction mechanisms ...........26
1.2.4
Application of ERM .....................................................29
1.3
Cyclohexane .....................................................................36
1.4
Cumene ............................................................................47 1.4.1
Ozonation in the presence of transition metal compounds ...................................................................51
1.4.2
Ozonolysis in the presence of NiO ...............................57
1.4.3
Ozonolysis in the presence of Mo and V oxides ...........60
1.4.4
Cumenehydroperoxide .................................................64
1.5
Polyethylene and polypropylene .......................................68
1.6
Polystyren .........................................................................74
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds ..................93
2.1
Alcohols ...... 932.1.1 Application of Estimation of Reaction Mechanism (ERM) .........................................................100
2.2
Ketones ...........................................................................102 iii
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
2.3
Hydrotrioxides ...............................................................110
2.4
Synthesis of oxolanes ......................................................124
2.5
2.4.1
Derivatives of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane ...........124
2.4.2
Phenyl ethers of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane .......124
2.4.3
Alkyl ethers of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane .........125
2.4.4
5-Nonylene-1,2,4-trioxolane ......................................127
Ethers .............................................................................130 2.5.1
2.6
Hydroxybenzenes ...........................................................140 2.6.1
2.7
2.8 3
Application of ERM ..................................................146
Carbohydrates and model compounds ............................149 2.7.1
2,3-Butanediol ...........................................................153
2.7.2
1,2-Cyclohexanediol ...................................................155
2.7.3
Mannitol and its derivatives .......................................156
2.7.4
A-D-Glucose ...............................................................158
2.7.5
A-D-Methyl-glucose....................................................160
2.7.6
B-Cyclodextrine and starch .........................................161
Catalytic ozonolysis and oxidation .................................162
Ozonolysis of alkenes in liquid phase............................................179
3.1
3.2
iv
Application of the ERM ............................................135
Olefins ............................................................................179 3.1.1
Mechanisms ...............................................................179
3.1.2
Kinetics ......................................................................189 3.1.2.1
Gas phase ...................................................189
3.1.2.2
Liquid phase ...............................................191 3.1.2.2.1
Effect of solvent .......................203
3.1.2.2.2
Effect of configuration ..............205
3.1.2.2.3
Effect of structure .....................209
Polydienes .......................................................................216
Contents
4
3.2.1
Polybutadiene .............................................................219
3.2.2
Cis-1,4-polyisoprene ...................................................227
3.2.3
Polychloroprene .........................................................228
3.2.4
Butadienenitrile rubbers .............................................230
3.2.5
Ethylenepropylene rubbers .........................................235
Degradation and Stabilisation of Rubber ......................................251
4.1
Ozonolysis of Elastomers in Elastic State ........................252
4.2
Antiozonants ..................................................................261 4.2.1
Mechanism of Action .................................................263
4.2.2
Synthesis .....................................................................267 4.2.2.1
Paraphenylenediamine ................................267 4.2.2.1.1
Alkylation in the Presence of Hydrogen ......................................267
4.2.2.1.2
Alkylation in the Absence of Hydrogen ......................................273
4.2.2.2
Hydroquinolines.........................................275
4.2.2.3
N,N´-Disubstituted Hexahydropyrimidines 276
4.2.2.4
N-Substituted Dimethylpyrols ....................276
4.2.2.5
Enamines ....................................................276
4.2.2.6
Nitrone Compounds ...................................277
4.2.2.7
Derivatives of 3(5)-Methylpyrazone ...........278
4.2.2.8
Enolethers ..................................................279
4.2.2.9
Ethers .........................................................279
4.2.2.10 Cyclic and Acyclic Acetals and Ketals .........280 4.2.2.11 Other Classes of Compounds ....................280 4.2.2.11.1 Bis-Alkylaminophenoxy Alkanes .... 280 4.2.2.11.2 Derivatives of 2,2,7,7,-Tetramethyl-1,4-Diazocyclopentane ......281 4.2.2.11.3 Bis-Cyclopentadienyl Compounds ..
v
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
281 4.2.2.11.4 Alkylnaphthenes .......................281 4.2.2.11.5 Aminomethylene Derivatives of Furane ......................................282 4.2.2.11.6 Lactams ....................................282 4.2.2.12 Sulfur-Containing Compounds ...................282 4.2.2.13 Si-Containing Compounds .........................285 4.2.2.14 P-Containing Compounds ..........................285 4.2.3
Application .................................................................286
4.2.4
High Molecular Antiozonants ....................................296 4.2.4.1
4.3
Apparatus for Ozone Resistance Determination ............301
4.4
Evaluation of Industrial Stabilisers .................................305
4.5
5
vi
Ethylene-Propylene Rubber With Diene Monomer (EPDM) ...............................................299
4.4.1
Antioxidant Action .....................................................306
4.4.2
Atmospheric Ageing ...................................................308
4.4.3
Antiozonant Action ....................................................308
Prediction .......................................................................312 4.5.1
Oxidation ...................................................................312
4.5.2
Ozonolysis ..................................................................312
4.6
Efficiency of Antiozonants Under the Conditions of Various Deformations ..................................................................319
4.7
Effect of Vulcanisate’s Structure ......................................327
Quantum Chemical Calculations of Ozonolysis of Organic Compounds ......................................................................................359
5.1
Alkanes ...........................................................................359
5.2
Oxygen-containing Compounds ....................................364 5.2.1
Water..........................................................................364
5.2.2
Methanol ....................................................................364
Contents
5.3
5.4
5.5
5.2.3
Ethylene Glycol ..........................................................368
5.2.4
Formaldehyde and Acetone ........................................368
5.2.5
Dimethylether .............................................................371
Sulfur-containing Compounds .......................................373 5.3.1
Hydrogen Sulfide ........................................................373
5.3.2
Methylsulfide .............................................................374
5.3.3
Dimethylsulfide ..........................................................375
Nitrogen-containing Compounds ...................................377 5.4.1
Ammonia ...................................................................377
5.4.2
Methylamine ..............................................................380
5.4.3
Dimethylamine ...........................................................381
5.4.4
Trimethylamine ..........................................................384
Phosphorus-containing Compounds ...............................384 5.5.1
Phosphine ...................................................................384
5.5.2
Methylphosphine ........................................................385
5.5.3
Dimethylphosphine ....................................................387
5.5.4
Trimethylphosphine ....................................................388
Abbreviations .............................................................................................395 Index .........................................................................................................399
vii
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
viii
I
ntroduction
Introduction The development of ozone chemistry started in 1840 when Schönbein discovered the gas which had a distinctive smell, and which formed near to the electrodes of electrical machines [1, 2]. He called it ‘ozone’, which in Greek means ‘smell’. It is a highly reactive gas - an allotropic modification of oxygen containing three atoms of oxygen [3, 4]. Upon studying the reaction of ozone with ethylene, which appears to be the first ozone reaction ever performed, it was shown that the ozone reacts with the double bonds, and products of their cleavage are formed. At the beginning of the last century Harries showed firstly that natural rubber reacts rapidly with ozone. He applied ozone as ‘chemical scissors’ to degrade the natural rubber and on the basis of the cut-off products he determined the elastomer structure and proposed the mechanism of the ozone reaction with the elastomers [5-12]. At present the mechanism of ozone reaction with double bonds, as proposed by Criegee [13-16], is widely accepted. The development of analytical methods opens possibilities for intensive and expanded research on the reactions of ozone with various polymers, elastomers and chemical compounds [17-25]. Since 1958 to the present day, a number of reviews and monographs describing and discussing the various aspects of ozone chemistry have been published [26-37]. The intensive research on this topic is illustrated convincingly by the huge number of publications, more than 10,000 titles in the patent and scientific literature, covering all aspects of ozone chemistry and physics, ozone preparation, application, storage, decomposition, etc. The study of the kinetics and mechanism of ozone reactions is an important field in modern science. It is closely related to the solution of the problem of ‘ozone holes’, the development of physical, organic, inorganic and polymer chemistry and biochemistry in connection with ozone, chemical kinetics, the theory and utilisation of the reactivity of chemical compounds with ozone, the development of new highly efficient technologies for the chemical industry, electronics, fine organic synthesis, the solution of ecological and medical problems by employing ozone, and the degradation
1
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds of organic, polymer, elastomer and biological materials, etc., and their stabilisation against ozone’s harmful action [39, 40]. The oxidative, antibacterial and antiviral properties of ozone make it very attractive for the purification of drinking water, the treatment of natural, waste and process water, artificial pools, waste gases and contaminated soils, in human and veterinary medicine, sterilisation, etc. Usually ozone can be found in the atmosphere at an altitude of 25-30 km. Here it is generated photochemically and its concentration reaches values of 10-20 ppm. Ozone absorbs ultraviolet (UV) light in the region of 200-300 nm wavelength and protects life on the earth from its harmful effects. The natural concentration of ozone at the ground level is in the range of 0.005-0.01 ppm, but in some cases it may approach values up to 1 ppm. At ground level, ozone is produced by photochemical reactions in the ‘smog phenomenon’, during the decay of some seaweed, during thunder and lightning storms, near high-voltage conduits, and in the vicinity of radiation sources, UV-applying units, lasers and radar units, electrolysis, and galvanic and welding moulding apparatus. The control of all these sources of ozone generation is rather difficult and in many cases they cause ecological pollution of dwellings and work places with harmful ozone levels. Ozone is highly toxic in concentrations greater than 0.1 mg/m3. The presence of ozone in the lower atmospheric layer leads to the appearance of undesirable phenomena related to the earth’s flora and fauna, and degradation of valuable organic, inorganic, polymeric and biological objects, materials and articles. In this connection the harmful effect of ozone on human health, rubber goods, polymeric materials should be outlined [31, 41-77]. The purposeful application of ozone promotes invention and the development of novel and improvement of well-known methods for its generation and analysis, and the means and methods for its more effective application, etc. [31, 61, 69-79]. A number of laboratory and industrial methods for its synthesis have been proposed. The modern ozonation stations have a capacity of 102-103 kg O3/day with ozone concentrations not higher than 5-7% vol. In some particular cases, solid or liquid ozone, or ozone deposited on inorganic supports such as silica gel, or absorbed in freons, etc. [80-89], is used. The joint research work on ozone chemistry has been intensively developing since 1972 [90-92]. We should mention that several hundred publications, reviews, plenary lectures, oral and poster presentations and patents have been published during this time interval. Serious attention has been paid to applied research work leading to the solving of the stabilisation problem of pneumatic tyres and rubber technical goods.
2
Introduction
References 1. C.F. Schonbein, Poggendorff’s Annalen der Physik und Chemie, 1840, 49, 616. 2. C.F. Schonbein, Comtes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances de l’Académie des Sciences, 1840, 10, 706. 3. C. Nebel in Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, 3rd Edition, John Wiley, New York, NY, USA, 1981, 16, 650. 4. M. Horwath, L. Vitzky and G. Huttner, Ozone, Academy Kiado, Budapest, Hungary, 1985. 5. H. Staudinger, Chemische Berichte, 1925, 58, 1088. 6. C.D. Harries, Chemische Berichte, 1904, 37, 2708. 7. C.D. Harries, Chemische Berichte, 1905, 38, 1195. 8. C.D. Harries, Chemische Berichte, 1912, 45, 936; 9. C.D. Harries, Untersuchungen über die Naturlichen und Kunstlichen Kautschukarten, Springer Verlag GmbH, Berlin, Germany, 1919. 10. C.D. Harries, Chemische Berichte, 1907, 40, 4905. 11. C.D. Harries, Chemische Berichte, 1908, 41, 1227. 12. C.D. Harries and V. Weiss, Liebig’s Annalen der Chemie, 1905, 343, 369. 13. R. Criegee, Annalen, 1949, 564, 9. 14. R. Criegee, Annalen, 1953, 583, 1. 15. R. Criegee, Record of Chemical Progress, 1957, 18, 111. 16. R. Criegee, Angewandte Chemie, 1975, 21, 765. 17. S. Hatakeyama, H. Lai, S. Gao and K. Murano, Chemistry Letters, 1993, 8, 1287. 18. W.S. Schutt, M.E. Sigman and Y.Z. Li, Analytica Chimica Acta, 1996, 319, 3, 369. 19. M.J. Lee, H. Arai and T. Miyata, Chemistry Letters, 1994, 6, 1069.
3
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 20. Y.S. Hon and J.L. Yan. Tetrahedron Letters, 1994, 35, 11, 1743. 21. Y.S. Hon and L. Lu. Tetrahedron Letters, 1993, 34, 33, 5309. 22. R. Atkinson, E.C. Tuazon, J. Arey and S.M. Aschmann, Atmospheric Environment, 1995, 29, 3423. 23. T.L. Rakitskaya, A.Y. Bandurko, A.A. Ennan and V.V. Litvinskaya, Kinetics and Catalysis, 1994, 35, 5, 705. 24. S.W. Mcelvany, J.H. Callahan, M.M. Ross, L.D. Lamb and D.R. Huffman, Science, 1993, 260, 5114, 1632. 25. R. Keshavaraj and R.W. Tock, Advances in Polymer Technology, 1994, 13, 2, 149. 26. S.D. Razumovskii, S.K. Rakovski, D.M. Shopov, and G.E. Zaikov, Ozone and Its Reactions with Organic Compounds, Publishing House of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, Bulgaria, 1983. [in Russian] 27. Ozonation in Organic Chemistry, Volumes I and II, Ed., P.S. Bailey, Organic Chemistry Monographs, Volume 39, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1978 and 1982. 28. S.D. Razumovskii and G.E. Zaikov, Ozone and Its Reactions with Organic Compounds, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1984. 29. P.S. Bailey, Chemical Reviews, 1958, 58, 925. 30. Ozone Chemistry and Technology, Advances in Chemistry Series, Volume No.21, ACS, Washington, DC, USA, 1959. 31. Ozone Reactions with Organic Compounds, Ed., P.S. Bailey, Advances in Chemistry Series Volume No.112, ACS, Washington, DC, USA, 1972. 32. G.Y. Ishmuratov, R.Y. Kharisov, V.N. Odinokov and G.A. Tolstikov, Uspekhi Khimii, 1995, 64, 6, 580. 33. B. Dhandapani and S.T. Oyama, Applied Catalysis B - Environmental, 1997, 11, 2, 129. 34. S.K. Rakovsky in Polymer Materials Encyclopedia, Ed., J.C. Solomone, CRC Press, Boca Ratan, FL, USA, 1996, p.1878. 35. ACS Division of the Petroleum Chemistry - Preprints, 1972, 16, 2.
4
Introduction 36. Handbook of Ozone Technology and Applications, Volume 2, Eds., R.G. Rice and A. Netzer, Butterworth Publishers, Boston, MA, USA, 1983. 37. Ozone: Science & Engineering, 1978, 1, 1-4; 38. Ozone: Science & Engineering, 1998, 20, 1-4. 39. D.P. Chock, G. Yarwood, A.M. Dunker, R.E. Morris, A.K. Pollack and C.H. Schleyer, Atmospheric Environment, 1995, 29, 21, 3067. 40. R.D. Bojkov and V.E. Fioletov, Journal of Geophysical Research – Atmosphere, 1995, 100, D8, 16537. 41. J.M. Giovannoni, F. Muller, A. Clappier and A.G. Russell, Tropospheric Modelling and Emission Estimation, 1997, 7, 111. 42. S.M. George and F.E. Livingston, Surface Review and Letters, 1997, 4, 4, 771. 43. M.T. Benjamin and A.M. Winer, Atmospheric Environment, 1998, 32, 1, 53. 44. B. Frakes and B. Yarnal, International Journal of Climatology, 1997, 17, 13, 1381. 45. L. Coy and R. Swinbank, Journal of Geophysical Research - Atmosphere, 1997, 102, D22, 25763. 46. W.R. Stockwell, F. Kirchner, M. Kuhn and S. Seefeld, Journal of Geophysical Research - Atmosphere, 1997, 102, D22, 25847. 47. B. Ramacher, J. Rudolph and R. Koppmann, Tellus B – Chemical and Physical Meteorology, 1997, 49, 5, 466. 48. R. Sander, R. Vogt, G.W. Harris and P.J. Crutzen, Tellus B – Chemical and Physical Meteorology, 1997, 49, 5, 522. 49. P.A. Ariya, V. Catoire, R. Sander, H. Niki and G.W. Harris, Tellus B – Chemical and Physical Meteorology, 1997, 49, 5, 583. 50. J. Rudolph, B. Ramacher, C. Plassdulmer, K.P. Muller and R. Koppmann, Tellus B – Chemical and Physical Meteorology, 1997, 49, 5, 592. 51. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 1997, 78, 11, 2681. 52. P.A. Newman, J.F. Gleason, R.D. McPeters and R.S. Stolarski, Geophysical Research Letters, 1997, 24, 22, 2689.
5
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 53. R.B. Pierce, T.D. Fairlie, E.E. Remsberg, J.M. Russell and W.L. Grose, Geophysical Research Letters, 1997, 24, 22, 2701. 54. J.P. McCormack, L.L. Hood, R. Nagatani, A.J. Miller, W.G. Planet and R.D. McPeters, Geophysical Research Letters, 1997, 24, 22, 2729. 55. M.K. Dubey, G.P. Smith, W.S. Hartley, D.E. Kinnison and P.S. Connell, Geophysical Research Letters, 1997, 24, 22, 2737. 56. S. Solberg, T. Krognes, F. Stordal, O. Hov, H.J. Beine, D.A. Jaffe, K.C. Clemitshaw and S.A. Penkett, Journal of Atmospheric Chemistry, 1997, 28, 1-3, 209. 57. R. Schmitt and A. Volzthomas, Journal of Atmospheric Chemistry, 1997, 28, 1-3, 245. 58. C. Nevison and E. Holland, Journal of Geophysical Research - Atmospheres, 1997, 102, D21, 25519. 59. Proceedings of the World Environmental Conference, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 1992. 60. Proceedings of the World Environmental Conference, Kyoto, Japan, 1998. 61. M.K.W. Ko, N.D. Sze and M.J. Prather, Nature, 1994, 367, 6463, 505. 62. V.A. Basiuk, Uspekhi Khimii, 1995, 64, 11, 1073. 63. V. Cataldo and O. Ori, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 1995, 48, 2, 291. 64. R.W. Murray in Techniques and Methods of Organic and Organometallic Chemistry, Ed., D.B. Denney, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY, USA, 1969, p.1-32. 65. Proceedings of the Second International Symposium on Ozone Technology, Eds., R.G. Rice, P. Pichet, M-A. Vincent, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 1975. 66. M.J.S. Dewar, J.C. Hwang and D.R. Kuhn, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1991, 113, 3, 735. 67. J.S. Belew in Oxidation: Techniques and Applications in Organic Synthesis, Volume 1, Ed., R.L. Augustine, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY, USA, 1969. 68. R.L. Kuczkowski, Chemical Society Reviews, 1992, 21, 79. 69. J. Prousek and A. Klcova, Chemicke Listy, 1997, 91, 8, 575. 6
Introduction 70. C.A. Zaror, Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 1997, 70, 1, 21. 71. B.I. Tarunin, V.N. Tarunina, M.N. Klimova and M.Y. Ratkova, Zhurnal Obshchei Khimii, 1997, 67, 5, 806. 72. E. Otal, D. Mantzavinos, M.V. Delgado, R. Hellenbrand, J. Lebrato, I.S. Metcalfe and A.G Livingston, Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 1997, 70, 2, 147. 73. F.J. Benitez, J. Beltranheredia, J.L. Acero and M.L. Pinilla, Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 1997, 70, 3, 253. 74. B.J. Finlaysonpitts and J.N. Pitts, Science, 1997, 276, 5315, 1045. 75. H.K Roscoe and K.C. Clemitshaw, Science, 1997, 276, 5315, 1065. 76. F.H. Tiefenbrunner, H.G. Moll, A. Grohmann, D. Eihelsdorfer, K. Seidel and G. Golderer, Ozone: Science Engineering, 1990, 12, 393. 77. F. Hegeler, and H. Akiyama, Japanese Journal of Applied Physics, Part 1, 1997, 36, 8, 5335. 78. S. Rakovski, V. Podmasterev, S. Razumovskii and G. Zaikov, International Journal of Polymeric Materials, 1991, 15, 2, 123. 79. R.A. Kerr, Science, 1996, 271, 5245, 32. 80. D.P. Ufimkin, V.V. Lunin, L.V. Sabitova, L.N. Burenkova, V.A. Voblikova and S.N. Tkachenko, Zhurnal Fizicheskoi Khimii, 1995, 69, 11, 1964. 81. B Dhandapani and S.T. Oyama, Chemistry Letters, 1995, 6, 413. 82. A. Naydenov, R. Stoyanova and D. Mehandjiev, Journal of Molecular Catalysis A - Chemical, 1995, 98, 1, 9. 83. I.V. Martynov, V.I. Demidyuk, S.N. Tkachenko and M.P. Popovich, Zhurnal Fizicheskoi Khimii, 1994, 68, 11, 1972. 84. E. Merz and F. Gaia, Ozone: Science and Engineering, 1990, 12, 401. 85. J. Kitayama and M. Kuzumoto, Journal of Physics D - Applied Physics, 1997, 30, 17, 2453. 86. V.A. Basiuk, Uspekhi Khimii, 1995, 64, 11, 1073.
7
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 87. S. Rimmer, J.R. Ebdon and M.J. Shepherd, Reactive & Functional Polymers, 1995, 26, 1-3, 145. 88. L.V. Ruban, S.K. Rakovsky and A.A. Popov, Izvestiya AN SSSR Seriya Khimicheskaya, 1976, 40, 9, 1950. 89. D.P. Ufimkin, V.V. Lunin, L.V. Sabitova, L.N. Burenkova, V.A. Voblikova and S.N. Tkachenko, Zhurnal Fizicheskoi Khimii, 1995, 69, 11, 1964. 90. S.K. Rakovsky, Kinetics and Mechanism of the Ozone Reactions with Paraffins in Liquid Phase, Institue of Chemical Physics, Moscow, 1975. [PhD Thesis] 91. M.P. Anachkov, Kinetics and Mechanism of the Ozone Reaction with Diene Rubbers in Solution, Institute Neftekhimii, Moscow, 1982. [PhD Thesis] 92. Proceedings of the 1st International Micro Symposium on Ozone Degradation of Polymers, Sofia, Bulgaria, 1984.
8
1
Kinetics and Mechanism of Ozone Reactions with Organic and Polymeric Compounds in the Liquid Phase
The oxidation of low molecular weight hydrocarbons by ozone is one of their few reactions that takes place both at low and ambient temperatures and transforms them into oxygen-containing products [1-12]. This reaction has been investigated by a number of authors [13-15]. The action of ozone as an initiator of oxidation processes [16-18], a modifying polymer agent [19-21] and an oxidiser in the preparation of alcohols, ketones and some other compounds is of special interest [22-24]. The kinetics and mechanism of this reaction have been intensively discussed [25-46]. Our investigations [47-64] are also dedicated to these problems.
1.1 Reaction mechanisms The first studies of ozone reactions with paraffins were carried out in the last century using the examples of methane, ethane, propane and butane in the gas phase [2-8]. It was established that upon the absorption of 1 mole of ozone 1 mole of final product is formed. These authors proposed two different mechanisms of ozone action: ozone is decomposed into atomic oxygen, which initiates the oxidation process [2] (M.1.1) and ozone interacts directly with the alkane [3-5] (M.1.2). O 3 = O2 + O RH + O m Rv + vOH
(M.1.1)
RH + O3 m ROv + vO2H
(M.1.2)
Later it was shown that mechanism M.1.1 can be realised only in the gas phase at temperatures >>50-60 oC [28, 29]. Thus this reaction is of no importance in the liquid phase whereby the reactions are usually carried out at ≤50-60 oC. On the other hand mechanism M.1.2 assume the formation of H2O2 in quantities proportional to the absorbed amount of ozone, but really in the liquid phase only a small amount of hydroperoxide is formed [1] which means that the role of the mechanism in M.1.2 in ozonation of alkanes is negligible.
9
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The ozonolysis of alkanes in the gas phase leads to the formation of excited species, which determines the specific character of these reactions [65]. The first studies in the liquid phase were carried out by Azinger and co-workers [16] on ozonation of octadecane. They came to the conclusion that ozone directly attacks the CH2 groups. Upon ozonolysis of decalin and adamantane the tert-CH groups are attacked, leading to the formation of the respective tert-alcohols. In cyclohexane, ozone reacts with the CH2 groups giving rise to cyclohexanol and cyclohexanone formation [16]. The kinetics of intermediate and end-product formation has been studied and the mechanism of ozone reaction with tetradecane is suggested to be [66]: RH + O3 m RO2v + vOH
(M.1.3)
Although the basic reaction in M.1.3 is exothermal its occurrence in two steps appears to be more entropy favourable than in one as assumed by this mechanism in regard to entropy. Hamilton and co-workers [6, 67] consider the most probable mechanism to be the ozone attack on the CH bonds via a 1,3-transition state (M.1.4): RH + O3 TS m [Rv + HO3v Rv + HO3 ] m ROOOH (1) (M.1.4) n ROH + O2 (s) (2);
cage
n
Rvl+ lvOH + O2 (t) (3)
n RO2v + O2, which is followed by H-atom abstraction and hydrotrioxide (1), alcohol, singlet oxygen (2), peroxy radical and triplet oxygen (3) leaving the kinetic cage in the bulk liquid phase. They postulate that the products in the cage have a radical character, while according to Myurei [68] they are more probably ionic pairs. Nangiya and Benson [28] assume the mechanism M.1.4 to be more probable, but the interaction between ozone and CH bonds is not synchronised.
10
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons Denissov and co-workers [26] considered the reaction of ozone with C-H bonds within the framework of the parabolic model of the potential surface and they also adhere to mechanism M.1.4. Another view of the mechanism of alkane ozonolysis is that Rv, HOv radicals are kinetically responsible for the reaction proceeding and that ROH, Rv, HOv and O2 leave the kinetic cage into the solution (M.1.5) [51]: RH + O3 m [Rv + HOv + O2]
(M.1.5)
However, one cannot exclude the possibility of RO2v radical formation from ROOOH as a precursor via the mechanism of ozone insertion into the CH bonds (M.1.6): RH + O3 m ROOOH
(M.1.6)
ROOOH could act as a precursor in all the mechanisms discussed in the literature [9, 67]. This reaction is probably entropically disadvantageous, because it goes through a cyclic transition state and it is necessary to assume a five-fold coordinated C atom.
1.1.1 Thermochemical analysis The heat of ozone reactions with paraffins via different mechanisms are calculated using the example of methane ozonation. Experimental and calculated (?) values of the bond energies and heat of formation [69, 70] have been used: CH3-H = 104 kcal/ mol; OO-O = 24; CH3O-H = 102; CH3OO-H = 77?; CH3OOO-H = 70?; CH3OOOH = 51?; CH3O-OOH = 47?; CH3-OH = 91; CH3-OOH = 69?; CH3-OOOH = 61?; H-Ov = 102; H-OOv = 77; H-OOOv = 62; C-Ov = 78; C-OOv = 59; and C-OOOv = 48 kcal/mol and the heat of the reactions (Q) in the various mechanisms are as shown in Table 1.1.
Table 1.1 Heats of ozone reactions (Q) Mechanism Q (kcal/mol)
M.1.1 26
M.1.2 -27
M.1.3 -33
M.1.4 66
M.1.5 26
M.1.6 -5
For alkanes with secondary and tertiary C-H bonds with lower bond energies, the Q values for each reaction will be higher by 10-15 kcal.
11
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
1.2 Structural-kinetic investigations As we have shown above there are two approaches concerning the interaction of ozone with paraffins: ozone insertion in the CH bonds and H-atom abstraction. We should note, however, that the effect of paraffin composition in this reaction has not been studied systematically, which limits the possibilities for analysis and elaboration of the mechanism of these reactions [25, 59]. The variety of the proposed mechanisms and the insufficient kinetic data means a systematic investigation of the reaction will need to cover a wide spectrum of conditions and theoretical and experimental research methods.
1.2.1 Normal paraffins and isoparaffins We have studied the kinetics of ozone reactions with a series of paraffins of different structure [47, 59]. The rates of the reactions (W) have been determined at stationary and dynamic conditions. By following the change of [O3] with time (t) under static conditions we have determined the rate constant of the pseudomonomolecular reaction ka = k × [RH] and the bimolecular constant – k: W = d [O3]/dt = k [RH]0.[O3] = ka [O3]
(1.1)
The constant ka has been determined during the half-decomposition time interval: ka= ln2/T1/2
(1.2)
or based on the slope of the curve in coordinates ln([O3]o/[O3])/t. The reaction in an open system has been carried out by bubbling ozone through the paraffin phase and following spectrophotometrically its concentration in the ultraviolet (UV) region (254-300 nm). The course of the concentration change has the following pattern: first it drops down abruptly from [O3]o, the concentration at the reactor inlet, to [O3]g, the concentration at the reactor outlet, after which for a long time it remains parallel to the x-axis, at a distance of $[O3] = {[O3]o – [O3]g}. The analysis of the kinetic curves has been done on the basis of its stationary part, when the rate of the chemical reaction becomes equal to the rate of ozone consumption W = WO3, or: k.[RH].[O3]l = W.$[O3]
(1.3)
from which it follows that: k = W.$[O3]/([RH].[O3]l) 12
(1.4)
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons where W = v/V is the relative rate, v is the rate of the gas flow, V is the volume of the liquid phase; in one of the models used [O 3 ] l = A × [O 3 ] 9 the ozone concentration in the liquid, A is Henry’s coefficient [31]. This model is valid in all cases when the rate of ozone absorption is greater than the rate of the chemical reactions. Several criteria could by applied if Henry’s law is observed in the course of absorption and there proceeds an irreversible first-order chemical reaction (k1): k1.T << 1, where T = 1/W, or DO3.k1/kL2<<1 where DO3 is the diffusion coefficient of ozone in solution; kL= DO3/D is the coefficient of mass transfer in liquid phase; and D is thickness of the boundary layer in the hydrodynamic model renovation surface; or kL=(DO3.s)1/2, where s is the time interval of renovation; in the bubbling method with small bubbles with diameters up to 2.5-3 mm kL = 0.31 × (gN)1/3 × (DO3/N)2/3, where N = H/R is the kinematic viscosity of the solvent, H is the viscosity of the solvent, R is the solvent density, g is the earth acceleration. Usually the kL value is 0.1-0.05 cm/s. In all other cases [O3]l is a complicated function of [O3]g and [O3]0 and it requires special investigation [54]. Conventionally, v = 0.1 l/min, V = 10 ml and W = 0.167/s, [O3]o z 10-6-10-3 M, the solvent is CCl4, for which A z 1.8-3, [RH] z 10-3-101 M depending on the temperature and for the paraffins A z 1.8-2.5. The bubbling reactors are made of glass with a grating G2, G3 or G4 built in their lower end, with a cylindrical form and the inner diameter F = 1.7-3.7 cm and height h = 7-15 cm. The accuracy of thermal control was p 0.1 oC. By applying the kinetic methods specified above we studied the influence of concentration, composition, solvent nature and temperature on the kinetics of a definite reaction. The rates of the studied reaction were linearly dependent on [O3] and, with some exceptions, linearly dependent on [RH] (e.g., adamantane in the first case and 3-methylpentane in the second case) (Figure 1.1). A linear dependence of 1/kobs on [RH] for 3-methylpentane has been observed while the 1/kobs values for adamantane do not depend on [RH] at [RH] < 0.3 M and on the molar ratio of [RH]/[O3] <1 × 104. During, ozonation of n-octane, n-pentane, 3-methylpentane and iso-pentane, Williamson and Cvetanovich [17] observed an increase of reaction rate (W) at low [RH] and ratios [RH]/[O3] <1 × 104. They concluded that ozone interacts with some microimpurities that initiate the chain reactions.
13
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
9 3-methylpentane
kobs-1, M.s
8
7
6
adamantane
5 0
10
20
30
40
[RH], mM
Figure 1.1 The dependence of 1/kobs on [RH] Our explanation of the dependence of 1/kobs on [RH] is that the reaction passes through a complex multistep pathway. To clarify the possible pathways of the reaction several kinetic schemes are applied. For example Scheme 1.1 provides a good agreement between the applied kinetic and chemical criteria and the experimental data which includes the formation of a complex [R...H...O3]. RH + O3
k1
R...H...O3
k2
products
k -1
R...H...O3
+ RH
k3
2RH + O3
Scheme 1.1 We have studied the case when the equilibrium concentration of the complex is not affected by the occurrence of reactions 2 and 3. The running concentration of the complex can be specified by the ozone concentration as follows: [R...H...O3] = [O3]0 – [O3] , Under quasistationary conditions in relation to [R...H...O 3] and taking into consideration the material balance, we obtain for kobs: kobs = k1k2/{k-1 + k2 + (k1 + k3) [RH]},
14
(1.5)
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons and in reciprocal form: 1/kobs = (1/k1 + k-1/k1k2 ) + {(k1 +k3)/k1k2}.[RH]
(1.6)
It follows from Equation 1.6 that 1/kobs will increase linearly with the increase of [RH]. From the ordinate intercept one can determine (1/k1 + Kd/k2 ), where Kd = k-1/ k1 is the dissociation constant of the complex and from the slope angle the value of the ratio (k1 + k3)/k1k2. In our calculations we have assumed that k2<< k-1 according to Scheme 1.1. Hence the intercept gives Kd/k2 and at k1>>k3 the 1/k2 value can be found from the slope. The last assumption transforms Scheme 1.1 into a mechanism of the Michaelis-Menten type (Scheme 1.2). RH + O3
k1
R...H...O3
k2
products
k -1
Scheme 1.2 Then Equation 1.5 is transformed into: kobs = k1k2/(k-1 + k2 + k1[RH]),
(1.7)
and Equation 1.6 becomes: 1/kobs = (1/k1 + k-1/k1.k2 ) + (1/k2 )[RH]
(1.8)
In the case when the equilibrium constant of [R...H...O3] varies as a result of the proceeding of reactions 2, 1 and 3, 1/kobs will be equal to: 1/kobs = (1/k1 + k-1/k1k2 ) + k3/k1k2.[RH]
(1.6a)
and 1/k 1 will be determined from the intercept as K d << k 2 , and k 3 /k 1 k 2 from the slope, respectively. In order to assess the validity of the kinetic schemes we have determined experimentally the rate constants of ozone interactions with 24 paraffins of various structures. The rate constants, depending on [RH], are given in Table 1.2 whereby the constants calculated from the ordinate intercepts are shown in column 3 and those obtained from the slope according to Equations 1.6a and Equation 1.8 are shown in column 4.
15
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
Table 1.2 Rate constants of ozone reactions with paraffins in CCl4 at 20 oC [47] No.
Hydrocarbon
k p 10% (M-1. s-1)
(k3/k2)/k2 (M-1)
1.
n-Pentane
0.015
0.001/15
2.
n-Hexane
0.019
0.0013/15
3.
n-Heptane
0.021
0.0012/17
4.
n-Octane
0.023
-
5.
n-Nonane
0.026
-
6.
n-Decane
0.029
<0.001<29
7.
n-Tetradecane
0.036
-
8.
n-Octadecane
0.048
<0.001/<48
9.
3-Me-pentane
0.15
0.75/0.2
10.
2,3-Di-Me-pentane
0.29
11/0.026
11.
2,4-Di-Me-pentane
0.08
-
12.
2,3,4-Tri-Me-pentane
0.59
40/0/015
13.
2-Methyl-hexane
0.13
5.2/0.025
14.
3-Me-hexane
0.20
7.4/0.027
15.
2,2-Dimethyl-hexane
0.015
<<0.001/<<15
16.
2,4-Dimethyl-hexane
0.13
-
17.
2,2,5-Trimethyl-hexane
0.19
9.0/0.021
18.
3-Methyl-heptane
0.20
9.0/0.022
19.
Hexa-methyl-ethane
0.0002
-
20.
Ethyl-n-propane
0.05
-
21.
Cyclohexane
0.01
<<0.001/<<14
22.
Norbornane
0.014
<<0.001/<<14
23.
Adamantane
0.22
<<0.1/<<2.2
24.
Isooctane
0.14
-
The analysis of the data in Table 1.2 shows that the kinetic models, most probably do not conform to the experimental results although they describe formally some of the experimental observations in Figure 1.1 and Table 1.2 For some of the representatives
16
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons of n-, iso- and cyclo-paraffins no dependence of 1/kobs on [RH] has been established (e.g., compounds 4, 5, 7, 11, 16, 19, 20, 24) or this dependence is within the limits of the graphic presentation, as for compounds 1, 2, 3, 6, 8, 15, 21, 22 and 23. A good correlation has been found for compounds 9, 10, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18 as all these are iso-paraffins with 1, 2 or 3 CH3 groups in the side chains. These isomers always contain microimpurities that are hardly separable, which have higher reactivity than the parent paraffins and they can affect the processes of di-, tri-merisation of the hydrocarbon molecules. It is seen that the values of k1 depend on the structure and type of the C-H bonds in the alkane molecule - for the primary bonds (I) it is 0.0002 (no.19), for the secondary bonds (II), 0.048 (no.8) and for the tertiary (III), 0.20 (no.18). These bonds differ in their energies which have a ratio of 1:0.98:0.96 [69, 70]. The effect of the bond energies assumes that the C-H bond in the transition state is highly elongated [75]. The enthalpy is within the limits of 0-10 kcal. According to Hammond’s rule under these conditions the transition state would be more similar to the final product than to the starting compound which means that the reaction coordinate has a relatively high value. This justifies to a great extent the assumption that the dependence of 1/kobs on [RH] is not so much related to the chemistry of the reaction but rather to the experimental conditions because it is observed only in some cases and it is concentration limited. In addition, W has a constant value in solvents of various natures (CCl4, CHCl3, CH3CN, decane). In the ozonation of paraffins the activation energies approach values of 14-15 kcal/mol, while reactions through a complex formation should have Ea <10 kcal/mol. The UV spectrum of ozone in n-hexane solution is similar to that in the gas phase. The insignificant bathochromic shift of 6 nm does not lead to a broadening of the absorption band. The hypsochromic effect leads to a change in the molecular absorbance (E) by 10% from 1820 to 2002 M-1.cm-1. The blue colour of ozone is preserved in the n-hexane solution. The infrared (IR) spectra of the gaseous ozone and of its solution in n-hexane are practically identical and new bands are not identified. In the nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of the n-hexane solutions of ozone at a temperature of 80 oC and after a long time no changes in the spectrum of n-hexane are observed. Only upon ozonolysis of olefins at 100 oC in the IR cell and the analysis of the IR spectra, is the formation of P-complexes presumed [76, 77]. Thus the reaction of ozone with paraffins is more likely to be a bimolecular process, excluding preliminary complex formation, which leads directly to the formation of the reaction products: RH + O3 m products (k)
17
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds and then the data extrapolated to [RH]m0 in column 3 of Table 1.2 will correspond to a bimolecular constant k. We have assumed that the reaction of ozone with the homologous series of n-paraffins is isoentropic and the differences in their reactivities are determined by the energies of the C-H bonds. In order to eliminate random factors we have related the relative rate constants to that of n-hexane: kn/k6 = exp (-0.3$D/RT)
(1.9)
where $D = Dn – D6 is the difference between the energies of C-H bonds in kcal/ mol; n is the carbon number for the corresponding paraffin; 0.3 is the empirical coefficient. At 293 K, R = 1.99 cal/(mol.K) and k6 = 0.019 M-1.s-1: kn = 0.019.exp (-0.514.$D)
(1.10)
The energies of C-H bonds for primary (I), secondary (II) and tertiary (III) C atoms are calculated according to the following equations [70]: DI = 93.6 + 830.4 f, g, i, j,...
(1.11)
DII = 85.6 + 830.4 f, g, i, j,...
(1.12)
DIII = 77.6 + 830.4 f, g, i, j,...
(1.13)
where f, g, i, j,... denote the number of C atoms in each linear hydrocarbon chain bonded to the C atom, where at the energy of the C-H bonds is calculated. The k values estimated by Equation 1.10 for paraffins comprising only primary C-H bonds (e.g., methane, neopentane) are within the limits 0.00078 w 0.000013; with secondary C-H bonds (n-paraffins) - 0.48 w 0.00078 and with tertiary C-H bonds (sec-butane, alkylsubstituted n-paraffins) - 2.93 w 0.048. The ratio in between to the maximum and minimum rates is 1:61:3756 and 1:60:3692, respectively. The calculated values of k and D of the C-H bonds for some paraffins are presented in Table 1.3 and a comparison with the experimental data has been made. It is seen that the calculated values of k and D are in a very good agreement with the experimental results of Table 1.2 and are also in a complete conformity with the data from the literature [2-15]. A slight difference is noticed only for hydrocarbons containing primary C-H bonds. Because of their lower reactivity insignificant amounts of microimpurities might increase the experimental values of k. Thus the
18
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons difference between the calculated and the experimental values of k could be used as a measure for checking the purity of paraffins.
Table 1.3 Calculated and experimental kinetic and thermodynamic parameters of ozone reactions with some paraffins No. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33.
Paraffin Methane Ethane n-Propane n-Butane n-Pentane n-Hexane n-Heptane n-Octane n-Nonane n-Decane n-Undecane n-Dodecane n-Tridecane n-Tetradecane n-Octadecane Polyethylene 3-Me-pentane 2,3-Di-Me-pentane 2,4-Di-Me-pentane 2,3,4-Tri-Me-pentane 2-Me-hexane 3-Me-hexane 2,2-Di-Me-hexane 2,4-Di-Me-hexane 2,2,5-Tri-Me-hexane 3-Me-heptane Ethylcyclopropane Neopentane Hexamethylethane Cyclohexane Norbornane Adamantane 2,2,4-Tri-Me-pentane
kcal/kexp (M-1.s-1) 1.2 × 10-5/6.6 × 10-4 1.52 × 10-4/6.3 × 10-3 1.8 × 10-3/3.4 × 10-3 5 × 10-2/5.8 × 10-3 0.013/0.015 0.019/0.019 0.029/0/021 0.033/0.023 0.039/0.026 0.041/0.029 0.043 0.046 0.046 0.047/0.036 0.048/0.048 0.048 0.15/0.15 0.08/0.29 0.06/0.08 0.04/0.59 0.10/0.13 0.23/0.20 0.01/0.015 0.17/0.13 0.08/0.19 0.26/0.20 0.15/0.05 1.12 × 10-4/3.8 × 10-5 0.00016/0.00002 0.01/0.01 0.014/0.014 0.22/0.22 0.05/0.14
DC-H (Kcal) 101.6 96.8 92 90 88.2 87.4 86.6 86.3 86 85.9 85.8 85.7 85.66 85.66 85.607 85.6 83.36 84.64 85.02 85.92 84.20 82.59 88.42 83.10 84.61 82.28 88.6? 97.4 96.67 88.6? 99? 82.6? 85.54
19
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The energies of C-H bonds, given in column 4 of Table 1.3 for linear and branched paraffins are calculated based on Equations 1.11-1.13 and for cycloparaffins 27, 30 and 32 from the rate constants. The latter approach can be regarded as a very good method for determination of thermodynamic parameters on the basis of kinetic data. The good correlation between the calculated and experimental values of k testifies that the H-atom abstraction mechanism is more adequate for describing the interaction of ozone with alkanes.
1.2.2 Cycloparaffins The kinetics and mechanism of ozone reactions with cycloparaffins ranging from cyclopentane to cyclododecane have been studied. From a thermodynamic point of view cycloparaffins contain only equivalent C-H bonds and their energies, calculated according to Equations 1.11-1.13, using a model of infinite chain, are 88.9-88.5 kcal/ mol, and for cyclopropane and cyclobutane they are 91 and 89.5 kcal/mol, respectively. The literature values for the former compound are within the limits of 94 ± 3 kcal/ mol and for the latter they are 100.4 ± 2 and 95 ± 3 kcal/mol [28]. The deviations of the calculated and literature values could be attributed to the approximations of the chosen model which considers both the small and the big cycles as infinitely large. In both cases, however, it could be stated that after cyclobutane, D does not actually depend on the cycle size. From a stereochemical point of view, however, the cycloparaffins differ considerably with respect to number, stability and symmetry of the conformers in which they exist, to the number of equatorial, axial, pseudoequatorial and pseudoaxial, exo- and endo-H atoms, to the deviations from the equilibrium values of the bond lengths, valent and torsion angles and steric hindrance in the cycles. Upon ozonation the energy of the system will either decrease and the reaction will be accelerated or increase and the reaction will be retarded and the reactivity of cycloparaffins would be different irrespective of the similar energies of the C-H bonds in them. The rate will also be determined by the product of the numbers of symmetry S: j
S = Ï Cv i=1
where CN is the axis of symmetry; N is the order of identity per one motion; and j is the number of axes of symmetry (e.g., cyclopropane has one axis of symmetry of third order or three-fold C3N and then S = 3, cyclobutane has three axes of symmetry of second order C2N and S = 8, and cyclohexane has one axis of third order C3N and one of second C2N and S = 6) of the initial compounds and of the activated complex (AC), and under other conditions, the increase of symmetry will increase W.
20
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons Using the PCMOD4 program based on molecular mechanics methods [78, 79], we calculated the steric energies (SE) of cycloparaffins and their radical forms (c-CnH2n and c-CvnH2n-1). First, we carried out calculations on the various stereoisomers and selected the conformer with the lowest energy (e.g., ‘envelope’ for C5 and ‘chair’ for C6) and SERH. Then we simulated the H-atom abstraction at consecutive moves of the reaction centre at each nonequivalent C-H bond in this conformer and thus we selected the model with minimum SER. Five calculations were made for cyclo-C5, 6 for cyclo-C6, 7 for cyclo-C7, etc. Thus by the difference $SE = SERH–SER we estimated whether or not the transition sp3 m sp2 is favourable. The results from the calculations are given in Table 1.4.
Table 1.4 Conformations, numbers of symmetry (S), calculated SERH and SER, $SE and SERH and the experimental SER of cycloparaffins S
SERH (kcal/ mol)
SER (kcal/ mol)
$SE (kcal/ mol)
SERH (exp) (kcal/mol)
Propane
3
26.2
39.9
-13.7
27.6
2.
Butane
4
24.0
21.7
2.3
26.4
3.
Pentane
1
5.5
3.4
2.1
6.5
4.
Hexane
6
0.0
0.0
0.0
0
5.
Heptane
2
7.1
4.1
3.0
6.3
6.
Octane
8
12.5
8.0
4.5
9.6
7.
Nonane
1
15.6
9.8
5.8
12.6
8.
Decane
10
15.3
9.3
6.0
12.0
9.
Undecane
1
14.6
9.9
4.7
-
10.
Dodecane
16
10.2
6.2
4.0
3.6
No.
c-Cn
1.
Conformation
Note: The designations of the conformations of cycloparaffins from top to bottom are: triangle, plane square, envelope, chair, twist chair, twist crown, twist crown, twist crown, twist crown and square with 4 butane segments in chair conformation. For the cycles bigger than C7, the conformations shown are among those which differ by not more than 1 kcal/mol but have the highest symmetry. Under real conditions the intrinsic (real) number of symmetry is between 1 and its maximum value and it will be determined by the share of each conformer: we have looked for a coincidence between the theoretical and the experimental values of SE [80]; we have calculated SERH.(exp) from the thermochemical values of the heats of combustion of cycloparaffins in the gaseous phase according to the expression (Qn/n-Q6/6), where n is the number of methylene groups in the cycle, and Qn and Q6 are the heats of combustion of the cycloparaffins and cyclohexane, respectively.
21
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The reaction with cyclopropane and cyclohexane appears to be the slowest due to the increase in energy cycle upon the sp3 m sp2 transition. In the other cases the energy decreases and this leads to a rise of the reaction rates. The parameters of cycloalkane ozonolysis [48, 51] obtained experimentally are depicted in Table 1.5.
Table 1.5 Kinetic parameters of ozone reaction with cycloparaffins (20 oC, CCl4) Parameters 3
k × 10 p 10% (M-1.s-1) A × 10-7 (M-1.s-1) Ea p 0.5 (kcal/mol)
Pentane
Hexane
Heptane
Octane
Nonane
Decane
Dodecane
24.9
10.0
229.0
480.0
890.0
408.0
62.0
2.7
38.2
2.2
1.7
24.3
170.0
168.0
12.2
14.3
10.8
10.2
11.4
13.0
14.1
For the elimination of some factors which are common for the reactivity of cycloparaffins we have used the values of the relative constants: kn/k6 = (An/A6).exp(-$E/RT)
(1.14)
where n is the number of carbon atoms in the cycle; $E = En-E6 is the difference between the activation energies of the n-th cycloparaffin and that of cyclohexane. Taking into consideration the experimental data in Table 1.2 the values of the parameters in the right term of Equation 1.14 are shown in Table 1.6: The decrease of $E to the left and to the right from cyclohexane indicates the sp3 m sp2 transition in cyclohexane is energetically most unfavourable. The variations in An/A6 and $E show the occurrence of the compensation effect (CEF), which in this particular case could be ascribed to the different SE of the cycles and to their symmetry.
Table 1.6 Values for parameters in Equation 1.14 C5
C6
C7
C8
C9
C10
C12
$E (kcal/mol)
–2.1
0
–3.5
–4.1
–2.9
–1.3
–0.2
Exp(-$E/RT)
35.9
1
383.7
1064.2
138.4
9.1
1.4
An/A6
0.071
1
0.058
0.045
0.636
4.45
4.34
22
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons On the basis of the expression for the rate constant in the theory of the AC including the entropy of the activation complex [81, 82]: k = e2.(RT/Nah).exp($S/R).exp(-$E/RT)
(1.15)
where e is the base of natural logarithm; Na is Avogadro’s number; h is Planck’s constant. The values of $S have been calculated in Table 1.7.
Table 1.7 Values of $S $S [cal/ (mol.K)]
C5
C6
C7
C8
C9
C10
C12
–19.46
–14.46
–19.87
–20.39
–15.06
–11.17
–11.20
The values of entropy increase from small, C5, to medium, C7-C9 cycles, and are lower for the large C10 and C12 but even in the latter case the rate constants are higher than that of cyclohexane. The combined solution of Equations 1.14 and 1.15 leads to: kn/k6 = exp($$S/R).exp(-$E/RT)
(1.16)
where $$S = $Sn - $S6. The change of $$S and $E is additional evidence for the occurrence of CEF. We have found an empirical relationship between the reactivity of cycloparaffins and their steric energy (Equation 1.17) [48]: log(kn/k6) = X.(SE)1/2
(1.17)
where X is an empiric coefficient and SE is the steric energy. Thus by applying Equation 1.17 (the data for the steric energies are available) it is possible to evaluate k for new compounds. The experimental dependence of the reactivity of cycloalkanes on their steric energy is shown in Figure 1.2.
23
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
1
C9
2.0
C8
lg(kn/k6)
1.5
C10
C7
1.0
C4 C3
C12
2
C5
0.5
C6 0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
1/2
(SE) , kcal
Figure 1.2 The dependence of the cycloalkanes reactivity on their steric energy. 1 for cycles > C6; 2 - for cycles < C6
It follows from Figure 1.2 that a = 0.54 and 0.16 for curves 1 and 2, respectively. The experimental point for C10, which deviates from the straight line by 16% (the experimental value of log(kn/k6) is 1.6 and the extrapolated value is 1.9, as denoted by a circle on curve 1). The same notation is used on curve 2 for the extrapolated points for log(kn/k6) of C4 and C3 with values of 0.8 and 0.83, respectively. The calculated rate constants for the ozone reaction with these two cycloalkanes will amount to 63 and 67 M-1.s-1, respectively. The difference in the slopes of the two curves is most probably associated with the more hindered sp3 m sp2 transition in smaller cycles. This fact is also supported by the data on the values of SE in Table 1.4. The theoretical and kinetic studies reveal that ozone reacts with cycloalkanes via H-atom abstraction. The reactivities of cycloalkanes depend on the direction of the steric energy change during the sp3 m sp2 transition in AC. The dependence of the rate constant of cyclooctane ozonolysis on its concentration is presented in Figure 1.3. The variation of [RH] and [O3] up to three orders of magnitude does not affect k and the rate of the reaction is described by the following equation: W = k.[RH]1.[O3]1
24
(1.18)
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
0.5
0.4
cyclooctane
k, M-1.s -1
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0 0
10
20
30
40
[RH], mM
Figure 1.3 Dependence of the rate constant of ozone reaction with cyclooctane at 10 oC The semilogarithmic anamorphosis of the kinetic curves of ozone consumption at [RH]>>[O3] upon ozonolysis of H12 cyclo-6 and D12 cyclo-C6 is shown in Figure 1.4.
0.4
D12
lg[O3]0/[O3]t
0.3
0.2 H12 0.1
0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Time, min
Figure 1.4 Semilogarithmic anamorphosis of the kinetic curves of ozone consumption upon ozonolysis of H12 cyclo-6 and D12 cyclo-C6 ozone consumption at 28 oC
25
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The reaction of ozone decomposition follows first-order kinetics and the rate of the reaction with D12 cyclo-6 is found to be higher. The ratio kH/kD = 5.4 is indicative of the occurrence of the primary isotope effect, which indicates that the H-atom abstraction is the rate-limiting step of the reaction.
1.2.3 Method for estimation of reaction mechanisms The method for the estimation of reaction mechanism (ERM), developed by us, is based on the comparison of values, calculated by means of the AC theory and experimental values of pre-exponents. According to the concepts developed in the AC theory [8183] the equation for the rate constant k of a bimolecular reaction is: k = G.C.[RT/(Nah)].[F#/(FaFb)].Ffrexp[-Ea/(RT)]
(1.19)
where F, Fa and Fb are the corresponding total statistical sums of the AC and of the initial compounds A and B. The total statistical sums are a product of the separate statistical sums of the state: F = Ft.Fr.Fv.Fe.Fn
(1.20)
where t, r, v, e and n denote the corresponding translational, rotational, vibration, electronic and nuclear sums of the state. The translational sum of the state at 3 degrees of freedom is described by Equation 1.21: Ft = h-3.(2PmkT)3/2
(1.21)
where m is the mass of the molecule; k is Boltzmann’s constant; and T is the absolute temperature. The values of Ft are within the limits 1024-1025 cm3 per molecule. The rotational sum of the state for nonlinear molecule is: Fr = 8P2(8P3IAIBIC)1/2(kT)3/2h-3
(1.22)
where I A I B I C are the principal moments of inertia of the molecule, when the origin of the coordinate lies at the mass centre of the molecule. The v a l u e s o f t h e s e s u m s d o n o t e x c e e d 1 0 2- 1 0 3 c m 3/ m o l e c u l e . The equation for estimation of the statistical sum of the vibration movement is: Fv = (1- e -hN/kT)-1 26
(1.23)
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons where N is the vibrational frequency. The magnitude of FN for one degree of freedom is of the order of 1-10 cm3 per molecule, as the vibrations in the molecules are within the range of 100-3000 cm-1, i.e., N is in the interval 3 × 1012 – 9 × 1013 cm-1 that is close to the value of kT/h = 6.1 × 1012 cm-1 at -173 oC. The statistical sums of the free rotator are: Ffr = (8P3Ia kT)1/2h-1S-1
(1.24)
where Ia is the reduced moment of inertia in regard to the axis of rotation. The electronic sum of the state for adiabatic processes, also including ozone reactions, is demonstrated by: Fe = 1
(1.25)
The nuclear sum of the state for Frank-Condon’s processes, which is the case with most of the chemical transformations, is given by: Fn = 1
(1.26)
The transmission coefficient (G) takes into account the AC probability to be converted into reaction products. In the case of adiabatic reactions it is equal to 1, and for multiple nonadiabatic reactions it may be much smaller than 1. The coefficient L takes into account the tunnel effects associated with the reaction pathway via the quantum way through percolation ‘below barrier’ of the potential surface. The probability for tunnelling depends on: (1) the mass of the particle m and the smaller it is, the greater is the probability for transition, (2) the barrier width D its decrease leads to increase in the tunnelling probability, (3) its height Ea - with its decrease the probability for tunnelling increases, and (4) the steepness of the potential surface at the depression point, (d2U/dx2) - its rise results in increasing the tunnelling probability. According to Gamov [83] the probability for tunnelling via triangle barrier is:
C = [2m(Ea-U)]1/2.exp[-8PD/(3h)]
(1.27)
where U is the height of tunnelling occurrence. In the case of reactions proceeding via redistribution of atoms at room or higher temperatures the tunnel effect is extremely small and L is equal to 1. This is also true for the reactions, studied by us.
27
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds For the calculation of the rate constant according to Equation 1.19 it is necessary to estimate the potential surface of the reaction and the statistical sums of AC, RH and O3. This is a typical quantum-chemical task, which has been the subject of intensive study by various researchers and we will not focus our attention on the difficulties and successes in this respect [84-88]. Easier methods for the calculation of potential surfaces are those that are semiempirical, such as Mopac 6 [87]. Its use will be presented later on. The estimation of the statistical sums provides important information about the mechanism of chemical reactions. For performing the calculations it is necessary to know the geometry of the starting molecules and AC and the vibration frequency of the bond on the reaction coordinate. The geometry of the starting molecules is usually well known [70], while the geometry of the AC is a more complicated problem, as the potential surface of the reaction is unknown. It is difficult to determine the reaction coordinate, usually done only by indirect data. In order to find an acceptable solution of this problem we have applied Franck-Condon’s principle [89] and Hammond’s empirical rule [75], which connect the thermal effect of the reaction with the reaction coordinate. These two principles allow the determination of the geometrical parameters of the AC with an accuracy up to 10%. The thermodynamic approach of the pre-exponential factor calculation in the Arrhenius equation can be given by the expression: A = G.C.[RT/(Nah)].[F#/(FaFb)].Ffr
(1.28)
These considerations were used in developing a computer program for calculating A and the statistical sums of internal rotation [90]. In addition the program also includes the calculation of A and the steric factor p, according to the collision theory. It also takes into account the number of equivalent H atoms and the proceeding of the reaction in the liquid phase. For calculation of A it is necessary to define the geometrical parameters of AC. Principally there exist two forms of the AC - linear and cyclic. In the first an inner rotation is possible while in the second it is absent. The values of A calculated for the linear AC in each case will be higher than those calculated with the cyclic form. The calculated values of A were compared with the experimental values and on the basis of the degree of coincidence one or another mechanism could be preferred. In this manner the method for ERM gives additional possibilities for clarifying the investigated reaction mechanism.
28
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
1.2.4 Application of ERM Using ERM we have analysed mechanisms M.1.1-M.1.6. According to these mechanisms, the reactions take place via two forms of the AC - linear (LC) and cyclic (CC) (Scheme 1.3).
O R R'
C
O H
O
O
O O
;
R
C R'
R"
H
.
R" CC
LC
Scheme 1.3 LC is associated with the H-atom bond cleavage mechanism and CC with ozone incorporation inside the C-H bonds. LC is characterised by the ozone interaction with the C-H bond via one of its terminal atoms and thus there is a possibility for free bond rotation around the H-O and O-O bonds, while in the CC it forms a five-membered cycle with the participation of a five-fold coordinated carbon. Table 1.8 summarises the calculated values of A for the two AC forms. Next we shall focus our attention on estimating the value of A calculated for each separate reaction [48, 52]. The ratio between the statistical sums of electronic and nuclear movement of the AC and those of the initial compounds is 1 as the change of energy is smooth and the electron-nuclear states are not changed; G and L are equal to 1 under the experimental conditions. The value of A can be presented by two multipliers [63]: Ao is a geometric factor, which is determined by the AC geometry and A1 is the contribution by the internal degrees of freedom. In this case we can write the following expressions: A0 = (kT/h) . (Ft#/FtRHFtO3).(Fr#/FrRHFrO3).Ffr#
(1.29)
A1 = (Fv#/FvC-H).(FvR#/FvR).(FvO3#/FvO3).J
(1.30)
where Fv are the statistical sums of the vibrations of the reaction centre, i.e., C-H bond in the initial alkane; J = Jo × exp(-Eh/RT) is the coefficient considering the highest energy that the rotator must overcome at its twist to 360°.
29
30 13.5 13.5
2.12
1.99 1.99
1.88
1.81
1.69
2
6 1
1
2
16
C7
C8
C9
C10
C12
where J = (kT/h) × (Ft#/FtRHFtO3)
8.3
2.29
6
C6
278
97
34
2.5
0.8
2.54
1
C5
IAIBIC × 10-6 (au.Å2)
S
Cycle
J × 10-7 (M-1.s-1)
13
7.68
4.53
2.88 -
2.25
1.23
0.71
S.Ffr
32
12.2
5.40
2.54 2.54
2.02
0.59
0.44
IAIBIC × 10-8 au.Å2
#
#
4.40
2.72
1.81
1.24 1.24
1.10
0.60
0.52
Fr × 10-6
1.41
1.39
1.37
1.34 1.34
1.32
1.28
1.24
Ffr × 10-3
40.3
5.6
3.2
21.5 3.6
8.56
26.6
6.84
A0 × 10-7
3.55
0.48
0.28
1.85 0.31
0.74
2.29
0.59
A × 10-7 (M-1.s-1)
9.95
1.34
0.77
5.17 0.86
2.06
6.40
1.65
Al × 10-7 (M-1.s-1)
Table 1.8 Pre-exponent (A) of the ozone reaction with cycloalkanes at 27 oC calculated by the method of the activated complex
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons The sums at 27 oC were calculated by using the following equations: Ft = 3.86.109[(mO3 + mRH)/mO3.mRH]
(1.31)
S.Fr = 78 (IAIBIC )1/2
(1.32)
S.Ffr = 6.24 I’ 1/2
(1.33)
Fv = (1- e -hN/kT)-1
(1.34)
It should be noted that the values of Ao thus calculated are relatively reliable. Literature values are used for ozone [29, 64] for the length of the O-O bond, 1.278 p 0.003 Å, and for the OOO angle, 116° 49a p 30a; the main inertial moments IaIbIc are 7.875 × 10-40, 62.844 × 10-40 and 70.888 × 10-40, respectively; S = 2, Fe and Fn = 1. For a cycloalkane the values of the length of the C-C and C-H bonds are 1.54 Å and 1.09 A, respectively, and a value 109.5 for the CCC=CCH=HCH angles has been used. In Table 1.8 the values of IaIbIc are calculated according to well-known methods [1, 89]. We have selected the most stable conformers of the cycles known [80], confirmed also by the calculations according to the Alinger method (Table 1.4). Thus the preferred conformation for cyclopentane is envelope (Cs), for cyclohexane - chair, for cycloheptane - twisted chair (C2v), for cyclooctane - twisted crown with 3 axes C2v, regular crown with 2 axes C2v or knocked crown without any elements of symmetry. The product IAIBIC is nearly the same for all conformations. However, bearing in mind that the different degrees of symmetry would affect the calculation of A we have used two conformations with numbers of symmetry of 6 and 1. The conformation state of cyclononane is a crown with a symmetry number of 1 but it is insufficiently studied and for this reason we have combined the calculations by the Alinger method with the X-ray data for cyclononylamine bromohydrate [80]. The conformation of cyclododecylamine-1,6 dihydrohydrate, which has only one axis of symmetry of second order, is taken as a base for cyclodecane. According to the X-ray data the cyclododecane has a square shape conformation with butane segments at its sides. This conformation has one axis of fourth and two of second order and its number of symmetry is 16. Some of the most stable conformations of cycloalkanes are represented in Figure 1.5.
31
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
C5
C6
C8
C7
C10
C9
C11
C12
Figure 1.5 Most stable cycloalkane conformations The structure of LC was elaborated on the basis of the following geometrical parameters: the H...O bond length was estimated according to Pauling’s formulae [91]; dH..O = dH-O-0.6.ln(r), where r is the bond order, dH...O is the bond length in the complex and dH-O is the length of ordinary H-O bond equal to 0.95 Å. Considering that the maximum coordinate on the potential surface can be only approximately determined, the bond order was defined within a wide range from 0.2 to 0.8 with dH...O varying from 1.92 to 1.08 Å. The actual value of dH...O lies most likely in this interval and thus the value of 1.35 Å at r = 0.513 was used for the calculations. The lengths of the C-H and O-O bonds in LC are increased by 10% compared with their normal values; the H...O-O angle is accepted as 100° (in water HOH it is 104.5° and in HOOH the HOO angle is 96.6°). The calculation of Ffr was carried out for two asymmetry rotators: one for rotation around the x-axis coinciding with the H...O bond and the second one with rotation around the y-axis coinciding with the O-O bond: y R R'
C
O H
O
O x
R"
The reduced moments of inertia around the y-axis are found to be equal for all cycles and have the value of kg\m2. However, those around the x-axis increase with the rise of the cycloparaffin masses and their values are shown in Table 1.9.
32
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
Table 1.9 Values for moments of inertia around the x-axis C5
C6
C7
C8
C9
C10
C12
50
53
56
58
60
62
64
The values of Ao are presented in Table 1.8 which depends on the LC geometry only and to a smaller extent on the potential surface. The values of A1 could be calculated with lower accuracy as they depend to a greater extent on the form of the potential surface. For the accurate calculation of Ffr it is necessary to know the values of the rotation barrier Efr. The latter were calculated by us using MOPAC6 and for the rotation around the x- and y-axes they are 1.8 and 7.5 kcal, respectively. These values correlate well with the energy of NO rotation in the nitromethane molecule [91]. The correction coefficient was also determined using Pitzer’s tables [92]. Although the latter are designed for symmetric rotators as Pitzer has shown, they can also be successfully applied for the approximate estimation of the thermodynamic functions of asymmetric rotators. The ratio of the vibration statistical sums (F#RHv × F#O3v)/(FRHv × FO3v), which stands for the variations of the vibration frequencies amounts to 1. At the same time one can expect for the ozone molecule, which is characterised by two stretching vibrational frequencies at 1106 and 1036 cm-1 and a deformational one at 703 cm-1 a decrease in the frequency at 703 cm-1, but not lower than the value within the range of 150-200 cm-1 to become kinetically active at kg\m2. The contribution of the vibrational sums to the thermodynamic functions is small and is accepted to be 1 for calculating the ratio F#rcv/FC-Hv at such moderate temperatures as kg\m2, where F#rcv is the vibrational statistical sum of the reaction centre. At higher temperatures, however, this ratio may be much higher [93, 94]. The accurate determination of the vibrational frequency of the reaction centre requires knowledge of the form of the potential surface near the maximum point. For that reason this value could only be approximately evaluated. The frequency of the deformational vibrations of the reaction centre C...H...C lies in the range of 100-400 cm-1 [94]. For the reaction centre C-H...O this value is probably shifted to the higher frequency kinetically nonactive range. This is due to the fact that NO-H lies in the range of 1000-1600 cm-1 and that of C-H in the 400-1000 cm-1 region. Hence, the contribution of the vibrational sums should not differ from 1. However one cannot rule out the probability of the vibrational sum of the reaction centre for bigger cycles reaching values 5-10% higher than those of the small cycles.
33
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds Even in this case the trend in the calculations remains the same. Upon increasing the inertial moment of cycloalkanes as shown above, the vibrational frequency should also increase as it is inversely proportional to its square root. For example, if we accept that N = 200 cm-1 for C5, then for C12 it will be 120 cm-1. In this case the vibrational term will be increased 3.5-fold. It should be noted, however, that the calculations have been made for reactions in the gas phase, while for those in a liquid medium the values of A would be different. According to the collision [95] and AC [81-83, 96] theories the number of collisions in the liquid phase is 2-3 times higher than in the gas phase. Both theories predict that at El = Eg the value of A will be 3 times higher than that in the gas phase. In reference [91] it is supposed that the increase of k for a bimolecular reaction proceeding in liquid phase will be about 5 times. The same tendency is observed when comparing the experimental results from the ozonolysis of acyclic hydrocarbons in the gas phase [2-10] and in an inert solvent, CCl4 [47]. The ratio of the pre-exponential factors is in the range of 2-3. The aforementioned considerations give us grounds to introduce a coefficient for the ratio Al/Ag equal to 2.8 (Table 1.8, column 11). When comparing the experimental results with the theoretical data the experimental value of A is usually related to the number of the active centres. It is well known [6] that the H atoms in cycloparaffins exist in various conformations in respect to the cycle planes - they can be oriented in various positions from equatorial to axial and from endo- to exo-. In cyclohexane, for example, the three equatorial H atoms are 7 times more reactive that the three axial H atoms [74]. The H atoms in the bigger cycles are even more nonequivalent as, besides the axial and equatorial atoms in them, there are also hydrogen atoms lying within the cycles of which a transannular interaction is characteristic. This can be clearly demonstrated by the models of Dreiding and by the various stereochemical programs. The conformation analysis performed demonstrates that the H-atom distribution in the studied cycles is as shown in Table 1.10.
Table 1.10 Hydrogen atom distribution in the studied cycles C5
C6
C7
C8
C9
C10
C12
ax
10
6
8
8
10
10
16
eq
-
6
4
4
6
6
-
exo
-
-
2
4
2
4
8
ax = pseudoaxial, eq = pseudoequational, exo = internal
34
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons In order to compare the experimental values of A with the calculated values we relate the experimental values of A per the number the equatorial H atoms (Table 1.11).
Table 1.11 The experimental and calculated values of A per one equatorial H atom A, M-1.s-1
C5
C6
C7
C8
C9
C10
C12
Aexp × 10
-7
0.32
3.34
0.36
0.29
2.48
22.8
12.9
Acal × 10-7
1.65
6.40
2.06
0.86
0.77
1.34
9.90
The experimental values of A vary from 0.3 × 107 to 23 × 107 M-1.s-1. It has been found that the values of A calculated for the AC with LC lie within the range (0.810) × 107, while those for the CC are in the range of 105–106 M-1.s-1. The lower (about 130 times) values in the latter case are related to the lack of free rotation and to the more compact structure (2-4 times) of this complex. However in this case the eventual increase of A, on account of the occurrence of low frequency vibrations of the reaction centre which in our opinion can bring about not more than 2-3 times increase, should be taken into account. Thus the values of A calculated with CC should be about 100 times lower than the experimental values. The agreement of A calculated with LC with the experimental values of A becomes even better when comparing them for each cycle alone. In fact the differences in the values of A for all cycles do not exceed 3, which fact will be discussed further. The obtained results show that the probability of the reaction to occur via a cyclic transition state is negligibly small. Consequently, the probability of the ozone reaction with the C-H bonds taking place through a mechanism of incorporation or formation of oxy-radicals in one step is also small. It follows from these two mechanisms that the reaction should take place in at least two steps: H-atom abstraction giving rise to (RU + UOOOH) or to (RU + HOU +O2). Because the endothermicity of the latter is lower by 16 kcal/mol it is thermodynamically more favourable. In our opinion, one of the reasons for the existence of such a variety of schemes describing the reaction RH + O3 is due to the lack of consideration of entropy factors. As a result of taking them into account it can be seen that the abstraction of the H atom is the limiting step in the ozonolysis of paraffins. In view of the possibilities, the ERM is a universal method because it can be applied to every type of chemical reaction.
35
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
1.3 Cyclohexane The reaction of ozone with cyclohexane [52] is studied in a wide range of concentrations. The typical kinetic curves are given in Figure 1.6. The profiles of the product curve formation show that cyclohexanol (-OH), cyclohexanone (C=O), peroxide (ROOH) and acids are obtained in parallel reactions. The initial rate of alcohol formation is about 3 times higher than that of the ketone. The same ratio for this reaction has also been reported by other authors [9, 67, 97]. The ratio between the rates of product formation is Wal:Wket:WROOH = 4:1:1. The nature of the peroxides formed in the course of the reaction has been clarified by studying the kinetics of iodine liberation during the oxidation reaction with HI solution in CHCl3:CH3COOH. The rate of iodine evolution was measured at L = 470 nm. In order to ignore the formation of peroxide compounds arising from the further oxidation of the reaction products (alcohol and ketone), we used reaction mixtures with very small conversion degrees, approximately 0.07%. The results obtained (Figure 1.7) justify the probable formation of H2O2, cyclohexylhydroperoxide (ROOH) and dicyclohexylperoxide (ROOR) in the reaction mixture, which react at different rates with HI (KI) [76].
10 -OH 8 C=O
[P], mM
6
4 ROOH
2
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
Time, min
Figure 1.6 Kinetics of basic product formation during cyclohexane ozonolysis at [RH] = 9.29 M, [O3] = 0.7 mM, 20 oC
The formation of the above-mentioned peroxides was confirmed by the iodometric procedure modified by us. A volume of 0.5 ml saturated water solution of KI and 0.5 ml
36
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons CH3COOH were added to 0.5 ml of oxidate. The latter was kept in the dark at room temperature for 2 h. The quantity of the iodine liberated after 30 min corresponds to H2O2 and ROOH, and that after 24 h to ROOR. Further, the separate determination of H2O2 and ROOH has been carried out by treatment of the oxidate sample with an aqueous solution of catalase (a specific enzyme decomposing H2O2) [98]. Thus the titration of the iodine liberated after 30 min gives the concentration of ROOH and by the difference between the two titrations, the content of H2O2.
100 140
1
3
80
60 100
2
40
D / D, %
D / D0, %
120
80 20 60 0 0
20
40
60
80 100 120 1440
1460
1480
1500
Titration time, min
Figure 1.7 Dependence of the relative optical intensities DT/D (%) on the titration duration: DT, D, - determined at time T and after 24 h at 470 nm; 1 - 0.07% conversion; 2, 3 - reference mixtures (solutions) - tert-butylhydroperoxide (2) and di-tert-butylperoxide (3) = 1:1
The duration of the quantitative iodine liberation was determined using a model system comprising H2O2, tert-butylhydroperoxide and di-tert-butylperoxide and it was found to be 30 minutes for H2O2 and tert-butyl-OOH and 24 hours for di-tertbutylperoxide. These time durations in the dark treatment correspond to well-known literature data for their rates of interaction with HI (KI) [99-102]. The possibilities of the proposed procedure for the separate identification of H2O2, alkylhydroperoxides and dialkylperoxides are illustrated by the data in Table 1.12. The yield of peroxides was found to be 1-15%. The authors of [78] reported a 45% yield but they, in fact, do not discuss it and have no explanation for this high yield.
37
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds In our opinion, it is most likely because of the higher experimental temperature - the chain radical oxidation might generate higher quantities of peroxides.
Table 1.12 Concentrations of H2O2, t-BuOOH and t-BuOOBu-t (s 102 M) Compound
0 min
30 min
24 h
H 2O 2
1
1
-
H2O2*
1
0
-
t-BuOOH
1
1.13
-
t-BuOOH*
1
1.2
-
t-BuOOBu-t
1
0.07
1.0
t-BuROOBu-t*
1
0.08
1.0
1 = 0.5 + 0.5
0.49
1.08
H2O2:t-BuOOH = 1:1
Note: *titration carried out in the dark
The ratio between the initial rates of peroxide formation as shown by the kinetics of H2O2, ROOH and ROOR accumulation is 1:1:4. The relationships of the rates of product formation on the ozone content, depicted in Figure 1.8, exhibit a linear pattern. The acid numbers of the reaction mixture, determined by titration with an aqueousalcohol solution of NaOH and indicator phenolphthalein, are an order of magnitude higher than the content of adipic acid as determined by gas chromatography. This observation demonstrates the complex composition of the acids. In reference [97] it is considered, however, that the acid number is completely determined by the presence of adipic acid, but this statement obviously contradicts the chromatographic data obtained by us which show that adipic acid comprises a very small percentage of the total acid content. In a number of experiments we have found that the content of water is about 50% of the total yield. The same water yield was obtained in tetradecane ozonolysis [1].
38
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
Sumof -OO-
30 25
HexOOHex
[P].104, M
20 15 HexOOH
10 5
H2O2
0 0
10
20
30
40
Time, min
Figure 1.8 Kinetics of peroxides formation, [RH] = 9.26 m, WO3 = 1 × 10-5 M/s-1, 20 oC On the basis of studies and analyses carried out, the most plausible mechanism of the reaction can be presented as shown in Scheme 1.4. }m (J) Rv + O2 + vOH RH + O3 = [Rv + HO3v (HOv + O2] }m cage
(1)
}m (1 - J) ROOOH; ROH +O2
RH + vOH = Rv + HOH
(2)
Rv + O2 = RO2v
(3)
}m (A) ROH+ R'C=O + O2 RO2v + RO2v }m
(6)
}m (1 - A) ROOR + O2 Scheme 1.4 In Scheme 1.4 the following reactions can be added: RO2v + RH = ROOH + Rv ROOH = ROv + HOv,
39
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds but as the concentration of the hydroperoxides in the reaction mixture is only about 2% and the experimental temperature is below 40 oC and the radical chain reactions are of minor importance in the oxidation process. The kinetic analysis of Scheme 1.4 leads to the following expressions for the rates of formation of alcohol, ketone and ROOR: WOH = (1 - J) WO3 + A k6 [RO2v]2 = (1 - J - 2AJ)WO3
(1.35)
WC=O = A k6 [RO2v]2 = 2AJ WO3
(1.36)
WROOR = (1 - A) k6 [RO2v]2 = (1 -A)JWO3,
(1.37)
where WO3 is the rate of ozone absorption. The experimentally obtained dependences of the accumulation rates of the alcohol, ketone and ROOR are in a good agreement with the equations derived from Scheme 1.4 (Figure 1.9). On the basis of Equations 1.35-1.37 obtained values for A and J were 0.7 and 0.3, respectively. From the rates of reaction product accumulation the stationary concentration of the peroxide radicals was determined to be 1.5 × 10-6 M. It has been suggested in references [11, 18] that ozone reacts with RO2v radicals: RO2v + O3 = ROv + 2O2
(4)
and then the alcohol will be obtained through the reaction: ROv + RH = ROH + Rv
(5)
However, in this case the dependence of WOH on WO3 should be linear in coordinates WOH/(WO3)1/2, which has not been experimentally observed (Figure 1.9). In addition W must be greater than the sum of the rates of all reaction product formation, a fact which has not been confirmed by the experimental results. These two facts suggest that reactions (4) and (5) could be ignored.
40
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
-OH, O3/O2 8
6
W.106
-OH, O3/He 4
C=O, O3/O2
2
ROOR, O3/O2
C=O, O3/He
0 0
2
4
6
W0.106, M.s
8
10
-1
6 ROOR, O3/He 5
W1/2.103, (M.s-1)1/2
4 3 ROOH, O3/O2, (100C)
2 1 0 0
1
2
3
W0.106, M.s
4
5
6
-1
Figure 1.9 Rates of product formation during cyclohexane ozonolysis depending on WO3 (20 oC)
If we accept that compared with cumene oxidation [14] the termination step generates RO radicals: RO2v + RO2v = 2ROv + O2 during this reaction, then an additional quantity of alcohol will be provided by reaction (5). Thus it may be expected that the dilution of cyclohexane with an inert solvent should decrease the rate of reaction (5), consequently the ratio alcohol:ketone. However the experimental results show that the ratio is not changed upon the cyclohexane dilution with tetrachloromethane thus rejecting the generation of oxyradicals from the peroxide radical recombination.
41
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The yield of H2O2 is 2-3%. The formation of an insignificant quantity of H2O2 could be explained by the following reactions [97]: HOv + O3 m HO2v + O2 HO2v + RH m H2O2 + Rv Adipic acid is obtained in the monomolecular decomposition of ROv radicals: ROv m vCH2(CH2)4CHO m HOOOC(CH2)4COOH In addition one should also consider that in the total yield some products of the ozone reaction with cyclohexanone, cyclohexanol or cyclohexylperoxide are also of course included in tenths of a per cent. This shows that the reaction with ROv radical participation has an insignificant contribution to the total yield. We also carried out cyclohexane ozonolysis with reduced concentrations of O2 by its replacement with He. In this case, at equal initial ozone concentration its consumption rate increases two-fold, which could be due to the proceeding of the following reaction: Rv + O3 = ROv + O2
(7)
and the increase of the contribution of reaction (5). Considering reactions (7) and (5), WOH and WC=O will depend on WO3 in the following manner: WO3obs = WO3RH + WO3Rv
(1.38)
WO3Rv= k7.[Rv][O3]=2J k7 [O3] WO3RH (k2 [O2])-1
(1.39)
WOH={1-J+2AJ+2Jk7[O3](k2[O2])-1}WO3RH
(1.40)
WC=O=2AJWO3RH=2AJk2 [O2]{k2 [O2]+2Jk7[O3]}-1WO3RH (1.41) The dependences of the rates of product formation on WO3 using O3/He and O3/O2 demonstrate that at the same rate of reaction 1 the rates of product formation vary upon the replacement of O2 by He (Figure 1.9). This fact could be due to the occurrence of reaction (7) which apparently reduces the efficiency of the ozone reaction. The
42
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons comparison of the equations derived for the processes with and without reaction (7) provides a reasonable explanation of the relationships given in Table 1.13.
Table 1.13 The rates of cyclohexanol and cyclohexanone formation at various rates of ozone absorption (WO3 × 106, M-1.s-1) O3/He, WO3 = 7
O3/O2, WO3 = 3.5
O3/He, WO3 = 5
O3/O2, WO3 = 2.5
Cyclohexanol
6.0
3.0
4.8
2.2
Cyclohexanone
0.8
1.2
0.6
0.8
RH
3.6
3.5
2.4
2.5
v
3.4
-
2.5
-
Rate of formation
R
At low O2 concentration the rates of alcohol formation will be described by: WOHHe = (1 - J) WO3RH + WC=OHe + k5[ROv][RH]
(1.42)
The rate of ozone uptake in its reaction with R radicals can be estimated by solving the following equation: WO3Rv = WOHHe - WOHO2+ WC=OO2 - WC=OHe
(1.43)
The values obtained for WO3RH and WO3Rv are in a good agreement with the experimentally observed two-fold rise of WO3. In the case of ozonolysis by mixtures O3/O2 ROOR are obtained via reaction (6) (Figure 1.9), and with the O3/He mixture, because of the higher stationary concentration of RO2v radicals, the rate of the square termination of the alkoxy-radicals increases and hence WC=O (Figure 1.9). We have identified chlorocyclohexane in the chromatograms of the oxidates resulting from the ozonation of cyclohexane solutions in CCl4. This fact confirms the generation of Rv radicals, which can further abstract the Cl atom from the solvent molecule via reaction (8): Rv + CCl4 = RCl + CCl3v
(8)
According to reference [14] the rate constant of the reaction at 20 oC is 1.59 M-1.s-1. We have estimated the stationary concentration of Rv to be 10-7 M from the dependence of the rate of cyclohexane formation on the CCl4 concentration.
43
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The mechanism of ozonolysis includes a stage of radical generation which has also been assumed by other authors [10]. The electron spin resonance (ESR) signals, however, have been registered only for ozonolysis of polyoleffins and cumene [50], which are characterised by relatively low values of k6 and high [RO2v]st. We have confirmed the existence of radical steps in the paraffins ozonolysis by carrying out the reaction directly in the ESR resonator. For this purpose we have developed and constructed a special ESR cuvette (Figure 1.10) [50].
1
3
2 4
5
Figure 1.10 A device for carrying out chemical reactions inside the ESR spectrometer. 1 - separating funnel with capillary for liquid reagent feeding; 2 capillary connected with a vacuum pump ensuring the necessary level of the liquid in the cuvette; 3 - capillary for the gas inlet; 4 - gas outlet; 5 - ESR cuvette
The registered ESR signals are shown in Figure 1.11. They have been interpreted by comparison with those obtained in the initiated oxidation of n-decane, cumene and polyvinylcyclohexane (PVCH) with oxygen. On the basis of the similarities in shape, g-factors and signal width, we have assigned them to RO2v radicals.
44
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
80
Intensity, %
70 60
1
2
50 40 30 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Magnetic field, [E]
100
Intensity, %
80
60
3 40
20
0 50
100
150
200
Magnetic field, [E]
Figure 1.11 ESR spectra: 1 - n-decane; 2 - cumene; 3 and 4 - PVCH at ambient temperature
45
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The dynamics of ESR signal intensities during the PVCH ozonolysis is represented in Figure 1.12.
5
4
Rel. Intensity
3
2
1
0 0
100
200
300
400
500
T ime, s
Figure 1.12 Dynamics of RO2v radical formation during the ozonolysis of powder PVCH at 20 oC
The rise of the intensity of the RO2v singlet at the beginning is related to the opening of new surfaces and ozone interaction with the intermediate products of the reaction. The latter effect [50] has been considered to be one of the reasons for the observed course of the chemiluminescence (CL) intensity in the ozonolysis of 2,7-dimethyloctane, which has been found to be similar. The drop off in the ESR intensity is due to the consumption of the initial compound (100% conversion after 7 min). When the O3/He mixture was used, as would be expected, the ESR signal intensity is an order of magnitude lower as a result of the active proceeding of reaction (7). The kinetics of RO2v radical formation during cumene ozonolysis is given in Figure 1.13. The absolute concentration of RO2v radicals was determined using Rubine dye as a reference compound.
46
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
1.0
[RO .2].105, M
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0 0
50
100
150
T ime, s
Figure 1.13 Kinetics of RO2v-radical formation during cumene ozonolysis. W = 3.5 ×10-4 M.s-1, 20 oC
The decrease in the intensity of the ESR signal with time is connected with the consumption of cumene because of the high rate of ozone absorption. As the first point in Figure 1.13 is registered at 0.6% conversion degree, the stationary concentration of RO2v radicals was determined by extrapolation to zero time and amounts to [RO2v] -5 st = 1.4 × 10 M. Under the experimental conditions applied the rate of the chain oxidation reaction is very low and so RO2v radicals would be consumed exclusively via the square law termination reaction. The rate of the latter, as estimated according to [ROv2]st and k6 = 1.26 × 104 M-1.s-1 [88] is 5.4 × 10-6 M.s-1. This value is 64 times lower than that calculated based on the assumption that WO3 = Wi (initiation rate). This fact confirms that ozone is apparently not an initiator in the studied reaction.
1.4 Cumene It has been found out that the O2 oxidation of cumene takes place through a chainradical route yielding cumylhydroperoxide (CHP), dicumylhydroperoxide (DCHP), acetophenone (ACP), dimethylphenylcarbinol (DMPC), A-methylstyrene, acetone, methanol, formic acid and benzoic acid [14] as reaction products. The kinetic curves of product formation during cumene ozonolysis are shown in Figure 1.14.
47
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
2.5
CH P
[P].103, M
2.0
1.5
DMPC
1.0
Ozonides
0.5
A cids 0.0 0
5
10
15
20
25
T ime, min
Figure 1.14 Kinetics of product formation during ozonolysis of cumene, [RH] = 7.17 M; WO3 = 8.6 ×10-8 M/s-1, 20 oC
The reaction products include ozonides, DMPC, CHP, DCHP, H2O and acids. The linear character at the plots and the absence of induction periods in the curves of ozonide, CHP and DMPC formation are an indication that these products are obtained in parallel reactions. The pattern of the kinetic curves is typical for the formation of intermediate products. In the case of DMPC the curve reaches a plateau in 10 minutes, and that of ozonide which at the beginning is identical to the DMPC curve, begins to go down after 15 minutes. This fact is apparently related to ozonide decomposition and polymerisation and from this part of the curve its rate of decomposition was calculated to be 3 ×10-3 s-1. The dependences of the initial rates of DMPC and ozonide formation on WO3 and of CHP on (WO3)1/2 are depicted in Figure 1.15. It is seen that, while the rates of DMPC and ozonide formation depend linearly on WO3, the rate of CHP formation is proportional to (WO3)1/2. These results suggest the occurrence of parallel steps of formation of the reaction products as well as radical stages in the reaction mechanism.
48
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
2.5
CH P
[P].103, M
2.0
1.5
DMPC
1.0
O zonides
0.5
A cids 0.0 0
5
10
15
20
25
T ime, min
0.4
W CHP .105, M.s -1
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
W 01/2.103
Figure 1.15 (a) Dependence of the rates of DMPC and ozonide formation on WO3, 20 oC. (b) Dependence of the rate of CHP formation on (WO3)1/2, 20 oC
The chemiluminescence kinetic curve, shown in Figure 1.16, resulting from the RO2v radical recombination [55, 104] becomes a straight line in coordinates ln[(I01/2+I1/2)/ (I01/2-I1/2)]/t, where Io is the intensity of the chemiluminescence signal and I is the current intensity. The tangent of the curves has a slope which is equal to 0.5 × (Wi × k6)-1/2, where Wi is the rate of the initiation equal to A × WO3 (A<1) and k6 is the rate constant of the square law termination.
49
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The obtained results could be described by the mechanism shown in Scheme 1.5:
RH + HOv = Rv + H2O (1) ROOv + RH = ROOH + Rv (2) 2ROOv = 2ROv + O2 (6) ROv + RH = ROH + Rv (5) Scheme 1.5
At quasistationary approximation [14, 28, 105] the rates of products formation will be represented as: WDMPC = (1 + 3A).B.W0
(1.44)
WCHP = k2 (2ABW0/k6)1/2 [RH]
(1.45)
W0 = WDMPC + WIDMPC + WCHP + WO3
(1.46)
where WIDMPC is the rate of DMPC formation at square law termination.
50
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons The values of A and B have been determined based on the slopes of the kinetic curves in Figure 1.15a and b and on the basis of the literature values for the rate constants k2 and k6 [95] and they are 0.04 and 0.23, respectively. It follows from the angle of the tangent on the ozonide curve (Figure 1.15a) that 75% of the effective collisions between ozone and cumene are with the benzene ring and only 25% are at the alkyl chain of the cumene molecule, which fits very well the calculated value of B from Figure 1.16. Based on Figure 1.15a we have estimated that the value of WDMPC comprises only 7% of that of WDMPC; hence, the basic share of carbinol is formed via the first reaction in the kinetic cage. Based on the slope of the curve in Figure 1.16 and using the literature values of k6 we have determined that 0.3% of WO3 and 1/6 of RO2 radicals yield products which are chemiluminescent. These results correlate well with the previously mentioned ESR data.
3.5
ln [( I 01/2 + I 1/2) / ( I 01/2 - I 1/2
3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 0
5
10
15
20
25
T ime, s
Figure 1.16 Dependence of the chemiluminescence’s intensity on time at Wo = 4.2 ×10-5 M/s-1
1.4.1 Ozonation in the presence of transition metal compounds The data on the ozonolysis of cumene in the presence of transition metals are very scant [106, 107]. This reaction has been studied mainly in sulphuric acid medium and at low cumene concentrations. Having this in mind we carried out the ozonolysis reaction in both a pure and a 50% solution of acetic acid [57]. 51
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds As has been shown the main products of cumene ozonolysis are ozonides, DMPC and CHP. In acetic acid, the product composition remains the same, but the amount of the products is decreased by about 1.6 times. The rates of CHP and ozonide formation are about 8.8- and 1.6-fold lower, respectively, and the rate of DMC accumulation increases 1.6 times. The ratio of the products is found to be 2.1:1.9:1 ozonide:DMPC:CHP. The rate constant (k) characterising the ozone-acetic interaction at ambient temperature amounts to 1.5 × 10-5 M/s-1, that is about 3.5 × 10-4 smaller that that found for the ozone reaction with cumene (k = 0.35 M/s-1). It is known that acetic acid (AcAc) deactivates ozone, inhibits RO2v radicals and protects the benzene ring [9-101]. The deactivation of ozone in AcAc is also confirmed by the change of the molar coefficient in the UV spectrum compared with that in CCl4. The catalytic properties of Co2+ in hydrocarbon oxidation have been the subject of intensive investigations [107]. It has been established that during the cumeneAcAc ozonolysis in 1:1 (v:v) in the presence of Co(AcO)2 the oxidation reaction is accelerated (Figure 1.17). In contrast to the noncatalysed process in the catalysed process by transition metal salts the ozonolysis is characterised by: (1) absence of ozonide formation that is indicative of the absence of ozone interaction with the phenyl ring, and (2) the main product is DMPC, the accumulation rate of which is proportional to the concentration of Co2+ after 10 min. The initial rates of CHP formation do not vary with the changes in Co2+ but after the 15 min the rates increase with [Co2+]. It can be seen from Table 1.14 that if we take the ozonolysis of pure cumene as a reference reaction then the addition of AcAc results in autoretardation of the oxidation rate and leads to reduction of the product yield. The ratio [3P]/[O3} reaches a value of 6.9. These data indicate the participation of oxygen (accompanying ozone) in the formation of the reaction products. The course of the kinetic curve of DMPC formation on the Co(AcO)2 concentration is connected with its formation in reactions with participation of Co(AcO)2 (Figure 1.17). The catalytic properties of the metal ions under other identical conditions depend on their rate constant of interaction with ozone [102]. For that reason we have determined the values of k in the presence of different transition metals in the cumene-AcAc medium. The rate constants of ozone reaction with some transition metals ions at 20 o C in cumene:AcAc solution (1:1, v/v) are represented in Table 1.15.
52
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
Table 1.14 The kinetics of formation of the sum of products (3P) and their ratio per unit of absorbed ozone [3P]/[O3] for the noncatalysed and catalysed reaction in the presence of AcAc (cumene:AcAc = 1:1) at ambient temperature Cumene
Cumene+ AcAc
5
0.3
0.2
0.8
0.8
0.9
1.0
1.1
1
0.7
2.7
2.7
3.0
3.3
3.7
0.7
0.4
1.4
1.4
1.8
2.2
3.3
1
0.6
2.0
2.0
2.6
3.1
4.7
1.0
0.6
2.1
2.1
2.9
4.0
5.9
1
0.6
2.1
2.1
2.9
4.0
5.9
1.4
0.8
2.8
2.8
4.5
6.1
8.7
1
0.6
2.0
2.0
3.2
4.3
6.2
1.7
1.0
3.5
3.5
6.2
8.1
11.7
1
0.6
2.1
2.1
3.6
4.8
6.9
2.0
-
4.2
4.2
8.0
10.1
-
1
-
2.1
2.1
4.0
5.1
-
[¤P] × 103 M [¤P]/[O3] [¤P] × 10 M
3
10
[¤P]/[O3] [¤P] × 10 M
3
15
[¤P]/[O3] [¤P] × 10 M
3
20
[¤P]/[O3] [¤P] × 10 M
3
25
[¤P]/[O3] [¤P] × 10 M
3
[Co2+]= 1 [Co2+]= 2 [Co2+]= 3 [Co2+]= 4 [Co2+]= 5 × 103 M × 103 M × 103 M × 103 M × 103 M
Time (min)
30
[¤P]/[O3]
Table 1.15 Rate constants of the ozone reaction with some transition metal ions Reagent
[Me+n] (mM)
k (M/s-1)
Co2+
1
500
2+
1
1500
0.5
64
6.52 × 103
0.032
Mn
3+
Cr
Cumene
53
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
15
4.5 mM 12
[DMPC].10 2, M
3.6 mM 9
2.7 mM
6
1.8 mM 0.9 mM
3
0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
T ime, min
0.16
3.6 mM
0.14
2.7 mM
[CHP].102, M
0.12 0.10 1.8 mM
0.08
0.9 mM
0.06 0.04 0.02 0.00 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Time, min
Figure 1.17 Kinetics of DMPC and CHP formation on [Co(AcO)2], 20 oC
Upon ozonolysis of cumene in AcAc the value of WO3 is 2 × 10-6 M/s-1 and upon addition of Co(AcO)2 in concentrations 0.9, 1.8, 2.7 and 4.5 × 10-3 its value is 0.6, 1.1, 1.7 and 2.9 M/s-1, respectively. This clearly shows that ozone reacts first of all with the Co2+ ions. In conformity with the obtained data we have proposed the following scheme of ozonolysis:
54
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons Mn+L + O3 m Mn+1L(O3 )
(0)
Mn+1L(O3 ) + RH m Rv + Mn+1L (ÎH) + O2
(1)
Mn+1L(OH) + RH m Mn+L + Rv + H2O
(1a)
Rv + O2 m RO2v
(2a)
RO2v + RH m ROOH + Rv
(2)
Rv + O3 m ROv + O2
(3)
m (A) 2 ROv + O2 RO2v + RO2v|
(6)
m (1 - A) ROOR + O2 ROv + RH m ROH + Rv
(4)
Scheme 1.6 Applying the quasisteady state approximation approach in relation to WDMPC we obtained: WDMPC = 2.[A/(1-A)].k0 .[Men+L].[O3].[RH]
(1.47)
Equation 1.47 has been derived without considering reactions (2) and (3) because of their insignificant contribution. It follows from Equation 1.47 that WDMPC is proportional to the concentration of the catalyst applied. By applying values from the literature of k2 and k6 to cumene oxidation [14, 103-105] and [RO2]st as determined from Figure 1.17 the value A is found to be 0.63 which is in good agreement with that reported by other authors [14]. From the analysis of Figure 1.18 and Table 1.15 and considering the concentrations of ozone, the same value of A is obtained. The good correlation of the kinetic results with the proposed Scheme 1.6 testifies to its validity. The addition of cobalt and manganese acetates to the reaction mixture changes the general features of the product formation kinetics (Figure 1.19). Thus WO3 increases and ACP has been identified. The sum of the products exceeds by 7.3 fold that during
55
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds cumene ozonolysis. Ozonides are obtained upon the interaction of ozone with the benzene ring, and ACP is produced by the monomolecular decomposition reaction of ROv radicals. The main role of manganese is most likely in accelerating these two reactions. The catalytic properties of the studied metal salts are confirmed by the ratio of the amount of the products formed in the catalysed and noncatalysed processes per unit of absorbed ozone. At Co:Mn = 5:1 this ratio becomes equal to 7.3 and it is greater by about 6% than that in the absence of manganese. The cumene conversion is increased but the selectivity of the process is reduced. The contribution of ozonides and ACP to the total sum of the formed products is 27%. The synergism of the simultaneous action of both salts (Figure 1.19) can be associated with the occurrence of the following reaction: Mn3+(AcO)2(O3-) + Co(AcO)2 = Co3+(AcO)2(O3-) + Mn(AcO)2
12 10
W DMPC .105 [M.s -1]
8 6 4 2 0
0
1
2
3
4
5
Co( A cO) 2.103 [ M]
Figure 1.18 Dependence of WDMPC on [Co(AcO)2] concentration
Nenchev and Shopov [108] stated that increasing the Mn concentration the catalytic effect should decrease mainly on the account of its noneffective interaction with the oxy-radicals. The data in Figure 1.19, however, show that such a trend is not observed as the variations in the concentrations of DMPC, CHP and ACP are insignificant. The curves, profiles are explained by the oxy-reduction interactions of the catalysts and by the radical intermediates.
56
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
4
DMPC
[P].10 2, M (25min)
3
2
O zonides CH P
1
0
AP 0
20
40
60
80
100
[ Co] / [ Mn] , mol.%
Figure 1.19 Reaction product formation depends on the ratio Co/Mn
1.4.2 Ozonolysis in the presence of NiO The ozonolysis of cumene in the presence of heterogeneous additives, which are effective in ozone decomposition [14] is of interest from two points of view: (1) for elaboration of the mechanism of ozone interaction with the heterogeneous surface, and (2) for increasing the oxidation selectivity. Upon passing ozone (0.1 l/min) through powder NiO (33 m2/g) depending on the oxide concentration either partial or complete ozone decomposition is observed (Figure 1.20). The ozone concentration becomes zero at NiO amount of 140 mg. A badly resolved singlet is registered in the ESR spectrum, however, this disappears in the course of the reaction. This signal was assigned to O3- anion radicals. The UV spectra have a maximum at 320 nm which is attributed to the electron transfers in Ni2. The intensity of the latter goes down in the process of ozone decomposition (the grey colour of the fresh NiO turns black during the reaction process). We have estimated that the catalytic coefficient, i.e., the number of decomposed ozone molecules per one NiO molecule is about 20. By special experiments it has been established that on one Ni2+ ion consequently about 133 ozone molecules of the gas phase are absorbed, but the probability of Ni2+ being transformed to Ni3+ ion is 1/7, i.e., only one out of seven ions is oxidised. These results indicate that the reaction of ozone with Ni2+ proceeds probably in two ways:
57
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds NiO + 2O3 m NiO + 3 O2 + Q NiO + O3 m ONi3+O3
4
1.0
3 2
0.8
ΔD:D 0
1 1 - 0.85 mM 2 - 0.44 mM 3 - 0.26 mM 4 - 0.08 mM
0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
Catalyst, mg
Figure 1.20 Dependence of the ozone decomposed quantity $D/Dot on the NiO amount. $D = Do–Dt; Do - ozone concentration at the reactor inlet at flow rate of 6 l/h with the formation of surface compounds of ONiO3+O3- type. They can react further with a new ozone molecule from a neighbouring centre, with NiO or with the oxides: ONi3+O3 +O3 m NiO2 + 2.5O2 ONi3+O3 + ONi3+O3 m Ni2O3 + 2O2 ONi3+O3 + NiO m Ni2O3 + O2 NiO2 + NiO m Ni2O3 If a hydrocarbon is added to this system, oxidation with participation of ONiO3+O3might be expected. For this purpose the cumene ozonolysis was carried out in the presence of NiO. Figure 1.21 illustrates that ozonides, DMPC and CHP are the main products of the cumene ozonolysis in the presence of NiO.
58
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons It can be seen that the rate of ozonide formation is the highest one and does not depend on [NiO] while the rates of DMPC and CHP formation are relatively lower and increase with [NiO]. As we have mentioned before the ozonides are obtained by the ozone interaction with C=C bonds in the benzene ring, and the ozonolysis of the hydrocarbon takes place via a H-atom abstraction mechanism. Our explanation of these experimental facts is related to the absence of ozonide formation on the surface and to the dominating homogeneous reactions as well as to heterogeneous reactions upon ozonolysis of the alkyl part. The latter is related to the ozone activation on the NiO surface via the formation of the surface compound Ni3+O3- which according to the scheme: Ni3+O3 m Ni3+ + O3 O3 + RH m Rv + HO + O2 Ni3+ + RH m Rv + Ni3+ + H+ oxidises the alkyl part of cumene. The contribution of these reactions to the formation of the reaction products is, however, small as the total rate of product formation is only from 5 to 17% higher compared with the rate of ozone consumption.
6
1, 2, 3
[P].10 3, M
5 4
3'
3
2'
2
1'
1
3" 2" 1"
0 0
5
10
15
20
25
T ime, min
Figure 1.21 Kinetics of product formation in the ozone reaction with cumene in the presence of NiO 20 oC. 1, 2, 3 - OZ; 1a, 2a, 3a - DMPC; 1aa, 2aa, 3aa - CHP; 1 0.05, 2 - 0.325, 3 - 0.635 wt% NiO
59
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
1.4.3 Ozonolysis in the presence of Mo and V oxides We studied ozonolysis of cumene catalysed by Mo-V catalysts. The reactions were performed at ambient temperature in a glass reactor with a centrifugal pump with 33 ml cumene in the presence of 0.35 wt% mixtures of MoO2 and V2O5 on SiO2 (Figure 1.22) at various ozone concentrations. The catalysts shown in Table 1.16 were prepared by soaking of SiO2 in water solutions of ammonium para-molybdate and ammonium vanadate and subsequent treatment at 400 oC.
3
2
1
Figure 1.22 Reactor for kinetic studies; 1 - magnetic stirrer; 2 - reactor; 3 - cooler; 4 - centrifugal pump with rotation speed 100-1100 rpm
Figure 1.23a-c illustrates the kinetic curves of major product formation - CHP, DMPC and ozonides. The rate of CHP formation for sample no.5 with Mo:V = 1:1 ratio amounts to 1.6 x 10-5 M/s–1. The values of WCHP for samples nos.7 and 8 are close to that value. In case of sample no. 1 the initial rate of CHP formation is 0.4 x 10-5
60
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons M/s–1 and it is the same as that for the noncatalysed reaction (curve K). The untreated SiO2 (sample no.8) also has some catalytic properties. The integral areas below (under) the kinetic curves, corresponding to the amount of the product formed vary in the presence and in the absence of the catalyst. For example, the area below the kinetic curve of CHP formation in the catalysed reaction is greater compared with that of the noncatalysed one. The stationary concentration of CHP depends on the type of the catalyst and in relation to its catalytic activity the sample shows the following order 5>8>7>1>K. Curve K is characterised by a S-shape form wherein three periods are distinguished: (1) the start of the product accumulation, (2) stationary regime in relation to the product, and (3) autocatalytic process of product formation (Figure 1.23a).
Table 1.16 Catalysts sample with total amount of oxides 10% No.
MoO2:V2O5
S (m2/g)
1.
0:1
13
2.
1:99
10
3.
1:9
11
4.
1:3
5
5.
1:1
4
6.
9:1
5
7.
1:0
10
8.
0:0
14
Upon DMPC formation (Figure 1.23b) one can also notice some difference in the course of the kinetic curves in the presence (curves 1, 5, 7 and 8) and in the absence (curve K) of the catalyst. It has been found that the rate of DMPC formation is one and the same for all studied samples and it is 4.2 x 10-6 M.s–1. After 10 minutes curve K becomes constant and after 15 minutes it rises again, i.e., its profile is typical of an autocatalytic process. The curves of DMPC formation in the presence of catalyst (1, 5, 7 and 8) are characterised by two sections - an initial one with a bigger slope and a second one with a smaller slope - and the transition point is in the interval 5-10 minutes. Obviously, WDMPC is slowed down in the advanced reaction because of the occurrence of secondary reactions associated with the DMPC depletion or are due to the catalyst deactivation. With respect to their activity the samples have the following sequence: 5>1>7>8>K.
61
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
8
5
A
7
8
(CHP].10 3, M
6 5
7
4
1
3
K
2 1 0 -1 0
5
10
15
20
25
T ime, min
5 4
1 7
B
8
[DMPC].10 3, M
3
2
K 1
0 0
5
10
15
20
25
T ime, min 10
K
C
8
1
7
,3M
6
8
[OZ].10
4
5 2
0 0
5
10
15
20
25
T ime, min
Figure 1.23 (a-c) Kinetic curves of product formation during the catalysed cumene ozonolysis. (a) CHP, (b) DMPC, (c) ozonides; 1, 5, 7 and 8 are the number of catalysts according to Table 1.16; K - in the absence of catalyst, WO3 = 1 x 10-5 M/s–1 62
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons The kinetics of ozonide formation is entirely different from that discussed before (Figure 1.23c). The initial section of the curves is characterised by the appearance of an induction period up to 15 minutes. These results unambiguously point out that the catalyst directs selectively the process to the oxidation of the isopropyl substituent in the cumene molecule and only after the accumulation of a definite amount of product, which probably block the catalytic surface, the ozone attacks the benzene ring. In this case the order of activity of the samples is just opposite to that of CHP formation, i.e., 5<8<7<1
20 min
7
CHP
[P].10 3, M
6 5 4 3
DMPC
2 1
OZ
0
20
40
60
80
100
Mn, %
Figure 1.24 Kinetic curves of product formation depending on the Mo:V ratio
The catalytic effect of the studied samples is also demonstrated by the increase of the initial rate of oxidation that results in a rise of CHP yield. This increase in time can be represented by the following equation: [CHP] = a.t2 + b.Wi1/2.t
(1.48)
63
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds For example, the CHP amount formed in the presence of catalyst is 2.4-fold higher compared with that of the noncatalysed process. The selectivity of the studied catalysts consists in directing the process to oxidation of the isopropyl substituent in the cumene molecule.
1.4.4 Cumenehydroperoxide In order to assess the effect of secondary reactions occurring during cumene ozonolysis we investigated its reaction in the presence of CHP. The dependence of WO3 and [O3] is studied by means of stopped-flow techniques at mixing time of 0.5 seconds.
3.5
Ozone
3.0
CHP
W 03.105, M.s -1
2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
Conc., mM
Figure 1.25 Dependence of the rate of ozone absorption on [O3] ([CHP] = 2.5 M) and [CHP] ([O3] = 0.68 mM), 20 oC, CCl4
As is seen the rate depends linearly on the concentration of both reagents, thus, showing first-order kinetics with respect to each one of them. The rate constant k was determined from the slope and it amounts to 14.5 p 0.2 M/s–1. The main reaction products were found to be DMPC and ozonides, while ACP was obtained in much smaller amounts (Figure 1.26).
64
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
Figure 1.26 Kinetics of product formation during ozonolysis of CHP in CCl4, [O3] = 0.36 mM
Ozone reacts simultaneously with both the alkyl and phenyl moiety in the CHP molecule yielding DMPC, ACP and ozonides. In the first case the attack on the OOH group is kinetically much more beneficial resulting in the formation of cumene peroxide and hydroxyperoxide radicals. These radicals according to the classical concepts of oxidation, further undergo transformations giving rise to DMPC and ACP. Upon attacking the phenyl ring, ozone is incorporated into the double bond forming mono-, di- and triozonides. The formation of mono-ozonide is the limiting step as at that moment the aromatic character of the ring is destroyed, while the ozone interactions with dienes and olefins occur with high rates and low activation energies [1, 25]. In view of this we have assumed the existence of the following mechanism shown in Scheme 1.7 for this reaction: ROOH + O3 m A (OZ) + B (RO2v + HOv + O2) +G (ROv + HO2v)
(1)
RO2v + RO2v m 2D (ROv) + (1-D) (ROOR)
(6)
ROv + ROOH m DMPC + RO2v
(4)
ROv m ACP + CH3v
(5)
Scheme 1.7
65
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds On the basis of the Scheme 1.7 and the available value of k for reactions (4) and (5) the theoretical ratio WDMPC:WACP is 25 ÷ 30:1. The experimentally observed value is 25:1 which is in a very good fit to the theoretical one. Another interesting ratio has been obtained for WDMPC:WOZ = 2.5:1 (Figure 1.16) and the values of A = 0.4 and (B + G) = 0.6 have been found. The good correlation between the theoretical and experimental values of the WDMPC:WACP ratio suggests that G<<1, i.e., the free radical formation is insignificant. The rate constant of the ozone reaction with DMPC at ambient temperature has been determined in a separate kinetic experiment and k = 3.4 ± 0.1 M-1.s–1. At this value of k the rate of end-product formation becomes commensurable at [CHP]:[DMPC] = 1:4.3. The linear profile of the kinetic curves of DMPC, ozonide and ACP formation depends on the time interval and the absence of induction periods can be regarded as kinetic evidence for the independent formation of the products in parallel reactions (Figure 1.26). Upon ozonolysis of cumene, 1 mol of absorbed ozone yields 1 mol of products, hence the reaction is not a chain one. The main products in the acetic acid medium (Figure 1.27) are ozonides, DMPC and ACP. The curve of CHP consumption is found to decrease exponentially (it becomes a straight line in semilogarithmic coordinates), the curve of ozonide formation passes through a maximum, DMPC is being accumulated linearly with the time and that of ACP formation is strongly accelerated after 50 minutes. The ratio of the initial rates of DMPC:ACP and DMPC:OZ formation are 1:1 and 1:5, respectively. Phenol (PhOH) which has been identified in the oxidate could be obtained from the wellknown heterogeneous decomposition of CHP in acidic medium giving rise to phenol and acetone (Scheme 1.8).
100
CH P
80
A cP
[P], mM
60
40
DMPC
OZ 20
0 -20
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
T ime, min
Figure 1.27 Kinetics of product formation during CHP ozonolysis in AcAc, [O3] = 0.8 mM
66
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons Ph C(Me)2 OOH + H+ Ph C(Me)2 O +OH2 Ph C(Me)2 O +OH2 m Ph C(Me)2 O+ + H2O Ph C(Me)2-O+ m Ph +O=C(Me)2 Ph +O=C(Me)2 + H2O m Ph O C(Me)2 +OH2 Ph O C(Me)2 +OH2 Ph O C(Me)2 OH + H+ Ph O C(Me)2 OH (H+) m PhOH + (Me)2C=O Scheme 1.8 The composition of products has been found to be different in ozonolysis in CHCl3 compared with that in pure cumene and in AcAc solution (Figure 1.28).
80
CH P
70 60
PhOH
50 [P], mM
40
OZ
30 20
DMPC
10
A cP 0 -20
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
T ime, min
Figure 1.28 Kinetics of product formation during CHP ozonolysis in CHCl3, [O3] = 0.8 mM
It has been established that the main products are again ozonides, DMPC and ACP but higher amounts of phenol are observed. In addition, the ozone reaction with CHCl3 yields inorganic chlorine-containing acids and the pH of the medium approaches values of 1-2. These acids (probably HCl and HOCl) are efficient catalysts for the
67
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds CHP decomposition into phenol. The ratios of the rates are WDMPC:WACP = 2.5:1 and WDMPC:WOZ = 1:14. The kinetic curve of ozonides formation is indicative of its formation in consecutive reactions. The rates of ACP and PhOH formation rise just at the moment of the fall in the kinetic curve of ozonide formation (Figures 1.27 and 1.28), thus suggesting the participation of ozonides in their formation. The dependence of the initial rate of DMPC, ozonides and ACP on WO3 during the cumene ozonolysis in CCl4 is presented in Figure 1.29. The values of A = 0.4, B = 0.6, G<<1 and D = 0.04 calculated from this figure are in a good agreement with those obtained from the analysis of Scheme 1.7 and Figure 1.26.
18
DMPC
16 14
W.10 6, M.s -1
12 10 8
OZ
6 4
A cP
2 0 -2 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
W O 3.105, M.s-1
Figure 1.29 Dependence of the initial rates of product formation (W) on the rate of ozone absorption (WO3) in CCl4, at 20 oC
1.5 Polyethylene and polypropylene We have extended our investigations on ozonation of the C-H bonds in polymer analogues of paraffins - polyethylene, polypropylene, their mixtures and polystyrene, with the aim of elucidating the effect of the polymer structure on this reaction.
68
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
dH/dt, mV
The ozonolysis of polyolefins leads to a change in the structural-physical and dynamic parameters of the polymer matrix such as: the degree of crystallinity (K); density of the amorphous phase; and orientation factor and segmental mobility of the macromolecules [109-110]. The variations of these parameters in polymer mixtures have been little studied. This provoked us to study the effect of the ozone reaction with orientated high-density polyethylene (PE), orientated isotactic polypropylene (PP) and their mixtures on the melting point of crystallites (TT), the relative melting heat, and thus on the degree of crystallinity and the size distribution in the crystallites of the two components. The polymer blends were prepared from noninhibited PP samples with average weight mass (Mw) of 2.86 x 105, average number mass (Mn) of 6.23 x 104 and the ratio between them (Mw/Mn) of 4.6 and for PE samples with the corresponding values of 4.15 x 104, 2.71 x 104 and 1.53. The isotropic films were prepared by pressing of granules at 190 oC and under pressure of 150 MPa on a cellophane support and tempered with water at 100 oC. The orientated films of 12 p 2 Mm thickness and stretching degree (L = 9) were obtained by local heating up to 100-110 oC K and 120-130 oC. The melting point and the degree of crystallinity were evaluated by means of the differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) method (Figure 1.30).
50
100
150
200
250
Temperature, K
Figure 1.30 DSC curves of the PE:PP = 90:10 blend at L = 9
The values of (K) for PP and PE were estimated using the following values of the relative heats of crystallite melting, i.e., 284.2 and 135.9 kJ/g, respectively. The polydispersity of the crystallites was characterised by the half width of its peak of
69
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds melting $h. The orientated samples were subjected to ozonolysis in a thermostated ozone chamber. The reaction kinetics were followed by monitoring the variations of the IR spectral intensity at N = 1715 cm–1, characteristic of C=O. The frequency at 1455 cm–1 which remains constant during the course of the experiment, was used as an internal reference. The dependences of the oxidation degree per unit thickness of the sample on the mixture composition at various oxidation times are presented in Figure 1.31.
0.24
46 h 0.20
24 h
D1715, (C=O)
0.16
0.12
10 h 0.08
4h
0.04
0
20
40
60
80
100
PP, %
Figure 1.31 Kinetics of C=O accumulation in orientated films from PE/PP mixtures with L = 9, [O3] = 1 mM
Two weak maxima are registered after 4 hours in the IR spectra of the samples containing 10 and 50% PP. Their appearance could be associated with the more porous structure leading to the better dissolving of ozone. This also suggests that the rate of oxidation should increase with increasing time of interaction. We will discuss further the changes of TT and K of PE and PP in the ozonised and fresh samples depending on the mixture composition. The relationship between TT of the crystallites in the initial samples from and those ozonised for 45 hours at ambient temperature are shown in Figure 1.32.
70
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
170
0h PP
160
46 h
TT, 0C
150
140
0h PE 130
46 h 0
20
40
60
80
100
PP, %
Figure 1.32 Variation of the melting points of PE and PP crystallites in mixtures
As is seen TT goes down for the PE and PP samples, irrespective of the composition and duration of treatment. For PE this decrease is 2-6 oC depending on the composition of the mixture and in the case of PP it is considerably higher - 12 oC for the initial PP and 24 oC for the 1:1 mixture. As for as the ozonised samples of 0-30% PP content, PP crystallites are not observed and for those with PP 40wt% their amount is within the limits of accuracy of the DSC method. The lower melting point of the crystallite films points to a reduced ordering of the crystal structure of PP and PE or to an increase in the relative free surface energy of the crystallites sides (Se) compared with those that were nonozonised. The disturbance of the crystallite ordering might be ascribed to the penetration of ozone. At PE ozonation the ozone penetration into the crystallites depth is much weaker since TT in the ozonised and nonozonised samples is similar (Figure 1.32) or it reacts only with the folded surface of the crystallites [115, 116]. The data in [117] support the latter supposition for it has been found that the treatment by 100% nitric acid of the orientated PE samples of stretching degree L = 10 leads to 5-8 oC reduction of TT of the crystallites. This decrease is related to the increase of Se of the crystallite walls as a result of this treatment. A similar decrease of TT (2-6 oC) has also been established upon ozonation of orientated PE with L = 9 (Figure 1.32) which gives us grounds to assume that similar to nitric acid, ozone also reduces TT on account of Se rise.
71
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The ozone ability to penetrate through the PP crystallites is accelerated with the decrease of its content from 90 to 50% in the mixtures (Figure 1.32). The notable decrease of the melting point (12-24 oC) upon PP ozonolysis could not be explained by the increase in Se of the crystallites as they simply disappear. More probably the amorphisation is connected to the destruction of crystallites as a result of the ozone action. Actually, in the DSC curves of the ozonised mixtures with 0-40% PP content crystallites are not observed, while in the IR spectra the amount of the CH3 groups is not altered. Ozone reacts with the tertiary hydrogen bond in the amorphous and crystal part. The former leads to an increase in the number of defects which facilitates the subsequent ozone access. Thus the crystallites are destroyed and become further amorphised. The melting point appears to be a very sensitive parameter in investigating the behaviour of the ozonised samples. In Figures 1.31 and 1.32, an antibatic dependence is observed between the curves illustrating the dependence of the oxidation level on composition and TT of the crystallites in blends with various PE content. The periods of acceleration, retardation and maximum occurrence correspond to decrease, increase and minimum appearance depending on TT of the PE crystallites in the mixture composition. Figure 1.33 demonstrates the effect of composition of mixtures on the degree of crystallinity (K).
PP, 0 h
80
PP, 46 h
, %
60
40
PE, 0 h 20
PE, 46 h 0 0
20
40
60
80
100
PP, %
Figure 1.33 Dependence of degree of crystallinity on the composition of the polymer blends
72
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons First we have to note the decrease for the values of K for PE and PP with the decrease of their content in the mixture both for the nonozonised and the ozonised samples. However, in the case of the nonozonised samples the profile of K is characterised by a range wherein it is constant. The value of K for PE in mixtures with PE content varying from 0 to 50% amounts to 60% and in those with a PP content of 50-70% it is 64%. The observation of the decrease in degree of crystallinity of the components in the system PE/PP is also confirmed by other authors [117]. In the case of PE the values of K for the ozonised samples are found to be higher than those for the nonozonised samples. An exception are the samples containing 10 and 20% PE for which K drops abruptly. The increase, could probably be explained by the fact that ozone does not penetrate into the PE crystallites but rather reacts with PE in the transition zone on their surface. This reaction leads to breakdown of the macromolecules in the transition zone and thus the degree of crystallinity is enhanced on account of the fragment provided by the cut-off molecules in the transition zone. The authors of reference [118] have also observed a similar increase of K for PE during its ozonation. These changes of K are also demonstrated by the curves in Figure 1.33. It has been found that the values of K in the PP crystallites of ozonised samples are always higher compared with those in the nonozonised samples (Figure 1.33). This observation could be related to the fact that ozone penetrates into the crystallites and reacts further with tert-C-H bonds. Thus they are gradually crushed and transformed in an amorphous state. This phenomenon is characterised by a decrease of TT and K in the ozonised samples whereby the initial content of PP decreases to lower than 30% and the crystal structure is completely destroyed. It is well known that the polydispersity of crystallites can be characterised by the half width of the melting peaks observed by the DSC method. The changes of this parameter for the two components are illustrated in Figure 1.34. For PE, $h in the ozonised samples is higher than that of the nonozonised samples in the whole range of the mixture compositions with the exception of pure PE and the mixture with 1:9 content. The comparison of the relationship between $h and K allows us to assume that the increase in polydispersity of the PE crystallites can be explained by physical reasons determined by the mixture composition. Thus, in mixtures with a high PE content ranging from 30 to 100% a simultaneous increase of $h and K is observed. The polydispersity of the crystallites results from the rebuilding of the destroyed parts of the macromolecules from the transition zones. In mixtures with lower PE content, below 30%, the rise of polydispersity is accompanied by a drop in the degree of crystallinity.
73
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
15
PP, 0 h
14
PP, 46 h
13
Δh
12
PE, 46 h
11 10
PE, 0 h
9 8 0
20
40
60
80
100
PP, %
Figure 1.34 Dependence of the half width of melting peaks on the mixture composition It has been found that the polydispersity of PP crystallites monotonously decreases with the decrease of PP content in the mixtures (Figure 1.34). In each case both the polydispersity and K in the ozonised samples are always lower than those in the nonozonised samples in the whole range of mixture compositions. Apparently, the decrease in PP polydispersity is associated with its initial reaction with the smallest crystallites. Upon more prolonged ozonation of PE and PP their amorphous phases become considerably altered as a result of the accumulation of oxygen-containing compounds of various molecular mass which can also destroy them.
1.6 Polystyrene When ozone is passed through a polystyrene (PS) solution in CCl4 the ozone is absorbed [58]. The rate constant at ambient temperature k has been determined according to Equation 1.14 and it is 0.37 M–1 s–1. The rate of ozone absorption (WO3) remains constant up to an uptake of 3.2 moles ozone per monomer unit. Further, at a consumption of 4.5 moles ozone it becomes 10 times lower. WO3 does not depend on the ozone flow rate in it but increases linearly with the increase of ozone and PS concentration (Table 1.17).
74
4.2
0.31
W x 107 (M.s-1)
k (M–1 s–1)
0.01
0.75
4
0.6
[O3] x 10 (M)
[PS] (M)
v x 103 (l/s)
0.23
8.4
0.75
0.027
0.8
0.45
34
0.81
0.054
0.8
0.27
1.2
0.09
0.027
1.0
0.35
3.9
0.23
0.027
1.0
0.32
11.6
0.75
0.027
1.0
0.47
39
1.7
0.027
1.0
0.25
35.2
2.9
0.027
1.0
0.38
131
7.1
0.027
1.0
0.40
35
0.72
0.068
1.4
0.48
80
0.78
0.12
2.1
0.33
30.4
0.71
0.072
2.8
Table 1.17 Dependence of the rate constant on ozone and PS concentrations and on the ozone flow rate (v) at 25 oC
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
75
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The IR spectra of the ozonised samples (Table 1.18) show that the content of tertCH2 groups hardly changes during ozonolysis as the intensity of the bands at 700 and 2930 cm–1 does not change practically. On the other hand, the intensity at 1500 cm-1, which is assigned to aromatic ring vibrations, decreases in the course of the reaction. This fact confirms that the ozone interaction with the benzene ring gives rise to ozonides. The latter compounds have been identified by the occurrence of C-O vibrations in the range of 1100-1200 cm-1, as well as by the iodometric titration of the oxidates. It is known that the stoichiometry of the ozone reaction with benzene is 1:3. The kinetic curves represented in Figure 1.35 demonstrate the linear kinetics of ozonide formation. The rate of the ozonide formation at 25 °C has a magnitude of 0.29 p 0.01 M-1.s-1. This value correlates well with the rate constant of benzene ring consumption for cumene which is 0.28 p 0.02 M-1.s-1.
Table 1.18 The intensity of the IR absorption bands of the products of PS ozonolysis: [PS] = 27.4 mM; [O3] = 0.88 mM; at ambient temperature Time (min)
700 cm-1 (%)
1500 cm-1 (%)
2930 cm-1 (%)
-log(It/I0) at 1500 cm-1
0
36.1
23.0
36.0
0
10
35.4
21.2
35.8
0.035
15
36.0
20.1
35.9
0.059
25
34.5
19.3
35.1
0.076
30
34.9
18.0
35.8
0.106
The kinetics of hydroperoxide accumulation is illustrated by the curves in Figure 1.36; their profile suggests the intermediate character of the hydroperoxides formed in this reaction. It is seen that at the initial stage of the reaction [ROOH] increases and WROOH depends linearly on [O3] (Figure 1.36, curve 2). The ROOH content at 40% conversion is about 6% irrespective of [PS] which is within the range 0.1-1.2%.
76
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
1.0
a 0.8
[OZ], mM
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Time, min 5
b 4
Woz.106, M.s-1
3
2
1
0 0
1
2
3
4
[O3]g.104, M 0.12
c
0.10
-1 lg(I/I0)1500 cm
0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0.00 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Time, min
Figure 1.35 Kinetics of ozonide formation (a) at 25 oC, [PS] = 24.7 mM, [O3] -5 g = 1.2 x 10 M; (b) dependence of the rate of ozonide formation on ozone concentration at the reactor outlet, 25 oC, [PS] = 27.4 mM; (c) variation of the band intensity at 1500 cm-1, 25 oC, [PS] = 27.4 mM, [O3]g = 8.8 x 10-4 M 77
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 1.6
a
1.4
[ROOH], mM
1.2 1.0 0.8
1
0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
-0.2 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Time, min b
30
2
WROOH.108, M.s-1
25 20 15 10 5 0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
[O3]g.104, M
Figure 1.36 (a) Kinetics of ROOH formation (1), at 25 oC, [PS]0 = 60 mM, [O3]g = 1.4 x 10-4 M; and (b) dependence of the initial rate of ROOH formation on the ozone concentration at the reactor outlet (2), 25 oC, [PS]o = 27.4 mM
The kinetic curves of the variation of PS molecular weight at [PS] = 1.5% pass through a maximum (Figure 1.37, curve 1). It has been established that carbonyloxides take part in crosslinking processes [1]. For this reason we have studied the PS degradation in solutions with concentrations below 1.5%. Upon ozonolysis of diluted PS solutions with concentrations below 0.5% we have observed a decrease of the average molecular weight (Figure 1.37, curve 2). The rate of degradation is constant up to a conversion degree of 30% (Equation 1.49): Wd = (1/M -1/M0).t-1.[PS]0-1
(1.49)
It is linearly dependent on the ozone uptake rate and on temperature (Figure 1.38).
78
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
1
1.4 1.2
Mn.10-5
1.0 0.8 2
0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Time, min
Figure 1.37 Kinetics of PS molecular weight variation with average number molecular mass 1.2 x 105 upon ozonolysis (1) [PS] = 3.5%, (2) [PS] = 0.3%, WO3 = 2 x 10-4 mol/(kg.s), at 25 oC
6 3
Wd.106, brakings/(kg.s)
5 2 4 3 2 1
1 0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
Rate.104, mol/(kg.s)
Figure 1.38 Dependence of the rate of PS degradation on the rate of ozone consumption: 1 - 0 oC; 2 - 25 oC; 3 - 60 oC, [PS] <1%
79
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The number of chain breaks in diluted solutions related to 1 mol absorbed ozone n = Wd/Wi does not depend on the polymer concentration but it rises with temperature (Table 1.19). Under these conditions the reactions, leading to an increase in the molecular mass do not exhibit any essential influence. This is also confirmed by the profiles of the molecular mass distribution (MMD) of low and high molecular weight components (Figure 1.39). The decrease of the molecular mass and the rise of the number of broken chains (n) is accompanied by narrowing of the MMD (Figure 1.39a) and the ratio Mw/Mn approaches a value equal to 1 (Figure 1.39b).
100
3
4
2 1
7
80
W (M), %
5
6
60
a
40
20
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
M.w.104 0.7
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.5
0.4
0.4
0.3
0.3
- lg [M w/ M n-1]
Mw/Mn-1
b 0.6
0.2
0.2 0.0
0.2
0.4 2
0.6
0.8
1.0
n.10 , brakings/mol
Figure 1.39 (a) Integral curves of MMD at 25 oC, WO3 = 6.6 x 10-5 mol/(kg.s), [PS] = 1% and ozonation time of: 1 - 0 min, 2 - 15 min, 3 - 30 min, 4 - 45 min, 5 - 60 min, 6 - 90 min and 7 - 120 min; (b) MMD in the course of ozonation
80
0.4
0.47
n x 102
nav x 102
W x 10
2.2
0.88
Wd x 106
p 0.07
0.54
3.1
1.6
0.7
1.5
[PS] (%)
4
0
0
2.8
1.2
3.4
0.19
25
1.8
1.9
2.0
3.8
0.30
25
p 0.6
2.3
2.2
5.0
0.42
25
1.2
1.2
1.4
0.71
25
1.7
3.4
5.8
1.5
25
0.9 p 0.8
0.8
1.7
1.4
6.5
25
0.2
2.1
0.4
10.4
25
6.2
6.0
1.0
6.0
1.5
60
6.4
1.2
7.7
0.7
60
p 0.2
Table 1.19 Dependence of the rate of PS degradation on the solution composition and temperature (t)
t ( C)
o
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons
81
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds It has been established by means of ESR that the ozonolysis of PS in the solid phase generates peroxide radicals [126] which arise not in the direct ozone reaction with PS but are also secondary products. The kinetic scheme of the reaction, proposed by us, is based on the experimentally obtained data and it can be represented as shown in Scheme 1.9: (-CH2-(Ph)CH-)m + O3 m AP1 + (1-A)(P2 + P3 + …)
(1)
P1 + O3 m RO2v
(2)
(-CH2-(Ph)CH-)m + RO2v + O2 m ROOH + RO2v
(3)
RO2v + RO2v m B(2ROv) (6a)+ (1-B) ROOH + O2,
(6a)
where: P1, P2 and P3 are intermediate products Scheme 1.9 The reactions describing the ozonides formation and the ozone interaction with ROOH are included in Scheme 1.9: (-R-)mPh + O3 m monoozonide (slow) monoozonide + O3 m diozonide
diozonide + O3 m triozonide
(4)
m GROH + 2O2
(5a)
ROOH + O3 }| m (1-G) (RO2v + HOv + O2v)
(5aa)
The linear dependence of the rate of ozone absorption on its concentration as well as the stoichiometric coefficient of the reaction in the range of 4.2-4.5 can be regarded as evidence for the absence of ozone absorption in a chain reaction. According to Scheme 1.9 the reaction of ozone consumption will be represented as: W = (k1 + 3k4)[PS][O3] + k2[P1][O3]
(1.50)
[P1] = A.[PS]0.k1.(k2 –k1)-1.{exp [-k1[O3].t – exp[–k2[O3].t}
(1.51)
and
82
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons It is apparent that reaction (2) has an insignificant effect in regard to the total balance of ozone consumption as only 6% of ROOH is obtained upon the absorption of 1 mol ozone. The value of the observed rate constant kobs is equal to k1 + k4 and then k1 = 0.13 M-1.s-1. The insignificant amounts of ROOH indicate that actually the oxidation of tert-H bonds does not take place via a chain reaction. During the initial stage of ozonation [P1] = A × k1 × [PS]o[O3] × t, as [RO2] ^O3 and WROOH = k3[RO2] × [PS] ^O3. This is also observed experimentally (Figure 1.36b, 2). The results suggest that the RO2 radical formation in PS is not dependent on the phase state of the occurring reaction. The recombination of RO2 radicals according to reaction (6a) gives rise to RO radicals. The macromolecule destruction takes place via a monomolecular decomposition of RO radicals: ROv m rv+ (Ra)2C=O (degradation)
(7)
In the case where the degradation process takes place via reaction (7), then W d ^W O3 . In order to elucidate the mechanism of the degradation process we carried out an initiated oxidation of PS {[AIBN] = 2%, 60 o C, Wi = 1 x 10 -5 mol/(kg.s)}, where AIBN is azoisobutyronitrile. For the inhibited oxidation W d has been found to be 9 x 10 -7 breakdowns/(kg.s) and upon ozonation a similar value for Wd has been obtained at WO3 = 1.5 x 10-5 mol/ (kg.s) (Figure 1.38, 3). If we assume that the initiated oxidation and the ozonolysis differ only in the pathway of RO2 radical generation, then the mechanism of destruction and the kinetic correlation should be similar. The experimental obtained for values the ratio of Wi/WO3 accounting for the occurrence of radical steps in the ozonolysis are: 0.05 at 0 oC, 0.2 at 25 oC and 0.69 at 60 oC (Figure 1.38). The activation energy of degradation Ea calculated on the basis of Figure 1.38 amounts to 7.6 kcal/mol and correlates well with the activation energy of radical isomerisation, Ea [120]. The ratio Wi/W could be estimated using the values of k1 and k4 and the quasistationary approximation conditions in respect to P1: Wi/W = 0.43AB
(1.52)
From the experimentally measured ratio Wi/W = 0.2 at 25 oC it follows that AB = 0.47. Because of the lack of any data for the magnitude of B for PS we have used the known value of B for cumene oxidation (low molecular weight analogue of PS) that is 0.86 and then we have obtained 0.55 for A. The latter value demonstrates that the major part of RO radicals have been generated not via reaction (6aa) but as a result of the direct ozone attack on the PS macromolecule. Thus it can be reasonably expected that the degradation will occur via C=C bonds scission, for which [1, 25] the rate of their reaction with ozone is known, i.e., 105 83
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds M–1s-1 and similar to polydienes they would be responsible for the PS degradation. However the amount of C=C bonds in PS is of the order of (3 p 0.5) × 10-2 mol/kg and at average number mass of PS - 10-4 mol/(kg.s) - which means that one macromolecule contains 1-2 double bonds. Upon statistical distribution of C=C bonds along the macromolecule length, the degradation at WO3^10-4 mol/(kg.s) should finish in 5-10 minutes. However we failed to observe a marked decrease of the molecular weight within this time interval. Further, Wd should begin to go down. Actually the rate of degradation remains constant even after 150 minutes when the conversion is already 30%. Apparently, the C=C bonds in PS are not effective in this respect, mainly because they are terminal double bonds. This supposition has been confirmed by measuring the concentration of C=C bonds which decreases during ozonation with the simultaneous rise of PS molecular mass. If we take into account that the degradation proceeds via a random law then the equilibrium width of MMD should approach value of 2 only after 2-3 breakdowns. However this is in contrast to the experimentally obtained data illustrated in Figure 1.39b. It is seen that MMD depends on the conversion degree and approaches 1. This effect could be explained by the variation of the ratio of the values of the elementary constants which characterise the scission of C-C bonds in the macromolecule. A decrease of Wd has been registered during the transition to lower molecular polymers as is the case with fractionated PS and with polymers with broad MMD. This might be the explanation for the decrease of the effective Wd upon ozonolysis and the narrowing of the MMD. The mechanism of alkane ozonolysis will be discussed further from the quantum chemical point of view in Chapter 5.
References 1. S.D. Razumovskii, S.K. Rakovski, D.M. Shopov and G.E. Zaikov, Ozone and Its Reactions with Organic Compounds, Publishing House of Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, Bulgaria, 1983. [in Russian]. 2. N.A. Klejmanov, A.B. Nalbandjan, Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR, 1958, 122, 103. 3. C. C. Schubert and R.N. Pease, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1956, 78, 2044. 4. C.C. Schubert and R.N. Pease, Journal of Chemical Physics, 1956, 24, 919. 5. F.J Dillemuth, D.R. Skidmore and C.C. Schubert, Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1960, 64, 1496. 84
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons 6. R.J. Morrissey and C.C. Schubert, Combustion and Flame, 1963, 7, 1, 263. 7. V.J. Dardin and L.N. Albright, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry: Process Design and Development, 1965, 4, 61. 8. T.H. Grewer in Low Temperature Oxidation, Ed., W. Jost, Institute für Physikalische Chemie, Göttingen University, Germany, 1964, p.186. 9. G. A. Hamilton, B.S. Ribner and T.M. Hellman in Oxidation of Organic Compounds, Advances in Chemistry Series, No.77, ACS, Washington, DC, USA, 1969, p.15. 10. V. Ya. Shljapintoh, A.A. Kefeli, V.I. Gol’denberg and S.D. Razumovskii, Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR, 1969, 168, 1132. 11. S.D. Razumovskii, A.A. Kefeli and G.E. Zaikov, Zhurnal Organicheskoi Khimii, 1971, 7, 2045. 12. J. R. Durland and H. Adkins, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1939, 61, 429. 13. G. Geiseler, F. Asinger and H. Wien, Chemische Berichte, 1959, 92, 958. 14. N.M. Emanuel, E.T. Denisov and Z.K. Majzus, Hydrocarbon Chain Oxidation Reactions in Liquid Phase, Nauka Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1965, p.202. 15. M.C. Whiting, A.J.N. Bolt and J.H. Parish in the Proceedings of the International Symposium on Oxidation, San Francisco, CA, USA, 1967, 2, p.267. 16. N. Tjutjunnikov, A.I. Ljashenko, A.M. Shiman, I.S. Suhoterin, G.I. Moskwina, A.S. Drozdov and G.F. Sanchenko, Khimicheskaya Promyshlennost, 1971, 653. 17. D.G. Williamson and R.J. Cvetanovic, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1970, 92, 2949. 18. S.D. Razumovskii, A.A. Kefeli, G.R. Trubnikov and G.E. Zaikov, Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR, 1970, 192, 1313. 19. E.T. Kang, K.G. Neoh, X. Zhang, K.L. Tan and D.J. Liaw, Surface and Interface Analysis, 1996, 24, 1, 51. 20. V.A. Basiuk, Uspekhi Khimii, 1995, 64, 11, 1073.
85
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 21. M. Horwath, L. Vitzky and G. Huttner, Ozone, Budapest Academiai Kiadoi, 1985. 22. S.D. Razumovskii and G.E. Zaikov, Izvestiya Akademii Nauk SSSR Seriya Khimicheskaya, 1973, 2244. 23. M. Tedder, Quarterly Reviews, 1960, 14, 336. 24. T. Herron and R.E. Huie, Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1969, 73, 3327. 25. Ozonation in Organic Chemistry, Volumes I and II, Ed., P.S. Bailey, Organic Chemistry Monographs, Volume 39, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1978 and 1982. 26. E.T. Denisov and T.G. Denisova, Kinetika Katalaliz, 1996, 37, 51. 27. P.S. Nangia and S.W. Benson, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1980, 102, 3105. 28. S.W. Benson, The Foundations of Chemical Kinetics, Mir Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1964. 29. R. Atkinson, Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data, 1997, 26, 2, 215. 30. O. Reiser, Angewandte Chemie - International Edition in English, 1994, 33, 1, 69. 31. S.D. Razumovskii, Zhurnal Prikladnoi Khimii, 1969 42, 2118. 32. T.G. Denisova, Kinetics and Catalysis, 2008, 49, 331. 33. S. Hatakeyama, H. Lai, S. Gao and K. Murano, Chemistry Letters, 1993, 8, 1287. 34. A. Hudson, Research on Chemical Intermediates, 1993, 19, 7, 635. 35. E.A. Kulik, M.I. Ivanchenko, K. Kato, S. Sano and Y. Ikada, Journal of Polymer Science Part A: Polymer Chemistry, 1995, 33, 2, 323. 36. P. Jacob, B. Wehling, W. Hill, and D. Klockow, Applied Spectroscopy, 1997, 51, 1, 74. 37. Z. Gross, and L. Simkhovich, Journal of Molecular Catalysis A: Chemical, 1997, 117, 1-3, 243.
86
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons 38. R. Atkinson, Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data, 1997, 26, 2, 215. 39. J. Cerkovnik and B. Plesnicar, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1993, 115, 25, 12169. 40. J.A. Marshall and A.W. Garofalo, Journal of Organic Chemistry, 1993, 58, 14, 3675. 41. I.R. Dunkin and A. McCluskey, Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology A - Chemistry, 1993, 74, 2-3, 159. 42. B. Dhandapani and S.T. Oyama, Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, 1997, 11, 2, 129. 43. J.M. Encinar, F.J. Beltran and J.M. Frades, Anales de Quimica, 1993, 89, 7-8, 682. 44. G.A. Galstyan, T.M. Galstyan, and L.I. Mikulenko, Kinetics and Catalysis, 1994, 35, 2, 231. 45. S.K. Rakovsky, D.R. Cherneva and M. Deneva, International Journal of Chemical Kinetics, 1995, 27, 2, 153. 46. M.P. Deninno, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1995, 117, 39, 9927. 47. S.D. Razumovskii, S.K. Rakovski and G.E. Zaikov, Izvestiya Akademii Nauk Seriya Khimicheskaya, 1975, 9, 1963. 48. S.K. Rakovski, A.A. Popov, S.D. Razumovskii, D.M. Shopov and G.E. Zaikov, Communications of the Department of Chemistry - Bulgarian Academy of Sciences1975, 8, 3, 544. 49. S.K. Rakovski, A.A. Popov, S.D. Razumovskii, D.M. Shopov and G.E. Zaikov, Communications of the Department of Chemistry - Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1975, 8, 3, 571. 50. S.K. Rakovsky, S.D. Razumovskii and G.E. Zaikov, Izvestiya Akademii Nauk Seriya Khimicheskaya, 1976, 3, 701. 51. A.A Popov, S.K. Rakovsky, D.M. Shopov and L.V. Ruban, Izvestiya Akademii Nauk Seriya Khimicheskaya, 1976, 40, 5, 982.
87
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 52. L.V. Ruban, S.K. Rakovski and A.A. Popov, Izvestiya Akademii Nauk Seriya Khimicheskaya, 1976, 5, 1950. 53. L.V. Ruban, S.K. Rakovski, S.D. Razumovskii and G.E. Zaikov, Izvestiya Akademii Nauk Seriya Khimicheskaya, 1976, 5, 2104. 54. S.K. Rakovski, D.R. Cherneva, D.M. Shopov and S.D. Rakumovskii, Communications of the Department of Chemistry - Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1976, 9, 4, 711. 55. S.K. Rakovski, D.R. Cherneva, D.M. Shopov and V.M. Parfenov, Communications of the Department of Chemistry - Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1978, 11, 1, 153. 56. S.K. Rakovski, L.K. Nenchev, D.R. Cherneva and D.M. Shopov, Communications of the Department of Chemistry - Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1979, 12, 2, 254. 57. S.K. Rakovsky, D.R. Cherneva and D.M. Shopov, Izvestiya Akademii Nauk Seriya Khimicheskaya, 1979, 9,1991. 58. A.A. Kefely, S.K. Rakovski, D.M. Shopov, S.D. Razumovskii, K.S. Rakovski and G.E. Zaikov, Journal of Polymer Science: Polymer Chemistry Edition, 1981, 19, 6, 2175. 59. S.D. Razumovskii, S.K. Rakovski, D.M. Shopov and G.E. Zaikov, Ozone and Its Reactions with Organic Compounds, Publishing House of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1983, p.1. [in Russian] 60. S.K. Rakovski, D.R. Cherneva and D.M. Shopov, Oxidation Communications, 1984, 7, 1, 181. 61. N.N. Blinov, A.A. Popov, S.K. Rakovski, A.K. Stoyanov, D.M. Shopov and G.E. Zaikiv, Vysokomolekulyarnye Soedineniya Seriya A, 1989, 31, 2212. 62. S.K. Rakovski, D.M. Shopov, D.R. Cherneva in the Proceedings of the 25th Microsymposium on Processing and Long-Term Stabilities of Hydrocarbon Polymers, Prague, Czechoslovakia, 1983, Poster No.33, p.1. 63. S.K. Rakovsky, L.K. Nenchev, D.R. Cherneva and D.M. Shopov in the Proceedings of the 7th Internernational Symposium Heterocyclic Catalysis, Varna, Bulgaria, 1979, Volume 2, p.231.
88
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons 64. S.K. Rakovsky, D.R. Cherneva, A.A. Spozhakina and K. Novakov in the Proceedings of the 8th International Symposium Hetercyclic Catalysis, Varna, Bulgaria, 1996, p.407. 65. R.I. Martinez, International Journal of Chemical Kinetics, 1982, 14, 237. 66. I.N. Komissarovva, V.D. Komissarov and E.T. Denisov, Izvestiya Akademii Nauk Seriya Kimicheskaya, 1978, 9, 1991. 67. T.M. Hellman and G.A. Hamilton, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1974, 96, 1530. 68. F.E. Stary and D.E. Emge and R.W. Murray, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1976, 98, 1880. 69. I. Vedeneev, L.V. Gurvich, V.N. Kondrat’ev, V.A. Medvedev and E.L. Frankevich, Energy Breaking of the Chemical Bonds, Ionisation Potencials, and Electron Affinity, Publishing House of the Akademy Nauk SSSR, Moscow, 1962, p.90. 70. V.V. Voevodskii, Physics and Chemistry of Elementary Chemical Processes, Nauka Publishers, Moscow, 1969. 71. D.A. Frank-Kamenetzkii, Diffusion and Heat Transfer in Chemical Kinetics, Nauka Publishers, Moscow, 1987. 72. T.K. Sherwood, R.L. Pigford and C.R. Wilke, Mass Transfer, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, USA, 1975. 73. P.V. Danckwerts, Gas-Liquid Reactions, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, NY, USA, 1970. 74. G. Astarita, Mass Transfer with Chemical Reaction, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1967. 75. G.S. Hammond, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1955, 77, 334. 76. I.C. Hisatsune, L.H. Kolopajlo and J. Heicklen, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1977, 99, 3704. 77. W.G. Alcock and B. Mile, Journal of the Chemical Society: Chemical Communications, 1976, 5. 78. U. Burkert and N.L. Allinger, Molecular Mechanics, ASC Monograph No 177, ACS Washington, DC, USA, 1982.
89
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 79. K.S. Chen and N.L. Allinger, Journal of Computational Chemistry, 1993, 14, 7, 755. 80. E.L. Eliel, N.L. Allingeri, S.J. Angyal and G.A. Morrison, Conformational Analysis, Mir Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1969. 81. H. Eyring, S.H. Lin and S.M. Lin, Basic Chemical Kinetics, John Wiley, New York, NY, USA, 1980. 82. I.N. Levine, Physical Chemistry, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, USA, 1988. 83. S.W. Benson, The Foundations of Chemical Kinetics, Mir Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1964. 84. N. Tyutyulkov, Quantum Chemistry, Nauka i Izkustvo, Sofia, Bulgaria, 1978. 85. T. Klark, A Handbook of Computational Chemistry, John Wiley, New York, NY, USA, 1985. 86. K.D. Dobbs and D.A. Dixon and A Komornicki, Journal of Chemical Physics, 1993, 98, 11, 8852. 87. M.J.S. Dewar, J.C. Hwang and D.R. Kuhn, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1991, 113, 3, 735. 88. C. Meredith, G.E. Quelch and H.F. Schaefeer III, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1991, 113, 1186. 89. G. Herzberg, Molecular Spectra and Molecular Structure, (two volumes), Van Nostrand, New York, NY, USA, 1954 and 1957. 90. P. Karadakov and S.K. Rakovsky, Computer Program - Calculation of Preexponents According to the Activated Complex Theory and Collision Theory, Colloquium of the Institute of Organic Chemistry and the Institute of Catalysis Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1988. 91. S. Benson, Thermochemical Kinetics, Mir Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1971. 92. K.S. Pitzer, Journal of Chemical Physics, 1946, 14, 239. 93. M.V. Bazilevskii, Molecular Orbitals Method and Reaction Ability of Organic Molecules, Khimia Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1969. 94. M.V. Bazilevskii and Z.T. Trosman, Uspehi Khimii, 1960, 41, 3. 95. E. Radinovitch, Transactions of the Faraday Society, 1937, 33, 1225. 90
Ozonolysis of low and high molecular weight saturated hydrocarbons 96. M.G. OEvans and M. Polany, Transactions of the Faraday Society, 1936, 32, 1333. 97. L.G. Galimova, V.D. Komissarov and E.T. Denisov, Izvestiya Akademii Nauk Seriya Kimicheskaya, 1973, p.307. 98. M. Dioxin and E. Ebb, Ferments, Mir Publishing House, Moscow, Russia, 1966, p.277. 99. V. Karnogitzkii, Organic Peroxides, Inostrannaja Literatura Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1961, p.115. 100. F. Kritchfild, Analysis of Basic Functional Groups in Organic Compounds, Mir Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1965, p.188. 101. E.J.E. Hawkins, Organic Peroxides, Khimia Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1965. 102. R.M. Johnson and J.W. Siddiqi, The Determination of Organic Peroxides, Pergamon Press, New York, NY, USA, 1970, p.15. 103. E.T. Denisov, Rate Constants of the Homolytical Liquid-Phase Reactions, Nauka Publishers, Moscow, 1971. 104. V.Ya. Shlyapintoh, O.N. Karpuhin, L.M. Postnikov, I.V. Zaharov, A.A. Vichutinskii and V.F. Tzepalov, Chemiluminescent Methods of Investigation of the Slow Chemical Proceses, Nauka Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1966. 105. E.T. Denisov, Kinetic of Homogeneous Chemical Reactions, Visshaya Shkola Publishing House, Moscow, Russia, 1988. 106. V.A. Yakubi, B.A. Ponomarev, N.F. Tupalo, G.A. Galstyan, L.P. Petrenko, S.M. Tyutyunnik and P.P. Karpuhin in Theory and Practis of Liquid Phase Oxidation, Ed., N.M. Emanuel, Nauka Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1974, p.303. 107. G.A. Galstyan in Proceedings of the 2nd Ozone Conference, Moscow, Russia, 1977, p.40. 108. L.K. Nenchev and D.M. Shopov, Neftekhimia, 1978, 18, 2, 256. 109. S.G. Karpova, A.A. Popov, S.N. Chvalun, Yu.A. Zubov and G.E. Zaikov, Vysokomolekulyarnye Soedineniya Seriya B, 1985, 27, 9, 686.
91
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 110. S.G. Karpova, A.A. Popov, S.N. Chvalun, Yu.A. Zubov and G.E. Zaikov, Vysokomolekulyarnye Soedineniya Seriya A, 1986, 28, 7, 1404. 111. A.A. Popov, A.V. Rusak, O.A. Ledneva and G.E. Zaikov, Vysokomolekulyarnye Soedineniya Seriya A, 1986, 28, 9, 1836. 112. N.N. Blinov, A.A. Popov, E.S. Popova, A.V. Butusov, A.N. Neverov, G.E. Zaikov and G. Irinyi, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 1988, 22, 7. 113. A. Cipitoin, A. Constantinesku and V. Dobresku in the Proceedings of the IUPAC Macro’83, Budapest, 1983, Section 4, p.727. 114. K.H.H. Patel, Journal of Polymer Science: Polymer Physics, 1975, 13, 2, 303. 115. A.A. Popov, N.N. Blinov and G.E. Zaikov, DokladyAkademii Nauk SSSR, 1986, 286, 4, 922. 116. V.I. Selihova, L.A. Ozerina, L.N. Ozerin and N.F. Bakeev, Vysokomolekulyarnye Soedineniya Seriya A, 1986, 28, 2, 342. 117. D.J. Priest, Journal of Polymer Science Part B: Polymer Physics Edition, 1971, 9, 10, 1777. 118. S.G. Karpova, Solid Phase Polyethelene Oxidation, Institute of Chemical Physics, Moscow, Russia, 1985. [PhD Thesis] 119. I.S. Gaponova, V.M. Gol’dberg, G.E. Zaikov, A.A. Kefely, G.B. Pariiskii, S.D. Razumovskii and V.Ya. Toptigin, Vysokomolekulyarnye Soedineniya Seriya A, 1978, 20, 2037. 120. J.A. Howard and K.V. Ingold, Canadian Journal of Chemistry, 1969, 47, 3797.
92
2
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
The ozonolysis of oxygen-containing compounds is a promising reaction that takes place under mild conditions and yields compounds of a higher oxidation level than that of the starting compounds. It may find various applications in chemical and pharmaceuticals industries, fine organic synthesis, etc. [1-2]. Moreover, this reaction is extremely important from an ecological point of view for the utilisation and purification of waste industrial waters from hydroxybenzene production, through their partial or complete oxidation [3-19]. The importance of this reaction for theory and practice gave us a basis for making systematic investigations [20-28].
2.1 Alcohols Current concepts on the ozonolysis of alcohols are discussed in several monographs [1, 2, 20, 29]. During recent years a number of authors have tried to elucidate the kinetics and mechanism of this reaction and its application for the selective preparation of ketones and aldehydes in high yields under mild conditions [29-34]. It has been established that the rate of ethanol ozonolysis does not change when the hydroxyl group is deuterated [33] and its value is 4.17 times higher than when the methylene group is deuterated. On this basis, together with the data from the analysis of the product composition and the kinetics of their formation the authors have suggested that the H-atom abstraction from ozone is the rate-determining step of the reaction. This conclusion is confirmed by the data in Table 2.1 as reported by various authors [31-33]. The ratio of the relative reactivities of tertiary:secondary:primary alcohols is 1:12:241 according to reference [31], or 1:156:817 according to reference [6]. On the basis of the studies on the reaction of ozone with methyl, ethyl and 2-propyl alcohol, the following reaction mechanism is proposed (Scheme 2.1) [30]: CH3OH + O3 [HOCvH2...HO3v]# m HOCH2OOOH, and in the presence of a base: CH3OH + O3 + (B) m HOCHO + O2H + BH+ 93
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds CH3CH2OH + O3 [CH3HCv(OH)...HO3v]# m CH3HC(OOOH)OH m CH3OOH + H2O2 and/or CH3CHO + O2 + H2O (CH3)2C(OH)H + O3 [(CH3)2Cv(OH)...HO3v]# m (CH3)2C(OH)OOOH n -O2 CH3C(OH)=CH2 + H2O +O2 (CH3)2CO + H2O n +O3 CH3COOH + HCHO Scheme 2.1
Table 2.1 Kinetic parameters of the ozone reaction with aliphatic alcohols at 25 oC k (M-1.s-1)
log A
E (kcal/mol)
Reference
t-Butanol
0.01
4.6
9.0
[32]
t-Butanol
0.05
-
-
[31]
Ethanol
0.35
6.7
9.8
[32]
Ethanol
0.25 (22 °C)
6.7
9.8
[33]
n-Butanol
0.54
7.3
10.3
[32]
n-Butanol
0.39
iso-Propanol
0.89
Cyclopentanol
1.35
Alcohols
[31] 7.3
10.0
[32] [31]
It is supposed that an intermediate ion or radical pair is formed whose recombination in the kinetic cage yields A-hydroxy-hydrotrioxide. The latter leaves the cage and passes into the solution volume. The authors of reference [30] found that the product composition of 2-propanol ozonolysis depends on the method of propanol purification. It has been established that the ozonolysis of 21 alcohols always leads to the formation of the corresponding aldehydes and ketones in 53-83% of the yields [34].
94
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds From the interesting results given above and the assumptions for the reaction pathway, in our opinion, the mechanism is still unclear and new data should be provided for its elaboration. In this connection we have carried out intensive experimental and theoretical studies of this reaction, the results of which are summarised in Figures 2.1-2.3 and Tables 2.2-2.4. Figure 2.1 demonstrates the results from ozone consumption in solutions of methanol and iso-propanol by means of the stopped flow technique with time of mixing below 0.2 seconds. It is seen that irrespective of the type of alcohol being ozonised, the kinetic curves coincide and first-order kinetics are observed under the experimental conditions applied. Calculations of the kinetic curves of ozone reaction with methyl alcohol (MeOH), ethyl alcohol (EtOH) and iso-propanol (i-PrOH) gave the following values of the rate constants: 0.057, 0.17 and 1.13 M-1.s-1, respectively. The same values were also obtained by carrying out the reaction in a bubble reactor. The values of k calculated according to Equation 1.4 are given in Table 2.2 and are presented graphically in Figures 2.2 and 2.3.
1.0
[O3].104, M
0.8
0.6
1 2
0.4
3 0.2
0.0 0
20
40
60
Time, s
Figure 2.1 Kinetics of ozone consumption in the reaction of ozone with: 1 methanol, 22 oC, 0.74 M; 2 - ethanol, 3 oC, 0.24 M; and 3 - isopropanol, 3.5 oC, 0.037 M
95
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
Table 2.2 Kinetic parameters of ozone reaction with MeOH in carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) and pure MeOH solutions: 22 oC, W = 0.167 s-1; v = 1.67 x 10-3 l/s, maximum rate of ozone inlet - 1.67 x 105 M.s-1 [MeOH] (M)
[O3]0 × 105 (M)
[O3]g × 105 (M)
$[O3] × 105 (M)
W × 106 (M.s-1)
k (M-1.s-1)
0
10
0
10
0
-
0.247
10
8.32
1.68
2.80
0.057
0.439
10
7.35
2.65
4.43
0.056
0.618
10
6.64
3.36
5.61
0.058
0.740
10
6.22
3.78
6.31
0.055
0.987
10
5.53
4.47
7.46
0.057
1.0
10
5.49
4.51
7.53
0.056
2.0
10
3.79
6.21
10.37
0.055
3.0
10
2.89
7.11
11.87
0.057
4.0
10
2.34
7.66
12.79
0.058
5.0
10
1.96
8.04
13.42
0.054
10.0
10
1.09
8.91
14.88
0.056
24.7
10
0.47
9.53
15.91
0.058
0.740
8
4.98
3.02
5.04
0.057
0.740
6
3.73
2.27
3.79
0.055
0.740
4
2.49
1.51
2.52
0.056
0.740
2
1.24
0.76
1.27
0.058
Processing the data from Table 2.2, columns 5, 2 and 3, according to Equation 1.3 yields the linear dependencies shown in Figure 2.2a and b. The rate of W on $O3 has also been found to be linear. The dependence of W on [ROH] (column 1) is a curve which approached a limit at W = 1.67 × 10-5 M/s-1. The nonlinear character of this relationship is in accordance with the complexity of Equation 1.3 (Figure 2.3) as when [ROH] md, [O3] m0 and $O3m [O3]o.
96
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
7 6
W.106, M.s -1
5 4 3 2 1 0 0
2
4
6
8
10
8
10
[O3]0.105, M
7 6
W.106, M.s -1
5 4 3 2 1 0 0
2
4
6 5
[O3]0.10 , M
Figure 2.2 Dependence of the rate of ozone consumption on the inlet (a) and outlet (b) ozone concentration
The values of k calculated by Equation 1.4 for each point of the curve are equal to 0.057. Hence, when using the bubbling method when the rate is of the first order in relation to ozone the dependencies of W on [O3]o, [O3]g and $[O3] should be linear and that on [ROH] should have the profile of the curve in Figure 2.3.
97
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds From the analysis of the data obtained (Tables 2.3 and 2.4) it follows that the rate constant and the activation energies are strongly dependent on the alcohol structure.
Table 2.3 Dependence of k on temperature in oC for ozone reaction with three types of alcohol k (M-1.s-1)
0 oC
10 oC
20 oC
25 oC
30 oC
MeOH
0.008
0.021
0.049
0.072
0.108
t-BuOH
0.005
0.013
0.029
0.045
0.064
EtOH
0.14
0.28
0.54
0.74
1.10
n-PrOH
0.19
0.36
0.67
0.89
1.18
n-BuOH
0.15
0.30
0.56
0.76
1.10
i-PrOH
0.93
1.61
2.71
3.46
4.39
s-BuOH
0.88
1.54
2.58
3.29
4.18
c-HexOH
0.92
1.59
2.65
3.37
4.27
BuOH: butanol PrOH: propanol HexOH: hexanol
The interaction of ozone with MeOH possessing primary A-H atoms and tert-BuOH with only primary C-H bonds has been found to be the slowest, and the value of k at 20 oC per one A-H atom in the first case is 1.62 × 10-2 M-1.s-1, and in the second case, related to one primary H atom, is 3.22 × 10-3 M-1.s-1. The difference in the values of these constants is due to the fact that while the OH group in MeOH directly affects the A-H atom, for the tert-BuOH, which does not possess any A-H atoms, the effect of the OH groups is carried through one S-bond and it is considerably weaker. As a result of this the reactivity of tert-BuOH becomes similar to that of methane and neopentane. The interaction of ozone with EtOH, n-PrOH, n-BuOH takes place at a higher rate and the values of k per one A-H atom amount to: 0.27, 0.34 and 0.28, respectively. The higher rate of the ozone reaction with these alcohols is associated with the presence of secondary A-H atoms in their molecule, which have lower bond energy than the primary ones. The enhanced reactivity of n-PrOH compared with that of EtOH could be ascribed to the donor effect of the second CH3 group while the donor effect of the C2H5 group in n-BuOH is weaker than that of the methyl group and thus k is lower. It has been found that the reaction
98
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds of ozone with i-PrOH, s-BuOH and s-HexOH alcohols possessing tert-H atoms with the lowest energy bond is the fastest with k equal to 2.71, 2.58 and 2.65, respectively, i.e., in fact they are the same. The ratio of the reduced values of k at 25 oC for methanol:ethanol:sec-butanol are 1:15:137. Simultaneously the values of Ea decrease with the decrease of the A-H atoms bond energy (D) and their ratio is 1:0.78:0.61 [11, 14]. This fact can be regarded as important evidence for the mechanism of A-C-H-atom abstraction by ozone.
7 6
W.106, M.s -1
5 4 3 2 1 0 0
2
4
6
8
10
8
10
[O3]0.105, M
7 6
W.106, M.s -1
5 4 3 2 1 0 0
2
4
6
[O3]0.105, M
Figure 2.3 Dependence of the rate of ozone consumption on methanol concentration according to Equation 1.4
99
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
2.1.1 Application of Estimation of Reaction Mechanism (ERM) We have tried to elaborate the mechanism of alcohol ozonolysis by means of ERM, as described in Chapter 1. The calculations of A were performed considering the two possible structures of the activated complex (AC): linear (LC) and cyclic (CC) (Figure 2.4).
_ HO H
C
+
H LC
O H
O
O
O
O
H
H
O
O
O
HO
C H
H CC'
O
O H
C
.
H
H CC
Figure 2.4 Structure of the probable activated complexes in the reaction of ozone with aliphatic alcohols: LC - linear with free fragment rotation and CCa and CC cyclic complexes without free rotation
The good agreement between the experimental and theoretical values for A allows the determination of the AC structure and on this basis the selection of the most likely mechanism. Simultaneously the value of the pre-exponential was calculated by the collision method and by comparing its value with that calculated by the AC theory the steric factor -p was determined (Equation 2.1) [36-40]: k = p.Z0.exp(-Ea/RT),
(2.1)
where: Z0 = P.(rA+rB)2 × (kT/Pm*)1/2; Zo is the collision factor; rA and rB are the van der Waals radii of the reagents; k is the Boltzmann constant; T is the absolute temperature; and m* is the reduced mass. The pre-exponentials for the reaction of ozone with alcohols, calculated according to the activated complex method (ACT) and collision theory (CT) are presented in Table 2.5.
100
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
Table 2.5 The values of A calculated by ACT with LC and CC and by CT, the sums (Rfr) and energy (Efr) of inner rotation, steric factors (p), van der Waals radii of the molecules (r) and the ratio between the calculated and experimental values of pre-exponentials ALC /Aobs cal
MeOH
EtOH
n-PrOH
i-PrOH
n-BuOH
s-BuOH
t-BuOH
c-HexOH
ACC × 10-4 (M-1.s-1)
52
8.3
3.7
3.5
2.4
2.2
6.3
1.6
ALC × 10-4 (M-1.s-1)
56
15
6.7
6.3
4.4
4.0
4.9
2.9
Ffr × 10-2
7.1
9.8
12
11
13.8
12.6
12.9
12.6
ALCcal × 10-7 (M-1.s-1)
40
15
8.1
6.8
6.1
5.0
6.3
3.6
r (Å)
2.24
2.57
2.91
2.88
3.13
3.23
3.13
3.23
CT
A × 10-11 (M-1.s-1)
2.6
2.6
2.7
2.7
2.8
2.8
2.8
2.7
p × 105
22
5.8
2.5
2.3
1.6
1.4
1.8
4.1
ALCcal/ Aobs
1.0
3.8
3.4
11
3.1
8.3
1.1
7.2
0
730
670
1368
701
1172
52
1081
Afr, (cal/mol)
Note: ALC is the pre-exponential calculated with LC without free fragment rotation (it is absent at Efr r4 kcal); ACC - calculated with CC; ALCcalc = at free fragment rotation, i.e., when exp(-Efr/RT) = 1 or Efr = 0 kcal; Act - calculated according to the collision theory at 27 0C and r - calculated by the Alinger method (pcmod4 program) at the radius of the ozone molecule of 2A; Efr - the calculated values of the rotation energy at ratio of ALCcal/Aobs = 1.
An interesting fact is the good agreement between the values of ALC and ACC. The values of ACC with the five- and seven-member cyclic form of AC are actually similar as they differ by not more than 1%. However the free rotation produces an increase in ALCcal by three orders of magnitude compared with those of ACC. The steric factor has a value which is in agreement with the liquid phase reaction. The ratio between the calculated and experimental values of ALC which increases in the sequence
101
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds primary:secondary:tertiary alcohols is 1:3.4:8.8, i.e., the coincidence in this sequence decreases. This is connected with the fact that Efr is not zero and they increase with the changes in the alcohol structure in the same sequence. It has been found that the values of ALCcalc. and Aobs. coincide when the values of rotation energy have the values in line 10. We have obtained the same values by means of the mopac6 program and therefore the values in line 10 can also be considered as calculated. The good agreement between ALCcalc and Aobs. suggests that the mechanism of the ratedetermining step of the ozone reaction with alcohols is associated with the formation of linear AC and abstraction of the A-H atom from the alcohol. The experimental and theoretical results conform well with Scheme 2.2.
R1R2(OH)C-H...O3
R1R2CHOH + O3
# R1R2COH + HO3 (HO + O2) kinetic cage
-O2
R1R2C(OOOH)OH
R1R2C(OOH)OH R1R2C(OH)OH
-H2O2
-H2O
-HO2
R1R2C(OH)OH
-H2O
R1R2C(O)OH
R1R2CO R2COOH + R1
R1R2CO
R1R2CO
Scheme 2.2 Ozone attacks the A-H atom forming a LC which further undergoes decomposition to a radical (or ion) pair in one kinetic cage. The A-hydroxy alcohol, A-hydroxyperoxy alcohol and A-hydroxytrioxy alcohol being unstable leave the cage and decompose rapidly to the corresponding aldehyde or ketone liberating water, hydroperoxide and oxygen or lead to the formation of hydroperoxy and alkoxy radicals. The latter can further undergo monomolecular decomposition.
2.2 Ketones The investigations of the reaction of ozone with ketones are of interest in relation to the theory of reactivity, the ozone chemistry, preparation of oxygen-containing compounds, and the degradation and stabilisation of organic materials. In particular, the ozonation of methylethylketone (MEK) [41-43] yielded acetic acid (AcAc), diacetyl and hydroperoxide as the main reaction products in CCl4. It has been assumed that the process proceeds as a nonchain radical reaction (RO2). Similar products are also
102
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds formed when the reaction takes place in water. However, in this case ozone interacts with the enol form of MEK [41]. The addition of nitric acid accelerates enolisation that is shown by the increase of the oxidation rate [43]. The decrease of the oxygen content in the ozone-oxygen mixture results in an increase of the oxidation rate that is due to the change of the radical leading the oxidation, from RO2v to ROv. The ozonation of isomeric decanones indicates that the reactivity of ketones depends on the length and structure of the alkyl chain. In this case the main products are A-ketohydroperoxides, monocarboxylic acids, keto alcohols and alkylbutyric lactones. However, it should be noted that the conclusions in these studies were based on product analysis at very high degrees of conversion whereby the secondary reactions play an important role in the product formation. This gives us grounds to doubt whether the proposed mechanism describes adequately the initial steps of the reaction. The rate constant and the activation energy of interaction between cyclohexanone and ozone are 1.6 × 10-2 M-1.s-1 and 11.2 kcal/mol, respectively. The reactivity of ozonised methyl derivatives of cyclohexanone is considerably higher than that of the H form. An increase in rate of interaction between the above derivatives and ozone is also observed depending on the site of substitution and it follows the sequence: 3-Me<4-M2< 2-Me [44-46]. It is evident that so far no systematic investigations on the ozonolysis of ketones have been carried out. In our studies on the ozonolysis of ketones we combined the kinetic approach and product analysis with theoretical methods. The results from the ozonolysis of some aliphatic ketones are shown in Table 2.6. The following six types of ketone have been the subject of our investigations: (1) Acetone containing only A-C-H bonds, (2) Ketones with general formula CH3CO(CH2)nCH3, where n = 1, 4, 5, 6 and 9, which contain secondary A, B, G C-H bonds, (3) Ketones with the general formula CH3(CH2)m CO(CH2)nCH3, where m = 1, n = 4, which contain A, Aa-secondary C-H bonds and cyclic cycloheptanone which contains A, B and G secondary C-H bonds, 4-4-methyl or 4-tert-butyl cyclohexanone with G-tert-C-H bond, (4) 2-Naphthylmethylketone with various substituents, and (5) Acetylacetone containing A-C-H bond activated by two keto groups. The rate constant of keto-enol tautomerism for the latter is considerably higher than that of the other ketones studied: CH3-CO-CH2-CO-CH3 CH3-CO-CH=C(OH)-CH3 103
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
Table 2.6 Kinetic parameters of the reaction of ozone with some aliphatic ketones at 21 oC k0 × 103 (M-1.s-1)
kst × 103 (M-1.s-1)
krel
log A
Ea (kcal/ mol)
CH3COCH3
3.5
7.7
0.2
10.823
18
CH3COC2H5
12
24
0.7
10.63
17
CH3COC5H11
23
67
1
10.54
16.5
CH3COC6H13
45
58
2.4
10.46
16
CH3COC7H15
448
54
2.3
10.31
15.8
CH3COC10H21
42
113
2.2
10.58
16.2
C2H5COC5H11
20
74
1
11.48
15.5
29000
-
-
87
80
4.1
9.00
17
CH3CO2-Naph
22000
-
-
5.77
6
4-CH3-c-C6H9O
117
101
6.2
8.97
12
4-t-Bu-c-C6H9O
166
123
8.1
7.93
11.8
Ketone
CH3COCH2COCH3 c-C7H12O
-
Note: ko is calculated according to Equation 1.4; krel is the relative rate constant determined by gas chromatography relative to ethylpentylketone. 2-Naph = 2-Naphthylmethylketane
The values of k, depending on the ketone structure, particularly on the content of primary, secondary or tertiary A-C-H bonds, vary in a wide range. The ratio of their reactivity is 1:3.4-24.8:33.4-47.4. In contrast to paraffins these values are more similar, which is associated to the activation of A-C-H bonds by the keto group. Ozone is sensitive not only to the activation to the A-C-H bonds but also to the keto-enol equilibrium. The rate of its reaction with acetylacetone is by three orders of magnitude higher than that with monoketones. Ketones with different substituents, for example, 2-naphthylmethylketones also show higher reactivity than the aliphatic ketones. It is concluded that the reaction centre in this case is the naphthyl ring and not the A-C-H bond in the methyl group. Another interesting observation is the higher values of Ea compared with those of paraffins (by 2-3 kcal/mol). As ozone is an electrophilic agent and the activation of the A-C-H bonds from the keto group favours the nucleophilic attack, the increase of Ea should be reasonably expected.
104
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds Figure 2.5 shows a typical kinetic curve illustrating the change of ozone concentration at the reactor outlet during ozonolysis of ketones in solution. The horizontal line describes the inlet ozone concentration and the curve corresponds to the change of its concentration at the reactor outlet. It is seen that the addition of ketone results in an abrupt fall of the ozone concentration followed by a steady-state condition ([O3]g1). After some time the ozone concentration rises again and a second steady-state region is attained ([O3]g2).
1.5
[O3]0 [O3]g
2
4
[O3].10 , M
1.0
0.5
[O3]g
1
0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Time, min
Figure 2.5 Ozonolysis of 0.712 mmol cycloheptylketone in 10 ml CCl4, 21 oC, v 0.1 l/min
The shape of the kinetic curve of ozone consumption (Figure 2.5) is complicated and supposes that ozone reacts with more than one compound [1, 21, 22]. The two horizontal sections of the curve are the result of the interaction of ozone with two compounds the rate constants of which differ considerably. The areas over the curve correspond to the amount of absorbed ozone. At the known concentrations of the reacted compounds the stoichiometry coefficients and other kinetic parameters can be calculated. This type of the kinetic curve for ketones is associated with the keto-enolic equilibrium and to the ability of ozone to react with the C=C bonds 106 times faster than with C-H bonds with nearly zero activation energy [1].
105
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The processes corresponding to the ozone-gas curve (Figure 2.5) are the following: (1) ozone starts its reaction with ketone (probably with the enol form) and an abrupt fall of its concentration is registered, (2) when the rate of ozone supply becomes equal to the rate of the chemical reaction, the first step is formed, (3) the end of the step is connected with the consumption of the enol form and the ozone concentration begins to rise, (4) at this moment ozone begins to react with the keto form and the second step is formed whereby the rate of ozone supply has become equal to the rate of the second reaction. The sharp transition between the two steady-state regions testifies that the rate of restoration of the keto-enol equilibrium is considerably lower than the rate of ozone interaction with the keto form. The general scheme of the keto-enol tautomerisation is shown next: HO- or H+
CH3C(OH)=CH2
CH3COCH3
+
OH
fast
1. CH3COCH3 + H+
CH3CCH3
+
OH
OH
CH3-C-CH2:H + H2O
slow
CH3-C=CH2 + H3+O O
O -
_
slow
2. CH3-C-CH2:H + OH
[CH3-C -H2O
O -
[CH3 C
CH2]
OH _ CH2]
fast
CH3
C
CH2
The concentration of the enolic form can be found from the area below the kinetic curve in Figure 2.5 and then the equilibrium constant of enolisation could be measured. It is known that the stoichiometry of the reaction of ozone with C=C is 1:1 and thus the amount of the enolic form can be judged by the amount of absorbed ozone, i.e., in this particular case the concentration of the enolic form is 0.134 mM. As the initial concentration of ketone is known, the equilibrium will be the difference between the initial concentration and that of the enolic form. Then the equilibrium constant can
106
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds be easily calculated using the formula: Ke=[Enol]e/[Ketone]e, and it amounts to 1.9 × 10-2. From the curve in Figure 2.5 one can also determine the rate constants of the ozone interaction with the two tautomeric forms. On the basis of the parameters of the first steady-state part and by using Equation 1.4, the value of the rate constant with the enol form is found to be kE= 2.9 × 102 M-1.s-1 and from that the second rate constant with the keto form is kK = 0.048 M-1.s-1. This demonstrates the importance of the method of ozone titration that makes possible the measurement of the equilibrium constant and the rate constants of ozone interaction with the two tautomeric forms in one kinetic experiment. It is evident that the rate constants of ozone interaction with ketone as measured by the steady-state method (Figure 2.6) through mixing of ozone and ketone solutions at [K] o>>[O3]o are higher than those found by the bubbling method (Table 2.6). This is not difficult to explain because in the former case the values obtained represent the total effective constant of interaction of the enol and the keto form. The results from the calculation of the equilibrium constants of keto-enol tautomerism for some aliphatic ketones in CCl4 are given in Table 2.7. In this table the data for acetylacetone and 2-naphthylmethylketone are not presented because in the former case the rate of reaching the equilibrium is commensurable with the rate of ozone interaction and in the latter case the ozone reacts with the double bonds in the naphthyl ring. The equilibrium constants do not differ from those found within the temperature range of 21 oC to 3 oC and agree with data from the literature [47-50]. The kinetics of ozone reactions with ketones are also determined by gas chromatography. The relative rate constants shown in Table 2.6, column 4 demonstrate that only acetone and methylketone possess lower reactivity than the standard. It is seen that the rate constants calculated from the relative values and the value of the standard constant correspond to those found by the bubbling method. The main products of ozone interaction with methylethylketone are 2-hydroxymethylethylketone, diacetyl, peroxides - alkyl and hydro, acetaldehyde and AcAc.
107
108
Ke × 10
4
Ketone
1.2
CH3COCH3 1.2
CH3COC2H5 46
CH3COC5H11 29
CH3COC6H13 96
CH3COC7H15
130
CH3COC10H21
Table 2.7 Equilibrium constants of keto-enol tautomerism of some ketones in CCl4 solution at 21 oC determined by titration with ozone 190
c-C7H12O
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
0.06 4
lg([O3]0/[O3]t)
3 0.04
2
0.02
1
0.00 0
20
40
60
80
100
Time, s
Figure 2.6 Semilogarithmic anamorphosis of the kinetic curve of ozonolysis of: 1 - methylethylketone; 2 - methylpentylketone; 3 – ethylpentylketone; and 4 – cycloheptylketone; 21 oC, ketone concentration 28 mM
On the basis of the kinetic results obtained and the product analysis we suggest Scheme 2.3 for the proceeding of ketone ozonolysis:
R1CHCOR2 + O3
H...O3 # [R1CHCOR2]
a. R1CH(OH)COR2
R1CHO + R2CHO
H
[R1CHCOR2 + OH + O2 , (HO3)]
a, b, c
+b R1COCOR2 + R1COCH(OH)R2 + O2 b. R1CH(OO)COR2
+b +RH
c. R1CH(OOOH)COR2
-O2
2R1CO + 2R2CHO
2 R1CH(O)COR2 + O2 R1CH(OOH)COR2
R1CHO + R2C(OH)O
R1CH(OH)COR2
Scheme 2.3
109
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds Ozone attacks the A-H atom forming a LC which further undergoes decomposition to a radical (or ion) pair in one kinetic cage, or leads to the formation of hydroperoxy and alkoxy radicals. The latter can further undergo monomolecular decomposition. The intermediate formation of LC is assumed in the first stage, followed by breaking of A-C-H leading to the formation of a radical (or ion) pair. Then A-hydroxyketone, A-peroxyketone radicals and A-hydroxytrioxyketone through C-C bond breaking can decompose to two aldehydes. The A-peroxyketone radical reacting with the initial ketone can be transformed into A-hydroxyperoxyketone which is decomposed through breaking of the C-C bond to aldehyde and acid or the two radicals recombine giving rise to diketone and A-hydroxyketone or two A-oxyketone radicals. The latter reacting with the initial ketone are transformed into A-hydroxyketone or through a monomolecular decomposition and breaking of the C-C bond to an alkoxy radical and aldehyde. A-Hydrotrioxyketone is decomposed to A-hydroxyketone and it in its turn to two aldehydes.
2.3 Hydrotrioxides Hydrotrioxides (HTO) are defined as compounds containing an HOOO group. HTO of oxygen-containing compounds have been studied and described in the literature in detail. They include those of ethers, acetals, alcohols and aldehydes [51-63]. They are obtained by ozonation of the corresponding organic compounds, for example: benzaldehyde, 2-methyltetrahydrofuran, methylisopropyl ether, di-iso-propyl ether, etc., at low temperatures (<–60 oC to –80 oC). HTO are unstable compounds and on heating they decompose and liberate oxygen. The nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) method has been used to confirm their structure including the unstable HOOO group [53]:
O CH3 O
OOOH
;
H 3C
CH3 .
C
C-OOOH ; H3CO
OOOH
The NMR signal of the proton in the HOOO group appears at D = 13.1 ppm, while that in HOO group at D = 9 ppm [53, 57]. Benzoic acid and singlet oxygen were the main products of decomposition of benzaldehyde HTO. This reaction, due to the high yield of 1O2, appears to be a suitable source for its preparation [55]. The proton signals of the HOOO group in the acetals below:
110
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
appear in the vicinity of D = 12-14 ppm [30, 31] and the proton signal of HTO of ethanol at 13.7 ppm is a doublet [62]. The kinetic parameters of decomposition of HTO of benzaldehyde, 2-methyltetrahydrofuran and methyl-iso-propylether are found to be dependent on whether the decomposition is performed in a solvent or in a pure substrate [53]. Thus in pure HTO a slight downfield shift (by <0.15 ppm) of the peak of HOOO is observed [64-66]. The doublet at <–50 oC is transformed into a singlet [56, 57, 62] with the rise of the temperature to ambient. This is explained by the participation of a proton in an exchange reaction with hydrogen bond formation. The lower values of A and Ea found for the decomposition of pure HTO result from the hydrogen bond formation and HTO stabilisation in TS: O
C O
#
H
O
H
O
O
O
OH
O
C
+ O2
C
O
O
The kinetic parameters of the decomposition of 23 HTO obtained by different authors are given in Table 2.8 [53-71]:
Cl CH3 O
O
C
C
C O
HOOO
O
HOOO
1
5
C
OCH3
OOOH
C
OOOH
8 OCH3 C
H 3C
OOOH OCH3
OCH3 10
OOOH
OCH3
OCH3 H 3CO
OCH3 9
C
F
7
6
C
OOOH OC2H5
OCH3 Cl
OCH3
OC2H5
C OOOH OOOH
O
HOOO 4
OCH3
C
C
3
2 O
O
OOOH CH3
11
111
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds OCH3 H 3C
C
OC2H5 H 3C
OOOH
C
OCH3
OC2H5
12
13
H 3C
C
O
16
21
20
C O
Ph
O
OOOH
O
C CH3
O
OC2H5 19
OOOH
O
OOOH C
H
O
O
18
O
OOOH C
C
O
17
OOOH
O
H3CCCHC3H7
OH
OCH3 15
OOOH
OH
O
H 3C
14
H3CCHOOOH
OOOH C
CH3
OOOH C
H 3C
H 3C
OOOH
OOOH
H 23
22
In studying the decomposition of A-methylbenzylmethylether HTO, Kovac and Pleshnichar have established that the main products are acetophenone, methanol, methylbenzoate and traces of water and hydroperoxide [53, 54]. They have explained the formation of these products as shown in Scheme 2.4.
CH 3
CH3 #
O
H O
C H 3C
O
O
O
C H 3C
O
H 3C
H
O
C
O I
I
OCH 3
OCH 3
C
C
OO' + 'OH 2
CH 3
OH + 1O2
CH 3
II
II
-CH 3
C
O
;
+RH II
CH 3
+RH I
OOH
CH 3
Scheme 2.4
112
OH
CH3
OCH 3 C
OCH 3 C
O + CH 3OH
+
1O2
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
Table 2.8 Kinetic and activation parameters of the decomposition reaction of HTO in pure substrate (-), ether and dichloromethane (DChM) HTO
Solvent
T1/2 (min)
t, 0C
k × 104 (s-1)
log A
Ea (kcal/ mol)
1
Ether DChM
43 58
–40 –30 –20 –30
160 660 640 120
14.8 20.6
12.2 16.6
2
Ether
-
–40
270
-
-
3
d6-Acetone
162 50 37 21 13
–35 –23 –20 –17 –12
0.7 2.3 3.1 5.4 10
16
10.4
4
DChM Ether
85 63
–20 –30 –40
380 80 110
18.6
14.7
5
Ether
14 33 82 180 41 82 216
0 –9 –2– –34 –27 –33 –39
8.6 3.5 1.7 4.6 2.8 1.4 5.3
10.8 16.5
5.4 11.1
6
Ether
58
–30 –35 –40
660 290 120
18.9
15.9
7
Ether
53
–30 –35 –40
760 280 130
19.8
16.7
8
Ether
–30 –35 –40
630 310 110
19.6
16.4
–35 –40
320 140
18.4
15.4
–25 –30 –35
440 200 100
17.2
13.7
–20 –25 –30 –35
2100 810 310 140
21.5
17.8
–20 –10 –10 –10 –20
270 560 400 290 90
20.8
15.6
63 9
Ether 49
10
Ether 69
11
Ether 49
12
DChM Ether
84
113
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
–10 –20 –10 –20 –50 –40 –29 –20 –10
1100 370 760 280 0.1 2 120 370 1000
14.6 13.1 22.7
11.1 9.8 18.2
3 17 58 330 8 18 60 138
–6 –30 –50 –68 –12 –19 –27 –33
40 6.9 2 0.35 10 6.5 1.9 0.83
7.9 17.4
4.1 11.7
15
2.6 13 16 52 114
–10 –22 –26 –33 –38
50 8.8 7.3 2.2 1
16.5
11.5
16
150 18 7
–30 –10 0
0.76 6.2 20
11.7
6.4
17
19 29 46 120 288
–30 –40 –45 –60 –70
6.9
3.8
4 2.5 0.9 0.4
18
2 3 10 23
0 –10 –20 –31
60 40 10 5
11.5
6.9
19*
3 10 23 38
–10 –20 –30 –40
40 10 5 3
12.4
8.0
20*
168
–30
0.7
-
-
21*
84
–30
1.4
-
-
12
–30
10
-
-
38
–30
3
-
-
13
Ether
14
Ether
22* 23* Note: *our data.
114
DChM
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds We have established that the decomposition reaction of HTO in the temperature range of (–70 oC to 0 oC) obeys Equation 2.2: -d [HTO]/dt = kd . [HTO],
(2.2)
where kp is the decomposition rate constant. The values of the rate constants of the HTO decomposition indicate that electronaccepting substituents to the benzene ring affect the process in a rather complex way (Table 2.9).
Table 2.9 Activation parameters of the decomposition of hydrotrioxides of some A-methylbenzylalkylethers OR X
C
OOOH CH3
Solvent
kd × 102 at –30 o C (s-1)
Ea (kcal/mol)
log A
X=H; R=CH3
EtAc Ether
0.5 8.9
15.2 17.7
11.4 14.9
X = Cl; R = CH3
Ether
12
16.7
14.1
X = Br; R = CH3
Ether
7.6
16.8
14.1
X = CH3; R = CH3
Ether
49
18.1
16
X = Br; R = C2H5
Ether
6.9
17.6
14.7
HTO
The decomposition reaction of the synthesised HTO of 1,1-diethoxyethane yields ethylacetate (0.75-080 mol per 1 mol of absorbed ozone), ethanol (0.80-0.85 mol), water (0.06-0.12 mol), acetaldehyde, acetic acid ethylformiate, diethylcarbonate, dissolved gases, probably methane and ethane, and traces of 2-hydroxydiethylether
115
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds and A,A-diethoxydiethylperoxide and hydroperoxide. It was assumed that ethylacetate, ethanol, and singlet oxygen are formed as follows: C 2H 5 H
O
H 3C
O
C O
O
CH3(O)C2H5 + C2H5OH + 1O2 .
O
C 2H 5
The rest of the decomposition products were assumed to be formed by the interaction of the products generated in the decomposition reaction radicals with the initial and intermediate reaction products:
C 2H 5 O
H 3C
O
C O
CH3C(OC2H5)2O + O2H
H
O
O
CH3C(OC2H5)2OO + OH
C 2H 5 CH3C(OC2H5)2OO + RH 2 CH3C(OC2H5)2OO CH3C(OC2H5)2O + RH CH3C(OC2H5)2OH
CH3C(OC2H5)2OOH + R [CH3C(OC2H5)2O]2 + O2 CH3C(OC2H5)2OH + R CH3C(O)OC2H5 + C2H5OH
The comparatively low values of the activation energy of the thermal decomposition of some HTO (Table 2.9) can be explained by the fact that the reaction takes place simultaneously in several directions. The reaction step of radical decomposition was suppressed and became negligible with the decrease in temperature. Ozonolysis of 1,1-diethoxyethane in the –20 oC to +60 oC range leads mainly to the formation of ethylacetate, ethanol, the corresponding HTO and water. The radical steps of the process yielded ROOH and water and, hence, they were responsible for the formation of the latter of about 40% at 50 oC whereas in practice it was below 1% at 5 oC. These results were also confirmed by the data in references [34, 37]. According to these authors, the share of the free radical route is 1.2% at –60 oC for the HTO of
116
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds 1,1-diethoxyethane while it varies in the range of 0.3-3.7 between –30 oC and 0 oC for the decomposition of HTO of 2-propanol. Formation of nitroxyl radicals has been observed upon decomposition of HTO of ethanol, isopropanol, 1,1-diethoxyethane and benzaldehyde in the presence of diphenylamine and 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperydine [66].
Table 2.10 Effect of temperature on the formation of water and HTO in the ozonolysis of 1,1-diethoxyethane (1) and 2-methyl-1,3-dioxolane at 12 mM absorbed ozone and initial concentration of acetal 0.1 M Acetal
t (oC)
HTO (mM)
H2O (mM)
HTO/O3
H2O/O3
1
60 50 40 20 5 –20
5.7 4.5 3.6 2.3 0.8 0
6.1 5.0 4.2 2.2 07 0
0.48 0.38 0.3 0.19 0.07 0
0.51 0.42 0.35 0.19 0.06 0
2
50 40 20 5 –20
4 3 2.1 0 0
4.3 3.3 2.2 0 0
0.33 0.25 0.18 0 0
0.36 0.27 0.19 0 0
According to Pryor and co-workers [55] the values of the activation parameters of cumene HTO decomposition (Ea and lgA) are 16 and 10 kcal/mol, respectively, whereas other authors reported 24 and 16 kcal/mol, respectively [67]. These parameters are very close to those of benzaldehyde HTO [53] and acetals [56, 57]. The main products of the cumene HTO decomposition are dimethylphenylcarbinol (DMPC), acetophenone (AcP), singlet oxygen and hydroperoxide (ROOH). The assumption that the decomposition process takes place via the chain-radical route was confirmed with the help of 2,5-di-tert-butyl-4-methylphenol (Ionol). In this case the activation energy is strongly reduced. The product formation could be explained by [70]:
117
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds CH3
CH3
C-O-O-O-H
C-O
CH3
CH3
CH3
CH3
C-O + InH
C-OH + In
CH3
CH3
+ OOH
CH3
CH3
C-O (O2H) + In
C-OIn (InO2H) .
CH3
CH3
Then the process occurs without an inhibitor: ROv + ROOOH m ROH + ROOOv ROOOH + vO2H m ROOOv + H2O2 ROOOv m ROv + 1O2 ROv m AcP + vCH3 We found that the thermal decomposition of HTO is accompanied by an intensive chemiluminescence in the visible and infrared (IR) regions [51, 60, 65], which has also been observed by other authors. Carbonyl compounds and singlet oxygen are assumed to be chemiluminescent emitters. The rate constant of the thermal decomposition determined by chemiluminescence (kCL) turned out to be very close to that measured by the NMR (kNMR) method through monitoring the disappearance of the signal at D = 13 ppm (Table 2.11).
Table 2.11 Rate constants of decomposition determined by chemiluminescence and by NMR for some HTO HTO (CH3)2C(OOOH)OH (CH3)2C(OOOH)OCH(CH3)2 CH3C(OOOH)(OC2H5)2
118
t (oC)
kCL × 103 (s-1)
kNMR × 103 (s-1)
0
2
2
–26
12
18
0
1.3
0.9
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds It should be noted, however, that the decomposition rate determined by chemiluminescence in the IR range of the spectrum is lower than that in the visible region [60]. The reason for this difference is not yet clear. Our attempts and those of other investigators to use HTO as oxidising agents have given satisfactory results in a number of cases [1, 2, 73-78]. It is known that the oxidation of sulfides to their respective sulfoxides using HTO of ethanol, 2-propanol, 1,1-diethoxyethane and benzaldehyde take place at a high rate and selectivity. Among them the latter two compounds were the most active [68]: +R'OOOH R2S
R2S=O
R = CH3, C4H9, C7H15
It has been found that dimethylsulfide was readily oxidised by the HTO of 1,3dioxolane to dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) (Table 2.12).
Table 2.12 Oxidation of dimethylsulfide by HTO of 1,3-dioxolane (1) and 2-methyl-1,3-dioxolane (2), at –30 oC and mol ratio [ROOH]/[DMC] = 1:4 HTO
[ROOOH]0 (mM)
[DMSO] (mM)
Yield (%)
1
0.7 0.6
0.6 0.6
86 100
2
0.5 0.6
0.3 0.4
60 67
Initially the HTO forms a monoether quantitatively. It was also demonstrated in the case of dimethyl and dibutyl sulfoxides that HTO can oxidise sulfoxides to the respective sulfones: R2S=O + RaOOOH m R2SO + RaOOH The HTO of benzaldehyde and 2-propanol were the most effective. The yield of sulfone per 1 mol of converted HTO was increased with the increase of the thermal stability of HTO (Table 2.13).
119
120 13 20 92 63 25 30 50 32 26 46 29 30
(CH3)2C(OH)(OOOH)
(CH3)2CHOC(CH3)2(OOOH)
CH3CH(OC2H5)(OOOH)
C6H5C(O)(OOOH)
[HTO]0 × 102 (M)
CH3CH(OH)(OOOH)
HTO 1.6 1.0 19 16.4 6.5 5.4 7.6 1.2 2.5 0.8 21.6 8.2
0.9 2.9 1.1 3.3 1.2 5.7 1.1 1.2 1 5 0.9 3.3
13.8 6.9 100 19 21 5.3 44 11
(CH3)2SO (C4H9)2SO
(C4H9)2SO 27 9.2 30.6 9
(C4H9)2SO (C4H9)2SO
(C4H9)2SO
[R2SO2] × 102 (M)
[R2SO]0 × 102 (M)
[HTO]0/ [R2SO]0
R2SO
Table 2.13 Oxidation of dialkylsulfoxides by HTO
0.67 1
0.09 0.087
0.17 0.11
0.18 0.86 0.31 1
0.12 0.15
[R2SO2]/ [R2SO]0
0.74 0.27
0.1 0.02
0.15 0.04
0.21 0.26 0.16 0.18
0.12 0.05
[R2SO2]/ [HTO]0
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds Another direction in HTO application is the oxidation reaction of phosphines. According to reference [76] the HTO of alcohols, ethers and acetals convert readily, selectively and quantitatively triaryl- and trialkyl-phosphines to respective phosphites: (RO)3P + RaOOOH m (RO)3P=O + RaOOH The data from the oxidation process of triphenylphosphine by HTO of ethanol and propanol, obtained by the authors of [50] are listed in Table 2.14.
Table 2.14 Stoichiometric ratios at the oxidation of triphenylphosphine by HTO of 2-propanol and ethanol in ether solution at –50 oC [76] HTO
[HTO]0 (M)
[HTO]f (M)
[Ph3P]0 (M)
[Ph3P]f (M)
$[Ph3P]/ $[HTO]
2-Propanol
0.52 0.19 0.09 0.1
0.37 0.08 0 0
0.14 0.14 0.018 0.33
0 0 0.01 0.1
0.9 1.3 1.9 2.0
Ethanol
0.10 0.08
0 0
0.23 0.29
0.04 0.13
1.9 2.0
Note: In 2-propanol, the R in HTO is (CH3)2C(OH) and in ethanol, the R is CH3CH(OH); index f is final concentration.
It is evident that the reaction stoichiometry depends on the initial concentration of the reagents and it attains its ultimate value of 2 at low HTO concentration and excess of phosphine. In this case HTO is converted to hydroperoxide which in its turn yields alcohol. It has been found that the titration with phosphines can be used as an analytical method for HTO determination. Its reliability is supported by the close values of the rate constant of A-hydroxyhydrotrioxide decomposition determined by the above method (–30 oC, kd = 6 × 10-4 s-1) and by the NMR method (–30 oC, kd = 4 × 10-4 s-1). It has been shown that pyridine is oxidised by HTO at –60 oC to N-oxide (60-80% yield). The oxidation of other organic compounds to corresponding products can also be accomplished by HTO. In this case, however, catalysts and higher temperatures should be applied.
121
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds Upon ozonation of 2-methyl-1,3-dioxolane in the temperature range of –60 oC to +50 oC it has been found that 1 mol ozone gives 2 moles of glycol monoester. It was presumed that the intermediate HTO can also oxidise the substrate (Table 2.15).
Table 2.15 Synthesis (–60 oC to +50 oC) and decomposition (–30 oC) of HTO of 2-methyl-1,3-dioxolanes in ethylacetate Acetal
[Ac]0 (mM)
[Ac]f (mM)
Time (min)
$[Ac] (mM)
[O3] (mM)
[Monoester] (mM)
2-Methyl1,3-dioxolan
22.4 11.2 11.2 11.2 5.6a 3.7a
18.0 9.4 9.4 9.7 3.8 1.9
45 10 15 10 15 20
4.4 1.8 1.8 1.5 1.8 1.8
1.8 0.7 0.8 0.6 0.9 1.0
4.2 1.2 1.6 1.5 1.5 1.8
The decomposition reaction of the HTO indicated above proceeds in the following way: O
OOOH C
O
C
+ R
H
O O
2 HO(CH2)2(O)C(O)R R
R = H, CH3
This suggestion was confirmed in the oxidation of 2-methyl-1,3-dioxolane by the HTO of 1,3-dioxolane. Besides ethyleneglycol-monoformiate, ethyleneglycol-monoacetate was found in the mixture of reaction products:
Ring opening on the decomposition of HTO formed by the ozonolysis of nonsymmetric dioxanes (2-methyl, 2,4-dimethyl and 4,4-dimethyl-1,3-dioxane) may take place via two routes resulting in the formation of two isomeric esters:
122
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
CH3
C
R"
O
O
C R'
R'C(O)O(CH2)2C(CH3)(OH)R" (a)
R"
+ O3
O
O
CH3
C
C H
R'
R'(O)OC(CH3)(R")(CH2)2OH (b) OOOH
R' = R" = H; R' = CH3, R" = H; R' = H, R" = CH3
The ratio of the products of type (a) and (b) upon ozonolysis of 1,3-dioxycyclanes at various temperatures are shown in Table 2.16.
;
O
O
OOOH
H
CH3
CH3
CH3
R"
H3C
1
;
O
O
O
O
OOOH
H
OOOH
CH3
3
2
Table 2.16 Products of ozonation of 4-methyl-1,3-dioxane (1), 2,4-dimethyl1,3-dioxane (2) and 4,4-dimethyl-1,3-dioxane (3) at various temperatures HTO
a/b, –50 oC
a/b, +15 oC
a/b, +50 oC
1
2:1
2:1
2:1
2
2.5:1
2:1
2:1
3
7:1
3:1
2:1
Note: a - monoesters with acylated primary groups. a/b: Ratio of products a and b
The main products of the reaction were monoesters with acylated primary groups. The more selective decomposition of the HTO of 4,4-dimethyl-1,3-dioxane (Table 2.16) is due to the steric repulsion between the OOOH group and the axial CH3 group at the 4C atom of the ring in the intermediate HTO:
H
O O
CH3
OOOH H3C
123
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The above discussion shows that the chemistry of organic trioxides is a new rapidly developing branch of organic chemistry and any progress in this field is essential for the development and improvement of the theory or reactivity and methods of organic synthesis [79-96]. 1,3-Dioxolanes, in particular those substituted in the fourth position, have found wide application as solvents, plasitifiers and biologically active substances. In this connection we have tried to develop a new method for the preparation of the above compounds in satisfactory yields and to obtain a number of new derivatives. The two-phase catalytic ‘liquid-liquid’ and ‘liquid-solid’ systems were applied.
2.4 Synthesis of oxolanes 2.4.1 Derivatives of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane A four-necked flask, supplied with a reflux condenser, a magnetic stirrer, thermometer and a funnel was charged with 10 ml aqueous NaOH and 5 mM Katamin AB and with continuous stirring, 0.05 M 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane was added dropby-drop [24]. The mixture was heated up to 15 oC and the corresponding chloride (0.05 M) was added drop-by-drop for 30 minutes. Then the mixture was diluted with water and extracted with ether. The ethereal solution was dried over MgSO4, the diethyl ether removed and the mixture subjected to vacuum distillation. Thus, the following oxolanes were obtained: 4-Propyloxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane; NMR spectrum [CCl4, D ppm of hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS)]: 0.7 - 1.0 (t) CH3; 1.3-1.7 (qt) CH3-CH2; 3.2 - 3.5 (m) CH2-O-CH2; 3.6-4.2 (m) 5H, -OCH2-CH2-CH2O; 4.7 (s) -O-CH2-O-ring. 4-Benzyloxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane; (CCl4, D ppm of HMDS): 3.6 - 4.2 (m) 5H, -OCH2CH2-CH2O; 4.35 (s) OCH2-Ph; 4.7 - 4.8 (s) O-CH2-O- ring; 7.0-7.3 (m) C6H5. Phenylsulfone of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane: (CCl4, D ppm of HMDS): 3.6 - 4.4 (m) 5H -OCH2-CH2-CH2O; 4.7 - 4.9 (s) 2H, O-CH2-O-ring; 7.5-8.0 (m) C6H5. Note: t = triolet, qt = quartet, m = multiplet and s = singlet
2.4.2 Phenyl ethers of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane A four-necked flask, provided with a reflux condenser, a magnetic stirrer, thermometer and a funnel was charged with the phenol, 0.1 M of solid KOH, a catalytic quantity of 18-crown-6 and acetonitrile or DMSO as solvent and under continuous stirring 0.05 124
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds M 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane was added drop-wise. The mixture was stirred for 3 h at 70 oC followed by ether extraction and the extract was dried over MgSO4. The diethyl ether was distilled off and the residual mixture subjected to vacuum distillation. Thus, 4-(2,5-dichlorophenoxymethyl)-1,3-dioxolane was obtained with the following NMR characteristics: (CCl4, D ppm of HMDS): 3.2-4 (m) 5H, -CH2CH2-CH2O; 4.8-4.9 (s) 2H, -CH2-O-ring; 6.6-7.2 (m) C6H5.
2.4.3 Alkyl ethers of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane The synthesis of alkyl ethers of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane (B) was carried out by the interaction of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane (A) with alkylhalides (RX): propylchloride, butylchloride, octylchloride, butylbromide and hexylbromide. In the presence of an aqueous alkaline solution with the application of interphase catalyst - Katamin AB - the following products were obtained: CH2OR
CH2OH O
O
+ RX
90oC
O
O
1.5 h
where R = C3H7 (I), C4H9 (II), C6H13 (III), C8H17 (IV), with the following physical constants: boiling point t in oC, at mm Hg, nD20 and yield in % - 42(5), 1.4313, 55; 58(4), 1.4320, 57; 80(6), 1.4359, 50 and 132(4), 1.5213, 44, respectively. In the series of normal alkychlorides the yields of monoethers decrease with the increase of the molecular mass of the substituents. The substitution of chlorides by the corresponding bromides also leads to an increase of the yields up to 65-70%. The arylmethylethers of 4-hydroxy-1,3-dioxolane were obtained under similar conditions. Benzyl and p-chlorobenzylchloride react with 4-hydroxy-1,3-dioxolane to give the corresponding ethers: CH2OCH2PhX
CH2OH 70oC O
O
+ XPhCH2X
O
O
where X = H(V) or Cl(VI) in yields of 84 and 70%, respectively. The physical constants for (V) are 132(4), 1.5231, R = 1.1832 g/cm3, and for (VI) 160(7), 1.5242, 1.0119, respectively.
125
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds In some case it seems more preferable to use epichlorohydrin derivatives. In interphase catalysis (solid KOH, catalyst - tetrabutylammonium bromide and 90 oC) it became possible to obtain benzyl ether of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolane: CH2OCH2Ph
CH2Cl 90oC O
O
+ PhCH2OH
O
O
The yield, however, does not exceed 25%. A series of aryl ethers were obtained by the reaction of 4-chloromethyl-1,3-dioxolane with substituted phenols in the presence of various solvents: Z
CH2 Cl O
+
O
CH2 O
Z
HO
O
Y
O
Y X
X
where X, Y and Z are: CH3, Cl, H (VII); H, H, H (VIII); Cl, H, Cl (X); Cl, H, H (XI); H, CHI, H (XII); and H, Cl, H (XIII). Depending on the conditions and the type of substituent the yield of monoethers varies from 10 to 80% (Table 2.17). The C4-C8 aliphatic alcohols do not react with 4-chloromethyl-1,3-dioxolane under interphase catalysis conditions. The results obtained show that it is better to conduct the synthesis of 4-alkoxymethyl-1,3-dioxolanes on the basis of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3dioxolane and the corresponding alkyl halides. Derivatives of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3dioxolane-arylsulfonates were obtained by the interaction of 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3dioxolane with arylsulfochlorides (aqueous-alkaline solution, Katamin AB): Y CH2 OH
Y
CH2 OSO2
15oC O
O
+
ClSO2
O
O
X
X
where X and Y are: H, H (XIV); CH3, H (XV); CH3, CH3 (XVI); Cl, H (XVII). The yields of the compounds in (%) and their melting points in (oC) are as follows: 88, 55-57; 80, 75; 50, 90-92 and 30, 37. 126
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds Compounds XIV-XVI are new. The data reveals that 4-hydroxymethyl and 4-chloromethyl1,3-dioxolanes can be successfully applied in the synthesis of cyclic acetals, containing alkyl and aromatic substituents.
Table 2.17 Synthesis of aryl derivatives Substrate
Solvent
Catalyst
bp (oC) (mm Hg)
R (g/cm3)
nD20
Yield (%)
VII
NaOH/ H2O
Katamin AB
154 (5)
1.2381
1.5330
10
VIII
NaOH/ H2O
Katamin AB
112 (7)
1.0548
1.5150
42
IX
CH3CN
18crown-6
165 (4)
-
1.5445
15
X
CH3CN
18crown-6
150 (5)
-
1.5341
10
XI
DMSO
18crown-6
118 (5)
-
1.5194
50
XII
DMSO
18crown-6
75-77
-
20
XIII
DMSO
18crown-6
113 (3)
1.5231
80
1.1832
2.4.4 5-Nonylene-1,2,4-trioxolane 1,2,4-Trioxolanes are the main products at the ozonolysis of olefins [1, 2]. In contrast to peroxides [100], and 1,2,3,4-tetraoxolanes their thermal properties have not been thoroughly investigated. The synthesis of 5-nonylene-1,3,4-trioxalane-1-deceneozonide was accomplished by ozonation of 10 ml solution of 0.5 M 1-decene at a temperature of –70 oC [25]. The yields of the ozonide was 60%. Its structure is: Its thermal properties were investigated by means of differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). A highly intensive exothermal peak with maximum (Tm) in the range of
127
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 110-130 oC was observed on the thermogram of 1-decene ozonide. It has been found that this peak depends on the heating rate. The analysis of the thermogram data are presented in Table 2.18.
Table 2.18 DSC analysis of the thermal decomposition of 1-decene ozonide Heating (oC/min)
Tm (K)
$H (kJ/mol)
Ea (kJ/mol)
n
o
3
110 C
341
129
1.02
5
117 oC
349
127
0.98
10
122 oC
353
131
1.01
15
128 oC
345
129
0.99
o
0
130 C
347
128
0.98
Average value
-
349 p 9
129 p 4
1 p 0.06
Note: $H, Ea and n are the enthalpy, the activation energy of decomposition and the order of the reaction, respectively.
It is seen that $H for the ozonide is 349 kJ/mol which is about 62% higher that the respective value for dicumene peroxide - 215 kJ/mol [110] (Table 2.19).
Table 2.19 Activation parameters of the reaction of thermal decomposition of organic peroxides Substrate
Ea (kJ/mol)
log A
Reference
RO-OR
155 p 5
15.3 p 0.5
[115-118]
Cumene-DPO
140 p 8
-
[101]
Acetone-DPO
153 p 5
13.8 p 1.1
[101]
Benzoil-DPO
128
-
[101]
Pynacoline-DPO
128
12.6 p 1.3
[101]
Ethylene-ozonide
115.1
13.6
[105]
Hexene-1-ozonide
99.2
10.8
[105]
Heptene-1-ozonide
95.4
10.2
[105]
Note: R = Me, Et, n-Pr, i-Pr, sec-Bu, t-Bu radicals; PO = peroxide; DPO = diperoxide.
128
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds A modified version of the method of Ellerstein [110] is used to determine the values of the activation energy and the kinetic order of the reaction. Calculations were made according to Equation 2.3 proposed by Crane and co-workers [111]. T2(S/h) = (Ea/R) – nT2(h/r)
(2.3)
where S = dH2/dT2, h = dH/Jdt = dH/dT, r = $H-Hp(T), $H is the total enthalpy of the reaction, Hp(T) is the partial enthalpy evolved up to T, t is the reaction time, J is the heating rate. From the linear plot in coordinates of Equation 2.4 (correlation coefficient of 96%) the values of Ea and n were determined form its intercept and slope, respectively. The Kissinger relationship between the peak maximum temperature (Tm) and Ea for data obtained at different heating rates was used as an alternative method for Ea determination [112, 113]: d(lnJ)/d(1/Tm) = -Ea/R - 2Tm
(2.4)
In this case the plot in coordinates J/(1/Tm) gives a straight line with a slope Ea/R when Ea/R>> 2Tm. The value of Ea was determined as 132 kJ/mol with a correlation coefficient of 0.999. Taking into account the first-order kinetics of the thermal decomposition of 1-decene, the value of A in the Arrhenius equation was calculated from the following expression (Equation 2.5) [114]: A = Ea.J.n.(RTm2)-1.exp(Ea/RTm),
(2.5)
according to which A = 1.7 × 1015 s-1. Thus the Arrhenius equation for the thermal decomposition reaction of 1-decene can be written as shown in Equation 2.6: k = 1.7.1015.exp(-129000/RT), s-1
(2.6)
The thermal data allows analysis of the scheme for the decomposition of the ozonides: O
O
A CH2
C8H17CH2 O
O
C8H17CH2
O
CH2 . O
O
O
CH2
B C8H17CH2 +
+
O
.
129
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds Kinetic data on the thermolysis of three different classes of peroxide compounds are summarised in Table 2.19. It is known that the homolytic scission of the peroxide bond [59, 64, 65] is the rate-limiting step in the thermal decomposition of dialkylperoxide and ketodiperoxides. In the case of 1,2,4-trioxalanes, it has been reported that they can decompose through a synchronous step along the ether and peroxide C-O bonds yielding carbonyloxide and carbonyl compounds [66, 67]. One of the arguments in favour of this suggestion (route B) is the lower values of Ea and A for ozonides than those for peroxides. However, the proximity of the Ea and A values of 1-decene ozonide with those of alkyl peroxides agree with the hypothesis of homolytic decomposition (route A). Thus it can be concluded that depending on the conditions and ozonide type either of the two possible routes for the decomposition reaction can dominate, but are always in a dynamic equilibrium.
2.5 Ethers Investigations of ozone reactions with ethers began as early as the last century [119123]. Results of these studied are summarised and reported by Bailley in his review [74]. The main products formed during ozonolysis of aliphatic ethers are alcohols, aldehydes, esters, acids, HTO, hydrogen and organic peroxides, singlet oxygen and water. Price and co-workers [125] propose the so-called ‘insertion’ mechanism, according to which ozone is inserted into the A-C-H bonds at the first step through a 1,3-dipolar addition, thus forming unstable HTO. This mechanism was also supported by the data of Erickson and Bakalik [126], Bailey [2] and Stary and co-workers [126] who measured the activation parameters of the decomposition of a series of HTO obtained by the ozonolysis of some ethers. Giamalva and co-workers [127] summarised the possible mechanisms known to date, i.e., interaction with the ether oxygen atom, 1,3dipolar insertion of ozone into the A-C-H bonds, homolytic abstraction of the A-H atom and heterolytic abstraction with carboanion and carbocation formation. These authors clearly indicate the predominance of the one-step mechanisms with transfer of a hydrogen atom, hydride anion or cation. As was mentioned above the low-temperature ozonolysis of ethers yields HTO which however are stable at very low temperatures. At normal temperatures the composition of the products is found to be different from that at the decomposition of HTO. These two reasons led us to carry out extended studies on the ozone reaction with ethers in order to establish the real mechanism of these reactions at normal temperatures. It was found from Figure 2.7 that the kinetic constant of diethyl ether (DEE) ozonation at –5 oC is 0.9 M-1.s-1 and the stoichiometric coefficient is 1. The calculated stoichiometric coefficient of the ozonation reaction with other ethers was also unity. The kinetics of ozonolysis was studied with the example of
130
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds n-dibutylether (DBE). The kinetic curves of the reaction product formation and the initial ether consumption are shown in Figure 2.8
1.2 [O3]0
A 1.0
[O3].104, M
0.8 0.6 [O3]t B
0.4
C 0.2 0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Time, min
Figure 2.7 Kinetic curve of ozone concentration at the reactor outlet 10 ml, 92 mM DEE at –5 oC
0.10
DBE n-BuOH
0.08
[P], M
0.06
n-PrCHO
0.04
0.02 n-PrC(O)O-n-Bu
0.00 0
5
10
15
20
Time, min
Figure 2.8 Kinetics of product formation and consumption of DBE during ozonolysis at ambient temperature, [O3]o = 2.34 × 10-4 M
131
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The following products were identified by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry in the reaction mixture after 10 minutes: 130 * 57 41 87 56 55 101 39 130 43 45 * n-dibutylether, 74 * 56 41 43 42 55 39 57 45 40 41 * n-butanol, 72 * 44 43 41 72 57 42 38 37 40 71 * butanal, 88 * 60 73 41 42 43 45 39 55 61 88 * butyric acid; 144 * 71 89 56 43 41 57 60 73 55 42 * butyl butyrate and 164 *& 247 * - chloro-containing compounds like: CH3(CH2)2CH(Cl)O(CH2)3CH3 (Mw 164.4) and CH3(CH2)2CH(CCl3)O(CH2)3CH3 (Mw 247) The rate of DBE decomposition (7.4 ×10-5 M/s-1 determined from Figure 2.8) is almost equal to the sum of butanal (6.5 × 10-5 M/s-1), butanol (6.71 × 10-5 M/s-1) and butyl butyrate (1.0 × 10-5 M/s-1) formation rates. The kinetic curves of butanol and butanal formation have almost the same slope and they start without any induction period. This could mean that they are formed in parallel reactions from a common precursor. The rate of butylbutyrate accumulation, as demonstrated by its kinetic curve, is approximately 7 times lower, thus indicating its formation in a parallel reaction to butanol (butanal) formation, most probably from the same precursor. The ratio product amount:initial DBE after 10 minutes is found to be 1:1. This means that the share of the auto-oxidation process is negligible although we have identified some butyric acid by its IR spectrum (1765 cm-1 (monomer) and E = 1470 M-1.cm-1) resulting from the butanal oxidation. The possible existence of a common precursor raises the question about its nature. Such a precursor could be either A-hydroxyether (EOH) or A-hydrotrioxyether (EOOOH) which through intermolecular disproportionation can further produce simultaneously aldehyde and alcohol: CH3(CH2)2-HC
O-(CH2)3CH3
CH3(CH2)2CHO +
CH3(CH2)2CH2OH
(2)
H
O O
CH3(CH2)2-HC O
132
-O2
O
O-(CH2)3CH3 H
CH3(CH2)2CHO +
CH3(CH2)2CH2OH (2')
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds Probably, the intermolecular reaction of EOOOH disproportionation is preferable, because of the six-member ring transition state, while EOH disproportionation occurs via a strained four-member-ring transition state, which is energetically unfavourable. If EOH is assumed to be the precursor, then butylbutyrate should be the major reaction product as a result of the rapid oxidation of EOH by ozone: O O
O
H
H
CH3(CH2)2C
O
-H2O, -O2
CH3(CH2)2C(O)O(CH2)3CH3
(3')
O(CH2)CH3
which is not observed experimentally. When EOH is assumed to be a precursor, it is difficult to imagine its one-step transformation into an ester without any additional assumptions. The solvent, CCl4, could not also affect this transformation bearing in mind its weak oxidising properties and nonspecificity. The formation of the ester from EOOOH in one step can be easily presented through a four-member ring transition state: H H
O
CH3(CH2)2C
O
O -H2O2 CH3(CH2)2C(O)O(CH2)3CH3 (3)
O(CH2)CH3
The formation of four-member transition state will be more unfavourable than the six-member transition state. This conclusion is in agreement with the kinetic data, namely, the rate of ester formation is approximately 7 times lower than that of alcohol and aldehyde formation. Direct evidence for EOOOH formation was found only after prolonged ozonation for 24 h at –78 oC [129]. The NMR spectrum of the oxidate has a signal at D = 13.52 ppm, which is attributed to OOOH. The order of the reaction in [DBE] and [O3] is unity (Figure 2.9) and the rate law can be written as W = k × [DBE][O3]. Based on the results discussed above, a scheme of the ozone reaction with aliphatic ethers is proposed in Scheme 2.5.
133
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds Ether + O3 m EOOOH
(k1)
EOOOH m Alcohol + Aldehyde + O2
(k2)
EOOOH m Ester + H2O2
(k3) Scheme 2.5
12 10 10 8 8
1
6
6
4
4
2
2
2
0
0 0
1
2
3 5
4
5
6
-1
W0.10 , M.s
Figure 2.9 Dependence of the reaction rate of DBE ozonation (21 oC) on the concentration of ozone (1) at [DBE] = 10 mM and DBE (2) at [O3] = 0.1 mM
The formation of chlorine-containing compounds (1-2%) can be explained by the presence of radical intermediates in the reaction mixture. This means that EOOOH will also decompose via the radical route: EOOOH m EOv + vO2H
(k4)
EOv + EH m EOH + Ev
(k5)
Ev + O2 m EO2v
(kpa)
134
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds Ev + CCl4 m ECl + CCl3v
(kpa)
EO2v + EH m EOOH + Ev
(kp)
Ev + CCl3v m ECCl3
(kta)
2EO2v m nonradical products
(kt)
The validity of the mechanism indicated above was confirmed by the good agreement between the experimental points on the DBE decomposition curve, and product accumulation and the theoretical curves calculated according to the scheme and given in Figure 2.8. For example, the curve describing the DBE consumption is obtained from Equation 2.7: [DBE]t = [DBE]0.exp(-kat)
(2.7)
where ka is the constant measured by the stop-flow method - 1.26 ×10-3 s-1, the corresponding bimolecular constant is 6.3 M-1.s-1.
2.5.1 Application of the ERM In order to elucidate the intimate mechanism of ozone interaction with ethers we have applied the experimentally theoretical approach developed by us which was described in Chapter 1. It is based on a comparison of the experimental and calculated values of A assuming linear (LC) and cyclic (CC) forms of the activated complex (AC). The kinetic constants of ozone reaction with diethylether (DEE), dichlorodiethylether (DClDEE), di-iso-propylether (i-PrE), di-n-butylether (n-ButE), di-iso-amylether (i-AmE) and di-n-amylether (n-AmE) in CCl4 are given in Table 2.20. The rate constants for DEE, n-ButE, i-AmE and n-AmE have similar values. All these ethers have close A-C-H bond energies and similar electronic environment. The value of the rate constant for i-PrE ozonation is also close to those mentioned above, while the constant for DClDEE is 100 times lower value. In DIPE the presence of tert-C-H bonds, according to our discussion in Chapter 1, should contribute to their higher reactivity because of the lower energy of these bonds. The presence of oxygen, however, and the more difficult stabilisation of the transition state due to steric factors, makes this interaction slower. The very low rate constant of DClDEE ozonation can be attributed to the strong electron-accepting properties of the chlorine atom. Arrhenius parameters calculated on the basis of the data in Table 2.20 are summarised in Table 2.21.
135
136 -
-
-
-
-
i-PrE
n-ButE
i-AmE
n-AmE 2.2
1.9
1.9
1.6
0.009
1.0
–5 oC
2.8
2.5
2.1
1.9
0.016
1.2
3.5 oC
-
-
-
-
-
1.6
4 oC
-
-
-
-
-
2.2
10 oC
4.2
4.1
4.3
3.4
0.028
2.4
13 oC
3.1/3.0
21 oC
7.8/7.5
7.8/7.0
6.3/6.3
5.4/5.1
0.035/0.04
Note: In column 9, after the solidus the values of the constants determined by stop-flow method are given.
-
0.9
0.5
-
–6 oC
–15 oC
DClDEE
DEE
Ether
Table 2.20 Rate constants of ozonation of ethers at various temperatures (oC) k p 5% M-1.s-1
-
-
-
-
-
3.6
24 oC
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds Comparison of the data obtained with reference data shows a good coincidence in relation to the values of the rate constants at 21 oC. Only a slight difference in the activation energies was observed. Perhaps, it is the heat of ozone dissolution in CCl4 that needs to be taken into account as the reason for these differences.
Table 2.21 Arrhenius parameters of ozone reaction with some aliphatic ethers k (M-1.s-1)
log A
Ea (kcal/mol)
3.1
6.4 (7.3)
7.9 (9.9)
0.035
4.9 (5.5)
8.5 (10.1)
5.4
6.3 (7.9)
7.6 (10.0)
n-ButE
6.3 (6.0)
6.6 (7.4)
7.8 (9.7)
i-AmE
6.8
6.6
7.8
n-AmE
7.8
6.5
7.6
THydP
(1.3)
(6.8)
(9.7)
THydF
(12.3)
(6.6)
(8.2)
Ether DEE DClDEE i-PrE
Note: The values in brackets are taken from reference [79]; THydP and THydF are tetrahydropyrane and tetrahydrofurane, respectively.
All literature reaction schemes describing the ozonation of ethers proceed by two geometric forms of the activated complex - LC and CC: R' R' R
C OR"
H
+
O3
R
R'
O3 C
H
R"O
or
R
C
# H...O3
OR" CC
LC
The CC has a more compact structure, without any possibility for free rotation. It can be a transition state for the following reaction: EH + O3 m EOOOH m products
(a)
where EOOOH if formed in one step via 1,3-dipolar insertion.
137
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The LC structure is an open one, allowing free rotation around H-O and O-O bonds. LC can be a transition state for the reactions: EH + O3 m Ev + HO3v m EOOOH m products
(b)
EH + O3 m E+ + HO3 m EOOOH m products
(c)
in which an H atom or hydride anion abstraction occurs and EOOOH is formed during the second step. The necessary parameters for estimating the A values are presented in Table 2.22.
Table 2.22 Heats of formation ($H) in kcal of initial, intermediate and final products, van der Waals radii of the ethers and free rotation energy (Efr) around H-O bond Ether
r (Å)
$H, EH
$H, EOOOH
$H, Ev
$H, E+
Ea (kcal/mol)
DEE
3.18
–68
–66
–32
135
1.3
DClDEE
3.51
–74
–73
–41
132
2.2
i-PrE
3.48
–76
–74
–42
125
1.4
n-ButE
4.03
–81
–79
–47
120
1.3
i-AmE
4.31
–87
–86
–53
115
1.3
n-AmE
4.45
–86
–85
–51
116
1.3
The calculated values of A are shown in Table 2.23. The good agreement between the calculated and experimental values for A confirms the conclusion that the geometry of the transition state is a linear (LC) and abstraction mechanisms (a) and (c) seem more probable. In order to evaluate which mechanism occurs we used the thermodynamic parameters shown in Table 2.22. The calculated heats of formation of the individual compounds fit well to the experimentally measured values [36, 37, 51, 66]. Using different expressions for the Hamiltonians, we have obtained the following values for $H: O3 –33.3 kcal against data from the literature of (34.1); HOOOH –17.8 (–17.1); HOOO –9.2 (–17.8); HOOO –20.3 (–24.9); HO –5.2 (–25.8) [66].
138
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
$H = –$H (EH) – $H (O3) + $H (EOOOH)
(a)
$H = –$H (EH) – $H (O3) + $H (Ev) + $H (HO3v)
(b)
$H = –$H (EH) – $H (O3) + $H (Å+) + $H (HO3 ) – e2/rip – Es
(c)
where e2/rip = 5.4 eV and Ea = 17 kcal for tetrachloromethane were taken from reference [66].
Table 2.23 The calculated pre-exponents (A) and steric factors (p) log A, CT
log A, CC
log A, LC
p × 106, CC
p × 106, LC
AcalcLC/ Aexp
DEE
11.66
4.02
6.40
0.02
5.5
1
DClDEE
11.66
3.62
4.99
0.009
0.2
1.23
i-PrE
11.67
4.28
6.35
0.04
4.8
0.91
n-ButE
11.72
3.99
6.09
0.02
2.3
0.31
i-AmE
11.75
3.90
6.00
0.01
1.8
0.25
n-AmE
11.74
3.77
5.87
0.01
1.3
0.23
Ether
Note: the values of A in columns 3 and 4 are per one equivalent A-C-H atom.
The calculated values for $H are shown in Table 2.24.
Table 2.24 Calculated heats of investigated reactions according to mechanisms a, b and c Ether
a (kcal/mol)
b (kcal/mol)
c (kcal/mol)
DEE
–32
–16
0
DClDEE
–33
–19
6
i-PrE
–32
–18
1
n-ButE
–32
–18
1
i-AmE
–32
–18
2
n-AmE
–33
–17
2
From thermodynamic point of view, (a) is the preferred mechanism and out of (b) and (c), (b) is more likely.
139
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
2.6 Hydroxybenzenes The reaction of ozone with mono- and dihydroxybenzenes has provoked a particular interest [1, 2, 129-132], namely, because of its great importance for environment protection, chemical stabilisation and the theory of reactivity. The ozonation of phenol, pyrocatechol, resorcinol and hydroquinone has been studied in different solvents - aqueous and organic, aimed at the elaboration of the kinetic parameters and product composition [133-139]. The rate constants at room temperature of phenol and resorcinol ozonation in water are 1.3 × 103 M-1.s-1 and >3 × 105 M-1.s-1, respectively, whereas the rate constants of benzene, toluene and anisole ozonation in organic media are 2, 14 and 2.9 × 102 M-1.s-1 [129]. Gurol and co-workers [130] found that the relative rates of pyrocatechol/phenol and resorcinol/phenol ozonation in water medium are 220 and 70, respectively. Provided that the rate constant of phenol ozonation is known [129], the calculated values of the rate constants of pyrocatechol and resorcinol ozonation are 2.86 × 105 M-1.s-1 and 9.1 × 104 M-1.s-1, respectively. However, if the reaction is carried out in organic solvents the values are quite different. For example, in CCl4 and at room temperature the following values have been obtained for: benzene - 0.06, ethylbenzene - 0.2, anisole - 1.1, phenol - 230 and pyrocatechol - 3.2 × 103 M-1.s-1 [136-139]. One of the possible explanations for the different values of the rate constants of hydroxyphenol ozonation obtained by the various researchers could be the great influence of the water on this reaction, for example for phenol they vary in the range 100-180 M-1.s-1, 500 M-1.s-1 for pyrocatechol and 300 M-1.s-1 for 3,6-di-tert-butylpyrocatechol. Pryor and co-workers [128] have reported that the rate constants of ozone reaction with A-tocopherol in CCl4 and water are 5.5 × 103 M-1.s-1 and 1 × 106 M-1.s-1, with A-tocopherol acetate - 1.45 × 102 M-1.s-1 and that with A-tocopherolquinone it is 1.15 × 104 M-1.s-1. Product analysis of pyrocatechol ozonation in aqueous medium shows that 3 moles of ozone are readily absorbed to give CO2 (24.8%), CO (6%), formic acid (32.5%) and glyoxal (4.2%). As CO2 and formic acid are the main reaction products, it seems very likely that most of the pyrocatechol undergoes anomalous ozonolysis [135]. Radical formation was observed during 2,6-di-tert-butylphenol ozonolysis. When the ratio of absorbed ozone to phenol is 0.8, 50% viscous yellow oil and 3,5, 2,6-di-tert-butyl-o-quinone were identified in the products [138]. In 3,6-di-tertbutyl-pyrocatechol ozonation the corresponding quinone was found to be the main product after complete consumption of the initial substrate [139]. Side products like 2,5-di-tert-butyl-, 3-hydroxy-p-quinone and 3,6-di-tert-butyl-1,2-phenylacetal5-hydroxy-3,6-di-tert-butyl-p-benzophenone were also found. The rate constant of this reaction amounts to 3 × 102 M-1.s-1. The same constant with the corresponding pyrocatechol with O-hydroxy-acetylated groups is estimated to be a two orders of magnitude lower value. A mechanism has been suggested to involve the formation of either a 1,3-cyclic activated complex between two hydrogen atoms from the OH
140
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds groups and one ozone molecule or P- or S-complexes with the benzene ring. The different values of the literature constants and the various mechanisms proposed for this reaction testify the necessity of further research of its kinetics and reaction pathway. In this connection we have studied the ozonolysis of the following hydroxybenzenes (Scheme 2.6): t-Bu t-Bu
OH
t-Bu
(II)
OH t-Bu
(III)
t-Bu O
O
O
O
t-Bu
t-Bu
(V)
S=O
O
O
O
O CHPh
CH2
C(CH3)
t-Bu
(IV)
t-Bu
t-Bu
t-Bu
OH
OH
OH
OH (I)
t-Bu
OH
OH
(VI)
t-Bu
(VII)
(VIII)
t-Bu
t-Bu O
O P O
HO t-Bu
t-Bu (IX)
Scheme 2.6 The probable mechanisms of ozone interaction with dihydroxybenzenes are presented in Scheme 2.7: OH R
TS
+ O3
PRODUCTS
OH H
TS
OH O +
R
O
#
H OH
O
H O
CC OOOH OH
C
R
R
OH
OH
O
A
H O O
LC-I O3
O R OH
LC-II
R
LC-I, CC
#
O
R
OH
TS
O
O
O
O-
OH A
B R
LC-II
O
O
O
O OH
Ozonide
O3 O R O
#
O CX 2 + O 3
R
CX2
D
Ozonides
O S or P-complex
Scheme 2.7
141
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds Mechanism A with a cyclic complex (CC) formation in the transition state was suggested by Konstantinova and co-workers [139]. Mechanism B with linear complex LC-II in the transition state was suggested and discussed by Bailey [2]. The interaction of ozone with C-H bonds with the formation of trioxide [127] as a possible parallel reaction is indicated in mechanism C. The acetylated forms of dihydroxybenzenes can react only via attack on the benzene ring according to mechanism D or C. Formally, mechanism D can be regarded as an extended version of mechanism B, involving the formation of TS similar to P- or S-complexes. We suggest a new mechanism, an extended version of the Razumovskii mechanism whereby the transition state is linear with LC-I structure. Upon ozonation of any of the investigated catechols directly in the electron spin resonance cell or after freezing the reaction products in liquid nitrogen no signals were detected. The kinetic curve of the change of ozone concentration at the bubbling reactor outlet (Figure 2.10, curve 1) is characterised by three different regions: AB - fast ozone consumption after the addition of pyrocatechol, BC - steady-state part when the rate of the chemical reaction becomes equal to the rate of ozone supply, and CD - ozone concentration begins to rise due to the pyrocatechol consumption. The BC part of the curve allows calculation of the rate constant, and from the area below the curve ABCD - the stoichiometry of the reaction. The straight line designated {O3}0 is the ozone concentration at the reactor inlet. Curve 2 presents the o-quinone formation with the reaction time. Its profile suggests the intermediate formation of o-quinone. The kinetic curves of the product formation in pyrocatechol ozonolysis, its consumption and o-quinone consumption during its ozonation in a separate experiment are given in Figure 2.11. Calculated from the kinetic curves in Figure 2.11, rate constants of pyrocatechol and o-quinone consumption were 3.2 × 104 M-1.s-1 and 7.1 × 104 M-1.s-1, respectively. The initial rate of o-quinone formation had almost the same value as that of pyrocatechol consumption. The small variation of the constants is due to the participation of pyrocatechol in parallel reactions. Actually, during the reaction small amounts of open-chain products were identified. Pyrocatechol ozonation at 15% conversion gave the following yields: o-quinone 85%, pyrogallol - 3%, ozonide - 10%, muconic acid -2%, maleic acid and fumaric acids and polymer products - 1%. The ratio between the amount of absorbed ozone and the consumed pyrocatechol was calculated as 6. Similar ratio values were obtained for the other hydroxybenzenes with free hydroxy groups.
142
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
12
[O3]0 10
D
A
1
8 6 4 2
B
C
0
2 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
Time, min
Figure 2.10 Kinetic curves of ozone absorption at reactor outlet (1) and o-quinone accumulation (2), at ambient temperature, [PC] = 0.227 mM in CCl4 (10 ml) during bubbling of ozone with 0.1 l/min flow rate
1. 0
1
0. 8 0. 6
3
0. 4
2
0. 2 0. 0 0
50
100
150
200
Time, s
Figure 2.11 Kinetics of pyrocatechol consumption (1), o-quinone accumulation (2) and o-quinine consumption (3), ambient temperature, [O3] = 1 × 10-5 M
143
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds It was found that with the increase of the conversion from 0 to 100% the amount of open-chain products continuously increases while that of the remaining products passes through a maximum. The individual compounds identified by 13C-NMR are: muconic semialdehyde and acid - 20%, maleic and fumaric semialdehyde and acid - 40%, glyoxal, formic acid, oxalic acid, carbon dioxide and polymer products - 40%. The reaction rate of dihydroxybenzene ozonation follows first-order kinetics in relation to each reagent (Figure 2.12, A and B). Table 2.25 presents experimental kinetic data on the ozonation of the investigated dihydroxybenzenes at various temperatures.
Table 2.25 Kinetic data of dihydroxybenzene ozonolysis in CCl4, 20 oC Substrate
k (M-1.s-1)
log A
Ea (kcal/mol)
I
3230
5.35
2.5
II
3100
4.91
1.9
III
3100
5.07
2.1
IV
3200
4.80
1.7
V
500
7.14
6.0
VI
749
7.17
5.8
VII
828
7.06
5.6
VIII
598
6.84
5.5
IX
111
6.81
6.4
Benzene
0.06
8.32
12.8
Toluene
0.40
7.05
10.3
Anisole
10
-
-
Phenol
160
7.31
7.0
A drastic difference between the values of the kinetic parameters of catechols I-IV and V-IX in which the OH groups are acetylated is observed. The rate constants of catechols I-IV manifested 4-28 times higher values than those of catechols of V-IX. On the other hand the pre-exponentials demonstrated by about two orders of magnitude lower values with the former compounds. The activation energies are 2.05 ± 0.5 and 5.9 ± 0.5 kcal/mol, respectively, or the acetylation of the HO groups leads to an increase in EA by about 4 kcal. Probably, ozone reacts predominantly with the hydrogen atoms of the HO groups and, to a very small extent, with the benzene
144
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds ring. The ratio of these ozone interactions varies from 94:4 to 80:20 depending on the hydroxybenzene nature. The lower activation energies of catechols I-IV with respect to those of V-IX are more consistent with the formation of an activated complex of contact type in the transition state, i.e., with structure LC-I (Scheme 2.7). This assumption could also be confirmed by analysis of the kinetic parameters of the ozonation of anisole, benzenes, phenol and toluene. The reaction of ozone with benzene proceeds with a low specific rate of 0.06 M-1.s-1 and relatively high activation energy equal to 12.8 kcal/mol. The methyl derivatives of benzene, i.e., toluene, reacts 6.7 times faster and the Ea is decreased by 2.5 kcal/mol, and the rate of anizol ozonation is even higher - 10 M-1.s-1. The exchange of ketyl group by a hydroxyl one leads to significant acceleration of the ozonation rate and approaches values of 160 M-1.s-1, and the activation energy is reduced by 5.8 kcal/mol. Probably, in this case the mechanism of the reaction is changed and ozone interacts predominantly with the hydrogen atoms of the OH groups. The decrease in the reactivity of anisole compared with that of phenol (^16 times) supports this assumption.
12
A
W0.105, M.s -1
10 8 6 4 2 0 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
[O3]t.105, M 3.0
B
2.5
W0 / [O3]t, s -1
2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 0
2
4
6
8
[P].104, M
Figure 2.12 Dependence of the rate of pyrocatechol ozonation on the concentration of ozone (a) and pyrocatechol (b)
145
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds Analysis of the kinetic parameters of catechols in acetylated form and those of benzene, toluene, anisole and phenol shows that the rate constants increase and the activation energies go down with increasing numbers of electron-donating substituents (Table 2.25). The high values of the pre-exponential factors could be associated with the high values of the energy of free rotation in the activated complex as a result of the steric hindrances caused by the presence of the bulky tert-butyl groups. This means that when the hydroxyl groups are acetylated, the activated complex should have a LC-II like structure and the ozonation would lead only to the formation of ozonides and open ring products. The kinetic parameters of some dihydroxybenzenes were determined in ozonation in aqueous medium (for those which are water soluble - I-IV, VIII and IX). However, we found that because of diffusion limitations in the bubbling reactor we were not able to measure constants higher than 1 × 104 M-1.s-1. In fact, the literature values for some of these constants are of this order, but they have been measured by a modified stop-flow technique [27]. The higher reactivity of dihydroxybenzenes in aqueous medium is connected with the change of the ozonation mechanism from a hidden radical to an ion one. However, this question requires special study and discussion. The analyses made so far show that the reaction path of the ozone reaction with dihydroxybenzenes depends strongly on their nature and it proceeds via a transition state with activated complex - LC-I or LC-II
2.6.1 Application of ERM For detailed analysis of the reaction mechanism of the ozone reaction with catechols we have used the ERM method. The necessary parameters for calculations are presented in Table 2.26. In addition, we calculated the heats of formation of pyrogallol - –117.6 kcal/mol (–129 kcal/mol [140]), 3-trihydroxy pyrocatechol - –59 kcal/mol, H2O3 - –21.2 kcal/ mol (–17.7 kcal/mol [140]) and ozone - 34.1 kcal/mol. Thus, the heats of the ozonation reaction according to the different mechanisms were calculated and are as follows: A - 33.1; B and D - 46.1 and C - 32.1 kcal/mol. All the mechanisms are exothermic and, therefore thermodynamically favourable. In this case only the magnitude of the activation energy and the entropy benefits will determine the reactivity of these compounds and the reaction pathway. Calculated pre-exponentials (Table 2.27) were compared with those obtained experimentally (Table 2.25) and it is seen that A have lower values (^10 times) for the cyclic form of
146
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds the activated complex if compared with the experimental values. At the same time the values of A for LC are about 200 times higher. The values of A for CC are the highest as predicted by the theory and they are lower than the experimental values. This suggests that the reaction takes place via a cyclic complex. The values of A calculated for LC in Table 2.27 were obtained without taking account of the energy of free rotation. The latter was calculated as a sum of the rotation around H-O and O-O axes (by MOPAC6) and amounts to 3.1 kcal. This means that the real values in column 4 are about 200 times smaller. The comparison between the A values corrected in this way and the experimental data for the compounds I-IV reveals full agreement.
Table 2.26 Symmetry numbers (S),van der Waals radii (r), heats of formation ($H) of dihydroxybenzenes and their corresponding quinones and ozonides Substrate
S
r (Å)
$H (kcal/mol)
$Hquinone (kcal/mol)
$Hozonide (kcal/mol)
I
2
3.02
–62 (–85)
–39 (–43)
–73
II
1
3.82
–88
–66
–99
III
2
4.46
–109
–86
–125
IV
1
4.39
–110
–90
–123
V
2
5.07
–116
–125
VI
2
4.56
–90
–103
VII
1
5.37
–63
–86
VIII
1
4.77
–73
–77
IX
1
5.30
–135
–140
Benzene
6
2.86
19 (13)
21
Toluene
1
3.37
12 (3)
11
Anisole
1
3.45
–16 (–26)
–20
Phenol
1
2.96
–21 (–38)
–24
Note: The experimental values are in brackets [140].
147
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds The reaction pathway of the ozonation reaction of compounds V-IX is quite different as the transition state includes the formation of a S or P-complex. For these compounds the formation of AC in the transition state is impeded due to the breaking of their aromatic character but simultaneously the free rotation is facilitated, which may be even zero, due to the action of the principle of the lowest energy. If the energy of free rotation is assumed to be very low then the values of A calculated for LC-II would coincide with the experimentally found ones. Such a coincidence is observed for compound V in column 5 (Table 2.27).
Table 2.27 Calculated pre-exponential values for ozone reaction with dihydroxybenzenes Substrate
log A
log A,
log A,
log A,
Acalc/
log p
TC
CC
LC
calc.
Aobs
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
I
11.318
4.346
7.69
5.39
1.10
5.928
II
11.422
3.905
7.25
4.95
1.10
6.472
III
11.500
4.070
7.42
5.12
1.12
6.380
IV
11.490
3.780
7.12
4.82
1.05
6.670
V
11.572
4.017
7.36
7.36
1.66
4.212
VI
11.511
4.056
7.40
7.40
1.70
4.102
VII
11.801
3.934
7.28
7.28
1.66
4.521
VIII
11.533
3.717
7.06
7.06
1.66
4.473
IX
11.575
3.689
6.88
6.88
1.10
4.695
Benzene
11.319
5.124
8.47
8.47-
1.41
2.849
Phenol
11.322
4.196
7.54
7.54
1.70
3.782
Note: p is the collision factor.
The basic conclusion for the analysis of the results obtained for this reaction is that the kinetics and mechanism of the ozonation reaction of dihydroxybenzenes depend strongly on their structure and the type of the reaction medium.
148
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
2.7 Carbohydrates and model compounds The selective oxidation of carbohydrates has received increasing attention in recent years [141-151]. This stems from interest in the transformation of carbohydrates to new valuable and ecologically friendly oxygen-containing compounds from available starting materials. Hence, a detailed clarification of the processes related to oxidation, the right choice of the catalysts and the definition of optimum conditions are of great importance [143, 145, 146, 148]. These reactions are invaluable for structure determination and transformation of polyhydrates and other natural products. The formation of two carboxylic groups alters significantly the carbohydrate (polymer) properties making it water soluble and imparting to it ion-acceptor properties. This polymer can be used for preparing new classes of detergents and ion-capture agents. The most interesting reaction is oxidative cleavage of C2-C3 bonds [147]:
OH
OH
O
O
-OOC
HO
-OOC
OH O
n
O
n
Formation of two carboxylic groups dramatically changes the properties of carbohydrates making them water soluble and they become ion capturers. If combined with hydroxylation of the double bond, the oxidation can be used as an alternative method for direct cleavage of double bonds by ozone [1, 2]. The oxidation of C2-C3 bond is accomplished by applying stoichiometric oxidants such as Pb(AcO)4 in organic solvents and HIO4 in aqueous media. Occasionally, other oxidising agents have been used such as ceric ammonium nitrate, sodium bismuthate, chromium trioxide and trivalent or pentavalent [152-161] iodine compounds. The mechanism of the C-C bond cleavage of vicinal diols with periodine acid can be represented as follows:
149
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds _
H
O
OH +
O I
O
_
O
O
I O
OH
O
O
OH
O A
_ + IO3 + H2O
O O
_
_
O O
O O
O
I O
O
OH I
+ H2O
O
OH
O
O O
_ + IO3
The cleavage of C-C bonds between two adjacent OH groups in the linear diols is a good source for aldehydes [162-164]. The efficiency and selectivity of the ozone reaction with C=C bonds in organic compounds is well known [1, 2]. Rate constants are of the order of 14-106 M-1.s-1, in contrast to 10-2-10 M-1.s-1 for the ozone reaction with C-H bonds. The rate determining step of the alcohol ozonolysis is the H-atom abstraction in the A position in relation to the OH group. The relative reactivity of the primary:secondary:tertiary alcohols with respect to ozone lies in the following sequence: 1:15:138 and corresponds to the C-H bond energies. The main products of alcohol ozonation are the corresponding aldehydes or ketones. The carbonyl compounds are in equilibrium with their enol forms which brings about their further decomposition via an ozone reaction with the C=C bond of the enol form according to Scheme 2.8. C
OH
O3
C
O
H+
C
OH
C
OH
-H2O; -O2
C
OH
HO-
C
OH
OH C
OH
O3
C
O
C
OH
H2O
C
O
OH
Scheme 2.8
150
+ H2O2
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds The monomer glucose unit contains the following A-hydrogen atoms: tert-C-H bond at C2 and C3 adjacent to the OH group; at C4 - adjacent to acetal group; at C1 - aldehyde hydrogen atom; at C5 -with alkyl substituents; and sec-C-H bond at C6. The energy of the aldehyde hydrogen atom is slightly lower than that of the tert-C-H bonds (difficult to determine the difference) and considerably lower than that of the sec-C-H bond. Obviously, the hydrogen atom in the aldehyde group will be the most reactive. Among the tert-C-H bonds those with higher electron density will be more reactive. They will be presented in the following order of decreasing reactivity: C5>C4>C3=C2. The sec-C-H bond at C6 appears to be the most inert in the ozonolysis reaction. The preliminary analysis reveals that ozone will attack predominantly the H atom at the C1 atom in starch with the formation of carboxylic groups and opening of the glucoside ring, and to a lesser extent, give rise to carbonyl compounds at the C5, C4, C3 and C2 atoms which can be easily converted to acids. However, a selective cleavage of the C2-C3 bond could not be expected to occur. Conventionally, the oxidation reactions of carbohydrates are carried out in an aqueous medium. It is known that the solubility of ozone in water is low and requires very good stirring. Moreover, at a pH above 7, ozone begins to react rapidly with the hydroxyl anions in the solution yielding HO radicals [129, 165-167]. The latter reduces the selectivity of the oxidation process (Scheme 2.9): HO2 O2 + H+
(1)
O3 + HO m HO2v (O2 ) + O2
(2)
O3 + (H+)O2 m (H+)O3 + O2
(3)
O3 + HOv m HO2v (O2 ) + O2
(4)
Initiation:
Propagation:
Termination: Any recombination between HOv, HO2v, O2
(t)
where (1) pKa= 4.8; (2) k2 = 48; 70 M-1.s-1. O3 + O2 m O3 + O2
(5)
151
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds O3 + H+ HO3v
(6)
HO3v m HOv + O2 ,
(7)
where k5 = 1.6 × 109 M-1.s-1; k6 = 5.2 × 1010 M-1.s-1, k-6 = 3.7 × 104 s-1; k7 = 1.1 × 105 s-1 Scheme 2.9 The study of this reaction is impeded by the low solubility of polymeric carbohydrates (starch) in water and in this connection we have used model compounds for elucidation of the reaction mechanism. The ozonolysis of methanol, ethanol, isopropanol and other alcohols proceeds via A-H-atom abstraction by ozone leading to the formation of a carbonyl group which is subsequently oxidised to a carboxylic one. It has been found that the ethanol ozonolysis is promoted by adding small amounts of hydroperoxide [168] because the steady concentration of the HO radicals is increased. Upon ozonolysis of isopropanol in an aqueous medium at pH 8, controlled by titration with NaOH, ambient temperature and 36% conversion, the following products in the high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) chromatogram were identified: acetone - 25%, AcAc - 6% and formic acid - 5% (Figure 2.13).
iso-Propanol
10
Ozone
[P], mM
8
6
4 Acetone 2 NaOH 0 0
20
40
60
80
Time, min
Figure 2.13 Kinetics of product formation during the ozone reaction with isopropanol at pH 8. The products were identified by means of HPLC and 13 C-NMR
152
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds The mechanism of the reaction could be expressed as shown in Scheme 2.10: (CH3)2C'OH + HO3' (HO' + O2)
(CH3)2CHOH + O3
-O2 (CH3)2C(OOOH)OH
(CH3)2C(OH)OH
-H2O
(CH3)2C(O')OH
-HO2'
(CH3)2CO CH3COOH + CH3'
Scheme 2.10
2.7.1 2,3-Butanediol Butanediol was oxidised in aqueous medium without pH control and at constant pH 10 and the main kinetic results are given in Figure 2.14.
25 Ozone
pH=10 20
[P], mM
15 NaOH Butandiol 10
5 Acetoin AcOH
0 0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Time, min
Figure 2.14 Kinetics of product formation during ozonolysis of 2,3-butanediol at pH 10. The products were identified by means of HPLC In the HPLC chromatogram of the starting material two peaks were recorded from the two stereoisomers. New peaks were found after ozonation: keto alcohol, acetoin,
153
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds AcAc, acetaldehyde, formaldehyde and formic acid. At higher conversions the peaks of the keto alcohol and acetoin disappeared whereas the peak from AcAc increased its intensity. The observed rate of butanediol consumption is higher than the sum of rates of product formation determined by HPLC. Probably at higher conversions of ozone the HO radicals oxidised the reaction products to carbon dioxide and water. In this connection calcium carbonate was found in the trap. The stoichiometry of the ozonation reaction with respect to ozone is unity and the rate constant of the reaction is 0.2 M-1.s-1. At low conversions up to 10-120% the main products of the reaction are acetoin and AcAc. It has been found that at pH 8 the rate of acetoin formation is lower than that without pH control. The scheme proposed for the ozonation reaction is shown in Scheme 2.11:
HO CH3
OH
C
C
H
H
HO
+ O3
HO C
CH3
CH3
HO
H
CH3
C
OH
O
OH
C
C
C
C
CH3
CH3
CH3 C O'
D
OH C
-H2O;-O2
O
O
C
C
CH3
C
H
CH3
+
'C
CH3
H
+RH F
B
F
G
G
Scheme 2.11
154
C
OH
O
E
C
E
CH3
CH3
OH
HOO
CH3
CH3
HO
-HO'
D
CH3
HO
H
-H2O2
+O3
C
H
D
HO
E
H
CH3
+ RH
O
A
C
'OO B
-H2O
-HO2'
CH3
OH
C
CH3
H
-H2O
H
HO
OH
A -O2
CH3 + HO3' + (HO', O2)
H
C
HOOO
OH C
C .
CH3
OH
C
CH3
HO CH3
+O3 CO2, HCHO, CH3CHO...
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
2.7.2 1,2-Cyclohexanediol A portion (100 ml) of 10 mM 1,2-cyclohexanediol was ozonised with stirring at ambient temperature. The pH of the medium was kept constant at 7, 8, 9 or 11. In the experiments without pH control its change was measured during the reaction duration. In all cases formation of keto alcohol, diketone and open-chain products was observed (Figure 2.15).
Figure 2.15 Initial rates of product consumption and formation upon 1,2cyclohexanediol ozonation (Sub) at various pH and without pH control (NC). The products cyclohexanol-2-on (KetAlc) and adipic acid (AdAc) were identified by HPLC and 13 C-NMR, and the total acid number by NaOH
Upon ozonolysis without pH control the main products were KetAlc and AdAc. The value of pH decreases rapidly at the beginning from 7 to 2.2. In the 13C-NMR spectra of the reaction mixture peaks were recorded at 179.5, 180.1 and 179.4 ppm which could be ascribed to adipic acid semialdehyde (179.5 and 179.4 ppm) and AdAc (180.1 ppm). Moreover, at conversions up to 20% other products with open chains like glutaric, succinic, malonic, AcAc and formic acid were also identified. The rate
155
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds of cyclohexanediol is found to be 2-3 times higher than the rate of ozone uptake, the latter corresponding to the sum of the rates of KetAlc and AdAc formation. This fact suggests that its decomposition occurs via another route. The ratio between the rate of formation of cyclic and open-chain products decreased from 2 to 0.5 with increasing pH from 4 to 11. Simultaneously the rate of alcohol consumption increases 4 times. When the pH was controlled from 7 to 11, the rate of consumption of NaOH and ozone corresponds to the rate of cyclohexanediol decomposition. In the NMR spectra the diversity of peaks corresponding to carboxylic carbons reaches its maximum at pH 11 and peaks at 167.8, 174.7, 184, 178.3 and 184.8 ppm were recorded. All of the above implies that the mechanism of cyclohexanediol ozonolysis in aqueous media is changed from stoichiometric A-C-H-atom abstraction in acidneutral media to a chain hydroxy-radical oxidation in alkaline media.
2.7.3 Mannitol and its derivatives The kinetics of product formation during the ozonolysis of mannitol and 1,2,5,6-diO-iso-propyl-mannitol:
HO
O
HO
O
HO
HO OH
OH
OH
O
OH
O
is shown in Figures 2.16 and 2.17. In the ozonation of mannitol at pH 7 the inner OH groups were converted to carbonyl groups or the C-C bonds broke leading to the formation of products with a reduced number of carbon atoms compared with that of the starting compound. For example, carbonyl and carboxylic compounds, CO2, H2O were obtained. The rate of ozone absorption and that of mannitol consumption coincide; the sum of the rate of acid formation and keto compounds is also close to these values.
156
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
3.0 pH=7
Mannitol 2.5
Ozone
2.0 1.5
[P], mM
3,4-C=O
1.0
NaOH
0.5 0.0 -20
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
Time, min
Figure 2.16 Kinetics of product formation during the ozone reaction with mannitol at pH 7. Products were identified by HPLC and 13C-NMR
7
NaOH
pH=4
6
[P], mM
5
Ozone
4 3 PM 2 Mannitol
1 0 -1 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Time, min
Figure 2.17 Kinetics of product accumulation during 1,2,5,6-O-di-isopropylmannitol ozonolysis. The products were identified by HPLC and 13C-NMR
The acetylation of the 1,2,5,6-OH groups at pH up to 7 causes hydrolysation of the compound thus obtaining mannitol and acetone (Figure 2.17). At pH above these values the selectivity of ozone interaction with the third and fourth A-H atom is increased.
157
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds If the ozonation (Scheme 2.12) was carried out without pH control the pH changes from 7 at the beginning to 2.8 at 20% conversion. A good correlation has been found between the rate of PM decomposition, ozone consumption and the rates of product (acetone, ketones and acids) formation. Ozonation at constant pH 4, kept constant through titration with 0.1 N NaOH, shows similar kinetic characteristics, i.e., monoketone at the third and fourth position is formed which is further converted into 3-4-diketone. It has been established that the rate of the reaction was accelerated by 4-5 times in an alkaline medium.
O
O
O O
O
O HO HO
+
O3
OOOH
-H2O
OH
-O2
OH
O OH
O O
O
O
O
O
A
.
O A
-HO2
OH
O HO
B
+ O
O O
;
A
-HO
B
+RH; -H2O2
;
A
+RH -H2O
B
Scheme 2.12 Ozonation of 1,2,5,6-O-di-iso-propylmannitol
2.7.4 A-D-Glucose In the ozonation of A-D-glucose it was found that firstly ozone attacks the H atom of the aldehyde group at the first C atom, and after that the H atoms of the tert-C-H bonds at C2, C3, C4 and C5. Upon ozonation without pH control, the values of pH changes from 7 to 2 in the course of the reaction (Figure 2.18). The yield of gluconic acid was 60% at 5% conversion (C1 signal at 177.2 ppm). The rest of products at this moment was about 40%: D-arabino-hexulose (C2 - 178.4 ppm), D-ribo-hexos3-ulose (C3 - 177.8 ppm), D-xylo-hexos-4-ulose (C4 - 176.9 ppm), D-xylo-hexos-5ulose (C5 - 176 ppm), D-gluco-hexodialdose (C6 - 175.9 ppm), oxalic (167.2 ppm) and formic acids. The pattern of product formation during glucose ozonolysis at pH from 7 to 9 was similar to that in an acid medium, but with a different ratio of product distribution. In that case the main product was gluconic acid reaching values up to 90-95% (Figure 2.19).
158
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
13
C NMR - 177.2, 167.2, 178.4, 177.8 ppm
10
10
D-glucose
8 pH
6
6 NaOH
4
2
pH
[P], mM
8
4
2 Gluconic acid
0
0 0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
Time, min
Figure 2.18 Kinetics of product formation during ozonolysis of D-glucose without pH control. Products were identified using HPLC and 13C-NMR 13
C NMR - 180.1, 173.0
pH=7
D-glucose
10
Ozone
[P], mM
8
6
NaOH
4
Gluconic acid
2
0 0
50
100
150
200
250
Time, min
Figure 2.19 Kinetics of product formation during the reaction of ozone with D-glucose at pH 7. Products were identified by means of HPLC and 13C-NMR
In an alkali medium sodium salts were formed and the peaks of the carboxylic carbon atoms were slightly shifted. The rate of the reaction rises 1.5-2 times compared with that in an acid medium. Among the other products, products were identified from the ozone attack on C2, C3, C4 and C5 - 177.4, 176.2, 174.7 and 172.6 ppm. Thus 159
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds analysing the results it can be assumed that ozone attacks all tert-C-H bonds in the glucose molecule with almost equal probability but the rate of cleavage depends on the energy bond and the electron density. The variations in pH change the rate of ozone interaction with the hydroxyl anions and thus changes the oxidation carrier species from ozone to hydroxyl radical.
2.7.5 A-D-Methyl-glucose The change of H in the hydroxyl group at C1 for a methyl group is used for protection of this group and for modelling of a part of the polymeric carbohydrate chain. From this point of view A-D-methyl-glucoside (MG) can be regarded as a suitable low molecular model for elaborating the reactivity and mechanism of ozonolysis. Figure 2.20 demonstrates a pattern of the ozone reaction with MG at pH 8. The reaction was carried out in an alkaline medium to prevent the hydrolysation of MG in acid medium and the transformation of the methoxy group to a hydroxyl one. It is seen that MG is almost quantitatively converted into glucose although the ozonation was carried out in an alkaline medium. This could be attributed to the occurrence of oxidative hydrolysation under the action of ozone. After this ozone and HO-radicals react with it yielding acids, identified by the 13C-NMR signals (Figure 2.20). We determined that the rate of MG decomposition is 3.4 × 10-7 M/s, the rate of acid groups accumulation as 3.12 × 10-7 M/s, the rate of ozone absorption 2.43 × 10-7 M/s and the initial rate of glucose formation as 1.9 × 107 M/s. 13
C NMR - 180.1, 172.5, 174.6 ppm
pH=8
6
NaOH
5 Ozone
[P], mM
4 3 -Me-D-glucoside
2 1
D-glucose
0 -50
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Time, min
Figure 2.20 Kinetics of product accumulation during A-D-methyl-glucoside at pH 8. The products were identified by HPLC and 13C-NMR 160
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds
2.7.6 B-Cyclodextrine and starch The ozonolysis of B-cyclodextrine and starch was carried out in solution and suspension and the kinetic results are presented in Figures 2.21 and 2.22.
13
C NMR - 172.4, 181.1, 179.8, 174.5, 177.1 ppm
16
pH=7
14
Ozone
12
[P], mM
10 8 6
NaOH
4 2 -cyclodextrine 0 -2 0
50
100
150
200
Time, min
Figure 2.21 Kinetics of product formation during ozone reaction with B-cyclodextrine at pH 7. Products were identified by HPLC and 13C-NMR
B-Cyclodextrine is an excellent model of polysaccharides that contains 10 glucoside units arranged in one cycle, in which the OH groups in the 1 and 4 position are blocked (acetylated). The OH groups at C2, C3 and C6 remain free. Upon ozonolysis of aqueous B-cyclodextrine solution at pH 7 its consumption rate amounts to 1.67 × 10-7 M/s. This value is almost equal to the rate of ozone consumption while the rate of titration by NaOH is found to be by about 25% of these rates. Ozone converts the B-cyclodextrine molecule into a linear one with formation of carboxylic groups. The latter were identified by the appearance of chemical shifts at 172.4, 181.1, 179.8, 174.5 and 177.1 ppm in their 13C-NMR spectra. The underlined values can be assigned to the carboxylic atoms at C2-C3 atoms. At ozonation of starch suspension (Figure 2.22), firstly it is oxidised and only after that does it dissolve. A series of peaks which could be ascribed to the carboxylic acid formation has been observed in the NMR spectra. A very good agreement was obtained between the rate of starch consumption, ozone uptake and rate of titration by NaOH.
161
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds
13
C NMR - 178.2, 177.4, 174.9, 172.6, 162.6 ppm
3.0 Starch
2.5
[P], mM
2.0 1.5 1.0 Ozone 0.5 NaOH 0.0 0
10
20
30
40
Time, min
Figure 2.22 Kinetics of product accumulation during starch ozonolysis at pH 7. Product identification was carried out using HPLC and 13C-NMR
The observation that the suspension is dissolved and the coincidence between the amount of absorbed ozone and the acid number of the oxidate suggest that the ozonation method can be used for transformation of natural polyhydrates to new valuable products. The mechanism of the reaction of ozone with model compounds (vicinal alcohols), as shown above, is based on the interaction between ozone and the A-H atom in the alcohol molecule, the cleavage of C-C bonds being a very rare and random process. The latter was observed during the monomolecular decomposition of oxy-radicals generated in the course of some of the conversion steps of intermediate products. The possibility of improving the selectivity of the C-C bond cleavage could be based on oxidation of carbohydrates using catalytic systems and specific reagents.
2.8 Catalytic ozonolysis and oxidation The selectivity of the C-C bond cleavage at vicinal OH groups is improved by applying specific reagents like RuO4 [29]. Usually Ru(VIII) is obtained in situ via Ru(III) oxidation by suitable oxidants, for example NaOCl in alkaline medium. After that RuO4 interacts with the alcohol forming a Ru-diol complex according to the following scheme (Scheme 2.13):
162
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds RuCl3 + 3NaOH Ru+3
+O3
Ru+3 + 3OH- + 3Na+ + 3Cl-
Ru+4
-O3-
+O3 -O2
Ru+6
+O3 -O2
Ru+8
O OH OH
-H2O + RuO4
H
O
H
O
Ru O
-RuO3
HO
O
+O3
HO
O
O
Scheme 2.13 Our idea was to use ozone instead of hypochloride. In this connection we have measured the rate constant of Ru(III) oxidation by ozone which at ambient temperature at pH 7 has the value of 15 M-1.s-1. Unfortunately, from a kinetic point of view this value is extremely low to compensate the rate of RuO4 interaction with the alcohol or carbohydrate and to ensure high Ru(VIII) concentration. Because of this, the ozonolysis was carried out in the following manner: the black solution of 1 wt%. RuCl3.H2O in 50 ml water was ozonised at pH 7 until it turned yellow (RuCl4). After that the substrate solution was added drop-wise. In this way all alcohols and carbohydrates mentioned above, were ozonised. AcAc was the main product of 2,3-butanediol ozonolysis (Figure 2.23).
NaOH
pH=8
20
15
Butanediol
Ozone
10
AcAc 5
0 0
75
150
225
300
Time, min
Figure 2.23 Kinetics of 2,3-butanediol ozonolysis (50 ml water), in the presence of 0.1 g RuCl3.H2O, ozone flow rate - 0.1 l/min and pH 8. Product identification was performed by HPLC and 13C-NMR 163
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds It is seen that (Figure 2.23) the initial rates (up to 90 minutes) of butanediol consumption, ozone absorption, AcAc formation and titration by NaOH are almost the same as shown by the equal slopes of the curves. However, after 90 minutes other products were also formed and the acidity of the reaction mixture begins to rise as shown by the sharp increase in the titration curve (by NaOH). Upon ozonolysis of 1,2-cyclohexanediol, mannitol and its derivatives via the method mentioned previously, a selective C-C bond cleavage between the vicinal HO groups with carboxylic group formation was observed only to 20-30% conversions. At higher conversions the number of products is increased, namely because of the occurrence of secondary processes. In the cases with straight-chain alcohols two monoacids are formed from one alcohol molecule and with cyclic alcohols - one dicarboxylic acid, for example adipic acid at 1,2-cyclohexanediol ozonolysis or 2,3-dicarboxylic acid at glucose (its derivatives) ozonolysis. When the oxidation was carried out at lower pH up to 6.5, a hydrolysis of the protected HO-groups takes place. Such an example is the ozonolysis of 1,2,5,6-di-O-mannitol at pH 6.5 (Figure 2.24).
13
C NMR - 174.7 ppm pH=6.5
5
NaOH 4 GlicAc
[P], mM
3
2
1
PM
0 0
20
40
60
80
Time, min
Figure 2.24 Kinetics of product formation during ozonolysis of 1,2,5,6-di-Omannitol in the presence of 1 wt%. RuCl3.H2O
The rate of glyceric acid formation (174.7 ppm) is almost the same as that of PM consumption but is found to be lower than the rate of NaOH titration. This could be associated only with the partial hydrolysation of PM and the formation of low molecular acids such as formic and acetic acids.
164
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds However, it should be noted that the carbohydrate oxidation by ozone and ruthenium has some shortcomings, such as the removal of ruthenium from the reaction mixture, its volatility, high toxicity and price. It is known that NaIO4, similar to Ru(VIII), can cause the selective C-C bond cleavage at the vicinal hydroxy groups with two carbonyl compound formation. Simultaneously it is reduced to NaIO3. The idea was to use ozone for reoxidation of iodate to periodate. Unfortunately, the rate of this process compared with that of reduction: IO4 + Substrate = IO3 + Products (very fast) IO3 + O3 = IO4 + O2 (slow) Products + O3 = Acids + O2 (fast) is not sufficiently high. This requires special conditions for performing ozonolysis: maximum iodate concentration and the absence of organic products in the ozonolysis medium. Such a situation could be achieved if the products of NaIO4 interaction with the substrate are oxidised and removed, and the ozonolysis proceeds further for the NaIO3 oxidation to NaIO4. The oxidation of 1,2-cyclohexanediol (10 ml) by an equimolar amount of NaIO4 under continuous stirring leads to the quantitative formation of adipic aldehyde which is further oxidised by ozone to semialdehyde and adipic acid. No oxidation of iodate to periodate was observed. The application of a number of heterogeneous catalysts Ag2O, Co(AcO)2, FeCl3, Pt/C, Pd/C, Adams catalyst, zeolite catalysts TS-1, microporous titanosilicate (ETAS) and catalysts synthesised by us on the basis of ion exchange: Ce with silicalite - Ce-Silic, Ce and Ru with alumophosphates - Ce-APO and Ru-APO and phthalocyanine (Pc) complexes: PtAu6Pc, PdAu6Pc and (manganese phthalocyanine) MnPc for the selective ozonation of alcohols, model compounds of saccharides and natural carbohydrates, in all cases accelerate the process but did not make the process selective with respect to C-C bond cleavage.
References 1. S.D. Razumovskii, S.K. Rakovski, D.M. Shopov and G.E. Zaikov, Ozone and Its Reactions with Organic Compounds, Publishing House of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, Bulgaria, 1983, p.1. [in Russian]
165
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 2. P.S. Bailey, Ozonisation in Organic Chemistry, Volume 2 - Nonolefinic Compounds, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA,1982, p.255. 3. E. Otal, D. Mantzavinos, M.V. Delga, R. Hellenbrand, J. Lebrato, I.S. Metcalf and A.G. Livingston, Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 1997, 70, 2, 147. 4. F.J. Benitez, J. Beltran-Heredia, J.L. Acero and M.L. Pinilla, Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 1997, 70, 3, 253. 5. L. Amalric, C. Guillard and P. Pichat, Research on Chemical Intermediates, 1995, 21, 1, 33. 6. E. Heinzle, H. Stockinger, M. Stern, M. Fahmy and O.M. Kut, Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 1995, 62, 3, 241. 7. F.J. Beltran, P.M. Alvarez, B. Legube and H. Allemane, Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 1995, 62, 3, 272. 8. M.J. Lee, H. Arai and T. Miyata, Chemistry Letters, 1994, 6, 1069. 9. E.M. Benko, V.V. Kovaleva, N.A. Mamleeva, A.N. Mitrofanova, V.A. Voblikova, A.N. Pryakhin and V.V. Lunin, Zhurnal Fisicheskoi Khimii, 1994, 68, 11, 1964. 10. Y.M. Artemev, M.A. Artemeva, M.G. Vinogradov and T.I. Ilika, Russian Journal of Applied Chemistry, 1994, 67, 9 (Part 2), 1354. 11. C. Scheuer, B. Wimmer, H. Bischof, L. Nguyen, J. Maguhn, P. Spitzauer, A. Kettrup and D. Wabner, Journal of Chromatography A, 1995, 706, 1-2, 253. 12. B. Hoger, E Gilbert and S.H. Eberle, Vom Wasser, 1993, 80, 187. 13. W. Ruck, Vom Wasser, 1993, 80, 253. 14. S. Gab, W.V. Turner, S. Wolff, K.H. Becker, L. Ruppert and K.J. Brockmann, Atmospheric Environment, 1995, 29, 18, 2401. 15. K. Takeuchi, C. Fushimi, K. Nakamura and T. Ibusuki, Bunseki Kagaku, 1993, 42, 10, 625. 16. G.Y. Pan, C.L. Chen, J.S. Gratzl and H.M. Chang, Research on Chemical Intermediates, 1995, 21, 3-5, 205. 17. H. Wada, T. Naoi and Y. Kuroda, Nippon Kagaku Kaishi, 1995, 4, 306.
166
Ozonolysis of oxygen-containing organic compounds 18. A. Marco, E. Chamarro and S. Esplugas, Afinidad, 1994, 51, 452. 18b. A. Marco, E. Chamarro and S. Esplugas, Afinidad, 1994, 51, 265. 19. J. Starek, A. Zukal and J. Rathousky, Carbon, 1994, 32, 2, 207. 20. S.K. Rakovsky and D.R. Cherneva, International Journal of Chemical Kinetics, 1990, 22, 4, 321. 21. S.K. Rakovsky, D.R. Cherneva, D.M. Shopov and S.D. Razumovskii, Communications of the Department of Chemistry - Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1976, 9, 4, 711. 22. S.K. Rakovsky and D.R. Cherneva, Oxidation Communications, 1989, 12, 3, 108. 23. S.K. Rakovsky, L.G. Kulak, E.M. Kuramshin, S.S. Zlotsky and D.L. Rakhmankulov, Communications of the Department of Chemistry Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1989, 22, 3, 722. 24. D.L. Rakhmankulov, S.S. Zlotsky, L.Z. Rudnik, G.T. Teregulova and S.K. Rakovsky, Communications of the Department of Chemistry - Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1989, 22, 3, 652. 25. M.P. Anachkov, S.K. Rakovsky, A.K. Stoyanov and R.K. Fotty, Thermochemica Acta, 1994, 237, 213. 26. S.K. Rakovsky, D.R. Cherneva and M. Deneva, International Journal of Chemical Kinetics, 1995, 27, 2, 153. 27. S.K. Rakovsky, D.R. Cherneva, M. Deneva and V.V. Ershov, Oxidation Communications, 1997, 20, 2, 169. 28. S.K. Rakovsky, R.A. Sheldon and F.V. Rantwijk, Oxidation Communications, 1996, 19, 4, 482. 29. E.T. Denisov, N.I. Mitskevich and V.E. Agabekov, Mechanism of LiquidPhase Oxidation of Oxygen Containing Compounds, Science and Technique Publishing House, Minsk, 1975. 30. M. Whiting, A. Bolt and J. Parish, Oxidation of Organic Compounds - III, Advances in Chemistry Series, No. 77, ACS, Washington, DC, USA, 1968, p.4.
167
Ozonation of Organic and Polymer Compounds 31. D. Williamson and R.J. Cvetanovich, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1970, 92, 2949. 32. A.Ya. Gerchikov, E.R. Kuznetzov and E.T. Denisov, Kinetika i Kataliz, 1970, 15, 109. 33. V.V. Shereshovetz, N. Shafikov and V.D. Komissarov, Kinetika i Kataliz, 1980, 21, 1596. 34. M. Waters and A. Rollin, Journal of Organic Chemistry, 1976, 42, 889. 35. S.K. Rakovsky, Kinetics and Mechanism of the Ozone Reactions with Paraffins in Liquid Phase, Institute of Chemical Physics, Academy of Science of the USSR, Moscow, 1975. [PhD Thesis] 36. Bond Energy, Ionisation Potential and Electron Affinity, Ed., V.N. Kondratiev, Nauka Publishers, Moscow, 1974, p.83. [in Russian] 37. A.J. G