This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
0 and lkl > E we have the estimates
lIFt+k(CP)vll,-j,(b) 5 C(~)IkI1--jeT~lmk~Il~ll~,a, For any c~ > 0 there
exist constants
O<j<m+l.
(9)
p and Ci such that for k E U,>p and any
j>O
ll&f - &+k(
5
Cl~ll-~eT’lmk~II~llo,a,
Then for
O<jlm+l.
(10) any (Y > 0
(11)
Theorems 3 and 4 contain the main technical load of this chapter. We will discuss the idea behind them. If condition C is fulfilled, then Theorem 4 is clearly a consequence of Theorem 3. If, however, condition C’ is fulfilled without condition C then a weaker variant of Theorem 3 is satisfied, and theorem 4 follows similarly. The estimates (9) are elementary. The main content of Theorem 3 is contained in the estimate (10). Since the function & is an exact solution of (2) for z E 6$,, and the difference between
B. R. Vainberg
62
problem yields the short-wave (I Re ICI --) oo) asymptotics of the solution of the corresponding stationary problem. The non-triviality of estimate (10) (and also the inaccuracy of the formulated heuristic statement, if conditions of the type A-D are not fulfilled) is connected with the fact that the Fourier transform of a smooth function need not decay at infinity (for example, w = et*). It is easy to check the assertion of Theorem 3 if we know the behavior of solutions of the non-stationary problem for 1x1 < b as t + co. Since nothing is known a priori about the behavior of solutions of (1) as t -+ 00, the proof of Theorem 3 is fairly difficult. Vice versa, it will be easy in the following sections to obtain the full asymptotic expansion of solutions of (1) for 1x1 < b as t --+ co from Theorems 3 and 4. Theorem 3 also yields the short-wave asymptotic expansion of solutions to the stationary problem in those cases when a parametrix of the non-stationary problem (that is, an operator differing from P by a smooth operator) is known. Concrete examples of this situation will be examined in the following parts. Remark. If for all s 2 0 we have, instead of estimate (3),
lll4ll~+~-l,Y 5 Csll~lls> then we may substitute
$2. The Expansion
s for m and --s for 0 in (lo),
s E Iw.
Long-wave Approximation and the Asymptotic as t + 00 of Solutions to Mixed Boundary Value Problems
2.1. Odd n. It follows from condition C that for I Im ICI > y the operator & has no poles (since Rkcp = Ft+kPp for these values of k, and the function Ft,kPp depends analytically on k, Im k > y). From this and from Theorem 4 it follows that any half-plane Im k > const contains no more than a finite number of poles of the operator &. We enumerate them in such a way that Imkk 2 Im kj+l. Then Im Ic, -+ -co for j -+ 03, moreover the successive poles get further from the real axis at least at a logarithmic rate. Theorem 5. Let n be odd, conditions A, D, C’ and D hold, cp E H,” and v E Brn-‘,+t’ be a solution of (1). Then in the domain Q, the following expansion is valid for any N
V(t, X) = -i 2 k~@&X-ik”] j=l 2
+ wj,T(t, x) ,
where for any E > 0 and any s, j = 0, 1,2,. , ., there is a T such that fort the following estimate holds
aj 5 C(N, atjWN I/ I/s,(b)
s, j, e)e-
kN+l+E)t IIpllo,a .
(12) > T
II. Asymptotics Remarks.
of Solutions to Exterior
BVP
63
1. Clearly formula (12) may be rewritten in the form
v = i:
fpuq,i(x))“~li3t
+ WN )
q=o
j=l
w.here pj + 1 is the order of the pole k = kj of the operator function & uqj
and
E c-(flb).
2. The poles of the operator & which lie in the upper half-plane correspond to the terms in (12) which grow exponentially as t + oo. Poles lying on the real axis correspond to terms in the form of a product of an oscillating exponential function (or unity, if kj = 0) and a polynomial in t. Poles in the lower halfplane correspond to the terms which decay exponentially as t + co. There are no more than a finite number of poles in the half-plane Im k > 0 and their locations are determnined by Theorem 1 if k # 0. In Vainberg (1975 and 1982) sufficient conditions for the absence of poles at the point k = 0 can be found. For the proof of Theorem 5, we write the solution of (1) in the form 1 v =
G
i(y+l)+m J Rkcpe-ikt
dk,
(14)
i(y+l)-lx
where y is defined by condition C. Then for x E fib and cpE H,” the operator & in (14) may b e replaced by & and the contour of integration moved to the lower half-plane, changing it to the line 1 : Im k = Im kN+l + E, where E > 0 is chosen so that no poles of & lie directly on 1. Then the estimates (13) will hold for the integral along I, and the difference between the integral (14) and the integral along 1 is equal to the sum of the residues appearing in the right-hand side of (12). Both of these assertions follow easily from Theorem 4. These arguments lead to the following asymptotic expansion of the solution ‘u of the problem of forced oscillations of a medium: ( Lv(t, x) = cp(x)eCiwt,
x E 62, t > 0, (15)
Theorem 6. Let n be odd, conditions A, I?, C’, 2, hold, ‘p E H,” and u E Brn-‘,y be a solution of (15), where w is an arbitrary complex number. Then in the domain f&, for any N < co we have the following expansion
21= 5 ,rrtj3p,:&e8”“]
+ x&‘pe-i”t
+ WN
,
j=l
where the estimates (13) hold for the function wN and x = 0 if w coincides with one of the poles kj or if Im kN+l 2 Im w. Otherwise, x = 1.
64
B. R. Vainberg
In this way, a periodic forcing term (w is real) can induce exponential growth in the solution (in the presence of eigenvalues of the stationary problem in the upper half-plane) or excite a finite number of modes, one of whose frequencies equals w, while the others’ do not depend on w. 2.2.
Long-wave Asymptotic Expansion. The long-wave (or low-freasymptotic expansion is the asymptotics of solutions of (2) as k -+ 0. In the case of a space of odd dimension, the asymptotic expansion is given by Theorem 1, by which the solution Rkcp, cp E H,” of (2) is expressed in a series in powers of k for x E &. This series may start with a negative power of k if & has a pole at the point k = 0, or with a zero power if there is no such pole. Sufficient conditions for the absence of such a pole can be found in Vainberg (1975, 1982). In the case of a space of even dimension, Theorem 1 says nothing about the behavior of the operator & for k + 0. The fundamental lemma, with whose help the behavior of the operator & is studied as Ic + 0 (among other applications), has the following form. We denote the following region on the Riemann surface of Ink by GT,E: quency)
f2,,, = {k : ) argkl Lemma for complex form:
< y,
I/C/ < E} .
1. Let Sk : H -+ H be an operator on the Hilbert space H defined k # 0, 1kl < 1, Fredholm for these values of k, and having the N Sk =Tklnk+CAjk-j+Gk. j=l
Here
Tk, Gk are analytic operators on the disk Ikl < 1, the s > 0, and Aj, 1 < j 2 N, are finite-dimensional, the operator Go is Fredholm, and the operator Sk0 is invertible at least for one value k = Ice # 0, lkal < 1. Then for any y < 00 and for some E = E(Y) the operator (Sk)-’ may be represented in the form operators
the operators &Tklkzoj
cc
(sk)-l = Nk + f(k)
i
c x(5& i=o 3=0
ld k)ki
,
where Nk is an analytic operator-function in the disk lkl < E(Y), the operators Szj are finite-dimensional, the series converges in the uniform operator norm for k E fl,,,, and the function f has the form
(16) Here a 2 0 is some integer, P and P, are some polynomials of order than a and s(a + 1)) respectively, Pa(t) E 1 and the series (16) absolutely and uniformly for k E Q?,,.
no higher converges
II. Asymptotics
of Solutions to Exterior BVP
65
The first term of the expansion for the operator (Sk)-’ has the following form: there exist integers a, /?, b (p 2 0), a polynomial P and operators D, such that for k E Q,,,
/I&rl - &
P CD, s=o
In” k < Clk”+l Ins ICI. II
Lemma 1 may be applied to the operator BI, which was examined above in the discussion of the proof of Theorem 1. (For this, it is first necessary to study the behavior of the operator & as k + 0 corresponding to a system with constant coefficients in R?.) As a result, we arrive at the following assertion. Theorem 7. Let n be even and conftitions A, B, C’, V hold. Then for any y > 0 and some E = ~(7) the operator RI, may be written in the form l&
= Lk + k-Of(k)
F
k
Ri,ki
lnj k,
(17)
where the operators Lk, Rij : H,” + H$) are bounded, the operator Lk depends analytically on k in the disk lkl < E(Y), the operators Rij are finitedimensional, the function f has the form (16), ,D = m - n for n < m, p = 1 for n = m, ,B = 0 for n > m, and the series (17) converges uniformly in the operator norm for k E GT>,. Remark. Expansion (17) may be rewritten in the following simple (but a little less explicit) form. fik = kKA
2 ki i,j=o
[ 1 L
P(ln k)
’ Pi,j(ln
k) ,
where A is an integer, P = P(X) is a polynomial in X, Pi,j are polynomials with operator coefficients. The analogous expansion is valid for the operator (Sk)-l in Lemma 1. Clearly, the series (17) may be written in the following, outwardly simpler, form: CorxJ & = k-A 71 x Bij (k lna+’ k)i In-’ k, (18) ix0 j=o
where A is some integer, the operators Bij : H,” + Hgj are bounded, all of the operators Bij, except possibly those for which i 2 A, j = i(a + l), are finite-dimensional, and the double sum converges uniformly in the operator norm. We may write the operator (Sk)-’ analogously in Lemma 1. The merit of the expansion (17) lies in the fact that with the help of a finite number of terms, it allows one to obtain an approximation to the operator & to any degree of accuracy (in k). In (18), an infinite number of terms differ by a logarithmic factor from the first term of the asymptotic expansion. We
66
B. R. Vainberg
note, additionally, that the proof in Vainberg (1982) of Lemma 1 is such that it allows one to refine the result in concrete situations, when one has further information about the operators Tk and Aj. 2.3. Mixed Problems, Even n. We denote the “singular part” of the operator & by ri’,. It is obtained from the sum (18) by throwing out the terms for which i 2 A and j = i(u + 1). For ]k] + 0 and ] argk] < 27r, let pk = BkP lnq k + O( 1kp lnqel ICI) ,
where the operator B is nonzero (clearly, it is finite-dimensional). Theorem v E Bm-‘ly holds
8. Let n be even, conditions A, l3, C’, V hold, ‘p E H,” and be a solution of (1). Then in the region fib the following expansion
21 = -i
c
;zr.[&pePikt]
Imk3>0
+ c,t-p-1(ln4+‘-P
t)Bq~ + wP.
’
Here p = 1 for p < 0, p = 2 for p > 0, cl = (-i)“q-p[(-p
- l)!]-l,
c2 = ~(-i)~~+~p!
and for any s, j = 0, 1, . . . , and some T, t > T
aj 5 C(s, j) dtjWp /I II,s@)
2
[t-p-1 lnqPfi
t11IIff4lo,a.
In an expansion of the type (18) for the operator kk,w E (k - w)-l Rk, we leave only those terms which contain a power of Ink or a negative power of k. We denote the remaining sum by iilk,,. For lkl + 0, I arg kl < 27r, let pk,,
= Dk’
lnh k + 0( Ik’ Inhe ICI) ,
where the operator D is non-zero (and finite-dimensional). Theorem an arbitrary the domain
9. Let conditions A, B, C’, D hold, with n even, cp E Hz, w be complex number. Let u E Brn-‘,y be a solution of (15). Then in fit, the following expansion holds
Here p = 1 for r < 0, p = 2 for r 2 0; d, = const # 0; x = 0, if Imw < 0, or w = 0 or w coincides with one of the poles kj, for which Im kj > 0. Otherwise, x=1. Foranys,j=0,1,2,... andsomeT witht>T
aj 5 C(s, j) mwp /I II,s(b)
&
[t-‘--llnh-‘” tII IIdlo,a
Theorems 8 and 9 are proved along the same lines as Theorems 6 and 7. Only now in order to choose a single-valued branch of the function & it is necessary to make a cut in the k-plane along the negative part of the imaginary axis and choose the contour 1 so that it passesabove the cut.
II. Asymptotics 2.4. Problems condition hold
with
of Solutions to Exterior BVP
Bounded
Condition E. For any solution lowing estimate holds
Energy. u E B”,r
ll4lL*(n, 5 c(cp),
67
Let the following
additional
of (1) with ‘p E C?(n) t >o.
the fol-
(19)
It has been shown in this case that the operator & cannot have poles in the upper half-plane and that it can have poles on the real axis of no higher than first order, and further that the domain of definition of the residues of the operator-function & at these poles coincides with the eigenspace of (2). In the case of even n, in addition II&II
< Clkl-l
for
IlcJ+ 0, I arg ICI< 2X.
(20)
This leads to the following simplified variant of Theorems 6 and 8. Theorem 10. Let conditions A, i3, C’, ID), I hold. Then (2) has no more than a finite number of eigenvalues k = wj, 1 < j 5 r, in the upper halfplane, all of which are real, their corresponding eigenspaces ‘l-tj are finitedimensional, for wj # 0 the eigenfunctions have compact support in a,, and there exist bounded operators Bj : H,” + 7$ such that in the domain Q, for solutions u E BrnP1ly of (1) with cp E H,” the following expansion holds
For the function w for any s,j = 0, 1,2,. . ., some T and following estimates hold: if n is odd, then for some S > 0
any t > T the
II-II SW do
and
if n
L: C(s, ~F”tllvllo,a ) s,(b)
is even, then
s,(b) Remarks. 1. If condition I holds, then similar variants of Theorems 7 and 9 also hold (see Vainberg 1982). 2. If the estimate (20) IS . k nown, then we can require, instead of (19), that for some j 2. 0, the following estimate hold
B. R. Vainberg
68
2.5. The Klein-Gordon Equation. The scheme developed above for obtaining the asymptotic expansion as t + co of solutions of hyperbolic equations is applicable also in more general situations than indicated earlier. As an example, we consider the problem
for the linear Klein-Gordon equation, describing the motion of a particle of mass ma and charge e in a constant magnetic field with vector potential A = (Al(z),... , A,(z)) E C”. Here m = moc2, c is the speed of light, z E Eta, v = (& )...) &). w e consider the case of the short-range field, that is, we assume that the vector-function A(z) has compact support. The reason why we may not apply the methods obtained in $2 to (21) in a strictly formal manner lies in the fact that (21) with m # 0 does not satisfy A. However, a method for studying (21) remains the same. But the result obtained in this case is very different. If the asymptotics as t + co of the solution of (21) f or m = 0 and odd n has an exponential character and is determined by the poles of the operator &, then for the samen and m # 0, the asymptotics has a power-law character for real A(z) and is determined by the behavior of the resolvent near the points fm. We mention the corresponding result (for the case of even n, see Vainberg (1974)). Let RI, be the resolvent obtained for the operator of (21) for m = 0. Then
For any N
where J(u) = ctPiu++)sin q=o
[mt
+
(q
-
i)
51
~h,,,H2p+lu,
p=o
b,,, are some constants, and we have for the functions ‘ZUNfor t >> 1 and any
s, j = 0, 1,2, . . ., the estimates 5
s>(b)
C(N,
s, j)t-
(
N+s) [IIPllo,a+ II~llo,al.
II. Asymptotics
of Solutions to Exterior BVP
69
Part II The Scattering Problem 5 1. Quasiclassical Asymptotic Expansion of the Solution to the Scattering Problem 1.1. Introduction, the Geometry of Rays. In this chapter, we study primarily the scattering of plane waves in an inhomogeneous medium. The process of scattering is described by a function + = +(L, X) satisfying the equation
[A + ~2hm = 0, and having the form $(lc,z) the radiation conditions
x E Et”, k>O,
= eikxn + u(lc,~),
21= f(O, IC)r(1-“)/2eikr(1
+ O(r-l)),
(1)
where the function r + cm,
f&:.
u satisfies
r
(2)
The function f is called the scattering amplitude. Here q E CW(IP); q(x) > 0; q(x) = 1 for r = 1x1 > a. The function eikxn corresponds to a plane wave propagating along the axis x, and the function u describes the scattered wave caused by the inhomgeneities of the medium (U = 0 if q = 1). Supposing that the non-trapping condition holds (see part 1) for the operator (l), we obtain the asymptotic expansion of the function $J as k + co, 1x1< b < co and the asymptotic expansion of f as k + co. The constants a and b are arbitrary and fixed, and we will not track the dependence of any quantities on a or b. In the problems of quantum mechanics, q(x) = E - U(x), k2 = 2mi’-‘, where E is the energy, U is the potential, m is the massof the particle, fi. is Planck’s constant, and the asymptotic expansions as lc + co are called quasi-classical. The origin of this term stems from the fact that the laws of classical mechanics can be obtained from their quantum mechanical analogues by passing to the limit ti + 0. These asymptotics are also called WKB-asymptotics in honor of Wentzel, Kramers and Brillouin, who first applied these asymptotic series in the study of one-dimensional quantum mechanica. problems. In acoustics, k is proportional to frequency and the asymptotic expansion as k + oc is called high-frequency or short-wave. Equation (1) corresponds to the hamiltonian H = IpI2 - q(x), p E R” and the hamiltonian system dx
- = 2p, ds
2
= Vq(x);
X(O) = (Y, -a),
P(O) = (0,. . ., 071) >
(3)
where y E lR”-‘. The initial conditions in (3) correspond to a plane wave propagating along the axis 2,. The projections of the phase curves of the system (3) into lF$ are called rays. It is easy to show that in regions where
70
B. R. Vainberg
q = 1, the rays propagate along straight lines. In particular, for IyI > a they coincide with the lines x’ = 1~, -CQ < x, < 0~). Here x’ = (xi,. . . ,x,-i). For IyI < a, the ray coincides with the line x’ = y while x, < -Vq, that is while the ray remains outside the ball 1x1 < a. Inside this ball, it travels along some curvilinear path, and exiting from the ball, goes straight in the same direction as it exited with. A function J/JN satisfying equation (1) with error O(lCPM), where M -+ OCI as N + oo, is called a formal asymptotic solution (f. a. s.) of the equation. In some sufficiently small neighborhood of the initial hyperplane x, = -a (which the rays emanate from), it is possible to construct a f. a. s. of equation (1) in the form ~+!JN= eilcscz) c,” aj(x)lc-j, where 4~ = eikxn for x, < -a. In a larger neighborhood, where it is possible for rays to intersect and the given f. a. s. does not exist, other solutions may be constructed with the help of the Maslov canonical operator. However, the relationship between these f. a. s. and the exact solution of the scattering problem is not clear a priori since (1) has infinitely many solutions if no boundary conditions are specified. The unique solution II, which interests us is determined by the far-field conditions (2). In this chapter, we briefly recall the construction of the canonical operator and use it to construct an f. a. s. $JN of (1) in the ball 1x1 < b. A method will then be described that is based on the use of the non-stationary problems and results of the previous chapter. It will allow us to estimate the difference + - IJN in the ball 1x1 < b, independently of the behavior of the constructed approximations 4~ for r + oo, and to prove that I,~,N is asymptotic to 4 in this ball as Ic + 00. 1.2. Maslov Canonical Operator (MCO). We explain only the formal construction of the MC0 and refer the reader to the previous article or to Maslov and Fedoryuk (1981), Mishchenko, Sternin, and Shatalov (1978), and Vainberg (1982) for details and proofs. The MC0 is contructed on an ndimensional lagrangian manifold, lying in 2n-dimensional phase space. In the present case, the MC0 will be constructed on the manifold n c Iw$P), formed by the phase curves of (3). We note that the non-trapping condition allows us to define the MC0 on all functions in C-(n), not only on functions with compact support. Let (Y = (oi,. . . ,as),/3 = (pr,. . . ,&-s) be disjoint subsets of the set ofindices (1,2,... ,n)suchthatan/?=flandaU/?=(l,2 ,..., n),andlet I,0 = n - s. By x, , xcp, p,, pp we denote vectors consisting of the corresponding components of the vectors x and p. On the manifold A there exist global coordinates (y, s) called ray coordinates. Since the manifold A is lagrangian, there exists on it an atlas {.G’j}, each chart of which is simply connected and such that for some cx = aj J. _ dx,dm ~2dyd.s 3
c #O,
C,%>
a = et(j).
II. Asymptotics
of Solutions
to Exterior
BVP
71
Here (~~,pp) is determined by the system (3). If the vector (Y = o(j) can be chosen in more than one way, we fix it arbitrarily. In light of (4), on any chart fij, in addition to ray coordinates, there exist local coordinates (~,,po), (Y = o(j), and on the chart flj the manifold A may be written in the form xcp = “p(x:a,Pp),
Pa = PcY(xa,Pp);
where U, is some domain in KY. Let the function S E C-(A) be defined
Q: = 4j),
(xCa,pa)
E uj,
(5)
by the formula
(6) where L(C) is an arbitrary smooth curve on n connecting the point with ray coordinates (y, s) = (0,O) with the point C (the function S does not depend on the choice of L). By S, = Sj (xcy , PO), (Y = o(j), we denote the value of the function S at a point of the chart f2j with local coordinates (xa,pp). Let @j = @j(GY, PP) = Sj(Xcx~ PP) - h3(xa~ The function @j is the generating that is, on that chart Vz_@p, = Pa(Gx,Pfi),
function
V,,@j
PO>, PO) .
of the manifold
(7)
A on the chart
flj,
= -“p(GY,PpL
where the functions p, and x0 are defined in (5). We call a point C E A non-singular if some neighborhood of it projects diffeomorphically onto some domain in IWE. We denote the set of singular points by E(A), and its projection into JR: is called the caustic set. We include a sufficiently small neighborhood G’j, of the point < E A in the atlas {Qj} with ray coordinates (y, s) = (0,O) such that fijO n E(A) = 8. We take x as the local coordinates on f2?, We denote by yj the Keller-Maslov index of the chain of charts connecting fij and Qjnj,. The value of rj does not depend on the choice of the chain. This constant is an integer which, in the case where fij n E(A) = 8, is equal to the intersection index of any curve connecting f2jnj, and f2.j with E(A). Let {ej} be some partition of unity on A subordinate to the covering {Qj} and gj = gj(x) be arbitrary functions in Cr(IF) that are equal to one on the orthogonal projection of the chart Qj in RF and equal to zero outside a unit neighborhood of this projection. The canonical operator KAJ : C-(A) + Cm(IRE) is defined by the formula
where
‘P E C-(A),
a = a(j),
(wJy’)
= (e3pJJ1)
(xa,pa)
E C~(fY$).
B. R. Vainberg
72
This formula is distinct from the standard construction due to the presence of the multipliers gj. If cp E C,-(A), their presence is not essential since it alters the MC0 by a quantity of order 0(X-“), X + oo. For cp E C-(A), thanks to the non-trapping condition and the presence in (8) of the functions gj, only finitely many of the terms in (8) differ from zero for 1x1 < c < 00, where c is arbitrary (that is, (8) is well defined). Finally, in this chapter it is convenient to take the atlas {Q} in a special form. Let Ac = {< E A : s = O}. Clearly, it possible to require A, c Uk>0&, p(2k) = 0, A,n&-, = 0 for any,1 = 1,2,. . . . This will simplify finding initial conditions below. 1.3. Asymptotic Expansion of the Solution to the Scattering Problem. We will seek a formal asymptotic solution of (1) in the form
*N
=
-f(ik)-Jyj , [ 1 ‘pj E C’==(A).
K/l,li
j=o
If the functions ‘pj satisfy the transport equations (some ordinary differential equations along the phase curves of problem (3), which make up A, see the previous article or Maslov and Fedoryuk (1981), Mishchenko, Sternin, and Shatalov (1978), Vainberg (1982)), then in any ball 1x1< b [A + k’q(z)]+N
= O@C-~+“‘~),
k--+co,
(9)
that is, +,N is a f. a. s.of equation (1). Theorem 1. Let the non-trapping condition the transport equations and (POI,=~ = 1, ‘pjlSEo v= (VI,... , v,) and 1x1 < b
$b(k,
hold, the functions ‘pj satisfy = 0 for j > 0. Then for any
x) - ?,bN(k, x)]i 5 c(N, v)k-N-1+v+n’2,
k> 1.
In particular, if the domain V c IRZ does not contain any caustic points and if m rays of system (3) pass through each of its points, then, uniformly on compacta belonging to V,
j=l
where the functions Sj are determined by formula (6) with < = <j(x), Jj by (4) with IpI = 0 and C = <j(x), and the <j(.x) are points on A whose projections on II%: coincide with x E V. The constants 35 are equal to the intersection index of L(&(z)) and E(A).
II. Asymptotics
of Solutions
to Exterior
BVP
73
As we have already mentioned, (1) has an infinite set of f. a. s. in the ball 11~1< b. It is necessary to show that it is $N that is asymptotic to the solution $J of the scattering problem. The key to the proof of the theorem is given by formula (10) appearing below, which connects the function
Let
l ( Lv-
( u(t,x)
q(x)$A
‘u=o,
t > 0,
XEE-P,
t 5 0,
2 E R” )
>
= P(--t)X(xn
- t),
where x E C-(W), x(r) = 0 for r > --a, x(r) = 1 for r < --a - 1. From the results of the previous chapter it follows that for a solution w of the problem Lw=O,
t > 0;
= 0,
Wlt,O
for any v, j, some T and t > T the following
w:itzo estimate
= f E ff,” holds:
where t--3++’ may be replaced by eest for some b > 0 if n is odd. This allows us to prove the following assertion in a relatively simple manner. Let of ‘p be equal to P E Cl?@), (P(T) = 0 for T < 0 and r > 1 and the integral one. Theorem 2. Let the non-trapping the non-stationary scattering problem u = $~(k,
where
for some T’,
u of
x)ePt
+ u1 ,
any N and u, 1x1 < b and T > T’ vleiktcp(t
Thus,
condition hold. Then the solution be represented in the form
can
- T) dt
< C(N,
.~)k-~,
k>
1.
for 1x1 < b and T > T’ +(k, x) = I”
w(t, x)etktcp(t
- T) dt + O(k-“)
.
(10)
For the proof of theorem 1 it is now sufficient to substitute the well-known (see the previous article or Maslov and Fedoryuk (1981), Mishchenko, Sternin, and Shatalov (1978), Vainberg (1982)) asymptotic expansion of the function w as k -+ 00 on the compact set 1x1 2 b, T 5 t 5 T + 1 into the previous integral and calculate the asymptotic behavior of the resulting integral. We note that this method allows us to avoid a two-parameter expansion of the function Q,, where k --f cm and 1x1 4 co simultaneously, connected with the fulfillment of the radiation condition for the functions $J, ‘$N for all k >> 1, and also with the determination of the behavior of the right-hand side of (9) for 1x1 + 03.
74
B. R. Vainberg
$2. Asymptotics
of the Scattering
Amplitude
We recall that for 121 > a the rays in problem (3) are straight lines. Let P be a map of JlJF’ to the unit sphere 57-r which transforms each point y E IP-l into a vector 0 E 57-l associated with the direction at infinity of a ray of the system (3) with ray coordinates y. The modulus of the jacobian 1(g) of the map is equal to the angular density of the rays at infinity. Let m rays of the system (3) go to infinity along the direction 0 = Be E ,‘FP1 with y = yj, 1 5 j < m, and I(yj) # 0. Th en an analogous situation occurs for 10 - 00 1 < 1 also. Let yj (0) be the value of the ray coordinates of y for which the rays lj of (3) go to infinity along the direction 8. We will denote a segment of the ray Zj from the point with ray coordinates (y, s) = (yj(0), 0) to the point J: by Ii, and the corresponding segment of the phase curve of (3) by Lj,. Let 1j(0) = r(yj(0)) and
Jz
S,(x) = -a + L3 (p, dx) . The
function
x E P,
Fj(@) = S,(x) - (Q,x), depends
only on 6’.
Theorem 3. Let the non-trapping (3) go to infinity along the direction l0-&/<1 andkAoo
j=l
where
1x1 z+ a,
condition hold, m rays of the system 00, and I,(&) # 0. Then for any N,
s=o
ajo E 1 and ~j is the intersection
index
of Lj, with
E(A)
The asymptotic expansion of the function f for any 8 is expressed through the canonical operators constructed on the (n - l)-dimensional lagrangian manifolds L+, LO c T*(S”-l). We pass to the coordinates (0,r,q8,qr) in (3), where (qo, qT) are impulses corresponding to the spherical coordinates (0, r). We then have L+ = lim,,,{(8,q,) : y E EY-‘}, and LO is the analogous manifold for q(x) E 1. In order to obtain the asymptotic expansion of the scattering amplitude f we can use the following integral representation of f in terms of the scattered wave u: f = pn I=,
[g w&k)?
+ il~(~, ~)u]
e-ik(elx)
dS,
II. Asymptotics
of Solutions
to Exterior
BVP
75
where R is arbitrary. This representation is a consequence of Green’s formula for u and the Green’s function of the Helmholtz operator. Then its quasiclassical asymptotic expansion from Theorem 1 is substituted for u = 1c,- eikz, and it remains to solve the non-trivial problem of the asymptotic evaluation of the resulting integral.
76
B. R. Vainberg
Part III The Parametrix and the Full Asymptotic Expansion of the Spectral Function of Differential Operators in JR” $1. The
Parametrix
for Hyperbolic
Equations
and Systems
1.1. Introduction. A parametrix (of a Cauchy problem) for hyperbolic equations or systems is a function EN, differing from the Green’s function E by a function in the class CM, where M + co as N + 00. Having an explicit formula for EN, it is possible to study the discontinuities of the function EN and thereby to study the discontinuities of the Green’s function. In particular, it gives the wave fronts and the singularities on the fronts for the problem of oscillation of a medium excited by point sources. The parametrix enables the solution of many other problems also, for example, it reduces the solution of the Cauchy problem to an integral equation with a smooth kernel. The parametrix may be constructed in the usual way (cf. the previous article or Maslov and Fedoryuk (1981), Mishchenko, Sternin, and Shatalov (1978), V. (1982)) with the aid of the Maslov canonical operator or a Fourier integral operator connected with an (n + 1)-dimensional lagrangian manifold lying in extended phase space. In this section a new, simpler formula for the parametrix is given for the case of equations in which the no-trapping condition holds (cf. chapter 1) and systems whose coefficients do not depend on t. This formula has the form: EN(t,x)
=
y)eixt d, Jrn -03(X7 gX,N
(1)
where gX,%J is constructed on the stationary part of the operator and is related to an n-dimensional lagrangian manifold lying in the phase space lKtz,P). Formula (1) is the analogue of an expression of the Green’s function in terms of the spectral function corresponding to the stationary operator. In contrast to the latter expression, the formula for the parametrix does not suppose self-adjointness of the operators or the fulfillment of any conditions on their spectra. In some cases of non-selfadjoint operators, it may substitute for the theorem of spectral decomposition. One of the applications of the new formula for the parametrix is the possibility of obtaining, with its help, the full asymptotic expansion of the spectral function corresponding to an elliptic operator on Iw” in the self-adjoint case. We leave this discussion for section 2. 1.2. Second of the form
Order
Equations.
Let z E Iw”, L be a hyperbolic
operator
II. Asymptotics
L==-A
d2
( x,~ “>,
of Solutions
A=2
to Exterior
BVP
77
aij (xl i,j=l
where the operator A has infinitely no-trapping condition. Let a(a,p) n-,dimensional lagrangian manifold the problem
differentiable coefficients and satisfies the = C aij(x)pipj, p E JR?, and A = Ay be an in IR$) consisting of the phase curves of
40) = Y, (3) P(O) = &f&,
w E 9-l
Here, p(0) is normalized so that a(y,p(O)) = 1. Let KA,X : Cm(A) + Cm(R~) be a Maslov canonical operator (MCO) which depends on the parameter y and is constructed on the manifold n = AY with the invariant measure dw ds on it (dw is the element of surface area on the sphere 9-l). The construction of the MC0 is described in the previous chapter. In order for it to be applicable to the lagrangian manifold described above, it is necessary to substitute the measure dw ds for 2 dy ds in the formula for J3, fix a generating function @j on the chart fij (they are determined only up to an additive constant), and indicate the value of the Maslov index on one of the charts. As a generating function @j = @j (x,, pp) on the chart Qj with local coordinates (x,, pp), a = a(j), we take @j =
s
LW4
= 2s(Gx>PP)
- (Q(G,P~),P~) - (xp(xci,
PP), PP)
Here C is a segment with ray coordinates
of the phase trajectory in problem (3) going from the point (w, s) = ( w”, 0) to a point < E flj with local coordinates s corresponding to the point (G, PP); S(G, PP) is th e value of the parameter <; the function xcp = x~(cca,pp) is determined by formula (5) of chapter 2. For 0 < s < t, where E > 0 is sufficient.ly small, the manifold Au projects diffeomorphically to GIBE.We include in the atlas {Gj} a chart Qj,, the points of which satisfy 0 < s < E, and where we take x as local coordinates and set “/jO = 0. Finally, we recall that t,he manifold A = Au depends on y E R”. We take all objects in the construction of K,I,x (cf. formula (8) of chapter 2) such that they depend smoothly on y (this is possible). We denote by ~A,N = j’~,~(x, y) the function
where the functions +j equations and the initial
E Cm(A) conditions
satisfy
the recurrent
system
of transport
B. R. Vainberg
78
&I,=, = $j(W,Y/)> j>o, which are taken such that for any N
W)ffi,Jr(G YY) dX -S(n: - ECN-n(R2n). JO" Y)
(5)
0
Here C is an arbitrary function in Cm(Iw) such that C(X) = 1 for X > 2, C(X) = 0 for X < 1, and the transport equations are written in the standard form so that on any compact set in Iw” /(A + X2)fx,NI
2 CX-N+n-3’2,
x+ccl.
Theorem 1. Let the no-trapping condition be satisfied. Then 1. It is possible to take $J~(w, y), j 2 0 such that (5) holds. Relation (5) and the transport equations determine the r+!~j (w, y), j > 0 uniquely with +J(,,~
=
$$27r-y
[a(y, w)]-“e
77 i’+nT
4
.
2. For the function
Y)x dA Jm<(X)f,&&, sin JX
EN(t,x,Y)
=
0
the following
relations
hold
(7) ENI~=~
= 0,
dEN at
6(2 - y) E cN-yIw2y. t=o -
1. The integrals (5) and (6), just as several other improper integrals encountered below, are to be interpreted in the standard manner that integrals of rapidly oscillating functions are usually interpreted. 2. The second assertion of the theorem is a consequence of the first. Also, from (5) and the tranport equations, it follows that for integers j E 10,(N - n)Pl Notes.
J
O” &A)Xjfd,N(~,y)
dX - (-A)jS(x
- y) E CN-n-2j(IW2n).
(9)
0
3. Let (-A) be a self-adjoint operator with an absolutely continuous spectrum, (Ex} its spectral family, and ei the kernel of the operator dEx/dX. Then if we substitute ei for the function C(X)fA,, in the integrals (5), (6) and (9), then the left hand sidesof (5), and (7))(g) will be identically zero and the indicated relations will turn into the usual spectral decomposition of the operators (-A)j, j > 0 and (sin -)/a. In this way, Theorem 1 may be viewed as an analogue of the spectral decomposition theorem for non-self adjoint operators.
4. Sometimes
II. Asymptotics
of Solutions
it is convenient
to replace
to Exterior (6) with
BVP
79
the equivalent
formula
5. To apply this method further, we need the parametrix for all t > 0. If we construct it only for t E [0, T], T < oo, then we may easily modify (6) and (6’) with the help of cut-off functions and still drop the no-trapping condition.
1.3. Higher
Order
Equations
and Systems.
Let
.;.,(x.&,2&)
(10)
be a hyperbolic operator of order m with a unit coefficient for (i3/iat)m, Lo = Lo(z, X,p) be the leading-order homogeneous part of its characteristic polynomial, X = &.(x,p), 1 5 T < m, be the (smooth) roots of the polynomial Lo with respect to the variable X. We assume that Lo(z,O,p) # 0 for p # 0, that is, X,(x,p) # 0 f orallr,xandp#O.Let+=sgnX,(x,p), p# 0; G(X,P> = lL(&P)l. We denote by A, = A,,, the n-dimensional lagrangian manifold in lRFzp) consisting of the phase curves of the hamiltonian system with hamiltonian H, = a,(x,p) and initial conditions
The no-trapping condition for the operator (10) is formulated the same way as for (2). In this case, the projections onto R” of the phase curves of each of the above hamiltonian systems, 1 5 T 5 m, are called rays corresponding to (10). The operator KA,,x is constructed exactly as the operator KA,~ was constructed in the previous section. Let
where initial
the functions conditions
which
are taken
$r,j
E C” (A,)
satisfy
?%,j Is=0 = h-,3 (w, Y),
the transport
equations
and the
j >o,
so that
lrn ((A) g [&?$(Z, g)(itJ,“-‘1
dX - 6(x - z/Y)E cN--n(~2n).
(12)
80
B. R. Vainberg
Theorem 2. Let the operator 1. There exist unique functions (ll), (12) are satisfied. Moreover,
(10) satisfy the no-trapping condition. Then $r,j(w, y), j > 0, for which the inclusions
Here A, = X,(y, w). 2. For the functions
the following
relations
hold LEN
d”EN
EC t=” d”-lE awN
atk
E CN-“(R2n+1),
Nfm-n-k-l(R2n),
t=”
O
- S(x - y) E CN--7yW2y.
For simplicity in the case of a system, order system. Let
we show the result
only
for a first-
(13) be an elliptic
matrix
operator
of dimension
m x m such that
the operator
L=&B
(14)
is hyperbolic. Here I is the identity matrix. This means that for all x,p the eigenvalues X,(x,p), 1 2 s 5 m, of the matrix Be(x,p) = C Mj(x)pj real and distinct. In view of the ellipticity of the operator (13), X,(x,p) for P # 0. Let E,~ = wL(x,p), P # 0, ~(55~) = I&(x,P)~. The lagrangian manifolds A, = Ar,Y, the no-trapping condition and operators KA,,~ are defined for the operator (13) exactly as they were equation (lo), whose characteristic polynomial has the same roots A,, s < m. By gl,N = gi,N(x, y) we denote the vector function
# 0 are # 0 the for 1 <
(15) where
the vector
functions
$)T,j E Cm(&)
~T&=O =
~T,j(W>Y),
are fixed jL0,
by the initial
conditions
(16)
II. Asymptotics
of Solutions
to Exterior
which will be specified later, and by the requirement mate holds uniformly on compacta in IR”:
BVP that
81 the following
esti-
This estimate means that the vector function (15) is an f. a. s. of the system (B - E,X)U = 0. From this estimate, it follows by standard methods that $+,j = ~~,j(~r+dr,j, where: 1) the vector functions d,,j are determined uniquely by recurrence from an algebraic system of equations containing $r,n, 0 < Ic < are the normalized eigenvectors of the matrix Ba with j (4,o = 0); 2) (PT eigenvalues X,(z,p); 3) the coefficients ,cL~,~ satisfy the transport equations. The arbitrariness in the choice of the initial conditions (16) lies in the fact that the initial conditions for the coefficients pr,j lsZo = pL,,? (w, 1~) may be prescribed in various ways. We take them so that
dX- 6(x - Y)hk E CN-n(R2n))
lW C(X)@,N
(17)
where hk is a vector whose kth component is one and all the others are zero. Let fk = C rCrCrn gi,,,, and let f$ be the columns which are obtained if only terms for which fe, > 0 are left in the last sum, and gzN be the matrices consisting
of the columns
fkf, 1 5 Ic 5 m.
Theorem 3. Let the no-trapping condition hold Then 1. The initial conditions pu,,j lSzo may be specified, that the relation (17) holds. In this case pu,,o(w, y) = (27r)-*e-i+n~A,(w, 2. For the matrix
LEN
relations
s0
O” <(X)[gT,NeiXt
Second
in fact,
operator
(13).
uniquely,
such
(hk, (~~l~,~).
E CN-n(iR2n+1
Order
+ gi,Ne-iXt]
dX,
hold ),
$2. Asymptotics 2.1.
the
function
EN = the following
y)I*
for
ENI~,~
- 6(x - y)I E CN-n(IR2n).
of the Spectral Function
Equations.
Theorem 4. Let the operator A, defined in formula (2), be formally selfadjoint, satisfy the no-trapping condition, and coincide with the laplacian for 1x1 >> 1. Let ei be the kernel of the operator dEx/dX, where {Ex} is the spectral
82
B. R. Vainberg
family of the operator (-A), and the function ~A,N be defined in (4). Then for any j 2 0, CI = (CQ, . . . , CY,), /3 = (PI,. . . , /3,), b < co and N, there exists a C = C(d, b, N) (h ere d = Ial + IPI +j), such that for 1x1, IyI 5 b and X --f CC
This assertion is a direct consequence of the results in chapter 1 and the formula for the parametrix, introduced in $1 of that chapter. In fact, corresponding to formula (6’) we obtain ENeiXt
dt .
On the other hand, for X > 0 in D’(IwF) we have the equality
sy
E(t, x, y)eixt
dt.
-lxJ
It follows then for X > 1 that ei2 -
f&N
= g
1
m (E - EN)eiXt
dt.
s -co
The difference E-EN is a sufficiently smooth function if N is large. Therefore for the proof of the estimate (18)) we need only obtain some information about the behavior of the function E - EN and its derivatives as t + 00. From (4) and (6’) it follows that EN and its t-derivatives decay faster than any power of t as t + 03. The information about the behavior of the function E as t + co necessary to obtain (18) is contained in Chapter 1. Theorem 4 gives the asymptotics of ei when (xc,y) belongs to any compact set in ll%2n.If the point (x0, y”) is such that the point x0 is not caustic for the ray family (3) for y = y”, then in some neighborhood of the point (x0, y”) (meaning also in any connected domain in Tw2” consisting of points of the indicated form) it is possible to make Theorem 4 more precise. This refinement allows one to write in a simple way the function fX,N in the formulation of Theorem 4 with the help of (4) and (8) from Chapter 2 and under a certain choice of the atlas (52) in the construction of the operator KA,x. Assume exactly one ray of (3) goes from point y to point II: for s > 0. Let C be the segment of the phase curve corresponding to it and let (w’, so) be the value of the ray coordinates (w, s) for which the ray passesthrough the point x. If x # y and (19) where x = x(w,z) is determined from (3), then the point x is called noncaustic. Let the function S = S(x, y) be equal to J,(~,dx) and y be the intersection index of C with the set of singular points E(n) = {< E A : &I6 = 0). If a single ray passesthrough the point x m times, we say that m rays pass through the point.
II. Asymptotics
of Solutions
to Exterior
BVP
83
Theorem 5. Let all the conditions of Theorem 4 befulfilled. Then 1) If exactly one ray from y” passesthrough the point x0 # y” for s > 0 and
the point x0 is not caustic, then this condition holds for all the points (x, y) in some neighborhood U c Iw2” of the point (x0, y’), and there exist functions aj(x, y) such that ei(x, y) = 5
aj(z, y)X”-t-”
x
j=o
(20)
cos
,++j)]
dis(x,y)-; [
Here for any compact set K
dd dXjdxc,dyP Further,
+ ew(x,
( c
Y) .
U, any j 2 0, a, ,B, (x, y) E K and X --+ M
eA,N(x, y) 2 CA*+*,
C=C(d,K,N).
if A = A, then aj = aj for all j and ao(x, y) = 1/5(271.)-9
[a(y,w)]-2
,
where w is the value of the ray coordinate corresponding to the ray going from the point y through the point x. 2) If m rays passfrom y” through x0 for s > 0 and condition (19) holds for them all, then it also holds for all points in some neighborhood U of the point (x0, y’), and ei is represented for (x, y) E U in the form of a sum of terms, each of which corresponds to its ray and has the form (20). 3) If the rays emanating from the point y = x0 do not return to that point, then this condition holds for all points x in some neighborhood V c IP of the point x0, and there exist functions a3(x) such that ei(x,x)
= ~ak(x)X~.‘-”
+ eA,N(x) .
(21)
k=O
Here a’(x) = :(27r-” and for all compacta Q @+lal -eA,N(x) dXjdX”
c
/
dp
4z,P)
C=W,a,Q,W.
If exactly m rays emanating from the point x = y” return back to that point for s > 0 and satisfy condition (19) at their return, then this condition holds for all points x in some neighborhood V c R2” of the point x0 and ei(x,x) is representable in the form of a sum of the expressions obtained for ei in
sections 3 and 2 (in the latter it is necessary to set y = x).
B. R. Vainberg
84
We note that the principal term in the asymptotics of the function ei(2, X) depends on the value of the coefficients of the operator A only at the point 2. The lower order terms do not have this local character and depend on the geodesic loops. Moreover, the main contribution of derivatives in x or X to the asymptotics is brought by geodesic loops. For n = 2, this is true for first order derivatives already, for n = 3, second order. For n = 3, the degree of the first derivative of expressions (20) for y = 5 and (21) is equal.
2.2. Systems proved
exactly
of First
as Theorem
Order
Equations.
The
following
assertion
is
4 is.
Theorem 6. Let the operator (13) satisfy the no-trapping condition and be formally self-adjoin& and let the matrices Mj(x) be independent of x and the matrix N(x) be zero for 1x1 >> 1. Let ei be the kernel of the (matrix) operator dEx/dX, where {Ex} is the spectral family of the operator (13). Then for any b < DC), j > 0, Q, ,B and N, 1x1, lyl < b and X --+ fco
there
exists
a C =
C(d, b, N)
such
that for
A consequence of this theorem is an analogue of Theorem 5. Commentary
on the Literature Chapter
1
There are five different approaches to the study of the behavior for t + 00 of the solutions of exterior mixed boundary value problems for hyperbolic equations and systems. One of them (cf. Eidus 1964, 1969, Mikhailov 1967, Mizohahta and Mochizuku 1966, Mochizuku 1969, Matsumura 1970) is based on representing the solution, via the theorem on spectral decomposition, in the form of an oscillating integral over the spectrum of the corresponding stationary problem. This integral can be successfully investigated if the properties (smoothness, estimates) of the spectral function are known. This method usually does not allow obtaining the asymptotic expansion of the solution, but only estimates of it, which are additionally not uniform in the set of initial conditions. The latter seriously reduces the possibility of applying results obtained by this method to the asymptotic investigation of the corresponding stationary problems. A further inadequacy of the method lies in the requirement that the problem be symmetric. In the articles by Morawetz (1962) and Lax and Phillips (1963) (see also Zachmanoglou (1963) and Morawetz, Ludwig, and Strauss (1977)), new energy estimates are found which allow determination of the decay rate for t -+ 00 of the local energy of solutions of the exterior problem for second order equations. More refined results for the wave equation on the exterior of a strictly convex body in two and three dimensions can be obtained with the help of a special reduction of the problem to an integral equation on the boundary, see for example Babich (1972), Muravei (1970, 1973), Babich and Grigor’ev (1974).
II. Asymptotics
of Solutions
to Exterior
BVP
The fourth approach to studying the behavior as t + co of solutions of non-stationary problems, presented in Lax and Phillips (1967) (see also Lax and Phillips (1971), Iwasaki (1969)), is b ase d on using the group properties of the solutions and the theory of scattering. Finally, the fifth approach, developed in this section, is due to this author (cf. 1974, 1975, 1982, and the references given there), and the article by Ladyzhenskaya (1957) served as a starting point. We note that this last approach allows one to obtain all of the results which follow from the theory of scattering, but without the restrictions imposed on the problem when studying it using that theory. Problems in which the no-trapping condition does not hold are examined in Ralston (1969), Majda and Ralston (1978a, 197813, 1979), Lazutkin (1981), Bardos, Guillot, and Ralston (1982), Petkov and Popov (1982), and Ikawa (1983). Several other results on the asymptotics for t --+ 00 of solutions to wave problems are contained in Wilcox (1978)) Mochizuku (1982)) and Gushchin and Mikhailov (1986). Further development of the results covered in this section is contained in Rauch (1978), Ralston (1976), Murata (1983), Melrose (1983), and Menzala and Schonbek (1984). A large list of works on the properties of the resolvent of a stationary operator is included in V. (1982, , see the supplement to chapter 9). Chapter
2
Theorems l-3 are obtained in V. (1977a, 1977b) (see V. (1982) also). A theorem analogous to Theorem 3 was announced in Guillemin (1977). The asymptotics of a function f for arbitrary 0 is contained in Protas (1982). The asymptotics for Ic -+ 00 of the Green’s function for equation (1) was obtained earlier in Babich (1965) and in Kucherenko (1969). The quasiclassical aymptotics of the scattering amplitude of waves in a homogeneous medium in the exterior of a bounded object are investigated in Majda (1976), Majda and Taylor (1977), Melrose (1980), and Petkov (1980). Additional references can be found in Babich and Buldyrev (1972), V. (1982) (see Kucherenko and Osipov (1983) also). Chapter
3
A good familiarity with the asymptotics of the spectral function of elliptic operators on unbounded domains can be obtained from the works Arsen’ev (1967), Babich (1965, 1980), Kucherenko (1969), Buslaev (1971, 1975), Majda and Ralston (1978a, 197813, 1979), Morawetz, Ralston, and Strauss (1977), Ivrij and Shubin (1982), Popov and Shubin (1983), V. (1983, 1984, 1985), and Popov (1985). In particular, in Buslaev (1971, 1975) the asymptotic behavior of the spectral characteristics (including the kernel of the resolvent) of exterior problems for operators with constant coefficients in their principal terms. In Babich (1965) and Kucherenko (1969) the shortwave asymptotics for second order operators with variable coefficients in Iw” are obtained. In Popov and Shubin (1983) the full asymptotic development of the function ei for X --+ 00 is obtained for a second order operator, assuming the conditions of theorem (4) are fulfilled and with the additional assumptions that IZ - y[ < 1 and that the operator A has no geodesic loops, that is, no ray corresponding to problem (2) crosses any point twice. The answer in this case is given by an integral over the sphere Ye1 of some rapidly oscillating (as X + oo) function depending on the parameter w E s”-1. Some stronger results are contained in Popov (1985). The asymptotics of ei was obtained without the above additional assumptions by this
85
86
B. R. Vainberg author in (1983, 1984) in the form of an integral over S”-l of some family of canonical operators. The results of this section were published by the author in (1985). Simpler formulas for e; were obtained in Babich (1980), where the remainder term was small only in an average sense. In this last work the problem was investigated on a bounded domain, the asymptotics of ei were found for 2, y lying in some compact set in the domain, and the assumption that the operator was of second order was used in an essential way.
References* Agranovich, M. S., and Vishik, M. I. (1964): Elliptic problems with a parameter and parabolic problems of general type. Usp. Mat. Nauk 19, vol. 3, 53-161 (Russian), Zbl. 137,296 Arsen’ev, A. A. (1967): Asymptotics of the spectral function for the Schrodinger equation. J. Vychisl. Mat. Mat. Fiz. 7, 1298-1319 (Russian), Zbl. 162,163 Babich, V. M. (1965): The short-wave asymptotic form for the problem of a pointsource in an inhomogeneous medium. Zh. Vychisl. Mat. Mat. Fiz. 5, no. 5, 949951, Zbl. 167,243. English transl.: USSR Comput. Math., Math. Phys. 5, no. 5, 247-251 (1968) Babich, V. M. (1972): On the asymptotics of the Green’s function for some wave problems. Mat. Sb. 87, Ser. 87(129), 44-57 (Russian), Zbl. 251.35015 Babich, V. M. (1980): Hadamard’s method and the asymptotics of the spectral function for second order differential operators. Mat. Zametki 28, vol. 5, 689694. English transl.: Math. Notes 28, 800-803 (1981) Babich, V. M., and Buldyrev, V. C. (1972): Asymptotic Methods for Short Wave Diffraction Problems. Moscow: Nauka, 456 pp. (Russian), Zbl. 255.35002 Babich, V. M., and Grigor’ev, N. S. (1974): The analytic extension of the resolvent of outer three-dimensional problems for Laplace operators in the second sheet. Functs. Anal. Prilozh. 8, no. 1, 71-72. English transl.: Funct. Anal. Appl. 8, 62263 (1974) Zbl. 292.35064 Bardos, C., Guillot, J. C., and Ralston, J. (1982): La relation de Poisson pour l’equation des ondes dans un ouvert non borne. Application a la thkorie de la diffusion. Commun. Partial Differ. Equations, no. 7, 905-958, Zbl. 496.35067 Blekher, P. M. (1969): On operators depending meromorphically on a parameter. Vestn. Mosk. Univ., Ser. I, no. 5, 30-36, Zbl. 187,393. English transl.: Moscow Univ. Math. Bull. 24 (1972), Zbl. 243.47010 Buslaev, V. S. (1971): Scattering of plane waves, spectral ssymptotics and trace formulas in exterior problems. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 197, no. 5., 999-1002. English transl.: Sov. Math. Dokl. 12, 591-595 (1971), Zbl. 224.47023 Buslaev, V. S. (1975): On the asymptotic behavior of spectral characteristics of exterior problems for the Schriidinger operator. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR., Ser. Mat. Mekh. 39, no. 1, 149235 (Russian), Zbl. 311.35010 Eidus, D. M. (1964): The principle of limit amplitude. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 158, no. 4, 794-797. English transl.: Sov. Math. Dokl. 5, 1327-1330 (1965), Zbl. 141,299 * For the convenience of the reader, references to reviews in Zentralblatt fur Mathematik (Zbl.), compiled using the MATH database, and Jahrbuch iiber die Fortschritte der Mathematik (Jbuch) have, as far as possible, been included in this bibliography
II. Asymptotics
of Solutions
to Exterior
BVP
87
Eidus, D. M. (1969): The principle of limiting amplitude. Usp. Mat. Nauk 24, vol. 3, 91-156, Zbl. 177.142. English transl.: Russ. Math. Surv. 24, no. 3, 97-167 (1969), Zbl. 197.081 Guillemin, V. (1977): Sojourn times and asymptotic properties of the scattering matrix. Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci., Kyoto Univ. 12, Suppl. 69-88 Gushchin, A. K., and Mikhailov, V. P. (1986): On uniform quasi-asymptotics of the solution of the Cauchy problem for a hyperbolic equation. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 287, no. 1, 37-40. English. transl.: Sov. Math., Dokl. 33, 326-329 (1986), Zbl. 629.35072 Hormander, L. (1968): The spectral function of an elliptic operator. Acta Math. 121, 193-218, Zbl. 164,132 Hormander, L. (1971): Fourier integral operators. Acta Math. 127, no. 2, 79-183, Zbl. 212,466 Ikawa, M. (1983): On poles of the scattering matrix for two strictly convex obstacles. J. Math. Kyoto Univ. 23, no. 1, 127-194, Zbl. 561.35060 Ivrij, V. M. (1978): The propagation of singularities of solutions of the wave equation near the boundary. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 239, 7722774. English transl.: Sov. Math. Dokl. 19, 400-402 (1978), Zbl. 398.35057 Ivrij, V. M., and Shubin, M. A. (1982): On the asymptotics of the spectral shift function. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 263, no. 2, 283-284. English transl.: Sov. Math. Dokl. 25, 332-334 (1982), Zbl. 541.58047 Iwssaki, N. (1969): Local decay of solutions for symmetric hyperbolic systems with dissipative and coercive boundary conditions in exterior domains. Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci. 5, no. 2, 1933218, Zbl. 206,400 Kreiss, H.-O. (1970): Initial boundary value problems for hyperbolic systems. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 23, no. 3, 277-298, Zbl. 193,069 Kucherenko, V. V. (1969): Quasi-classical asymptotics of a point-source for the stationary Schrodinger equation. Teor. Mat. Fiz. 1, no. 3, 384-406 (Russian) Kucherenko, V. V., and Osipov, Yu. V. (1983): The Cauchy problem for non-strictly hyperbolic equations. Mat. Sb., Nov. Ser. 120, no. 1, 84-111 (Russian), Zbl. 519.35048 Ladyzhenskaya, 0. A. (1957): On the principle of limiting amplitude. Usp. Mat. Nauk 12, vol. 3, 161-164 (Russian) Lax, P., and Phillips, R. (1967): Scattering Theory. Academic Press, 276 pp., Zbl. 186,163 Lax, P., and Phillips, R. (1971): Scattering theory. Rocky Mt. J. Math. 1, no. 1, 173-223, Zbl. 225.35081 Lax, P., Morawetz, C., and Phillips, R. (1963): Exponential decay of solutions of the wave equation of a star-shaped obstacle. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 16, no. 4, 4777486, Zbl. 161,080 Lazutkin, V. F. (1981): Diffractive losses in open resonators: A Geometric Approach. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 258, no. 5, 10891092 (Russian) Lions, J., and Magenes, E. (1968): Problems aux Limites Non Homogenes et Applications. Paris 1, 372 pp., Zbl. 165,108 Majda, A. (1976): High frequency asymptotics for the scattering matrix and the inverse problem of acoustical scattering. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 29, no. 3, 261-291, Zbl. 463.35048 Majda, A., and Osher, S. (1975): Reflection of singularities at the boundary. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 28, 479-499, Zbl. 307.35077 Majda, A., and Ralston, J. (1978a): An analogue of Weyl’s formula for unbounded domains I. Duke Math. J. 45, 183-196, Zbl. 408.35069 Majda, A., and Ralston, J. (197813): A n analogue of Weyl’s formula for unbounded domains II. Duke Math. J. 45, 513-536, Zbl. 416.35058
88
B. R. Vainberg
Majda, A., and Ralston, J. (1979): A n analogue of Weyl’s formula for unbounded domains III. Duke Math. 3. 46, 725-731, Zbl. 433.35055 Majda, A., and Taylor, M. (1977): The asymptotic behavior of the diffraction peak in classical scattering. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 30, no. 5,639%669, Zbl. 357.35007 Maslov, V. P. (1973): Operator Methods. Moscow: Nauka, 543 pp. (Russian) Maslov, V. P., and Fedoryuk, M. V. (1981): S emi-Classical Approximation in Quantum Mechanics. Dordrecht, Holland, 301 pp. Matsumura, M. (1970): Comportement asymptotique de solutions de certains problemes mixtes pour des syst&mes hyperboliques sym&riques a coefficients constants. Publ. Res. Inst. Mat,h. Sci. Kyoto Univ. 5, no. 3, 301-360, Zbl. 242.35056 Melrose, R. (1980): Forward scattering by a convex obstacle. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 30, no. 5, 461-499, Zbl. 435.35066 Melrose, R. (1983): Polynomial bound on the number of scattering poles. J. Funct. Anal. 53, no. 1, 287-303, Zbl. 535.35067 Melrose, R., and Sjijstrand, J. (1978): Singularities of boundary value problems I. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 31, 593-617, Zbl. 378.35014 Menzala, G. P., and Schonbek, T. (1984): Scattering frequencies for the wave equation with a potential term. J. Funct. Anal. 55, no. 3, 297-322, Zbl. 536.35060 Mikhailov, V. P. (1967): On the stabilization of the solution of a non-stationary bounded problem. Tr. Mat. Inst. Steklova 91, loo-112 (Russian), Zbl. 162,152 Mishchenko, A. S., Sternin, B. Yu., and Shatalov, V. E. (1978): Lagrangian manifolds and the canonical operator method. Moscow: Nauka, 352 pp. (Russian) Mizohata, S., and Mochizuku, K. (1966): On the principle of limiting amplitude for dissipative wave equations. J. Math. Kyoto Univ. 6, no. 1, 109$127, Zbl. 173,371 Mochizuku, K. (1969): The principle of limiting amplitude for symmetric hyperbolic systems in an exterior domain. Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci. Kyoto Univ. 5, no. 2, 259-265, Zbl. 206,110 Mochizuku, K. (1982): Asymptotic wave functions and energy distributions for long range perturbations of the d’Alembert equations. J. Math. Sot. Jap. 34, no. 1, 143-171, Zbl. 475.76077 Morawetz, C. (1962): The limiting amplitude principle. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 15, no. 3, 349-361, Zbl. 196,412 Morawetz, C., and Ludwig, D. (1969): The generalized Huygens’ principle for reflecting bodies. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 22, no. 2, 189-206, Zbl. 172,383 Morawetz, C., Ralston, J., and Strauss, W. (1977): Decay of solutions of the wave equations outside nontrapping obstacles. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 30, no. 4, 447-508, Zbl. 372.35008 Murata, M. (1983): High energy resolvent estimates I, first order operators. J. Math. Sot. Jap. 35, no. 4, 711-733, Zbl. 522.35013 Muravei, L. A. (1970): Asymptotic behavior of solutions to the second exterior boundary value problem for the two-dimensional wave equation. Differ. Uravn. 6, no. 12, 2248-2262, Zbl. 218,232. English transl.: Diff. Eq. 6, 1709-1720 (1973), Zbl. 263.35054 Muravei, L. A. (1973): Large-time symptotic behavior of solutions to the second and third boundary value problems for the wave equation with two space variables. Tr. Mat. Inst. Steklova 126, 73-144 (Russian), Zbl. 284.35005 Petkov, V. (1980): High frequency asymptotics of the scattering amplitude for nonconvex bodies. Commun. Partial Differ. Equations 5, 293-329, Zbl. 435.35065 Petkov, V., and Popov, G. S. (1982): Asymptotic behaviour of the scattering phase for nontrapping obstacles. Ann. Inst. Fourier 32, no. 3, 111-149, Zbl. 497.35009 Popov, G. S., and Shubin, M. A. (1983): Asymptotic expansion of the spectral function for second-order elliptic operators in Iw”. Funkts. Anal. Prilozh. 17, no. 3, 37-45. English transl.: Funct. Anal. Appl. 17, 193-200 (1983), Zbl. 533.35072
II.
Asymptotics
of Solutions
to Exterior
BVP
89
Popov, G. S. (1985): Spectral asymptotics for elliptic second-order differential operators. J. Math. Kyoto Univ. 25, 6599681 (1985), Zbl. 598.35081 Protas, Yu. N. (1982): Quasi-classical asymptotics of the scattering amplitude of a plane wave in an inhomogeneous medium. Mat. Sb. Nov. Ser. 117 (159), no. 4, 494-515 (Russian), Zbl. 508.35065 Ralston, J. (1969): Solutions of the wave equation with localized energy. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 22, no. 6, 807-823, Zbl. 209,404 Ralston, J. (1976): Note on the decay of acoustic waves. Duke Math. J. 46, no. 4, 799-804, Zbl. 427.35043 Rauch, J. (1978): Asymptotic behaviour of solutions to hyperbolic partial differential equations with zero speed. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 31, no. 4, 431-480, Zbl. 378.35044 Sakamoto, R. (1970): Mixed problems for hyperbolic equations, I. Energy inequalities. J. Math. Kyoto Univ. 10, no. 2, 3499373, Zbl. 203,180 Sanchez-Palencia, E. (1980): Non-homogeneous media and vibration theory. Lect. Notes Phys., 127 pp. Taylor, M. (1976): Grazing rays and reflection of singularities of solutions to wave equations. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 29, no. 1, l-38, Zbl. 318.35009 Tikhonov, A. N., and Samarskij, A. A. (1953): The equations of mathematical physics. Moscow: Gostekhizdat, 679 pp. English transl.: Oxford, 1963, Zbl. 111,290 Vainberg, B. R. (1974): Behavior for large-time of solutions to the Klein-Gordon equation. Tr. Mosk. Mat. O.-va 30, 139-158 (Russian), Zbl. 318.35051. English transl.: Trans. Moscow Math. Sot. 30, 139-159 (1974) Vainberg, B. R. (1975): On short-wave asymptotic behaviour of solutions to stationary problems and the asymptotic behaviour as t + cc of solutions of nonstationary problems. Usp. Mat. Nauk 30, vol. 2, 3-55, Zbl. 308.35011. English transl.: Russ. Math. Surv. 30, no. 2, l-58) (1975), Zbl. 318.35006 Vainberg, B. R. (1977a): Statinonary problems in scattering theory and the largetime behavior of solutions of non-stationary problems for large values of time. Moscow: Mosk. Univ. Publ., 58-62 (Russian), Zbl. 498.35068 Vainberg, B. R. (197713): Quasi-classical approximation in stationary scattering problems. F’unkts. Anal. Prilozh. 11, no. 4, 6-18, Zbl. 381.35022. English transl.: Funct. Anal. Appl. 11, no. 4, 427-457 (1978), Zbl. 413.35025 Vainberg, B. R. (1982): Asymptotic Methods in Equations of Mathematical Physics. Moscow: Mosk. Univ. Publ., 294 pp., Zbl. 518.35002. English transl.: New York: Gordon and Breach Science Publ., 498 pp., 1989, Zbl. 743.35001 Vainberg, B. R. (1983): A complete asymptotic expansion of a spectral function of elliptic operators in Iw”. Vestn. Mosk. Univ., Ser. I, no. 4, 29-36, Zbl. 547.35050. English transl.: Moscow Univ. Math. Bull. 38, no. 4, 32239 (1983) Vainberg, B. R. (1984): The complete asymptotic expansion of the spectral function of second-order elliptic operators in Iw”. Mat. Sb., Nov. Ser. 123, no. 2, 195-211, Zbl. 573.35070. English transl.: Math. USSR, Sbornik 51, no. 1, 191-206 (1985) Vainberg, B. R. (1985): On the parametrix and the asymptotics of the spectral function of differential operators in Iw”. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 282, no. 2, 265269, Zbl. 617.35098. English transl.: Sov. Math. Dokl. 31, no. 3, 456-460 (1985) Vainberg, B. R. (1990): Asymptotic behaviour as t -+ 00 of solutions of exterior mixed problems periodic with respect to t. Mat. Zametki 47, no. 4, 6-16. English transl.: Math. Notes 47, no. 4, 315-322 (1990), Zbl. 708.35015 Wilcox, C. (1978): Asymptotic wave functions and energy distributions in strongly propagative anisotropic media. J. Math. Pures Appl., IX. Ser. 57, 2755321, Zbl. 409.35064 Zachmanoglou, E. (1963): The decay of the initial-boundary value problem for the wave equation in unbounded regions. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 14, no. 4, 312325, Zbl. 168,80
III. The Higher-Dimensional WKB Method or Ray Method. Its Analogues and Generalizations V. M. Babich Translated from the Russian by J. S. Joel
Contents Introduction..................................................... Chapter
1. Fundamental
Non-Local
93 Short-Wave
Expansions.
..........
94
31. The Classical Ray Method. .................................... 94 94 1.1. The Starting Formulas ................................... 96 1.2. The Eikonal Equation ................................... 97 1.3. Rays and Ray Coordinates ............................... 98 1.4. Integration of the Transport Equations. .................... 99 1.5. Discussion of the Our Results ............................. 100 1.6. Reflection and Refraction of Ray Solutions ................. 102 $2. Point Source of Vibrations in an Inhomogeneous Medium. ......... 2.1. Ansatz.................................................lO 2 .103 2.2. Transport Equations. ................................... 104 2.3. Discussion of Our Results ................................ §3. Short-Wave Expansion in a Neighborhood 105 of a Nonsingular Piece of a Caustic ............................. 3.1. Basic Assumptions .105 ..................................... 3.2. The Analytic Character of an Eikonal Close to a Caustic ..... 106 108 3.3. Asymptotics of a Solution ................................
V. M. Babich
92
Chapter
2. Some Modifications
of the Ray and Caustic
Expansions.
$1. Asymptotics of Vibrations of Whispering Gallery Type 1.1. The Ray Method in the Small . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Boundary Conditions and Transport Equations . 1.3. Analogues and Generalizations . . . .. . .. . . . .. . . . $2. Surface Wave Propagated Along an Impedance Surface 2.1. Initial Statements. Ansatz . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. Construction of the Asymptotics of a Solution . . Chapter
3. Gaussian
Beams and Their Applications
.. .. .. .. .. .. ..
.. ..
4. On Other Short-Wave
Diffraction
.. .. .. ..
.. .. ..
110 110 112 113 114 114 115
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .116
$1. Solutions Concentrated in a Neighborhood of a Fixed Ray . . . 1.1. Statement of the Problem. Ansatz . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Determination of r(O), r(l), and T(~) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3. Determination of ~i~,,.i~, ujil,,,ih . . . . .. . .. . . . . . .. $2. The Case of a Closed Ray .. . . .. . . .. . .. . . .. . . .. . .. . .. 2.1. Properties of the System of Jacobi Equations . . . . . . . . . 2.2. Construction of Quasimodes in the Case of a Closed Ray in the First Approximation .. . . . .. . .. 2.3. Higher Approximations . . .. . .. . . . .. . . . .. . . .. . . . 93. Summation of Gaussian Beams. . .. . .. . . . .. . . .. . .. . . . .. . . 3.1. Basic Ideas of the Method (see Babich and P an k ra t ova (1973) and Popov (1981)) . 3.2. Application of the Method of Stationary Phase. . . . . . Chapter
. . . 110
Problems
.. .. .. .. .. ..
116 116 118 119 120 120
. . . . 121 . . . . 121 . . 123 . . . . 123 . . 125
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125
$1. The Case of Smooth Reflecting Boundaries .. . . . .. . .. . . .. . . . 1.1. Fock’s Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Point Sources of Vibrations on the Boundary of a Domain (see Babich (1979), Babich and Buldyrev (1972), and Buslaev (1975)) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $2. Various Problems. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. The Problem of the Change of Sign of the Curvature (Babich and Smyshlyaev (1984), Popov (1979)) . . . . . . . 2.2. Problems with Sharp Edges and Screens . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . 125 . . . .125
. . . ..
127 128
. . . .128 . . . . 129 . . . .130
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
93
Introduction In this paper we shall discuss the construction of formal short-wave asymptotic solutions of problems of mathematical physics. The topic is very broad. It can somewhat conveniently be divided into three parts: 1. Finding the short-wave asymptotics of a rather narrow classof problems, which admit a solution in an explicit form, via formulas that represent this solution. 2. Finding formal asymptotic solutions of equations that describe wave processesby basing them on some ansatz or other. We explain what 2 means. Giving an ansatz is knowing how to give a formula for the desired asymptotic solution in the form of a series or some expression containing a series, where the analytic nature of the terms of these seriesis indicated up to functions and coefficients that are undetermined at the first stage of consideration. The second stage is to determine these functions and coefficients using a direct substitution of the ansatz in the equation, the boundary conditions and the initial conditions. Sometimes it is necessary to use different ansatze in different domains, and in the overlapping parts of these domains the formal asymptotic solutions must be asymptotically equivalent (the method of matched asymptotic expansions). The basis for success in the search for formal asymptotic solutions is a suitable choice of ansatze. The study of the asymptotics of explicit solutions of special model problems allows us to “surmise” what the correct ansatze are for the general solution. 3. The proof of the solvability of the problem of mathematical physics under consideration and the fact that the formal asymptotic solution constructed via suitably chosen ansatze actually represents the asymptotic behavior of a solution of this problem. In the present paper we shall mainly discussthe problem of finding asymptotic solutions via ansatze, that is, constructions making up the second part of this topic. We give some (well known) definitions. Let ‘pj(z, e), j = 1,2,3, be a function of a point x E 6) c R” and a parameter c, which varies in some fixed interval 0 < c < ~0. In addition, let f(z, E) be a fixed positive uniformly bounded function for x E R, 0 < E < ~0, defined where ‘pj(x, E) is. Definition
1. The series
is called an asymptotic Ipj(x,e)I
5 AjeB3f(x,e);
expansion
if the following
Aj, Bj = const,
estimates Bj --+ +oo
hold: as j ---) +CO.
(2)
The following Definition 2 and the concept of an asymptotic expansion of a solution u (see formula (4)) goes back to the classical works of Henri
94
V. M. Babich
Poincare on the method of small parameters in celestial mechanics. Let C be a differential operator. Definition 2. An asymptotic expansion of the equation Cu = 0 if
(1) is called
a formal
asymptotic
solution
IC(cpl + (p2+ . . . + cpj)l 5 CjED” f(x, t);
03 + +CC as j + +CO.
(3)
For many problems of mathematical physics, in particular, for practically all problems that are of interest for applications, the following marvelous thing happens: if we have been able to construct some asymptotic solution of the problem under consideration (where all the ‘pj are smooth and constructed uniquely), then for sufficiently small Ethere exists a unique classical or generalized solution of the problem of mathematical physics, and the formal asymptotic solution gives the asymptotics of this ordinary solution, that is, in its domain of definition the following inequality holds:
Here u is the ordinary solution and Fj -+ +co as j --+ DC).The proof of inequalities of the type (4) .1soft en a very difficult problem, which requires, as a rule, the application of a mathematical apparatus that is different from the one required for the construction of the ‘pj. This mathematical apparatus is based principally on the technique of a priori estimates of solutions of problems of mathematical physics.
Fundamental
Chapter 1 Non-Local Short-Wave
Expansions
fjl. The Classical Ray Method 1.1. The Starting Formulas. The short-wave asymptotics of problems of mathematical physics is important by virtue of its applications,both inside of mathematics (for example, the problem of finding the asymptotics of the spectral function of elliptic differential operators) and in physics and engineering physics (for example: the construction of theoretical seismograms). Here we shall not concern ourselves with the numerous and important applications of short-wave expansions, but endeavor to give a brief survey of the main ideas of this area of mathematical physics. These ideas can be conveniently illustrated using the comparatively simple model example of the wave equation with variable velocity: 1
-wtt(x)C2(X)
Aw = 0;
x= (xl,...
(1)
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB Method or Ray Method
95
Here the function C(X) is positive and infinitely differentiable in the domain in which it will be considered. The surfaces and functions that occur in what follows will be assumed to be infinitely differentiable. Instead of “infinitely differentiable function” (or surface) we shall generally write “smooth function” (or surface). ,In the present paper only solutions of equation (1) are considered that depend harmonically on time. More general variants of the dependence of w on time, which are important from both the practical and the theoretical point of view of space-time ray expansions, their analogues and modifications (see Babich, Buldyrev and Molotkov (1985) and Whitham (1974)) will have to be omitted in order to keep this paper to a manageable size. We set w = u(x) exp(-iwt). (2) The function
u satisfies
the Helmholtz
equation
with variable
coefficients:
(A+&)u=O,
(3)
The number w is a large parameter for the problem. The term “nonlocal” in the title of this chapter means that the range of applicability of the expansions obtained in this chapter does not depend on w. Of fundamental significance in what follows is the following ansatz, sometimes called a ray expunsion: u
=
y = const,
ewl) g
(-Y$i+,)
(4) C-4 j+‘=exp[-q(j+y)], (where T and uj are real functions subject to determination). As a rule ray expansions diverge. Formula (4) simply means that the letter u denotes the formal series exp iwr C C--iIj3+7. The ray expansion (4) is obviously a natural multidimensional analogue of the WKB-expansion [Fedoryuk (1983)]. Substituting expansion (4) in equation (3), assuming that 2~0# 0 and setting the coefficients of successive powers of w equal to zero, we arrive at the equations:
(W”=& 2VrVuj
+ujAr
= AIL-~,
v= (& >...>-& ) , u-~ ~0; j = O,l,....
(5)
(6)
The desired function r is called an eikonal and equation (5) is called the equation. The recursive equations (6) are so-called transport equations.
eikonal
V. M. Babich
96
1.2. The Eikonal Equation. The eikonal equation (5) is integrated by a traditional method using the method of characteristics (see the classical treatments by Smirnov (1981) and Courant (1962)). Before we give a system of characteristic equations, we write equation (5) in the form: H 3 ;c’(x)
-&I;
= a;
d-r pj=dlcj.
j=l
The
characteristic
system dxj ds=$
of equations dH
dp, ds
for (7) has the canonical aH, dxi ’
dr ds
form:
l
In order to define a Cauchy problem with initial data on some m - ldimensional hypersurface C c R” it is necessary that the eikonal r on C coincide with a given function which is denoted by I/X rlc = $, and necessary that the sign of 2 be given (n is a continuously varying normal to C). In what follows C will simply be called a surface. For the (local) Cauchy problem to be solvable it suffices to require that any derivative of the initial function $ along the surface C be less than l/c in modulus. The method of characteristics in this problem can be presented using variational ideas. Indeed: it is easy to show that the characteristic system (8) is equivalent to the system of Euler equations for the functional (which is sometimes called the Fermat functional)
(9) if as a parameter on the extremals we take the value of the integral s” ds/c, counted from a fixed point on the corresponding extremal. These extremals, following a long-established tradition, are called rays. This terminology is completely compatible with the physical concept of a ray. The first m equations of the system (8) can be written in the form
We have used the eikonal equation and the equalities dr/dxj = pj (see (7)). We return to the Cauchy problem. We outline the process for solving it. Knowing ~1~ = 11, and the sign of dr/dn and using the eikonal equation we can find all the derivatives dr/dxi, j = 1,2,. . . , m, and, hence, we can find the direction of the vector VT. From each point x0 E C a ray is emitted in the direction of VrlzO. Such a ray exists and there is only one of them. We now set
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
97
z$ r(x)=$(x0) f J20 The integral is taken along a ray joining 20 and IC, with a “+” (respectively, a “-” ) sign if LI: is located on the side of C to which the normal n is directed (respectively, if 2 is in the domain for which n is an exterior normal). Formula (1.1) also defines a solution of the Cauchy problem for the eikonal equation. It is not hard to see that this recipe for constructing a solution of the Cauchy problem is the same as the usual method of constructing this solution by the method of characteristics. The distinction is only terminological. 1.3. Rays and Ray Coordinates. A solution to the eikonal equation is easy to construct using rays, that is, extremals of the Fermat functional (9). These extremals are obviously geodesics of the Riemannian metric with square of the length element (ds2) equal to
2 (dx92 j=l c”(x). Thus, the theory of rays and along with it the theory of the eikonal equation can be considered as a special case of Riemannian geometry. Suppose the function q = C = const (see 31.2 above). The gradient of the eikonal T must be orthogonal to this level surface, and thus the rays from which T(X) is constructed must be orthogonal to C, that is, because of (10) VT and dzldH are only different by a positive multiplicative factor. Suppose the points on C are characterized by the parameters ol, cr2,. . . , am-‘. We shall characterize the points on the ray passing through ZO((Y’, . , cP-‘) E C in terms of the value of the integral f srz1 ds/c = 7 ( 5, ~0). The “+” sign is taken in case z is located on the side of C to which the normal n is directed and the “-” sign otherwise. The coordinate system (cx’, CX~, . . . , CL?-‘, r) is semigeodesic in the terminology of Riemannian geometry. It is regular close to C. In works on diffraction theory o?, 02, . . , o?-’ , r are called ray coordinates. Suppose that theformulaszj =~j(c~~,c~~,...,cP-~, T), j = 1,2,. . , m, or, in vector form, x = x(d,a2,. . . ) a--l, r) realize the transition from the coordinate system CY~,r to Cartesian coordinates. Fixing cy’, . . , G-l, we obtain the parametric equation of a ray, and, having fixed r, we obtain a level surface of the eikonal Another variant of ray coordinates is obtained by considering the central field of rays, that is, the set of rays issuing from a single point ~0. In order to define a ray it suffices to define a unit vector se directed along the ray at the point ~0. The end of the vector SO traces out the unit sphere [se/ = 1. Let al,. . . , am--l be coordinates on the sphere. By defining ol,. . . , am-’ we define se and thus a ray. The points on the ray will be characterized by the magnitude of the integral sZ: ds/c (th e integral is taken over a ray joining 20 and x). Thus a coordinate system ol, . , am-‘, r is defined in a neighborhood
V. M. Babich
98
of the point 20, and this coordinate system is also called “ray coordinates”. Let si be the components of the unit vector se. We can also take -r& = Xj as coordinates. The coordinates {Xj} are the classical Riemannian normal coordinates. The Riemannian normal coordinates will be essential in Section 2. The ray coordinates o?, . . . , cZ’-’ , r give us the possibility of integrating the transport equations (6). 1.4. Integration of the Transport Equations. We shall assumethat a ray coordinate system ol,. . . , am-‘, r has been introduced. We first turn to the first transport equation
2VueVr Multiplying
+ t&J& = 0.
(12)
this equation by ~0, we give it the divergence form div(z@r)
= 0.
(13)
We shall derive a formula that allows us to integrate equation (13). Suppose the vector A in the coordinate system o?, . . , cP-‘, r has contravariant components 0, 0, . . . , z$/c” . In Cartesian coordinates its components will be 87 z&c” = 21;:
dXi
-. dr
8x2
(we have used formula (10) here). Writing the expression for div(U$r) coordinate system (aj, r), we obtain the equality divA
= div(uiVr)
where
Here D(xj)/D(
(14)
= +c&
1 D(ri,...,xm) c D(d, . . . ) a-1,
J=-
in the
T) ’
(15)
oj, r) is the Jacobian. The quantity J is called the geometric
spreading.
In the caseof the plane m = 2 and three dimensions m = 3, J is respectively equal to J=
and
dz I da’
J=i&x&i,
I
where x denotes the vector product. Formula (14) also gives the possibility of solving equation (12) or the equivalent equation (13). It follows from (13) and (14) that ug 5 = const on each ray, from which we find uo = ?fQo(&
. . . ) a”-‘)~.
(16)
The modulus symbol has been omitted on the left-hand side by assuming that ue does not change sign. The function $0 depends only on the ray. The
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
99
equation for the uj (see (6)) is easy to integrate by the classical method of variation of constants. Setting uj = ZL~U~, where II~ is a new unknown function, which is easy to find, using formula (lo),
from which Uj
we find =I@
$j(C2,...,CEm-1 ) +
~~(al,,,,,am-l,
,?Aui-ldT] 0
[
.
(17)
The
integral is taken along the ray. The functions $i, usually called the diffraction coefficients, and the function T&G,. . ) am-l) remain undetermined for now. In order to find them we need additional information about the desired expansion. 1.5. Discussion of the Our Results. We return to the ray expansion (4). The expression exp(-iwt + iw7) is called the phase factor. It remains constant on the moving surfaces S: t - T(X) = C = const, called wave fronts. We define the velocity u of the moving surface 5’. Suppose that a point x lies on S at time t. We construct a normal to 5’ at x and fix it. The velocity ~(5, t) of the moving surface S is the velocity of the point of intersection of S with this normal at time t. It is not hard to see that in our case v(x, t) = C(X)UT/lUTl
= c(x)so,
(18)
where so is a unit vector directed along the ray at the point 20. We return to the first approximation of the ray method uo exp(-iwt + iw~(z)). Using the approximation uo (x) X5 uo(xo), close to 5, we find up to principal uo exp(-iwt
+ LX-(X))
4x1
= 7(x0)
terms
+ P~)z,(X
- x0)
that
z exp(-iwt+iW(VT),O(x
- x0))
~uoexpiw~(xo).
Thus, in a neighborhood of a given point the first approximation of the ray method represents a plane wave, which is an exact solution of the wave equation Au - utt/c2(z0) = 0. The ray approximation can therefore be considered as a perturbation of a plane wave. In physics literature the vector wVr is denoted by k and is called the wave vector. The eikonal equation can be written in the form w = w(k), where w(k) = clkl. Physicists usually call the equation that expresses w as a function of k a “dispersion equation”. The equation w = cl ICI,equivalent to the eikonal equation, is the simplest example of a dispersion equation. Formula (13)) which gives the possibility of integrating the transport equation, admits an interesting energetic interpretation (see the book by Babich and Buldyrev (1972)), but we shall not go into this.
V. M. Babich
100
1.6. Reflection and expansion of the form U
inc
Refraction
of Ray
=
) .z
exp(iw?
Solutions.
Let uinc be a ray
?A~“,(-iwy
(19)
defined on one side of the surface C (see Fig. 1 below) and suppose that the normal n to C is directed to the side “illuminated” by the incident wave. We shall assume that drinc/dnlc < 0. The problem is to find a “reflected” ray expansion uref : u ref = exp(-iwrref)
2 uTf/(-iw)j, j=O
such that drref/dnl c > 0 and such that formally relation is equivalent to the series of equalities
(20)
uinc + uref 1c = 0. The
last
The condition drref/dnlc > 0, equality (21) and equation (5) determine rref. We can regard relation (22) as Cauchy data for the transport equations (6), in which we must substitute rref (respectively, uTf) for r (respectively, for uj). Thus, uref is uniquely determined from the incident ray solution uinc. The case of the boundary condition
&(uinc + Pf)lC = 0 is considered
analogously.
Fig. 1 We consider an example. Let R c R” be a bounded domain, bounded by a surface C. Suppose C has positive curvature everywhere. This means that the Gauss second fundamental form of the surface C is positive definite at every point. We consider the case C(X) EE 1. Assume that the following plane wave is incident on C: m U
inc
= exp(i&“‘),
7inc = xjpj;
C$ j=l
= 1.
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB Method or Ray Method
101
(A plane wave is obviously a special case of a ray expansion.) The problem of finding the reflected wave, satisfying the Helmholtz equation (3), for c = 1, the radiation conditions, and whose sum with the incident wave vanishes on E is a classical well-posed problem. The question arises of how to find the short-wave asymptotics of the reflected wave as w + 0~). The ray method gives the possibility of finding this asymptotics in the domain illuminated by the incident wave (see Fig. 2; the rays in the case C(X) = 1 are straight lines), following the scheme outlined above. One can show that the ray expansion of the reflected wave ceases to be an asymptotic expansion in approaching the shadow zone from the illuminated domain (in the so-called penumbral zone). The short-wave asymptotics in the shadow and penumbral zones have a considerably more complicated form than the wave expansion.
Rays of the incident wave
Rays of the reflected wave
Fig. 2 The natural question arises of what the formal constructions outlined here are related to. Indeed, in spite of the naturality of our constructions from the physical point of view and their relative simplicity, it does not at all follow from them that our ray series exp(iwVef) . Cc, uTf/(-iw)j actually gives the asymptotics of the reflected wave. In the case when the reflected wave can be constructed explicitly (a ball, an ellipsoid), the proof of the fact that the ray expansion gives the asymptotics of the reflected wave can be obtained by analyzing the explicit solution. However this approach is not simple even in the case of a ball, and in the case of an ellipsoid the corresponding computations are extremely cumbersome and the resulting technical difficulties have not been overcome by anyone. In the general case the justification of the ray expansion requires the consideration of formal short-wave asymptotics of the reflected wave in the whole domain Rm\Q and successive estimates of the remainder term. Problems of this kind were posed rather recently and were studied by Ursell, Babich, Ludwig, and Morawetz. The most complete results, from which, in particular, the justification of the expansion for the
V. M. Babich
102
reflected wave constructed here follows, were obtained by Buslaev [Buslaev (1975)]. References to earlier works are contained in the book by Babich and Buldyrev (1972) and the article by Buslaev (1975). The problem of the rigorous justification of asymptotics in the deep shadow zone (see Section 1 of Chapter 4 in this connection) was solved rather recently [Zayaev and Filippov (1984)] (in the plane case) using very delicate analytic considerations. We briefly discuss the question of refraction. Suppose now that the surface C separates two domains L’i and 02 in which the velocities cl in L’r and c2 in K&J are generally different. The incident wave will be defined by its ray expansion in the domain fir, close to C, and it is assumed that drinc/dnlc < 0. (It is assumed that the normal n is directed to the interior of L’i.) Suppose that the classical boundary conditions
7J1qc = u(2)Ic,
&(l)/dn[,
= dt~(~)/thl~
are defined on C. (Here u(~)]~ and &A(~)/&]~ are the limit values of the corresponding functions, starting from the values in &.) The reflected and refracted waves are sought in the form of ray expansions, where the corresponding eikonals satisfy the equalities
and the inequalities d7-‘ef/lh(c
> 0,
d7-refr/th(c
< 0.
If the tangential derivatives drinc/dZ of ?nclC satisfy the inequality of the reflected and refracted waves pT’““/dzl < l/ ~2, then the construction is carried out just like the construction of the reflected wave outlined above. If ]dGC/dl] > 1/ c2 f or certain tangential directions, then it is necessary to introduce a complex eikonal (see Chapter 2).
$2. Point
Source
of Vibrations
in an Inhomogeneous
Medium
2.1. Ansatz. The ray expansion loses its asymptotic nature in a neighborhood of the point set where the geometric spreading vanishes: the principal term of the ray expansion is already infinite for J = 0. In neighborhoods of the points where J = 0, another form of asymptotic expansion, different from (4), is necessary, i.e., another ansatz. In this section we consider the case of a point source of vibrations, when the equation describing the wave process has the form:
(A+&)
?A= -S(z - 2lj),
(23)
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
103
with the Dirac h-function on the right-hand side. Equation (23) does not yet determine u completely. We construct a formal asymptotic solution of equation (23) in some neighborhood of the origin. The partial sums of this solution tend exponentially to zero as w + +co if z # 20 and argw is a fixed number E (0,~). In this sense our solution satisfies the limit absorption principle. It is natural to expect that outside of a small neighborhood of ~0 the asymptotic solution of equation (23) in which we are interested will become a ray solution, corresponding to a central field of rays centered at ~0. It is not hard to prove that the geometric spreading J of a central field is different from zero at points x that are close to 20 (Z # ~0). The shape of the desired asymptotic solution (ansatz) is not simple. The question of how to conjecture what form it should take will be discussed briefly afterwards. This ansatz is as follows:
where
the functions
f, are expressed
by the formula:
fp(w, 7) = &+J
27 p Hp(w7),
2
where
7 = ~(20, X) is the eikonal,
(
equal
ray joining the points 20 and x, Hil) smooth functions of their arguments.
W
>
to the integral .IS the Hankel
szO ds/c, function,
taken
over a
and the ~1 are
2.2. Transport Equations. An expansion of the form (24) for T 5 const is asymptotic not only with respect to the small parameter l/w but also with respect to the degree of smoothness in the following sense: the functions f, lose smoothness for T(X,XO) = 0 but the number of continuous derivatives of fp increases without bound as p + co. The most singular term in the expansion (24) is the zeroth term vof-~. It is natural to require that the b-function in the right-hand side of equation (23) should actually occur because of this term. For the application of the operator A + $ to vof-q to lead to a singularity whose principal term is equal to -S(x - x0) it is necessary that -$lnr Zlof-E+
for m = 2
-
r; ( 2(m
-
>
2)7rm/2rm-2
as 5 4 ~0
(26)
for m > 2
since applying the m-dimensional Laplace operator to the right-hand side of the relations (26)) we obtain -6(x - x0), and the term W~TJO~-,Z/C~ is less singular. Taking the behavior of the Hankel functions for small values of the
104 argument obtain
V. M. Babich and the well-known
relation
‘uo(T 20)/,,,” Now we substitute
the expansion
af,(wlr) rdr
w2.fp(w,
T)
=
~(2 - 20) - T/C(Q)
into
account,
we
11
2(C(Q))m-2m-
(24) into equation
(27)
m-l (23).
The
=
-?,fp-l(U,
=
4(1 - p)fp--l(w, 7) - 4t2fp-2(w, ~1
relations
71,
once again give the possibility of representing this expansion as a series in the functions fP(w, r) with coefficients that are independent of w. Setting the coefficients of the function fP equal to zero, we obtain a recursive system of relations
The differentiation For vc we will find
IJO= For the ‘~1 we will
a/&-
is taken
2
along
m-l f-w (c(xo))m--227rz [I obtain
a ray leaving
T Ar2 - 2m/c2 47 0
from
the point
20.
d7
I.
the formulas
Here $~l+r = const on each ray. These are the diffraction coefficients. The “recipe” for choosing them is very simple. We set $l+r = 0. This ensures the smoothness of ‘u~+i(~, Q), I = 0, 1, . . .. The proof of the smoothness of ZQ and even its analyticity (this in the case of an analytic C(X)) is carried out by introducing Riemannian normal coordinates in a neighborhood of ~0 analogously to how the analyticity of the coefficients in the expansion of an elementary solution (see Hadamard (1932)) is proved.
2.3. Discussion of Our Results. In the considerations of the previous subsection there is a striking analogy between the recurrence relations for the ~11and the recurrence relations for the coefficients in the Hadamard expansion of an elementary solution (see Hadamard (1932)). This analogy is not random. It is explained by the fact that expansion (24) is obtained if we take the Fourier transform of the series giving the Hadamard elementary solution’
’ Hadamard considered expansions analogous to (28), only in the case of an even number of space variables (in this connection see Courant (1962)).
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
105
(28) The
elementary
solution
satisfies
the conditions
-1w,, c”(x)
- nw = S(x- xo)b(t), Wlt<0= 0.
A formal application of the Fourier transform to the series (28) also leads to the functions f, (see Babich (1965)). Both the Hadamard expansion (28) and the expansion (24) are unique: similar expansions have not been written down for several general equations with variable coefficients (for example, for the dynamic equations of elasticity theory in the case of an inhomogeneous medium). It. is necessary to use an indirect procedure, connected with the Radon transform or so-called Fourier int,egral operators. The expansion (24) possesses a nonlocality property: it holds2 in a domain that does not depend on w. Nonlocal expansions of this kind are more the exception to the rule than the norm. The ray expansion (see Section 1) and expansions in a neighborhood of a caustic, treated in the following section, are also nonlocal.
$3. Short-Wave Expansion in a Neighborhood of a Nonsingular Piece of a Caustic 3.1. Basic Assumptions. The ray expansion (4) ceases to be valid in neighborhoods of the points where the geometric spreading J (see (15)) vanishes. The set of points where J = 0 is called a caustic. We consider here the most regular case when the caustic is a smooth surface. We shall denote it by the letter S. We shall also make other, additional assumptions that indicate the nondegeneracy of the situation. Suppose we have introduced ray coordinates (a’, cy2, . . . , c.rrn-‘: r) (see Section 1) and let al, a2,. . . , am-r, r(~l,. . , Q-l) be a point on the ray where J = 0 (that is, a common point of the ray and S). Then r = ~(a’, . , cP-‘, 7(d,...,Cym--l )) (where z = x(0,7) is t,he formula realizing the transition from ray coordinates to Cartesian coordinates) is a parametric equation for the caustic. Our first assumption is that ~(a’, 02,. . , cPP1) is a smooth functionand (c$,c~~,...,cP-~) are regular coordinates on the caustic S, that is, the vectors dr/dai = dx/daj + dx/d-r . dr/daj, j = 1, . . . , m - 1, are linearly independent. We shall now prove the following lemma: Lemma.
The rays are tangent
to S
’ Instead of writing “the series is the asymptotic wording “the expansion holds.”
expansion”
we shall use the shorter
V. M. Babich
106
To prove this it suffices to establish that the tangent vector to the ray 8x/&- is expressed as a linear combination of the dr/da~ , for which it suffices to prove the linear dependence of the vectors &-/da and dx/daJ (since the dr/daJ are linearly independent). We shall first prove that the vectors dx(ai’, . . . , cP-‘, r)/&rj are linearly dependent. In fact: the equality J = 0 is equivalent to the linear dependence of 8x/&j and 8x/&, that is, the existence of numbers dj such that m-1
c
djdx/@
+ d,ax/th
= 0,
j=l
c
,dj, > 0.
(29)
j=l
Taking the scalar product of equality (29) with dx/dr and using the fact that axjaolj I ar, axjar f 0,we find that d, = 0 and thus m-1
m-1
C djax/aaj = 0, C ldjj > 0,
(30)
j=l
j=l
that is, the ax/da3 are linearly dependent. We shall now prove the linear dependence of &-/a& dependence is a consequence of the obvious equality
and ax/d-r. This linear
m-1
C
dZiarlaa'
(31)
+
j=l
where the dj , j = 1, . . , m - 1, are the sameas in (30). The following (and last) nondegeneracy assumption is that the tangency of the ray and the caustic S is of first order. 3.2. The Analytic Character of an Eikonal Close to a Caustic. It is natural to expect that close to a caustic S which is the envelope of a field of rays, the eikonal r will no longer be uniquely defined. (Two rays intersect at the point x. On each ray the value of the eikonal r = s ds/c will be distinct. See Figure 3.)
Fig. 3 The ray coordinates cease to be regular. We shall prove that in a neighborhood of a caustic there exist smooth functions r(x) and p(x) of x such that
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
107
(32) (p is positive in the domain illuminated by the rays). To prove this we note that it follows from (31) that C,“<’ dj&-/daJ # 0, so that at least one of the derivatives dr/daj is different from zero and we can take the value of r on S as one of the coordinates on S. We denote this coordinate by cyi. Thus, in ray coordinates the equation of the caustic has the form 7- = a?. We now introduce coordinates crl, 02,. . . , crm-‘, n close to S, where n is the distance along the normal from S, which is taken with a + sign (respectively, with a - sign) in the domain illuminated by the rays (respectively, in the unilluminated domain). We write the eikonal equation (7) in the coordinate system o?, . . , am-l, n. The canonical system of equations that the rays . satisfy has the form: dn =c2pn,..., d-r
$f=-g(~~(V~)~i)...,
(we will not write down The geometric meaning
where
(p,-g)
(33)
the other equations). On the caustic we have p, = 0. of n and the equations (33) give us:
where (35) (where l/p is the curvature of a normal section of S along a ray). of a ray and the caustic is Inequality (35) is valid because the tangency of first order and, moreover, n > 0 in the illuminated domain. The quantity P is called the effective radius of curvature [Babich and Buldyrev (1972)]. Inequality (35) is equivalent to the positivity of the curvature of a normal section of S along a ray if the curvature is understood as the curvature of a surface in a space with the Riemannian metric E(dxj)2/c). It follows from (33))(35) that n = (r - a1)2A, where A is a function that is positive close to S. Taking the square roots of both sides of this last equality, we will find q = (T - c+ll, Formula theorem
n,=a>o,
7)=ffi.
(36)
(36), the inequality &((T - a’)Ai) > 0, and the implicit imply that we can write down the following representation r=F(c2,...,
(F is a smooth
function
d--l,?&
of all its arguments),
7/=*&i, from
which
we get
function for r:
108
V. M. Babich F(al,
7=
. . . ) a-l,
+ F(d,
r)) + F(c2,.
. . ) am--l,
-q)
2 - F(d,. . . ,cP--l, -7) 2 nz-1,q2) + ?7F&21,. . . ,am-1,r/2),
. . . ,cP--l,~)
=F&2,...,a
(37) 77 =
&/ii.
Because dr/dn 1s = 0 and because of formula (37) we obviously have: dFlldn(n=o = 0 and F21nzo = 0, so that F2 = nF3, where F3 is a smooth function of ol, . . , o?-l, n that is positive for n = 0. The last of these is proved using the eikonal equation. Recalling that the coordinate system a’, . . , am-‘, n is regular for small n, and passing to Cartesian coordinates, we obtain the desired formula (32), starting from (37), where
< = F~(d(cr~),n(x)), Using
the eikonal
equation,
+ip3/2
= Gzn3/2F3(aj(z),n(x)).
it is not hard
to show that
(W2 + P.(W2 = f > VEVP = 0,
(38)
where
(39) 3.3. Asymptotics of a Solution. We can look for an asymptotic solution of equation (3), describing a wave field in a neighborhood of a caustic, in the form u = Av(-W2/3p) + i~-l/“Bv’(-~~/~ p)] eiw~w-6. (40) Here b = const,
A = 2 Aj(z)(-G-j, j=o
B = F B,(z)(-h-j, j=o
(41)
u(c) is the Airy function, satisfying Airy’s equation ‘u”-cc21 = 0 and having the asymptotics V(C) N $<-1/4 exp( - $c3j2) as C + co (see Babich and Buldyrev R e pl acing the function in formula (40) (1972, Appendix) and Fock (1970)). by its asymptotic behavior for ,LL> 0, w + oo, we obtain instead of (40) the sum of two ray expansions u -
lw-6-l/2eai/4
- BOp1’4) + - UT (-iw)
(AOpd4
2
{[ -l/4
+
J30p1/4)
+
&
The first (respectively, the second) ray expansion with the eikonal r-
+
. . .]
+ .
1
. &A-3?)]
&,(EtibW]}.
of these expansions corresponds = < - $p3i2 (respectively, with
to the r+ =
III. The Higher-Dimensional J+$p3/‘). The gradient Vr(respectively, away from the whose gradients are directed +cc the Airy function tends shadow. Substituting the ansatz in
L,A, where
Llf
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
109
(respectively, VT+) is directed toward the caustic caustic). Every point corresponds to two eikonals along the rays (see Fig. 3). For p < 0, w -+ exponentially to zero; this is the zone of caustic equation
(3), we arrive
+ L3Bj = AAj-l,
at the recursive
equations:
CIA, + L2Bj = ABj_,,
(42)
A-1 = 0, B-1 = 0, j = O,l,. . ., = 2VpVf
+ fAp,
Cd = 2VEV.f + fat,
Lsf = pLlf
+ f(Vp)‘.
(43) The coefficients Aj and Bj can be found by integrating over the rays. We set j = 0 in the formulas (42). If we multiply the first of the equations of (42) by the results, we arrive at two P -114, the second by p1/4 and add and substract equations analogous to the transport equations of the ray method: 2Vr-V@;
+ @iAr-
= 0,
2V+V@of
+ @,+Ar+ = 0,
(44)
where r+ Using
formula
= 5 f p,
@t = Aop-1’4’f
Bop1’4.
(45)
(16) we obtain (46)
from
which
In order
we get
to have Bo bounded
it suffices to require
that
In order to find the diffraction coefficient $0 it suffices to define the ray expansion of a wave going to the caustic, that is, a wave corresponding to the eikonal c . The coefficients Aj and Bj lie on the same path as A0 and Bo. If a wave going to the caustic is defined, then Aj andBj are uniquely determined. It is possible to show that Aj and Bj, j > 0, are smooth. However, the mathematical apparatus described in this section does not determine either t.he
V. M. Babich
110
functions [, domain not expansions the caustic.
,LAor the coefficients Aj and Bj in the shadow illuminated by rays (see Fig. 3). Here we have of <, 7, Aj and Bj in asymptotic power series n plays the role of a small parameter in these
zone, that is, in the to be satisfied with in the distance n to expansions.
Chapter 2 Some Modifications of the Ray and Caustic Expansions 51. Asymptotics
of Vibrations
of Whispering
Gallery
Type
1.1. The Ray Method in the Small. The theory of whispering gallery waves is closely connected with the theory of caustics. We consider the following ray picture (Fig. 4): close to the reflecting surface S there is a caustic, and the family of rays after grazing the caustic, reaching S and being reflected, is transformed to itself. If we were able to associate a wave field to this family, then there would exist a “surface wave”, that is, a vibration that is essentially different from zero only close to the surface. Such vibrations are called vibrations of whispering gallery type. If we could construct a continuous family of caustics that coincide in the limit with the reflecting surface S and possess the above properties, then we would have to consider a whole set of whispering gallery waves. The existence of a family of caustics such as described above is a rare exception. However, such families can be constructed approximately, in the form of formal power series [Babich and Buldyrev (1972), Ludwig (1966)]. Following Buldyrev (see Babich and Buldyrev (1972)) we shall call the technique of constructing such approximate families of rays the ray method in the small. For simplicity we restruct ourselves to the plane case.
Fig. 4 We shall look for a pair of functions equations (see Chapter I, $3) (W2 and the boundary
+ PL(W2
5 and p that
= 1/c2,
vL$vp
satisfy = 0
the system
of
(1)
condition
< and p are assumed
to be power
I*ls = 7; series in y:
(2)
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
111
In a neighborhood of 5’ we introduce coordinates s and n, where s is arc length, measured from a fixed point on S, and n is distance along a normal from 5’. The coefficients & and ,uj are in turn assumed to be power series in n: cc co
(4) The velocity c -
Substituting
c has a Maclaurin co + cl72 +
c2n2 + . . , where
cj = @c/i%
expansion I,=,(j!)-‘.
(5)
(3) in (1) we find (vEo)2
2VJow1+Pl(VPo)2
series as its asymptotic
+ Po(vpo)2
+2povpovp1
= 1/c2, =
0,
v
= 0,
V
+
E &g
+
VEOVPl
(6) = -2
Granting
that
~~01~ = 0 (see (2))
and
where p = p(s) is the radius of curvature (6) (assuming that ~10 # 0) that
VaVb
of 5’ at s, we will
(
1+ %
> easily find
0.
(7)
p$b s s, from
(8)
Assuming for definiteness that dfo/ds is positive, we will find <ec up to a constant term that is left undetermined, the diffraction coefficient. For the partial sum of our expansions appearing as an argument in the Airy function to tend to +co for fixed n > 0 and w + +oo, it is necessary that the effective radius of curvature P = (l/pcl /CO)-1 be positive (a concentration condition for a whispering gallery wave close to S. For P < 0 it is not possible to construct whispering gallery waves). From the formulas in (7) and the condition ~01 = 1 (see (2)) we will find dEo1 ds Thus <ei has been found up to a constant term, the diffraction coefficient. The construction of the remaining functions & proceeds analogously. All the coefficients pij and &, i > 0, are found uniquely, and the <ej are found up to constants of integration. After assuming that the series (3) and (4) converge, we obtain a continuous family of caustics p(n, s, y) = 0. Condition (2), the formulas rh = < f $p3j2
112
V. M. Babich
and the inequalities d~/dnl~=e > 0 and d 0 ensure that the angles of incidence and reflection are equal for waves going to the caustic and leaving it. However, it should be noted that the series (3) and (4) diverge as a rule. In particular, it is possible to prove that if there exists a continuous family of caustics close to S and S is a closed curve, then this family can be destroyed by an arbitrarily small analytic perturbation of the contour S (due to D. Sh. Mogilevskij). 1.2. Boundary Conditions and Transport Equations. An asymptotic solution called a wave of whispering gallery type has the form of Equation (I.40)3, where < and p were found in 1.1 above, and Aj and Bj are in turn the expansions:
Aj = 9
Bj = 2
Akjyk,
Bkjyk,
(10)
Bkj = c Blkj(s)nz. l=O
(11)
k=O f&j
=
E
k=O Al,&)&
l=O
We shall consider the case of the Dirichlet boundary condition uIs = 0. Substituting an ansatz of the shape of Equation (1.40) in the boundary condition u 1s = 0 and considering condition (2)) we find
Alsu(-~2’3y) For
this
+ i~-~‘~Bl~z~‘(-~~‘~y)
= 0.
(12)
equality to hold for sufficiently small y, it is necessary that = 0. It is impossible to set Al, = 0, since it can be shown leads to a trivial (zero) asymptotic solution. Hence, it is necessary
Alsv(-~2/3y) that this to set
y = l&2/3 (where -cl, In all the rameter and (13) formula
(13)
1 = 1,2,. . ., are the roots of the Airy function (zi(-cl) = 0)). remaining constructions we shall treat y as an independent paonly in the final formulas replace y by expression (13). In view of (12) leads to the equality BI, = 0, or, equivalently (see Equation
(I.411 1
BjInzO=O, Using
Equations
(1.42),
(1.43)
2%
and (lo)-(14)
.+ 2~10A100
3 Translator’s note: The notation X. Thus (1.40) means Equation
j=O,1,2
,.... above,
(14) we find the equalities
+ AoooA~o~,=o = 0,
(15)
+ AoooA~oI~=~
(16)
= 0.
(X.y) here and later means Equation 40 of Chapter I.
y of Chapter
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
113
By analogy with Equation (1.6), it is natural to call (15) a transport equation. This is an ordinary differential equation along S. Computations show that a solution of it has the form
Aooo = Coo (39
l/6
> co = clnzo
(17)
Here P is the effective radius of curvature of 5’ and COO = const is the diffraction coefficient. We find Aloo from Equation (16). Differentiating Equations (1.42) and (1.43) with respect to n. and setting n = 0, we find Biec (obviously Bcee = 0) and A 2oo. Continuing this process, we can find all the coefficients Aloo and Bloc, that is, the expansions for A00 and Boo. Then we find in sucfinding cession &IO, &IO, ADO, BZZO (I = (41, . ..I and thus A0 and Bo. After A0 and Bo, we proceed to find Al, B1, etc.
1.3. Analogues and Generalizations. The case of a Neumann boundary condition is considered completely analogously. Here; though, there is a complication: in the expansions (10) the summation must begin with -j. Because of formula (1.41) and the negativity of
=
wq
+
alwq
1’3
+
o(w;1’3),
(18)
where
In the case of a Dirichlet (respectively, Neumann) boundary condition -<, is a root of the Airy function, u(-&p) = 0 (respectively, of the derivative of the Airy function, ~‘(-6) = 0). The parameters p and q are integers > 0 and q -+ 00, p = O(1). The last condition can be weakened. Formula (19) (more precisely, an analogue of it) gives the possibility of estimating the width of lacunas in the spectrum of the Laplace operator [Lazutkin (1979)] from above. Passing from the two-dimensional problem to the case of arbitrary dimension requires the construction of a ray field on S that corresponds to the velocity c, that is, the construction of a field of extremals of the functional s ds/c, where the level curves lie on S. There is significant interest in considering the ansatz (1.40) in the case of a negative effective radius of curvature. In this case it is appropriate to set
114
V. M. Babich u = (Awl(
-w~/~~U)
+ i~-“~Bzui
( -w2i3p))
exp iw<,
(20)
where WI(<) is a solution of Airy’s equation, having the asymptotics - (-<)-1/4eiR/4exp $(-<)3/2i as < + co. As before A = xA,(-iw)-j; j=o Ai = x
AI&“,
B = c B+iw)-j, j=o
(21)
Bj = c
(22)
k=O
Bkjyk,
k=O
(23) j=O
j=O
Here, however, Aki, Bkj,
Fig. 5
52. Surface
Wave
Propagated
Along
an Impedance
Surface
2.1. Initial Statements. Ansatz. Suppose that Equation (1.3) holds close to some surface S on which the so-called impedance boundary condition
g+whu=O
(24)
is given. Here d/dn is the normal derivative directed to the side where the vibrations are considered and h is a positive function on S. Here we shall consider an asymptotic solution of Equation (1.3), concentrated close to the
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB Method or Ray Method
115
surface: its partial sums tend exponentially to zero as w + co outside of strips close to 5’ of width of order greater than l/w. The previously constructed expansions are completely analogous to the well-known Rayleigh waves, propagated along the surface of an inhomogeneous elastic body of arbitrary shape, to Stoneley waves, and to some types of surface waves in acoustics and electrodynamics. The corresponding ansatz is formally the same as the ray expansion (1.4) and r and uj satisfy the same equations (1.5) and (1.6). The main difference from Chapter I is the assumption that 7 and ZL~are formal power series in the distance to S. Let ol, o?, . . , am-l be an arbitrary regular coordinate system on S and n the distance from S; then (Y’, 02,. . . , o?-‘, n define a regular coordinate system close to S. Let n be the second small parameter for this problem and let (25)
Uj =~Ulj(a’,...,am-‘)n’.
(26)
z=o For the expressions for wr and Cuj/(-iw)j to be asymptotic expansions it is sufficient that n = O(w-c), where Eis any positive fixed number. 2.2.
Construction
of the
Asymptotics
of a Solution.
The boundary
condition leads to the following equations (27)
gI,=o = 0, where U =
C,“=, uj(-iw)j+T
= C,“=, zlej (-iw)J+Y.
(28)
For convenience we write the eikonal equation (1.5) and the transport equation (1.6) in the coordinates a’, . . . , cP-‘, n. The square of the length element in these coordinates has the form Gklda’dcx’;
~2” = n, G,,
= 1, Gkrn = 0 for k < m, (29)
Gkl = gkl - hbkl + o(TL”).
Here gkl (respectively, bkl) are the coefficients of the first (respectively, the second) fundamental form of the surface S. The eikonal equation (1.5) and transport equation (1.6) then look like: Gkl
a?da”
2Gk1$g
+ s&
(v??GklA)
a7 dd
_
1 c2’
(G”‘) = (Gkl)-‘,
= Au~-~.
Setting n = 0 in (30) and using (27), we find the equation
(3’4 (31)
116
V. M. Babich /.“l al- dUj g =&F=z+h2.
1
co = ClhrO’
(P)
= (9kV.
(32)
Equation (32) is the eikonal equation on the surface 5’. It is integrated using the rays, that is, the extremals of the integral s da/w (where da is the differential of an arc of a curve on S, the level curves lie on 5’ and ZI is the velocity of surface waves on S: l/u 2 = l/c: + h2), like the classical eikonal equation. Finding 70, differentiating (30) successively with respect to n and setting n = 0, we find the rj, j > 0. We turn to the transport equations. Here it is convenient to carry out the considerations using ray coordinates ~e,fl’, . . . , ,SmP2 on S corresponding to the eikonal re(cr?, . . . , cP-’ ). Integrating Equation (1.6) leads in this case to successively finding the coefficients ulj in the expansion (26). Recursive equations are obtained for these coefficients if we successively differentiate relation (31). These equations are integrated in the same way as the transport equations of Section 1 of Chapter I. We shall give only the expression for uoo:
uoo=lLoo(P1,... , ,Fe2) x exp
fiexp
lrn
hiKv2dT
7o 1 T u2c1 ~ d-r . exp -dr. s o 2ihR s o 2icih
Here K is the mean cxurvature of S, l/R is the curvature of a normal section of S along a surface ray, cl = dc/dn~,=O, J is the geometric spreading of surface rays: J = ; 1Do”;;;
‘;.$;l!,
/.
It is interesting to note that ~00 is rebresented as a product of several factors, each of which characterizes the influence of some one factor on the principal term of the surface ray: $00 characterizes its initial form, v’% is the influence of the impedance, J- 1/2 is the geometric spreading, etc. In the construction of the theory of Rayleigh and Stoneley waves there is an analogous decomposition of the principal term into factors.
Gaussian $1. Solutions
Chapter 3 Beams and Their
Concentrated
in a Neighborhood
1.1. Statement of the Problem. of the ray expansion eiwr(z)
Applications
2 j=o
Ansatz. uj(s)/(-iw)j
of a Fixed
An interesting
Ray
modification
(1)
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
117
if the eikonal is assumed to be complex, with Im r 2 0, and equality occurs only on some curve 2. One can prove that 1 must be a ray. We assume this from the start. The partial sums of (1) will then be exponentially small everywhere except for a small neighborhood of 1. The complex eikonal and the corresponding coefficients uj can be constructed as expansions, which we shall now describe. We introduce special coordinates [Babich and Buldyrev (1972)] in a neighborhood of 1. We shall describe them in the three-dimensional case. Suppose that arc-length, measured from a fixed point, characterizes the points on 1. Let n(s) and b(s) be the principal normal and binormal of 1 at a point s. We introduce basis vectors ei and e2 by the relations
is obtained
el = ncos6 - bsin8,
e2 = nsin8 + bcos0.
Here 8 is the angle between e and n, satisfying the condition dO/ds = l/T, where T = T(s) is the radius of curvature. One can show that ej(s) is obtained from ej(sc) (where se is a fixed value of s) up to a positive multiple via parallel transport of ej along I, corresponding to the connection defined by the metric $((dx1)2 + (dx2)2 + (dx3)2). The points close to 1 will be characterized by the coordinates s, $, q2, whose relationship with the Cartesian coordinates xi, i = 1,2,3, is given by the formula n
T = TO(S)+ 2
qiei.
(2)
i=l
Here T is the radius-vector of the points x1, x2, x3 and T = Q(S) is the vector equation of the ray I. All the succeeding constructions will be done in the coordinates s, ql, q2. (We note that we could use the Fermat coordinates defined by the Riemannian metric $ C(dzi)2 with equal success,even in the case of an arbitrary number of variables.) We proceed to a description of the ansatz. We assume that the desired expansion is given by formula (l), where I- and IL? are in turn given by the expansions: &4 )
T=
dh) =
i:
h=O
il,i2,...,ih=l
h=O
il,i2,...,ih=l
uj =
Til..&(s)qil
Ujili2...ih
(S)qi’
. . . qy
. . . qih.
(3)
(4
The coefficients of the polynomials do not change when ii,. . . , ih are permuted. It is assumedthat r(‘)(s), 71(s) and 7i(s) are real, and that
V. M. Babich
118
is a ositive definite quadratic form. The last requirements ensure that Im xF!c 7-ch) > 0 for any fixed M and sufficiently small ql, q2, not simultaneously equal to zero. An asymptotic solution of equation (1.3) corresponding to the ansatz (l)(4) is called a Gaussian beam. 1.2. Determination of T(O), 7(l), and T(‘). The square of the length element and the eikonal in the coordinates s, ql, q2 have the respective forms [l - K(s)(ql cos0 + q2 sin0)]2ds2 + (c&l)’ + (&2)2, 1 (a>“+ [l - K(s)(ql cos0 + q2sint9)12
($)2+
(&)‘=
(5)
$7
(6)
where K(s) is the curvature of I at s. Substituting (4) in (6) an d considering the positive definiteness of Imr(2) and the equation of 1 in the coordinate system s, qi, q2, it is not hard to find
s s dslco(s),
4’) = const +
co = ClqzO’ T(l) E 0,
so
2 dd2) --+(VqT co as
c2q2 + -t (!Pq, q) = 0, 4 2 a&) -co as
Here c77(dv7(2) = I;=,
+ 2(V#,
W2))
= ni.
4 = (4J’A2),
(7)
(8)
(9)
G$$
The function Ai is defined if r(i’) are defined for j’ < j. We shall look for a solution of equation (8) in the form
where r equation setting r have the
= (rzj) is a (2 x 2) symmetric matrix. We then find a matrix Riccati for r. We look for a solution, following a well-known method, by = P&-l, where P and Q are new desired matrices. Thus, ~(~1 will expression .c2) = ;(PQ-‘q,
q).
(11)
The matrix r will satisfy its Riccati equation, and ~(~1will satisfy equation (8), if P and Q are solutions of the system of equations: dQ
--cop, ds
dP -= ds
(12)
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
119
If 4 and p are vectors generating the j-th column (j = 1,2) of the matrices Q and P, respectively, then the system of equations (12) is equivalent to the canonical system of equations dqi -=ds
dHz
-=
(13)
b’pi ’
It is not hard to seethat the system of equations (13) is also a characteristic system of equations for the Hamilton-Jacobi equation (8), and simultaneously a system of equations in the first approximation for rays close to I, that is, a system of Jacobi equations for the ray 1. We also require that the matrices P and Q satisfy the relations: QTP
- PTQ
= 0,
Q*P
- P*Q
= iI,
(14)
where I is the identity matrix, T denotes matrix transpose and * denotes the Hermitian conjugate. Since the left-hand sides of (14) are first integrals of the system (13), in order that the formulas (14) hold it suffices that they hold for some one value of the argument. The first of the relations (14) ensures that the matrix r is symmetric and the second ensures the positive definiteness of Im r. It follows from the second equality of (14) that the matrix r is not singular at any point of 1. To prove this, we shall1 show that det Q # 0 everywhere on the ray 1. Indeed, suppose that det Q = 0 at some point. Then there exists a vector c= cl IG + lC2l > 0 ( c2 > ’ such that QC = 0. Then (14) gives us (-i)lC12
= (C, (Q*P
- P*Q)C)
= (QC, PC)
- (C, P*QC)
= 0,
which is impossible, since ICI2 > 0. 1.3. Determination of TiTil...ih)ujil...ih. After rc2) has been found, the determination of the remaining ril,,,i,, does not present great difficulties: if instead of q = (ql, q2) we introduce new variables (gl, g2), where
(g’,g2) = g =
Q-h
(15)
then the determination of r(h) from the relation (9) leads in view of (11),(12) to a quadrature with respect to s. We pass to the problem of solving the transport equation. We consider only the equation for ue. We shall assume that uc $ 0. Let UP’ be the first term of the series C,“=, uF’ which is not identically equal to zero. The equation for u.(“I has the form:
120
V. M. Babich 2 dtp - ~ co as
+ 2~p)vup)
+ ,(yo)
$;+TrPQ-’
where Tr denotes matrix trace. Using (Liouville’s) formula for the derivative $det and the first equation
22 co as Equation set equal
of (la),
(17) is obtained to zero. Equation
of a determinant:
Q = det Q. Tr(Q’Q-‘) we find
(ho)+ 2VTW&p O
(16)
in place
of (16) that
= 0; gm) = ,p
J
det, C
from (9) if rch) there is replaced by v?“) (17) .is solved by the change of variables
$2. The Case of a Closed
(17) and Aj is (15).
Ray
2.1. Properties of the System of Jacobi Equations. Let 1 be a closed ray. In this case, under some additional assumptions there exists a sequence of nonzero asymptotic solutions of equation (1.3), which are exponentially small as w + 00 outside of 1 and are defined and unique in a neighborhood of 1 (so-called quasimodes). If to every point s E 1 (where 1 is a closed ray) we associate the set of vectors that are orthogonal to 1, then we are led in a natural way to a so-called normal bundle: a bundle space 0 whose base is the ray 1 and whose fiber is the plane C normal to 1 at the point s E 1. If we assume that s varies from -co to +co, tUhSenwe have a fibration @ which is the universal cover of fi. If L is the length of l! then the vectors a(s) E .YS, which are invariant under translation by L, that is, a(s + L) = a(s), are defined and unique on the above-defined normal bundle CS’. The Jacobi equations (12) for the closed ray 1 can be considered as an equation on @. The classical methods from the theory of systems with periodic coefficients are then applicable in their entirety to the equations (12). For later use it will be convenient for us to consider the natural complexification of the planes Es normal to 1. The solutions of (12) that satisfy the condition q(s + L) = yq(s);
p(s + L) = y&s),
where
y =const,
will be called Floquet solutions and the constant y is called a multiplier. If y is a multiplier, then l/y is also a multiplier. The ray 1 is said to be stable if any solution q(s), p(s) (-oc < s < +oo) of the system (12) is bounded. In this case all the multipliers have the form efcvz (Im cx = 0). We shall assume that the closed rays under consideration are stable. The stability of a ray is one variant
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
121
or Ray Method
of a general position situation. The Floquet solutions form a fundamental system of solutions of (12). Let eial, eiaz, eei”l, ePiaz be multipliers, and y(j),p(j), j = 1,2,3,4, the corresponding Floquet solutions. It turns out that it is possible to number the multipliers and to normalize q(j),p(j) such that the matrices Q and P whose columns are q(l), q(‘) and p(‘),p(‘), respectively, will satisfy (14).
the set
2.2. Construction of Quasimodes in the Case First Approximation. In the first approximation u”, = eiWO[7(0)+d*)]C0
of a Closed Ray in to a quasimode we
&bl~a%2)a2~ /----
($)-Q-l($),
(18)
Co=const#O.
The function ZL~ depends on ql, q2 and s, that is, we may assume that it is defined on the fibration @. We require that if s is translated by L (L =length of 1)) then U: is left invariant (u: (s + L) E U:(S)), that is, u”, can be considered as a function on the normal bundle R. Since the eigenfunctions of the operator -c2(x)A must be defined and unique in a neighborhood of 1, it is natural to impose the condition $(s + L) = U:(S) on 71.51,which is used to represent the eigenfunction approximately. The quadratic form rc2) does not vary if s is replaced
by s + L, and the expression
J-
&(gr
)“I (g2)“”
acquires
the
factor exp[-$(oi + cua) - ialar - iazcrz]. This is a simple consequence of the definition of Floquet solutions and the fact that the columns of the matrices P and Q are composed of these solutions. By choosing w” suitably, we can obtain the periodicity of uz. We should obviously set
where The expressions
L
ds a1 +a2 -+---+ alal + u2a”i, 2 0 co(s) al, u2 = 0, 1,2,. . . , b > 0 and b is an integer.
w” = 2x-b
IS
(18) and (19) define
a quasimode
(19)
in the first approximation.
2.3. Higher Approximations. In order to construct higher approximations we change the ansatz somewhat. We shall assume that the desired quasimode has the form of a ray expansion
where we is not the frequency in the equation, but the expression (19). The number we will be a large parameter for the problem. The frequency w in equation (1.3) is assumed to be expressed by
V. M. Babich
122
w = wo = s,/w, + s2/w; + . . . )
(21)
where the Sj are unknown numbers which we must find. We need an additional restriction on the multipliers: suppose that ol, cr2 and T = 3.14.. . are linearly independent over the ring of integers, that is, + h2Qr2+ h3n = 0 with
hiai
hi integers
=+ hl = 0, h2 = 0, h3 = 0.
(22)
We turn first to the determination of the rch). Again introducing (gl, g2) in place of (q1,q2), we reduce the problem of finding the coefficients to a successive computation of quadratures. For our purposes it is necessary that the ~(~1, h 2 2, be L-periodic. For h = 2 this follows from the expression for ~(~1. Now suppose that the T ch’) have been constructed and are L-periodic for h’ < h; then ~(~1 is found from the equation
(23) where
Ah is an L-periodic
It follows
from
the expression
B,,,,(s Representing
and requiring
homogeneous
of g1 and g2, of degree
for gi and the periodicity
+ L) = exp(cial
h:
of Ah that
+ ~2cr~)iB,~,~(.s)
rch) as a sum of monomials:
$4= c AE,C, b)(g’N7”)”
that
r ch) be L-periodic,
A,l,z(~ + L) = exp(tia’ Equation
polynomial
we arrive
at the equalities
+ qgx2)iAElEZ(s), with
er + ~2 = h.
(24)
(23) gives
2 d --A co ds “”
= Be,,,
(25)
In view of (22) all the A,,,, In an analogous
are found uniquely from (24) and (25). way we can find uj = C;l”=, up). Here it is not the uy)
that must be L-periodic, but the product exp iwsr (0) /up ) which when we take formula (19) for wc into account leads to a condition analogous to (24), from which all the coefficients in the expansion of uj (h) into monomials are found. However, there is one exception. Among the monomials that make up ~j there is, in particular, the following one: Jco.Cjalaz (s)(g1)a1(g2)az/m, where al and a2 are the same as in formula (19). The coefficient C,,,,, must be L-periodic:
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB Method or Ray Method
CjcQaz (s+ L) = cja,,,(s). The equation
123 (26)
for Cjalaz has the form (27)
where Cs is the same number as in formula (18) and Ajalaz denotes an Lperiodic function that depends on ujr for j’ < j and on ~7’) for h’ < al + ~2. For an L-periodic solution Cj,,,, of equation (27) to exist, the integral of the right-hand side of (27) must be zero. This uniquely determines the Sj and completes the construction of quasimodes in the case of a closed ray. Along the same line one could consider the problem with reflections, that is, the problem of constructing quasimodes in a neighborhood of a ray that has been reflected successively from N mirrors. This problem is very essential in the theory of lasers.
$3. Summation
of Gaussian Beams
3.1. Basic Ideas of the Method (see Babich and Pankratova (1973) and Popov (1981)). Th e ray expansion (see Section 1.1) loses its asymptotic nature close to those points where the geometric spreading vanishes, that is, close to caustics. Caustics are far from exhausted by the case considered in Section 1.3. It would significantly extend the range of application of the ray method to be able to extend the ray expansion into a neighborhood of a caustic of arbitrary type. Of course, in such a neighborhood an asymptotic solution of Equation (1.3) will have a rather different form from the expansion (1.4). An important generalization of the ray method is the canonical operator method of Maslov, which gives the possibility of describing arbitrary caustics [Maslov and Fedoryuk (1976)]. The method of swnmation of Gaussian beams gives another approach to the difficult problem of describing a wave field in a neighborhood of an arbitrary caustic. The basis of the method is the property of a Gaussian beam that it does not have singularities (see Section 1 above). Summing Gaussian beams, one can obtain an asymptotic solution in the domain of regularity of the field of rays. This solution is equivalent to the ray expansion but does not have singularities even on caustics. Since Gaussian beams can be reflected and refracted (if both the incident and refracted rays are not tangent to the reflecting and refracting surfaces), then the summation of Gaussian beams is applicable with these restrictions and in the presence of boundaries. Here are the basic ideas of the method. We consider a field of rays corresponding to an eikonal 7. Let C be a level surface of the eikonal. For definitenessassumethat T = 0 on C. Close to C we introduce ray coordinates cyl, 02, r as described in $1.1. Suppose in addition that a ray solution of the form (1.4)
124
V. M. Babich
corresponds to this field of rays. To each ray CY~= const, j = 1,2,. . ., in this ray field we associate a Gaussian beam (28) Suppose that on the ray CY~= const, j = 1,2, in a neighborhood Gaussian beam is constructed, we have
uao(~)/ql+=o
=
\i
of which
the
co(x) -Q’
and that the eikonal rol(x) vanishes on the surface C. We multiply the expansion (28) by a non-negative cut-off function na(x) of class C”, equal to one for ~‘(4~)~ + (q2)” < E, and equal to zero for ,/(q’)2 + (q2)2 > 2~. Th e number E can be chosen so that the coordinates ql, q2, s (see Section 1) do not lose regularity for d(q1)2 + (q2)2 5 2~. We consider the integral
w=
J c
C~,Uada1da2,
(29)
where c
=
2 j=.
w1~2), (-ibJp+J
6 = const,
(30)
and the Cj are smooth functions whose determination will be discussed below. The integral is understood as follows: the series in powers of l/w are formally multiplied out. The series obtained as a result of term-by-term integration of this expansion is W, by definition. Here we need to make precise the question of how to understand the integral of an individual term. We recall that r, and U,j are not functions in the expression (28), but expansions in homogeneous polynomials of q1 and q2. We note that if r,, Uaj are replaced by the sums C,” 7-L’) and Co”-? U$’ with A4 and Mj sufficiently large, and if E is sufficiently small, then the integral of the corresponding expression will already be meaningful. Replacing M and Mj by still larger numbers M’ and Mi leads to corrections of a higher order of smallness as M’ and Mi become larger. We shall assume that in the integrals in which we are interested M and Mj are replaced by sums of a sufficiently large number of terms that are homogeneous in q1 and q2. If we consider the choice of the functions C~(CX’, 02), then it turns out that close to C the series W will be asymptotically equivalent to the given ray expansion up to terms of arbitrarily high order of smallness. In extending the ray solution along rays we may encounter caustic singularities, but the integral expressions for the terms of U, do not become singular. W is the extension of the ray field into the caustic domain and beyond it. Since it is a superposition of formal asymptotic solutions of equation (1.3), W remains a formal asymptotic solution of this equation.
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB Method or Ray Method
125
3.2. Application of the Method of Stationary Phase. The absolute value of the exponential factor T,(X) in (28) (recall that 7, and Uaj are replaced by finite sums) for fixed z attains a maximum for al, a2 corresponding to a ray passing through Z. This follows from the positive definiteness of Irn7c2). Applying the method of stationary phase, we obtain an expansion of the form cc (31)
pT(z) c (-i$+J+l j=.
close to C. A sufficiently large number of terms of this expansion must satisfy the recurrence equations of the ray method (1.5),(1.6), since (31) is asymptotically equal to W, which formally satisfies equation (1.3), and, hence, this expansion must likewise formally satisfy the same equation. Using the method of stationary phase we have for the principal term of (31) uo = C~(c2, a2)x(a1, a2)
J
;,
where x(cr’, CX’) is some non-zero function and J is the geometric spreading corresponding to the ray coordinates cyl, 02, T. For the principal terms of the expansions (31) and (1.4) to be equal it is sufficient that 6 + 1 = y and that ug = ZQ on C, that is, for T = 0. This can be done by choosing CO(& , a2) suitably. For succeeding approximations of expansions (31) and (1.4) to be equal one must consider higher terms of the expansion of W in powers of (&-I. We will omit these constructions.
Chapter 4 On Other Short-Wave Diffraction 51. The
Case of Smooth
Reflecting
Problems Boundaries
1.1. Fock’s Problem. Suppose that a wave defined by its ray expansion hits a convex body with nonzero curvature. We briefly consider the plane case. The asymptotic expression for the wave field is naturally partitioned (see Fig. 6) into an illuminated region and a shadow zone. One would naturally expect to have a rather complicated expression in the transition zone between the illuminated region and the shadow zone. The key region whose investigation leads to an explanation of the behavior of the wave field both in the penumbra and in deep shadow is a neighborhood of the point C, which is the point of tangency of the ray of the incident wave and the reflecting
126
V. M. Babich Rays of the
Rays of the incident wave
Fig.
6
surface 5’. This domain was first studied by V. A. Fock using the boundary layer method in the 1940s. Introducing the coordinates s and n that we used in Chapter 2 (the point C has coordinates 0,O) and assuming that y = 0 in the incident wave (see formula 1.4)), we can obtain the first term of the short-wave asymptotic expansion of the wave field in the form
(1)
To(S) =
s ’
ds ~ 0 co(s)’
J/3
cJ= q%#3(op2/3(~)
'
v =
J
2
3 P(s)c~(~)
'
where u and wi are Airy functions 4, P(0) is the effective radius of curvature of the curve at C (see Chapter II), and -=-t-
1 d/l%
in the case of Dirichlet boundary conditions in the case of Neumann boundary conditions.
Fock’s formula (1) t urns into rather complicated penumbral asymptotics in a neighborhood of the limit ray CM (see Fig. 6), into geometric formulas in the illuminated domain and into the wave field corresponding to gliding rays with respect to a tangent that leave S in the shadow zone (see Chapter II, Section 1). For an arbitrary number of dimensions m the role of the point C is played by the (m - 2)-dimensional manifold of tangent points of S with the field of rays of the incident wave. This manifold is called the terminator.5 The wave field in a neighborhood of the terminator is expressed via Fock’s function (1). * For the definition of the function v(C) see Chapter I, $3.3, and for the definition of WI(<) see Chapter II, $1.3. 5 The terminator in astronomy is the boundary between the illuminated and unilluminated parts of the Moon or some planet by the Sun.
III. The Higher-Dimensional
WKB
Method
or Ray Method
127
An interesting approach to the construction of short-wave asymptotics in shadow and penumbral regions and in a neighborhood of the terminator is due to Ludwig (see Ludwig (1967) and Babich and Buldyrev (1972)). His formulas give a unified representation of a wave field in these domains as integrals over caustic solutions, analogous to those considered in 51 of Chapter II,. Unfortunately, Ludwig’s method is restricted to being applied only in the case of the Dirichlet problem. 1.2. Point Sources of Vibrations on the (see Babich (1979)) Babich and Buldyrev (1972), be a domain contained in R2 with a boundary of the problem of finding an asymptotic solution to
(A+w")u Eels
Boundary of a Domain and Buslaev (1975)). Let R positive curvature. We pose the problem
= 0,
= S(s - so), where
E’=lor&,and&($-&zl)--+Oasr+oo.
(2) In this case formal constructions allow us to construct an expansion for 21 close to C (s = 0). In the first approximation this expansion is equal to the solution of the problem for the Helmholtz equation in a half-plane with a source on the boundary. This solution is combined with the ray expansion corresponding to the central field of rays (the center is the point C). The penumbra close to C is described by an integral which is close in nature to the Fockfunction. This expression becomes the shadow asymptotics corresponding to the field of gliding rays shown in Fig. 7 (see Babich and Kirpichnikova (1974)). All these constructions can be generalized to the higher-dimensional case. Buslaev (see Buslaev (1975)) was able to construct a unified expression for an asymptotic solution of the problem (2) which can be applied both close to the source and in the Fock zone. Using this expression he was able to give a justification for the short-wave asymptotics of the Green function for the Helmholtz equation outside a convex smooth domain, under some natural assumptions.
Gliding rays Fig. 7
V. M. Babich
128
In the case of a source of vibrations on a concave reflecting boundary no gliding wave arises, but there is an uncountable set of reflections. Waves corresponding to rays that exit from the source at an angle to the boundary less than w-1/3 in order of magnitude lose their individuality. The total position effect of these waves ca.n be described by some special function (see Babich and Buldyrev (1972), Babich and Molotkov (1985), and Philippov (1981)).
$2. Various
Problems
2.1. The Problem of the Change of Sign of the Curvature (Babich and Smyshlyaev (1984), Popov (1979)). Suppose that a whispering gallery wave moves along a curve S on which a Dirichlet condition holds. Suppose that the effective radius of curvature changes its sign at a point C (see Fig. 8). Apparently, close to the ray r tangent at C to the curve S, the wave field will have a penumbral character and then the typical picture of a shadow wave field corresponding to gliding waves tangent to S arises. The boundary layer method reduces the problem on the behavior of