Physicochemical Kinetics and Transport at Biointerfaces
IUPAC SERIES ON ANALYTICAL AND PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY OF ENVIRONMENTAL SYSTEMS
Series Editors Jacques Buffle, University of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland Herman P. van Leeuwen, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands Series published within the framework of the activities of the IUPAC Commission on Fundamental Environmental Chemistry, Division of Chemistry and the Environment. INTERNATIONAL UNION OF PURE AND APPLIED CHEMISTRY (IUPAC) Secretariat, PO Box 13757, 104 T. W. Alexander Drive, Building 19, Research Triangle Park, NC 27709-3757, USA Previously published volumes (Lewis Publishers): Environmental Particles Vol. 1 (1992) ISBN 0-87371-589-6 Edited by Jacques Buffle and Herman P. van Leeuwen Environmental Particles Vol. 2 (1993) ISBN 0-87371-895-X Edited by Jacques Buffle and Herman P. van Leeuwen Previously published volumes (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd): Metal Speciation and Bioavailability in Aquatic Systems Vol. 3 (1995) ISBN 0-471-95830-1 Edited by Andre´ Tessier and David R. Turner Structure and Surface Reactions of Soil Particles Vol. 4 (1998) ISBN 0.471-95936-7 Edited by Pan M. Huang, Nicola Senesi and Jacques Buffle Atmospheric Particles Vol. 5 (1998) ISBN 0-471-95935-9 Edited by Roy M. Harrison and Rene´ E. van Grieken In Situ Monitoring of Aquatic Systems Vol. 6 (2000) ISBN 0-471-48979-4 Edited by Jacques Buffle and George Horvai The Biogeochemistry of Iron in Seawater Vol. 7 (2001) ISBN 0-471-49068-7 Edited by David R. Turner and Keith A. Hunter Interactions between Soil Particles and Microorganisms Vol. 8 (2002) ISBN 0-471-60790-8 Edited by Pan M. Huang, Jean-Marc Bollag and Nicola Senesi
IUPAC Series on Analytical and Physical Chemistry of Environmental Systems. Volume 9
Physicochemical Kinetics and Transport at Biointerfaces Edited by HERMAN. P. VAN LEEUWEN Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands ¨ STER WOLFGANG KO Swiss Federal Institute for Environmental Science and Technology (EAWAG), CH-8600 Du¨bendorf, Switzerland
Copyright ß 2004 by IUPAC Published in 2004 by John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England Telephone (þ44) 1243 779777 Email (for orders and customer service enquiries):
[email protected] Visit our Home Page on www.wileyeurope.com or www.wiley.com All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise, except under the terms of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP, UK, without the permission in writing of the Publisher. Requests to the Publisher should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England, or emailed to
[email protected], or faxes to (þ44) 1243 770620. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the Publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. Other Wiley Editorial Offices John Wiley & Sons Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA Jossey-Bass, 989 Market Street, San Francisco, CA 94103–1741, USA Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, Boschstr. 12, D-69469 Weinheim, Germany John Wiley & Sons Australia Ltd, 33 Park Road, Milton, Queensland 4064, Australia John Wiley & Sons (Asia) Pte Ltd, 2 Clementi Loop #02–01, Jin Xing Distripark, Singapore 129809 John Wiley & Sons Canada Ltd, 22 Worcester Road, Etobicoke, Ontario, Canada M9W 1L1 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Physicochemical kinetics and transport at biointerfaces / edited by H.P. van Leeuwen, W. Ko¨ster. p. cm. – (IUPAC series on analytical and physical chemistry of environmental systems; . v.9) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-471-49845-9 (ppc : alk. paper) 1. Biological interfaces. 2. Chemical kinetics. 3. Biological transport. I. Leeuwen, H. P. van. II. Ko¨ster, Wolfgang. III. Series. QP517.S87P485 2004 571.6’4–dc22 2003060730 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0471 49845 9 Typeset in 10/12 pt Times by Kolam Information Services Pvt. Ltd, Pondicherry, India Printed and bound in Great Britain by MPG, Bodmin, Cornwall This book is printed on acid-free paper responsibly manufactured from sustainable forestry in which at least two trees are planted for each one used for paper production.
Contents List of Contributors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Series Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
2
3 4
5
6 7
8 9 10
Physicochemical Kinetics and Transport at the Biointerface: Setting the Stage. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W. Ko¨ster and H. P. van Leeuwen Molecular Modelling of Biological Membranes: Structure and Permeation Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. A. M. Leermakers and J. M. Kleijn Biointerfaces and Mass Transfer. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . H. P. van Leeuwen and J. Galceran Dynamics of Biouptake Processes: the Role of Transport, Adsorption and Internalisation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J. Galceran and H. P. van Leeuwen Chemical Speciation of Organics and of Metals at Biological Interphases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. I. Escher and L. Sigg Transport of Solutes Across Biological Membranes: Prokaryotes . . . . . W. Ko¨ster Transport of Solutes Across Biological Membranes in Eukaryotes: an Environmental Perspective . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . R. D. Handy and F. B. Eddy Transport of Colloids and Particles Across Biological Membranes . . . . M. G. Taylor and K. Simkiss Mobilisation of Organic Compounds and Iron by Microorganisms . . . . H. Harms and L. Y. Wick Critical Evaluation of the Physicochemical Parameters and Processes for Modelling the Biological Uptake of Trace Metals in Environmental (Aquatic) Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K. J. Wilkinson and J. Buffle
vii ix xi
1
15 113
147
205 271
337 357 401
445
Herman P. van Leeuwen is an electrochemist who obtained his degree in chemistry at the State University of Utrecht, The Netherlands, in 1969. His thesis was in the field of pulse methods in electrode kinetics, and his Ph.D. degree was awarded cum laude (best 5% in The Netherlands) in 1972. He then joined the Colloid Chemistry and Electrochemistry group of Professor J. Lyklema at Wageningen University, where he became a senior lecturer in 1986. His teaching includes analytical/ inorganic chemistry, electrochemistry and environmental physical chemistry. He was appointed Extraordinary Professor at the University of Geneva in 2000. His current major research interests are twofold: (1) ion dynamics and electrokinetics of colloids, and (2) dynamic speciation and bioavailability of metals in environmental systems. He has published some 140 research papers, reviews and book chapters in these fields. He was chairman of the IUPAC Commission on Fundamental Environmental Chemistry from 1995 to 1999, and Chairman of the Electrochemistry Section of the Royal Dutch Chemical Society from 1993 to 2001. Together with J. Buffle, he edits the IUPAC Book Series on Analytical and Physical Chemistry of Environmental Systems, launched in 1992. Wolfgang Ko¨ster studied biology at the Universities of Bielefeld and Tu¨bingen, Germany. Placing emphasis on biochemistry, plant physiology, genetics and microbiology he was influenced by the work of Professor V. Braun, Professor E. Sander and Professor H. Za¨hner. In 1986, he earned his Ph.D. from the University of Tu¨bingen. With a grant from the German Science Foundation (DFG), in 1988 he became a post-doctoral fellow in the laboratory of Professor R. J. Kadner at the School of Medicine, University of Virginia, USA. He was then promoted to a position equivalent to Assistant Professor and the ‘Habilitation’ in Microbiology at the University of Tu¨bingen. Between 1998 and 1999 he held the position of ‘Visiting Scientist’ (Cantarini Fellowship of the Institut Pasteur and Fellowship of the Centre National de la Recherche Scientific (CNRS), France) in the laboratory of Professor M. Hofnung, Institut Pasteur, Paris, France. In 1999, he joined as a Senior Scientist (leading the group Drinking Water Microbiology) the Swiss Federal Institute for Environmental Science and Technology (EAWAG). He gained teaching experience from the Universities of Tu¨bingen and Hohenheim and ETH Zu¨rich by conducting lectures, seminars and practical courses at undergraduate and graduate levels in the areas of microbiology, genetics, biochemistry, molecular biology and environmental science. His major areas of work and interest comprise: (1) survival strategies and molecular detection methods for bacteria in drinking water and environmental habitats, (2) membrane-associated transport phenomena in microbes, with focus on metal transport in bacteria, and (3) bioavailability and ecotoxicity of metals and hydrophobic organic compounds in green algae.
List of Contributors J. Buffle CABE (Analytical and Biophysical Environmental Chemistry/Chimie Analytique et Biophysicochimie de l’Environnement), 30, quai Ernest Ansermet, Universite´ de Gene`ve, CH-1211 Gene`ve 4, Switzerland F. B. Eddy Environmental and Applied Biology, School of Life Sciences, The University of Dundee, Nethergate, Dundee, DD1 4HN, Scotland, UK B. I. Escher Environmental Microbiology and Molecular Ecotoxicology, Swiss Federal Insti¨ berlandstrasse 133, tute for Environmental Science and Technology (EAWAG), U CH-8600 Du¨bendorf, Switzerland J. Galceran Departament de Quı´mica, Universitat de Lleida, Av. Rovira Roure 191, 25198 Lleida, Spain R. D. Handy School of Biological Sciences, The University of Plymouth, Drake Circus, Plymouth, PL4 8AA, UK H. Harms Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, ENAC–ISTE–LPE, Baˆtiment GR, CH1015 Lausanne (EPFL), Switzerland J. M. Kleijn Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Colloid Science, Wageningen University, Dreijenplein 6, NL-6703 HB Wageningen, The Netherlands W. Ko¨ster Environmental Microbiology and Molecular Ecotoxicology, Swiss Federal ¨ berlandstrasse Institute for Environmental Science and Technology (EAWAG), U 133, CH-8600 Du¨bendorf, Switzerland F. A. M. Leermakers Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Colloid Dreijenplein 6, NL-6703 HB Wageningen, The H. P. van Leeuwen Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Colloid Dreijenplein 6, NL-6703 HB Wageningen, The
Science, Wageningen University, Netherlands Science, Wageningen University, Netherlands
viii
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
L. Sigg Analytical Chemistry of the Aquatic Environment, Swiss Federal Institute for ¨ berlandstrasse 133, CHEnvironmental Science and Technology (EAWAG), U 8600 Du¨bendorf, Switzerland K. Simkiss School of Animal and Microbial Sciences, University of Reading, Whiteknights, Reading, RG6 6AJ, UK M. G. Taylor School of Animal and Microbial Sciences, University of Reading, Whiteknights, Reading, RG6 6AJ, UK L. Y. Wick Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, ENAC–ISTE–LPE, Baˆtiment GR, CH1015 Lausanne (EPFL), Switzerland K. J. Wilkinson CABE (Analytical and Biophysical Environmental Chemistry/Chimie Analytique et Biophysicochimie de l’Environnement), 30, quai Ernest Ansermet, Universite´ de Gene`ve, CH-1211 Gene`ve 4, Switzerland
Series Preface The main purpose of the IUPAC Series on Analytical and Physical Chemistry of Environmental Systems is to make chemists, biologists, physicists and other scientists aware of the most important biophysicochemical conditions and processes that define the behaviour of environmental systems. The various volumes of the Series thus emphasise the fundamental concepts of environmental processes, taking into account specific aspects such as physical and chemical heterogeneity, and interaction with the biota. Another major goal of the series is to discuss the analytical tools that are available, or should be developed, to study these processes. Indeed, there still seems to be a great need for methodology developed specifically for the field of analytical/physical chemistry of the environment. The present volume of the series focuses on the interplay between organisms and the physical chemistry of the environmental media in which they live. It critically discusses the different physicochemical and biophysical features of the kinetics of processes at the biointerface, with special attention given to aspects such as bioavailability of chemical species, analysis of the necessary mass transfer towards/from the biointerface, routes of transfer through the biomembrane, etc. This volume was realised within the framework of the activities of the former IUPAC Commission on Fundamental Environmental Chemistry of the Division of Chemistry and the Environment. We thank the IUPAC officers responsible, especially the executive director, Dr John Jost, for their support and assistance. We also thank the International Council for Science (ICSU) for financial support of the work of the Commission. This enabled us to organise the discussion meeting of the full team of chapter authors (in Du¨bendorf, Switzerland, 2001) which formed such an essential step in the preparation and harmonisation of the various chapters of this book. The series is indeed being well received, and is growing prosperously. New volumes, on fractal properties of soil particles and physical techniques for micro/nanoparticle characterisation respectively, are in an early stage of preparation. As with all books in the series, these volumes will present critical reviews that reflect the current state of the art and provide guidelines for future research in the field. Jacques Buffle and Herman P. van Leeuwen Series Editors
Preface The idea of broadening the scope of analytical and physical chemistry of environmental systems, to include the interactions of chemical species with living organisms, has been on the priority list of the former IUPAC Commission on Fundamental Environmental Chemistry for some time. It had been recognised that the distribution and transport of chemical components in biotic and abiotic reservoirs is of paramount importance in understanding the effects and fate of organic and inorganic material in environmental systems. The development of mechanistic models for the transport and distribution of chemical components both within and between biotic and abiotic environments requires an integrated approach, with functional links between the various modes of transport of bioactive chemical species and the biophysicochemical processes to which they are subjected. This challenging goal has sparked interest across many fields of research, with the result that much of the key knowledge necessary for progress has become dispersed over several rather poorly interacting disciplines. It is thus timely to integrate these activities, which are all focused essentially on a common broad objective. In doing so, this book will provide the current overall state of the art, as well as highlight key directions for future research. At the end of the 1990s Professor Alex Zehnder (EAWAG/Du¨bendorf CH) and Professor Ronny Blust (Antwerpen University/Belgium) made the first steps towards the creation of this publication. In close cooperation with the chairman of the IUPAC Commission at that time (Dr Herman P. van Leeuwen) it was decided to focus the subject of the book on the physicochemical kinetics of the various processes at the biointerface, and their coupling with the mass transfer of the chemical species involved. This brief would necessarily encompass subtopics such as the structure and permeative properties of biomembranes and their aqueous interfacial layers, the description of diffusive and convective processes at the biointerface, the routes for transport of chemical compounds across membranes, and the biological chemistry of organisms as relevant, for example, for the mobilisation of essential chemicals in the medium. The heart of the book would be on the interphasial region between external medium and organism, and not so much on details of the various chemical conversions inside the organism. A meeting with all prospective chapter authors was hosted by EAWAG/ Du¨bendorf (Switzerland) in early 2001, and the organisation and editing of the book finally came into the hands of the undersigned. It was decided to
xii
PREFACE
create an opening chapter in order to introduce some of the basic physicochemical features of biointerfaces, e.g. those regarding their characteristic spatial organisation and timescales of transport and chemical reactions. Obviously, chemical speciation and bioavailability are elements of inherent importance in this context. Internalisation of chemical species by organisms is considered in itself, on the level of routes of transfer through the biomembrane, as well as in relation to preceding chemical conversions, stimulated or not by specific reactions of the organism. The elements of the different chapters, that span such apparently disparate topics as the statistical thermodynamics of membrane formation and the endocytosis of colloidal particles, are interlinked as much as possible. The book is concluded by a chapter where experimental biouptake data is critically interpreted in terms of available knowledge, so as to provide an impression of the state of the art. The editors would like to express their gratitude to EAWAG/Du¨bendorf (Switzerland) for hosting the preparatory meeting, to the various external reviewers who carefully looked into the draft chapters and, last but not least, to Dr. Raewyn M. Town (Queen’s University of Belfast) for scrutinising all chapters in terms of their scientific and linguistic qualities and the proper use of IUPAC terminology. Herman P. van Leeuwen and Wolfgang Ko¨ster
1 Physicochemical Kinetics and Transport at the Biointerface: Setting the Stage ¨ STER WOLFGANG KO Microbiology, Swiss Federal Institute for Environmental Science and Technology ¨ berlandstrasse 133, CH-8600 Du¨bendorf, Switzerland (EAWAG), U
HERMAN P. VAN LEEUWEN Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Colloid Science, Wageningen University, Dreijenplein 6, NL-6703 HB Wageningen, The Netherlands
Life has developed in media with very diverse chemical compositions and with a variety of physical conditions, including temperature, pressure and their gradients. Evolution actually implies an optimisation in the functioning of organisms in response to these physical and chemical conditions in which they live. It follows that a change in conditions will give rise to a change in the properties of the organism, and this is known in biology as adaptation. The chemical conditions relevant to survival, evolution and adaptation comprise not only the composition and the chemical dynamics of the medium in which the organism is living, but also the availability of the various chemical species. Therefore the distribution and mobilities of inorganic and organic materials in abiotic and biotic media are of paramount importance in understanding their fate and effects in environmental systems. The present book is concerned with the coupling between environmental media and biota, and focuses on the physicochemical features of processes at their interphases.1 Every living cell, whether it be a unicellular organism on its own or a part of a multicellular organisation, is encircled by a biological membrane. In this context, the terms ‘cell membrane’, ‘plasma membrane’, and ‘cytoplasmic membrane’ are used synonymously. Generally, the interphase between an organism and its environment encompasses the elements outlined in Figure 1. The scheme shows that the cell membrane, with its hydrophobic lipid core, has the most 1 Depending on the context, we sometimes prefer the term ‘interphase’ over ‘interface’ because the latter refers to an infinitely sharp dividing plane between two phases. Organisms generally form boundary layers, e.g. the cell wall, that are characterised by a gradual transition from the biological phase to the medium phase, and if we discuss the volume properties of such layers the term ‘interphase’ is more appropriate.
Physicochemical Kinetics and Transport at Biointerfaces Edited by H. P. van Leeuwen and W. Ko¨ster. ß 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
2
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
Cell membrane O(5 to 10) nm Cell wall layer O(up to 10) nm
O r g a n i s m
Electric double layer O(1 to 10) nm
Medium
Diffusion layer O(10 to 100) µm
Figure 1. Schematic outline of the typical dimensions of the various physically relevant layers at the organism/medium interphase: cell membrane, cell wall layer, electric double layer, diffusive depletion layer
prominent function in separating the hydrophilic aqueous medium from the interior of the cell. The limited and selective permeabilities of the cell membrane towards components of the medium, be they nutrients or toxic species, play a key role in the transport of material from the medium towards the surface of the organism. The lipid bilayer has a very low water content and its core behaves quite hydrophobically, while the cell wall is rather hydrophilic, containing some 80% of water. Physicochemically, the cell wall is particularly relevant because of its high ion binding capacity, and the ensuing impact on the biointerphasial electric double layer. The presence of such an electric double layer ensures that the cell
¨ STER AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN W. KO
3
wall possesses Donnan partition characteristics, leaving only a limited part of the interphasial potential decay in the diffuse double layer of the adjacent medium. Mass transfer phenomena usually are very effective on distance scales much larger than the dimensions of the cell wall and the double layer dimensions. Thicknesses of steady-state diffusion layers1 in mildly stirred systems are of the order of 105 m. Thus, one may generally adopt a picture where the local interphasial properties define boundary conditions while the actual mass transfer processes take place on a much larger spatial scale. The availability of chemical species to organisms is defined by a number of basic features, including: . their chemical reactivity, as derived from equilibrium distributions of species and their rates of interconversion; . the supply (flux) of these chemical species to the relevant sites at the surface of the organism, as governed by their mass transport properties and the concentration gradients that arise at the interphase as a consequence of the interplay between chemical reactivity and biological affinity; and . the internalisation of the chemical species, governed by an internalisation rate constant, kint , usually accompanied or followed by some bioconversion process. The actual processes of uptake of chemical species by an organism typically encompass transport in the medium, adsorption at extracellular cell wall components, and internalisation by transfer through the cell membrane. Each of these steps constitutes a broad spectrum of physicochemical aspects, including chemical interactions between relevant components, electrostatic interactions, elementary chemical kinetics (in this volume, as pertains to the interface), diffusion limitations of mass transfer processes, etc. Life on Earth in all its diversity could never have evolved without the existence of lipids that are able to spontaneously arrange in aqueous solutions into structures such as micelles or bilayers. Although the composition of biological membranes varies markedly with their various functions, and with the type of organism and environmental conditions, there is a common structural organisation involving lipid, protein, and carbohydrate components. With only a few exceptions, lipids are arranged as bilayers and constitute the basic characteristic architecture for a variety of biomembranes found in different living organisms. The average thickness of biomembranes is approximately 7 nm. The majority of lipids in the plasma membrane of bacteria (prokaryotes) 1 Such layers are frequently denoted as ‘unstirred’ layers. The term ‘unstirred’ however, is physically incorrect [1], since velocity profiles in liquid media are continuous functions which only approach zero at the actual interface. In gel layers the liquid velocity is generally low, but this is due to their high viscosities.
4
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
and eukaryotes are comprised of acyl chains (e.g. palmitic acid, stearic acid, oleic acid), which are ester-linked to glycerol. However, many other more complex lipids that contain additional elements like phosphorus, nitrogen or sulfur, may also be found in biomembranes. In addition, hydrophilic components such as small sugars, choline, serine, or ethanolamine are commonly found. Phospholipids containing a phosphate group are ideal amphipathic components, and represent the largest group of membrane lipids. Sterols like cholesterol are almost exclusively found in eukaryotic membranes, where they can make up to 25% of the total lipids. Archaebacteria can exist in the most extreme conditions, and their membrane composition differs from those of the bacteria and eukaryotes. Some unusual components like hopanoids have been found in this group of organisms. Hopanoids are pentacyclic triterpenoids, biosynthetically derived from the linear molecule squalen, which is formed by joining six isopentenyl units. It is assumed that hopanoids may play a role similar to that of sterols in eukaryotic cells. Another common feature of archaeal membranes are acyl chains derived from repeating units of isoprene (e.g. phytanol) which are ether-linked to glycerol or nonitol. The membranes of hyperthermophilic Archaea living at high temperatures are composed of glycerol di-ethers and glycerol tetra-ethers. Lipids containing biphytanyl chains can form monolayers (resembling somewhat the usually found bilayers) with a hydrophobic milieu inside and hydrophilic surfaces outside. They are very stable under extremely high temperatures. Proteins represent another major group of membrane components. They play structural roles and/or are involved in many cellular processes, which are strictly coupled to membranes. Proteins can be either entirely embedded within the bilayer, or they might be firmly anchored (e.g. by a hydrophobic transmembrane segment composed of hydrophobic amino acid side-chains or as lipoprotein), or they can be just associated with the surface. Carbohydrates related to membranes can be found as lipopolysaccharides or as parts of glycoproteins. Sugars are often characteristic determinants of cell surfaces (see below). The great majority of carbohydrates are found in the outer leaflet of a membrane, resulting in an asymmetrical structure. This is especially true for many plasma membranes and the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacterial cells (see below). The membrane is the regulating barrier for exchange of chemical species between the environmental medium and cell interior. It may be practically impermeable to one type of species and highly permeable to another. In the chain of transport steps from the bulk of the medium to the cell interior, the membrane transfer step may thus vary from fully rate-limiting to apparently fast with respect to transport in the medium. The overall rate of this biouptake process is determined by mass transport either in the medium or through the membrane: the actual rate-limiting step will depend on a large variety of factors. Membrane
¨ STER AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN W. KO
5
transfer rates may be influenced by external chemical conditions, such as pH, ionic strength, presence of surfactants, etc., which alter the permeability features of the membrane, as well as by biological factors like conditioning and adaptation, which may regulate the effectiveness and abundance of transporter functions inside the membrane. An intact and largely undisturbed cytoplasmic membrane or plasma membrane representing the innermost layer enclosing a biological cell is absolutely essential for its vitality. Any major impairment or even a small hole would cause unimpeded exchange of ionic species and thus electrical depolarisation of the membrane, resulting in immediate cell death. This effect can also be generated by certain toxins, which assemble into pores in the membrane. Therefore, channels that are simultaneously open to both sides of the cytoplasmic membrane cannot persist in a living cell. With the help of the atomic force microscopy (AFM) technique, it is possible to obtain three-dimensional images of surface structures at the nanometre scale. Erythrocyte membranes, which are stable during the preparation of an AFM experiment, can be used as a rather basic model with respect to composition and surface structure. This enables a number of details to be visualised, e.g. the deformation of a rhesus monkey erythrocyte membrane caused by an infecting virus (Figure 2). In most cases, however, a given solute approaching the surface of a living cell has to deal with more complex structures, a ‘naked’ membrane surface being highly unusual. In human or animal cells, various glycopeptides and glycosylated proteins are integrated into the lipid bilayer, while most plant (a)
(b)
500 2000 400 1500 300
500
2000
1000 1500 1000
500
400
200 300 200
100
500 0 0
100 0
0
Figure 2. Atomic force microscopy images showing the surface of a rhesus monkey erythrocyte membrane. Damage, such as formation of humps on the peripheral surface and pits in other parts, results from the interaction with virions of the canine parvovirus. (a) edge of erythrocyte; (b) pits on membrane surface. (Source: http://www.ntmdt.ru/ publications/download/211.pdf, Reproduced with permission from Dr Boris N. Zaitser)
6
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
cells are surrounded by a cell wall composed of polymers of carbohydrates. Bacteria are usually encircled by a sacculus: this peptidoglycan (or murein) sheet contains glycan chains formed by the alternating sugar derivatives N-acetylglucosamine and N-acetylmuramic acid, which are cross-linked by small peptides building a network. Gram-positive bacteria are characterised by multiple layers of peptidoglycan with attached teichoic acids (acidic polysaccharides consisting predominantly of glycerophosphate mannitol phosphate or ribitol phosphate). Alternatively, Gram-negative bacteria possess only a single peptidoglycan layer, but additionally have a second membrane, called the ‘outer membrane’, harbouring various proteins, lipoproteins, and lipopolysaccharides. Moreover, a number of bacterial species produce external capsules or slime layers, while others are capable of building spores that are highly resistant to adverse environmental conditions. This book focuses on the processes that control the transfer of chemicals between environmental media and living organisms. The major driving forces for transport and chemical conversion are contained in the electrochemical potential, that is, the chemical potential difference plus the electrostatic freeenergy change for charged species. Electrical potential differences between the inner and outer boundary of the biological membrane play a crucial role in the various physiological mechanisms. Such potential differences, usually denoted as membrane potentials, derive from differences in permeability of the membrane with respect to ions in the inner and outer media. Common membrane potential expressions, like the Goldman–Hodgkin–Katz equation [2,3] for Naþ , Kþ and Cl , are valid under steady-state conditions of zero net charge transport: X
zi Ji ¼ 0
(1)
i
where i indexes the permeable ionic species, zi is the charge number of i, and Ji is the flux1 of i across the membrane. Fluxes of charged species are generally the result of gradients in concentration, potential and pressure, which are collect~. ively represented by the electrochemical thermodynamic potential m Application of elementary conservation laws leads to formulation of a general expression for Ji , which is often denoted as the Nernst–Planck equation: Ji ¼ Di grad ci (zi =jzi j) ci ui grad C þ ci
(2)
1 For convenience, fluxes from the medium towards the organism will be counted as positive throughout this book. Analysis of mass transport in the medium is usually based on a coordinate system with the origin at the interface and a positive axis going outward, leading to a negative sign in fluxes towards the interface.
¨ STER AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN W. KO
7
Equation (2), where D denotes diffusion coefficient, c concentration, u mobility, C electric potential, and flow velocity, explicitly shows the diffusion, conduction and flow terms respectively. Within the context of biological systems, transport represented by this Nernst–Planck equation (2) is often referred to as ‘passive’ transport. This qualification is intended to make a distinction from situations where apparently transport takes place in the opposite direction, against a gradient of concentration or potential or pressure. Obviously, such ‘uphill’ or ‘active’ transport requires special conditions, which in biomembrane transport are created by metabolic chemical reactions such as ATP hydrolysis. The coupling of the ionic transport process with the energy providing chemical reaction must be of an asymmetrical nature, in the sense that the production/ consumption of ions at the inner side of the membrane is different from that at the outer side. It has been hypothesised that the asymmetry is in the kinetic features of the interfacial transfer process, in such a way that, in the apparent steady-state, the ratio between influx and efflux is modified. Under such conditions, which essentially are of a nonequilibrium nature, it is possible to realise net uphill ionic transport, and this is the basis of the biologically well-known ionic pumps. The existence of ionic pumps is not in conflict with fundamental transport laws like the Nernst–Planck equation (2): these pumps are generated by the special geometrical and chemically asymmetrical conditions in a biological membrane. In fact, for a rigorous analysis of the pump situation, the Nernst–Planck conservation equation has to be complemented with a chemical source term with a confined spatial distribution. Transport across biological membranes is facilitated by their fluid-like nature. The water content varies strongly from the core to the outer boundary; overall it comes to some 25% by mass. The classical Singer–Nicholson fluid mosaic model represents the biomembrane as a two-dimensional sea of the lipid bilayer, in which proteins and other constituents are floating around. Indeed, most lipid membranes are fluid at physiological temperature, and consequently the lateral mobility of the lipids and proteins is relatively high, whereas the transversal movements (including the flip-flop exchange of lipids between the inner and outer sides) are strongly limited. This feature explains the maintenance of the asymmetry of the membrane with respect to composition and orientation of the ion transporter proteins. As outlined above, this chemical asymmetry is essential for the basic functioning of the biomembrane. Below a certain temperature, the fluid bilayer turns into the crystalline–gel state, in which the lateral mobility of the constituents is greatly diminished. In the fluid state, the lateral diffusion coefficient of lipids in the bilayer structure is O(1013 ) m2 s1 (the symbol ‘O’ is used to indicate order of magnitude). Interestingly, it has been shown that the diffusion coefficients of phospholipids may differ greatly from the inner to the outer leaflet of the biomembrane layer [4,5]. Again, this is related to the differences in chemical
8
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
composition. Lateral transport of lyophobic species like water and ions in the core of the bilayer is not very relevant, because of their extremely low local concentrations. Mobilities of ions in the interphasial region, even inside the stagnant water layer at the actual interface between the aqueous phase and the lipid bilayer, are on the level of that in the bulk solution [6]. As noted above, biouptake involves a series of elementary processes that take place in the external medium, in the interphasial region, and within the cell itself. One of the most important characteristics of the medium is the chemical speciation of the bioactive element or compound under consideration. Speciation not only includes complexation of metal ions by various types of ligands, but also the distribution over different oxidation states, e.g. Fe(II) and Fe(III), and protonation/deprotonation of organic and inorganic acids of intermediate strength. The relationship between speciation and the direct or indirect bioavailability1 of certain species has received a lot of recent attention. Organisms are able to take advantage of a wide range of nutrients, ranging from trace elements to biopolymers such as proteins, DNA, RNA, starch, lignin, etc. Although they are often present in relatively large amounts, these compounds are not always accessible, as illustrated by the following examples: (1) iron, which is an essential nutrient for most living bacteria (lactobacilli being the only notable exception), is the fourth most abundant metal on Earth. However, iron is not readily bioavailable under ‘normal’ physiological conditions. In the environment it is mainly found as a component of insoluble hydroxides; while in biological systems it is chelated by highaffinity iron-binding proteins (e.g. transferrins, lactoferrins, ferritins) or found as a component of erythrocytes (haem, haemoglobin, haemopexin). As a consequence, organisms have evolved a number of different sequestering strategies for this metal. Under anaerobic conditions, ferrous iron can be transported without the involvement of any chelators. Likewise, at pH 3, ferric iron is soluble enough to support growth of acid-tolerant bacteria. At higher pH values, however, iron is mostly found in insoluble compounds. Therefore, a great variety of low-molar-mass iron ligands, socalled siderophores, which bind Fe3þ with very high affinity, are produced by many bacterial species, certain fungi, and some plant species. These chelators are released in their iron-free forms and subsequently transported back into the organism as ferric-siderophore-complexes. Furthermore, a 1 The notion ‘bioavailability’ is used with different meanings. Environmental chemists understand it in terms of the supplying potential of the medium, whereas (micro)biologists relate it to the assimilation properties of the organism. In the case of metal uptake, for example, a certain complex may be fully labile and thus potentially contribute to the supply of free metal ions. In contact with an organism with a modest affinity towards the metal in question the uptake requirements may be so small that such labile complexes are completely unimportant and their lability irrelevant. In microbiological jargon this complex would be ‘not bioavailable’, whereas a chemist would say that this complex is fully available to the organism.
¨ STER AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN W. KO
9
number of organisms are able to use haem-bound iron from haemoglobin and similar molecules. Some bacterial species can acquire iron that is released by an as-yet unknown mechanism from transferrins or lactoferrins, whereas vertebrates take up the whole iron–protein complex. All these processes involve specific uptake systems in the cell envelope and in the cytoplasmic membrane. (2) although many biopolymers represent an excellent source of nutrients, they are often too large to be transported into a biological cell. A number of species have developed ways to overcome this problem by the secretion of enzymes, which are able to breakdown polymers into their constituents. Many organisms originating from all kingdoms of life are known to use this strategy. So-called exo-enzymes, which are released from the producing cell, can be classified according to their functions (e.g. proteases, lipases, nucleases). Although in some cases these enzymes only carry out a partial degradation, oligomers (e.g. peptides) up to a certain size become ‘bioavailable’ and can then be transported into the cell. In particular, the kinetics of dissociation reactions as preceding steps in the biouptake of organics and metals from complex media have been extensively studied. It is likely that the gap between the concentration of labile species, as measured by a certain dynamic analytical technique [7], and the effective bioavailability of that species will soon be bridged. The role of the adsorption of bioactive species in the cell wall region becomes important as soon as a mechanistic interpretation of biouptake fluxes beyond their mere values in the ongoing steady-state is sought. Back-extrapolation of fluxes to zero time, or even better, analysis of the initial transient behaviour of the flux, will provide more comprehensive information on the molecular details of the internalisation kinetics. Such means will enable distinction between receptor sites (physiologically active) and mere adsorption sites (physiologically inactive), metal ion buffering action of the adsorption sites in the cell wall region, and true nonconditional rate constants of the actual membrane transfer steps. Comprehensive models for the overall biouptake process range from simplifying schemes like the free-ion activity model (FIAM) [8] and the biotic ligand model (BLM) [9] to more differentiated approaches at the level of the Best equation (i.e. Michaelis–Menten control of the uptake and mass transport limitations in the medium) coupled with homogeneous chemical kinetics of formation of the bioactive species in the medium [10–12]. Clearly, the local speciation in the biological interphase may be very different from that in the bulk phase, and this may have a great impact on the nature and rate of bioaccumulation processes. Thus, with the ionic composition of the medium generally being very different from that inside the organism, ion trapping mechanisms may be essential in facilitating efficient transport across the cell membrane.
10 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
In addition to their function as a permeability barrier to the extracellular environment, membranes also fulfil important tasks inside most eukaryotic cells and in some bacteria. One crucial role is the separation of different cell compartments. A few examples of intracellular membranes may illustrate the large variety of membrane functions: . a special type of membrane represents the so-called ‘tonoplast’ that surrounds the vacuoles characteristic of many plant cells. Vacuoles, which can differ in size, help to maintain the osmotic pressure of the cell, and are used as temporary stores for reserve materials or final storage compartments for waste products of the cell metabolism. The central vacuole of a fully differentiated cell can reach an extensive size, thus constituting the major part of the cell’s volume. . the nuclear envelope consists of an outer and an inner membrane surrounding the nucleus, which harbours most of the genetic information of the eukaryotic cell. The nucleus is the location of, for example, replication, transcription, and RNA processing, and the enzymes involved in these vital functions have to be imported from the cytosol. . an extensive intracellular membrane system, the so-called endoplasmatic reticulum (ER) is directly connected to the nuclear envelope. A significant portion of protein synthesis is associated with the ER. . stacks of membranous cistern-like structures (dictyosomes) as well as derived small vesicles and tubules (Golgi vesicles) form the Golgi apparatus. Dictyosomes and Golgi vesicles are involved in intracellular transport and secretion of macromolecules. Exocytosis describes a process in which such vesicles undergo a fusion with the plasma membrane and consequently release enclosed substances into the external medium. Likewise, this membrane flow can occur as a reverse process: endocytosis. In this case invagination of membrane areas leads to intracellular vesicles containing substances from the external medium. This process of ‘budding’ can also occur in the opposite direction, thus delivering cellular components (or membraneenclosed phage particles) to the external medium. . membranes are essential elements of organelles that are exclusively found in plants – the plastids. Among them, the chloroplasts, typical of green plants and algae, display a complex structure. Surrounded by an envelope composed of outer and inner membrane, a complicated system, the thylakoid membranes (see Figure 3), harbours all elements essential for photosynthesis. . a special compartment, also consisting of an outer and inner membrane, is realised in mitochondria. These organelles contain all components for generating energy in the form of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) via oxidative phosphorylation. The examples mentioned above exclusively apply to eukaryotic cells. In prokaryotic cells, intracellular membranes are the exception. However,
¨ STER AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN W. KO
11
Figure 3. Example of intracellular membrane organisation: a transmission electron microscopy (TEM) image of a section through the thylakoid stack from a chloroplast. (Source: http://www.ru.ac.za/administrative/emu/gr10p6.htm, Reproduced with permission from Dr. R. Cross)
exceptions are known in a few groups of bacteria where complex intracytoplasmic membrane systems result from the invagination of the plasma membrane. Vesicles, tubuli and thylakoid-like structures are reported. Some of them are present in certain phototrophic bacteria. Extensive intracytoplasmic membrane systems are also found in nonphototrophic nitrifying methane-utilising bacteria. Transport processes across membranes can be divided into several categories: . transport of signals in the form of a signal transduction cascade can be achieved by a series of conformational changes in the components involved, or by consecutive modification events (e.g. phosphorylation–dephosphorylation, methylation–demethylation). These processes enable cells to communicate with their environment, and allow them to respond to changing conditions such as pH, osmolarity, pressure, temperature. . uptake of ions and nutrients (mostly molecules of lower molar mass) and the secretion of metabolites and other smaller molecules (e.g. signalling molecules, siderophores) depend on different types of transport systems, which are either using primary energy sources such as ATP or which are coupled to a gradient like the membrane potential. . transport (import and export) of polymers, including proteins, is also mediated by special transport systems which, in many cases, represent multicomponent systems.
12 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
All these transport processes are of comparable importance for an organism in order to adapt to changing conditions and to exist in a given environment. This book focuses on the mass transfer aspects across biomembranes, involving ions, molecules, and particles. Intact membranes are essential for a great variety of vital functions, such as energy-generating processes taking place in the mitochondria of eukaryotes (see above) or at the cytoplasmic membrane of bacteria. In addition, membranes are indispensable for components involved in electron transport chains, and photosynthesis is strictly coupled to the lipid bilayers. Export machineries for proteins, as well as secretion systems for a variety of substances (such as metabolites, signalling molecules, enzymes and extracellular structures) are located in membranes. Moreover, components involved in cell growth and cell division are specifically associated with membranes. In bacteria, a great variety of extracellular structures are anchored in the membranes, which constitute the envelope. Some structures (e.g. pili, fimbriae) take part in cell–cell interaction, adhesion to surfaces, and biofilm formation, others (e.g. flagellae) allow locomotion and mobility. Since so many functions and processes all occur either within, or coupled to, lipid bilayers, it is easy to realise that a fine-tuned balance of embedded and associated components is highly important for the integrity and functionality of all the different types of biomembranes. Therefore, the design and interpretation of test systems and in vitro assays for studying phenomena related to membranes must consider that both the elimination or overproduction of a single membrane protein (or indeed any set of components) may disturb a fragile system and lead to artificial results. The various aspects mentioned above can be summarised as follows: fluxes and distribution of solutes in aqueous solutions and at (or through) hydrophilic/hydrophobic interphases (see Figure 4) can be modelled by following the rules of physics and physical chemistry. In many cases, equations describing transport phenomena can be rather simple, so long as processes like diffusion and osmosis are dominant, and the shapes and surfaces of particles or cells are not very complicated. However, the complexity of the situation increases greatly once parameters like ‘transport against a concentration gradient’, ‘multicomponent systems’, ‘high or low affinity to a substrate’ or ‘complex structures associated with a cell surface’ have to be taken into account. Thus the development of mechanistic concepts and models for the transport and compartmentalisation of chemicals in bioenvironmental systems requires an integrated approach, which provides functional links between processes at different levels of organisation. Indeed, a thorough understanding of environmental processes can only be achieved if studies of the chemistry (e.g. reaction kinetics and mobilisation) and the biology (e.g. transport near and across biological interphases) are combined. Although it is now widely recognised that integration is the way to proceed, these areas of research have to date been the subjects
¨ STER AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN W. KO
13
diffusion
MY
kd(MY)
ka(MY) kin(M) Mads
M
ka(ML)
kd(ML)
kin(ML) ML
excretion
Figure 4. Schematic representation of the various processes involved in the transfer of metal ions from a complex medium to an organism. The free metal ion and the lipophilic complexes ML are effectively bioactive. Bioinactive complexes MY, present in the medium, can only contribute to biouptake processes via dissociation into M
of the individual disciplines, with little interaction between them. The present book critically summarises and integrates current knowledge of the physicochemical mechanisms, kinetics, transport and interactions involved in processes at biological interphases in environmental systems. It starts with fundamental chapters on the physical chemistry of the structure and permeation properties of the lipid bilayer membrane (Chapter 2), and the basic features of various chemical gradients at the biological interphase and ensuing mass transport from/towards its environment (Chapter 3). The coupling of transport processes in the medium with the actual transfer of chemical species through the cell
14 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
membrane, whether or not this occurs via an adsorbed intermediate, is analysed in Chapter 4 and the role of the chemical speciation of both organic compounds and metals at the biological interphase is discussed in Chapter 5. The biochemical background of transporter functions for the transfer of chemical species across the biological membrane is highlighted for prokaryotes (Chapter 6) and for eukaryotes (Chapter 7). The particular case of transfer of colloids and particles across the biological membrane, known as endocytosis, is reviewed in Chapter 8. The active mobilisation of components in the medium by specific chemical strategies of organisms, with emphasis on mobilisation of organics, is evaluated in Chapter 9. Finally, a number of elements of the foregoing chapters are integrated in Chapter 10, where experimental data for the biological uptake of trace elements from aquatic media are modelled on the basis of knowledge of the speciation and transport parameters of the medium and the cell membrane.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
8. 9. 10.
11. 12.
Levich, V. G. (1962). Physicochemical Hydrodynamics. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ. Goldman, D. E. (1943). Potential, impedance and rectification in membranes, J. Gen. Physiol., 27, 37–59. Hodgkin, A. L. and Katz, B. (1949). The effect of sodium ions on the electrical activity of the giant axon of the squid, J. Physiol. (Lond.), 108, 37–77. Cevc, G. and Marsh, D. (1987). Phospholipid Bilayers. Wiley-Interscience, New York. van der Wal, A., Minor, M., Norde, W., Zehnder, A. J. B. and Lyklema, J. (1997). Electrokinetic potential of bacterial cells, Langmuir, 13, 165–171. Lyklema, J. (1995). Fundamentals of Interface and Colloid Science. Volume II: Solid–Liquid Interfaces. Academic Press, London. Buffle, J. and Horvai, S. eds. (2000). In Situ Monitoring of Aquatic Systems. Chemical Analysis and Speciation. Vol. 6, IUPAC Series on Analytical and Physical Chemistry of Environmental Systems, Series eds. Buffle, J. and van Leeuwen, H. P., John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester. Morel, F. M. M. and Hering, J. (1983). Principles and Applications of Aquatic Chemistry. Wiley-Interscience, New York. Playle, R.C. (1998). Modelling metal interactions at fish gills, Sci. Total Environ., 219, 147–163. Whitfield, M. and Turner, D.R. (1979). Critical assessment of the relationship between biological thermodynamic and electrochemical availability. In Chemical Modeling in Aqueous Systems. ed. Jenne, E. A., ACS Symposium Series, Vol. 93, pp. 657–680. Hudson, R. J. M. (1998). Which aqueous species control the rates of trace metal uptake by aquatic biota? Observations and predictions of non-equilibrium effects, Sci. Total Environ., 219, 95–115. van Leeuwen, H. P. (1999). Metal speciation dynamics and bioavailability. Inert and labile complexes, Environ. Sci. Technol., 33, 3743–3748.
2 Molecular Modelling of Biological Membranes: Structure and Permeation Properties FRANS A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. MIEKE KLEIJN Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Colloid Science, Wageningen University, Dreijenplein 6, NL-6703 HB, Wageningen, The Netherlands
1
2
3
4
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1 Water and the Hydrophobic Effect . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2 The Hydrocarbon Chains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3 The Hydrocarbon–Water Interface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4 Surfactants and the Surfactant Packing Parameter . . . . . . . . 1.5 Membrane Tension . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.6 Vesicles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.7 Lipid Phase Behaviour . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.8 Complexity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.9 Models of Lipid Bilayers. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.10 Ensembles in Molecular Modelling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Molecular Dynamic Technique . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1 The Strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 The Box . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 The Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4 The Force Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Time and Length Scales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6 Dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine Bilayers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7 Coarse-Grained MD . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Monte Carlo Technique . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 The Strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 The Box and the Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Pragmatic Approximations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Hybrid MC and MD Approaches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5 Typical Monte Carlo Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Self-Consistent-Field Technique . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 The Strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Physicochemical Kinetics and Transport at Biointerfaces Edited by H. P. van Leeuwen and W. Ko¨ster. ß 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
16 19 20 20 21 24 26 30 30 31 32 33 33 34 35 35 39 40 44 46 46 47 48 48 49 51 52
16
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
4.2 4.3
The Box . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 53 The Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54 4.3.1 Lipids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54 4.3.2 Water . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55 4.3.3 Ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56 4.3.4 Free Volume and the Pressure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56 4.4 The Segment Potentials. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57 4.5 The SCF Solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61 4.6 Phosphatidylcholine Bilayers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63 4.7 The Lateral Pressure Profile. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69 4.8 Comparison of SCF and MD for SOPC Membranes. . . . . . 70 4.9 Case Studies: SCF Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 74 4.9.1 Effects of the Length of the Hydrocarbon Tails . . . . 74 4.9.2 Lipid Variations: Charged Lipids in Bilayers . . . . . . 75 4.9.3 The Gel-phase of DPPC Bilayers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 76 4.9.4 Mechanical Parameters of Lipid Bilayers. . . . . . . . . . 78 4.9.5 Membrane–Membrane Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83 4.9.6 A DPPC Layer as a Substrate for a Polyelectrolyte Brush . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 84 5 Transport and Permeation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 86 5.1 Solubility–Diffusion Mechanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 86 5.1.1 Equilibrium Aspects: Partitioning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88 5.1.2 Dynamic Aspects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 5.2 Pore Mechanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 5.3 MD Modelling of Mediated Membrane Transport . . . . . . . 97 6 Summary, Challenges and Outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 Glossary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102
1
INTRODUCTION
In this review we bring together issues relevant for the structure and permeation properties of biological membranes, from a theoretical, physicochemical perspective. After an introduction concerning the nature of biological membranes, models to evaluate their structural, thermodynamic and mechanical properties will be critically discussed. The input and output of models with molecular detail, in particular the molecular dynamics (MD) and self-consistent-field (SCF) approaches, are analysed. The underlying idea is that all membrane properties should be deducible from that of their constituents. We will pay some attention to the relative importance of intra- and intermolecular forces. Most SCF results that will be presented are updated, i.e. literature results are recomputed using a considerably improved set of interaction parameters. We
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
17
will attempt to cover the complete set of membrane properties that has been considered by SCF modelling to date. The hope is that, eventually, modelling will support measurable system characteristics and predict the unmeasurable ones. With respect to the structure of membranes, we will concentrate on that of phospholipid bilayers, and only briefly mention the work on more complex systems. The review will be biased towards those issues that are relevant to permeation. Our conclusion is that detailed knowledge is available on the structural properties of membranes. The molecularly realistic models mentioned are all in good mutual agreement and indeed complement available experimental data. Structure is only one aspect relevant for transport of molecules across the bilayer; partitioning and dynamics are others. Not surprisingly, significantly less is known about the molecular details that control permeation issues. Indeed, modelling of transport phenomena, especially when specialised molecules are involved, is one of the key challenges for the near future. The fluid mosaic model of the nature of the biological membrane, as put forward by Singer and Nicolson [1] in 1972, is still the starting point for most of the modern work done on biomembranes. The first-order effects described by this model are undisputed. The basis of the biological membrane is a bilayer of lipid molecules, i.e. the lipid bilayer. Computer graphics allow beautiful representations of such a bilayer. The example given in Figure 1 depicts a snapshot of a MD simulation of a bilayer composed of phosphatidylcholine lipids in a slab of water. The fluid mosaic model points further to the role of the lipid molecules. On the one hand, the bilayer forms a barrier to transport for many molecular species that go from one compartment to the other, i.e. the membrane is semi-permeable. The matrix also provides a medium in which protein molecules are incorporated in such a way that they are biologically active. The fluid mosaic model also points correctly to the strongly anisotropic mobility of molecules in this topology. A lipid molecule easily moves around in its ‘own’ monolayer, but it is strongly hindered from flipping from one side to the other (flip-flopping) or jumping out of the bilayer into the aqueous phase. The fluid mosaic model conveniently describes how the constituent molecules are ordered, and it correctly describes, in first order, some of the membrane’s properties. However, it does not give explicit insight into why the biological membrane has a particular structure, and how this depends on the properties of the constituent molecules and the physicochemical conditions surrounding it. For this reason, only qualitative and no quantitative use can be made of this model as it pertains to permeation properties, for example. It is instructive to review the physicochemical principles that are responsible for typical membrane characteristics. In such a survey, it is necessary to discuss simplified cases of self-assembly first, before the complexity of the biological system may be understood. The focus of this quest for principles will therefore be more on the level of the molecular nature of the membrane, rather than viewing a
18
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
Figure 1 (Plate 1). A molecular view of a small section of a flat lipid bilayer generated by molecular dynamics simulations. The bilayers are composed of 1-stearoyl-2-docosahexaenoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylcholine lipids, i.e. the sn1 chain is 18 C atoms long and the sn2 chain has 22 carbons, including six cis double bonds. The hydrophobic core is in the centre of the picture, and the hydrated head-group regions are both on top and bottom of the view graph. The head group is zwitterionic and no salt has been added. From [102]. Reproduced by permission of the American Physical Society. Copyright (2003)
membrane as a flexible sheet that can be characterised by a number of mechanical parameters. However, the mechanical parameters must also have a molecular origin. Indeed, the large-scale properties of the bilayer (i.e. the lamellar topology) are essential for the compartmentalisation function of membranes. This has a direct link to transport and permeation. For this reason, we will also give this topic some attention. Lipid assemblies of the lamellar type, such as lipid bilayers, can feature a true phase transition in which the topology does not change. Upon cooling, the bilayer goes from the fluid phase to the gel phase. In the fluid phase, the acyl chains are disordered, in the sense that there is enough free volume around the chains to allow for chain conformation variations. In the gel phase, the acyl chains are more densely packed and believed to be ordered in an all-trans (straight) configuration. For very pure systems, at temperatures below this sharp gel-to-liquid phase transition, there are several other states and distinct transitions detectable (pre-transition, ripple phase, etc.). These phases will not be reviewed here. In biomembranes, many type of lipids (and other molecules) occur, and it is known that for this reason the gel-to-liquid phase transition is
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
19
not sharp and occurs over a temperature range of ten degrees or more. In the transition region, there are relatively large density fluctuations, especially when the transition is sharp. These fluctuations lead to pronounced changes in permeation characteristics [2]. As these changes are transient we will not focus on these effects. 1.1
WATER AND THE HYDROPHOBIC EFFECT
Soft condensed matter, e.g. a liquid, is composed of molecules that strongly interact with each other. Without the intermolecular interactions, one only would have gases and, at extreme densities, solids. In all systems that are of interest for biology, water is the main liquid. The water H2 O molecule is very special, and to some extent water has peculiar properties [3]. It has a very low molar mass and, as such, one would expect water to be a gas at ambient conditions, like methane (CH4 ). However, water has the ability to form up to four H-bonds per molecule (each molecule can donate two and accept two Hbonds) and at room temperature is far closer to its freezing temperature than to its critical temperature. Water has a local tetrahedral arrangement dictated by the strongly angular-dependent H-bonds between neighbours. This ‘network’ leaves open voids or free spaces that are equal in size to the water molecule themselves. These voids are stabilised against a collapse by repulsive forces between the molecules, which occur when two water molecules make close contact with each other in an orientation unsuitable for H-bond formation. A realistic picture of water is that H-bonds tend to break and reform easily, and in such a dynamic situation it can be understood that water has a relatively low viscosity. Water is not a particularly good solvent. Not many types of molecules mix with water in all proportions. When a compound has no ability to participate in the H-bonding network, it is likely to be rejected from the water phase. We call these compounds hydrophobic. Hydrocarbon chains are representatives of this class of molecules: hydrocarbons and water strongly segregate. Charged molecules, i.e. ions, are an exception to this rule. The water molecule has a dipole with a fractional negative charge near the oxygen, and a corresponding positive charge halfway between the protons. This dipole will orient in such a way that the molecule is attracted to the ion. As a result, a hydration layer coats the ion. This cluster of molecules dissolves easily, often to very high concentrations, in water. Usually, dissolution of a small amount of one compound in a pure liquid is enthalpically unfavourable and driven by an increase in (mixing) entropy. At room temperature, the opposite is true for the dissolution of a small apolar compound in water. This unexpected behaviour is referred to as the hydrophobic effect [4]. Classically, this effect has been rationalised by ordered water structures around apolar compounds (entropy reduction) and the increase in number
20
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
of H-bonds supposed to form in this layer (enthalpy gain). This interpretation has its problems. It is not very likely that the apolar compounds that prevent the H-bonding network in water from developing can generate structures that overcompensate this loss. We strongly prefer the less-known interpretation of Besseling et al. [5,6]. These authors argue that dissolving a small apolar compound has the effect that the H-bonding network is deformed (entropy loss). The enthalpic gain is not explained by an increase of H-bonds (this remains constant or can even go down when the network is stretched too much), but by the fact that the additives can screen the unfavourable inter-water contacts discussed above. In this picture, the hydrophobic effect and the density maximum of water at 4 8C are strongly correlated phenomena. It is of interest to mention that, at elevated temperature, the usual thermodynamic behaviour is also found for dissolving apolar entities in water. Irrespective of how the free energy of mixing is split up into an enthalpic or entropic part, in effect it remains very difficult to dissolve much of the apolar compound in water. These thermodynamic subtleties are important for explaining the sensitivity for membranes with respect to temperature. We will not do this here. 1.2
THE HYDROCARBON CHAINS
Hydrocarbons can be viewed as semi-flexible chains. The rotation around a C–C bond can be expressed by the rotational isomeric state scheme. The trans configuration is favoured with respect to gauche conformers by an energy difference of about 1 kT. This means that the persistence length – the length along the contour of the chain in which a free-flying chain in a good solvent can ‘remember’ the direction it is going in – is four to five carbon atoms. Short hydrocarbon chains with a chain length of order 16 carbons can thus be viewed as extremely short polymer chains of just about four segments long. In a hydrocarbon melt, the chains are oriented isotropically. This is not the case for hydrocarbon chains at the hydrocarbon–air interface. These chains have anisotropic conformations and are more ordered. Upon cooling a hydrocarbon phase, the freezing of the liquid starts at the hydrocarbon–air interface and at slightly lower temperature the bulk solidifies. This phenomenon is called surface freezing, and has received considerable attention in recent years [7,8]. The slight (order-induced) increase in density of the acyl chains at the boundary is responsible for this effect. Indeed, the shift in freezing temperature is marginal (only one or two degrees), which indicates that the density change of the ordered top layer differs only slightly from that in the bulk. 1.3
THE HYDROCARBON–WATER INTERFACE
When sufficient amounts of hydrocarbon chains are mixed with water, macroscopic phase separation takes place. The saturation value of hydrocarbon
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
21
molecules in water decreases exponentially with the length of the hydrocarbon chain [4,9]. Typically the free energy penalty to transfer a CH2 group from its own environment to water at around room temperature is of order 1 kT (i.e. the thermal energy) [4]. For this reason, the surface tension between a hydrocarbon phase and water is relatively high (ca. 30 mN m1) and the interface between these two phases is sharp, that is only one or two times the size of a water molecule. It is instructive to rationalise the latter result from the point of view of energy transfer of a CH2 group to water. As mentioned above, this value is about 1 kT. This means that the thermal energy suffices to allow the transfer of one or two CH2 groups of the hydrocarbon chain to water, but not many more. This means that the protrusion of hydrocarbon fragments into the water phase is also limited to a few CH2 groups. In other words, the hydrocarbon–water interface is fairly sharp, but it is not a mathematical step-function. The amount of water that can dissolve in an apolar phase is very low (mole fraction of the order of 0.001). The origin of this low value is the loss of H-bond energy when a water molecule enters the hydrophobic phase. This result is only weakly dependent on the acyl chain length. Finally, it is noted that at room temperature all lipid acyl chains are far from their critical points for the water–hydrocarbon unmixing. Therefore the density of the hydrocarbon phase is high. Indeed, the density of a hydrocarbon melt does not differ much from that of water. 1.4 SURFACTANTS AND THE SURFACTANT PACKING PARAMETER There are molecules that dissolve in water (hydrophilic molecules) and molecules that do not (hydrophobic molecules). Of course there are also molecules that chemically combine both entities. These molecules have peculiar mixing properties with water. It is as if these molecules become ‘frustrated’ when mixed with water. They are called amphiphiles or, more frequently, surfactants. Here we are interested in those surfactants that consist of two hydrocarbon chains as the hydrophobic part of the molecule combined with a hydrophilic moiety (usually a charged group), such that these are in a head–tail configuration. These molecules tend to show a solubility limit in water, typically near a value that would have been found for the hydrophobic part alone, but the result of supersaturation is not a macroscopic phase separation. Instead, the aggregation is stopped by the hydrophilic part of the molecules [10]. This process, arrested phase separation, is known as self-assembly. The results of self-assembly of lipid molecules into flat bilayer objects are called membranes. Other geometries exist. The start–stop mechanism of self-assembly dictates a specific rule regarding the type of geometries that can form. At least one of the dimensions of these objects, which are generally called micelles, must remain of the size of the surfactant molecule. As not all dimensions of the micelle can grow without bounds, these micelles can be referred to as being mesoscopic in size.
22
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
It is important to remember that the surfactants in the micelles are in equilibrium with the remaining surfactants in solution. The concentration of free surfactants is known as the critical micellisation concentration (c.m.c.). The molecules in these objects are mobile, and they can exchange with molecules in the bulk. Furthermore, the micelle concentration and the size and shape of the micelles may be a function of the surfactant concentration. Typically, the main effect of increasing the overall surfactant concentration is that the number of micelles increase. The secondary effect is that the free surfactant concentration increases slightly and, because of this, the micelle size adjusts. When the number of surfactants per micelle increases, it can result in some type of packing frustration. When the aggregation number is no longer compatible with the micellar shape, shape changes are implemented. This leads to cylindrical or lamellar-shaped micelles at surfactant concentrations well above the c.m.c. In this review, we are mostly interested in lamellar topologies, i.e. membranes. Israelachvili and co-workers [11] argued that in order to have stable bilayers the averaged shape of the molecule should be a cylinder. This means that the so-called surfactant parameter S ¼ =‘ao (where ‘ is the all-trans length of the hydrophobic tail, ao is the area occupied by the hydrophilic head group, and is the volume occupied by the tails) assumes a value of S 1. Straightforward geometry tells us that cylindrical micelles are favourable when S 1=2, and spherical micelles should be expected when S 1=3. This rule of thumb works very well indeed. It predicts, for example, that surfactants with one tail, for which S 1=3, will tend to form micelles, but surfactants with the same head group, i.e. with same ao , on to which two similar tails of length ‘ are connected will be more likely to form membranes. This is because now is larger by a factor of two and thus S 2=3. Although the following will not add to the proof of the effectiveness of the surfactant parameter approach, it is instructive to mention the implicit assumptions made in it (see also Figure 2). . the first approximation is that the area per molecule a can be defined. There are two counter acting forces that control this area. Firstly, there is the tendency to minimise hydrocarbon–water contacts. The free energy contribution of this is fh (a) ¼ ~ga. Here, ~g is the surface tension between the hydrocarbon phase and the water phase. This tends to decrease the area per molecule. Secondly, pressing head groups near to each other gives repulsive forces that may be of an electrostatic or steric origin. A generic form for this repulsion is fr (a) ¼ k=a, where k is a constant modulating this repulsion (that is, a function of ionic strength, etc.) and can, in principle, weakly depend on the surfactant tail length or micelle shape. The sum of these contributions: ft (a) ¼ fh (a) þ fr (a) may be optimised to give the parea ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi per molecule. The optimal area per molecule is found when a ¼ ao ¼ k=~g. Variations in this area are typically small. This means that membranes are laterally rather incompressible.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
23
:-(
Incompressible
:-(
:-)
:-(
Only small protrusions
:-)
:-(
No interdigitation
:-) :-(
Tails semi-flexible
Figure 2. This figure gives a schematic illustration of various fluctuations that exist in lipid bilayers. From top to bottom: (1) the increase in area and concomitant reduction in membrane thickness is strongly damped. (2) Up and down movements of the lipids are restricted to small amplitudes, i.e. much less than the tail length. (3) Interpenetration of lipids into the opposite monolayer is, in first approximation, forbidden. (4) Conformations of the lipid tails have only few gauche defects, so that the tail is only slightly curved. Reproduced from (58) with permission from the Biophysical Society
. lipid protrusions, i.e. movements of lipids in membranes in the normal direction of the membrane surface, are small as compared with the length of the amphiphile (cf. the width of the oil–water interface discussed above). This allows in principle for a definition of (an intrinsic) membrane thickness and membrane volume (necessary for the estimation of partition coefficients of additives). . in a typical aggregate the chain may have a number of gauche defects which will reduce its effective length. Nevertheless, the thickness of the bilayer is still expected to scale linearly with the extended length of the tails, ‘. . in addition, there is the issue of the volume occupied by the tails in an aggregate. Above, it was argued that hydrocarbons strongly segregate from water. This means that the density of the hydrocarbon phase is high; the acyl chains pack rather densely. Inside a membrane the density is not necessarily
24
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
equal to the bulk density of the corresponding hydrocarbon phase because the apolar tails in the aggregated amphiphiles are anisotropically oriented. However, as a first approximation, one can equate these densities. This means that the volume occupied by the surfactant tails is under water– hydrocarbon phase segregation control. . chains from one leaflet do not interpenetrate (interdigitate) into the opposite leaflet. Although there is no obvious (free-energy) argument why this is generally the case, it is common belief that it is (in first order) true. . cooperative lateral movements of many lipid molecules, usually called undulations, do not frustrate the packing arguments. This means that these fluctuations are on a length scale that is large as compared with the size of the lipid molecules (or, equivalently, the membrane thickness). A detailed justification of the surfactant parameter approach is still the subject of theoretical investigations, and we will return to several issues below. We mention that the surfactant parameter approach is consistent with the fluid mosaic model of Singer and Nicolson. It tells us that the self-assembly of amphiphiles is driven by the strong segregation of water and hydrocarbon chains, and that packing effects dominate the self-assembly process. All of the above considerations have sometimes led to a too rigid picture of the membrane structure. Of course, the mentioned types of fluctuations (protrusions, fluctuations in area per molecule, chain interdigitations) do exist and will turn out to be important. Without these, the membrane would lack any mechanism to, for example, adjust to the environmental conditions or to accommodate additives. Here we come to the central theme of this review. In order to come to predictive models for permeation in, and transport through bilayers, it is necessary to go beyond the surfactant parameter approach and the fluid mosaic model. Of course it is extremely challenging to build a molecular model for the bilayer which incorporates all of the above properties, and which includes the important fluctuations. From a physicochemical point of view, it is clear that such a model should accurately represent the size and shape of the surfactants. This is necessary because we have seen that the packing effects are important. Such a model should be able to work at very high densities of strongly interacting molecules. The interactions are both of the short-range type (hydrophobic–hydrophilic) as well as of a longer-range type (electrostatics, van der Waals). Below we will discuss only those methods that are powerful enough to do so. 1.5
MEMBRANE TENSION
The combination of the first and second laws of thermodynamics exactly defines the equilibrium of a system. Of course, many biological systems are
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
25
not in equilibrium, and not even in so-called steady-states. It is not known by how much such dynamically evolving bilayers differ structurally from equilibrated ones. In the following sections of this review, we are going to assume that the bilayers have come to a thermal equilibrium. The simple reason for this is that such a bilayer system is unequivocally defined. For obvious reasons, we need to introduce surface contributions in the thermodynamic framework. Typically, in interface thermodynamics, the area in the system, e.g. the area of an air–water interface, is a state variable that can be adjusted by the observer while keeping the intensive variables (such as the temperature, pressure and chemical potentials) fixed. The unique feature in selfassembling systems is that the observer cannot adjust the area of a membrane in the same way, unless the membrane is put in a frame. Systems that have self-assembly characteristics are conveniently handled in a setting of thermodynamics of small systems, developed by Hill [12], and applied to surfactant self-assembly by Hall and Pethica [13]. In this approach, it is not necessary to make assumptions about the structure of the aggregates in order to define exactly the equilibrium conditions. However, for the present purpose, it is convenient to take the bilayer as an example. Let us consider, for example, a flat symmetrical bilayer of which the area is large, so that end-effects can be ignored. Finite size effects are important, and will be discussed in the following section. The membrane is freely floating in solution, i.e. it is not supported by a frame. Combination of the first and second laws of thermodynamics gives for the difference of internal energy dU of a bulk system with membranes with area A: X mi dni þ gdA (1) dU ¼ TdS pdV þ i
where S is the entropy, T the temperature, p the pressure, V the volume, i is the index pointing to molecular components and m the chemical potential. The intensive variable associated with the membrane area is the surface tension g. In principle, the last term seems to be redundant, because the first three terms should already cover any energy change (in a macroscopically homogeneous bulk). In other words, we have introduced extra knowledge of the existence of membranes. The last term is thus some kind of ‘hidden’ contribution. It is often more convenient to control the temperature than to control the entropy, and therefore it is more convenient to switch to the Helmholtz energy F ¼ U TS, for which we can write: X mi dni þ gdA (2) dF ¼ SdT pdV þ i
It will be clear that the membrane is free to adjust its area. Let the system be closed, i.e. let the number ni of molecules in it be fixed. Let the temperature
26
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
T and volume V also be fixed. In this case the system minimises its Helmholtz energy. This can be done by adjusting its surface area:
qF qA
¼g¼0
(3)
T , V , {ni }
This leads to the equilibrium condition that the membrane tension is zero. For stability reasons it is necessary that q2 F =qA2 0, or equivalently that qg=qA 0. To understand this, it may be convenient to consider an off-equilibrium membrane under tension. A finite tension leads to a bilayer in which the area per molecule is slightly larger than the optimal one. This also means that the thickness is slightly reduced. A finite tension means thermodynamically that it is unfavourable to have a large surface area. As a response, the system will try to reduce its area. When doing so, the area per molecule goes down, the membrane thickness must increase (the loss of material to the bulk can often be ignored) and, as a consequence, the membrane tension is reduced. Exactly the opposite will occur for membranes with a negative surface tension. Sufficiently rigorous models of equilibrated flat bilayers must therefore necessarily have the tension-free state of the bilayer as a constraint. There is a discussion in the literature about the effect of undulation entropy on the equilibrium membrane tension [14,15]. Formally, undulations are included in the surface tension, and thus we need not worry about this. However, if in some model the two are artificially decoupled, one may allow for a very small (positive) surface tension as the equilibrium structure. In other words, the entropy (per unit area) from undulations should compensate for the tension (excess free energy per unit area). 1.6
VESICLES
Flat bilayers only exist in lamellar phases (or in theoretical models). In practice, end-effects are important, and can be eliminated by closing the bilayer into vesicles, known in biology as liposomes. Closing a vesicle introduces curvature energy into the system. It is important to discuss this aspect in some depth. Any curved interface can be described by determining at each point of the surface, two radii of curvature R1 and R2 [16,17]. Typically, we will be interested in a large radius of curvature (R very much larger than the membrane thickness), and therefore it is convenient to define two small parameters: the total curvature J ¼ 1=R1 þ 1=R2 , and the Gaussian curvature K ¼ 1=R1 R2 . Both J and K are invariant upon interchanging the numbering. For a spherical object, R1 ¼ R2 ¼ R and J 2 ¼ 4K ¼ 4=R2 . For cylindrical vesicles one R is infinite and thus K ¼ 0 and J ¼ 1=R.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
27
Helfrich has shown [18] that the surface tension of a curved interface can be expressed as a Taylor series up to second order in the radius of curvature: 1 K g ¼ go þ kc (J Jo )2 þ k 2 1 1 K ¼ go þ kc Jo2 kc Jo J þ kc J 2 þ k 2 2
(4)
are (phenomenoThe mean bending modulus kc and the saddle splay modulus k logically) mechanical parameters specific for a particular interface. A molecular model is necessary to give an interpretation to these parameters. We will show this below. Equation (4) also allows for a finite so-called spontaneous curvature Jo ¼ 1=R1o þ 1=R2o . For a particular membrane, the Jo (sphere) ¼ 2Jo (cylinder). When a lipid bilayer is composed of just one type of lipid, it must be true that the flat bilayer is stable against small curvature fluctuations. In other words, for reasons of symmetry one should expect that for such a bilayer Jo ¼ 0. In principle, the situation may be fundamentally different for membrane systems which are composed of more than one type of amphiphile. In this case it is, at least in principle, feasible that the flat bilayer is unstable against curvature fluctuations. When a small curvature is imposed, one may witness an uneven partitioning of the various lipids between the inner and outer leaflet of the curved bilayer. Although the two lipids may differ in their surfactant parameter (and thus there may be a thermodynamic driving force for uneven partitioning), entropy strongly counteracts any strong segregation of the lipids. As a result, we must expect that the reshuffling of the lipids is modest and the spontaneous curvature remains strictly zero. However, when entropy cannot counteract a major sorting of the lipids, e.g. when the lipids laterally segregate due to unfavourable lateral interactions, one may expect a nonzero spontaneous curvature. This may be the case when a mixed bilayer membrane is near its gel–liquid phase transition temperature, or when the chemistry of the mixed surfactants is sufficiently different, e.g. when surfactants with fluorinated carbon tails are mixed with hydrogenated ones [19]. Systems of this type, i.e. lipid systems, which are composed of components that laterally segregate, may however, prefer to form two types of vesicles, each composed of one type of lipid only. This again counteracts the nonzero value of Jo for each vesicle. In biological systems, one often observes membrane structures with nonzero spontaneous curvatures, e.g. in mitochondria. This type of bilayer structure is also essential in various transport related processes such as endo- and exocytosis (see Chapter 8 of this volume). These curved membrane systems may be stabilised by protein aggregation in the bilayer, or may be the result of the fact that biological membranes are constantly kept off-equilibrium by lipid transport and/or by (active) transport processes across the bilayer. These interesting
28
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
subjects are not yet within reach of state-of-the-art molecular modelling techniques. In model systems for bilayers, one typically considers systems which are composed of one type of phospholipid. In these systems, vesicles very often are observed. The size of vesicles may depend on their preparation history, and can vary from approximately 50 nm (small unilamellar vesicles or SUVs) up to many mm (large unilamellar or LUV). Also one may find multilamellar vesicular structures with more, and often many more than, one bilayer separating the inside from the outside. Indeed, usually it is necessary to follow special recipes to obtain unilamellar vesicles. A systematic way to produce such vesicles is to expose the systems to a series of freeze–thaw cycles [20]. In this process, the vesicles are repeatedly broken into fragments when they are deeply frozen to liquid nitrogen temperatures, but reseal to closed vesicles upon thawing. This procedure helps the equilibration process and, because well-defined vesicles form, it is now believed that such vesicles represent (close to) equilibrium structures. If this is the case then we need to understand the physics of thermodynamically stable vesicles. For lipid bilayers, equation (4) can be simplified. Above we have seen that the flat unsupported bilayer is without tension, i.e. g(0, 0) ¼ 0, and therefore the first two terms must cancel: go ¼ 12 kc Jo2 . As argued above, Jo ¼ 0, and thus also the third term drops out. The remaining two terms are proportional to the curvature to the power two. For a cylindrical geometry only, the term proportional to J 2 is present. For spherical vesicles, the two combine into one: )J 2 . The curvature energy of a homogeneously curved bilayer is ( 12 kc þ 14 k found by integrating the surface tension over the available area: ] sphere gAs ¼ 4p [2kc þ k 1 gAs =L ¼ 2p [ kc J] cylinder 2
(5)
In a cylindrically curved bilayer, the area per unit length As =L is of course used. The terms in the square brackets are necessarily positive, and therefore there is > 0. Considering the importance a constraint on spherical vesicles that 2kc þ k of the two bending moduli, it is rather surprising that estimates for these quantities are very rare. The few experiments on phospholipids point to kc values ranging between 10 and 40 kT [21]. To date, there is no experiment which . Again, molecular modelling is needed to leads directly to reliable values for k gain insight into these quantities. controls the memIt is believed that the Gaussian bending modulus k brane topology. In particular, a negative value of this constant is needed for stable bilayers. A positive value will induce nonlamellar topologies, such as is negative for bicontinuous cubic phases. Therefore, it is believed that k membranes.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
29
). As The total curvature energy of a spherical vesicle is given by 4p(2kc þ k all experimental data on phospholipids indicate that kc is not small, one is inclined to conclude that the vesicles are thermodynamically unstable: the reduction of the number of vesicles, e.g. by vesicle fusion or by Ostwald ripening, will reduce the overall curvature energy. However, such lines of is sufficiently negative to allow the thought overlook the possibility that k overall curvature free energy of vesicles to remain small. is only slightly larger than zero, one can envisage that the When 2kc þ k mixing entropy of the vesicles can compensate for the curvature energy. Accounting for the mixing entropy, which, for dilute solutions, is proportional to lnj of the vesicle solution, equilibrium vesicles are expected when ) ¼ 0. Equivalently, j ¼ exp[ 4p(2kc þ k )=kT]. Fmix ¼ kTlnjy þ 4p(2kc þ k y Safran showed [22] that when the vesicles are thermodynamically stabilised by translational entropy, the vesicle size decreases with decreasing lipid concentration with a power-law R(j) / j0:25 . Experimentally, a smaller power-law exponent is found [23]. The reason for this is that vesicles are not rigid and can assume shape fluctuations, often referred to as undulations. The effect of undulations may be understood from the observation that a membrane may be characterized by a membrane persistence length x. The persistence length is the length along the surface over which the membrane can ‘remember’ its orientation. Orientational information is lost due to the fact that the bilayer is not rigid but semi-flexible. It is known that the persistence length is an exponential function of the mean bending modulus x ‘m exp(kc =kT ) [24,25]. Here ‘m is a molecular length. When we consider two points on the surface that are closer together than x, we know they are on a piece of the bilayer that may be considered approximately flat. However, when the two points are further apart than x, the local orientation of the bilayer on these two points is uncorrelated. This means that when a bilayer closes on length scales larger than x, the curvature energy must vanish. One way to , and thus the curvature energy implement this idea is to allow both kc and k of the vesicle, to depend on the radius of the vesicle. For example, one can write the renormalised mean bending modulus of the form kc (R) ¼ kbare ln( ‘Rm ), c bare is the unnormalised mean bending modulus (all coefficients are where kc ignored for the sake of the argument). When R x, it is clear that the renormalised constant vanishes. Such renormalisation leads to the conclusion that fluctuation-induced stabilisation of vesicles occurs when R x. Usually, one assumes that this argument leads to the prediction that only very large vesicles can exist, because of the very strong dependence of x(kc ) and the relatively high is of the same order of values of kc reported in the literature. However, when k magnitude as kc , the argument may well explain the thermodynamic stability of the vesicle. In conclusion, lipid vesicles that are fully equilibrated (freeze–thaw procedure) may be stabilised by both translational as well as undulational entropy.
30
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
Taking both contributions into account leads to the prediction [26,27] that R(j) / j0:12 . Recent experiments are consistent with this [23]. 1.7
LIPID PHASE BEHAVIOUR
Besides the regulation of the surface area, surfactant (lipid) aggregates have the extra degree of freedom of choice of topology. Above, we have already discussed the formation of curved bilayers or vesicles and mentioned the possibility of formation of (spherical) micelles. Other aggregates are also possible, i.e. in some systems, spherical, cylindrical or lamellar micelles (membranes) may form. These objects can float either randomly in solution or they can be ordered in a liquid-crystalline array, leading to, for example, a cubic-, a hexagonal-, or a lamellar phase. On top of these phases there may be various phases in which saddle-shaped surfaces occur, such as double diamonds (cubic) and sponge phases. A phase diagram is therefore rather crowded and complex. Nomenclature exists to refer to particular phases: for example, phases with lamellar topology are referred to by the letter L. The liquid-crystalline phase of the bilayers is known as the La phase and the gel phase is Lb . Extra labels on the latter may refer to packing variations of the tails in the various gel phases. The sponge phase L3 is locally lamellar, but this phase has ‘handles’ in between the bilayers. Hexagonal phases are referred to using the letter H. Again, indices may refer to cases where the head groups are on the outside or are in the inside (inverted hexagonal) of the cylindrical objects. Isotropic phases, i.e. dilute micellar phases, are assigned the letter I. However, in this review, we will not need this nomenclature extensively, as we are mainly interested in La phases. It is important for the theoretical understanding of the formation of various topologies that these aggregates have entropic contributions on the scale of the objects, i.e. on a much larger scale than set by the molecules. These cooperative entropic effects should be included in the overall Helmholtz energy, and they are essential to describe the full phase behaviour. It is believed that the mech and Jo , control the phase behaviour, anical parameters discussed above: kc , k where it is understood that these quantities may, in principle, depend on the overall surfactant (lipid) concentration, i.e. when the membranes are packed to such a density that they strongly interact. 1.8
COMPLEXITY
It is necessary to elaborate on yet another essential aspect of biological membranes, i.e. their ‘complexity’. This keyword points to the large number of different molecules that are usually found in the biological membrane. First of all, there is a large variety of lipid molecules. The lipid composition of the biological membranes varies from one species to another, and is adapted to meet the needs of organs, cells, organelles, etc. The variations in the head–tail
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
31
overall structure are large. There are differences in hydrocarbon chain length, chain branching, number and position of unsaturated bonds, hydrophilic head group size, charge, etc. There may be other lipid components, such as cholesterol, modulating the physical properties of the bilayers. Most of all, there are proteins embedded into the bilayer or associated with it. The complexity of the biological membranes poses huge problems for the molecular modelling of these objects. Without doubt, the complexity is there for good reasons. For example, the many protein molecules facilitate the chemical reactions and transport events. From a physicochemical point of view, we are still far from a full understanding of complexity; why is there such a variety of lipids and additives (other than proteins) in the biological membrane? Trying to understand model systems is a good way to start, followed by gradually increasing the complexity. This is the route that will be followed in this review. Firstly, the focus will be on ‘simple’ membranes composed of just one type of (saturated) lipids. After that we will consider the effect of number and position of unsaturated bonds, lipid mixtures and the effects of additives. When we arrive at this stage, we can also address permeation issues. 1.9
MODELS OF LIPID BILAYERS
From the above, it will be clear that molecular modelling of lipid bilayers is a challenging task. Models are tailored to give insight into many different aspects. Here we will concentrate mainly, but not exclusively, on models that feature lipid molecules, of which both the hydrophilic as well as the hydrophobic parts are taken into account. The models should reproduce self-assembly, and there should be both a relevant driving force for phase separation and a realistic stopping mechanism. The results should be at least qualitatively consistent with the surfactant parameter approach and the fluid mosaic model. Most importantly, the model should go beyond these approaches by including as many of the aforementioned fluctuations as possible. For such a model, there is hope that it may give predictive insight into the membrane structure and performance, e.g. into permeation issues. It will be rather obvious that models that satisfy these requirements will require the use of a computer to do the detailed work of dealing with all the molecules and the forces between them. Apart from this, there is usually a considerable amount of information that needs to go into the formulation of the problem before one can get something useful out. In this review, we will demonstrate that the ‘break-even point’ has been passed convincingly by several but not all modelling approaches in recent years. To elaborate on this, we will discuss both the in- and output of these models. A further issue is the quality of the results. It will not come as a surprise that the quality of the information gain depends nonlinearly on the computation time that one is willing or able to spend on the problem. There are highly
32
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
detailed models in which very subtle information (on a particular aspect) is obtained. There are more pragmatic models in which it is rather easy to scan some part of the parameter space and gain qualitative insight. How these models work and why these models work, what the limitations are, etc., will be discussed next. Basically, there are two types of molecular approaches: molecular simulations and self-consistent-field (SCF) methods. We will discuss these two approaches in order. The molecular simulations will include molecular dynamics (MD), and Monte Carlo (MC) simulation. Moreover, we will briefly discuss the recently developed dissipative particle dynamics (DPD) method. Like SCF, the last technique is not exact, because not all excludedvolume (packing) correlations are properly accounted for, but it may be used to obtain dynamical information on much longer timescales than can be reached by MD. 1.10
ENSEMBLES IN MOLECULAR MODELLING
The molecular modelling of systems consisting of many molecules is the field of statistical mechanics, sometimes called statistical thermodynamics [28,29]. Basically, the idea is to go from a molecular model to partition functions, and then, from these, to predict thermodynamic observables and dynamic and structural quantities. As in classical thermodynamics, in statistical mechanics it is essential to define which state variables are fixed and which quantities are allowed to fluctuate, i.e. it is essential to specify the macroscopic boundary conditions. In the present context, there are a few types of molecular systems of interest, which are linked to so-called ensembles. . the canonical ensemble: (N, V , A, T) systems, where the number of molecules N, the volume V, the area A, and the temperature T, are fixed, and, as a consequence, the internal energy of the system can fluctuate, . the grand canonical ensemble: (m, V , A, T) system, which allows transfer of molecules from a reservoir with fixed chemical potentials to the system and back, but which restricts the spatial dimension in the system, . the constant-pressure/surface-tension ensemble: (N, p, g, T)-systems, where both the volume and the area of the system may vary (in order to keep the pressure and the surface tension constant), but where both the number of molecules and the temperature remain fixed. The relative importance of fluctuations, e.g. in the membrane area, as is possible in a (N, p, g, T ) ensemble, becomes larger when the system that is under investigation is smaller. For macroscopic systems, the fluctuations in such quantities are negligible, but, for some of the modelling techniques that are restricted to small systems, one cannot avoid dealing with it. Of course, for a (N, p, g, T ) ensemble in which both the volume and the surface area are allowed
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
33
to fluctuate, one can compute the time-average of these quantities. Using these averaged quantities subsequently to specify macroscopic boundary conditions in a canonical ensemble, one typically will recover structural characteristics of the system that match those of the (N, p, g, T ) ensemble. The reverse can also be done. One can perform computations in a canonical ensemble, compute, e.g. the pressure or the surface tension, and subsequently adjust the boundary conditions iteratively until these intensive variables assume the ‘equilibrium’ values of e.g. p ¼ 1 atm and g ¼ 0.
2 2.1
THE MOLECULAR DYNAMIC TECHNIQUE THE STRATEGY
The strategy in a molecular dynamics simulation is conceptually fairly simple. The first step is to consider a set of molecules. Then it is necessary to choose initial positions of all atoms, such that they do not physically overlap, and that all bonds between the atoms have a reasonable length. Subsequently, it is necessary to specify the initial velocities of all the atoms. The velocities must preferably be consistent with the temperature in the system. Finally, and most importantly, it is necessary to define the force-field parameters. In effect the force field defines the potential energy of each atom. This value is a complicated sum of many contributions that can be computed when the distances of a given atom to all other atoms in the system are known. In the simulation, the spatial evolution as well as the velocity evolution of all molecules is found by solving the classical Newton equations of mechanics. The basic outcome of the simulation comprises the coordinates and velocities of all atoms as a function of the time. Thus, structural information, such as lipid conformations or membrane thickness, is readily available. Thermodynamic information is more expensive to obtain, but in principle this can be extracted from a long simulation trajectory. For example, the average kinetic and potential energy in the system is easily obtained from the velocities and the pair interactions. The notoriously difficult part is the evaluation of the entropy. To compute the entropy, it is necessary to know the probability that each distinguishable state can occur in the system. The ‘book-keeping’ to find this probability distribution is not feasible – even more so because in a typical MD run only a part of the possible and allowed configurations of the system is sampled. All known alternatives to compute the entropy are also computationally expensive. Correspondingly, it is very hard to compute, the Helmholtz energy, for example. Fortunately, it is straightforward to obtain differences between Helmholtz energies, upon small changes in the system. Therefore, it is not too difficult to calculate the pressure (tensor) and/or the surface tension, for example. For details we refer to the literature [30].
34
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
The strong point of molecular dynamic simulations is that, for the particular model, the results are (nearly) exact. In particular, the simulations take all necessary excluded-volume correlations into account. However, still it is not advisable to have blind confidence in the predictions of MD. The simulations typically treat the system classically, many parameters that together define the force field are subject to fine-tuning, and one always should be cautious about the statistical certainty. In passing, we will touch upon some more limitations when we discuss more details of MD simulation of lipid systems. We will not go into all the details here, because the use of MD simulation to study the lipid bilayer has recently been reviewed by other authors already [31,32]. Our idea is to present sufficient information to allow a critical evaluation of the method, and to set the stage for comparison with alternative approaches. 2.2
THE BOX
There are several commercial packages that realise the above strategy for molecularly realistic systems. It is useful to discuss some of the limitations. Ideally, one would like to do simulations on macroscopic systems. However, it is impossible to use a computer to deal with numbers of degrees of freedom on the order of Nav . In lipid systems, where the computations of all the interactions in the system are expensive, a typical system can contain of the order of tens of thousands of particles. Recently, massive systems with up to a million particles have been considered [33]. Even for these large simulations, this still means that the system size is limited to the order of 10 nm. Because of this small size, one refers to this volume as a box, although the system boundaries are typically not box-like. Usually the box has periodic boundary conditions. This implies that molecules that move out of the box on one side will enter the box on the opposite side. In such a way, finite size effects are minimised. In sophisticated simulations, i.e. (N, p, g, T)-ensembles, there are rules defined which allow the box size and shape to vary in such a way that the intensive parameters (p, g) can assume a preset value. The finite size of the box has several important consequences. One of them is that the area of the membrane piece is only of the order of 100 nm2 . It is expected that the membrane is, on this length scale, roughly flat, i.e. the area is small as compared with the persistence length x for the bilayer. Interestingly, however, in recent simulations the first signs of fluctuations away from the flat bilayer structure (undulations) have reportedly been found by MD simulations [33]. The periodic boundary conditions applied in the system have the consequence that one bilayer leaflet can interact in the normal direction with the other leaflet, not only through the contact region in the core of the bilayer, but also through the water phase. To minimise artifacts, one should systematically increase the size of the water phase. However, this is expensive, especially if the main interest is in the behaviour of the lipids. Another solution is to cut off the
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
35
permitted range of interactions, to be smaller than the typical box-size. But then salient features in, for example, spatially varying water densities or water orientation in the normal direction, may remain undetected and have an effect in the simulations. These effects can influence, e.g. the pressure measurements. Physically, it means that a simulation focuses not on isolated membranes but on a stack of membranes as in, for example, a lamellar phase, where the membranes interact with each other. 2.3
THE MOLECULES
Many MD packages contain some basic organic chemistry to accurately define the molecule structure including the positions of H-atoms. For an illustration of the level of detail of how lipids can be represented, we will refer to Figure 3. Many packages can also make use of crystallographic data, such that one can position the molecules to relative coordinates given by the unitcell data characteristics. Then it is rather trivial to build a bilayer of lipid molecules that can serve as a reasonable initial guess configuration for the simulation run. An example is given in Figure 4. The bilayer is positioned in, for example, a pre-equilibrated water phase, by removing the water molecules at the positions of the lipid molecules. Finally, one should introduce ions in the system. These ions are necessary to screen the electrostatic interactions. As very accurate input data are needed for a successful MD run on lipid systems, it is not surprising that most of the simulations done are for a very limited number of systems for which these are available. Phosphatidylcholine (PC) bilayers have been and still are popular [31,33–41], but, nowadays, other types of lipid bilayers are under investigation as well [42–46]. MD studies on lipid mixtures, as well as a lipid bilayer including some protein-like object, give all kinds of additional problems that we will touch upon below. 2.4
THE FORCE FIELD
The full description of the interactions in the system that are included in the simulations is called the force field. A typical potential function of the system features extremely simplified forms (for example, harmonic terms) for the various contributions: ! 2 X1 X Aij Bij X qi qj b 0 k þ þ r b V¼ ij ij 2 ij 4p"0 rij r12 r6ij ij i<j i<j bonds 2 h io X1 X f n þ kijkl 1 þ cos n fijkl f0ijkl kyijk yijk y0ijk þ 2 angles dihedrals
(6)
36
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
Figure 3 (Plate 2). Representation of molecular structure in MD simulations. Shown here is the SOPC lipid, discussed in the text. The numbers at each atom indicate the partial charge on the atom. The space-filling picture on the left gives insight into the van der Waals radii of the various groups, and thus into the shape of the molecule. Reproduced from (58) with permission from the Biophysical Society
Here the atoms in the system are numbered by i, j, k, l ¼ 1, . . . , N. The distance between two atoms i, j is rij , q is the (partial) charge on an atom, y is the angle defined by the coordinates (i, j, k) of three consecutive atoms, and f is the dihedral angle defined by the positions of four consecutive atoms, "o is the dielectric permittivity of vacuum, n is the dihedral multiplicity. The potential function, as given in equation (6), has many parameters that depend on the atoms involved. The first term accounts for Coulombic interactions. The second term is the Lennard–Jones interaction energy. It is composed of a strongly repulsive term and a van der Waals-like attractive term. The form of the repulsive term is chosen ad hoc and has the function of defining the size of the atom. The Aij coefficients are a function of the van der Waals radii of the
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
37
Figure 4 (Plate 3). Typical snapshot of a start configuration in MD simulation. Figure 1 (Plate 1) resulted from the equilibration of this initial guess. From [102]. Reproduced by permission of the American Institute of Physics. Copyright (2003)
two atoms si , sj and interaction energy "ij between the two atoms. The Bij coefficient is also a function of the two radii and the interaction energy "ij . The third term in equation (6) deals with stretching of bonds. The spring constant kbij is only nonzero when i and j share a bond and boij is the equilibrium bond length. The fourth term accounts for the energy penalty of bending of a bond away from the preferred angle yoijk . For small differences, again a harmonic assumption is taken and the constant kyijk is the force constant for the angle deformation, and is only nonzero when i, j and k are consecutive atoms in the molecule along a chain. The final term accounts in a similar way for the rotation around bonds, and depends on four consecutive atoms. We note that modern force fields and simulation packages may use extra and/or more complicated forms of the potential V. The first and second terms in equation (6) are rather expensive in terms of computer power needed. They include the interaction of all atoms with all other
38
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
atoms. This becomes a problem for large systems. As the interaction energy decreases with the distance between the atoms, it is reasonable to cut them off at some distance. The decay of the van der Waals term of the Lennard–Jones contribution is fast, and the cut-off distance is set to a few times the size, s, of the atoms involved. The electrostatic contribution decays very slowly (1/r), and in the literature there are a number of suggestions to deal with this contribution accurately and economically. One of the problems is that the box size can be small as compared with the decay length. Then the Ewald method [30] can be used to sum the contributions of neighbouring boxes. At present, this methodology is still under development for the modelling of charged membranes. In the integration scheme, not only the potential energy in the system, but also the potential energy felt by a particular atom, is needed. This value is trivially found, similar to an equation as given by equation (6) by selecting only those terms in which atom i occurs. It is instructive to see that the kinetic energy does not occur in equation (6), and that equation (6) only depends on the coordinates of the atoms which are unambiguously known at a given moment in time. The Newton equation F ¼ ma is conveniently cast in the form:
qV q2 ri ¼ mi 2 qt qri
(7)
and of course there is one such equation for each atom i. The number of parameters that occur in equations (6) and (7) is huge, and it should be noted that there is a whole industry in finding acceptable values for a balanced force field. Ideally, one would like to have one correct parameter set which can be used to solve all problems, and one would like to have a theoretical justification for these values, e.g. from quantum mechanics, or unambiguous justification of the parameters from spectroscopic data. However, in practice the situation is not so. Many of the parameters are chosen quite empirically, and if they can be obtained from spectroscopic data or from ab initio quantum mechanics, this still may not guarantee good results in a potential form that contains simplified (harmonic) contributions. Therefore, there is a large number of force fields available. One force field tends to perform better for intermolecular interactions. The other one is tuned to represent intramolecular forces accurately. Therefore the optimum force field may depend on the type of problem at hand. An example of a force field used in lipid systems is the ‘optimised parameters for liquid systems’ (OPLS) [47,48]. In such force fields, polarisable atoms are usually given partial charges (cf. in equation (6) or Figure 3). These partial charges may be found from quantum mechanical analysis, and obviously these values differ per force field. Of course the water molecules should be treated with more than average care. Several water models exist and have been applied to lipid systems [49]. There are, for example, a single point charge model (SPC) [50], an extended single point charge model (SPC/E),
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
39
and a TIP water model, of which the first one is popular because of economic reasons. See, for example, [51] for a critical evaluation of parameters for the modelling of alkanes. It is not unimportant to realise that there are several possible ways to implement the Newton equation in an MD simulation. It is not trivial to make sure that all degrees of freedom, e.g. very fast C–H vibrations, or much slower conformational changes, have their proper share of the internal energy. One MD-‘dialect’ may be superior to the other in, e.g. distributing the energy in such a way that the temperature is constant. It would take too long to discuss all the options, so we will only mention that well-known packages such as GROMOS [52], CHARMM [53] and AMBER [54] are widely available. New developments are still being made, such as the collisional dynamics method [55]. In this method, the atoms experience collisions with ghost particles. These collisions are an efficient way to distribute the energy in the system, and the method has the property that all degrees of freedom are at the same temperature. 2.5
TIME AND LENGTH SCALES
To integrate the equations of motion in a stable and reliable way, it is necessary that the fundamental time step is shorter than the shortest relevant timescale in the problem. The shortest events involving whole atoms are C–H vibrations, and therefore a typical value of the time step is 2 fs (1015 s). This means that there are up to one million time steps necessary to reach (real-time) simulation times in the nanosecond range. The ns range is sufficient for conformational transitions of the lipid molecules. It is also sufficient to allow some lateral diffusion of molecules in the box. As an iteration time step is rather expensive, even a supercomputer will need of the order of 106 s (a week) of CPU time to reach the ns domain. Of course there are many phenomena that equilibrate on the nanosecond timescale. However, the majority of relevant events take much more time. For example, the ns timescale is much too short to allow for the self-assembly of a set of lipids from a homogeneously distributed state to a lamellar topology. This is the reason why it is necessary to start a simulation as close as possible to the expected equilibrated state. Of course, this is a tricky practice and should be considered as one of the inherent problems of MD. Only recently, this issue was addressed by Marrink [56]. Here the homogeneous state of the lipids was used as the start configuration, and at the end of the simulation an intact bilayer was found. Permeation, transport across a bilayer, and partitioning of molecules from the water to the membrane phase typically take also more time than can be dealt with by MD. We will return to this point below. A typical MD simulation usually consists of two parts. The first part is an equilibration time (ca. 1 ns) starting with a reasonably accurate initial configuration (see, for example, Figure 4), which is followed by a production run.
40
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
Considering the relatively short equilibration phase, one should always be alert for possible artifacts that originate from the choice of the initial configuration of the system. In particular, if for equilibration, a considerable adjustment of the area of the membrane is necessary, it may take a very long time before this is completed. An example where this is an issue, is the level of interdigitation of the lipid tails. If the simulations are started in a fully noninterdigitated state, significant chain interdigitations may never be found – not even in the production phase. There can also be hindered equilibration effects that have their origin in finite box size effects. For example, if the number of lipids on each side of the bilayer is taken to be of order 30 to 100, which is reasonable, a fluctuation in this number is not expected to occur in the simulation, because this would be too large an overall perturbation. Cooperative movements of many molecules at the same time, which occasionally may be necessary before equilibration is a fact, may also be very slow. 2.6
DIPALMITOYLPHOSPHATIDYLCHOLINE BILAYERS
From the above, one may be left with the impression that the MD technique has major problems. It is important to realise that there are relatively straightforward ways to systematically improve the method. In the future, the force fields will become more accurate, the computer power will increase and allow larger box sizes and longer (real-time) simulation times. Even today, MD simulations are the closest to this ‘ideal’ situation as compared with other methods. To show this, we will present and discuss some typical results readily available in the literature. Here we will select systems simulated in the constantpressure constant-surface-tension ensemble, i.e. with a temperature, pressure and surface tension control. MD simulations need a sufficiently accurate initial guess for the bilayer structure in order to find relaxation of the structure in the nanosecond range. X-ray diffraction techniques can be used to determine the electron density profile across the bilayer to high precision, and, from these, the required input data can be extracted. However, typically for X-ray diffraction experiments it is necessary to have oriented bilayers, and therefore most results are available for systems with very little water between them. These results are of interest for lipid membranes that strongly interact. Indeed, fully hydrated bilayers are expected to have a slightly different structure. In 1996, Nagle et al. [38] reported the (X-ray) structure of a highly hydrated DPPC bilayer. One problem is that in the fully hydrated state the bilayers do not remain perfectly flat. The shape of the bilayer may be sinusoidally deformed, i.e. it can undulate up and down, and therefore the intrinsic membrane structure is blurred and an ‘averaged’ one is found. Nagle took these undulations into account, and, as a result, there are accurate numbers for the structural parameters of DPPC layers. For example, the area per lipid molecule is a0 ¼ 0:629 0:013 nm2 .
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
41
The number of water molecules per lipid molecule is 29.1 when the equilibrium (centre to centre) distance (swelling limit) between bilayers is 6.72 nm. These data serve also as an accurate test for MD methodology (including the force field). Rand and Parsegian have collected accurate structural parameters for many other lipid systems [57]. From this perspective it is not surprising that most simulations are done on DPPC bilayers, albeit that, from a biological perspective, other lipids, e.g. partially unsaturated lipids, are perhaps more relevant. DPPC bilayers have been extensively reviewed in the literature [31,36], and therefore we will visit this system only briefly. The MD simulation results that easily attract attention are snapshots. From these, it is easy to tell how the molecules are distributed in the box at a particular point of time in the simulation. See Figure 1 for a typical example. These snapshots are important to obtain a good idea of how order parameters and density profiles follow from the positions of the atoms. However, these structural parameters can only reliably be found after sufficient averaging over a large number of such snapshots. Of course, one can find many MD results in the literature, and it is always arbitrary to pick one of those. We choose to present some good results from a simulation by Berger and co-workers [58]. They paid attention to particular values of the force-field parameters, such that the lipid densities were in accordance with experimental observations, and therefore we should interpret the result depicted for the atom distribution profiles as given in Figure 5 to be rather accurate. In Figure 5, the overall water profile, the overall lipid distribution, as well as that of the CH2 , CH3 groups and several head-group fragments, are plotted. It is of interest to discuss some highlights, because we will return to these when discussing corresponding distributions that result from more approximate modelling attempts. The water profile penetrates into the bilayer just up to the glycerol units. Thus, in MD, one does not find any water molecules in the hydrophobic core. The atom density of the lipid shows a dip in the core. The shape of the dip correlates with the distribution of the CH3 groups. These groups have a large volume per atom. As a result of the dip, the profiles suggest that the two monolayers do not overlap greatly (the tails do not interdigitate much). If this were the case, one would expect a bimodal distribution for the CH3 groups. However, there are plenty of chains that cross the symmetry plane and the CH3 is nicely unimodal. The distributions of the head-group fragments are depicted only on the righthand side of Figure 5. Obviously the CO groups that originate from the glycerol backbone are between the PC head group and the hydrocarbon chains. Interestingly, the average position of the P and that of the N are at approximately the same z-coordinate. This means that the average P–N vector is almost parallel to the membrane surface. Close inspection shows that the N profile is significantly wider than that of the phosphate. This reflects the higher mobility
42
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 50 Lipid
r
no. of atoms/V
40 CH2
30 Water
20
PO4
N(CH3)3
10 0
CH3
0
1
2
CO
3 z / nm
4
5
6
Figure 5. Profiles across the bilayer of the total lipid density of DPPC, the water density and the densities of certain lipid groups as obtained from MD simulations by Berger et al. [58]. The profiles are found by taking the time average over the last 300 ps of the simulation. The densities for the lipid head-group components are only shown on one side for clarity. The origin of the z-axis is arbitrarily positioned on the left of the bilayer. On the y-axis, the atom density in atoms per nm3 is given. Redrawn from [58] by permission of the Biophysical Society
of this group, which is expected because it is positioned at the end of the head group. There is a tendency for the distribution of the N group to be bimodal, something which will be discussed below. From these overall profiles, it is not easy to extract conformational properties, other than that it will be clear that the lipid molecules are strongly anisotropically oriented in the bilayer. For this, other characteristics are much more appropriate. It is possible to define an order parameter which indicates how much the lipid tails are oriented normal to the membrane: 1 S ¼ h3 cos2 W 1i 2
(8)
Here the angular brackets mean that the ensemble average is taken, and the angle W can be defined and computed for each bond in the molecule. When a bond is perfectly aligned normal to the bilayer surface, the order parameter assumes a value of unity. In a random orientation, the order parameter is zero. Bonds that are perfectly aligned parallel to the surface gives a negative order parameter of S ¼ 0:5. Such order parameters can also be obtained from deuterium NMR measurements, and therefore one frequently finds predictions for these order parameters in the literature. The order parameter profile that belongs to the tails of the lipid membrane as given in Figure 5 is shown in Figure 6. There is a consensus in the literature about the typical patterns found in the order parameter profile along the chain in the phospholipid bilayer. The order
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
43
0.2 S
0.1
0
0
2
4
6 8 10 12 Carbon atom number
14
16
Figure 6. Variation of the orientational order parameter S along the hydrocarbon chains of the lipids of DMPC lipid bilayers, according to MD simulations of Berger et al. [58]. The line is drawn to guide the eye. The spheres are experimental values obtained by Seelig and Seelig [59] using 2 H-NMR spectroscopy. (Numbering of C-atoms from the head group to the CH3 terminal group). Redrawn from [58] by permission of the Biophysical Society
is relatively high for hydrocarbon chain segments near the glycerol backbone, and slowly decreases toward the ends of the tails, which are more randomly oriented. The absolute value of the order parameter profile is also correct, as can be seen by the satisfactory comparison with data from Seelig and Seeling [59]. It is important to note that the absolute value of the order parameter is of course strongly dependent on the value of the area per lipid in the membrane. In these simulations, the area found is sufficiently close to the experimental data, i.e. a0 ¼ 61 nm2 . Although not an easy task, it is possible to compute, for example, the electrostatic potential profile across the bilayer. In Figure 7, we give an example for DPPC, as reported by Tieleman and Berendsen [49]. In MD many atoms and molecules contribute to the electrostatic potential, because of the partial charges assigned to them. From such an exercise, it turns out that the electrostatic potential assumes very large values of several hundred mV. This is in line with experimental data, where it has been found that the magnitude of the dipole potential of biomembranes is typically several hundreds of millivolts [60] – the hydrocarbon core being positive with respect to the aqueous phases. The surface potential of most biomembranes is of the order of tens of millivolts. As seen in Figure 7, simulations also indicate that the electrostatic potential in the membrane is positive with respect to the aqueous phase. The region 1 < z < 1 is the hydrophobic core of the bilayer, where the effective dielectric permittivity is low (and thus potentials are high). In the aqueous parts of the system, the potential drops rapidly to very low values. This is because the presence of the water molecules, which can orient to compensate for the high potentials (i.e. they have a high dielectric permittivity).
44
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 0.8
y/ V
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
−3
−2
−1
0 z / nm
1
2
3
Figure 7. The total electrostatic potential profile across the DPPC bilayer as given by Tieleman and Berendson [49]. Redrawn by permission of the American Institute of Physics
Tu et al. [61] analysed the dynamics of water molecules in the vicinity of the bilayer. Water molecules remain bound to the phosphate and carbonyl groups on a 10 ps timescale. The lipid molecules change their conformations more slowly. Only at the hydrocarbon chain ends are there some isomerisation events on the 10 ps timescale. Then, over the period of 100 ps, water molecules can diffuse away from the lipid. Also the centre of mass of the hydrocarbon chains rattles vertically and laterally. On the nanosecond timescale the lipid molecules experience rotational and translational motion (rattling in a cage, no large-scale movement across the box), and the head group can undergo major conformational changes. We need to go to much longer times to see partitioning and transport across the bilayer. It is therefore not possible to use MD to model all relevant processes for transport and permeation. We will return to this in Section 5. 2.7
COARSE-GRAINED MD
Even when the computer ‘power’ will increase significantly, it is not easy to greatly exceed the 10 ns timescales in MD simulations. This is a problem, because many relevant membrane problems in which major lipid rearrangements are necessary have much longer characteristic times. One way of proceeding is to be pragmatic and simplify the models that one is willing to work on. Indeed, in an all-atom MD simulation, most of the simulation time is used to accurately follow the C–H vibrations. This is no longer needed if united atoms are used where a CH2 - or a CH3 group (or in fact several of these groups) are merged together in effective (spherical) units, sometimes called segments. As a result, it is possible to use larger time-steps in the integration of the Newton equations. Of course, for such artificial units, new force-field parameters are
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
45
necessary. The values of the effective interactions between the segments must be chosen such that the physical behaviour on the length scales of the segments is similar to that of the more detailed simulations. The process of ‘integrating’ out the short time-scale events is known as coarse graining. An interesting simulation on coarse-grained lipids is reported by Lipowsky and co-workers [62]. These authors used surfactants that are composed of just a few beads and simplified potentials, similarly to those used in surfactant studies performed by Smit and co-workers [63]. One of the results that was reported is an estimate of the stretching modulus of a model bilayer. We will discuss this point below, where similar properties are reported to have been obtained by the SCF theory. One aspect of MD simulations is that all molecules, including the solvent, are specified in full detail. As detailed above, much of the CPU time in such a simulation is used up by following all the solvent (water) molecules. An alternative to the MD simulations is Brownian dynamics (BD) simulation. In this method, the solvent molecules are removed from the simulations. The effects of the solvent molecules are then reintroduced into the problem in an approximate way. Firstly, of course, the interaction parameters are adjusted, because the interactions should now include the effect of the solvent molecules. Furthermore, it is necessary to include a fluctuating force acting on the beads (atoms). These fluctuations represent the stochastic forces that result from the collisions of solvent molecules with the atoms. We know of no results using this technique on lipid bilayers. Coming from the field of rheology, there is yet another interesting technique to model complex fluids. This technique is called dissipative particle dynamics (DPD) and has recently been applied to (model) lipid bilayers. The fundamental trick here is that the lipids are represented by a set of soft beads, with either hydrophilic or hydrophobic properties that are linked according to the lipid architecture. For soft beads (particles), the appropriate interaction potentials differ fundamentally from the usual Lennard–Jones ones. In DPD, the interaction curve between beads does not have the usual ‘hard-core’ part, and it also lacks an attractive well at small separation. Instead, a weak repulsion, linear with respect to the centre-to-centre distance, is implemented. This potential then allows the molecules to interpenetrate each other to some extent. The weakness of the potential has the big advantage that long time steps can be used in the simulation. This then opens up the possibility of covering significantly longer evolution times than MD. In principle, one should map the DPD potentials to the force fields in atomistically realistic MD simulations. How accurately this can be done is not yet known exactly. A strong point of DPD simulations is that the simulations conform to Navier–Stokes hydrodynamics. Qualitatively, the bilayer structures that result from DPD simulations are reasonable [65]. In the simulation box, it is possible to find a stable bilayer in which the head groups shield the apolar core from the water phase. This means that the model effectively features a start-and-stop mechanism for
46
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
Figure 8 (Plate 4). Typical snapshot of DPD simulation results [64]. The hydrophobic part of mixed bilayers of DPPC-like lipids and up to 0.8 mole-fraction of the non-ionic surfactant C12 E6 (left) and 0.9 (right). The surfactant C12 chains are represented by grey curves, and the lipid C15 chains are black. The hole in the left conformation is transient; on the right they are stable. Reproduced by permission of the Biophysical Society
self-assembly. A recent simulation of a mixture of lipids and surfactants clearly proves that the DPD method has additional value [64]. When a bilayer of such a mixture was kept under a finite lateral tension, it was possible to visualise and analyse the formation of pores or holes. A graphical representation is given in Figure 8. It is clear that bilayers that lose their integrity also lose their biological functions. These holes were attributed to the presence of the surfactants, and were therefore interpreted to be relevant for the toxic effect of surfactants for bacteria. Of course the possibility that there are transient holes or water channels is relevant for transport and permeation. Such spontaneous fluctuations may determine to some extent the permeability of the bilayer for hydrophilic compounds. We will return to these phenomena below.
3 3.1
THE MONTE CARLO TECHNIQUE THE STRATEGY
In many simulations that use a time trajectory to sample membrane properties, it is the equilibrium situation that one is interested in, rather than the dynamics themselves. The dynamics are then just a by-product that is only used to judge the degree of equilibration.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
47
When dynamic properties are not one’s main interest, one can consider alternatives to obtain solutions for the equilibrium properties of complex molecular systems. As equilibrium fluctuations can be used to estimate the response of a system when it is slightly off equilibrium (Onsager reciprocal relation [66]), it is still of interest to discuss these alternatives in this review. In the MD simulation, the system can only evolve towards equilibrium by a dynamic path (trajectory), through all kind of possible states of the system (phase space). In a Monte Carlo (MC) simulation technique, the trajectory is typically nonphysical. For example, it is possible to suggest and implement conformational changes, or large changes in system properties, from one MC step to the other. There is no limitation at all on the type of changes that can be made in the system before an evaluation of the system’s energy takes place. In order to prevent ad hoc changes in the system from leading to a random mixing of all molecules (this is often the maximum in the entropy of the system), there is a simple rule which can tell whether or not the changes are accepted or rejected. If the potential energy V in the system is decreased, the suggested move is favourable, and the changes are accepted. If, however, the potential energy V increases, which is unfavourable for the system, the move is either rejected or accepted. This is how the choice is made: (1) Let the potential energy increase be DV > 0, then the Boltzmann factor P ¼ exp ( DV =kT) is a number smaller than unity. (2) Next a random number is generated between 0 and 1. (3) If this number is smaller than P, the move is accepted (and implemented). If it is larger than P, then the suggested changes in the system are rejected, and the old state is counted once more (for taking appropriate averages). This strategy, known as the Metropolis scheme, guarantees that the MC trajectory evolves towards equilibrium [30]. Drawing of the random numbers guarantees, for example, that the system can escape from a local minimum, i.e. that it can sample all relevant system configurations. 3.2
THE BOX AND THE MOLECULES
One can apply the MC technique to the same molecular model, as explored in MD. One can use the same box and the same molecules that experience exactly the same potentials, and therefore the results are equally exact for equilibrium membranes. However, MC examples of this type are very rare. One of the reasons for this is that there is no commercial package available in which an MC strategy is combined with sufficient chemistry know-how and tuned force fields. Unlike the MD approach, where the phase-space trajectory is fixed by the equations of motion of the molecules, the optimal walkthrough phase space in an MC run may depend strongly on the system characteristics. In particular, for densely packed layers, it may be very inefficient to withdraw a molecule randomly and to let it reappear somewhere else in
48
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
the system. Excluded-volume constraints will almost certainly reject the move. Snake-like movements (reptation) would be more efficient, as would small conformational changes within a molecule (typical moves that are done in a MD simulation). Also, the water phase poses huge problems for MC simulations. We recall that the interactions between the water molecules (H-bonds) are very strong, and that each water molecule has, on average, four of these ‘contacts’. It is necessary to invent ingenious MC moves in order to prevent a significant reduction of H-bonds in the water network upon a series of random changes in the positional and orientational distribution of the water molecules. Again, the acceptance probability for such system changes is expected to be small. It is the ingenuity of the researcher to implement efficient trajectories through phase space that can make the difference between failure and success. The lack of guidance as how to design the MC trajectories also explains the lack of commercial MC packages. 3.3
PRAGMATIC APPROXIMATIONS
As the dynamics of the system are removed from the model, it is no longer necessary to allow the molecules to ‘live’ in a continuous space. Instead, the use of lattices – discrete sets of coordinates on to which the molecules are restricted – is popular. Digital computers are of course much more efficient with discrete space than with continuum space. The use of a lattice implies that one removes all properties that occur on shorter length scales than the lattice spacing from the model. This is no problem if the main interest is in phenomena that are larger than this length scale. With the Monte Carlo technique, a very large number of membrane problems have been worked on. We have insufficient space to review all the data available. However, the formation of pores is of relevance for permeation. The formation of perforations in a polymeric bilayer has been studied by Mu¨ller by using Monte Carlo simulation [67] within the bond fluctuation model. In this particular MC technique, ‘realistic’ moves are incorporated, such that the number of MC steps can be linked to a simulated time. 3.4
HYBRID MC AND MD APPROACHES
In principle, MC algorithms can be tuned for particular systems and can thus be more efficient than MD for obtaining equilibrium distributions. An interesting idea is to use MC simulations to obtain accurate initial guesses for subsequent MD simulations. Already as early as 1993, Venable and co-workers [68] used a scheme for efficiently sampling configurations of individual lipids in a mean field. These configurations were then used to develop the initial conditions for the molecular dynamic simulations.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
3.5
49
TYPICAL MONTE CARLO RESULTS
Monte Carlo may be used to study the lateral distribution of lipid molecules in mixed bilayers. This of course is a very challenging problem, and, to date, the only way to obtain relevant information for this is to reduce the problem to a very simplistic two-dimensional lattice model. In this case, the lipid molecules occupy a given site and can be in one of the predefined number of different states. These pre-assigned states (usually about 10 are taken), are representative conformations of lipids in the gel or in the liquid state. Each state interacts in its own way with the neighbouring molecules (sitting on neighbouring sites). Typically, one is interested in the lateral phase behaviour near the gel-to-liquid phase transition of the bilayer [69,70]. For some recent simulations of mixtures of DMPC and DSPC, see the work of Sugar [71]. Levine and co-workers [72,73] have considered an ensemble of chains end-grafted on a plane and the space is represented by an ingenious (highcoordination lattice suitable for representing saturated as well as unsaturated acyl chains. In the MC simulation, only moves that could realistically take place, i.e. small conformational changes, etc., are incorporated, and, for this reason, one can optimistically connect the MC trajectory with a time-axis. Although this is not completely unrealistic, there always is some ambiguity in how this mapping is done. A number of very interesting predictions that compare favourably to that of MD simulations as well as experimental observations, were drawn. For example, the average order of the chains as a function of the distance away from the grafting plane can be computed. In Figure 9, a typical example is shown for unsaturated alkyl chains. A pronounced dip in the order profile at 0.3 S 0.2
0.1
0
0
3
6
9 t
12
15
18
Figure 9. A comparison of the order parameter profile as found by MC simulations [72] of model 9/10 cis unsaturated chains in a monolayer (the x-line is to guide the eye) with experimental data obtained from NMR experiments () on the same chains incorporated into a biological membrane. Redrawn from [72] by permission of the American Institute of Physics
50
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 0.8
0.6
S 0.4 N = 10 13
0.2
15
0
6
9
15
12
19
18
t
Figure 10. Calculated order parameters of the CH2 groups of isolated molecules of linear alkanes with chain length N as indicated, starting from the centre of the molecule towards its end. The ranking number along the chain is indicated by the letter t. MC simulations by Rabinovich and co-workers [74–76]. Copyright (1997) by Elsevier
the position of the double bond is a very characteristic feature. This dip shows that the double bond significantly disturbs the local order in the bilayer. Not all MC simulations are done on a lattice. We would like to mention a particularly interesting study by Rabinovich and Ripatti [74–76], who analysed the conformational states of a short acyl chain with and without unsaturated bonds (see Figure 10) The idea of the simulations is to consider isolated chains with realistic short-range potentials. As the chains are not much longer than their persistence length, they cannot return to themselves. For this reason, there is no need to specify interaction potentials other than those that exist for two neighbouring segments (vibrations), three segments in a row (bending), and those found for four consecutive segments (rotation). The usual Lennard–Jones parameters for the nonbonded interactions are not needed. Many conformations were sampled by the usual MC procedure. The result is of course that there is no preferred orientation of the molecule. Each conformation can, however, be characterised by an instantaneous main axis; this is the average direction of the chain. Then this axis is defined as a ‘director’. This director is used to subsequently determine the orientational order parameter along the chain. The order is obviously low at the chain ends, and relatively high in the middle of the chain. It was found that the order profile going from the centre of the molecules towards the tails fell off very similarly to corresponding chains (with half the chain length) in the bilayer membrane. As an example, we reproduce here the results for saturated acyl chains, in Figure 10. The conclusion is that the order of the chains found for acyl tails in the bilayer is dominated by intramolecular interactions. The intermolecular interactions due to the presence of other chains that are densely packed around such a chain,
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
51
determine the orientation of the molecule to be roughly perpendicular to the membrane surface. The level of alignment is high when the area per molecule is low, and vice versa.
4
THE SELF-CONSISTENT-FIELD TECHNIQUE
The previous result is an important one. It indicates that there can be yet another fruitful route to describe lipid bilayers. The idea is to consider the conformational properties of a ‘probe’ molecule, and then replace all the other molecules by an external potential field (see Figure 11). This external potential may be called the mean-field or self-consistent potential, as it represents the mean behaviour of all molecules self-consistently. There are mean-field theories in many branches of science, for example (quantum) physics, physical chemistry, etc. Very often mean-field theories simplify the system to such an extent that structural as well as thermodynamic properties can be found analytically. This means that there is no need to use a computer. However, the lipid membrane problem is so complicated that the help of the computer is still needed. The method has been refined over the years to a detailed and complex framework, whose results correspond closely with those of MD simulations. The computer time needed for these calculations is however an order of 105 times less (this estimate is certainly too small when SCF calculations are compared with massive MD simulations in which up to 1000 lipids are considered). Indeed, the calculations can be done on a desktop PC with typical
z U(z) for head groups MEAN-FIELD 0 APPROXIMATION
u(z) U(z) for tail segments
Figure 11. A schematic representation of the mean-field approximation, a central issue in the self-consistent-field theory. The arrows symbolically represent the lipid molecules. The head of the arrow is the hydrophilic part and the line is the hydrophobic tail. On the left a two-dimensional representation of a disordered bilayer is given. One of the lipids has been selected, as shown by the box around it. The same molecule is depicted on the right. The bilayer is depicted schematically by two horizontal lines. The centre of the bilayer is at z ¼ 0. These lines are to guide the eye; the membrane thickness is not preassumed, but is the result of the calculations. Both the potential energy felt by the head groups and that of the tail segments are indicated. We note that in the detailed models the self-consistent potential profiles are of course much more detailed than shown in this graph
52
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
CPU times of 100 s or less. The method can additionally provide insight into the mesoscopic behaviour of the bilayer systems, and can deal with polymeric additives. Dynamic information is not directly available, although there are several attempts to reintroduce dynamics in a mean-field framework [77,78]. More so than in ‘exact’ simulations, it is necessary to give details of SCF methods. This is to give an insight into how and when approximations are introduced. Only then it is possible to build a realistic picture of the approach, understand its limitations in terms of conformational detail and loss of information about dynamics, and to interpret the results. 4.1
THE STRATEGY
A central issue in statistical thermodynamic modelling is to solve the best model possible for a system with many interacting molecules. If it is essential to include all excluded-volume correlations, i.e. to account for all the possible ways that the molecules in the system instantaneously interact with each other, it is necessary to do computer simulations as discussed above, because there are no exact (analytical) solutions to the many-body problems. The only analytical models that can be solved are of the mean-field type. The most essential step in a mean-field theory is the reduction of the manybody problem to a scheme that treats just a small number of molecules in an external field. The external field is chosen such that it mimics the effect of the other molecules in the system as accurately as possible. In this review we will discuss the Bragg–Williams approach. Here the problem is reduced to behaviour of a single chain (molecule) in an external field. Higher order models (e.g. Quasi-chemical or Bethe approximations) are possible but we do not know applications of this for bilayer membranes. Needless to say, a simplified model leads to corresponding thermodynamic quantities, i.e. not all correlations are included. However, the thermodynamic framework itself is fully internally consistent. This is an important observation, because such a model can for this reason be of use to establish the thermodynamic feasibility of ‘what-if ?’ questions. Full control over the absolute deviations from the true thermodynamic behaviour is unfortunately not possible. The approach ignores important (cooperative) fluctuations, and it is expected that especially near phase transitions the approach may give only qualitative results. In particular, comparison of SCF results with experiments or with simulation data can lead to insights into how rigorous the method is. It is of interest to mention that, once particular choices are made concerning how the mean-field interactions are incorporated into the model, the corresponding partition function and thermodynamics follow in a straightforward manner. In particular, there exists a method based upon a variational argument, to formulate the best possible corresponding (mean-field) potential fields. We will not go into these details here, but refer to the variational method, as
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
53
explained in standard textbooks [79]. Typically, the optimal potential fields become a function of the average properties of all test molecules in the system (one for each united-atom type). On the other hand, the average properties of a test molecule depend on the actual values of the potentials. This interconnection of dependencies is solved numerically by some iterative process. As soon as the potentials and the densities are mutually consistent, one can evaluate the partition function, and all thermodynamic and structural characteristics are extracted from it. Such a fixed point is called, for obvious reasons, the selfconsistent-field solution, and the models that make use of this strategy are self-consistent-field models. SCF models typically make use of lattice approximations. As dynamics are not an issue, it is not necessary to specify all the potentials in equal detail. Therefore there are many differences between the SCF and simulation methods. Comparing and contrasting both methods remains of interest, because this will give insight into essential and less essential aspects of membrane formation. 4.2
THE BOX
It is important to realise that the SCF technique differs significantly from the simulation methods, due to the above-mentioned averaging procedure and the use of (average) density-dependent, self-consistent external potentials. This averaging should be done over a large number of molecules, or equivalently, over a sufficiently large region. An averaging procedure is only expected to work if the property over which averaging is done does not fluctuate strongly. Therefore, it makes sense to average in planes parallel to the membrane surface, and account for density-and potential gradients perpendicular to this, i.e. in the z-direction. In this section we will restrict ourselves to this approach. In effect, it is assumed that the system is translationally invariant in the x–y directions. As a consequence, the presentation of the results will also differ from that in a MD or MC box, where a full set of molecules can be depicted (as snapshots). In an SCF model, all properties will be presented in, for example, (average) numbers of molecules per unit area of the membrane, or equivalent, i.e. the (average) densities of molecules as a function of the z-coordinate. The ‘box’ thus consists, if one insists, only of one coordinate. For this reason, we can refer to this method as a one-gradient SCF theory or simply 1D-SCF theory. Extensions towards 2D-SCF are available, where lateral inhomogeneities in the bilayer can also be examined [80]. There are even implementations of 3D SCF-like models, but here the interpretation is somewhat more delicate [78]. For computational reasons, it is necessary to discretise the space in such a way that one considers only a finite number of z-coordinates for the segments of the molecules to take positions. Again, the coarse graining is justified as long as the relevant phenomena do not take place on a smaller length scale. Here we consider lattices with sites that fit united atoms, e.g. CH2 units. The
54
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
z-coordinates can be numbered arbitrarily, z ¼ M, M þ 1, . . . , 1, 0, 1, . . . , M 1, M, where M is a sufficiently large number such that the membrane can fit into the ‘box’. Typically, we will put the centre of the bilayer on the z ¼ 0 spot. The trick of putting the bilayer in the centre of the coordinate system is a convenient one, in order to remove an uninteresting translational entropy term from consideration. Computational tricks are not included in this review [81]. 4.3
THE MOLECULES
In the SCF technique, there is a straightforward way to account for intramolecular excluded-volume correlations [82], i.e. by generating all possible selfavoiding conformations, albeit a computationally expensive task. Accounting for intermolecular excluded-volume correlations cannot be treated exactly, not even by using up much more CPU time (unless, of course, one is willing to resort to simulations). One of the challenges is to put as many of the effects of intermolecular excluded-volume correlations in to the procedure as possible. From the MC results discussed above, we have learned that for short chains it is sufficient to just account for short-range along-the-chain excluded-volume correlations. For this reason, it is tolerable to generate conformations in a rotational isomeric state scheme (RIS). In this context, we refer to this scheme as a finite memory Markov process: excluded-volume correlations over a distance of four consecutive united atoms are included, i.e. these cannot overlap, but for segments further apart this is not strictly forbidden. This problem is (partially) corrected by a contribution to the segment potential as discussed below. In contrast to the RIS scheme used in MD only discrete angles are included on the lattice typically only those corresponding with the trans (lowest energy) and the two gauche (two local minimums of the energy) conformers. Correspondingly, only the energy difference between the trans and a gauche state becomes a parameter in the model. In calculations discussed below, we will use a value of 0.8 kT for this difference, except when we mention otherwise. 4.3.1
Lipids
Molecules that are restricted with their segments on to lattice sites need a force field with characteristics different from those in MD simulations. For example, restricting atoms on the lattice leads to fixed bond lengths, and the bond length control is not needed. By the same token, the bond angles are fixed and there are no parameters to control this angle. In fact, we will consider models in which all united atoms in the molecule are of equal size, exactly fitting to a lattice site. The number of united atoms, as well as the type of united atoms (polar, apolar, charged, etc.) determines the molecular architecture and the type of interactions felt by the molecule. Instead of Lennard–Jones potentials, the
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
55
square-well potential is popular. This potential assumes a finite value if the segments that interact occupy neighbouring lattice sites. If they are further apart then the interaction is assumed to be zero. In a modern implementation of the SCF approach, GOLIATH [83], detailed architectures of the molecules can be handled. Typically the protons are not explicitly defined, but molecular groups that are large can be split up into a group of beads. In this way, the lipid molecules may have rather realistic structures, i.e. they consist of a glycerol backbone on to which two acyl chains and a head group with accurate composition are linked [84–86], as shown in Figure 12. There are also possibilities for considering organic molecules with various chemical groups and spatial arrangements. Typically, unsaturated bonds in the acyl chains can be mimicked, at first approximation, by forcing a gauche kink in the chain. This way of dealing with lipid unsaturation is, of course, much more approximate than can be done in MD or in MC simulations. 4.3.2
Water
A relevant model of self-assembly of hydrocarbon-based surfactants in aqueous solutions should pay sufficient attention to water. Detailed attention has been given to water in MD simulations [31,36], but much less effort has been spent on water in a realistic SCF model. In many SCF treatments of lipid bilayer systems, the chains are end-grafted on to a surface, and the interaction with water is considered to be so strong that excursions into the water phase are excluded [87–91]. At this limit, the water phase is (almost) completely eliminated from the problem. In this review, we will concentrate on SCF models that include water in the model. Up to very recently, even the most detailed SCF models featured a simplistic water model. Typically, water was a spherical monomer that strongly repelled hydrocarbon segments. The membranes resulting from such a model show large amounts of water in the core. Typically, in the order of 5% of the volume in the core was occupied by water [86]. This value is several orders of magnitude too high. A reasonable model that tackles this problem will be discussed next. The most important aspect of water that should be accounted for in this context is that water and hydrocarbons strongly unmix. In practice, this can be attributed to the strong associative nature of water molecules. This is the rationale of using a model that accounts for lateral (in a lattice layer) association of water monomers forming dimers, trimers, etc. It is assumed that water clusters are in equilibrium with each other, according to the reaction: XN þ X Ð XNþ1 , where X is the concentration of water monomers, and the subscript indicates the cluster size. In fact, each cluster of N-water molecules is given only one amount of entropy of mixing, irrespective of the size of the cluster. The total water density can easily be expressed in terms of the reaction
56
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
constant K and the concentration of water monomers, if it is assumed that K does not depend on N. A natural consequence worth mentioning is that the cluster size distribution depends very strongly on the local water concentration. We consider a system with K >> 1. At positions where the water density is low (i.e. in the centre of the bilayer), one can have only free monomers, and large clusters do not exist. On the other hand, in the aqueous phase where the water density is high, almost all water molecules are incorporated in (large) clusters. As a consequence, the free monomer density in the bulk remains very low. Of course, the free monomers in the aqueous bulk are in equilibrium with the free monomers in the bilayer in the same way as in the classical model. The larger clusters prefer the bulk and avoid the membrane core. A typical value of K ¼ 100 is sufficient to remove most of the water from the membrane interior. One can argue that the value of K should be related to the strength of an H-bond in water. Then, a much larger K value should be appropriate. However, this is not implemented for computational reasons. 4.3.3
Ions
In biologically relevant systems, the ionic strength is not extremely low, and the charges in the head-group region are largely screened. The screening by positively or negatively charged ions influences the conformational properties of the ionic head groups and, to a lesser extent, that of zwitterionic head groups. The Gouy–Chapman theory [3] describes the distribution of ions near a charged interface. The classical Gouy–Chapman theory, including a Stern-layer, cannot account for relevant features such as penetration of ions in the head-group region, but it gives the distribution of ions in the immediate surroundings of the bilayers. The self-consistent-field model as elaborated on below may be viewed as an extremely sophisticated Gouy–Chapman model. On top of the use of the Poisson–Boltzmann equation for the charged groups, it has the chain statistics and volume constraint effect (e.g. the Stern concept) included automatically. 4.3.4
Free Volume and the Pressure
One usually distinguishes two types of lattice models. The first type may be called lattice-gas models. In this case, the number of molecules in the system is less than the number of available sites. In other words, there are vacant sites. The second type of lattice models may be called lattice fluids. In this case, all lattice sites are filled exactly by the molecular components in the system; the system is considered to be incompressible. It is easily shown that a two-component incompressible lattice–fluid model can be mapped on a one-component lattice gas one. In other words, it is possible to interpret vacant sites to be occupied by a ‘ghost’
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
57
particle. The chemical potentials in the lattice fluids and the chemical potential and pressure in the lattice–gas model can be related to each other. This can be generalised to more components in the system. Below we will see that a sufficiently general model for the lipid bilayer system should account for some free volume (unoccupied lattice sites) in the bilayer core. If this is not done, then the lipid bilayer system will change spontaneously into the gel phase (at all reasonable temperatures). The choice of lattice-gas versus lattice-fluid models also has consequences for the natural choice of the type of parameters used. Let us consider the squarewell potential as an example. In a lattice-gas model where only one type of molecules, A, exists, there is only one relevant parameter accounting for the particle–particle contacts, i.e. UAA . Neither the interaction energy of a particle with a vacant site, nor the interaction between vacant sites, will contribute to the total energy in the system. In a lattice-fluid system there are two molecular species, A and B. As a consequence, there are UAA , UAB and UBB contact energies. However, the total number of contacts in the system is fixed, because all lattice sites are exactly occupied. It can be shown that in this system one can use Archimedes-like parameters. These parameters, known as the Flory– Huggins (FH) interaction parameters, combine the three energies mentioned above. For convenience, the FH parameter is normalised by the thermal energy kT, and, for technical reasons, it is multiplied by the lattice coordinationZ number Z: wAB ¼ 2kT ½2UAB UAA UBB . The reference is the UAA and the UBB contact energies, and therefore the wAA and wBB quantities have a numerical value of zero. A positive w-value means that A and B repel each other. In fact, the difference between the lattice-gas and lattice-fluid parameters is a difference of reference energy only. When, for example, the B-units are interpreted as vacant sites, we have UAB ¼ UBB ¼ 0 and wAB ¼ ZUAA =(2kT). We note that a particular choice for the reference energy is inconsequential for the properties of the system under consideration, and the set of wAB can always be converted into the appropriate U parameters. For historical reasons, the incompressible lattice-fluid system description is used, even if the distribution of one of the components is coupled to the distribution of vacant sites. Constant ‘pressure’ SCF calculations are the same as constant chemical potential calculations for the vacant sites. These conditions are used below. 4.4
THE SEGMENT POTENTIALS
Unless one is willing to become involved in many intricacies, a lattice model with united atoms (segments) features segments which are all of equal size. The price we have to pay for this is that there is no unique way to convert from lattice units to real space coordinates. We will discuss this point in the ‘Result’ sections in more detail.
58
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
In a lattice model, the only way to discriminate between various segment types is by assigning to each segment type a unique set of interactions, e.g. of the nearest-neighbour type parameterised by Flory–Huggins parameters, or of electrostatic origin influenced by the charge and polarisability of the various fragments of the molecule. These segment-type dependent interactions lead to segment-type dependent potentials. Typically, the segment potentials are used in Boltzmann-like weighting factors which influence the molecular distributions. Without going into too much detail, we can note the segment potentials are composed of four terms. For a unit of type A they are given by: uA (z) ¼ u0 (z) þ A ec(z) X 1 1 þ kT wAB ½jB (z 1) þ jB (z) þ jB (z þ 1) jbB "rA E(z)2 3 2 B (9) The first term is a contribution to the segment potential that does not depend on the segment type. The value of this term is chosen such that the predicted density of molecules in the system is consistent with the incompressibility constraint: X
jx (z) ¼ 1
(10)
x
which applies in each layer z. The second term in equation (9) is the usual electrostatic term. Here vA is the valency of the unit and e is the elementary charge, and c(z) is the electrostatic potential. This second term is the well-known contribution accounted for in the classical Poisson–Boltzmann (Gouy–Chapman) equation that describes the electric double layer. The electrostatic potential can be computed from the charge distribution, as explained below. The third term is the one that accounts for the short-range nearest-neighbour contact energies, parameterised by the Flory–Huggins parameter introduced above. The summation is over all segment types in the system. Here the approach is used that nearest-neighbour contacts can be made with segments that reside in the same – or in one of the adjacent – layers. This implies an a priori weighting of contacts of l1 ¼ 1=3. We note that we here assume that the lattice cell is not isotropic, i.e. the size in the x and y direction is not the same as the size in the z-direction. We will discuss this below. The volume fraction jB (z) is equal to the probability of finding a segment of type B in layer z. The quantity jbB is the probability of finding this segment type in the homogeneous bulk with whichPthe system is in equilibrium. In the bulk all densities add up to unity as well: x jbx ¼ 1.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
59
The fourth term is a polarisation term. Here E(z) ¼ qc=qz is the electric field at position z. In previously published SCF results for charged bilayers, this last term is typically absent. It can be shown that the polarisation term is necessary to obtain accurate thermodynamic data. We note that all qualitative results of previous calculations remain valid and that, for example, properties such as the equilibrium membrane thickness are not affected significantly. The polarisation term represents relatively straightforward physics. If a (united) atom with a finite polarisability of "rA is introduced from the bulk where the potential is zero to the coordinate z where a finite electric field exists, it will be polarised. The dipole that forms is proportional to the electric field and the relative dielectric permittivity of the (united) atom. The energy gain due to this is also proportional to the electric field, hence this term is proportional to the square of the electric field. The polarisation of the molecule also has an entropic consequence. It can be shown that the free energy effect for the polarisation, which should be included in the segment potential, is just half this value –12 "rA E 2 . If for each segment in the system the proper segment potential (according to equation (9)) is computed, one can evaluate easily the overall potential energy in the system. This result is comparable with the first two terms of equation (6) for MD. As discussed above, the bond length is fixed and the RIS scheme is used to control the chain flexibility. For a particular conformation c of a molecule, the positions of all (united) atoms in space as well as the chain conformers are known. The potential energy of this conformation is therefore just the sum of the contributions, as given by equation (9) for all the united atoms and a particular energy quantity per gauche bond in the chain. The statistical weight for this conformation is proportional to the Boltzmann factor containing this segment potential: c
Pci / eui =kT
(11)
The next step is to generate all possible and allowed conformations, which leads to the full probability distribution Pci . The normalisation of this distribution gives the number of molecules of type i in conformation c, and from this it is trivial to extract the volume fraction profiles for all the molecules in the system. With these density distributions, one can subsequently compute the distribution of charges in the system. The charges should be consistent with the electrostatic potentials, according to the Poisson equation: q"(z)E(z) ¼ q(z) qz
(12)
where "(z) is the local dielectric constant that is dependent on the local composition. From equation (12), the electrostatic potential is extracted, and, together
60
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
with the density profile information, equation (12) is recomputed. What follows has been explained above. The potentials and the densities should be consistent with each other, and these solutions are found routinely by computer. Of course, such a solution should also obey the compressibility conditions. The formalism sketched above has been used in the literature in more or less the same detail by many authors [87–92]. The predicted membrane structure that follows from this strategy has one essential problem: the main gel-to-liquid phase transition known to occur in lipid membranes is not recovered. It is interesting to note that one of the first computer models of the bilayer membrane by Marcˇelja [93] did feature a first-order phase transition. This author included nematic-like interactions between the acyl tail, similar to that used in liquid crystals. This approach was abandoned for modelling membranes in later studies, because this transition was (unfortunately) lost when the molecules were described in more detail [87]. The reason for the failure of such an SCF model to predict a gel-to-liquid phase transition is known. The coupling of the single-chain behaviour to the external field is insufficient to induce some cooperative phenomenon necessary for this transition to occur. In the Marcˇelja approach, this coupling was made through a Mayer–Saupe (thermotropic) potential. In this case, the interaction energy is made more attractive for the tails when they are aligned normal to the membrane than when they do not line up. This is reasonable for the molecule as a whole, as may be judged from conformational phase transitions that take place in polymer brushes in the presence of Mayer–Saupe interactions [94], but the ordering efficiency becomes too weak when it is applied on the CH2 CH2 level. It can be shown that in order to recover a cooperative gel-to-liquid phase transition, one should include conformational entropy effects (lyotropic effects). Indeed, it was shown that anisotropic lateral interactions are not necessary for the transition. The solution for the problem was found by introducing weighting factors for placing the bonds of the molecule in the system. It may be of interest to qualitatively explain the origin of the effect. In the derivation of the mean-field partition function, it is necessary to know the probability for inserting a chain molecule in a given conformation into the system. The classical way to compute this quantity is by approximating it by a product of the local volume fractions of an unoccupied site (averaged over lattice layers). It was realised that, besides the density information, information on the bond distributions is also available. The bond distribution gives information on the average local order. Using this information, it becomes possible to more accurately access the vacancy probability. For example, if many chains are perfectly aligned, e.g. in the z-direction, the probability of the test chain also placing its segments in the z-direction becomes strongly enhanced. The oriented molecules leave an open corridor in the direction of the director. In terms of the vacancy probability, it is an event that it is enhanced with respect to the classical mean-field prediction. As a result, the test
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
61
molecule is likely to follow the average orientation of its neighbours. For very densely packed chains, this effect may introduce a cooperative phase transition. The SCF theory that accounts for the anisotropic placing of segment bonds is called SCAF (self-consistent anisotropic field) theory [95]. It is now realised that in a SCAF analysis the chain statistics are done in a quasi-chemical approximation (on a pair-level). Typically, the interactions are still implemented on the Bragg–Williams level, as outlined above (but this is not a matter of principle). Theories that combine the SCAF approach (lyotropic effects) with anisotropic Mayer–Saupe (thermotropic) interactions do not exist. Such a model in combination with a realistic model for water (based upon the quasi-chemical approximation), may well become a next generation of SCF modelling. 4.5
THE SCF SOLUTION
In practice, the scheme as explained above is not implemented. The consecutive generation of all possible chain conformations is a very expensive step. The reason for this is that there are of the order of Z N number of conformations, where Z is the lattice coordination number. A clever trick is to generate a subset of all possible conformations and to use this set in the SCF scheme. This approach is known in the literature as the single-chain mean-field theory, and has found many applications in surfactant and polymeric systems [96]. The important property of these calculations is that intramolecular excludedvolume correlations are rather accurately accounted for. The intermolecular excluded-volume correlations are of course treated on the mean-field level. The CPU time scales with the size of the set of conformations used. One of the obvious problems of this method is that one should make sure that the relevant conformations are included in the set. Typically, the set of conformations is very large, and, as a consequence, the method remains extremely CPU intensive. There exists a less-dangerous method which has the additional advantage that it is computationally extremely cheap. In an RIS scheme, it suffices to know the exact positions of four consecutive segments. Ignoring any longerrange correlations along the chain allows the use of a Markov scheme to generate conformations. In this scheme the combined statistical weight of the full set of conformations is evaluated using a computation time that is linearly proportional to the number of segments in the molecule. This trick is the basis for the huge gain in CPU time. Again, the MC simulations have indicated that such a Markov process is legitimate. The SCF solution, i.e. the condition that the segment densities and the segment potentials are consistent with each other, is found for a canonical ensemble. This means that the number of molecules of each molecule type is fixed. As explained above, membranes should be modelled in a (N, p, g, T), i.e.
62
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
in a fixed surface tension (g ¼ 0) and fixed pressure ensemble. Both the pressure and the surface tension can be evaluated as a function of the composition, that is, the number of lipid molecules per unit area in the system. Typically, an extra iteration of the composition is needed to evolve to an equilibrium tension-free membrane. Unless otherwise mentioned, we will present results for membranes that are free of tension. With respect to SCF models that focus on the tail properties only (typically densely packed layers of end-grafted chains), the molecularly realistic SCF model exemplified in this review needs many interaction parameters. These parameters are necessary to obtain colloid-chemically stable free-floating bilayers. A historical note of interest is that it was only after the first SCF results [92] showed that it was not necessary to graft the lipid tails to a plane, that MD simulations with head-and-tail properties were performed. In the early MD simulations (i.e. before 1983) the chains were grafted (by a spring) to a plane; it was believed that without the grafting constraints the molecules would diffuse away and the membrane would disintegrate. Of course, the MD simulations that include the full head-and-tails problem feature many more interactions than the early ones. The set of parameters, i.e. the force-field parameters used in the SCF calculations, are listed in Table 1. We will not discuss all of them. The most important one is the repulsion between water and hydrocarbon. The value of this FH parameter is set to wH2 O, C ¼ 0:8. One should remember however that in Table 1. Parameters used in (most of) the SCF calculations as presented in this chapter H2 O
V
C
CH3
N
P
O
Na
Cl
"r
80 0
1 0
2 0
2 0
10 1
10 –0.2
10 0
10 1
10 –1
w
H2 O
V
C
CH3
N
P
O
Na
Cl
0 2.5 0.8 0.8 0 0.5 0 0 0
2.5 0 2 1 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5
0.8 2 0 0.5 2.6 2.6 2 2.6 2.6
0.8 1 0.5 0 2.6 2.6 2 2.6 2.6
0 2.5 2.6 2.6 0 0 0 0 0
0.5 2.5 2.6 2.6 0 0 0 0 0
0 2.5 2 2 0 0 0 0 0
0 2.5 2.6 2.6 0 0 0 0 0
0 2.5 2.6 2.6 0 0 0 0 0
H2 O V C CH3 N P O Na Cl
In the first row the relative dielectric constant for the compound is given. In the second row the valency of the unit is given. The other rows give the values for the various FH parameters. Remaining parameters: the characteristic size of a lattice site 0.3 nm; the equilibrium constant for water association: K ¼ 100; the energy difference for a local gauche conformation with respect to a local trans energy: DU tg ¼ 0:8 kT; the volume fraction in the bulk (pressure control) of free volume was fixed to jbV ¼ 0:042575
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
63
the calculations the water–cluster approximation has been implemented. Consistent with this model is a fairly low repulsion between water and hydrocarbon. The parameter has been chosen in order to find the predicted critical micellisation concentrations for surfactants that match experimental ones [97]. In Table 1, the interaction parameters of the unoccupied sites V with the real segments in the system are all positive and relatively high. Again, the reason for having interaction parameters for these ‘contacts’ originates from the Archimedes-like FH parameters. The effect of the relatively high values is that the vapour phase is a bad solvent for all components in the system. The parameters shown in Table 1 must still be considered preliminary. For example, several interactions between two polar compounds are assigned the athermal w ¼ 0 value. This ideal value is chosen in order to keep the set as simple as possible. We also kept the system exactly symmetrical with respect to the interactions of the Na and Cl ions. Again this is a simplification of the real system. One undoubtedly has an asymmetry with respect to the interaction with the hydrophobic core for these two ions. This in itself will generate an electrostatic potential at the membrane–water interface. These ion-specific effects may be studied systematically and are relevant for permeation and transport phenomena. 4.6
PHOSPHATIDYLCHOLINE BILAYERS
A selection of the predictions of the equilibrium structure of DPPC bilayers as found by numerical self-consistent-field calculations is given in the following figures. In a series of articles, the SCF predictions for such membranes were published, starting in the late 1980s. As discussed above, we will update these early predictions for the theory outlined above with updated parameter sets. The calculations are very inexpensive with respect to the CPU time, and thus variations of the parameter-set will also provide deeper insight into the various subtle balances that eventually determine the bilayer structure – the mechanical properties as well as the thermodynamic properties. The saturated PC molecule differs (apart from the length of the tails) from the SOPC molecule depicted in Figure 12 only with respect to the double bond, which is replaced by a single one. In this figure, each unit that is included in the SCF model is drawn. The corresponding parameters are collected in Table 1. From this it is clear that a united atom approach is implemented. This means that the protons are not explicitly included. Note that, in contrast to the recent work of Meijer [84–86], the end groups of the acyl chains now have double the volume as compared with CH2 groups. This is realised by a branching point at the CH2 group on the last but one position in the chain. Furthermore, the CH3 group is given some small repulsion with the CH2 groups to specify that these units differ significantly. The overall density profiles across the DMPC bilayer are given in Figure 13 (see also refs. [84–86,92,95,98]). Together with these profiles, the water-density
64
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES NC 3
+
PO 4
–
C=C 9 10
5
i ii
1
iii
1
sn2 sn1 10
5
15
Figure 12. A typical example of the level of detail used to represent molecules in the SCF calculations: sn1-stearoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine. The open squares are the CH2 groups, the light grey squares on the end of the tails represent the CH3 groups. The C C unsaturation (cis and on position 9) along the acyl chain is indicated. The mid-grey w squares represent oxygen. The darkest grey square is the phosphate. The nitrogen atom as well as the three surrounding carbons in the choline group (CH3 ) are striped. The numbering of the carbons along the sn1 and sn2 tail (1–18) and the carbons in the glycerol backbone (i, ii, iii) are indicated. The positive charge is located at the nitrogen, and the negative charge is distributed over the five units of the phosphate group
Water
DMPC 0.8
j Head
0.4
CH3 0 −20
−10
0 z
Free volume 10
20
Figure 13. The overall density (volume fraction) profile for DMPC bilayers is shown here. Apart from the distribution of the overall DMPC molecules, the density distribution of the head-group units (including the choline group, the phosphate group and the oxygens of the glycerol unit), and the end groups of the lipid tails are also indicated. In addition, the free-volume profile and the water profile are depicted
profile is given. In line with data from the MD simulations, the SCF method predicts that the water molecules only penetrate into the head-group region, and that the water density in the core is reached already in the region of the glycerol backbone. In the model there is also a component which is interpreted as free volume. The parameters were chosen such that the amount of free volume in the core of the bilayer is slightly higher than in the water phase. The free volume density in water is fixed to the equilibrium value found for the water–vapour coexistence calculations: jbv ¼ 0:042575. This value was fixed, which implies, from a lattice-gas perspective, that the pressure was fixed to some reference value, i.e. p ¼ 1.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
65
In the interfacial region between the hydrophobic core and the water phase, there is always a small increase in free volume. The increase is not particularly large, and we are not aware of attempts in MD simulations to measure this small drop in local density. As can be seen from Figure 13 the distribution of head groups is almost as wide as the width of the hydrophobic core. On the one hand, this is because we have collected several head-group units in this overall head-group distribution. On the other hand, there are a number of protrusion fluctuations that are automatically ‘excited’ in the computations. The end groups of the hydrocarbon tails are depicted separately in Figure 13. In line with data from MD simulations, we see a significant spread of the end groups throughout the core. This means that there are considerable fluctuations in conformations of the tails. The atom density dip, as found above in the MD simulation, correlates with the distribution profile of the CH3 units. In reality, the CH3 groups are rather voluminous, and thus conversion of the MD data to volume fractions, or the SCF data to atom densities, leads to the conclusion that the SCF results are at least qualitatively consistent with the MD predictions. The membrane thickness can be defined in many ways. The z-axis is in units of a lattice-cell dimension. As can be seen, the thickness is 20 to 30 lattice units. In principle, the size of a lattice unit can still be chosen. When this value is scaled to the size of a water molecule, i.e. 0.3 nm, a bilayer thickness of the order of 6 nm is obtained. However, a C–C bond in the hydrocarbon chain is significantly shorter, and taking this (i.e. 0.15 nm) as a measure for the lattice size, a P–P distance of approximately 20 lattice units corresponds with a size of order 3 nm. Of course some average is more appropriate. To dissolve the conversion problem from lattice units to real space coordinates it is necessary to compare the results to accurate simulations or experiments. Comparison of MD results, for example as presented in Figure 5, and the SCF result shown in Figure 13 suggests that a more accurate scaling of the size of a lattice site should be around d ¼ 0:2 nm. This value is indeed between the size of a water molecule and that of a C–C bond. We will use this value below to convert from lattice units to real coordinates. Using this value, the bilayer thickness given by the cross-membrane P–P distance for the membrane given in Figure 13 is approximately 4 nm. A more detailed investigation of the DMPC bilayer is given in Figure 14. In this figure, the distributions are split up into two groups, depending on which side the choline group of the lipid is positioned. In this way it is possible to illustrate how much the chains from opposite monolayers interact with each other. The average position of the CH3 groups of the chains is approximately at the centre of the bilayer, albeit that the end groups belonging to chains that have the head group on the positive side have a positive average position. Surprisingly, however, the maximum in the end-point distribution is positioned slightly on the opposite side.
66
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
CH2
0.6 j
0.4
0.2 CH3
P 0 −20
−10
0 z
N 10
20
Figure 14. Volume-fraction profiles of parts of the DMPC molecules for lipids that have the head group at positive coordinates (continuous lines) and at negative coordinates (dashed lines). The centre of the bilayer is positioned at z ¼ 0. The phosphate group, the nitrogen of the choline group and the CH3 groups of the tail ends, as well as the other hydrocarbon units, are indicated
Now we can discuss the interdigitation issue in more depth. The key point is that there is undoubtedly some interdigitation, but that this remains relatively limited. The two monolayers are thus not completely independent. A limited interpenetration should also be expected from entropic considerations. Below we will see that the chain ends are not particularly highly ordered. Thus the chains do not have a clear memory as to which side of the bilayer they ‘belong’. In previous SCF calculations, the interpenetration is likely to have been overestimated. This is because the interpenetration is sensitive to the detailed properties of the CH3 groups. These groups have a larger volume and are expected to be more hydrophobic than CH2 groups. These properties are represented in the parameter set discussed above (and not present in previous ones). The quantitative results depend to some extent on the details of the parameter set. However, it is virtually impossible to completely remove all the overlap between opposing monolayers. This is of course an important observation for the ability of the bilayer to absorb additives in the core. We will return to this issue below. The orientation of the head group can also be deduced from Figure 14. In line with results published in SCF results of Meijer et al. [85], and also in line with all MD simulations of PC layers, the head group is laying flat. This flat orientation is very much promoted by the zwitterionic nature of the head group. The acyl groups connected to the nitrogen group may even push the choline group towards the membrane core. However, entropically it is expected that the end group can be positioned more freely and thus will have a wider distribution. For this reason, the choline group can be found on both sides of
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
y
67
0.05
0.006
0.025
0.003
0
0
−0.025
−0.05 −30
q
−0.003
−20
−10
−0.006 0 z
10
20
30
Figure 15. The electrostatic potential (V) profile (dashed line; left ordinate) and the overall charge (in units of elementary charges) profile (continuous line; right ordinate) across the DMPC bilayer, as found by SCF calculations
the phosphate group. Meijer [84] has shown that with increasing ionic strength the bimodal character of the N profile becomes more pronounced. This result is also in accordance with experimental observations. It has been reported that in PC crystals both conformations of the head group are present [99]. The charge distribution and the electrostatic potential profile across the DMPC bilayer are much more complex that one would intuitively expect. The electrostatic potential profile is presented in Figure 15. It is slightly positive on the outer side of the bilayer as well as in the membrane core. A region with negative electrostatic potential is found at the position of the phosphate group. The electrostatic potential profile must be zero throughout the bilayer, as long as the phosphate and the choline group have identical z-positions. These identical positions do not occur, and thus there is a potential profile and a charge distribution which remains finite, albeit that the local charge density as well as electrostatic potentials are small. The differences between the electrostatic potential profiles as found by SCF calculations and that of MD simulations (cf. Figure 7) are large. First of all, there is a huge difference in absolute value. Furthermore, the SCF results are more detailed. It is instructive to discuss these disparities. For this we need to return to the force fields used in both methods. In MD, many segments have partial charges, and therefore they all contribute to the electrostatic potential. In SCF, these partial charges only occur on the groups which carry an effective charge. All the other contributions are ‘hidden’ in the Flory–Huggins parameters and the local dielectric permittivities, and as such do not show up in the charge distribution and the mean-field electrostatic potential. For this reason, it is not a surprise that the two methods give different results. Perhaps it remains worthwhile to note that both methods indicate that the electrostatic potential in
68
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 0.0015 j
Cl 0.001 Na
0.0005
0 −30
Figure 16.
−20
−10
0 z
10
20
30
The distribution of the ions across the DMPC bilayer
the core is positive with respect to that in the water phase, in accordance with experimental data. The distributions of the ions (Na and Cl) follow the electrostatic potential profile accordingly, as is seen from Figure 16. Of course the ions have a strong preference for the aqueous phase. Nevertheless, they have to partition inside the membrane to some extent. Because the electrostatic potential is positive inside, the negative ions have a small preference for the membrane interior over the positive ions. It should be noted that this preference is solely the result of the electrostatic potential, because the size and the nonelectrostatic interactions were chosen to be identical for the two ions. A more realistic model can discriminate between the ions with respect to the intrinsic affinities for oil and water, respectively. The electrostatic potential profile in the water phase is of course well understood, and follows exactly the Gouy–Chapman theory [3]. For sufficiently low electrostatic potentials (smaller than 25 mV), there is an pffiffiffiffi exponential decay with a decay length given by the Debye length kD 3= js where js is the volume fraction of ions that is proportional to the concentration of ions. The order parameter is directly available from the calculations and the SCF results are given in Figure 17. The absolute values of the order parameter are a strong function of head-group area. Unlike in most SCF models, we do not use this as an input value; it comes out as a result of the calculations. As such, it is somewhat of a function of the parameter choice. The qualitative trends of how the order distributes along the contour of the tails are rather more generic, i.e. independent of the exact values of the interaction parameters. The result in Figure 17 is consistent with the simulation results, as well as with the available experimental data. The order drops off to a low value at the very end of the tails. There is a semi-plateau in the order parameter for positions t ¼ 6 14,
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN 0.4
69
sn2
S
sn1 0.3
0.2
0.1
0 0
2
4
6
8 t
10
12
14
16
Figure 17. Order parameter profile for the two tails of DMPC bilayers. The chain closest to the head group is named sn1 and the other one sn2. Segments closest to the glycerol backbone are numbered t ¼ 1, and the chain ends are t ¼ 16. The lines are drawn to guide the eye
and there is a maximum in the order parameter at chain segments near the glycerol backbone. Together with the known positions of the chain segments and the order along the chain, we can deduce that the central region in the bilayer is slightly more disordered than the outer part of the core. Such a result is relevant for the mechanism of incorporation of foreign objects in the bilayer. The two chains in the lipid bilayer are not identical, because they are positioned asymmetrically with respect to the PC head. It turns out that the tail closest to the head group is buried less deep in the bilayer than the other chain [98]. The difference is not very large; it amounts to about half a segment size. From this difference, we can rationalise the disparities in order between the two tails. The chain that is pulled out will be stretched most, and the order tends to be higher than the other chain. Below we will see that the differences in the behaviour of the tails can become larger if there are differences between the tails, e.g. with respect to the degree of unsaturation. 4.7
THE LATERAL PRESSURE PROFILE
Recently, the lateral pressure profile in a bilayer has been discussed in the context of partitioning of proteins in bilayers [100]. It is argued that this pressure profile can be used to rationalise the effects of additives on the membrane properties. Here a note of caution is necessary. It is not possible to define the lateral pressure profile through a bilayer unambiguously. The reason for this problem is that the local pressure not only has contributions that come from the local densities (this property is uniquely defined), but also from
70
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
interaction between molecules. As molecules typically do not occupy the same coordinate, the method of keeping track of binary, tertiary, etc., interactions becomes somewhat arbitrary. All choices that one can make to do this are equally good. For example, all results of thermodynamic observables that result from moments over the lateral pressure profile and moments over the derivatives of the lateral pressure profile, such as the surface tension and the mechanical parameters of the bilayer, can be shown to be independent of this choice [16,101]. The fact that the lateral pressure profile is ill defined indicates that this property is not a useful one to be monitored or to be discussed in the context of partitioning of additives in membranes. For this reason, we will neither discuss the lateral pressure profile further, nor give an example of the lateral pressure profiles. For one and the same membrane we can generate many strongly varying lateral pressure profiles [16,101]. 4.8
COMPARISON OF SCF AND MD FOR SOPC MEMBRANES
In biological membranes, the class of fully saturated PC lipids is just one of many. Indeed, variations in the lipid architecture are frequently encountered. There are variations with respect to the head-group structure as well as variations in the tail architecture. For example, in the tails, single or multiple unsaturated bonds are very common. There is relatively little knowledge about the role of lipid unsaturation in biomembranes. There are relatively few MD simulations on bilayers composed of lipids with unsaturated bonds. Nevertheless, single unsaturation as well as multiple unsaturated chains have been of some interest. For a recent review see reference [102]. We will now present a selection of the results. We will also take this opportunity to compare the results from the MD simulations with those from the SCF calculations. In Figure 1 we showed a snapshot of a typical MD result for a membrane composed of lipids of the type 1-stearoyl-2-docosahexaenoyl-sn-glycero-3phosphatidylcholine, which has six unsaturated bonds. From a snapshot, it is not possible to understand the role of unsaturation in any detail. However, the averaged density profiles are more informative. In Figure 18, various profiles as found by SCF modelling are compared with corresponding MD results for SOPC bilayers in the hydrated state (see also reference [103]). Before this figure can be discussed, one should realise that in MD simulations the results are typically presented in terms of the density in g cm3 versus the distance from the centre of the bilayer in nm units. The SCF results are available in terms of dimensionless densities (volume fractions) and the dimensionless distance to the centre of the bilayer (i.e. in lattice units). Implementing the above suggested conversion of 0.2 nm leads to a good match in membrane thickness. The problems with the conversion of volume fractions to densities are not easily resolved, and therefore we need to concentrate on the shape of the distributions and not on the heights of the distributions.
(a)
F. A. 1M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN Tails
(b)
0.8
1.2
Water
1
0.6
0.8
0.4
Head
r/g cm−3
j
71
Water
Gly 0.2
CH3 V
Tails 0.6
Head
0.4
Gly 0.2
0.015
0.2
Na
0.01
Cl
0.005
r/g cm−3
j
0 P
0.075
j
P
0.1
0.05 N
0.025 −20
−15
−10
−5
0
z
5
10
15
N
0 20
0
−4
−3
−2
−1
0
1
2
3
4
z /nm
Figure 18. Molecular modelling results for hydrated bilayers of 1-stearoyl-2-oleoyl-snglycero-3-phosphatidylcholine PC (SOPC). (a) SCF results. The volume fraction profiles for tails, head group, glycerol backbone, CH3 end-groups and water (top panel), Na and Cl (middle panel) and the P and N atoms of the head group (bottom panel) are presented. Note that the volume fractions are dimensionless densities and that the z coordinate is made dimensionless by the lattice spacing. (b) MD results. Mass density distributions, g cm3, for the tails, head-group segments, glycerol backbone units and water (top panel), the P and N atoms (bottom panel). In the MD simulation systems there were 48 times two lipids per cell, 24 H2 O molecules per lipid, and altogether there were 20 544 (SOPC) atoms. Mean cross-sectional area per lipid molecule was 0.6624 nm2. The MD trajectories of 1018 ps were computed at T ¼ 303 K. The zero point (z ¼ 0) is the centre of the bilayer: it was calculated during the MD simulations as the middle point between the centres of P–N vectors of the two monolayers (the centre of the P–N vector is the middle of P–N distance). The ratio between the CPU times (MD/SCF) needed to obtain these results is in the order of 105
First of all it is seen that the SCF results are free of any noise, whereas there is plenty of noise in the MD profiles (note, however, that the density profiles on both halves of the bilayer are in this case not averaged; the close resemblance between the profiles on both halves thus indicates that the membranes are well equilibrated). Apart from this, inspection of Figure 18 shows a remarkable resemblance between the two set of predictions. Many details are in semiquantitative agreement. Moreover, many of the features of membranes composed of SOPC resemble those of DMPC discussed above. For example, the width of the membrane–water interface is about 1 nm, i.e. the size of just two to three water molecules. This width is consistent with the scaling arguments mentioned at the beginning of this chapter. A more accurate comparison
72
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
between the SCF and MD results shows that even the shapes of the head-group profiles match accurately and the distributions of the P and N atoms have the same features. The fact that these two distributions are strongly overlapping means that the PC head group is roughly oriented parallel to the membrane surface, as is the case for DMPC. Of course there are differences. For example, in the SCF calculations a 1:1 electrolyte solution was used, whereas in the MD simulations no salt ions were added. We note that the densities of the two ions, as shown in Figure 18a, are almost the same in the centre of the bilayer. This means that in this case the electrostatic potential in the centre of the bilayer is virtually zero. Other features of the ion profiles are the same as in Figure 16 for DMPC. The noted difference is not attributed to a fundamental difference between DMPC and SOPC bilayers. The difference is caused by the fact that the ionic strength used in the SOPC system (Figure 18a) is 10 times higher than in the DMPC system (Figure 16). The higher ionic strength leads to a more efficient screening of the electrostatic potential. A minor effect already noticed by Meijer and co-workers [84] is that the head-group properties slightly depend on the ionic strength, even in the case of a zwitterionic head group. From the density profiles one cannot really judge the effect of the double bonds; the density profiles for membranes of saturated lipids are very similar to those of unsaturated ones. Therefore it is necessary to consider some of the conformational characteristics of the tails. It is possible to compute the order parameter profile for both the saturated and the unsaturated chains. The order parameter profile for the saturated chain closely follows the results presented in Figure 17 for DMPC membranes for both the SCF and the MD predictions. The order parameter profiles for the unsaturated chain closely follows the MC predictions, as discussed in Figure 9. A pronounced dip is found near the cis double bond. For this reason, we choose here to present complementary data about the conformational properties of the acyl chains. In Figure 19 the root-mean-square positions (fluctuations) of all segments of both tails as a function of the average positions are shown for both modelling techniques. These results are significantly more informative than order parameter profiles. From Figure 19 it is easily seen that towards the tail end the fluctuations increase and that the segments close to the glycerol backbone have the sharpest distributions. The average positions of the first segments of the two tails differ slightly; the sn1 tail is (similarly to in DPPC bilayers) buried slightly deeper in the bilayer than the sn2 tail, as can be judged from the hzi positions of the first segments. In lipid bilayers with saturated tails, the two tails differ only with respect to this small shift. However, in SOPC the unsaturated chain is buried significantly less deep in the bilayer than the saturated one; the unsaturated chain behaves effectively as a shorter chain [104]. The fluctuations tend to increase relatively fast for the free chain ends, especially for the unsaturated tail, i.e. left of the arrow (which indicates the position of the double bond) in Figure 19. The fact that the average end position (CH3 groups) of the saturated
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
73
5 1.4
(a)
(b)
18 18
4
18
18
RMSZ /nm
RMSZ
1.2 18:1
3 18:0
18:0
1 2
1
18:1
2
2 2
1
0.8 2 1
1
1 0
2
4
6
8
0.6 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
< z >/nm
Figure 19. The root-mean-square (RMS) position of each segment of both acyl chains of SOPC lipids is plotted as a function of the average position of the segment. The sn1 tail is given by the closed symbols, and the sn2 tail is given by the open symbols. Various numbers of the tail segments and of the backbone segments are indicated. The lines are drawn to guide the eye. The arrow points to the position of the unsaturated bond. (a) SCF results (conversion from dimensionless units to real units is approximately a factor of 0.2 nm), (b) MD results (the average over the sides of the bilayer is taken)
tail is near the centre of the bilayer, and because the fluctuations are large, it is again true that there is a significant interdigitation between tails of opposite monolayers. The interpenetration is significantly less for the unsaturated chain. In both the SCF calculations, as well as for the MD results, the two curves in Figure 19 cross each other. The local growth of the fluctuations at the position of the double bond and suppression of fluctuations just around the double bond are both very characteristic of a cis double bond. Similar results are also discussed in some depth in a paper where statistical mechanical calculations are compared with corresponding MD simulations [105]. The mean-field model that is used in the latter study is one where chains of equimolar amounts of saturated and unsaturated bonds are grafted at a density which corresponds with the experimental data. Not all studies agree on the effect of unsaturation. In an MD study made by Heller [106] it was found that around the unsaturated bond there is a region with increased fluctuations, whereas above these regions there were just a few less fluctuations. One can argue that this might be due to an insufficient equilibration of the system. From the modelling results for bilayers composed of unsaturated lipids one can begin to speculate about the various roles unsaturated lipids play in biomembranes. One very well-known effect is that unsaturated bonds suppress the gel-to-liquid phase transition temperature. Unsaturated lipids also modulate the lateral mobility of molecules in the membrane matrix. The results discussed above suggest that in biomembranes the average interpenetration depth of lipid tails into opposite monolayers can be tuned by using unsaturated lipids. Rabinovich and co-workers have shown that the end-to-end distance of multiple unsaturated acyl chains was significantly less sensitive to the temperature than that of saturated acyls. They suggested from this that unsaturated
74
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
lipids may have a role in providing a temperature-insensitive lipid jacket around protein molecules [102]. Whether it is generally true that membrane proteins are preferentially surrounded by unsaturated lipids remains to be proven. 4.9
CASE STUDIES: SCF RESULTS
We have seen from the above that the simulations and the calculations give a consistent picture of the PC bilayers. The strong and weak points of both methods are now well illustrated, and we can proceed by presenting results for gradually more complex problems obtained by the SCF method. 4.9.1
Effects of the Length of the Hydrocarbon Tails
It is of interest to elaborate on the effect of the tail lengths of the PC lipids on various (overall) membrane parameters. Here we will concentrate on the area per molecule and the compressibility modulus in the range C12 to C16 . Relevant data can easily be obtained from SCF calculations, and the predictions of this theory are presented in Figure 20. In line with experimental data, the area per molecule is almost independent of the length of the tails. Only a very small linear correction is found, which indicates that the longer the tail length the larger is the head group area. As a consequence, the thickness of the bilayer is to a good approximation proportional to the length of the chains. It is necessary to convert the dimensionless area as given in Figure 20 to real areas per molecule. For this, we need to know the cross-sectional area of a lattice site. The first-order approximation of this is d 2 . However, this is only correct for isotropic lattice sites. It can be shown that, consistent with the weighting of the interactions in equation (9) (l1 ¼ 1=3), the area is a factor of three higher: 0.9
(a)
5.4
0.2
1.3
(b)
C16PC
1.1
g
5.3
0.85
0.1 0.9
0.8 12
13
14 t
15
5.2 16
0 0
0.05
0.1 (a − a0)/a0
0.15
d ln a / d g
d ln a/d g
a0
0.7 0.2
Figure 20. (a) The (dimensionless) lateral compressibility (dilatational modulus, elastic area expansion modulus) (left ordinate) and the dimensionless area per molecule (right ordinate) as a function of the tail length (t) of the PC lipids in equilibrium bilayer membranes. The conversion to real compressibilities and areas per molecule is discussed in the text. (b) The (dimensionless) surface tension and the (dimensionless) lateral compressibility as a function of the relative expansion for the C16 PC lipid
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
75
as ¼ 3d 2 . Again, when we use d ¼ 0:2 nm, as explained above, it is possible to convert the prediction to the area per molecule. One simply needs to multiply the dimensionless areas by 0.12 to obtain the area in units of nm2 . The correspondence with experimental data is satisfactory. The lateral compressibility, i.e. the relative area change upon an imposed membrane tension, decreases slightly more than linearly with the chain length. This means that it is more difficult to expand the membrane surface area of a long-chained lipid than a shorter one. In Figure 20 dimensionless units are used, which means that the surface tension is given in units kT=as . Again, using a lateral dimension of a site, d ¼ 0:2 nm, and the lattice site area as ¼ 3d 2 , means that g ¼ 1 corresponds with about 33 mN m1 lateral tension. In other words, one needs to apply a lateral tension of order 40 mN m1 to double the membrane area. This prediction seems to be a factor of about six lower than estimates that were recently reported by Evans and co-workers [107]. These authors use micropipettes to pressurise giant vesicles and obtain values of the order KA ¼ qg=q ln a ¼ 230 mN m1 . There are also some data on the compressibility modulus, as found by MD simulations on primitive surfactants [62] KA ¼ 400 mN m1 . In a molecular detailed simulation study on DPPC lipids, Feller and Pastor [40] report a KA value of about 140 mN m1 . In Figure 20 the surface tension of the bilayer is given as a function of the relative expansion of the bilayer. Of course, when the surface area is increased, the surface tension invariably goes up. The slope of this curve decreases slightly with increasing relative expansion. From this, it is seen that the membrane compressibility increases when the membrane is stretched. 4.9.2
Lipid Variations: Charged Lipids in Bilayers
An important ingredient at the disposal of nature to vary the membrane properties in subtle ways is to make changes in the head-group structure. A PC lipid is zwitterionic and, as such, it is rather inert with respect to variations in ionic strength. We note that the insensitivity with respect to the membrane structure does not imply that the colloidal stability is not affected by the ionic strength. Meijer [84] has shown that it is expected that PC bilayers are only colloid-chemically stable at an intermediate ionic strength; then the electrostatic repulsion is largest. Both at high and low ionic strength attractive contributions may dominate over repulsive interactions. Charged lipids have not frequently been modelled. In simulations, the charges impose significant problems because it is extremely expensive to account for long-range interactions. Also by SCF techniques there has been little work done. Meijer et al. [84] reported on some properties of phosphatidylserine-type lipids. We connect here to these results and present a short survey. In an SCF model the PS lipids are parameterised on the same level of detail as the PC lipids. The extra carboxyl group is modelled with one negative charge with similar properties as a negative ion, on to which
76
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
24 5.8 dP−P
ao PS
20 5.4 PC
16 5 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
fPS
Figure 21. The area per molecule (left ordinate) and the distance between the phosphate groups on opposite sides of the bilayer of the PC and PS lipids as indicated (right ordinate) as a function of the fraction of PS molecules in equilibrated bilayers composed of mixtures of C16 PC and C16 PS lipids. Reproduced from ref (85) with permission from the American Chemical Society
two oxygens are coupled. For PS, there are two negative charges and one positive charge in the head group. A net negative charge on the head group gives the head group a more hydrophilic nature. This leads to a more hydrated head group that tends to extend more towards the water phase than the PC group. The average phosphate – phosphate distance across the bilayer is a convenient measure for the thickness of the bilayer. This property is presented in Figure 21 for bilayers composed of mixtures of PS and PC lipids. The phosphate of the PS head group is extended more outwards than the phosphate of the PC group. At the same time, the area per molecule increases with an increase of the PS in the bilayer. These effects are shown in Figure 21. It is anticipated that the membranes composed of charged lipids are more sensitive to the ionic strength. Very often in such cases the Debye length is the controlling parameter. As the Debye length is proportional to the square root of the ionic strength, we present in Figure 22 the area as well as the hP Pi distance as a square root of the ionic strength. The number of molecules per unit area (the inverse of the area per molecule) is inversely proportional to the Debye length (i.e. ðjs Þ1=2 ). When the area per molecule goes down, the molecules must pack more closely, and thus it is natural to find that the membranes become thicker. This is reflected by the increase in hP Pi, increasing again with the square root of the ionic strength. 4.9.3
The Gel-Phase of DPPC Bilayers
At sufficiently low temperature, the liquid state of the bilayer is not stable and the membrane abruptly ‘freezes’ into the so-called gel state. The structure of a
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
77 21
5.9
dP−P
a0
20 5.7
19
5.5
5.3
18 0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
js
Figure 22. The average dimensionless area per molecule (left ordinate) and the phosphate – phosphate distance in lattice units across the bilayer (right ordinate) of phosphatidyl serine bilayers as a function of the square root of the ionic strength
bilayer membrane in the gel state has recently been modelled by MD simulations [35,106,108]. To obtain good results, it is necessary to have a constant pressure rather than a constant-area simulation. In the gel phase, the molecules are almost in an all-trans configuration. Only approximately 0.1 gauche torsion was found per acyl chain. The acyl chains can be ordered in several ways with particular tilting angles. The SCF modelling of gel-state membranes has also some history. There are some early works on the gel-to-liquid phase transition [109,110], where the main interest is in the cooperative ordering of the acyl chains. The full problem of thermodynamically relaxed bilayers composed of lecithin-like molecules has been reported by Leermakers et al. more than a decade ago [95]. Although the SCAF model makes use of lattice approximations which become rather restrictive when the molecules go towards the fully ordered state, it was shown that it is possible to generate tensionless membranes in the gel state. Both fully interdigitated gel phases and noninterdigitated ones could be found which depended on the degree of hydration of the bilayers. We will not present these results in this review in more detail. In passing, we note that Schick and co-workers also modelled lipid monolayers using a SCAF-like technique [111]. They go essentially off-lattice by allowing steps in many different directions. By doing so, they found some cooperative tilt direction of the lipid tails as a function of the headgroup area. Such an approach should be applied to the bilayer problem as well. Then gel phases in which the molecules are cooperatively tilted with respect to the membrane normal can be analysed. To our knowledge this has not yet been done.
78
4.9.4
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
Mechanical Parameters of Lipid Bilayers
In principle, one can analyse the equilibrium fluctuations as found from an MD simulation around the perfectly flat configuration of a bilayer to obtain information on the mechanical properties of the bilayer [14,15]. The finite size of the box is a serious limitation to do this accurately, and results of this type can best be reached using coarse-grained MD simulations. The alternative to learning about the mechanical parameters of the bilayer is to do molecular realistic simulations on nonlamellar geometries (i.e. curved bilayers). Periodic boundary conditions dictate that the (average) shape of the bilayers in MD simulations is flat. This is why such results do not (yet) exist in the literature. The authors are aware of some preliminary MD simulations on primitive surfactants (coarsegrained MD) in which the molecules follow the equations of motion in the presence of some type of bias force. This force is chosen such that it maintains a well-defined local curvature in the bilayer [112]. The strength of the bias gives information on the mechanical resistance of the bilayer against shape changes. Some information on the behaviour of lipids in curved geometries for a molecularly simplistic model is available from MC simulations [113]. Much more work has been done using SCF theory. Above, we argued that a portion of a finite-sized membrane can close upon itself to remove edge effects. In this way, vesicles are formed. The thermodynamic stability of vesicles is still a topic of hot debate in the literature, primarily because there are so many scenarios. The SCF analysis of vesicles leads to information on the mechanical parameters for a particular membrane system. The first point to be made is that the structure of the bilayers changes due to an imposed curvature. These curvature effects are easily monitored in an SCF analysis. Unless one is willing to do a three-dimensional analysis, the method is restricted to homogeneously curved bilayers, i.e. cylindrical or spherically shaped vesicles. Curvature-induced structural changes are best observable when the curvature is extremely high. Curved vesicles composed of lipids with molecular detail were first performed by Leermakers and Scheutjens [114]. The results presented in Figure 23 were obtained with the same parameter-set as discussed in Table 1, but the anisotropic bond-weighting factors were omitted. This means that the bilayers are slightly thinner than given in Figure 13. In Figure 23 the centre of the vesicle is at r ¼ 0. The head groups on the inner leaflet, positioned at r ¼ 20 have a higher local density than the head groups in the outer leaflet. The tails, excluding the CH3 end-groups, show a clear maximum on the outer side of the core region. The CH3 groups, on the other hand accumulate slightly more on the inner side. This shows that two halves of the curved bilayer contain chains that have different conformational properties. The total contribution of the tails, i.e. including the CH2 and CH3 groups, still reaches a maximum in the
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
79
1 Tails
0.8 j
0.6
0.4 Head
0.2
0
CH3
0
10
20
30
40
50
r
Figure 23. Radial segment density profile through a cross-section of a highly curved spherical vesicle. The origin is at r ¼ 0, and the vesicle radius is very small, i.e. approximately r ¼ 25 (in units of segment sizes). The head-group units, the hydrocarbons of the tails and the ends of the hydrocarbon tails are indicated. Calculations were done on a slightly more simplified system of DPPC molecules in the RIS scheme method (thirdorder Markov approximation), i.e. without the anisotropic field contributions
outer region of the core. These curvature-induced changes in the membrane structure are the locus of some additional free energy in the system. By means of a thermodynamic analysis, one can extract these changes in free energy and obtain information on the mechanical properties of the bilayers. The thermodynamic analysis of curved bilayers is typically done on very weakly curved objects (much less curved then the example shown in Figure 23). This is to guarantee that the free energy of curvature remains quadratic in J and K. The bending modulus that controls the undulation fluctuations kc is known to depend strongly on the length of the hydrocarbon chains. The classical theory of elastic deformation [115] already indicates that the energy needed to bend a plate scales with the third power of its thickness. Such a strong increase of the bending modulus with lipid chain length appears to be consistent with both theoretical SCF computations [116] and with experimental findings [107]. It is also believed that for stable bilayers the Gaussian bending modulus is negative [25]. There is no experimental technique available that points directly to this quantity. It is believed that theoretical predictions may help to understand these matters in more detail. A typical outcome of the Helfrich analysis for charged bilayer systems is presented in Figure 24b–d in combination with experimental results for the dependence of the equilibrium radius of vesicles composed of DOPG and DOPC as a function of the ionic strength in Figure 24a. The vesicle solution was equilibrated using the freeze–thaw method [20], and the size was measured
80
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 140
(a)
(b) 6.5
R / nm
120
kc/kT 100
DOPG
cW-ion = −2
5.5
80 cW-ion = 0
DOPC 60 0
100
200
300 cNaBr /mM
0
400 (c)
_ k/kT
c
W-ion
0.01
80
= −2
0.02
fs
0.03
0.04
(d)
cW-ion = 0
−5
c
W-ion
= −2
em/kT cW-ion = 0 40
−10
−15 0
4.5 0
0.01
0.02
0.03
fs
0.04
0
0
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
fs
Figure 24. (a) Experimental results for the radius of vesicles composed of DOPG and DOPC lipids as a function of the concentration of NaBr. The vesicles were prepared by the freeze–thaw method mentioned above, and the size R was found from dynamic lightscattering analysis. (b) The mean bending modulus as found by SCF calculations for DOPG-like lipids as a function of the ionic strength of 1:1 electrolyte. (c) the Gaussian bending modulus as found by SCF calculations for DOPG-like surfactants as a function ) as of the ionic strength of 1:1 electrolyte. (d) The total curvature energy em ¼ 4p(2kc þ k a function of the ionic strength of 1:1 electrolyte. In b, c and d the two curves illustrate the effect of the solvent quality for the ions (as indicated). Reproduced from (132) with permission from the American Institute of Physics
using dynamic light scattering [23]. The experimental data show that the vesicle size R goes through a minimum for DOPG, and is essentially an increasing function for DOPC as a function of the ionic strength. For computational reasons, the corresponding SCF analysis has been done on a relatively primitive model. The chain statistics is set to the lowest order (i.e. a first-order Markov approximation instead of the RIS scheme). The lipid molecules were modelled as linear chains with a charged head group in the middle of two C18 tails, i.e. with a Gemini-like architecture: C18 M2 C2 M2 C18 . The charge on the head-group units was set to vM ¼ 0:25 mimicking DOPG, so that the overall charge was –1. The ionic strength is given by the volume fraction of ions in the bulk, which was varied from 104 to 0.04. Interaction parameters were chosen to be as simple as possible (still reflecting the essential amphiphile characteristics): w ¼ 1:6 for water–C as well as ion (M, Na, Cl)–C contacts. In the calculations the affinity of ions for the water phase was varied
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
81
to show the effect of changes with respect to the ionic properties. Below, results are presented for the athermal interactions, i.e. wionwater ¼ 0 and for attractive interactions between ions and water wionwater ¼ 2. The interaction parameter for the M–water contacts was fixed at zero. Lekkerkerker [117] examined the curvature dependence of the free energy of the electric double layer for fixed surface charge density. From this, the electrostatic part of the mean and Gaussian bending moduli of charged bilayers was predicted as a function of the ionic strength. Both the mean bending modulus and the Gaussian bending modulus were found to depend relatively strongly on the ionic strength. With increasing ionic strength, the absolute value a of these quantities decreases as a power law (kc / ca salt and k / csalt ). The power-law exponent is predicted to be a function of the surface charge density. At high surface charge density, a ¼ 0:5, whereas at low surface charge density a value of a ¼ 1:5 was reported. One problem with these early predictions is that the surface charge density is fixed for all values of the imposed curvature J and K and the value of the ionic strength. Thus the model does not allow for curvature-dependent head-group areas and local charge compensation mechanisms such as the penetration of the ions in between the charged head groups. Indeed, for lipid membranes, one should expect that the head-group area, and thus the effective charge density of the bilayer, is a function of the ionic strength. These restrictions do not apply for the SCF analysis. In these calculations, the surface charge density adjusts itself automatically. In the SCF analysis of curved bilayers, it was found that all results could be fitted with the Helfrich equation, without the need to invoke a nonzero J0 . This means that the vesicles are typically stabilised by translational and undulational entropic contributions. This result is consistent with results by Leermakers [114] for uncharged lipid bilayers, and can be rationalised by symmetry arguments as discussed above. In Figure 24b and 24c, the mean and Gaussian bending moduli are plotted as a function of the ionic strength for charged lipid vesicles in a 1:1 electrolyte ) is presolution. For convenience, the total curvature energy em ¼ 4p(2kc þ k sented in Figure 24d. Results are presented for two values of the ion–water interactions. Let us first discuss the ideal case where the ions interact athermally with the solvent (closed spheres). In this case, the predictions of Lekkerkerker [117] are qualitatively recovered: with increasing ionic strength the Gaussian bending modulus becomes less negative, the mean bending modulus is reduced and the overall curvature energy is an increasing function of the ionic strength. Forcing a power law through the data of Figures 24b,c (solid points), however, gives a much lower ionic strength dependence than predicted by Lekkerkerker [117] (a 0:1). The reason for this weak ionic strength dependence is that with increasing ionic strength the area per molecule goes down, which tends to increase the absolute values of the bending moduli.
82
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
One may argue that the ideal interactions of all ions with water are not physically realistic. For this reason, we have repeated the full analysis with better than athermal solvent conditions. The results of this exercise are given by the open circles in Figure 24b,c,d. Indeed, for this case, the mean bending modulus goes through a minimum as a function of the ionic strength. For the other properties presented in Figure 24, the qualitative behaviour is not affected. We may argue that, with increasing ionic strength, the solvent (water þ ions) becomes a worse solvent for the apolar tails. As a consequence, the membrane thickness increases just slightly more with increasing ionic strength than in the athermal case (not shown). At high ionic strength, the change of the bare bending modulus due to the increase in thickness of the bilayer, dominates over the change of the electrostatic part of the bending modulus. Above we have argued that the equilibrium radius of a vesicle may be related to the persistence length of the bilayer. This implies that the radius of the vesicle kc ). The strong correlation between the curves for DOPG in R x / exp ( kT Figures 24a and 24b (open circles) strongly indicates that this line of reasoning makes some sense. Using this approach, one can extract from Figure 24a how the bending modulus depends on the ionic strength. Consistent with the SCF results, a very weak ionic strength dependence is found (a 0:06). It is of significant interest to discuss the overall curvature energy (as shown in Figure 24d) as a function of the ionic strength, in somewhat more detail. Consistent with predictions based upon the electrostatic part of the bending moduli [117], it is found that the overall curvature energy goes down with decreasing ionic strength. When the overall curvature energy drops below zero, the vesicles become unstable. The SCF thus predicts that at very low ionic strength, a micellar phase, not the vesicles, becomes the more favourable aggregation state of these lipids. This is consistent with the surfactant parameter arguments mentioned in the introduction. With decreasing ionic strength, the effective size of the head group increases. Therefore, the effective shape of the surfactant becomes less like a cylinder and more like a cone. In other words, the surfactant parameter drops to such a low value that bilayers are not stable. Interestingly, at the point where the curvature energy vanishes, the size of the vesicles is very large, because kc increases with decreasing ionic strength. The transition from the solution with vesicles to a micellar solution is predicted to be a jump-like (first-order) phase transition. Going in the opposite direction, i.e. when we consider the membrane stability towards zero. Going with increasing ionic strength, we notice the approach of k towards this value, the tendency of the bilayers to form saddle-shaped connections (also called ‘stalks’) between bilayers increases. Saddle-shaped membrane structures also occur in processes like vesicle fusion, endo and exocytosis. The SCF predictions thus indicate that these events will occur with more ease at high ionic strength than at very low ionic strength.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
4.9.5
83
Membrane–Membrane Interactions
Invariably, the thermodynamic stability of lipid vesicles in the colloid–chemical sense is an important issue. In this context, it is very important to know how a given bilayer interacts with other bilayers of its kind. In MD simulations, it is virtually impossible to do predictions for isolated, noninteracting bilayers. Typically, one uses experimental data on the equilibrium membrane–membrane spacing when a simulation box is created. Systematic thermodynamic analysis of the effect of the membrane–membrane spacing is not available from simulations. For this, we again have to turn to more approximate SCF modelling. In an SCF technique the partition function is accurately available, and therefore it is straightforward to examine interacting membranes. In Figure 25 we show a prediction of Meijer et al. [85] for DMPC membranes interacting with each other as a function of an applied lateral tension (see reference [85] for the details of the values of interaction parameters used). Membranes under lateral tension have an increased area per molecule, and thus are thinner than equilibrium membranes. As a result, the number of water– hydrocarbon tail contacts is increased, and also the head-group conformation may be altered. As a result of this, one would expect that membranes under tension become more attractive to each other than when they are free of tensions. Basically, this is also what can be extracted from Figure 25. The repulsion at high membrane spacing has an electrostatic origin. When increasing tension is applied to the membrane, the repulsion goes down. The attraction in the curve is due to conformational changes in the head-group region when membranes are in very close proximity. The depth of this minimum is not 0.0008
F int γ(∞)= 0.160 0.0004 0.0 0.087
0
5
7
9
11
D
Figure 25. The free energy of interaction between two DMPC membranes at various degrees of surface tension as indicated. We note that the indicated surface tension is the tension at large membrane–membrane spacing. The salt bulk volume fraction was js ¼ 0:002. Redrawn from [85] by permission of the American Chemical Society
84
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
affected greatly by the lateral tension. The position of the minimum is a function of the applied tension, as must be expected from the reduced dimensions of the bilayers. The steep repulsion at very close proximity is due to a compression of the bilayers, which is, as explained above, energetically unfavourable. Stress-induced adhesion is also found in experimental systems, as discussed by Helfrich [118]. The typical interpretation of stress-induced adhesion differs significantly from the one given above. It is generally believed that the main effect of an applied tension is to reduce undulations. In the absence of undulations, the corresponding repulsion vanishes and the membranes can attract each other by, for example, van der Waals forces. It should be noted that the interaction free energy of the bilayers reported in Figure 25 is an intrinsic interaction. For a complete picture, one needs to add the van der Waals contribution, but also, more importantly, the contributions due to the undulation. To some extent, these two contributions cancel each other out, and it is expected that the intrinsic effects as discussed above are relevant for the interaction of bilayers at rather close proximity. 4.9.6
A DPPC Layer as a Substrate for a Polyelectrolyte Brush
In many biological systems the biological membrane is a type of surface on which hydrophilic molecules can be attached. Then a microenvironment is created in which the ionic composition can be tuned in a controlled way. Such a fluffy polymer layer is sometimes called a slimy layer. Here we report on the first attempt to generate a realistic slimy layer around the bilayer. This is done by grafting a polyelectrolyte chain on the end of a PC lipid molecule. When doing so, it was found that the density in which one can pack such a polyelectrolyte layer depends on the size of the hydrophobic anchor. For this reason, we used stearoyl C18 tails. The results of such a calculation are given in Figure 26. Because the amount of matter in the form of DPPC lipids in these calculations is about 25 times higher than for the polyelectrolyte modified lipids, it is necessary to rescale the latter densities such that one can understand the interesting aspects. Therefore there are different scales on left and right ordinates in the figures. In Figure 26a, the overall density profiles of both lipids are shown. The DPPC lipids are not much affected by the intrusion of the PEmodified ones. The overall membrane thickness due to the DPPC chains is about equal to the thickness of an unperturbed DPPC bilayer. The conformations of the PE chain are understood from polymer brush theory. In particular, the work on polyelectrolyte brushes has advanced in recent years [119,120]. The distribution of small counterions in the polyelectrolyte layer is such that the charge is almost exactly compensated locally. It is relevant to mention that the charge per segment on the PE chain was set to ¼ 0:25 and
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN DPPC
1
0.008
H2O
(b)
0.006
C PC-P
0.6
18
0.04
0.005
(a)
0.8
j
85
200
0.02
0.0025
j 0.004
q
0.002
−0.0025
y
0
0
0.4
Na 0.2
−0.02
Cl 0
0
j
20
40
z
60
80
0 100
0.006 C
0.0003
0
20
40
z
60
(d)
j 0.0003 0.04
P200 0.00015
j
C PC-P 18
N
0.003
−0.04 100
80
0.06
j
(c)
P
−0.005
C PC 16
200
0.00015
0.02 P N
N
P
0 0
20
40
z
60
80
0 100
0 0
5
10
z
15
0 20
Figure 26. The structural properties of a mixture of C16 PC (DPPC) and stearoyl C18 PC lipids of which there is a polyelectrolyte chain attached to the N of the choline group. The polyelectrolyte (PE) chain is a string of hydrophilic segments, each of which has a charge of ¼ 0:25. The amount of lipid is y ¼ 10:1, and that of the PE chain is y ¼ 0:4. In all views graph profiles are shown for only half the bilayer, i.e. starting from the centre of the bilayer (at z ¼ 0). (a) The overall profiles for C16 PC and water are solid lines, left ordinate, and C18 PCP200 , Na and Cl all dashed lines, right ordinate. (b) The charge distribution, q, left ordinate and electrostatic potential profile, c, right ordinate. (c) Detailed distribution of the PE-modified lipid C18 PCP200 . The C units and the PE chain are dashed (left ordinate), and the P and N distributions are solid lines (right ordinate). (d) The P and N distributions for the C16 PC lipids, broken lines (left ordinate) and that for the PE-modified lipid, solid lines (right ordinate)
that on the small mobile ions is unity. Therefore the density of polymer is about a factor of four higher than the difference between the density of positive ions and negative mobile ions. This local electroneutrality is illustrated in Figure 26b, where the charge density profile q(z) is plotted. The electrostatic potential profile is rather complex. In the hydrophobic region, the features are similar to those discussed above for the pure DPPC layer cf. Figure 15. The electrostatic potential profile in the PE layer is parabolic, and outside the PE layer the potential is very low, but decays according to the classical Gouy–Chapmann theory, i.e. exponential decay towards zero. In Figure 26c and 26d some more details are plotted for the PE-modified lipid. On the PE chain there are some features deviating from the parabolic profile near the lipid–water interface. We should realise that in the membrane
86
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
there is a positive electrostatic potential, whereas the electrostatic potential in the brush is negative. The relatively high brush density near z ¼ 20 is therefore attributed to electrostatically driven ‘adsorption’. One would intuitively argue that grafting a long hydrophilic tail on the end of the head group would cause the P–N vector to orient towards the membrane normal. This is indeed the case. The distribution of the N is shifted to higher z values than the P group, as is best seen in Figure 26d. In this part of the graph it is shown that the head-group orientation of the unmodified DPPC is surprisingly unperturbed by the presence of the PE chains near the membrane.
5
TRANSPORT AND PERMEATION
To facilitate specific uptake of nutrients and secretion of products, as well as to maintain the ionic concentration gradients and membrane potentials essential for life processes, nature has developed different kinds of more or less specialized transport systems incorporated in the lipid bilayer. However, some types of molecules and ions can pass biomembranes by themselves. Examples are water, oxygen and carbon dioxide (which need to move rapidly into and out of cells), nitrous oxide, and various toxins and drugs. For the explanation of this so-called nonmediated transport, two alternative mechanisms are commonly used. In the first, it is proposed that molecules diffuse across the membrane (solubility–diffusion mechanism), in the other the transport is assumed to take place along water wires or stochastic pores in the lipid bilayer (pore mechanism). In the next subsections we will go into some detail with respect to these two mechanisms, and will discuss the molecular modelling performed in this direction using MD simulations and SCF calculations. In Section 5.3 we will pay attention to the modelling of mediated membrane transport, i.e. the transport through peptide or protein channels, or otherwise catalysed by carriers or transport proteins. 5.1
SOLUBILITY–DIFFUSION MECHANISM
Travel across the lipid bilayer must be an exciting undertaking. The molecular traveller has to go through a complex inhomogeneous soft material. In doing so, the molecule first passes a crowded head-group region that is still rather aqueous. Then, on a length scale of about a nanometre (as soon as the glycerol backbone is passed), the polarity drops to a value that is close to that found in hydrocarbon liquids. Subsequently, a region with a relatively high orientational order is encountered. Near the centre of the bilayer the order gradually diminishes somewhat. After this, the molecule has to move out again through the other half of the bilayer, encountering the similar regions in reverse order. In short, there are gradients in polarity, in electrostatic potential, in packing
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
87
density and orientational order. Not many molecules can readily cope with all these gradients. In 1899, Overton [121], who, of course, at that time had no conception of the structural complexity of biological membranes, recognised that these provide a barrier to the free diffusion of solutes. From numerous investigations on the osmotic properties of both plant and animal cells [121,122], he found that the permeabilities of membranes to different solutes correlate with the water– octanol partition coefficients of the solutes. The resulting Overton rule, implying that solutes that dissolve well in organic solvents (such as hexane or octanol) can penetrate membranes more rapidly than solutes that are less soluble in such solvents, has been for a long time the most important guideline in physiological studies concerning membrane permeability and related issues (see Figure 27). In more recent years it was found, however, that for small nonelectrolytes (e.g. water, ammonia, formamide) the Overton rule does not hold. Their permeabilities are much higher than predicted from the trends seen for larger molecules, and are inversely proportional to their size [123,124]. The ideas of Overton are reflected in the classical solubility–diffusion model for transmembrane transport. In this model [125,126], the cell membrane and other membranes within the cell are considered as homogeneous phases with sharp boundaries. Transport phenomena are described by Fick’s first law of diffusion, or, in the case of ion transport and a finite membrane potential, by the Nernst–Planck equation (see Chapter 3 of this volume). The driving force of the flux is the gradient of the (electro)chemical potential across the membrane. In the absence of electric fields, the chemical potential gradient is reduced to a concentration gradient. Since the membrane is assumed to be homogeneous, the −1 −2
log P (P in m s−1)
−3 −4 −5 −6 −7 −8 −7
−6
−5
−4
−3
−2
−1
0
log K
Figure 27. Relationship between water–hexadecane partition coefficients and membrane permeabilities for a broad selection of solutes. (Data collected by Walter and Gutknecht [124]. Reproduced with permission from the American Chemical Society)
88
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
concentration profile of the permeant molecule in the membrane is taken to be linear, and the concentration drop going from one side to the other is related to the concentration differences in the solutions at both sides of the membrane, according to the equation: Dcmembrane ¼ KDcw
(13)
with K the water/membrane partition coefficient of the molecule. If any interfacial barriers for the entrance and exit of the membrane are neglected, the permeability P of a solute over the membrane is given by: P¼
KD d
(14)
Here, D is the diffusion coefficient of the solute in the membrane, and d is the thickness of the membrane. In all its simplicity, the above equation shows that both equilibrium and dynamic information is needed for predicting the permeability of biological membranes for particular solutes, and therefore has added value with respect to the Overton rule. The permeation of molecules across membranes, and their distribution in the lipid bilayer are closely related phenomena, but, to describe membrane permeability, knowledge of the diffusive behaviour of the solute in the bilayer must be available as well. Of course, with increasing knowledge of the structure of lipid bilayers and biological membranes, the classical solubility–diffusion model has been refined. The most obvious improvement is to divide the bilayer into different regions (e.g. an inner hydrophobic region and two more hydrophilic outer regions with dielectric properties different to those of the surrounding electrolyte solutions, and with different mobilities for the permeating solutes [127]). Meanwhile, computational methods have reached a level of sophistication that makes them an important complement to experimental work. These methods take into account the inhomogeneities of the bilayer, and present molecular details contrary to the continuum models like the classical solubility– diffusion model. The first solutes for which permeation through (polymeric) membranes was described using MD simulations were small molecules like methane and helium [128]. Soon after this, the passage of biologically more interesting molecules like water and protons [129,130] and sodium and chloride ions [131] over lipid membranes was considered. We will come back to this later in this section.
5.1.1
Equilibrium Aspects: Partitioning
The equilibrium modelling of additives in bilayers is already a challenging task. For example, in MD simulations it is difficult to consider very low loading
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
89
because one can consider only very small systems. Above a certain (still low) concentration of foreign molecules in the bilayer, one should expect serious perturbations of the membrane properties, and the possibility exists that this loading threshold is exceeded by just putting a single foreign molecule in the box. In SCF calculations, one can both investigate the infinite dilution case and study the effects that occur upon increasing the loading. In the former case, the equilibrium membrane properties are not affected, but in the latter one they are. However, for the prediction of partition coefficients from first principles it is necessary that all parameters are known. This situation has not been reached yet. For this reason we can only rely on predictions of trends in partition coefficients for a series of additives in which some parameter is varied systematically. As indicated above, in MD the infinite dilution case cannot be investigated. For hydrophobic small inert units like noble gases, however, it is assumed that their distribution in the bilayer follows the distribution of free volume. An extensive analysis of free-volume-related properties (free-volume fraction, hole size distribution, local order parameters) of the lipid membrane has been given by Marrink et al. [132]. On the basis of MD simulations of a DPPC bilayer, the membrane was divided into four distinct regions with very different free-volume properties, shown in Figure 28. The first region contains the adjacent water layer, the second is the head-group layer, the third comprises the first half of the hydrophobic tails, and the fourth is the centre of the membrane, i.e. the second half of the tails. The largest free-volume fraction is found in the centre of the membrane, with large cavities in which even larger molecules with a diameter of 0.6 nm, like urea, could fit without disturbing the structure. The third region, where the order in the lipid tails is high (cf. the order
Accessible free-volume fraction
0.6
1
2
3
0.5 0.4
4 0.0
3
2
1
0.1
0.3
0.2 0.2
0.28 0.34 0.4 0.6
0.1 0
−2
−1
0
1
2
z / nm
Figure 28. Accessible free-volume fraction profile across a DPPC bilayer for solutes of different sizes (diameters indicated in nm; 0.0 corresponds with the total free volume). Results of Marrink et al. [132]. Redrawn by permission of the American Institute of Physics
90
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
parameter profile for a DMPC bilayer given in Figure 17), has clearly the lowest free-volume fraction, and is therefore considered to represent the largest resistance to the permeation of small solutes. This view is supported by MD simulations [133,134]. Xiang and Anderson [133] investigated the processes to insert noble gases into the bilayer interior. The unfavourable free energy to generate a cavity in the bilayer was analysed by scaled-particle theory, and the interaction energy between the inserted particle and the lipids in the molecule was determined. They found that it was much more difficult to create a cavity in a membrane with oriented lipids than in an isotropic alkane (dodecane), which suggests a model with an anisotropic surface tension at the noble gas–lipid interface. In these MD simulations the alkyl chains were grafted with a harmonic potential to a plane. In a more recent paper [134], they evaluated, from a series of MD simulations on a DPPC bilayer, the contributions of functional groups like CH3 , Cl, OH and COOH to the free energy for transfer of solutes from water to the ordered-chain region of the bilayer. In an experimental study, the same authors [135] systematically explored the effects of permeant size and shape, using as permeants seven monocarboxylic acids with different chain length and chain branching. Deviations of the permeability coefficients found for permeation across DPPC bilayers from the values predicted by solubility– diffusion theory, were found to correlate with the minimum cross-sectional area of the permeants, which was explained as resulting from lipid-chain ordering. The pronounced size-dependency of bilayer permeation by small solutes has also been analysed in terms of the structure and ordering of the lipid-chain region of bilayers by Mitragotri et al. [136], using scaled-particle theory. The partitioning of polar molecules is restricted to the head-group region and typically remains limited. Since the partitioning of lipophilic molecules in the interior of the bilayer is expected to be relatively high, it can be studied in MD simulations with some confidence. For example, in animal cells the cholesterol/ lipid ratio is relatively high and therefore suitable for MD studies. Indeed, there are quite a number of simulation studies on the effect of cholesterol on lipid bilayers (see the review by Ohvo-Rekila¨ et al. [137] and references therein). The rigid steroid ring system of the cholesterol molecules affects the conformations of the acyl chains, and tends to increase the population of trans conformations and decrease the free-volume fraction. Cholesterol contains one hydroxyl group, which gives this otherwise hydrophobic compound its hydrophilic character and ability to partition in hydrogen-bonding, with water molecules or with the lipid carbonyl and phosphate groups [138]. Simulations further show that the introduction of cholesterol allows for a broader distribution of P–N angles in the lipid head groups. This is caused by the relatively low position of cholesterol in the lipid bilayer, leaving holes in the bilayer surface, which are filled by choline N-groups from neighbouring lipids [139]. This leads to rearrangement of water molecules and changes the electrical properties of the
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
91
bilayer/water interface in the sense that the membrane dipole potential increases. An increase in dipole potential with increasing cholesterol content has experimentally been found for egg phosphatidylcholine monolayers [140]. Furthermore, cholesterol decreases the fluidity of membranes by slowing down large-scale rearrangements and reorientational motions. The experimental observation that the permeability of bilayers for small permeants like water decreases with increasing cholesterol content [141], is probably connected with both the tighter packing of the lipid chains, as well as with the slower dynamics. In the literature, one can find many more interesting MD studies concerning lipid bilayers with additives. In particular, a wealth of MD simulations of such systems is in the field of anaesthetics (for a review see [142]). Many anaesthetics tend to accumulate at the membrane/water interface, implying that their potencies are not related to their ability to cross the membrane. Instead, it seems to be more likely that their functioning is via binding to membrane receptors. Generally, they have an effect opposite to that of cholesterol, i.e. they increase the membrane fluidity and permeability. In Section 4.6 we discussed the partitioning of ions in the bilayer as found from SCF calculations. Bilayers possess an internal dipole potential that favours the partitioning of anions over cations (see Figure 16). This is due to the orientation of molecular dipoles at the bilayer interface, lipid head groups and bound water, rendering the hydrocarbon core positive with respect to either aqueous phase. Apolar molecules may preferentially partition in the core of the bilayer, and then the saturation level is potentially high, especially when the additive is able to separate the two halves of the bilayer. Amphiphiles partition in the outer regions of lipid membranes. The effect of charged surfactants on the orientation of the head group of DMPC as determined by SCF calculations has been reported by Meijer et al. [85]. It should be noted, by the way, that strong partitioning of lipophiles or amphiphiles in the core of the bilayer or the bilayer/solution interface, respectively, slow down trans-bilayer transport. Experimentally determined rates of transport of drug molecules have been analysed in terms of the amphiphilicity and lipophilicity of these molecules, by Bala´z˘ [143]. In Figure 29a we show the well-known result that for alkanes the partition coefficient is a strongly increasing function of the molecular weight. (It should be noted, as mentioned earlier, that SCF calculations can only give trends in partition coefficients.) This result can be explained by realising that by partitioning in the bilayer the alkane gains interaction energy, which scales linearly with the chain length DU ¼ NwC, water . However, the transfer of an additive from the water phase to the membrane phase implies a loss of translational entropy. This loss is given by DS ¼ k log K. The free-energy balance DF ¼ DU T DS ¼ 0 gives log K / N. This law is followed as shown in Figure 29a. In Figure 29b three typical absorption isotherms are given near the saturation levels of the alkanes in the DPPC membrane. The results presented in this graph
92
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 8 (a)
(b)
n excN
7
6
log K 5
4
C8 3
2
C24 C4
1 0
5
10
15 N
20
25
0 −0.5
−0.4
−0.3
−0.2
∆m
−0.1
0
0.1
Figure 29. (a) The log of the partition coefficient as a function of the chain length of alkanes CH3 (CH2 )N2 CH3 (at infinite dilution) in DPPC membranes. The CH3 units are modelled as a double bead, similarly to the DPPC lipids. (b) The absorption isotherm of three alkanes in equilibrated DPPC membranes. The excess number of molecules (multiplied by the chain length) is plotted as a function of the chemical potential of the alkane minus the chemical potential of alkane at saturation (binodal) in water
are highly nontrivial. They show that the absorption of both low- and highmolecular-weight alkanes is limited, whereas, for intermediate chain lengths, the amount of alkanes is unbounded at the bulk saturation conditions. For C8 – an intermediate case – the isotherm is smooth. With an increasing concentration of octane, i.e. with increasing chemical potential, the absorbed amount increases. It is expected that long-range van der Waals interactions, not included in the model calculations, will keep the absorbed amount finite, also at coexistence. For C4 the absorbed amount remains very low. The arrow in Figure 29b points to this low value. In fact, this result is rather surprising, because one may argue that short-chain alkanes can easily penetrate between the tails and expand the bilayer, this behaviour being predicted from polymer brush theory [24]. However, butane has two CH3 groups, which are given small, unfavourable interactions with CH2 groups, see Table 1. For this reason, the incorporation of low-molecular-weight alkanes is limited for enthalpic reasons. This mechanism is expected to limit the concentration of additives in membranes in most, if not all, cases. This is because there are always chemical differences between the additives and the acyl chains. The finite absorbed amount for very large alkanes C24 is expected, because the long chains experience a reduction in conformational entropy when they partition inside the finite-sized bilayer. This is an old result already predicted by Gruen [144]. It is also known that a melt of long chains does not penetrate a brush of short chains (at high grafting densities) [24]. The absorption isotherm is nontrivial in this particular case. Before the finite absorbed amount of the C24 alkane at the binodal, indicated by the arrow in Figure 29b, is found, there is a stepwise growth of the absorbed amount. This jump-wise growth means that there is a first-order phase transition taking place in the layer. Such a stepwise growth of absorbed amount may be expected when
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
93
the transition is from a finite absorbed amount to an infinite absorbed amount, which may be generated by changing the temperature, for example, in a firstorder phase transition. Then, the C24 case is just close to such a transition. The unexpected effect is that the step in the isotherm is found for the case that the absorbed amount at coexistence remains finite. This must indicate that there are two mechanisms active on two length scales that should be considered for the control of additive uptake. One of these is the hydrophobic compatibility. The other one is likely to be the ability of the additive to be compatible with the local order in the bilayer. These data have been collected as an example for this review. More work is needed to understand the physics involved here. The authors do not know sufficiently accurate experimental data on absorption isotherms to test the above predictions. In Figure 30, the partition coefficients are given for a series of molecules with equal overall composition, but which differ in architecture. This graph is reproduced from the work of Meijer and co-workers [86]. The key point here is that the partition coefficient is largely determined by the chain composition, but in addition to this there is a weak contribution to how the various groups in the molecule are linked to each other. The additive, which is just designed to show the potential application of the model, has a positive charged N on one side and a negatively charged P group on the other. In addition, there is a C6 group somewhere along the chain, splitting the chain into two fragments. These fragments can be positioned on the chain in an ortho, a meta or a para position, as depicted in Figure 30. All these variables have their effect on the partition coefficient. The partition coefficient is largest when the C6 group is positioned about halfway up the chain, and in particular when the two chain fragments are
1.0⫻107
o m 8.0⫻106
p K 6.0⫻106 +
o
N
1
4.0⫻106
Cn+1
m
Cm+1 −
P
4
p
2.0⫻106
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
n
Figure 30. Partition coefficients for a series of molecules that all have the same overall composition, but in which the architecture is changed systematically. The second chain can either be positioned on the ortho, meta or para position of the C6 -ring
94
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
in the ortho position. This can be understood, because in this way the C6 group can be positioned near the centre of the bilayer, where the order is lowest, while the two charges can still reach the membrane–water surface. The asymmetry with respect to the C6 group being near the positive or negative chain is interesting. As the positive charge in the PC head group is more mobile, it can adjust to accommodate the negative charge on the ring, irrespective of whether it sits in an ortho, meta or para position. However, the restricted phosphate cannot do the same when the positive charge is positioned at the ring. Then the ortho position is particularly unfavourable. 5.1.2
Dynamic Aspects
Study of the dynamic aspects of permeation processes across lipid bilayers from molecular modelling is still in its infancy. As yet, SCF theory has not been developed to deal with dynamics (modelling of steady-state processes is just starting), whereas the MD technique cannot cover the relevant time frame to simulate the full dynamic process of a particular molecule crossing the lipid bilayer. Despite this limitation, permeation processes may be investigated with MD, using indirect methods. For example, Marrink and Berendsen [129] deduced the rate of permeation of water across DPPC membranes via the computation of the free-energy profile and diffusion rate profile across the bilayer. For the head-group region and adjacent water layer, the diffusion rate profile was obtained by determination of the mean squared displacement of the water molecules in a short time interval (1 to 5 ps trajectories). For the interior part of the bilayer, a force-correlation method was used, in which the autocorrelation function of random forces acting on a water molecule (constrained or inserted as a ghost particle, i.e. without disturbing the configuration) is converted into a local friction coefficient x. This friction coefficient is related to the local diffusion coefficient by Einstein’s well-known equation D ¼ kT=x. From the results (depicted in Figure 31), it is concluded that the rate-limiting step is the permeation of the water molecule through the dense, ordered region of the lipid tails. In the centre of the membrane, where the hydrocarbon tails are disordered (comparable with the situation in liquid alkanes), diffusion is fastest. MD simulations of Bassolino-Klimas et al. [145,146] suggest that cavities play a role in the permeation of small solutes across membranes. In these simulations, occasionally large and rapid displacements of a benzene molecule are observed. The benzene molecule is trapped in a cavity, where it undergoes rattling motions, until a pathway opens to another, nearby cavity. This usually requires a rearrangement of the lipid chains, often involving a gauche–trans transition. Jumps from one cavity to another seem to be of particular importance for diffusion through the best-ordered region of the lipid tails, i.e. near the head-group region. Hopping between voids was already proposed by Lieb and Stein [123] on the basis of the size-dependent permeability of small solutes.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
95
⫻10−5 20
1
2
3
4
3
2
1
D/cm2 s–1
15
10
5
0
−2
−1
0
1
2
z / nm
Figure 31. Diffusion coefficient of water in a DPPC bilayer as a function of position. Results of MD simulations of Marrink and Berendsen [129]. Redrawn by permission of the American Chemical Society
Obviously, the availability of large enough cavities decreases strongly with the size of the solute. We have already discussed another explanation of the relationship between permeation rate and solute size, based completely on solubility, i.e. the size-selectivity of solute partitioning in the ordered lipidchain region [133–136]. 5.2
PORE MECHANISM
Experimental results have shown that the solubility–diffusion model is satisfactory for many permeants, but for some solutes it clearly fails. One of the features that will frustrate its applicability is the possibility that thermal fluctuations give rise to the formation of transient water-channels or hydrated pores. The smallest type of short-lived hydrophilic channels may be single strands of hydrogen-bonded water molecules or water threads. When such a channel is somewhat larger, the head groups may also cover the water–tail interface inside the pore. Such a mesoscopic pore can grow to semi-macroscopic size, especially when the membrane is under tension [147]. This mechanism may be considered when the failure of the bilayer under tension is studied. Earlier we discussed the example of such a (stressed) membrane as simulated by DPD [64], where it was shown that surfactants stabilise long-lived pores, giving a mechanism for the toxicity in microorganisms. Mesoscopic pores may in turn provide a mechanism for lipid flip-flop events. Related to the pore mechanism is the process of ion transport over bilayers, as suggested by molecular dynamics simulations by Wilson and Pohorille [131]. These simulations show that permeation of ions into a glycerol 1-monooleate (GMO) bilayer is accompanied by the formation of deep thinning defects in the bilayer, whereby the lipid head groups and water penetrate into the bilayer interior. As the ion passes the mid-plane of the
96
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
membrane, the deformation switches to the other side, and, while the initial defect slowly relaxes, a defect forms in the outgoing side of the bilayer. During the process, the ion remains hydrated. As discussed earlier, lipid bilayers possess an internal dipole potential, which favours the partitioning of anions over cations. Therefore, the solubility– diffusion model predicts lower permeabilities for cations compared with anions [148]. However, in particular for small cations and relatively thin bilayers, the permeability is much higher than predicted on the basis of this model. Back in 1969, Parsegian [149] calculated the free energy of a small cation located in an aqueous pore, and showed that this is significantly lower than in the hydrophobic part of the bilayer, implying a lower diffusion barrier for crossing the bilayer along a water pore. If the pore-mechanism applies, the rate of permeation should be related to the probability at which pores of sufficient size and depth appear in the bilayer. The correlation is given by the semi-empirical model of Hamilton and Kaler [150], which predicts a much stronger dependence on the thickness d of the membrane than the solubility–diffusion model (proportional to exp(–d) instead of the 1/d dependence given in equation (14)). This has been confirmed for potassium by experiments with bilayers composed of lipids with different hydrocarbon chain lengths [148]. The sensitivity to the solute size, however, is in the model of Hamilton and Kaler much less pronounced than in the solubility-diffusion model. A number of MD studies have been published on permeation along water wires, all devoted to proton permeation through bilayers [130,151,152]. This process is a very special case. Experimental studies [153–155] have shown that protons penetrate bilayers at rates five orders of magnitude faster than other monovalent cations. In contrast to the nonmediated transport of other ions, for protons the rate of this process is so high that it is of physiological significance. Protons can diffuse by a special mechanism not applicable for other cations: hopping along hydrogen-bonded strands of water molecules (see, for example, ref. [156] and references therein). One of the first MD studies in which the hypothesis of proton transport through water pores via hopping over a single strand of water molecules was tested, was performed by Marrink et al. [130]. As the observation of spontaneously formed water channels is still far from accessible in MD studies, a strand of water molecules was gradually induced across a DPPC bilayer (64 DPPC and 736 water molecules in the box). From the forces needed to constrain the pore in the bilayer, its free energy of formation was calculated. After lifting the constraints, it was found that the lifetime of the pore before being dispersed is in the order of a few picoseconds, which would be – according to the authors – just long enough to accommodate the transport of a single proton. However, Venable and Pastor [151] argued that this lifetime is too short to demonstrate the feasibility of proton transport along water wires. Their MD simulations on
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
97
a DPPC bilayer, as well as on a crude model system for a lipid bilayer (water/ octane/water sandwich model), suggest much longer lifetimes of water wires, on the 50–100 ps timescale. In both systems a water wire was inserted, preformed in vacuum under cylindrical constraints. Subsequently, the systems were energy-minimised and subjected to 10 ps of MD with restraints to keep the water molecules in the wire. After this, simulations were performed without restraints until the wire dissipated. In a similar way Zahn and Brickmann [152] studied the breaking of water wires in a DLPE bilayer, and they found an average lifetime of about 90 ns. These authors give a rough calculation of the minimum lifetime to allow proton transport over the hydrophobic core of a DLPE bilayer (6.7 ps), based upon the rate of proton transfer from one water molecule to another (1.2 (ps)1) and the number of water molecules in a singlefile water pore long enough to bridge this hydrophobic core (8). The obvious conclusion is that water chains are sufficiently stable to allow proton permeation. Conduction along water wires may as well be the dominant mechanism in the permeation of protons in channels; an MD study of proton transport through a gramicidin channel can be found in, for example, [156]. 5.3
MD MODELLING OF MEDIATED MEMBRANE TRANSPORT
The Holy Grail of membrane modelling is without doubt the modelling of molecular realistic biological membranes, including membrane transport systems or systems with other functionalities (like the photosynthetic reaction centre, the respiratory chain and molecular complexes for recognition). Membrane transport systems comprise pores and channels, which only facilitate downhill or passive transport (i.e. movement towards equilibrium), and carriers and pumps, which are able to perform transport uphill. Pores select their transported substrates according to size, while channels are more selective and characteristically transport ions [157,158]. Ion-selective transmembrane protein channels form dynamic structures that rearrange their structure in response to outer influences, such as changes in ion gradients or electric potential across the membrane, and ligand binding. If the different conformational states are characterised by different ion permeabilities (open and closed states), this is called channel gating. Generally, gating is a complex process, involving various intermediate states [159,160]. A well-known example is the potentialdependent opening and closing of Naþ channels in nerve membranes. Ionselective channels can also be formed by molecules other than proteins. These have very specific properties, like a flexible conformation (so that conformational changes connected to ion transport can occur readily), sufficient length, and a hydrophobic exterior (except at the ends of the channel). A well-known example is gramicidine, a pentadecapeptide, of which two molecules in a b-helix conformation form, head-to-head, a transmembrane channel [161]. Cyclic
98
PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
oligopeptides with a hydrophobic exterior, like the antibiotic valinomycin, are characteristic ion carriers. A general difficulty that is encountered in MD simulations of mediated transmembrane transport is, again, the timescale of relevant processes. For example, the mediated transport of a single ion across a membrane takes tens to hundreds of nanoseconds, and gating transitions several microseconds. Coarse-grained MD simulations do not provide insight into the delicate balance of forces and interactions involved in the transport. Furthermore, to construct a good starting conformation is especially difficult for the simulation of protein– membrane complexes, since structural information on membrane proteins is still sparse [162]. On the nanosecond timescale, simulation results are still sensitive to details of the starting structure of the proteins. Nevertheless, there are many recent papers concerning MD simulations of lipid bilayers containing biomolecules, among these various articles on proteins and oligopeptides forming transmembrane ion channels, reviewed by, amongst others, Biggin and Sansom [163], Feller [164] and Roux [165,166]. These simulations focus on different aspects, like the testing of channel structures, the effect of the lipid bilayer on the structure and vice versa, the dynamics of ion or water transport, and the identification of structurally relevant features that affect this process: e.g. multiple occupancy and gating. The above-mentioned problems have been dealt with (as fully as possible) by using somewhat simpler molecules to model the functioning of membrane proteins, special techniques, or combining MD simulations with other methods (see the review by Feller [164]). For example, helix bundles of (synthetic) channel-forming peptides have been studied as a model for the bilayer-spanning part of membrane proteins [163,167]. We end this section with an example of a recent MD study of Tieleman and co-workers [168] on the selectivity of a bacterial Kþ channel, KcsA, which is formed by a protein. Experimentally, it has been found that the channel is selective for Kþ , but under certain conditions it is possible for Naþ to pass through it. Furthermore, intracellular Naþ can block the channel. In Figure 32, the structure of the channel is depicted. The starting conformation was built using X-ray diffraction data (which have a relatively low resolution of 0.32 nm), and the missing KcsA side-chain coordinates were added by building stereochemically preferred conformers. A number of amino acid residues at the N and C terminal regions were not included in the simulations. The KscA protein was embedded in a preequilibrated POPC bilayer (116 POPCs in the extracellular leaflet, 127 in the intracellular one), hydrated with 9821 water molecules. All ionisable side-chains were in their default ionisation state, and Cl ions were added to have a net charge of zero in the system. Van der Waals and electrostatic interactions were cut off at 1.0 and 1.7 nm, respectively. The duration of the simulations (ca. 2 ns, taking about 20 days of CPU time on eight processors) was an order of
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
99
Figure 32. (a) Overview of the simulation system for the bacterial potassium channel KcsA, as used by Shrivastava et al. [168]. The channel consists of four peptide chains (for clarity in the picture only two are given), and is embedded in a lipid bilayer. The structure can be thought of as being made up of a selectivity filter, a central cavity, and a gate at the inner side of the bilayer. (b) Water molecules and Kþ ions in the selectivity filter; SO represents the extracellular mouth. From [168]. Reproduced by permission of the Biophysical Society
magnitude shorter than the estimated time for an ion to pass through the channel. Therefore, only short time- and length-scale motions can be observed, and the study of ion transport concentrates on the passage through the selectivity-filter part of the channel. Another limitation is that the parameters for ion–filter and ion–water interactions are not accurately known, but the authors checked that the results are not dependent on small changes in these parameters. It was found that the structure of the selectivity filter is somewhat flexible and is distorted by the presence of ions; Kþ ions and water translocate between the binding sites in the filter (in either direction) on a subnanosecond timescale, while Naþ remains bound. The distortion of the filter is significantly larger when the smaller Naþ ion is present. The results clearly correlate with the experimentally observed selectivity of the channel. 6
SUMMARY, CHALLENGES AND OUTLOOK
In this review, we have presented a molecular picture of the lipid bilayer system in relation to its permeation properties, as it appears from simulations and from self-consistent field calculations. Of course, it was not possible to go into all the details. In fact, the practicalities are always much more complicated, and the fine details are only of interest to the experts. The level of detail in this review is sufficient to evaluate the state of the art, at least to some extent. We hope that the previous pages have shown that the molecularly realistic models that have been elaborated on by the various
100 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
computational tools start to give a consistent and transparent picture of the lipid bilayer membranes. The computations can help to interpret experimental findings, and the MD snapshots will further guide our intuition. The MD simulations of molecular detail can give all the information that can be known for a small part of an ideal bilayer for fast processes (on the order of 10 ns). The dynamic aspects that take place on longer timescales can be investigated by coarse-grained methods, or with DPD or quasi-dynamic MC simulations. Due to continuously increasing computer power, the field of MD is gradually moving into larger systems and longer (real-time) scales on the one hand, and more complex, biologically relevant systems, e.g. including additives and functional molecules, on the other. Equilibrium properties are surprisingly accurately predicted by molecularlevel SCF calculations. MC simulations help us to understand why the SCF theory works so well for these densely packed layers. In effect, the high density screens the correlations for chain packing and chain conformation effects to such a large extent that the properties of a single chain in an external field are rather accurate. Cooperative fluctuations, such as undulations, are not included in the SCF approach. Also, undulations cannot easily develop in an MD box. To see undulations, one needs to perform molecularly realistic simulations on very large membrane systems, which are extremely expensive in terms of computation time. One can formulate many challenges for the near future. One of these is to include dynamics in SCF calculations in a convincing way. The advantage of SCF is that the technique is computationally extremely efficient. Therefore it is more easy to sample large parts of the parameter space, and, by doing so, one can understand the regularities of particular problems. Some first initiatives to take the approach into the world of dynamics have already given interesting results, but these approaches have not yet been applied to lipid bilayers. There is also some work under way to analyse off-equilibrium so-called steady-state distributions of molecules that are exposed to some chemical potential gradients. This development will help us understand many aspects that have to do with the semi-permeable properties of the bilayer membranes. The link from lipid properties to mechanical properties of the bilayers is now feasible within the SCF approach. The next step is to understand the phase behaviour of the lipid systems. It is likely that large-scale (3D) SCF-type calculations are needed to prove the conjectures in the field that particular values of the Helfrich parameters are needed for processes like vesicle fusion, etc. In this context, it may also be extremely interesting to see what happens with the mechanical parameters when the system is molecularly complex (i.e. when the system contains many different types of molecules). Then there will be some hope that novel and deep insights may be obtained into the very basic questions behind nature’s choice for the enormous molecular complexity in membrane systems.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
GLOSSARY a a A As BD c.m.c. d DPPC DLPE DMPC DPD DSPC e E f F F int J J0 k kc k K K K l L m M MC MD ni N N Nav p P P PC PG q
Area per molecule, ao equilibrium area (m2 ) Acceleration (m s2 ) Surface area of the system (m2 ) Surface area of membrane (m2 ) Brownian dynamics Critical micellisation concentration (mol m3 ) Thickness of the membrane (m) Dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine Dilauroylphosphatidylethanol Dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine Dissipative particle dynamics Distearoylphosphatidylcholine Elementary charge 1:6 1019 (C) Field strength (V m1 ) Free-energy contribution (J) Helmholtz energy (J) Free energy of interaction (J) Total or mean curvature (m1 ) Spontaneous curvature (m1 ) Boltzmann’s constant 1:38 1023 (J K1 ) Mean bending modulus (J) Saddle splay modulus (J) Gaussian curvature (m2 ) Cluster constant used in water model Water/membrane partition coefficient Length of surfactant tail (m) Length of cylinder (m) Mass of particle (kg) Last layer in lattice used in SCF calculation Monte Carlo Molecular dynamics Number of molecules of type i Number of molecules in system Number of segments in chain Avogadro’s number 6:02 1023 (mol1 ) Pressure (N m2 ) Probability Permeability (m s1 ) Phosphatidylcholine (zwitterionic) Phosphatidylglycerol (negatively charged) Charge (C)
101
102 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
r rij ri R1 , R2 R S S S SCF SOPC t t T U u vA v V V z Z g e0 erA em kD l x ji js c w
Dimensionless radial coordinate Distance between atoms i and j (m) Position of particle number i (m) Radii of curvature (m) Radius of vesicle (m) Surfactant parameter Entropy of the system (J K1 ) Order parameter Self-consistent-field 1-stearoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylcholine Time (s) Ranking number of tail segments Absolute temperature (K) Internal energy of the system (J) Self-consistent (segment) potential (J) Valency of component A Volume of surfactant tail(s) (m3 ) Volume of the system (m3 ) Potential energy in MD simulation (J) Layer number Lattice coordination number Surface tension (J m2 ¼ N m1 ) Dielectric permittivity of vacuum 8:85 1012 (C V1 m1 ) Dielectric permittivity times segment volume of A (C V1 m2 ) Total curvature energy of vesicle (J) Debye length (m) A priori step probability in lattice Membrane persistence length (m) Volume fraction of component i Volume fraction of salt Electrostatic potential (V) Flory–Huggins interaction parameter
REFERENCES 1.
Singer, S. J. and Nicolson, G. L. (1972). The fluid mosaic model of the structure of cell membranes, Science, 175, 720–731. 2. Papahadjopoulos, D., Jacobson, K., Nir, S. and Isac, T. (1973). Phase transitions in phospholipid vesicles fluorescence polarization and permeability measurements concerning the effect of temperature and cholesterol, Biophys. Biochim. Acta, 311, 330–348.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23.
103
Lyklema, J. (1991/1995). Fundamentals of Interface and Colloid Science I–II. Academic Press, London. Tanford, C. (1973). The Hydrophobic Effect: Formation of Micelles and Biological Membranes. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, New York. Besseling, N. A. M. (1993). Statistical Thermodynamics of Fluids with OrientationDependent Interactions. Applications to Water in Homogeneous and Heterogeneous Systems. Ph.D. Thesis, Wageningen University. Besseling, N. A. M. and Scheutjens, J. M. H. M. (1994). Statistical thermodynamics of fluids with orientation-dependent interactions in homogeneous and inhomogeneous systems, J. Phys. Chem., 98, 11 597–11 609. Beaglehole, D. and Wilson, P. (1993). Thickness and anisotropy of the ice–water interface, J. Phys. Chem., 97, 11 053–11 055. Leermakers, F. A. M. and Cohen Stuart, M. A. (1996). Self-consistent-field lattice gas model for the surface ordering transition of n-hexadecane, Phys. Rev. Lett., 76, 82–85. Shaw, D. G. (ed.) (1989). Hydrocarbons with Water and Seawater. Part II: Hydrocarbons C8 to C38. IUPAC Series on Solubility Data, Vol. 38, Pergamon, Oxford. Evans, D. F. and Wennerstrom, H. (1994). The Colloidal Domain Where Physics, Chemistry, Biology and Technology Meet. VCH Publishers, New York. Israelachvilli, J. N., Mitchell, D. J. and Ninham, B. W. (1976). Theory of selfassembly of hydrocarbon amphiphiles into micelles and bilayers, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. II, 72, 1525–1568. Hill, T. L. (1991/1992). Thermodynamics of Small Systems (Part 1; Part 2). Dover Publications, New York. Hall, D. G. and Pethica, B. A. (1976). Nonionic Surfactants. Chapter 16. Marcel Dekker, New York. Lindahl, E. and Edholm, O. (2000). Spatial and energetic–entropic decomposition of surface tension in lipid bilayers from molecular dynamics simulations, J. Chem. Phys., 113, 3882–3893. Marrink, S. J. and Mark, A. E. (2001). Effect of undulations on surface tension in simulated bilayers, J. Phys. Chem., 105, 6122–6127. Oversteegen, S. M., Barneveld, P. A., van Male, J., Leermakers, F. A. M. and Lyklema, J. (1999). Thermodynamic derivation of mechanical expressions for interfacial parameters, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 1, 4987–4494. Gibbs, J. W. (1993). The Scientific Papers, Vol. 1. OxBow Press, Oxford, UK. Helfrich, W. (1973). Elastic properties of lipid bilayers: theory and possible experiments, Z. Naturforsch., 28c, 693–703. Jung, H. T., Coldren, B., Zasadzinski, J. A., Iampietro, D. J. and Kaler, E. W. (2001). The origins of stability of spontaneous vesicles, Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 98, 1353–1357. MacDonald, R. C., Jones, F. D. and Qui, R. (1994). Fragmentation into small vesicles of dioleoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers during freezing and thawing, Biochim. Biophys. Acta–Biomembranes, 1191, 362–370. Seifert, U. and Lipowsky, R. (1995). Morphology of vesicles. In Handbook of Biological Physics. Vol. 1, eds. Lipowsky, R. and Sackmann, E. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 403–460. Safran, S. A., Pincus, P. A., Andelman, D. and MacKintosh, F. C. (1991). Stability and phase behavior of mixed surfactant vesicles, Phys. Rev. A, 43, 1071–1078. Claessens, M. M. A. E., van Oort, B. F., Leermakers, F. A. M., Hoekstra, F. A. and Cohen Stuart, M. A. (2003). Charged lipid vesicles: effects of salts on bending rigidity, stability, and size, submitted to Biophys. J.
104 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39.
40. 41. 42. 43.
de Gennes, P. G. and Taupin, C. (1982). Microemulsions and the flexibility of oil/ water interfaces, J. Phys. Chem., 86, 2294–2304. Helfrich, W. (1990). Elasticity and thermal undulations of fluid films of amphiphiles. In Liquids at Interfaces. eds. Chavrolin, J., Joanny, J. F. and Zinn-Justin, J., Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 209–237. Herve, P., Roux, D., Bellocq, A. M., Nallet, F. and Gulik-Krzywicki, T. (1993). Dilute and concentrated phases of vesicles at thermal equilibrium, J. Phys. II, France, 3, 1255–1270. Simons, B. D. and Cates, M. E. (1992). Vesicles and onion phases in dilute surfactant solutions, J. Phys. II, France, 7, 1439–1451. Hill, T. L. (1986). An Introduction to Statistical Thermodynamics. Dover Publications, New York. Safran, S. A. (1994). Statistical Thermodynamics of Surfaces, Interfaces, and Membranes. Addison Wesley, Reading, UK. Allen, M. P. and Tildesley, D. J. (1987). Computer Simulation of Liquids. Clarendon Press, Oxford. Tieleman, D. P., Marrink, S. J. and Berendsen, H. J. C. (1997). A computer perspective of membranes: molecular dynamics studies of lipid bilayer systems, Biochim. Biophys. Acta-Biomembranes, 1331, 235–270. Scott, H. L. (2002). Modeling the lipid component of membranes, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol., 12, 495–502. Lindahl, E. and Edholm, O. (2000). Mesoscopic undulations and thickness fluctuations in lipid bilayers from molecular dynamics simulations, Biophys. J., 79, 426–433. Zubrzycki, I. Z., Xu, Y., Madrid, M. and Tang, P. (2000). Molecular dynamics simulations of a fully hydrated dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine membrane in liquid-crystalline phase, J. Chem. Phys., 112, 3437–3441. Venable, R. M., Brooks, B. R. and Pastor, R. W. (2000). Molecular dynamics simulations of gel phase lipid bilayers in constant pressure and constant surface area ensembles, J. Chem. Phys., 112, 4822–4832. Tobias, D. J., Tu, K. and Klein, M. L. (1997). Atomic-scale molecular dynamics simulations of lipid membranes, Curr. Opin. Colloid Interf. Sci., 2, 15–26. Pastor, R. W. (1994). Molecular dynamics and Monte Carlo simulations of lipid bilayers, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol., 4, 486–492. Nagle, J. F., Zhang, R., Tristram-Nagle, S., Sun, W. J., Petrache, H. I. and Suter, R. M. (1996). X-ray structure determination of fully hydrated L-alpha phase dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers, Biophys. J., 70, 1419–1431. Hyvonen, M. T., Rantala, T. T. and Ala-Korpela, M. (1997). Structure and dynamic properties of diunsaturated 1-palmitoyl-2-linoleoyl-sn-glycero-3phosphatidylcholine lipid bilayer from molecular dynamics simulation, Biophys. J., 73, 2907–2923. Feller, S. E. and Pastor, R. W. (1999). Constant surface tension simulations of lipid bilayers; the sensitivity of surface areas and compressibilities, J. Chem. Phys., 111, 1281–1287. Chiu, S. W., Clark, M., Balaji, V., Subramaniam, S., Scott, H. L. and Jakobsson, E. (1995). Incorporation of surface tension into molecular dynamics simulation of an interface: a fluid phase lipid bilayer membrane, Biophys. J., 69, 1230–1245. Damodaran, K. V., Merz, K. M. Jr and Gaber, B. P. (1992). Structure and dynamics of the dilauroylphosphatidylethanolamine lipid bilayer, Biochemistry, 31, 7656–7664. Damodaran, K. V. and Merz Jr, K. M. (1994). A comparison of DMPC and DLPE based lipid bilayers, Biophys. J., 66, 1076–1087.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62.
105
Raghavan, K., Reddy, M. R. and Berkowitz, M. L. (1992). A molecular dynamics study of the structure and dynamics of water between dilauroylphosphatidylethanolamine bilayers, Langmuir, 8, 233–240. Perera, L., Essmann, U. and Berkowitz, M. L. (1996). Role of water in the hydration force acting between lipid bilayers, Langmuir, 12, 2625–2629. Lopez Cascales, J. J., Garcia de la Torre, J., Marrink, S. J. and Berendsen, H. J. C. (1996). Molecular dynamics simulation of a charged biological membrane, J. Chem. Phys., 104, 2713–2720. Jorgensen, W. L., Madura, J. D. and Swenson, C. J. (1984). Optimized intermolecular potential functions for liquid hydrocarbons, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 106, 6638–6646. Jorgensen, W. L. and Tirado-Rives, J. (1988). The OPLS potential functions for proteins. Energy minimizations for crystals of cyclic peptides and crambin, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 110, 1657–1666. Tieleman, D. P. and Berendsen, H. J. C. (1996). Molecular dynamics simulations of a fully hydrated dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer with different macroscopic boundary conditions and parameters, J. Chem. Phys., 105, 4871–4880. Berendsen, H. J. C., Postma, J. P. M., Gunsteren, W. F. and Hermans, J. (1981). Intermolecular Forces. Reidel, Dordrecht. Chiu, S. W., Clark, M. M., Jakobsson, E., Subramaniam, S. and Scott, H. L. (1999). Optimization of hydrocarbon chain interaction parameters: application to the simulation of fluid phase lipid bilayers, J. Phys. Chem. B, 103, 6323–6327. van Gunsteren, W. F. and Berendsen, H. J. C. (1987). Groningen Molecular Simulation (GROMOS). Brooks, B. R., Bruccoleri, R. E., Olafson, B. D., States, D. J., Swaminathan, S. and Karplus, M. (1983). CHARMM: a program for macromolecular energy minimization and dynamics calculations, J. Comput. Chem., 4, 187–217. Weiner, S. J., Kollman, P. A., Case, D. A., Singh, U. C., Ghio, C., Alagona, G., Profeta, S. and Weiner, P. (1984). A new force field for molecular mechanical simulation of nucleic acids and proteins, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 106, 765–784. Lemak, A. S. and Balabaev, N. K. (1996). Molecular dynamics simulation of a polymer chain in solution by collisional dynamics method, J. Comput. Chem., 17, 1685–1695. Marrink, S. J., Lindahl, E., Edholm, O. and Mark, A. E. (2001). Simulation of the spontaneous aggregation of phospholipids into bilayers, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 123, 8638–8639. Rand, R. P. and Parsegian, V. A. (1989). Hydration forces between phospholipid bilayers, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 988, 351–376. Berger, O., Edholm, O. and Jahnig F. (1997). Molecular dynamics simulations of a fluid bilayer of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine at full hydration, constant pressure and constant temperature, Biophys. J., 72, 2002–2013. Seelig J. and Seelig A. (1974). Dynamic structure of fatty acyl chains in a phospholipid bilayer measured by DMR, Biochemistry, 13, 4839–4845. Kleijn, J. M. and van Leeuwen, H. P. (2000). Electrostatic and electrodynamic properties of biological interphases. In Physical Chemistry of Biological Interfaces. eds. Baszkin, A. and Norde, W., Marcel Dekker, New York, pp. 49–63. Tu, K., Tobias, D. J. and Klein M. L. (1995). Constant pressure and temperature molecular dynamics simulation of a fully hydrated liquid crystal phase dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer, Biophys. J., 69, 2558–2562. Goetz, R. and Lipowsky, R. (1998). Computer simulations of bilayer membranes; self-assembly and interfacial tension, J. Chem. Phys., 108, 7397–7409.
106 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78.
79. 80. 81.
Smit, B., Hilbers, P. A. J., Esselink, K. Rupert, L. A. M. van Os, N. M. and Schlijper, A. G. (1991). Structure of a water–oil interface in the presence of micelles – a computer-simulation study, J. Phys. Chem., 95, 6361–6368. Groot, R. D. and Rabone, K. L. (2001). Mesoscopic simulation of cell membrane damage, morphology change and rupture by nonionic surfactants, Biophys. J., 81, 725–736. Venturoli, M. and Smit, B. (1999). Simulating the self-assembly of model membranes, Phys. Chem. Comm., 10. Onsager, L. (1996). World scientific series in 20th century physics. In The Collected Works of Lars Onsager. Vol. 17, eds. Hemmer, P. C., Holden H. and Ratkje, S. K., World Scientific Publishing Co., New Jersey. Mu¨ller, M. and Schick, M. (1996). Structure and nucleation of pores in polymeric bilayers; a Monte Carlo simulation, J. Chem. Phys., 105, 8282–8292. Venable, R. M., Zhang, Y. H., Hardy, B. J. and Pastor, R. W. (1998). Molecular dynamics simulations of a lipid bilayer and of hexadecane: an investigation of membrane fluidity, Science, 262, 223–226. Pink, D. A., Green, T. J. and Chapman, D. (1981). Raman scattering in bilayers of saturated phosphatidylcholines and cholesterol. Experiment and theory, Biochemistry, 20, 6692–6698. Mouritsen, O. G. (1991). Theoretical models of phospholipid phase transitions, Chem. Phys. Lipids, 57, 179–194. Sugar, I. P., Thompson, T. E. and Biltonen, R. L. (1999). Monte Carlo simulation of two-component bilayers: DMPC/DSPC mixtures, Biophys. J., 76, 2099–2110. Levine, Y. K., Kolinski, A. and Skolnick, J. (1993). A lattice dynamics study of a Langmuir monolayer of monounsaturated fatty acids, J. Chem. Phys., 98, 7581–7587. Levine, Y. K. (1993). Monte Carlo dynamics study of cis and trans unsaturated hydrocarbon chains, Mol. Phys., 78, 619–628. Rabinovich, A. L. and Ripatti, P. O. (1997). Intramolecular ordering of the bonds of hydrocarbon chains of lipids. Computer simulation, Biophysics, 42, 143–151. Rabinovich, A. L. and Ripatti, P. O. (1997). A theoretical study of the intramolecular ordering of the bonds of cis-octadecene chains, Biophysics, 42, 879–887. Rabinovich, A. L. and Ripatti, P. O. (1997). A theoretical study of the intramolecular ordering of the bonds of trans-octadecene chains, Biophysics, 42, 889–895. Fraaije, J. G. E. M. (1993). Dynamic density functional theory for microphase separation kinetics of block copolymer melts, J. Chem. Phys., 99, 9202–9212. van Vlimmeren, B. A. C., Maurits, N. M., Zvelindovsky, A. V., Sevink, G. J. A. and Fraaije, J. G. E. M. (1999). Simulation of 3D mesoscale structure formation in concentrated aqueous solution of the triblock polymer surfactants (ethylene oxide) 13(propylene oxide)30(ethylene oxide)13 and (propylene oxide)19(ethylene oxide)33(propylene oxide)19. Application of dynamic mean-field density functional theory, Macromolecules, 32, 646–656. Chandler, D. (1987). Introduction to Statistical Thermodynamics. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Leermakers, F. A. M., Scheutjens, J. M. H. M. and Lyklema, J. (1990). Statistical thermodynamics of association colloids. IV. Inhomogeneous membrane system, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1024, 139–151. Evers, O. A., Scheutjens, J. M. H. M. and Fleer, G. J. (1990). Statistical thermodynamics of block copolymer adsorption. 1. Formulation of the model and results for the adsorbed layer structure, Macromolecules, 23, 5221–5233.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN 82. 83. 84. 85. 86.
87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99. 100. 101. 102.
107
Guerin, C. B. E. and Szleifer, I. (1999). Self-assembly of model nonionic amphiphilic molecules, Langmuir, 15, 7901–7911. Meijer, L. A. and Leermakers, F. A. M. (1998). GOLIATH: Self-Consistent Field Implementation Dedicated to Self-Assembly. Wageningen University. Meijer, L. A., Leermakers, F. A. M. and Lyklema, J. (1994). Head-group conformations in lipid bilayer membranes, Recl. Trav. Chim. Pays-Bas, 113, 167–175. Meijer, L. A., Leermakers, F. A. M. and Lyklema, J. (1995). Modeling the interactions between phospholipid bilayer membranes with and without additives, J. Phys. Chem., 99, 17 282–17 293. Meijer, L. A., Leermakers, F. A. M. and Lyklema, J. (1999). Self-consistent-field modeling of complex molecules with united atom detail in inhomogeneous systems. Cyclic and branched foreign molecules in dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine membranes, J. Chem. Phys., 110, 6560–6579. Gruen, D. W. R. (1980). A statistical mechanical model of the lipid bilayer above its phase transition, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 595, 161–183. Cantor, R. S. and Dill, K. A. (1986). Theory for the equation of state of phospholipid monolayers, Langmuir, 2, 331–337. Szleifer, I., Ben-Shaul, A. and Gelbart, W. M. (1986). Chain statistics in micelles and bilayers: effects of surface roughness and internal energy, J. Chem. Phys., 85, 5345–5358. Ben-Shaul, A. and Gelbart, W. M. (1994). Statistical Thermodynamics of Amphiphile Self-assembly: Structure and Phase Transitions in Micellar Solutions. Chapter 1. Springer, Berlin. Dill, K. A., Naghizadeh, J. and Marqusee, J. A. (1988). Chain molecules at high densities at interfaces, Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem., 39, 425–461. Leermakers, F. A. M., Scheutjens, J. M. H. M. and Lyklema, J. (1983). On the statistical thermodynamics of membrane formation, Biophys. Chem., 18, 353–360. Marcˇelja, S. (1974). Chain ordering in liquid crystals. II. Structure of bilayer membranes, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 367, 165–176. Amoskov, V. M. and Birshtein, T. M. (2000). Homeotropic and planar structures in liquid-crystalline polymer brushes, Vysomolekul. Soedin. A B, 42, 612–626. Leermakers, F. A. M. and Scheutjens, J. M. H. M. (1988). Statistical thermodynamics of association colloids. III. The gel to liquid phase transition of lipid bilayer membranes, J. Chem. Phys., 89, 6912–6924. Szleifer, I., Ben-Shaul, A. and Gelbart, W. M. (1990). Chain packing statistics and thermodynamics of amphiphile monolayers, J. Phys. Chem., 94, 5081–5089. Leermakers, F. A. M. and Scheutjens, J. M. H. M. (1990). Statistical thermodynamics of association colloids. V. Critical micelle concentration, micellar size and shape, J. Coll. Interf. Sci., 136, 231–241. Leermakers, F. A. M. and Scheutjens, J. M. H. M. Statistical thermodynamics of association colloids. I. Lipid bilayer membranes, J. Chem. Phys., 89, 3264–3274. Hauser, H., Pascher, I., Pearson, R. H. and Sundell, S. (1981). Preferred conformation and molecular packing of phophatidylethanolamine and phosphatidyl choline, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 650, 21–51. Cantor, R. S. (1999). Lipid composition and the lateral pressure profile in bilayers, Biophys. J., 76, 2625–2639. Oversteegen, S. M. and Leermakers, F. A. M. (2000). Thermodynamics and mechanics of bilayer membranes, Phys. Rev. E, 62, 8453–8461. Rabinovich, A. L., Ripatti, P. O., Balabaev, N. K. and Leermakers, F. A. M. (2003). Molecular dynamics simulations of hydrated unsaturated lipid bilayers in
108 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
103.
104. 105. 106. 107. 108. 109. 110.
111. 112. 113. 114. 115. 116. 117. 118. 119.
the liquid-crystal phase and comparison to self-consistent field modeling, Phys. Rev. E, 67, 011909. Leermakers, F. A. M., Rabinovich, A. L. and Balabaev, N. K. (2003). Selfconsistent field modeling of hydrated unsaturated lipid bilayers in the liquidcrystal phase and comparison to molecular dynamics simulations, Phys. Rev. E, 67, 011910. Rabinovich A. L. and Ripatti, P. O. (1991). On the conformational, physical properties and functions of polyunsaturated acyl chains, Biochim. Biophys. Acta-Lipid. Metabol., 1085, 53–62. Fattal, D. R. and Ben-Shaul, A. (1994). Mean-field calculations of chain packing and conformational statistics in lipid bilayers: comparison with experiments and molecular dynamics studies, Biophys. J., 67, 983–995. Heller, H., Schaefer, M. and Schulten, K. (1993). Molecular dynamics simulation of a bilayer of 200 lipids in the gel and in the liquid-crystal phases, J. Phys. Chem., 97, 8343–8359. Rawicz, W., Olbrich, K. C., McIntosh, T., Needham, D. and Evans, E. (2000). Effect of chain length and unsaturation on elasticity of lipid bilayers, Biophys. J., 79, 328–339. Tu, K., Tobias, D. J., Blasie, J. K. and Klein, M. L. (1996). Molecular dynamics investigation of the structure of a fully hydrated gel-phase dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer, Biophys. J., 70, 595–608. Nagle, J. F. (1980). Theory of the main lipid bilayer phase transition, Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem., 31, 157–195. Marsh, D. (1991). Analysis of the chainlength dependence of lipid phase transition temperatures: main and pretransitions of phosphatidylcholines; main and non-lamellar transitions of phosphatidylethanolamines, Biochem. Biophys. Acta– Biomembranes, 1062, 1–6. Schmid, F. and Schick, M. (1995). Liquid phases of Langmuir monolayers, J. Chem. Phys., 102, 2080–2091. Den Otter, W. K. and Briels, W. J. (2003). The bending rigidity of an amphiphilic bilayer from equilibrium and nonequilibrium molecular dynamics, J. Chem. Phys., 118, 4712–4720. Baumgartner, A. (1994). Asymmetries of a curved bilayer model membrane, J. Chem. Phys., 101, 9060–9062. Leermakers, F. A. M. and Scheutjens, J. M. H. M. (1989). Statistical thermodynamics of association colloids. II. Lipid vesicles, J. Chem. Phys., 93, 7417–7426. Love, A. E. H. (1907). Lehrbuch der Elastizita¨t. Teubner Verlag, Wiesbaden, Germany. Szleifer, I., Kramer, D., Ben-Shaul, A., Roux, D. and Gelbart, W. M. (1988). Curvature elasticity of pure and mixed surfactant films, Phys. Rev. Lett., 60, 1966–1969. Lekkerkerker, H. N. W. (1990). The electric contribution to the curvature elastic moduli of charged fluid interfaces, Physica A, 167, 384–394. Helfrich, W. (1995). Handbook of Biological Physics. Tension-Induced Mutual Adhesion and a Conjectured Superstructure of Lipid Membranes. Chapter 14. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Zhulina, E. B., Borisov, O. V., van Male, J. and Leermakers, F. A. M. (2001). Adsorption of tethered polyelectrolytes onto oppositely charged solid–liquid interfaces, Langmuir, 17, 1277–1293.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
109
120. Borisov, O. V., Leermakers, F. A. M., Fleer, G. J. and Zhulina, E. B. (2001). Polyelectrolytes tethered to a similarly charged surface, J. Chem. Phys., 114, 7700–7712. ¨ ber die allgemeinen osmotischen Eigenschaften der Zell, ihre 121. Overton, E. (1899). U vermutliche Ursachen und ihre Bedeutung fu¨r die Physiologie, Vierteljahrsschr. Naturforsch. Ges. Zuerich, 44, 88–114. ¨ ber die osmotischen Eigenschaften der lebenden 122. Overton, E. (1895). U Pflanzen und Tierzelles, Vierteljahrsschr. Naturforsch. Ges. Zuerich, 40, 159–201, 1895. 123. Lieb, W. R. and Stein, W. D. (1969). Biological membranes behave as non-porous polymer sheets with the respect to the diffusion of non-electrolytes, Nature, 224, 240–243. 124. Walter, A. and Gutknecht, J. (1986). Permeability of small nonelectrolytes through lipid bilayer membranes, J. Membr. Biol., 90, 207–218. 125. Hanai, T. and Dayton, D. A. (1966). The permeability to water of bimolecular lipid membranes, J. Theor. Biol., 11, 1370. 126. Finkelstein, A. and Cass, A. (1967). Effect of cholesterol on the water permeability of thin lipid membranes, Nature, 216, 717–718. 127. Aguilella, V., Belaya, M. and Levadny, V. (1996). Ion permeability of a membrane with soft polar interfaces. 1. The hydrophobic layer as the rate-determining step, Langmuir, 12, 4817–4827. 128. Sok, R. M., Berendsen, H. J. C. and van Gunsteren, W. F. (1992). Molecular dynamics simulation of the transport of small molecules across a polymer membrane, J. Chem. Phys., 96, 4699–4704. 129. Marrink, S. J. and Berendsen, H. J. C. (1994). Simulation of water transport through a lipid membrane, J. Phys. Chem., 98, 4155–4168. 130. Marrink, S. J., Ja¨hnig, F. and Berendsen, H. J. C. (1996). Proton transport across transient single-file water pores in a lipid membrane studied by molecular dynamics simulations, Biophys. J., 71, 632–647. 131. Wilson, M. A. and Pohorille, A. (1996). Mechanism of unassisted ion transport across membrane bilayers, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 118, 6580–6587. 132. Marrink, S. J., Sok, R. M. and Berendsen, H. J. C. (1996). Free volume properties of a simulated membrane, J. Chem. Phys., 104, 9090–9099. 133. Xiang, T. X. and Anderson, B. D. (1999). Molecular dissolution processes in lipid bilayers: a molecular dynamics simulation, J. Chem. Phys., 110, 1807–1818. 134. Xiang, T. X. and Anderson, B. D. (2002). A computer simulation of functional group contributions to free energy in water and a DPPC lipid bilayer, Biophys. J., 82, 2052–2066. 135. Xiang, T. X. and Anderson, B. D. (1998). Influence of chain ordering on the selectivity of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer membranes for permeant size and shape, Biophys. J., 75, 2658–2671. 136. Mitragotri, S., Johnson, M. E., Blankschtein, D. and Langer, R. (1999). An analysis of size selectivity of solute partitioning, diffusion, and permeation across lipid bilayers, Biophys. J., 77, 1268–1283. 137. Ohvo-Rekila¨, H., Ramstedt, B., Leppima¨ki, P. and Slotte, J. P. (2002). Cholesterol interactions with phospholipids in membranes, Progr. Lipid Res., 41, 66–97. 138. Robinson, A. J., Richards, W. G., Thomas, P. J. and Hann, M. M. (1995). Behavior of cholesterol and its effect on head group and chain conformations in lipid bilayers: a molecular dynamics study, Biophys. J., 68, 164–170.
110 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 139. Tu, K., Klein, M. L. and Tobias, D. J. (1998). Constant-pressure molecular dynamics investigation of cholesterol effects in a dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer, Biophys. J., 75, 2147–2156. 140. McIntosh, T. J., Magid, A. D. and Simon, S. A. (1989). Cholesterol modifies the short-range repulsive interactions between phosphatidylcholine membranes, Biochemistry, 28, 17–25. 141. Fettiplace, R. and Haydon, D. A. (1980). Water permeability of lipid membranes, Physiol. Rev., 60, 510–550. 142. Pohorille, A., New, M. H., Schweighofer, K. and Wilson, M. A. (1999). Insights from computer simulations into the interactions of small molecules with lipid bilayers. In Membrane Permeability, Vol. 48: 100 Years Since Ernest Overton. eds. Deamer, D. W., Kleinzeller, A. and Fambrough, D. M., Academic Press, San Diego pp. 50–76. 143. Bala´zˇ, S. (2000). Lipophilicity in trans-bilayer transport and subcellular pharmacokinetics, Persp. Drug Discov. Des., 19, 157–177. 144. Gruen, D. W. R. and Haydon, D. A. (1981). A mean-field model of the alkanesaturated lipid bilayer above its phase transition. II. Results and comparison with experiment, Biophys. J., 33, 167–188. 145. Bassolino-Klimas, D., Alper, H. E. and Stouch, T. R. (1993). Solute diffusion in lipid bilayer membranes: an atomic level study by molecular dynamics simulation, Biochemistry, 32, 12 624–12 637. 146. Bassolino-Klimas, D., Alper, H. E. and Stouch, T. R. (1995). Mechanism of solute diffusion through lipid bilayer membranes by molecular dynamics simulation, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 117, 4118–4129. 147. Sandre, O., Moreaux, L. and Brochard-Wyart, F. (1999). Dynamics of transient pores in stretched vesicles, Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 96, 10 591–10 596. 148. Paula, S., Volkov, A. G., van Hoek, A. N., Haines, T. H. and Deamer, D. W. (1996). Permeation of protons, potassium ions, and small polar solutes through phospholipid bilayers as a function of membrane thickness, Biophys. J., 70, 339–348. 149. Parsegian, A. (1969). Energy of an ion crossing a low dielectric membrane: solutions to four relevant electrostatic problems, Nature, 221, 844–846. 150. Hamilton, R. T. and Kaler, E. W. (1990). Alkali metal ion transport through thin bilayers, J. Phys. Chem., 94, 2560–2566. 151. Venable, R. M., and Pastor, R. W. (2002). Molecular dynamics simulations of water wires in a lipid bilayer and water/octane model systems, J. Chem. Phys., 116, 2663–2664. 152. Zahn, D. and Brickmann, R. (2002). Molecular dynamics study of water pores in a phospholipid bilayer, Chem. Phys. Lett., 352, 441–446. 153. Nichols, J. W. and Deamer, D. W. (1980). Net proton hydroxyl permeability of large unilamellar liposomes measured by an acid–base titration technique, Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 77, 2038–2042. 154. Elamrami, K. and Blume, A. (1983). Effect of lipid phase transition on the kinetics of Hþ/OH diffusion across phosphatidic acid bilayers, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 727, 22–30. 155. Perkins, W. R. and Cafiso, D. S. (1986). An electrical and structural characterization of Hþ/OH currents in phospholipid vesicles, Biochemistry, 25, 2270–2276. 156. Pome`s, R. and Roux, B. (2002). Molecular mechanism of Hþ conduction in the single-file water chain of the gramicidin channel, Biophys. J., 82, 2304–2316.
F. A. M. LEERMAKERS AND J. M. KLEIJN
111
157. Post, R. L. (1999). Active transport and pumps. In Membrane Permeability: Vol. 48 100 Years Since Ernest Overton. eds. Deamer, D. W., Kleinzeller, A. and Fambrough, D. M. Academic Press, San Diego pp. 397–417. 158. Eisenberg, B. (1998). Ionic channels in biological membranes: natural nanotubes, Acc. Chem. Res., 31, 117–123. 159. Honig, B. H., Hubbell, W. L. and Flewelling, R. F. (1986). Electrostatic interactions in membranes and proteins, Ann. Rev. Biophys. Biochem., 15, 163–193. 160. Schulze, K. D. (1994). Investigations of the channel gating influence on the dynamics of biomembranes, Z. Phys. Chem., 186, 47–63. 161. Arseniev, A. S., Barsukov, I. L., Bystrov, V. F., Lomize, A. L. and Ovchinnikov, Y. A. (1985). 1H-NMR study of gramicidin-A transmembrane ion channel: headto-head right handed single stranded helices, FEBS Lett., 186, 168–174. 162. Werten, P. J. L., Re´migy, H. W., de Groot, B. L., Fotiadis, D., Philippsen, A., Stahlberg, H., Grubmu¨ller, H. and Engel, A. (2002). Progress in the analysis of membrane protein structure and function, FEBS Lett., 529, 65–72. 163. Biggin, P. C. and Sansom, M. S. P. (1999). Interactions of a-helices with lipid bilayers: a review of simulation studies, Biophys. Chem., 76, 161–183. 164. Feller, S. E. (2000). Molecular dynamics simulations of lipid bilayers, Curr. Opin. Coll. Interf. Sci., 5, 217–223. 165. Roux, B. (2002). Theoretical and computational models of ion channels, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol., 12, 182–189. 166. Roux, B. (2002). Computational studies of the gramicidin channel, Acc. Chem. Res., 35, 366–375. 167. Law, R. J., Tieleman, D. P. and Sansom, M. S. P. (2003). Pores formed by the nicotinic receptor M2d peptide: a molecular dynamics simulation study, Biophys. J., 84, 14–27. 168. Shrivastava, I. H., Tieleman, D. P., Biggin, P. C. and Sansom, M. S. P. (2003). Kþ versus Naþ ions in a K channel selectivity filter: a simulation study, Biophys. J., 83, 633–645.
3 Biointerfaces and Mass Transfer HERMAN P. VAN LEEUWEN Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Colloid Science, Wageningen University, Dreijenplein 6, NL-6703 HB Wageningen, The Netherlands
JOSEP GALCERAN Departament de Quı´mica, Universitat de Lleida, Av. Rovira Roure 191, 25198 Lleida, Spain
1 2
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Organism–Medium Interphase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1 Physicochemical Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 Ionic Distributions at Biological Interphases . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 Electrodynamics of Biological Interphases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 General Mass Transfer Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 Conservation Laws and the Nernst–Planck Equation. . . . . . 3.2 Boundary Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 The Impact of Geometry. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Transient and Steady-State Conditions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5 Diffusion in Composite Media . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Convective Diffusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 Convective Diffusion from an Unbounded Laminarly Flowing Liquid to a Planar Surface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Convective Diffusion from a Channelled Laminarly Flowing Liquid. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 Convective Diffusion from a Liquid to a Moving Spherical Body . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Glossary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . List of Symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Superscripts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Subscripts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Latin Symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Greek Symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Physicochemical Kinetics and Transport at Biointerfaces Edited by H. P. van Leeuwen and W. Ko¨ster. ß 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
114 115 115 117 120 122 122 124 125 125 127 129 130 135 137 141 141 141 142 142 143 143
114 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
1
INTRODUCTION
Life has evolved in media with colourful chemical composition, under a variety of physical conditions, which include temperature, pressure and their gradients (see Chapter 1 of this volume). Evolution implies an optimisation of the functioning of organisms with respect to the physical and chemical conditions in which they live. Likewise, a change of conditions will give rise to a change in the properties of the organism, and this is known as adaptation. The chemical conditions relevant to evolution, adaptation and survival do not only comprise the composition and the chemical dynamics of the medium in which the organism is living. More generally, it is the operational availability of the various chemical species that determines their effect. In general terms, the availability of chemicals is defined by a number of basic features: . the chemical availability as derived from equilibrium distributions of species and their rates of interconversion; . the supply of these chemical species to the relevant sites at the surface of the organism; and . the actual internalisation of the chemical species by the organism, usually followed by some bioconversion process. The second feature is largely concerned with mass transfer of chemicals from the medium to the biosurface or back. It generally involves diffusion (transport due to a concentration gradient), flow (transport due to a pressure gradient), and sometimes also conduction (transport due to an electric potential gradient). Organisms may be actively involved in the efficient organisation of transport processes. This may be realised, for example, by the creation of flow via their own motility, or by tuning the physical structure of their active uptake surface to the transport conditions. This chapter deals with the basic principles of mass transfer, and their application to the specific case of transport to/from biological surfaces. It will do so after an appropriate characterisation of the physicochemical features of the biological interphase between an organism and an aqueous medium. The origin and nature of chemical gradients and ionic distributions near the biointerphase will be outlined, with special emphasis on electric double layers, diffusion layers, and their dimensional and dynamic properties. The mathematical formulation of mass transport processes is derived from basic conservation laws, which include conservation of mass and conservation of momentum. Their application to the mass transport situation, with simultaneous gradients in pressure, concentration and electric potential leads to the well-known Nernst–Planck equation, which comprises individual recognisable terms for diffusion, flow and conduction. The elaboration of this fundamental equation to practical biouptake situations calls for explicit consideration of such aspects
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
115
as the geometrical conditions and the distinction between transient and steadystate transport situations. The combination of flow and diffusion is especially important in many practical transport situations, so, by way of illustration and implementation of the basic equations, some cases of convective diffusion are dealt with, such as diffusion towards planar active surfaces or moving spherical organisms. More pertinent elaboration on the resulting biouptake fluxes can be found in Chapters 4 and 10 of this volume.
2
THE ORGANISM–MEDIUM INTERPHASE
Quite generally, the interphase between an organism and its environment encompasses the elements outlined in Figure 1 of Chapter 1. The scheme shows that the cell membrane, with its hydrophobic lipid bilayer core, has the most prominent function in separating the external aqueous medium from the interior of the cell. The limited and selective permeabilities of the cell membrane towards components of the medium – nutrients as well as toxic species – play a governing role in the transport of material from the medium towards the surface of the organism. While the lipid bilayer has a very low water content, and therefore behaves quite hydrophobically, especially in its core (see Chapter 2 of this volume), the cell wall is rather hydrophilic, with some 90% of water. Physicochemically, the cell wall is particularly relevant because of its high ion binding capacity and the ensuing impact on the biointerphasial electric double layer. Due to the presence of such an electric double layer, the cell wall possesses Donnan-like features, leaving only a limited part of the interphasial potential decay in the diffuse double layer in the adjacent medium. For a detailed outline, the reader is referred to recent overviews of the subject matter [1,2]. Mass transport phenomena usually are effective on distance scales much larger than cell wall and double layer dimensions. Thicknesses of steady-state diffusion layers in mildly stirred systems are in the order of 105 m. Thus one may generally adopt a picture where the local interphasial properties define the boundary conditions, while the actual mass transfer processes take place on a much larger spatial scale. 2.1
PHYSICOCHEMICAL CHARACTERISTICS
The chemical and structural features of the membrane and cell wall are extensively discussed elsewhere in this volume (see Chapters 2, 6, 7 and 10). They usually contain numerous charged groups, which, as far as they are not internally compensated by counterions, give rise to the formation of an electric double layer at the interphase. The net charge of membrane surface plus cell wall is counterbalanced by a diffuse charge with opposite sign. This so-called diffuse
116 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
double layer extends into the medium over a distance depending on the electrolyte concentration. In aqueous systems of low salt concentration, for example, rivers and lakes, the diffuse countercharge around the cell wall of a microorganism may extend over distances of the order of 10 nm, whereas, in more saline systems, such as seawater and most body fluids, the compensating charge will be situated at distances less than a nanometre. The charge on bacterial cell walls mostly originates from carboxylic, phosphate and amino groups [1,3,4]. The degree of protonation of these anionic and cationic groups is determined by the pH and the ionic composition of the medium. At neutral pH, almost all bacterial cells are negatively charged, because the number of deprotonated carboxylate and phosphate groups is generally higher than that of the protonated amino groups. The compensating charge mainly consists of (positive) counterions that penetrate the porous wall, and, to a minor extent, of (negative) co-ions that tend to be expelled from it. The thickness of bacterial cell walls is in the range of several tens of nanometres [4]. Electrostatic fields associated with biomembranes arise from several sources. The net charge on the membrane generates a potential at the surface relative to the bulk aqueous phase (the surface or double layer potential). This charge resides in the outer parts of the membrane and arises from charged head groups of phospholipids, adsorbed and penetrated ions, and proteins. It is dependent on the pH and ionic composition of the medium, and should be considered in conjunction with the charges in the cell-wall layer. In the hydrophobic core of the membrane, the net charge density is essentially zero. In most biological systems the double layer potential of membranes is negative, owing to the predominance of negatively charged lipids. These typically constitute 10–20% of the effective lipid area of the membrane (about 0:02 C m2 [5–7], corresponding with about one elementary charge per 10 nm2 ). Furthermore, most of the membrane proteins have isoelectric points below pH 7. Altogether, this results in z-potentials (i.e. potentials in the electrokinetic slip plane, that is, the outer boundary of the hydrodynamic stagnant layer at the surface, usually some tenths of a nm thick) of 8 to 30 mV [5,7]. Internal membrane potentials are due to the inhomogeneous distribution of charges within the membrane. Lipid bilayers possess a substantial dipole potential arising from the structural organisation of dipolar groups and molecules. These groups are oriented in such a way that the hydrocarbon phase is positive with respect to the outer membrane regions. The magnitude of the dipolar potential is usually large, typically several hundreds of millivolts [5,7,8]. Other internal potentials arise from membrane asymmetry, including differences in adsorption at the two sides of the membrane, and from differences in penetration of ions (see Chapter 2 of this volume). Finally, separation of charge across the membrane gives rise to a transmembrane potential. The transmembrane potential is defined as the electric potential
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
117
difference between the bulk phases at the two sides of the membrane, and results from selective transport of charged species across the membrane. In biological systems it is typically of the order of 10 to 100 mV [6,7]. As a rule, the potential at the cytoplasm side of cell membranes is negative relative to the extracellular physiological solution. The issues of ion permeation and transmembrane potential recur in other chapters of this volume (2, 6 and 10) Typical values for the dimensions of the various layers are included in Figure 1 of Chapter 1. Diffusion layer thicknesses depend on the timescale and hydrodynamic conditions; they will be dealt with in detail in Sections 3 and 4. 2.2
IONIC DISTRIBUTIONS AT BIOLOGICAL INTERPHASES
In the electrochemical literature one finds the Gouy–Chapman (GC) and Gouy–Chapman–Stern (GCS) approaches as standard models for the electric double layer [9,10]. According to the Gouy–Chapman model, the thickness of the diffuse countercharge atmosphere in the medium (diffuse double layer) is characterised by the Debye length k1 , which depends on the electrostatic properties of the medium: qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi k1 ¼ ee0 RT =2F 2 z2 c (1) where F stands for the Faraday constant, c is the concentration of the (supposedly symmetrical) electrolyte, z the ionic charge number (z ¼ zþ ¼ z ) and ee0 the permittivity. Typical values for k1 are 1 nm for 0:1 mol dm3 1–1 electrolyte and 10 nm for 103 mol dm3 1–1 electrolyte. In the diffuse part of the double layer, the profile of the electrical Volta potential c [10] is given by an exponential decay function, with k as the mathematical argument: c ¼ c0 exp ( kx)
(2)
where c0 is the electrical potential at the surface. The quantity ee0 k is the capacitance Cd of the diffuse double layer. The applicability of GC and GCS models to biological systems is limited because they completely ignore the interphasial structure with its spatial distribution of charged sites, counterions and co-ions. Nevertheless, in a number of cases, GCS adequately describes the dependence of potential on distance at a lipid membrane surface [11–13]. An obvious first attempt to take into account the three-dimensional distribution of charges in the interphase is to extend the double layer model with a Donnan layer. A Donnan layer contains a number of fixed charges and is accessible for water and dissolved ions. For a biological interphase, the Donnan layer would encompass the head-group charges of
118 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
the membrane lipids, the ionisable sites in the cell-wall layer, and part of the countercharge. The countercharge is generally distributed over the Donnan layer and the diffuse layer, the distribution ratio being dependent on the electrolyte concentration in the medium. A theoretical derivation of the potential in a system with a combination of a Donnan layer and a diffuse layer has been given by Ohshima and Kondo [14–17]. The basic step is to write Poisson’s equation in terms of all relevant charge carriers. For the Donnan layer, it reads: d2 c r þ re ¼ w eD e0 dx2
(3)
where rw represents the space charge density due to the lipid head groups and the charged groups of the cell wall, re that of the electrolyte ions and eD is the relative permittivity of the Donnan layer phase (see Figure 1). For the adjacent diffuse layer in the aqueous phase, the GC approach is maintained. The potential profile can be derived if rw is taken as constant for any x and the distribution of ions that generates re follows a simplified solution of the Poisson–Boltzmann equation [14,17]. Using the continuity of potential and potential gradient across the interphase and taking eD as identical to the relative permittivity e in the surrounding medium, Ohshima and Kondo [17] found: cDm ¼ cD
RT zF cD tanh zF 2RT
(4)
where cDm is the potential at the boundary between the Donnan layer and the medium, and cD is the Donnan potential, corresponding with the limiting situation of the pure Donnan profile (no diffuse layer at all): cD ¼
RT r sinh1 w 2zFc zF
(5)
The expression for the potential variation with x within the Donnan phase is approximated by [17]: h i1=4 2 x c(x < 0) ¼ cD þ ðcDm cD Þ exp k 1 þ ðrw =2zFcÞ
(6)
where k1 is the Debye length given by equation (1). Figure 1 shows a set of calculated potential profiles for different electrolyte concentrations. For each curve, the asymptotic value on the left is cD , while the intercept with ordinates is cDm . For large c, the profile approaches the step functionality of the pure Donnan model. Note that for low potentials, the ratio
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN −10
−5
119
x / nm 0
0
5
c = 0.2 mol dm−3 −2
c = 0.1 mol dm−3 c = 0.05 mol dm−3
−4
y / mV
−6
−8 c = 0.02 mol dm−3 −10
−12 c = 0.01 mol dm−3 −14
Figure 1. Potential profile c(x) across the cell wall (x < 0) according to the simplified expression (6) from the Ohshima and Kondo model [15]. The profile within the solution (x > 0) is assumed to follow the usual GC decay expression c ¼ cDm exp ( kx) (equation (2)). Parameters: T ¼ 298 K, z ¼ þ1, e ¼ 78:5, thickness of the Donnan layer ¼ 10 nm, rw ¼ 1447 C dm3 . Curves correspond with c ¼ 0:2, 0:1, 0:05, 0:02 and 0:01 mol dm3
cDm =cD tends to 1/2 according to equation (4). The diffuse double layer potential is lower than in the pure GC model, because part of the ‘fixed’ charge is already compensated within the Donnan layer phase. In the Ohshima-modified Donnan approach it is assumed that the distribution of fixed charges in the Donnan layer, rw , is homogeneous and that the thickness of this layer is larger than k1 , resulting in an exponential variation of the potential in the interphase. This feature makes the Ohshima-modified Donnan approach primarily suitable for describing the double layer at the cell wall–solution interface, and less appropriate for the lipid bilayer membrane. For the construction of the full electric potential profile of a biological interphase, the preceding approach is a good starting point. It divides the interphase into different regions, each with its own thickness, permittivity, and fixed charge density, and applies a Poisson–Boltzmann type of approach. At all boundaries between distinguishable layers, we have the Gaussian conditions of continuity, taking into account the differences in permittivity for the various layers cþ ¼ c ; eþ (dc=dx)þ ¼ e (dc=dx) . For the diffuse part of the double layer in the solution, the GC model may be used again. More detailed reviews concerning the electric double layer at biological interphases are given in references [5,11,18,19].
120 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
2.3
ELECTRODYNAMICS OF BIOLOGICAL INTERPHASES
How fast does an electric double layer in a biological interphase and the adjacent solution build up or adjust itself to changing conditions? In other words, what are the characteristic time constants for formation of the interphasial double layer? The time constant, td , for relaxation of the diffuse part of the double layer is determined by bulk properties of the medium: td ¼
ee0 K
(7)
where K is the specific conductivity. In terms of electric equivalent circuitry, the relaxation process corresponds with the discharge of the capacitor with capacitance ee0 (i.e. the dielectric formed by the bulk electrolyte solution) across the solution of resistivity K 1 . In electrical jargon, td represents the RC time constant of the solution, and this indeed governs the rate of interphasial double layer formation. Equation (7) can be rewritten in terms of the ionic diffusion coefficients Di because: K ¼F
X
jzi jui ci ¼
i
F2 X 2 z D i ci RT i i
(8)
in which ui represents the ionic mobilities. For a single symmetrical electrolyte with Dcation ¼ Danion ¼ D, and using equation (1), it follows that: td ¼
1 Dk2
(9)
Thus, the time constant td is directly related to the time necessary for ions to migrate over a distance equal to the Debye length k1 . For example, 1 for a 103 mol dm3 aqueous electrolyte solution with D ¼ 109 m2 s , and 8 1 7 k ¼ 10 m , equation (9) yields a td value of 10 s. Note that k is proportional to the square root of the electrolyte concentration, (see equation (1) ), so that td is inversely proportional to c. Thus, for electrolyte concentrations of the order of 0:1 mol dm3 , td reaches values as low as 109 s. Lipid bilayer membranes, with their apolar cores, generally have extremely poor conductivities. K can be as low as 106 V1 m1 [20], and also depends on the type of ions transferring the charge across the membrane. The time constant tm (as given by equation (7) with em e0 and Km representing the membrane permittivity and conductivity, respectively) to relax from electric polarisation by conduction through the bilayer is correspondingly large. For a membrane with a relative permittivity of the order of 10 and a thickness of about 108 m, the geometrical capacitance is 102 F m2 . Thus, the corresponding time
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
121
constant tm is 104 s. This means that on the relevant timescales of biological processes, the double layer at the solution side adjusts instantaneously (td typically 109 to 107 s), whereas the apolar core of the lipid bilayer may behave as a dielectric that does not allow appreciable passage of charge on timescales below 104 s. In real biological systems, this is generally overruled by specific ionselective permeation processes (e.g. see Chapters 5, 6 and 10). When the bilayer contains ion-transport channels or other transport mediators, the individual channels have conductivities typically of the order 1011 V1 m1 [21]. Realising that such a channel occupies a part of the membrane surface area of the order of 10 nm2 , this corresponds with a local K of about 106 V1 m1 . Thus, locally, the relaxation time constant comes down to around 108 s, which logically is again in the range of that for electrolyte solutions. Lateral transfer of ionic species through the biointerphasial double layer has only recently received attention. Yet it is a subject of significant relevance, because it may play a crucial role in the interactions of organisms with their surroundings, for example in bacterial adhesion processes, biofilm formation (and removal), etc. As an example, we may refer to a study of bacterial cells of the genus Corynebacterium. The cells are more or less spherical, with diameters of 1.1 and 0:8 mm for the longer and shorter axes, and can be prepared as fairly homodisperse suspensions. Electrophoretic mobilities of Corynebacterium cells are displayed as a function of pH in Figure 2. Via the z-potential and other double layer features, the mobility represents the particle charge (see Chapter 4 in [10]). Thus, the mobility increases with increasing charge in the wall, and with decreasing electrolyte concentration. For the Corynebacterium cells, the mobility versus charge function levels off and becomes quite insensitive to the electrolyte concentrations at higher pH, i.e. at increasing (negative) charge. This behaviour points to surface conduction effects, i.e. tangential displacement of counterions inside the double layer. A comprehensive analysis of the electrodynamic features is accessible by combining mobility data with the dielectric spectra of the dispersed cells [22,23]. As suggested before, the role of the interphasial double layer is insignificant in many transport processes that are involved with the supply of components from the bulk of the medium towards the biosurface. The thickness of the electric double layer is so small compared with that of the diffusion layer d that the very local deformation of the concentration profiles does not really alter the flux. Hence, in most analyses of diffusive mass transport one does not find any electric double layer terms. For the kinetics of the interphasial processes, this is completely different. Rate constants for chemical reactions or permeation steps are usually heavily dependent on the local conditions. Like in electrochemical processes, two elements are of great importance: the local electric field which affects rates of transfer of charged species (the actual potential comes into play in the case of redox reactions), and the local activities
122 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 3
108 u/m2 V-1 s-1
2
1
0
−1 −2 −3 0
2
4
6 pH
8
10
12
Figure 2. Electrophoretic mobility of Corynebacterium versus pH. The general trend of the markers for each KNO3 concentration (D ¼ 0:001; O ¼ 0:01 and ¼ 0:1mol dm3 ) is indicated with an auxiliary line. Redrawn from reference [22]
of charged species (different from their values just outside the double layer by some type of Boltzmann factor). These aspects are of primary importance in defining the boundary conditions (see Section 3.2).
3
GENERAL MASS TRANSFER EQUATIONS
3.1 CONSERVATION LAWS AND THE NERNST–PLANCK EQUATION Basic elements of transport equations are the laws expressing conservation of mass and conservation of momentum. The former is self-evident; the latter derives from Newton’s second law (stating that the sum of forces acting on a system equals the rate of production of momentum in that system). For details on the basic premises and features, refer to the specialised literature [24–29]. Let us consider the very general situation where a liquid system is subject to: . a pressure gradient, so that there is a flow of the liquid with velocity v, . a concentration gradient for a certain component i, so that there is diffusion of i, and
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
123
. an electric potential gradient, so that the charged components of the system are subjected to conduction (often denoted as ‘migration’ in the electrochemical literature). For this set of stimuli, the general linear flux equation for component i can be formulated as Ji ¼Di grad ci
|fflfflfflfflffl{zfflfflfflfflffl} diffusion term
zi ci ui grad c þ ci v jzi j
|fflfflfflffl{zfflfflfflffl}
|fflfflfflffl{zfflfflfflffl}
conduction term
flow term
(10)
where subscript i denotes that the magnitude (J for flux, c for concentration, u for mobility and z for charge) corresponds with the species i, and v is the velocity of the solution at the point where the flux is measured. For transport in one dimension, equation (10) reduces to: Ji ¼ Di
dci zi dc ci ui þ ci v dx jzi j dx
(11)
Equation (10) is known as the Nernst–Planck equation. This equation can be given in all kinds of formulations. Another common one is: Ji ¼
Di ~i þ ci v ci grad m RT
(12)
where the diffusion and conduction terms are contained in the gradient of the ~i . electrochemical potential m Mass conservation for component i implies that at a certain point in space, the time dependence of ci is related to the divergence of the flux of i. It is easily understood that a finite positive divergence in the flux will lead to depletion, i.e. to a lowering of the concentration. This can be expressed as: qci ¼ div Ji qt
(13)
where div denotes the divergence, i.e. div J ¼ qJx =qx þ qJy =qy þ qJz =qz in Cartesian coordinates, which reduces to dJ/dx in the one-dimensional case. We shall also encounter situations where a chemical reaction influences the concentrations. For a volume reaction of the type j Ð i, the reaction rate for the production of i is given by kf cj (if we assume it to be an elementary reaction), where kf is the forward reaction rate constant, and the rate of consumption of i by a term kb ci , where kb is the rate constant of the backward
124 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
reaction. Then the conservation equation (13) has to be extended with the chemical source terms: qci ¼ div Ji þ kf cj kb ci qt
(14)
The relative importance of reaction with respect to diffusion can be described in terms of the nondimensional (second) Damko¨hler number [30–36] (also called Thiele modulus), in terms of the reaction layer thickness [37,38] or in terms of lability criteria [39,40]. 3.2
BOUNDARY CONDITIONS
For a given mass transfer problem, the above conservation equations must be complemented with the applicable initial and boundary conditions. The problem of finding the mathematical function that represents the behaviour of the system (defined by the conservation equations and the appropriate set of initial and boundary conditions), is known as a ‘boundary value problem’. The boundary conditions specifically depend on the nature of the physicochemical processes in which the considered component is involved. Various classes of boundary conditions, resulting from various types of interfacial processes, will appear in the remainder of this chapter and Chapters 4 and 10. Here, we will discuss some simple boundary conditions using examples of the diffusion of a certain species taken up by an organism: . fixed concentration at a boundary. If an isolated organism is immersed in a huge volume, then the bulk concentration of the species taken up is constant and its fixed concentration (either at finite or infinite distance) can be used as a boundary condition. In the particular case of fixed zero concentration at the organism surface, we would have the maximum (‘limiting’) flux allowed by the diffusion supply. . fixed flux at a boundary. If a biological internalisation flux can be considered constant along a certain period, then a fixed-flux condition holds at the interfacial boundary. If the species cannot cross a surface (e.g. a ligand of the species taken up not being able to cross a cell membrane), then a zeroflux condition for that species applies. The nonflux condition would also be relevant for the case of an organism in a finite medium, as the internalised species in the medium is not replenished [41]. Obviously, many combinations arise: different boundary conditions for different species on the same surface, different boundary conditions on different adjacent surfaces (mixed boundary conditions) for the same species, prescribed combinations of flux and concentrations at a certain surface, etc.
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
3.3
125
THE IMPACT OF GEOMETRY
For an incompressible liquid (i.e. a liquid with an invariant density which implies that the mass balance at any point leads to div v ¼ 0) the time dependency of the concentration is given by the divergence of the flux, as defined by equation (13). Mathematically, the divergence of the gradient is the Laplacian operator r2 , also frequently denoted as D. Thus, for a case of diffusion and flow, equation (10) becomes: qci ¼ Di r2 ci div(ci v) qt
(15)
which, performing a local balance of matter, is a continuity equation. Like the divergence or the gradient, the Laplacian operator has different forms for different geometrical situations [42]; see Table 1.
3.4
TRANSIENT AND STEADY-STATE CONDITIONS
The general equation of convective diffusion in liquids, equation (15), is a second-order, partial differential equation with variable coefficients. Its solution yields the spatial distribution of ci as a function of time, namely its transient behaviour. On an analytical level, solution of equation (15) into the transient c(t) is possible only for a number of relatively simple systems with well-defined geometry and flow properties. The problem is greatly simplified if the concentration function ci (x, y, z) is essentially independent of time t, i.e. in the steadystate. Then equation (15) reduces to: Di r2 ci divðci vÞ ¼ 0
(16)
It is useful to point out here that we frequently encounter partial steadystates. An important example is the case where the diffusion process is much faster than a surface process, and thus a quasi-steady-state is reached for the diffusion concentration profile at each changing concentration of the surface. This distinction between different timescales of the processes can lead to a significant simplification of complex problems, see end of Section 4.3 or Chapter 4 in this volume. The derivation of a steady-state solution requires boundary conditions, but no initial condition. Steady-state can be seen as the asymptotic solution (so never mathematically reached at any finite time [43]) of the transient, which – for practical purposes – can be approached in a reasonably short time. For instance, limiting-flux diffusion of a species with diffusion coefficient Di ¼ 109 m2 s1 towards a spherical organism of radius r0 ¼ 1 mm is practically attained at t r20 =Di ¼ 1 ms.
Variable
x r r r, z
r, y, j
x, y, z
System of coordinates
Planar (1D) Spherical (1D) Cylindrical (1D) Axisymmetrical (2D)
Spherical polar (3D)
Cartesian (3D)
q2 S=qx2 þ q2 S=qy2 þ q2 S=qz2
(qS=qx)ex þ (qS=qy)ey þ (qS=qz)ez
(qS=qx)ex (qS=qr)er (qS=qr)er (qS=qr)er þ (qS=qz)ez qS 1 qS 1 qS er þ ey þ ej r sin y qj r qy qr
r2 S q2 S=qx2 q2 S=qr2 þ (2=r)(qS=qr) q2 S=qr2 þ (1=r)(qS=qr) q2 S=qr2 þ (1=r)(qS=qr) þ q2 S=qz2
q2 S 1 qS 1 q qS 1 q2 S þ þ sin y þ qr2 r qr r2 sin y qy qy r2 sin2 y qj2
grad S
Table 1. Gradient and Laplacian operators for different geometries. S stands for a scalar and ei stands for a unit vector associated to coordinate i
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
127
Some transient problems tend to a trivial (and useless) steady-state solution without flux and concentration profiles. For instance, concentration profiles due to limiting diffusion towards a plane in an infinite stagnant medium always keep diminishing. Spherical and disc geometries sustain steady-state under semi-infinite diffusion, and this can be practically exploited for small-scale active surfaces. As steady-state can only be maintained by the concurrence of some pumping energy, it has been associated with many life processes of no change. Conversely, equilibrium would correspond with a no-change situation of ‘death’.
3.5
DIFFUSION IN COMPOSITE MEDIA
For some biological systems, the species that eventually crosses the cell membrane has travelled through different media, each one with its own mass transfer characteristics. As an example, we deal with the case where the two media are the bulk solution and the cell wall (with the separation surface parallel to the cell membrane) with diffusion as the only relevant mass transfer phenomenon in each medium. Apart from having different parameters in the differential equations in each medium (due to the unequal diffusion coefficients), we need to impose two new boundary conditions at the separating plane which we denote as s. The first boundary condition follows from the continuity of the material flux: Ji, s ¼ Ji, sþ
(17)
where sþ and s indicate opposite sides of the separating surface. The second boundary condition arises from the continuity of chemical potential [44], which implies – under ideally dilute conditions – a fixed ratio, the so-called (Nernst) distribution or partition coefficient, KN , between the concentrations at the adjacent positions of both media: c i , s ¼ KN c i , s þ
(18)
The transient solution can be obtained, for planar or spherical geometry, using Laplace transforms [26,45], but, for simplicity, we restrict ourselves to the steady-state solutions. We consider, then, two media (1 for the cell-wall layer and 2 for the solution medium) where the diffusion coefficients of species i are Di,1 and Di,2 (see Figure 3). For the planar case, pure semi-infinite diffusion cannot sustain a steady-state, so we consider that the bulk conditions of species i are restored at a certain distance di (diffusion layer thickness) from the surface where ci ¼ 0 [28,45], so that a steady-state is possible. Using just the diffusive term in the Nernst–Planck equation (10), it can be seen that the flux at any surface is:
128 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
Medium 2
Medium 1
Di,2
Di,1
s ci,s−
* ci,s+ ci (di) = c i,2
ci (0) = 0
xs di
Figure 3. Outline of the concentration profile of species i due to steady-state diffusion in a composite region with two media
Ji ¼
c i, 2 xs = Di,1 KN þ ðdi xs Þ=Di,2
(19)
where xs denotes the position of the separating plane s. Expression (19) can be physically interpreted as due to the ‘resistance’ to flow generated by each medium due to its length and diffusion coefficient. Although Di,1 is expected to be lower than Di,2 , the fact that xs is di can result in the practical neglect of the retardation due to the thin wall layer. Expressions analogous to (19) have been used in interpreting analytical techniques with composite media [46]. In the case of semi-infinite diffusion towards a spherical organism of radius r0 , with the surface of separation (concentric with the organism’s surface) at radius rs , the flux at the membrane surface is [26]: Di,1 KN ci,2 Ji ¼ ð1=rs Þ ð1=r0 Þ Di,1 KN =rs Di,2 r20
(20)
If rs and r0 are very similar, the previous expression practically reverts to the diffusion in only one medium. If the transported species is volatile, it is convenient to relate the concentration to the pressure via the solubility (or Henry law coefficient), because the steady-state solution does not depend on the particular values of the diffusion
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
129
coefficients and of the solubility parameters of each medium [26,44], but on their product, which is known as the permeability of this medium. Other geometries can be substantially more difficult to solve [45], mostly when the one-dimensional approach is not appropriate. The steady-state analytical solution through a multilayer medium towards a disc surface is available [47], but for most problems (especially transient ones) only numerical simulation is feasible.
4
CONVECTIVE DIFFUSION
Let us consider the transport of one component i in a liquid solution. Any disequilibration in the solution is assumed to be due to macroscopic motion of the liquid (i.e. flow) and to gradients in the concentration ci . Temperature gradients are assumed to be negligible. The transport of the solute i is then governed by two different modes of transport, namely, molecular diffusion through the solvent medium, and drag by the moving liquid. The combination of these two types of transport processes is usually denoted as the convective diffusion of the solute in the liquid [25] or diffusion–advection mass transport [48,49]. The relative contribution of advection to total transport is characterised by the nondimensional Pe´clet number [32,48,49], while the relative increase in transport over pure diffusion due to advection is Sh – 1, where Sh is the nondimensional Sherwood number [28,32,33,49,50]. Transport of i due to the flow of the surrounding liquid travelling at a velocity v amounts to ci v so that the total flux Ji resulting from diffusion and flow comes to: Ji ¼ Di grad ci þ ci v
(21)
which is nothing other than the Nernst–Planck equation (10) for the case without the conduction term. We note that for not too high concentrations of i, the diffusion coefficient Di can be considered as a (temperature-dependent) constant. In many biological works, which have tended to focus on the organism rather than on the surrounding medium, the flux coming from the medium and crossing the surface is taken as positive (see Chapter 1). Following this sign convention, and considering the usual absence of flow of the fluid across the surface, the flux reads: Ji (diffusion) ¼ þDi grad ci
(22)
which is just the first term from the Nernst–Planck equation (10). Taking into account that the liquid acting as a medium for the microorganism is incompressible (div v ¼ 0), equation (15) becomes:
130 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
Di
q2 c i q2 c i q2 c i þ þ qx2 qy2 qz2
!
qci qci qci vx ¼0 þ vy þ vz qx qy qz
(23)
which is the general equation of steady-state convective diffusion. Mathematically, it is a second-order partial differential equation, which can be solved (either analytically or more frequently numerically) for a given a set of boundary conditions that are characteristic for the problem under consideration. In most cases, the velocity profile is known or can be solved prior to (and independently of) the determination of the diffusion profile. Unfortunately, the rigorous solution of most realistic hydrodynamics problems is rather involved (for instance, due to the presence of turbulence) and sometimes it is reasonable to use empirical expressions for the velocity profile. One particular simplification arises when the scale of the turbulence [48] is much larger than the size of the microorganism, which effectively results in a locally linear shear (velocity gradient) [49,51] or, for that matter, a laminar sublayer close to the biological surface [25,52]. Below we shall treat three relevant, although simplified, examples. 4.1 CONVECTIVE DIFFUSION FROM AN UNBOUNDED LAMINARLY FLOWING LIQUID TO A PLANAR SURFACE We consider a plane with length l and width w, which is exposed to a flowing solution with a dissolved component i at a bulk concentration ci . The direction of the bulk stream of flow is parallel to the plane in the direction of the y-axis; the x-axis is perpendicular to the plane, as shown in Figure 4. The bulk velocity of the flow far from the plane is denoted as v. The z-axis is considered immaterial, due to a sufficiently large value of w compared with the dimensions of the velocity and concentration perturbations. l is assumed to be much larger than the diffusion layer thickness (di ). The first step in solving convective diffusion problems is the derivation of the velocity profile. In this case, the flow arriving with velocity v is modified by y x
w
l
Direction of flow
z
Figure 4. Schematic representation of the convective–diffusion problem for an active plane parallel to the direction of flow dealt with in Section 4.1. The liquid flow extends up to x ¼ 1, where its free velocity is v in the direction of increasing y. The leading edge of the plane is the segment x ¼ 0, y ¼ 0, 0 z w
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
131
the leading edge of the plane (y ¼ 0) and develops a velocity profile for which the rigorous solution, attributed to Blasius in 1908 (p. 20 in [25], p. 396 in [53], Chapter 4 in [54]), can be approximated by: vy 0:332v3=2 x=
pffiffiffiffiffi ~y
(24)
vx 0:083ðv=yÞ3=2 x2 ~1=2
(25)
where ~ is the kinematic viscosity of the solution (the quotient between the viscosity and the density, which for aqueous solutions at room temperature is about 106 m2 s1 ). Notice that vx and vy depend on both x and y, but vx =vy (usually small except close to the leading edge, where the Blasius solution is not accurate [50,55]) is independent of v. Exact (continuous line) and approximate (dotted line, given by equation (24) ) profiles of the velocity are depicted in Figure 5. An important concept in fluid mechanics is the hydrodynamic boundary layer (also known as Prandtl layer) or region where the effective disturbance 16 di
ci /ci*
vapprox
0.8
vexact
0.6
d0 8
ci /ci*
108v/m s−1
12
1.0
0.4 4 0.2
0 0
0.1
0.2
0.3 x/mm
0.4
0.5
0.0 0.6
Figure 5. Exact (numerical solution, continuous line) and linearised (equation (24), dotted line) velocity profile (i.e. vy of the fluid at different distances x from the surface) at y ¼ 105 m in the case of laminar flow parallel to an active plane (Section 4.1). Parameters: Di ¼ 109 m2 s1 , v ¼ 103 m s1 , and ~ ¼ 106 m2 s1 . The hydrodynamic boundary layer thickness (d0 ¼ 5 104 m), equation (26), where 99% of v is reached is shown with a horizontal double arrow line. For comparison, the normalised concentration profile of species i, ci =ci , the linear profile of the diffusion layer approach (continuous line) and its thickness (di ¼ 3 105 m, equation (34) ) have been added. Notice that the linearisation of the exact velocity profile requires that di d0
132 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
of the main flow takes place, with d0 labelling its thickness as seen in Figure 5. It is good to emphasise that the diffusion layer and the hydrodynamic boundary layer are principally different. The former denotes the layer of solution where the concentration of diffusing species is depleted, whereas the latter refers to the layer of solution where the liquid velocity is reduced with respect to the bulk velocity. The d0 (assumed to be much smaller than l or w) can be quantified as the distance from the plane where vy 0:99v, using the exact (numerical) solution. In this problem, d0 can be taken as [53,55,56]: pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi d0 5 ~ny=v
(26)
With the expressions for the velocities, i.e. equations (24) and (25), at hand, one can turn to the diffusion problem and seek to solve equation (23). Apart from dropping the terms with derivatives in the z-direction, it can be shown that the diffusive term q2 ci =qy2 is also relatively small in comparison with q2 ci =qx2 (see p. 87 in [25]). Thus, equation (23) boils down to:
q2 c i qci qci ¼0 þ vy Di 2 v x qx qx qy
(27)
The leading boundary conditions correspond with semi-infinite diffusion with an instantaneous sink of the diffusing species at the plane x ¼ 0: ci (x, y) ¼ 0 ci (x, y) ¼
x¼0
ci
x!1
8y
(28)
8y
(29)
with ci (0, 0) well behaved. Substitution of equations (24) and (25) into equation (27) and further manipulations (see p. 88 in [25] for details), leads to the solution: 3=2 3 1=2 ci =ci ¼ 1 0:373G 1=3, 0:0277D1 x ~n i ðv=yÞ
(30)
where G stands for the incomplete gamma function: G(a, z) ¼
Z
1
ta1 expt dt
(31)
z
It can be seen that the profile of the concentration (see Figure 6 and dashed line in Figure 5) is largely linear over a wide range of x-values away from the plane. On the other hand, the change in ci with y, at a given x, is of a parabolic nature (see Figure 7). With the complete concentration profile ci (x, y) at hand, it is straightforward to compute the magnitude of the flux Ji towards the plane:
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
133
1.0
y = 30 µm
0.8
ci /mol m−3
y = 20 µm 0.6
y = 10 µm
0.4
0.2
0.0 0
4
8
12
16
20
x/µm
Figure 6. Concentration profiles of species i (equation (30)) as a function of the distance from the surface (x) in the case of laminar flow parallel to an active plane (Section 4.1). 1 Parameters: Di ¼ 109 m2 s1 , v ¼ 0:012 m s1 , ci ¼ 1 mol m3 , and ~ ¼ 106 m2 s
1.0
ci /mol m−3
0.8
0.6
x = 30 µm
0.4
x = 20 µm 0.2 x = 10 µm 0.0 0
250
500 y/µm
750
1000
Figure 7. Concentration profiles of species i (equation (30) ) as a function of the distance from the leading edge (y) in the case of laminar flow parallel to an active plane (Section 4.1). Other parameters as in Figure 6
134 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 2=3
Ji ¼ Di ðqci =qxÞx¼0 ¼ 0:339ci Di
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1=6 v=y~
(32)
which shows that the diffusive flux of solute i towards a plane in a laminarly flowing solution is proportional to its diffusion coefficient Di to the power 2/3 [48]. Thus, changes in the exponent of Di (sometimes on empirical basis) are linked to the hydrodynamic regime and the contribution of advection. The magnitude of the flux given by equation (32) decreases with increasing distance from the upstream edge of the plane and with decreasing velocity of the liquid according to square root dependencies. Formally, the flux can also be written: Ji ¼ Di ci =di
(33)
where di is the thickness of the diffusion layer of species i. Comparison with equation (32), yields di for the present case of laminar flow along a plane: 1=3
di ¼ 2:95Di
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1=6 y=v~
(34)
Physically, di represents the distance from the plane where bulk concentration would be recovered if a concentration profile were simply linear with a slope given by the tangent of the true concentration profile at x ¼ 0 (see continuous line in Figure 5). Notice that the boundary (equation (26) ) and diffusion (equation (34) ) layers, in this example, extend as the square root of the distance from the leading edge, i.e. the steady-state thicknesses of the hydrodynamic boundary layer and the diffusion layer increase with increasing distance (y) from the upstream edge, according to parabolic relationships. The flux of i at x ¼ 0, being inversely proportional to di , decreases with increasing y. Figure 8 summarises this typical behaviour. It should be noted that the ratio di =d0 is independent of the coordinate y and the liquid velocity, and that the solution for convective diffusion given by (30) and following equations requires that di =d0 is well below unity, to allow for the approximate expressions of the velocities, equations (24) and (25), to apply. One easily verifies that for small ions and molecules in aqueous systems with D O(109 ) m2 s1 and ~ O(106 ) m2 s1 , di =d0 is small enough for the approximate treatment developed here to be acceptable. In passing, it is good to emphasise that the above analysis illustrates the limitations of the widely used Nernst diffusion layer concept. This concept assumes that there is a certain thin layer of static liquid adjacent to the solid plane under consideration at x ¼ 0. Inside this layer, diffusion is supposed to be the sole mechanism of transport, and, outside the layer, the concentration of the diffusing component is constant, as a result of the convection in the liquid. We have seen that, in contradiction with this oversimplified picture, molecular diffusion and liquid motion are not spatially separated, and that the thickness
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
135 6.0
d0
0.2
4.0
2.0
0.1
104 J/mol m−2 s−1
Boundary or diffusion layer thickness/mm
0.3
Ji di 0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0 y/mm
1.5
0.0 2.0
Figure 8. Variation of the hydrodynamic boundary layer thickness (d0 , equation (26), continuous line), the diffusion layer thickness (di , equation (34), dotted line) and the ensuing local flux (J i , equation (32), dashed line) with respect to the distance from the leading edge (y) in the case of laminar flow parallel to an active plane (the surface is a 1 sink for species i). Parameters: Di ¼ 109 m2 s , v ¼ 103 m s1 , ci ¼ 1 mol m3 , and 6 2 1 ~ ¼ 10 m s . Notice that di d0 (as required for the derivation of the flux equation (32) ), and that the flux decreases when di increases
of the diffusion layer depends on the properties of the diffusing molecules as well as on hydrodynamic characteristics. Needless to say, a formal flux expression like equation (33) becomes meaningful only after combination with the appropriate formulation of the values of di . 4.2 CONVECTIVE DIFFUSION FROM A CHANNELLED LAMINARLY FLOWING LIQUID In some biological cases, liquid is forced to flow inside a channel (e.g. a tube inside an animal, as in gills, for example). The channel can be modelled as a long pipe or cylinder of radius R. The active surface corresponds with r ¼ R (see Figure 9). As usual, we must first solve for the velocity profile. The flow can be taken as laminar for low Reynolds numbers, vR=~ < 2500, where v is the maximum velocity of the flow reached at the centre of the channel (r ¼ 0) [52]. For simplicity, we will consider the particular case where the Poiseuille velocity profile has been fully developed when the solution carrying the active species
136 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
Parabolic velocity profile
r
v R
x
y
Figure 9. Model of convective diffusion inside a tube channel (radius R) towards the walls of the tube considered as perfect active surfaces. A Poiseuille profile for the velocity (equation (35) ) is also schematically shown with arrows on the right-hand side. The maximum velocity v is reached at the centre of the tube (r ¼ 0)
reaches the part of the pipe with the active surface. Thus, the main difference with respect to the previous case is that the velocity profile does not change along the direction y (under steady-state conditions, the incompressible fluid is forced to flow at the same velocity all along y), because no end effects distort the velocity profile. The parabolic Poiseuille profile (including the no-slip condition on the surface at r ¼ R) is: vy ¼ v 1 r2 =R2
(35)
Via a simple integration of this parabolic profile, one can find a relationship between v and the effective flow rate vf (volume of liquid crossing any section of the channel per unit of time): vf ¼ pR2 v=2
(36)
A further simplification (known as the Le´veˆque approximation [57]), linearises the profile in the vicinity of the surface (where a local coordinate x, perpendicular to the surface, is taken): vy 2vx=R
(37)
Considering also that in the y-direction the rate of mass transport due to convection is much higher than that due to diffusion [58], equation (23) reduces to: Di
q2 c i qx2
!
2vx qci R qy
¼0
(38)
Through a change of variable (see p. 114 in [25]), the concentration profile, for the limiting situation where the active surface is a perfect sink, can be expressed (similarly to equation (30)) as:
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
ci =ci ¼ 1 0:373G 1=3, 2vx3 =(9Di Ry)
137
(39)
Then, we obtain for the flux: 1=3 Ji ¼ 0:678 ci D2i v=ðRyÞ
(40)
As physically expected, the flux diminishes as we move downstream (increasing y) due to the previous depletion at lower y. No direct relation to the viscosity is present, as the flow is forced to go with a constant v (along different y), but the viscosity of the liquid has an indirect effect via Di . The diffusion layer thickness can be computed as: di ¼ 1:474 ðDi Ry=vÞ1=3
(41)
Obviously, this approximate treatment fails when di > R, as then the Le´veˆque linearisation is clearly unapplicable. For an approximation to account for lateral effects of nonactive walls in box-like channels, see ref. [46].
4.3 CONVECTIVE DIFFUSION FROM A LIQUID TO A MOVING SPHERICAL BODY Another case of great practical importance in the bioenvironmental context is the convective–diffusive transport of solutes towards the surface of suspended bodies (or particles) in a liquid medium. We will consider the situation where a spherical body of radius r0 moves with respect to the liquid, which, of course, is mathematically equivalent to the situation of a stagnant particle in a flowing liquid [48]. Figure 10 shows a planar cross-section of the situation and the polar coordinate system relevant to the analysis. As the starting velocity profile (for vr and vy ), we take the simplified regime corresponding with ‘creeping’ flow around the sphere [24], which limits the applicability of the results to parameters corresponding with low Reynolds numbers, i.e. cases where turbulences do not come into play: < 0:1 vr0 =~
(42)
The field of velocities corresponding with such a regime (which includes ‘no-slip’ of the fluid at the sphere surface) is indicated by the arrows in Figure 10, where the length of each arrow is proportional to the local velocity of the fluid. The perturbation of the bulk velocity extends to quite large distances; for instance, it is necessary to move 75 times the radius r0 from the centre of the sphere normal to the free stream direction of flow in order to obtain 99% of v.
138 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
r
r0 q
Figure 10. Velocity field of creeping flow around a sphere [24]. Each arrow represents the velocity at the origin of the depicted vector. The length of the arrow corresponding with the free velocity v would equal the radius of the sphere
In the steady-state situation qci =qt ¼ 0, and we can use equation (23) as the appropriate starting equation. For the case of diffusion towards a sphere in polar coordinates (see Table 1), this comes to: Di
q2 ci 2 qci þ qr2 r qr
! vr
qci qci vy ¼0 qr qy
(43)
where r and y are the two relevant variables. Due to axisymmetry, the elevational angle j is immaterial (not depicted in Figure 10), so that we are left with two essential spatial variables, i.e. r and y. For clarity, we choose again the boundary conditions corresponding with limiting transport (maximum flux): ci (r, y) ¼ 0
r ¼ r0
8y
ci (r, y) ¼ ci
r!1
8y
(44)
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
139
The second expression in equation (44) implies that the bulk concentration in the medium is not affected by the consumption of i towards the particle, i.e. the overall depletion is insignificant. In case of the presence of an ensemble of bodies (or particles), this means that the distance between different bodies (or particles) is sufficiently large compared with the steady-state diffusion layer (i.e. the dispersion should be sufficiently diluted). Then an approximate analytical solution of the convective diffusion equation (43), which satisfies the boundary conditions, equation (44), is available under the assumption that the thickness of the diffusion layer di is small compared with the body radius r0 (p. 80 in [25]). As in the example of Section 4.1 (see equation (33)), the results of the derivation can be formally written in terms of the diffusion layer thickness, which now is:
1=3 di 1:29 Di 1 ¼ y sin 2y r0 sin y vr0 2
(45)
The value of the product v r0 becomes critical as, on one hand (see condition (42)), it must be low, but on the other it must be high enough to satisfy di r0 [48]. For instance, Figure 11 (where the end of the diffusion layer is depicted with a discontinuous line) just fulfils both conditions, except in the rear down1 stream flow if ~ < 106 m2 s . Inspection of equations (33) and (45) confirms that the flux Ji is maximal for y ¼ 0. It decreases with increasing y, and tends to zero for y ¼ p, where the depletion layer thickness is no longer small compared to r0 . This result is not practically important, since the fluxes for y close to p are relatively small and hardly count in the total transport rate. It may also be noted that, as a consequence of the approximations in the derivation, the limit v ! 0 of equation (45) does not approach the purely diffusional value given by r0 . The total transport rate (in mol s1 ) to the whole body (or particle) is found 1 by integration of the flux (in mol m2 s ) over the total surface area: ð
Ji dA ¼ 2pr20
ðp Ji sin ydy
(46)
0
which, after substitution of equations (33) and (45), yields the average flux: Ji ¼ 0:65(D2i v=r20 )1=3 ci
(47)
It should be highlighted that equation (47) holds for solid particles. In the case of liquid particles, e.g. with emulsions, the convective diffusion process is very different due to interfacial momentum transfer which gives rise to a different velocity profile. Consequently, convective diffusion to/from a liquid particle is more effective than that for a solid particle. Starting again from equation (43),
140 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 0.4
x/mm
0.3
Flow 0.2
0.1
di r0 0.0 −0.4
−0.3
−0.2
−0.1 y/mm
0
0.1
0.2
Figure 11. Position of the diffusion layer limit (dashed line; computed with equation (45) ) for a species diffusing towards a spherical surface (continuous line) when creeping flow coming from the right-hand side is considered. Notice that the ensuing flux will be maximum at positions facing the flow. Parameters: r0 ¼ 104 m, Di ¼ 109 m2 s1 , and v ¼ 103 m s1
the following equivalent of equation (47) for a moving particle can be obtained (see page 404 in [25]): 1=2 1=2 1=2 Ji ¼ 0:65Di ci r0 v0
(48)
Z v v0 ¼ m 2 Zm þ Zp
(49)
with:
where Zm and Zp are the viscosities of the medium and the particle, respectively. Literature data seem to suggest that the behaviour of vesicles with a lipid bilayer skin is more close to that of rigid particles [2,12,23]. In many interfacial conversion processes, certainly those at biological interphases, the diffusion situation is complicated by the fact that the concentration at the organism surface is not constant with time (c0i (t) not constant). However, in most cases of steady-state convective diffusion, the changes in the surface
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
141
concentration are slow compared to the characteristic time for reaching a steady-state diffusional situation (typically of the order of r20 =D [59] in the spherical case). This means that the thickness of the diffusion layer and the shape of the concentration profile have reached their steady-state properties. Then, it is allowed to apply the flux equations above together with the appropriate expression for di , withci replaced by the relevant concentration change over the diffusion layer, i.e. ci c0i (t) . Applying this, by way of example, to the spherical body case, we may write the flux as [9]: Ji ¼ ms ci c0i (t) (50) where ms is shorthand notation for the steady-state mass transfer coefficient, which for the case of diffusion towards a rigid spherical body in creeping flow (see equation (47)) is: 1=3 ms ¼ 0:65 D2i v=r20
(51)
Thus, with a variable degree of empiricity, mass transfer coefficients for a number of biologically relevant cases have been described: phytoplankton uptake [60], periphyton uptake [61], coral-reef supply of nutrients [62–64], fixation of carbon at leaf surfaces [65], etc. Due to the difficulties in having rigorous analytical expressions for the flux at any given geometry and flow conditions, in many instances it is convenient to include all the characteristics of the supply in the mass transfer coefficient ms and use expression (50). It must be pointed out that expression (50), stating a linearity between the flux and the difference between bulk and surface concentrations, cannot be – in general – valid for nonlinear processes, such as coupled complexation of the species i with any other species (see Chapters 4 and 10 for a more detailed discussion).
GLOSSARY GC GCS RC
Gouy–Chapman Gouy–Chapman–Stern Resistance–Capacitance
LIST OF SYMBOLS SUPERSCRIPTS * 0
bulk conditions (spherical) surface of the organism
142 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
SUBSCRIPTS D Dm e i m m r, y w x,y,z s þ – 1,2 0
Donnan phase Donnan–medium interphase electrolyte ions charge species i medium membrane polar components of a vector (fixed) wall phase charge Cartesian components of a vector separation surface between different media limit approaching from the right limit approaching from the left labels of media spherical surface of the organism
LATIN SYMBOLS Symbol
Name
Units
Equation
A c D div F grad J K KN k k f , kd l ms
Area Concentration Diffusion coefficient Divergence Faraday constant Gradient Flux Conductivity Nernst distribution coefficient Boltzmann constant Kinetic constants Length of plane Steady-state mass transfer coefficient Gas constant Radius of the cylindrical channel Radius, radial coordinate Temperature Time Ionic mobility Fluid velocity Flow rate Width of adsorbing plane
m2 mol m3 1 m2 s Operator C mol1 Operator 1 mol m2 s 1 1 V m None J K1 s1 m m s1
(46) (1) (8) (13) (1) (10); see Table 1 (10), (22) (7) (18) (1) (14) Figure 4 (50)
R R r T t u v vf w
1
J K1 mol m m K s 1 m2 V1 s 1 ms 1 m3 s m
(4) (35), (36) (20) (1) (13) (8), (10) (10) (36) Figure 4
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN
x y z z
Coordinate normal to the surface Coordinate of main flow Ionic charge Cartesian coordinate
143
m m None m
(3) Figure 4 (1), (6), (10) Figure 4
None m m None F m1 V N s m2 rad m1 1 m2 s J mol1 C m3 s V
(31) (33) (26) (1), (3) (1)
GREEK SYMBOLS G di d0 e e0 z Zm , Zp y k ~ ~ m r td c
Incomplete gamma function Diffusion layer thickness Boundary layer thickness Relative permittivity Absolute permittivity of vacuum Electrokinetic potential Medium and particle viscosities Polar coordinate Reciprocal of Debye length Kinematic viscosity Electrochemical potential Density of charge Double layer relaxation time Electrical potential
(49) (43) (1) (24) (12) (3) (7), (9) (3), (4)
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Kleijn, J. M. and van Leeuwen, H. P. (2000). Electrostatic and electrodynamic properties of biological interphases. In Physical Chemistry of Biological Interfaces. eds. Baszkin, A. and Norde, W., Marcel Dekker, New York, pp. 49–83. Barenholz, Y. and Cevc, G. (2000). Electrostatic and electrodynamic properties of biological interphases. In Physical Chemistry of Biological Interfaces. eds. Baszkin, A. and Norde, W., Marcel Dekker, New York, pp. 171–241. van Grondelle, R. (1985). Excitation-energy transfer, trapping and annihilation in photosynthetic systems, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 811, 147–195. Harden, V. P. and Harris, J. O. (1952). The isoelectrical point of bacterial cells, J. Bacteriol., 65, 198–202. Cevc, G. (1990). Membrane electrostatics, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1031, 311–382. Pethig, R. (1985). Ion, electron, and proton transport in membranes: a review of the physical processes involved. In Modern Bioelectrochemistry. eds. Gutmann, F. and Keyzer, H., Plenum, New York, pp. 199–239. Honig, B. H., Hubbell, W. L. and Flewelling, R. F. (1986). Electrostatic interactions in membranes and proteins, Ann. Rev. Biophys. Biophys. Chem., 15, 163–193. Gawrisch, K., Ruston, D., Zimmerberg, J., Parsegian, V. A., Rand, R. P. and Fuller, N. (1992). Membrane dipole potentials, hydration forces, and the ordering of water at membrane surfaces, Biophys. J., 61, 1213–1223. Bard, A. J. and Faulkner, L. R. (1980). Electrochemical Methods. Fundamentals and Applications. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, New York.
144 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33.
Lyklema, J. (1995). Fundamentals of Interface and Colloid Science, Vol. II. Solid– Liquid Interfaces. Academic Press, London. McLaughlin, S. (1989). The electrostatic properties of membranes, Ann. Rev. Biophys. Biophys. Chem., 18, 113–136. Cevc, G. and Marsh, D. (1987). Phospholipid Bilayers. Wiley-Interscience, New York. Langner, M., Cafiso, D., Marcelja, S. and McLaughlin, S. (1990). Electrostatics of phosphoinositide bilayer-membranes – theoretical and experimental results, Biophys. J., 57, 335–349. Ohshima, H. and Ohki, S. (1985). Donnan potential and surface-potential of a charged membrane, Biophys. J., 47, 673–678. Ohshima, H. and Kondo, T. (1987). Electrophoretic mobility and Donnan potential of a large colloidal particle with a surface-charge layer, J. Coll. Interf. Sci., 116, 305–311. Ohshima, H. and Kondo, T. (1989). Approximate analytic-expression for the electrophoretic mobility of colloidal particles with surface-charge layers, J. Coll. Interf. Sci., 130, 281–282. Ohshima, H. and Kondo, T. (1991). On the electrophoretic mobility of biological cells, Biophys. Chem., 39, 191–198. Blank, M. (1985). Electrical Double Layers in Biology. Plenum, New York. Baszkin, A. and Norde, W. (2000). Electrostatic and Electrodynamic Properties of Biological Interfaces. Marcel Dekker, New York. Lakshminarayanaiah, N. (1969). Transport Phenomena in Membranes. Academic Press, New York. Haydon, D. A. and Hladky, S. B. (1972). Ion transport across thin lipid membranes: a critical discussion of mechanisms in selected systems, Q. Rev. Biophys., 5, 187–282. van der Wal, A., Minor, M., Norde, W., Zehnder, A. J. B. and Lyklema, J. (1997). Electrokinetic potential of bacterial cells, Langmuir, 13, 165–171. Barchini, R., van Leeuwen, H. P. and Lyklema, J. (2000). Electrodynamics of liposome dispersions, Langmuir, 16, 8238–8247. Bird, R. B., Stewart, W. E., and Lightfoot, E. N. (1960). Transport Phenomena. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., New York. Levich, V. G. (1962). Physicochemical Hydrodynamics. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ. Crank, J. (1975). The Mathematics of Diffusion. Clarendon Press, Oxford. Pedley, T. J. (1997). Introduction to fluid dynamics, Sci. Mar., 61, 7–24. Cussler, E. L. (1999). Diffusion. Mass Transfer in Fluid Systems. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Berry, R. S., Rice, S. A. and Ross, J. (2000). Physical Chemistry. Oxford University Press, New York. ¨ ber die Adsorptionsgeschwindigkeit von Gasen an porDamko¨hler, G. (1934). U o¨sen Adsorbentien, Z. Physik. Chem., 169, 222–239. Damko¨hler, G. (1937). Einflu¨sse der Stro¨mung, Diffusion und des wa¨rmeu¨berganges auf die Leistung von Reactionso¨fen. 2. Die isotherme, raumbesta¨ndige, homogene Reaktion erster Ordnung, Z. Elektroch. Bd., 43, 1–13. Boucher, D. F. and Alves, G. E. (1959). Dimensionless numbers, Chem. Eng. Prog., 55, 55–64. Jannasch, H. W., Honeyman, B. D. and Murray, J. W. (1996). Marine scavenging: the relative importance of mass transfer and reaction rates, Limnol. Oceanogr. 41, 82–88.
H. P. VAN LEEUWEN AND J. GALCERAN 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53.
145
Wolf-Gladrow, D. and Riebesell, U. (1997). Diffusion and reactions in the vicinity of plankton: a refined model for inorganic carbon transport, Mar. Chem., 59, 17–34. Galceran, J., Taylor, S. L. and Bartlett, P. N. (1999). Application of Danckwerts’ expression to first-order EC reactions. Transient currents at inlaid and recessed microdisc electrodes, J. Electroanal. Chem., 466, 15–25. Galceran, J., Puy, J., Salvador, J., Cecı´lia, J. and van Leeuwen, H. P. (2001). Voltammetric lability of metal complexes at spherical microelectrodes with various radii, J. Electroanal. Chem., 505, 85–94. Heyrovsky´, J. and Ku˚ta, J. (1966). Principles of Polarography. Academic Press, New York. van Leeuwen, H. P., Puy, J., Galceran, J. and Cecı´lia, J. (2002). Evaluation of the Koutecky´–Koryta approximation for voltammetric currents generated by metal complex systems with various labilities, J. Electroanal. Chem., 526, 10–18. van Leeuwen, H. P. (1999). Metal speciation dynamics and bioavailability: inert and labile complexes, Environ. Sci. Technol., 33, 3743–3748. van Leeuwen, H. P. (2001). Revisited: the conception of lability of metal complexes, Electroanalysis, 13, 826–830. Pinheiro, J. P., Galceran, J. and van Leeuwen, H. P. (2003). Metal speciation dynamics and bioavailability. Bulk depletion influence in biouptake, Environ. Sci. Technol., submitted. Gradshteyn, I. S. and Ryzhik, I. M. (1994). Tables of Integrals, Series and Products. Academic Press, New York. Zoski, C. G., Bond, A. M., Allinson, E. T. and Oldham, K. B. (1990). How long does it take a microelectrode to reach a voltammetric steady-state? Anal. Chem., 62, 37–45. Gnaiger, E. (1983). Symbols and units: toward standardization. In Polarographic Oxygen Sensors. eds. Gnaiger, E. and Forstner, H., Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 352–358. Carslaw, H. S. and Jaeger, J. C. (1959). Conduction of Heat in Solids. Clarendon Press, Oxford. Tomaszewski, L., Buffle, J. and Galceran, J. (2003). Theoretical and analytical characterisation of a flow-through permeation liquid membrane with controlled flux for metal speciation measurements, Anal. Chem., 75, 893–900. Galceran, J., Salvador, J., Puy, J., Cecı´lia, J. and Gavaghan, D. J. (1997). Analytical solution for the steady-state diffusion towards an inlaid disc microelectrode in a multi-layered medium, J. Electroanal. Chem., 440, 1–25. Csanady, G. T. (1986). Mass-transfer to and from small particles in the sea, Limnol. Oceanogr., 31, 237–248. Pahlow, M., Riebesell, U. and Wolf-Gladrow, D. A. (1997). Impact of cell shape and chain formation on nutrient acquisition by marine diatoms, Limnol. Oceanogr., 42, 1660–1672. Adamczyk, Z. and van de Ven, T. G. M. (1982). Particle transfer to a plate in uniform-flow, Chem. Eng. Sci., 37, 869–880. Lazier, J. R. N. and Mann, K. H. (1989). Turbulence and the diffusive layers around small organisms, Deep-Sea Res., 36, 1721–1733. Sˇtulı´k, K. and Pacakova, V. (1987). Theory of electroanalytical flow measurements. In Electroanalytical Measurements in Flowing Liquids. Series eds. Chalmers, R. A. and Masson, M., Ellis Horwood, Chichester, pp. 27–81. White, F. M. (1986). Fluid Mechanics. McGraw-Hill, New York.
146 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65.
Landau, L. D. and Lifshitz, E. M. (1987). Fluid Mechanics. Vol. 6. Pergamon Press, Oxford. Douglas, J. F., Gasiorek, J. M. and Swaffield, J. A. (1985). Fluid Mechanics. Longman Scientific & Technical, New York. Vogel, S. (1994). Life in Moving Fluids: the Physical Biology of Flow. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. Le´veˆque, M. A. (1928). Les lois de la transmission de chaleur par convection, Ann. Mines. Mem. Ser., 13, 201–208. Alden, J. A. (1998). Computational Electrochemistry. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Oxford, UK. Oldham, K. B. and Myland, J. C. (1994). Fundamentals of Electrochemical Science. Academic Press, San Diego. Pasciak, W. J. and Gavis, J. (1974). Transport limitation of nutrient uptake in phytoplankton, Limnol. Oceanogr., 19, 881–888. Ploug, H., Stolte, W. and Jorgensen, B. B. (1999). Diffusive boundary layers of the colony-forming plankton alga Phaeocystis sp – implications for nutrient uptake and cellular growth, Limnol. Oceanogr., 44, 1959–1967. Patterson, M. R., Sebens, K. P. and Olson, R. R. (1991). In situ measurements of flow effects on primary production and dark respiration in reef corals, Limnol. Oceanogr., 36, 936–948. Atkinson, M. J. and Bilger, R. W. (1992). Effects of water velocity on phosphateuptake in coral reef-flat communities, Limnol. Oceanogr., 37, 273–279. Bilger, R. W. and Atkinson, M. J. (1992). Anomalous mass transfer of phosphate on coral-reef flats, Limnol. Oceanogr., 37, 261–272. Wheeler, W. N. (1980). Effect of boundary-layer transport on the fixation of carbon by the giant-kelp Macrocystis pyrifera, Mar. Biol., 56, 103–110.
4 Dynamics of Biouptake Processes: the Role of Transport, Adsorption and Internalisation JOSEP GALCERAN Departament de Quı´mica, Universitat de Lleida, Av. Rovira Roure 191, 25198 Lleida, Spain
HERMAN P. VAN LEEUWEN Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Colloid Science, Wageningen University, Dreijenplein 6, NL-6703 HB Wageningen The Netherlands
1 2
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Uncomplicated Mass Transfer of the Species Being Taken up . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1 A Transient Model for Two Parallel Internalisation Routes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.1 General Model with Two Types of Langmuirian Adsorption Sites Coupled to First-Order Internalisation Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.2 Typical Results for the Case of Two Internalisation Routes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.3 A Particular Case: One Internalisation Route and One Adsorption-Only Route. . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.3.1 Transient . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.3.2 Steady-State. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 The Steady-State Limit for Two Parallel Internalisation Routes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 The Linear Adsorption Limit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.1 Model Formulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.2 Analytical Solution for Steady-State . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.3 Analytical Solution for the Transient . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.4 The Impact of the Radius . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.5 The Approach to Steady-State After a Maximum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Physicochemical Kinetics and Transport at Biointerfaces Edited by H. P. van Leeuwen and W. Ko¨ster. ß 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
149 150 150
150 153 155 155 155 156 160 160 160 161 162 163
148 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
2.3.6
How Long Does it Take to Reach Steady-State? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.7 Discriminating the Individual Parameters of the Product kKH Through the Cumulative Plot. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4 The Diffusional Steady-State (dSS) Approach . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.1 The Essence of the dSS Approach . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.2 Linear Adsorption . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.3 Langmuirian Adsorption . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.3.1 One Site Adsorbing and Internalising . . . . . 2.4.3.2 Two Sites: Site 1 ¼ Adsorption þ Internalisation, Site 2 ¼ Adsorption Only . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Biouptake When Mass Transfer is Coupled With Chemical Reaction (Complex Media) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 Mathematical Formulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 Totally Inert Complexes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Fully Labile Complexes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Partially Labile Complexes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.1 The Limiting Supply Flux in the Steady-State Uptake Considering Homogeneous Kinetics . . . . . . . 3.4.2 The Degree of Lability and Lability Criteria . . . . . . . 3.4.3 Combining Supply and Internalisation. . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5 Relationship with the FIAM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Key Factors and Challenges For Future Research in Biouptake Modelling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 Refinements Based on Mass Transport Factors . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.1 Finite Media. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.2 Nonstagnant Media . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.3 Complex Media . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Refinements Based on Adsorption Processes. . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.1 Adsorption Isotherm and Kinetics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.2 Competition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 Refinements Based on Internalisation Factors . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3.1 Internalisation Kinetics. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3.2 Efflux . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Glossary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix A: Notation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Latin Symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Greek Symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
165
168 170 170 172 175 175
176 178 178 180 180 182 182 183 184 186 190 190 190 192 192 193 193 193 194 194 194 194 195 195 196 196 197 198
J. GALCERAN AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN
1
149
INTRODUCTION
Biological systems are open to the exchange of matter with their environment. If species from the medium (either nutrients or pollutants) travel towards the membrane and a net increase in their concentration arises in the cell, then an uptake process is occurring. Apart from the obvious importance for the organism itself, there is an impact on the medium (e.g. regulating the fate of pollutants in the environment). Modelling biouptake processes helps in the understanding of the key factors involved and their interconnection [1]. In this chapter, uptake is considered in a general sense, without distinction between nutrition or toxicity, in which several elementary processes come together, and among which we highlight diffusion, adsorption and internalisation [2–4]. We show how the combination of the equations corresponding with a few elementary physical laws leads to a complex behaviour which can be physically relevant. Some reviews on the subject, from different perspectives, are available in the literature [2,5–7]. Here we discuss in some detail a few recent models for biouptake, highlighting their physicochemical basis, especially the diffusive transport involved. Numerical examples are usually taken from the biouptake literature on bacteria and algae, because the uptake occurs across a single membrane and the application of the modelling is simpler; thus no exploration is done of more ‘macroscale’ models based such as those based on compartments [4,8]. The goal is to help the reader in the building up of a coherent picture of the various processes and their mathematical modelling, taking into account their relative importance and the specific equations describing them (e.g. Henry or Langmuir adsorption isotherm). Special attention is paid to analytical solutions – even if their applicability requires simplifying assumptions – as they can provide primary understanding for the main trends in global behaviour. We shall consider spherical microorganisms [9] (see ref. [10] for spheroidal shapes), but the treatment applies equally well to cases of larger organisms where the uptake takes place in individual, well-separated microregions. The planar case can be found by letting r0 tend to infinity. We recall from Chapter 3 (this volume) that planar semi-infinite diffusion without any convection cannot sustain steady-state, which is attainable in practice only for sufficiently small radii. We will first deal with the uptake of a species that diffuses towards the biosurface without coupled chemical reactions in the medium (Section 2) and then move to the case of a coupled reaction (Section 3). Dynamic aspects are then highlighted, because it might not be realistic to assume that the species being taken up is in equilibrium in the medium surrounding the microorganism [11]. The idea of kinetics possibly being relevant was pioneered by Jackson and Morgan [12] and Whitfield and Turner [9], and then experimentally proved by Hudson and Morel [13] with regard to Fe
150 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
uptake. The consideration of further physical phenomena is discussed in Section 4. A list of the symbols used is given in Appendix A. 2 UNCOMPLICATED MASS TRANSFER OF THE SPECIES BEING TAKEN UP 2.1 A TRANSIENT MODEL FOR TWO PARALLEL INTERNALISATION ROUTES 2.1.1 General Model with Two Types of Langmuirian Adsorption Sites Coupled to First-Order Internalisation Processes Let us consider the uptake of a given species, either a nutrient or a pollutant heavy metal or an organic (macro)molecule, etc., which will be referred to as M. M is present in the bulk of the medium at a concentration, cM , and we assume that the only relevant mode of transport from the medium to the organism’s surface is diffusion. The internalisation sites are taken to be located on the spherical surface of the microorganism or in a semi-spherical surface of a specialised region of the organism with radius r0 (see Figure 1). Thus, diffusion prescribes: " # qcM (r, t) q2 cM (r, t) 2 qcM (r, t) ¼ DM þ qt qr2 r qr
(1)
In the most general case considered here, M is adsorbed on two kinds of sites, labelled ‘1’ and ‘2’. Each adsorption process is assumed to be fast enough (when
Medium
Organism
r0
Mads,1
Minter
M
M
Mads,2
Figure 1. Outline of the uptake model showing the spherical diffusion of species M through the medium towards two different sites where adsorption is followed by internalisation. The radius of the organism is taken as r0
J. GALCERAN AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN
151
compared with diffusion or the internalisation process) as to be described by a Langmuir (equilibrium) isotherm relating the coverage fraction of each kind of site (y1 and y2 , respectively) and the local concentration of M at the organism surface: cM (r0 , t): y1 (t) ¼
G1 (t) cM ðr0 , tÞ G2 (t) cM ðr0 , tÞ ; y2 (t) ¼ ¼ ¼ Gmax,1 KM,1 þ cM ðr0 , tÞ Gmax,2 KM,2 þ cM ðr0 , tÞ
(2)
where Gj stands for the surface concentration associated with sites of type j, and KM,1 and KM,2 are a type of adsorption constant. The adsorption process can thus be considered as the coordination of M with a finite number of transport sites on the surface of the microorganism [3,11,14,15]. Once adsorbed, we assume that M is internalised following a first-order kinetic process in each of the sites, with internalisation rate constants k1 and k2 respectively [9,16–18]. For each kind of adsorption site, we have an uptake flux given by: Ju, j (t) ¼ kj Gmax , j
cM (r0 , t) KM, j þ cM (r0 , t)
j ¼ 1, 2
(3)
which can be seen as a Michaelis–Menten-like expression, with KM, j called the half-saturation constant or bioaffinity parameter [13,14,19]. Within the hypothesis of adsorption equilibrium, the usual Michelis–Menten coefficient KM, j ¼ kdesorption, j þ kj =kadsorption, j kdesorption, j =kadsorption, j (usually kdesorption, j > kj , due to the fast adsorption process), thus becomes the inverse of the usual Langmuir coefficient [4,13,15] (which is indicative of the stability of the surface complex). For a constant ‘cell quota’ (as amount of M per unit biomass) [20], Ju can be related to the rate of growth of biomass, and equation (3) has been described in the uptake context as a Monod expression [16,21]. Thus, the fundamental boundary condition arising from the flux balance at r ¼ r0 can be written as: dG1 (t) dG2 (t) qcM (r, t) þ ¼ DM k1 G1 (t) k2 G2 (t) dt dt qr r¼r0
(4)
simply expressing that the change in adsorbed amounts follows from the difference between the diffusive supply flux and the internalisation rates. The remaining boundary condition for the diffusion equation (1) is semiinfinite diffusion:
152 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
cM (r, t) ¼ cM
r!1
t0
(5)
and the initial distribution of M is assumed to be homogeneous: cM (r, t) ¼ cM
r r0
t¼0
(6)
As expected from the presence of nonlinear terms in the boundary conditions, no analytical solution for the problem defined by equations (1)–(6) is available to our knowledge, so a numerical strategy is applied here. As seen in ref. [22], the problem given by the differential equation (1) with boundary conditions (4)–(6) can be recast in the form of an integral equation for cM (r0 , t): ðt DM 1 cM ðr0 , tÞ cM pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi dt cM t pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi r0 pDM 0 r0 t t ðt DM cM ðr0 , tÞ dt k1 G1 (t) þ k2 G2 (t) þ r0 0
G1 (t) þ G2 (t) ¼
(7)
and the numerical solution of this equation can be obtained by discretising the unknown cM ðr0 , tÞ. Once the value of cM (r0 , t) (which for simplicity will be denoted as c0M from now on) is known, any physical quantity of the system can be computed. In particular, the incoming diffusive (or mass transport) flux: Jm (t) ¼ DM
qcM (r, t) qr r¼r0
(8)
has been selected in this work as a relevant response function. For the general case considered here, equation (4) can be reorganised as: Jm (t) ¼
dG1 (t) dG2 (t) þ þ k1 G1 (t) þ k2 G2 (t) dt dt
(9)
where fluxes towards the organism are counted positively (see Chapters 1 and 3 of this volume). The bioaccumulated amount, Fu , is the time integral of the uptake flux: Fu (t)
ðt Ju (t)dt
(10)
0
representing the amount of matter that has been internalised per unit of surface area. The product 4pr20 Fu is the number of moles taken up per individual cell from the beginning of the process, i.e. the cell quota [23]. On the other hand, the total supply from the medium can be defined as:
J. GALCERAN AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN
Fm (t)
153
ðt Jm (t)dt
(11)
0
The relationship between the accumulated fluxes can be easily found by integrating the boundary condition (4) as: Fm (t) ¼ Fu (t) þ G1 (t) þ G2 (t)
(12)
which is nothing else than mass conservation of M. 2.1.2
Typical Results for the Case of Two Internalisation Routes
Figure 2 plots the evolution of the incoming fluxes Jm and Ju with time for some typical values from the literature [24,25] and references therein. As expected, the diffusive flux Jm decreases with time and tends towards a steady-state value when converging with Ju . It is noticeable that, in the initial transient, the internalisation flux Ju is much closer to its eventual steady-state 1.00
1.6
0.90
1.4
0.70 1.0
0.60 0.50
0.8 Ju
q
J /10−10 mol m−2 s−1
0.80
q1
Jm
1.2
0.40
0.6
0.30 0.4 0.20
q2
0.2
0.10 0.00
0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5 t/s
6
7
8
9
10
Figure 2. Evolution of diffusive (Jm , continuous line) and internalisation (Ju , circles) fluxes with time for a system with two internalisation sites (Section 2.1.2). Fraction of coverages of each site type, y1 and y2 , are indicated with dashed lines. Parameters: DM ¼ 109 m2 s1 , cM ¼ 104 mol m3 , r0 ¼ 104 m, KM,1 ¼ 105 mol m3 , KM,2 ¼ 103 mol m3 , Gmax,1 ¼ 108 mol m2 , Gmax,2 ¼ 1011 mol m2 , k1 ¼ 102 s1 and k2 ¼ 1 s1
154 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
value than Jm , whose values are huge for short t. Plots on suitable scales establish that Ju goes through a maximum (of around 9:1735 1011 mol m2 s1 ) for t 148 s, which is slightly larger than the steady-state flux of around 9:1734 1011 mol m2 s1 . Obviously, such a small maximum is irrelevant for practical purposes, but other maxima – for other sets of parameters – could appear to be more prominent. For more detailed discussion on these maxima (for the simpler case of linear adsorption), see Section 2.3.5. It is also seen in Figure 2 that there is no saturation of either of the two kinds of sites (the largest coverage is about 90% for sites of type 1), because cSS M is too small. The shape of the various Ju versus t plots reflects the impact of different maximum coverages for each of the site types. Figure 3 shows a system with the same parameters as in Figure 2, but with Gmax,2 a factor of 1000 higher. At around 0.2 s, sites 1 (with high affinity and same Gmax ) depart from the linear regime of the isotherm; a smaller fraction of the supply accumulates on G1 ; c0M increases more steeply and so does the flux Ju,2 and consequently Ju . Sites of type 2 are always in the linear regime; the curvature of Ju,2 (e.g. at 1.2 s) being due to the progressive achievement of the steady-state concentration
10
2.0 Ju
9
Ju,2
8
1.8 Jm
1.4
7
1.2
6
1.0
5
0.8
4
0.6
3
0.4
2
0.2 0.0 0.0
1
Ju,1
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
Ju /10−10 mol m−2 s−1
Jm /10−8 mol m−2 s−1
1.6
2.5
0 3.0
t /s
Figure 3. Plot of fluxes (solving integral equation (7) numerically) for parameters in Figure 2, but Gmax,2 ¼ 108 mol m2 . The individual uptake fluxes for sites of type 1 (Ju,1 , þ ) and sites of type 2 (Ju,2 , ) are added to provide the total flux Ju (s). The inflexions in Jm arise from the saturation of sites of type 2 and from the approach to the steady-state
J. GALCERAN AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN
155
c0M cSS M KM,2 . When the inflexions in (the increasing) Ju occur, there are also the inflexions of (the decreasing) Jm , because Ju increases with c0M , but Jm decreases with c0M . For a detailed discussion on the effects of the parameters on the fluxes, see ref. [22]. 2.1.3 A Particular Case: One Internalisation Route and One Adsorption-Only Route We deal now with two parallel Langmuir adsorption steps, only one of which is followed by internalisation. Parameters of the site with both adsorption and internalisation will be denoted with subscript 1 (physiologically active site), while the other, with no internalisation, will be denoted with subscript 2 (physiologically inactive site) [2]. 2.1.3.1 Transient The numerical solution of this case can be obtained by setting k2 ¼ 0 in the expressions for the general model of two routes (or ‘mouths’) described in Section 2.1.1. Now, material adsorbed on site 2 simply acts as a reservoir, buffering c0M . 2.1.3.2 Steady-State If one defines the limiting biouptake flux for each site (which would appear for cSS M much larger than each KM, j ) as [26]: Ju, j (t) ¼ kj Gmax, j
j ¼ 1, 2
(13)
the internalisation flux Ju (for steady-state) can be written as: Ju ¼ k1 Gmax,1
cSS cSS M M ¼ Ju,1 SS K M, 1 þ c M KM,1 þ cSS M
(14)
which depends only on the parameters of site 1 because, for steady-state fluxes, the adsorption-only route is irrelevant. So, results in this section also apply when there are only internalising sites present. SS can be written: The supply flux Jm c cSS DM cM cSS cSS SS M M Jm ¼ J (15) ¼ DM M ¼ 1 M 1 m r0 r0 cM cM where: Jm DM cM =r0
(16)
is the limiting supply flux, namely the product of bulk concentration and the mass transfer coefficient DM =r0 (see Chapter 3).
156 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
The result of equating the steady-state fluxes, equations (14) and (15), is sometimes known as the Best equation [9,13,16,27–31] which we normalise to its most elementary parameters [26] (other normalisations have also been suggested [21]): ( 1=2 ) (1 þ a þ b) 4b 1 1 J~ ¼ 2b (1 þ a þ b)2
(17)
where J~ is the normalised flux: SS J~ Jm =Ju
(18)
(with Ju ¼ Ju,1 , if there is a second noninternalising site) a is the normalised bioaffinity parameter: a ¼ KM =cM
(19)
(with KM ¼ KM,1 , if there is a second noninternalising site) and b the limiting flux ratio: b ¼ Ju =Jm
(20)
Equation (17) shows quite elegantly that the biouptake flux is governed by the two fundamental parameters a and b. A set values of J~ is easily of limiting derived by using that (1 x)1=2 approaches 1 12 x for x 1. If we consider, by way of example, an organism with a relatively low affinity for M (a 1) in a medium with a relatively high transport flux (b 1), then equation (17) reduces to: ( 1=2 ) a 4b 1 1 2 J~ ¼ 2b a
(21)
which, since for this case 4b=a2 is much smaller than unity, approaches J~ ¼ 1=a or
SS Jm ¼ Ju cM =KM
(22)
2.2 THE STEADY-STATE LIMIT FOR TWO PARALLEL INTERNALISATION ROUTES Let us now consider the simple case of steady-state, towards which the transient solution tends when t ! 1 but which, for sufficiently small r0 , is practically
J. GALCERAN AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN
157
reached within a very short time. In this case, the balance of flux, equation (4), can be written as [18]: DM
cM cSS cSS cSS M M M ¼ k1 Gmax,1 þ k2 Gmax,2 SS r0 K M, 1 þ c M KM,2 þ cSS M
(23)
This is a cubic equation of the unknown quantity cSS M which is the eventual concentration at the surface of the organism. Then, the resulting steady-state flux can be computed using either side of equation (23). Some insight on the effect of the parameters on the mathematical solution can be gained through a graphical procedure. The basic idea is to plot the uptake and diffusive fluxes as functions of a variable concentration on the surface c0M (i.e. cM (r0 )) and seek their intersection. It is therefore convenient dSS to introduce the ‘diffusive steady-state’ (dSS, see Section 2.4 below) flux, Jm , or flux corresponding to the diffusion profile conforming to the steady-state situation for a given surface concentration c0M : dSS Jm DM
cM c0M r0
(24)
14 12 10 8 6 4
Ju −0.0011
2
−0.0008
−0.0005 cM(r0)/mol m−3
−0.0002
Ju
0 0.0001 −2
J /10−10 mol m−2 s−1
JmdSS
−4 −6
Figure 4. Graphical determination of the three real solutions of the cubic equation (23) corresponding with the steady-state case. The diffusive flux JmdSS (a straight line with negative slope) and the uptake flux Ju are plotted as a function of the variable cM (r0 ) (including physically meaningless negative values). Ju is the addition of two hyperbolae dSS (for Ju,1 and Ju,2 ) with its asymptotes plotted as dashed lines. The intersections of Jm and Ju yield the three solutions, from which one is positive (the physically relevant) and the remaining two real and negative. Parameters as in Figure 2, except r0 ¼ 103 m, Gmax,1 ¼ 5 109 mol m2 , Gmax,2 ¼ 1012 mol m2 and k2 ¼ 10 s1
158 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
As depicted in Figure 4, all the solutions for cSS M can be found graphically at dSS (which is a straight line of slope DM =r0 ) with the each intersection of Jm curve for Ju ¼ Ju,1 þ Ju,2 (which is the sum of two hyperbolae with their corresponding vertical asymptotes at c0M ¼ KM,1 and at c0M ¼ KM,2 ). Due to the positive character of all the physical constants, one concludes that there is only one positive (physically meaningful) solution of equation (23). The above graphical method, where the fluxes are plotted in terms of c0M (in the region c0M > 0), can help in rationalising the impact of several parameters on the steady-state flux (as well as in the graphical solution of the cubic equation with a spreadsheet). Each diagonal line in Figure 5a represents the diffusive flux dSS versus c0M for different cM values (given by the intercept with the abscissas). Jm As seen in Figure 5a, at low cM , a small change in cM implies a large shift SS (upwards) of the ordinate of the intersection (a large change in Jm ) within the linear region of the Ju curve. On the other hand, at large cM , the impact of changing cM on the ordinate of the intersection point is low, because in this region the uptake flux approaches its maximum value: Ju ¼ Ju,1 þ Ju,2 ¼ k1 Gmax,1 þ k2 Gmax,2
(25)
SS Figure 5b shows the resulting steady-state flux Jm (obtained as the positive SS solution for cM from equation (23)) for a range of cM values. At low cM values (usually associated with low cSS M values), there is a linear dependence between SS and cM , as expected from the linearisation of the Langmuir isotherms (see Jm equation (31), below). At large cM values, the usual Michaelis–Menten saturating effect of cM is also seen. From inspection of equation (23), it follows that the effects of r0 and DM dSS are opposed. Three Jm versus cM (r0 ) plots for different ratios DM =r0 are shown as straight lines with different slopes in Figure 5c, converging at a common point at c0M ¼ cM . Thus, the steady-state flux increases with DM =r0 up to an asymptotic value given by the maximum (at this cM ) uptake flux c c SS ! Ju,1 KM,1Mþc þ Ju,2 KM,2Mþc < Ju . The overall effect of changing organism Jm M M SS size (i.e. r0 ) on the Jm can be seen in Figure 5d, which exhibits a sigmoidal c c shape (falling practically from Ju,1 KM,1Mþc þ Ju,2 KM,2Mþc to 0) when the ratio M M spans over a large interval, but could be experimentally seen as practically linear even for certain regular variation ranges of r0 . The same analysis can be performed on the effect of the similar parameters SS increases when any of them k1 , Gmax ,1 , k2 and Gmax,2 . The steady-state flux Jm increases. As seen in Figure 5f for the particular case of Gmax,1 variation, there SS are two asymptotic limits for Jm given by the fixed Ju,2 (at low Gmax,1 ) and by the fixed limiting diffusion value (see equation (16) and Figure 5e).
J. GALCERAN AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN 2.0 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
159
1.2
(a)
(b)
J /10−10 mol m−2 s−1
J /10−10 mol m−2 s−1
1.0
Ju
cM* =
10−4 mol m−3
cM* = 5⫻10−5 mol m−3 0
0.00005
cM* = 2⫻10−4 mol m−3
0.00015
* Ju,1
0.6 0.4
* Ju,2
JmSS
* cM * KM,1 + cM * cM
* KM,2 + cM
0.2
cM* = 1.5⫻10−4 mol m−3
0.0001
0.8
0.0
0.0002
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
(c)
5.0
DM −6 −1 r0 = 2.5⫻10 m s
1.0
DM −6 −1 r0 = 10 m s
Ju
J /10−10 mol m−2 s−1
J /10−10 mol m−2 s−1
3.0 2.0
0.0 0
0.00002
0.00004
0.00006
0.00008
0.0001
J*u
1.00 0.80
J*u,1
0.60 0.40
J*u,2
* cM
* KM,1 + cM
JmSS
* cM
* KM,2 + cM
0.20 0.00 −6
−5
−4
−3
cM(r0)/mol m−3
−2
−1
0
log (r0/ m)
(e)
2.0
J /10−10 mol m−2 s−1
1.5
Gmax,1=2×10−8 mol m−2 Gmax,1=5×10−9 mol m−2
0.5
0.0 0
0.00002
0.00004
0.00006
cM(r0)/mol m−3
0.00008
0.0001
J /10−10 mol m−2 s−1
Gmax,1=2×10−8 mol m−2
1.0
1
(d)
1.20 DM −6 −1 r0 = 5⫻10 m s
4.0
0.9
* /10−3 mol m−3 cM
cM(r0)/mol m−3
1.0 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0.0 0.0
(f)
J*m
JmSS
Ju,2
0.5
1.0
J *u,2 1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
Gmax,1 /10 −8 mol m−2
SS Figure 5. Effect of the model parameters on the steady-state flux Jm illustrated by the graphical procedure (left column), and the corresponding outcome (right column) with rest of parameters as in Figure 4, except Gmax,1 ¼ 5 108 mol m2 for (a)–(d) and DM ¼ 109 m2 s1 for (d). SS dSS (a) Impact of cM on Jm . Straight lines with negative slope indicate the diffusive flux Jm for different cM . Circles stand for the uptake flux Ju , sum of two terms like equation (3). Each intersection between a straight line and the quasi-hyperbolic succession of circles SS corresponding with that cM value. yields the Jm SS on cM . The maximum values expected for Ju, j at each bulk (b) Dependence of Jm concentration are also depicted. SS dSS . Straight lines indicate Jm at different (c) Impact of the relationship DM =r0 on Jm DM =r0 values.
160 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
2.3 2.3.1
THE LINEAR ADSORPTION LIMIT Model Formulation
For sufficiently low coverages (such as those expected for low bulk concentrations, e.g. trace pollutants), the adsorption isotherms, equation (2), revert to linear ones: G1 (t) cM (r0 , t) ; Gmax,1 K M, 1
G2 (t) cM (r0 , t) Gmax,2 K M, 2
(26)
then equation (4) can be written as: KH
dcM (r0 ) qcM (r) kKH cM (r0 ) ¼ DM dt qr r¼r0
(27)
with an effective linear (Henry) adsorption coefficient: KH ¼
Gmax,1 Gmax,2 þ KM,1 KM,2
(28)
and an effective internalisation rate constant: k1 Gmax,1 k2 Gmax,2 Gmax,1 Gmax,2 k¼ þ þ KM,1 K M, 2 K M, 1 K M, 2 k1 Gmax,1 KM,2 þ k2 Gmax,2 KM,1 ¼ Gmax,1 KM,2 þ Gmax,2 KM,1
2.3.2
(29)
Analytical Solution for Steady-State
The steady-state solution associated with equation (27) is: (d) Dependence of JmSS on the logarithm of the radius. Notice that for r0 ! 0, c c SS ! Ju,1 KM,1Mþc þ Ju,2 KM, 2Mþc < Ju as diffusion is no longer limiting. For r0 ! 1, Jm M M SS Jm vanishes. SS . The straight line indicates JmdSS . Each succession of (e) Impact of Gmax,1 change on Jm circles indicates the uptake flux Ju at a given Gmax,1 (5 109 mol m2 , 108 mol m2 and 2 108 mol m2 ). SS on Gmax,1 (solid line). Notice that for Gmax,1 ! 0, JmSS ! (f) Dependence of Jm SS Ju,2 (cSS M ) (O) and that Ju,2 (cM ) < Ju,2 ¼ k2 Gmax,2 (dashed line). For Gmax,1 ! 1, SS ^ Jm ! Jm ( )
J. GALCERAN AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN
cSS M ¼
cM 1 þ ðkKH r0 =DMÞ
161
(30)
from which the steady-state diffusion flux can be computed as [11,21]: SS Jm ¼
DM cM cM ¼ r0 þ (DM =kKH ) (r0 =DM ) þ (1=kKH )
(31)
This expression has been interpreted as the total ‘resistance’, being the sum of the diffusion ðr0 =DM Þ and adsorption þ internalisation (1=kKH ) resistances [11,32] or a combination of permeabilities [19]. If the couple: adsorption þ internalisation is much more effective than diffusion (kKH DM =r0 ), then cSS M ! 0 and we recover the steady-state maximum uptake flux for a spherical organism Jm . 2.3.3
Analytical Solution for the Transient
It can be shown (see [33–35]), that the expression for the flux can be expressed in terms of the auxiliary parameters a and b: pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi DM r0 þ DM r0 4 DM KH þ kKH2 r0 a pffiffiffiffi 2KH r0 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi DM r0 DM r0 4 DM KH þ kKH2 r0 b pffiffiffiffi 2KH r0
(32)
(33)
type of combination of parameter values Thus, if a ¼ b, that is, for a particular
DM r0 ¼ 4 DM KH þ kKH2 r0 : rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi SS Jm Jm 1 DM t 1 2 2 p ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi þ ¼ þ DM cM DM cM p KH r0 pDM t " # pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi DM t 4KH 1 1 2 2 DM t F þ 2 2KH KH KH r0 2KH r0 where: F(x) exp x2 erfc(x) For the more general case with a 6¼ b:
(34)
162 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES SS Jm Jm 1 ¼ þ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi DM cM DM cM pDM t pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffi 2 DM DM a þ F(a t) 2 KH r0 (a b) KH r0 a(a b) KH (a b) pffiffiffiffi pffiffi 2 DM DM b F(b t) 2 KH r0 (a b) KH r0 b(a b) KH (a b)
(35)
From the previous expressions, the accumulated uptakes (Fu and Fm , see equation (11)) follow by simple integration [35]. 2.3.4
The Impact of the Radius
Figure 6 shows the evolution of Jm with time, for three different radii. As expected from the enhanced diffusion efficiency, the smaller the radius, the sooner steady-state values are approached. For a large radius of 1 mm, after SS (in practice, with such long 200 s, the value of Jm is still approximately twice Jm times, convection will usually overrule the pure diffusion conditions). It can also be seen in Figure 6 that larger radii yield larger fluxes at intermediSS ate times, while Jm decreases with increasing r0 . Plots at very short times (not 3.00
Jm /10−5 mol m−2 s−1
2.50
2.00
1.50
1.00
0.50
0.00 0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5 t /s
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
Figure 6. Impact of the microorganism radius, r0 , on the time evolution of the diffusive flux Jm (given by equations (34) and (35)). Three curves are depicted: u (r0 ¼ 10 mm), n (r0 ¼ 100 mm) and þ (r0 ¼ 1 mm). Parameters: KH ¼ 2 105 m, k ¼ 5 105 s1 , DM ¼ 109 m2 s1 , cM ¼ 1 mol m3
J. GALCERAN AND H. P. VAN LEEUWEN
163
shown here) indicate larger fluxes for smaller radii, as expected from the enhanced diffusion transport towards microbodies. The inversion of the order in the fluxes at intermediate times can be explained as larger radii producing more gradually decreasing fluxes than smaller radii. 2.3.5
The Approach to Steady-State After a Maximum
As seen in Figure 7, the surface concentration c0M attains a maximum, overshooting the steady-state concentration value. It has been shown theoretically [35] that the maximum appears for any combination of parameters’ values. Experimental evidence of the appearance of transient uptake rate maxima (which might be totally or partially related to the maximum predicted by the present uptake model) has already been reported [36–39]. The maximum can be physically understood as a result of the simultaneous settling of two processes: adsorption governing short times (see Section 3.2, below) and internalisation ruling longer times. If only adsorption were present (i.e. k ¼ 0), the final cM ðr0 , tÞ value would be cM . So, at relatively short times, for the combined processes, the surface concentration ‘aims at’ a value closer to cM than the eventual cSS M value, overshooting it. After the maximum (longer times), cM ðr0 , tÞ is relatively large, and the corresponding Ju cannot match the
0.25
* cM(r0,t)/cM
0.20 k = 10−2 s−1
0.15
0.10
k = 10−3 s−1
0.05 k = 10−4 s−1 0.00 0
500
1000
1500
2000 t /s
2500
3000
3500
4000
Figure 7. Evolution of cM ðr0 , tÞ=cM for three different combinations of KH and k yielding a common product 105 m s1 . Curves for k ¼ 102 s1 , k ¼ 103 s1 and 9 2 1 m s k ¼ 104 s1 converge towards cSS M =cM ¼ 0:09. Other parameters: DM ¼ 10 and r0 ¼ 1 mm
164 PHYSICOCHEMICAL KINETICS AND TRANSPORT AT BIOINTERFACES
‘exhausted’ diffusive flux Jm (due to the depleted surroundings of the surface). Then, cM ðr0 , tÞ begins to decrease towards cSS M . Such a type of overshoot, a typical transient phenomenon, was already seen for adsorption–internalisation in planar geometry [40] and for the electrodic conversion affected by a slow preceding chemical reaction [41]. Figure 8