Lecture Notes in Mathematics Editors: J.-M. Morel, Cachan F. Takens, Groningen B. Teissier, Paris
830
J.A. Green
Polynomial Representations of GLn 2nd corrected and augmented edition
with an Appendix on Schensted Correspondence and Littelmann Paths by K. Erdmann, J.A. Green and M. Schocker
ABC
Author and co-authors for the appendix James A. Green 19 Long Close Oxford OX2 9SG United Kingdom e-mail:
[email protected]
Manfred Schocker Department of Mathematics University of Wales Swansea Singleton Park, Swansea SA2 8PP United Kingdom e-mail:
[email protected]
Karin Erdmann Mathematical Institute University of Oxford 24-29 St Giles Oxford OX1 3LB United Kingdom e-mail:
[email protected]
Library of Congress Control Number: 2006934862 Mathematics Subject Classification (2000): Primary: 20C30, 20G05, 20G15, 16S50, 17B99, 05E10 ISSN print edition: 0075-8434 ISSN electronic edition: 1617-9692 ISBN-10 3-540-46944-3 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York ISBN-13 978-3-540-46944-5 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York DOI 10.1007/3-540-46944-3 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springer.com c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2007 ° The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typesetting by the authors using a Springer LATEX package Cover design: WMXDesign GmbH, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper
SPIN: 11008118
VA41/3100/SPi
543210
Preface to the second edition
This second edition of “Polynomial representations of GLn (K)” consists of two parts. The first part is a corrected version of the original text, formatted in LATEX, and retaining the original numbering of sections, equations, etc. The second is an Appendix, which is largely independent of the first part, but which leads to an algebra L(n, r), defined by P. Littelmann, which is analogous to the Schur algebra S(n, r). It is hoped that, in the future, there will be a structure theory of L(n, r) rather like that which underlies the construction of Kac-Moody Lie algebras. We use two operators which act on “words”. The first of these is due to C. Schensted (1961). The second is due to Littelmann, and goes back to a 1938 paper by G. de B. Robinson on the representations of a finite symmetric group. Littelmann’s operators form the basis of his elegant and powerful “path model” of the representation theory of classical groups. In our Appendix we use Littelmann’s theory only in its simplest case, i.e. for GLn . Essential to my plan was to establish two basic facts connecting the operations of Schensted and Littelmann. To these “facts”, or rather conjectures, I gave the names Theorem A and Proposition B. Many examples suggested that these conjectures are true, and not particularly deep. But I could not prove either of them. This work was therefore stalled, until I sought the help of my colleagues Karin Erdmann and Manfred Schocker. They accepted the challenge, and within a few weeks produced proofs of both conjectures. Their proofs constitute the heart of the Appendix, and make it possible to begin a comparison of the Littelmann algebra L(n, r) with the Schur algebra S(n, r). Karin and Manfred have made this Appendix possible, and have written large parts of the text. It has been a happy experience for me to work with them. A few weeks before the final manuscript of the Appendix was ready, we heard that A. Lascoux, B. Leclerc and J.-Y. Thibon have published a work
VI
Preface
on “The plactic monoid”, which contains results equivalent to Theorem A and Proposition B. Their methods are rather different from ours, and they prove also many important facts which do not come into our Appendix. We give a brief summary of this work in §D.11. Oxford, August 2006
Sandy (J. A.) Green
Contents
Polynomial representations of GLn 1
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
2
Polynomial Representations of GLn (K): The Schur algebra 2.1 Notation, etc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 The categories MK (n), MK (n, r) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 The Schur algebra SK (n, r) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4 The map e : KΓ → SK (n, r) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Modular theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6 The module E ⊗r . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7 Contravariant duality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8 AK (n, r) as KΓ-bimodule . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11 11 12 13 14 16 17 19 21
3
Weights and Characters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 Weights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 Weight spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Some properties of weight spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Characters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5 Irreducible modules in MK (n, r) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
23 23 23 24 26 28
4
The modules Dλ,K . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 Preamble . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 λ-tableaux . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 Bideterminants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4 Definition of Dλ,K . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5 The basis theorem for Dλ,K . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6 The Carter-Lusztig lemma . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7 Some consequences of the basis theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8 James’s construction of Dλ,K . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
33 33 33 34 35 36 37 39 40
VIII
Contents
5
The Carter-Lusztig modules Vλ,K . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1 Definition of Vλ,K . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 Vλ,K is Carter-Lusztig’s “Weyl module” . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3 The Carter-Lusztig basis for Vλ,K . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4 Some consequences of the basis theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 Contravariant forms on Vλ,K . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.6 Z-forms of Vλ,K . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
43 43 43 45 47 48 50
6
Representation theory of the symmetric group . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1 The functor f : MK (n, r) → mod KG(r) (r ≤ n) . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2 General theory of the functor f : mod S → mod eSe . . . . . . . . . . 6.3 Application I. Specht modules and their duals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4 Application II. Irreducible KG(r)-modules, char K = p . . . . . . . 6.5 Application III. The functor f : MK (N, r) → MK (n, r) (N ≥ n) 6.6 Application IV. Some theorems on decomposition numbers . . .
53 53 55 57 60 65 67
Appendix: Schensted correspondence and Littelmann paths A
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.1 Preamble . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.2 The Robinson-Schensted algorithm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.3 The operators e˜c , f˜c . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.4 What is to be done . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
73 73 74 75 78
B
The Schensted Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B.1 Notations for tableaux . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B.2 The map Sch : I(n, r) → T (n, r) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B.3 Inserting a letter into a tableau . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B.4 Examples of the Schensted process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B.5 Proof that (µ, U, V ) ← x1 belongs to T (n, r) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B.6 The inverse Schensted process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B.7 The ladder . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
81 81 81 82 85 88 89 92
C
Schensted and Littelmann operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 C.1 Preamble . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 C.2 Unwinding a tableau . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 C.3 Knuth’s theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103 C.4 The “if” part of Knuth’s theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107 C.5 Littelmann operators on tableaux . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 C.6 The proof of Proposition B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 116
D
Theorem A and some of its consequences . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 D.1 Ingredients for the proof of Theorem A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 D.2 Proof of Theorem A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 124 D.3 Properties of the operator C . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127
Contents
IX
D.4 The Littelmann algebra L(n, r) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 129 D.5 The modules MQ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 131 D.6 The λ-rectangle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134 D.7 Canonical maps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 135 D.8 The algebra structure of L(n, r) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137 D.9 The character of Mλ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 139 D.10 The Littlewood–Richardson Rule . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 140 D.11 Lascoux, Leclerc and Thibon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 143 E
Tables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 147 E.1 Schensted’s decomposition of I(3, 3) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 147 E.2 The Littelmann graph I(3, 3) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 148
Index of symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 151 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 155 Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 159
§I.
Introduction Issai Schur determined the polynomial replesentations of the complex
general linear group in 1901.
GLn(¢)
in his doctoral dissertation [S], published
This remarkable work contained many very original ideas, developed
with superb algebraic skill.
Schur showed that these representations are
completely reducible, that each irreducible one is "homogeneous" of some degree
r ~ 0
(see 2.2), and that the equivalence types of irreducible
polynomial representations of
GLn(~) ,
of fixed homogeneous degree
in one-one correspondence with the partitions not more than
n
parts.
see 3.5).
~I
in
n
kn)
of
are
r
into
Moreover Schur showed that the character of an
irreducible representation of type function
k = (~i'''"
r,
k
is given by a certain symmetric
variables (since described as a "Schur function";
An essential part of Schur's technique was to set up a correspond-
ence between representations of
GL (~) n
of fixed homogeneous degree
and representations of the finite symmetric group
G(r)
on
r
r,
symbols,
and through this correspondence to apply C. Frobenius's discovery of the characters of
G(r)
[F, 1900].
This pioneering achievement of Schur was one of the main inspirations for Hermann Weyl's monumental researches on the representation theory of semi-simple Lie groups [We, 1925, 1926].
Of course Weyl's methods,
based on the representation theory of the Lie algebra of the Lie group and the possibility of integrating over a compact form of
F,
F,
were very
different from the purely algebraic methods of Schur~s dissertation; in particular Weyl's general theory contained nothing to correspond to the symmetric group GLn(~),
G(r).
In 1927 Schur published another paper IS'] on
which has deservedly become a classic.
"dual" actions of
GLn(¢)
(see 2.6) to rederive
and
G(r)
on the
In this he exploited the
~ th
tensor-space
E~r
all the results of his 1901 dissertation in a new
and very economical way.
Weyl publicized the method of Schur's 1927 paper,
with its attractive use of the "double centralizer property",in his influential book "The Classical Groups" [We',1939]. in Chapters 3(B) and
4
of that book has become the
polynomial representations of
GL (~) n
standard treatment of
(and, incidentally, of
representation theory of the symmetric groups this explains the comparative neglect
In fact the exposition
G(r)),
Alfred Young's
and perhaps
of Schur's work of 1901.
I think
this neglect is a pity, because the methods of this earlier work are in some ways very much in keeping with the present-day ideas on representations of algebraic groups. in part
It is the purpose of these lectures to give some accounts,
based on the ideas of Schur's 1901 dissertation, of the polynomial
~epresentatlons of the general linear groups infinite field of arbitrary characteristic.
GLn(K),
where
K
is an
Our treatment will be "elementary" use algebraic interesting
in the sense that we shall not
group theory in our main discussion.
But it might be
to indicate here some general ideas from the representation
theory of algebraic
groups
inverse is not important
(or of algebraic
in this context),
semigroups,
since the group
which are relevant
to
our
work. Let
F
be any semigroup
associative multiplication) field.
A representation
space over
K)
~(IF) = ~V'
•
is a map
for all
identity map on
V.)
: KF-+ EndK(V);
(i.e.
is a set, equipped with an
with identity element of
F
on a
K-space
• : F ~EndK(V )
g, g' E F.
KF
T
~,
and let
V
(i.e.
which satisfies
(For any set
We can extend
here
F
V,
K
a vector T(gg')
= ~(g)~(g'),
we denote by
~V
linearly to give a map of
is the semlgroup-algebra
of
be any
F
the
K-algebras
over
K,
whose
We can make
KF
act
elements are all formal linear combinations
=
whose support on
V
by
Z g~F
supp K = {g ~ F : K
Kv = ~(~)(v) (V,~),
(V',~')
is, by definition,
bijective
representation KF-modules;
or simply
V. a
~'(g)f = f~(g)
is called a
a right
# 0}
g
A
K-map
and thereby get a left KF-module,
f : V ~ V'
for all
g E r.
Kr-modules
(i.e, A
f
(V,~),
is a linear map)
KF-map which is
or an equivalence
One has analogous
KF-module
is finite.
KF-map between such
KF-isomorphism,
~, ~'.
~ K, g
(~ ~ K~, v ~ V),
denoted
which satisfies
K Kgg,
definitions
between the
for right
can be regarded as a pair
(V,~)
where
T
: F ~ EndK(V)
i.e.
~(gg')
is an a n t i - r e p r e s e n t a t i o n
= ~(g')~(g)'
The set
KF
g ~ f(g)f'(g),
element If
~
s ~ F
of
KF
and
are defined
defined
takes each
f ~ KF
K-algebra
Lsf ,
Ls, R s
maps
homomorphism)
a representation
F
rifht
Thus
KF
KF-module
that if
s ~ F
on
and
(using
L).
f ~ KF
takes
that these actions
f ~ K F. f ® f'
: F ~K
KF
while
F.
for all
The identity 1K
of
f
of
K.
by
s
g ~ F.
In particular,
L : s ~ L
K-algebra L s, R s
both
R : s ~ Rs
gives
gives an anti-represent-
s
KF- module
(using
R)
actions by
and a o,
so
we write
and
f o s = L f. s (sof) o t = s o(fot) K F ® K F ~ K FxF
(®
to the function m a p p i n g s, t ~ F.
structure
on
and
F
for all means
F x F ~ K
s, t E F
~)
which
by
This linear map is injective
, and we use it to identify
8 : K F -* K F×F
to
given by
We denote both module
com~ute:
(f, f' ~ K F)
The semigroup
of
into itself and is a
K F ~ K F.
The~e is a linear map
(s,t) ~ f(s)f'(t),
g
is defined
It is easy to check that
K F,
s o f = R f s Notice
ff'
("point")
can be made into a left
and
e.g.
K-algebra,
to the identity element
Rsf
V,
g, g' E F.
R f : g ~ f(gs), s
EndK(KF ) .
ation.
K-space
is s commutative
"pointwise",
g ~ F
belong to the space of
f : F ~K
on the
then the left and r i g h t translates
to be the maps
Each of the operators
F
for all
for every element
L f : g ~ f(sg), s
map (i.e.
~ ~V
of all maps
with algebra operations take
~(IF)
of
KF @ KF
with a subspace of
gives rise to two maps
~ : K F -~ K~
K FxF.
as follows: Both
A,e
if are
f £ K F,
then
&f : (s,t) -~ f(st),
K-algebra maps.
and
~(f) = f(IF)-
We shall say that an element
f ~ K F is
finitary, or is a representative function, if it satisfies any one of the conditions
FI, F2, F3
<see e.g.
[H, Ch. 2]).
FI.
The left
below:
these three conditions are in fact equivalent
KF-submodule
KFof
generated by
f
is finite-
dimensional. F2.
The right
KF-submodule
foK/"
generated by
f
is finite-
dimensional. F3.
Af ~ K F ® K F.
(h
This means that there exist elements
fh' fh E K F
runs over some finite index set) such that
(Is)
Af =
[ih fh ® fh' "
This equation is equivalent to the system of equations
(ib)
f(st) =
~ h
fh(s)f{(t),
all
s, t 6 F.
It is also equivalent to each of the following systems
(ic)
tof =
Z f~(t)fh, h
all
t ( F,
fos =
~ fh(s)f~, h
all
s 6 F.
or (id)
The set
F = F(K F)
of all finitary functions
f: F ~ K
is a
K-bialgebra (see [Sw] for the definitions of coalgebras and bialgebras). It is a
K-subalgebra of
£F ~ F ~ F
K ~,
(this means that if
and is also closed to f
A
in the sense that
is finitary, then the functions
fh' fh F ,
in (la) can be chosen to be themselves finitary).
equipped ~ith the maps
these two structures on fact that
A
and
c
A : F ÷ F ~ F , ~ : F + K ,
F ,
of algebra and coalgebra,
are both
K - a l g e b r a maps
F i n i t a r y functions on
F
d i m e n s i o n a l r e p r e s e n t a t i o n s of on a f i n i t e - d i m e n s i o n a l V ,
z(g)v b = gv b =
Suppose
V °
rab(g)
~ K .
E rab(g)v a , a eB
The functions
c o e f f i c i e n t functions of
If
K-coalgebra;
are linked by the ~,
T
p. i ~ ) .
is a r e p r e s e n t a t i o n of
{vb : b e B)
T ,
or of the
KF-module
for
rab
is a
F
K-basis of
V .
g c F , b e B ;
: F ~ K (a,b g B)
or of the
of these functions is a subspace of T ,
is a
we have equations
(le)
here
K-space
appear as coefficient functions of finite-
F .
K-space
(see
The
KF
KF-module
are called
V = (V,T)
.
The
K-span
called the coefficient space (1)
We denote this space by
cf(V) =
of
E K.rab a,b
;
it is e l e m e n t a r y to verify that it is independent of the choice of the basis {vb} . i.e.
The m a t r i x
R = (tab)
R(gg') = R(g)R(g')
Kronecker delta).
gives a m a t r i x r e p r e s e n t a t i o n of
, R(IF) = (~ab)
for all
tab
(if)
~ r ac ~ rcb , S~rab) ' = 6ab ' eEB
The m a t r i x
,
R = (rab)
C = cf(V)
all
a, b c B .
is sometimes called an "invariant m a t r i x "
are finitary~ hence that
~,
p.140].
it follows that all the coefficient functions cf(V)
is a subspace of
is a s_ubcoalgebra of
As a m a t t e r of fact, every finitary f u n c t i o n space of some f i n i t e - d i m e n s i o n a l
(I)
is the
viz°
From the first equations
shows that
(~ab
These conditions translate into conditions on the
coefficients
Arab =
g, g' c F
F ,
KF-module
F ,
F = F(K F) . i.e.
f : F ÷ K V ;
that
But AC~
rab
(If)
also
C ~ C
lies in the coefficient
for this purpose
In [HI, this is called the ~'space of r e p r e s e n t a t i v e functions" of T, or
V.
we could take
V = KFof
(see
FI).
It is for this reason that finitary
functions are sometimes called "representative functions". If K-space), left
S
is any
mod (S)
S-modules.
shall denote the category of all finite-dimensional Similarly
dimensional right over
K
F(KF), the
K-algebra (possibly of infinite dimension as
mod'(S)
S-modules.
An algebraic representation theory of
could be defined as follows: i.e.
A
is a
K-subspace of
"A-representation theory" of
full subcategory
mOdA(KF )
dimensional left
KF-modules
f : V ~ V' just the
of
F,
first choose a subcoalgebra F(~)
V
such that V, V'
satisfying
~A c A ® A.
cf(V) c A,
of finite-dimensional right way.
The assumption
if
KF-module
cf(V) ~ A ;
A-rational left
V
fh' fhT from
appearing in (ic) (id)
(la)
implies that if
KF-moduleso
A
It is A-rational
mod~(KF)
A-rational in the same f ~ A,
then the functions
can themselves be chosen to belong to
follows that
is
then mOdA(KF)
We can define the category
KF-modules which are
gA c A ~ A
Then
(The morphisms
clear that submodules, quotient-modules and finite direct sums of A-rational.
of
of this category are, by definition,
"rational", or more precisely "A-rational",
modules, are themselves
A
whose objects are all finite-
In some contexts we say that a
is the category of finite-dimensional
F
is defined to be the study of the
mod (KF),
between two objects Ki'-maps.)
is the category of all finite-
is a left and right
A.
KF-submodule of
Then KF ;
also by quite elementary calculations that any finite-dimensional left (or right) (or
KF-submodule
mod~(KF))o
V
of
A
belongs to the category
mOdA(KF)
Examples i.
Let
closed field
K
F
be an affine algebraic group over an algebraically
(see for example ! H, p.21]), and
regular functions on mOdA(KF)
F
(A
A = K[F]
is often called the affin~ ring of
is the category of rational (finite-dimensional)
the usual sense of algebraic group theory~ sub~oalgebra of
F(KF),
remarks apply when
F
In this case,
A
is an affine algebraic semigroupo F(~)
= K F.
2.
If we take
F).
Then
KF-modu!es in is not orlly a
but a sub-blalgebra (see [Se, p. 46]).
finite semigroup, then of course mOdA(Kr) = mod (KF).
the ring of
The same
Let
F
A = K F,
be a then
The (left and right)
K~-module structures on
A,
are dual to tile (right and left) "regular"
KF-module structures on
K
given by multiplication:
we may identify
(KF)
Let
= HomK(KF, K)f
integer, and
3.
F = CL (K)
K
K.
polynomial functions
f : F ~ K
be an infinite field,
We could take
A
(see 2.1).
R = (tab)
F
2.2) by taking
mention that semigroup
g E F
~(n)
Mn(K )
r
M (K), n
F.
matrices
V = (V,T)
in
see 2.2) are
K-bases
(including {Vb}
of
The study of such represent-
the space of polynomial functions in the
n
2
coefficients of a
(see 2.1 for a precise formulation.)
Finally we might
can also be regarded as the affine ring of the algebraic of a l l
n x n
matrices (singular or not) over
we may regard polynomial representations of ations of
n x n
We get another category (denoted
A = ~(n,r),
which are homogeneous of degree
general element
~(n),
obtained by using
ations is the subject of these lectures. in
a positive
the ring of all
The objects
are called polynomial representations of
~(n,r)
n
KF-modules, and the associated representations
the matrix representations
on
~(n),
(we shall later denote this category by
called polynomial
V)
with the dual space
the group of all non-singulsr
with coefficients in
mOdA(K~)
KF
and conversely.
CLn(K),
K,
so that
as rational represent-
Now suppose once more that identity
IF ,
and that
A
F
is an aribtrary
is a subcoalgebra
all flnitary
functions on
to the maps
A : A ~ A ~ A, s : A ~ K.
com(A)
of all right
dimensional which is
F.
A-eomodules;
K-space,
= RV
A
of the space
A-module;
[Se, p. 38] or [Sw, p. 30]). as follows:
if
an object
V
of
the identities
Our category
(le).
relative
com(A)
is a finite-
T : V ~ V ® A
(T ~ ~A)T = (~V ~ A)~ , A-comodule
better references
V E mOdA(KF),
and write down the equations
of
So we may consider the category
(see [G, p. 138], where a right
referred to as a left
F(K F)
is itself a coalgebra,
together with a "structure map"
K-linear and satisfies
(IV ® s)T
com(A),
Then
semigroup with
are [H, p. ].6],
mOdA(KF)
take any
is equivalent
K-basis
Now define
is perversely
{Vb}
of
~ : V -+ V ~ A
to V
to be the
K-linear map given by equations
(Ig)
Y(Vb)
--
% a~B
It is easy to check that using (if) we see that Conversely
given an
the elements
rab
hold, so we may use It is evident that
v a ® rab
T T
satisfies
A ; (le)
such that these morphisms
of the basis
the comodule
(V, T),
{vh}.
Moreover
identities just given.
use equations
to define the left
of(V) c A .
f : V ~ V~
b ~ B.
(Ig)
to define
the comodule identities now show that
can be regarded as a right of morphism
for
is independent
A-comodule of
,
So every
A-comodule,
in
com(A)
KF-module
A-rational,
KF-maps in
KF-module
The definition
(see the references
are the same as
V = (V, ~).
left
and conversely.
(if)
cited)
mOdA(KF).
is
10
This formal transition trivial,
from
but it is nevertheless
20 begin with,
KF-modu]es
worth making,
the basic representation
(~e should here work in the category are possibly infinite-dimensional) discovered (see
[G]).
A-comodules
is rather
from several points of view.
theory of arbitrary
Mod(A),
A-comodules
whose objects
V = (V, T)
follows to a surprising extent the pattern
by R. Brauer and C. Nesbitt
[B],
to
for finite-dimensional
Included here is the possibility
algebra
of a modular
theory,
which we shall discuss below. Next,
the
an important
A-comodule
for the
K-algebra
is the dual of the coalgebra tile product (1)
~D
= Hon~(A,
structure
to be the map of
(~)(f)
(la).
b~longs ~ ~, = ([ o~
A
on A
A,
K).
K
can be regarded as
The algebra structure on
i.e.
into
profit by
if
~,D ~ A ,
we define
which takes the element
to
(lh)
see
also permits us to
fact, namely that every right A-comodule
a left module
f ~ A
interpretation
V,
to v
=
Z ~(fh)~(f~), h
The identity element of com(A),
® ~) (v),
we make for
~v b
=
(see
s : A-* K.
K -module
(1) This product
V = (V, T)
Working in terms of a basis
(ig))
% ~(rab)V a , a~B
for
b E B.
Therefore we have three kinds of matrix representation our original
If
A -module by the rule
into an
~ ~ A , v 6 V.
this rule becomes
(]i)
V
is
A
V = (V, ~),
relstlve
is often called "convolution"
associated
to the basis
{Vb}:
with
{vb}
A
(i)
the representation
g ÷ (rab(g))
whose elements are functions on
F,
of
F ;
(il)
the matrix
satisfying equations
(If), and which
can be thought of as a kind of representation of the coalgebra (iii)
the representation
equetions g ~ F all
(li).
let
We can recover
eg : A ~ K
f 6 A.
Then
e
E A ,
g
K-algebra map
(iii)
with If
e , A
(i)
from
and the map
for
So
modA(KF )
dimensional algebra
r),
for
satisfies may be extended linearly
(i).
is finite-dimenslonal,
A = ~(n,
for each
and if we compoee the representation
and
then it is quite elementary to show mod(A )
mOdA(KF) by composition with the map
Jn the case
e
finally
given by
eg(f) = f(g),
i.e.
e :F + A
are equivalent; this amounts
to showing that every finite-dimensional left in
A ,
A ;
(ill7 very easily: g" ,
g, g' ~ I'.
e : KF ~ A ,
we recover
that the categories
of the algebra
be "evaluation at
e eg, = egg, , elF = s , to a
£ ~ (~(rab))
R = (tab)
e.
A -module
V
yields a module
Schur exploited this fact
end could thereby work with the finite-
AK(n~ r)
= SK(n, r)
(which I have called the
"Sehur algebra" in these lectures; see 2.3, 2.4), instead of with the i1~flnite-dimensicnal and irrelevantly complicated group-algebra If
A
is infinite-dimensional,
V ~ mOdA(KF) is dense in O~ group
F
it is often useful to regard modules
~s modules over some "dense" subalgebra A
~en
if, for every A = K[F]
0 # a 6 A,
by(F)
of
there is some
F
(see
K,
of
A*
~ ~ S
[CFS, §6]).
In ease
F
such that
hy(F)
S
the
is simply-
mOdA(KF)
sets up an equivalence of eategorles (J. Sullivan; see
Moreover in that case
(S
one may take for
connected and semisimple, the correspondence between mod(S)
S
is the affine ring of a connected algebraic
over an algebraically closed field
"hyperalgebra"
KF.
can be identified with an algebra
and [CPS, 6~8]). UK
12
constructed out of the complex semisimple Lie algebra associated with the root system of algebra
UK
F
(W. Haboush:
[CPS, 6.5, 6.6] o r [ H a ,
1.3]).
This
(which is sometimes defined to be the hyperalgebra of
F)
has an explicit basis with sufficiently good multiplicative properties to make it immensely valuable in studying the rational representations of In an important paper
[CL]
F.
R, Carter and G. Lusztig have used the
hyperalgebra -- rather than the Schur algebra -- to investigate the polynomial representations of
F = GLn(K).
Carte1-Lusztig use the idea, which is derived from C. Chevalley's fundamental paper
[Ch]
family of all groups
on split semisimple algebraic groups, that the
GLn(K )
(n
fixed,
of commutative rings) is "defined over
K Z".
varying over some class
K
This makes possible a '~odular
theory" for tile polynomial representations of these groups, which in its essentials corresponds to R. Brauer's modular representation theory for finite groups. as follows. the class
We can give a sufficiently general setting for such a theory
Suppose we have a family K
of all infinite fields,
K~-subcoalgebra of are satisfied. ZI. i.e.
The (a)
O~basis.
F(KFK).
(Q
AQ = (AA, ~Q, ~Q)
AQ , and
Z2~
For each
K ~ K
(here
~
®v~ ,
means
is a semigroup and
K
A~K
in is a
Suppose also that the following two conditions
is a laLtice in
{av.l of
FK
where for each
denotes the rational field.)
Q-coalgebra AZ
{FK, ~K} ,
AQ ,
(b)
there is a and
"e~ten~ion of scalars").
AZ ® K
contains a
which means
z-form
AZ = ~v Zav
&Q(A Z) _c A Z @ A Z ,
for some
~:Q(~Z) --c Z.
K-coalgebra isomorphism is made into a
AZ ,
aK : A Z ® K + A Z
K-coa]gebra by
13
In this case we say that the f~mily means of
Let
n : ~ g -+ EndcE
semisimple Lie algebra dimension n, and let or [St, p. 17 ]). defined by SLn(K ).
~ EZ
be an "admissible lattice" in
its
K ~ K
let
FK
For each pair
(~,v)
showed in over
Z.
[Ch]
of
(see also
The relevant
generated by the
cQ
isomorphisms, .tnd take
(see [Bo, p. A-5]
be the Chevalley group over
K cpKk @' c ~
gc K = L fly X cK
is a
we take this to be
[Bo,
]#thatthe
§4 AZ
the maps
of eK
A0
g = (g~v)
,
we deduce that
family
~..
Chevalley
{FK, AK}
is defined
is just the subring of
are
c~v~t ® 1K ~ cK
K-algebra (as well as
K-coalgebra)
K,
and the family
defined by the
(FK, ~ )
{FK, AK}
Z-bialgebra
AZ .
[Se, p. 46].)
Example 5. K E K. r ~ 0
Z",
A0
for all
is an affine algebraic group defined over is an "affine group scheme over
K
K-subcoalgebra (hence
F(KFK);
Z-form ;
E
of finite
(From the standpoint of algebraic group theory, each pair
See
by
define the coefficient function
From the equations
K-subbialgebra)
E
elements can be regarded as matrices
K-subalgebra generated by all the
even a
Z
be a faithful representation of a complex
over a complex vector space
For each
IY, E Z ;
cK : g ~ gl~v " ~v the
is defined over
AZ .
Example 4.
in
{FK, ~ }
Fix the positive integer
For
AK
(see 2.1).
the fa~aily Az(n, r) {F K, ~ ( n ,
we may take either
and let
~(n),
or
FK = GLn(K)
AK(n,r)
for each
for some fixed
It is completely elementnry to verify that in each case
{FK' AK}
is defined over
are described in 2.5. r)}.
n,
Z;
the relevant
Z-forms
Az(n) ,
in these lectures, we study the family
/4
The first essential of the modular representation family
{FK, AK}
reduction. K E K. which
which is defined over
We shall ~ i t e
Then an object FQ
acts.
equations like
(lj)
If
VQ
Z,
~
for the category
in
MQ
mod~(KFK) ,
is a finlte-dimensional
{Vb, Q : b E B}
N Z r]b(g)v a = " aEB
Here the functions
is a
Q-basis of
rQ ab
,
for
for any
Q-space on
VQ ,
we have
belong to
AQ
and satisfy equations like
'
a subset
Z-form (or admissible lattice) of
VQ
V Z = ~ ZVb, Q
for some
if
VZ (a)
Q-basis
All the coefficient functions
b E B,
g ~ -0 'r
We make the following definition:
(b)
is the process of modular
(le)
gvb, n~ =
~.~hich means
theory of any
rQ ab '
of VZ
VQ
(if)
is called a
is a lattice in
r iVb,Q}
of
VQ ,
VQ ,
and
relative to this basis, lie in
AZ . Another way of expressing condition ~n
AQ-COmodule by means of a map
like
(ig).
Then
(b)
VQ
into
using equations
to
YQ(v z) i V z e A z •
Now suppose that (~
is to convert
~Q : VQ ~ VQ ® AQ ,
is equivalent
(b')
(b)
means
rabK
=
®Z )
(if).
We can make the
into an object of
~K (rQab ® 1 K)
~K : AZ ® K ~ ~
K E K.
of
AK '
~
,
as follows.
usimg the
postulated in Z2.
So we may define an action of
K-coalgebra K rab
These FK
K-space
on
VK
VK = V Z @ K
Define elements isomorphism
satisfy equations like by equations
15
(ik)
Z a6B
gvb, K =
Here
r[~(g)Va,K=u '
Vb, K = Va, Q ® 1 K ,
converted,
via the
A general z-form
Z-form
into
V Z , V~ ,...
VK = VZ ® K ,
V K , V K' ,...
Different
may give non-isomorphic
MK ,
but another general theorem
form to Brauer and Nesbitt)
have the same composition
the notion of decomposition
is
possesses at least one
[G, (2.2d), p. 159]).
VQ
in
VQ
is called modular reduction.
VQ 6 MQ
or
of the same
V~ = V~ @ K ....
(due i~ its original
VK
that every
([Se, Lemma 2, p. 43]
g E F K , b ~ B,
The p~oeess by which
b 6 B.
VZ ,
theor~n guarantees
VZ
Z-forms
for
for
says that all these modules
factor multiplicities;
numbers can be defined
from this
([Se, p. 44] or
[G, (2.5a), p. 162]).
In these lectures we take and study
KF-modules
a fixed homogeneity algebra
SK(n,r )
of
SK(n,r )
V = (V,T)
degree r
where
K
I, above).
and it is shown how
when the latter is given its natural structure
group
G(r)
then every module
V
in
~(n,r)
Schur's multiplication
V
elements
.
in
By definition, homogeneous
SK(n,r)
of degree
r
theorem
SK(n,r)
~(n,r)
An alternative
can
description
as module for the synmletric (2.6e):
if
char K = O ,
in
(see (2.3b)) provides
MK(n,r ) .
are easily expressed Weights
the character of
in
is completely reducible.
method for calculating with modules
~
Schur's
rule for
spaces" of such a module
, for
algebra of the r-th tensor space
E ~r ,
This has as corollary
MK(n,r)
In chapter 2 the Schur
KF-modules
SK(n,r)-modules , and conversely.
is that it is the endomorphism
.
is an infinite field,
which belong to the category
(see Example
is defined,
be regarded as left
F = GL (K) n
V
and characters
For example, in
n
variables
the "weight-
terms of certain idempotent
are discussed
is a symmetric polynomial
in a set of
an effective
over
XI,...,X n .
in chapter 3. Z ,
which is
16
In 3.5 is reproduced
the argument by which Schur showed that the isomorphism
classes of irreducible modules with the partitions
in
% = (%1,...,%n)
Of course Schur considered only minor modification
K ;
yet been determined
of
for an arbitrary
we write this
are in one-one correspondence r
only the case
of an irreducible module of type of
~(n,r)
~%,p
% For
except in special
into not more than
K = ¢ ,
n
parts.
but his argument requires
infinite field
K .
The character
depends only on the characteristic p # O
these characters
cases.
For
~%,p
p = 0 ,
p
have not
Schur showed in
IS] that they are the symmetric functions now known as "Schur functions".
A
proof of this is given at the end of 3.5 - our proof uses some identities involving symmetric functions which can be found, Macdonald's
recent book
for example,
in I.G.
[M].
In chapters 4 and 5, I have departed widely from Schur's dissertation. These chapters K ,
are concerned with the construction,
of two modules
"explicit"
has a unique irreducible
{F%,K}, parts,
V~, K
in our category
in the sense of the "contravariant"
has a unique minimal
then
and
as
X
submodule,
factor module;
F%, K ~ VX, K ~ D%, K .
in
They are
They are dual
this is denoted
% of
gives a full set of irreducible modules
.
duality described
which is isomorphic
ranges over all partitions
% and for each
MK(n,r)
in the sense that a basis can be given for each.
to each other, V%, K
D~, K
for each
to r
F%, K .
F ,K .
D%, K
The set
into not more than
P~(n,r)
But for char K = p # 0 ,
in 2.7.
.
If
knowledge
n
char K = O , of the
F%, K
is still very incomplete.
The history of the modules indebted
to J. Towber
D%, K
and
V%, K
is interesting,
(see IT]) for much of the following
is generated by certain determinantal
expressions
and I am
information.
(here denoted
D%, K
(T%:Ti)),
17
whose significance in 1892.
as "primary covariants" was noted by J. Deruyts
Although Schur refers to two later papers of Deruyts,
no sign in [S] that he appreciated set of irreducible modules in "standard"
(T~:T i) ,
observation that the equivalently that the by G. Higman
M~(n,r)
.
The discovery of the basis of the [Y, 1902].
The
generate a Z-form V~, K
D%, Z
(and the Z-form
called these "Weyl modules",
M. Clausen
V%, K .
G.D. James describes,
are isomorphic to the D%, K .
They
Towber
~]
showed that
([DKR]) to construct both modules in his book
~a],
some
Chapter 6 r e t u r ~ t o
theory of D%, K
KF-modules which
His construction is quite different from those D%, K
in the sense of algebraic group theory.
Schur's disseration.
procedure by which he constructed G(r) .
D%, K
and more
we show in 4.8 that it yields the important and deep fact that
is an "induced" module,
group
1974].
[CI] has used recent combinatorial
G.-C. Rota and his collaborators
above;
were constructed,
are dual to each other - his framework is "functorial"
general than ours.
and
~L,
D%,Q - was made
and their construction was based on methods used
in the theory of semisimple algebraic groups. V%, K
in
V%,Z)
independently of all this, by R. Carter and G. Lusztig
and
The
can be constructed over an arbitrary field - or
(T%:Ti)
~Hi, 1965].
there is
that Deruyts had really given a complete
seems to go back to A. Young D%, K
[D!,
KF-modules
I have "reversed" the elegant from modules for the symmetric
This provides an interesting illumination of some recent work
of James on the modular representation
theory
of the symmetric groups.
1 Introduction
Issai Schur determined the polynomial representations of the complex general linear group GLn (C) in his doctoral dissertation [47], published in 1901. This remarkable work contained many very original ideas, developed with superb algebraic skill. Schur showed that these representations are completely reducible, that each irreducible one is “homogeneous” of some degree r ≥ 0 (see 2.2), and that the equivalence types of irreducible polynomial representations of GLn (C), of fixed homogeneous degree r, are in one-one correspondence with the partitions λ = (λ1 , . . . , λn ) of r into not more than n parts. Moreover Schur showed that the character of an irreducible representation of type λ is given by a certain symmetric function Sλ in n variables (since described as “Schur function”; see 3.5). An essential part of Schur’s technique was to set up a correspondence between representations of GLn (C) of fixed homogeneous degree r, and representations of the finite symmetric group G(r) on r symbols, and through this correspondence to apply G. Frobenius’ discovery of the characters of G(r) (see [17]). This pioneering achievement of Schur was one of the main inspirations for Hermann Weyl’s monumental researches on the representation theory of semi-simple Lie groups [54]. Of course Weyl’s methods, based on the representation theory of the Lie algebra of the Lie group Γ, and the possibility of integrating over a compact form of Γ, were very different from the purely algebraic methods of Schur’s dissertation; in particular Weyl’s general theory contained nothing to correspond to the symmetric group G(r). In 1927 Schur published another paper [48] on GLn (C), which has deservedly become a classic. In this he exploited the “dual” actions of GLn (C) and G(r) on rth tensor space E ⊗r (see 2.6) to rederive all the results of his 1901 dissertation in a new and very economical way. Weyl publicized the method of Schur’s 1927 paper, with its attractive use of the “double centralizer property”, in his influential book “The Classical Groups” [55]. In fact the exposition in Chapters 3B and 4 of that book has become a standard treatment of polynomial representations of GLn (C) (and, incidentally, of Alfred Young’s representation theory of the symmetric group G(r)), and perhaps this explains the comparative neglect of
2
1 Introduction
Schur’s work of 1901. I think this neglect is a pity, because the methods of this earlier work are in some ways very much in keeping with the present-day ideas on representations of algebraic groups. It is the purpose of these lectures to give some accounts, in part based on the ideas of Schur’s 1901 dissertation, of the polynomial representations of the general linear groups GLn (K), where K is an infinite field of arbitrary characteristic. Our treatment will be “elementary” in the sense that we shall not use algebraic group theory in our main discussion. But it might be interesting to indicate here some general ideas from the representation theory of algebraic groups (or algebraic semigroups, since the group inverse is not important in this context), which are relevant to our work. Let Γ be any semigroup (i.e. Γ is a set, equipped with an associative multiplication) with identity 1Γ , and let K be any field. A representation τ of Γ on a K-space V (i.e. a vector space over K) is a map τ : Γ → EndK (V ) which satisfies τ (gg ) = τ (g)τ (g ), τ (1Γ ) = IV , for all g, g ∈ Γ. (For any set V , we denote by IV the identity map on V .) We can extend τ linearly to give a map of K-algebras τ : KΓ → EndK (V ); here KΓ is the semigroup-algebra of Γ over K, whose elements are all formal linear combinations κ= κg g, κg ∈ K, g∈Γ
whose support supp κ = { g ∈ Γ : κg = 0 } is finite. We can make KΓ act on V by κv = τ (κ)(v) (κ ∈ KΓ, v ∈ V ), and thereby get a left KΓ-module, denoted (V, τ ), or simply V . A KΓ-map between such KΓ-modules (V, τ ), (V , τ ) is, by definition, a K-map f : V → V (i.e. f is a linear map) which satisfies τ (g)f = f τ (g) for all g ∈ Γ. A KΓ-map which is bijective is a KΓisomorphism, or an equivalence between the representations τ , τ . One has analogous definitions for right KΓ-modules; a right KΓ-module can be regarded as a pair (V, τ ) where τ : Γ → EndK (V ) is an anti-representation of Γ on the K-space V , i.e. τ (gg ) = τ (g )τ (g) for all g, g ∈ Γ, τ (1Γ ) = IV . The set K Γ of all maps Γ → K is a commutative K-algebra, with algebra operations defined “pointwise”, e.g. f f is defined to take g → f (g)f (g), for every element (“point”) g of Γ. The identity element 1 of K Γ takes each g ∈ Γ to the identity element 1K of K. If s ∈ Γ and f ∈ K Γ , then the left and right translates of f by s are defined to be the maps Ls f, Rs f : Γ → K given by Ls f : g → f (sg),
Rs f : g → f (gs),
g ∈ Γ.
Each of the operators Ls , Rs maps K Γ into itself and is a K-algebra map (i.e. K-algebra homomorphism) K Γ → K Γ . In particular, Ls , Rs both belong to the space EndK (K Γ ). It is easy to check that R : s → Rs gives a representation of Γ on K Γ , while L : s → Ls gives an anti-representation. Thus K Γ can be made into a left KΓ-module (using R) and a right KΓ-module (using L). We denote both module actions by ◦, so that if s ∈ Γ and f ∈ K Γ we write s ◦ f = Rs f
and
f ◦ s = Ls f.
1 Introduction
3
Notice that these actions commute: (s ◦ f ) ◦ t = s ◦ (f ◦ t) for all s, t ∈ Γ and f ∈ K Γ . There is a linear map K Γ ⊗ K Γ → K Γ×Γ (⊗ means ⊗K ) which takes f ⊗ f (f, f ∈ K Γ ) to the function mapping Γ × Γ → K by (s, t) → f (s)f (t), for all s, t ∈ Γ. This linear map is injective, and we use it to identify K Γ ⊗ K Γ with a subspace of K Γ×Γ . The semigroup structure on Γ gives rise to two maps ∆ : K Γ → K Γ×Γ
and
ε : K Γ → K,
as follows: if f ∈ K Γ , then ∆f : (s, t) → f (st), and ε(f ) = f (1Γ ). Both ∆, ε are K-algebra maps. We shall say that an element f ∈ K Γ is finitary, or is a representative function, if it satisfies any one of the conditions F1, F2, F3 below: these three conditions are in fact equivalent (see e.g. [24, Chapter 2]). F1. The left KΓ-submodule KΓ ◦ f generated by f is finite-dimensional. F2. The right KΓ-submodule f ◦ KΓ generated by f is finite-dimensional. F3. ∆f ∈ K Γ ⊗ K Γ . This means that there exist elements fh , fh ∈ K Γ (where h runs over some finite index set) such that fh ⊗ fh . (1a) ∆f = h
This equation is equivalent to the system of equations fh (s)fh (t), all s, t ∈ Γ. (1b) f (st) = h
It is also equivalent to each of the following systems (1c) t◦f = fh (t)fh , all t ∈ Γ, h
or (1d)
f ◦s=
fh (s)fh , all s ∈ Γ.
h
The set F = F (K Γ ) of all finitary functions f : Γ → K is a K-bialgebra (see [51] for the definitions of coalgebras and bialgebras). It is a K-subalgebra of K Γ , and is also closed to ∆ in the sense that ∆F ⊆ F ⊗ F (this means that if f is finitary, the functions fh , fh in (1a) can be chosen to be themselves finitary). The K-space F , equipped with the maps ∆ : F → F ⊗F , ε : F → K, is a K-coalgebra; these two structures on F , of algebra and coalgebra, are linked by the fact that ∆ and ε are both K-algebra maps (see [24, p. 15]). Finitary functions on Γ appear as coefficient functions of finite-dimensional representations of Γ. Suppose τ is a representation of Γ on a finitedimensional K-space V . If { vb : b ∈ B } is a K-basis of V , we have equations (1e) τ (g)vb = gvb = rab (g)va , for g ∈ Γ, b ∈ B; a∈B
4
1 Introduction
here rab (g) ∈ K. The functions rab : Γ → K (a, b ∈ B) are called coefficient functions of τ , or of the KΓ-module V = (V, τ ). The K-span of these functions 1 is a subspace of K Γ called the coefficient space of τ , or of the KΓ-module V . K · r We denote this space by cf(V ) = ab ; it is elementary to verify a,b that it is independent of the choice of the basis {vb }. The matrix R = (rab ) gives a matrix representation of Γ, i.e. R(gg ) = R(g)R(g ), R(1Γ ) = (δab ) for all g, g ∈ Γ (δab is the Kronecker delta). These conditions translate into conditions on the coefficients rab , viz. (1f ) ∆rab = rac ⊗ rcb , ε(rab ) = δab , all a, b ∈ B. c∈B
The matrix R = (rab ) is sometimes called an “invariant matrix” [20, p. 140]. From the first equations it follows that all the coefficient functions rab are finitary, hence that cf(V ) is a subspace of F = F (K Γ ). But (1f) also shows that C = cf(V ) is a subcoalgebra of F , i.e. that ∆C ⊆ C ⊗ C. As a matter of fact, every finitary function f : Γ → K lies in the coefficient space of some finite-dimensional KΓ-module V ; for this purpose we could take V = KΓ ◦ f (see F1). It is for this reason that finitary functions are sometimes called “representative functions”. If S is any K-algebra (possibly of infinite dimension as K-space), mod(S) shall denote the category of all finite-dimensional left S-modules. Similarly, mod (S) is the category of all finite-dimensional right S-modules. An algebraic representation theory of Γ over K could be defined as follows: first choose a subcoalgebra A of F (K Γ ), i.e. A is a K-subspace of F (K Γ ) satisfying ∆A ⊆ A ⊗ A. Then “A-representation theory” of Γ, is defined to be the study of the full subcategory modA (KΓ) of mod(KΓ), whose objects are all finite-dimensional left KΓ-modules V such that cf(V ) ⊆ A. (The morphisms f : V → V between two objects V , V of this category are, by definition, just the KΓ-maps.) In some contexts we say that a KΓ-module V is “rational”, or more precisely “A-rational”, if cf(V ) ⊆ A; then modA (KΓ) is the category of finite-dimensional A-rational left KΓ-modules. It is clear that submodules, quotient-modules and finite direct sums of A-rational modules, are themselves A-rational. We can define the category modA (KΓ) of finitedimensional right KΓ-modules which are A-rational in the same way. The assumption ∆A ⊆ A ⊗ A implies that if f ∈ A, then the functions fh , fh appearing in (1a) can themselves be chosen to belong to A. Then from (1c), (1d) follows that A is a left and right KΓ-submodule of K Γ ; also by quite elementary calculations that any finite-dimensional left (or right) KΓ-submodule V of A belongs to the category modA (KΓ) (or modA (KΓ)). Examples. 1. Let Γ be an affine algebraic group over an algebraically closed field K (see for example [24, p. 21]), and A = K[Γ] the ring of regular functions on Γ 1
In [24], this is called the “space of representative functions” of τ , or V .
1 Introduction
5
(A is often called the affine ring of Γ). Then modA (KΓ) is the category of rational (finite-dimensional) KΓ-modules in the usual sense of algebraic group theory. In this case, A is not only a subcoalgebra of F (K Γ ), but a subbialgebra (see [49, p. 46]). The same remarks apply when Γ is an affine algebraic semigroup. 2. Let Γ be a finite semigroup, then of course F (K Γ ) = K Γ . If we take A = K Γ, then modA (KΓ) = mod(KΓ). The (left and right) KΓ-module structures on A, are dual to the (right and left) “regular” KΓ-module structures on K given by multiplication: we may identify K Γ with the dual space (KΓ)∗ = HomK (KΓ, K). 3. Let K be an infinite field, n a positive integer, and Γ = GLn (K), the group of all non-singular n × n matrices with coefficients in K. We could take A = AK (n), the ring of all polynomial functions f : Γ → K (see 2.1). The objects (V, τ ) in modA (KΓ) (we shall later denote this category by MK (n), see 2.2) are called polynomial KΓ-modules, and the associated representations (including the matrix representations R = (rab ) obtained by using the K-bases {vb } of V ) are called polynomial representations of Γ. The study of such representations is the subject of these lectures. We get another category (denoted by MK (n, r) in 2.2) by taking A = AK (n, r), the space of polynomial functions on Γ which are homogeneous of degree r in the n2 coefficients of a general element g ∈ Γ (see 2.1 for a precise formulation). Finally we might mention that AK (n) can also be regarded as the affine ring of the algebraic semigroup Mn (K) of all n×n matrices (singular or not) over K, so that we may regard polynomial representations of GLn (K), as rational representations of Mn (K), and conversely. Now suppose once more that Γ is an arbitrary semigroup with identity 1Γ , and that A is a subcoalgebra of the space F (K Γ ) of all finitary functions on Γ. Then A is itself a coalgebra, relative to the maps ∆ : A → A ⊗ A and ε : A → K. So we may consider the category com(A) of all right A-comodules; an object V of com(A) is a finite-dimensional K-space, together with a “structure map” γ : V → V ⊗ A which is K-linear and satisfies the identities (γ ⊗ IA )γ = (IV ⊗ ∆)γ, (IV ⊗ ε)γ = IV (see [20, p. 138], where a right A-comodule is perversely referred to as a left A-comodule; better references are [24, p. 16], [49, p. 38] or [51, p. 30]). Our category modA (KΓ) is equivalent to com(A), as follows: if V ∈ modA (KΓ), take any K-basis {vb } of V and write down the equations (1e). Now define γ : V → V ⊗ A to be the K-linear map given by equations (1g) γ(vb ) = va ⊗ rab , for b ∈ B. a∈B
It is easy to check that γ is independent of the basis {vb }. Moreover using (1f) we see that γ satisfies the comodule identities just given. Conversely given an A-comodule (V, γ), use equations (1g) to define the elements rab of A; the comodule identities now show that (1f) hold, so we may use (1e) to define the
6
1 Introduction
left KΓ-module V = (V, τ ). It is evident that cf(V ) ⊆ A. So every A-rational, left KΓ-module can be regarded as a right A-comodule, and conversely. The definition of morphism f : V → V in com(A) (see the references cited) is such that these morphisms are the same as KΓ-maps in modA (KΓ). This formal transition from KΓ-modules to A-comodules is rather trivial, but it is nevertheless worth making, from several points of view. To begin with, the basic representation theory of arbitrary A-comodules (we should here work in the category Com(A), whose objects V = (V, γ) are possibly infinite-dimensional) follows to a surprising extent the pattern discovered by R. Brauer and C. Nesbitt for finite-dimensional algebras (see [5, 20]). Included here is the possibility of a modular theory, which we shall discuss below. Next, the A-comodule interpretation also permits us to profit by an important fact, namely that every right A-comodule can be regarded as a left module for the K-algebra A∗ = HomK (A, K). The algebra structure in A∗ is the dual of the coalgebra structure on A, i.e. if ξ, η ∈ A∗ , we define the product2 ξη to be the map of A into K which takes the element f ∈ A to (1h) ξη(f ) = ξ(fh )η(fh ), h
see (1a). The identity element of A∗ is ε : A → K. If V = (V, γ) belongs to com(A), we make V into an A∗ -module by the rule ξv = (IV ⊗ ξ)(γ(v)), for ξ ∈ A∗ , v ∈ V . Working in terms of a basis {vb } of V , this rule becomes (see (1g)) (1i) ξvb = ξ(rab )va , for b ∈ B. a∈B
Therefore we have three kinds of matrix representation associated with our original KΓ-module V = (V, τ ), relative to the basis {vb }: (i) the representation g → (rab (g)) of Γ; (ii) the matrix R = (rab ) whose elements are functions on Γ, satisfying equations (1f), and which can be thought of as a kind of representation of the coalgebra A; (iii) the representation ξ → (ξ(rab )) of the algebra A∗ , given by equations (1i). We can recover (i) from (iii) very easily: for each g ∈ Γ let eg : A → K be “evaluation at g”, i.e. eg (f ) = f (g), for all f ∈ A. Then eg ∈ A∗ , and the map e : Γ → A∗ satisfies eg eg = egg , e1Γ = ε, for g, g ∈ Γ. So e may be extended linearly to a K-algebra map e : KΓ → A∗ , and if we compose the representation (iii) with e, we recover (i). If A is finite-dimensional, then it is quite elementary to show that the two categories modA (KΓ) and mod(A∗ ) are equivalent; this amounts to showing that every finite-dimensional left A∗ -module V yields a module in modA (KΓ) by composition with the map e. Schur exploited this fact in 2
This product is often called “convolution”.
1 Introduction
7
the case A = AK (n, r), and could thereby work with the finite-dimensional algebra AK (n, r)∗ = SK (n, r) (which I have called the “Schur algebra” in these lectures, see 2.3, 2.4), instead of with the infinite-dimensional and irrelevantly complicated group algebra KΓ. If A is infinite-dimensional, it is useful in many cases to regard modules V ∈ modA (KΓ) as modules over some “dense” subalgebra S of A∗ (S is dense in A∗ if, for every 0 = a ∈ A, there is some ξ ∈ S such that ξ(a) = 0). When A = K[Γ] is the affine ring of a connected algebraic group Γ over an algebraically closed field K, one may take S the “hyperalgebra” hy(Γ) of Γ (see [9, §6]). In case Γ is simply-connected and semisimple, the correspondence between modA (KΓ) and mod(S) sets up an equivalence of categories (J. Sullivan; see [9, 6.8]). Moreover in that case hy(Γ) can be identified with an algebra UK constructed out of the complex semisimple Lie algebra associated with the root system of Γ (W. Haboush; [9, 6.5, 6.6] or [22, 1.3]). This algebra UK (which is sometimes defined to be the hyperalgebra of Γ) has an explicit basis with sufficiently good multiplicative properties to make it immensely valuable in studying the rational representations of Γ. In an important paper [6] R. Carter and G. Lusztig have used the hyperalgebra— rather than the Schur algebra—to investigate the polynomial representations of Γ = GLn (K). Carter-Lusztig use the idea, which is derived from C. Chevalley’s fundamental paper [7] on split semisimple algebraic groups, that the family of all groups GLn (K) (n fixed, K varying over some class K of commutative rings) is “defined over Z”. This makes possible a “modular theory” for the polynomial representations of these groups, which in its essentials corresponds to R. Brauer’s modular representation theory for finite groups. We can give a sufficiently general setting for such a theory as follows. Suppose we have a family {ΓK , AK }, where for each K in the class K of all infinite fields, ΓK is a semigroup and AK is a K-subcoalgebra of F (K ΓK ). Suppose also that the following two conditions are satisfied. (Q denotes the rational field.) ) contains a Z-form AZ , i.e. (a) AZ is Z1. The Q-coalgebra AQ = (AQ , ∆Q , εQ a lattice in AQ , which means AZ = ν Zaν for some Q-basis {aν } of AQ , and (b) ∆Q (AZ ) ⊆ AZ ⊗ AZ , εQ (AZ ) ⊆ Z. Z2. For each K ∈ K there is a K-coalgebra isomorphism αK : AZ ⊗ K → AK (here ⊗ means ⊗Z , and AZ ⊗K is made into a K-coalgebra by “extension of scalars”). In this case we say that the family {ΓK , AK } is defined over Z by means of AZ . Examples. 4. Let π : GC → EndC E be a faithful representation of a complex semisimple Lie algebra GC over a complex vector space E of finite dimension n, and let EZ be an “admissible lattice” in E (see [4, p. A-5] or [50, p. 17]). For
8
1 Introduction
each K ∈ K let ΓK be the Chevalley group over K defined by π, EZ ; its elements can be regarded as matrices g = (gµν ) in SLn (K). For each pair (µ, ν) define the coefficient function cK µν : g → gµν . From the equa K K K tions ∆cµν = λ cµλ ⊗cλν , we deduce that the K-subalgebra generated by ΓK ); all the cK µν is a K-subcoalgebra (hence even a K-subbialgebra) of F (K we take this to be AK . Chevalley showed in [7] (see also [4, §4]) that the family {ΓK , AK } is defined over Z. The relevant Z-form AZ of AQ is just the subring of AQ generated by the cQ µν ; the maps αK are K-algebra (as K well as K-coalgebra) isomorphisms, and take cQ µν ⊗ 1K → cµν for all µ, ν. (From the standpoint of algebraic group theory, each pair (ΓK , AK ) is an affine algebraic group defined over K, and the family {ΓK , AK } is an “affine group scheme over Z”, defined by the Z-bialgebra AZ . See [49, p. 46].) 5. Fix a positive integer n, and let ΓK = GLn (K) for each K ∈ K. For AK we may take either AK (n), or AK (n, r) for some fixed r ≥ 0 (see 2.1). It is completely elementary to verify that in each case the family {ΓK , AK } is defined over Z; the relevant Z-forms AZ (n), AZ (n, r) are described in 2.5. In these lectures, we study the family {ΓK , AK (n, r)}. The first essential of the modular representation theory of any family {ΓK , AK } which is defined over Z, is the process of modular reduction. We shall write MK for the category modAK (KΓK ), for any K ∈ K. Then an object VQ in MQ is a finite-dimensional Q-space on which ΓQ acts. If { vb,Q : b ∈ B } is a Q-basis of VQ , we have equations like (1e) Q rab (g)va,Q , for g ∈ ΓQ , b ∈ B. (1j) gvb,Q = a∈B Q belong to AQ , and satisfy equations like (1f). We make Here the functions rab the following definition: a subset VZ of VQ is called a Z-form (or admissible lattice) of VQ if (a) VZ is a lattice in VQ , which means VZ = b Zvb,Q for some Q-basis {vb,Q } of VQ , and Q (b) All the coefficient functions rab , relative to this basis, lie in AZ .
Another way of expressing condition (b) is to convert VQ into an AQ -comodule by means of the map γQ : VQ → VQ ⊗ AQ , using equations like (1g). Then (b) is equivalent to (b’) γQ (VZ ) ⊆ VZ ⊗ AZ . Now suppose that K ∈ K. We can make the K-space VK = VZ ⊗K (here ⊗ Q K = αK (rab ⊗ 1K ) ∈ AK , means ⊗Z ) into an object of MK , as follows. Define rab using the K-coalgebra isomorphism αK : AZ ⊗ K → AK postulated in Z2. K These rab satisfy equations like (1f). So we may define an action of ΓK on VK by equations
1 Introduction
(1k)
gvb,K =
9
K rab (g)va,K , for g ∈ ΓK , b ∈ B.
a∈B
Here vb,K = vb,Q ⊗ 1K , for b ∈ B. The process by which VQ is converted, via the Z-form VZ , into VK is called modular reduction. A general theorem guarantees that each VQ ∈ MQ possesses at least one Z-form VZ (see [49, Lemma 2, p. 43] or [20, (2.2d), p. 159]). Different Z-forms VZ , VZ , . . . of the same VQ may give non-isomorphic VK = VZ ⊗ K, VK = VZ ⊗ K, . . . in MK , but another general theorem (due in its original form to Brauer and Nesbitt) says that all these modules VK , VK , . . . have the same composition factor multiplicities; from this the notion of decomposition numbers can be defined (see [49, p. 44] or [20, (2.5a), p. 162]). In these lectures we take Γ = GLn (K), where K is an infinite field, and study KΓ-modules V = (V, τ ), which belong to the category MK (n, r), for a fixed homogeneity degree r (see Example 3, above). In chapter 2 the Schur algebra SK (n, r) is defined, and it is shown how KΓ-modules in MK (n, r) can be regarded as left SK (n, r)-modules, and conversely. An alternative description of SK (n, r) is that it is the endomorphism algebra of the rth tensor space E ⊗r , when the latter is given its natural structure as a module for the symmetric group G(r). This has as corollary Schur’s theorem (2.6e): if char K = 0, then every module V in MK (n, r) is completely reducible. Schur’s multiplication rule for SK (n, r) (see (2.3b)) provides an effective method for calculating with modules in MK (n, r). For example, the “weight spaces” of such a module V are easily expressed in terms of certain idempotent elements ξa in SK (n, r). Weights and characters are discussed in chapter 3. By definition, the character of V is a symmetric polynomial over Z, which is homogeneous of degree r in a set of n variables X1 , . . . , Xn . In 3.5 is reproduced the argument by which Schur showed that the isomorphism classes of irreducible modules in MK (n, r) are in one-one correspondence with the partitions λ = (λ1 , . . . , λn ) of r into not more than n parts. Of course Schur considered only the case K = C, but his argument requires only minor modification for an arbitrary infinite field K. The character of an irreducible module of type λ depends only on the characteristic p of K; we write this φλ,p . For p = 0 these characters have not yet been determined except in special cases. For p = 0, Schur showed in [47] that they are the symmetric functions now known as “Schur functions”. A proof of this is given at then end of 3.5— our proof uses some identities involving symmetric functions which can be found, for example, in I. G. Macdonald’s recent book [39]. In chapters 4 and 5, I have departed widely from Schur’s dissertation. These chapters are concerned with the construction, for each λ and for each K, of two modules Dλ,K and Vλ,K in our category MK (n, r). They are “explicit” in the sense that a basis can be given for each. They are dual to each other, in the sense of the “contravariant” duality described in 2.7. Vλ,K has a unique irreducible factor module; this is denoted Fλ,K . Dλ,K has a unique minimal submodule, which is isomorphic to Fλ,K . The set {Fλ,K }, as λ ranges over all partitions λ of r into not more than n parts, gives a full set of
10
1 Introduction
irreducible modules in MK (n, r). If char K = 0, then Fλ,K ∼ = Vλ,K ∼ = Dλ,K . But for char K = p = 0, knowledge of Fλ,K is still very incomplete. The history of the modules Dλ,K and Vλ,K is interesting, and I am indebted to J. Towber (see [52]) for much of the following information. Dλ,K is generated by certain determinantal expressions (here denoted (Tl : Ti )), whose significance as “primary covariants” was noted by J. Deruyts [13], in 1892. Although Schur refers to two later papers of Deruyts, there is no sign in [47] that he appreciated that Deruyts had really given a complete set of irreducible modules in MC (n, r). The discovery of the basis of the “standard” (Tl : Ti ), seems to go back to A. Young [58, 1902]. The observation that the Dλ,K can be constructed over an arbitrary field—or equivalently that the (Tl : Ti ) generate a Z-form Dλ,Z in Dλ,Q —was made by G. Higman [23, 1965]. The Vλ,K (and the Z-form Vλ,Z ) were constructed, independently of all this, by R. Carter and G. Lusztig [6, 1974]. They called these “Weyl modules”, and their construction was based on methods used in the theory of semisimple algebraic groups. Towber [52] showed that Dλ,K and Vλ,K are dual to each other—his framework is “functorial” and more general than ours. M. Clausen [8] has used recent combinatorial theory of G.-C. Rota and his collaborators [15] to construct both modules Dλ,K and Vλ,K . G. D. James describes, in his book [27], some KΓ-modules which are isomorphic to the Dλ,K . His construction is quite different from those above; we show in 4.8 that it yields the important and deep fact that Dλ,K is an “induced” module, in the sense of algebraic group theory. Chapter 6 returns to Schur’s dissertation. I have “reversed” the elegant procedure by which he constructed KΓ-modules from modules for the symmetric group G(r). This provides an interesting illumination of some recent work of James on the modular representation theory of the symmetric group.
§2.
Polynomial
2.1
Notation, Let
representations
of
GLn(K):
The Schur algebra
etc.
n
be a positive
integer,
K
an infinite field, and
F = GL (K) n
the group of all non-singular of elements of ates to each the of
n = {l,...,n}, g ~ F
K-subalgebra A
its
of
the
c
matrices over
let
c
KF
generated
the polynomial
For each pair
D,v
be the function which associg~v"
Denote by
independent over
over K
A
c v~,v
functions on
regarded as the algebra of all polynomials
c v(~,~ ~
K.
by the functions
are algebraically
~v
~ ~
~,v)-coefficient
are, by definition,
infinite,
n × n
in
Since
K,
so that
n
the elements
~ n);
F.
2
~K(n)
or
is
K A
can be
"indeterminates"
n_).
For each
r > 0
we denote by
of the elements expressible
~(n,r)
the subspace of
A
as polynomials which are homogeneous
consisting of degree
r
(n2+r-l) in the
c v.
particular
Then
AK(n,r)
~(n,0)
= K-IA,
1 A : g -+ iK(g ~ F).
The
(2.1b)
has finite dimension where
1A
K-algebra
A = AK(n ) =
If integers
n,r
set of all functions
i : r ~ n.
vector or "multi-index" group on the set on the right on
(both
A
has the standard
Z" r~0
by
i~
K-space;
in
function
grading
AK(n,r).
are given, we write
Such a function
i = (il,.°.,i r)
r = {l,...,r} I(n,r)
~ i)
denotes
as
r the constant
G(r)
for the
is usually written as a
with values
is denoted
I(n,r)
or
= (i (i) .... ,i (r)) ,
i~ ~ _n" G.
The symmetric
It acts naturally
so that
~ ~ G(r)
~9
acts as a "place-permutation" on the set
I(n,r)
× l(n,r)
that the elements j = i~ and
for some
g = j~
i,J
as
= (i~,j~).
Similarly
(i,j) ~
AK(n,r)
in bijeetive
The categories The maps
& : KF~
with
K r×F c
) =
the
IF
A(Cp,q)
= 1
P,q
or
k = i~
that
AK(n,r)
is
is not uniquely
if and only if monomials
G(r)-orbits
of
(i,j) ~
(2.1b), I(n,r)
determined (k,~).
and these are
× I(n,r).
(n2+r-l) . r -
is
~ g : KF ~ K
O,
=
(see introduction)
behave
as
(~,v 6 n_):
k6nZ
c k ~' ckv
of
F.
for any "multi-indices"
5
notice
(i,j)
,
from the rule for multiplying
for the unit element
(2.2b)
that
that
MK(n) , MK(n,r)
&(c
These follow
the pair ci, j = Ck, ~
of these orbits
on the functions
(2.2a)
i.e.
... c i . , r Jr
the set of distinct
correspondence
2.2
deduce,
in fact
K-basis
the number
follows
Of course
(2.1b);
Thus
to indice
by the monomials
i,j f I(n,r),
has as
means
act also
i ~ j
G(r)-orbit,
(k,g)
of the use of this notation,
K-module,
by the monomial
G(r)
We write
are in the same
ci, j = c . . ci2J2 i131
for all
We make
, ~ G(r).
(2.1b)
Here
i ~ I(n,r).
(i,j)~
I(n,r)
~ ~ G(r).
As an example spanned,
by
of
for some
on each
Z s61
Since p,q
g(c v) =
6Gv.
two matrices,
&,c
are both multiplicative
6 I(n,r)
of length
Cp, s ~ c
according
r ~ I,
6 s,q'
as
and from the formula
p = q
g(Cp,q) or
p
=
~ q.
P,q
we
20
These formulae show that bialgebra) of (for
r = 0
MK(n,r)
F(~),
A = ~(n)
is a sub-coalgebra (hence also a sub-
and that each
this is because
~(n,r)
Al A = 1A ~ IA).
for the categories
modAK(n)(kT)
is the category of finite-dimensional representations of
F = GLn(K);
and
(left)
~K(n,r)
is a sub-coalgebra of
AK(n)
We shall write
and
ME(n)
mOdAK(n,r)(F$).
Thus
MK(n)
~Y-modules which afford "polynomial"
the subcategory consisting of those
affording representations in which all the coefficients are polynomials homogeneous of degree IS, p. 5] in case
r
in the
K = ~,
c v.
By an argument first given by Schur
but valid for any infinite field
K
of any character-
istic, we have (2.2c) V =
Theorem
~ re0
V r,
Each
KF-module
where for each
V (~(n)
r e 0
v '
cf(V r) E AK(n,r) ,
i,e.
has a direct sum decomposition is a sub-module of
V
with
r
Vr ¢ MK(n'r)"
In other words each polynomial representation of
F
is equivalent to
a direct sum of homogeneous ones. Remark A
In fact (2.2c) follows from n general theorem on
is any coalgebra which is a direct sum
(p then
ranging over an index set V =
%~
Vp,
where for each
maximum sub-comodule of Vp (com(Ap)
P).
V
A
of sub-coalgebras
p
This theorem says that if p ( P
such that
[G, p. 156, (io6C).
A = Z~ P
A-comodules, where
the space
cf(Vp) E Ap,
Vp i.e.
V = (,~)
~ com(A),
is the unique such that
The proof given there does not depend on
the assumption that the sub-coalgebra summands
R
P
are minimal].
A
21 2.3
The Schur algebra
SK(n,r )
Theorem (2.2c) shows that each indecomposable module homogeneous,
i.e
V ~ MK(n,r)
confine our attention fixed, and define
for some
r > O.
to homogeneous modules.
SK(n,r )
As
K-space,
S K ~ , r ) has basis
{ei, j : i,J E l(n,r)} of
SK(n,r )
of
i
ci, j
if and only if
r
r ~ 0
be
~(n~r).
: i,j 6 I(n,r)}
For
dual to the basis
i,j 6 I(n,r),
~i,j
is the element
given by
~i'j(Cp'q) As with the
From now on, let
= HOmK(~(n,r) , K).
{~i,j
~(n,r).
is
This means that we may as well
to be the dual space of
SK(n,r) = ~ ( n , r )
V E ~(n)
=
if if
(i,j) ~ (p,q) (i,j) ~ (p,q)
all
•
p,q ~ I ( n , r ) .
we have an e~uality rule to take into account:
(i,j) ~ (k,g).
The dimension of
SK(n,r)
is
~i,j = ~k,~
of course
/ = dim AK(n,r ) . Since
algebra.
AK(n,r )
We saw in
is a coalgebra,
its dual
§i that the product
is defined as follows:
if
c ~ ~(n,r)
&(c) =
~
SK(n,r)
of elements
~,~
of
SK(n,r)
and if
Z ct @ ct t
where the sum is finite and the
ct, c t ~ AK(n,r),
(2.3a)
= ~ ~(ct)~(e ~),
(~n)(c)
is an associative
then
t The unit element of for all
c E AK(n,r).
SK(n,r)
will be denoted
a;
it is given by
s(c) = c(l r)
22
Applying (2.3a) to a basis element
of
c = Cp,q
AK(n ,r),
we ge<
(see (2.2b)) ( ~ ) (Cp, q) = s~ I(n,r) Specializing to the case where SK(n,r),
~ (c p, s)~ (c s,q ).
= ~i,j' ~ = ~k,g
we deduce a
Multiplication rule for
(2.3b)
SK(n,r ).
~i,j~k,Z
=
% {Z(i,j,k,g,p,q). IK} ~p,q, P,q
where the sum is over a set of re~r_esentatives of
are basis elements of
l(n,r) × l(n,r),
(p,q)
of the
G (r)-orbits
and
Z(i,J,k,~,p,q_)_ = Card{s 6 I(n,r)
: (i,J) ~ (p,s)
and
(k,~) ~ (s,q)}.
This multiplication rule (rather differently expressed) in due to Schur [S, p. 20]. (2.3c) (i)
Some special cases are worth noticing.
For any
i,j,k,~ 6 l(n,r)
~i,jSk,g = 0
i,i i,j
unless
i,J
j ~ k,
and
s, p,q k ~ s, From
with hence
distinct
~i,i
~i,j~k,g ~ 0,
(i,J) ~ (p,s)
and
then by (2.3b) there must
(k,g) ~ (s,q).
This implies
j ~ s
j ~ k.
(2.3c) follows that
Of course if
and
i,j j,j "
For example, (i) holds because if exist
there hold
i ~ J,
then
~2 :'i,i =
(i,i) ~ (J,j)
and
~i,i~j,j = 0
if
and hence
~i,i = <J,j"
But the
~i,i'
i # J.
form a set of mutually orthogonal idempotents, and their sum
is the unit element
e
of
SK(n,r).
This last equation,
23
sum over a set of representives of the
(2.3d) of
L = Z ~i,i, i l(n,r)
C (r)-orbits
c
is proved by evaluating both sides at all the basis elements Of great importance in the modular theory for for fixed
n,r,
the scheme or family of algebras
in the following sense. K ~i,j
elements Sz(n,r)
of
of
Let us use a superscript
SK(n,r).
SQ(n,r),
K
is "defined ever
is a
Z-order in
K-algebras
Z",
to denote the basis Z-submodule
SQ(n,r).
is
And for any field
Sz(n,r) @ K ~ SK(n,r)
which takes
K
~ ,j ® IK ~ ~i,j
The map
e : KF ~ SK(n,r)
For each
g E F
we define the element
eg(C) = c(g) (c E AK(n,r)). for all
g,g' E F;
the map
g ~ e
of
SK(n,r)
Q ~i,j(i,j E I(n,r)),
which is generated by the
there is an isomorphism of
each
2.4
is the fact that,
n
It is clear from (2.3b) that the
multiplicatively closed - - i t K,
GL
~(n,r) .
of
P,q
g
also
eg E SK(n,r )
by
It is clear from (2.3a) and (i) that
eI =
s by the definition of
linearly we get a map
~.
e : KF ~ SK(n,r)
egeg, = egg,
So if we extend which a morphism
K-algebras. Any function
f : KF ~ K. <=Z~g
(2.4a)
g
f E KF
has a unique extension to a linear map
With this convention,
EKF,
is "evaluation at
e(~)
' c -+ c(K),
the image under <";
all
e
of an element
i.e.
e E ~(n,r).
Propositions (2.4b,c) give the most important facts about
e.
24
(2.4b)
Proposition
(ii)
Let
Then
f ( AK(n,r )
Proof
(i)
exist
some
(i)
Y = Ker e,
e
is surjective.
and let
f
be any element
if and only if
If lme were a proper 0 # c E ~(n,r)
of
F K
f(Y) = 0. subspace
such that
of
SK(n,r)
eg(C)
= ~(n,r)
= c(g) = 0
,
there would
for all
g ( F,
a
contradiction. (ii)
If
f (AK(n,r)
by (2o4a).
So
K I' such that
and
f(Y) = 0. f(Y) = 0.
K E Y,
we have
Now suppose By
(i)
e(K) = 0
conversely
there
and hence
that
f
f(~) = 0,
is any element
of
is an exact sequence
0 ~ Y ~ KF ~ SK(n,r)
~ 0, *
from which it is clear y(e(~))
= f(<)
for all
there exists = e(<),
that there
c (1~(n,r)
then, we have
K E KF.
(2.4c)
Proposition
y (SK(n,r)
y(<) = <(c)
f(K) = e(K)(c)
and the proof of (2.4b)
some
By the natural
such that
f = c,
Let
exists
= c(<),
such that
isomorphism
SK(n,r)
~ ~(n,r),
for all
< (SK(n,r).
Put
all
K ~ KF.
Therefore
is complete.
V E mod(KF).
Then
V (~(n,r)
if and only if
YV = 0. Proof
Let
{v b}
by the action of if
rab(Y ) = 0
saying
be a basis KF
But of course the proof
of
V,
on this basis
for all
that all the
of
rab
a,b.
(rab)
(see (i)).
the invariant Clearly
By the last proposition,
lie in
AK(n,r) ,
this is the condition (2.4c)
and
is complete.
for
V
YV = 0
afforded
if and only
this equivalent
that is, that to belong
matrix
to
cf(V)
to
~ AK(n,r).
MK(n,r),
and so
25
There propositions are equivalent,
and in a very elementary
can be transformed
Kv
= e(K)v,
to relate the action on actions determine
V
of submodule,
all
[S,
on a module
V ~ ~(n,r),
F
action of
SK(n,r)
on a basis
We might mention
and
SK(n,r).
it holds for all
etc. coincide
on
Since both
V,
the
in the two categories.
that the action of
which is given by (2.4d),
{Vb}
of
% ~(rab)V a a
For it's clear that
outlined V
SK(n,r)
= AK(n,r)
is the same as that which
in the Introduction.
is given by equations
all
~ ~ SK(n,r) ,
(2.4d) holds, whenever
K f K
If the
(I~),
then the
and
K = g
Vb ~ B
and
v = v b.
By linearity
v ~ V.
theory
R. Brauer's
theory of modular representations
by Brauer himself
[B] and by Nakayama
More recently Serre [Se]
affine algebraic
groups,
GL
K
F K = GLn(K).)
n
(see also
of finite groups was
[N], to finite dimensional
[G]) extended
or rather to affine algebraic
group scheme
"reduction"
KF
is given by
~v b =
the group
in either category
was one of the main techniques used by Schur in his
p. 21].
action of
algebras.
V
mod(SK(n,r))
v E V
of the two algebras
is obtained by the general procedure
extended,
~ ~ KF,
module homomorphism,
dissertation
M0dular
way; an object
and
the same algebra of linear transformations
This category equivalence
2.5
MK(n,r )
into an object of the other, using the rule
(2.4d)
concepts
show that the categories
is a functor, which associates We can describe
or "decomposition"
the theory to
group schemes.
to each commutative
the characteristic
process as follows.
(The ring
modular
26 Let
Az
be the subsets of
consisting of those polynomials in the Z.
These are
"Z-forms" of Q-basis
{c~,j}
a(Az(n,r) 5 Z
(see (2.2b)).
of
i,j ~ l(n,r).
The
of all elements
Z-order
Now let
VQ
taking
such that
be any object of
which (i)
is the
Z-span of some
closed to the action of defined by rab
lie in
{vb}
Az(n,r).
That every
If
K,
there is a
c ,j ~ iK ~ ci, j
K-coalgebra
for all
~(Az(n,r) ~ Z.
M(n,r); we shall regard By a
Z-form of
Q-basls
{vb}
RQ = (rab)
where
(VQ,~) VQ
in
is the
of
VQ
as
VQ
is meant a subset
V,
and (ii) i~
is the invariant matrix
Az(n,r)-comodule determined hy
MQ(n,r)
contains at least one
Z-form,
, p. 256, §6] or [Se, p. 43, lemme 2] or [G , p. 158, (2.2c)].
If we now take any infinite field
hence as a
A~(n,r) ~ AZ(~,r) ~ ~(n,r),
Still another formulation of (ii) is that
QFQ-mOdule
follows from [B
VK = VZ ® K
is the
(see (I e )), then condition (li) just says that all the
T(V Z) ! V Z ® Az(n,r), VQ.
Sz(n,r ),
Az(n,r)
which we defined in (2.3), is the set
SQ(n,r)-module when this is convenient. VZ
and
For any infinite field
Sz(n,r)
~ ~ So(n,r)
for example
AQ(n,r),
Az(n,r) ® K ~ AK(n,r)
respectively,
whose coefficients all lie in
AQ(n), AQ(n,r);
Z-span of the
isomorphism
c
AQ(n), AQ(n,r)
K,
it is clear that the
can be regarded as a left module for ~K-mOdule in
M~(n,r).
K-space
SK(n,r ) ~ Sz(n,r) ~ K,
The transition from
VQ
to
VK
is
particularly easy to express in terms of invariant matrices; the invariant matrix
RK
defined by the
K-basis
{vb ® 1K}
of
VK,
(tab) = RQ
is the Invariant matrix defined by the basis
case where
K
has finite characteristic
the coefficient of
RQ.
is
(tab ~ IK) , where
{vb}
of
VQ.
In the
p, this amount to "reducing mod p"
27
Our notation in the preceding discussion conceals a disadvantage: there are in general many different VQ E MQ(n,r),
Z-forms
and the corresponding
may be not all isomorphic.
Vz,V~,...
KFK-mOdules
of a given
~Q-mOdule
V K = V Z ® K, V~ = V~ ~ K,...
However one of the classical results of modular
theory, deducible from [B , p. 257, (8)] or [Se, p. 44, theorhme 2] or [G, p. 162, (2.5a)], says that, for any type of simple E MK(n,r),
the multiplicity
depends only on case that d ~k'
VQ, i.e.
VQ = V
~ ( V K)
of
Lk
as composition factor in
is the same for all
is a simple
KFK-mOdule
Z-forms
VZ
of
VQ.
VK
In the
QFQ-mOdule, this multiplicity is often written
and referred to as a decomposition number for the modular reduction
MQ(n,r) ~ MK(n,r).
2.6
The module
E~r
Fix our infinite field E = E K = K.e I @ ... • K-e n {e
v
: v E n}
on which
=
gev
K,
and write
be an
n-dimensional
E
Z e ~E~ g~v ~
is an object of
Now let E<%r = E ~ . . ®
r ~ 0 E
Let
K-space with a basis
F acts "naturally":
=
% ~En
c v(g)e v ,
Since the corresponding invariant matrix is KF-module
F = F K = GLn(K ).
all
g E F, v E ~.
C = (c),
we see that the
AK(n,I).
be given, and then
in the usual way
(®
F
acts on the
here means
~).
{ei = eil ® "'" ~ eir : i E l(n,r)},
and relative to this the action of
F
is given by
r-fold tensor power Eer
has
K-basis
28
gej = ge
®.. ~
ge. ]r
Jl =
Z i(I(n,r)
The invariant matrix is E~r ( M K ( n , r ) . as an
(2.6a)
Sej =
Z i( I (n,r)
ci, j(g)ei,
all
. gilJl
g ~ F,
(ei,j) = C x ... × C,
According
SK(n,r)-module,
=
to
what
ei "" girJr
j ( l(n,r)
and this shows that
was said in (2~4),
E®r
can be regarded
by the rule
Z <(ci,j)ei, i(I(n,r)
all
< (SK(n,r) ,
j (l(n,r).
In a very famous paper [S'] which appeared in 1927, Schur rederived all the results of his 1901 dissertation ~r
[S] by an analysis of this module
Although his method gives a complete answer only when
char K = O,
it
is still valuable for fields of finite characteristic.
We make the s}~mmetric
group
act on the right of
Ef~r
G(r),
and hence also its group-algebra
KG(r),
by
(2.6b)
ei~
= ei~ ,
all
6 G(r).
i (l(n,r),
It is clear that this action commutes with that of with that of all
SK(n,r);
~ (SK(n,r),
KF,
we can verify from (2.6a) that
x ( Eo~r
and
~ (G(r).
or (what is the same) (~x)~
= ~(x~r)
We have however a stronger
statement. (2.6c)
Theorem (Schur)
representation afforded by the (i)
Im @
(ii)
Ker @ = 0.
Hence
= EndKG(r )(E ~ ) ,
SK(n,r ) ~ EndKG(r ) (E@r)
Let
~ : SK(n,r) ~ EndK(E~)
SK(n,r)-module and
E ~r.
Then
be the
for
2g
Proof
Each element
basis
{ei}
of
E®r.
of course, and the EndKG(r)(~ 'r)
0 E EndK(E Here
i,j
Ti, j ~ K.
Tin,j ~
the set
)
has matrix, say
(Ti,j)
for all
has a
lies in
Ti, j = i
and all
~p,q
of
SK(n,r )
I × I,
or
0
0
namely if
co
according as
(p,q).
~0 is such an orbit,
to be that
e E EndK(E~r)
whose
(i,j) ~ ~0 or not. (p,q) E I × I,
~r
is represented on
G(r)-orbit containing
~ ~ G(r).
K-basis in one-to-one correspondence with
G(r)-orbits On
has
i,j ~ I
it follows very readily from (2.6a) that, for any
~0 is the
e
From (2.6b) follows at once that
Ti,j,
EndKG(r)(E~r )
~ of all
element
I = I(n,r) ,
run independently over the set
define the corresponding basis element matrix
relative to the
(Ti,j) ,
if and only if
(2.6d)
Consequently
~r
by
Therefore
the basis
~(~p,q) = ~0 '
~
Now
where
induces an isomorphism
SK(n,r) -~ EndKG(r ) (E~r) , and this proves the theorem. Remark
The proof of (2.6c) shows that
sentation by the algebra of all condition having ~i,i
(2.6d).
Ti, j = 1
nr × nr
The basis element or
0
SK(n,r)
matrices
~p,q
according as
has a faithful matrix repre(Ti, j)
which satisfy
is represented by the matrix
(i,j) ~ (p,q)
or not.
The idempotents
are represented by diagonal matrices, and the "orthogonal" decomposition
(2.3d) is easy to deduce from this. (2.6e) then Proof
Corollary to (2.6c) (Sehur [S, S']). SK(n,r )
is semisimple.
Hence every
Under the given conditions on
is semisimple K-G(r)-module,
(since
char K
If
V ~ MK(n,r)
char K,
does mot divide
and in particular
E~r,
char K = 0,
or if char K = p > r,
is completely reducible.
the group algebra IG(r) I = r!).
K-G(r)
Therefore every
is completely reducible.
But the
endomomorphism algebra of a completely reducible module is semisimple,
so by
30
(2.6c), and
SK(n,r)
mod SK(n,r)
is semisimple.
is clearly "defined over is simply a version of
{~r}
Z"
,
r
fixed but with
Z.
GL -module, n
We say that the family
a
of
in the category
VQ,
{V K}
and for each
~(n,r).
varying,
GL
being regarded
n
See [Se, p. 46]).
Suppose that for each infinite field
VZ
K
in the sense of the following definition (which
V K E MK(n,r).
and
with
the definition of
as affine group scheme over
Z-form
~(n,r)
now completes the proof of (2.6e).
The family of modules
Definition
The equivalence of the categories
K
K
we have a
is defined over
an isomorphism
More exactly we say
{VK}
KFK-mOdule Z
if there is
6 K : VZ @ K ~ VK
is
Z-defined by
VZ
{6K}.
Example I.
Take
of
VQ
(we write
of
EK, E®r K ),
MK(n,r), ively.
for all
is defined over
Definition
The module
Suppose that
K
the
K
Z i~l(n,r)
Z.e i
is a
Z-form
for the basis elements
6K : V Z ~ K ~ V K
is an isomorphism in
taking ~(n,r).
So
Z. {VK} , {WK} Z,
Suppose we have for each
We say that the family
K-map
i E l(n,r),
both defined over
and for each
VZ =
e~,K, ei,K = eil,K ® "'" ® eir,K
and for each
e i ® 1 K ~ ei,K, {~K r}
V K = E~ r.
{eK}
By K
are both families of modules in VZ
and
{6K} ,
a morphism
is defined over
Z
GQ~ K
VK
>
OK - - >
and
{~K},
eK : V K ~ W K
the diagram shown commutes VZ ® K
WZ
WZ ® K
WK
if
eQ
maps
in
respectM~(n,r).
VZ
into
Wz,
31
Example 2. the
r th
Define the
r th
monomial
Dr, K
of a given
Z-form
of degree
in the variables
r
Dr, Z
The isomorphism
for all
i E I(n,r).
defined over
Z
in
by
becomes a
{Dr,K}
is defined over
belong
e I = el,Q,..., en = en,Q, takes
which have coefficients
e(i ) ,Q ~ 1K ~+ e(i ) ,K
V
In this sectlo~ we keep = HomK(V,K)
of a
(v E V).
K
one defines
a left
action
However the
to our category
which is still in
with this
{O K } is
KF-module if
fixed and write V E MK(n,r )
f E V ,
To make
V
g E F
(denoted
KF-module
NK(n,r).
V
by a d o t )
F-action
~L.(n,r). K-
KF-module
F
to "reverse" on
V
so defined will not, in
B u t i f we r e p l a c e
We denote by
can be
g ~ g-i of
F = F K.
define
into a left
(transposed matrix) in the above definition, we get a left V
Z ;
is the set of all homogeneous polynomials
K -module in a natural way:
by (g'f)(v) = f(g-lv). general,
Dr, K
which takes
It is clear now that the family of morphisms
(fg)(v) = f(gv)
multiplication;
KF-map:
is the restriction to
the traditional practice in group-theory is to use the map
on
There is
in the sense of the last definition.
The dual space made into right
Dr, Q
@K
K[el,.°.,en]
~]K : Dr,Z ~ K -~ Dr, K
Contravariant duality
fg E V
g E F,
We can show that the family
the relevant
2.7
K[el,...,en];
KF-module, such that
K-algebra automorphism of
-~ ge (~ E n).
Z.
to be
are regarded as commuting indeterminate..
has a unique structure as
of the unique
in
EK
K-map
in fact tha action on
e
of
e K : Eer -~ Dr(EK) taking e i = ell @ ... ~ e i to the K r e(i) = ell "'" eir ' for all i E I(n,r). It is well-known that
a surjectivc
r,K
Dr, K = Dr(EK)
homogeneous subspace of the polynomial
e I = el,K,..., e n = en, K
D
symmetric power
V°
g
-i
by
g
tr
KF-module structure
the space
V ,
equipped
32
(2.7a)
V°
(g-f)(v) = f(gtrv)
all
is called the "contravariant dual" to
g E F, f E V , v E V.
V;
an analogous dual applies to
rational modules over all semisimple algebraic groups a great
deal in recent years by Wong
F,
and has been used
[W], Verma [V] and Jantzen
[J].
It is convenient to express (2.7a) in terms of the action of It is easy to see that the J(
all
K-linear map
i,j E I(n,r)
In fact one has clearly, for any
J(~)(ci,j) = ~(cj,i),
and by taking
~
= e
we find that
is regarded as
the contravariant dual
(2.7c)
MK(n,r) ,
V°( = V )
J(eg) = e t r ' g
(,) : V × W ~ K
V, W
g E F.
gives an exact contravariant function on V ~ (V)
of
K-spaces,
V ~ (V°) °.
be modules in
MK(n,r).
Then a
K-bilinear form
is called contravariant if it has the property
(~v,w) = (v,J(~)w),
So if
~ E SK(n,r) , f E V , v E V.
and that the usual natural isomorphism
Let
all
reads
all
V ~ V°
gives a natural isomorphism Definitio N
i,j E I(n,r),
SK(n,r)-module the action (2.7a) which defines
(~.f)(v) = f(J($)v),
It is clear that
~ E SK(n,r),
all
g V E MK(n,r)
given by
is an involutory anti-automorphism of
(2.7b)
(2.7d)
J : SK(n,r ) -~ SK(n,r)
SK(n,r).
all
~ E SK(n,r) , v E V, w E W.
The proof of the next proposition is standard.
33 (2.7e)
Proposition
correspondence A
: V~
W°
If
V, W 6 ~ ( n , r )
between contravariant
in
~(n,r),
(,)
forms
(,) : V × W + K,
and morphisms
given by
A(v)(w)
The form
are given, there is a bijective
= (v,w),
is non-singular
all
v ~ V, w 6 W.
(= non-degenerate)
if and only if
F
is an
isomorphism. Example 1
We can use the last proposition to show that the module
self-dual,
that is that
~r
~ (~r)o
: E~r × ~ r
<,>
i,j ~ I(n,r).
But a simple calculation,
on
defined by
condition
<ei,ej>
=
6ij,
using (2.6a), shows that
(2.7d). Call <,>
all <,>
the canonical form
E~r .
Example 2
Let
Z-defined by
{VK} VZ
and
be a family of modules {6K}
V Z.
For each
a basis of
K,
write
(V K E ~ ( n , r ) )
as in the last section.
running over some finite index set Va, K =
B) be a basis of 6K(Va, Q ® 1 K)
For each Then a,Q
K,
write
{fa,K}
for the basis of
VzO = {f ~ VQ : f(Vz) --c Z} }.
which is
Let VQ
so that
{Va,Q} which
(~ Z-generates
{Va, K : a 6 B}
is
V K.
We can now show easily that the family
{f
is
For there is clearly a non-singular
bilinear form
satisfies the contravariant
~ K
E~r
is a
It is not hard to see that
6K : VZo ® K ~ VKo
which take
° {V K}
V K* = V oK
Z-form of {VK} o
is
fa,Q ~ IK °+ fa,K'
is defined over
o VZ,
dual to having
Z-defined by all
a 6 B.
Z.
{Va,K}°
Z-basis V oZ
and the maps
34
Example 3
Let
which are
Z-defined by
K
and
{WK}
is defined over
and for each
be families
VZ, {6 K}
we have a bilinear form
{(,)K } K,
{VK}
and
(VK
WZ, {~K }
(')K : VK x WK ~ K,
Z
if
v Z E VZ,
(,)Q
wZ E WZ
maps
and
WK
both in
respectively.
M~(n,r)~
If for every
we say that the family
Vz x Wz
into
z,
and for each
there holds
(SK(Vz ® IK), nK(wZ ® IK)) K = (Vz,Wz).l K. If all the (')K
are contravariant, W Ko
then we can
(given, for each
show
K,
by Proposition
family of morphisms
AK : VK
is defined over
For example, the family of canonical forms
Z.
EK~)r is defined over EK~r ~ (E~r) ° K
2.8
AK(n,r)
Z,
is a
these two
KF
on
derived from these forms.
as
KF-bimodule
KF-bimodule,
i.e.
actions commute.
there holds an equation (see 2.3).
<'>K
(2.7e))
and so therefore is the family of isomorphisms
We saw in the introduction (p.4) that the space f:F ÷ K
that the
KF
it is a left and right If we take an element
&(c) = Z c t ~ c't ' t
of all functions KF-module, and
c E AK(n,r)
for suitable elements
,
then
c t ,c't c AK(n,r)
By formulae (ic), (Id),
(2.8a)
g o c = ~ c~(g)c t , t
for any
g g F .
KF-actions, hence
c o g = Z ct(g)c' t' t
This shows that ~(n,r)
AK(n,r) is closed to both the left and right
is itself a
K -bimodule.
linearity, to give the action of an arbitrary element
Now extend (2°8a) by < c K :
35
c o < = Z ct(K)_- c tv
< o c = Ec'(K)ctt'
By (2.4b), we find (2.4c) shows that MK(n,r)
.
~(n,r)
AK(n,r)
Similarly of right
bimodule,
(2.8b)
K o c = c o ~ = O , ,
regarded
AK(n,r)
belongs
KF-modules
as left
K ~ Y = Ker e . K£-module,
to an analogously
(see 4.4).
AK(n,r)
belongs
defined
becomes
Then
an
to
category
SK(n,r)-
with actions
~ o c = Z$(c~)e t ,
c o % = Z~(ct)c ~ ,
Now let us define a bilinear rule:
for any
if
~ E SK(n,r)
form
, c c AK(n,r)
,
(
,
for
~ E SK(n,r)
•
by the
):SK(n,r)~K(n,r ) ~ K
then
($,c) = J ( O ( c )
This is non-singular, to
(
,
)
(see (2.7b)).
~,q E SK(n,r)
(2.8c)
in fact
,
{cj, i}
are dual bases with respect
The reader may check that for any
c e AK(n,r)
there holds
(~n,c) = (~,J(~) o c) = (~,c o J(q))
In fact, using
(2.3a),
all three expressions shows that left
{$i,j},
(
,
)
(2.7e) we deduce
(2.8b) and the d e f i n i t i o n just given are equal
is eontravariant,
SK(n,r)-modules that
.
to
SK(n,r)
of
( , ) ,
E(~,c~)(q,c t) • and
AK(n,r)
(and even when they are regarded AK(n,r)
~ (SK(n,r)) ° ,
we see that But
(2.8c)
being regarded
as right modules).
an isomorphism of
as
By
KF-bimodules.
2 Polynomial Representations of GLn (K): The Schur algebra
2.1 Notation, etc. Let n be a positive integer, K an infinite field, and Γ = GLn (K) the group of all non-singular n × n matrices over K. For each pair µ, ν of elements of n = {1, . . . , n}, let cµν ∈ K Γ be the function which associates to each g ∈ Γ its (µ, ν)-coefficient gµν . Denote by A or AK (n) the K-subalgebra of K Γ generated by the functions cµν (µ, ν ∈ n); the elements of A are, by definition, the polynomial functions on Γ. Since K is infinite, the cµν are algebraically independent over K, so that A can be regarded as the algebra of all polynomials over K in n2 “indeterminates” cµν (µ, ν ∈ n). For each r ≥ 0 we denote by AK (n, r) the subspace of A consisting of the elements expressible as polynomials which are homogeneous of degree r 2 as K-space; in parin the cµν . Then AK (n, r) has finite dimension n +r−1 r ticular AK (n, 0) = K · 1A , where 1A denotes the constant function 1A which maps g → 1K for all g ∈ Γ. The K-algebra A has the standard grading AK (n, r). (2.1a) A = AK (n) = r≥0
If integers n, r (both ≥ 1) are given, we write I(n, r) for the set of all functions i : r → n. Such a function is usually written as vector or “multiindex” i = (i1 , . . . , ir ) with values i ∈ n. The symmetric group on the set r = {1, . . . , r} is denoted G(r) or G. It acts naturally on the right on I(n, r) by iπ = (iπ(1) , . . . , iπ(r) ), so that π ∈ G(r) acts as “place-permutation” on each i ∈ I(n, r). We make G(r) act also on the set I(n, r) × I(n, r) by (i, j)π = (iπ, jπ). We write i ∼ j to indicate that the elements i, j of I(n, r) are in the same G(r)-orbit, i.e. that j = iπ for some π ∈ G(r). Similarly (i, j) ∼ (k, l) means that k = iπ and l = jπ for some π ∈ G(r). As an example of the use of this notation, notice that AK (n, r) is spanned, as K-space, by the monomials (2.1b)
ci,j = ci1 j1 ci2 j2 · · · cir jr ,
12
2 Polynomial Representations of GLn (K): The Schur algebra
for all i, j ∈ I(n, r). Of course the pair (i, j) is not uniquely determined by the monomial (2.1b); in fact ci,j = ck,l if and only if (i, j) ∼ (k, l). The space AK (n, r) has as K-basis the set of distinct monomials (2.1b), and these are in bijective correspondence with the G(r)-orbits of I(n, r) × I(n, r). Thus 2 . the number of these orbits is n +r−1 r
2.2 The categories MK (n), MK (n, r) The maps ∆ : K Γ → K Γ×Γ , ε : K Γ → K (see introduction) behave as follows on the functions cµν (µ, ν ∈ n): (2.2a) ∆(cµν ) = cµλ ⊗ cλν , ε(cµν ) = δµν . λ∈n
These follow from the rule for multiplying two matrices, and from the formula for the unit element 1Γ of Γ. Since ∆, ε are both multiplicative we deduce, for any “multi-indices” p, q ∈ I(n, r) of length r ≥ 1, cp,s ⊗ cs,q , ε(cp,q ) = δp,q . (2.2b) ∆(cp,q ) = s∈I
Here δp,q = 1 or 0, according as p = q or p = q. These formulae show that A = AK (n) is a subcoalgebra (hence also a subbialgebra) of F (K Γ ), and that each AK (n, r) is a subcoalgebra of AK (n) (for r = 0 this is because ∆1A = 1A ⊗ 1A ). We shall write MK (n) and MK (n, r) for the categories modAK (n) (KΓ) and modAK (n,r) (KΓ). Thus MK (n) is the category of finite-dimensional (left) KΓ-modules which afford “polynomial” representations of Γ = GLn (K); and MK (n, r) is the subcategory consisting of those affording representations in which all the coefficients are polynomials homogeneous of degree r in the cµν . By an argument first given by Schur [47, p. 5] in case K = C, but valid for any infinite field K of any characteristic, we have (2.2c) Theorem. Each KΓ-module V ∈ MK (n) has a direct sum decomposition Vr , V = r≥0
where for each r ≥ 0, Vr is a sub-module of V with cf(Vr ) ≤ AK (n, r), that is Vr ∈ MK (n, r). In other words each polynomial representation of Γ is equivalent to a direct sum of homogeneous ones. Remark. In fact (2.2c) follows from a general theorem onA-comodules, where A is any coalgebra which is a direct sum A = A of subcoalgebras A ( ranging over anindex set P ). This theorem says that if V = (V, τ ) ∈ com(A), then V = V , where for each ∈ P the space V is the unique maximum sub-comodule of V such that cf(V ) ≤ A , i.e. such that V ∈ com(A ) [20, p. 156, (1.6c). The proof given there does not depend on the assumption that the subcoalgebra summands R are minimal].
2.3 The Schur algebra SK (n, r)
13
2.3 The Schur algebra SK (n, r) Theorem (2.2c) shows that each indecomposable module V ∈ MK (n) is homogeneous, i.e. V ∈ MK (n, r) for some r ≥ 0. This means that we may as well confine our attention to homogeneous modules. From now on, let r ≥ 0 be fixed, and define SK (n, r) to be the dual space of AK (n, r): SK (n, r) = AK (n, r)∗ = HomK (AK (n, r), K). As K-space, SK (n, r) has basis {ξi,j : i, j ∈ I(n, r)} dual to the basis {ci,j : i, j ∈ I(n, r)} of AK (n, r). For i, j ∈ I(n, r), ξi,j is the element of SK (n, r) given by 1 if (i, j) ∼ (p, q) , all p, q ∈ I(n, r). ξi,j (cp,q ) = 0 if (i, j) ∼ (p, q) As with the ci,j we have an equality rule to take into account: ξi,j = ξk,l if and only if (i, j) ∼ (k, l). The dimension of SK (n, r) is of course equal 2 = dim AK (n, r). to n +r−1 r Since AK (n, r) is a coalgebra, its dual SK (n, r) is an associative algebra. We saw in §1 that the product ξη of elements ξ, η of SK (n, r) is defined as follows: if c ∈ AK (n, r) and if ∆(c) = ct ⊗ ct t
where the sum is finite and the ct , ct ∈ AK (n, r), then ξ(ct )η(ct ). (2.3a) (ξη)(c) = t
The unit element of SK (n, r) will be denoted ε ; it is given by ε(c) = c(1Γ ) for all c ∈ AK (n, r). Applying (2.3a) to a basis element c = cp,q of AK (n, r), we get (see (2.2b)) ξ(cp,s )η(cs,q ). (ξη)(cp,q ) = s∈I(n,r)
Specializing to the case where ξ = ξi,j , η = ξk,l are basis elements of SK (n, r), we deduce a Multiplication Rule for SK (n, r). {Z(i, j, k, l, p, q).1K }ξp,q , (2.3b) ξi,j ξk,l = p,q
where the sum is over a set of representatives (p, q) of the G(r)-orbits of I(n, r) × I(n, r), and Z(i, j, k, l, p, q) = Card{ s ∈ I(n, r) : (i, j) ∼ (p, s) and (k, l) ∼ (s, q) }.
14
2 Polynomial Representations of GLn (K): The Schur algebra
This multiplication rule (rather differently expressed) is due to Schur (see [47, p. 20]). Some special cases are worth noticing. (2.3c) For any i, j, k, l ∈ I(n, r) there hold (i) ξi,j ξk,l = 0 unless j ∼ k, and (ii) ξi,i ξi,j = ξi,j = ξi,j ξj,j . For example, (i) holds because if ξi,j ξk,l = 0, then by (2.3b) there must exist s, p, q with (i, j) ∼ (p, s) and (k, l) ∼ (s, q). This implies j ∼ s and k ∼ s, hence j ∼ k. 2 = ξi,i , and ξi,i ξj,j = 0 if i ∼ j. Of course From (2.3c) follows that ξi,i if i ∼ j, then (i, i) ∼ (j, j) and hence ξi,i = ξj,j . But the distinct ξi,i form a set of mutually orthogonal idempotents, and their sum is the unit element ε of SK (n, r). This last equation, ξi,i , sum over a set of representatives of the G(r)-orbits (2.3d) ε = i of I(n, r) is proved by evaluating both sides at all the basis elements cp,q of AK (n, r). Of great importance in the modular theory for GLn is the fact that, for fixed n, r, the scheme or family of algebras SK (n, r) is “defined over Z”, in the K following sense. Let us use a superscript K to denote the basis elements ξi,j of SK (n, r). It is clear from (2.3b) that the Z-submodule SZ (n, r) of SQ (n, r), Q (i, j ∈ I(n, r)), is multiplicatively closed—it is which is generated by the ξi,j a Z-order in SQ (n, r). And for any field K, there is an isomorphism of K-alQ K gebras SZ (n, r) ⊗ K ∼ . = SK (n, r) which takes each ξi,j ⊗ 1K → ξi,j
2.4 The map e : KΓ → SK (n, r) For each g ∈ Γ we define the element eg ∈ SK (n, r) by eg (c) = c(g) for all c ∈ AK (n, r). It is clear from (2.3a) and §1 that eg eg = egg for all g, g ∈ Γ; also e1 = ε by the definition of ε. So if we extend the map g → eg linearly we get a map e : KΓ → SK (n, r) which is a morphism of K-algebras. Any function f ∈ K Γ has a unique extension to a linear map f : KΓ → K. With this convention, the image under e of an element κ = κg g ∈ KΓ, is “evaluation at κ”; i.e. (2.4a)
e(κ) : c → c(κ), all c ∈ AK (n, r).
Propositions (2.4b), (2.4c) give the most important facts about e. (2.4b) Proposition. (i) e is surjective. (ii) Let Y = Ker e, and let f be any element of K Γ . Then f ∈ AK (n, r) if and only if f (Y ) = 0.
2.4 The map e : KΓ → SK (n, r)
15
Proof. (i) If Im e were a proper subspace of SK (n, r) = AK (n, r)∗ , there would exist some 0 = c ∈ AK (n, r) such that eg (c) = c(g) = 0 for all g ∈ Γ, a contradiction. (ii) If f ∈ AK (n, r) and κ ∈ Y , we have e(κ) = 0 and hence f (κ) = 0, by (2.4a). So f (Y ) = 0. Now suppose conversely that f is any element of K Γ such that f (Y ) = 0. By (i) there is an exact sequence e
0 −→ Y −→ KΓ −→ SK (n, r) −→ 0, from which it is clear that there exists an element y ∈ SK (n, r)∗ such that y(e(κ)) = f (κ) for all κ ∈ KΓ. By the natural isomorphism SK (n, r)∗ ∼ = AK (n, r), there exists c ∈ AK (n, r) such that y(ξ) = ξ(c) for all ξ ∈ SK (n, r). Put ξ = e(κ), then we have f (κ) = e(κ)(c) = c(κ), all κ ∈ KΓ. Therefore f = c, and the proof of (2.4b) is complete. (2.4c) Proposition. Let V ∈ mod(KΓ). Then V ∈ MK (n, r) if and only if Y V = 0. Proof. Let {vb } be a basis of V , and (rab ) the invariant matrix afforded by the action of KΓ on this basis (see §1). Clearly Y V = 0 if and only if rab (Y ) = 0 for all a, b. By the last proposition, this is equivalent to saying that all the rab lie in AK (n, r), that is, that cf(V ) ≤ AK (n, r). But of course this is the condition for V to belong to MK (n, r), and so the proof of (2.4c) is complete. These propositions show that the categories MK (n, r) and mod(SK (n, r)) are equivalent, and in a very elementary way; an object V in either category can be transformed into an object of the other, using the rule (2.4d)
κv = e(κ)v, all κ ∈ KΓ, v ∈ V
to relate the action on V of the two algebras KΓ and SK (n, r). Since both actions determine the same algebra of linear transformations on V , the concepts of submodule, module homomorphism, etc. coincide in the two categories. This category equivalence was one of the main techniques used by Schur in his dissertation [47, p. 21]. We might mention that the action of SK (n, r) = AK (n, r)∗ on a module V ∈ MK (n, r), which is given by (2.4d), is the same as that which is obtained by the general procedure outlined in the introduction. If the action of Γ on a basis {vb } of V is given by equations (1e), then the action of SK (n, r) is given by ξ(rab )va , all ξ ∈ SK (n, r), b ∈ B. ξvb = a
For it is clear that (2.4d) holds, whenever κ = g and v = vb . By linearity it holds for all κ ∈ KΓ and v ∈ V .
16
2 Polynomial Representations of GLn (K): The Schur algebra
2.5 Modular theory R. Brauer’s theory of modular representations of finite groups was extended, by Brauer himself [5] and by Nakayama [42, 43, 44], to finite dimensional algebras. More recently Serre [49] (see also [20]) extended the theory to affine algebraic groups, or rather to affine algebraic group schemes. (The group scheme GLn is a functor, which associates to each commutative ring K the group ΓK = GLn (K).) We can describe the characteristic modular “reduction” or “decomposition” process as follows. Let AZ (n), AZ (n, r) be the subsets of AQ (n), AQ (n, r) respectively, consisting of those polynomials in the cµν whose coefficients all lie in Z. These are “Z-forms” of AQ (n), AQ (n, r); for example, AZ (n, r) is the Z-span of the Q-basis {cQ i,j } of AQ (n, r), and we have ∆AZ (n, r) ⊆ AZ (n, r) ⊗ AZ (n, r) and ε(AZ (n, r)) ≤ Z (see (2.2b)). For any infinite field K, there is a K-coalQ gebra isomorphism AZ (n, r) ⊗ K ∼ = AK (n, r) which takes ci,j ⊗ 1K → cK i,j for all i, j ∈ I(n, r). The Z-order SZ (n, r) which we defined in 2.3, is the set of all elements ξ ∈ SQ (n, r) such that ξ(AZ (n, r)) ≤ Z. Now let VQ be any object in MQ (n, r); we shall regard VQ as a module for SQ (n, r) when this is convenient. By a Z-form of VQ is meant a subset VZ which (i) is the Z-span of some Q-basis {vb } of VQ , and (ii) is closed to the action of SZ (n, r). If RQ = (rab ) is the invariant matrix defined by {vb } (see (1e)), then condition (ii) just says that all the rab lie in AZ (n, r). Still another formulation of (ii) is that τ (VZ ) ⊆ VZ ⊗ AZ (n, r), where (VQ , τ ) is the AZ (n, r)-comodule determined by VQ . That every QΓQ -module VQ in MQ (n, r) contains at least one Z-form, follows from [5, p. 256, §6] or [49, p. 43, lemme 2] or [20, p. 158, (2.2c)]. Now take any infinite field K. It is clear that the K-space VK = VZ ⊗ K can be regarded as a left module for SK (n, r) ∼ = SZ (n, r) ⊗ K, hence as a KΓK -module in MK (n, r). The transition from VQ to VK is particularly easy to express in terms of invariant matrices; the invariant matrix RK defined by the K-basis {vb ⊗ 1K } of VK , is (rab ⊗ 1K ), where (rab ) = RQ is the invariant matrix defined by the basis {vb } of VQ . In the case where K has finite characteristic p, this amounts to “reducing mod p” the coefficients of RQ . Our notation in the preceding discussion conceals a disadvantage: in general there are many different Z-forms VZ , VZ , . . . of a given QΓQ -module VQ ∈ MQ (n, r), and the corresponding KΓK -modules VK = VZ ⊗ K, VK = VZ ⊗ K, . . . may be not all isomorphic. However one of the classical results of modular theory, deducible from [5, p. 258, (8)] or [49, p. 44, th´eor`eme 2] or [20, p. 162, (2.5a)], says that, for any type of simple KΓK module Lλ ∈ MK (n, r), the multiplicity mλ (VK ) of Lλ as a composition factor in VK depends only on VQ , i.e. is the same for all Z-forms VZ of VQ .
2.6 The module E ⊗r
17
In the case that VQ = Vµ is a simple QΓQ -module, this multiplicity is often written dµλ , and referred to as a decomposition number for the modular reduction MQ (n, r) → MK (n, r).
2.6 The module E⊗r Fix our infinite field K, and write Γ = ΓK = GLn (K). Let E = EK = K · e1 ⊕ · · · ⊕ K · en be an n-dimensional K-space with a basis { eν : ν ∈ n } on which Γ acts “naturally”: geν = gµν eµ = cµν (g)eµ , all g ∈ Γ, ν ∈ n. µ∈n
µ∈n
Since the corresponding invariant matrix is C = (cµν ), we see that the KΓmodule E is an object of AK (n, 1). Now let r ≥ 1, then Γ acts on the r-fold tensor power E ⊗r = E ⊗ · · · ⊗ E in the usual way (⊗ here means ⊗K ). The space E ⊗r has K-basis { ei = ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ eir : i ∈ I(n, r) }, and relative to this the action of Γ is given by gej = gej1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ gejr =
gi1 j1 · · · gir jr ei =
i∈I(n,r)
ci,j (g)ei ,
i∈I(n,r)
all g ∈ Γ, j ∈ I(n, r). The corresponding invariant matrix is (ci,j ) = C × · · · × C, and this shows that E ⊗r ∈ MK (n, r). According to what was said in 2.4, E ⊗r can be regarded as an SK (n, r)-module, by the rule (2.6a) ξej = ξ(ci,j )ei , all ξ ∈ SK (n, r), j ∈ I(n, r). i∈I(n,r)
In a very famous paper [48] which appeared in 1927, Schur rederived all the results of his 1901 dissertation [47] by an analysis of this module E ⊗r . Although his method gives a complete answer only when char K = 0, it is still valuable for fields of finite characteristic. We make the symmetric group G(r), and hence also its group algebra KG(r), act on the right of E ⊗r by (2.6b)
ei π = eiπ , all i ∈ I(n, r), π ∈ G(r).
It is clear that this action commutes with that of KΓ, or (what is the same) with that of SK (n, r); we can verify from (2.6a) that (ξx)π = ξ(xπ) for all ξ ∈ SK (n, r), x ∈ E ⊗r and π ∈ G(r). We have however a stronger statement.
18
2 Polynomial Representations of GLn (K): The Schur algebra
(2.6c) Theorem (Schur). Let ψ : SK (n, r) → EndK (E ⊗r ) be the representation afforded by the SK (n, r)-module E ⊗r . Then (i) Im ψ = EndKG(r) (E ⊗r ), and (ii) Ker ψ = 0. Hence SK (n, r) ∼ = EndKG(r) (E ⊗r ). Proof. Each element θ ∈ EndK (E ⊗r ) has matrix, say (Ti,j ), relative to the basis {ei } of E ⊗r . Here i, j run independently over the set I = I(n, r), of course, and the Ti,j ∈ K. From (2.6b) follows at once that θ lies in EndKG(r) (E ⊗r ) if and only if (2.6d)
Tiπ,jπ = Ti,j , for all i, j ∈ I and all π ∈ G(r).
Consequently EndKG(r) (E ⊗r ) has a K-basis in one-to-one correspondence with the set Ω of all G(r)-orbits on I ×I, namely if ω is such an orbit, define the corresponding basis element θω to be that θ ∈ EndK (E ⊗r ) whose matrix (Ti,j ) has Ti,j = 1 or 0 according as (i, j) ∈ ω or not. Now it follows very readily from (2.6a) that, for any (p, q) ∈ I × I, the basis element ξp,q of SK (n, r) is represented on E ⊗r by ψ(ξp,q ) = θω , where ω is the G(r)-orbit containing (p, q). Therefore ψ induces an isomorphism SK (n, r) → EndKG(r) (E ⊗r ), and this proves the theorem. Remark. The proof of (2.6c) shows that SK (n, r) has a faithful matrix representation by the algebra of all nr × nr matrices (Ti,j ) which satisfy condition (2.6d). The basis element ξp,q is represented by the matrix having Ti,j = 1 or 0 according as (i, j) ∼ (p, q) or not. The idempotents ξi,i are represented by diagonal matrices, and the “orthogonal” decomposition (2.3d) is easy to deduce from this. (2.6e) Corollary (Schur [47, 48]). If char K = 0, or if char K = p > r, then SK (n, r) is semisimple. Hence every V ∈ MK (n, r) is completely reducible. Proof. Under the given conditions on char K, the group algebra KG(r) is semisimple (since char K does not divide |G(r)| = r!). Therefore every KG(r)-module, and in particular E ⊗r , is completely reducible. But the endomorphism algebra of a completely reducible module is semisimple, so by (2.6c), SK (n, r) is semisimple. The equivalence of categories MK (n, r) and mod SK (n, r) now completes the proof of (2.6e). ⊗r The family of modules (EK ), with r fixed but with K varying, is clearly “defined over Z” in the sense of the following definition (which is simply a version of the definition of GLn -module, GLn being regarded as affine group scheme over Z. See [49, p. 46]).
2.7 Contravariant duality
19
Definition. Suppose that for each infinite field K we have a KΓK -module VK ∈ MK (n, r). We say that the family {VK } is defined over Z if there is a Z-form VZ of VQ , and for each K an isomorphism δK : VZ ⊗ K ∼ = VK in the category MK (n, r). More exactly we say {VK } is Z-defined by VZ and {δK }. ⊗r Example 1. Take VK = EK . The module VZ = i∈I(n,r) Z · ei is a Z-form of VQ (we write eµ,K , ei,K = ei1 ,K ⊗ · · · ⊗ eir ,K for the basis elements ⊗r ), and for each K the K-map δK : VZ ⊗ K → VK taking of EK , EK ⊗r } ei ⊗ 1K → ei,K , for all i ∈ I(n, r), is an isomorphism in MK (n, r). So {EK is defined over Z. Definition. Suppose {VK }, {WK } are both families of modules in MK (n, r), both defined over Z, by VZ and {δK }, WZ and {ηK }, respectively. Suppose we have for each K a morphism θK : VK → WK in MK (n, r). We say that the family {θK } is defined over Z if θQ maps VZ into WZ , and for each K the diagram shown commutes. VZ ⊗ K
θ Q ⊗ πK
ηK
δK VK
/ WZ ⊗ K
θK
/ WK
Example 2. Define the rth symmetric power Dr,K = Dr (EK ) of EK to be the rth homogeneous subspace of the polynomial ring K[e1 , . . . , en ]; the elements e1 = e1,K , . . . , en = en,K are regarded as commuting indeterminates. ⊗r → Dr (EK ) taking ei = ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ eir to There is a surjective K-map θK : EK the monomial e(i) = ei1 · · · eir , for all i ∈ I(n, r). It is well-known that Dr,K has a unique structure as a KΓ-module, such that θK becomes a KΓ-map; in fact the action on Dr,K of a given g ∈ Γ, is the restriction to Dr,K of the unique K-algebra automorphism of K[e1 , . . . , en ] which takes eµ → geµ for all µ ∈ n. We can show that the family {Dr,K } is defined over Z; the relevant Z-form Dr,Z in Dr,Q is the set of all homogeneous polynomials of degree r in the variables e1 = e1,Q , . . . , en = en,Q , which have coefficients in Z. The isomorphism ηK : Dr,Z ⊗ K → Dr,K takes e(i),Q ⊗ 1K → e(i),K for all i ∈ I(n, r). It is clear now that the family of morphisms {θK } is defined over Z in the sense of the last definition.
2.7 Contravariant duality In this section we keep K fixed and write Γ = ΓK . The dual space V ∗ = HomK (V, K) of a KΓ-module V ∈ MK (n, r) can be made into a right KΓ-module in a natural way: if f ∈ V ∗ , g ∈ Γ,
20
2 Polynomial Representations of GLn (K): The Schur algebra
we define f g ∈ V ∗ by (f g)(v) = f (gv) for all v ∈ V . To make V ∗ into a left KΓ-module the traditional practice in group theory is to use the map g → g −1 to “reverse” multiplication; one defines a left action (denoted by a dot) of Γ on V ∗ by (g · f )(v) = f (g −1 v). However the KΓ-module V ∗ so defined will not, in general, belong to our category MK (n, r). But if we replace g −1 by g tr (transposed matrix) in the above definition, we get a left KΓ-module structure on V ∗ which is still in MK (n, r). We denote by V ◦ the space V ∗ , equipped with this action (2.7a)
(g · f )(v) = f (g tr v), all g ∈ Γ, f ∈ V ∗ , v ∈ V .
The module V ◦ is called the “contravariant dual” to V ; an analogous dual applies to rational modules over all semisimple algebraic groups Γ, and has been used a great deal in recent years by Wong [56], Verma [53] and Jantzen [29]. It is convenient to express (2.7a) in terms of the action of SK (n, r). It is easy to see that the K-linear map J : SK (n, r) → SK (n, r), defined by J(ξi,j ) = ξj,i for all i, j ∈ I(n, r), is an involutory anti-automorphism of SK (n, r). In fact one has clearly, for any ξ ∈ SK (n, r) (2.7b)
J(ξ)(ci,j ) = ξ(cj,i ), all i, j ∈ I(n, r),
and by taking ξ = eg we find that J(eg ) = egtr , all g ∈ Γ. So if V ∈ MK (n, r) is regarded as SK (n, r)-module the action (2.7a) which defines the contravariant dual V ◦ (= V ∗ ) reads (2.7c)
(ξ · f )(v) = f (J(ξ)v), all ξ ∈ SK (n, r), f ∈ V ∗ , v ∈ V .
It is clear that V → V ◦ gives an exact contravariant functor on MK (n, r), and that the usual isomorphism V → (V ∗ )∗ of K-spaces, gives a natural isomorphism V → (V ◦ )◦ . Definition. Let V , W be modules in MK (n, r). Then a K-bilinear form (, ):V ×W →K is called contravariant if it has the property. (2.7d)
(ξv, w) = (v, J(ξ)w), all ξ ∈ SK (n, r), v ∈ V , w ∈ W .
The proof of the next proposition is standard. (2.7e) Proposition. If V, W ∈ MK (n, r) are given, there is a bijective correspondence between contravariant forms ( , ) : V × W → K and morphisms Λ : V → W ◦ in MK (n, r), given by Λ(v)(w) = (v, w), all v ∈ V , w ∈ W . The form ( , ) is non-singular (=non-degenerate) if and only if Λ is an isomorphism.
2.8 AK (n, r) as KΓ-bimodule
21
Example 1. We can use the last proposition to show that the module E ⊗r is self-dual, that is that E ⊗r ∼ = (E ⊗r )◦ . For there is clearly a non-singular bilinear form , : E ⊗r × E ⊗r → K, defined by ei , ej = δij , all i, j ∈ I(n, r). But a simple calculation, using (2.6a), shows that , satisfies the contravariant condition (2.7d). Call , the canonical form on E ⊗r . Example 2. Let {VK } be a family of modules (VK ∈ MK (n, r)) which is Z-defined by VZ and {δK } as in the last section. Let {va,Q } (a running over some finite index set B) be a basis of VQ which Z-generates VZ . For each K, write va,K = δK (va,Q ⊗ 1K ) so that { va,K : a ∈ B } is a basis of VK . We can now show easily that the family {VK◦ } is defined over Z. For each K, write {fa,K } for the basis of VK∗ = VK◦ dual to {va,K }. Then VZ◦ = { f ∈ VQ : f (VZ ) ⊆ VZ } is a Z-form of VQ◦ , having Z-basis {fa,Q }. It is not hard to see that {VK◦ } is Z-defined by VZ◦ and the maps δˆK : VZ◦ ⊗K → VK◦ which take fa,Q ⊗ 1K → fa,K , all a ∈ B. Example 3. Let {VK } and {WK } be families (VK and WK both in MK (n, r)) which are Z-defined by VZ , {δK } and WZ , {ηK } respectively. If for every K we have a bilinear form ( , )K : VK × WK → K, we say that the family {( , )K } is defined over Z if ( , )Q maps VZ × WZ to Z, and for each K, and for each vZ ∈ VZ , wZ ∈ WZ there holds δK (vZ ⊗ 1K ), ηK (wZ ⊗ 1K ) = (vZ , wZ )Q · 1K . K
If all the ( , )K are contravariant, then we can show that the family of mor◦ (given, for each K, by Proposition (2.7e)) is defined phisms ΛK : VK → WK ⊗r is defined over Z. For example, the family of canonical forms , K on EK ⊗r ⊗r ◦ ) derived over Z, and so therefore is the family of isomorphisms EK → (EK from these forms.
2.8 AK (n, r) as KΓ-bimodule We saw in the introduction (p. 2) that the space K Γ of all functions f : Γ → K is a KΓ-bimodule, i.e. it is a left and right KΓ-module, and these two actions of KΓ commute. If we take an element c ∈ AK (n, r), then there holds an equation ∆(c) = t ct ⊗ ct , for suitable elements ct , ct ∈ AK (n, r) (see 2.3). By formulae (1c), (1d), (2.8a) g◦c= ct (g)ct , c ◦ g = ct (g)ct , t
t
for any g ∈ Γ. This shows that AK (n, r) is closed to both the left and the right KΓ-actions, hence AK (n, r) is itself a KΓ-bimodule. Now extend (2.8a) by linearity, to give the action of an arbitrary element κ ∈ KΓ:
22
2 Polynomial Representations of GLn (K): The Schur algebra
κ◦c=
ct (κ)ct ,
c◦κ=
t
ct (κ)ct .
t
By (2.4b), we find κ ◦ c = c ◦ κ = 0, for any κ ∈ Y = Ker e. Then (2.4c) shows that AK (n, r), regarded as left KΓ-module, belongs to MK (n, r). (n, r) of Similarly AK (n, r) belongs to an analogously defined category MK right KΓ-modules (see 4.4). Thus AK (n, r) becomes an SK (n, r)-bimodule, with actions ξ(ct )ct , c ◦ ξ = ξ(ct )ct , for ξ ∈ SK (n, r). (2.8b) ξ◦c= t
t
Now let us define a bilinear form ( , ) : SK (n, r) × AK (n, r) → K by the rule: if ξ ∈ SK (n, r), c ∈ AK (n, r), then (ξ, c) = J(ξ)(c). This is non-singular, in fact {ξi,j }, {ci,j } are dual bases with respect to ( , ) (see (2.7b)). The reader may check that for any ξ, η ∈ SK (n, r), c ∈ AK (n, r) there holds (2.8c)
(ξη, c) = (η, J(ξ) ◦ c) = (ξ, c ◦ J(η)).
In fact, using (2.3a), (2.8b) and the definition of ( , ), we see that all three expressions just given are equal to t (ξ, ct ) (η, ct ). But (2.8c) shows that ( , ) is contravariant, SK (n, r) and AK (n, r) being regarded as left SK (n, r)-modules (and even when they are regarded as right modules). By (2.7e) we deduce that AK (n, r) ∼ = (SK (n, r))◦ , an isomorphism of KΓ-bimodules.
§3
Weights and Characters
3.1
Weishts In this chapter we describe
of modules
in
MK(n,r),
in terms of the Schur algebra
results go back to Schur researches
of Weyl and Chevalley.
ideal domain,
Let
n,r ~ 1
G(r)-orbits
in
weights
(more precisely,
weight
6
of reductive
see [Se,
number of
The elements
as unordered
such that
partitions
of
any
It acts on
w E W,
w
~ = (~w(1)'''''
dominant weight,
W
i.e
into
of
denote the set of all of
A(n,r)
GLn,
i.e.
n
acts on
for each
a weight
to (ordered)
parts.
A+(n,r)
~v
is the
can also be regarded
can be identified with the Weyl group wi = (~(il),... , w(i r)
if
W-orbit of X
A
which gives the
~ f ~ ' ~
r).
parts (zero parts being allowed).
7~(n,r):
Each
will be called
of dimension
These vectors
on the left,
weights correspond Denote by
to the category
This action commutes with that of
~w(n) )"
in classical
split over a
6 = (61,... , 6 n)
~ 6,
W = G(n)
l(n,r)
i ~ I(n,r).
right, and therefore -i
e,~ ....
i p = v. r
The symmetric group GL . n
A(n,r)
they are weights
i = (i I .... ,ir)
p ~ -r-
group schemes
All our
§3].
is specified by the vector
content of any
of
For the generalization
be given~ and let
I(n,r).
SK(n,r) o
[S], and all have been generalized
of rational representations principal
the theory of weights and characters
such that
partitions
of
w ~ W, A(n,r)
~ ~ A(n,r)
on the then
contains exactly one
X1 ~ "'" ~ Xn. r
G(r)
for
Thus dominant
into not more than
the set of all dominant weights.
n
37
3.2
Weight spaces Take a fixed infinite field
weight < .
e E A(n,r)
K.
If
i E l(n,r)
we shall denote the idempotent
This is reasonable, since
<j,j
belongs to the
{.
.
(see
if and only if
2.3) by i ~ j.
The
orthogonal decomposition (2.3d) now reads
s
=
If we apply this to any module
(3.2a)
V =
a decomposition of
V
In fact space
Va
of
[[ <~ ~(A(n,r) V ~ MK(n,r)
we get
~]~> < V, aEi(n,r)
as direct sum of subspaces ([S, pp. 6,7])
V,
< V
Tn(K )
a-weight
which is defined as
all
x(t) E Tn(K)}.
is the diagonal subgroup (a maximal split torus) of
consisting of all diagonal matrices tl,... , tn E K character
~ V.
coincides with the
V a = {v E V : x(t)v = tI ,..tnnv ,
Here
•
X
= K\{0}. : Tn(K ) ~ K
To show that
(3.2b)
ex(t) =
For each ,
by
x(t) = diag(tl,... , tn) c~ E A = A(n,r),
F K = GLn(K)
with
define the multiplicative
51 an X (x(t)) = t I ...t n
~i~V = V~,
first verify the formula
~i en aEAZ tI ... tn ~
,
all
x(t) E Tn(K) ,
by evaluating both sides at each deduce
c. . (i,j E I(n,r)). If v E ~ V , we 1,3 51 ~ V s" x(t)v = ex(t)v = t I ...tnnv; hence ~ V ~ But for distinct
~,~ E A(n,r)
the multiplicative characters
k , X~
are unequal (since
38
K
is infinite),
spaces that
V
and by a familiar argument
, ~ E A(n,r),
< V = V~
is direct.
for each
it
follows
Comparing
that the sum of the
this with
(3.2a), we see
e:
(3.2c)
V =
%~ V ~. ~Efi
Remark.
It follows from (3.2b), and the fact that
image of K'Tn(K) of
SK(n,r )
which has the
commutative, Example V =
under the map
split,
For each
ArE
is any
~
(see 2.4)
(5 E A(n,r))
is infinite,
is the subalgebra as
K-basis.
that the
DK(n,r)
This is a
semisimple algebra. r
satisfying
(= Altr(E)) r-element
e
K
is a
0 ! r ~ n,
KF-module
subset of
~
in
the
r
th
~(n,r).
exterior power
If
(i I < i 2 < ... < ir)
s = {il, .... ir}
write
e s = e i A ... A e i r
Then
V
has a basis consisting
x(t) E Tn(K) = ~(s)
then
x(t)e s = til~.,
is the weight containing
r-element
subsets
s,s'
the weight spaces r-element
3.3
subset
V~
Let
V
n
and
of weight
Let
($)
elements
e s.
Moreover
~I an t.1 es = t I ... tn es' r i = (il,...,ir).
V~ = 0
1
or zero:
for all other
distinct
~(s), ~(s').
So
v~(S)
for any
= K.e
s
~ E A(n,r).
spaces ~(n,r),
w E W = G(n).
and
~
an element of
Then the
if
where
Clearly,
give distinct weights
all have dimension
be a module in
Proposition
are isomorphic.
of
s ~,
Some properties
(3.3a)
of these
K-spaces
A(n,r).
V ~, V w(~)
39
Proof
Let
el,...,
en
of
n~ 1
verify
hence that
(3.3b)
n
be the element of
w E
to
ew(1),... , ew(n)
v ~+ n v w
gives a
Let
0 ~ VI ~
V ~ -~ V ~2
0
Since
Now let to
be an exact sequence in
sequence of
is obtained
is idempotent,
K-spaces
by applying
KF-module
~(n,s)
to every term of
the result follows.
be any non-negative
MK(n,r) ,
regarded as
(3.3c)
~a
r,s
* t I ..... t n E K ,
for all
is exact.
The second sequence
the first.
It is simple to
V ~ ~ V w(~) .
0 ~ V 1 ~ V -~ V 2 ~ 0
Then the naturally induced
elementary
respectively.
K-isomorphism
MK(n,r).
belonging
which maps the basis elements
x(t I .... , tn)n w = X(tw(1),... , tw(n)) ,
Proposition
Proof
F = GL (K) n
integers and
respectively.
V, W
Clearly
in the usual way, belongs
to
be
~-modules
V ~ W = V ®KW ,
~(n,
r+s).
It is
to verify the
Proposition.
Let
where the sum is over all
y E A(n, r+s). e E A(n,r),
Then
(V ® W)~ =
8 (A(n,s)
Z~
V~ ~
such that
(~i ..... an) + (~i ..... Pn ) = (~I ..... ~n )" Next suppose with a subset of i,j E l(n,r).
L
is a field containing
SL(n,r)
Then
~K ~ =
K ~i,j
~L ,
~ E A(n,r).
into an
identify
with the subset
(3.3d) V~=
Pr@position.
$~K V.
for all
SL(n,r)-module
with
~° ,j'
V ® 1L
of
VL,
VL = ~
SK(n,r) for all
So if we make
by "extension of scalars",
The weight-space
In particular,
We identify
by identifying
VL = V ®K L V
K.
and
we have the L
dimK V~ = dim L V L .
VL
is the
L-span of
W ~,
40
Contravariant spaces.
If
duality (see 2.7) behaves well with respect to weight-
V,W E MK(n,r )
and
(,) : V × W ~ K
is a contravariant
form, then
(V~,W ~) = 0
for any distinct weights
[W, p. 42],
[J, p. 6]).
For
(~aV,~W)
= (V, ~ W )
= 0.
only if the restrictions E A(n,r).
(3.3e)
Taking
J(~)
,
(,)~ : V
× W
(see
so by the contravariant
It follows that
W = V°
Proposition.
= ~
~,~ E A(n,r)
(,)
~ K
is non-singular
are non-singular
bilinear
property if and
for all
there follows the
dimK V~ = dimK(V°)~ ,
for all
V E MK(n,r )
and
E A(n,r). Finally let as in 2.6.
{V K}
Because the idempotent$
we have a direct sum These
(3.3f)
in
and
Z-defined by
SQ(n,r)
actually lie in
~ V Z = V Z ~ VQ~ Z-module
VZ, {5 K}
VZ,
for all
Sz(n,r) ~ E A(n,r).
are themselves free
We have the
Proposition
6K : V Z ® K ~ V K
3.4
V Z = Z @ ~ Vz,Q
%aYQVz, being surmnands of the free
Z-modules.
free
be a family of modules,
Z-module
For each ~Q V Z ® 1K
of ~Q~ VZ,
K, •
VK
is the
Hence
K-span of the image under equals the rank of the
dim K V aK
and so is independent of
K.
Characters Let
V
be a
KFK-mOdule in
we assign the monomial
~i ~n X 1 ... Xn
MK(n,r).
To each weight
of degree r
in
n
~ E A(n,r)
indeterminates
XI,...,X n
over the rational field
Q.
character,
cf.
is defined to be the polynomial
[J', p• 274]) of
V
Then the character
(or formal
4]
@v(XI,...,Xn)
~i • X1
dimK v~
Z
=
an ... X n
~EA(n,r) Thus
~V
is an element
homogeneous
of degree
(3.4a)
of the polynomial r.
By (3.3a)
ring
Z[XI,.,.~Xn] ,
it is symmetric,
and is
Jn fact
Z dimK V% • mt(X 1 ..... Xn) ,
+v(XI ..... Xn) =
k the sum being over all dominant monomial
symmetric
of the distinct Xl,... , X n. character
function
monomials
V =
ArE
k E A+(n,r).
(see for example
obtained
For example,
of
weights
let
r
(see 3.2)
from
[M, p. ii]),
kI A n X1 ... X n
be in the range is the
r th
Here
~k
is the
i.e.
the sum
by permuting
0 ! r ! n,
elementar7
then the
symmetric
function
e = ~(i,i,...,I,0 ..... 0) = XIX 2 ... X r + ... --r The propositions If
0 ~ V1 ~ V + V 2 + 0
in 3.3 give rise to propositions is an exact
sequence
in
~(n,r),
about characters. then
~V
=
~V 1
+
2 ,
by (3.3b).
It follows
series for
V,
by induction
on the length
g
say
V : V ° D V1 D %/2 D .. . D Vii = 0,
that
(3.4b)
~V = o=ig %o-I/Vo From
(3.3c) we have
of a composition
42 when
V E MK(n,r),
W E ~(n,s);
this extends of course to a similar formula
for tensor products of any finite number of factors. = (~i''''' ~r ) ![i + "'" + ~ r
is any partition of
= r)
r
....> I~r ~ 0
~I
and
then the s~wmetric function
~ ( X I ..... Xn)
is the character of the module ~V
(i.e.
For example if
lies in the ring
~(n,r)
~i
.o°
e
~Ir
£ ~i E ®... ® A Zr E.
Since every character
of all symmetric functions in
Z[XI,... , Xn],
and since by the fundamental theorem on symmetric functions ([M, (2.4), p. 13]) S(n,r) is Z-spanned by the e (3.4d)
Theorem.
by all characters
above, we have the well-known
The additive subgroup of ~V' V E MK(n,r),
group is independent of the field
is
Z[XI,,.., Xn]
S(n,r).
In particular, this additive
K.
We must next connect our "formal" character character
~V
of
V = (V,p) E ~ ( n , r ) ,
~v(g) - Trace p(g),
~V
is an element of
~(n,r),
(rab)
(3.4e)
Theorem (see [S, p, 17]).
g E rK = GLn(K)
afforded by any basis
there holds
are the eigenvalues of
g.
Let
~V
with the natural
defined hy
all
in fact
matrix
which is generated
g E r
~V
[Va }
= GLn(K ).
is the trace of the invariant of
V.
V E MK(n,r ).
~T(g) = %T(
Then for any where
43
Proof
By (3.3d), the character
module L.
VL = V ® K
L (~(n,r)
@V
obtained by extending
Since this process replaces
coincides with that
K
on
FK'
~V
K.
C
be the
by a function on
by the
to a larger field I = GLn(L)
which
we may legitimately assume, in proving (3.4e),
n x n
Define elements
(I)
matrix
(c v) ,
and let
fl' .... fn ( ~ ( n , r )
u
be an indeterminate
by
det(ul-C) = u n - fl un-I + ... + (-l)nfn
It is clear that
f (g) = ~r(~ , ~ ), r 1 ~''" n %
of
~(n,r)
by
~
% (K1 . . . . . ~n )
-I
g
r,
=
as above.
Then we have, for any
having
dim V ~ diagonal terms
traces
we have
~i ~i
g ( FK
~"(g) "
Relative to a basis of
V = Z~ Vg~ diag(~l,...,~ n)
Now we may write
Define the element
is diagovalizable i.e. that there is some
= diag(~l,...,~n).
decomposition
of
I < r < n. -- -
(bg ( Z ) .
~ = Z (b .iK) f~l ...f~rr "
(2) Now suppose
for
~i ~r = Z b~ -~I "'" ~r
the sum being over the partitions
zgz
K
V
is algebraically closed. Let
over
@V
is unchanged if we replace
V
z ~ FK
such that
which is adapted to the
is represented by a diagonal matrix
an "'" ~n '
for each
~ (A(n,r).
Taking
44
2
We have now two polynomials in
n
and
~(g) = ~v(g)
~V'
and by (2) and (3,),
diagonalizable elements of are distinct belongs to satisfying polynomial
d(g) # O, (i).
Corollary.
F K = f~n(K).
D,
we have
where
~ = ~V'
~i''''' ~t
namely
for all
g
~(g) = ~v(g )
for all
~i''''' ~t
Proof
the natural characters ~i''''' ~t elements of If
~(n,r).
z .
are the characteristics of a set of VI,... , V t ~ ~ ( n , r ) . S(n,r).
(see [CR, p. 184, (27.13)] shows that FI,... , F t
are linearly independent
is a non-trivial relation
p = char K
Then by (3.4e)
g ~ FK
(It is here that we need absolute irreducibility.)
Zl~ 1 + ... + zt~ t = 0
assume, in case
of
of
and this completes the proof of (3.4e).
are linearly independent elements of
A theorem of Frobenius-Schur
D
is the discriminant of the
mutually non-isomorphic, absolutely irreducible modules Then
in the set
Since every matrix whose eigenvalues
d ~ ~(n,r(r-l))
It follows
Suppose that
variables c v ,
is finite, that
p
(z~ E Z),
we may
does not divide all the
(Zl.iK)~l(g) + ... + (zt'iK)~t(g) = 0
for all
g ~ FK-
But this contradicts the Frobenius-Schur theorem.
3.5
Irreducible modules in
~(n,r)
The next theorem, forerunner of far-reaching generalizations by Weyl [We]
and Chevalley(
=ee[S~])
, is due in the case
K = ~
to Schur
Is, p. 37]. The leading term of a polynomial in to the usual lexicographical of monomials
X1
... X
an n
Z[XI,... , Xn]
(Gaussian) ordering of weights
(see [S, p. 17]).
is taken relative a ~ A(n,r),
or
45 (3.5a)
Theorem
Let
any infinite field. (i)
For each
FX, K E ~ ( n , r )
n,r
be given integers,
whose character
These
(iii)
Every irreducible module
Proof to
(i)
k.
(k E A+(n,r))
[S, p. 37]
Let
U
X kl 1 ... X kn n .
a E K
such that
U' = {u 6 U : 0(u) = a.u} equal to the scalar map (ii) for
Z-basis of
V E ~(n,r)
~ = (~l,...,~r) V =
~(n,r). Fk, K
for
We may take
be the partition conjugate A~IE
~V U
of
• k,K(k E A+(n,r))
V
~
and since e(u) = a.u
e
to be
FX, K.
Uk
u E U k.
is a submodule of
kn ... X n .
By
To prove that
U
KFK-endomorphism
Since our assumption on
must map
for
kl
has character
whose character has
it is enough to show that every
U,
into itself, there
But the set
hence
U = U'
and
@
is
a-~. mk
If we express the functions
equations of the form
~... ® A~rE
is therefore
U
The monomial symmetric functions S(n,r).
~I Xn X 1 ... X n
is isomorphic to
is scalar (see [CR, p. 202, (29.13)].
shows that dim U k = i,
is some
form a
The leading term of
is absolutely irreducible,
~U
has leading term
there is some composition factor
leading term
of
be
~ E A+(n,r).
~V = hi~I " " ~ ~r
0
~,K
We saw in 3.4 that the module
(3.4b)
K
these exists an absolutely irreducible module
(ii)
exactly one
Let
Then
k E A+(n,r)
~,K
n ~ I, r t 0.
~X,K = ex +
Z
~
also form a basis for
(k E A+(n,r))
form a basis
@X,K
in terms of these, we get
~
and it follows at
,
S(n,r).
46 (iii) by
Suppose
Fk, K
L
L
is an algebraically closed field containing
the module
Fk, K L .
irreducible, so is ¢~ = ~k,K
as
~ , K ® K L 6 ~(n,r).
6 A+(n,r))
Fk,KL ,
Fk, K
Denote
is absolutely
Fk, K L has the same character
On the other hand
FX, K , by (3.2d).
isomorphic to one of the
Since
K.
Any irreducible
X 6 ~(n,r)
must be
since otherwise the characters
~X' ~k
would be linearly independent by (3.4e) Corollary, and that
would contradict (ii) above. Now let
V
be any irreducible module in
a minimal submodule of that
Fk,K L ~ X "
V L = V ~K L.
hence the space
HomSK(n,r)(Fk,K,. , V) # O.
Therefore
MK(n,r) , and let
There is some
k 6 A+(n,r),
IIomsL(n,r)(Fk,KL , VL) # 0,
X
be
then, such it follows
V ~ F>~,K, and the proof of Theorem
(3.5a) is complete.
Remarks. (i)
The proof above shows that
isomorphism in
~(n,r),
FX, K
by the properties
is defined, uniquely up to
(a)
Fk, K ~ ~(n,r)
is
irreducible, and (b) FX, K has character CX,K whose leading term is kI kn X 1 ... X Moreover if L is any field containing K, then n
Fk,K ® K L 6 ~(n,r)
has the corresponding properties
fact its character is the same as that of ~k,K = ~k,L ~k,K Write
if
K, L
for
~k,K'
{~h,p : k6 A+(n,r)} dk~
are infinite fields with
is the same, for all infinite fields ~k,p
Fk, K.
is a
if
p = char. K. Z-basis of
which appear in the equations
K
In other words, K _c L.
It follows that
of given characteristic.
For each
~(n,r).
(a), (b), since in
If
p,
the set
p > 0,
the coefficients
47
=
Z ~EA+(n,r)
@k,O
k E A+(n,r),
dk~'k, p,
are the decomposition numbers relative to the modular reduction from to
~(n,r),
(ii)
where
K
is any field of characteristic
Suppose that
K
is fixed.
ring for the category corresponding
~(n),
to a module
was said in 3.3, that R(~(n))
R(MK(n ))
and let
[V]
V E ~(n).
[V] -~ ~V
onto the ring
Let
p
MQ(n,r)
(see 2.5).
be the Grothendiock
be the element of
R(MK(n))
Then it as clear from (3.4a) and what
defines an isomorphism of rings from
S(n) =
% _S_(n,r) of all symmetric functions in r>0
Z[X I,..., X n]. (iii)
The symmetric functions
~k,0
were determined by Schur [S,
and are now known as Schur functions or finite characteristic
p,
S-functions
for
and write
X1
... X ~n n ; s(w)
~k
,P
For
have not yet
We sketch here a proof, rather different from
Sehur's, of his theorem for characteristic X~
(see [M, p.24]).
the irreducible characters
been calculated explicitly.
23],
recall that
for the "sign"
(+i)
zero.
W = G(n)
If
e E A(n,r)
acts on
A(n,r)
of a permutation
w E W.
we write (see 3.1), Define
a = ~ ( X l , .... Xn) = Z s(w) X w(~), an alternating function in =~ wEW which in fact is expressible as the n × n determinant Xl,..., 1 Let 6 = (n-l, n-2,...,l,O) E A(n, ~ n(n-1)). Define the S-function iX
= [k(Xl ..... Xn)
for any
(see [M, (3.2). (4.3)]) (in fact
the
k E A+(n,r)
~k (k E A+(n,r))
has leading term X%), n
~l = a~+6/-9~ " form a
-
Then
Z-basis of
S(n,r)
and there holds the formal identity
1
l _ X vV ~ ~,v=l
by
~. "'IXi]I.
Z + kEA (n)
S_.(X)S=x(Y),
48
where and
Y = (YI""' A+(n) =
Yn )
is a set of variables independent of
X = (XI,..., Xn),
~ A+(n,r). r~0
Schur's theorem [S, §23]
is that
¢'k,0 = ~
'
for all
k 6 A+(n,r).
To prove this, it is enough to show that (I) remains true when replaced by
#~0's.
given degree
r
(2)
For then, considering only the part of (I) which is of
in (both)
%
X
and
Y,
S%(X)Sx(Y) =
k~A+(n,r) = If we write
~% =
Z vk~ ~
we shall have
Z +
=
~k o(X)@x,O (Y)"
k(A (n,r) (k 6 A+(n,r))
be a signed permutation matrix, i.e.
the
to order and sign (cf. [M, p. 35]). X k,
we must have
So we must prove (I), with
'
we get an integral matrix
which, on account of (2), must be orthogonal.
leading term
S=>'s are
This matrix must therefore
S=k's coincide with
But since both
S) = ....
~)
k,O
Sk's
g=X
for all
replaced by
and
~k,0's ~'k
coincide on the two sides of the proposed equation.
Z (r)
I] X ~v y ~v ~,v=l
=
~+
X~A (n,r)
r Let
module
have
~k,0's.
It is clearly r ~ O,
So we must prove
~X,o(X)~x,O(7),
where the sum on the left is over all non-negative that
up
X 6 A+(n,r)
sufficient to prove that the sums of terms, of each given degree
(3)
(v~v)
integrsl
matrices such
= r. K
@r EK
irreducible faithfully on
be an infinite field of characteristic is completely reducible Fk, K (k E A+(n,r)) E 6Y,
zero.
Because the
(2.6e), and contains each (absolutely)
with positive multiplicity
see (2.6c)) we have
(SK(n,r)
acts
49
•~i(n,r) =
Now
~(n,r)
is a
~(n,r).
y = diag(y I ..... yn )
cf(~l,K ) .
K~-bii'~odule, using right and left translation
operators g o c,c o g (see sub-bimodule of
~ ~ + h~A (n,r)
~ i. Each coefficient space Take diagonal matrices
(~ ,yy E K ),
ef(F~.,K)
is a
x = diag(xl,...,Xn),
and calculate the trace
f(x,y)
of
the linear transformation
(c ~ y o c o x : c E ~ ( n , r ) ) .
Using the basis of monomials is obtained by substituting
ci, j x
for
for X,
But from (4) we get another basis of A+(n,r)
(r~b)
for
the coefficient functions
F~, K,
relative
~(n,r), y
~(n,r), rab
to some b a s i s of
theorem (see 3.4) shows t h a t t h e s e f u n c t i o n s If we choose a basis for Fk, K
for
we find that Y
f(x,y)
in the left side of (3).
by taking for each
appearing in an invari~nt matrix
F~, K. (The F r o b e n i u s - S c h u r k rab are l i n e a r l y i n d e p e n d e n t . )
which is adapted to the weight-space
decomposition, so that each basis element belongs to some weight-space it is easy to show that the trace of the map is
~(x)~k(y);
hence by (4),
of the variables
(c -~ y o c o x : c E c f ( ~ , K ) )
f(x,y) = Z~ ~ ( x ) ~ ( y ) .
since it holds for arbitrary substitutions XI''''' Xn' YI''''' Yn"
F~, K,
But this proves (3), * Xl''''' Xn' Y I ' ' ' " Yn ~ K
3 Weights and Characters
3.1 Weights In this chapter we describe the theory of weights and characters of modules in MK (n, r), in terms of the Schur algebra SK (n, r). All our results go back to Schur [47], and all have been generalized in classical researches of Weyl and Chevalley. For the generalization to the category of rational representations of reductive group schemes split over a principal ideal domain, see [49, §3]. Let n, r ≥ 1 be given, and let Λ(n, r) denote the set of all G(r)-orbits in I(n, r). The elements α, β, . . . of Λ(n, r) will be called weights (more precisely, they are weights of GLn , of dimension r). A weight α is specified by the vector α = (α1 , . . . , αn ) which gives the content of any i = (i1 , . . . , ir ) ∈ α, i.e. for each ν ∈ n, αν is the number of ∈ r such that i = ν. These vectors α can also be regarded as unordered partitions of r into n parts (zero parts being allowed). The symmetric group W = G(n) can be identified with the Weyl group of GLn . It acts on I(n, r) on the left, wi = (w(i1 ), . . . , w(ir )) for any w ∈ W and i ∈ I(n, r). This action commutes with the action of G(r) on the right, and therefore W acts on Λ(n, r): w−1 α = (αw(1) , . . . , αw(n) ) for α ∈ Λ(n, r) and w ∈ W . Each W -orbit of Λ(n, r) contains exactly one dominant weight, i.e. a weight λ such that λ1 ≥ · · · ≥ λn . Thus dominant weights correspond to (ordered) partitions of r into not more than n parts. Denote by Λ+ (n, r) the set of all dominant weights.
3.2 Weight spaces Fix an infinite field K. If i ∈ I(n, r) belongs to the weight α ∈ Λ(n, r) we shall denote the idempotent ξi,i (see 2.3) by ξα . This is reasonable, since ξi,i = ξj,j if and only if i ∼ j. The orthogonal decomposition (2.3d) now reads ε= ξα . α∈Λ(n,r)
24
3 Weights and Characters
If we apply this to any module V ∈ MK (n, r) we get (3.2a) V = ξα V , α∈Λ(n,r)
a decomposition of V as a direct sum of subspaces ξα V . In fact [47, pp. 6,7], ξα V coincides with the α-weight-space V α of V , which is defined as αn 1 V α = { v ∈ V : x(t)v = tα 1 · · · tn v, all x(t) ∈ Tn (K) }.
Here Tn (K) is the diagonal subgroup (a maximal split torus) of ΓK = GLn (K) consisting of all diagonal matrices x(t) = diag(t1 , . . . , tn ) with t1 , . . . , tn in K ∗ = K\{0}. For each α ∈ Λ = Λ(n, r), define the multiplicative charαn 1 acter χα : Tn (K) → K ∗ by χα (x(t)) = tα 1 · · · tn . α To show that ξα V = V , first verify the formula αn 1 tα (3.2b) ex(t) = 1 · · · tn ξα , all x(t) ∈ Tn (K), α∈Λ
by evaluating both sides at each ci,j (i, j ∈ I(n, r)). If v ∈ ξα V , we deαn α 1 duce x(t)v = ex(t) v = tα 1 · · · tn v; hence ξα V ⊆ V . But for distinct elements α, β ∈ Λ(n, r) the multiplicative characters χα , χβ are unequal (since K is infinite), and by a familiar argument it follows that the sum of the weight-spaces V α , α ∈ Λ(n, r), is direct. Comparing this with (3.2a), we see that ξα V = V α for each α: V α. (3.2c) V = α∈Λ
Remark. It follows from (3.2b), and the fact that K is infinite, that the image of K · Tn (K) under the map e (see 2.4) is the subalgebra DK (n, r) of SK (n, r) which has the ξα (α ∈ Λ(n, r)) as K-basis. This is a commutative, split, semisimple algebra. Example. For each r satisfying 0 ≤ r ≤ n, the rth exterior power V = Λr E (= Altr (E)) is a KΓ-module in MK (n, r). If s = {i1 , . . . , ir } is any r-element subset of n (i1 < i2 < · · · < ir ) write es = ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eir . These nr elements es form a K-basis of V . Moreover if x(t) ∈ Tn (K) and α = α(s) is αn 1 the weight containing (i1 , . . . , ir ), then x(t)es = ti1 · · · tir es = tα 1 · · · tn es . Clearly, distinct r-element subsets s, s of n give distinct weights α(s), α(s ). So the weight-spaces V α all have dimension 1 or zero: V α(s) = K · es for any r-element subset s ⊆ n, and V α = 0 for all other α ∈ Λ(n, r).
3.3 Some properties of weight spaces Let V be a module in MK (n, r), and α an element of Λ(n, r).
3.3 Some properties of weight spaces
25
(3.3a) Proposition. Let w ∈ W = G(n). Then the K-spaces V α , V w(α) are isomorphic. Proof. Let nw be the element of Γ = GLn (K) which maps the basis elements e1 , . . . , en of E to ew(1) , . . . , ew(n) respectively. It is simple to verify n−1 w x(t1 , . . . , tn )nw = x(tw(1) , . . . , tw(n) ), for all t1 , . . . , tn ∈ K ∗ , hence that v → nw v gives a K-isomorphism from V α onto V w(α) . (3.3b) Proposition. Let 0 → V1 → V → V2 → 0 be an exact sequence in MK (n, r). Then the naturally induced sequence of K-spaces 0 → V1α → V α → V2α → 0 is exact. Proof. The second sequence is obtained by applying ξα to every term of the first. Since ξα is idempotent, the result follows. Now let r, s be any non-negative integers and V , W be KΓ-modules belonging to MK (n, r), MK (n, s) respectively. Clearly V ⊗ W = V ⊗K W , regarded as KΓ-module in the usual way, belongs to MK (n, r + s). It is elementary to verify the (3.3c) Proposition. Let γ ∈ Λ(n, r + s). Then V α ⊗ W β, (V ⊗ W )γ = α,β
where the sum is over all α ∈ Λ(n, r), β ∈ Λ(n, s) such that α + β = γ. Next suppose L is a field containing K. We identify SK (n, r) with a subset K L with ξi,j , for all i, j ∈ I(n, r). Then ξαK = ξαL , of SL (n, r) by identifying ξi,j for all α ∈ Λ(n, r). So if we make VL = V ⊗K L into an SL (n, r)-module by “extension of scalars”, and identify V with the subset V ⊗ 1L of VL , we have the α
(3.3d) Proposition. The weight-space VL = ξαL VL is the L-span of the α α α weight space V = ξαK V . In particular, dimK V = dimL VL . Contravariant duality (see 2.7) behaves well with respect to weight-spaces. If V, W ∈ MK (n, r) and ( , ) : V × W → K is a contravariant form, then (V α , W β ) = 0 for any distinct weights α, β ∈ Λ(n, r) (see [56, p. 42], or [29, p. 6]). For we have J(ξα ) = ξα , so by the contravariant property (ξα v, ξβ w) = (v, ξα ξβ w) = 0. It follows that ( , ) is non-singular if and only if the restrictions ( , )α : V α × W α → K are non-singular for all α ∈ Λ(n, r). Taking W = V ◦ , there follows the
26
3 Weights and Characters
(3.3e) Proposition. dimK V α = dimK (V ◦ )α , for all α ∈ Λ(n, r). Finally let {VK } be a family of modules, Z-defined by VZ , {δK } as in 2.6. Because the idempotents ξαQ in SQ (n, r) actually lie in SZ (n, r), we have a di α rect sum VZ = α ξαQ VZ , and ξαQ VZ = VZ ∩VQ , for all α ∈ Λ(n, r). These ξαQ VZ , being summands of the free Z-module VZ , are themselves free Z-modules. We have the α
(3.3f ) Proposition. For each K, VK is the K-span of the image under the α map δK : VZ ⊗ K → VK of ξαQ VZ ⊗ 1K . Hence dimK VK equals the rank of the free Z-module ξαQ VZ , and so is independent of K.
3.4 Characters Let V be a KΓK -module in MK (n, r). To each weight α ∈ Λ(n, r) we assign the monomial X1α1 · · · Xnαn of degree r in n indeterminates X1 , . . . , Xn over the rational field Q. Then the character (or formal character, cf. [32, p. 274]) of V is defined to be the polynomial (dimK V α ) · X1α1 · · · Xnαn . ΦV (X1 , . . . , Xn ) = α∈Λ(n,r)
Thus ΦV is an element of the polynomial ring Z[X1 , . . . , Xn ], and is homogeneous of degree r. By (3.3a) it is symmetric, in fact (3.4a) ΦV (X1 , . . . , Xn ) = (dimK V λ ) · mλ (X1 , . . . , Xn ), λ
the sum being over all dominant weights λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r). Here mλ is the monomial symmetric function (see for example [39, p. 11]), i.e. the sum of the distinct monomials obtained from X1λ1 · · · Xnλn by permuting X1 , . . . , Xn . For example, let r be in the range 0 ≤ r ≤ n, then the character of the exterior power V = Λr E (see 3.2) is the rth elementary symmetric function er = m(1,1,...,1,0,...,0) = X1 X2 · · · Xr + · · · . The propositions in section 3.3 give rise to propositions about characters. Suppose 0 → V1 → V → V2 → 0 is an exact sequence in MK (n, r), then ΦV = ΦV1 + ΦV2 , by (3.3b). It follows by induction on the length l of a composition series of V , say V = V0 ⊃ V1 ⊃ V2 ⊃ · · · ⊃ Vl = 0, that (3.4b)
ΦV =
l σ=1
From (3.3c) we have
ΦVσ−1 /Vσ .
3.4 Characters
(3.4c)
27
ΦV ⊗W = ΦV ΦW
when V ∈ MK (n, r), W ∈ MK (n, s); this extends of course to a similar formula for tensor products of any finite number of factors. For example if µ = (µ1 , . . . , µr ) is any partition of r (i.e. µ1 ≥ · · · ≥ µr ≥ 0 and µ1 + · · · + µr = r) then the symmetric function eµ (X1 , . . . , Xn ) = eµ1 · · · eµr is the character of the module Λµ1 E⊗· · ·⊗Λµr E. Since every character ΦV lies in the ring Sym(n, r) of all symmetric functions in Z[X1 , . . . , Xn ], and since by the fundamental theorem on symmetric functions ([39, (2.4), p. 13]) Sym(n, r) is Z-spanned by the eµ above, we have the well-known (3.4d) Theorem. The additive subgroup of Z[X1 , . . . , Xn ] which is generated by all characters ΦV , V ∈ MK (n, r), is Sym(n, r). In particular, this additive group is independent of the field K. We must next connect our “formal” character ΦV with the natural character ϕV of V = (V, ) ∈ MK (n, r), defined by ϕV (g) = Trace (g), all g ∈ Γ = GLn (K). The map ϕV is an element of AK (n, r), in fact ϕV is the trace of the invariant matrix (rab ) afforded by any basis {va } of V . (3.4e) Theorem (see [47, p. 17]). Let V ∈ MK (n, r) and g ∈ GLn (K), then ϕV (g) = ΦV (ζ1 , . . . , ζn ), where ζ1 , . . . , ζn are the eigenvalues of g. Proof. By (3.3d), the character ΦV is unchanged if we replace V by the module VL = V ⊗K L ∈ ML (n, r) obtained by extending K to a larger field L. Since this process replaces ϕV by a function on ΓL = GLn (L) which coincides with ϕV on ΓK = GLn (K), we may legitimately assume, in proving (3.4e), that K is algebraically closed. Let C be the n × n matrix (cµν ), and let u be an indeterminate over K. Define elements f1 , . . . , fn ∈ AK (n, r) by (1) det (uI − C) = un − f1 un−1 + · · · + (−1)n fn . It is clear that fr (g) = er (ζ1 , . . . , ζn ), for 1 ≤ r ≤ n. Now we may write bµ eµ1 1 · · · eµr r (bµ ∈ Z), ΦV = µ
the sum being over the partitions µ of r, as above. Define the element ψ of AK (n, r) by ψ = µ (bµ · 1K )f1µ1 · · · frµr . Then we have, for any g ∈ ΓK (2) ΦV (ζ1 , . . . , ζn ) = ψ(g).
28
3 Weights and Characters
Now suppose g is diagonalizable, i.e. that there is some z ∈ ΓK such that zgz −1 = diag(ζ1 , . . . , ζn ). Relative to a basis of V which is adapted to the decomposition V = V α , diag(ζ1 , . . . , ζn ) is represented by a diagonal matrix having dim V α diagonal terms ζ1α1 · · · ζnαn , for each α ∈ V (n, r). Taking traces we have (3) ϕV (g) = ϕV (zgz −1 ) = ΦV (ζ1 , . . . , ζn ). We have now two polynomials in n2 variables cµν , namely ψ and ϕV , and by (2) and (3), ψ(g) = ϕV (g) for all g in the set D of diagonalizable elements of ΓK = GLn (K). Since every matrix whose eigenvalues are distinct belongs to D, we have ψ(g) = ϕV (g) for all g ∈ ΓK satisfying d(g) = 0, where d ∈ AK (n, r) is the discriminant of the polynomial (1). It follows that ψ = ϕV , and this completes the proof of (3.4e). Corollary. Suppose that Φ1 , . . . , Φt are the characteristics of a set of mutually non-isomorphic, absolutely irreducible modules V1 , . . . , Vt ∈ MK (n, r). Then Φ1 , . . . , Φt are linearly independent elements of Sym(n, r). Proof. A theorem of Frobenius-Schur (see [11, p. 184,(27.13)]) shows that the natural characters ϕ1 , . . . , ϕt of V1 , . . . , Vt are linearly independent elements of AK (n, r). (It is here that we need absolute irreducibility.) If there is a non-trivial relation z1 Φ1 + · · · + zt Φt = 0 (zτ ∈ Z), we may assume, in case p = char K is finite, that p does not divide all the zτ . Then by (3.4e) (z1 · 1K )ϕ1 (g) + · · · + (zt · 1K )ϕt (g) = 0 for all g ∈ ΓK . But this contradicts the Frobenius-Schur theorem.
3.5 Irreducible modules in MK (n, r) The next theorem, forerunner of far-reaching generalizations by Weyl [54] and Chevalley [49], is due in the case K = C to Schur [47, p. 37]. The leading term of a polynomial in Z[X1 , . . . , Xn ] is taken relative to the usual lexicographical (Gaussian) ordering of weights α ∈ Λ(n, r), or of monomials X1α1 · · · Xnαn (see [47, p. 17]). (3.5a) Theorem. Let n, r be given integers, n ≥ 1, r ≥ 0. Let K be an infinite field. Then (i) For each λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r) there exists an absolutely irreducible module Fλ,K in MK (n, r) whose character Φλ,K has leading term X1λ1 · · · Xnλn . (ii) These Φλ,K (λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r)) form a Z-basis of Sym(n, r). (iii) Every irreducible module V ∈ MK (n, r) is isomorphic to Fλ,K for exactly one λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r).
3.5 Irreducible modules in MK (n, r)
29
Proof. (i) (see [47, p. 37]) Let µ = (µ1 , . . . , µr ) be the partition conjugate to λ. We saw in 3.4 that the module V = Λµ1 E ⊗ · · · ⊗ Λµr E has character ΦV = eµ1 1 · · · eµr r . The leading term of ΦV is therefore X1λ1 · · · Xnλn . By (3.4b) there is some composition factor U of V whose character has leading term X1λ1 · · · Xnλn . We may take U to be Fλ,K . To prove that U is absolutely irreducible, it is enough to show that every KΓK -endomorphism θ of U is scalar (see [11, p. 202, (29.13)]). Since our assumption on ΦU shows that dim U λ = 1, and since θ must map U λ into itself, there is some a ∈ K such that θU (u) = a · u for u ∈ U λ . But the set U = { u ∈ U : θ(u) = a · u } is a submodule of U , hence U = U and θ is equal to scalar map a · 1U . (ii) The monomial symmetric functions mλ (λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r)) form a basis of Sym(n, r). If we express the functions Φλ,K in terms of these, we get equations of the form Φλ,K = mλ + µ<λ zλµ mµ , and it follows that the characters Φλ,K (λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r)) also form a basis for Sym(n, r). (iii) Suppose L is an algebraically closed field containing K. Denote L the module Fλ,K ⊗K L ∈ ML (n, r). Since Fλ,K is absolutely irreby Fλ,K L L . On the other hand Fλ,K has the same character Φλ = Φλ,K ducible, so is Fλ,K as Fλ,K , by (3.3d). Any irreducible X ∈ ML (n, r) must be isomorphic to one L , since otherwise the characters ΦX , Φλ (λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r)) would be of the Fλ,K linearly independent by Corollary (3.4e), and that would contradict (ii) above. Now let V be any irreducible module in MK (n, r), and let X be a minimal submodule of VL = V ⊗K L. There is some λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r), then, L L ∼ , VL ) = 0, it folsuch that Fλ,K = X; hence the space HomSL (n,r) (Fλ,K ∼ lows HomSK (n,r) (Fλ,K , V ) = 0. Therefore V = Fλ,K , and the proof of Theorem (3.5a) is complete. Remarks. (i)
The proof above shows that Fλ,K is defined, uniquely up to isomorphism in MK (n, r), by the properties (a) Fλ,K ∈ MK (n, r) is irreducible, and (b) Fλ,K has character Φλ,K whose leading term is X1λ1 · · · Xnλn . Moreover if L is any field containing K, then Fλ,K ⊗K L ∈ ML (n, r) has the corresponding properties (a), (b), since in fact its character is the same as that of Fλ,K . In other words, Φλ,K = Φλ,L if K, L are infinite fields with K ⊆ L. It follows that Φλ,K is the same, for all infinite fields K of given characteristic. Write Φλ,p for Φλ,K , if p = char K. For each p, the set { Φλ,p : λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r) } is a Z-basis of Sym(n, r). If p > 0, the coefficients dλµ which appear in the equations dλµ Φµ,p , λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r) Φλ,0 = µ∈Λ+ (n,r)
are by definition the decomposition numbers relative to the modular reduction from MQ (n, r) to MK (n, r), where K is any field of characteristic p (see 2.5).
30
3 Weights and Characters
(ii) Suppose that K is fixed. Let R(MK (n)) be the Grothendieck ring for the category MK (n), and let [V ] be the element of R(MK (n)) corresponding to a module V ∈ MK (n). Then it is clear from (3.4a) and an isomorphism of rings what was said in 3.3, that [V ] → ΦV defines from R(MK (n)) onto the ring Sym(n) = r≥0 Sym(n, r) of all symmetric functions in Z[X1 , . . . , Xn ]. (iii) The symmetric functions Φλ,0 were determined by Schur [47, p. 23], and are now known as Schur functions or S-functions (see [39, p. 24]). For finite characteristic p, the irreducible characters Φλ,p have not yet been calculated explicitly. We sketch here a proof, rather different from Schur’s, of his theorem for characteristic zero. If α ∈ Λ(n, r) we write X α for X1α1 · · · Xnαn ; recall that W = G(n) acts on Λ(n, r) (see 3.1), and write s(w) for the “sign” (∈ {−1, 1}) of a permutation w ∈ W . Define aα = aα (X1 , . . . , Xn ) = w∈W s(w)X w(α) , an alternating function in X1 , . . . , Xn , which in fact is expressible as the n × n determiα nant |Xi j |. Let δ = (n − 1, n − 2, . . . , 1, 0) ∈ Λ(n, 12 n(n − 1)). Define the S-function Sλ = Sλ (X1 , . . . , Xn ) for any λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r) by Sλ = aλ+δ /aδ . Then (see [39, (3.2), (4.3)]) the Sλ form a Z-basis of Sym(n, r) (in fact Sλ has leading term X λ ), and there holds the formal identity (1)
n
1 = 1 − X µ Yν µ,ν=1
Sλ (X) Sµ (Y ),
λ∈Λ+ (n)
where Y = (Y1 , . . . , Yn ) is a second set of variables, independent of the set X = (X1 , . . . , Xn ), and Λ+ (n) = r≥0 Λ+ (n, r). Schur’s theorem [47, p. 23] is that Φλ,0 = Sλ , for all λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r). To prove this, it is enough to show that (1) remains true when Sλ ’s are replaced by Φλ,0 ’s. For then, considering only the part of (1) which is of given degree r in (both) X and Y , we shall have Sλ (X)Sλ (Y ) = Φλ,0 (X)Φλ,0 (Y ). (2) λ∈Λ+ (n,r)
λ∈Λ+ (n,r)
vλµ Φµ (λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r)) we get an integral matrix (vµν ) If we write Sλ = which, on account of (2), must be orthogonal. This matrix must therefore be a signed permutation matrix, i.e. the Sλ ’s coincide with Φλ,0 ’s up to order and sign (cf. [39, p. 35]). But since both Sλ and Φλ,0 have leading term X λ , we must have Sλ = Φλ,0 for all λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r). So we must prove (1), with Sλ ’s replaced by Φλ,0 ’s. It is clearly sufficient to prove that the sums of terms, of each given degree r ≥ 0, coincide on the two sides of the proposed equation. So we must prove (3)
n
(r)
µ,ν=1
r
r
Xµµν Yν µν
=
λ∈Λ+ (n)
Φλ,0 (X) Φλ,0 (Y ),
3.5 Irreducible modules in MK (n, r)
31
wherethe sum on the left is over all non-negative integral matrices such that µ,ν rµν = r. Let K be an infinite field of characteristic zero. Because the module E ⊗r is completely reducible (2.6e), and contains each (absolutely) irreducible Fλ,K (λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r)) with positive multiplicity (SK (n, r) acts faithfully on E ⊗r , see (2.6c)) we have cf(Fλ,K ). (4) AK (n, r) = λ∈Λ+ (n,r)
Now AK (n, r) is a KΓ-bimodule, using right and left translation operators g ◦ c, c ◦ g (see 2.8). Each coefficient space cf(Fλ,K ) is a subbimodule of AK (n, r). Take diagonal matrices x = diag(x1 , . . . , xn ) and y = diag(y1 , . . . , yn ) (xµ , yν ∈ K ∗ ), then calculate the trace f (x, y) of the linear transformation c → y ◦ c ◦ x (c ∈ AK (n, r)). Using the basis of monomials ci,j for AK (n, r), we find that f (x, y) is obtained by substituting x for X, y for Y in the left side of (3). But from (4) we get another basis of AK (n, r), by taking for each λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r) λ λ the coefficient function rab appearing in an invariant matrix (rab ) for Fλ,K , relative to some basis of Fλ,K . (The Frobenius-Schur theorem (see 3.4) λ are linearly independent.) If we choose a shows that these functions rab basis for Fλ,K which is adapted to the weight-space decomposition, so α , it is easy to that each basis element belongs to some weight-space Fλ,K show that the trace of the map c → y◦c◦x (c ∈ cf(Fλ,K )) is Φλ (X)Φλ (Y ); hence by (4), f (x, y) = λ Φλ (X)Φλ (Y ). But this proves (3), since it holds for arbitrary substitutions x1 , . . . , xn , y1 , . . . , yn ∈ K ∗ of the variables X1 , . . . , Xn , Y1 , . . . , Yn .
§4.
The modules
4.1
Preamble
Dk.~K In this section and the next we shall define, for each
k = (kl,... , kn) Dk, K
and
in
Vk, K
A+(n,r)
(see Introduction).
We shall define in
~(n,r)
case
(see 4.4).
K = ~,
and for each infinite field
~,K
Both have character
K,
the modules
~k,0 = S~\(XI''"'Xn)"
in terms of certain determinantal functions
These modules have been known, in the "classical"
for a very long time -- they were discovered (under the guise
of "primary convariants") by J. Deruyts in 1892 [D, p. 71] (1) .
More recently
they have been described, for fields of arbitrary characteristic, by M. Clausen [CI, p , i 8 0 ] , and by G. D. James [Ja, p. 129]. refers to the module
DX, K
in fact James
as a "Weyl module", but we prefer to reserve this term for
Vh, K
which was defined by Carter-Lusztig
as we show in 5.2, is the contravariant dual of However James's construction in [Ja ] ours, since it can be used to identify
Dh, K
[CL, p. 211], and which,
DX, K. gives more information than
with the "induced module" of
a one-dimensional character on the lower triangular Borel subgroup
Bn(K) 4.2.
of
F K = GLn(K).
k-tableaux
We mention this identification
For the rest of
The diagram (or "shape") of
§4, k
[k] = {(s,t) : 1 e s,
in 4.8.
k = (k I ..... kn) ~ A+(n,r)
is fixed.
is defined to be the subset i ~ t ! k } S
of
Z x Z
(cf. [DKR, p. 66]).
bijective, of
(I)
[k]
into a set.
A
k-tableau is a map, not necessarily Since
[k]
has
r
elements, there exists
I am indebted to J. Towber for this reference. In his article IT], Towber
gives an account of the history of Dh,K; see particularly IT, po 448].
51
at least one bijection
T : IX] ~ r.
We shall arbitrarily
biJection,
and call it the basic k -tabLeau ~
of
is
(s,t)
(4.2a)
x(s,t),
we may depict
. . . . . .
x(2,1)
x(2,2)
...
x(3,1)
x(3,2)
...
x(l,k I)
x(2,k2)
°i,
p 6 r
appears
we say that
p
R(T)
is the subgroup
preserve
T
as
x(l,2)
Thus every element
T
If the image under
x(l,l)
• .,
of
T
T = Tk .
choose one such
is in row
s
once in (4.2a).
and in column of
the rows of (4.2a),
exactly
G = G(~)
t of
T.
p = x(s,t),
The row stabilizer
consisting
and the column
If
of all
stabilizer
n E G
C(T)
which
is defined
similarly. If k-tableau
i = (il,... , Jr)
is an element
iT : [k] ~ ~
T i.
= x(s,t), (s,t)
we often
place,
of
by
refer
to
of
In general, i
I(n,r), Ti
as the entry
P
we denote
the
is not bijective. in place
P ,
If
or in the
T.. I
Example basic
Suppose k-tableau
i i 3 i5)
r = 5, T = I1 \2
Ti =
i2
4.3°
Bideterminants
of l(n,r). formula
i4
n = 3 3 4
51 /
The entries
We define
Let
and
K
k = (3,2,0).
Then,
of
T.l
for any
belong
be an infinite
an element
(T i : Tj)=
We might
take for our
i 6 I(3,5),
to the set: _3 = {1,2,3}.
field,
and let
(T i : Tj) K
of
i,J
be elements
AK(n,r)
by the
52
(4.3a)
(T i : Tj) =
Here
s(o)
ci,jo
=
c
~ s(o)ci,jo = o~C(T)
is the sign of -i
io
"
o.
for any
Z o~C(T) s(°)ci°'J
The second equality comes from the fact that
~ ~ G(r).
,j
Apart from the interchange of rows and columns, bideterminant
in the sense of Desarmenien,
= (~I''''' ~r )
be the partition of
might not be an element of Then it is easy to see that t
of
[k],
of the
Gt x ~t
x(s,t),
(If
~t = O,
we take this determinant
to be
s(o)(T i : Tj),
Let
for all
(T i : Tj)
22
'
Ti =
Cla
Clb
Cl d
Clelclf|
C2a
e2b
C2d
C2e I
be
n
parts.)
Ti,
= 1,...,~ t
i.)
From this, or directly
is zero if there are equal entries at or of
Tj.
Also
(T i : Tjo) = (Tio : Tj) =
a E C(T).
k = (3,2,0),
T~ =
(notice that
determinants
s,s'
any two places in a column of
k
Let
is the product, over all columns
x(s',t)
from (4.3a), we see that
Example I.
conjugate to
since it might have more than
(T i : Tj)
is a
Kung and Rota [DKR, p. 67].
~
A+(n,r),
(T i : Tj)
T
be as in the example in 4.2. .
Then
(Tg : Ti)
is equal to
Let
53 ,Example 2.
Let
(4.3h)
be the element of
Tg
i
1
2
2
3
3
whose
l(n,r)
•. ,2 , .
k-tableau is
I1 • J
In other words,
gx(s,t) = s,
for all
(s,t) ~ [hi. Then
(Tg : T~) = C(~l)C(~ 2) ... where, for any integer of the
4.4.
n × n
matrix
Definition of The space
m(0 ~ m ~ n),
denotes the
DX, K
AK(n,r )
h,j ~ I(n,r) = I
is a blmodule for
KF,
Z ~(ci,j)Ch, i i~l
(4.4a')
Ch, j o ~ =
Z ~(Ch,i)ci, j, iEI
~(n,r), ~(n,r)
As left module
acting SK(n,r).
~(n,r)
and
belongs to the category
and as right module it belongs to the analogously defined category of all right, finite-dimensional
coefficient space lies in ~(n,r),
F = FK
we have (see
~ o Oh, j =
~ ~ SK(n,r ).
with
Equivalently, it is a bimodule for
(4.4a)
for all
mth leading minor
C = (c v).
by right and left translations. If
c(m)
~(n,r).
KF
(or
SK(n,r))-mo~ules whose
In fact the coefficient space of
whether regarded as left or right
KF-module, is precisely
AK(n,r).
54
Now let that
~
~
be the element of
belongs to the weight
Definition
Dk, K
is the
l(n,r)
defined in (4.3b).
It is clear
k = (kl,... , in).
K-span of the bideterminants
(Tz : T!),
for all
i E l(n,r).
Dk, K
is therefore a subspace of
(4.4a), multiply by
L ~.~.
s(o),
~ o(Tg,j) =
It follows that
Dk, K
~(n,r).
and sum over all
a
% ~(ci,j)(T g : Ti) , i61 is a left
Replace in
all
SK(n,r)-submodule
h
C(T).
by
Zo
in
We get
< E SK(n,r ).
of
AK(n,r).
If we
compare (4.4b) with (2.6a), we see also that the surJective linear map = ~K : EK ®r + Dk,K' an
SK(n,r)-module
Remark basic
k-tableau
i 6 l(n,r),
T
and of
(see 4.2).
T' = ~T
and if
g
for some
Z, = Z -i
In case
~ 6 G(r).
we have
k = (r,0,...,O)
T i = (i I .... , Jr)
map this to the monomial Dr, K
j E l(n,r),
is
is isomorphic to the
and
ell "'" eir rth
depends our choice of
However any other bijective
diagram is a single row of length
i E I(n,r),
for all
(Tg : T i)
Then
T i' = TiT
k-tableau
(% of
and
Therefore
T.
we shall ~ i t e r,
T'
for any
(Ti, : Ti) = (Tz : T i ).
is in fact independent of the choice of
Example i. k
e3 -" (T~:j)
homomorphlsm.
Our definition of
can be written
Dk, K
which takes
Dr, K
for
Tg = (I,I,...,i).
: T i) = Cl,il ... Cl,ir,
DX,K.
For any If we
2.6, Example 2, we see that
symmetric power of
E.
The
55 Example 2.
Assume
we shall write and
r ~ n.
In case
k = (i,i,...,I,0,...,0)
with
r
l's,
for Dk~ K. The k diagram is a single column, (Ir),K has entries 1,2 .... ,r. For any i E I(n,r), ( % : Ti) is the
T
D
r-rowed determinant we see that
D
det(c~, i ).
Mapping this onto
is isomorphic to the
rth
ell A...A e ir
(see 3.2), r
exterior power
A EKO
(ir),K 4.5.
The basis theorem for As usual,
K
is an infinite field.
(4.5a) ...............Basis ...... theorem for such that
Ti
Dk, K
Dk~ K.
DX, K
Our aim is to prove the
has
K-basis consisting of all
is "standard", i.e. the entries in each row of
Ti
(Tg : T i)
are weakly
increasing
(!)
from left to right, and the entries in each column are strictly
increasing
~)
from top to bottom.
This theorem generalizes the theorem of Specht-Garnir for Specht modules (see [P] and [Ja, §§8, 13]).
It may be deduced from a more general basis
theorem of D@sarm~nien, Kung and Rota [DKR, p. 78]. also to prepare for the transition to the module
For completeness, and
Vk, K
in
§5,
we give here
a proof of (4.5a) based on a combinatorial lemma of Carter-Lusztig (see 4.6). We begin by showing that (4.5b) All the
The set
{(T~ : Ti) : T i
(Tg : T i) (i E I(n,r))
k~(n,r) = ~(n,r) o ~k"
in = j.
lie in the "right"
eg, i (i E I(n,r))
if and only if there is some
The condition
stabilizer of the basic
is linearly independent. k-weight-space
For it is clear from (2.3c) that
is spanned by the elements o~, i = cg,j
standard}
~ E G(r)
g~ = g is equivalent to X-tableau (4.2a).
(remember
$o
kAK(n,r) ~k= ~,~).
such that
~ E R(T), c~, i = cg,j
~
Now = g and
the row if and only if
56
T i, Tj
can be obtained from one another by a row permutation (thus the
correspond to James's For each ~s(i) if
(4.5c)
"k-tabloids" [Ja. pp. I0, 127]).
i 6 I(n,r), define
If
i,j 6 I(n,r)
and
~(i)
usual lexicographic way.
If
Ti
s
(~l(i) ..... ~n(i)), of
T i.
Clearly
where
~(i) = ~(j)
by what we have just said; hence
We order these vectors
(4.5d)
~(i) =
is the sum of the entries in row
c4, i = cg,j,,
c~,i
~(i) # ~(j),
then
cg, i # c
(they are in fact elements of
j.
A(n,r))
in the
The reader may verify
is standard and if
1 # ~ ~ C(T),
then
~(i~) > ~(i).
Now suppose we have a non-trivial linear relation
Z fi(Tg : T i) = O, i6H
fi 6 K,
where the sum is over a non-empty subset that
Ti
is standard.
(4.5e)
H
of those
fi # 0
i ~ I(n,r)
such
By (4.3a), this gives
Z i~H
Z fi s(~) cg = 0. ~fC(T) ,in
By (4.5c) we can equate to zero the partial sum of all terms (i,~)
in (4.5e)
such that
the
~(i~)
least of the for
is equal to any given
~(i~)
(i ~ H,
i ~ H, ~ ~ C(T),
~ ~ A(n,r).
~ C(T)). only if
By (4.5d),
~ = i.
Take for
6,
we can have
~ = ~(i~),
So the partial sum has the
form Z f =0, i~H' i c~,i for some non-empty subset
H'
of
H.
But since
Ti
is standard for all
57
i E H',
the
c~, i
appearing in (4.5f) are linearly independent, and this
gives a contradiction.
4.6.
This proves (4.5b).
The Carter-Lusztig lemma To complete the proof of the basis theorem (4.5a) we must show that
every bideterminsnt combination of
(Tg : Ti)
(Tg : T i)
(i E I(n,r))
for which
Ti
is expressible as a linear
is standard.
This is the harder
part of the proof of (4.5a), and we deduce it from a combinatorial lemma (4.6a) of Carter-Lusztig.
The proof of (4.6a) is given in [CL, pp. 214, 215],
and does not depend essentially on other results in
[CL].
The reader may
note some variations of expmession between Carter-Lusztig's paper and this one: our
their "semi-standard" is our "standard"; their Ti ;
their
oT
to the "weight" of
is our
i.
the "type"
k'
corresponds to
of
T( = T i)
corresponds
Finally, in our (4.6a) we have no > restricted
to tableaux of a given type
(4.6a)
Tio ;
T
f
k v.
Carter-Lusztig lemma Let
f : I(n,r) ~ F
be any map with values in an abelian group
F,
satisfying the following three conditions: (i)
f(i) = O,
if
Ti
has equal entries at two distinct places in the
same column. (ii)
f(io) = s(q)f(i),
(iii) (Garnir relations) for any ~+i and
i E l(n,r)
of the basic G(J)
for any
i E l(n,r)
and
~ E C(T).
Z s(v)f(iv) = O, vEG(J)
and any non-empty subset k-tableau
T.
Here
h
J
of the
(h+l)th column
is any element of
is a transversal of the set of cosets
{vX : v E Y},
{1,2 .... ,r-l}, where
Y
58
is the subgroup of
G(r)
consisting of all
element outside
U J,
and
Then {f(i) : T. i Remarks
~
Im f
~ G(r)
which fix every
X = C(T) @ Y.
lies in the subgroup of
F
generated by the set
standard}.
Condition (ii) shows that the sum in (iii) is independent of the
choice of transversal
G(J).
Condition (iii) is equivalent, by an argument
given in [CL, p. 212], to condition (37) of
[CL, p, 214].
A slightly weaker
form of (4.6a), which uses a larger set of "Garnir relations" (but is still adequate for our purposes) can be proved by an adaptation of the proof of Garnir [Ga] for Specht modules; see [P, pp. 93, 94] or [Ja, pp. 29, 30]. Lemma (4.6a) completes the proof of the basis theorem (4.5a), as soon as we observe (4.6b)
The function
f(i) = (Tg : Ti)
satisfies conditions (i), (ii) and
(iii) of (4.6a). Proof
That
f(i)
satisfies (i) and (ii) has already been said in 4.3.
The proof of (iii) is like that for Specht polynomial~. ~ Every element of the set with (with
v ~ G(J)
and
B = Y • C(T)
~ ~ C(T).
f(i) = (T~ : Ti))
Z v~G(J)
has unique expression
transposition in
becomes
Z ~C(T)
{~,~}, R(T).
, = vo,
So the left side of the Garnir relation (iii)
s(~)s(~)cg,iv °
An argument given in [P, pp. 92, 93] shows that union of subsets
Noos as follows.
in which
K
For such a pair
=
Z ~EB B
s(~)c~ i~' '
can be written as disjoint
(which depends on
~)
is some
5g
s(.)c~,i~
because
c%,i~ K
+ s(~)c~,i~ K
= O,
~K = % for all
= c~K,i ~ = c%,i~ (notice
K ~ R(T)).
Hence the sum above is zero, as required.
4.7.
Some consequences of the basis theore______mm Let
~. ~
~ { A(n,r)
Putting
~(=
be a given weight, and
~a,a )
for
o (Tg : Tj) = (Tg : Tj)
each bideterminant i.e.
~
or zero, according as
(Tg : Tj)
(4.7a) with
j.
(j E I(n,r)) Dk,K,
j E e
or not.
Consequently
is a "weight element" of where
~
Dk, K,
is the weight
Then (4.5a) gives the first statement below:
For each i E ~
an element of
in formula (4.4b) we see that
it belongs to the weight-space
containing
a 6 I(n,r)
and
~ ~ A(n,r), Ti
Dk, Kq
standard.
has
K-basis consisting of all
Hence the character
~D
(T~ : T i)
is equal to X,K
~ ( x I .... , Xn). The second statement in (4.7a) follows fact that the coefficient of number of
h-tableaux
Ti
X~
in
from the first, and from the
S=%(XI,... , X n)
which have "content"
can be proved by a direct combinatorial
(i.e.
is precisely the weight)
~
-- this
argument from the definition of
(see [M, p. 42]). Since when
(4.7b)
~
char K = O,
If
is the character of an irreducible module in we deduce
char K = 0,
then
DX, K
is irreducible.
~(n,r)
~A
60 We show next that the family infinite field
K,
we may write
is defined over
{~,K }
(~
Z.
For each
to denote the element
: Ti) K
(~
: T i)
defined in 4.3.
(4.7c)
The
Z-span
(i E l(n,r)) is a D~, Z to
~,Z
of the elements
Z-form of
~,Q.
6K : ~ , Z
K~
and the maps
(~
: Ti) Q
The family ~,K
{~,K }
is
Z-defined by
which take each
(T~ : Ti) Q ® 1K
D~,K~+ k~(n,r)
is also defined
(Te : Ti) K. Moreover the family of inclusions
over
Z.
Proof
The Carter-Lusztig !emma (4.6a), applied to the function
f(i) = (T~ : Ti)Q,
shows that
(Tg : Ti) Q
{(Tg : Ti) Q : T i But by (4.5a), this set is a basis of to the left action of Dk, Q.
The maps
5K
Sz(n,r ).
is in the
standard}. Dk, Q.
By (4.4b),
It follows that
described above are clearly
are isomorphisms by (4.5a) applied to
Z-span of
DX, K.
DX, Z
D~, Z is a
is invariant Z-form of
SK(n,r)-morphisms , and
The last statement of (4.7c)
is immediate from the definitions. Remark
Dk, Z
is a direct summand, as
Z-module, of
inc Az(n,r ) the exact sequence 0 ~ DX, Z -----> from (4.7c) and the next lemma.
is
Az(n,r);
Z-split
equivalently,
This follows
61 (4.7d)
Lemma.
Z-defined by
Suppose VZ
{VK} , {WK}
and {6K} , W Z
family of morphisms in (i)
If all the 0 + VZ
(ii)
If
}~(n,r),
@Q----> W Z
is
also defined over
eK : V K ~ W K
is a
(see 2.6).
Then
Z
Z-split.
9K
are surJective, then the exact sequence
VZ ~ W Z ~ 0
is
Z-split.
Let of
M = (m~)
be the matrix of
VQ, WQ J which {9K}
and that for each
K,
appropriate bases of has rank
d
Z-generate
are equal to
M' = (m~)
9Q,
VZ, W Z
is defined over ~
= (mB~ • IK)
VK, W K.
= dimQVQ,
relative to bases respectively.
Z
implies
M
9K
The assumption
9K
relative to
are injective, this means
and that it still has rank p.
{v },
is an integral matrix,
is the matrix of
If all the
reduction modulo any rational prime M
Suppose
~(n,r),
are injective, then the exact sequence
that the family
M
{~K }.
all the
Proof {w~}
9K
and
are families of modules in
d,
even after
Hence all elementary divisors of
i, and therefore there exists an integral matrix
such that
M'M = identity.
This proves (i). The proof of (ii)
is similar.
4.8
James's construction of
DX, K
G. D. James has given [Ja, p. 129] a construction of a W X, D~ K"
KFK-mOdule
which he calls a "Weyl module", but which is in fact isomorphic to If
e,~ E A(n,r),
then the elements
ci,j(i ~ ~, J E ~)
may be identified with James's "s-tabloids of type not necessary that either
~ = (~i ..... an)
dominant, i.e. be proper partitions of X~(n,r)
in our language (see 4.5).
r.)
or
of
~(n,r)
~" [Ja, p. 127].
~ = (~i .... , ~n )
James's space
S°'%
(It is
be becomes
He defines, for all pairs of integers
62
s E {i .... ,n} and
v E {0,..., ks+ 1 }
a linear map
k ~s,v :
~(n,r)
~ ~(n,r)
by the rule:
(4.8a)
Ss,v(C~,i) = Zh
sunmed over all ks+ I - v
h 6 l(n,r)
of the entries
Definition such that
%s,v(C) = O
obtained by replacing,
s + I by
[Ja, p. 129]
Ch'i'
Wk
in
e
Tg),
s.
is the set of all elements
for all
(or in
s E {i .... ,n}
c E k~(n,r)
v E {0, .... ks+ I - i}.
By a rather delicate combinatorial argument, James proves a theorem [Ja, 26.3, p. 128] from which it follows readily that the set
{(T$ : T i) : T i
standard}; hence
~
= Dk, K.
definition has a very important group-theoretical
Wk
has as basis
However James's
interpretation,
which we
shall now give. Let
U
= U (K)
be the subgroup of
lower triangular unipotent matrices in generated by the elements
Us(t)
F.
F = GLn(K)
consisting of all
It is well-known that
U-
is
(s 6 {I .... ,n-l}, t E K) where
I 0
"°° i
us(t)
t 1
=
0
(row
S)
(row
s+l)
.
'. i
Now write F
on
~(n)
g = Us(t)
and
(see Introduction)
i E l(n,r).
By definition of the action
63
(4.8b)
cg i o g = '
it is clear that
(4.8c)
For all
such that
h E l(n,r) the entries
then
Cg,h(g ) = tw,
s + i
by
s.
c £ k~(n,r),
ks+l ks+l-V Z t v=0
s E {!,...,n-l}
w
is the number of
Ce,h(g ) = tw,
in
Z
(or in
it is clear that
Te) ,
w
t 6 K.
of
(i E l(n,r)).
%s,v(C) = c, K
Naturally we prove
for all
c E X~(n,r).
is infinite, we see that for any
the conditions
~s,v(C) = O,
all
s E {i, .... n-l},
v E {0,..., ks+l-l}
are equivalent to the conditions c o Us(t) = c,
all
s E {i .... ,n-l},
which in turn are equivalent to the conditions
(4.8e)
for any
~s,v(C),
and
c = ce, i
So by (4.8d), and using the fact that c E kAK(n,r) ,
where
Thus (4.8b) gives a formula
(4.8d), by taking first the case v = ks+l,
(s+l,s)},
In other words,
which can be obtained by replacing,
c o Us(t) =
If
is zero unless
p E r, (gp,h@) E {(i,i) .... ,(n,n),
(gp,hp) = (s+l, s).
(4.8d)
for all
C~,h(g)ch, i •
Cg'h(g) = gglhl "'" gP~rrh
and if (4.8c) is satisfied, p
Z hEI(n,r)
c o u = c,
all
u E Un(K).
t E K,
64 k
~(n,r)
is the right
Extend the character Bn(K) = Tn(K)Un(K) ,
X k of
k-weight-space of Tn(K )
by defining
allows us to reformulate James's
(4.8e)
Theorem
c £ ~(n,r)
The module
Xk
~(n,r)
FK = GL (K)), n of
for all
u ~ Un(K).
This
theorem as follows.
Dk, K = W
k
is the set of all elements
which satisfy the conditions
This shows that
for
(see 4.5).
(see 3.2) to the Borel subgroup
Xk(u) = 1
c 0 b = Xk(b)c,
category
~(n,r)
Bn(K).
Dk, K
all
b 6 B-(K). n
is the induced module
Ind~-(Kk)
in the
(or, in fact, in the category of all rational modules of a
K-B-(K)-module n
Kk
which affords the character
For a discussion of a theorem equivalent to (4.8e), for
semisimple algebraic groups, see [J"~ §i.].
4 The modules Dλ,K
4.1 Preamble In this section and the next we shall define, for each λ = (λ1 , . . . , λn ) in Λ+ (n, r) and for each infinite field K, the modules Dλ,K and Vλ,K (see introduction). Both have character Φλ,0 = Sλ (X1 , . . . , Xn ). In 4.4, we shall define Dλ,K in terms of certain determinantal functions in AK (n, r). These modules have been known, in the “classical” case K = C, for a very long time—they were discovered (under the guise of “primary covariants”) by J. Deruyts in 1892 [13, p. 72]1 . More recently they have been described, for fields of arbitrary characteristic, by M. Clausen [8, p. 180], and by G. D. James [27, p. 129]. In fact James refers to Dλ,K as a “Weyl module”, but we prefer to reserve this term for the module Vλ,K which was defined by Carter-Lusztig [6, p. 211], and which, as we show in 5.2, is the contravariant dual of Dλ,K . However James’ construction in [27] gives more information than ours, since it can be used to identify Dλ,K with the “induced module” of a one-dimensional character on the lower triangular Borel subgroup Bn− (K) of ΓK = GLn (K). We mention this identification in 4.8.
4.2 λ-tableaux For the rest of §4, λ = (λ1 , . . . , λn ) ∈ Λ+ (n, r) is fixed. The diagram (or “shape”) of λ is defined to be the subset [λ] = { (s, t) : 1 ≤ s, 1 ≤ t ≤ λs } of Z × Z (cf. [15, p. 66]). A λ-tableau is a map, not necessarily bijective, of [λ] into a set. Since [λ] has r elements, there exists at least one bijection T : [λ] → r. We shall arbitrarily choose one such bijection, and call it 1 I am indebted to J. Towber for this reference. In his article [52], Towber gives an account of the history of Dλ,K : see particularly [52, p. 448].
34
4 The modules Dλ,K
the basic λ-tableau T = T λ . If the image under T of (s, t) is x(s, t), we may depict T as x(1, 1) x(1, 2) · · · (4.2a)
···
x(1, λ1 )
x(2, 1) x(2, 2) · · · x(2, λ2 ) x(3, 1) x(3, 2) · · · ···
···
Thus every element ∈ r appears exactly once in (4.2a). If = x(s, t), we say that is in row s and column t of T . The row stabilizer R(T ) of T is the subgroup of G = G(r) consisting of all π ∈ G which preserve the rows of (4.2a), and the column stabilizer C(T ) is defined similarly. If i : r → n is an element of I(n, r), we denote the λ-tableau i ◦ T : [λ] → n by Ti . In general, Ti is not bijective. If = x(s, t), we often refer to i as the entry in place , or in the (s, t) place, of Ti . Example. Suppose r = 5, n = 3 and λ = (3, 2, 0). We might take for our
1 3 5 i1 i3 i5 basic λ-tableau T = . Then, for any i ∈ I(n, r), Ti = . 2 4 i2 i4 The entries of Ti belong to the set 3 = {1, 2, 3}.
4.3 Bideterminants Let K be an infinite field, and let i, j be elements of I(n, r). We define an element (Ti : Tj ) = (Ti : Tj )K of AK (n, r) by the formula (4.3a) (Ti : Tj ) = s(σ)ci,jσ = s(σ)ciσ,j . σ∈C(T )
σ∈C(T )
Here s(σ) denotes the sign of σ. The second equality comes from the fact that ci,jσ = ciσ−1 ,j , for any σ ∈ G(r). Apart from the interchange of rows and columns, the element (Ti : Tj ) is a bideterminant in the sense of D´esarm´enien, Kung and Rota [15, p. 67]. Let µ = (µ1 , . . . , µr ) be the partition of r conjugate to λ (notice that µ might not be an element of Λ+ (n, r), since it might have more than n parts). Then it is easy to see that (Ti : Tj ) is the product, over all columns t of [λ], of the µt × µt determinants . det cix(s,t) ,jx(s ,t) s,s =1,...,µt
(If µt = 0, we take this determinant to be 1.) From this, or directly from (4.3a), we see that (Ti : Tj ) is zero if there are equal entries at any two places in a column of Ti , or of Tj . Also (Ti : Tjσ ) = (Tiσ : Tj ) = s(σ)(Ti : Tj ), for all σ ∈ C(T ).
4.4 Definition of Dλ,K
35
Example 1. Let λ = (3, T be as in the example in 4.2. Consi 2, 0), 1 1 1 a d f der Tl = , Ti = . Then 2 2 b e c1a c1b c1d c1e c ∈ AK (3, 5). (Tl : Ti ) = c2a c2b c2d c2e 1f Example 2. Let l be the element of I(n, r) whose λ-tableau is ⎞ ⎛ 1 1 ··· ··· 1 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 2 2 ··· 2 ⎟ ⎟. (4.3b) Tl = ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 3 3 ··· ⎠ ⎝ ··· In other words, lx(s,t) = s, for all (s, t) ∈ [λ]. Then (Tl : Tl ) = c(µ1 )c(µ2 ) · · · , where, for any integer m (0 ≤ m ≤ n), c(m) denotes the mth leading minor of the n × n matrix C = (cµν ).
4.4 Definition of Dλ,K The space AK (n, r) is a bimodule for KΓ, with Γ = ΓK acting by right and left translations. Equivalently, it is a bimodule for SK (n, r). If h, j ∈ I(n, r) = I, we have (see 2.8) (4.4a) ξ ◦ ch,j = ξ(ci,j )ch,i i∈I
and (4.4a )
ch,j ◦ ξ =
ξ(ch,i )ci,j ,
i∈I
for all ξ ∈ SK (n, r). As left module AK (n, r) belongs to the category MK (n, r), (n, r) of and as right module it belongs to the analogously defined category MK all right, finite-dimensional KΓ- (or SK (n, r)-) modules whose coefficient space lies in AK (n, r). In fact the coefficient space of AK (n, r), whether regarded as left or right KΓ-module, is precisely AK (n, r). Now let l be the element of I(n, r) defined in (4.3b). It is clear that l belongs to the weight λ = (λ1 , . . . , λn ). Definition. Dλ,K is the K-span of all bideterminants (Tl : Ti ), i ∈ I(n, r). Hence Dλ,K is a subspace of AK (n, r). Replace h by lσ in (4.4a), multiply by s(σ), and sum over all σ in C(T ). We get
36
(4.4b)
4 The modules Dλ,K
ξ ◦ (Tl : Tj ) =
ξ(ci,j )(Tl : Ti ), all ξ ∈ SK (n, r).
i∈I
It follows that Dλ,K is a left SK (n, r)-submodule of AK (n, r). If we compare (4.4b) with (2.6a), we see also that the surjective linear map ⊗r ϕ = ϕK : EK → Dλ,K ,
which takes ej → (Tl : Tj ) for all j ∈ I(n, r), is an SK (n, r)-module homomorphism. Remark. Our definition of l and (Tl : Ti ) depends on our choice of basic λ tableau T (see 4.2). However any other bijective λ-tableau T can be written T = πT for some π ∈ G(r). Then Ti = Tiπ for any i ∈ I(n, r), and if l = lπ −1 we have (Tl : Ti ) = (Tl : Ti ). Therefore Dλ,K is in fact independent of the choice of T . Example 1. In case λ = (r, 0, . . . , 0) we shall write Dr,K for Dλ,K . The λ diagram is a single row of length r, and Tl = (1 1 . . . 1). For any i ∈ I(n, r), we have Ti = (i1 i2 . . . ir ) and (Tl : Ti ) = c1,i1 · · · c1,ir . If we map this to the monomial ei1 · · · eir of 2.6, example 2, we see that Dr,K is isomorphic to the rth symmetric power of E. Example 2. Assume r ≤ n. In case λ = (1, . . . , 1, 0, . . . , 0) with r 1’s, we shall write D(1r ),K for Dλ,K . The λ diagram is a single column, and Tl has entries 1, 2, . . . , r. For any i ∈ I(n, r), (Tl : Ti ) is the r-rowed determinant det (cl,1 ). Mapping this onto ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eir (see 3.2), we see that D(1)r ,K is isomorphic to the rth exterior power of Λr EK .
4.5 The basis theorem for Dλ,K As usual, K is an infinite field. Our aim is to prove the (4.5a) Basis theorem. Dλ,K has K-basis consisting of all (Tl : Ti ) such that Ti is “standard”, i.e. the entries in each row of Ti are weakly increasing (≤) from left to right, and the entries in each column are strictly increasing (<) from top to bottom. This theorem generalizes the theorem of Specht-Garnir for Specht modules (see [45] and [27, §8, 13]). It may be deduced from a more general basis theorem of D´esarm´enien, Kung and Rota [15, p. 78]. For completeness, and also to prepare for the transition to the module Vλ,K in §5, we give here a proof of (4.5a) based on a combinatorial lemma of Carter-Lusztig (see 4.6). We begin by showing that (4.5b) The set { (Tl : Ti ) : Ti standard } is linearly independent.
4.6 The Carter-Lusztig lemma
37
Proof. All the (Tl : Ti ) (i ∈ I(n, r)) lie in the “right” λ-weight-space AK (n, r) = AK (n, r) ◦ ξλ .
λ
For it is clear from (2.3c) that λAK (n, r) is spanned by the elements cl,i , where i ∈ I(n, r) (remember ξλ = ξl,l ). Now cl,i = cl,j if and only if there is some π ∈ G(r) such that lπ = l and iπ = j. The condition lπ = l is equivalent to π ∈ R(T ), the row stabilizer of the basic λ-tableau ((4.2a)). So cl,i = cl,j if and only if Ti , Tj can be obtained from one another by a row permutation (thus the cl,i correspond to James’ “λ-tabloids” [27, pp. 10, 127]). For each i ∈ I(n, r), define β(i) = (β1 (i), . . . , βn (i)), where βs (i) is the sum of the entries in row s of Ti . Clearly β(i) = β(j) if cl,i = cl,j , by what we have just said; hence (4.5c) If i, j ∈ I(n, r) and β(i) = β(j), then cl,i = cl,j . We order these vectors β(i) (they are in fact elements of Λ(n, r)) in the usual lexicographic way. The reader may verify (4.5d) If Ti is standard and if 1 = π ∈ C(T ), then β(iπ) > β(i). Now suppose we have a non-trivial linear relation fi (Tl : Ti ) = 0, fi ∈ K, fi = 0, i∈H
where the sum is over a non-empty subset H of those i ∈ I(n, r) such that Ti is standard. By (4.3a), this gives (4.5e) fi s(π) cl,iπ = 0. i∈H π∈C(T )
By (4.5c) we can equate to zero the partial sum of all terms (i, π) in (4.5e) such that β(iπ) is equal to any given β ∈ Λ(n, r). Take for β, the least of the β(iπ) (i ∈ H, π ∈ C(T )). By (4.5d), we can have β = β(iπ), for i ∈ H, π ∈ C(T ), only if π = 1. So the partial sum has the form (4.5f ) fi cl,i = 0, i∈H
for some non-empty subset H of H. But since Ti is standard for all i ∈ H , the cl,i appearing in (4.5f) are linearly independent, and this gives a contradiction. This proves (4.5b).
4.6 The Carter-Lusztig lemma To complete the proof of the basis theorem (4.5a) we must show that every bideterminant (Tl : Ti ) (i ∈ I(n, r)) is expressible as a linear combination
38
4 The modules Dλ,K
of (Tl : Ti ) for which Ti is standard. This is the harder part of the proof of (4.5a), and we deduce it from a combinatorial lemma (4.6a) of CarterLusztig. The proof of (4.6a) is given in [6, p. 214, 215], and does not depend essentially on other results in [6]. The reader may note some variations of expression between Carter-Lusztig’s paper and this one: their “semi-standard” is our “standard”; their T corresponds to our Ti ; their σT is our Tiσ ; the “type” λ of T (= Ti ) corresponds to the “weight” of i. Finally, in our (4.6a) we have not restricted f to tableaux of a given type λ . (4.6a) Carter-Lusztig lemma. Let f : I(n, r) → F be any map with values in an abelian group F , satisfying the following three conditions: (i) f (i) = 0, if Ti has equal entries at two distinct places in the same column. (ii) f (iσ) = s(σ) f (i), for any i ∈ I(n, r) and σ ∈ C(T ). (iii) (Garnir relations) ν∈G(J) s(ν) f (iν) = 0, for any i ∈ I(n, r) and any non-empty subset J of the (h + 1)th column Ch+1 of the basic λ-tableau T . Here h is any element of {1, 2 . . . , r − 1}, and G(J) is a transversal of the set of cosets { νX : ν ∈ Y }, where Y is the subgroup of G(r) consisting of all π ∈ G(r) which fix every element outside Ch ∪J, and X = C(T )∩Y . Then Im f lies in the subgroup of F generated by the set { f (i) : Ti standard }. Remarks. Condition (ii) shows that the sum in (iii) is independent of the choice of transversal G(J). Condition (iii) is equivalent, by an argument given in [6, p. 212], to condition (37) of [6, p. 214]. A slightly weaker form of (4.6a), which uses a larger set of “Garnir relations” (but is still adequate for our purposes) can be proved by an adaptation of the proof of Garnir [19] for Specht modules; see [45, pp. 93, 94] or [27, pp. 29, 30]. Lemma (4.6a) completes the proof of the basis theorem (4.5a), as soon as we observe (4.6b) The function f (i) = (Tl : Ti ) satisfies conditions (i), (ii) and (iii) of (4.6a). Proof. That f (i) satisfies (i) and (ii) has already been said in 4.3. The proof of (iii) is like that for Specht polynomials, and goes as follows. Every element of the set B = Y · C(T ) has unique expression π = νσ, with ν ∈ G(J) and σ ∈ C(T ). So the left side of the Garnir relation (iii) (with f (i) = (Tl : Ti )) becomes s(ν) s(σ) cl,iνσ = s(π) cl,iπ . ν∈G(J) σ∈C(T )
π∈B
An argument given in [45, pp. 92, 93] shows that B can be written as disjoint union of subsets {π, πκ}, in which κ (which depends on π) is some transposition in R(T ). For such a pair s(π) cl,iπ + s(πκ) cl,iπκ = 0, because cl,iπκ = clκ,iπ = cl,iπ (notice lκ = l for all κ ∈ R(T )). Hence the sum above is zero, as required.
4.7 Some consequences of the basis theorem
39
4.7 Some consequences of the basis theorem Let α ∈ Λ(n, r) be a given weight, and suppose a ∈ I(n, r) is an element of α. Putting ξα (= ξa,a ) for ξ in formula (4.4b) we see that ξα ◦ (Tl : Tj ) = (Tl : Tj ) or zero, according as j ∈ α or not. Consequently each bideterminant (Tl : Tj ) (where j ∈ I(n, r)) is a “weight element” of Dλ,K , i.e. it belongs to the weightα , where α is the weight containing j. Then (4.5a) gives the first space Dλ,K statement below: α (4.7a) For each α ∈ Λ(n, r), Dλ,K has K-basis consisting of all (Tl : Ti ) with i ∈ α and Ti standard. Hence the character of Dλ,K is equal to the Schur function Sλ (X1 , . . . , Xn ).
The second statement in (4.7a) follows from the first, and from the fact that the coefficient of X α in Sλ = Sλ (X1 , . . . , Xn ) is precisely the number of λ-tableaux Ti which have “content” (i.e. weight) α—this can be proved by a direct combinatorial argument from the definition of Sλ (see [39, p. 42]). Since Sλ is the character of an irreducible module in MK (n, r) when char K is zero, we deduce (4.7b) If char K = 0, then Dλ,K is irreducible. We show next that the family Dλ,K is defined over Z. For each infinite field K, we may write (Tl : Ti )K to denote the element (Tl : Ti ) defined in 4.3. (4.7c) The Z-span Dλ,Z of the elements (Tl : Ti )Q (i ∈ I(n, r)) is a Z-form of Dλ,Q . The family {Dλ,K } is Z-defined by Dλ,Z and the maps δK : Dλ,Z ⊗ K → Dλ,K , (Tl : Ti )Q ⊗ 1K → (Tl : Ti )K Moreover the family of inclusions Dλ,K → λAK (n, r) is also defined over Z. Proof. When applied to the function f (i) = (Tl : Ti )Q , the Carter-Lusztig lemma (4.6a) shows that (Tl : Ti )Q is in the Z-span of { (Tl : Ti )Q : Ti standard }. But by (4.5a), this set is a basis of Dλ,Q . By (4.4b), Dλ,Z is invariant to the left action of SZ (n, r). It follows that Dλ,Z is a Z-form of Dλ,Q . The maps δK described above are clearly SK (n, r)-morphisms, and are isomorphisms by (4.5a) applied to Dλ,K . The last statement of (4.7c) is immediate from the definitions. Remark. Dλ,Z is a direct summand, as Z-module, of AZ (n, r); equivalently, inc
the exact sequence 0 → Dλ,Z → AZ (n, r) is Z-split. This follows from (4.7c) and the next lemma.
40
4 The modules Dλ,K
(4.7d) Lemma. Suppose {VK }, {WK } are families of modules in MK (n, r), and are Z-defined by VZ and {δK }, WZ and {ηK }. Suppose θK : VK → WK is a family of morphisms in MK (n, r), also defined over Z (see 2.6). Then θQ
(i) If all the θK are injective, then the exact sequence 0 → VZ → WZ is Z-split. θQ
(ii) If all the θK are surjective, then the exact sequence VZ → WZ → 0 is Z-split. Proof. Let M = (mβα ) be the matrix of θQ , relative to bases {vα }, {wβ } of VQ , WQ which Z-generate VZ , WZ respectively. The assumption that the family {θK } is defined over Z implies M is an integral matrix, and that for each K, MK = (mβα ·1K ) is the matrix of θK relative to the appropriate bases of VK , WK . If all the θK are injective, this means that M has rank d = dimQ VQ , and that it still has rank d, even after reduction modulo any rational prime p. Hence all elementary divisors of M are equal to 1, and therefore there exists an integral matrix M = (mαβ ) such that M M = identity. This proves (i). The proof of (ii) is similar.
4.8 James’s construction of Dλ,K G. D. James has given [27, p. 129] a construction of a KΓK -module W λ , which he calls a “Weyl module”, but which is in fact isomorphic to Dλ,K . If α, β ∈ Λ(n, r), then the elements ci,j (i ∈ α, j ∈ β) of AK (n, r) may be identified with James’s “α-tabloids of type β” [27, p. 127]. (It is not necessary that either α = (α1 , . . . , αn ) or β = (β1 , . . . , βn ) be dominant, i.e. be proper partitions of r.) James’s space S ◦,λ becomes λAK (n, r) in our language (see 4.5). He defines, for all pairs of integers s ∈ {1, . . . , n} and v ∈ {0, . . . , λs+1 } a linear map ψs,v : λAK (n, r) → AK (n, r) by the rule: (4.8a)
ψs,v (cl,i ) =
ch,i ,
h
summed over all h ∈ I(n, r) obtained by replacing, in l (or in Tl ) λs+1 − v of the entries s + 1 by s. Definition (see [27, p. 129]). W λ is the set of all elements c ∈ λAK (n, r) such that ψs,v (c) = 0 for all s ∈ {1, . . . , n} and v ∈ {0, . . . , λs+1 − 1}. By a rather delicate combinatorial argument, James proves a theorem (see [27, 26.3, p. 128]) from which it follows readily that W λ has as basis the set { (Tl : Ti ) : Ti standard }; hence W λ = Dλ,K . However James’s definition
4.8 James’s construction of Dλ,K
41
has a very important group-theoretical interpretation, which we shall now give. Let U − = Un− (K) be the subgroup of Γ = GLn (K) consisting of all lower triangular unipotent matrices in Γ. It is well-known that U − is generated by the elements us (t) (s ∈ {1, . . . , n − 1}, t ∈ K) where ⎞ ⎛ 1 ⎟ ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎜ . ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ (row s) ⎜ 1 ⎟ ⎜ us (t) = ⎜ ⎟ (row s + 1) t 1 ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ . .. ⎠ ⎝ 1 with t in position (s + 1, s). Now write g = us (t) and i ∈ I(n, r). By definition of the action of Γ on AK (n) (see introduction) (4.8b) cl,i ◦ g = cl,h (g) ch,i . h∈I(n,r)
It is clear that cl,h (g) = gl1 h1 · · · glr hr is zero unless (4.8c) For all ∈ r, (l , h ) ∈ {(1, 1), . . . , (n, n), (s + 1, s)}, and if (4.8c) is satisfied, then cl,h (g) = tw , where w is the number of such that (l , h ) = (s + 1, s). In other words, cl,h (g) = tw , for any h ∈ I(n, r) which can be obtained by replacing, in l (or Tl ), w of the entries s + 1 by s. Thus (4.8b) gives a formula
λs+1
(4.8d)
c ◦ us (t) =
tλs+1 −v ψs,v (c),
v=0
for all c ∈ λAK (n, r), s ∈ {1, . . . , n − 1} and t ∈ K. Naturally we prove (4.8d) by taking first the case c = cl,i (i ∈ I(n, r)). If v = λs+1 , it is clear that ψs,v (c) = c, for all c ∈ λAK (n, r). So by (4.8d), and using the fact that K is infinite, we see that for any c ∈ λAK (n, r), the conditions ψs,v (c) = 0, all s ∈ {1, . . . , n − 1}, v ∈ {0, . . . , λs+1 − 1} are equivalent to the conditions c ◦ us (t) = c, all s ∈ {1, . . . , n − 1}, t ∈ K, which in turn are equivalent to the conditions (4.8e)
c ◦ u = c, all u ∈ Un− (K).
42
4 The modules Dλ,K
Recall from 4.5 that λAK (n, r) is the right λ-weight-space of AK (n, r). Extend the character χλ of Tn (K) (see 3.2) to the Borel subgroup Bn− (K) = Tn (K) Un− (K), by defining χλ (u) = 1 for all u ∈ Un− (K). This allows us to reformulate James’s theorem as follows. (4.8f ) Theorem. The module Dλ,K = W λ is the set of all c ∈ AK (n, r) which satisfy the conditions c ◦ b = χλ (b)c, all b ∈ Bn− (K). This shows that Dλ,K is the induced module IndΓB − (Kλ ) in the category MK (n, r) (or, in fact, in the category of all rational modules for GLn (K)), of a K · Bn− (K)-module Kλ which affords the character χλ of Bn− (K). For a discussion of a theorem equivalent to (4.8f), for semisimple algebraic groups, see [30, §1].
§5
The Carter-Lusztig modules
5.1
Definition of Let
%~,K
~ ~ #~+(n,r)
Denote by
NK
~,K
be given, and let
the kernel of the
defined in 4.4.
Let
VX, K
the canonical form
on
E~rK ' Vk,K
{x (
is also a submodule of
o Vk, K ~ (Dk, K) ,
contravariant
to
DX, K
If
K
is an
NK,
relative to
SK(n,r)-submodule
of
Since
<, > is non-singular,
we
form
(,) : Vk, K × D k K -~ K
by
@r x ~ Vk,K, y ~ E K .
all
dual modules in
V%,K
~ = Sk(X 1 ..... Xn) o ' Vk, K is irreducible, and is isomorphic
has finite characteristic,
V~~,K
and
5.2
Vh~,K is Carter-Lusztig's
then in general
are not isomorphic.
We shall identify
Vk, K
Lusztig in [CL, pp. 211, 222]. more exactly.
"
(by 3.3e))
if char K = 0, then
(see 4.7). Dk,K
,
NK
and because (contravariant)
have the same character
In particular,
and E~.
(x, ~K(y)) = <x,y~
l~(n,r)
--> 0
.~r : <x, Nk;~ = 0}
is contravariant
may define a non-singular,
Hence
,K
(see 2.7, example I):
Vk, K =
<,>
D~
~(n,r)
be the orthogonsl complement to
<,>
(5.1b)
~r ~K : EK ~ ~ , K
SK(n,r)-epJmorphism
®r ~ K --> EK
0 --~ N K
Since
be any infinite field.
We have then an exact sequence in
(5.1a) Delinition.
K
"Weyl module" with the module
~
defined by Carter-
First we must describe
N K = Ker ~K
@6
(5.2a)
NK
(i)
is the
R1
K-span of the subset
consists of all
ei
R = R1 U R2 U R 3
such that
i E I(n,r)
and
of
E~,
where
Ti
has equal
entries in two distinct places in some column. (ii)
R2
cons~ists of all
e i - s(o)elo ,
(iii)
R3
consists of all elements
where
Y
i ~ I(n,r)
s(w)eiv,
where
and
o ~ C(T).
i ~ l(n,r) _
o~G(J) and
J
is a non-empty subset of
Proof the
All the elements of K-span
N'
F = EK®r'-'/m onto function
of
R.
~,K'
R
Ch+I(T)
lie in
for some
N = NK,
h E {1,2 ..... r-l}.
by (4.6b), and so
There is therefore a well-defined given by
~(x+N') = ~K(X),
all
K-map
x ~ E~ r.
N ~
contains from
Now the
f : I(n,r) ~ F given by f(i) = ei+N' clearly satisfies the hypotheses
of (4.6a), hence
F
is K-spanned by the set {e i + N' : T i standard}.
this set onto a basis of implies
NC
N';
hence
~,K'
by (4.5a).
N = N',
Therefore
and (5.2a) is proved.
Ker ~ = O,
But ~ maps
which
As a corollary
we have
(5.2b)
~,K
x E ~EKr which satisfy the
is the set of all elements
following conditions: (i)
<x,
ei>=
0
for all
i ~ I(n,r)
such that
Ti
has equal entries
Jn two distinct places in the same c61umn. (ii)
~
(iii)
= s(o)x %
for all
s(~)x~ -I = 0
o E C(T). any non-empty subset
J
of
~h+l(T), h ~ {l,2,...,r-l}
~ G(J) Proof (5.2a) shows that <x, R
>= 0
for
VX, K
s = 1,2,3.
consists of all
x E E~ r
such that
(5.2b) is an almost immediate consequence
S
of this, together with the fact that an "invariance" condition
<,>
is non-singular, and satisfies
67
(5.2c)
<x~, y> = <x, y~
for all
x,y 6 E K ,
n ~ G(r).
form the deflnitien of
<,>
>
This last condition is verified trivially
(see 2.7, example I).
It is now easy to see that "Weyl module"
-I
Vk, K
~oincides with Carter-Lusztig's
~± ", conditions (28), (29) of [CL, p. 211] are essent~ally
(i), (ii), (iii) of (5.2b).
Example..... I.
If
k = (r,0, "'" ,0)
(i), (il) of (5.25) are vacuous. transpositions all s ~ e t r i c
x
in
contravariant sense to the
over all
~1
e~ = e I
Pn
...e n
for
•
So
Assume
{v
Vk, K
Dr, K
: a ~ A(n,r)},
(v ,e~) = 6
r ~ n
x ~ = x,
for all
is the space of
EK~r. Therefore this module is dual in the
where
The non-singular contravariant form
so that
Conditions
Vk,K"
Condition (iii) says
rth symmetric power
has basis
is given by
[x ample 2. We write
Vr, K
I ~ ~.
(see 5.])
V r,K
v = (h, h +I) (h = i,..., r-l). tensors•
Example i).
we write
for all
~'~
{e ~ : ~ ( A(n,r)}
and that
of
EK va
(see 4.4, =
~ei,
sum
(,) : Vr, K × Dr, K ~ K
a,~ 6 A(n,r).
is a basis of
k = (I,...,I,0 .... ,0)
D
Here r,K"
with
r
l's.
V
for Vk, K. Condition (iii) of (5.2b) is vacuous, and (ir),K conditions (i), (ii) show that V is the space of all antisymmetric (ir),K whatever tensors in E,er K . V (ir),K is an irreducible module in ~ ( n , r ) , the characteristic of
K,
since its character
er(Xl,...,X n)
non-trivial expression as a sum of symmetric functions in Therefore
V
(Ir),K
Is isomorphic to the
rth
has no
Z(XI,...,Xn].
exterior power
68
D(ir), K =
~&rEK
ArEK ~ V
(see 4.4, example 2). which takes each
e
(ir),K
'fhere is an isomorphism
= e s
A ...4
ei
iI
(see 3.3) to r
(eil ® "'" ~ elr )( ~6G Z s(~)~). 5.3
The Carter-Lusztig Carter-Lusztig
is a cyclic module
basis for
Vk, K
have given a basis for [CL, pp. 216-219],
different proof of these results.
VX,K,
V~, K
It Is interesting that the Carter-Lusztig DX, K
If
X
given in (4.5a);
are connected by a certain unimodular matrix
(see (5.3)) which has appeared in work of D~sarmenien
Notation.
VX, K
We shall give here a slightly
basis (see (5.3b)) is not the dual of the basis of these bases of
and shown that
[De, ~.7~ ].
is any subset of the syum~etric group
Ix]
=
z
~,
{x}
G(r),
we shall write
=
n~X These are elements of the group-rlng even belong to
ZG(r).
(5.3a)
be the element of
Let
fg = eg{C(T)}
Proof For
lies in
Verify that y ~ RI U
as in (5.2a) y = e~{G(J)}. B = G(J)C(T) up
g
B
R2 (iii).
KG(r),
l(n,r)
of course.
K = Q,
given in (4.3b).
they
Then
Vk, K .
= O,
for all
there is no problem.
y E ~i U R 2 U R 3
Suppose then that
In the notation just introduced,
Using (5.2c),
<e~{C(T)},
{~, ~K}, each
(see (5.2a)).
y =
% s(v)eiv, v~G(J)
this reads
ei{G(J)} > = <e~, el{B}>,
= YC(T) -- see the proof of (4.6b).
as union of pairs
If
K
where
As in that proof, we break
being a transposition
6g
in
R(T).
Using (5.2c) again, and the fact that
<e%, ei(s(~)~
+ s(~K)~<)> = 0
for each pair.
e%<
= e% ,
Therefore
we have
= 0,
and this completes the proof of (5.3a).
Remark.
fg
is the element denoted by
Now let by
fg.
Since
As
V'
be the
K-space,
V'
V'
is
in [CL, p. 216].
SK(n,r)-submodule of
V~, K
is spanned by the elements
~i,jfg = (~i,jeg){C(T)}, Hence
~
~i,jfg(i,j
we see by (2.6a) that
K-spanned by the elements
which is generated E I(n,r)).
~i,jfg = 0
unless
b i = ~i,gfg(i ~ I(n,r)).
In fact we have the following much more precise statement.
(5.3b)
Theorem
[CL, Theorem 3.5, p. 218].
{b i = ~i,~fg
is a
K-basis for
generated as
Proof
Let
Vk, K.
SK(n,r)
In particular
(or
i,j ~ I(n,r).
that there is some ~ ~ R(T)
iR(T) of
h ~ l(n,r)
~ ~ G(r)
(see (4.3b)).
standard}
i.e.
VX ,K
is
f~.
From (2.6a) we have
~i,ge$ =
where the sum is over all
Ti
V' = Vk, K,
KFK)-module by
(5.3c)
if
: i ~ I(n,r),
The set
with
~i: e h , h such that
h = i~, f = ~ .
(i,~) ~ (h,g), But
g = ~
So the sum in (5.3c) is over the
i.e. such if and only
R(T)-orbit
i.
Now we bring in the form and calculate
(,) : VX, K x D~, K ~ K
introduced in 5.1,
70
(bi, (Tg : Tj)) = =
< ~i,ge~ ,
=
<
and
~(i,j)
i
=
~ eh , h~iR(T)
% s(o),
belong to the same Now suppose
% ~C(T)
o E C(T)
If
this implies
o = i,
(see 4.5), and if the matrix I
(~(i,j)),
= {k E I(n,r)
that
either
i > J
singular.
Note.
5.4
i
and
for all
and
J
i
that
jo
There
R(T)-orbit.
~(i) = ~(jo)
~(jo) > ~(j).
Let
~
denote
running over the set I
i,j ~ I ,
any total order
then
~(i,i) = i.
~(i,j) = (bi, (Tg : Tj)),
standard}
~(i,j) # O.
are in the same
If we give
and clearly
{(Tg : Tj) : Tj
A proof that
such
In any case we have
standard}.
{b i : T i
standard}
~
such
is a unimodular ~(i,j) ~ 0 Hence
and since
is a basis of
is a basis of
>
VX, K.
~ (,)
implies is nonis
Dk, K,
it
This proves (5.3b).
is unimodular is given by D~sarm~nien in [De, ~ . ~ ] .
Some consequences of the basis theorem For each
b i = ~i,~f~ of
o ~ C(T)
then (4.5d) implies
i = j ,
But since
follows that
is equal to
For by what we have shown above,
or
non-singular and
jo
i = j.
~(i) > ~(j) = i ~ J
triangular matrix.
~(i,j),
using (5.3c).
are both standard, and that
with
: Tk
s(o)ejo > ,
sum over all
such that
¢ ~ 1
using (5.2c)
R(T)-orbit.
Ti, Tj
must exist
< ~i,~eg{C(T)}, ej>
ej{C(T)} > ,
This last expression, which we denote (5.3d)
=
i.
From
i ~ I(n,r),
satisfies (5.3b)
it is clear by (2.3c) that the element
~i,i bi = b i , we deduce
thus
~ K, b i ~ V~,
where
is the weight
71
(5.4a)
Let
a (£(n,r).
{b i : i ~ ~,
In particular,
Then
Ti
Vk, K
has
K-basis
standard}
V k,K ~ = K.fg
(since
b~ = ~g,g fg
= f~).
A well-
The element
fg
known argument (see e.g. [J", p. 2]) shows (5.4b)
VX, K
has a unique maximal submodule
does not lie in character
Proof Vk,K,
~ax ,K '
~k,p,
By (5.3b)
V' =
FX,K = Vk,K/~ax ,K
has
Any proper submodule
M
The irreducible module
where
VX, K
p = char. K.
is generated by
since it does not contain
lie in
~ax ,K "
fg,
a proper
Z Vk,K, ask
sum of all proper submodules
M
f&.
has
M k= M N VX, K = 0,
K-subspace of of
and is the unique maximal submodule
VX, K
V~, K.
lies in
V',
hence is proper,
and does not contain
Since
DX, K
is dual to
VX, K
VX, K
M
Therefore the
third statement in (5.4b) now follows from the definition of (see 3.5, Remark (i)) and the fact that kI kn ~k = XI ... Xn + . . . .
and so
of
f~.
The
~k,p
has character
we have the following corollary to
(5.4b).
(5.4c) Hence
Dk, K
has a unique minimal submodule
minK , FX, K D~,
_min uk, K
and
min Dk, K
~
(Fk,K)°.
are isomorphic modules.
Proof.
The second statement follows from the first, and the fact that any
module
V
V°
in
~k(n,r)
(see (3.3e)).
If
has the same character as its (contravariant) dual V
is irreducible
this implies
V ~ V °.
72
Remark
Since
Fk, K
same is true of
has
minK . Dk,
k-weight space of dimension minK Dk,
Therefore
SK(n,r)-module
by, the element
k-weight-space
of
DX, K
is
1
(by (5.4c))
the
contains, hence is generated as
(Tg : Tg).
For (4.7a) shows that the
K (T~ : T~).
This proves (5.4d) below.
A
quite different proof comes from a standard argument for semisimple algebraic groups, using the fact (cf. 4.8) that the action of the upper and lower unipotent F = GL (K). n (5.4d)
(T~ : Tg)
of
@r V~,Q = {x ( EQ : < x, NQ > 0},
Vk, Z = E~Z
Lemma.
(i)
bi,Q
~r EZ ,
The sets
=
Vk, Z.
Vk, Z.
It
Vk, Q
is defined over
NO = Ker
is a
that,
lies in
Since (i) is a Q-basis of
Z-form of
Since
j ~ I(n,r).
Take any
t h e p r o o f of
(5.3b)
j gives
Ti .
(see 5.1).
it has
Vk, Q.
<x,
Sz(n,r) ,
i 6 I(n,r),
(by (5.3b)), the proof of (5.4e)
we have T. J
Z-basis
hence that (i) is a subset of
x = ~k.b. ll
such that
Recall that
standard}
every element
x E E~r Z ,
~
the standard
~r,
We certainly have
k.1 ~ Q"
Ti
for each
Vk, Q
be a c h i e v e d i f we show t h a t
some
~Q
Z.
are both closed to the action of
is clear
~i,~ e~,Q{C(T)}
Z-span of (i). for
Vk, K
where
N Vk, Q
generates the irreducible module DX, K .
{bi, Q : i E l(n,r),
hence so is
will
triangular subgroups of
min
Dk, K
We show next that the family
Proof.
is stable under
See [St. p. 214].
The element
(5.4e)
(Tg : Tg)
is
x ( Vk, Z
is
(sum is over <x,
ej>
standard.
e.> = ~k. !,~ ( i , j ) , j 1
6
in the
Ti Z
standard)
for all
The c a l c u l a t i o n t h e sum b e i n g o v e r
s
But t h e " D e s a r m e n i e n m a t r i x "
~ = ~(i,j)),
in case
in
73
K = Q,
is integral and unimodular.
standard
Remark
E~;
Tj) follows
(5.4e) shows that
hence the inclusion
0 ~ l~, Z ~ EZ ~
in the category EZ~ ® K.
8K
(5.4f)
described.
as submodule of {EK ~}
is
Z-defined
From (5.4e) and (5.3b) it is
induces an isomorphism
bi, Q ® IK~
The family
If we tensor with
0 ~ V~, Z ~ K ~ E~r ~ K
VX, z ~ K
6 K : el, Q ® 1 K ~ el, K.
Z-submodule of
Z-split.
we showed that the family
8~ : Vk,Z®
which maps
is
We shall regard
In 2.6, Example 1
immediate that
Uence (5.4e) is proved.
is a pure
we get an exact sequence
MK(n,r ).
E~ ~r and maps
Ti).
(all
VX, Z = Sz(n,r)f ~.
Vk, Z = E~ r n VX,Q
K
~k i ~ (i,j) ~ Z
(all standard
It is clear that
any infinite field
by
ki ~ Z
So from
bi, K
{Vk, K } is
for all
K -+ VX, K.
i E I(n,r).
Z-defined by
The family of inclusions
So is the family of contravariant
Vk, Z
VX, K ~+ E ~r K
forms
From all this we deduce:
and the maps
6'K just
is also defined over
(')K : VX,K x Dk, K -+ K
Z.
defined in
5.1.
5.5
Contravariant
forms on
J.C. Jantzen (see
V%, K
~], CJ'] ....
)
has studied contravariant forms
on the Weyl modules for a simply-connected,
semisimple algebraic group;
particular,
SLn(K)
his results apply to the group
alteration to our case
F = GL (K) . n
,
in
and extend with little
In this section we shall give an
independent description of the contravariant
forms on the modules
V%, K .
74
We saw that element
is generated
f~ = e~{C(T)}
in the submodule form
V%, K
< , >
on
(5.5a)
of
E mr ,
Emr{C(T)} E mr ,
of
as
S(= SK(n,r))-module
and it follows
E mr
that
by the
VI, K
is contained
We have the canonical
and from (5.2c) we deduce
<x{C(T) }, y> = <x, y{C(T)}>
This allows us to define a "contracted"
contravariant
that
for all
v e r s i o n of
x, y g E mr
< , >
on
Emr{C(T)}
by
the rule
(5.5b)
If
x, y e E ~r ,
define
<<x{C(T)},
y{C(T)} >> = <x, y{C(T)} >
Any ambiguity
arising
from the fact that an element
expressed
x{C(T)}
= x'{C(T)}
as
is eliminated
by (5.5a).
contravariant
form on
symmetric, rule
(5.5b) gives
We might
also m e n t i o n
form on
If we restrict
V%, K ,
=
of
E mr ,
is a symmetric, it to
V%, K
which is moreover
= <e~,e~{C(T)}>
fields
x, x'
may be
~ s(o) oEC(T) << ' >>K '
K , is defined over
Z
we get a
non-zero,
<e~,e~o>
since
= 1
constructed
in
in the sense of
3.
Any contravariant factor, with
.
<< , >>
that the family of forms
this way for all infinite 2.7, Example
It is clear that
<>
Emr{C(T)}
for distinct elements
Emr{C(T)}
contravariant
of
<< , >> .
form
(
,
)
on
V%, K
For the contravariant
coincides, property
up to a scalar
(2.7d),
together with
75
the fact that values
VX, K = Sf~ ,
shows that
(f~,v) , v E VX, K .
with each
v
If
(
,
v s V%, K
)
is
determined by the
is decomposed as sum
belonging to the weight space
V%, K~
v = Ev~ ,
(~ c A(n,r)) ,
then
since weight spaces for distinct weights are orthogonal with respect to (
,
)
(see 3.4),
by the values space is
(f%,v)
K.f%
for
(f~,v) = (f~,vx) , v
(see 5.4a).
Therefore (since for all
we have
in the So
(
<> = i)
i.e.
%-weight space
,
if
)
(
,
)
x VX, K .
is determined
But this weight
is completely determined by (f~,f%) •
(f~,f%) = k ,
then
(v,w) = k<> ,
v,w e VX, K o
In the work of Jantzen which we have mentioned, and also in the earlier work of W.J~ Wong ([W],[W']) , a Weyl module submodule
(5.5c) space
(~W',
of
V .
In our case the result reads as follows.
Theorem 3B, p.362~).
M = {v g VX, K : <
M
M # V%, K , of
is that it provides a method of calculating the maximal
Vmax
submodule
Proof.
V
V%, K (~ ~ X)
of
I,K
since
The radical of
>>= O}
<< , >> ,
i,e.
coincides with the unique maximal
f% ~ax ,K
Since
M .
V~, K
by the contravariant property.
Therefore
M £~%ax -
lies in the sum V'
V'
is orthogonal to
.
v~%ax lies in ,K
M
Also
But we saw in the proof
,K
of all the weight-spaces X VX, K = K.f~ ,
we have
(~ax VX,K ) = <
the
V%, K .
is a submodule of
(5.4b) that
the importance of the contravariant form on
and the proof of (5.5c) is complete.
76
Example.
We shall calculate
of 5.2, Example
i).
one row, and so
Since
the form
I = (r,O,.,.,O),
C(T) = {i} .
to
Vr, K
of the canonical
{v
: ~ e A(n,r)}
and
< , >
E ~r .
form
Since
(r,~)
maxK , M = Vr,
1
has only
is just the restriction to the basis
I, the form is given by where
r~ f
C~n -
of this form is spanned by those
the integer
(notation
Relative
= (r,~).l K ,
C~I . . . .
divides
on
Vr, K
the diagram of
<< , >>
(r, ~)
M
on
Therefore,
given in 5.2, Example
= O (e # B)
So the radical
<< , >>
v
p = char K
for which
.
the irreducible
module
F r , K = V r,~~/vma~ r,~
(see
(5.4b)) has basis
(v
The
a-weight
the character with
(r,e)
+ M : ~ s A(n,r),
space of
Fr, K
of
is
Fr, K
~ O mod p .
~r,p
expansion
(5.5d)
(XI+°..+Xn)r
is
~
r,p
~ 0 m o d p} .
K . ( v ~ + M) =
IX ~ 1
°'°
Since the integers
the multinomial
we have the result:
is
(r,~)
=
~ esA(n,r)
,
for all
x~n n
(r,~)
~i
(r,~)X 1
(which is a polynomial
t h e sum o f t h o s e m o n o m i a l s
X l l ' " .xan n
'
e e A(n,r)
sum over all
.
Hence
~ e A(n,r)
are the coefficients
in
~n
... X n
over
Z ,
which have non-zero
by definition)
coefficients
77
when
(5.5d) is reduced mod
p .
The reader may deduce
case of Steinberg's
"Tensor Product T h e o r e m " ( ~ t ,
r = r0 + r l P
(O < ro,rl,... , ! p - l )
+ ...
i ~r,p(Xl,...,Xn) M = 0
=
symmetric
5.6
function"
Z-forms
of
Fr, 0 = Vr, K .
h =r
and
~ ~eA(n,r)
Of course in case
The character
X ~ (~i, p.14])
p = 0
is the "complete
.
V%,Q
D%,Q
are irreducible, mr
~Q : EQ
In fact the map
isomorphism.
: if
then
In this section we work over the rational V%,Q
p.218])
i
E ~ri,p(X ~ ...,X p ) . i>O ' n
and we can take
from this a special
For
~
÷ DX,Q
is certainly
field
Q .
The modules
and isomorphic
to each other
i n d u c e s a map
~:Vx,Q ~ DX, Q
a homomorphism, and i t
(see 5.1).
w h i c h i s an
is non-zero
because
(5.6a)
~(f ) =
Therefore
by Schur's
We would Z-form
Z ocC(T)
L ,
a
the argument
L % = Z. Yfz
Z-form of
essential
lemma
V%,Q
for some ,
and
the Z-forms
(since
lying in
V%,Q = Q'fz
O # y ~ Q .
(y-IL)% = Z . f
if we confine our attention
"normalized"
s(o)(T~:Tzo)
=
V%,Q
at the end of 3.3 shows that
of rank 1 '
Z oEC(T)
IC(T) I(T%:T%)
•
~ is an isomorphism.
like to describe
a free Z-submodule that
s(o) %(e%o ) =
by the condition
to
.
For any such
L % = L ~V~,Q
has dimension
It is clear that .
Therefore
Z-forms
L
i),
y-iL
is so is also
we shall lose nothing of
V%,Q
which are
78
(5.6b)
L % = Z.f
We already know two such normalized Sz(n,r).f %
Z-forms, namely
~r V%, Z = E Z {'~ V I , Q
=
(see (5.4e)), and
(5.6c)
XI, z = g-l(ic(T ) IDI,z) .
XI, Z
is a Z-form of
is a
Z-form of
VI,Q , because
DI,Q •
DI, Z
-
hence also
IC(T) IDI,Z
-
It is normalized, because
XI,ZI = ~-I(Ic(T) ID%I,Z) = %-I(z. IC(T) l.(r :T~)) = Z.f% , by (4.7c) and (5.6a).
Our aim is the following theorem.
(5.6d) ~
Verma IV, p.681]). Then
Proof.
contain
write
SZ
L
for
f% ,
Sz(n,r) ).
spaces
La
for
Z-form of
V%,Q
which
it contains
Sz.f ~ = V%, Z
(we shall
<> = <>
using the contravariant property of
SzL ~ L . ~ ~ I .
be any
On the other hand
= <<SzL,f~>> ~ <> , and the fact that
L
Vk, Z C_ L c_ X%, Z .
satisfies (5.6b).
Since
Let
So
But
f%
<< , >>
is orthogonal to all the weight
<> = <> = <>
= Z<> = Z . We have hereby proved that
L
Y%,Z = {y ~ V%,Q : <> ~C Z}
lies in the set
79
So it will'be
enough
to prove
follows
from the argument
let
be any element
z
DX, Q
~(z)
.~ kj 3
=
the sum being over
just given,
of
Y%,Z
"
taking
Using
That
X%,Z ~ Y % , z
L = X%, Z .
the basis
Conversely
theorem
(4.5a) for
Q .
Because
IC(T)I(T%:Tj) ,
j e I(n,r) z e YI,Z
such that
Our definition the case
is standard;
the
k. J
lie
(5.5b) gives
e Z ,
for all
a particularly
simple
i e I(n,r)
formula
.
for
<<
,
>>
in
char K = O , namely 1 <> =IC(T-~
(5.6f)
For if
T. J
we have
<> = <> i i
by
Y%,Z = X%,Z
we may write
(5.6e)
in
that
u = x{C(T)}
(5.2c),
following
(5.6g)
{C(T)} 2 =
for all
u, v E EmriC(T) j "- -~
as in (5.5b), we have
IC(T) I{C(T)}
.
We use
= <x,y{C(T)} 2>
(5.6f)
to
make
the
calculation:
<>
= I kj = E k. ~(i,j) J J J comes
of the D~sarm~nien T. , l
for all standard therefore
, v = y{C(T)}
and also
The last equality
standard
,
from the calculation
coefficient
~(i,j)
the unimodularity T. . J
the proof
Referring
of (5.6d)
.
preceding
Since
(5.6g)
of the Desarmenien to (5.6e),
is complete.
the definition lies in
matrix
this proves
Z
for all
shows that
that
(5.3d)
k° ~ Z J
z s X%, Z , and
5 The Carter-Lusztig modules Vλ,K
5.1 Definition of Vλ,K Let λ ∈ Λ+ (n, r) be given, and let K be any infinite field. Denote by NK ⊗r the kernel of the SK (n, r)-epimorphism ϕK : EK → Dλ,K defined in 4.4. We have then an exact sequence in MK (n, r) (5.1a)
ϕK
⊗r 0 −→ NK −→ EK −→ Dλ,K −→ 0.
Definition. Let Vλ,K be the orthogonal complement to NK , relative to the ⊗r (see 2.7, example 1): canonical form , on EK (5.1b)
⊗r Vλ,K = { x ∈ EK : x, NK = 0 }.
⊗r Since , is contravariant and NK is an SK (n, r)-submodule of EK , Vλ,K ⊗r is also a submodule of EK . Since , is non-singular, we may define a nonsingular, contravariant form ( , ) : Vλ,K × Dλ,K → K by ⊗r (x, ϕK (y)) = x, y , all x ∈ Vλ,K , y ∈ EK . ◦ Hence Vλ,K ∼ , and because (contravariant) dual modules in MK (n, r) = Dλ,K have the same character (by (3.3e)), ΦVλ,K = Sλ (X1 , . . . , Xn ). In particular, if char K = 0, then Vλ,K is irreducible, and is isomorphic to Dλ,K (see 4.7). If K has finite characteristic, then in general Vλ,K and Dλ,K are not isomorphic.
5.2 Vλ,K is Carter-Lusztig’s “Weyl module” λ
We shall identify Vλ,K with the module V defined by Carter and Lusztig in [6, pp. 211, 222]. First we must describe NK = Ker ϕK more exactly. ⊗r (5.2a) NK is the K-span of the subset R = R1 ∪ R2 ∪ R3 of EK , where
44
5 The Carter-Lusztig modules Vλ,K
(i) R1 consists of all ei such that i ∈ I(n, r) and Ti has equal entries in two different places in some column. (ii) R2 consists of all ei − s(σ)eiσ , where i ∈ I(n, r) and σ ∈ C(T ). (iii) R3 consists of all elements ν∈G(J) s(ν) eiν , where i ∈ I(n, r) and J is a non-empty subset of Ch+1 (T ) for some h ∈ {1, 2 . . . , r − 1}. Proof. All the elements of R lie in N = NK by (4.6b), and so N contains the K-span N of R. There is therefore a well-defined K-map ψ ⊗r ⊗r /N onto Dλ,K , given by ψ(x + N ) = ϕK (x), all x ∈ EK . Now from F = EK the function f : I(n, r) → F given by f (i) = ei + N clearly satisfies the hypotheses of (4.6a), hence F is K-spanned by the set { ei + N : Ti standard }. But ψ maps this set onto a basis of Dλ,K , by (4.5a). Therefore Ker ψ = 0, which implies N ⊆ N ; hence N = N , and (5.2a) is proved. As a corollary, we have ⊗r which satisfy the following (5.2b) Vλ,K is the set of all elements x ∈ EK conditions:
(i) x, ei = 0 for all i ∈ I(n, r) such that Ti has equal entries in two distinct places in the same column. (ii) xσ = s(σ) x for all σ ∈ C(T ). (iii) ν∈G(J) s(ν) xν −1 = 0 for any h ∈ {1, 2 . . . , r − 1} and any non-empty subset J of Ch+1 (T ). ⊗r such that x, Rs = 0 Proof. (5.2a) shows that Vλ,K consists of all x ∈ EK for s = 1, 2, 3. (5.2b) is an almost immediate consequence of this, together with the fact that , is non-singular, and satisfies an “invariance” condition
(5.2c)
xπ, y = x, yπ −1
⊗r , π ∈ G(r). This last condition is verified trivially from the for all x, y ∈ EK definition of , (see 2.7, example 1).
It is now easy to see that Vλ,K coincides with Carter-Lusztig’s “Weyl λ
module” V ; conditions (28), (29) of [6, p. 211] are essentially (i), (ii), (iii) of (5.2b). Example 1. If λ = (r, 0, . . . , 0) we write Vr,K for Vλ,K . Conditions (i) and (ii) of (5.2b) are vacuous. Condition (iii) says xν = x, for all transpositions ν = (h, h + 1) (h = 1, . . . , r − 1). So Vλ,K is the space of all symmetric ⊗r . Therefore this module is dual in the contravariant sense tensors x in EK th to the r symmetric power Dr,K of EK (see 4.4, example 1). Vr,K has basis { vα : α ∈ Λ(n, r) }, where vα = ei , sum over all i ∈ α. The non-singular contravariant form ( , ) : Vr,K ×Dr,K → K (see 5.1) is given by (vα , eβ ) = δα,β for all α, β ∈ Λ(n, r). Here eβ = eβ1 1 · · · eβnn , so that { eβ : β ∈ Λ(n, r) } is a basis of Dr,K .
5.3 The Carter-Lusztig basis for Vλ,K
45
Example 2. Assume r ≤ n and that λ = (1, . . . , 1, 0, . . . , 0) with r 1’s. We write V(1r ),K for Vλ,K . Condition (iii) of (5.2b) is vacuous, and conditions (i), (ii) show that V(1r ),K is the space of all antisymmetric tensors ⊗r in EK . V(1r ),K is an irreducible module in MK (n, r), whatever the characteristic of K, since its character er (X1 , . . . , Xn ) has no non-trivial expression as a sum of symmetric functions in Z[X1 , . . . , Xn ]. Therefore V(1r ),K is isomorphic to the rth exterior power D(1r ),K = Λr EK (see 4.4, example 2). There is an isomorphism Λr EK → V(1r ),K which takes (see 3.3) ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eir −→ (ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ eir ) s(π) π . π∈G
5.3 The Carter-Lusztig basis for Vλ,K Carter-Lusztig have given a basis for Vλ,K , and shown that Vλ,K is a cyclic module [6, pp. 216–219]. We shall give here a slightly different proof of these results. It is interesting that the Carter-Lusztig basis (see (5.3b)) is not the dual of the basis of Dλ,K given in (4.5a); these bases of Vλ,K are connected by a certain unimodular matrix Ω (see (5.3d)) which has appeared in work of D´esarm´enien [14, p. 74]. Notation. If X is any subset of the symmetric group G(r), we shall write π, {X} = s(π) π. [X] = π∈X
π∈X
These are elements of the group ring KG(r), of course. If K = Q, they even belong to ZG(r). (5.3a) Let l be the element of I(n, r) given in (4.3b). Then fl = el {C(T )} lies in Vλ,K . Proof. Verify that fl , y = 0, for all y ∈ R1 ∪ R2 ∪ R3 (see (5.2a)). For y ∈ R1 ∪ R2 there is no problem. Suppose then that y = ν∈G(J) s(ν) eiν , as in (5.2a)(iii). In the notation just introduced, this reads y = el {G(J)}. Using (5.2c),
el {C(T )}, ei {G(J)} = el , ei {B} , where B = G(J)C(T ) = Y · C(T )—see the proof of (4.6b). As in that proof, we break up B as a union of pairs {π, πκ}, each κ being a transposition in R(T ). Using (5.2c) again, and the fact that el κ = el , we have for each such pair el , ei (s(π)π + s(πκ)πκ) = 0. Therefore fl , y = 0, and this property completes the proof of (5.3a). Remark. The element fl is denoted by Φµ in [6, p. 216].
46
5 The Carter-Lusztig modules Vλ,K
Now let V be the SK (n, r)-submodule of Vλ,K which is generated by fl . As K-space, V is spanned by the elements ξi,j fl (i, j ∈ I(n, r)). However, since ξi,j fl = (ξi,j el ){C(T )}, we see by (2.6a) that ξi,j fl = 0 unless j ∼ l. Hence V is K-spanned by the elements bi = ξi,l fl (i ∈ I(n, r)). In fact we have the following much more precise statement. (5.3b) Theorem (see [6, Theorem 3.5, p. 218]). The set { bi = ξi,l fl : i ∈ I(n, r), Ti standard } is a K-basis of Vλ,K . In particular, V = Vλ,K , i.e. Vλ,K is generated by fl as SK (n, r)- (or KΓK -)module. Proof. Let i, j ∈ I(n, r). From (2.6a) we have (5.3c) ξi,l el = eh , h
where the sum is over all h ∈ I(n, r) such that (i, l) ∼ (h, l), i.e. such that there is some π ∈ G(r) with h = iπ, l = lπ. But l = lπ if and only if π ∈ R(T ) (see (4.3b)). So the sum in (5.3c) is over the R(T )-orbit iR(T ) of i. Now we bring in the form ( , ) : Vλ,K × Dλ,K → K introduced in 5.1, and calculate (bi , (Tl : Tj )) = bi , ej = ξi,l el {C(T )}, ej = ξi,l el , ej {C(T )} , using (5.2c) eh , s(σ)ejσ , using (5.3c). = h∈iR(T )
σ∈C(T )
This last expression, which we denote Ω(i, j), is equal to (5.3d) Ω(i, j) = s(σ), sum over all σ ∈ C(T ) such that jσ and i σ belong to the same R(T )-orbit. Now suppose Ti , Tj are both standard, and that Ω(i, j) = 0. There must exist σ ∈ C(T ) such that jσ and i are in the same R(T )-orbit. If σ = 1, this implies i = j. In any case we have β(i) = β(jσ) (see 4.5), and if σ = 1 then (4.5d) implies β(jσ) > β(j). Let Ω denote the matrix (Ω(i, j)), with i and j running over the set I ∗ = { k ∈ I(n, r) : Tk standard }. If we give I ∗ any total order > such that β(i) > β(j) implies i > j for all i, j ∈ I ∗ , then Ω is a unimodular triangular matrix. For by what we have shown above, Ω(i, j) = 0 implies either i > j or i = j, and clearly Ω(i, i) = 1. Hence Ω is non-singular. But since Ω(i, j) = (bi , (Tl : Tj )), and since ( , ) is non-singular and { (Tl : Tj ) : Tj standard } is a basis of Dλ,K , it follows that { bi : Ti standard } is a basis of Vλ,K . This proves (5.3b). Note. A proof that Ω is unimodular is given by D´esarm´enien in [14, p. 74].
5.4 Some consequences of the basis theorem
47
5.4 Some consequences of the basis theorem For each i ∈ I(n, r), it is clear by (2.3c) that the element bi = ξi,l fl satisα , where α is the weight of i. From (5.3b) we fies ξi,i bi = bi ; thus bi ∈ Vλ,K deduce α (5.4a) Let α ∈ Λ(n, r). Then Vλ,K has K-basis { bi : i ∈ α, Ti standard }. λ = K ·fl (since bl = ξl,l fl = fl ). A well-known argument In particular, Vλ,K (see e.g. [31, p. 2]) shows max
(5.4b) Vλ,K has a unique maximal submodule Vλ,K . The element fl does not max max lie in Vλ,K . The irreducible module Fλ,K = Vλ,K /Vλ,K has character Φλ,p , where p = char K. Proof. By (5.3b) Vλ,K is generated by fl . Any proper submodule M of Vλ,K , λ = 0, and so M lies in since it does not contain fl , has M λ = M ∩ Vλ,K V =
α Vλ,K ,
α=λ
a proper K-subspace of Vλ,K . Therefore the sum of all proper submodules M max of Vλ,K lies in V , hence is proper, and is the unique maximal submodule Vλ,K , and does not contain fl . The third statement in (5.4b) now follows from the definition of Φλ,p (see 3.5, Remark (i)) and the fact that Vλ,K has character Sλ = X1λ1 · · · Xnλn + · · · . Since Dλ,K is dual to Vλ,K , we have the following corollary to (5.4b). min min (5.4c) Dλ,K has a unique minimal submodule Dλ,K , and Dλ,K ∼ = (Fλ,K )◦ . min Hence Dλ,K , Fλ,K are isomorphic modules.
Proof. The second statement follows from the first, and the fact that any module V in MK (n, r) has the same character as its (contravariant) dual V ◦ (see (3.3e)). If V is irreducible this implies V ∼ = V ◦. Remark. Since Fλ,K has λ-weight-space of dimension 1 (by (5.4b)) the same min min is true of Dλ,K . Therefore Dλ,K contains, hence is generated as SK (n, r)module by, the element (Tl : Tl ). For (4.7a) shows that the λ-weight-space of Dλ,K is K · (Tl : Tl ). This proves (5.4d) below. A quite different proof comes from a standard argument for semisimple algebraic groups, using the fact (cf. 4.8) that (Tl : Tl ) is stable under the action of upper and lower unipotent triangular subgroups of Γ = GLn (K). See [50, p. 214]. min
(5.4d) The element (Tl : Tl ) of Dλ,K generates the irreducible module Dλ,K . We show next that the family Vλ,K is defined over Z. Recall from 5.1 that Vλ,Q = { x ∈ EQ⊗r : x, NQ = 0 }, where NQ = Ker ϕQ .
48
5 The Carter-Lusztig modules Vλ,K
(5.4e) Lemma. Vλ,Z = EZ⊗r ∩ Vλ,Q is a Z-form of Vλ,Q . It has Z-basis B = { bi,Q : i ∈ I(n, r), Ti standard }. Proof. The sets EZ⊗r , Vλ,Q are both closed to the action of SZ (n, r), hence so is Vλ,Z . It is clear that, for each i ∈ I(n, r), bi,Q = ξi,l el,Q {C(T )} lies in EZ⊗r , hence that B is a subset of Vλ,Z . Since B is a Q-basis of Vλ,Q (by (5.3b)), the proof of (5.4e) will be achieved if we show that every element x ∈ Vλ,Z is in the Z-span of B. We certainly have x = ki bi (sum is over Ti standard) for some ki ∈ Q. Since x ∈ EZ⊗r , we have x, ej ∈ Z for all j ∈ I(n, r). Take any j such that Tj is standard. The calculation in the proof of (5.3b) ki Ω(i, j), the sum being over the standard Ti . But the gives x, ej = “D´esarm´enienmatrix” Ω = (Ω(i, j)), in case K = Q, is integral and unimodular. So from ki Ω(i, j) ∈ Z (all standard Tj ) follows ki ∈ Z (all standard Ti ). Hence (5.4e) is proved. Remark. (5.4e) shows that Vλ,Z = SZ (n, r)fl . It is clear that Vλ,Z = EZ⊗r ∩ Vλ,Q is a pure Z-submodule of EZ⊗r ; hence that the inclusion 0 → Vλ,Z → EZ⊗r is Z-split. If we tensor with any infinite field K we get an exact sequence 0 → Vλ,Z ⊗ K → EZ⊗r ⊗ K in the category MK (n, r). We shall regard Vλ,Z ⊗ K as submodule of EZ⊗r ⊗ K. ⊗r } is Z-defined by EZ⊗r and In 2.6, example 1 we showed that the family {EK maps δK : ei,Q ⊗ 1K → ei,K . From (5.4e) and (5.3b) it is immediate that δK induces an isomorphism δK : Vλ,Z ⊗ K → Vλ,K ,
which maps bi,Q ⊗ 1K → bi,K for all i ∈ I(n, r). From all this we deduce: (5.4f ) The family {Vλ,K } is Z-defined by Vλ,Z and the maps δK just de⊗r scribed. The family of inclusions Vλ,K → EK is also defined over Z. So is the family of contravariant forms ( , )K : Vλ,K × Dλ,K → K defined in 5.1.
5.5 Contravariant forms on Vλ,K J.C. Jantzen (see [29], [32], ...) has studied contravariant forms on the Weyl modules for a simply-connected, semisimple algebraic group; in particular, his results apply to the group SLn (K), and extend with little alteration to our case Γ = GLn (K). In this section we shall give an independent description of the contravariant forms on the modules Vλ,K . We saw that Vλ,K is generated as S (= SK (n, r))-module by the element fl = el {C(T )} of E ⊗r , and it follows that Vλ,K is contained in the submodule E ⊗r {C(T )} of E ⊗r . We have the canonical contravariant form , on E ⊗r , and from (5.2c) we deduce that
5.5 Contravariant forms on Vλ,K
(5.5a)
49
x{C(T )}, y = x, y{C(T )} for all x, y ∈ E ⊗r .
This allows us to define a “contracted” version of , on E ⊗r {C(T )} by the rule (5.5b) If x, y ∈ E ⊗r , define
x{C(T )}, y{C(T )} = x, y{C(T )} . Any ambiguity arising from the fact that an element of E ⊗r {C(T )} may be expressed as x{C(T )} = x {C(T )} for distinct elements x, x of E ⊗r , is eliminated by (5.5a). It is clear that
, is a symmetric, contravariant form on E ⊗r {C(T )}. If we restrict it to Vλ,K , we get a symmetric, contravariant form on Vλ,K , which is moreover non-zero, since rule (5.5b) gives
fl , fl = el , el {C(T )} = s(σ) el , elσ = 1. σ∈C(T )
We might also mention that the family of forms
, K , constructed in this way for all infinite fields K, is defined over Z in the sense of 2.7, example 3. Any contravariant form ( , ) on Vλ,K coincides, up to a scalar factor, with
, . For the contravariant property (2.7d), together with the fact by the values (fl , v), v ∈ Vλ,K . that Vλ,K = Sfl , shows that ( , ) is determined vα , with each vα belonging to the If v ∈ Vλ,K is decomposed as a sum v = α (α ∈ Λ(n, r)), then since weight-spaces for distinct weights weight-space Vλ,K are orthogonal with respect to ( , ) (see 3.3, p. 25), we have (fl , v) = (fl , vλ ), i.e. ( , ) is determined by the values (fl , v) for all v in the λ-weightλ . But this weight-space is K · fl (see (5.4a)). So ( , ) is comspace Vλ,K pletely determined by (fl , fl ). Therefore (since
fl , fl = 1) if (fl , fl ) = k, then (v, w) = k
v, w , for all v, w ∈ Vλ,K . In the work of Jantzen which we have mentioned, and also in the earlier work of W.J. Wong [56, 57], the importance of the contravariant form on a Weyl module V is that it provides a method of calculating the maximal max of V . In our case the result reads as follows. submodule V (5.5c) [57, Theorem 3B, p. 362]. The radical of
, , that is, the space M = { v ∈ Vλ,K :
v, Vλ,K = 0 }, coincides with the unique maximal max submodule Vλ,K of Vλ,K . Proof. Notice that M is a submodule of Vλ,K , by the contravariant property. max / M . Therefore M ⊆ Vλ,K . But we saw in the proof Also M = Vλ,K , since fl ∈ max α (α = λ). of (5.4b) that Vλ,K lies in the sum V of all weight-spaces Vλ,K λ Since V is orthogonal to Vλ,K = K · fl , we have (Vλ,K , Vλ,K ) =
Vλ,K , Sfl ⊆
SVλ,K , fl ⊆
V , fl = 0. max
max
max
max
This shows that Vλ,K lies in M , and the proof of (5.5c) is complete.
50
5 The Carter-Lusztig modules Vλ,K
Example. We shall calculate the form
, on Vr,K (notation of 5.2, example 1). Since λ = (r, 0, . . . , 0), the diagram of λ has only one row, and so C(T ) = {1}. Therefore,
, is just the restriction to Vr,K of the canonical form , on E ⊗r . Relative to the basis { vα : α ∈ Λ(n, r) } given in 5.2, example 1, the form is given by vα , vβ = 0 (α = β) and vα , vα = (r, α)·1K , where r! . (r, α) = α1 ! · · · αn ! So the radical M of this form is spanned by those vα for which p = char K divides the integer (r, α). max max Since M = Vr,K , the irreducible module Fr,K = Vr,K /Vr,K (see (5.4b)) has basis { vα + M : α ∈ Λ(n, r), (r, α) ≡ 0 modulo p }. The α-weight-space of Fr,K is K ·(vα +M ), for all α ∈ Λ(n, r). Hence the charX1α1 · · · Xnαn , sum over all α ∈ Λ(n, r) with (r, α) ≡ 0 acter of Fr,K is Φr,p = modulo p. Since the integers (r, α) are the coefficients in the multinomial expansion (5.5d) (X1 + · · · + Xn )r = (r, α) X1α1 · · · Xnαn , α∈Λ(n,r)
we have the result: Φr,p (which is a polynomial over Z, by definition) is the sum of those monomials X1α1 · · · Xnαn which have non-zero coefficients when (5.5d) is reduced modulo p. The reader may deduce from this a special case of Steinberg’s “Tensor Product Theorem” [50, p. 218]: If 0 ≤ r0 , r1 , . . . ≤ p − 1 such that r = r0 + r1 p + · · · , then
i i Φr,p (X1 , . . . , Xn ) = Φri ,p (X1p , . . . , Xnp ). i≥0
Of course in case p = 0, M = 0 and we can take Fr,0 = Vr,K . The character is the “complete symmetric function” hr = α∈Λ(n,r) X α (see [39, p. 14]).
5.6 Z-forms of Vλ,K In this section we work over the rational field Q. We have seen in 5.1 that the modules Vλ,Q and Dλ,Q are irreducible, and isomorphic to each other. In fact the map ϕQ : EQ⊗r → Dλ,Q induces a map ϕ : Vλ,Q → Dλ,Q which is an isomorphism. For ϕ is certainly a homomorphism, and it is non-zero because (5.6a) ϕ(fl ) = s(σ) ϕ(elσ ) = s(σ) (Tl : Tlσ ) = |C(T )| (Tl : Tl ). σ∈C(T )
σ∈C(T )
5.6 Z-forms of Vλ,K
51
Therefore by Schur’s lemma ϕ is an isomorphism. We would like to describe all the Z-forms lying in Vλ,Q . If L is any λ such Z-form, then the argument at the end of 3.3 shows that Lλ = L ∩ Vλ,Q λ is a free Z-submodule of rank 1 (since Vλ,Q = Q · fl has dimension 1), so that Lλ = Z · yfl , for some 0 = y ∈ Q. It is clear that y −1 L is also a Z-form of Vλ,Q , and (y −1 L)λ = Z · fl . Therefore we shall lose nothing essential if we confine our attention to Z-forms L of Vλ,Q which are “normalized” by the condition (5.6b)
Lλ = Z · fl .
We already know two such normalized Z-forms, namely Vλ,Z = E ⊗r ∩ Vλ,Q = SZ (n, r) · fl (see (5.4e)), and (5.6c)
Xλ,Z = ϕ−1 ( |C(T )| Dλ,Z ).
Xλ,Z is a Z-form of Vλ,Q , because Dλ,Z —hence also |C(T )| Dλ,Z —is a Z-form of Dλ,Q . It is normalized, because λ λ = ϕ−1 ( |C(T )| Dλ,Z ) = ϕ−1 (Z · |C(T )| · (Tl : Tl )) = Z · fl , Xλ,Z
by (4.7c) and (5.6a). Our aim is the following theorem. (5.6d) (cf. [53, p. 681]). Let L be any Z-form of Vλ,Q which satisfies (5.6b). Then Vλ,Z ⊆ L ⊆ Xλ,Z . Proof. We write SZ = SZ (n, r). Since L contains fl , it contains SZ · fl = Vλ,Z . On the other hand
L, Vλ,Z =
L, SZ · fl =
SZ L, fl ⊆
L, fl , using the contravariant property of
, and the fact that SZ L ⊆ L. But we know that fl is orthogonal to all the weight spaces Lα for α = λ. It follows that
L, fl =
Lλ , fl =
Z·fl , fl = Z·
fl , fl = Z. We have hereby proved that L lies in the set Yλ,Z = { y ∈ Vλ,Q :
y, Vλ,Z ⊆ Z }. So it will be enough to prove that Yλ,Z = Xλ,Z . That Xλ,Z ⊆ Yλ,Z follows from the argument just given, taking L = Xλ,Z . Conversely let z be any element of Yλ,Z . Using the basis theorem (4.5a) for Dλ,Q we may write kj |C(T )| (Tl : Tj ), (5.6e) ϕ(z) = j
the sum being over j ∈ I(n, r) such that Tj is standard; the kj lie in Q. Because z ∈ Yλ,Z we have
bi , z =
z, bi ∈ Z, for all i ∈ I(n, r). Our definition (5.5b) gives a particularly simple formula for
, in the case char K = 0, namely
52
(5.6f )
5 The Carter-Lusztig modules Vλ,K
u, v =
1
u, v , for all u, v ∈ E ⊗r {C(T )}. |C(T )|
For if u = x{C(T )}, v = y{C(T )} as in (5.5b), then u, v = x, y {C(T )}2 by (5.2c), and also {C(T )}2 = |C(T )| {C(T )}. We use (5.6f) to make the following calculation: (5.6g)
bi , z = kj bi , ϕ−1 (Tl : Tj ) = kj Ω(i, j). j
j
The last equality comes from the calculation preceding the definition (5.3d) of the D´esarm´enien coefficient Ω(i, j). Since (5.6g) lies in Z for all standard Ti , the unimodularity of the D´esarm´enien matrix shows that kj ∈ Z for all standard Tj . Referring to (5.6e), this proves that z ∈ Xλ,Z , and therefore the proof of (5.6d) is complete.
§6.
Representation
6.1
The functor
theory of the s y ~ e t r i c
f:~(n,r)
÷ mod KG(r)
group
(r i n )
In this chapter we shall apply our results on the representations FK = GLn(K) , to the representation G(r)
.
IS] . in
The method is to use a process Suppose first that
A(n,r)
;
u-weight
r
space
l's). V~
determines
ES, sections
in
a functor
III, IVy)
Then there exists a weight
~
(notice that
f:MK(n,r)
that in case MK(n,r)
K = ~
are completely
which uses another functor,
in
representation of
MK(n,r)
profitable
MK(n,r)
theory of
G(r)
the
The correspondence
Sehur proved
(see
n < r
by this means he showed that
The proof which we have given later proof in
by an argument
~(r,r)
to
~',
p.77])°
(Is, pp.61-63])
~(n,r)
.
This
6.5.
Of course Schur used his functor about
.
,
hence are determined up to
Schur's
this time from
second functor will be described
;
~ , p.35].
handle the case
V s MK(n,r)
n ,
this funetor gives an equivalence
reducible,
(see
(I,I ..... 1,0 ..... O)
is a vector of length
KG(r)-module.
KG(r)
of this fact, see (2.6e), is essentially
make deductions
~
÷ mod KG(r)
and mod
isomorphism by their characters
ThenSchur was able to
of the symmetric group
invented by Schur in his dissertation
can be regarded as a left
Mc(n,r)
K
We shall see that for any module
between the categories modules
r ! n .
we denote this by
and contains
V ÷ V~
theory over
of
f ,
and its "inverse"
(see 6.2), to
his starting point was the known .
But since we have already got some knowledge
by the "combinatorial"
methods of §§4,5, it is also sometimes
to work in the other direction.
81
Let us keep Any m o d u l e
K, n, r
V ~ MK(n,r)
for any w e i g h t
fixed for the moment, can be r e g a r d e d as left
e ~ A(n,r)
regarded as left
and w r i t e
,
the w e i g h t - s p a c e
S(~)-module, w h e r e
S(e)
S = SK(n,r)
.
S-module, and therefore V~ = ~ V
(see 3.2) can be
denotes the algebra
~ S~
.
We
get then a functor
(6.1a)
f :M~(n,r) ÷ rood S(~)
w h i c h takes each 0:V + V'
in
S(~)
V s MK(n,r)
~(n,r)
is a
to
,
V ~ c mod S(~)
to its r e s t r i c t i o n
K-algebra with
$
,
and each m o r p h i s m
@~ :V ~ ÷ V ,~
as identity element.
If we choose some
G element
i e I(n,r)
(6. Ib)
w h i c h belongs
i = (i 1 ... 1 ~---~w- - ~
to
~ ,
2 2 ... 2 ~
for example
...
n n ... n)
w e m a y use the m u l t i p l i c a t i o n rules in 2.3 to show that as
K-space, b y the elements
~iz,i
follows that, for any elements if
~, ~'
' ~ c G .
~, 7'
of
is spanned,
F r o m the e q u a l i t y rule in 3.2
G ,
~iz,i = $i~',i
of
G .
So
S(~)
has
K-basis
if and only
{~i~,i } ,
over a set of r e p r e s e n t a t i v e s of the d o u b l e - c o s e t space
N o w suppose that
(6.1c)
S(~)
b e l o n g to the same double coset w i t h respect to the subgroup
G~ = {~ E G:i~ = i}
The e l e m e n t
,
r < n ,
and that
(6.1b) c o r r e s p o n d i n g to
u = (l,2,...,n)
Since the stabilizer in
G
e
e = ~
e
G~G
~
running
/G
is the w e i g h t d e s c r i b e d above. is w r i t t e n
l(n,r)
of this element is
.
G
= {I} ,
the algebra
82
S(~) has
K-basis
multiplication ~,~' in
{~u~,u : ~ c G} .
rule
G .
An elementary
(2.3b) shows that
We have therefore
application
~u~,u~u~,, u = g u ~ ' , u
an isomorphism
of
for all
of K-algebras
~
(6. Id)
S(~)
which takes isomorphism
~u~,u ÷ ~
KG(r)
for all
to be the functor
Hecke ring follows. set
K .
~(G,H) H(G,H)
H\G/H
By means of this
and mod KG(r)
can be identified.
the Schur functor
~, p.22~,
+ mod KG(r)
For the general case, where
over
.
f = f
with no restriction HK(G,G ~)
S(~)
we define
f:MK(n,r)
Remark.
~ ~ G = G(r)
the categories mod
With this identification
,
on
n, r)
S(~)
~
is any weight in
is isomorphic
We may follow Iwahori for any subgroup
has a free
Z-basis
of all double-cosets
of H
H
~,
A(n,r)
(and
to the Hecke ring
p.218~
and define the
of any finite group
as
{XA} ,
where
in
the product of elements
G;
A
G ,
runs over the in
this basis is given by
(6.1e)
where if Hv
XA XB =
¥
is any fixed element of
in the set
rule, see
~,
C g H\G/H
A-Iy ~ B . §~].
ZA'B'C XC '
C, ZA,B, C
(For an explanation
Alternatively
we may define
is the number of H-cosets of this artificial-looking ~(G,H)
to be the
83
e n d o m o r p h i s m ring of the subset r e g a r d e d as right
ZG-module.
Z G - e n d o m o r p h i s m of
EH]ZG
[H]ZG
HK(G,H)
R e t u r n i n g n o w to our case
6.2
~H]
(7 ~ G),
to
G = G(r)
becomes If
K
K-algebra
, H = G
,
the
is any
~(G,H)@ Z K .
we leave it as an
S(~) ÷ ~ K ( G , G )
is an i s o m o r p h i s m of
General theory of the functor
XA
~A] .)
to be the
prove that the K - l i n e a r map
~i~,i ÷ XG ~G
ZG , this subset b e i n g
In this i n t e r p r e t a t i o n
w h i c h takes
c o m m u t a t i v e ring, we define
exercise to
of
g i v e n by
K-algebras.
f:mod S + mod eSe
It soon becomes clear that m a n y p r o p e r t i e s of Schur's functor b e l o n g to a m u c h m o r e general context. need to be f i n i t e - d i m e n s i o n a l ) We define a functor the subspace
eV
E mod eSe .
If
f(0):eV ÷ eV' morphism.
of
Let
S
and let
be any e ¢ 0
K-algebra
be any idempotent in
f:mod S ÷ m o d eSe as follows. V
@:V ÷ V'
is an
eSe-module,
to be the r e s t r i c t i o n of
mod
@ ;
It is important to observe that
If
f
S ,
clearly
S .
V s m o d S , clearly
so we define
is a m o r p h i s m in