Primary Care Centres
This page intentionally left blank
Primary Care Centres a guide to health care design Second Edition
Geoffrey Purves
OXFORD AMSTERDAM BOSTON LONDON NEW YORK PARIS SAN DIEGO SAN FRANCISCO SINGAPORE SYDNEY TOKYO
Architectural Press is an imprint of Elsevier
Architectural Press
Architectural Press is an imprint of Elsevier Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP, UK 30 Corporate Drive, Suite 400, Burlington, MA 01803, USA First edition 2002 Copyright © 2009, Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permission may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier website at http://elsevier.com/locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use of operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made British Library Cataloging in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress Library of Congress Control Number: 2009920711 ISBN-13: 978-0-7506-6696-1
For information on all Architectural Press publications visit our website at www.architecturalpress.com
Typeset by Macmillan Publishing Solutions www.macmillansolutions.com Printed and bound in Great Britain 09 10 11 12 13
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents Foreword
vii
Acknowledgements
viii
Executive summary
ix
Chapter 1
Introduction
1
Chapter 2
An outline review of the main issues (including a summary of the approach to designing health buildings)
5
Chapter 3
International comparisons
17
Chapter 4
Political framework
28
Chapter 5
Approach to briefing
35
Chapter 6
Design development/measurement of design quality
51
Chapter 7
Holistic care
73
Chapter 8
Art in health
79
Chapter 9
Case studies
83
Chapter 10
The next steps
168
Bibliography
175
Further reading
178
Acronyms
184
Appendix A: Colour images
185
Index
195
v
Case studies A. LIFT 1. Community Health Centre Purves Ash LLP
89
2. Conan Doyle Medical Centre Richard Murphy Architects
2. Vale Drive Primary Care Resource Centre Murphy Philipps Architects
128
94
3. Community Centre for Health, Partick Gareth Hoskins D. Community care centres 1. Grassroots in Memorial Park Eger Architects
134
3. Chelmsley Wood and Woodgate Valley Primary Care Centres One Creative Environments Ltd 4. The Vermuyden Centre PHS Architects B. Northern Ireland 1. The Bradbury Centre Penoyre & Prasad LLP with Todd Architects
97 101
110
2. The Arches Centre Penoyre & Prasad LLP
113
3. The Grove Well Being Centre Kennedy FitzGerald and Associates with Avanti Architects Limited
114
4. Portadown CCTC Avanti Architects Limited with Kennedy Fitzgerald and Associates
119
C. Scotland 1. Robin House Gareth Hoskins vi
122
126
2. The Oak Tree Centre macmon chartered architects
137
3. Washington Primary Care Centre PHS Architects
144
4. Rothbury Community Hospital Mackellar Architecture Limited
145
E. Special interest buildings 1. Clinical Education Centre Richard Murphy Architects
151
2. The Richard Desmond Children’s Eye Centre One Creative Environments Ltd
154
3. The Breast Care Centre, St Bartholomew’s Hospital Greenhill Jenner Architects
160
4. Kaleidoscope Children and Young People’s Centre 161 van Heyningen and Haward Architects
Foreword It is remarkable how rapidly thinking and development can advance in any specialty in just a few years. When the first edition of this book appeared, I noted that health care buildings needed to change and adapt to the changes in the way services were being delivered. They needed to present patients and the public with a new vision of health, in the same way that practitioners were trying to think more of the needs of the person behind an illness. This volume shows just how much has been accomplished and how experience from different parts of the country and the world can inspire and how practical learning can occur. I also noted that at the heart of all health service architectural developments a focus on patients and the staff involved needed to be retained, and that the architect was part of a large team with the vision of improving patient care and well-being. Once again, this is a key part of this book. My own interests in the arts and health are represented, reflecting again on an important development in patient care. This area has developed substantially over the last ten years with the visual arts and architecture becoming more
prominent. This, together with the chapter on holistic care, puts patients where they matter, at the centre of the process. The major case studies provide a rich seam to mine for reflection and fresh thinking. In the first edition, I also noted that as a schoolboy I had always wanted to be an architect, perhaps because Charles Rennie MacIntosh had been a pupil at the same school before me. If things had been different and I had chosen architecture as a profession, I hope I might have written such a book as this, bringing together as it does many of my own professional medical interests in patient care, the arts, and my passion for space and buildings. A few words from CRM say it all: Reason informed by emotion, expressed in beauty, elevated by earnestness, lightened by humour; that is the ideal that should guide all artists. Professor Sir Kenneth Calman Chancellor, University of Glasgow
vii
Acknowledgements Since Healthy Living Centres was published in 2002, many changes have occurred in the government’s approach to the provision of primary health care services. I am therefore pleased to have this opportunity to re-examine some of the issues which have emerged concerning the design of doctors’ surgeries, and the increasing demands placed on these buildings. Patients are increasingly seeing the provision of health care services from the point of view of being a consumer and are expecting higher standards of environmental design. My practice, Purves Ash LLP – a result of the merger of the Geoffrey Purves Partnership with David Ash Partnership in 2003 – has continued to work in the primary health care sector and I would like to thank my colleagues for their support. I have been able to draw on their ideas which has allowed me to develop my research and follow the changes in academic thinking as we have designed buildings using new procurement routes such as LIFT. Much of the new material for this book is also included in my PhD thesis “The Design of Primary Health Care Buildings” (awarded by Newcastle University, March 2009) and I would like to thank my supervisors Prof Andrew Ballantyne and Dr Peter Kellett for their guidance and helpful comments.
viii
The production of this book would not have been possible without the encouragement, support and tolerance of the editorial staff at Architectural Press. I would also like to thank Sharon Brown who has helped coordinate and check all the illustrations and copyright issues as well as spending many hours dealing with my revisions to the text. Every effort has been made to contact the copyright holders for their permission to reproduce material in this book. However, I would be grateful to hear from any copyright holder who is not acknowledged so that any errors or omissions can be corrected in any future editions of this book. This publication was completed at an exciting time for architecture in the health sector and I am sure that many opportunities will unfold during the next few years as new government policies give direction to procurement routes and the development of professional employment contracts with the medical profession. The case studies illustrate the high standard of work that can be achieved and I would like to thank all of the architects who have provided detailed information about their projects which are illustrated in this book. Finally, I would like to thank my wife, Ann, for her support and encouragement to complete this project.
Executive summary
Introduction
1
History can be written at any magnification. One can write the history of the universe on a single page, or the lifecycle of a mayfly in forty volumes. (Davies, 1997, p. 1) Norman Davies uses this description to justify his broad sweep of European history and offers an alternative approach to ‘the modern compulsion to know more and more about less and less’ (p. 1). This study of primary care health in the UK, its evolution and framework fills a slot at a particular time (2008) and seeks to explain the background, and highlight some influences during a number of key periods in history. It also identifies several factors and makes recommendations about how the design of primary health care buildings should be undertaken in the future, including how the medical profession should be engaged in that process. The specific contribution of this book lies in two areas of primary care architecture. 1. The importance of the brief in an architectural commission and the need to set out the ethos for design quality using tools such as design quality indicators and evidence-based design principles. 2. An examination of the procurement systems which need to become more flexible, with different structures of privately financed providers. This implies changes to the contractual employment conditions for doctors. The following summary of key factors includes issues identified by other research studies. The introductions and conclusions for each chapter more specifically set out my own findings.
Relationship between doctor and patient
From earliest times (before 3000 BC) the health and wellbeing of a person have been subject to a close relationship between two people – the patient and the doctor. This relationship can be traced through many civilisations and remains constant even as the development of knowledge about the body has increased. The Greeks paid close attention to the workings of the body as well as spiritual well-being. The Romans advanced aspects of care through the development of rest houses where the quality of life was seen as a vital component in recovery from ill health. These ideas continued to be refined in both the East and West with Islamic influences coming together with Renaissance intellectualism in Italy during the 15th and 16th centuries. Eighteenth-century Britain saw the development of wealth and civic responsibility evolve into charitable giving with the formation of the early hospitals in London and elsewhere in England. These well-meaning philanthropic ideals began to institutionalise health care, and although Florence Nightingale made huge strides by recognising some important issues in nursing standards the growth of Victorian Britain saw health care of variable quality. Technical standards in surgery gave rise to some barbaric practices. It was not until the early 20th century, when Lord Dawson attempted to focus attention again on primary care, and health services were provided within the community, that the significance of the patient as an individual was re-established. These far-reaching ideas were lost in the race to create the welfare state, a concept that was at the centre of political debate during the first half of the last century. The first 50 years of the NHS (the second half of the last century) saw the development of a bureaucratic system, dominated by the provision of health services for all, but implemented from the standpoint of the provider rather than the patient.
ix
Executive summary By the end of the 20th century the NHS was struggling to survive, unable to meet the escalating costs of medical care amidst a political climate of uncertainty about what to do next. The introduction of the NHS Plan 2000 was the beginning of a refocusing on patient-centred care and already (by 2008) the government is gaining confidence in promoting the ‘importance of patient power’ and showing increased confidence in being prepared to take on the entrenched attitudes of the medical profession. There is renewed interest in reestablishing a strong patient/doctor relationship as the core of medical care, but also a recognition that the quality of the environment and a sense of place are vital to provide a social framework in which individuals can thrive in terms of both mind and body. Conclusions 1.1 Everyone should have the freedom to choose their own doctor in the UK (or even in Europe and beyond). 1.2 Doctors should provide flexible services that are convenient for the patient (e.g. surgery hours should be appropriate to the locality). 1.3 Service standards should be comparable with other service industries (e.g. complaints procedures). 1.4 Patient care must be focused on giving priority to the patients’ needs (patient power). 1.5 The NHS should continue to develop electronic services for easy record-keeping and other communication systems and investigative procedures. 1.6 Primary care services should continue to be based in the community with specialist services based on locally accessible community hospitals.
2
Cultural issues
As with the patient/doctor relationship, issues of spirituality have been interwoven with health care from the earliest recorded times. Overlapping with religious principles, the concept of healing the soul has always remained an important component in the overall well-being of mankind. The Renaissance saw many strands of mental health coming together with recognition that the quality of the environment, and therefore architecture, played a significant role in creating human settlements that were conducive to good health. These philosophical strands extended to other disciplines including music and art. Some of these issues are understood by the briefing documentation prepared for the design of hospices. The brief for a hospice starts out with the objective of creating a place that is most calming to someone who is physically ill. The conventional approach to the design of NHS buildings, including doctors’ surgeries, has rarely recognised the significance of these factors.
x
Conclusions 2.1 The brief for a primary care health facility should adopt a holistic approach and should be cognisant of the benefits that art, music and good food can bring to a sense of well-being. 2.2 Mental well-being is about being content and a brief should be written that reflects this ethos. 2.3 A building should have a high-quality local environment. Not only should the internal spaces be designed for calmness and humanity but the external space and its relationship to the urban fabric of the neighbourhood should be accessible and welcoming. 2.4 A healthy place is somewhere people can enjoy living and can go about their daily lives free from stress; this leads to healthy lifestyles and healthy people. 2.5 Health care buildings should be integrated with the community. 2.6 Primary care buildings should contribute to a sense of place.
3 Therapeutic benefits Early civilisations understood in a largely non-scientific way that religious and spiritual issues were important to man’s well-being. This can be seen from the close relationship between a patient and their doctor, a pattern which can be traced over many centuries. As scientific knowledge increased, based on sound research, there was an increasing tendency to assume that health problems could be resolved by purely physical and technical interventions. From the Renaissance onwards, but particularly during the 19th century, medical practitioners became increasingly assertive on account of their technical expertise. This continued throughout the 20th century and until very recently the assumption was that medical advances would find solutions to all problems. Clearly, there are outstanding success stories which are continuing to unfold, such as the search for advanced techniques to treat all cancers, the latest DNA research and the possibility of genetic manipulation of the human body in a way which could not have been envisaged only a few years ago. The apparently exponential growth of scientific discovery is now balanced, however, by an understanding that we must look again at the provision of health care, how it is financed and the benefits that can be accrued from understanding some of the therapeutic benefits, physical and spiritual, known to the early civilisations. Therefore, architectural research into evidence-based design is giving substance and factual data to support the environmental benefits to which previous generations have responded intuitively.
Executive summary Conclusions
5
3.1 The ethos of buildings should be welcoming and friendly. 3.2 Lessons should be learnt from the design of hospices, particularly the way in which architectural briefs are written. 3.3 Therapeutic benefits – the technical solutions need to be incorporated into design solutions for such issues as good lighting, sound insulation, views to the natural world, and a wide range of other design issues leading to accessible and friendly environments. 3.4 The quality of life should be central to the brief of any primary care facility.
Architects should be given the opportunity to create places within the health sector by responding to local needs and with greater flexibility in setting briefs. They should be designing buildings for various organisations who have become additional providers of GP facilities in the UK. Doctors need to be made more accountable to the marketplace. There should be a change from the contractual relationship between the government and GPs with the introduction of flexible employment packages via other providers, although these must be controlled by the government. Patients should have a choice of GP, not just based on where they live, and the government should continue to develop community services as part of an integrated primary care package including doctors, ambulance services, paramedic services, nursing and mental health services. All of these services could be under the umbrella of community-based structures. The existing PCTs should be encouraged to develop their procurement policies to generate a variety of building types.
4
Architecture
The power of architecture to influence a person’s well-being has been recognised for centuries. The design of Egyptian temples was recognised as contributing to the spirituality of a place and the Greek and Roman civilisations clearly understood the beneficial effects of well-designed buildings as healthy places to live. More recently, the ability of architecture to contribute to a sense of well-being is known not only philosophically but also technically through the development of environmental standards for buildings. The brief is the starting-point for a well-designed building and for health care buildings the ethos must be set out if a successful building is to result. In the twentieth century, these ideas were recognised by Lord Dawson when he launched his ideas for health care buildings. Sadly, many of these concepts were lost after the NHS was set up, as bureaucratic systems and massive administrative structures were put into place to manage the nation’s health buildings estate.
Conclusions 4.1 Architects should have more training in health buildings. 4.2 The brief is crucially important and should set out the ethos for health buildings. 4.3 Architectural design should be driven by quality not function and cost. 4.4 The government should encourage and facilitate the procurement of buildings in the health sector from a range of other providers. 4.5 Private finance should be introduced to the provision of primary care buildings to a greater extent than exists at present. 4.6 Innovation should be encouraged so that different design ideas are explored depending on the scale of the building and its locality.
Professional services
Conclusions 5.1 Doctors should be exposed to the marketplace and understand that patients have the power to demand the service they require. This will give greater choice for patients, and lead to a wider range of types of service. A range of contractual arrangements covering the employment of doctors should be developed by the private sector. 5.2 These services should be available at times and in places convenient to patients, not just the doctors. 5.3 Individuals should be free to choose the type of GP service they require. For example, do they continue to use a traditional GP or would they prefer to use other providers such as supermarkets or other high street based providers? Alternatively, private GP services could also be available. 5.4 Architects should be encouraged to provide innovative design solutions for alternative providers. The government should ensure that procurement routes are simplified; for example, the current system of LIFT is causing substantial delays and delivering buildings very inefficiently. 5.5 The government should be more flexible in buying primary care health services. 5.6 Buildings should be designed to a high quality and this factor must come before functionality and cost.
Summary I would like to end this Executive Summary by identifying three key areas that should be considered when primary health care buildings are designed in the future.
xi
Executive summary 1 Political influences and the government’s role in shaping health policies in the future I have argued that the retention of the original NHS principles of free care available to all should remain the central tenet for government health policy in the UK. Elsewhere in the world (for example, in the USA) the escalating costs of an insurance-based national health structure are making it increasingly difficult to afford. The contractual arrangements between the government and GPs, however, do require further change. The government has introduced new contractual arrangements and is encouraging the creation of new primary care providers, but the power of the BMA should be reduced.
2
Patient power
The government is using the phrase ‘patient power’ and this reflects the increasing trend of patients wishing to access medical services as consumers in the market economy. This also is the way in which individuals access most other personal services. We can anticipate the evolution of new patterns of health care in the UK as more GP service providers
xii
enter the marketplace. New contractual arrangements for doctors should be encouraged. Greater patient freedom will also bring the need for greater personal responsibility and the government is introducing schemes to encourage selfhelp with appropriate guidance. The continuing development of electronic records will help to speed up this process.
3 The design of primary health care buildings With a range of providers, greater expectations of patients about the quality of buildings, and better briefs being given to architects, the range of health care buildings in the future should be more responsive to local needs. They will be responding to an increasing volume of evidence-based design criteria, which will bring therapeutic benefits to the buildings’ users. Increasingly, designers should look beyond the immediate constraints of the individual building to examine how a primary health care building fits into the urban environment. Government policy will encourage the cross-fertilisation of ideas between urban planning and the generation of healthy places. There will also be an increasing awareness that welldesigned places bring a sense of well-being for both mind and body.
1
Introduction Historically, there has been a long tradition of a strong relationship between patient and doctor. This evolved over an extended period from the care exercised in the mercy temples of early civilisations to the holistic treatments that were found in the monastic hospitals founded in the Middle Ages. The rapid advancement of knowledge, and its wide dissemination through the printed book invented during the Renaissance, saw the commencement of a scientific approach to medical treatment. By the mid 19th century there was a greater understanding of disease and Florence Nightingale introduced major changes in the way nursing was carried out. The Dawson Report (1920) advocated primary care policies based on local services by the GP. At the same time, political and social pressures led to the formation of the welfare state and the creation of the National Health Service (NHS) (1948). The Royal College of General Practitioners was not formed until 1952. General Practitioners (GPs) at that time (mid 20th century) did not have an influential position in the medical hierarchy. This developed into a pattern of control in the NHS which focused on ever more ambitious plans for large, technologically advanced hospitals during the second half of the 20th century. In turn, this culminated in the failure to deliver services on time and within budget giving rise to wide-ranging reviews on the structure of the NHS. In line with other major government spending (e.g. education) it became clear that tax revenues could not continue to rise indefinitely to service the ambitions of increasingly ambitious and technologically advanced hospitals. Due to financial pressures and social changes, giving more power to individuals as consumers, the NHS had to change to reflect these realities. Hence, private capital was introduced and health policies have been focused on providing patient focused care. Services are now examined in relation to convenience and the ability for medical care to be provided in the community. Community hospitals are being built reflecting considerable similarity to cottage hospitals, many of which were closed with great speed in the 1980s.
Ambulance services are also being redeployed on community needs and increasingly being linked to medical facilities (GP practices and community hospitals, particularly in rural areas) once again reflecting similarity to the recommendations of the Dawson Report of 1920. The advantages of a primary led health service are also reinforced by the successful policies found in developing countries. As young doctors have the means to work throughout the world often taking a ‘gap’ year before or after their medical training, they see the successful results of primary health care services operating in poor countries. The changing pattern of health care is beginning to re-establish the importance of the relationship between doctor and patient. Patient focused care returns power and influence to the individual who is able to exercise greater control over the medical interventions advocated for their body. Today, we are at an exciting point in the evolution of health care facilities with a wide diversity of options depending on a variety of political, social and economic pressures. However, each solution is striving to give appeal to the customer and with this comes the realisation that the medical facilities need to compete with each other in a market economy. The unexpected conclusion is that the NHS, although giving universal access to high quality medical services, did not provide a convenient or patient focused service. The government is grappling with the challenge of providing consistent and high quality technical competence, but in a manner which responds and reflects the needs and aspirations of the patient rather than the convenience of the medical and administrative staff of the NHS. The architectural design quality of new buildings is therefore of greater importance today than it has been for nearly a century. The therapeutic benefits of good design are now recognised in both the large hospitals under construction using the PFI (Private Finance Initiative) procurement route and the wider variety of small health buildings being procured using a variety of financial models.
1
Primary Care Centres The starting point for good architecture is always rooted in the quality of the brief. It has been said many times before, and in many different ways, but the time spent by an architect understanding the aspirations of a client, and thoroughly digesting the spatial requirements that a building is expected to meet, is invariably time well spent. This functional analysis will develop into the architectural form of a building reflecting the ethos of the client. The design must also be capable of being executed within the permitted budget. These three tenets underpin the philosophical expression of firmness, commodity and delight, which have been restated more recently as built quality, functionality and impact and are the bases of the design quality indicator (DQI). This methodology is part of the evaluation tool developed by CABE (Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment) to assess the design quality of a building. This is never more important than with health buildings. However, health building present a particularly complex set of relationships between the medical staff and the patients who visit the building because many will be anxious, or indeed stressed. This provides an opportunity for the therapeutic benefits of a high quality building to contribute to the sense of well-being sought after for patients. The first edition of this book, Healthy Living Centres, published in 2002 concentrated on the relationship between the architect and the doctor. This second edition develops these themes and reflects the rapidly changing climate in the procurement methods and attitudes towards primary health care buildings that have evolved and are continuing to change. In particular, the approach to primary health care buildings is more readily identified with community-based initiatives. The NHS Plan 2000 underpinned the political will to focus attention on patient centred care. The NHS Plan 2000 had also set a new agenda to reinvigorate the NHS service, not just in patient care, but also the government’s move to privatise investment in capital projects, which has changed the basis for financing new buildings. New primary care buildings involve a wide range of skills and activities and the solutions being designed include community uses. Indeed, primary care centres can be seen as community resource buildings, reflecting the demands of a particular locality in areas such as social services, related medical services such as physiotherapy, dentistry, podiatry and pharmacy as well as preventive health initiatives such as leisure and fitness clubs, cafés with healthy food options, libraries and computer centres. These activities place an emphasis on encouraging a healthy mind and body as well as providing diagnostic services for those people who have become ill. The government has provided additional finance, which in the financial year 2004–2005 reached £78 billion and is continuing to climb. By 2008 the annual expenditure had exceeded £100 billion. Contraindications, which make the advances in health care more demanding, are linked to the nation’s sedentary lifestyle. This leads to a tendency for greater obesity and lack of fitness, and critics of current government policy point to such factors as the large number of school
2
playgrounds that have closed in recent years, and the fact that few children now cycle to school as a result of parents citing health and safety problems. There has been a reduction in competitive sports in schools, which brings greater risks for developing diabetes, various cancers and cardiovascular problems (heart attacks and strokes). However, there is now a greater understanding that welldesigned buildings can have a positive effect on health outcomes. There has also been a growth in the area of evidence-based design and an increase in the number of research papers that point to the advantages that can be achieved.
Review of historical bureaucracy and procedures for building procurement The NHS is the last of the large nationalised industries to come under the spotlight of privatisation. Steel, coal, the railways, electricity and gas were all privatised many years ago but the NHS is continuing to go through a painful process of change. Although the government is committed to the retention of the NHS as a public service, the funding of services will include an increasing percentage of private finance. This will be particularly evident in the provision and financing of new buildings, including those in the primary care sector. There had been a philosophy of tight economic planning in the post-war period, which the public had accepted. The benefits of nationalisation and the ‘welfare state’ had significantly outweighed the shortcomings now coming under the spotlight. The new NHS Plan reflects some of these changing attitudes, in particular the influence of information technology and the importance of consumerism or putting the patient first. The NHS has not been customer focused. Historically, the perception (even if legally incorrect) was that the customer (i.e. the patient) had few rights and the attitude was often along the lines of ‘aren’t you lucky to have a ‘‘free service’’ ’. Although the government recognises the need for change, this will not happen overnight. Investment cannot take place instantly, and there will be a decade of changes as the new initiatives begin to be implemented. This does raise the question of striking a balance between political influence and power and the responsibility for the delivery of high quality medical services. Other countries have made greater strides in the introduction of joint venture agreements between public and private finance for their health programmes. Obviously, the American health sector has long been driven by a competitive market economy and is dominated by a two-tier service largely financed by insurance. There is a safety net for those without health insurance but it is regarded by most as a backstop position. The best doctors and the best equipment are found in the private sector. More meaningful comparisons can be found on the other side of the Channel, in France. Some in the medical profession regard the French system as superior to the British NHS Health Scheme. Certainly, there are many reports of excellent
Introduction health services being available in France, such as a patient visiting a GP in the morning, having a consultant undertake tests and further examination in the afternoon, and results being delivered the same evening. This may lead to some interesting unexpected developments. Medical politics in the UK has evolved as a process of the BMA (British Medical Association) acting like a trade union in its negotiations with its employer (the government). Perhaps inadvertently, doctors have not given sufficient attention to directing their discussions to the customer (their patients). Architects went through these same traumas 20 years ago when the Thatcher government turned the spotlight on the perceived restrictive practices of the architectural profession at the beginning of the 1980s. Mandatory fee scales for architects were abolished, and architects were thrown into the cauldron of the competitive open marketplace. Today, doctors find themselves at the centre of public interest, receiving wide publicity for those doctors who have strayed outside their professional boundaries with a series of damaging court cases and public exposés. The government is taking the initiative, and doctors are caught between the demands of a vociferous and articulate public and an employer adopting an uncompromising stance towards conditions of contract and expectations of the quality of service. Nevertheless, new contracts of employment for general practitioners appear to be more advantageous to doctors than was envisaged by their employers (the government). Medical services will also become increasingly international. Already, along the south coast of England, people are crossing the Channel to seek medical advice, and it is expected that this trend will increase in popularity. Obviously, many people also come to the UK for highly specialised treatment, but for initial consultations with a GP consumers are likely to become more demanding, more selective, and more likely to ask for second opinions. It can be argued that this may lead to a privatisation of GP services, similar to GP services before the introduction of the NHS. Already, there is evidence that in our more affluent suburbs, personal recommendation between patients is creating a network of preferred GPs who are perceived to have specialist knowledge in certain areas. Patients are saying ‘Let’s go and see Dr A – I’ve heard he is very good with knees.’ Patients are increasingly able and willing to pay for a second opinion. However, the privatisation of GP services, should this trend develop, will be heavily influenced by the pharmaceutical industry. It is difficult to predict how the pharmaceutical industry will react if, for example, the supply of drugs through the NHS was to begin to decline and an increasing percentage of medication was prescribed by doctors privately. At present, if doctors leave the contractual arrangements between themselves and the NHS, they are no longer able to give patients the benefit of subsidised medication. Further speculation invites consideration of whether the privatisation of GP services will be taken over by large commercial organisations, rather than left as a network of individual private practitioners as in the pre-NHS situation. Not that long ago every high street had a privately run optician’s
shop. Now, the market is dominated by a handful of large commercial organisations that employ large numbers of opticians within national networks of shops. There are those in the retail trade who have already spotted the opportunity for providing pharmacy services and the next step may be GP services, within their retailing empires. How convenient it would become, when doing the weekly shop, to see a GP at the local supermarket, particularly if this could be done at a time convenient to the patient. Already, many supermarkets are operating 24 hours a day. Time remains a crucial component of the cost effectiveness of GP services. The personal consultation period between a patient and their GP remains a vital interface for that initial consultation. There are examples of bad doctors (in medical terms) who are popular with patients because of their personal charisma. There are even examples of doctors hauled before the Disciplinary Committee of their professional organisations who bring their own patients as witnesses to support their defence. Time spent with a patient is crucial if a sympathetic, healing environment is to be engendered. For example, in the Mayo Clinic in the USA, consultants see on average four cases during a morning session, but in a typical NHS hospital a consultant’s caseload for a morning session is more likely to be 20 patients. For GPs, the national average consultation period in the UK is eight minutes – all too short if a meaningful rapport is to be developed between doctor and patient and those subtle tell-tale signs are to be identified from a patient’s unhurried description of their concerns. Intuitively, therefore, one is led to believe that buildings in the future for primary health care services need to be friendly, non-threatening, and full of old fashioned concepts of comfort, light, cleanliness, warmth and friendliness. They should be relaxing, accessible, community-based facilities, which patients are keen to make full use of – to pop in for a chat or to ask a nurse or a pharmacist or a social worker for advice.
Why has the NHS concentrated on time and cost parameters for health building procurement? Until recently, the government’s approach to financing health care facilities, in line with all government spending, has been based largely on negotiating lowest cost tenders within annual spending budgets. This tended to downgrade the consideration of whole-life costs, and it is only lately that the Treasury has begun to promote ‘best value’ as the basis for selecting successful bidders for government contracts. Inevitably, this led to an approach within the NHS bureaucracy to concentrate on setting targets for different sizes of GP surgeries and offering guidance on the space standards that would be acceptable. This approach created a cultural background to the provision of buildings encapsulated within the framework of the ‘Red Book’. Standards
3
Primary Care Centres were set for accommodation, maximum allowances were set down for professional fees and cost limits were established. These principles were developed over many years resulting in a well-established set of procedures with which doctors needed to comply to improve or redevelop their premises. The environmental quality of these buildings was given scant attention. The philosophy regarding design was essentially that the administrators of NHS funds would establish a framework of requirements and set cost limits in the belief that this would leave designers free to interpret, in an imaginative way, the built form. Fortunately, because of the relatively short timescale between inception and completion for primary health care buildings, and the personal rapport between doctors and architects, many successful small surgeries have been completed over the last decade. However, there are many more of these buildings that could have been even better. There could have been more encouragement from NHS Estates to the doctors under their contract to build facilities that were more flexible, more responsive to their patients’ requirements and more likely to offer better value to the community. Functionality has been a key test of previous appraisal systems, a process devised by the administrators or service providers with negligible attempts to ask patients what they wanted. The new NHS Plan recognises the importance of putting patients first, and an exciting period lies ahead as new approaches to satisfying consumer demands begin to be developed and implemented. This is very good news indeed for patients, doctors and architects. The legacy of the previous approach to procuring health buildings does create some problems for the future. Those
4
doctors who have invested in their premises, and may have substantial loans outstanding against their property, may find that there is little alternative use for their bricks and mortar should they be interested in moving on to more exciting flexible facilities under the umbrella of a coordinated housing, social services, and health programme. A question of equity values, the approach of district valuers and rental calculations, and alternative resale values will all need to be considered and it may be that the government will need to devise some systems to ensure that the problems of negative equity do not stifle development of health care services. These problems are likely to be greatest in those areas most in need. It is in those areas where property values are likely to be lowest, and the need for alternative combined resources may be greatest. At the time of writing (July 2008), the NHS is celebrating its 60th anniversary and the government has just published Lord Darzi’s review of health services. In future, the health service will be judged on quality and it will be interesting to see if the aspirations set out in the Darzi Report are fulfilled in the years ahead. Much has been spent on dubious pay settlements to health workers, particularly GPs, and now the recommendations include the expectation that patients will benefit from private sector competition in primary care contracts. The key founding principles for the NHS remain firmly intact but how the new expectations for the quality of patient care are paid for remains the critical challenge for government health policies over the next few years. The emphasis is now firmly on primary care services and architects have an exciting opportunity to shape the success of GP surgeries by the skills they bring to providing innovative and popular designs for buildings in the future.
2
An outline review of the main issues (including a summary of the approach to designing health buildings)
Until the advent of scientific discovery led to the development of a technical base for medical practice, healing remedies relied on a holistic approach based on healthy living and the quality of life. Early civilisations in Egypt, from the third millennium BC, the ancient Greek communities from c. 1000 BC onwards and the Roman Empire spanning a few centuries before and after the birth of Christ all left evidence of their interest in medicine and the importance that it played in their philosophies and faiths. Early papyri from the Nile region of Egypt provide information about injuries and wounds. The most important papyri are the Edwin Smith Papyrus (1600 BC) and the Ebers papyrus (c. 1550 BC) found at Thebes. The literature is wide including Porter (1999, pp. 47, 48) and Walsh (2006). The Egyptians believed well-being was endangered by earthly and supernatural forces…was associated with correct living, being at peace with the gods, spirits and the dead; illness was a matter of imbalance which could be restored to equilibrium by supplication, spells and rituals. (Porter, 1999, p. 49) The Egyptians used a considerable number of remedies and physicians held clinics in the temples. Similar customs prevailed in Greece and the sick resorted to the temple of Asclepius where they spent the night (incubatio) in the hope of receiving directions from the god through dreams which the priests interpreted. They were run by priests and patients were encouraged to bathe, sleep and meditate.
The importance of the relationship between medicine and philosophy is implicit in a holistic approach to life advocated by the ancient Greeks. One examination of these concepts (Van der Eijk, 2005) draws out the significance of ‘spirit’ and the reluctance to adopt the materialist position that reduces mental phenomena completely to processes in matter. ‘Many of us, instinctively, seem to prefer to think of body and mind as distinct but interacting on each other.’1 Greek philosophers praised health as one of the greatest blessings of life and this approach was exemplified in the Hippocratic Oath. Writers such as Empedocles, Plato, Aristotle and the Stoics took a great interest in medical topics such as the nature of health and the causes of disease, phenomena such as respiration, old age, sleep and dreams, mental and psychosomatic illnesses such as epilepsy and melancholy, and questions of embryology, reproduction, fertility and sterility. Aristotle wrote, ‘how shall a doctor or a general who has had a vision of Very Form become thereby a better doctor or general? As a matter of fact it does not appear that the doctor makes a study even of health in the abstract. What he studies is the health of the human subject or rather of a particular patient. For it is on such a patient that he exercises his skill …’ (Thompson, 1953, p. 35). This is an early indication of the importance of the patient, which in 20th century medicine was obscured by the framework and systems of 1 Prof. P. van der Eijk, lecture notes, 20 April 2005, Newcastle University.
5
Primary Care Centres health care only to re-emerge as a key factor in the present day philosophy of health care, now referred to as patient centred or patient focused care (NHS Plan, 2000). Plato also examined the holistic nature of health and the importance of mind and body in maintaining a sense of well-being. For with a view to health and disease and virtue and vice, there is no symmetry or want of symmetry greater than that of the soul to the body… – that we should not move the body without the soul or the soul without the body, and thus they will aid one another, and be healthy and well balanced. (Jowett, 1999, pp. 1213, 1214) More recently, Scruton (1994, pp. 210, 211) reminds us that ‘once again it is Descartes who set the agenda for modern philosophy, arguing for a ‘‘real distinction’’ between mind and body … in particular, thought does not belong to the essence of body. I therefore clearly and distinctly perceive that the mind is essentially distinct from the body and therefore in principle separable from it.’ We can see that for over 5000 years there has been interest in exploring the relationship between a renewed awareness that technical and scientific medical expertise continues to be influenced by the state of the human mind and our sense of well-being. New techniques to measure environmental conditions are being developed so that emotional and spiritual factors can be evaluated. These are broadly included in the term ‘evidence-based design’. The Hippocratic Oath has survived from its Greek origins when health care was viewed within a natural and totally holistic framework. I swear by Apollo the physician, and Aescuplapius, and Health, and All-heal, and all the gods and goddesses, that, according to my ability and judgement, I will keep this Oath and this stipulation – to reckon him who taught me this Art equally dear to me as my parents, to share my substance with him, and relieve his necessities if required; to look upon his offspring on the same footing as my own brothers, and to teach them this art, if they shall wish to learn it, without fee or stipulation; and that by precept, lecture, and every other mode of instruction, I will impart a knowledge of the Art to my sons, and those of my teachers, but to none others. I will follow that system or regiment which, according to my ability and judgement, I consider for the benefit of my patients, and abstain from whatever is deleterious and mischievous. I will give no deadly medicine to any one if asked, nor suggest any such counsel; and in like manner I will not give a woman a pessary to produce abortion. With purity and with holiness I will pass my life and practise my Art. I will not cut persons labouring under the stone, but will leave this to be done by men who are practitioners of this work. Into whatever houses I enter, I will go into them for the benefit of the sick, and will abstain from every voluntary act of mischief and corruption;
6
and, further, from the seduction of females or males, of freemen and slaves. Whatever, in connection with my professional practice or not in connection with it, I see or hear in the life of men, which ought not to be spoken of abroad, I will not divulge, as reckoning that all such should be kept secret. While I continue to keep this Oath unviolated, may it be granted to me to enjoy life and the practice of the art, respected by all men, in all times! But should I trespass and violate this Oath, may the reverse be my lot! This translation, quoted by Calman (1998, p. 218), is ascribed to Francis Adams. The Hippocratic Oath was updated by the Geneva Convention (adopted on 12 August 1949 and brought into force on 21 October 1950). The Declaration of Helsinki developed by the World Medical Association sets out the ethical principles for the medical community regarding human experimentation. It was originally adopted in June 1964 and distinguishes between therapeutic and non-therapeutic research. The Declaration made informed consent a central requirement for ethical research and is important in the history of research ethics as the first significant effort of the modern medical community to regulate itself. The development of regulations was stimulated by the exposure, by whistleblowers such as H.K. Beecher (1904–76) in the United States and M.H. Pappworth (1910–94) in Britain (Porter, 1999, p. 651), of unethical procedures being performed on vulnerable patients such as the mentally ill. There were other shocking examples including the Tuskegee (Alabama) experiment started by the US Public Heath Service in 1932 which deprived black men of proper treatment for syphilis. The Second World War focused attention on the German medical scientists who conducted programmes of human experimentation (including Dr Josef Mengele, camp doctor at Auschwitz). Other human experimentation took place in Japan where biological weapons were developed. The Hippocratic Oath is clouded by questions of academic authenticity; many versions exist and the library at Alexandra houses a collection of texts. However, Hippocratic medicine ‘was also to win a name for being patient-centred rather than disease-orientated’ (Porter, 1999, p. 56). Several parts of the Oath have been removed or reworded over the years as the social, religious and political importance of medicine has changed. Modern medical ethics have also addressed the historic difficulties of the Oath on issues such as abortion, confidentiality, surgery and the teaching of men but not women. A hospital was a place of hospitality (Latin: hospes, a guest; hence hospitalis, hospitable; hospitum, a guest house or guest room). With almost no technical knowledge as we know it today (but a long tradition of faith, wisdom and experience by practice and observation) health care was also associated with religion, music, poetry, the arts and good food. The lack of scientific knowledge as we understand it put reliance on the natural healing process which is today
An outline review of the main issues (including a summary of the approach to designing health buildings) receiving greater attention than ever before as an alternative approach to modern high technology medicine. The Romans incorporated both a scientific and mythological approach to medicine and health care. They adopted much of the Greeks’ scientific data concerning medicine. Primarily, the teachings of Hippocrates (460–384 BC) gave the Romans a holistic look at medicine and the treatment of illnesses and diseases. Instead of the Greek method of simply observing the symptoms and recording them in order to treat the patient, the Romans also included many prayers and offerings to the gods. Almost all the Roman gods had healing powers. This led to an eclectic medical system but despite this lack of focus the Romans enjoyed relatively good health for several reasons. The availability of fresh water prevented many diseases associated with standing water, and hygiene led to good health. The Roman baths became a part of life and kept germs and bacteria under control. Finally, the drainage system took old wastewater away from the population and prevented many illnesses and infections. The Romans also tried, whenever practical, to boil medical tools and prevent using them on more than one patient without cleaning. Health care was largely personal between the physician and the patient although in large households there were slave physicians caring for their sick fellows in valetudinaria (hospitals). The adoption of Christianity as the state religion of the Roman Empire gave an expansion of the provision of care, but not just for the sick. Galen (131–201 AD) was a prominent physician in the ancient world and worked diligently to expand medical knowledge. He pursued Hippocrates’ methods of observation and research by dissecting and studying human anatomy. Thanks to him, doctors for centuries afterward had at least a basic knowledge of practical medicine. In the Roman army, buildings were set aside for treating the sick and wounded. A standard military hospital plan evolved, with individual cells off a long corridor, a large top-lit hall, latrines and baths (Porter, 1999, p. 78). In England, the Venerable Bede (c. 672–735) was aware of the need to meld healing and holiness. Although Northumberland lay on the northern edge of the civilised world at that time, Bede and his monks possessed many medical writings. His influence is being carefully researched and recorded at Bede’s World in Jarrow (www.bedesworld.co.uk). The Islamic world was also developing medical practice and built up a high standard of care between the 8th and 12th centuries AD. There are records of hospitals in Sri Lanka, India, Baghdad, Damascus, Cairo and throughout Persia. The birth of the healing arts with Hippocrates was corrupted by the Medieval (Porter, 2000, p. 189). This is traced by the entry in Chambers Cyclopædia (1738). At length, however, they [Galen’s errors] were purged out and exploded by two different means: principally indeed by the restoration of the pure discipline of Hippocrates in France; and then also by the experiments and discoveries
Years 0–1800 – Care takes place at home or in the community 1800–2000 – Care takes place in medical institutions 2000 and beyond – Care takes place at home or in the community 0
1800
2000
(Valins and Salter, 1996, p. 4 )
Figure 2.1 Chronology for the place of care
of alchymists and anatomists; till at length this immortal Harvey overturning, by his demonstrations, the whole theory of the ancients, laid a new and certain basis of the science. Since his time, Medicine is become free from the tyranny of any sect, and is improved by sure discoveries in anatomy, chymistry, physics, botany, mechanics, etc.2 The Enlightenment brought scientific analysis to the forefront of academic study, although ‘by the middle of the eighteen century, however, strict mechanism was being judged incapable of accounting for the full complexities of living phenomena, especially properties like growth and reproduction’ (Porter, 2000, p. 139). Thus, the study of holistic forms of medicine is part of a process of reverting to care in the community, and is beginning to take precedence again over the institutionalised treatment of the ill, which has been prevalent during the last 200 years. Indeed, it is a fundamental aspect of current UK government health policy and part of the principle of patient focused care (NHS Plan, 2000). These ideas had also begun to influence policy in the USA some years earlier (in the 1990s). Based on a system of payment for medical services by insurance policies it was convenient to the patient and cost effective for the provider of health services to locate facilities within, or close to, residential areas. It is only comparatively recently that the focus has returned to care in the community. As medical invention and technology become further sophisticated so technology itself can begin to break away from hospital buildings and move into the community. Therefore the hospital no longer needs to be the focus of health care. This is also reflected in the world-wide economic crisis in the funding of large hospital programmes and the enormous expense of hospital technology which encourages providers towards the low tech form of treatment. Have we therefore come full circle? (Valins and Salter, 1996, p. 4) Although the rituals and belief systems of the ancient civilisations are not being revived, the philosophical issues between the mind and the body’s physical condition have parallels that remain as valid today as they were 2000 years ago. The same authors suggest a chronological split for the nature of caring in the Western world as shown in Figure 2.1. 2
Ephrain Chambers, Cyclopædia, 2nd edn (1738 [1728]), Vol. ii, unpaginated, ‘Medicine’.
7
Primary Care Centres It could be argued that the first period (0–1800 AD) should be extended to 3500 BC–1800 AD. Although valid in wealthy, industrialised and technologically advanced societies this analysis would not be representative of countries where home and community care may be all that is available to the great majority of the population. Hospitals may be many miles away and very limited in medical skills and facilities. The World Health Organisation (WHO) – see below – has adopted policies which support locally based primary health services. Patient demand for convenience encourages this policy in Western countries together with the natural preference for people to be treated at, or close to, their home rather than in a large institutionalised building. These trends are likely to provide new opportunities for the design of specialist buildings, to provide sophisticated day-care treatment located within the localities they serve, thereby reducing the demand for highly expensive capitalintensive hospitals (although some will continue to be required for research and complex medical conditions). The historical pattern of health care has been reviewed by several authors. Verderber and Fine (2000) in Healthcare Architecture in an Era of Radical Transformation identify ‘six periods in the history of health architecture that capture key developments through the centuries’ (p. 10). The following quotations chart the six categories of health care identified by the authors. They trace the range of community facilities that were available, the links to ‘wellness’ and the development of a range of architectural solutions to accommodate the services provided. As medical knowledge increased so did the complexity of the built environment. Until about the 1850s, surgery could be performed in a variety of settings but steadily it became focused and interdependent with hospitals. This development of Victorian technical mastery led towards the concentration of medical expertise in hugely expensive and technologically sophisticated hospitals that continued throughout the 20th century. For many reasons, society (in the UK and other leading industrialised countries) has changed its approach to the provision of health care facilities. The emphasis has moved from large complex hospitals (although some of these will continue to be required as centres of technical excellence) to a pattern of smaller, community-based facilities. 1. The Ancient period follows the development of wellness care by the Greeks and the importance the Roman army put on military hospitals near the front lines throughout their Empire in both Europe and the Middle East. ‘Nature and the afterlife played a role in the healing process … although the earliest infirmaries were operated in conjunction with wellness and spiritual treatment centres. Wellness care was developed by the Greeks between 1000 BC and AD 100. The private room first appeared nearly three thousand years ago in the Greek Asclepion’ (p.10). (up to 500 AD or thereabouts: the Greek and Roman Empires)
8
2. The Medieval describes the Catholic Church’s provision of monastic hospitals built on the edges of villages and cities. ‘These hospitals were the origins of the modern medical centre’ (p. 11). (500–1500: largely in Italy and Western Europe) 3. The Renaissance period saw the development of architecturally planned buildings with symmetrical, axial plans and formal facades. Many of these were constructed in response to the declining standards of hygiene that saw the spread of disease and plagues throughout parts of Europe including Britain (London’s Bethlehem Hospital, 1676, also known as Bedlam). (1500–1850) 4. The Nightingale phase saw functional ward designs emerge from dealing with casualties of the Crimean War during the 1850s. For the first time we see concerns for high levels of natural light to be introduced to wards for the benefit of patients. ‘She emphasized function above form some two decades before the phrase ‘‘form follows function’’ was coined by Chicago architect Louis Sullivan to epitomize the new epoch of modern architecture’ (p. 11). (British Empire – 1850s and later than that) 5. The ‘Minimalist Megahospital’ is a phrase used to describe the evolution of large ‘high-tech’ hospitals. These were developed in response to the complex scientific medical technologies that dominated health care in the 20th century. Particularly in the USA, where health care is insurance based (compared to the UK NHS system), this led to ‘huge, selfcontained ‘‘mothership’’ medical centres’ (p. 14). However, they ‘were to become anachronisms when they opened in an era of a restructured healthcare system soon to be refocused on community-based managed care. These hospitals therefore symbolized to critics everything wrong with the healthcare system in advanced industrialized nations’ (p. 14). They have become outdated as health care has reverted to a predominantly community-based structure reflecting the 21st century preoccupation with patient focused care. Developing from about 1990, ideas are fast changing: ‘the information age is profoundly influencing how we define health and how we care for ourselves’ (pp. 14, 15). (20th century – mainly USA) 6. The Virtual Healthscope anticipates a more flexible and open system for health care. New computer technologies are permitting health care solutions that offer greater choice, flexibility and accessibility for everybody. A concise history of medical buildings is Lorenzo Dall’Olio’s essay ‘Origin and development of health-care facilities’ (Materia, 38, August 2002, pp. 20–27). It emphasises the importance of the Hippocratic doctrine in attempting
An outline review of the main issues (including a summary of the approach to designing health buildings) ‘to go beyond the medicine of the priesthood in favour of clinical study of the patient’ (p. 20). He goes on to say, ‘the dual roots, secular and religious, of medical theory and practice conditioned for centuries the entire hospital and welfare system as well as the overall organization of health care’ (p. 20). More recently, Dall’Olio identifies Powell and Moya’s design in 1962 for Wexham Hospital at Slough as ‘perhaps the clearest attempt to design a hospital for patients, considering their needs, the psychological implications of everything that concerns the patients’ wellbeing, through a high quality environmental and architectural context’ (pp. 25, 26). The essay concludes with the following summation of policy: The ‘humanization’ of the hospital thus seems to be the primary objective of the research conducted in recent years, humanization that has to do with quality and even with the vivacity of interiors, finishes, materials and colors, that calls for the addition of new functions and spaces, for both patients and personnel, and for the visitors – shops, cafés, indoor gardens, meeting points, libraries and, lastly, breaking down the historic isolation of this type of structure, considers it fundamentally important to insert the hospital in the life processes of the city. (p. 27) The idea that health care buildings should be enjoyed and include works of art has historical antecedents. This approach is being developed by many architects who are designing health care buildings today after the austerity, financial restraint and practical approach to the design of health care buildings during the early years of the NHS. That the arts can be therapeutic is an idea that emerged in the 1980s and Sir Kenneth Calman, a former chief medical officer of the UK, used the phrase when writing in 2001 that embracing the arts and humanities with health and medicine was an ‘idea whose time had come’ (lecture, University of Durham, July 2001). Art in health buildings is usually thought of as a recent phenomenon and it is certainly true that there has been considerable interest, and awareness of the benefits, in recent years (Haldane and Loppert, 1999; Waller and Finn, 2004; NHS Estates, 2002). However, the Victorians decorated their public buildings, including hospitals, with paintings and sculpture celebrating great personal achievements. Proud of their financial and technical progress, benefactors were recorded for posterity by these self-indulgent acts of artistic patronage. A typical example is the entrance area of the Royal Victoria Infirmary, Newcastle upon Tyne. Known as the Peacock Hall, it is a richly decorated space with inlaid timber panelling. Plaques, portraits and busts commemorate people important to the institution including ● ●
●
Portrait of Robert Stephenson (1805–1899) Portrait of Shute Barrington, Bishop of Hexham (1734–1826) Bust of Thomas Emerson Headlam (1777–1864), physician to the Newcastle Infirmary 1805–1840
●
Plaque recording the official opening of the RVI on 11 July 1906 by King Edward VII commemorating the Diamond Jubilee of Queen Victoria’s reign. Also mentioned are the contractors, funding committee and the architects (Lister Newcombe and Percy Adams).
This tradition of recording significant people has been continued with a small brass plaque commemorating that Ludwig Wittgenstein, philosopher, worked at the hospital from April 1943 to February 1944. This legacy is still with us, often exercising the minds of today’s administrators as to the best way to incorporate these works in new hospital buildings. A historical anecdote illustrates how art was beginning to be associated with health. The story is that Nijinsky was taken ill during a visit to London in 1912 with Dyaghilev’s Ballets Russes and was taken to St Stephen’s Infirmary, a Victorian workhouse-turned-hospital on the site of the Chelsea and Westminster Hospital. On his recovery three days later he apparently performed L’Après-midi d’une faune and Dyaghilev had ‘distributed gold sovereigns to patients and staff ’ (Loppert, 1999). He obviously felt that this performance would help the other patients as well as being a ‘thank you’ for the improvement in his own condition. Susan Loppert, in charge of the arts programme at the Chelsea and Westminster Hospital, has developed a track record of integrating public awareness of cultural issues into a healing environment. Music, opera and the visual arts all have an important part to play in raising the environmental quality of the building for those who visit it. The hospital is now an important research centre (under the direction of Dr Rosalia Staricoff) for examining and quantifying therapeutic benefits and patient outcomes resulting from environmental factors. Art is seen not only as honouring the ‘great and the good’ but as enhancing public enjoyment; indeed it can be argued that art in health care environments should be conceived not just as an adornment to a building or a space but integral with the design of the environment as a whole. This approach and the potential importance of art and good design to hospital patients are summed up by Linda Moss in her study of Arts and Healthcare: The arts offer an important area in which the conflicts of the modern hospital provision can be partially resolved, or at least mediated. The arts are a human intervention, expressive of human emotion and response to experience. Their presence in the hospital can raise the profile of the human aspects of health care without infringing upon its clinical efficiency. (Moss, 1988) Others have promoted the importance of integrating art into the design of the building as a whole (including Leichak Staricoff et al., 2001; Francis, 2003; McDonald, 2002). I have argued (Purves, 2002) that quantifying the cost benefits of the intangible qualities of art presents today’s designers with considerable obstacles. These difficulties
9
Primary Care Centres may be put into perspective if the concept of quality is not divided into tangible and intangible benefits. Our perception of intangible benefits is categorised thus only because the factors involved are more difficult to quantify. With more research, perhaps meaningful conclusions will be able to be drawn and the mysteries of concepts such as ‘welcoming’, ‘relaxing’ and ‘calm’ will be given quantifiable characteristics for the architect to manipulate. In this way, the control of environmental qualities will emerge as the future path to improving patient outcomes by offering therapeutic benefits. Today, we are seeking scientific evidence. There is growing awareness of the need for more research and over the next few years, our intuitive instincts will be tested and challenged by the results of the research being carried out by Ulrich and others known as ‘evidence-based design’. A study funded by NHS Estates (where I was a member of the research team) examined the role of art in a new hospital in the North East of England and suggests that there might be an additional cultural role for art in hospitals, and for hospital buildings (Macnaughton et al., 2005 – to be published in the International Journal of Cultural Policy). This work has been developed and Macnaughton considers the wider evidence for the changing role of art in hospitals, the history behind it and places the idea within an aesthetic framework. She says: that the art can be seen to have a wider role within hospitals than purely that of providing a ‘therapeutic environment’, has implications for arts and design planning and for the kinds of question asked in researching and evaluation current hospital arts and design programmes … For this synergy between hospitals and artists to work, artists do have to have some further potential professional benefit from displaying their works in these locations and information is essential to this process. From the research point of view theories about art and design in hospital spaces have not yet caught up with the idea that hospitals may be being used as a cultural resource in this way. The questions asked in the new evidence-based healthcare design movement (led by Ulrich) are entirely related to either clinical effectiveness or cost effectiveness. The evidence presented here suggests that the functions of hospitals are expanding to provide a social and cultural resource for their communities, although this is not necessarily uppermost in the minds of most day-to-day hospital users. Clearly the main focus for art and designs must be their impact upon patients and upon the NHS purse. However, it would be interesting in the future to extend research questions to look at the impact of arts programmes on the wider communities served by those NHS hospitals which are increasingly seeing them as part of their role. The perceptiveness of Florence Nightingale’s observations should be considered in the context of other views being expressed at the time. Goethe’s Theory of Colours was an example of holistic science and ‘parted radically with
10
the dominant Newtonian light and optical theories of his time, but also with the entire Enlightenment methodology of reductive science’ (retrieved from http://en.wikipedia. org/wiki/Theory_of_Colours, accessed 29/1/06). Colour has an extraordinary power to move us emotionally and designers have long recognised its importance to the design process. Other ways of sensing colour via hearing, taste and smell have also been reported (http://midwest-facilitators. net/downloads/mfn 1999 1025 frank vodvarka.pdf, accessed 30/1/06). John Ruskin, writing in The Stones of Venice, which he started in 1849, said: We have seen that all great art is the work of the whole living creature, body and soul, and chiefly of the soul. (Ruskin, 2001, p. 319) Exhibited at the Academy in 1840, Turner’s painting Slavers Throwing Overboard the Dead and Dying – Typhoon Coming On reflects the great sunset blaze on a heaving sea. Romantic images are contrasted with the scientific work of Darwin and others during a period of great intellectual energy. Nightingale addressed the necessity of healing relationships with patients and family and with colleagues. Having travelled in Europe as a young woman with her family, she was exposed to a wide range of views and opinions and she thought that nurses were well positioned to create a new vision of healing that integrates relation-centred care into all aspects of the health care system. She saw that a person’s well-being was not just physical health but also psychological and spiritual health. By understanding that the environment was central to her concept of good nursing practice, she looked for ways in which the environment could be modified to improve conditions so that natural healing could occur. This had developed from her empirical observation that poor or difficult environments led to poor health and disease. In contrast to this holistic approach to health, Brunel had developed a modular hospital for casualties of the Crimean War. ‘In Brunel’s design he placed emphasis on the environment, particularly lighting, ventilation, drainage, colour and cleanliness, and the resulting hospital was found to provide a healthier environment, with better recovery rates than the other British hospitals…Florence Nightingale was aware of Brunel’s design concept and the improved infection rates, and this influenced her future thinking’ (Glanville, 2005, p. 1). Florence Nightingale had this intuitive foresight of therapeutic benefits in health care nearly 150 years ago. Writing in her Notes on Nursing: what it is and what it is not in 1859 she recorded: The effect in sickness of beautiful objects, of variety of objects, and especially of brilliancy of colour is hardly at all appreciated. Such cravings are usually called the ‘fancies’ of patients. And often doubtless patients have ‘fancies’, as e.g. when they desire two contradictions. But much more often, their (so called) ‘fancies’ are the
An outline review of the main issues (including a summary of the approach to designing health buildings) most valuable indications of what is necessary for their recovery. And it would be well if nurses would watch these (so called) ‘fancies’ closely … I shall never forget the rapture of fever patients over a bunch of brightcoloured flowers. I remember (in my own case) a nosegay of wild flowers being sent me, and from that moment recovery becoming more rapid. (p. 58) Going on she expanded on her views of the connection between mind and body in the healing process: This is no fancy. People say the effect is only on the mind. It is no such thing. The effect is on the body, too. Little as we know about the way in which we are affected by form, by colour, and light, we do know this, that they have an actual physical effect. Variety of form and brilliancy of colour in the objects presented to patients are actual means of recovery. But it must be slow variety e.g. if you show a patient ten or twelve engravings successively, ten-to-one he does not become cold and faint, or feverish, or even sick; but hang one up opposite him, one on each successive day, or week, or month, and he will revel in the variety. (p. 59) Perhaps even the more recent research examining the recovery time for patients which compared patients looking at a brick wall compared to looking at natural landscape (Ulrich, 1984) was anticipated by Florence Nightingale’s observations: The fact is, that these painful impressions are far better dismissed by a real laugh, if you can excite one by books or conversation, than by any direct reasoning; or if the patient is too weak to laugh, some impression from nature is what he wants. I have mentioned the cruelty of letting him stare at a dead wall. In many diseases, especially in convalescence from fever, that wall will appear to make all sorts of faces at him; now flowers never do this. Form, colour, will free your patient from his painful ideas better than any argument. (p. 60) He was a workman – had not in his composition a single grain of what is called ‘enthusiasm for nature’ – but he was desperate to ‘see once more out of a window’. Yet the consequence in none of their minds, so far as I know, was the conviction that the craving for variety in the starving eye, is just as desperate as that of food in the starving stomach, and tempts the famishing creature in either case to steal for its satisfaction. No other word will express it but ‘desperation’. And it sets the seal of ignorance and stupidity just as much on the governors and attendants of the sick if they do not provide the sickbed with a ‘view’ of some kind, as if they did not provide the hospital with a kitchen. (p. 61)
No one who has watched the sick can doubt the fact, that some feel stimulus from looking at scarlet flowers, exhaustion from looking at deep blue, etc. (p. 62)
International position World Health Organisation (WHO) The fact that health care is of great concern to all nations is reflected by the existence of the World Health Organisation. At the World Health Assembly in 1977 a commitment was made to ‘the attainment by all citizens of the world by the year 2000 of a level of health that will permit them to lead a socially useful and economically productive life’ (World Health Organisation, 1979). A joint World Health Organisation/UNICEF Conference at Alma-Ata in 1978 declared that primary health care was the most promising vehicle for ‘attaining the target of health for all by the year 2000 as part of overall development and in the spirit of social justice’ (World Health Organisation, 1978). This approach (since 1978) has had an impact on the planning, building and operation of health care facilities. It is therefore important, in order to avoid mistakes, to consider carefully what should be the place of these activities in a health system based on primary health care and what are the constraints to be overcome. This is further developed by Kleczkowski and Pibouleau, the editors of a World Health Organisation document published in 1983 (Kleczkowski and Pibouleau, 1983). They identify that the role of the hospital in the primary health care context will inevitably change, and argue that it is difficult to predict the full extent of that change until the primary health care programmes have become more firmly established. Many developing countries are staking large investments in vast national networks of health care facilities, and the success or failure of their planning, building and operation is an issue of high priority. They state that architects are frequently not involved in formulating the building brief ‘when decisions require relating to the size and scope of facilities and to their general standard of construction and equipment are being made’. At the design and production stage, an excess of project loads lead to a general lowering of professional standards and the easy adoption of ad-hoc designs as standard solutions. In achieving the ‘goal of health for all’ through the medium of health systems oriented towards primary health care, there needs to be a fundamental rearrangement of building and equipment priorities involving completely new building types, design approaches, methods of construction, uses of material and modes of implementation. USA – the early days for primary health care
And long before today’s view that blue is a colour inducing coolness and depression and that red suggests warmth and invigoration she had recorded:
In the USA, more literature is available on the evolution of the primary health care facility and its development over the last 50 years. During the 1950s, there was considerable
11
Primary Care Centres development of the concept of a health centre. The Hill Burton Programme developed the provision of a range of medical services from the same building. Health centres ranged in size from 1000 to 20 000 sq. ft in area but the national median size was about 5000 sq. ft, although a greater number of about 3000 sq. ft were built, which were deemed capable of serving a rural population of up to 35 000. The general background of this programme is set out in Hospitals, Clinics and Health Centres (Hunt, 1960). The overall planning concepts were much the same then as they are today in the UK and the list of accommodation which was recommended would be familiar to an architect designing a doctor’s surgery under the requirements of the current ‘Red Book’ procedures3 (NHS, 1996). They include: 1. Waiting, including the main entrance. 2. Administration, including offices and record space. 3. Clinic, including subwaiting, examination, treatment and consultation rooms. 4. Service, including heating, storage and maintenance rooms. The importance of flexibility in the use of rooms was also recognised and ‘multi use of clinic space should be exploited in the interest of economy, not only of expensive space but of valuable personnel’. It was also recognised that benefits would accrue from incorporating additional medical services such as dental and x-ray facilities. The idea of collecting or putting interconnecting examination and consulting rooms in groups of two or more closely pre-dates the design of treatment suites in GP surgeries which were built during the last decade in the UK. The importance of using a doctor’s time as efficiently as possible has been recognised for 40 years or more. Today, there is increasing awareness of the value of patients’ time. Other facilities that were considered included nutritional advice and mental health clinics. It was estimated that one full-time mental health clinic per 50 000 population should be provided as a minimum need. However, it was acknowledged that the provision of mental health facilities was at an early stage of development and that the required standards were not fully understood (Hunt, 1960). Development work continued in the USA during the 1960s and 1970s and the design of primary health care facilities advanced. During this period, the emphasis also shifted from the treatment of disease to keeping people healthy. The trend is to prevent disease; to keep people out of the hospital through health education programmes and holistic ideology, making persons responsible for their own health. Raising the general public’s knowledge about the 3
Details of schedules of space and cost limits for GP premises (now superseded) were set out under the Cost Rent scheme in the Statement of Fees and Allowances (the ‘Red Book’). Various revisions and amendments were issued to this essential working document, which formed the core of negotiations for the designs of GP premises over many years.
12
importance of proper nutrition, exercise and the risks associated with alcoholism, drug abuse, and smoking is perhaps the most effective weapon in the battle against disease. Health education centres as agents to hospitals and other health service agencies have sprung up recently in store fronts and shopping centres, making sound information accessible to the community. Future social, economic, and political considerations will change the character of health delivery systems considerably. Good medical care is now considered the right of all citizens, rather than the privilege of a few. In addition, we have increased longevity, so more elderly persons will be around to need medical care. These two factors demand a comprehensive health planning system co-ordinated on a nation-wide basis. From the stand point of economics, prevention of illness is more economical than disability and disease. (Malkin, 1982, p. viii)
Early NHS policy Functionality and cost The NHS Estates’ procurement policy was based until recently on the Capital Investment Manual, which required a business case approach to justify new investment. This led to a position where design quality was understood to be represented by functionality. Design quality was assessed by its functional suitability. That methodology was enshrined in their Estate Code document that set out a five-facet analysis process: ● ● ● ● ●
Space utilisation Functional suitability Energy efficiency Statutory standards (compliance) Physical condition.
These factors were used as a basis for design quality evaluation. This is done by subdividing each category into four sections from fully compliant (e.g. new building) to below an acceptable standard. With this background, an assessment of design quality does not include qualitative issues, or an assessment of the desired ethos of a building. The criteria set out in the analysis process do not include emotional responses such as ‘pleasantness’ or ‘calmness’ or indeed any suggestion of ‘therapeutic value’. However, the problem remains that even if appropriate categories of patient satisfaction were included there would be difficulties in measuring or placing values on these factors. Design quality had to be based on quantifiable data. The tests of functionality were set against cost targets established by the Treasury. Over the first 50 years of the NHS, management of the health budget for physical assets (buildings) was based on annual targets that provided little incentive to consider lifecycle costs or to allow for the development of value-for-money concepts.
An outline review of the main issues (including a summary of the approach to designing health buildings) Development of hospice design A comparison with NHS policies for GP surgeries can be made with the procurement of hospices. The concept of holistic healing had been lost in the development of technical medicine in the 20th century. As I have shown, a holistic approach to health care was much more central to the care of those who were ill in earlier civilisations. Examples of hospice briefing documents for both children and adults are discussed in Healthy Living Centres (Purves, 2002). The central difference of these briefing processes (for both children and adults) is that the care of the patient is central to the design objective. Costs and space standards are considered after the aspirations have been set to create an environment within the buildings that will be comforting to the patient. A conference (Breathing Space: Towards an Aesthetic for Cancer Care) held in Dundee (October 2003) examined the philosophy of the Maggie Centres, a network of buildings being created by Charles Jencks in memory of his wife who died of cancer. Jencks joked that ‘in the old days, people used to die in factories … called hospitals’. They are similar to hospices, in that the design ethos or therapeutic value of the spaces was central to the architectural brief. Funding, usually from charitable sources, was secondary to achieving a building that provided a calm and comforting environment for patients with life threatening cancers. The Glasgow Homoeopathic Hospital demonstrates that the qualitative factors of sensitive and therapeutic benefits can focus on environmental design issues, achieve high standards of architectural quality and yet still be constructed within NHS procurement cost limits. These differences between the briefing process for hospices and GP surgeries arise from the way they are funded. Most hospices are privately funded charities; they set their environmental standards or ethos for the building and then set about raising the finance. The Glasgow Homoeopathic Hospital was unusual because it was publicly funded on a site within a large general hospital complex. However, the brief, because of the determination of one person, reflected the aspirations for a caring holistic environment. The building was chosen by an architectural competition. It is a rare example that demonstrates that it is possible to design a caring environment which is architecturally sensitive within an NHS budget. The building provides a rare facility of ‘last resort’ where conventional technical medical services can offer no further treatment within normal NHS services so that patients can experience a caring ‘hospice’ environment on an NHS District Hospital site with palliative care in a pleasant environment. For further discussion of this project, see the case study in Healthy Living Centres (Purves, 2002, p. 133). Development of the NHS Until the last few years, the government’s approach to financing health care facilities, in line with all government spending, has been based largely on negotiating lowest cost
tenders within annual spending budgets. This tended to downgrade the consideration of ‘whole-life’ costs, and it is only recently that the Treasury has begun to promote ‘best value’ as the basis for selecting successful bidders for government contracts (Technical note 7, HM Treasury). Inevitably, this led to an approach within the NHS bureaucracy to concentrate on setting targets for different sizes of GP surgeries and offering guidance on the space standards that would be acceptable. This approach created a cultural background to the provision of buildings encapsulated within the framework of the ‘Red Book’.4 Standards were set for accommodation, maximum allowances were set down for professional fees and cost limits were established. These principles were developed over many years resulting in a well-established set of procedures with which doctors needed to comply to improve or redevelop their premises. The environmental quality of these buildings was given scant attention. The philosophy regarding design was essentially that the administrators of NHS funds would establish a framework of requirements and set cost limits in the belief that this would leave designers free to interpret the built form in an imaginative way. Because of the relatively short timescale between inception and completion for primary health care buildings, and the personal rapport between doctors and architects, many successful small surgeries have been completed over the last decade. There could have been more encouragement from NHS Estates to the doctors under their contract to build facilities that were more flexible, more responsive to their patients’ requirements and more likely to offer better value to the community. NHS Estates collected a great deal of data about the performance of primary care facilities but these statistics have not been used (or made available to others) for research or analytical purposes. The lack of direction in utilising these data seems to be lost in bureaucracy. Functionality has been a key test of previous appraisal systems, a process devised by the administrators or service providers with negligible attempts to ask patients what they wanted. Functionality was seen as a measure of how efficient the building was for staff and doctors to process the patient. The emotional well-being of a patient was secondary to issues such as special and ergonomic requirements. The new NHS Plan recognises the importance of putting patients first, and opportunities lie ahead as new approaches to satisfying consumer demands begin to be developed and implemented. Thus, the effects of supply 4
The ‘Red Book’, as it is known, is the General Medical Services Statement of Fees and Allowances (SFA). Bound in a bright red A5 sized file it was regularly updated and formed the basis for financial issues relating to GP practice. This included a section on premises where cost limits and allowable space standards were set out relating to different sized practices, particularly for practices between two and seven GPs. This document has now been superseded by the Statement of Financial Entitlement (SFE) with details available on the NHS website (www.dh.gov.uk/assetRoot/04/06/97/63/04069763.pdf).
13
Primary Care Centres and demand and qualitative factors will emerge as patients begin to exercise their freedom to make choices (about the location of their treatment for health matters) in a market economy. The legacy of the previous approach to procuring health buildings does create some problems for the future. Those doctors who have invested in their premises, and may have substantial loans outstanding against their property, may find that there is little alternative use for their bricks and mortar should they be interested in moving on to more exciting flexible facilities under the umbrella of a coordinated housing, social services and health programme. A question of equity values, the approach of district valuers and rental calculations, and alternative resale values will all need to be considered and it may be that the government will need to devise some systems to ensure that the problems of negative equity do not stifle development of health care services. These problems are likely to be greatest in those areas most in need. It is in those areas where property values are likely to be lowest, and the need for alternative combined resources may be greatest. Peckham and Finsbury health centres Two health centres built in the UK in the 1930s represent a significant moment in the architectural response to designing health care centres at that time. The Finsbury Health Centre was designed by Berthold Lubetkin and was constructed between 1935 and 1938, and the Peckham Health Centre was built in 1935 to designs by Sir Owen Williams. The Peckham Experiment (notes extracted from www.open2.net/modernity/3): In 1935, two pioneering doctors opened the Pioneer Health Centre in Peckham, south London. Their aim was to conduct a huge experiment into the effect of environment on health. The Pioneer Health Centre (usually known as the Peckham Health Centre) was a bold departure in the medical field in the 1930s, concentrating on a preventative, rather than a curative approach to health. In order to facilitate their grand project, the two doctors housed their centre in a purpose built modern building, creating an early example of how new architectural techniques could help further bold new social experiments. George Scott Williamson and Innes Pearse were a husband and wife team who believed that an individual’s social and physical environment could decisively affect his or her long-term state of health. Nine hundred and fifty families signed up to be part of ‘the Peckham Experiment’. For one shilling a week, they relaxed in a clublike atmosphere: physical exercise, games, workshops, or even simple relaxation were all encouraged. All the time they were observed by Williamson & Pearse, and their team of doctors. There was no set programme of exercise at Peckham, and members were obliged to attend a thorough medical examination once a year.
14
The Finsbury Health Centre (notes extracted from www.open2.net/modernity/3): Finsbury was one of London’s poorest boroughs. In the 1930s lice, rickets, and diphtheria were common and most residents suffered from poor housing and atrocious, vitamin-deficient diets. In Britain as a whole, 2,000 people per year died of whooping cough and tuberculosis killed 30,000 annually. The local council, one of the most leftwing in Britain, set about tackling the problems with the ambitious ‘Finsbury Plan’. The idea was to build a comprehensive health centre amid public baths, libraries and nurseries. In the end, only the health centre was built. The centre incorporated a TB clinic, a foot clinic, a dental surgery, and a solarium. The basement had facilities for cleaning and disinfecting bedclothes, and a lecture theatre and mortuary were also included. Lubetkin wanted people to feel welcome but never patronised. He also wanted the centre to be like a club, or a drop-in centre. It was important that people did not feel they were walking into just another bureaucratic staging post. To this end, the reception desk was left out of the original plans (but was added later), and furniture in the foyer was deliberately not arranged into traditional waiting room rows. People had to feel they could drop in at any time and see clinicians in a relaxed, unthreatening atmosphere. Lubetkin also wanted the centre to persuade people to live healthier lives, as well as treat their ailments. Murals on the walls encouraged patients to get some fresh air. The glass bricks of the front wall were a conscious attempt to ‘propagandise’ the physical benefits of a light, airy environment. The solarium allowed the children of Finsbury (who spent much of their early lives enveloped in a thick smog), a chance to feel the benefits of sunlight. Of this revolutionary new approach to public health, Lubetkin famously commented ‘Nothing is too good for ordinary people’. The interior of the Centre was bright-coloured in reds and azures which were designed to contrast with the gloom of the surrounding slums, and the expanse of glass walls on each of the wings would sparkle on sunny days – ‘as beautiful as the hair of a beautiful young girl in the summer sunshine’, according to Lubetkin. Finsbury shows that Modernist buildings do not have to be sombre. Lubetkin saw his Health Centre as a multicoloured beacon in the heart of the smoky city. The Centre was also designed to be a flexible building: in itself a progressive concept in a British building of the 1930s. Lubetkin foresaw that in years to come the changing technology of healthcare would require buildings which could be easily adapted to the new needs of clinicians. The building’s services – its plumbing, wiring, and piping – were all designed with adaptability in mind. The political significance of the Centre was not lost on Winston Churchill. In 1943 he suppressed an Army
An outline review of the main issues (including a summary of the approach to designing health buildings) Bureau poster designed by Abram Games which superimposed the shining centre onto a picture of starving children standing in a slum. Next to the Centre were the words: ‘Your Britain – Fight for it Now’. In 1945, Churchill would lose the General Election and the era of the welfare state, central planning, and the National Health Service, would begin. The marriage of modernist architecture and socialist reforming zeal, first seen at Finsbury, was about to take centre-stage. The most comprehensive analysis of Lubetkin’s work is by John Allan (1992). Allan first met Lubetkin in 1970 and traces a comprehensive review of his life through the 1930s when he founded Tecton (1931) and developed an architectural stance that set him apart from the architectural establishment of the time, and identified his artistic debt to Le Corbusier. The lack of organisation in health services prior to the creation of the NHS was typified in Finsbury as a microcosm of the uncoordinated muddle of facilities throughout the country … In this context of sluggish officialdom in the face of ever more compelling evidence, the Finsbury Health Centre, diminutive as it may now seem, was a conspicuous advance in social policy and administrative coordination, anticipating by a clear decade the reforms embodied in the 1948 Act and … on completion that it marked ‘the dawn of the new era in public health services’. (p. 333) It is interesting to compare the Peckham and Finsbury projects with American senior centres which have developed from the 1965 Older Americans Act. This identified senior centres as the preferred vehicle for coordinated delivery of a range of services in the USA. At the end of the 1980s some 15 per cent of older Americans were members of the 12 000 or so senior centres strung across the USA (Krout et al., 1990). It was predicted that Healthy Living Centres could become the UK equivalent of senior centres, but open to the whole age range (Iliffe, 1999).
Architectural context Design of GP surgeries During the 1980s and 1990s, the starting point for the brief of a doctor’s surgery had been based on the standards set down in the ‘Red Book’. Included in the document is a section on premises, which includes a series of schedules of space standards for different sized GP practices from two to seven doctors. The schedule of allowable areas is linked to a financial formula and establishes the area and financial limit for a new GP surgery. This document makes no reference to the quality of care to be provided within the buildings. Doctors could exceed the financial limits set down by these schedules but any additional finance had to be provided from the doctor’s own resources. In practice, this very rarely occurred.
There are guidance notes available to doctors, and their architects, giving additional information about the design of the spaces within a GP surgery, but there is almost no reference at all to the quality of the design. For example, Health Building Note 46, General Medical Premises, identifies under the sketch design stage at section 3.17 that ‘the architect will base the design of the sketch proposal upon the written brief – a statement of the operational policy and functional space requirements of the practice’. The brief is developed by the GP and the architect in discussion with the primary health care team and the FHSA. At section 4.1 it is noted that the building of new practice premises ‘provides the ideal opportunity to ensure that the building can accommodate all the functional and operational requirements of the primary health team’. As already noted (see section 3.1), the document makes no reference to consideration of the design ethos of the building, and does not invite doctors to consider the quality of the environment that they are wishing to create for their new building. The changing attitude of government policies is noted, including the new LIFT programme of contracts to expand and develop GP premises based on the aspirations of the NHS Plan. There has been a significant shift in government policy which now recognises the importance of good design in the development of new GP surgeries. ‘Red Book’ – the traditional approach The ‘Red Book’ set the standards for the modus operandi of GP practice in the UK for many years. It represented the outcome from a long period of development, periodic reviews and updating of data. It typifies the outcome of a bureaucratic approach of controlling a very large organisation. The rules, costs limits and schedules of permitted accommodation were very prescriptive, and it is interesting that much high quality architectural work has resulted from such a constricting briefing framework. Although the official briefing methodology offered little encouragement, a wide range of innovative GP surgeries has been built over the last decade. This framework of controls is now rapidly breaking down as new forms of procurement expand and develop in the joint public private partnerships that the government is encouraging. Controls on loose furniture, tight budgets, discounted fee scales for professional services and other prescriptive requirements for accommodation requirements and overall floor areas made life difficult for both doctors and architects. A different approach to building design is being advocated for the next wave of primary care buildings. They will be buildings that are flexible, can incorporate the demands of a knowledge-based economy and respond to the rapidly changing demands for information technology and different working methods that will develop from faster communications between doctor, patient and specialist testing facilities (e.g. x-rays, consultant reports). Government procurement methods are seeking to enable future buildings to be flexible shells within which highly serviced workstations can be developed
15
Primary Care Centres and changed over short periods of time. For example, a doctor’s consulting room may have entirely different requirements in five years’ time than it does today – although it is likely to remain the fundamentally important space within which patient and doctor exchange information. Finance Lifecycle costs and ‘best value’ – the government’s approach Until recently, lifecycle costs were assessed in the government process of procuring buildings, including those for the NHS. The tradition has been to award contracts predominantly on a lowest cost basis. The Treasury has now changed its policy and the interest in design quality is also manifesting itself in a reassessment of whole-life costs. This approach is encapsulated under the umbrella of ‘best value’. All government departments and local authorities are taking a broader look at ‘best value’ issues and this is providing an opportunity to develop new thinking about a whole range of tangible and intangible aspects of a building during its overall lifespan. At the simplest level, building material manufacturers are able to demonstrate ‘best value’ for their products not only as the result of initial costs but also taking into account maintenance schedules and renewal timescales. With design issues the growing recognition of user reactions and user satisfaction levels is beginning to influence the decision-making process. GP surgeries are too small to justify the competitive precontract procedures that potential development partners face under PFI (Private Finance Initiative) procedures. The emerging policies from NHS Estates for their Procure 21 method of procurement are yet to be tested in the marketplace and the bundling together of groups of primary health care facilities seems to be a risky strategy. However, there is a growing group of specialist companies forming partnerships with GPs to finance new primary health care facilities. Their success rate in putting together viable procurement packages is being helped because of the changes in attitude by district valuers. District valuers are moving towards the creation of a special class of valuation for medical facilities,
16
whereas previously they were seriously disadvantaged by being included with residential or local commercial values. These high valuations that are being rentalised as surgeries are enabling contracts to be written for a minimum of 25 year lease periods guaranteed by local health authorities under the terms of existing procedures. Cost limits and functionality – a restraint on innovation Hospital design in the UK over the last 50 years is considered by many to have been disappointing.5 With few exceptions, architectural quality has been bland, institutional and not responsive to patients’ needs. The procurement process has been extended, design quality has been largely ignored and functionality has been given high priority in a process largely controlled by the service providers and the administrators far removed from the interface between patient and doctor within the confines of a clinical ward. Similarly, primary health care buildings were constrained by a set of procedures contained within the ‘Red Book’ which is now outdated. There have been enlightened solutions in recent years by architects who have enjoyed a sustained period of work in this sector, but imaginative solutions have been the result of very good architects going beyond the brief which was set out only in terms of cost limits and functionality.
5
For example, the Conservative Party has become interested again in good design. John Gummer is Chairman of the Tory Party’s new environmental group (appointed by the new Conservative leader, David Cameron) and he claims to have a very real passion for architecture and the built environment. He says, ‘Britain went through an enormous philistine period between the end of the Second World War and the early Nineties, when most decisionmakers seemed to almost make a virtue of vulgar Brutalism … this was the period when it seemed to be accepted that it was a morally good thing not to have any decoration or art … when I was secretary of state for the environment I like to believe I began to reverse this attitude, making art and architecture more important … it is too important for the quality of life of people to ignore these things’ (Dorrell, 2006).
3
International comparisons
Introduction – overlapping interests
role of the patient. This emphasis on patient focused care is having two far-reaching results:
As long ago as 1961 Kerr White and his colleagues writing in ‘The ecology of medical care’ (an article that appeared in The New England Journal) observed that ‘the patient may be a more relevant primary unit of observation than the disease, the visit, or the admission’. This work was summarised in the ‘cube’ diagram of health ecology (see Figure 3.1). This research indicated to White and his team that health care delivery and the training of physicians did not bear any logical relationship to the actual experience of illness in a given population. They argued that greater attention should be devoted to primary, continuing medical care as opposed to more exceptional episodes of hospitalisation or consultation of specialists. Further support for these ideas has developed during the last decade. In Europe and the USA, the quality of design is being understood as a benefit to health care environments resulting in much more significance being placed on the
Total A population at risk: 1000
A
Persons receiving primary care: 720
B
B
Persons admitted to C general hospital: 100 Persons admitted to D university hospital: 10 Figure 3.1
Ecology of health problems, annual rates, USA
C D
1. The rich and highly developed countries understand that the primary health care policies of many developing countries are showing significant results. 2. The importance of the workplace environment is being increasingly recognised as a significant factor in achieving a healthy living lifestyle. Neither of these factors is dependent on high levels of income. A healthy diet and good quality working environment in conjunction with an efficient primary health care system can produce very beneficial results.
Health policy is shifting to preventive care in the primary sector Not only in the UK, but also in many other parts of the world, health policies are focusing on the importance of preventive care in the primary health sector. The World Health Organisation’s (WHO) declaration of Alma-Ata in 1978 remains as valid today as when it was adopted. The objectives were: 1. To promote the concept of Primary health care in all countries. 2. To exchange experience and information on the development of Primary health care within the framework of comprehensive national health systems and services. 3. To evaluate the present healthcare situation throughout the world as it relates to, and can be improved by, Primary health care. 4. To define the principles of Primary health care as well as the operational means of overcoming practical problems in the development of Primary health care.
17
Primary Care Centres 5. To define the role of Government’s national and international organisations in technical co-operation and support for the development of Primary health care. 6. To formulate recommendations for the development of Primary health care. (World Health Organisation, 1978, p. 11) The declaration goes on (p. 34) to provide a definition: Primary health care is essential healthcare made universally accessible to individuals and families in the community by means acceptable to them, through their full participation and at a cost that the community and country can afford. It forms an integral part both of the country’s health system of which it is the nucleus and the overall social and economic development of the community. Primary health care addresses the main health problems in the community, providing promotive, preventive, curative and rehabilitative services accordingly. In order to make Primary health care universally accessible in the community as quickly as possible, maximum community and individual self-reliance for health development are essential. To attain such self-reliance requires full community participation in the planning, organisation and management of Primary health care. As long ago as 1995, an editorial in the BMJ (7 October, pp. 891–892) was highlighting that over the past 30 years a wide range of developing countries have successfully developed a model of primary care promoted by the World Health Organisation. This is based on the idea of ‘essential healthcare based on practical science particularly sound and socially acceptable methods of technology, made universally accessible to individuals and families in the community through their full participation and at a cost that the community and country can afford to maintain’. It went on to say that this ‘differs fundamentally from the primary care system in the United Kingdom, which relies more on technical and curative care than the community orientated approach. Many western countries, including the United Kingdom are now, however, shifting their policies to strengthen primary health care, and there could be lessons to be learnt from the achievements of developing countries. The WHO had recognised the importance of community health workers and put forward a global strategy goal of ‘health for all by year 2000’ and pointed out the task of achieving this based on primary health care during the Alma-Ata Conference in 1978. Community oriented primary care is a theme that has been picked up in the UK by the current Labour government as it has moved its policies set out in the NHS Plan 2000 towards its patient focused care objectives, and increasingly is advocating the development of community-based hospitals.
18
In the 1950’s and 60’s many developing countries faced a daunting task. Economic recession meant that many could not even start to emulate the west’s medical model of health based on hospital medicine and high technology. A different model of care emerged, which recognised that the health of populations was determined by factors other than medical care and that these factors could be controlled by communities themselves, through collaboration with other sectors, such as agriculture, water sanitation and education in a spirit of self reliance and self determination. These words, from the same BMJ editorial in 1995, highlight the difference from Western health models and those supported and developed in countries with socialist administrations such as China, Cuba and Tanzania. The government of China has endorsed the WHO agreement and done much work towards implementing it. The new policies in the United Kingdom that are led by primary health care trusts have therefore resulted from international health policies based on the experiences of many developing countries over the past 30 years. A wealth of knowledge about primary health care exists in developing countries, which is now relevant to the NHS. It is time for us to recognise this and learn from it. China has drawn up a national plan for improving primary health care in rural areas, aiming to make services accessible to all rural residents who make up to about 80 per cent of its population. However, the gap between standards of health care between urban areas and rural areas is widening. Government officials have said that the goal of promoting primary health care in rural areas was to give basic medical services to every resident. This work was vital for the global fulfilment of health for all goals set by the WHO. In the coming years, departments of development planning, finance, public health, agriculture and environmental protection will work jointly to control infectious and endemic diseases, vermin and occupational illnesses, to help further improve village clinics and to ensure more people can have access to clean drinking water and standardised toilets. China achieved enviable improvement in the health status of its people between 1952 and 1982. Despite a limited number of well-trained professionals and hospital beds and an expenditure of US$5 per capita for health care, within 30 years the country increased the average life expectancy from 35 to 68 years (Hsiao, 1995). The developed and underdeveloped countries are, therefore, moving more closely towards a common philosophy for community-based primary health care services. South Africa is perhaps a good example where the excellent tertiary health care facilities have been modelled on Western standards. There is a high standard of academic medicine in the country and South Africa spends 6.4 per cent of its gross domestic product on health, which is more than the
International comparisons based on internal medicine. Confucius was opposed to cutting the human body so surgery was not developed. Chinese medicine was based on empirical knowledge – to observe the patient’s indications and to question the patient’s feeling as an individual. Chinese doctors investigated by observation a patient’s total sense of well-being or illness. In contrast, Western medicine has developed over the last two centuries, refining analytical skills and the development of specific technical research programmes. Today, China is struggling to understand the compromises between traditional Chinese medicine and Western technology. In Japan, before the introduction of Chinese culture and medicine in the 6th century, local Japanese medical skills were based on the ancient Shinto religion, which principally worships nature, so the Japanese had medical gods (Daikoku Ebisu), which could be compared to the Asclepious in Greece. After the introduction of Chinese medicine to Japan, most doctors were monks who had a strong influence on society including politics. There are great similarities between the Japanese monastic care services for poor people in temples and the Western monastic care during the same period. Gradually, Western culture invaded Japan but the Japanese government was concerned about the infiltration of Western high-tech culture and
goal – 5 per cent by the year 2000 – set by the WHO. But 46 per cent of this amount is spent on the private sector, which serves 19 per cent of the population. South African health policy for the primary sector aims to achieve a balance between promotion, prevention, rehabilitation and curative services. An example of a community resource (library and clinic) in the Blaawberg Municipality, City of Cape Town, is included as a case study.
Japanese primary health care systems The development of the Japanese health system, and its underlying philosophies, has been influenced by both Chinese and Western traditions (see Figures 3.2 and 3.3). Western traditions have been influenced by the Hippocratic period from early civilisations, the monastic care, which developed in the Middle Ages, and more recently the technical advancements, which began in the middle of the 19th century. Medical science rapidly developed and nursing care was transformed by the work of Florence Nightingale. In contrast, the development of Chinese medicine saw progress at a very early period (around 2000 years ago) but was
1776: The declaration of independence of the USA
Western and Eastern medical history timeline
Mid of 18C: Proposal for replacing hotel-dieu
Before Independence
USA
450–370 BC: Hippocrates
Western
China
1456: Ospedale maggiore
Philosophical medicine
500 Japan
Western monastery care 0
500
(Shinto Japanese religion)
Philosophical medicine
The basement of Chinese medicine completed
1000
400–200 BC: Chinese medicine got high level – herbal medicine, acupuncture, etc. Western Medicine
1500
2000
Chinese monastery care
Not much change in Chinese medicine
400–500 AD: Starting to introduce Chinese culture into Japan
Figure 3.2
Nightingale Kirkbride
Japan: Closure of ports Japan: Reopening of ports Western medicine into Japan Chinese Medicine
Diagrammatic history of medicine (timeline comparisons USA, Western, Japan and China)
19
Primary Care Centres
Western medicine and Chinese medicine
Formative process
Western medicine Development period
Basement
Special field
Chinese medicine
From 16th century to17th century
From 4BC to AD2 (600 years)
Refined analysis and local specific research
Empirical knowledge Medical theory based on acupuncture and moxibustion, herbal medicine
Bacteriology, surgery
Internal medicine (Confucianism opposed cutting human body, so surgery has not been developed)
- Reveal the illness point and the cause based on objective scientific data from many examinations
- Observe the patient’s indications and question the patient’s feeling
- Value the type of diseases Exclude individual and categorise diseases
- Recognise comprehensive patient’s symptoms individually
Diagnosis
Treatment features
- Surgery - Drugs
- Acupuncture - Moxibustion - Herbal and mineral medicine
Figure 3.3 Comparison of Western and Chinese medicine
limited trade with overseas. Japan suffered a period of isolation and the Japanese culture flourished in this late middle age period. Thereafter, Japanese culture rapidly became Westernised. Today, as communications become global, Western and Chinese medicine are becoming increasingly inter-related. In contrast, the development of Western medicine has evolved through the research of special areas including bacteriology and surgery. Western philosophy is based on the diagnostic techniques to reveal illness and identify the cause based on objective scientific data. These ancient philosophical approaches can therefore be seen to have influenced modern political policies for health care in China, Japan and Western Europe including the UK. The priority given to the patient as an individual has changed in the West. As Western technology developed, the importance of the patient as an individual decreased, and it is only in the last 20 years or so that there has been a re-emergence of concern for the patient as an individual. In Japan, present day health statistics are very revealing when compared to those of the USA. Japan has universal health insurance and its total health expenditure as a percentage of the gross domestic product is almost 50 per cent less than that of the USA. In the USA about 15 per cent of the population under aged 65 are uninsured. However, the health of the Japanese population, as judged by neonatal, postnatal and total infant fatality, percentage of infants with birth weights below 2500 grams and life expectancy
20
at birth and ages 20 and 65, is superior to the health of Americans. Primary care in Japan, as an academic discipline, and primary care training programmes are absent in Japan. However, considerable difficulties are emerging in Japan today with hospital outpatient departments seriously overstretched and record systems are at a surprisingly inefficient level. Compared to the UK, where everyone has a medical record held by his or her GP, Japan has no comparable system. This leads to great repetition of early diagnostic testing because no historical records are readily available. Hence, when someone visits a hospital outpatients department the diagnosis process starts very often from square one. This must lead to great inefficiencies and an overloading of health care services at the primary level. Figures 3.2 and 3.3 were prepared by Ruka Kosuge, PhD student, Tokyo University (unpublished lecture, November 2005). In recent years, there has been a series of initiatives and exchanges between UK and Japanese architects working in the health sector and there is a much better understanding of the differences between the systems for primary health care in the UK and Japan (Cooper, 2006). Although there has been no tradition to build primary care centres in Japan, a wide range of smaller health facilities have recently been constructed including community hospitals, private medical clinics and specialist health care projects such as sheltered premises for the elderly and small-scale private clinics for cancer patients. As in many other parts
International comparisons of the world, there is now a greater awareness of the quality of life and this has produced an emphasis on ‘healing and comfort’ (Cooper, 2006, p. 95).
Client: Blaawbert Municipality, City of Cape Town Blaawberg Sub-structure Architect: Ngonyama Okpanum and Associates (NOA) Introduction
Conclusion The lessons to be learnt, in general, from examining primary care systems in the developing world might be considered under three headings: 1. Health for all – a WHO objective sought through the primary care system. A community-oriented primary care system supported and encouraged by the developed countries but until recently not recognised as a model for their own environment. 2. Fear of socialism was a concern of developed countries, cautious that ideological concepts of primary care for all in developing countries would undermine the 20th century models of health care based on technical advancement and issues of professional status. 3. More recently (from the 1990s), the emergence of a caring society in developed countries, and the view that there are wider determinants of health by engaging with wider community issues and other sectors outside the health service. Although there are many initiatives under way throughout the world many of the ideas can be traced back to giving greater importance to patient focused care. In poor and underdeveloped countries, great strides are being taken to achieve better standards of primary health care. There is concern about the well-being of everyone as an individual, and how this is reflected in their working environment to provide a safe and healthy future for their economic development. In the rich countries of the world, these issues are being addressed by more imaginative architectural solutions, often for smaller-scale buildings. In Europe, a large number of smaller health buildings are being commissioned where the quality of design is given a high priority. Like the UK case studies, there are many examples around Europe of delightful environments being created for health facilities.
Albow Gardens Library and Clinic; Architect: Ngonyama Okpanum and Associates (NOA)
In 1999, Ngonyama Okpanum and Associates (NOA) were commissioned to design a public facility for the Blaawberg Municipality, City of Cape Town Blaawberg Sub-structure. The facility was to include a clinic and a library for the people of Albow Gardens, Brooklyn and Du-Noon. This previously predominantly disadvantaged community did not have any public facility and its inhabitants needed to travel great distances for these services. It is imperative to have a primary health care facility within a reasonable distance in all suburbs in Africa Urban Planning Context, in order to contain the scourge of all types of infectious diseases, such as malaria, TB, AIDS and others. The complex supports the government policy of accessible primary health care to all. This building encompasses two disparate services under one roof, and by so doing contributes to the community and its educational and recreational activities as well as to the quality of its built environment. Despite its size the new facility has become a focal point for the local community regardless of age, status and interests. Planning rationale
International examples of primary care and community buildings The following illustrations show a small number of buildings in Europe and Japan and, in addition, a more detailed description of a mixed use building (clinic and library) in South Africa.
South Africa Project: Albow Gardens Library and Clinic
The architectural planning articulating the complex reenforces the concept of combining public services into one facility. The building is compact in design and the arrival and movement of visitors is clear and unambiguous. The main entrance wing connects the clinic and the library wings, housing combined facilities such as a kitchen, ablutions and a community hall. These three building masses can be distinctly read from the parking area, which acts as a forecourt precinct to the building. On arrival, one is directed from the parking area to the amphitheatre and on to the main entrance to the secondary entrances of the clinic or the library.
21
Primary Care Centres Simple H-plan concept While the conceptual bones of the design are kept to a simple H-plan, the concrete brick skin that wraps around the building modulates the perimeter walls. These external walls have various architectural elements designed to guide relief to the facade. It creates a play of varying shadows and light throughout the day. The corners of the library and clinic wings are cut away to accommodate a freestanding painted column. The rainwater down pipes are detailed and integrated into the brick structural nibs with a defined rhythm around the building. At the centre of each ‘wing’, the brickwork is recessed to create an inverted bay window. Albow Gardens Library and Clinic; Architect: Ngonyama Okpanum and Associates (NOA). See Appendix A for coloured figure
Building location on site This single-storey building sits in a prominent position in the centre of its site. Set back from the road, the building is easily visible from the street with its scenic backdrop of Table Mountain and Lion’s Head. The clerestory lighting protrudes from the building symmetrically to the entrance. This additional feature adds height and interest to the building frontage. The pedestrian access is defined by a bricked path which cuts through the parking areas and connects to a landscaped amphitheatre.
Additional elements Several climate control devices have been ‘clipped onto’ the external skin. Aerofoil sunscreens protect the western facade from harsh rays. They are located on the west facade neatly inserted within the space created by the modulated walls. The two entrances are defined by steel canopies that project, front and back, from the central ‘wing’. They relieve the formality of the rectilinear walls and are playful elements. Reception areas The reception areas on both sides of the main entrance are flooded with overhead light. Each reception area is defined by a steel frame suspended from the ring beam above. This beam delineates the central area of the room. From this point, the roof structure tilts up to allow natural south light to percolate into the spaces below. The timber trusses with steel ties are exposed which heightens the effect internally of the external architectural bulk. Microclimate control Mechanical fans are built into these windows to draw the warm air up and out of the spaces below. The structural elements of column, beam and truss are all painted blue, the steel ties red, creating colour contrast. Light shafts and dematerialisation of the corners
Albow Gardens Library and Clinic; Architect: Ngonyama Okpanum and Associates (NOA)
Once inside the complex there is an awareness of the large amount of natural light that floods into the rooms. The corners of the building dissolve into vertical light shafts. The windows are adapted to the functions within the rooms sitting squarely within the walls where necessary or below the ceiling to give privacy and light.
Urban square–amphitheatre feature The front entrance amphitheatre creates an urban square and an outdoor room as a precursor to the main entrance. The amphitheatre is landscaped and has curved steps, and two further landscaped courts are placed on either side of the main entrance. The dual purpose amphitheatre acts as a reading room for library school groups and as an overflow waiting area for the clinic.
22
Conclusion It is necessary to highlight the importance of the presence of a primary health care facility that is predominantly located within the urban fabric and easily accessible for the public. The success of this facility as a valuable urban community complex has been enhanced by the fusion of its function and structure. Architecture is used as both a serious and attractive force to promote the needs of the people it serves.
23
International comparisons
Albow Gardens Library and Clinic; Architect: Ngonyama Okpanum and Associates (NOA)
Primary Care Centres
24 Albow Gardens Library and Clinic; Architect: Ngonyama Okpanum and Associates (NOA)
25
International comparisons
Albow Gardens Library and Clinic; Architect: Ngonyama Okpanum and Associates (NOA)
Primary Care Centres Japan
Germany
Designer: Hamada Kawashima Architects
New Children’s Clinic, Darmstadt
New Children’s Clinic, Darmstadt; Architect: Angela Fritsch Spa Rehabilitation Clinic, Kawashima Architects
Amakusa;
Architect:
Hamada
The Japanese have one of the longest life expectancies in the world, with over 20 000 centenarians.
New Children’s Clinic, Darmstadt; Architect: Angela Fritsch
New Children’s Clinic, Darmstadt; Architect: Angela Fritsch Machida Court, Tokyo; Architect: Masanobu Komuro, Sapporo, Japan
This building was built in a Tokyo suburb and accommodates a dental practice and two apartments.
26
Designed by Angela Fritsch this building was inspired by Alvar Aalto. Having studied sculpture before architecture the building form is based on the rounded forms of a glass vase designed by Aalto.
International comparisons Radon Revival Spa in Menzenschwand, St Blasien
Radon Revival Spa in Menzenschwand, St Blasien; Architect: Sacker Architekten, Freiburg, Darmstadt
A new medicinal and wellness spa designed by Sacker Architekten built in a nature reserve in the Southern Black Forest. Vital Centre, Ostfildern
Vital Center, Ostfildern; Architect: HSP Hoppe Sommer Planungs GmbH, Stuttgart, Darmstadt
A health centre combining preventive care and rehabilitation with therapy for inpatients and outpatients. Facilities include treatment areas such as the exercise apparatus and physiotherapy area, the wellness area, sauna and steam bath.
27
4
Political framework
The NHS Plan (2000) stresses the importance of patient centred care and envisaged the formation of Primary Care Trusts (PCTs). These Trusts are developing the control and procurement of primary health care facilities and are working with other agencies such as Social Services (a local authority function) and Mental Health Care to create community-based centres offering a wide range of services. They will respond to local services and the briefs will include specific needs, where appropriate, such as dentists, pharmacists, retail units and even cafés. Government policy regarding the design quality of health buildings has changed significantly since 2000. For example, NHS Estates identified design quality as one of four main themes in their Procure 21 programme and defined it as follows: Our programme aims to deliver design quality in NHS buildings. Good design creates the best atmosphere for the patients, staff and visitors, promoting more effective services and a speedier recovery. We propose to build on our existing programme, working with the NHS and other colleagues. This focuses on identifying and sharing best practice, anticipating development so that designs can reflect future clinical needs as well as design competitions, with NHS and Private Sector colleagues. (NHS Estates, 2000) At a national level, the UK government is also strongly promoting the importance of design quality in public buildings. However, results from the PFI (Private Finance Initiative) programme raise serious doubts about the effectiveness of good design intentions to survive the rigorous ‘value engineering’ processes.1 These concentrate on providing the best ‘value for money’ by focusing on quality control of the process rather than design quality of the product. Health Building Notes 36 and 46 published by NHS Estates set out their advice on the briefing and design implications of departmental policy. Health Building Note 46 ‘focuses on general medical practice premises and is
28
intended to assist GPs and their architects in understanding the problems and principles involved in building new premises for general practice, or in converting or refurbishing existing premises. It seeks to help GPs and all those concerned in a project through the various processes of a building scheme from inception to completion.’ The document concentrates on functional and practical issues of design and typifies the historical approach to health buildings briefing which has concentrated on defining spatial requirements and setting cost limits, in the belief that the appointed architect would transform this data into a welldesigned building (NHS Estates, 1991). Health Building Note 36, Local Health Care Facilities, does include a statement that Primary Health Care Centres and Local Health Care Resource Centres should be planned and designed to provide patients and their escorts with high quality facilities which will be as easy as possible for staff to manage and operate. The layout of these Centres should be simple and straightforward: long corridors, awkward corners, and changes in level should be avoided. The design should help to assure patients that they are receiving a high quality service. To this end, particular attention 1
Value engineering (VE) is an American concept, developed at General Electric Corp. during World War II and is widely used in industry and government. VE is defined as ‘an analysis of the functions of a program, project, system, product, item of equipment, building, facility, service or supply of an executive agency, performed by qualified agency or contractor personnel, directed at improving performance, reliability, quality, safety, and life cycle costs’. VE is an effective technique for reducing costs, increasing productivity and improving quality. It is a technique directed toward analysing the functions of an item or process to determine ‘best value’. In this context, the application of VE in facilities construction can yield a better value when construction is approached in a manner that incorporates environmentally sound and energy-efficient practices and materials. (Office of Management and Budget: www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars, accessed 15/01/2006, circular no. A131.)
Political framework should be paid to the visual aspects of Centres as well as to functional and environmental needs. Patients and escorts may be anxious; the building design should help to alleviate patient’s stress. Particular care should be taken with the most public spaces, especially waiting areas. (NHS Estates, 1995, p. 21)2 However, there are no qualitative components to this design guide, and therefore the architect is given no guidance on the expected environmental qualities of these buildings. It is this lack of qualitative definitions that provides a major opportunity to improve the briefing process for future primary health care buildings. In the last few years there have been several initiatives that have produced a series of documents designed to enhance awareness of the importance of good design. These include ●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Advice – a document developed by the Design Brief Working Group (DBWG). Chaired by architect Richard Burton the group comprised a multidisciplinary team of practitioners in architecture, design, engineering and health care planning. Better Health Buildings – in October 2000 the Prime Minister published Better Public Buildings, which called for a step change in the quality of the nation’s public buildings. Better Health Buildings is the Department of Health’s response. Launched on 1 May 2002 it addressed many of the Department’s design initiatives such as Design Champions. Achieving Excellence Design Evaluation Toolkit (AEDET) – a toolkit for evaluating the design of health care buildings from initial proposals through to postproject evaluation. NHS Estates Design Review Panel – set up by the Secretary of State in November 2001 to provide advice, guidance and support to the NHS in the form of a design review. Initially looking at hospitals this peer review process is looking at primary care buildings and local community hospitals. The Architectural Health Care Environment and its Effect on Patient Health Outcomes – a report on the NHS Estates funded research project led by Professor Brian Lawson and Dr Michael Phiri of the University of Sheffield School of Architecture in collaboration with John Wells-Thorpe. CABE (Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment) is also looking closely at the design of health buildings with work led by Susan Francis. The RIBA (Royal Institute of British Architects) has also established CDAs (Client Design Advisers) to give independent advice to clients on procurement policy and briefing documentation.
The Prince’s Foundation also worked with NHS Estates on a joint initiative ‘Building a Better Patient Environment’ 2
Health Building Note 36 has been superseded by a website www.primarycarecontracting.nhs.uk/planning-and-design-guidance. php
assisting five NHS Trusts in delivering a design vision for their schemes. Following the winding-up of NHS Estates these design policy responsibilities are now administered by the Department of Health.
New policies funded with major capital investment Following the launch of the NHS Plan in 2000, procurement policies directed towards the health sector have been evolved based on the principle of introducing private finance to fund capital projects. The PFI model has been used for a number of large-scale hospital projects. Two other programmes have been developed specifically for the health sector known as Procure 21 and LIFT. Procure 21 is aimed at medium sized projects from £5 million to £25 million in capital value and includes a number of communitybased projects. The LIFT Programme (Local Improvement Finance Trust) is an initiative to stimulate the funding and operation of primary health care facilities. Many PCTs are developing programmes for the redevelopment of primary care facilities within their area using the LIFT Programme. The NHS Plan 2000 also tackles the issues that no health system is free. Generally, health expenditure in the UK as a percentage of GDP has been lower than in many other European countries and the USA. Since the launch of the NHS Plan 2000 the Treasury has steadily introduced measures through general taxation to fund a catch-up period with a target of health spending representing 9.4% of GDP by 2008 – easily matching European levels of health spending (Figure 4.1). The changes envisaged in the delivery of services, and the additional finance set aside to fund these developments, highlight how the 1948 model of the NHS is now inadequate for today’s needs. Figure 4.2 illustrates these comparisons (Department of Health – www.dh.gov.uk). Recent statements by the Department of Health set out present government policy, which is driven by more focus on patient responsibility. The major part of the structural changes in health care delivery is based on the development of the PCTs who will, over a period of years, become responsible for controlling budgets of over 75 per cent of NHS expenditure. The PCTs will be encouraged to promote diversity in supply and encourage new initiatives and incentives to develop patient choice. Patients will be given greater access to their medical information to enable a more informed choice about where that medical care should be provided. It may be at a location closer to a patient’s home or at a location where waiting lists are shorter. The following extract from Primary Care, General Practice and the NHS Plan (January 2001) sets out the framework envisaged by the government for primary health. 1. The NHS Plan is an ambitious but practical blueprint to restore and modernise the health service around its founding principles. The goal, through reform and investment, is
29
Primary Care Centres 140.0 Expenditure (£ billions)
Education
120.0
Health
100.0 80.0 60.0 40.0 20.0 0.0 2003–04
2004–05
2005–06
2006–07
2007–08
2008–09
2009–10
2010–11
Figure 4.1 Pre-Budget Report 2008 summary (HM Treasury, 2008) – Health and Education spending
1948 model
New model
Values: free at point of need
Values: free at point of need
Spending: annual lottery
Spending: planned for 3/5 years
National standards: none
National standards: NICE, NSFs and single independent healthcare inspectorate/regulator
Providers: monopoly
Providers: plurality – state/private/voluntary
Staff: rigid professional demarcations
Staff: modernised flexible professions benefiting patients
Patients: handed down treatment
Patients: choice of where and when to get treatment
System: top down
System: led by frontline – devolved to primary care
Appointments: long waits
Appointments: short waits, booked appointments
Figure 4.2 Comparisons in the NHS (1948 model and current model)
to secure the modern, high-quality and convenient health service that both patients and primary care professionals want. 2. General practice has a vital role in achieving this goal. The future of the NHS rests on the strength of its primary care services. General practice has always been central to the NHS. Nine out of ten NHS patients are seen in primary care, while it remains the gateway to secondary care and has a key role in helping people stay at home and out of hospital. 3. The public trusts and values family doctors. But GPs and primary care staff also know that the expectations of patients are rising. People want more convenient and quicker access to advice and treatment. 4. GPs and other primary care staff share the desire to improve the NHS. Many practices are leading the way in meeting patient needs. The NHS Plan will build on their work by enhancing the role of primary care and putting in place the policies and investment to expand and improve services and raise standards further. The NHS Plan will mean: ● Primary care will provide a greater range of services with control over £25 billion of the NHS budget.
30
●
●
●
●
Resources will be directed at improving professional working lives, increasing job satisfaction and supporting GPs and other primary care staff in improving patient care. Successful, flexible multidisciplinary working with respect for individual professionals will be developed further to delivery better services to patients. The practice will remain the basic unit of primary care within a system in which standards are improved and a wider range of more accessible services is offered. Practices will be offered greater freedoms and incentives as modernisation proceeds. ● 3000 GP premises to be substantially refurbished or replaced by 2004. ● 500 one stop primary care centres by 2004. ● All GPs have access to NHSnet by 2002. ● 50% of PCTs to have electronic personal medical records by 2004. ● Electronic prescribing of medicines by 2004. ● At least 2000 more GPs and 450 more than now in training by 2004. ● All PCGs to become PCTs by 2004.
Political framework ●
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
● ● ●
New Care Trusts to commission primary, community and social care. 1000 extra primary care mental health workers. 500 extra community mental health workers. A new national contract. A major expansion of PMS. New arrangements for single-handed practices. 48 hour appointment target by 2004. Practice staff to book hospital appointments within guaranteed timescales. NHS Direct to triage all out of hours calls by 2004. 1000 GP specialists. Nurses undertaking more roles.
Too many GP practices are housed in rundown and out-ofdate buildings that are depressing for staff and patients. The NHS Plan provides £1 billion investment to refurbish some 3000 GP premises and build 500 one-stop centres with doctors, dentists, pharmacists, opticians and other services on one site.
NHS LIFT The NHS Local Improvement Finance Trust (NHS LIFT) will work to provide capital for local investment strategies that have been formed from the bottom up, based on the assessment by PCGs (Primary Care Groups) and PCTs of the needs of their practices. There will be substantial investment in IT. Some 70 per cent of practices are already connected and access to NHSnet will become universal, funded fully by government. It will be developed to help GPs diagnose, inform, prescribe for and refer patients more easily. GPs and other staff will also use IT to access up-to-date and accurate information on patients’ medical histories and order tests more easily and quickly. GPs and practice staff should have straightforward systems to book hospital appointments on the spot in the surgery, offering their patients the choice of a convenient time within a guaranteed timescale. The government sets out its vision for primary care as follows: ● ● ● ● ●
universal, fast and convenient access by informed patients to an extended range of high quality services delivered in modern primary care settings by suitably trained and qualified primary care professionals.
These services require greater flexibility from the buildings developed by the NHS over more than 60 years since its formation in 1948. Primary care centres are one group of buildings in a wide range of facilities being developed from major acute hospitals with close links to world class research and teaching facilities to a wide range of smaller and more locally based buildings providing services for less urgent medical demands. This increase in flexibility is also reflected in the wider range of financial management of these assets.
NHS LIFT is one of the major government initiatives created to develop a wider range of primary care buildings. It is a vehicle for improving and developing front line primary and community care facilities, which will allow PCTs to invest in new premises in new locations. NHS LIFT is flexible in respect of the type of buildings it provides. The approach does not provide a building in which to put services. Rather it allows the building design to reflect the needs of the services. To date, LIFT is providing a range of building types including re-provision of GP premises, one-stop primary care centres, integrated health and local authority service centres and community hospitals. The one-stop shop principle is an important component of NHS LIFT – allowing the patient to be treated in his or her locality in so-called ‘One-Stop-Centres’ or primary care centres that are modern, convenient, easy to access and staffed by a wide range of health care professionals. The growth of the NHS over the first 50 years of its life has resulted in it becoming a victim of its own success. Following the publication of the NHS Plan (2000), the government has begun to develop its responses to a range of political pressures in both the acute and primary care sectors. Major expenditure has been channelled into the PFI system whereby private capital is introduced, thereby reducing the need for the government to raise additional tax revenue. This shift in financial policy is also reflected in the primary care sector by the introduction of LIFT as well as the encouragement of private developers to enter into private arrangements with GP practices. It has been noted (Nazarko, 2006) that the NHS employs 1.3 million people and is the third largest employer in the world after the Indian State Railways and Chinese Army. In the UK one person in 23 of the working population is employed by the NHS and since 1997 the NHS has taken on an extra 230 000 staff. The NHS now employs 386 000 nurses, 109 000 doctors and 122 100 scientists and therapists (Lister, 2004). Despite the increase in staffing and resources, the government is concerned that primary care is expensive and has not succeeded in moving the NHS forward. There are plans to reform primary care and to open up primary care provisions to foundation trusts and the independent sector. However, when the NHS was introduced politicians thought it would be more expensive in the early years and cheaper as the NHS improved the health of the nation. Increasingly, it is being recognised that there can be no limit to the amount of money being spent on ‘cures’ and that the balance of expenditure should move towards preventing people from becoming ill in the first place. This shift in government policy is now being reflected in the range of White Papers now emerging as the ten year programme of work envisaged in the NHS Plan of 2000 reaches its middle phases. Primary Care Trusts have been introduced (2001) and these were overseen by strategic health authorities. The Department of Health envisages that primary care would move from being purchasers and providers of care to simply being purchasers. Care would be purchased from a range of sources including arm’s length companies set up as community nursing, community hospitals and intermediate care teams. These ideas
31
Primary Care Centres are developed in the White Paper ‘Our health, our care, our say’ (Department of Health, 2006), which explains that one of the aims of reorganisation is to open the market to more diverse providers with more freedom to innovate and improve services. PCTs will be expected to assess all the services they commission, including those they directly provide, to ensure that they provide equity, quality and value for money. This also raises the question as to whether the private sector can provide the same services more cost effectively. Also implicit in this approach is the idea that private sector employers can employ staff more efficiently and more effectively than the NHS where pension fund costs currently run at approximately 20 per cent of salary costs. Clearly, the cost of pension provision is an issue at the centre of government fiscal policy. Once again, the government is seeking to devise procedures to shift responsibilities for pension provision from the state to private individuals. Legislation is being introduced to oblige all employees to make contributions to pension provision. Fundamentally, the political debate will centre around the range of services provided by the NHS, and taken to an extreme view it raises the question as to whether the NHS will become a franchise rather than a provider of services. Secretary of State Patricia Hewitt, writing in the foreword of the White Paper ‘Our health, our care, our say’ (Department of Health, 2006), says that the document set out a new and ambitious vision for the future of our community services and that patients wanted ‘seamless health and social care to help them to stay healthy and to lead independent lives with more services provided locally’. She continues: ‘implementing the White Paper will involve a fundamental shift to provide care closer to home, where the overwhelming majority of people’s daily contacts with services take place, and where the services can fit around the lives people want to lead’. The aim is to help people to make healthy choices in environments that support their physical and mental health and well-being. The Department of Health is trailing individual budgets in social care and developing new approaches to prevention and shift in care out of hospitals. This is also giving rise to pilot projects to provide direct payments and individual budgets to provide new levels of choice and control for people who need support from social care services. The White Paper argues that practice-based commissioning gives primary health care teams the freedom and incentives to develop new models of support, to strengthen prevention and early intervention and avoid unnecessary admissions to hospitals. This development of the patient centred care philosophy recognises that new mechanisms and other tools and developments are required to provide the best services. This will include:
●
The government says that these principles are at the heart of everything they wish to undertake. However, the opposition, not surprisingly, is critical of these developments and the leader of the Conservative Party, David Cameron, said on 10 October 2006 that ‘he would give doctors more power, patients more choice and health providers more competition’. The opposition party have said that they would ensure that an NHS board would run the health service. The board would be responsible for allocating resources, commissioning services and increasing standards of care, the government would remain accountable to the electorate for spending and for decisions about the scope of what is offered by the NHS. A Conservative policy commission on health has also proposed introducing more competition in the NHS. This, it says, would allow patients to choose their health care provider and allow groups of specialist clinicians in private sector organisations to commission services. The White Paper ‘Our health, our care, our say: a new direction for community services’ was published at the end of January 2006. It advocates a new direction for social care and community health services with four main goals: ●
●
● ●
●
ensuring the changes put people at the centre of their care and developing the local partnerships that are needed to support them; getting upstream on prevention, early intervention and support for individuals for self-care and promoting wellbeing for the wider population;
32
Better prevention and early intervention for improved health, independence and well-being. More choice and a stronger voice for individuals and communities. Tackling inequalities and improving access to services. More support for people with long-term needs.
The White Paper ‘Our health, our care, our say: making it happen’ developed the argument set out by the government and highlighted those areas where early substantial progress was being made. It identified a ‘road map’ towards implementation (Figure 4.3). With regard to primary care the targets set include the following points: ●
●
Exploring incentives for practices to expand – review of primary medical care contracts (2006/07). A nationally led, locally tailored procurement way of supporting equitable provision of primary care (2006/07).
Patients are identified as key partners in this process and the following targets have been identified: ●
●
planning how to shift care – not just shifting activity from one big building into another smaller one, but developing models of care that support people in communities and in their homes; reducing unnecessary admissions to hospitals and institutions; and getting in early to stop problems developing.
●
●
Framework for choice, incorporating information for choice (2007). Creation of expert patients’ programme community interest company with increased investment (2006). Development of information, prescription and piloting an integrated approach to provision, and searching, of information (2006/07).
Political framework
Users as partners • Services designed around people • Public engagement • Implementation of self-care strategy • Use of direct payments and individual budgets
Intelligent commissioning • Joint strategic needs assessment • Use of PBC, PbR/tariff • Use of LAAs • Plans for development of primary and community care, including shifting resources
Provision • Review of resource use • Integrated workforce planning and delivery • Exploration of co-location • Better partnership working with third and independent sectors
Starting point for local action
Leadership • Appointment of DASS and DPH • Joint leadership development of DASS, Director of Children’s Services, PCT Chief Executive • Strategic partnership/sign up to achieving WP goals
Quality • Use of informed best practice, e.g. NSFs, NICE, SCIE guidelines • Development and deployment of care pathways • Information for users • Implementation of choice • Survey of patient experience
Improved outcomes by... Better prevention with earlier intervention More choice with a stronger voice Tackling inequalities and improving access to community services More support for people with long-term needs Figure 4.3
‘Road map’ for implementing change (2006)
Evidence-based design and the evidence base of interventions are both seen as targets for defining and measuring preventive health budgets during the latest stages of the NHS Plan 2000. Politically, the government recognises the importance of greater patient participation in the management of each individual’s health care. It is moving towards better prevention and early intervention for improved health, independence and well-being. Research undertaken by the Department of Health indicates that people want to take more control of their own health and well-being but want more support to do this. This has led to the concept of NHS ‘life check’, which will be a two-part service – a self-assessment followed by personalised advice and support for those shown to be at risk – and is aimed at helping people to assess the risk of ill health created by their own lifestyles. Initially, NHS life checks are being developed for use at three key life stages – the first year of life, adolescence and mid-life (age 50–60). Piloting of these programmes is under way across the country. Research has also indicated that millions of people suffer from mild to moderate mental health problems, and treating them takes up about a third of GPs’ time. The White Paper also makes commitments to extend the availability of direct payments to groups of people currently excluded from receiving them, and to increase awareness and boost the uptake of direct payments. There is also a plan to pilot the use of individual budgets. The intention is that this will increase individual control over the services received.
Individual budgets will build on some of the features of direct payments by increasing people’s choice and control over the way they are supported. As well as social care funding, it will bring together different resource streams, but an individual might receive, for example, access to work and independent living funds, and allocate a single transparent sum to them. Following the White Paper ‘Our health, our care, our say’, published in January 2006, the government published the White Paper ‘Our health, our care, our say: investing in the future of community hospitals and services’ in July 2006. It announced that the Department of Health would invest £750 million of capital funding over the next five years in a new generation of community hospitals and services, and gave detailed guidance to PCTs wishing to bid for some of this capital. The design principles stated that the services should: ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
be locally led provide high quality services redesign patient pathways anticipate future needs as the population changes adopt new technologies plan across primary and secondary care be affordable for the whole health economy promote integrated service solutions engage and harness the potential of staff enable the transition of staff engage the public, the whole health and social care system and be innovative.
33
Primary Care Centres Yet another White Paper, ‘Our health, our care, our say: a new direction for community services’, had been issued in January 2006 setting out new directions for the whole health and social care system. The government wants the people to have a real choice of the GP surgery they register with. The right of patients to choose one surgery over another will help to ensure that those surgeries are open at times that are suitable for them. The government argues that if patient choice and PBC (practice-based commissioning) expand then health services will develop that are safe, high quality and closer to home in the community. The aim is to meet people’s aspiration for independence and greater control over their lives and to make services flexible and responsive to individual needs. This will enable people to be more in control of their health care and place greater emphasis on the prevention of illness. Four main goals are identified: 1. Better prevention services with earlier intervention. The government response to this aspiration is the introduction of the new NHS life checks for people to assess their lifestyle risks and to take the right steps to make healthier choices. The aim is for this to be a personalised service in two parts. (a) The assessment tool will be available either online as part of health direct online or downloaded locally in hard copy. (b) Specific health and social care advice and support for those who need it will be available. 2. More choice and a louder voice. Patients will be given a guarantee of registration onto a GP practice list in their locality. To help them to make this choice it will be easier for people to get the information they need to choose a practice and understand what services are available in their area. 3. Do more on tackling inequalities and improving access to community services. There will be a clear focus on those with ongoing needs and the quality and quantity of primary care will be increased in underserved, deprived areas. People with particular needs will be targeted including young people, mothers, ethnic minorities, people with disabilities, people at the end of their lives, offenders and other special groups. 4. More support for people with long-term needs. The intention is to improve communications between health care and social care services. These changes are inextricably moving the original philosophical arguments set out for the NHS in 1948 towards a consumer driven service with an increasing element of private finance introduced to the provision of services. It would give GPs more responsibility for local health budgets, and it seeks to reorientate our health and social care services to focus together on prevention and health promotion. It is anticipated that more care will be undertaken outside hospitals and
34
in the home. Work is also under way on commissioning social care services in conjunction with medical services. Health and well-being are essential planks of this shift in policy. General practitioners enjoy special status within the NHS, being the most public face of health care because they have most contact with the public. Just about everyone has at some time had reason to ‘see their doctor’. People are more likely to know the name of their doctor than that of any other public servant. Though GPs are paid out of the public purse, few of us think of them as public sector workers. They run their practices very much as private businesses – as independent contractors and for profit, and have done so since 1948. The argument runs (as described by Jenny Hjul in The Sunday Times of 17 December 2006) that if a private practice decided to move into the general practice market and take over a surgery, it is quite probable that patients would not notice the difference, rather like a favourite retail outlet being bought by a multinational, the defining characteristics that make the brand popular, the doctors in this case, would remain unchanged. Why, then, has there been concern over the proposed takeover by a private firm of a vacant GP practice in Hart Hill, North Lanarkshire, which would make it the first privately run practice in Scotland? What this amounts to, say critics, is a creep in privatisation of the NHS, the thin edge of the wedge. Shareholders’ dividends will take precedent over patients’ demands, services will be trimmed and the cherished doctor/patient relationship will be destroyed by a rapid turnover in locum staff. However, locums are often an essential part of most modern practices, and a telephone helpline is now the first port of call for out of hours emergencies. However, almost a third of the GP workforce is over 50 and nearing the end of their careers. Added to this, the feminisation of general practice – almost 60 per cent of GP registrars in Scotland are women – has brought a shift to more part-time work. The Royal College of General Practitioners (Scotland) conservatively estimates that by 2012 Scotland will be short of at least 750 GPs. If the government, in Scotland and in Westminster, wants to expand out of hospital community health services, it will have to invest more in GPs – in training, in offering incentives for doctors to return to work after childbirth and to remain in practice for longer. Funds will also have to be found to improve GPs’ premises. Three quarters of GPs surveyed by the BMA felt that their premises were not suitable for future needs. The BMA said a critical shortage of investment is to blame. It seems that Scotland’s reluctance to accept the private option in public health will be unsupportable. In England, private firms provide hospital services for the NHS and privately run diagnostic and treatment centres for NHS patients have cut waiting lists considerably. By 2008, private firms are expected to carry out one in every ten non-emergency operations. It seems a natural progression for this kind of investment to find its way into general practice and so help bring health care to the doorstep.
5
Approach to briefing
Any briefing process is complex and ultimately depends on the clarity and vision of the client to identify the ethos of the project. Of course, a successful building also requires a good architect who is able to interpret this mission statement, and balance the inevitably conflicting requirements to create an architectural solution that adds to its urban context and provides (in the case of primary health care buildings) a healing environment. Without the preset rules of a design school, architectural theory is either infinitely variable or confused depending on whether you take an optimistic or a pessimistic view of the opportunities that are presented by the lack of design guidelines. On the one hand, Jencks (1995) advocates the advantages emanating from chaos theory, resulting in a fractured and segmental architecture of great variety, or more negatively the philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein is reported to have said ‘you think philosophy is difficult enough but I tell you it is nothing to the difficulty of being a good architect’ (Lawson, 1994, p. 2). Lawson (1994, p. 2) identifies four techniques we can employ to understand the designing process: 1. We can analyse the task and propose logical structures and processes that we imagine must or should take place. 2. We can observe designers at work. 3. We can conduct laboratory experiments on designers. 4. We can ask designers to tell us what they do. He concludes the review of these approaches by favouring dialogues with architects, and inviting them to describe their working methods. However, the subjective appraisal of his choice of architects interviewed relies on the arbitrary appraisal of what represents high quality. Can high quality be justified solely by those architects who are held in highest esteem by their peer group at any particular point in time?
An interview with Richard Burton (Lawson, 1994, p. 12) recorded the following points as being most important: ● ● ● ● ●
● ●
Interaction between members of a design team Relationship with client is critical Interactive nature of brief making Briefing is an absolutely crucial element The higher the level of client contact is in the client organisation, the better the process works Obtain feedback Importance of drawing as part of the design process.
Other architects identified their own crucial factors, for example: Hertzberger – human relationships are fundamental. Michael Wilford – sees himself as an editor waiting for copy to come forward from his staff. Eva Jiricna – design is a generic process, map out the range of alternatives. Richard McCormac – sees his role as making a series of interventions at different stages of the design process. Another explanation of the design process is made by using an analogy with the conductor of an orchestra. Working from a brief (the score), he or she coordinates and welds together a variety of contributions (individual musicians) each interpreting their line of the score – sometimes brilliantly, sometimes less so – to orchestrate a performance. The component parts may vary in skill and flair but sometimes are brought together for a memorable concert. There have been several recent attempts to develop systems to give scientific credence to artistic concepts, and it seems for the time being at least that progress in this field is dependent on providing an economic justification for all design processes.
35
Primary Care Centres The key issue that emerges from an examination of these systems is that comparisons are being made between the expectations set out in the brief for a building and then compared with the results found in a post-evaluation study. However, the components of the brief are often very limited and it is therefore difficult to establish sufficiently worthwhile tests to measure the outputs from the finished building. This leads to the suggestion that the quality of the brief needs to be raised. A number of approaches attempting to quantify the qualitative aspects of a design use an arithmetical approach. Essentially, they are systems of point scoring against a series of scales judging performance. This leads to problems of assessment (Macnaughton, 1996) and the dangers and difficulties of assuming sliding scales of assessment which adopt a smooth or consistent gradient. There is undoubtedly very limited research, either completed or under way, in this broad field and more sophisticated briefing techniques will not appear overnight. We should be less apprehensive about linking the philosophical concepts of complementary medicine with mainstream professional methods. Exploration of the holistic approaches to alternative medicine should be looked at in parallel with scientifically founded evidence produced from control experiments of environmental factors. The Glasgow Homoeopathic Hospital is a good example of a recent building designed within the budgetary constraints of the NHS system and yet seeking out new ways to interpret a pleasing environment. Newspapers and magazines are full of articles about lifestyle: about how to remove stress from the workplace – about well-balanced diets – about ‘making over’ interior spaces. There is a newfound enthusiasm to control and influence our individual lives. The Prince of Wales, writing in The Times on Saturday 30 December 2000, says ‘we should be mindful that clinically controlled trials alone are not the only prerequisites to apply a health care intervention. Consumer based surveys can explore why people choose complementary and alternative medicine and tease out the therapeutic powers of belief and trust.’ With the medical profession under great pressure from society to become more responsive to consumer demands, another article in The Times (19 January 2001) starts from the premise that health is more fundamental to happiness, well-being and prosperity than anything else. Surely, this is the wrong way round: good health is likely to result from happiness, well-being and prosperity and it is our failure to understand the historic values of a holistic lifestyle that has led us into the trap which assumes that a technical solution lies behind every medical disorder. We should turn our attention to the quality of the environment; to the design of the places where we live and work and the therapeutic advantages that flow from the best examples. Doctors need to widen their horizons and understand the benefits that the humanities can add to our health. Science adds to our knowledge but philosophy and the arts make life worth living.
36
Changes in NHS requirements An article published in Hospital Design in 1996 (Rogerson, 1996) set out the case that hard facts are needed to convince hospital administrators that good design brings therapeutic benefits. Since that time, the awakening of interest in this subject has spread widely, and as we have seen, the government has now accepted the arguments and is looking for the evidence to underpin its ambitious spending plans in the NHS. Under a previous administration, the Junior Health Minister in 1996, Tom Sackville, addressing a conference chaired by John Wells-Thorpe, said that ‘we have an enormous responsibility to get this right … buildings with architecture and design that lift the spirits of patients need be no more costly than the depressing, austere buildings so familiar to many who use and work in the NHS’. Already, there were anxieties about the influence of the PFI procurement procedure with the Minister going on to say: ‘I will not pretend PFI particularly helps (design quality) but it need not hinder it either.’ Therefore, we have seen the pendulum of opinion steadily shifting towards acceptance of the importance of good design in health buildings. In the mid 1990s, conference speakers still needed to remind their audiences that they were not doing the taxpayer a good turn by automatically opting for the cheapest option. What was needed was more serious research to form the basis on which therapeutic advantages could be measured. Another influential architect at that time was Richard Burton of Ahrends Burton and Koralek, who understood the need to create calming environments and to look at design from the point of view of the patient. He pointed out that ‘designs which are calming when one is healthy can be depressing when is in a subdued state … satisfaction measures are not enough – we need to measure behaviour and outcome’. This pioneering work has had an effect on policy within government circles and the then Prime Minister Tony Blair advocated high quality design for civic buildings. At the beginning of the 21st century, therefore, we are in a much more receptive culture to accept and understand the therapeutic benefits that can arise from well-designed primary care buildings. New design performance indicators are being developed to include a ‘delight factor’. Research at Sussex University under the direction of David Gann is investigating: ●
●
●
Functionality Does the building perform its purpose? What is a building’s productivity? Whole-life costing Sustainability In-use costs/adaptability Delightfulness Is it a focal point in the community? What do passers by think? Effect on the mind and the senses.
Approach to briefing These issues are not just about measuring the performance of buildings but about raising public awareness of the quality and delight that can be enjoyed from well-designed environments (Weaver, 2000). The complexity of these relationships leads back to the wide conceptions of life and the world which Bertrand Russell, in the introduction to his History of Western Philosophy, describes as philosophical and the product of two factors, ‘one, inherited, religious and ethical conceptions; the other, the sort of investigation which may be called scientific, using this word in its broader sense’. He contends that all definite knowledge belongs to science and all dogma belongs to theology. ‘But between theology and science there is no-mans land, exposed to attack from both sides; this no-mans land is philosophy.’ The design of health care environments occupies this space.
The design process – alternative approaches There have been many attempts to analyse the design process and to map out systematic patterns to guide the intellectual methods of design. Design education in universities has, until fairly recent times, followed a historical route, taking each time period as a subject of analysis. In the last quarter of the 20th century, more complex studies have been undertaken about the nature of design and studies have compared the design process between different fields of study, for instance comparing the differences between how fashion designers create their ideas and how civil engineers develop a structure (Lawson, 1997, p. 3). With architecture, the design process is influenced by two main characteristics, namely the design problem and the design approach. The following examination of various design systems considers how these two aspects are brought together by different people in the increasingly complex field of how an architect develops the brief and processes the information to produce a design product. Design is now taught as a skill as well as an art. Computer graphics involve manipulative skills that can be learned and developed by teaching students, and this will enhance their ability to convey their imaginative and innovative ideas into reality. A bee puts to shame many an architect in the construction of her hive but what distinguishes the worst of architects from the best of bees is this, that the architect raises his structure in imagination before he erects it in reality. At the end of every labour process we get a result that already existed in the imagination of the labourer at its beginning. (Karl Marx, Das Capital, cited in Lawson, 1997, p. 14) The design process has been formalised over the last 100 years by the development of professional organisations, not least by the Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA), founded in 1834. The development of respect for the professions gave their members social status and for a while the division of labour between those who design and those who
make was a keystone of our technological society (Lawson, 1997, p. 22). The process of brief and design development has long fascinated architects. The model advocated by the profession for the architectural design process is set out in the Architect’s Job Book (6th edition 1995) published by the RIBA and this remains the basic approach adopted by most architectural practices when commissioned to design a new building. It is essentially a linear process and the foreword to the document states that ‘Architects are those who organise themselves to systematically translate their imagination and design flair into a building that meets their clients’ needs.’ It is a systematic approach to the design and construction process which has survived from the first edition published in 1969. The foreword boldly concludes by saying: ‘The Architect’s Job Book provides a framework for this systematic approach, which can be applied to any building or procurement method.’ The diagram of the process highlights the progressive linear path (see Figure 5.1). Although there are feedback loops which anticipate a dialogue developing between the written components of the brief and the evolving design
Client requirements
Initial brief Development of the brief
Constant interaction between brief and proposals
Feasibility studies A–B
Project brief Outline design
Development of the design process In smaller projects or those with a fast track programme the stages may be compressed
C Design brief Scheme design D Consolidated brief Detail design Production * information F–G
E
*The transition from detail design to production information is difficult to establish precisely and there is usually a measure of overlap. Figure 5.1 RIBA Plan of Work (source: RIBA Architect’s Job Book, 1995, p. 94)
37
Primary Care Centres proposals, there is no reference to post-occupancy evaluations and feedback is only briefly mentioned at the end of the document. Debriefing is not referred to in the plan of work and most importantly not covered by the normal fee agreement entered into under the standard terms and conditions of appointment. Indeed, the Architect’s Job Book states that ‘both in-house appraisals and debriefing are exercises not normally listed in the services provided by the architect and are unlikely to be funded by the client … a full feedback study can be costly, and if the client wishes this to be undertaken, it will probably have to be the subject of a separate commission.’ The lack of provision for fees for post-occupancy work in an architect’s normal appointment is probably at the heart of poor appraisal and analysis of complete projects. Each architectural commission is often viewed as a unique opportunity to start with ‘a clean sheet of paper’ to create an individualistic solution to a client’s requirements. However, it goes further in almost discouraging the debriefing process. It states: ‘it is a sensitive area, and confrontation should be avoided at all costs. It will not therefore be a productive exercise in all cases and great care needs to be taken in deciding whether or not it will be worthwhile for a particular project.’ It seems remarkable in a document published in 1995 that there should still be such a negative attitude towards post-occupancy evaluation techniques and the benefits of cyclical learning, which is considered a prerequisite in other professional disciplines. Two obvious examples are the law and medicine. English law is developed on the principle of case law, or learning from previous experience, and likewise medicine is a developmental profession, which in the last 100 years has relied on the development of technical expertise. Elsewhere, I comment on the changing philosophy of health care from a medical point of view, which is moving towards a holistic approach not entirely based on scientific methodology. My interviews with, for example, Professor Sir Kenneth Calman have highlighted how leading members of the medical profession are beginning to advocate the introduction of artistic considerations to their work and have recognised the therapeutic benefits that can result from such combinations. The Seventh Edition of the Architect’s Job Book (RIBA, 2000), which remains the current edition in 2008, refers in the editor’s notes (p. 7) that ‘care has been taken to retain the straightforward and timeless advice which has made the Job Book a popular course of help for architects in the past’. However, this has resulted in little change from the Sixth Edition and continues the failure to recognise the importance of feedback and post-project evaluation. It states that ‘neither of these kinds of activities should be attempted if there is a risk of inviting acrimony and dispute’ (p. 280). There is such concern about feedback that it is not now listed in the Architects Plan of Work, nor is it referred to in current standard appointing documents and it advises that ‘the architect’s professional indemnity insurers should
38
be informed before a full feedback study is undertaken for the client’ (p. 273). The attempt by the RIBA to distil the design process to a simplistic linear pattern would appear not to do justice to the complex inter-relationships, sometimes intangible, which build up the design process.
Traditional NHS procurement policy The NHS Estates procurement policy was based until recently on the Capital Investment Manual, which requires a business case approach to justify new investment. This has led to a position where design quality is understood to be represented by functionality. Design quality is assessed by its functional suitability. This methodology is enshrined in the NHS Estate code document which sets out a five facet analysis process: ● ● ● ● ●
Space utilisation Functional suitability Energy efficiency Statutory standards (compliance) Physical condition.
These factors are used as a basis for design quality evaluation. This is done by subdividing each category into four sections, from fully compliant (e.g. new building) to below an acceptable standard. With this background, an assessment of design quality can miss the point. Design quality had to be based on quantifiable data.
Hospice procurement policy An interesting comparison with NHS policies can be made with the procurement of hospices. The concept of holistic healing had been lost in the development of technical medicine in the 20th century, although historically it was much more central to the care of those who were ill. Examples of hospice briefing documents are discussed in Healthy Living Centres (Purves, 2002) for both children and adults. The central difference of these briefing processes is that the care of the patient is central to the design objective. Costs and space standards are considered after the aspirations have been set to create an environment within the buildings that will be comforting to the patient. A conference (Breathing Space: Towards an Aesthetic for Cancer Care) held in Dundee (October 2003) examined the philosophy of the Maggie Centres, a network of buildings being created by Charles Jencks in memory of his wife who died of cancer. Jencks joked that ‘in the old days, people used to die in factories … called hospitals’. The Glasgow Homoeopathic Hospital demonstrates that a hospice can focus on environmental design issues, achieve high standards of architectural quality and yet still be constructed within NHS procurement cost limits.
Approach to briefing Design quality indicators (DQIs)
● ●
Pilot studies have been carried out by the Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment (CABE) to formulate design quality tools. An attempt was made by the DETR (Department of Environment Transport and Regions) in conjunction with the Housing Corporation to formulate a series of housing quality indicators (DETR, 1999). A key requirement of the system was for the Housing Corporation to be able to assess quality differences between schemes. It is based on a scoring system which examines a number of factors. A similar approach is being adopted by NHS Estates who are developing a quantitative methodology for evaluating design quality in the health sector and this work has been submitted to the Prime Minister’s Office as part of the background work in the government’s drive to raise design quality in public buildings. The development of a set of primary care quality indicators would similarly allow them to be used to audit the progress of a design and may be a more effective test of value for money than current PFI (Private Finance Initiative) procedures. They would also be appropriate for reviewing the design quality of small projects without having to resort to batching a large number of projects to achieve the critical financial mass to fit the PFI model. A diagram seeks to illustrate those areas of the design process where more work is required to develop a critical understanding of the healing environment. By acknowledging these issues, the briefing process will become more comprehensive and meaningful in helping to achieve high quality buildings. The introduction of design ethos concepts will enable the quality of the building (e.g. the product) to be raised as well as ensuring high quality of construction (e.g. the process). The Centre for Health Design have undertaken an extensive literature search and having looked at 78 761 articles have identified only 84 articles published within the last 30 years that contain relevant data concerning health care environment. They conclude that many of the ‘studies have significant methodological flaws that render their conclusions suspect or cast doubt on the generalizability of their findings. Future research into the effects of their health care environment on patient outcomes should be more carefully design and performed with greater methodological rigour’ (Rubin et al., 1998). Using the case study model, the Centre for Health Design has carried out a design evaluation of six primary care facilities for the purpose of ‘informing future design decisions’ (Kantrowitz and Associates, 1993). This report identifies a series of critical design issues arising from the data collected from the case studies. These are: ● ● ● ● ●
Design process Humanistic design Functional factors Technical factors Aesthetic factors
●
Cost factors Materials and furnishings Primary care practice. The conclusions are hopeful: the research finds that although the definition of primary care varies among the six organisations, these groups have taken the initiative to custom fit the mix of primary care services to meet the needs of the population and communities they serve. These organisations are finding ways to lessen the sterile, clinical image of medical settings of yesterday and instead, are designing more comfortable, welcoming space in primary care facilities. There appears to be shift from large scale to smaller scale facilities and facility components that maintain a manageable yet effective size. Several of the six facilities attempted to decentralise a number of main functions in an effort to enhance the reality and the perception of personal attention in individual care.
How is policy related to theory The literature demonstrates that there is an emerging body of evidence to support the argument that high quality architectural design can bring therapeutic benefits to patients. There are also a small but growing number of research papers that demonstrate a positive connection between good design and patient satisfaction. The evidence suggests that there are two main strands to this evolving condition. 1. Medical results demonstrate a measurable improvement in patient recovery rates when treated in high quality environments. 2. Patient expectations in the health sector are rising in parallel with general higher standards and aspirations throughout all sectors of our lifestyle (education, safety, security, wealth, houses and other possessions). Hence, it is not surprising that government policy is reflecting these changes and is attempting to modify standards to incorporate these factors. The NHS Plan has set a broad policy target to put ‘patient centred care’ as the focus of its overall objective. A consequence of this policy is to create a significant demand for better primary care buildings. Through control of the briefing process, the beneficial results stated above are more likely to be achieved in primary health care buildings.
Work at the James Cook University Hospital Outline This section is based on the project undertaken for the NHS Research Group which examined the outcomes at the James Cook University Hospital.
39
Primary Care Centres It sets out the methodological approach which considered both the design process as well as the outcomes of the architectural sequence of events. Background 1. As an architect in private practice I have been designing doctors’ surgeries for over 20 years. I became interested in the relationship between client and designer (usually doctor and architect) and the factors which govern the briefing process. 2. My book Healthy Living Centres (Purves, 2002) was the product of the background interest from my work as an architect, supplemented by a series of interviews which I conducted with a wide range of people in both the medical and architectural professions. 3. These professional interests led to my appointment as an honorary research assistant at the Centre for Arts and Humanities in Health and Medicine (CAHHM), a research group at Durham University. This group (2003/04) undertook a research evaluation of the design quality of the James Cook University Hospital. This has come about from the major reconstruction of the South Cleveland Hospital under a PFI contact of £120 m. The reconstruction will involve the disposal of Middlesbrough General Hospital and North Riding Infirmary, and the creation of a single site hospital on the South Cleveland Hospital site. The hospital has been renamed the James Cook University Hospital (JCUH) in honour of Captain James Cook, who came from the region. The Chief Executive of South Tees Hospitals NHS Trust and his planning team are committed to the delivery of high quality ‘patient centred care’ and believe that the solution lies in high quality architectural design and the integration of public art – commissioned and created regionally – into the health care environment. The development of the James Cook University Hospital has paid special attention to building design, therapeutic colour schemes, materials, lighting, space and acoustics. The design features and colour schemes are intended to individualise departments within the hospital to help create a sense of intimacy within the whole. (Extracts from 2nd interim report, CAHHM, June 2003)
Process issues 1.1 Introduction – government policy, a Health Resource Centre and a comparison with office buildings. 1.2 Reviewing the evolution of the decisions taken by the architect when designing a doctor’s surgery using the Geoffrey Purves Partnership data over a number of projects. 1.3 The documentation for the JCUH brief has also been examined and analysed to explore the objective of achieving a patient centred design. 1.4 Similarly, some of the data from the interviews I have conducted at JCUH have been used to examine the design process. The outcome of the design process has then been examined by: Outcome issues – outline 2.1 Discussing the results of the NHS questionnaire about GP surgery levels of satisfaction. In addition, the results of a survey undertaken by Geoffrey Purves Partnership on behalf of Brent and Harrow NHS Trust in 1996/97 are included in Appendix 5. This example of fieldwork demonstrates an early attempt by an NHS Trust to evaluate the environmental quality of its building stock. 2.2 This has been elaborated to a limited degree by two participant observation studies undertaken at GP surgeries designed by Geoffrey Purves Partnership (Gosforth Memorial Medical Centre and West Road Medical Centre). 2.3 Using data from interviews to assess satisfaction about a building’s success in achieving the design aspirations set out in the brief.
I have interviewed a number of senior staff, both administrative and clinical, together with members of the design team.
By using several sources of data, I have attempted to test some cross-fertilisation of ideas and concepts in a qualitative sense. There are strengths and weaknesses in this approach. By using several types of data and from a range of sources my conclusions have established trends and patterns and identified the qualitative components of a good design brief rather than generate statistically based quantitative results. However, the variety of data gives greater validity to those trends or patterns of opinion that emerge as common themes. A framework of the issues involved is shown in Figure 5.2. As previously mentioned, the financial implications have not been evaluated for this study.
Approach
Process issues
The research questions have been approached by considering both the design PROCESS as well as the OUTCOMES of the architectural sequence of events which led to the final building. Broadly, the design process has been explored by:
Introduction – government policy, a Health Resource Centre and a comparison with office buildings The briefing process in the health sector is changing rapidly and government policy has shifted markedly since the commencement of this research study (1997). Much of my early
40
Approach to briefing
1 Physical
site restraints space standards
2 Emotional
design aspirations
healing environment
user satisfaction
3 Financial
budget/ estimates
cost limits/ procurement methods
value for money
Figure 5.2
functionality
Matrix of factors influencing the design process
experience (early 1980s onwards) as an architect in private practice was gained in the health sector by following the guidance contained in the ‘Red Book’. The ‘Red Book’ was the standard NHS document used by general practitioners as a framework for all aspects of their work, and it included details about how their surgery should operate. It set out room sizes and functional requirements for the main activities such as the consulting room, nurse treatment areas and waiting room. No quality issues are considered or required to be considered by this document although passing reference to quality issues is made in the NHS design guides available at that time. It is not oversimplistic to say that the design brief was set out in terms of space requirements and room areas. Against this schedule of accommodation, cost limits were set (and periodically revised). The process of approval by NHS managers did consider, although largely subjectively and dependent on the skill, experience and sensitivity of the appointed member of staff, the quality of the design proposed. With a good NHS manager and a good architect, many excellent small health projects were completed throughout the UK during this period. Equally, there were other projects which were more modest but there was no process available to identify low quality buildings. However, during the 1990s a number of initiatives began to emerge in government strategies to re-examine patient care and to focus the process on the patient rather than on the medical system. These issues were recognised in the new contract for health promoted by the government in 1998 (Our Healthier Nation, 1998). New alliances were explored between different sections of the NHS and, importantly, some people began to consider joining together NHS services with those of local authorities and other community-based agencies. Comparison with design criteria in the commercial sector for work environments Perhaps because of the commercial office market being led by financial and private sector interests, there has been more research carried out in this field than on health buildings. There is also, normally, a clear distinction between building owner and building occupier. Much of the office space in the UK is leased by the tenant from the building owner. Historically, this has not been the case with health buildings. All of the UK NHS Health Estate has been designed, built and owned by the government.
This is now changing rapidly with the huge increase in PFI projects and similar procurement policies such as Procure 21 and LIFT. They all introduce private capital into the provision of health facilities but the tenant (i.e. the NHS on behalf of the government) has only recently begun to attach importance to the design quality of the completed building. The concepts of change, working patterns and the way buildings need to change to accommodate these requirements have been developed more rapidly in the office sector of the property market. For over 20 years Frank Duffy has been leading his firm, DEGW, through an exhaustive series of experiments and research projects looking at the way office accommodation must change to cater for new working practices. This research work needs to be transferred to the health sector, and indeed ‘other workplaces’. … I should mention what I mean by ‘office’. I do not mean only prestige office buildings housing large corporations. I mean all places where professional, administrative, recording, accounting activities are carried out, whether they be factories, surgeries, shop windows or prestige blocks – any place in which people who used to be called white collar workers work. (Duffy, 1992) Duffy argues that applied research should be the basis for the development of this design work and should be based on an analysis of the way people use buildings. Buildings provide a framework for behaviour. They exist only to allow people to do what they want to do. (p. 38) These arguments are summarised in a neat list of variables (see Figure 5.3). His more recent work described in New Environments for Working (Laing et al., 1998) develops these issues and sets out a framework for describing working patterns and the differing types of environmental systems required to support these. Much of this research work needs to be urgently transferred to the health sector and transform the way in which primary health care facilities are conceived. It is essential to break the mould of the briefing document being based on static physical requirements so that future projects embody the human ethos and quality of life issues begin to take precedence over traditional space standard and cost factors. Notes on the design process for surgeries designed by Geoffrey Purves Partnership The Geoffrey Purves Partnership (now Purves Ash LLP) has been designing doctors’ surgeries since the early 1980s. During this period, the design culture has shifted from an approach revolving around the ‘Red Book’ procedures to the current environment where the procurement of GP surgeries is increasingly under the control of private sector financial arrangements. The ‘Red Book’ was the comprehensive
41
Primary Care Centres
Organisation of work – the job
Whatever is directly to do with getting the work done, e.g. the task to be completed, the line of authority and responsibility, work communication channels, management style, equipment used, numbers of visitors, etc.
Behaviour at work – the worker
The social consequences of getting work done, e.g. display and prestige, work expectations, visitor communications, sex, age, income, education of the workers, secrecy required, etc.
Building form – the building
The physical consequences of job and worker, e.g. location, space and equipment standards, disposition of groups and workers in plan, arrangement of equipment, size of room, use of partitions, screens, room dividers, etc.
seems valid to look at the briefing process of this hospital to understand how qualitative issues were addressed. The research group looked at the management approach that was adopted during the design process and considered whether the design development process was effective. The JCUH was one of the early PFI hospital projects, and more recent contracts undoubtedly place greater emphasis on assessment protocols to examine the effectiveness of the design quality outputs. This focus on design quality by the government is discussed in several documents including ‘Improving Standards of Design in the Procurement of Public Buildings’ (OGC and CABE, October 2002 – for more details see www.ogc. gov.uk or www.cabe.org.uk). This is discussed in greater detail in Chapter 6. I have examined the PFI documentation including the ● ● ●
Figure 5.3
Variables on the way people use buildings
NHS handbook for GP methods and included a section on the requirements for surgery buildings. Review of the documentation for the James Cook University Hospital brief The James Cook University Hospital (JCUH) provides an interesting example of the briefing process for a major PFI hospital development at Teesside. As a member of the research team from CAHHM at Durham University, I have been involved in the work funded by the NHS Estates Research and Development Group to evaluate the design quality of the new hospital. The key questions that the group examined were: 1. How were patient centred care concerns articulated in the brief? How was the design process managed to ensure that these priorities were maintained? 2. How closely does the completed building reflect the patient centred aspirations of the brief? 3. How important are the briefing process and the design brief in influencing the outcomes of the building project for the users? There were two underlying assumptions to this study as follows: 1. Is it possible to define a patient centred care strategy in the brief? 2. If patient centred care is appropriately articulated in the brief it will be possible to identify the benefits of the completed building. Although the scale of this project at approximately £150 million is vastly greater than the value of a GP surgery, it
42
●
single site pre-selection information memorandum outline business case overview evaluation report full business case (including the design report).
The study did not examine financial aspects of the contract in detail and it did not include value engineering appraisals, value for money assessments, or financial comparisons between PFI and traditional procurement routes. From an examination of the documentation and interviews with key members of the design team, two key factors in the briefing process became apparent. 1. The documents consistently stressed the design quality aspirations that had been established for the new hospital. These were based on a patient centred care strategy and the excellence of clinical care throughout the full range of acute services in both the new and existing buildings. 2. The success in not losing sight of these objectives has been greatly assisted by the inclusion of senior clinical members of staff in the core planning team established from the earliest meetings of the project. The involvement of the senior clinicians who had ‘hands-on’ medical responsibilities ensured that the design development process had the support of a wide range of staff all the way through the design process. Although this technique was very expensive in terms of time for senior staff, it did ensure ownership of the design. Even the early briefing documents such as the outline business case (spring 1995) included qualitative statements and aspirations such as: ● ●
●
‘Will deliver demonstrable benefits for patients’. ‘Providing scope for a new pattern of healthcare tailored to … patients’ requirements and aspirations’. ‘A draft development control plan has been produced … based upon an innovative patient centred model to ensure the proposed development is human in scale and highly efficient’.
Approach to briefing The design report section of the full business case (November 1998) included the following objectives: ●
●
●
●
‘Provision of facilities to maximise the development of patient centred services’. ‘The provision of facilities which encourage the physical, mental and spiritual well-being of all patients’. ‘The provision of a safe, attractive and reassuring environment for all diagnostic and treatment services’. ‘The location of wards, outpatient and diagnostic services in close proximity to each other, to limit transfers and minimise travel distances for patients around the site, to enhance the development of the patient centred care concept’.
This emphasis on patient centred care spreads throughout all aspects of the hospital development proposals including the site layout, departmental adjacencies, flexibility and patient environment such as minimising travel distances and making signage an important aspect of the design. The Design Report accompanying the Full Business Case (November 1998) analyses these issues from the qualitative stance. For example, the landscape setting is regarded as important in establishing a therapeutic environment and minimising the impact of the roads and car parks. How successful this has been is questionable as demand for parking increases relentlessly. The low rise buildings have been designed to allow high levels of natural light ‘to provide a link with life outside’ and a ‘degree of individual environmental control has been achieved’. The Full Business Case also says: ‘views have been deemed to be important – to external landscapes and internal courtyards or artworks, as they can appear to extend space and provide a secure connection to the outside world’. Throughout the design process, great emphasis was placed on maintaining the integrity of these core principles. The patient centred care strategy was paramount but the development of the institute concept within the hospital so that various departments were grouped together for the greater convenience of patients influenced the planning constraints established by the architect. Overlaying these basic physical parameters, other qualitative factors were introduced such as the James Cook theme. By naming the hospital the James Cook University Hospital, the local roots of the community were recognised and this provided a platform to use various themes throughout the hospital associated with James Cook. For example, the artistic activities, scientific discoveries and educational opportunities arising from James Cook’s voyages of discovery to the Southern Ocean could be exploited throughout the hospital. This helped to create patient focus, local involvement with the community, a sense of pride and a range of devices to improve, identify and find one’s way around the large-scale building. Importantly, the requirement for hospital buildings to provide facilities that encourage the physical, mental and spiritual well-being of all patients was given appropriate
prominence in the briefing process. The new hospital has both a multifaith chapel and a holistic care centre. The success of the qualitative issues inherent in the new James Cook University Hospital facilities is largely due to the successful leadership of the design development team. This was stimulated by the then chief executive, Bill Murray, and rigorously pursued by the hospital briefing team, which included, as already mentioned, both administrative and clinical staff with senior managerial responsibilities. Notes from interviews conducted at JCUH concerning the briefing process As part of the NHS Estates Evaluation Study being undertaken by CAHHM, I interviewed a range of senior members of the management team including the chairman, the chief executive, senior members of the planning team and several senior clinicians. They had all been involved in the design process at the JCUH from the initial stages of the PFI contract. Clearly, this is not similar to the scale of operations encountered with the design of a new GP surgery but it does reflect an involvement in all members of the team from an early stage. Their views confirmed that they believed this to be valuable and helped them to understand what the new building would look like and to have an influence on the interdepartmental relationships. Examples demonstrating this support include: Well, Ken and Bruce worked with the Trust’s project team, as we called it, and produced a public sector comparison in terms of the site development control plan which had required a number of discussions with individual parties and ultimately received 90–95% approval in that people were delighted with the plan, particularly in terms of the adjacencies. Another comment from a senior non-clinical administrator includes the comment: There were lots of meetings but, you know, the brief really was to make things as patient positive as possible, to have specialities working adjacently so that specialities and that sort of thing work as near to each other as they could. And you know we actually got it right for the patients. Another example: I suppose for me it was less on the cost issue, we were involved less on cost and more on design and making the, coming from a nursing background I was very keen personally to make sure that the nursing issues … make it easier for the nurses … better for patients. That was always in the back of my mind, but we were encouraged. And the public were consulted as well: Yes there was public consultation and the part I remember was terms of public consultation – new building – and
43
Primary Care Centres all the consultation that was necessary in the scheme of things – we were very encouraged by patient involvement and really they kept us on the straight and narrow ensuring that the services were adequate and suitable … Continuing: Question: Was there any constraint on design expectations or ambitions as a result of cost? Yes, well I mean, there were restrictions, we had to limit the number of offices to the number of people we had at the time and the whole scheme has to be frozen at a point in time in order to secure the contracts for building maintenance, but I think other than that there was a lot of clinical freedom as to how and input as to how it best be developed for the patients. These short extracts illustrate typical responses indicating how the whole team took ownership of the concept of patient centred care, and worked together to develop a high quality brief. Undoubtedly, it was expensive in terms of staff time and resources but there was no serious criticism that, at the end of the day, this was not a worthwhile investment to secure a high quality design of the new hospital. Outcomes issues The NHS has no data on the results questionnaire issued to GPs. With the publication of Environments for Quality Care – Health Buildings in the Community (NHS Estates, 1994), doctors were invited to complete a self-appraisal questionnaire about their own premises. It provided a comprehensive review of topics to allow doctors to examine the day-to-day running of this practice and to gauge its performance against patient satisfaction. The questionnaire (see the appendix at the end of the chapter) sets out a series of questions covering the following topics: ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
First impressions Access Reception and waiting area Consulting, examination and treatment rooms Circulation spaces Staff areas Building efficiency.
The last question invited doctors to ask themselves ‘Does the building convey a message of well-being?’ Obviously, this questionnaire does not gather information about the views of other users of the building such as patients or members of staff, although some doctors may have canvassed views from other people before completing the forms. In addition, some of the questions only invite a selfassessment of policies which will have been established by the doctors themselves.
44
In addition, the National Primary Care Research and Development Centre have carried out a survey of ten innovative projects where the processes of service development and premises development have been interactive (Bailey et al., 1997). This has led to the resultant buildings developing individual facilities particular to their locality. The NHS Estates questionnaire is the potential source of a great deal of valuable data, but there has been no process to collect or collate the results. An opportunity has been lost to invite doctors to return the forms so that an analysis of their views could be undertaken. What does the ‘Environments for Quality Care’ questionnaire demonstrate about existing facilities? The questionnaire was an imaginative initiative by NHS Estates and sought to look beyond the traditional assessment criteria of functionality and cost effectiveness for primary health care facilities. The questions reflect the philosophies that were common currency a decade ago. As a self-appraisal system designed to give doctors a quick review of how their surgery performed, in their eyes, it served a valuable purpose. However, it is disappointing that NHS Estates did not collate any of the information and therefore no statistical results have been published. The same questionnaire could have been made available to a randomly selected cross-section of patients and staff and the results compared with the judgements scored by the doctors. Therefore, the questionnaire is not an assessment of patient satisfaction and more probing questions might have been asked about patient needs and facilities not included in the designs. It would have been useful to go back to the briefing process to see if appropriate challenges had been set for the design team and the quality thresholds set out as a requirement for approving the design. Lessons might be learned from the commercial world of marketing and PR, where customer requirements are reviewed and analysed by focus groups and other surveys conducted from the point of view of the customer. Fortunately, these issues are now better understood and acknowledged by the NHS and the annual patients’ survey has begun to tackle these issues. More work remains to be done as priority shifts from meeting the requirements of the service provider to satisfying the services expected by patients. Analysis of questionnaire results from GPP (Geoffrey Purves Partnership) designs Of the primary care centres designed by the Geoffrey Purves Partnership 14 have completed the questionnaire. An analysis of the results highlights some interesting points. The overall response to section 1, First Impressions, shows a high level of satisfaction (88.9 per cent). The main criticism from this group of questions arises at 1.03, which indicates that there is dissatisfaction with the level of parking for patients and staff. All of the respondents said that their building appeared welcoming and that there was easy access for disabled people and parents with prams.
Approach to briefing However, section 2 on Access showed the lowest level of satisfaction of all the sections with less than half (46.4%) considering that all parts of the building were accessible to everyone, and that adequate provision had been made for people with mobility, hearing and sight difficulties. This immediately suggests either that the briefing requirements to the architect are inadequate, or that the architect has failed to respond adequately to the needs of patients and staff with disabilities. Although there was a high level of satisfaction with the questions regarding reception and waiting areas, the design and structure of the questionnaire itself is suspect in that doctors were scoring against their own requirements for the brief. For example, all surgeries were satisfied with their patient call system. This should not be surprising because the patient call system in every case is that which was requested by the doctors themselves. Following a more limited participant observation exercise involving two waiting areas, it was apparent that there were many deficiencies in the detailed functioning of the reception and waiting areas which would not necessarily be apparent to the doctors or staff of the surgery in question. However, there were significant shortcomings when seen from the patient’s perspective. The patient call system does, of course, touch upon the very essence of the patient/doctor relationship. Should a doctor greet a patient personally, which is time consuming, or should a patient be called to the consulting room by the use of indicator boards, tannoy systems, or simply by reception staff calling out names? In many cases, the patient feels disadvantaged, and immediately less equal than the doctor. An apprehensive patient, feeling unwell, waiting to be called by the doctor conjures up the mental image of a child being called into the headmaster’s study, or in an adult scenario, someone seeking a job being called in to present themselves to an interview panel. A visit to a private hospital, for example the Nuffield Hospital in Newcastle upon Tyne, illustrates the different approach taken where consultants come to the waiting area personally to greet their patient on neutral territory. How do you measure the cost of these alternative approaches? High levels of satisfaction were expressed for the consulting, examination and treatment rooms. These spaces are the subject of detailed briefs within the NHS procurement system and doctors have a significant control over the detailed layout of their working environment. However, there was a significant level of dissatisfaction (21 per cent) of the confidentiality ensured in terms of both sight and sound (question 4.04). Generally, circulation spaces were not criticised although 64 per cent of the respondents said that staff could not circulate without going through the waiting room. Although not stated, the implication of this question is that it was disadvantageous for staff to use the waiting room as a circulation route. This, of course, may not necessarily be so. Lighting in the staff areas was not considered to have been designed to meet flexible working needs by 29 per cent of respondents.
The highest levels of negative answers to the questionnaire were in the building efficiency section. Overall, only 61.3 per cent answered yes to the questions in this section and only 36 per cent thought that there was flexibility in relation to future needs. The question regarding telephone systems is flawed, in that it asks two questions (i.e. is the telephone system adequate and is a telephone provided for patient use?).
Current government policy for primary care buildings General practitioner surgeries If the special needs and cancer care buildings illustrate an outstanding concern for designing sensitive environments then the general practitioner buildings demonstrate the rapidly changing procurement routes that are revolving in primary health care. We have seen that the special needs and cancer care buildings have had more opportunity to explore the development of a design brief outside the constraints normally imposed by the NHS procedures. With general practitioner buildings the pressures for development have focused on the procurement route and a variety of models have begun to emerge. Primary sector finance is being introduced, both by the government through its LIFT initiatives and by developers offering comprehensive building services to health providers. PFI contracts have explored batching general practitioner premises together to form larger contract values. The projects that are illustrated include a variety of procurement routes, as well as several examples from the last generation of cost rent generated projects based on the principles laid out in the ‘Red Book’. The best of the new examples not only succeed in embracing new procurement and financing routes but also rise to the challenge of producing high quality architecture with stimulating environments and an understanding of the therapeutic benefits that good design can provide. Over the next few years the opportunity to explore these trends should be grasped. The design and theory of a patient focused architecture needs to be shared internationally. We can expect to see a new wave of buildings offering spatial flexibility, patient accessibility and a caring environment. Pushing at the boundaries of this work is a group of professionals who have recognised the need to mix disciplines, and design buildings that are humane and contribute to the built environment. During the last decade there have been very many excellent examples of primary care buildings. The RIBA Clients Advisory Service (CAS) lists over 600 practices with experience of designing primary health care buildings and their database provides a substantial track record of competent buildings. Many are excellent, and will continue to provide a good service to patients for many years. Some of these good examples can be found on the NHS CD-Rom ‘Design Quality’, and, of course, the NHS booklet Environments for Quality Care published as long ago as 1994 provides a selection of exemplar projects from around the UK.
45
Primary Care Centres More recently, the results of innovative architects working with sympathetic medical practitioners have explored a number of approaches to improve environmental quality and these are discussed elsewhere in this book. Issues such as the introduction of artworks, stained glass and improved disability access (including mobility, audio and visual impairments) have all added to the knowledge base for buildings used for primary health care purposes.
A Contract for Health
46
Local players and communities can:
People can:
Provide national coordination and leadership.
Provide leadership for local health strategies by developing and implementing health improvement programmes.
Take responsibility for their own health and make healthier choices about their lifestyle.
Ensure that policy making across government takes full account of health and is well informed by research and the best expertise available.
Community facilities As we have seen, a variety of solutions have been designed to meet the multifarious requirements of local circumstances both in the UK and around the world. These buildings are invariably complex and lay down a challenge for the clarity of the design to be preserved during the procurement route. Hence, the buildings encapsulate the often conflicting objectives of ‘product v. process’ discussed more fully in earlier chapters. They are a test of the UK government’s policies to achieve high standards of design while seeking to introduce private funding including the use of PFI contracts. This has led to differences of opinion within the architectural profession. On the one hand, academics such as Susan Francis, at the Medical Architecture Research Unit, say: ‘Over the past 10 years some of the most successful designs have come through primary and community settings.’ However, she is concerned that NHS LIFT will mean the batching of smaller buildings within a given area to form larger contracts that will be procured through framework agreements. This, she believes, will lead to a lack of site-specific work and will attract consortia that might not otherwise be interested in jobs of this scale. Mike Nightingale of Nightingale Associates does not share such a pessimistic view. He says: ‘We do both building and interior design in the health sector so are well set up. It is a good time to be specialising because there is a wealth of work and a feeling that days of utilitarian hospital architecture are over: first the Egan Report suggested good design was good for patients and now CABE is working with the Government through the NHS Design Forum on the importance of good design. Starting small with clinics will give small firms a chance to get in, but they will have to show competence and an ability to cope with complex work. There is evidence that PCTs will be quite entrepreneurial about procuring buildings’ (Richardson, 2001). Of course, the other major factor in the shape of primary health care buildings of the future will be the working practices of GPs themselves. Doctors are under increasing pressure in the UK to modify their working practices, look again at job descriptions and the work that may be undertaken by nurses, and their involvement, if at all, in the financial structure of the ownership of medical buildings. Examples in the UK and in other countries illustrate the range of work and approaches adopted for primary health care community facilities in response to these changing needs of both the medical and architectural professions (see Figure 5.4).
Government and national players can:
Work with other countries for international cooperation to improve health.
Work in partnerships to improve the health of local people and tackle the root causes of ill health. Plan and provide high quality services to everyone who needs them.
Ensure their own actions do not harm the health of others. Take opportunities to better their lives and their families’ lives, through education, training and employment.
Assess risks and communicate those risks clearly to the public. Ensure that the public and others have the information they need to improve their health. Regulate and legislate where necessary. Tackle the root causes of ill health.
Figure 5.4 A contract for health – national and local responsibilities
The same document (p. 31) identifies two key aims: ●
●
To improve the health of the population as a whole by increasing the length of people’s lives and the number of years people spend free from illness. To improve the health of the worst off in society and to narrow the health gap.
These policies were further reinforced in the NHS Plan which lays down the criteria for a patient focused health service, and increases further the emphasis placed on primary care and the preventive nature of those services. A list of proposals includes more routine screening tests and guidance to patients on how to minimise or reduce risks to their health. In essence, it is a policy about encouraging communities to adopt healthier lifestyles. As 90 per cent of all health care is undertaken at the primary level there are obvious cost benefits to aim for in a service that costs the country over £40 billion each year. The introduction of NHS Direct, which allows people to make direct contact by telephone to health professionals, will encourage individuals to regard the NHS as a resource from which they can seek assistance to develop a healthier lifestyle, and look after themselves in their own homes.
Approach to briefing What are the design and policy consequences of preventive medical care? There has been a fundamental reorganisation of the way in which primary care is organised in the UK. The introduction of Primary Care Groups has changed the landscape of GP services and the effects of these changes will snowball as the Primary Care Groups assume the status of Trusts, with the attendant responsibilities of self-administration and control of substantial resources beginning to become effective. The integration of social services within these Primary Care Trusts will provide a comprehensive range of services covering primary care, mental health and social services, thereby creating a wide-ranging resource. In part, these changes are, perhaps, a result of the recognition that patients are consumers, and the medical profession has been slow to recognise the higher standards of service which a market economy has provided for the consumers of most other service providers. Therefore, there is a very rapid learning curve in process whereby the medical profession understands that the patient is a customer who will have all the usual questions of efficiency, cost effectiveness and quality of service uppermost in their minds when seeking health advice in the future. The medical professions should see this as an opportunity, particularly with regard to health care facilities where the physical assets can be designed with quality as a key factor in the briefing process. The brief will recognise that buildings of the future should be designed to provide a healing environment. The aim will be to achieve therapeutic benefits by the use of good design to provide flexibility, long life and visually satisfying environments. Even the Treasury is recognising that intangible benefits should be taken account of when looking at PFI projects. Not that PFI is an appropriate vehicle for the design of small primary care health facilities. Therefore, the history of primary care health facilities is set to embark on another phase of development. Following the first health centres designed in the 1930s, for example the Finsbury Health Centre designed in 1938 by Lubetkin, through the generation of health centres designed in the 1950s (not a success because they were unpopular with GPs) and moving away from the ‘Red Book’, generated GP surgeries of the 1980s and 1990s. This last group of buildings produced many very well-designed projects arising from the close working relationship between GPs and architects. It provided an example of health buildings that were procured relatively quickly, and avoided the bureaucratic and extended delivery period of the hospital building programme of the same period. Unfortunately, the financial constraints encapsulated in the ‘Red Book’ still frustrated the fluidity of much innovative design and both doctors and architects were constrained in their aspirations. For example, the cost allowances only allowed for fixed furniture. How does a doctor provide sofas in a consulting room? A doctor may not wish to tell a distressed patient that cancer has been diagnosed, or deal with a serious mental anxiety,
across the corner of a desk sitting on upright chairs more appropriate to an office. Few doctors have been prepared to supplement the ‘Red Book’ allowances to fund additional equipment and furniture to personalise their surgeries. Stereotyped room data requirements have stultified innovative solutions within consulting rooms. The next generation of health care buildings for the primary sector will be flexible long-life buildings, based on a comprehensive briefing document where design quality plays a major part in establishing the design philosophy.
GP policy aspirations Many doctors do not wish to be building owners. Many doctors also wish to be salaried employees, rather than selfemployed contractors to the NHS, providing a service where their remuneration is based on the quality of care they provide, rather than on accountancy rules using patient lists, and number of visits and consultations as the basis for pay. Professional demarcations have also become outdated, and we will see developments in the integration of social service personnel, mental health practitioners and greater specialisation for routine procedures to be part of the GP’s future contract of employment. Technology will develop and telemedicine will offer more rapid diagnostic services from the laboratory back to the consulting room. The aspirations for future doctors will be more rounded, less clinical and integrated with the community in an accessible building. The next generation of doctors will have a much broader-based education involving the humanities as well as the traditional clinical and technical basis for their studies. Already being introduced by Durham University at the Stockton campus, there will be a programme of humanity modules including literature, the arts and architecture to encourage a holistic approach to the complete healing environment. Similar courses are also being introduced in London and Wales (University of Wales, Swansea).1 Far better to have a community thriving with a high quality of life than doctors fighting a rearguard action to treat diseases which are often the result of poor environmental standards. Perhaps doctors may even prescribe environmental conditions. We already understand some of these issues, for example: ● ●
●
Safer driving reduces accidents. No smoking in offices and restaurants reduces the risks of cancers. Fitness and diet are promoted as health policy.
The provision of new facilities will embrace a new partnership between public and private finance. 1
These issues are more fully discussed in Medical Humanities, A Practical Introduction (eds Deborah Kirklin and Ruth Richardson) published by the Royal College of Physicians, 2001. It includes schemes of modules for the MA (Wales) in Medical Humanities and the BSc in Medical Sciences and Humanities.
47
Primary Care Centres Evolution of concepts Evidence-based design The changing pattern of the approach to health has evolved through phases of holistic care, followed by more technical solutions. More recently (over the last decade), there is emerging a greater awareness of the importance of welldesigned buildings and justification for this approach is being directed through ‘evidence-based design’ (EBD). The most widely cited and quoted researcher internationally in the area of evidence-based health care design is Roger Ulrich, Professor of Architecture at Texas A&M University. In 2005, he began working in the UK for the NHS. Although most of his work relates to hospital design, aspects of his research are relevant to primary care health buildings. He has reviewed more than 650 scientific studies linking aspects of the designed hospital environment to reduced patient stress, better medical outcomes, increased patient safety, improved staff morale and effectiveness and reduced operational costs. A helpful source for a review of literature on this subject is to be found in two university research papers. 1. ‘A Comparative Study of the Impact of Environmental Design upon Hospital Staff and Patients’ (Leather, 2000) looked at the design of a measure of environmental appraisal within a context of ‘therapeutic environment’. It defined ‘therapeutic’ as ‘an environment which is supportive of patient needs and which portrays a ‘‘nurturing’’ and ‘‘non-threatening’’ image which ‘‘helps to put people at ease’’’ (Carver, 1990). It concludes that ‘the physical design of a hospital environment is not simply a matter of functional purpose and specification. Rather it is a matter of symbolic meaning. Put simply, the image created by any particular design conveys an important set of messages about such things as the likely feelings to be experienced there, the value placed on patients and visitor comfort, and the hospital’s humanness and competence as an institution.’ The report goes on to make two further statements about the relationship between patient satisfaction and well-being. 1.1 The conclusion which follows is that positively appraised environments are beneficial to patient satisfaction and well-being. At the very least, they are conducive to the generation of positive moods. Beyond that, however, there is also evidence that they are associated with increased mental capacity, lower drug use and a shorter post-operative stay. 1.2 The major conclusion drawn, that hospital design is an important factor in promoting patient well-being, is certainly worthy of further systematic attention and research. The effects of design are clearly not arbitrary. It is important, however, that the full range and size of these effects is carefully and scientifically investigated, rather than being the subject of personal opinion, anecdote and unsupported conjecture.
48
2. A more recent report commissioned by NHS Estates in 2002 was titled ‘Investigation and Assessment of Attitudes to and Perceptions of the Built Environments in NHS Trust Hospitals’ (University of Salford, 2002). It concluded from its literature review ‘that it was possible to use the built environment to support patients’ recovery. The research reviewed suggested that the built environment of hospitals influenced the healing process and that it had a direct impact on patients’ health outcomes through enhanced relaxation, enabling views of nature and creating a healing environment. In this way, the built environment of hospitals can facilitate and encourage optimistic perspectives, attitudes and responses from patients. Through its healing environment, it can help to reduce the stress that patients encounter during their hospitalisation period and thereby help them in their personal recovery and recuperation.’
Work in this area is being taken forward by another research project funded by NHS Estates (Leeds) being undertaken by CAHHM at the University of Durham. The research project evaluated the quality of environment at the James Cook University Hospital. ‘The object is to investigate whether the Trust and the architects’ vision of the new hospital development as one which promoted wellbeing is indeed achieved’ (2nd draft report). The project is a £140 m major reconstruction of the South Cleveland Hospital under a PFI contract. The brief sets out a commitment to the delivery of high quality ‘patient centred care’ and one of the research questions addressed was ‘what did the architects and the Trust aim to achieve with this new hospital and how did they go about it?’ From the pioneering research of Roger Ulrich (Ulrich, 1984) the USA has been at the forefront of environmental design quality work in health buildings. Much of it has been centred around a group of people working at the Texas A&M University, together with a further group of specialists who have created the Center for Health Design, based at Martinez in California (www.healthdesign.org). More recently, a series of research initiatives has developed in the UK, with considerable interaction between MARU (Medical Architecture Research Unit) (London), Manchester, Sheffield, Nottingham and Durham Universities, all of whom are developing research outputs. Several international conferences have been held and the output of properly researched papers examining various aspects of environmental design, and the therapeutic benefits that can be achieved, is steadily increasing. Wayne Ruga is an architect, and was responsible for founding the Center for Health Design, and organising its first international symposium in 1986. Now working in the UK at Manchester University, he is interested in the relationship between the environment and our culture. He asserts ‘that in order to improve an organisation’s environment you must first improve its culture, giving the patient the empowering Plaintree model in the US as a successful example in health
Approach to briefing care’ (Parker, 2001). The challenge to bring together robust evidence-based data and combine it with the philosophical theories of human nature continue to give difficulties to research groups around the world. The Center for Health Design has produced a number of reports, including the following four studies particularly of interest for the design of primary health care facilities:
●
●
●
●
Design evaluation of six primary care facilities for the purpose of informing future design decisions. Gardens in health care facilities: uses, therapeutic benefits and design recommendations. Consumer perceptions of the health care environment: an investigation to determine what matters. An investigation to determine whether the building environment affects patients’ medical outcomes.
In the UK MARU has been a leader of research into the design of health care environments and has produced a wide range of documents and publications. The difficulty remains the requirement by government policy makers that research must be evidence based before priorities are changed in the procurement process for new facilities. The requirement to demonstrate economic advantage continues to be a difficulty: for example, work undertaken by the Department of Design and Architecture at the University of Luton, looking at the design implications of the Patient’s Charter, identifies the shortcomings in the questions asked of patients about their perceptions of the building environment. ‘The design variables highlight the conflicting views of some patients when comparing information or data. The results showed that questions relating to the patient’s perception of the built environment generated an average response on the aesthetics and functional aspects of the hospital. Whereas questions relating to their immediate wellbeing and personal relationship with medical and professional staff generated a higher response from patients’ (Amoah-Nyako and Henderson, 2001). A conference in Stockholm (June 2000) also brought together many influential speakers and participants in the field of environmental design quality research. The transactions of the symposium (Dilani, 2001) provide a valuable summary of the information available at that time. However, it is apparent that the empirical research data available is limited and more high quality evidence is required. This research continues to evolve and further conferences (Montreal 2003, Frankfurt 2005 and Glasgow 2007) arranged by the International Academy for Design and Health have built on the data available. The last conference in Glasgow has highlighted the move towards the need to create a healthy environment which is socially and economically sustainable. This underpins the sense of wellness and spiritual fulfilment which is necessary to enjoy a healthy lifestyle.
Future plans Community-based health/holistic approach (echoes of Finsbury and the Peckham Experiment) It is interesting to compare the latest government proposals for the provision of primary health care buildings with the Peckham Experiment and Finsbury Health Centre models of the 1930s. There is a return to providing primary health care facilities at a community level (80–90 per cent of all health care is provided by GPs outside of hospitals) through the programme of Health Living Centres and other initiatives which are developing new procurement policies such as the PFI programme, Procure 21 and LIFT. Better informed patients/consumerism Patients are better informed today than when the NHS was introduced over 60 years ago. Consumerism will influence the attitude of patients who are used to high levels of customer care in other sectors of the economy. As the NHS Plan makes clear, ‘too many patients feel talked at rather than listened to’ (NHS Estates, 2000). It will take time for patients to understand the new power within their grasp to influence the shape of future facilities. However, the influence of supply and demand in the market economy will inevitably challenge the providers of buildings to meet the new requirements. CABE The Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment (CABE) has replaced the Royal Fine Art Commission. It is developing a role to monitor and comment upon design standards for major new buildings including health buildings. The Office of Government Commerce (OGC) has published a report ‘Improving Standards of Design in the Procurement of Public Buildings’ (OGC, 2002). This document underlines the change in government policy towards design standards. The Rt Hon. Paul Boateng MP, then Chief Secretary to the Treasury, says in the foreword: ‘the report underlines the Government’s repeated message that sound, creative design is an essential ingredient to achieve best value for money. Through the working life of a building, design excellence can make service delivery more efficient and enhance the working environment for all those who use our public buildings.’ This is followed by Sir Stuart Lipton (Chairman of CABE at the time) noting that ‘two years ago the Prime Minister asked for a step change in the quality of new public building projects’. Importantly, HM Treasury is reported as recognising the value that design adds, not only in the construction process but also over the lifetime of the building. The document identifies that ‘setting clear benchmarks for the expected design quality on best practice’ is an important goal as part of the government’s commitment to the largest public building programme for a generation. A massive increase in public capital investment is occurring, doubling the level of investment in just four years to £38 billion per year by 2003/04. One of the main products of this commitment will be new and improved hospitals, schools
49
Primary Care Centres and other public buildings and infrastructure. Issues identified as being important include
● ● ●
● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
fitness for purpose build quality sustainability adaptability safety efficiency appreciation of context and an aesthetic impact that contributes to civic life.
However, contradictions and problems are thrown up by this approach. The government recognises the importance of the breakdown of a building’s cost. Over the lifetime of a building, the construction costs are unlikely to be more than 2–3 per cent of total costs, but the costs of running a public service will often constitute 85 per cent of the total. On the same scale, the design costs are likely to be 0.3–0.5 per cent of the whole-life costs, and yet it is through the design process that the largest impact can be made on the 85 per cent figure. The report acknowledges that ‘to date, the evidence suggests that we have made considerable progress in achieving the improved efficiency but that we have not yet consistently achieved excellence in terms of design quality’. CABE summarises good design as being a mix of the following attributes: ● ●
functionality build quality
50
efficiency and sustainability designing in context aesthetic quality.
These aspirations are further explored by examining the design process within PFI contracts and by the appointment of Design Champions by Clients. Although not directly related to primary health the experience of the research project undertaken by CAHHM at the new James Cook University Hospital in Teesside is a useful comparator. Some early results from PFI contracts for the procurement of new hospital projects have been criticised in the press as being poorly designed. Indeed, the design by HOK for the new London Hospital (St Barts) has been severely criticised as poor by CABE. Communications between client, clinicians, contractor and design team are blamed but the heavy weighting on value for money has driven design standards down, in the view of many outside commentators. It would seem that the aspirations for good design have now been recognised by the government and it is keen to include high quality environmental standards as a target within building briefs. However, the tests for evaluation are still poorly developed and there is evidence that the Treasury continues to use lowest cost as their key benchmark when awarding PFI contracts (Nisbet, 2004).
6
Design development/measurement of design quality
Outline of chapter and introduction This chapter reviews the traditional approach to designing GP surgeries, considers the development of alternative procurement routes introducing private capital and looks at several evaluation toolkits that are in use to look at the performance of health buildings. Over the last 20 years the starting point for the brief of a doctor’s surgery has been based on the standards set down in the ‘Red Book’. The ‘Red Book’ is a comprehensive manual defining a wide range of operating standards to be used by doctors when running their GP practices. Included in the document is a section on premises which includes a series of schedules of space standards for different sized GP practices from two to seven doctors. The schedule of allowable areas is linked to a financial formula and establishes the area and financial limit for a new GP surgery. This document makes no reference to the quality of care to be provided within the buildings. Doctors could exceed the financial limits set down by these schedules but any additional finance had to be provided from the doctor’s own resources. In practice, this very rarely occurred. There are guidance notes available to doctors, and their architects, giving additional information about the design of the spaces within a GP surgery, but there is almost no reference at all to the quality of the design. For example, Health Building Note 46, General Medical Premises, identifies under the sketch design stage at section 3.17 that ‘the architect will base the design of the sketch proposal upon the written brief – a statement of the operational policy and functional space requirements of the practice’. The brief is developed by the GP and the architect in discussion with the primary health care team and the FHSA. At section 4.1 it is noted that the building of new practice premises ‘provides the ideal opportunity to ensure that the building can accommodate
all the functional and operational requirements of the primary health team’. The document makes no reference to consideration of the design ethos of the building, and does not invite doctors to consider the quality of the environment that they are wishing to create for their new building. The changing attitude of government policies is explored, including the new LIFT programme of contracts to expand and develop GP premises based on the aspirations of the NHS Plan. There has been a significant shift in government policy, which now recognises the importance of good design in the development of new GP surgeries. Finally, a range of challenges is identified which are likely to affect the future design of GP surgeries, and the issues which will need further exploration to build on the principles of evidence-based design.
Traditional approach – the ‘Red Book’ The ‘Red Book’ has represented the modus operandi of GP practice in the UK for many years. It represents the outcome from a long period of development, periodic reviews and updating of data. It typifies the outcome of a bureaucratic approach of controlling a very large organisation. The rules, costs limits and schedules of permitted accommodation are very prescriptive, and it is remarkable that so much high quality architectural work has resulted from such a stifling environment. A wide range of innovative GP surgeries built over the last decade have been achieved despite the procurement process being heavily weighted towards issues of functionality and cost rather than design quality. Fortunately, this framework of controls is now rapidly breaking down as new forms of procurement expand and develop in the joint public private partnerships that the government is encouraging, but there is a long way to go.
51
Primary Care Centres Controls on loose furniture, tight budgets, discounted fee scales for professional services and other prescriptive requirements for accommodation requirements and overall floor areas made life difficult for both doctors and architects. A completely different approach to building design is required for the next wave of primary care buildings. They must be buildings that are flexible, can incorporate the demands of a knowledge-based economy and respond to the rapidly changing demands for information technology and different working methods which will develop from faster communications between doctor, patient and specialist testing facilities (e.g. x-rays, consultant reports). Government procurement methods must enable future buildings to be flexible shells within which highly serviced workstations can be developed and changed over short periods of time. For example, a doctor’s consulting room may have entirely different requirements in five years’ time than it does today – although it is likely to remain the fundamentally important space within which patient and doctor exchange information.
Lifecycle costs and ‘best value’ – the government’s approach Until recently, lifecycle costs have been relatively unimportant in the government process of procuring buildings, including those for the NHS. The tradition has been to award contracts predominantly on a lowest cost basis. The Treasury has now changed direction and the welcome interest in design quality is also manifesting itself in a reassessment of whole-life costs. This approach is encapsulated under the umbrella of ‘best value’. All government departments and local authorities are taking a broader look at ‘best value’ issues and this is providing an opportunity to develop new thinking about a whole range of tangible and intangible aspects of a building during its overall lifespan. At the simplest level, building material manufacturers are able to demonstrate ‘best value’ for their products not only as the result of initial costs but also taking into account maintenance schedules and renewal timescales. With design issues the growing recognition of user reactions and user satisfaction levels is beginning to influence the decision-making process. GP surgeries are too small to justify the competitive precontract procedures that potential development partners face under PFI (Private Finance Initiative) procedures. The government policies for their Procure 21 method of procurement seem to be stalling, with considerable delays and increasing resistance from the contractors who have subscribed to the framework agreement. However, there is a growing group of specialist companies forming partnerships with GPs to finance new primary health care facilities. Their success rate in putting together viable procurement packages is being helped because of the changes in attitude by district valuers. District valuers are moving towards the creation of a special class of valuation for medical facilities, whereas previously they were seriously disadvantaged by
52
being included with residential or local commercial values. These high valuations that are being rentalised as surgeries are enabling contracts to be written for a minimum of 25 year lease periods guaranteed by local health authorities under the terms of existing procedures.
Cost limits and functionality – a restraint on innovation Hospital design in the UK over the last 50 years has been disappointing. With few exceptions, design quality has been disappointing, sometimes institutional, and not responsive to patients’ needs. The procurement process has been too extended, design quality has been largely ignored and functionality has remained too important in a process dominated by the service providers and the administrators far removed from the interface between patient and doctor within the confines of a clinical ward. Similarly, primary health care buildings have been constrained by a set of procedures contained within the ‘Red Book’, which is now outdated. There have been enlightened solutions in recent years, by architects who have enjoyed a sustained period of work in this sector but imaginative solutions have been inhibited by the cost limits and tests of functionality.
Changing procurement systems It was encouraging, therefore, that the government launched a new organisation, NHS LIFT (Local Improvement Finance Trust), first previewed in the NHS Plan (p. 45) and included in the government’s proposals for new legislation in the Queen’s speech given on 6 December 2000. The intention is to mirror the PFI programme for hospital developments with a scheme suitable for family doctors. The Department of Health envisage 3000 GP premises, mostly in inner cities and poor estates – more than a quarter of the total – being transformed by a £1 bn fund combining public and private money. NHS LIFT will be set up as a limited company, working jointly with the private sector. The government’s first allocation will be £175 m (Hawkes, 2000). The Secretary of State at the time (Alan Milburn) foresaw a complementary programme of public private partnership invested in primary care facilities to improve accessibility, particularly in the neediest areas. It is envisaged that the new facilities will also combine other services such as retail outlets, an optician’s shop, a pharmacy, or other related services. Similarly, the intention is to bring primary care and social services together to improve communications and coordination of needs, thereby achieving a one-stop service for health, social services and housing. The ‘Red Book’ policy continues to focus on room areas and cost parameters but new procurement systems will emerge. The NHS Plan is moving in the right direction. The
Design development/measurement of design quality new financial proposals through LIFT will introduce private finance and increase the flexibility of procuring new primary health care facilities. We can anticipate that there will be fewer partnerships, and that doctors will move towards being salaried employees of Primary Care Trusts. Younger doctors, in common with many other professions, are increasingly reluctant to take on the financial responsibilities of a partnership in an economy that has seen sustained and steady growth with security of employment prospects. Financial success and security can often be achieved without taking on commercial risks. The historical advantages of partnership are increasingly being overtaken by new structures for professional services. Therefore, we can see a major shift towards greater concern for design quality as more sophisticated measuring systems are introduced to evaluate ‘value for money’. Much more research is required to develop accurate appraisals of whole-life costs. From an environmental stance, all five senses of the human body should be considered. 1. Touch 2. Smell 3. Sight 4. Hearing 5. Taste. Some research work is under way paying particular attention to these issues (John Wells-Thorpe, who is chairing a research group based at Sheffield University under the direction of Professor Bryan Lawson).
The Health Minister, Alan Milburn, said when he announced the publication of a report on the progress necessary to improve the NHS Estate (February 2001): One third of our hospitals were built before the NHS was created, and one tenth dates back to Victorian times. You cannot deliver 21st century care in 19th century buildings. For too long investment in NHS infrastructure has been a low priority when it should have been a high priority. Capital investment in the NHS was lower at the end of the last Parliament than it was at the beginning. The consequences are plain for all to see. Buildings that are shoddy, equipment that is unreliable, hospitals that are out of date. Kate Priestly, Chief Executive of NHS Estate when speaking at the CABE conference in London on 6 February 2001, restated that the NHS has the largest property portfolio in Europe. However, 30 per cent of the estate was built before 1940. As part of NHS Estates’ plan to raise the importance of design quality to meet the aspirations set out in the NHS Plan 2000, the biggest ever hospital building programme in the history of the NHS has been launched with a £7 billion capital investment planned by 2010. By then, 40 per cent of the NHS Estate is planned to be less than 15 years old. Part of this plan is to achieve a £1 bn investment in primary care facilities. These issues are now being challenged with huge investment by the government and rapid change is gaining momentum.
Government policy
Construction targets
Procurement routes are changing. Primary health care facilities are becoming larger multifunctional ‘healthy living centres’ offering integrated health and care services. A variety of agencies and professional skills will work in buildings serving the local community. Private finance will be provided by specialist developers and local initiatives will ensure greater control of matching requirements with services. This will have the benefit of allowing the new community facilities to include a wider range of services such as pharmacies, dentists, physiotherapists and alternative or complementary medical practitioners to work all under one roof. As health and care services become more integrated, the new community buildings, or healthy living centres, will grow in size and become multifunctional with a target of 500 new healthy living centres. Opportunities for small and medium practices are set to expand. Building costs can be expected to range between £500 000 and £5 million.
Primary care buildings have faired better during the last 20 years, with some excellent projects having been constructed, showing innovation in design and procurement. Potentially better is to come following the announcements in the NHS Plan.
The condition of the existing estate An examination of the NHS buildings that followed the launch of the NHS Plan in 2000 recognised the size of the problem.
● ●
Refurbish or replace 3000 GPs’ premises. Build 500 ‘one-stop’ primary care centres by 2004.
The formation of Primary Care Trusts is an important policy change creating separate legal entities that can own property and act as clients. Previously, GPs were the main client body, often raising their own commercial loans to finance surgery buildings. Problems of negative equity have arisen and this has discouraged younger doctors to take on the responsibilities of debt to finance their partnership aspirations. The attraction of salaried employment has encouraged specialist developers to offer long-term leases for new premises. How are these ambitious investment plans going to be achieved? The construction industry as a whole is witnessing an upheaval in its procedures, and procurement routes, which are more radical than at any time in the last 50 years. In the mid 1980s over 70 per cent of construction was procured
53
Primary Care Centres using ‘traditional’ contractual arrangements but this had reduced to less than 40 per cent by 1998. The last 20 years has seen an unprecedented upsurge in new contractual arrangements between client and builders which has all had an impact on the way in which design teams have been employed and briefed. There has been a decline in the traditional role of quantity surveyors, project managers are beginning to emerge as a separate professional discipline and design and build contracts have offered maximum price building costs, but all too often there was disappointment about the finished building. The translation of design aspirations often led to disappointment in the realisation of the finished product. Buildings were often over budget, delivered late and had too many defects. The Latham Report, ‘Constructing the Team’ (1994), was the first major investigation set out to examine how buildings were commissioned and built in the UK. This was followed in 1998 by the Egan Report, ‘Rethinking Construction’, a document that concentrated on improving the construction industry by viewing it as a manufacturing process. It identified targets to reduce defects, reduce costs, encourage standardisation of components and offer continuity of work by encouraging the major clients to enter into framework agreements with selected contractors and design teams. Many architects were concerned about the implications of these reports upon their profession, believing that their influence would be diminished and that they would be marginalised by big guns in the major contractors and client bodies – and for a while these concerns were probably well founded. More recently, stimulated by a refocusing of effort in looking at the quality of the product, as well as the quality of the process, there has been a resurgence of concern for high standards of design. These arguments are covered elsewhere in this book. Society has become more aware of the importance of a sustainable, environmentally friendly environment and is developing an understanding for designs that embrace the quality of life factors – the joy and delight that architecture can add to the fabric of society. This highlights the need to fundamentally shift priorities in the current briefing process. The ethos of the organisation must be the springboard for the development of the brief. Procurement routes are therefore changing, and developing to reflect these requirements: ●
●
Criticism of the PFI route – architects have felt their influence constrained by often being expected to work speculatively, or at peppercorn rates, during the competitive bidding stages of appointment often taking many months (if not years) to reach a conclusion. They also feel subservient to the main contractor after their novation in a winning team and sometimes lose authority over their own designs. Procure 21 – the NHS Estates’ proposals for meeting government expectations for repeat business to a selected list of approved large contractors but subject to much criticism by medium sized architects and contractors.
54
●
The LIFT scheme promises to meet many of the difficulties inherent in the other procurement routes particularly for primary health care facilities.
The potential damage caused by the marginalisation of SMEs (small and medium sized enterprises) in the procurement route is considerable, with a loss of skills, resources and local knowledge. There should be a rejection of policies which polarise organisations as either small or very large. The damage done to medium sized contractors, architects and many others in the design process is likely to be enormous.
LIFT (Local Improvement Finance Trust) The launch of LIFT is a new initiative to stimulate the funding and operation of future primary health care facilities. This scheme has superseded the earlier concept of batching primary care facilities together to form the ‘critical mass’ necessary to carry out improvement work under PFI rules. Newcastle had been a pilot study area for the batching of 32 primary health care buildings to create such a single contract opportunity under PFI rules. The Outline Business Case (OBC) had been prepared, but for a variety of reasons the number of sites was reduced to 22. Extensive and helpful comments were received on the OBC from the regional office. However, the launch of the NHS Plan included proposals for LIFT which is designed to introduce private finance in a structure that devolves responsibility down to smaller building blocks at a regional and local level. This company would have a board of advisers and oversee the allocation of funds to regionally organised LIFT companies. These in turn will attract further finance from local authorities, housing associations and Primary Care Trusts and would operate with local boards. The regional LIFT companies would then seek to enter into joint venture agreements with local developers to provide new local primary care facilities. Hence, the initial government funding is designed to lever in a substantial proportion of private finance. A concern is whether the local companies would be of sufficient size (i.e. big enough) to provide competencies in the key areas of: ● ● ●
Strategy Construction Facilities management (FM) and health services.
It might be anticipated that all these skills may be difficult to find within one company, which would be of a size commensurate with the scale of project envisaged at a local level.
Local responsiveness and flexibility To provide high quality local primary care facilities requires flexibility, and a local responsiveness to the needs and
Design development/measurement of design quality requirements that are particular to a community. It can be argued that the provision of the physical building should be separated from the provision of health services and the attendant facilities management needs during the life of a lease. Other sectors of the building industry and property market make clearer distinctions between the provision of the buildings and the operation of the services within them. As discussed elsewhere the office market has clearer structures which govern the way buildings are commissioned and occupied. Although some building owners occupy their own building, a much more sophisticated briefing process has evolved in recent years to enable a greater understanding of flexibility, efficiency and satisfaction by the people who use the spaces. The development of similarly comprehensive briefing documents should be a prerequisite for all new primary health buildings. Within the structure of NHS Estates, regional responsibilities are also limited to an expenditure level of £25 m. This will also limit the size of packages that can be put together at a local level if responsibility and accountability are to be kept within the communities requiring the services. Site acquisition is likely to be a critical factor, and location is a crucial component in the success of a primary health care building. It seems essential, therefore, to ensure that this imaginative initiative is fully explored at a local level, to ensure that the mechanisms are in place to provide the flexibility and responsiveness that will be required for its success. Medium sized developers, consultants and construction firms will need to work together so that collectively the competencies required are provided. This fundamentally different approach to PFI will encourage a ‘bottom-up’ rather than a ‘top-down’ approach to new solutions. There are those who argue for repetition, and standardisation in the provision of primary health care facilities leading to ideas of the same building being reproduced on many sites. An analogy might be drawn to the standardisation of fast food outlets such as McDonald’s, or even the larger supermarket operators such as Tesco or Sainsbury’s where there is a standardisation of building design. However, the NHS is not dispensing commodities; people do not go to their GP to buy off-the-shelf products and the diversity of services suggests that primary care demands a more flexible solution, which will respond to local needs and the peculiarities of a particular community. Perhaps there will be components of a building which could be standardised but health care needs to accommodate the social values that can flow from flexible and humane spaces.
Green to submit designs for five sites at Walker, Brunton, Benwell, Shiremoor and Kenton. The first three were designed by the Geoffrey Purves Partnership and the last two were designed by B3 Burgess. An extensive round of negotiations was conducted before final bids were submitted to the Primary Care Trust. There was a prolonged and exhaustive appraisal process, including a presentation and interview session involving many of the agencies involved in the design process. The client body was complex, including both the local authority and individual GP surgeries. This involved subgroups of activities including dentistry, social services, housing benefit agency, podiatry, physiotherapy and other nursing services. Robertson Capital Projects were successful with their bid and the Geoffrey Purves Partnership was therefore invited to design primary health care facilities at Walker, Brunton and Benwell. These three areas are all suburban locations around Newcastle upon Tyne. The Brunton site is located in an affluent area of middle class housing whereas the Walker and Benwell sites are located in areas of high social deprivation. The concept of providing multifunctional services from the same building led to many conflicting requirements in the brief. For example, it was difficult to allocate responsibility for individual waiting areas, and therefore allocating the cost of cleaning and maintaining these spaces. However, the brief does set out aspirations for design quality and does make reference to the internal environment. The interview process and final selection showed interest in the architectural responses to these issues but the appraisal system for selection resulted in a small percentage of the score being allocated to architecture. Although precise details were treated as confidential, the design team was led to believe that only 30 per cent of the assessment score was allocated to design and construction matters. The balance was given over to other issues including legal matters, facility management services and the overall financial package for the 25 year life of the contract. Within the 30 per cent score allocated to construction and design there was also a significant percentage given over to functionality issues such as the robustness and suitability of materials, their lifespan and suitability for a medical environment. By deduction, therefore, the percentage of the scoring system allocated to design matters could have been as low as 10 per cent. Extracts from the briefing document for the Walker Satellite Facility and the Brunton Park Facility are included in Box 6.1.
Newcastle and North Tyneside LIFT Project
Government aspirations for good design
In September 2002, the Geoffrey Purves Partnership was selected by Robertson Capital Projects Ltd to join their multidisciplinary team to bid for the Newcastle and North Tyneside LIFT Project. They were joined by a second team of architects, the B3 Burgess practice, together with quantity surveyors Gardiner & Theobald and engineers White Young
With better design being seen as part of New Labour’s ‘Cool Britannia’, architects find themselves in the position of political encouragement from the highest level. How is this manifesting itself on the ground? The public sector programme being led by Sir Steve Robson at the Treasury may have some validity for the handful of big hospitals that
55
Primary Care Centres
Box 6.1 Nature of the service and clinical specialities to be provided The Satellite Facility will bring together a number of community oriented services that can be summarised as follows: ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Chiropody/Podiatry Welfare Food Health Visiting District Nursing Consulting Suite for Dietetics, HV, Sure Start, DN Community Dentist Mental Health Physiotherapy – initial assessment
Key functions of the primary care teams not only include the delivery of direct patient and client care but also health needs assessment, health promotion, treatment protocols, care management and the PCT will continue to develop a range of (specialist) services through enhanced collaboration with other professionals/agencies.
●
●
●
●
●
●
Design Quality The NHS is committed to achieving excellence in healthcare design, and LIFTCos’ designs will be assessed against the following principles: ●
●
●
●
Functionality. The design should deliver the occupants’ functional requirements detailed in section 3.0 with sufficient flexibility to ‘future proof ’ the design. Access. Good access to facilities both for everyday and emergency situations, using both private and public transport, should be available for all irrespective of physical ability. Way finding and signage will be clear and an integral part of the design solution. Proximity to areas of pedestrian activity with good lighting and being overlooked from public spaces help to minimise the risk of crime and provide a sense of comfort to all users. Access to the reception area is, for most people, the point where the first impression is made, however, the approach to the building and the ease of access will also play an important part in that process. Space Standards. Space standards shall be developed around ergonomically sound principles. Patient areas should be sized to enable an efficient yet comfortable and therapeutic environment. Character and Innovation. Facilities should be welcoming for patients and conducive for staff to give their best results.
NHS Estates has to deliver over the next few years. But how will it be able to implement this policy for the multitude of small community-based health projects that are going to form the backbone to the primary care health sector in the future and that will need to mesh with local conditions? Their success will depend on the ability to be flexible and responsive to complement existing patterns of housing, education, shopping and transport systems. The emphasis coming out of PPG3, which the private house building companies are being asked to follow, places
56
Citizen Satisfaction. The design of public health facilities should stimulate civic pride, acting as a focal point for the community. Internal Environment. Designs shall ensure that patients are treated with privacy and dignity in safe and comfortable surroundings. The building must also provide staff with the optimum working conditions. Urban and Social Integration. The buildings shall be designed to integrate into the fabric of their surroundings, rather than be insular, detached or self contained. Integration of landscape and external works into the overall design will be critical from the outset. Performance. Standards of day lighting, artificial lighting, ventilation, acoustics and thermal comfort should be tailored to deliver the highest levels of patient comfort and staff efficiency in a safe and secure environment. Engineering. Designs should incorporate the latest and emerging technology. Construction. Construction should be of a high build quality with a strong regard for sustainability issues to minimise maintenance and life cycle costs. Standardisation and prefabrication of building elements could be considered if they are appropriate.
LIFTCo should be aware of the importance the NHS places on design by consulting the NHS Estates’ website, which can be found at www.nhsestates.gov.uk. Designs will be assessed using the ‘Achieving Excellence Design Evaluation Toolkit (AEDET)’ which can be found on NHS Estates’ website. The designs should also reflect the content of the CABE ‘2002 Vision: Our Future Healthcare Environments’ report published in June 2002. Account should be taken of the guidance on design quality included in the DCMS publication ‘Better Public Buildings’, the OGC guidance ‘How to Achieve Design Quality in PFI Projects’ and the 4Ps ‘Achieving Quality in Local Authority PFI Building Projects’. The designs should also aim to meet, as appropriate, the key objectives of the Egan Report.
General The buildings should provide: ●
●
●
a professional environment from which staff can deliver a wide range of high quality integrated services to patients an environment that will promote a sense of well being for both staff and patients an improved image of the service and the organisation
The design should incorporate principles which are sympathetic to the environment and create a sense of place which will make working in or visiting the building an uplifting experience.
the emphasis on good design very much at the level of the local planning authority. Although PPG3 recognises that there may be building technologies to be examined by the house builders, the emphasis is on ‘small is beautiful’. Therefore, is good design sitting in the middle of procurement methodologies that are diametrically opposed? The government is encouraging partnering, which is perhaps a response to dealing with decades of frustration in delivering big projects behind programme and above budget. The Egan philosophy of productivity benefits and
Design development/measurement of design quality economies of scale has yet to be proven in the construction industry where each project is a unique product. It is very different to the production line technologies of 20th century economic theory of supply and demand. A knowledge-based sustainable environment has more to do with recognising the uniqueness and individuality of each site. The challenge for NHS Estates is to find procurement methodologies that meet Treasury objectives, that do not stifle high quality design, and offer flexibility, not standardisation. The government has set out its aspirations for good design and is looking to the private house building industry to rise to this challenge. However, will it be able to achieve the same high standards of design for the big public sector projects via partnering? Perhaps the private sector might just have an opportunity to demonstrate its flexibility and responsiveness by producing better quality designs, that are also better value, be it for housing or privately funded community health projects.
Local competencies Partnering at small and medium levels of contract size also offers potential for productive working relationships. If the LIFT programme is to be successful, cooperation at a local level to allow specialist skills to flourish would seem to argue against all the necessary competencies being provided by one organisation. One possible split is: ● ● ●
Strategic Construction Facilities management/health services.
Allowing competencies to evolve at local level suggests the willingness to consider separately function and ownership of primary health care facilities. The provision of health services and their management and maintenance are quite different to the skills required to build a high quality flexible building that is sustainable, environmentally friendly and efficient to run. The LIFT programme, by encouraging the leverage into the system of private finance, provides every opportunity to develop the more sophisticated marketplace for the provision of primary health care buildings.
Challenges for the future and issues to be taken forward This chapter has explored the very different approach taken by the traditional (or ‘Red Book’) approach to brief writing when compared to the objectives set down for the design team in the brief prepared for buildings in the hospice sector, and more recently the emerging body of work being undertaken under the LIFT programme. The focus of attention in the traditional brief was on functionality and cost. The NHS did not set down guidelines or expectations for patient comfort beyond functional practicalities such as adequate toilet facilities and an appropriate number of seats in the waiting area.
Not being constrained by these requirements, the hospice movement started out from a very different position when the need for such a building had been identified. Funding for these buildings often came from charitable or fundraising sources and their procurement was led by a group of committed people who were seeking a caring environment for patients who would not be offered any further treatment within the NHS system. Consideration of the needs of the dying led to a more humane set of objectives for the environment of these buildings. The language of the brief was different, referring to homely and comfortable aspects of the accommodation above setting down space standards or placing a cost limit on the building. The challenge, of course, is how to measure personal interpretations of the physical environment and this is discussed in greater detail in this chapter. The government is supporting the move towards greater awareness of high quality design and is supporting research in this field such as the evaluation of the briefing process and outcome of the design at the James Cook University Hospital. Policy changes can be detected in this governmental shift towards good design in public buildings and evidence can be found in both the briefing documents and the selection process of the appointed construction teams. The government can be seen, therefore, to be responding to patient requirements and expectations in this consumer-led society, which typifies the first part of the 21st century.
Design quality in health care Outline and objectives There is a need to manage the design process to ensure that the expectations of the patient are achieved. There is also a need to ask ‘How closely do completed buildings reflect the vision and aspirations of the brief and achieve patients’ needs and expectations?’ Put another way, does quality make a difference? The development of research agendas has been limited, not least by very restricted budgets; for example, the NHS research budget amounts to a few hundred thousand pounds per year which is miniscule compared to the overall cost of the NHS which is in the order of £50 bn per year. The shape of the primary health care sector in the UK has been modified much more fundamentally by government policy, which has developed out of the NHS Plan published in 2000. Focused on the concept of patient centred care Primary Care Trusts have been established and the procurement of new and upgraded GP facilities is being channelled through the LIFT programme. The LIFT programme represents a dramatic change in approach reflecting a more fluid and flexible response to patients’ needs based in the community. The brief involves multi-agency activities and recognises the importance of community-led civic pride but at the same time is dependent upon private finance finding economic solutions to build the facilities. Because of commercial pressures there is awareness that evidence-based design should play an increasing role in
57
Primary Care Centres how a building is procured. The objectives for PCTs include the following issues: ●
●
●
Medical approach – The services of locally based GPs will be supplemented with greater involvement of consultant services being offered in the community. Specialist clinics will be established, often tailored to suit local demand. Financial approach – The injection of private capital will be influenced by the availability and value of sites in any particular locality. Design – Consumerist factors will influence the weighting of the other factors so that the local LIFT company will be responding to demand from and convenience for the patient.
Part of this process is a recognition that a well-designed building will provide greater patient satisfaction. This is demonstrated by the work of CABE (Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment) and also NHS Estates through its publication ‘Advice’ which develops a concept of AEDET (Achieving Excellence Design Evaluation Toolkit). This builds on the work done by Prasad for the CIC (Construction Industry Council) and this chapter examines this work. The evaluation of design quality issues is further considered by post-occupancy evaluation techniques. NHS has historically used cost parameters as a benchmark for design evaluation It was said by Kate Priestley, a former Chief Executive of NHS Estates, that ‘the NHS is the most complex organisation in Europe. Employing 1 in 20 of the working population in the UK, the NHS has an annual expenditure of £42.5 bn.’1 The estate includes 11 000 GP surgeries. It is not surprising, therefore, that enormous challenges arise when fundamental changes are planned, such as modernising the procurement process for health buildings. NHS Estates was included in the government’s plans to change traditional forms of construction contracts (such as the Joint Contract Tribunal or JCT model forms) for building procurement in all but the most exceptional circumstances. From 1 June 2000, all central government clients were asked to limit their procurement strategies for the delivery of new projects to PFI, Design and Build and Prime Contracting. Refurbishment and maintenance contracts
will be included in these procurement routes from 1 June 2002. The Treasury has said: ‘this means that traditional, non-integrated strategies will only be used where it can be clearly shown that they offer the best value for money. This means in practice that they will seldom be used.’ As already mentioned, the guidance notes for GP surgeries is heavily biased towards achieving value for money. Projects are expected to ●
● ●
The process flowcharts do not include an interchange with the patients, the ultimate client, and for whom the facilities are being provided. The business case is established on the perceived aims and objectives of the health authority and the doctors. For example, the Guide to the Provision of Leasehold Premises for GP Occupation includes a 17 stage checklist of activities. At stage 4, Prepare Outline Proposal, a series of key issues that should be examined is listed: ● ● ●
●
● ●
●
●
●
●
● ● ●
1
This information was updated in The Times (20 March 2004). One in every 23 of the working population is employed by the NHS. Almost 1.3 million people – or the combined populations of Birmingham and Coventry – now work for the NHS, which is one of the world’s biggest employers. Since 1997, the number of NHS staff has risen by nearly 230 000 with a record 59 000 people – enough to fill Old Trafford football stadium – joining last year alone. A total of 1 282 900 people in England have jobs with the NHS: 4.3 per cent of the 30 million people of working age. Only the Chinese Army and the Indian State Railways are believed to employ more people – with 2.3 million and 1.5 million staff, respectively – but both workforces represent a far smaller proportion of the national population.
58
improve the quality and range of services in proportion to the extra cost promote the right pattern of services provide practice accommodation reasonable for the needs of the patients in the area.
The problem(s) that the project is aiming to address. Analysis of key issues of service need. Objectives of the proposals – which should be specific, measurable and achievable. Key benefits of the project and how these are to be quantified. What other options could meet the objectives of the project? Costs and implications of doing nothing, or doing the minimum. Building and other costs are reasonable and provide VFM (value for money). Other costs will include additional staff, IT and business rates. A statement confirming the commitment of all parties associated with the project. An outline of the risks involved with the project (e.g. security of rental income, assumptions, financial risks to the practice/NHS Trust/HA and other users) and what management structure will be in place. Identification of opportunities for other primary care users, e.g. dentistry, pharmacy, community nurses and other professionals involved in primary care. Analysis of potential facilities management content. DV’s initial assessment of CMR. Environmental impact study.
In ‘A Guide to the Size, Design and Construction of GP Premises’ the introduction ‘explains the principles of the Schedule of GP premises which provides maxima both in terms of size of premises and building costs attached to them. Also provided are guidance notes for the development of the design brief and the assessment of individual schemes.’ Design quality factors in the briefing process NHS Estates considered that their involvement in primary health care was primarily to provide mechanisms for
Design development/measurement of design quality There follows a series of sections about lighting, heating, ventilation, hot and cold water, power, security, communications, patient call system, acoustics, fire safety and lifts. During the last few years many of these factors have been picked up by government departments, and other agencies such as CABE, as design quality issues have emerged as an important component in the procurement process for health buildings.
reimbursing the costs of providing premises for GPs, who, as independent contractors to the NHS, have the responsibility of providing premises for the delivery of services to their patients. They were not overly prescriptive in this, preferring to delegate responsibility for managing the process to the local health authorities who, in conjunction with local GPs, are considered best placed to make decisions which meet local needs and are within the resources available to them. This policy was reflected in General Medical Practice Premises – A Commentary (1998) which included a section entitled ‘Environment’. It says:
Advice on the main components of the design brief for health care buildings
the control of the internal environment should be considered at the brief stage when opportunities to minimise maintenance and running costs can be addressed successfully. The performance of the building services will be a major determinant of the comfort and perception of the premises by both patients and staff. Draughts, smells, poor ventilation and noise should be avoided.
The CIC and NHS Estates have worked closely together, in conjunction with CABE, in developing methodologies for evaluating design quality in the health sector. Figure 6.1 shows the relationship between ● ● ●
functionality impact and build quality.
Location
Type specific attributes
Siting orientation Composition
Efficiency
Fu
nc
tio
Adjacencies
Space allowance
Community/ privacy
Circulation efficiency
Wayfinding
Type specific attributes
Civic contribution Conviviality
Valuing the user
Artificial lighting Image
Natural light
Adaptability
Innovation
Vision
Character
Acoustics
Health and safety
Integration
Material quality
User control
Finishes
Ease of maintenance Construction detail
Durability
Spatial qualities External form
ct
Clarity
pa
Fitness
Landscape
Im
na
lity
Accessibility
Thermal comfort
Structural elegance
Finishes
Natural light
Acoustics
Structural elegance
Artificial lighting
Type specific attributes
Build quality
Figure 6.1
Relationships between functionality, impact and build quality
59
Primary Care Centres This has been developed and used as the basis for the design guide briefing document ‘Advice’ published by NHS Estates. However, it is still difficult to see how this advice is adhered to other than by a determined and clear-sighted client. Benchmarking standards remains largely subjective and subject to pressure from the PFI contractor. At the James Cook University Hospital, the design aspirations were fixed by a determined client who invested a very large amount of staff time in controlling the vision for patient centred care.
These relate to the engineering performance of a building, which includes structural stability and the integration, safety and robustness of the systems, finishes and fittings. 3. Functionality: ● use ● access ● space. These are concerned with the arrangement, quality and interrelationship of spaces and how the building is designed to be useful to all.
Design quality indicator This work has led to the development of the Design Quality Indicator (see Figure 6.2). The more overlap there is between these three quality fields the higher the overall quality. Each topic under the three main indicator sections is separately rated against a group of about ten questions. 1. Impact: ● character and innovation ● form and materials ● internal environment ● urban and social integration.
2. Build quality: ● performance ● engineering systems ● construction.
Added value
Basic
y lit na ity tio od nc m Fu om c
Bu i fir ld q m u ne al ss ity
This system is a tool for evaluating the staff and patient environment in health care buildings. Although the method provides a logical scoring system for assessing the quality of a health care environment the user is still left with no direct financial connection between the result and the implication it may have on the design of the building.
User questionnaires
These refer to the building’s ability to create a sense of place and to have a positive effect on the local community and environment. They also cover the wider effect the design may have on the arts of building and architecture.
Excellence
AEDET (Achieving Excellence Design Evaluation Toolkit)
Impact delight
A national survey of NHS patients was conducted in the last quarter of 1998. The government is committed to carry out a similar survey annually to enable systematic comparisons to be made of the experience of patients. It will also allow comparisons to be made about the performance of primary care services in different parts of the country. The survey was administered as a self-completion questionnaire posted to 100 000 people and the results are based on over 60 000 completed questionnaires. The Department of Health said that the GP survey was designed to help assess the quality of general practice through the patients’ eyes and covered a wide range of issues including access and waiting times, communications with patients, patients’ views of GPs’ knowledge, out-of-hours care, courtesy, and the availability and helpfulness of other surgery staff and services including practice nurses and receptionists. However, it appears that an opportunity has been missed to ask patients to comment on the quality of the buildings. There has been no attempt to connect the information potentially available from the self-administered questionnaires sent to GPs (referred to in the last section) or to invite patients to address similar questions. It would be hugely beneficial if future annual surveys included a section about patients’ perceptions of the quality of the built environment. Valuable data could be built up over a period of years about a range of qualitative issues. For example: ● ●
Figure 6.2 delight
60
Design Quality Indicator – firmness, commodity and
● ●
Did patients find the building convenient to use? Did the building have a calming or relaxing atmosphere? Was the building warm and comfortable? Did it feel welcoming?
Design development/measurement of design quality ● ●
● ●
shortage of this type of data to back up statements that health outcomes are improved from well-designed buildings.
Was it accessible? Did it function satisfactorily (e.g. toilets, soundproofing, privacy at the reception desk)? Was it clean? Were there views to the outside (to a garden or natural surroundings)?
Key performance indicators The use of key performance indicators (KPIs) has evolved out of the KPI Working Group which has been looking at these issues on behalf of the Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions. They identified seven major groups:
Some of these points have been identified by the Picker Institute: The environment around us can set a mood, create a barrier, provide a distraction, give us pleasure or cause us harm. Yet, it is surprising to find that little systematic research has been done examining the impact of the health care environment on its consumers – patients, family members and clinicians. How these consumers are impacted by the physical or built environment is poorly understood. Hitherto, we have not had answers to questions such as: What do patients notice in the physical environment when they go to a doctor’s office, a hospital, or a nursing home? What stands out in their minds? What gets in the way? What matters most to them? What impact does the built environment have on them? Throughout health care, patients and family members are increasingly recognised as the ‘experts’ about the subject of quality of their experience – what matters, what makes them feel better, and what they need to help them recover, heal, and adapt to significant changes in their lives. Because they are truly the only individuals who can tell us this information, as we work to create ‘life enhancing’ environments in health care, we must understand how patients and their families experience those environments and what it is about them that matters to them most. (Picker Institute, 1998)
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Time Cost Quality Client Satisfaction Client Changes Business Performance Health and Safety.
Interpretation of the key project stages (see Figure 6.3) For the most common systems of procurement, experience of the first year’s use of the construction industry KPIs suggests the following common interpretations of the five key stages (see Figure 6.4). However, given the diversity of modern procurement systems and the many variations in practice, it may be appropriate or necessary to adopt different interpretations. The key project stages In order to define the KPIs throughout the lifetime of a project, five key stages have been identified:
The important point of these data would be to make the connection between the quality of the environment and the quality of the medical services. If design is to be taken seriously then it is essential that hard statistical evidence is used to examine the quality of health care. There is an acute
A
Commit to invest – the point at which the client decides in principle to invest in a project, sets out the requirements in business terms and authorises the project team to proceed with the conceptual design.
Key project stages Commit to invest
Commit to construction Planning and design
A
Figure 6.3
Available for use
Defect liability period
Construction
B
End of defects liability period
C
End of lifetime of project
Lifetime of project
D
E
Key performance indicators – key project stages
61
Primary Care Centres Procurement system
Typical milestone at key point/stage A
Figure 6.4
B
C
D
E
B
D
E
Traditional (designer led)
Appointment of lead designer
Appointment of lead (main) contractor
Handover of built facility for use; payment of all non-retention monies
End of defects liability period (often 12 months); payment of any retention monies
End of useful life
Design and build
Appointment (if any) of consultants prior to main contract
Appointment of lead D&B contractor
Ditto
Ditto
Ditto
Construction management
Appointment of lead designer
Ditto Appointment of construction manager
Ditto
Ditto
PFI
Appointment of ‘special purpose vehicle’
Handover of Appointment built facility of lead for use contractor (if different), or sanction to proceed with construction phase
End of defects liability period if relevant
End of concession useful life; ongoing payment to contractor
Procurement systems and five key stages
Commit to construct – the point at which the client authorises the project team to start the construction of the project. Available for use – the point at which the project is available for substantial occupancy or use. This may be in advance of the completion of the project. End of defect liability period – the point at which the period within the construction contract during which the contractor is obliged to rectify defects ends (often 12 months from point C). End of lifetime of project – the point at which the period over which the project is employed in its original or near original purpose ends. As this is usually many years after the project’s completion, this is a theoretical point over which concepts such as full life can be applied.
made on design solutions quickly and efficiently. It is easy to use and gives a valuable indication of the performance of a building design.
Post-occupancy evaluation The RIBA (Royal Institute of British Architects) Architect’s Job Book lays out a systematic app-roach to the design and construction process. It is presented as an aide-mémoire to assist architects with the design of all building types. The sequential and systematic framework advocated is with ‘feedback’ at the end of this process and identifies three possible areas for examination: ●
The KPIs The KPI groups, their associated indicators and guidance on their use are shown in Figure 6.5.
NHS Environmental Assessment Tool (NEAT) The BRE Environmental Assessment Method (BREEAM) provides another valuable evaluation tool. Largely based on a ‘tick-box’ approach the tool enables assessments to be
62
C
● ●
An analysis of the project records An inspection of the fabric of the completed building Studies of the building in use.
It recognises that a full feedback study may be expensive and suggests that it may be necessary to negotiate a separate commission with the client should this work be deemed to be necessary. This highlights the failure of the profession to grasp the enormous value to be gained by constantly reviewing all available knowledge about the design problem in hand. As often as not, this feedback process suffers
Design development/measurement of design quality
Group
Indicators
Level
Time
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Time for Construction Time Predictability - Design Time Predictability - Construction Time Predictability - Design and Construction Time Predictability - Construction (Client Change Orders) 6. Time Predictability - Construction (Project Leader Change Orders) 7. Time to Rectify Defects
Headline Headline Headline Operational Diagnostic
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Headline Headline Headline Operational Diagnostic
Cost
Quality
Cost for Construction Cost Predictability - Design Cost Predictability - Construction Cost Predictability - Design & Construction Cost Predictability - Construction (Client Change Orders) 6. Cost Predictability - Construction (Project Leader Change Orders) 7. Cost of Rectifying Defects 8. Cost in Use
Diagnostic Operational
Diagnostic Operational Operational
Headline 1. Defects Operational 2. Quality Issues at Available for Use 3. Quality Issues at End of Defects Rectification Operational Period
Headline Client Satisfaction 1. Client Satisfaction Product - Standard Criteria 2. Client Satisfaction Service - Standard Criteria Headline 3. Client Satisfaction - Client Specified Criteria Operational Change Orders
1. Change Orders - Client 2. Change Orders - Project Manager
Diagnostic Diagnostic
Business Performance
1. Profitability (company) 2. Productivity (company) 3. Return of Capital Employed (company) 4. Return on Capital Employed (company) 5. Interest Cover (company) 6. Return on Investment (client) 7. Profit Predictability (project) 8. Ratio of Value Added (company) 9. Repeat Business (company) 10. Outstanding Money (project) 11. Time taken to reach Final Account (project)
Headline Headline Operational Operational Operational Operational Operational Diagnostic Diagnostic Diagnostic Diagnostic
Health and Safety 1. 2. 3. 4. Figure 6.5
Reportable Accidents (inc. fatalities) Reportable Accidents (non-fatal) Lost Time Accidents Fatalities
Headline Operational Operational Operational
Key performance indicators: main groups and associated criteria
from the day-to-day pressures of dealing with the next job in hand. It always seems to be more important to press on with the excitement of the next design challenge, and even if there was time available there never seems to be the right moment to ask a client to spend more money on a project which as often as not will be stretching financial limits to the brink of acceptability. How easy it is to gloss over a few rough edges, not question a few embarrassing oversights in meeting the brief or open up old discussions about compromises on the quality of finishes due to cost limitations.
All architects are familiar with this scenario and the most important issue on their minds may well be ensuring that their last fee instalment is paid on time. The culture of sharing knowledge and the benefits which might accrue if the same design team is commissioned to build a second or third building of the same type is a luxury rarely shared in the construction industry. Of course, the Egan and Latham Reports seek to address these issues but unfortunately they concentrate on improving the quality of the process rather than the quality of the product (see Chapter 3).
63
Primary Care Centres In 1996, MARU (Medical Architecture Research Unit) published a review of primary health care buildings including a helpful section about evaluating buildings in use. It recognises the circular process of reassessing design decisions and suggests three types of evaluations:
●
●
●
1. Audit – measurement of certain criteria against an implied standard, in a defined location, to establish a range of values and indicate relative position. 2. Case study – investigation of selected examples to learn lessons. 3. Evaluation – assessment of the success in terms of specific criteria. However, a more thorough review of post-occupancy evaluation techniques is described by Mardelle McCuskey Shepley (Shepley, 1997). This broad review of methodologies includes a comprehensive list of references at the end of her chapter in Healthcare Design, edited by Sarah O’Marberry. A more specific publication is The Exeter Evaluation (Scher and Senior, 1999). This report sets out the detailed results of an intensive research project undertaken at the new Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital. The report ends with five conclusions concerning: 1. Awareness and communications (a programme to inform all staff about the benefits of art in the healing process). 2. Displaying visual arts (careful consideration of location in both public spaces and in close proximity to patients). 3. Staff participation (using staff skills in music, photography and writing, for example). 4. Resources (establish a budget heading). 5. The value of arts in health care (increase knowledge). Although not directly relevant to primary care facilities this work represents an example of the systematic evidencebased research work that will become increasingly necessary to justify design quality decisions. The intuitive and artistic responses of the architect will in future require justification and substantiation to ensure design approval.
●
the process: the client is determined not to lose sight of the vision during the procurement process urban design: civic responsibility and community involvement must engage with patient and indeed all users of the building benchmarking: evaluation techniques should be used to monitor progress of the design during the construction stage, and after completion by post-occupancy evaluations patient centred: priority must be given to patients as consumers in the health sector.
The research has highlighted the contradictions that exist between the power of architecture to influence human emotions and the practical constraints imposed by the requirements of a functional brief. The research questions are reconsidered and recommendations are made about how to improve the design quality of primary health care buildings.
Contradiction between the influence of architecture and the demands of a functional brief This book has examined the quality of design in primary health buildings and how this is expressed in the brief, and compared it with the functional issues and standards of construction more usually set down as a client’s expectation. The conclusion remains elusive. Leaving aside the issues of therapeutic benefits and holistic care considered in earlier chapters, Frank Lloyd Wright’s philosophy displays as powerful an argument about the influence of architecture to create a healing environment as it is possible to state. ‘He pioneered the “organic” approach to architecture, which was a radical departure from the traditions of his day, dominated as it was by European styles that dated back hundreds of years’ (Knight, 2001). His clinic for Dr Kenneth Meyers in Dayton, Ohio, built in 1956 provides a timeless and compelling example of the power of place.
This chapter has identified a growing range of evaluation toolkits to assess design quality. There is recognition in government of the value of striving for high standards of design. However, the connection between the high standards of design and financial accountability remains elusive and inadequately defined. In essence, it remains in the gift of the client who is determined enough not to lose sight of design aspirations and to strive for excellence – essentially an intellectual target, but with growing evidence that it can be justified. The key issues seem to be
The patient arrives through an entry between two rectangles, which are set together not at a right angle but at a wider, right-angle-and-a-half: on the left is the waiting room, a harmonious and regular rectangular space. When called to see the doctor, however, the patient moves into a more mobile zone – also rectangular but with half an octagon joined to it to supply examination rooms. The laboratory is situated under the peak of the octagon, with the practice library tucked away on the far side. The opposite side of the rectangle contains further examination rooms and the x-ray space, with a darkroom attached. This means that the surgery area, unlike the waiting room, itself invites change and a sense of progression – architectural optimism appropriate for a centre of healing. (Knight, 2000)
the vision: a client has a clear view of the design quality envisaged
The vigorousness of this debate is further encapsulated by the strength of feelings expressed about the design of the
Summary
●
64
Design development/measurement of design quality new Royal London Hospital. Widely reported in the architectural press (e.g. Building Design, 6 August 2004) the government’s PFI strategy is being challenged over the quality of the design solution. Criticism of the procurement system is made by both the interim chairman of CABE (Paul Finch) and the president elect of the RIBA (Jack Pringle). There are major lessons we have to learn from the way the Royal London has been procured … the fact that the result is, in our view, a failure in significant aspects is as much a criticism of the process of hospital procurement in this country as of the efforts of the trust or its preferred bidder. (Finch, 2004) CABE’s coruscating criticism of this project’s strategic design decisions made early in the procurement process and the quality of the resultant design puts another nail in the coffin of this crude type of PFI mechanism … Architects and their clients need to work with the real client, the hospital trust. (Jack Pringle, RIBA president elect, 2004) The current sensitivity of these divergent pressures on the design process continues to be very much under scrutiny in the architectural professional press as this book is being written (autumn 2008). Austin Williams, writing in the Architects’ Journal (26 August 2004) says: ‘the noble Vitruvian ideals of commodity, firmness and delight have been reduced to mundane tick box criteria such as “functionality”, “build quality” and “impact”.’ Compare this interpretation with the aspirations of the CIC’s work undertaken by Sunand Prasad (see Chapter 6). Williams denigrates that stance thus: ‘Value added’ is now a recommended assessment tool in architectural circles. Whereas we used to get on with the business in hand, knowing that the product of architecture had intrinsic value, these days we all seem to be angst-ridden about whether we are adding enough value and if it is the right quality value. After all, how do we measure how valuable the added value is; is the value that we are trying to add sufficiently valued by others? Could a concentration on certain core values devalue other fringe values? We just don’t know and so we continue to have conferences to pontificate about it with little chance of reaching a conclusion. This is the recipe for building by numbers, with architects playing a demoralising never-ending game of benchmarking. He goes further and says: … architects now have to justify their work in moral terms: does the design improve wellbeing? Does it add value to business efficiency? Will it improve the health of the occupant? Vitruvius did not judge the success of architecture by getting a range of responses from lay user and community groups. He did not use a questionnaire. He understood
that good architecture could lift the spirit but did not claim that architecture could heal the sick. He did, however, acknowledge that good architecture advances the health of society. Architects need to find their critical voice again and start challenging the craze for value added, that actually adds no value other than increased regulation, and for design quality masquerading as social engineering. These criticisms of the procurement process for health buildings highlight the weaknesses and shortcomings in many present day briefing processes. Most research has been conducted on large projects, and in particular PFI projects, but 90 per cent of health care in the UK is dealt with by GPs in primary health care buildings. This book has used the literature about large hospitals but aims to provide recommendations that are appropriate to small buildings which are usually very much part of the local community and the need to have a sense of place appropriate to their locality. The ethos of the building is a generator of its stature in the community and an important factor in a patient’s sense of being at ease in using the space. It contributes to the sense of well-being.
Quotations The following quotations highlight the holistic approach to designing primary health care buildings which many people believe brings advantages to all users of the facility. Architecture is also about the spiritual needs of people as well as their material needs. It has much to do with optimism, joy and reassurance; of order in a disordered world; of ‘privacy’ in the midst of many; of space in a crowded site; of light on a dull day. It is about quality. Increasingly, there has rightly been a focus on the commissioning of hospitals and other healthcare buildings of quality, durability and style. Of course it will continue to be important to control costs, but aesthetic and architectural considerations must also be given proper recognition. (Lord Foster, quoted by Mr Chris Smith, as Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport at the Opening Plenary Session of the Arts in Hospitals and Healthcare Conference, held in Strasbourg, France, 4–6 February 2001) Increasingly doctors and other healthcare professionals will need to work more closely with their patients to explore which treatment the patient feels best meets their need. I believe the potentially powerful role of complementary therapies will need to be increasingly recognised and incorporated into an individual’s healthcare. (HRH The Prince of Wales, 11 November 2000, at the Millennium Festival of Medicine Conference) You can have the most efficient procurement process in the world but if you don’t have a decent design you will still end up with a second-rate building.
65
Primary Care Centres Quality and quantity must be evaluated together, with quality receiving a far higher weighting. The client’s design advisers should be just as important as the Quantity Surveyors. (Sir Stuart Lipton, Chairman of the Commission for Architecture and the Building Environment). In public health, we’ve got to address the rising expectations of consumerism. People demand better buildings. (Peter Wearmouth, NHS Estates acting chief executive).
Anticipating the future The information age has given us the ability to share knowledge globally. There has been a new awakening of moral attitudes and responsibilities arising out of the Human Rights Act which is giving a greater sense of respect for the individual person. This is reflected in health care which is once again becoming focused on the patient as an individual. We should be encouraged by the opportunities now being presented to capture the ethos coming out of thoughtful building briefs. Everyone involved in the provision of primary health care is increasingly aware that individuals must be the centre of their own health care or well-being. There seems to be a universal acceptance that this policy can apply in both rich and poor economies. Health for all really is a policy for primary medical care, which has no opponents and crosses political boundaries. The training of doctors is becoming more broadly based. Many university departments are now recognising that a scientific and technology-based approach for medical education does not give a sufficiently well-rounded training for the doctors of the next generation. Humanities are being introduced to the curriculum of medical schools which reflect the recognition that doctors need to treat patients in a more holistic manner. In the same way that architects have moved on from the principle of ‘a house is a machine for living in’, so doctors are recognising that well-being is more complex than scientific enquiry alone. The government is also moving its position on health care policy with a new understanding of the importance of patients’ needs. The requirements for health care are being assessed from the perspective of patients and there is recognition that the social agenda for health care needs to become more inclusive. Inevitably, this will lead to greater complexity in the organisation of services, and the crossing of boundaries between traditional concepts of health care, social services such as housing and the treatment of mental health issues. One is led down the path of recognising the importance of the built environment to provide a humane place in which to live a healthy life.
Trends The research brings together a range of solutions from which it is possible to distil a series of common strands in the design approach.
66
1. Policies around the world are concentrating on improving health care services at a primary level. 2. There is universal attention to patient centred care irrespective of the size of the building, or wealth of the country, in which it is located. 3. Architecture and medicine are talking to each other. The quality of the humane healing environment is seen as a positive benefit. The technocrats are acknowledging the contribution to health care from urban design. The quality of the place we live in is important to our well-being. 4. Our well-being is reflected in the environmental quality of our new health buildings: smaller, community-based flexible spaces, easily accessible and welcoming. They are designed for the benefit of the patient rather than the provider of medical services. 5. There is a high incidence of curved shapes in the design of small health buildings. The building form envelopes the user, provides comfort and is reassuring. It is non-threatening and not confrontational. By a combination of form, light and colour, buildings around the world straddle cultural differences with an architectural language that individuals can recognise whatever their mother tongue.
Objectives of a brief Doctors and architects need to work more closely together. Through the development of briefing documents, we should be optimistic about the opportunities that will arise for primary health care buildings in the future. They will provide the physical framework within which the complex social interaction of the community can engage with the medical profession. There is agreement that many of the better examples of good design for health buildings have been built in the primary care sector. 1. The brief should be the central and fundamental cornerstone for the provision of future health care buildings. It should set down the ethos and culture for the health care environment. Many of these overarching objectives will be common to the design of a doctor’s surgery anywhere in the world. 2. There are both strategic and practical levels of planning. It is at the practical level where there may be more substantial differences in the briefing document between one country and another. 3. The brief should set down the design aspirations. It will set out the ‘wish list’ and establish the sense of wonder which excites the spirit when good architecture is encountered. 4. The brief must bring together current ideas and anticipate future trends. 5. It must also capture the sense of change which is sweeping through the primary health care design field not just in the UK and the USA, but in many parts of the world. 6. In another decade we are likely to find much broader acceptance of alternative therapies. In the West, we have only recently begun to understand and accept the contribution
Design development/measurement of design quality that alternative health remedies can bring. How much more there must be to learn about traditional Chinese medicine, for example, and environments such as the Glasgow Homoeopathic Hospital may well be the forerunner of many other buildings in the future seeking to combine traditional medicine, alternative therapies and a high quality of environmental design. 7. More sophisticated linkages are likely to emerge. Key words and phrases to consider when writing a brief are shown in Figure 6.6. An examination of these issues will assist in establishing the strategic framework for the design of a new primary health facility. It may be helpful to prepare checklists on these points as an aide-mémoire during discussions with key members of the client and design team. This will give focus and direction to the establishment of both the strategic and practical aspects of the brief.
Design quality Our modern understanding of a primary health centre was set out in the Dawson Report (1920) as ‘An institution equipped for services of curative and preventive medicine to be conducted by general practitioners of that district, in conjunction with an efficient nursing service and with the aid of visiting consultants and specialists.’ It remains a valid definition today, but during the intervening 80 or so years the earlier professional arrogance of architects and doctors has shifted markedly towards a more humane, understanding and listening attitude. This approach is explored in the editorial of Medical Humanities (volume 27, number 1). Medical Humanities as an aspiration looks both forward and backward, seeking in part the rediscovery of a certain attitude towards medicine, its natural objects/subjects (patients) and its place in the cultural, artistic and scientific order. That attitude is embodied in the idea of a Renaissance Man or Woman embracing an interdisciplinary (even omni-disciplinary) view of the world, a universal gaze which is, on the face of it, no longer available
Key words: networking concepts • Government policy
• Finance and funding
• Community facilities
• Flexibility
• Education (training)
• Communications
• Sustainability
• Location (accessibility)
• Knowledge (transfer of skills) • Transport policy • Value for money
• Patient needs
Figure 6.6 Brief writing – key words and phrases
to us in a world of runaway specialisation in knowledge. Consider how one might both celebrate ‘The beauty of the human form and the nobility of the human spirit’ and peruse ‘An insatiable curiosity for the materiality of the here and now, a Faustian itch to explore … ’ – a universal gaze which, fused within an individual mind, may seem paradoxical, rather than merely daunting. Be that as daunting – or as paradoxical – as it may, we suggest that one source of both moral and intellectual renaissance for the contemporary physician lies in recapturing a sense of wonder at the human body, its place in the natural realm and its miraculous functioning as the fount, and the medium, of embodied human experience. (Evans, 2001) This view is echoed by the government, by CABE and by many others in the architectural profession in recognising the importance of design quality and the need for a ‘wow’ factor. The excitement and vision that architecture can give to the human spirit can be more readily seen as the basis of a health policy built around personal well-being. In short, a holistic approach. Perhaps all this was foreseen by Anton Chekhov who said in a letter to a fellow writer: I thought then that the sensitivity of the artist may equal the knowledge of the scientist. Both have the same object, nature, and perhaps in time it will be possible for them to link together in a great and marvellous force which is at present hard to imagine. By closer cooperation the medical and architectural professions will be better equipped to answer in a more rounded and complete way our individual health needs. The large commercial architectural practices in America are beginning to question the philosophy of creating very large hospital complexes, partly as a result of pressure on cost fitting policies in the USA. The problems being experienced in the UK with the quality of the new wave of hospitals procured through the PFI process highlight the historical priorities given to functionality and cost standards in the UK building programme. The sheer size of some of the largest hospital projects invites comparisons with the environments of some large airport complexes, or even the new town developments of the 1960s. The government, fortunately, is now recognising the importance of good design and the limitations of a project management profession which has mushroomed in recent decades. Perhaps the ambitions of grandeur on a larger scale would be better served by a more humble approach to meeting the smaller scale of human requirements of social interchange at a person-to-person scale. It is at this scale that the all-important relationship between patient and doctor takes place. The gap between large practice, working on the big hospital projects, and those who are working on the smaller primary health care projects is a difficult one to bridge.
67
Primary Care Centres The LIFT programme is promising but is still at an early stage in development. Government policies are not consistent. For example: 1. The government is advocating better design standards in civic buildings. 2. The NHS Plan has a very ambitious programme for investment in small-scale buildings (i.e. GP surgeries). 3. The government seems intent on pursuing building procurement through the PFI process (which is not suitable for small projects and is attracting a great deal of adverse criticism on the design standards achieved in recent health projects).
Right at the beginning of the document there should be a section that encourages the design team to set out the quality aspirations expected from the building. It needs to encourage future users of the building to think about what the ethos of the building should be; to set out what the building users want out of the building; and to consider the intangible values that the designers aim to achieve. For example, should the building be: ● ● ● ● ● ●
Recurring themes The following list sets out a number of key issues that have kept re-emerging throughout the preparation of this book. ●
● ●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
● ●
Emphasis on quality of architectural design – importance of high quality environmental factors. Emphasis on the patient as an individual. Patient focused care as a local level of primary care being the hub of patient treatment rather than the start of a linear process of passing through various levels of specialisation. Building flexibility – design for change, openness, accessibility. Buildings have not played a key role in health policy, but need to in future. There has been insufficient recognition of the importance of environmental quality, and the effect that this can have on health care. Architects need to take up the opportunity to build on the new interest by doctors to embrace health and humanities. It is people that regenerate places, not places that regenerate people. Over-reliance on economic, social and physical modelling techniques and statistical analysis at the expense of visual stimulus undervalues the importance of architecture. Visual stimulus is a key ingredient of the built environment. The delight of architecture should not be squeezed out of the built environment by analytical methodologies. Give status to the product as well as the process (think of design as well as construction). Put architecture back into health. The patient must come first.
A framework for the brief – the ethos The key words and phrases listed earlier in this chapter (Objectives of a brief, point 7) will shape the brief and establish the starting point for defining the ethos of the building that is being commissioned.
68
● ●
Friendly? Efficient? Welcoming? Relaxing? Comfortable? Warm? Pleasant? Accessible?
There should be a fundamental skew to the way briefing documents are written compared to the priority given to the tests for functionality and finance which have been the benchmark for commissioning primary care health buildings until recently. The brief should seek to encourage the achievement of high design standards through the eyes of the patient – the tests of functionality and cost should be a secondary, albeit essential, requirement of the procurement process for any new primary health care building. Huge potential benefits are coming out of these changing philosophies in primary health care buildings, which will influence the quality and procurement methodology for our health buildings at the specialised end of health care. Opinions are being voiced about larger hospital sites being broken down into villages, with different architects being appointed for specialist departments, or even viewing a hospital in terms of adjacent development within the urban planning of adjacent blocks in our existing city centres. Medical schools are responding to these challenges by the introduction of humanity courses. Architectural departments in our universities should similarly respond by giving greater attention to the training of future generations of architects in the health sector. There is little attention being given to the design of health buildings at either an undergraduate level, or research programmes for post-graduate study. Jessica Corner articulates some of the shortcomings from the eyes of the nurse when she says the clinical setting adopts, through its architectural presence, both the interior design and building structure, a message of progress, cleanliness and efficiency. This takes precedence over comfort, reassurance, information or participation. The architecture supports the quite literal transportation of people into the world of treatment and its time dimensions … There is a process of separating people from normal life in the manner from which they are conducted from the hospital door towards all departments inside … Clinic, ward and consultation room structures reinforce the separation between
Design development/measurement of design quality patient and professional … These are the architectures of treatment and not of personal care.
●
●
She goes on to argue that
● ●
policy makers for healthcare need to determine the form of future buildings. Buildings, whether they are large hospitals or local surgeries, need to be different. They need to embody different meanings. In particular buildings need to convey recognition of people’s sense of self, of ‘me’, rather than promote, as they do now, the collective need for healthcare to get ‘the job done’ by controlling and processing patients. (Corner, 2001)
●
● ●
● ● ● ●
Strategic components of a brief Having established a framework of ideas or ethos, and understanding the context and networking requirements for a particular building in a specific location, the strategic components of a brief can be more precisely laid down. These will include: ●
●
●
●
●
●
The vision – how will the experience of visitors, patients and staff be enhanced by the building? – how will the design quality add to the expectation of excellence? – how will a high quality environment be achieved? – will it be patient focused? The process – select an appropriate procurement method to ensure that design quality is not stifled. Urban design – will the building contribute to the sense of place? – will transport linkages work? Benchmarking – is the building going to add to the level of competencies prevailing in the vicinity? Value for money – will it represent ‘best value’? Patient centred – will the brief encourage good environmental design and achieve therapeutic benefits for patients and all other users of the building? – is it patient centred?
Practical components of a brief After the ethos of the project has been defined, and the strategic objectives have been agreed, the practical issues of functionality and cost can be explored. What this research has revealed is that what benefits would arise if a new databased handbook for primary health care facilities was available, but written through the eyes of the patient rather than from the perspective of the health service provider. Thus, new standards could be quantified and dimensioned for:
patient control of their environment in treatment rooms, waiting rooms and other spaces design of furnishings, fixtures and fittings flexibility in the layout of equipment within a space flexibility of use of a space environmental design standards and performance specifications compliance with access for the disabled transportation links (on foot, by cycle, car or public transport) functionality landscaping building materials cost limits.
A 19th century approach to well-being for town dwellers was the Victorian park, which was conceived as a green lung to improve the public health of the urban workforce. Allowed to fall into disrepair during the 20th century they are being restored, once again, and their original qualities are being rediscovered. Healthy living centres should be seen as a future resource (in the 21st century) for good advice – a patient centred facility in the community where help can be found about diet, fitness, health checks, social services and a range of other activities to encourage a sense of well-being in the place where we live. Although not exhaustive, these items are typical of the main thrust of a design brief, which needs to be analysed by looking at patient convenience, effectiveness and efficiency. The practical performance of a building is obviously important and it must work efficiently – i.e. there must be a basic level of design competence of technical matters but they must contribute to achieving the design quality issues set out in the ethos. The process should be completed by ensuring that postoccupancy evaluations are undertaken to measure the success (or otherwise) of meeting the aspirations for the building which were set out in the ethos statement.
Recommendations During the research period for this book, the approach to design quality in health buildings had significantly changed. Positive support for good design is now being given by the government and the effect of this change of policy is cascading down through a variety of commissioning bodies and agencies with responsibility for approving projects in the primary health care sector. This is excellent news for all architects, and doctors can expect higher quality buildings than sometimes was the case 10 or 20 years ago. Architects should exploit the opportunity to develop a brief that reflects design quality as the primary benchmark of any new commission. There is ample evidence to support approval for putting patient priorities
69
Primary Care Centres Assembling a brief
A framework of issues for doctors and architects to discuss together when developing a brief for a healthy living centre – to compare, contrast and challenge each other about ideas when establishing the criteria for a new building. Issue
Architecture
Medicine
1
Functionality
space standards, initial cost effectiveness, data sheets
flexibility, meeting future working patterns
1
Multi-agency
planning flexibility, long life, loose fit
choice of agencies, services to be offered
1
Accessibility/ convenience
transport linkages, pedestrian routes, parking, disabled access
patient adjacency, alternative locations
environmental performance standards
good practice models, standard room plans
1/2 Exemplar design models
1/3 Site/location/ urban context, land acquisition planning constraints, value for money 2
Brief – the ethos architectural of the building language, style, patient comfort, therapeutic benefits
convenience, visibility of building, availability personal rapport with patients, relationships, working environment, sense of well-being
2
Community
quality of the place, welcoming, comfortable
friendliness, reassurance, accessible
3
Finance – procurement method, costs
contractual arrangements, PFI, LIFT, design criteria, project management, programming
PCGs/PCTs ability to influence funding, budgets, access to finance
3
Sustainability
energy consumption, lifecycle costs
recycle facilities, medical efficiency
3
Standardisation standard components routine procedures, within unique design, clinic requirements, compatibility with choice of materials other surgery operating systems
2. Consider the strategic objectives
3. Establish the requirements for patient satisfaction
4. Identify the practical requirements (functionality)
5. Check: (Post-occupancy evaluation – have points 1, 2, 3 and 4 been achieved?)
Figure 6.8 Writing a brief – flow chart of actions
Quality ●
●
Key: 1. Physical 2. Emotional 3. Financial
Figure 6.7
1. Define the ethos
●
●
●
Writing a brief – matrix of factors to consider
first. Seen from the perspective of the patient let us consider three key elements of an architectural brief: 1. Quality – to set the standard for well-being. 2. Functionality – to check the technical performance. 3. Cost – to ensure economic viability and value for money. Taking these in order, the following bullet points highlight a series of issues which should be discussed, and written into the brief before design work commences.
70
‘Building a 2020 vision: future healthcare environments’ by the Nuffield Trust (Francis and Glanville, 2001) summarises the changing attitudes towards designing health care buildings, including primary care facilities. It offers an excellent overview of likely future trends and is the product of a series of focus groups consisting of some of the most informed health care professionals working in the UK in the period 2000–2001. Quality needs to be viewed from a wide perspective including the social and community values which new buildings should seek to meet. Aspirations and ambience are both words that invite a description of the cultural environment within which a building will sit, and which extends beyond any perception of its physical limitations. Patients and staff, as well as doctors, should be asked for their views. The World Health Organisation’s view that the single most important factor for health in a hospital is the atmosphere captures the sense of well-being that flows from a well-designed environment. The therapeutic benefits of this approach are accepted, as the increase in the literature of evidence-based research demonstrates.
Functionality ●
●
The brief should list all technical standards that are required to be met. This will include both NHS space standards and statutory regulations. Performance specifications should be reviewed and discussed with all users so that expectations of colour, light,
Design development/measurement of design quality
●
●
● ● ●
●
sound and other environmental factors are understood. This will include the Disability Act to ensure compliance with all legislation for accessibility. Several recent documents provide guidance and checklists to simplify this task for architects. Security and external accessibility, e.g. transportation links, pedestrian routes and other practical aspects of the building fitting into its urban context, need to be assessed. Flexibility of the building shell over its anticipated lifespan. Multipurpose community uses. Location. Sustainability – consider the choice of materials and the economic and environmental factors. An analysis of benefits arising from local services may show considerable improvement in lifestyle and well-being. Construction methods – the government is encouraging a variety of techniques for larger projects (including large health buildings) to show economies of scale such as repetition and standardisation. This is to encourage construction to be seen as a manufacturing process. With smaller projects, usually the norm for primary health care buildings, these perceived advantages are usually harder to achieve.
The brief will comprise two parts: ● ●
The initial brief should include the following. Introduction and overview: ● ● ● ●
●
●
●
Procurement routes are changing. PFI is advocated by the government for large projects but has limitations for small projects. LIFT offers new challenges for primary health care facilities through the Primary Care Trusts and Primary Care Groups. Procurement methodology will evolve and new models will be tested over the next few years. Direct construction costs must be judged to give value for money. The cost to society brings to bear more complex economic analysis including lifecycle costs. Indirect costs, as well as the direct construction costs, need to be considered, such as pride in the locality and lifestyle satisfaction issues. What value is placed on a sense of well-being?
Ethos, aims and objectives of the project Key constraints Organisation Population.
Operational policy statements for: ● ●
Cost ●
Initial brief Full brief.
Clinical functions Support functions Administration Reception, admissions, appointments Materials handling Waste management Security Domestic services Portering Car parking Sanitary facilities Staff amenities Visitor amenities.
Design quality statement Schedule of accommodation: ●
Room by room schedule including: Unit area of each room type Number of rooms of each type Room occupancy. Functional relationships diagram:
●
Network of adjacencies and links between scheduled spaces.
Typical layouts (1:50) of key accommodation types showing:
Example of typical specification for a brief The following notes are a typical specification for a brief for a health care building as proposed by Gordon Kirtley (from personal discussions and correspondence). A crucial component is the development of the ethos, aims and objectives of the project which should form part of the initial brief.
● ●
The full brief should include for each room or space. ● ● ●
Typical specification for the brief of a health care building The brief for the project should comprise a comprehensive but concise statement of the requirements of the client and the user groups, normally following the scope and format described in the Capital Investment Manual.
Key modular dimensions Generic equipment and furniture layouts.
●
Equipment list for Groups 1, 2 and 3 equipment Key dimensions, including room height Requirements for: Wall, floor and ceiling finishes Daylight/blackout Acoustic requirements Doors and access (size, security, vision panels, etc.) Other special requirements Room data sheets for engineering services requirements.
71
Primary Care Centres Note: The client should appoint an equipment specialist who will liaise with the user group and collect detailed information on equipment items, including procurement proposals (e.g. existing equipment relocated, new equipment, etc.). The role of the briefing consultant will be to collate and coordinate this information.
● ● ●
Fire safety (may be covered by H&S) Security Facilities management and estates issues, including deliveries, waste, domestic services, catering and maintenance.
Preparation of the brief
Summary
The initial brief and the full brief will be prepared in consultation with the client’s nominated representatives. A typical consultation process would include, for each user group, a series of three meetings:
The conclusion and recommendations of this chapter provide an opportunity to set out four key guides to providing better primary health care centres in the future.
● ● ●
Initial briefing meeting Review of the first draft Review of the final draft.
The briefing consultant will prepare an agenda and chair the user consultation meetings. User groups In addition to core user groups for clinical services, there should be special working groups for the preparation of the initial brief, including: ● ● ● ●
Interior design Equipment coordination Phasing and decanting Health and safety
72
1. Doctors and architects must work together and develop common briefs for the next generation of primary health care buildings. They must be written for the benefit of patients. 2. The buildings must be designed to create a framework for the social interaction of the community that they serve. They must be socially inclusive, flexible, caring and accessible. 3. Well-designed primary health care buildings will become the focal point for the next generation of health buildings and will influence the shape and operation of larger and specialist facilities. 4. Primary care buildings will become the catalyst to encourage greater harmony between health policies around the world. Sustainable construction methods will develop and at the same time provide shelter for holistic medical protocols to flourish.
7
Holistic care
In an earlier chapter we saw that holistic care was a central part of caring for the sick. The development of hospitals began out of a wish to offer hospitality to those in need. In those early times, up until the Renaissance, almost everything done for the sick in Western Europe was provided by the church. However, with the development of scientific medicine much of this pastoral care was gradually taken out of the church’s hands and during the past two centuries the medical profession has become secularised (House of Bishops, 2000). The development of the medical profession, in a technological sense, has developed with the creation of the Royal Colleges and the establishment of specialised qualifications. Unfortunately, this has led, until recently, to an attitude of mind that saw death as a failure of medical treatment. In a similar manner to taking your car to a garage where you expect the repair to be fixed, the medical profession pursued technical innovation which saw death as a failure. The World Health Organisation has reported that the single most important factor for health in a hospital is the atmosphere. If this is true then the spirit in which the medicine is practised is important. However, with government policy rapidly changing the focus of attention onto patient centred care based in the community we know that the vast majority (75 per cent or more) of the health budget of the NHS is spent in the primary care sector. This would suggest that there is an urgent need to address the provision of holistic care services within the primary care sector. A recent government report, NHS Chaplaincy (Department of Health, 2003), addresses the need for chaplaincy services in hospitals and includes the following key roles for chaplains: ●
● ● ●
provide appropriate spiritual and religious care to patients, staff and other users provide pastoral care provide regular opportunity for religious expression identify and assess the needs for chaplaincy/spiritual care within the organisation regularly
●
support multi-faith working which respects and supports faiths identified within the trust.
The main thrust of the document is based on the provision of hospital chaplaincies. It identifies that spiritual and religious care has been part of the NHS since 1948, and the Human Rights Act, introduced in October 2000, enshrines in English law the right of the individual to religious observance. Similarly, the Scottish Executive offers guidelines on chaplaincy and spiritual care on the NHS in Scotland (Scottish Executive, 2002) but this also focuses on the role of hospital spiritual caregivers. Therefore, we should re-examine the role of holistic care in the primary health sector. Many GPs already have links with alternative medical treatment offering guidance on complementary medicine and alternative therapies. Should community-based GP surgeries have more direct links with chaplains or representatives of other faith groups? Should GP surgeries be encouraged to develop formal links with faith groups in their locality? Perhaps primary care buildings should reflect these issues of well-being in their design, and provide spaces for contemplation or rest. This is part of the development of an environment for healing. There is an immense shift from assessing the value of what is being done by many medical and nursing staff as a sense of vocation to assessing it in terms of cost effectiveness. Do staff need to rediscover the sense of vocation where they have to help in healing and not just regard themselves as ‘service providers’? The use of language is important. A balance has to be struck between the book-keeping elements of running a GP surgery and offering compassion for suffering people. The hospice movement has developed rapidly over the last three or four decades. Modern hospices are historically routed in Christian belief, although in practice they are broadly theistic. Interestingly, a survey of findings from chaplaincies in hospices and hospitals in England and Wales (Wright, 2001) traces the development of the modern hospice movement
73
Primary Care Centres led by Cicely Saunders who was following the tradition of the ancient Christian ‘hospes’ of welcoming the sick and performing the works of mercy contained in Matthew chapter 25 verses 35 and 36. The report goes on to argue that evidence is emerging of a continuing