springer Monographs in Mathematics
Arkady L. Onishchik • Rolf Sulanke
Projective and Cayley-Klein Geometries With 69 Figures
^ Spri ringer
Arkady L Onishchik Faculty of Mathematics Yaroslavl State University Sovetskaya 14 150000 Yaroslavl, Russia e-mail:
[email protected] RolfSulanke Institut fiir Mathematik Humboldt-Universitat zu Berlin Rudower Chaussee 25 10099 Berlin, Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
Library of Congress Control Number: 2006930592
Mathematics Subject Classification (2000): 51-01,51N15,51N30, 51M10,51A50,57S25 ISSN 1439-7382 ISBN-10 3-540-35644-4 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York ISBN-13 978-3-540-35644-8 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York This workis subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9,1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springer.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typesetting by the authors using a Springer TgX macro package Production: LE-TgX Jelonek, Schmidt & Vockler GbR, Leipzig Cover design: Erich Kirchner, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper
44/3100YL - 5 4 3 2 1 0
Preface
Projective geometry, and the Cayley-Klein geometries embedded into it, are rather ancient topics of geometry, which originated in the 19th century with the work of V. Poncelet, J. Gergonne, Ch. v. Staudt, A.-F. Mobius, A. Cayley, F. Klein, S. Lie, N. L Lobatschewski, and many others. Ahhough this field is one of the foundations of algebraic geometry and has many applications to differential geometry, it has been widely neglected in the teaching at German universities — and not only there. In the more recent mathematical literature these classical aspects of geometry are also scarcely taken into account. In the present book, the synthetic projective geometry and some of its recent applications, e.g. of the finite geometries, are mentioned only in passing, i.e., they form the content of some remarks. Instead, we intend to present a systematic introduction of projective geometry as based on the notion of vector space, which is the central topic of the first chapter. In the second chapter the most important classical geometries are systematicaUy developed foUowing the principles founded by A. Cayley and F. Klein, which rely on distinguishing an absolute and then studying the resulting invariants of geometric objects. These methods, determined by linear algebra and the theory of transformation groups, are just what is needed in algebraic as well as differential geometry. Furthermore, they may rightly be considered as an integrating factor for the development of analysis, where we mainly have in mind the harmonic or geometric analysis as based on the theory of Lie groups. Even though, wherever it does not require any extra effort, we allow for vector spaces over an arbitrary skew field, we nevertheless mainly deal with geometries over the real, the complex, or the quaternionic numbers; we also discuss the consequences of extensions as weU as restrictions of the scalar domain to the geometries in question. Apart from the real projective geometry we also treat some of the complex and quaternionic geometries in detail, which are rarely presented on an elementary level. The elementary conformal or Mobius geometry is extensively discussed, and even some aspects of the symplectic projective geometry are studied. The concluding Section 2.9 contains a brief introduction into the theory of Lie transformation groups with an outline of the classification
VI
Preface
of transitive Lie group actions on the n-dimensional spheres and projective spaces. The octonions and the octonion geometries, which correspond to the exceptional groups rather than to the classical series of Lie groups remain outside of the scope of this book; for this topic we refer to H. Freudenthal [39], M. M. Postnikov [89], and H. Salzmann, D. Betten, Th. Grundhofer, H. Hahl, R. Lowen, M. Stroppel [97]. With this systematic presentation we hope to provide a useful tool for all who intend to acquire the necessary background material all by themselves or in special seminars. The systematic organization, the detailed proofs, interspersed exercises, and an extensive index starting with a hst of symbols, are meant to facilitate choosing the topic of respective interest as well as its study. The appendix contains the definitions of several notions from algebra and geometry used in the text, which are not treated in greater detail there. The book is intended to be a manual and work book, and was by no means written as the text on which a lecture should be based. A flaw of the book which the reader will soon notice is the missing or, at best, loose connection of the material with its history. The presentation by no means follows the course of the historic development; that would have expanded the size of the book considerably and also claimed too much time and working capacity from the authors as well as the readers. Instead, we decided to take the systematics of the subject from the current point of view as the guiding principle, and to start from the structures also used in other parts of mathematics, e.g. groups or vector spaces, which in fact developed in connection with geometry. We consider labelling propositions, principles, etc., by the names of mathematicians rather as the usual way of denotation than stating any priority or authorship of the mathematician in question for the result. Interpreting these propositions as historicaUy correct claims of authorship would, implicitly, assert to have studied the complete literature, even the correspondence or the the oral traditions up to this moment, in order to exclude the existence of any predecessor, a venture the authors do not want to pride themselves on. We do not intend to include a complete bibliography of this field. Today it is not difficult to gather arbitrarily extensive lists of references from the available data banks. We only refer to the titles used to work on this subject, where chance and personal choice play an essential part. Frequently, we relied on the well-known basic textbooks by E. Artin [4] and R. Baer [5]. Of course, we have to thank our teachers for the suggestions and orientations we received since the time of our studies and over the long years of our cooperation, which, perhaps sometimes unknowingly, influenced the presentation. Particularly to be mentioned here are the lectures, seminars, and writings by W. Blaschke, E. B. Dynkin, L. A. Kaloujnine, A. G. Kurosch, P. K. Raschewski, and H. Reichardt. We also want to quote some textbooks and monographs dealing with our subject from a different point of view or with differing emphasis. First, there is the report of results by J. Dieudonne [36] containing more general and more
Preface
VII
detailed results than this book as weU as a comprehensive bibliography. The very interesting and brief textbook by A. Beutelspacher and U. Rosenbaum [12] contains the analytical as well as the synthetic foundations of projective geometry, and, in addition, recent applications to coding theory and cryptography. The finite geometry is also discussed there, a subject to which the complete two-volume treatise [10], [11] by A. Beutelspacher is devoted, see also L. M. Batten, A. Beutelspacher [6]. The book [7] by W. Benz presents interesting propositions characterizing geometric transformations under weak assumptions, e.g. the Theorems of Beckmann and Quarles for Euclidean isometries, and the theorem of A. D. Alexandrow concerning Lorentz transformations. In that book the geometries of Lie and Laguerre are also treated, which are not included here. Interesting concrete material discussed from the point of view of Klein's Erlanger Programm can be found in the book [8] by W. Benz. There, apart from the classical geometries, the reader may also find descriptions of the Einstein cylinder universe and the de-Sitter space. The rich summary [69] by Linus Kramer describes the recent development of projective geometry; the structure of the projective group, the relation between incidence properties and algebraic properties of the scalar domain, generalizations of the fundamental theorem, Tits buildings, Moufang planes, polar spaces, and quadratic forms are discussed there, and non-commutative scalar domains receive particular emphasis. As prerequisites for the understanding of this book the reader is assumed to be familiar with the fundamental notions of linear algebra as well as the afhne and Euclidean geometries based on it as they are usually presented in the first year of any course in mathematics or physics. This also includes the knowledge of the affine classification of quadrics and its Euclidean refinement by means of the principal axes transformation. We will frequently use these notions and results without special reference. Moreover, some experience of the metric Euclidean, non-Euclidean, and spherical elementary geometries are useful for understanding this book; as a brief and clearly written, very rich presentation we mention the recently published textbook [1] by I. Agricola and Th. Friedrich. Obviously, for the authors and the readers, who are familiar with or have at their disposal both volumes of the series "Algebra und Geometric" [82, 83], it is advisable as weU as convenient to make use of the relations to the topics discussed there. For this reason we frequently refer to these sources, e.g.. Proposition 1 in § 4.2 of [82] is quoted as Proposition 1.4.2.1, and, correspondingly, § 6.2 from [83] as § II.6.2. Instead of these books the reader may of course draw on other textbooks which as a rule contain similar results. Familiarity with differentiable manifolds or Lie groups, however, is not required to understand this text. The authors tried to include an extensive index. Nevertheless, the entries usuaUy do not occur twice; e.g., "orthogonal group" is only hsted as "group, orthogonal". References to the book itself have the usual format; i.e.. Proposition 5 stands for the corresponding proposition in the same section. Proposition 6.3 refers to Proposition 3 in Section 6 of the same chapter, and CoroUary 1.3.4 cites Corollary 4 in Section 3 of
VIII
Preface
Chapter 1. The same holds for formulas: (2.5.19) is formula (19) in Section 5 of Chapter 2. The nearly 70 illustrations accompanying the text mostly were produced using the software Mathematica by St. Wolfram [114]. This program provides numerous possibilities for numerical as well as symbolic calculations and contains a varied graphic apparatus for the visualization of plane and spatial geometric objects, which is naturally tied to Euclidean geometry. On the homepage http://www-irm.mathematik.hu-berlin.de/'~sulanke some notebooks written using this software can be found. They were developed writing this book and extend the possibilities of Mathematica. They include notebooks for pseudo-Euclidean geometry, by means of which relativity theory, Mobius geometry. Lie's sphere geometry, and, via their Killing forms, semi-simple Lie algebra may be studied. In great detail the three-dimensional Euchdean and the Mobius geometry of A;-spheres, A; = 0,1, 2, is treated. Some of the formulas obtained by means of symbolic calculations using these notebooks, expressing Mobius invariants in terms of Euclidean invariants similarly to the Coxeter distance of hyperspheres, are included here. On the homepage one also finds a very fast orthogonalization algorithm going back to Erhard Schmidt as well as a procedure to orthogonalize sequences of vectors in pseudoEuclidean spaces. This opens up possibilities which, because of the scope and complexity of the calculations involved, are impossible to reach by the traditional methods, i.e. "by hand". The so-caUed "artificial intelhgence" reaches its limits as soon as it leaves the finite algorithmic ground and turns towards the abstract conceptual thinking abounding in modern mathematics. Already implementing the naive set theory in Mathematica meets serious difficulties, as the example of a system of Mathematica notebooks and packages designed for this purpose shows, which can also be found on the homepage. The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of their work provided by the Humboldt-Universitat zu Berlin. In particular, we thank Heike Pahlisch, Hubert GoUek, Jiirgen Gehne, and Hans-Joachim Spitzer for their assistance and technical help. We express our sincere gratitude to Bernd Wegner from the Technische Universitat Berlin for his interest in our work as well as his endeavor to publish it. We thank the Springer-Verlag for including the English translation of the book into its publishing program and the permission to publish the German manuscript on the homepage above for private use. Last but not least we thank Andreas Nestke for his careful translation of the German manuscript and the always friendly and fruitful cooperation with us during his work. We think and hope that this book may cause some of our colleagues and many students to considerations and investigations of their own.
Berlin, June 2006
A. L. Onishchik R. Sulanke
Contents
Projective Geometry 1.1 Projective Spaces 1.1.1 Definitions and First Properties 1.1.2 Plane Projective Geometry 1.2 Homogeneous Coordinates 1.2.1 Definition. Simplices 1.2.2 Coordinate Transformations. The Projective Linear Group 1.2.3 Inhomogeneous Projective Coordinates 1.2.4 The Projective Linear Group over a Field 1.3 CoUineations 1.3.1 Collinear Maps 1.3.2 The Main Theorem of Projective Geometry 1.3.3 The Group of Auto-Colhneations 1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps 1.4.1 The Group Aut P ^ 1.4.2 The Cross Ratio 1.4.3 Projective Maps 1.4.4 Harmonic Position 1.4.5 Staudt's Main Theorem 1.4.6 Projective Equivalence of Colhnear Maps. Involutions . . 1.5 Affine Geometry from the Projective Viewpoint 1.6 Duality 1.6.1 Duality in Plane Incidence Geometry 1.6.2 Projective and Algebraic Duality 1.6.3 Projective Pencil Geometries 1.6.4 Dual Maps 1.7 Correlations 1.7.1 Definition. Canonical Correlation 1.7.2 Correlative Maps 1.7.3 ^-Correspondences and a-Biforms
1 2 2 11 15 15 20 21 22 24 25 32 35 40 41 42 46 51 53 55 59 65 66 67 71 73 75 76 77 80
X
Contents 1.8
Symmetric Auto-Correlative Maps 1.8.1 Null Systems and Polar Maps 1.8.2 Equivalence of Auto-Correlative Maps 1.8.3 Classification of Null Systems 1.8.4 Linear Line Complexes 1.9 Polarities and Quadrics 1.9.1 (T-Hermitean Biforms 1.9.2 Classification of Polar Maps 1.9.3 The Real Polar Maps 1.9.4 The Complex Polar Maps 1.9.5 The Quaternionic Polar Maps 1.9.6 Quadrics 1.9.7 Polar Maps of Projective Lines 1.9.8 Tangents and Tangent Subspaces 1.9.9 Dualization: Coquadrics 1.10 Restrictions and Extensions of Scalars 1.10.1 Hopf Fibrations 1.10.2 Complex Structures 1.10.3 Quaternionic Structures 1.10.4 Projective Extensions 1.10.5 The Projective if-Geometry of P ^ 1.10.6 if-Classification of Projective L-Subspaces 1.10.7 Extensions of Null Systems, Polar Maps, and Quadrics 2
Cayley-Klein Geometries 2.1 The Classical Groups 2.1.1 The Linear and the Projective Groups 2.1.2 The Projective Isotropy Group of a Correlation 2.1.3 The Symplectic Groups 2.1.4 The Orthogonal Groups 2.1.5 The Unitary Groups 2.1.6 The Quaternionic Skew Hermitean Polarities 2.1.7 SL{n, K) is Generated by Transvections 2.2 Vector Spaces with Scalar Product 2.2.1 Vector, Projective, and Affine Geometries 2.2.2 Subspaces 2.2.3 E. Witt's Theorem 2.2.4 Properties of Isotropic Subspaces 2.2.5 The Proof of E. Witt's Theorem 2.2.6 Transitivity Results 2.2.7 Neutral Vector Spaces 2.2.8 Tensors and Volume Functions 2.2.9 The General Vector Product 2.2.10 Adjoint Linear Maps 2.2.11 Properties of the Root Subspaces
84 84 86 87 89 92 92 94 96 96 98 101 107 109 Ill 112 112 115 117 119 123 126 . 128 133 133 134 136 137 139 141 143 145 148 149 150 151 151 154 157 159 161 163 165 172
Contents
XI
2.3 The Projective Geometry of a Polarity 176 2.3.1 The Quadric of a Polarity 176 2.3.2 Efficiency 179 2.3.3 Orthogonal Geometry. Reflections 182 2.4 Invariants of Finite Configurations 186 2.4.1 PG„-Congruence of Finite Point Sequences 186 2.4.2 Orbits of Points. Normalized Representatives 189 2.4.3 Invariants of Point Pairs 191 2.4.4 Real Orthogonal Geometries 196 2.4.5 Projective Orthogonal Geometries for Arbitrary Fields . 198 2.4.6 Plane Cone Sections 203 2.5 Spherical and Elhptic Geometry 207 2.5.1 Spherical as a Covering of Elhptic Geometry 207 2.5.2 Distance and Angle 211 2.5.3 The Law of Cosines and the Triangle Inequality 217 2.5.4 Excess, Curvature, and Surface Area 221 2.5.5 Spherical Trigonometry 227 2.5.6 The Metric Geometry of Elhptic Space 232 2.5.7 Angle between Subspaces and Distance of Great Spheres234 2.5.8 Quadrics 238 2.6 Hyperbolic Geometry 243 2.6.1 Models of Hyperbohc Space 245 2.6.2 Distance and Angle 256 2.6.3 Distance and Angles as Cross Ratios 260 2.6.4 The Hyperbolic Law of Cosines and Hyperbolic Metric . 266 2.6.5 Hyperbolic Trigonometry 272 2.6.6 Hyperspheres, Equidistants, and Horospheres 277 2.6.7 Stationary Angles 283 2.6.8 Quadrics 291 2.6.9 Pictures of Hyperbohc Quadrics 309 2.7 Mobius Geometry 314 2.7.1 Spheres in Mobius Space 314 2.7.2 Pairs of Subspheres 319 2.7.3 Cross Ratios and the Riemann Sphere 331 2.7.4 Mobius Invariants and Euclidean Invariants 341 2.7.5 Three-Dimensional Mobius Geometry 344 2.7.6 Orbits, Cychds of Dupin, and Loxodromes 349 2.8 Projective Symplectic Geometry 358 2.8.1 Symplectic Transvections 359 2.8.2 Subspaces 361 2.8.3 Triangles 363 2.8.4 Skew Lines 366 2.8.5 Symmetric Bilinear Forms and Quadrics 374 2.9 Transformation Groups: Results and Problems 385
XII
Contents
Basic N o t i o n s from Algebra and Topology A . l Notations A.2 Linear Algebra A.3 Transformation Groups A.4 Topology
403 403 404 404 407
References
417
Index
423
List of Figures
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9
Line bundle and the projective plane Central projection of parallel planes Central projection of non-parallel planes The projective plane over Z2 Desargues' Theorem Pappos' Theorem Coordinate triangle in P^ Harmonic Position An Ellipsoid
4 7 8 12 13 14 17 52 104
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13 2.14 2.15 2.16 2.17 2.18 2.19 2.20 2.21
Hyperboloid, tangent plane, inner and outer tangents A cross-cap J. Steiner's Roman Surface Boy's Surface Euler Triangles Angles of a Euclidean triangle Proof of Lemma 10 Stereographic projection of P ^ ( R ) Euler triangles in P ^ ( R ) A Mobius strip Decomposition of P (R) into four congruent triangles A spherical eUipse Intersection of the sphere with an elhptic cone Stereographic projection of a spherical eUipsoid Stereographic projection of a spherical hyperboloid The isotropic cone The pseudo-Euchdean model The hyperboloid (?,?) = 1 The pseudo-Euchdean and Klein's model for H^ Parallels in Klein's model for H^ Stereographic projection
194 210 211 211 218 222 225 228 229 230 231 239 239 241 242 244 246 249 251 252 253
XIV
List of Figures
2.22 2.23 2.24 2.25 2.26 2.27 2.28 2.29 2.30 2.31 2.32 2.33 2.34 2.35 2.36 2.37 2.38 2.39 2.40 2.41 2.42 2.43 2.44 2.45 2.46 2.47 2.48 2.49 2.50 2.51 2.52 2.53 2.54 2.55 2.56 2.57 2.58 2.59 2.60
Parallels in the Poincare model for H Circle tangents in the conformal disk model for H Polar coordinates in Poincare's model for H Cartesian coordinate lines x,y in the conformal disk model for H^ Cartesian coordinate lines x, y in Poincare's model for H Equidistants of a hne in the conformal disk model Equidistants as orthogonal trajectories for the normals of a line in the conformal disk model (cf. Figure 2.27) Horocycles in the conformal disk model Ellipse in the conformal disk and in Poincare's model, Ai = 1.1, A2 = 4 Non-Euclidean hyperbolas, Ai = 0.5, A2 = 1.8 J3-curves, A = ± j / 2 , j = 1, 2 , . . . , 10 J2--curves, A = 1, /x = 1.1,1.4,1.7,..., 3.2 J2--curves, A = 3, /x = 3.1, 3.8,4.5,..., 8 J2--curves, A = 1.5, 2 . 5 , . . . , 9.5, /x = 10 J2--curves, A = 0.2, n = .3, 2.3, 4 . 3 , . . . , 18.3 J2--curves, A = - . 1 , - 1 . 1 , - 2 . 1 , . . . , - 8 . 1 , n=l J2--curves, A = 0, -0.2, -0.4, -0.6, ...,-2,jj,= l J2--curves, A = - 1 0 , /x = - 1 , - 2 , . . . , - 9 J2--curves, A = - 2 , . . . , - 1 1 , /x = A + 1 J2--curves, A = - 1 0 , n = - 1 1 , - 2 , . . . , - 1 9 J2--curves, A = - 1 , . . . , - 1 1 , / i = A - 1 J2^-curves, X = 1^ = - 1 , - 2 , . . . , - 1 0 , for A = /x = - 1 the limit circle qc-curves, A = 2^ ± i V7, j = 1, • • •, 10 qc-curves, X = e'^''''i/^°J = ± 1 , . . . , ± 9 Eigenspheres of orthogonal point pairs in S^ C S^ The sphere pencil of a circle A pencil of circles and its orthogonal trajectories Existence of circles in a pencil meeting a test circle The function F(0.3,1.5, s,t) The function F(0.6,0.6, s,t) The surface {C(a, a)\0 < a < 7r/3} The torus t)(s, t, 7r/7) A torus generated by inversion Image of a circular cylinder under an inversion Image of a circular cone under an inversion A loxodrome in the plane A loxodrome on the sphere A spiral cyhnder Inversion of a spiral cyhnder
255 256 261 261 262 271 279 282 296 299 302 309 309 310 310 310 311 311 311 312 312 312 313 313 324 325 340 340 347 347 348 349 351 351 352 354 355 355 357
List of Tables
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4
Polarities, biforms, and their isotropy groups Normalization for the classical polarities Transitive actions on spheres Transitive actions on C P " and H P "
146 191 400 401
Projective Geometry
The presentation of projective geometry in this chapter will be based on linear algebra. We will start with some remarks concerning the central projection intended to be a motivation, which will then lead to the definition of a projective geometry as the lattice of subspaces of a vector space. The first fundamental result to be proved is the Main Theorem of projective geometry relating its geometric properties closely to the algebraic ones: If the dimension is at least two, i.e. for the plane and all higher-dimensional projective spaces, then geometric isomorphy implies algebraic isomorphy. There exists a collineation between two spaces, i.e. a bijective map transforming lines into lines, if and only if, first, both their dimensions coincide, and, second, their scalar fields are isomorphic. The one-dimensional case, the projective line, requires special considerations, since the collineation condition cannot work there; we will introduce the cross ratio of four collinear points and prove Staudt's Main Theorem: Invariance of the harmonic position alone implies invariance of the cross ratio. The duality of vector spaces has a projective counterpart, the duality of projective spaces. This duality enables to study correlations, i.e. bijective maps from point spaces to spaces of hyperplanes preserving incidence. Symmetric auto-correlations will be classified by reducing the problem to the classification of skew-symmetric and Hermitean biforms. The results of both classifications will be interpreted geometrically: as linear line complexes in the skew-symmetric case, and as hyperquadrics in the Hermitean case. Over the scalar domains of the real numbers, the complex numbers, and the quaternions we will obtain a complete classification. Finally, we will also investigate the geometric implications brought about by extending or restricting the scalar fields. In particular, we will describe the Hopf fibrations, which play a prominent part in topology.
2
1 Projective Geometry
1.1 Projective Spaces 1.1.1 D e f i n i t i o n s a n d F i r s t P r o p e r t i e s There are two, in their course essentiaUy different approaches to projective geometry, the synthetic and the analytic one. T h e latter should better be called the linear-algebraic approach, since linear algebra rather t h a n analysis forms its basis and provides the methods. Nevertheless, the name "analytic geometry" became firmly estabhshed in the course of history. In synthetic geometry sets of geometric elements of various kinds, e.g. points, lines, planes, are given, and the existing relations between t h e m are fixed axiomatically; these axioms correspond to familiar geometric concepts. Instead, here we prefer an approach based on linear algebra, which is more abstract but at the same time much more general and, in principle, even simpler. There is no need to build a special theory whose axioms have to be changed frequently, but everything relies on the notion of vector space. This structure is fundamental for analysis as well as many applications of mathematics, hence its knowledge is compulsory for every mathematician. Moreover, any undergraduate course would include this topic. Synthetic projective geometry is already systematically treated in the comprehensive two-volume treatise [106] by O. Veblen and J. W. Young t h a t appeared in 1910 and 1918. T h e two-dimensional case, i.e. plane projective geometry, plays a prominent part there, cf. G. Pickert [87]. Later in this section we will present a brief discussion of its simple axiomatics. In this context, interesting connections between this synthetic axiomatics and algebraic properties of the scalar domain will arise, t h a t can be constructed on the basis of these axioms. Conversely, these relations wiU become evident by looking for the analytic projective geometries satisfying certain synthetic axioms. A vivid introduction into the plane projective geometry can be found in H. S. M. Coxeter [34]. In the sequel we wiU always suppose t h a t a vector space V over a skew field K is given^. T h e set of one-dimensional subspaces of V wiU be denoted by P{V); we will call it the projective space associated with the vector space V. It is common to define the projective space as an extension of the affine point space by means of a so-called hyperplane at infinity. T h e one-dimensional subspaces of the vector space associated with the affine geometry bijectively correspond to the families of parallel lines in the affine space, which are determined by attaching the vectors of the subspace to the points in the affine point space. Expressed differently, each of these families is the orbit of a onedimensional vector subspace in point space. Intuitively, one thinks of all the
The only skew field essential for the following is the skew field of quaternions H. To distinguish between a left and a right vector space is only necessary in the case of a non-commutative field K. For now it will suffice to take the fields of real or of complex numbers as K, hence the whole discussion will remain within the usual framework of vector spaces.
1.1 Projective Spaces
3
lines within such a family as passing through a common single point at infinity. The set of all these points at infinity corresponding to all the different families of parallels constitute the hyperplane at infinity to be attached. To make this concept more precise is elementary, but lengthy and laborious. It is much simpler to start from the definition above and then embed the affine geometry into the projective one by distinguishing an arbitrary hyperplane, which, consequently, is to be called the hyperplane at infinity, cf. Section 5 of this chapter. The projective plane will serve as an example to illustrate these observations. In Example 2 below we wiU see that the projective extension of point space is necessary and expedient to describe central projections: Example 1. The Real Projective Plane. Let V= R^ be the three-dimensional vector space over the field R of real numbers, and denote by A the associated affine space; we wiU frequently consider this to be the physical space. By e G A we denote the point with coordinates (0, 0,1), i.e. the unit point on the z-axis. Attaching the one-dimensional subspaces of V to the point e defines a bijection from P{V) onto the set of hnes passing through e, cf. Figure 1.1. Attaching in a similar way the two-dimensional subspaces of V to e defines a bijection between the set of these subspaces and the set of planes through e. Each line through e, which is not parallel to the x, y-plane H (z = 0), meets this plane in a unique point. Obviously, the lines through e parallel to H form a one-parameter family, whereas to describe the others we need to specify two parameters, e.g. the coordinates of their intersection point with the X, y-plane H. All lines through e lying in a plane B through e, i.e. whose vectors belong to the same two-dimensional subspace W C V, intersect H in one line, the line of intersection B n H. The only exception to this is the vector space U oi H itself, which, by attaching it to e, determines the plane Bo = e + U parallel to H. Thus it appears natural to extend the affine plane by a "line at infinity", whose points just correspond to the lines through e paraUel to H. We wiU denote this extension by H. In this picture, the line at infinity appears as the intersection of the similarly extended plane BQ with H. It is common to introduce the real projective plane this way: Start from the affine plane and attach a line at infinity to it, whose points correspond to the non-oriented directions of the plane, i.e. the equivalence classes of parallel lines in the affine plane. So all parallel lines in such a class appear to meet in a unique point of the line at infinity. Since there is a bijective correspondence p : X e P{V)
1-^ p{x) e H
between the elements of P{V) and the points of the extended plane H, we arrive at a clear picture of P{Vy^. Note that, in the projective sense, the line at infinity in the picture above is equivalent to any of the other lines in the plane. • ^ The topological shape of the real projective plane will be described in Examples 2.5.1 and 2.5.4 in the following chapter.
1 Projective Geometry
Fig. 1.1. Line bundle and the projective plane. The bijection p described in the previous example induces a similar bijection between the two-dimensional subspaces W G V oi the vector space V and the set of lines h G H '\n the projective plane H:
WGV^B
= e + W^h
=
Br\H.
Here, the subspace U oi H corresponds to the plane parallel to H through e and the line at infinity of H. These considerations can easily be generalized to the n-dimensional case; they suggest to interpret the lattice of subspaces of the vector space V (cf. § 1.4.2) in the following projective-geometric way extending the affine point of view that, basically, amounts to renaming the structures provided by the lattice of subspaces: Definition 1. Let V be a right vector space over the skew field K. By ^ ( V ) we will denote the lattice of subspaces of V and call it the projective geometry of V: its elements are called projective subspaces. The projective dimension Dim of an element W G ^{V) is equal to the dimension of the vector space diminished by one: Dim W := dim W — 1.
1.1 Projective Spaces
5
Since all right (and left, respectively) vector spaces V of equal finite dimension n + 1 over the same skew field K are isomorphic, we will usually just write
^l
:= *P(F"+i)
This is the n-dimensional projective geometry over K. T h e zero-dimensional elements in ^ ( V ) are the points of the projective space P{V)
:= {a G ^{V)\
D i m a = 0}.
For the n-dimensional projective space we will also use the notation P^:=P(F"+i)
(n
If the skew field K is clear from the context, we will omit the index K. In general, W is called a projective k-plane if Dim Vt^ = k] the set of A;-planes of an n-dimensional projective geometry will be denoted by Pn,k and referred to as the Grafimann manifold.^ As usual, the elements of P „ , i are called lines, those of P „ , 2 are the planes, and for A; = n — 1 we have the hyperplanes; the word "projective" will be omitted if there is no danger of confusion. Two elements U,W e ^{V) are said to be incident, written as t / ( , Vt^, negation:
UlH,
ii U C W or W C U holds. Keeping the notation we transfer the inclusion relation'^ C of subspaces of V to ^{V). The vector space V itself is the largest element with respect to the order C, and the trivial subspace is the smaUest, o := {o} G ^{V); we decided to called it the nopoint in projective space. T h e section of two projective subspaces U,W e ^{V) is understood to be their (set-theoretic) intersection:
uAW •.= unw. Their join is defined to be the smallest subspace containing both, i.e. the linear span of their union (cf. § 1.4.2):
WW
:= Z{U yjW) = U + W.
It is straightforward to extend the notions section and join to arbitrary famihes of subspaces ( i J J t g / :
In correspondence with the dimension convention, the Grai^mann manifold has a differing notation in vector algebra, Gn+i,fc+i(= Pn,k)'^ We do not distinguish between C and C, i.e., A C B is the same ss A
1 Projective Geometry
i.ei
i.ei
The familiar rules of linear algebra (cf. § 1.4.2) remain valid; this is summarized by stating t h a t projective geometry is a "complete lattice" with respect to the inclusion C. T h e nopoint o has only a formal, hardly any geometric meaning. Two projective subspaces are called skew if their intersection is the nopoint. By Definition 1 we have D i m o = — 1. This definition together with the dimension theorem of linear algebra (Proposition 1.4.6.3) immediately implies the analogous result for projective subspaces: P r o p o s i t i o n 1. formula holds:
Consider
D i m ( t / AW)
U,W
^ ^{V).
Then the following
dimension
+ D i m ( t / y W) = Dim U + Dim W.
Exercise 1. Use the dimension formula (Proposition 1) to discuss all possible position relations of projective subspaces F^, _ff™ C P " for 0 < fc < m < n < 4. Find an example for each of the resulting cases. The two subspaces are skew if and only if their join is not contained in any (fc + m)-dimensional subspace. Compare the results with the corresponding ones in afRne space (s. § 1.4.6). T h e next example clearly shows the advantage of the historically younger concept of projective geometry: From this point of view, the properties of central projection are derived by direct reference to the dimension formula. From the afRne point of view, i.e. looking at the projective plane as the extended affine plane, it is necessary to distinguish several cases. We wiU nevertheless discuss them, as they also provide a useful bridge between affine and projective geometry. E x a m p l e 2. C e n t r a l P r o j e c t i o n . We start by considering the three-dimensional projective space P^. Let H and B be different projective planes in P ^ , and let e be a point not incident with either plane. T h e central projection from B onto H with projection center e is the m a p : q : X e B I—> X = q{x) := {x\/ e) A H e
H.
In Section 1.3 we will give a more general definition of the central projection, which plays a very important part in projective geometry. Interpreting the definition projectively, it is easy to see t h a t q : B ^ H is a bijection mapping lines to lines; this is a direct consequence of the dimension formula.
1.1 Projective Spaces
7
Fig. 1.2. Central projection of parallel planes. From the affine point of view the situation turns out to be more varied. First we have to distinguish two cases. Case 1: The planes B and H are paraUel. In Figure 1.2, let the upper plane B = g\/ hbe the pre-image, and take the lower one as the image H = g\/ h. For the images of the lines g, h and points a,x oi B above we then have: q{g) = 9, q{h) = h, q{a V a;) = q{a) V q{x) = a\/ x. In this case, q is actually an affine map between the affine, not just the extended planes; it thus maps parallel lines to parallel lines. The projectively extended planes B, H intersect in their common line at infinity, /loo = B/\H, containing the fixed points of the central projection q. Case 2: The pre-image plane B = c y d y a and the image plane H = c\/ d\/ a are not parallel; they intersect in a line c\/ d = B A H formed by the fixed points of q, cf. Fig. 1.3. Let e\/u\/v be the plane parallel to H through the projection center e; it intersects B in the line u\/ v. For w e u\/ V the line w\/ e is parallel to H; hence it meets the line at infinity /loo C H" of the image plane in the sense of extension as described in the previous example. Moreover,
1 Projective Geometry
Fig. 1.3. Central projection of non-parallel planes.
q{uV v) = /looAll lines in the pre-image plane B incident with w, e.g. the lines a V d and by c, are mapped to parallel lines: q{aV d) = aV d, q{bV c) = bV c. Thus the pencil of hnes through w corresponds to the pencil of paraUel lines in the common, non-oriented direction of the image plane H determined by their images. On the other hand, the images of parallel lines from B intersect: q{a V c) A q{b V d) = {a V c) A {b V d) = i. Denote by boo the line at infinity of the pre-image plane B and by t the point of intersection on it determined by the parallel lines a\/ c and b\/ d. Then we have q{t) = t. Hence the line of intersection r V s of the image plane H with the plane parallel to the pre-image plane B through e is the image of the line at infinity of B: (/(boo) = r V s. These considerations imply t h a t q cannot be an afhne m a p , since it does not preserve parallelism. The situation just described is known in photography as the occurrence of plunging lines in pictures of high buildings taken with inclined camera. From the point of view of geometry, central projection
1.1 Projective Spaces
9
is the ideal model for photographing with a pinhole camera; unfortunately, the luminosity decreases with increasing precision of the reproduction. Central projections and their generalizations are a n a t u r a l point of departure for projective geometry as they m a p lines into lines and preserve incidence. • Exercise 2. Introduce a cartesian coordinate system adapted to the configuration shown in Fig. 1.3 and prove the statements in the previous example by computations based on the methods of affine geometry. For formal reasons it is often advisable to adjoin the nopoint to projective space. Therefore we define the disjoint union P : : = P " U { O } .
As a first application consider the canonical ^ : ? € F " + i ^x:=
(1)
map, [y] G P ^ ,
(2)
where [p] denotes the hnear huU [p] = £({j;}) in the vector space V. T h e m a p TV aUows to identify the elements H G ^{V) with the point sets TV{H) C P " ; this identification preserves the order. If not explicitly stated otherwise, we will always assume t h a t the nopoint o is included into each projective subspace of P " . Since the section of projective subspaces is also a projective subspace, setting MeViP:)^\JiM):=
/\
HenV)
(3)
M c H e ^(v) defines the projective above we obtain
hull of the subset M C P " . Using the identification
V(M)=^(£(^-i(M)))=
n
HeViP:).
M c H e ^(v) \ / ( M ) will also be called the projective
subspace spanned by M.
Exercise 3 . Prove that (3) defines a hull operator, i.e. that the following properties hold: a) M CV W; b) M C L implies \/{M) c\/{L);
c)
V(VW)=VW-
Prove, in addition, that: d) V(0) = o e \/{M) for all M C P ^ e) The equality \/{M) = M holds if and only if M is a projective subspace. Exercise 4 . Prove that a subset M C P" is a projective subspace if and only if, firstly, o E M and, secondly, with every x,y E M, x ^ y, the connecting line x V y also belongs to M.
10
1 Projective Geometry
Exercise 5. Let H" ^ C P" be a projective hyperplane. Prove that \/{P:\H"-')
= P:.
Now we will transfer the notion of linear independence to projective geometry. D e f i n i t i o n 2. Let (ajj^g/ be a family (or set) of points Xi_ G P " . (ajj^g/ is said t o be in general position if for each of its subsequences (or subsets) with k + 1 points, 0 < A; < n, D i m Xi,g\/ Xi,^\/
A sequence (or set) {XQ, xi,..., if Dim
. ..\/
x,^
= k.
Xr) of points is called projectively XQV
xi\/
independent
.. .\/ Xr = r.
a Exercise 6. Let Xi = [f^] e P". Prove: a) The sequence {xo,... ,Xk), k < n, is in general position if and only if the vectors (pQ,... ,p^) are linearly independent. - b) An arbitrary sequence {xi)i£i is in general position if and only if every subsequence of at most n + 1 points is projectively independent. - c) Each subsequence of a sequence in general position is itself in general position. (Similar statements to a), b), c) hold for sets.) C o r o l l a r y 2. In n-dimensional projective space there are n + I projectively independent points; every sequence or set with r > n + l points is projectively dependent. There is at least one set M containing n + 2 points in general position in P " . P r o o f . First, note t h a t the points {ai)i=o,...,n of V"+^ corresponding to any basis Oj = [Oj] are projectively independent. Then add the unit point e = [oo + ai + . . . + o„] to the set {ao, a i , . . . , a „ } of these so-caUed base points. Together, we obtain n + 2 points in general position. D E x a m p l e 3. P r o j e c t i v e L i n e s . Consider the projective line P over the skew field K. Let (oo, Oi) be a basis of the associated vector space V'^. T h e projective scale corresponding to (oo, fli) is defined as follows^:
C.x = [aox° + aixi] e P' - C{x) := ( -H-°)-^ € if (00
if x V 0,
(4)
if x^ = 0.
Obviously, this definition is independent of the chosen representatives; to both, p and pA, A ^ 0,, the same value is assigned. Setting K = K U {00} ^ As is common in tensor calculus, the upper indices label the coordinates of a vector, here 0, 1; they are not to be confused with powers.
1.1 Projective Spaces the m a p S, • P relation between The point ao = and e = [oo + fli] are obvious:
11
^ K becomes a bijection establishing a close and natural the properties of K and those of the projective geometry. [oo] is called the zero point, ai = [oi] the point at infinity, the unit point of the projective scale; the following relations e ( a o ) = 0 , e ( a i ) = o o , e(e) = l.
In the cases i f = R , C or H , a metric as well as a topology are defined on the scalar domain. Then there is a standard topology on K, t h a t of the socalled Alexandroff compactification, cf. W. Rinow [94], § 28: This is nothing but the usual topology of K to which the complements in K of all compact sets in K are added as the neighborhoods of oo. Considering t h e m as homeomorphisms the projective scales transfer the topologies defined on K onto the corresponding projective lines. T h e space obtained this way is completely different from the afRne and the Euclidean one: Topologically, the real projective line P j ^ is a circle S^, the complex one, PQ, is the Riemann sphere S"^, and the quaternionic projective line P ^ is homeomorphic to the four-dimensional sphere S"*. Later we will see t h a t the above topology does not depend on the chosen projective scale, i.e. the basis (oo, a i ) , cf. Exercise 2.4. D A first example for the duality in projective geometry, which will be treated in detail in Section 1.6 below, is the following proposition: P r o p o s i t i o n 3 . Let ^ " be a projective geometry over K. a) For each couple of points a;, y G P " , x ^ y, there h G Pn,i incident with both, the connecting line h = xV y. b) For each couple of hyperplanes X,Y G Pn,n-i, X unique (n — 2)-plane H G Pn,n-2 incident with both, the intersection H = X AY.
Then: is a unique
line
^ Y, there is a (n — 2)-plane of
P r o o f , a.) X y^ y implies xAy = o. Since D i m o = — 1, the dimension formula yields Dim a; V y = 1. If /ii is any line incident with x and y, then we have h = x\/ y C hi, and hence D i m / i = D i m / i i = 1 implies h = hi. b) From X y^ Y we conclude X\/Y = P " . Since D i m P " = n, the dimension formula yields D i m X AY = n — 2.1i Hi is any (n — 2)-plane incident with X and Y, then we have H = XAY D HI, and hence D i m H " = D i m i J i = n—2, i.e.H = Hi. D 1.1.2 P l a n e P r o j e c t i v e G e o m e t r y E x a m p l e 4. P l a n e I n c i d e n c e G e o m e t r y . For n = 2 Proposition 3 and CoroUary 2 comprise the foUowing statements: P . l . Any two different points are incident with exactly one line. P.2. Any two different lines are incident with exactly one point. P.3. There are four points no three of which lie on the same line.
12
1 Projective Geometry
These three statements may serve as axioms for a synthetic projective plane incidence geometry 11. Such a geometry has two basic sets: points x G P and Unes X G G, together with a single relation, the incidence L. Points and lines may be incident, x LX, or they may not be incident, xlY. T h e properties of this relations are described by the axioms P. 1-3. However, these axioms do not suffice to guarantee the existence of a skew field K whose plane projective geometry is isomorphic to the one determined by the axioms. The existence of such a scalar domain can be achieved by additional axioms. In this context, interesting interrelations between more general scalar domains and syntheticgeometric properties of the projective planes arise, cf. G. Pickert [87]. For more recent developments concerning this subject we refer to the survey article [69] by L. Kramer, where in particular the case of non-commutative scalar domains is stressed. A very vivid presentation of the real plane projective geometry based on a synthetic system of axioms goes back to H. S. M. Coxeter [34]. T h e multifaceted textbook [12] by A. Beutelspacher and U. Rosenbaum treats the synthetic as well as the analytic foundations of projective geometry. T h e books [106] by O. Veblen and J. W. Young contain a synthetic presentation of higher-dimensional projective geometry. Note however, t h a t the axioms necessary to describe incidence in three-dimensional space restrict the scalar field decisively stronger t h a n in the case of planar incidence geometry. D
0,0,1
1,0,1
1,0,0
0,1,1
1,1,0
0,1,0
Fig. 1.4. The projective plane over Z2.
Exercise 7. Prove that in every plane projective incidence geometry U satisfying the axioms P.1-3 there are four lines no three of which meet in a point. Hint: First prove that on the lines A e G connecting the points in a configuration as in axiom P.3 there are at least three different points.
1.1 Projective Spaces
13
Exercise 8. Consider a projective geometry ^ ^ over a field K. Prove: a) If there exists a line h e ^ ^ containing exactly p + 1 points, p any prime, then K = Zp, the field of cosets mod p. - b) The projective geometry ^ Z j consists of exactly seven points and seven lines with the incidence relation described by Fig. 1.4. The circle together with the six segments represent the seven lines. This geometry is also known as the Fano plane . - c) In ^ z ^ there are exactly 2"+^ — 1 points. D e f i n i t i o n 3. A set of points M G P " is called coUinear, if there is a line h G Pn,i such t h a t M C /i. A set 9}t C ^ " is called concentric, if there is a point 2 G P " such t h a t ztA for aU A eTl. •
Fig. 1.5. Desargues' Theorem.
T h e proposition stated in the next exercise goes back to Desargues and is particularly interesting for the plane projective geometry, since it does not follow from the Axioms P. 1-3 of plane incidence geometry; incidence planes satisfying it are called Desarguesian planes. It can be shown t h a t Desargues' Property is equivalent to the associativity of the scalar domain, cf. G. Pickert [87]. In the incidence geometry of three-dimensional space Desargues' Theorem already follows from the other incidence axioms, cf. L. Heffter [48], Section A.5. Hence there are no projective spaces of dimension n > 2 with a nonassociative scalar domain. The projective plane over the octonions is perhaps the most important example for a plane not having Desargues' Property, cf. H. Freudenthal [39] or H. Salzmann et al. [97]. In the geometries based on skew fields as they are discussed here the following proposition holds in all dimensions n > 2. Exercise 9 (Desargues' T h e o r e m ) . Let ^ ^ be a projective geometry over a skew field K, n > 2. Consider six different points ai,bi e P", i = 1,2,3, whose
14
1 Projective Geometry
connecting lines hi := at V bi, i = 1, 2, 3, are concentric. Prove that "corresponding sides" intersect in points, i.e. ci = (a2 V as) A (62 V63), C2 = (ai Vaa) A (61 V63), C3 = (ai Va2) A (61 V62), and that, moreover, these points are coUinear, cf. Fig. 1.5. For the proof of Pappos' Theorem, which does not fohow from the incidence axioms P. 1-3 as well, the commutativity of the scalar field is essential (cf. Exercise 2.10):
Ol
02
as
Fig. 1.6. Pappos' Theorem.
Exercise 10 (Pappos' Theorem). Let -P^ be a projective plane over a field K. Let A, B he two lines intersecting in the point z = A A B. Consider three points, different from one another and from z, on each of the lines A, B, ai G A, 6i e B, i = 1, 2, 3,, cf. Fig. 1.6. Prove that under these conditions the points c i = (02 V 6 3 ) A (03 V 6 2 ) , C2 = ( a i V 6 3 ) A (03 V 6 1 ) , C3 = ( a i V 6 2 ) A (02 V61)
are collinear. T h e finite geometries some examples of which we have been mentioning here are studied systematically in the monographs [10], [11] by A. Beutelspacher. For more recent developments we in addition refer to L. M. Batten,
1.2 Homogeneous Coordinates
15
A. Beutelspacher [6], K. Metsch [76], and J. W. P. Hirschfeld [54]. T h e latter also contains an extensive bibliography. Finite geometries are applied to numerous kinds of problems and subjects, among others in the field of combinatorics.
1.2 Homogeneous Coordinates Let K be an arbitrary skew field. Then KP" (and KP", respectively) denotes the projective space associated with the right vector space 7^"+^ of ( n + l)-tuples: KP" := P{K"+^). The elements of i f P " are called homogeneous (n + I)-tuples; they are the orbits of the multiplicative group K* of K for the right action ((x*). A) G i f " + ^ X if* I—> ( x U ) G i f " + \
(1)
where in the case of KP" the zero tuple is excluded. Just as the vector space if™ of m-tuples from K serves as the standard coordinate space for all the m-dimensional vector spaces over K, the space KP" will now be used as the coordinate space for any n-dimensional projective space over K. Using homogeneous ( n + l)-tuples, i.e. admitting a superfiuous degree of freedom in the form of an arbitrary factor A, allows to work with just a single coordinate system for the whole projective space. Moreover, it turns out to be possible to describe projective coordinate transformations in a way similar to the familiar representation of the transformations of vector coordinates, i.e. by means of matrix calculus. 1.2.1 D e f i n i t i o n . S i m p l i c e s Now we consider an arbitrary ( n + l ) - d i m e n s i o n a l right vector space V over K and the associated projective space P " = P{V). Let (Oj) be a basis of V, and let (Cj) be the standard basis of i f " + ^ , i = 0 , . . . , n . Linearly extending the relations f{ai) = Cj, i = 0,... ,n, defines a hnear isomorphism ip : i f " + ^ -^ V of vector spaces, which in t u r n determines vector coordinates on V. Denoting by TT both the respective canonical maps the linearity of cp immediately implies ^ ( ^ ( y ) ) = TTMT))
(T G V),
(2)
i.e., the m a p if : P " -^ KP" does not depend on the chosen representative p G n^^{x). (f is called the homogeneous coordinate system determined by (Oj) on the projective space P " ; correspondingly, the x* defined by ^(a;) = {x^)K* are called the homogeneous coordinates of x with respect to (p. They are determined only up to a common factor A G K*. T h e points Oj := 7r(0i) are called the base points, and e := '^{YIH^QO^I) is the unit point of the homogeneous coordinate system. T h e j - t h base point has homogeneous coordinates ((5*)if *, where (5* is the Kronecker symbol:
16
1 Projective Geometry
i
Jo
d„- = < . J [1
fori 7^ j ,
„ . , ior I = J,
. ,
«, 7 = 0, . . . , n . '•' ' '
The coordinates of the unit point are ah equal ( 1 , . . . , 1)7^*. Obviously, the sequence ( a o , . . . , a „ ; e) formed by the base points and the unit point of a homogeneous coordinate system is in general position, cf. Exercise 1.6. Hence any family of A; + 1 base points of a coordinate system spans a coordinate k-plane: In general, two projective subspaces A, B are called complementary, if A A B = o and A v B = P " . For every coordinate A;-plane Hi^,,,i^ there is exactly one complementary coordinate plane, namely Hj-^,,,j^, where {ji,... ,ji} is the complement of {io,..., ik} in the set { 0 , . . . , n } ; its dimension is n — A; — 1. Exercise 1. Let A,B C P" be complementary subspaces. Prove: a) For every point z e P" \{AU B) there is exactly one line H such that zeH,HnA^o and i f n B / o. - b) Setting p:
X e P" I—> {xW B) AAe
A
defines a surjective map p : P" -^ A; the equality p{x) = o holds if and only if a: e -B. - c) The map p satisfies f/ = p. T h e following example illustrates the situation: E x a m p l e 1. S i m p l i c e s . A projectively independent sequence of A;+ 1 points (6o, • • •, bk) is called a k-dimensional simplex, k-simplex for short. T h e points themselves are the vertices, and the subsequences form the faces of the simplex. Frequently we will also use the t e r m face of the simplex to denote the whole projective subspace spanned by the face of the simplex as well. Onedimensional faces will also be called edges. For each vertex bj of a A;-simplex the {k — l)-face not containing bj is called its opposite face Bj. The base points of a homogeneous coordinate system for P " form the coordinate simplex. Denoting by Bj the opposite face of aj the points in the hyperplane spanned by Bj are characterized by the equation x^ = 0. The j-th projection Pj of a point x onto the face Bj (from the point aj) is defined by Pj : a; G P " I—> Xj := Bj A {aj V x) e Bj,
(3)
thus Pj{aj) = o. T h e unit point in the face Bj is the image of the unit point under the corresponding projection, Cj :=pj{e). Fig. 1.7 illustrates the situation for the plane. Take the face BQ as the line at infinity, cf. Example 1.1. Its complement, the affine plane A := P \ BQ, is characterized by x^ y^ 0. T h e homogeneous coordinates there can be normalized so t h a t x^ = 1 holds. T h e coordinates x^,x^ of the triples normalized in this way then become the cartesian coordinates of the point x e A^. They can also be computed as the scale values of the projections of x onto the axes of the
1.2 Homogeneous Coordinates
17
scales chosen as described in Example 1.3. The point OQ will be called the origin of the cartesian coordinate system. Note that the projections from aj onto the axes Bj, j = 1,2, appear as parallel projections in the afhne picture. The quadrangle (00,61,6,62) thus becomes the unit parallelogram. In the n-dimensional case the situation is quite similar. D
Fig. 1.7. Coordinate triangle in P^ The following proposition justifies the definition of homogeneous coordinates: Proposition 1. The map (p : P " -^ KP^ uniquely defined by (2) is a bijection. If {o-i) is a basis ofV determining the homogeneous coordinate system 'ip, then for n > I the maps (p and -0 coincide if and only if there exists an element jj, in the center Z{K*) of the group K* such that Oj = OjyU,, « = 0 , . . . , n. P r o o f . The bijectivity of ^5 is a direct consequence of the bijectivity of 95. Now suppose (f = tp. Then for the base points we have ^^-^([Cj]) = -(/'^"^([Cj]) = Oj, hence Oj = OjAj for certain Aj G K*. For the unit point we similarly obtain
6 = [oo + ... + a„] = [oo + ... + o„], thus
n
n
n
i=0
i=0
i=0
18
1 Projective Geometry
This implies Xi = JJ, for i = 0,... ,n. All we have to show now is yU, G Z{K*). Starting^ from p = OjX* = OjX* = (Oi/i)x* for all a; = [p] G P " we obtain (p{x) = {x^)K* = i}{x) = (x*)if*and (x*) = (/xx*). Hence {iix'^)K* = {x^)K* holds for aU (x*) G 7^"+^ Consequently, there has t o be a m a p T : i f " + ^ \ { ( 0 , . . . , 0)} ^ i f * with the property {jix') = {X')T{X').
(4)
For linearly independent (a*), (6*) this leads to the foUowing: {li{a' + 6*)) = (a* + 6*)T(a* + V) = {a')T{a' + 6*) + {V)T{a' + 6*), = (^a*) + (M6') = (a*)r(a*) + (6*)r(6*); since n > 1 we thus obtain the equality T{a^) = T(CO) for aU (a*) ^ [co]. Again as n > 1 we also have (a*) = CQS for (a*) G [co], s 7^ 0, and, similarly, T(COS) = T(CI) = T(CO). Hence T(X*) = T G i f * is constant, and for (x*) = Cot, t G K*, (4) immediately implies: 1.) /x = T — just take t = 1, and 2.) /it = t/x for all t G if*. But this just means ^ G Z{K*). The converse is trivial. • Remark: In the case of a one-dimensional vector space (n = 0), in general, maps of the form r(x°) = (x°)-Va;° are not constant solutions of (4). P r o p o s i t i o n 2. The sequence ( a o , . . . , a „ ; e) formed by the base points and the unit point of a homogeneous coordinate system is in general position. Conversely, for every sequence ( a o , . . . , a „ ; e) of n + 2 points in general position there is a system of homogeneous coordinates (p such that ai is its i-th base point and e its unit point. Two coordinate systems (x*)if*, (x*)if* with equal sequences ( a o , . . . , a „ ; e) of base and unit points are related by a left dilation: (x*)if * = (jj,x^)K*; consequently, for JJ, G Z{K*) or in the case of a field they coincide. P r o o f . T h e definitions for the base points and the unit point of a homogeneous coordinate system immediately imply t h a t any n + 1 vectors representing these points are linearly independent. Hence, according to Exercise 1.1.6, they are in general position. Conversely, let ( a o , . . . , a „ ; e) be a sequence of points in general position. Then any vectors Oj representing the ai are linearly independent. Choose a sequence of representatives (Oj,« = 0 , . . . , n ) , aj = [Oj]. For simplicity we will use the sum convention of tensor calculus from now on: If an index occurs twice in an expression, as a lower as well as an upper index, then this has to be interpreted as a sum over this index for its complete domain of definition (in the present formula from 0 to n). To indicate that for a particular formula the sum convention is not in action we will use the notation ^ .
1.2 Homogeneous Coordinates
19
These vectors then form a basis of V . Let e be a vector with e = [e] and write it as e =
y^^ajr/i i=0
Since the sequence ( a o , . . . , a„; e) is in general position, r/i y^ 0 for ah i. Hence, setting bj := ttiiji yields a sequence of vectors (bo,..., b„; e) also representing the chosen sequence of points. The definition of the bj implies that they form a basis, and, moreover, that e is the unit point of the corresponding homogeneous coordinate system. An arbitrary basis with base points Oj necessarily has the form (bj) with bj = bjAj. If e is to be the unit point for this basis as well, then e = [J2 bj] = [J2 ^i] = [J2 ^iW has to hold. Hence, Xi = /J, e K* for « = 0 , . . . , n. This implies yux* = x* for the corresponding coordinates. The final statement follows from Proposition 1. D The close relation between sequences of n + 2 points in general position and homogeneous coordinate systems stated in Proposition 2 suggests to call such a sequence ( a o , . . . , a„; e) a projective frame. Thus, every homogeneous coordinate system uniquely determines a projective frame. Obviously, the following holds. Corollary 3. If K is a field, then for each projective frame there is a unique homogeneous coordinate system corresponding to it (and vice versa). • In the case of a skew field this relation is not bijective, in general. Let us just look at the projective line: The bases (oo, fli), (floMi 1IM) determine one and the same projective frame, whereas the corresponding homogeneous coordinates are related by an inner automorphism: The equalities p = OjX* = Oiyux* = OjX* imply {x')K* = {jix^)K* = {a^{x'))K*, where Un '. t E K i-^ fjctfji^^ G K denotes the inner automorphism of K associated with fi G K*. Additionally, for later use we point out the following. Corollary 4. Let P he a projective line. Then for each projective scale of P there is a uniquely determined projective frame (ao,ai;e) (cf. Example 1.3). The set of all scale values for x, {^(a;)}, forms a conjugacy class in K. Here ^ runs through all projective scales with the same projective frame (ao,ai;e). D To prove this, note that, by its very definition (1.1.4), the projective scale is the ratio of both homogeneous coordinates.
20
1 Projective Geometry
1.2.2 C o o r d i n a t e T r a n s f o r m a t i o n s . T h e P r o j e c t i v e Linear G r o u p Now we t u r n to the transformations of homogeneous coordinates. Denote by GL{n + 1, K) the hnear group of order^ n + 1 over the skew field K, cf. § II.7.4. As is weU-known, this group acts as a matrix group from the left on the vector space 7^"+^: ((af), {x')) e GL{n +l,K)x
K"+^ ^
(af )(x*) G K"+\
t,j =
Q,...,n.
Consider the homogeneous coordinate systems (p, 'ip determined by the bases (Oj) and (Oj), respectively. For the corresponding coordinates (x*), (x^) of any point X G P " we then have the following relations: X = [OjX*] = [OjX^] = [Oj-afx*]. Here (a^) denotes the transformation matrix for the vector coordinates. Hence, i^ix) = {x^)K* = {ai){x')K*
= (aiMx).
(5)
T h e situation is thus the same as in the case of a transformation of vector coordinates: The group GL{n + 1,K) acts from the left on the set (p of homogeneous coordinate systems, cf. § 1.5.7. L e m m a 5. The action of GL(n+l, K) on
A
(6)
P r o o f . T h e transitivity immediately follows from the transitivity of the action of GL{n + l,K) on the set of all bases. By Proposition 1 we have {al)(f = (p \i and only if there exists a yU, G Z{K*) with the property (6). This obviously holds for aU ^5 G ^ , if it is true for any single one. • D e f i n i t i o n 1. Let i f be a skew field, and denote by Z{n + 1) the subgroup Z{n+l):={{5i)ii\iieZ{K*),i,j=Q,...,n}.
(7)
T h e quotient group PGL{n is called the projective following exercise.
+ 1, K) := GL{n
+ 1, K)/Z{n
+ 1),
linear group of order n + 1 over K. Note also the
Exercise 2. By Lemma 5 the center Z{n + 1) is the kernel of the action under consideration (cf. Definition 1.1.4.2) and hence a normal subgroup. The action of PGL(n + 1) on $ defined via representatives is thus simply transitive, cf. § 1.1.4. Prove that Z(n + 1) is the center of the group GL(n + 1, K) (cf. Example 1.1.4.7). This notion is not to be confused with that of the order of a finite group.
1.2 Homogeneous Coordinates
21
1.2.3 Inhomogeneous Projective Coordinates In this section we will consider the inhomogeneous coordinates associated with a homogeneous coordinate system (p{x) =
{x\x))K*
and calculate their transformation rule. The i-th coordinate hyperplane Bi is defined as the coordinate hyperplane complementary to the base point Oj. Let Ui = P " \ Bi be its complement in P " , cf. Example 1: Ui =
{xeP'''\x'{x)^0}.
Obviously, the i-th chart cpi on Ui, is correctly defined: xeUi^
y^i,j=0,...,n)eK".
(8)
For brevity we set ef (a;) := x^{x){x\x))-^
for x e Ui
and prove the following. Lemma 6. a) Each homogeneous coordinate system (p on the projective space P " determines n + 1 charts, cpi : Ui ^ K", defined by (8), that are bijective maps. b) The domains of definition of these charts cover the projective space, i.e. c) Let, as above, 'ip denote the homogeneous coordinate system associated with the basis (oj), let (a^) be the matrix of the coordinate transformation, and let ''Pi = (Ci) be the charts 'ipi : Vi ^ K" determined by 'ip. Then the coordinate transformations
V-b o ^ - 1 : if^iUa n Vb) —> MUa n 14) defined on the intersections of coordinate neighborhoods, UaC\Vi,, are fractional linear transformations; moreover, it{^)
= a';il{x){a\Ca{x))-'.
(9)
P r o o f . Note that in this formula, according to the sum convention, the sum in the numerator runs over j and that in the denominator over i. Moreover, Q = 1, ^. For arbitrary (y^,...,y") G if" the point x with homogeneous coordinates x°{x) = y\ x\x) = y ^ . . . , x'-\x) = y\ x\x) = 1, x'+\x) = y'+\ . .., x"(a;) = y" is the only point in Ui mapped to (y^,..., y"). This proves a). Since for every point X G P " at least one among its homogeneous coordinates does not vanish, b) holds. The remaining statement c) immediately follows from the transformation rule (5) and the definition of inhomogeneous coordinates. •
22
1 Projective Geometry
E x a m p l e 2. T h e P r o j e c t i v e L i n e . For n = 1 there are two inhomogeneous coordinates essentially coinciding with the corresponding projective scales. For example, the value ^{ai) is not yet defined by ^ := Co- Setting, as seems obvious, ^{ai) := oo yields the projective scale defined in Example 1.3. In this case, formula (9) describes the transformation of projective scales on P ^ , 6A'- K ^ K, entailed by a change of bases in V"^: OA--i^i--={ai
+ h){ci + d)-^ with A = ( ^ J J eGL{2,K).
(10)
To complete t h e picture, we extend 9A in the following way:
^^(_c-id) = oo, ^A(OO) = ('*'^"'' IJ'^^J'' [ oo,
(11)
it c = U. D
Exercise 3 . In the notation of Lemma 6, let (p, ip be homogeneous coordinate systems on P" satisfying the additional condition Uo = VQ. Prove that the coordinate transformation i/>o o ipg-^ is an affine transformation in K", cf. I, (5.7.36). Exercise 4 . Prove that the map of K to itself defined by (10), (11) is a bijection and satisfies the equality (OA)^^ = ^ A - I - (Note that, in general, A" is a skew field and hence determinants cannot be used.) Denote by S{K) the group of all bijective maps on K. Prove that the map F : Ae
GL{2, K) ^ 9A e S{K)
is a homomorphism whose image is isomorphic to PGL(2,K). Show that for K = R, C , H every 9A is a homeomorphism with respect to the topology on K described in Example 1.3. Exercise 5. A projective plane P is said to have Pappos' Property if Pappos' Theorem holds in it, cf. Exercise 1.10, i.e., if the points ci, C2, cs in a configuration as depicted in Figure 1.6 are always collinear. Prove that P^ has the Pappos' Property if and only if the skew field on which it is based is commutative, i.e., it is a field. — Hint. Choose homogeneous coordinates in a way that (z, as, 63; C2) are the base points and the unit point of the coordinate system, respectively, and express then the condition in these coordinates. 1.2.4 T h e P r o j e c t i v e Linear G r o u p over a F i e l d E x a m p l e 3. Let K he a field. T h e n we have Z{K*) = K* = Z{n + 1). Consider t h e canonical homomorphism resulting from Definition 1, p : ( 4 ) G GL{n
+ 1, if) ^ ^ (a})if * G PGL{n
+ 1, K).
The matrices from GL{n + 1, K) contained in the same coset of the factor group PGL{n+l, K) = GL{n+l, K)/Z{n+l) only differ in a factor fie K*.
1.2 Homogeneous Coordinates
23
Now choose a "fixed" projective frame R in the projective space P " over K and, in addition, a variable "moving" projective frame R; let (x*) and (x*) be the homogeneous coordinates associated with R and R, respectively, defined by the bases (Oj) and (Oj) of V. According to Proposition 1, these bases are determined by the homogeneous coordinates only up to a common factor /i G K*. Hence the cosets of GL{n + 1, K) by Z{n + 1), i.e. the elements of PGL{n + l,K), correspond bijectively to the projective frames. Thus, the set of these frames is a geometric reahzation of the group PGL{n + l,K), just hke the set of linear frames, (Oj), is a geometric realization of the group
GL{n + l,K). Now we will try to find a distinguished representative in each coset of GL{n + Ijif) by Z{n + 1) in a natural way. To this aim, we consider the determinant as a function of yU. Looking at the well-known formula det(A/i) = det(A)/i"+^, the obvious condition to impose on a distinguished representative should be Aet{An) = 1 for A = (a|) G GL{n + 1, K) and n e K*
(12)
Hence the intended choice amounts to deciding the solvability of M"+I = (det(A))-i, and, apart from n, this again essentially depends on the algebraic properties of the field K. Let now if = R. If n is even, for given A the equation (12) has exactly one real solution /x. Hence, each coset contains a unique representative with determinant one, and we arrive at the isomorphism PGL{n + 1, R) = SL{n + 1, R) (n even).
(13)
Hence, in this case, the projective linear group is isomorphic to the special linear group, SL{n + 1, R) := {A G GL{n + 1, R) | det(A) = 1}.
(14)
The situation is different in the odd-dimensional case: Now the sign of det(A) is constant on every coset, and this allows to introduce an orientation: Two projective frames, or the homogeneous coordinate systems associated with them, respectively, are called equally oriented if the coordinate transformation A transferring one into the other has positive determinant, i.e. sign(det(A)) = 1. Apparently, there are two classes of equaUy oriented homogeneous coordinate systems (cf. the foUowing exercise); a real projective space of odd dimension is caUed oriented if one of these classes is distinguished. This orientation, introduced within the framework of linear algebra, is in complete accordance with the topological notion of orientation, cf. Appendix 4.2. It can be shown that a real projective space, considered as a differentiable manifold, is orientable if and only if its dimension is odd [103], Exercise 1.4.2. D
24
1 Projective Geometry
Exercise 6. a) Prove that the relation "equally oriented", introduced in the preceding example, is an equivalence relation, and that there are precisely two equivalence classes for odd n. - b) Use the definition \SL\{N,IC):={AeGL{N,IC)\
|det(A)| = l }
(15)
to prove the isomorphy PGL{n
+ l,IC}-^\SL\{n+l,IC}/{±1}
(n odd),
(16)
where / denotes the unit matrix. Exercise 7. In this exercise we consider the action of the group GLiV"^^) of linear automorphisms of the right vector space T^"+^ over the skew field K. Prove: a) Setting (ff,x) e G L ( F " + i ) xP"^gx
:= [ff(y)] e P" for x = [y]
(17)
defines a transitive action; its kernel is isomorphic to the center Z{K*) of K*. - b) If -R" is a field, then the restriction of this action to the special linear group SL{V"+')
:= {g e GL{V"+')\N{g)
= 1}
(18)
is transitive; here N{g) denotes the norm of the linear automorphism g, which is equal to the determinant of the matrix for g with respect to an arbitrary basis of T^"+^. - c) Let (C) be the inhomogeneous coordinates of a: e P", and let (??^), i,j = 1 , . . . , n, be the inhomogeneous coordinates of the image point y = gx under a linear automorphism g e GLiV"^^). Prove that these coordinates are related by a fractional linear transformation of the following form: r?^' = {a' + S^;alC){b + S^;bie)-\
(19)
Here the coefficients a-',al,b,bi are the entries of the matrix for g with respect to the basis for T^"+^ determining both the homogeneous and the corresponding inhomogeneous coordinates, which again depends on the charts chosen so that X e Uk,y e Ui.
1.3 Collineations Collineations are the isomorphisms of projective geometry; sometimes they are even introduced t h a t way, cf. Exercise 5 below. Here we will start with a much weaker definition: a m a p from one projective point space to another is coUinear if it commutes with the operation of joining points. If, in addition, it is bijective, then we will call it a collineation: A bijective m a p transferring lines into lines. This property even implies t h a t a collineation maps projective A;-planes onto projective A;-planes. Since the projective A;-planes are embedded into the subsets lattice of the projective point spaces P " via the canonical m a p TT, each collineation generates an isomorphism of the lattices called projective geometries, and vice versa. The essential result here is the Main Theorem of
1.3 CoUineations
25
Projective Geometry describing the collineations algebraically in dimensions n > 2. One consequence of this is that geometric isomorphy implies algebraic isomorphy: Just the existence of a colhneation / : P{V) i-^ Q{W), where V, W are finite-dimensional vector spaces of dimensions larger than two, suffices to conclude that the scalar domains of the vector spaces are isomorphic, and, moreover, that the spaces have equal dimensions. Note that the isomorphy of the scalar domains for the vector spaces is not a precondition, but a conclusion of the Main Theorem. In Subsection 3 this will lead to complete descriptions of the group of auto-coUineations for the projective point space P " and of the group of automorphisms of the projective geometry ^{V), 2 < d i m F < oo. 1.3.1 CoUinear Maps In this section we consider maps / : P " -^ Q™ preserving the geometric operation of join, i.e. satisfying f{A y B) = f{A) V f{B) for all projective subspaces A,B a P". It suffices to require this property for the join of points (cf. Corollary 5). We define: Definition 1. Let P", Q™ be projective spaces over the respective (possibly different) skew fields Ki and K2 • A map / : P " -^ Q™ is called coUinear if it satisfies the following two conditions: f(o) = o, fix V y) = fix) V / ( y ) for all x,y e P^. A bijective coUinear map is called a coUineation.
(1) (2) •
Any bijective map / : P " -^ Q™ transferring lines into hues can always be considered as a colhneation by setting /(o) := o. Conversely, because of (2), each colhneation maps lines into lines. If the dimension of the image is less than two, D i m / ( P " ) < 2, then, obviously, the definition has not much substance; e.g., every bijective map between projective lines satisfying (1) is a colhneation. For this reason, the one-dimensional case will be treated separately in the following section. The colhnear maps with D i m / ( P " ) > 2 can be represented as the superposition of a colhneation with a (general) central projection to be introduced in the following example. Example 1. General central projections. Let Q™ C P", 0 < TO < n, be a projective subspace, and let B C P " a complementary subspace to Q™. The central projection p from P " onto Q™ with center B is defined to be the map pix):=ixVB)AQ:^, xeP:. (3) In case x ^ B Proposition 1.1 immediately implies
26
1 Projective Geometry Dim(a; \/ B) = Dim x + Dim B + 1 = Dim B + 1 = n - m
as well as Dim((a; V B) A Q™) = 0, so that (3) indeed uniquely determines a point of <5™. Obviously, p-\o) = B. (4) Let W := 7r^^(<5™) and t/ := TV^^{B) be the corresponding vector subspaces. Since Q™ and B are complementary, we have V"+^ = W®U,dimW
= m+l,dimU
= n-m.
(5)
Denoting by pr : V ^ W the projection of vectors determined by the decomposition (5) it can easily be checked that the foUowing equation holds for all ? € V: p{[f]) = br(p)]. (6) This or Definition (3) itself can be used for a straightforward proof that p is a coUinear map satisfying p op = p. If the center B is a point, we obtain the central projection discussed in Example 1.2. For a coordinate m-plane Q™, e.g. <5™ = ao V . . . V a„t, and its complementary coordinate [n — m— l)-plane B = Om+iV.. .Va„ the projectionpr occurring in (6) is just the corresponding vector coordinate projection: pr:i
= aix'e
F"+^ ^ pr{i) = o^x" G VF™+^
Here W™^^ denotes the vector subspace spanned by the m + 1 basis vectors Oa, a = 0 , . . . , m,« = 0 , . . . , n, and the sum convention is in action. Restricting the coordinate functions (x"(x)), a = 0 , . . . , m, to the coordinate m-plane Q™ yields a homogeneous coordinate system for this projective subspace with the base points OQ, whose unit point CQ is the image under the projection of the unit point e for the coordinate system in P " we started from: eg
: p{e) = (e V a™+i V . . . V a„) A (OQ V . . . V a^) = [oo + • • • + a™]. (7)
Definition 2. Consider again the situation from Definition 1. Denote by V and W the vector spaces associated with the projective spaces P " and Q™, respectively. Let, moreover, a : V ^ W and a : Kf ^ K2 be maps such that a(o) = 0 and a(pa) = a(p)o-(a) (p G F , a G if*). (8) Setting x=[^]eP:^
fix)
:= [a(y)] G Q ^
(9)
correctly defines a map / : P " ^ Q™: the map induced by a. If there exists a map
1.3 CoUineations
27
E x a m p l e 2. S e m i - L i n e a r l y I n d u c e d M a p s . The m a p a : V ^^ W considered in Definition 2 is called semi-linear if there is an isomorphism of skew fields, a : Ki ^ K2, such t h a t a(pa + t)/3) = a(p)o-(a) + a(t))o-(/3)
(p, t) G F , a, /3 G i f i ) .
For brevity, semi-linear maps with the isomorphism a will often be called
G K.
(10)
(p G W, a G Ki).
This construction is called replacement of scalars; in Example II.7.1.4 it is defined in greater generality. Obviously, the subspaces of W are nothing but those of W, and the dimension of a subspace is not changed by replacing the scalars. Moreover, the relation a(pa) = a(p)o-(a) = a(p)a
(p G V , a G i f i ) ,
implies t h a t , now, i.e. considered as a m a p from V to W, a is even linear. Hence images as well as pre-images of subspaces under a are again subspaces. In particular, the kernel of a, K e r a := a^^(o) C V, and the image of a, I m a := a{V) C W are well-defined subspaces. As for hnear maps we define the rank of a by r k a := d i m ^ j I m a . For a finite-dimensional vector space V we then have the same relation as in the case of linear maps: d i m ^ i K e r a + r k a = d i m ^ i V^ = « + 1 < 00.
(11)
28
1 Projective Geometry
Now we will prove t h a t the m a p / between the associated projective spaces defined, according to (9), by a semi-linear m a p a is coUinear; relation (6) then shows t h a t , in particular, this holds for a central projection p . P r o p o s i t i o n 1. Let a : V -^ vt^™+ ftg a-linear. f : P " -^ <5™ defined by (9) is coUinear, and, moreover,
Then
Dim/-i(o)+Dim/(P^) = n - l .
the
map
(12)
P r o o f . Since a is semi-linear, we have a(o) = o implying (1). Now take any 33 = [?], y = [t)] € -P"• Then a; V y = 7r([{p, t)}]) is determined by the linear hull, and this implies (2): fix
V y) = ^(a([{y, t)}])) = ^([{a(y), a(t))}]) = fix)
V /(y),
where a([{p, t)}]) = [{«(?), a(t))}] follows from the semi-finearity of a. Hence / is coUinear. T h e dimension formula (12) is a direct consequence of (11). • As a straightforward consequence of Definition 1 we note the following. P r o p o s i t i o n 2. The inverse f^^ of a coUineation f again is a collineation. If f and g are coUinear, then their composition f o g is also coUinear. The class of projective spaces over arbitrary skew fields with the coUinear maps as morphisms form a category. • E x a m p l e 3 . T h e constant maps on P " , i.e. the maps / : P " -^ Q^ with / ( o ) := o and fix) := yg = const for x ^ o, are always colfinear. If yg ^ o, then D i m / ^ ^ ( o ) = —1. In this case, (12) is satisfied if and only if n = 0; this is the only situation where / is induced by a semi-linear m a p (Proposition 1). In case yg = o the m a p / is obviously induced by the zero m a p . Moreover, an arbitrary bijection of projective fines, / : P\ -^ QI, such t h a t / ( o ) = o, is a collineation which, in general, is also not induced by a semi-linear m a p . • Exercise 1. Find an example for a collineation / : Pi -^ Ql of projective lines over non-isomorphic fields. Next we want to deduce some properties of colfinear maps. Definition 1 and Exercise 1.4 immediately imply the following. L e m m a 3 . Let f : P " -^ Q™ be coUinear, and let A C P " , B C Q™ be projective subspaces. Then / ( A ) and f^^iB) are also projective subspaces; so, in particular, / ^ ^ ( o ) and fiP^) are projective subspaces. • L e m m a 4. Let f : P " -^ Q™ be coUinear. Then for all k G Ng and any XieP: fixo \/ ...\/Xk) = fixo) V . . . V fixk). (13)
1.3 CoUineations
29
P r o o f . T h e prove will proceed by induction. For A; = 0 , 1 the statement is trivial or holds by assumption, respectively. Assume t h a t (13) is already proved for k. If Xk+i G H^ := a;o V . . . V Xk, then (13) obviously also holds for {xo,..., Xk+i}. Suppose t h a t Xk+i ^ H^, set M^^^ := XQV .. .V Xk+i = H^ V Xk+i, and take z G M^^^. Then we wiU have to prove the following relation: fiz) G fixo) V . . . V fixk+i) = f{H') V f{xk+i). We may assume z ^ Xk+i as weU as ^ ^ H^, since otherwise the claim holds by the induction hypothesis. As H^ C M^'^ is a hyperplane, the line Xk+iVz intersects it in precisely one point, y = {xk+i V 2) A H^. Since / is coUinear, z e y\/ Xk+i imphes fiz)
G / ( y V Xk+i) = f{y) V f{xk+i)
C f{H') V /(a^^+i),
hence f{xo V . . . V Xk+i) C f{xo) V . . . V / ( a ; fc4 - 1
•
On the other hand, M^'^ is a projective subspace of P " , and, by Lemma 3, so is / ( M ' ' + i ) C g ™ . Since f{xi) e / ( M ' ' + i ) , i = 0 , . . . , A; + 1, t h e statement follows from t h e definition of the join as the smallest of all subspaces containing the one considered. • C o r o l l a r y 5. Let f : P " -^ Q™ be coUinear. Then for any two projective subspaces A, B C P " the restriction, f\A : A -^ Q™, is also coUinear, and D i m / ( A ) < Dim A . Moreover, f{A\/B) = f{A)\/f{B).
(14)
P r o o f . Both claims follow from (13) by considering A , B as generated by projectively independent points. • T h e following proposition characterizes injective coUinear maps: P r o p o s i t i o n 6. Let f : P " -^ Q™ be coUinear. Then the foUowing ments are equivalent: a) / is injective; b) D i m / ( P : ) = n ; c) D i m / ( A ) = Dim A for every projective subspace A.
state-
P r o o f , a) imphes b): Suppose t h a t B := f{P") ^ o and D i m B = k < n. Then there are k + 1 points in general position spanning B: B = 60 V . . . V bk- Choose Oj G f^^{bi) ^ o, i = 0,... ,k. Setting A : = OQ V . . . V a^ we conclude / ( A ) = B = f{P^) and Dim A < n from (13). Therefore, there is an X G P " \ A for which, nevertheless, f{x) G B has to hold. Hence / cannot be injective. li B = o, then, because of n > 0 we obtain f{x) = o for all x G P " , i.e., / is not injective. b) implies a): Consider a m a p / t h a t is not injective. Then there are x,y e P " , X ^ y, such t h a t f{x) = f{y). If, e.g., x = o, then / ( y ) = o and
30
1 Projective Geometry
y y^ o. Set now ao := y and choose additional points to obtain a projectively independent sequence ( a o , . . . , a „ ) in P " . > F r o m / ( O Q ) = O we conclude by Lemma 4 / ( P : ) = / ( a i ) V . . . V / ( a „ ) , hence D i m / ( P : ) < n.
(15)
If a; and y are different from o, denote t h e m by ao := x, ai := y, and once more form a sequence of projectively independent points (OQ, . . . , a „ ) in P " . Since / ( O Q ) = / ( a i ) , this again yields (15). As for each subspace A C P o t h e restriction / | A of the m a p / is also injective, c) immediately follows from the equivalence of a) and b). Since b) is a special case of c), t h e latter is equivalent to b). • R e m a r k . Obviously, for each injective collinear m a p we have / ^ ^ ( o ) = o. As t h e example of a constant m a p (Example 3) / with y^ ^ o and n > 0 shows, this property does not imply t h e injectivity of / . Nevertheless, we have t h e following. P r o p o s i t i o n 7. Let f : P " -^ Q™ be collinear and suppose, moreover, D i m / ( P " ) > 1. The map f is injective if and only if f^^{o) = o.
that
P r o o f . W i t h o u t loss of generality we may assume t h a t / is surjective. Let bj, j = 0,... ,m, be points spanning Q™: Q™ = 6o V . . . V 6 ^ . Choose points Uj G f^^{bj), ttj ^ o, and form A := ao V . . . V a ^ . Relation (13) implies f{A) = <5™, and by CoroUary 5 we have Dim A = m. According to Proposition 6, g := f\A is bijective. Now t h e proof proceeds by contradiction. Suppose t h a t f^^{o) = o and t h a t / is not injective. T h e n there has to be a point c G P " \ A for which there exists a point CQ G A satisfying / ( C Q ) = / ( c ) . Since c ^ o and f^^{o) = o, we have / ( c ) 7^ o as well as CQ ^ o. Consider t h e projective subspace H™^^ := cV A and define the m a p q := g-^ o f\H"'+^
: H"'+^
-^
A,
which is collinear by Proposition 2. Now q\A = i d ^ immediately implies q"^ = q. For each x G H'™+^ there is precisely one XQ G A, namely XQ = q{x), satisfying f{x) = f{xo). By definition, q{x) G A, f{q{x)) = {g o g-'^ ° I){x), and g = f\A is injective. Let x G H\A. T h e n q{x\/XQ) = q{x)\/q{xo) = XQ, and hence a; V a;o C q^^{xo). We are now going to show q^^{xo) = x\/ XQ. To this end, suppose t h a t xi ^ x \/ XQ and q{xi) = XQ- Since x ^ o and q^^{o) = o, this implies XQ y^ o and Dima; V a;o V a;i = 2. The dimension formula then yields Dim(a; V a;o V xi) A A = 2 + m - ( m + l ) = l. Because oi q\A = i d ^ , this contradicts t h e relation Xo = q{{x V a;o V Xi) A A ) = (a; V a;o V Xi) A A .
1.3 CoUineations
31
But by assumption we have m + 1 > 2. Therefore, there has to exist a 2GH'™+^\(AU(a;Va;o)). In fact, take any projective frame ( a o , . . . , am+i', e) for H such that x V xo = aoV ttm+i and A = ao V . . . V a^n- Then z = e has the above property. Let zo := q{z). As shown before, q^^{zo) = z\/ ZQ, and hence ZQ ^ XQ. Moreover, {z V ZQ) A (a; V a;o) = o. Then, yL{z V ^o) A (a; V a;o) has to satisfy q{y)LXo as well as q{y)LZo. Since 030 7^ ^0, this is only possible for y = o. Thus the hnes ZVZQ, XVXQ are skew, and hence L := (zV ZQ) V (a; V a;o) is a three-dimensional subspace of H™^^. Since f f ^ + i = I, V A, this implies Dim L AA = 2. Because of q\A = i d ^ we arrive at the contradiction AAL
C q{L) = q{x) V q{xo) V q{z) V q{zo) =
XQV ZQ.
The converse is trivial. Now we can easily deduce the foUowing.
•
Corollary 8. Let f : P'^^ -^ Q"^ he collinear with D i m / ( P ^ ) > 1. Then f can be represented as a composition, f = g o p, of a central projection p and an injective collinear map g in the following way: For B = /^^(o) and any subspace A complementary to B in P " , let p be the central projection p : P " -^ A with center B. Then g := f\A is injective, and f = g op. P r o o f . First, by construction {gop){x) = f{{xVB)AA)tf{x)Vf{B) = f{x). Since AAB = O, the relation {g op)(x) = o can only occur for p{x) = o, i.e. X e B, and hence {gop){x) = f{x). Moreover,p(a;) G A, thus f{P") = f{A). Hence we have Dim gr( A) > 1, and because of A A B = owe obtain gr^^(o) = o. By Proposition 7 the map g is injective. • Proposition 6 implies Dim A = D i m / ( P " ) , and hence we immediately arrive at the following property corresponding to (12): Corollary 9. Let f : P " -^ Q™ be a collinear map such thatDmif(P") Then, for every projective subspace H C P",
Dim/(H') = D i m H ' - D i m H ' A / " i ( o ) - 1.
> 1.
(16)
Thus for any collineation f the dimensions of a projective subspace and its image always coincide, Dim f(H) = DimH". P r o o f . By CoroUary 8, f = g op. Hence f{H) = {g op)(H), and since g is injective, Proposition 6, c) implies Dim/(H') = T>iinp{H). On the other hand, p{H) = {H V B) A A. Applying the dimension formula twice, the complementarity of A and B = f^^{o) yields:
32
1 Projective Geometry Biinp{H)
= Dim H + Dim B - Dim H AB = BiinH
-BiinHAB
+ Dim
A-n,
- 1.
For a collineation / we have by d e f i n i t i o n / ^ ^ ( o ) = o, hence Dim i J A B = —1; the case D i m / ( P " ) < 1 is triviaUy true for coUineations (and in general false for collinear maps, cf. Example 2). D 1.3.2 T h e M a i n T h e o r e m of P r o j e c t i v e G e o m e t r y In this section we will prove the following Main Theorem of Projective Geometry, which also implies the characterization of collinear maps mentioned in the introduction to this chapter (cf. E. Artin [4], J. Dieudonne [36]): P r o p o s i t i o n 10. Let V, W he {n+1)-dimensional vector spaces, n > 2, over the skew fields Ki and K^, respectively, with associated projective spaces P " andQ". Let, moreover,
f:xeP:^x'
= fix) e Q:
be a collineation. Then there are an isomorphism of skew fields a : Ki -^ K^ and a a-linear bijection a : V ^ W inducing f, i.e. satisfying /([p]) = [«(?)] for all f (^ V. Lf ai : V ^ W is another ai-linear bijection inducing f, then there exists JJ, G Kf such that ai(?) = a(?M),
? e V,
^i(e) = ^(M"'eM),
eeifi-
(17)
(is)
P r o o f . Proposition 6, c) implies t h a t the images of the points in a projective frame ( a o , . . . , a „ : e) of P " , a^ = / ( a i ) , e' = / ( e ) , * = 0 , . . . , n ,
(19)
form a projective frame of Q " , since any n + 1 among t h e m are projectively independent. Let (Oj) and ( o ^ be bases of V and W, respectively, determining the projective frames ( a o , . . . , a „ : e) and ( o g , . . . , a^ : e'). By Proposition 2.2 each of t h e m is uniquely defined up to a factor from if* and if^ •• respectively. We will prove t h a t there is an isomorphism a : Ki -^ K2 for which, in the homogeneous coordinates corresponding to the bases, / is represented by f{[aix%
= [a[a{x%
(20)
(Recall the sum convention!), the a-linear m a p we are looking for is thus a : OjX* eV
^
a'iCrix^) G W.
To see this, consider a coordinate axis OQ V a^, 0 ^ j . Because of (19) we obtain a bijection aj : Ki -^ K^ defined by
1.3 CoUineations
/([oo + oj-e]) = [o^ + o;.a,-(e)], e e K,,
33
(21)
(cf. Example 1.3). We prove: The map GJ is independent of j . Consider, say, <Ti and
c' = ix[iOVx',iO)Aia[Va',) = [(0^ + o'iai(e))5 + (0^ + o^a2(e))^] = [a'i7 + a^^]. Comparing coefficients yields a = - / 3 , 7 = cri(C)a, S = cr2(C)/3 = -c^2(C)«,
and we conclude c ' = [0^^2(6-o'iai(e)]. Since c' does not depend on ^, we may set ^ = 1 and finally obtain from the resulting equation, (TJ{1) = 1, that c' = [02 — a'l]. This together with the last formula imphes the assertion ai{S,) = (^2(0 foi" ^H ^ & Ki. Now we prove (20). First let x ^ HQ, where HQ = a i V.. .Va„ denotes the coordinate hyperplane complementary to OQ. Since f{Ho) is the coordinate hyperplane H'Q complementary to Og, we also have x' = f{x) ^ H'^. Hence the coordinates x'-', x"-' of a; and x' are different from zero. Normalizing these to have x" = 1, x ' " = 1 we obtain the normalized representations
34
1 Projective Geometry a; = [oo + aix^ + . . . o„x"], x' = [OQ + a[x''^ + ... a^x'"].
Let pi,p'i be the respective projections onto the coordinate axes ao V a i and Og V a[. Moreover, denoting by HQI, H'Q-^ the coordinate planes complement a r y to these axes, we have p-i{x) = {xV Hoi) A (ao V a-i) = [oo + aix^] p[{x') The equations from Example other, the fact Definition (21)
= {x' V H'o,) A {a'o V a[) = ^
+
a[x%
on the right-hand side of these formulas immediately result 1, (6). Now, since / maps the coordinate planes into one ant h a t the colhneation / commutes with V and A together with of a implies:
f{pi{x)) i.e. x'^ = a{x^). we obtain
= [a'o +a[a{x')]
=p[{f{x))
= [a'o +
a[x'%
As corresponding relations hold for all the coordinate axes, n
n
/([oo + Yla^^']) = K + E4^(^')]' ^' ^ ^1'
(22)
and this is just assertion (20) for the case x ^ HQ- If a; G HQ, then also x' = f{x) G HQ, and we have x° = x ' ° = 0. In this case, x = [p] with p = Yl^=i l j ^ ^ lies on the line ao V [oo + ?]. Hence, by (19) and (21), f{x) lies on the line a'g V [OQ + Yl"=i a'jCr{x^)]. Thus n
n
This implies JJ, = —v and, since a common factor does not matter, y^ = a(x^). This again is the asserted equation (20). Now it is not difficult to show t h a t a is an isomorphism: T h e point X = [oo + ai(C + v) + I2] lies on the line [oo + aiC] V [air/ + 02]. Consequently, the image point x' = [OQ + Cl[a{^ + r]) + O2] is on the image line [a'Q + a[cr{^)]\/[a[cr{r/) + a'2]. This implies o-{^ + r/) = o-{^)+a{r/). Analogously, the point a; = [oo + Cli^r] + 02??] hes on the fine ao V [oi^ + O2], so the image point x' = [a'o + a[cr{^r/) + a'20-{r/)] belongs to the image line ag V [0iO-(C) + 02]. Comparing coefficients in a'o + a'lCriCl]) + 02Cr(??) = aoJ^ + (a'iCr(C) + 02)^ yields i/ = 1, 1^ = (T{r]), ^(^ry) = (T{S,)a{r]). This completes the proof of the existence part of the proposition. To prove uniqueness consider the m a p b := a^^ o a i : V ^ V . It is a semilinear bijection with the isomorphism T := a^^ o ai of Ki. Since it induces the identity on P " , there has to be a function
1.3 CoUineations
35
A : p G F \ {0} H^ A(p) G K* with 6(p) = pA(p). In particular, we have 6(0i) = Ojaj, a j G Kf.
From
6(0i + Oj) = (Oi + aj)A(oi + Oj) = 6(0i) + 6(0j) = Ojaj + Oj-aj we conclude a j = a^ = : JJ, and hence 6(aj) = ajjj, for a certain /x G Kf and all j . Since Oi is an arbitrary vector t h a t is linearly independent of Oo, and d i m F > 3, we obtain A(p) = /x for ah p G V \ {0}. Thus 6(p) = p/x, i.e. ai(p) = a(p/i) for some /x G i f J. Furthermore, we obtain 6(p^) = TI^T{0 = ?CM) i.e. T ( ^ ) = /X^^CM and cri(C) = cr(/i"^C/i). D For coUinear maps the Main Theorem implies the following. C o r o l l a r y 1 1 . Every coUinear map f : P"^ ^ Q™ such that D i m / ( P " ) > 2 is generated by a semi-linear map between the associated vector spaces b:V ->W. P r o o f . In the notations of Corollary 8 the m a p / can be represented in the form f = g o p; according to (6) the central projection pi is induced linearly. Since g{A) = f{P"), the m a p g : A ^ f{P") is a coUineation satisfying the hypotheses of Proposition 10. Hence it is generated by a semi-Unear m a p a. Consequently, the composition f = g o p \s induced by a semi-linear m a p b = a o pr. D 1.3.3 T h e G r o u p of A u t o - C o U i n e a t i o n s An important and somewhat surprising partial result of the Main Theorem is the isomorphy between the skew fields of two projective spaces t h a t are m a p p e d onto one another by a coUineation. Because of this invariance of the scalar domains, considering coUinear maps we will always suppose Ki = K2, i.e., we will be working within the category of projective geometries (or spaces, respectively) over a fixed skew field K. Since, as already mentioned, the notion of a coUineation is less rich in substance for n < 2, for the description of the automorphism group of projective spaces we will require n > 2 until the end of this section. The projective Unes, for which the cross ratio plays a decisive part, will be studied in the subsequent section. Let us start with the following definition. D e f i n i t i o n 3. For n > 2, let A u t P " denote the group of all coUineations f .pn ^ pn f^^^ pn ^^ -^g^jj^ rpj^^ elements / G Aut P " are called the auto-collineations of P " . Here and in the sequel we will often omit the index o, when there is no risk of confusion; if necessary, a m a p / : P " -^ Q™ will be understood to be extended by / ( o ) := o to a m a p / : P " -^ Q™ . • T h e Main Theorem allows us to describe Aut P " algebraically, since each auto-coUineation is generated by a semi-linear bijection. First we will prove the following.
36
1 Projective Geometry
L e m m a 12. The group of all the f G A u t P " leaving each point of a given projective frame {ai] e), i = 0 ..., n, of P " fixed is isomorphic to the group of automorphisms Aut K of the skew field K for P " . P r o o f . Let a G Aut K, and take a basis (Oj) of the vector space V associated with P " determining the frame (OJ; e ) . Then the m a p ip : a i-^ fa- with faiiaix'])
:= [aM^l]
(23)
defines a homomorphism from Aut i f to A u t P " , for which every f^ belongs to the stationary subgroup of ( a j ; e ) , i.e., it satisfies the conditions f{ai)
= Ui, f{e)
= e, i = 0,...,n,
(24)
since
/<,([oo + aiC]) = [ao + aicr(C)] = [ao + aiC], and this imphes a{S,) = ^ for all ^ & K. Hence f is injective. So we stiU have to show t h a t each auto-colhneation / satisfying (24) has the form (23). First, the equations (24) yield for any semi-linear m a p a inducing / with corresponding automorphism a G Aut K:
a(Oi) = Oi/ij, a ( 2 j 1j) = 22 '^Jf^J ^ ( Z J '^J')'"' i.e. iJ,i = jj, =^ 0 for « = 0 , . . . , n. Hence we have a(OiX*) = Oi/iO-(x*),
(25)
f{[aix'])
(26)
= [aii^a{x')] = [aii^a{x')i^-'].
Setting thus T := cr^i O a, where
(27) this way, and the associated is linear. Any automorphism
1.3 CoUineations
37
Consequently, the matrix (a^) is invertible, and we obtain a m a p
: a G G ( F " + ^ ) i—> <^{a) := ((af), a) G GL{n
+ l,K)x
Aut K.
Furthermore, 'P{a-')
= {{a-Ha\))-\a-').
(28)
A straightforward calculation using ^(6) = ((/3f), T ) leads to .(6oa) = ( ( A ' ^ ) ( r ( a ^ ) ) , r o a ) .
(29)
Defining in the product set G „ + i ( i f ) := GL{n
+ l,K)x
Aut i f
a multiplication by ((/3f),r).((a^),a):=((A'^)(r(a^)),roa),
(30)
results in a group, the semi-linear group Gn^i{K) of order n + 1 over K, as the semi-direct product of the normal subgroup GL{n + 1) x { i d x } with the subgroup {(<5j)} X Aut if, cf. Exercise 1.3.2.3. Moreover, ^ t u r n s out to be an isomorphism: G ( F " + i ) = G„+i(if), n G N o . (31) In Example 2 we introduced the dilation d^ by dn{i) = p/x, p G V , yU, G K*; d^ is semi-linear with automorphism a^i-i. As the following proposition implies, the set of all dilations Z>:=K|MGif*}cG(F) is a normal subgroup oi G{V). neK*
By means of
^ d^-i
G -D,
K* = D,
it is isomorphic to K*. In the sequel we consider K* as canonically embedded into the semi-linear group via ^eK*^
and correspondingly write K* C G „ + i ( i f ) .
a^) G G „ + i ( i f ) ,
(32)
38
1 Projective Geometry
Proposition 13. The map F : a e G(F"+^) ^ fa e A u t P " , n>2, by /a([?]) := [«(?)]; is a surjective homomorphism with kernel Kei F = D,
defined (33)
so that A u t P " = G„+i(if)/if*,
n>2.
(34)
P r o o f . The Main Theorem together with the obvious formula fboa = fb° fa immediately show that F is a surjective homomorphism. Hence, (34) can be deduced from (33) using (31) and (32). To describe the kernel K e r F , choose a basis for V " ^ and consider a map fa e G(F"+^) determined by fa = (P^^{{al),a), for which /„ = idpn. Since /„ in particular satisfies (24), we derive relation (26) as in the proof of Lemma 12; we only have to replace ( " D = (<^iM"^),
/ a = / r w i t h T = cr^-l OCT,
cf. (23). Since the map a i-^ fa- is injective by Lemma 12, T has to be the identity of K, i.e. a = a^. On the other hand, each d^ e D obviously belongs toKerF. D Now we ask whether the sequences (ao, . . . , a „ ; e) we caUed projective frames actually are frames in the sense of the group-theoretic view onto geometry. According to E. CARTAN [28] this means that the group, on which the geometry is based, acts simply transitively on this set of frames. As will be shown below this does not hold, in general for the group of auto-coUineations; in the important case of the field if = R of real numbers, however, it is true. Proposition 14. Let P^, Q" be n-dimensional projective spaces, n>l, over the skew field K, and let a G Ant K be any automorphism of K. Then, for every pair of projective frames, {aj]e), ( a ' ; e ' ) of P^ and Q^, respectively, there exists a collineation f : P " -^ Q " generated by a a-linear map such that f{aj) = a;.,
/ ( e ) = e'.
(35)
/ / K is commutative, f is uniquely determined by (35) and a. Conversely, if such a map is uniquely determined by a couple {aj]e), {a'j]e') together with (7 G Aut K, then K is a field. P r o o f . By Proposition 2.2, we find bases (Oj) of F " + \ (o^) of W"+^ such that (oj-; e) and (a^; e') are the associated projective frames. Considering (20) as a definition for / , the equations
1.3 CoUineations
39
L e m m a 15. The scalar domain of P^, n G N , is a field if and only if there is only one collineation f generated by a linear map a G GL{V ) that satisfies (24), namely f = i d p r i . P r o o f . As in the proof of Lemma 12, relation (24) implies the condition a(Oj) = ajjj,,
jj, G K*,
(36)
for the linear m a p a we want to find. If i f is a field, then each of these maps generates the identity collineation / = i d p r i . Consequently, the latter is uniquely determined by requiring (24) as well as linearity. If K is not commutative, there exist i^, a e K* with i^a/^^^ ^ a. Since n > 1, the associated vector space has at least dimension two. Consider the vector p := Ooa + ai and the linear m a p a determined by (36) t h a t generates / . Then /([?]) = [«(?)] = [loM" + IIM] = [aoM"M"^ + i i ] 7^ [loa + ai] = [p], since the vectors Ooa + fli, Oo/UQ^M^^ + l i ^ire obviously linearly independent. T h u s / is a linearly generated auto-coUineation t h a t is different from the identity and satisfies (24). D C o r o l l a r y 16. Let K = H be the field of real (or rational) numbers. If f : P " -^ <5™ is a collinear map with D i m / ( P " ) > 2, then f is generated by a linear map between the associated vector spaces. The group A u t P " , n>2, acts simply transitively on the set of projective frames. P r o o f . It can easily be shown, cf. Exercise 1.2.1.3, t h a t the the fields of rational and real numbers each have only a single automorphism, the identity m a p . Hence, in these cases there is only one coUineation satisfying (35) by Proposition 14. Hint. To prove the statement concerning the automorphisms a of R, first show that for each of these automorphisms the restriction (7|Q to the field Q of rational numbers is the identity idq. Then, starting from (7(5^) = ((7(5))^ prove that a is monotonous and derive from this its continuity. This, finally, implies a = idR. D Exercise 2. Let / : P" -^ Q™ be a map with the following properties: a) / ( o ) = o; b) f{x V J/) C f{x) V f{y) for all x,y E P"; c) f{P") is a projective subspace of dimension n. Prove that / is an injective collinear map. Exercise 3. Let P", Q™ be projective spaces over the field K, let {aj;e) be a projective frame of P", and let {bj; b), j = 0,... ,n, he a sequence of points in Q™. Find examples to show that there does not always have to exist a collinear map / : P" -^ Q™ , for which / ( o j ) = bj, j = 0,. .. ,n, and / ( e ) = b. Prove, moreover, that, in general, these conditions together with the postulate a = idx for the automorphism of K associated with / do not determine / uniquely. (Compare this, however, with Proposition 1.5.3.4 for afline maps!)
40
1 Projective Geometry
Exercise 4 . Let P", Q"^^', K,{aj;e) be as in Exercise 3, and let, in addition, {bo,... ,br;b), n > r > 2, be a projectively dependent sequence of points from Q™, each (r + l)-element subsequence of which is projectively independent. Prove that for every automorphism a G Aut K there is precisely one collinear map f : P" ^ Q™ with the properties: a) / ( a ^ ) = bp, p = 0,. .. ,r; h) / ( e ) = b; c) / ( c r + i V . . . V a„) = o; d) / is generated by a a-linear map c : F"+^ -^ VF™+^ of the associated vector spaces. Exercise 5. Let \^"+^, W be right vector spaces over the skew fields Ki and K2, respectively, n > 2, and let ^" = ^(V), Q = ^(W) be the associated projective geometries (cf. Definition 1.1). A map F : ^ " ^ Q is called monotonous if ior A,B e ^ , A C B always implies the relation F{A) C F{B). Prove: If F is bijective, and F as well as F^^ are monotonous, then / := F\P" is a coUineation. Conversely, every coUineation / generates an isomorphism of the lattices F : [^", C] ^ [Q, C]. (In R. BAER [5], § III.l, the projective maps are actually defined as such isomorphisms of lattices.) Exercise 6. In analogy to Corollary 8, describe all collinear maps / : P" -^ Q™ with D i m / ( P ^ ) = 0. Exercise 7. Let / G A u t P " , n > 2, and let F be the automorphism of the lattice [^", C] determined by / according to Exercise 5. Prove that / is the identity of P " , if for some k, 0 < k < n, the restriction of F to Pn,k is the identity. Exercise 8. Coarse Classification of Collinear Maps. Let PO,QTJ projective spaces over the skew field K. Define: T:={f:P:^
n,m
> 2, be
Q ^ l / collinear, D i m / ( P : ) > 2},
G:= AutQ" X AutP". Via {{g,h),f) ^GxTi-^gofo hr^ e T the group G acts on JF; denote by ~ the corresponding equivalence relation. Prove that / i ~ /2 if and only if Dim/i(P^) = Dim/2(P^). Exercise 9. Prove that the group A u t P " , n > 2, acts transitively on the Grafimann manifolds P„,k of fc-planes in n-dimensional projective space. (To this end, consider the realization of fc-planes as subsets of point space defined by the canonical map (1.2) as well as the action defined on them via the action of A u t P " on P".) Determine the isotropy group of a fc-plane. (The isotropy group or stationary subgroup of an element x in the transformed space is the set of all those elements g in the transforming group G leaving x fixed, i.e. gx = x, cf. I, § 1.4.)
1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps In afRne geometry, the length ratio of two parallel segments or vectors is an important invariant closely related to the afRne parameter on a line, cf. Exercise 1.4.3.1. In projective geometry, an analogous procedure starting from
1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps
41
the projective scales on a line leads to the notion of the cross ratio of four coUinear points, t h a t can be interpreted as the quotient of two length ratios, which explains its name^. In this section we will first deal with the geometry on the projective line over a skew field K. The cross ratio of four collinear points will be defined by means of a projective scale on the line; nevertheless, it does not depend on the choice of the scale. In general, however, this cross ratio is not invariant under collineations; it is transformed by the automorphism of K associated with the coUineation. Requiring invariance of the cross ratio will lead to a special class of colhnear maps, the projective maps. These form a category whose objects are the projective geometries (or spaces) over the skew field K, t h a t , in general, is smaller t h a n the category based on all collinear maps. For the field i f = R of real numbers all collinear maps / with D i m / ( P " ) > 2 are projective.
1.4.1 T h e G r o u p A u t P ^ In Example 3.3 we already pointed out t h a t arbitrary bijections between lines are collinear. The Main Theorem of Projective Geometry does not hold for n = 1, and the group A u t P is not defined, yet. In order to characterize the projective geometry on a line by a group we will proceed as follows: Consider the Grafimann manifold Pn,i of lines in an n-dimensional projective geometry, n > 1. The group of auto-colhneations of P " acts transitively over Pn,i (Exercise 3.9); denote by H the isotropy group of a fixed line B C P " . T h e elements h e H leave the line B as a whole fixed, i.e., they transform the points of B among themselves. This way, an action of H over B is defined, t h a t allows to develop a rich projective geometry on the line. To describe this action we choose a projective frame (OJ; e) of P " for which B = ao V a i is a coordinate axis. A semi-linear m a p a inducing the coUineation h £ H G Aut P " then has to satisfy the conditions a(oo) = ao^o + a i 6 j ,
a(oi) = 006? + ai6j
(1)
with respect to a basis (Oj), i = 0,... ,n, determining this frame. Since h is a coUineation, the 2 x 2-matrix (60) occurring here has to have rank two. Conversely, each semi-hnear transformation of the vector space V " + ^ associated with P " having property (1) determines a coUineation belonging to H. Since the remaining coefficients 6^, « > 1 or j > 1, do not affect the action of h on B, we arrive at the same initial situation for the projective line as in the case of higher dimensional projective spaces: Formulas (3.27) to (3.33) retain their validity even for n = 1. They describe the action of the restrictions h\B to the line B, where, of course, plenty of different elements h e H yield the same restriction. We obtain a homomorphism F from G(V ) to the group of all bijections on P = B, which is defined as in Proposition 3.13. Setting ^ Specialize Formula (15) below to the case K = R.
42
1 Projective Geometry A u t p i := {U\a e GiV')}
= FiGiV')),
(2)
Formulas (3.33), (3.34) also hold true for n = 1. We call A u t P ^ the automorphism group of the projective line. It is not difficult to see that, formally, the case n = 0 is included here; we have G{V^) = £), and A u t P ° just consists of the unit element. The reader may easily check that Lemma 3.12 and Proposition 3.13 remain valid for n = I, including their proofs. 1.4.2 The Cross Ratio Now we consider the projective line P^ under the action of the group A u t P ^ and look for the invariants of this transformation group. By Proposition 3.14, applied to the case Q^ = -P^, the group Aut P^ acts transitively on the triples (a, b, c) formed by pairwise different points on the hue. Of course, these triples may always be viewed as the points in a projective frame. Thus, an invariant is first to be expected looking at quadruples w = (a, 6, c, d) of points on the line P . The point of departure for the determination of such an invariant is a projective scale on the line, cf. Example 1.3. Let, for the time being, the points b, c, d of the quadruple w be pairwise different. Then, by Proposition 2.2 we find a basis (oo, ai) of the vector space V associated with P that is uniquely determined up to a common factor /x G K* and satisfies [oo] = c, [oi] = d, [oo + ai] = b.
(3)
Let ^ denote the value assigned to a by the projective scale for this basis. If the scalar field K is not commutative, then the factor /x G K*, occurring due to the arbitrariness in the choice of the basis, indeed plays a part. By CoroUary 2.4, the different scale values, obtained by varying the basis satisfying (3), are related by inner automorphisms of K. Hence, it is not the scale value itself but its conjugacy class that is assigned to the quadruple in a way independent of the chosen basis. We denote this conjugacy class by < e >:= {MCM" V e K*}, if e G if, < oo >:= {oo}.
(4)
The last postulate only serves to include the case C = oo that actually occurs, for a = d. If if is a field, we can do without these considerations, since each conjugacy class only consists of the element itself. In general, we agree to set < ^ > = ^, if < ^ > has just a single element. In particular, for a skew field < 0 > = 0, < 1 > = 1, < oo > = oo.
(5)
Now we summarize the observations above in the following definition, that now refers to the n-dimensional space, since, typically, we will have to deal with hues as embedded objects. Definition 1. Let P " be a projective space over the skew field K. A quadruple w = (a, 6, c, d) of points in P " is caUed a throw if the points a, 6, c, d are
1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps
43
coUinear, and at least three of them are pairwise different. A throw is caUed special if its last three entries, b, c, d, are pairwise different. If w is a special throw, then its cross ratio, abbreviated as CR, is defined by CR(w;) = (a, 6; c, d) :=< ^ >, where ^ = ^(a) is the scale value of a with respect to a basis for the vector space of the hne c V d satisfying (3). • According to the above considerations CR(w;) does not depend on the choice of the basis satisfying (3). In particular, because of (3) and (5) we have (6, b; c, d) = 1, (c, b; c, d) = 0, (d, b; c, d) = oo. (6) The CR does, however, depend on the order of the points in the throw. In order to remove the asymmetry in Definition 1, and to define the CR for an arbitrary throw we suppose that the four points are mutually different and investigate the way the CR changes under a permutation of the points in the throw. The case that two points of the throw are equal will be considered afterwards. Note that, by (6) this is the case if and only if the CR attains one of the values occurring in (5). This immediately follows from the properties of a projective scale. Since each permutation in the symmetry group 6*4 can be represented as a product of the transpositions (12), (23), (3, 4) (cf. Exercise 1.1.2.7), it suffices to consider the action of these transpositions. We wiU prove: (6, a; c, d) = (a, 6; d, c) = (a, 6; c, d)^^.
(7)
In this as well as in similar formulas, the algebraic operations are to be applied to aU elements in the conjugacy class. Obviously, it suffices to prove the claim for any representative ^ G (a, b; c, d). Using Definition 1 we conclude from (3) the following, where the second line of the formula refers to the computation of (6, a; c, d):
Here, the vectors each have to represent the points: a=[a],b=[b],c=[c],d=m, 0 = oa, b = b/3, c = C7, 6 = t)(5,
(9) {a, f3,'-/,S e K*).
By (9), equations (8) and (10) hold, if we set 0 = 0, b = b, c = c, 6 = t)^.
The value of ^ has to be computed from
tj = c + (fe)e = c+1),
(10)
44
1 Projective Geometry
leading to ^^ = 1, i.e. claim (7) for the permutation of a, b. The pair c, d is treated similarly. The next formula is proved along the same lines (of. the proof of Proposition 1 below): (a, c,b,d) = 1 — (a, b; c, d).
(11)
So far, we considered throws consisting of four different points, hence, e.g. ^ ^ 0 and ^ = ^^^ make sense. If now C = 0, then a = c, and, interchanging c, d, relation (6) imphes 0 = (c, b; c, d) 1-^ (c, b; d, c) = oo. FormaUy setting 0^^ := oo the equality ^ = ^^^ remains vahd also in this case. Considering in the same way the case a = d we analogously see that oo^^ := 0 again yields the correct result. If, finally, a = d, the exchange of b and c together with (6) lead to oo = (d, b; c, d) i-^ (d, c; b, d) = oo. Setting 1 — oo := oo relation (11) also holds in this case. Summarizing we have the following. Proposition 1. Let (a, b; c, d) be a throw containing four different points of the n-dimensional projective space P " over the skew field K. Then, their cross ratio satisfies the relations (7) and (11). Moreover, (a, 6; c, d) = (c, d; a, b) = (6, a; d, c) = (d, c; b, a).
(12)
Relation (12) provides a unique way to define the CR also for arbitrary throws. Setting 0"^ := oo, oo"^ := 0, 1 - oo := oo, (13) rules (7), (11), (12) remain true for arbitrary throws. If S, €z {a,b;c,d) arbitrary CR, then
e, r\ 1 - e, 1 - r\ (i - 0'\ e(e -1)"'
is an
(w)
represent all the possible cross ratios for permutations of the four points in the throw. P r o o f . We first prove formula (11). Since b and c are interchanged, the second line in formula (8) now reads as
0 = b + 6C,
c = b + 6.
Inserting (10) into these equations, using the first line of (8), and comparing coefficients in the representations with respect to the basis (c, ti) of the vector space associated with the hue yields
1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps a = /3 = 7 = -(5,
45
C = 1 - C,
and this is just claim (11). For a special throw with only three mutually different points, in all the three cases for a = b,c, d, it is straightforward to check (11) taking into account (13). Decomposing the permutation, 1234 34 12
(2 3)(3 4 ) ( 1 2 ) ( 2 3),
the first equation of formula (12) follows from (7) and (11). The two remaining equations immediately follow by applying (7) to both pairs of the CR in the resulting equation. If a throw contains only three mutually different points, then, by applying one of the permutations occurring in (12), we can always achieve a situation where the last three points are different from one another. The resulting CR is then correctly defined by extending equation (12) to this case, so t h a t (7), (11), and (12) hold for the CR of an arbitrary throw. Since, according to (12), for each of the CRs corresponding to the 24 throws obtained by permuting four points, there are three others with the same value, altogether at most six different values are possible. These can be obtained as the expressions mentioned in (14) by applying (7) and (11) once or twice. Of course, in particular cases even more of these values may coincide; in the case K = Z2, e.g., there are only three values at all: 0 , 1 , 00. D Exercise 1. Let P be a projective line over the skew field K, let ^ : P^ ^ K be an arbitrary projective scale on P^, and let bj e P ^ , j = 1 , . . . , 4, be four different points with scale values /3j := ^{bj) / 00. Prove the following formula for the CR: (61, 62; b3, 64) = < (/3i -/33)(/3i -/34)"'[(/32 -/33)(/32 -/34)
(15)
(Hint. Apply transformation formula (2.10) from Example 2.2.) Exercise 2. Let K he a field, let P^ he a projective line over K, and let (61, 62, ^3, ^4) be a throw in P^. Denote by {xj,yj) the homogeneous coordinates of the point bj with respect to an arbitrary projective frame ( a o , a i ; e ) of P , J = 1 , . . . ,4 (cf. Corollary 2.3). Prove the following expression for the CR in terms of determinants containing the homogeneous coordinates: Xl
(61,62:^3,64)
Xs
X2
X3
yi ya
2/2 J/3
Xl
X4
X2
yi
yi
2/2 J/4
=
(16)
X4
Formulas (15) and (16) are the classical expressions for the CR; they explain the name "cross ratio". T h e behavior of the CR under coUinear maps is described in the following. P r o p o s i t i o n 2. Let f : P" -^ <5™ be a coUinear map induced by the a-linear map g : F " + i ^ W""^ with a G Aut K, and let (a, b, c, d) a throw in P". Then either
46
1 Projective Geometry
Dim(/(a)V/(6)V/(c)V/(d))
f{d)) = a{{a, b; c, d)).
(17)
In particular, the CR is invariant under any collineation induced by a semilinear map with inner automorphism a = a^. P r o o f . Consider, say, the case c ^ d and H" = c V d. If /(c) = / ( d ) , then Dim/(H') < 1, and we are in the first situation. For /(c) ^ f{d) we know that H := f{H) = f{c) V / ( d ) is a hne, and, by Proposition 3.6, f\H is a colhneation. Hence {f (a), f (b), f (c), f (d)) again is a throw. Let U C V, tj C W be the two-dimensional subspaces associated with H and H, respectively. Then g{U) = U. Because of (12) we can suppose that b, c, d are mutually different, which then has to hold for their images as well. Choosing the basis (oo,ai) for U as in Definition 1, we have, using the notation introduced there,
0 = oo + aiC und gr(o) = ^(oo) + giai)a{^), since <; is a a-linear bijection. As the images of the base points correspond to the image of the throw, a{S,) corresponds to the CR of this image, proving (17). The last assertion follows from the fact that every inner automorphism leaves each conjugacy class invariant. • 1.4.3 Projective Maps The observations preceding the definition of the CR show that the CR is a fundamental notion for projective geometry, comparable to the ratio of segment lengths in afRne geometry and to the distance in Euclidean geometry. Indeed, in the following section on afRne geometry and in Sections 2.5, 2.6 on metric geometries we will see that both these notions can be based on the CR. Hence it should only be reasonable to expect a projective map to leave the CR invariant. Thus excluding the a-linear maps with an automorphism a that is not an inner one: Definition 2. A map / : P " -^ Q™ is called projective if it is colhnear and leaves the CR invariant. More precisely, for every throw {a,b,c,d) in P " , such that / ( a ) V f{b) V /(c) V / ( d ) is again a line, (/(a),/(b);/(c),/(d)) = (a,6;c,d).
(18) D
Corollary 3. The class of spaces over the skew field K together with the projective maps as morphisms forms a category. •
1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps
47
P r o p o s i t i o n 4. Let K be afield, and let P^, Q " be n-dimensional projective spaces over K, n > 0. A map f : P " -^ Q " is a projective bijection induced by a linear isomorphism of the associated vector spaces if and only if it has the following properties:
1. / ( o ) = o; 2. / maps each throw again into a throw; 3. relation (18) holds for every throw in P " , i.e., f leaves the C R
invariant.
P r o o f . 1. and 2. immediately imply t h a t / is injective. To see this, consider a throw (6, b, c, d) in P " . Since the image of this throw also is a throw, the three image points have to be mutually different. For each point 6 G c V d, c 7^ d, we have f{b) G f{c)\/f{d) for the same reason. Hence f{c\/d) C f{c)\/ f{d). Let now ^ G -ft' be arbitrary and take d to be the point in / ( c ) V f{d) for which e=(a,/(6);/(c),/(d)). Since i f is a field, and as the projective scale is bijective, d is uniquely determined by ^ G if, and vice versa. T h e same is true for ^ = (a, 6; c, d) with a G c V d. Because of Properties 2 and 3, we thus have / ( a ) = d, and hence / ( c V d) = / ( c ) V / ( d ) . So / is colhnear, and by Proposition 3.6 it is a coUineation. For n = 1 the fact just proved means /([oo + aiC]) = [ao + aiC], where the bases (oo, a i ) , (oo, ai) of the vector spaces corresponding to P ^ , Q^ are chosen to determine the CR as in Definition 1. Thus it is clear t h a t / is induced by the linear m a p transforming (oo, fli) into (oo, &i). For n > 2, the Main Theorem implies t h a t / is induced by a a-linear bijection of the vector spaces. In the case of a field, the values of the CR belong to K. As there are no proper inner isomorphisms, because of Proposition 2, (17), condition 3 implies a = i d ^ , and hence / has to be a linear isomorphism. Conversely, it is clear t h a t each of the maps obtained this way has Properties 1-3. • Propositions 4 and 3.14 immediately imply the following: C o r o l l a r y 5. Let K be a field, and let P " , Q " be projective spaces over K. Then for every pair of projective frames [aj] e) of P " , [dj] e) of Q " , j = 1 , . . . , n, there exists a unique projective bijection f : P " -^ Q " such that f{aj) = dj, / ( e ) = e. D Exercise 3 . Let K he a field. Prove that assigning to each linear a : T^"+^ -^ |y™+i the projective map it induces defines a covariant functor the category of linear maps between finite-dimensional vector spaces over K the category of projective maps between finite-dimensional projective spaces K.
map from onto over
Exercise 4 . Let K he a skew field, and let P", Q™ be projective spaces over K. Consider throws (6j), (bj), j = 1,...,4, in P" and Q™, respectively. Prove that
48
1 Projective Geometry
there is a projective map / : P " -^ Q™ with f{bj) = 6j, j = 1,... , 4 if and only if (61,62:^3, 64) = (61, 62:^3, 64).
Proposition 6. Let K be a skew field satisfying the following condition: I. Each automorphism a G Ant K such that
) = < ^ > for all conjugacy classes < S, >C K is an inner automorphism. Then for every projective space P " , n >2, over K the group G of projective auto-collineations is isomorphic to the projective linear group PGL(n+ 1, K) (cf. Definition 2.1). This statement always holds, if K is a field or the skew field H of quaternions. P r o o f . According to the Main Theorem, every auto-coUineation / G A u t P " is induced by a a-linear bijection a of the associated vector space V . Since / is projective, a leaves each conjugacy class in K invariant, and so, by condition I, it is an inner automorphism of K. Choose a basis (Oj) of V"^^, « = 0 , . . . , n. With respect to this basis the map a inducing / has the representation where yU, G K* determines the associated inner automorphism a = a^. But then / is also induced by the linear automorphism of V"+ corresponding to the matrix (af/u): f{[aix']) = [aMiix% (19) Hence we already obtain all projective auto-collineations by restricting the homomorphism F from Proposition 3.13 to the subgroup GL{V^^ ) x {idx} of Gn+i{K); denote this restriction by F. Then by (3.33) we have KeiF = (KerF) n (GI,(F"+^) x {idx}) = {(id-^.+i M,idK)|M e Z{K*)} ^ Z{K*),
(20)
where Z{K*) denotes the center of K*. Since F is surjective, we deduce from the Homomorphism Theorem for groups (see Proposition 1.3.1.6) the claim, cf. Definition 2.1: G = GL{n + 1, K)/Z{n + 1) = PGL{n + 1, K).
(21)
In the case of a field. Property I is satisfied for trivial reasons; the skew field H of quaternions also has it, cf. Example II.8.8.5. • Nevertheless, there are skew fields not having Property I, cf. G. K O T H E [68], R. B A E R [5], § HI.4. For these skew fields the following definition is geometrically not compelling; it provides, however, a unified foundation for the further elaboration of projective geometry: Definition 3. Let P " be the projective space associated with the vector space V"+ over the skew field K. Then a projectivity or projective transformation of P " (or from P " to a projective space Q " over K) is always
1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps
49
understood to be a collineation that can be induced by a linear isomorphism. The group of projectivities from P " to itself will be denoted by PZ((P") or, for short P i „ ; it is called the projective group of P " . • With this definition we now have the general relation PLn = GL{V"+^)/Z{GL{V"+^)) = PGL{n + 1, K).
(22)
This immediately implies: The projective group PLn acts transitively on the Grafimann manifolds Pn,k of projective k-planes in P " , hence in particular on the projective space P " , since the linear group acts transitively on the Gra£mann manifolds Gn^i^k+i of (k + l)-dimensional subspaces in the (n + l)-dimensional vector space V"^^. To see the latter, consider two subspaces U,W e Gn+i,k+i and choose bases ao, • • • ,Clk for U, b o , . . . , bfc for W, and complete both to obtain bases (Oj), (bj), i = 0,.. .n, for V. Then the linear transformation g G G L ( V " ^ ) defined by g{ai) = bj, « = 0,.. .n, satisfies gU = W. Propositions 4 and 6 can be considered as geometric characterizations of the projective group. In accord with the Erlanger Programm [65] by F. KLEIN we want to consider projective geometry as the geometry of the transformation group [PLn, P " ] . Since the group PGL{n+ 1, K) is the group of coordinate transformations of P " over K (cf. Definition 2.1), we again obtain the correspondence between geometric and coordinate transformations already described in § 1.5.7: The homogeneous coordinate systems of P " form an atlas adapted to the transformation group [PLn,P"] (cf. Definition 1.5.7.5 and Exercise 1.5.7.6). In the case of a field, the group PLIP"") is identical to the group of projective bijections of P " onto itself. For a skew field with Property I this holds by Proposition 6 for n > 2; in the case n = \ the group of projective bijections is larger, in general. E x a m p l e 1. The group PLi is isomorphic to the group GK of fractional linear transformations (2.10), cf. Exercise 2.4. This fact leads to models of projective lines P {K) as transformation groups [GK, K] that are simple and, in the cases if = R, C, H, easy to work with. D E x a m p l e 2. By Corollary 3.16, each collineation / : P " -^ Q " , n > 2, over the field if = R of real numbers is a projectivity. In this case, we thus are in the very convenient situation that each bijective map transforming lines again into lines also leaves the CR, and hence all projective properties, invariant. • Exercise 5. Prove that the only continuous automorphisms of the field C of complex numbers are the identity and the conjugation a : z t-^ z. Hint. Prove first that every continuous automorphism r of C has to satisfy T(R) = R, cf. Exercise 1.2.3.3. E x a m p l e 3. If if = C is the field of complex numbers, then there are infinitely many automorphisms. This follows from Proposition V.6.1 in the algebra book by N. BOURBAKI [19]. From the geometric point of view, it is natural
50
1 Projective Geometry
to confine oneself to the continuous collinear maps / : P " -^ Q™, n > 2; here, continuity refers to the topology introduced via inhomogeneous coordinates. If / is continuous, then its restriction to an arbitrary projective line also has to be continuous. Interpreting the C R occurring in (17) as projective scales, the arguments in the proof of Proposition 4 show t h a t ^{f{x)) = a{^{x)), or a = ^o f o^^^. Hence a is continuous. According to Exercise 5, a is either the identity — then the collineation / is a projectivity — or a is the conjugation. In this case, we caU the colhneation / an anti-projectivity, cf. also W . BuRAU [24], § III.20. In analogy to Proposition 4, anti-projectivities are characterized by the property (/(a),/(b);/(c),/(d)) = (a,6;c,d). In the sequel, we will only consider continuous collinear maps for complex scalars K = C. This correspondingly also applies to the automorphism group A u t P of the complex projective line. Using a projective scale z = z{x{^)) (cf. Example 2.2) to describe the group, we see t h a t the projectivities are represented by fractional linear transformations, f(z)
=
with ad — be =^ 0, cz + a
and the anti-projectivities correspond to fractional conjugate-linear transformations, f{z)
= -^ with ad — be =^ 0. cz -\- d D
E x a m p l e 4. The sole non-commutative skew field t h a t is important for us is the skew field H of quaternions'^ , cf. § 1.2.3. Since by Example II.8.8.5 or Exercise II.8.9.5 every automorphism of H is an inner one. Propositions 2 and 6 together with the Main Theorem imply: Each collineation f : P " -^ Q " , n > 2, between quaternionic projective spaces can be induced linearly; in addition, it preserves the CR. More generally, this holds for every collinear m a p / with D i m / ( P ^ ) > 2, cf. Corollary 3.11. D E x a m p l e 5. Exercise II.7.4.7 immediately implies the rather obvious isomorphy of centers Z ( G I , ( F " + ^ ) ) = Z{K*), by assigning to JJ, e Z{K*) the corresponding dilation d^i G GL{V^^ ) . Denoting as usual the special linear group by SL{m, K), i.e. the group of square matrices of order m with determinant one over the field K, then (22) and the computation of the kernel for the homomorphism p:ge
GL{n
+ 1, R ) i—> {det{g))
— ^ SL{n —
+ 1, R ) ,
n = 2ke
No,
An elementary introduction into the quaternions (and the octonions) can be found in I. L. KANTOR, A . S . SOLODOWNIKOW [58] and in many textbooks on algebra.
1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps
51
show the relation PLn = SLin+l,^.),
n = 2ke'No.
Denote, moreover, as usual the unit matrix of order rn hy Im- In addition, let \SL\('m, R ) be the group of real square matrices of order m whose determinant has absolute value one. Then, for odd n, we analogously obtain PLn
= |^L|(n+ l,R)/{±/„+i},
n = 2k +
leN.
For K = C denote by Km the group of m-th roots of unity, of. Proposition 1.2.3.7. Dividing g e G I , ( F " + i ) by an (n + l ) - t h root of the norm N{g) and multiplying the result by i f „ + i we obtain PLn = SL{n + l,C)/Kn+i
{K=C).
Here, i f „ + i is embedded into SL{n + 1, C ) as the set of dilatations d^, e G Kn+l. • 1.4.4 H a r m o n i c P o s i t i o n In general, the six CRs corresponding to all permutations of the points in a throw are mutually different according t o (14). As already noted, this does not hold in the case (13) t h a t the throw contains two identical points. If the CR of a throw is (a, b;c,d) = —1, then the throw is called harmonic; this is also expressed by saying t h a t the pairs (a, b), (c, d) are in harmonic position. In this case, permuting the points of the throw we only obtain the values — 1, 2 , 1 / 2 by (14). T h e following exercise describes a geometric construction for the fourth point being in harmonic position with three given ones: Exercise 6. Let P be a projective plane over the skew field K. A complete quadrangle is understood to be any configuration consisting of four points, the vertices Ui e P^, i = 0 , . . . , 3, no three of which are collinear, together with their six connecting hues, also called the sides of the complete quadrangle, cf. Figure 1.8. The sides are arranged into three pairs of opposite sides, {ao V a i , 02 V 03}, {ao V 02, oi V 03}, {ao V as, ai V 02},
(23)
intersecting in the diagonal points of the complete quadrangle do
(ao V 03) A (ai V 02),
di
(ai Va3) A(ao Va2),
d = d2
(02 V 03) A (ao V a i ) .
(24)
Prove: a) do, di, d2 are not collinear if and only if char K ^ 2. - h) The connecting hues di \/ dj, i / j , of diagonal points do not pass through the vertices of the quadrangle. (Hint. Compute the homogeneous coordinates of di with respect to a basis for the projective frame ( a o , a i , a 2 ; e ) with e := as..) - c) Each side of the
52
1 Projective Geometry
Fig. 1.8. Harmonic Position.
complete quadrangle contains precisely one diagonal point, e.g. d := d2 G oo V ai. Denote by s the point of intersection of the side with the connecting line of the diagonal points not lying on it; e.g., for the side ao V a i this point of intersection is s = (ao V a i ) A (do V di). Prove that (s, d; ao, oi) = —1.
(25)
d) Consider a complete quadrangle in the real affine plane, in which the sides ao Vai, a2 V as are parallel and prove that s then cuts the segment ao, a i into halves. R e m a r k . T h e requirement t h a t there exists a complete quadrangle in P whose diagonal points are not coUinear, is known in synthetic projective geometry as the Fano Postulate, cf. R. B A E R [5], Ch. II. It imphes t h a t the characteristic of the synthetically constructed scalar domain is different from two. If the scalar domain has characteristic two, then the relation 1 = — 1 together with (25) imply s = d; harmonic position thus is of no interest in this case. Exercise 7. Let char A" / 2. Using the notations of Exercise 6 prove that the diagonal points (do, di) together with the intersection points p, q of the lines do Vdi with the sides of the complete quadrangle not passing through do, di, p := (do V di) A (ao V a i ) ,
q := (do V di) A (a2 V as),
form a harmonic throw: (p, q; do, di) = —1. Exercise 8. Permuting the points in a throw results in at most six different CRs by Proposition 1. Prove that the number of values ^ of the CR under the permutations of the points in a throw is less than six precisely in one of the following cases:
1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps
53
a) 5 = 1,0,00;
(26)
6)C = - 1 , 2, i ;
(27)
c) 5 is a root of the equation x — a; + 1 = 0.
(28)
In the cases a) and b) the specified values are attained. For char K = 2, a) and b) coincide. If A" = R, then only the cases a) and b) are possible. For A" = C, in the situation of case c), the throw is called equi-anharmonic; in this case, only the two values C=(l±iV^)/2 (29) can occur. Prove by means of Exercise II.8.9.5 that for the quaternions, K = H, all solutions of (28) are conjugate; there are infinitely many of them. So the value < C > of the CR just consists of a single conjugacy class. Exercise 9. As in Example 1.3 we identify the complex projective line with the Riemann sphere: P^{C) = C. Prove: If zo,zi,Z2 are the vertices of an equilateral triangle in the complex number plane C, and m is its center, then (zo, zi, Z2,m) and (zo, zi,Z2, 00) are equi-anharmonic throws. 1.4.5 S t a u d t ' s M a i n T h e o r e m For the projective geometry over a field K we are now going to prove the following result due to K. G. C H R . V . S T A U D T (1798-1867) t h a t completes the Main Theorem of Projective Geometry and is therefore sometimes called Staudt's Main Theorem: P r o p o s i t i o n 7. Let P he the projective line over a field K with characteristic char i f ^2. A surjective map f '• P ^ P is a projective automorphism if and only if it preserves harmonic position. Thus, for the real projective line f is a projectivity. P r o o f . Obviously, the condition is necessary. To prove the converse, we choose a projective scale ^ in P and identify the points x e P with the correspondingly labeUed scalars x = ^{x) G K. Since any pair of different points on the line can always be completed to a harmonic throw by Exercise 6, and because of char K y^ 2, the points of a harmonic throw are mutually different, the m a p / is bijective, and /(O), / ( I ) , / ( o o ) are three different points. Let a denote the projectivity satisfying a ( / ( 0 ) ) = 0, a ( / ( l ) ) = l, a ( / ( o o ) ) = oo. By Corollary 5 it is uniquely determined. Then, <; := a o / is a m a p from P to itself preserving harmonic position with fixed points 0 = g(0), 1 = g{l), 00 = g{oo). Now the proof is finished once we have shown t h a t g\K is an automorphism of the field K, since then / = a^^ o gr is a projective automorphism on P^. In the case i f = R this has to be a projectivity according to Exercise 1.2.1.3 (note also the hint foUowing Corollary 3.16), because oi g = idR.
54
1 Projective Geometry Relation (16) implies t h a t for all x,y ^ K, x ^ y: (x, y- (x + y ) / 2 , oo) = {g{x), g{y)- g{{x + y)/2),
oo) = - 1 ,
(30)
hence giix + y)/2) = igix) + giy))/2,
x^y.
(31)
Setting here y = 0 we conclude from g{Q) = 0 g{x/2)
= g{x)/2,
x e K,
(32)
and from x = 2y t h a t g{2y) = 2g{y),
y e K.
(33)
(31) and (33) imply g{x + y) = g{x) + g{y),
x,y e K.
(34)
Once again from (16) we obtain {-z,z;l,z^)
= {g{-z),g{zy,l,g{z^))
= -l,
(z e K).
(35)
Since (34) immediately implies g{—x) = —g(x), we deduce from (35) t h a t giz^)=gizf,
zeK.
(36)
Inserting z = x + y into this last equation and applying (33) and (34) yields
g{x-y) = g{x)- g{y),
x,y e K.
(37)
Since / and a are bijective, t h e same holds true for g; hence, by (34) and (37) the m a p g is an automorphism of the field K. D For i f = R t h e assertion can be proved without assuming the surjectivity of / . This is a consequence of two facts: The continuity of each endomorphism of R , and the density of the rational numbers in R . R e m a r k . T h e proof of Proposition 7 presented here can also be found in E . S P E R N E R [98], Bd. II, or W . K L I N G E N B E R G [67]. A more general result for a skew field K with char i f =^ 2 contains E . A R T I N [4], Theorem 2.25, cf. also R. B A E R [5], § III.4. Exercise 10. Let P^ be a projective line over the field K, char if / 2, and let, in addition, f : P -^ P be a surjective map preserving harmonic position and leaving the point oo e if = P^ fixed. Here we identify if with P^ as in the proof of Proposition 7. Prove that there exist a G Aut if, a e if* and /3 G if such that fix) = aa{x) +l3ior xeK
= P^\ {oo}.
Exercise 1 1 . Let I n t i f be the group of inner automorphisms of the skew field if. Then Int if is a normal subgroup of the group Aut if of automorphisms of if. Prove that for every projective space P", n > 2, over if the group PLn is a normal subgroup in A u t P " , and that the following quotients are isomorphic: Aut P"/PL„
-^ Aut if/ Int if.
1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps
55
1.4.6 P r o j e c t i v e E q u i v a l e n c e of C o U i n e a r M a p s . I n v o l u t i o n s We conclude this section by some considerations concerning the of coUinear maps. They wiU be based on the fohowing.
classification
D e f i n i t i o n 4. Let P " , Q" be projective spaces over the skew field K. Two maps / i : P " -^ P " , /2 : <5" -^ Q " ^^^ called projectively equivalent, if there exists a projectivity g : P " -^ Q" such t h a t f2 = 9 ° fi° 9^^^ It is obvious t h a t projectively equivalent coUinear maps have to satisfy the condition Dim/i(P:) = Dim/2(g:); if the fj are induced by the o-j-linear maps a^, then the 0 projective subspaces Ai C P", where a) Ai A \J Aj = o, r
b) y^(DimAi + 1) < n + 1. i=l
In the case of a projective line, any projectivity / / id p i can thus have at most r < 2 fixed points; accordingly, the map / is called elliptic, parabolic or hyperbolic if r = 0,1, or 2, respectively. Exercise 1 3 . Let P^ be a projective line over the field K, char A" / 2. Prove: a) If there are two points a,b & P^, a ^ b, that are transformed into each other by the projectivity / , / ( a ) = b and f{b) = a, then / is involutive, i.e. /^ = i d p i . - b) If / e PLi, f / i d p i , is involutive, then / either has two difi'erent or no fixed point at all. If a, b are two different fixed points of the involution f, then we have (a, b; x,f{x))
= -1
(a: / a, b).
(38)
c) Let a,a',b,b' e P^ be four different points. Prove that there is a unique involutive projectivity with / ( a ) = a' and f{b) = b'. Exercise 14. Again consider the situation of Exercise 13. Prove that every projectivity / e PLi can be represented as the product of two involutions.
56
1 Projective Geometry
Now we want to describe the involutive
coUineations f G A u t P " , / ^ =
idpn.
Exercise 1 5 . Let P" ,n > 2, be a (right) projective space over the skew field K. Consider an involutive and fixed-point fi-ee / G A u t P " : /
= idpn,
/ ( * ) / X for all x e P",
Prove that n is odd, and / can be induced by a cr-linear map a of the associated vector space V^''\ 2k = n + 1, which has the following properties: a) There is A e K* such that a^ = d\; here the following relations hold (7(A) = A and a = a^ ,
(39)
where cxiS,) = A^A^ denotes the inner automorphism of K corresponding to A. b) There is a basis (o^, Otk+K)K=i,...,k of V'^^ such that, in this basis, a has the following representation:
a{ar.) = ak+r., a{ak+r.) = ar.\.
(40)
c) There is no /it G K* with X = IJ,a{iJ,).
(41)
Conversely, each collineation induced this way is involutive and fixed-point free. Classify all these coUineations in the cases K = H and K = C, a the identity or the conjugation of C. (Hint. Note that p / 0 and a(p) are always finearly independent, since f{x) / a: = [p]. Moreover, by /^ = i d p n the subspace W C V they span is invariant under a.) T h e classification result, whose proof we outhned in Exercise 15, may be summarized as follows: In the case K = H, the fixed-point free involutions f G Aut P " are projectively equivalent to the normal form (40) with A = —1, a = idR. Thus, in homogeneous coordinates, / can be represented in the form k
/ ( [ ^ ( o « x « + ak+.x^+^)])
k
= [ ^ ( - o « x ' ^ + « + Ofc+«x«)],
(42)
i.e. / is the simultaneous "rotation through 7r/2" in all the two-dimensional subspaces W^ := £ ( 0 K , afc+fj), "- = 2A;. In the case K = C, the automorphism a has to be conjugation, and up to projective equivalence all fixed-point free involutions are of the form k
k
/([^(o«x« + ak+.x'^+n]) = [J2(-a.x''^^ n=l
+ ak+.x^)].
(43)
n= l
For K = C, a = i d c , and in the case of the quaternions K = ii there are no fixed-point free involutions at all. This is a consequence of the following. Exercise 16. Prove: a) If K is an algebraically closed field, then each projectivity / G PLn has at least one fixed point. - b) Over the skew field of quaternions H, each collineation / G A u t P " , n > 2, has at least one fixed point.
1.4 Cross Ratio and Projective Maps
57
Exercise 17. Let K he a skew field, char A" / 2, let P" be a (right) projective space over K, n > 2, and let / G Aut P " be an involutive collineation having at least one fixed point. Prove that under these conditions / even has at least n + 1 fixed points in general position. More precisely, prove that there is a basis (Oi), i = 0,.. . ,n, of the associated vector space V such that a cr-linear map a inducing / has diagonal form in (cu), and a{ai) = OiPi, Pi(T{Pi) = l,a^=
idy, a^ = idx .
(44)
(Hint, a^ = d\ and a{b) = b/x together imply IJ,IJ{IJ) = A. Consider, in addition, the map a' := d^ o a also generating / , and prove that the maximal subspace of V spanned by the eigenvectors of a' is all of V.) Starting from (44) and specializing K as well as a, it is often possible to obtain a complete classification of t h e involutions with fixed points. Below we will quote some of the related results, b u t leave the proofs to the reader. E x a m p l e 6. Under the assumptions of Exercise 17 let, in particular, K be a field a n d a = i d ^ - Then, with a suitable numbering of t h e basis elements, (44) imphes t h a t for each of these involutions / ^ i d p n there exists a number A ; G N o , 0 < A ; < n / 2 , such t h a t , for an appropriate choice of the basis, a{o.a) =-0.a, 0(0^) = OK,
a = Q,...,k, K = A; + 1 , .. . , n .
,
,
Denoting by aj := [Oj] t h e points corresponding to the basis elements, the A;-plane A := ao V . . . V a^ as well as its complementary [n — k — l)-plane B := Uk+i V . . . V a „ are point-wise fixed; AU B is the set of fixed points of / . T h e m a p / is called a reflection of P " with respect to the pair of complementary subspaces A, B. Obviously, for every such pair of subspaces there is precisely one reflection, and two reflections of this kind are projectively equivalent if and only if the dimensions k,n — k — I are the same. Choosing one of t h e spaces, say B, as a subspace of the hyperplane at infinity H of an afRne space A " = P " \ H results in an affine reflection in a A;-plane A in the direction of t h e complementary space B; compare this also with the results of t h e subsequent section. D E x a m p l e 7. In t h e case K = C, apart from t h e cases already treated in Example 6, we now consider the involutive anti-projectivities J with t h e conjugation a = T : z 1-^ z as inducing automorphism having, in addition, a fixed point. According to Exercise 17 then (44) holds, i.e. /3j/?j = |/3j|^ = 1, and hence f3j = e' '-^^. Transforming t h e basis according to b,- = 0jei'^^'/2,
^- = 0,
,n.
we arrive at bj = a(bj); hence all of these involutions are projectively equivalent. Moreover, in an adapted basis (bj) as just described, they aU have the normal form
58
1 Projective Geometry n
n
J{[J2b,x^]) = [J2b,x^]. 3=0
(46)
3= 0
So the homogeneous coordinates {TJ) of the fixed points satisfy TJ = ^^z, where ^^ G R and z G C*. Obviously, they form a real projective space P " ( R ) C P " ( C ) , for which the points bj = [bj],j = 0 , . . . , n, and e = [J2j bj] form a projective frame. This sequence of points is a projective frame for the complex space P " ( C ) as weU. For this reason, a n involution J with normal form (46) is caUed a real structure on P " ( C ) , cf. Definition II.8.9.5; the set P " ( R ) C P " ( C ) of fixed points of J is caUed a Staudt chain. Consequently, all real structures, and hence all Staudt chains of a given dimension are projectively equivalent. • E x a m p l e 8. Let now K = ii denote the skew field of quaternions. In order to classify the involutions of P " ( H ) we could again start from (44). Instead, we prefer to make use of a fact already mentioned in Example 4: Each collineation can be induced by a linear m a p . According t o Exercises 16 and 17 the involution / has a t least n + 1 fixed points in general position. Thus we find a basis (o;) of the associated vector space V as weU as a linear m a p a inducing / t h a t is in diagonal form with respect t o this basis: a{ai) = aiqi,
qi G H .
(47)
According t o (22), involutivity means t h a t a? = d\ has t o b e a dilation by A G .^(H) = R . This again implies: ?;2 = A G R * ,
/ = 0, . . . , n .
(48)
Turning to the equivalent representation of / by a!:=d^oa,
/x : = |A|^2
(49)
we can assume without loss of generality t h a t A = ± 1 . Recalhng how the multiphcation is defined in H , cf. 11.(8.9.4), it is easy t o see t h a t in H the equation q^ = \ only has the solutions = ± 1 . So in this case we again arrive a t the reflections (45) in a pair of complementary subspaces (Example 6). Now consider A = —1. Using 11.(8.9.4) we see t h a t the set of solutions of q^ = —\ coincides with the unit sphere in the space of imaginary quaternions S"^ C R ^ C H ; here R ^ denotes the real subspace of H spanned by the imaginary units i, j , k G H . On this sphere S"^ the group of inner automorphisms of H , which is isomorphic to the special orthogonal group S ' 0 ( 3 ) , acts transitively, cf. Exercise II.8.9.5. Thus, for each of the qi in (47) we find a p; G H* such t h a t Pi^qiPi=\-
(50)
Looking a t the basis bi := aipi, / = 0 , . . . , n, we immediately see t h a t a{bi) = aiqipi = bii.
(51)
1.5 AfEne Geometry from the Projective Viewpoint
59
Hence any involution of P " ( H ) , n > 2, is either a reflection or a projectivity J , which by (51) has the normal form
Ji[J2b,x']) = [J2b,Ax'].
(52)
Note t h a t , according to Exercises 15-17 and the subsequent examples for the cases i f = R , H , the involutive colhneations, and for i f = C the continuous involutive coUineations are completely classified. • Exercise 18. Find an example showing that the assertion in Exercise 17 is wrong without the assumption char if / 2. Exercise 19. Let A, B be complementary projective subspaces in P " , both different from o, and consider xi, y^ e P"\{AUB), {xi\/y-^^)AA = ai, (xi\/y{}/\B = bi. a) Prove that there is a unique projectivity / G PLn with the properties f\A = idj^, f\B = i d j j , and f{xi) = y^. - b) For n > 2, find a geometric way to construct fix) for any point x e P " \ (A U B). (Hint. Recall Exercise 2.1.) For n = 2, such maps are also called central coUineations, cf. J. BOHM et al [18], Bd. II. - c) Prove that / is involutive if and only if (a:i, j/j^, a i , 6i) is a harmonic throw.
1.5 AfRne Geometry from t h e Projective Viewpoint In Section 1 we started from the afhne plane and obtained the projective plane by adjoining a "line at infinity". This idea motivated the definition of the projective geometry ^ " as the lattice of subspaces of an (n + l)-dimensional vector space V . This way we avoided to pursue the rather awkward process of extending the n-dimensional afhne geometry towards the projective one. Now we want to proceed the other way round: AfRne geometry is shown to arise from the projective one by distinguishing a projective hyperplane H in J-*". All affine notions are derived from the projective ones by relating the latter to this distinguished hyperplane. For simplicity, we will use the symbols introduced in the course of the axiomatic approach to affine geometry in Chapters 1.4, 1.5 to denote the corresponding projective notions as well. This should not lead to any confusion. Note also t h a t this time we wiU be more general t h a n there, since now the scalar domain may be a skew field. D e f i n i t i o n 1. Let P " denote the projective space associated with the (n + l)-dimensional right vector space V " + ^ over the skew field K, and let H C P " be a fixed hyperplane in P " . Then for n > 1 its complement A " := P " \ H" is called an n-dimensional affine space over K. For n = 0, — 1 we set A ° := P ° , A^^ := 0. In the case n > 1, H" is called the hyperplane at infinity of the affine space A " ; it is also called the absolute hyperplane, the ideal hyperplane, or the improper hyperplane. •
60
1 Projective Geometry
Proposition 3.14 immediately implies that the projective linear group acts transitively on the set of hyperplanes: Just assign a frame to each hyperplane in a suitable way and consider the case a = id^- Hence it does not matter which particular hyperplane is distinguished. To say it lies "at infinity" is suggested by the geometric interpretation described in Section 1. The fundamental property special to afRne and not belonging to projective geometry is parallelism: Definition 2. In the notation of Definition 1, let B be a projective A;-plane, A; > 0. If B'^ C H, then B^ is called improper, and otherwise proper. For every proper A;-plane we have B'' r\ A^ ^ 0; so M'' := B'' n A " is called the affi,ne k-plane corresponding to B . Let B , C he proper projective subspaces of P " , whose dimensions satisfy 1 < / < A;. Denote, moreover, the affine /-plane corresponding to C ' . £)' is said to be parallel to M'' (or C ' parallel to B'', respectively) if
Hn&cHnB''.
(1)
Starting, conversely, from an affine A;-plane M , the proper projective A;-plane B to be defined is uniquely determined; it is called the projective closure of tv
— k
M and will be denoted by M . I t is thus the projective subspace for which M'^ = M ' ' n A " . D The dimension formula (Proposition 1.1) yields the following. Corollary 1. For every proper projective plane B BimH
AB'' = k - l .
(2)
In particular, a proper k-plane B , k > I, is parallel to a proper hyperplane C " - i if and only if B'' C C " - ^ or B'' A C " - ^ CH. D Definition 2 is in accordance with the idea that two different lines in the plane (or, more generally, hyperplanes in P " ) are parallel if they intersect "at infinity". It can be shown (cf. Exercise 4 c ) ) , that the A;-dimensional vector space associated with an affine A;-plane M'' = B'^HA" (cf. Proposition 1.4.5.1) is precisely the vector space UnW C V"^^; here U and W denote the vector subspaces determining B'' and H, respectively. Hence Definition 2 exactly corresponds to the Definition 1.4.5.3 of parallelism in affine geometry. Since parallelism is to be an afRnely invariant property, we can only permit those projectivities as affine transformations that map H (and hence also A") into itself: The affine group 2l(n) = 2l(A") is thus defined to be the stationary subgroup of H: 2l(n) := {/ G PLn\f{H) = H}. (3) In order to obtain the coordinate representation of affine transformations in its usual form (cf. 1.(5.7.46)) we first have to grasp the notion of an affine
1.5 AfEne Geometry from the Projective Viewpoint
61
coordinate system from the projective point of view. A basis (Oj) of the vector space V or a projective frame (OJ; e) wih be called affinely adapted if H = aiV ...Van
(ai = [Oi]),
(4)
i.e., if the points Oj, « = 1 , . . . ,n, are improper. The only proper base point ao = [oo] is called the origin of the affine coordinate system. The afhne space A " is then just the domain of definition UQ for the zero chart cpo that is defined by x° 7^ 0 and determined by the inhomogeneous coordinate system belonging to the homogeneous coordinate system for the affinely adapted basis (cf. Lemma 2.6). Hence we will consider the inhomogeneous coordinates defined by (2.8) for « = 0 as the affine coordinates of a point x G A " with respect to the affinely adapted basis Oo, • • •, On: For each x G A " there is precisely one n-tuple (x^) G if", j = 1,... ,n, such that
Mx) = (x^) e K",
(5)
n
hence a; = [oo + Y J
ttjxJ].
(6)
j=i
In particular, the unit points [oo + flj] on the axes ao + [Oj] coincide with those of the affine geometry, cf. Fig. 1.7 (for n = 2). Now let (Oj), « = 0 , . . . , n, be a fixed affinely adapted frame in P " , and let / G PLn; take a linear map bf G GL{V"+^) inducing / . Obviously,
f em{n) ^=>bf{aj)eQiai,...,a„),
j = l,...,n.
(7)
Denote by LA{n + 1, K) C GL{n + 1, K) the set of block matrices of the form '/3oo o'' ^ ^ ,, /3oo € if *, b G if", B G GL{n, K). (8) Then (cf. (4.22)) ^{n)^LA{n+l,K)/Z{n+l).
(9)
Here Z{n + 1) denotes the center of GL{n + 1, if), i.e. the group of diagonal matrices /„+iyU,, yU, from the center Z{K*) of the multiplicative group of if. If if is a field, then we normalize the matrices via multiplication by /Jgg to have the form {b,B):=[l°^\
beK^\Be
GL{n, if).
(10)
This immediately implies that the recent definition is compatible with the earlier Definition 1.5.1.2 of the affine group; since (10) is the coordinate matrix of the affine transformation / , using the normalization x" = 1, y" = 1 we obtain for the coordinates of the image point y = f{x):
J i
\ RO RJ I \ -r.J I '
^^^•^
62
1 Projective Geometry
thus n
y^ =/3^+ J2/3fx\
j = l,...,n.
(12)
Up to notation, this is the coordinate representation 1.(5.7.42) for the affine map / . Exercise 1. Let A" be a field. Taking into account definition (10), prove the niultiphcation rule in 2l(n,-R'): ( b , B ) - ( c , C ) = (b + B c , B - C ) .
(13)
Calculate the expression (p, X) = {b, B)^^, and show that 2l(n, K) is the semi-direct product of the normal subgroup {{b,I)\beK"}^[K",+],
I = {Si),
(14)
with the subgroup {{o,B)\B
e GL{n, K)} ^ GL{n, K)
(15)
(cf. § 1.5.3). Exercise 2. Consider the affine space A " over the field K. a) Let g^ be a proper line, Coo := g^ A H, and denote by t the affine parameter on the affine line g^ Pi A " with zero point co and unit point ci / CQ. Prove the relation X = co+ coci t •<=^ t = (x, a; Co, Coo). Thus the affine scales on g^ are just the projective scales assigning the value oo to the improper point g^ A H. Moreover, the CR t is equal to the ratio of the parallel vectors CQX and coci. - b) Let char A" / 2. Prove for three coUinear points co,ci,a: e ^ n A": x bisects the segment (co,ci) (cf. 1.(4.3.30)) if and only if (co,ci; Coo,*) = - 1 . Exercise 3 . Let again A" be a field. Prove: a) The group of homotheties^ of A" is isomorphic to the group of all those projectivities / G PLn for which f\H = idj^j. - b) Each homothety g / idj^n has at most one fixed point in A". - c) The homotheties of A" having no fixed points in A" together with idyj^n form the group T{A") of translations, which again is isomorphic to the group (14). Formulas (11), (12) show t h a t the transformation group [2l(A"), A"] has the same coordinate transformation rules both in the sense of Corollary 1.5.1.3 and in the projective perspective; choosing a cartesian as well as an afRnely adapted coordinate system yields an equivariant isomorphism onto the transformation group [2l(n, K), K"] defined in the matrix algebra over K with the action (11). Therefore, in the sense of the Erlanger Programm by F . K L E I N (s. § 1.6.5), up to isomorphy, both methods determine one and the same affine geometry. Exercise 3 contains the projective description of translations, which Homotheties are the affine maps for which the image of each affine subspace is parallel to the subspace itself, cf. § 1.4.3.
1.5 AfEne Geometry from the Projective Viewpoint
63
form an n-dimensional vector space over K.li f ^ id^ri is a translation, then all lines x V f{x) pass through the same point of H, and we have {x\/f{x))AH=[b],
(16)
if y = a; + b is the affine representation of / (cf. I. (4.5.3)). According to (16), translations by proportional vectors b, bA, A G if*, determine the same improper point. Hence the points of the improper hyperplane can be interpreted as directions in the affine geometry, i.e. equivalence classes of parallel lines. Viewing translations as vectors it is easy to verify the axioms (I), (II), (III) of affine geometry (§ 1.4.3). This completes the projective incorporation of affine geometry. Exercise 4 . Let (cu), i = 0, . . . , n , be an affinely adapted frame; then W" := -C(Oi,... , On) C F"+^ defines the absolute of the affine space A", a) Prove that [A", W,_ftr] satisfies axioms (I), (II), (III) of Definition 1.4.3.1 for an affine geometry, if the action of W" on A " is as follows:
tf, :« = [?] e A"^^tf,(a:):=[j;+b] e A",
beW".
- b) Each it| with b / 0 is a translation in the sense of Exercise 3, i.e., it, = / | A " is the restriction of a projectivity / on P " with f\H = idjj that has no fixed points in A". - c) If M'' = A"n B^ is an affine fc-plane, and C/'=+^ C F " + i denotes the vector subspace associated with B^, then the set of vectors corresponding to the affine fc-plane M (cf. Proposition 1.4.5.1) is V ( M ' = ) = {b e W"|if,(M'=) = M ' ^ } = W " n C7'=+\ Exercise 5. Find an example of two affinely skew planes M'^ , B^ G A^ C P* in the four-dimensional affine space over a field K whose defining projective planes intersect. (Remark: "affinely skew" means that the affine planes are disjoint and not parallel, cf. § 1.4.6.) Exercise 6. Prove (in the notations of Definition 2): If 7) is parallel to M _D' n M'^ / 0, then 7)' C M'=.
and
To conclude this section we want to consider ajfine coUineations, i.e. bijecfive maps / : A " -^ A between affine spaces over skew fields, not necessarily isomorphic, mapping hues into hues satisfying f{x\/y) = f{x)\/f{y). Here the operation V denotes the restriction of the corresponding projective operation to the affine subspaces; similarly for A: £>' A M'' := {D^ A M'') n A " ,
D'
V M ' ^ := {D^ V M'')
D
A".
(17)
We will prove t h a t each affine collineation is the restriction of a uniquely determined colhneation between the associated projective spaces. Using the Main Theorem of Projective Geometry we can draw some interesting conclusions from this fact.
64
1 Projective Geometry
Lemma 2. Let f : A ^ A be an affine coUineation between affine spaces A " C P " , A C P over the skew fields K, K, char if ^ 2, char if ^ 2. Then there is a unique coUineation f : P " -^ P such that f = / | P " . P r o o f . For n = 0,1 the statement is triviaL Let now n > 2. If / is a coUineation extending / , then we obviously have f{H) = H for the improper hyperplanes, and for every affine subspace D C A " the relation fiDAH)=fiD)AH
(18)
has to hold. This allows the following construction for the image f{x) of any improper point x G H: Choose an affine line h in the direction of x, i.e. satisfying x = h A H, and set f{x) := f{h) A H. To justify this definition one has to show that the image f{x) does not depend on the choice of the affine line h with improper point x. In other words, the following lemma has to hold: Lemma 3. Under the assumptions of Lemma 2, every affine coUineation f : A ^ A maps pairs of parallel lines into pairs of parallel lines. P r o o f . Since the closures hi, 1x2 of paraUel hues, hi 7^/12, intersect in an improper point x G H, they span a plane, i.e., they are not skew. Consider a parallelogram a, b, c, d with a V d = /ii, 6 V c = /i2, whose sides a\/ b,c\/ d are paraUel, too. The diagonals a\/ c,b\/ d then intersect in a proper point s = (a V d) A (6 V c) G A". Of course, this intersection point lies in the plane spanned by the parallels. This plane intersects the improper hyperplane H in the line spanned by the diagonal points of the complete quadrangle a, 6, c, d corresponding to the pairs of paraUel sides of the parallelogram. Because of char if ^ 2, the diagonal points are not coUinear, cf. Exercise 4.6, and this implies s G A". Since the affine coUineation / is bijective, the image hues intersect in the proper point / ( s ) = / ( a V d) A f{b V c). So the image points / ( a ) , /(6), / ( c ) , / ( d ) , and hence also the associated image lines f{hi) = f{a V 6), /(/i2) = / ( c V d) lie in a plane. As they are disjoint due to the bijectivity of / , they have to be paraUel. • Now we complete the proof of Lemma 2. Since the map / is uniquely determined according to Lemma 3, all we have to show is that it also maps improper lines into improper lines. So let x,y, z £ H he three different coUinear points. Consider a projective plane M intersecting H in the line a; V y. In this plane we choose three lines /ii, /i2, /i3 such that x = H Ahi, y = H Ah2, z = H A hs. These lines determine a proper triangle in the plane M . The image points / ( a ) , /(6), / ( c ) of the vertices a, b, c in this triangle determine ^—2
a plane M , and for the images of the improper points we have fix) = f{hi) n H, f{y) = f{h2) n H, f{z) = f{hs) n H.
1.6 Duality Because of f{hi)
C M
65
, « = 1, 2, 3, these points lie on the line of intersection
M A H, hence they are collinear. The bijectivity of / follows directly from the bijectivity of / . Hence / is a coUineation. D T h e Main Theorem of Projective Geometry immediately leads to a series of coroUaries: C o r o l l a r y 4. Let m > 2. Under the assumptions of Lemma 2, the dimensions of the affine spaces coincide, n = m, and there is an isomorphism a : K ^ K such that the affine coUineation f has a basis representation of the form n
fix)
n
= f{a + J2 l i ^ ' ) = / ( a ) + E
''i^(^')-
If K is a field, and f preserves the affine ratio of parallel segments, an affine bijection with K = K and a = i d ^ .
(19) then f is
P r o o f . By Corollary 3.9 and Lemma 2 we have n = m. Hence n > 2, and we may apply the Main Theorem of Projective Geometry. For affinely adapted frames we obtain representation (18) starting from the basis representation of the (T-linear m a p inducing / . By Exercise 2, the segment ratio is a special case of the cross ratio, and this implies K = K as well as a = i d x • C o r o l l a r y 5. For n > 2 and a field K with char i f ^ 2, the affine group 2l(n) is the group of affine coUineations for A " leaving the ratio of parallel segments invariant. • For a later application, we point out the real case i f = R . There is only the trivial isomorphism a = idpt, and this leads to a particularly simple description of the affine group: P r o p o s i t i o n 6. The affine group 2l(n) of the real affine space A " , n > 2, consists of all bijective maps from A " to itself mapping lines into lines. • Exercise 7. Using the Main Theorem of Projective Geometry prove that the isometry group^ of the Euchdean point space E", n > 2, is the Euchdean group. (A different proof of this statement can be found in Exercise 1.6.2.13.)
1.6 D u a l i t y In projective geometry, there is a fundamental conceptual symmetry under which the notion pairs join and meet, points and hyperplanes, or, more generally, A;-planes and (n—A;—l)-planes, correspond to one another. This symmetry. ^ This is understood to be the set of all bijective maps from a metric space to itself preserving distance. Obviously, this is a group with respect to composition, see also Section 2.5.6 below.
66
1 Projective Geometry
called duality, allows to produce new geometric results without new proofs, just by formally replacing each notion by its dual counterpart. It reflects the duality of vectors and linear forms, the covectors, cf. § 1.5.6; we will apply this relation to study the duality for projective geometries of arbitrary dimension, see 1.6.2 below. Let us start with the simplest interesting case: 1.6.1 D u a l i t y in P l a n e I n c i d e n c e G e o m e t r y In plane incidence geometry (cf. Example 1.4) there are two basic sets, the set of points and the set of lines, together with a relation, incidence, between points and lines. Performing the dual replacements point I—> line, line I—> point, incidence i—> incidence, in the axiom system P. 1-3, Axioms P . l and P. 2 of plane incidence geometry are transformed one into the other: P . l I—> P.2,
P.2 I—> P . l ,
whereas P.3 changes into a new statement P.3': P.3'. There are four lines no three of which pass through the same point. Statement P . 3 ' can, however, be proved using Axioms P. 1-3, cf. Exercise 1.7. Adding P . 3 ' as a (superfluous) axiom to the axioms P.1-3 leads to an axiom system of plane incidence geometry t h a t is transformed into itself by the dual replacements. This conceptual symmetry is called the duality of the projective plane. Points and lines form a mutually dual pair, and the incidence is a notion t h a t is dual to itself^. Since all deflnitions and propositions of plane incidence geometry are exclusively based on the three fundamental notions mentioned together with the quoted self-dual axiom system, dual replacement assigns a corresponding dual notion to every derived notion. Substituting the dual notion for each notion occurring in a proposition (i.e. a proved statement) again produces a valid statement, a proof of which could just proceed by replacing the notions in the original proof of the flrst one by the dual ones. Hence there is no need to explicate it. In special cases, the dual notion or the dual statement may, of course, coincide with the original one, cf. Exercise 1. T h e formal rule t h a t for any true proposition in plane incidence geometry there is a dual one also holding is called the duality principle for the projective plane. In fact, since in the algebraically deflned plane projective geometry over a skew field K the Axioms P.1-3 can be derived as propositions, the plane duality principle can be applied in this case as well. In the subsequent In fact, incidence is defined as including or to be included, cf. Definition 1.1.1, and, from the point of view of lattice theory, to contain and to be contained form a dual pair, see also Equation (2) below.
1.6 Duality
67
Section 1.6.2 we will discuss the n-dimensional case, t h a t will establish the plane duality principle once again, this time as a special case. T h e book by L. H E F F T E R [48] commences with a self-dual axiom system for the projective geometry of three-dimensional space, from which the duality principle for this geometry follows. Exercise 1. Prove that, in the projective plane P over a skew field K, the figure in DESARGUES' Theorem (Exercise 1.9, Fig. 1.5) is self-dual. Starting from this, conclude the following self-dual proposition: Let (01,02,03), (61,62,^3) be two triangles, i.e. triples of non-collinear points, and let A i = 02 V 0 3 , A2 = 03 V o i , A3 = o i V 02
B i = 62 V 63, B2 = b3 V 61, B3 = bi V 62 be the corresponding trilaterals, i.e. triples of non-concentric lines. Then the following holds: The connecting lines of corresponding points, oi V 61, 02 V 62, 03 V 63, are concentric if and only if the intersection points of corresponding lines, Ai A Bi, A2 A B2, A3 A B3, are collinear. Exercise 2. Dualize PAPPOS' Theorem (Exercise 1.10), and sketch the corresponding situation. Exercise 3 . Let P^ be a projective plane over a skew field K, char A" / 2. Dualize the notion of a complete quadrangle (Exercise 4.6) to define a complete quadrilateral. As the support of the point series the line dually corresponds to the point as the support of the bne pencil, i.e. the set of all lines of the plane passing through that point. According to Example 1 one obtains the notions of cross ratio and harmonic position for lines in the pencil by dualizing the corresponding notions defined for the point series. Find a construction for the fourth line that is harmonic to three concentric hues by duabzing Exercise 4.7. 1.6.2 P r o j e c t i v e a n d A l g e b r a i c D u a l i t y Introducing projective geometry by starting from linear algebra, the geometric duality results from the algebraic duality between vectors and covectors. In this section, we will only consider finite-dimensional vector spaces V over a skew field K. As in the commutative case, the dual V is defined as the set of linear maps u : V ^ K; these are also called linear forms or covectors. Defining addition and multiplication by scalars argumentwise, the dual again is a vector space over K of the same dimension. Note t h a t the dual of a right (left) vector space is a left (right) vector space (Proposition II.7.3.7); in fact, in the non-commutative case linearity of the form can be ensured only if scalar multiplication takes place from the opposite side: /iu(j;a + t)/3) = /iu(j;)a + /iu(t))/3,
/x, a, /3 G if, p, t) G V , u G
V.
As in the commutative case, the dual of the dual space, (V)', again is a vector space t h a t is canonically isomorphic to the original space V. As a rule, both
68
1 Projective Geometry
spaces are identified via the canonical isomorphism: (V')' = V. This can be described most easily using the symmetric notation for the scalar product of a vector and a covector: (u, T)eV'
x V ^
(UIP)
:= u(j;) e K.
The canonical isomorphism V -^ {V)' is obtained by fixing the vector p G V in (UIP) and considering u G V ' as the variable. It is easy to see t h a t , for any basis (Oj) of V, the set of projections onto a single component,
uniquely defines a basis (o^) of V, which is called the dual basis to (Oj); here the sum convention is in action, and Sf denotes the Kronecker symbol.^ If p = OiC,
U = WjO*
are the basis representations of a vector and a covector in mutually dual bases, then their scalar product has the simple expression
It is clear t h a t the propositions of projective geometry hold for right as well as for left vector spaces over the skew field K. In fact, projective geometry is determined by the lattice of subspaces, and, according to Example II.7.2.14, every left vector space over K can be considered as a right vector space over the opposite skew field KQ. SO the lattice of subspaces does not change. This is the way to understand the projective geometry ^(V'): T h e projective geometries of equal dimension over opposite skew fields are isomorphic. Conceptually, projective duality is described by means of the annihilator relation and, in contrast to synthetic projective incidence geometry, accessible to calculations. As is well-known, the annihilator (cf. Definition 1.5.6.1) is defined as a m a p _L : « P ( F ) -^ V(V) in the following way: A G * P ( F ) ^ A^
:= {u G V'\
(UIP)
= 0 for all ? G A } G ViV)-
(1)
Here the subspaces A G ^(V), A G ^(V) are viewed as vector sets; considering t h e m as projective subspaces, the annihilator relation makes sense for b o t h arguments due to the homogeneity of the scalar product; the definition u=
[u] e A ^ :<^=>
(UIP)
= 0 for all x = [f] e A
is independent of the chosen representatives u, p of u,x. > F r o m what we proved in linear algebra, cf. § 1.5.6 and Proposition II.7.3.7, Exercise II.7.3.7 in the non-commutative case, the following is immediate. ^ In Chapter II.7, these results are obtained by specializing the propositions concerning free modules over non-commutative rings. An elementary presentation of vector algebra over skew fields can be found in Chapter III of the book by H. REICHARDT
[91].
1.6 Duality
69
Proposition 1. Let ^ " = ^(V), ^ ' " = ^(V') be the projective geometries associated with the (n + I)-dimensional vector space V over the skew field K and its dual V , respectively. Then the annihilator relation _L : ^ " ^ ^ " is a bijection of lattices reversing inclusion C, and hence preserving incidence. In detail: AcB-^^ B^ CA-^, (A-VB)^ = A^AB^, {AAB)^ -= (A^)^ = A, Dim A = k •<==> Dim A^ == n — k — I, o^=P'",
P"^=o'.
A^\/B^,
(2) (3) (4) (5) (6) D
According to Proposition 1, projective duality can be described as follows: The map _L : ^ " -^ ^ ' " assigns to each basic notion, more precisely, to each element of the projective geometry ^ " , the dual basic notion for the dual projective geometry ^ ' " so that formulas (2) to (6) hold. Since each derived notion as well as every proposition are obtained starting from these basic notions through finitely many steps, each concept leads to a pair of mutually dual notions, and each result leads to a pair of mutually dual statements, that are either both true or both false. In this connection, recall (4). Since all n-dimensional geometries over the same or the opposite skew fields are isomorphic, according to this duality principle, for each proposition there is a proposition dual to it, which, because of (5), as a rule has a different geometric content. As in plane incidence geometry it may, of course, happen that the dual proposition coincides with the original one. Note that, by its very definition, the map _L always depends on the space it is based on, hence on its dimension, which becomes particularly evident in Formula (5). In the examples to follow we will apply the duality principle. Example 1. Let « = [u] G P " be a "point" of the dual projective space. Since by (4) the annihilator, viewed as a map _L : ^ ' " ^ ^ " , is the inverse to (1), u represents the hyperplane «^={a;=[y]GP"|(u|y)=0}.
(7)
As the map _L defines a canonical bijection from the dual point space P ' " onto the Grafimann manifold P „ , „ - i of hyperplanes in the original space P " , it is reasonable and customary to interpret the elements u = [u] G P ' " as hyperplanes in P " , even to call them this way. In (7), the hyperplane u^ is characterized as the set of points whose representatives satisfy the equation (UIP) = 0; fixing, conversely, a point x = [f] ^ o oi P " and looking at all hyperplanes u = [u] satisfying this equation, the dual configuration x^ turns out to be the set of all hyperplanes through the point x. In general, the Grafimann manifold P„,fc of A;-planes in the projective space P " corresponds
70
1 Projective Geometry
to the G r a £ m a n n manifold P'„ n-k-i oi (n — k — l)-planes in P ' " . Since P ' " itself is a projective point space, dualizing the notions and propositions on projective configurations of points we obtain the dual notions and propositions concerning projective configurations of hyperplanes. If, e.g. n = 3, then points are dual to planes, and lines are dual to lines. Each hue B determines the set of points incident with it; we identified this set via the canonical m a p n (cf. (1.2)) with the line itself. W i t h o u t this identification, the object "line" has to be distinguished from this set, which, just for this reason, is sometimes caUed a point series. The associated dual notion is the set of all planes incident with the line, i.e. containing it. The totality of all these planes is called the plane pencil with support B. Let a, 6 G .B be two different points on the line; then we have B = ayb=
(a^ A6^)^,
i.e., the line appears as the join of two points, and, dually, as the intersection of two planes. Transferring the notion from the point series onto the plane pencil, which, in fact, is nothing but a line in P' , the latter is thus equipped with a CR. Hence, e.g., there is the notion of harmonic position for four planes in a plane pencil. For n = 2, the set of all lines through one point dually corresponds to the set of aU points in a line. This is caUed a line pencil., and in this set the C R is defined as well. For arbitrary n > 1, the pencil of all hyperplanes through a fixed (n — 2)-plane corresponds to a line in the dual space P ' " ; the latter is again called the support of the hyperplane pencil. Algebraically, viewing a A;-plane as the join of points corresponds to its parameter representation, and considering it as the intersection of hyperplanes corresponds to its representation as the solution set of a homogeneous system of equations. • Exercise 4 . a) Dualize the notions collinear, throw, CR of a throw to refer to hyperplanes. - b) Prove for a throw of points in P " , (a, b, c, d), that ( a ^ , b^ ,c^, d^) is a throw of hyperplanes in the space P ' " , and that the CR of these throws coincide. - c) Formulate and prove an analogue of Exercise 4.4 for throws of hyperplanes. E x a m p l e 2. In (1.2) we defined a canonical m a p n : V ^ P " t h a t , applied to subspaces, aUowed to reahze the projective subspaces B G ^ " as point sets preserving inclusion C; using the incidence relation this is expressed as (,: Tr{B) = {xeP"\x i B}. (8) T h e analogous canonical m a p TV : V' ^ P ' " can be used to consider each projective subspace U C P ' " as a set of points in P ' " , hence, by duality, as a set of hyperplanes in P " . By (6), the nopoint o' = 7r(o) G P ' " then corresponds to the whole space P " . Duahzing (8) leads to the foUowing geometric interpretation of the annihilator relation _L: T{B):={ueP"'\uLB}
= B^,
(9)
1.6 Duality
71
since T(B) by definition is nothing but the incidence in the set of aU hyperplanes u containing B, for which we thus have {u\B) = 0. But this is just B ; T(B) is called the hyperplane pencil with support B. (Still to be included is the whole space P " corresponding to the nopoint o' t h a t always has to be added to all spaces of hyperplanes. In the sequel we will usually not mention this explicitly.) The canonical m a p n preserves the relation C, whereas it is reversed under T by (2); for this reason, to avoid confusions we will not use T as an identification like TT. D Exercise 5. Let (Oi)i=o,...,n be a basis of \^"+^, and let (o^) the basis of V to it. The hyperplane Hj corresponding to 0^ is defined by
dual
X e Hj •<=^ X = [p] and (a^lp) = 0; Hj is the face opposite to the point aj = [ttj] in the coordinate simplex for this basis. The object dual to the unit point e = [Oo + . . . + fln] is the unit hyperplane n
E:=[a°
+ ... + a^] = {xe
PZ\x = [ajx'] and Y^ x' = 0}.
Choose the unit hyperplane E C P " of a projective frame as the hyperplane at infinity for the affine space A " and prove
= MeA"^^^xV J= 0
moreover, the normalization v
:= X
\Y.xT'
{xeA-)
defines the barycentric coordinates of x with respect to the n-simplex ([flo],... , [Un]), cf. Exercise 1.4.5.5. 1.6.3 P r o j e c t i v e P e n c i l G e o m e t r i e s Let ^ " be an n-dimensional, e.g. right projective geometry over the skew field K, and let A G ^ " be an arbitrary, fixed A;-plane. The pencil of projective subspaces with support A'' is defined as the set of all subspaces containing *P"/A'^ : = { B G * P " | A ' ^ C B } .
(10)
Now we prove P r o p o s i t i o n 2. Under the assumptions of Definition (10), letV"^ D W ^ be the vector spaces over the skew field K corresponding to P" and A , respectively. Denote by V/W the quotient space. Then
72
1 Projective Geometry p:Be
*P"/A'^ I—> p{B) := {b + W\b e B} e ^i{V/W)
(11)
defines a canonical bijection, which is an isomorphism of lattices. This way, a projective geometry of dimension n — k — 1 is defined in ^ " / A . The space dual to the projective point space P{'V/W), i.e. the space of its hyperplanes, is canonically isomorphic to A . P r o o f . For simplicity, let B denote the vector subspace and, at the same time, the projective subspace; depending on the context, it thus has to be interpreted as a set of vectors or points. Considered as a map between vector subspaces, the map pi is obviously generated by the canonical projection p-.feV^f
+W
eV/W,
hence it is surjective. Since its kernel is W, we have for the zero vector 0 G V/W the preimage p^^{0) = W, and this is the nopoint in ^ " / A ' ^ . Thus the map (11) is also injective. Obviously, it preserves the relation C and, in addition, satisfies
p{Bi)Vp{B2)=p{BiVB2). Therefore, it is a coUineation as well, where the relative dimension in the pencil has to be taken into account: Dimrel(B) : = D i m B - A ; - l .
(12)
Furthermore, A is the pencil of hyperplanes in P " containing A . For any of these hyperplanes, u = [u], we have u\W = 0, and vice versa. Hence, u(j; + W) := u(j;) is a well-defined linear form on V/W. The map u e W 1-^ fi G (V/Wy is hnear and has kernel o; thus it is injective and, since the dimensions of both spaces coincide, dim W = dim V/W = n — k, it yields a canonically defined linear isomorphism, W^ = {V/Wy,
W (ZV & subspace, AimV < oo.
This immediately implies the second assertion.
(13) D
E x a m p l e 3. In order to illustrate Proposition 2, which may appear a bit formal at first glance, we recall the heuristic description for the projective plane from Example 1.1. There we defined the projective plane by means of the pencil of all rays through a point, cf. Fig. 1.1. The relative dimension of a line as an object in the pencil is zero; they are the "points" of the pencil. Intersecting the pencil with support A by a plane H not passing through A, the assignment h:xeH<—>h{x):=xV
AeP'^/A
(14)
is a projectivity; in Example 1.1 we had n = 3. In the general case of a pencil in an arbitrary P " with support A one has to choose an (n — A; — l)-plane
1.6 Duality
73
complementary to A as H; H is called a section (or a complete system of representatives) for the pencil P " / A . In fact, the m a p S : X G * P " / A I — > s{X):=X
AH
CH
(15)
is the inverse of the m a p between the lattices of projective subspaces defined by h. T h e m a p (14) transfers the (n—A; —l)-dimensional projective geometry from H to the pencil through A. Transferring a homogeneous coordinate system from H onto the pencil h can be represented as assigning equal coordinates. Hence it is a projectivity. If / : F ^ P"'/A is an analogous projectivity from another [n — k — l)-plane F complementary to A onto the pencil with support A , then f^^ oh : H ^ F defines a projectivity generahzing the construction of the central projection in Example 1.2, Fig. 1.3. For this reason, we call it the central projection from H onto F with center A. Denoting by q the central projection from P" onto the subspace F with center A defined in Example 3.1, we h a v e / " ^ o/i = i^lH". D 1.6.4 D u a l M a p s For a linear m a p a : V ^ W the associated dual map a' : W' -^ V' is defined by the following well-known formula: (a'(w)lj:) := (W|a(j:)),
^eV,roeW',
cf. Definition 1.5.2, where a' was caUed the m a p transposed to a. For the applications in projective geometry a slight generalization of this notion will be needed. RecaU, (cf. Definition II.7.2.7), t h a t a m a p a : K ^ L between skew fields is called an anti-isomorphism if a is an isomorphism for the additive groups of the skew fields and, moreover, a(al3) = a(l3)a(a). A m a p a : V ^ W from the right vector space V over K into the left vector space W over L is called a-linear if we have a{fa + t)/3) = a{a)a{f)
+ o-(/3)a(t)),
^,t)eV,a,l3eK,
where a : i f ^ L is an anti-isomorphism. It satisfies a(j; a/3) = o-(/3)o-(a)a(j;), p, G V , a, /3 G K. (There is an analogous definition for maps a from a left into a right vector space.) D e f i n i t i o n 1. Let V be a right vector space over the skew field K, let W be a right (or left, respectively) vector space over the skew field L,\et a : K ^ L be an isomorphism (or anti-isomorphism, respectively) of the skew fields, and let, finally, a : V ^ W he a-linear. Then the m a p a' : W' -^ V' defined by (a'(w)|j:):=a-i((w|a(j:))), or(a»|y):=a-i((a(y)|w)) is called the dual map to a.
^eV,roeW',
(16) (17) D
74
1 Projective Geometry
In Equation (17) we reversed the order in which the vector t) (^ W and the covector tn G W enter the canonical scalar product (t)|tti), since this way W' becomes a right vector space. The following is straightforward from the definitions. Lemma 3. Equations (16) or (17), respectively, define a a^^-linear
a' -.W -> v.
map
a
This lemma suggests the following definition: Definition 2. In the notations of Definition 1, let P " and Q™ be the projective spaces associated with the vector spaces V"+^ and W™^^ over the skew fields K and L, respectively. Moreover, let / : P " -^ Q™ be a colhnear map induced by the a-linear map a : V ^ W. Then the collinear map / ' : <5o™ -^ P Q " induced by the dual a^^-linear map a' is called the dual collinear map associated with the map f. • The following proposition contains an interesting application of the dual map: Formula (18) proved below, written a bit differently in the form
shows the possibility to express the inverse images of the coUinear map / through the images of / ' . Proposition 4. Under the assumptions and in the notations of Definition 2, the dual collinear map f is independent of the choice of the map a inducing f, and, moreover, f-\H)^=f'{H^),
He^{W^+').
(18)
P r o o f . Consider the case that Vt^ is a left vector space and (17) holds. Let U C W be an arbitrary subspace. We wiU then prove the equation a-\U^) = a!{U)^.
(19)
In fact, p G a^^{U ) if and only if a(p) G U , and this is the case if and only if every tn G L/" satisfies the equation (a(p)|tti) = 0. By Definition 1, this is equivalent to (a'(tti)|p) = a^^{a{f)\vo) = 0 for ah vo e U, hence p G a'{U)^. Since a induces the map / , we obtain for the projective subspaces
f-\U^)=a'{U)^=f'{U)^, so that / ' only depends on / , and is independent of the chosen inducing map a. Setting U = H in the last equation and applying _L we arrive at Equation (18). D Proposition 4 justifies the definition of the dual colhnear map / ' . The following properties are immediate.
1.7 Correlations (/')' = /,
{fogy
75 (20)
= g'of'.
(21)
Exercise 6. Let / ' be the map dual to / : P " ^ Q™ . Prove: a) X L f'{H)^^
f{x) L H
{xeP",
H eQ""),
/'-i(o')=/(P")^=r(/(P")).
(22) (23)
b) / determines a coUineation / from the pencil ^ " / / ^ ^ ( o ) onto the projective geometry of the image / ( P " ) : f:Xe
W r \ o )
^
f{X)
:= f{X)
e *P(/(P"),
and applying the canonical cr^^-bijection alV)' = W'/a(V)^
yields
(/)' = (?)•
(25)
E x a m p l e 4. In the notations of Definition 1 suppose t h a t a : V " + is bijective. The contragredient map to a is defined as a* := (a-y Obviously, a* = {a')-^ we have
(24)
: V -^ W.
-^ Vt^"+
(26)
(cf. Exercise 11.7.2.12). (18) implies: For ah B e * P ( F ) r{B^)
= f{B)^,
(27)
where / * denotes the coUineation induced by a*. Setting M = B (27) can also be written in the form
equation
r ( M ) = (/(M^))^. Thus it is clear t h a t the contragredient m a p does not yield anything essentially new for projective geometry. For all B G ^{V), the set f{B)
=
{f{x)\xeB}
is the image of B as a point set, and, dually, f*{B^)
= {f*{W-^)\W-^
D B}
is the image of B as the support of a pencil of hyperplanes.
•
1.7 Correlations In this chapter we will place special emphasis on the lattice structure of the projective geometry ^ " . According to Exercise 3.5 coUineations can be characterized as monotonously increasing bijections F : ^ " -^ Q " between projective geometries whose inverse F^^ is monotonously increasing as well. T h e dualistic structure of projective geometries suggests to consider monotonously decreasing maps likewise.
76
1 Projective Geometry
1.7.1 Definition. Canonical Correlation Definition 1. Let F : ^ " , Q™ be (right or left) projective geometries over the skew fields K and L, respectively. A bijective map F : ^ " -^ Q™ is called a correlation if it satisfies the following condition: AcB-^=^
F{A) D F{B), A,Be
*P",
i.e., if F and F^^ both are monotonously decreasing.
(1) D
Example 1. Forming the annihilator
_L : *P" ^ *P'", _L : *p'" ^ *P"
(2)
is a correlation from a right to a left (or from a left to a right) projective geometry that we will call the canonical correlation, since it is uniquely determined by the very structure of the projective geometry. For these structural reasons we admit the obvious notational misuse. In fact, since the two maps considered in (2) are mutually inverse, strictly, we would have to distinguish -Lqj from -Lqj' and to write J-qj' = -^qy'-' As the correlations are anti-isomorphisms for the lattice structures, the characterization of /\ as the infimum and that of \/ as the supremum lead to the following rules: Fi/\A,)
= \jFiA,),
Fi\jA,)
= /\FiA,),
A, G *p".
(3)
Now we ask under which conditions there exists a correlation between two projective geometries. Since for n = 1 the order C is rather useless — each bijection F : *P^ -^ Q^ with F{o) = Q^ and F{P^) = o is a correlation — we will suppose n > 2, as a rule. First we note two facts immediately following from the definition. Corollary 1. The composition FoG of two correlations is a collineation. The composition of a correlation and a collineation is a correlation. • In order to discuss the existence question, consider two right projective geometries; if one of the geometries is a left one, then by Example II.7.2.14 we may pass to the opposite skew field and vector space, and this way reduce everything to the case of right geometries. Proposition 2. Let ^ " , Q™ be right projective geometries over the skew fields K and L, respectively, n > 2. There exists a correlation F : ^ " -^ Q™ if and only ifn = m and if, in addition, there is an anti-isomorphism a : K ^ L. If both these conditions are satisfied, then each correlation F : ^ " -^ Q " has the form F = JL o G, where G : ^ " -^ Q ' " is a collineation induced by a a-linear bijection, where a runs through the set of all anti-isomorphisms from K onto L.
1.7 Correlations
77
P r o o f . Let F : ^ " -^ Q™ be any correlation. According to Example 1 and Corollary 1, G := _L o _F is a collineation from the right projective geometry ^ " over K onto the left projective geometry Q'™ over L. Let L denote the skew field opposite to L, and denote by Q ' the right projective geometry t h a t arises by passing to the opposite module structure W over the vector space W associated with Q ' . Since the lattices Q ' and Q ' coincide, G : ^ ^ £i' is a collineation of right projective geometries. Hence, by Proposition 3.6 we have n = m, and from the Main Theorem 3.10 we conclude the existence of an isomorphism a : K ^ L and a a-linear m a p a : V ^ W inducing G due to G([j;]) = [a(j;)]. Returning now to the original structures, because of a{a • f3) = a{a) x
= a ( A ) ^ , A e *P";
(5)
a is called a a-linear m a p inducing F. a : K ^ L is an isomorphism or an anti-isomorphism depending on whether V and W are opposite or like vector spaces. By Proposition 2 the m a p F is a correlation if a is a a-linear bijection (in the case n > 2); in case n = 1, we always suppose t h a t correlations are correlative bijections. • For brevity, we only formulated an algebraic definition for correlative maps; it is clear t h a t , just as colhnear maps (cf. Section 1.3.1), they should also have a geometric definition. Composing them, instead, with the canonical correlation and, this way, reducing the situation to the case of collinear maps turns out to be easier. By Proposition 2, every correlation is a correlative m a p as well. Obviously, each correlative m a p is monotonously decreasing: A c B
implies F{A)
D F{B),
A, Be
*p".
(6)
78
1 Projective Geometry
Exercise 2. Let F : ^ " -^ £3™ be the correlative map induced by the cr-linear map a : V ^ W'. Prove that if ai : \^ ^ W' is a ui-linear map also inducing F, then there is /it G K* such that (4) holds. E x a m p l e 2. Let F : ^ " -^ Q " be a correlation. Proposition 2 with G := J- o F implies for each A;-plane H G ^ " : BiinF{H'')
= Biin{G{H'')^)
= n - k - l .
In particular, the image of a line H is an (n — 2)-plane, and the set of points incident with H is transformed into the pencil of hyperplanes incident with F{H^). By Exercise 6.4, these hyperplanes are m a p p e d into the "points" of a line L, on which, consequently, a C R is defined. For a correlation to be projective, i.e. to preserve the CR, it is necessary t h a t K = L and a = i d ^ ; moreover, if ^ " and Q " b o t h are right projective geometries, then K has to be a field, in addition. D E x a m p l e 3 . Let i f = L = R be the field of real numbers. Then there is just the isomorphism a = idpt, cf. Exercise L2.1.3). Each correlative m a p F : *P" ^ Q™ is thus induced by a hnear m a p a:V^W'. D E x a m p l e 4. In the case of complex numbers, K = L = C, as for collineations, we confine ourselves to the continuous automorphisms of C, cf. Example 4.3. Accordingly, there are two types of correlative maps: Taking a = i d c we obtain the (proper) correlative maps, and choosing the conjugation as a leads to the anti-correlative maps. • E x a m p l e 5. Let K = L = ii he the skew field of quaternions, and let ^ " be a right projective geometry over H . If Q™ is another right projective geometry over H , and the correlative m a p F : ^ " -^ Q™ is induced by a
= m — 1 •^=> x = [p] and p ^ K e r a .
(8)
1.7 Correlations
79
More generally, the kernel of F defined by Ker F := Kera is a projective subspace of dimension D i m K e r F = n — rka. (9) If rka = 0, i.e. KevF = P " , then F is called the correlative null map; it is characterized by F{A) = Q™ for all A G ^ " . For any correlative map F and each projective subspace H G ^ " we have DimF(H') = m - D i m H ' + Dim(H'AKerF).
(10)
Note that, in this relation, F{H) appears as the support of the hyperplane pencil T{F{H))
= {F{x)\x
e
H};
in particular, F is surjective if and only if F{P") = o. Definition 3. Let F : ^ " -^ Q™ be a correlative map induced by the
F'{X)
:= a'{X)^
G *P".
(11) D
Proposition 3. Let F : ^ " -^ Q™ be correlative. Then the dual map F' does not depend on the choice of the a-linear map a inducing F. Moreover, F'(g™) = KerF, F o F'{Y) DY, F'O (F'y = F.
F{X)
D
X, for Y G Q™, X e *p",
(12) (13) (14)
/ / F is a correlation, then F'= F-\
(15)
P r o o f . The first statement follows from Proposition 6.4. Furthermore, by (11) with X = g™ and (6.19) with U = W we have F'iQ"") = a'{W)^
= Kera = KerF.
The first relation in (13) also follows from the definitions using (6.19), FiF'iY))
= (a(a'(Y)^))^ = ( a ( a - i ( Y ^ ) ) ) ^ D Y,
since a{ar^{Y )) CY . The second part of (13) is a consequence of the first combined with equation (14), which immediately follows from Definition 3. If F is a correlation, then this is also true of F', and, for dimensional reasons, equality has to hold in both parts of (13), implying (15). •
80
1 Projective Geometry
1.7.3 i^-Correspondences and cr-Biforms Now we want to express correlative maps in terms of the points x G P " , y G <5™. To this end, we start with the fohowing definition. Definition 4. Let F : ^ " -^ Q™ be a correlative map. Then the pair (x, y) G P " X <5™ is said to correspond under the map F, or to belong to the F-correspondence if y iF{x). D Corollary 4. F-correspondences have the following properties: a) The set {y G Q^\y iF{x)} is the hyperplane F(x) C Q™ considered as a point set, if x ^ Ker F, and it is the whole space Q™, if x ^ K e r F . h) In general, yiF{x)^^XiF'{y)(16) hence for fixed y the set {x G P^\y iF{x)} is the hyperplane F'{y) C P " considered as a point set, if y ^ F(P"), and all of P", otherwise. • >From now on, we will again suppose that if = L is an arbitrary skew field and a an anti-automorphism of K. Let *P" = *P(F"+i), Q™ = *P(VF™+^) be projective geometries associated with right vector spaces over K, and let F : ^ " -^ Q™ be a correlative map induced by the a-linear map a : V ^ W'. Then we define 6(y,t)):=(a(y)|t)), fet))GFxVF. (17) L e m m a 5. The map h : V x W ^ properties: a) b is linear in t), i.e.
K defined by (17) has the following
6(p, t)a + 1(3) = 6(p, t))a + 6(p, j)/?, b) b is a-linear in p, i.e. b{^a + u/3, t)) = cr(a)6(y, t)) + cr(/3)6(u, t)).
(18) D
Definition 5. Let V, W be right vector spaces over the skew field K. The map b : V X W ^ K is called a biform or, more precisely, a a-biform if it has properties a) and b) from Lemma 5. • Bilinear or hermitian forms are examples of a-biforms. In the literature, instead of a-biforms the term sesqui-linear form is frequently used. If ai : V ^ W' is a map that also induces the correlative map F, then (4) holds (cf. Exercise 2), and ai determines the ai-biform 6i(y, t)) := (ai(p)|t)) = a(/i)6(p, t)).
(19)
1.7 Correlations
81
Two biforms b, 61 differing only in a factor v G K* will be called proportional. If 6 is a (T-biform, and 61 = lyb is proportional to 6, then 61 is a ai-biforni with (Ti(a) = i/(T(a)i/^ . Obviously, each biforni 6 7^ 0 uniquely determines the corresponding anti-automorphism of K. Biforms are particularly well suited to describe correlative maps as correspondences: Proposition 6. For each correlative map F : ^ " -^ Q™ between right projective geometries over the same skew field K there exists a biform b : V X W ^ K, which is uniquely determined up to proportionality, such that M iFm ^^ 6(y, t)) = 0, (y, t))eVxW. (20) Conversely, according to (20), to each class of mutually proportional biforms there corresponds a correlative map F : ^ " -^ Q™. P r o o f . The first part of the assertion follows from Lemma 5 combined with the argument leading to (19). If, conversely, 6 is a biform, then it defines a
a(y)(t)) := 6(y, t)), t) G W.
(21)
But proportional biforms define the same correlative map. In the above notations, CoroUary (4) and (20) immediately imply y,F(a;)^^6(j:,t)) = 0 ^ ^ a ; . F ' ( y ) ,
• (22)
so that we can also describe the dual correlative map by b. On the other hand, applying (17) to the dual map a' we see that, because of (6.16), the transposed biform corresponds to F', 6'(t),y):=a-i(6(y,t))), {T,t))eVxW.
(23)
In fact, we have (a'(t))|p) = cr^-^((a(p)|t))). Obviously, b' is a^-^-linear in t) and linear in p. Next we want to describe the representation of correlative maps in homogeneous coordinates. Consider a pair of dual bases,
(Oi), (a^'), iai\a^) = Sf, i,j = 0,...,n, {b^)Ab^), {b^\b^) = Si a,/3 = 0,...,m, determining coordinate systems on P " and Q™, respectively. Here we will write the coordinates (x*) of a vector p as a column and those of a dual vector as a row; the sum convention will again be used. The matrix (ojo,) describing the (T-linear map a : V ^ W is defined by a(Oi) = ttjab", « = 0 , . . . , n, a = 0 , . . . ,
TO.
(24)
If the coordinates of p G V and u = a(p) G W are (x*) and (««), respectively, then
82
1 Projective Geometry Ma = o-(x*)ajo,;
(25)
(MQ,) are the homogeneous coordinates for the hyperplane F(x) corresponding to the point x = [p] with homogeneous coordinates (x*). At the same time, (ttjo,) G Mn^i^m+iiK) is the matrix of the a-biform b corresponding to F: 6(p, t)) = (a(p)|t)) = a{x')aiay",
ai^ = b{ai, ba).
(26)
Here, (y") are the coordinates of t). For the m a p F' dual to F a straightforward calculation using (24) and (6.16) yields a'(ba) = aLil* = <7^\a,io,)a\
(27)
i.e., the matrix (a^^) of a' coincides with the transposed of the matrix obtained by transforming t h a t of a by means of a^^:
K.) = (^"'Ka))'-
(28)
Exercise 3 . Let {aia) be the matrix of the correlative map F : ^ " -^ Q™ according to (24). Prove the relation Dim Ker _F = n — r, Dim Ker _F = m — r,
(29)
where r is the rank of {aia) (cf. Exercise II.7.3.7). This implies that r does not depend on the chosen coordinates; the integer r is called the rank of F. Exercise 4 . Let ^ := ^ ( ^ " , Q ™ ) denote the set of all correlative maps from *P" to Q " . Consider the action of the group G := PL{P") x PL{Q'^) of pairs of projectivities on VB defined by
(fli,fl2) e G, F e * 8 H^(72oFo(7-i e * 8 .
(30)
Prove that two correlative maps F, F E ^ are equivalent under this action of G if and only if they have equal rank and determine the same class a in the group Aut{K)/lnt{K), cf Exercise 4.11 and (4). T h e following proposition will allow to define the restriction auto-correlative m a p F : ^ " -^ ^ " to a subspace A C P " :
F\A
of an
P r o p o s i t i o n 7. Consider *P" = * P ( F " + i ) , A G *P" with A = n{W) for a subspace W C V of the vector space V. Let F : ^ " -^ ^ " be an autocorrelative map induced by the a-linear map a : V ^ V'. Then xeA^F\A{x):=F{x)AAcA defines an auto-correlative
map F\A ^eW^a{^)\W
If b is a a-biform
(31)
that is induced by the a-linear eW.
describing F, then the restricted b^ := b\W X W
describes the restriction
F\A.
map (32)
a-biform (33) D
1.7 Correlations
83
T h e proof immediately follows from the above definitions. Looking at examples it is obvious t h a t F\A may well be the correlative zero m a p , even for KevF = o (cf. also Section 1.10 below). A notion dual to itself is t h a t of a mixed throw: D e f i n i t i o n 6. Let ^ " , n > 2, be a projective geometry over the skew field K, let a,b e ^ " be points, and let C,D e ^ " be hyperplanes, a ^ b, C ^ D. Set c := C A ( a V 6), d:= D A{aV b). The quadruple (a, b, C, D) is called a mixed throw if (a, b, c, d) is a throw. T h e cross ratio of the mixed throw is defined as (cf. L. Heffter [48], §18) {a,b;C,D)
•.= {a,b;c,d).
(34) D
Exercise 5. Under the assumptions of Definition 6 show the following: A quadruple (a, b, C,D) is a mixed throw if and only if {A,B,C, D) is a throw of hyperplanes, where A := a V (C A _D), B := 6 V (C A _D) (cf. Exercises 6.3, 6.4). In addition, for the CR we have {a,b;C,D)
= {A,B;C,D).
(35)
Exercise 6. Let ^ " , Q™, n > m > 2, be right projective geometries over the skew field-R"; moreover, let {a,b,C,D) and {ai,bi,Ci,Di) be mixed throws in ^ " and Q™, respectively. Prove that there is a projective map F : ^" -^ Q™ with F{a) = ai, F{b) = bi, F{C) = C i , F{D) = Di, if and only if their CRs coincide: (a,b;C,D)
= (ai,bi;Ci,Di).
(36)
Exercise 7. In the notations of Exercise 6 with the additional assumptions that n = m and K is a field, show the following: There is a projective correlation F:^" ^Q" with F{a) = Ci, F{b) = Di, F{C) = ai, F{D) = bi, if and only if (36) holds.
84
1 Projective Geometry
1.8 Symmetric Auto-Correlative Maps In this section we will study auto-correlative maps F : ^ " -^ ^ " . Such a m a p is called symmetric if it coincides with its dual, i.e., if F = F'.
(1)
This name is suggested by the fact t h a t the associated ^-correspondence is a symmetric relation over P": By (7.16) F is symmetric if and only if X iF{y)^^y
iF{x),x,yeP:;.
(2)
There are two types of symmetric auto-correlative maps: the null systems and the polar maps. Now we are going to obtain a projective classification of these maps; for the null systems this will be completely accomphshed in this paragraph, whereas for the polar maps we will achieve a classification of important special cases in the next paragraph. Null systems form the basis for symplectic geometry; we will also interpret t h e m geometrically as linear line complexes. Remarks concerning the terminology. The obvious name "symmetric" for property (1) appears to have rarely (or even never?) been used until now. The reader may forgive us, that we add still another one to the various names already to be found in the literature. The name "reflexive" chosen by J. Dieudonne [36], § 1.6, does not seem very fortunate to us, since the associated F-correspondence is reflexive only for the null systems (compare Deflnition 1.0.2.7, Property 1, with Deflnition 1 below). W. Burau [24] calls the correlative maps satisfying (1) "involutory", even though by 7.3, (7.15), only the symmetric correlations share the property FoF = idojn characterizing involutions; these symmetric correlations are called "polar maps" by R.Baer ]5], thereby possibly making the notational confusion complete. On the other hand, R. Baer uses the name "dual map" instead of correlation, and "self-dual map" instead of auto-correlation, so that we preferred to avoid the obvious name "auto-dual" for (1). 1.8.1 N u l l S y s t e m s a n d P o l a r M a p s D e f i n i t i o n 1. Let F : ^ " -^ ^ " be a symmetric correlative m a p . T h e points in the kernel, x G Ker F, are called singular and the remaining ones, X ^ K e r F , regular points of F] a point x ^ K e r F is called a pole of the hyperplane F{x), and F{x) the polar of x for the correlative m a p F. An element X e ^ " is caUed auto-polar if X tF{X). Let QF C P " denote the set of auto-polar points of F. If Qp = P " , then F is caUed a null system; otherwise, F is a polar map. Moreover, we will call F non-degenerate if Ker F = o, i.e., if F is a correlation; a polar correlation is a polarity . • Note t h a t , according to Definition 7.2, every auto-correlative m a p F is induced by a semi-linear m a p a : V ^ V'. Obviously, the polar of a regular
1.8 Symmetric Auto-Correlative Maps
85
point is uniquely determined; conversely, for the pole this only holds in the case of a non-degenerate F: li x ^ Ker F, then every point y G (a; V Ker F)\ Ker F is a pole of F^x); in fact, P " 7^ F{y) D F{x) A F(KerF) = F{x). Corollary 1. An auto-correlation F : ^ " -^ ^ " is symmetric if and only if it is involutive: F^ = idqj^ . P r o o f . The assertion immediately follows from Definition (1) and (7.15): F = F' = F-K D The symmetric correlations F thus are the involutions in projective geometry *P": The equality A = F{B) holds if and only ii B = F{A); in this case, A, B are called mutually polar under F. For the dimensions of a polar pair we have (cf. Example 7.2) m\nA
= k-i=^m\nF{A)=n-k-l.
(3)
By means of the following proposition, the symmetric correlative maps will be reduced to the symmetric correlations: P r o p o s i t i o n 2. Let F he a symmetric correlative map of the projective geometry ^ " . Then Kei F = F{P"), (4) and, moreover, Kei F c F{A) for all A eV''-
(5)
F determines the symmetric correlation of the bundle of subspaces through KeiF: F : X G * P " / K e r F i — > F{X) e ^"/Ker F. (6) P r o o f . By Proposition 7.3, (7.12), (4) holds because of F = F'. By (7.6), Equation (5) for A C P " foUows from (4). Now recaU the definition of the projective bundle geometries. Section 1.6.3. Because of (5), the map F is well-defined. Let F be induced by the a-linear map a : V ^ V' with Ker F = Ker a =: W; then F is induced by the canonically associated, a-linear bijection a : V/W -^ (V/W)' = W^ that is defined by iaiT+W)\t)
+ W):=iaiT)\t)).
(7)
We still have to show that F is symmetric, i.e. (F)' = F. By definition of the dual map, 6.1, (6.16), it is induced by the dual semi-linear map, which is (T^^-linear: ((a)'(j: + W)\t) + W)=
a-\iait)
+ W)\T+ W)) = a-i((a(t))|j:)) = (a'(y)|t)).
Since F is symmetric, the dual semi-linear map a' also induces F. Hence, according to the uniqueness statement in the Main Theorem 3.10, (3.17),
86
1 Projective Geometry
there is yU G i f * such t h a t a'(p) = a{iij). Inserting this into the last equation yields ((a)'(y +W)\^
+ W) = (a(yM)|t)) = {h{w +W)\^
i.e., (a)'(p + W) = a((p + W)i^),
+
W),
implying the symmetry of F.
D
1.8.2 E q u i v a l e n c e of A u t o - C o r r e l a t i v e M a p s Now we define the projective equivalence of two auto-correlative maps: D e f i n i t i o n 2. Two auto-correlative maps Fa, a = 1,2, of the projective geometries ^ " are called projectively equivalent, Fi ^ F^, if there is a projectivity gr :
(8) D
Again, we may and will consider only the case ^ " = ^ 2 = ^ ( ^ ) - Let ai : V ^ V be a ai-linear m a p inducing Fi, and let the linear transformation c G G L ( V ) induce the projectivity g; by c* := c'^^ we denote the transformation contragredient to c. Since (c*t)|cy) = (t)|y),
(9)
we obtain c ( X ) ^ = c*{X^),
c{Y^)
= c*{Y)^,
XCV,Y
cV.
(10)
Because of (8) and (10) the likewise ai-linear m a p c* o a i o c^^ induces the m a p F2; in fact, c* o a i o c-\X)^
= c*(ai(c-i(X)))^ = c(ai(c-i(X))^) = 3 0 ^ 0
g-\X),
cf. (7.5). According to the uniqueness statement in the Main Theorem 3.10 we know: If 0,2 is any (T2-linear m a p inducing F2, then Fi '~ F2 if and only if there are c G G L ( V ) and 1^ e K* such t h a t 02 = c o a i o c "^ o d ^ and 0-2 = o"! o o - u ^
(H)
here d^i denotes the dilation by the factor jj, in V, and
(12)
1.8 Symmetric Auto-Correlative Maps
87
hence there has to be a projectivity transforming the associated correspondences into one another. Choosing a basis (Oj) in V and denoting by (7*j), (ttij), and (bij), respectively, the matrices of c^^, 61 and 62 with respect t o this basis, then (12) and (7.26) immediately imply the corresponding properties of these matrices (Note again the sum convention!):
«(ai,-) = (^2(7^))'(&fcO(7S-)-
(13)
Formulas (12) and (13) are generahzations of the transformation rules (1.5.9.45) and (1.5.9.81) for bilinear and Hermitean forms, respectively. These considerations apply to an arbitrary correlative m a p F from ^ " to itself; by Proposition 7.6, (7.23), the symmetric correlative maps are characterized by the condition «6(t),j:)=a-i(6(j:,t))),
(14)
or, in matrix form, by «(«ij) = (c^ H^ij))'-
(15)
Apart from the symmetric bilinear forms, the Hermitean biforms and matrices, respectively, are special cases, cf. (1.5.9.77). T h e correlative m a p F is nondegenerate if there is no p G V , p 7^ 0, such t h a t 6(j;, t)) = 0 for all t) e V; biforms with this property are also called non-degenerate. Exercises 7.3 and 7.4 immediately yield the following necessary condition for projective equivalence: C o r o l l a r y 3. Projectively equivalent correlative maps from ^ " to itself have equal rank. Such a map is a correlation if and only if it is non-degenerate, i.e. its rank is n+ I. D Exercise 1. Let Fa, a = 1,2, be symmetric, auto-correlative maps of the projective geometries ^ ^ . Prove that -Fi ~ F2 if and only if the correlations Fi, F2 associated with them according to Proposition 2 are projectively equivalent. (Hint. Consider subspaces Aa e ^ ^ complementary to KeiFa; identify ^{Aa) with ^^/KeiFa by means of
B e^iAa)^^BVKej:Fa
e*P::/KerF„,
and reahze the Fa as correlations of ^ ( A Q , ) . )
1.8.3 Classification of Null Systems Let now F be a null system. If 6 7^ 0 is a a-biform defining F, then for all ^ e V the relation 6(y,y)=0 (16) has t o hold, from which, by inserting p + t) for p, we immediately obtain 6(p,t))+6(t),y)=0.
(17)
88
1 Projective Geometry
Since 6 7^ 0, by the linearity in t) we find a pair (p^, t)g) e V x V with 6(y„,t)J = l.
(18)
As 6 is a cr-biform, (17) and (18) imply K?oC, t)o) = ^ ( 6 = -K^o,
?oC) = e
for aU ^ e K. Hence a = id^, if is a field, and b has to be an alternating bilinear form over V, cf. Proposition 7.6 and Definition 1.5.9.3. Thus we arrive at (cf. also Exercise 1.5.9.13) Lemma 4. An alternating bilinear form on a finite-dimensional vector space V over the field K always has even rank 2r. There is a basis (Oj) of V with respect to which the matrix (bij) of b has quasi-diagonal form with r block matrices
0 r -1 0 along the principal diagonal, and zeroes everywhere else (cf (I.5.9.82)J; /f 0 11\ ^ ^\ o o -1 0 0 1 o o o -1 0
ih
(19)
V
o o
o
0 1 -1 0
o
P r o o f . Because of (16), the assertion is trivial in the case dim V = 1: Since 6 = 0, we have rk6 = 0. For d i m V = 2 the assertion follows from (18): In case 6 = 0 we have r = 0, and for 6 7^ 0 we set Oi = po, O2 = t)o- Suppose that we already found vectors Oi,..., 02fc € V such that
6(o2j-i,a2j) = -b{a2j,a2j-i) = 1 for j =
l,...,k,
6(0i, a;) = 0 for i,l = 1, .. ., 2k, \i - l\ y^ 1. Consider the hnear span W'^'' := £ ( o i , . . . , 02fc) and its orthogonal complement W •.= {^e F|6(t),?) = 0 for aU t) G W}. Since 6| Vt^ x Vt^ is non-degenerate, we have W DW = {0}, and a straightforward consideration of ranks implies dim W = dim V—2A;. Hence V = W(BW. lib\W xW = 0, then we complete Oi,..., 02fc by means of an arbitrary basis of W to obtain a basis for V. This leads to the normal form (19) with k = r.
1.8 Symmetric Auto-Correlative Maps
89
Otherwise, we find vectors a2k+i,0^2k+2 & W with b{a2k+i,0^2k+2) = 1 and proceed hke before. • Lemma 4 and what was said before immediately lead to the projective classification of all nuU systems: P r o p o s i t i o n 5. Let ^ " be an n-dimensional projective geometry over the skew field K, n > 2. There exists a null system F o / ^ " with rkF > 0 if and only if K is a field. The biforms determining a null system F are bilinear, alternating and of even rank. Two null systems are protectively equivalent if and only if they have the same scalar field K and equal rank. Non-degenerate null systems only exist for projective geometries of odd dimension. P r o o f . Apart from what was just said it suffices to note t h a t nuU systems of equal rank also have coinciding normal forms (19). Choosing bases for Fi, F2 in which each has normal form, and then assigning corresponding vectors defines a linear isomorphism mapping the null systems into one another. Hence it provides the projective equivalence g in (8). T h e converse is obvious by Corollary 3. • 1.8.4 Linear Line C o m p l e x e s A geometric interpretation of null systems can be obtained by considering the Graf^mann manifold Pn,i of lines in ^ " . Let F be a null system of rank 2r > 0. Then the set of lines RF:={HePnAH iF{H)}
(20)
is called a linear line complex., if n > 3. Concerning the case n = 2 note Exercise 2. Exercise 2. If _F is a null system of rank 2r > 0 in the projective plane ^ , then r = 1, Kei F = Zo is a point, and ^F = T(KeiF) is the pencil of lines through Zo. No we will show t h a t Rp is the set of all connecting lines a; V y for which X is incident with F{y). L e m m a 6. / / F is a null system in ^ " , « > 3, then SiF = {xVy\x,ye^",Xy^y,x
LF{y)}.
(21)
P r o o f . For H = xV y e Sip (20) implies xV y t F{xV y) C F{x) A F{y); in fact, F is monotonously decreasing. Hence, in particular, x t F{y). Conversely, assume t h a t x t F{y). Since F is a null system, y L F{X), X LF{X), and y t F{y). Let now a : V ^ V be a linear m a p inducing F; then X = [p] and y = [t)] imply t h a t the hnear span is £(j;, t)) = H. Thus F{H) = (a(£(j;, t))))^ = £(a(j;), a(t)))^ is characterized by
90
1 Projective Geometry z=[i\e
F{H)
^ ^
(ay|3) = 0 und (atjli) = 0.
From the incidences above we conclude (ap|p) = (at)|p) = (ap|t)) = (at)|t)) = 0. Hence x t F{H), y t F{H), and, since F{H) is a projective subspace, xy y iF{H),i.e. H e^Fn For a better understanding of the concept of a linear line complex we need an embedding of the G r a £ m a n n manifold of all lines P „ , i = Gn+i,2, cf. Definition 1.1, as an algebraic submanifold of a certain higher-dimensional projective space. To obtain such an embedding we need some simple tools from exterior algebra, see e.g. II.8.3. Let A^V denote the space of aU alternating contravariant tensors of degree 2 associated with V, also called bivectors. It is generated by the splitting bivectors j;At):=j;(g)t)-t)(g)j;;
p, t ) G F .
If (Oj), « = 0 , . . . , n, is a basis for V, then the set of all bivectors Oj A Oj with 0 < i < j < n IS a basis for A^V; hence dim7lV= (n+l)n/2. Thus the associated projective space P'^{A'^V)
has dimension
2 Now let p = OjX*, t) = Ojy* be the basis representations of two vectors p, t) G V . Then we have p A t) = ^
Oi A ttjp^^ with p^^ = x^y^ - xJy\
(22)
Obviously, p A t) 7^ 0 if and only if the vectors are linearly independent. Set H = x\/ X e Pn,i for X = [p], y = [t)]. Then the coordinates p^^ of p A t) are called the Pliicker coordinates of the line H. li H = a\/ b, a = [0], b = [b] is another representation of H, then 0 V b = p V t)K for K G K* . Hence the m a p h:H
= x\/ye
Pn,i
-^ h{H)
:= [p A t)] G P^(A^V)
(23)
is correctly defined. Since each splitting bivector p A t) 7^ 0 uniquely defines the line: z = [^] e H if and only if p V t) V 3 = 0, the m a p h is injective and defines the embedding of P " ' as a manifold of points in P (A^V) we were looking for. In the case n = 2 the m a p h can be shown to be even surjective. For n > 3 this is not true. A general bivector
1.8 Symmetric Auto-Correlative Maps
91
T = i o i A ajp^^, p^^ +p^^ = 0, is splitting, i.e. has the form T = o V b for some 0, b G V if and only if its coordinates satisfy the Pliicker relations piii2pi3i _^_pi2i3 pill _^_ pish pi2i = 0 , 0 < n < ii < ^3 < n , / = 0, . . . , n .
(24)
Formula (24) is a special case of II.8.3.20. The equations (24) are not independent. For n = 3 they reduce to a simple quadratic equation defining the Pliicker quadric Q C P^iA^V^): / V 3 + / V ' + P V
= 0,
(25)
(see the next section). According to Proposition 5, the null systems F of ^ " correspond to the alternating bilinear forms & € / \ V . T h e latter are uniquely determined by F up to a factor K G if*; in other words: The null systems of ^ " are described bijectively by the points of the projective space P{/\ V). Let Uij be the homogeneous coordinates of F (or b); then we have a,ij + a,ji = 0 , «, j = 0, .. ., n,
(26)
and this implies: L e m m a 7. Let F be a null system corresponding to the alternating with coordinates aij. Then M.F consists of all lines H = xV y whose coordinates (22) satisfy the linear equation
J2aijP''=0.
2-form Pliicker
(27)
i<j
a In fact, according to Lemma 6 we have aijxy^ = 0, and (25) follows by a straightforward computation from (22) and (26). For 6 7^ 0 it is obvious from (25) t h a t a linear line complex is the intersection of the Grafimann manifold, according to (23) embedded into P ^ , with a hyperplane of P ^ . More generally, apart from the linear line complexes there are more general line manifolds, whose definition is not based on the single linear equation (25), but on a system of algebraic or even just differentiable equations. In the older literature, the geometry of the line space (for different transformation groups) is also called line geometry, and, accordingly, the terms line coordinates, line, or ray complexes etc. are used. Exercise 3 . Prove that under the canonical embedding (23) each hyperplane A C - P ^ ( / \ V) intersects the Grafimann manifold (23) in a proper subset M.:= An /i(Pn,i) / 0, and that M. = M.F for a suitable null system F of ^". Exercise 4 . Prove that for a symmetric auto-correlative map F oi ^ and any subspace A C P" the restriction F\A (cf. Proposition 7.7) is a symmetric autocorrelative map in ^ ( A ) . In particular, the restriction of a null system is again a null system.
92
1 Projective Geometry
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics In this section we consider polar maps F : ^ " -^ ^ " (Definition 8.1). First we will show that the associated correspondences can be described by (T-Herniitean biforms 6, which are generalizations both of the symmetric bilinear and the Hermitean forms. According to Definition 8.1, the set QF C P " of auto-polar points of F is a proper subset of projective space, QF T^ - P " ; this set QF will be caUed the quadric in P " determined by F. If if is a field and b is bilinear, this definition coincides with the classical one considered in § 1.5.9. In this case, a quadric is the set of points whose coordinates satisfy a quadratic equation of the form (1.5.9.1). Since projective geometry is described by means of homogeneous coordinates, the homogeneous equations occurring are of second degree: If a point with coordinates (x*) is a solution, then for any ^ & K the point with coordinates (x*)^ is a solution as weU. Hence, in a projective geometry over the field K with a = id^ the equation for a quadric in P " corresponding to (1.5.9.1) has the form n
where not all coefficients aij are equal to 0. Note that the upper i,j are coordinate indices and no powers. If char K ^ 2, then one may additionally assume that the coefficient matrix is symmetric; in fact, the coefficients aij may be replaced by a,ij := (aij + aji)/2 without changing the solution set. Of course, this set may well be empty. In the general case, the anti-automorphism a also comes into play, cf. (1) below. The aim of this section is to obtain a classification of polar maps and, consequently, for the corresponding quadrics in projective geometries whose scalar field are the real, the complex, or the quaternionic numbers. Starting from this classification we will introduce the most important Cayley-Klein geometries in the next chapter. 1.9.1 cr-Hermitean Biforms Let 6 be a a-biform determining F, and let (ajj) G Mn+i{K) be its matrix in a homogeneous coordinate system defined by the basis (Oj) of V"+ . Then we obtain the equation for the associated quadric QF C P " from (7.22), (7.16) (Note that the sum convention is in action!): a; = M G QF -^^ &(?,?) = 0 •<^^ a{x')aijx^
= 0 , {x y^ o);
(1)
here x* denote the homogeneous coordinates of the point x with respect to the basis (Oj), i = 0,... ,n. Definition 1. Let V be a vector space over the skew field K, and let a be an anti-automorphism of K. A a-biform b : V xV ^ K is called a-Hermitean if it satisfies
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics 6(j:,t))=a(6(t),j:)), y, t ) G F .
93 (2)
P r o p o s i t i o n 1. Let ^ " = ^^(V) be a projective geometry over the skew field K. Then: a) For every polar map F : ^ " -^ ^ " there are an anti-automorphism a of K, a a-Hermitean biform b over V determining F, and an p^ G V such that K?o,?o) = lConversely,
each a-Hermitean
biform of this kind determines
(3) a polar map F
ofV"b) The anti-automorphism involutive, i.e.
a corresponding a oa =
Because of (2), in
\AK
to a a-Hermitean
biform b ^ Q is
•
(4)
particular, a(6(y,y)) = 6fey), J G F .
(5)
P r o o f . Let bo be any biform defining F. Since F is polar, there is an Xo = [po] G P " with Xo ^ F{xo), hence A := 6O(?OJ ?O) ¥" 0- Setting b := A^^6o we obtain (3). According to Proposition 7.6, the biform b also defines F; let
K = K6(yo,yJ = cr"^(6(Po,pJ) = 1. Thus (2) immediately foUows from (8.14). Conversely, (2) is a special case of (8.14). Hence the correlation determined by b is symmetric, and due to (3) a polar m a p (Definition 8.1). b) Since b is non-zero and linear in t), for every ^ G i f one can find a pair (p, t)) G V X F with 6(p, t)) = ^. From (2) we now conclude (4): e = a(6(t),y))=a(a(6(y,t))))=aoa(e).
Exercise 1. Let F,b,a,^^ be as in Proposition 1. If 6i is a cri-biform also defining F, then 6i = Kb, where K E K is a scalar for which there is an t) e T^ with K = b{\), t)) / 0; 6i is cri-Hermitean, ai = a^^ o a, and crK(C) = KS,K^^. Conversely, if K = 6(t), t)) / 0 holds for some t) E V, then 6i = K6 is a cri-Hermitean biform also defining F. E x a m p l e 1. Let K he a field of characteristic 2 and consider V = K".
Then
94
1 Projective Geometry
is a symmetric bilinear form of rank 2 for which 6(j;, p) = 0 holds for all p G V ; hence it does not determine a polar m a p in the associated projective geometry. T h e following lemma is obtained in a way similar to the argument in the proof of Proposition 1 showing, in the case char i f ^ 2, t h a t every (T-Hermitean biform b =^ 0 defines a polar m a p . • L e m m a 2. Let K be a skew field, char K ^ 2, and letb y^O be a biform over V. Then there is an f (^ V with 6(p,p) y^ 0.
a-Hermitean
P r o o f . Assume t h a t 6(p,p) = 0 for all ^ eV. Because of 6 7^ 0, there are p, t) G V such t h a t 6(p, t)) 7^ 0; due to the linearity of 6 in t) we may suppose 6(p, t)) = 1. Then for every A G i f 0 = 6(p + t)A, p + t)A) = 6(p, t)A) + 6(t)A, p) = A + cr(A). Thus o-(A) = —A for all A G if, hence, in particular, cr(l) = 1 = —1. But this implies char i f = 2. D D e f i n i t i o n 2. Let b : V x V ^ b is the subspace
K he a-Hermitean. T h e defect subspace of
VF6:={pGF|6(p,t)) = 0 f o r a l l t ) G F } .
(6)
T h e defect of b is defined by def(6) := dim Wb.
(7)
If a is the a-linear m a p fromV to V defined by 6, and if, moreover, dim V < 00, then the rank of b is defined by the equation rk(6) : = d i m F - d e f ( 6 ) .
(8)
Obviously, the defect subspace of b is equal to Wb = Ker a = Ker F, if F denotes the polar m a p defined by 6, cf. (7.9). Hence we have rk(6) = rk(a). D 1.9.2 C l a s s i f i c a t i o n of P o l a r M a p s The following proposition can be proved in a way similar to Proposition L5.9.5: P r o p o s i t i o n 3. Let b be a a-Hermitean biform on the (n + I)-dimensional vector space V over the skew field K with char i f ^ 2. Then there is a basis (Oj) for V in which the matrix ofb has diagonal form:
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics //3oO 0 •
0\
13, r-l
b{ai,aj
95
(9)
0
Vo
0/
f^h = <J{M 7^ 0 / o r /i = 0 , . . . , r - 1; r = rk(6).
(10) D
Of course, the numbers /3ft, G i f in (9) are not uniquely determined by b. Replacing o^ by o^ = a^A^, A^ G K*, relations (9), (10) remain valid, and hence /3ft := 6(0ft,0ft) = cr(Aft)/3ftAft. (11) T h e transformation (11) can be used to obtain normal forms for polar maps and (T-biforms, respectively. These normal forms depend upon the properties of both the skew field K and the anti-automorphism a. For the classification one first has to describe all the involutive anti-automorphisms a of K, and then t o determine, for each a, corresponding normal forms for the a-Hermitean biforms b. In the subsections to foUow we wiU discuss the cases i f = R , C, H separately. Exercise 2. Let i^ be a polar map of the projective geometry ^ " , n > 2 and char if / 2. Prove: a) There are n + 1 points at e P",i = 0 , . . . ,n, such that Oi e F{aj) for i / j and ai ^ F{ai) if and only if i^ is a polarity. - b) Formulate the dual of Statement a). - c) The points ai with the properties stated in a) are in general position; choosing a projective frame {ai;e) with at as base points, the matrix of F has diagonal form (9) with r = n + 1. A simplex (a^), i = 0,... ,n, with the properties from a) is called a polar simplex for the polarity F. Exercise 3 . Let i^ be a polarity satisfying the assumptions from Exercise 2, and let ai e P", i = 0 , . . . ,n, be a sequence of points in general position. Prove that the following statements are equivalent: a) (ci) is a polar simplex;
h) Fiai) =
\/aj;
= A^(« j^i
96
1 Projective Geometry
1.9.3 T h e R e a l P o l a r M a p s As is well-known, the only anti-automorphism of the field of real numbers is the identity a = idR. Hence, by Sylvester's Law of Inertia, Proposition 1.5.9.6, polar maps are classified by their rank and index. Its projective formulation is P r o p o s i t i o n 4. Let K = H be the field of real numbers, and let ^ " be an n-dimensionalprojective geometry ower R , n > 2. Choose any basis and denote by Fr^i the polar map of ^ " whose matrix in this basis has normal form (9) (cf (i.5.9.49);, where^ fJx = - 1 , A = 0 , . . . , / - ! ; fJ^ = 1, /i = / , . . . , r - 1 , 0 < / < [r/2], 0 < r < n + 1 . (12) Denoting by x* the homogeneous point coordinates, and by yi the homogeneous hyperplane coordinates dual to them, the polar map y = Fr^i{x) has the following normal form: Vj = -x^ for j = 0,...,l1; Vk = x'' for k = I,. . .,r -1, {0
(13)
to one of the Fr^i, and no
P r o o f . According to Exercise 1.2.1.3, cf. also CoroUary 3.16, a = idR, and the biform 6 determining F has to be bilinear; moreover, because of (2) it is also symmetric. In (9), the /3ft, 7^ 0 are arbitrary. Choosing the transformation (11) with Aft := |/3ft|^^'^ and renumbering the basis elements in such a way t h a t the first / diagonal entries are equal to —1 followed by r — / times the entry 1, we arrive at Sylvester's Law of Inertia 1.5.9.6; the matrix of h has the normal form (9) with 0 < / < r. For / > [r/2] the form (12) is obtained via multiplication of 6 by K = —1 and a suitable numbering of the basis elements. Choosing again the indices in the range i = 0 , . . . , n implies t h a t each polar m a p of ^ " is projectively equivalent to one of the Fr^i. By (8.13) and Proposition 1.5.9.6, no two of the Fr^i are projectively equivalent. •
1.9.4 T h e C o m p l e x P o l a r M a p s As in the case of colhnear maps (Example 4.3), the continuity of correlative maps implies t h a t we only have to consider continuous automorphisms of the field C of complex numbers, cf. also Example 7.4. Hence there are two types of polar maps to be classified: those corresponding to a = i d c and the ones associated with the conjugation T : z ^^ z. For i f = C we agree t h a t the As usual, for 5 e R the greatest integer less than or equal to ^ is denoted by [5].
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics
97
t e r m polar map always refers to a = i d c - On the other hand, the polar maps associated with a = T will be called antipolar. Starting from (9) the proof of the analogue to Proposition 4 is straightforward. P r o p o s i t i o n 5. Two polar maps of a complex projective geometry ^ " , n > 2, with a = i d c are projectively equivalent if and only if they have equal rank r, 1 < r < n + 1. Hence the coordinate representations Fr : yj = x^ for j = 0,...
,r - I, yk = 0 for k = r,...,
provide a complete set of normal forms for these polar maps. C o r o l l a r y 6. All polarities of the complex projective with a = i d c are projectively equivalent.
geometry
n,
(14) •
^ " , n > 2, •
T h e following proposition dealing with r-Hermitean biforms and the corresponding anti-polar maps is proved along the same lines as the Law of Inertia (cf. Proposition 1.9.13). As the proof works without any change also in the case of quaternionic projective geometries, we simply combine b o t h situations into one statement. P r o p o s i t i o n 7. Let T be the conjugation in the field C of complex numbers or in the skew field H of quaternions. Denote by Fr^i the polar map of the that, , in projective geometry ^ " that in a fixed coordinate system, has the normal
form % = --xJ for 3 = 0, yk =- x'' for k =-l, yh = 0 for h =-r,
.1-1] r - 1 , (0 < r < n + l ) ; ,n,
(15)
where the matrix (9) satisfies (12). Every polar map of the projective geometry ^ " determined by a r-Hermitean biform is projectively equivalent to one of the maps Fr^i, and no two of the latter are projectively equivalent. P r o o f . According to Proposition 3 we may start from normal form (9) for the matrix of F. Because of (10), we have f3h G R*. As in the proof of Proposition 4 we obtain the diagonal form for the matrix of F with property (12). The following lemma characterizes the number / in an invariant way: L e m m a 8. Let i f = R, C, H. Take a to be the identity in the case of the real numbers, and take conjugation as a for K = C,ii. Consider a a-Hermitean form b whose matrix has the diagonal form (9) in a suitable basis (Oj). Then the number I of negative values among the diagonal entries pi is equal to the maximal dimension of a subspace W C V " for which the restriction h\W^ X W is negative-definite, i.e., 6(j;, p) < 0 for all p G W^,f ^ o.
98
1 Projective Geometry
P r o o f . Because of (2), even in t h e case i f = H we immediately have /3ft, G R . Take f3k < 0 for A; = 0 , . . . , / — 1, and /3ft > 0 otherwise. Obviously, t h e restriction of b t o t h e subspace U := £(oo, • • •, a ; - i ) spanned by Oo, • • •, a ; - i is negative-definite. Consider t h e complementary subspace B := £ ( o ; , . . . , 0„). For every subspace W C V whose dimension satisfies dimVF > / there is a vector p G BnW such t h a t p 7^ o by t h e dimension formula. Since we obviously have 6(j;, p) > 0 for all ^ e B, b cannot be negative-definite on W. D Lemma 8 implies t h a t t h e index I of 6, defined t o be t h e number of negative diagonal entries in (9), does not depend on t h e chosen basis in which b has this diagonal form. T h e same holds for t h e dimension n — r of t h e defect subspace of 6, hence also for t h e rank r. Summarizing, we arrive at t h e analogue of Sylvester's Law of Inertia L5.9.6 for r-Hermitean biforms in t h e cases i f = C , H , and complete t h e proof just as we did proving Proposition 4. D Exercise 4 . Let T^"+^ be a complex vector space, and let r be conjugation in C. A T-biform b is called skew Hermitean if it satisfies the condition 6(t),p) = -6(p,t)), p , t ) e F .
(16)
Prove: a) Each skew Hermitean r-biform determines an anti-polar map of ^"(V), that can also be described by a r-Hermitean biform. - b) Classify the skew Hermitean biforms with respect to the action (8.12) with K = 1 of the linear group of \^"+^. To this end, prove that b(j, t)) is skew Hermitean (or Hermitean, respectively) if and only if i6(p,t)) (with i^ = — 1) is Hermitean (or skew Hermitean, respectively). 1.9.5 T h e Q u a t e r n i o n i c P o l a r M a p s It is well-known t h a t t h e center of t h e skew field H of quaternions is t h e real subfield R . Denote by R ^ t h e real subspace of H spanned by t h e imaginary units i , j , k G H . First we prove: L e m m a 9. The only involutive anti-automorphisms a of the skew field H of quaternions are the conjugation T : q 1-^ q and the anti-automorphisms defined by r , ( A ) : = - < / A < / , < / G R ^ , | < / | = 1.
(17)
P r o o f . Let a be an arbitrary anti-automorphism of H . Then, according t o Example II.8.8.5, T o a has t o be an inner automorphism of H . Hence there is (/ G H*, \q\ = 1, such t h a t T o a = a^. This implies a = T o a^. Since a is involutive, we obtain for all A G H q^^qX =
Xq^^q.
Consequently, q^^q must belong t o t h e center R of H . Now || = 1 implies \q^^q\ = 1, hence q^^q = ± 1 , i.e. q = ±q. li q = q, then (/ = ± 1 G R , and o'q = i d n , thus a = T. On t h e other hand, q = —q implies q G R ^ = £R(i, j , k).
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics
99
and o-(A) = —qXq. A straightforward computation shows that each of these anti-automorphisms is involutive. • The polar maps corresponding to r-Hermitean biforms were already classified in Proposition 7. For later application, we write out the formula for such a biform over an n-dimensional vector space V^ below; according to Sylvester's Law of Inertia this is characterized by its index / and rank r and thus, in a suitable basis (Oj),« = 1 , . . . n, has the form: I
r
6(y, t)) = -J2 ^"y" + E ^V, 0 < / < r. a=l
(18)
c=l + l
Here x^,y^,i = 1 , . . . , n, are the vector coordinates of p, t) in this basis. Now we turn to the Tg-Hermitean biforms and start by noting Lemma 10. Let Tq be defined by (17). Then a biform b : V x V ^ H is Tq-Hermitean if and only if b = qb is skew Hermitean in the sense of (16). • The proof is nothing but a straightforward calculation. Since Tq = Tq = T^q, we immediately obtain Corollary 11. / / b is a Tq-Hermitean biform over V, then b := ±iqb is a T^-Hermitean biform over V. D First we consider the Tj-Hermitean biforms. Later, the general case will be reduced to this situation. A simple calculation shows: The set of fixed elements of Ti is the real subspace o / H spanned by l,j,k.' {/3GH|ri(/3)=/3} = £ R ( l , j , k ) .
(19)
Let now 6 be a Tj-Hermitean biform, and let {aj),j = 1 , . . . ,n, be a basis in which the matrix of b has the form (9). In this case, transformation (11) takes the form /3=-iAi/3A. (20) Choosing first A = |/3|^^/^, which is possible by /3 7^ 0, we obtain |/3| = 1. Thus we may already assume |/3| = 1 and henceforth only consider transformations with|A|^ = AA = 1, i.e. A = A^^. Because of (19), the element i/3 lies on the unit sphere in R^. According to Exercise II.8.9.5, each element of the special orthogonal group SO(R^) can be represented as an inner automorphism ax, |A| = 1. As is well-known, SO(R^) = SO(3) acts transitively on the unit sphere; hence we can find A such that Ai/3A = i, i.e. /3 = 1. Performing these transformations for each of the diagonal entries f3h in (9), Proposition 3 together with Corollary 11 implies Proposition 12. Let V be an n-dimensional vector space over the skew field H of quaternions, and let Tq be the anti-automorphism defined by (17). Lfb is
100
1 Projective Geometry
a Tq-Hermitean biform, then there exists a basis (a,,), v = 1,... ,n, ofY that b has the following normal form: r
such
r
6fet)) = ^ r , ( x " ) f i y " = - < ? ^ x " i y " . a=l
(21)
a=l
Here r is the rank of b, x" and y" are the coordinates of p and t) with respect to the basis (Oj/). P r o o f . By the above, for = i there is a basis with pa = qi = I for a = 1 , . . . , r, hence (21). If 6 is a Tg-Herniitean form, then CoroUary 11 imphes b = —q\b, where 6 is a Tj-Hermitean form. Bringing this into normal form we again obtain (21) for arbitrary q G H ^ , \q\ = 1. D In the notations of Proposition 12 we have the foUowing Corollary 13. / / b is a skew Hermitean biform of rank r over V, then there is a basis (Oj/) of V in which b has the normal form r
S(y,t)) = ^ x " i y " .
(22)
The proof is a consequence of (21) and Lemma 10. Note that (21) and (22) provide sets of normal forms with respect to the action (8.12) with K = 1 of the quaternionic linear group for the Tg-Hermitean and the skew Hermitean biforms, respectively; no two of these normal forms are equivalent. In fact, the rank of b is obviously invariant, and to be Tg-Hermitean or skew Hermitean, respectively, is a property preserved by any linear transformation. Combining all these results immediately leads to the classification of polar maps: Proposition 14. Let F be a polar map in the n-dimensional projective geometry ^ " over the skew field H of quaternions, n > 2. Then F is projectively equivalent to one of the maps Fr^i by Proposition 7, or F is projectively equivalent to one of the maps Jr with normal form Jr '• Va = x"" i for a = 0, . . . , r — 1; yc = 0 for c = r,... ,n] 0 < r < n. (23) In both cases, r is the rank of F, and the corresponding anti-automorphism is the conjugation T in H. NO two of these normal forms are projectively equivalent. P r o o f . According to Proposition 7.6 F can be described by aa-biform (7.20). Proposition 1 implies that a is an involutive anti-automorphism of H. By Lemma 9 the anti-automorphism a has to be either conjugation, a = T, or
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics
101
we can always require this to hold. From Proposition 12 we derive the following set of normal forms for the polar maps with a = T;: ija = Tiix"") = — ix" i for a = 0, . . . , r — 1; yc = 0 for c = r,..., n] 0 < r < n. (24) The transition to 6 = i 6 discussed in Lemma 10 leads to the skew Hermitean normal form (22) and this again to (23). No two of the normal forms (15) (with (12)) and (23) (or (24) instead) are projectively equivalent: According to Proposition 7, and because of the invariance of the rank, it suffices to show that no Tj-Hermitean biform can be transformed into a r-Hermitean biform b y^ 0 via multiplication by /i G H*, and vice versa. Let 6i = hbhe a Tj-biform. Since 6 is a r-biform, 6i is a biform with respect to the anti-automorphism C '-^ h^h^^. If this were equal to T;, then, up to an irrelevant real factor, we had h = i. But this again implied 6i(t),j;) = i6(t),j;) = i6(?,t)) = ii6(j;, t))i, hence 6i(t),j;) = —Ti(6i(j;, t))). However, this can only be Tj-Hermitean if and only if 6 = 6i = 0. D 1.9.6 Quadrics Because of Equation (1), the projective classification of polar maps immediately leads to a corresponding classification of quadrics. AUowing for some incorrectness, we will call two quadrics projectively equivalent if the polar maps defining them are related this way. It is easy to prove that equivalence of the polar maps implies equivalence of the quadrics as sets; more precisely: If Fo, Fi are two equivalent polar maps, and if <; is a polarity realizing their equivalence, i.e. Fi = gFog^^, then for the associated quadrics Qo,Qi we have the relation Qi = g{Qo). The converse of this statement, however, is, in general, not true. Consider, for example, the projective plane over the field Q of rational numbers. For every prime number p G Z the quadrics determined by the equations ( x ° ) 2 + p ( x i ) 2 = 0 a n d {xy
-p{x^f
=0
are equal. In fact, they only contain the point satisfying x'-' = x^ = 0, as can easily be seen using the prime decomposition in Q. The polar maps defining them, however, cannot be equivalent: Any polarity over the rational numbers realizing the equivalence would also be an equivalence over the real numbers, but this contradicted the Theorem of Inertia. Considering the equations over the real numbers, their solution sets are obviously not projectively equivalent: One consists of a single point, and the other is the union of two lines. Over the complex numbers the defining polar maps, and hence their solution sets as well, projectively equivalent.
102
1 Projective Geometry
R e m a r k . In the case that the scalar domain K is an algebraically closed field, e.g. the field C of complex numbers, and if the polar maps and quadrics un question are defined by a symmetric bilinear form, then the converse holds in general: //, under the assumptions above, the quadrics Q, Q corresponding to the symmetric bilinear forms b, b are equal, then the b and b are proportional. To prove this we show that the quadrics are different, if the forms are not proportional. So take a point x = [p] with 6(j;, p) = 1 (cf. (3)). If 6(j;, p) = 0, then X G Q \ Q, i.e. the quadrics are different. Hence, normalizing 6 by a suitable factor K G if * we may assume that 6(p, p) = 1 as weU. Since the forms are supposed to be not proportional, there is a vector t) such that 6(t), t)) y^ 6(t),t)). Now consider the line joining x to the corresponding point y = [t)]. It has the parametrization z(t) = [3(t)] w i t h 3 ( t ) = p + t)t. Its intersection with the quadric Q is determined by the roots ti,t2 of the quadratic equation
Hiit), iit)) = t^ + 2tK?, t)) + Kt), t)) = 0, for which tit2 = b{t), t)). Considering the intersection QOxVy we analogously obtain two parameter values ti, t2 with tit2 = Kt), t))- These roots exist, since the scalar domain is an algebraically closed field. Because of 6(t), t)) ^ 6(t), t)), they have to be different. Hence the intersections with the line x V y, and therefore the quadrics, cannot be equal. • The affine classification of quadrics can be derived by first distinguishing a hyperplane at infinity and then discussing the various position possibilities for the quadric with respect to this hyperplane. Conversely, one might start from the affine classification (cf. Proposition 1.5.9.11 for the case if = R) and then, after having passed to homogeneous coordinates, decide, which among the affine types are projectively equivalent. Example 2. Let if = R. We denote by Qr^i the quadric corresponding to the normal form Fr^i. Then the equation of the quadric Q^.o is r-l
^(x*)2 =0, 0 < r < n + l ;
(25)
i=0
hence Q^.o = Ker Frfi. Note that we never consider the nopoint o as an element of any quadric. In particular, Q„+i,o = 0 is the empty set; this is expressed by calling it the empty quadric. The set of base points for the related coordinate system a^ = [ofc], k = r,... ,n, span the kernel KerFrfi = a^ V . . . Va„, which thus, for r < n, always lies in the coordinate hyperplane x° = 0. Since this projective (n — r)-plane is now defined by the quadratic equation (25), it is usually called a double counted projective (n — r)-plane. The reason for this term is the following: Consider the family of quadrics defined by
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics
103
depending on the parameter t G R. For t ^ 0 each of these quadrics "decomposes" into the pair of hyperplanes X
0
•tx^ = 0 , x ° + t x ^ = 0 .
Letting then t tend to zero, both the hyperplanes move towards one and the same hyperplane (x°)^ = 0, which, for this reason, has to be counted twice. Let us now return to equation (25). As in Section 5 we choose the hyperplane x° = 0 as the hyperplane at infinity for an affine space A " C P " and consider, as usual, only the part AQrj := A " n Qrj as the affine quadric. In the inhomogeneous coordinates, the affine points x° = 1 from (25) satisfy the equation for AQr^: r-l
j2{xr = -1. This, obviously, has no real solution, so that for all r the affine quadric AQrfi is the empty set: The kernel KerF^.o completely lies in the hyperplane at infinity. A similar consideration shows: The quadric Q„+i,i has the equation n
-ixy + J2{x^f=0,
(26)
i=l
its section with the hyperplane at infinity x'-' = 0 is the empty quadric Qn,o, and hence it is the hyperellipsoid AQn^i^i = Q„+i,i, whose equation has the following normal form in inhomogeneous affine coordinates n
^ ( x * ) 2 = 1,
(cf. Proposition L5.9.11)
(27)
i=i
Interpreting the x* as the orthonormal coordinate of an n-dimensional Euclidean space (27) becomes the equation of a hypersphere with radius 1 and the origin of the coordinate system as its center; for n = 3 Figure 1.9 shows an ellipsoid, which is projectively, even affinely, equivalent to it. It is not difficult to prove that for n > 1 the hyperellipsoids are the only non-empty real quadrics for which there is a hyperplane not intersecting them. Hence the hyperellipsoids are the only real projective quadrics that can be represented as closed surfaces in a Euclidean space; any other non-empty quadric intersects the hyperplane at infinity, if it is considered as affine or Euclidean. For topological reasons they are, however, always compact subsets of the ambient projective space. Let now Q = Qn+i,i be a non-degenerate quadric of the n-dimensional projective space; the degenerate quadrics may always be viewed as cones over non-degenerate ones, cf. Example 4 below. We suppose that its index / is greater than one and write its equation in the form
104
1 Projective Geometry
Fig. 1.9. An Ellipsoid
Here |p| denotes the Euclidean norm in the vector space V " ^ for which the x^,i = 0,... ,n, are orthonormal coordinates. Since these coordinates are, at the same time, also homogeneous point coordinates for the associated projective space, and as the nopoint does not belong to the quadric, for arbitrary r > 0 the solution set for this equation is the product of two spheres of dimensions / — 1 and n — / of radius r with the origin as their center lying in orthogonal coordinate planes: n — lf
S^,-\r) X Sr\r) I ( ? O J ? I ) I ? O — (X
, • • • ,X
), P]^ — (X'
= >a;"),|?ol = l ? i l = r } -
Since each point x = [(POJ?I)] ^ Q has precisely two representatives in this solution set, differing in the factor ± 1 , we stiU have to identify opposite vectors in the solution set; assuming r = 1 leads to: The real, non-degenerate projective quadric Qn+i,i C P " of index I > I is bijectively represented by the quotient set l-l Q n+l,l s- X S"-'-/{±l}, I > 1. Applying straightforward topological or differential geometric considerations the bijection in question can be proved to be a homeomorphism or diffeomorphism with respect to the canonically induced structures. In the case / = 1 already considered, the first factor is 5*° = {1, —1}; choosing, say, 1 as the representative for pg the representative of the point is already uniquely determined, and we again obtain the representation of the quadric as the hypersphere (27). Fixing a homogeneous coordinate system the points x G P " of the real projective space are bijectively represented by unit vectors whose
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics
105
first coordinate is positive; this way, the projective space itself is represented as the unit hypersphere of the associated vector space with identified opposite points (cf. also Example 2.2.1): P " = S ' " / { ± 1 } , (if = R ) . Since now, in the representation of Q just described, already the first vector Po has to be non-zero, we conclude for the representation of the real nondegenerate quadrics in general Qn+i,i = - P ' " ' X S^-\
1 < / < (n + l ) / 2 .
For n = 3 we obtain apart from the ellipsoid (/ = 1) also the hyperholoid QA^2, whose affine image (cf. Fig. 2.18) has to be completed by an eUipse in the plane at infinity x^ = 0. Since the projective line itself is homeomorphic to a circle, the above representation amounts to the homeomorphy of the hyperboloid with the product S^ x S^, which is also called a torus. Figure 2.53 shows a torus embedded into the Euclidean space E as the surface with the parametrization described in (2.7.56). Obviously, the hyperboloid itself is not embedded in this way into the Euclidean (or projective) space; note t h a t each plane, hence t h a t at infinity as well, intersects the hyperboloid in a non-empty set. • Exercise 5. Prove for K = R and n = 2: li Q G A^ is one of the afRne quadrics ellipse, hyperbola, or parabola, then there is a unique projective quadric Q
^i/(?'t)) = Zl^'^'=-''^>In fact, according to Exercise 5.4 we may also identify the vector space W" := £ ( 0 i , . . . , 0 n ) of the hyperplane at infinity with the vector space of the afline geometry A". Prove that for p / 0 the polar F{x) of the point x := [Oo + p] is the hyperplane with Hessian normal form (cf. (1.6.3.37))
106
1 Projective Geometry z = [ao+3]Gf(.)^(3,^) =
^ .
For p tending to 0, the point x tends to ao, and Fix) converges to the hyperplane at infinity F{ao) = H. Example (Equation (1, i, 0 , . . . , vertices of
3 . Obviously, for K = C the quadric Q „ + i corresponding to F „ + i (25) with r = n + 1) is not empty; e.g., the point with coordinates 0) belongs to Qn+i- Again denoting by Uj = [Oj], j = 0 , . . . , n, the a polar simplex for F „ + i we obtain Cp := [a2p + a2p+i i] G Q „ + i , p = 0,...
,k := [{n - l ) / 2 ] ,
(28)
M'^ :=coV...VCfc c g „ + i . Note t h a t the restriction of the bilinear form associated with F„^i vanishes identically.
(29) to
M'' •
D e f i n i t i o n 3. Let 6 be a a-Herniitean, skew Herniitean, or alternating biform over the vector space V with the skew field K as scalar domain. A subspace W C V is called isotropic (with respect to b) if there exists p G W, p 7^ o, such t h a t for aU t) G Vt^ the equation 6(p, t)) = 0 holds; W is called totally isotropic if the restriction of b vanishes, b\W x W = 0. D C o r o l l a r y 15. Let char K ^ 2, and let b he a a-biform determining the polar map F of the projective geometry ^ " . Then a projective subspace A is contained in the quadric Qp corresponding to F if and only if the restriction of b to it vanishes, bj^ = 0, i.e., if the subspace W
we have •
C o r o l l a r y 16. Let char K ^ 2. If A is a subspace contained in the quadric QF of the polar map F, then A V K e r F also lies in Qp; in particular, KerFcQpP r o o f . If W is the vector space corresponding to A, then W is totally isotropic. Since the defect subspace (6) is also totaUy isotropic, and, in addition, b{Wi„ W) = 0, the sum W + Wf, again is totally isotropic. As the defect subspace corresponds to the kernel of F, this implies the assertion of Corollary 16. • E x a m p l e 4. Let Qp be a quadric with Ker F ^ o. Then K e r F is called the vertex space of the quadric. For char i f ^ 2, according to (16) we have X V K e r F C QF for each x G QF- For this reason, quadrics corresponding to degenerate polar maps are also called projective cones, and the maximal projective subspace contained in QF is the generator of the cone. •
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics
107
Exercise 7. Let char A" / 2, let QF be the projective cone determined by the (7-biform b, and let A be a subspace complementary to KeiF. a) Prove: QF
=
y
a; V Ker F,
xeQpnA (xWKeiF)
A {y V K e r F ) =Ker_F for x,y e QF n A,x
y^ y.
b) The restriction (of. Proposition 7.7) F\A is a polarity described by the biform b\W X W , where W denotes the vector space associated with A. - c) If A i , A2 both are complementary subspaces to KeiF, then the polarities -F|Ai, F\A2 are projectively equivalent. Using the elementary definition of cone sections (Exercise 1.5.9.3) this leads to a new proof for the first part of Exercise 5.— Hint. Recall, in this connection, (7.33) and Proposition 8.2. 1.9.7 P o l a r M a p s of P r o j e c t i v e L i n e s As a preparation for the study of tangents and tangent subspaces of a quadric, we first want to discuss polar maps F of a projective line ^ . For the rank r of F the only possible values are r = 1, 2 by (8). T h e first case is the subject of the following simple proposition: P r o p o s i t i o n 17. Let F be a polar map of the projective line ^ over the skew field K, char K ^ 2. Then the rank r of F is equal to 1 if and only if all points X ^ K e r F have the same image F{x) = a; in this case, QF = K e r F = a. P r o o f . Let 6 be the a-Hermitean form defining F. Now F has rank 1 if and only if K e r F just consists of a single point, say a = KeiF. Obviously, a G QFAccording to Proposition 3, we may suppose t h a t the matrix of h has diagonal form; hence the equation for Q F is cr(x°)/3oa;° = 0 with /3o ^ 0. This implies x° = 0. Thus QF = ai = [oi] is the first base point of the corresponding projective frame. Hence QF contains just one element, and this imphes a = ai. The coordinates of the image point F{x), x ^ a, can be computed using the annihilator of the covector with components Mo = cri^x )/3o, Ml = 0, yielding y° = 0, y^ = 1. Thus F{x) = a. The converse immediately follows from the definition of the rank. D T h e possibilities occurring in the case r = 2 again depend b o t h on the field K and on the type of the quadric. According to CoroUary 8.3, F is now bijective and thus defines an involution of P .
108
1 Projective Geometry
E x a m p l e 5. Let K be a skew field with char if ^ 2. By Proposition 3, any polarity of ^ can be described by a a-biform 6(y, t)) = a(x°)/3oy° + <j{x})f3iy' = 0.
(30)
Because of 6(aj, Ck) = f3i ^ 0, i = 0,1, the base points Oj = [Oj] do not lie on the quadric Qp- For every point x G Q F we may thus take the coordinates to be (x°,x^) = (1,^) with ^ G if*, and then write ^ = ^{x). This imphes a; G Q F ^ ^ a(e)/3ie = -Po-
(31)
If if is a field, and a = id^, then (31) is equivalent to
e = -fhifh-
(32)
So there are only two possibilities, Qp may either be empty or else contain two points. This coincides with the result of Exercise 4.13 b); in fact, in this case F is, at the same time, a projectivity defined by the linear isomorphism y
-pix\y^=pox°.
(33)
Relation (30) immediately implies (even in the case of an arbitrary skew field K) that the points of the quadric Qp are nothing but the fixed points of the involution F. For if = R both possibilities occur according to Proposition 4: QF = 0 for i^ = i^2,o, and QF consists of two points for F = i^2,i- If K is algebraicaUy closed, e.g. if = C, and a = id^, then it is just the second case that occurs. • E x a m p l e 6. Consider the Hermitean normal forms F from Proposition 7 for if = C , H , n = l , r = 2. The equation of this quadric is ez°z° + z^z^ = 0 , e = ± l .
(34)
For e = + 1 equation (34) has no solution in P . I n case e = — 1, each solution of (34) satisfies x° 7^ 0,x^ ^ 0; hence we can take the coordinates of the solution point to be (2;°, z^) = (1, ^); ^ G if*. Then ee = \i? = 1 (e = - 1 ) ,
(35)
i.e., the set of solutions is the unit circle for if = C, and the unit hypersphere S*^ in case if = H. Let now x G P^ be a variable pre-image point with coordinates (1,C), C ^ K*. For the homogeneous coordinates of the image point y = F{x) we then obtain from (30):
ey° + ey' = 0. Because of ^ G if*, necessarily y° ^ 0; again setting (y°,y^) = (1,??) this yields
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics ri=-eC'
= -ei/\i\''{ieK*).
109 (36)
In case e = — 1 this is nothing but the formula for the inversion (or the map hy reciprocal radii) in the unit circle S*^ C C or in the unit hypersphere S*^ C H, respectively. For e = + 1 this inversion still has to be composed with the point reflection in 0. In each case these involutions interchange the points 0,00 eK. a Example 7. Let now K = H. Consider the involution J2 on the quaternionic projective hue P ^ , cf. (23). The associated quadric Q has the equation x°ix°+x^ix^ =0.
(37)
Its solutions are all points x with coordinates (1,C) satisfying ^ = j c o s a + ksina, a G R,
(38)
i.e., the unit circle in the j,k-plane of H. The image y = F{x) of the point X e P^ with coordinates (1,C), C ^ H*, has coordinates (1,??) satisfying V = i^im'-
(39)
In H = R** this is a reflection in the j , k-plane composed with the involution in the unit hypersphere S*^ C H; again the points 0 and 00 of H are interchanged hy F. a 1.9.8 Tangents and Tangent Subspaces In this section we want to describe the possible positions of a hue relative to a quadric. This will lead to the notions of tangents and, more generally, tangent subspaces of a quadric. Example 8. Let again char if ^ 2, let F denote a polar map, and let QF be the associated quadric in P " . For a; = [p] G QF consider the line h = x\/ y, where y = [t)] ^ x is an arbitrary point in P " . Each point z e h, z ^ x, can be represented in the form z = [fS^ + t)] with uniquely determined ^ G if. Because of 6(p, p) = 0 we have: z G QF C\h if and only if z = x or if the following equation is satisfied:
^(e)K?,t)) + Kt),?)e+Kt),t)) = o.
(40)
Next we will distinguish the following cases: a) i\{F\h) = 0: This holds if and only if 6(p, t)) = 6(t), t)) = 0; by Corollary 15 it is thus equivalent to a; V y C QFb) Yk{F\h) = 1: Then, according to Proposition 17 and Example 4, Qpifi = QF n h consists of a single point, hence QF C\ H = {x}. This is the case if and only if 6(p, t)) = 0 as weU as 6(t), t)) 7^ 0 in (40). If x is singular.
110
1 Projective Geometry
i.e. X e KevF, then 6(p, t)) = 0 for all y G P " . Thus {x\/y)nQp = {x} for every y G P"'\QF- If a; is a regular point of QF, then 6(p, t)) = 0 defines the polar F{x) of a;, and for the points y (, F{x), y y^ x, we now have x\/ y C F{x). In this case as weU as in case a) the line h = x \/ y is caUed a tangent for the quadric QF- More generally, we say that a projective subspace B G ^ " is tangent to the quadric Q F at a regular point x G Q F if a; G B C F{X). If a; G QF is a regular point of the quadric, then TXQF '•= F{x) is the tangent hyperplane of the quadric QF at the point x. The totality of tangent subspaces at x forms the bundle F{x)/x. For the singular points x G Kev F tangent subspaces will not be defined. c) Yk{F\h) = 2: In this case h is caUed a secant or secant line of QF- In fact, equality holds in (40) if and only if 6(j;, t)) ^ 0. Hence x has to be a regular point of QF- Moreover, the rank condition together with (40) implies that QF H h contains at least one more point z ^ x. Since 6 is a-Hermitean, the equation e=-6(t),j:)-i6(t),t))/2
(41)
determines a solution for (40). (Because of char if 7^ 2, 2 7^ 0 belongs to the center Z{K*)) As Examples 6, 7 show, there may well be further solutions; if, however, if is a field, and 6 is bilinear, then (41) determines the unique point y G QF H h different from a;, cf. Example 5. • The following proposition contains a geometric interpretation of isotropic subspaces: Proposition 18. Let char if ^ 2, and let F he a polar map of the projective geometry ^ " described by a a-Hermitean biform b. Moreover, consider a projective subspace o ^ A = -KiyV) with associated vector space W. Then W is isotropic if and only if Ker(F\A) ^ o. Here, Ker(i^|A) = ( A A K e r i ^ ) U B ( A ) ,
(42)
where B(A) denotes the set of those regular points of the quadric QF at which A is tangent to QFP r o o f . The defect subspace oi b\W x W is the vector space associated with Ker(i^|A), which immediately implies the first assertion. Moreover, X G Ker(i^|A) if and only if a; G A C i^(a;).
(43)
For this, there are just two mutually excluding possibilities: Either i^(a;) = P " , i.e. x G AAKeri^, or Dimi^(a;) = n— 1, and then x belongs to B{A). D Corollary 19. Under the assumptions of Proposition 18 , let F be a polarityThen W ^ o is isotropic if and only if A = 'K{W) is tangent to QF in at least one point x; the set B{A) of points of contact is a projective subspace of A, whose vector space is the defect subspace of h\W x W. D
1.9 Polarities and Quadrics
111
Exercise 8