This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
m-°. If x = x(y) then
axk
an,
= 0 and we obtain this estimate from (1.24) without assuming g + 6:!5; 1. Similarly, if m - Q + I <--_ m + b, i.e. Q + b >__ 1, it follows from (1.25) that 1.5
2CK<17>^'+a, and the same estimate is obtained without the extra
Isy assumption Q+ b >- 1 if 0 = 0 (q).
The necessary estimates of the form (1.10) are thus verified when I a + Q 1
-<- 1
for an arbitrary function a (x, 0) E S.I. (U) in all the three cases a), b), c). Now,
inductively, assume that the estimates hold for I a + $1 < k and arbitrary a ESQa(U). In particular, we then obtain that for the derivatives of order <-k of bU) and b0, the estimates of the classes S' (V) and S' (V) respectively hold.
But then we obtain from (1.24), (1.25) by analogous reasoning, that these estimates hold for derivatives of order <-- (k + 1) and for arbitrary aeSQa(U).
§ 1.
Oscillatory Integrals
9
Lemma 1.3 (variant of the Hadamard lemma). Let the functions O, (x, 0), .. . 0&,0) belong to C°° (U), with U a conic region in IR" x (IRN\ 0), and assume that they are positively homogeneous in 0 of degree 0; dP, , ... , dok being linearly independent at points of the set
C={(x,0)eU,Oj(x,0)=0,j=1,...,k}. Let a E Se".j (U), a I c = 0 and Q + 6 = 1. Then there is a representation k
a= Y a, 0j,
(1.26)
i=1
where as (x, 0) e SQ e '(U), j = 1, ... , k. If the function a (x, 0) here has a zero of infinite order on C, then all the functions a; (x, 0), j = 1, ... , k, also have a zero of
infinite order on C.
Proof. Note, that (1.26) is a linear equation in the functions a;. It is therefore enough to be able to find the functions aj locally (for (x, 0/101) close to (xo, 00110,1), (xo, 00) being a fixed point in U). A global solution could then be glued
together in U using a partition of the unity in U consisting of functions homogeneous of degree zero supported in conical regions in which the required functions a; have already been constructed. Thus let (x0 i 00) a U. If (x0, 00) t C, there exists a jo such that P1, (x0, 00) 4 0. For (x, 0/ 101) close to (x0 , 00/ 1001) we can put at, = a/0t, and at = 0 for j $ jo. It remains to verify the existence of a1 locally for (x, 0/101) close to (xo, 00/1001) e C. By the implicit function theorem 0 1, ... , 4)k can be supplemented by functions Ok + 1,
,
01(1= N+ n - 1), homogeneous of degree zero, to form a local
coordinate system 0,,
..., i, on
the manifold {(x,0): 161=1) in a
neighbourhood of (xo, 00/ 100 1). Therefore, the transformation
(x,0)-(1(x,0), ..., 01(x, 0),10I)e1R'x]R+ is a diffeomorphism of a conical neighbourhood of the ray (x0,100) onto the conical set B x IR+ , B a ball in ER', and the image of C has the form {(0,101): 01 = ... = Ok=0). Let us now consider the symbol a(-P, 101)=a(x(O, 101), 0(0, 101)),
obtained from a (x, 0) under this diffeomorphism. It follows from lemma 1.2 that x (10,101) S g'" (B x IR+). But then, by the Newton-Leibnitz formula k
1
a(d',I01)= Y 0, aUl(t01, ..., tok> 0k+1, ..., 0,, 101)dt, j=1
0
where au, = a d eSQ a °(B x 1R+). It remains to carry out the inverse
substitution.
10
Chapter 1. Foundations of `PDO Theory
Proof of Theorem 1.3. Assume that Q + b = 1. Then, if a I c. = 0, by lemma 1.3 with 0; = a8 , we may represent a (x, 0) in the form
a= Y a; ;_,
a
a;eSQ a"(U).
a0;
(1.27)
ao
However, taking into account that e'm= -i a e'm, we obtain, on inteao; ao; grating by parts, that
But a©; e SQ d a - °(U), demonstrating the second statement of the theorem. From
this proof it is obvious, that if a (x, 0) had a zero of infinite order in C, then b (x, 0) could also be chosen to possess this property. So in proving the first statement we can assume a (x, 0) eSQ ' (X x R"), M as large as desired. But then the integral (1.21) converges absolutely and uniformly in x as do the integrals obtained from it by differentiation of degree S 1 (M), where I (M) --+ + oo as
M - + oo, and hence the smoothness of A (x) follows. D Exercise 1.10. Prove theorem 1.3 when the second of the assumptions (1.22) is fulfilled (0 (x, 0) linear in 0).
Hint. It amounts to applying of part c) of Lemma 1.2.
§2. Fourier Integral Operators (Preliminaries) 2.1 Definition of the Fourier Integral operator and its kernel. Let X, Y be open sets in IR'x and IR"r. Consider the expression
Au(x) =
a(x, y,0) u(y) dydO,
(2.1)
where u (y) E Co (Y), x e X, 0 (x, y, 0) is a phase function on X X Y X IR"' and
a(x,y,0)eSm(Xx Yx1R') with Q>O and b <1. Under these conditions the integral= J JJe'.(x.Y.a) a(x,y,0) u(y) v(x) dxdyd0,
veCO (X), (2.2)
is defined and is an ordinary oscillatory integral. It is easily verified, that for fixed u the expression (2.2) viewed as a functional of v, defines a distribution Au E Y'(X). Therefore a linear operator
§2. Fourier Integral Operators (Preliminaries)
11
A: Co (Y)-+-9'(X),
(2.3)
is defined. We will formally write it as the integral (2.1) Definition 2.1. An operator A of the form (2.1) is called a Fourier integral operator (abbreviated FIO) with phase function cp (x, y, 0). Definition 2.2. The distribution K,, c21'(X x Y) defined by the oscillatory integral
w(x,y)dxdydO,
(2.4)
is called the kernel of A.
Proposition 2.1. a)
K,, a Cy (Rm)
where
Rm = {(x, y):
(x, y, 0) + 0,
O c-]RN\0}
b) If a (x, y, 0) = 0 in a conical neighbourhood of the set Co = {(x, Y. 0):.0B (x, y, 0) = 0} , then K,, e C' (X x Y).
Proof. This follows immediately from Theorems 1.1 and 1.2.
O
In view of the obvious formula
ueCo (Y),
veCol" (X),
(2.5)
the kernel K4 is the usual kernel of A in the sense of L. Schwartz. Exercise 2.1. Verify that the kernel K4 is uniquely defined by the map (2.3) given by A and, conversely, uniquely determines this map.
Remark. One can easily construct two different pairs consisting of a phase function and a function a (x, y, 0), both pairs giving rise to the same operator (2.3). Furthermore, as a rule, a (x, y, 0) is not uniquely defined by A, even with the same phase function 0. 2.2 Operator phase functions.
Definition 2.3. A phase function 0 (x, y, 0) is called an operator phase function, if the following two conditions are fulfilled;
y, O) *0 for 0* 0,
xeX,
yeY
(2.6)
s,a(x,y,0)40 for 0 * 0
xeX,
yeY
(2.7)
0 y. a (x,
The role of these two conditions is brought out by the following two propositions.
Chapter 1. Foundations of `PDO Theory
12
Proposition 2.2. Under condition (2.6) the operator (2.1) continuously maps Co (Y) into C°O(X).
Proof. The integral (2.1) is already defined as an oscillatory integral, depending on the parameter x. Its x- derivatives are of the same form. In what follows,.f' (Y) denotes the dual to C°° (Y) (and is the set of compactly
supported distributions in Y). Proposition 2.3. Under condition (2.7) the map (2.3) defined via (2.1) extends by continuity to a continuous map:
A: 6'(Y) -- 2'(X).
(2.8)
Here the continuity is understood in the sense of the weak topologies on X'(Y) and Y'(X). Recall that the weak topology on the space E', consisting of the linear functionals on E, is defined by the family of semi-norms p,o(f) = I (f (p) I, where f E E' and (p is any fixed element of E. Proof. The transposed operator
'Av(y) = J
je'm(X.Y'O) a(x,y,O) v(x)drdO
(2.9)
defines, by proposition 2.2, a map
'A: Co (X) -. C' (Y). Thus, defining A by=
with u e 8'(Y), v e Co (X) we are done.
Exercise 2.2. Verify that the operator A, defined in this way, is indeed an extension by continuity of the map (2.3). So an F10 A with operator phase function dy maps Co (Y) into C'(X) and 1'(Y) into 2'(X). We now study the change in the singular support under the action of A. Let us settle a notation. If X and Y are two sets, S a subset of X x Y and K a subset of Y, then S o K is the subset of X consisting of the points x E X, for which there exists a y e K with (x, y) c- S. Theorem 2.1. The following inclusion holds:
sing supp Au c So ° sing supp u
(2.10)
where Sm = (X x Y)\ Rm consists of those pairs (x, y) for which there exists a 0 eIRN\0 with 0; (X, y,©) = 0.
§2. Fourier Integral Operators (Preliminaries)
13
Proof Splitting U E 9'(Y) into a sum of a function in C, '(Y) and a distribution with the support in a neighbourhood of sing supp a we see that it suffices to demonstrate that sing supp (Au) c S. o supp u. Let K = supp u and K' an arbitrary compact set in X not intersecting So o K and so that K' x K C Rm. Since R. is open, there are open neighbourhoods S2 and ST of the compact sets K and K' respectively such that ST x S2 C R,. So it suffices to verify that Au E C°°(Sl'). But this is evident, since KA(x, y) E C°°(R,) and in particular, KA (X, y) E Coo (ST X S2).
Exercise 2.3. Verify the statement used above that if K4 E C (Q' x (2) then A maps d'(Q) into C°°(Q').
2.3 Example 1: The Cauchy problem for the wave equation. Consider the Cauchy problem (2.11)
f I(=o = 0
f' 1,=0 = u(x)
(2.12)
where x e IR", f = f (t, x), d is the Laplacian in x and - to begin with u (x) a Ca (1R"). We solve (2.11)-(2.12) with the help of the Fourier transformation in x, putting je-,,..cf(t,y)dy.
In this way, we have a
are
_-
.JIt=o = 0,
(2.13)
.1j" It=o = uO
(2.14)
where u(i;) is the Fourier transform of u(x). From (2.13) and (2.14) we easily obtain that
f (t,
)=
(,),in t I1
Therefore by the Fourier inversion formula
f(t,x) = f f =ff
sin t14 lu(y)dyd e-`1f1)u(y)dyd(;.
We would like to split the last integral into two parts separating the exponents ei'111 and e-l"41. However this would lead to a singularity at t = 0. To avoid E Co (lit"), such this singularity, let us again use a cut-off function X = x that x (!) = I near 0 and split the integral into three parts:
f (t, x) = f+(t, x) - f_(r, x) + r(t, x)
14
Chapter 1. Foundations of 4'1)0 Theory
f+(t,x) = f- Q. x) = f
r(t,x) =
ffe'lc.,-3'>t+rIt11(1
- x(4))(2i X (.))(2il I)-dyd4, I-1
sintI dyd4.
It is clear e.g. that f+ = Au where A is a FIO with the phase function
) (t, x, y, ) = (x - y) . This is an operator phase function. Since 45{ = x
+ t 1C.
-y+
we have
Cm = (Q. X, y, ) : y -x = tIII), sm=((t,x,y):Ix-y12=t2).
The second term f_(t, x) can be similarly presented as f_ = Au, where A is a FIO with the phase function
<(t,x,y,(x-y) -tll It has the same set Si = Sm. For the third term we clearly have r = Ru where R has a C°° Schwartz kernel KR (t, x, y). In fact, it is easy to see that any such operator R can be also presented as a FlO in the form (2.1) with an arbitrary choice of the phase function and with an amplitude a E S. (See also Exercise 2.4 below.)
So we see that each of the terms ff(t, x), r(t, x) can be presented as a result of the application of a FIO to the initial condition u. In particular, by Proposition 2.3 we can define f (t, x) for any u E e'(lR°). By Theorem 2.1 the singularities of f (t, x) belong to ((t, x) : 3u E sing suppu, Ix - y12 = t2}. This is the classical statement that singularities propagate with the speed of light (which is equal to 1 in this case). In particular, the singularities of the fundamental solution (the case u(y) = 8(y)) belong to the light cone Ix12 = t2.
Note also that if we fix the time to, then 45,,(x, y, ) = ' (to, x, y, 4) remains an operator phase function. Therefore the mapping of u into f (to, ) is a FIO. 2.4 Example 2: Linear differential operators. Let
A= Y a,(x)DR, where aQ (x) e C ' (X), X an open set in IR" and D = i - t
Using the Fourier transformation, we may write
D'u(x) = JJaeitx-r)-Eu(y)dyd,
(2.16)
a
§2. Fourier Integral Operators (Preliminaries)
IS
hence
(2.17)
where a,, (x,
Y_ as (x) ' is called the symbol of the operator A. Since 14I S m
a,, (x, ) a S'(X x lR"), we see from (2.17) that A is an FIO with phase function (x,Y,
2.5 Example 3: Pseudodifferential operators
Definition 2.4. Let n x = n y = N = n and X = Y. Then an FIO with the phase function ds (x, y, l;) _ (x - y) is called a pseudod{ff erential operator (briefly: 'PDO). The class of `PDO, defined by a(x, y, l;) E SQ1(X x X x IR") is denoted oted byn (X) or simply by L'" a. We also put L"' instead of L 'no and L-00
L
.
As demonstrated in the previous example, any linear partial differential operator is a `PDO.
We now display the properties of 'PDO, which follow from the already shown properties of FIO. Proposition 2.4. Let A be a `PDO given by the formula Au(x)=IIetcx-r,-
(2.18)
Let K4 be the kernel of A and d the diagonal in X x X. Then a) K,, a Ca, ((X x X)\ d)); b) A defines continuous linear maps
and
A: Co A: d'(X)- .9'(X)
(2.19)
sing supp Au = sing supp u
(2.21)
(2.20)
for u e d'(X) (this property is called pseudolocality of A); c)
the function a (x, y, ) a S,1.o a(X x X x IR") vanishes for x = y and b <
then we can write A in the form (2.18) with b (x, y, ) e SQ a to -b' (X x X x IR") instead of a (x, y, ). d) (f a (x, y, ) has a zero of infinite order at x = y, then K,, E C'°(X x X) and the operator A transforms 1'(X) into C °° (X).
Proof. Left to the reader as an exercise. Exercise 2.4. Let K(x, y) e C °° (X x X) and A bean operator from C, '(X) to C°°(X) with kernel K(x, y). Prove that A is a `PDO and that in the representation (2.18) we can take a(x, y, ) E S-' (X X X x IR"). Hint. If X
a Co (lR"), X ( ) z 0 and JX
dd =1 we can take
e-ccx-Y'*4K(x,Y)
X()
16
Chapter I. Foundations of `I'DO Theory
Note that linear differential operators enjoy the locality property: supp (Au) c supp u,
u e Co (X)
(2.22)
The following exercise shows that in general this is not the case for IFDO.
Exercise 2.5. Show that an operator whose kernel K(x, y) E C' (X x X) is not identically zero does not obey (2.22) Problem 2.1. Given a linear continuous operator A : Co (X) -+ Co (X) satisfying (2.22), then for any subdomain X' c X, whose closure is compact in X, we get a linear differential operator by restricting A to Co (X'). Hint. Verify that for any fixed x0 E Xthe linear functional given by (A q0) (xo) for cp E Co (X), is supported at xo and thus can be written as (A (p) (xo) _
as (xo) (Da(p) (xo)
Derive from the continuity of A the local finiteness of this sum and the smoothness (in xo) of the coefficients a,,,(xo).
§3. The Algebra of Pseudodifferential Operators and Their Symbols 3.1 Properly supported pseudodifferential operators. Let A be a TDO with kernel KA and let supp KA denote the support of KA (the smallest closed subset
Z C X x X such that KAI(XXX)\z = 0. Consider the canonical projections 171, 172 : supp KA -+X, obtained by restricting the corresponding projections
of the direct product X x X. Recall that a continuous map f : M -> N between topological spaces M, N is called proper if for any compact K C N the inverse image f -I (K) is a compact in M. Definition 3.1. A TDO A is called properly supported if both projections f71,172 : supp KA -+ X are proper maps. Example. Linear differential operators (cf. item 2.4) are properly supported TDO (in this case supp KA = d, the diagonal in X x X).
Proposition 3.1. Let A be a properly supported `PDO. Then A defines a map (3.1) A: Co (X) -+ Co (X) which extends to continuous maps
A:
d'(X)-d'(X)
(3.2)
§3. The Algebra of Pseudodifferential Operators and Their Symbols
A: C'(X)->C'(X) A:
9I'(X) -' 2'(X)
17
(3.3)
(3.4)
Proof. For u (y) E Co (X), we have the inclusion supp (Au) c (supp K4) o (supp u)
(3.5)
Indeed, if v E Co (X) is such that supp v n (supp K4) o (supp u) = 0, then supp K4 n supp [u (y) v (x)] = 0 and therefore= 0 by (2.5). Furthermore, from the obvious formula (supp K4) o (supp u) = 17, (supp K4 nI1 2 ' (supp u))
(3.6)
it follows that the right hand side of (3.5) is compact, so that Au e CO '(X), which establishes (3.1). The continuity is easily verified. Since the kernel Kt,, of the transposed operator' A is obtained from KA by
permuting x and y (more precisely: (KtA, w(x, y)) = (K,,, w(y, x))): then'A also defines a continuous map
'A: Co(X)-iCo(X), which yields (3.4) by duality. Finally, as is easily verified, formula (3.5) also applies for u e t' (X) which gives (3.2). Since this can also be said of'A, by duality we obtain (3.3).
Exercise 3.1. Let X. be a sequence of open subsets of X such that 1)
X,cX2c...
2) Ux,,=x 3)
the closure X. of X. in X is compact in X.
Let X. (x) e Co (X) and X. (x) = I for x e X,,. Finally let A be a properly supported `A'DO in X. Show that if u e 9' (X), then for arbitrary m one can find N = N (m) such that the distribution [A Q. u)] I does not depend on n for n Z N. In this way, we can define Au e 2'(X) by the formula Au = lim
(3.7)
A. M
Show that this definition coincides with the one given above in proving Proposition 3.1.
Exercise 3.2. Show that all the three definitions of a properly supported PDO given above, coincide on C°° (X):
a) by duality from the map'A : 9'(X) -. 8'(X); b) as a restriction to C' (X) of the map A: I'(X) -+ 9'(X), constructed by duality from the map 'A: Co (X) - Co (X), c) by formula (3.7).
Chapter 1. Foundations of PDO Theory
18
Exercise 3.3. Verify that the operator A is properly supported if and only if 'A is.
The importance of properly supported'PDO lies in the fact that they form an algebra where multiplication is the ordinary multiplication (composition) of operators. This statement will be proved below, but presently it is clear from Proposition 3.1, that the composition A oA2 of two properly supported'PDO is defined as a linear continuous operator on the spaces Co (X), -f'(X), C'° (X) or
Note that it is not immediately clear that (2.18) which determines A via a (x, y, ) applies for u E -9'(X) (or even for u e C°°(X)). This is not surprising, since the function a (x, y, ) is not uniquely defined by the operator A. However, utilizing this arbitrariness, we can make a better choice of a (x, y, ). Definition 3.2. We say that a function a (x, y, ) is properly supported if both the projections 111, 172: supp:.r a (x,
are proper maps (by suppz,,, a (x, y, ) we denote the closure of the projection of supp a (x, y, ) in X x K).
In this case the corresponding Y'DO A is obviously properly supported. Proposition 3.2. If A e LQ,,, (X) is properly supported, then A can be put in the form (2.18) with a (x, y, ) e SQ a(X x X x IR") being properly supported.
Proof. Let X (x, y) e C °` (X x X), X (x, y) = I in a neighborhood of supp K4
and let both projections 111, 172: supp X - X be proper (verify that such a function exists!). Then, substituting in (2.18) X (x, y) a (x, y, ) for a (x, y, ), the
kernel K,, and hence the operator are unchanged while X (x, y) a (x, y, ) is properly supported. D Note that if a (x, y, ) is properly supported then (2.18), viewed as an iterated integral, is defined for u e C' (X).
Proposition 3.3. Any 'PDO A can be written in the form A = AO + A, where Ao is a properly supported'PDO and A, has kernel K,,, E C°° (X X X). Proof. Given A in the form (2.18) with function a (x, y, ), we obtain AO and A, by substituting as (x, y, ) = X (x, y) a (x, y, ) and a, (x, y, ) = (1 - X (x, y))
a (x, y, ) respectively instead of a (x, y, ) where X (x, y) equals
1
in a
neighborhood of the diagonal d c X x X and is such that both projections 17, 172: supp X X are proper.
,
Proposition 3.4. Let A be a'PDO. Then A is properly supported if and only if the following two conditions are fuflled ; a) for any compact set K e X we can find a compact set K, e X such that supp u c K implies supp (Au) c K,; b) the same condition with 'A instead of A.
§3. The Algebra of Pseudodifferential Operators and Their Symbols
19
Proof. The necessity of a) and b) is clear from (3.5). So we are left with proving the sufficiency. For instance let us verify that the projection 172: supp K,, -' X is a proper map. Let K be an arbitrary compact set in X. Find a (K) n supp KA c K, x K. If compact set K, as in a) and verify that 172 -'(K) (x0, yo) E (X\K1) x K and if a smooth function w(x, y) = u(y)v(x) is supported in a neighbourhood of this point, then by a) (KA, w) = 0. By linearity and continuity this then also holds for an arbitrary function w E Ca (X X X), supported in a neighbourhood of (xo, yo) from which the desired inclusion
follows. 0 3.2 The symbol of a properly supported pseudodifferentlal operator. We would like to define the symbol of an arbitrary properly supported `PDO A by analogy with example 2 of §2. Let us point out that in this example the following holds Q,, (x, 4) = e _, (x) A e{ (x),
(3.8)
where et (x) = e" t, and that the right hand side of this expression also makes sense for a properly supported `PDO. Definition 3.3. Let A be a properly supported `PDO. Its symbol (or complete symbol) is the function aA(x, ) on X x IR", defined by (3.8). Since e, (x) is an infinitely differentiable function of c with values in C°° (X) and A is a continuous linear operator on C°° (X), it is clear that a,, (x, ) is also an
infinitely differentiable function of
taking values in C°°(X), therefore
aA (x, ) e C °° (X X R").
Writing u (x) E Co (X) as the inverse Fourier transform u (x) = j e4 (x) u (i;) d
where the integral converges in the topology of C`° (X), we see that
Au(x)=!ei" 4CA(x, )4 (4)d
(3.9)
or
Au(x)=
fe`c=-Y' 4aA(x, )u(Y)dyd
(3.10)
(where the integral is viewed as an iterated one), which coincides with the corresponding formulas for differential operators. As is demonstrated by the formulas (3.8) and (3.9), the symbol aA (x, ) defines A and is also defined by A. Below it will be shown that if A E LQ,6(X) and 8 < p, then we will have x IV) implying that (3.10) can also be viewed as an oscillatory a4 (x, ) E Se lm integral ((3.9) is absolutely convergent).
Remark If A is an arbitrary `PDO on X, then its symbol is frequently defined as the symbol aA. (x, !) of a properly supported `PDO A 1 on X such
20
Chapter I. Foundations of'I'DO Theory
that A - AI E L-00. In this case the symbol is not uniquely defined although, as will be seen later, any two such symbols differ by a function r(x, ) E S-°°. 3.3 Asymptotic expansions in S1 a Definition 3.4. Let a, (x, 0) E SQ J8 (X X RN), j=1, 2,
j - +oo, and let a(x,0)eC''(XxWe will write
..., mj - - oo
as
a(x,0) - Y aj(x,0), j=1
if for any integer r ? 2 we have r-1
a(x,0)-
a;(x,0)ESI,,(Xx1R"),
(3.11)
j-1
where in, = max m,. jT,r
From this it follows, in particular, that a ES.1.6 (X x IR").
Proposition 3.5. For a given sequence a, e S; b (X x RN), j = 1, 2, ... , with mj- - oo as j-+ + oo, we can always find a function a (x, 0) such that
If, furthermore, another function a' has the same property a'-
a-a'ES-°°(XxIR").
aj, then j=1
Proof. The second assertion is obvious so let us prove the first one. We can assume that m, > m2 > m3 > .... In fact, if this is not the case, we can always
achieve this situation by a simple rearrangement and gathering the terms of the same order. Let X = U X,, where Xj are open subsets of X and such j=1
that Kj = Xj cc X (i.e. Kj is compact in X). Let 9 (0) E C ' (R') and (P(0) =
for 101 5 1/2
0
11 for 101>1.
Put a (x, 0) _
cp
j=1
(-0) aj (x, 0), tj
(3.12)
where t, approaches + co so quickly as j - + co that I8e8= [q'
(p:) a,(x,0)]2Jm
I=I+610t;-
for x e K1 and I a I + I IJ I + 1 5 j. Let us show that this is always possible.
(3.13)
§3. The Algebra of Pseudodifferential Operators and Their Symbols
21
First observe that 1:5 Ca<0>-lal,
ago
t> 1,
(3.14)
where C. does not depend on t, that is for cp (8/t) and t z I we have uniform in t estimates of class S10.0 . In fact aaq (0/t) _ (aa(p) (©/t) - t-1a1
and
101 5 t5 2 101
for 0 esuppaegp(9/t), from which we obtain (3.14). Further from (3.14) follows that <e>m'-e 1a1 +6161
l aeax [1P (0/t) aj(x, e)J I < Cj
if x e K,
, t? I and 1 a I+ 1#1+1:5j. Let us observe now that <©)m,-e1a1+6161 < g<0>m' .-elal+6161
for (B>'",-' -m' z 1/e. Thus, by the choice of tj we can achieve (3.13) which implies
the convergence of (3.12), together with all its derivatives, uniformly on any compact K c X, and for arbitrary fixed a, Q and 1 we obtain a^ aeaX
L co(©/tj)aj(x,©)
j=r+1
Thus, a -
<2
r<e>m,-ela1+6161
xeK,,IuI+Illl+l<-r.
aj E S,*',, (X x IR") and since ar E S,',,, (X x lR"), we obtain from this j=1
r-1
that a -
aj a S,.,, (X x IR"), as required. j=1
The following proposition facilitates the verification of a -
aj.
Proposition 3.6. Let aj ESQ;6(X x K r), m, -+ - oo as j + oo and let a e C°°(X x IR") so that for each compact Kc X and arbitrary multi-indices a,# there exist constants u = p (a, fi, K) and C = C (a, fi, K) with Iaea,'a(x,0)1 5 C<©>",
xeK.
(3.15)
Furthermore assume that for any compact K c X, there exist numbers p, = p, (K), 1=1, 2, ..., and constants C, = C1(K), such that p, --+ - oo as I - + oo and the following estimate holds
aj(x,0) 5 C,<0>",
a(x,©) i=1
xeK.
(3.16)
22
Chapter 1. Foundations of `FDO Theory w
Then a - Y_ aj. J=1
The point of this proposition is that instead of (3.11) one has to verify the
remainder estimates only for the functions themselves (and not for all the derivatives) provided the fairly weak estimates (3.15) are guaranteed. The proof is based on the following well-known lemma. Lemma 3.1. Let a junction f (t) have continuous derivatives f' (t) and f" (t) for
te[-1,1].PutAj= sup If1J)(t)jj=0,2. Then _1$,51
(3.17)
If (0) 12 5 4Ao(Ao+A2).
Proof. By the intermediate value theorem we have
If'(t) -f'(0)I < A21t1. Therefore I f' (t)1 > 1 /21 f' (0) I for Ai 1 t l 5 1 /2 I f' (0) I, I t 151. Denoting
d = min
1 }we have I f'(t) I >1/21 f'(0) I for t e [- d, A]. We have
2A2
J
2A0? If(A) -f(-A)I ? 2A If'(O)I 2
and consequently, 11(0)1 5 2 e ° = 2Aomax
IA2
IT(O)i,
i}.
or If'(0)I 5 2A,, i.e. either If'(0)12 II (o)I 5 4AOA2 or If, (0) 12 S 4A2 and thus (3.17). O
This implies that either If'(0) 1
54ApA2.
Lemma 3.2. Let K, and K2 be two compact sets in lR° so that K, C Int K2 (the set of interior points in K2). Then there exists a constant C> 0, such that for any smooth function f on a neighborhood of K2, the following estimate holds
(sup
jaj=1
IDaf(x)I
sup If(x)I +ja1=2 sup Z I Daf(x)I(3.18)
Csup If(x)I (xc.Kz xeX2
Proof. Immediate from Lemma 3.1.
0
§3. The Algebra of Pseudodifferential Operators and Their Symbols
23
Pro of of Proposition 3.6. Let b - Y a, (such a function exists by Proposition j=3
3.5). Putting d (x, 0) = a (x, 0) - b (x, 0), we have for every compact set K c X the estimate
xeK,
Iaea,d(x,0)I < C<0>',
(3.19)
where C and p depend on a, fi, K, and additionally
Id(x,0)I 5 C,<0>-', where C,= C,(K). Set do(x, ) = d(x,
xeK,
(3.20)
Then a{a° ds(x, x) 14 =0 = aBax d(x, 0),
and applying Lemma 3.2 with K, = K x 0, K2 = k x { I 151 }, where k is a compact set in X such that Int k =>K, we obtain from (3.20) d(x,0)I\2 ( sup
I0B0P
xQK iai+ipisl
C<0)-, (<0)-'+<0)p) l1
Here r can be choosen arbitrarily, µ depends on a, fl, K and C depends on
a, fi, K and also on r. Thus it follows that for x E K and Ia1 + Illl < 1 0) -+ 0 faster than any power of (0) as 101 -f +oo. By the function induction we obtain the same for arbitrary a, fi which gives d E S-°°(X X IR") as required. 0 3.4 An expression for the symbol of a properly supported `YDO in terms of a (x, y, t). In this and the following subsections we assume that b < Q.
Theorem 3.1. Let A be a properly supported 'PDO given by (2.18), and 04 (x, ) its symbol. Then
a4Dya(x,Y,
(3.21)
where the asymptotic sum runs over all multi-indices a.
Remark. Obviously a sum (3.21) is therefore meaningful.
a
Q-61l
and the asymptotic
Proof of Theorem 3.1. Observing that by Proposition 3.2 we can assume that a (x, y, 4) is properly supported, then (3.8), defining the symbol a4 (x, ), can be rewritten in the form
a4(x, 0 = f
fa(x,y,0)er(x-y)-eei(y-x)
4 dyd0,
(3.22)
Chapter 1. Foundations of `PDO Theory
24
Here the integral is regarded as an iterated one and the integral makes sense since
for each fixed x, the y-integration is over a compact set. In this way, if K is a compact set in X, the oscillatory integral given by (3.22) depends on a parameter x e K. Making the change of variables z = y - x, q = 0 - to simplify the exponent we obtain dzdq.
(3.23)
Expanding a (x, x + z, + q) inn near q = 0, using the Taylor formula, we have:
Y
(3.24)
i:i5N-1
where
N q' a
-'
(3.25)
0
Now observe that
"dzdq=a D,a(x,x+z,U
IS a'4
4
(3.26)
by Fourier inversion formula, this gives the finite terms in formula (3.21). We would now like to use Proposition 3.6. Let us first get a rough estimate for a,, (x, ) of the type (3.15). For this we rewrite (3.23) by integrating by parts
a,,(x,5)= $Je
(3.27)
where v is even and non-negative.
Taking into account the inequality <+'> < 2 <> -, we obtain from (3.27) that la',aX o4 (x, ) I < J °-(1-°)"dq, where p = max (m - p I C (I + 6 1# I, 0), x E K and v is sufficiently large. This gives the desired estimates for the derivatives of Q4 (x, ) of the type (3.15). It remains to estimate the remainder term. Inserting in (3.23) the expression rN (formula (3.25)) for a (x, x+ z, + q) and interchanging the orders of integration over t and over z, q, we see that it is necessary to have a uniform in t c- (0,1 ] and x E K estimate of the integral
where I a I = N. Integrating by parts, we obtain (3.28)
Let us decompose the integral in (3.28) into two parts: Ra.1 = Ra., + R.",,
(3.29)
§3. The Algebra of Pseudodifferential Operators and Their Symbols
25
where in RQ,, the integration is over the set {(z,q): and in R;., it is over the complement to this set. Note that if I q 15 I fl /2 then 11!2 < I + n7 l 5 j I I and moreover in &, the volume of the domain of integration for q doesn't exceed C I I", hence IRa.,(x, )I
(3.30)
C doesn't depend on and t.
Let us next estimate R.",. Integrating by parts and using the formula
' e : It = e
= ''
where v is an even and non-negative number, we see that R.", can be written as a finite sum of terms of the form 11
e-`='q-'D';Da+aa(x,x+z,
+tq)dzdq,
(3.31)
Iql> M12
where 1#1:5v. For I' I ?ICI/2 the expression 84D= +e a (x, x + z, + tq) is m- (Q - b) N+ by ->- 0 and by C for m - (Q - b) N + by < 0 (in both cases C is independent of S, q and t). Taking into account the factorwe obtain from (3.31) that for sufficiently estimated in absolute value by Cm -(Q
-8)N+av for
large v I
SC
f
P-(1-a1.
,
Iql>Ifl/2
where p = max { m - (Q - 6)N, 0}. If p - (1- O v + n + 1 < 0, it follows that IRa.O.t(x,S)I S
CP-(1-a)v+n+1 j-n-1 dq S
C doesn't depend on x, and t (for x e K, t e (0,1 ]). Selecting a large enough v we can make the exponent in (3.32) p - (1- b) v + n + I negative and as large as we like in absolute value. Taking (3.29) and (3.30) into account, we obtain for R,,, the estimate C«)'"-(Q-d/N+.,
xeK,
te(0,1],
which ensures the applicability of Proposition 3.6 and so finishes the proof. U Remark. The method of proof of Theorem 3.1 is very typical for the theory of `PDO and the corresponding arguments are to be found in all versions of this theory independently of the mode of presentation. We therefore strongly urge the reader to carefully study the proof of this key theorem.
26
Chapter I. Foundations of'I'DO Theory
3.5 The symbol of the transposed operator and the dual symbol. The transposed operator 'A is defined by=
(3.33)
for any u, v c- Co (X), where
Therefore, if A E Le".,, (X) is given by (2.18), where a(x, y, ) ESQ 6(X x IV), the transpose 'A is given by
'Av(y) = f f e"x-'''C a(x,y,l;) which with the change of variable ry = - gives 'Av(y) = f f
e'"''-X)-4 a(x,
y, -') v(x)dxdrl.
(3.34)
It is therefore obvious that 'A c- V,",, (X).
Theorem 3.2. Let A be a properly supported'I'DO with symbol aA(x, ) and aA(x, ) the symbol of'A, then a'. (x,
0" D,2
(3.35)
Proof. Note that 'A is also properly supported (cf. Exercise 3.3). Also, instead of a (x, y, l;) in the formula (2.18), giving the action of A, we can substitute aA(x, ) (cf. (3.10)). Then (3.34) can be written
'Av(x)= ffe(:-y)-{o'A(Y,- )v(Y)dYd
(3.36)
This is the standard form for a'PDO (cf. (2.18)) where the role of a (x, y, l;) is played by aA(y, -c). It remains only to apply Theorem 3.1. Exercise 3.4. Let A be a properly supported 'I'DO with symbol aA (x, ) and let A* be the "adjoint" operator, defined by (Au, v) = (u, A*v), u, v E Co (X)
where (u, v) = f u(x)v(x) dx. Prove that A* is a properly supported Y'DO whose symbol satisfies
aA* (x,)
a" D' aA(x, &a!
where the bar denotes the complex conjugation.
(3.37)
§3. The Algebra of Pseudodifl'erential Operators and Their Symbols
27
We now introduce the dual symbol by setting aA(x,
O'' (XI -)
(3.38)
Taking into account that '('A) = A, we obtain from (3.36) that A can be expressed via the dual symbol a4 (x, ) in the form Au(x) = J fe"s-YI'c rA(y, ) u(y)dyds or
(Au)(k)= Je -ir
aA(y, )u(y)dv
(3.39)
Theorem 3.3. The dual symbol aA (x, O is connected with the symbol aA (x, via the asymptotic formula aA(x,
)
(3.40)
) ~ Y(-d4)aDxa, (x,0/a! a
Proof. Obvious from (3.38) and (3.35). L 3.6 The composition formula
Theorem 3.4. Let A and B be two properly supported `YDO in a domain X RV and let their symbols be aA (x, l;) and aB (x, ) respectively. The composition
C = B A is then a properly supported`PDO, whose symbol satisfies the relation (3.41)
/a!
QBA(x,
Proof. Using formula (3.39) for A and applying formula (3.9) to B, we obtain Cu (x) =if eitx - ri ' 4 c, (x, ) aA (y, ) u (y) dy dS .
It follows that if A E LQ.6(X) and B E LQ.6(X) then C E
we obtain 'C='A 'BeLQ.a
Analogously
The fact that the `PDO C is properly
supported now follows from Proposition 3.4 and it remains to compute 6BA (x, ) using Theorems 3.1 and 3.3.
We have
8cDy1aB(x,i)eA(y, )]/a!Ir
aBA(x,
= L Ca IQB(x, 0 DxaA(x, )]la! i3{ [a. (x, ) (-at)r Dx+0QA(x, 01/0'! fl!
~ a.0
(3.42)
Chapter I. Foundations of Y'DO Theory
28
Next we state two well-known algebraic lemmas. Lemma 3.3 (Leibniz' rule). Let f(x) and g (x) be two smooth functions in an open set X c lR" and a a multi-index. Then
(f(x) g(x)) _ Y_
r+6=a Yab
[ayf(x)] [a°g(x)]
(3.43)
Lemma 3.4 (Newtons binomial formula). Let x, y e 1R" and a a multi-index, then
(x+y)a _
a .i Y_
xyyd.
(3.44)
,.+,$=a Y.8
Exercise 3.5. Prove Lemmas 3.3 and 3.4. Hint. (3.44) can be shown by induction or by using the Taylor formula for polynomials. (3.43) is obtained from (3.44) by noting that
asU(x) g(x)] = {(ax+3,yV(x) g(y)]} 1r=x. Conclusion of the proof of Theorem 3.4. Rewrite (3.42) using Lemma 3.3. 034 a. 0. Y. b
.+e=a
_ Y_ (-1)ivi [ayae(x, 0.r.a
/
)] 100+6D.011+
.4 (x, )]PP!y!6!
(3.45)
(-1)lel\
= E Ex +\ +a=x E !a! y
J1 [ay 68(x, )] [ac'Dr+Ya, (x, )]lY!
We then obtain from (3.44) with x = -y = e, where e = (1,1, ...,1) and with a = x; x! ee( _ e e)
bjx 0+e=x
atb!
I' = x! E (1
$+s=x
/J18!
here S'x, is the Kronecker symbol, equal to I for x = 0 and 0 for I x 1 > 0. Because
of this relation, in (3.45) there only remain terms with x = 0, which proves (3.41).
Corollary 3.1. Let A E Loa(X), B E LQa(X), 0 S 8 < p< 1, and assume that B is properly supported. Then the operators A B and B A viewed Loa+m,(X). as operators from CO '(X) to C' (X) belong to
Proof. Decompose A into sumA = A, + R, where A, is properly supported and R has a kernel R (x, y) a C°° (X x X). It is easily verified that the operators
§3. The Algebra of Pseudodifferential Operators and Their Symbols
29
BR and RB have smooth kernels equal to B R (x, y) and 'Br R (x, y) respectively, where Bx operates on x keeping y fixed and analogously for `B,,. The assertion of the corollary now follows from Theorem 3.4.
3.7 Classical symbols and pseudodifferential operators. It is sometimes convenient to consider narrower classes of `PDO. Here we describe one of this classes, closed under the majority of the necessary conditions.
Definition 3.5. By a classical symbol we mean a function a (x, 0) E C" (X x IR") such that for some complex m these is an asymptotic expansion 00
a(x,0)
E W(0)
a'"-;(x,0),
j=o
where w E C' (1R"), iy (0) = 0 for 101 S 1/2, v (0) = I for 101 z 1, and a", _j (x, 0) is positive homogeneous of degree m -j in 0, i. e. a, _ j (x, t 0) = t" -j a, _j (x, 0) for all t > 0 and (x, 0) e X x (IR"\0). Denote the class of all symbols fulfilling these
requirements by CSm(X x RN). Furthermore, denote by CL"(X) the class of `PDO which can be written in the form (2.18) with a(x, y.1;) E CS"(X X X X IR"). These operators will be called classical PDO.
If ak(x, 0) is positive homogeneous of degree k in 0, then 8;8fak(x, 0) is positive homogeneous of degree k - I a I in 0. Therefore it is clear that CSTM(X X R"),= SRem(X X 1RN) .
Proposition 3.7. a) If A E CL'" (X) and is properly supported, then a, (x, S) E CSt'(X x IR"). b) If A e CL"* (X) and B e CL!", (X) and both are properly supported then BAECL'",+'"1(X). c) If A e CL'"(X), then 'A E CL!"(X) and A* E CL'"(X).
Proof. Follows immediately from Theorems 3.1-3.4. Thus the class of all classical `PDO is closed under composition, taking the adjoint, and the transpose. In what follows we will show that it is also closed under changing variables, taking the parametrixes (cf. §5) and complex powers of an elliptic operator.
3.8 Exercises and problems
Exercise 3.6. Show the following generalization of Leibniz's rule (3.43): if
p (x, ) = E a, (x) °, and p (x, D) is the corresponding differential operator, then
1219-
p (x, D) (f(x) g(x)) = Y [p'"l(x,D) f(x)1 [D°8(x)]/a!, "
where p("(x, ) = a, 4,p (x, ).
(3.46)
Chapter I. Foundations of `PDO Theory
30
Exercise 3.7. Derive theorem 3.4 for differential operators from the result of Exercise 3.6.
Exercise 3.8. Let x, , xs , ... , xk be n-vectors and a an n-dimensional multiindex. Prove that a.i a
(xl+x2+... +xk)a=
k'
-
a, '
... xkI.
(3.47)
'
Deduce from this that for any smooth functions fl, ... , fk da U (x) ... fk(x)]
ai =a,+. Ya,=a a, !
.
akt (a°1-f, ) (x)
... (aa.f)(x).
(3.48)
Exercise 3.9. Given a function a (x,) E SQ s (X x IR"), X an open set in IR",
show that there exists a properly supported `I'DO A in X, such that a -aA E S-°°(X x IR"). Hint. Consider the operator given by (2.18) with a(x,y, where Z (x, y) is the same as in the proof of Proposition 3.3.
y (x, y) a(x, ),
Exercise 3.10. Derive from Exercises 2.4 and 3.9 that the operation of taking the symbol defines (for b < e) an isomorphism Le.a(X)/L-'°(X)
SQ 8(X x IR")/S-°"(X x IR").
Problem 3.1. Consider the following operator in R"
u(y)dydc,
Au(x)=
(3.49)
where a (x, ) satisfies
laga°a(x,)I
Cae<>"'-Qiai+aiei
(3.50)
Assume that B > 0 and b < 1. Attach a meaning to the integral (3.49) in the following two situations; a) u (x) a S(IR"); b) u (x) E C6 (IR") i. e. I as u (x) I < C. for an arbitrary multi-index a. Show that A defines a continuous transformation of the spaces S(IR") and Cb (IR") into themselves. Show that the symbol a (x, ) is
uniquely defined by the action of A on S(W) or Cb' (W). Problem 3.2. Show that the operators of the form described in Problem 3.1 form an algebra with involution and obtain an asymptotic formula for the symbols of the composition of two operators, of the transpose and of the adjoint operator. Problem 3.3. Let K(x, z) E C" (X x (lR"\0)) be positive homogeneous in z of
degree - n and let S
I=1- I
K(x,z)dS.=O
(3.51)
§4. Change of Variables and Pseudodifferential Operators on Manifolds
31
(integral over the sphere I z I = 1). Show that for u c- Co (X), the following limit exists
Au(x) = lim
J
K(x, x-y) u(y)dy,
(3.52)
i0 Ix-Ylit defining a `I'DO A E CL°(X). The operator A, defined by (3.52) (under condition (3.51)), is called a singular
integral operator. We see that such operators are just special cases of Y'DO. Remark. The solution of Problem 3.2 can be found in one of the works of Kumano-go [1 ]-[3], and the solution of Problem 3.3 can be extracted from the book of Mihlin [1 ]. The solutions of these problems are rather laborious but very useful for understanding 'PDO theory.
§4. Change of Variables and Pseudodifferential Operators on Manifolds 4.1 The action of change of variables on a `PDO. Given a diffeomorphism x: X - X, from one open set X c IR" onto another open set X, C 1R", the induced transformation x': C' taking a function u to the function u o x, is an isomorphism and transforms Co (X,) into Co (X). Let A be a `PDO on X
and define A,: Co
with the help of the commutative diagram
CO (X) A Cs (X) x-J Co_(X,)
A.
.
i-C_(XI)
If xt = x-', then A, u = [A (u o x)] o xl .
(4.1)
Let A be given by (2.18), then
A,u(x) = J
Jei(xI(x)-Y) c a(x,(x),
y = x, (z), we obtain
A,u(x)=
Idetxi(z)Iu(z)dzdd,
(4.2)
where x, is the Jacobi matrix of the transformations xi. It follows from this that A, is a FIO with phase function d' (x, y, ) _ (x, (x) - x1 (y)) 0. We will show, that for 1 - Q < S < q the operator A, is a `I'DO. This fact can be obviously derived from the following more general theorem.
Chapter I. Foundations of `I'DO Theory
32
Theorem 4.1. Let 0 be a phase function in X x X x IR", such that 1) P (x, y, 0) is linear in 0; 2) 0,'(x, y, 0) = 0'e' x = y.
Let A, be a FIO with phase function 4>(x, y, 0) and a(x, y, 0) E Saa (X x X x IR") (cf. formula (2.1)), where
1-QSS
(4.3)
Then A, e LQ, j (X).
For the proof we need Lemma 4.1. Let the phase function 'P satisfy conditions 1) and 2) of theorem 4.1. Then there exists a neighbourhood S2 of the diagonal d C X x X and a COO-map i/r : S2 -+ GL(n, IR) (non-degenerate matrix-function 1`r(x, y)), such that (4.4) (x, y) E S2, 'P(x,Y, W (x,Y)c) _ (x-y) - , where
det'P,(x,y,0)1,,=x= 1.
detyr(x,x)
(4.5)
Proof. We have
0(x,Y,0)
.0j(x,Y)0;,
(4.6)
where 0; (x, x) = 0 and if 'P (x, y) = 0, j = 1 , 2, ... , n, then x = y. Further "
ox.e =
;i ax,
0;,
..., fi
a4s;
ax"
0,, 4s, ,
... 10
Note that differentiation of the relation 45 (x, x, 0) = 0 with respect to x shows that 'P;, (x =,, = - Px 1 x s,. Now, by definition of the phase function 4sx , e * 0 for 0 * 0, so in order that 0#'(x, x, 0) = 0, it is necessary that
'P (x, x, 0) $ 0, i.e. for arbitrary 0 + 0 there exists k, 16 k S n, such that "
a0,
l
axk x=y
0 * 0.
It follows that det
(a'; (x, Y) (4.7)
``
axk
J
By the Hadamard Lemma we have O; (x, Y)
4sk; (x, Y) (xk - Y0, k=1
§4. Change of Variables and Pseudodifferential Operators on Manifolds
33
for close x and y, Pkj E C°° (ST), ST some neighbourhood of the diagonal in
X x X and (x, x) _
aoj (x, Y) (4.8)
(0xk
1.=y
Denoting by 0(x, y) the matrix (Pkj(x, y))_ , we see from (4.7) and (4.8) that there exists a neighbourhood 0 of the diagonal in Ix X such that det 41(x, y) 4 0 for (x, y) E Q. Put W (x, Y) = 0(x,Y)-1.
(4.9)
Since 45 (x,Y,0) _
j.k=1
-Oki(x,Y) ©j(xk-Yk) = (x-Y) - (4 (x,Y)0),
and putting t1 (x, y) 9 = , we clearly obtain (4.4). The formula (4.5) follows from (4.8) and (4.9). Proof. of Theorem 4.1. In view of Proposition 2.1 and Exercise 2.4 we may assume that A is given by (2.1), where a (x, y, 0) = 0 for (x, y) t 0' with Q' any neighbourhood of the diagonal. Making the change of variables 0 = W (x, y) in the integral (2.1), we obtain
A1u(x)=
IdetW(x,Y)I u(Y)dydl.
(4.10)
It remains only to remark that for a, (x, y, ) = a (x, y, W (x, y) ) condition (4.3) guarantees that a1 (x, y, ) E SQ a (X x X x lR"), in view of Lemma 1.2. El
4.2 Formulae for transformations of symbols
Theorem 4.2. Given a diffeomorphism x: I-' X1 and a properly supported `PDO A E Lo 8 (X) with I - Q 5 8 < g, let A l be determined by (4.1). Then Q.1,(Y, 1)ly=x(x)^ L
a
a
(x, ) = 8'aA(x, ) and xx (z) is given by
xx (z) = x (z) - x (x) - x'(x) (z - X).
(4.12)
Proof. Note first of all that the function x, (z) has a zero of second order for z = x. Therefore, denoting
0.(x,n)=D=elx;(=) "I:=x,
(4.13)
Chapter 1. Foundations of'VDO Theory
34
we have that 4>a (x, q) is a polynomial in q of degree no higher than I a 1/2. Taking
Lemma 1.2 into consideration, we see that vI
=
S' -(e-1/2)121 (XxIR").
But from the condition I - p < b < p it follows that p > 1/2, so the asymptotic sum (4.11) is well defined. To prove formula (4.11), we utilize formula (4.2) with a (x, y, 0) = a,, (x, 0). Using the transformation described in the proof of Theorem 4.1, we get A, u (x) = J J e' -r) " aA (xi (x), W (x, Y) q) D (x, Y) u (y) dy dq ,
(4.14)
where D (x,),) = I det x, (x) I I det' (x, y) 1. By Theorem 3.1, we have QA,(Xl q) - Y- aMDy [aA(xi (x), W (x,Y)q)D(x,Y)]/
!
I
r=..
(4.15)
a
From the terms with multi-index a, we obtain (before substituting x = y) a sum of terms of the form c(x,Y) 01'0'A
W (x,Y)q),
(4.16)
where c (x, y) depends only on the diffeomorphism (but not on A). For the multiindices y and Q in (4.16) we have the estimates I13I < 21a1,
(4.17)
I'I+IalsIll.
(4.18)
Here, (4.17) is obvious and (4.18) follows from the fact that applying Dy to expressions of the type (4.16) does not change I Q I - I Y I and 0, increases I /31 - I Y I
by 1.
From (4.17) and (4.18) we have
II 11l-lal: 11l-1/31/2=1/31/2.
(4.19)
Note now, that applying (4.5) to 0 (x, y, 0) = (x, (x) - x, (y)) 0 gives w (x, x) = (`x, (x))-'. Also, rearranging in (4.15) the terms of the form (4.16), collecting together all the terms with the same /3, we obtain
aT'(xi(x), (`xiWY `q) Pp(x,q)//3!,
aA,(x,1)
(4.20)
9
where'P0(x, q) is a polynomial in q of degree no higher than 1131/2 (with C°°(X,)-
coefficients) and independent of A. Here To
1.
§4. Change of Variables and Pseudodifferential Operators on Manifolds
35
Replacing x by x(x) in (4.20) we easily obtain the equivalent formula aA,(X(x),n)
Q°'(x> 5'(x),)
(4.21)
A
where 'P (x, n) is a polynomial inn of degree no higher than 1#1/2 (with C°° (X)coefficients) independent of A and where 4P0 - 1. It remains to show that these polynomials are given by (4.13).
We will compute the polynomials P (x, q) with the help of differential operators. For the differential operator A we have iy' q
ly=x(x) CA,(Y,q)ly=x(x)-e = e-ix(=)'" aA(z D:) eix(x) "I 1:=x A)ely."
(4.22)
(here a, (z, D:) denotes the operator A, acting on the variable z). We write now x (Z) = X (x) + X' (x) (z - x) + Xi (Z),
from which
(z) q-x'`X'(x)n.
X(z)
Putting this into formula (4.22), we obtain 0 A, (Y, i) l y=x(x) = e-' ',(x), {aA (Z, Dz) eis 'x'(x)q eix;(Z) q,l I. -x
(4.23)
Now use the Leibniz rule (3.46) (Exercise 3.6) to differentiate the product of two exponents in (4.23). We then obtain clearly
aA,(X(x),n)=Y-
1
aA(a)
(x,fX'(x)n)'Da
a)
:eix:(:)
I==x
(4.24)
(we have used here yet another obvious formula for differentiating a linear exponent : aA (z, D:) a i= - c =
e11-4
aA (z, c))
Formula (4.24) signifies the validity for differential operators of (4.13) for
the polynomials P] (x, q) in (4.21). But in view of the universality of the polynomials 0a(x,n), then (4.13) is valid also in the general case. Examples. 00 = 1, 4i,=O for I P 1= 1, bg (x, )7) = Dr (i x (x) n) for I Ii I = 2. Corollary 4.1.
0A,(Y,n) - aA(XI(Y), (N
i(Y))-ln) ESQ a
z(o-)lz)(X1 xlR").
(4.25)
This statement shows, that modulo symbols of lower order, the symbols of all operators obtained from A by a change of variables form a well-defined function on the cotangent bundle TX.
36
Chapter I. Foundations of `l'DO Theory
Corollary 4.2. If A E CL"(X ), then A, e CL'" (X, ).
Proof. Obvious from formula (4.11).
4.3 Pseudodifferential operators on a manifold. Let M be a smooth ndimensional manifold (of class C"'). We will denote by C' (M) and Co (M) the space of all smooth complex-valued functions on M and the subspace of all functions with compact support respectively. Assume that we are given a linear operator
A: C(M)-C(M). If X is some chart in M (not necessarily connected) and x: X -. X, its diffeomorphism onto an open set X, c 1R", then let A 1 be defined by the diagram
C( (X)
'' i C°°(X)
CC (X,)
"-' -C"(X1)
(note, in the upper row is the operator ra.o A o ia., where ix. is the natural embedding iX: Co (X) - Co (M) and rx is the natural restriction rX: C"(M) - C' (X); for brevity we denote this operator by the same letter A as the original operator).
Definition 4.1. An operator A: C o (M) -. C°` (M) is called a pseudodifferential operator on M if for any chart diffeomorphism x: X - X, the operator A I defined above is a `'DO on X 1.
Theorem 4.1 shows that the `PDO on an open set X C IR" for 1-Q 3 < Q are `PDO on the manifold X. Furthermore, from Lemma 1.2, we see that the class of symbols SQ a(T*M), as well as the class of operators LQ,,,(M), are well-defined for I - o <_ 6 < o, and Lemma 4.1 shows that the principal symbol is well-defined as an element of the S"'.,(T*M)/S'"-2,Q-1/2)(T*M). quotient space Q. Q. Also, in view of Theorem 4.2 the class of classical `PDO CL'"(M) is welldefined on M. If A E CL"(M), then the principal symbol of A can be considered as a homogenous function a,, (x, c) on T*M with degree of homogeneity equal to m, since two functions a, (x, ) and a2 (x,1;), positively homogeneous in for I I z I of degree m, which define the same equivalence class in Sm(X x 1R") modulo S' -1(X x 1R"), must coincide for I I >_ 1. In conclusion note, that it is essential to allow the use of non-connected charts in definition 4.1, since otherwise we would have to consider the reflection f (x) -. f(- x) in C'0 (IRS {0}) as a pseudo-differential operator.
§4. Change of Variables and Pseudodifferential Operators on Manifolds
37
Exercise 4.1. Show that a `PDO A on a manifold M can be extended by continuity to a mapping
A: 4f'(M) - 9'(M) where t' (M) and 9' (M) denote the spaces dual to the spaces of smooth sections and smooth sections with compact support respectively of the line bundle of densities I A"(T*M) I. (This bundle can be defined for instance, by choosing a covering of M by charts, regarding the bundle as trivial on each chart and setting
the transition functions equal to the absolute values of the Jacobians of the coordinate transformations. The sections of the density bundle can be integrated on the manifold, which cannot be said of exterior n-forms, where one needs an orientation, i.e. essentially an isomorphism between A"(T*M) and I A"(T*M) 1. If we fixed a smooth positive density on M, then this gives us an isomorphism of the bundle I A"(T*M) I and M x 1R', which allows us to consider functions as densities and therefore to view the elements in if'(M) and 9'(M) as functionals on functions.)
The inclusion C'(M)c- 9'(M), inducing the inclusion Ca (M)- or'(M), is defined in a natural way by the formula
(4.26)
M
where u e C'°(M) and (p is a smooth density with compact support (so that u
(P
is also a smooth density with compact support). Verify the property of pseudolocality for the operator A. it:
Exercise 4.2. Let E and F be smooth vector bundles on the manifold M; let be the natural projection; n*Eand n*Fthe induced vector bundles
over T'M. Define a `PDO A : Ca (M, E) -+ C°°(M, F) (Co (M, E) the space of smooth compactly supported sections of E and C°°(M, F) that of the smooth sections of F) and show that its principal symbol is a well-defined element in the space SQ e(Hom(n*E, 1t*F))/SQ a
2 (a-112) (Hom(n*E,n*F)).
Problem 4.1. Let A be a differential operator of order m on a manifold M (an operator A: C o (M) -+ Co (M), such that any operator A 1: Co (X1) -' Co' (X1), as defined before, is a differential operator of order m). Give an invariant definition of the principal symbol a function on T*M which is a homogeneous polynomial of order m in (i.e. along the fibres).
Hint. Use the formula lim
2q. eC°°(M).
(4.27)
Chapter I. Foundations of'I'DO Theory
38
Problem 4.2. Compute the principal symbol of the (de Rham) exterior differentiation operator: d: AD (M) - i1v+' (M) ,
where A"(M) denotes the space of smooth exterior k-forms on M (k = 0, .. , n).
Problem 4.3. Prove that the one-dimensional singular integral operator on
a smooth closed curve r c c Au(t) = a(t) u(t) + lim
!
`.,p It-alas
K(t, T)
t-T
u(T)dr,
t, T er,
for a(t) E C110 (F), K(t, T) E Co (Jr x r), is a classical `PDO and belongs to
the class CL°(r).
§5. Hypoellipticity and Ellipticity 5.1 Definition of hypoelliptic symbols, operators and examples
Definition 5.1. A function a (x, ) e C Z (X x IR"), where X is an open set in IR", is called a hypoelliptic symbol if the following conditions are fulfilled: a) there exist real numbers m(, and m, such that for an arbitrary compact set
Kc X one can find positive constants R, C, and C2 such that C2
IfI ? R, xeK;
(5.1)
b) there exist numbers P and 6, with 0:5;6 < Q 51, and for each compact set K c X a constant R such that for any multi-indices a and fi
IfI ? R, xeK,
(5.2)
with some constant C,,B, K . Denote by HSQ a °(X x IR") the class of symbols satisfying (5.1) and (5.2) for
fixed m, m0, p and 6. Sometimes we will denote this space simply by HS,',"*, if the domain X is obvious (or irrelevant). From (5.1) and (5.2) it obviously follows that
HSQ',°(XxJR")cSQ, (XxIR").
We will denote by H La a ° (X ), X open, the class of properly supported `PDOA for which CA(x,t;) E HSQa °(X x IR").
§5. Hypoellipticity and Ellipticity
39
Definition 5.2. A 'PDO A is called hypoelliptic if there exists a prop-
erly supported 'PDO Al E HL" °(X) such that A = A, + R,, where R, E L-°°(X), i.e. R, is an operator with infinitely differentiable kernel.
Note, for any representation of the hypoelliptic operator A in the form A = A, + R, , where A, is a properly supported PDO and R, is an operator with smooth kernel, it is true that A, e HLQ; a '(X).
Example 5.1. Let A be a differential operator, i.e. A = aa(X)D°, with lalsm a" e C°°(X). Denote by am(x, ) the principal symbol
am (x, ) _ Y a(x).
(5.3)
Iat=m
Definition 5.3. A differential operator A is called elliptic, if
am(x, ) + 0
(x, ) E X x (IR"\0) .
for
(5.4)
Proposition 5.1. The following conditions are equivalent for a differential operator A: a) A is elliptic;
b) AEHUI;o(X). Proof. The implication b) a) is obvious. To show the converse implication, we introduce the complete symbol of the operator A
a (x, ) = Y_ a(x) `
(5.5)
IsI sm
and notice that, if a) is fulfilled, then a(x, ) = 1
am (x, )
where the functions b _j (x, ) a C°° (X x (R"\ 0)) are homogeneous in 4 of degree
-j. From this (5.1) follows with m = mo and (5.2) is obtained similarly. O Examples of elliptic operators:
the Laplace operator
d=
a2
a2
in iI";
ax + ... + ax^
the Cauchy-Riemann operator
a a2
=
a
ax,
+i
a axe
Example 5.2. The heat operator a
a
at-d=at-a
a2
a2
-
-ax2
is hypoelliptic in 1R"+', although it is not elliptic.
in 1R2.
40
Chapter 1. Foundations of `l'DO Theory
Exercise 5.1. Verify the hypoellipticity of the heat operator and find the corresponding in, mo, p, S. Example 5.3. Let A be a classical `l'DO with principal symbol a," (x, ). Then the following definition makes sense.
Definition 53'. An operator A E CL'"(X) is called elliptic, if its principal symbol a. (x, ,) satisfies condition (5.4).
As in the proof of Proposition 5.1 it is easy to verify that if A E CL"(X) is properly supported then its ellipticity is equivalent to the inclusion A E HL" '(X). (X). Generally, A E CLm(X) is elliptic if and only if A = At + R where AI E HL" L",0" and R E L'°°(X). Examples 5.1 and 5.3 motivate the following
Definition 5.3". An operator A E Lma(X) is called elliptic if A = AI + R where Al E HLQa (X) and R E L
Proposition 5.1'. For a properly supported A E L',,,(X) (X) to be elliptic it is necessary and sufficient that the condition a) in Definition 5.1 is satisfied for
its symbol with mo = m. Generally A E L(X) is elliptic if and only if A = A I + R where A 1 is properly supported and the condition a) in Definition 5.1 is satisfied for the symbol of A 1 with mo = m. In this case this is true for any presentation A = AI + R as above.
Proof. The proof is left to the reader as an excercise.
0
5.2 Basic properties of hypoelliptic symbols. First of all, say that a (x, ) E SQ a for large , if for any compact set K c X there is an R = R (K), such that v (x, ) is defined for x e K, I I >_ R (K) and for these (x, c) all the necessary estimates of type (1.10) are fulfilled. If, in addition, the estimates (5.1) and (5.2) are fulfilled, we say that a (x, ) E HSQ "0 for large 4. Note that if a (x, ) belongs to SQa or HS','- for large then, multiplying by a smooth cut-off function Vi (x, ), equal to 1 "for large " (e. g. for x e K, I I z R(K) + 2 for any compact set K) and equal to 0 in a neighbourhood of the set where the symbol a is not defined (e.g. for x e K, I t I < R (K) + 1), we obtain a symbol a1(x, ) E SQa(X x IR°) or HSQa °(X x IR") respectively, which coincides with a(x, ) "for large ". Lemma 5.1. If a (x, ) E HSQ o jor large 4, then a -' (x, c) E HS,-'-' a -'for a multi-indices a, ft we have for large large . Furthermore, for arbitrary , that a240!a (x, )/a (x, ) ESQ.8I"1 +aIBI
Proof. Let y = (x, ) and y, S be 2n-dimensional multi-indices. By induction in 16 1 one verifies that
§5. Hypoellipticity and Ellipticity
_
E1aYa(Y)
a(Y)
161
ca,...a, k
41
as°Q(Y) a(Y)
k
a6a(Y)
(5.6)
rn a(y)
Obviously, setting y = (J1, a) we obtain from the definitions all the necessary estimates for the proof of the lemma. El Lemma 5.2. If or' e HSQ ,
and a" E HS, 7j "; then a' o a" a HSQ .g
Proof. Direct from the Leibniz rule.
+
;l
Lemma 5.3. If a (x, ) E HS,'-'"- and r (x, ) e SQ -j, where m, < mo , then
a + r a (1 + r/a) and using Lemmas 5.1 and 5.2, we see that it suffices to consider the case or = I and mo = m = 0, i.e. m, < 0. But then the assertion of the lemma is trivial. Lemma 5.4. Let a (x, 4) E HS,,- e ' for large and let a, (y, q) = a (x (y), (y, q)), where the map (y, rl) --+ (x(y), (x, q)) is a Coo map from X I x (NV \ 0) into X x (1W' \ 0) and where 4(y, rl) is positive homogeneous of degree 1 in rl. Assume that 1-Q < S < Q. Then a, (y, rl) E HS."" ° for large >l.
Proof. Completely analogous to the proof of Lemma 1.2 and is left to the reader. 5.3 Basic properties of hypoelliptic operators Proposition 5.2.
If
A' c- HLQ a°'a (X)
and
A" e HL-,,. "y"; (X),
then
A' o A" E HLQ. j mm"-;+,m°(X)
Proof. By theorem 3.4 aA'A-(x, 0 - aA'(x,
1 + Y
)
L
12121
ark
aA'
and from Lemmas 5.1 and 5.3, we see that the series in square brackets is an asymptotic sum which (in the sense of Proposition 3.4) belongs to HSQ a° . It remains to use Lemma 5.2. Proposition 53. If A E HLQ:6'(X), then both 'A and A* belong to HE,", e o(X).
Proof. Similar to the proof of the preceeding proposition. Proposition 5.4. If A E HLQ;; ^(r) and R E V," ,-,(X) with m, < ma, where R is properly supported, then A+ R EHLQ:a o(X).
Proof. The statement follows immediately from Lemma 5.3. Proposition 5.5. If I - L q< S < e, then HL!,":'-(X) is invariant with respect to
changes of variables i.e. if we are given a diffeomorphism x: X-+ X, and an operator A 1 is defined as in §4 (formula (4.1)), then A I E H L'"'"'0 (X ).
42
Chapter 1. Foundations of TDO Theory
Proof. By Lemma 5.4 0' .4 (X I (y), ('X; (y))-
-" (X)
(here x, = x-1). But then, by Theorem 4.2 and Lemma 5.1, it is obvious that QA, (y, q) = QA (x1 (y), (`x'1 (y))-' q) (1 +r(y, 1)), where r (y, q) e SQ. 2(e -' n) for large q. The assertion of the proposition now a follows from Lemmas 5.2 and 5.3.
O
Proposition 5.5 allows us to define the class HL" °(M) of hypo-elliptic TDO to an arbitrary manifold M provided I - Q = S < Q. 5.4 The parametrix and the rough regularity theorem Theorem 5.1. Let A e HLQ; a "(M), with either 1 - Q = S < Q or b < Q and M a
such that
domain in W. Then there exists an operator BEHLQ
BA = I + R1,
AB = I + R2,
(5.7)
where Rt e L- ' (M), j = 1, 2, and I is the identity operator. If, furthermore, B' is which either B'A = I + R; or AB' = I + Rz (where
another TDO for
R,'E L- (M)), then B'- BE L-'O (M). Corollary 5.1. If A is a hypoelliptic 1PDO on M (not necessarily properly supported), then there exists a properly supported TDO B, such that (5.7) holds.
Proof of Theorem 5.1. First let M be a domain X in IR" and aA the symbol of
A. Consider a function bo (x,) E HSQ e -'"(X x IR") such that bo (,r, )
= a,' (x, ) for large . Next choose a properly supported operator B E HLQ - -'"(X) such that o80 - bo c- S -'° (X x IR"). Let us verify that BOA = 1+ RO,
(5.8)
with RO a LQ tg-°'(X).
In fact, by Theorem 3.4 we have for large
a,A(x, )^ 1+I2IY l al o
1
i
a 'DxaA=1-1
D.QA
1
1x121 at
a;'
6A
and it remains to use Lemma 5.1. Now let Co be a properly supported PDO such that CO
CO
Y J=O
i. e.
§5. Hypoellipticity and Ellipticity
43
X
oc.
Y (-1)j j=0
From (5.9) we clearly have
C0(I+Ro) - IEL', so that putting B, = C0B0, we have
B,A=1+R,
(5.10)
where R, eL-°°(X). From the construction it is clear that B, E HLQ sy -"'(X). Further, we can similarly construct an operator B2 EHLQ b^ -"'(X), such that A B2 = I+ R2
(5.11)
where R, a L- °° M. Let us now verify, that if B, and B2 are two arbitrary `FDO, for which (5.10)
and (5.11) hold, then B, - B2 E L-°°(X). This will then also demonstrate the existence of the required B (for which we may take either of the operators B, and B2) and its uniqueness (modulo L- `° (X)). Note, that B, and B. can be taken to be properly supported. Multiplying (5.10) on the right by B2 and using (5.11), we obtain B, - B2 = R, B2 - B, R2 and it only remians to note that B, R2 and R, B2 both belong to L- `° (X). Now let M = U XY be an arbitrary manifold with a covering by charts X7. Then, (by the results just shown) there is a properly supported operator BY in X",
such that
B'-A=I+R",
A- B''=I+R2,
where R; and RI are operators with smooth kernels. Now let (pj, j = 1, 2, ..., be a partition of unity subordinate to the covering of M by the X. This means that the following conditions are fulfilled: 1) (pi E Co (M), Qj > 0, suppcpj C XY for some y = y(j); 2) for any x E M, there exists a neighbourhood IM, of x in M, such that W, intersects only a finite number of sets supp Vj;
3)(pi=1.
(See e.g. Theorem 6.20 in Rudin [1].) Now let us construct functions tfj E Co (M) such that they still satisfy the conditions 1) and 2) above (with the same y(j)) and in addition if/j = 1 in a neighbourhood of supp pj. Denote by Oj and Wj the multiplication operators by fpj and >lij respectively. We set then
B = E OjBY(j),Iii
Chapter I. Foundations of `PDO Theory
44
where necessary operations of restriction and extension by zero are understood. We claim that then B satisfies all the required conditions. Clearly B is properly supported. Note also that on the intersection X Y tl X Y' the operators BY and BY' differ by an operator with a smooth kernel, so modulo operators from L-00 they may be given by the same symbol. This allows us to
calculate the compositions BA and AB modulo L-°° using the composition formula (3.41). For example, the symbol of BA will locally have the form aBA(x, )
a O;(x)(a' ae(x, ))D«(aA(x, )P;(x))
If we apply a derivative in x to P;, then the resulting term will vanish because 45; D; WL; - 0 for any a 0 0. Therefore we conclude that aBA(x,
'Pi(x)y;(x)
which is equivalent to the first relation in (5.7). The proof of the second relation is not different. O
Remark. The formula for the parametrix B above can be simplified if we add small neighbourhoods of supp rp; to the set of all XY. In this case we can simply write
B=E Y
where (py satisfy the same properties as (pj above and it is understood that some of the functions co can be identically 0. If M is a closed manifold then we can also assume the covering (XY) to be finite, so the formula for B will be a finite sum.
Definition 5.4. An operator B satisfying the condition (5.7) is called a parameirix of the operator A. Corollary 5.2. Any elliptic operator AeLQ,a(M) has a parametrix BeHLQ
a hypoelliptic 1'DO, then sing supp Au = sing supp u,
u e e' (M) .
(5.12)
In other words, if S2 is an open submanifold of M, then Au JQ e C'° (Q) if and only if u JOEC'(S2).
If A is a properly supported hypoelliptic `YDO, then (5.12) is true for an arbitrary distribution u E 2'(M).
§5. Hypoellipticity and Ellipticity
45
Proof. It obviously suffices to prove the first part of the theorem. For this, the inclusion sing supp Au c sing supp u follows from the pseudolocality of A (cf.
Proposition 2.4) and it only remains to show the inclusion sing supp u c sing supp Au
(5.13)
Let B be a properly supported parametrix of A. Then, from the formula u = B(Au) - R,u and the pseudolocality of B, it follows that sing supp u c sing supp (Au) using supp R, u, and since R, u e C°° (M), we have that sing supp R, u = O proving (5.13).
Theorem 5.2 is a rough regularity theorem for solutions of hypoelliptic equations of the form Au = f More precise theorems will be proved after we have introduced exact regularity classes of functions, i.e. the scale of Sobolev spaces.
5.5 A parametrix for classical elliptic pseudo-differential operators. In this case a parametrix can be constructed in a much more explicit way. Let A be a classical'PDO in an open set X C IR", whose symbol for large r; admits the asymptotic expansion z x
a(x,S)
j=o
(5.14)
a. (x, S),
(x, ) E C°° (X x (IR" \0)), a,"_; is positive homogeneous of degree where m - j in l and also satisfies the ellipticity condition (5.4). Let B be a parametrix of A. We will show that B is a classical'PDO, whose symbol b(x, ) for large admits an asymptotic expansion
b-m-i(x,5),
b(x,
(5.15)
J=O
where b
(x, ) e C`° (X x (R"\0)) and b
_j (x, ) is positive homogeneous
of degree - m -j in g. The composition formula shows that the symbol b (x, ) must satisfy the condition 1, or 1 .
k.i
(5.16)
Chapter 1. Foundations of'PDO Theory
46
Clearly, regrouping the terms in (5.16) by their homogeneity degree we make (5.16) into just an equality of the corresponding homogeneous components, i.e.
E
tam-k(x,) Dxb-m-i(x,)l«! = So,
p = 0, 1, ....
(5.17)
k+j+lal-D
or, more explicitly am a,,,
(a*gam-k)
(DXb_._1)/a! = 0,
j = 1, 2, ... (5.17")
k+l+lal=j '<j
Clearly, from (5.17) the functions b_.-;(x, 4), positive homogeneous of de-
grees -m - j (j = 0, 1, ...), are uniquely defined. If we now define b(x, ) by (5.15) and find a properly supported'PDO B such that aB (x, b(x, ) E S-°°(X x IR"), then this operator B is a parametrix of A. Formula (5.17) defines a parametrix of A also in the case when A is a matrix PDO: in this case are square matrix functions and the ellipticity condition takes the form (x, ) E (X x (IR" \ 0)
det am (x, ) $ 0,
(5.18)
Problem 5.1. Show that the terms b _ m _, (x, ) (j > 0) in the parametrix of the classical elliptic operator A in the scalar case can be expressed via am -,t (x, 4) by 2j+1
,
b_m-j(x, ) = Y c,(x, ) (am(x,
(5.19)
1=2
where c, (x, ) is a function positive homogenous of degree m (1-1) -j in , polynomial in the functions am , a.-,, ..., am _; and their derivatives of order <j. The analogous formula in the matrix case is of the form 2j+1
b- m -; (x, ) =
(x, )
1
fl (ck., (x, S) a;' (x, )]
1=2 k=1
.
(5.20)
§6. Theorems on Boundedness and Compactness of Pseudodifferential Operators 6.1 Formulation of the basic boundedness theorem. Let A be a'PDO in IR". Consider A as a map A : Co (lR") - C'° (lR") .
§6. Theorems on Boundedness and Compactness of Pseudodifferential Operators 47
Let K,, be the kernel of A in the sense of L. Schwartz. If supp IC4 , is compact in
IR" x IIt", then A defines a map A : Co (IR") - Co (R") .
Is it possible to extend the operator A to a continuous linear operator A : L2 (IR")
L2 (1R") ?
Clearly, this is so if and only if the following estimate holds IIAuII
CIlull,
uECo (IR"),
(6.1)
where C> 0 does not depend on u and II ' II denotes the norm in L2(IR") Theorem 6.1. Let A E LO O's (IR" ), 0
3 < Q < 1. and let supp KA be
compact in IR" x HR". Then (6.1) holds and A can be extended to a linear continuous operator on L' (UV). 6.2 Auxiliary results and proof of Theorem 6.1. In the sequel we will use the notation lim I a(x, ) I = lim sup I a (x, ) 1.
- Ici?t xeK
i
Theorem 6.2. Let A be a properly supported `YDO in LQ a (X), with 0 E < Q < 1 and X an open set in R". Suppose there exists a constant M such that lim
M
(6.2)
ui-W xeK
for any compact set K C X. Then there exists a properly supported integral operator R with hermitean kernel R E C°° (X x X), such that
(Au,Au)<M2(u,u)+(Ru,u),
ueC0 (X).
(6.3)
If, in addition, supp K,, is compact in X x X, then supp R is also compact in X x X.
Proof that Theorem 6.2 . Theorem 6.1. It suffices to show the boundedness
in L2(IR") of an operator R with smooth compactly supported kernel. This, however is well known (one can show for instance that 11R112 < f I KR (x, y)12
dxdy, where IIRII is the operator norm of R in L2(IR") and KR (x, y) is the kernel of the operator R). 0
To prove Theorem 6.2 it suffices, in view of the relation (Au, Au) _ (A" Au, u), to construct a properly supported operator B E LO a such that
A*A + B*B - M2 = R
(6.4)
48
Chapter I. Foundations of `1'DO Theory
where R has a smooth kernel (in which case R is properly supported since the left hand side of (6.4) is a properly supported operator). Rewriting (6.4) in the form B*B = M2 - A*A + R, we note that the symbol of M2 - A*A is equal to M2 - Ia., (x,4)12 modulo symbols of class SQ,60-8 (X), from which we infer lim_ Re [a(,a,_4.A) (x, 0] > 0
(6.5)
iti- W xeK
for an arbitrary compact set K c X. Therefore we derive Theorem 6.2 from the following proposition. Proposition 6.1. Let C e LQ, a (X) and be properly supported, 0 5 6< Q 5 I and let C* = C and assume lim Re ac(x, ) > 0 -fEK
for arbitrary compact sets K c X. Then there exists a properly supported operator
B E LQ4(X) such that R = B*B - C has a C°° kernel. Lemma 6.1. Let a (x, ) a SQ a (X x IR") and let a (x, c), for arbitrary (x, ) e X x IR", take values in a compact set K c C. Let a complex-valued junction
f(z) be defined on a neighbourhood of K and be infinitely differentiable as a function of two real variables Re z and Im z. Then
f (a (x, )) E SQS(X X M')
(6.7)
Proof.a Denote u = Rez and v = Im z. Then we evidently have vyJ (a(y)) =
Y_
x Op (Rea) ... ay.(Rea) from which (6.7) follows, since I (a;pvg1 f) (a (y))1:5 Cpq .
(a(y)) x
a;.(Ima),
(6.8)
1-j
Proof of Proposition 6.1. It follows from Lemma 6.1 that j/Re ac (x, ) belongs to SQ,,, for large . Therefore there exists a properly supported WM Bo E L°q a(X), such that if bo (x, ) is its symbol then
From this it follows that C - Bo B0 a L; (61? -6)(X).
(6.9)
The operator Bo serves as the "zero order approximation" to B. We will seek a first order approximation in the form Bo + B, , where B, e L.1 °"(X).
§6. Theorems on Boundedness and Compactness of Pseudodifferential Operators 49
We have
C- (Bo + Bi) (Bo + B,) = (C- Ba Bo) - (Bo B, + B* Bo) - Bi B,
.
(6.10)
The point is to reduce the order of the operator on the left-hand side, taking B1 to be properly supported with symbol b1 (x, ), such that for large
2b, (x, ) bo(x,) = ac_(x,),
(6.11)
which is obviously possible, since by Lemma 6.1 bo '(x, ) E S.O. a for large . It follows from (6.10) and (6.11), that
C-(Bo+B,)* (Bo+B,)EL..(6.12) Arguing by induction, we may in exactly the same way construct properly
supported `PDO B; E L(X), j = 0, 1, 2, ..., such that C - (Bo+ ... +B,)* (Bo+ ... +B;) ELQ aQ-s'(X).
(6.13)
Now let b1(x, ) be the symbol of B3 . It only remains to construct a properly
supported operator B, such that Y b, (x, ) i=o
It follows easily from (6.13), that this operator will be the one we are looking for.
Thus Proposition 6.1 is proved and together with it Theorems 6.1 and 6.2. D
6.3 The compactness theorem. We will derive the compactness theorem from the following much more general statement. Theorem 6.3. Let A E LQ,a(IR"), 0:!9 6 < q:5 1, let the kernel K,, have compact
support in IV x IR" and let the symbol a,, (x, ) satisfy I'M I a,, (x, c) I < M'
(6.14)
Then there exists an operator A, such that A - A, E L- (IR"), the kernel K,, has compact support and
IIA,uII S MIIuII,
ueCO (R").
(6.15)
P r o o f. Let X e C o (IR) be such that X (x) ? 0, f X (x) dx = 1, 0 < X 1. Such a function can be found. Indeed, to begin with let the function Xo (x) be such that Xo (x) a C o (IR"), Xo (x) z 0 and J Xo (x) d x = 1. Then obviously I Xo 1. Put now X (x) = f Xo (x+ y) Xo (y) dy. In view of the fact that j (e) = 110 ( ) I Z the I
function X (x) fulfills all the requirements.
50
Chapter I. Foundations of `YDO Theory
Now put xL(x) = E-"x(x/E) and define the operator AL by (6.16)
AL u = Au - A (xL * u),
where (xL * u) (x), the convolution of xL and u, is defined by
(XL*u)(x)= 1x.(x-y) u(y)dy= ju(x-y) X.(y)dy Now, in view of Theorem 6.2
IIALuII2 s M2IIu-xL*u112+ (R(u-xL*u), u-xL*u),
(6.17)
where R is an operator with kernel R (x, y) e Co (IR" x Ilk"). Note that the Fourier transform of u - xL * u is (1- 2 (En)) u ( ) and from the condition 0 < X < 1, it follows that
IIu-xL*ull < (lull.
(6.18)
Further, denote by RL the operator which maps u into R (u - xL * u), then its kernel is given by the formula
RL(x,y)= R(x,y) - IR(x,z)
E)
or
RL (x, y) = R (x, y) - I R (x, y + t z) x (z) dz,
from which it is obvious, that supp RL (x, y) lies in some fixed compact set K (independent of z for 0 < &:5 1) and, in addition, for
sup X. Y
It follows that II RL II -i 0 for a - 0. We now obtain from (6.17) and (6.18) that IIALu112 < M2IIu112+
IIRLUII (lull.
(6.19)
From the conditions of the theorem it is evident that we may replace M by M - 6, where b is sufficiently small. But then it follows from (6.19), that for sufficiently small z > 0 11ALuII2 s M211u112
Put A, = AL . Since the symbol of the convolution operator with xL is (Ed) e S - (1R" x IR"), it is evident that A - A, a L- W (IR"). It is also easily
verified, that the kernel KA of A, has compact support.
§6. Theorems on Boundedness and Compactness of Pseudodifferential Operators 51
Theorem 6.4. Let A e LQ (IR"), 0 <_ b < Q < 1, let the kernel KA have compact support and
sup la4(x,c)I-0
as
ICI -s +oo.
(6.20)
X
Then A extends to a compact operator in L2(IR").
Proof. By Theorem 6.3 there exists a decomposition A = A, + R, for arbitrary e > 0, where II Ar II < e and Re has a smooth compactly supported kernel
(and is thus compact). Therefore lim II A - R, II = 0 and the compactness of A follows.
r"0
Corollary 6.1. Let A E L,", j (IR"), 0 5 b < e5 1, m < 0 and K4 have compact support. Then A extends to a compact operator on L2 (IV).
6.4 The case of operators on a manifold. Consider first the case of a closed manifold M (a compact manifold without boundary). Using a partition of unity on M, it is easy to introduce a measure, having a smooth positive density with
respect to the Lebesgue measure in any local coordinates. If du is any such measure, the Hilbert space L2 (M, du) is defined. Note, that the elements and the
topology in L2 (M, dµ) do not depend on the choice of dµ. It is therefore meaningful to talk about the space I.? (df) as a topological vector space in which
the topology can be defined using some non-uniquely defined Hilbert scalar product. Theorems 6.1 and 6.4 obviously imply Theorem 6.5. Let M be a closed manifold, A e LQ (M), I - Q S 6 < Q. Then 1) operator A extends to a linear continuous operator
A: L2(M)-+L2(M); 2) if the principal symbol a,,(x, ) ESQ 8(T*M)ISQ,s a+' (T*M) satisfies cona?ticri (t .2-0) (k is the same for all representatives of u"ir r"yui'vaknt rC class in
S8(TM)/S'-'(TM)), then the operator so obtained is a compact operator L2(M) -4 L2(M).
Corollary 6.2. If A e Lr, d (M), i - Q 5 6 < Q and m < 0, then A extends to a compact operator
A: L2(M) - L2(M). We now formulate a version of the boundedness theorem, adequate for non-
compact M. For this we introduce the spaces LA(M) and LP(M). Let f be a complex-valued function on M, defined everywhere except, perhaps on a set of measure 0. In the sequel, we consider functions f, and f2 as equivalent if they coincide outside some set of measure 0. Indeed, the elements of the spaces LL (M) and
52
Chapter I. Foundations of Y'DO Theory
LL (M) are not functions but equivalence classes, although we will write f e LA(M) for a function f, by abuse of language. We will write that f e L L(M) if for an arbitrary diffeomorphism x: X- X, of an open set X c lR" into an open set X, c M and an arbitrary open subset X° C- X, such that Xo is compact in X, we have [x* (f I x)] Ix,e LZ(X°, dx), where dx is the Lebesgue measure on X0 induced by the Lebesgue measure on W. The topology of L? ,,,,(M) is given by a family of seminorms
III IL, x,= II[x'Ulx,)]Ix,liL2cx,.ax)'
If M has a countable basis, then L ',,,,(M) is a Frechet space (a complete metrizable and locally convex space or, what is the same thing, a complete countably normed space). the linear subset of LA(M), consisting Further, we will denote by of those elements f e LL(M) for which suppf is compact in M. Given x: X - X, and X° c X as described above, define the inclusion i,, xo: LZ (X°, dx) - Lo.P(M), mapping a function f ° e LZ (X°, dx) into the function J(y) on M, equal to f (x) at
the point x (x) of M and to 0 at y e M\ x (X°). The topology of ...p(M) is defined as the inductive topology, i.e. the strongest locally convex topology for which all the inclusions i, , are continuous. From this it follows that the linear operator A: L,mp(M) -+ E, E any locally convex space, is continuous if and only if all the compositions A o x, are continuous. This circumstance being taken into account, we clearly get the following Theorem 6.6. If A e LQ, a (M), where 1 - Q < b < p, then A extends to a linear continuous operator
A: Loomp(M) - 9.(M) Exercise 6.1. Prove that if A e L°Q.a(M), I - Q S b < g, and if A is properly supported, then it extends to a linear continuous operator A: L2.mP(M) -. LICOMP (M)
and also to a linear continuous operator
A: L« (M) -* 1.(M)
.
§7. The Sobolev Spaces 7.1 Definition of the Sobolev spaces
Lemma 7.1. Let M be an arbitrary manifold. Then for any real s there exists on M a properly supported, classical elliptic 'I'DO A, of order s with positive principal symbol (for 1
0).
§7. The Sobolev Spaces
53
Proof. To begin with let M = X, a domain in W. Then we may take as A, an arbitrary properlysupported'YDO A, e CL'(X) with principal symbol I Is. Next let M be arbitrary and let there be given a covering of M by charts Al = U X17. Y
We will denote by x' any coordinate diffeomorphism x' : X' -+ X; , where X' is
an open set in R". We construct on X1 operators AL, having the required properties and transport these to Xl by the standard procedure (cf. §4) using the diffeomorphisms x', producing a properly supported, classical TDOA'.I on X,' with positive principal symbol. The operator A. on M can be glued together from the operators AL I by the process used to construct B from By in the proof of theorem 5.1.
Definition 7.1. We write u e HA(M), if u E.Q'(M) and A,u E LA(M). Further set HA(M) = H;a(M) n f'(M). (Concerning -Q'(M) and 1'(M), see Exercise 4.1.) If M is a closed manifold, we denote HHa(M) = HHmp(M) simply
by H'(M). If K is a compact in M, we denote by H'(K) the set of all u E for which supp u C K. and There is a well-defined topology in the spaces H'(K), but for the time being only the set of elements in these spaces is essential to us. Below we will show that these spaces do not depend on the choice of the operator As.
7.2 The action of'YDO on Sobolev spaces. The precise regularity theorem. Theorem 7.1. If A e LQ, a(M), 1 - Q 5 S < p, or S < Q and M = X, an open set in W, then A defines a mapH,,m,(M) -. HH, "'(M). If A, in addition, is properly supported, then A defines maps
A: HL,mp(M) -' H o (M) ,
A: HA(M)-+Hiam(M). Proof. Without loss of generality, we may assume that the operator A _, is a parametrix of A, for arbitrary s e 1R, i.e.
A-,oA,=I+R,,
(7.1)
where R, is a properly supported operator with smooth kernel and therefore transforming 0'(M) into Ca (M) and 9'(M) into Cm(M).
If ueH(M), then, setting Au = ua, we will obtain from (7.1), that u = A-,ua + v, where uo a LL,mp(M), v e Co (M). Therefore
A,_",Au = A,_.A(A_,uo+v) = A,_mAA_,u0+ A'Av,
Chapter 1. Foundations of `PDO Theory
54
and in view of the fact that A,_mAA_,ELQ.6(M), we obtain from Theorem 6.6, from which A,_mAueLL(M), that A,_mAA_,u0EL4.,(M), i.e. Au E H;a '(M). Thereby we have proved the first assertion of Theorem 7.1.
The remaining ones follow from this one or are shown similarly. O
We are now in a position to give a definition of Sobolev spaces, not depending on the choice of A,. It clearly suffices to define HA(M). Definition 7.1'. We will write u e HHa(M), if u e 9'(M) and Au e L «(M) for any properly supported A E L1.0(M).
The equivalence of Definitions 7.1 and 7.1' follows in an obvious manner from Theorem 7.1. Theorem 7.2. Let A e HLQ: a '(M), where I - Q < 6 < Q, orb < Q and M = X, an open set in IV. Then, if u e -9'(M) and Au E HA(M) we have u e 3M+"`-(M).
Proof Let B be a parametrix for A, BeHLQ '"-,-"(M). Then, by Theorem 7.1 we have BAu E H',+"'-(M). But BAu = u + v, where v e C°°(M) so
u E H "- (M). O Corollary 7.1. a) If A is elliptic of order m, u e if' (M) and Au E Hj«(M ), then
b) If A is properly supported (in particular if A is a differential operator) and elliptic of order m, u c -!?'(M) and Au e HL(M), then u e H,« '(M).
7.3 Localization. Theorem 7.1 clearly implies that if u e H;«(M) and a(x) e C' (M), then au a HHa(M).
If, in particular, a (x) E Co (M), then au E H ,(M). The following is a precise version of the converse.
Proposition 7.1. Let the distribution u e 2'(M) be such that for any point e Co (M), such that cpxe(xo) + 0 and
xo e M one can find a function e H ,(M). Then u e H;«(M).
Proof. We may select from the functions a system of functions { qy}, such that some neighbourhoods of supp cp, form a locally finite covering of M and for any point xo e M one can find y such that cp., (x0) * 0. Put now
_ (Pr. (r
.
Y- Ic'yI2 Y
Then obviously Vi, has the same properties as cp., and, in addition, Wy Z 0 and = 1. We now have
(M) because, by the fact that A, is properly supported, the sum finite.
A, (s1 u) is locally
§7. The Sobolev Spaces
55
Corollary 7.2. Let M = U X, be an open covering of M, u e 9'(M). Then the r c o n d i t i o n u e HA(M) i s e q u i v a l e n t to
u I x, e H (X,) for any y.
Proposition 7.1 shows that it is essentially sufficient to study H'(K) for K compact in IR". 7.4 The space H'(IR").
Definition 7.2. Let s E IR, U E S' (R'). We will write u e H'(IR"), if E L1Z,C(IR") and 11U11.2
= J I u (x)12 <>2s d <
(this also serves as a definition of the norm 11 '
+00
(7.2)
II,).
Exercise. Show the completeness of H'(IR") (with the norm II ' IIs) The following Hilbert scalar product can be introduced in H'(IR") (7.3)
(u, v). = Ju(g) 6(e)
and the map (D)', mapping u E S'(IR") into
(F is the Fourier
transformation), provides an isometric isomorphism
': H'(W)- L2(IR").
(7.4)
Lemma 7.2. Let K be compact in IR". Then
H'(K) = 9'(K)nH'(IR")
(7.5)
d'(K) denotes the set of all u E d'(IR"), such that supp u c K).
Proof. 1. Since'EL1j1.0(IR") and is elliptic, then by Corollary7.1 it is clear that u E of' (K) and ' u e L2 (IR") implies u e H'(K), i.e. 9'(K) n H'(IR") c Hs (K). 2. Now let u e H'(K). We must verify that 'u a L2(IR") if it is known that 'u e LL(IR"). Indeed, a stronger result is valid: if (p (x) e Co (II."), q = I in a neighbourhood of K. then (1- (p) 'u a S(I V). Let us prove this. Let W e Co (IR") be such that rp = I in a neighbourhood of supp ' (in
particular (1- (p) w =- 0) and moreover w = I in a neighbourhood of K. Then +y u = u and (1- (p)'u = (1- cp) 'yi u. Let us study the operator (1-(p) 'w. Clearly its kernel K(x, y) belongs to C°°(IR" x IR"). It suffices
to verify that K(x,y) ES(IR" x IR"). But K(x,y) is given by an oscillatory integral:
K(x,y)=
Je'(:-ri
e(1-(,(x))<>'W(y)dd,
56
Chapter I. Foundations of 'I'DO Theory
which can be rewritten as
Ix - yl-2N
K(x,Y) =
(p (X)) W(Y) (-d4)N<)sd
since Ix-yI _ a>O forxesupp(1-(p),yesuppqi. For2N>s+n weobtaina convergent integral, which can be estimated by The C(1+IxI+IYI)-2N
derivatives of the kernel K(x, y) are estimated in a similar way. 1]
Noting that H'(K) is a closed subspace of H'(1R"), we see that the scalar product (u, v)s induces a Hilbert space structure on H'(K).
Lemma 7.3. Let k be a compact set in lR" such that Kc Int k. Then for u E H' (K), there exists a sequence u" a Co (lR"), supp u" a k, such that Ilu" - uI1,--* 0 for n-' +oo. Proof. Let (p (x) E Co (lR"), J cp (x) dx = I and gyp, (x) = s -"gyp (x/s). We put uL (x) _ ((P, * u) (x) _
r>0.
,
It is clear that u, (x) e Co (lR") so let us prove that lim II u: - u Its = 0. Since a»o+ apt ( ) = ip and rp (0) = 1, the question reduces to establishing the relation lim t»+o
0,
I21
which is evident from the dominated convergence theorem. L 7.5 Topology in the Sobolev spaces on a manifold. Let M = U X; be a locally
finite covering of a manifold M by relatively compact coordinate neighbourhoods X', xY : X Y -* X Y the coordinate diffeomorphisms (X Y an open set in IR") and co' a partition of unity on M subordinate to (X',). Let K be a compact set in M. Introduce a scalar product in H'(K), setting (u, v), _ Y_ ((x')* ((,YU), (x'')* ((o'v))s ,
u, v E H'
(K) .
(7.6)
Y
Proposition 7.2. The scalar product (7.6) induces a Hilbert space structure on
H'(K). Proof. Clearly we only need to verify the completeness of H'(K) in the norm II I. defined by the scalar product (7.6). Let the sequence of elements in H'(K) be a Cauchy sequence with respect to 11 II,. Then (x')*VYU", -+ ui E H'(xy(suppSpY))
(7.7)
in the H'(lR") norm (here x;=(x')-'). We may take v'=(x;)*vi, thus v; = (xl)* v1. Then vY a H' (supp q ) and we put u =
vY (which is obviously a Y
§7. The Sobolev Spaces
57
finite sum). It is clear that u E H'(K) since vY E H'(K). It remains to prove that lim Plum - ull., = 0. This means in view of (7.6), that M-oo
lim II ('Y)'9p'(um - u)II., = 0
M-M
for any y. But it is evident from (7.7) that it suffices to verify vY = W'u, which
is clear since ur -- u in 1'(M), hence (PYUm (p'U in 1'(M), and (7.7) implies V u -+ vY in 1'(M) (convergence in 1'(M) in the weak sense). U
We now want to prove that the topology, induced on H'(K) by the norm II
'
II, , is independent of the choice of arbitrary elements in (7.6) (the covering, the
partition of unity and the coordinate diffeomorphisms). For this
it is
appropriate to give another definition of this topology. Let A, be as in Lemma 7.1 so that A _, is a parametrix for A, (relation (7.1) is satisfied). Then we have
u= A_,A,u-R,u.
(7.8)
Let p > s be a positive integer and Q 1, ... , QN differential operators, generating the left C°°(M)-module of all differential operators of order not greater than p
on M. We then set N
(u, v): = (A,u, A,v) + Y (QkR,u, Qk R,v),
(7.9)
k=1
where u, v eH'(K), (, ) the scalar product in L'C,,,,(M) induced by any smooth positive density on M. From (u, u)s = 0 it follows that A,u = 0 and R,u = 0 and
then, in view of (7.8), we have u = 0. Therefore the scalar product (7.9) is well defined and we will denote the corresponding Hilbert norm by II
H.
Proposition 7.2'. The scalar product (7.9) induces a Hilbert space structure on
H'(K). Proof. Once again, we need only verify the completeness. For the beginning note, that from the convergence of a sequence u, E H' (K) with respect to the norm II I1; the weak convergence in J'(M) follows. If a sequence U. E H' (K) is a Cauchy sequence with respect to 11 then this means, that the following limits exist in the L2(K)-topology (K some compact set in M)
lim A,um = v,
M-00
lim QR,u,,, = wQ, Trot
(7.10)
where Q is any differential operator of order <-- p. In particular A,u,,, and R,u,, converge in the topology of L (M), so that weak convergence of u, in 1'(M) results from (7.8). Denoting the limit of u,,, (in the weak topology of 1'(M)) by u, we obviously have
58
Chapter I. Foundations of `FDO Theory
u=A_,v-w,,
(7.11)
where wl = lim R,ur. If as Q in (7.10) we take an elliptic operator of order T-00 p, we have
Qwl = lim QR,um = WQ E L (M), M-00
from which w1 E Hi (M), therefore w1 E but then w1 E HIP(K) for some compact set K since the operators A, and R, are properly supported. Therefore U E H'(K). It remains to verify that lim IIum - u111 = 0.
We have
um - U = u, - A_,v + wl = A_,A,Um - R,u,,, - A_,v + wl = A-,(A.su, - v) - (R,um - wl), hence N
Ilum - uil, < IIA,A-,(A,um - v)II + E II Q&R,A_,(A,Um - v)II k=1
N
+ IIA,(R,um - wl)II +
II QkR,(R,ur - w1)II
(7.12)
k=I
(here the norm II (7.9)).
II
is induced by the same scalar product
as in formula
The convergence to 0 of the first, second and last terms in (7.12) follows from the boundedness of the operators A, A_ Qk R, A_,. and Qk R, as operators from L2(K) into L2(K), and in the case of the third term from the following argument. Take an elliptic differential operator Q of order p and its properly supported parametrix Q1. Then
-
As(R,um - w1) = A,QI Q(R,u,,, wl) + A,R(R,u,,, - wl), The desired result now follows from the fact that A, Q, is a where R e L properly supported PDO of order s - p ;S 0 continuously mapping L2 (K) into L2 (RC).
There also exists a third way to introduce a topology on H'(K), via the seminorms IIuIIA,k= IIAuIRII,
AeL;,0(M).
(7.13)
Proposition 7.3. The three topologies introduced on H'(K) above (i.e. via II
' II,,
11
'
Its and the seminorms (7.13)) coincide.
§7. The Sobolev Spaces
59
Proof. The equivalence of the topologies determined by the norms II ' Its and 1I
' II;
is clear from the closed graph theorem. The topology given by the
seminorms (7.13) is obviously stronger than the one given by the norm II ' II;, since the latter can be estimated by a sum of N + I semi norms of the type (7.13), where the corresponding operator A is equal to A, and Qk R, . To verify the
equivalence of the two topologies, it therefore sufficies to establish that if A e Lj.0(M) and K, k are compact in M, then the following estimate holds IIAuIRII < C11ulls,
uEH'(K).
(7.14)
Now, writing u in the form (7.8) we obtain
Au = (AA-,)A,u - AR,u, and, since AA _, a L°, o(M), AR, a L- (M), (7.14) follows from Theorem
6.6. O Corollary 7.3. The topology defined in H'(K) by the norms II ' II, and II ' II; does not depend on arbitrary elements entering the definition of these norms.
Proposition 7.4. Let k be a compact set in M, such that K CZ Int K. Then if u e H'(K), there is a sequence w" E Co (R), such that cp" -. u as n - + oo in the topology of H'(k).
Proof. Follows from Lemma 7.3 taking into account the definition of the norm II
.
II,
Proposition 7.5. Let K be a compact set in M and let A e LQ 6(M), where either 1 - Q S 6 < Q or b < Q and M = X an open set in W. Then, provided A is properly supported, it defines a linear continuous operator
A: H3(K) -. H,-,(k), where k is a compact set in M depending on K. Without assuming that A is properly
supported, the same holds for the operator 4pA, * a Co (M).
Proof. It is most convenient to use the norm 11 ' 11;. Then, to verify the continuity of A acting from H' (K) into H' -"(k), we have to estimate II A, _ ", Au II
and IIQR,_,"Aull by CIIA,ull and CIIQ'R,uII (here Q and Q' are differential operators). But from (7.8) we have
Au = (AA_,) (it,u) - AR,u, from which
(A,-.AA_,) (A,u) - (A,-.AR,) u, QR,_",Au = QR,-",A-,A,u and the required estimate follows from Theorems 6.1 and 6.6, if we take into
Chapter I. Foundations of PDO Theory
60
consideration that As_mAA_seLe°.a(M) and that the operators AS_JARC, QRs _ m A _ s and QRs _,,,
belong to L(M). 0
We now introduce topologies in HHa(M) and H;mp(M).
The topology of H;a(M) is defined as the weakest locally convex topology making all the mappings M.: HA(M) - Hs(supp (p), (p a Co (M) and M,u = cpu, continuous. In other words, this topology is given by the system of seminorms IIuIL.m= Ogvuf"
cpeCC (M).
(7.15)
The topology on is defined as the strongest locally convex topology, making all the embeddings iK: H5(K) - H'P(M) continuous. The most important characteristic of this topology (called the inductive topology) is that a linear map f- H.mp(M) -' E to any locally convex space E is continuous if
and only if all the compositions f o iK: H(K) - E are continuous. These definitions and Proposition 7.5 imply the following Theorem 7.3. Let A E L' a (M) with either I - Q 5 b < Q or b < p and M = X, an open set in W. Then A is a linear continuous operator for any s e IR
A: HHmp(M) - H M(M) . If A is properly supported it extends to linear continuous operators
A: H(M)-+H(M) and
A: HL(M) - Hi«"'(M). 7.6 Embedding theorems. First, note the completely trivial (and already used) fact, that for s > s', we have the embeddings
H'(K) c H''(K),
H;a(M) c HL(M),
H',(M) c H p(M), which are continuous. Less trivial is the following
Theorem 7.4. Let s > s' and K a compact set in M. Then the embedding operator
is": Hs(K) -Hs'(K) is a compact operator.
Proof. By the equality (7.8), we obtain
§7. The Sobolev Spaces
61
(A: A_,) (A. u) - (A: R,) u _ (As A-,) (A. u) - (A.,, A
(A, R. u) + (As R,) (R,u)
(3-'1(M) (hence from Corollary 6.1 for any compact set K, Since A; A_,eL-1.0 one can find a compact set K2, such that A,. A _, is a compact operator from L2(K1) to L2(K2)) it is clear that if u runs through a bounded set in H'(K) (and, consequently A,u and R,u run through a bounded set in L2(K,)) then As u runs through a precompact set in L2(K2). Similarly one shows that in this case QR,,,u runs through a precompact set in L2(K2) for any differential operator Q. But this, in view of the equality (7.8) and the definition of the norm, implies the compactness of the corresponding set in H' (K2), hence in H"(K), since, actually, it belongs to H" (K) and the topology in H"(K) is induced by the
one in H(K2) provided K C K2. A generalization of Theorem 7.4 is Theorem 7.5. Let A e L"Q, a (M), A properly supported, either I - Q < b < Q or b < Q and M = X, an open set in IR'. Let the numbers s, s' e IR be such that s' < s - m. Let K be a compact set in M and k a compact set in M (depending on K) such
that A 4f '(K) a r'(R). Then the operator A: H5(K) --- Hs'(k) is compact.
Proof. Theorem 7.5 is a consequence of Proposition 7.5 and Theorem 7.4, since
the operator A: H'(K) -, H" (k) can be viewed as a composition
H'(K)
A H'-M(R)
H''(R).
Cl
Denote by CP(M) the space of functions on M having continuous derivatives of order Sp in any local coordinates. The topology in CP(M) is defined by the seminorms IIu1IA,K= sup I Au(x)
(7.16)
xeX
where A is any differential operator of order Sp. We denote by Cg(K) the subspace of the functions u e CP(M) with supp u c K. It is clear that the topology of CP(M) induces a topology on Cg(K), which can be given by a Banach norm.
Theorem 7.6. If s > n/2 + p, then H;a(M) c CP(M) is a continuous embedding. If K is a compact set in M, then the embedding H'(K) c Cg (K) is a compact operator under the same assumption s > n/2 + p.
Proof. Since differential operators of order p are continuous maps H'(K) - H'-P(K), it is obvious that it suffices to consider the case p = 0. Further, it suffices to verify that for s > n/2, we have a continuous embedding
Chapter I. Foundations of PDO Theory
62
Hs(K) c Co(K), since the compactness of this embedding is obtained by writing it as a composition
H'(K) c H'-`(K) c Co (K) (e > 0 such that s - e > n/2) and using Theorem 7.4. Finally, it is clear that it suffices to consider the case of K lying inside a chart, i.e. the question reduces to the case M = IR". Thus, let K be a compact set in IR" and s > n12. It follows from Lemma 7.3,
that it suffices to prove the estimate sup Iu(x)I < C11u115,
u c- Co (K),
(7.17)
xCR'
where C does not depend on u. We will prove this estimate with C even independent of K. We have
lu(x)I= I je1z fu( dal [jlu( )12< >z'd where C =
+oo, as required.
Corollary 7.4. f Hja(M) = C-(M). This corollary is obvious. Let us also note the dual fact: U Hs(K) = f'(K) for any compact set K c M. This fact follows from the well-known statement of distribution theory, that if u e d'(K), then u can be written as u = Y_ Q;v;,
where v; E L2 (k), k is compact and Q J are differential operators. if If m is the
greatest order of the Q;, then uEH-'(K). 7.7. Duality. Let there be given a smooth positive density du on M. This defines a bilinear form = j u (x) v (x) du (x),
(7.18)
for instance, if u r= Co (M) and v E C°° (M).
Theorem 7.7. The bilinear form (7.18) extends for any s e IR to a pairing (separately continuous bilinear mapping)
H.'.P(M) x H,; (M) - C
(7.19)
which we will denote as before by < -, >. The spaces Ho,,,P and HL are dual to each
other with respect to this pairing, i.e. any continuous linear functional 1(u) on can be written in the form for some v e H1« '(M), and any
§7. The Sobolev Spaces
63
continuous linear functional 1(v) on H,« (M) can be written as , where If the manifold M is closed, then the transformation which attaches
u
to any v eH-'(M) the linear functional is an invertible linear continuous operator from H-'(M) into (H'(M))* (where the latter space is endowed with the natural Banach space topology).
Proof. 1. First let us verify that the form (7.18) extends to the pairing (7.19).
Note that the operator A appearing in the definition of the Sobolev space can be chosen symmetric with respect to the given density, i.e. such that =
construct all the A s >_ 0, as symmetric operators, and then consider their parametrices A, and take for A-, the symmetrization of A',: A-s
1/2(A,
,+'A' ,)).
From the definition of the topology on extend (7.18) to a pairing
it follows, that it suffices to
H'(K) x H,a (M) -, C
(7.20)
where K is any compact set in M. Clearly this is possible for s = 0. For s + 0, we take u e Co (K), v c- C°° (M) and write u in the form (7.8). Then == - ,
(7.21)
from which the extendability of < , > to the pairing (7.20) follows since A. and
A, are continuous linear mappings A,:
A-,: Hj«(M)-.L,«(M)
2. Now let be a linear continuous functional on H,O'(M). We will show that it can be written in the form I (v) = , with u e 11,11,,,(M). First of all, since C' (M) c H,; !(M) is a continuous embedding, the restriction of 1(v) to C°`(M) can be written in the form , u E 9'(K) for some compact K in M. The distribution u is thereby uniquely defined and it only remains to verify that uEH3(K), i.e. A,ueL2(k). But =
and therefore the desired statement can be derived from the fact that A. is a continuous mapping LL(M) -+ H,a (M) and also from the Riesz theorem, which guarantees the assertion for s = 0.
64
Chapter 1. Foundations of `PDO Theory
on HomP(M) Similarly one shows the representability of the functional in the form l (u) = , where v E H,a (M). 3. Now let M be a closed manifold and let us verify that the map v -+ 1"(-)
=<-,v> is a topological isomorphism between H-'(M) and Obviously this is true for s = 0 by the Riesz theorem. Consider the case of an has already been arbitrary s E IR. Since the bijectivity of the map v - i established in 2., it suffices to verify its continuity. But this follows at once from (7.21).
7.8 Exercises and problems
Exercise 7.1. Verify that 6 (x) a H'(1R") for s < - n/2.
Exercise 7.2. Show that the embedding operator H'(IR") c H" (W) is not compact for any s, s'(s>s').
Exercise 7.3. Let T' = R"/2,r71" be the n-dimensional torus (7Z" is the lattice of points with integer coordinates in ]R"). If f E C°°(lr) (= Co (1r)), then f decomposes into a Fourier series fk e",
f(x) =
(7.22)
keZ*
where fk are the Fourier coefficients, given by the formula
f = (2n)-" $ f(x) e"dx.
(7.23)
The same formula also applies to f e 9'(1'") if as the integral in (7.23) we take the value of the functional f at the function e-jk (in this case the series (7.22) converges in the weak topology of then the condition f c- H'(Y") is equivalent to Show that if f keZ'
1112(1+Ik12)'<+00,
(7.24)
where the left-hand side of (7.24) defines the square of a norm in H'(T"), equivalent to any of the previous norms. Exercise 7.4. Show that if A satisfies the conditions of Theorem 6.4, then A:
H'(K) - H" (k) is a compact operator for any s e IR. Exercise 7.5. Show that the spaces H'(IR") and H--(R") are dual to each other with respect to the bilinear form= r f (x) g (x) dx. Problem 7.1. Verify that if N is a submanifold of M of codimension d, then the restriction map f -f IN (defined a priori for f e C°° (M)) extends for s > d/2 to a linear continuous map
§8. The Fredholm Property, Index and Spectrum
65
Hi «(M) -' Hi« d12 (N).
Problem 7.2. Show that the map defined in Problem 7.1 is surjective.
§8. The Fredholm Property, Index and Spectrum 8.1 The basic properties of Fredholm operators
Definition 8.1. Let E, and E2 be Banach spaces and A : E, -. E2 a linear continuous operator. It is said to be Fredholm if dim Ker A < + oo and dim Coker A < + oo (recall that Ker A = {x c- E,: Ax = 0}, Coker A = E2/Im A, where Im A = AE, and the quotient space is meant in the algebraic sense, i.e. regardless of a topology). The index of a Fredholm operator is the number index A = dim Ker A - dim Coker A.
(8.1)
We will denote by V (E, , E2) the set of all linear continuous operators A : E, -' E2 and the set of all Fredholm operators A E 2 (E, , E2) will be denoted by Fred (El, E2).
Lemma 8.1. Let A e 2 (El, E2) and let dim Coker A < + oo. Then Im A is a closed subspace in E2.
Proof. Clearly, Ker A is a closed subspace of E, and therefore the quotient space E, /Ker A has a natural Banach space structure. The operator A induces a continuous map A, : E, /Ker A - E2 with Im A, = Im A and Ker A, = 0. Now let C denote any finite-dimensional subspace of E2 for which E2 = ]m A ® C (direct sum in the algebraic sense). Define the operator
A: E,/KerAOC-'E2
(8.2)
mapping a pair {x, c} into A, x + c E E2. Obviously A is bijective and continuous, if the space on the left hand side is considered as a Banach direct sum (e. g. with the norm II {x, c} II = II x II + II c 11, where If c 11 is defined by any norm on
Q. By the Banach inverse operator theorem, A is a topological isomorphism implying that Im A is closed in E2 since A-' (Im A) = E, /Ker A ® 0 is closed
in E, /Ker A ®C. 0 Corollary 8.1. If dim Coker A < + oo and L, is a closed subspace in E, such that E, = L, e Ker A, then A defines a topological isomorphism A: L, - Im A.
Note that in the case A e Fred (E,, E2) there always exists a subspace L, of this type, since by the Hahn-Banach theorem, we may extend the identity map Ker A -. Ker A to a continuous linear operator PI: E, --+ Ker A and then put L,
=KerP,.
66
Chapter I. Foundations of `YDO Theory
Corollary 8.2. If A e 2 (Et, E2) and dim Coker A < + oo, then dim Coker A
= dim KerA*, where A* is the adjoint operator A*: Ez -. E. Proof. It is known (and trivial) that
KerA*= {feE2:=O}. From the closedness of Im A and the Hahn-Banach theorem it follows that
ImA = {xeE2:
C!
Lemma 8.2. Let E be a Banach space and let T e
(E, E) be of finite rank, i.e.
dim Im T < + oo. Then the operator I + T is Fredholm and index (1+ T) = 0.
Proof. It is easily seen that there exists a decomposition E = Lo ® L1, where Lo is a closed subspace, La a Ker T, L1 Im T, dim L1 < + oo. Then (1+ T)14 = I I L., (1+T) L1 c L1, because TL1 c Im Tc L1. Therefore Lo and L1 are invariant subspaces for (1+ T) with Im (1+ T) Lo, Ker (I+ T) C L1. Therefore 1+ T is Fredholm and index (1+ T) equals the index of (I+ 7), viewed as an operator from L1 into L1, which means that the whole matter reduces to a trivial statement from linear algebra. O Lemma 8.3. If A E Fred (El, E2), then there exists an operator B E Fred (E2, E1) such that
BA=1-P1,
AB=I-P2
(8.3)
where P1 is a projection onto Ker A and (I- P2) a projection onto Im A (so that P1 and P2 are of finite rank).
Proof. Let L, be a closed complement to KerA in E1 and L2 any complement to Im A. Define the operator B such that
BAIL,=11L,,
BIL,=O.
From Corollary 8.1 it is clear that Be 2 (E2 , El) and Ker B = L2 , Im B = L1,
from which the Fredholm property of B follows. The relation (8.3) immediately verified.
is
El
Lemma 8.4. Let A E Y (E1, E2) and let B1, B2 a 2' (E2, El) be such that
B1A=I+T1,
AB2=1+T2,
where T, , T2 have finite rank. Then A is Fredholm.
(8.4)
§8. The Fredholm Property, Index and Spectrum
67
Proof. The statement follows from the obvious inclusions Ker A c Ker (B, A) = Ker (I+ T,), Im A : Im (AB2) = Im (I+ T2)
and from Lemma 8.2.
17
Lemma 8.5. Let A e Fred (E, , E2), B e Fred (E2, E3). Then BA e Fred (E,, E3)
and index BA = index A + index B
(8.5)
Proof. We show first of all, that there exist closed subspaces LC Ej, j = 1, 2, 3, such that Ker A I L = 0, AL, = L2 , Ker B I L2 = 0, BL2 = L3, where codim Lj < + oo, j = 1, 2, 3. (The codimension of a subspace L of E is codim L = dim (E/L). Here, in particular we have codim Lj = dim (Ej/Lj), j= 1, 2, 3.) Indeed, if L, is a closed complement of Ker A in E1, LZ a closed complement of Ker B in E2, we may put L2 = Li n Im A,
L' = (AIL.) -' (L2),
L3 = BL2 .
Let us now note the following fact: Let L1, L2 be closed subspaces in El, E2 respectively, A e Fred (E, , E2), Ker A IL, = 0 and AL, = L2. Then, denoting by A: E1/L, -+ E2/L2 the map induced by A, we have A E Fred (E,/L1, E2/L2) and index A = index A. Therefore, using the above constructed subspaces Ljc Ej reduces the proof of (8.5) to the case dim EE < + oo, j =1, 2, 3, which is evident, since if A e2 (E,, E2) and dim Ej < + oo, j = 1, 2, then index A = dim E, - dim E2 . L Proposition 8.1. Fred (El, E2) is an open subset of .' (El, E2) (in the uniform operator topology, i.e. the topology defined by the operator norm) and the function
index: Fred (E,, E2) - Z is continuous (i.e. constant on each connected component of Fred (E, , E2)). In particular, if A, is a continuous (in the norm) operator-valued function, oft a [0,1 ], with values in Fred (E, , E.) then index Ao = index A,.
Proof. Let A E Fred (E, , E2). We have to prove the existence of E > 0 such that if D e 2' (E, , E2) and JID II< E then A + D e Fred (E, , E2) and index (A + D) = index A.
Let B e 2 (E2, E,) be an operator such that
BA =I+T1,
AB =I+T2
(8.6)
with T,, TT of finite rank (which is always possible by Lemma 8.3). We will verify
68
Chapter 1. Foundations of 1I'DO Theory
that one may take e = II B II '. Indeed, let 11D II
+ T, and if we put B, =(I+ BD) -' B, then B, (A+ D) = 1+ T,, where T, is of finite rank. Note that index B = index B, . Analogously, there is an operator B2 such that (A+D)B2 = I+ T2, with T2 of finite rank. By Lemma 8.4, the operator A + D is Fredholm and by Lemmas 8.5 and 8.2 we have
index (A + D) = - index B, = - index B = index A. D In what follows we will denote by C(E,,EZ) the set of all compact linear operators from E, into E2.
Lemma 8.6. Let E be a Banach space and let R e C (E, E).
Then
I + R e Fred (E, E) and index (1+ R) = 0. Proof. Since I I Ke,(1+R) = - R I Ker(I+R), the unit ball in Ker (1+ R) is compact and therefore dim Ker (1 + R) < + oo. Further, since R* is also compact, dim Ker (1+ R)* < + oo and to show the Fredholm property of (I+ R) it only remains to verify the closedness of Im (1+ R) (since then dim Coker (1+R) = dim Ker (/+ R)*). n-++oo. We need to verify Let x.eE,n=1,2,...,and the existence of an x e E, such that (1+ R)x = y. Let L be any closed subspace complementary to Ker (1+ R) in E. Adding to xn vectors from Ker (I+ R) (which
does not change yn), we may assume that x e L for all n.
Let us show that the sequence x is bounded. Indeed, if this is not as the case, taking a subsequence of {xn), we may assume that n--++oo. But then, putting x;, = xn/I)x11, y.' = (I+R)x;, we have y;,-'0 as n - + oc, and since II x;, II = I we may assume that lim Rx;, exists. But then
+.
also lim xn = - lim Rx;, = x and clearly II x 11= 1, x E L, (I+ R) x = 0, contra-
n+ac n dicting the choice of L. Thus the sequence {xn} is bounded and we may assume that lim Rx exists n»+x and, consequently so does lim xn =Y - lim Rxn . Denoting x = lim x., n»+m n»+z. n»+x we clearly have (1+ R) x = y, proving the closedness of Im (I+ R), i. e. the Fredholm property of (1+ R). By Proposition 8.1, we have index (1+ tR) = const for t e [0,11 implying index (1+ R) = Index I= 0.
Proposition 8.2. Let A e . (El, E2) and let there exist B, and B2 such that
B,A=I+R,,
AB2=I+R2,
(8.7)
where R,eC(E;.EE), j=1,2. Then A eFred (E,,E2). Proof. It immediately follows from Lemma 8.6 in a similar way to the proof of Lemma 8.4. LJ
Proposition 8.3. Let A e Fred (E,, E2), Fred (E,, E2) and index (A + R) = index A.
R e C (E,, E2).
Then
A+Re
§8. The Fredholm Property, Index and Spectrum
69
Proof. Obvious from Proposition 8.2 and Lemmas 8.5 and 8.6. 8.2 The Fredholm property and the index of elliptic operators on a closed manifold Theorem 8.1. Let M be a closed manifold and A E HLQ .a (M), 1 - Q =< S < Q. For any s e IR construct the operator A, E 2' (H' (M ), H' - '(M)) the extension of A by continuity. Then,
a) A,EFred(H'(M),
H'_T(M));
b) Ker A, c C' (M), therefore Ker A, does not depend on sand will be denoted simply by Ker A; c) index A, does not depend on s (so we will denote it simply by index A) and is expressed by the formula
index A = dim Ker A - dim Ker A*,
(8.8)
where AS is the formal adjoint PDO (cf. §3) in the sense of a scalar product determined by any smooth density. d) if D e LQ 'd(M), where m' < m, then index (A + D) = index A. Proof. By Theorem 5.1 we may construct a parametrix B E HL-
'(M) of
the operator A. In view of Theorem 7.5, the operators Rt E L- ' (M) can be e C(H'(M), H'(M)) for arbitrary s EIR. But now, extended to operators the Fredholm property for all the operators A, follows from proposition 8.2. Further, from Theorem 5.2 statement b) of the theorem follows and since A* a HL'- e , we also obtain c). Finally, d) follows from Proposition 8.3 since if D E LQ;b(M), m' < m, then
D e C(H'(M), H'-'"(M)) by Theorem 7.5. Remark 8.1. The assertion of this theorem is clearly true not only for scalar operators, but also for operators acting on the sections of vector bundles. Remark 8.2. For classical elliptic 'PDO, d) says that the index depends only on the principal symbol. It is easy to deduce from Theorem 6.2 that the index does not change with arbitrary continuous deformations of the principal symbol within the class of homogenous elliptic symbols. This is important in the index theory of elliptic operators. 8.3 The spectrum (basic facts). Let M be a closed manifold, A E HLQ, a (M),
1 - Q S 6 < Q, m > 0. In the space L2 (M) consider the unbounded linear operator defined by A by taking as domain the space H'(M). We will denote this unbounded operator by A0, or sometimes just by A if there can be no confusion. So the domain of Ao is DAa = H'(M). Proposition 8.4. The operator A0 is closed, i.e. if for u" E H'" (M), n =1, 2, ... ,
the limits u = lim u" and f = lim Au" exist in L2 (M) then u e H"' (M) R. + "" + °` and Au =f
Chapter 1. Foundations of `PDO Theory
70
Proof. Since convergence in L2(M) implies convergence in 9'(M) and since A is continuous in 9'(M) (in the sense of, e.g. the weak topology), we obtain Au =f, and then u E HM(M) in view of Theorem 7.2. From the fact that Cm(M) is dense in Hm(M) (in the Hm(M)-topology), we have Corollary 8.3. The operator Ao is the closure (in L2(M)) of the operator A 1 c=(M)
.
Definition 8.2. The spectrum of A is the subset a (A) of the complex plane,
defined as follows: for A E C, d 4 a (A) is equivalent to (A0 - Al) having a bounded everywhere defined inverse (A0-Al)-' in L2(M). It is easy to verify that a (A) is a closed subset of C and that (A0 - A1)
is a
holomorphic operator-valued function of A on C\a(A) with values in & (L2(M), L2(M)). The function R, = (A0 - 21)-' is called the resolvent of A.
Proposition 8.5. Let a fixed positive smooth density dµ(x) bejixed on M. Then the conditions A ' a (A) and Ker (A - ,Xl) = Ker (A' -.k1) = O are equivalent. Proof. The statement follows from Theorem 8.1, since (A -Al) E HLQ. a (M)
because m > 0. O Theorem 8.2. (the inverse operator theorem) Let A e HLQ a (M), I - e S 6
<e, m > 0 and let AO be constructed as before. Let also ,1 t a (A). Then
(A,-Al)-' is an extension by continuity (from C(M)) or restriction (from 9'(M)) of an operator from HLQ a -'"(M) (we denote it by (A-AI) I n particular, (A0 - AI) -' is compact in L2 (M).
Proof. It suffices to consider the case A=O. Let B E HLo a-'(M) be a parametrix for A. More precisely
AB =1- R
(8.9)
where R is an operator with smooth kernel R (x, y) (for simplicity we assume that
a smooth, positive density on M is fixed, so the kernel R (x, y) is an ordinary function on M x M). It follows from (8.9) that
A-'=B+A-'R,
(8.10)
and it remains to verify that A -'R is an operator with smooth kernel. But by (M) for any s e IR, and, moreover, is Theorem 7.2, A -' maps H' (M) into H" (M) continuous by the closed graph theorem. By the embedding Theorem 7.6, A -'
maps C°°(M) into C°°(M). But then A-'R is given by the smooth kernel R, (x, y) = [A -' R (- , y)](x).
§8. The Fredholm Property, Index and Spectrum
71
Theorem 8.3. Let a fixed smooth positive density dµ(x) on a closed man-
ifold M be fixed. Let A' = A E HL% (M), 1 - Q < 8 < Q, m > 0. Then Ao is a self-adjoins operator in L2(M) and there exists in this space a complete orthonormal system {tp; }, j = 1, 2, ... of eigenfunctions of Ao. Here (pi E CO0(M), Acp; = Atp; and the eigenvalues A; are real, with IA; I -+ +oo as j - +oo. The spectrum or (A) coincides with the set of all eigenvalues. Proof. Note first of all that a (A) c IR in view of Proposition 8.5, since A is symmetric on C' (M) and can thus have no non-real eigenvalues. Next, we want to show that a (A) * IR. Assuming a (A) = IR then we could for any A e IR find a function cpx e C°° (M), such that Aqpj = Aqp,, and II tpx II = 1
But then ((p,, cp,) = 0 for A * a by the symmetry of A, contradicting the separability of LZ(M). Now take A. a IRS a (A). By Theorem 8.2, R4 = (A - AO 1) -' is a compact self-adjoint operator in LZ (M). By a known theorem from functional analysis there is an orthonormal basis { v;)- , of eigenfunctions, where the eigenvalues r,
tend to 0 as j- + oo. Now note that r; 4 0 (since Ker (A - ).o 1) -' = 0). The condition R,,otp; = r; q7;
can therefore be rewritten in the form (A-AoI)(p; = r1 'cp;
or
A(Q;=(r,-i +Ao)rp;.
(8.11)
It is obvious from (8.11) that tp; E C °° (M) and the V, are eigenfunctions of A with
eigenvalues A, = r; ' + A0. It is also clear that I A; I -. + oo as j-' + oo. The remaining assertions of Theorem 8.3 are obvious. The fact that the spectrum a (A) coincides with the set of all eigenvalues {A;} follows from Proposition 8.5 and the self-adjointness from the representation A = Rxo + Aol.
The following theorem extends one of the statements of Theorem 8.3 to the non-selfadjoint case.
Theorem 8.4. Let A e HL'" -h (M), 1 - e <= 8 < e and m > 0. Then for the spectrum or (A), there are two possibilities:
a) a (A) = C (which, in particular, is the case if index A 4 0); b) a (A) is a discrete (maybe empty) subset of C (subset without limit points). If b) holds and AO e a (A) then there is a decomposition L2 (M) = E,, (D EL such that the following conditions are satisfied: 1) E,1, c C I (M), dim E,. < + oo, and E4 is an invariant subspace of A such that there exists a positive integer N > 0 with (A - A0 I)" E,. = 0 (in other words, the operator A I s,, has only the eigenvalue AO and is equal to the direct sum of Jordan cells of degree S N);
2) E,, is a closed subspace of L2(M), invariant with respect to AO (i.e. A (D,,.nE,) e and if we denote by A, the restriction AO I Ey, (understood as
Chapter 1. Foundations of'I'DO Theory
72
an unbounded operator in E;0 with domain DA° fl E;.O), then A' - AoI has a bounded inverse ( o r , in other w o r d s, A o ¢ a (A1Q)-
Proof. 1. Let or (A) $ C. Let us prove that a (A) is a discrete subset in C. There is a point AOe C\ a (A) and we may, without loss of generality, assume that AO = 0, so that by Theorem 8.2 A0 has a compact inverse Ao '. Then since
A0 - Al = (I-).A0 ')A0 the inclusion A e a (A) is equivalent to A + 0 and A -' e a (Ao ' ). Discreteness of a (A) follows from the fact that a (A. ') may have
only 0 as an accumulation point. 2. Let a (A) * C, AO e a (A). Once again, without loss of generality, we may assume that A0 = 0. Let /'0 be a contour in the complex plane, encircling 0 and not containing any other points of a (A) (e. g. a circle, sufficiently small and with centre at the origin). Consider the operator 1
PO =
2I
I
(8.12)
Standard arguments (cf. Riesz, Sz.-Nagy [1), ChapterXI) show that PO is a projection, of finite rank in view of the compactness of R, commuting with all the operators RA (and with AO in the sense that POAO c AOPO) and such that
if EEo = PO (L2 (M)), E2= (I - PO) (LZ (M)), then conclusions 1) and 2) of Theorem 8.4 hold. We leave it as exercise for the reader to take care about the details. We note only that the inclusion Eao C C°°(M) follows from Ao Ea° = 0 if we take into account the ellipticity of A and utilize the regularity Theorem 5.2. 8.4 Problems
Problem 8.1. Let E be a separable Hilbert space, nO (Fred (E, E)) the set of connected components of Fred (E, E) provided with the semigroup structure induced by the multiplication. Show that taking the index gives an isomorphism index: nO (Fred (E, E)) =- Z.
Hint. An operator A of index 0 can be written in the form A = A0 + T, where A0 is invertible and T has finite rank. Show (by use of the polar decomposition) the connectedness of the group of all invertible operators in E.
In all the following problems M is a closed manifold and 1 - g S S < g, m > 0.
Problem 8.2. Let A e HL'"-,1'-(M). Prove that A is a Fredholm operator in
C(M), i.e. that dim Ker A < + oo, ACW (M) is closed in C(M) and dim CokerA < +oo, where Coker A= C°°(M)/AC°°(M). Show that AC`°(M) consists of all f c C`° (M) for which (f, g) = 0 for any g e Ker A' (here ( , ) is a scalar product determined by some smooth positive density and A* is the adjoint 'PDO with respect to this scalar product).
§8. The Fredholm Property, Index and Spectrum
73
Problem 8.3. Let A e HL!,":--(M) and mo > 0. Let there be given on M a smooth positive density defining the scalar product(-, -)and the formal adjoint
'DO A. Assume A = A'. Let AO be the closure of the operator AIc.(M). Then Ao is self-adjoint in the Hilbert sense in the space L2(M). Problem 8.4. Let A e HLQ: s o(M), let A* be the formal adjoint operator and A0, Ao the closures of A I c. (M) and A I c.(M) in L2 (M) respectively. Show that AO
and Ao are adjoint to each other in the sense of the Hilbert space P(M). Hint. Consider the matrix of 'PDO'2I =
0 A
AO
'
Problem 8.5. Find an example of an operator A e HL ' (M) for which a (A) = C.
Problem 8.6. A sequence of Hilbert spaces E, and linear continuous operators d,: 0
°-`1E0 d o E1
-EN -1
°-'
) EN
°" 60 (8.13)
is called a complex if d 1+
1
dj = 0 for all j = 0, 1, ..., N-2. Put
Z'=Kerdt, B'=lmd,-1, H'=Z'/B', j=0, 1, ..., N. (if (8.13) is a complex, BicZ'). The spaces H' are called the cohomology of the complex (8.13). The complex is called Fredholm if dim H' < oo for all
j=0, 1, ..., N. a) show that if the complex (8.13) is Fredholm, then the B' are closed subspaces of Z'. b) Let d; = b;df + dj-1 b;-1, where bj = d,*. The operators d; are called the Laplacians of the complex (8.13) (or the Laplace-Hodge operators). Put I'' = Ker A, . Show that for the complex (8.13) to be Fredholm it is necessary and sufficient that all A, are Fredholm operators in Ej, j = 0, 1, 2, ... , N. In this case
dim H'= dim T'.
More precisely, I'' c Z' and the map T' - H' induced by the canonical projection
is an isomorphism (in the case of a Fredholm complex).
c) Put now N
X(E) _ E (-1)'dimH' J=0
(the Euler characteristic of the Fredholm complex E). Prove that if N = 1, then the Euler characteristic of the complex
74
Chapter I. Foundations of `YDO Theory
0 -. Eo °6 E1 - 0 is simply the index of do.
Prove that if dim Ej < +oo, j = 1, 2, ... , N, then N
X (E) _ E (-1)j dim Ej. J=o
d) Show that X (E) does not change under a uniform deformation of all the operators d, if under this deformation the sequence (8.13) remains a Fredholm complex. Problem 8.7. Let V ; (j = 0, 1, ... , N) be vector bundles on a closed manifold M and H'(M, Vj) the Sobolev spaces of sections. Let d,: C°°(M, Vj) - C'
(M, V.1) be classical PDO of the same order m. Let To (M) be the cotangent
bundle over M without the zero section and no: To (M) --* M the natural projection. Assume that the operators ...
0 ° _. C°°(M, Vo) a ' C_ (M' V1)
16
C°°(M, VN) , 0 (8.14)
form a complex. Let ad'- no V -+ no Vj+, be the principal symbols of the operators d, (homogenous functions in of order m). The complex (8.14) is called elliptic if the sequence of vector bundles ,
o
0 -+ no Vo
o
no VN --* 0
nO VI
is exact (i. e. an exact sequence of vector spaces at every point (x, ) a To (M)). a) Show that ellipticity of the complex (8.14) is equivalent to ellipticity
of all the Laplacians Aj = bjdj + dj_,8,_1, where 8j is the'PDO adjoint to d, with respect to some density on M and a Hermitean scalar product on the vector bundles Vj. b) Show that if (8.14) is an elliptic complex, then for any s e IR, the complex
H'--(M, V1)....
0 d - HS(M, V0) -d'
dam - Ha-N",(M, VN) °-" . 0
is Fredholm and the dimension of its cohomology (and thus the Euler characteristic) does not depend on s. The cohomology itself can be defined also as the cohomology of the complex (8.14), i.e. putting Hi= Ker(dJIc-i,M.v,))/dj-1(C00(M,Vj-1))
Problem 8.8. Show that the de Rham complex on a real n-manifold M
0 - A0(M)
? A' (M) - A2 (M) d ° i
_, ....
0 A"(M) --; 0
§8. The Fredholm Property, Index and Spectrum
75
(AJ (M) is the space of smooth exterior j-forms on M, d is the exterior differential)
and the Dolbeault complex on a complex manifold M, dim, M = n,
0 -, Aa. o(M)
. AP-'(M)
-L ...
, AP-"(M) - 0
(AD.9(M) is the space of smooth forms of type (p, q) on M and is the CauchyRiemann-Dolbeault operator) are elliptic complexes. Derive from this the finite-dimensionality of the de Rham and Dolbeault cohomology in case of a closed M.
Chapter II Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators §9. Pseudodifferential Operators with Parameter. The Resolvent 9.1 Preliminaries. Let A be a subset of the complex plane (in the applications this will, as a rule, be an angle with the vertex at the origin). In spectral theory it is useful to consider operators depending on a parameter A E A
(an example of such an operator is the resolvent (A -).I) To begin with, we introduce some symbol classes. Let X be an open set in IR" and let a (x, 0, A) be a function on X x lR" x A,
xeX, OEIR, AEA. Definition 9.1. Let m, Q, b, d be real numbers with 0 5 S < g ;S 1, 0 < d < + oo. The class So o. d(X x R, A) consists of the functions a (x, 0, A) such that 1) a (x, 0, AO) E C°° (X x JR') for every fixed A0 E A;
2) For arbitrary multi-indices a and f and for any compact set K C X there exist constants
such that
laeafa(x,9,A)j S
(9.1)
for x e K, 0 E lR1, A E A. As usual we put
S-°°(XxIR",A) = n S'",Q a:a(XxIR",A) MCR
(the right-hand side does not depend on g, b and d). If a(x, y, 4, A) E SQ J;d(X x X x IRA, A), we may construct a `PDO A,,, depending on the parameter). E A: (Ax u) (x) = l l e1 , - y t a (x, y, , A) u (y) dy dd ,
(9.2)
for u E Co (X). In this case we will write A,ELQ a:d(X,A)
Note that A, a L- Ic (X, A) if and only if the operator A, has a smooth kernel K, (x, y) for any fixed A E A and there exist constants C; s!K (K a compact set in X,
Chapter H. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
78
a and fi multi-indices and N a positive integer) such that the following estimate holds
Iaxaf K2(x,y)I 5
Cvp'x(I+IA1)-",
x, yEK.
(9.3)
Many of the statements about `PDO without a parameter (cf. §§3-7) can also be proved for the case with a parameter A. We indicate now some of these statements, which are necessary in what follows. First, note that the whole theory of asymptotic summation (Definition 3.4 and Propositions 3.5 and 3.6) carries over to symbols depending on a parameter. The corresponding formulations are obtained by changing SQ a (X x IR") to SQ b;d (X
X IR", A) and the proofs are almost verbatim repetitions of the arguments in 3.3 and are left for the reader as an exercise. We only state that the role of <0> in these proofs (as in the following) is now played by (1+I©I2+ 1A121d),12
Further we will call an operator A,1 E LQ d;d(X, A) properly supported if it is uniformly properly supported in A, i. e. there exists a closed set L C X x X, having proper projections on each factor in X x X, such that supp KA, c L for all A E A.
Note that any operator A ELQ 6;d(X, A) can be decomposed into a sum A = A, + R1, where A 1 (depending on a parameter) is properly supported in the sense described and R, a Lo s d(X, A). For properly supported `PDO AA depending on a parameter, the symbol aA.(x, S) = aA (x, , A) is defined and a theorem of type 3.1 is valid. Naturally, we have to interpret formula (3.21) taking the parameter into account, i.e.
aA(x, S, A) - L « G A S Dy a(x, y, S,A)Iy_xe 121S"-1
ESQ d
d-d!"(XxIR", A).
In an analogous way Theorems 3.2-3.4 on the transpose and adjoint operato and composition can be generalized.
Exercise 9.1. Prove all the statements in sec. 3 in the case of operators an symbols depending on a parameter. Further, repeating the arguments of §4, for 1 - Q < 6 < Q, we may introduce the classes LQ a:d (M, A) on a manifold M. Let us now pass to considering hypoellipticity and ellipticity. We introduce the class HS,',-.' , (X x W, A) of symbols a (x, , A) (we will call them hypoelliptic with parameter), belonging to S',,,,, (X x 1R", A) and satisfying the estimates C1 (ICI+IAI"d)m, < l a(x,
C2(Ifl+IAi"d)
(9.4)
for x e K (K compact in X), I I + I A I ? R, C1 > 0 and R, C, , C2 may depend on K;
§9. Operators with Parameters
s
I [asaXa(x,
79
(9.5)
+ IA I z R (here, as above, R may depend on K). We will denote by HL"" a a (X, A) the class of properly supported `'DO (depending on the parameter I E A), whose symbols belong to HS0' a (X X for x e K, I
IRA, A). We have an analogue of Theorem 5.1: If A e HL Q (X, A), then there exists an operator B, a HLQ called the parametrix of the operator A,, such that
B,A,=!+Rx,
A,BA =I+Ri
(X, A)
(9.6)
where R;, Rx E L-w(X, A). The same statement is also true when X is a manifold.
Exercise 9.2. Prove this analogue of Theorem 5.1. It is natural also to consider classical `I'DO depending on a parameter. In this case A is assumed to be an angle with the vertex at 0. The corresponding symbols a(x, ! , A) admit asymptotic expansions (for I I + III' ? 1) of the form Tco
Y am -i(x, ,2),
(9.7)
f=o
where am _, (x, , A) is positive homogeneous in
A"') of degree m -j, i. e.
am-1(x, t > 0, A e A and t') e A. Here m can be any complex number. This class of symbols will be denoted by CS, (X x IV, A) and the corresponding class of operators by CLd (X, A). This class is stable under composition, taking the transpose and taking the adjoint.
We will say that the operator A, e CLa (X, A) is elliptic with parameter if it is
properly supported and
a,, (x, , 2) 4 0
if
x e X and I f I + 12I"' * 0 .
(9.9)
It clearly follows that A, a HL; ; '" d (X, A). There exists a parametrix B, a CL;- m(X, A) of a classical elliptic operator with parameter, which is also an elliptic operator with parameter. Example 9.1. Let A be a differential operator in X of degree m and I the unit
operator. Then A - Al a CL (X, C) and the principal symbol is given by the formula am (x, ) is the principal symbol of A. If A is a closed angle in the complex plane with vertex at the origin such that am (x, ) for I I = I does not take values
Chapter If. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
80
in A, then the operator A - 2I is elliptic with parameter (and, in particular, belongs to HL-,-
m
(X, A)).
9.2 Norms of operators with parameter. In this subsection we will consider operators with parameter of two kinds: 1) operators Ax in IR", such that supp KAA lies in a fixed compact set k c IR2rt
(where 056
m ands, / e JR. Let one of the numbers
6, s, s - I be equal to 0. Then 11A,, II,.,-, C, (1+IA11'd)m,
IIAx11s,s-l
if if
Cs.l(1+jAj11d)-p-m),
Corollary 9.1. If AA E LQ, b d (X, A), where m
1;_> 0,
/<_0.
(9.11)
(9.12)
0, then
IIA,II < C(1+I2l a)m,
(9.13)
where II AA II denotes the operator norm of A. in L2 (X).
We will need the following useful Lemma 9.1 (Schur Lemma). If A is an operator with the Schwartz kernel KA such that
Sup f I KA(X, y)ldy < C and x
sup f I KA(X, y)ldx < C, t.
then IIA:L2--), L211
(This lemma holds for integral operators in L2 on any measure space, or for L2(X) for any measure spaces X, Y.) integral operators L2(Y) Proof. By the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality we have
IAu(x)I2 < (f I KA(x, y)IIu(y)Idy)2 _ (f IK,+(x, y)1112IKA(x, y)I1/2Iu(y)Idy)2
f I KA(x, y) Idy f I KA(x, y)IIu(y)I2dy
< C f IKA(x, y)IIu(y)l2dy.
§9. Operators with Parameters
81
Now integrating with respect to x and changing the order of integration we obtain the desired norm estimate. Proof of Theorem 9.1. 1. Note first of all that a partition of unity reduces the case X = M to the case X = IR", which we will now study.
2. Consider first the case s = I = m = 0. The statement of the theorem reduces to the estimate (9.14)
IIkII:5 C,
which is proved by repeating verbatim the argument in §6 (we recommend the reader to work this through as an exercise). Note now that the estimate (9.14) could be proved directly utilizing the results from §6 if the constants Ca. a (A) = sup l as as a (x, , 2) I « ° lal alai
(9.15)
X.(
where bounded as 12 I -+ + oc. This evidently follows from (9.1) for S = 0, but for b > 0 some of the constants Ca, a (A) can grow as I A I -+ + oo. Therefore, for 6 > 0
it is indeed necessary to repeat the argument from §6. 3. Now consider in IR" the standard operator-valued 0m()) E L m ,. o; a (R",
C) with the symbol f p m (x, , 2) = (1 + I
I2 + 1 A
function 121a)"n. This
1PDO with parameter will be useful to us, although it does not satisfy condition 1). Let us estimate the norm of the operator 4',,,(A). The operator 0. (0) induces an isometric isomorphism of H"(IR") onto L2(IR"). Therefore II0"(A)Ils.s-I = Il0:-1(0) 0. (A) It -s(0)II
But 0.-1(0) 0.(A) 4P _,(0) =0.(A) 0_1(0) is simply the multiplication operator in V(W) of the Fourier transform by and therefore its norm is equal to 21a)m/2
W,",(A) = sup (1+1
12+IA121d)"r2
4CW
We obviously have
Y/., (A) 5 Csup (1+Ici+IAI1jd)"0 4eR
where C only depends on m and / (but not on A). Now, from the easily verified relation
sup(1+x+1)"(1+x)-'= Xao
5(1+if /?0, C", t" ', if
(we assume m:51 everywhere) it follows that
1_< 0
and
i z R",
Chapter II. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
82
Wm (2) 5 Cm (1 + W.1 (A)
I2rd)m,
if 1 z 0,
if 150,
Cm1
i.e. for 0m (2) one of the norm-estimates (9.11), (9.12) holds as asserted in the theorem. 4. Consider now the general case AA E LQ a, d (1R", A). We obviously have IIAAIIa.a- =
(0-m(2) AA)II,s(9.16)
III-m(2) AAlls.a
and analogously IIAAII3.a- = II(AA-0-m(2))0.(2)I1a.a5 II II'm(2)Ils.a-
(9.17)
Using the already proven norm-estimate for II0m(A)I1a.a- we see that in order to complete the proof of the theorem when s = 0 or s -I= 0 it suffices to verify that II'-m(A)AAII 5 C,
(9.18)
II AA- 0-m(2)II S C.
5. Let us define -m (A) as an operator with the Schwartz kernel which is obtained by multiplying the Schwartz kernel of 45..m(A) by tp(x - y), where
(p E Co (IR"), (P = I in a neighbourhood of 0 E IR". Then &_m(A) is a uniformly properly supported `PDO in L" o;d(1R", (r). Let us write
(9.19)
d5_m(A) + R-m(A)
and investigate the remainder operator R_m (A) which has a Schwartz kernel KR_", vanishing in a s-neighbourhood of the diagonal. In fact it is a convolution operator, so KR_. depends on x - y and A only. It is easy to see from the construction of R_m (A) that KR_", (x, y; A) = r-m (x - y, ),) with
r-m(z, A) = f e'-{(I - V (Z)) (I +
IAI2/d)-m/2 a,
Ia"
where W E Co (IV), (p = 1 is a neighbourhood of 0.
Now it is easy to prove that
I) E S(lR") for every fixed A E C.
A) in S(IR") decay as III -' oo faster than Moreover, all seminorms of any power of IA I. Indeed, we can apply the standard integration by parts to get
r-m(z, A) = f e''{IzI-2N(l _'p(z)) [(-at)"(1 + IRR
hence
IAI21d)-m/2]
§9. Operators with Parameters
83
z'Dlr-.(z,),) = f zaDq [eiz'EIZI-2N(1 - p(Z))} L
(R"
X [(-e{)N(1 + 112 + IAI2/d)-m/21 dt,
for an arbitrary integer N > 0 and any fixed multiindices of, P. The integrand can be estimated by Izl)iai-2N(1
C(1 +
+ 141)1ai(t + 141 +
IAI11d)-m-2N
with a constant C > 0. We can assume that m + 2N > 0 and use the obvious estimate IAI11d)_m-2N
(I + I4I +
< (1 +
IAI11d)-m12-N
to arrive to the estimate lzaDar-m(z, ),)I < Ca0N(1 +
IAI1/d)-m/2-",
which holds for sufficiently large N and implies the desired result. 6. Now we will sketch two possible proofs of estimates of type (9.18) for R_," (A) A, and AAR_m (A).
Let us recall that it is assumed that the Schwartz kernels of A, are supported in a fixed (independent of A) compact subset of IR" x IR".
(a) Note that the proof of the boundedness result (e.g. Proposition 7.5) implies that IIAaII,;-m <_ C(I + ICI)"',
where M = M(s, A) is independent of A. This is a rough estimate and it is easy to obtain by following the steps of the proof of Proposition 7.5 and of the necessary results from Sect. 6. Now note that R_,,(A) is infinitely smoothing in the Sobolev scale Hr(IR"), and, more precisely, IIR-m(A)II,. < C.r.t.N(I +
IAI)-N
for all s, t E IR and N > 0. This holds because the convolution operator R_m(),) can be presented as the multiplication of the Fourier transform by a function r_m(i;, A) = F2.4r(z, A) which is in S(IR") with respect to t with seminorms which decay as IAI --+ oo faster than any power of IAI due to the estimates obtained in the first part of my comments to this question above. Combining the two inequalities above we immediately obtain the desired estimates of the type (9.18) for R_m ().)A, and A, R_m (A).
(b) Another way to establish these estimates is to study first the structure of the operators R_m(A)A, and A,R_m(A). It suffices to consider the operator A, R_. (A) and then use the relation
84
Chapter II. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
(R-m(),)Ai)* = AxR-.,(X) to establish the same estimates for the operators of the type R_," (1) Ax. Clearly Ax R_", (1) can be written in the standard form (3.9) with the symbol ax.. (x, 4) = aA, (x, 4) L. (t, )A), where the function F was defined above. Note that o,,, (x, 4) has a compact support with respect to x, uniformly in 4. Taking into account the behavior of r` we see that ax,m (x, 4) satisfies the estimates Ia4 D ax.m(x, 4)1 < Ca.Pm.M.x(l + 151)-'"(l +
IAI)_N
for any M, N > 0 and any multiindices a, P. The Schwartz kernel of the operator A,, R_", (1) has the form
KA(x, y) = f
4) d4.
IR"
The estimates for ax immediately imply that
IKx(x, y)l < CN(1 + Ix - yl)-N, and the required norm estimates follow from the Schur lemma. 7. Now let 8 = 0. It is clear from (9.16) that we need to show that (9.20)
II0-m(A)AAIL.. _< C,
where C does not depend on ,l (but may depend on s). Clearly (9.21)
III-,(A)AxIIF..T =
Acting as in the part 5 of this proof, we may replace 'P, (A) by a properly supported `YDO 0, (A) (for any t E IR) and instead of (9.20) prove the estimate
C.
(9.22)
Denote the symbol of 4;_m(A)A, by b(x, 4, A). We claim that b(x, 4, x) E S°O.d(IR"; A)
in the sense of the uniform classes in IR" (see problems 3.1 and 3.2), and in particular b(x, i . ,l) E SO °(1R2') uniformly in A, i.e. Q
sup[Ia,dfb(x,
+oo
x.E.)L
Using an appropriate composition formula (e.g. in the uniform classes discussed in Problems 3.1 and 3.2) we see that the same estimates hold for the symbol a(x, 4. X) of the operator ds,(0)dy_m(A)Ax _,(0). Now applying the boundedness theorem (again extended to uniform operators in lR") we get the desired estimate (9.22) for the operator norm. Another possible way of arguing (to avoid using uniform operators in IR"): introduce appropriate cut-off functions to reduce everything to functions sup-
§9. Operators with Parameters
85
ported in a fixed compact set, and then investigate remainders, using the Schur
Lemma. 0 9.3 The inverse of operators with parameter. In this part we will consider only operators on a closed manifold M. Theorem 9.2. Let A .x eHLQa5(M, A). Then there exists R > 0, such that for IzI z R, the operator A, is invertible with AA-' EHLQ.e°e '`(M,i1R).
(9.23)
where AR = A o (.111) I z R}. More precisely, if B, is a parametrix for the operator with parameter A, , i.e. condition (9.6) is fulfilled, then AA-' - B,1 E L- x (M, AR).
(9.24)
Proof. Let B, be a parametrix for the operator A,. Then it is obvious from (9.6) that it suffices to prove that I + R, with R, e L- ac (M, AR) is invertible for small A and
(I+R,,-' - 1EL-°O(M, AR).
(9.25)
Note that for arbitrary N > 0 and s, t E 1R
IIR1II, < C;"'(1+IAI)-".
(9.26)
From this it follows, in particular, that there exists R > 0 such that II R, II R is guaranteed in each of the spaces H' (M). To prove (9.25) it is convenient to use
(1+R,)-' - 1= -R,(I+R,)-'
(9.27)
and (9.26). Denoting the left hand side of (9.27) by Q, we see that estimates of the
form (9.26) hold for Q, . The kernel Q,(x, y) of Q, can be expressed by the formula Q,I (x, Y) _ [Qab( - -Y)l(x),
(9.28)
where b (z - y) is the b-function (in z) at a point y e M on which it depends as a parameter. The operator Q, in (9.28) acts on the variable z and the result is taken at the point x. Note that if s < - n/2, then b (- - y) a H'(M). Further, b (- - y) is
Chapter II. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
86
a differentiable function of y with values in H' -' (M) and is more generally a k times differentiable function of y with values in H-' -'(M). Therefore from (9.26) it follows that estimates of the form (9.3) hold for the kernel Q j(x, y), which also demonstrates that Q, a L- °° (M, AR). The inclusions (9.23) and (9.24) then also readily follow. 9.4 The resolvent of an elliptic operator. Returning to example 9.1 in the case
of an operator on a manifold and applying the results obtained we get Theorem 93. Let A be a differential operator on a closed manifold M with principal symbol a. (x, ) and A a closed angle in the complex plane C with vertex 0 e C. Let A be elliptic with parameter relative to A, i. e. for $ 0, a.(x, ) does not take values in A. Then a) there exists R > 0 such that A - AI is invertible for A EAR with
(A-AI)-`eCL.-"(M,AR);
(9.29)
b) the following norm estimate holds
II(A-AI)-'II,.,rj:5 C,.r/I2I'-um,
0515m,
AFAR,
(9.30)
where s is any real number.
Proof a) follows from Theorem 9.2 and b) from a) and Theorem 9.1. Corollary 9.2. Under the conditions of Theorem 9.3 we have II(A-AI)-
II 5 C/IAI,
AEAR.
(9.31)
Corollary 9.3. Let A be an elliptic self-adjoint differential operator on a closed manifold M with principal symbol a (x, l;). Assume that a. (x, i;) > O for all (x, g), 4 0. Then A is semi-bounded from below, i. e. there is a constant C > 0 such that
A>- -CI or (Au,u) >_ -C(u,u),
(9.32)
We mention here another important fact, namely that under the condition of ellipticity with parameter, the resolvent (A -AI)-' differs from the parametrix only by an operator of L- °° (M, A). This is used in the theory of complex powers along with the explicit construction of a parametrix as given in the elliptic theory (cf. section 5.5).
Problem 9.1. Extend the theory of elliptic operators with parameter to the case of matrix operators, i.e. to systems.
§ 10. Definition and Basic Properties
87
Hint. The condition of ellipticity with parameter for a matrix function a, (x, ), means that det (a. (x, ) - A) $ 0 for * 0 and A e A or, equivalently, that the eigenvalues of a. (x, ) do not belong to A for I # 0. Problem 9.2. Let A be an elliptic differential operator on a closed manifold
M, and suppose that for some angle A the operator A - Al is elliptic with parameter for A e A. Show that index A = 0.
§10. Definition and Basic Properties of the Complex Powers of an Elliptic Operator 10.1 Definition of the holomorphic semigroup A= . Let A be an elliptic differential operator of order m on a closed n-dimensional manifold M and a,,, (x, ) the principal symbol of A. Assume that a,,, (x, c) does not take values in a
dosed angle A of the complex plane C for * 0 (here the vertex of A is assumed to be at 0 e C). In other words, in the notation of §9, A - AI e CLT (M, A) and satisfies the condition of ellipticity with parameter. It follows from Theorem 9.3 that the resolvent R,, = (A - A 1) -' is defined for ? R, A e A i. e. for A e AR. Now, in view of Theorem 8.4, we see that the spectrum a (A) of A is a discrete subset of C. Hence, in the angle there can be only a finite number of points of a (A). We may therefore draw a ray Lo, starting at 0 and running inside A such that a (A) n Lo is either empty or consists of the point 0 only. In what follows, we assume for convenience firstly that 0 * a (A), i. e. A -' exists as an operator (cf. §8), and secondly that Lo = (- oo, 0]. Neither of these assumptions is very essential; we may get rid of the first one by replacing A with A + e1 and the second by studying e'"A instead of A. So, finally, our assumptions are as follows: 1)
for +0 and 1.E(-oo,01;
2) or (A) n (- oo, 0] = 0.
(10.1) (10.2)
It follows from conditions 1) and 2) that for some angle A of the form (n - a:5 arg2 <- it + e), with e > 0, the following hold:
1')a,.(x,I;)-A#0for 4*0and XEA;
(10.1')
2') a(A)nA=0.
(10.2')
In what follows we shall assume that A has been chosen in this way. Since 0 ¢ a(A), we see that a(A) does not intersect a disk I X I < 2q in the
complex A-plane. Now select in this plane a contour r = rQ of the form
r=r, ur2vr,, where (Fig.1)
Chapter 11. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
88
lal
or9 a = a 0
r
Fig. I
A= rei" (+ oc > r > Q)
on r,,
.1=Qe'' (n>qp>-n) A.=re-'" (Q
on r2 , on F3.
Consider the integral
Az=Zn fAx(A-AI)-'dA,
(10.3)
r
where z e C, Az is defined as a holomorphic function of A for A e C\ (- oo, 0], equal to ei1nz fort > 0 (here it is assumed that In ,1 a IR for A. > 0). In other words,
on 1' we set A: = er'n1 = ezlnlll+'zar9A =I A IzeizarsA,
(10.4)
where - it < arg A 5 it (arg A is described more precisely in the definition of the
contour r). Note that in view of the estimate (9.31) (Corollary 9.2) the integral (10.3) converges in the operator norm on L2 (M) for Re z < 0 and also A2 is a bounded
operator on L2(M). In the same ray, by Theorem 9.3, the integral (10.3) converges in the operator norm on H5 (M) for arbitrary s E IR and also, for Rez <0, AQ maps H2(M) into H5(M) hence also maps C°`(M) into C' (M) as
well as I'(M) into 9'(M), since
C'°(M) _ fHs(M)
and
W(M) = U Hs(M).
J
S
Proposition 10.1. a) For Re z < 0 and Re w < 0 we have the semigroup property A=Aw= Asrw
(10.5)
A -,= (A-')'`.
(10.6)
b) If k E Z and k> 0 then
c) For arbitrary s E R, A= is a holomorphic operator function of z (for Re z < 0) with values in the algebra of bounded operators on the Hilbert space H2(M).
Proof. a) Construct a contour r' (Fig. 2) of the form r' = r; u r2 u r; , where
89
§ 10. Definition and Basic Properties
Fig. 2
A= reA''-O (+oo>r>i Q) A = z Qe' (n-e>(p> -n+e)
on I'1
on r; on r;.
.l = re'(-x+e) (Z Q
The number a> 0 is chosen so that (10.1') and (10.2') are satisfied. The contour F
is contained "within" I", and in view of (9.31) and the condition on I" it is obvious that the integral (10.3) does not change if we replace F by V. Utilizing this fact, we obtain A=Aw
4I
I
(A-µl)-' Azpw dpd1
J(A-2l)-'
r, r
Azµ"'
4rt rJ rJ x_ p [(A-AI)- -
(A-,uI)-'] dµdA
= L J Aw+z(A-AI)-`dA+..± J J (A -µl)-` r r r,
: w
p
dldp
= Az+w+ 0 = Az+w
In this computation we have used the Cauchy formula and the so-called Hilbert identity (A
(A
[(A
-(A
(10.7)
which is clear if we, for instance, multiply both sides by (A-Al) (A-uI).
b) Note that if z = -1, -2, ..., then (re' )' = (re-ix)' and the integrals along the straight line parts of r in (10.3) cancel. Therefore A-k __
J -' (A-.ll) 2s r,
' d2,
90
Chapter H. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
where 12 = {IAI = e}, traversed clockwise. Now make a change of variables, putting A = 1/p which gives r x Jpk(A_p-'I)-ip-Zdp, A_k= -2
r;
where I'2 = fl p I =1 /e}, also traversed clockwise. Taking into account that (A
-p`I)-' =,uA-1(p1-A-')-', we may now write lA-' A-k = - 2n Jp k-1 (pl-A- )-'du = A- (A r; 1
1
1)k
1
-= (A
1)k,
since the entire spectrum of the bounded operator A-' is situated inside the contour f and we may use the Cauchy formula. c) Differentiating the integral (10.3) with respect to z we obtain the integral
J2Z (ln.l) (A-AI)-1 d.1, 2n r
(10.8)
converging in operator norm (in H'(M)) uniformly for Re z:5 - s < 0. We conclude, that the operator function A. is holomorphic in z and the derivative dz
As is equal to the integral (10.8).
CJ
10.2 Definition of the complex powers of an operator Definition 10.1. Let z e C and k e Z be such that Re z < k. Put, on C °° (M) or -9, (M) AZ = AkAZ k -
(10.9)
We need to verify that this is well-defined and that is the content of the first part of the following theorem.
Theorem 10.1. a) The operator A' as defined by (10.9) is independent of the choice of integer k, provided Re z < k. b) If Re z < 0, then A' = AZ . c) The group property holds
AzA'"=AZT",
z, weC
(10.10)
d) If k c- Z, then (10.9) with z = k gives the usual k-th power of the operator A
(in particular A° = I, A'= A and A - ' is the inverse to A).
§ 10. Definition and Basic Properties
91
e) For arbitrary k e Z and s e IR, the function A= is a holomorphic operator function of z in the half-plane Re z < k with values in the Banach space .V (H'(M),
H'-Mk(M)) of bounded linear operators from H'(M) to H' -'k (M). Proof. a) Let z e C, k, I e Z be such that Rez < k, Re z < 1. We need to verify
that A&A=_k = A'A=_1
(10.11)
Assume that k > 1 and put k -1= p and z - k = w. Then (10.11) reduces to the
equality Aw=A-PA,,.,, with p a positive integer and Re(w+p)<0. This however, follows at once from Proposition 10.1 since A -P =A -P by (10.6) and it only remains to use the semi-group property (10.5).
b)-d) These properties follow in an obvious manner from a) and Proposition 10.1.
e) This statement follows straightforwardly from a) and c) in Proposition 10.1, if we remember that Ak, for k an integer, maps H'(M) continuously into H'-"(M) (this follows from Theorem 7.3 (on boundedness)
and the fact that A-'eCL-M(M), as is clear from Theorem 8.2 (about the inverse operator)).
10.3 The self adjoint case. Let a smooth positive density on M be given defining a scalar product on L2(M) and A a self-adjoint elliptic differential operator of order m on M. Then its principal symbol a. (x, 1;) is real-valued. In this case, conditions (10.1) and (10.2), which we assume to hold, mean that
a.(x,4)>0,
A?bI,
4#0,
6>0,
(10.12) (10.13)
Let {(p}' 1 be a complete orthonorRemember that mal system of eigenfunctions for A with eigenvalues Aj-. + oo as j - oo (cf. Theorem 8.3). It follows from (10.13) that A,? 6 > 0 for all j = 1, 2, .... Now, any distribution f e 9' (M) may be represented as a Fourier series r
i.e. (Au,u) z 6(u,u) for any
f- > fapt(x),
where
xeM,
(10.14)
1=J
f=(f,w;)
(10.15)
Here, when f e L2 (M) we of course have the usual scalar product in LZ (M).
If, however f e 9' (M), then (f, 9j) denotes U; ipjdp>, where du is the fixed density on M (recall that the distributions are linear continuous functionals on the space of smooth densities). We now describe the properties of the Fourier series of smooth functions and distributions.
92
Chapter 11. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
Proposition 10.2. For a series OD
(10.16)
Y- ci(pj(x)
j=1
with complex coefficients cj the following properties are equivalent: a) the series (10.16) converges in the C00(M)-topology; b) the series (10.16) is the Fourier series of some function feC°°(M);
c) for any integer N Icj12AJN<+oo.
(10.17)
j=1
Furthermore, conditions d), e) and f) are also equivalent: d) the series (10.16) converges in the weak topology of 9'(M);
e) the series (10.16) is the Fourier series of some distribution f e 2'(M); f) the exists an integer N (perhaps negative), such that (10.17) is fulfilled.
Proof. The basic idea of the proof is to use the relations
C°°(M) = nHs(M),
9'(M) _ y Hs(M), a
s
and the fact that A' is a topological isomorphism between the spaces H'"N(M) and LZ(M). Now, LZ(M) is easily characterized in terms of the coefficients of Fourier series by the Parceval equality. Therefore the topology of C°`(M) may be determined via the seminorms II f II A; N where IIJ IIA:N = j=1
'ii
'J",
because ANf has the Fourier coefficients ,tN J. From this the equivalence of conditions a), b) and c) is obvious. Let us verify the equivalence of d), e) and f). If d) is satisfied denote by f the sum of the series (10.16), so that f e 9' (M) and W
(f (P) _ Y- cj((Pj,w) J=1
for any p e C'° (M). In particular, taking (p = (pj we obtain cj = j i.e. precisely e). Further, if e) is satisfied, i. e. cj = (f, qpj), with f c- 9' (M), then selecting an integer N such that AN f e LZ (M) we also see that f) is satisfied. Finally, if f) is satisfied,
then the series (10.16) converges in the norm of HN(M), thus giving d).
§ 10. Definition and Basic Properties
93
We now introduce a "spectral" characterization of the complex powers of a
self-adjoint operator A in terms of the coefficients of the eigenfunction expansion associated with the eigenfunctions rpt. x
Proposition 10.3. Let f e 21'(M) and let f (x) = Y_ fjgpj (x) be the Fourier I=I
series expansion off in the eigenfunctions of the operator A. Then
Azf =
A; f gyp; (x)
(10.18)
.
l=1
In particular, q (x) are the eigenfunctions of the operator As with eigenvalucs Aj .
Proof. The operator AZ maps C'(M) continuously into itself. In view of the easily verified relation (AZ)* = A4 we see that AZ being the adjoint of AZ
continuously maps 2'(M) into 1'(M) provided I'(M) is endowed with its weak topology. Since the series on the right hand side of (10.18) converges weakly in -9'(M) by Proposition 10.2, in order to verify (10.18) in the general case it suffices to do so for f = V,, Re z < 0. But, f = gyp; and Re z < 0 imply JA'(A-AI)-I
AZpt = 2n r
(ppd2 = 2r r
Az(Aj-A)
d) = )Jrpt
r
by the Cauchy formula. But this is exactly (10.18) for f = (Pp
0
Exercise 10.1. Let A satisfy (10.1) but instead of (10.2) require the weaker condition
a(A)n(-oo,0) _0, so that KerA may be a non-empty finite-dimensional subspace in C'(M). Define A. via the contour integral (10.3) and let E0, EE be the invariant subspaces of the operator A introduced in Theorem 8.4. a) Show that A2 E° = 0 and EE is an invariant subspace of A. for Re z < 0. b) Show that for the operators Az the semigroup property AZ A.= Re z < 0, Re w < 0 holds, allowing Az to be well-defined for all z by formula (10.9), so that the group property (10.10) holds for the operators A. c) Verify that Az for a sufficiently large positive integer z is the usual power of A whereas
A°=I-P° where P° is the projection onto the subspace E° parallel to Ea and that, analogously, A _k for a sufficiently large positive integer k is the inverse of the operator Ak on EE and equals 0 on E°.
94
Chapter Il. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
Problem 10.1. Let A be an elliptic differential operator with principal symbol a, (x, ) on a closed manifold M. Assume that Re aT (x, ) < 0 for # 0. Show that the Cauchy problem au
81=Au,
t>0;
U I'=0 = (P W;
(10.19)
has a unique solution in C°°(M) and .9'(M). Hint. The solution u (1, x) will necessarily be of the form u = e`Aco ,
(10.20)
where the operator e" is determined via the contour integral e'" = 21
r
Se-t'(A-2I)-1 dA.
(10.21)
Assuming that the spectrum a (A) is situated in the half-plane Re A < 0 (which can be achieved by changing A into A - CI or substituting u = ve' in (10.19)), it suffices to take r =1', u T2 , where r, and r2 are the following two rays:
A=re'lz-` (+oo>r>0) on I',, A = re`
Z
(0 < r < + oo) on F2 .
The uniqueness of the generalized solution of the problem (10.19) is demonstrated using the Holmgren principle (cf. e. g. Gel'fand 1. M., gilov G.E. [1], vol. 3).
§ 11. The Structure of the Complex Powers of an Elliptic Operator 11.1 The symbol of the resolvent. Let A be an elliptic differential operator on a closed manifold M. We shall next construct in local coordinates the symbol of a special parametrix of the operator with parameter A - Al (which we view here as an operator in CL.(M, A), A a closed angle in C with vertex at 0). We assume that A satisfies the conditions for ellipticity with parameter relative to A, where
the angle A is as described in §10 (i.e. it satisfies (10.1') and (10.2'), and A contains the semi-axis (- oo, 01). The parametrix will be constructed in a chart XcM and we will identify X with an open set in 1R" using a coordinate system on X. Let the operator A on X be of the form
§ 11. The Structure of the Complex Powers
95
A = E aa(x)D*.
(11.1)
IaIS m
Its total symbol Y_ a. (x)
(11.2)
I*IS on
may be decomposed into homogeneous components
a; (x, ) _ Y as (x)
j = 0, 1.... , m .
(11.3)
I=I=;
The total symbol a (x, , A) = a (x, ) - A of A - AI may be decomposed into components homogeneous in (, A"'") given by the formulas
a. (x, S, A) = a,, (x,0-), a, (x,
(11.4)
j=0, 1, ..., m-1.
(11.5)
The condition of ellipticity with parameter means that
for xEX, J.EA,
it 1+1A1'tm
0
(11.6)
It is natural to look for the symbol of the parametrix of A - ).1 in the form of
Denote these an asymptotic sum of functions homogeneous in functions by b°-m_j (x, , A), j = 0, 1, 2, ... , where the lower index indicates the degree of homogeneity:
t>0, IfI+IAI'1'"*0.
(11.7)
These functions are recursively defined by the relations
am(x,
0,
(11.9)
k+I+IaI=J
I<j
j=1,2,...
(compare the construction of a parametrix for the classical elliptic PDO in §5, formulas (5.17') and (5.17")). To obtain a real parametrix from these functions b°- m -t (x, , A) it is first of all necessary to eliminate their singularities for I I + 1). 1 = 0 by multiplication
with a cut-off function and, secondly, to glue together the various local parametrices using a partition of unity (cf. §5).
Chapter II. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
96
11.2 The Symbols of complex powers. We shall construct the homogeneous components of the symbol of Az using the homogeneous components of the parametrix constructed earlier, in exactly the same way as the powers AZ were constructed using the resolvent (A - Al) - `. Indeed, from the condition of ellipticity with a parameter there follows the existence of Q = Q (x, ) such that am (x, , A) * 0 for I A I < 2 Q, r; 0 and A e C. From (11.8) and (11.9) it is clear that b-m -i (x, r;, A) is holomorphic in A in the disc I A I < 2,q. Forming the contour F as in §10, we may define the functions b(ZZ. ) for Rez < 0 by the formulas 1(x,
b(=z.0
(x, ) =
j=0, 1, 2, ...,
fA
27r
r
(11.10)
where the branch AZ is defined as in §10.
In particular, for j = 0, we obtain by the Cauchy formula that bTZ=.°(x,
) =27rt
)-A)-'dA
I AZ(a,(x,
r
= a, ,(x, ).
(11.11)
Let us note that for a sufficiently small Q the integral (11.10) is independent of the
choice of g (in the disc I A I< 2 Q there are no singularities of the functions (x, r;) is positively homogeneous in of b _ m _i (x, , A)). The function degree mz - j, i.e.
t>0,
r;$ 0.
(11.12)
To prove this, it is necessary to perform a change of variables in the integral (11.10) and use the homogeneity of bom-i (x, 4, A): 2n
r = 2 f (tmp)zb-M-i(x, tm1) . tmdp r'
=
tmz-i
-t
mz-I
i
_
2n 1µ t
2n r
mz-j (z).0 fµzb-m-i(x,,p)dp=t 0 bmz-i(x,
Here F` is the contour t-"F (it has the same shape as F but the radius of the curved part is t-mQ instead of Q). (x, ) to all z E C. This is Now it is necessary to extend the definition of done in the same way as the construction of AZ for Z E C in §10. The following analogue of Proposition 10.1 holds.
Proposition 11.1. a) For Re z < 0 and Re w < 0 we have the semigroup property
97
§ 11. The Structure of the Complex Powers as 1a1 +p+q = j
o b(2). '° (x ) xD41 b"1- o, (x )/I = b(2 { n,z-P mw-q ,n(2+w)-j (x,
j=0,1,2,... j (x, l; ), j = 0, 1, 2, ... , is the set of b) If k e Z and k > 0, then the set b! homogeneous components of the parametrix of Ak. c) For any multi-indices a, fi the derivative 64 '00 b'21-_°j (x, c) is a holomorphic
function of z for Re z < 0 and t + 0.
Proof. This is achieved by repeating on the symbol level the proof of Proposition 10.1; recommended to the reader as a useful exercise.
L
In what follows it is convenient to denote by a;k) (x, ), k > 0 and integer, the homogeneous components (of degree j) of the symbol a(') (x, S) of the operator Ak, so that a(k)(x,
S) _ Mk > aak)(x, j=° FF
xx
If k is an integer and k < 0, then by a,") (x, ) we denote the homogeneous components of the symbol of the parametrix to the operator Ak, or, what is the
same thing, the homogeneous components of the symbol of A-;. They are defined recursively by the relations a! ,'A(x, a(-nik (x, S) ' a4akA -j (x,
S) +
a a(mA(x,)
+
(11.14)
akA(x,
Dsa'"kA-4
(x, )la! = 0,
j = ], 2. ...
(11.15)
P+q+ 1411 =j q<j
Definition 11.1. Let z e C and k e Z be so chosen that Re z < k. Put b,(z=,o
(x,) _
a4a(kA-P(x,i)
Dxbrnz(:!c)k)-9(x,)/«!,
P+4+1411 -j
j=0, 1,...
(11.16)
Theorem 11.1. a) The function b _ , j (x, ) as defined via formula (11. 16) is independent of the choice of the integer k as long as Re z < k. b) If Re z < 0, then the functions b.a. ° (x, ) obtained by formula (11.16) coincide with the functions, denoted by the same symbol, obtained via the contour integral (11.10). c) The group property (11.13) holds for any z, w e C. d) If k e Z, then b (kA'-jo (x,
a(.k) o -j
(x,
)
e) For any multi-indices a, fi, any x, l; ( * 0) and any j = 0, 04"6$ x Ma-j(x, ) is an entire function in z.
1,
... ,
Chapter If. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
98
Proof. Statements a)-d) are proved in exactly the same way as the corresponding statements in Theorem 10.1 (it is only necessary to pass from the
operator algebra to the symbol algebra consisting of formal series of homogeneous functions and with multiplication given by the composition formula for symbols). The proof of e) is obtained immediately by looking at the formulae defining the functions b.(=Z, ° (x, 0. 11.3 Smoothed resolvent symbols. Let w (t) E C °° (R'), so that co (t) = 0 for
t- 1. Put (11.17)
IZIZ'm)
and let us define (11.18)
With the help of the function b_m -j (x, , A) we construct on the manifold M
a parametrix of the operator with parameter A - Al in a way similar to the second part of the proof of Theorem 5.1. Now let M = U Xr be a finite covering r
of M by charts, qv a subordinated partition of unity and the functions wr e Co (Xr) be such that wr =_ I in a neighbourhood of supp Apr. Further let 01, Tr be the multiplication operators by q and wr and By m-j(Z) a pseudo-
differential operator on Xr with the symbol by m_ j(x, , Z) constructed by formula (11.18) in the coordinate neighbourhood Xr. Now put B-m_j(Z) _ Y_ V'Bym-j(A) V7
(11.19)
r
and
N-1
B(N)(A) _ Y
B-m-j(Z).
(11.20)
j=o
Proposition 11.2.
(A-J.I)-' - B(N)(Z)ECL;m-N(M,A).
(11.21)
Proof. First we construct an exact parametrix B (Z) of the operator A - Al, putting 00
B(2) - Y B-.-j(Z)
(11.22)
j=o
The precise meaning of this formula is: construct in each Xr an asymptotic sum
Y
j=o
(11.23)
then take the operator By (Z) in Xr with the symbol by (x, , Z) and finally put
§ 11. The Structure of the Complex Powers
B(,) = EOYBYVIY,
99
(11.24)
Y
where 0Y, TI are as in formula (11.19). Then we obviously have
B(A)-B(N)(A)ECL;"'_N(M,A).
(11.25)
But from Theorem 9.2 it follows that
(A-..n-' - B(2)EL-°°(M,A).
(11.26)
Equating (11.25) and (11.26) we arrive at (11.21). C 11.4 Smoothed symbols of complex powers and the structure theorem. Let w (r) be the same function on IR' as at the beginning of 11.3. Put 6(e) =
(11.27)
and define
b"': _
0 (x,
(x,
(11.28)
The construction of (x, and bMz _ j (x, ) can be carried out in any coordinate neighbourhood XY (the corresponding functions will be denoted by
b? Y (x, ) and
Y
j (x, ) if we need to know exactly which coordinate
",-
neighbourhood). Denoting by B( .Z=_7. the operator in XY with symbol b(')-Y (x, ),
we once again put
Bz) - j _ Y 45 7 B(,nzz). Yj T Y
(11.29)
V
and
-
N-1
B(Nlz)) -
Bmz(z)
j=o
(11.30)
-
For the statement of the basic structure theorem, we shall also need the definition of holomorphic families of `PDO, which constitute the set d (G, LQ a (M)), where G is a domain in the complex plane C.
Definition 11.2. Let X be an open set in IR", G a domain in C, a(x, S, z) E C°° (X x IR" x G) where a (x, , z) is holomorphic in z. We shall write a (x, , z) E d (G. SQ a (X)) if for any multi-indices a, fi any k e Z + and any compacts K1 c X, K2 c G there exists a constant C = C (a, fl, k, K, , K2) such that l
IPl,
for (x, , z) E K, x IR" x K2. If A (z) is a `PDO in X, depending on the parameter z, then we shall write that A (z) E d (G, LQ,,, (X)) if A (z) = A, (z) + R (z), where A, (z) is a properly supported TDO on X with symbol a (x, , z) e 0 (G, SQ d (X))
100
Chapter 11. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
and R (z) has kernel R (x, y, z) e C°° (X x X x G), holomorphic in z. Finally, we shall write that A (z) e d (G, L. a (M)), if A (z) is a PDO on M, depending on the
parameter z c- G such that for any coordinate neighbourhood Xc M and any local coordinates x: X + X, , X, an open set in IR", the family of operators AK(z) on X, induced by the operators A (z) on M via the diffeomorphism x is such that A"(z) e 0 (G, LQ a (Xi ))
Repeating the arguments of §4 we see that to verify that A (z) e 4 (G. L, a(M)) for 1 - g:5- 6 < p it suffices to do so for a fixed coordinate covering of M and fixed coordinate diffeomorphisms. Also, repeating the argument in §3 and §5, we see that composition, taking the adjoint and forming the parametrix of a hypoelliptic operator (we assume that the condition for hypoellipticity is fulfilled uniformly in z) does not take us outside the holomorphic families, specified in Definition 11.2. We shall now formulate the basic structure theorem.
Theorem 11.2. For any z E 4 A= E CL" (M),
(11.32)
moreover for any integer N;-> 0 and t E lR
A= - B((N) e0 (Rez < 1, L1"0'(M)) .
(11.33)
Proof. 1. First let us show that (11.32) follows from (11.33). For fixed z e 4 set
(11.34) i=o
(this formula can be decoded in the same way as (11.22)). Then it is obvious that we may assume B(=) e CL"'=(M).
(11.35)
Now, fixing in (11.33) t e IR such that t > Rez and then letting N tend to + oo, we
obtain
A=- B{=)eL-'(M),
(11.36)
from which (11.32) follows. 2. Let us prove (11.33). Set RN' = A= - BAN), .
(11.37)
§ 11. The Structure of the Complex Powers
101
First of all note, that the group property of the complex powers A= and its, for the time being hypothetical, symbols b.==_0 (Theorem 10.1 and 11.1) together
with the fact that the composition of holomorphic families yields again a holomorphic family allow us to reduce the proof to the case t = 0 (N may be arbitrary). In other words, it suffices to verify that
R((N)e0(Rez<0,Li
(11.38)
o(M)).
In order to make use of Proposition 11.2 it is convenient to consider for Re z < 0 and together with the operator Ba)), the operator (11.39)
SA B)N)(A)d? .
2n r
'B((") =
It is easily verified that 'Bj(N)) -
B(()))e0(Rez<0,L-x(M)).
(11.40)
Indeed, we obviously have N-1
'Bl INz) )
= Y- ,B(z) mz-;+ i=0
where 2n
JA
(11.42)
(x, ) of the operator 'Bm(z=_; is expressed in and this is why the symbol some local coordinate system by the formula 'bmz:-;(x, 4) = 2n
(11.43)
r
From this it obviously follows that b;.z. -;
(x, ) =
=1(x, )
for
1
I>1
(11.44)
But then the same holds for the symbols j(x, ) of the operators B(z)-,, the sum of which gives the operator B((N) (cf. the formulas (11.28)-(11.30)). Taking the obvious estimates for the derivatives with respect to z into account, (11.40) is
obtained at once. Now, in view of (11.40), it is clear that it suffices to verify a memberthe symbol ship of the type (11.38) for 'R((N) = Az -'B(N). Denote by of 'R(()1 in some local coordinate system and by r(N)(x, , )) the symbol of R1N)(A)=(A-AI)-1_B(N#). Then
Chapter II. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
102
(11.45)
JA
and we have
2n r
J A (in A)' 01,V rN)(x,
(11.46)
But in view of Proposition 11.2, we have the estimate Ia
s
xeK,
(11.47)
where K is some compact set in the coordinate neighbourhood under consideration. From this it follows that
xeK,
I64aBr(N)(x, ,A)I <
(11.48)
and via (11.46) we get (11.38) for
Exercise 11.1. Extend Theorem 11.2 to the situation described in Exercise 10.1.
§ 12. Analytic Continuation of the Kernels of Complex Powers 12.1 Statement of the problem. Expressing the kernel in terms of the symbol. Let M be a closed manifold, A an elliptic operator on M, satisfying (10.1) and (10.2), which makes it possible to construct the complex powers. For Re z < - n/m we denote by A, (x, y) dy the kernel of A2 (this then depends on the parameter x e M and is a density on M and may, in local coordinates defined for y E Y, be expressed as A. (x, y) dy, where dy is the Lebesgue measure defined by
the local coordinates and A. (x, y) is a continuous function on M x Y). By a abuse of language, this function A, (x, y), which depends on z and on the local coordinates in a neighbourhood of y, is called the kernel. Our immediate goal is to construct an analytic continuation (in z) of the kernel A. (x, y) to the entire complex z-plane C. Note, that if X, Y are open subsets of M, then A. (x, y) is uniquely defined for x e X, y e Y by the values (A=u, v) for u e Co (X) and v c- Co (Y).
Now let X be a coordinate neighbourhood (not necessarily connected), which we identify with an open subset of IR". If we write the `NDO B E Lm (X) in the form
Bu(x)=
-Y4
u(y)dydt,
§ 12. Analytic Continuation of the Kernels
103
where b e Sr(X x R), then for I < - n the kernel A (x, y) is continuous and is of the form
A(x,y)= The restriction of the `FDO A= to X (cf. 4.3) can be represented in the form
A' = A,,,+ R,,,, where A,,, is a properly supported `I'DO and R,,, is an operator with kernel R, (x, y, z) e C °° (X x X x (), holomorphic in z and equal to zero for x and y close to each other. Denoting by a (x, , z) the symbol of A,,, we
will also by abuse of language, call this symbol the symbol of A'. The kernel A,(x, y), for x, y e X close to each other, may be represented in the form
.4,(x,),)-
(171)
The kernel A, (x, y), for Rez < - n/m, is continuous and holomorphic in z. For x = y we obtain A, (x, x) = I a (x, , z) d; .
(12.2)
Note that the result of the integration in (12.2) (and in (12.1) for x and y close to
each other) does not depend on the choice of the "symbol" a (x, , z). 12.2 Statement of the result. In the statement of the result we will make use °,(x, ) of the symbol of A', which were of the homogeneous components
constructed in §11. Note here that for Rez < j/m, these homogeneous components are given by the formulas b
;'-°t(x, )=2n
A 1*
where bo_",_;(x, , A) are the homogeneous components of the symbol of the parametrix for the operator A - Al, also constructed in §11.
Earlier (12.3) was applied only for Rez < 0, but the integral in (12.3) converges for Rez <J/m, hence both parts of (12.3) are holomorphic in z for Re z < J/m demonstrating their equality for these Z. We shall also need the functions
jr'bo-(x,i,-r)dr,
j=0, 1, 2. ...,
(12.4)
o
defined for - I < Re.- < J/m and positively homogeneous in .; of degree mz - j.
Theorem 12.1. Let X be a fixed arbitrary coordinate neighbourhood on M, A, (x, y) the kernels of the complex powers A' of the elliptic operator A. defined for
Rez < - n/m and for x, y e X. Then y the function A,(x, y) can be extended to an entire function 1) for x of z, equal to O for z = 0, 1, 2, ...;
Chapter II. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
104
2) AZ(x, x) can be extended to a meromorphic function in the whole com-
plex z-plane with at most simple poles, which may be situated only at the points of the arithmetic progression z; = I n, j = 0, 1, ..., and the residue of A, (x, x) at z, is equal to
Y,(x) _ - I
J
(12.5)
m 141=1
where
(2n)'"dd' and
is the surface element of the sphere I fl l = 1;
3) if z , = l is a non-negative integer then 'y1(x) = 0 and the value x, (x) = A, (x, x) of the analytically extended kernel at z =1 is given by the formula
x,(x) _ (-1), 1
(12.6)
J d()- °(x, )dd'.
m 1t1=
Statement 1) is valid uniformly in x E K, , y e K2; K, and K2 being disjoint compact sets in X, i.e. K= (x, y) can be continued to an entire function of z with values in C (K, x K2). Similarly, statements 2) and 3) are uniform in x E K, where K is a compact set, i. e. the map z -+ A= (x, x) viewed as a function of z with values in C (K), can be extended meromorphically to the whole complex z -plane with poles at the points z, f = 0, 1, ... , with residues y, (x)1 K at these poles and values x, (x) I
at 1=0, 1,2,....
Remarks. 1) In formula (12.5) the function O%; ° (x, ) appears, which may, according to the notation in § 11, be written also b'=;l. ° (x,
)=
b':d. o (x,
(12.7)
MzJ-J
since mzj -j = -n. 2) Since z;
,-"
i
m- 2n
J
d1' J k - b°_,,-1(x, , A) d7..
r
ICI=
(12.8)
A similar expression can be written also for x&):
x1(x) _ (-1)
1
J
m 141=1
d
-r)dr,
J
(12.9)
0
where I is a non-negative integer (the subscript -m (1 + 1) - n in (12.9) is In obtained by expressing j in terms of l by J - = l ). n
3) Note the special formula for the residue of the left-most pole z°
n/m:
§ 12. Analytic Continuation of the Kernels
yo(x)= --
105
(12.10)
J
m itt =
In the important special case, when a. (x, ) > 0 for * 0, it follows from this formula that yo (x) + 0. In what follows in this case we transform (12.10) to a form more convenient for applications.
Proof of Theorem 12.1 1. We will make use of the structure theorem 11.2 and the notation used there, viz. B,,,--) and R(N) = Aa - Ba)). Let us denote by RAN) (x, y) the kernel of RAN) and by r((N) (x, ) its symbol in some chart X. Then, if
x, y e X we have
Ri))(x,y)= This integral converges for Re z <
dc.
N- n m
(12.11)
and defines for these z a holomorphic
function of z with values in C(K1 x K2), where K,, K2 are arbitrary compact sets in X. Therefore the statements about holomorphy, poles and residues reduce to the corresponding statements about the kernels of the operators B((N) .
The kernel of B(()), in its turn, is a sum of terms of the form BMl.. (x, y) =
Je'(x-r
(12.12)
therefore in what follows we will study integrals of the form (12.12). 2. Let K, and KZ be disjoint compact sets in X. We will show that
L, (x, y)
is an entire function of z with values in C(K1 x K2). Integrating by parts in (12.12) for x # y, we obtain
Bl')-i(x,y)=I e'(x-Y)'4 IX-yI_2M4
(12.13)
where M is a positive integer. This integral converges already for Re z <
2M+j-n m
and defines a holomorphic function of these z with range in
C (K, x K2), since l x - y I > e > 0 for x e K, , y E K2 . Since M is arbitrary, it is clear that B'";,)_, (x, y) is an entire function of z with values in C (KI x K2). 3. We have for x = y
or
B(z) -i(x,x) = B(ai _; (x, x) = J 0
b,MZ_1(x, )
(12.14)
co (IgI),w(T)eC°`(IR1),w(t)=0 for t5i,w(T)=1 for t where 0( Passing to polar coordinates in the integral (12.14), we obtain
Chapter II. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
106
BM=-i (x, x) =
f cu (r) r"-J+4-1 dr
bmz= 0 (x, ) dd'
.
(12.15)
iSlJ
Obviously, the second factor is an entire function of z with values in C(K) (K any
compact set in X). The first factor may be decomposed into the sum 00
1
5 w(r) rmz-j+ n- 1 dr = I w (r) r'"t-j+ e- 1 dr + I rm:-1+n- 1 dr. 0
0
(12.16)
1
The first integral in (12.16) is an entire function of z and the second one can be computed
f rmz-t+n-1dr= -
where z, =i mn. Therefore
1
mz-j+n
=_
1
1
m z-zz
(12.17)
j (x, x) has one pole with the residue y,(x),
given by the formula (12.5). Let us verify that y, (x) = 0 if z, =1, a non-negative integer. This is clear from
Theorem 11.1, part d) (the functions b° (x, ) are the homogenous components of the symbol of the differential operator A' and therefore vanish for
ml -j < 0 and, in particular, for ml -j = - n). 4. To conclude the proof of 1) and 2) in Theorem 12.1 it remains to show that A, (x, y) = 0 for x + y and 1 e Z + . For this, it suffices to show that if u, v E Co (X) and supp u n supp v = 0, then f A, (x, y) u (y) v (x) dy dx = 0.
(12.18)
This however is equivalent to the fact that = 0, since in view of Theorem 10.1 part e), the functionis an entire function of z. Thus we have shown 1) and 2) of Theorem 12.1 and the absence of poles for z e Z + . In what follows we will in fact give a new independent (although also more intricate) proof, allowing us to compute A, (x, x) for 1 e Z + . The reader who is not interested in this computation may omit the remainder of the proof. without any loss of understanding of the later parts of the book. 5. To investigate the values of A= (x, x) for z e Z + , it is convenient to use
another approximation of A= (x, y) which is obtained if we smooth off the symbols of the parametrix b°_-m _; (x, , A) instead of the symbols M' (x, ) of the complex powers. This was essentially done in 11.3, where we introduced the J, 'BiN) and 'R,N) and their symbols, operators B_m_ j(A), B(N)(A), R(N)(A), defined in any coordinate neighbourhood X, b _ m _; (x, , A), b(N) (x, , A), r(N) (x, , (x, ), 'r(J) (x, f) (cf. formulae (11.17)-(11.48)). As
),
107
§ 12. Analytic Continuation of the Kernels
an approximation of the kernel A. (x, y) we will use here the kernels 'B((H) (x, y) of
the operators
:
N-1
'Bi )) (x, y)
'B! (x, y)
j, expressed by the formula
where 'B',,;= _ j (x, y) is the kernel of the operator 'B(z)
mz-;
,
(X,
(12.19)
=o
Y) _ (eicx -r
'b(:)
111:-J
(x )d
(12.20)
or
b_m_j(x,c,A)dl.
'B(z=-1(x,y) = 2x Jd J'1 el(x-Y
r
(12.21)
Here an important role is played by the choice of contour F, since, generally speaking, the integral (12.21) depends on the radius of the curved part of the A) entering the definition of b _ m _1(x, 4, A) is contour (the cut-off function not holomorphic in A). We shall denote by em, the radius of the curved part of the A) in contour F, Q > 0. In view of the homogeneity of bo_m_ _j A 'I-), it is
clear that there is a constant L > 0 such that the function bo_ m _ j (x, ,
)) is
holomorphic in A for I A I < Lm I ' Im. We take the radius of the curved part of F
equal to Qm, Q > 0 and such that
e < L/(2 11L? + 1).
(12.22)
Then, if I I + I I2/m = 1 /4 and A e T, we have either I A I > Qm (i. e. A belongs to the straight line part of F) or I A I = Qm and Lm Lm
14
(1 _ QZ)mr2> Qm= IAI
l4
(the last inequality is equivalent to (12.22)). In this way, and in view of the fact that 0 A) = 0 for I2 + 1212im S 1 /2, we may always assume that bo_m_;(x, , d) is holomorphic inside the curved parts of T. The kernels 'B.I=z _, (x, y) are defined and holomorphic for Re z < j/m (for these z-values, the integral in (12.21) converges absolutely). Our present aim is to analytically continue these kernels to the entire complex z-plane. Let us show first of all, that for x $ y, the kernel 'B,4== _; (x, y) may be continued to an entire function of z (and furthermore, if K, and K2 are disjoint compact subsets of X, then the kernel 'Bm= _; (x, y) may be continued to an entire function of z with values in C (K, x K2)). Indeed by the standard integrating by parts I
108
Chapter 11. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
B- (x, y) =2n fdd
Ix-y1-2MA
r
(12.23)
where M is a positive integer, and from this expression the holomorphy of j (x, y) for z such that Re z < (j+ 2 M)/m is obvious. 6. We now demonstrate that ' B m z _ j (x, y) = 0 f o r x 4 y and z E Z + . If z e Z + , then A' is a single-valued function and the integrals along the straight line
parts of r in (12.23) cancel. But also the integral along the curved part of r equals 0 by the Cauchy theorem, since dE (b-m-;
[ax
Y_
IaI+IBI- 2M
the function as b°_,, - j (x, , A) is holomorphic in A inside the curved part of r and any derivative Of 0 A) is constant in A for I A I = const.
7. Let us now study the analytic continuation of the integral 'B(z)_j(x,x) =
2n !dt
b°-
;(x, ,.l)d1..
Let r' be the part of r, in I 12 + IA > I and r 2 the part where I < 1 (for I I > I this set is empty). We then clearly have
(12.24)
12/m
f AzObO_m_jdA
r
= f Azb°- m -jdA+ r'
12 + I A
12p
f A"Ob°-._jdA. r=
It is obvious that the integral
fdf
2n
b°-
r
is an entire function of z. This entire function equals 0 for z = 0, 1, 2, ... , since then the integrals along the straight line parts of r2 cancel due to the singlevaluedness of Az, and the integral along the curved part is 0 by Cauchy's theorem is constant for I f I = const and I A I = const and b°_._j (x, 4, A) is holomorphic in A inside the curved part of F'). We may therefore prove all the statements on continuation for the integral
1(z)= f- fd4 Ff It is obvious that
two rays for
1
1<
r' = r for
1 - Q2 .
(12.25)
I
I>
1 - e2
and r'
Let us put F,=F' for
1
1<
consists of 1 - Q2 and
109
§ 12. Analytic Continuation of the Kernels
!'r = I I"(1 _ Q2)-m12 F for I I Z
1 - Q2. Since it follows from (12.22) that
e1 VI - Q2
I/
1 - Q2
and by the Cauchy theorem f Azb°-
f )=bo-
1(x,.,A)dl.
(12.26)
Let us now make a change of coordinates, putting
)1= et l t' on the straight line parts of F,;
A = a' 1 I'a", where a =
, - it 9;5 it on the curved part of f,' .
Q 1
- Qz
The purpose of this change is to derive from (12.25) an integral of a t) and to proceed as in part 3. of this proof. After
homogeneous function in the change, we obtain
if
Azbo-.-jdA = 11
2n r,-I -I
2n r,1 Alb°-
jdA=12+13
1 - Q2,
ICI <
if
1 -Q2,
ICI Z
where 11 = m sin nz n
+0 J
t'":+",-1
b_,"-j(x,
,
-t")dt,
1-141'
t
=
P191
7p2
t Fig. 3
12=m
sinnz It
13=f n
"
-"
+
t"':+,"-1bo 2141
(x, ,-t"')dt,
Chapter II. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
110
Let us remark that the sum
I, d +
f
f
12 d
(12.27)
is an integral of a function in t), homogenous of order mz + m - I - m - j in the domain consisting of the intersection of a conic domain and the complement of a ball (Fig. 3). Introducing spherical coordinates in the space t), we see that the integral
(12.27) converges absolutely for Re(mz-j-1) < -n - I and that, in view of (12.17), it can be written in the form
msinnz n(mz I-I-n)
f
iei +t t-
t" 1 bo_j(x,
(12.28)
t>Q
where
t)' is the surface element on the unit sphere S" in the
t)-space. Since
p > 0 and t > p, the integral (12.28) is well-defined as an entire function of z. Further this whole expression can have only one pole for z = z, =1
Mn
; if zj * 0,
1, 2, ... , it vanishes for all z e Z + ; if z j = l E Z + it vanishes for all integer z $l and there is no longer a pole at z = 1. Here one can, of course, write down the value of (12.28) for z = z j =1 E Z + , but it will be more convenient to do this later for the whole integral (12.25).
Let us consider the remaining term
Here it is convenient to go over to spherical coordinates in the c-space. We then obtain R
V1 -a
mz-j+n
eiv(:+n f
(12.29)
141-1
where C= const. From this the fact that the integral is meromorphic is obvious and the only possible pole is at z = zj. If z =1 e Z + we have
f _R
/
f IWI-I
since the function b°-_ _ j (x, , A) is holomorphic in A for JAI < a'. From this it is also clear that for z = I E Z + the integral (12.29) vanishes, except maybe at z = zj
(if zjeZ), where in this case there is no pole.
8. In this way we have demonstrated that the integral (12.24)
is
meromorphically extendable to the whole complex plane, having no more than
§12. Analytic Continuation of the Kernels
11 I
n
one simple pole, which is only possible for z = zj = - . Further, the value of m
this integral for z =I e Z + is zero, with the possible exception of the point z =1= zj, but then we have no pole at z,. Let us consider now just this case, z =1= z j E Z + , and compute the value of the analytic continuation (12.24) at
z=I=zj.
Note that the integral with respect to
in (12.24) is convergent for z = zj,
since zj = J - n < j/m. Decompose the c-integral into a sum of the integrals over
m the ball I < I and over its complement I I > 1. Standard arguments, already used before, show that the integral over the ball I <1 is 0 for z = zj. For I I ? I we have 0 A) = 1 and instead of (12.24) it is enough to consider the integral
I =2n1iflel J d rz
(x,, ) d.I .
(12.30)
Changing to spherical coordinates in the -space, we obtain
I
mz
'
+n
b°-m-, (x ,
r R,-, 2n JA
) ) dAd ' .
, .
(12 . 31)
Using the Cauchy theorem for Re z > -1 we may contract the curved part of I' to 0. Then we obtain for (12.31)
sinnz
n(mz-j+n)
Srzbo_(x, I4I=1
o
The value of this expression for z = z j =1 e Z + equals exactly x, (x), where x, (x)
is given by the formula (12.6) or (12.9). Therefore 'B'';, (x, x) = x, (x).
9. Let us now note that the difference 'R( 'N') (x, y) = A. (x, y)
=- Ids 2
'BiN'i (x, y)
fAze'(X-r)
(12.32)
1r
can be extended to a holomorphic function of z for Re z <
N -n m
with values in
C(K x K), where K is any compact set in X. From this one can see that in the half-
plane Re z <
N- n the functions Az (x, y) and 'BAN) (x, y) have the same poles m
with identical residues. Further, if z = l e Z + and x * y, then A, (x, y) _ 'BAN) (x, y) = 0 (cf. parts 4 and 6 of this proof). It is therefore clear, that by
Chapter 11. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
112
continuity A, (x, y) = 'BAN, (x, y) for all x, y (if I< Nm n). In particular, A, (x, x) = 'B()1 (x, x), which together with the result of part 8. completes the proof of Theorem 12.1. O
§ 13. The c-function of an Elliptic Operator and Formal Asymptotic Behaviour of the Spectrum 13.1 Definition and the continuation theorem. Let A be an elliptic operator
on a closed manifold M, satisfying the same conditions as in the foregoing section. Let A2 (x, y) dy be the kernel of A2. For x = y we obtain from this kernel the density A2 (x, x) dx which is well-defined on the whole manifold M and which
can be integrated over M. Definition 13.1. The function
CA(z)_ JA.(x,x)dx
(13.1)
N
is called the S function of the elliptic operator A. In the next section we show that (A (z) can be expressed via the eigenvalues of
A allowing us in the self-adjoint case to obtain the simplest theorem on the asymptotic behaviour of the eigenvalues. For now, we shall be content with the
formal Definition 13.1 and will formulate a theorem on the analytic continuation of the t-function. Theorem 13.1. The function CA(z) defined by the formula (13.1) for Re z < - n/m can be continued to a meromorphic function in the entire complex z -plane with at most simple poles, which can be situated only in the points of
the arithmetic progression z, = j
n j = 0, ], 2,
m
.., except for the points
z; = I = 0, 1, 2, ... , and where the residue y; at zj and the value x, = C (I), in the notations of Theorem 12.1, are given by the formulae y, = J y; (x) dx = -
1 J dx f m At
At
ia
i
f tam Alfdx 1t1=1
b"A o (x, t) d '
141=t
r
(13.2)
1 Jdx j xr= Jx,(x)dr=(-I)' mM It1=1 w _ (-1)' 1 Jdx f m Al
Kl=1
(13.3) 0
§ 13. The C-Function and Formal Asymptotic Behaviour
113
Proof. Follows from Theorem 12.1 by integrating (12.5) and (12.6) with respect to x, taking into account the remarks following Theorem 12.1. i 13.2 The spectral meaning of the C-function. In this section we shall assume that on M there is given a smooth positive density, which by abuse of notation is denoted dx. Then the kernel of an operator may be identified with an ordinary function on M x M. In addition, the self-adjointness of an elliptic operator on M is a meaningful concept. Theorem 13.2. Let A be a self-adjoint positive elliptic differential operator on
M and let 2j (j =1, 2,...) be its eigenvalues. Then C,, (z) _
Rez < - n/m ,
Aj ,
(13.4)
1=1
where the right-hand side converges absolutely for the indicated z-values. This convergence is uniform in z in the half-plane Re z < - nlm - e for arbitrary e > 0.
Proof. Let Rez < - n/m and let A, (x, y) be the kernel of AZ, which is a continuous function on M x M. Let { gp1(x)},'. , be complete orthonormal system
of eigenfunctions for A. Decomposing AZ (x, y) into a Fourier series in the we obtain complete orthonormal system of functions (co A. (x, y) _
J=1
2 j (pi (x) (pi (Y) .
(13.5)
where the series converges in L2 (M x M). If z is real, then by the Mercer theorem
(cf. Riesz and Sz.-Nagy [1), §98) the series (13.5) converges absolutely and uniformly. Putting x = y in (13.5) and integrating over x, we obtain the identity (13.4). In the case of a non-real z it is only necessary to note that I A z I = 2i °Z, from
which it follows that the series in (13.4) and (13.5) converge absolutely and uniformly. The last statement of the theorem follows from the fact that if so E
IR, so < -n/m, then the series (13.5) for Rez < so is majorized in absolute value by the sums of the series Co
2 Y A°I(P;(x)12+ j=1
1
'O
j
-1'lj°Iq';(Y)I2,
which are themselves absolutely and uniformly converging series with positive
terms. O Remark 1. One may also prove Theorem 13.2 without using the Mercer
theorem, noting that for Rez < -n/(2m) the operator AZ has a kernel AZ (x, y) a L2 (M x M) (i. e. A' is a Hilbert-Schmidt operator) and in view of the Parceval identity we have 00
Y Ajs= f= 1
A,(x,Y)12dxdy, MxM
s< -n/(2m).
(13.6)
Chapter 11. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
114
From the group property it follows that for s < - n A, (x, y) = f A,, (x, z) A512 (z, Y) dz, or
A, (x, y) = f Aij2 (x, z) A:12 (Y, z) dz
using the fact that the kernel A512 (x, y) is hermitean. Putting now x = y and integrating in x we obtain from (13.6) that (13.4) holds for real z < -n/m. The transition to complex z is accomplished in the same way as above or by using analytic continuation. Let us remark however that from this proof it is hard to get exact information on the decomposition (13.5) (in particular about the uniform convergence of the series there).
Remark 2. The equality (13.4) is valid also without the assumption on selfadjointness of A. The proof is easily obtained from the theorem of V. B. Lidskii
(cf. Gohberg I.C. and Krein M.G. [I ], Theorem 8.4). However, in the nonselfadjoint case it is not possible to extract any kind of interesting information about the eigenvalues from (13.4). The only exception is the case of a normal operator, where in fact the results may be deduced from the corresponding results in the self-adjoint case. 13.3 Formal asymptotic behaviour of the function NQ) in the self-adjoint case. The function V(I). Let A be as in Theorem 13.2. Set
N(t) = Y 1
(13.7)
I's, for arbitrary t EIR, i.e. N(t) is the number of eigenvalues of A not exceeding t (counting multiplicity). It is clear that N(t) is a non-decreasing function of t which equals 0 for t < A1. We assume here for convenience that the eigenvalues have been arranged in increasing order:
0<,11 ;9 .125.135...
(13.8)
We then have an obvious formula, expressing S,1 (z) in terms of N(t) in the form of a Stieltjes integral: a-,
CA(z) = f t'dN(t).
(13.9)
0
Assume now that N(t) admits the following asymptotic expansion as
N(t)=c1t +C2t
(13.10)
§ 13. The -Function and Formal Asymptotic Behaviour
where Re a, > Re a 2 > ... > Reak > Re ak + 1
then
x
k
CA (Z) _
,
115
t=d(t'') +l (z),
c1
1=1
1
where f (z) is holomorphic for Re z < - Reak + I. Since W
J t=d(t-,) = f a, t=+- 1 dt = -
a,
z+a,
,
it follows that (13.11) may be rewritten as (13.12)
Hence for Re z < - Re ak+ 1 the function CA (z) has simple poles at - a, with
residues -c,a1, 1=1, ... , k. Therefore knowing the poles of CA(s) and the residues at these poles allows us to write down a formal asymptotic expansion
for N(t). In reality however, only the computation of the first term of the asymptotic expansion works out well. This term, dictated by comparison of rr0
(13.10) and (13.12), must have the form - t5' if CA (s) has its left-most pole at - so < 0 with residue ro . SO The formula r-0
N(t)
r-
(13.13)
SO
will be rigorously proved in the following section using the Tauberian theorem of Ikehara, while for the present we shall occupy ourselves with the specification of its coefficients. By Theorem 13.1 we have s0 = n/m and
r0 = -
1
M
j
I dx M
a,- "* (x, ) d '
(13.14)
141=1
Since in the situation under consideration a. (x, ) > 0 for + 0, then r0 + 0, so that the pole at -n/m really exists. Formula (13.13) may now be written
N(t) ^'
1
J a(x,)dc' t(13.15)
j dx nkr Ic1=1
Now rewrite the right-hand side of (13.15) in a more natural form. For this, introduce the function
116
Chapter If. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
V(t) = (2n)-"
(13.16)
J a.(x.f)<e
Note that this function has an invariant meaning: it is the volume in T*M of all points (x,4) such that a. (x, ) < t, multiplied by (2n)-". Here the volume is given in T*M by the measure, induced by the canonical symplectic structure (cf. Arnol'd [11). Lemma 13.1. We have the following formula
V(t)= 1 Jdx f nM
(13.17)
itl=i
and may, therefore, instead of (13.15) write
N(t) - V(t).
(13.18)
Proof. Let us remark to begin with, that the condition a", (x, ) < t, in view of the homogeneity of is equivalent to a", (x, t< 1. Thus, changing variables in (13.16), q = t-'1' , we obtain
V(t)
dxdrl
t"/1".
The later arguments will take place for a fixed value of x, and we shall write a",
instead of a. (x, 5).
Fig. 4
We have to show that J
d = 1 J a,
d'
.
(13.19)
§ 13. The {' -Function and Formal Asymptotic Behaviour
Let 14'1= land d
=sup { t : am (t ') < 1 } (Fig. 4), so that d
117
is the
i>0
distance of 0 from the surface am =I in the direction '. Let us consider the infinitesimal cone with vertex in 0 and height d(4') - ', cutting out the area dc'. on the surface =1. The volume of this cone equals j (d Therefore dd
But am
am (
am(t:); hence if
I
I
'
I
I
j
=1
".ct>
J = I f I m am I 1
then
(13.20)
n u'+-I I
1
),
in view of the homogeneity of
a.( ' )=Iw-, from which d(')= l
I
i
Substituting this expression for
in (13.20) we obtain
(13.19).
13.4 Asymptotic behaviour of the eigenvalues. We shall now state an asymptotic formula for Ak ask -' + oo, equivalent to the asymptotic formula for N(t) ((13.13), (13.15) or (13.18)), and infer from this that, essentially, N(t) as a function of t, and .k as a function of k, are mutually inverse functions. Denote by V, the coefficient of the term t"'' in (13.17), so that V, = V(1). Then the desired formula is of the form Ak- V,- m'"
k"'"
as
k-*+oo.
(13.21)
Proposition 13.1. The asymptotic formulae (13.21) and (13.18) are equivalent (i.e. each implies the other).
Proof. 1. Suppose (13.18) holds, i.e. for any c > 0 there exists to > 0 such that
1-c
(13.22)
for t > to. Choose an integer ko > 0, such that ) ku > to and Ak,+ I > 2k, Then show that
-c
(13.23)
fork z ko. Indeed, for any k ko there exist integers k, and k2 such that ko <= k, < k < k2 and 2k, < Ak,+I ='lk, < Ak,+, . In particular, we have N(2k) = k, and N(Ak) = k2, so that from (13.22) it follows that (13.24)
1-e:5 k2V,'.lk="'"S1+E.
(13.25)
118
Chapter H. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
Further, N (t) = k, for Ak S t < Ak, so that for these t 1
E:5 k, V,-'t
5I+s
and by continuity
1eSk,Vj-'A-Rlm51+e.
(13.26)
It follows from (13.25) and (13.26) that
1- e 5 kV,-' 2;"/m 5 I + e, and it remains to note that Ak = follows that (1
Ak,.
(13.27)
Hence (13.23) is proven. But from this it
+e)-m/" V1-ml"kmI" 5 A.k S (1
-e)-m/" Vim/"k"m/",
(13.28)
and this implies (13.21).
2. Now let (13.21) hold. Choose e > 0 and let ko be an integer such that for any integer k > ko, the inequality (13.28) holds. Let Ak 5 t < Ak,, where k, and
k2 are the same as in part 1. of this proof. It follows from (13.28) that, in particular,
1-eSk,V1'1k"/"'5I+e,
(13.29)
1-e5(k,+1)Vj- 'Ak"/m51+e,
(13.30)
Ak, . Choose now a number ko so large that V,-' .1k "Im 5 e for k>ko. We then obtain from (13.30) that since 2k,
I-
(13.31)
But N(t) = k, and therefore from (13.29) and (13.31) we get
1 -2e5N(t) V '.lk
1 +2e,
1 - 2e 5 N(t) V1 '.1k,"/m < 1 + 2e,
from which it follows that
I -2c5N(t) V;'t-"/'"51+2e, in view of the fact that '1k < t < Akj, as required.
§ 13. The c-Function and Formal Asymptotic Behaviour
119
13.5 Problems
Problem 13.1. Find the poles, residues and values at the non-negative z
integer points of the C-function of the operator A = - dz2 on the circle IR/2 x Z. Express the classical Riemann C-function C (z) =
(13.32)
in terms of S,, (z) and find all the poles, residues and values of C (z) at z = 0, - 2,
-4,....
Problem 13.2. Consider the Schrodinger operator A = - A + q (x) on the torus 12= R2/2n V. Here q (x) e C' (12). Express C., (0) in terms of q(x). Problem 13.3. Let A be an elliptic differential operator, mapping Cm (M, E) into C°° (M, fl, where E and F are smooth vector bundles on M. Let there be given a smooth density on M and hermitean structures on E and F (a hermitean metric on each fiber). Show that index A = Cl+AA (z)
(13.33)
where the right-hand side does not depend on z. (This formula allows us, in principle to write down the index A in terms of the symbol of A, using Theorem 13.1 which gives the possibility of computing (e(0)
for B= I+A*A or B= I + AA*.) Hint: All non-zero eigenvalues of AA* and A*A have the same multiplicities, since A maps an eigensubspace of A *A into an eigensubspace of AA* and A* acts in the opposite direction.
Problem 13.4. Show that the kernel K(t, x, y) of the operator eAt from Problem 10.1 is infinitely differentiable in t, x and y for t > 0 and for all x e M, y e M. As t -+ + 0, we have the following asymptotic properties of K(t, x, y):
a) If x + y, then K (t, x, y) = 0 (t") for any N > 0. b) K(t, x, x) has the following asymptotic expansion as t-. +0: K(t, x, x)
E aj (x) t
j=o
(13.34)
where a j (x) e C °° (M). Express aj (x) in terms of yj (x) and x, (x) (cf. Theorem 12.1) and write down an expression for aj (x) in terms of the symbol of A.
120
Chapter 11. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
Verify that if A* = A, then
K(t,x,y)_
e- 1,1(p;(x),pt(y)
(13.35)
0(t)= Y, e-''= JK(t,x,x)dx
(13.36)
and the 6-function
j=o
u
J=O
has the asymptotic expansion 0 (t) - 2 aJ t M
.
(13.37)
i=o
Express index A in terms of the 0-functions of the operators A*A and AA*.
Problem 13.5. Let E be a hermitean vector bundle on a closed manifold M with smooth positive density and let A be an elliptic self-adjoint differential operator mapping C a (M, E) into C °° (M, E) (not necessarily semibounded). Consider the function U
_
(sign A)
t,.Iz,
(13.38)
where the sum runs over all the eigenvalues of A. Show that the series (13.38) converges absolutely for Re z < - n/m and the function defined by it, >,4 (z), may be continued to the whole complex z-plane as a meromorphic function with simple poles at z, = J - n , j = 0, 1, 2, .... Express the residues at these poles via m the symbol of A. Hint. Express 17A(z) in terms of (; (z) and C" (z) where C. (z) and C;; (z) are two C-functions of A, obtained by different choices of the branch for Az with cuts along the upper and lower semi axes of the imaginary axis.
§ 14. The Tauberian Theorem of Ikehara 14.1 Formulation. The Tauberian theorem of Ikehara allows us to deduce from the fact that the C-function is meromorphic asymptotic formulae for N (1) as t-. + co or for A,% as k -+ + oo (cf. §13). Let us give its exact formulation. Theorem 14.1. Let N (t) be a non-decreasing junction equal to 0 jor t:5 1 and such that the integral
(z) = J tzdN(t)
(14.1)
§ 14. The Tauberian Theorem of Ikehara
121
converges for Re z < -ko, where ko > 0 and the function
(z)+z+A
k0
can be extended by continuity to the closed half-plane Re z < -ko. We will assume that A 0 0. Then, as t -+ +oo we have
N(t) - k t*-
(14.2)
0
(recall that f, (t) - f2 (t) as t - + oo means that lim f, (t)/f2 (t) =1). ,.+,0 (The convergence of the integral in (14.1) for Re z < - k0 easily follows from a weaker condition. Namely, it suffices to suppose that the integral converges for
Re z < - k, for some k, and the function C (z) thus expressed can be holomorphically continued to the half-plane Re z < -ko). Corollary 14.1. Suppose that the function C (z), defined for Re z < - ko by (14.1), can be meromorphically continued into the larger half-plane Re z < - ko + e, where e > 0, so that on the line Re z = - ko there is a single and moreover simple pole at - ko with residue - A. Then the asymptotic formula (14.2) holds. 14.2 Beginning of the proof of Theorem 14.1: The reductions.
1st reduction. It is convenient to consider instead of C (z) the function f (z) = C (- z). We then obtain
f(z) = J t-=dN(t),
(14.3)
where the integral converges for Re z > ko and the function f (z) continuous for Re z ? ko.
- z -Ako
is
2nd reduction: Reduction to the case ko = 1. By introducing the function f, (z) = f (ko z), we obtain
f,(z)= Jt-k":dN(t)= TdN,(T), where N , (T) = N (T' /k"). Since
.f(koz)-k
A
0z
=f(z)-kA z-1 0 1
-k0
1
and since N(t) , A tr- is equivalent to N, (T) - A T, then Theorem 14.1 reduces TO
to the following statement:
ko
122
Chapter 11, Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
Let N(t) be a non-decreasing function and let the integral 00
f(z) = $ t-zdN(t) be convergent for Re z > 1, where f(z)
N(t) - At
A
(14.4)
is continuous for Re z 2! 1. Then
-z-1
t-'+oo.
as
Note that from the continuity of f(z) -
z
A
1
(14.5)
for Re z z 1 and the fact that
f(z) z 0 for real z;-> 1, it follows that A > 0. Changing N(i) for A - 1 N(t), which results in changing f (z) for A -1 f (z), we see that it suffices to show the statement for A = 1.
3rd reduction. Let us pass from the Melin transformation to the Laplace transformation, i. e. make a change of variables t = ex. Put N (ex) = 9 (x). We then see that rp (x) is a non-decreasing function, equal to zero for x < 0 and that the integral
f(z) = ! e-zxd(p(x)
(14.6)
0
converges for Re z > 1 and f (z) z-1 show that
is continuous for Re z z 1. We must
lim e-xgp(x)=1.
(14.7)
x.+w
4th reduction. Denote H(x) = e-x(p(x). The So(x) is non-decreasing if and only if H(y)zH(x)ex-y
y> x.
for
(14.8)
Integrating by parts in (14.6) gives, for Re z > I
f(z) = zfe-'x(p(x)dx =
ze-(z-1)x H(x)dx 0
0
Now put z =1 + s + it, where z > 0 and t is real. Note that °D
0
therefore, (14.9) implies
e-(z- ,)xdx = 1 z-1
(14.9)
§ 14. The Tauberian Theorem of Ikehara
f(z) _ z
= $e
1
z-
c=
123
.
0
Since
fZZ)- Z
1= 1(f(z)- Z
1
I-
1
then, putting
h,(t)=Z(f(z)- z
1
1
-1)
(14.10) =+e+lf
we obtain 00 h.(t) = J e-`x_"x(H(x)- 1)dx.
(14.11)
0
We may now give the following reformulation of Theorem 14.1.
Theorem 14.1'. Let H(x) be a function, equal to 0 for x < 0 and satisfying (14.8) for all real x and y. Assume that the integral (14.11) converges absolutely for
any e > 0 and the function h, (t) defined by it, is such that the limit lim h, (t) = h (t)
(14.12)
exists and is uniform on any finite segment I t 15 22. Then
lim H(x) = 1.
(14.13)
Remark. If H(x) tends to I sufficiently quickly (if e.g. H(x) -1 EL' ([0, + oo))), then we obtain (14.12) from (14.13) by passing to the limit under the integral sign, which one may do in view of the dominated convergence theorem (the function h (t) then equals the Fourier transform of O (x) (H(x) - 1), 6(x) the Heaviside function). In some sense, the Tauberian condition (14.8) allows one to invert this statement.
143 The basic lemma. It is clear that in order to prove Theorem 14.1' we have to somehow express H(x) - 1 in terms of h (t) which, formally, is possible by the inverse Fourier transformation. However, we know nothing about the behaviour of h (t) as t -. + oo or about the nature of the convergence of h. (t) to h (t) on the whole line and it is therefore necessary, to begin with, to multiply the limit equality (14.12) with a finite cut-off function j (t). These considerations, linked to the convenience of having transformations with positive kernels (of the Fejer type), demonstrate that it is convenient to consider p (t) to be the Fourier transform of a non-negative function g (v) c- L' (R):
Q(t)= Je ""go (v)dv.
(14.14)
Chapter 11. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
124
We shall assume that Q (t) is a continuous function with compact support such that a (0) = 1, p (v) >_ 0 and p (v) a Ll (IR). From this it follows that
f p(v)dv=1.
(14.15)
-OD
The existence of a function B (t) of the type described may be shown in the same way as in 6.3 (at the beginning of the proof of Theorem 6.3 a function fi(t) E Co (IRl) is constructed which satisfies all these requirements). We can also explicitly define Q(t) , putting
1- 121;
(t) =
A
0
f
111>2.
;
Then indeed, for a fixed v * 0 we have
p()v =
I2tll
J e
dt=-
2 ertV
;,
/
d l-
I 2t11
eu°
2
+2rziv
2
e"'
2
e"° sign =-2J2iv - t dt
4nv
2
2
4av
10
2
I2) tII
""v
0
2
1
- 1 -cos2v 2nv 2
I since n
v
2
,
from which all the necessary properties of p (v) are obvious. Lemma 14.1. For any fixed A >/0 lim Y.
\
! H ` y - Al p (v) dv = 1
.
(14.16)
OD -x
Proof. 1. Put e, (t) = B (t/A) and Q, (v) = Ap (A v) so that p, (t) is the Fourier
transform of p, (v). It is clear that + 00
I Hfp(v)dv= $ H(y-v) p,(v)dv,
-x
(14.17)
-ac
a nd since p, (v) possesses the same properties as p (v), it suffices to prove (14.16)
forA=1. 2. Putting F(t) = e(t)ht(t), we compute the inverse Fourier transform of the function F (t) with compact support, taking into account that a (t) and ht (I)
are the Fourier transforms of the absolutely integrable functions p (v) and
0(v) (H(v)-1)e-t 00
+
-m
+ cc
ettYF.(t)dt = J eitvp(t) m
[1wx_ 1)eidx]dt 0
§ 14. The Tauberian Theorem of Ikehara
125
J Q(t) a""y-x'dt dx
(H(x)-1)e-`x
J
(14.18)
-00
o
J (H(x)_ 1) e-`xQ(y-x)dx. 0
As a result, as one might have anticipated, we obtain a convolution and we have made sure that (14.18) holds everywhere and in the usual sense (the change
in the order of integration is permitted by the Fubini's theorem). Let us now rewrite (14.18) in the form
J e"''F(t)dt+ Je-`xQ(y-x)dx = JH(x) e-" Lg(y-x)dx -00
(14.19)
0
0
and take the limit as a- + 0. Since supp F c supp Q and F (t) - F(t) uniformly in t e supp j (here F(t) = Q (t) h (t)), then the first integral on the left-hand
side has a limit as s-s +0 for any y. The same also holds for the second integral (e.g. by the dominated convergence theorem). Therefore, the integral on the right-hand side of (14.19) has for any y a limit as a- +0. Since
H(x)e-"e(y-x) converges monotonely as a-++0 to H(x) e(y-x), we get + ac
00
OD
J e"yF(t)dt+ f Q(y-x)dx= JH(x)Q(y-x)dx. 0
(14.20)
0
Now let y tend to + oo. By the Riemann lemma +m
lim
J e"y F(t) dt = 0.
In addition, it is clear that lim J Q (y - x) dx = 1. Therefore, it follows from .D o (14.20) that lim JH(x) y..+x; 0
Q(y-x)dx= 1.
(14.21)
But ac
+W
+co
JH(x)Q(y-x)dx= J H(x) Q(y-x)dx= J H(y-v) Q(v)dv, - CO
so that (14.21) implies the statement of the lemma.
126
Chapter 11. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
14.4 Proof of Theorem 14.1'. 1. First, we show that lim H (y) <_ 1 y.+m
(14.22)
.
Since
+,o
a
J H y-
Q(v)dv S J H y-
-a
(
-00
J Q(v)dv
for any a > 0, it follows from Lemma 14.1 that
J H(y-V) Q(v)dv 5 1
slim
.
(14.23)
Now, in view of the Tauberian condition (14.8) we have
H(y-v)>H(y-ale 2i
for
ve[-a,a].
Now, it follows from (14.23) that
/
2 _a a
lim H l y- )/ e y.+m
A J Q (v) dv 5 1,
-a
or 2a
lim H (y) < e z
a
(J
1
Q (v) dv)
(14.24)
-a
Inequality (14.24) holds for any a > 0 and A > 0. Let a - + oo and A - + co in this inequality in such a way that a/A--'0. Then we obtain the required estimate (14.22) from (14.24). 2. We will now verify that
lim H(y) z 1.
y.+m
(14.25)
To begin with, note that (14.22) implies the boundedness of H(y):
IH(y)I <M,
yeIR ,
(14.26)
in view of which //
J HI y-- I Q(v)dv < (b), roiab
`
I
(14.27)
§ 14. The Tauberian Theorem of Ikehara
127
where a (b) - 0 as b - + oo (this means, in particular that the integral on the lefthand side of (14.27) approaches 0 as b - + oo, uniformly in y and A). Since
)v 0 (V) dV
+m
-m
H
b
-b
IvI?b
then, by (14.27) and Lemma 14.1 we obtain for arbitrary b > 0 lim j H (Y - v) Q (v) dv >-- 1 - a (b). y.+m IvISb
\
(14.28)
Let us again use condition (14.8). We have
b\
2b
U
ve[-b,b],
from which, in view of (14.28), it follows that
mH Cy+ b/ e'
y li
J Q(v)duz I -a(b),
2b -b b
or zz
lien H(y) z (1-a(b)) e 7++m
b
(J Q (v) du)
(14.29)
b
Now let b -+ + oo and A -+ + oo, so that b/2 - 0. Then from (14.29) we obtain the
desired inequality (14.25). D
Problem 14.1. Let N(t) be a non-decreasing function, equal to 0 for t5 I and let the integral (14.1) be convergent for Re z < - ko, some ko > 0. Assume furthermore, that the function a (z), defined by (14.1), can be meromorphically continued to larger half-space Re z < - ko + e, where e > 0 so that on the line Re z = - ko there is a single pole at - ko with principal part A (z + ko) -' in the Laurent expansion (here I is a positive integer, equal to the order of the pole at
-ko). Show that
N(t) ' (-1)'''A t,o(lnt)r-t
(I-1)!
as
Problem 14.2. Prove the Karamata Tauberian theorem: Let N(t) be a non-decreasing function oft E IR', equal to 0 for t < 1 and such that the integral
128
Chapter II. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
0(z) = f e-s`dN(t)
(14.30)
0
converges for all z > 0 and
0(z) - Az
as
z-.+0
(14.31)
(here A > 0 and a > 0 are constants). Then
N(t)
r( +1)
to
as
t-++oo.
(14.32)
§15. Asymptotic Behaviour of the Spectral Function and the Eigenvalues (Rough Theorem) 15.1 The spectral function and its asymptotic behaviour on the diagonal. Let M be a closed n-dimensional manifold on which there is given a smooth positive
density and let A be a self-adjoint, elliptic operator on M such that (15.1)
Then A is semibounded. Denote by A its eigenvalues, enumerated in increasing order (counting multiplicities):
A,5A2;9A35..., By 47j(x) we denote the corresponding eigenfunctions, which constitute an orthonormal system. Let E, be the spectral projection of A (the orthogonal projection onto the linear hull of all eigenvectors with eigenvalues not exceeding t). It is clear that E,u = Y_ (u, apt) p,
(15.2)
x,St
Definition 15.1. The spectral junction of A is the kernel (in the sense of L. Schwartz) of the operator E, . Taking into account that on M there is a correspondence between functions and densities, we may assume that the spectral function is a function, not a density. From (15.2) it is obvious that this function, e(x, y, t), is given by the formula e (x, y, t) _ > (Pt (x) *P; (y) A's,
(15.3)
§ 15. Asymptotic Behaviour of the Spectral Function and Eigenvalues
129
and, in particular, belongs to C°°(M x M) for every fixed t. Let us note immediately the following properties of e (x, y, t): 1) e (x, x, t) is a non-decreasing function of t for any fixed x c- M; 2) the function N(t) introduced in section 13.3, can be expressed in terms of e (x, x, t) by the formula
N(t)= $e(x,x,t)dx,
(15.4)
where dx is a fixed density on M. Now assume that local coordinates in a neighbourhood of x are so chosen, that the density coincides with the Lebesgue measure in these coordinates and put
I
V. (1) _
d
(15.5)
.
Theorem 15.1. For any x e M the following holds:
e(x,x,1) - V. (t)
as
(15.6)
Proof. 1.To begin with, note that without loss of generality we may assume Al ? 1. Indeed this is satisfied by the operator A I = A + MI for sufficiently large M. Now, if eI (x, y, 1) is the spectral function of AI , we have e (x, y, 1) = e 1(x, y, t + M). Therefore, the asymptotic formulae 1(x, x, t) - Vx (1)
implies e(x, x, t) - Vx(t+M). But Vx(t+M)=Vx(1) (t+M)"lm=Vx(1) t°Im(1+O(t-I))_. Vx(1) t"""'=V.0), which implies (15.6).
2. Thus let A,;-> 1. We may then define complex powers Az of A in accordance with the scheme of §10. Using (13.5), we may for x = y express the kernel Az (x, y) of A= in terms of the spectral function as follows 00
A, (x, x) = J t z de (x, x, t),
(15.7)
0
where d signifies the differentiation with respect to t (for a fixed x this is simply a Stieltjes integral). In view of Theorems 12.1 and 14.1 we obtain now fore (x, x, t)
the asymptotic formula
e(x,,x,t)- I 11,
I 141 =1
a-film (x,
,)A,l J
.
t°/"g.
(15.8)
130
Chapter II. Complex Powers of Elliptic Operators
An elementary transformation of the right-hand side of this formula, carried out in the proof of Lemma 13.1, shows that it equals V,,(t), implying (15.6). 15.2 Asymptotic behaviour of the Eigenvalues Theorem 15.2. Let A satisfy the conditions described at the beginning of this section. Then one has the following asymptotic relations
N(t) - V(t),
(15.9)
Ak - V(1)-""k"",
(15.10)
where V(t) is defined by the formula (13.16).
Proof. In §13 we showed the equivalence of (15.9) and (15.10). (Proposition 13.1). Let us prove (15.9). This is done on the basis of the Tauberian theorem of Ikehara, by analogy with the proof of Theorem 15.1. Indeed, again we may assume that A, > 1. Then for Re a < - n/m, we clearly have the formula
S,(z)= f tzdN(t). It remains to use Theorems 13.1 and 14.1 and Lemma 13.1. Remark. One can derive (15.9) from (15.6) by integration over x. To justify this integration, it is necessary, however, to prove the uniformity in x of (15.6), which requires in several places (in particular, in the proof of the Ikehara theorem) the verification of uniformity in the parameter. To avoid this cumbersome verification, we have preferred to give an independent proof.
15.3 Problems
Problem 15.1. In the situation of this section prove the estimate
Ie(x,y,t)I SCt"1T, where x, y e M and the constant C > 0 does not depend on x, y and t (t z 1). Problem 15.2. Let A be an elliptic differential operator, on closed manifold M with smooth positive density, which is normal, i.e. A*A = AA*.
(15.12)
a) Show that A has an orthonormal basis of smooth eigenfunctions (p; (x),
j = 1, 2, . . ., with eigenvalues A; E C, such that IA;I
+oo
as
(15.13)
b) Show that if N (t) denotes the number of A,, such that I.ij I S t, and if V (t) is defined by the formula
§ 15. Asymptotic Behaviour of the Spectral Function and Eigenvalues
V(t) = (2n)""
f
131
(15.14)
la.(x, 0 1
then
N(t)-V([)
(15.15)
as
Problem 15.3. Deduce Theorems 15.1 and 15.2 from the results of Problem 13.4 and the Tauberian theorem of Karamata (Problem 14.2). Problem 15.4. Let M be a closed manifold, A an elliptic differential operator on M, such that a, (x, ) > 0 for c + 0. Let A j be its eigenvalues and N, (1) the number of eigenvalues with Re.lj < t (here we take for the multiplicity of an eigenvalue Ao the dimension of the root subspace EA., cf. Theorem 8.4), N2 (t) the
number of eigenvalues with IA; < t. Show that
N,(t)-N2(t)-V(t)
as t-++oo,
(15.16)
k -++oo
(15.17)
where V(t) is defined as before. Show that
2k _ V(1)-nf"krl"
(this means, in particular, that Im Ak has a lower degree of growth than Re Ak).
Chapter III Asymptotic Behaviour of the Spectral Function §16. Formulation of the Hormander Theorem and Comments 16.1 Formulation and an example. Let M be a closed n-dimensional manifold on which there is given a smooth positive density dx and let A be an elliptic, self-adjoint operator of degree m on M such that aM (x, ) > 0 for + 0. We will use the notations e (x, y, A), N (A), V. (A) and V (A) introduced in § 15. The
following theorem refines Theorems 15.1 and 15.2.
Theorem 16.1 (L. Hormander). The following estimate holds I e (x, x, A) - Vx (A) 15 CA(" -')/m,
A>_ 1,
xeM,
(16.1)
where the constant C > 0 is independent of x and A.
Corollary 16.1. The following asymptotic formula holds
N(A)=V(A)(1+O(A-'/°'))
A --+oo
as
(16.2)
Remark 16.1. In general the estimate of the remainder in (16.1), (16.2) cannot be improved. This can be seen by looking, for instance, at the operator
A=-
on the circle S' =1R/2,t Z. The corresponding eigenfunctions are
of the form yrk (x) =
1
e'kx,
k = 0,
±1,
and the eigenvalues are Ak = k2, k = 0, ± 1, ± 2,
± 2, ... ,
... .
Further, since tWk(x)12= (2n)-', then clearly e(x,x,A) =(21r)-N(A). Since V(A) _ (2x) -' V (A) then (16.1) and (16.2) are equivalent. So it suffices to show that the estimate of remainder in (16.2) can not be improved.
But in this example (16.2) has the form N(A) = V(A) (1 +O(A-'l2)) or N (A) = 2 i/ + O (1). The estimate O (1) can not be improved because N (A) has only integer values.
Chapter 111. Asymptotic Behaviour of the Spectral Function
134
Later, in §22, we will study a more interesting example, which is a generalization of the present one (the Laplace operator on the sphere) and shows
that (16.1) cannot be improved in the case of arbitrary n and m.
16.2 Sketch of the proof. First of all, the theory of complex powers of operators, allows a reduction to the case when A is a'f'DO of order 1. In this situation we will show, that for small t, e«4 is itself an FIO, with a phase function
which is a solution of a certain first order non-linear equation. Let us now remark, that the kernel of eu4 is the Fourier transform (in A) of the spectral function of A. From this the asymptotic (16.1) is obtained,