Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age The Penetrating Eye
Max Fincher
Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
This page i...
17 downloads
1598 Views
844KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age The Penetrating Eye
Max Fincher
Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
This page intentionally left blank
Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age The Penetrating Eye Max Fincher
© Max Fincher 2007 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted his right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2007 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 Companies and representatives throughout the world PALGRAVE MACMILLAN is the global academic imprint of the Palgrave Macmillan division of St. Martin’s Press, LLC and of Palgrave Macmillan Ltd. Macmillan is a registered trademark in the United States, United Kingdom and other countries. Palgrave is a registered trademark in the European Union and other countries. ISBN-13: 9780230003477 hardback ISBN-10: 0230003478 hardback This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. Logging, pulping and manufacturing processes are expected to conform to the environmental regulations of the country of origin. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 09 08 07 Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham and Eastbourne
Contents
Acknowledgements
vi
Introduction Gender and Gothic Sexuality Queering Gothic writing
1 2 7 12
1 Reading the Gaze: A Culture of Vigilance Horace Walpole William Beckford Matthew Lewis
23 24 30 39
2 Guessing the Mould: Or, The Castle of Otranto?
45
3 Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
65
4 Camping in the Monastery: The Monk
87
5 Caleb Williams and the Queer Sublime
110
6 Penetrating Eye(s): Lara, The Giaour, The Vampyre Feeding the vampire: Polidori and The Vampyre Penetrating eye(s): Lara and The Giaour
131 137 145
Conclusion
157
Notes
164
Works Cited
193
Index
202
v
Acknowledgements I would like to thank Judith Hawley, Sophie Gil-Martin and Robert Eaglestone at Royal Holloway, University of London, whose initial enthusiasm for my idea of the project as a PhD thesis, back in 1998, now seems like such a long time ago. This book would not have been possible without Clare Brant at King’s College London. Without her understanding, superb knowledge of eighteenth-century literature and culture, and tireless reading of drafts, the book would not have reached its present stage. I would also like to thank the support and advice of others at King’s College London, especially John Stokes, Bob Mills and, in particular, Mark Turner, whose advice on the many ways one can be queer was invaluable. Thanks are also due to Lucie Sutherland, Alison Stenton, Ralph Parfect, Lucy Munro, Fiona Ritchie, Anita Gnagnetti, Lola Cary, Jennifer Walters, Philippa Wilmott, Sarah Darby, Sharon Atkins, Donna Easterbrook, David Morris/Celia Pudwell and Simon Avery, all of whose friendship and enthusiasm for the project helped to keep me going. Thanks are also due to Matthew Bell, Lauren Fitzgerald, Frances Chiu, George Haggerty, Netta Murray Goldsmith, Michael Eberle-Sinatra, James D. Steakley, Matthew O’Rourke and William Hughes for reading drafts of chapters, giving advice, or providing leads for research which were invaluable. Finally I would like to thank my family, particularly my parents, who have endured my obsession with all things Gothic over the years and whose financial support and love has enabled me to complete the book. A version of parts of Chapters 1, 2 and 3 appeared as ‘Guessing the Mould: Homosocial Sins and Identity in Horace Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto’, Gothic Studies 3/3 (2001): 229–245. A version of Chapter 4 will appear as a forthcoming article in Romanticism on The Net, ‘The Gothic as Camp: Queer Aesthetics in The Monk’.
vi
Introduction
When I was 10 or 11 years old, I wanted to be a witch. As soon as the nights began to get dark and frosty with the leaves turning various shades of red, I would get excited at the prospect of dressing up for one special night of the year, Halloween, to be a witch. I did not want to be a warlock. I wanted to be a real, classic witch like I had seen in The Wizard of Oz and read about in the books by Jill Murphy at school.1 I persuaded my mother to buy me eyeliner and lipstick to complete the transformation with a black pointed hat and cape, a broomstick, green foundation and the ugliest set of nail extensions I could find. A group of my friends and I would then roam the surburban streets (with my mother always supervising). Those who were amused or kind gave us sweets, those who were irritated or exhausted just did not get up to answer the door, and those who were terrified, the devout Christians, opened the door and told us we would go to hell. It was all great fun. But I was told by some of my peers that I could not be a witch. I was not allowed to be a witch. I was a boy and how could a boy be a witch when girls were witches? Unless you were gay of course which might explain it, nominally at least. I had no concept of what being ‘gay’ meant when I was first called gay. Looking back now, my subsequent interest in ghost stories, horror films and later Gothic probably stemmed from an identification with the witch as a transgressive outsider figure, one that I can now see we might describe as queer. The witch is a figure that combines both masculine and feminine traits. My performance as a witch, cross-dressing and making up, had nothing to do with desiring men – that happened not long afterwards. But it was queer. This book aims to queer Gothic writing in the Romantic Age, taking as its starting point the 1760s with The Castle of Otranto by Horace Walpole through to poetry by Byron and the first vampire story by 1
2
Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
John Polidori.2 Although Walpole’s novel may seem an early starting point for some to describe the beginning of the Romantic Age, the novel did mark a pronounced shift in reading tastes that can be broadly defined as Romantic in the sense of presenting us with a fantastic historical past with the interest in the supernatural. The introduction is divided into three broad topics with significant weighting given to the last two: gender and Gothic, sexuality and queering Gothic writing. Recognizing the Gothic as queer takes us to a new point in rereading (or more accurately, revisioning) these texts and critical approaches to them.
Gender and Gothic Undoubtedly, feminist criticism of Gothic writing is the major inspiration for my thinking of what might be queer about Gothic. What follows, then, is a brief and necessarily concise account of some of the developments in feminist-based criticism of Gothic writing and how these have been instrumental in the recent rise in queer readings of Gothic writing. The bifurcation of Gothic writing into ‘male’ and ‘female’ Gothic arose in the 1970s with the advent of feminist criticism when a critical re-evaluation of Gothic writing began in earnest. Following Ellen Moers who coined the term ‘female Gothic’ in her study of nineteenth-century women authors like Ann Radcliffe and Mary Shelley, feminist critics argued for ‘female Gothic’ as a distinct aspect of the genre.3 Moers’ analysis depends upon the biographical circumstances of Radcliffe and Shelley (particularly the latter), implying that Shelley’s experience as a woman determines the literary ‘offspring’. The signifying power of texts like Frankenstein (1818) and Radcliffe’s novels can be attributed to the writers’ femaleness as a biological and physiological fact. Consequently, the result is that these texts produce responses in female readers who can appreciate the problems of being female. Subsequent critical attention significantly complicates the reading of the relation of ‘female’ to ‘femininity’ and ‘male’ to ‘masculinity’ in Gothic plots, themes and characterization: One may believe that all writing or forms of writing are ‘marked’ by gender; demonstrating this has proved extremely difficult [ ] we need to be clear about the sorts of heuristic devices or strategies which have been used in making claims about the Gothic as ‘women’s fiction’.4
Introduction
3
Whether it is critically advantageous to retain the terms ‘male’ and ‘female’ to read Gothic writing is addressed in an issue of the journal Women’s Writing (1993). In his introductory essay Robert Miles attributes the emergence of the concept of ‘female Gothic’ to a more sophisticated approach to Freudian theory and fantasy: The texts with the richest meanings were not those fully mediated by the author’s consciousness, but those arising from sites of the greatest conflict. The greater the social repression, the more authors’ minds were forced into roundabout ways of addressing their experience, the more articulate their texts, and the more significant and representative their evasions.5 Miles’s argument that female Gothic writing ‘met the criteria of this aesthetic revaluation, perhaps more than any other “genre” ’ is true due to the social and material disadvantages of women during the period.6 But can this understanding of the fantastic genre, in which Gothic forms a significant part, apply to male writers too? Can ‘social repression’ encompass repression that extends to both men and women, particularly with reference to the prohibition of specific sexual desires? As Michel Foucault argues, repression and sexuality are in a dialectical relation to one another (particularly in times of major socio-economic and political upheaval like in the late eighteenth century) where the institutionalized forces of repression produces a discourse of sexuality through other discourses: Rather than the uniform concern to hide sex, rather than the general prudishness of language, what distinguishes these last three centuries is the variety, the wide dispersion of devices that were invented for speaking about it, for having it spoken about.7 Social repression should be taken to include the unequivocal enforcement of the law of ‘heterosexuality’. If we take a biographically-centred approach to reading the fictions of those writers whom we suspect of same-sex desires and whose gender is ambiguous or complicated, we might anticipate that their writing will in covert ways signify for a queer reader. However, one must realize that this reading practice privileges sexuality and authorial intention as the prime determinants of constructing meaning for the reader. As I discuss below, the very concept of sexuality as a socially-verifiable identity is difficult in the pre-Victorian period. Framing a discussion of Gothic writing in terms of ‘male’ and
4
Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
‘female’ ignores or covers over those instances where the terms overlap or interchange their characteristics with one another. It also conflicts with a queer reading practice that attempts to de-essentialize categories of identity that are spoken of as essences, like sex or gender are sometimes spoken about. Recent feminist criticism of the Gothic mobilizes queer readings by suggesting that gender can be read obliquely through discourses. One way to understand discourses is to interpret them as the ‘roundabout ways’ that Miles describes women writers using. Jacqueline Howard suggests that the theorist Mikhail Bakhtin’s concept of the novel as a form that is in dialogue with other types of writing or narratives is especially applicable to the Gothic: we can examine whether and how the Gothic folk-tales, fairy-tales, superstitions, myths, discourses of the sublime, everyday ‘common sense’, and fragments of discourse drawn from non-literary realms are simply reproduced or actually transformed, and in whose interests.8 The formal characteristics of Gothic writing, such as its Chinese-box narrative structures, its multiple narrators and interrupted stories, invite a circuitous reading attitude. Such a roundabout approach stands as a symbol of how we can read Gothic writing at the level of narrative as intimately related to the ‘perverse’ or ‘wayward’. Gothic stories never follow a ‘straight’ course, a fact that in itself makes them queer. Howard argues for the need to contextualize Gothic writing by women; for instance by recognizing that the late eighteenth-century interest in sensibility and the sublime are expressive discourses through which to negotiate female experience. Following Howard, feminist criticism of the female Gothic writers in the late 1990s has taken up these ideas. In her recent book Women’s Gothic: From Clara Reeve to Mary Shelley (2000) Emma J. Clery suggests that the actress Sarah Siddons associated the sublime with femininity, both in her performances and in the critical writing about her. Clery argues that this provided a liberating image of inspiration for women writing Gothic.9 So one can reasonably conclude that queerness might require being interpreted through a nexus of other discourses which ostensibly would seem to have little relation to sexual desire. The critical premise that Gothic writing is divided along the lines of horror/terror and male/female accordingly helped to form the ontological groundwork for the binaries of early feminist criticism of Gothic writing.10 Sandra M. Gilbert’s and Susan Gubar’s The Madwoman in the
Introduction
5
Attic: The Woman Writer and the Nineteenth Century Literary Imagination (1979) concretized an approach to Gothic writing that was based in the idea of essentialized sexual difference. They argue that the spectacle of imprisonment in women’s writing is determined by the material oppression of women in the domestic sphere.11 But the motif of imprisonment within domesticity also applies to men in Gothic writing by men. And this is not said in an attempt to engage in some kind of war of the ownership of conventions or critical terrain, as Lauren Fitzgerald accurately points out characterizes one history of critical approaches to the Gothic.12 And as Diane Long Hoeveler has argued the representation of a victimized femininity by women authors is more complicated than by men in Gothic writing simply oppressing women and women embodying a masochistic position.13 Anne Williams develops the idea of separate spheres further. She organizes the conventions of Gothic writing along the lines of an Aristotelian paradigm of opposing forces that constitute reality.14 In particular, male Gothic writing expresses an anxiety about the mother. This anxiety results in horror because the female body is historically linked to femininity through a theological discourse of the body as materiality, or mater meaning mother in Latin. However, Williams neglects where men experience suffering and terror in Gothic writing at the hands of the father and how this too could express sexual fears and desires, whether incestuous, homoerotic or masochistic. As I discuss further in section two, it is important not to underestimate how these desires connect to ‘female victimization’. I must emphasize here that I agree with feminist readings which argue that male Gothic writing can portray a misogynistic viewpoint of women. As I outline later, in such novels as The Castle of Otranto, Vathek and The Monk the maternal is imagined as both evil and an obstacle to male power. The negative stereotyping of femininity in male Gothic writing (i.e. the castrating mother and the passive victim) is, sometimes, a result of how the erotic component, of excessive feelings between (hatred, jealousy) is diverted onto women. Why are women who disrupt the boundary between femininity and masculinity such potent objects of fear and hatred in Gothic writing that need to be marked off, if not destroyed? One useful strategy of feminist criticism is to use theories of how narratives work, paying particular attention to the positions of narrators and spectators. Susan Wolstenholme, for instance, suggests that female Gothic writing is distinguished formalistically by who narrates or observes. These inescapable structures of perception and representation mirror the social position of women as objects of observation: ‘Even
6
Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
when in a relatively powerless position, a man assumes the powerful position of spectator more easily than does a woman.’15 However, criticism has focused upon how the female body is objectified by the male gaze. What I wish to give attention to is the implications of the gaze and looking between one man and another. Since a discourse of looking between men and women in fiction often signals the reciprocal exchange of love and sexual desire, then it is not implausible to read the gaze between men as love and desire. As I point out below, theories of the gaze offer one way of understanding how the male as the object of an other’s (male) gaze might be read as part of the queerness of Gothic writing. I do not think this is an anachronistic leap to make. With its focus on appealing to the ocular sense, its dramatic plots and repeatable conventions, it is no coincidence that the traditional figures and motifs from Gothic writing have proved so popularly adaptable to film. Allowing for differences between cinema and fiction, early Gothic writing invites the description ‘cinematic’.16 The conventions and themes of Gothic writing form the basis for the narratives and imagery of the modern horror film, and these have often been given queer resonances as, for example, in the vampire sub-genre. Harry Benshoff’s study, Monsters in the Closet: Homosexuality and the Horror Film, discusses how the genre of horror has circulated a semantic coupling of monstrosity with ‘homosexuality’ either in plots or images which have their origins in Gothic writing.17 Recently there has been a re-evaluation of the term ‘female Gothic’ that takes account of critical developments in the 1990s and provides new readings of ‘female’ Gothic that expand the range of texts and approaches.18 The development of queer readings of the Gothic from feminist readings has an important parallel to the development of queer theory out of feminist theory and some of the problems this has brought to light feed into the evolution of Gothic criticism.19 To some extent the above account of feminist reading of the Gothic simplifies the complex evolving nature of feminist enquiry itself. I do not wish to suggest that a feminist reading of Gothic is static, stuck in a theoretical binary tangle of what is ‘male’ Gothic and what is ‘female’ Gothic, any more than to suggest that a queer reading is the last word on reading sexual desire in Gothic. To claim that the study of sexuality in Gothic belongs to queer theory any more than gender belongs to a feminist practice overlooks how queer readings and feminist readings can complement one another. The goal of the analyses is to argue that it is not necessary to take sex or sexuality as the primary objects of reading desire between men in the period. My readings are inspired
Introduction
7
by feminist criticism but they do not automatically privilege gender, although gender is crucial to reading how eighteenth-century homophobia can open up Gothic and vice versa.
Sexuality One of the reasons that it is perhaps necessary to distance oneself from reading ‘sexuality’ in Romanticism is that sexuality suggests an essentialized position. Discussing sexuality along the lines of a modern idea of sexuality as a category of identity that we and others define us by is not so easily transferable to the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. Neither ‘gay’, ‘homosexual’ or ‘sodomite’ are satisfactory in capturing the complexity, spectrum and evanescence of the men and women who loved each other, desired one another or whose fantasies for one another were played out in other forms that were not immediately socially visible.20 Up until now I have been using the terms ‘homosexual’, ‘homosexuality’ and ‘heterosexuality’ in inverted commas to indicate a critical distance and scepticism towards their appropriateness. Michel Foucault suggests 1870 as the date when ‘homosexuality’ was pathologized through the rise and practice of psychoanalysis: The nineteenth-century homosexual became a personage, a past, a case history, and a childhood, in addition to being a type of life, a life form, and a morphology, with an indiscreet anatomy and possibly a mysterious physiology. Nothing that went into his total composition was unaffected by his sexuality. It was everywhere present in him: at the root of all his actions because it was their insidious and indefinitely active principle;21 It would be anachronistic and reductive to apply the terms ‘homosexual’ and ‘homosexuality’ to the period under discussion. To discuss ‘homosexuality’ immediately invokes the implications established in Freud’s theories of sexuality that homosexuality is a perverse and a pathological developmental condition that needs to be cured.22 ‘Homosexual’ is a dirty word among self-identified openly gay people and queers. Because of how psychoanalysis has been subtly coercive in a political mobilization against gay men and women in the twentieth century, it is a term that many rightly prefer to disown. Rictor Norton chooses the term ‘gay’ for his discussion of the mollies in the eighteenth century, describing the beginnings of a same-sex subculture.23 I have chosen to avoid using gay because it seems to me to lack a descriptive expansiveness and
8
Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
elasticity that queer possesses. The risk of the charge of anachronism in using queer is a risk anyone must confront who reads fiction queerly before the most widely recognized queer, Oscar Wilde. Nevertheless, there is a significant and growing body of work that seeks to challenge the idea that ‘queer’ can only apply to Wilde-and-after in the twentieth century. For the purposes of this study, I have chosen to use ‘queer’ to refer predominantly to men who engage in same-sex activity or who feel desire for one another that resists an essentialized identity category. To discuss same-sex desire solely in terms of sodomy is reductive and unsatisfactory because it immediately invokes one bodily practice amongst others which excludes other expressions or sublimations of homoerotic desire.24 It is also a term that is overdetermined in the eighteenth century and unstable. In A Lover’s Discourse, Roland Barthes suggests that the body acts as a non-verbal discourse of desire between the ‘amorous subject’ and his/her object: ‘The other’s body was divided: on one side, the body proper – skin, eyes – tender, warm; and on the other side, the voice – abrupt, reserved, subject to fits of remoteness, a voice which did not give what the body gave.’25 This disjunction that Barthes notices between the lover’s body, particularly the gaze and that of the voice, might be adapted as a model for reading the interaction between bodies in Gothic. Especially when those bodies call into question gender norms. The act of translating the meanings of the body, and in particular the gaze, that sometimes seems to be at odds with other signals, and which the Gothic foregrounds, is especially queer. I use ‘homoerotic’ to describe those representations between men that for the queer reader register a meaning that points beyond the emotions of friendship, rivalry or enmity towards desire. My understanding of ‘homoerotic desire’ therefore builds on G.S. Rousseau’s definition as ‘male-oriented friendship not necessarily oral or genital’, to describe a desire which may or may not be conscious and is usually unfulfilled sexually.26 Gothic writing in the period 1765–1820 was a cultural form through which homophobia can be explored in contexts other than the pillory, for example in more subtle forms such as the construction of a middleclass identity politics. I do not believe it to be a prerequisite of homophobia that it depends upon the term ‘homosexuality’. If we define homophobia as the fear and hatred of same-sex desire, there is ample evidence in eighteenth-century contemporary social and legal discourses for the existence of a public homophobia, albeit predominantly determined by the spectacle of the convicted sodomite.27 In
Introduction
9
Gothic writing, the fear of effeminacy and transvestism signifies for a queer reader that there could be a link to those societal fears. The question of effeminacy’s slippery meaning, both in the eighteenth century and currently, is important to take into consideration because of effeminacy’s association with a history of same sex desire.28 An exaggerated reaction against being perceived as effeminate and an equally exaggerated drive to punish effeminacy in others can be seen as a representation of internalized homophobia. Jonathan Dollimore suggests that twentieth-century homophobia can be defined as ‘integral to a conventional kind of masculine identity’ and that it ‘intersects with other kinds of phobia and hatred’.29 I think this is also true for the late eighteenth century, even though the kinds of masculine identities and the phobias are in different forms that are not so readily recognizable. Looking at the overlaps and the linguistic links between misogyny and effeminacy illustrates how we can read Gothic writing as encoding one of the structures of homophobia. By describing Gothic writing as ‘homophobic’, I do not mean to suggest that it openly targets and denounces a sociallyidentifiable group like the mollies caught and exposed throughout the eighteenth century. Rather, because gender in Gothic writing is under threat by unstable or transgressive manifestations that are invariably portrayed as evil and destructive, this can help us to see where else homophobia may be operating in the late eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century Britain, apart from the pillory in Charing Cross in London. Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick’s Between Men: English Literature and Homosocial Desire has been the most important influence on the development of my argument. Sedgwick argues: ‘the Gothic was the first novelistic form in England to have close relatively visible links to male homosexuality’.30 This book aims to examine what and where these links are, and how they are interrelated. Despite her brilliant analysis, Sedgwick nevertheless uses ‘homosexual’ which, as I explained above, is historically and theoretically problematic. I wish to suggest instead that these ‘links’ are in fact more ambiguous and not so easily perceived; they have the power to appear and disappear in the texts. A stable interpretation of gender or sexuality by the reader is frequently resisted by Gothic writing which makes it queer. Paulina Palmer has argued for the similarities between Gothic and queer, particularly in how they both deconstruct ideas of sexual identity: ‘Gothic’ and ‘queer’ share a common emphasis on transgressive acts and subjectivities. In addition both acknowledge the importance of
10 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
fantasy, sexual as well as cultural, and represent subjectivity as fractured and fluid. Whereas Gothic narrative explores the disintegration of the self into double or multiple facets, queer theory foregrounds the multiple sexualities and roles that the subject produces and enacts.31 The goal of my argument differs from Sedgwick. She argues: ‘The present study is concerned, not distinctively with homosexual experience, but with the shape of the entire male homosocial spectrum, and its effects on women’ [my emphasis].32 Although exploring misogyny in relation to how Gothic writing plays out homoerotic desire and homophobia is important, Sedgwick’s feminist aim to explore ‘the effects on women’ is tangential to my interest in exploring how desire works between men.33 Sedgwick’s idea that homophobia is ‘terroristic’ in its structure – that it is episodic, isolated and parochial – is one that I develop. For example the fear characters experience encountering the supernatural depends upon their isolation. The Gothic ghost is more often than not a kind of transvestite, destabilizing gender as it terrorizes the straight subject.34 Sedgwick’s account of how homosocial relationships work is useful to understand how cultural forms like Gothic writing can be interpreted from a queer reader’s perspective. Sedgwick argues that homosociality is a structure of male bonding that depends upon acknowledging the existence of ‘homosexual’ desire and relationships in order to repudiate or mark itself off from them. The presence of either femininity or effeminacy works to circumvent or triangulate homoerotic desire (either through love or hatred) in the homosocial relationship. Desire between men is triangulated, or it is negated into homophobic impulses that find expression in misogyny. As Sedgwick comments: ‘it has apparently been impossible to find a form of patriarchy that was not homophobic’.35 ‘Homosocial’ relations are predicated upon a bonding between men which is characterized by silence and unspeakability about sexual desires for one another. Silence and unspeakability come to stand in for the possibility that such homosocial bonds contain the potential for an erotic expression or interpretation. ‘Homosocial’ offers a useful term to articulate the unstable, excessive nature of relationships between men that are not specifically sexualized in terms of literal physical contact, yet through which desire operates. In thinking about how an internalized homophobia might be operating in the relationships between male and female characters, it is difficult to avoid privileging gender to enable a queer reading of Gothic writing. Foucault argues that the definitional power of gender
Introduction
11
in the construction and perception of same-sex desire begins with the inscription ‘homosexual’; before this, only specific sexual practices existed: ‘Homosexuality appeared as one of the forms of sexuality when it was transposed from the practice of sodomy onto a kind of interior androgyny, a hermaphrodism of the soul. The sodomite had been a temporary aberration.’36 Androgyny, as an awareness of being masculine and feminine simultaneously or self-consciously positioning oneself in varying degrees with types of masculinity or femininity, seems to be queer in escaping gender. Androgyny could even be freedom from gender. Foucault’s argument suggests that the psychic importance of gender for sexuality was non-existent before the late nineteenth century. We should not underestimate, however, the degree to which the culturally shifting meanings and representations of masculinity and femininity in the late eighteenth century problematized the nature of the links between sex, gender and desire. How far do newspaper accounts, legal trial papers, broadsides or pamphlets reflect contemporary social attitudes? Are there voices of support that are more obscurely expressed? Reductive as these texts are, in their imperative for evidence and the need to socially identify and excoriate those bodies whose gender does not conform or is out of kilter with ‘normality’, they converge together into a homophobic discourse. Certain kinds of masculinities complicate the boundaries between sex and gender, and consequently desire. The visibility of feminized masculinities that are thought to attract women such as the man of feeling, the fop, the macaroni and the pretty gentleman may work to make queer men invisible by comparison. If ‘homosexual’ and ‘homosexuality’ are unsatisfactory terms to describe the nature of erotic male relations in the period, then so too are ‘heterosexual’ and ‘heterosexuality’ as terms to define them against. As George Chauncey argues: ‘If homosexuality did not exist in the early nineteenth century, then neither did heterosexuality, for each category depends for its existence on the other.’37 However, some term is needed to describe desire and intercourse between opposite genders that is socially visible. I have chosen to use the term ‘straight’ where I want to signal this and I differentiate this from the idea of the heteronormative, which I define below. I think ‘straight’ has an appropriate symbolic valence for Gothic. It suggests that the twisted, crooked, circuitous narratives, structures and motifs of Gothic writing are in fact less than straight. Queer readings are in a dialogue with straightness in that they are constantly alert to making visible the points at which straightness is precarious. This is particularly the case with the depiction
12 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
of the dysfunctional family unit in Gothic.38 The aim of the book is to argue that Gothic writing offers us ways of recognizing queerness in the late eighteenth century and Romantic period which exceeds the idea of sexuality itself.
Queering Gothic Writing In this section I explain why I have chosen to use the term ‘queer’ and what I understand by ‘queering’ as a critical reading practice. Despite queer often being used in late twentieth-century contexts, ‘Queer’ is useful as a noun to describe men in the late eighteenth century and Romantic period that experience and express sexual desire for other men.39 Queer moves beyond the boundary of a preformed, imposed identity category like ‘sodomite’ or ‘homosexual’, and also recognizes where these men might be erased in culture.40 Queer, as Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick defines it, is ‘the open mesh of possibilities, gaps, overlaps, dissonances and resonances, lapses and excesses of meaning when the constituent elements of anyone’s gender, of anyone’s sexuality aren’t made (or can’t be made) to signify monolithically’.41 According to this definition of Sedgwick’s, queer individuals problematize the links between gender and sexuality as identity categories. Queering, as a way of reading or as a verb, is intimately connected to the idea of crossing over or between places, making links that have perhaps gone unnoticed or are not immediately obvious. And it must be said, those links are open to be challenged and debated. As William B. Turner points out, queer is ‘a relatively novel term that connotes etymologically a crossing of boundaries but that refers to nothing in particular, thus leaving the questions of its denotations open to contest and revision’.42 As an adjective, queer refers to the breaking down of structures we take for granted, like gender: ‘it is to abrade the classifications, to sit athwart conventional categories or traverse several’.43 And one of the most important ways to describe pre-twentieth-century culture as queer is to pay attention to the resonances of language. The interest in historicizing novels by showing where there are overlaps and conjunctions (Sedgwick’s idea of the mesh) with non-fictional texts and discourses is now vital to queering pre-Wildean fiction.44 However, there is an observation that a queer reading practice might end up having nothing to do with sex or sexuality. The plurality of queerness might empty out the idea of queer to pertain to same-sex erotic relationships.45 Queer is also sometimes used as a catch-all term for the idea of polymorphous perverse sex, or sexual acts, practices and desires that include
Introduction
13
straight sex but which are perceived to be beyond ‘the norm’. To a degree, I am compromising queer by limiting the analysis to a focus on just same-sex desire between men, perhaps at the expense of a richer, more diverse reading.46 The emphasis on difference and non-normativity which queer theorists propose as ‘queer’ informs its reading practice. A key idea that queer reading engages with is that of heteronormativity or the heteronormative. The heteronormative is a presumptive sense that certain ways of being and identity are natural, normal and are privileged over others. The ideal family and its centrality in society is a good example. As Lauren Berlant and Michael Warner explain further, ‘Heteronormativity is more than ideology, or prejudice, or phobia against gays and lesbians; it is produced in almost every aspect of the forms and arrangement of social life: nationality, the state, and the law; as well as in the conventions and affects of narrativity, romance and other protected spaces of culture.’47 A queer reading attempts to articulate these points of disruption in culture where the heteronormative is resisted, particularly by unconventional gendered behaviour(s) that disturb its underpinning. And it must be noted that heteronormativity is not a preserve of being straight or heterosexual. It is perfectly possible for gays and queers to engage in and reproduce heteronormative practices because it is so pervasive and endemic across culture(s). I understand queerness to signify as desire for and between men which contains the potential for a sexualized interpretation. Transvestitism occurs occasionally in Gothic writing and I wish to explore how changing one’s clothes is queer.48 An etymology of queer enforces linguistically the sense of crossing and throwing into disequilibrium the boundaries of masculinity and femininity which transvestitism enacts. I wish to draw attention to how I am not attempting to reclaim a particular literary period for a moralizing or reclamative position that an identity-based politics sometimes takes up. Scott Bravmann argues for the need of a critical approach to the insensitivities of gay and lesbian historiography towards differences in historical timeframes: ‘In so far as they set out to establish a pan-cultural lesbian and gay existence, certain “popular” texts that seek to reclaim a “lost” gay and lesbian history can be criticized for reiterating culturally specific identity categories as universal’ (29).49 Although my queer analysis is partly informed by a historicist approach to Gothic writing (by looking at say the parallels between homophobic texts and Gothic writing), I wish to emphasize that I do not wish to engage in a historiographical methodology based on uncovering evidence.50 Instead, I wish to argue
14 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
that queer is descriptively powerful enough to permit a reading of desire between men where ostensibly it does not seem to be visible, except in derogatory or homophobic terms. There is now a significant body of criticism on how many of the major literary figures in the Romantic period are queer or can tell us what it means to be queer in the period. As Michael O’Rourke and David Collings point out: ‘Like queer, Romanticism is always messy, excessive, overspilling historical and corporeal boundaries. Like queer, Romanticism is resistant to the impulsion of critics to define it, pin it down, place a cordon sanitaire around it.’51 Robert Tobin in Queer Theory and the Age of Goethe provides a definition of how a queer reading can be applied to eighteenth-century texts. He argues: Queering the eighteenth century means wrenching it from established contexts in order to read it against the grain of traditional readings and dissolving the accreted interpretations that stifle or avoid those textual passages that do not lend themselves to orthodox readings. Such passages might often suggest a queer sexuality, that is to say, a sexuality divergent from the assumptions of present-day heterosexual norms.52 Through close reading, I intend to queer Gothic writing by focusing attention onto those conventions which either seem to exceed their narrative content, as in the gaze and gender ambiguity, or which resonate with implications for a twentieth-century queer reading practice. In historical periods of invisibility and prohibition, there is perhaps more than ever a requirement to read obliquely, because the queer gets mediated through other signs and discourses. Other discourses such as travel literature, the sublime and religion provide relevant contexts for a discussion of the ever-present threat of the destabilization of sex, gender and desire which Gothic writing provokes us with. This pleasurable phobia can be interpreted queerly. My reading of Gothic writing as a cultural form in which the destabilization of masculinity points towards what is queer about Gothic derives, in part, from the work of Judith Butler. Butler exposes how gender is constructed as an unquestioned element of identity for the subject through the discourses of psychoanalysis and philosophy. In fact, gender, she argues, is an effect of contingent laws and attributes. She concludes:
Introduction
15
In this sense, gender is not a noun, but neither is it a set of freefloating attributes, for we have seen that the substantive effect of gender is performatively produced and compelled by the regulatory practices of gender coherence. Hence, within the inherited discourse of the metaphysics of substance, gender proves to be performative— that is, constituting the identity it is purported to be. In this sense, gender is always a doing, though not a doing by a subject who might be said to pre-exist the deed [ ] There is no gender identity behind the expressions of gender; that identity is performatively constituted by the very “expressions” that are said to be its results.53 Butler’s idea upsets the idea of cause and effect. That is, that to be male is masculine and female feminine is so routinized in culture that it goes unnoticed until the queer steps in. The implications of Butler’s argument for de-essentializing both ‘heterosexuality’ and gay and lesbianism based on the causal relation between sex and gender have been central to shaping the notion of queer. Queer desire refuses to be aligned along any one axis of identity; it refuses the idea of a coherent identity that never changes, evolves or can be seen differently from varying positions. Anna Marie Jagosé comments that Butler ‘argues that those failures or confusions of gender—those performative repetitions that do not consolidate the law but that [ ] nevertheless generated by that law—highlight the discursive rather than the essential character of gender’ [my emphasis].54 It is the points of ‘failure’ and ‘confusion’ of the readability and intelligibility of gender ‘identity’ in Gothic writing that facilitate a queer reading. As an example one might concentrate on the moments when an association of the mind and rationality with masculinity and the body and emotion with femininity is reversed – for example where male bodies are represented as hysterical or where they feel threatened by a figure of an unstable gender identity.55 Butler’s idea of gender as a reiterated performativity draws attention to how gender is constructed as natural when it is challenged by bodies and behaviour which disestablish ‘relations of coherence and continuity among sex, gender, sexual practice and desire’.56 This deconstruction is useful to articulate how we might see Gothic writing as circulating a homophobic/homoerotic economy.57 However, the queerness of Gothic writing also emerges through an idea of gender performativity that is more self-conscious. Superficially, Gothic writing is replete with situations where changes in identity (usually class or gender) are mobilized for particular ends. Identities are mistaken, and Gothic often presents us with characters whose gender is exaggerated, theatricalized and almost
16 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
stereotyped. I interpret and term these instances as hyperbolic gender.58 I do not mean that gender is performed in a self-conscious parodic way as with drag. As Butler comments: ‘If drag is performative, that does not mean that all performativity is to be understood as drag.’59 I understand her to mean that gender is not always performed self-consciously like drag, although one might make an exception with Rosario/Matilda in The Monk who intentionally imitates a type of masculinity. What is the effect of this sense of exaggeration and excess of the gender signified? The queerness of Gothic writing is partially made up by how the Gothic is camp. Susan Sontag (one of the first to articulate a discussion of camp) locates the historical origins of camp as a style in the eighteenth century: ‘The dividing line seems to fall in the eighteenth century; there the origins of camp taste are to be found (Gothic novels, Chinoiserie, caricature, artificial ruins and so forth).’60 One of Sontag’s defining ‘notes’ about camp is that it is recognizable as a nostalgia for forgotten cultural forms. Gothic writing’s distinct idealization of place and history suggests this nostalgia. Sontag divides camp into naive and deliberate camp: In naïve, or pure, Camp, the essential element is seriousness, a seriousness that fails. Of course, not all seriousness that fails can be redeemed as Camp. Only that which has the proper mixture of the exaggerated, the fantastic, the passionate, and the naïve. [my emphasis]61 Clearly Gothic writing can be evaluated according to the last four defining criteria. The seriousness that fails in Gothic writing is, I believe, found in its reverential, yet popularizing transposition of a set of archetypes (such as a character or a plot) from traditional ‘high’ literary culture. In his preface to the second edition of The Castle of Otranto, Walpole explicitly outlines how the novel is indebted to Shakespeare; its five chapters attempt to mirror the five-act play. This ‘borrowing’ explains his wish to naturalize the reactions of his characters: ‘The simplicity of their behaviour, almost tending to excite smiles, which at first seem not consonant to the serious cast of the work, appeared to me not only improper, but was marked designedly in that manner. My rule was nature.’62 The effect conforms to Sontag’s pure camp. The theatricalized performativity of characters becomes what Cleto terms ‘a failed seriousness’.63 Novels by less accomplished authors also have a camp effect in their serious imitation and admiration of Radcliffe and Lewis. For example in Percy Bysshe Shelley’s early attempts at writing Gothic
Introduction
17
novels, Zastrozzi (1810) and St Irvyne (1811), one can only read so many claps of thunder and lightning as ominously terrifying before they become laughable.64 And there are of course parodies of Gothic writing, most famously Northanger Abbey (1818) by Jane Austen, which capitalize on the reader’s awareness of narrative conventions to induce laughter. However parody is differentiated from naive camp in that it deliberately intends its effect to be that of satire and laughter. I do not believe, for example, that Gothic writing intends to ridicule Shakespeare by burlesquing his plots. Sontag’s formulations about camp have been criticized for stripping camp of its historical specificity – its distinctive association with a gay and lesbian subcultural politics and culture that begins around the turn of the twentieth century. Nevertheless Sontag’s ideas and their pertinence to Gothic writing suggest that camp as queer (or what I would like to call ‘queer-camp’) has a much longer history. Fabio Cleto’s deconstructionist reading of how camp is queer is particularly useful for a reading of campness in the Gothic. Cleto’s reading of camp is informed by a post-structuralist theoretical viewpoint of how there exists a slippage between language, meaning and interpretation. In deconstructionist terms, as a signifier, camp’s implied referent is not always ‘homosexuality’, with an always and forever stable ‘gay’ signified. As a result of the instability that exists because of this gap, camp is therefore queer: But ‘queer’ in its potentially queering value does not invest just gender, but semiotic structures at large, the signs of domination moving in concert with sexual and non-sexual hierarchies, and the constitution of self-alleged naturality and univocity of the sign, in its relations of signifier, signified and referent, we are doing nothing else than stabilising in a universally consensual (and ‘natural’) code a sign [i.e. camp] that works on the crisis of codes and signs, and through these, of the cultural hierarchies that are inscribed in all ‘naturality of signs’. [emphasis added] Gothic writing can therefore be read queerly in that it frequently represents a crisis of reading the ‘relations of signifier, signified and referent’ particularly when reading gender and desire. This crisis is located in the (mis)interpretation of the signifiers of the body, such as the gaze and the voice, so that opposite meanings or intentions are deduced and gender positions reversed. As Cleto argues ‘camp works by contradiction, by crossing statements and their possibility of being’. In particular,
18 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
the principal semiotic that is in crisis in Gothic writing, and which by implication queers it, is how we read the characters’ encounters with the supernatural. Signs that we interpret as real, natural and masculine/feminine (one of Cleto’s ‘cultural hierarchies’) turn out to be false, supernatural or feminine/masculine; they become inverted. Cleto’s metaphor for how camp works uncannily evokes the settings of Gothic writing. According to Cleto, camp is ‘a queer twisted discursive building, the site of an improvised and stylized performance, a propergroundless, mobile building without deep and anchoring functions, a building devoid of stasis’. This description could apply to every castle, monastery or prison we find in Gothic writing. In these sites, gender is both performed and collapsing. The performance of gender in Gothic writing is hyperbolic, to the extent that it can be read as theatricalized and exaggerated. As I will show with The Monk, the misinterpretation of the body, especially through the voice and the gaze, are central to how Gothic novels open up questions about the concept of gender itself. It is the reversal of these codes of gender that makes a reading of The Monk into a camp experience. Although each reading focuses upon particular aspects of the texts that can be read queerly, there is a unifying theme running through the book of how the gaze works. I concentrate upon the exchange of looks between men, but not exclusively, as how men and women look with desiring eyes can be revealing. Eighteenth-century culture continues a tradition of how the exchange of looks and the gaze is a means by which sexual desire can be communicated between men and women. For instance, in the early eighteenth century the author of The Lover’s Pacquet provides the reader with a guide to the ‘kingdom of love’: ‘Not far from this grove there is an inn, at a small distance from the highway, call’d alluring glances, and this is a baiting place for travellers.’65 In Sterne’s Tristram Shandy, Widow Wadman’s attempts to get Tristram to gaze into her eye by feigning she has got something in it is implied by the narrator to have sexual motives: ‘There is nothing, my dear paternal uncle! But one lambent delicious fire, furtively shooting out from every part of it, in all directions, into thine—’.66 The narrator claims he will be ‘undone’ if he gazes any longer into her eye, asserting later that ‘It did my uncle Toby’s business’, supposedly referring to a sexual encounter.67 There are probably numerous other examples from fiction that could be quoted. But how far are the gaze and the interpretation of looks and looking functioning as a conduit for sexual desire between two male characters, between a narrator and his subject, or even between the narrator and the reader? What can we infer from such visual
Introduction
19
relations that destabilizes the category of a straight, dominant type of masculinity? Frequently a male character who is positioned as the object of the gaze (in literal symbolic and supernatural ways) becomes both unspeakable and powerless. Anne Williams points up how there is a repeated focus on the ‘penetrating’ eyes of the hero-villain and argues: In English the first-person pronoun and the word for the organ of sight sound the same – an accident, but one that conveniently serves to repress speculation that all I’s/eyes might not be the same. The existence of Male and female Gothic narratives, however, demonstrates that they are not.68 I have used the title ‘The Penetrating Eye’ to play upon this homonym of I/eye to indicate the reversibility of the positions of subject and object of the gaze. Not all subjects or ways of seeing are the same and we can ‘see’ in Gothic writing relations of gender as more conflicted or queer. This does not mean necessarily that we have to lose the definitional usefulness of male or female Gothic but just to realize that the edges are looser than have perhaps been assumed to date. I have chosen the term ‘penetrating’ to suggest how, normatively, the male gaze is understood to symbolize the sexually dominant and active position. Penetrating also works to highlight a homophobic need to uncover a ‘core’ secret in a surface-depth model of subjectivity. My discussion of the gaze draws on those who have used both a Freudian and a Lacanian reading of how the gaze works (predictably writing on film), and although I do not investigate or apply Freud or Lacan’s theories with any sustained analysis, the result is that my readings are implicitly dependent upon them.69 The first chapter considers the issue of biography and how (until perhaps very recently) queer readings of Romantic texts and figures have to a certain extent been caught up in the question of evidence over whether writers practised same-sex desire. The aim of this chapter is to argue that the existing terminology of ‘gay’, ‘homosexual’ and ‘bisexual’ is inadequate to describe their complex and elusive sexual, and erotic positions, and to argue that to find evidence does not necessarily help us make meaning out of the texts. I shift the focus away from a reading practice that ends up with one going round in paranoiac circles and speculation, to focus on how biographers are concerned to narrativize the secret of their subject’s sexual desires. This desire to find (or penetrate) evidence is always-already Gothic and mirrors the plots of Gothic stories. The chapter looks at biographies about Walpole, Beckford
20 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
and Lewis, as well as extracts from their own journals and writings not to find out if they are conclusively queer or not, but to show how secrecy, suspicion and rumour get constructed and talked about, and to ask if we can find a parallel to this in Gothic writing. In particular, this chapter looks at how a homophobic gaze is operating and where we might find this in the novels. Chapter 2 looks at the representation of masculinity and femininity in The Castle of Otranto and argues that gender is represented as hyperbolical. The excess of Manfred’s masculinity can be read in terms of how homophobia is dependent upon both misogyny and gender confusion. The novel also initiates in Gothic writing how ‘doubting’ and secrecy operate surrounding narratives of illicit sexual desires and the supernatural. This can be read queerly because they have parallels for instance with how extortion works in homophobia. Finally, I argue that the novel focuses on how the novel dramatizes the possibility for misinterpretation, for example the gaze and the voice, the supernatural for the natural. Chapter 3, on Vathek, emphasizes the suspicions attached to effeminacy in the context of how effeminacy is linked to monstrosity and luxury. Monstrosity and the demonic in Vathek can be read queerly by their links to a homophobic discourse of representing sodomitical relations as both ‘monstrous’ and ‘diabolical’. The chapter looks closely at the metaphor of translation as it becomes linked to the translation of bodies and their gendered meanings, particularly by the character of Vathek whose frustrated attempts at classification strike a queer note. Chapter 4 on The Monk argues that The Monk can be read as queercamp because it draws attention to the possibility for the misinterpretation of bodies and desires which undermines the concept of identity, particularly through the cross-dressed character of Matilda/Rosario. The disguises and reversals of gender are particularly queer, but I argue that it is also through the mismatch between signifiers and signifieds of the body, for example the voice and dress (but especially the gaze), that this occurs. The history of the representation of the male cleric as a queer in an English Protestant culture is also emphasized. The novel genders the gaze as male and then offers several instances of its reversal, particularly at moments of experiencing the supernatural. I argue that the supernatural in Gothic writing functions metaphorically for the inability to prove both an identity and sexual desire by recourse to ocular proof. I also argue that the gaze is connected to persecution. Chapter 5 on Caleb Williams focuses particularly on the gaze. Caleb Williams’s position as a feminized narrator underlies the mutual perse-
Introduction
21
cution between him and Falkland. Both Caleb and Falkland represent paranoid positions about being the object of a ‘vigilant’ gaze which inscribes the difficulty of distinguishing between, if we like, the front and the back of same-sex attraction and homophobia in the late eighteenth century. Reading the discourse of the sublime as sexualized, I argue that Caleb’s reaction to Falkland’s performance of his masculinity in sublime terms can be read in terms of erotic arousal. I also argue that Caleb’s desire for Falkland is queer because he characterizes his persecution in terms of demonic possession, and continually returns to experience the thrill of Falkland’s ‘penetrating eye’. The final chapter on Byron’s Oriental tales and Polidori’s short story The Vampyre (1819) consolidates the thematic of the book that the gaze and unspeakability represent queerness, reading Byron’s biography to show how biography is always-already Gothic and queer in fostering the idea of secrecy. In Lara and The Giaour, the narrators of both poems occupy the position of the paranoid observer who is frustrated by secretive men around whom a suspicion circulates because of a lack of knowledge. Both poems draw attention to the (mis)interpretation of looks and the meaning of the gaze, and I argue that one can read this as similar to the suspicious gaze of homophobia. The Vampyre continues such themes and initiates a long tradition of vampirism’s association with queer sexual desires. The focus of the book is specifically on what is traditionally described as the ‘male Gothic’. As indicated above, queering the Gothic necessarily questions how far the biological, essentializing implications of ‘male’ and ‘female’ accurately reflect the viewpoint that Gothic represents a reactionary strain of gender politics in Romantic writing. We can, of course, queer friendships and rivalries between men in ‘female Gothic’ and between women in ‘male Gothic’ and there may be objections as to why Frankenstein is not included in a discussion of queer relations between men here. I have deliberately chosen to exclude Mary Shelley’s novel, partly because of the wealth of readings of the novel’s gender politics, particularly from feminist perspectives, and partly because any analysis would be limited when it would be pertinent to consider other women writers like Clara Reeve, Ann Radcliffe and Charlotte Dacre. The thematics of obsession, escape and persecution, monstrosity and doubling have already been read as representing repressed same-sex desire in homosocial friendships and rivalries, even if these have yet to be described specifically as queer.70 Eric Daffron has recently implied that the narrative of Frankenstein is in effect queer, following Michael Warner’s idea that the novel is a narrative of ‘repronormativity’.71
22 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
Daffron also effectively illustrates how the relationship between the narrator Walton and Victor Frankenstein can be read as queer, devoting particular attention to instances in the novel where looking between the two men suggest the gaze as a conduit of desire and simultaneously prohibiting desire’s open expression. Daffron has already marked out ground I would have covered, but that is not to say that the readings of the gaze between men in Gothic writing by women have been exhausted. One final point on how the book queers the early Gothic. In perceiving the spectacle of gender as both hyperbolic and defensive in Gothic, I also discuss how ‘the closet’ operates. Although we cannot speak of ‘being in the closet’ in the Romantic period because being out is not an option, being doubted is, and this is strikingly visualized in Gothic writing.72 The desire to escape from locked rooms and prisons, as well as to investigate the half-open doors or distant archways with shadowy figures on the threshold: all of these motifs are metaphors for a desire to both escape from a closeting (or closing in) of identity and to open identity up, to release and simultaneously reinforce doubt. Imprisoning is a way of silencing, of preventing certain knowledge(s) from being publicized, which would destabilize sexual, class and power hierarchies. As Sedgwick argues: ‘ “Closetedness” itself is a performance initiated as such by the speech act of silence [ ] a silence that accrues particularly by fits and starts, in relation to the discourse that surrounds and differentially constructs it.’73 What I wish to do is to examine those points of silence between men. In particular I wish to examine the connection between the depiction of unspeakability as terror and the fear of others speaking about same-sex desire. The communication of knowledge in Gothic writing often centres on narratives of illicit sexual desire which are posited as terrifying and unspeakable and need to be translated. It does not in fact lead to a strengthening of identity as in the modern sense of ‘coming out’, but a symbolic fragmentation of it. Manfred’s castle is literally fragmented by lightning in The Castle of Otranto, Ambrosio’s body is mangled in The Monk, Falkland dies from his confession in Caleb Williams, Aubrey dies after seeing his tormentor in a love locket. If anything, we are left with a sense that in the Romantic period Gothic offered both a chance to come out silently through reading – reading alone by candlelight or in a group offered the chance to escape from imposed identities and sexualities – and a chance to reaffirm them through fantasy.
1 Reading the Gaze: A Culture of Vigilance
The subtitle of this chapter refers to two distinct phenomena. First, to describe the construction and practice of a homophobic gaze in the late eighteenth century as revealed through the correspondence of three of the writers under discussion here.1 And, secondly, it aims to characterize much of the biographical writing of those writers who have been subjected to this scrutinizing gaze. There is no intention to suggest that the two are necessarily linked to one another, i.e. that the biographies are explicitly or unconsciously antagonistic towards their subjects. However, what the following discussion aims to do is to draw out the structural similarities between an eighteenth-century need to watch for the signs of, for example, effeminacy, transvestism or codes of desire between men, and biographers’ methodologies of looking for evidence and writing about their subject’s sexuality as a fixed category of identity. With this in mind, I argue that instead of replicating this vigilant, scrutinizing or penetrating gaze to see what really lies beneath the surface of these subjects, and how this determines a reading their fiction, we need to look at how the biography of Gothic writers is to some degree always-already Gothic. In wanting to get to the bottom of the mystery of a writer’s sexuality, or positing it as a secret to be unveiled, the boundary between Gothic fiction and biography of Gothic writers merges. To some extent this focus on Walpole, Beckford and Lewis is an acknowledgment of how critical readings of their novels, The Castle of Otranto (1765), Vathek (1786) and The Monk (1796) have been informed and influenced by a fixation on them as ‘homosexual’ writers. My attempt is to question and redress this position by suggesting that reading them as queer can instead help us to read their novels queerly, but not in a deterministic, relational way to sexuality that closes other readings. 23
24 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
Horace Walpole In a letter to the Reverend William Cole of 9 March 1765, Horace Walpole describes his inspiration for writing the first work of British Gothic writing, The Castle of Otranto: When you read of the picture quitting its panel, did you not recollect the portrait of Lord Falkland all in white in my gallery? Shall I even confess to you what was the origin of this romance? I waked one morning in the beginning of last June from a dream, of which all I can recover was, that I had thought myself in an ancient castle (a very natural dream for a head filled like mine with Gothic story) and that on the uppermost bannister of a great staircase I saw a gigantic hand in armour. In the evening I sat down and began to write, without knowing in the least what I intended to say or relate. The work grew on my hands, and I grew fond of it—add that I was very glad to think of anything rather than politics.2 [my emphasis] Critics and biographers have taken Walpole’s confession in the above letter, that he wrote The Castle of Otranto after a dream, to support largely psychobiographical interpretations of the novel. In particular, it has been suggested Walpole’s subconscious drives and repressions can be decoded, particularly a sexual desire for men and anxieties over his perceived effeminacy and his relationship with his father, the Prime Minister Sir Robert Walpole. Significantly, Walpole describes how he sits down to write, ‘without knowing’ exactly what he would write. This acknowledged lack of intention has led biographers and critics to think of Walpole’s correspondence primarily in psychoanalytical terms, and to suggest that The Castle of Otranto is a wish-fulfillment of Walpole’s neuroses. For example in the question ‘Shall I even confess to you what was the origin of this romance?’ the hesitant tone of ‘confess’ might suggest to a psychoanalytic critic that Walpole is self-consciously exorcising through The Castle of Otranto some private, secret sin. He could, however, be playing a Catholic. However, criticism and biography whose narrative implies that there is a direct, unidirectional relationship between the writing of Walpole, Beckford, Lewis and Byron and their sexual desires invites a re-reading from a queer critical approach. Such psychoanalytical readings rest upon the premise that sexuality is a stable and essentialized category in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries when perhaps the idea of sexuality is just perhaps embryonic. These readings of the relationship
Reading the Gaze
25
between a writer’s sexuality and their fiction allow little room for how sexual desire and identification can be interpreted in more oblique ways. There is also the implication that a precondition of writing fiction which represents or encodes same-sex desire and a homoerotic/homophobic dynamics must be that the writer is ‘homosexual’ or ‘gay’. However, the personal lives of writers like Godwin, Radcliffe and Maturin elude suspicion. Nevertheless, their texts may have much to tell us about the relation between heteronormative values and what is queer about the Romantic period. To interpret Gothic writing according to a preformed idea of sexuality further reinforces the binary thinking of ‘homosexual’ or ‘heterosexual’ identity. Interpreting a genre of fiction as characteristic of a writer who is ‘homosexual’ also becomes very tricky and a limiting business. We have to ask: how does one define ‘homosexual’ in fiction of the Romantic period? Is it according to thematics, a pre-existing sensibility, the writers’ or readers’ response? The limits and gaps that this term implies, and what it leaves unsaid or unarticulated needs to be addressed. In essence, what is queer about ‘homosexual’? Speculation about Walpole’s sexual life and his desires has always existed. His interests, mannerisms and social activities, such as dressing up as women at masquerades, invited comment from a variety of observers. The diarist and friend of Samuel Johnson, Hester Lynch Thrale (later Mrs Piozzi), believed Walpole and his friend John Chute to be effeminate and, thus in her eyes, suspicious. Walpole appeared to represent a gender enigma that excited contempt, especially in nineteenth-century male critics of his work and personality. Behind the enigma and mystery of a great eighteenth-century personality who never married lurked the suspicion that Walpole had secret sexual desires for men. Coleridge, writing in 1834, condemns Walpole’s fiction suggesting that there is a link between his work and Walpole’s perceived effeminacy: ‘the “Mysterious Mother” is the most disgusting, vile, detestable composition that ever came from the hand of man. No one with a spark of true manliness, of which Horace Walpole had none, could have written it.’3 Thomas Babington Macaulay speaks of Walpole in terms of disease, as possessing ‘an unhealthy and disorganized mind’. He characterizes him in terms that in the early nineteenth century had connotations with effeminacy and dandyism such as ‘eccentric’, ‘artificial’, ‘fastidious’ and ‘capricious’ and how ‘his features were covered by a mask within a mask’.4 The ‘real’ Walpole was only a superficial surface, there was always a secret hidden self to be seen through. The inability to authenticate Walpole’s masculinity, the possibility that Walpole’s effeminacy might signify same-sex desire that could be neither
26 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
openly affirmed nor positively denied infuriated Walpole’s enemies and detractors. Walpole could be referred to as an ‘effeminate’ or a third gender like Lady Mary Wortley Montague’s friend, the poet John Hervey, or ‘Sporus’ as he was dubbed by Alexander Pope. But he could not be openly accused as either a sodomite or a pathic (a passive sexual partner), in a court of law at least, without witnesses. Nevertheless, Walpole continues to be described in terms that close down any complexity, sexual or otherwise. For instance, Timothy Mowl describes Walpole as ‘a homosexual who consorted with other homosexuals and bisexuals of his class’.5 He suggests that earlier biographies obscure the image of Walpole to suggest that he was asexual; in fact the reading of Walpole as asexual reinforces Walpole’s queerness if we want to understand asexualism as a refusal of a sociological imperative to be heterosexual, straight or just sexual.6 Walpole’s sexuality is a secret that needs to be exposed or ‘outed’ through scrutinizing his letters. Mowl refers to Walpole’s correspondence as a source of evidence indicating that Walpole had strongly developed erotic relationships with other men that can be described as ‘homosexual’. These relationships which are explored were principally with the poet Thomas Gray both at Eton and on the Grand Tour in the early 1740s, with his cousin and MP Henry Seymour Conway, and with Lord Lincoln (later the second Duke of Newcastle). Raymond Bentham takes the view that ‘Walpole’s biographers have been unanimous in their claim that he was emotionally distant’.7 He seeks to counter this claim by examining Walpole’s letters to Lord Lincoln and argues that the expressions of love in these letters reveal a mutual, coded expression of sexual desire between the two of them. Bentham also suggests that in letters to Walpole’s other friends there are jokes, comments and innuendos about the male body, particularly the penis.8 He argues: ‘Walpole was, I believe, a man of powerful but usually suppressed feelings, which he concealed because he was sexually and romantically attracted to men’ (276). He suggests that in The Castle of Otranto Walpole deliberately tried to ‘create a kind of fiction that will use metaphor and symbol to describe darker passions, ones not easily spoken about openly’ (283). However the suggestion that Walpole relies on metaphor and symbol veers dangerously close to the Intentional Fallacy and a Freudian reading.9 Instead George Haggerty argues convincingly that Walpole’s letters self-consciously exploit a culture’s desire for a secret truth: ‘The Walpole that emerges in his letters is constructed so as to exploit the assumption that there must be something beneath the surface.’10
Reading the Gaze
27
The desire to find secrets is one defining narrative characteristic of the Gothic. Haggerty suggests for example that Walpole’s professions of love for Lincoln and Conway are deliberately manipulative. Walpole ‘wears the mask of truth itself’ in order to deflect attention away from the possibility that what can be read as platonically affectionate may really be expressive of erotic desire.11 Nevertheless, we have to remember who the recipients of these letters were and that they were meant to be read in private. However, one still has to remember that it would have been dangerous for men to communicate their sexual desire for one another frankly in print, no matter how discreet they believed they or their recipients were. It is more than likely that many love letters between men in this period were either burnt after being read or simply destroyed by later family generations susceptible to paranoia about reputation. Nevertheless, Haggerty’s approach is the most sensitive to articulating the complexity of reading Walpole through his correspondence; he argues that critics ‘are asking the wrong question entirely’.12 One aspect of the reading of Walpole’s letters which has suggestive implications for how the secret becomes circulated and exchanged in Gothic writing (what we might call its economy) is how Walpole’s letters are attuned to reading and misreading the body. In a letter to his friend Henry Montague, there is a description by Walpole of his observation of the covert body language of the Duke of Newcastle, Lord Pelham (Lord Lincoln’s father), who tried to prevent Walpole’s friendship with Lord Lincoln while on the Grand Tour in Italy: ‘From thence he went into the hazard room, and wriggled, and shuffled, and lisped and winked and spied, till he got behind the Duke of Cumberland, the Duke of Bedford and Rigby; the first of whom did not deign to take notice of him’ (Lewis, vol. 9, p. 232). What is revealing here are the observations about Pelham’s means of getting near to these men and his winking, which Walpole observes as a means of silently communicating his intentions. Walpole is also in the position of an onlooker, observing small details which others are oblivious to. A wealth of information on eighteenth-century social life and politics, Walpole’s letters often point to a heightened awareness of the ridiculous in social situations, a quirky humour and a tone of eccentric frivolity. One might be tempted to term Walpole’s style as ‘camp’. However, one must be careful when using this term. A predisposition to irony and a love of innuendo and theatricality do not therefore prove Walpole to be ‘homosexual’ in the way that Mowl seems to imply. These traits of style and personality can be just as expressive of a ‘heterosexual’ sensibility as well as a trait of an aristocratic hypersensitivity to matters of style and taste.
28 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
Instead of seeking out evidence to prove that Walpole is ‘homosexual’, his correspondence gives us an insight into how Walpole is aware that gender is constructed and perceived by others as always variable. In a letter to his cousin Seymour Conway at the time of Conway’s impending marriage to Lady Caroline Fitzroy (which Walpole opposed) he reveals a concern about how others perceive his masculinity: ‘I am sensible of having more follies and weaknesses and fewer real good qualities than most men. I sometimes reflect on this, though I own too seldom. I always want to begin acting like a man and a sensible one, which I think I might be if I would’ (Lewis, vol. 37, p. 170) [my emphasis]. The wish to be ‘acting like a man’ is significant for suggesting that Walpole understood that gender was a construct, not an essential given of ‘reality’. Masculinity can be performed in a theatrical sense, perhaps for the purposes of disguise. His letter to Conway, when the latter was dismissed from parliament in 1764, highlights again how he conceives of his gender in terms of performativity: I am come hither alone to put my thoughts into some order, and to avoid showing the first sallies of my resentment, which I know you would disapprove [ ] My anger shall be a little more manly, and the plan of my revenge a little deeper laid than in peevish bon-mots. (Lewis, vol. 37, p. 170) [my emphasis] At this time the source of his anxiety resided in the vociferous and public attack made on Walpole by the political writer William Guthrie after the dismissal of Conway from Parliament, in a pamphlet entitled Reply to the Counter Address.13 Guthrie’s pamphlet focuses principally on the ambiguity of Walpole’s gender, and throughout the defence Walpole is positioned as effeminate. He is ‘delicate’ and possesses ‘a most ladylike form of speaking’ as well as being Conway’s ‘very loving defender’ (p. 10). However Guthrie is finally unable to determine Walpole’s gender, ‘a being between both’ implying, as the poet Alexander Pope did with Lord John Hervey ‘Sporus’ earlier in the century, that Walpole is a ‘third sex’: there is a weakness and an effeminacy in it, which seems to burlesque even calumny itself. The complexion of the malice, the feeble tone of the expression, and the passionate fondness with which the personal qualities of the officer in question are continually dwelt on, would tempt one to imagine, that this arrow came forth from a female quiver; but as it wants both the true delicacy and lively imagination
Reading the Gaze
29
which characterizes a lady’s pen, the attack must probably have been made from a neutral quarter, from a being between both, neither totally male or female [ ] so halting between the two that it would very much puzzle a common observer to assign to him his true sex. (pp. 6–7) The ‘common observer’, presumably the general public, would be confused by the signs or tone of the writing. Guthrie’s homophobic attack on Walpole contains a potential affirmative reading. In Guthrie’s perception that Walpole’s gender resists alignment to one sex or the other, Walpole is queer in that he confuses the boundaries between masculinity and femininity. The predominant intention of the pamphlet is to expose a belief in Walpole’s desire for Conway. In the twenty-first century, the term ‘outing’ is associated with gay political activists who declare a knowledge of closeted same-sex behaviour in socially prominent public figures who, usually, represent an institutionalized politics that devalues gay sexuality and affirms heteronormative values and practices like family, marriage or parenting. Guthrie is not trying to expose Walpole’s hypocrisy, which would presuppose that he had evidence of Walpole’s sexual behaviour. ‘Outing’ therefore seems an inappropriate term to apply to the pamphlet’s effect. Instead, Guthrie is deploying a subtle homophobic strategy that I prefer to call ‘doubting’ – openly fostering suspicion and rumour about a person’s sexual life, suggesting there is a secret, without openly stating so. In the readings that follow, I will show that Gothic writing moves towards the exposure of the secret of an influential or powerful individual that plays with a character’s or reader’s doubts over the interpretation of secrets as sexual secrets. Guthrie’s attack also shows how Walpole’s body is suspiciously queer, described in terms which oppose it to a discourse which figures the masculine in terms of the sublime. It is significant that as a political speaker who has been trained in the art of rhetoric and gesture to powerfully overwhelm and manipulate his opponent, Guthrie attacks Walpole on the grounds of his style, ‘the feeble tone of expression’. Guthrie here could be referring quite equally to Walpole’s speech, as much as his writing style.14 Guthrie’s Reply to the Counter Address is important for showing how homophobia in the eighteenth century is constructed through the prism of gender relations, particularly the attack on Walpole as effeminate. It underscores how implicit or explicit misogyny is sometimes linked to effeminophobia and the spectre of same-sex desire that lies behind the veil. Walpole’s sexuality is constructed as suspicious by his
30 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
contemporaries and fuels a critical desire to separate truth from falsity, fact from fiction, heterosexual from homosexual. Even if Walpole was unnerved by Guthrie’s arousal of public interest in his sexual outlook, it is still not possible (or critically desirable) to say with any certainty that the fear of exposure of identity in the novel refers directly to Walpole’s experiences. Instead, there exists a cultural need for enjoying the spectacle in Gothic writing of the working through of a knowledge of a secret that reflects any number of societal anxieties, for example about power and class as much as sexual desires. With some notable exceptions, existing criticism shows the continuing power of rumour, suspicion and the need to verify sexual identities. What Gothic writing allows us to see is how a narrative of rumour and gossip about secrets (especially sexualized secrets) shows that there is a subtler form of homophobia operating in Regency England than the regulation of sodomy via a spectacle of punishment in the pillory.
William Beckford While on a tour of England’s country houses in 1779, William Beckford met William Courtenay (3rd Viscount, later 9th Earl of Devon) at Powderham Castle. Beckford fell instantly in love with Courtenay. In his letters to his cousin’s first wife, Louisa Beckford, he nicknamed Courtenay ‘Kitty’, describing his frustration at his separation from ‘her’. In 1785 Beckford went to stay at Powderham Castle with his wife Margaret. A few weeks after the Beckfords had left Powderham, Lord Loughborough, Courtenay’s uncle, accused Beckford of an indiscretion with Courtenay although he had no witnesses to provide evidence in a court of law. As Brian Fothergill, one of Beckford’s biographers, argues: ‘Loughborough hoped to catch his victim in some compromising situation and later spread the rumour that this in fact happened, that Beckford had been caught in Courtenay’s bedroom in circumstances that offered no reasonable explanation. But did such an episode occur?’15 Loughborough then instigated a press campaign against Beckford, which caused him to go abroad. While waiting at Dover for the weather to turn favourable to cross the Channel, Beckford decided to return to his home, the magnificent mock-Gothic abbey he had built, Fonthill Abbey, in Wiltshire. Fothergill interprets this return as Beckford’s confidence in his own innocence if a charge of sodomy was to be brought against him. Beckford then left the country a year later, intending originally to go to his father’s plantation in Jamaica, but travelling to Portugal. Beckford was never openly accused or charged with sodomy; one of
Reading the Gaze
31
his earliest biographer’s observations is therefore still valid: ‘no serious charge brought against him has any foundation stronger than gossip’.16 Despite the degree to which suspicion determined Beckford’s departure for Portugal and Jamaica, he still cannot elude the culture of vigilance that continues today in attempts to reconcile the ‘facts’ of his life and personality with his writing. There are lines of continuity with his detractors. The eighteenth-century diarist and writer, Hester Lynch Thrale (later Mrs Piozzi), suggests that the story of Vathek and its characterization is a transparent allegory of Beckford’s personality and supposed sexual desires: Mr Beckford’s favourite propensity is all along visible I think; particularly in the luscious descriptions given of Gulchenrouz: but his Quarantine seems to be performed and I am told he is return’d quietly to Fonthill. When we were at Milan Mr Bisset brought over the news how he was hooted from Society by my Lord Loughborough, who threatened corporal or legal Punishment for Mr Beckford’s Violation of young Courtenay [ ] no Englishman would exchange a word with the Creature; and charming Doctor Fisher’s charitable Heart pitied his wretched exclusion from the World. But since Courtenay came to his Estate and Title, and I suppose treated the whole Business as a Joke, or common Occurrence, all is over; and I hear nothing said of Mr Beckford but as an Author. What a world it is!!!!17 [my emphasis] Thrale’s judgement on Beckford reveals several important issues. First, her use of ‘Quarantine’ implies that same-sex desire is constructed in terms of disease and contagion, and that Beckford is excluded from polite society. Secondly, the practice of same-sex desire is connected to xenophobia because ‘no Englishman’ speaks to Beckford. And lastly, that there existed a conflicting opinions surrounding Beckford’s relation to Vathek. Thrale’s shock arises from how Beckford’s social status as a suspected sodomite remains distinct from his identity as an author, as she perceives Vathek to express his sexual desires for young men in the comment: ‘the luscious Descriptions given of Gulchenrouz’. This approach to Beckford is still current in contemporary critical writing that specifically perceives Vathek as an expression of Beckford’s guilt over his same-sex desire. However, the founding basis for this argument – that Beckford had sodomitical relationships – cannot be proven. It remains open to speculation whether or not Beckford fulfilled his
32 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
desire for Courtenay or other young men like Gregorio Franchi. Nor is it possible to verify with any certainty that Beckford’s insinuations of spiritual suffering and persecution (for example his prayers to his patron saint, Saint Anthony, in his correspondence) are anything more than an attraction to the performativity of Catholicism.18 Vathek provides a series of instances where queer subjectivity challenges a particular kind of ‘heterosexual’ hyperbolic masculinity in the character of Vathek. At the same time it also constructs queer sexual practice and desire as evil. But whether it encodes (as I will show critics claim) any emotional guilt and fear of punishment for same-sex behaviour is difficult to reconcile with the strong possibility that Beckford would follow his friend’s advice (Lady Hamilton) to ‘keep a perpetual watch’ over himself.19 Would Beckford write so openly about his own personal relationships, thereby fuelling the suspicion about him? Possibly, but unlikely. However, biographers and critics remain undeterred from referring to Beckford’s sexuality in solidified terms, namely as a ‘homosexual’ or a ‘bisexual’. Brian Fothergill for instance, although arguing that Beckford never expressed his desires physically for Courtenay, describes and characterizes Beckford as ‘bisexual’ (p. 93). Fothergill interprets the character of Vathek as a strongly autobiographical portrait: Here the characters of Vathek and Gulchenrouz have become fused to represent the two unreconcilable aspects of Beckford’s own personality: the temperament flawed (as he still saw it) by homosexual and other ‘wayward’ passions which threatened to make him an outcast from society, and the irrepressible longing to regain the lost innocence of childhood. (p. 133) Fothergill suggests that when Beckford met Courtenay again in 1785, he thought Courtenay had grown more effeminate: ‘The boy had physically outgrown his former persona, the androgynous qualities which appealed so strongly to Beckford and had inspired the character of the boy-girl Gulchenrouz in Vathek.’20 Ignoring for the moment the suggestion that Beckford intentionally modelled Gulchenrouz on Courtenay, the inference one can draw from Fothergill’s argument is that the younger Courtenay represented a queer body in his androgyny, rather than the elder Courtenay who was hardening into a specific social type that could be identified by his effeminacy. An implicit sense of a hierarchy or pecking order of sexuality emerges that devalues certain positions above others: ‘Beckford was not a homosexual, he was a confident, active, self-aware bisexual, and that is a much richer and
Reading the Gaze
33
more confusing condition.’21 Why being bisexual rather than ‘homosexual’ ‘is more confusing’ or ‘richer’ is never explained and implies a normativizing position. The reader later infers that Mowl is not really certain himself as to how he should label Beckford. Confusingly he comments: ‘Not many people these days strike attitudes about homosexuals, but paedophilia remains another thing – an area grey to the point of sooty blackness. The relationship between the two Williams was soon to become actively and physically paedophiliac’ (Mowl, p. 107). Is Beckford ‘bisexual, ‘homosexual’ or a ‘paedophile’? Paedophile seems an inflammatory and inaccurate judgement of Beckford and Courtenay’s relationship. George E. Haggerty reformulates Beckford’s sexuality to indicate a new type of male sexuality in the late eighteenth century – the paederast. But there is still some difficulty in stabilizing Beckford’s sexual desires in this way.22 However, Haggerty is attuned to the complexity of Beckford’s sexual desire. Paederasty does not imply sodomy but refers to ‘boylove’ in the tradition of Greek literary culture. Analysing the attack on Beckford and Courtenay in the newspaper, The Morning Herald, as a ‘pair of fashionable male lovers’, Haggerty argues that the description of ‘lover’ does not conform to a prevailing discourse of sodomy: ‘In fact, it articulates the possibility of a male relation that is rare in the eighteenth century, suggesting in its turn of phrase something more like our own configuration of relational possibilities.’23 The figure of the lover opens up a more positive and queerer understanding of Beckford. Beckford becomes queer if he is seen as appropriating the conventions (and arguably poses) of Romantic sensibility and love, the cultural preserves of ‘heterosexual’ desire. In a letter dated 1 July 1782 which Haggerty quotes, Beckford’s romantic attitude towards Courtenay is evident in the pastoralism of the scene and Beckford’s imaginative fancy: I often dream after a solitary ramble on the dreary plains near Rome, that I am sitting with you in a meadow at Ford on a summer’s evening, my arm thrown round your neck. I seem to see the wilds beyond the House and the Cattle winding slowly along them. I even fancy, I hear your voice singing one of the tunes I composed when I was in Devonshire. Whilst thus engaged and giving way to languid melancholy tenderness, two snakes start from the hedge and twine round us. I see your face turn pale and your limbs tremble. I seem to press you closely in my arms. We both feel the cold writhing of the Snakes in our bosoms, both join our lips for the last time and expire.24
34 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
Beckford’s dream evokes a conventional pastoral landscape as found for example in the poetry of Thomas Gray, in for instance Elegy in a Country Churchyard or in the paintings of the seventeenth-century French painter Claude Lorrain, of which Beckford owned some originals. The Edenic scene is shattered by the snakes which are associated with Beckford and Courtenay’s bodies. Beckford interpreted the snakes as being Courtenay’s father and aunt; however the snake is also symbolic of Satan, evoking the idea of corruption through a knowledge of sexual desire. Haggerty comments: they also represent the destructive power of desire to corrupt the pure love that Beckford constantly tries to articulate when talking to the boy. It is as if he is saying that the destruction of their love is present in its very constitution.25 Haggerty argues therefore that Beckford experiences a kind of internalized homophobia about his desire: ‘internalised self-hatred seems increasingly to haunt Beckford’s paederasty [ ] desire implies death, brings the threat of death, becomes almost a desire for death as Beckford’s culture had taught him all too well’.26 But in the abovequoted passage, Beckford also indulges in ‘languid melancholy’ in a scene that could be found in any novel of Sensibility. Although not quite a Marianne Dashwood (in Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility, 1811), here Beckford seems to consciously appropriate those conventions of feeling that Austen feared. By expressing same-sex desire in images and figures drawn from the tropes of the culture of Sensibility – such as the mutual appreciation of natural beauty inspiring love, and bodily signs indicating overwhelming feelings, like blushing or gazing, Beckford frustrates an understanding of his sexual desire solely in terms of physical acts like sodomy. ‘Queer’ describes the emotional complexity of Beckford’s sexual desires without limiting Beckford to an identifiable type of sexuality. Beckford represents a more individualist position that has resonances with a contemporary understanding of queer. His plea to Charlotte Courtenay, William’s aunt (later Lord Loughborough’s wife), pressing her to ask Courtenay to respond to his letters, reveals this individualism: ‘Of all the human creatures, male or female with which I have been acquainted in various countries and at different periods he is the only one that seems to have been cast in my mold’ [my emphasis].27 What is noticeable here about Beckford’s phrase (apart from its implicit arrogance) is the claim for a kind of individuality that Courtenay and
Reading the Gaze
35
he possess. Neither of them will fit into any preformed social mould that would define them by sexual practice or even gender. Beckford seemed to recognize that his emotional and sexual desires were complicated when he commented: ‘Am I not the strangest of Beings?’ (Melville, p. 78). Another argument (perhaps even the strongest) for describing Beckford as queer is that Beckford was married. His marriage to Lady Margaret Gordon in 1783 was arranged by his mother and aunt, and although it appears to have been a conventional eighteenth-century marriage of social convenience, Beckford does claim to love his wife and his two children. He also flirted with women while travelling abroad and possibly had an affair with his cousin’s wife, Louisa Beckford. It is all too easy to categorize him as a repressed ‘homosexual’ or as a ‘bisexual’ – the latter term in particular seems to imply a self-conscious choice of sexual partners which sits awkwardly with Beckford’s romantic approach to love and desire. The uncertainty surrounding Beckford is also compounded by the inability to determine exactly which letters (or parts of the letters) in Beckford’s correspondence are invented or reveries. The reason for questioning whether Beckford’s descriptions of his feelings and thoughts are genuine stems from Guy Chapman’s argument that many of the letters Beckford wrote between 1777 and 1791 were copied out in a red leather copybook much later in his life, and that the originals were destroyed or are without trace (Chapman, p. 323). Chapman focuses on how Louisa Beckford’s replies to Beckford contain tonal variations to the letters allegedly sent by Beckford. There are also factual inconsistencies in Beckford’s letters compared to Horace Walpole’s correspondence. He concludes therefore that: the fabricator was ‘none other than William Beckford himself’ (p. 323). Chapman notes that lines and passages referring to Courtenay or ‘Kitty’ are obliterated in the letters Beckford copied out himself. He argues: ‘It is not a case of concealment; for many letters in the book refer quite openly to William Courtenay’ (p. 341). If, as Beckford claimed, Lord Loughborough possessed letters that Beckford had written to Courtenay, which he threatened would prove his accusation, one can understand Beckford’s need to change the originals. Again the search for evidence to verify Beckford’s sexual identity surfaces in Chapman’s account, and biography seems to shade into Gothic conventions. For instance, there are no surviving letters from the painter Alexander Cozens, Beckford’s drawing master, among Beckford’s papers: ‘Everything connected with Cozens, save Beckford’s own letters, has been destroyed, although letters from everyone else with whom Beckford was at all connected have been preserved, even from
36 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
William Courtenay [ ] What is the reason?’ (p. 343). Cozens died in 1786. Legally, Beckford would have been obliged to return any of Cozens’s correspondence to his son, John Robert Cozens. Chapman comments: ‘We can only conclude that there was something in Cozens’ letters which Beckford preferred should not be known’ (p. 343). Had Cozens penetrated the veil of romantic sensibility Beckford used to express his love for Courtenay? Perhaps Cozens was too candid with Beckford in a language that Beckford felt revealed too visibly the nature of his desire. One is led back into a Gothic web of searching in the closet with a candle. We must, therefore, be careful of interpreting Beckford’s attitude towards his sexual desire from a reading of his correspondence, and then projecting this onto Vathek. However, this is not to argue that all of Beckford’s correspondence or his recipients’ have no heuristic value in thinking about how Beckford’s desire is queer. Mowl argues casually that Beckford ‘forged his own life’ and that his letters, particularly to Courtenay and Cozens, are deliberately rewritten and influenced by the cult of Sensibility (Mowl, p. 1). Guy Chapman does not account for the important letter of Lady Hamilton that strongly points towards Beckford discussing his erotic attachment to Courtenay, Conaro and others quite candidly. I am not arguing that Beckford did not practise a certain kind of selffashioning and invention in his letters – clearly he did, and in a way that has fuelled psychobiographical criticism. For example in a draft of a letter, which Chapman cannot verify as having been sent, Beckford seems to apply the conventions of his own Gothic writing to his life: How is poor Ly. [sic] Charlotte? I should be very sorry if she was doomed so young to descend into the cold dark regions. And yet I should be disposed to let myself down into them were some phantom in the shape of Loughborough to scream in my ears – I have strangled Louisa and shut Wm. Up in an inaccessible tower with fifty concubines. (Chapman, p. 172) Beckford emphasizes a sense of persecution by Loughborough that positions Loughborough as a Gothic tyrant not dissimilar to his character of Vathek. In an unaddressed letter, probably either to his wife’s cousin, Louisa Beckford, or to Cozens written at Spa in the Netherlands in 1780, Beckford describes himself as persecuted and tormented by his ‘wayward love’:
Reading the Gaze
37
Would to God the memorable Fountains of Merlin were still attainable – I might then be happy with the hopes of forgetting a passion which preys upon my soul [ ] This wayward Love of mine makes me insensible to everything [ ] but it is in vain it pursues me – pursues me with such swiftness! seizes upon me and marks me for its own. (Melville, p. 91) Perhaps in those letters which were copied out later, Beckford selfconsciously plays up the suspicion about his sexual desires through alluding to his novel Vathek. He had after all written the novel in French and did not wish for an English translation, perhaps in a gesture of pique at society’s rejection of him. Beckford’s correspondence though provides an insight into how Beckford’s sexual desire as a stabilized category of sexuality is problematic. However, it is also obvious by the replies of his friend, Lady Hamilton, that Beckford did indeed openly discuss his sexual desires for young men and did not always feel the need to appropriate a language of romantic love to express his feelings. Lady Hamilton foresaw that Beckford would have to act very discreetly to preserve his reputation and warns him against physical intimacy: For Heaven’s sake keep a perpetual watch over yourself or you will still be a lost man. Let not a word escape you that the World may take hold of. You are so exposed to envy from your situation, but above all from those talents and parts of which Nature has been so lavish to you, that you will find it more necessary than any one [sic] to be upon your guard. If you are not, I repeat your reputation will be lost for ever, lost never never to be regained [ ] remember the Manly Energetic Hector is my Hero, not the furious Achilles, sacrificing every consideration to the violence of his passions [ ] May you be a true Hero in getting the better of every sensation which is not consistent with true honour and principle and which (if indulged) must in the end make you miserable. (Oliver, pp. 68–69) Beckford acknowledged to Cozens that he took Lady Hamilton’s advice seriously. Her letters to him were his ‘finest rule of conduct’ (Chapman, p. 83). The classical allusions to different models of masculinity point towards a defence of the expression of his desire. Beckford’s awareness of the homoerotic possibilities of the military comradeship between
38 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
Achilles and Patroclus in Homer’s The Illiad is suggested in his response to Lady Hamilton: ‘I am vain enough to imagine I should make you less averse to Achilles. Hector is doubtless more amiable but what feeling breast can refrain to sigh with the young Grecian and his agonising on the shore after the murder of Patroclus’ (Melville, p. 114). Lady Hamilton’s reply also underscores how the queer subject’s fear of being observed and watched works from the perspective of institutionalized homophobia. In a letter to the Contessa D’Orsini Rosenberg, Beckford refers to the classical image of the Argus, a monster with a hundred eyes that the Roman Goddess Juno employs to watch Io, her rival for Jupiter’s love. Beckford uses the allusion to describe both his relations and the society surrounding him: From the theatre, I take him to my bed. Nature, Virtue, Glory all disappear – entirely lost, confused, destroyed. O, heavens, that I could die in these kisses and plunge my soul with his into the happiness or the pain which must never end [ ] Do you know of a state more frightening than this which I suffer – spied upon by a thousand Arguses without hearts and without ears, constrained to abandon the unique hope that reconciles me to life, menaced at each instant, accused of the ruin of a being I adore in whom all human affections are concentrated to a point.28 The image of the Arguses watching him signals how the act of looking and gazing between men to express desire is always potentially dangerous because they are observed by spying eyes. Several references to Courtenay throughout Beckford’s correspondence discuss him in terms of looking. Writing to Louisa, Beckford comments: ‘Today it talked of languid glances – looked them – till I grew quite intoxicated’ (Chapman, p. 151). But again Beckford’s fear of exposure is framed within a metaphor of the gaze: ‘Scrag and Phemy are outrageous. They have moved Heaven and Hell to alarm L. [Loughborough] but as yet some Daemon spreads a thick film over his eyes – and prevents him seeing a conflagration which every duty calls him to extinguish’ (Chapman, p. 151). Scrag and Phemy remain unidentified. The ‘L.’ could equally refer to Lord Loughborough or to Lord Courtenay, William’s father. In A View of Society and Manners in High and Low Life (1781), the writer Madge Culls suspects that men and soldiers cruising in St James’s Park use their bodies to communicate with each other while the casual bystander is blindly oblivious to the meanings such signals indicate: ‘These wretches have many ways and means of conveying intelligence, and many signals
Reading the Gaze
39
by which they discover themselves to each other.’29 Madge Culls then proceeds to give an example of the use of handkerchiefs – but presumably these signals could also include the use of the eyes and the gaze to signal desire – indicating that there existed a climate in Georgian Britain in which men were scrupulously watched and observed. The paranoia about the gaze finds a parallel of the fear of being watched in Gothic writing: By means of these signals they retire to satisfy a passion too horrible for description, too detestable for language; a passion which deserves the punishment not of the law only, but an exclusion from Society [sic] on the most light glance of just suspicion of it.30 [my emphasis] The gaze and the glance are both instrumental to homophobia in the late eighteenth century and is one of the ways in which men can signal desire for one another. Even if we cannot verify the authenticity of the above letter to Louisa about Courtenay, it has interesting implications for how Beckford describes a supernatural agency intervening to obscure Lord Loughborough’s, ‘L’, perception. This occurs in Vathek with Vathek blindly following the commands of the Giaour. The ignorance of being watched over by a higher uncontrollable or undefined power which leads to the subject’s destruction works as a metaphor for a culture eager to police gender boundaries and illicit desire. The novel’s narrative of seeing how others make mistakes that lead to a terrible punishment can be read alongside how those men who loved one another needed to self-regulate the language of love to avoid suspicion from the moral Arguses of society who would condemn them to the pillory, or worse.
Matthew Lewis With Matthew Lewis, writer of the infamously popular The Monk (1796), there has been a tendency to either ignore Lewis’s sexuality or discuss him within the anachronism of ‘homosexuality’. Discussion of Lewis’s private life brings into play the accusation that there is an element of paranoia, i.e. the fear that every text might contain a potential queer reading.31 The objection that is levelled at readers performing paranoid readings is that such readings are seeing something more in the text than there is evidence or grounds for justification. Again, interpretation becomes a matter of visibility and invisibility. Queer critics are seeing things that are not apparent (apparitional?) to other critics. Refutations and confirmations of ‘paranoid’ readings hinge on referring back to an
40 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
argument centred on proving by evidence that a writer did or did not experience same-sex desire and therefore can or cannot be described as ‘homosexual’: On the other hand, the statement that Lewis was homosexual, while it would require for confirmation more convincing evidence than has been presented, is impossible to confirm or disprove. Moreover, the term is popularly used to cover such a wide range of phenomena, from the mere enjoyment of the company of one’s own sex to the most appalling abnormalities, that a biographer who applies it to his subject would seem to need a careful definition of what he means, to say nothing of strong evidence. To publish the statement with such assurance was rather a pity, because since its appearance it has become fashionable to add piquancy to accounts of Lewis by describing him as sexually abnormal. (Peck, p. 66) [my emphasis] It is clear that Peck is circumscribed by his own normative values about same-sex desire when he was writing in 1961, in a pre-Stonewall era of repression. The flexibility Peck suggests resides in the term ‘homosexual’ is, more accurately, present in the term ‘queer’ which wishes to move away from an idea of sexuality as a fixed identity. The sexuality of Lewis cannot, in fact, be defined as sexuality, as a visible social identity that others recognized him by, as it was for late nineteenth-century writers such as Oscar Wilde. Peck tells us that as a young boy, Lewis used to cross-dress: ‘He delighted to dress himself in whatever of his mother’s jewelry and gaudy clothing he could find and parade before a mirror, a foreshadowing, perhaps of the lavish display of costume in his melodramas’ (Peck, p. 4). Or perhaps a foreshadowing of something more unspeakably queer which Peck does not wish to confront? Or are we seeing a ghost of transvestism that is not really there? The accusation of performing a paranoid reading is upped if queer criticism becomes too fixated on the question of biographical evidence, especially according to the theory that ‘paranoia is drawn towards and tends to construct symmetrical relations, and in particular symmetrical epistemologies’.32 One example of these ‘symmetrical epistemologies’ (epistemology being a philosophy of how we possess knowledge and what we do with it) is in lining up a writer’s life or personality with their writing. Even if we suspect that Lewis had same-sex relations, where does this take or advance our reading of The Monk, if we can prove or disprove, once and for always, what we had already known all along?
Reading the Gaze
41
D. L. MacDonald has recently rewritten Lewis’s biography, paying significant attention to his sexuality. He also notes the factual inaccuracies of Montague Summers’ romantic construction of Lewis as ‘homosexual’, pointing out Summers’ romantic interpretation of Lewis’s correspondence. MacDonald’s argument is that ‘The evidence suggests that he was attracted to men, but that he thought of these attachments as (in Louis Crompton’s terms) romantic friendships rather than love affairs or (in Eve Kosofsky’s Sedgwick’s terms) as homosocial rather than “homosexual”.’33 However, this argument seems to conflict with MacDonald’s use of ‘homosexuality’. For example, discussing the anecdote by Margaret Baron-Wilson’s of Lewis cross-dressing as a young boy, he comments: ‘Lewis’s culture seems to have associated homosexuality with cross-dressing and transexuality even more insistently than ours does’ (MacDonald, p. 69). MacDonald quotes a letter from William Lamb to his mother in 1800 about Lewis: ‘He might be pleasant enough if he were not always upon the strain [ ] I hear he intends proposing to Emily Stratford [ ] She will make him shed more tears and look more doleful in assembly rooms than ever I did’ (MacDonald, p. 64). MacDonald argues that this proves that Lamb thought of the ‘homosocial and the homosexual as essentially continuous’ (MacDonald, p. 68). The continuum of male relations and relationships does not make it easy to know or see queer desire. The late nineteenth-century definition of ‘homosexuality’ as a socially recognisable and pathologized identity had not arrived yet. However, ‘homosexual’ and ‘homosocial’ are used as distinctive terms when he argues that the poems Lewis sent to Lord Holland from Inverary Castle in 1807 ‘touch more or less lightly, on homosexual or homosocial themes’ (MacDonald, p. 70) [my emphasis]. In the preface to another poem, ‘St Anthony the Second’, Lewis describes the inspiration for a poem about sexual temptation. At dinner one evening he praised a pie on the table and as a result: ‘the Ladies drest up a female figure [ ] with the intention of placing both that and the Pye in my bed’. I listened looked and longed; By turns surveyed Now the Goose-pye, and now each white-robed Maid. Now hunger led me tow’rds the savoury Pye, But the fair Nymphs recalled me with a sigh: Now leaving That, I hastened towards Those; But then the Pasty caught me by the nose! Less strongly tempted Grandsire Adam fell; Eve bought him with a hard raw Non-pareil;
42 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
More powerful bribes did Satan here produce; My Eves were three, and seasoned was the Goose. (MacDonald, p. 71) MacDonald focuses on how Lewis’s gender becomes ambiguous by his reference to himself as ‘Calista-like’ and adopting feminine poses. He argues that eating is connected to ‘an infantile orality’ which is, in turn, ‘associated with homosexuality, either directly or through the common association with childishness’ (MacDonald, p. 72). If the pie represents a symbol for same-sex desire, it also represents a choice. And what appears most strongly is the oscillation between the choice of an oral pleasure and the choice of a pleasure of intercourse with the virginal ‘white-robed Maids’. Desire extends in both directions but as the choice of temptation is left inconclusive, it cannot strictly be read as ‘homosexual’. Rather it inscribes desire as queer in suggesting a variety of possibilities and positions. Lewis’s interest in the companionship of men younger than himself could simply be a pleasure in the company of the young, reflecting Sir Walter Scott’s observation of his ‘boyishness’ (Peck, p. 51). Or possibly, it could refer to a homoerotic interest in young men. There is also the possibility that Lewis is queer because he is asexual and unattractive to women. MacDonald quotes from the satirist Susan Wilcock who describes Lewis’s lack of manliness. What is most interesting however (in terms of the gender performance of The Monk) is the implication that Lewis may have consciously been playing it straight. He may have adopted the role of the seducer for instance as a kind of straight performativity, as a means of averting any suspicion away from accusations of same-sex desire. The Prince Regent’s wife, Caroline, recognized the artifice of Lewis in a letter to her lady-in-waiting, Lady Charlotte Campbell: Lewis did play de part of Cupidon, which will amuse us, as you will suppose. He is grown so embonpoint, he is more droll than ever in that character; but he tink [sic] himself charming, and look so happy when he makes les yeux doux to the pretty ladies, that it is cruel to tell him, ‘You are in the paradise of fools’. (MacDonald, p. 66) Whether Lewis deliberately assumed a disguise to mask suspicions about a preference for younger men, or was really in earnest with Princess Caroline is quite difficult to tell from this passage. What is clear is that
Reading the Gaze
43
others perceived his flirtations as performances which made him seem ridiculous to women as a sexual partner. Lewis was obviously aware of the power and the necessity of disguise. In a poem to Charles William Stuart, a lieutenant-colonel of the Royal Irish Dragoons, the metaphor of veiling, so often found in Gothic writing, is used by the speaker selfreflexively: ‘Veil with assumed content your keen affliction, Nor wish his heart to feel a pang like yours’ (MacDonald, p. 67). It is unclear whether the need to masquerade his distress at his friend’s departure is due to Stuart’s ignorance of the depth of his love, or to the suspicion with which a display of intense feeling for another man might be regarded by society. Lewis’s attitude to Giovanni Battista Falcieri, his manservant on his continental tour and who accompanied him on his second voyage to his Jamaican plantations when he died of yellow fever, also suggests that Lewis was mildly amused by effeminacy. In his Journal of a West India Proprietor Lewis records the agonies of his second sea voyage in 1817: Then we had a young lady who was ready to die of sea sickness, and an old one who was little better through fright; and I had an Italian servant into the bargain, who was as sick as the young lady, and as frightened as the old one. The poor fellow had never been on board ship before; and with every crack which the vessel gave, he thought that to be sure, she was splitting right in half.34 While he was in Venice Byron employed Falcieri, possibly through Lewis, and he became his gondolier. After Lewis’s death, Falcieri, or ‘Tita’ as Byron affectionately termed him, was taken into Byron’s household, and is referred to in his will.35 Was there a kind of homoerotic economy operating between Lewis and Byron in the circulation of young Venetian working-class male bodies? The answer to the question may not advance our queering of The Monk, but the question may be applied instead to thinking about relations between bodies in the novel. In The Monk, the idea of the exchange of Ambrosio between men (i.e. the Devil and in Matilda, a quasi-man) is suffused with sexualized imagery. The impulse to reveal and confirm the sexualities of Walpole, Beckford and Lewis as identity categories is a misplaced critical endeavour. Even if we did discover conclusive evidence to prove that Lewis practised same-sex love (which is unlikely) it does not necessarily follow that Lewis would inscribe same-sex desire in his fiction for all to see. On the contrary, in a culture of fear and repression, same-sex desire is just as likely to be as evanescent as the ghosts found in Gothic writing.
44 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
Sedgwick observes ‘paranoia is characterized by placing in practice, an extraordinary stress on the efficacy of knowledge per se – knowledge in the form of exposure. Maybe that’s why paranoid knowing is so inescapably narrative.’36 What I understand her to mean by ‘narrative’ is that if such a knowledge about Lewis becomes available, it can close down the potentiality of the novel’s meanings. It would limit a reading of Lewis’s writing to a deterministic, parallel relationship between Lewis’s sexual behaviour, and the meanings of desire in the text. Reading Walpole, Beckford and Lewis’s behaviour and desires as queer does not necessarily mean that they recognized their feelings, desires or positions accordingly. Queering their writing does not depend upon whether we read them as ‘homosexual’, ‘bi-sexual’, ‘asexual’ or even straight but showing how their novels can represent a homophobic culture and also how this is subtly reinscribed through a biographical penetrating eye. The insights we derive from reading their correspondence and biographies about the importance of secrecy, suspicion, gender ambiguity and the gaze to the queer subject and homophobia are all present in Gothic writing.
2 Guessing the Mould: Or, The Castle of Otranto?
The Castle of Otranto’s thematics, such as the sins of the father, divorce and incest, do not appear to have much to do with a reading of same-sex desire and queerness. However, one theme that emerges strongly and is related to how we can understand same-sex desire in the late eighteenth century and Romantic age is the fear of the exposure of a secret to a public, penetrating eye. It is with this theme in mind that I will be exploring how the novel is a cautious warning against suspicious narratives and paranoid interpretation which characterizes homophobia in the eighteenth century, looking in particular at extortion and the drive to see queer desires in effeminate bodies. With this in mind, the question form of the title of this chapter is meant to play on both the alternative titles many Gothic novels were given and to suggest how secrets always keep readers asking questions about the relation between Walpole’s own sexual identity and his novel. The central antagonist, Manfred, and his false claim of possessing the castle and principality of Otranto, is a subject who has the potential to be exposed, much like the eighteenth-century male who desired his own sex as I will describe below. Manfred’s tenants and subjects suspect that the ancient prophecy predicting that the castle will ‘pass from the present family, whenever the real owner should be grown too large to inhabit it’ is the cause of Manfred’s urgency to marry his son Conrad to Isabella. We are told that Manfred’s ‘family and neighbours [ ] did not dare utter their surmises on this precipitation’ (73).1 It is implied that Hippolita knows Manfred’s secret, and as his wife, she holds the most private intimate relation to Manfred above the other characters. Manfred continually attempts to prevent a public exposure of his secret. He is, in effect, in a kind of closet, albeit a semi-public one, as the public knowledge of the prophecy points to a secret. In his defensive 45
46 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
narrative to Frederic about his grandfather, Ricardo, Manfred is unable to name the act of betrayal and usurpation, a breach of the chivalric code of honour between these men: ‘My grandfather was incapable — I say, sir, Don Ricardo was incapable-Excuse me, your interruption has disordered me — I venerate the memory of my grandfather’ (120). Significantly, the secret that prompts all the subsequent developments in the novel is left unspeakable. The meaning of Ricardo’s secret creates a discourse of the secret which leaves its meaning unsignified and freefloating. What I am underlining here is how the state of unspeakability that defines the possession or knowledge of a secret (one that is both personal and political) is in Gothic writing foregrounded for itself, despite later revelations of what that secret actually is. For readers attuned to a knowledge of how same-sex desires and practices have either been erased from history, or have been spoken about in circumlocutory ways, because such desires and practices are termed unspeakable, there always remains the possibility that the secret referred to might be a queer one. Theodore, the true heir to Otranto, represents for Manfred the threat of exposure. Drawing attention to the similarity between the helmet Conrad is crushed by and the helmet of the marble statue of the knight Alfonso in the church, Theodore is imprisoned by Manfred under the helmet. The space of the helmet becomes a metaphorical closet. Manfred’s anger at Theodore derives from his fear about his vassals’ interpretation of the visual connections Theodore makes between the armour and the statue: The folly of these ejaculations brought Manfred to himself: yet whether provoked at the peasant having observed the resemblance between the two helmets, and thereby led to the farther discovery of the absence of that [the helmet] in the church; or wishing to bury any fresh rumour under so impertinent a supposition; he gravely pronounced that the young man was certainly a necromancer. (77) Theodore also embodies the uncanny. Freud observes that: ‘the uncanny is that class of the frightening which leads us back to what is known of old and is long familiar’.2 Theodore becomes uncanny for Manfred as we are told by Bianca of Theodore’s resemblance to ‘the picture of the good Alfonso in the gallery’ who she describes as ‘a lovely young prince, with large black eyes, a smooth white forehead, and manly curling locks like jet’ (95). Manfred does not recognize this resemblance until Theodore is disguised in armour trying to escape from the castle. According
Guessing the Mould 47
to Bianca, it is implied that looking at portraits is sexually arousing, as Matilda quickly denies she ‘gazes’ on the portrait when she is told Bianca has been watching her. ‘Everybody’ is in love with the portrait. As a visual reminder of Alfonso then, Theodore recalls to Manfred’s consciousness his need for secrecy about his true family history. Significantly, it is the armour, a stylized, exaggerated exterior of a man’s body, all hard edges and angles, which terrifies Manfred the most; he is in ‘an agony of amazement and terror’. The image and presence of Theodore confirms Manfred’s guilt over his secret and destroys the identity he has constructed for himself. This moment of recognition takes place in a public space with Manfred’s vassals looking on. As such, it can be read as inscribing the fear of the recognition of a secret between two men, particularly a secret that is charged with the queer overtones of unspeakability. The tragic and apocalyptic resolution of the ending of the novel with the vision of the true owner of the castle, the giant Alfonso, destroying the castle, implies that the fear of the revelation of one’s identity lies in the potential for such knowledge of secrets to be used as power. In chapter two, Matilda and Bianca speculate on the question of who Theodore is: Do, madam, let us sift him. He does not know you, but takes you for one of my lady Hippolita’s women. Art thou not ashamed, Bianca? said the princess: what right have we to pry into the secrets of this young man’s heart? He seems virtuous and frank, and tells us he is unhappy: are those circumstances that authorize us to make a property of him? (98) Matilda’s objection implies that Bianca’s use of ‘sift’, meaning to examine for evidence of authenticity but resonating with the idea of sorting out people into types, is unethical. Theodore would become their ‘property’ by the exchange of a secret or their discovery of such, and be rendered even more powerless. Matilda refuses to trust Bianca with her mother Hippolita’s secret, arguing that secrets should be kept within families. The above scene is central to thinking about how we might wish to consider the genre of Gothic writing as manifesting an anxiety about secrets, particularly secrets to do with the exposure of taboo sexual desires. The silence and invisibility that surrounded queer bodies in the Romantic age, and the punitive legal system that increasingly condemned those convicted of sodomy to the pillory or hanging, was
48 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
perhaps particularly difficult for aristocratic or middle-class men in the public eye, especially vulnerable to those eager to profit from this socio-cultural repressiveness. Isabella’s suggestion that Theodore would become their ‘property’ suggests that Bianca could perhaps blackmail Theodore if she was so inclined. However, the nomenclature of blackmail did not exist in the eighteenth century. As Netta Murray Goldsmith states: ‘[ ] blackmail was deemed a species of robbery and very little account was taken in law of the psychological damage suffered by anyone menaced with the loss of his good name’3 . Instead, throughout the long eighteenth century, there were several cases of extortion where the accused was charged with intimidating the defendant by accusing them, usually by letter, either of practising sodomy or of sodomitical intent.4 Frequently there was a ring involved in orchestrating the extortion, occasionally impersonating night-watchmen or acting as false witnesses. Sometimes younger men or boys, desperate for money, were bribed to act as victims on behalf of the accused. It is also very likely that a significant number of those accused of practising extortion could have been queer themselves. Certain public places in London such as Covent Garden, St James’s park and Moorfields presented opportunities for potential perpetrators of extortion to accost their victims publicly, and threaten to expose them to the mob. Messages for people to rendezvous at taverns were common. Both the lower classes and the aristocracy could be at risk. However, servants extorting money from their aristocratic masters or middle-class employers by threatening to expose their secrets are almost non-existent. However, that is not to say this did not occur more frequently and that there is no surviving evidence because of the need for secrecy. The merest suspicion would have motivated many men to have paid their persecutors (or perhaps done worse) to preserve their reputation. In 1767, John Preston, claiming to be a servant, wrote to the Marquis of Carnavon demanding money. When Martha Quinn, Preston’s go-between was turned away from the Marquis’ door, it is likely that the Marquis’ servants sent for the constable, Joseph Brown, to catch Preston and his accomplices in the act of writing another letter at the Cherry Tree tavern in Southgate. This letter threatened to expose the ‘unnatural freedom’ the Marquis had taken with Preston unless he provided for him and his supposed wife, Quinn. According to this last letter, the Marquis’ servants may have suspected their employer to have been a victim of extortion and forestalled the inevitable accusatory letter Preston sent: ‘I have sent several before, and could not get any answer from your Lordship, for I suppose your servants have kept them, and
Guessing the Mould 49
you have not seen them.’ Although we must be wary of judging from the evidence of a convicted extortionist, Preston’s letter shows that servants occupied an ambiguous position; they could be loyal and sensitive to their employer, or unscrupulous by poking into their secrets.5 But perhaps one of the most important cases involving the extortion of the nobility is that of Walpole’s own brother, Sir Edward Walpole.6 Walpole was accused by John Cather, a young man who had been recommended to him while staying in Dublin, of battery with the intent to commit sodomy. When Cather came to London, he was employed in Edward Walpole’s household and then later discharged. Walpole asked for an open hearing and he seems to have wanted to have made Cather an example to deter other potential extortionists. He went so far as to hire a private detective, James Worsdale, who was an actor and cross-dressed as a woman to find evidence against Cather and his supposed associates.7 What is particularly notable is that throughout the case Horace Walpole remains fairly inconspicuous. Although he produced his journal entries as evidence when testifying at the trial against one of the accused, he makes no mention of the trial itself or even his brother in any of his letters. As Goldsmith indicates, it is possible that Edward desired young men.8 We are only left with speculation and suspicion as to why Horace makes no mention of his brother or the trial in his letters. A popular text about extortion between two men in the eighteenth century that Horace Walpole was aware of is the Love Letters between a Certain Late Nobleman and the Famous Mr Wilson; this was published anonymously in 1723 and later in 1745.9 The relationship between extortion and the closet, and the extremes men will undertake to resist even the suspicion of sodomy are foregrounded in this text. In his essay that attempts to separate out the facts and fantasy of the Love Letters, G.S. Rousseau argues that Walpole was aware of the historical basis for the text, although Walpole was evasive on the precise dates and details: ‘Even Horace Walpole, who continued to disguise the nature of his sexuality in old age when there was little reason for doing so given the reclusive manner in which he lived at Strawberry Hill, blurrily remembered the events of 1694 almost a hundred years later.’10 The ‘facts’ of 1694 read like a prototype of a Gothic novel, not least because they cannot be proven. According to Rousseau’s evidence from the letters of the writer DelaRivière Manley, Elizabeth Villiers, a mistress of William III, met Richard ‘Beau’ Wilson in a London park and subsequently on several occasions, supporting him in a luxurious
50 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
lifestyle. She always arranged to meet him veiled, but one day he tore off her veil to discover who she was. The unveiling outraged her so much that she arranged to have him murdered by John Law (a corrupt Scottish financier) in a duel. There was no suggestion in 1694 of Wilson having been supported as a catamite by a nobleman, or of his having any sexual relations with John Law. In a letter to the Earl of Buchan who was writing a history of the biographies of prominent Scottish figures, Walpole refuses to substantiate for Buchan any possible homoerotic connection between Law and Wilson: I cannot contribute anything of consequence to your Lordship’s meditated account of John Law. I have heard many anecdotes of him, though none I can warrant, particularly that of the duel for which he fled early [ ] I have two or three different prints of him, and an excellent head of him in crayons by Rosalba [ ] Law was a very extraordinary man, but not at all an estimable one.11 Whether or not Walpole knew of the Love Letters is not indicated here; he has no comment on Beau Wilson. The rumours could refer equally to Law’s involvement in The South Sea Bubble, a political disaster for the government of Walpole’s father, Sir Robert Walpole, as to any rumours of sexual indiscretion. Even with the remote possibility that Walpole did not know of the Love Letters, the text is illuminating for the representation of extortion between men of different classes in the eighteenth century, and also for how it foreshadows characteristics of Gothic writing. The preface is reminiscent of much Gothic writing in arousing mystery, which is designed to appeal to a popular audience, and creating uncertainty as to whether the letters are real or fictitious: ‘The only Contest among the politer of Mankind will be, Whether the Facts are true, and the letters genuine, or only a fictitious Scene of the worst Sort of Gallantry, and the Product of a mercenary pen’ (12). This deliberately equivocal comment indicates both the implicit homophobic intention of the writer of the letters and the attempt to cover his hypocrisy in recognizing the advantage of creating a discourse of doubt to a scandal-hungry public. The posture of the prevaricating narrator about to reveal a deep, terrible secret is one that is adopted repeatedly within Gothic writing, and one the editor of the letters employs here. The narrator also suggests that there is something unspeakable about how the letters have come to be circulated: ‘How, or by what Means this was done and from what
Guessing the Mould 51
Hand they are made Publick, is a Point too tender and consequential to relate’ (p. 13). The letters bring to our attention how we might need to give more thought to how powerful the threat of extortion may be as an explanatory factor for the relative invisibility of same-sex desire in comparison to, say, the late nineteenth century. The explanatory appendix in the original edition informs us that the nobleman used a female relation, Cloris, as a ruse to deceive ‘Mrs V-ll-s’ [sic], and that he later brutally attacks Cloris in a park after she threatens him with a gun because he has abandoned her while she is pregnant.12 The argument for reading the letters as fictional, and not real, is strengthened by how they reinscribe and reiterate a misogynist ideology that is displaced onto the queer. The editor or author of these letters reinforces the stereotypical representations of queer men, such as the mollies, who were popularly represented as misogynistic.13 What is more significant for a reading of The Castle of Otranto is how extortion occurs in the gap between the classes, and how positions of power and class are reversible. Both Bianca and Theodore symbolize these possibilities. In Letter IV, the nobleman warns Mr Wilson about a plot by Wilson’s friends to get Wilson drunk so he will reveal the source of his wealth. He is anxious to keep their liaison a secret: ‘Don’t let us meet, nor be seen together ’till this Business is over’.14 Wilson is later bullied with a pistol by a Great Lady to: ‘make me reveal what those private Meetings between us meant’ (p. 20). The nobleman sends Wilson a copy of a letter that has been sent to him (which is not seen by the reader) but which seems to imply from Wilson’s answer in Letter XX that Wilson has been secretly meditating to extort money from his lover. The letter which is sent to the nobleman, probably by the mysterious ‘Mrs V-ll-s’, indicates a manipulation of their respective states of paranoia. The nobleman’s fear of dishonour and his loss of reputation, status and power are played upon by the anonymous writer of the letter who accuses Wilson of planning to practise extortion. To return to the scene in The Castle of Otranto in Chapter two between Bianca and Isabella with this context in mind, Matilda’s use of the word ‘property’ suggests a condemnation of the economic commodification of the secret that the extortionist uses. It also suggests a fear of the closet, of being put into a position of knowledge about another person that makes one vulnerable. When Theodore asks if he can trust Matilda, she replies: ‘Speak boldly, if thy secret is fit to be entrusted to a virtuous breast’ (99), with the implication that if it is of a sexual nature it will compromise Matilda’s ‘virtue’. Theodore is interrupted as he is about to speak by the labourers coming into the fields. There are other similar
52 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
moments in the novel where the communication of secrets is deferred. The hermit in the wood at Joppa fails to disclose his secret to Frederic on his deathbed. Later on, Frederic ‘on the ground in a conflict of penitence and passion’ in Hippolita’s oratory after receiving a warning from the ghost of the hermit cannot tell Hippolita what he has learnt: ‘I cannot speak’ (158). The state of unspeakability, and the inability to name the secret, suggests to a queer reader a discourse of the secret as a secret about sexual desires and practices, particularly as sexual relations between men have both legally and culturally been understood as ‘the love that dare not speak its name’. The communication of secrets is also represented in Gothic writing as a fearful or unsettling experience. In Chapter four, when Hippolita tells of Frederic’s agreement to Manfred’s idea of marrying Matilda and Frederic, there is the implication that fear and terror are the emotions one experiences when a secret is voiced because one cannot anticipate the substance, which might always be the unspeakable: ‘What art thou going to utter? said Isabella trembling. Recollect thyself, Matilda’ (142). Hippolita suspects that Isabella is in a kind of closet herself over Matilda’s secret: ‘thou art conscious to this unhappy secret, whatever it is. Speak ![sic]’ (142). One of the most important ways in which we can read the novel as queer is that The Castle of Otranto represents gender as a performative act. Masculinity and femininity, although they appear to be represented as polarized opposites by the stereotypical characterization, are in fact shown to be more complicated on a closer reading. There is a crossing over of masculinity and femininity that is central to understanding the Gothic as queer. In fact, the stereotypical characterization is self-conscious; masculinity and femininity are shown to be artificial constructions and poses that can be assumed. More often than not, for example, masculinity is almost hysterically exaggerated, what I would call hyperbolic gender.15 One can read the novel as demonstrating (implicitly) how eighteenth-century homophobia is concerned with the elimination of effeminacy in male subjectivity. In both the characterization and the movement of the plot we can perceive a reflection of a cultural homophobia about the fear of effeminacy lurking within those men whose masculinity is questionable. Diane Long Hoeveler has argued that the ‘female Gothic’ hyperbolizes a sentimental, naturalistic image of the female as domestic, maternal and embodying self-sacrificing virtues, which exposes the misogynist law of patriarchy but occasionally appears to reinforce it.16 Can this hyperbolism of female characters with its ambivalent political and ideological effects in the ‘female Gothic’ also be applied to male characters? What are the sources and origins for
Guessing the Mould 53
masculinity displayed in Gothic writing and do those representations subvert or reinforce those sources? Manfred’s displays of his power and authority reflect back on his status as an implicitly homophobic subject. In particular Manfred’s masculinity draws attention to itself; he invites us to see how masculinity works in a dialectical relation to femininity. At the opening of the novel, Manfred’s son Conrad is destroyed by a predominantly masculine symbol, a military helmet. Conrad’s lack of potential as a father is immediately pointed out to the reader as a possible source of dissension between father and son. He is ‘a homely youth, sickly and of no promising disposition, yet he was the darling of his father’ (73). The narrator implies by ‘yet’ that the reverse ought to be true. Manfred should be disappointed by his deficient virility because it borders on effeminacy, denoting physical weakness, but also perhaps the possibility of homoerotic tendencies. Isabella subsequently declares that she was ‘indifferent’ to marrying Conrad. Manfred attributes Conrad’s death to Providence because Conrad does not conform to a kind of masculinity in his physicality: ‘he was a sickly, puny child, and heaven has perhaps taken him away that I might not trust the honours of my house on so frail a foundation’ (22). There is an emphasis on his delicate physicality, with the repetition of ‘sickly’. Manfred, by contrast, proudly pits his virility against Conrad in his proposal of marriage to Isabella: ‘Instead of a sickly boy, you shall have a husband in the prime of his age, who will know how to value your beauties, and who may expect a numerous offspring’ (80). He becomes determined to prove himself to her. The implication of the narrative is that Manfred will rape her if he catches her in the vaults or if he can persuade her to return from the convent to the castle. If we turn to the characterization of femininity, we can explore further the idea that the characterization of Manfred represents an example of internalized homophobia in the eighteenth century, if we consider that to be perceived as effeminate borders on being queer. Initially, in terms of the story and characterization, women and femininity seem to be treated negatively. Hippolita, Matilda and Isabella do not openly challenge Manfred’s authority or cruelty. Matilda for instance allows her mother to believe that Manfred is grieving with ‘manly fortitude’, when in fact he has just told Matilda he does not want a daughter and slammed the bedroom door in her face. Women are described as suffering from the effects of love and terror that are archetypal to the heroines of Sensibility. As G.J. Barker-Benfield points out, such displays of bodily terror contain a sexual frisson for male characters and spectators.17 All three women are reduced to mere
54 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
commodities, objects over which tyrants like Manfred and Frederic can squabble in their desire to continue their family lines. Manfred asserts the law of patriarchy when he tells the friar Jerome: ‘I do not use to let my wife be acquainted with the secret affairs of my state; they are not within a woman’s province’ (102). The homosocial bonding between men that underpins the patriarchal structures of inheritance and property is dependent upon mystification and secrecy, from women. Manfred’s ‘state’ has as much a personal as a political resonance here for the queer reader. William Patrick Day has argued: ‘Manfred regards Isabella neither as a person nor even as a sexual object; she is just another human mechanism for the replication and maintenance of his identity and power.’18 If, as Day argues, Manfred rejects the feminine component of his personality while recognizing his dependence on women by requiring Hippolita to give him a divorce and Isabella an heir, then one might read Manfred as a characterization of how one form of homophobia in the eighteenth century is based upon the effeminizing power of women upon men. Running throughout eighteenth-century observations of those convicted for sodomy, or suspected of sodomy, is an attack on effeminacy that shows how the prevalent form of homophobia in the eighteenth century is predicated on misogyny.19 Manfred’s ‘insensibility’ over Conrad’s death confirms his masculinity in refusing to show his suffering. Manfred secrets himself away in his chamber to supposedly weep unobserved. He only impersonates the late eighteenth-century man of feeling, crying before Frederic’s knights in order to persuade them to allow Isabella to remain in Otranto.20 Isabella, Matilda and Hippolita are portrayed as innocent, virtuous, modest and self-sacrificing – the prototype for Ann Radcliffe’s later heroines. The female is persecuted and punished in the novel; she is driven underground, removed to enclosed sanctuary spaces and, in Matilda’s case, dies. When Manfred chases Isabella in the castle, the spectacle of the female subject in distress may satisfy an erotic desire in the narrator and/or male reader. The narrator permits the reader access to the fear she experiences. Isabella is situated conventionally within the tradition of the sexually-persecuted heroine of sentimental fiction whose distress only serves to arouse her persecutor: ‘Yet where conceal herself! How avoid the pursuit he would infallibly make throughout the castle!’ (82). However, one might also read the narrator as sympathetic to her persecution. Matilda voices her protest at Manfred’s ‘disdain’ and ‘causeless severity’ towards Hippolita, both to Bianca and to Hippolita herself: ‘Weep not, my child; and not a murmur, I charge thee. Remember he is thy father still. — But you are my Mother too, said Matilda fervently;
Guessing the Mould 55
and you are virtuous, you are guiltless! Oh must not I, must not I complain?’ (141). Arguably, the characterization of Hippolita’s hyperbolical femininity produces an ironic effect. The etymology of her name links her with the mythical figure of Hyppolita, a queen of the amazons in Greek myth, serving to underscore the slightly comic effect of her devotional ineptitude to a tyrant; Hippolita is the polar opposite of the quasimasculine female warrior. In Chapter one, Manfred reminds Hippolita cruelly of her sterility, yet she is portrayed as dutiful and deferential to the point of absurdity. In Hippolita’s consciousness, it appears as if she has exaggerated the remembrance of her marriage vows obsessively: ‘he is dearer to me even than my children’ (79). Marriage is exalted above maternal love and even sacrificed to personal suffering, so that it seems to be almost mocked as a state to produce happiness. When Bianca warns Matilda about existing self-sufficiently, one might read Hippolita’s pronouncement ironically, as it is being propagated by Bianca, who is not married herself, and is, supposedly, ignorant: ‘I do not wish to see you moped in a convent, as you would be if you had your will, and if my lady your mother, who knows that a bad husband is better than no husband at all, did not hinder you’ (95). Arguably, it would appear then that the novel depicts the ‘heterosexual’ family and marriage as ultimately flawed and dysfunctional, setting the pattern for later Gothic writing. Matrimony is depicted as rather absurd and redundant for women. Hippolita supposes naively that Manfred is grieving like herself; she does not realize that his only interest is in furthering his ambition: ‘Manfred cannot support the sight of his own family [ ] and dreads the shock of my grief’ (79). It is difficult to ascertain whether this irony implies a contemptuous opinion of women in the blind foolishness of one remaining married to a man who cares nothing for her, or whether such innocence over Hippolita’s own procreative sexual power is to be commended as a virtue. As I have argued above, the misogyny of Manfred can, at one level, be read as an example of how a certain type of homophobia in the eighteenth century is motivated by the increasing presence of effeminacy, which blurs the boundary between masculine and feminine behaviour. Reading the novel with this context in mind theodore is important in this respect. Theodore functions as an uncanny double for Manfred’s past, but he also works against Manfred’s ideas of what it is to be manly because he is, confusingly for Manfred, both a peasant and refined, of a lower status but of a higher status in his feelings. In the latter respect he can symbolize the disrupting presence of the
56 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
queer. Raymond Bentham suggests that in Theodore Walpole creates ‘a hero from the sentimental tradition who can function successfully in a rough and violent society’.21 He is certainly not ‘irrelevant’ nor is he ‘alienated from the values of the feminine’.22 He has the most interaction with the female characters, and, after all, he inherits the castle of Otranto. Theodore represents an alternative to the masculinity of Manfred; he possesses the qualities of compassion, softness and honour that are the antithesis to Manfred’s aggressive double-dealing. The narrative events that revolve around Theodore are anchored consistently by the idea of his integrity; he keeps his word, he does the right action by others, so that at a symbolic narrative level he stands for the truth. In the opening scenes, he alerts the community to the resemblance between the helmet and the statue and is punished by Manfred for this ‘outing’. Theodore enters the community and causes disorder. He signifies the racial/class/sexual outsider who enters the bourgeois domestic household and proves ‘uncanny’ by causing that which is hidden to be exposed. Theodore’s class (signalled by his clothes) and his behaviour disturb Manfred. As a peasant he has ‘a mixture of grace and humility’ in defying Manfred that makes him a contradictory figure. We are asked where the borderline is between the act of those in a lower position exposing and criticizing their superiors when they believe them to be acting wrongly, and when this moral purpose becomes a situation for personal or (to return to the idea of extortion) monetary gain. Arguably, the narrator’s sympathy is with Theodore whom Isabella terms a ‘necromancer’, an outcast who is in disguise, and who is treated as a scapegoat for Conrad’s death. The narrator reflects sarcastically on the impossibility of one man moving such a great weight as the helmet. Theodore embodies reversal. He is later discovered to be the son of Count Falconara, now Friar Jerome. When Manfred expects to meet Isabella in the vaults, his expectation is reversed by meeting Theodore instead: ‘What was the astonishment of the prince, when, instead of Isabella, the light of the torches discovered to him the young peasant, whom he thought confined under the fatal helmet!’ (85) [my emphasis]. ‘Astonishment’ connotes speechlessness and unspeakability; Manfred is later ‘staggered’ by Theodore. The power Theodore wields over Manfred, which results in Manfred’s speechlessness and astonishment, is that Theodore threatens to expose Manfred’s masculinity as a façade used to maintain his power. Theodore is substituted into Isabella’s position, so that the gaze of Manfred does not meet the object he anticipates. This reversal of gender can also be read as terrifying because it invokes
Guessing the Mould 57
the possibility of a homoerotic attraction that cannot be articulated but only registered as ‘astonishment’. Manfred terms Theodore an ‘imposter’, suggesting Theodore’s ability to pose and fool others with an assumed identity. It is likely that this early form of passing was a strategy that queers cultivated to survive, even more so if they were aristocratic because of the threat of extortion. Ironically, it is this very process of posing that Manfred objects to, because his authority and power (those attributes that define his masculinity) are threatened by Theodore’s refusal to confirm his identity. What aspect of his identity, for example his gender, class or sexuality, is not explicitly stated in the text. Theodore is, in effect, a queer body, one which cannot be verified with any certainty. Matilda’s exclamation – ‘I fear, said the princess, I am serving a deceitful one!’ (125) – and Manfred’s accusation of necromancy also suggest that Theodore is allied with the demonic. One characteristic of the demonic is that is continually changes its shape so that it is not readily identifiable; the demonic is also ‘unnatural’, a key word for marking off the sodomitical body in the eighteenth century. Manfred’s threats to extract ‘sincerity’ from Theodore via torture and imprisonment dramatize the condition of the queer subject as persecuted by the power of the State which is determined to verify the queer’s identity. Theodore perhaps expresses best Walpole’s attempt at ‘blending’, which is why he frustrates Manfred’s clearly defined notion of what it means to be a man. Any queer signification he implies is closed finally by his willingness to die for Matilda and his marriage to Isabella. Manfred is symptomatic of how the act of looking becomes symbolic of a kind of masculine-defined prerogative of sexual penetration in the Gothic. Gothic writing dramatizes the fear of secrets haunting its male protagonists. It symbolizes this thematic with a visual correlative, i.e. that characters in Gothic writing are physiognomists and interpret both the looks, and the act of looking of others. Motivations, character and intentions are read from the expressions and looks of others. In Gothic writing, one person is ‘seen’ through by another, they are found ‘out’ through a disguise or a veil being penetrated. This thematic of a penetrating gaze provides a way of thinking through how the gaze and looking inscribe how a homoerotic/homophobic dynamic work in the late eighteenth century. After the wounded Frederic is taken back to the castle, Matilda and Isabella try to interpret the meaning of Theodore’s looks. Matilda reflects: ‘His eyes, it was true, had been fixed on her in Frederic’s chamber; but that might have been to disguise his passion for Isabella from the fathers of both’ (137). The
58 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
narrator describes how ‘Isabella, not less restless, had better foundation for her suspicions. Both Theodore’s tongue and eyes had told her his heart was engaged, it was true—yet perhaps Matilda might not correspond to his passion’ (137). Both women attribute sexual desire, ‘passion’, to the process of looking and being looked at. Looking and gazing are also foregrounded to have the capacity for misinterpretation. Matilda suspects that she is not the real object of Theodore’s gaze, but that he gazes as a deflective tactic against the scrutinizing looks of Frederic and Manfred. Matilda’s deduction that looks have the capacity to be used as a means of concealment and can be misinterpreted should be remembered when we read that Isabella’s ‘suspicions’ have a more solid foundation in seeing Theodore’s ‘eyes’ as confirming his love. There is an implication that we are to read Isabella’s belief in the power of reading the gaze as confirming love or desire cautiously. To return to how we might think about the novel in the context of the extortion of queer desire, the novel also implies that to be secretly watched over, as for example by an invisible supernatural force, is particularly terrifying for men in positions of power. When the sable plumes of the giant’s helmet wave backwards and forwards, Isabella tells Manfred: ‘Look my lord! see Heaven itself declares against your impious intentions’ (81). The supernatural occurrences such as the massive sabre that magnetically clings to the helmet, the statue of Alfonso that drips blood, and the reports of the giant hand and leg in the castle all terrify Manfred. The interpretations given by his servants suggest that he is being watched invisibly by another male, either Alphonso the Good, or God. Jerome warns him that heaven ‘will continue to watch over’ Isabella. The metonymic instances of Manfred’s secret past are those of the supernatural armour and the dismembered body of Alfonso, both of which are phallic in their associations. The armour reflects Manfred’s terror at the prospect of the exposure of his masculinity in contrast to a stronger, more virile version represented by the supernatural.23 Beyond the supernatural as terrifying per se, it can be argued to represent a cultural fear of the male being watched by another unidentifiable being. The sword, foot and hand are all phallic signifiers that cause terror and alarm, as for example in Bianca where her comparison is significantly left unspeakable: ‘as big, as big’ (154). To be the subject of the gaze that attempts to penetrate into the heart of an identity or uncover the ‘true’ or ‘natural’ face of a subject is also a phenomenon that occurs with the social pastime of the masquerade in the eighteenth century. There is an overarching narrative present in
Guessing the Mould 59
The Castle of Otranto about how the representation of secret identities and desires that need to be uncovered, exposed and often punished links in with how Romantic period homophobia operates. First, the ways in which disguise and reversal are used in Gothic writing can provide a way of reading queerness in the eighteenth century. If we think about Walpole’s novel according to how the masquerade functioned in aristocratic eighteenth-century social life, this connection underscores further the queerness of the novel. The masquerade’s importance as a performative, public spectacle that simultaneously licensed the opportunity for secret meetings between men who could express their desires under the cover of appearing as women should not be underestimated in any discussion of same-sex desire in this period. In terms of the masquerade’s aesthetics, and the costumes people frequently dressed up in, Gothic writing is similar to the spectacle of the masquerade in its tendency towards flamboyant exaggeration. Terry Castle comments how social, sexual and class identities were problematized even further by the phenomenon of the masquerade: ‘The true self remained elusive and inaccessible – illegible within its fantastical encasements.’24 The suggestion is that the whole structure and experience of the masquerade was based on a kind of an open secret where individuals could fantasize, and, sometimes, act out their desires safely. The potential for sex, gender and desire to be mistaken created an eroticized fear that is not dissimilar to the tension surrounding bodies without a confirmed identity found in Gothic writing. The types of characters that were impersonated at masquerades could quite easily be found inhabiting the pages of Gothic novels: ‘Witches, conjurors, demons, hermaphrodites and druids and other more or less marvellous beings crowded eighteenth-century masquerade rooms; the Devil was a ubiquitous presence.’25 This particular choice to impersonate supernatural beings may have derived its source from the popularity of the Gothic, especially as the enjoyment of reading Gothic crossed all classes of reader. The reversal of gender was a very important part of the pleasure of the masquerade. It offered its participants who crossed over from masculine to feminine and vice versa the opportunity to temporarily explore desiring their own sex with their ‘real’ identity invisible. In Gothic writing, the act or moment of a reversal overturns and unbalances truths and supposedly established certainties. To those who are witnesses to the reversal of an identity, this induces self-doubt and questioning because they are forced to renegotiate their own identity position. Perhaps the key emotional effect of reversal that is present in The Castle of Otranto
60 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
is the fear of betrayal. This is the founding basis of Manfred’s original secret and the backstory of the novel. Ricardo (who poisoned Alfonso the Good) was Alfonso’s chamberlain. As well as meaning a person who manages the private chambers or household of a nobleman, ‘chamberlain’ can also mean someone who is a personal attendant of a king or aristocrat in the space of the bedroom. The post of a chamberlain to a nobleman is one of those intimate positions in the bedroom space between two men that is also shared by the valet, or the personal manservant. As his chamberlain, Ricardo might be privy to a knowledge of sexual secrets that might include same-sex desire between valets and nobleman, especially in the context of the Love Letters I discussed above. As well as suggesting political treachery, Ricardo’s betrayal could also encompass the potential for blackmail in his homosocial intimacy with Alfonso and his knowledge of any bedroom secrets. Reversals of gender occur throughout the novel: Manfred expects to catch Isabella in the vaults and instead finds Theodore; Theodore later believes he follows a man in the caverns and comes across Isabella. Fear is experienced in the reversal of these anticipations. In Chapter five, when Frederic goes to look for Hippolita, he sees instead an unidentifiable figure whose gender he is not entirely sure of: ‘As he approached nearer, it seemed not a woman, but one in a long woolen weed, whose back was towards him’ (156). Turning round the figure reveals itself to be the spectre of the hermit in the wood at Joppa. The point of ‘turning slowly round’, or reversal, is dramatized as the origin for terror, and the turn works as a symbol for the general pattern of extreme reversals of identity, as in Manfred’s turn from sexual predator and patriarch to celibate and outsider. The effects of reversal are both tragic, for Manfred who retreats into convent to do penance, and emancipatory, for Theodore who claims the castle as his property. Reversal also represents the disappearance, or a vanishing of something that once existed but cannot in the present be proven to have been a reality. Those who witness the supernatural are represented as hysterical and delusional because it is an experience which requires ocular proof to be believed by others. They are isolated in their own belief. After the ambiguously-gendered figure of the hermit turns round, and then disappears, we are told that Frederic’s ‘blood froze in his veins’; he falls ‘prostrate on his face before the altar’; weeps ‘a flood of tears’, and lays on the ground in ‘a conflict of penitence and passion’ (157). When Hippolita discovers him she misinterprets Frederic’s ‘transport’ to relate to herself, ‘I see thou feelest for me’ (158). She has not seen the spectre so she cannot understand the real cause for his passion. When Theodore
Guessing the Mould 61
offers to investigate the reports of the servants about the appearance of the enormous pieces of armour in the castle, Manfred replies, ‘I am so circumstanced, that I dare trust no eyes but my own’ (90), suggesting he will only believe what he can see. Robert Miles has explored the relationship between the concept of ‘ideal presence’, an idea that was formulated by the Scottish philosopher and lawyer, Henry Home, Lord Kames, in Elements of Criticism (1774), and how Gothic writing seems to transform the morally instructive purpose of ideal presence.26 Miles views Horace Walpole, William Beckford and Matthew Lewis as ‘sexual dissidents’ resisting the ‘flow of power’ between the subject and the civilizing, improving experience of ideal presence as it is generated by art forms, notably reading and the theatre. He comments: The recurrence of these writers to the instabilities of the ‘male gaze’ represent discursive interventions standing against ideal presence. Their texts mimic Kames’ mechanism of moral impression, but for doubtful ends. One of the reasons why these texts may seem so uncertain and irresolute is that their object is hidden from us. Their visual sabotage may appear to have no purpose beyond baiting the bourgeoisie. However, the picture changes once we accept that ideal presence encodes a normative model of subjectivity, one deeply implicated in those eighteenth century discursive practices which sought to stabilize the civil subject.27 The implication of Miles’s argument is that because of their marginalized subjectivity, and their resistance to a ‘normative model’ of subjectivity, the concept of ideal presence is disrupted for the reader by how these texts parody ideal presence through how the supernatural works. This argument suggests that Walpole, Beckford and Lewis are self-consciously and even actively queer, i.e. ‘sexual dissidents’ mimicking the structures of bourgeois culture in their art, than my reading of them would allow for. It is, of course, difficult to say how far these writers consciously thought of themselves in a way that we might now call queer, particularly as the problem of how we can, or should, read a text according to authorial intentionality arises. There is a further complication in that Walpole and Beckford participate in, even shape perhaps in Walpole’s case, polite eighteenth-century culture.28 The instability of the male gaze often occurs around the encounter with the supernatural, as for example when Manfred is terrified by seeing the pieces of armour, and the example quoted above with the character of Frederic. Miles compares the effect of the supernatural in Walpole, Beckford and Lewis’s
62 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
writing to Etienne Gaspard Robertson (who made the Phantasmagoria shows popular) and argues that their use of the supernatural corrupts the educative purpose of ideal presence, because the supernatural is presented as a deception, and, like the phantasmagoria shows, an illusion manipulating the spectator for economic gain.29 I would argue that the representation of the supernatural as deceptive goes beyond a wish to exploit readers’ pockets and suggest that these works enlighten us as to how illusion and deception function in understanding the eighteenth century’s fascination with wider forms of what is invisible, such as same-sex desire. The use of the supernatural in The Castle of Otranto works against a normative view of gender relations by suggesting that masculinity and femininity are reversible, and almost interchangeable. The panic and fear this causes in the male spectator, and by extension the reader, can be related to a concomitant social need to define and stabilize gendered behaviour, and by extension to suppress and regulate unorthodox desires. The points of reversal and revelation in the narrative also function to confirm or confute narratives that have proliferated around unidentifiable or mysterious male bodies that may have something to hide. The Castle of Otranto implies an anti-homophobic attitude to the destructive effects of gossip and speculation about social reputation, and to how paranoia functions. It suggests that these oral stories are uncontrollable once they are set in motion. Jerome manipulates Manfred’s jealous suspicion that Theodore is Isabella’s lover in order to prevent Manfred’s plan of marrying her: ‘With this unhappy policy, he answered in a manner to confirm Manfred in the belief of some connexion’ (107) [my emphasis]. Manfred in turn manipulates Frederic’s knights to retain his hold over Isabella: ‘Is it possible, sirs, continued the prince, that my story should be a secret to you?’ (121). He is discovered to be concealing information when one of the friars reveals that Isabella is staying in the convent to claim sanctuary from Manfred’s pursuit. However it is Bianca, originally a peasant before becoming a lady-in-waiting to Matilda, who is portrayed as the principal manipulator of stories and rumours. Bianca plots the fragmented accounts of the supernatural armour by Manfred’s servants, Diego and Jaquez, into a coherent, but embellished narrative that gives her a measure of authority. Bianca represents a dissident voice and the fear of the power differential between the classes being dislodged in favour of the servant class, in accessing the secrets of their masters and mistresses with the consequent potential for exploitation and blackmail. Could these secrets encompass the possibility of the discovery of same-sex desire? In an oblique way, via the rhetoric of straight courtship
Guessing the Mould 63
and incest, we can understand the narrativization of secrecy which we can then extend to think about same-sex desire. Bianca also represents the female equivalent of Ricardo in her potential for betraying Matilda. The bedroom is metaphorically a confessional as well; Bianca implores Matilda to confide in her – ‘Oh dear madam, cried Bianca, what were they?’(96) – and is criticized on the grounds that she is not really a part of the family. The sexual life of others also forms the grounding basis of Bianca’s narrativization of what happens, particularly with Theodore and Isabella. Her maxim, ‘A by-stander often sees more of the game than those that play’, has sinister implications for the prospect of bodily and verbal signs being misconstrued and used against the players. Interestingly, Bianca’s repeated exclamation of ‘I accuse nobody’ works against itself rhetorically so that the implication of a pre-marital sexual encounter does indeed fall on Isabella and Theodore, which even Matilda begins to believe. The narrator indicates how suspicion progresses insidiously through Bianca calling into question Isabella’s motives and identity: ‘No, no madam; my lady Isabella is of another guess-mould than you take her for. She used indeed to sigh and lift up her eyes in your company, because she knows you are a saint – but when your back was turned –’ (101). Is she a sinner, a whore, a lesbian when Matilda is not actively looking at her? The use of ‘guess mould’ suggests that The Castle of Otranto can be read queerly through the implication that visible sexual identities still may be read uncertainly. Certain bodies and behaviours provoke doubt and suspicion because they can never be completely authenticated. The implications of the concept of the ‘guess-mould’ that Bianca alerts us to are that bodies and looks are not always what they seem to be, and that this can work both for and against the queer body in the eighteenth century. Certain signifiers of sexual orientation also allow for the possibility of concealment in that they can correspond to non-sexual meanings and nothing can be proven or verified. Yet those very signifiers generate suspicion and rumours that are difficult to disprove once they are circulated. These narratives provide the impetus for the paranoid condition that Manfred often displays which culminates in the murder of Matilda, his daughter, in the mistaken belief that Isabella is romantically and sexually attached to Theodore. Throughout the novel Manfred is depicted as susceptible to misconstruing narratives, and supernatural and human signs. When Frederic and his knights arrive at the castle, we are told that ‘he [Manfred] put several questions to them but was answered only by signs’ (119) and he becomes angry and frustrated. Isabella cautions
64 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
Manfred against being ‘discomposed’ at ‘the glosing of a peasant’s son’ (134), meaning she fears the effects on Manfred of an artfully misleading interpretation. Previous to the denouément, his conversation with Bianca in Chapter five reveals how any communication becomes distorted to fit his preconceptions that are based on ignorance and fear, the staples of paranoia and panic about the queer body. The secret that Manfred so ardently desires to know is not revealed by Bianca, but she has hinted enough to confirm Manfred’s suspicion that Theodore and Isabella are lovers ‘Indeed! said Manfred: has it gone so far?’ (152). When he thinks he overhears Theodore and Isabella talking in the church of Saint Nicholas his violently jealous reaction is based upon the misinterpretation that they are meeting one another secretly and results in the tragic end of mistaking Matilda for Isabella. The novel’s dynamics show how speculative gossip can function as a powerful instrument to incite paranoia, particularly with Manfred’s response to Theodore’s masculinity whose effeminacy suggests he may be queer. The opening chapter focused upon how biographical interpretations of Walpole’s sexuality offer a way in to read the novel queerly. The precarious situation of upper-class men like Walpole, whose social status might be constantly undermined by the servant class or political rivals like William Guthrie, allows a discursive frame in which to read the theme of secrecy in Gothic writing. Further work could be undertaken to look at how Walpole’s correspondence contains a good deal of gossip which ‘doubts’ the motives and behaviour of those in eighteenthcentury society. Arguably, Walpole attacks his enemies, like Lady Mary Wortley Montagu, with a strategy that he most fears himself: gossip. Gossip about sexual orientation and same sex desire is dependent upon an absence of knowledge and the possibility for the signifiers of gender to be interpreted as ambiguous. The Castle of Otranto reflects those paranoid dynamics of homophobia in the inability to control narratives about the self and to identify the queer body and its desires.
3 Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
Vathek is a hybrid novel that refuses classification. A composite of different genres of late eighteenth-century writing, its flexibility and uniqueness mark it as a text replete with queer potential. Vathek is an Oriental tale, an embellished narrative of a historical figure, and a moral fable. Perhaps best described as a work of the fantastic, it combines different sub-genres of the fantastic.1 The most predominant sub-genre is ‘Gothic’ and I include it under the rubric of Gothic writing while recognizing that the work can adapt itself to different generic expectations and conventions. Elements from both the Oriental genre and Gothic writing could be said to overlap: for example, the monstrous, threatening genii found in The Thousand and One Nights (more commonly known as The Arabian Nights) are supernatural figures and these are found in Gothic writing.2 The ‘inexplicable’ nature of the world of Vathek includes how queer bodies and sexualities are represented and queerness is celebrated but also complicated by an association with evil. A substantial part of Vathek explores the cultural implications of the supernatural and the demonic, central themes in Gothic writing. In addition, the depiction of ambition, evil and monstrosity are also closely associated to the supernatural and the demonic and feature in later Gothic writing such as The Monk and Frankenstein. However, Vathek refuses to fit or conform to any one of these genres, and it is its generic hybridity that is a metaphor for the queerness we find in the novel. As in the discussion of The Castle of Otranto in the preceding chapter, I wish to move away from the psycho-biographical readings of Beckford that have, until fairly recently, dominated the discussion of the representation of sexuality in Vathek.3 To begin with, reading the novel as an intentional expression of Beckford’s sexual desires becomes more difficult when the history of the publication of the novel is considered. 65
66 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
Significantly, the English version of the novel was a pirated translation by the Reverend Samuel Henry whom Beckford had employed as a translator while Beckford wrote the novel in French. The questions of ownership, authorship and intentionality (and consequently the production of the text’s meaning) are complicated by this fact. Reading the novel as an expression of Beckford’s own personal desires is risky. Henley’s English edition appeared in 1786, followed by Beckford’s two French editions published in both Paris and Lausanne in 1787 and without the four episodes which Beckford stipulated to his publisher must be included: ‘The question as to which of these editions is the single, authoritative one is not amenable to straightforward answer, and that fact itself suggests that the traditional model of primary author/authority is particularly problematic in this case.’4 Complicating the picture even further is Beckford’s assertion that he wrote the novel in three days which is contradicted by the evidence of his correspondence which suggests he took much longer to compose it. And how much of the novel is the translator Samuel Henley’s? As argued in the introduction, the ‘author’ is often deliberately de-centred in queer readings of a novel’s representation of gender and sexual desires. In some cases, we can infer a close relationship between characterization and a writer’s sexual preferences, but the reading of sexuality itself is problematic in the Romantic period. All the writers chosen for discussion here (except for Godwin) cannot be described in terms that are absolute and abiding which is why they invite the description queer. It is therefore a reductive move to simplify, say, the character of Gulchenrouz to a fictionalized version of William Courtenay that Beckford, as the author, purposely includes in the novel.5 Roberts and Robertson explore how the problems surrounding the authoritativeness of the text as a translation are mirrored in the text’s resistance to interpretation. This focus on interpretation allows us a way into reading Vathek queerly. If ‘ “translation” can be seen as the organizing principle behind the sort of hermeneutic task a reader of Vathek must undertake’, we can include the translation of gender ambiguity and sexual otherness.6 They conclude that ‘experience is radically ambiguous, pleasure and pain coexist, Vathek/Vat(h)ek is a text that marks the uncertain character’.7 Taking this argument one step further, I suggest that one of the ‘associations’ which is connected to translation is the interpretation of the queer body and its desires. If queer means in one sense a movement across and between two borders or poles, then one might compare the queer body to a script or a text that needs to be translated or interpreted, to be understood and ultimately controlled. The theme of translation works as a metaphor for how the signifiers of
Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
67
the body, particularly its desires, represent a foreign language that needs translation. Any translation is always an act of loss or addition in relation to its original meaning. The translation always calls into question the sense of a real, original meaning. Rather like the queer body complicates and causes us to question the authenticity of gender. Because translation borders on creativity there is the potential for ambiguity and embellishment. In the ever-widening gap between the translations, the original text and any sense of an authentic, original signified the stability of an interpretation of a text, an identity or a body is never assured. The sabre with the constantly changing characters is the most powerful symbol of this. Characters (in both senses) frustrate Vathek’s attempts at interpretation. Vathek boldly states: ‘I have skill enough to distinguish, whether one translates or invents.’8 The implication is that translation or interpretation always contains the possibility of a degree of invention and performative creativity. The invitation by Vathek is a call to anyone to prove their powers of translation in a public forum with an audience. The act of translation as performance provokes doubt as to what is original and authentic, both in bodies and in texts. In fact, Vathek’s professed power of discriminating translators from inventors is a defensive posture on his part. Vathek is powerless to know if the Indian’s tale is authentic or not because he is offered conflicting translations. Vathek claims to know the ‘true’ interpretation beforehand. His resistance, his absolutist desire for a translator to reveal the empirical truth on the sabres, is symptomatic of a rationalist, eighteenth-century need for gender, sexuality and race to be clearly outlined and signified for the maintenance of patriarchal power. In this context, the issue of the signature as a proof of one’s identity in the eighteenth century is pertinent. Paul Baines’ study of the parallels between economic and literary forgery shows how the need to control and punish forgery can be linked to the need to safely demarcate identity in the eighteenth century: ‘Alongside the perennial search for monetary authenticity, the goal of the inimitable note, there ran the need for a perfect, unassailable touchstone of human identity against which all falsifications could be measured.’9 The multiplicity of potentially conflicting interpretations created by the symbolic and the fantastic in Gothic writing mirrors the fear of those queer bodies whose gender or sexuality cannot be easily read and who remain suspicious. In Vathek, ‘the Indian’ or Giaour who brings the sabre embodies an identity that cannot be translated or verified, and therefore signifies a queerness in his resistance. The character of the Indian/Giaour is formulated in terms of the monstrous. His corporeality inspires repulsion: ‘a
68 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
man so abominably hideous that the very guards, who arrested him, were forced to shut their eyes, as they led him along’ (31). In the lurid description of the Indian, his body is described as being disproportionate and in terms that characterize him as monstrous and terrifying: The man, or rather monster, instead of making a reply, thrice rubbed his forehead, which, as well as his body, was blacker than ebony; four times clapped his paunch, the projection of which was enormous; opened wide his huge eyes, which glowed like firebrands; began to laugh with a hideous noise, and discovered his long amber-coloured teeth, bestreaked with green. (32) The Indian’s body implies that monstrosity is linked to hybridity and disproportion, as well as inflecting monstrosity as racial difference. However there are other conceptions of monstrosity in the eighteenth century which suggest that the authenticity of identity is constantly challenged by how bodies look and behave. Marie Hélène Huet discusses how in the eighteenth century theories and fantasies of monstrosity were often related to questions of sexual identity and kinship, particularly around hermaphroditism.10 Huet quotes the widespread belief that unfaithful wives in the eighteenth century, by the force of their imagination, could produce a child who resembled their spouse: ‘Thus though the monster was first defined as that which did not resemble him who engendered it, it nevertheless displayed some sort of resemblance, albeit a false resemblance, to an object external to its conception.’11 The idea of resemblance in the heteronormative family then became dubious as a means of proving the existence of one’s identity. Gothic writing often presents us with narratives where we finally discover each family member and their ‘real’, occasionally monstrous relationship with one another. These theories of monstrosity reinforced the prevailing opinion that sex difference was essentially natural and the order of things. The monstrous is transgressive and unnatural because it blends those categories that should be classified as distinct. During the latter part of the eighteenth century there was a marked interest in the monstrous, with even a society devoted to investigating the concept.12 The identification and stigmatization of queer bodies, in for example the mollies (as I will show further below), is often described as ‘monstrous’. The man who desires other men but who can also imitate and even, in some cases, simulate femininity calls into question the authenticity and stability of masculinity or femininity.13 This kind of body fuses and juxtaposes signs
Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
69
that are, ordinarily, to be kept separate. ‘Queer’ suggests a discontinuity between sex and gender. For instance when the Indian finally relieves Vathek’s thirst, the narrator juxtaposes both images of death and beauty onto the Indian’s body: ‘In the transports of his joy, Vathek leaped upon the neck of the frightful Indian, and kissed his horrid mouth and hollow cheeks, as though they had been the coral lips and the lillies and roses of his most beautiful wives’ (37). There is an implication here that this act is both unnatural and monstrous. Vathek should not be kissing the Indian both because he is male and because he is physically monstrous. Judith Halberstam perceives monstrosity as a metaphor for constructing subjectivity and the fear generated by monsters as linked to identities that cannot be reduced to any one form: ‘the production of fear in a literary text (as opposed to a cinematic one) emanates from a vertiginous excess of meaning’.14 Throughout the eighteenth century the term ‘monstrous’ was used as a constructive synonym for the bodies and desires of queer men, particularly by evangelical Christian writers. Above all, it was the idea of using one’s body improperly that gave the most offence: ‘in using his orifice ‘improperly’ he became more monstrous still, a sodomite’.15 Monstrosity was clearly connected with the creation of the unnatural body (such as the hermaphrodite) or the use of bodily parts and organs in what were perceived to be inverted or reverse ways. Certain eighteenthcentury journalists and commentators often vehemently perceive samesex desire to be expressive of the monstrous, and demand its punishment in biblical terms of the exodus of people: ‘such casting out of Sodomites is demanded by the voice of reason and nature; for they counteract the foundation laws [sic] of all human society; [ ] No monstrous births are equally hateful and offensive’16 . ‘Monster’ and ‘monstrosity’ become ritualized terms of fanatical abuse and a way of linking samesex desire to the unnatural and to the demonic. A poem appended to the pamphlet, Reasons for the Growth of Sodomy (1749) by ‘a gentleman commoner’, shows how the queer body is thought to be monstrous. The body that provokes such amazement and outrage is not a specific individual nor an identifiable social group, such as the mollies. Instead, it is implied that the person described is one of the ‘pretty fellows’ whose ubiquitous presence, effeminacy and ambiguous sexuality is denounced in the eighteenth-century London press. The writer of this pamphlet and poem is particularly disturbed by the difficulty of reading his gender: I stand amaz’d, and at a loss to know To what new species thou thy form
70 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
Dost owe? [ ] Thou appear’st to humane eyes, Like some ape of monstrous size; [ ] Thy oddities so much my mind perplex; I neither can define thy kind or sex. Art thou substance, art thou shade? That thus mounst’rouly [sic] array’d, Walking forth in open day Dost our senses quite dismay?17 The typological designation of ‘species’ indicates how same-sex desire was thought to be monstrous because, in an abstract sense, it consisted of two mutually separate categories or species such as male and female. The discontinuity of the narratives of Gothic writing like The Castle of Otranto and Vathek signals a textual monstrosity that plays with the reader. We are taken from one story strand to another and then back again; coherence is sacrificed to gaps, interruptions and the deferral of information. Vathek embraces the genre of the fantastic wholeheartedly, in that the representation of excess ranges in its effects from sublime fantasy to horror. And excess is nearly always connected to the body in Vathek, often transforming the body into an example of the monstrous. While staying in the Emir Fakreddin’s palace, the Emir invites Vathek to join him and his attendants at prayer. For a modern, twenty-first century readership this particular episode is problematic. We are told that Vathek enjoys ‘the multitude of calendars, santons, and derviches who were continually coming and going’ (63). However, he is particularly fascinated by the ‘bramins, faquirs, and other enthusiasts’ (63–64), all members of various Indian religious sects. The display of their individual ability to withstand excessive bodily pain is conceived of as monstrous; for example, ‘There were some amongst them that cherished vermin, which were not ungrateful in requiting their caresses’ (64). Vathek’s sado-masochistic personality is fascinated by the endurance of bodily pain these travellers undergo. Babalouk views them as monstrous and, in a language that is reminiscent of eighteenth-century pamphleteers on sodomy, calls for their destruction in terms reminiscent of the fire and brimstone preachers in the British press: Your majesty should be cautious of this odd assembly; which hath been collected, I know not for what. Is it necessary to exhibit such
Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
71
spectacles to a mighty potentate, with interludes of talapoins more mangy of dogs? Were I you, I would command a fire to be kindled, and at once rid the estates of the emir, of his harem, and all his menagerie. (64) The ‘odd’ assembly – can this be extended to suggest a possibly queer crowd? – assembles for unseen, invisible purposes or pleasures. Babalouk’s proposal for an auto da fé is thus sinister. Although Vathek reproves of Babalouk’s fearful intolerance by claiming that ‘all this infinitely charms me’, both his attitude and the narrator’s is no less intolerant than Babalouk’s, particularly in his mockery of the religious convictions of those he meets: These rambling fanatics revolted the hearts of the derviches, the calendars, and santons; however, the vehemence of their aversion soon subsided, under the hope that the presence of the Caliph would cure their folly, and convert them to the mussulman faith. But, alas! how great was their disappointment! for Vathek, instead of preaching to them, treated them as buffoons, bade them present his compliments to Visnow and Ixhora, and discovered a predilection for a squat old man from the Isle of Serendib, who was more ridiculous than any of the rest. (64) Reading Vathek, we might sense that the novel embraces, and even celebrates the monstrous for its own sake. However, this parade of religious ascetics from a variety of faiths as monstrous, because of their excess, sits uncomfortably with a gallery of those with physical disabilities: ‘At noon, a superb corps of cripples made its appearance; and soon after advanced, by platoons, on the plain, the completest association of invalids that had even been embodied till then’ (64). It is difficult to judge the tone of the writing here. Is the novel celebrating the diversity of humanity, including queer desires? Or is this another example of Fakreddin’s excessive generosity in contrast to Vathek’s selfcentredness? The ‘cripples’ are displayed after all to ‘extol the munificence of Fakreddin’ (64). At this point, the subtle suggestion that there is an element of freakish display is perhaps out of sympathy with a twenty-first century viewpoint of understanding and inclusiveness.18 Although there seems to exist an undercurrent of the enjoyment of breaking down the boundaries between reality and fantasy through the display of excess, this pleasure is problematic. Those who transgress boundaries, both physical and cultural, are ridiculed and often punished.
72 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
The Indian, for example, is a racial and social outsider, travelling from a region of India that is ‘wholly unknown’ (37). His ability to travel beyond boundaries and his physical mutability is a source of wonderment and terror. The Indian transgresses socio-cultural laws in that he refuses to submit to the will of Vathek’s gaze and to his authority. Metamorphosing himself into a self-propelling ball, his superhuman power enables him to defy Vathek. He leads him and his people like a magnet to the gulph of Catoul where he cannot be caught or contained. Refusing to name himself at Vathek’s command, he proves a challenge to Vathek’s power, because Vathek cannot penetrate or fix his fluid identity: ‘tell me who he is, from whence he came’ (32). The sabres the Indian brings with him, with their continually changing hieroglyphs, function as a metonym for how the demonic and evil are shown to operate. The hieroglyphs continually change their characters, a characteristic that is central to the ideology of the demonic.19 Inscribed or floating on the portal of the subterranean palace, the letters continuously alter their shape so no final signified can be attributed to them, which infuriates Vathek and cause him to lose his self-control, a sign of his masculinity. The signs that defy interpretation actually weaken him physiologically, challenging his masculinity: ‘The perplexing occupation inflamed his blood, dazzled his sight, and brought on such a giddiness and debility that he could hardly support himself’ (35). Vathek experiences dizziness and disorientation in looking upon the monstrous subject. The Giaour, an agent of Eblis and represented in monstrous human form by the Indian, offers Vathek the treasures of the pre-adamite sultans in a language of eroticized courtship calling him his ‘beloved’ (36) and asking ‘ “Wouldest thou devote thyself to me?” ’ (22), a phrase that is evocative of a kind of marriage. His stipulation for Vathek to obtain these treasures is that ‘I require the blood of fifty children’ and that they must be ‘the most beautiful sons of thy vizirs and great men’ (42) [my emphasis]. Vathek has to interpret who is the most physically attractive of his young male subjects. The scopophilic eye of the narrator suggests an erotic pleasure in the description of the scene: ‘The fifty competitors were soon stripped, and presented to the admiration of the spectators the suppleness and grace of their delicate limbs’ (43). In this pseudostriptease Vathek is positioned like a male pimp, serving to help the Devil: The Caliph, in the meanwhile, undressed himself by degrees; and, raising his arm as high as he was able, made each of the prizes glitter in the air; but, whilst he delivered it, with one hand, to the child,
Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
73
who sprung forward to receive it; he, with the other, pushed the poor innocent into the gulph; where the Giaour, with a sullen muttering, incessantly repeated; ‘more! more! (44) The landscape of the ‘yawning’ gulph and the boys being pushed into it is a metaphor for the act of sexual penetration between men. The cannibalistic sacrifice of the Giaour can be readily translated into sexual desire, as the imagery of eating as a displaced sexual desire is established early on. For instance, when the Indian arrives at Vathek’s court, Vathek is disturbed by his voracious hunger which he equates to sexual desire. He implies to Babalouk that he is terrified by the Indian’s fearlessness and hunger: ‘what would be the consequence should he get at my wives!’ (38). The Giaour is specifically linked to the demonic which is terrifying and monstrous. The sacrifice symbolizes an act of sexual desire that connotes the dark, the forbidden, the unknown and the terrible through the image of the bottomless chasm the victims are pushed into. The sacrifice of the 50 boys to the Giaour then acts as a condensed metaphor for anal sex incorporating eighteenth-century associations of sodomy with the demonic and the monstrous. Moreover, any act of penetration is explicitly tabooed in the novel. The eye of the general populace is forbidden to penetrate beyond the veils of the harem, to sexualize the Arabic woman’s body. Vathek’s curiosity to look into things, to build a tower of Babel, is expressly condemned as an ‘insolent curiosity of penetrating the secrets of heaven’ (31). Penetration, in almost any form, is formulated as transgressive. Vathek is afraid of how the Indian threatens to undermine his masculinity. It is implied that he challenges Vathek’s sexual prowess and his control and authority. An example of this is how the Indian meets the gaze of Vathek’s eye which is capable of literally killing his subjects when he gazes upon them. Richard Dyer comments on how the male gaze in film is a discourse through which sexual desire can be asserted and gender norms reinforced: ‘The idea of looking (staring) as power and being looked at as powerlessness overlaps with ideas of activity/passivity. Thus to look is thought of as active; whereas to be looked at is passive.’20 He goes on to argue: ‘it is the taboo of anal eroticism that causes masculine-defined men to construct penetration as frightening and the concept of male (hetero)sexuality as ‘taking’ a woman that constructs penetration as an act of violence’.21 The disembodied voice that Nouronihar overhears which describes Vathek constructs him as ‘masculine-defined’, in that Vathek’s penetrating look (and his height) is connected to an active sexual desire: ‘a prince six feet
74 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
high; and whose eyes pervade the inmost soul of a female, is inflamed with love for her’ (70). When Vathek meets Nouronihar for the first time, looking is signalled as a silent language of unspoken desire: ‘He approached Nouronihar with a throbbing heart, and seemed enraptured at the full effulgence of her radiant eyes, of which he had before caught a few glimpses: but she instantly depressed them, and her confusion augmented her beauty’ (70). At the entrance to the palace of subterranean fire, desire transcends the body or the material world through the gaze: ‘they gazed on each other with mutual admiration; and both appeared so resplendent, that they already esteemed themselves spiritual intelligences’ (91). Thus looking between men and women is established as indicating love and desire. By returning the look of Vathek, the Indian disturbs Vathek’s sense of his power which he needs to reassert more strongly and openly. Like Manfred in The Castle of Otranto, Vathek is another example of a hyperbolical masculinity. The excess of his posturing and actions suggests that he is not so assured in his masculinity as he would like others to believe: ‘Up, cowards! Seize the miscreant! See that he be committed to prison, and guarded by the best of my soldiers!’ [ ] No sooner had he uttered these words, than the stranger was surrounded, pinioned and bound with strong fetters, and hurried away to the prison of the great tower; which was encompassed by seven empalements of iron bars, and armed with spikes in every direction, longer and sharper than spits. The Caliph, nevertheless, remained in the most violent agitation. (32) [my emphasis] Even surrounded and imprisoned by such a potently phallic symbolism, Vathek still fears the Indian’s capacity to make him seem ineffectual. When he discovers the Indian is missing, his rage ‘exceeded all bounds’ and he kicks his guards interminably. Is kicking an inherently masculine act? If women kick, are they thought to be behaving like men? There is a sense that Vathek is performing his masculinity for all to see, to instil fear in his subjects and to maintain his power. This performativity also extends to the relationships with his wives. Vathek’s harem is never closed off completely, but rather his sexuality always has an audience that foregrounds the display of his virility. This occurs when Carathis comes across Nouronihar and Vathek in a sexual embrace. However, some of his wives seem to be chosen to test his
Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
75
masculinity. When he is forced to touch the soil while crossing the desert from Samarah, the narrator describes how: one of his Ethiopian wives (for he delighted in variety) clasped him in her arms; threw him upon her shoulder, like a sack of dates, and, finding that the fire was hemming them in, set off, with no small expedition, considering the weight of her burden. (56) [my emphasis] Assuming an active, masculine role, this woman suggests that Vathek’s masculinity and sexual interests are more ambiguous than at first appears. When he later sees Nouronihar’s body his reaction is more typical of a swooning heroine from the fiction of Sensibility: ‘With a trembling hand he raised the veil that covered the countenance of Nouronihar, and uttering a loud shriek, fell lifeless on the floor’ (73). Despite declaring that the character of Gulchenrouz has ‘been brought up too much on milk and sugar to stimulate my jealousy’ (77), Vathek is afraid that Nouronihar prefers Gulchenrouz to himself. He is disturbed by how Nouronihar prefers ‘the most delicate and lovely creature in the world’; she appears to reject a masculine identity that he believes women are attracted to. Gulchenrouz is characterized as effeminate and his display of feeling, his qualities of tenderness, softness and compassion are attractive to women. The narrator describes him as physically inept: ‘but his arms, which twined so gracefully with those of the young girls in the dance, could neither dart the lance in the chace [sic], nor curb the steeds that pastured in his uncle’s domains’ (66). He faints like a woman and, as Nouronihar informs us, he would not be able to endure the terror she is subjected to: ‘Dear Child! how would thy heart flutter with terror, wert thou wandering in these wild solitudes, like me!’ (69). His typically sensuous and refined accomplishments such as composing poetry, singing, dancing and drawing arabesques are expressive of his sensibility. While his natural father is away on a ‘voyage’ he is raised in the harem within the company of women. We can read Gulchenrouz within the discussion about the nature of effeminacy that predominated in the latter half of the eighteenth century. Gulchenrouz has all the characteristics that were perceived to define effeminacy but also men of feeling who were not necessarily queer.22 In the interrelationship between Vathek, Gulchenrouz and Nouronihar, the novel can be read alongside late eighteenth-century discussions about how effeminacy marks either an asexualism or a childlike innocence, and is imbricated with suspect sexual desires. The relationship between Gulchenrouz and Nouronihar is more maternal and
76 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
sensual; it is essentially desexualized. When Fakreddin organizes a staged death to fool Vathek, the text recalls the convention of the feigned death in Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet. This allusion to Shakespeare’s play romanticizes the innocence and sexual purity of their relationship. Gulchenrouz imagines an Edenic, pre-lapsarian scene with Nouronihar: Gulchenrouz was amused with the delusive hope of once more embracing Nouronihar, in the interior recesses of the mountains, where the ground, strewed over with orange blossoms and jasmines, offered beds much more inviting than the withered leaves in their cabin; where they might accompany with their voices, the sounds of their lutes, and chase butterflies. (78) What is imagined in Gulchenrouz’s childlike fantasy is an Arcadian scene that is erotic in its appeal to the senses, and romantic in its sensibility. It is however a delusion. There is an implication that Gulchenrouz has experienced sexual desire for Nouronihar: ‘for he was now persuaded he should actually be damned for having taken too many little freedoms, in his life-time, with his cousin’ (87). But Gulchenrouz’ ‘heterosexuality’ still arouses suspicion. This suspicion resides in the ambivalence about Gulchenrouz which is signified by his transvestism. The narrator observes how ‘when Gulchenrouz appeared in the dress of his cousin, he seemed to be more feminine than even herself’ (67). His gender reversal in his cross-dressing repulses Vathek: ‘as if it were less an honour for you to espouse the sovereign of the world, than a girl dressed up like a boy!’ (77). Vathek reverses Gulchenrouz’ sex – from boy into ‘girl’ – indicating his sense of confusion to Nouronihar even more pointedly. Carathis also implies that Gulchenrouz’ effeminacy is a sexual attraction for the Giaour: ‘This [sic] is nothing so delicious, in his estimation, as the heart of a delicate boy palpitating with the first tumults of love’ (83). The gender ambiguity of Gulchenrouz has been read as both morally dubious and affirmatively subversive.23 The subversive quality of Gulchenrouz lies in the confusion he causes over whether he is masculine or feminine. His ability to disturb Vathek’s unquestioned perception of heterosexual relations supports a reading of him as queer. It is specifically his ambivalence – that he might be asexual, a lover of his own sister and might be mistaken for a girl all at the same time – that asks for him to be nominated as queer. Transvestism is also the mode for reading how the relationship between two princes in one of the ‘Episodes’ of Vathek is queer.24
Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
77
In ‘The Story of Prince Alasi and the Princess Firouzkah’, an obsessively destructive relationship develops between prince Firouz who is a refugee in the protection of prince Alasi, while Firouz’ father fights Vathek’s troops who are supporting the rebels in his city. We discover that Firouz is in fact Firouzkah, and that she has been brought up as a boy because her father’s advisors feared a rebellion if the King Filanshaw did not produce a male heir. Nevertheless, Firouzkah/Firouz persists in performing as male. She lets Alasi see a cameo of herself and then explains that the picture is his twin sister and that she has been kept in hiding since the war with Vathek. The transvestism allows the possibility to read their friendship and attraction as queer. Firouzkah comments: ‘Alasi is insensible to a woman’s charm. It is in the guise of friendship that I must make him feel a woman’s power’ (49). It is after Firouz’ revelation of his sex as female that events take a turn for the worse and Alasi’s damnation is sealed.25 After they find themselves in the Palace of Subterranean Fire for religious persecution and the disfigurement of the Princess Rondabah, Alasi’s bride-to-be, Alasi reflects that Firouz/Firouzkah’s love needed to be masqueraded as friendship: ‘ but Love, which in its own shape would have been repelled, took Friendship’s shape, and in that shape effected my ruin’ (21). So the conclusion we perhaps reach about queer love or desire is a bit pessimistic. Neither a sexualized love (one that would be repelled) nor friendship leads to ‘that divine sojourn in which a happy eternity of mutual love and tenderness may be enjoyed’ (53). In keeping with the ambivalence surrounding Gulchenrouz in Vathek, the ambiguous gender is apotheosized as an ideal. Rondabah, the Princess of Ghilan to whom Alasi is betrothed from birth, possesses the best qualities of both genders: ‘Is it not said that the Princess of Ghilan unites to the fortitude, the courage of a man, all the charms of her sex? What more will you want when you possess her?’ (25). If it is accurate to describe how the implied same-sex desire between Alasi and Firouz/Firouzkah leads to corruption and evil further reinforces a reading of Vathek as a conforming to a conservative ideology of homophobia, then it is also true to say that this episode celebrates the figure who transgresses the gender boundary in Rondabah.26 In the unfinished third episode, ‘The Story of the Princess Zulkaïs and Prince Kalilah’, the theme of inseparability leading to a corruption of values is present again. Similarly, there is the implication that the combination of both features of the sexes from their spending too much time together leads to moral degeneracy. The monomaniacal Emir, Abou Taher Achmed, wishes to control the future and renounces Islam for
78 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
a belief in ancient Egyptian magical rites. Determined to bring up his son and daughter as ‘extraordinary beings’ (queer people perhaps?), Zulkaïs and Kalilah cannot endure separation from one another. The natural consequence of this inseparability is, supposedly, incest, with both of them ‘ always with eyes [sic] always looking into each other’s eyes’ (139). Perhaps, unsurprisingly, this unconventional upbringing is later regretted by the Emir. He berates his son’s lack of perceived manliness such as Kalilah’s disinterest for physical activity, in terms that are suggestive that Kalilah may well turn out to be a queer: Must the sun, as it rises and sets, see you only bloom and fade like a weak narcissus flower? . You are now nearly thirteen, and never have you evinced the smallest ambition to distinguish yourself among your fellow-men. It is not in the lurking haunts of effeminacy that great characters are formed; it is not by reading love poems that men are made to fit to govern nations! Princes must act; they must show themselves to the world. Awake! . I see well enough that it is she who is perverting you. (186) [my emphasis] The reference to ‘narcissus’ might remind us that the myth of Narcissus is often taken as a displacement for two men desiring one another, perhaps in an unattainable way. ‘Lurking’ effeminacy brings us back to how effeminates inspired fear, suggesting a shadowy life that is hidden from the eyes of others and not on full display with nothing to hide. The Emir wants to model Kalilah after ‘great characters’, who are active and whose masculinity is on display. Finally his call for him to cease ‘to haunt’ the company of his sister and to ‘Awake’ suggests that Kalilah’s developing effeminacy is vampiric. He is one of the undead whom she has perverted, with all the implications that term has for post-Freudian readers. The debate about the representation of the men of sensibility and effeminacy was largely fuelled by the suspicion that surrounded their sexual desires and practices in the late eighteenth century. This was particularly evident for example with a group of upper-class men who were referred to popularly as the ‘Macaronies’ throughout the 1770s and early 1780s. The ambiguity of these men rested in their physical appearance, dress and mannerisms and in their cultural interests, for instance an interest in Italian culture, particularly Roman art and history. Some could be taken to be foppish or queer as one writer observes: ‘If I consult the prints, ‘tis a figure with something uncommon in its dress or appearance; if the ladies, an effeminate fop; but if the ‘prentice-boys, a queer fellow with a great large tail.’27 As Rictor Norton explains, these were
Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
79
two different perceptions of the same man: one is an ‘effeminate fop’ and the other an ‘effeminate sodomite’. Queer obviously had a semantic currency in the 1770s to denote the reaction of working-class men to men who did not appear to be men, superficially at least. Even if they were married or had mistresses, as many of the macaronis probably did to screen their intense and intimate friendships with other men, or their cruising excursions, effeminate men still provoked suspicion. How they incurred the penetrating eyes of the moral guardians of society is indicated by the following diatribe: but Suspicion, that jealous, troublesome passion. Suspicion is got abroad – the carriage – the deportment – the dress – the effeminate squeak of the voice – the familiar loll upon each other shoulders – the gripe of the hand – the grinning in each others faces, to shew the whiteness of the teeth – in short, the manner altogether, and the figure so different from that of Manhood, these things conspire to create Suspicion; Suspicion gives birth to watchful observation; and, from a strict observance of the Maccaroni Tribe, we very naturally conclude, that to them we are indebted for the frequency of a crime which Modesty forbids me to name.28 Clothing, bodily gestures and movements, even eye contact perhaps, contained the potential for misreading and for ambiguity relating to sexual desire. In William Kenrick’s satire, Love in the Suds (1772), about the famous eighteenth-century playwright-manager David Garrick, we find an observation on the precariousness of the cruising practices that took place in and around St James’s Park: ‘Yet slight the cause of Nyky’s late mishap; Nyk but mistook the colour of the cap: A common errour, frequent in the Park, Where love is apt to stumble in the dark.’29 Misinterpretation of desires and intentions or looks is then a common occurrence for men who desire other men. Carter comments on how the sermon writer James Fordyce refers to the macaronis in the 1770s: ‘he [Fordyce] applied the term more generally and more seriously as a label for a faceless, but apparently very real breed of social miscreants’ [my emphasis].30 What Carter means by ‘social miscreants’ here is not explained but most probably refers to men soliciting in public places like St James’s Park. ‘Faceless’ implies a social invisibility and an absence of identity, and suggests that the confusion about reading the body whose desires resisted a secure classification in the eighteenth century is similar to our modern understanding of what it means to be queer.
80 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
In his Addresses to Young Men, Fordyce takes a social constructionist view of effeminacy, suggesting that effeminate types of men are the result of upbringing: Such, I am sure, is the natural tendency of the conduct we reprobate; nor can I help thinking, that we often perceive in the nursery the embryos of those distorted beings called fops, fribbles and cox-combs. So at least they were wont to be called: but it is one of our late refinements to give them an Italian appellation.31 [my emphasis] The ‘Italian appellation’ referred to here is the macaroni. A silent suspicion of the existence of a hazy continuum between effeminacy and same-sex desire is also implied by Fordyce: I am in earnest when I say, that the lax nerves, the ludicrous decorations, the affected jargon, the trivial conceits, the courtly simper, the soft insipidity and the unfeeling heart, of the thing now termed a — but no, I will not name it — may generally, in the first instance be attributed to the effects of the nursery.32 The refusal to name the macaroni invokes the idea of unspeakable sin suggesting that Fordyce, as a Christian writer, is perhaps also referring to sodomy. What is revealing is how he anticipates that his argument of a connection between early education, effeminacy and possibly same-sex desire will not be taken seriously by his protest that he is ‘in earnest’. The heteronormative family and how it educates its sons and daughters may be responsible for bringing into society the ‘distorted beings’ that Fordyce and others condemn. ‘Distorted’ brings us back again to the idea of queer as referring to twisting. Effeminacy is also a recurring example in eighteenth-century debates about luxury and one of the central themes of luxury. I would argue that the censorious conservatism, which the novel states about luxurious excess, is also central to shaping Vathek as Gothic writing. Vathek is ultimately conservative in approaching bodies and sexualities that disturb the categories of masculinity and femininity and heteronormative relations. Moral degeneracy of the individual and the state are linked to problematic bodies and desires. Vathek complains to Fakreddin about Nouronihar’s choice of Gulchenrouz as a husband: ‘would you surrender this divine beauty to a husband more womanish than herself; and can you imagine, that I will suffer her charms to decay in hands so inefficient and nerveless?’ (71) [my emphasis]. The physical presence and effect of
Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
81
Gulchenrouz’s gender ambiguity would cause Nouronihar’s own body to decay, perhaps a process that invokes the idea of the body becoming a corpse or monstrous-like. Vathek characterizes Gulchenrouz’s body in terms of a degeneration that echoes writing about the effect of luxury on masculinity in the eighteenth century. The Scottish philosopher and lawyer, Henry Home, Lord Kames’s study of the ‘progress’ of various aspects of Western society, Sketches on the History of Man, characterizes luxury as creating an excessive, self-perpetuating desire that causes individual and social morality to degenerate: The luxury of a great city descends from the highest to the lowest, infecting all ranks of men; and there is little opportunity in it for such exercise as renders the body vigorous and robust superfluity of animal spirits, and love of pleasure, form a character the most liable to vice.33 As with eighteenth-century writers who condemned transgressive sexual behaviour, Kames employs an ideology of human development that is founded on an ideology of ‘natural’ behaviour. For example, he argues that marriage arises from how children are necessarily helpless, and that promiscuity in men and women is unnatural compared to the behaviour of animals: ‘pairing in the strictest sense is a law of nature among men as among wild birds and that polygamy is a gross infringement of this law’.34 Within the eighteenth century there was a broad evaluative change in the concept of luxury situated within a political and/or economic discourse to a moral discourse.35 As the century progressed, the term ‘luxury’ came to stand in for what was perceived to be socially undesirable behaviour such as adultery and same-sex desire. Kames’s evaluation of the way luxury leads to immorality is noticeable for how luxury is linked to effeminacy through assumptions that luxury made the male body physically soft, voluptuous and less restrained in its sexual appetite. Berry’s observation points up how this came to be associated with sexual behaviour which went beyond the heteronormative marriage bed: What connects these two concerns [luxury and effeminacy] is the classical link between luxury and effeminacy. While the ancients were, on balance, more concerned with the lack of military virtue exhibited by the effeminate, in the modern period the lack of procreative potency associated with the effeminate came to the fore.36
82 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
This concern over sexual behaviour(s) that are not focused on procreativity, and which might displace a social organization centred around marriage and children, is voiced by James Fordyce who characterizes luxury as ‘without limitation and without end’ (115) and: tending to alienate the heart from the company of the wife and worthy, from the duties and joys of domestic life; [ ] to beget a disrelish for virtuous attachments in those that are not married, to supplant affection in those that are, [ ] when this is the case, can you easily conceive a more alarming symptom, or a more fatal perversion.37 [my emphasis] Fordyce warns his readers specifically about adulterous relations as a result of the corrupting force of effeminacy through luxury. However, there is an implied concern over how luxury produces a lack of boundaries that might be connected to the boundaries of the body and the expression of any sexual desires and practices considered to be beyond the pale. There is an unexpressed fear over the regulation of bodies and desires which are characterized by excess. Read in terms of how late nineteenth-century sexologists and psychiatry pathologized same-sex desire, Fordyce anticipates a Freudian ideology of perversion. By contrast, Vathek can also be perceived as an example of the debilitating effects of luxury that Kames and Fordyce discuss. However, luxury does not effeminize him in the sense that we may think that he is attracted to men, even if he is in love with a certain kind of tyrannical, machismo image of himself. We are told that ‘Notwithstanding the sensuality in which Vathek indulged, he experienced no abatement in the love of his people, who thought that a sovereign giving himself up to pleasure, was as able to govern, as one who declared himself an enemy to it’ (30). It would seem then that Vathek’s self-indulgence is not incompatible with ruling the state of Samarah, in contrast to a Kamesian theory that the individuals pursuit of luxury and his effeminacy corrupted the political state at large. Vathek would seem to engage in a fantasy of the public and private spheres being erased for the political leader. However, this is exposed by the narrator to be a naïve aspiration. Vathek abandons Samarah for self-gratification, chaos ensues and he is punished in hell. He neglects the worlds of business and government because of his desire for luxury and sensuality, as expressed by his building the palaces of the five senses. His ability to rule is degraded and enfeebled by the appetite that controls him. Although we are told he ‘rarely gave way to his anger’ (29), this is contradicted by how Vathek is a victim to
Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
83
his passions. The implication of sexual degeneracy is present in Vathek’s sacrifice of the 50 boys to the Giaour as a means to gain what he wants. Elfenbein notes that there is an element of seduction between Vathek and the Giaour which contains an erotic charge: ‘an especially bizarre version of the casual homoeroticism endemic to market relations themselves, in which men must attract other men to buy them’.38 Vathek has to lure and seduce his people through a display of luxury. By having a feast, Vathek is able to attract the boys to the edge of the gulph for the Giaour to devour them. Throughout the novel, the moral status of the characters is figured in typically Romantic images of ascension and descension. The narrator ironizes Vathek’s view of his masculinity as morally superior to the effeminacy of Gulchenrouz. Both the fates of Vathek and Nouronihar to end up in hell are predetermined by Allah, whom the narrator permits us, but not Vathek, to overhear in Allah’s judgement of Vathek’s ‘irreligious conduct’ (4). Allah allows Vathek to continue blindly in his pursuit of power by preventing him falling into the chasm after the Indian: ‘an invisible agency arrested his progress’ (40). Vathek’s autonomy, his belief in his own active self-empowerment and ambition, is thus shown to be an illusion. He fails to perceive that his decisions are controlled and determined by a higher destiny. For example he does not interpret his raging thirst as a warning to himself. No less does Nouronihar, who, after following the omen of the moving light, eavesdrops on her potential fate in the dialogue between the two divinities, which turns out for the worse. Her choice of Vathek as a partner proves ironic in that through renouncing Gulchenrouz whom she hears described as a false, inverted version of masculinity, she finds herself condemned with Vathek in a place characterized by excess. Vathek descends the stairway into the subterranean palace of Eblis to damnation, while Gulchenrouz is apotheosized by the Genius and, along with the 50 boys sacrificed to the Giaour, ascends to heaven: ‘Remote from the inquietudes of the world; the impertinence of harems, the brutality of eunuchs, and the inconstancy of women; there he found a place truly congenial to the delights of his soul’ (85). This vision of an innocent, homosocial heaven contrasts with the mutual torment Vathek and Nouronihar experience in the subterranean palace: In the midst of this immense hall, a vast multitude was incessantly passing; who severally kept their right hands on their hearts; without once regarding any thing around them [ ] Some stalked slowly on; absorbed in profound reverie; some shrieking with agony, ran
84 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
furiously about like tigers, wounded with poisoned arrows; whilst others, grinding their teeth in rage, foamed along more frantic than the wildest maniac. They all avoided each other, and, though surrounded by a multitude that no one could number, each wandered at random, unheedful of the rest. (92) The pattern of inversion reaches its apex in the descriptions of the palace of Eblis recalling Vathek’s palaces in its vastness. Unrestrained desire is symbolized in the sublime architectural imagery of the palace, the limits of which cannot be seen: ‘all without bounds or limits [ ] all adorned with the same awful grandeur’ (95). Like the continually-changing characters on the sabres, hell is characterized by bodies that are deteriorating physically and psychologically and which cannot be understood by one another. It is not so much sexuality or the direct expression of tabooed sexual desires that is being punished, but those bodies which represent excess and defy understanding, and whose uncontainability might represent the possibility of sexual transgressions too. Vathek does not confine itself to the implication that only queer male bodies are linked to the demonic and the monstrous; it suggests that women can be queer too. Randall Craig argues that: ‘the novel envisions a parity between genders, with the implications that the faults of ambition and pride are not exclusive to masculinity’.39 Carathis, Vathek’s mother, is the first evil female character we find in Gothic writing. As a witch and a necromancer she connotes deviance and a dominant sexuality, traditionally associated with masculinity. Carathis displays ‘masculine’ qualities in the use of her intellect. She is ‘a person of superior genius’ (33). Advising Vathek on how to avoid the anger of the mob, the narrator judges her to be deceptive and dominating: ‘This Princess was so far from being influenced by scruples, that she was as wicked, as woman could be’ (45). The suggestion is that her evil unsexes her like Lady Macbeth in Shakespeare. Her femininity is also inscribed within traditional associations with the demonic. Morakanabad, Vathek’s ‘prime vizier’, is suspicious of her duplicity and her capacity to change her form and shape like the Devil: ‘Nor did he know well what to think of Carathis, who, like a chameleon, could assume all possible colours’ (50). Her ‘cursed eloquence’ is reminiscent of the characterization of Satan by Milton. Described as ‘chastity in the abstract, and an implacable enemy to love intrigues’ (82), Carathis, like Vathek, is also sadistic. Pursuing Vathek to the city of Ishtakar, we are told that ‘Carathis enjoyed most whatever filled others with dread’ (80). She suggests to Vathek the emasculating
Vathek and the Monstrous Queer
85
idea of burning the beards of those who feign to interpret the cryptic writing on the sabres. She also enjoys letting poisonous snakes bite her friends and then ‘amused herself in curing their wounds’. Part of her moral depravity is the implied incestuous desire for her son, evident in her extreme rage and hatred for Nouronihar: ‘Thou double-headed and four-legged monster! what means all this winding and writhing? art thou not ashamed to be seen grasping this limber sapling; in preference to the sceptre of the pre-adamite sultans? (82–83) The accusation of monstrosity levelled against Vathek reveals how the manifestation of sexual desire for her son by another woman reflects her own unconscious desire for him. Carathis’s desire is figured in metaphorical terms when we read the description of her lighting a fire at the top of the tower to perform a magical rite on behalf of her son: The oil gushed forth in a plenitude of streams; and the negresses, who supplied it without intermission, united their cries to those of the Princess. At last, the fire became so violent, and the flames reflected from the polished marble so dazzling, that the Caliph, unable to withstand the heat and the blaze, effected his escape; and took shelter under the imperial standard. (47) This event is a metaphor for masturbation: the fire and the ‘cries’ of Carathis can be interpreted as sexual passion. The fact that Vathek cannot watch the ecstasy of his mother suggests that he experiences a sublimated incestuous desire for her. He is rendered passive by it: ‘he fell down in a swoon’ (47). Alternatively, he may need to escape from a situation in which the public expression of female desire supplants male sexuality because he cannot control it. This magical ceremony of Carathis produces a magnificent feast, enabling him to satiate his gluttony. If we accept that eating is established as a metaphor for the satisfaction of sexual desire in the novel, the relationship between Carathis and Vathek takes an incestuous turn, albeit an implicit one. In the palace of Eblis, Soliman Ben Douad tells Vathek a story which is a warning against the potential of men’s excessive desire for women to destabilize male power. Vathek blames his mother for his principles being ‘perverted’ and for his punishment in hell, but should he be blaming Nouronihar according to Douad’s experience? In spite of the moralistic tone of the narrator warning against the transgressive power
86 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
of excess, the narrator does not discriminate and suggest blame be apportioned to either men or women: ‘Such was, and such should be, the punishment of unrestrained passions and atrocious deeds! Such shall be the chastisement of that blind curiosity, which would transgress those bounds the wisdom of the Creator has prescribed to human knowledge’ (97). If we can include same-sex desire among ‘unrestrained passions and atrocious deeds’ (120) then the novel would seem to reinforce a conservative, implicitly homophobic stance against same-sex desire. Translation and transgression – the two are related through reading the body of the queer, particularly the effeminate male who baffles the gaze of the reading public and the killing eyes of Vathek. The overarching narrative of Vathek’s story is that an unregulated, private desire that questions the boundaries of a hierarchical order or consumes itself at the expense of the individual or public welfare is destructive. Looking at the novel momentarily as an example of the Oriental genre, one of the key aspects of that genre is that the stories are a displaced reflection or exploration of Western civilization and its fears and concerns. In this way, Orientalist fiction shares similarities to Gothic writing in the act of displacement – Radcliffe, Lewis and Maturin’s novels all take place in displaced settings, even if they are less geographically and culturally distant than the Middle East. Vathek offers a fictionalized engagement with how queer bodies and desires in the late eighteenth century came increasingly to be described in terms of monstrosity. The figure of the Indian and the Giaour are two of the earliest monsters who represent queer sexuality. Vathek’s attempts to decipher the Indian and his sabres with the hieroglyphics reflect the societal vigilance and paranoia of late eighteenth-century society about effeminacy and queer desire. The questions and doubts are those Judith Halberstam identifies: ‘The reading subject (but also the characters and seemingly the writer) of the Gothic is constructed out of a kind of paranoia about boundaries: do I read or am I written? Am I monster or monster-maker? Am I monster hunter or the hunted? Am I human or other?’40 Vathek explores the question of interpreting those identities and bodies that are ambiguous or confusing in their gender. An irreducibility of gender is often formulated in terms of the supernatural and an ideology of evil, and makes the novel Gothic. It suggests an unholy alliance with a homophobic ideology, one which scrutinizes and destroys the queer body that will not permit its desires to be defined and regulated by the authoritarian discourses of law, religion and a heteronormative culture.
4 Camping in the Monastery: The Monk
The Monk (1795) contains just about every conceivable possibility of anti-heteronormative sexual interests: incest, sado-masochism, autoeroticism, necrophilia, voyeurism and same-sex desire.1 Meanwhile, an ambiguously gendered, Cagliostro-like figure destroys the reputation of a symbol of a tyrannical and repressive institution that regulates its members’ sexuality. What more could one ask for? Rosario/Matilda’s infiltration of the monastery, where she temporarily camps out (and camps it up) to tempt the abbot Ambrosio, is queer in the act of appropriating certain gender characteristics to unsettle the patriarchal order. Specifically, Matilda’s gender indeterminacy and her playful manipulation of whether she is male or female and Ambrosio’s perception are the keys to unlocking the queer vault of this most self-consciously shocking of novels. There have been recent attempts to penetrate into this vault by exploring how the initial attraction between Rosario/Matilda and Ambrosio can be read.2 One strand of Clara Tuite’s argument is that ‘not everything is “laid bare” in The Monk. What The Monk does not uncover, what it does not present in “libidinousness minuteness” is the romance plot of monastic male homoeroticism’.3 The reader is left to decipher the descriptions, speeches and characterization of Rosario (or Matilda) and Ambrosio in the opening of the novel before Rosario reveals that he is Matilda. The first description of Rosario emphasizes that there is a ‘Mystery’ surrounding him. The amorphous, shapeless effect of the cowl he wears makes his gender ambiguous for Ambrosio who has no reason to suppose that Rosario is female. However, the reader may be aware of how Gothic writing plays upon Shakespearean conventions and may expect a reversal. We are told that ‘He seemed fearful of being recognized, and no one had ever seen his face’ (42). Timidity and his 87
88 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
lack of participation in the activities of the monastery set him apart as different: ‘The Youth had carefully avoided the company of the Monks’ (42). If some eighteenth-century men gravitated towards homosocial communities, like the monastery or the navy, as places where same-sex love could be sublimated or sometimes acted upon, then there is already in place a space in which to read Rosario as queer.4 Rosario’s name also resonates with gender ambiguity. As Stephen Blakemore points out: ‘Even the endings of both names (Rosario–Ambrosio) suggestively link both “males” together, in scenes that are homoerotic.’5 These early scenes are mildly homoerotic, but they are also queer in that they can be read to contain a surplus of desire and emotion between two men that cannot be adequately explained by the narrative framework of their relationship as father and son, teacher and pupil. The intensity of Rosario’s emotional melancholia about his secret is also suggestive of the unspeakable secret of desire for Ambrosio. There are also literary ghosts present in the queer vault whose presence supports the queerness of their relationship. The declaration by Rosario/Matilda that he is female occurs in a garden monastery, the description of which strongly recalls Milton’s Eden in Paradise Lost: ‘the walls were entirely covered by Jessamine, vines and Honeysuckles. The hour now added to the beauty of the scene.’ This recalls the ‘blissful bower’ of Adam and Eve in Paradise: and each odorous bushy shrub Fenced up the verdant wall; each beauteous flower, Iris all hues, roses, and jessamine Reared high their flourished heads between, and wrought Mosaic;6 When Ambrosio advises Rosario that misanthropy will make him unhappy, his pedagogical relationship to Rosario represents an inverted parody of Adam and Eve where Adam lectures Eve on Sin. After Rosario’s revelation, when Matilda is about to leave the garden, Ambrosio is bitten by a serpent that lies ‘Concealed among the Roses’ (71). Ideas of death, sin and sexual knowledge are concentrated in this overdetermined symbol which is derived from Milton. The implications of this literary trope now shift the connotations with Eve from Rosario to Ambrosio, so that ‘Ambrosio is also explicitly presented as a male Eve who acts entirely out of lust’.7 Rosario is characterized as effeminate in his taste for flower arranging in Ambrosio’s cell and in his subservient role. Rosario’s personality and
Camping in the Monastery
89
behaviour are confusing for Ambrosio. His actions and his melancholia suggest an effeminacy which Ambrosio finds intriguing and attractive without being able to explain why. The relationship between Ambrosio and Rosario is also one of mutual attraction: ‘Ambrosio on his side did not feel less attracted towards the Youth’ (42) even though this is qualified by ‘He loved him with all the affection of a Father. He could not help sometimes indulging a desire secretly to see the face of his Pupil’ (43). After Rosario is on the point of declaring what we might anticipate to be love for Ambrosio, he goes to pray at Vespers, a service for early evening prayers marked by the appearance of the evening star of Venus, and of course symbolizing the Roman goddess of love. When Rosario reveals that he is in fact Matilda, a woman, it would appear that this revelation closes this narrative of homoerotic attraction. Tuite, for instance, argues that from this point of revelation the text splits into two structures of sexuality: From the moment at which homoerotic desire is buried under a tableau of heterosexual libidinal excess, two distinct sexual economies are generated within the text: one of orgiastic excess, and one repressed or marked by the operations of the closet. These are the conflicting dynamics that mark the circulation of hetero- and homosexual economies, respectively.8 In fact, it is not so easy to perceive these economies as separate; it is the ‘excess’ of the heterosexual economy that undermines its description as ‘heterosexual’. Its excess signifies that there is something which we can call queer about the straight relationships depicted, although this is to move towards a queer reading that encompasses those polymorphous perverse aspects of sexuality that the novel expresses.9 We must also remember that Matilda is still an ambiguous figure. Is she a woman or a supernatural demon in the guise of a woman? Rosario’s confession represents for many a classic coming-out scene, where the truth about one’s sexual identity and desires is revealed to others. A queer reader would strongly anticipate that Rosario will declare that he loves Ambrosio, because of the emphasis given to unspeakability and his ‘unaccountable behaviour’ (45). His silence is determined by his fear of Ambrosio’s potential disgust and hatred: ‘Ah! Father, how willingly would I unveil to you my heart! How willingly would I declare the secret, which bows me down with its weight! But Oh! I fear I fear!’ (58). This primary event of the novel can be interpreted like a palimpsest, where the erasure of same-sex desire occurs in the change
90 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
of sex, but the traces and echoes of this initial suspicion of attraction still reside in the reader’s memory. The narrator implies that Ambrosio resists acknowledging his desire for Rosario even as Matilda: ‘Still less did He perceive that his heart throbbed with desire, while his hand was pressed gently by Matilda’s ivory fingers’ (62). From the point at which Matilda threatens to stab herself unless he agrees for her to remain in the monastery, Ambrosio’s sexual desire is associated with the death of femininity. Ambrosio’s desire for Antonia, as both a fetishized body and one who is dead and buried, develops out of a homophobic need for control over those bodies like Rosario/Matilda. Femininities are the source of physical horror and supernatural terror in The Monk, and return us to the suspicion and fear surrounding effeminacy at the turn of the nineteenth century. The manner in which the female body is eroticized through the eyes of the narrator, and the destructive, graphic descriptions of the successive deaths of the Abbess, Elvira and Antonia position women as victims. The sources of the novel also reside partly in French pornographic texts such as Joseph Marsollier’s Camille, or The Vault (1791) and Jacques Marie Boutet de Monvel’s The Cloistered Victims (1791). To a certain extent this confirms the accusation that the novel titillates its male readership in its pornographic overtones.10 Nevertheless, the representation of the maternal is another important aspect of how femininity and masculinity are shown to be complex conditions. The maternal woman is complicated in The Monk. She is represented in turn as a victim, a sacrifice and a survivor who overcomes death. The narrative of the subplot with Agnes and the Prioress envisages the maternal in terms of physical horror. What makes one question that the text is pointing at something beyond its generic limitation of exposing a corrupt Catholic institution and its inhabitants is how the descriptions are designed to arouse horror. Agnes breaks her vow of chastity with Raymond in the convent garden and plans to escape. The discovery by Ambrosio of her elopement and her illegitimate unborn baby bring down a harsh exercise of his power over her by him: ‘Shall St. Clare’s Convent become the retreat of Prostitutes? Shall I suffer the Church of Christ to cherish in its bosom debauchery and shame?’ (46). In Ambrosio’s rhetorical question, Agnes is positioned like an infant within the mother Church’s ‘bosom’. This occurs in the interval between Rosario telling Ambrosio he has a secret and the unveiling of Rosario in the monastery garden. Thus, we might see Ambrosio’s exposure of Agnes as a displaced reaction to what he fears Rosario will tell him. In condemning Agnes, Ambrosio recalls the excessive hyperbolical
Camping in the Monastery
91
masculinity of the tyrants Manfred in Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto and Vathek in William Beckford’s novel. This tyranny conflicts with his attempt to understand Rosario. By moving into the position of the exposer (as opposed to the powerless, anticipatory position of the listener), Ambrosio resists a move into another closet with the knowledge of Agnes’s pregnancy. While Ambrosio focuses specifically on her sexual sin, she emphasizes her maternal status ‘I shall soon become a Mother’ (47) and it is as a mother that she curses him: ‘You are my Murderer, and on you fall the curse of my death and my unborn Infant’s!’ (48–49). When Ambrosio subsequently murders Elvira, which Lucifer reveals later on to be matricide, the repeated occurrences of Ambrosio’s sexual desire being linked with the death of the maternal is maintained. There are parallels to be found in other Gothic writing by Lewis, in particular his immensely popular play The Castle Spectre (1798) where the villain, Osmond, is tortured by a vision of the ghost, Evelina, his sister-in-law, whom he has murdered 16 years ago and whose husband is imprisoned in the dungeons of the castle: While speaking, her form withered away: the flesh fell from her bones; her eyes burst from their sockets: a skeleton, loathsome and meagre, clasped me in her mouldering arms! [ ] Her infected breath was mingled with mine; her rotting fingers pressed my hand, and my face was covered with her kisses!11 Evelina is characterized as a Madonna-like figure, especially in the stage directions when she appears as an omen to her daughter Angela, whom Osmond is trying to seduce: ‘the Oratory is seen illuminated. In its center stands a tall female figure, her white and flowing garments spotted with blood [ ] her eyes are lifted upwards, her arms extended towards heaven, and a large wound appears upon her bosom’ (79). She also acts with divine intervention to save Osmond from stabbing Reginald, Angela’s father. This mixture of the iconography of religious female figures with the images of suffering and death is also central to The Monk. At the very matrix of the narrative and the convent is the imprisoned Agnes, over whom the Prioress has performed a mock burial. In the ‘Conclusion of the History of Agnes de Medina’, narrated by Agnes, the description of the dying child she holds to her breast provokes physical revulsion in the auditors and the reader. The Prioress’s cruelty and sadism contradict her position as a symbolic figure of motherhood. Her ambition, cunning and violent reputation invert the model of selfless
92 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
femininity she professes to follow. Consistent with the novel’s pattern of inverting familiar iconography, the image of Agnes and her child plays upon a pictorial tradition of the Madonna and child, inverting its image of divine beauty and love into one of horror and death designed to arouse disgust: It soon became a mass of putridity, and to every eye was a loathsome and disgusting Object; To every eye but a Mother’s. In vain did human feelings bid me recoil from this emblem of mortality with repugnance: I with-stood, [sic] and vanquished that repugnance. I persisted in holding my Infant to my bosom, in lamenting it, loving it, adoring it! (412–413) Agnes supposedly implies that this maternal devotion was a state of madness – ‘reason at length prevailed’ (413) – but while she is imprisoned she does not share the perception by the other nuns that the body of the child is ‘disgusting’. It is disgusting to ‘every eye but a Mother’s’. Agnes’s narrative suggests more widely that monstrosity is only in the eye of the beholder and argues against a social pressure to reject the child. In allowing Agnes to survive, and giving her a voice (albeit one of a ventriloquist in sounding similar to the narrator), there is the suggestion that Agnes’s defiance represents a challenge to the homosocial order of things in loving a child, which in the eyes of others is monstrous and disgusting. Femininity is a contested category in the novel. Women who transgress the boundary between femininity and masculinity, and who articulate their sexual desire publicly are the target of the narrator’s satire and ridicule. In the opening scene in the Capuchin Cathedral, Antonia’s aunt, Leonella, aggressively ‘penetrates’ through the congregation ‘By dint of perseverance and two brawny arms’ (8). The contrast between Leonella’s feminine voice and her physicality, which verges on the masculine, is emphasized when Raymond and Lorenzo meet her. However, the reversal of their expectations has a comic effect against them too. This reversal suggests that her voice frustrates the association between the supposed characteristics of a feminine voice, softness, lightness with soprano notes, and its alignment with a female body: ‘Hearing this appeal to their politeness pronounced in a female voice, they interrupted their conversation to look at the speaker [ ] Her hair was red, and She squinted. The Cavaliers turned around and renewed their conversation’ (9). Leonella’s voice which arouses their attention contradicts the expectation of beauty they expect to see so that she no longer
Camping in the Monastery
93
becomes an object of interest. Leonella’s status as an ‘old maid’, who is self-sufficient, renouncing sexual or economic dependence upon men, is mocked: ‘I always knew how to keep the men at a proper distance.’ ‘Of that, Segnora, I have not the least doubt’ (15). She is at the same time a stereotype of the garrulous, older woman and a woman who protests against another stereotype – a meek and submissive femininity – such as Antonia: ‘Indeed, as her Niece was generally silent in her company, She thought it incumbent upon her to talk enough for both: This She managed without difficulty, for She very seldom found herself deficient in words’ (15). One detects here a tone of sarcastic bitterness which does not quite square with what is supposed to be comedy.12 The desire to silence the assertive female voice occurs when Raymond arranges for Agnes’s tyrannical chaperone, Dame Cunegonda, to be literally gagged while he plans Agnes’s escape. One must also remember that Raymond is narrating this part of the plot retrospectively to Lorenzo, and that it is designed to justify his elopement with Agnes. Therefore, his portrayal of Donna Rodolpha, Agnes’s aunt, is designed to silence her version of the events. It is important to Raymond to preserve his friend’s approval of his honour, integrity and reputation as a suitor, which defines Raymond’s masculinity. Thus, the homosocial investment of the narration of these events is strong; Donna Rodolpha’s public condemnation is a threat to him. Donna Rodolpha’s tyrannical imperiousness recalls the tyrants of hyper-masculinity Manfred and Vathek, and reverses the active/passive role of husband and wife: ‘Her Husband paid her the most absolute submission, and considered her as a superior Being [ .] Her passions were violent: She spared no pains to gratify them, and pursued with unremitting vengeance those who opposed themselves to her wishes’ (133). The ridicule of Rodolpha continues when she mistakes Raymond’s gallantry for the language of desire. Declaring her passion for Raymond, he clarifies his intentions towards her and she feels humiliated ‘you have mistaken for the solicitude of Love what was only the attention of Friendship’ (136). Through the veil of heterosexual courtship, we can see that friendship between men or between women might be taken for love, and vice-versa. Both Leonella and Donna Rodolpha are different examples of women who are ridiculed and portrayed as threatening, because they fluctuate between being both masculine and feminine. Over the course of the novel, this depiction of the woman’s voice which silences the male can be traced back to the persuasive rhetoric of Matilda and the relative silence of Ambrosio after Matilda announces she is female.13 The fear that the silencing female voice inspires in men might be explained by how a silenced man
94 Queering Gothic in the Romantic Age
destabilizes a male claim to power through possession and control of a symbolic language of patriarchy. There is also the implication that if a man is attracted to a woman who embodies the social and linguistic attributes normally apportioned to men, then perhaps he may prefer to romance a man instead. Matilda’s queerness precipitates Ambrosio’s final violation and murder of Antonia and her mother. Matilda effectively reverses Rosario’s submissive masculinity into the aggressive, persuasive femininity of Matilda. This change is marked by a move from Rosario’s silence to Matilda’s questioning verbal presence that disturbs Ambrosio. Joseph Andriano suggests that Matilda undergoes a progressive gender transformation and becomes increasingly masculinized, and that in vampire folklore: ‘the symbol of absolute, aggressive evil was seen as male, whereas many lesser demons were androgynes’.14 Peter Grudin has also shown that the mythical basis for Matilda’s androgyny resides in the tradition of the vampiric Incubus-Succubus where ‘the term is hyphenated because it denotes alternate forms of the same essence’.15 The alternate forms denote masculinity and femininity in the sexual positions they adopt towards the victim. And as noted above, Matilda is also linked with the image of Satan as the seducer, tempting Eve in the garden. Matilda describes her education and upbringing as unconventional in her material freedom and her power to marry whom she chooses. Within the context of eighteenth-century educational theory and practice, her instruction would have been more suited to a young man: ‘Under his instructions my understanding acquired more strength and justness, than generally falls to the lot of my sex’ (60). Ambrosio terms her an ‘Enchantress’, associating her with the idea of the witch, a powerful cultural symbol of a fear of the feminine, and he acknowledges his passivity towards her. She places him in an impossible situation by threatening suicide as the result of his rejection and declares her intention to expose her situation to the brotherhood. It is analogous to the older queer in a position of authority who fears exposure by a younger male, in that Matilda blackmails him with her suicide threat. At the point of trying to kill herself, Ambrosio is sexually awakened to her as suggested by the narrator’s eroticizing eye: ‘She had tore open her habit, and her bosom was half exposed. The weapon’s point rested upon her left breast: And Oh! that was such a breast! The Moon-beams darting full upon it, enabled the Monk to observe its dazzling whiteness’ (65). The whiteness of the spectacle of Matilda’s flesh (and, for example, The Bleeding Nun who haunts Raymond) can signal a desire for the
Camping in the Monastery
95
absence of femininity.16 The narrator repeatedly emphasizes Ambrosio’s powerlessness: ‘He found it impossible’, ‘He was incapable’, ‘He was irresolute’. Ambrosio’s fear of a tangible, dominant femininity leads him to a position of weakness: ‘He began to feel that He was not proof against temptation’ (68). The wish for the absence of Matilda/Rosario’s problematic gender is also evident in how Ambrosio expresses affection for Matilda as Rosario, even after he believes that she is female: ‘He remembered, the many happy hours which He had passed in Rosario’s society, and dreaded that void in his heart which parting with him would occasion’ (66) [my emphasis]. After the description of their lovemaking, Ambrosio acts as if Matilda is still Rosario reassuring Father Pablos that Rosario is recovering from the snake-bite in the garden. Later, although Ambrosio ‘forbore to show that it affected him’, the narrator describes Ambrosio’s susceptibility to Rosario/Matilda’s ‘soft melanchol