7556tpCast.indd 1
11/4/09 11:24:48 AM
This page intentionally left blank
7556tpCast.indd 2
11/4/09 11:24:49 AM
...
78 downloads
1734 Views
8MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
7556tpCast.indd 1
11/4/09 11:24:48 AM
This page intentionally left blank
7556tpCast.indd 2
11/4/09 11:24:49 AM
Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224 USA office: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Biennial Reviews of Fusion Physics — Vol. 1 RELAXATION DYNAMICS IN LABORATORY AND ASTROPHYSICAL PLASMAS Copyright © 2010 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN-13 978-981-4291-54-5 ISBN-10 981-4291-54-4
Printed in Singapore.
Lakshmi - Relaxation Dynamics.pmd
1
9/30/2009, 1:41 PM
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
In 2003, three of the most distinguished and brightest plasma physicists passed away: Professor Marshall Rosenbluth, Professor Masihiro Wakatani and Doctor Ren´e Pellat. This book is dedicated to them.
v
BkFestival2003
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Foreword
The material for this book was written shortly after the second “Festival de Th´eorie,” held in Aix-en-Provence (France) in July 2003. This Festival de Th´eorie was initiated in 2000 by Jean Jacquinot, and Ren´e Pellat chaired the Director Committee. From the very beginning, the Festival de Th´eorie was also supported by Professor Masihiro Wakatani and Professor Marshall Rosenbluth. But Professor Masihiro Wakatani, Professor Marshall Rosenbluth and Doctor Ren´e Pellat passed away in 2003. This book is dedicated to them. A specific article addresses the crucial achievements of Professor M. Wakatani. Tributes to the outstanding contributions of M. Rosenbluth and R. Pellat will be paid in the following volumes of the series. The Festival de Th´eorie has taken place every two years in Aix-enProvence, since 2001. Its scientific committee is chaired by Professor Patrick Diamond and co-chaired by Doctor Xavier Garbet. This international meeting gathers during three weeks about 30 senior experts on well-focused subjects in magnetised plasma physics, both in controlled fusion and in astrophysics. The objective is three-fold. First, the participants present the most recent results in the field and promote new ideas. Secondly, subgroups are formed and start new common work on the subject. The third objective is to provide educational training for PhD and post-doc students. This latter is being given a growing attention, and dedicated lectures are being organised for the younger physicists. This book explores in a pedagogical way the present understanding of “Relaxation Dynamics in Magnetised Plasmas,” which was the focus of the Festival in 2003. It is suited for physicists and advanced students in the field, as well as researchers in other fields who would like to acquire an exhaustive and up-to-date view on these problems. vii
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Contents
Foreword
vii
In memory of ...
1
1. Prof. Masahiro Wakatani and Fusion Research in His Days
3
K. Itoh 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4
Research period of Prof. Wakatani . Research on nonequilibrium systems Wakatani-sensei’s gifts to scientists . Closing words . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
Magnetic relaxation and self-organization in astrophysical and laboratory plasmas
3 6 9 11
13
2. An Introduction to Mean Field Dynamo Theory
15
D.W. Hughes and S.M. Tobias 2.1 2.2
2.3
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Kinematic Mean Field Theory . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.1 Formulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.2 Calculation of the transport coefficients . 2.2.3 Linear mean field dynamo models . . . . Incorporating Nonlinear Effects . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.1 The nonlinear behaviour of the transport coefficients . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
15 19 19 23 28 32
. . . . .
32
September 30, 2009
14:1
x
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
2.4
2.3.2 Other nonlinear effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.3 Nonlinear mean Field Models . . . . . . . . . . . Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3. Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
40 41 45 49
P.-Y. Longaretti 3.1 3.2
3.3
3.4
3.5
3.6 3.A
3.B
3.C 3.D 3.E
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Generalities on astrophysical jets . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.1 Accretion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.2 Magnetic fields in jets . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.3 Relativistic vs non-relativistic jets in AGNs . Origin of jets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1 Central object . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.2 Disk/central-object interaction region . . . . 3.3.3 Disk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . MHD jet structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.1 Jet launching and magnetic surface opening 3.4.2 Current structure, and jet acceleration and collimation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stability of MHD jets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5.1 Global disk-jet stability and stationarity . . 3.5.2 Motion driving: the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5.3 Magnetic driving: the current and pressure instabilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary and open issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A brief compendium of relevant astrophysical facts . 3.A.1 Mostly AGNs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.A.2 Origin of magnetic fields . . . . . . . . . . . 3.A.3 On the MHD approximation in astrophysics MHD axisymmetric steady-state equations . . . . . . 3.B.1 General form . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.B.2 Ideal MHD form . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Kelvin-Helmholtz instability of a single vortex sheet layer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . MHD stability and the energy principle . . . . . . . Pressure-driven instabilities asymptotic limit . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
49 52 53 56 58 60 60 62 64 69 70
. . . . . . . . .
71 74 76
. . .
77
. . . . . . . . .
81 90 92 92 93 94 96 96 98
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . 100 . . . 101 . . . 102
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Contents
xi
Turbulence and turbulent transport - the agents of relaxation and structure formation
117
4. A Tutorial on Basic Concepts in MHD Turbulence and Turbulent Transport
119
P.H. Diamond, S.-I. Itoh and K. Itoh 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K41 beyond dimensional analysis - revisiting the theory of hydrodynamic turbulence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Kraichnan-Iroshnikov, Goldreich-Sridhar and all that: a scaling theory of MHD turbulence . . . . . . . . . . . . . Steepening of nonlinear Alfven waves - a little compressibility goes a long way... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Turbulent flux diffusion in 2D MHD - a ‘minimal’ problem which is not so simple... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5. Intermittency Like Phenomena in Plasma Turbulence
119 120 127 137 142 149 151
A. Das, P. Kaw and R. Jha 5.1 5.2 5.3
5.4 5.5 5.6
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Concept of intermittency in hydrodynamic fluids Evidence for intermittency in plasmas . . . . . . 5.3.1 Laboratory fusion plasma . . . . . . . . . 5.3.2 Space plasmas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.3 Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Plasma intermittency: fluid approach . . . . . . Alternative approach for plasma turbulence . . . Summary and conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
6. Nonlinear Cascades and Spatial Structure of Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence
151 153 158 159 165 166 168 174 178
187
W.-C. M¨ uller and R. Grappin 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Magnetohydrodynamics . . . . . . . . Basic concepts . . . . . . . . . . . . . Phenomenologies of turbulent cascades 6.4.1 Kolmogorov phenomenology .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
187 188 190 191 192
September 30, 2009
14:1
xii
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
6.5 6.6
6.7 6.8
6.4.2 Iroshnikov-Kraichnan phenomenology 6.4.3 Goldreich-Sridhar phenomenology . . Numerical simulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.1 Pseudospectral method . . . . . . . . Nonlinear energy dynamics . . . . . . . . . . 6.6.1 Isotropic energy spectra . . . . . . . . 6.6.2 Anisotropic energy spectra . . . . . . 6.6.3 Residual energy spectra . . . . . . . . Spatial structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.7.1 Intermittency modelling . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
7. Scale Covariance and Scale-ratio Covariance in Turbulent Front Propagation
194 195 196 197 198 198 199 202 206 208 212
219
A. Pocheau 7.1 7.2 7.3
7.4
7.5 7.6
7.7
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Turbulent front and scale symmetries . . . . . . . . . . . . From scale invariance to scale covariance . . . . . . . . . . 7.3.1 Single variable relationship . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3.2 Geometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3.3 Equilibrium systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3.4 Out-of-equilibrium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . On the scale-ratio invariance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4.1 The meaning of scale-ratio invariance . . . . . . . 7.4.2 Single variable function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4.3 Multivariable function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4.4 Front propagation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Front propagation laws both scale covariant and scale-ratio covariant . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Experimental evidence of scale covariance in turbulent front propagation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6.1 Experimental set-up and data processing . . . . . 7.6.2 Integral analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6.3 Local analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6.4 Sensitivity of scale covariance . . . . . . . . . . . Scale construction of turbulent fronts . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7.1 Deterministic construction of front geometry in scale space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
220 221 223 224 225 227 228 230 231 232 233 234 235 238 238 241 242 243 243 244
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Contents
7.7.2 7.7.3 7.8
“Apparent” fractal dimensions . . . . . . An artifact of finite size: the variation of dimensions” with turbulence intensity . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xiii
. . . . . 246 “fractal . . . . . 248 . . . . . 249
Transport bifurcations and relaxation
253
8. Transport Barrier Relaxations in Tokamak Edge Plasmas
255
P. Beyer 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Model for resistive ballooning turbulence . . . . . . Formation of a transport barrier . . . . . . . . . . Appearance of relaxation oscillations . . . . . . . . Low dimensional model and non-linear short-term dynamics of shear flow stabilization . . . . . . . . . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
255 256 259 261
. . . . 264 . . . . 267
9. Dynamics of Edge Localized Modes
269
X. Garbet, P. Ghendrih, Y. Sarazin, P. Beyer, G. Fuhr-Chaudier and S. Benkadda 9.1 9.2
9.3
9.4
9.5
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . An introduction to edge localized modes . . . . . . . . . . 9.2.1 Tokamak geometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2.2 A brief description of edge localized modes . . . . 9.2.3 MHD stability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dynamical models of edge localized modes . . . . . . . . . 9.3.1 Minimal model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3.2 Quasi-linear MHD model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3.3 Status of the modelling of ELM’s based on the MHD quasi-linear model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . L-H transition and edge localized modes . . . . . . . . . . 9.4.1 Models based on a subcritical bifurcation . . . . . 9.4.2 Models based on shear flow stabilization . . . . . 9.4.3 Models based on shear flow generation . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
269 271 271 272 273 276 276 278 280 281 282 286 289 291
September 30, 2009
xiv
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
10. On the Onset of Collapse Events in Toroidal Plasmas Turbulence Trigger
295
K. Itoh, S.-I. Itoh, M. Yagi, S. Toda and A. Fukuyama 10.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2 Phenomenological observations and problem definition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.1 Onset of collapse and topological change of magnetic surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2 Approaches for bifurcation phenomena . . . . . . 10.3 Theoretical Framework . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.1 Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.2 Stochastic equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.3 Statistical properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4 Example of Neoclassical Tearing Mode . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.1 Description of nonlinear instability and stochastic equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.2 Nonlinear instability, subcritical excitation and cusp catastrophe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.3 Statistical property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.5 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
296 297 298 302 302 302 303 305 308 308 310 312 316
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
PART 1
In memory of ...
1
BkFestival2003
This page intentionally left blank
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Chapter 1
Prof. Masahiro Wakatani and Fusion Research in His Days
K. Itoh National Institute for Fusion Science, Toki 509-5292, Japan Prof. Wakatani has passed away on 9th January 2003 at the age of 57. It is a big tragedy that we have lost Prof. Wakatani. This article is to remember his achievements in fusion and plasma science.
1.1
Research period of Prof. Wakatani
Prof. Masahiro Wakatani (Fig. 3.7) was born on 15 May 1945, and was given the PhD degree from Kyoto University in 1973. He has worked at JAERI, IPP Nagoya University and PPL Kyoto University. He has been a full professor at Kyoto since 1985, (and on that occasion I have joined his chair as an associate professor to him). It was the thirty years, from 1973 to 2003, when he has played a leading role in fusion and plasma research. Progress in the fusion and plasma research during these thirty years, from 1973 to 2003, can be seen in Fig. 1.1, which shows the starts of experiments of tokamaks and helical devices (stellarators). Each symbol corresponds to one experimental device. Devices are clarified into four: circular cross section (conventional) tokamaks (open circle), noncircular tokamaks (closed circle), helical devices (triangle), and spherical tokamaks (square). This figure clearly illustrates that the steady progress was first made on the circular cross-section tokamaks. Then the noncircular tokamaks are developed. In parallel, helical devices have been explored, slightly slower but steadily. In the fourth category, we observe that the spherical tokamaks have been attracting focused interest recently. 3
September 30, 2009
4
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
1000 3
ITER ITER
V (m )
100
TFTR
JET JT-60U LHD
10 1
NSTX T-3
Stellarator-C 0.1 1960
Fig. 1.1
START 1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
Year
2020
Plasmas in the research period of Prof. Wakatani.
The research in the last three decades may be characterized by the following: (1) (2) (3) (4)
the exploration of configurations was pursued, the tokamak plasma has been evolving to fusion regime, the optimization of toroidal systems was investigated, the plasma physics has been recognized as a frontier of general modern physics.
In particular, deeper and wider recognition of the fact that “the shape and size change the property of the matter in the confined plasma”. Prof. Wakatani has provided many keys for the development in the above four aspects of the recognition in the fusion research. Initial phase An explicit goal of the fusion research has been to establish the scientific feasibility for the realization of controlled thermonuclear fusion. I would like to stress that, at the same time, our goal has been to systematize the research as a discipline. This latter goal has been recognized as important as the former, from the time of early 70s when Prof. Wakatani has started his academic carrier. For instance, we could quote from, e.g., Feynman Lectures on Physics, “The next great era of awakening of human intellect
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Prof. Masahiro Wakatani and Fusion Research in His Days
BkFestival2003
5
may well produce a method of understanding the qualitative content of equations. Today we cannot. Today we cannot see that the water flow equations contain such things as the barber pole structure of turbulence · · · ” [1]. It was 1974, when Prof. S. Yoshikawa, being collaborated by Prof. K. Nishikawa, has initiated “Workshop on Theoretical Research of Fusion” at Hachiouji near Tokyo. In the first and consecutive workshops, Prof. Yoshikawa has tried to establish a methodology for the research on confined plasmas in Japanese academic society. Those who have joined the series of this workshop, as a newcomer to this field then, have later grown up as leading researchers in Japan. Prof. Wakatani has been one of the leading figures in the series of the workshop. Four examples from Prof. Wakatani’s outstanding achievements Prof. Wakatani’s work has been always in the frontier of fusion research for the last three decades, which is illustrated in Fig. 1.1, and may be organized into four categories corresponding to the four characterization listed above. The first is the problem of stability and plasma shape. The initial works are typical examples including the toroidal effect on vertical displacement of elliptic tokamak [2] and nonlinear calculation of the m = 1 internal kink instability in current carrying stellarators [3]. The second is the nonlinear instability problem, in which he proposed the so-called ‘Hasegawa-Wakatani equations’ [4]. This set of equations has been an elegant and elementary tool for theory and simulational studies of plasma turbulence. Thus, the influences of the plasma size and parameters on the turbulent transport have been clarified. The third, he has devoted continuously for understanding of helical systems [5] including the design study. In this area, he has developed a systematic theory of the stability of Heliotron systems, played a central role in the theoretical design of the large helical device (LHD) and also developed a helical axis system (heliac or helias). The fourth is the study of the structure formation in turbulent plasmas. By use of his ‘HasegawaWakatani equations’ he has demonstrated that the global structures are generated by plasma turbulence [6]. It is evident that these four categories are the central issues in the fusion research of the last three decades as is illustrated in Fig. 1.1. In the next section, his originality is highlighted by selecting some of his leading achievements [7].
September 30, 2009
14:1
6
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
1.2
Research on nonequilibrium systems
In the research of complex phenomena in nonequilibrium systems, such as confined plasmas, it is essential to identify the appropriate equations. In particular, reduction of variables illustrates the physical processes and stimulates the finding of physics law. Prof. Wakatani has recognized this importance of selecting proper equations for proper problems, and has given illustrative results of key issues in confinement physics. One example is his research on the relaxation phenomena in helical systems. Pressure driven relaxation instability in a current-free high-shear helical system has been studied by him and his students (e.g., [8]), and repetitive sequence of onsets of crash and following gradual recovery was shown by numerical simulation (Fig. 1.2). Thus he and his colleagues have opened the way that the nonlinear MHD dynamics of pressure-driven collapse events, which may limit the performance of helical devices, is treated quantitatively.
Fig. 1.2
Evolution of pressure profile in relaxation phenomena of Heliotron [8].
More famous example of his achievements is the investigation of the ‘Hasegawa-Wakatani’ equations. ∂ 2 (1.1) ∇ φ + φ, ∇2⊥ φ = d (φ − n) + µc ∇4⊥ φ ∂t ⊥ ∂ ∂φ n + [φ, n] = d (φ − n) − + Dc ∇2⊥ n (1.2) ∂t ∂y −1 −1 2 νei ωci Ln ρ−1 where d ≡ k2 vth,e s . (Plasma parameters such as the density, temperature, characteristic scale of gradient, magnetic field are included
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Prof. Masahiro Wakatani and Fusion Research in His Days
BkFestival2003
7
into this one parameter d .) This set of equations is simple, and includes the drive by instabilities and the process of generation of structures (such as zonal flow or convective cells, etc.). This is a prototypical set of equations which clarifies many of essential elements in the plasma turbulence, and has given tremendous impacts for the progress of physics for the confined plasmas. This has opened the area of research where mutual interactions between turbulence and meso-scale structure are studied. Two most important results are illustrated here. The first is the spectrum of plasma turbulence which is driven by inhomogeneity. When one talks about a generality of turbulent spectrum, many efforts have been devoted to the universality of the inertial regime [9]. It is true that, after the evolution of nonlinear turbulent interactions, external energy which is injected to a relevant scale is transferred to smaller scales and is finally dissipated by molecular collisions. In such a study to pursuit ‘universality’, the longerwavelength components are often treated as external parameter. However, the longer-wavelength component contains dominant part of turbulent energies. Thus impact of turbulence to observable phenomena (or that to human recognition of nature) is mainly carried by the dynamics of the energy containing region. The determination of the energy spectrum in a region where free energy is injected by various instability mechanisms has vital importance. Such a problem needs a formulation a set of equations which include both the nonlinear dynamics of vortex together with instability mechanism. Thus, the Hasegawa-Wakatani equations have served the simplest set of equations, which provides insights for the evolution of turbulence. By use of this set of equation, Prof. Wakatani has obtained the spectrum −3 , E(k) ∝ k⊥
(1.3)
where E(k) is the energy spectrum [10]. This spectral form tells that the dominant part of turbulent energy is contained in the region of longest wavelength. The rate of the nonlinear transfer is summarized in the index, −3. Another important finding is the flow generation by turbulence. Figure 1.3 is one early example [4], in which the formation of potential contour, loosely resembling that of the magnetic surface, is demonstrated. These contour structures indicate the presence of banded poloidal E × B flow, called zonal flow. It has been pointed out that in the two-dimensional turbulence, the turbulence energy can cascade, not only into the finer scales, but also in the direction of longer scale lengths. As the injection of energy to
September 30, 2009
8
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
a mode continues, the wave energy starts to pile up in the longer-wavelength region if the molecular dissipation is weak. Turbulence in toroidal plasmas is quasi-two-dimensional owing to the strong magnetic field. The HasegawaWakatani equations are formulated in a form of two dimensional turbulence, where the wavenumber in the direction of magnetic field is treated as a constant parameter. The accumulation of wave energy in the longer wavelength region is demonstrated by the simulation of the Hasegawa-Wakatani equations. As is seen from Fig. 1.3, the potential contour is akin to the magnetic surface. This means that the fluctuation electric field in the poloidal direction is weak, i.e., the fluctuating velocity in the radial direction is small. Thus, the reduction of radial transport is expected to occur when such a global electrostatic potential is established. It is well known now that the studies of the improved confinement in 90’s are developed based upon several key ideas, such as the suppression of turbulence by radial electric field, bifurcation of the radial electric field, and the formation of zonal flow by turbulence [11]. All of us are aware of the leading role of Prof. Wakatani’s work in the progress of the theory of plasma confinement.
Fig. 1.3
Contour of electrostatic potential from the simulation of [4].
We could now enlighten his work as a historical achievement. We recall Helmholtz’s theorem, i.e., vortex lines move with fluid (in invicid fluid). In a terminology of plasma physics [12] one may express the evolution of the vorticity as ∂ 2 ∇ φ + φ, ∇2⊥ φ = · · · (1.4) ∂t ⊥ The Helmholtz theorem tells that the RHS vanishes, · · · = 0. In the nature, however, there are abundant of examples that the vortical flow structure is ‘generated’. More generally, the global axial vector fields are generated
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Prof. Masahiro Wakatani and Fusion Research in His Days
BkFestival2003
9
by the turbulent convection of thermal energy. Such as, geodynamo, solar dynamo, Jet formation in accretion disk, Jovian zonal flow, Jet stream, Venus super rotation, etc. In the problems of plasma structure formation, one can point out the relaxation to Taylor state, sawtooth oscillation, Hmode, ITB, zonal flow, dynamo, etc. These phenomena will be explained if “· · · ” in the right hand side of this equation is properly modelled. In this aspect, Prof. Wakatani has given a critical step for the development of general physics. Prof. Wakatani has thus clarified an essence of the problem. This attitude of him was described as “· · · Perhaps because Wakatani-sensei lived in the ancient cultural region of Kyoto and Nara, he liked theories that were simple, orderly, and yet elegant, like a Zen garden. · · · ” by Prof. J. W. Van Dam and Prof. C. W. Horton, Jr. in the tribute to Prof. Wakatani. Looking into waves of pebbles in Zen garden, one may see waves, tide and vortices in nature. 1.3
Wakatani-sensei’s gifts to scientists
There are a lot of key elements in order to promote the future progress. Among them, Prof. Wakatani has contributed much in the following aspects: (1) Systematization of achievements as a branch of academic research, (2) Improve creativity, (3) Improve environment of research. What he has done in relation to these issues is now considered as a gift from Prof. Wakatani to the future researchers. Systematization of research results as an academic discipline What should be emphasized first is that, Prof. Wakatani has been an excellent teacher for the students. Education of students was a joy for him, and his devotion to the education has been awarded by the energetic scientific production by those in Wakatani school. They are now central members in the theory and simulation researchers in Japan. In relation with the education, he has also made efforts in publication of books. The achievement includes: “The Beta Equilibrium Stability and Transport Codes: Applications to Design of Stellarators” by F. Baure,
September 30, 2009
10
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
O. Betancourt, R. Garabedian, M. Wakatani (Academic Press, Inc., 1987); “Plasma Physics Basic Theory with Fusion Applications” by K. Nishikawa, M. Wakatani (Springer-Verlag, 1990 (Second ed. 1993, Third ed. 1999)); and “Stellarator and Heliotron Devices” by M. Wakatani (Oxford University Press, 1998). The fact that the third edition of his “Plasma Physics Basic Theory with Fusion Applications” was published shows that this book is widely accepted by the international academic community. Improve creativity Next, he played a role in improving the creativity of researchers. I would point out three keys. “Increasing creativity” might be heard as a miracle, but what Prof. Wakatani has done has been full of the essence for it. The first key for the creativity is ‘Self-belief’. Without self-belief, one cannot achieve a really new scientific achievement on which nobody has thought or analyzed. Only by the self-belief, we can continue the work until the final breakthrough is realized. Prof. Wakatani has been always encouraging his colleague and students. By warm encouragement by him, many researchers have been injected self-belief. The next key is ‘chemistry’ among researchers. From the time of ancient peripatetic school at Greek, to the modern Copenhagen spirit, and to recent group researches, the communication between many researchers has been the central scheme for driving creative ideas that had shed lights for human understanding. In the area of fusion and plasma research, Prof. Wakatani has been always leading friendship among researchers. He has been always stressed ‘loose-coupling’ among scientists: this was the key of him so that researchers keep good chemistry among them while each of the members can grow their own originality. Third, his efforts to grow the chemistry has been most impressive in his contribution in the international collaborations. Interactions between different ways of thinking, no doubt, is the key for the emergence of the new idea. For this, the interactions between Oriental-Occidental ways of thinking, as well as International and Interdisciplinary way of thinking, are very effective way of progress. Wakatani-sensei’s efforts have covered many endevours, e.g., IUPAP (plasma physics), US-Japan collaboration on fusion research, in particular Joint Institute for Fusion Theory, International Stellarator Workshop, International Toki-conference, Festival de Theorie, and others. Every participant in the first Festival de Theory remembers Wakatani-sensei’s warm and leading work in the festival (see Fig. 3.8).
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Prof. Masahiro Wakatani and Fusion Research in His Days
BkFestival2003
11
Improve environment of research Prof. Wakatani was the leader in Japanese education for plasma and fusion science. He was elected as councilor of Kyoto University, and everyone has believed that he would soon be a dean. He was the key promoter for the 21st Century COE (center of excellence) Program of MEXT (ministry of education, culture, sports, science and technology) on “Establishment of COE on Sustainable-Energy System”. For this, he was the task leader for “Plasma Group”, and provided a splendid conditions for researcher who belonged to this programme. He has also made a lot of efforts for academic agreement between Kyoto U. and Universite de Province and others. His devotion benefited the communication between the scientists, government officials and citizens. He was a member of Fusion Council of Japan, which was the highest subcommittee specializing at the national policy of the fusion research. He was also a subcommittee member of Science Council of Japan, in which academic society has shown opinions to the government. Prof. Wakatani has played a role of spokesman for the researchers in the field of plasma and fusion study to the government and to wider academic society. Among these activities, his role for the big project ITER was outstanding. He was a member of Technical Advisory Committee, and was the chairman for scientific and technical evaluation of ITER for Fusion Council of Japan. Through these activities, he guided Fusion Council of Japan to have scientific judgement for the decision of participating the ITER project. In the end of this article, let me be a bit sentimental. We had started an activity of “Group of Seven” since 1985. Members were (in alphabetical order) M. Fujiwara, K. Itoh, S.-I. Itoh, S. Matsuda, O. Motojima, Y. Shimomura and M. Wakatani. At that time, foreseeing the start of the LHD project, an endeavour to make an inter-institutional research collaboration project in Japan has been studied. One of the first outcome of this activity was ‘Method for design of Large Helical Device’. It strengthened the spirit of collaboration, domestic as well as international, which has been the essence of Wakatani sensei’s research moral.
1.4
Closing words
All of us have been impressed by his dedication to the science, students, colleague, academic society and, last but not least, his family. The enlightening ideas and selfless devotion for research have sprung from his heart.
September 30, 2009
12
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Prof. Wakatani’s spirit lives with us so long as the plasma physics and fusion research continue to evolve. Acknowledgements The author would like to thank the “Director Committee”, the chairman and local organizers for giving this opportunity for a memorial talk at Festival Th´eorie 7 July 2003 (Aix-en-Provence, France). He acknowledges discussions and help in materials by colleague in preparing the talk; in particular, Drs. S.-I. Itoh, M. Yagi, H. Sugama, N. Kasuya, A. Fukuyama, S. Hamaguchi, R. M. More, H. Sanuki, S. Toda, A. Fujisawa, Y. Miura, A. Yoshizawa, P. H. Diamond, T. S. Hahm, S. Benkadda, X. Garbet, V. Naulin, C. W. Horton, and J. van Dam. I would like to thank a partial support in completing this manuscript from Grant-in-Aid for Specially-Promoted Research (16002005) and Grant-in-aid for Scientific Research (15360495) from MEXT Japan. References [1] Feynman R P, Leighton R B and Sands M L 1965 The Feynman Lectures on Physics (Addison-Wesley, Reading) §41-6. [2] Wakatani M 1975 J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 38 1555. [3] Wakatani M 1978 Nucl. Fusion 18 1499. [4] Hasegawa A and Wakatani M 1983 Phys. Rev. Lett. 50 682. [5] Wakatani M 1998 Stellarator and Heliotron Devices (Oxford University Press). [6] Hasegawa A and Wakatani M 1987 Phys. Rev. Lett. 59 1581. [7] A thorough list of Prof. Wakatani’s work is now under preparation. [8] Wakatani M, Shirai H and Yamagiwa M 1984 Nucl. Fusion 24 1407. [9] Kolmogorov A N 1941 Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR [Sov. Phys. Dokl.] 30 299. [10] Wakatani M and Hasegawa A 1984 Phys Fluids 27 611. [11] See, e.g., Yoshizawa A, Itoh S -I, Itoh K 2002 Plasma and Fluid Turbulence (IOP, Bristol). [12] Taylor J B and McNamara B 1971 Phys. Fluids 14 1492.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
PART 2
Magnetic relaxation and self-organization in astrophysical and laboratory plasmas
13
BkFestival2003
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
This page intentionally left blank
14
BkFestival2003
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Chapter 2
An Introduction to Mean Field Dynamo Theory
D.W. Hughes and S.M. Tobias Department of Applied Mathematics, University of Leeds
2.1
Introduction
Magnetic fields are essentially ubiquitous, being detected over a tremendous range of scales in planets, stars, accretion discs and in the interstellar medium. The dynamic behaviour of such fields is then responsible for a vast range of astrophysical phenomena (see, for example, Parker 1979). For instance, the solar magnetic field gives rise to sunspots, solar flares and coronal mass ejections; it also plays a major role in shaping the solar wind which, on interacting with the Earth’s magnetic field, causes aurorae. Starspots, analogous to sunspots but covering a much greater surface area, have been detected on a number of cool stars. The pulsed emission of pulsars is a consequence of an extremely strong magnetic field. On the largest scales, the interstellar magnetic field plays a role in star formation, mediating angular momentum transport as the star collapses. The ultimate question in the study of astrophysical magnetic fields must then be that of the origin of the magnetic field in cosmical objects. In particular, one might ask whether the observed magnetic fields are simply ‘fossil fields’, or whether, alternatively, they are being continually regenerated — i.e. whether some sort of dynamo process is taking place. For collision-dominated plasmas with short mean free paths, such as those found in stellar interiors, the evolution of magnetic fields is very well described by the equations of single-fluid magnetohydrodynamics (MHD). 15
September 30, 2009
16
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
(Although, for example, in studies of stellar atmospheres — such as the solar corona — the use of MHD is not based on such solid foundations.) In this review we shall be concerned only with physical systems for which the MHD description is appropriate. The key equation of MHD is the magnetic induction equation, derived from the pre-Maxwell equations (in which the displacement current is neglected) and the simplest form of Ohm’s law in a moving conductor, namely J = σ(E + U × B),
(2.1)
where J is the electric current, E the electric field, U the velocity field, B the magnetic field, and σ the electrical conductivity. The induction equation takes the form: ∂B (2.2) = ∇ × (U × B) + η∇2 B, ∂t where η (= 1/µ0 σ, where µ0 is the magnetic permeability) is the magnetic diffusivity (assumed constant in this derivation). The first term on the right hand side of Eq. (2.2) describes the advection of the magnetic field by the velocity, the second term describes collisional dissipation of the field. An order of magnitude estimate of the relative size of these two terms is given by the magnetic Reynolds number Rm = U L/η, where U and L are a typical velocity and length. Significantly, in most astrophysical contexts Rm is huge. Clearly, in the absence of any fluid motions the induction equation simply reduces to a vector diffusion equation, with a timescale for decay of the magnetic field (the Ohmic timescale) given by τη ∼ L2 /η. For the Earth, taking L as the radius of the metallic core and η as the appropriate molecular value, the Ohmic decay time τη is of the order of 104 years, several orders of magnitude shorter than the timescale over which the Earth’s magnetic field has existed, namely O(109 ) years (see, for example, Backus et al. 1996). Thus it follows immediately that the advective term in Eq. (2.2) is of paramount importance — any fossil field would by now have decayed to a negligible strength. In other words, the fluid motions are critical to maintenance of the magnetic field. This is what is meant by a (hydromagnetic) dynamo. For the case of the Sun, whose magnetic field can be studied in far greater detail than that of the Earth, the Ohmic time is very long (roughly speaking, L is large and η small), and is comparable with the lifetime of the Sun. Solely on these grounds it is not therefore possible to assert that the Sun’s field cannot be primordial in origin. However, conversely, it is the
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
17
fact that the observed solar field varies on a short timescale, with reversals roughly every eleven years, that strongly suggests that the magnetic field is a product of dynamo action. The alternative — an observed rapidly reversing field fed somehow by a (hidden) slowly decaying and non-reversing field (a hydromagnetic oscillator ) — is much harder to envisage. Magnetic fields with short-term variability have also been observed on a number of other solar-type stars, and it is natural to assume that they are also the result of some kind of dynamo action (see, for example, the review by Rosner 2000). Within accretion discs, although there is no compelling observational evidence of dynamo action, numerical simulations of the nonlinear development of the magneto-rotational instability, which is believed to play a crucial role in angular momentum transport, suggest a novel ‘bootstrapping’ dynamo mechanism in which the instability of a weak field leads to turbulent motions, which can then act to amplify the magnetic field (see the review by Balbus & Hawley 1998). On the largest, galactic, scale the question of whether the magnetic field is a product of dynamo action is rather more open (see Zweibel 2005). The Ohmic decay time of the field is about ten orders of magnitude larger than the age of the Universe, so on these grounds the field could obviously be primordial. Although there are possible difficulties in reconciling a wound-up primordial field with the observed spatial scale between galactic field reversals, there is currently no overwhelming observational evidence to decide the issue either way. A complete mathematical description of MHD dynamo action requires the solution of the induction equation (2.2) and also of the momentum equation, which accounts for the back-reaction of the magnetic field on the fluid flow through the Lorentz force J × B. For compressible fluids an energy equation and an equation of state must also be solved. Thus the full problem requires the solution of a set of coupled nonlinear partial differential equations, which represents a formidable mathematical and computational challenge. A simpler, but still non-trivial problem, is to consider the evolution of the magnetic field under a prescribed velocity field, which requires solution only of Eq. (2.2). Investigating the growth of the magnetic field governed by this linear equation is known as the kinematic dynamo problem; a flow for which the magnetic field grows exponentially (governed solely by Eq. (2.2)) is said to act as a kinematic dynamo. Determination of kinematic dynamo action, even though it requires solution of only one linear partial differential equation, is nonetheless not straightforward. Indeed, from the initial formulation of the problem in a
September 30, 2009
18
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
short paper by Larmor (1919) (reproduced in Ruzmaikin et al. 1988), it took a period of nearly forty years before the first rigorous demonstrations of kinematic dynamo action (Herzenberg 1958; Backus 1958). The main obstacle to success came from the fact that simple fields and flows of the kind that allow analytical progress with Eq. (2.2) typically do not act as dynamos; indeed, there are a number of anti-dynamo theorems that expressly rule out flows and fields with certain symmetries. The most famous are due to Cowling (1934), who showed that a purely axisymmetric magnetic field cannot be maintained by dynamo action, and to Zeldovich (1957), who showed that dynamo action cannot result from plane two-dimensional motion. Subsequently there have been many extensions to these fundamental results (see, for example, Hide & Palmer 1982; Ivers & James 1984). Consequently, the dynamo problem is inherently three-dimensional and, as such, decidedly non-trivial. A distinction of a different kind may be drawn between small-scale and large-scale dynamos. A small-scale dynamo is one in which a growing magnetic field occurs on scales comparable with or smaller than those of the driving flow. A large-scale dynamo, on the other hand, has significant energy on scales very large compared with those of the velocity field. (The magnetic field of the Sun, which gives rise to sunspots and is global in scale, is envisaged to be the product of a large-scale dynamo.) However, this distinction, although sometimes useful, is not clear-cut. A large-scale dynamo will, typically, also have strong small-scale fields; conversely a small-scale dynamo flow, given the opportunity, will typically generate a certain amount of large-scale field — i.e. the spectrum of the field will not have an abrupt cut-off at the driving scale, but will decrease gradually to small wavenumbers (large scales). Thus a certain amount of caution is needed in categorising any dynamo as being of small or large scale. Moreover, in a turbulent flow there may be a wide range of energetic scales of motion; in such cases even the idea of a separation of scales becomes unclear. A major breakthrough in the study of dynamo action occurred with the formulation of mean field electrodynamics by Steenbeck, Krause and R¨ adler (1966 and subsequent papers; see the monographs by Krause & R¨ adler 1980 and Moffatt 1978). This theory considers the generation by dynamo action of magnetic fields on scales large compared with those of the driving flow, and is formulated in terms of the large-scale (or mean) component of the field, with the influence of small-scale motions and field encapsulated in a few fundamental coefficients of the problem (such as the famous ‘α-effect’). In a few special cases these can be calculated exactly; more generally though
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
19
they are parameterised in a physically plausible manner. For the past forty years astrophysical dynamo theory has been dominated by mean field electrodynamics. In this review we aim to provide a brief introduction to mean field electrodynamics. We shall concentrate on the generic aspects of the theory, rather than on object-specific models aimed at describing the magnetic fields of particular astrophysical bodies. The literature relating to mean field electrodynamics is vast, and so we make no claim here to be exhaustive in our choice of references; a fuller reference list may be obtained from the reviews of Roberts & Soward (1992), Ossendrijver (2003) and Brandenburg & Subramanian (2005). In Sec. 2.2 we discuss kinematic considerations — the formulation of mean field electrodynamics, the calculation of the governing coefficients in the theory, and simple linear mean field dynamo models. The incorporation of nonlinear effects is described in Sec. 2.3. Research into mean field electrodynamics remains an active, and indeed controversial, topic in astrophysical MHD; some of the difficulties of the theory and the issues that arise are discussed in Sec. 2.4.
2.2 2.2.1
Kinematic Mean Field Theory Formulation
Mean field electrodynamics is, at heart, a linear (or kinematic) theory, being based on the induction equation. In this section we shall concentrate solely on the linear formulation; nonlinear effects, which may be incorporated through a variety of approaches, are described in Sec. 2.3. The fundamental assumption underlying mean field electrodynamics is that there exists a strict separation of length scales for both the magnetic and velocity fields. The velocity and magnetic fields have a small-scale component, with characteristic length scale , and a large-scale — or mean — component with scale L . For the case of a turbulent velocity field,
may be regarded as a typical size of the energetic eddies. Averages, which we denote by · , may then be taken over an intermediate length scale a satisfying a L. The velocity and magnetic fields may be decomposed into their mean and fluctuating components: B = B0 + b,
U = U0 + u,
(2.3)
where, by definition, b = u = 0. Averaging the induction equation
September 30, 2009
20
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
(2.2) yields an equation for the evolution of the mean magnetic field: ∂B0 = ∇ × (U0 × B0 ) + ∇ × E + η∇2 B0 , (2.4) ∂t where E = u × b is the mean electromotive force (emf), resulting from interactions between the small-scale velocity field and the small-scale magnetic field. It is this term that provides the crucial distinction between the (un-averaged) induction equation and the mean induction equation. Clearly, in order to make progress with Eq. (2.4) it is necessary to close the system by expressing E in terms of the mean field B0 and its derivatives. This is done by considering the equation governing the fluctuating magnetic field, obtained by subtracting Eq. (2.4) from Eq. (2.2): ∂b (2.5) = ∇ × (U0 × b) + ∇ × (u × B0 ) + ∇ × G + η∇2 b, ∂t where G = u × b − u × b. Symbolically, Eq. (2.5) may be written as L(b) = ∇ × (u × B0 ),
(2.6)
where L is a linear operator. There are two distinct possible modes of behaviour for the small-scale magnetic field b. One is if b is ‘slaved’ to the mean field B0 ; here b is driven solely by the inhomogeneous term ∇ × (u × B0 ) — in the absence of B0 the small-scale field simply decays to zero. The second is when the operator L can support non-trivial solutions even in the absence of a large-scale field B0 — in other words, the velocity field supports small-scale dynamo action. As we shall see, the implications for mean field theory for the two cases can be rather different. Let us consider first the case when b exists only if the right hand side of Eq. (2.6) is non-zero; it is then linearly and homogeneously related to B0 . Hence, for a given velocity field u, the mean emf E is also linearly and homogeneously related to B0 . Since, by construction, the mean magnetic field varies on a long length scale, one may therefore postulate an expansion for E of the form ∂B0j + ··· . (2.7) Ei = αij B0j + βijk ∂xk For consistency with Eq. (2.4), which is a second order partial differential equation, it is important that the first two terms (and only the first two terms) of this expansion are retained. Since the vector E is a polar vector, whereas B0 is an axial vector, it follows therefore that αij and βijk are pseudo-tensors (i.e. they change their sign, compared with tensors, under transformation). Their physical interpretation is brought out most clearly
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
21
by considering the case of isotropic turbulence. In the kinematic regime the pseudo-tensors αij and βijk can depend only on the statistical properties of the flow field and on the diffusivity η; therefore, for isotropic turbulence, they must take the form αij = αδij ,
βijk = β ijk ,
(2.8)
where α is a pseudo-scalar and β a true scalar. Substitution from Eq. (2.8) into Eq. (2.4) gives ∂B0 = ∇ × (U0 × B0 ) + ∇ × αB0 + (η + β)∇2 B0 , ∂t
(2.9)
where we have made the further simplifying assumption that β is constant. Clearly β is an additional, turbulent, contribution to the magnetic diffusivity. On physical grounds we expect this to be positive for a genuinely turbulent flow; however it is of interest to note that there are certain types of flow (e.g. random potential flows) for which β is negative (Krause & R¨adler 1980). The most important term though is ∇ × αB0 , the ‘α-effect’ of mean field dynamo theory, which may lead to growth of the mean magnetic field. Whereas in the full induction equation (2.2) the advective term has the form of the curl of a vector perpendicular to the magnetic field, in the mean induction equation (2.9) the new (α) term is the curl of a vector parallel to the mean field. This turns out to have profound consequences. One is that Cowling’s theorem no longer holds (because it is possible to have dynamos that are axisymmetric on average); the problem then becomes much simpler, analytically and computationally, and allows ready progress to be made in dynamo modelling. We explore some such models in Sec. 2.2.3. However, even without any calculation, it is possible to gain considerable insight into the nature of any turbulence that can lead to a non-zero value of α. Consider the case when the turbulence is reflectionally symmetric; i.e. its statistics have no sense of ‘handedness’. Then, on changing from a right-handed to a left-handed frame of reference, the quantity α, which depends only on the statistics of the turbulence, is invariant. Conversely though, α, being a pseudo-scalar, must change sign under this reflection of coordinates. Thus it follows that α must vanish for reflectionally symmetric turbulence. Equivalently, α can be non-zero only for turbulence possessing some sense of handedness. In nature, reflectional symmetry is broken in any rotating system. The simplest measure of the lack of reflectional symmetry in a flow is the helicity, H = u · ∇ × u.
September 30, 2009
22
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
For non-isotropic turbulence it is instructive to split the αij tensor into (s) its symmetric and antisymmetric parts. The symmetric pseudo-tensor αij may be referred to its principal axes: (1) α (s) . αij = (2.10) α(2) (3) α Arguing as above, α(1) , α(2) and α(3) must vanish for turbulence that lacks reflectional symmetry. (a) The antisymmetric part of αij may be written as αij = − ijk γk , leading to a contribution γ ×B0 to the emf. From comparison with Eq. (2.4), it can be seen that γ is to be regarded as a velocity acting on the mean magnetic field; it can be non-zero provided the statistics of u are either anisotropic or inhomogeneous, but is not dependent on the symmetry properties of the turbulence (Cattaneo et al. 1988). A detailed review of the transport effects of turbulence on both scalar and vector fields is given by Moffatt (1983). For any given flow, one can calculate αij (at least in principle, and often in practice) by imposing a uniform field and measuring the resulting emf; here the scale separation is between the scale of variation of the flow field and that of the uniform magnetic field (which is formally infinite). This is not a dynamo calculation as such, since the uniform field remains constant in time. However, the resulting value of αij can then be used (once βijk is known) to calculate the growth of magnetic fields of large but finite scales. Conceptually (though with great difficulty in practice) βijk may, provided dynamo action is not taking place, be calculated by considering the diffusion of a magnetic field that is non-uniform but has a scale of variation far in excess of the characteristic scale of velocity. If, however, the flow acts as a large-scale dynamo then such a field will of course not decay but will grow. The discussion above has focused on the case where the fluctuating field b is driven by the ∇ × (u × B0 ) term in Eq. (2.5). However, turbulent flows, regardless of their symmetry properties, typically act as small-scale dynamos at sufficiently high values of Rm; i.e. b can grow quite happily of its own accord with B0 = 0. The growth rate of such a dynamo will then be determined not by α and β but by completely different properties of the flow, such as its Lyapunov exponents (see, for example, the monograph by Childress & Gilbert 1995). The difficulty comes in determining the nature of the dynamo action that may result from a helical, turbulent flow at high Rm — the typical astrophysical situation. If large-scale growth is
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
23
forbidden, through restricting the size of the domain and through the choice of boundary conditions, any dynamo action that ensues will be unambiguously small-scale. However, if the same flow is embedded in an extended domain there are two possibilities: a modified version of the small-scale dynamo with some magnetic energy on the large scales, or alternatively a genuine large-scale — but not small-scale — dynamo, though this too will have associated with it strong small-scale fields. Thus, given one particular realisation of kinematic dynamo action in an extended domain, drawing a meaningful distinction between these two types of dynamo may not be possible. 2.2.2
Calculation of the transport coefficients
Calculation of the mean emf E, and hence of the tensors αij and βijk , requires solution of Eq. (2.5) for the fluctuating magnetic field b. Unfortunately, for a general turbulent flow this is impossible. There are, however, certain limiting cases in which E can be calculated — or at least wellapproximated. These results can be complemented by numerical solutions — away from the limiting regimes — for particular flows, although it is not possible to probe the astrophysical regime of extremely high Rm. The term that renders Eq. (2.5) so troublesome is ∇ × G. It is therefore obviously of interest to consider situations in which this term can safely be ignored. (The neglect of this term is sometimes referred to as the first order smoothing approximation or the second order correlation approximation.) Suppose we denote the time and length scales of the velocity field by τ and
respectively, and the rms velocity by u. Then if either Rm = u /η 1 or S = uτ / 1 (where S is the Strouhal number), the ∇ × G term can be neglected. If Rm 1 Eq. (2.5) for b (assuming, for simplicity, U0 = 0) simplifies to 0 = ∇ × (u × B0 ) + η∇2 b, (2.11) assuming that dissipative effects are so strong that the time-dependence of b can be neglected. As described by Moffatt (1978), Eq. (2.11) can be solved via Fourier transforms to give (for isotropic turbulence) F (k) 1 dk, (2.12) α=− 3η k2 where F (k) is the helicity spectrum function. The corresponding expression for β is E(k) 2 β= dk, (2.13) 3η k2
September 30, 2009
24
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
where E(k) is the energy spectrum function. If, on the other hand, S 1 then b is governed by ∂b = ∇ × (u × B0 ), ∂t
(2.14)
leading to the expressions τ τ and β = u2 α = − u · ∇ × u (2.15) 3 3 (see Krause & R¨adler 1980). The significant feature of expressions (2.15) is that they are independent of the magnetic diffusivity η. Analogous, but more complicated expressions can be obtained for αij and βijk for non-isotropic turbulence; these are discussed at length in Krause & R¨ adler (1980). New physical effects can result, but they fall outside the scope of this introductory review. The crucial points to note from the above expressions are that α is directly related to the flow helicity (it is proportional to the helicity in Eq. (2.15) and to a weighted average of the helicity in Eq. (2.12)), and that β is determined by the energy of the flow. The clear link between α and the flow helicity can be understood in terms of Parker’s picture of helical motions that raise and twist field lines to provide a net current anti-parallel to the initial field (Parker 1955), as sketched in Fig. 2.1. It is clear though that for this picture to be valid the loops must undergo only small twists — which will be true provided that either diffusion dominates (Rm 1) or the motions act only for a very short time (S 1). Astrophysical turbulence, however, is characterised by Rm 1 and S = O(1); it is therefore of fundamental importance to see whether the close link between the helicity of the flow and the α-effect carries through into this regime. A very different approach can be taken by the formal neglect of the diffusive terms in the induction equation. The magnetic field is then frozen into the (perfectly conducting) fluid and can be expressed in terms of its initial configuration via the Cauchy solution. This leads to the following expression for α in terms of the Lagrangian displacement ξ (Moffatt 1974): d ξ · ∇ × ξ. (2.16) dt It is of interest to note that the helicity again appears, albeit in a Lagrangian sense. However, it is by no means straightforward to calculate α from Eq. (2.16), and indeed it is not clear that the expression converges as t → ∞. One might hope that expression Eq. (2.16), derived under the assumption of infinite Rm, sheds some light on the behaviour for large but α=−
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
25
Fig. 2.1 Distortion of the magnetic field by a rising, twisting motion (after Moffatt 1978). For this small value of the twist the associated current is anti-parallel to the initial magnetic field.
finite Rm. If so then this would provide a possible avenue into exploring the astrophysically important case of Rm 1. However, the link between the cases of Rm infinite and Rm large but finite is a subtle one that is not fully understood. Expression Eq. (2.16) thus currently remains a relatively unexplored approach to understanding the α-effect. In order to investigate the relationship between the α-effect and the properties of the velocity field, many calculations of αij have considered spatially periodic, helical motions. This was an idea pioneered by G.O. Roberts (1972), who considered two-dimensional, incompressible, steady flows, i.e. u(x, y) = ∇ × (ψˆ z) + wˆ z.
(2.17)
Such flows have the simplifying feature that the induction equation (2.2) supports monochromatic solutions of the form B(x, y, z, t) = B(x, y)ept+ikz ,
(2.18)
has the same spatial periodicity as the flow. However they also where B pose a difficulty in defining precisely what is meant by a large-scale magnetic field. For any given value of z a field of the form Eq. (2.18) has a component that is independent of x and y. Clearly, in some sense, this is a large-scale component — it has no variation in x or y and so has an infinite length
September 30, 2009
26
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
scale in these directions. Its evolution can be described through an α-effect in which the averaging procedure involves averaging over planes of constant z. Conversely though, this purely z-dependent component of the magnetic field may be thought of as simply part of the ‘small-scale’ eigenfunction B(x, y). This indeterminacy seems unavoidable for these special — but computationally tractable — flows. Roberts (1972) calculated the α-effect for four different flows in the limit as k → 0, exploiting symmetry arguments to determine the form of the anisotropic tensor αij . He focused particularly on the case of ψ = sin x sin y,
w = Kψ,
(2.19)
using analytical and numerical solutions to obtain α, and hence also the dynamo growth rate, for a range of Rm. The nature of the α-effect for the Roberts flow in the limit of Rm → ∞ was considered by Childress (1979) and later by Soward (1987), who showed that the growth rate scales as ln (ln Rm) . (2.20) ln Rm Childress & Soward (1989) extended their analysis to calculate the α-effect for large Rm for the ‘cat’s eye’ flow with ψ = sin x sin y + δ cos x cos y. Plunian & R¨ adler (2002) considered the k-dependence of the α-effect for the Roberts flow, and the possible relationship between this dynamo and that of the Karlsruhe dynamo experiment. In order for a dynamo to be ‘fast’ — i.e. to have a positive growth rate in the limit as Rm → ∞ — it is necessary that it has chaotic particle paths (Vishik 1989; Klapper & Young 1995). Steady two-dimensional flows are integrable and hence, as such, cannot act as fast dynamos — although, as for the Roberts flow analysed by Soward (1987), the growth rate may be an extremely slowly decaying function of Rm. It is of interest therefore to consider the α-effect produced by non-integrable flows as Rm → ∞. A much-studied flow in the context of possible fast dynamo action is the timedependent version of the Roberts flow introduced by Galloway & Proctor (1992), with p∼
ψ = sin(x + cos ωt) + cos(y + sin ωt),
w = Kψ.
(2.21)
(When ω = 0 flows Eq. (2.19) and Eq. (2.21) are equivalent after a simple transformation.) Courvoisier et al. (2006) have investigated the nature of the α-effect for the flow Eq. (2.21), for both finite and zero k, and demonstrated that, for this time-dependent flow, α is a sensitive function of Rm which, furthermore, does not tend to zero for large Rm.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
27
Another widely used approach to investigating the kinematic α-effect, which is one step closer to astrophysical reality, is to consider flows that are driven by rotating thermal convection. Here the flow is not specifically prescribed, but results from the nonlinear evolution of a convective instability; the spatial and temporal dependence of the flow depends on the parameters of the problem (such as the Rayleigh number) and on the boundary conditions. The simplest configuration is the plane layer model, with the rotation axis parallel to gravity, which was investigated in the pioneering studies of Childress & Soward (1972) and Soward (1974), who explored the nature of dynamo action for mildly supercritical Boussinesq convection under the assumptions of first order smoothing. The antisymmetry of Boussinesq convection about the mid-plane leads to an antisymmetric helicity distribution and hence an antisymmetric α— where the large-scale field is horizontal and dependent solely on the vertical coordinate. Weakly supercritical convection is characterised by a relatively simple planform. Soward (1974) was able to demonstrate large-scale dynamo action for some simple steady flows — though the very simplest planform consisting of a single roll with a single horizontal wavenumber does not exhibit dynamo action. The plane layer dynamo has been investigated further numerically (kinematically and dynamically), particularly in the regime of rapid rotation, by Jones & Roberts (2000), Rotvig & Jones (2002) and Stellmach & Hansen (2004). The convection in all of these studies, although outside the weakly nonlinear regime considered by Soward, is nonetheless fairly wellordered; it gives rise to a significant α-effect and, hence, to dynamo action with a pronounced large-scale component. Cattaneo & Hughes (2006) took a somewhat different approach to the plane-layer convective dynamo, concentrating on more turbulent flows which, although rotationally influenced (O(1) Rossby number) were not rotationally dominated; furthermore they considered horizontally extended domains, thereby allowing the convection to evolve without influence from sidewall boundaries. Their results differ considerably from those that emerge from considerations of ‘well-ordered’ convection. In particular they found that, despite the helical nature of the flow, two significant problems arose in determining α — even in the parameter regime where there is no self-sustaining dynamo action and hence E is due entirely to the imposed mean field. One problem is that α, even after spatial averaging over many convective cells, is a strongly fluctuating quantity in time (see Fig. 2.2); the second is that, even if one is bold enough to assign a mean value to α then this is extremely small — only O(u/Rm) (where u is the rms velocity) rather than O(u) as one might expect in a tur-
September 30, 2009
28
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
bulent process. The underlying problem — and one that seems inescapable — is that at large Rm the fluctuations completely dominate the mean. This result is potentially extremely bad news for mean field dynamo modelling, and will be discussed further in Sec. 2.4.
Fig. 2.2 Time history of the spatially-averaged x-component of the emf for rotating Boussinesq convection, with the rotation axis vertical and with an imposed magnetic field of unit strength (measured in terms of the equivalent Alfv´en velocity) in the xdirection. Thus this component of the emf corresponds to α11 . The computational domain has size 5 × 5 × 1; the rms velocity u ≈ 50 and Rm ≈ 250. The spatial average at any time involves many convective cells. Despite this, it can be seen that α is a wildly fluctuating quantity in time. The thick line in the upper panel corresponds to the time average up to time t of the signal. The same curve is plotted again in the lower panel with a more appropriate vertical axis, showing a painfully slow convergence to a value much smaller than that of u.
2.2.3
Linear mean field dynamo models
In the modelling of astrophysical magnetic fields it is natural to think of the averaging procedure as an azimuthal average, and the mean fields that
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
29
result as therefore axisymmetric. In terms of cylindrical polar coordinates (s, φ, z) we may then write U = sω(s, z)eφ + Up ,
B = B(s, z)eφ + Bp ,
E = Eφ eφ + E p ,
(2.22)
where the subscript p denotes the poloidal component. The quantities ω, Up and Bp therefore represent the differential rotation, large-scale meridional flow and large-scale meridional field. For simplicity, but without losing the essence of mean field dynamo theory, we may consider the case of isotropic turbulence. The mean emf then takes the form E = αB − β∇ × B.
(2.23)
On writing Bp = ∇ × A(s, z)eφ (by axisymmetry), the mean induction equation (2.4) can be expressed as the two scalar equations: ∂A 2 A, + s−1 (Up · ∇) (sA) = αB + ηT ∇ (2.24) ∂t
∂B 2 B, (2.25) + s (Up · ∇) s−1 B = s (Bp · ∇) ω + (∇ × αBp )φ + ηT ∇ ∂t 2 = ∇2 − s−2 , and where ηT = η + β is the effective magnetic where ∇ diffusivity (assumed constant in the above equations). It can be seen from Eq. (2.24) that the α-effect can generate poloidal field from the toroidal component, and from Eq. (2.25) that it can also generate toroidal from poloidal field; the differential rotation ω can generate toroidal field by stretching out the poloidal field. A mean field dynamo must continually regenerate magnetic field through some combination of the αand ω-effects; the relative magnitudes of these generation terms allows us to classify the nature of the dynamo action. If, on the right hand side of Eq. (2.25), the term involving α dominates that involving ω then we may neglect the s (Bp · ∇) ω term and speak of an α2 -dynamo; if the ω term dominates we may neglect the (∇ × αBp )φ term and speak of an αωdynamo; if they are comparable then we speak of an α2 ω-dynamo. Note that the α-term in Eq. (2.24) is indispensable for mean field dynamo action. In its absence A simply decays; the removal of the source terms for B then leads to the eventual decay of the toroidal field also. The key characteristics of these dynamos can be brought out in a Cartesian model, for which Eq. (2.24) and Eq. (2.25) simplify to ∂A + (Up · ∇) A = αB + ηT ∇2 A, ∂t ∂B + (Up · ∇) B = (Bp · ∇) U − α∇2 A + ηT ∇2 B, ∂t
(2.26) (2.27)
September 30, 2009
30
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
where U = Up + U ey , B = Bp + Bey . Under the assumption that Up , α and ∇U may be treated as uniform, we may seek local solutions of these equations, of the form A = A˜ exp (pt + ik · x) ,
(2.28)
leading to the following dispersion relation governing the growth rate p:
2 p + i(Up · k) + ηk 2 = α2 k 2 − iα(k × ∇U )y (2.29) (Parker 1955). Exponential growth of the field — a kinematic mean field dynamo — occurs if Re(p) > 0. For an α2 -dynamo with no meridional circulation (Up = 0), Eq. (2.29) simplifies to p = ±αk + ηk2 ,
(2.30)
showing that steady dynamo action (Re(p) > 0, Im(p) = 0) will occur provided |α| > ηk; i.e. growth is guaranteed for sufficiently small k. For an αω-dynamo with no meridional circulation, Eq. (2.29) reduces to 2
(2.31) p + ηk 2 = −iα(k × ∇U )y = 2iΓ, say. Dynamo action occurs if Γ > η 2 k 4 ; i.e. if the dynamo number D = Γ/η2 k 4 is greater than unity. The growing solution takes the form of a travelling wave, propagating in the +k (−k) direction if Γ < 0 (Γ > 0). (More generally it can be shown that for spatially varying underlying quantities, dynamo waves tend to propagate along lines of constant rotation (Yoshimura 1978).) If the equatorial migration of sunspots is viewed as the surface manifestation of an underlying, equatorially propagating, dynamo wave, then this suggests that in the northern (southern) hemisphere of the Sun the product α∂ω/∂r should be negative (positive). From Eq. (2.29) it can be seen that, at least within this simple model, a meridional flow affects the frequency, but not the growth rate, of any dynamo, with the α2 -dynamo now also assuming an oscillatory character, and with the direction of propagation for the αωdynamo dependent (for Γ > 0) on the sign of Γ1/2 − Up · k. Although all the fundamental ingredients of mean field dynamos are contained in the extremely simple plane layer model described above, clearly many important effects are omitted, even when attention is restricted to kinematic dynamos. Linear mean field dynamos in a sphere were considered by Steenbeck & Krause (1969a, b), Roberts & Stix (1972) and P.H. Roberts (1972). The evolution of dynamo waves in a spherical αω-dynamo for one
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
31
Fig. 2.3 Evolution of the magnetic field through one cycle of a kinematic αω-dynamo (from P.H. Roberts 1972). Meridian sections are shown, with poloidal field lines on the right and lines of constant toroidal field strength on the left. For this choice of parameters it can be seen that the pattern of the field progresses from the equator to the poles.
September 30, 2009
32
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
specific choice of α and ω is shown in Fig. 2.3. In certain astrophysical circumstances there are good reasons for believing that the α-effect and/or the ω effect are concentrated into regions that are thin in comparison with the body as a whole (for example, the solar tachocline, a thin region of radial velocity shear at the base of the convection zone, is widely conjectured to be the location of the ω-effect of the solar dynamo). Mathematically, such concentrated generation and shear can be modelled by δ-function representations of the α- and ω-effects. Away from the generation regions, A and B satisfy diffusion equations, with the generation terms brought in through the interface conditions; this approach has been investigated by Steenbeck & Krause (1966), Moffatt (1978) and Kleeorin & Ruzmaikin (1981). The role of a weakly modulated background state on the propagation of short wavelength dynamo modes was first considered by Kuzanyan & Sokoloff (1995), who showed that the eigenfunction of the magnetic field is localised away from the maximum of the dynamo number. The related problem of the influence of lateral boundaries (i.e. boundaries in the direction of propagation of the dynamo waves) has been considered in the linear regime by Worledge et al. (1997). 2.3 2.3.1
Incorporating Nonlinear Effects The nonlinear behaviour of the transport coefficients
The discussion above indicates that the validity of mean field electrodynamics is unclear even in the kinematic regime, where the back-reaction of the Lorentz force on the plasma motions is ignored. In this section, we discuss the role of the nonlinearity in modifying the transport coefficients. We proceed on the (far-from-certain) assumption that mean field electrodynamics yields sensible results in the kinematic regime, with transport coefficients (the α-effect and turbulent diffusivity) of the right order of magnitude, and ask how the generation of a mean magnetic field affects the transport in the flow. The question above may be restated as, ‘What is the strength of the mean magnetic field that can be generated by the α-effect before the αeffect is itself suppressed via nonlinear effects in the momentum equation?’ The momentum equation for an incompressible flow (with unit density) is given by ∂u 1 2 (2.32) + (u · ∇) u = −∇p + j × b + ∇ u + F, ∂t Re where F represents any external forces. The Lorentz force in a dynamo is
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
33
believed to be significant once the magnetic energy reaches the same order of magnitude as the kinetic energy of the flow that is generating it. Within the mean field framework this has traditionally been assumed to occur when the magnetic energy of the mean field reaches equipartition with the kinetic energy of the flow, i.e. when ρu2 ∼ B02 /µ0 .
(2.33)
Hence it is convenient to model the mean field transport coefficients as having the dependence α0 β0 α= , β= , (2.34) 2 2 1 + B0 /B 1 + B02 /B 2 where α0 and β0 are the kinematic values of the transport coefficients and B is the strength of the equipartition field. These, and other similar expressions, have been extensively used in models of astrophysical dynamos (Jepps 1975; see the review by Ossendrijver 2003 for further references). They are particularly appealing for a number of reasons. Clearly their inclusion will lead to a model that is capable of generating a substantial mean field — they are designed precisely to allow a mean field that has an energy comparable with that of the turbulence. In addition, these formulae are simple to implement. In the mean field ansatz only the mean field is calculated, and so a nonlinearity that relies solely on the amplitude of the mean field sits self-consistently within the framework of the theory. There is, however, significant doubt over the validity of these expressions at high Rm. Moreover, the uncertainties exist at such a fundamental level that even the order of magnitude of the mean field generated in the nonlinear regime is open to question. The issue of the level of saturation of the mean magnetic field is contentious and subtle, and a comprehensive discussion is well beyond the scope of this paper (see, for example, the recent review by Diamond et al. 2005a). However, as the issue is of such importance for astrophysical dynamo theory, a brief introduction will be included here. Perhaps the clearest (and most convincing) argument for the level of suppression of the transport coefficients is on physical grounds (see, for example, Vainshtein & Cattaneo 1992). It is generally accepted (as argued above) that the kinematic phase in a mean field dynamo will continue until the magnetic energy becomes comparable with that of the turbulence. Moreover at high Rm, both theory and numerical experiments indicate that the magnetic energy of the small-scale field will be much larger than that of the mean field. Turbulence is known to amplify magnetic fields locally (i.e. on the scale of the small-scale eddies with short turnover times)
September 30, 2009
34
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
so that the small-scale fields are more energetic than those on large scales — indeed most numerical experiments indicate that the ratio of the energy of the small-scale field to that of the large-scale field is given by b2 ∼ Rmq B02 ,
(2.35)
where 0 ≤ q ≤ 2 is a flow- and geometry-dependent coefficient. This, of course, poses a major problem for mean field theory. In particular, from this simple order of magnitude argument it appears as though the transport coefficients will be altered significantly once the strong smallscale field reaches equipartition with the kinetic energy of the turbulence, i.e. when ρu2 ∼ Rmq B02 /µ0 .
(2.36)
(Though the dynamic effect of the small-scale field will depend also on its filling factor — i.e. on how much of the volume is occupied by strong smallscale fields.) If Eq. (2.36) rather than Eq. (2.33) is the correct estimate of the strength at which the large-scale field becomes dynamically significant, then the expressions in Eq. (2.34) should be replaced by α=
α0 , 1 + Rmq B02 /B 2
β=
β0 . 1 + Rmq B02 /B 2
(2.37)
This leads to what is sometimes referred to as ‘catastrophic’ quenching of the transport coefficients; i.e. a dramatic reduction in their efficiency even when the mean field is many orders of magnitude smaller than equipartition. The above argument relies on simple physical balances, but seems plausible nonetheless. However, calculation of the transport coefficients relies on correlations between the turbulence and the small-scale field, and these may have unexpected properties. There are currently two possible ways of discriminating between the expressions in Eq. (2.34) and Eq. (2.37), neither of which is entirely satisfactory. The first is to derive analytical expressions for α and β by applying conservation laws and closure approximations. The second is to compute straightforwardly the correlations between the small-scale fields at moderate Rm — and then to extrapolate the results to higher Rm. Analytical progress may be made in certain circumstances by first recognising that the induction equation (and indeed Ohm’s Law, which leads to its derivation) results in a number of relations which, in the absence of dissipation, reduce to conservation laws. These take the form (see Diamond
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
35
et al. 2005a; Brandenburg & Dobler 2001; Blackman & Field 2000) 1 E · B0 = − j · b + e · b = αB02 , (2.38) σ da · b = −2e · b + ∇ · (bφ) − ∇ × (a × e), (2.39) dt dHM (2.40) = −2ηQH − FH , dt where φ is an arbitrary scalar (gauge) that is used to define the vector potential A, HM is the total magnetic helicity A · B, QH is the total current helicity J · B, and FH is the surface-integrated magnetic helicity flux through the boundaries of the domain. The first of these equations follows simply from Ohm’s Law, and relates α and the mean field to correlations between the small-scale magnetic fields, currents and emfs. The second is a conservation law for the averaged small-scale magnetic helicity — for statistically steady fields and suitable boundary conditions this may be simplified substantially to yield an equation for e · b (see Diamond et al. 2005a). The final equation expresses conservation of magnetic helicity. In the absence of magnetic diffusion and for boundary conditions that do not allow magnetic helicity to leave the domain the total magnetic helicity is conserved. Hence, under these constraints, if the large-scale magnetic helicity is to grow it must be at the expense of the small-scale magnetic helicity. These relations all allow the achievement of a similar goal — they permit the expression of the average emf E, which relies on correlations between u and b, in terms of correlations between j and b. This substitution is not much more than a matter of taste, since a priori we know none of u, j or b in the dynamic regime. However, the above expressions do become useful if they can be combined with a further expression relating α to b · j. As described below, this has been done, in an approximate sense, by Pouquet et al. (1976). As stated above, in order to calculate α it is necessary to solve for the fluctuating magnetic field and velocity. The dynamics is all contained in the role of the Lorentz force in modifying the small-scale velocity, which at high Rm may be subtle and unexpected. A widely used, though often misunderstood, result utilises the eddy-damped quasi-normal Markovian (EDQNM) framework to approximate this back-reaction for turbulence possessing a short correlation time. This approach has been used extensively for purely hydrodynamic turbulence (see, for example, Frisch 1995; Davidson 2004), although the range of its applicability is still an open question. For magnetised flows, in which the turbulence at high Rm appears to deviate
September 30, 2009
36
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
significantly from being normally distributed, there is no convincing evidence that the theory is applicable in any regime. Nonetheless, in the limit of short correlation time, and assuming that the magnetic field has no effect on the correlation time of the turbulence, the EDQNM formalism yields a relationship between α and b · j, namely τc α = − u · ω − b · j, (2.41) 3 where ω = ∇ × u (Pouquet et al. 1976). Note that in the kinematic limit this expression reduces to that given in Eq. (2.15), and that the effect of the Lorentz force is thus to add to the kinematic expression a magneticallydriven α-effect αM = τc /3 b · j. There are two other ways to derive this approximate result; either by using closure mode such as the ‘minimal τ approximation’ (Kleeorin et al. 2002), or by linearising about a pre-existing turbulent MHD state with low Rm and short τc (Proctor 2003). (In the second approach, great care must be taken in the interpretation of the meaning of the variables u, ω, b and j, as noted by Proctor.) It is worth stressing again that this approach has circumvented the need to calculate correlations between u and b in favour of calculating those between b and j — clearly some dynamical relationship between j and u has been assumed (or approximated). Ignoring for the minute any reservations about the validity of expression (2.41), it is now clear how to derive expressions for the dynamic effects of the magnetic field on the α-effect (and similarly for β). Combining one of the conservation laws with Eq. (2.41) yields either a dynamic result for the evolution of the magnetically-driven α-effect (αM ) (e.g. Blackman & Brandenburg 2002) or, under the assumption of stationarity, a simplified expression for α in the nonlinear regime — see, for example, the expressions in Gruzinov & Diamond (1994, 1995, 1996) and Kleeorin et al. (1995). In general these expressions support the notion that the α-effect is catastrophically quenched at high Rm (with the nature of the β-effect much less clear), though they indicate that the presence of a large-scale current (J) or of boundary conditions that allow magnetic helicity to escape from the domain may lead to alleviation of the catastrophic quench. The other approach to the question of the nonlinear suppression is to perform numerical simulations to calculate explicitly the emf as a function of Rm and B0 . This has the advantage that no approximations are necessary, but the disadvantage that results can only be obtained for fairly moderate values of Rm. Despite claims to the contrary in the literature, this is actually a reasonably severe restriction (as discussed below), and
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
37
considerable care should be taken in assessing the claimed values of Rm in different calculations. As an order of magnitude estimate, a calculation performed with 10003 spectral modes (or equivalently 16003 finite difference points), with a separation of scales of about a decade between domain size and the size of the most energetic turbulent eddy, is able accurately to reach magnetic Reynolds numbers of O(103 ). Two classes of numerical calculations have been performed in order to calculate the nonlinear dependence of the transport coefficients. The first employs a prescribed body force F(x, t) in Eq. (2.32) in order to drive the flow u. This can be carefully selected so as to drive a flow with particularly advantageous properties for large-scale dynamo action (in a similar manner to the way kinematic flows are selected to be maximally helical so that they yield strong α-effects). The forcing is typically chosen in order to drive a flow with large pointwise and net helicity and also strong time-dependence, so that particle trajectories within the flow are chaotic. Separation of scales can be achieved in two ways. One is to force the flow on a scale much smaller than that of the computational domain; e.g. in a spectral calculation applying the forcing at a wavenumber kf = 8, which determines the small-scale, and ascribing flows and fields with k = 1 to be large-scale (e.g. Brandenburg 2001). Here, however, there is no natural separation of scales and a continuous spectrum of scales emerges. The other (Cattaneo & Hughes 1996) is to drive the small-scale flow on the scale of the computational domain (kf = 1) and to achieve the separation of scales by imposing an infinite-scale (k = 0) mean magnetic field (B0 ), as in the kinematic case described above. The second approach to calculating the α-effect numerically in the nonlinear regime is to drive the flow via the action of buoyancy in a rotating convective flow (either compressible or incompressible), as discussed for the kinematic case in Sec. 2.2.2. A mean magnetic field is inserted and the emf E (and hence α) calculated self-consistently, taking account of the Lorentz force. There are now many examples of calculations employing both these approaches (e.g. Cattaneo & Hughes 1996; Cattaneo et al. 2002). Here we proceed by giving details of one such calculation (Cattaneo & Hughes 1996) and then discuss its relation to other such calculations later in the section. Here, the forcing F(x, t) is chosen so that in the absence of a magnetic field the Galloway-Proctor flow Eq. (2.21) is driven. A mean magnetic field is then imposed in the z-direction and the full magnetohydrodynamic system (Eq. (2.2) and Eq. (2.32)) evolved to a statistically steady state. The components of the mean emf E = (Ex , Ey , Ez ) are then calculated as a
September 30, 2009
38
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Fig. 2.4 Time histories of components of the emf for the 3d turbulent flow driven by the Galloway-Proctor forcing with a magnetic field imposed in the z-direction (from Cattaneo & Hughes 1996). The emf has strong temporal fluctuations, but a meaningful time average (thick line) can clearly be defined. The top two panels show Ez and Ex for a weak magnetic field; the time average of Ex converges to zero, as expected from symmetry considerations. The lowest panel shows Ez for a field of almost equipartition strength.
function of Rm and B0 , as shown in Fig. 2.4. These time series show clearly that the (space-averaged) emf is a wildly fluctuating quantity and that, in order to achieve average values for α that have converged to a meaningful result, temporal averages over significant time periods (very many turnover times of the flow) are necessary. However it is possible to integrate the equations for long enough to obtain a meaningful average value for α. This is plotted as a function of B0 (at fixed Rm) and Rm (at three representative values of B0 ) in figures 2.5a and 2.5b respectively. Taken together, these results strongly suggest that the α-effect is suppressed with a very strong dependence on field strength at high Rm. In particular, it appears possible to discriminate between the formulae in Eq. (2.34) and Eq. (2.37), with the numerical results indicating that Eq. (2.37) is a considerably more accurate description of the behaviour of the α-effect in the nonlinear regime.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
39
Fig. 2.5 α versus B02 (upper panel, from Cattaneo & Hughes 1996) and versus Rm (lower panel, from Cattaneo et al. 2002), for the same flow as in Fig. 2.4. The upper panel shows the predictions of the two quenching formulae Eq. (2.34) and Eq. (2.37) (with q = 1), and shows that the numerical simulations strongly support the latter.
Many other numerical calculations with various assumptions and interpretations (e.g. Brandenburg 2001; Ossendrijver et al. 2003) also indicate that the transport coefficients may be catastrophically quenched in the nonlinear regime. These results have, however, been criticised on the grounds that they are all undertaken in closed domains with boundary conditions that do not allow magnetic helicity to leave the computational domain (Blackman & Field 2000). The argument put forward is that large-scale helicity can only grow at the expense of small-scale helicity, as discussed above, and that the system is thus overly constrained. This is an interesting point and one that merits further investigation. It is difficult however to envisage a situation where the flux of magnetic helicity out of the domain can alleviate the constraint on the transport coefficients without removing flux from the domain and limiting the efficiency of the dynamo. Moreover,
September 30, 2009
40
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
the physical argument for strong suppression outlined above relies solely on the dynamics of the small scales and it is not clear how the modification of boundary conditions (possibly far away from the turbulent small-scale eddies) can lead to a significant enhancement of the local transport properties of the turbulence. 2.3.2
Other nonlinear effects
The suppression of the transport coefficients in the nonlinear regime is contentious and is likely to remain so for the foreseeable future. This issue lies at the very heart of mean field electrodynamics as it determines the level of saturation of nonlinear mean field models. However, there are other nonlinear processes that may be of importance for saturating the exponential growth of field in a kinematic mean field model. In Sec. 2.2.3 we described how differential rotation is a key feature of the dynamo process, stretching out a poloidal field and converting it into toroidal field (the ω-effect). Therefore a possible saturation mechanism involves the modification of the differential rotation by the Lorentz force. In order to model this, a detailed understanding of the mechanism for the generation and maintenance of differential rotation by rotating turbulent motions is required. In general, mean flows are set up in turbulent rotating systems via small-scale correlations, leading to Reynolds stresses that naturally transport angular momentum, allowing the formation of a pattern of differential rotation. As in mean field electrodynamics, the role of correlations in this picture is crucial — and poorly understood (see Diamond et al. 2005b for a comprehensive review of the generation of zonal flows in plasmas, and Brummell et al. 1998 or Brun et al. 2004 for a discussion of the generation of mean flows and differential rotation by convection). In the mean field formalism, the generation of mean flows by small-scale correlations is often parameterised using the Λ-effect, a closure scheme that relates the average Reynolds stresses to the local angular velocity and its derivatives (see R¨ udiger 1989 for a complete discussion). It is sufficient here to state that the theory underpinning the Λ-effect is a two-scale theory in a similar vein to mean field electrodynamics — and so has the same strengths and weaknesses. Just as for the transport coefficients α and β, the role of magnetic fields in modifying angular momentum transport, and hence differential rotation, is also poorly understood. However what is known is that the magnetic field can modify the differential rotation in a straightforward manner, with
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
41
a large-scale magnetic field B0 driving a large-scale flow via the action of the large-scale Lorentz force J0 × B0 in the momentum equation. This mechanism is often termed the ‘Malkus-Proctor effect’ (Malkus & Proctor 1975) in astrophysical dynamo theory (especially in solar dynamo theory, where this saturation mechanism has been extensively invoked). In addition, in a high Rm environment the presence of a large-scale field and a small-scale flow inevitably implies the presence of a strong small-scale field, as argued above. This small-scale field can itself influence the angular momentum transport in two ways; either by modifying the dynamics of the small-scale velocity (in particular the correlations that lead to the driving of mean flows in the first place) via the small-scale Lorentz force, or by itself driving mean flows via average Maxwell stresses (which arise through small-scale/small-scale interactions of magnetic fields). This process in mean field models has usually been either crudely parameterised in the form of ω-quenching (e.g. Roald & Thomas 1997), or Λ-quenching (e.g. Kitchatinov et al. 1994) in which the back-reaction of the magnetic field on the angular momentum transport is calculated within the same framework as the mean field equations. It is though important to note that all the difficulties and uncertainties surrounding the transport coefficients in mean field electrodynamics arise a fortiori in any theory of the modification of angular momentum transport.
2.3.3
Nonlinear mean Field Models
We discussed briefly in Sec. 2.2.3 how the framework of mean field electrodynamics could be used to construct kinematic dynamo models. As for the kinematic theory, most of the computational effort in the nonlinear regime has been ‘object specific’, with computations being undertaken with the specific aim of explaining the generation of magnetic fields in either planets, stars or galaxies. In these cases, plausible profiles for the differential rotation, α-effect and turbulent diffusivity are selected for the object to be modelled and, likewise, a nonlinear saturation mechanism is selected that may be of importance for the dynamo operating in that object. In this paper we do not attempt to discuss these astrophysically-motivated mean field models, as it is extremely difficult to draw robust conclusions from studies that aim specifically to model a particular astrophysical object in detail. Instead we focus on aspects of nonlinear behaviour that are inherent to all nonlinear mean field models, and refer the interested reader to reviews by Ossendrijver (2003) and Tobias & Weiss (2007), who discuss solar and
September 30, 2009
14:1
42
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
stellar models, by Jones (2003), who discusses planetary dynamos, and by Beck et al. (1996), who discuss the galactic dynamo. 2.3.3.1
Nonlinear Travelling Waves
Here we give a brief discussion of the role of nonlinearities in modifying the behaviour of the kinematic mean field dynamos discussed in Sec. 2.2.3 — i.e. plane-wave dynamos, bounded dynamos and spherical dynamos. The simplest example of a mean field dynamo (as discussed earlier) is the local travelling-wave solution of Parker (1955). There the solution is assumed to be independent of the z-coordinate and wave-like solutions depending on the x-coordinate are constructed. In order to extend this model to the nonlinear regime, where computational techniques are required, a finite domain must be considered. In two dimensions, boundary conditions must be imposed in both directions. Here we choose appropriate matching conditions in the z-direction and periodic boundary conditions in the x-direction (see Tobias 1997 for a detailed discussion). Within this framework it is now permissible to introduce the possibility that the transport coefficients (α and β) and the shear have an underlying dependence on the z-coordinate (though they remain independent of x). Such a model is local in the x-direction, but global in the z-direction. The nonlinear dynamics of such a model was investigated in detail in Tobias (1997) and the results summarised here. The linear theory (as for the completely localised Parker model described earlier) indicates that as the dynamo number is increased past a threshold value, instability sets in to travelling wave solutions, with a welldefined preferred wavelength and frequency (which depend on the critical dynamo number). The waves now possess non-trivial spatial structure in the z-direction, determined by the underlying profiles of the transport coefficients. What happens to the nonlinear solutions as the dynamo number D is increased further depends on the form of the nonlinearity adopted. The first class of nonlinearities considered are ‘static nonlinearities’ (such as α, β or ω-quenching), in which the mean magnetic field acts back instantaneously on the transport coefficient or differential rotation through a parameterised formula such as Eq. (2.34). For these instantaneous nonlinear effects the travelling wave solutions that are destabilised in the initial bifurcation remain stable as the dynamo number is increased and no further temporal structure is added. It is also found that α- and ω-quenching have similar properties, acting purely as equilibration mechanisms that have
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
43
little effect on the spatial dependence of the waves. Furthermore, for these cases, the wave-speed remains largely independent of the amplitude of the magnetic field as the dynamo number is increased. For β-quenching both the spatial structure and the wave speed of the travelling waves are modified in the nonlinear regime. Waves tend to travel more slowly as the magnetic diffusivity is quenched, and the dynamo becomes more inefficient. This change in the frequency of the waves due to diffusivity quenching may provide a constraint for oscillatory dynamo models. In the second class of nonlinearities the magnetic field acts back via a separate dynamical equation. This could be due to the mean field driving large-scale flows directly (the Malkus-Proctor effect), or to the mean magnetic field suppressing the small-scale turbulence dynamically (which may involve the addition of a dynamic equation for the evolution of the transport coefficients, α, β or Λ). If the dynamic Malkus-Proctor effect is included as a nonlinearity, then the travelling wave solutions created in the initial bifurcation rapidly lose stability to states with more spatio-temporal variability. In particular, a complicated series of bifurcations, involving a secondary and tertiary Hopf bifurcation to modulated travelling waves and quasi-periodic waves, leads to a transition to chaotic oscillations. The basic magnetic cycle becomes modulated on a time-scale that is determined by the ratio of the turbulent diffusivities for magnetic field (β) and angular velocity (νT ). This natural modulation of the basic magnetic cycle is often used as an explanation of intermittent behaviour in nonlinear dynamos — for example, the solar cycle is modulated and undergoes recurrent periods of reduced activity known as Grand Minima. 2.3.3.2
Nonlinear Dynamos in Finite Cartesian and Spherical Domains
The behaviour of nonlinear travelling waves described above is instructive, and yields some important results for the dependence of the amplitude and period of the mean field as a function of dynamo number. It also gives an indication of the role of dynamical nonlinearities in producing complicated spatio-temporal behaviour. However, we noted at the end of Sec. 2.2.3 that, even in the kinematic regime, dynamo solutions may have very different properties in finite domains to those found for periodic boundary conditions. Of particular importance is the interaction of the dynamo solutions with inhomogeneities in the underlying profiles of either the transport coefficients or the differential rotation, or the interaction with
September 30, 2009
44
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
boundaries. In the linear regime, both the frequency and the spatial form of the dynamo solutions were found to be sensitive to the imposition of boundary conditions and the inhomogeneities. It is therefore of no surprise that the behaviour of nonlinear mean field dynamo models in finite domains such as spheres, spherical shells, discs and Cartesian slabs may be very different to that of nonlinear travelling wave solutions. As for the kinematic case, most of the calculations of nonlinear mean field models in finite domains are targeted at modelling dynamos in specific astrophysical objects, with the structure of the transport coefficients and rotation profiles usually chosen using some plausible physical assumptions for the object to be modelled. In a similar manner the nonlinearity is chosen in a plausible, but ad hoc, manner. There are therefore a vast number of nonlinear mean field dynamo calculations, whose conclusions differ owing to the different assumptions behind the model in question (see, for example, the reviews cited above by Beck et al. 1996; Jones 2003; Ossendrijver 2003; Tobias & Weiss 2007). Discriminating between such models is extremely difficult and largely subjective. We prefer here to focus on generic properties of nonlinear models in finite domains — i.e. properties that appear robust whichever assumptions are included in the model. For nonlinear dynamo models in finite domains, the following properties tend to be observed. In general, the amplitude of the energy in the mean magnetic field is an increasing function of dynamo number. More specifically, the magnetic energy is often observed initially to increase linearly with supercriticality (i.e. B2 ∝ (D − Dc )) for D sufficiently close to its critical value Dc . As D − Dc is increased further there is a saturation of the amplitude of the mean field as a function of dynamo number. Moreover, as D − Dc increases, the dynamo solution becomes more irregular for all types of nonlinearities used. A sequence of bifurcations leads to the spatio-temporal fragmentation of solutions and eventually to chaotic time dependence of the dynamo solutions. This pattern of spatio-temporal chaos may in general be the result of either nonlinear interactions between the magnetic field and the mean flow (as discussed above for nonlinear dynamo waves), or the interaction between mean magnetic modes with different symmetry properties. These interactions can be understood with reference to the theory of nonlinear dynamical systems (see, for example, Knobloch et al. 1998, Tobias 2002 for an in-depth discussion of the mechanisms that can lead to the formation of chaotic solutions). For all nonlinearities, the primary frequency of oscillation of the dynamo appears to be an increasing function of dynamo number. This is due to the interaction of the nonlinear
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
45
wavetrain with the boundaries of the domain, and the subsequent change in lengthscale for the dynamo wavetrain (see, for example, Tobias 1998). Despite some common themes running through the nonlinear development of mean field dynamo models, there is still great uncertainty as to the range of applicability of such models. We stress again here that these models are based upon a theory for which even the kinematic behaviour is uncertain. It is clear that one must proceed with great care in evaluating the results of such nonlinear mean field models, though they may yet provide some insight into the mechanisms for the generation of magnetic field in astrophysical bodies.
2.4
Discussion
Since the formulation of mean field electrodynamics by Steenbeck, Krause and R¨ adler in the 1960’s — foreshadowed by the work of Parker (1955) — it has been used extensively in the modelling of the generation and maintenance of magnetic fields in planets, stars, galaxies and accretion discs. It is, in some sense, a remarkably successful theory, being able to reproduce temporal and spatial features of a tremendous range of observed astrophysical magnetic fields. This suggests strongly therefore that the ‘true’ equation describing the evolution of the mean field does indeed take the form of Eq. (2.9) — although this is possibly not all that surprising, since the αeffect closes the dynamo loop and β is (in its simplest form) a turbulent diffusivity. However, that is not to say that the all is well with mean field electrodynamics. Even at the level of reproducing observed cosmical fields, the freedom in the choice of parameters means that models inspired by different physical assumptions can lead to the same global features. Thus it is not possible to assert that specific magnetic behaviour (such as the cyclic evolution of a star’s magnetic field, for example) results from specific forms of αij and βijk , and hence from specific physical considerations. Conversely it is possible to have two rather similar mean field models that produce very different behaviour. Thus great care needs to be taken in the description — and, a fortiori, in the prediction — of astrophysical magnetic fields via parameterised mean field models. Detailed investigation of the micro-physics of the mean field transport coefficients leads to further difficulties. Although for turbulent flows with low magnetic Reynolds numbers or very short correlation times the mean field description seems to hold, for the astrophysically relevant case of
September 30, 2009
46
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
turbulence with Rm 1 and O(1) correlation times the very foundations of mean field electrodynamics seem unsure. Here it seems unavoidable that the fluctuations in the magnetic field overwhelm the mean. This leads, as discussed earlier, to problems both in the kinematic regime, in which it can be hard even to determine α, and in the dynamic regime, where any α-effect is ‘catastrophically’ quenched by an extremely weak mean magnetic field. It appears that maybe what is required are less turbulent, more ordered flows. In the Sun these may arise from the presence of the tachocline, a thin shear region at the base of the convection zone. However, what happens in fully convective stars, for example, or with the evolution of galactic magnetic fields, remains very much an open question. References [1] Backus G E 1958 Ann. Phys. 4 372–447. [2] Backus G, Parker R and Constable C 1996 Foundations of Geomagnetism (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). [3] Balbus S A and Hawley J F 1998 Rev. Mod. Phys. 70 1–53. [4] Beck R, Brandenburg A, Moss D, Shukurov A and Sokoloff D 1996 Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 34 155–6. [5] Blackman E G and Brandenburg A 2002 Astrophys. J. 579 359–73. [6] Blackman E G and Field G B 2000 Astrophys. J. 534 984–8. [7] Brandenburg A 2001 Astrophys. J. 550 824–40. [8] Brandenburg A and Dobler W 2001 Astrophys. J. 369 329–38. [9] Brandenburg A and Subramanian K 2005 Phys. Rep. 417, 1–209. [10] Brummell N H, Hurlburt N E and Toomre J 1998 Astrophys. J 493 955–69. [11] Brun A S, Miesch M S and Toomre J 2004 Astrophys. J 614 1073–1098. [12] Cattaneo F and Hughes D W 1996 Phys. Rev. E 54 R4532–5. [13] —- 2006 J. Fluid Mech. 553, 401–18. [14] Cattaneo F, Hughes D W and Proctor 1988 Geophys. Astrophys. Fluid Dyn. 41 335–42. [15] Cattaneo F, Hughes D W and Thelen J-C 2002 J. Fluid Mech. 456 219–37. [16] Childress S 1979 Phys. Earth Planet. Inter. 20 172–80. [17] Childress S and Gilbert A D 1995 Stretch, Twist, Fold: The Fast Dynamo (Springer-Verlag, Berlin). [18] Childress S and Soward A M 1972 Phys. Rev. Lett. 29 837–9. [19] Childress S and Soward A M 1989 J. Fluid Mech. 205 99–133. [20] Courvoisier A, Hughes D W and Tobias S M 2006 Phys. Rev. Lett. 034503. [21] Cowling T G 1934 Mon. Not. R. Astr. Soc. 94 39–48. [22] Davidson P A 2004 Turbulence: an Introduction for Scientists and Engineers Oxford University Press: Oxford. [23] Diamond P H, Hughes D W and Kim E 2005a In Fluid Dynamics and Dynamos in Astrophysics and Geophysics (eds A M Soward, C A Jones,
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Mean Field Dynamo Theory
BkFestival2003
47
D W Hughes and N O Weiss) (CRC press, Boca Raton) p 145–92. [24] Diamond P H, Itoh S-I, Itoh K and Hahm T S 2005b Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 47 R35–R161. [25] Frisch U 1995 Turbulence: the Legacy of A N Kolmogorov (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). [26] Galloway D J and Proctor M R E 1992 Nature 356 691–3. [27] Gruzinov A V and Diamond P H 1994 Phys. Rev. Lett. 72 1651–4. [28] Gruzinov A V and Diamond P H 1995 Phys. Plasmas 2 1941–6. [29] Gruzinov A V and Diamond P H 1996 Phys. Plasmas 3 1853–7. [30] Herzenberg A 1958 Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A250 543–83. [31] Hide R and Palmer T N 1982 Geophys. Astrophys. Fluid Dyn. 19 301–9. [32] Ivers D J and James R W 1984 Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A312 179–218. [33] Jepps S A 1975 J. Fluid Mech. 67 625–45. [34] Jones C A 2003 In Stellar Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics (eds. M J Thompson and J Christensen-Dalsgaard) (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) p 159–176. [35] Jones C A and Roberts P H 2000 J. Fluid Mech. 404 311–43. [36] Kitchatinov L L, R¨ udiger G and K¨ uker M 1994 Astron. Astrophys. 292 125–32. [37] Klapper I and Young L S 1995 Commun. Math. Phys. 173 623–46. [38] Kleeorin N and Ruzmaikin A A 1981 Geophys. Astrophys. Fluid Dyn. 17 281–96. [39] Kleeorin N, Rogachevskii I and Ruzmaikin A 1995 Astron. Astrophys. 297 159–167. [40] Kleeorin N, Rogachevskii I and Sokoloff D 2002 Phys. Rev. E 65 36303-7. [41] Knobloch E, Tobias S M and Weiss N O 1998 Mon. Not. R. Astr. Soc. 297 1123–38. [42] Krause F and R¨ adler K-H 1980 Mean Field Electrodynamics and Dynamo Theory (Pergamon Press, Oxford). [43] Kuzanyan K M and Sokoloff D D 1995 Geophys. Astrophys. Fluid Dyn. 81 113–29. [44] Larmor J 1919 Rep. Brit. Assoc. Adv. Sci. 1919 159–60. [45] Malkus W V R and Proctor M R E 1975 J. Fluid Mech. 67 417–44. [46] Moffatt H K 1974 J. Fluid Mech 65 1–10. [47] Moffatt H K 1978 Magnetic field generation in electrically conducting fluids (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). [48] Moffatt H K 1983 Rep. Prog. Phys. 46 621–64. [49] Ossendrijver M 2003 Astron. Astrophys. Rev. 11 287–367. [50] Parker E N 1955 Astrophys. J. 122 293–314. [51] Parker E N 1979 Cosmical Magnetic Fields: Their Origin and Their Activity (Clarendon Press, Oxford). [52] Plunian F and R¨ adler K-H 2002 Geophys. Astrophys. Fluid Dyn. 96 115–33. [53] Pouquet A, Frisch U and L´eorat J 1976 J. Fluid Mech. 77 321–54. [54] Proctor M R E 2003 In Stellar Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics (eds. M J Thompson and J Christensen-Dalsgaard) (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) p 143–158.
September 30, 2009
48
[55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76] [77] [78] [79] [80]
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Roald C B and Thomas J H 1997 Mon. Not. R. Astr. Soc. 288 551–64. Roberts G O 1972 Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A271 411–54. Roberts P H 1972 Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A272 663–98. Roberts P H and Soward A M 1992 Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 24 459–512. Roberts P H and Stix M 1972 Astron. Astrophys. 18 453–66. Rosner R 2000 Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A358 689–709. Rotvig J and Jones C A 2002 Phys. Rev. E 66 056308-1–15. R¨ udiger G 1989 Differential Rotation and Stellar Convection: Sun and SolarType Stars (Gordon and Breach, New York). Ruzmaikin A A, Shukurov A M and Sokoloff D D 1988 Magnetic Fields of Galaxies (Kluwer, Dordrecht). Soward A M 1974 Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A275 611–46. Soward A M 1987 J. Fluid Mech. 180 267–95. Steenbeck M and Krause F 1966 Z. Naturforsch. 21a 1285–96. Steenbeck M and Krause F 1969a Astron. Nachr. 291 49–84. Steenbeck M and Krause F 1969b Astron. Nachr. 291 271–86. Steenbeck M, Krause F and R¨ adler K-H 1966 Z. Naturforsch. 21a 369–76. Stellmach S and Hansen U 2004 Phys. Rev. E 70 056312-1–16. Tobias S M 1997 Geophys. Astrophys. Fluid Dyn. 86 287–343. Tobias S M 1998 Mon. Not. R. Astr. Soc. 296 653–61. Tobias S M 2002 Astron. Nachr. 323 417–423. Tobias S M & Weiss N O 2007 In The Solar Tachocline (eds D W Hughes, R Rosner and N O Weiss) (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) p319–50. Vainshtein S I and Cattaneo F 1992 Astrophys. J. 393 165–71. Vishik M M 1989 Geophys. Astrophys. Fluid Dyn. 48 151–67. Worledge D, Knobloch E, Tobias S and Proctor M 1997 Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A453 119–43. Yoshimura H 1978 Astrophys. J. 226 706–19. Zeldovich Ya B 1957 Sov. Phys. JETP 4 460–2. Zweibel E G 2005 In Fluid Dynamics and Dynamos in Astrophysics and Geophysics (eds A M Soward, C A Jones, D W Hughes and N O Weiss) (CRC press, Boca Raton) p115-43.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Chapter 3
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
P.-Y. Longaretti LAOG, Observatoire de Grenoble, BP53X, 38041 Grenoble Cedex 9, France The dynamics of the powerful jets observed in a variety of astrophysical objects is discussed, with special emphasis on the question of jet stability. This introduction is primarily aimed at researchers and graduate students of the fusion and plasma physics community, but is expected to provide a useful review to astrophysicits as well, especially the section concerning jet stability. The exposition begins with well-established background notions and more or less direct observational constraints on jet physics. Then the question of MHD jet origin and structure is discussed. Finally, jet stability is addressed in particular with respect to Kelvin-Helmholtz, current-driven and pressure-driven instabilities. The first half of the paper is rather descriptive, and the second half somewhat more technical. Although obviously useful, no prior exposure to astrophysics is required.
3.1
Introduction
Astrophysical jets span a surprisingly wide range of physical conditions. The largest ones are produced in some categories of Active Galactic Nuclei1 (AGNs in short). They can propagate over2 ∼ 106 pc, at nearly 1 A short description of AGNs, along with a brief survey of the relevant background astrophysical notions is provided in Appendix 3.A. 2 1 pc ∼ 3 × 1018 cm; 1 M 33 g; 1 L = solar mass ∼ 2 × 10 = solar luminosity ∼ 4 × 1033 erg/s.
49
September 30, 2009
50
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
the velocity of light. They originate from the environment of giant black holes of ∼ 106−9 M (see Fig. 3.11). At the opposite end of the mass and size spectrum, jets originating from Young Stellar Objects (YSOs), in their various early stages of formation, have typical extents of ∼ 1 pc, and propagation velocities of the order of a few 100 km/s; their parent protostars have masses ∼ 1 M (see Fig. 3.12). In between, one finds jets associated with neutron stars, X-ray binary systems and stellar mass black holes. For definiteness, only AGN and YSO jets are considered as specific examples of the physical processes discussed in this review. The ejection appears to be bipolar, with one jet on two opposite sides of the source. One of the jets may be weaker or even absent on images, due to observational selection effects; for example, relativistic emission in AGNs is often detected close to near alignment with the observer, so that one jet is strongly amplified, while the other one is strongly de-amplified. Somewhat paradoxically, these energetic ejection phenomena occur in conjunction with a vigorous accretion of gaseous matter onto the associated central object. The details of the involved processes are not and by far all understood, nor are they all agreed upon. However, there is a large consensus over the fact that large scale infalling gaseous matter fuels the small scale engine. A disk most likely forms in the process because energy is dissipated into heat and radiation during the collapse, while angular momentum is conserved in mechanical form. In the course of time, the matter of the disk is partially accreted onto the central object and partially expelled by the jet. For such a large scale collapse to proceed, the concentration of the ambient magnetic field flux must be largely limited through some sort of ambipolar, or turbulent diffusion process. The present observational limits do not allow us to pinpoint the source of large-scale jets, as the central region is too small to be directly observed: the jet driving source can either be the central object, its accretion disk, or the interaction zone between the two. As the central engine (central object and inner disk) is not directly accessible to observation, even in YSOs, its dynamics is only indirectly constrained. Nevertheless, the coexistence of accretion and ejection phenomena is well supported by the available body of observations. All the most powerful jets observed in all classes of astrophysical objects — the so-called FR2 jets in AGNs, and most YSO jets — appear as very narrow, highly collimated outflows over most of their propagation length, with opening angles not exceeding a few degrees. They end up in gigantic, much less well-organized, lobes of hot matter, which form through the
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
51
interaction of the jet with the ambient medium (see Fig. 3.11 and 3.12); this interaction takes on the form of a (usually double) bow shock in YSOs. These lobes often seem much more prominent than the well-organized jets themselves3 . An important feature which is often observed in both AGN and YSO jets is the presence of bright knots travelling along the jet, known as Herbig-Haro objects in the case of YSOs. The origin of these structures is still highly debated, and is possibly system dependent. Also, their relation to the global dynamics of the jets is unclear, as radiation is not always a reliable tracer of mass in astrophysical objects. Finally, it is worth noting that the jet radiation is mostly produced through thermal emission lines in the case of YSOs, while it is mostly a non-thermal continuum in the case of AGNs. A striking feature in both cases is the propagation distance compared to the size of their region of birth. Indeed, both for AGNs and YSOs, the characteristic scale of the central region is ∼ 1 AU (Astronomical Unit4 ). Therefore jets can propagate over about 105 times their initial radial extent in YSOs, and 1011 times in AGNs. Even if one restricts attention to the quasi-cylindrical propagation section, jets propagate over at least tens to hundreds of times (for YSOs) to 106 times (for AGNs) their radius. The question of jet stability has at least two different aspects in this context. On the one hand, one would like to understand how these jets can propagate over such enormous distances without losing coherence. On the other, one would like to understand the origin of the jet apparently inhomogeneous spatial and temporal structure (this last question is barely addressed in the present review). Our present lack of observational constraints makes these questions ill-posed to some extent. As a consequence, our present understanding is only partial, and partially model-dependent, and in any case, less well-developed than (although on some issues related to) the theory of fusion devices. Our present core knowledge of the systems in which jets are observed is presented in Sec. 3.2. What is known (or not known) on jet launching mechanisms is discussed in Sec. 3.3. Models of jet structure are exposed in Sec. 3.4, with special emphasis on disk-driven jets, the most studied ones; our understanding of jet acceleration and collimation is also discussed in this context. Jet stability, the main object of these notes, is reviewed in Sec. 3.5; this topic is the one most directly connected 3 The 41
dynamics of the formation of this lobe is not considered in the present review. AU ≡ Sun-Earth distance 150 × 106 km∼ 10−5 pc.
September 30, 2009
52
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
to the physics of fusion devices. Finally, a summary is proposed and some open issues are gathered in Sec. 3.6. The material presented here is rather descriptive at first, before moving to a more theoretically oriented exposition. No attempt is made at a complete or even fair bibliographical coverage, as this would easily constitute an overwhelming fraction of this chapter. Instead, well-established facts and ideas are exposed with reference to more complete reviews or books, but limited in number, to provide an easier entry point to the subject. References to original articles are reserved for more specialized or less wellknown aspects, for which no recent review is available. They are therefore more numerous in the later sections. Peripheral or more technical matters are relegated to various appendices. The exposition is intended to be self-contained, and to provide a guideline to the more specialized literature.
3.2
Generalities on astrophysical jets
A discussion of the stability of jets supposes some knowledge of their structure and fundamental physical properties. Unfortunately, we have no detailed or direct observational constraints on some of the most important physical parameters. Furthermore, the type of information we have depends on the class of objects considered. The purpose of this section is to briefly survey what we know, in order to focus as much as possible on the relevant physics. An underlying theme is that one can define a “core” knowledge, common to all object classes, while taking into account particular features when needed. This idea is reasonably consistent with our current body of knowledge. Accretion and ejection seem to be highly interdependent phenomena. For example, accretion and ejection efficiencies appear to be closely related in YSOs through their various evolutionary stages [1] and an understanding of jet stability partially relies on the identification of the constraints put by this interdependence on jet essential characteristics. Arguments for the presence of accretion-ejection structures, as well as some of their physical characteristics, are briefly surveyed here in both AGNs and YSOs. The aim of this section is to make the whole picture plausible, rather than to establish its various aspects in full detail. For more in-depth discussions of our core body of knowledge on AGNs, see, e.g., [2, 3] and references therein. Concerning AGN jets more specifically, see [4, 5] and references therein. For YSOs, see, e.g., [6–8, 1] and references therein.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
3.2.1 3.2.1.1
BkFestival2003
53
Accretion Active Galactic Nuclei
The existence of a massive central object, most probably a Black Hole, was recognized relatively early on after the now more than forty years old discovery of AGNs (see [2] for a review; for an introduction to the relevant Black Hole physics, see [3] pp. 192-208). Of course the Black Hole itself is not visible; its existence is inferred from the radiation emitted by the material in its neighborhood, or from the motion of this material, if accessible to observation. The spectra of AGNs suggest that the innermost medium producing the high energy emission is fully ionized. In such conditions, the material, mostly composed of electrons and protons, must be bound against the radiation pressure by the gravitational attraction of the central body. The radiation pressure on electrons considerably exceeds that on protons5 , while the gravitational attraction is larger on protons. Assuming that both species are bound by electrostatic forces leads to the definition of the Eddington luminosity LE : LE =
4πcGM mp ∼ 1046 M8 erg/s, σT
(3.1)
where mp is the proton mass σT is the Thomson cross-section, and M8 ≡ M/(108 M ). This argument, combined with the observed luminosity of AGNs, explains the M = 106−9 M mass range quoted in the introduction for the nucleus. That this nucleus must also be a Black Hole follows from various lines of arguments (for a more complete critical discussion, see [3]): • AGNs exhibit rapid variability, with time-scales tv as short as a few minutes (they are longer for the more luminous objects). The coherence of this variability implies that the size of the emission region is l < ctv , i.e., of the order of the Schwarzschild radius (RS = 2GM/c2 ) of Black Holes in the above quoted mass range. • The efficiency of conversion into radiation (i.e., the ratio of the emitted radiation to the nuclear mass, E/M c2 ) is of the order of a few percents, making nuclear reactions an unlikely source of energy. Actually, gravitation is the most efficient known reservoir, as the energy 5 The resulting force is F = Lσ /4πcr 2 where L is the luminosity of the central object T and σT the Thomson cross-section. Spherical symmetry is assumed in this definition, but an asymmetric matter or radiation distribution would only change the result by a factor of order unity.
September 30, 2009
54
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
that can be released by a test particle falling from infinity onto a Black Hole is comprised between 6% and 42% of the particle rest mass energy. • The analysis of stellar motions in the vicinity of a Black Hole galactic nucleus implies an increase in the stars’ velocity dispersion. This has been reported in a few galaxies (in particular, our own, although it does not host an AGN). • The density of a large mass Black Hole is fairly small6 . Consequently, most scenarios of nucleus formation end up in a Black Hole being formed, by lack of ways to halt gravitational collapse. An AGN must steadily accrete gaseous matter to maintain its radiation output7 . For example, assuming an efficiency = 0.1 for definiteness, the mass accretion rate of an AGN at the Eddington limit of Eq. (3.1) is dME /dt ∼ 2M8 M /yr. There is enough time since the formation of galaxies and appearance of AGNs in the past to build up their inferred mass, and enough gas in the host galaxy to do this. Furthermore, as pointed out in the introduction, the specific angular momentum of this gaseous supply implies that it must form a disk, sufficiently close to the Black Hole8 . An accretion disk has at least two main virtues for the theorist: it allows the angular momentum to be evacuated outwards and/or upwards if the disk launches a jet while mass is accreted9 , and in the process explains how the energy gained by infall in the gravitational potential well is liberated as radiation. The weakest point of this picture is that the transfer requires anomalous (wave or turbulent) transport in the disk, as the efficiency of the process exceeds by many orders of magnitude the expected microscopic transport. The physical origin and properties of this transport are not yet fully understood, although the last 15 years have witnessed an important breakthrough on this issue (see [9, 10] for an introductory review). The disk physics in AGNs is badly constrained: it is still unclear whether disks are thin or thick in the direction perpendicular to the disk plane (“vertical”), whether angular momentum transport is primarily driven by 6 As m n ∼ M/R3 ∝ M −2 , only stellar mass Black Holes are very dense objects; note p S that space curvature changes the usual estimates of volumes by factors of order unity only. 7 Only gas, as opposed e.g. to stars, can collisionnally dissipate the kinetic energy of infall into radiation. 8 Although spherical or quasi-spherical accretion has been largely discussed in the literature, and is probably relevant far enough from the nucleus, the mere presence of jets indicates the breaking of spherical symmetry, anyway. 9 The maximum angular momentum density theoretically allowed in the central Black Hole is much smaller than that of the accreted gas.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
55
turbulent stresses or Maxwell stresses associated to a magnetic field threading the disk, and so on. Thick disks radiate less efficiently than thin disks, in part because they must be optically thick to geometrically thicken in the first place. As the physics is simpler to formulate in the latter case than in the former, a thin disk is often assumed, resulting in a keplerian rotation law10 [v(r) ∝ r1/2 ].
3.2.1.2
Young stellar objects
YSOs are observed in our Galaxy, i.e., at distances which are considerably smaller than AGNs (hundreds of parsecs instead of mega- or gigaparsecs). They are rather numerous in giant interstellar molecular complexes (tens of parsecs in size), such as the Taurus ones. The size of the “central engine” is roughly the same in AGNs and YSOs; consequently, because of their relative proximity, the latter are much better known from an observational point of view, and the various stages of star formation, from the initial collapse of a cloud core, to a young individual or multiple star, are rather well constrained. After the initial stage of cloud core collapse, taking at most 104 years, a protostar forms and evolves to a main sequence star in about 106 to 107 years. This factor of 10 of uncertainty is the object of a lively debate in the community, as it may rule out ambipolar diffusion as a mechanism of magnetic flux expulsion in the collapse stage of cloud cores (see, e.g., [11, 12]). The accretion disk forms and dissipates on the same time-scale, as well as the jet. The overall accreted/ejected mass amounts to ∼ 1 M /10−1 M , for a solar mass star. Accretion disks around protostars or young stars, such as T Tauri stars, have initially been postulated to explain the infrared continuum excess observed in these objects (which in this picture would arise from the viscous heating and the subsequent black-body radiation, of a disk in nearly keplerian rotation). With the advent of high resolution imaging techniques, such as adaptative optics and infrared interferometry, outer disk regions are now directly seen in a number of instances, out to a few hundreds of astronomical units (see Fig. 3.12 for example). In a few instances, the velocity profile has been determined from a Doppler effect measurement at millimeter radio wavelengths, and was found to be compatible with a keplerian law ([13] p. 192). 10 For the disk to be thin, the internal pressure must be small compared to the gravitational attraction of the central object, which then dominates the motion.
September 30, 2009
56
3.2.2
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Magnetic fields in jets
The present evidence and constraints on the magnetic field in astrophysical jets is rather indirect. In fact, one of the best arguments in favor of dynamically significant magnetic fields in astrophysical jets is theoretical: a magnetic field offers the best way to create, accelerate and collimate the jet; if furthermore the jet originates in the accretion disk, then the magnetic stress can also contribute to the accretion flow by extracting angular momentum from the disk and transferring it to the jet (see Sec. 3.3.3). Furthermore, purely hydrodynamic jets are prone to destructive KelvinHelmholtz instabilities (see Sec. 3.5). The idea of a dynamically significant magnetic field is supported by the available evidence: • In AGNs, the jet emission is linearly polarized. This indicates both that the jet is magnetized, and that the jet material is ionized. The inferred direction of the magnetic field is either longitudinal (in compact sources) or transverse (mostly in extended radio sources) (see, e.g., [14]). The significance of these directions measurements is difficult to assess, as it is biased by the dominant emitting region. For example, the field will become predominantly transverse in MHD shocks due to plasma compression, even if it is mostly longitudinal elsewhere. The evidence from radio sources is usually compatible either with a predominantly longitudinal field in the jet core, and predominantly toroidal further out, or with a helical field (e.g., [15, 16]). • The continuum of AGN jets is best interpreted in terms of synchrotron and inverse Compton emission. For a synchrotron source, at fixed spectral emissivity, the total pressure of the plasma is minimized at equipartition between the gaseous and magnetic energy density (see, e.g., [3] p. 170-172). This minimal pressure exceeds the intergalactic pressure, in particular in FRII sources, as constrained by X ray observations of the hot and tenuous intergalactic gas. This implies in turn that these jets must be magnetically confined, as free expansion is observationally excluded (ibid, p. 230-232). Magnetic confinement implies that the gaseous pressure cannot exceed equipartition on average. • Polarization measurements in YSO jets prove the existence of a ∼ 1 G magnetic field at distances of a few tens of astronomical units from the jet source in at least one case [17]. The temperature, density and pressure are also constrained from the analysis of line emission [1, 18]. Depending on the assumed magnetic field configuration, this results in
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
57
Table 3.1 Estimates of the physical parameters relevant for AGN and YSO jets. Values are typical in YSOs, but refer to strong AGN jets. Quantities in parentheses belong to the ambient medium, when applicable. For the jet radius and jet speed, the range of values is indicative, not only of intrinsic uncertainty, but of the trend along the jet. An Alfv´ en speed of the order of the sound speed is usually assumed. The magnetic fields estimates are obtained with the same type of equipartition argument.
Jet radius Jet length Jet speed Vj Magnetic field Sound speed
AGNs 10−2 – 103 pc 1 Mpc 10−3 c – c 1 – 10−4 (< 10−5 ) G 10−2 – 1 Vj (?) (10−3 c)
YSOs 30 – 300 AU 1 pc ∼ 300 km/s 10−4 (< 10−5 ) G 10 (0.2) km/s
badly constrained values of β = 2µo P/B 2 , which can be as low as 10−3 or as high as 103 . However, recent observations such as the one on Fig. 3.12 imply that jets are collimated very close to the source (down to 0.1 pc), while the external pressure is unlikely to play any role. As in the case of AGNs, this suggests that jets are self-collimated, which excludes values of β much in excess of unity. • Conversely, in YSOs, the ratio of the jet velocity to the jet sound speed is consistent with freely expanding jets. This however raises the question of the mechanism responsible for their initial acceleration, as purely hydrodynamical mechanisms lead to destructive Kelvin-Helmholtz type of instabilities ([19, 20]; see also Sec. 3.5). Furthermore, these jets are significantly more extended in the transverse direction than the region which gives them birth. The size of these regions is comparable to the central object’s, as jets asymptotic velocities are comparable to the central object escape velocity. The most likely collimation mechanism consistent with this feature is magnetic in origin (see Sec. 3.4). Order of magnitude estimates of the most important physical parameters are summarized in Table 3.1. The quoted values are highly uncertain concerning pressure and magnetic fields in AGNs, as they result from the very rough equipartition argument exposed above. Note however that this argument is self-consistently checked in some synchrotron self-Compton (SSC) sources where the ratio of the synchrotron to the Compton emissions can be measured and constrains the magnitude of the magnetic field, so that the gas pressure can then be derived from the synchrotron emissivity itself.
September 30, 2009
58
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
In any case, the overall jet β parameter is probably not smaller than, say, 10−2 or 10−3 , and not larger than ∼ 1. Magnetic field values in YSOs are also highly uncertain, as the effect of the magnetic field on line emission is more difficult to detect, but temperatures and pressures are more stringently constrained from the analysis of the line thermal emission. A similar crude equipartition is usually assumed in YSO jets as well. The jet velocities are measured from the outflow speed in YSOs. It is more uncertain in AGNs, because the measurement is less direct: the absence of emission lines makes a Doppler measurement impossible; also the relation that the speed of the material producing the jet high emission possibly bears to the speed of the bulk of the jet is highly uncertain (see next section). The origin of the magnetic fields observed in jets and postulated in disks is unclear11 . They can either have been advected along in the initial collapse of the central object, or generated in the disk through some sort of dynamo process. Actually, as pointed out in the introduction, there is more than ample ambient field to do that, and the field flux must be evacuated somehow during the infall and disk formation. If too much flux is expelled out, a dynamo action must be invoked, and the problem relies not so much in explaining the magnitude of the field than in understanding its configuration. In models where the jet originates from the disk, a dipolar-like field is usually assumed (see Fig. 3.14), threading the disk vertically at the disk mean-plane. Quadrupolar configurations, with the disk midplane as a plane of symmetry, have also been considered. Analytical investigations indicate that when the coupling of the jet to the disk is taken into account only dipolar configurations are capable of producing stationary jets, at least for keplerian accretion disks [21]. Either dipolar or quadrupolar geometries can be produced by a disk dynamo, depending on the sign of the α effect. Both signs can apparently emerge from disk dynamo simulations, but simulations also seem to confirm the analytic argument on the preferred dipolar configuration for jet production (see e.g. [22] and references therein).
3.2.3
Relativistic vs non-relativistic jets in AGNs
Bulk Lorentz factors of 10 or larger can be inferred from the high energy emission of AGNs, and it has long been debated in the community whether this implied that the entire jet is relativistic, or only a more energetic but 11 The question of the origin of astrophysical magnetic fields is briefly overviewed in Appendix A.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
59
highly sub-dominant population12 . The first type of models is conceptually simpler, but the second one is energetically more favorable. Over the years, various lines of arguments have been put forward, favoring the second option over the more widely accepted first one (note however the possible role of the light cylinder13 [23]): • Recent numerical simulations have shown a lack of cylindrical collimation in relativistic jets [24, 25]. This problem is well-known in the pulsar wind community (where Lorentz factors are usually rather large) and arises because the energy in the electric field is always comparable to or even larger than the energy in the azimuthal magnetic field (for some details, see e.g. [5]), counteracting the confining action of the azimuthal magnetic field tension14 . Parabolic confinement is possible once relativistic jets have become large enough in radius [26, 27], but this type of confinement may be difficult to reconcile with the jet-like appearance of the emission regions, due to the relativistic focusing of the radiation in the forward direction. • The total emission observed in radio lobes is compatible with comparatively low (∼ 0.1) bulk Lorentz factors. • High bulk Lorentz factors can only be achieved if the ejection efficiency (the mass-loss rate in the outflow compared to the mass accretion rate in the disk) is extremely low, 10−5 , typically; this follows because the energy reservoir is the electromagnetic field, and is finite, so that the asymptotic speed achieved decreases with increasing mass ejection, a qualitative consequence of Bernoulli’s invariant (see e.g. [26] for a more quantitative assessment). However, such low mass ejection efficiencies cannot be obtained for stationary jets if the jet originates in the disk [21, 28]. Of these arguments, probably the most critical, although not yet widely acknowledged, is the first one. Taken together, they suggest that relativistic 12 It is also not clear that large bulk Lorentz factors are intrinsic, as they can be biased by simplifying assumptions made in the analysis of the data. 13 The issue is the following. Because jets widen substantially before collimation takes place, relativistic velocities can be achieved if the jet radius r reaches r = Ω/c. Then, the local neutrality assumption of MHD must fail, and a fully relativistic treatment is called for. On the other hand, the other terms in the generalized Ohm’s law must also become non-negligible, and the question has apparently not yet been convincingly addressed in the literature. 14 The electric field contribution in the nonrelativistic regime is smaller by a factor (v/c)2 , as seen from the ideal MHD Ohm’s law E + v × B = 0.
September 30, 2009
60
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
ejections are less important than previously anticipated for the dynamics of most of the ejected material, a point which is however still debated in the community. In such a context, the relativistic motions and emissions could be explained by the existence of a subdominant electron-positron developing and accelerating to relativistic velocities in the core of a more massive nonrelativistic, or mildly relativistic MHD jet, which would act as an energy reservoir for the whole structure, as sketched on Fig. 3.13. The MHD jet would provide the turbulence which is responsible for the continuous reheating of the pair plasma, while the radiation force from the disk can accelerate it to relativistic velocities (see [29, 30] and references therein). Alternatively, a Blandford-Znajek type of mechanism (described in Sec. 3.3.1) can produce the inner jet. In any case, the idea of a twocomponent model, of this type of another, is slowly attracting attention, due to the problems that one component models are facing (see, e.g. [31]).
3.3
Origin of jets
As mentioned in the introduction, jets can be produced either by the central object, the disk/central-object interaction region, or the disk itself. These three possibilities are briefly discussed here.
3.3.1
Central object
YSO jets are usually not believed to originate from the protostar, as they carry too much momentum for this to be a viable option [32]; in particular, the large mass ejection rates observed in the very first stages of protostellar formation (∼ 10−6 M /yr) exceed by several orders of magnitude the largest rates that can be produced by a stellar wind. This option is therefore not further discussed here. Conversely, the central object of an AGN is often believed to be a viable source of AGN jets. This may be somewhat surprising, because, as discussed in Sec. 3.2.1, this central object is believed to be a Black Hole, a fact requiring some explanation. Black Holes are described by only three quantities, as all other characteristics of the material which ended up in the Black Hole are lost in the Hole formation process: their mass M (or gravitational radius rg = GM/c2 ), their specific angular momentum a (< rg c), and their charge, which is
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
61
usually assumed to be zero (presumably, Black Holes form from globally neutral material). The gravitational radius characterizes the Black Hole event horizon, i.e., the limit between the inner and outer space of the Black Hole (the inner space is curved and closed on itself). The specific angular momentum defines a region outside the horizon, called ergosphere, of maximum radius r+ = rg + (rg2 − a2 /c2 )1/2 . In the ergosphere, no object can maintain itself static with respect to an observer at infinity. RL
ΩL
Magnetic flux surface (Φ)
Load electric resistance
Ω I (current) I (current) RH Hole electric resistance Black Hole
ΩH
( ΩH − Ω ) ∆Φ = I RH ( Ω − ΩL ) ∆Φ = I RL
Fig. 3.1 Sketch of a rotating Black Hole equivalent circuit in the Blandford-Znajek mechanism. The Hole rotation generates by induction an electromotive force between the pole and the equator. If the Hole and “astrophysical load” rotation velocities differ, a current flows, generating energy dissipation. This system is powered by the Hole rotation (after [3]). The energy sink may be a jet.
Although no energy and momentum can be extracted from a nonrotating Black Hole, this is not true for a rotating one, as first demonstrated by Penrose. Indeed, inside the ergosphere, some particle orbits have a total negative energy so that the energy of the Hole decreases when such particles cross its horizon. This can lead to energy extraction, if e.g., a pair of particles is created out of vacuum fluctuations in the Hole potential well, one with total negative energy and an orbit entering the Hole, and one with positive energy and an orbit escaping the Hole. Because the area of Black Holes cannot decrease (a theorem due to Hawking), there is a limit to energy extraction of a rotating Black Hole, which cannot exceed 29% of its total mass and binding energy (see [3] p. 194-200, and references therein for more details).
September 30, 2009
62
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
In a famous paper [33], Blandford and Znajek have devised a more powerful way to extract energy and momentum from the rotation of a Black Hole, by transfer from the Hole to an electromagnetic field anchored on the Hole horizon. The involved processes are rather complex, and are best grasped within the framework of the “membrane paradigm” [34], which establishes the idea that the Black Hole horizon acts as a conducting membrane of finite resistivity equal to the vacuum resistivity, and endowed with fictitious charges and currents to account for the behavior of electric and magnetic fields in the vicinity of the horizon. Based on this idea, MacDonald and Thorne [35] have reformulated the Blandford and Znajek mechanism as a form of general relativistic direct current electric circuit problem. In this picture, a Hole rotating in a magnetic field induces an electromotive force between the pole and the equator V ∼ ΩH rg2 B ∼ ΩH Φ (Φ is the magnetic flux at the membrane). Energy extraction comes about due to the difference in angular velocity between the hole itself and some far away “astrophysical load”, as sketched on Fig. 3.1 (for a more complete heuristic description of this picture, see [3] p. 205-207). A pair plasma can be produced and accelerated into a jet in this context [36], but most of the energy remains in the electromagnetic field. To date, the exact efficiency of the mechanism remains to be precisely quantified, due to the high level of complexity of the involved general relativistic apparatus, and the poor knowledge of the characteristics of the astrophysical load. A potential problem of principle has been raised by Punsly and Coroniti [37], who argued that the outgoing wind that might be driven in this picture cannot be in causal contact with the event horizon. This point has recently been shown to be incorrect [38, 39]. Also, it seems to appear that the process is efficient only for AGNs radiating well below the Eddington limit of Eq. (1) unless the magnetic field on the Hole horizon largely exceeds the maximum field allowed in the accretion disk by stability considerations [5], and that in any case the power source from the gravitational binding energy exceeds that from the Black Hole rotation energy, at least for thin accretion disks [40]. 3.3.2
Disk/central-object interaction region
In the context of AGNs, the coupling between the disk and the central object (Black Hole) is formulated as a modification of the Blandford-Znajek mechanism, in which the astrophysical load is partly or wholly constituted by the disk itself (e.g., [40, 41] and references therein). This line of work
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
63
mostly emphasizes the effect of this coupling on the radiation emitted by the AGN central engine, and virtually nothing is known on the effect on a potential jet, beyond what has been said above in the previous subsection. The situation is somewhat clearer in the YSO context, where the physics does not reach such a high level of intricacy, and investigations have been started by various groups both semi-analytically (see [42–44] and references therein) and numerically (see [45] and references therein). These investigations are rather preliminary, and some important aspects of the involved physics are not yet understood. However, a few elements seem unavoidable: • The protostar magnetosphere plays an essential role in its interaction with its accretion disk. Protostars rotate at about 10% of their breakup velocity [6], and seem to maintain a constant period during their accretion phase. If the disk extended down to the protostar surface, it would rotate much faster than the star in the accretion layer, and would spin up the protostar. • Conversely, in presence of a magnetosphere, the disk may be truncated near the corotation radius, i.e., the radius at which the star rotation velocity matches the disk’s. Magnetic coupling with the material beyond corotation will slow down the star, and accretion could occur through magnetospheric columns, as suggested by recent observations [46]. In fact, this type of model was initially put forward to explain the low rotation of newly formed stars. • The interaction region must be narrow otherwise the magnetospheric field lines inflate and diffuse out, because of the turbulent diffusivity whose existence is inferred from the accretion itself [47]. Two basic configurations have been explored in the literature, to match the disk field to the magnetospheric one. They are sketched on Fig. 3.2. In one of them [42, 43], two azimuthally extended “Y-points” are present in the field above and below the disk mid-plane, noted as n on the sketch. In this picture, the angular momentum of the star is deposited in the disk via the magnetic coupling of the magnetospheric field. It is then presumably carried outwards by the disk turbulent viscosity, and then evacuated from the system by a conventional disk jet (see next section). In the second picture [44], the magnetospheric field and the disk one reconnect through an azimuthally extended “X-point”, a jet forms from mass transferred from the disk to the newly opened field lines, and is expelled by the centrifugal force of the rotating protostar. The spin down of the star is a priori more
September 30, 2009
64
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
outflow accretion
X type magnetic configuration
Y type magnetic configuration
Fig. 3.2 Sketches of the two proposed configurations of protostar-disk magnetic interaction, presented as cuts in the (r, z) plane (axisymmetry is assumed). The relative sizes of the stars and the various distances are somewhat arbitrary. The configuration of the right involves two “Y-type” neutral points, denoted by the letter n, while the configuration on the left relies on the existence of an X reconnection point (adapted from [44] and [43]).
efficient in this model but it requires reconnection to go on, possibly in a time-dependent fashion, throughout the life-span of the structure, thus implying that the star continuously replenishes its magnetic flux, or that more and more stellar magnetospheric lines are open. 3.3.3
Disk
Although criticized in the literature (a point addressed right below), diskdriving is by far the most studied case. On the analytical front, original papers and some noteworthy developments include references [48–56, 21]. The constant progress of computers has also prompted numerical investigations of the problem in the last decade (see e.g., [57–61] and references therein). Disk-driving has been criticized on two different fronts. First, it has been pointed out that in a standard disk model supplied with turbulent resistivity and viscosity, the field lines are either not bent enough due to flux diffusion [62], or the flux is totally expelled [63]. However, the existing global disk-wind solutions involve an inflow velocity which is substantially larger than the standard model prediction [56, 21], with sufficient resultant field line bending, thereby escaping escaping the self-consistency problem, but possibly not the formation one. Secondly, disk-jet models have been argued to be unstable [64, 65]; however, the global disk-wind solutions
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
65
just mentioned possibly escape this problem as well, as briefly discussed in Sec. 3.5.1. In any case, one reason behind the favor enjoyed by the disk-driving scenario is undoubtedly that, as complex as the physics of jet launching from accretion disks may be, it is significantly simpler to analyze than the other two options previously discussed. Another reason (circumstantial evidence, rather), is that an accretion disk is the only physical ingredient common to all the systems where jets are observed ([66] and references therein). In fact, some care should be in order in the use of this argument, as what is shown by the observations of a wide variety of physical systems, besides YSOs and AGNs, is that: • All systems in which jets are observed have also direct or indirect signs of the presence of an accretion disk. • However, the reverse is not true. In particular, some cataclysmic variable (CV) systems (a particular kind of stellar binaries) have an accretion disk, but no jet. • All observed jets have velocities comparable to the central object escape velocity. The last point implies that if jets are produced by the disk and not by the central object, they originate from the disk inner region. As the central object does not clearly play a role in YSOs and in the other systems except those containing a Black Hole, such as AGNs or microquasars, the prevailing opinion (or bias) is that jets are produced by accretion disks. In any case, the absence of jet in CVs is an important open issue. The basic MHD processes which allow a disk to drive a jet are sketched15 on Figs. 3.14 and 3.15. An accretion disk is threaded by a magnetic field, producing axisymmetric magnetic flux surfaces. The rotation velocity provides for the vertical winding of the field lines, and the self-consistently produced accretion flow for the inward (at the disk plane) motion of the magnetic flux. Turbulence in the disk is assumed to provide a turbulent diffusivity which allows the structure to reach steady state, and the matter in the disk flows through the magnetic surfaces, both azimuthally and radially. In the process, the magnetic field is made to rotate at a velocity slightly smaller than the rotation velocity of the matter where the magnetic surface crosses the disk midplane. 15 Beware that in more realistic configurations, the radius at which jet magnetic surfaces recollimate towards the axis is considerably larger than shown on Fig. 3.14.
September 30, 2009
66
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
From an electrodynamic point of view, this difference of rotation velocity between the field and the disk material induces an electromotive field E ∼ uφ × Bz , and, correlatively, an outward radial current in the disk. This current induces in turn a torque on the disk, which acts against the disk rotation (Lenz’s law). This torque dominate any possible turbulent torque in the disk (see Appendix 3.B.2), and causes matter to fall onto the central object. Matter lying close enough to the disk midplane eventually accretes onto the central object. Matter lying somewhat farther away from the mid-plane gradually undergoes an uplifting force due to the disk vertical pressure gradient, until it ends up in an ideal MHD region. It is then entrained by the magnetic field rotation, which provides an outward centrifugal force and feeds the ejection. This follows because the corresponding field lines are anchored in the disk closer to the central object, and therefore rotate faster than the matter at the location of “loading” of the matter onto the field line, i.e., at the transition between resistive and ideal MHD. Note that the efficiency of turbulent diffusion in the jet is not constrained. It is a necessary assumption of this whole picture that it can be neglected, at least in first approximation. In the initial stage of the ejection process (close to the disk), the field energy density dominates over the matter one. However, in the centrifugal acceleration process just described, more and more of the energy stored in the field is transferred to the matter, until the inertia of the matter dominates. Magnetic flux surfaces are then forced by the matter inertia to widen further; both the azimuthal and poloidal components of the field decrease due to matter acceleration for the one, and magnetic flux conservation for the other, but the ratio of Bθ /Bz increases. The process halts when the rotational inertia becomes negligible, and magnetic tension due to the azimuthal field is dynamically significant, and the jet recollimates (see next section for more details). Let us specify a bit more some of the aspects of the picture described above. Theorists who wish to construct steady-state solutions meet with three difficulties: i/ one needs some specification for the turbulent transport coefficients; ii/ the full disk/jet resultant problem is non-ideal in the disk, and ideal in the jet; iii/ the jet equations possess three critical surfaces associated to the Alfvenic, the slow and the fast magnetosonic waves, where regularity conditions need to be imposed for the looked-for steady-state solution to cross smoothly through these critical surfaces (see Fig. 3.16). Because of this, a vast majority of papers does not consider the coupled
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
67
problem: either the disk is treated, or the jet. Notable exceptions are provided in the work of Sauty and coworkers, Ferreira and co-workers. Analyses concentrating on the jet dynamics directly assume ideal MHD, and treat the disk as a boundary condition. Even with these simplifying assumptions, only self-similar solutions have been amenable to a semi-analytic treatment (see next section for a more detailed discussion of jet models). Here, only the principal results directly connected to the disk-jet interaction are reported ([21, 28, 60] and references therein). For simplicity, the disk is assumed to be cold, i.e. radiatively efficient; most of the literature is related to thin and cold disks in any case. In such disks, because all forces are small compared to the central body gravitational attraction (a point still debated out of the disk midplane), the rotation velocity Ω(r, z) is close to keplerian (Ω2K ∝ (r2 + z 2 )−3/2 ). It is useful to define a local vertical scale height h such that PT = ρΩ2K h2 at the disk midplane, where PT is the total (gaseous and magnetic) pressure. Cold disks are thin, as measured by ≡ h(r)/r, believed to be of the order of 10−2 to 10−1, from the available evidence in YSOs. The steady state equations used in disk-jet modelling are presented in Appendix 3.B. Writing u = Ωreφ + up , the toroidal component of the momentum equation yields an equation for angular momentum conservation
rBθ dΩ Bp − 2πρνv r2 ∇. ρΩr2 up − (3.2) er = 0, µo dr where νv is the turbulent viscosity used in the modelling of the turbulent Reynolds stress tensor. In the plane of the disk, the first term is the advection of angular momentum due to the radial motion, the second is the Maxwell stress term, which describes the extraction of angular momentum from the disk by the magnetic structure of the jet, and the last one is the turbulent transport of angular momentum (directed outwards for most known processes [9]). Let us define Λ = |jet torque|/|turbulent torque|, which measures the ratio of the last two terms. Defining a turbulent magp netic Reynolds number16 Rm = rup /νm , Eq. (3.2) implies p νm . (3.3) 1 + Λ ∼ Rm νv p /νv ∼ 1 is expected, it turns out that disks dominated by the As νm turbulent torque (Λ 1) require Rm ∼ 1 to launch a jet, with a large 16 The
p
t , α quantities νm , νm m and αSS are introduced in Appendix 3.B.
September 30, 2009
68
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
t p turbulent resistivity anisotropy (νm /νm ∼ 1/α2SS −1 ). Such an anisotropy seems unrealistic to achieve; furthermore, the resulting jets are rather weak. As a consequence, this option is not favored. On the contrary, in disks dominated by the Maxwell stress, Rm ∼ Λ ∼ −1 is required for jet launching, t p with a reduced implied anisotropy, νm /νm ∼ 1/α2SS , which nevertheless requires αSS 1 to be realistic, a rather stringent constraint. Note that a large efficiency of the magnetic torque is in any case expected on general grounds (see Sec. 3.B.2), although “disk people” often assume the contrary. The turbulent resistivity in this case implies a significant bending of the magnetic surfaces towards the disk plane, at the disk surface. Correlatively, the magnetic field tends to compress the disk. Turning to the vertical component of the momentum equation, one finds, in the thin disk approximation, to leading order in
up .∇uz −Ω2K z +
1 ∂P 1 ∂Br2 + Bθ2 − . 2µo ρ ∂z ρ ∂z
(3.4)
This shows that the gas pressure gradient is the only force responsible for deflecting matter from the accretion flow into an upward motion. Consequently, the heating of the disk surface controls in an large way the efficiency of the ejection. For cold disk surfaces, the ratio of the accreted to ejected mass is limited to 1%, while it can represent a significant fraction of unity otherwise. It must be noted that ejection is possible from a disk only when a rough equipartition between the gaseous and magnetic energy holds at the disk midplane (β ∼ 1 at z = 0), and requires large values of the “magnetic Shakura-Sunyaev parameter” (αm 0.3). Although generally speaking αSS < αm , this last contraint is rather stringent. All this also shows that the vertical structure of the disk needs to be realistically represented, to obtain relevant constraints on the ejection; this is true even if one relaxes the stationarity assumption made here. This point is largely underestimated in the literature. Overall, the constraints to produce ejection from a disk are rather tight, a point which is sometimes taken against a disk origin for astrophysical jets. Finally, the disk-jet interaction also constrains the way the global poloidal current is closed. It has already been pointed out that the disk carries an outward radial current (it also carries an azimuthal current, obviously, but this is of no concern here). There are two possible ways to close the electric circuit. Either the vertical current flows into the disk, and the return current flows outside the disk-jet structure (in this case, the radial current increases outwards in the disk), or
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
69
the vertical current flows out from the disk, and return current flows close to the jet axis (in this case, the radial current decreases outwards in the disk; this configuration is represented on Fig. 3.3). Ejection is possible in both cases, but in the first case, the jets are not able to cross the Alfv´enic critical surface, so that the second configuration is favored. It is also more favorable from the point of view of jet collimation (see next section).
3.4
MHD jet structure
Having discussed jet origin, let us now turn to jet structure. For simplicity, only non-relativistic MHD will be used in this section and in the next one. Concerning YSOs, jet poloidal velocities are well below the velocity of light. The situation is less clear for toroidal velocities, if the jet widens a lot. It is usually assumed that relevant rotation velocities (i.e., for magnetic surfaces carrying most of the jet flow) are also subrelativistic (but see [23] for a different opinion). The situation is a more complex in AGNs. However, it has been argued in Sec. 3.2.3 that nonrelativistic jet models may exhibit a significant part of the relevant physics. In any case, understanding their properties is a necessary first step towards an understanding of relativistic MHD jet models. An extension of the description made here to a relativistic context can be found, e.g., in Ref. [5]. The equations of jet dynamics are reduced in Appendix 3.B.2 to a set of invariants on magnetic surfaces, and to the Bernoulli and generalized Grad-Shafranov equation. The invariants are χ(a), which follows from the continuity equation and measures the mass flux (as it is issued from the continuity equation), Ω∗ (a), which can be interpreted as the magnetic field line angular velocity, l(a), the total specific angular momentum, and K(a), the coefficient in the polytropic equation of state. In these equations, only the Alfv´enic point explicitly appears as a critical point (through the poloidal Alfv´enic Mach number m) in the generalized Grad-Shafranov equation, but the other two critical points are hidden in the fact that E(a) (Bernoulli’s integral) must be positive for ejection to occur. The three critical points appear explicitly in the important case of self-similar solutions. As a matter of fact, the only known solutions to these equations are self-similar. Nearly all such solutions assume that z/r is the self-similar variable, so that a flow quantity X ∝ rαX fX (z/r). A notable exception is the work of Sauty, Tsinganos and co-workers who assume a separation of variables of the form X = fX (r)gX (θ) in spherical coordinates r, θ, φ (see
September 30, 2009
70
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
[67] and references therein). An important limitation of the self-similar approach is that neither the jet axis, nor the radial outer jet boundary, are accounted for. As such, self-similar jet solutions solely rely on the specification of boundary conditions at the jet base. Only in the case of disk-driven jets are some of these boundary conditions constrained, but with still a certain degree of arbitrariness. This explains both why these jets are so much studied, and why there exists such a wide range of solutions in the literature. The most constrained ones are those in which the disk-jet coupling is explicitly taken into account in a full solution, as discussed in the previous section. Note also that most solutions cross only one critical surface (the Alfv´enic one), as they are started beyond the slow magnetosonic surface, and no regularity condition is imposed on the fast one. Here again, notable exceptions are the work of Sauty, Tsinganos and co-workers on the one hand, and Ferreira and co-workers on the other, which cross all three critical surfaces.
3.4.1
Jet launching and magnetic surface opening
An often quoted constraint on the magnetic surface opening needed to launch a jet has been derived by Blandford and Payne for cold jets [52]. It follows from the following consideration. With the help of Eq. (3.26), Eq. (3.27) can be rewritten E(a) − Ω∗ (a)l(a) = u2p /2−Ω2 (r2 +z 2 )/2−ΩΩ∗ (r2 +z 2 )+ΩΩ∗ z 2 . Note that the ideal MHD situation applies very close to the disk, and that for z 0, Ω∗ Ω and up 0. Assuming that matter is ejected along a magnetic surface from (r = r0 , z = 0) to (ro + δro , z), a Taylor expansion of the reexpression of Bernoulli’s integral given above yields u2p /2 Ho −H +Ω2o (3δro2 −z 2)/2 > 0, which translates into the condition
1/2 √ 2 Ho − H z < 3 1+ . tan θ = δro 3 Ω2o δro2
(3.5)
Thus, cold jets (H = Ho = 0) require that magnetic surfaces are bent by more than 30◦ with respect to the vertical axis at the disc surface. This limit keeps some relevance when the jet enthalpy is not neglected. Heavy mass injection in jet is hardly possible below it; reversely, efficient ejection requires a bending sufficiently in excess of 30◦ , but not arbitrarily large, other wise the magnetic pressure vertically compresses the disk, which limits the ejection or even totally suppresses it.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
3.4.2
BkFestival2003
71
Current structure, and jet acceleration and collimation
A complete understanding of the dynamics of steady-state jet structures can only be gained from an exact resolutions of the equations presented in Appendix 3.B.2. However, some features can be understood by direct inspection. MHD jets are dominated by the magnetic force. As such, it is useful to look at the expressions of the toroidal and poloidal components of this force. They read Bp ∇ I 2πr Bφ F = − ∇ I 2πr Bφ F⊥ = Bp Jφ − ∇⊥ I 2πr Fφ =
(3.6)
where ∇ = ∇·Bp /Bp , ∇⊥ ≡ (∇a·∇)/|∇a|, and I = 2πrBφ /µo is the total poloidal current flowing inside the magnetic surface. Note that Bφ < 0, as a consequence of the disk rotation and of the outwards radial current in the disk. This shows that when the current results in acceleration of the fluid along the magnetic surface (F > 0), it also results in azimuthal acceleration, i.e., in specific angular momentum increase. The total specific angular momentum invariant, Eq. (3.26) implies in turn that Bφ decreases along a magnetic surface. It turns out, as mentioned earlier that, in selfsimilar solutions at least, the magnetic flux conservation implies that Bp decreases faster, so that Bφ eventually dominates over Bp . Furthermore, ρ decreases very fast along a magnetic surface, because the flow velocity increases along the magnetic surface, and because the surfaces expand. Consequently, the variation of the density in fact dominates over that of Bφ , and the tension of bφ eventually dominates over the rotational inertia in Eq. (3.29). Similarly, past the Alfv´enic critical point, the gravitational potential term becomes negligible, and the transfield equation reduces to
Bφ2 Bp2 B (3.7) −m2 − − ∇⊥ P + ∇⊥ r 0. µo R 2µo µo r The jet recollimates if the curvature of the magnetic surface R < 0. As the gas pressure decreases outwards, this requires that the total (pressure and tension) magnetic force is directed inwards. Equivalently, as F⊥ −(Bφ /2πr)∇⊥ I, |I| must increase outwards (as Bφ < 0, I < 0 by Ampere’s theorem). A general theorem about collimation in the asymp-
September 30, 2009
72
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Fig. 3.3 View of the poloidal current (dashed lines) and magnetic surfaces (solid lines) in a self-similar solution of the coupled disk-jet problem (adapted from [21]).
totic regime (infinite distance from the source) has been demonstrated by Heyvaerts and Norman [68] from the set of steady state equations assembled in Appendix 3.B.2. This theorem states that the collimation of a given surface is asymptotically cylindrical if I = 0, and parabolic if I = 0. In both cases, the curvature term is asymptotically negligible in Eq. (3.7). Note however that as the electric circuit is closed, the parallel current density must change sign in the radial direction. This implies that at a given vertical distance z along the jet, not all magnetic surfaces will be sufficiently collimated, a point (over)emphasized by Okamoto [69]. Note however that one must have j > 0 right above the accretion disk for super-Alfv´enic ejection to occur. Fig 3.3 shows how a disk-driven jet manages all these contraints. The solid lines represent magnetic surfaces, and the dashed line the poloidal current. The return current is carried by the jet core. For a given magnetic surface, a high degree of collimation is eventually reached, far enough from the disk, where the enclosed current I is sufficiently negative. However, at a given altitude z, the inner magnetic surfaces are collimated, while the outer ones are still fairly open, as a consequence of the return current flowing inside the structure, and not outside. If, in a real disk-driven jet, most of the ejection comes from the inner disk regions, as constrained by the observations, this implies that the jet would appear collimated, even though not all magnetic surfaces would be. Two connected issues concerning the jet asymptotic structure are usually not addressed in the type of model discussed here, mostly by lack of
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
73
relevant constraint on the physical conditions prevailing in jets. They are both connected to the existence of turbulence and/or dissipation heating inside the jet, compared to radiation losses. For one thing, the simple polytropic gas law assumed in most jet models implies that the gas pressure becomes asymptotically negligible, as the density drops considerably during the expansion. However, jets are believed to be in rough equipartition (see Sec. 3.2), i.e. β ∼ 1. In fact, if one applies polytropic models to YSOs, where the physics is best constrained, even the minimum heating source known to be present (the ambipolar diffusion) easily leads to equipartition [70], implying that a more realistic energy equation needs to be included in the model for realistic predictions on this issue17 . However, the jet β could remain small if radiation losses are underestimated. One may also ask if jets can relax to a force-free configuration while they propagate. K¨ onigl and Choudhuri [71] have transposed Taylor’s relaxation theory [72, 73] to MHD jets. In fusion devices known as Reversed Field Pinches (RFP), such a relaxation occurs because an m = 1 instability transforms the azimuthal field Bφ in axial one Bz , and turbulent resistive diffusion and reconnection allows for the field reversal to take place and be maintained through a form of non-kinematic turbulent dynamo (see, e.g. [74] chapters 4-5 and references therein). With our present state of knowledge, it is difficult to assess whether any such relaxation mechanism can develop over the time-scale associated to the propagation of the jet, and the subject is not mature enough from an astrophysical point of view for such an attempt to be undertaken. It seems likely that the large velocity gradient due to the propagation in the ambient medium may alter such a mechanism in essential ways. Nevertheless, a relaxed force-free equilibrium is sometimes considered in studies of cold jet stability (see next section). More generally, the jet models adopted for the study of jet stability usually ignore most of the complexities discussed here. For simplicity, a purely cylindrical configuration is generally assumed, with a total current which may or may not be vanishing. However, it is yet unclear how the stability properties of such structures relate to those of the jet models discussed in this section. The question of the origin of the knotty structure observed in AGN and YSO jets is not addressed here. Birkinshaw [75] reviews the possible role of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability as a cause of these structures in AGNs. 17 The effect could be mimicked within the present framework by an isothermal (Γ = 1) model, with substantial heating at the jet base, though.
September 30, 2009
74
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Similarly, the effect of magnetically-driven instabilities in YSOs has been illustrated in the simulation of Todo [76].
3.5
Stability of MHD jets
The question of jet stability was raised as soon as jets were invoked to explain the power supply of extended radio galaxies, and before they were directly observed. Indeed, in their original paper, Blandford and Rees [77] have pointed out that in laboratory experiments, jets do not maintain their coherence over propagation lengths exceeding a few times their diameter, in clear distinction to observed astrophysical jets. As such jets are dominated by their bulk kinetic energy — a feature shared by both HD and MHD jet models — a major source of concern for theorists was to understand how large scale jets could survive the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. It has become clear over the years that purely hydrodynamic jets would be too quickly destroyed by the instability by comparison to observed jets; see, e.g. the simulations of Bodo and co-workers [19, 20]. Conversely, other simulations have shown that a jet can propagate over distances much larger than its radius if it contains a significant azimuthal field, a somewhat unexpected result [78, 79]. As a matter of fact, the catastrophic disruption of purely hydrodynamic jet has been one of the incentives behind the development of MHD jet models, long before the three-dimensional simulations just mentioned could have been performed. In any case, the question of the stability of jets with respect to the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability largely dominates the astrophysical literature on jet stability; it is discussed in Sec. 3.5.2. The progressive construction of MHD jet models has raised other sources of concern relating to the stability of the required magnetic structure when the toroidal field is largely dominant. For example, in the asymptotic confinement and propagation domain of disk-driven jets, the toroidal field (Bφ ) is expected to dominate by a factor of 10 to 100 over the axial (Bz ) one. In the fusion context, such configurations are well-known to be prone to disruptive MHD instabilities. This is often invoked in the astrophysical community as an argument against the viability of magnetically self-confined jet models. Several important points are usually ignored in such statements. For one thing, the current structure is sensibly different in jets and toroidal fusion devices (the current provides its own return current by construction in the latter). Furthermore, the velocity gradient (or more generally, the
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
75
existence of large gradients) between the jet and the ambient medium, which is the cause of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability, may also be a source of stabilization of the MHD instabilities, a feature which has attracted considerable attention in the fusion community in the last decade as a means to generate “transport barriers” and to increase fusion devices stability (see, e.g. [80] and references therein). Also, the assumed role of the kink instability is often oversimplified. Finally, recent simulations indicate that a helical magnetic field helps to stabilize the Kelvin-Helmholtz modes in the nonlinear regime. The question of ideal MHD pressure- and current-driven instabilities in jets has unfortunately not yet attracted a lot of attention in the astrophysical community, because of the rather late developement of MHD jet models, and because of the long focus of the community on the question of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. What is known on this question is discussed in Sec. 3.5.3. Note that in a realistic jet equilibrium configurations, all sources of instability just mentioned may act at once. However, in many of the studies performed so far, they can still be individually identified, and the distinction is kept, as it provides a useful way to organize the literature. Finally, is is legitimate to ask whether the picture of stationary MHD background structure described in the previous section is meaningful. Indeed, the mere presence of knots along AGN and YSO jets as well as the existence of the high energy emission in AGN jets suggest that the structure is at least turbulent, and may be non-stationary in an essential way. Some aspects of this question have partially been addressed in the literature, in the context of disk-driven jets. This is discussed right below. For completeness, it is worth mentioning that the possible role of the magneto-rotational instability, now regarded a major source of turbulence in accretion disks, has recently been investigated in jets [81]. However, it is unlikely that this instability can lead to the jet disruption. The Kelvin-Helmholtz instability of jets has been extensively reviewed by Birkinshaw [75]. Consequently, only the major points will be collected here, as well as the advances performed since this earlier review. On the contrary, the sections on current and pressure-driven instabilities will be a bit more detailed, as this material has not yet been significantly reviewed, and as some aspects of it are not known in the astrophysics community. Note that instabilities could be absolute (i.e., grow at fixed space points) or convective (grow in the jet rest frame), a question which may obviously depend on the nature of the considered instability. Although the latter
September 30, 2009
76
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
option is a priori favored, a temporal approach has generally been adopted in the literature as it is simpler to implement in numerical simulations; the present discussion of linear stability follows this choice for consistency with most of the literature, unless otherwise specified. 3.5.1
Global disk-jet stability and stationarity
The question partially addressed here is twofold: do disk instabilities induce instability of the whole accretion/ejection structure? Are jet structures essentially stationary or intrinsically time-varying? Concerning the first point, it is unlikely that local disk instabilities can endanger the entire structure. For example, the most studied local disk instability (the magneto-rotational instability) leads to local turbulence, and may be the source of the required turbulent transport (see, e.g. [82] and references therein), although, as β ∼ 1 is required in disks for jet launching, the instability would operate close to its threshold. Also, global instabilities do not necessarily lead to disk-jet disruption, either. For example, the well-known Papaloizou and Pringle [83] instability, as all global instabilities, is rather sensitive to boundary conditions [84], and furthermore, its nonlinear development appears to produce large scale spiral waves instead [85]. Wardle and K¨ onigl [86] have argued that jet-driving disks should not be affected by the radial interchange instability of Spruit et al. [87]. It has been argued that wind-driving disks in which the magnetic torque is the dominant source of angular momentum transport may be inherently unstable [62, 64, 65], but this may either result from oversimplifying assumptions concerning the disk vertical structure or apply to structures which are not in the regimes identified in Sec. 3.3 for jet stationary launching to occur [88, 89, 21]. In particular, it must be noted that opening the magnetic surfaces at the disk surface does not necessarily produce an increase in the ejection efficiency, as often assumed in these stability studies. On the contrary, the increased vertical magnetic pressure gradient compresses the disk and results in a reduced ejection efficiency, and prevents runaway. Recently, numerical simulations which incorporate a realistic disk physics have been performed [90, 60], and show that accretion/ejection structures are stable over at least tens of dynamical times, although they may not be strictly stationary. These structures are found for disk effective transport parameters which are less constrained than their stationary self-similar counterpart discussed in Sec. 3.3.3: the time-varying accretion-ejection structures are found for αSS 10−1 and isotropic turbulent resistivity.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
77
These simulations were performed in 2.5D cylndrical geometry, thus excluding the possibility of purely 3D modes of instability. Extension to 3D is therefore required before firm conclusions can be reached on this issue. Other indications that jets may not be stationary also come from simulations in which the disk is not resolved, but treated as a boundary condition, in much the same way as in most jet models. For example, Ouyed and Pudritz [91–93] find a transition from steady ejection to episodic one when the mass loading of the jet, which is imposed as a boundary condition at the jet base, is decreased. However, Anderson et al. [94] reach an opposite conclusion. The difference between the two works is attributed by Anderson et al. to a difference in the treatment of the boundary conditions: the magnetic field is imposed to be vertical at the jet base in the Ouyed and Pudritz simulations, while this constraint is released in Anderson et al. . In any case, the self-similar disk-jet solutions exist only in somewhat restricted mass-loading window [21, 28]. It is likely that non-stationary but long-lived jets exist outside it, but a definite answer on this issue must probably await the implementation of realistic back-reactions of the jet on the disk in numerical simulations, as well as full 3D calculations. 3.5.2
Motion driving: the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability
Because the bulk kinetic energy of a jet in the superfast asymptotic regime (discussed in Sec. 3.4.2) dominates the energy budget of the jet, the KelvinHelmholtz instability is certainly the most obvious source of potential disruption of a jet. The instability occurs when a free velocity shear layer is present in a fluid, stratified or not. An extreme case is represented by the free interface between two fluids moving at different velocities (the two fluids may be identical). The instability is illustrated on Fig. 3.4. A ripple in the velocity shear layer (infinitely thin in this case) creates variations of velocity between peaks an troughs; correlatively (e.g., because of Bernoulli’s integral), such variations translate into pressure variations, and the resulting pressure gradient amplifies the motion. In the most simple situation, all wavelengths are unstable (see Appendix 3.C). Another useful view on this instability stems from Rayleigh’s inflexion point theorem, which states that in a pure shear flow (i.e., without stratification and such), a necessary condition of instability is that the velocity profile contains an inflexion point (see, e.g., [95] p. 131). Such an inflexion point is unavoidable when a free velocity shear layer is formed to match different fluid velocities. Fig. 3.4 provides an extreme example, where the shear layer has zero width (the so-called vortex sheet limit).
September 30, 2009
14:1
78
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
U
+
z
Fig. 3.4
+
yv ar
ia
tio
n
cit
x
-
ve lo
-U
pr es su re va ria tio n
+
Sketch of the mechanism of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability (see text).
The Kelvin-Helmholtz linear stability has been studied for cylindrical jet configurations, by a number of authors (most notably for our purposes here: [96–103]; for a more extensive list of references, see [75]; see also [4] for a more recent but briefer survey of the subject). In this geometry, perturbations of the form exp(iωt−ikz−imφ) are looked for. The geometry as well as the inclusion of a finite thickness of the velocity shear layer, of relativistic motions, of longitudinal, azimuthal or helical field, of density contrast between the jet and the ambient medium, all lead to considerable complexities in the form of the dispersion relation D(ω, k, m) = 0 with respect to the simplest case derived in Appendix 3.C. In all but the simplest cases, this dispersion relation is not analytic, but a systematic method of exploration of the stability domain is presented in Bodo et al. [102]. Because of this complexity, realistic cylindrical equilibrium configurations have rarely been studied, either in the linear or the nonlinear regime. The major features of all these investigations are summarized here. • Because of the geometry, two types of mode exist in MHD jets: ordinary surface modes, with amplitude which decrease steeply with the distance from the jet interface; these are the generalization to cylindrical geometry of the modes found in Appendix 3.C, and they are nodeless in the radial direction. And reflected body modes, which become resonantly unstable in cylindrical, or planar slab geometry, where the mode can reflect off the interface of the jet with the ambient medium. • In unmagnetized jets, the most unstable wavelength is λ ∼ 2πRM , with growth times τ πM × 2R/cs (M = Vj /cs is the sonic Mach number based on the jet velocity Vj ). Ordinary surface modes dominate for M < 2 — 3, and reflected body modes dominate otherwise; reflected modes are completely suppressed in low Mach number jets. When the velocity shear layer has a finite extent δ, wavelengths smaller than ∼ δ are stabilized. Higher density in the jet, as well as larger Mach numbers, result in enhanced stability (as inertia is increased).
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
79
• An azimuthal magnetic field is destabilizing while a longitudinal one is stabilizing. In particular, all modes are stabilized by a longitudinal field in subalfvenic jets (Vj < vA ). • Jet rotation produces a stabilization of ordinary surface modes at all wavelengths at small Mach number, and at small wavelengths at large Mach numbers. • The effects of jet heating and radiative cooling on the development of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability have been studied by various authors [104–106]. Not surprisingly, the radiative losses can either enhance or reduce the instability, depending on the (not well-constrained) cooling functions. The interested reader is referred to these publications for details. The nonlinear evolution of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability has been addressed through 3D numerical simulations in the last ten years, and some significant findings have been made. It has already been noted earlier that purely hydrodynamic jets loose coherence due to this instability once they propagate over a few times their radial extent. The linear Kelvin-Helmholtz unstable modes tend to develop the so-called “cat’s eye” vortices, i.e., the interface ondulations roll over themselves a number of times, to form a vortex aligned with the flow vorticity, before disruption takes place. The linear stability analysis suggests that the inclusion of a longitudinal magnetic field component might significantly change this picture, and this expectation has been confirmed by the numerical simulations of Jones et al. [107] and Jeong et al. [108] at least for small enough fast-Mach numbers. These authors have studied a plane slab geometry (i.e., a configuration analogous to Fig. 3.4, except that the fluid is sheared at two different interfaces), in which a longitudinal magnetic field (along the fluid motion) is added. They have maintained a jet sonic Mach number smaller than unity, and varied the jet Alfvenic Mach number. They found basically four regimes of nonlinear evolution: • When MA 2, the fluid is essentially linearly stable, due to the magnetic tension. • When 2 MA 4, the perturbation produces a nonlinear increase in the magnetic tension which relaminarizes the flow before the cat’s eye Kelvin-Helmholtz rolls briefly described above have time to form. In the process, the velocity shear interface is widened (strong field regime). • For 4 MA 20, a Kelvin-Helmholtz vortex forms. However, at
September 30, 2009
80
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
the same time, the magnetic field is sheared, the magnetic field energy correlatively increased, and magnetic field reversal takes place in the vortex. The subsequent evolution is dominated by the reconnection dynamics of the magnetic field, which disrupts the vortex, but also leads to a nearly complete relaminarization of the flow, with a significantly widened velocity interface, and nearly aligned velocity streamlines and magnetic field lines. This evolution avoids the disruption of the fluid slab (weak field regime). • Finally for large Mach numbers (MA 20), the field plays very little role, except to enhance the dissipation of the Kelvin-Helmholtz vortices. These findings offer the first real window into an understanding of processes through which jets manage to avoid a catastrophic outcome because of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. However, they suffer from a number of drawbacks which need to be addressed in the future before a more complete picture of the problem can be obtained. First, the exact relevance of the temporal approach to the instability adopted in these simulations seems questionable at the light of the fact that jets are supersonic and probably superfast: new material continuously enters and leaves the jet, at speeds which greatly exceed the advection speed of the Kelvin-Helmholtz vortices at the jet interface. Secondly, the structure studied is far from being realistic: in the jet asymptotic regime, the azimuthal field dominates largely over the longitudinal one, and it has been noted that in the linear regime, an azimuthal field has a destabilizing influence. Although the jets outer region may not have reached this asymptotic regime, leading to a possibly more dynamically significant longitudinal field, such regions are not in asymptotic cyclindrical collimation either (see Sec. 3.4). Recent simulations implementing a more realistic structure have been performed [109]. As these simulations involve some interplay between current-driven and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities, their discussion is deferred to the end of Sec. 3.5.3.1. Finally, the fast Mach number plays an important role in the problem. Cat’s eye structures do not develop for fast Mach numbers 2. On the other hand, superfast jets are liable to global and eventually destructive instabilities when the velocity interface has a width comparable to the jet radius (Hubert Baty, private communication). Simulations with non-periodic boundary conditions along the jet are required to draw firmer conclusions on this issue, as periodicity implements a temporal approach
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
81
to the instability, whereas a spatial one would be required, especially for superfast modes of instability. At present, these results suggest that jets reaching the fast magnetosonic critical point become unstable; this may be related, e.g., to the observed large scale braking of AGN jets and the formation of large radio lobes. 3.5.3
Magnetic driving: the current and pressure instabilities
In the asymptotic regime, the transfield equilibrium equation for a given magnetic surface [Eq. (3.7)] reduces to
Bφ2 d P + B 2 /2µo − − 0, (3.8) dr µo r i.e., the jet is approximated as the familiar screw pinch18 of the fusion literature, with two important differences: at a given altitude z, not all magnetic surfaces may be in this asymptotic regime (at least for disk-driven jets) due to the fact that the jet carries its own return current, and that jets are not static columns. If furthermore, one assumes that |Bφ | |Bz |, which is supposed to hold over most of the jet radial extent, the resulting configuration is close to a Z-pinch19 . The stability of these columns has been largely studied in the fusion literature. The relevant background concepts directly useful to this review are recalled in Appendix 3.D. Because of the adopted cylindrical geometry, the displacement with respect to the chosen static equilibrium can be chosen as a Fourier mode as in Sec. 3.5.2: ξ = ξo exp [i(ωt − mφ − kz z)] ,
(3.9)
where ξo is the Fourier transformed displacement vector, whose components ξr (r), ξφ (r), ξz (r) depend on radius only (the displacement and its Fourier transform are no longer distinguished in the rest of the text). Magnetic resonances play an important role in the stability of cylindrical columns. Magnetic resonances are defined by k · B ≡ Bk = 0, and are radially located on surfaces where the wave number k = (m/r)eφ + kez is locally perpendicular to the unperturbed magnetic field. In a sheared 18 A screw pinch is a cylindrical plasma column, with arbitrary magnetic shear s = d ln(rBz /Bφ )/d ln r. 19 A Z-pinch is a cylindrical column where the magnetic field is only azimuthal. Note that with respect to the fusion labelling, the toroidal and poloidal components are exchanged between a screw pinch and a jet, as the symmetry axis is the z-axis in a jet, while it is the axis of the torus in fusion devices.
September 30, 2009
14:1
82
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
magnetic field, where s = d ln(rBz /Bφ )/d ln r = 0, such resonances occur on a given cylindrical magnetic surface, for any given wave-number20. High wave-number pressure-driven unstable modes are localized near the resonance. Usually current-driven unstable modes have a non-zero displacement inside the resonance radius, and a vanishing displacement outside it, but the mode may be broadened if inertial terms are important. Current-driven and pressure-driven instabilities are examined in turn in the next two subsections. 3.5.3.1
Current-driven instabilities
Generally speaking, the fastest growing current-driven instability is the kink (m = 1) mode. This is a global instability, and no general criterion is available. Quite often, a Kruskal-Shafranov type of criterion is used as a simple semi-quantitative guideline (for a derivation of the KruskalShafranov criterion, see ref.[110] pp. 342-343). The basic quantity entering such criteria is the safety factor21 q(r) = rBz (r)/Lbφ (r); L is the length of the column. Equivalently, two quantities relating to the safety factor are used in the literature: the pitch Pi = rBz /Bφ (2πP is the length of a field line circling once around the axis at radius r), and the twist Φ = LBφ /(rBz ), which measures the amount be which a line is twisted over the length L of the column. The Kruskal-Shafranov criterion states that Φ > 2π at the column surface r = a is a condition of instability with respect to the kink (m = 1). This is in fact one example of such limits. For example, in an equilibrium with constant pitch, the limit is close to 4π (see, e.g., [111] pp. 259-264); also, higher order current-driven modes (m > 1) usually have a more stringent safety factor, but smaller growth rates. The Kruskal-Shafranov limit is not dependent on the vertical current density profile jz (this is usually not true for higher order modes), and therefore indicates the existence of a generic and potentially very disruptive instability. Generally speaking, the twist limit varies by a factor of order unity, when varying the equilibrium configuration. This type of criterion can also be understood as giving a minimum wavelength in the z direction, for instability to occur. In a sufficiently long column, such as a jet, this type instability is bound to occur. The mechanism underlying the instability is often discussed in the lit20 Not all wavenumbers may be resonant in a given equilibrium; they can also be multiply resonant. 21 Note also that the magnetic shear is the logarithmic derivative of the safety factor.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
83
Fig. 3.5 Growth-rate of the most unstable current-driven mode, for various equilibrium configurations, as a function of the inverse relative pitch R/Po . In the “astrophysical regime” (R/Po 1), the growth-rate scales like the inverse relative pitch, independently of the details of the current structure. See text for detail. Adapted from [114].
erature (see, e.g., [110] p. 323): as the plasma column is kinked sideways, the azimuthal field Bφ at the column surface is compressed on the concave side of the kinked column, while the contrary is true at the radially opposite convex side, inducing a magnetic pressure gradient which amplifies the kinking motion. Another widely used picture is the analogy with a rubber band that is twisted upon itself; at some point, the increase in elastic tension energy will cause the band to kink and fold on itself. Based on this picture, it is often assumed that an MHD jet will kink and fold on itself, leading to disruption and/or decollimation (e.g. [112, 113]). This possibility has prompted a number of linear numerical analyzes of current-driven instabilities for a variety of simple cylindrical equilibria [115–118, 114]. The most significant findings are those of Appl et al. [114], and are briefly summarized and discussed here. These authors have discussed the stability of a variety of cold (P = 0) equilibria with respect to both current-driven and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities, for static columns (where the KH instability disappears) or moving jets, in the vortex sheet limit. For cold jets, the equilibrium relation Eq. (3.7) implies that the equilibrium is completely defined once a relation between Bz and Bφ is specified. To this effect, they choose to impose the radial variation of the pitch Pi . They have considered different families of equilibria, with constant or quadratically varying pitch profile. They have also considered a Bessel function model chosen to represent an energetically relaxed, force-free equilibrium. In what follows, Po refers to the value of the pitch on the axis.
September 30, 2009
84
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
At a radius R (identified with the jet radius), the jet is interfaced with an unmagnetized outer medium of constant density and appropriately defined gas pressure to maintain equilibrium. If Po /R is small enough, this external confining pressure is small, and the jet model is essentially magnetically self-confined. Furthermore, for r Po , Bφ Bz . Therefore, the first two models share some important features with the self-similar jet structures discussed in Sec. 3.4 when Po /R 1. The last one is studied in case the jet relaxes as it propagates.
Fig. 3.6 Radial displacement of m = −1 mode, for constant (left) and increasing quadratic (right) pitch radial variation, and a relative pitch Po /R = 1/3. Various boundary conditions are used (rigid, or coupling with the appropriate radiating outgoing decaying solution). The mode is already essentially internal in spite of the still substantial relative pitch, and largely independent of the chosen boundary condition. The stabilization of the boundary increases with increasing Alfv´enic Mach number, defined as the jet velocity over the Alfv´en speed evaluated on the jet axis. The radial field perturbation is also shown; it vanishes at the mode resonance, if any. Adapted from [114].
For illustration purposes, the growth-rate of the most unstable currentdriven mode (usually an m = −1 mode; k is assumed positive) is shown on Fig. 3.5 as a function of R/Po , while a typical mode displacement is shown on Fig. 3.6, for the constant and quadratic pitch profiles. The most important results are the following: • For R/Po 1 the growth rate is dependent on the equilibrium and related current structure, while for R/Po 1 — 10, the growth-rate becomes largely independent of the equilibrium (except for the relaxed Bessel function model, which corresponds to an energy minimum at given magnetic helicity, and therefore has particular favorable stability properties).
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
85
• The growth-rate is ∝ vA /Po for large enough R/Po (vA is the Alfv´en speed on the axis). It is substantially larger in these configurations compared to the equilibria which are usually considered in fusion, where instead R/Po 1 is rather chosen, precisely for this reason. It is comparable to the Kelvin-Helholtz growth-rate for these configurations (except for the relaxed model). This question has also been reinvestigated by Baty [119], who finds that the current-driven instability growth-rate dominates over the Kelvin-Helmholtz one for R/Po 10, for a variety of equilibria. • The mode is internal, independently of the assumed boundary condition. This is related to the fact that the parallel current peaks around r ∼ Po when Po /R is small. • The velocity gradient present at the jet surface due to the jet global motion with respect to the ambient medium has a stabilizing effect on the jet boundary. This feature reinforces the internal character of the modes with increasing Alf´enic Mach number MA = V /vA , where V and vA are evaluated on the jet axis. For MA 3 – 4, the boundary effectively becomes rigid. The internal character of the modes of instability is the major reason why jets, although not stable with respect to current instabilities, are not expected to disrupt. This expectation is borne out in the nonlinear evolution of these instabilities, as computed by Lery et al. [120]. These authors have followed some of the unstable equilibria discussed above in the nonlinear stabilization phase. They confined themselves to static equilibria, to focus on pure current-driven instabilities, and with the idea that the jet superalfv´enic motion is stabilizing, as discussed above. They did indeed find that the jet does not disrupt, but reorganizes itself internally. This reorganization leads to the development of some internal helical structure, with a prominent, confined helical current sheet for equilibria having a radially increasing pitch. The time-scale of the process is consistent with the results of the linear analysis. Internal reorganization is also observed for relaxing unstable equilibria; magnetic reconnection plays an important role in the process, as it allows a kink unstable magnetic flux tube buckling on itself to change its structure to a more stable state. However, the process of relaxation, if present, could not be followed in these simulations. The obtained results are consistent with earlier simulations of the kink instability which were performed to understand if the kink instability could account for the knot structure observed in YSO jets [76].
September 30, 2009
14:1
86
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Baty and Keppens [109] have considered the stability of cylindrical moving jets, with an increasing pitch profile and a constant axial field (the velocity shear is confined to a small layer at the jet interface), which are liable to both Kelvin-Helmholtz and current-driven instabilities. They found that in the “weak” longitudinal field regime discussed in Sec. 3.5.2, the development of a current-driven instability in the jet core, as discussed above, leads to the interaction of the resulting azimuthal field distribution and the K-H nonlinear vortices, which helps to saturate the latter, leading to reduced disruption effects. Increased Mach number, as well as allowing for vortex coalescence, further contributes to this mechanism. These results are still preliminary, and only a few equilibrium structures have been tested, but this certainly constitutes an important step towards an understanding of the processes which allow jets to avoid disruption for astrophysically relevant magnetic structures. 3.5.3.2
Pressure-driven instabilities
Because jets are believed to be close to equipartition between the gaseous and magnetic energy, and because the azimuthal field is believed to dominate over the axial one, it would appear that, in fact, pressure-driven instabilities can be potentially much more critical from the point of view of jet disruption than the previously discussed current-driven ones. This point has unfortunately largely gone unnoticed in the astrophysical community, where only few papers have been devoted to this question, most notably Begelmann [121]. Here again, the analysis of the stability properties of cylindrical columns (or pinches) performed in the fusion context provides useful guidelines. From the Energy Principle and Eq. (3.44), it appears that the pressure term is destabilizing when the pressure gradient and the field line curvature are directed in the same half-space. More precisely, for cylindrical static equilibria, they are aligned, and a necessary condition of instability is Kc Kρ > 0,
(3.10)
where Kc ≡ |e · ∇e | = (Bφ /B) /r is the field line curvature, and Kρ ≡ −d ln ρ/dr is the density length scale, directly related to the pressure lengthscale by the assumed polytropic equation of state. Eq. (3.44) also implies that, in order of magnitude, the contribution of the pressure term to ω 2 is ∼ −c2s Kc Kρ (cs is the sound speed). In the absence of magnetic shear, and in an infinite cylinder, one can always find modes that will be destabilized. One can partially understand 2
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
87
this result by considering the dispersion relation of Alfv´en and slow magnetosonic waves in an homogeneous medium in the quasi-perpendicular 2 2 2 propagation limit, ω 2 = vA k and ω 2 = c2s k2 /(c2s + vA ), where k is the component of the total wavenumber along the unperturbed magnetic field. This suggests that instability will set in in inhomogeneous media, for small enough parallel wavenumbers, when this stabilizing contribution to the dispersion relation becomes smaller than the destabilizing effect due to the plasma pressure and field line curvature ∼ −c2s Kc Kρ . The magnetic shear s = −d ln Pi /d ln r (Pi = rBz /Bφ is the pitch) has an important effect on this simple picture. When the magnetic field is sheared, unstable modes are confined to the vicinity of magnetic resonances, where k = 0, as the shear makes k2 increase with radial distance to the resonance. Furthermore, a large enough magnetic shear can stabilize radially localized modes. Indeed, Suydam’s criterion states that the magnetic shear stabilizes the plasma if Bz2 2 dP s + > 0. 8µo r dr
(3.11)
This criterion is a necessary condition of instability for all modes (see e.g. [110] section 9.4 for a derivation). It is a necessary and sufficient condition of stability for high wavenumber modes [122, 123]. Two other criteria have been derived by Kadomtsev for the stability of the Z-pinch (see [110] section 9.3 for a demonstration). They read 1 d ln |Bφ | < m2 − 1, d ln r 2
(3.12)
γβ/2 − 1 d ln |Bφ | < , d ln r γβ/2 + 1
(3.13)
for m = 0 modes, and
for the m = 0 mode; β = 2µo P/B 2 as usual. Both criteria are difficult to meet in practice. The physics of this type of instability is rather involved, and its physical origin difficult to grasp. For a Z-pinch in the large wavelength, quasiperpendicular limit, perturbations are pressureless (δP∗ = 0), and the origin of both the destabilizing term and stabilizing one is to be found in the variation of the magnetic tension. For example, in a flux tube exchange, as one would operate in a typical interchange reasoning, a direct computation of the magnetic tension variation for the m = 0 mode shows that the destabilizing term must not exceed the contribution of the plasma compression
September 30, 2009
88
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
for the plasma to be stable with respect to this type of disturbance. Once the equilibrium relation is used, Eq. (3.13) is recovered. One would think at first glance that Kadomtsev criteria should provide guidelines to understand the stability behavior of cylindrical equilibria in which the toroidal field dominates over the axial one, as in jets. In fact, this is not quite true, as pointed out by Begelman [121]. As this result is directly relevant to the present discussion, but has only been derived in the relativistic framework in the published literature, an alternative derivation based on material more familiar in the fusion context is outlined in Appendix 3.E. Eqs. (3.55) and (3.56) imply that low m modes can always be made unstable once Eq. (3.10) is satisfied, by choosing the resonant k for m = 0, and for an appropriate range of k for m = 0. This is at variance with Kadomtsev criteria: even a negligibly small Bz lifts the degeneracy which imposed a special treatment of the m = 0 mode; as a consequence, this mode cannot be made stable by compressibility effects as in Z-pinches, even if |Bφ | |Bz |. The most unstable wavenumbers are always close to k2 γβKc Kρ /4, in which case the growth rates are always ∼ γβKc Kρ /4 ∼ 2 /R2 for β ∼ 1. These are very large growth-rates, pertaining to large vA scale modes, thus making the question of stabilization of the pressure-driven modes in MHD jets rather acute. The most obvious question to ask in this context is the role of the axial flow of the jet on the stability properties of pressure-driven modes. This problem has not yet been investigated in the astrophysics literature, but some of its important aspects have been addressed in the fusion literature, and are briefly discussed here, as they are directly relevant to the question of jet stability. In all the investigations cited below, the adopted velocity profile contains no inflexion point, in order to avoid triggering the KelvinHelmhotz instability (see Sec. 3.5.2). Bondeson et al. [124] have generalized Suydam’s analysis to a sheared flow. They provide the appropriate generalization of the linearized momentum equation Eq. (3.37), which is not reproduced here, as it is rather complex and not needed for the purpose of this simplified discussion. Focusing attention on axial flows (v = vz (r)er ), their analysis shows that the behavior of localized modes depends on the magnitude of M ≡ ρ1/2
vz , Pi Bz /Pi
(3.14)
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
89
where the prime denotes radial derivative, and Pi is the pitch introduced for the discussion of current-driven instabilities. This quantity is a form of Alfv´enic Mach number based on the velocity and magnetic shear. When M 2 < β, the flow shear destabilizes Suydam modes (i.e., modes such that k · B = 0). Above this limit, Suydam modes are stable, but in this case, unstable modes exist at the edge of the slow continuum, and may be global. The authors found however that the growth rates are small (comparable to resistive instabilities growth rates). Note also that, as Pi /Pi ∼ 1/r, M ∼ (Bφ /Bz )(r/d)(vz /vA ) 1 in MHD jets (d is the width of the velocity layer). These results seem to suggest that the velocity shear layer at the jet boundary is substantially linearly stabilized in MHD jets. This seems to be confirmed by global linear stability analyzes. Shumlak and Hartman [125] and Arber and Howell [126] have examined the stability analysis of a variety of equilibria in a pure Z-pinch (Bz = 0), with a smooth axial velocity profile (similar analyzes of the ballooning mode stabilization have also been performed; see, e.g. [127–129] and references therein). The m = 1 mode is stabilized for modest velocity shear in equilibria for which the m = 0 mode is marginally stable in the static limit. This is not the case in more general equilibria (even though the m = 0 mode is apparently easily stabilized by the velocity shear), but in all cases, increasing the flow Mach number produces a vanishing displacement of the unstable modes at the plasma boundary. An sheared azimuthal velocity also tends to stabilize the kink mode [130]. Nonlinear stabilization of pressure-driven modes has been studied by Hassam [131] and DeSouza-Machado et al. [132]. Hassam exploits an analogy between the m = 0 pressure-driven interchange mode and the Rayleigh-Taylor instability in an appropriately chosen magnetized plasma configuration: the magnetic field is perpendicular both to the velocity and the direction of the density gradient responsible for the instability. From this analysis, he concludes that the m = 0 pressure-driven mode is nonlinearly stabilized by a smooth velocity shear (dVz /dr ∼ V /R) if Ms = Vz /cs [ln(τd /τg )]1/2 , where τg is the instability growth time-scale (τg ∼ cs (Kρ Kc )1/2 ) and τd the diffusion time-scale (τd ∼ νKρ Kc where ν is the viscosity, assumed comparable to the resistivity). The nonlinear evolution of an unstable, slightly viscous and resistive Z-pinch, was simulated by DeSouza-Machado et al. [132]. They found that the plasma relaminarizes over almost all its volume for applied velocity shears that are in good agreement with this analytic estimate. The core of the plasma
September 30, 2009
90
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
still has some residual unstable “wobble”, which can apparently be stabilized if by the magnetic shear if some longitudinal field Bz is added to the configuration. This nonlinear stabilization mechanism of Hassam [131] apparently hinges on the existence of a small, but nonvanishing dissipation. Even assuming that the effective Reynolds number22 R = τd /τg ∼ 1030 , one finds [ln R]1/2 ∼ 8. The resulting Mach number is within what can be reasonably expected for astrophysical jets. On the other hand, the extent to which the result of Hassam [131] depends on the form of the nonlinearity involved in the solution, and is applicable to pressure-driven instabilities, is unclear. Consequently, the relevance of this result to the simulation of DeSouza-Machado [132] remains to be ascertained. 3.6
Summary and open issues
In guise of conclusions, I would like to stress here a few points which I believe to be now well-established, although some of them may not yet be widely recognized, and to point out some of their consequences in terms of open problems. This list may reflect my own interests in the problem, though. It appears that, with respect to all the issues addressed here (jet production, collimation, acceleration and stability), MHD as opposed to HD is an unavoidable framework. It seems that all the elements are now gathered to begin understanding the ability of jets to avoid disruption, and the presence of a magnetic field in the jet seems an essential factor in this problem. On the other hand, it may also turn out that some of the stability problems discussed in these notes may eventually become irrelevant, because of the very crude assumptions made on the badly known jet structure, and on its interface with the ambient medium. Of particular importance is the question of the true current distribution, and its connection to the jet structure, a problem somewhat ignored in the literature. In any case, although the necessary ingredients allowing the jet to avoid disruption seem to have been identified, it is fair to say that the global physics of the problem is not yet understood. Developing such an understanding is certainly an important issue. 22 This estimate comes from the assumption that in AGN jets, plasma microturbulence provides a minimum diffusion, which involves velocities of the order of a fraction of the Alfv´ en velocity, and typical sizes comparable to the ions Larmor radii which are of the order of 10−15 times the jet radius. In YSO jets, the effective diffusion, collisional or other, is expected to be much larger and the constraint on the Mach number weaker.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
91
In what concerns AGN jets, the issue of the confinement of relativistic jets (discussed in Sec. 3.2.3) has apparently not yet reached a wide audience in the astrophysics community. Nevertheless, this problem seems to make two-components models, such as the one briefly alluded to in Sec. 3.4.2, an almost unavoidable construct to explain both jet collimation and the high energy emission of AGNs. On a related front, the question of the light cylinder needs to be further clarified. The various options through which a jet may be launched seem to be more or less known by now. However, none of the scenarios discussed in Sec. 3.3 is understood in full detail yet. Also, the Blandford-Znajek mechanism may require some modification at the light of the confinement problem just recalled. The disk-central object scenarios are still in their infancy. Even the best understood launching mechanism (disk-driving) suffers from a number of weak points. Indeed, although a significant number of studies of disk-driven jet structure have been performed, all of them are formulated in a self-similar framework, and most of them treat the disk as a boundary condition. However, it appears that a careful treatment of the disk-jet coupling is required to get realistic jet ejection efficiencies, and realistic stability properties of the disk-jet structure. Furthermore, it appears that stationary accretion-ejection structures require rather contrived parameters to exist: extremely efficient turbulent transport in the disk, anisotropy in this transport, and near equipartition between gas and magnetic pressure. The evidence from numerical simulations is that non-stationary accretionejection structures do most probably exist, and appear to be long-lived at least on the time-scales accessible to numerical computation, i.e., up to several tens of dynamical time-scales. This certainly questions the true relevance of stationary structures in spite of their obvious usefulness to define parameter regimes in which accretion-ejection structures can be found in numerical simulations, especially that observed jets do not appear to be stationary. This last point is also related to the question of the observed jet variability. Quite obviously, such a variability can either be the result of an instability in the jet23 , or of a variability at the jet source. Both options have been explored in the literature. However, the recent developments reported here on the nonlinear behavior of the most important dynamical instabilities probably calls for a reexamination of this issue. 23 In
this respect, there are instabilities which have not been discussed in these notes, in particular in relation to radiation processes rather than dynamical ones, such as the well-known filamentary instability; see, e.g. [4] pp. 568-569, and references therein.
September 30, 2009
14:1
92
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Appendices 3.A
A brief compendium of relevant astrophysical facts
A few properties of stars, galaxies, AGNs, and astrophysical magnetic fields, are briefly summarized here. More details can be found in any lecture book on general astrophysics.
3.A.1
Mostly AGNs
Galaxies are ensembles of ∼ 1011−12 stars, with a varying amount of mass in gaseous form (from basically none for ellipticals to about 10% for spirals), and of sizes ∼ 10 kpc. Typical intergalactic distances are the order of a few megaparsecs (Mpc) in clusters of galaxies. Most galaxies are grouped in such clusters, of a few tens to a few hundreds of galaxies. The gas observed in spirals is clumpy, with a hierarchy of structures at almost every possible scale from the galactic one down to a parsec or smaller, the smallest structures usually being the densest and coldest ones (except star forming cores). Present day star formation proceeds from the gravitational collapse of a parsec scale (or less), cold, magnetized, cloud core of interstellar matter of a few tens of solar masses at most, a solar mass or so being the typical value. Newly forming or formed stars are grouped under the general denomination of Young Stellar Objects (YSOs). It is now known that accretion disks and outflows are always present in the early stages of star formation. Only a small fraction of galaxies, of the order of a few percents, contain extremely active central regions, baptized “Active Galactic Nuclei” (AGNs in short). These regions are extremely compact, as indicated by the very short time-scales of variability of the radiation output observed in a number of cases, but nevertheless produce a power exceeding by a factor of ∼ 103 the output of a whole normal galaxy. The most active have a power output ∼ 1046 erg/s, i.e., several solar masses per year, assuming all the mass is converted into energy. The activity of these galaxies signals itself in two different forms: radiation from the region surrounding the nucleus, and, when present, large scale jets. The radiation output is reprocessed many times, to larger and larger scales, and correlatively larger and larger wavelengths. This emission comes out in wide variety of spectral form, intensity, variability etc, which has led to a fairly complex classification of these object. Understanding the relation between these various objects,
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
93
and possibly uniting them in a single framework, is a major open problem in this field. Jets were initially mostly observed in the radio wavelengths; their progenitors were divided into extended or compact radio sources, depending on whether their radio emission was produced within one kiloparsec from the nucleus. It is now apparent that both types are different aspects of the same underlying phenomenon. Extended radio sources are also subdivided into FR1 and FR2 objects (after Faranoff and Riley), with the first ones being the most energetic. Apparent super-luminal motions are often observed in compact sources. This proper motion is interpreted as a special relativistic effect: i/ relativistically moving sources emit in a small cone in the forward direction, and can consequently only be observed if the jet is nearly aligned with the observer; ii/ for such small subtended angles, the relativistic Doppler effect results in an apparent super-luminal motion on the velocity component projected on the sky plane. Most compact radio sources are associated with quasars, and the remainder with a nearby class of objects, known as BL Lac. A new category of objects, named blazars, has been more recently defined, based on their high variability. They include BL Lac and the most variable quasars. Their properties are thought to emerge when the emission of the jet dominates the emission from the central object. Most AGNs have a rather extended spectrum. For example, the blazar spectrum can extend up to TeV energies in some cases. The list of observational characteristics of these objects can become fairly involved, although they are largely correlated in a given class. It is believed that at least some, perhaps most, of this classification arises from orientation effect of the source with respect to the observer. A simplified diagram is presented in Fig. 3.17. For more details see, e.g., references [133, 134] and references therein. 3.A.2
Origin of magnetic fields
The key role played by magnetic fields in various aspects of astrophysical phenomena has only relatively recently been recognized by the astrophysical community, through a slow evolution which took place over the last two or three decades. For the problem at hand, MHD phenomena are unescapable in the formation, acceleration, and confinement of jets, as well as on some essential aspects of disk physics. As magnetic fields are not believed to be primordially present in the Universe, one is faced with the task of explaining their origin.
September 30, 2009
14:1
94
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Fields are most probably not generated in the early Universe with their presently observed magnitude, as they would strongly affect the now well established mechanisms of structure formation24 . Therefore, they are thought to arise as rather weak seed fields, which are subsequently amplified after structure formation has started, either through elementary mechanisms of flux concentration and/or streamline shearing, or through dynamo processes (see e.g. [135] for a recent review). At present two categories of mechanisms have been proposed: either quantum field processes taking place during inflation or phase transitions in the primordial Universe; and charge separation effects (battery effects) in the “late” Universe. The first ones have extremely varying and usually extremely weak efficiencies, from 10−65 to 10−9 G, and they are all compatible with the probably very conservative upper bound of ∼ 10−8 G recently deduced from the analysis of the CMB fluctuations [136]. In any case, a nanogauss upper limit is required at the recombination epoch if one does not want to affect our present understanding of large scale structure formation. The late Universe mechanisms usually produce amplitudes ∼ 10−20 G, to the notable exception of the most recently proposed one [137], which reaches magnitudes of ∼ 10−5 G from anisotropic and inhomogeneous radiation pressure effects at the epoch of reionization of the Universe25. This process seems to provide magnetic fields with the right coherence scale and at the right magnitude for astrophysical purposes. 3.A.3
On the MHD approximation in astrophysics
Discussing in detail the validity of the MHD approximation in astrophysics in general, or even only in disks and jets, would take us too far afield. I will only briefly discuss the various MHD approximations, i.e., electro-neutrality, the one fluid approximation, and Ohm’s law, in 24 For a cosmologist, structures are everything from the largest structures observed in the Universe, such as low density contrast “walls” made of galaxies, down to clusters of galaxies and galaxies themselves. They are explained through the gravitational collapse of small primordial inhomogeneities in the matter and radiation of the Universe. These inhomogeneities are themselves directly observed in the temperature fluctuations of the cosmic microwave background (CMB), and thought to originate from quantum fluctuations in the primordial inflationary Universe. 25 It is now well established that the Universe, which was fully ionized in its first few 105 yrs of existence after the quark-baryon phase transition and until the recombination which produced the CMB, has been reionized by the radiation emitted by the first generations of objects formed, without recombination since then due to the decreasing density implied by the cosmic expansion.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
95
the context of astrophysical media. For more extensive discussions of the MHD approximation, see, e.g., [138] pp. 290-294, or [139] pp. 92-95. For an introduction to MHD with astrophysical applications in mind, see Ref. [138, 111]. Generally speaking, any relevant astrophysical scale L is always gigantic compared to the Debye length λD of the fluid, which is typically (way) smaller than centimeter scales, so that the local quasi-neutrality assumption is always satisfied to a high degree of precision in nonrelativistic plasmas. Relatedly, the plasma parameter (1/ne λ3D ) is small (although orders of magnitude larger than λD /L). Furthermore, astrophysical plasmas are often characterized by values of β ∼ 1 within an order of magnitude or so, so that all relevant velocities, except drift velocities, are of the order of the Alfv´en velocity vA = Bo2 /(µo mi no ). Requiring that dynamical time-scales exceed −1 = mi /eBo of cyclotron motions of the ions (usually the the time-scale ωci most directly relevant one capable of distinguishing ion and electron motions) is equivalent to requiring that astrophysical scales L > ro = vA /ωci , where ro is of the order of the Larmor radius of the ions. Correlatively, the drift velocity |ue − ui | ∼ Jo /(no e) ∼ Bo /(µo Lno e) ∼ vA ro /L. In general, again because astrophysical scales are so huge, L ro , and the one fluid approximation is well-satisfied. Similarly, for typical dynamical time-scales T ∼ L/vA , ωci T ∼ L/ro (vA L/T )2 ∼ 1, and ωci T ∼ L/ro (cs L/T )2 ∼ 1, where cs is the sound speed; this implies that the Hall term and the electronic pressure term are negligible in the generalized Ohm’s law, which reduces to E + v × B = ηJ. Mean free paths are usually significantly larger than the ion Larmor radius, but nevertheless typically still many orders of magnitude smaller than relevant dynamical scales, so that magnetic Reynolds numbers are enormous, and that perfect MHD holds to a very good approximation as well. Nevertheless, the effect of small scale turbulence on larger scales is often modelled in terms of turbulent viscosities and resistivities in astrophysics, so that an effective, possibly anisotropic resistivity is retained, e.g., in the description of disk dynamics, with all the caveats involved with this type of approximations. Jet instabilities usually have growth rates which can be significantly shorter than the collision time-scale, making them effectively collisionless. No step has been taken yet, though, to take this point into account. Note that some non-thermal high energy populations are known to exist in a number of instances, in particular to explain the AGN high energy emission. This population is thought to be accelerated by shock waves or turbulent motions through Fermi-type mechanisms. In this case, the
September 30, 2009
14:1
96
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Larmor radii of these particles become comparable to the size of the accelerating region. Also, not all astrophysical plasmas are ionized enough to allow good coupling between charged particles and neutrals, leading to the breakdown of the one-fluid approximation, or implying that, e.g., the ambipolar resistivity and/or Hall term can no longer be neglected in the analysis of some types of fluid instabilities. This is in particular the case in some regions of YSO disks, the so-called dead-zone. 3.B
MHD axisymmetric steady-state equations
For definiteness, and reference in the main text, the basic form of the equations most commonly used in the analysis of steady-state accretion-ejection structures are compiled here. Axisymmetry is assumed in the (r, φ, z) coordinate system. Because of this symmetry, poloidal field components (up , Bp , Jp ) belong to the (r, z) plane, while the toroidal (uφ = rΩ(r, z), Bφ , Jφ ) component is identical to the azimuthal one26 . Instead of the poloidal magnetic field component, it is convenient to make use of the flux function a(r, z), defined such that 1 ∇a × eφ , r which characterizes a surface of constant magnetic flux: Φ= B · dS = 2πa(r, z). Bp =
(3.15)
(3.16)
S
The variables of the problem are the density ρ, the pressure P , the velocity u, the magnetic field B (the temperature may be included too, but quite often, a polytropic equation of state is assumed, due to our poor knowledge of the heating and cooling properties of disks and jets). A turbulent viscosity and resistivity modelling is assumed, and a separation of mean and fluctuating quantities is implicitly performed in all published studies of disks and disk/jet global dynamics. 3.B.1
General form
The continuity equation reduces to, without surprise ∇ · ρu = 0.
(3.17)
26 If one views a jet as a form of straight fusion device, note that the convention on poloidal and toroidal components just described differs from the one used in fusion.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
97
The momentum equation writes ρu · ∇u = −∇P − ρ∇ΦG + J × B + ∇ · T
(3.18)
where Tij = ρδui δuj is the turbulent Reynolds stress tensor (the turbulent contribution to the Maxwell stress is usually included as well in the definition of T). In general, only the Trφ component of this tensor (responsible for the radial turbulent transport) is kept. The turbulent viscosity prescription amounts to assume that Trφ νv ρrdΩ/dr with νv = αss cs h, where cs is the sound speed and h the local disk scale-height; αss is a parameter introduced by Shakura and Sunyaev [140] to account for the effect of the unspecified mechanisms producing the transport27 . Depending on the considered systems, the value of αSS varies between 10−3 and 1. The next equation is the induction equation. Because of the assumed axisymmetry, the toroidal component of the electric field vanishes (Eφ = 0). The poloidal component of the induction equation (or equivalently, the toroidal component of Ohm’s law) reduces to p νm Jφ = up × Bp ,
(3.19)
p is the poloidal turbulent resistivity. Similarly, the toroidal comwhere νm ponent of the induction equation reads t
νm 1 ∇· = ∇ · (Bφ up − Bp Ωr), ∇rB (3.20) φ 2 r r t is the toroidal turbulent resistivity. where νm The turbulent resistivity has never been specifically studied nor modelled, although it is needed in the analysis of the coupling of the magnetic field to the disk in disk-driven jet models. A Shakura-Sunyaev type of prep scription is used: νm = αm vA h, where vA is the local Alfv´en velocity, and t p /νm and αm are h the local disk scale-height. In this picture, the ratio νm free parameters. The system is closed with the help of a polytropic equation of state:
P = KρΓ ,
(3.21)
where Γ is the polytropic index (Γ = γ = 5/3 for nonrelativistic adiabatic jets, and Γ = 1 for isothermal ones). 27 The transport may be due to 2D-waves as well as to 3D turbulence, although it is always referred to as a turbulent transport coefficient; for an overview of our present understanding of mechanisms contributing to this coefficient, and of their efficiency, see Ref. [9, 10].
September 30, 2009
14:1
98
3.B.2
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Ideal MHD form
In the ideal MHD context that is relevant in jets, it is possible to reduce the problem to only two equations, namely, Bernoulli’s energy integral, which describes the flow evolution along magnetic surfaces, and a generalized Grad-Shafranov (transfield) equilibrium equation, which defines the shapes of the magnetic surfaces. First, note that in ideal MHD, Eq. (3.19) implies that the poloidal velocity and magnetic field are parallel, so that one can define without loss of generality, χ such that χ up = Bp . (3.22) µo ρ The continuity equation (3.17) then implies that Bp · ∇χ = 0,
(3.23)
i.e., χ = χ(a) is constant on magnetic surfaces. All such constant quantities are most conveniently evaluated on the Alfv´en critical surface (designated by a subscript “A”), where the poloidal velocity is equal to the poloidal √ Alfv´en velocity, so that χ(a) = µo ρA . Similarly, the toroidal component of the induction equation , Eq. (3.20), yields Ω∗ (a) = Ω − χ
Bφ . µo ρr
(3.24)
With the help of Eq. (3.22) and (3.24), one can compute the electric field, which reads E = −u × B = −Ω∗ reφ × Bp ,
(3.25)
which shows that Ω∗ can be interpreted as the rotation velocity of the magnetic field. The toroidal component of the momentum equation, Eq. (3.2) yields an equation of conservation of the total angular momentum on magnetic surfaces: rBφ 2 , (3.26) l(a) ≡ Ω∗ rA = Ωr2 − χ which implicitly defines the magnetic “lever arm” rA . This denomination derives from the fact that, for disk-driven jets, the torque ratio (introduced in Sec. 3.3.3) Λ ∼ βrA /h, where h is the disk scale height (see, e.g., [52, 53]; as β ∼ 1, and as most jet models have rA h, this implies that the magnetic torque always dominates over the turbulent one in these jets.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
99
An assumption commonly made about the polytropic equation of state is that K = K(a). The only remaining dynamical information is contained in the poloidal part of the momentum equation. It is equivalent to Bernoulli’s equation and the generalized Grad-Shafranov equation; they can be expressed as E(a) =
u2 Bφ , + H + ΦG − Ω∗ r √ 2 µo ρA
where H = ΓP/(Γ − 1) is the gas enthalpy, and 2 dΩ∗ rA ∇a dE 2 2 dΩ∗ ∇ · (m − 1) − Ω + (Ωr2 − Ω∗ rA = ρ ) 2 µo r da da da 2 2 2 2 B + m B d ln K Cs p d ln χ φ + , − γ(γ − 1) da µo da
(3.27)
(3.28)
2 where m2 ≡ u2p /VAp is the poloidal Alfv´enic Mach number and Cs2 = γkB T /µmp is the jet sound speed. The derivation of these last two equations is rather involved and is not performed here (see, e.g., [53] for intermediate steps). This form of the generalized Grad-Shafranov equation stresses the fact that once the functional dependence on a of the various invariants just derived is given (i.e., χ, Ω∗ , l, E and K), the shape of the magnetic surfaces is determined. Note that the Poynting flux in the jet is E × Bφ = −Ω∗ rBφ Bp ; it appears as the magnetic term in Bernoulli’s equation. It is the conversion of this magnetic energy into mechanical energy which accelerates the jet. Jets in which the Poynting flux everywhere dominates over the matter kinetic energy are called Poynting, or electromagnetic jets. An equivalent form of the generalized Grad-Shafranov equation can be derived, which has a somewhat more transparent physical content. It reads
2 Bφ2 B2 2 Bp 2 − ρ∇⊥ ΦG + ρΩ r − (1 − m ) − ∇⊥ P + ∇⊥ r = 0 µo R 2µo µo r (3.29) where ∇⊥ X ≡ ∇a·(∇X)/|∇a| is the gradient of a quantity X perpendicular to a magnetic surface; it is negative if X decreases with increasing magnetic flux. One also defines R, the curvature radius of the magnetic surfaces, by
∇a (Bp · ∇)Bp 1 , ≡ · R |∇a| Bp2
(3.30)
When R > 0, the surface is bent outwards while for R < 0, it bends inwards.
September 30, 2009
100
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
3.C
The Kelvin-Helmholtz instability of a single vortex sheet layer
One wishes to study the stability of the fluid time-independent equilibrium sketched on the left-hand side of Fig. 3.4, which is made of two regions (hereafter 1 and 2), endowed with uniform velocities U and −U respectively, uniform pressure, and constant density. A cartesian reference system is erected, such that region 1 corresponds to x > 0 and region 2 to x < 0. The unperturbed interface is at x = 0. The direction z is the direction of the velocity field, the direction y is transverse both to x and z. The fluid is assumed incompressible. The only force acting on the fluid is the pressure. The fluid is perturbed, and the interface between the two regions is designated by ζ = ζ(y, z, t). Region 1 now corresponds to x > ζ, and region 2 to x < ζ. The linearized equations of motion in regions i = 1, 2 read ∂δvi ∇δP i ∂δvi + U =− , (3.31) ∂t ∂z ρ where = +1 in region 1, and = −1 in region 2, and ∇ · δvi = 0.
(3.32)
The boundary conditions are that the perturbation vanishes when x → ±∞, and that the perturbed pressure and velocity appropriately match at the boundary x = ζ. Perturbations of the form exp(iωt − ikz) are assumed (a wavenumber could be added in the direction y). The two preceding equations imply that ∆δP i = 0 so that δP i = pi exp[iωt − ikz − k(x − ζ)] pi exp[iωt − ikz − kx].
(3.33)
The last approximate equality follows from the linearization. The velocity perturbation is connected to the pressure one through ∇δP i δvi = − , (3.34) iρω i where ω i = ω − kU is the Doppler shifted frequency in regions 1 and 2. The boundary condition at the interface on the pressure reduces to δP 1 = δP 2 . To express the boundary condition on the velocity a small detour through lagrangian dynamics is necessary. Assume a fluid particle on the boundary is at position (ζo , yo , zo ) at time to , and define the displacement from this position as ξ = ξ(ζo , yo , zo , t); note that ζ(yo , zo , t) = ζo +ξx . One has δvxi (ζo , yo , zo , to ) = (Dξx /Dt)t=to (∂to + U ∂zo )ζo = iω i ζo ,
(3.35)
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
101
where the approximate equality results from the linearization. Collecting all these results together yields the dispersion relation ω = ±ikU.
(3.36)
One of these two modes is unstable.
3.D
MHD stability and the energy principle
The stability of MHD astrophysical fluids is rarely considered around static equilibria, so that the variational formulation of perturbation MHD around such equilibria is not a well-known topic among astrophysicists. The notions needed in this review are briefly recalled here. Only ideal MHD stability is discussed in this review (for a discussion of non-ideal MHD stability, see [141]). For static equilibria, the MHD equation of motion can be written as (to first order): −ρo ω 2 ξ = −∇δP∗ + δT ≡ F(ξ),
(3.37)
where δT is the perturbation of the magnetic tension, δP∗ = δP + B · δB the total pressure perturbation, and ξ the fluid element displacement from equilibrium (a Fourier transform in time has been performed). The density, pressure and magnetic field perturbations follow from the time integration of the respective equations, which read δρ = −∇·(ρξ),
(3.38)
δB = ∇×(ξ×B),
(3.39)
while the expression of the total pressure perturbation follows from the assumed adiabatic equation of state: B·δB , (3.40) δP∗ = −ξ·∇P − γP ∇·ξ + µ δP δPm The linear operator F of Eq. (3.9) is self-adjoint (see [110] p. 242, and his Appendix A, and references therein). Consequently, an Energy Principle can be formulated. Defining 1 ∗ ξ ∗ · F(ξ)d3 r, (3.41) δW (ξ , ξ) = − 2 and 1 K(ξ ∗ , ξ) = (3.42) ρ|ξ|2 d3 r, 2
September 30, 2009
102
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
and taking the scalar product of Eq. (3.37) with ξ ∗ leads to ω2 =
δW . K
(3.43)
The self-adjointness of F implies that Eq. (3.37) is the extremum of Eq. (3.43) with respect to a variation of ξ. A useful form of δW has been derived by Bernstein et al. [142], which reads (see [110] p. 259) 1 d3 r |Q⊥ |2 + Bo2 |∇ · ξ⊥ + 2κc · ξ⊥ |2 + γPo |∇ · ξ|2 δW = − 2 ∗ ∗ − 2(ξ⊥ · ∇Po )(κc · ξ⊥ ) − J (ξ⊥ × e ) · Q⊥ , (3.44) where ξ⊥ is the component of the displacement perpendicular to the unperturbed field B, Q⊥ = ∇ × (ξ⊥ × Bo ) is the perturbation in the magnetic field, and κc ≡ (e · ∇)e ] = −Bθ2 /(B 2 r)er is the curvature vector of the magnetic field (e is the unit vector in the direction of the unperturbed magnetic field. The first term describes the field line bending energy. The second term is the energy in the field compression, while the third is the energy in the plasma compression. The fourth term arises from the perpendicular current (as ∇P = J⊥ × B in a static equilibrium), and the last one arises from the parallel current J . Only these two terms can be negative, and give rise to an instability if they are large enough to make ω 2 < 0. These instabilities are referred to as pressure-driven and current-driven, respectively. They include the well-known pressure-driven “sausage” (m = 0) and current-driven “kink” (m = 1) modes; these denominations follow from the generic shape assumed by the deformation, for any given, finite vertical wave-number k. Pressure-driven instabilities are further subdivided into interchange and ballooning modes (see [110] for details). Also, it is important to know whether unstable modes are internal or external, i.e., have vanishing or non-vanishing displacement on the plasma surface. The distinction is important, as unstable external modes are prone to disrupt the plasma. 3.E
Pressure-driven instabilities asymptotic limit
In this Appendix, successive analytic reductions of the momentum equation, Eq. (3.37), are outlined, leading to a simple dispersion relation for pressuredriven modes in the |Bφ | |Bz | limit, which is of interest for MHD jet models.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
103
After some algebra (detailed in Appendix C of [110]), the perturbation equations can be combined in a single, exact but somewhat complex equation for the radial displacement ξ ≡ ξor [143, 144]: d d A (rξ) + C(rξ) = 0 (3.45) dr dr with 2 (ω 2 − v 2 k 2 )(ω 2 − v 2 c2 k 2 /(v 2 + c2 )) ρ(c2s + vA ) s A A s A , r D 2 2 2 4k2 Bφ vA Bφ d 2 2 2 2 2 k ) − µo Dr C = ρr (ω 2 − vA 3 (ω − cs k ) − dr r2 µo 2B B 2 2 2 2 2 2 ⊥ + µφo kk v k − (c + v )ω c , 2 s s A A r D
A=
D = (ω 2 − ωf2 )(ω 2 − ωs2 ),
(3.46)
(3.47) (3.48)
where ωf and ωs are the frequencies of the usual fast and slow magnetosonic modes, vA and cs the local Alfv´en and sound speed, and finally k = (mBφ /r + kBz )/B
(3.49)
k⊥ = (mBz /r − kBφ )/B
(3.50)
are the components of the wavenumber k parallel and perpendicular to the unperturbed magnetic field. A first simplification is obtained by noting that unstable modes have |ω 2 | ∼ c2s Kc Kρ , so that, in the large wavelength limit (|k⊥ r| 1), ω 2 ωf2 . If one furthermore restricts oneself to quasi-perpendicular wavenumbers and keeps only the leading order terms in the |k |/|k⊥ | expansion, A and C reduce to ρ 1
2 A = − 2 ω 2 − ωA , (3.51) r k⊥ 2Bφ2 C =− 3 r
rP B2
−
4β ∗ Bφ4 ω2 , (1 + β ∗ )r3 B 2 ω 2 − ωs2
(3.52)
2 2 ) in this limit, and where β ∗ = c2s /vA . with ωs2 = c2s k2 /(c2s + vA The remainder of this Appendix is devoted to the large toroidal field limit. Note that, in the vicinity of a resonance, the parallel wavenumber can be expanded to first order in the distance δr to the resonance rc to read
|k | = |k⊥ |
|Bφ Bz | |δr| |s|. B2 rc
(3.53)
September 30, 2009
104
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
In the large toroidal field limit, the magnetic shear term in the Suydam criterion Eq. (3.11) is small, and, correlatively, for |k⊥ | |Bφ /Bz | and β ∼ 1, the mode can extend over distances ∼ r without imperiling the 2 2 k < c2s Kc Kρ (to have unstable modes). Consequently, one requirement vA can choose ξr (r) = ξo exp(ikr r), with 1 |kr r| |k⊥ r|, and the term involving A in the momentum equation Eq. (3.45) becomes negligible. The remaining terms lead to the looked for dispersion relation: 2 2 2 2 + vSM ) + ωc2 ω 2 + k2 k2 − 2β ∗ Kc Kρ vSM vA = 0, (3.54) ω 4 − k2 (vA 2 2 β ∗ vA /(1 + β ∗ ) is the slow magnetosonic square speed (β ∗ = where vSM 2 2 cs /vA = γβ/2), and
4β ∗ Kc2 2 2 . (3.55) ωc = vA −2βKρ Kc + 1 + β∗
As seen by direct inspection, only one root of Eq. (3.54) is negative at a time, and only when k2 < 2β ∗ Kc Kρ
(3.56)
Acknowledgments I thank Jonathan Ferreira and Guy Pelletier for the many exchanges we have had over the years, and in the course of the preparation of this work, on various aspects of the physics discussed here. I also thank Hubert Baty for discussions on some aspects of current-driven instabilities in jets. References [1] Cabrit S 2002 Constraints on accretion-ejection structures in young stars. In Star formation and the physics of Young stars, J Bouvier and J-P Zahn, eds (EDP Sciences). [2] Rees M J 1984 Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 22 471. [3] Blandford R D 1990 Physical Processes in Active Galactic Nuclei. In Active Galactic Nuclei, 20th Saas-Fee Advanced Course in Astronomy and Astrophysics (Springer-Verlag). [4] Ferrari A 1998 Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 36 359. [5] Pelletier G 2004 Black Hole induced ejection. In the Cargese lectures on Black Holes in the Universe (to be published; available as astroph/0405113). [6] Bertout C 1989 Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 27 351. [7] Andr´e P 2002 The initial conditions for protostellar collapse: observational constraints. In Star formation and the physics of Young stars, J Bouvier and J-P Zahn, eds (EDP Sciences).
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
105
[8] Ferreira J 2002 Theory of magnetized accretion disks driving jets. In Star formation and the physics of Young stars, J Bouvier and J-P Zahn, eds (EDP Sciences). Available as astro-ph/0211621. [9] Papaloizou J C B and Lin D N C 1995 Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 33 505. [10] Lin D N C and Papaloizou J C B 1996 Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 34 703. [11] Hartmann L 2001 Astrophys. J. 121 1030. [12] Tassis K and Mouschovias T C 2004 Astrophys. J. 616 283. [13] M´enard F and Bertout C 2002 Accretion disks around young stars: an observational perspective. In Star formation and the physics of Young stars, J Bouvier and J-P Zahn, eds (EDP Sciences). [14] Gabuzda D C 1997 in Relativistic Jets in AGNs, M Ostrowski, M Sikora, G Madejski, M Begelman eds, Cracow. [15] Asada K, Inoue M, Ushida Y, Kameno S, Fujisawa K, Igushi S and Mutoh M 2002 Pub. Astron. Soc. Pac. 54 L39. [16] Krause M and L¨ or A 2004 Astron. Astrophys. . 420 115. [17] Ray T P, Muxlow T W B, Axon D J, Brown A, Corcoran D, Dyson J and Mundt R 1997 Nature 385 415. [18] Reipurth B, and Bally J 2001 Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 39 403. [19] Bodo G., Massaglia S., Rossi P., Rosner P., Malagoli A. and Ferrari A. 1995 Astron. Astrophys. 303 281. [20] Bodo G., Rossi P., Massaglia S., Ferrari A., Malagoli A. and Rosner P. 1998 Astron. Astrophys. 333 1117. [21] Ferreira J 1997 Astron. Astrophys. 319 340. [22] Rekowski M v, R¨ udiger G and Elstner D 2000 Astron. Astrophys. 353 813. [23] Camenzind M 1986 Astron. Astrophys. 156 137. [24] Bogovalov S 2001 Astron. Astrophys. 371 1155. [25] Bogovalov S and Tsinganos K 2001 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 325 249. [26] Vlahakis N and K¨ onigl A 2004 Astrophys. J. 605 656. [27] Vlahakis N 2004 Astrophys. J. 600 324. [28] Casse F and Ferreira J 2000 Astron. Astrophys. 361 1178. [29] Phinney E S 1982 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 198 1109. [30] Renaud N and Henri G 1998 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 300 1047. [31] Gracia J, Tsinganos K and Bogovalov S V. 2005 Astron. Astrophys. 442 L7-L10. [32] K¨ onigl A 1986 Can. J. Phys. 64 362. [33] Blandford R D and Znajek R L 1977 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 179 433. [34] Thorne K S, Price R H and MacDonald D A 1986 Black Hole: the Membrane Paradigm (Yale University Press). [35] MacDonald D A and Thorne K S 1982 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 198 345. [36] Phinney E S 1982 In Astrophysical jets, 1st Torino workshop p. 201. Ferrari and Pacholczyk eds (Reidel). [37] Punsly B and Coroniti F V 1990 Astrophys. J. 350 518.
September 30, 2009
106
[38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46]
[47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71]
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Komissarov S S 2004 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 350 427. Komissarov S S 2004 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 350 1431. Li L X 2000 Phys. Rev. D 61 084016. Wang D.-X., Ma, R.-Y. and Lei W.-H. 2003 Astrophys. J. 595 109. Shu F H, Najita J, Ostriker E and Wilkin F 1994 Astrophys. J. 429 781. Lovelace R V E, Romanova M M and Bisnovatyi-Kogan G S 1999 Astrophys. J. 513 368. Ferreira J, Pelletier G and Appl S 2000 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 312 387. Romanova M M, Ustyugova G V, Koldoba A V and Lovelace R V E 2004 Astrophys. J. 610 920. Bouvier J, Chelli A, Allain S, Carrasco L, Costero R, Cruz-Gonzalez I, Dougados C, Fern´ andez M, Martn E L, M´enard F, Mennessier C, Mujica R, Recillas E, Salas L, Schmidt G and Wichmann R 1999 Astron. Astrophys. 349 619. Bardou A and Heyvaerts J 1996 Astron. Astrophys. 307 1009. Blandford R D 1976 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 176 465. Lovelace R V E 1976 Nature 242 649. Benford G 1978 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 183 29. Chan K L and Henriksen R N 1980 Astrophys. J. 241 534. Blandford R D and Payne D G 1982 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 199 883. Pelletier G and Pudritz R E 1992 Astrophys. J. 394 117. Contopoulos J and Lovelace R V E 1994 Astrophys. J. 429 139. Sauty C and Tsinganos K 1994 Astron. Astrophys. 287 893. Li Z-H 1996 Astrophys. J. 465 855. Ustyugova G V, Koldoba A V, Romanova M M, Chetchetkin V M and Lovelace R V E 1999 Astrophys. J. 516 221. Krasnopolski R, Li Z Y and Blandford R D 1999 Astrophys. J. 526 631. Ouyed R, Clarke D A and Pudritz R E 2003 Astrophys. J. 582 292. Casse F and Keppens R 2004 Astrophys. J. 601 90. Kato S, Kudoh T and Shibata K 2002 Astrophys. J. 565 1035. Lubow S H, Papaloizou J C B, Pringle J E 1994 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 267 235. Heyvaers J, Priest E R and Bardou A (1996) Astrophys. J. 473 403. Lubow S H, Papaloizou J C B, Pringle J E 1994 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 268 1010. Cao X and Spruit H C 2002 Astron. Astrophys. 385 289. Livio M. 1997, in IAU 163, Accretion Phenomena and Related Outflows, ASP Conf Series 121, p. 845. Sauty C, Trussoni A, and Tsinganos K 2002 Astron. Astrophys. 389 1068. Heyvaers J and Norman C (1989) Astrophys. J. 347 1055. Okamoto I 2001 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. bf 327 55. Garcia P J V, Ferreira J, Cabrit S and Binette L (2001) Astron. Astrophys. 377 589. K¨ onigl A and Choudhuri A R 1985 Astrophys. J. 289 173.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
107
[72] Taylor J B 1974 Phys. Rev. Lett. 33 139. [73] Taylor J B 1986 Rev. Mod. Phys. 58 741. [74] Ortolani S and Schnack D D 1993 Magnetohydrodynamics of Plasma Relaxation (World Scientific). [75] Birkinshaw M 1991 The stability of jets. In Beams and Jets in Astrophysics, P A Hugues, ed (Cambridge University Press). [76] Todo Y, Uchida Y, Tetzuya S and Rosner R 1993 Astrophys. J. 403 164. [77] Blandford R D and Rees M J 1974 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 169 395. [78] Hardee P E, Clarke D A and Rosen A 1997 Astrophys. J. 485 533. [79] Rosen A, Hardy P E, Clarke D A and Johnson A 1999 Astrophys. J. 510 136. [80] Terry P W 2000 Rev. Mod. Phys. 72 109. [81] Hanasz M, Sol, H and Sauty C (2000) Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 316 494. [82] Balbus S A 2003 Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 41 555. [83] Papaloizou J C B and Pringle J E 1984 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 208 721. [84] Blaes O M 1987 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 227 975. [85] Hawley J F 1991 Astrophys. J. 496 507. [86] Wardle M and K¨ onigl A 1993 Astrophys. J. 410 218. [87] Spruit H C, Stehle R and Papaloizou J C B 1995 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 275 1223. [88] K¨ onigl A and Wardle M 1996 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 279 L61. [89] K¨ onigl A 2004 Astrophys. J. 617 1267. [90] Casse F and Keppens R 2002 Astrophys. J. 581 988. [91] Ouyed R and Pudritz R E 1997 Astrophys. J. 482 712. [92] Ouyed R and Pudritz R E 1997 Astrophys. J. 484 794. [93] Ouyed R and Pudritz R E 1999 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 309 233. [94] Anderson J M, Li Z-H, Krasnopolsky R and Blandford R D 2005 Astrophys. J. 630 945. [95] Drazin P G and Reid W H 1981 Hydrodynamic Stability (Cambridge University Press). [96] Ferrari A, Trussoni E and Zaninetti L 1981 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 196 1051. [97] Ray T P 1981 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 196 195. [98] Ray T P 1982 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 198 617. [99] Cohn H 1983 Astrophys. J. 269 500. [100] Fiedler R L and Jones T 1984 Astrophys. J. 283 532. [101] Roy Choudhury S and Lovelace R V E 1986 Astrophys. J. 302 188. [102] Bodo G, Rosner R, Ferrari A and Knobloch E 1989 Astrophys. J. 341 631. [103] Bodo G, Rosner R, Ferrari A and Knobloch E 1996 Astrophys. J. 470 797. [104] Hardee P E and Stone J M 1997 Astrophys. J. 483 121. [105] Stone J M, Xu J and Hardee P E 1997 Astrophys. J. 483 136. [106] Xu J, Hardee P E and Stone J M 2000 Astrophys. J. 543 161. [107] Jones T W, Gaalaas J B, Ruy D and Frank A 1997 Astrophys. J. 482 230.
September 30, 2009
108
[108] [109] [110] [111] [112] [113] [114] [115] [116] [117] [118] [119] [120] [121] [122] [123] [124] [125] [126] [127] [128] [129] [130] [131] [132] [133] [134] [135] [136] [137] [138] [139] [140] [141] [142] [143] [144]
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Jeong H, Ryu D, Jones T W and Frank A 2000 Astrophys. J. 529 536. Baty H and Keppens R 2002 Astrophys. J. 580 800. Freidberg J P 1987 Ideal Magnetohydrodynamics. Plenum Press. Priest E R 1982 Solar Magnetohydrodynamics. Reidel. Eichler D 1993 Astrophys. J. 419 111. Spruit H C, Foglizzo T and Stehle R 1997 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 288 333. Appl S, Lery T and Baty H 2000 Astron. Astrophys. 355 818. Istomin Y N and Pariev V I 1994 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 267 629. Istomin Y N and Pariev V I 1996 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 281 1. Appl S 1996 Astron. Astrophys. 314 995. Lyubarskii Y E 1999 Monthly Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 308 1006. Baty H 2005, Astron. Astrophys. 430 9. Lery T, Baty H and Appl S 2000 Astron. Astrophys. 355 1201. Begelman M C 1998 Astrophys. J. 493 291. Dewar R L, Tatsuno T, Yoshida Z, N¨ urenberg C and McMillan B F 2004 Phys. Rev. E 70 066409. Cheremhykh O K and Revenchuk S M 1992 Plasma Phys. Contr. Fusion 34 55. Bondeson A, Iacono R and Bhattacharjee A 1987 Phys. Fluids 30 2167. Shumlak U and Hartman C W 1995 Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 3285. Arber T D and Howell D F 1996 Phys. Plasmas 3 554. Waelbroeck F L and Chen L 1991 Phys. Fluids B 3 601. Miller R L and Waltz R E 1994 Phys. Plasmas 1 2835. Chiueh T 1996 Phys. Rev. E 54 5632. Wanex L F, Sotnikov V I and Leboeuf J N 2005 Phys. Plamas 12 042101. Hassam A B 1992 Phys. Fluids B 4 485. DeSouza-Machado S, Hassam A B and Sina R 2000 Phys. Plasmas 7 4632. Woltjer L 1990 Phenomenology of Active Galactic Nuclei. In Active Galactic Nuclei, 20th Saas-Fee Advanced Course (Springer-Verlag). Netzer H 1990 AGN emission line. In Active Galactic Nuclei, 20th Saas-Fee Advanced Course (Springer-Verlag). Vall´ee J P 2004 New Astron. Rev. 48 763. Yamazaki D G, Ichiki K and Kajino T 2005 Astrophys. J. Lett. 625 L1. Langer M, Puget J-L and Aghanim N 2003 Phys. Rev. D 67 043505. Shu F H 1992 The Physics of Astrophysics. II: Gas Dynamics. University Science Books. Krall N A and Trievelpiece A W 1986 Principles of Plasma Physics. San Francisco Press. Shakura N I and Sunyaev R A 1973 Astron. Astrophys. 24 337. Bateman G 1978 MHD Instabilities. MIT Press. Bernstein I B, Frieman E A, Kruskal M D and Kulsrud R M 1958 Proc. Royal Soc. London A 244 17. Hain K and L¨ ust R 1958 Z. Naturforsch. Teil A 13 936. Goedbloed J P 1974 Physica 53 501.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
Fig. 3.7
Fig. 3.8
Professor Masahiro Wakatani.
Prof. Wakatani and friends at the first ‘Festival de Th´eorie’.
BkFestival2003
109
September 30, 2009
110
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Fig. 3.9 Magnetic field lines in globally isotropic turbulence as in the simulation underlying Fig. 6.2 (left) and in a system with strong mean field component, b0 = 5 (right).
Fig. 3.10 Dissipative micro current sheets in isotropic (left) and anisotropic (right) turbulence. The anisotropic system is permeated by a mean magnetic field of strength b0 = 5 pointing upwards (cf. Fig. 3.9). Every current sheet is accompanied by vorticity sheets (not shown).
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
111
Fig. 3.11 Views of the jets of the galaxies M87 (left) and 3C175 (right). The blow-up insert on the left image shows a gas disk, whose size is considerably larger than that of the central engine. The disk fast rotation strongly suggests the existence of a massive black hole at the galaxy center. The image of 3C175 shows the large scale collimated jet, and the end lobes (of rather modest size in this case). There are in fact two jets, one on each side of the galaxy, but one of them is not visible because of Doppler shift effects. Credits: Hubble Space Telescope Science Institute (left); National Radio Astronomy Observatory (right).
Fig. 3.12 Views of jets from three different forming stars. The sketch at the bottom shows them in relative scale, and gives some indication of the typical global appearance of YSO jets. The HH-30 image shows not only a jet, but an edge-on disk. The disk corresponds to the dark region of the “diabolo”-shaped feature of the upper-left image; it is darkened by the aborption due to the presence of dust in the disk plane. Light from the protostar is processed and reemitted towards the observer by the top and bottom of the disk (green regions). The protostar itself is hidden by the disk. As in AGNs, jets are two-sided. Colors are artificial. Credits: Space Telescope Science Institute.
September 30, 2009
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
MHD Jet
112
14:1
Gb Plasma
non thermal radiative emission synchrotron+ICS
plasma - MHD Waves interaction
radiative acceleration
accretion disk
central engine
(supermassive black hole)
Fig. 3.13 Poloidal cut through a two-component model of AGN jet. A conventional, non-relativistic, disk-driven MHD jet provides the energy to confine and heat a pair plasma in its core, which is responsible for AGN high energy radiation (figure by Ludovic Saug´ e).
Fig. 3.14 A differentially rotating disk threaded by a dipolar field can give rise to a jet, which is centrifugally accelerated by the field. Collimation eventually follows once the jet has widened enough (magnetic surfaces opening and recollimation are not shown to scale).
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
113
Bp Ideal MHD
- dP/dz
up
resistive MHD
Central Object
Matter streamline
Fig. 3.15 Vertical cut through an accretion-disk. The disk is assumed to be effectively resistive and viscous through turbulent processes, while the jet is assumed ideal. The polo¨idal velocity and magnetic field are shown (figure by Fabien Casse).
Fig. 3.16 Poloidal cut through an accretion-disk and jet. The sketch illustrates the existence of three critical surfaces in steady-state solutions to the ideal MHD jet problem, with a change of type of the PDEs at the surfaces (figure by Jonathan Ferreira).
September 30, 2009
114
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Radio power Radio galaxies
Distance (redshift)
Seyfert galaxies Sf 1 :broad and narrow lines Sf 2 : narrow lines QSO radio-quiet
FR I
FR II
Quasars Radio quasars BL Lacs (very weak lines)
Fig. 3.17 Qualitative classification of AGNs based on their radio power, and their distances to the observer (measured by their cosmological redshift). Figure by Gilles Henri.
Fig. 3.18 Snapshots of electric potential fluctuations in a poloidal plane in a quiescent phase (left) and during a relaxation (right). The radial co-ordinate is stretched by a factor 4 (comp. Fig. 8.1). The relaxation is dominated by a (m, n) = (5, 2) mode which is the lowest order (m, n) mode localized at the barrier position.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Origin, Structure and Stability of Astrophysical MHD Jets
BkFestival2003
115
Fig. 3.19 Radial profiles of density (top) and electron and ion temperature (bottom) in the tokamak JET (from [21]).
Fig. 3.20
Radial shape of a global mode calculated with the MISHKA code [24].
September 30, 2009
14:1
116
Fig. 3.21
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
Domain of existence for type I and type III edge localized modes [12].
Fig. 3.22 Map of the pressure gradient versus radial coordinate and time for the model Eq. (9.16) with RS = 0.
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
PART 3
Turbulence and turbulent transport the agents of relaxation and structure formation
117
BkFestival2003
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
This page intentionally left blank
118
BkFestival2003
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Chapter 4
A Tutorial on Basic Concepts in MHD Turbulence and Turbulent Transport P.H. Diamond∗† , S.-I. Itoh† and K. Itoh‡ ∗
University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093-0319 USA † Research Institute for Applied Mechanics, Kyushu University, Kasuga City 816-8580 Japan ‡ National Institute for Fusion Science, Toki-Shi 509-5292 Japan
4.1
Introduction
In this paper, we present an eclectic tutorial on some of the basic ideas in MHD turbulence and turbulent transport, with special attention to incompressible and weakly compressible dynamics with a mean magnetic field. The approach throughout is conceptual - we emphasize intuition, ideas and basic notions rather than detailed results. The latter are already well documented in the research literature. Also, we place primary emphasis on understanding the case of magnetized MHD turbulence, in which an externally fixed, large scale magnetic field breaks symmetry, produces anisotropy and restricts nonlinear interactions. This case should be contrasted with that considered in many (but not all) discussions of MHD turbulence, which focus on weakly magnetized or unmagnetized systems. This paper is organized into four sections, each of which discusses an essential paradigm in MHD turbulence theory. These four sections should be thought of as four related but distinct vignettes, rather than one continuous narrative. Each attempts to give the reader the chance to peep at some essential ideas in the theory. The four sections are the following. Section 4.2: K41 beyond dimensional analysis - revisiting the theory of hydrodynamic 119
September 30, 2009
120
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Relaxation Dynamics in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas
turbulence. Section 4.3: Kraichnan-Iroshnikov, Goldreich-Sridhar and all that: a scaling theory of MHD turbulence. Section 4.4: Steepening of nonlinear Alfven waves - a little compressibility goes a long way... Section 4.5: Turbulent flux diffusion in 2D MHD - a ‘minimal’ problem which is not so simple... While these four topics are distinct, they do have a common theme, namely the effect of Alfvenically induced ‘memory’ on turbulence and transport. These four sections are followed by a brief discussion and conclusion, Sec. 4.6. We indicate some possible future research directions throughout the paper, where appropriate.
4.2
K41 beyond dimensional analysis - revisiting the theory of hydrodynamic turbulence
Surely everyone has encountered the basic ideas of Kolmogorov’s theory of high Reynolds number turbulence [1]! Loosely put, empirically motivated assumptions of (I) spatial homogeneity - i.e. the turbulence is uniformly distributed in space, (II) isotropy - i.e. the turbulence exhibits no preferred spatial orientation, (III) self-similarity - i.e. all inertial range scales exhibit the same physics and are equivalent. Here ”inertial range” refers to the range of scales
smaller than the stirring scale 0 but larger than the dissipation scale ( d < < 0 ), (IV) locality of interaction - i.e. the (dominant) nonlinear interactions in the inertial range are local in scale, i.e. while large scales advect small scales, they cannot distort or destroy small scales, only sweep them around. Inertial range transfer occurs via like-scale straining, only. Assumptions (I)-(IV) and the basic idea of an inertial range cascade are summarized in Fig. 4.1 and Fig. 4.2. Using assumptions (I) - (IV), we can state that energy through-put must be constant for all inertial range scales, so
∼ v03 / 0 ∼ v( )3 / ,
(4.1)
September 30, 2009
14:1
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
BkFestival2003
Basic Concepts in MHD Turbulence and Turbulent Transport
121
and v( ) ∼ ( )1/3 ,
(4.2)
2/3 −5/3
E(k) ∼
k
,
(4.3)
which are the familiar K41 results. The dissipation scale d is obtained by balancing the eddy straining rate 1/3 / 2/3 with the viscous dissipation rate ν/ 2 to find the Kolmogorov microscale.
d ∼ ν 3/4 / 1/4
ut np i y erg ing En stirr by
(4.4)
Inertial range Local energy transfer in the inertial range
En vis ergy co us outp he ut b a ti ng y
Fig. 4.1 Basic cartoon explanation of the Richardson-Kolmogorov cascade. Energy transfer in Fourier-space.
l0
.. .. .
.. .. .
.. .. .
.. .. .
.. .. .
.. .. .
.. .. .
.. .. .
..................
l1 = α l0 .. .. . l n = αn l 0 .. .. . ld
Fig. 4.2 Basic cartoon explanation of the Richardson-Kolmogorov cascade. That in real space.
A related and important phenomenon, which also may be illuminated by scaling arguments, is how the distance between two test particles grows in time in a turbulent flow. This problem was first considered by Louis Fry Richardson, who was stimulated by observations of the rate