M. Artin, H. Bass, J . Eells, W. Feit, P. J. Freyd, F. W. Gehring, H. Halberstam, L. V. Hormander, M. Kac, J. H. B. Kemperman, H. A . Lauwerier, W. A. J. Luxemburg, F. P. Peterson, I. M. Singer and A . C . Zaanen
NORTH-HOLLAND PUBLISHING COMPANY AMSTERDAM . NEW YORK . OXFORD
RIESZ SPACES I1 A. C. ZAANEN
NORTH-HOLLAND PUBLISHING COMPANY AMSTERDAM . NEW YORK . OXFORD
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner.
ISBN: 0 444 86626 4 Published by: NORTH-HOLLAND PUBLISHING COMPANY AMSTERDAM . NEW YORK . OXFORD Sole distributors for the U.S.A. and Canada: ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHING COMPANY, INC. 52, VANDERBILT AVENUE NEW YORK, N.Y. 10017
This i s Volume I1 of a r a t h e r d e t a i l e d work on Riesz s p a c e s ( v e c t o r l a t t i c e s ) . Volume I , w r i t t e n j o i n t l y w i t h W . A . J .
1971. The c o n s i d e r a b l e t i m e i n t e r v a l between t h e appearance of t h e s e volumes
i s caused mainly by t h e f a c t t h a t i m p o r t a n t p a r t s of t h e t h e o r y were p u t i n t o a n e l e g a n t and more o r less f i n a l form o n l y v e r y r e c e n t l y . This i s t r u e f o r Chapter 13 on k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s ( i n t e g r a l o p e r a t o r s ) and s t i l l more f o r Chapter 18 on compact o p e r a t o r s . To mention one example, i t w a s unknown n o t s o l o n g ago t h a t , even i n a f a m i l i a r s p a c e l i k e a n L 2 - ~ p a c e , any p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r m a j o r i z e d by a k e r n e l o p e r a t o r is i t s e l f a k e r n e l o p e r a t o r and any p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r m a j o r i z e d by a compact o p e r a t o r i s i t s e l f compact. Chapters and s e c t i o n s i n t h e two volumes are numbered through. The p r e s e n t volume b e g i n s , t h e r e f o r e , w i t h Chapter 1 1 , s e c t i o n 76. T h i s does n o t imply t h a t e v e r y t h i n g i n Volume I i s needed f o r Volume 11. For t h e u n d e r s t a n d i n g of Chapters 12-20 i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o b e f a m i l i a r w i t h Chapters 2-4 and p a r t of Chapter 6 ( F r e u d e n t h a l ' s s p e c t r a l theorem). Much of t h i s can a l s o b e found i n t h e f i r s t p a r t of Chapter I1 o f t h e book by H.H.
1974) a s w e l l a s i n Chapters 1 and 4 o f t h e book by E . de Jonge and A.C.M.
van Rooij ( [ 1 ] , 1 9 7 7 ) .
w e d i s c u s s e x t e n s i o n s and g e n e r a l i z a t i o n s of what was proved i n Chapter 5 (and s e c t i o n 52 of Chapter 7) about prime i d e a l s i n d i s t r i b u t i v e l a t t i c e s and i n R i e s z s p a c e s . Chapter 12 c o n t a i n s a g e n e r a l i n t r o d u c t i o n t o o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r s i n R i e s z s p a c e s . I n Chapter 13 t h i s m a t e r i a l i s immediately p u t t o u s e i n an i n v e s t i g a t i o n of k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s i n s p a c e s o f measurable f u n c t i o n s . T h i s c u l m i n a t e s i n A.V.
Buhvalov's n e c e s s a r y and s u f f i c i e n t c o n d i t i o n f o r a n
Operator t o b e a k e r n e l o p e r a t o r . Chapters 14-16, mainly about normed Riesz s p a c e s ( i n p a r t i c u l a r Banach l a t t i c e s ) have t h e i r r o o t s i n a s e r i e s of n o t e s in t h e Proceedings o f t h e N e t h e r l a n d s Academy of S c i e n c e (1963-65;Notes
by W . A . J . Luxemburg and A . C . Zaanen, Notes 14-16 by W . A . J . Chapter 17, based p a r t l y on c l a s s i c a l work of H.F.
Luxemburg). I n
Bohnenblust and S. Kaku-
tan5 around 1940, we d e a l with a b s t r a c t L -spaces, i n p a r t i c u l a r with ALP spaces and AM-spaces. Chapter 18 i s b u i l t around the r e c e n t r e s u l t s of P.G.
Dodds and D.H.
Fremlin on compact operators i n Banach l a t t i c e s . I n the
f i r s t p a r t of Chapter 19 we discuss O r l i c z spaces. In the p r o p e r t i e s of these spaces, g e n e r a l i z a t i o n s of the f a m i l i a r L -spaces, we recognize
b e a u t i f u l i l l u s t r a t i o n s of much t h a t was observed about a b s t r a c t normed Riesz spaces i n the e a r l i e r chapters. The second p a r t of Chapter 19 i s devot e d t o band-irreducible
operators ( i . e . ,
v a r i a n t except t h e n u l l band and the entkre space). Generalizations Of c l a s s i c a l eigenvalue theorems of 0. Perron, G. Frobenius (matrices with non-negative
e n t r i e s ) and R. Jentzsch ( p o s i t i v e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s ) a r e de-
rived. These g e n e r a l i z a t i o n s (and even some s t i l l more g e n e r a l r e s u l t s ) a l s o occur i n the abovementioned book by H.H.
i s somewhat d i f f e r e n t because we have made an attempt t o keep a l l proofs f r e e of any r e p r e s e n t a t i o n methods. The attempt i s almost s u c c e s s f u l , with one exception i n Theorem 1 3 6 . 8 . A representation-free
of t h i s theorem i s d e s i r e d . F i n a l l y , Chapter 20 on orthomorphisms ( i . e . , o r d e r bounded operators t h a t a r e band preserving) contains r e s u l t s t h a t a r e mostly of very r e c e n t o r i g i n . Some o l d e r r e s u l t s t h a t were f i r s t proved
(1969-71) by m a n s of r e p r e s e n t a t i o n theorems a r e now presented i n a
representation- f r e e manner .
The p r e s e n t a t i o n of the m a t e r i a l i n some of the chapters has been s i g n i f i c a n t l y influenced by the work of s e v e r a l of my s t u d e n t s ( e i t h e r t h e s i s work o r otherwise). This holds f o r A.R. p a r t of Ch. and B.
1 9 ) , W.J.
Claas (Ch. 17), W.K.
Schep (Ch. 13 and the second
Vietsch (Ch. l a ) , C.B.
de P a g t e r (Ch. 2 0 ) , E. de Jonge ( s e c t i o n s 119 and 133) and J.J. Grob-
l e r ( s e c t i o n 129). Furthermore, many d e t a i l s i n the t e x t come from conv e r s a t i o n s w i t h s t u d e n t s and colleagues. I n p a r t i c u l a r , the f r e q u e n t cont a c t s with W i m Luxemburg over a p e r i o d of many years have been very import a n t , a s e v i d e n t a l s o from the b i b l i o g r a p h i c a l r e f e r e n c e s . Several books dealing with Riesz spaces have been published since 1971. There i s some overlap, b u t not too much, of the p r e s e n t book w i t h the book on Banach l a t t i c e s and p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r s by H.H. book by E. de Jonge-A.C.M.
Schaefer ( [ 1 ] , 1 9 7 4 ) .
t h e theory, is from 1977. In the books by D.H.
C.D.
Aliprantis-0.
g e n e r a l t h a n n o r m d o n e s , are i n v e s t i g a t e d . The books by H.E. 1974) and by J. Lindenstrauss-L.
Banach s p a c e s , a r e r e l a t e d . The same h o l d s f o r t h e book on k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s by M.A.
K r a s n o s e l s k i i , P.P.
(C11,1976).
Zabreiko, E . I .
P u s t y l n i k and P.E.
p a r t i a l l y ordered topological vector spaces. Thanks ame due t o Sonja Wassenaar who p r e p a r e d t h e typed m a n u s c r i p t and t o t h e s t a f f a t t h e North-Holland
cooperation. December 1982
A.C.
CHAPTER 11. PRill£ ll>EAL EXTENSlO'
16. Prime ideal separ ation 77. The hull-ke-rnel t opol ogy and the d\L&l hull-kernel t.opol ogy
78 . The unique priae ideal extension property 79 . Strongly order dense Rieu subs~cea
80. Extent iO'Il theorcas
81 • PrUDe ideal extension and t he p rojection property 82. Hor.al and extrenally disconne c ted lattice•
CHAPTER 12. ORDER BOUNDED OPEAATORS
83, Order bounded opera t or s 84. Order cone i nuoua o pe rators
65 . The orde r dual of a Riesz sptlcre
86 . Integrals o n ideals o f
81. lntearah tmd singular: l i near function•h
88 . The largect. ideal on which every order bo~ded oper4tor ie nrder continuous 89. Annihilator• and weak topologies 90. The carrier of an order bounded linear luncliooal
91 . CO.plex lie•z spaces
92. Coaplox order bounded operators
CHAPTER 1 3. KEMtL OPEAATORS
93. Kernel oper,tors 94. The b4nd ot absol ute kernel ope rators 9S . The b ~nd guncrutcd by the kor nel operators ot f in i t e rank 96 . 8uhva l ov •s
91 . Adjoint opera tors
98. Dunford'• theorc.
99.
CIIAP'tl:R 14. NORIUID R IESZ SPACES
100. Normed Riesz s p~ces 10 1. Banach lattices
102. The Banach dual
CHAPTER 15 . ORDER CONTlNUOUS NORMS
10). OrdQr continuous •lornas
104.
105. Ando'a thcoreQ and the order ~opology 1 0~. Order continuity and tbe ordeY dual
CIIAPTEI\ 16. EI
107. Riea& of
about Riesz seainores 109. Embedding of L into the order biduol
110. Perfect R\eoz &paces
1 1 I. Perfect Banach l attices
11 2. 8taon.cb funct i on spaces
I I 3. Tho Patou property
I tt.. Ecbedding in the Sanach bid ual; reflexivity
115. Adjoint operators
116. Di•joint stquences and order concinuout nonDt
11 7. Copiu
108.
CIW"l'ER 17. AliSUW:f Lp- SPACES
t18.
119. Seo.i-H-ap..aces
IZO. J.pretentation by a space of 12:1. Repretentation by a space of
CIIAPTER I 8 . COHPACT OPERATORS
12:2. C.ompo.c: t tcu . pr ecompoact set a: and alaao.tt order boundl!d
seta 12 3. The bnnd of
124. 1'heortmt of Dodd&-i:'rem.l in andl A lipra n tis-Bur k int~ha.w
125.
126. Semi- compac t operators and or de r continuity of the operator
norm 127 . St!mi- compa c t operator s and d isj oin t sequences
128. Semi-compact operators and o r der project ions
1Z9. Scl'lli -compact operators and indi ces
19 . ORLICl SPACES AND I RREDUCIBLE OPERATORS
t30 . Youn.g' s inequality
131 . Youog classes
132. The
133 . The Ban ach d ual of an Odicz space
134. The spectrum of an operator in Banach s pace
13$. The Krein- Rutma n theorem and the spe c tral radius
136. Irreducible operators
137 . Spectra l p roper t i es o f
13 8. The peripheral spectrum of irreducible pos it i ve op e rato rs CHAl'TER 20. OR·r nOM0Rl'1HSMS AND f - ALCEBRAS
139. &l ementary prope rc iea o f orthomorphi sms
140 . The s pace
141 . E~amp l es of orthomorphisms 142. Pcoperties of f- algobras
143. The stabi..li zer of a Rics2 spac e
1~ 4 .
145 . Theor ems of Radon- Nikodym type
146 . The range of an orthomorphism
In the present chapter we consider extensions and generalizations of certain results for prime ideals proved in Volume 1 . Readers interested primarily in the theory of linear mappings between Riesz spaces, in particular when it concerns normed Riesz spaces, may immediately proceed to Chapter 12. (X,e)
and L will denote a Riesz space. In section 76
. This
. The
. It follows easily that
a proper prime ideal. The definition in a Riesz space is similar but not quite the same. The non-empty subset F the zeroelement is not in F furthermore u,v E F+ and
. The dual
. The main
theorem i s due to G . Birkhoff (1933) and M.H.
.
is empty. This
proved again independently by several other mathematicians (J. Hashimoto, 1952; S . J .
Bernau, 1972). A similar theorem holds in a Riesz space. The
prime ideal extension theorem (cf. Theorem 51.8 for for L ) is an easy corollary.
. For any
. Thesets
hull-kernel topology. It will be proved that this is a T -topology such that
are compact. Denoting by
. The hull-kernel topology
dual hull-kernel topology. Some properties of this topology will be discussed. We also introduce the Boolean topology in fi ; this is the weakest topology stronger than the hull-kernel topology and the dual hull{wIx
kernel topology. The collection of all
is a subbase for the open sets of the Boolean topology. (X,e)
has a unique extension to a prime ideal in the Boolean ring generated by (the Boolean ring generated by X
as a sublattice). The sublattice
.
. We
is an ideal in X ' .
monotone prime ideal extension property. By way of example, every subring of a Boolean ring is a p-sublattice. A second example is obtained by considering the lattices X(L) Riesz spaces L L'
.
. Then L'
.
.
.
there exists a number o, > 0 and an element u E L+ such that In this case, the unique extension of a given proper prime 2 u
.
ch. 1 1 1
. The
J.J. Masterson for different purposes (cf. Exercise 3 7 . 1 6 ) . that if
extension property is strictly weaker than Dedekind completeness of to the situation that (X,e)
. The results on unique prime
. Finally, returning
paper by W.A.J. Luxemburg (1973) According to the definition in section 2 1 the ideal A Archimedean Riesz space L
.
. This can be
the notion of strong order denseness.
does not consist only of the zeroelement. For an ideal L
then strong order denseness is a stronger condition than order denseness.
. This last result is due to
A. Bigard (1972). In section 80 we assume, for simplicity, that L' = IL (i.e., L Riesz subspace of
itself). For any ideal I in L in L' L
.
. For
(due in this case to J.J. Masterson) was already indicated in Exercise 37. 17.
sufficient condition for this is indicated, as follows. If Archimedean, L
Ch. 1 1 1
following main theorem. If
has the projection property. For the special case that
result is due to K.K. Kutty
and 3 . Quinn (1972).
another prime extension theorem. Every proper prime ideal in a sublattice
.
contains a unique minimal prime ideal. It will be shown that X is d x A y = 0 implies X = {x) v {yjd , and also if
holds for any pair of different minimal prime p2 d ideals. Similar conditions (i.e., L = {u} + {vId if u A v = 0 and
.
contained in a unique maximal ideal. We shall prove that a topological space is normal or extremally disconnected (in the usual topological sense)
if and only if the lattice of its closed subsets is normal o r extremally disconnected in the sense as defined here. The lattice
is extremally disconnected. Similarly
L ) containing a prime ideal is prime itself.
Another one is that the family of all proper prime ideals containing a given proper prime ideal is linearly ordered by inclusion. Every Riesz space is completely extremally disconnected, but not every lattice (X,e)
. Finally,
is normal. A necessary and sufficient condition is that the
family of a l l prime ideals contained in a given proper prime ideal is linearly ordered by inclusion. Another condition is that X = w 1 V w 2 holds for any pair of incomparable proper prime ideals. Complete normality in a Riesz space is defined by these last conditions. Finally, if
i s normal and completely extremally disconnected, then X is completely norma.1. Similarly for a Riesz space. Hence, any normal Riesz space is
Ch. 111
completely normal. It will be shown by examples that all situations considered in the theory can really occur. Some of the results in this section are due to A.A. Monteiro (1954) and some (independently) to W.H. Cornish (1972). It is not without some importance, finally, to observe that the analogy with commutative rings goes still farther than indicated in section 52 (52.6,
52.14 and 52.15) and section 78 (78.16 and 78.17).
regular semi-prime rings are of interest in this respect (the commutative there exists an element r E R
nilpotent elements). The following theorems hold. A. R
B. R is regular if and only if R in R
for some ideal J ) .
is a maximal ideal.
C. If R
conditions are equivalent. (i)
is a maximal ideal.
is a minimal prime ideal.
of all proper prime ideals are open and closed. (iv)
is Hausdorff. is a T -topology. 1
is regular.
D. If R
conditions are equivalent. (i)
ideal. (ii)
prime ideals. (iv)
(x:rx=O) ) .
contains a unique minimal prime ideal.
.
and D with Theorems 37.6 and 82.5-82.7.
details we refer to C.B. Huiismans ("21, 1974).
[Ch. 11,576
76. Prime i d e a l s e p a r a t i o n A s i n Chapter I ,
. We
. According t o t h i s d e f i n i t i o n of X . The lower s u b l a t t i c e S
. As
i s n o t p r o p e r l y included i n any o t h e r lower s u b l a t t i c e .
...
.
x,, x E D that x A A x # 8 n 1 lower s u b l a t t i c e has t h e f i n i t e i n t e r s e c t i o n
property. There i s another fundamental n o t i o n which we s h a l l d e f i n e now. The subset
.
I n o t h e r words, a dual i d e a l i s anon-empty property ( i v ) . In algebraic discussions
b u t i n s e t theory one more o f t e n speaks about a f i l t e r . Note t h a t t h e i n t e r s e c t i o n of a family of dual i d e a l s i s e i t h e r empty o r it i s again a dual ideal.
i s c a l l e d maximal whenever i t i s n o t p r o p e r l y i s a maximal dual i d e a l i f
included i n any o t h e r d u a l i d e a l . Obviously, F and only i f
i s a maximal lower s u b l a t t i c e .
. Proper
prime d u a l i d e a l s a r e r e l a t e d , a s shown by t h e following theorem. THEOREM 76.1.
i s a prime dual i d e a l . Hence, I F = X-I
i s a maximal dual i d e a l (ef.
Theorem 5.4 ( i ) ) . PROOF. We sketch one h a l f of t h e proof. Let w i t h complement
. Evidently,
F. I f
Ch. 11.§761
i s an i d e a l ) . This shows a l r e a d y
i s a dual i d e a l . Finally, x
i s prime). Also, x E F
i s an i d e a l ) . Hence,
i s prime. If
. Note
( i t ) t h a t any x -maximal i d e a l i s prime. 0 Dually, i f F i s a dual i d e a l i n X denote t h e s e t of a l l
. To
. It
f o r a given xo n o t i n 0 w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e p r o p e r t y of not c o n t a i n i n g that
. Then
i t i s a g a i n a d u a l i d e a l which i s t h e n a p p r o p r i a t e l y c a l l e d t h e d u a l i d e a l and
. The d u a l
.
F 'is now c a l l e d x -maximal f o r a 0 n o t i n F whenever xo i s c o n t a i n e d i n (F,yO) f o r any y 0 I n o t h e r words, F i s not p r o p e r l y included i n any o t h e r d u a l
.
dual i d e a l . We g e n e r a l i z e t h e d e f i n i t i o n s of an x -maximal i d e a l and an x -maximal 0 0 I and t h e non-empty lower s u b l a t t i c e F such
dual i d e a l . Given t h e i d e a l that I
empty. Note t h a t i f
F ' = (y:y2x f o r some x E F) ), t h e n i s F'-maximal.
i d e a l , which makes t h e d e f i n i t i o n more symmetric. This becomes even more e v i d e n t i f we compare t h e d e f i n i t i o n of an F-maximal
f o l l o w i n g d e f i n i t i o n of an I-maximal d u a l i d e a l . Given a g a i n t h e i d e a l and t h e dual i d e a l
i s empty.
i s prime.
.
(ii) Let 1 be a proper i d e a l i n X i n X is prime. (iii) Let
.
.
Ch. 11,5761
{ e l t h i s i s the weZZ-known f a c t t h a t if F i s a x i s not i n F , there e x i s t s y E F such
PROOF.
.
xo (cf. Theorem 5.1 (ti)).
. The proof
. The
.
.
p, v y E F ' for some p1 E P Similarly, p2 v z E F ' for some p 2 E P Setting p3 = p1 v p 2 , we have p E P with p v y and p3 v z in F' 3 Hence
. Hence
. Hence, f3
. Contradiction, since
is prime.
.
.
.
. Hence
is empty. It follows that
. Similarly,
. The
is also in i s empty.
is prime. is not in the I-maximal dual ideal F , the set
.
.
Ch. 11,5761
The prime ideal separation theoremwhich follows now is an immediate consequence. The theorem occurs in the famous paper by M.H. Stone ([11,1937, Theorem 6) on distributive lattices. The result stated in the theorem is essentially due to G. Birkhoff ([l1,1933,Theorem 2 1 . 1 ) .
been rediscovered, in one form or another, by several other mathematicians (for example, J. Hashimoto [11,1952; S . J . Bernau C21,1972). We first recall
THEOREM 76.3 (Prime ideal separation). I f
.
i s empty.
Actually, there e x i s t s an F-maximal prime ideal satisfying these conditions, m d there also e x i s t s an I-minimal prime ideal satisfying these conditions. PROOF. Consider the set of all ideals J
is empty. It follows from Z o m ' s lemma that this set has a maximal element w
. By
.
is empty. It follows from Zorn's lemma that this set has a maximal element
. By
. It follows that
n F is empty.
Stone's original formulation of the theorem is as follows. Given the proper ideal
A 2 F .
The prime ideal extension theorem, already proved in Theorem 5 1 . 8 , may be regarded as an immediate corollary of the prime ideal separation theorem. THEOREM 76.4 (Prime ideal extension). I f
i s a sub2attice of the i s a proper prime ideal i n X , such that w ' n x = w (X,t?)
.
Ch. 11,5761
PROOF. The s e t generated i n
i s a lower s u b l a t t i c e . Furthermore, t h e i d e a l
i s empty. Hence,
by t h e prime i d e a l s e p a r a t i o n theorem, t h e r e e x i s t s a prime i d e a l such t h a t
i s empty. It follows from
. This
i f desired.
. The
. As
concludes t h e proof.
We b r i e f l y d i s c u s s t h e corresponding n o t i o n s i n a Riesz space d e f i n e d i n s e c t i o n 3 3 , any s u b s e t
included i n any o t h e r lower s u b l a t t i c e . We a l s o i n t r o d u c e t h e n o t i o n of a
dual i d e a l . The s u b s e t
.
lower s u b l a t t i c e w i t h t h e e x t r a p r o p e r t y ( i v ) . The d u a l i d e a l
maximal whenever it i s n o t p r o p e r l y included i n any o t h e r dual i d e a l . Obviously, F
lower s u b l a t t i c e . The dual i d e a l follows from is i n
.
I t can be proved s i m i l a r l y a s i n Theorem 76.1 t h a t t h e complement
.
. Conversely,
i s a proper prime i d e a l . It was proved i n Theorem 3 3 . 7 t h a t
i s t h e same d e f i n i t i o n as i n t h e l a t t i c e case. The proof t h a t any F-maximal
Ch. 11,1761
i d e a l i s prime i s a l s o t h e same a s i n t h e l a t t i c e case. Given t h e i d e a l we say t h a t
i s empty. A maximal
i d e a l c o n s i s t i n g of t h e zeroelement only. The next theorem, s t a t i n g t h a t dual i d e a l i s prime, i s now analogous to p a r t s ( i i ) and ( i i i )
of Theorem 76.2. THEOREM 76.5. Let
. ALSO,
PROOF. It w i l l be s u f f i c i e n t t o show t h a t the complement
a prime i d e a l . It i s evident t h a t and
. By what
. Now,
i n common). It follows t h a t
. We
. Hence,
. Also,
.
. Then m y
I.
. As
i s then prime.
The prime i d e a l s e p a r a t i o n theorem and t h e prime i d e a l extension theorem follow now, e x a c t l y a s i n t h e l a t t i c e case. The analogy between i d e a l s ( i n p a r t i c u l a r p r i m e i d e a l s ) i n a d i s t r i b u tive lattice
t h e following remarks. Given a Riesz space
. Let
. Note
. For
) . Evidently, X(L)
as smallest element.
)-maximal ideals and prime ideals onto prime ideals. Also, rhe
Ch. 11,5761
. Finally, note that the inverse image of
non-zero multiple of each of its elements.
The analogy is not complete, however. In theorem 52.4 it was proved that prime ideal extension for Riesz spaces is monotone in the following sense. If
.
A similar result does not always hold in the lattice case. Indeed, let w1
. Assume, furthermore, that
. Then
in another one. That a distributive lattice is embedded in a Boolean ring (even i n a Boolean algebra) is exactly the situation that occurs in the Stone representation theorem, where a given distributive lattive embedded in the Boolean algebra of all subsets of the set i2 prime ideals in X
. For a
76.14 at the end of the present section.
Ch. 11,5761
EXERCISE 76.6.
. Show
is prime. Next, show that if
is empty.
This prime ideal separation result is known as Iirull's lemma. EXERCISE 76.7.
ideal I is completely prime if and only if EXERCISE 76.8.
space as in earlier chapters. The set
. The set
hull-kernel topology. We recall that, by Corollary 3 5 . 4 , the kernel d Now, let satisfies k({P} ) = (AU) = {uId k({P)U) = n (P:PE{P}u) {PIu
.
. We have
. Write
EXERCISE 76.9. by
{ u p . Show that
. Since o,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
L is Archimedean.
Archimedean. HINT: The intersection Q' = Q fl A, principal ideal A
.
.
Ch. 11,9761
AU that is u-maximal. Hence, Q" is a prime ideal in A, , and so can be This extended (even uniquely by Theorem 52.2 (ii)) to a prime ideal in L prime ideal is properly larger than Q diction. Hence, Q'
. Conversely, by
.
. By
u (cf. Theorem 27.5).
.
. . Contra-
i.e., if and only if there i s at least one u-maximal ideal not containing the element
EXERCISE 76.10. by
. Note
.
.
.
.
EXERCISE 76.11.
. But
.
We generalize the preceding exercise. Let u,v
. Note
. Denote
. Show that
. It
v-maximal. Equivalently, Q,,,
.
S may be empty .(for example, if u I v ) . Show that u,v k(SU,v) = {inf(u,v)Id , where it is understood that the kernel of the empty
Ch. 1 1 , 5761
. Show that
are empty. Assume,
. Observe now
(i.e., the set of all u-maximal ideals not containing w ) .
EXERCISE 76.12.
R the set of all u-maximal ideals Q such that v is u,v contained in any ideal properly larger than Q (it is possible that v is
already contained in Q ) . Show that k(R in
. The result that
) = {uId and R is dense u,v is due to A. Bigard and
K. Keimel (Cl1,Lemma 4 ) . R is the set of all u-maximal ideals Q such that u,v is contained in any ideal properly larger than Q , i.e.,
is the set of all ideals that are u-maximal as well as w-maximal. EXERCISE 76.13.
.
.
,... . In the general case, assume that u > 0 is a . There are two cases: u in F+ or u not in F+ . If u E F+ , then u = inf(v:vEF+) . But this is impossible since 1. < u and 1. is still in F+ . If u is not in F+ , then inf(u,v) = 0 for some v E F+ . But u 5 v since u is a lower bound of F+ . Hence u = inf(u,v) = 0 , contradicting u > 0 . It follows that u = 0 is the only lower bound of F+ in L+ . u
EXERCISE 76.14. different elements
largest element, and furthermore xo < x 1 and page 16). Show that
{ e l is a prime ideal. Show that there are two
w 1 = w2 nor Show that by adding yo,yl and y2 as in the diagram, X is 2 c w1 embedded in (obviously) the smallest Boolean algebra B(X) containing X
.
.
.
EXERCISE 76.15. Let
.
. Define
Ch. 11,5761
. Show that that g-f E C . Show
L , (ii) L has the Riesz decomposition property, (iii) L is an anti-lattive (i.e., sup(f,g) exists if and only if f 20 g or f 0 5 g for
. The cases
. Then
).
.
Ch. 11,1761
. Hence
.
.
.
inf(v-ul,v-u2) EXERCISE 76.16.
ordered vector space with the Riesz decomposition property, but not a Riesz space. Here is another example. Let
. It
.
is not a Riesz space. This is Problem 5882
in the Am. Math. Monthly (1972), due to E.S. Langford. HINT: Given that u1+u2 ;nvl;2 existence of C.W.. = v 1 1~
w.. (i,j=1,2) 1J
define w.. 1J
.
.
w.. (x)
= u.
if w(x) # 0 and w. .(x)
u. (x)v.(x)w-'(x) 1
. Exactly as
if w(x) = 0 It remains to prove that w is everywhere differentiable. ij Hence, let If w(xo) # 0 , then w ij is differentiable at xo a < x < b and w(xo) = 0 , s o ui(xo) = v.(x ) = 0 and u!(x ) = 0 and
.
.
U. (X +h) 1
. Then, for
w.. (x ) 1J
u. (x +h) v. (xo+h) 1
. This shows that
EXERCISE 76.17.
continuously differentiable functions on is still continuous. Show that
has the Riesz decomposition property. It
Ch. 11,9761
can be proved that the same holds for the space of twice continuously differentiable functions on
differentiable functions, but not for the space of three times continuously differentiable functions (A. Nagel and W. Rudin [ I ] ,
1974).
HINT: Determine the derivative w! in a point x where w(x) lj by means of the ordinary differentiation formula, and show that if w(xo)
EXERCISE 76.18.
composition property which makes it more evident why the property is also called the Riesz interpolation property (cf. Exercise 15.12). ordered vector space L
if L has the property that for any systems fl,...,f and g l ,...,gm n satisfying g. 5 f for i = I , m and j = I , ,n there exists an 1 j element f E L such that g. 5 f 5 fj for all i and j
...
.
. Assume
.
f for i,j = 1,2 Set u . = f.-g. (i=1,2) , v I = fl-g2 and j 1 1 1 f2-gl Then u1+u2 = vl+v2 , so there exist wij (i,j=l,2) such that
.
(see the diagram). It follows easily that
element. The proof in the converse direction will also be evident.
Ch. 11,1771
77. The hull-kernel topology and the dual hull-kernel topology
. For reasons of
a Riesz space is quite similar. The elements of the elements of w
x,y,...
. We
respectively. For any non-empty subset S
. For any
. The
for the hull-kernel topology (briefly hk-topology) in R ; the closure of any given subset in R
. The hull-kernel
(cf. Theorem 7.3 for the lattice case and Theorem 36.3 for the case of a Riesz space). Let A
. In the case of
.
This extra condition is included here since we desire to have the situation that the set theoretic complement of
lattice case this holds without any extra condition, by Theorem 76.1. return to the lattice case. For every x E X { h I x = (A:hEA,xEh)
. In the We
. is empty, and
. It follows that the mapping
is a lattice isomorphism.
We define hulls and kernels similarly as for prime ideals. Explicitely, if
.
.
Theorem 6 . 2 ) t h a t
I t can be proved now e x a c t l y as f o r prime i d e a l s ( c f . S = h(D)
.
. Note
.
Ch. 11,1773
i t s e l f as a subbase f o r t h e c l o s e d s e t s i n t h e topology.
A c t u a l l y t h i s i s a b a s e f o r t h e topology, s i n c e any f i n i t e union of s e t s of t h e form the hull
i s a g a i n of t h e same form. For any s u b s e t
.
THEOREM 77.1. For any s u b s e t For this reason, fhk-topology)
is h(k(S)).
. But
. Then
i . e . , h(D)
.
PROOF. S
i s c l o s e d in t h e j u s t i n t r o d u c e d topology. Conversely, every
.
.
Ch. 11,1771
THEOREM 77.2. The hull-kernel topology in
PROOF. I f
are compact.
. Similarly
t h e topology i s a T -topology. 0
. If
, i . e . , t h e set t h e o r e t i c complement of f X I x , , so ({X}x)c i s a neighborhood of X2 not
. Hence,
i s compact. The s e t s
a r e then a l s o compact. Note f i r s t t h a t t h e s e t s
ness proof i t i s s u f f i c i e n t , t h e r e f o r e , t o show t h a t any covering of
these base s e t s has a f i n i t e subcovering. L e t
i s non-empty.
... A
.
has t h e f i n i t e i n t e r s e c t i o n property, i . e . ,
... A
. This
has t h e f i n i t e i n t e r s e c t i o n property. It follows
.
Hence, i s then a maximal dual i d e a l , we have D C Xo E A Xo the i n t e r s e c t i o n n ({XIY:y€D) contains ho , s o t h i s i n t e r s e c t i o n i s
non-empty.
i s compact. Am
c o n s i s t i n g of a l l maximal dual i d e a l s .
. Then
f i n i t e i n t e r s e c t i o n property. Hence, t h e r e e x i s t
. Let
Ch. 11,8771
.
is a lower sublattice. Hence, we have x2 E X2 and {XIx2 are closed sets in the hk-topology of
, say.
. Since
. It X
X i respectively, such that the intersection of {XI and i s empty. Hence, {XIx1 is a closed set containing and not XI
. It follows that
is a T -topology. Furthermore, the space Am 1
in its hk-topology; the proof is the same as above (note that Xo last proof is an element of A
). We have, therefore, the following theorem.
THEOREM 77.3. The hull-kernel topology i n
T -topology. 1
From Theorem 7 6 . 1 it follows immediately that the mapping
. The subset
of all minimal prime ideals. The image
. Hence
. The mapping
to be a base for the closed sets. The topology generated thus in
is called the dual hull-kernel topology in il (briefly the dhk-topology). THEOREM 7 7 . 4 . The dual hu1l-ksrne1 topology i n
i s a compact , are then To-topoZogy. The s e t s { w l x , x E X , being closed subsets of dhk-compact. Furthermore, the dual hull-kernel topology i n the s e t Rm of il
a l l minimal prime ideaZs i s a compact T1-topoZogy, ueaker then the huZ1 kernel topology i n om
.
PROOF. We have only to show that in Rm
then the hk-topology, i.e., we have to show that every dhk-closed set i s hk-closed. Any dhk-closed set in Rm
.
Ch. 11,5773
(cf. Theorem 7.4(ii)),
any intersection of these sets is hk-closed. This
is the desired result. In Exercise 77.13 it will be indicated how to prove that the hk-topology and the dhk-topology in
is a Boolean algebra.
. The sets
.
The next theorem is due to J. Hashimoto ([11,1952,Theorem THEOREM 77.5. Let
4.2).
has the f i n i t e intersection property. Then the f m i Z y has a non-empty intersection. PROOF. Note first that for T
empty this is Theorem 6.8. In the
I property. Let
empty). We show that F n I is empty. This is trivially true if If F n I is non-empty, there exist elements x l , y l ,...,y
... A
...
.
Ch. 1 1 , 9 7 7 1
contradicting the finite intersection hypothesis. Hence F n I is empty, so
. But
This is the desired result. THEOREM 7 7 . 6 . Let
. Then any
is campact in the dhk-topology. For
compact in the hk-topology. PROOF. We may assume that A open covering of A
is non-empty. Let
in the dhk-topology. Then A
non-empty. Hence, by the preceding theorem, there is a finite
intersection that is already empty (note that this finite intersection must contain at least one
{ w } ~). It follows that for appropriate '1
. This shows that
2.
dhk-compact. The proof that A
is non-empty is similar.
R is dhk-compact. is hk-compact.
COROLLARY 77.7. (i) Every hk-closed subset of R
(ii) Every dhk-closed proper subset of PROOF. (i) Every hk-closed subset of is of the form n ({W}~:~€T) with
T non-empty. In both cases the set is
dhk-compact. (ii) Every dhk-closed subset A of the form A
non-empty. If A
is now hk-compact.
is impossible. Hence, by the
Ch. 11,9771
The next theorem, which is of a topological nature, will be of great importance for the proof of the unique prime ideal extension from a distributive lattice
. We
have to deal with a T -space possessing a base of open and closed sets. 0
Note that in this case the space is Hausdorff. Indeed, if x
different points in the space, then one of the points, say x , has a neighborhood V
THEOREM 77.8.
.
. The
contains all s e t s of N , i s a BooZean ring with respect t o ordinary s e t t h e o r e t i c
union and intersection. Then the Stone representation space of the space
.
PROOF. Given any xo E X
.
.
. For this purpose, let A = B(N)-Iu be the . Since A is a dual ideal it has the finite intersection property, i.e., fly Ai # 0 for A ,,...,A E h . Given AO,AI,...,A E A , the sets .A n A. (i=l,...,n) are relatively closed n subsets of the compact set A. with (A nA.) # 0 . It follows that 0 1 A E
is non-empty. We show that
consists of only one point. If not, there exist points xo,yo E S with
. Hence, there exist disjoint neighborhoods respectively such that A 1 and
.
) . Now, let
. The dual so
.
B E A ' ) . Furthermore, since
. This shows already that
Ch. 11,8771
. Proper inclusion, however, is impossible,
since in a Boolean ring dual prime ideals are maximal. Hence, S
of one point. It has been proved thus that there is a one-one correspondence between the prime ideals w A:AEB(N),x
. Hence
corresponds to (x:x not in A ) . But then This shows that the base sets to the base sets
.
are homeomorphic. We return to the situation that smallest element 8
.
topology stronger than the hk-topology and the dhlc-topology. This is called the Boolean topology (briefly 5-topology) in B
. The family
is a subbase for the open sets of the 5-topology. Note that { u } ~= R
included in the subbase. Note also that the
Ch. 11,5771
sets in the subbase are closed as well as open. The family of open and closed sets
is a base for the open sets in the 8-topology. There is a somewhat smaller
base. Indeed, since
is also a base. All sets in this base are open and closed. We prove that they are compact as well. It will be sufficient to show that every
is compact. For the proof (due to S . J . Bernau,C21,1972) we shall need Alexander's subbase theorem, stating that if the subset A
space has the property that every covering by sets of a subbase (for the open sets) has a finite subcovering, than A
proof of Alexander's subbase theorem, cf. for example the book by J.L. Kelley, General Topology, Ch. 5,Theorem 6 ) . In our case, let U B be a covering of
n (n Bc) is empty. This intersection is of the form n{w}xn{wjY:xEs,yET
. Hence, this intersection being
empty, a finite intersection must already be empty by Theorem 77.5, i.e., {w),~
has a finite subcovering. The sets in the base
Ch. 11,5771
and, therefore, open, closed and compact. Furthermo
and hence is Hausdorff. According to the preceding theorem, the space
space of the Boolean ring of its own open, closed and compact subsets. There is a possibly smaller Boolean ring of open, closed and compact sets
. The family of
.
indication of the proof that S is indeed a Boolean ring, cf. Exercise
77.16). Note that all sets in S are open, closed and compact. Hence, il
s.
with the 6-topology is homeomorphic to the Stone representation space of Once more, we make some topological remarks. The non-empty subset Y
such that 0 n Y and 0 n Y are non-empty it 1 2 follows that 0 f7 0 n Y is non-empty. In other words, Y is irreducible 1 2 if and only if for each pair of closed subsets FI,F2 of X such that subsets O 1
. Evidently, Y is irreducible if and only if for each finite family 0 1 , ...,0 of open subsets of X such that 0. n Y is non-empty for i = I, ...,n it follows it follows that Y c F 1 or Y c F2
0 . ) fl Y
follows that Y c F.
1,. ..,n
consisting of one point is irreducible. If X
.
one point. Every (relatively) open subset of an irreduaible set is also irreducible. If space X I and Y
. For the proof, let FI,F2 be closed sets . Then the inverse images Q -1 (F1) and
. Hence
is irreducible. It follows
Y 1 is irreducible.
Ch. 11,5773
THEOREM 77.9. The folZaJing conditions f o r a subset
topological space are equivalent. (i) Y i s irreducible. (ii) The closure Y of Y
is irreducible. 0 i n X the intersection
.
is open and 0 n Y and 1 on^^. (iv) Y
i s connected ( i . e . , i f
n Y non-empty, there cannot e x i s t open 01,02 such t h a t n Y are non-empty, d i s j o i n t and with union equal t o 2
has a non-empty intersection. PROOF. The equivalence of (i) and (ii) follows by observing that for
or non-empty. Now consider condition (iii). To say that, for 0 open, 0 is dense in Y
meets every other non-empty relatively open subset of Y equivalent to (i).
is irreducible. Conversely,
is not irreducible. Then there exist open
are non-empty and disjoint. This
n Y is not connected, which contradicts (iv).
Finally, (i) and (v) are evidently equivalent. The set theoretic union of a chain of irreducible subsets of irreducible. Hence, by Zorn's lemma, every irreducible subset of contained in a maximal irreducible set. Evidently (since Y
is irreducible) every maximal irreducible set is closed.
hk-topology). THEOREM 77.10.
there e x i s t s a prime ideal ( i . e . , Y consists of a l l
.
i s closed and irreducible if and only i f such t h a t Y i s the closure {w0}- of wo 1. Hence, Y i s a rnmirnal irreducible
Ch. 11,1771
PROOF. (i) Let first k(Y) non-empty. Then x
be prime. Let
be closed and irreducible. Then k(Y)
. But
. It follows that
.
. Hence, all
is irreducible. Let us call this prime ideal wo
. Hence, there exists a prime ideal . It follows that x A y is not in
. If
is irreducible.
be irreducible. In order to show that k(Y)
and so this intersection is non-empty. It follows that Y
. This implies that, for at
.
is closed. Hence, every
.
Y is irreducible.
Note that since a prime ideal may contain several different minimal prime ideals, it may occur that two different maximal irreducible subsets of have a non-empty intersection. EXERCISE 77.11.
EXERCISE 77.12.
.
. Show that
EXERCISE 77.13.
. By
. Show that the collection
Ch. 1 1 , § 7 7 1
{ v } ~ is a Boolean ring if and only if the hk-topology and the dhk-topology coincide on each { u l X Hence, the collection of a l l {u)x of all
.
. This result is due
to T.P. Speed (C11,1969).
{ u l x form a Boolean ring. Let {u}xo 0 of {u} is
fixed. We have to show that every hk-open subset (relatively) dhk-open. Any hk-open { u j Y T with
. Note now that the complement of
form a Boolean ring. Hence, the complement ' 0
. Every
are dhk-compact by Theorem 7 7 . 4 , s o all sets are (relatively) compact for the dhk-topology in
0 is (relatively) dhk-open.
is dhk-closed. Hence 0 is the intersection of
.
is arbitrary, it follows that xo are hk-compact, and so the collection of all {pix is a Boolean hk-compact. Since
ring by Corollary 8 . 3 . For the proof that the collection of all Boolean algebra if the topologies coincide on
compact in the dhk-topology (Theorem 7 7 . 4 ) . Hence, if the topologies coincide, then $2, all
is then a Boolean algebra (Theorem 8 . 4 ) .
EXERCISE 7 7 . 1 4 . Let X
is introduced by defining that the open sets are the empty set and all subsets of
X possessing a finite complement. Show that X is an
irreducible Tl-space. EXERCISE 7 7 . 1 5 . Let X element 0
. Show that if
in the hull-kernel topology. The converse does not hold; the lattice in Exercise 7 6 . 1 4 is a counterexample. EXERCISE 7 7 . 1 6 . Let and y
.
. Show that
Ch. 11,5781
theoretic union and intersection, the empty set is the smallest element of and the set theoretic difference of two sets in
is again in S ) .
. Note now
.
. It follows that
.
s.
78. The unique prime ideal extension property
be a sublattice. It was proved in Theorem 51.8 that
. The
.
example; for this very simple lattice every proper prime ideal can be uniquely extended to a prime ideal in the Boolean ring generated by the lattice. This holds generally. We present the proof. THEOREM 78.1.
PROOF. As before, let R
).
.
. Note
now that, by the Stone representation, X is isomorphic to the family of all {wIx Hence, identifying the point x E X with {wlx for every x E X ,
.
Ch.
the Stone representation space of explained there). Theorem 77.8,
(cf. Exercise 77.16). It follows by Theorem 77.8 that
. According to
that do not contain w 1 Conversely, any collection of all finite unions of this kind is the
.
. The points
.
. This shows that
. Hence
It may be useful to note that even though in general the points of cannot be uniquely written as finite unions of sets
.
.
. Indeed, I' l X c w
the following definition.
in the following sense. Given
. In view of
. The extension procedure is monotone
, prime ideal exension i s unique.
DEFINITION 78.2. The s u b l a t t i c e
Ch. 11,§781
(X',8) i s said t o have the monotone prime i d e a l extension property whenever f o r every i d e a l I' i n X ' and every proper prime idea2
.
. As
at the same time fail to be monotone (cf. Exercise 7 6 . 1 4 ) . For simplicity, assume now first that the ideal generated in the larger lattice X '
. As
itself. We shall indicate this a consequence, every proper
now in a proper prime ideal. Indeed,
. But this smallest ideal is
the hypothesis. The mapping
. The prime
is hk-continuous. We prove that if, in addition, X
the monotone prime ideal extension property, then $ THEOREM 78.3. I f
is also hk-closed.
not only hk-continuous, b u t a l s o hk-closed. PROOF. Let F' c R' @(F')
be hk-closed. We have to show that the image
is also closed. Since F' = h(k(F'))
.
Ch.
. satisfies X fl k(F') c w
.
. This
.
is hk-closed.
We now combine monotonicity and uniqueness of the extension. THEOREM 78.4. ?'he sub2attice (X',e)
PROOF. If X
.
and monotone, as already observed earlier in this section. For the proof of the converse, assume that X
. Then
. Hence, we may
. The mapping
extension the mapping is now one-one. Hence, since the extension is $
. Given
. By
. Hence
.
Ch. 11,9781
.
.
For later use it will be practical to have available a certain class of sublattices possessing the monotone prime ideal extension property. The following definition will be useful for this purpose. (X,e) of the d i s t r i b u t i v e l a t t i c e i s called a p-sublattice of X ' whenever f o r a l l x,y E X and y' E X' such t h a t y = x v y' and f o r e v e q proper prime i d e a l w ' i n X ' such t h a t y' E w ' there e x i s t s an element z E w ' n X s a t i s f y i n g DEFINITION 78.5. The s u b l a t t i c e
y = x v z . Note that every ideal X z =
satisfies the condition mentioned in the definition. It is also
.
THEOREM 78.6. Every p-sublattice
(X',e) has the montone prime i d e a l extension property. PROOF. Let
. We have w'
. To
. We prove first that
this will be the greatest part of the proof. By means of Zorn's lemma it follows from
is prime. If not, there exist x',y' E X'
. Hence
. But
.
. From the maximality
.
Ch. 11,§781
is prime. Assume now that J' fl X
. Since
. Hence y' v z' . But
.
. Thus we
= w ).
. On
.
is prime.
. This contradicts the hypothesis that = w .
suchthat x v y = y v z . B u t x
. Then there
is empty.
. It remains to prove that w ' . It follows from F fl w ' =
implies w = X fl J' c X fl w ' .
This concludes the proof.
In theorem 7 8 . 4 it was proved that the sublattice (X,e)
. The last theorem shows that every p-sublattice has
automatically the monotone prime ideal extension property. The following statement is, therefore, an imediate consequence. THEOREM 78.7. The p-sublattice (X',0)
.
We recall (cf. section 76) that the distributive lattice of all principal ideals in the Riesz space L
. As
. If X(L)
. Nevertheless, we
.
Ch. 11,9781
The following theorem showsnow that p-sublattices occur frequently. Note first that if we say that (B,9) is a subring of theBooleanring (B',B), this means that elen?ent 9
.
holding for all f E L Hence, for 1 I p < every order bounded P is an integral represented by a function in L linear functional on L P 9 For p = m not every order bounded linear functional is an integral, but those that are integrals are represented by an L -function, as will follow 1
from a general theorem whcih will be proved in the next section. EXERCISE 84.6.
is order separable, s o any a Dedekind complete space M that every operator from L
is order continuous by Theorem 84.4. Show into M
deriving it from the general results above or immediately from the matrix representation.
Ch. 12,1851
85. The order dual of a Riesz space
is a Dedekind complete Riesz space. It is evident that if L
consists only of the null functional. It i s perhaps disappointing at first that also if L
functional. We present two standard examples. EXAMPLE 85.1.
(The space M(r) (X,p) ). Let
a-finite countably additive and non-negative measure in the non-empty point set X
El that the set theoretic difference E-El is of measure zero). Lebesgue
measure in the real line is an example. As on earlier occasions, let M(r)
everywhere equal functions, and with p-almost everywhere pointwise ordering). We shall prove that every positive linear functional on M(r) is identically zero, i.e., {M(r)}" We note first that if and
.
...
and if furthermore the measurable subsets E (n=l,Z, ) of E satisfy n Indeed, if we should have En 4 E , then $(ux ) > 0 for some n En $(uxE ) = 0 for all n , then F = E-E satisfies ~ ( U X ) = a for all n n Fn n , and hence the function
.
...
leads to a contradiction.
finitely many terms of CT ux differ from zero. A s a first consequence Fn of what has been proved we find that if ,$ is a positive linear functional on M(r) such that +(u) > 0 for some u E {M(r)}+ , then $(uxE) > 0 for some set E
of finite measure. Now, since 1-1
.
Ch. 12,5851
. Then
.
. This is impossible, and hence there does
= 1,2,..
functional. EXAMPLE 85.2. (The space L ; 0 < p < 1 ) . Let u be a countably P additive and non-negakive measure in the non-empty point set X such that p(X)
does not possess any atoms. Furthermore, let p
. The collection of
L (compare Example 11.2(vi)). Functions that are u-almost P equal are identified, as before. It is evident that every f E L is P is a subset of the Riesz finitevalued u-almost everywhere, and hence L P space M(~)(x,~) . We observe first that
is linear, and hence f,g E L * it follows immediately that L P' P It is sufficient for the desired is an ideal in the space M(r)(X,A)
.
e b + ' .
(cf. also Exercise 7 1 . 9 ) . be a positive linear functional on
.
L It will be proved P that @ is the null functional, and for this purpose we first show that there exists a finite constant C > 0 such that @(u) 2 C holds for all Now, let $
Ch. 12,1851
.
.
. But
. This leads to a contradiction. Hence there exists a
.
It follows that if 0 5 u 4 u E L , then $(un) I. $ ( u ) for all u € L+ P P There exists a sequence Assume now that $ ( u ) > 0 for some un€ L+ P of step functions (s (x):n=l,Z, ...) , each s vanishing outside a set n of finite measure, such that 0 5 s 4 u , and so (by the result n established above) there is a step function s ( x ) 2 0 such that $ ( s ) > 0
.
. Let
1 El does not have any atoms there exists at least one E l having these properties. Generally, for n = 2,3, , let En be a subset of En-]
...
.
. We set
. On the other hand we have
... . This shows that
the null functional.
.
.
Ch. 1 2 , 9 8 5 1
Note that in these examples the situation is different as soon as 1-1 has at least one atom, because then there exists a nonzero positive linear functional. Given the order bounded linear functional $ relatively uniformly to zero, we have
.
-.
($(u ) : n = l , 2 , n (un:n=l , 2 , . .) in L+
(un:n=l , 2 , .
.
is order bounded. Precisely, we
have the following theorem. THEOREM 85.3. The Zinear functional
i s order bounded i f (un:n=O, 1.2,. .) i n L+
(fn:n=l , 2 , .
.. )
,... . Hence,
.
zero. PROOF. Let $
... . We have
I $ (v) I :05V5U is bounded. Assuming this to be false, there exists an element uo E L+ that
.
Ch. 12,1851
. Hence, w 1 =
I are both finite, since this would contradict the formula (1). first of these numbers is case denote w I by
. Then
.
. We
for n = 1,2,.
.. . By hypothesis, however, a
. We
. The definition of
Riesz norm is similar. The familiar norms on spaces Lp(X,p)
Ch. 12,1851
are Riesz norms. More generally, the norms on Orlicz spaces (cf. section 10) and the function norms on normed KEthe spaces (cf. section 9) are Riesz norms. Also, the uniform norm on the space of all real continuous functions on a topological space is a Riesz norm. Orlicz spaces will be discussed more
in detail in sections 131-133. (i) If
THEOREM 8 5 . 4 .
is a Riesz seminorm on L such t h a t l$(f)l 5 p(f) hoZds f o r a l l $ is order bounded, i . e . , $ E L" . (ii) Conversely, i f E L" is given, then p(f) = 191 (If/) is a
only i f there e x i s t s a nonzero Riesz seminorm on PROOF. (i) For every
.
.
is order bounded by definition (cf. Definition 8 3 . 2 ) . Evident.
. Conversely, if
$(auo) = a p ( u o ) is then a nonzero positive linear functional on the Riesz subspace of all real multiples of uo such that I$(auo) I 5 p(auo) holds for all real a to all of $
. By the Hahn-Banach extension theorem
is order bounded by part (i). Then
. Hence,
Ch. 12,5851
.
Theorem 83.6.
In the proof of part (iii) of the last theorem we could also have used Theorem 83.17 (extension of a positive operator majorized by a sublinear operator
is absolute and monotone). Note that a sublinear
is also absolute and monotone is exactly a Riesz seminorm on specializing Theorem 83.17 to the case that M
. Hence,
we get the following theorem. THEOREM 85.5. (Extension of a p o s i t i v e linear functional). Let
a Riesz seminom on L and l e t $ be a p o s i t i v e linear functiona2 on the K of L such that l $ ( f ) l 5 p(f) holds f o r a l l f E K Then there e x i s t s a p o s i t i v e linear functional J, on L such t h a t J1 =
.
.ern .
.
. Then
.ern . For
is a norm bounded poiitive linear functional on ( c ) . It
is easily seen that there exists a sequence u .I. 0 in (c) such that n for all n , so $ is not order continuous on (c). It follows
is not order continuous. Hence, if
.
(Xn:n=l ,2,. .) of positive measure. The role of (c)
can now be taken over by the Riesz subspace of all functions f a constant value k
c s is not the null functional. The
) exists.
We briefly return to some facts touched upon already in Exercise 83.29. We recall that a
norm. If the space is norm complete, it is called a Banach lattice.
THEOREM 85.6.
i s a Banach Zattice, then L* PROOF. The norms on
respectively. For any
Cb. 12,5851
.
is a Riesz norm. I f
is order bounded by definition. This shows already that L*
. Hence, if
. Finally, if
. Conversely, it follows
.
.
. Hence, L*
by the present result. Hence L*
.
In Theorem 85.3 we have indicated a condition, necessary and sufficient foralinear functional on L to be order bounded. There are a l s o conditions which guarantee that every linear functional on L
is order bounded. The
following theorem mentions one condition of this kind. THEOREM 85.7.
bounded i f and only i f o f f i n i t e dimension.
PROOF. Assumefirsr that
is of finite dimension. Let $
Ch. 12,5851 u
. We have
,en) of atoms. There exist ' 'i.. yiei , and for any f
. Hence
B.e. 1
Conversely, assume that every linear functional on For the proof that L and let
is order bounded.
. Then
. It follows that
. But then
L is Archimedean.
is of infinite dimension. Then, for any natural number mutually disjoint elements in A,
. There exists a Hamel basis
. We may
L containing all u there exists a linear functional $ on L such that $ ( u ) = 1 n n Since $ is order bounded, we have $+(un) 2 1 for all n
.
...
. Then
... . This is
impossible. It follows that
.
Ch. 12,5853
Combining the last theorem with Theorem 6 1 . 4 , we find that the following conditions on the Riesz space L (i)
is Archimedean).
dimension. (iii) L
X such that f(x) # 0 for only finitely many points x E X, these points depending on f
.
Archimedean. (v)
L is order bounded.
Some further remarks can be made. Several authors call a Riesz space having the property that each of its quotient spaces is Archimedean a hyper-
archimedean Riesz space. We shall follow these authors in adopting this name.
It was observed by C.B. Huijsmans ([3],1976)
condition equivalent to the five conditions mentioned above, as follows. (vi)
is a projection band. (vi)
. The proof
(iii) implies (vi) is not difficult. We briefly indicate how to prove that (vi) implies (ii).
L is certainly Archimedean. As in the proof
of the last theorem, assume now that there is an element v E L+ the principal ideal A,
is of infinite dimension. Then again there exists
. Let
...) . Then E Ad
. Then
...,ak . Hence, if the
Ch. 12,1863
. This implies
...,nk , then un is disjoint from is disjoint from v . On the other hand u n is
. Hence
.
Note, finally, that by Theorem 37.5 (ii) condition (vi) is equivalent to the following condition. (vii) For every ideal A {PIA
.
EXERCISE 85.8. Let v E L+
.
.
86. Integrals on ideals of measurable functions
measure space. The Riesz space M(r) (X,A,u) of all real p-measurable M(X,p).
. The
equal functions are identified. Let L be an ideal in M(X,p) p-measurable subset E
. For
. It is possible
-.
contain any L-zero set of positive measure. For the proof we first consider the case that p(X) and let
0.
,... )
. The union
.
Em = U 1 E n is an L-zero set such that p ( E m ) = a is maximal and uniquely determined except for a u-null set.
. Then there exist mutually disjoint u-measurable = U l Xk . For each k ,
set. We prove that
\ . Then
Ch. 12,1861
is maximal. If not, then X-Em
is maximal.
. The carrier of
. As
. This is what
. In general the characteristic function of the carrier
is uniquely determined modulo null sets. We shall denote the carrier
.
. Then
. We shall prove now
shall now state and prove. Before stating the theorem, we introduce a convenient definition. Given the sequence of measurable sets Xn 4 X shall say that the measurable subset E exists a natural number n THEOREM 86.1.
(Exhaustion theorem). Let
.
.
of measurable subsets of X such t h a t Xi 4 X and ~(x;) < m for a l l n Let (P) be some property which any (xA)-bounded s e t does possess or not. I t i s understood here t h a t if one of two u-almost equal s e t s has (P) , then so has the other one. Asswne furthermore that the following hotds. (i)
.
.
possesses (P) (iii) Any (XA)-bounded s e t o f p o s i t i v e measure has a subset of p o s i t i v e measure possessing (P)
.
Ch. 12,5863
Then there e x i s t s a sequence ofmeasurabZe s e t s (Xn:n=1,2, ...) Xn + x , x, c :x for alL n and every Xn has property (P) E
PROOF. Let
. Note
.
is finite. Let
0.
. We prove
is ascending. The set Fm = Urn F satisfies ! n a = p(E) If not (i.e., if a < p ( E ) ) , the
.
. Hence
for all n , and n O sufficiently large. This contradicts
of positive measure. It follows that F a = p(E)
It follows that there exists a sequence of measurable sets such that Xn c X A , Xn
... . It may
satisfies XI-X,~x'-x, , so n n But XA-Xm 4 X-X, , s o p(X-Xm) = lim p(X'-Xn,) set X, =
is ascending. The
. Thus the sequence
.
neglected). THEOREM 86.2. For.any ideal
1. XL
PROOF. Let
.
. For any
. It is evident that the
theorem. Concerning condition (iii) we observe first that for any measurable subset E
of positive measure. Hence, there If(x)l
Ch. 1 2 , 1 8 6 1
of positive measure. Since qF5 If1 Property
E L .
theorem. The exhaustion theorem can now be applied. It follows that there exists a sequence
with the desired properties.
.
We shall now prove that an order continuous linear functional on an ideal in M(X,p)
. This
an order continuous linear functional an integral. THEOREM 8 6 . 3 . For any i n t e g r a l
. We may
determined. is a positive integral on
PROOF. It may be assumed that $
. Hence, the number
of this kind. We write A(E)
. By
. Given
, we have $(x ) f $(X,) such a set E and given that E 4 E as k + k Ek since $ is a positive integral. In other words, we have A(Ek) + A(E) , is a measure on the u-measurable subsets of X
. Hence, by
.
x"0 such that for all p-measurable subsets E of X The function no , but it is evident that by varying depends on the choice of "0
.
. Setting
Ch. 12,5861
s(x) is now a step function are measurable and (X )-bounded, then Finally, given 0 5 f E L , there exists a sequence
for every (X )-bounded set E. Hence, if s(x)
ZT ai xE. (x)
.
a step function. Then
by the theorem on integration of increasing sequences. Hence
follows immediately.
.
by Theorem 85.6. This implies that every integral on
bounded linear functional. Let L = L ( X , p ) P 1 5 p 5 and let Q be an integral on L Hence that
. Then
is a Banach lattice.
Ch. 12,1871
.
It i s well-known (and not difficult f E L P that @ is norm bounded) that now t E L (X,LJ) for q particular it follows that every integral on L_(X,w) above with t E Ll(X,u) for all
.
.
87. Integrals and singular linear functionals In the present section we continue with the investigation of the order dual
.
section 84 any sequentially order continuous element of integral and any order continuous element of L" integral. The bands in L" integrals are denoted by
functionals. We have L
Lx respectively. The elements in the
L z are called singular linear functionals.
.
. In view of
.
= L z n Lin is a band in :L Note that L" c,sn hence it is a band in L" Furthermore
.
L" = {O} if and only if L ; = L ; , i.e., if and only if every c,sn integral is a normal integral. Finally note that by the band decomposition
. Similarly for
.
Ch. 12,8871
every integral to be a normal integral. If for every principal ideal A there exists a strictly positive linear functional on order separable and so every integral on L
is normal. This holds in
particular if there exists a strictly positive linear functional on the whole of
.
. Then, by
. If
.
.
We uroceed with some examples. Let X
EXAMPLE 87.1.
therefore excluded). The order dual L" any xo E X
the null functional.
consists exclusivelv of integrals. i.e.,
. For this purpose, let 0 5 $ E L" and let un J. 0 in L . We have to show that $(u,) .C 0 . Note that u J. 0 is equivalent to monotone n pointwise convergence of un(x) to zero on X . It is no restriction of the generality to assume that u,(x) > 0 for all x E X . Assume now that L"
. This implies that
exists as a finite number. On the other hand
impossible. Hence $(un)
J.
.
m.
Li and f o r any subset E of X , l e t @ ( x E ) Evidently A i s now a non-negative o-additive measure on
.
. The measure
Ch. 12,1871
.
U y En , s a t i s f i e s $ ( f ) 2 CnE1 k an - 1 .a = k n i s impossible. I t follows i n p a r t i c u l a r t h a t t h e r e a r e only
. This
A-measure zero. There a r e now two p o s s i b l e cases, e i t h e r A(XI)
.
. Since
. Note
. i s of or
. Hence
but even a normal i n t e g r a l . If
A(E-E ) = 0 ) . Indeed, i f
1 1 of p o s i t i v e measure. S i m i l a r l y , E i = E2 U E;
and of p o s i t i v e measure. Proceeding i n t h i s manner, we o b t a i n a d i s j o i n t sequence
(En:n=l ,2,.
. This,
however, is impossible (as observed above). Hence
contains an atom. S i m i l a r l y a s above it follows now t h a t t h e number of d i f f e r e n t atoms i n
. But
.
i s t h e d i s j o i n t union of a f i n i t e number of atoms, some of which
c o n s i s t of one point and the o t h e r ones c o n s i s t of an uncountable number of
Ch. 12,9871
points. Let A
be one of the uncountable atoms. For the investigation of the
x
in A
,
(x:f(x)>a)
of these sets is of positive measure (since A example, that = A(A)
= 1
(x:f(x)>a)
. This set
$(f)
the set A and
. Let
X(A) = 1
. We write
= CY
is the disjoint
, and
(x:f(x)=a)
.
, where B 1
; n = 2,3,
Bn = (x:a+(n-l)-'tf(x)>a+n-l)
This contradicts $(f) = a
and
... . =
n0 '
is of measure zero.
(x:f(x)>a)
is of measure zero. Then
1
h(x:f(x)=a f
. Hence,
=
= (x:f(x)>a+l)
Only one of the sets B is of positive measure, say for n n so A(B ) = 1 . But then "0
It follows that
only one
is an atom). Assume, for
is of positive measure, i.e., X(x:f(x)>a)
is of the form Uy Bn
Similarly, (x:f(x)
f be a
.
=
X(A)
=
1
.
is constant A-almost everywhere on the atom A fE L
final result is now that any
is A-almost everywhere on X
.
The
equal
to a X-step function, and we may write $(f) = 1; f(xi).A(Cxi}) The functional 0
5 $ E
the corresponding measure observed already that
$
A
+
L" =:L
Zy f(Ai).A(Ai)
.
is a normal integral if and only if
does not have any uncountable atoms. It was
is normal if
h
does not have uncountable atoms.
Conversely, observe that
for any subset A of A , we have
xB
of X 4
, so
if we let B
xA , and
hence
$(xB)
run through the finite subsets 4
g(xA)
if
$
is normal,
150
i.e., A ( B ) 4 A(A) A(B)
Ch. 12,8871
INTEGRALS AND SINGULAR LINEAR FUNCTIONALS
= 0
. Note now
that if
A
for every finite subset B
do not exist uncountable atoms f o r
is an uncountable atom, then
of
A
A
if
, but
A(A)
. Hence, there
0
>
0 is normal.
As an additional remark, we observe that an infinite set X
is said
to have a measurcrble cardinal if there exists a o-additive non-negative measure and
A
A(E)
on the collection of all subsets of =
X
such that 0 < A ( X ) <
.
X
0 for every at most countable subset of
exist such a measure, then X
m
If there does not
is said to have a non-measurable cardinal.
If in the case above X has a non-measurable cardinal and A is again the on the space
measure corresponding to the positive linear functional Q L
of all real functions on
X , then it is obvious that
any uncountable atoms and hence E
Q
A
does not have
is a normal integral. It follows that
.
is now a normal integral, i.e., L" = L" = L" It is not c n known whether there exist sets having a measurable cardinal, and so it is every
L"
not known either whether in the discussion above the measure
A
really
can possess uncountable atoms. Every countably infinite set has a nonmeasurable cardinal. It is known that, under an extra assumption, there exist uncountable sets having a non-measurable cardinal. It was shown, for example, by S . Banach and C. Kuratowki ([11,1929) that, under the continuum hypothesis, the interval
(x:O<xsl)
in the real line has a non-measurable
cardinal. For further information about non-measurable cardinals we refer to S.M. Ulam ([11,1930) and A. Tarski (Cll.1962). EXAMPLE 87.2. This is a specialization of the preceding example. Let X be the set of all real numbers and on
X
. Let
L
the Riesz space of all real functions
0 be a positive linear functional on
L
with corresponding
A , as in the preceding example, and assume now that A has an Every f E L i s a A-step function, so there exists a uncountable atom A
measure
subset Af
.
of A
such that
implies A(Af) = A(A) all x E X )
> 0
. It would
. We
f
is constant on
A
in this case, and
Q
so
and
A(A-A ) = 0
f
apply this to the function f(x) = x
follow that
contradicts the hypothesis that A atom with respect to
Af
, which (for
consists of one point only, which
,
Af and therefore Af
,
is an uncountable
. Hence, there do not exist any uncountable atoms is of the form
Ch. 12,1871
.
f E L
for every
151
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
The same argument works if X
is n-dimensional real
number space l R n . A s observed in the preceding example, it follows from the s o obtained
formula for $(f)
"
is normal, i.e., L
that every integral on L
N
Lc Note that this has been proved now without using that the set of real =
numbers has a non-measurable cardinal. Note also that the space L
=
Ln. N
in this
.
Hence, order separability example is not order separable, and yet L" = L" c n of L is sufficient but not necessary for L" = Li to hold. EXAMPLE 87.3. It is not known whether there exist sets having a measurable cardinal and s o it is not known either whether in Example 87.1
. There are other examples Li . Let L be the Riesz space of all
the space LL can be properly larger than in
which LL is indeed larger than
L;
real (finitevalued) Lebeseue summable functions on denotes that
f(x)
5
g(x)
holds for all x
in
, where f
[O,ll
. Hence. we
C0,ll
5 g
do not
have identification of functions differing only on a set of measure zero. The Lebesgue integral on
L
is a positive integral in the sense of our
present definitions, but not a normal integral. There exist nonzero normal integrals as well; for any defined by
$(f)
=
f(xo)
,
xo
in C0,ll
the linear functional @
,
is a normal integral. Observe that the space L
in this example is Dedekind a-complete. It follows that Dedekind a-comnleteness nf a Riesz space L
.
does not necessarily imply that
L" = L" Of course, super Dedekind completeness of L implies :L = Li c n since super Dedekind completeness imDlies order senarability. For some remarks about the case that L examp1e
.
is Dedekind complete we refer to the next
EXAMPLE 87.4. Let X be a non-empty point set and of a l l real bounded functions on X for any
xo
all f E L
. The space
E X the linear functional
, is
$
X({x))
X >
the Riesz space
. Let
$(f) = f(xo) 0 5 $ E L"
for
. Exactly
of X , E is a o-additive non-negative measure on the collection of
the function A all subsets of
L
L
Li has nonzero elements;
, defined by
a nonzero normal integral on
as in Example 87.1, if we define A(E) =
which
,
0
$(x
)
for any subset E
. There are at most countably many points x E X for , say xI,x*,... . Hence, writing X 1 = X-U.{xil , we have
Ch. 12,5871
INTEGRALS AND SINGULAR LINEAR FUNCTIONALS
152
for every If
.
f E L
X has a non-measurable cardinal, then X I
measurable cardinal, every
f t L
,
and
X(Xl)
so
0
. This
has likewise a non-
implies that $(fXX ) 1
is now of the form
Q(f)
so
=
on
Conversely, assume that every non-negative integral Q form. We prove that in this case X such that 0 < A ( X ) <
X
countable subset E
of
A (i.e., h(f)
corresponding to
m
. Denoting by
X
=
4
x E X
u (x) J. 0 holds for every n
for every h-summable
X
, we
for any at most
the Lebesgue-Stieltjes integral is A-summable,
. Furthermore, since
L
on the collection of all
A
X(E) = 0
and
IX fdh
evident that every bounded function on certainly defined on
is of this
has a non-measurable cardinal. If not,
there exists a o-additive non-negative measure subsets of
L
0 for
=
u
J. 0
f), it is
$
so
is
in L means that
Q(un) C 0 by the properties
have
of a Stieltjes-Lebesgue integral. This shows that
is as well an integral
$
in the sense of our present definitions. By hypothesis, therefore, Q the form ( 1 )
for every
f E L
. But
that
$(f)
follows from formula ( I )
A({x}) =
for every x E X
= 0
0 for every
f E L
is of
, so
, i.e.,
it
$ is
the null functional. On the other hand 4(x,) = A(X) > 0 by hypothesis. Thus we get a contradiction. Hence, if every non-negative integral is of the form ( l ) , then X
has a non-measurable cardinal.
It follows now immediately that X and only if every
Q E L"
where the real numbers where
C.lail <
(ai:i=1,2 ,...) points in X $(f)
m
. As
Z.la.1 < 1
1
C.a. f(x.) 1 1
Q
depend upon
1
m
and (x.:i=1,2 ,...)
converges for every
$
C.a. f(x.1 1 1
, and
1
,
is a sequence of
f E L
, and
. In addition, one sees integral on L . This implies L
has a non-measurable cardinal if and only if every
is normal integral, i.e., if and only if L" = L" c n
It is an open problem whether Lz complete Riesz space L set X
x.
of this form is a normal
now immediately that X integral on L
and the points
is evidently an integral on
= Cai f(x.)
easily that any
ai
=
a kind of converse, note that if the real numbers
satisfy
, then
has a non-measurable cardinal if
can be written in the form Q(f)
.
Lz holds for every Dedekind An affirmative answer implies that every point =
has a non-measurable cardinal. Indeed, if
present example, then L
.
L
is the space in the
is Dedekind complete, and s o if Dedekind complete-
Ch. 12,1871
153
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Li , then L" = L" holds now for the space L which c n we consider here. As observed above, L" = L" is equivalent to the c n condition that the underlying point set X has a non-measurable cardinal. ness implies :L
=
In Theorem 87.10 we shall prove in the converse direction that if every point set has a non-measurable cardinal, then Lz Dedekind complete space L
.A
=
Li holds for every
situation, similar to the situation in the
Examples 87.1 and 87.4, is discussed by G.W. Mackey ([11,1944). EXAMPLE 87.5. We shall present now an example in which
L" = Li
.
In other words, there are no integrals except the null functknal. Let L of all real continuous functions on the
be the Riesz space C([O,ll)
interval [O,ll with the natural pointwise ordering. Furthermore, let
...)
be the set of all rational numbers in C0,lI
(rn:n=1,2, pair
(m,n)
. For any
of natural numbers, there exists a function umn
is L
such
that
Let vm
=
sup(uml,
...,umn) . Then
vml 5 vm2 5
...
, the pointwise limit
function f (x) of this increasing sequence exists on C 0 , l l and the m function fm satisfies 0 2 f (x) 5 1 for all x and fm(rn) = 1 for m all r Observe nowthatby condition 1;) the set Fmn = (x:v mn (x)>O) is n
.
of Lebesgue measure at most ascending as
n
2/m
for every n
increases, the set
(x:fm(x)>O)
and s o , since Fmn
is
is of Lebesgue measure at
2/m . In combination with f (rn) = 1 f o r all n this shows that (at m least for m > 2 ) the function fm is not continuous, i.e., fm is not an
most
element of
L
. Once again on
account of
fm(rn) = 1
evident that the least upper bound of the sequence
for all n
...)
(vm1,vm2,
it i s
exists
in L and this least upper bound is in fact the function identically one.
.
4 1 in L Hence v mn Assume now that :L
# I01
.
. Then there exists a positive integral
4
on L such that $ ( I ) = 1 In view of vmn t n l , there exists a natural number n ~ ( I V ~) < 2-m-1 A s observed above, the set such that m m (X:vmn(x)>0) is of Lebesgue measure at most 2/m for every n , in
.
154
INTEGRALS AND SINGULAR LINEAR FUNCTIONALS
. Finally, let
particular for n = n m wm
Ch. 12,1871
inf,,v1nl,v2n2,...,v f mnm
=
.
Then w C and (x:w (x)>O) is of measure at most 2/m Hence w C 0 m m m (this holds even pointwise almost everywhere), which implies $(wm) C 0
.
But
m so
of
m
...
$(l-wm) < 2-2 + $(1)
= 1
.
+ 2-m-l
<
1 , which
implies $(wm) >
4
on account
We thus get a contradiction. It follows that L"= L"
.
The result that every positive linear functional on the space C(C0,Il) is singular may seem surprising at first since it follows among other things that the familiar Riemann integral on
C(C0,ll)
is a singular linear
functional, although the Riemann integral has the property that if (un:n=l,2, ...)
x E [O,ll
,
is a sequence in c(C0,ll)
then
+
un(x)dx
0
+
satSsfying un(x)
0
for every
(note that by Dini's theorem u
converges uniformly). This seems to contradict the result above. Observe, however, that u
n
C 0 in C(C0,ll)
wise. It is evident that but
u
n
J. 0
in C(C0,ll)
the sequence of all u
n
u (x) C 0 pointn u (x) C 0 pointwise implies u 0 in C(cO,ll), n n
is not the same as
+
does not always imply that the pointwise limit of is identically zero (remember that we had
vmn l.n
in the example above, but the pointwise limit of this eequence is not identically one).
This explains why a non-negative linear functional $
+
satisfying $(u ) 0 if n integral in the Riesz space sense.
c(C0,ll)
We return to the situation that L any
$ E L"
the null i d e a l
The null ideal of and instead of an ideal in L
$
N(4)
,
N($)
+
u (x) n
of
$
0
on
pointwise is not yet an
is an arbitrary Riesz space. For is defined by
is sometimes also called the absolute kernel of $ , we sometimes write N
$ '
It is evident that N($)
contained in the n u l l space (or k e r n e l ) of
9
, which
is is by
Ch. 1 2 , § 8 7 1
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
d e f i n i t i o n t h e l i n e a r subspace of a l l i s a normal i n t e g r a l , then
The d i s j o i n t complement
(N($))d
of
0
F i n a l l y , note t h a t i f
A
then
E L"
$
i s included i n
observation t h a t f o r
and
. This
N($)
f E A
if
Ad = { O ]
A
(equivalent t o {A]
included i n
Add
Archimedean, then
C($) f
i s c a l l e d the carrier of
. The ,
E L
$
Riesz seminorm
p$
i s a Riesz norm on
$ ;
'
.
C($)
i s i d e n t i c a l l y zero on the i d e a l
$
A,
follows immediately from t h e
in
L
i s s a i d t o be quasi o r d e r dense
Add = L ) and
A
generated by
, any
. If
$(f) = 0
we have
We r e c a l l t h a t . t h e i d e a l i f t h e band
N($)
by
$
\ $ ! ( i f \ ) for a l l
p (f) =
satisfying
i s a band. Note t h a t
N($)
we s h a l l denote t h e c a r r i e r of defined by
f E L
155
i s s a i d t o be order dense
A
. Since
{A] = L
satisfies
{A]
order dense i d e a l i s quasi order dense. I f
{A] = Add
f o r every i d e a l
is
is
L
A (by Theorem 2 2 . 3 ) , so
order dense i d e a l s and q u a s i o r d e r dense i d e a l s a r e now t h e same. It w i l l be proved now t h a t every i n t e g r a l i s normal on a q u a s i order dense i d e a l .
THEOREM 87.6. For every
order dense. For every
$
E L,,:
$
nomal integral i s the quasi order dense ideal PROOF. Let
N
E Lc,sn
$
we may assume t h a t of
4
satisfies
p o s i t i v e on
. For
c(4)
=
, and
on
(01
. The
r e s t r i c t i o n of
with
$
E L"
and
$ E L"
. This
$
sn n i s t h e n u l l f u n c t i o n a l . Since $
4
i s i d e n t i c a l l y zero on
C($)
p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on
is s t r i c t l y
tr) C(4)
$
C($)
C($)
by Theorem
t h e minimal p o s i t i v e l i n e a r extension
of t h i s r e s t r i c t i o n i s a normal i n t e g r a l on
L
i s q u a s i o r d e r dense
N($)
s o t h i s i s a normal i n t e g r a l on
84.4. Hence, by Theorem 8 3 . 7 ( i i ) , $
acts as a
.
N($c,sn)
t h e proof t h a t
i s quasi
$
i s p o s i t i v e . We have t o show t h a t t h e c a r r i e r
$
C(4)
N($)
the n u l l ideal
the largest idea2 on which
f:L
. On
C($)
= $
L
. We
implies t h a t holds on
C($)
t h e o t h e r hand
. Hence
C($) =
thus g e t
JI E L" n
$ {O}
,
n
0 <
JI
5
L" so sn ' i t follows t h a t
is a s t r i c t l y
.
To prove t h e second p a r t of t h e theorem we observe f i r s t t h a t f o r
$
0 S $
E L z we have
$ =
4,
on
, which
N($c,sn)
shows a l r e a d y t h a t
i s a normal i n t e g r a l on t h e q u a s i order dense i d e a l proof t h a t 'that
A
i s normal on
minimal l i n e a r extension
,
&
O S J I S $c , s n
E Lsn
J,
hence
E Lin
C($)
N($)
L
that
N($) = N ( l $ l )
. It
C($)
(ii) If
with
E :L
,
N
E Lc,sn
$
This holds a l s o i f $
L
then
of
$
N($n) # L that
C($)
and
\$Isn =
lesnl , we
i s normal on
, 2
so
L
.
C($,)
C($,)
#
L :
L
. If
@
{O]
On # 0
E Lz
, so ,
N($)
$
is
s o by
C($) = { O )
.
be Archimedean and C(I$l) =
{OI
. We
o t h e r words, we
, then , then
t h e normal t h e band
i s Archimedean, we have
= {N($n))d
{O}
with
L ,,:
C($) =
$n = 0
. Since
C($)
C($)
$
may assume
i s quasi o r d e r dense, so
E L i with
satisfies
i s not t h e whole of =
N($)
SO
N($sn).
i f and only i f
. In
0 S $
{N($,)Jdd
-
E Lc,sn
, i.e., I $ \ E , i.e., I $ ] E
have t o prove t h a t i f
$ 2 $n 2 0
$
L
E Lz,sn
$n
$
,
Lin
E L i the quasi order dense ideal
i s not Archimdean. Now l e t
$
component
c,sn
C($) tB N($) c N(Osn)
C($) =
have t o prove t h a t
N($n)
.
n
i s i d e n t i c a l l y zero on
is s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e on
$
follows t h a t
t h e l a s t theorem we have
let
$
.
is p o s i t i v e . Then
$
normal on
J,
N(J,c,sn)
( i ? For every
PROOF. ( i ) Since
n
.
i s Archimedean, then
C($) = { O )
and
i s normal, and s o t h e
$c,snlA
i s included i n the quasi order dense ideal
(ii) I f
. Then
A
IA i s normal. But 'c,sn This implies t h a t JI E L i
i s included i n
A
COROLLARY 87.7.
$
i.e.,
of
J,
so
,
A
$
For the
i s normal, assume
$
i s normal on
$
i s t h e n u l l f u n c t i o n a l . It follows t h a t
, and
A
such t h a t
L
.
N($c,sn)
i s t h e l a r g e s t i d e a l on which
N($c,sn)
i s an i d e a l i n
$c,sn = $-$n
J,
ch. 12,1871
INTEGRALS AND SINGULAR LINEAR FUNCTIONALS
156
#
, contrary
{O]
. It
follows then from
t o our hypothesis. Hence
= o . W e s h a l l prove now t h a t , under t h e hypothesis t h a t every s e t has a
non-measurable c a r d i n a l , every i n t e g r a l on a Riesz space with t h e p r o j e c t i o n property i s a normal i n t e g r a l . For t h i s purpose we f i r s t prove a lemma.
LEMMA 87.8. Let
A
. Then there
be a non-empty subset of the complete Boolean
e h s t s a d i s j o i n t subset C = ( c :aEIa)) of B ( i . e . , a 1 # a2 implies c A c = e , where e i s the smallest element a a2 i n the Boolean algebra) suc!~ that sup C = sup A and such that f o r every algebra
B
Ch. 12,1871
157
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
a
a E {a) there e x i s t s an element
E
PROOF. The c o l l e c t i o n of a l l d i s j o i n t s u b s e t s of element i n t h e subset i s majorized by an element of
.
ca S a
A .satisfying
such t h a t each
B
i s non-empty and
A
p a r t i a l l y ordered by i n c l u s i o n . Each chain i n t h e c o l l e c t i o n has a l e a s t upper bound i n t h e c o l l e c t i o n (obtained simply by taking t h e union of t h e s e t s i n t h e chain). Hence, by Zom's lemma, t h e r e e x i s t s a maximal subset C
of t h e Boolean algebra
Evidently and l e t
c'
c' # 8
and
a.
such t h a t
B
that
be t h e r e l a t i v e complement of c
= sup aT
,
a r e equal t o c'
. Writing
c' = 8
A
so
c'
a
A
=
A
a
c
t o the s e t
A
c'
, we
C
, so
# a.
c
c < a
with r e s p e c t t o
, we
a.
a
0 A
= 8
, i.e.,
a
#
8
0 ' , so
have
by Exercise 4 . 1 3 . Not a l l
c'
. Hence
# a.
c
A = (aT:TE{T))
now
sup(c'AaT)
0 8 , because otherwise
t o our hypothesis t h a t Adjoining
has t h e s t a t e d p r o p e r t i e s .
C
. Assume
c = sup C 5 sup A = a.
,
c' = 8
f o r some
c'
A
aT
contrary
T =
T
0 ' '0 get a l a r g e r subset s t i l l possessing
'0 t h e p r o p e r t i e s s t a t e d a t t h e beginning, thus c o n t r a d i c t i n g t h e maximality
of
C
. Hence
; i n o t h e r words, sup C = sup A
c = a.
THEOREM 87.9.
L
Let
such that f o r euery
.
be a Riesz space with the projection property
f E L
the ideal
Af
f
gemrated by
i s a point
s e t with a non-measurable cardinaZ. Then every integral on L PROOF. I f a positive
has an i n t e g r a l which i s not normal, then t h e r e e x i s t s
L N
which i s not t h e n u l l f u n c t i o n a l . By Theorem 87.6
$ E Lc,sn
thenullideal
N($)
i s q u a s i o r d e r dense. Since
i s then o r d e r dense, i.e., L
S
u
4 u
with
i s Archimedean, N($)
$(u) > 0
uT E N ( $ )
L
r e s p e c t i v e l y . Then
$J(U ) =
. Furthermore
0
sup Q,
= P
d e f i n e a non-negative la)
$(P u) = 0
and
P = sup ?
lemma t h e r e e x i s t s a system
index s e t
T
. Note
i s a complete Boolean algebra. Let
L
PT be t h e p r o j e c t i o n s on the bands generated by
such t h a t
for a l l
i s a complete Boolean algebra. Equivalently, t h e s e t
of order p r o j e c t i o n s on bands i n
$(u) > 0
there
h a s t h e p r o j e c t i o n p r o p e r t y , so by Theorem 30.6 t h e set of a l l
p r o j e c t i o n bands i n and
L
0 < u E L with
f o r any
0
e x i s t s a d i r e c t e d system now t h a t
i s normal.
and T
and
and every p
P
u $(Pu) =
by Thoorem 3 1 . 2 ( i i i ) . By t h e preceding
(Oa:a€{a]) of mutually d i s j o i n t p r o j e c t i o n s
measure
by s e t t i n g
for a l l
u
Qa
i s majorized by some
PT
. We
now
on t h e c o l l e c t i o n of a l l s u b s e t s of t h e
p(0) = 0
f o r t h e empty s e t
0
and
158
Ch. I2,§88l
LARGEST IDEAL OF ORDER CONTINUITY
f o r every non-empty subset whoie set
{a) we have
Theorem 3 0 . 5 ( i i ) . Hence a t most countable s e t
of
A
sup A
u(Ia1)
. It
t h e measure
u
implies
. Note
sup PT = P
=
$(u) > 0
that for
, so
A
equal t o t h e
sup 0 u = Pu = u
, whereas
u(A) = 0
has thus been proved t h a t
by
f o r any
{a) has a
= 0 u f o r every a , it follows t h a t a a can be t r a n s f e r r e d t o t h e s e t of a l l p (note t h a t
measurable c a r d i n a l . Writing now
a, # a2
fa]
=
p
a1
# pa2
p
), s o
(pa:aE{a])
has a measurable c a r d i n a l .
Since t h i s i s a subset of t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l t r i v i a l l y be extended t o t h e set
A,
. It
AU
, the
measure
follows t h a t
A,
u
can
has a measurable
c a r d i n a l , contrary t o our hypothesis. Hence t h e assumption t h a t
L
has a
non-normal i n t e g r a l leads t o a c o n t r a d i c t i o n , and s o every i n t e g r a l on
L
i s normal. COROLLARY 87.10. Asswne that every point s e t has a non-measurable cardinal. Then every integral on a Riesz space with the projection
property i s a normal integral. In particuZar, every integral
071
a Dedekind
complete Riesz space i s normal. This theorem i s due t o W.A.J. EXERCISE 87.11.
Let
X
Luxemburg ( [ 4 1 , 1 9 6 7 ) .
be an a r b i t r a r y t o p o l o g i c a l space and
t h e Riesz space of a l l real continuous functions on u
n
for
E L
$(un)
-+
o
n = 1,2, f o r every
...
and
4 E L"
.
u (x) n
J.
0
X
. Show t h a t
holds pointwise on
X
,
L
if then
HINT: Similar t o t h e proof of Example 87.1.
88. The l a r g e s t i d e a l on which every order bounded o p e r a t o r i s order continuous
Let
L
be an a r b i t r a r y Riesz space and
M
a Dedekind complete Riesz
space. We use t h e same n o t a t i o n s as i n the preceding s e c t i o n s . I n p a r t i c u l a r
Lb
i s an abbreviation f o r
k(L,M)
. Similarly f o r
W e r e c a l l t h a t t h e null o p e r a t o r i s denoted by
on
L
, however,
Lc,Ls,Ln and Lsn 8 ; f o r the n u l l functional
.
we u s u a l l y w r i t e an ordinary zeno. I n a l l t h a t follows t h e
Ch. 12,1881
case t h a t
is t h e space of real numbers i s of s p e c i a l importance.
M
A
DEFINITION 88.1. For any non-empty subset
A0 = (T:TELb,Tf=O for
all fEA,1
of Lb
B
For any non-empty subset B
L
the (L,M)-anni-
.
the inverse (L,M)-annihiZator
0 B
of
i s defined by OB = (f:fEL,Tf=O f o r a l l E B )
. Note
L
A c L
that i f B c L"
and
Lb
i s a l i n e a r subspace of
Evidently, Ao of
of
of A i s defined by
Ao
hilator
159
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
. and
i s a l i n e a r subspace
OB
Lb = L - ,
i s r e a l number space, then
M
so for
we have now
t h e usual d e f i n i t i o n s f o r a n n i h i l a t o r and i n v e r s e a n n i h i l a t o r i n t h i s s p e c i a l case ( f o r a f u r t h e r d i s c u s s i o n of t h i s case we r e f e r t o t h e next
A c A cL 1 2 implies o B 1 3 OB2
s e c t i o n ) . Note t h a t BI c B
Lb
of fl
2
c
L
b
, then
Tf = 0
# f2 in L
for a l l
implies t h a t
3
OLb
, it
is evident t h a t i f
does t h e l a r g e r s e t LEMMA 88.2.
.
A
0 1
3
A
0 2
3
Lo =
{el
and
I f OB = {O} f o r some subset B E B implies f = 0 I n o t h e r words, T f l # Tf2 f o r a t l e a s t one T E B . This i s
o f t e n expressed by saying t h a t OB
implies
.
T B
separates t h e p o i n t s of B
s e p a r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
L
. Since
L
, thenso
Lb'
If there i s a subset of
that separates the points Lb of L , then L i s Archimedean. I n particular, i f there i s a subset of L" that separates the points of L , then L is Archimedean.
have
0
5
nv
0 5 nTv 5 Tu
for all
T E
Lb . Then OLb = I01 . . For any 8 < T E Lb we 'n 1,2, ... , so Tv 0 . It follows t h a t T v = 0 implies v = 0 on account of OLb = {O] . Hence L
OB = 10)
PROOF. Let
Assume t h a t
for
& , which
B
f o r some subset
< u for n =
= 1,2,
...
in
of
L
=
LARGEST IDEAL OF ORDER CONTINUITY
160
ch. 12,8883
i s Archimedean. If
and
OB = (0)
f E L
satisfies
. I n p a r t i c u l a r , i f u E L+ . The f o l l o w i n g lemma shows
f = 0 u = 0
Tf = 0
satisfies
for a l l
Tu = 0
T
E B , then
for a l l
T E B
,
then
t h a t under c e r t a i n c o n d i t i o n s t h e i n v e r s e
holds. LEMMA 88.3. If T
u E L+
E B and
Lb
i s an idea2 i n
B
PROOF. It i s s u f f i c i e n t t o show t h a t f o r t h i s it i s enough t o prove t h a t
E B
0 5 T S
E B , so
. Hence,
let
Sf = 0
0 5 T
E B
. For
{B)
A
IT1
ITI(u) = 0
for
A
. It
E A'
lSul
5
. Hence,
,T E
0 5 u
Tu = 0
for
e
8 5 T A
Ao
T(lfl) = 0
B
and
for we have
IS1 5 T
Lb f
have '
T
. We have
0 2 u E A
in
let
0
Su
Lb
0
IS1
, so
with
Tu = sup T,u
, i.e.,
{B] =
.
B
. If
show f i r s t t h a t
T E Ao
E A and
T E Ao
implies
If1
5
u
. Then
I t follows t h a t
and =
0
then OB i s a band i n L
n'
0 S u
i s a band
Ao
is an idea2 i n L
, then
. We
L
, then
OB
S
IT1
t r i v i a l l y . Since
IS1 E Ao
, we
is an ideal i n L e t now
for
, then
b e an i d e a l i n
S E
IS1 (u) = 0
0 B
.
i s s u f f i c i e n t t o show t h a t
0 S u E A
j u s t proved, and s o
Ao
0
=
Lb
E A , s o Tf = 0 by h y p o t h e s i s .
Assume now t h a t
for a l l
If1 E
satisfying
S
i s an idea2 contained i n L
( i ) Let
PROOF.
implies
Tu = 0
implies
implies
any
i s the band generated by the idea2 B
B
i s an idea2 i n L
i s an idea2 i n
B
If
( i i i ) If
f
( i ) If
.
(ii)
0
f E
0
.
by h y p o t h e s i s . It follows by Theorem 83.9 t h a t
THEOREM 88.4.
Lb
OB = { O ]
B
f E
T ( l f 1 ) = sup(lSf1:ISIST)
in
such t h a t
, then
u = 0
impZies
T E Ad
S E Ao
TT E Ao
. Then 0
/TI E Ao a s s u E A implies
. This
f o r a11
shows a l r e a d y t h a t T
,
so
T u = 0
( c f . t h e proof of Theorem 83.4),
. This
shows t h a t
Ao
i s a band.
so
.
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Ch. 12,1881
B be an ideal in Lb
(ii) Let
f E
already that and
lgl
.
If
S
0
In the last lemma it was proved
implies If1 E B 0 Then If1 E B , and s o B
. Assume now that lgl E
follows now from 6 5 T E B that lTg\ 5 T(1gl) 0 so g E B This shows that OB is an ideal.
.
{B}
Let
0
B
.
For this purpose, let
Now, let
6
S
0 2 u
g E L , f E
0
B
trivially. Since it
=
be the band generated by the ideal
c O{B}
B '
161
0
0
, we
B
. We
E B , so
Tu
=
Tg = 0
have
,
have to prove that 0
for all
.
T E B
. There exists an upwards directed set {TT} in B . Hence T0u = sup T u = 0 . This shows that u E OIB} . HenceT OB c O I B I . (iii) Let B an ideal contained in Ln . To show that the ideal OB 0 is actually a band, let 0 5 u I. u with u E B for all T . Since all T
in B
T
in B
To E {B}
6 5 T
such that
.
To
4
are now order continuous, we have Hence
Tu
=
DEFINITION 88.5.
s e t of a l l
f E L
0
, so
u
E OB
.
La (more precisely
By
such that
+
If1 t u
0 = Tu
La(L,M)
implies
0
Tu
4
)
for any positive
we shall denote the
Tun
+
0 f o r every
TELb.
Similarly, we shall denote by the s e t of a l l
f E L
such t h a t
/fI t uT
L
Lan
+
0
(as an abbreviation f o r
I
Lan(L,M)
1 i s any dowmards directed s e t i n , then inflTu I = 0 f o r any T E L,, .
such that i f
Iu
Note that La
=
(,EL:
If Itu +O
implies Tu J.0 for every 8STELb
Lan
=
(fEL:If12uT+0
implies TuT+O for every 8STELb
THEOREM 88.6.
La and
n
1.
Lan are ideals i n
L
. For
any
T E Lb
r e s t r i c t i o n TILa i s a-order continuous (by d e f i n i t i o n ) . Hence largest ideal i n L on which every Lan i s the largest ideal i n PROOF. We prove that La
T E Lb
the i s the
i s o-order continuous. Similarly
on which every
L
La
T E Lb
i s order continuous.
is an ideal. The proof for Lan
is similar.
It follows immediately from the definition of La that f E La holds if and only if If( E La holds. Also lgl 5 If1 and f E La imply g E La It remains to prove that fl,f2 E La implies f +f E La Hence, let fl,f2 E La
and
If,+f21
t un J. 0
. We have
1 2 to show that
.
Tun
J.
0 for
.
162
LARGEST IDEAL OF ORDER CONTINUITY
. It follows from our assumptions that
8 5 T E Lb
Ch. 12,1881
I f l /+
I f 7I
t u
n 4 0
,
so
v
Ifll
=
-
+ If21
un 4
By Theorem 15.5 there exist sequences 0 such that vn l+vn2 w
nl
=
vn
= /flI
for all n
-
v
5
. Hence
v i 0 , wn2 nl
If 1
4
nl
1
If2/ -
=
.
.
If21
IflI +
0
and
5
v n2
+ If2/
v 40 n2
and w +wn2 = un for all n In view of fl,f2 E La we have Twnl nl and TWn2 J 0 for every T t 9 in Lb By addition Tu 4 0 for 0 5
T E
.
+
O
. This is the desired result.
Lb
COROLLARY 88.7. La
if and only if Ln
=
=
.
Lb
Lc
L if and only if
=
Lb
. Similarly, Lan = L
The main theorem in the present section follows now. THEOREM 88.8. La
and
OLS
=
Lan
=
OL
.
sn
. We prove first that La . For this purpose it is sufficient to show that for 9 5 T E L . Given f E La and 8 5 T E L s '
PROOF. We present the proof for La contained in OL implies Tf
=
0
restriction TILa
is o-order continuous on the ideal La
minimal positive linear extension TI of L
and it satisfies 8
Ls
is an ideal), so
(since f E La and
T
S
TI E TI
=
1
5
T
. But then La )
T, E Ls
.
= 9
2
so
Tu
9 5
T E
4 0
u
. Then all
u
=
n 0 holds for any 9
,
i.e., f E La
and s o the
(since T E Ls
. Hence
For the proof of the converse direction. assume that If1
the
T / La is o-order continuous on
Lc I7 Ls , i.e., T 1
T on
,
is f E La
are members of
Tf
=
1
f E OLS
OLS (since O L S
and
T f = 0 and
is an ideal),
5 T E L and all n . Assume now that Lb . Then T has a unique decomposition T = Tc+T s with Tc E Lc and Ts E Ls , s o T u J. 0 and T u = 0 for all n . It follows that s n c n
n
Tun J. 0
.
It has thus been proved that O L S c La
It follows immediately from the definitions that A c '(Ao)
non-empty subset A
of
L
and
B c (OB)'
.
for any
for any non-empty subset B
of
Ch. 12,1881
163
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
. In particular, O L
.
c (L~~)'. L~ implies ts c (L~)' Similarly, Lsn It is, therefore, a problem of some interest to determine when one or both
tb
of the equalities
=
(La)'
=
Ls
(Lan)O
or
Lsn will hold. There is one
=
particular case for which the answer is easy to give. A s observed above, we have La
=
L
Lc
=
Lb , i.e., Ls
{el
=
L
if and only if
case the equality
(La)'
=
0
L
=
a 0 (L )
THEOREM 88.9. The equality
=
{ e l , and in this
holds. =
Ls
holds i f and onZy i f
.
d i f f e r e n t members of Lc h a w d i f f e r e n t r e s t r i c t i o n s t o La Similarly, (Lan) 0 = Lsn holds i f and only i f d i f f e r e n t members of Ln have d i f f e r e n t restrictions t o
.
L~~
PROOF. Note first that the statement about La may a l s o be formulated a 0 holds if and only if it follows from 8 # T E Lc (L ) = L
by saying that
L a ) ' . In view of L 0 L = { 9 ) it is evident that if tbat T is not in ( c s a 0 (L ) = Ls and 8 # T E Lc , then T is not in (La)' Conversely, let it
.
Lc the operator T is not in (La)' , and is properly larger than Ls , i.e., there exists an
be given that for 8 # T E (La)'
assume not that operator T E (La)'
, because E Lc and
IT/ Tc
such that T
(La)'
Ls
and
. Then
Ts E Ls
is not in Ls
Tc # 9
since
Hence, by our hypothesis, Tc is not in follows from 0 2 T shows that
(La)'
:s
IT1 E (La)'
S
Lb
are ideals in
IT1
(La)'
that Tc E
not properly larger than
. The same holds then for . Let IT1 = Tc+T with is not a member of
Ls
. On the other hand, it (La)' . This contradiction a 0 Ls , so (L ) = Ls .
There exists a close connection between order denseness or super order denseness of (Lan)O
=
Lsn
La
or
dense if the band generated by
A
is L
there exists an upwards directed set The ideal A
THEOREM 88.10.
Lc
*
such that
(i) I f
Ls
or is order
in A
such that 0
u f L+
if for any
0s u
n
I. u
.
u E L+
La i s super order dense i n
L
5
u
+
u
.
there exists
, then
(La)'
=
Ls.
La i s super order dense i n L and if L separates the a 0 L , then (L ) = Ls and t h e p d i n t s of L are aZready separated
(ii) I f
by
in A
=
in L
itself, i.e., for any
{uT}
is super order dense in L
a sequence {un}
points of
(La)'
Lan and the conditions that
should hold. We recall that the ideal A
164
LARGEST IDEAL OF ORDER CONTINUITY a 0 (L ) = Ls
(iii) ConverseZy, if
then La i s order dense i n L
.
PROOF. (i) Assume that La show that (La)'
=
Ch. 12,0881
Lc separates the points
and
is super order dense in L
. We have
to
Ls holds, which by the preceding theorem is equivalent
to showing that if a a-order continuous operator T vanishes on
. Hence, let
T = 0
of L,
Lc and Tf
T E
=
0 for all f E La
La
. For every
, then
0 c v E La we have
and since
If1
5
v E La
satifying
If1
5
v
implies f E La , we have
f
Tf = 0 for all
. Hence ITI(v) = 0 . We shall prove now that ITI(u> = 0 . Given u E L+ , there exists by hypothesis a sequence (un:n=1,2,...) in La such that 0 5 u + u . By the result just n established we have IT1 (u,) = 0 for all n (since u E La) . Furthermore n for every u E L+
we have
ITI(un) 4 ITI(u)
IT1 (u) = 0 (ii)
since
. This holds for every
Assume that La
IT1
is a-order continuous. Hence
u E L+
,
IT1
so
0
=
is super order dense in L
have to show only that OLC
,
= {O}
sufficient to show that if u E L+
,
and hence T = 8
and
. We
OLb = {Ol
.
i.e., in view of Lemma 8 8 . 3 , it is and
Tu
=
0 for all T E L
then
c'
. Hence, let us assume that u E L+ satisfies Tu = 0 for all T E Lc . By hypothesis there exists a sequence 0 5 u + u with all u n n La . Since Tu = 0 for every T satisfying 8 5 T E L , we have Tu = n for 8 5 T E L and all n . Also Tu = 0 for every T satisfying u = 0
8 5
T E L
an:
in 0
all n (since u E La = L ). By addition it follows that n satisfying 8 5 T E Lb and for all n But
.
Tun = 0 for every T
"L
= { O } by hypothesis, so b it follows that u = 0
u
(iii) Assume that
=
.
(La)'
=
0 for all n
Ls and
0
Lc
. On account of
= {O}
. Then
L
0 2 un .f u
is Archimedean,
order denseness of La is the same as (La)dd = L , i.e., the same as ad ad We have to show, therefore, that (L ) = { O } holds. Assume (L ) = { O )
so
(La)d # { O }
. . Then
(La)d
collows then from O L such that
Tu > 0
contains a non-zero positive element u
= {O}
that there exists an operator
. If necessary, we may replace
linear extension of
TI (La)d
,
Lc
T by the minimal positive
s o we may assume that
which implies that T vanishes certainly on La
. It
0 C T E
T vanished on
. This
shows that
(Laldd,
Ch. 12,1881
T E (La)'
165
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
. Hence
Ls
=
T E Lc
(La)d # { O }
It follows that
Il
so
T
, which contradicts Tu
= B
is impossible, so
(La)d
(ii) Lan is order dense i n (Lan)'
=
L and
= {O}
L
.
an 0 (L )
, tlzen
separates the points of
Lsn and Ln
.
> 0.
= Lsn Lb separates the points of L
(i) If Lan i s order dense i n
THEOREM 88.11.
adn only i f
,
Ls
L
.
i f
PROOF. Similarly as the proof of the preceding theorem.
(i) Lc = Ln implies La = Lan . Ls holds, then the eonverse of the above statement holds as well. I n other words, i f (La)' = Ls holds, then La = Lan i f and only i f Lc = Ln . I n t h i s case ( i . e . , i f a l l these conditions are an 0 s a t i s f i e d ) , the condition (L ) = Lsn i s also s a t i s f i e d . COROLLARY 88.12. (ii) I f
(La)'
=
PROOF. (i) lC
L~ implies L~
=
Ls
Note first that
. We have
=
Ls
c
Lsn ,
(La)'
(ii) Let
so it
.
0
L~ = O L sn = L~~ to show that La = Lan implies =
follows from La = Lan
and
(La)'
Lc =
=
Ls
L n.
that (Lan)O = (Lalo
=
Ls c Lsn
an 0 On the other hand the inclusion Lsn c (L ) is always true. Hence an 0 (L ) = Lsn , which immediately implies
Ls and so
L
c
=
L
=
n
a 0
(L )
an0
= (L
=
Lsn ,
(by taking disjoint complements).
For examples that the conditions in Theorems 88.10 and 88.11 and Corollary 88.12 are best possible in some respects, we refer to Exercises 88.14-88.16
at the end of this section.
THEOREM 88.13.
Let
L~(D) the s e t of a l l f o r every
that
T E D
If1 2 u
I ~ zI
denote by
Lan(D)
. Similarly,
J. 0
Lb and denote by c o implies TU n + o
D be a non-empty subset of f E L such t h a t
implies
u
the s e t of a l l T E D
infITu I = 0 f o r every
.
f
E L such
166
The s e t s
(i)
and
La(D)
continuous respectively (ii) Denoting by
, we have
D i n Lb
.
and
BD
{Dl
La(D) = La(BD)
.
are ideals i n L , the largest
Lan(D)
T E D i s u-order continuous o r order
ideals i n L on which every
=
Ch. 12,9881
LARGEST IDEAL OF ORDER CONTINUITY
=
the ideal and the band generated by and
L~({D})
L~"(D) = Lan(BD)
=
L~~(IDI)
Lb , then
(iii) If B i s an ideal i n
Lan(B) = Lan(BnLsn) =
=
0
(BllLsn)
PROOF. We restrict ourselves to indicating the proof that La(B ) D holds. Let f E La(BD) We have to prove that f E La({Dl) La({D})
.
For this purpose, assume that If1 t u J. 0 n we have
,
Taun Gn
so
T_ 4 T with all T
9 S
0 for all
Tu = (T-Ta )u
+
a
. For
in BD
.
.
. Let
any fixed a
(T-Ta) (If I ) + Taun
Ta un
=
,
.
inf Tu < (T-T )(If/) This holds for every a Since , we get inf Tu = 0 This shows that f E La({D}) = n as desired. so
.
infa(T-Ta);lfl)
EXERCISE 88.14. of
La
It was shown in Theorem 88.10 that super order denseness OLb
together with
implies OLc = 103
= {O}
shown in Theorem 88.11 that order denseness of
. Show that if
implies OLn = { O }
,
OLb = { O }
Lan
. Similarly, it was
together with
OLb
= {O}
is omitted, then these con-
clusions do not necessarily follow. HINT: If
Lb
the case that M dual L"
,
=
0
=
Lan
=
L
,
so
a an L = L
is super order
.
= L = {e} does not deparate the points of L In n is the space of real numbers the space Lb is the order
so
=
{Ol
L
b
= {9}
,
is now the same as L"
= {9}
. For examples
for
holds we refer to Examples 85.1 and 85.2.
EXERCISE 88.15. OL
La
, but Lc
dense in L
which L"
; then
=
then La
It was shown in Theorem 88.10 that if is order dense in L
a 0 (L )
. Similarly, it was
=
Ls
shown in
and
167
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Ch. 12,9881
= Lsn and OLn = 1 0 ) , then Lan is order Theorem 88.11 that if (Lan)' n 101 it is only dense in L . Show that if instead of OL = { O } or o ~ =
assumed that
OLb
,
= {O}
functions on
C0,ll
do not necessarily
then the same c:nclusion
follow. For an example, choose for L
the space of all real continuous
and use the fact that L"
consists only of singular
linear functionals (as proved in Example 87.5). HINT: L" =
' ( L "
L"
=
s"
=
) =
{Ol
=
LLn
L
Li
=
. But
separates the points of
Lyn
, i.e.,
La = Lan La
=
Lan
L
,
'(L")
so
. It follows that
= {O}
=) ; L ( '
(La)'
is not order dense in L
=
.
=
(Lan)O =
EXERCISE 88.16. It was shown in Corollary 88.12 that L c = L n implies an a an = L I n the converse direction, it was shown that L = L together a 0 an 0 with (L ) = Ls implies Lc = L and (L ) = Lsn Show now that if
.
a L
.
(Lan)O = Lsn
holds, it may occur that
Lc # Ln
HINT: Let L be the space of a l l real bounded functions f
on the
La = Lan together with and
(La)'
interval
# Ls
.
(x:O<xil)
for every (i.e., Q
f E L
,
f
such that
most countable set. Let M
is an integral on
then Q
, but
is in LL
has a constant value
be real number space, s o
L
, but
af outside an at
Lb
= L"
. If $(f)
=
, and s o L; # Lyn recall that on the sequence space
not in L" ) . Hence Lc # Ln N
n
For the determination of
La
, we
af
not a normal integral
N
.
Lrn there exists a positive linear functional that is not an integral (this was proved in section 85). Applied to the present situation it means that if f E L
and
satisfies f(x ) n
t E >
0
for some sequence
, then
f(x) = 0 for all other x E ( 0 , l )
linear functional Q
on L
...)
(xn:n=1,2,
there exists a positive
such that the restriction of
Q
to the
is not an integral. It follows now that La
principal ideal Af
(0,l)
in
of all f vanishing outside an at most countable set
(xn:n=1,2,
.
consists
...)
with
Then La = Lan, lim f(x ) = 0 , the set (xn:n=1,2,...) depending upon f n an 0 So Lan is order dense in L This implies (L ) = Lin by Theorem
.
88.11 (i). Hence La = Lan and a 0 (L ) = = L" # Li sn
(Lan)'
.
=
L"
sn
' but LL # Li and
EXERCISE 88.17. Show that La consists of all f E L condition that if and
.
(un:n=l ,2,. . )
is any sequence in L
T is any positive operator in
Lb '
satisfying the
such that un
then T(inf (un, I f I ) )
J.
0
.
J.
0
LARGEST IDEAL OF ORDER CONTINUITY
168
EXERCISE 88.18.
Show t h a t i f
t h e band generated by in
and
L
,
B
EXERCISE 88.19. Let
L
T
E Lb
A c La
0
. Show t h a t
B
A
be an i d e a l i n
,
La
TIA
and
then
A
.
, then
, the
L
. If
Ad = (La)d
La
C
by ( i i ) , s o
(La)'
It follows from
A
t
there exists
w > 0
not i n
, there 0
5
La
that
in
Ad
T
Ad
3
Lb
know t h a t
E Lb
with
on
A
. But
then again
equality
Ad = (La)d
i n Example 85.1. Then ideal i n
.
L
TI =
(B n :n=l,2,
...
. For
Bo
with
f T I nE Bn
that
fnn
f o r every
l Ln
-+
T
f
Lb
does not
Ln
.
follows from ( i ) t h a t i f 0 A c Ls Hence
.
i s always t r u e .
s e p a r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
Ad
i s properly l a r g e r ,
i s not i n such t h a t
(La)d
u
=
. Since
. If TIAd
L
necessary, r e p l a c e
. Then
T
w
inf(w,v) > 0
s e p a r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
Tu > 0
.
L
T
vanishes on
is
.
, so by t h e Add
,
E Ls , which implies Tu = 0 (since u E La Lb does not s e p a r a t e t h e p o i n t s of L , t h e
any
and
, so
E Lb f
L have t h e p r i n c i p a l p r o j e c t i o n property. I f
,
we have a unique decomposition f = f m + %'n d f i n E Bo ll Bn , and i t follows from Theorem 3 0 . 5 ( i i )
f E Bo
I f [ 2 Ifinl c 0
. This
. We
=
.
. Hence,
if
f E La
, then
holds i n p a r t i c u l a r f o r any sequence
Tfln TI
+
0
of
B 4 Bf , where Bf i s t h e p r i n c i p a l band n ask whether t h e converse holds. Let La be t h e s e t of
p r o j e c t i o n bands s a t i s f y i n g generated by
.
LC
) i s a sequence of p r o j e c t i o n bands s a t i s f y i n g Bn 4 Bo i s a l s o a p r o j e c t i o n band, we s h a l l say t h a t t h e sequence T
Bo
exhausts
0
does not n e c e s s a r i l y hold. Take L = M(r)(X,u) as a 0 L" = {O) , so L = L = L Take f o r A any
EXERCISE 88.20. Let
where
T
1. Contradiction. I f
. If
w
0 5 v E La
minimal p o s i t i v e l i n e a r extension of SO
(La)d
such t h a t
exists
. We
u E La ll Ad
there e x i s t s
= OLS
. It
c Ao
Assume now t h a t we know i n a d d i t i o n t h a t
Hence
A
l a s t e q u a l i t y does not n e c e s s a r i l y hold.
and T vanishes on A , then T E Ls , and s o 0 c A c Ls . I n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n Ls c (La)'
(La)d
=
and ( i i ) f o r any
Formulate and prove t h e corresponding statement f o r
(La)'
ll Ln
{A)
is
f o r example, s a t i s f i e s these c o n d i t i o n s ) . Show t h a t 0 a 0 A = (L ) = L Show t h a t i f i t i s given i n a d d i t i o n t h a t
s e p a r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
HINT: A
0
{B}
i s an i d e a l
A
h a s an extension which i s a member of
,
s e p a r a t e t h e p o i n t s of
T E Lb
and
if
such t h a t ( i ) d i f f e r e n t
L
have d i f f e r e n t r e s t r i c t i o n s t o
the r e s t r i c t i o n
(the ideal
Lb
A
Lb
i s an i d e a l i n
B
OIB} =
i s t h e band generated by
{A)
members of
then
12,1881
Ch.
Ch. 12,§8Q]
of a l l Bf
f E L
such t h a t
Tfin
HINT: W e have t o show t h a t
Given
8 2
, we
T E Lb
. Take
any
-pn
,
3
La
. Let
. Show t h a t 0
Tu C 0 " + pn = (6f-un)
together i s
pn
, we
B
have
E v i d e n t l y , t h e component of u -6f is n (6f)nn-Pn
La
La c La
and w r i t e
band g e n e r a t e d by a l l t h e p
holds f o r every sequence
have t o show t h a t
6 > 0
band g e n e r a t e d by
0
-t
. Evidently
T E Lb
and f o r every
Tf > 0
169
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
6f-u
n
, so
4 Bf
in
Bf
is
Bn
_<
. We may . Since
n and i t f o l l o w s t h a t , t h e component
and
f
2
un
,
pn 4 6f by
C 0.
the
the
Bn
(because
, so
.
assume t h a t
. Denoting pn
exhausting
La = La
f E La
Tfin 4 0
n
f
E La
).
t h e component of
(unlnn
of
u
n
, so
is
O < ( u ) S 6 f . n nn The component Tu
(un)in
,
< T(6f) + T f i n
6 > O , s o
so
B
inf
infyu = O . n
EXERCISE 88.21.
Lan
in
d n n
n
Bf
Tu n
satisfies
.
0 5 (un)in 5 f ' Hence nn < T(6f) = 6Tf This h o l d s f o r a l l
.
Formulate and prove t h e corresponding s t a t e m e n t f o r
.
89. A n n i h i l a t o r s and weak t o p o l o g i e s For t h e f o l l o w i n g we need some elementary f a c t s about a n n i h i l a t o r s and weak t o p o l o g i e s . L e t dual
W# ( i . e , , W#
Furthermore, l e t fixed
.
W
be a r e a l o r complex v e c t o r space w i t h a l g e b r a i c
i s t h e v e c t o r space of a l l l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s on
W'
For any non-empty
b e a l i n e a r subspace of subset
A
of
W#
. We
keep
t h e annihilator
W
A'
W
of
W ).
and
W'
A
is
OB
of
d e f i n e d by Ao = (+EW':b(f)=O
and f o r any non-empty
i s d e f i n e d by
subset
f o r a l l fE*) B
of W'
,
t h e inverse annihilator
B
ANNIHILATORS AND WEAK TOPOLOGIES
170
Ch. 12,9893
Compare this with the formulas in ( 1 ) of section 88, where we had W and W'
W'
N
L
=
and W
= {O}
. It is evident that
Ao
B1 c B2 c W'
and
implies OB
throughout this section that '(W')
=
OB
and
respectively. Note that A
1
1
C
=I
A2
OB
{O)
2
,
(r
are linear subspaces of 0 0 W implies A 1 3 A2 2 Wo =
3
'(W')
w .
A
It is of some importance to observe that A 0 0 W For the proof, note first that A C (A )
0
.
In the converse direction, substituting B Ao c {o(Ao)}o
. We
=
{O(A0)Io
=
implies Ao in B
Ao
shall assume
separates the points
i.e., W'
of C
L
=
. Hence there is equality. Similarly, OB
for any 0 0 0 2 { (A )I
.
(OB)' we obtain 0 0 0
C
=
{ ( B)
1 for any
BcW'.
We now recall that if X and, for each u E {a} mapping from X system
, Ya
into Y a
,
is a non-empty point set, {a) an index set is a non-empty topological space and
then the weak topology in X
is the weakest topology i n
(Fa:aE{a})
X which makes all Fa
continuous. The system of all inverse images Fi'(Oa) through the open sets in Y the set each a Yu
in
,
Ou
(i.e., a
we restrict Oa
runs
to run only through a subbase for the topology in
.
Let W
Oa
is variable, and for each fixed a
and W'
is still a subbase for the weak topology
be the same as introduced above. The weak topology in
generated by the members of W' i s denoted by
W
, where
is again variable), is a subbase for the weak topology. If for
the system of all F - l ( O ) a a
x
Fa a generated by the
o(W,W')
and the weak to-
pology in w' generated by the members of W is denoted by o(W',W)
o(W,W')
. Hence,
is the weakest topolony in W such that every $ EW' is a continuous
(real or comp1ex)functionon W . Similarly, o(W',W)
is the weakest topologyin
W' such that every f E W i s a continuous (real or complex) function on W'
.
Werecall thatthevalue of the function f at the point $ E W' is $(f) The inverse images $
-1
(0)
, with
$
running through W'
and
.
0
through the open subsets of the space of real or complex numbers, form a subbase for o(W,W')
. For the complex case, the open circles
( z : I z-z
0
ICE)
form a subbase for the topology in the complex plane, so the inverse images $
-1
(z:lz-z
0
ICE)
form a subbase for
(f :FEW, I $ (f)-zol
<E)
,
o(W,W')
,
i.e., the sets
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Ch. 12,5891
depending upon the parameters
$,zo and
E
,
171
form a subbase for u(W,W')
.
The finite intersections
form a base for S
. Let S be one of these base sets, and fo E S . Then I$,(fo)-zkl < holds for
o(W,W')
is not empty. Let
k = l , . ..,n
the circle
E~
. Writing ck
-
I$
k
assume that
(f )-zkl = 6k O
for k = I ,
...,n
,
,
(z: Iz-zk I < E k )
(z: (z-$k(fo) 1 ~ 6 ~ is ) included in
so
It follows that the open neighborhood
with
6
=
min(61,...,6
the union of sets
) , is contained in the given set n of this kind, i.e., S = U(Uf:fES)
Uf the system of all sets
is a base for
parameters by
. Note
o(W,W')
. Then
. This
S
shows that
>
0
. We
shall denote the set
. Finally, we observe that the same result holds in
U(fo;$l,...,$n;6)
the real case.
(i) Addition and mZtipZication by (real o r compzex) o(W,W') In other oords, the space W equipped with the topoZogy O(W,~') i s a topoZogica2 vector space. THEOREM 89.1.
constants are continuous i n (ii)
The
o(W,W')
a Zinear subspace of
is
that a base set of this kind depends on the
E W' and 6
fo E W ;
S
W
(iii) The topoZogy
.
cZosure of any Zinear subspace o f
.
o(W,W')
i s Hausdorff.
W
i s again
ANNIHILATORS AND WEAK TOPOLOGIES
172
Ch. 12,1891
PROOF. (i) For the addition it is sufficient to observe that if fl+fi = f3
in W
and the neighborhood
U(f3;$1,...,$n;6)
is given, then
is a member of this neighborhood as soon as
f; E U(fl;$l,...,$n;i6) f;+f; and f; E U(f2;+1,...,$n;i6) For the multiplication, if f = a f 1 0 0 and V 1 = U(fl;$l,...,$n;6) , we have to prove the existence of a neighborhood
.
vo
of
fo and a neighbordood
af E V 1
f E Vo
for all
f E Vo
For
af-fl that
=
af-a f
l$k(af)-$k(fl)l (ii) Denote the
0 0
a l f + a2f2 E AA
point of
. By
,
=
(a-a )f 0
0
0
. We may
assume that
0 < 6 < 1
and from
+ a (f-f ) + (a-ao)(f-fo) 0 0
holds for k
< 6
o(W,W')
We have to show that if
in the complex plane such that
a
it follows from 0 < 6' < 6
a E Co
and
of
a E Co
. Let
V1
in the defintion of
Co
and all
...,n
I,
=
and
so
af E V 1
fl,f2 E A-
al,a2
and
i.e., every neighborhood
U
.
by
closure of the linear subspace A
.
A-
are constants, then of
a f + a2f2 I 1
part (i) there exist neighborhoods
contains a
U 1 and U2
of
f
and
a f' + a f' E U for all f; E U 1 and all 1 1 2 2 f2 are members of A , the neighborhoods u1 each contain at least one point of A Hence, choosing f; in
f2 respectively such that f; E U2 and
U2
U1
A
n
. Since
and
f l and
in U2 n A
f;
, we
.
have
a f' + a f' E U l A 1 1
desired result. (iii) W' exists
$
separates the points of
E W'
such that
neighborhoods U(f1;$;6)
$(fl) # and
W
$(f2)
U(f ; $ ; 6 ) 2
2 2
. This
is the
. Hence, if f l # f2 in W ,there . Let 6 = ~l$(fl)-$(f2)l . The are now disjoint,
so
o(W,W')
is Hausdorf f. THEOREM 98.2. (i) For any non-empty subset
if
A = '(Ao)
.
(iii) For any linear subspace
is
'(Ao)
.
of W'
B
the inverse
OB
i s o(W,W') closed. (ii) The linear subspace A of
annihilator
A
W
is o(W,W')
of W
the
closed if and only
o(W,W')
closure of
A
Ch. 12,8891
173
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
PROOF. (i) If OB =
0
B
$o , then
consists of one point
,
(f:$ 0 (f)=O)
{$ } = 0
and all we have to prove is that the complement be a point in the complement,
open. Let
(f:$o(f)#O)
fo U(fo;$o,~~$o(fo)~) is an open neighborhood of fo
is an interior point of the complement of
of
OB
is
If
so
. Hence,
OB
so
the complement
of
satisfies A
W
=
0
is closed by the result in (i).
Conversely, assuming that A
closed, we have to show that A
=
,
in '(Ao) fo
,
OB
, then
W'
is an intersection of closed sets. This shows that
.
set
fo disjoint from
is an arbitrary non-empty subset of
(ii) If the linear subspace A
than A
. The
~(w,w*) open.
B
OB
u(W,W')
is
$O(fo) # 0
so
0
0
(A )
. Since
A
either, i.e., $ (f ) # 0
Hence, let
0
fo be given such that
fo
. From
does not exist any
,
0
then A
is o(W,W')
fo
is not in A $,
for at least one
is not in A
there is a neighborhood V = U(fo;$l,...,$n;G) disjoint from A
is closed.
is not properly larger
In other words, we have to show that if
is not in '(Ao)
0
(A )
is trivially included
'(Ao)
it is sufficient to prove that
OB
of
. Since
A
,
then
E Ao
.
is closed,
fo such that V
is
the disjointness it follows in particular that there
g E A
satisfying $,(g)
=
$,(fo)
for k
= 1,
...,n
simultaneously. We introduce now a linear mapping complex number space
where $,, ...,$,
En
, defined
En
, and
no point
@(A)
g E A
from W
are the same elements of
definition of the neighborhood of
@
V
into n-dimensional
by
. The
W'
as occurring in the
image @ ( A )
is a proper subspace of
is mapped onto the point
En
is a linear subspace
because (as observed above)
($l(fo),...,$n(fo))
of
En
.
A s follows from simple linear algebra facts, there exists now a linear
subspace L $(A)
of
En
of dimension n-1 (a hyperplane) such that L
but does not contain the point
(fo),...,$n(fo))
contains
. Denoting the
ANNIHILATORS AND WEAK TOPOLOGIES
174
coordinates in En L C
be
C i = l ckzk = 0
ck $ k ( g ) = 0
$,(g)
by
Ch. 12,1891
...,zn , let the equation of the hyperplane
zI,
. Since
Q(A)
, we
is included in L
have
for every g E A , s o the point $, = Z ckOk E W' satisfies for every g E A , i.e., 4' E A' Furthermore, since
= 0
.
is not contained in L , we have C c $ (f ) # 0 , s o (@l(fO),...,$n(fO)) k k 0 @'(f0) # 0 Hence we have now that @'(f0) # 0 for at least one $, E Ao
.
.
This is the desired result. The reader who is familiar with the theory of locally convex vector spaces will easily see another proof. Since A
, there
in the locally convex topology u(W,W')
. Observing now
# 0
is a member of
W'
(iii) Let A '(Ao) A-
by
S
,
exists a
that every
for brevity. Then A
W with closure A
and denote
is included in the closed set S
is the smallest closed set including A
and
continuous linear functional
o(W,W') the proof is complete.
be a linear subspace of
o(W,W')
for all g E A
= 0
such that @,(g)
continuous linear functional $' $,(f0)
is a closed linear subspace
,
A c A- c S
so
. But
. It follows
that
-
The sets A
and
S
are closed linear subspaces (note that we use here that
the closure of a linear subspace is a linear subspace), so by part (ii) the
-
second and third terms in ( I ) are A be rewritten as
S c A- c S
and
respectively. Hence ( I ) can
S
. This shows that
A- = S
There exist similar theorems for o(W',W)
,
-
i.e., A
.
= 0 (A 0 )
. One might
as for o(W,W')
repeat the proofs. It is more illuminating, however, to observe that the theorems for a(W',W)
are in a certain sense the same as for o(W,W')
that no further proofs are necessary. Explicitly, observe that every
,
so
f E W
can be regarded as a linear functional on W' ; the value of the functional f at the point
$
E W'
is the number @(f)
. Different
functionals, since (due to our hypothesis that W'
of W ) for f, # f2 there exists at least one $ E W' $(fl) # $(f2)
. It follows that
W
if we look at the points
functionals on W' ). Then the topology o(W',W) and, for any non-empty subset B
such that
can be regarded as a linear subspace W"
of the space of all linear functionals on W' (i.e., W" but we use the notation W"
f give different
separates the points
of
W'
, the
is the same as W f of
W
is the same as
,
as linear u(W',W")
inverse annihilator OB
in W
Ch. 12,9891
175
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
. The followinn theorem follows now imme-
is the same as the annihilator Bo in W" diately.
THEOREM 89.3 (i) The system of a l l f i n i t e intersections
$o E W' ; f l , ...,f n E
depending upon the parameters base f o r t h e
.
topology i n W'
o(W',W>
w
and
6 > 0
, is a
(ii) Addition and multiplication by constants are continuous
operations i n the Hausdorff topology the annihilator
of
W
W'
is o(W',W)
w'
B of
o(W',W)
the
closure of
o(w',w)
any non-empty subset
closed. The linear subspace
closed if and only if B
=
B is
(OB)' (OB)'
. For .
P
,
is the Banach dual
then o(W,W')
usually called the weak topology in W = W
weak s t a r topology in W' closed sets in W
=
P
=
and
o(W
w*)
P' P
P
o(W',W)
and
is what is = a(w*,W ) P P
is the norm
that fail to be closed in the weak topology (unless
P
is of finite dimension), it is true that every norm closed linear sub-
W
P
space of of
W
W
is closed in the weak topology, i.e., any linear subspace
P
is weakly closed if and only if the subspace is norm closed. For
P
the proof, it is sufficient to show that the linear subspace A closed if A Since A
fo
is norm closed. Let
element $o E WE joint from A
, so
fo
is an interior point of the complement of
. Also,
0
(A )
closure of Let W
A
if A
of W
# 0
. It
fo
dis-
A (in the
P
is norm closed if and only if
is an arbitrary linear subspace of W the norm P '
is equal to )'A(' and W'
.
be as before, and let Z' be a linear subspace of W'.
It is not difficult to see that the topology o(Z',W)
in 2'
. It follows that the
is the
relative topology in Z' of
o(W',W)
closure of any subset D of
Z' is the intersection of Z' and the B is a linear subspace of
u(W',W)
closure of
.
is weakly closed. It is an immediate consequence
that the linear subspace A =
be a point i n the complement of A
= 0 for all f E A and $,(f0) is a weakly open neighborhood of
such that $o(f)
weak topology). Hence A 0
is weakly
is norm closed, there exists (by the Hahn-Banach theorem) an
follows that U(fo;$o;~l$o(fo)l)
A
B of
p
. Although in general there are many
W*
A
any linear subspace
is a normed vector space with respect to the norm
If W = W if W'
is
Ao
. For
o(W',W)
D
. In particular, if
o(Z',W) Z'
,
176
CARRIER OF A LINEAR FUNCTIONAL
then the o(Z',W)
B
closure of
0
is equal to
(
B) 0 fl Z'
. Hence,
Z' of any subset A
denoting the annihilator with respect to 0
AO , we have A" = A f l 2 ' , and for the o(Z',W) subspace B of Z' we can write ( 0 B) 0 = (0B) 0 course the o(Z',W)
Ch. 12,5901
of W
by
closure of the linear Z' Note that of
.
n
topology is Hausdorff, but it may happen that although
distinct members of W
act differently in W'
the smaller space Z' (i.e., '(W')
=
I01
they act
, but
identically on
it may be that
# I03
'(Z')
).
We conclude with the following theorem which will be of use later (cf. Theorem 106.2). THEOREM 8 9 . 4 (i) Let
A 1 and
A2
be linear subspaces o f
only the n u l l element i n comon and such that o f W' , i . e . , (AIbA2)0 = I03 Then Ao and
.
1
element i n comon. If, i n addition, A 1 and
0 A1
0
0
separates the points of W
A2
(ii) Similarly, l e t
B 1 and
w , i.e.,
' ( B ~ ~ B ~ )= C O I
. Then
then
OB1 e
0
,
f E $ = 0
so
o
$(f) =
. This shows
n
0
A2
for all
that :A
A]
so
=
A 01
0
(A1) and A2
@
A20
=
):A('
, then f E A] 0
and A2
Assume now that, in addition, A1 0
and
B2 separates the points o f
PROOF. (i) If $ E A l
a(W,W') = {O}
.
W
closed, then W', having
separates the points
B I 0 B2 OB2 have only the null
OBI and
element i n common. If, i n addition, B, 0
are
be linear subspaces o f
B2
, having
A2
0 0 , i . e . , o2(AI@A2)
only the null element i n common and such that of
@
A2d A
W
separates the points have only the n u l l
A
B2
are
, i.e.,
o(W',W) 0
closed,
0
( B l b B2)0 =
$(f) = 0 for all
I01
f E A1
.
and all
8 , i.e., $ E (A 1@A 2lo = I O I , so have only the null element in comon.
and A2
. Then
are
o(W,W')
closed, so
separates the points of W
(ii) Similarly.
90. The carrier of an order bounded linear functional
Before investigating further the properties of the null ideal and bhe carrier of an order bounded linear functional, we prove a certain decomposition lemma with some corollaries.
Ch. 12,5901
177
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Let
LEMMA 90.1.
and
P
be Riesz seminorms on the Riesz space L
A
L is a A-Cauchy
such that every monotone order bounded sequence in sequence. Furthermore, l e t
c1 W
p(un)
izn}
<
.
m
L+
in (a)
0 2 u
Then, f o r any
5
> 0
E
u E L
, there
(b)
A(wn)
(c)
u
n
5 z
n
PROOF. Let
n
4
u
5
,
n
5
and
,
=
n
,
... um
+
ZY;
(. =
z
n
C
n
C 0 as
that p(zn)
-.
and it follows from +
-u.
for all n
E
. Furthermore, since
(x -u. ) + x. 5 x. for n i,m 1 1 for all n Ogserving that u 5 x xn-yn 5 zn n n ' yn+zn for all n By the Riesz decomposition property there have
xn-yn
_<
.
.
exist sequences {v,} 0 S v 5 z n n
such that
let
, we
S
...,um )
n,m is a X-Cauchy
increases. For brevity, write
. Then
inf(x l,...,x )
=
u
5
yn
n
z
n n,m For every" n
we get un
twn3
= sup(un,
set u
en)
S u , so
increases as n
We may assume that m z
,
.
n n,m m sequence. Hence, there exists a natural number m
n,m x =nu
{vnl
,
be given. For every n
> 0
E
,
n
f o r aZZ
n
C 0
p(zn)
for all
< E
= v +w
n
and
C
n
for m > n . Then u
n
and
e x i s t sequences
such that
0 5 v
x = u
...
n = 1,2,
for
and
{wn}
and
0 5 wn 5 yn
in L+
for all n
such that u
n
= v +w
. The conditions
n
n
with
(a), (b), (c)
are now satisfied. COROLLARY 90.2. ~(2,)
j.
(i) I f
0 i n concZusion
(ii) If
A(f)
I Cp(f)
p
is a Riesz norm i n L
, then
(a) of the l e m a implies t h a t f o r some
concZusions of t F z lemma hold i f
un
C > 0
zn
f E L
and a l l
E L+ f o r all n and
PROOF. (i) Evident. (ii) The lemma becomes trivial. Since ZA(un) <
-
zn C
.
and
j.
0
,
then the
CP(U,)
, there is
<
a natural
CARRIER OF A LINEAR FUNCTIONAL
I78
number N v
n zn
=
N
0
, wn
=
z
=
sup (u,,
n
=
such that X(un) u
=
n
...,UN) .
and for n
Let
COROLLARY 90.3.
(c)
u
$(f)
n
5
already i f
...,N
. For
,
n > N
take wn = 0 , v
=
n
take
u
and
n
0
...
n
c
u E L+ for a l l n
PROOF. A(f) = $(lfl)
,
n
v +w f o r a l l n n
~p(f) f o r some
+
p(zn)
5
=
I,
N
_<
(b)
0
=
2
be a Riesz seminomi i n L and l e t
P 0
v 5 z + and n n $(wn) < E for a l l
(a)
If
o
>
E
for all n
E
E L".
5 $
u 2 u E L f o r n = l,Z, and Cp(un) < m n , t h e r e e x i s t sequences {vn} , {wn} , {znl i n L+
Furthermore, l e t again Then, for any such t h a t
<
Ch. 12,5901
0
.
,
. and a l l
> 0
n and
f E L , the conclusions hold
Cp(un) <
m
satisfies the conditions of the lemma.
Let L be a Riesz space As observed already in section 87, for any $ E L"
the set = (f:fEL,l$l Ifl)=O)
N($)
,
is an ideal in L
called the n u l l i d e a l or absolute kernel of is called the carrier of
disjoint complement C ( $ ) = {N($)Id
$
$I
. The
. This
notion should be distinguished from the notion of the carrier of an ideal of measurable functions, as defined in section 86. The null ideal of should also be distinguished from the n u l l space of of all f E L
satisfying $(f) = 0
null space of
$
of
C($)
N($)
and
.
0
i s the band i n L" 0
( t h e r o l e s of (ii)
C($)
=
$
E L"
generated by
and
W
C(l$l)
I t follows then t h a t
(iii) F o r
and
.
$
and
W'
We have $
and
o~
N($)
$
which is the set is contained in the
If convenient, we shall write N 4
THEOREM 90.4 (i) For any
of
. Evidently, N($)
$
=
C
$
N(l$l)
instead
= ' 8 ,
where
i s the inverse a n n i h i l a t o r
are now taken over by
L
and L" 1.
and p ( f ) = I $ l ( l f l ) i s a Riesz norm on C($) $ i s Archimedean. $ p o s i t i v e t h e nu12 i d e a l of sup($,$) i s the
C($)
.
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Ch. 12,1901
i n t e r s e c t i o n of null ideal
and
N($)
L
For (v) (vi) For C
PROOF.
E L"
c (N )dd J
the
$ E L"
.
then N($)
Archimedean and
$,$
$
I t follows t h a t f o r any
i s the i n t e r s e c t i o n o f N ( $ + ) and N($-) is a o-ideal. I f $ E L i , then N ( $ )
N ( $ ) = N(I$/)
(iv) If 4 E L,: i s a band.
.
N($)
179
,
0 # $ E L:
- -
we have
# I03
C($)
.
we have
C IC $
J
,
C c (N$)
dd
J,
.
(i), (ii) and (iv) are evident from the definitions. In (ii)
we use that every normed Riesz space is Archimedean. This follows immediately nu S v
by observing that
0
all n
is the norm),
(where p
(iii) For
(v) For
5
J,
and
$
for n so
...
l,Z,
=
implies p(nu)
, i.e.,
p(u) = 0
t
=
L ,
E L i and L Archimedean the null ideal N 8 C is L itself. Hence, if $ 0 $ = 0 It follows that 0 # $ E L i implies d c ( N ~ )implies ~ ~ C$ I ( N ~ =) (N$) ~ ~ = ~c $
c Ic +
J
,
.
so
c
(vi)
$
C IC $
*
{ll;}
and
Hence
C$(un)
Since p(f) 90.2(i). {Vn}
,
-
$ = 0
(inf($,$)}(u)
such that u = u +u'
in L+
< =
$(If!)
and
0
n
5
u n
n 5 u
and J, and
Cb # I01
, we
have
.
. Conversely,
are positive. Let $(un)+$(u;)
for all n
is a norm on C
, {zn} in
0
= {O}
$
L+
0 5 u
E
that there exist sequences {un}
, we
As a result we find that for any
{w,}
4
C
J,
PROOF. We may assume that
It follows from
J,
is a band and
N
JI E L,: then C c N w i t h $ E L-and $ J , C c (N ) dd by p a r t (vi) of t h e l a s t theorem). $ 4
THEOREM 90.5. If $ 1 (and hence
.
( ~ $ 1=~ ( N ~ dd )
implies C$ c
for
positive we have
the band generated by N
.
u = 0
p(v)
5
such that 0
5
5
. Now we
2-n
C $ *
and
for all n
.
apply Corollary 90.3.
can combine this with Corollary E
v
n
> 0 5 z
there exist sequences n
J. 0
, v(wn)
<
E
and
I80
Ch. 12.1901
CARRIER OF A LINEAR FUNCTIONAL
. Then
for all n u =v+w n n n which implies that
u:
= u-u
=
n
u-vn-wn ,
.
u-v
so
n
ul+w n n'
=
-
u Z u-v Z u-z +u Hence, since J, is u-order continuous by n , so $(u) 5 E This holds hypothesis, we have J,(u-vn) + $ ( u ) as n +
with
for every
,
> 0
E
$(u) = 0
so
,
i.e., u E N
J , .
i s Archimedean and i f
THEOREM 90.6. If L
following conditions are equivalent: (i) $ I J, , (ii) C c N $
J,
PROOF. (i)
(iii)
'
(ii). If $ I J,
=$
.
with
$
C
E L z and
$
IC
4
(iv)
J I '
*
(ii)
(iii). C c N J
I C
J , .
(iii) c (iv).
L
and
,
$
c Ic $
J
, which
implies CJ,c (N$)dd
$
c4
is equivalent to
,
is Archimedean, we have
(Nj)dd
N
=
E Ln , the N
C c $
E Lz , then C c N
last theorem.
cQ
J,
J,.
4
9 '
by the
is equivalent to
.
c ( N ~ ) Since ~ ~
C c N
Hence
N
$
E :L
J,
J,'
(iv) * (i). The linear functional oo = 101 A I J , ! satisfies +o E L; (since J, E Lx ), so N($O) is a band. Furthermore $o vanishes on N 4 Since C C N this implies that $o vanishes on C @ N and on N so
C
J,'
$
0
N
$
$
is the whole space L But then
$,
J,'
is contained in N ( $ O ) =
0
,
, it
. Since the band
follows now that the band
i.e., 191
lJ,l = 0
A
THEOREM 90.7. (i) If 0 < $ E L"
(ii) If 0
5 $
E L"
c($AJ,) =
and
c nc $
0 5 $
,
=
Bd
and
(AnB)dd = Add n Bdd so
so
0
I J,
$
S J,
N($O)
.
$
C
$
$ '
@
N
$
is equal to L
E L" , then
E L" , then
J,'
(i) Note first that N($VJ,) Theorem 90.4(iii),
and
and
PROOF. We recall that for ideals A d A
generated by
.
= N(@+J,)
C(@vJ,) = C($+J,)
and =
N
$
B
nN J
in L
,
we have
(A+B)d =
by the proof of
. Furthermore,
.
Ch. 12,5901
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
181
so
x
(ii) Write $ =
$]+x
and
$ =
= $
J,
A
JII+x
for brevity. Let
$
=
1
$-x
q1
and
=
J,-x
. Then
with all functionals involved positive. It follows
that N Furthermore,
+'
=
n NX and N J,
N($])
1 $,
with
0
5 $
1
=
N(JIl) ll NX
E L"
and
.
0i
E Lc
,
so
c($,)
c N($~)
by Theorem 9 0 . 5 . Since
we find
so
EXAMPLE 90.8. We have proved that if
0 < $ E L"
then C($A$) = C($) n C($) and C c N if @ J , necessarily hold if it is only given that $ of
L"
. By
way of example, let
L
$
I JI
and
be the space
JI
and
0 < $
E Li ,
. This does not
are positive elements
C(CO.11)
of all real
182
Ch. 1 2 , § 9 0 1
CARRIER OF A LINEAR FUNCTIONAL
continuous functions on the interval C 0 , l l , let f f L
and let $(f)
I01 f dx
=
for all
, where (rn:n=1,2, ...) is the set
2-"f(rn)
=
$(f)
. Then $ and J, are strictly positive, = C = L . It is easily seen that if J,,(f) = . This holds for all n = 1,2 ,... , s o $ I J,
of all rational numbers in C 0 , l l so
N
$
=
J
N
I
= 2-"f(tn)
and
= {O}
, then
$
C
I J,n
k
are disjoint, neither
J
JIn
J, = supk .InE1
(because
$
,
) . The example shows that although
C$ c N J ,
or
C cN
J
I
nor
$
C($AJI)
C$ fl C
=
It will be indicated in Exercise 90.14 and 90.15 that if
L
JI
and
$
holds.
J,
has the
Egoroff property, then the situation is improving, because in this case C($A$)
C
=
C
$
fl C J
N
generated by If A
$ A JI = 0
holds for all positive $,I) and
,
, but
is perhaps not included in N
JI
J,'
,
is an ideal in an Archimedean Riesz space L
an order dense ideal. In particular therefore, if
+
(Ng)dd
is the band generated by the ideal NQ
some condit
L
.
THEOREM 90.9.
(i) I f
L
projection property, then L (ii) I f
property and
+ ldd
(N
8,
c
+
*
i s an integraZ on
$
L = N eC
N
0
i s a band in
L L
, then
. Hence,
projection property, then L
is
L has the
L has the projection $
i s a normal integral on
L
i n t h i s case we have
=
(N )dd $
C
4
8
= (N+)d
(N+)d
=
For the present proof we may also assume that $ is Archimedean, so have
=
all w n
N
$
@
sup(t$(w):O<%u,wEC in Cg
I
. Hence, if
L
,
so
(N9)dd
case the proof is trivial. Let us assume now that
a
Ad
$ '
PROOF. (i) By definition we have
Let
0
C+
0
i s Dedekind o-complete o r i f =
L i s Dedekind a-complete or i f
i f and only i f
0
. Under
then A
E L"
is an order dense ideal. The same is true for is equal to
implies that
it is included in the o-ideal
L
@
C
$
has the in this
is Dedekind o-complete
is positive. The space L
is order dense. Hence, given 0 < u E L
C
p
4)
, we
. There exists a sequence 0 < wn 4 < u with . Since L is Dedekind o-complete,
such that +(wn) I. a
Ch. 12,1901
183
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
the element wo
=
sup wn
exists in Cb
. Then
wo
u
, and we shall prove
and
sup(wo,w) > w 0 ’
S
that
If n o t , there exists w E C so
it follows from
0 5 w 5 u
such that
0
SUP(W0,W) - sup(wn,w)
5
wO-wn
that
which implies (since 0
is strictly positive on
~(suP(wn,w~-wn)
> 0
O(sup(wo,w)-wo)
2
C
0
) that
.
But the expression on the left tends to zero (since $(wn) 4 a ,
so
that
,w)) tends likewise to a ). Thus we get a contran diction. Hence formula (1) holds. Observe now that for 0 5 v E N and
necessarily Qi(sup(w 0 5 w
E C0 the condition v+w
conditions v
S
u
and w 5 u
u
0
is equivalent to the separate
(since v+w
sup(v,w)
=
in view of the
condition that v I w ) . Hence, writing
we find for any fixed v1 E N
and so
u
0
with
0
S
v1
5
u
that
is an upper bound of A . Evidently, every upper bound of
greater than or equal to u , s o
u = sup A
. Then
A
is
CARRIER OF A LINEAR FUNCTIONAL
184
so
wo E C
(ii) If
$
L = N
0
Hence $
u = (u-w ) + wo
It follows that L = (Nm)Bd
$ *
N
. Hence
u-wo E (N$)dd
$
@
u-wo E (N$)dd
with
C
0 ‘
dd is a band, s o N = (Ng) 4 qJw by part (i). Conversely, assume that 0 5 $ E L and
C
$
N $
=
(B
by part (i).
C 4
L
$(vn)
J. a
0 < vo
5
N
=
= a
$
@
C
it may be assumed now that u
$
. There
. Let us
is a sequance v
such that
.
inf(vo,uo) < vo =
’0
6
is strictly positive on
- inf(v
v
T
in L
. In
for all
T
4 0
E C
$
-
u ) 2 vo
n’ 0
. Let
such that vn C and
vo Then there exists also an element
4 (vo-inf(v o,uo)) since $
u
Tn assume that there exists an element
for all n
vn
(u,:T€{T})
= u
.
We have to prove that
$ ( u T ) J. 0 holds for any downwards directed system
infT $ ( u , )
and
is a normal integral, then N
is a band. Then L
view of
Ch. 12,1901
such that
, so
1
C
$ ’
It follows from
inf(vo,uO)
that
.
for all n Now we have $(v ) C a so $(inf(vn,uo)) < $(vn) - B n there exists a natural number no such that < a-48
$(inf(vno,uo)) The system of all u u T!
This contradicts inf, $ ( u , ) = a
a
=
0
,
i.e.,
EXERCISE 90.10. and
$*(f)
=
f(0)
functionals on L $,
and
+2
so
.
is directed downwards, so there exists an element
in the system satisfying u
Hence
,
$(u,)
Let
C 0
5
inf(v no,~O)
. Hence
. It follows that .
‘1
L = C(E0,ll)
for all f E L such that N ( $ , )
,
. Show that
then
and
is a band and
$ ( u T ) < a-16 1
vn 4 0
,
so
$(vn)
ji’2
.
4
0
if
$l(f)
$2
are positive linear
N($2)
=
.
f(x)dx
i s not. Note that
are singular linear functionals by Example 87.5.
Ch. lZ,§9Ol
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
185
EXERCISE 90.11. Let L be the RBesz space of all real functions f on [0,11 any
E
[O,ll
>
for which there exists a real number f(m)
0
, we
have
. Show that if
If(x)-f(m)l $l(f)
=
for all f E L
f(m)
such that, given
for at most finitely many
> E
, then 0,
x
in
is a non-
normal positive integral on L with
, but
an order dense ideal in L
not a band. Show also that if
(an:n=1,2,...) is a sequence of positive numbers such that Xan < $ (f) = .Eanf(n-l) is a positive normal integral on L such that 2
.
m
, then
is a positive non-normal integral such
N($*) C N($l) Hence, $ = that N($) = N ( I $ ~ ) is a band.
EXERCISE 90.12. For the proof of Exercise 90.14 we need the following 0 5 $ E L- and
result, a particular case of much more general result. Let 0
5
u
E L
.
Show that the integral component $
of
$
satisfies
n HINT: Denote the right hand side by Show first that Or(u+v)
5
or
is additive on
+ gr(v)
$,(u)
. For
L+
$ (u)
. Evidently
. It is evident that
0
5
$,(u)
5
$(u).
the inverse inequality, apply the Riesz
decomposition theorem to a sequence 0 < w 4 u+v satisfying n lim $(wn) < $,(u+v) + E . It follows that $r can be extended as a ppsitive linear functional on L
.
Show now that $r is countably additive on L+
by observing first that, by definition,
.
.
Let u = Cv For the proof that $,(u) = Z$r(vn) , let E > 0 For every n n , there exists C vnk = vn with Ck $(vnk) < $r(vn) + c/Zn Then w = Cn j=l CA=l B vjk satisfies 0 s w t u and $(wn) < C Ipr(v.) + E for all n J n Hence $,(u) is < Z $,(v.) The inverse inequality is evident. Thus $r J It-follows that $r 5 OC an integral satisfying 0 5 $ 5 $ Since It follows also Q c 5 $ , the definition of $r implies that ($=)= 5 $r
.
from the definition that
.
.
($c)r
.
=
$c
. Hence
$c
2
$r
.
.
.
186
CARRIER OF A LINEAR FUNCTIONAL
EXERCISE 90.13.
Show t h a t i f
Ch. 12,1903
has t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y , t h e n i n
L
t h e p r e c e d i n g e x e r c i s e t h e infimum i s a t t a i n e d . HINT: For every n a t u r a l number
that
s Q c ( u ) + n-'
$(un,)
for a l l
0 5 v
p r o p e r t y t h e r e i s a sequence
. Then
m,n
. Hence
j = j (m,n)
appropriate
Let
Show t h a t i f
0 5 Q E L"
(ii)
Show t h a t i f
0
Q
ll C
JI'
= 0
$,(u)
0 5 u i.e.,
n
4 u
u
to the
.
. By t h e d e f i n i t i o n of u
such t h a t
v
u
such
t h e Egoroff
s u
m .) 5 Qc(u) + n'j "3 l i m $(vm) Qc(u)
5 Q(u
, so
m
and
,
$ E L"
implies
0 5 u E L
f o r an for all
.
Q
then
$
, but
I CJI
b e given. S i n c e
C
.
, then
0 s JI E L"
and C
i s singular, then C(Q) = C($c)
0
.
= {O]
C(QhJI) =
n o t conversely. i s s i n g u l a r , we have
fj
Furthermore, by t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y , t h e r e e x i s t s a sequence
0 5 Q(un) I. QC(u)
such t h a t
E N for all n n Q o - i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by
(ii)
m
0 s Q E L"
Hence, Q I JI
HINT: ( i ) Let
+
+
unk
have t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y .
L
(i)
( i i i ) Show t h a t i f = C
t h e r e i s a sequence
k
Q(vm)
Q(vm) 5 Q C ( d f o r a l l
EXERCISE 90.14.
n
Since
0 2 $ = $;+QS
0
( i i i ) Note t h a t i f
. This N
Ib'
, so
$(un) = 0
shows t h a t every It f o l l o w s t h a t
= Qc v
Q = Qc+$,
Qs
and
and
0
C
u E L+
belongs
=
= {O}.
0
(Nib) d
, we
C(Qs) = { O }
JI
JI +JI
=
n
for a l l
E
S
,
have
, then
so
EXERCISE 90.15. implies
Q I$ (i) that
C
Q
It w a s proved i n Theorem 90.4 t h a t
CQ c (N$)dd
Show t h a t i f
L L
and
Q I JI
implies
and conversely.
has t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y , t h e n
i s c o n t a i n e d i n t h e o-ideal generated by
( i i ) Show t h a t i f
Q,$ E L"
N
JI'
has t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y and
N(I
$1
hlJI1)
i s order
dense in L HINT:
,
then C
= 0
that J,(u,!
$
+
IN 1
is contained in the band
(i) We may assume that $
then from $ I $ J,,(u)
187
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Ch. 12,§911
that C$ c N(Jlc)
and
, 80
N
$ '
are positive. It follows
J,
any
generated by
0
. But then, as above, there exists a
<
u E C
satisfies
$
sequence 0
5
u -t u
such
n
= O for all n , and so u is a m e m b e r o f t h e o - i d e a l g a n e r a t e d b y N
. There exists a directed system 0 < u 4 u for all T . Note that uT E C for every T such that u E N(l$lhl$I) $ and also that $ I $ holds in the ideal N ( l $ l h l J I I ) . Hence, by part (i), every u belongs to the o-ideal generated by N . Then u E IN 1 for $ T $ all T , 5 0 u E {Nql . (ii) Let 0
5
u E C+
$
EXERCISE 90.16. Let the Archimedean space L have the Egoroff property and let $,$ E L". dd I~(l$lhl$l)1 = L
.
Prove that C I C
$ 4 J
if and only if
91 Complex Riesz spaces All Riesz spaces investigated in the preceding sections are reel vector spaces. We shall now extend some parts of the theory to complex Riesz spaces. Given the Riesz space L L
x
of all pairs
L
(f,g)
with
, we
f and
g
equip the Cartesian product in L with a vector space
structure in the usual manner by defining that
(a+iB)(f,g)
=
(af-Bg,Bf+ag)
for a,B
real numbers,
and the so defined complex vector space is denoted by
L+iL
with
f nad
(f,O) E L+iL
g in L
, the
, we
space L
write
. Instead of
. Also, if h E L + iL and h f+ig € Re h . Identifying f E L and
(f,g) we appropriately write f+ig
=
=
is embedded in L+iL
as a real linear sub-
space. The so defined complexification of a given (real) Riesz space L
is
only of interest if it is possible to define the notion of the absolute value
Ihl
of an element h E L + iL
in such a manner that for h E L
new absolute value coincides with the existing one in complex numbers we would like to define
L
. Just as for
the
I88
Ch. 12,1911
COMPLEX RIESZ SPACES
Ihl ,Note th
=
(
sup Re(he-ie):0<8<2n
).
if this supremum exists in L
, then
Ihl
occur in pairs, for 8 and
elements Re(he-ie)
)
=
2
, since t ie , and such that
0
B+n
-Re(he-').
Hence, if the supremum exists, then
For the special case that =
, so
h cos 0
h
is an element of
, we
L
-i€l have Refhe ) =
the supremum exists and is equal to the already existing
absolute value
Ihl
=
sup(h,-h)
.
To derive a simple condition sufficient for the existence of the desired supremum, we first consider the complexification of the Riesz space C(X) space X
of all real continuous functions on a compact Hausdorff
. Taking the complex function
the ordinary abslute value
Ihl
/ h /= (f2+g2)1/2
h
=
f+ig with
f,g
in
C(X)
,
satisfies
E C(X) ,
but also Ihl
=
supg Re(he-ie)
=
supe (f cose+g sine)
,
where the supremum must be taken with respect to the ordering in the Riesz space C(X) function
.That the last supremum exists and that it is equal to the is seen by observing that, for every fixed x E X
(f2+g2)l12
the number Re(h(x)e-ie)
is less than or equal to
with equality holding for exactly one value of h(x) that
# 0 , and equality for all 0 if h(x) Ihl
is on X
f cose+g sine
, and
,
=
0
0
(depending on x ) if
. It follows, therefore
the pointwise supremum of the functions so
Ihl
is also the supremum of this set of functions
Ch. 12,5911
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
with respect to the ordering in
189
.
C(X)
We observe furthermore that, bytheYosida representation theorem in section 4 5 , if the Riesz space L
is Archimedean and has a strong unit,
then there exists a compact Hausdorff space X isomorphic to a linear subspace of complete, then L
. If
C(X)
such that L in addition L
is Riesz is uniformly
, as proved
is isomorphic to the whole space C(X)
in Theorem 45.4. This implies the following result.
If
LEMMA 91.1.
L
is Archimedean and uniformly complete, then
f cos8+g sin8:0<8<2n
exists i n
L
for a l l
PROOF. Let
f
f and
and
g
g in
L
I
in L be given. For every
we
8(/0<8<2n)
have
,
If cos8+g sinel < If1 + lgl so all elements
in L by
f cos8+g sin8 are members of the ideal A
generated
. According to what was observed above, the ideal
If1 + lgl
is Riesz isomorphic to a space C(X)
with
f and
Hence, denoting the images of
g
X
compact and Hausdorff.
in C(X)
by
f^
and
g-
respectively, the supremum
exists in C(X)
, and
sup8(f
)
cos8+g sine
exists in the ideal A THEOREM 91.2.
so by the isomorphism
, and
hence exists in L
If L i s Archimedean and uniformly complete, then ):0i852n)
e x i s t s for every
.
h
=
f+ig E L+iL
, and
=
sup(f
we have
cos8+g sin8:0<8<2*
A
I90
Ch. 12,§911
COMPLEX RIESZ SPACES
Furthermore, Ihl
only for h
0
=
= 0
, ;Ah1 = Ihl.Ihl f o r
a complex
A
nwnber, and the t r i a n g l e i n e q u a l i t i e s
hold. Since any Dedekind o-complete space i s Archimedean and uniformly complete (as proved i n s e c t i o n 3 9 ) , these r e s u l t s hold i n p a r t i c u l a r i f
L
i s Dedekind o-complete. PROOF. The existence of already by taking 0
and
Ih( follows from the last lemma. A s observed together, we get
8+s
= sup(1f
IRe(he-ie)l:05052n) Taking
8 = 0
and
8
= I *, we
find that
If1
cos8+g sinel : 0 5 8 < 2 ~ lhl
2
and
lgl
5
. The
lhl
second form of the triangle inequality follows by observing that IhlI - Ih21 2 Ihl-h21 and
-
.
Ih2-hlI = Ih1-h2 I In Exercise 91.12 it will be indicated how to prove the existence of
Ihl
lh21
lh,l
5
without using that any principal ideal in L
space C(X)
is isomprphic to a
.
The dominated deoomposition property (also called the Riesz decomposition property) carries over to the complex case. THEOREM 91 . 3 . (Dominated decomposition property. 1 I f
Archimedean and uniformly complete, and i f
in that
L+ s a t i s f y h
=
Ihl
IhlI 5 f l
hl+h2 w i t h
PROOF. The ideal A to the space C(X) space X
, and
md
Ih21
generated in L
5
by
h l and
f2
.
f-+ig^
h2 i n
fl,f2 L+iL such
fl+f2 is Riesz isomorphic
of all real continuous functions on a compact Hausdorff
function identically one on X =
f+ig E L+iL and
=
the isomocphism is such that the image of
corresponding to and h-
h
f I+f2 , t h e n there e x i s t
5
is
L
...
f,g,
. We denote the functions in
in A
. Note that
fl+f2 is the
by
f-,g-,
...
,
so
1h-l = Ihl- 2 (f 1+f 2 ) -
C(X)
(fl+f2)= 1
. We
= 1
on X
define h;
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Ch. 12,8911
and h;
in
and
are the images of elements h l and
so
h2
and 5
by
h;
h-f;
=
and
h;
=
h2
. Furthermore, since the images of
hl+h2 = h
Ih;l Ih,I
C(X)+iC(X)
I91
Ih21
f l and
,
it follows from
Ih21
5
Ih;l
.
f2
5
f;
and
.
h-fThe functions 2 h; in A+iA , and
IhlI and lh21
Ih2j
f;
5
are
that
In view of these theorems it is reasonable to assume now, in the further investigation of a complex Riesz space L+iL
,
that L
is
Archimedean and uniformly complete. h l and
THEOREM 91.4. (i) I f
h2 i n
L+iL s a t i s f y
IhlI J.
then Ih,-h21 = Ihl+h21 = IhlI + Ih21 h = f+ig with
(ii) I f
f and
=
Ilhll-lh21I
sup(1h
=
g positive, then
f cosO+g sinO:O
.
(iv)
I f
lgll 5 1g21
h = f+ig and
h'
If I + ilgl with
=
f +igl and h2 1 , then IhlI 5 Ih21 hl
=
.
PROOF. (i) For arbitrary 2 inf(f
Hence, if h l and
f )
1' 2
h2
0 = 2 inf(lh
=
f2
in L we have
fl+f2 + Ifl-f21
in L+iL
1
2
f l and
g in
with Ifl[ 5 If2/
f +ig2
=
f and
I,Ih
2
I)
satisfy =
Ih
1
I
+ Ih2b
- I IhlI-lh21I
.
L
, then
and
COMPLEX R I E S Z SPACES
192
Ch. 12,1911
Combining these results we get the desired equalities. (ii)
Since f and g
are positive, we can restrict ourselves to
o s e s f ~ i . (iii) Let and
0
5 8 5
$a be fixed. We consider also the numbers
. For the given
-(Ti-e)
8
-0,v-8
in L
we take the element f cose+g sine
and we take also the corresponding elements f o r the other three values. We compute the supremum pe -8
, we
of these four elements. Taking first
8
and
get
Similarly, the supremum of the two remaining elements is
Hence
by part (i ), it follows that (iv) 1by
lg2
Ihl = Ih'I
Let h l = f +igl and
. Then
f,I
= f +ig,
f +ig2 are disjoint
2
1
Note as a corollary that h
.
h2 = f +ig2 with
and h2 = 1 (i.e., lh,l I /h21 ) if and only if both f l and g l k Also, if h = Z both f2 and g2 with all n=l 'nhn joint, then
.
1
5
If2]
and
2
are disjoint from h
mutually dis-
193
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Ch. 1 2 , § 9 1 1
Freudenthal's spectral theorem can also be extended to the complex case, as follows. THEOREM 9 1 . 5 . Let h
=
L be Dedekind o-complete and l e t
( w i t h f and
f+ig
g in
L
)
satisfy
Ihl
5
e
e E L+
. Furthermore,
be a p o s i t i v e number. Then there e x i s t d i s j o i n t components e and complex numbers
with
Iy
n
I
5
1
for
n
PROOF. Since L
yl,
=
I,
...,yk
and let
...,ek
E
of
el,
such t h a t
...,k
is Dedekind u-complete, we can apply Freudenthal's
spectral theorem for the real case. Hence there exist disjoint components ei -1
,...,e'P S
a
m
5 1
,..., aP
e and real numbers a l
of
for m
= 1,
...,p
such that
satisfying Cp e' = e and 1 m
It may be assumed here that for a 2 0 we have a e t 5 f + and for m m m a < 0 we have la e'I 5 fHence l a e'] 5 If1 for m = 1 , ...,p m m m m m Similarly, there exist disjoint components ey, e" of e and real
.
numbers j = I , ...,q
,,...,
satisfying Cq e" 1 j such that fiq
=
.
e and
..., 4 -1
5
.
B.
J
5 1
for
Note that some of the am for j = 1 , . . . , q and l!'ejBl 5 lgl and j ' may be zero. Let e = inf(e' e ' ! ) for all m and j involved. Then all mj m' J = e and e are mutually disjoint, C . e mj m~ mj
Hence, writing
ymj =
am+iB , we have j
COMPLEX RIESZ SPACES
194 Ih-C y e I mj mj mj
IBjemjI
.
e'I 5 If/ and IB.e'!l 5 lgl that lamemjl 5 I f 1 J J m m l g / for all m and j Hence, by part (iv) of the
It follows from
and
5 Ee
Ch. 12,§911
5
la
.
preceding theorem, we find for all m
and
j
that
.lemj = Iymjemj I = lamem j+iB.e jmj'' mJ
(y
If+igl = Ihl
e
5
= C
mjemj
'
which implies
(
Iy .lemj = inf I y .lemj,ly
mJ
.
mJ
. lemj
mJ
This shows that lymjl 5 1 for all m and j .lemj 2 e mJ mj # 0 , we get satisfying e # 0 Renumbering the elements e mj mj so
Iy
.
Ih-C y e I I n n
k
5 Ee
...,ek
for appropriate disjoint components e l , yI,...,yk
and comp ex numbers
bf absolute va ue at most one. Since
follows from the triangle inequality that
II
k
I c 1Ynen
k hl -CnI ynI en
The subset A
of
5 Ee
.
L iL is called an i d e a l if A is a complex linear IhlI 5 Ihl with h E A and h l E L+iL implies
subspace of L+iL and if hl E A
. This is the same definition, therefore, as
for an ideal in a real
Riesz space. The set of all real elements in the ideal A will be denoted by
Ar
,
i.e., Ar
=
(f:f€AllL)
.
Evidently, h = f+ig € A with f are members of
A
r'
and of course
and Ihl
g
in L
implies that f
is also a member of A,
.
and
g
Ch. 12,5911
195
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
If A i s an ideal i n L+iL, then Ar is an idea2 i n Ar+iA . Conversely, i f B i s an ideal i n L , then B+iB
THEOREM 91.6.
L
, and
A
=
i s an ideal in
L+iL, and
PROOF. Let A A
A n L
=
g E A =
. It is easy to see that . Note now that for any g E L we have . It follows that for real f and g we
ig E A
if and only if
if and only if
.
A +iA r r Conversely, let
1
h E A
f +ig, with
=
1
Ihl I If1 + lgl
If A
.
and
and
B
A + B so
A+B
=
f
= f
(A+B)r = Ar+Br f E
and
and
E B
1
. Also,
.
It follows
satisfies
. This
=
g1+g2
.
Let
A
If1
8
5
(that is to
B having the decampo-
. Then
lgl
A IB ,
If1 = I f l /+ If2/ and
lgl
IflI 5 1g,1 so
=
If1
of
L+iL
and
1g,/ + 1g21
is called a band if the real part Ar subset D
.
A n B = {O}
) if and only if
follows by observing that
in L+iL
,
.
is a
the d i s j o i n t complement
is defined similarly as in the real case by =
d (
hEL+iL:lhlIlfl
It is evident that Dd fo = sup(f:fEE) f E E' satisfies
).
for all FED
is an ideal in L+iL
For this purpose, let E that
g
. Furthermore, A I B
A and g E B
. For any non-empty D
Every
Similarly
g be elements of
g
have the decompositions
D
If1 + lgl E B
so
(Ar+B ) + i(A,+B,)
lgl
Dd of
.
=
IfZ[ 5 1g21
The ideal A
,
B
fl E B
so
+ Br + iBr
+ iAr
A
and
band in L
,
the algebraic sum A+B
for all +f
so
and A = B+iB . Then A is . firtermore, let h = f+ig and lhll IIhI . We have to prove that h l E A .
,
In this case, let f sitions
Ar , and
are members of
are ideals in L+iL
is an ideal and
say, If1 I lgl
g
g are members of
f
IflI
that h l E A
and
L+iL
and
The elements IIhli S
f
B be an ideal in L
a complex linear subspace of h
.
= B
be an ideal in L+iL
is an ideal in L
have f+ig E A A
(B+iB),
. We
prove that Dd is a band. d (D )r such d We have to prove that fo E (D Ir
be a set of positive elements in
exists in L f I Igl
.
for all
g E D
,
so
fo
=
.
sup(f:fEE)
196
COMPLEX RIESZ SPACES
satisfies
f o I lgl
for all d fo E (D )r
is real, so If
D
.
is a non-empty subset of
the disjoint complement Dd Di
D
of
. This
g E D
in L
. It is
of
D
L
Ch. 12,1913
, we
in L+iL and the disjoint complement d = (D
.
( i ) If A i s an ideal i n L+iL, then A d dd LL hence (A lr = ((A,) lr = (A~)' AZSO (A )r = (A,) (ii) Every band k i n L+iL s a t i s f i e s A = Add . n (iii) If A1 A are i d e a l s in L+iL , then n = n;=, dd
.
.
PROOF. (i) Let A be an ideal in L+iL d . Conversely, if f E (Ar)d that A c
. If
g E Ar
h
=
gl+ig2 E A
Ihl S lgll + 1g21 , so d A = (Ar)' Replacing
.
with
g1 and
A
by
Ad
dd (A )r (ii) Let =
A
Ar
i.e., the bands Add = A
.
=
,
be a band in L+iL
II )
=
(A,)
in Ar
.
u
(Ar)
d
, and
Aj)dd =
A cA
I f 1 I lgl fzr all
then
g2
,
then
It follows that d (A )r = (Ar)'
in the formula
d l = ((A,) ((A 1),
=
. It follows from
/fI I Ihl , i.e., f E Ad
7
so
d
,...,
.
fo
have to distinguish between
evident that D'
THEOREM 91.7. d
. But
fo E Dd
shows that
, we
get
*
. The real part
since L
is a band in L dd is Archimedean. It follows that (A )r = Ar ,
Add
A
and
(iii) Let A ],...,A ideal in L+iL , so
n
Ar
have the same real parts. This implies
be ideals in L+iL
. Then ng=l Aj
is also an
by part (i). Using Theorem 19.3 (in which the intersection formula was proved for the real case) and part (i) again, the right hand side becomes
The real part being equal, it follows now that
A.)dd (nn J=1 J
=
dd fly=, Aj
.
,
Ch. 1 2 , 8 9 1 1
The ideal A ideal Ar Br
is included i n the band
in L+iL
in L
is included in the band
is the band generated by
generated by
A
Br
.
B
if and only if the
It follows that
B
is the
A (i.e., the smallest band containing A ) if and only
band generated by if
197
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
if and only if
Ar B,
=
. In other words, B (Ar)u . But (Ar)u
is the band dd = (A ) r by
part (i) of the last theorem. Hence, B is the band generated by A if and dd As in the real case, only if Br= (A )r , i.e., if and only if B = Add
.
the ideal A
is called order dense if the band generated by
.
A
is the
This holds if and only if whole space L+iL , i.e, if Add = L+iL i.e., if and only if A, is order dense in L (Ar)LL = L
.
For any ideal A in L , so
A
fB
Ad
The ideal A
in L+iL
L
8
.
(A )
.
is order dense
is called a projection band if
in L+iL
projection bandin
the real ideal A
is order dense in L+iL
I
. In this case
.
A
Ar
is a
is a band, and it follows from
'
is the decomposition h +h 2 d of an arbitrary h E L+iL into h l E A and h2 E A , then [hi , so Ihl = lhll + Ih21 is the decomposition of
Ar
(A )'
B)
=
L
that A
Conversely, if A
(B
Ad
=
L+iL
If
is a band in L+iL
then h l E A
=
with the property that every
h E L + iL admits a decomposition h satisfy ( I ) ,
h
=
and h2 E A
d
h +h I 2
, so
such that A
fOllows immediately from Theorem 30.1 that if A bands in L+iL Particular, if in L+iL if
L
,
then A n B
L
and A+B
,
then A
8
and
We still assume that L
B
are projection
are also projection bands. In B
has the projection property and A
be an ideal in L
A
and
B
are bands
is a band in L+iL is a band in L+iL
,
. Hence, then A
@
Ad =
is Archimedean and uniformly complete. Let A,
. The quotient space
L/Ar
is uniformly complete
(Corollary 5 9 . 4 ) , but perhaps not Archimedean. By Theorem 60.2
Archimedean if and only if
Ih21
is a projection band. It
has the projection property and
satisfying A I B
IhlI and
L/Ar
is
is uniformly closed. Hence, the quotient A, L/Ar is Archimedean and uniformly complete if and only if A, is uniformly satisfies this condition, SO we have closed. We shall assume now that Ar
198
COMPLEX RIESZ SPACES
the situation that both
L
and LIA
Ch. 12,9911
admit complexification with an
absolute value. More generally, let first A
. We
Ar
denote the elements of
it follows that
[h]
(L+iL)/A This shows that
[fl+ iCgl
=
=
be an ideal in L+iL with real part
(L+iL)/A
,
L/A + iL/Ar
(L+iL)/A
by
h
f+ig
=
so
.
is the complexification of
, if
is real, i.e., Chl E L/Ar
the element [hi
... . From
[f],[g],
. For
L/Ar
and only
[g]
=
h = f+ig
,
[Ol
i.e.,
gEAr Assume now, as above, that h
=
1
Cf,]
fl+igl and h = f +ig2 2 2 [f,] and Cg,l = Cg,l
=
\hl-h21E A
is uniformly closed. Note first that Ar satisfy Ch,l = [h,] if and only if
,
and in this case we have h -h E A ,
. It follows then that
1
, so
lhll - Ih2J E A
2
Clh,c1
=
[lh211
We shall prove now that the absolute value of the equivalence class Chl
is exactly the equivalence class of I Clhll
is easy to see that
l[hll
f cose+g sine
that
Ihl
2
, i.e.,
Ihl
, because
C(X)
such that
E
>
0
in the system such that
0
I
po(x$
-
p
80
compactness X
(x) <
E
=
. It
=
, so
Cfl cos8+[gl sine
is compact and Hausdorff
is a system of non-negative functions in
(p,:e€{e))
supe p,(x)
continuous. Given
Clh19
=
exists for each xo E X
0 I p (x ) - pe (x,) 0
X , where po
pointwise on
po(x)
, there
<
0
0
for all x
, and
E
is also
a function p
hence
in a neighborhood of
x
. By
eO
the
can be covered by a finite number of these neighborhoods, SO
there exists a function q, , a finite supremum of functions pe , such It follows that there exists a that 0 I po(x) qE(x) < E on X sequence (\:n=1,2, ) of non-negative functions in C(X) , each qn
-
.
...
a finite supremum of functions pe converges uniformly to C(X)
po
sup np8
=
po
,
such that
. Hence, if
onto the Archimeden space M
relatively uniformly to and hence
.
it follows from
Clhll t Cf cos8+g sinel
To get equality, we return to the situation that X and we assume that
lChll
so
?rpo in M
,
n
0
qn I.
5
then 0
I
rqn
4
and
. This implies that
. Applying this to
and
qn
is a Riesz homomorphism of nq n converges sup aqn = sp0 ,
the situation that
Ch. 12,1911
pe = If cose+g sinel
pe
image of of
199
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
in
and pi
C(X)
, as
, we
derive from
L onto L/Ar
[lhll = s u p r p e
(2)
If^ cosB+g- sinel
=
in Lemma 91.1,
=
is the isomorphic
and taking for
lhl = sup pe
supllfl cose+C:l
the mapping
?i
that
sinel
.
IChll
=
Let L be a uniformly complete Riesz space equipped with a Riesz
. Then
norm p
then np(u)
L
0
is Archimedean (if
p(v)
5
, so
for all n
nu 5 v
5
p(u) = 0
for n = 1,2
, which implies
,...
,
u = 0 ).
Hence L+iL admits an absolute value, as explained. Defining p(h)
=
sup(lfl,Igl) only if
,
for all h E L+iL
p(lh1)
satisfying p(hl)
5
p(h2)
If+igl
5
5
for
If1
+
the function p
IhlI 5 /h21 Igl
is a norm on
. It follows from
that L+iL
,
L+iL
is norm complete if and
is norm complete.
L
EXERCISE 91.8. functions f
Show that if
on [O,l]
for all x
L
in a neighborhood of
then the complexification of same holds if
L
such that f (x)
consists of all real continuous
such that f(x) L
0
a+bx
=
(a and
b
real numbers)
(the neighborhood depending on f ),
does not admit an absolute value. The
consists of all real continuous functions on [O,ll a cos (x-b)
=
in a neighborhood of
HINT: Take (I+x) + i(1-x) check first that
L
0
.
in the first example. In the second example,
is a vector space and secondly that L
is a vector
f ,f E L and fI(G) = f2(G) , then either fl and f2 1 2 coincide in a neighborhood of 0 or f l and f2 have different derivatives lattice (if
at
0 ). Now take cos x+i sin x
EXERCISE 91.9.
.
L
Show that if
is the space C(X)
continuous functions on the topological space X then
Ihl
=
supg (f cose+g sine) exists in L
Ihl (x) = (f2(x)+g2(x))1/2 Let
for all x E
the Riesz space M(r)(X,A,p) and
every x E
.
and
of all real h = f+ig E L+iL
Ihl
,
satisfies
(X,A,p) be a o-finite measure space an let L be an ideal in
Show that if in L
x
and
Ihl
x
of all real p-measurable functions on X
h = f+ig E L+iL
.
satisfies
,
then
lhl(x)
=
.
supe (f cos@+g sine) exists (f2(x)+g 2 (x))”~ for p-almost Ihl
=
200
COMPLEX RIESZ SPACES
EXERCISE 91.10.
Let
Ch. 12,1911
. It
f,g,fo,go be elements of a Riesz space L
is an immediate consequence of the Birkhoff inequalities that
There is a sharper inequality. Show that
and by induction
I
p
HINT: For p V q - p
A
q
,...
sup(f
I
fn)-sup (g
sup(f,g)
=
, write
p
A
and
q
q
=
sup(f
A
q 2 (fAfo) v (gAgo)
Ip-ql
5
p v q-r
EXERCISE 91.11. h
=
f+ig E L+iL
.
,g ) 0
, use
that
Ip-ql
=
as the supremum of four terms and derive
from this that p
=
0
=
r
. Hence
I(fvfo)v(gvgo)} 'I
-
r
=
Let L be Archimedean and uni Drmly complete. For
0
and
S 8 S
277, let h(8) = If cos8+g sin81
...)
and
Show that if 8 (n=l,Z, converges to 8 , then e = If1 + l g l n h(8 ) converges e-uniformly to h(8) Show also that if (On:n=I,2, n dense in [0,2771 and s = sup h(8 ) exists in L , then n s = sup(h(e):ose
.
...)
is
.
EXERCISE 91.12. With the same hypothesis and the same notations as in
...
the preceding exercise, let P (n=l,2, ) be the partition n e2" ) with e k = 2nk/Zn for all k , defined by P = ( e l , n h(Pn) = sup(h(O1) h(8 )) Show that (h(Pn):n=1,2 ) 2" increasing e-uniform Cauchy sequence. Hence, by the preceding
...,
,...,
the e-uniform limt
.
jh/ satisfies
,...
of
[0,2nl
and let is an exercise,
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Ch. 12,5921
This method to prove the existence of
Ihl
201
without representation theory
is due to B. de Pagter. Use this to proveagain the formula Clhll (:ormula
(2) above) in the quotient space
(L+iL)/A
.
=
Clhl]
HINT: It is evident that h(P n ) is increasing. Let m < n , and let be the corresponding partitions. By Exercise 91.10,
Pm and P n
where the supremum is taken for j the points of
I f3
-8.1
Pn
.
=
l,...,2m
situated in the interval
(Bj-l,8jl
< 21~/2~ It follows that for any given
k J Ih(Pn)-h(Pm)l
c
Ee
if m
Bk
and where
is large enough, so
E
>
,
runs through
so
0 we have
(h(P ):n=1,2, ...) is
e-uniformly Cauchy.
92. Complex order bounded operators If T
is a (linear) operator from the real vector space V
real vector space W
, then
operator from V+iV
into W+iW
into the
T has a unique extension as a (linear) by defining
T(f+ig) = Tf+iTg for all V
f and
into W
L(V+iV,W+iW) h y w+iW
T
g
in L
. The set
L(V,W)
of all (linear) operators from
can be regarded thus as a real linear subspace of the space of all complex (linear) operators from V+iV
in this set is called a real linear operator from
. An arbitrary
T
in L(V+iV,W+iW)
T = Tl+iT2 , where T 1 and
T2
has a unique decomposition
Tf
for f E L
into real and imaginary
Parts; Tf = T f+iT f It follows then that Th = T h+iT h for all 1 2 1 2 , and so T = T +iT2 This shows that the space L(V+iV,W+iW)
h E L+iL
the complexification of
1
.
L(v,w)
.
into
are real. Indeed, the operators TI and
T2 appear in the decomposition of
.
into w+iw V+iV
.
is
Now, let L and M be Riesz spaces such that L is Archimedean and uniformly complete and M is Dedekind complete (hence, L and M have complexifications admitting an absolute value). The operator T = T +iT 1 2 from L+iL into M + i M is order bounded if and only if T1 and T2 are
so,
202
COMPLEX ORDER BOLlNDED OPERATORS
Ch. 12,5921
.
hence L (L+iL,M+iM) is the complexification of Lb(~,~) The operator b T is called positive if T is real and the restriction of T to L is positive; T ever
is said to be order continuous (or o-order continuous) when-
TI and T2 are s o . For any order bounded /TI
value
T = T +iT2 the absolute 1
is, by definition, the operator
f cosO+T2 sinO:W852~1 1 IT( = sup\T1
) -
The supremum exists since Lb(L,M) (i.e., if
T
for any
E L+
u
is real), IT1
. We
is Dedekind complete. In the real case
satisfies
shall prove that the corresponding formula holds if
T is complex. For this purpose we start with some lemmas, one of which is similar to the complex case of Freudenthal's spectral theorem (Theorem 91.5). The difference is that we do not assume Dedekind o-completeness but only the Archimedean property and uniform completeness. In return we get a somewhat weaker result (Lemma 92.3), sufficient for what we wish to prove. LEMMA 92.1. I f
Hausdorff space
,... ,gn
(Ul,
, then
X
...,U
such t h a t
vanishes outside
Uk (k=l,
on
i s an open covering of the compact
there e x i s t non-negative continuous functions
x
g1
)
(gl+...+gn)( x) = I
x
on
...,n) . Such a system of
and each
gk
functions i s called
a p a r t i t i o n of unity subordinate t o the open covering
...,Un) .
(U1,
PROOF. The space X, being Hausdorff and compact, is normal, i.e., disjoint closed sets have disjoint open neighborhoods. Equivalently, if is contained in the open set U
the closed set E open set V
such that E c V c V- c U
In the present situation, En in the open set Un
.
, so
=
X-(UIU...UUn-I)
open set Un-l En-l cVn-l
C
, so -
V-
, then
,...,Un-l,Vn)
there exists an
is the closure of
V
.
is a closed set contained
there exists an open set Vn
E c V c Vi c U Note that (U1 n n n of X Hence, En-l = X-(U,U...UUn-2W
.
, where
such that
is still an open covering
) is a closed set contained in the n there exists an open set Vn-l such that
Vn-l C Un-l
, and
(Ul,...,Un-2,Vn-1,Vn) is still an open
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
Ch. 12,1921
covering of
...,Vn )
. Proceeding in this manner we -
X
of X
(Vl,
writing Fk
-
=
covering of
Vk
such that V
c Vk c Uk
k
, the
for all k
such that F c Uk
X
get an open covering
= I , ...,n . Hence, ...,Fn ) is a closed k . By Urysohn's lemma there
for k
(FI,
system
203
for every
k exists, for each k = I,...,n , a continuous real function fk on X that 0 s fk 5 1 on X , f = 1 on Fk and f = 0 outside It follows that
k
I,
=
=
k f 1 +...+En
...,n . Then all Let
LEMMA 92.2.
X
Hausdorff space
...,an
al,
%
k
. Let
on X
t 1
gk
on
fk/f
=
'
for = 1
...,n) .
(k=l,
k
f be a complex continuous function on the compact
and l e t
. Then
> 0
E
there e x k t eompZex nwnbers
und non-negative continuous functions
g l , ...,gn
Iakl s llfll
gl+...gn = 1 on X and is the s u p r e m norm i n C(X)
(i)
, i.e., and
PROOF. For every x E X, le
Ux
for
= 1
k
X
on
that
llfll
k' X
are continuous and non-negative, gl+...+gn
gk vanishes outside U
X and
on
f
such
,...,n , where
llfll =sup(lf(x)/:xEX)
!If(x) 1-z:
la
k
I
such
gk(x)l
5 E
,
x
on
.
be the open neighborhood of x
defined by
ux
=
(y€x: I f (y)-f (x)
<€)
.
BY the compactness of X there exists an open covering (UXl,".,U 1 of xn Let (gl,...,gn) be a partition of unity subordinate to this covering
X
.
and let ak
=
f(5)
for k
i=
I,...,n
. Then
lakl
5
llfll
for all
k
and
Hence, conditions (i) and (ii) are satisfied. For the proof of (iii), note first that
II f(dI g,(x)-
lak Igk(x)
since gk vanishes outside Uk
I
If (x)g,(x)-a,g,(x)
. Hence
I
5
EPk(X)
,
204
for all
LEMMA 92.3. Let L be an Archimedean and uniformZy complete Riesz s?ace, Let u E L+ , f E L+iL with If1 i u and E > 0 Then there
,...,an
e x i s t compZex numbers
a1
that
.
,...,v
and elements
...,n
(i) v +...+ v = u and l a I i 1 f o r k = 1, I n k (ii) Z: l ak I vk 5 u , (iii) If-Cn a v I 5 EU and Ilfl-Cy laklvkl 5 E 1 k k
L+ such
in
v1
,
.
U
PROOF. Follows from the preceding lemma by observing that the principal ideal generated by
, where
is Riesz isomorphic with a space C(X)
u
is Hausdorff and compact, such that the image of
X
is the function
u
identically one. (Tcr:a{ a } ) i s a system of reaZ order bounded operators
LEMMA 9 2 . 4 . I f
from the Riesz space L that
i n t o the Dedekind complete Riesz space
exists i n
To = sup T
Lb(L,M)
and i f
u E L+
M
such
, then
n n
where
(al,...,an) runs through aZZ non-empty f i n i t e subsets of
...,
{ a } and,
runs through n-tupZes of f o r each subset of t h i s kind, ( u ~ , u ) n p o s i t i v e elements s a t i s f y i n g u l + ...+ u = u n PROOF. If
{a)
,
..
consists of two elements a ,
and
a2
, so
that
To = sup(Ta ,T
)
case that
has a finite number of elements follows by induction. The
!a}
a2
the formula for TOu was proved in Theorem 83.6. The
general case is now derived by observing that if T
0
system of all TB is directed upwards, then T u
M.
0
=
=
sup TB
sup T u B
, where
the
in the spare
Ch. 12,9921
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
In what follows we assume again that L
LEMMA 92.5. (i) If T E Lb(L,M)
i s r e a l and
IT1 (lhl) (ii) If T E Lb(L+iL,M+iM)
f E L , then
.
5
and
(ii) Let
T
=
, so
T +iT2 with
TI and
I
T2
has the decomposition Tf = T 1f+iT2f , lTfl
=
h E L+iL, then ITfI
. Since
f,g E L
PROOF. (i) Let h = f+ig with the decomposition Th = Tf+iTg
Tf
is an Archimedean and uni-
is a Dedekind complete Riesz space.
formly complete Riesz space and M
lThl
205
T
THEOREM 92.6. Let
L and
M
be an order bounded operator from
PROOF. We have
IT1
is real,
ITI(lfl)
cose+T2 sine
.
be a s defined above and l e t L+iL i n t o M+iM
. Let
, where
T(t3)
sup(T(8):0<8<2a)
=
has
so
I
5
(lfl)
is real, Th
real. Since f
supelTlfcose+T2f sine = sup81(TI cosB+T cose ( l f l ) 2
IT1
5
T = Tl+iT2
u E L+
=
. Then
TI cose+T2 sine
I
Hence, by Lemma 92.4 above,
IT[(u) = sup Z. T(8
(1)
J
)u j j '
where the supremum is taken over all finite systems all u
j
are positive and
let p = X.(cosO.)u J ~j TIp+T2q = Re{T(p-iq)}
and
.
(ej,uj)
such that
X.u = u If {(O.,u.)} i s one of these sysiems, ~j J J q = Z.(sinej)uj , s o Ip-iql 5 Z.u = u and
J . This implies
~j
206
COMPLEX ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
T p+T q 1 2
But
T(ej)uj
= C.
J
,
Ch. 12,5921
so
IT(f+ig)/:lf+ig/
For the inequality in the converse direction it is now sufficient to holds for all h E L+iL
prove that lThl 5 ITI(lh1)
. This
is the more
complicated part of the proof, in which it is necessary to appeal to the approximation property proved in Lemma 92.3. Note that although in general an element h E L+iL does not have a polar decomposition of the form h
=
alhl
with a
a complex number, Lema 92.3 is a kind of substitute
and as such it will be of use in the proof which follows now. We prove first that
/Thl < 21TI(Ihl)
holds for every h E L+iL
.
Indeed, we have
and so
lThl 5 21TI(Ihl)
. It follows that if
h j holds u-uniformly in L+iL (all h and h in L+iL ), then Th j j holds v-uniformly in M+iM , where v = 21TI (u) This implies that by Lemma 92.5(i),
.
ITh.1 J
p E M
.+
IThl
holds v-uniformly in M ITh.1 5 p
such that
J
. Hence, if
for all j
, then
+
h
+
Th
there exists an element
lThl
5 p
.
Now, to return to theinequality we want to prove, let h E L+iL be given such that
Ihl 5 u
exists a sequence
. By
the approximation result in Lemma92.3 there
(h.:j=1,2,...)
in L+iL such that h converges j is a finite sum Z a v with all ak u-uniformly to h , and each h j k k k complex, all vk positive with Ckvk = u and Cklaklvk 5 u Hence, by J
.
what was observed above, lThj I
converges
IT1 (u)-uniformly to
lThl , so
that it is sufficient to prove now that ITh.1 5 IT1 (u) for la11 j , J because this will imply lThl 5 ITI(u) For any h. = kkvk we have by
.
Lemma 92.5(ii)
that
J
Ch. 12,1921
ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
lTh.1 = /Xkak Tv 1 3 k
S
207
0
Xk lak/./Tvk/S IT1 Z k / a k / v k
S
.
/TI(u)
This concludes the proof. A s already defined, T = Tl+iT2 is said to be order continuous (or
a-order continuous) whenever
TI and
T2 are
so.
It follows that T
order continuous (or a-order continuous) if and only if
IT1
before, the band of all real order continuous operators (from L is denoted by
Ln
=
. The set of
Ln(L,M)
operators (from L+iL
is
is s o . A s into M )
all complex order continuous
into M+iM ) is now the band
Ln+iLn
. Similarly, Lc+iLc .
the set of all complex a-order continuous operators is the band
Ln and tc are projection bands in Lb(L,M) , the bands Ln+iLn and Lc+iLc are projection bands in L (L+iL,M+iM) . b
Since
We apply the above results to the case that M numbers, s o
M+iM
is now the order dual L" is of the form $
=
. Any complex linear functional
$l+i$2 , where
L+iL of real linear functionals on on
L+iL
For any
If
if and only if
and
$ = $l+i$2E (L+iL)-
u E 'L
is the space of real
is the space of complex numbers. The space Lb(L,M) and
L
$
on
L+iL
$2 are the extensions to
. Evidently, +
is order bounded
$2 are order bounded on L ; in formula
we have
, then
The sets of all order continuous or o-order continuous linear functionals on
L+iL are the bands
L2iL:
or L-+iL" c c
respectively.
Complexifications of Banach lattices and of operators between Banach lattices were introduced by U. Krengel ([11,1963) and H.P. Lotz ([11,1968).
208
COMPLEX ORDER BOUNDED OPERATORS
The case that L
Ch. 12,1921
is an Archimedean and uniformly complete Riesz space, and
not necessarily a Banach lattice, was treated by W.A.J. Luxemburg A.C. Zaanen ([31,1971) and W.J. de Schipper ([11,1973). Theorem 92.6, stating that and u
ITl(u)
positive, is due to W . J .
=
The important
sup(lThl:hEL+iL,lhjiu)
for T
complex
de Schipper and, independently, to
H.H. Schaefer (cf. the book [11,1974,Ch.IV,Theorem 1.8). EXERCISE 92.7. If L
is Dedekind o-complete (which implies that
uniformly complete and Archimedean) and M
L
is
is Dedekind complete, the proof
of Theorem 92.6 may be simplified. Instead of using Lemma 92.3, the proof of which depends on representing a principal ideal in L
as a space C(X)
of continuous functions on a compact space, we can now simply use Freudenthal's spectral theorem (Theorem 91.5). the proof that
lTh1
5
ITI(lh1)
Show first that if h E L+iL
(i)
...,ek
disjoint components e l , (with 0
5
lynl
Ihl
-
5
1
Clynlen
of
and
~lhl
.
(ii) Show now that if the operator T
M+iM ) is order bounded and h
=
f+ig
,
E
.
are given, there exist
> 0
and complex numbers y I ,
Ihl
for all n ) such that 5
The change occurs only in
holds for any h = f+ig
Ih-Cynenl =
T +iT
then
lTh1
1
5
2
Elhl
...,yk
and
(from L+iL into
I!TI(Ihl)
.
CHAPTER 13
KERNEL OPERATORS
Let M(X,p)
and M(Y,v)
be the Riesz spaces of all real measurable
functions on the o-finite measure spaces (X,A,p) L
and
M be ideals in M(Y,v)
and M(X,p)
shall mainly deal with operators which map the carrier of
L
is the set Y
on X
x
(Y,C,v)
, and
let
respectively. Since we L
into M we may assume that
itself. The operator T: L
called a kernel operator if there exists a real T(x,y)
and
+
M
is
(pxv)-measurable function
such that, for every f E L , the equality
Y
holds for p-almost every x E X The function T(x,y)
(the exceptional set depending on
is called the kernel of the operator T
is a kernel operator with kernel T(x,y) operator Ta mapping L
into M(X,u)
, then
. If
f ). T: L
-+
M
is the kernelof an
IT(x,y)l
. If the kernel operator
T: L + M
,
then
T is called an absolute kernel operator. Evidently, the set Lk(L,M)
of
has the property that the corresponding Ta also maps L
into M
all absolute kernel operators is a linear subspace of the space Lb(L,M) of all order bounded operators (from L into M ). Furthermore, the kernel operator T
is positive if and only if the kernel T(x,y)
negative almost everywhere on and only if
T(x,y)
=
X
x
Y
and
T
= 0
is non-
(the null operator) if
0 almost everywhere.
In section 94 it will be proved that the set Lk(L,M) of all absolute kernel operators is a band in Lb(L,M) The proof as we shall present it
.
is based on a majorization theorem of A.R. Schep (1977), 0 5 S 5 T
and
operator. If S and T(x,y) S(x,y)
and
T
is a kernel operator, then
and
, then T(x,y).
S
stating that if
is likewise a kernel
T are absolute kernel operators with kernel S(x,y)
the kernel of
sup(S,T)
is the pointwise supremum of
In particular, the kernel of
209
IT1
is
IT(x,y)l
.
CHAPTER 13
210
Ch. 131
In section 86 it was proved that the band L" of all integrals on L n (i.e., all order bounded linear functionals that are order continuous) may consisting of all v-measurable
be identified with the ideal in M(Y,v) functions g
. If now the functions
fE L
hi E M
and
fg is v-summable over Y
such that the product
for all
i
,
gi and
...,k)
h.
for every N
satisfy g. E L i n
(i=l,
then
is evidently the kernel of an absolute kernel operator T which maps
L
into M
. Any
T
of this type is called a kernel operator of finite
rank. In section 95 we prove that if the ideal :L
is
large that its
so
carrier is the whole set Y , then L (L,M) is exactly the band generated k by the kernel operators of finite rank. This was proved by A.V. Buhvalov (1974) in a different manner. A sequence
(un:n=1,2,...) of v-measurable functions on Y
to star-converge to zero (notation u
*
+
is said
0 ) if every subsequence contains
a subsequence converging pointwise almost everywhere on
Y
to zero. This
notion occurs in Buhvalov's theorem (1974) which we prove in section 96. The theorem states that i f , once more, the carrier of L" is Y and T n is an operator mapping L into M , then T is a kernel operator (not necessarily an absolute kernel operator) if and only if it follows from
*
...
0 5 u S u E L for n = 1.2, and u -+ 0 that Tu converges pointn n n wise almost everywhere on X to zero. The proof is presented first for
T order bounded (in which case T
is an absolute kernel operator). If T
is not order bounded as an operator from L
into M
but
the mentioned condition (Buhvalov's condition), then T as an operator from L
, so
into M(X,u)
T
satisfies
is order bounded
that the already established
result for the order bounded case can still be applied. If L and if T
and M
are vector spaces with algebraic duals L#
is an operator mapping L
is an operator mapping M# all
fE L
and
into L#
all 41 E M#
into M
, defined
spaces (M Dedekind complete) and
T
of M
T#
to the order dual M"
The operator T"
N
maps M
by
. In the case that
T"
of
, the
into L"
and M#
algebraic adjoint T# (T#$)(f)
I=
$(Tf)
for
L and M are Riesz
is order bounded, the restriction and
is called the order adjoint of T . T"
but even order continuous. If, in addition, T
is not only order bounded, is order continuous, then
Ch. 131 T"
21 I
KERNEL OPERATORS
maps
Mi
,
into :L
so
the restriction T'
order continuous operator mapping M ; and M
be ideals in M(Y,v)
carrier of both L
of
.
into :L
and M(X,p)
T"
to Mi
and assume that Y
is the
Li and X is the carrier of both M
and
Under these hypotheses, if T into M ) with kernel T(x,y)
is an
ow, let once more L
.
and MZ
is an absolute kernel operator (mapping L
,
then T'
is an absolute kernel operator
.
(mapping MZ into L" ) with kernel T(y,x) Conversely, if also n (Mn)n = M and T is an operator (from L into M ) such that the "
N
restriction T' MX
of
T#
, then
into :L
T
to MZ
is an absolute kernel operator mapping
-
is an absolute kernel operator. As applications,
we prove in section 98 that for
1 5 p <
-
every norm continuous operator
from L (Y,v) into Lm(X,p) is an absolute kernel operator and for P 1 < p 2 every norm continuous operator from LI(Y,v) into Lp(X,p)
is
an absolute kernel opezator (Dunford's theorem). Assume now that the ideal L g E M(Y,v)
For any
The ideal L' space of norm of
L p
x
Y
of all
g
satisfying p'(g)
and the restriction of
. If, for example, L =
then L' = L X
in M(Y,v)
9
for p
-1
+q-'
=
I
L
p'
for these values of
every x
-
is defined by
is called the associate
L'
y
t(x)
. In this case the function
on Y
x ), so =
t
-
is called the associate
for some p
finite or infinite number for these x generalized Oarleman kernel if
<
to
p'(g)
satisfying
P . The measurable function
is a v-measurable function of
we write T (y)
is equipped with a norm p .
the (finite or infinite) number
1 5 p 5
T(x,y)
on
for p-almost every x p'(Tx(y))
. We shall say that
, (and
is a well defined T(x,y)
is a
is finite for almost p'(Tx(y)) is measurable on X , i.e.,
(W.A.J. Luxemburg,l958). In section 99 we discuss some results
t E M(X,u)
due to A.R. Schep (1979).
It will be proved that if
then the following conditions for the operator T
p
is order continuous,
from L
into M(X,p)
are equivalent:
every
(i)
T
(ii)
There exists a non-negative function t E M(X,p)
fE L
is a kernel operator with a generalized Carleman kernel. satisfies
(iii) If f E L n for almost every x
.
l(Tf)(x)l
for n = l , Z , .
p(f).t(x)
.. and
such that
for almost every x P(fn)
*
0
,
then
.
(Tfn)(x)
+ 0
KERNEL OPEUTORS
212
we have L ' = L
For L = L2(Y,v) kernels T(x,y) over Y
, so
Ch. 13,1931
in this particular case we get
with the property that the integral of
. These are
is finite for almost every x
introduced by T. Carleman (1923).
IT(x,y)l
2
the Carleman kernels,
Several results are proved, relating
Carleman kernels to orthonormal systems in L2(Y,v)
.
93. Kernel operators
Let
(X,A,p)
and
(Y,Z,p)
be 0-finite measure spaces. The correspon-
ding Riesz spaces of all real measurable functions will be denoted by M(X,p)
and M(Y,v)
respectively. We recall that almost equal functions
are identified. The product measure of product
X x Y
on the semiring
is denoted by
r
r
and
= m.0
v
in the Cartesian
A E A
of all sets A x B with
(with the convention that 0.m on the semiring
p
. The product measure
v
p x
=
and
is first defined
B E E
by
0 ) , and the thus obtained measure
is then extended by means of the Carathzodory exten-
sion procedure. be a realvalued (uxv)-measurable function on X x Y
Let T(x,y) any
f E M(Y,v)
the function T(x,y)f(y)
is (pxv)-measurable, which
implies by Fubini's theorem that for p-almost every x E X T(x,y)f(y)
is v-measurable as a function of
is well defined for these values of
x
f E M(Y,v)
the function
y , It follows that
(the value
permitted) and by Fubini's theorem the function h The set of all
+m
for h(x)
is
is v-measurable on X
for which the corresponding h
Obviously, domy(T) h
T(x,y)
, and
it will be denoted by
is an ideal in M(Y,V)
in ( 1 ) is finite p-almost everywhere on
. For X
f E domy(T)
, and
so
.
in ( 1 ) is
finitevalued p-almost everywhere on X (i.e., for which h E M(X,u) be called the Y-domain of
. For
)
domy(T)
will
.
the function
Ch. 13,5931
KERNEL OPERATORS
213
. The function
is also finite u-almost everywhere on X
g
is u-measurable.
This follows from g(x)
=
1
(T(x,y)f(Y))+
dv(y)
-
Y
1
(T(x,y)f(y))-
,
dv(y)
Y
where the terms on the right are p-measurable by Fubini's theorem. Hence, formula (2) defines an operator T: f
+
g with
doy(T)
as domain and with
. The operator T is called a kernel operator and T(x,y) is called the kemeZ of T . Kernel operators are often called integraZ
range in M(X,u)
operators, but this name has the disadvantage that it is also used for other purposes. If T
is a kernel operator with kernel T(x,y)
are ideals in M ( Y , v )
and M(X,y)
a kernel operator from L T maps
L
for every
into M
f E L
. This
into M
=
I
if L
L
and M
is said to be
is included in doy(T)
and
implies that
. I n this case
(Tlf)(x)
and if
respectively, then T
T
, as
and T2
1
T+(x,y)f(y)dv(y)
,
T-(x,y)f(y)dv(y)
,
defined by
Y
(T2f)(x)
=
1
Y
are also kernel operators from L and
T2 are positive operators such that T
where
Ta
is the kernel operator from L
as kernel. If T and Ta both map
L
into M )
mapping L the set
into M
, we
TI-T2 and T = T +T a 1 2 ' having IT(x,y)I into M
shall say that T
. Then
Ta
and
such that T
is an absolute kernel
T -T are positive operators
, so T = Ta-(T a-T) is order bounded. It follows that of all absolute kernel operators from L into M is
into M
Lk(L.M)
a linear subspace of is a band in
Lb
T(x,y)
.
Lb(L,M)
. It will be
proved in the next section that
. For this purpose we first prove a few simple facts.
THEOREM 93.1. Let
kerneZ
=
. It is evident that
into M(X,u)
is a kernel operator from L
operator (from L
Lk
into M(X,u)
T be a k e r n 1 operator from Then t h e f o l l d n g hoZds.
L into
M with
214
Ch. 13,9933
KERNEL OPERATORS
(i)
is p o s i t i v e i f and only if T(x,y) Z 0 hoZds (uxv)-aZmost everyuhere on x x YL , where YL denotes the carrier o f L . T
( i i ) T = 8 ( t h e nu22 operator) i f and onZy if (pxv)-aZmost everywhere on
.
X x YL
PROOF. ( i ) It i s evident t h a t
T
T(x,y) = 0
is positive i f
everywhere. For t h e converse, assume t h a t
holds
T(x,y) 2 0 almost
i s p o s i t i v e . By Theorem 86.2
T
t h e r e e x i s t s a sequence all
. Since
n
that
u(Xn) <
u
m
Y .f YL such t h a t v(Yn) < and Xy E L f o r n i s o - f i n i t e , t h e r e a l s o e x i s t s a sequence X I. X such n for all n It i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t T(x,y) 2 0
.
holds almost everywhere on every that
u(X)
that
jy
add
v(Y)
Xn x Yn
a r e f i n i t e and
IT(x,y)l dv(y)
xy
,
so we may j u s t a s well assume
E L
. From xY
i t follows
E L
i s f i n i t e almost everywhere on
X
. Hence,
i f we
write
Y
for
k
=
1,2,
...
,
then
9 I.
,
X
so it i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t
i s non-negative almost everywhere on every
\
i s (uxv)-summable over
x Y
, so
9x
Y
. The f u n c t i o n
f o r any measurable
E C \
and
T(x,y) T(x,y) F c Y
we have
( ~ x ~ ) ( x ) d u ( x2 ) 0
.
E
From t h i s it follows e a s i l y t h a t t h e i n t e g r a l of T(x,y) over any (pxv)measurable subset of which
T(x,y)
q x yi s
non-negative. This implies t h a t t h e set on
i s s t r i c t l y negative i s of measure zero, and so
T(x,y) t 0
holds almost everywhere. ( i i ) Follows by applying t h e r e s u l t i n p a r t ( i ) t o
T
and
-T
.
94. The hand of a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s A s i n t h e preceding s e c t i o n , w e assume t h a t
(X,A,u)
and
(Y,C,v)
are
Ch. 13,1941
KERNEL OPERATORS
0-finite measure spaces and L
and M
215
are ideals in
and M(X,P)
M(Y,V)
respectively. For the investigation of operators from L
into M
we may
assume without restriction of the generality that the carrier of the set Y
LEMMA 94.1.
let
L
is
itself.
Let
S
be a p o s i t i v e operator from L i n t o M
E x F be a measurahle subset of
I
x
Y sueh that
xF
and
E L
and
.
<
(SxF)(x)du(x)
X
E
Furthermore, l e t that
A
1' be the semiring of a l l subsets
i s u-measurable and
B i s v-measurable.
A x B of
E x F
such
Then
A
is a non-negative and f i n i t e Z y additive s e t function on A i s a f i n i t e Z y additive measme on r . PROOF. It is evident that also that A x B c A, x B
1
0 < A(AxB) <
. In
other words,
for all A x B E
m
r
and
. The additivity
< A(AIxBI)
implies A(AxB)
r
proof seems simple, but there i s a small complication, caused by the fact n that if fo,fl, f are functions in L such that fo(y) = C 1 fk(y) n = Zy(Sfk)(x) holds only for p-almost for all y E Y , then (Sfo)(x)
...,
every x E X
, and
not necessarily for all x E X
We present the additivity proof. Let A x B and all A
x Bk k disjoint. Then
for all
members of
(x,y) E E
x
F
, so
r
holds for u-almost every x E X depends on xo (1,2,
...,n)
and such that all
if we fix xo
,
.
= U ;
(%xBk)
%x
Bk
with A x B are mutually
then
. The exceptional set of measure zero
. More precisely, denoting by
consisting of those k
D(xo)
for which
the subset of
((xo,y):y€B)
has a non-
216
BAND OF ABSOLUTE KERNEL OPERATORS
4, x
empty intersection
Bk
, the
Ch. 13,5941
exceptional null set depends on D ( x o )
.
For x varying in E , there are only finitely many different D ( x o ) , 0 so there are only finitely many different exceptional null sets. The union
of these null sets is again a null set, so for almost every x E X we have
Hence
In other words, h(AXB) = In h ( q c X B k )
.
The next theorem is of fundamental importance for the further results in this chapter. The proof which we present here is due to A.R. Schep (Theorem 4.2 in C11,1977,cf. also [21,1979). THEOREM 94.2. If 8
5 S 5
T in
T is a kernel operator,
Lb(~,~) and
t h e n S is a kernel operator. I n o t h e r words, any p o s i t i v e operator majorized by a kernel operator is a kernel operator. PROOF. The proof is divided into five steps. (i) Let E such that
xF
and
E L
I
F
be measurable subsets of
X and Y
respectively
and
T(x,y)d(uxv)
=
EXF
I
(TxF)(x)dv(x)
-.
E
, defined
Then the set function h
for any measurable subset P
of E x F
by
is a countably additive measure on the o-algebra of all (pxv)-measurable The measure A is absolutely continuous with respect subsets of E x F to x v , i.e., (vxv)(P) = 0 implies h ( P ) = 0 .
.
A s before, let
r
be the semiring of all sets A
a u-measurable subset of
E
and
B
is a +measurable
B
, where
subset of
F
A
is
. For
A x B E l'
we define
A (AXE)
(2)
1
'
=
J
.
(SXB)(x)du(x)
A
It follows from the last lemma that
r
. Since
0 5 XI
r
on
A
5
with disjoint terms, and n
is a finitely additive measure on
Al
A
and
is countably additive, the measure
r
is actually countably additive on
A1
217
KERKEL OPERATORS
Ch. 13.1941
. Indeed, if
A x B
=
is a natural number, then A x B
xD ) can be written as a finite disjoint union Up(C l i i if E > 0 is given, then
m
Ul(%xBk)
-
UY(\XBk)
. Hence,
r
of sets of
sufficiently large, so in view of
for n
Al(%XBk)
it follows that :1
4
AI(AxB)
as n +
m
.
We now apply the Carathsodory extension procedure to the measures A A1
and
r
on
denoted by
A
; the exterior measures corresponding to
A*
A:
and
respectively. It is evident that of E x F
holds for every subset P
What we have done is to restrict
A
and
0
2
A,
will be
A*(P) 5 A*;P) 1 A*
. Let us take a closer look at
to the sets of
r
.
and then extend
the restriction again by means of the Carathgodory extension procedure. The question arises whether in the first place every (uxv)-measurable set P (for which
A
was originally defined by formula ( 1 ) ) becomes
after the extension and secondly, whether formula ( 1 ) A(P)
replaced by
A*(P)
. The answer is obviously affirmative if
o-set (i.e., a finite or countable union of sets from p
A*-measurable
continues to hold with
r
)
, hence
P
is a
also if
is a finite or countable intersection of u-sets. It follows that the
Same holds if P
is a set of (vxv)-measure zora, because in this case there
exists a set Q
P
3
, also
of (pxv)-measure zero, such that Q
is the
intersection of a decreasing sequence of u-sets. Since any (pxv)-measurable set differs only in a set of measure zero from such a countable intersection, the formula ( 1 ) holds therefore for any (pxv)-measurab%e set P with replaced by
A*(P)
. Hence, A*(P)
A(P)
has the same value as the original A(P)
.
BAND OF ABSOLUTE ERNEL OPERATORS
218
Ch. 13,1941
As usual with X*-measurable sets, we drop the asterisk, so we write
A(P)
as before. The next fact to observe is that every (pxv)-measurable set P h*-measurable. This is evident if P
is also P
is a o-set, hence also if
1
is a finite or countable intersection of a-sets. It remains to prove
that every set of (pxv)-measure zero is A*-measurable. This is easy; if
,
(pxv) (N) = 0 0
< A*1
X*
2
then A (N) = 0
. This
by ( 1 ) ,
1
X:(N) = 0 on account of is a X*-null set, so N is h*-measurable
shows that N
so
1
A,(P)
For any (pxv)-measurable set P we shall write
1
instead of
ht(P)
.
Recapitulating, we have proved that any (pxv)-measurable subset P of E x F
is X*-measurable as well as
h*-measurable and 1
0
2
A,(P) < h(P)
holds for any set P of this kind. Note now that if we combine these inequalities with the fact that A the same for X I
, i.e.,
XI
is (pXv)-absolutely continuous, we get
is (pxv)-absolutely continuous on the
a-algebra of all (pxv)-measurable subsets of
E x F
. It follows then from
the Radon-Nikodym theorem that tihere exists a (pxv)-measurable non-negative function S(x,y) A,@)
on =
E x F
I
such that
S(x,y)d(pxv)
P
for all (pxv)-measurable subsets P A x B E
r , we
of E
x
F
. In particular, for
have
X I (AxB) in formula (2) and observing is an arhitrary u-measurable subset of E , we get
Comparing this with the defintion of that A (3)
(SxB)(x)
=
1
S(X,Y) xB(Y)dv(Y)
Y for almost every x subset B of
F
.
in
E
. Note that
(ii) We assume again that F that
xF
E L
. Furthermore, since
disjoint union of sets X. ( j = l , with kernel T(x,y)
J
is from L
(3)haldsfor every v-measurable
is a v-measurable subset of Y
X is of a-finite measure, X
...)
such is the
of finite measure. The operator T
into M
and
xF
is a member of L
,
so
KERNEL OPERATORS
Ch. 1 3 , § 9 4 1
I
219
T(x,y)dv(y)
F
is finite u-almost everywhere on X E jk
=
1
. For
(x€X. :k-I< T(x,y)dv(y)
j,k = l,2,
... , let
.
F
Then, except for a set of measure zero, X
... .
is the disjoint union of the
sets E (j,k=l,2, ) Note that T(x,y) is (pxv)-summable over E x F jk jk for all j,k Hence, by step (i), there exists a (pxv)-measurable non-
.
negative function S . (x,y) on E Jk jk subset B of F the equality
x
.
F
such that for every v-measurable
holds u-almost everywhere on E Defining now S(x,y) on X x F by jk S(X,Y) = S (x,y) on E x F for j,k = 1,2 , we find for every jk jk u-measurahle subset B of F that (SxB) (x)
=
I
,...
S(x,y)xB(y)dv(y)
Y
holds u-almost everywhere on X
. It follows immediately that if
measurable step function on Y vanishing outside F ,i.e., t(y) finite sum of terms aiXBi(Y) (St)(x)
=
/
t
is a
is a
with all B. measurable subsets of F
, then
S(x,y)t(y)dv(y)
Y holds u-almost everywhere on X
xy
.
(iii) By Theorem 86.2 there exists a sequence Y .f Y such that n € L for all n (we recall that by assumption the carrier of L is
thg set Y
for n = 2 , 3 , itself). Writing D = Y l and D = Y -Y 1 n n n-l ) are disjoint, their union is Y and each
... . Applying the result in step (ii) to each
the sets D (n=1,2, n xD is a member of L
X x Dn
SeFarately, we obtain a (uxv)-measurable non-negative function S(x,y)
x
x Y
such that (St)(x)
=
[
JY
S(x,y)t(y)dv(y)
... , on
220
Ch. 1 3 , 5 9 4 3
BAND OF ABSOLUTE KERNEL OPERATORS
holds almost everywhere on X such that
t
vanishes outside some
(iv) We prove that if
0 < f (y)
4
n
for each measurable step function t on
f(y)
n'
...
f,fl,f2,
*
are functions in L
holds almost everywhere on
. Since
Y
,
then
such that
(Sfn)(x)
holds almost everywhere on
X
holds almost everywhere on
X , it is sufficient to prove that
(Tfn)(x)
almost everywhere on X
1. (Tf)(x)
Y
. For almost every
4
(Sf)(x)
x E X we
have
Y ,
almost everywhere on over Y
.
(v) Given 0
5
f E L
functions tn (n=l,2,.-.) on Y
(Tfn)(x)
so
,
1. (Tf)(x)
there exists a sequence of non-negative step
satisfying 0 < t (y) 4 f(y)
. It may be assumed that for each
outside Yn
, where
Yn
follows by integration
almost everywhere
the step function
n
tn
vanishes
is the same set as in step (iii). Hence, by step
(iii),
holds almost everywhere on X ges almost everywhere on X
for each n to
(Sf)(x)
side converges almost everywhere on X
Y
, by
. Now,
the left hand side conver-
by step (iv), and the right hand to the integral of
S(x,y)f(y)
over
the theorem on integration of monotone sequences. Hence
.
This shows that S is a kernel operator. Note that by for almost every x is uniquely determined modulo (pxv)-null Theorem 93.1 (ii) the kernel S(x,y) functions.
Ch. 13,5941
22 1
KERNEL OPERATORS
A s noted earlier, the absolute kernel operators from
a linear subspace of the Riesz space Lb(L,M)
L
into M
form
. More precisely, since any
absolute kernel operator is order continuous, the absolute kernel operators form a linear subspace in the supremum sup(T,S) space. Hence, if exists in
T
Lb(L,M)
.
Lc(L,M)
. For
L,(L,M)
=
T
and
exists in Lb(~,~) since Lb(L,M)
and
in
S
is a Riesz
are absolute kernel operators, then sup(T,S)
S
It is a reasonable conjecture now that if
have kernels T(x,y)
and
Lb(L,M)
S(x,y)
T
and
S
i s also a
respectively, then sup(T,S)
kernel operator with kernel equal to the pointwise supremum of
T(x,y)
S(x,y)
, the con-
. For. S = t3
almost everywhere. Similarly for inf(T,S)
jecture is, therefore, that T+
=
i s a kernel operator with kernel
sup(T,B)
equal to the pointwise supremum of
T(x,y)
zero, i.e., with kernel the positive part
and
and the function identically T+(x,y)
of
T(x,y)
. The proof
that this i s true was given by W.A.J. Luxemburg-A.C. Zaanen ([31,1971), before the theorem about a positive operator majorized by a kernel operator was known. The details of the Luxemburg-Zaanen proof are not simple. It is a pleasant fact, therefore, that by means of our last theorem we can give now a short and transparent proof of the conjectured result about as mentioned above. Note already that this will imply that if absolute kernel operator with kernel T(x,y) kernel operator with kernel THEOREM 94.3.
.
IT(x,y)\
, then
T
sup(T,S),,
i s an
IT1 = sup(T,-T)
is a
If T and S are absolute kernel operators from L
i n t o M w i t h kernels
T(x,y)
and
S(x,y) r e s p e c t i v e l y , then
sup(T,S)
i s likewise a kernel operator w i t h kernel equal t o t h e pointwise supremum of T(x,y) and S(x,y) almost e v e w h e r e . PROOF. It is sufficient to present the proof for S
=
t3
, since
the
general result will then follow from the formula sup(T,S) The positive part
=
S + sup(T-S,B)
T+(x,y)
of
T(x,y)
zero function, so the operator To satisfies To 2 T
and
. majorizes
T(x,y)
as well as the
corresponding to the kernel T+(x,y)
.
T > 0 , and hence To t sup(T,B) = T+ Since 0 is a kernel operator, it follows from the last theorem
To 2 T+ 2 t3 and To that 'T is also a kernel operator. Let TI(x,y) be the kernel of T+ account of To 2 T+ the corresponding kernels satisfy T+(x,y) 2 T,(x.y)
. On
BAND OF ABSOLUTE KERNEL OPERATORS
222
Ch. 13,9943
almost everywhere. On the other hand it follows from T+ t T that
TI(x,y) t T(x,y)
as well as
TI(x,y)
2
0
T+ t 0
and
hold almost everywhere,
so
' T (x,y> 2 T+(x,y) almost everywhere. The final conclusion is that TI(x,y)= I + This shows that T+ has = T (x,y) almost everywhere, i.e., T+ = To T+(x,y) as kernel.
.
To guarantee a smooth proof of the next theorem we include a lemma. be the set of all u-measurable functions f
Let P(X,u)
on
X
assuming
non-negative values in the extended system of real numbers (i.e., 0 5 f(x) 2
for all x E X ). Functions differing only on a p-null set
m
is partially ordered as usual, i.e., f 5 g
are identified. The set P(X,u) means that
f(x) 5 g(x)
holds p-almost everywhere on X
. Then
evidently a lattice. Note that the positive cone of M(X,p) of P(X,u)
(f : T€{ T} )
LEMMA 94.4. I f
f o = sup f
i s a s e t of non-negative functions i n
e z i s t s i n P(X,p)
and
fo i s already the sup-
r e m of an a t most countable subset of the s e t of a l l PROOF. Let
f
=
T,n
for n = l , 2 ,
inf(fT,n)
Dedekind complete, the supremum u n
, and
= supT
f
fT
... . Since
. M(X,u)
exists in M(X,u)
T,n
is super for any
is already the supremum of an at most countable subset of
u
(fT,n:~E{~})
. It follows easily that
THEOREM 94.5. The s e t
into M
is
is a sublattice
-
M(X,u) , then
P(X,u)
i s a band i n
fo = sup u
is the required supremum.
Lk (L,M) of absolute kernel operators from
Lb(L,M)
.
L
.
PROOF. (i) We prove first that L (L,M) is an ideal in Lb(L,M) If k T is an absolute kernel operator with kernel T(x,y) , then IT1 = sup(T,-T) is likewise a kernel operator and ly, if
T € Lb(L,M)
0 C T+ S IT1
T
= T+-T-
and
IT1
0 C T- S IT1
and
IT1
has the kernel
IT(x,y)I
. Converse-
is a kernel operator, then it follows from that T+ and
T-
are kernel operators, so
is a kernel operator. Note that we have used the fundamental ma-
jorization result in Theorem 94.2 several times. For the proof that the absolute kernel operators form an ideal, assume now that
IS1 C IT1
to show that same
S
is true f o r
in Lb(~,~), where
T is a kernel operator. We have
is a kernel operator. Since T
IT1
. But then
IS1
is a kernel operator the
is a kernel operator by Theorem 94.2
Ch. 13,9941
so
223
KERNEL OPERATORS
.
the same holds for S (ii) Let
0 5 T
T in Lb(L,M)
4
, where
all TT are kernel operators.
F o r the proof that the kernel operators form a band, we have to show now
that
T
is a kernel operator. The system of functions
directed upwards in the Riesz space M(XxY,pxv) functions on
X x Y
functions on
X
. Let
x Y
P(XxY,pxv)
(TT(x,y):rE{~})
is
of all (pxv)-measurable
be the set of all (pxv)-measurable
assuming non-negative values in the extended real num-
ber system. According to the last lemma the function T(x,y) = sup TT(x,y) exists in P(XxY,pxv) and there is even a subsequence (Tn(x,y):n=1,2, ...) in the system of all TT(x,y)
such that
T(x,y)
of the subsequence. Since the system of all
is already the supremum
T (x,y)
almost everywhere on
.
kernel Tn(x,y)
0
Now, let have
(Tf)(x)
X x Y
(Tnf)(x)
2
. Since
f E L
5
(Tnf)(x)
=
. Let
I
Tn
x
almost everywhere on
so
Tf = sup T f holds in the space M
for all n
, we
almost everywhere on X. Furthermore
Tn(x,y)f(y)dv(y)
4n
Y for almost every
is directed upwards,
0 5 T,(x,y) 4 T(x,y) be the operator corresponding to the
we may assume that the subsequence is increasing,
I
T(x,y)f(y)dv(y)
Y
. Hence
X
. Denoting the function on
the right by
g(x)
, we
have
almost everywhere on X
, so
almost every x
T(x,y)
(5)
in M
. Since
g t sup T f
. Combining
=
it follows already that g(x) t TT(x,y)
for all
T
Tf
( 4 ) and (5),
we get
g = Tf
,
i.e.,
is finite for
, we have
224
Ch. 1 3 , 5 9 4 1
BAND OF ABSOLUTE KERNEL OPERATORS
To conclude the proof, we show that the set on which measure zero, i.e., T(x,y)
, where
E
is a subset of
[ T(x,y)dv(y)
('4, (XI)=
show
xE
Y such that
T(x,y)
so
. It is sufficient to
first that in this case (6)
is of
m
is almost everywhere finite valued,
is a member of the Riesz space M(XxY,pxv) finiteness on X x E
T(x,y) =
f L
. Note
<
E
for almost every
x
. Assume now that the subset P of X = on P . Writing P = (y:(x,y)EP)
measure and
T(x,y)
the set Px
is a subset of
E
for all
> 0
x E Xo
(TxE)(x)
and it follows from
. For
X
of
(uxv)(P)
that there
> 0
such that u(Xo) > 0 and
these x we get therefore
T(x,y)dv(y)
=
has positive
for all x E X ,
m
exists a u-measurable subset Xo v(Px)
x E
2
E
1
T(x,y)dv(y)
.
=
pX
is finite almost everywhere on X x Y ,
This contradicts (6). Hence T(x,y)
is the kernel of a kernel operator according to our definition
i.e., T(x,y) in section 9 3 .
The final conclusion is, therefore, that the absolute kernel operators
.
form a band in Lb(L,m)
We present some examples. The first example illustrates that one must not conclude too soon that one measure is absolutely .continuous with respect to another measure. To begin we recall that the measurable set E (Y,I,w)
o-finite measure space measurable subset F
of
is well-known that i f Y
E
is called an atom if v(E)
satisfies either v(F)
= 0 or
v(E-F)
=
. It
0
Y does not contain any atoms and E is a subset of 0 < a < v(E) , then E has a
of finite positive measure and if also
.
For the special case that v subset E l satisfying v(E ) = a I sional Lebesgue measure, the proof is almost trival. EXAMPLE 94.6. Let (Y,C,u) without atoms and let A
in the
0 and every
>
be a finite measure space (i.e., v(Y)
be the semiring of all sets A x B
B w-measurable. For A x B E
and
A(AxB)
r
=
v(AnB)
if A x B
=
. Then
urn( I %xBk)
is n-dimen-
r
we define the number
, I is a countably additive measure on
with disjoint terms, then A n B
=
U;(\nB,)
in Y
X(AxB)
r
x
<
m
)
Y with by
(note that with
KERNEL OPERATORS
Ch. 13,9941
disjoint terms). (vxv)(AxB)
=
The measure
is finite, i.e., A(YxY)
A
0 implies A(AxB)
=
(because (vxv)(AxB)
0
one at least of the numbers u(A)
and
dory's extension procedure to
v
extended measure
A
V X
v(B)
and
and
<
m
=
0 implies that
is zero). We apply CarathEoA
to
. One might
expect that the
will be (vxv)-absolutely continuous, but this is not
the case. Indeed, writing sets AI and A2
225
v(Y)
=
a
for brevity, there exist disjoint sub-
such that their union is Y
Then the union D 1 of
A1
X
A 1 and A
=
0
2
x A2
and
v(A ) = v(A ) = ;a I 2 2 satisfies (vxv)(D ) = ;a
.
1
and
since A(AIxA2) = A(A2XAI)
. Repeating this ...)
obtain a descending sequence (D :n=1,2, (vxv)(Dn)
in Y x Y
such that
A(D ) =na for all n . Then the intersection n (vxv)(D) = 0 and A(D) = a . This shows that A is
2-"a2
=
decomposition procedure, we
and
D = nmD
satisfies I n not (uxv)-absolutely continuous on the o-algebra generated by smallest o-algebra containing
r
It is evident, therefore, that if one has measures, A such that
A(AxB)
= 0
not guarantee that however, 0
5
XI 5 A
XI
r
(i.e., the
).
for A x B E
r
implies AI(AxB)
=
and
0
,
A1
say,
then this does
will be A-absolutely continuous after extension. If, '
holds on
r
(as in the proof of Theorem 9 4 . 2 ) , there will
be no unpleasant surprises; after extension X I
will be A-absolutely
continuous. In our second example we consider the case that are the same a-finite measure space and identity operator
I in L
L
=
M
(X,h,p)
and
(Y,C,v)
is an ideal in M(Y,v)
. The
is a positive operator and it may be asked now
I is a kernel operator. We shall prove that if Y doesnot contain atoms, then I is not a kernel operator. The proof is due to A.R. Schep if
(C 1 3 , 1 9 7 7 ) .
THEOREM 9 4 . 7 . Let L be an idea2 i n M(Y,v) , #here Y does not cont a i n any atoms. Then the i d e n t i t y operator I i n L i s d i s j o i n t t o the band Lk(~,L) of absoZute kernez operators i n I i s not a kernel operator.
$,(L,L)
. It
foZZous that
226
BAND OF ABSOLUTE KERNEL OPERATORS
PROOF. Let
b e a p o s t i v e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r (from
T
. Then
S = inf(T,I)
and l e t
holds i n
8' 5 S 5 T
94.2 t h e r e e x i s t s a (vxv)-measurable f u n c t i o n that
is t h e k e r n e l of
Sfx,y)
p o s i t i v e on a s u b s e t of
Y x
assume t h a t t h e c a r r i e r of Y
xy E
such t h a t
1. Y
one a t l e a s t of t h e s e
n
Yn
and
,
v(Yn) <
c a l l it
For any (vxv)-measurable s u b s e t X(E) =
I
,
that
0
2
itself)
Y x Y
on
S(x,y)
L
s o by Theorem such
is strictly
Y i t s e l f , so t h e r e e x i s t s a sequence
is
L
L
S(x,y)
. Assume now
S
into
L
Lb(L,L)
Y of p o s i t i v e measure. A s b e f o r e , we may for a l l
m
, we
2
have
i s s t r i c t t y p o s i t i v e on a s u b s e t of
S(x,y)
Ch. 13,9941
of
E
. It
n
v(2) <
2 x 2
m
follows t h a t f o r
, xz E
and
L
of p o s i t i v e measure.
we d e f i n e t h e number
2 x 2
X(E) by
.
S(x,y)d(vxv)
E
Hence, f o r
and
A
5
I
B
measurable subsets of 2 , we have
1
(IxB)(x)dv(x) =
A
xBdv = v(AIIB1
-.
,
A
in particular
A(Zx2) 5 3(Z)
a non-negative
countably a d d i t i v e measure on t h e o-algebra of a l l (vxv)-
measurable s u b s e t s of 5
v(AIIB)
for
A
and
<
2 x 2
B
From t h e s e f a c t s we conclude t h a t
such t h a t
, we
have
0 < a 5 B <
m
v x v
. Since A1
e x i s t measurable d i s j o i n t s u b s e t s is
and
2
A2 x A2
i s f i n i t e and
2 . By . Writing
measunable s u b s e t s of
a b s o l u t e l y continuous w i t h r e s p e c t t o
B = v(2)
X(Zx2)
v(A ) = v(A2) = 16
. Then
1 s a t i s f i e s (vxv)(D ) = l B 2 1
and
its definition
a = X(Zx2)
A2
t h e union
of
DI
X
2
such t h a t D =
of
that
S(x,y)
A1 x A1
and
and
.
and X ( D ) = a n s a t i s f i e s (vxv)(D) = 0 and
(Dn:n=1,2,
(vxv)(Dn) = 2-nf32
for a l l
n"ID n
X(D)
d i c t s t h e a b s o l u t e c o n t i n u i t y of
is
X
and
such t h a t t h e i r union
2
Repeating t h e procedure, we o b t a i n a descending sequence intersecti,on
X(AxB) 5
does n o t c o n t a i n atoms, t h e r e
Y
A(DI) = X(A,XAI) + X(A xA ) = X(ZX2) = a 2 2
2
is
X
X with respect t o
in
. Then t h e . T h i s contra-
n
= a
v x v
...)
. The
assumption
i s s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e on a s e t of p o s i t i v e measure i s t h e r e f o r e
Ch. 13,5941
KERNEL OPERATORS
S(x,y) = 0
f a l s e . Hence S
I
inf(T,I) = 8
227
Y
almost everywhere on
Y
x
f o r any p o s i t i v e i n t e g r a l o p e r a t o r
. This shows t h a t T . In o t h e r words,
i s d i s j o i n t t o t h e band of a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s . As before, l e t
ideal i n
.
M(Y,v)
(Y,C,v) Since
be a a - f i n i t e measure space and l e t
t h e e x i s t e n c e of an a b s o l u t e v a l u e i n t h e c o m p l e x i f i c a t i o n f i e d . Hence, any
f = f +if2 1
s a ti s fying
The elements
fl
and
f2
L
be an
i s super Dedekind complete, t h e c o n d i t i o n s f o r
L
in
L+iL
a r e r e a l f u n c t i o n s on
,so
X
are satis-
L+iL
has an a b s o l u t e value
If
I
in
L+
t h e supremum can be
taken pointwise (almost everywhere), and we g e t
f o r almost every
y
. We
E Y
d e f i n e complex k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s . I f
i s another a - f i n i t e measure space and
T
o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r
from
L+iL
M
i s an i d e a l i n M+iM
into
M(X,p)
(X,A,v)
, then
the
i s s a i d t o be an a b s o l u t e
k e r n e l o p e r a t o r i f t h e r e e x i s t s a complexvalued (uxv)-measurable f u n c t i o n T(x,y)
on
X x Y
T
Assume t h a t T2
r e a l and l e t
such t h a t
s a t i s f i e s t h e s e c o n d i t i o n s . Let T(x,y) = T1(x,y) + iT2(x,y)
r e a l . It follows from
ITI(x,y)I S ( T ( x , y ) (
jlTl(x,y)f(y)I
dv(y)
T = T + i T 2 with 1 w i t h T I ( x Y y ) and
that
E M for all
f E L
,
Y and i t follows from t h e d e f i n i t i o n of (Tlf)(x) =
j Y
TI
T,(x,y)f(y)dv(y)
that for a l l
f
E L
.
TI
and
T2(x,y)
KERNEL OPERATORS OF FINITE RANK
228
Hence, T I is an absolute kernel operator (from L
. Similarly, T2
TI(x,y)
Conversely, if
1
and
T (x,y) 2
is an absolute kernel operator from L+iL = TI(x,y)
If
into M ) with kernel
is an absolute kernel operator with kernel T2(x,y). T2 are real absolute kernel operators from L
T I and
with kernels T (x,y)
into M
Ch. 13,9951
.
respectively, then T
into M+iM
with kernel
=
Tl+iT2
T(x,y) =
iT2(x,y) T = T +iT2 is an order bounded operator, the absolute value +
IT1
1
satisfies
T I cosB+T sinB:O
T
is a kernel operator, then so are
follows from
/TI 5 IT1[+ IT2/ that
kernel T(x,y) = T I(x,y)+iT2(x,y)
IT1
ITII and
IT2/
. Hence, it
is a kernel operator. Since the
satisfies
(x,y)cosB+T (x,y)sinB:O<€I<2~ 2 almost everywhere, it is evident that If T
IT1
has
IT(x,y)l
as kernel.
T is a non-absolute kernel operator from L+iL into M+iM , then
is an absolute kernel operator from L+iL into M(X,!.I) + iM(X,u)
the above remarks for
IT1 and
EXERCISE 94.8. Let an ideal in M(Y,v) that
IT(x,y)l
(Y,C,v)
,
so
hold in this situation.
be a o-finite measure space and let L be
such that the carrier of L
is the set Y
itself. Show
(Y,Z,v) contains an at most countable number of atoms. More pzecisely,
show that Y = Y atoms and Y2 to Y
1
U Y2
, where
Y 1 is the union of at most countably many
does not contain any atoms. Show that Y 1 is v-almost equal
if and only if the identity operator in L
is a kernel operator.
95. The band generated by the kernel operators of finite rank A s in the preceding section, we assume that
measure space and Y
L
is an ideal in M(Y,v)
itself. The band in the order dual L”
,
is a o-finite
L:
. If
0
is an integral on
there exists (by Theorem 86.3) a uniquely determined v-measurable
function g
on Y
such that
L is
consisting of all integrals (order
continuous linear functionals) is denoted by L
(Y,C,v)
such that the carrier of
Ch. 13,8951
KERNEL OPERATORS
It is evident that satisfy g
,
2
if and only if the corresponding g1 and
$ , 2 $,
. Hence,
g2
sup($,,$,)
.
inf($ ,$ ) 1 2 corresponds with lgl
similarly for
1$1
corresponds with
In particular, if
. This
fore, the band
on
L
L i in L”
-
$
sup(gl,g2)
corresponds with
82
and
g
,
then
shows that
simply because the integral on the left is is a v-measurable function on Y with an integral $
229
I$l(lfl)
. Conversely, if
such that ( 2 ) holds, then g
by means of formula ( I ) . with the ideal in M(Y,w)
We may identify, thereconsisting of all g
L (Y,v) for some p P satisfying 1 5 p 2 , then L” may be identified with the ideal L (Y,u) n q in M(Y,v) , where q is determined by p-l + q-l = 1 satisfying condition (2).
Let
(X,A,u)
in M(X,u) h
As an example, if L
g
corresponds
=
.
be another o-finite measure space and let M
. If the function
g
on
Y
is a member of :L
be an ideal
and the function
is a member of M , then the (pxu)-measurable function T(x,y)
on X
h(x)g(y)
into M
is the kernel of an absolute kernel operator from L f E L
since for every
=
,
we have
Any finite linear combination (with real coefficients) of kernel operators of this elementary kind is called a kernel operator o f f i n i t e rank. For the set of kernel operators of finite rank we use the notation L”
Q
M (tensor
product notation). The set L” B M is evidently a linear subspace of n L b ( ~ , ~ ) The band generated by L” 0 M in L b ( ~ , ~ ) is the second disjoint n Complement (L-BM)dd Since L” 0 M consists of absolute kernel operators, n n the band (L”BM)dd is contained in the band of all absolute kernel operators. n It may be asked whether there are other absolute kernel operators besides
.
.
those in (L2)dd
. We shall prove that under a rather natural condition
there are no other absolute kernel operators. Before mentioning the condition, we note that if kernel T(x,y)
,
T is an absolute kernel operator from L into M with then T(x,y) vanishes (uXu)-almost everywhere outside
230
5x
5
Y , where
xz
such that
E L
is the carrier of M
1,
, then
. Indeed, if
/T(x,y)/ du(y)
x E X-%
,
Letting
Z run through a sequence Yn 4 Y
and
so
IT(x,y)l
over
outside
x
the integral of
(X-$)
.
Y
X
Y
is zero, s o
to
Z i s a subset of
Y
vanishes for almost every
IT(x,y)l
THEOREM 95.1. If the c a r r i e r of
set
Ch. 1 3 , § 9 5 1
KERNEL OPERATORS OF FINITE RANK
over
, we
T(x,y)
(X-%)
x
Z is zeEo.
find that the integral of vanishes almost everywhere
Li i s the s e t
Y
L
lk(~,~) o f a l l absolute kernel operators from
i t s e l f , then the i n t o M i s equal
( L ~ M .) I~n ~other words, i n t h i s ease the s e t o f absolute kernel
operators i s the band generated by the kernel operators of f i n i t e rank. PROOF. It is sufficient to prove that every positive kernel operator is a member of and let V
n
(L>)dd Y
4
the carrier of
. Let
such that
E L for all n , 4 Y such that x Un E L l for all n (this is possible since
U
x
Vn Li is Y ). Then Y
.
= Un
n Vn satisfies Yn
4
Y
and
E L n:L for all n Furthermore, let Xn 4 % such that x E M Xn n' for all n and let be the kernel operator of finite rank with kernel Sn
x
Now, let T be an arbitrary positive kernel operator. For n = 1 , 2 , the operator T = inf(T,Sn)
...
,
is a kernel operator with kernel
n
T(x,y),Sn(x,y)
1.
and S E L" 8 M for all n , we have Tn E (L2M)dd Since 0 < T 5 S n n n n Taking into account now that T(x,p) = 0 almost everywhere
for all n outside
.
5x
Y
, it
alsmost everywhere on space Lb(L,M) T E (L2)dd
.
is evident that T (x,y) 4 T(x,y) holds pointwise n X x Y This implies that T I. T holds in the Riesz
.
. Hence, since
Tn E (L2)dd
We shall prove now that the carrier of
n
for all n
, it
follows that
L';I is the set Y
itself if
L" (when regarded as a subspace of the space of all linear n functionals on L ) separates the points of L ,i.e., if and only if
and only if
Ch. 13,8951
KERNEL OPERATORS
THEOREM 95.2. The c a r r i e r of :L
I,
f E L and
fgdv = 0 for a l l
I,
1
f E L
i t s e l f if and only
i f and only i f it follows from that
g E:L
PROOF. Note first that if
g E:L
Y
is t h e s e t
L , i.e.,
separates t h e p o i n t s of
if :L
23 1
f
, then
=
0
fgdv
JY
.
=
0 holds for all
. It is evident
Y lfgldv = 0 holds for all g E L i lfgldv = 0 implies fgdv = 0 Conversely, let
if and only if
.
1,
1
that fgdv = 0 Y for all g E L" i.e., in the terminology of linear functionals, +(f) = n' for all E:L The result proved in Theorem 83.9 imp ies now that
+
.
o
It follows that :L
separates the points of
g E:L
for all
L
implies f =
if and only if
o
.
LL
Assume now that the carrier of
is Y
f E L
1,
f = 0
points of
.
L
.
lfgldv = 0
-
f lfldv = 0 for all n 'Yn observed above, this implies that Ln separates the
. As
Conversely, assume that if then f = 0
I,
. Then there exists a . Hence, if f E L
for all n sequence Y t. Y such that xy E: L n satisfies Ifgldv = 0 for all g E:L , then and so
and
f E L
and
I,
I fgl dv
If, under this condition, the carrier of
ly smaller than Y
,
= 0
,
for all R E L;,
Li would be proper-
there would exist a subset F1 of Y
of positive
.
measure such that any g E L" vanishes almost everywhere on F 1 The set n Every g E L" F 1 has a subset F of positive measure such that xF E L vanishes almost everywhere on F which implies the carrier
";x of
=
n
, so
1,
.
(XFgldv= 0 for all g E L';I ,
0 by hypothesis. This contradicts v(F) > 0 is Y
.
. Hence,
A special case of the result that the band of absolute kernel operators is generated by the kernel operators of finite rank was proved by
G.Ya. Lozanovskii ([11,1966).
His proof is based on a theorem of N. Dunford
(1936), stating that anynorm continuous operator from Ll([O,ll,v)
Lp([O,ll,p)
, with
1 < p
5
m
and
1-1
into
Lebesgue measure, is an absolute
kernel operator, Dunford's theorem was generalized to more general measure spaces (by G.Ya. Lozanovskii and by A.V. Buhvalov, 1974); on the basis of this generalization A.V. Buhvalov fC13,1974) gave a proof of the general result in the present section. Our proof, as presented here, is quite
KERNEL OPERATORS OF FINITE RANK
232
Ch. 13,8951
different, since it is founded essentially on Schep's majorization theorem (Theorem 94.2). Dunford's theorem (in its generalized form) will appear as a corollary of some further results in section 98. The caae investigated by Lozanovskii deals with a class of normd Riesz spaces, the KB-spaces, to which a good deal of attention has been given in the Soviet literature. The normed Riesz space L (with the norm of noted by f
C
p(f) ) is called a KB-space if
0 implies p(fn)
constant M
+
0 ) and
0
5
p
de-
is o-order continuous (i.e., with p(f )
f 4
f
.
5
M
for some
sup f exists in L It follows immediately n that any KB-space is Dedekind o-complete. In the situation investigated implies that
by Lozanovskii v subspace of
is Lebesgue measure in Y
M(Y,v)
such that
L
=
C0,ll
and
i s a Riesz
L
is a KB-space with the additional
property that
The main result is now that if M
i s another KB-space of the same kind and
T is an order bounded operator from L rator if and only if where L*
T
into M , then T
is a kernel ope-
is contained in the band generated by
denotes the Banach dual of
L
.
L*
@
,
M
For the proof that this is a
special case of our general result, we refer to the exercises at the end of the present section. Another special case was investigated by R.J. Nagel and U. Schlotterbeck ([1],1972).
They consider order bounded operators from a Banach lattice
L
into a Banach lattice M
L
is order continuous (i.e., p ( u )
u
+
0 in L ) and M
under the conditions that (i) the norm
+
is Dedekind complete, (ii) L
and M
interior points, i.e., there exists a positive element u u
the ideal generated by
in
p
0 for any downwards directed system
is norm dense in L
,
have quasi-
in L
such that
and similarly for M
(iii) there exists a strictly positive normal integral on M therefore, a more general situation insofar as L
and M
. This
,
is,
do not necessarily
consist of measurable functions on a measure space. Nagel and Schlotterbeck use a representation of
L
and M
as spaces of continuous extended real-
valued functions to show that an order bounded operator (from L belongs to
(L*@M)dd
into M )
if and only if it can be represented as a kernel ope-
rator on these representation spaces. We say a few words about complexification of the results in this section,
Ch. 13,1951
KERNEL OPERATORS
s t i l l assuming t h a t t h e c a r r i e r of
L (L+iL,M+iM)
is
LL
233
i t s e l f . The s e t
Y
of a l l complex e b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s (from
k M+iM) i s now t h e c o m p l e x i f i c a t i o n of t h e band t o s e e t h a t t h i s i s t h e band g e n e r a t e d by EXERCISE 95.3. where
As i n Theorem 94.7,
(L-+iLL) n
let
L
into
L+iL
and it i s e a s y
.
(M+iM)
be an i d e a l i n
M(Y,v)
,
does n o t c o n t a i n any atoms. It was proved i n t h e theorem r e f e r r e d
Y
t o t h a t t h e i d e n t i t y o p e r a t o r i s d i s j o i n t t o t h e band kernel operators i n
.
L
L k ( ~ , ~ of ) absolute
I t f o l l o w s t h a t any o p e r a t o r i n t h e band g e n e r a t e d
by t h e i d e n t i t y o p e r a t o r i s d i s j o i n t t o T
,
(L2M)dd
.
L k ( ~ , ~ ) Show t h a t any o p e a r a t o r
i n t h e band generated by t h e i d e n t i t y o p e r a t o r i s a m u l t i p l i c a t i o n , i . e . ,
t h e r e e x i s t s a v-measurable f u n c t i o n almost everywhere f o r every
f E L
t
. This
on
Y
such t h a t
(Tf)(y) = t ( y ) f ( y )
l a s t result is also true i f
Y
has atoms.
EXERCISE 95.4.
i s an o p e r a t o r i n t h e i d e a l generated by t h e
T
H I N T: Assume f i r s t t h a t
i d e n t i t y o p e r a t o r and t h a t
xy E
L
.
L
Show t h a t any KB-space f E L
H I N T : Denote t h e norm of
by
p(f)
i s a Banach l a t t i c e .
. It
i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove
I f n w i t h terms i n L i s a b s o l u t e l y convergent i n norm k Cp(f ) < m 1, t h e n Cf i s convergent. Writing sk = Z If I , n I n p[=sk) S CY f o r a l l k , s o s = sup sk e x i s t s by one of t h e pro-
that i f the series (i.e.,
CY =
we have
p e r t i e s of m - s p a c e s . converges w i t h sum as w e l l , so
Cfn
L
. It
+
s-sk
0
implies
+
p(~-s,)
follows now e a s i l y t h a t
,
0
If:
and
so
Zfi
Zlfnl converge
converges.
EXERCISE 95.5. and l e t
Then s
Let
(Y,Z,v)
be a f i n i t e mpasure s p a c e , i . e . ,
be a Riesz subspace of
the additional property that (a) Show t h a t i f
fn
Y
almost everywhere on
.
+
M(Y,v)
0
in
L
, then
(b) Show t h a t i f
0 < g
( c ) Show t h a t
L
i s an i d e a l i n M(Y,v)
(d) Show t h a t
Y
is t h e c a r r i e r of b o t h
5
f
in
L
such t h a t
c L c LI(Y,v)
L,(Y,v)
M(Y,v)
fn(y) and
.
L
.
+
0
m
,
i s a KB-space w i t h holds pointwise
f E L
and
v(Y) <
:L
,
then
g E L
.
.
HINT: ( a ) I f f (y) = l i m f (y) i s p o s i t i v e on a s e t o f p o s i t i v e 0 n measure, t h e r e e x i s t s a number E > 0 and a s e t F of p o s i t i v e measure such
234
BUHVALOV' S THEOREM
that f
n
fo(y)
EX^
2
on
2 E
for a l l
. It
F n
and s i n c e
(b) I t follows from
0 5 gn4
Hence
go = sup gn
in
f o l l o w s from
,
L
exists in
in
, we
for a l l
go-gn J. 0
so
L
in
almost everywhere, so
(c) I f
i s measurable and
f
(by p a r t ( b ) ) , s o since
f E L
Y
. It
f o l l o w s from
for
that
xy E
t h a t f o r any
L
, so
f E L
....
1,2,
=
J. 0
(go-gn)(y) as well a s
,
f E L
n
idplies that
f-
are i n
L
then
If1 = s u p ( f , - f )
Y
i s t h e c a r r i e r of
t h e i n t e g r a l of
E L ,
/fl
over
i s f i n i t e , so
xy E
This shows t h a t
N
so
Ln
EXERCISE 95.6. Let
M
L, c I,
. Hence
.
Conversely, i f
L c L1
. This
gn(y) 1. go(y) g = g E L 0 If1 E L , t h e n f + and
i s a Riesz subspace.
L
(d) It follows from
L
.
. Since
E L
get a contradiction. n
L
almost everywhere by p a r t ( a ) . But t h e n gn(y) 4 g f y )
€xF
gn = i n f ( g , n ) E L
p(gn) < p ( f )
and
L
that
that
Lm c L
fn 9 0
L_ c L
Ch. 13,5961
L
i s t h e c a r r i e r of
Y
L"n
b e t h e same a s i n t h e preceding e x e r c i s e and l e t
be a s p a c e of t h e same type. It f o l l o w s a l r e a d y from t h e r e s u l t s i n t h i s
s e c t i o n and from what was proved i n t h e p r e c e d i n g e x e r c i s e t h a t an o p e r a t o r T
from
member of
(L>)dd
HINT:
f o r any
M
into
L
$
i s an a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r i f and only i f
. Shm that
It f o l l o w s from
E L*
. This
L;
f n J. 0
shows t h a t
i s e q u a l t o t h e Banach d u a l in
L
L* c L i
that
. For N
is norm complete by E x e r c i s e 95.4, so L* = L L" c L" = L* n
. It
follows t h a t
N
Ln = L*
.
p(fn) J. 0
,so
is a
T L*
L.
of
$(fn)
+
0
t h e converse, n o t e t h a t
L
by Theorem 85.6, and hence
96. Buhvalov's theorem I n t h i s s e c t i o n we s h a l l prove a remarkable theorem, due t o A.V. Buhval o v ([1],1974)
d e a l i n g w i t h a n e c e s s a r y and s u f f i c i e n t c o n d i t i o n f o r an
o p e r a t o r t o be a k e r n e l o p e r a t o r . Even f o r p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r s i n L -spaces 2
t h e c o n d i t i o n was n o t known b e f o r e . F i r s t we l i s t some p r o p e r t i e s of t h e space
M(X,u)
of a l l r e a l +measurable
f u n c t i o n s on t h e s e t
X
, where
( X , A , u ) i s a a - f i n i t e measure space. These p r o p e r t i e s w e r e d i s c u s s e d and
Ch. 13,1961
KERNEL OPERATORS
235
proved i n s e c t i o n 71. ( i ) (Lemna 71.1).
If
h o l d s f o r u-almost every and '-almost
( i i ) (Theorem 7 1 . 4 ) .
Xn
4
If
,
X
consequence, w r i t i n g
E M(X,p)
f
Xnfn(x)
f o ( x ) = sup,
f -uniformly t o z e r o . ( i i i ) (Theorem 71.5).
un
e x i s t numbers
.
M(X,')
> 0
n
.
for
fn(x)
lfn(x)I
n = 1,2
+
0
i s '-measurable
,... and
+
0
+
f(x)
, we
Xnfn(x)
0 5 f
If
have
E M(X,u) n (unfn:n=1,2,
such t h a t
for
...)
I t f o l l o w s now from t h e s e p r o p e r t i e s t h a t
. As
X
almost everywhere on
f o E M(X,u)
0 < f (x) < A-'f0(x) n
p r o p e r t y ( i ) , so i t f o l l o w s from 0
.. and
n = 1,2,.
0
then t h e r e e x i s t s a sequence of p o s i t i v e r e a l
such t h a t
m
for
p ( x ) = sup p E M(X,u)
everywhere f i n i t e , i . e . ,
almost everywhere on numbers
f E M(X,u) n x E X , then
that
fn
n = 1,2,
...
a
by converges
,
then there
i s bounded above i n
M(X,p)
has t h e s t r o n g
Egoroff p r o p e r t y (Theorem 71.6). We p r e s e n t a p r o o f , u s i n g only p u r e l y measure t h e o r e t i c terminology. THEOREM 96.1. k
in
M(X,u)
> 0
we have
e x i s t numbers in f
M(X,u)
n,k (n)
5
(fnksk=l , 2 , .
such t h a t
. It
-1 n h
'n
> 0
in M M
n
k(n)
..)
k
f o l l o w s t h a t f o r each
. Hence,
setting
such t h a t f o r every
. Then
M
n,k(n)
such t h a t
there exists
n
, we
be an i d e a l i n M(X,u) fnk
there e x i s t s a sequence
c
a s above, and l e t
h
n
...)
' gn
*
i.e.,
for
( i i i ) there
0
k = k(n)
un h n
2 h
such t h a t
obtain the desired result.
as
0
and l e t k
(hn:n=1,2,
X
n,k(n)
gn
as
a positive function
n
. By p r o p e r t y
h E M(X,u)
such t h a t hn(x) + 0 almost everywhere on there e x i s t s a number k(n) w i t h 0 5 f PROOF. Make
be a
and such t h a t
converges h -uniformly,
g = n-lh n
n we have
X
0 < f
with
t k(n,E)
and a f u n c t i o n
COROLLARY 9 6 . 2 . Let
where on X
for all
fnk 5 Ehn
...) +0
there e x i s t s a sequence (gn:n=1,2,
By p r o p e r t y ( i i ) t h e r e e x i s t s f o r every
hn E M(X,u)
fnk
n we have
almost euerywhere on
t h e r e e x i s t s a nwnber
n
PROOF.
. Then
gn(x) C 0
such t h a t
f o r every
E
such t h a t f o r every
almost everywhere on X
+ m
(fnk:n,k=1,2,
(Strong E g o r o f f p r o p e r t y . ] Let
double sequence in M(X,p)
+
m
...)
0 5 fnk
5
fo
almost everyi n the ideal
and such t h a t f o r every
' hn
*
= inf(gn,fo)
.
BLlHVAL0V"S THEOREM
236 THEOREM 96.3. Let
Let
be an i d e a l in M(X,u) and l e t 0 5 fnk < fo in inf f = 0 almost everwhere on X k nk for every n Then there e x i s t f i n i t e subsets
M
such t h a t f o r evevy
M
Ch. 13,1963
n we have
En = (fnk:k=1,2,.. . )
.
.
(n=l,Z,. . . I such t h a t f o r every natural number m n n inf(Um E ' ) = o in M . m n
E' c E
PROOF. Let 0 < gnk
2
fo
everywhere on (hn:n=1,2,
nk
...)
X
. By
in
= inf(fnl, f ) for n , k = l,2, Then nk and for every n we have gnk(x) C 0 as k +
'
we get for any natural number m
and M
(X,A,p)
that
and
e,Z,v)
be ideals in M(Y,v)
assumed that Y
almost
such that h (x) C 0 almost everywhere on X and n there exists a number k(n) with 0 < g n,k(n) hn*
n
Writing now
A s before, let
-
the last corollary there exists a sequence
M
such that for every
let L
... .
...,
g
in M
we have
be o-finite measure spaces and
and
is the carrier of both
M(X,u)
respectively. It is
L and L"
. We
recall the
definitions of convergence in measure and star-convergence. If the sequence (fn:n=1,2,
... )
of functions in L
and the measurable subset E
given, it is said that fn converges on
for every number function f
E >
0
converging pointwise to fn
*
+
f
, and
it is said that
if every subsequence of
of
Y
are
t o zero in measure if
E
fn star-converges
(fn:n=l,2, ...)
f almost everywhere on Y
to the
contains a subsequence
. This is denoted by
. The following lemma shows how convergence in measure and
star-
convergence are related. LEMMA 96.4. If 0
5 un
conditions are equivalent.
u
in
L for
n
=
1,2,.
.. , then
t h e following
Ch. 13,5961
KERNEL OPERATORS
*
0 as
237
.
(a)
un
+
(b)
u
converges t o zero i n measure on every subset of
n
n
+ m
measure, (c) For every subset r
as
]udv+O
of
E
Y satisfying
xE
Y
of f i n i t e
E LL we have
n+-.
E PROOF. (a)
* (b). Let
have to prove that v(Enk)
> 6
be the subset of E
of Y of finite
on which
u (y) 2
6 > 0 and some subsequence (nk:k=1,2, ...)
nk
E
. We
n tends to zero. If this fails to hold we have
"(En)
for some
a subsequence of
0 and the subset E
E >
measure be given and let En
if necessary, we may assume that
zero almost everywhere on E
,
so
t
k
v(lim sup E ) = 0 "k lim sup v(E
nk
u
. Selecting
converges to
"k . Hence
) t 6 > 0
,
which is impossible. (b)
* (a). Let E be a subset
sufficient bo prove that almost everywhere on
E
(un:n=1,2,
of
...)
Y
of finite measure. It is contains a subsequence converging
to zero. By means of the well-known diagonal
procedure it is then easy to obtain a subsequence converging almost everywhere on
Y
to zero. We restrict ourselves, therefore, to points
In view of the convergence in measure on k > 0 an index
and we may assume that
v(Ek)
< 2-k
.
there exist for every integer
such that
-k
we have
E
y € E
,
n l < n2 <
for n 2
nk'
... . Hence, if
so
that is, w(lim s u p E ) = 0 . This is the desired result, since u (y) "k k to zero for all y € (E-lim sup Ek) .
tends
BUHVALOV’S THEOREM
238
Ch. 13,9961
.
If the (a) * c). Let E be a subset of Y such that xE E Li integral of u over E does not tend to zero, there exists a number E
>
0 such that
for some subsequence sequence Since 0
(vm:m=1,2, 5
v 2 u E L m
-
. This subsequence contains a
(un :k=l,2,...)
... )
ksuch that
vm(y)
+
*
. This
m
Y
.
and
it follows now from the dominated convergence theorem that
m
sub-
0 almost everywhere on
contradicts ( I ) ,
+
v du m
and so (c) holds.
+
0 as
.
Let Y Y such that xy E Ln for all m It is m sufficient to prove that (un:n=1,2,. ..) $as a subsequence converging to (c)
(a).
N
zero almost everywhere on a fixed Ym
,
since by means of the diagonal
procedure it is then easy to obtain a subsequence converging to zero almost everywhere on
Y
. Fix
m
and, for the purposes of this proof only, let
the integration sign denote integration over Ym n + =
Hence
,
so there exists a subsequence
W
(u
%
. We have
:k=l,2,...)
almost everywhere on
u du
I n
* 0 as
such that
Ym , which implies that
holds for almost every y E Y m
.
The first main result in this section follows now. THEOREM 96.5. (BuhvaZov’s theorem f o r order bounded operators.) For
an order bounded operator
T
from L i n t o M
t h e foZZowing conditions
are equivalent. (a) T is a kernel operator. ( b ) If
uhere on X
.
0
5
PROOF. (a)
un 5 u E L
and
un
0
, then
(b). We may assume that T
(Tun)(x)
*
0
ahfost every-
is positive (because if
KERNEL OPERATORS
Ch. 1 3 , 8 9 6 1
(a)
(b)
holds for T+ and
T- , then it holds for T ). Hence, let T
be a kernel operator with kernel with
u
*
n
X with
+
0 as
p(X-X
n +
) = 0
0
m
. Since
<
, where
holds for all xo E Xo it follows for every
n
from
almost everywhere on
Y
that
holds for all
k
(vm:m=1,2, ...)
2
0 and let
,
05 u
n
5 u
E
there exists a subset
L
xo
of
zero as n
-
the integration i s over Y
Assume now that for some point
to
T(x,y)
05 u E L
such that
T(xo,Y)u(y)dv(y)
does not tend
239
+ m
xo E Xo
. Then there exists a number
+
xo E X
0 ’
the sequence
. By hypothesis, (un :k=l,Z,...)
such that vm(y)
. If
E
> 0 and
has a subsequence
0 kalmost everywhere,
so
by the dominated
convergence it follows that
This contradicts (2). We have proved, therefore, that
E XO , i.e., (Tun)(x) + 0 as n + m for ,almost every x E X 0 * (a). Assume first that T is positive, so let the positive
for all x (b)
.
2.40
operator T
satisfy condition (b). We have
.
8 5 Tq E
kernel operator and
kernel operators form the band
,
Lb(L,M)
It follows from 8
2
T 5
Let Y
T2
2
0
S
I. Y
such that
x
*
+
=
0
{T(u-uxyn))
(XI
+
for a l l
n
u
T
. There exists a
is the carrier of both
L
and
,
Ln
.
so
0
, i.e., {T(ux )}(x) + (Tu)(x) for almost every n' it evident that we need only prove that (Tu)(x) = 0 for all
05 u E L
vanishes outside some fixed Y
. We
satisfying the condition
fix therefore a natural number
and we assume now that we have a non-negative function u
that
Hence
x E X
. This makes
u
.
E L fl :L
, then (u-ux )(y) + 0 almost everywhere on Y n' 0 holds certainly. Hence
holds almost everywhere on X that
T I a positive
and we have to prove that if
u E L
for almost every x E X
TI+T2 with
that T2 also satisfies condition (b).
T E (L2M)d
n' sequence with this property since Y (u-ux ) n'
=
(L-@M)d This decomposition holds since the n(Ln8M)dd in the Dedekind complete space
satisfies condition (b), then T
If
T
so
we may assume now that 8
no
Ch. 13,1961
BUHVALOV'S THEOREM
vanishes outside Yn
. Let
Fo = (x:(Tu)(x)>O)
in L
and let
such
S be the
kernel operator of finite rang with kernel
Then
inf(T,S)
the ideal M
= 8
holds in L b ( ~ , ~ ), and
. By Theorem 83.6 this means
so
{inf(T,S)}(u)
= 0 holds in
that
(3) Since M
is order separable there exists an at most countable set
(vk:O
such that
Ch. 13,1967 From
241
KERNEL OPERATORS
(Sv )(x)
(Sv +T(u-vk))(x) almost everywhere on k 0 almost everywhere on X , i.e.,
5
k
inf (Sv )(x) k k
=
(Tu) (x)
.(infk /vkdv)
almost everywhere on
X
, where
it follows that
= 0
the integration is over Y
"0
that for every positive integer n we have infk{(Svk+T(u-vk))(x):
(5)
X
/vkdvcn-'}
alsmost everywhere on the set Fo
=
This implies
0
. It follows
(x:(Tu)(x)>O)
=
.
that for every
n we have infk{(T(u-v almost everywhere on
k ) J ( x ) : Ivkdv
Fo
. Note now
that we may assume that no vk
Fo
It follows that if for n = 1,2,.
=
0 we have
.. we
any given vk = 0
set
,
En = (T(u-vk) : /vkdv
1 vkdv
is
Sv +T(u-v ) = Tu , s o the k k in (5) does not change if we leave the zerofunction out.
identically zero, because for vk infimum on
= 0
can occur in o n l y finitely many
, which
functions in En
would imply vk
=
vanish outside Fo
0
. Note
En
, because
otherwise
that for every n
. It follows
the
from (6) that for each n
is zero almost everywhere on En is a common majorant of all func-
separately the infimum of the functions in
X and the element Tu in the ideal M tions in all
En
together. Hence, Theorem 9 6 . 3 can be applied. By this
...
theorem, there exists finite subsets E' c E (n=1,2, ) such that n n inf(UmE') = 0 for every m Returning to the original notation, this means m n that there exists a subsequence (vkn:n=1,2, ) such that
.
(7)
(8)
(y)dv + 0
infn>m {T(u-v
kn
...
as n
)](x)
=
+ m
,
0 almost everywhere on Fo
for every m
.
242
BUHVALOV'S THEOREM
Ch. 13,5961
*
It follows from (7) by the last lemma that v -+ 0 as n + m , s o kn (Tv )(x)- 0 almost everywhere on X A l s o , it follows from ( 8 ) that, kn for all m ,
.
almost everywhere on where on Fo (Tu)(x) X
. Hence
> 0
. This
Fo
,
and
(Tu)(x)
so
lim sup(Tvk )(x)
=
. Combining these results, we get (Tu)(x) n= 0 . But Fo is, by definition, the set of all x
where on Fo
ii(Fo) = 0
, and
so
(Tu)(x)
=
almost everyalmost everysatisfying
0 almost everywhere on
is the desired result.
It remains to extend the proof to the case that
i s order bounded
T
but not necessarily positive. It is sufficient to prove that if order bounded operator such that Tu
-+
n + Tu
n
5
u
have this property for the sequence
0
2
. Then
, which
v = u-u n implies
satisfies 0 2 v
(un:n=1,2, 5 u
from v
*
-+
u
that
Hence, noting that
(10)
+
*
inf(v,v ) v , so T(inf(v,vn)) n T(inf(v,v ) ) 5 T+vn , we get n -+
0
v
5
-+
so
T+U =
0
sup ~ v : ~ s v i u5 lim inf
Combining (9) and ( l o ) , we obtain T+u T+u
=
T+(u-v )
-+
=
T+V
...)
for all
For an inequality in the converse direction, let
and
*
E L and u
T
is an
0 implies
0 pointwise almost everywhere, then T+ has the same property. Hence,
let T u
02 u
.
lim T+vn , so
0
pointwise almost everywhere. This concludes the proof.
S
satisfying
n
,
so
u
.
It follows
0
5
T+v
n
Tv by hypothesis.
2
KERNEL OPERATORS
Ch. 13,§961
243
As noted already, the first proof i?f the above theorem was given by An independent proof is due to A.R.
A.V. Buhvalov ([1],1974).
Schep ( [ I ] ,
1977). Their proofs are similar. The proof presented here closely follows Buhvalov's theorem possesses points of
Schep's method (cf. also C21,1979).
analogy with a theorem on bilinear forms proved much earlier by H. Nakano ([31,1953). Nakano proved (in Theorem 5.2 of his paper) that a positive bilinear form is contained in the band generated by the finite rank bilinear forms if and only if it satisfies a certain continuity condition analogous to condition (b) in Buhvalov's theorem. The analogy extends itself to the proof; the formulas (3)-(8)
above correspond to analogous formulas in Naka-
no's proof. Our final a i m in this section is the proof that if
T
is an operator
(not necessarily order bounded) which maps the ideal L
into the ideal M
and which satisfies Buhvalov's condition (i.e., 0 2 u
u E L
implies
(Tun)(x)
+
0
almost everywhere), then T
2
and
*
u
+
n is a kernel operator.
0
The first step is to derive from Buhvalov's condition that T ,when regarded as an operator from L
into M ( X , p )
,
is order bounded. For this purpose
. We
we need more information about order bounded sets in M ( X , p ) mention an Egoroff type result for uniform divergence.
first
-
LEMMA 96.6. Let 0 2 un E M(X,u) s a t i s f y un(x) 4 as n + m on a E of X of f i n i t e p o s i t i v e measure. Furthermore, l e t E > 0 be
subset
given. Then there e x i s t s a measurable subset and t h e sequence C > 0
(un:n=1,2,
...)
there e x i s t s a natural number
x E A and
all
A
of
E
diverges uniformly on N
such that
such that p(E-A) < A
, i . e . , f o r any
u (x) 5 C
for all
n 5 N .
PROOF. Apply Egoroff's theorem to the sequence of functions
c ( I + ~)-':n=1,2,
...} .
THEOREM 96.7. Let
D
be a non-empty subset of
order bounded i f and only i f f o r any sequence
hnfn(x)
(fn:n=l ,2,,..)
+
from
M(X,p)
. Then
D
0
almost everywhere on X
I)
and a n y sequence of numbers
xn+o. PROOF. For the purposes of the present proof we shall say that
is
holds
D
E
244
BUHVALOV'S THEOREM
satisfies condition
if
(a)
...)
sequence (f :n=l,Z,
from
that order boundedness of satisfies
,
(a)
so
implies that D
satisfies
.
0
(a)
for any
It is evident
. For
the
(If]:fED) likewise
we may just as well assume that D
consists of non-
the upwards directed set obtained
Dl by taking finite suprema, i.e., each g E D l is of the form
g = sup(fi:i=l,
...,k)
fni E D
for all
pi = X I pi =
Then pi J. 0
and let
. Every
x
almost every
,
A2
so
fi E D
with
be a sequence in D l
with
+
satisfies
. Then the set
(a)
negative functions. We now denote by from D
X
0 almost everywhere on
+
and any sequence A n
D
D
D
converse, assume that
Anfn(x)
Ch. 13,5961
for
An C 0
i
= I,
. We prove
...,k . Let that
(gn:n=l, 2,
Angn(x)
+
. . .)
0 for
is of the form
g
n
i. Define
for
i
for i
= I, =
...,k 1
*
'
k +I,...,kl+k2;... 1
in view of condition
(a)
.
the sequence
...,u k lf 1 , k l t u k l + l f 2 1 ~ ~ ~ +k ~'uk f2,k27'*'
Ulfl1,
1
converges pointwise almost everywhere on X
2
to zero. This implies that the
sequence
...
converges pointwise almost everywhere on X
to zero, i.e., Algl,A2g2,
converges pointwise almost everywhere on
to zero. It has thus been shown
that D 1 satisfies condition that the given set D
f
0
=
sup D
X
we may just as well assume immediately
i s directed upwards. By Lemma 94.4 the function
exists (it is not excluded in this lemma that
on a set of positive measure) and there is a sequence
D such that f
( a ) , so
4
fo
f = sup f 0
. Assume now that
. Since
D
f (x) =
...)
(fn:n=1,2,
,...)
in
is directed upwards, we may assume that holds on a set E
n 0 Then, by the last lemma, there exists a subset A
ofpositive measure and
fo has the value (fn:n=1,2
of
E
of positive measure. such that A
diverges uniformly to
m
on
is A
.
Ch. 13,5961
n 1 < n2 <
Hence, there exist natural numbers holds on A A
for k
245
KERNEL OPERATORS
for all n t nk (k=l,Z,
...
= 1,2,
...
such that
...) . This implies
fn(x) t k
k-'fn, (x) t 1
on
, which is impossible since D satisfies Eondition
. It follows that fo is finite almost everywhere on sup D = fo E M(X,u) . In other words, D is order bounded. (a)
X
,
so
Everything is now available to prove the final main theorem. L
THEOREM 96.8. (Buhvalov's theorem.) A s before, Zet
and M(X,p)
i d e a l s i n M(Y,v) of both L and
Lx
r e s p e c t i v e l y such t h a t
and l e t
i.e., 0 every
u
5
x E X
5
.
u E L and
PROOF. If T(x,y)
,
un
*
-f
0
implies
into M
L
. Then
s a t i s f i e s Buhvazov's condition, (Tun)(x)
f o r almost
0
-f
T is a kernel operator from L into M with kernel
then (as observed already when kernel operators were defined) there
exists a kernel operator Ta from L kernel, and if then T
T
be
i s the c a r r i e r
Y
T be an operator from
T i s a kernel operator i f and only if
and M
=
into M(X,u)
having
IT(x,y)l
as
T is now regarded as an operator from L into M(X,u) ,
T~-(T~-T)with T
and
T -T
positive,
T
so
is order bounded.
The proof that T satisfies Buhvalov's condition can now be taken over from Theorem 96.5. Conversely, let
T be an operator from L
1w's condition. Note first that if into M(X,u) that T
, then
T
T
into M
still satisfies Buhvalov's condition. We shall prove
is now order bounded. For this purpose, let in L and let D = (Tv:O
val (v:Osv
have to show that (hn:O
satisfying Buhva-
is regarded as an operator from L be an order inter-
S
. We
be its image in M(X,u)
. To do this, let C 0 . Then implies X v 0 . n n
D is an order bounded set in M(X,p)
be an arbitrary sequence in D and let A
v X u .L 0 , so A v -+ 0 , which certainly n n n n n Hence X fin = T(Xnvn) + 0 pointwise almost everywhere by Buhvalov's n condition. This shows that D satisfies the condition ( a ) in the last 0 5
theorem, so
D is order bounded in M(X,p)
image of any order interval in L follows that T
. Having shown
thus that the
is an order bounded set in M(X,u)
is an order bounded operator from L
into M(X,u)
, it
. But
then, by Buhvalov's theorme for order bounded operators (Theorem 96.5), T is an absolute kernel operator from L into M
into M(X,u)
by hypothesis, it is evident that T
.
Since T maps
(as a mapping from L
L
into
246
Ch. l 3 , § 9 6 1
BUHVALOV'S THEOREM
M ) is a kernel operator. We add some remarks about the case that the ideals L equipped with Riesz norms, i.e., L
and M
is norm complete (in other words, if L an absolute kernel operator from by Theorem 83.12 T
M
is a Banach lattice) and
into M , then T
L
and
are
are normed Riesz spaces. If T
is norm bounded. It remains to investigate the case that
T
THEOREM 96.9. Let
+
L
f i n norm i n
and
L
r e s p e c t i v e z y such t h a t fn
is
is order bounded, so into M .
is an arbitrary (possibly non-absolute) kernel operator from L
operator mapping
L
M
L and M
be i d e a l s i n M(Y,v)
into M
. Then
and
Tfn + g
L
and
are Banach l a t t i c e s . Let
M(X,y)
be a kernel
T
T i s a cZosed operator ( i . e . , if i n norm, then
g = Tf
1. Hence, by t h e
closed graph theorem, T i s n o m bounded. PROOF. Let
f
+
f
and
Tfn
+
irl norm. By Theorem 100.6 (which will
g
follow in the next chapter, but to the proof of which we refer because it can be read independently) any norm convergent sequence in a Banach lattice has a subsequence converging in order,
(passing to a subsequence if neces-
so
sary) we may assume that there exists a sequence If-f 1 < hn
that
+
0 pointwise almost everywhere on Y
certainly 0 s If-f I
5
hl E L
for all n
seen, the operator Ta with kernel from L on X
into M(X,y)
. Hence
. On
(since M
,
i.e., Tfn
the other hand we have
and
IT(x,y)l
Ta(lf-fnl)
-t
by Buhvalov's condition. Then also
wise almost everywhere on X on X
Tfn
+
+
g
1,2,3 and f o r each
let T and into L2 of
S
*
+
in L
such
. This implies that 0
.
As we have
is a positive kernel operator /T(f-fn)I
Tf
< Ta(lf-fnl)
-t
0 point-
pointwise almost everywhere
in norm in M
by hypothesis, so
is a Banach lattice) there exists a subsequence Tf
EXERCISE 96.10. Let =
If-fnl
...)
0 pointwise almost everywhere
converging pointwise almost everywhere on X
i
(hn:n=1,2,
to
g
. Hence
Tf
...)
(i=l,2, =
g
.
(Xi,Ai,yi) be a-finite measure spaces for i
,
let Li be an ideal in M(Xi,yi)
. Furthermore,
S be order bounded and order continuous operators from L l into L3 respectively. Show that if one at least
and from L2
and
L l into L j
T is a kernel operator, then ST
.
is a kernel operator mapping
Ch.
13,9961
EXERCISE 96.11. L e t
u
gue measure
and l e t
be k-dimensional r e a l number space w i t h Lebes-
X
be an i d e a l i n
L
v a r i a n t under t r a n s l a t i o n s , i . e . , =
f(x-a)
24 7
KERNEL OPERATORS
for a l l
,
x E X
i d e n t i t y operator i n
L
then
if
M(X,u)
Ta(aEX)
Taf E L
such t h a t
f o r every
f E L
i s in-
L
i s d e f i n e d by
(Taf)(x) =
. We
denote t h e
by I. Show t h a t any t r a n s l a t i o n o p e r a t o r
d i s j o i n t from any a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r
L
T (from
is
Ta
i n t o i t s e l f ) . For
t h i s i s Theorem 94.7.
a = 0
i s a k e r n e l o p e r a t o r by t h e preceding e x e r c i s e , so
HINT: T T-a
i n f ( T T-a,I)
by Theorem 94.7.
= 9
I t f o l l o w s t h a t , f o r every
u E L+
0 = l i n f ( T T-a,I)
=
1
=
,
inf(Tv'+T wl:vt ,w'EL+,v'+w'=u)
.
= {inf(T,Ta)}(u)
EXERCISE 96.12. With t h e same d e f i n i t i o n s and n o t a t i o n s a s i n t h e p r e c e d i n g e x e r c i s e , show t h a t a l l t r a n s l a t i o n o p e r a t o r s i n d i s j o i n t . Hence, i f l a t i o n operator Lk(L,L)
Ba
,
Ta
i s t h e band g e n e r a t e d i n
then each
Ba
Ln(L,L)
a r e mutally
L
by t h e t r a n s -
i s n o t only d i s j o i n t from t h e band Ba
of a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s , b u t a l l
a r e a l s o mutually
d i s j o i n t . This r e s u l t was noted by B. d e P a g t e r .
HINT: For s i m p l i c i t y of n o t a t i o n , l e t space. We i n d i c a t e t h e proof t h a t
X
b e one-dimensional number
inf(Ta,I) = 9 f o r
a > 0
.
For
n
integer, l e t
A = U(A :n even) and B = U(An:n odd). Then n j o i n t w i t h union X Note now t h a t , f o r any u E L+
and l e t
.
A
and
B
are dis-
,
. For
v = uxA
x E A
,
so
and
w = uxB we have
{inf(Ta,I)](u)
f u n c t i o n v a n i s h e s on EXERCISE 96.13. ideal
L
in
M(Y,v)
B
Let
.
v+w = u
v a n i s h e s on
(Y,x,u)
A
and
. Prove
(lav+w)(x) = 0
for a l l
similarly that the
be a o - f i n i t e measure space and l e t t h e
be equipped w i t h an o r d e r continuous Riesz norm
P
248
ADJOINT OPERATORS
such t h a t
i s a Banach l a t t i c e with r e s p e c t t o
L
(i)
Ch. 13,§9751
Show t h a t
p(fn)
+
0
implies
.
p
*
, but
fn + 0
not conversely i n
general. (ii) p(fn)
Show t h a t i f i f and only i f
0
+
0 S If
( i i i ) Let an i d e a l i n
fn
n
I
f E L O
5
.
3 0
for
...
n = l,Z,
then
(X,Ayu) be another o - f i n i t e measure space and l e t
. Show
M(X,u)
t h a t t h e operator
T
, mapping
implies
0
0
(Tfn)(x)
+
HINT:
( i ) To show t h a t
be
M
,
into
L
sequence onto an almost everywhere n u l l sequence ( i . e . , 0 p(fn)
M
is
T maps every dominated norm n u l l
a k e r n e l o p e r a t o r i f and o n l y i f and
,
almost everywhere on
i
p(fn) + 0
implies
*
fo E L
5
X ).
, use
fn + 0
I
If
S
again (as i n
t h e proof of Theorem 96.9) than any norm convergent sequence i n a Banach l a t t i c e has a subsequence converging i n order. For t h e converse, l e t Y = [O,ll
on
f n (y) =
, but
y
L = L (Y,v) . Now choose 2 and zero elsewhere. Then f n ( y ) + 0 f o r a l l
with Lebesgue measure
CO,n-'l
IlfnlI2 = 1
0
( i i ) Let
for all
n
If I 5 f o E L
5
and l e t
w
.
and
0
fn
. Assume
that
pff,)
+
0
does not hold. Passing t o a subsequence i f necessary, we may assume t h a t p(fn) t
f o r some
E
a subsequence
f
> 0
E
and a l l
, i.e.,
that
If
I
If
"k %
5
L
"k . Since
k
+
m
I
+ p
5
f
hk
+
20
fn
of
"k
M(Y,v) . Then . In o t h e r words,
0
in
(\:k=1,2,
in
L
there exists
y E Y
. By
converges t o zero i n order i n t h e space
t h e r e e x i s t s a sequence
0
. In view
converging t o zero f o r almost every
nk
Theorem 7 1 . 3 t h i s means t h a t M(Y,v)
n
0 f
2
"k
...)
M(Y,w)
gk = i n f ( h k , f o )
E L
such and
converges t o zero i n order i n
i s order continuous, t h i s implies t h a t
. Contradiction.
in
p(f
"k
)
+
0
as
9 7 . Adjoint operators Let L#
and
L M#
and
M
be a r b i t r a r y ( r e a l ) v e c t o r spaces with a l g d b r a i c duals
and l e t
d e f i n i n g $ ( f ) = $(Tf)
i.e.,
$J
E L#
i f we w r i t e T#
. Any
$ = T#g
be an operator from
T
for a l l
f E L
L
into
g e t a mapping
i s l i n e a r ; i n o t h e r words, T#
R e c a p i t u l a t i n g , we have
. For
any $ E M#
we get a l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on
6 E M # thus determines an element
, we
M
T#
from
Mfl
$
E L#
into
i s an operator from M#
L# into
, so
L
that
, ,
. Obviously, L#
.
Ch. 13,8971
KERNEL OPERATORS
(T#@)(f)
@(Tf)
=
fE L
for all
249 and
@
E M#
.
Note also that
for all T1,T2 and all real coefficients al,a2 called the algebraic adjoint of Assume now that L M
and M
.
T
T# is
are Riesz spaces such that, in addition,
is Dedekind complete, The additional hypothesis ensures that any
T E Lb(L,M)
is of the form T = TI-T2 with TI and T2 positive. Given
any T E Lb(L,M)
, the
The operator Td
maps
let Ji
where
=
. For
T"$
Jil
and
Q2 Ji E L"
shows that
restriction of T# into L"
M-
. For
to M*
are obviously positive linear functionals on
. The operator
the general case that T
T"
+
L
is also
is positive ( s o
T"
is positive). Let
satisfying
$T
For the theorem which follows now we recall that :L
n
+ 0 . We
taking an arbitrary and
L"
the bands of o-order continuous and order continuous members of
and Me
. This .
is order continuous. For
. This follows by (TV$T) (u) = $T(Tu) .L 0 .
0 in L"
E L+ and observing :hat
Similarly for :M
.
are "" L .
THEOREM 97.1. Let L m d M be Riesz spaces such that, i n addition, i s Dedekind complete. I f T E l,(L,M) i s o-order continuous, then T" maps Mi n t o L: Similarly, i f " T i s order continuous, then T- maps :M i n t o L" M
n
.
.
and
is positive. Hence, in
is order bounded, the operator T"
be a downwards directed system in M" T"+
N
T
is called the order adjoint of T
is positive if T
this purpose, we may assume that T
($T:~€{~l)
E M"
the proof, let 0 5 @
order bounded. More is true ; we show that T"
have to show that
will be denoted by
f E L we have
any
The proof shows a l s o that T"
u
. The operator
.
PROOF. Let T be o-order continuous. We may assume that T
is posi-
250
t i v e . T o show t h a t in
Ch. 13,1971
A D J O I N T OPERATORS
implies
L
T-$ E L z
(T-g)(un)
+
for
0
$
for
f M i , we have t o prove t h a t $ E :M We may assume t h a t
.
u $I
n
+
0
is
p o s i t i v e . Then
since
Tun
+
. The
0
proof f o r o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y i s s i m i l a r .
W e r e t u r n t o t h e s i t u a t i o n a s discussed i n t h e e a r l i e r p a r t s of t h i s chapter. Let and
M
(X,A,u)
(Y,C,v)
and
be i d e a l s i n
M(Y,v)
i s t h e c a r r i e r of both
.
and
and
L
be a - f i n i t e measure spaces and l e t M(X,v)
= L;
L-
L
r e s p e c t i v e l y . We assume t h a t
Y
i s t h e c a r r i e r of both
M
and
X
M" = M" Note t h a t t h e l a s t c o n d i t i o n is obviously s a t i s f i e d i f L c n M a r e of t h e L -type f o r some p such t h a t 1 S p 2 m , because i f P f o r example L = L (Y,v) , then LL may be i d e n t i f i e d w i t h L (Y,v) for P 9 p-'+q-' = I Under t h e s e hypotheses, l e t T be an a b s o l u t e k e r n e l opera,., t o r from L i n t o M Then T i s o r d e r continuous, so T i s a l s o order and
and
.
.
:M
continuous and maps
into
i s , t h e r e f o r e , an o p e r a t o r from i s an a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r .
L" "N
Mn
THEOREM 97.2. Let L and M be clyl absolute kernel operator Then the r e s t g e t i o n T ' of Tfrom :M i n t o :L such that f o r T
n
a h o s t everywhere on Y PROOF. For
f E L
. The r e s t r i c t i o n i n t o ;,I
g E M i we have
s o by F u b i n i ' s theorem t h e f u n c t i o n h(y) =
I
X
TI
of
T"
to
s h a l l prove t h a t
M : T'
s a t i s f y the mentioned conditions and l e t from L i n t o M uith kernel T(x,y) . t o :M i s an absolute kernel operator any g E M L U e have
.
and
. We
IT(x,y)g(x)ldv(x)
Ch. 1 3 , § 9 7 1
KERNEL OPERATORS
i s a measurable function on
Y
I
25 1
with t h e property t h a t
h(y)lf(y)ldv(y) <
m
Y for all
f E L , so
. Writing
h E :L
T'(x,y)
=
, it
T(y,x)
follows t h a t
L f o r every g E M i , and t h e same holds with T(x,y) n replaced by IT(x,y)l This shows t h a t t h e k e r n e l T'(x,y) d e f i n e s an N
i s a member of
.
absolute kernel operator f E L
and
,
M g E ;
M"
from
S
T'
is exactly the r e s t r i c t i o n
of
into
" , T
to
L';I
Mi
. We have . For t h i s
t o prove t h a t
S
purpose, t a k e
and observe t h a t
L e t us assume now t h a t
L
, besides
s a t i s f y i n g t h e same conditions as
i n t h e l a s t theorem, i s a Banach l a t t i c e with r e s p e c t t o a norm which we p ; the
shall call by
.
p(f)
norm of an element
f E L
w i l l be denoted t h e r e f o r e
We s h a l l denote t h e norm i n t h e Banach dual by
p*
. Since
L
is a Banach l a t t i c e , t h e Banach dual i s t h e same as t h e order dual (by
so
Theorem 85.6), t h e norm
p*(g)
N
L* = L
. It
follows t h a t
i s given by
L" c L* n
. For
any
g E :L
Y
Now, € o r any g(Y)
2
= lfgl
0
and and
g E :L
and
f E L
f j ( y ) = -If(y)l p(fl) = p(f)
. It
,
let
at a l l
f J ( y ) = If(y) I y
where
g(y)
at all i
0
y
. Then
where flg =
follows t h a t we may j u s t a s well w r i t e
,
252
ADJOINT OPERATORS
This shows that p *
, because it is evident from the
is a Riesz norm on :L
last formula that p*(g)
=
.
implies p*(gl) s p*(g2)
Ch. 13,1973
for all g E:L
p*(lgl)
and
0
5
g1
N
2
g2 E Ln
It is perhaps of some interest to note that a Banach lattice L
as
introduced here is often called a Banach f u n c t i o n space. The space L' all v-measurable functions g
is then called the associate space of
norm of
p
. From what was proved
hypotheses the space L' of
p*
to
N
L' = Ln
L
and
p'
is called the associate
above, it is evident that under the present
is the same as :L
. For a
of
satisfying
and
p'
is the restriction
further investigation of Banach function spaces
we refer to section 112. Next, assume that both
L
and M
, besides
satisfying the same con-
ditions as in the last theorem, are Banach lattices. Any norm continuous by Theorem 83.12,
the operator T*
N
and the order adjoint T
the algebraic adjoint T# =
M"
, we
T € Lb(L,M) is the Banach adjoint operator T* exists;
is a continuous mapping from M*
the Banach adjoint T* M*
so
T*
find that
to M* =
T"
and M"
into L*
. Observing that
are the restrictions of
respectively and noting that
. The restriction
T' of T"
N
to Mn
,
as introduced in the last theorem, is therefore the same as the restriction of
N
T* to Mn
. As
a consequence of all these observations, the following
theorem is now a variant of the last theorem.
Let L and M be Banuch l a t t i c e s as introduced above T be an absolute kernel operator from L i n t o M w i t h kernel T(x,y) . Then T i s norm continuous and t h e r e s t r i c t i o n T' o f T* t o :M i s an absolute kernel operator from M" i n t o Ln such t h a t f o r any g E M"n n THEOREM 97.3.
and l e t
N
we have
almost evemhere on Y
.
13,5971
Ch.
KERNEL OPERATORS
253
In Theorem 97.2 and 97.3 we have met w i t h c o n d i t i o n s from which one may conclude t h a t
i s a k e r n e l o p e r a t o r i f it i s known t h a t
T'
is a
T
k e r n e l o p e r a t o r . We prove one r e s u l t i n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n . B e f o r e , doing s o , we observe t h a t i f ( a s b e f o r e ) L t h e c a r r i e r of b o t h N
N
(Ln)n (Lz):
,
so
L
and
f o l l o w s by observing t h a t
functions
f
and every
f E L
then
L (:):
i s a l i n e a r subspace of
L
. That
i s included i n
L
c o n s i s t s of a l l v-measurable
THEOREM 97.4.
in M(Y,v)
and i n
N
ll and
(Ln)n
T
.
(c,)
of a l l sequences con-
. We assume a l s o t h a t
and M i
M
be an operator from L
of the algebraic dual
T'
=
Once more, l e t us a s s m e t h a t L and M are i d e a l s M(X,p) such t h a t Y i s the c a r r i e r o f both L and
i s t h e c a r r i e r o f both
Furthermore, l e t
--
i s t h e sequence space
L
Ln =
striction
, L (:):
such t h a t
obviously s a t i s f i e s t h i s c o n d i t i o n . A s an example, we
verging t o z e r o . Then
X
Y
M(Y,v)
satisfying the condition t h a t
mention t h e c a s e t h a t
and
is
L;
i s a l s o t h e c a r r i e r of
Y
i s an i d e a l i n
M :
operator which maps
T#
. Then
i n t o :L
into M
M (:):
= M.
such t h a t the re-
t o M i i s an absolute kerneZ T
i s an absolute kernel operator.
PROOF. Note t h a t , b e s i d e s l i n e a r i t y , w e have assumed n o t h i n g about t h e s t r e n g t h of t h e hypotheses i s a l l on Denoting t h e r e s t r i c t i o n of Theorem 97.2 t h a t into
(MZ):
. We
to
(TI)-
T'
:L )(:
. We apply Theorem 97.2 by
T"
,
s h a l l prove now t h a t t h e r e s t r i c t i o n of
exactly t h e given operator
T
. For
t h i s purpose, l e t
T"
f E L
to
T"f.gdp
=
( T # g ) ( f ) = g(Tf) =
T ; T'
(L;); L
and
be given. Then
f
to
i t f o l l o w s from
i s a n a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r which maps
T"
L';I
is g E M" n
= (T"f)(g) = ( T ' g ) ( f ) =
A
J
Tf.gdu
.
X For %ixed f E L
Mi
t h i s holds f o r a l l
i s t h e vhole s e t
X
,
g E Mi
it f o l l o w s t h a t
o p e r a t o r , so t h a t , d e n o t i n g t h e k e r n e l of
. Hence,
T"f = Tf T"
by
s i n c e t h e c a r r i e r of
. But
T(x,y)
T"
, we
is a kernel
have
.
ADJOINT OPERATORS
254
for a l l
. To
f E L
I
Ch. 13,8971
complete t h e proof, we s t i l l have t o show t h a t
lT(x,y)f(y)\dv(y) E M
f o r all
f E L
,
(MX):
=
Y
and t h a t i s where w e use t h e hypothesis t h a t
M
. Since
T"
i s an
a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r , we have
Y for a l l
f E (Li):
,
and hence c e r t a i n l y f o r a l l
f E L
.
Teh condition i n t h e l a s t theorem t h a t (Mw)- = M holds may seem somen n what a r t i f i c i a l . I n some important cases, however, the condition i s s a t i s -
M = L ( X , p ) f o r a value of
f i e d . For example, i f then
(MX):
that
T
= M
. If
P
p
such t h a t
i s order bounded, then t h e f i n a l conclusion t h a t
o p e r a t o r (from
L
1 5 p
2 m
,
t h e condition i s not s a t i s f i e d , but i n s t e a d i t i s given
into
T
i s a kernel
M ) i s s t i l l v a l i d . The proof i s t h e same u n t i l t h e
conclusion t h a t
Since
T"
i s an absolute k e r n e l o p e r a t o r , t h e operator
IT"I
has
a s kernel. Hence, t h e l e f t hand s i d e of (1) may be r e w r i t t e n a s
IT(x,y)l
IT"I ( f ) I ,
which i s equal t o
I f , in p a r t i c u l a r , we have a r e a l s o members of
L
0 s f E L
and s o
t h a t t h e element i n (2) i s now
, then
all
1T"gI = / T g /
ITI(f)
, which
g
satisfying
f o r these
lgl
2
f
g . I t follows
by our new hypothesis i s a
13,1973
Ch.
member of
and s o
KERNEL OPERATORS
M
. Hence,
I
we f i n d t h a t
returning t o ( I ) ,
IT(x,y)lf(y)dv(y) E M
255
0 S F E L ,
for a l l
i s an a b s o l u t e k e r n e l operator.
T
(Me)= M and t h e r e i s no e x t r a hypothesis, n n i t i s s t i l l of i n t e r e s t sometimes t o conclude a t l e a s t t h a t T , when
I f it i s not given t h a t
regarded a s an o p e r a t o r from
,
N N
into
L
(Mn>,
i s an a b s o l u t e k e r n e l ope-
rator. The extension of t h e r e s u l t s i n t h i s s e c t i o n t o t h e complex case i s not d i f f i c u l t . The only p o i n t which i s perhaps not immediately evident
i s where we have a Banach function space with norm
i s given, then
g E :L
that i f
I f g l dv:p I n t h i s case, it i s a p p r o p r i a t e t o define
z/[zl i f
sgn z =
,
f E L and
let
and we have t o prove
p
# 0 and
z
sgn z =
, since
p(fl) = p(f)
1
if
. It
IflI = ( f l
f o r any complex
sgn z
.
z = 0
for all
f l ( y ) = / f ( y ) I / s g n g(y)
(f)s1
y E Y
Given
by
z
g E Li
. Then
and
f l g = Ifgl
follows a s before t h a t hhe
e q u a l i t y i n (3) holds. EXERCISE 97.5.
As before, let L
(X,A,u)
and
M
be i d e a l s i n
r e s p e c t i v e l y . Furthermore, l e t
Y
be t h e c a r r i e r of both
M
and
X
let
be t h e c a r r i e r of both
L
(a) Prove t h a t dense i d e a l i n
L (:)
. Similarly
, we
fl n
maps
T' = 8
Mi
T'
denote by into
L';[
. Similarly,
into
Lx
, then
.
T4
t h e r e s t r i c t i o n of
. Prove
that
T = 0
S
show t h a t i f
into
S = 0
i f and only i f
TI'
( c ) Show t h a t i f
TI'
M
such t h a t
T,
A
so
M(X,p)
:L
and
L
i s an order
e
S' = 8
T2 = 8
T2
,
into
that
T'
. Derive a s a s p e c i a l
i s from L
T
.
and
. We r e c a l l
:M
( t h e n u l l o p e r a t o r ) i f and only i f
i f and only i f =
to
and
i s an order continuous o p e r a t o r from
case t h a t i f t h e order continuous o p e r a t o r T = 0
, and
M(Y,v)
L
i s an order continuous operator from L
T
(b) As b e f o r e , i f M
M
for
n
and
M(Y,v)
.
M"
i s order dense i n
be a - f i n i t e
(Y,.Z,v)
and
measure spaces and l e t
into
M
,
then
a r e order continuous o p e r a t o r s from then
Ti'
A
T" = 9.. 2
L
Ch. 1 3 ,5 9 7 1
ADJOINT OPERATORS
256
(d) Show t h a t i f
T, and T2 a r e order continuous o p e r a t o r s from L (T VT ) " = T','v T; . S i m i l a r l y f o r TI A T2 Show f i n a l l y 1 2 t h a t (T VT ) ' = T' V Ti S i m i l a r l y f o r TI A T2 1 2 1 For more general r e s u l t s we r e f e r t o s e c t i o n 115.
into
,
M
then
.
HINT: For ( c ) , n o t e t h a t
which implies t h a t
0 5 u E L (:): for
TY
A
(i=1,2)
T;
T','A TY coincides with
. Since
L
T" 2
,
and
T','
so
For ( d ) , w r i t e The l e f t hand s i d e i s
which i s equal t o
8
T3
=
-
(T'vT')
T1 v T2
. We have
1
2
T :
p a r t (b). Note a l s o t h a t
4 u
L
T'
>
3 -
-
T' v Ti 1
. Assume
,
L
. For
such t h a t a l l
t o prove t h a t
by p a r t ( c ) .
. Then
> 8
on
Tl A T2 = 8' 0 2 v
Ti on
T" a r e order continuous, the 2
For t h e l a s t p a r t , n o t e t h a t
T :
coincides with
t h e r e e x i s t s a d i r e c t e d system
are in
v
.
.
T;
same holds
-
(T"vT") = e 1
2
.
i n e q u a l i t y , so
(T~vT;)' > 0 by what was proved about (T'1vT')2' t T"I v T; . Hence
in
S
a contradiction.
EXERCISE 9 7 . 6 . With the hypotheses and n o t a t i o n s of t h e pPeceding L
e x e r c i s e , aSsume.in a d d i t i o n t h a t an a b s o l u t e k e r n e l operator from p
:):L(
,
t h e a s s o c i a t e norm i n :L by
p"
, we
have
M
by
p'
p"(f) 5 p ( f )
cases e q u a l i t y holds f o r a l l
as well as f o r
L
. Prove
o p e r a t o r norms s a t i s f y i n g
f f L
now t h a t
and
M
into
M
a r e Banach l a t t i c e s and
. Denoting
t h a norm in
T is
L
by
and t h e second a s s o c i a t e norm i n for a l l
f f L
. Assume t h a t
, but
i n some important
t h i s case occurs f o r
T,T' and T" a r e continuous with IITil = IIT'Il = IIT"II
.
L
Ch. 13,8981
25 7
KERNEL OPERATORS
98. Dunford's theorem
I t was mentioned i n s e c t i o n 95 t h a t the o r i g i n a l method of proving Buhvalov's theorem is based on a theorem of N. Dunford (1936), s t a t i n g t h a t any continuous o p e r a t o r from an L1-space i n t o an L -space, f o r 1 < p 5 P i s an a b s o l u t e k e r n e l operator. More p r e c i s e l y , t h e proof of Buhvalov's
m
,
theorem w a s based on t h e g e n e r a l i z a t i o n of Dunford's theorem t o a r b i t r a r y (not n e c e s s a r i l y separable) measure spaces. We s h a l l prove now t h a t i f one follows t h e method presented h e r e , Dunford's theorem may be derived from Buhvalov's theorem. F i r s t we prove a dual theorem. It i s assumed again t h a t (X,A,p)
and
a r e a - f i n i t e measure spaces.
(Y,Z,w)
LEMMA 98.1. Let L be an ideal i n M(Y,v) equipped with a a-order continuous Riesz norm ( i . e . , u J 0 i n L implies p(un) + 0 1 . Then it n * f o Z l o ~ sfrom 0 5 u 5 u E L and un + 0 t h a t p(un) -+ 0 as n + m n
PROOF. I f
p(un)
and a subsequence
does not tend t o zero, t h e r e e x i s t a number
(u
?(
:k=1,2,
.
...)
of
(un:n=1,2,
...)
E
> 0
such t h a t
The subsequence contains another subsequence converp(un ) 2 E f o r a l l k k ging t o zero almost everywhere on Y The l a s t subsequence i s , t h e r e f o r e , order convergent t o zero i n
.
L
. Hence,
by t h e a-order
c o n t i n u i t y of
t h e subsequence converges t o zero i n norm, c o n t r a d i c t i n g all
. Hence,
k
p(un)
p(u
tends t o zero.
) 2
?(
E
p
,
for
L
THEOREM 98.2. I f
i s an ideal i n M(Y,v) equipped with a a-order continuous Riesz norm, then every norm continuous operator from L i n t o i s an absolute kernel operator. I n partieuZar, i f 1 5 p < then every continuous operator from L (Y,v) i n t o L_(x,u) i s an
L,(X,v)
&soZute
PROOF. We s h a l l denote the norm i n
L
For
f
E L w e have
almost every (Tv:OSvSu)
ness
Of
into
L-(X,U)
. We
L
by
,
so
x E X. It follows t h a t f o r each
L,(X,u)
¶
t h e function
p
. Let
prove f i r s t t h a t
IITf\lm 5 I [ T / l . p ( f )
i s bounded above i n
,
P
kerne Z operator.
operator from
m
L_(X,u)
T T
be a continuous
i s order bounded.
[ ( T f ) ( x ) l 5 llT[l.d(f)
u 2 0
. Hence,
in L
for
the set
by t h e Dedekind Complete-
258
Ch. 13,1981
DUNFORD'S THEOREM
f o r every
e x i s t s i n L,(X,u) prove t h a t
u
E L+
. As
i n Theorem 83.3, we can e a s i l y
i s an a d d i t i v e mapping from
T
into
L+
(by Lemma 83.1) can be extended t o a p o s i t i v e operator
. It
L,(X,p)
follows t h a t
T = TI
-
(TI-T)
a d i f f e r e n c e of p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r s , s o and TI we have
, which
(L-(X,u))+ from
T,
into
L
i s a decomposition of
as
T
i s order bounded. The o p e r a t o r s
T
T -T a r e norm continuous, s i n c e i t i s easy t o s e e t h a t f o r u E L+ 1 1 (Tv)(x) I S \IT11 . p ( u ) f o r a l l v s a t i s f y i n g 0 2 v I u , s o
It i s s u f f i c i e n t , t h e r e f o r e , to prove t h a t every p o s i t i v e continuous opera-
t o r from
L
into
L_(X,p)
i s a k e r n e l operator. Hence, l e t
0 2 un I u E L
and continuous. I f
and
un
*
+
,
0
then
be p o s i t i v e
T
p(un)
+
0
by t h e
l a s t lemma, s o i t follows from
X
almost everywhere on
that
by Buhvalov's theorem, T
(Tun)(x)
+
0
x E X
f o r almost
. Hence,
i s a k e r n e l operator.
By combining the l a s t theorem with Theorem 9 7 . 4 , we s h a l l now derive a theorem (dual t o the l a s t theorem) which includes Dunford's theorem as a s p e c i a l case. THEOREM 9 8 . 3 . Let
c a r r i e r o f both M
M
and
be an i d e a l i n M ( X , u )
M
MX
and such t h a t
(Mi):
such t h a t =
M
be a Banach l a t t i c e w i t h respect t o t h e Riesz nom
a s s o d a t e norm p*
from
LI(Y,v)
let
such t h a t the
p
( i . e . , the r e s t K c t i o n t o MX o f the adjoint norm
p'
i n fl = M"
is the
X
. Furthermore,
is a-order continuous. Then every norm continuous operator into M
is an absolute kernel operator.
PROOF. Note f i r s t t h a t
M*
=
M"
since
M
makes sense t o say t h a t t h e a s s o c i a t e norm
p'
of t h e a d j o i n t norm
T
.
p*
in
fl
=
M"
. Let
i s a Banach l a t t i c e , s o i t
i s t h e r e s t r i c t i o n t o :M
be a continuous operator from
L (Y,v) i n t o M The Banach a d j o i n t o p e r a t o r T* i s a continuous o p e r a t o r 1 is a from M* i n t o L_(P,v) , s o the r e s t r i c t i o n T ' of T* t o :M
continuous o p e r a t o r from :M
into
.
L _ ( Y , ~ ) The norm
p'
in
o-order continuous by hypothesis, s o by the preceding theorem
M : T'
is i s an
Ch. 13,5981
KERNEL OPERATORS
259
a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r . But t h e n , by Theorem 97.4, T
i t s e l f i s an
absolute kernel operator. COROLLARY 98.4.
Ll(Y,v)
operator from
M = L (X,u) P mentioned i n t h e l a s t theorem.
r a t e d by
. For t h e s p e c i a l . Furthermore, as
t
M(Y,v) L
in
M(X,u)
0 2 t ( x ) E M(X,u)
EXERCISE 98.4. Let
M
every continuous
m
case t h a t
s a t i s f i e s a l l conditions
M
and l e t
be t h e i d e a l gene-
i s i d e n t i c a l l y one, w e g e t
t
i n Theorem 98.2,
equipped w i t h a u-continuous norm
into
5
L ( x , ~ ) is an absoZute kerneZ operator. P
into
PROOF. The i d e a l
M = L_(X,u)
1 < p
(Dunford's theorem.) For
p
let
. Let
L
be an i d e a l i n
T
b e an o p e r a t o r from
such t h a t
almost everywhere on
f o r every
X
. Show
f EL
that
i s a kernel
T
operator. H I N T : The proof i s s i m i l a r t o t h e proof i n Theorem 98.2.
98.2 t h e f u n c t i o n
i s equal t o t h e c o n s t a n t
t(x)
EXERCISE 98.5. Let in
M(X,u)
every
be an i d e a l i n
M(Y,v)
f E L
,
then
T
(i.e.,
t
into
M
$O(f) =
$o
JY f t d v
b e an i d e a l
L = Ll(Y,vI)
v1
f o r t h e measure
v-measurable
subsets T
E
f E L ). Let
Y
0
of
Y
, defined
. The
by
S
n $,(If\)
for
Ll-norm of
is a kernel operator, i . e . ,
Yo = ( y : t ( y ) > O ) .
= Y (because, o t h e r w i s e ,
T ). Note now t h a t
vl(E) =
i s a norm continuous o p e r a t o r from
by Theorem 98.3, T
O p(Tf)
the
. Show
E L"
i s r e p r e s e n t e d by a non-negative f o r every
i s of no i n t e r e s t f o r t h e o p e r a t o r
Y-Yo
0 5 $
such t h a t
Without l o s s of g e n e r a l i t y we may assume t h a t
hypothesis
M
is a kernel operator.
HINT: The l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l
the s e t
and l e t
included. Furthermore, l e t
p
is an o p e r a t o r from L
T
function
.
llTll
s a t i s f y i n g a l l t h e c o n d i t i o n s mentioned i n Theorem 98.3,
c o n d i t i o n s on t h e norm that i f
L
I n Theorem
f E L
1,
is
Ll(Y,vl)
tdv
for a l l
$,(If
1)
into
. By M . Hence,
260
s
DUNFORD'
f o r every
f
E L
. In
Ch. 13,1981
THEOREM
t h e l a s t formula we have used t h a t t h e o-algebra of
a l l v -measurable s e t s and t h e o-algebra of a l l v-measurable 1
identical (i.e., measure
sets are
i f we apply t h e Carathgodory extension procedure t o t h e
on t h e o-algebra of a l l v-measurable s e t s , then we do not get
v1
any more vl-measurable s e t s than we had a l r e a d y ) . EXERCISE 98.6.
Let
X = Y
be t h e s e t of a l l i n t e g e r s , equipped with
the counting measure, i - e . , u(m) = v(m) = 1 = M(Y,v)
M(X,u)
sequences
y = (...,n - l , n o , r t l , n 2 X x Y be defined by
T(m,n)
on
f o r every p o i n t
i s , t h e r e f o r e , t h e space
The space
,...)
m
of
X
=
Y.
of a l l
(s)
of r e a l numbers. Let the f u n c t i o n
-1 T(m,n) = n (m+n+i)-l We take
T(m,n)
t o be the k e r n e l of a k e r n e l operator
( a ) Show t h a t I
Cln- 1
nnl
<
, where
m
i s a member of
y E (s)
the symbol
domy(T)
T
.
i f and only i f n = 0
denotes t h a t t h e term with
'C
omitted i n t h e summation. (b) Show t h a t f o r any included i n that
domy(T)
m
Cn,,Innlp
<
m
p
. Note .
satisfying
Lp
that
1
5
p <
m
the space
i s t h e space of a l l
Lp
y E (s)
is such
(c) Shuw t h a t
(d) Show t h a t
T , a s an o p e r a t o r from
L2 i n t o
e2 , i s
a unitary
operator (and t h e r e f o r e a norm continuous o p e r a t o r ) . The o p e r a t o r one of t h e v a r i a n t s of t h e HiZbert transform. HINT:
(b) Use Hglder's i n e q u a l i t y .
(c) zn(m+n+i)-2 = zn(n+:)-2
8 E;(2n+l)-* For
ml f m2
,
set
zn (m
=
T
2
.
a = m2-ml
+n+4
= 4 zn(2n+1)-2 =
. Then
(m2+n+1 )-I
= zn(n+4)-l
(a+n+l)-l =
T
is
is
(d) It follows from part (c) that
L2 consisting
subspace of
y E
of all
preserves inner products on the
T
L2
coordinates. By continuity this restricted tor
e2
on
Tex
nm
Zn T(m,n)S,
=
. This .
,
for all m
in (c) it follows now that
L2
with only finitely many nonzero T
T2
=
so
) = t = T
(77
Tex = T
, where
I
implies that the range of
T
[,,
can be extended to an opera-
such that Tex prserves inner products in
more by continuity it follows that if then
26 I
KERNEL OPERATORS
Ch. 13,598:
x ex
for x
=
and once
(5 ) E
e2
. By means of the formulas
,
I is the identity operator in
is the whole of
L2
. Hence, T
is
unitary
EXERCISE 98.7. Under the same hypotheses as in the preceding exercise, let x
=
(5
) E
En “n
Let
e2
=
and y
(n,)
E L2 be defined by
I
(n’log n>-’ for n
= (~n~’log~n~)for l
=
(a) Show that for x T
and y
does not exist. Hence,
2,3,.
..
and
n = -2,-3,...
/TI be the operator with kernel
(ITly,x) if
=
IT(m,n)l
S n = O forall other n
and
“n
,
= O for all othern.
.
as defined above the inner product
IT1
is regarded as an operator from
does not map
L2
1, into L2 , and
into itself, then T
so
is not
order bounded. This shows that although every order bounded operator from one Banach lattice into another is continuous, the converse is not generally true. It is only under special circumstances, as in Theorems 98.2 and 98.3 in this section, that a continuous operator from one Banach lattice into another is order bounded. HINT: If equal to
(ITly,x) would exist, then
77
times
(IT/y,x) would be
262
GENERALIZED CARLEMAN OPERATORS
against the assumption that
(ITly,x)
Ch. 13,9993
is finite.
99. Generalized Carleman operators If
(X,A,p)
and
(Y,Z,v)
T
T is a
are a-finite measure spaces and
kernel operator with kernel T(x,y)
mapping
L2(Y,v)
into L2(X,p)
,
then
is called a Carlernan operator if the function
Y is finite for almost every function t
,
x E X
,
t E M(X,u)
if
is u-measuable, even in the case that
positive measure. As well-known, T if
i.e
=
that the
on a set of
m
is called a HiZbert-Schmidt operator
is (uxv)-sumable over X
IT(x,y)l‘
t(x)
. Note
X
Y
, i.e.,
if the function t
(as defined above) is p-sumable. Carleman operators were introduced by T. Carleman ([l],l923).
There exist kernel operators, mapping
L (Y,v) into 2 L2(X,~) , even absolute kernel operators, that are not Carleman, and there exist Carleman operators that are not Hilbert-Schmidt (for exampleswerefer to Exercise 99.10).
T
, mapping
L (Y,v) 2
It was proved by J. Weidman ([11,1970) into L2(X,u)
,
that an operator
is a Carleman kernel operator if and
only if it maps every norm null sequence onto an almost everywhere null sequence (i.e., IIfn(12 + 0 in L (Y,v) 2
every
implies
(Tfn)(x)
+
0 for almost
x E X ) . It is of interest to compare this with the condition for T
to be a kernel operator (not necessarily Carleman), where it is required that every dominated norm null sequence in L (Y,v) 2
is mapped onto an al-
most everywhere null sequence (cf. Exercise 96.13). We shall now investigate a more general situation. Once more, let let
(X,A,u)
L be an ideal in M ( Y , v )
and
(Y,X,v)
, equipped
be u-finite measure spaces and with a Riesz norm
p
.
Ch. 13,5991
KERNEL OPERATORS
THEOREM 99.1. Let
T
263 L
be an operator t h a t maps
.
i n t o M(X,u)
The
fofollyowing conditions are now equivalent. (i)
There e x i s t s a non-negative f u n c t i o n
.
t
E M(X,u)
such t h a t every
s a t i s f i e s 1 (Tf) (x) I 5 p ( f ) t (x) almost everywhere on X ( t h e exceptional s e t depending on f 1 . ( i i ) I f f E L f o r n = 1,2, and p ( f n ) 0 , then ( T f n ) ( x ) f E L
n
almost everywhere on X
...
.
If ( i ) and ( i i ) hoZd f o r
T
, then
-f
i s order bounded. A s a consequence,
T
IT/ s a t i s f i e s ( i ) and ( i i ) j u s t as well as
continuous and ( i ) and ( i i ) hold f o r
T
T
, then
. If T
the norm i n L
is order
i s a kerne2 operator (and
i s a kernel operator s a t i s f y i n g ( i ) and ( i i ) ) .
IT1
hence
+ 0
PROOF. It i s e v i d e n t t h a t ( i ) i m p l i e s ( i i ) . For t h e converse, assuming t h a t ( i i ) h o l d s , we have t o prove t h a t set in if
. According
M(X,u)
(un:n=1,2, ...)
and
(hn:n=1,2,
(An Tu,)(x)
...)
i n d i c a t e d . Then
(An Tun)(x)
+
that if
u
.
= Anp(un)
S
f o r almost every
x
T
0 < v S u
x E X
(/Tvl:0SvSu:1
p(un) 5 1
x E X
+
An
,
0
. This
for a l l
n
An C 0 , t h e n
. Hence,
let
un
and
An
as
so by ( i i ) we have
shows t h a t ( i i ) i m p l i e s ( i ) .
i s o r d e r b o m d e d i f ( i ) and ( i i ) h o l d , we have t o prove
i s g i v e n , then
E L+
Hence, l e t
f o r almost every that
such t h a t
L
i s a sequence of numbers such t h a t
p(Anun)
0
To show t h a t M(X,u)
i s a sequence i n
h o l d s f o r almost every
0
-+
i s an o r d e r bounded
S = (Tu:p(u)
t o Theorem 96.7 i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t
,
so
(ITvl:OSv
i s an o r d e r bounded s e t i n
. Then
L
lTvl S p ( u ) . t
holds i n
M(X,u)
i s ccmtained i n t h e o r d e r i n t e r v a l
. This shows . Note
CO,p(u).tl
now t h a t
SO
c o n d i t i o n ( i ) h o l d s f o r IT1
.
Assume, f i n a l l y , t h a t t h e norm
first that if
0 S u
< uo E L -
and
in
p
un
*
+
L
,
0
i s o r d e r continuous. We prove then
p(un)
n may assume (by p a s s i n g t o a subsequence i f n e c e s s a r y ) t h a t some
E >
0
and a l l
n
. I n view
of
u
*
n
+
0
+
0
. If
n o t , we
P(U) 2 E
for
t h e r e e x i s t s a subsequence
264
u
Ch. 1 3 , 1 9 9 1
GENERALZZED CARLEMAN OPERATORS
.
(k=1,2,. . )
nk
. By
y E Y
converging to zero for almost every
Theorem
u converges to zero in order in the space M(Y,v) , "k i.e., there exists a sequence (h :k=l,2,. . . ) in M(Y,v) such that k u 5 hk i 0 in M(Y,v) Then 0 5 gk = inf(h , u ) E L and u 5 gk i 0 k O "k .nk in In other words, u converges to zero in order in L Since p is
7 1 . 3 this means that
.
.
.
-
nL
order continuous, this impTies p(un ) + 0 as k + , which contradicts k p ( u n ) 2 E for all k . Assume now that conditions (i) and (ii) hold for k T. Let 0 5 u I uo E L and u -+ 0 Then p(un) + 0 by what was proved n a moment ago, and hence (Tun)(x) -t 0 almost everywhere on X by condition
*
.
T satisfies Buhvalov's condition,
(ii). This shows that
T
so
is a kernel
operator. A s observed above, /TI satisfies conditions (i) and (ii) just as well as
in condition (i)).
T (and with the same function t
/TI is also a kernel operator. We recall that if
that T(x,y)
,
then
IT1
has the kernel
We shall prove now that if the norm
T has the kernel
.
IT(x,y)l
in L
p
It follows
is order continuous and
the equivalent conditions (i) and (ii) in the last theorem hold for T then T
is not only a kernel operator, but in this case T
,
is a kernel
operator of a special type. For this purpose we recall that if we define, Y , the finite or infinite number
on
for any v-measurable real function g ~ ' ( g ) by
p'(g)
= SUP(
1
1
lfgldv:p(f)
Y then the space L' ate space of te norm of T(x,y)
on
L p
y
satisfying p'(g) to
p'
<
L'
-
is called the associis called the associa-
(cf. section 97). If the real (uxv)-measurable function
X x Y
(we write Tx(y)
tion of
g
and the restriction of
for u-almost every x
of all
,
is given, then x
,
so
T(x,y)
p'(Tx(y))
to indicated that
for some fixed
is a v-measurable function of
y
is well defined for these values of T(x,y)
is regarded here as a func-
x ) . Let u s denote p'(Tx(y))
by
, as
x
question arises whether the function t
a function of
u-measurable. An affirmative answer (for any Riesz norm
p
t(x) on
, not
X
. The ,
is
necessarily
order continuous) is contained in a paper by W.A.J. Luxemburg ([2],1958). Luxemburg's result was generalized by Ya.1. Gribanov (Cl],1970). This more general result will enable u s to prove now that if then conditions (i) and (ii) hold for of
T has the property that
t(x)
=
T
p
is order continuous,
if and only if the kernel T(x,y)
p'(Tx(y))
is finite for almost every
Ch. 13,5991
x
. In other words, taking into account
that
find that (i) and (ii) hold if and only if that
L
=
265
KERNEL OPERATORS
L (Y,v)
and
2
is p-measurable, we shall
t t
E M(X,p)
.
In the special case
is the corresponding L -norm we have
p
2
This shows that conditions (i) and (ii) hold if and only if
T
L' = L
is a Carle-
man kernel operator. We present the proofs, first of all the proof of the Luxemburg-Gribanov result.
(Luxemburg-Gribanov.) Let
THEOREM 99.2.
be o-finite measure spaces, l e t function on
x
x Y
functions on Y
and l e t
. Then,
S
T(x,y)
(Y,C,v)
(X,h,p) and
be a non-negative (pxv)-measurable
be a s e t of non-negative v-measurable
for u-ahost e v e q
x E X
, the f i n i t e or i n f i n i t e
non-negative number d(x)
= sup(
T(x,y)v(y)dv(y):vES Y
i s well defined. Furthermore, there e x i s t s a sequence
(vk:k=l,2,
...)
in
such that d(x)
=
(I
sup
holds for p-almost a l l
Y
x E X
x
p-measurable function on PROOF. Since T(x,y) of
X
T(xO,y) x E Xo
T(x,y)vk(y)dv(y):k=1,2
satisfying p(X-X
0
.
,...
simultaneously. I t foZZows that
is a
is (uxv)-measurable, there exists a subset xO ) = 0 such that for every xo E Xo the function
is non-negative and v-measurable on Y and every v E S
the integral of
. It follows that
T(x,y)v(y)
over
defined, and so 0 5 d(x)
d(x)
= SUP(
T(x,y)v(y)dv(y):vES)
5
-
Y
for every i s well
S
266
Ch. 13,1991
GENERALIZED CARLEMAN OPERATORS
for every x E X
0 '
(i) Let now X n = l,Z,.
n
+
For each x E Xo
n
dn(x)
5
dn+,(x)
. Furthermore
,
Y
for all
Tn(x,y)vn(y)
.
n
4
u(Yn)
and
,
On the other hand
lim dn(x) n
-.
limn + w dn (x)
so
as
T(x,y)v(y)
n
-f
Taking the supremum over all v E S on the left, we get =
over Y
Tn(x,y)vn(y)
exists for each Hence, for any
Y
Y
d(x)
non-
and each x E Xo , let
,
x E Xo,and any v E S
finite for
let
the integral of
so
1,2,..
=
u(Xn)
,
, as a function of y , is
the function Tn(x,y)
is well defined. For each n
Note that
Y with
and each v E S
n
negative and v-measurable on
x E Xo
+
X and Y
.. . For each
dn(x)
5
d(x)
for all n
for all x E Xo
prove that for each n
=
1,2,
...
,
so
d(x)
lim d (x) n n
5
S
limn dn(x)
d(x)
. It follows immediately that
. Hence
if we can
there exists a countable subset
sn
of
s
such that
for p-almost all x E X
p-almost everywhere on
simultaneously, then
X , which will then prove the theorem. For the re-
maining part of the proof we may restrict ourselves, therefore, to the case X and Y
that in
S
are of finite measure, T(x,y)
is bounded and the functions
are uniformly bounded. (ii) We assume now that
u(X)
and
u(Y)
.
are finite and there exists
Ch. 13,5991
0
a constant a > 0 such that x,y
267
KERNEL OPERATORS
and all v E S
. Let first
5
T(x,y)
and
5 CY
0
v(y)
5
for all
5 CY
be a step function on
T(x,y)
X X Y
of
the form
non-negative, all A. p-measurable subsets of X i B; v-measurable subsets of Y Then T(x,y) can be written as P with X I , X disjoint u-measurable subsets T(x,Y) = CiE1 xX2(x)gi(Y) I of X and all g. non-negative v-measurable functions. It is easy to see
with all coefficients c and all
...,
.
that in this case the corresponding function d(x) X
possessing the desired properties (note that
is a step function on is constant on each
d(x)
xi 1. (iii) We assume again that u(X) and
0
5
v(y)
.
for all v E S
a
5
v(Y)
and
are finite, 0
Then T(x,y) E LI(XxY,pxv) ,
so
...
; n = 1,2,
well-known result there exists a sequence Tn(x,y)
T(x,y) < a
5
by a
, each
Tn a step function as in part (ii), such that
XXY
I
I
T(x,y)-Tn(x,y)
d(uxv)
.
0
+
+ 0 By passing to a subsequence it may be assumed that /T(x,y)-Tn(x,y)l holds (uXv)-almost everywhere on X x Y It is also evident that we may
.
assume that
0
5
T (x,y) n
IT(x,Y)-T~(x,~)~ 5
CY
almost everywhere on p(X-X ) 1
=
on
on
a
5
x
X x Y
x Y
,
f o r all
X x Y f o r all
n
n
, and
. Since IT-T,~
so
there exists a subset X I of
0 such that, for every x E X I a 2 IT(x,y)-Tn(x,y)1
-+
o
+
X
pointwise satisfying
, we have
0 v-almost everywhere on
Y
.
Hence, by the dominated convergence theorem,
/
IT(x,y)-Tn(x,y)ldv(y)
+
0
Y for all x E XI
.
Since 0
for x E XI fixed,
5
v(y) s a
for all v E S
,
it follows that,
268
Ch. 13,§991
GENERALIZED CARLEMAN OPERATORS
uniformly with respect to v E S
.
In other words, introducing the uniform
norm in the space of all real bounded functions on
S , we have
[lt-tn/l+O.
Still keeping x E X 1 fixed, we have
d(x) = sup(t(v):vES)
=
#It11
.
It follows from Illtll-llt / I I 5 llt-tnll + 0 that IltnII +IItI/ , i.e., n dn(x) -+ d(x) Since this holds for each x E X I and since all dn are
.
p-measurable on
X by part (ii), we see already that the function d
p-measurable on X S
. For each
n there exists a countable subset
of
such that Tn(x,y)v(y)dv(y):vES
nJ
Y
almost everywhere on X
almost everywhere on
. Hence, writing
X
for all
n
m
S = U 0
S 1 n
,
we have
simultaneously. Arguing now with the
uniform norm in the space of all real bounded functions on on
sn
is
S
, we
get exactly as above that
Y =
limn{sup(
I
lltll = limlltnll
,
So
instead of
i.e.,
Tn(x,y)v(y)dv(y):vES
Y
holds p-almost everywhere on X
. But
lim d (x) = d(x) n n
,
SO
T(x,y)v(y)dv(y):v€So
Y This is the desired result. Luxemburg's original result is contained in the following corollary.
Ch. 13,5991
KERNEL OPERATORS
COROLLARY 99.3. Let
L be an i d e a l i n
equipped w i t h a Riesz norm
=
M(Y,v) such t h a t
. Furthermore, Zet T(x,y) x Y . Then t h e pointwise
p
(uxv)-measurable f u n c t i o n on X t(x)
269
P'(T~(Y)) =
I
SUP(
is
L
be a r e a l supremm
1 T(x,y)f (y) 1 dv (y) :P (f)< 1
Y
i s u-measurable and there e x i s t s a sequence that
p(fn)
5 1
for a l l
t(x)
=
(fn:n=1,2, ...) i n
such
L
and
n
P'(Tx(y))
1
sup(
=
1 d v ( y ) :n=l,Z,. ..
1 T(x,y)fn(y)
Y
holds f o r u-almost a l l
x E X
simultaneously.
We return to the properties (i) and (ii) in Theorem 99.1. THEOREM 99.4. Let
Riesz norm
L
and l e t
p
be an i d e a l i n M(Y,v)
T be an operator mapping
w i t h order continuous
.
i n t o M(X,p)
L
The
following conditions are now equivalent. (i) There e x i s t s a non-negative f u n c t i o n
I (Tf) (x) I
satisfies
f E L
(ii) If
f
n
E L
for
almost everywhere on X
.
5 p(f).
n
=
l,2,
and
p(fn)
(iii) T i s a kernel operator w i t h kernel P'(Tx(y))
E M(X,u)
such t h a t every
almost everywhere on X
t (x)
...
t E M(X,p)
.
+
0 ,
T(x,y)
then
.
(Tfn)(x)
satisfying
PROOF. If the equivalent conditions (i) and (ii) hold, then T kernel operator by Theorem 99.1. Let observed in Theorem 99.1, IT1
. By
is a
. As
T
. Note
that the kernel of
IT1
is
the Luxemburg-Gribanov theorem there exists a sequence
(fn:n=1,2, ...)
in L
such that
for u-almost every x
. For each
(i) that
T
is also a kernel operator satisfying the
Same conditions (i) and (ii) as
1 T(x,y)l
be the kernel of
T(x,y)
+
p(fn)
5 1
n = l,2,
for all n
...
and
, we derive from condition
0
270
GENERALIZED CARLEMAN OPERATORS
Iiolds f o r p-almost
every
Hence, t a k i n g f o r
Xo
x
,
Ch. 13,1991
t h e e x c e p t i o n a l pi-null s e t depending upon
t h e union of t h i s countable number of e x c e p t i o n a l
s e t s , we f i n d t h a t t h e formulas i n t h e l a s t l i n e s h o l d f o r a l l neously o u t s i d e t h e u-null s e t we g e t
p'(Tx(y)) 5 t ( x )
Conversely, i f
T
Xo
. Taking
f o r almost every
n
fn
simulta-
t h e supremum w i t h r e s p e c t t o n ,
, so
x
E M(X,p) . E L b e given.
p'(Tx(y))
s a t i s f i e s condition ( i i i ) , l e t
f
Then
COROLLARY 99.5.
If t h e equivaLent conditions ( i ) , ( i i ) , ( i i i ) hold f o r T , we s h a l l c a l l any 0 5 t E M(X,p) such t h a t , f o r e v e r y f E L , t h e i n e q u a l i t y I (Tf) (x) 1 L p ( f ) . t ( x ) holds almost everywhere on X , a majorizing function. Then p'(Tx(y)) = i n f ( t : t is majorizing)
.
PROOF. It was shown i n t h e proof of t h e l a s t theorem t h a t 5
t(x)
almost everywhere on
X
f o r any m a j o r i z i n g
a s e v i d e n t from t h e l a s t l i n e of t h e p r o o f ,
p'(T
t
(y))
. On
p'(T (y)) 5
t h e o t h e r hand,
is itself a
ma j o r i z i n g f u n c t i o n . I f i n t h e l a s t theorem p'
is also the
1
L,-norm. L
IT(x,y)l
2
L
is the mace
L2(Y,v) w i t h L2-norm p
,
then
Condition ( i i i ) e x p r e s s e s now t h e f a c t t h a t dv(y)
Y
i s f i n i t e f o r almost every
x
. i.e.,
T
i s now a Carlernan o p e r a t o r . A s ob-
s e r v e d a l r e a d y , i t w a s proved by J. Weidman (C11,1970) t h a t i n t h i s c a s e
KERNEL OPERATORS
Ch. 13,9991
27 1
condition (ii) is necessary and sufficient for T
It was proved by V.B. Korotkov ([11,1965)
to be a Carleman operator.
that condition (i) is necessary
and sufficient to be a Carleman operator. The present generalization in Theorem 99.4 and also the theorems which will be proved next are due to A.R. Schep (C21,1979).
We shall call any operator satisfying the conditions
in Theorem 99.4 a generalized Carleman operator. The following theorem is an immediate corollary of what was proved above. L
Let
THEOREM 99.6.
be an ideal i n M(Y,v)
with order continuous
.
Riesz norm P and l e t M be an ideal i n M ( X , u ) with Riesz norm h Furthermore, l e t T be an operator mapping L i n t o M The following
.
conditions are now equivaZent. (i) There e x i s t s a non-negative function
t
E M such that every
.
satisfies 1 (Tf) (x) 1 5 ~(f).t(x) almost everywhere on X is a kernel operator with kernel T(x,y) s a t i s f y i n g
f E L
-.
(ti) T p'(Tx(y))
EM
PROOF.
, so
(i)
X{P'(T~(Y))I
<
* (ii). According to Theorem
with kernel T(x,y)
, mapping
99.4 T
into M ( X , v )
L
is a kernel operator
and such that p'(Tx(y))
is a majorizing function. Since by hypothesis there exists a majorizing function t
such that
t
E M and since p'(T
X
(y))
is the minimal
majorizing function by the last corollary, it follows that (ii)
(i). If (ii) holds, then
everywhere on
X
E
By hypothesis p'(Tx(y)) function belonging to M Any operator
f E L
for any
T
.
M
,
so
. Hence
I (Tf)(x)] p'(T
2
(y))
p'(Tx(y))
p(f).p'(Tx(y))
E M
.
almost
is a majorizing function.
t(x) = p'(Tx(y))
is a majorizing
satisfying condition (ii) in the last theorem is
sometimes called an operator of f i n i t e doubZe norm. Let us take a brief look at the case that
M
=
Lq(X,u)
L = L (Y,v) P
for some q
order continuoas for
I 5 p <
M = L
P'
for some p
-.
satisfying
1 5 p <
satisfying
1 5 q <
m
. Note
m
and
that the L -norm is
P
from L = L into P , where II IIT ( Y ) I / ~ , / I ~ <
The operator T
is now of finite double norm whenever q -1 is the conjugate exponent of p , i.e., p +(p')''
= 1
. These operators
Our last theorem states are known as Hille-Tamarkin operators ([1],1934). that T is a Hille-Tamarkin operator if and o n l y if there exists a nonnegative function g E L ( X , v ) q
such that for any
f E L
P
the ineqUalitY
272
GENERALIZED CARLEMAN OPERATORS
I ( T f ) ( x ) l s Ilf 1 ) . g ( x )
h o l d s almost everywhere on
P
We r e t u r n t o Carleman o p e r a t o r s , i . e . , L2(Y,v)
into
,
M(X,u)
I
/T(x,y)l
.
X
kernel operators
such t h a t t h e k e r n e l
2
Ch. 13,5991
T(x,y)
T
, mapping
satisfies
.
dv(y) E M(X,u)
Y
every
(i)
T
(ii)
There e x i s t s a non-negative f u n c t i o n
x (iv)
,...,e
.
If
n
.
i n t o M(X,u)
i s a Carleman operator.
( i i i ) If
e
L2(Y,v)
conditions are now equivalent.
f E L2(Y,v)
any
be an operator mapping
T
THEOREM 99.7. Let
The following
, the
IlfnlI2
I(Tf)(x)/ 5 Ilf/I2.g(x)
inequality +
0
g E M(X,v)
, then
(Tfn)(x)
(ea:aEIa)) is an orthonorma2 system i n i s a f i n i t e subset of t h e system and
then the s e t
of a l l
S
t h i s case, t h e s e t
S
i n t e g r a t i o n i s over
Y
hoZds f o r almost
almost everywhere on
0
-f
such t h a t , f o r
L2(Y,v)
,i
.
X
f
.
s ( a l , ...,a ) i s order bounded i n M ( X , y ) In n 2 i s bounded above by IT(x,y)I du(y) , where t h e
I
.
PROOF. I t f o l l o w s from Theorem 99.4 t h a t t h e c o n d i t i o n s ( i ) , ( i i ) and ( i i i ) a r e e q u i v a l e n t . The proof t h a t (i) i m p l i e s ( i v ) f o l l o w s by observing t h a t , by B e s s e l ' s i n e q u a l i t y , s(a
5
,,...,an ) ( X I
1
=
11
:Z
2 T(x,y)ea.(y)dv(y)/ 1
Y
/T(x,y)I
2
dv(y)
.
Y
This shows a t t h e same time t h a t i n t h i s c a s e t h e s e t by
I IT(x,y)l
2
dv(y)
.
S
i s bounded above
For t h e converse, assume t h a t ( i v ) h o l d s . We s h a l l prove t h a t t h i s i m p l i e s ( i i i ) . Hence, l e t
f n E L2(Y,v)
There e x i s t s an orthonormal system
for
(el,e2,
n = 1,2,
...)
in
...
with
L (Y,u) 2
Ilfn112
such t h a t
-t
0.
Ch. 13,9991
KERNEL OPERATORS
...
every finite linear combination of
(fl,f2, ) is a finite linear combinaand conversely (Gram-Schmidt). Let S be the set in
... )
tion of
(el,e2,
M(X,y)
273
corresponding to this orthonormal system according to our hypothesis
about condition (iv) and let
be an upper bound of
g2 E M(X,v)
function fn is afinite sum Cc.e.
, so
Tfn = Cc.Tei
, and
. The
S
by Schwarz's in-
equality we have
for almost every
.
x
Evidently we may assume now that
IJf I] .g(x) holds almost everywhere on X n 2 Since \lfn112 -t 0 , it follows that (Tfn)(x) 5
f o r all +
n
5 l(Tfn)(x)l simultaneously.
0 for almost every x ,
so
(iii) holds. THEOREM 99.8. Let
and l e t 2et
T be a Carleman operator a s in the l a s t theorem
be an orthonormal b a s i s i n
(ea:a€{a))
be onee more the s e t of a l l
S
(i)
sup S =
1,
2
IT(x,y)l
dv(y)
s(a1,
.
...,an ) . Then the following
holds.
... , f o r
a E {a} , say
(ii) There are a t most eountabZy many
which
. Furthermore,
L2(Y,v)
a1,a2,
Tea is not zero almost everywhere, and
holds f o r a l m o s t every
x
x E
.
PROOF. (i) Note first that according to the proof of the last theorem
I (T(x,y)l 2 dv(y)
. Furthermore,
S
is an upper bound of
Theorem 99.5, the same integral is the infimum of all any X
,
f E L2
. Now,
let
the inequality f E L2(Y,v)
I (Tf)(x)l
5
according to
8'
such that, for
))f)I2.g(x) holds for almost every
be given. The inner product
c
=
(f,ea)
, i.e., ilf-fkl/ + 0 k Hence, by property (iii) of a Carleman operator in the last theorem f
is the norm limit (as k
(Tfk)(x) we have
+
(Tf)(x)
+
m
) of
f = Ctciei
almost everywhere on
X
. Denoting now
satis-
,... . Then
ea , say for el,e2
fies ca # 0 for at most countably many
sup S
by
.
h2
3
274
GENERALIZED CARLEMAN OPERATORS
almost everywhere on
X
for k x
S
l,2,
=
...
/ (Tf)(x)/
on the left, we get
+ m
. This shows that
1 (Tf)(x)/
for k
the function h
simultaneously. Taking the limit
s llf112.h(x)
1
sup S = h2 2 inf g2 =
for almost every
is one of the functions g
almost everywhere on
Ilfi/ .g(x) 2
Ch. 13,5993
/T(x,y)l
X 2
.
satisfying
It follows that
dv(y)
.
Y Combining this with the earlier observation that the last integral is an S
upper bound of
, we
get the desired result.
(ii) On account of the order separability of
M(X,u)
an at most countable subset possessing the same supremum as
the set S
(An:n=1,2, ...) of finite subsets of
there exists a sequence
has
. Hence,
S
{a) such
that (T(x,y)/
2
dv(y)
=
I (Tea)(x)I2:n=1,2,
sup
...
Y
It follows immediately that
(Tea)(x)
in the complementary set of
UIAn
as
, we
ctl,a2,...
m
= 0
almost everywhere for every
. Numbering the elemenbs
get the frlnal result
for almost every x E X F o r the case that
a
in
a
u>n
. L (Y,v) 2
i s separable (i.e., every orthonormal basis
is at most countable), the equivalence of (i) and (iv) in Theorem 99.7 and the results in Theorem 99.8 are due to M. Schreiber and G. Targonski ( [ l ] ,
1970). EXERCISE 99.9. Let L2(X,p)
T
L (Y,u) into 2 are o-finite measure spaces. Show
be a linear operator mapping
, where (X,A,p) and
(Y,C,v)
that the following conditions are equivalent. (i) T
is
a
Hilbert-Schmidt operator, i.e., T
with kernel T(x,y)
satisfying
is a kernel operator
Ch. 13,1991
KERNEL OPERATORS
1
IT(x,y)l
2
d(uxu) <
XXY
-.
There exists a non-negative function g E L2(X,p)
(ii)
f E L2(Y,v)
every
275
.
most every x € X
, the inequality I (Tf)(x)/
(iii) For every orthonormal system
5
It is easy to see
that (i) implies (iii) Assume that (iii) holds and let
. It follows from
holds for at most countably many
*<
,
Cy\lTekII
,
(ea:a€{a})
(iii) that
say for al,a2
be any
I/Teall > 0 Then
,... .
i.e.,
1 (Tek) (x) 1
Cy
a E {a}
holds for al-
in L (Y,u) we have 2
(ea:a€{a})
HINT: (i) and (ii) are equivalent by Theorem 99.6. orthonormal system in L2(Y,v)
such th t, fo
llfl12.gk)
2
,
dub) <
X and
m
C1
so
(Te )(x)
=
I (Tek)(x)I2
i s finite for almost every
0 almost everywhere far any
... , we
T
. Hence, by
T is Carleman operator. It follows from Theorem 99.8 (ii)
i s Hilbert-Schmidt.
EXERCISE 99.10. Let A
be the interval [ O , l l
measure. Furthermore, let 0 < a < 1
(i) Show that T(x,y)
and
T(x,y)
, equipped with Lebesgue = Ix-yl
-a
on
A x A
1
(ii) For
5
a < I
the function T(x,y)
a kernel operator T mapping
-1
=
Ix-~I-~
$
and
f
is
i s the kernel of
L (A) into itself such that 2 Carleman operator. For the proof, note the following facts. If
.
i s the kernel of a Hilbert-Schmidt operator
(from L (A) into itself) for 0 < a < and TI(x,y) = x T(x,y) 2 the kernel of a Carleman operator which is not Hilbert-Schmidt.
(a)
that
a E { a } which is not one of
by the function E y 1 (Tek)(x)I2
is bounded above in M(X,u) that
. Observing now
find that the set of all
a1,a2,
Theorem 99.7,
x
T
is not a
are (real or complex) Lebesgue measurable functions
276
Ch. 13,1999
GENERALIZED CARLEMAN OPERATORS
on the real line, both of period one and Lebesgue s m a b l e over A , then h(x)
=
i
+(x-y)f(y)dy
A
is Lebesgue sumable over A (b) then hp (c)
It1 2 and
4
llhlll 2 ~ ~ $ ~ ~ .l . ~ ~ f ~ ~ l
and
is sumable for some p satisfying 1 <
If in addition fp
llhll 2 I I $ I I , . I I f I l P be defined for real t
is sumable and Let and
$(t)
$(t+l) = $(t)
for all
for
,
2 $(t)
It1 5 1
t
.
P by
.
Then
$(t)
11$11,
Za(l-a)
-1
is finite
so
f (y)dy
A
This implies that
Ix-~I-~
is the kernel of a kernel operator mapping
L (A) into itself. For p = 2 and P operator.
1
HINT: For (a), note first that $(x-y variables, is measurable. Hence, since $
..
For (b), let
q be defined by
p-'+q-l
Holder's inequality and by part (a),
so
this is not a Carleman
2 a < 1
= 1
,
as
m ,
for
= =
<
a function of two
is periodic,
and let g E L q
. Then, by
Ch. 13,1991
KERNEL OPERATORS
277
EXERCISE 99.11. Show that if in the Luxemburg-Gribanov theorem the measure space
(Y,C,v)
is separable, then there exists a simpler proof than
the one in Theorem 99.2. HINT: Parts (i) and (ii) of the proof remain the same.
may be assumed now that Ll(Y,v) L (Y,v) 1
S
is separable,
...
is also separable. Let vj,v2,
so
In part (iii) it
the subset S
be a sequence in
with respect to the L -norm, and let X 1 be the subset of
X
is a v-measurable function of
y
I
of all x u(X-Xl)
=
such that T(x,y) 0
.
one of the v
1
x E XI , v E S
I f now
and
E >
< E
.
Y
It follows that d(x) = sup(
=
sup(
/
/
T(x,y)v(y)dv(y):vES
T(x,y)vn(y)dv(y):n=l,2,.
)
consisting
,
so
0 are given, there exists
such that T(x,y).lv(y)-vn(y)ldv(y)
of
S , dense in
=
1
.. .
CHAPTER 14
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
A Riesz space
L
then L
(L,p)
L
or
P
.
is called a normed Riesz
If
L
is norm complete,
P
is called a Banach lattice. In section 100 we compare the norm to-
P
pology in L
with the order topology and the uniform topology. We recall
P
of a Riesz space L
that, by definition, the subset D (ru-closed) if it follows from fn E D
p
equipped with a Riesz norm
space and will be denoted by
for all n
f E D
that
fn
.
+
f
is order closed
in order (relatively uniformly) and
In the normed Riesz space L
,
P
if
.
fn
+
f
f 2 g for all n , then f 2 g This n implies that the positive cone L+ is closed in the topologies mentioned. (in order, ru
or in norm) and
Furthermore, fn
-f
P
f(ru)
implies fn
+
f
(in norm) as well as
fn
+
f
(in order). There is, in general, no such implication between norm convergence and order convergence of a sequence. F o r monotone sequences the situation is nicer; if the monotone sequence fn then f then f
converges to =
f
in order (i.e., if
order, then the limits are the same, i.e., if If
L
P
fn4 and
fn
+
f
f
in norm, in norm,
) . Finally, if a sequence converges in norm as well as in
sup f
in order, then
converges to
f
=
g
.
is a Banach lattice, then L
norm convergent sequence in L
P
P
fn
+
f
in norm and
fn
+
g
is uniformly complete and any
has a subsequence that converges in order
Furthermore, every order closed set in a Banach lattice is norm closed and every norm closed set is ru-closed. In general, this does not hold in a normed Riesz space which is n o t a Banach lattice, but i t remains true for ideals. Hence, every order closed ideal in a normed Riesz space is norm closed. It will be proved a l s o that the Riesz space structure in L extended i n a naturpl manner to the norm completion makes
(L-,p)
into a Banach lattice containing L
P
(L-,p)
of
Lp
P
can be
. This
as a norm dense Riesz
subspace. In theexercisesbelonging to this section most of the results are extended to the complexification L
P
+ iL P
and to the case that
L is a
Riesz space with a topology which is not determined by one single norm, but 279
Ch. I41
CHAPTER 14
280
by a system of Riesz seminorms or, even more generally, by a system of Riesz pseudonorms. In section 101 we discuss norm completeness. It is recalled first that (un:n=1,2, . . . )
if L
such that
is a sequence of positive elements in the Riesz space
supn Zyuk
m
Z u
exists, then this supremum is denoted by
I n '
The normed Riesz space L is now said to satisfy the Riesz-Fischer conP for every sequence (un:n=1,2, ...) of podition if Emu exists in L I n
mp
sitive elements for which Z1p(un)
is finite and
L
m
the weak Riesz-Fischer condition if
EIp(un)
<
is said to satisfy
P
implies the existence of
m
.
E L+ such that un s vo for all n It is proved that the O P normed Riesz space L is a Banach lattice if and only if L satisfies
an element v
P
P
the Riesz-Fischer condition (I. Halperin-W.A.J. Luxemburg, 1956) and also
L
that
P
is a Banach lattice if and only if
L
Since any normed Riesz space L P tion LA of L exists. The norm p P
is uniformly complete and
P
satisfies the weak Riesz-Fischer condition.
is Archimedean, the Dedekind complemay be extended to a Riesz norm
P-
on LA by defining
The normed Riesz space
(L^,p^)
is now a Banach lattice if and only if
satisfies the weak Riesz-Fischer condition.
L P
In section 102 we investigate the properties of the Banach dual (Banach
.
The Banach dual of adjoint space) of a normed Riesz space L P denoted by L* , the norm in L* by p* and the order dual of P
It i s proved that
P
L;
is an ideal in L"
, not
L
will be
Lp
by
P
L".
necessarily a band. Further-
more, the space L* , with the order structure inherited from L" , is a P Dedekind complete Riesz space and p* is a Riesz norm in L* . If L saP
L
P
is a Banach lattice, then L* = L" P
ed Riesz space L if
0
P
Everymonotone sequence in the norm-
converging weakly to zero converges to zero in norm, i.e.,
P
2 u J.
.
in L
P
and 4 (u,)
+
0 for every
Similarly for downwards directed sets in L
P
4 E L*
.
In section 87 it was s h m that the order dual L
satisfies
L"
=
P
. In particular, if
tisfies the weak Riesz-Fischer condition, then L* = L"
L" m L;
=:L
m L;~
,
P
L"
,
then p(un)
J.
0
.
of the Riesz space
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
Ch. 14,51001 N
where
Lc
and
28 1
N
are the bands of all integrals and all normal integrals Ln respectively and Ls and Lsn are their disjoint complements. In the case N
N
is a normed Riesz space L , the Banach dual L* P PN N and the intersections of :L , Ln , Ls and Lsn with
that N
L
L
L*
and L*
by Lp*,c 7 LE,n 1 p , s sections are ideals in L”
We introduce
the set
p,sn
f E L
P
such that
E L*
L
P
P
. The
and bands in L* P
L,” of all
If/ 2 u
sets La
on which every
P
I$ E LE
P
are denoted
P
such that
f E Lp such that
. Similarly, Lan P
0 implies I$(u,)
C
and Lan
L*
respectively. This implies thattheseinter-
@(un) C 0 for every positive 4 E Lp* @
is an ideal in
N
If1
2
u
J-
0 implies
is the set of all
0 for every positive
C
, the largest ideals in
are ideals in L
P
is an integral. or a normal integral respective-
ly. It will be proved that La is also the largest ideal in L on which P P the norm p is a-order continuous, i.e., La consists of all f E L such
.
P
P
(fl 2 u C 0 implies p(un) C 0 Similarly, Lan is the largest n P ideal in Lp on which p is order continuous. Furthermore, La is the P inverse annihilator of L* and Lan is the inverse annihilator of L* P,S P p,sn (i.e., La consists of all f E L such that @(f) = 0 for all @ E L* * P P P,S ’ similarly for Lan ) . This implies that La and Lan are norm closed. In
that
P
P
P
the converse direction, it is of interest to know under which conditions
L*
P,S
I$ E L* satisfying + ( f )
consists exactly of all
This holds if and only if weak star topology of
L* P
L*
P
. Super order denseness of P,S
L* P
for all
f E L ~ . P
a(L* L ) , the P’ P
in L is a P consists exactly of all 4 E L* La
sufficient condition. Similarly, L* P,sn satisfying $(f) = 0 for all f E La* if and only if the weak star topology of
o
=
is closed in the topology P
P
L* is closed in p,sn Lan is sufficient. Most
P
. Order denseness of
P
of the results in this section are extended to the complexification L + i L P
P
and the case of a Riesz space with a topology that is determined by a system of Riesz seminorms.
100. Normed Riesz spaces A Riesz space
L equipped with a Riesa norm space and will be denoted by (L,p) or L P
is called a z o n e d
p
.
If
L
P
is norm complete,
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
282
is called a Banach l a t t i c e . Any normed Riesz space is Archimedean,
then L
P
because it follows from 0 < nu 5 v for all
,
n
,
p(u) = 0
so
i.e., u
We shall assume now that L
Ch. 14,§1001
L
for n
.
= 0
l,2,
=
...
that
is an Archimedean Riesz space (also when
is not assumed to carry a Riesz norm) and we shall adhere to the conver-
gence notations introduced earlier. We recall that fn and
p ( u ) 5 n- 1 p(v)
fn
+
f(ru>
denote that
fn
converges to
+
f , fn
+
f(u-unif)
i n order, u-uniformly or
f
relatively uniformly respectively. In a normed Riesz space norm convergence of
fn
to
f will be denoted by
vergence the limit f
fn
fn
+
The subset D
In all these cases of con-
is uniquely determined (for u-uniform convergence and
relatively uniform convergence because follows from
f(norm).
+
f(ru) of
that L
fn
+
f
L
is Archimedean). Furthermore, it
.
is order closed, ru-closed or norm closed if it
...
follows from f f D (n=I,Z, ) and fn + f (in order, ru or in norm) n that f E D For the order topology and the relatively uniform topology
.
this is the defintion of a closed set (cf. section 16); for the norm topology this is not a defintion, but one of the properties of the norm topology. For an ideal A
in L
a weaker condition implies already that A
is closed.
This was proved in Theorem 83.22 and we recall the result. The ideal A closed (in order, ru
or in norm) if and only if
order closed if and only if THEOREM 100.1. If
fn
sup(f ,gn) + sup(f,g) and nfn + f and lfnl -+ If/
A
+
0
5 u I.
in A
and
. In particular, the ideal
(in order, ru or in norm) implies u E A
is
u + u
A
is
i s a o-ideal.
f and
g
inf(fn,gn)
+ +
. The mappings
therefore continuous mappings from
L
( i n order, ru or i n norm), then
g
inf(f,g) f
+
f+
. I n particuZar,
,f
+
f-
and
f
f+ +
;fi
+
f+ ,
are
into itself.
PROOF. Follows immediately from
and similarly for the infimum.
In Lemma 83.11 it was proved that if all n , then
f
2
g
.
fn
+
f (norm) and
f
n
t
g
for
This holds for the other types of convergence as well.
Ch.
14,11001
NORMED RIESZ SPACES (i) If fn
THEOREM 100.2.
for all
n
, then
.
f t g
+
. Hence,
283
or i n nomn) and
f ( i n order, ru i f
fn
+
f and
f
for a l l
fn t 0
n
g
t
,
n
This shows t h a t the p o s i t i v e cone L+ i s closed. (ii) I f D i s a subset of L and fn + f (in order, ru o r i n n o m ) such t h a t fn I D f o r a l l n , t h e n f I D . Hence, every disjoint complement i s closed or, equivalently (since L i s Archimedean), every band is cLosed. then
f
2
0
PROOF. (i) It may be assumed that
...
g
0
=
f-
the sequence (fi:n=l,Z, ) converges to so f = 0 In other words, f 2 0
.
.
It was already observed above that fn so every order closed subset of be a normed Riesz space
given
E
i E.~(u)
> 0
,
we have
for all
n t
If-f I n(E)
and
fn
for all
5 EU
It follows that every norm closed subset of
fn
+
f(norm),
+
. This shows that
Having observed thus that
fn
But
If -f
I
S
If-fnl ,
for all n ,
f- = 0
implies fn
+
f , and
is stronger than the order topology. Now,
L P
relatively uniform topology in L
.
f(ru)
+
- -
Since
is ru-closed. In other words, the
L
relatively uniform topology in L let L
.
L
in L
f(u-unif)
,
so
. For
any
~(f-f,) 2
n t
n(E)
fn
converges to
f
in norm.
is ru-closed, and so the
is stronger than the norm topology. +
f(ru)
implies fn
+
f
as well as
it may be asked if there is any relation between norm conver-
gence and order convergence, We shall prove first, by means of an example, that norm convergence does not necessarily imply order convergence, and hence does not imply ru-convergence. EXAMPLE 100.3.
x
=
[O,ll
Let u
and let L
be Lebesgue measure in the closed interval
be the space L I ( X , p )
f (x) i 0 as n
and only if
...
+
. Note
that
fn
holds for p-almost every
+
0 holds if
x E X
.
Now, 1
let (En:n=1,2, ) be the sequence of closed intervals [O,fl,[~,lI,[O,jl, 1 2 1 [j,31,[2,ll,[O,-],. . , and let f be the characteristic function of En 3 4 for all n Then fn converges to zero in norm but not in order.
.
.
For monotone sequences the situation is different because now norm convergence implies order convergence. Details are contained in the first part of the next theorem. In the second part it is proved that a u-uniform Cauchy sequence has a u-uniform limit if and only if the sequence converges in norm.
NORElED RIESZ SPACES
284
THEOREM 100.4. (i) I f
.
Ch. 1 4 , § 1 0 0 ]
fn4 i n the normed Riesz space
and fn P S i m i l a r l y f o r decreasing sequences. I n other L
(norm), then
f
words, i f
i s the norm l i m i t of a monotone sequence, then
f
=
sup f
the order l i m i t of t h e sequence.
f
f
+
i s also
.
,...
(ii) I f f o r some u E L+ the sequence (fn:n=1,2 ) in L is a P P u-uniform Cauchy sequence, then the sequence i s a l s o Cauchy i n norm. In t h i s
ease, t h e sequence has a u-uniform l i m i t i f and only i f t h e sequence has a norm l i m i t , and these l i m i t s are then the same. Any Banach l a t t i c e i s theref o r e uniformly complete. (iii) Similarly, i f
Cauchy, then
fn
v-uniformzy,
(f ) n
i s u-uniformly Cauchy as w e l l as v-uniformly
converges u-uniformly i f and only i f
f (norm). Since f 2 f for all n 2 m, n m by Theorem 100.2. This holds for all m , s o f is an
PROOF. (i) Let we have
f f
and
fn
f s'f m upper bound of the sequence. Let for all
fn converges
and the l i m i t s are then the same.
n
,
so
f 2 g
+
g
be another upper bound. Then f
by Theorem 100.2. It follows that
.
upper bound of the sequence, i.e., f = sup f
f
2
g
is the least
(ii) It is evident that any u-uniform Cauchy sequence is also Cauchy in norm. It is also evident that if i n this case the sequence has a u-uni-
form limit
f
, then f is also the norm limit. It remains to prove, there-
fore, that if the u-uniform Cauchy sequence then f If -f I m n
is also the u-uniform limit of 4 EU
for m,n
2 n(E)
fn
.
(f ) has the norm limit f n For any E > 0 we have
and also (n fixed, m
-z m
,
) the sequence
(Ifm-fnl :m=n,n+I,...) converges in norm to If-f fn
I < E U for
n 2
If-fnl n(E)
. Hence, by
Theorem 100.2, we find that
. This shows that
f
is the u-uniform limit of
*
(iii) Similarly. It was shown above (Example 100.3) that norm convergence does not
always imply order convergence. In the converse direction, we have similarly that order convergence does not necessarily imply norm convergence, even for monotone sequences. To mention an example, let the usual supremum norm) and let u
n
(for n
L
P
= 1,2,
be the space Lm (with
...
) be the elemen0 with
Ch. 14,11001
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
the first n u
+
0
285
coordinates equal to zero and all other coordinates one. Then
, but the sequence does not converge in norm. The sequence is not
p(un-um) = 1 for n # m . For an example with an order convergent monotone sequence such that the sequence is Cauchy in
even Cauchy in norm because
norm but not convergent in norm we refer to the exercises at the end of this section. The examples presented show that norm convergence and order convergence are to a great extent independent. Fortunately, as we prove now, if a sequence is convergent in norm as well as in order, then the limits are the same. THEOREM 100.5. If fn L~
, then
f
g
=
.
PROOF. Writing un exists a sequence pn u
=
+
p(v-un) 0
5
+
0
.
f (norm) and
, we
lfn-gl
0 such that
converges in norm to
we have
+
/f-gl
.
fn
have
0
5
+
u
un
i n t h e normed R i e s z space
g
0 by hypothesis, so there
+
pn
5
Hence, writing
If-gl = v
It has to be proved that v
inf(v,u ) s inf(v,pn)
5
for all n =
0
. Note
. Furthermore,
for brevity, that
v ,
so (by one of the Birkhoff inequalities)
o
5
v - inf(v,pn)
5 v
- inf(v,u )
2
Iv-u
I ,
which implies
The decreasing sequence
(inf(v,pn):n=1,2, ...) converges, therefore, in
order to zero and in norm to v
. It follows from Theorem 100.4(i)
that
v = o .
-
It was shown in Example 100.3 that a norm convergent sequence need not be order convergent. Thinking of L -spaces (for I 5 p 5 ) , where each norm P convergent sequence has a pointwise converging subsequence, it is a natural conjecture that in a Banach lattice each norm convergent sequence has a sub-
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
286
Ch. 14,§lOOl
sequence converging in order. We prove that the conjecture is right. THEOREM 100.6. Every norm convei,ent
sequence i n a Banach l a t t i c e has
a subsequence which converges i n order. As a consequence, every order closed s e t i n a Banach l a t t i c e i s nomi closed. PROOF. Let x.
11
-t
f (norm) in the Banach lattice L
(gk=fnk:;=l,2, ...) from
sequence for
f
.
(fn:n=1,2,
... )
. Choose
P
such that
It is evident now that the partial sums
s
= 1:;
the sub-
p(f-gk) f-gkl
: 2-k
of the
seriz, -,f-gkj form a Cauchy sequence in norm, s o the series converges in norm. Let 5 s-s
k- 1 order.
s = sup s s o that n ’ Clf-g 1 cannot cause any confusion. Since If-g I 5 k k k + , it is evident now that gk converges to f in
be the sum. By Theorem 100.4(i) we have
s
the notation s
=
C 0 as
-
Let us assume now that proof that D all n
D
is norm closed, assume that
. We have
to show that
fn
+
f (norm)
P
with
For the f
E D
for
. As proved above, there exists a sub(fn:n=1,2, ...) such that gk converges to f f E D
(g :k=I,Z,...) of k in order. Since g E D for all k k that f E D
sequence
.
is an order closed set in L
.
If the normed Riesz space L
P
and D
is order closed, it follows
fails to be a Banach lattice, there may
exist norm convergent sequences without order convergent subsequences and that fail to be norm closed. For there may exist order closed sets in Lp an example we refer to the exercises at the end of this section. Recapitualting, we have found that in a Banach lattice L
P
wing implications hold for any subset: (1)
order closed -norm closed
but not if
L
P
the follo-
* ru-closed,
is a normed Riesz space which fails to be norm complete. In
this case, however, the implications in ( 1 ) are still true for ideals, as we shall prove now. It will be proved later (in Example 105.8) that in a Banach lattice every norm convergent sequence has a relatively uniformly convergent subsequence. Hence, a subset of a Banach lattice is norm closed if and only if it is ru-closed.
NORMED
Ch. 14,§1ool
THEOREM 100.7. For any idea2
A
i n a normed Riesz space the fol2owing
ho Zds : order closed
A
(2)
=$
nomi closed
A
287
RIESZ SPACES
-
A
ru-closed.
I n p a r t i c u l a r , therefore, every o-idea2 is nomi c2osed ( t h i s i s an improve-
ment upon Theorem 100.2(ii)). PROOF. It was observed in the beginning of the section that every norm closed set is ru-closed, so we have to prove only that if the ideal A order closed, then A with all un
in A
0
u
5
u 4
and
i s norm closed. Let
A
be order closed. For the
is norm closed it is sufficient to show that if
proof that A
+
and u
+
n Theorem 1 0 0 . 4 , i.e., 0 < un 4 u u E A .
then u E A E A for all n
u(norm),
u (norm) with
.
u
is
0
5 u
. Hence, assume . Then u = sup un
4
by is order closed, this implies
Since A
The inverse implications of those in (2) do not hold. The ideal of all null sequences is norm closed in =
(c,) not order closed. In the
of all (real) continuous functions on
space C(C0,ll) p(f)
em , but
i0 If (x) ldx 1
the ideal of all
f
[O,ll
satisfying f (0)
=
with norm
0 is uniformly
closed, but not norm closed. Under certain additional conditions, which will be discussed in section 105, one or both of the inverse implications hold. A s an application of the lasc theorem we mention the case that
$
is a
positive linear functional on
L such that the null space (kernel) of @ P is a o-ideal. In this case the null space of $I is therefore norm closed,
which implies that
@
is norm continuous. This holds in particular if
@
,
as a mapping from L into the real numbers, is a Riesz o-homomorphism. P Actually, this is the only possible case (i.e., if the kernel op the positive linear functional
@
is a o-ideal, then
@
is a o-homomorphism; cf.
Exercise 100.23). A further simple remark concerns operators from one normed Riesz space
.
L into another, say LA If L is a Banach lattice, then every positive P P operator from L into LA is continuous (the proof in Theorem 83.12 P fails to be norm complete. In this applies), but not necessarily if L P case, i t is sometimes easy to know that if S and T are operators from Lp
into LA
satisfying
€I 5
S 5 T
and
T
is continuous, then
S
is con-
2aa
Ch. 14,81001
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
f E Lo
tinuous. This follows by observing that for any X(Sf)
so
=
X(ISf+-Sf-l)
is continuous and
S
jection band in L B
Evidently
u
for every
operator in L
P
.
IITll
llS// 5
h(Slfl) 2
=
As an example, let
E Li ,
. It follows that
llPBll = 1
B # {O}
if
PB 2 I
8 2
so
PB
.
, where I
T
is a positive operator from L
tor in the ideal generated by
T
in
.
Then
is the identity
is a norm continuous operator in L
It follows now also easily that if, in addition, LA plete and
B be a pro-
with corresponding band projection PB
P
0< P u 2 u
h(Sf++Sf-)
5
we have
LA
into
P
Lb (L p ' Lh )
is Dedekind com-
,
then every opera-
is continuous.
Before discussing some properties of the norm completion of
Lp
, we
observe that the result in Theorem 100.4 about monotone sequences may be extended to directed sets. The upwards directed set to converge i n norm to in the set such that
f
E >
for all
.
p(f,-f)
< E
f
wards directed sets. THEOREM 100.8. If
converges to
(fT :n=l,Z,...)
from
. Also,
for an appropriate
The sequence
(fT ) n
T'
'
t f
To
f
=
sup f
(f':'€{~})
such that
choose a fixed
fT 0
C
{TI ,
+
L
P
and
fT
and a sequence
0
f
'0
Similarly for down-
.
E~
is said
0 an element f
fTS in the normed Riesz space
f in norm, then
PROOF. Choose a sequence of numbers all" fT 2 fT n
(f?:~E{-i})
if there exists for any
1-
. Thenn
and
p(f-f,)
2
SO
i s increasing and converges in norm to
f , so
E~
for
.
Ch. 14,51001
f =
sup f
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
289
by Theorem 100.4. For an arbitrary
n
SUP(fT,f) - f
(
sup fT'fT
=
.f)
fT we have
- SUP(fT
n
)
,f) s SUP(fT>fT n
- fT n
n
,
so
Since
+
E
0
follows that Hence
f
, this implies pIsup(fT,f)-fl f
f
5
.
sup f
=
for all
. We
fT
= 0
,
so
sup(fT,f)
know already that
. It
f
=
.
f = sup f
T
We shall now derive some simple properties of the norm completion of an arbitrary normed Riesz space L
.
P
It will be proved that the norm comple-
tion is a Banach lattice under the natural definitions. For brevity we write instead of Lp ; the norm completion is denoted by L and the extended
L
(as well as the original norm in L ) is denoted by
norm in Lof
L-
are denoted by
... . By
fo,go,
defintion, an element uo
called positive if there exists a sequence in L+ Note that for elements in L
LEMMA 100.9.
The s e t
in L-
sure of L+
.
a uo + a2u2 E (L-)+ 1 1
for uo 1
numbers. We prove now that if There exist sequences
(u,)
in L-
is
converging in norm to u
0
.
.
o f all p o s i t i v e elements i n
(L-)'
containing
PROOF. It is evident that 0
Elements
this definition is in agreement with the
existing notion of positiveness in L
generating cone in L-
.
p
L+
L+
cone
u2
uo
and
(L-)'
in
(L-)+ . .
is a
and also that
al,a2 non-negative
-uo are positive, then uo in L+
(v,)
and
L-
is t h e norm clo-
(L-)'
is contained in 0
and and
. The
=
converging in norm to
0 u
.
0
converges in norm to zero. It follows then -uo respectively, so u +v n n from 0 s u 5 u +v and p(un+v ) 0 that p(un) + 0 , so uo = 0 n n n Having thus proved that (L-)+ isna cone in L- , it remains to show that and
.
-f
(L-)+
is generating. For this purpose, let
(fn) be a sequence in L
and 0 U2
(fi) in L-
converging to
fo
0
f
E L- be given, and let
in norm. The sequences
are Cauchy sequences in L , converging to elements uy
.
The elements uo 1
0 and u2
( f : )
and
are positive by definition. Since
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
290
Ch. 14,§1001
.
0 0 f+-f- = f converges in norm to fo , we have ul-u2 = fo This shows that n n n every element in L- is the difference of elements in the cone (L-)' .
Hence, (L-)+
is generating. L-
The lemma shows that
f0
called equivalent (as usual). converges to
go whenever
5
go-fo
Note now that if
go (all fn
and all
(hn=sup(f n ,gn ):n=l,2,
fn
in L
gn
and
1
changed into an equivalent sequence, that
ho
ho
so
2
bound of so
fo
.
fo and
go
.
(h,)
is
is not changed. We shall prove
.
fo and
.
If
there exists a sequence
k' t f for all n n n converging in norm to ko =
ho
. If
in L-
go in LSince h -f t 0 0 on h -f converges in norm to ho-fo , we have h -f t 0 , n n 0 Similarly h 2 go It follows already that ho is an upper
and
that
kn
so
is the least upper bound of
for all n
fo and
...
are replaced by equivalent sequences, then
(9,)
are
then the sequence
is Cauchy in norm, and s o the sequence has a norm limit ho (fn)
-
converges to ) ?
as
is positive.
converging t o the same element in L
Norm Cauchy sequences in L gn
(L-)'
is an ordered vector space with
positive cone. By definition, we have
ko
.
is another upper bound, we have in L
0
k -f
converging in norm to ko
( k : ) Similarly, there exists a sequence
.
0
t 0
) : k (
in L
and such that k" t g for all n Let n n for all n Then kn converges in norm to ko and
sup(kA,k:) k n
2
sup(f .g ) n n
.
=
h n
for all n ,
.
0
,
and such
0
k t ho This shows that ho is the least upper bound of fo and g in L . As a special case,note that if fn converges to fo , then 0 0 sup(fn,-f ) converges to sup(f ,-f ) , i.e., Ifn\ converges to lfol n Having proved thus that L is a Riesz space containing L as a norm dense Riesz subspace, we prove finally that p is a Riesz norm in L so
.
o
+
so the norm
is absolute. To prove that
p
implies p(lf
0
Since p(fo-fn)
There exist sequences 0
0
p(v -u -dn)
+
0
. Then
(u,) un+dn
and
I-ifnl)
(d,)
+
o , we
p
in L+
.
get
is monotone, let 0 such that
converges in norm to
v
0
,
0
p(u -un) so
5
uo -f
0
5
v
0
and
.
NORMED R I E S Z SPACES
Ch. 14,§1001 0
) = lim p ( u +d ) 2 lim p ( u )
p(v
n
n
0
.
p(u )
=
n
29 I
We formulate the final result.
-
THEOREM 100.10. The norm completion L
P
i s a Banach l a t t i c e containing
L
of the nomned Riesz space
(L , p )
as a norm dense Riesz subspace.
P
A s an application we prove the following theurem. THEOREM 100.11. D~
D
of
D
If
i s solid i n
P
. In particular,
s o l i d in L-
of A i n L
and in
P
vely.
i s a solid set i n L and the norm closure
L
(L-,p)
i f
If/ E D 1
fn
+
f(norm).
.
Then
lfnl
. There exists a
u E D1
02 u
sequence
lfnl E D E D1
Iv
(~-,p)
respecti-
, we
f E D1
Given
in D
(~-,p) i s
the norm closures
and i n
.
D1
(fn)
If 1 (norm) and
+
. Next, if
D in
of P '
L~
are i d e a l s i n
There exists a sequence
If1 E D I
solid), so
D
i s an idea2 i n L
A
PROOF. We first present the proof for
that
then the norm cZosure
'-
p
n (since D
for all
is
, we have to show that
of positive elements in D
(v,)
show
such that
such
are members of D and that v + v(norm). Then all u = inf(vn,u) n + u(norm) , so u E D1 T o prove now that D1 is solid, we have to show
.
u
f E Dl
that g E DI
if it is given that
,
lgl E D 1
that
so
If1
/gl and
i
If] E D l
be a sequence of positive elements in D f+ 2
If I
of D 1
add
. Let
in norm to
f-
5
(un)
f+
.
If I
,
. It follows from
g E D1
by what was proved already. Let
the elements
converging in norm to
f+
and
f-
u
5
f+
and
.
u
n
i
w
n
converging
for all n
(otherwise, replace u
; this does not change the
convergence to
by inf(un,wn,f+) f+ ) . Similarly, let (v,)
elements in D
converging in norm to
be a sequence of positive and such that v 2 f and
V
IW
for all n
n n inf(u ,v ) n n
=
o
.
Since inf(f+,f-)
for all n ,
Un + Vn =
.
so
f=
0
(w,) Since
are likewise members
be a sequence of positive elements in D
We may assume that
If1
, this implies now that
it follows from
sup(un,v ) 2 w
E D
that u +v E D Then Jun-v 1 i u +v E D , s o u -v E D since D is n n n n n n +" solid. The sequence (an-vn) converges in norm to f -f = f , SO it follows
292
Ch. 14,51001
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
at last that
.
f E D1
For the investigation of the closure Dduce the subset D2 0
If 1
of
L- consisting of all
of
D
in
fo E L-
.
we intro-
(L-,P)
such that
for some g E D Evidently, D is contained in D2 and a solid subset of L We prove that D2 i s a subset of D . Let 5
fo E D to
fO 2
lgl
.
.
D2
is
be given. There exists a sequence (fn) in L converging in norm 0 o p .ithermore, since f E D2 , we have If I C: lgl for some g E D.
We may assume that
note that :f E D
/fnl
,
lgl
S
since D
is solid in L
for all n , and so the limit proved therefore that solid set D2
is
D-
for all n (otherwise, replace fn by
fo of
,
D c D2 c D-
.
is contained i n
fn
D-
the norm closure in
so
fn E D
). It follows that
P
. We have
(L-,p)
of the
is solid in L-
Hence, by what was proved above, D-
of an ideal A , the
If one is only interested in the closure A1 proof is simpler. Since A l
is a linear subspace, it follows immediately
from f+ E A 1
that
f- E A l
and
The following remark about
L
f
P
=
f+-f- E A
and
I '
(L-,p)
may be of use for a better
understanding of the difference between convergence in norm and convergence in order. A sequence in L
P
f E Lp
is convergent in norm to an element
if and only if the sequence is convergent in norm to
f
in
(L-,p)
, but
for convergence in order the situation is different. If the sequence con-
-
verges in order in L
P '
versely. If all to
f
in L-
,
fn and then
f
If-f I
are members of 5
is not necessarily a member of order in
, but not con-
then it converges in order in L L
P
and
fn
po J. 0 for appropriate :p
L
P
converges in order
E L-
. Since
0
Pn , the sequence may fail to converge in
LP
In some cases the properties of a Riesz space equipped with a Riesz seminorm can be derived from the properties of a normed Riesz space. We recall Theorem 62.3. If is an ideal in L manner in L / A
by
,
L
is a Riesz space with Riesz seminorm p
then the quotient seminorm X
, defined
and
A
in the usual
.
Ch. 14,§1001
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
[fl E L/A
for every
,
i s a Riesz seminorm in L/A
. If
for n
and
i.e., if it follows from
,
f E A
that
A
then
The space L every sequence
(fn)
in L
f E L
Clp(fn) <
. Choose
m
P (gk+l-gk) <
. Choose
Cp(fA) <
m
,
so
that
1
=
Xf [f,]
s =
served above, L/A N
SO
N
P
P
=
m
. Then
A
+
0
n
+
m,n m
.
-+ m
If
L
there is
is evidently p-convergent, n
, then sn
-+ m
. Conversely,
~f fi
<
m
fn
L/A
so by hypothesis
p(fA)
.
[sl
is A-convergent to is a Riesz norm,
P
5
h(Cfn]) s E L
+ 2-n
.
. Then
It follows
L
L/Np
so
is p-complete and
is a Banach lattice. Note is a Banach lattice
is contained in any p-closed ideal,
is the smallest p-closed ideal.
EXERCISE 100.12. On the Riesz space of all real sequences
f =
(fl,f2,...) , let p
and let L
=
(f:p(f)<m)
be defined by
. Show that
L
P =
is a Riesz space and
is a
Riesz norm in L
. Let
coordinates equal to zero and all other coordinates one.
Then u
J.
0 ,
so
u
the sequence
(for n (u,)
...
p
with the first n
P
1,2,
)
be the element in L
P
converges in order to zero. The
sequence is evidently Cauchy in norm. Show that the sequence does not have a norm limit. HINT: If (un) order limit.
.
,
Hence, by what was ob-
L/A
so
is a p-closed ideal,
N
gk f
is p-convergent to
is A-complete. For the proof, let
is A-complete. In particular, if
(fEL:p(f)=O)
such that
,
is p-convergent to some
is p-complete. Note also that
=
be the quotient seminurm in L/A
f' E [f 1 such that
is p-closed, then A L
p(f-fn)
0 as
0 as
+
k . Then Cp(gk+l-gk) f E L . It follows that
is an ideal in L m
if
CE=l fk
p(s-sn)
Zp(fn) <
be p-complete and let
<
[s
=
+
0 as
for all k
XA([fn])
that
sn
+
(gk=fn :k=1,2,...)
the subsequence
2-k
L
where A
A
then
is p-closed,
Xnl fk i s is p-complete. For the proof, let p(fm-fn) + 0 as
is p-convergent to some Let
.
A
is said to be p-complete if for
p(f-fn)
such that
have the property that if
p-convergent. Then L +
,
m
s E L
i,e., there exists
m,n
1,2, ...
=
satisfying p(fm-fn)
such that
m
p-complete and let L
f E A
is a Riesz norm in L/A
with Riesz seminorm p
exists an element
293
would have a norm limit, it would be the same as the
294
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
EXERCISE 100.13. f u n c t i o n s on L
Let
C0,ll with
Lp
Ch. 14,51001
b e t h e R i e s z s p a c e of a l l r e a l c o n t i n u o u s 1 lfldx We d e f i n e a sequence (f,) in
.
p(f) =
converging t o z e r o i n norm b u t such t h a t no subsequence converges t o
P
zero i n order. L e t
0 < f
< 1 1 -
(1)
with
f
= 1
and
p(f ) = 2
and
p(f2) = 2
1
0 5 f2
2
1
with
1 2 f (-) = f (-1 = 1 2 3 2 3
O < f
5 1
with
f
-1
,
-2
,
1
generally
for
... .
n = l,2,
= I
n
I
n+l,...,L
in
and
n+ I
p ( f n ) = 2-n
It i s evident t h a t
converges to z e r o i n norm. Show fn t h a t no subsequence converges t o z e r o i n o r d e r . L e t D = (f : n = l , 2 , . . . )
Show t h a t t h e s e t
,...
HINT: I f
fn ,fn 1 2 p(x)
subsequence, t h e n Assuming t h a t
0 5 f
2
"k C0,ll
on
f
.
2
K
in
P
pk
is a majorant f o r a l l
K
in
L
L
P
A
(L-,p)
.
L
P
L
P
.
be a R i e s z seminorm i n t h e Riesz s p a c e
and
a Riesz subspace of
K L
,
such t h a t p,(x)
so
2 1
Show t h a t t h e c l o s u r e of
and t h e c l o s u r e of
P
and t h e A-closure of
L
.
L
K
in
. Let
L
(L-,p) be an i d e a l
A
Show t h a t t h e A-closure of
i s a R i e s z subspace of
K
EXERCISE 100.15. I n t h i s e x e r c i s e L
fn, (irk) J
.
C0,ll
on
pk C 0
b e a normed Riesz s p a c e w i t h completion
b e a Riesz subspace of
i s a R i e s z subspace of Let
t h e r e i s a sequence
But
i s a Riesz subspace of
L
,
k
-f
i s a m a j o r a n t of t h e
p
p(x) 2 1
Contradiction.
and l e t
ideal in
-
on a dense s e t , s o
as
EXERCISE 100.14. L e t
(L-,p)
i s any subsequence and 1
0
+
o"k
pk J.
.
i s o r d e r c l o s e d b u t n o t norm c l o s e d .
D
P
L
.
A
i s an
i s a normed R i e s z s p a c e such t h a t
i s uniformly complete. Note t h a t e v e r y Banach l a t t i c e i s u n i f o r m l y com-
p l e t e (by Theorem 100.4). On t h e c o m p l e x i f i c a t i o n
. Show
p(f) = p ( l f / )
that
p
i s a norm i n
L
P
monotone, i . e . ,
p(f) = p(lfl)
that
i s norm complete i f and only i f
L
P
t h i s case
+ iL
L
P
P
+ iL
P
and
If1 5 lgl
L
+ iL
P
+ iL
P
implies L
P
P
we d e f i n e p
by
which i s a b s o l u t e and p(f)
2
p(g)
. Show
i s a Banach l a t t i c e . I n
i s c a l l e d a compZex Banach Zattice.
Ch. 1 4 , § ~ 0 0 1
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
295
Convergence in order, u-uniform convergence and relatively uniform convergence in L
P
+ iL
are defined as in the real case. Closed sets are
P
also defined as in the real case. (a) Show that if
fn
f(norm)
+
and
fn
+
g
in L
P
+ iL
P '
then
f = g . (b) Show that order closed sets and norm closed sets are ru-closed. + iL
(c) Show that a u-uniform Cauchy sequence in L
P
P
has a u-uniform
limit if and only if the sequence has a norm limit. Hence, every complex Banach lattice is uniformly complete. (d) Show that in a complex Banach lattice every norm convergent sequence has a subsequence that converges in order. Show that now every order closed set is norm closed. (r) Show that if in L
P
+ iL
Ar
is an ideal in LP ' then the ideal A = A r+iAr o r in norm) if and only if Ar is
is closed (in order, ru
P
.
closed in L
P
(f) Show that the norm closure of a solid set in L and the norm closure of an ideal is an ideal. (9) Let
(L-,p)
be the norm completion of
be the complexification of (L-+iL-,p)
(L-,p)
+ iL
and let
P
is solid
P
(L-+iL-,p)
in the manner indicated above. Show that
is the norm completion of
EXERCISE 100.16.
L
P
L
P
+ iL
P
.
B be a projection band in the normed Riesz space L and C its disjoint complement, so L = B Q C Prove that the norm P P closure B of B in (L , p ) is a projection band in L More precisely, prove that
L-
=
HINT: Let in norm to uo
E C
and w
B-
0
5
Let
d C-
u
0
.
E L- and let
. For every
. The sequences
n
, let
(u,) u
(v,)
and wo E C- , this shows already that that
B-
n
= {O}
C(v,)
P(Vn-Wn)
+
0
P(Vn+wn)
+
0
2
0
=o.
. Assume
in B
and
0
converging
be a sequence in L+ P
v +w with v E B n n n and (w,) are Cauchy sequences in L
converiing, therefore, to elements vo
sequences
.
.
5 zo
(wn)
=
.
P
and wo in LSince vo E B- L- = B +C It remains to prove
E B-
in C
.
fl C-
. Then there exist positive
converging in norm to
. But vn I wn implies that Ivn-wn I = vn+wn ' . On the other hand vn+wn converges in norm to
z
so
2zo
0
,
so
. Hence
296
EXERCISE 100.17. Let Riesz space L
, where
a
,
then f
0
=
.
Let T
be a system of Riesz seminorms inthe
(pa:aE{aj) L
in the sense that if
f E L the function p,(f-f ) 0 0 into the real numbers. Show that the sets
. Assume
that the
pa(f) = 0 for all
be the weakest topology in L
a E { a ) and every from L
{a}
runs through the index set
system separates the points of
a
Ch. 14,51001
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
such that for every
is a continuous function
depending upon n , ai (i=l,...,n) , fo and logy T
E , form a base for the topo, and show that T is Hausdorff. Note that these base sets are
convex and addition and multiplication by real constants are continuous operations. Note also that for
f
= 0
are solid. The null element of
L
has, therefore, a neighborhood base
0
the base sets
consisting of solid sets. On account of this property T
is said to be a
ZocaZZy s o l i d topology. To recapitulate, T is a locally convex, Hausdorff
.
and locally solid vector space topology in L It will be evident that the sequence topology T
whenever pa(fo-fn)
this case fo rally, let
(f,)
0 as n
-f
+
converges to m
i s uniquely determined (since T
(fT:.rE{T))
be a n e t in L
fo
holds for every
in the
(i.e., the index set
{T)
upwards directed subset of a partially ordered set) converging to T
,
f E U
that
for every index
holds for all
T(a,&)
such that
that each directed system
,
then
i.e., fo
of
T
{T}
1
fo
. Then
T(U)
T 2
a , that is to say, for any
ordering in fT
U
i.e., for every neighborhood
pa(fo-fT) < E
a
. In
a
is Hausdorff). More gene-
there is an index pa(f -f O
and any
E
> 0
holds for all
in
fo
T(U)
such
converges to zero
)
T
is an
T
there exists an 2 T(~,E)
. Note
is automatically a net; the partial
(fT:TE{Tj)
is determined by the partial ordering in the system ofall T2
whenever
fT
S
1
is uniquely determined.
HINT: By the definition of f:/pa(f-fo)-al<E
f ‘2
. If
T ,the sets
fT converges to
fo
in T
,
Ch. 14,51001
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
for all a E { a ) , f o E L , real T , and
so
d. 6i
for i
=
= 1,
and positive
E
, form a subbsase for
the finite intersections form a base. Let
be a non-empty base set. Let
Let
a
297
=
Ipa . (f0-f i)-a.1 < 1
E.-d. 1
1
for
is contained in A
E
...,n
min(fil,...,6 ) n
. Note
that
B
for
i
1,...,n
=
, and let f
=
E L
such that
is open in the topology T
a
and
since by the
are continuous. It follows that the
d = pa (f,-f2) > 0
/ f z p (f-fI)
6i
satisfy pa (f-fo) i
.
is Hausdorff is standard. For
The proof that
.
the set
is a base for T
collection of all sets B
\
i
=
hypothesis all functions pc,(f-fo)
seminorm pa
E
i
...,n . Then
It follows that for
I,
, so
fo E A
fl # f2
. The neigborhoods
there is a
(f:pa(f-f2)
are now disjoint. EXERCISE 100.18. Let T be the topology in the Riesz space L duced in the preceding exercise. (a) Show that
L
is Archimedean. Show that if
fT converges to
intro-
fO
298
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
+ -
T , then
in
f,,f,
+and
(b) Show t h a t
L
t h a t f o r any f i x e d
g
f
.
T
in
lfTl
converge t o
the sets
L
then
fn
converges t o
f
form topology i s s t r o n g e r t h a n (d) Show t h a t i f to
fo
in
T
,
then
f,
, then
L+
formly t o
+
.
T
i f and o n l y i f
converges i n o r d e r t o
converges t o
go 5 L
and a system
fo
.
= go
,
go
fn
are closed
fo
in
T and
converges r e l a t i v e l y uniformly t o
fo
I n t h i s case
converges t o (fn)
T
in
fT
converges
in
. More
converges e-uni-
T fo
.
T
in
and
g e n e r a l l y , show t h a t i f
fn
and i f t h e r e e x i s t s a n element
such t h a t
(g) Show t h a t e v e r y band i n
fo
fn
converges t o
f o = go
then
J. 0
p
(f:fsg)
converges t o
It f o l l o w s t h a t t h e r e l a t i v e l y uni-
t h e sequence i s T-Cauchy.
fo
T . and
i a a n e-uniform Cauchy sequence f o r some
( f ) Show t h a t i f t h e sequence (fT:TE{T})
.
T
!f 1 r espect i vel y. 0 More g e n e r a l l y , show
and
i s upwards d i r e c t e d and
.
fo
(fn)
(fn)
(fn)
in
0
.
g
2
(f,:TE{T})
( e ) Show t h a t i f
e
(f:f?g)
I n p a r t i c u l a r , i f t h e sequence
holds f o r a l l n, then f 0 ( c ) Show t h a t i f t h e sequence
,
f:,fi
i s c l o s e d i n t h e topology in
t g
fo
Ch. 14,§100]
s
/go-f,l
p,
for all
T
,
then
i s T-closed.
L
EXERCISE 100.19. The r e s u l t s i n t h e l a s t
two e x e r c i s e s may be genera-
l i z e d t o a more g e n e r a l topology determined by Riesz pseudonorms. The r e a l valued function
q
on t h e Riesz space
(i)
q(f) 2 0
(ii)
q(f+g)
(iii)
If/
(iv)
q(af)
Note t h a t
0
+
5
f t L
q(f)+q(g)
2
lgl
2
InfI
for all
If1
a
for
+
q(f) 0
jal
i s c a l l e d a R i e s z pseudonomi i f
f,g E L
for a l l
implies
as
L
, sq(g)
,
,
. 5
1
,
so
q(af)
5
q(f)
for
. Every
la1 s 1
Riesz seminorm i s a Riesz pseudonorm. If
then
(X,h,u)
q(f) =
i s a measure s p a c e , 0 < p < 1
I f I P du
i s a Riesz pseudonorm i n t h e R i e s z s p a c e
i s n o t a seminorm. I n t h i s example f =
0
i f and o n l y i f
Let
(q,:n€{aI)
and
q(f) = 0
q
L
P
which
has t h e a d d i t i o n a l property t h a t
.
be a system of Riesz pseudonorms i n t h e Riesz s p a c e
L
Ch. 14,11001
NOWED RIESZ SPACES
q (f) = 0
such t h a t i f topology i n function
T
. Let
f = 0
a, t h e n
a E IaJ
L
be t h e weakest
T
and e v e r y
i s a c o n t i n u o u s f u n c t i o n from
qa(f-fO)
Show t h a t
for a l l
such t h a t f o r every
L
299
f
F L the 0 i n t o t h e r e a l numbers.
i s a Hausdorff and l o c a l l y s o l i d v e c t o r s p a c e topology s u c h
t h a t t h e system of a l l s e t s
i s a b a s e . Show t h a t t h e r e s u l t s i n t h e l a s t two e x e r c i s e s h o l d f o r EXERCISE 100.20. L
space
,
Show t h a t i f
i s a R i e s z pseudonorm i n t h e Riesz
q(f)
then
i s a l s o a R i e s z pseudonorm i n
L
. Show t h a t
(qn(f):n=l,2,
...)
zoo n= 1
qo(f) =
L
and l e t
for a l l
n
...)
q ( f ) = 1;
n
q
, let
2-"qI]l(f)
i s a se-
i s a sequence of pseudonorms i n f = 0
implies
g e n e r a t e d by t h e system of a l l
e x e r c i s e . F o r each
...)
t h e sequence o f
qn(f)
2-
(qn:n=1,2,
qn(f) = 0
such t h a t in
f E L
i s bounded, t h e n
i s a l s o a R i e s z pseudonorm. Assume now t h a t
(qn:n=1,2,
if
quence o f R i e s z pseudonorms s u c h t h a t f o r e a c h numbers
.
T
T
be t h e t o p o l o g y
as defined i n t h e preceding
n '
. Show t h a t
. Let
L
i s a m e t r i c space w i t h r e s p e c t
L
t o the distance function
and show t h a t t h e topology b e l o n g i n g t o t h e m e t r i c i s e x a c t l y t h e topology
T
. It
Closure
follows t h a t i f S-
, then
i n t h e topology T .
S
i s a s u b s e t of
t h e r e e x i s t s a sequence
L
and (fn)
is a point i n the
fo in
S
converging t o
fO
Ch. 14,91001
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
300
Show that every order closed ideal in L
is T-closed and every
closed ideal i s ru-closed. Show also that if A
-
T-
is an ideal (or Riesz
subspace), then the T-closure
A
Show that if the metric space
(L,T) is complete, then every T-convergent
is also an ideal (or Riesz subspace).
sequence has a subsequence which converges in order. In this case, every order closed set is therefore T-closed. EXERCISE 100.21. Let pact Hausdorff space X continuous function u
f be a complex continuous function on the com-
and let on X
E
>
. Show that
0
there exists a complex
such that
for all x E X (Ux,, ...,U
HINT: Let
)
be the same open covering of
X as in Lemma
(g,, ...,g n) ge a partition of unity subordinate to this covering. Now define the numbers ai (i=l, n) by a . = 0 if f(xi) 92.2 and let
and Then
ai
=
f(xi)//f(xi)/
lu(x)I
for all x
5
1
. The
if
for all x
f(xi) # 0
..., . Let u(x)
=
E y aigi(x)
on X
=
.
and
last inequality is evident for x
g.(x) = 0 outside Ux. ) and also if
f(x.) = 0
outside Ux,
. For
f(xi)
#lo
(since the left
hand side is at most
It follows that
EXERCISE 100.22. Let Ar
0
be a uniformly closed ideal in the Archine-
Ch. 14,§100]
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
dean and uniformly complete Riesz space L quotient
(L+iL)/A
f E L+iL we denote by
containing
f
. It was proved I [f 31
Riesz space such that Let
, ,
(L+iL)/A (L+iL)/A
[fl
=
[If I
A
,
A +iA the r r ’ i.e., =
.
the equivalence class in
in section 91 that
(L+iL)/A
1 for every f E L+iL
be a Riesz seminorm in L
p
. Writing
is the complexification of L/Ar
(L+iL)/A = (L/Ar) + i(L/Ar) For any
301
. According
to the formula above for
there are two methods of deriving from p one by first complexifying to
L+iL
.
(L+iL)/A
is a complex
a seminorm on
and then taking the quotient
seminorm and the other one by first taking the quotient seminorm in L/Ar and then complexifying. Precisely, let pc(f)
= p(
If 1 )
infimum of
and
p(f)
pc
be defined on
L+iL
for
p
.
is a Riesz seminorm in L/Ar by Theorem 62.3. The seminorms p pqc
in
(L+iL)/A
Note that p P
qc
(El) <
p
qc
are now defined by
is a Riesz seminorm, that is to say,
.
(Cgl)
(i)
qc Prove by a simple argument that
(ii)
Show that p
for every
p
cq
([f 1)
g E L
h E L+iL
,h
,
5 p
qc
([f 1)
p
2 p
I Cf 11
5
cq
p
and
ICgll
q
implies
.
c4 qc is equivalent to
( 1 hl ) :hCL+iL,hS[ fl
. It is sufficient, therefore, to prove
g E L , g r: Clfll
for any
by
(Cf 1) be defined for [f 1 E L/Ar as the 9 f E L and f running through [fl Note that
let
g
r Cfl
[If11
and any
E
> 0
.
, such that p(/hl)
(iii) For the proof of the last inequality, let g C L such that g r [:If11
, say
Principal ideal generated by
g = If[
+ p with p E A
e = If1 + lpl
that
there exists an element
.
. Let
be given
Le be the
According to the Yosida
representation theorem Le is Riesz isomorphic to the space of all real continuous functions on an appropriate compact Hausdorff space X that
e
corresponds with the function identically one on
X
such
. Then
Le+iLe
Ch. 14,11011
NORMDED RIESZ SPACES
302
i s Riesz isomorphic t o t h e s p a c e o f a l l complex c o n t i n u o u s f u n c t i o n s on For
, denote
f E Le+iLe
e-(x) = 1
o b s e r v e d ) we have Now, l e t p(e) = 0
if
I fl +
g =
u^
If-/ up
for a l l
on
X
h- = f-+p^u^
1 u-I
such t h a t
1 h-/
satisfies
E
1
5
fies
h = f+z
. The
(L+iL)/A
,
.
The
, and
p(e) # 0
(as
6 =
and
E
, so I z/ 5
.
.
h E [f
1 , and
h
.
6e-
5
i t f o l l o w s from
f^+p-u^
1 g-/ + 6e-
5
/ f"-/ f-1 u-I
and
i s approximated by
g-u-
= 1f-l
if
. Show t h a t
f^
L +iL be such t h a t z ^ = p^u^ Then e e of t h e i d e a l A Show now t h a t t h e element
z
.
x 5 X
1-
.
t o E x e r c i s e 100.21 t h e r e e x i s t s a complex c o n t i n u -
i s approximated by that
If
6 = E/p(e)
be g i v e n . L e t
. According
ous function Hence
> 0
E
f-
t h e c o r r e s p o n d i n g f u n c t i o n by
correspondence p r e s e r v e s a b s o l u t e v a l u e s , i . e . ,
X
. Show t h a t
p ( I h-1 ) 5 p ( g - )
, so
Ipl
+
E
. Let
i s a member
z
corresponding t o
h-
. Hence
satis-
on pcq = Q q c proof a s i n d i c a t e d h e r e i s due t o B. de P a g t e r . A s a f i n a l so
p ( / hl ) 5 p ( g ) + c
remark we n o t e t h a t t h e r e s u l t s i n t h i s s e c t i o n become t r i v i a l i f we t a k e
A
for
the ideal
N
of a l l
P
f E L
EXERCISE 100.23. Show t h a t i f L
l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on then
,
$(if I) = 0
. Assume now
t h e element
h = Bu-nv
and
$(v) = B
But
lhl = Bu+av
$(u)
(since
$(v) = 0
A
u
and
v
.
i s a Riesz s p a c e and
L
that
u
is a positive
$
$ i s an i d e a l ( o - i d e a l ) ,
such t h a t t h e k e r n e l of
i s a Riesz homomorphism (o-homomorphism).
$
i f and o n l y i f
that
p(f) = 0
satisfying
A
Note f i r s t t h a t v = 0
. Writing
$(h) = 0
satisfies
are d i s j o i n t ) , so
.
Zap
$(f)
=
,
s o $ ( l h l ) = 0.
=
0
.
It follows
101. Banach l a t t i c e s A s well-known,
series i n
i s c o n v e r g e n t . More p r e c i s e l y , V
V
f o l l o w s from n
fk
= C;
C y fn
,
i s norm complete ( i n o t h e r
V
i s a Banach s p a c e ) i f and o n l y i f e v e r y a b s o l u t e l y c o n v e r g e n t
words, V
s
a nomed v e c t o r space
Cy
/I
frill
< -
(all
have a norm l i m i t i n
fn V
in
. The
i s Banach i f and o n l y i f i t
V ) t h a t t h e p a r t i a l sums norm l i m i t i s t h e n w r i t t e n a s
b u t t h i s may c a u s e c o n f u s i o n i n c a s e
i s a normed Riesz s p a c e
V
because according t o our e a r l i e r conventions t h e o r d e r l i m i t of t h e i n c r e a s i n g p a r t i a l sums
Z
m
u 1 x 1
0
$(u) = a
i s the notation for
Ch
.
14,B 1011
s
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
...;un20
u +...+ u (n=1,2, 1 n
=
n
303
for all n)
if t e limitexists. If the normlimit for anincreasing sequence of posi ive elements exists, then norm limit and order limit are identical (Theorem 1 0 0 . 4 ) , s o that in this case no misunderstandings can arise. It may happen,
however, that the order limit exists and the norm limit does not exist. We shall adhere, therefore, to the convention that
C y
denotes an order limit
of positive terms if existing.
The fofozlowing conditions i n the normed Riesz space
LEMMA 101.1.
are equivalent. (i) Lp i s a Banach l a t t i c e . (ii) ~f un E L+
ezists i n
L
PROOF. (i)
n
=
=
I,Z,
m
...
p(un)
and
.
m
Z~ p(un)
<
(sn)
m
p(un)
C1
<
m
. Write
is Cauchy in norm,
is increasing as
s
s
so
n
= u
n
1
u
+...+ u
P
m
, then zI u n
m
* (ii). In the Banach lattice LP , let
l,Z,... and
sequence
n
~ ( z Yun) s c 1
and
P
for
L
n
E L+ p
for
for every
has a norm limit
s
n
. Since
. The s
n
increases, it follows from Theorem 100.4 that
n
m
s = sup s i.e., s = Z u Furthermore, it is evident that n ' 1 n .
(ii)
* (i). We assume now that L
condition (ii). Let that
fn
( g =f
nk
(f )
P
is a normed Riesz space satisfying
converges in norm to an element of
:k=l,2,...)
partial sums
s
of
(fn)
such that
L
P
P
. There
Zy p(gk+]-gk)
<
to show
is a subsequence
, and
m
so the
of
and the partial sums
tn
of
increasing sequences in L+ such that Zp(sn+!-sn) P < w It follows from condtion (ii) that s
Ep(tn+l-tn)
. We have
be a p-Cauchy sequence in L
.
<
m
and
= sup s
and
304
t
=
BANACH LATTICES
sup t
exist s-s
.
By the same argument we have
sup f s -sm) n\ n
=
m
Ch. 14,51011
=
Zkm ,m
(sk+l-sk,
.
But then s-t
and
Similarly
p(t-tm)
+
0
as m
+
m
(gm:m=l,2,...) of
i.e., the subsequence
It follows easily that
fn
(fn)
is the norm limit of
converges in norm to
converges in norm to
L+ P
such that
p(un)
Cy
<
m
exists in L
P
P
.
satisfies the Riesz-
We shall say that the normed Riesz space L
Fischer condition if 17 un
s-t
.
s-t
for every sequence
. Evidently, condition (ii)
(un)
in
in the last lemma
implies the Riesz-Fischer condition. We shall prove that, actually, condition (ii) and the Riesz-Fischer condition are equivalent. In other words,
L
we shall prove that
P
L
is a Banach lattice if and only if
THEOREM 101.2. The normed Riesz space
on23 if L
L
satisfies
P
the Riesz-Fischer condition.
i s a Banach Zattice if and
I,
s a t i s f i e s the Riesz-Fischer condition.
P
PROOF. It is sufficient to show that the Riesz-Fischer condition implies a,
p(CI un)
S
. Assume
m
C 1 p(un)
that for some sequence
fails to be true. Then there exists a number P(CUn) For k
=
1,2,
n l < n2 <
...
satisfy s
>
E +
...
p(u,) , let nk satisfy Cm %+' , which implies that the elements
2 s2 2
times if
n
>
(u,)
in L+
this
0 such that
CP(Un)
... . Arranging all
single order, we get a sequence k
>
E
u 5
. We may
m
sk = Cn
u
assume that (k=l,Z,
k n occurring in all sk
(wl,wz,...)
% . Note that Xp(wi)
< k-2
-2
zk
in which u <
m
,
so
...)
into
occurs at least s = Zw.
exists by
Ch. 14,11011
hypothesis. It is not difficult to see that all k
,
303
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
p(s)
SO
2
k
kp(s ) > k & for all k
.
s = Csk =
l,2,
Hence
... .
s
2
ksk
for
This is impossible.
Hence, the triangle inequality
L h o l d s . This is the desired P
for infinite sums in the positive cone of result.
The theorem that L is a Banach lattice if and only if L satisP P fies the Riesz-Fischer condition is due to I. Halperin and W.A.J. Luxemburg (C11,1956). For normed KGthe spaces, i.e., normed Riesz spaces of
measurable functions on a measure space, this was already mentioned (without proof) in section 9. 5 u
+
P
-
is sometimes called monotone complete if it follows
The space L from 0
and
sup p(un) <
sup u
that
exists in L
P
. It was
proved by I. Amemiya ([21,1953) that monotone completeness implies that L
P
is a Banach lattice. This is now evident since it is immediately clear that monotone completeness implies the Riesz-Fischer condition. Note also that monotone completeness is not equivalent to the Riesz-Fischer condition. The space (c,) of all null sequences, equipped with the uniform norm, is a Banach lattice, but the space is not monotone complete. For brevity, we shall denote the Riesz-Fischer condition by W). We introduce two conditions, called (RF)' and (RF)" respectively, weaker than (W).
(w)'
~f u
n
..
E L+ f o r n = I , 2 , . p u I + ...+u
eZement
u
e Zement
vo E Lo such t h a t
0
such t h a t
LP (W)" If un E L+ P
for
n = 1,2,P.. un i vo
m
, there e x i s t s an
n
.
zp(un) <
m
a d zp(un) for a l l
5 uo
and
for a l l
n
<
.
, t h e r e e x i s t s an
LEMMA 101.3. The conditions ( W ) ' and (RF)" are equiualent. PROOF. It i s sufficient to show that (RF)" implies ( R F ) ' . fore, that (RF)"
holds and let u
n
€
L+ for n
There exist natural numbers n l < n2 <
c i=nk .
p(ui)
5
C.4
-k
...
for all
=
l,?.,..
such that n l k
,
with = 1
Assume, thereXp(un) and
<
m
.
BANACH LATTICES
306
where
C
is a constant satisfying C
to make it possible to choose n
Vk =
c.nk+ 1-I
m
4 E l p(ui)
. For
k
.
The last condition is
= l,Z,
...
, let
.
u.
'="k
I
= 1
t
Ch. 14,51011
Then
so by condition (RF)" there exists an element
for all k k
. Now, for each natural number
n
k E L such that 2 v < v 0 k - 0 there exists a natural number v
such that u
1
+
... +
u
2
v1 +
... + vk '
so 0 2 u1
+
...
+ un
2
. . . + vk <- (*-1+2-2+. ..+z-k)vo
v1 +
5
vo
This shows that ( R F )' holds. It is evident that (RF) implies (€3)'.Indeed, if n
=
,...
1,2
n , where
with
Cp(un)
m
s = E l un
<
m
u
E L+
and (RF) holds, then u +...+ u 1
exists by (€3).If
L
P
for
I s
for all
satisfies the equivalent
conditions ( R F ) ' and (W)", we shall say that L
satisfies the weak Riesz-
Fischer condition. We present two examples of spaces satisfying (RF)', but not (RF). In the first example L is the space of all real continuous functions f on P [O,l] such that the graph of f consists of a finite number of straight is the uniform norm. Note that every non-negative
linesegments; the norm
p
continuous function on
[O,l]
L
P
is the linear subspace of
consisting of all
. In the second example
has a majorant in L Ll([O,l],p)
f E Ll([O,ll,p)
, where
P
p
is Lebesgue measure,
assuming at most countably many different
values. Note that every non-negative
f E L l has a majorant in L . P together with
It will be proved now that (RF) is equivalent to ( R F ) ' relatively uniform completeness.
Ch. 14,51011
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
307
THEOREM 101.4. In the normed Riesz space
L the Riesz-Fischer P condition i s equivalent t o the weak Riesz-Fischer condition together w i t h
r e l a t i v e l y uniform completeness. PROOF. The space L
satisfies (RF) if and only if
P
L
is a Banach
P
lattice and any Banach lattice is uniformly complete by Theorem 100.4(ii). Hence, if (RF) holds, then L
is ru-complete.
P
For the converse, we assume that (RF)' holds and For the proof that (RF) holds, let un E L+
. We
Cp(un) <
for n
P
L P
= 1.2,.
is ru-complete.
..
and
(vk:k=1,2, ...) as in the last
introduce the same elements
lemma and again there exists an element vo
such that vk
. Writing
5
2-kv0
for all
s = v +...+ v for all n , it is evident that (s), is a n l v -uniform Cauchy sequence, so on account of the uniform completeness s 0 n has a v -uniform limit s Then sn converges also in norm to s , so
k
p(s-sn)
.
0
-f
, and since s n is increasing, it follows from Theorem 100.4(i) s , i.e., s = Cvk . But then s is also the supremum of the
0
that s ? n partial sums of the series Zu
n '
so
. This shows that
s = Zu
n
COROLLARY 101.5. If the normed Riesa space
L
P
and s a t i s f i e s the weak Riesz-Fischer condition, then
(RF) holds.
i s Dedekind o-complete L
lattice.
P
i s a Banach
PROOF. It was proved in section 39 that Dedekind o-completeness implies uniform completeness. Any normed Riesz space L a Dedekind completion LA P-
in L-
for all
is Archimedean which implies that in L
p
P
by defining
f- E L-
Actually, p^
.
It is easily seen that p -
is the maximal extension of
any Riesz norm in LA the Riesz norm
p-
THEOREM 101.6. Lo
P
. The norm
that extends
p
,
p
L
has
P
can be extended to a norm
is a Riesz norm in Lin the sense that if
then p l < p - .
p1
The space L-
. is
with
.
will be denoted by
(L-,p-)
The space
i s a Banach l a t t i c e if and only i f
(L-,p^)
s a t i s f i e s the weak Riesz-Fischer condition.
308
(L-,p-)
PROOF. First assume that
satisfies (RF). For the proof that u
with u;
Ch. 14,51011
BANACH LATTICES
n cun
=
E L+
.
for all n
p exists in L-
Since
. Any
therefore, a majorant in L
P
satisfies ( W ) ' .
Conversely, assume that
.
is a Banach lattice, satisfies ( R F ) ' ,
L
P
let Cp(un)
<
m
satisfies (RF), the supremum
(L-,p-)
positive vo
satisfying u" 2 vo
in L
P
.
of all sums u +...+ u 1
Lp
(L-,p")
so
is,
This shows that
satisfies ( R F ) ' and let
<
Zp-(u;l)
LP
with
m
for all n By the definition of p" , there exists for every n an element v E L such that u- 5 v and p(vn) I- p-(u;l) + 2-n n p n n Then Cp(vn) < m , so in view of (RF)' there exists an element v o in L 0 5 u" E L"
.
n
1
.
jorant of all
s"
such that v +. .+vn =
n
the supremum Cu" (RF),
2
vo
for all
n
.
in L- , s o that by the Dedekind completeness l exists in L- . This shows that (L-,p-) satisfies is a Banach lattice.
It is evident from the last theorem that if (L",p")
is now also a ma-
u"+ ...+u-
i.e., ( L - , p - )
then
P
The element vo
L
is a Banach lattice,
P
is likewise a Banach lattice. This is trivially so if
as a Riesz space, is Dedekind complete, since in this case L
It can happen, however, that in
continuous functions on lattice but in
(L-,p^)
L
If
-
L
P
P
of
P
L
.
P
[O,l]
P
is the space C(C0,ll)
of all real
with the uniform norm, then L
is not Dedekind complete,
is a Banach lattice, but
consisting of all
is properly included
P
I.
is not. The norm completion
P
f
in C(C0,ll)
in
P
(L",p-). C(C0,ll)
Lp
is
C(C0,ll)
,
but
L
P
(L",p-)
is
is the sub-
LI~cO,II) consisting of all Lebesgue summable real functions assuming at most countably many different values, the Dedekind
C0,ll
completion LI
P
whose graph consists of a finite number
of linesegments, the norm closure of
with
L
is the subspace of
much larger (cf. Exercise 83.30). In the example in which on
is a Banach
P
L
so
In the example mentioned earlier in which L
space of
'
is a Banach lattice and properly included
may now be identified with the norm closure of
L
.
satisfies the weak (RF)-condition, but not the (RF)-condition,
(L",p")
then
L
. If, for example, LP
(L-,p")
P
(L-,p")
=
P
L
.
(L^,p-)
and the norm closure of
The norm closure L P
L
P
may both be identified
of a normed Riesz space L
identified with a linear subspace of
(L-,p-) . If
real bounded Lebesgue summable functions on
P
may not always be
Lp is the space of all 1 0 , I l , with for P the L 1 -
Ch. 14,51011
norm, then LP is Dedekind complete, so LP so L is now properly larger than (L^,P^) P
the last theorem) L
P
P
. Note
Show that if the norm p
is order continuous (i.e., p(u
Ll([O,ll),
=
P
that (in agreement with
in the normed Riesz space
for any downwards directed system
) C 0
) , then the extension
4 0 in L
, but L-
= (L-,P^)
does not satisfy the weak (RF)-condition.
EXERCISE 101.7.
L
309
NORMBD RIESZ SPACES
to the Dedekind completion L* is unique. In this case L^ is contained in L T
P
of
p-
p
.
P
HINT: Let
0
5
u- E LA
and let
(va:a€{a))
sets of all positive elements in L
and
be the
and wB
t u-
satisfying v
P
(wB:BE{B})
u^
5
respectively. The system of all v -wB is directed downwards. Since sup wB , we have v -w
= u^ =
inf v exist
v
and
a of
For any Riesz norm extension p 1 p-(u-)
are both between p(v,)
Hence
C 0
a B p ( v -w ) <
wB such that
8
to
p
and
,
p(w,)
for any given
so
. Hence
E
L^
,
0
5
the numbers
so
there
> 0
E
p(v,)-p(w,)
< E
.
< E
lp-(u-)-pl(u-)l
.
p l (u^) = p^( u ^ )
.
and
pI(u^)
EXERCISE 101.8. The sequence (f ) in the Riesz space L is said to be n a Cauchy sequence in order if there exists a sequence un C 0 in L such If -f I
that
m
5
n
for all m t n
u
. The space
is said to be order com-
L
p l e t e if every Cauchy sequence in order has an order limit. Show that the following conditions are equivalent (F. Papangelou, [13,1964). (i)
L
is order complete.
(ii) If
, qnC
pn4
s E L
element
HINT: For (i) Cauchy in order m
and any fixed
and
,
=$
so
n
n
=
.
.
.
, we
... . Set
l,Z,
then there exists an
for all n
(ii), let p 4 , qnJ. and qn-pn C 0 Then (p,) n pn 4 s for some s E L Since p, 2 qn for all
s
have
5
q
For (ii) + (i), let for n
,
qn-pn C 0 in L
such that pn5s'q
n
and hence pn
5
s 5 q
for all n
.
If -f I 5 u C 0 for m Z n Then m n q = f +ul . We have also f s f2+u2 1
1
... . Set q2 = inf(ql,f2+uz) . Then n = 2.3, ... . Furthermore f 5 f3+u3 for n n q3 = inf(qz,f3+u3) . Then q3 5 q2 and f 5 n
q2
n = 2,3,
5
q1 and
q3
f
... . Set
= 3,4,
is
f
i
f +u
5
q2
for
n for
1
.
1
... . Proceed
for n = 3,4,
.
f i q for m 2 n Similarly we find n m n From q -p 5 2u it follows that Pn4 such that fm Z pn for m 2 n n n n qn-pn C 0 By hypothesis, there exists s E L such that pn 5 s 5 qn for by induction. We get
q C
and
.
all n
. Finally, we
derive from pn
.
5
fn i qn
that
Is-fnl
5 qn-pn
J
0
,
BANACH
310
fn
so
converges in order to
EXERCISE 101.9. Let such that the distance
s
nu&
Ch. 14,81021
.
T be a metric topology in the Riesz space L
d(f,g)
between
f
and
by means of the formula d(f,g)
pseudonorm q
g
=
is given by the Riesz
f
=
0
. The
. Since the topology
q(f-g)
is a metric topolcgy, if is assumed therefore that
q(f)
=
0
holds only for
T in Exercise 100.20 is an example. Assume further-
topology
more that one at least of the following conditions holds: 0 < u
(i)
number
in L
4 u
> 1
CL
implies q(un)
such that
metric space
(L,T)
q(2f) 2 aq(f)
<
or
q(u)
m
EXERCISE 101.10.
.
exists in L
(ii) there exists a fixed
. Show that
f E L
for all q
is complete if and only if
Fischer condition, i.e., cun satisfying Cq(un)
+
the
satisfies the Riesz
for any sequence
in L+
(un)
i s a Banach lattice
Show that if the Riesz space L
with respect to two different norms, then these norms are equivalent. HINT: Note that by Theorem 83.12 the identity mapping in L
is con-
tinuous in both directions.
102. The Banach dual Let
p
be a Riesz seminorm in the Riesz space L
functional $ such that
on L
l$(f)l
. The real linear
is called p-bounded if there exists a number M t 0
5 Mp(f)
for all
f E L
.
The smallest number M
fying this condition is called the p-bound of
$
and is denoted by
satis-
,
p*($)
so
The set N A(Cf1)
P
= (f:p(f)=O)
in L/Np
f l and
f2
and so
A([f])
in the same equivalence class Efl = p(f)
. Since p(f , we
have
-f 2 ) = 0
1
for all
p(fl) = p(fZ)
,
. It will cause no A(Cf1) . Any p-bounded
for any arbitrary chosen f E If]
confusion, therefore, if we write linear functional $
; the quotient seminorm
is a p-closed ideal in L
is therefore a norm in L/Np
p(Cf])
instead of
gives rise immediately to a norm bounded linear func-
tional on L/Np , denoted likewise by
$
, and defined by
$ ( c f ] ) = $(f)
,
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
Ch. 14,51021 where
f
is again arbitrarily chosen from
[f]
31 1
.
The number
, de-
p*($)
fined above, may then just as well be written as
The set L*
of all p-bounded linear functionals on L may be identified,
P
by these arguments, with the set of all p-bounded linear functionals on the normed Riesz space L/Np to
as norm. If p
p*
Banach duaZ of
. As
well-known, L* P
is a Riesz norm in L
,
(L,p)
use the name also if p-bound of
$
, will
i s a Riesz seminorm in
is called the
P
(L/NQ-,p)
L
. In this
. The number
also be referred to as the norm of
Theorem 85.4 the space L*
$
(L,p)
O*($)
L"
shall
. Note
, the that by
is not identically zero. As before, the order dual of
be denoted by
. We
case, therefore,
contains nonzero elements if and only if the
P
seminorm p
then L*
also sometimes the a d j o i n t space of
P
L* is actually the Banach dual of P
is a Banach space with respect
,
.
LEMMA 102.1. If 0 < $ E L"
L
will
, then
where both s i d e s may be i n f i n i t e . I t foZZows t h a t i f
0 < $ E L"
and
$
is
p-bounded, then
Hence, i f P*($)
5
0 < $
P*(JI)
.
$
and
$
i s p-bounded, then
$
is p-bounded and
PROOF. Denoting the suprema in the first formula to be proved by r
respectively, it is evident that 1 < r
LEMMA 102.2. I f and
P*(l$l)
= P*($)
4 E L*
.
P '
then
$ E L"
1 and
. On the other hand, we have
. In
addition, we have
141 E Lp*
312
PROOF. Let
$
E Lp* and u E
we have to prove that l$(f)l
,
5 P*($).P(U)
L+
.
To show that
sup(lb(f)l:lfl
4
is a member of
is finite. For
If1 < u
L"
we have
so
(
< p*($).p(u)
SUP l$(f)I:Ifl<") Having proved thus that u
Ch. 14,§102]
BANACH DUAL
$
<
m
.
E L" , it follows that
1$1
exists. For any
E L+ we have
so
On account of the preceding lemma it follows from this formula that 141 E LE l$(f>l
and
p*(l$l)
I$l(lfl)
5
2 p*($)
. Conversely, it is evident from
~ ~ ( 5$ ~*(14.i) 1
that
.
The following theorem extends Theorem 85.6.
THEOREM 102.3 (i) LE is an i d e a l in L" (ii)
The space
L*
P '
s t r u c t u r e i n h e r i t e d from R i e s z norm in L* =
.
P
, but not necessarily a band.
as a Rie sz space on i t s own (with t h e order L" ), is Dedekind complete, t h e nom
and it follows from 0 < $
+
4 E L*
p*
that
P
sup P*($,) (iii) If p
p*($)
is a =
i s a Riesz norm in L and the nomed Riesz space In p a r t i c u l a r , has the weak Riesz-Fischer property, then L* = L" (L,p) P if ( ~ , p ) is a Banach Zattive, then L; = L"
.
.
PROOF. (i) It was proved in the last lemma that L*
L"
. To prove
JI E L" have
and
$
that
E LE
L*
P
is an ideal in L"
. We must prove
, assume
that Jl E LE
P
that
. By
is contained in
lJll
S
1$1
with
the last lemma we
1 $ 1 E LE , and so $+ and Jl- are members of L*P by Lemma 102.1 5 I$\ and J, < j $ l ) . It follows that JI E L* . P For an example that L* is an ideal in L" , but not a band, let L
(since J',
be the Riesz subspace of
P
consisting of all sequences f
=
(fl,f2 , . . . )
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
Ch. 14,51021
f # 0 for only finitely many k m Let $(f) = Clkfk for f E L
with
.
in L
linear functional on L , but n let $,(f) = Ck,] kfk for n and
+
$
$
k , and let
. Then
be the uniform norm
p
$ E L" since $
is a positive
is evidently not p-bounded. Furthermore,
$
= l , 2 , ... . Then 0 5 $ E L* n p . This shows that L*P is not a band in
in L"
(ii) The space L* SO
313
for all n L"
.
,
is an ideal in the Dedekind complete space L"
P
is Dedekind complete. Combining the results in the Lemmas 102.1 and
L* P
102.2 we see that
+p
u E L
(and hence in L" ) . For any
in L* P
Therefore, i f
p(u)
. Finally, let
is a Riesz norm in L*
p*
5 1
0
4 $
5 $
$ ( u ) = sup $,(u)
we have
.
, then
so
The inverse inequality is evident. Hence (iii) Let
Riesz-Fischer property and assume that Then there exists a positive $ 2
n3
for n
=
1,2
=
sup P * ( $ ~ )
such that
L"
(L,p)
.
has the weak P
such that
(u,)
,... . Writing
vn
-2
n
=
un
$
, we get ~p(v,)
<
5 w
tisfying v
for all
n
. But
then
.
= L"
$(w)
2
$(vn)
2
n
.
,
m
so by the weak Riesz-Fischer condition there exists an element w E L
which is impossible. Hence L*
.
is properly larger than L*
fails to be in L* P in L+ we have p(un) < 1 and
in L"
It follows that for some sequence $(un)
P*($)
be a Riesz norm in L
p
sa-
for all n
,
We recall Theorem 85.5 according to which any positive linear functional J, all that
on a Riesz subspace
K
of
L , satisfying
l$(f)/
f E K , can be extended to a positive linear functional $ l$(f)l
2
p(f)
for all
linear functional $ functional $ P-bound of
$
on
. As
L
on
K
f E L
.
for
5 p(f)
on
L
such
It follows that any positive p-bounded
can be extended to a positive p-bounded linear
such that the p-bound of
$
is the same as the
a corollary, we immediately have the following lemma.
LEMMA 102.4. If the Riesz seminorm p i s not i d e n t i c a l l y zero, there e x i s t s f o r alzy u E L+ a p o s i t i v e $ i n L* such t h a t P * ( + ) = 1 and $ ( u ) = P(U)
.
P
314
BANACH DUAL
PROOF. If p(u)
=
, then
0
$(u) = 0
Ch. 14,01021
$ E L* P
for any
, and
so
any
positive $ in L* of unit norm satisfies the condition. If p(u) > 0 , P we define the positive linear functional J, on the Riesz subspace of all real multiples i s one and
$
au
of
u
. Any
$ ( u ) = p(u)
.
$(au) = ap(u)
by
Evidently, the p-bound of
positive extension $
of
with the
$
same p-bound satisfies the required conditions. We proceed with a lemma showing that a monotone sequence converging weakly
zcro converges to zero in seminorm.
co
LEMMA 102.5. (i) If 0 5 u + i n L , then @(un) + 0 f o r every $ E L* n P i f and only i f p(un) 4 0 . is a downwards d i r e c t e d s e t of p o s i t i v e eZements (ii) If (u?:T€{T}) in L , then $ ( u ) 4 0 f o r every p o s i t i v e $ in L* if and only i f
+
P(UJ
P
.
0
P(U ) 4 0 implies $(un) + 0 for every n For the proof in the converse direction, we denote as before the
PROOF. (i) It is evident that $
.
E L*
P
elements of the quotient space L/NP by
... .
Cf],[g],
By hypothesis the
(Cunl:n=1,2, ...) converges to zero in the weak topology (i.e.,
sequence
in the topology o(L/N ,L*) ) . According to a theorem of S. Mazur this P P implies that the null element C O ] is contained in the closure of the convex hull of the set
(Cull,[u21,
a natural number m p ( C m A.[u I
that
i
p(Cy
p(un)
so
i
1)
. Since
i E
Aiui) <
i E
...) . Hence, if X I , . . . ,A m
and numbers
E
> 0
for every
p(f) = p(Cf1) n 2 m we have
. For
for all
E
is given, there exist
(05Ai51, Z y Ai=l
)
such that
f E L , this implies
.
n 2 m
We present an alternative proof which does not make use of Mazur’s theorem. The proof is due to E. de Jonge and A.C.M. van Rooy (Theorem 11.2 of [1],1977).
Note first that on the space (c) of all convergent sequences
...
f = (fl,f2, ) with the uniform norm the linear functional $(f) = lim fn is positive and of norm one, s o J, can be extended to a positive linear functional Y 0
2
u 4
in L
on
lmsuch that
and
$(un)
+
0
Y
is of unit norm. Now assume that
for every
$
E L;
, but
P(U
) 2
n
(x
> 0
Ch. 14,51021
for all n
. By
the last lemma there exists for each u
functional $n E LE f
315
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
E L we have
such that
I$n(f)l
I. p(f)
P*($~) = 1
,
so
and
$,(un)
($](f) , $ 2 ( f ) , . . . )
a positive linear =
. For each
p(un)
is a member of
.
Let
Then 0
so
0
s
5 $
0 E L"
$
E L* and
O
and
P*($J~) 5 1
P
.
. Now, let the natural number
Note first that We make an estimate for $ (u ) O k n t k since u i and $, is positive. Hence n
This implies that $o(uk) t a $,(u,)
+
k
0 as
.
+ m
for all k
$,(uk)
t
k
On(un)
be fixed. for
, contradicting the hypothesis
It follows, therefore, that p(un)
J. 0
.
that
(9;) Analogously. =:L @ L z and L" = L';I n 0:L , are the bands of all integrals and all normal integrals
In section 87 we have seen that L" where L"
and Ln
respectively and their disjoint complements are the bands of all singular linear functionals and all normal singular linear functionals. Taking intersections with
Lz
and omitting
L* = :L L* =
n
N
Ln
n
n
, we
p
set
L*
,
L;
L*
,
L ; ~= L~~ n L*
=:L N
n L* ,
.
316
Ch. 14,51021
BANACH DUAL
(i) The s e t s
THEOREM 102.6.
bands i n
and
L;,L;,L;
are i d e a l s i n L"
LEn
and
such t h a t
L*
L*
=
L* 8 L* c s
=
L* e L* n s n
(ii) The band p r o j e c t i o n s i n
are norm bounded operators i n N
PROOF. (i) Since Lc
.
L* is an ideal in L"
on the bands
L*
Lgn
and
Lr,L:,L:
of norm a t most one.
L*
and
.
are ideals in L" , their intersection
L*
Similarly for LE,L*
""
. For
the proof that
L* 8 L* , note first that for any $ E L we have the unique decompoc s sition $ = Qc+$is with $c E L z and $s € L z It is sufficient to show
L*
=
.
Qc
now that dent if
and
are members of
$s
.
This implies that
(where it was proved that that A
8
and LEn
B
=
bounded and
and : L
are bands in L*
B
and
L* , let P IIPclI
5
llIll
e
5
and M
J
f E L
subset D
such that
Similarly, Lan(D)
L*
L* c
. It has 8
that
0 implies inflTu I
La(D)
which every
and
. For
Lb
Lan(D)
T E D
and
Lzn
=
:L
Pc
is norm
*
are Riesz spaces (with M
of
Lb
If1 2 u
the set La(D)
=
consists
C 0 implies
is the set of all
0 for every T E D
f E L
Tu -+ 0 for n such that
(here
(u~:T€{T))
that
D
this case, the main result in Theorem 88.13 states are ideals in L , the largest ideals in L
on
is o-order continuous or order continuous respectively.
Furthermore, La(D) = La (DflLs) and to the case that M
L* s
. Denoting the
L:
is a downwards directed system). We shall be interested in the case is an ideal in
.
S $
Lb is the space of all order bounded operators from
. For any non-empty .
is evi-
by one of the remarks made in section 100.
= 1
L
TE D
Q
by Theorem 24.1
I , so
P
We recall Theorem 88.13 in which into M
5
. The proof for
be the band projection on
, :L
by definition of all
0
such that
are bands in L )
L;
Dedekind complete) and
. This
if A and B are ideals in the Riesz space L such
L , then A
Similarly for the band projections on
If1 t u
and
is similar.
(ii) I n
every
E L*
$
are ideals in L*
identity operator in L* by I , we have
L
$
<
L;
and
L;
5 $
is an arbitrary element of
$
By linearity the same follows if been proved thus that Lr L*
L* whenever
is positive since in this case 0
$
Lan(D)
=
Lan (DnLsn)
. Specializing
is the space of real numbers, the space
Lb is the
Ch. 14,81021 order dual
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
. Assume now
L"
we choose t h e i d e a l L~
and
that
in
L*
c a r r i e s a Riesz seminorm
L
and we denote
L"
317
La(L*)
and
. For
p
D
L ~ ~ ( L *by )
r e s p e c t i v e l y . A s a r e s u l t we g e t t h e following theorem a s a
Lan
s p e c i a l case of Theorem 88.13. THEOREM 102.7. t u
+o
s e t of a l l
. Then
on which every
Furthermore, we have
o
+
f o r every
If1 2 u
+
f
4 E L* implies
0
E L such t h a t L~~
and l e t
)I
infl$(u
be the for
= 0
are i d e a l s i n L , t h e Zargest i d e a l s
Lan
La and
is an i n t e g r a l o r a normal i n t e g r a l r e s p e c t i v e z y .
E L*
$
be the s e t of a l l
La
implies $(un) E L such t h a t
f
C$ E L*
evew
( i ) Let
, i.e.,
La = La(Lz)
La
i s the largest i d e a l on which
every singular l i n e a r functional is an i n t e g r a l . Similarly, we have
.
L~~ = L ~ ~ ( L ~ ~ )
( i i ) We have
and only if
L:
La = L
= L*
.
if and only if
PROOF. Only p a r t ( i i ) n e e d s proof. I f
an i n t e g r a l on
4 E L*
La = L
,
i s an i n t e g r a l on
so L
$
E
,
so
L*,
La = L
. Conversely,
L~ = L
. Similarly,
L* = L*
.
, then
every
if
= L*
L:
For t h e next theorem we r e c a l l t h a t f o r any subset annihilator
Ao
of
A
i s t h e s e t of a l l
$
C$ E L
,
of
A
such t h a t
E L"
Lan = L
*
if
is
then every
L
the
$ ( f ) = 0. f o r
E A and f o r any subset B of L" t h e i n v e r s e a n n i h i l a t o r OB of B i s t h e s e t of a l l f E L such t h a t $ ( f ) = 0 f o r a l l $ E B .
all
f
THEOREM 102.8.
In other words, La continuous and
L~~
( i ) We have
is t h e l a r g e s t i d e a l i n L on which P i s the largest i d e a l i n L
continuous. ( i i ) La = ' ( I , : ) PROOF.
and
Lan = O(Lgn)
on which
P
i s o-order i s order
.
( i ) Follows by combining t h e d e f i n t i o n s of
LeDnM 102.5 according t o which, i f i t i s given t h a t
0
La S u
+
and
, we
Lan
have
with
318
@(un) if
Ch. 14,51021
BANACH DUAL
0
+
0 for every
5
u
@
E L*
if and only if
B
n
).
(ii) Follows from Theorem 88.13(iii); called
p(u ) J
in Theorem 88.13(iii)
l L*
by 'A 0
annihilator
and to denote for any subset B
. Hence
B by B'
(and similarly
note that the ideal which is
is now the ideal L*
It is convenient to denote for any subset A 'A
0
of
of
in L" L L*
.
the intersection the inverse
Note that part (ii) of the last theorem may now be formulated by saying that La = '(LE)
and
Lan =
I
(L:n)
. This implies immediately that
are norm closed. Note also that seminorm p
'(L*)
= {O)
if and only if B
points of
L
p
,
so
L
,
then L*
(X,A,u)
-.
sarily o-finite, and let L = L = L ( X , k , p ) P P 1 C p < Let p be the familiar P is order continuous. For the proof, observe then the subset of X
and so all
u
B
L
of
L*
itself separates the
is a norm.
p
We mention some examples. Let fying
Lan
separates the points of
is a norm. Of course, if there exists a subset
separates the points of
and
if and only if the Riesz
is a Riesz norm. In other words, L*
such that
La
on which
If(x)l
be a measure space, not neces-for some value of
.
vanish outside this subset. It follows that
a decreasing subsequence
(u,)
p
saiis-
L -norm in L The norm p P P P that if If1 2 u J 0 in L P' > 0 holds is of o-finite measure, (U~:T
IT))
has
converging to zero. Then
X and so
p (u,)
J 0
for the given downwards directed set. It is evident now
that LanP= L and so L* = L* (which implies immediately that La P P' P PI" P L* = L* ) . As well-known, L? may be identified with L , where P PYC P 9 is determined by p-'+q-l = 1
and
=
q
.
If the measure space does not have any atoms, then :L seen from part (i) of the last theorem. It follows that
= {O),
{ O } = :L
=
L
P
as easily
I
(L* ) , -9
s
Ch.
14,11021
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
319
.
On the other i.e., Lt,, is large enough to separate the points of La is not so large as to be equal to L z , because each function hand, Lz ,S by means of in L, determines an element @ of L*
@(f)
1
=
C
-3
fg dp
.
f E La
for all
X
If the measure space is o-finite, then L*
m,
with
L1
c
may actually be identified
I
Finally, if Lan
then La
L
is the sequence space
(co)
=
.
La
It was proved above that under whish, conversely, (La)*
=
=
l
Lz
(LE)
and
La with the uniform
norm
p
,
.
and Lan = '(LZn) Conditions an I (L ) = Lgn are therefore of
interest. THEOREM 102.9. (i) We have
members o f
LE
a l (L )
=
: L
if and only if d i f f e r e n t
have d i f f e r e n t r e s t r i c t i o n s t o
if Lz is o(L*,L) topology of L*I.
La and a l s o if and only
closed ( t h a t is t o say, : L
i s closed i n t h e weak s t a r
(Lan)l = L* if and only if d i f f e r e n t members o f :L sn have d i f f e r e n t r e s t r i c t i o n s t o Lan and a l s o if a n d only i f Lfn i s (ii) We have
u(L*,L)
closed.
PROOF. (i) The proof that members of
:L
(La)*
=.L:
holds if and only if different
have different restrictions to
is very similar to the
La
proof in Theorem 88.9, where it was shown that
(La)'
=
Ls
holds if;.and
only if different members of Lc have different restrictions to The proof that (La ) l = : L holds if and only if Lz is o(L*,L) follows from Theorem 98.3(ii), general assertion) that the
where it was shown o(L*,L)
closure of
La
.
closed
(as part of a more
L;
is
P(L:)I* .
(ii) Similarly.
In the next theorem it will be shown that the condition that (L ) La
= L*
holds is related to order denseness or super order denseness of
. The sheorern is
similar to Theorem 88.10, but it is not a special case
of that theorem.
THEOREM 102.10.
(i) I f
La is super order dense i n L
, then
320
Ch. 14,51021
BANACH DUAL
a 1 (L ) a l (L )
then
.
Lg
=
is a norm and La is super order dense i n L , then I = LH and (L;) = I01 . (iiij ~n the converse d i r e c t i o n , if (L~)' = L; and *(L:) = 101, (ii) I f
P
i s order dense i n L (we may n o t expect t h a t
La
i s super order
La
dense in L ; ef. Exercise 102.22). PROOF. (i) Assume that (La)'
show that
to showing that if a member $ E Lr
Hence, let
i s super order dense in
La
L
. We have
to
LE holds, which by the preceding theorem is equivalent
=
and
of
$
$(f)
= 0 . . For every positive
vanishes on La , then $
L;
f E La
0 for all
=
v E La we have
and since
If1
v E La
S
. Hence
satisfying
If/ 5 v
I$/
for every
(u) = 0
implies f E La
hypothesis a sequence
/ $ I (v)
E L+
u
(un)
(u,)
. We
u E L+
in La
just established we have
0
=
. If
, we
=
have $(f)
such that
0
0 for all
5 u
4 u
E :L
$
$(u) = 0
for all
0
2
u
0
5
$ E Lr
$(un) u
4 u
n
= 0
E La
=
s:tisfying so
u
, we
u $
0
. By
5 $
E L*
0 for all
n
. Hence, assume
.
. Since 0
for
satisfying 0 and for all n
. On
that
$(u) = 0
5 $
5 $
(La)d # { O }
u
= {O}
) and = {O}
u E L+
u E L+
E La ) .
161 ( u )
and
0.
=
La
. In
$(u) = 0
satisfies
.
. Then
(La)d
$(un)
But '(L*)
L
for every
$
satisfying
E L* and all n . Also E L: and all n (since
account of 0 i u a l (L ) = Lz and '(Lry
is a norm, which implies that Assume
5
. Hence $ = 0 .
hypothesis there exists a sequence
in La
=
+
u
=
{O}
=
0 for every $
I01 by hypothesis,
it follows that
. Then
*(L*)
u = 0
=
.
is Archimedean. To show that La
is order dense, we have to show therefore that = {O}
By the result
have to show only that ):L('
). By addition it follows that
;iii) Assume that i.e., p
=
$(un) = 0
have
for every
I(L:)
u
$ E L*
with all
0
=
, then
.
n (since 0
view of Lemma 88.3 it is sufficient to show that if for all
f
shall prove now that
/ $ I (u,) 1. (u) since l $ l E L*, This holds for every u E L+ , so l $ l = 0 , and hence (ii) Assume that p is a norm (equivalently, '(L*)
. We
0 for all
is given, there exists by
Furthermore, we have
is super order dense in L
=
(La)dd = L , i.e., (La)d
contains a nonzero positive
=
.
Ch. 1 4 , 5 1 0 2 1
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
.
element u
It follows then from
@ E
'(L*)
.
32 1
that
= {O}
@(u) > 0
for some
If necessary, we may replace $ by the minimal positive linear extension of $ 1 (La)d , so we may assume that @ vanishes on
positive
L :
, which implies that $
E (La)'
.
LE
=
.
$(u) > 0
Hence
$
vanishes certainly on
@
E Lr n Lz (La) d #
=
It follows that
I01 ,
so
@ =
La
. This
0 , which contradicts
.is impossible, and so
{O}
shows that (La)d
=
{O}.
(i) If Lan is order dense i n L , t h e n (Lan)' = L&. is order dense in L and p is a nomi if and only if and '(L;) = 101 .
THEOREM 102.11. (ii) =
Lan
zzn
PROOF. Similarly. a l
L~ = L~~ . (ii) ~f (L ) = holds, t h e n t h e converse o f t h e above statement holds a s w e l l . In = Lz o t h e r words, i f (La)' = , t h e n La = Lan if and onZy if = L; I n t h i s ease, ( i . e . , if a l l t h e s e c o n d i t i o n s are s a t i s f i e d ) , t h e c o n d i t i o n
(i) L*
COROLLARY 102.12.
=
LE i m p l i e s
.
(Lan)'
=
is also s a t i s f i e d .
Lgn
PROOF. (i) L* c
=
L* n
implies L* s
=
L* sn
(by taking disjoint comple-
ments), so La
=
'(LE)
=
:L
.
=
Lan
.
.
a 1 We have to show that (L ) = :L Note first that L : n , so : cL
(ii) Let
=
I(Lgn)
an1 (L )
=
a 1 (L) =LZcL* sn
La = Lan
implies L*
.
On the other hand, the inverse inclusion
an 1 is always true. Hence (L ) - LEn LZ and so
L* c
=
=
L* n
(La)*
=
, which
(Lan) I = LZn
immediately implies
,
(by taking disjoint complements).
=
322
BANACH DUAL a l (L )
The condition that of the Banach dual of
La
.
Ch. 14,51023
Lz holds is also related to the structure
=
Since the ideal N
P
(fEL:p(f)=O)
=
La , it may be assumed for the investigation of
of
(La)*
is a subset
that
is a
p
norm. We shall need the fact, well-known from general Banach space theory, that if
A
let
$I
V*/A'
$I E
A*
Conversely, if such that
lence class and
A
and let 0 -
V*/A'
4
and
.
of A*
N
O1 =
and
Q1
Q2 , s o every N
It follows from
O2
0-
have the same norm, N
0- satisfies
110
11 <
11011 =
so
11@11.
con-
have the same
E V*/A'
uniquely
that
11$I11 5 11011
i s given, there exists an extension O
,
0 E V*
be the member of
is the equivalence class modulo 'A
if and only if $I
V
to
as one of its elements). Note that
determines a member
A*
0
Q (i.e,, @-
containing
restriction to A
V*
then A*
are isomorphic. We briefly recall the proof. For any
be the restriction of
taining 0
,
is a linear subspace of the normed vector space V
and V*/Al
0
of
in
$I
the corresponding equivaThe corespondence between
is therefore one-one and norm preserving. Note now that if
is a normed Riesz space and A
is an ideal in V , then 'A
closed ideal in the Banach lattice V* , so the quotient V*/A'
is a norm is
a
Banach lattice with respect to the quotient norm. Furthermore, 0- E V*/A' is positive if and only if the corresponding $I E A* shows now that A*
and V*/Al
is positive. This
are not only isomorphic as Banach spaces
but they are Riesz isomorphic as well. Applying the above result to L*/(La)'
tified, therefore, with
It follows from La a l implies that (L ) of
Lr
= '(LE) =
B
8
consisting of all
that LE
La , the Banach dual
can be iden-
, so
(La)'
, where
@ E L*
(La)*
B
. Since
L* , this c s is the norm closed linear subspace
3
Lf
which vanish on
La
L*
= L*
. Hence, formula
can be written as
from which it follows that, algebraically (i.e., norms),
not yet looking at the
(I)
Ch. 14,51021
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
(2)
(La)*
=
323
.
L:/B
The last equality holds also isometrically (i.e., in norm). To see this, let $ Q~
Qc+$s
=
Q E L*
be the decomposition of an arbitrary
into
E Lz and Q S E Lz and let Pc be the band projection on L*,
Qc = Pc$
(ii)),
so
L*/(La)l
.
The operator norm of
satisfies
Q
that if we replace an element
QC
and
$
Lr/B
,
,
so
/IPcII 2 1 (by Theorem 102.6
in some equivalence class of
by the corresponding element $c
equivalence class of that
Pc
=
PcQ
in the corresponding
then the norm is not increased. Note now also
are contained in the same equivalence class of
Combining these facts, it follows that any equivalence class of has the same norm as the corresponding equivalence class of
L : / ( L a ) ' . L*/(La)*
Lr/B
.
It i s now an easy matter to prove the following theorem. a l
THEOREM 102.13. We have
(L )
=
LE
i f and only i f
i d e n t i f i e d (algebraically and i s o m e t r i c a l l y ) w i t h PROOF. It is evident from and only if
B
. Comparing
= {O}
a l (L )
=
BeLZ
can be
= Lg
holds if
.
Lr
that
(La)*
(La)'(La)*
the condition that
and
L*, can be
identified with the condition that formula (2) above holds, it is evident that
(La)*
=
L*
holds if -and only if
and only if (L~) *
.
L*,
=
B = I01
. Hence
(La)'
=
Lz
if
The proof of the next theorem is similar. THEOREM 102.14. We have
(Lan)'
=
L:~ i f and onZy i f
Let
L
P
L+iL
,
let p(f)
norm in L+iL
and
g
,
p
be a Riesz seminorm in L
. Then
is a p-closed and uniformly closed ideal in L
= (fEL:p(f)=O)
f E
can be
be Archimedean and uniformly complete. Consequently, L+iL
mits absolute values. Let N
(LBn)*
.
i d e n t i f i e d ( a l g e b r d e a l Z y and i s o m e t r i c a l l y ) w i t h :L
be defined by
an extension of the seminorm
in L+iL
satisfying
Ifi 4 lgl
appropriate, therefore, to say that p is easy to see that the set of all exactly the ideal N +iN P
P
and that
. Then
p ( f ) = p(/fl)
f
p
we have
in
L
p(f)
,
p
ad-
. For
is a semi-
such that for f p(g)
. It is
is a Riesz seminorm in L+iL in L+iL satisfying p(f)
= 0
. It is
324
Ch. I 4 , § 1 0 2 1
BANACH DUAL
(L+iL)*
P
=
{ (L+iL)/(N
+iN ) p
(L/N )* + i(L/N ) * P P
P P
$ E (L+iL)* P
For
=
the number
=
>*P
=
L* + iL* P
P
is defined by
p*($)
l$(f)l:fEL+iL,p(f)
is a norm in
(L+iL)*
P
and
wfth respect to the norm p * . We prove that
(L+iL)*
is a Banach space
P
is a Riesz norm. I n the
p*
first place, note that lemma 102.1 can be complexified, that is to say, if
0
5 $
E Lp*
,
then $(u):uEL+,p(u)
(1)
=
$
is complex, s o
:fEL+iL,p(f)
1$(f)l s $ ( l f l )
The proof follows by observing that Assume now that
sup( l$(f)l
$ E L*+iL* P P
for all
, and let
= p*($)
f E L+iL
u E L+
. Then,
.
by one of the formulas near the end of section 92,
so
Hence, by formula ( I ) ,
we get
from
l $ ( f ) l < 1$1(lfl)
p*($)
= p*(l$l)
Omitting
.
p
p*(l$l)
for all
p*($)
f E L+iL
that
It follows immediately that
, it follows from L*
=
L*c
.
(B
p*
L* s
Conversely, it is evident p*($)
5
@*(/$I)
. Hence
is a Riesz norm. that
Similarly (L+iL)* R o r any
$ E
(L+iL)*
=
(L*+iL*) n n
, let
(B
(L:n+iL:n)
$ = $,+$,
. be the decomposition of
$
into a
Ch. 14,51021
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
325
0-order continuous and a singular linear functional. Writing and
0,
Lr+iLr
=
Ps$
,
the operators Pc and Ps
and L*+iL* s s
respectively. On account of
I l $ s l we have This implies that
$ c = Pc$ are the band projections on
I $ / = /$,I
P*($~)
the operator norms of
Pc
Similarly we find that
,
+
and
5 p*($)
and Ps
/\Pnll5 1
5
and
/ $ I and
.
I p*($)
p*($,)
satisfy
llPcll
llPsnll
with
$ = $c+$s
so
5
IIPs/l
Pn
(fEL+iL: I f 1 >uT+0 implies p ( u l ) ~ o )
For any subset D
of
L+iL
,
the subset 'D
of
.
1
5
.
and Psn
are the barid projections on L*+iL* and L* +iL2n respectively. n n sn It is easy to see that the complexifications of La and Lan
=
141
5
It follows that
and
, where
I
5
1
/$,I
satisfy
. (L+iL)*
is defined
exactly as in the real case by 'D
=
($E(L+iL)*:$(f)=O
Similarly, for E
a subset of
).
for all fED (L+iL)*
, the subset
b
of
L+iL
is
and any subset B
of
defined by
It is easy to see that for any subset A
of
L
L*
we have (A+iA)*
=
A* + i A '
, '(B+iB)
=
%+
i%
,
wherethe terms on the right are to be understood in the original real sense (i.e., AI c L* and % c L ) . In particular, it follows from I(LE) = La and '(Lm) = Lan that
326
BANACH DUAL *(L*+iL*) s
=
s
J-(L* +iL* sn sn
Ch. 14,§1021
L~ + iLa ,
Lan + iLan
=
.
a 1 (L )
Several conditions under which
=
Lz or
an 1 (L )
=
Lgn
holds were
mentioned in this section. We leave it to the reader to complexify these conditions. As observed in the real case, one of the conditions for a l (L ) = Lz to hold is that Lz is o(L*,L) closed (that is to say, weak star closed). The proof (in Theorem 102.9) was derived from Theorem 89.3(ii) closure of
by observing that the a(L*,L)
Lz
is '})zL('{
. Note
that
Theorem 89.3 holds as well in the complex case, i.e., the o{(L+iL)*,L+iL) closure of
Lz+iLz
is
L be the space of all real continuous functions
EXERCISE 102.15. Let
11 with norm p(f) = 1 If Idx for all f E L 1 The positive linear functional $o on L is defined by $O(f) = fdx on the closed interval
for all
f E L
on L
. Let
LO,
x
E C0,ll
0
be defined by
$x (f)
and let the positive linear functional f(xo)
=
for all
0
OX0
f E L
. Show that
is dis-
are disjoint in L" and derive from this that and $, $XO $XO This implies that L* is not order dense in Ljoint from L*
.
that if
Ox
x 1 # xo
$x (f)
and
=
f(xl)
for all
1
are disjoint.
.
f E L , then $
X
. 1
Show and
0
a l EXERCISE 102.16. (i) In Theorem 102.10 it was proved that if (L ) = 1 an l ( L : ) = ( 0 ) , then La is order dense. Similarly, if (L ) = = L* and 1 1 ) : L ( = I01 , then Lan is order dense. Show that if = Lzn and (Lr) = = { O ) (or
I
) : L (
= {O} )
does not hold, then La
(or Lan ) is not
necessarily order dense. a 1 (ii) In Corollary 102.12 it was proved that if (L ) = LE and a an an 1 La = Lan , then :L = L* Show that if (L ) = Lzn and L = L n .it may occur that :L # :L .
.
,
then
HINT: For (i), see Exercise 88.15. For (ii), see Exercise 88.16. EXERCISE 102.17. jection property. If
(i) Let the Riesz space L
...)
r E (B :n=l,2,
have the principal pro-
i s a sequence of principal projec-
Ch. 1 4 , 51021
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
B
t i o n bands s a t i s f y i n g
,
4 Bo
where
i s likewise a p r i n c i p a l projec-
Bo
t i o n band, w e s h a l l s a y t h a t t h e sequence f
E
Bo
E
1
.
J 0
p(fin) C 0
g e n e r a t e d by
IT
f E L
.
. We
f
i s a R i e s z seminorm i n
p
+
B
...)
. Show
Da
Show t h a t i n t h i s c a s e
L
that
Bf
i s t h e p r i n c i p a l band b e t h e s e t of
Da
L
( i i i ) Assume a g a i n t h a t
i s a RBesz seminorm i n
C 0
p(f;,)
L
.
.
Da = La
i s t h e s e t of a l l
La
p r o j e c t i o n bands e x h a u s t i n g
(B
, where
Bf
possess a f i n i t e o r countable order b a s i s .
h o l d s f o r e v e r y i n c r e a s i n g sequence
IT 5
f
E
L
C 0
such t h a t p(f;n)
E ( B : n = 1 , 2 , . . . ) of
IT
principal
itself. h a s t h e p r i n c i p a l p r o j e c t i o n p r o p e r t y and
L
. Show
that
Lan
i s t h e s e t of a l l
h o l d s f o r e v e r y upwards d i r e c t e d system
of p r i n c i p a l p r o j e c t i o n bands s a t i s f y i n g
:7€{7))
and
,so
p ( f ' ) C 0 hoZds f o r e v e r y i n c r e a s i n g sequence nn of p r i n c i p a l p r o j e c t i o n bands e x h a u s t i n g Bf Evidently
( i i ) In addition, let
such t h a t
+ f
L
a s k whether t h e c o n v e r s e h o l d s . L e t
i s contained i n
p
For any
f I T nE Bn
such t h a t
E (B :n=1,2,
La
.
Bo
fITn and f E La , P This h o l d s i n p a r t i c u l a r f o r any sequence IT of p r i n c i -
Hence, i f
p a l p r o j e c t i o n bands s a t i s f y i n g all
exhausts
IT
w e have a unique decomposition f = f + f ' with m vn d Bo fl Bn , and i t f o l l o w s from Theorem 3 0 . 5 ( i i ) t h a t
If1 t I f ' then
327
BT 4 L
f E L
. Note
t h a t t h e r e e x i s t systems of t h i s t y p e . H I N T : For t h e proof i n ( i ) t h a t
f
2
. We may (6f-u ) + . For n +
u
pn =
0
n = l,2,
...
Da c La
p(f) > 0
,
let
.
En
,
let
Take
and
0 5 f E Da
6 > 0
and w r i t e
b e t h e band g e n e r a t e d by
p
.
pn 4 6f , t h e sequence IT Z (B : n = l , 2 , . . . ) s a t i s f i e s B 4 Bf , n p ( f ' ) C 0 (because f E Da ). E v i d e n t l y t h e component of 6f-u in rn i s pn , so t h e component of u -6f i s -pn , and i t f o l l o w s t h a t t h e
Since so Bn
component nent 5
assume t h a t
p(6f)
+
6 > 0 , so
u
in
inf
p(un) = 0
.
.
For ( i i i ) , t o prove t h e e x i s t e n c e of systems (ua:aE{a)) for all sup(ua
1
a
.
5 6f The compo~ of ) ~u ~ is (Gf)ITn-pn , s o 0 5 (u ) n rn d n B n Bf s a t i s f i e s 0 S (u ) ' S f ' Hence p(un) 5 Tm n n vn This holds f o r a l l p ( f i n ) , so i n f p(un) S p ( 6 f ) = 6 p ( f )
(
(un)in
be
an o r d e r b a s i s of
and l e t
,...,u
)
for
(vT:7E{7))
n
be t h e band g e c e r a t e d by EXERCISE 102.18.
and v7
( i ) Let
.
BT I. L
,
let
L ( c f . Theorem 28.5) such t h a t
ua E L+
b e t h e s e t of a l l elements of t h e form a l , ...,a
. Then L
v a r i a b l e . For e v e r y
BT 4 L
.
T
,
let
BT
b e a Riesz s p a c e p o s s e s s i n g t h e p r i n c i p a l
328
BANACH DUAL (v~:T€{T}) is an order basis of
projection property. If 0 I v I. and if for every
.
then BT I. L
Ch. 14,51021
the band generated by
T
Riesz seminorm in L , then Lan )
'7
+
is the set of all
0 holds for every system
IT
: ( B :T€{T})
(vn:n=1,2, ...I
(B :n=l,2,...) of principal projection
E
71
.
L he a Riesz space possessing the principal
EXERCISE 102.19. (i) Let
he a Riesz seminorm in L
p
haustive upwards directed system of the ideal generated by
nT
such that
is generated by some increasing sequence
in L+
projection property and let
=
if
(vT) have a finite or countable order basis. Show
L
that every increasing sequence bands exhausting L
f E L
'
BT
is generated p is a
that is generated by
.
some exhaustive upwards directed system (ii) In addition, let
(B,)
. Show that
(v,)
such that
is denoted by
In this case we shall say that the system
by the exhaustive upwards directed system p(f'
v
L
IT
. Note
IT
: (v
. For any
ex-
: ? € I T } ) , let LTI be the p-closure P
that 'L
is an ideal. Show that Lan
P
=
Lg , where the intersection is taken over all positive exhaustive up-
wards directed systems
.
TI
(ii) In addition, let L that
La
=
have a finite or countable order basis. Show
n LIT , where the intersection is taken over all possible exT
P
haustive increasing sequences HINT: Let in L
.
(v )
IT f
(v,,v,, . . . )
IT E
be an arbitrary exhaustive upwards directed system
(n vT:~E{~),n=1,2,...)
Note that
.
0< f € L
is likewise exhaustive and up-
= inf(f,nv ) for all n nT Then pnT f (proof as in Theorem 28.2) and evidently 0 < p E and T nr E LIT for all n and T Hence, if 0 I f E Lan , it follows from
wards directed. Let
.
+
and write p
.
P
i 0 that p(f-p,,) i 0 , which implies immediately that f E ' L f-PnT P (since 'L is p-closed). If f is an arbitrary member of Lan , the arguP
ment is applied to
f+ and
f-
separately,
For the converse, assume that
Lan
. We may
assume f 2 0
. By
haustive upwards directed system that
p(f'
IT,
) >
is a sequence p(f-gn)
+
0
E
for all
(gn:n=1,2, ...)
. On account of
i t may be assumed that
p(f-gn)
< E
T
.
0I g
.
f
,
is contained in nT :L
but not in
the preceding exercise there exists an ex-
I T } ) and a number
: (v :T
IT
Since
P
in the ideal generated by lf-g+l 5
f
5
If-g I
and
for all n
Corresponding to this particular
.
IT
gn
T
,
there
such that
/f-inf(f,gn)l
Now take n
0 such
E >
f € LTI for this particular 5
If-g I
such that
there exist
...,vk
vl,
Ch. 14,11021
in
(v,)
such that
is contained i n the ideal generated by
gn
and hence in the ideal generated by
...,vk
of v l ,
329
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
in
. It follows
(v,)
, where
v-
v-
vl,
...,vk
is some majorant with
positive components, and s o
which is impossible. be as in the preceding exercise. EXERCISE 102.20. (i) Let L and p Lan = LIT for at least one exhaustive upwards directed system
Show that 1~
if and o n l y if (ii)
(Lan)'
=
P
Lan
.
is order dense in L
Show that if
Lan
LTI for at least one system
=
P
(iii) Show that if it is given in addition that :L points of only if
L , then Lan an I (L ) = Lzn
.
=
, then
P
Lan
. We may
Lan
corresponding to this particular possible
is order dense. Let
assume that
LIT P
P
.
For (ii), see Theorem 102.11(i). always imply that
Lan
continuous functions on
0
5
, satisfies 'L
TI
Conversely, Lan c LTT since Lan
p-closed).
P
v
c tan
L*
sn
[O,l]
To prove that
with for
-
.
is satisfied, but
EXERCISE 102.21. Let L
TI
(since Lan
an I (L ) = L*
sn
p
the uniform norm. Then
Lan
=
L*
= {O}
since L
.
It follows
is not order dense.
102.11(ii). and
p
be as in the preceding exercise. In
for at least one exhaustive increasing
i f and only if
(ii) Show that if =
L*
, but
is
does not
L
is order dense and possesses an at most
comaable order basis. a l (L )
P '
have an at most countable order basis.
(i) Show that La = L; sequence
:T€{T))
is order dense, let L be the space of all (real)
For (iii), see Theorem
addition, let L
(v
ideal LIT
is the intersection of all
sn
=
if and
IT
IT 5
+ . The
I."= L" by Example 87.5, so L" = Lsn Furthermore, L" is a Bznach lattice. Hence L* = L* . Then Lan = ' ( L : n ) (Lan)'
separates the
LTI holds for at least one system
HINT: For (i), assume that be an order basis of
that
II
LEn , but the converse is not true.
La
=
LIT for at least one sequence P
the converse is not true.
'TI,
then
330
BANACH DUAL
Ch. 14,11023
(iii) Show that if it is given in addition that
L*, separates the holds for at least one sequence TI if and
L , then La = 'L a l (L ) = LE and 'L
points of only if
has an at most countable order basis.
HINT: We indicate a proof for (ii) since Theorem 102.lO(i) cannot be used immediately. It is sufficient to prove that (La)' c LE . For this a l purpose, let 0 5 @ E (L ) , s o @ vanishes on La = : L We have $ = @c+@s
with
account of
La
TI
0
(v :n=1,2,. . . )
E
pn
E L :
IC (LE)
=
inf(f,nv )
= S
+
p
Hence
@ s E LE
and
.
and let
for n
,
0
J-
so
Since
), it follows that
f
@=(f-pn)
@ (p ) = 0 for all n , so c n L , and so @ = @ s E L; .
.
(on
La
=
:L
be an arbitrary element of
L+
.
Write
J-
@c
. Then
1,2 ,...
=
vaniihes on La
@,
vanishes on
f by Theorem 28.2 (note that
f-pn
.
II
p E Ls = La for all n and n p is an order basis for L ) .
0 since
@,(f)
=
0
.
Let
@c
is an integral. But
This shows that
@c vanishes on
EXERCISE 102.22. A s observed in section 87, it was proved by S. Banach and C. Kuratowski that, under the continuum hypothesis, the interval X
=
C0,lI
has a nonmeasurable cardinal. Assume this to hold and let L
the Riesz space of all real bounded functions f P(f) Note that
L
1.
has an order basis consisting of one member (the function
identically one).
Show that
La
on an at most countable set (the points dense in L a of
x
.
(n=l,2,... )
for every L
@ E Lr
.
be
with norm
:xEX1
(
sup If(x)l
=
on X
consists of a l l
(xn:n=l ,2,. .)
depending on
,
f
with
Clan\ <
,
(I
then
m
E L*,
and for which f (x,) + 0 of course). It follows that La is order
(n=1,2,...) in X
Let the points x
f E L
.
f E L vanishing except
and the real numbers
be given. Show that if
.
It follows that :L
I$(€) = Lan f(xn) separates the points
Show by means of what was proved in Example 8 7 . 4 that every is of the form indicated. Use this to prove that
in the formula
(La)*
=
B + LE , where
B
B
=
{O}
holds
is the norm closed linear sub-
.
Hence space of "*, consisting of all @ € L* which vanish on La a 1 ( L ) = L* . Comparing these results with those in the preceding exercise, note now that there does not exist any exhaustive increasing sequence L
such that
La
=
'L
P
holds, in agreement with the fact that
La
possess an at most countable order basis. Finally, note that L* c
=
IT
in
does not L* n
(see
NORMED RIESZ SPACES
Ch. 14,§1021
Example 87.4),
and so all conditions mentioned in Exercise 102.20 are satis-
. Note also that
fied for L
L~
EXERCISE 102.23. Let
T
La
is not super order dense in L
although
(p :aE{a}) be a system of Riesz seminorms in
such that
pa(f)
0 for all a E {a} implies f
=
0.
=
T be the topology in L generated by the system of all pa , i.e., is the locally convex, Hausdorff and locally solid topology introduced
in Exercise 100.17. elements pa
It may be assumed that every finite supremum of the
is itself one of the
pa * (i) Show that the linear functional $ on @
only if
(pa:aEIa7)
is T-continuous if and in the system
.
=
(L,T)*
functionals is an ideal in the order dual
0
(iii) Show that if
E L*
L
i s pdbounded for at least one seminorm p
(ii) Show that the space L*
$
,
satisfies the hypotheses of Theorem 102. IO(iii).
the Riesz space L Let
33 1
if and only if
S
,
in L
u C
converges to
u
of all T-continuous linear L"
.
then $(un)
0
+
0 for every
in the topology T
.
,
i.e.,
p (u ) C 0 as n -t m for every a a n (iv) Show that if (u~:T€{T}) is a downwards directed set in L+ , then $(u ) + 0 for every positive $ in L* if and only if u conif and only if
verges to
0 in T
,
i.e., if and only if p (u )
(v) For brevity, denote the intersections of
L*
by
in L"
LE,L:,L:
+
0 for every a
L " "
Lc,Ls,Ln and
.
Lyn with
and
L* respectively. Show that these sets are ideals sn and bands in L* such that L* = L* c
8)
L* = L*
s
n
EXERCISE 102.24. Let T
8)
s
L*
n
.
be the same topology in the Riesz space L
as in the last exercise.
La(T) be the set of all f E L such that If1
(i) Let
implies $(un) of all f E L Positive $
+ 0
for every
such that
in L*
.
Show that La(T)
largest ideals on which every respectively. (ii) Show that
$ € L*
.
Similarly, let
If1 2 uT J. 0 implies $(u,) $
E L*
and
Lan(T)
Lan(T)
2 u
C 0
be the set
C 0 for every
are ideals in L
,
the
is an integral or a normal integral
Ch. 14,91021
BANACH DUAL
332
fEL:
I ~ >uI n co
o
i m p l i e s p (u )J. a n n
f o r every a
L a n ( ~ )= (fEL: Ifj>u,+O i m p l i e s pa (u,)+? 0 f o r e v e r y a Show t h a t
0
La(T) =
(Lg)
and
L
0
and d e n o t e
by
B
T-closed f o r any
B'
B c L*
.
L a n u ) = '(Lgn)
Ao
( i i i ) For convenience, d e n o t e
n
A'
by
L*
f o r any s u b s e t
B
so
Lan(T)
,
La(T)
and
of
f o r any s u b s e t
. Note
L*
f = 0 ) we have
implies
t h e p o i n t s of
.
L
'(L*)
= {O)
a 1 {L (T)} = L*
( i v ) Show t h a t
have d i f f e r e n t r e s t r i c t i o n s t o
only i f
Lgn
separates
and a l s o i f and o n l y i f
Lz
is
"*,
i f and o n l y i f d i f f e r e n t sn have d i f f e r e n t r e s t r i c t i o n s t o Lan(T) and a l s o i f and
L:
members of
for all
pa(f) = 0
o t h e r words, L*
is
Show by
i f and o n l y i f d i f f e r e n t members of
La(r)
c l o s e d . S i m i l a r l y , {Lan(T)}'
o(L*,L)
. In
of
A
t h a t B'
a r e T-closed.
means of t h e Hahn-Banach e x t e n s i o n theorem t h a t ( s i n c e
a
1.
is
a(L*,L)
= L*
closed.
(v) Show t h a t i f La(T) i s s u p e r o r d e r dense i n L , t h e n {La(T)}' I = Lz and (Lr) = { O } Conversely, i f t h e s e c o n d i t i o n s a r e s a t i s f i e d ,
.
then
i s o r d e r dense i n
La(T)
( v i ) Show t h a t
.
L
L
i s o r d e r dense i n
Lan(T)
L* and ('L:) = {O) , sn ( v i i ) Show t h a t i f {La(T)l' = L*
{Lan(T)}'
i f and o n l y i f
=
and o n l y i f
L* = L*
c
n
EXERCISE 102.25.
holds, then
La(T) = Lan(T)
Let
T b e t h e same topology i n t h e R k s z s p a c e L has the principal
L
p r o j e c t i o n p r o p e r t y . For any upwards d i r e c t e d system p r i n c i p a l p r o j e c t i o n bands s u c h t h a t TT
+f'
with
TIT
f T I TE B T
( i ) Show t h a t
f o r every
a
Lan(T)
and
B 4 L ' d f;T E B,
.
i s t h e s e t of a l l
and f o r e v e r y s y s t e m
TI
E (B,)
,
let
Ln(T)
Lan(T) =
nT
only i f
Lan(T)
L*(T)
n E (B
and f o r any f E L with
f
.
f L II E
(v
b e t h e T-closure of t h e i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by
. Show t h a t
Lan(T) = LT(T)
i s o r d e r dense i n
L
.
:T€{T))
of
E L w e have
such t h a t B,
( i i ) For any e x h a u s t i v e upwards d i r e c t e d s y s t e m L+
if
.
as i n t h e l a s t e x e r c i s e . Assume f u r t h e r m o r e t h a t
f = f
=
p a ( f k T ) C,O
:,€{TI) 1~
f o r a t l e a s t one
in
. Show t h a t TI
i f and
CHAPTER 15
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
L = L
Throughout t h i s c h a p t e r norm
t e d system p(u )
L
in
+
i s a normed Riesz space. We r e c a l l t h a t t h e
P
i s c a l l e d o r d e r continuous i f
p
0
uT
+
0
in
and
L
.L 0
p(u,)
f o r any downwards d i r e c -
i s c a l l e d a-order continuous i f
p
f o r any d e c r e a s i n g sequence
+
u
n
0
in
L
. We
s h a l l say t h a t
s a t i s f i e s t h e p-Cauchy c o n d i t i o n i f e v e r y bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence
i s a p-Cauchy sequence. I n s e c t i o n 103 i t i s proved t h a t
L
continuous i f and o n l y i f
i s a-order continuous and
p
p-Cauchy c o n d i t i o n . Hence, i f
p
L
p
i s known t o be a-order continuous, t h e n
t h e p-Cauchy c o n d i t i o n i s e x a c t l y n e c e s s a r y and s u f f i c i e n t t o make continuous. S i m i l a r l y , i f t e n e s s of
L
is order
satisfies the p order
i s a-order continuous, t h e n Dedekind a-comple-
p
i s a l s o s u f f i c i e n t t o make
t h a t . P r e c i s e l y , o-order c o n t i n u i t y of
o r d e r continuous and more t h a n
p p
n e s s i s e q u i v a l e n t t o o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of
t o g e t h e r w i t h Dedekind a-completet o g e t h e r w i t h s u p e r Dedekind
p
Completeness and a l s o e q u i v a l e n t t o t h e c o n d i t i o n t h a t every bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i n
L
has a norm l i m i t . I n a Banach l a t t i c e t h e last c o n d i t i o n
i s e x a c t l y t h e p-Cauchy c o n d i t i o n . I f , t h e r e f o r e , L then
P
i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f
L
s a t i s f i e s t h e p-Cauchy
i s s u p e r Dedekind complete. It i s a l s o proved
c o n d i t i o n and i n t h i s c a s e
L
i n t h i s section that i f
i s o r d e r continuous, t h e n
P r o p e r t y and i f
L
L
p
i s a Banach l a t t i c e ,
L
has t h e Egoroff
i s a Banach l a t t i c e w i t h a-order continuous norm, t h e n
has t h e s t r o n g Egoroff p r o p e r t y . I n t h e much s h o r t e r s e c t i o n 104 we prove (by means of a lemma due t o
p. Meyer-Nieberg)
that
L
s a t i s f i e s t h e p-Cauchy c o n d i t i o n i f and only i f
o r d e r bounded sequence of d i s j o i n t elements i n
L
converges t o z e r o
in norm. Hence, i n a Banach l a t t i c e t h e l a s t c o n d i t i o n i s e q u i v a l e n t t o o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of t h e norm. I n s e c t i o n 105 we f i r s t compare t h e norm topology and t h e o r d e r topolo-
gy. I n any normed Riesz space every o r d e r c l o s e d i d e a l i s norm c l o s e d . I n the converse d i r e c t i o n , every norm c l o s e d i d e a l i s o r d e r c l o s e d ( i . e ,
333
it is
i f and o n l y i f t h e norm
a a-ideal) easily that L
Ch. 151
CHAPTER 15
334
P
i s o-order continuous. It follows
p
i s o-order continuous i f and only i f f o r e v e r y i d e a l
t h e o r d e r c l o s u r e of
and t h e norm c l o s u r e of
A
does n o t mean t h a t i n t h i s s i t u a t i o n ( i . e . , t h e o r d e r topology
T
or
if
p
and t h e norm topology
T
A
A
in
a r e t h e same. This
i s o-order continuous) are already identical.
P p
i s o-order continuous or P and e v e r y norm convergent sequence has an o r d e r convergent subsequence. I n
E q u a l i t y of
and
T
h o l d s i f and only i f
T
a Banach l a t t i c e , t h e r e f o r e , w e have
T
o r d e r continuous.
= T
or
i f and only i f
P
i s o-
p
It was observed above t h a t every norm c l o s e d i d e a l i s a a - i d e a l
only i f
i s a-order continuous. I n an analogous manner, every norm c l o s e d
p
i d e a l i s a band i f and only i f
p
i s o r d e r continuous (Ando's theorem).
Another c o n d i t i o n e q u i v a l e n t t o o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of ideal
N
every
@
i f and
+# 0
i s a band f o r every in
@
the c a r r i e r
L* P
C
i s that the null
p
and s t i l l a n o t h e r one i s t h a t f o r
E L*
P
satisfies
0
C+
# {O}
. There
i s an
i n t e r e s t i n g a p p l i c a t i o n of t h e s e r e s u l t s i n an a r b i t r a r y Riesz space (not n e c e s s a r i l y a normed Riesz s p a c e ) . It was proved e a r l i e r t h a t i f o r d e r continuous, t h e n t h e n u l l i d e a l always t r u e . We prove now t h a t i f i n t h e i d e a l generated by
@
,
and
. It
T
quence. Furthermore,
if
T
= T
ru in L
p
'
i s a band f o r every
@
T
@
and t h e r e l a t i v e l y uniform
P
i s proved f i r s t t h a t
ru only i f every norm convergent sequence i n
L
= T
T
P has a ru-convergent
i f and subse-
s a t i s f i e s t h e weak Riesz-Fischer c o n d i t i o n (and
L
i s a Banach l a t t i c e ) , t h e n
L
therefore certainly i f
N
i s o r d e r continuous.
F i n a l l y , we compare t h e norm topology topology (ru-topology)
is
E L"
i s a band. The converse i s n o t
N
-6
@ E L
then @
@
T~~
= T
P
. If
i t f o l l o w s e a s i l y t h a t e v e r y monotone norm convergent sequence
i s ru-convergent.
T h i s l a s t p r o p e r t y i m p l i e s t h a t f o r every i d e a l
-
-
and t h e norm c l o s u r e A a r e t h e same. I n ruP t h e converse d i r e c t i o n , i f ArU = A f o r every i d e a l A and i f b e s i d e s t h a t
A
in
L
has t h e a-property
L
t h e ru-closure
A
(i.e.,
P
every c o u n t a b l e s e t i n
L
is contained i n a
p r i n c i p a l i d e a l ) , t h e n every monotone norm convergent sequence i s ru-converg e n t . It i s shown t h a t even w i t h t h i s a d d i t i o n a l c o n d i t i o n be d i f f e r e n t . I n s e c t i o n 106 we assume f i r s t t h a t
r i l y normed) such t h a t i.e.,
B
L-
L
c o n t a i n s an i d e a l
s e p a r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
wing c o n d i t i o n s a r e e q u i v a l e n t :
L
. We
T
ru
and
T
P
may
i s a Riesz s p a c e ( n o t necessaB
satisfying
OB =
,
prove t h a t i n t h i s c a s e t h e f o l l o -
Ch. 151
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
B c L :
(i) (ii)
u(L,B)
Every
If L
Every band in B
in B is
L
.
is a band.
the carrier C
u(B,L)
closed.
B = L*
is a normed Riesz space, then
the points of
is a normal integral).
closed ideal in L
4 # 0
(iii) For every (iv)
B
(i.e., every element of
335
'$
satisfies
C$ # { O }
is an ideal in L
.
separating
This implies then that the following conditions are equi-
valent:
(i)
p
(ii)
Every norm closed ideal in L
is order continuous.
(iv)
is a band.
4 # 0 in L*
(iii) For every
L*
Every band in
the carrier C satisfies C4 # { O } 4 is weak star closed (i.e., u ( L * , L ) closed).
The equivalence of (i),(ii),(iii)
.
was proved earlier in the chapter, but
condition (iv) did not occur before. Several results are extended to Riesz spaces with a topology determined by a system of Riesz seminorms.
103. Order continuous norms
In this section we assume that Riesz norm
p
. We
p ( u T -u
such that
is a Riesz space equipped with a
recall thatthe upwards directed system
is said to be a p-Cauchy system tT}
L
1
)4 E
T2
if for any
for all uT 2 u 1
for downwards directed systems. LEMMA 103.1. The
(i)
E >
To
0
and u
T2
in L
(U,:T€{T])
there exists t u
in
T~
. Similarly
following conditions are equivalent.
Every order bounded increasing sequence i n L
i s a p-Cauchy
sequence.
(ii) Every order bounded upwards d i r e c t e d system i n system. I f these equivalent conditions hold i n
L
i s a p-Cauchy
, we s h a l l say t h a t
L
L
s a t i s f i e s the p-Cauchy condition. PROOF. It is evident that (ii) implies (i). For the proof in the converse direction, assume that (i) holds but (ii) does not hold. Then there exists
+s un such that
a system 0 2 u that for some
E
>
o
is not p-Cauchy. This implies
(IJ~:T€{T))
we have a sequence
(u,
)
n
in
(u,)
such that u T t n
ORDER CONTINUOEIS NORMS
336
-u
P(uT
and
(ii) hold::'
) >
n , thus contradicting (i).
for all
E
p
any downwards directed system u
is order continuous if
0 in L and
C
Theorem 102.8 the ideal Lan Z u
J 0
implies p ( u T )
.
have L*
Lan
=
.
0
C
for
Recall that by
f E L
such that
. Once more by
is
p
Theorem 102.8, we
*(L* ) Hence, L = Lan if and only if Lzn = I01 . Since sn the last condition is equivalent to L* = L* Recapitula-
L* @ L* n sn ting, we have =
.
It is evident, therefore, that
L = Lan
order continuous if and only if
p(u,)
is a-order continuous in L
consists of a l l
in L C 0
p
C 0
p(u ) J 0 for any decreasing sequence u
If1
It follows that
Tn
A s defined earlier, the norm
if
Ch. 15,91031
.
'
p
order continuous
p
a-order continuous
Q
Similarly,
-
L* = L*
L
=
Lan
L
=
L~ Q L* = L*
Q
.
p is order continuous, then L* = L* = L* n c' every p-bounded linear functional is now not only an integral, but even
It is also evident that if so
a normal integral. It is interesting to observe that it is also possible to prove something about linear functionals that are not p-bounded. Every integral, p-bounded or not, is a normal integral. The proof follows. THEOREM 103.2. If the n o m p i s order continuous and if 0 5 u, 4 u in L , then there e x i s t s a sequence (u ) i n (u,) such that 0 u 4 u . Tn Tn It foZZows tha-0 every integraZ on L i s a noma2 integraZ, i.e., Lz = L z . PROOF. If 0
5
, then
4 u
u
order continuous. It follows that that u
and p(u-u,
4
) J
n cgnverges in norm to
(u,
u ="sup u
n
,
i.e.,
o
5 u
0 u
.
u-u
C 0
(uT)
,
so
p(u-uT) J 0 since
contains a sequence
(u, )
p
In other words, the increasing se&ence
. Then, by
Theorem 1 0 0 . 4 , we have
4 u .
n
Observe that there are many examples of Riesz spaces showing that 0
5
u
4 u
does not always imply the existence of a sequence
(u, ) n
is
such
in
Ch.
15,51031
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
337
.
(uT) satisfying 0 5 u 4 u To obtain a smooth presentation of the n main theorems in this section, we include a lemma.
LEMMA 103.3.
(i) If 0
2
i s a p-Cauchy system and
uT+
E~
sequence of p o s i t i v e numbers, there e x i s t s a sequence (uT ) that uT
n
and
4
n
.
f o r aZZ
(uT) such
(uT )
n Furthermore, any upper bound o f the sequence upper bound o f the system (u,)
.
is a
J 0
in
i s an
n
(ii) If every order bounded increasing p-Cauchy sequence has a norm
l i m i t and 0
+
u
2
i s a p-Cauchy system, then
and any increasing sequence sup u
Tn
=
p(u-uT)
J
i s Dedekind o-complete and
(iii) If L
system, then
(uT )
. FurthermoFe,
u = sup u
u = sup u
0 5 u 4 5 uo
n
PROOF. There exists a sequence
. We prove
n
the proof, fix u such that
that
u T' (n> 2 SUP(UT
n
It follows that bound of (uT ) n
>UT
O
supT p{sup(u
,
(uT )
so
u
S
v
T~
1
,U
9
T
(
T
TnVv>
-
as i n
such that
u
4
and
n
satisfies the conditions in (i). For T
n
there exists u
T'(n)
t u
Tn
so
)-u
T,
n
sup u , u
(uT )
n
(u,)
in
n
} 5
for all n
SUP(UT,V)
=
(uT )
temporarily."For any
TO
i s a p-Cauchy
.
= u = sup u
sup u
exists
.
0
e x i s t s and any increasing sequence
part (i) above s a t i s f i e s
for every
u = sup u
as i n part (i) above s a t i s f i e s
-
. Now, let n . Then E
SUP(UTn,V)
v
=
SUP(UT n ,v) 2 SUP(UT,UTn)
-
U Tn
be an upper
338
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
,
for all n and all
T
This implies that
p{sup(u
all
T
, i.e.,
u
5
v
p{sup(u
so
,v)-v}
for all
. Hence
T
for all n
2 E
n for all
= 0
,v)-v}
Ch. 15,51031
v
T
, so
and all
sup(uT,v)
=
.
T
v
is an upper bound of
for (uT)
be a p-Cauchy system. For any increasing se-
uo
as in part (i) we have
(uT )
so
is an order bounded increasing p-Cauchy sequence. Hence, by hypoconverges in norm to some u € L
thesis,nu u = sup u
(uT) +
0
. Henge
and
. By
sup u
u = sup u 0 5
(iii) Let plete space L part (i).
,
so
. It follows immediately from p(u-uT ) C 0 , so p ( u - u T ) C 0 .
that f 5 uo (u
and let
sup u
= u =
p(u-uT ) +
n
be anp-Cauchy system in the Dedekind o-combe an increasing sequence in
)
exists. By part (i), u n
then, by Theorem 1 0 0 . 4 ,
u = sup u
=
e
. But
is now also an upper bound of the system
L
Since the sequencenis order bounded and
u = sup u
(uT)
part (i), u
sup u T
(uT)
as in
is Dedekind u-complete,
is also an upper bound of the system
. Note
that u
is not necessarily the norm
(uT ) ; cf. Exercise 100.12.
limit of the sequznce
n
In the next two theorems we shall encounter conditions, sufficient or necessary and sufficient for a o-order continuous norm to be order continuous. THEOREM 103.4. The Riesz norm
tinuous i f and only i f
i n the Riesz space
p
i s o-order continuous and
p
i s order con-
L
s a t i s f i e s the
L
p-Cauchy condition, i . e . , every order bounded upwards directed system i n L i s p-Cauchy. PROOF. Let
p
be o-order continuous and let L
condition. Furthermore, let such that
u
. For the proof
C 0
to assume that uo t so
(vT)
(uT)
+
u
0
satisfy the p-Cauchy
be a downwards directed system in L that
p(u ) C
for some uo E L
0
, it
. Then
is no
restriction
0
=
vT
u 0 -u T
+ u o '
is a p-Cauchy system by hypothesis. By part (i) of the preceding
lemma there exists a sequence upper bound of it follows that
(vT ) v
n
(vT )
in
(vT)
is also an Zpper bound of 4 u0
, and
so
p(u
-v
O
) C 0 Tn
such that v (vT)
. Since"
because,
p
and any
4
v
7
4 u
0 '
is o-order
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
Ch. 15,f31031
+
continuous. But then p(uo-vT)
0
, i.e.,
339
+
p(u,)
0
.
In the converse direction it is sufficient to prove that order continuity of
implies the p-Cauchy condition. Hence, assume that 0
P
and let V
u +SU
_<
n is Archimedean, we have
.
for n=1,2, ...I Since L
(V:V>U
O
4 0 (cf. Theorem 22.5), s o p(v-u ) + 0 because p is order n v,n n v,n continuous. For m 2 n we have 0 5 um-u n 5 v-un for all v E V , s o
v-u
p(um-un) that
is arbitrarily small if n
is sufficiently large. This shows
is a p-Cauchy sequence. Hence, the p-Cauchy condition is satis-
(un)
fied. EXAMPLE 103.5. The p-Cauchy condition and o-order continuity of the norm are independent. The space of all real continuous functions on
with p(f) =
1
0
[O,ll
If Idx satisfies the @-Cauchycondition, but p is not o-order
continuous. For an example with a o-order continuous norm and not satisfying the p-Cauchy condition, let L
be the Riesz space of all real functions f
on the uncountable point set X
such that, given any
f(-)
x E X
finitely many
E
>
. The norm
for which there exists a finite number
0
, we
have
p(f)
easy to see that if the sequence
(un)
convergence is uniform, s o
C 0
p(un)
(f(x)-f(-)l
is p(f)
>
for at most
E
. It is
sup(lf(x)l:xEX)
+
satisfies u
in L
. This
=
n
shows that p
0
, then
the
is o-order con-
tinuous. On the other hand, there exists a downwards directed system u in L
such that
continuous, and so
p(uT) = 1
f o r all
T
. This shows that
C 0
is not order
p
L does not satisfy the p-Cauchy condition.
In the next theorem we show that o-order continuity of the norm together with Dedekind g-completeness is more than sufficient to imply order continuity of the norm. In fact, we get not only order continuity of the norm, but super Dedekind completeness as well. THEOREM 103.6. The following conditions for t h e Riesz norm
P
in
L
*re equivalent. (i> (ii)
P is u-order continuous and L i s Dedekind o-complete. Every order bounded increasing sequence i n L has a norm l i m i t .
(iii) p
i s order continuous and
PROOF. (i) plete, so
3
(ii) Let 0
u = sup u n
5 u
L
4 5 uo
exists. Then u-u
o-order continuous. Hence, u
i s super Dedekind complete.
. The space C 0
, so
L
i s Dedekind o-com-
+
~(u-u,)
n is the norm limit of
un
.
0
since P
340
O-ER
(ii)
=.
CONTINUOUS NORMS
(iii) Note first that in view of (ii) L
condition. We shall prove that For the proof that p(uT) uo E L
Ch. 15,51031
. Then
05 v
+
0 we may assume that uo 2 uT
u -u
=
satisfies the p-Cauchy
+
is order continuous, so let u
p
,
I. uo
so
(vT)
+
0
.
0 for some
is an upwards directed
T O r p-Cauchy system (since L satisfies the p-Cauchy condition). The hypotheses
of part (ii) in Lemma 103.3 are now satisfied for
+
i.e., p(q)
0
(vT)
.
, so
is super Dedekind complete, let 0 _< u
For the proof that L
In view of the p-Cauchy condition the system
is p-Cauchy,
(ur)
hypotheses of part (ii) in Lemma 103.3 are now satisfied for follows that u (uT )
=
(uT)
in
sup ur
0
+ _ < uo
so
(uT)
+
,
.
the
. It
exists, and furthermore there exists a sequence
such that
sup u
=
. This shows that
u = sup u
n
supEr Dedekind complete. (iii)
p(uo-vr)
L
is
* (i) Evident.
The above theorem was proved essentially by H. Nakano ([11,1943; reprinted in [41,p.321-322). We add several corollaries. COROLLARY 103.7. If t h e normed Riesz space
then
La
i s Dedekind o-complete
L
(as a Riesz space i n i t s own r i g h t ) i s super Dedekind complete and
t h e norm i n
La i s order continuous (and so
PROOF. Since La
is an ideal in L
La
, the
=
Lan 1.
space La
inherits the
property to be Dedekind a-complete. Furthermore, the norm in La continuous. Hence, by the last theorem, La the norm in La
is
super Dedekind complete and
is order continuous.
COROLLARY 103.8. Let
L
have t h e property t h a t every order bounded
increasing p-Cauchy sequence has a norm l i m i t . Then i f and only i f
L
p
i s order continuous
s a t i s f i e s t h e p-Cauchy c o n d i t i o n . I n t h i s case L i s s u p e r
Dedekind complete. I n p a r t i c u l a r , i f order continuous i f and only i f t h i s case
is a-order
L
L
i s a Banach l a t t i c e , then
P
is
s a t i s f i e s t h e p-Cauchy condition and i n
L i s super Dedekind complete.
PROOF. If
p
is order continuous, then L
satisfies the p-Cauchy
condition (by Theorem 103.4). Conversely, assume now that every order bounded increasing p-Cauchy sequence has a norm limit and also that L satisfies the p-Cauchy condition, i.e., every order bounded increasing sequence is
Ch. 15,§1031
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
34 1
p - ~ a u c h y . T h i s means e x a c t l y t h a t c o n d i t i o n ( i i ) i n Theorem 103.6 i s s a t i s f i e d , so i t follows t h a t
p
i s o r d e r continuous and
i s s u p e r Dedekind
L
completeNote t h a t t h e c o n d i t i o n s i n t h e l a s t c o r o l l a r y do n o t imply t h a t a Banach l a t t i c e
(th e space
w i t h t h e L -norm).
Lm([O,l])
1
Some of t h e main r e s u l t s f o r t h e c a s e t h a t THEOREM 103.9. I n a Banach l a t t i c e
i s a Banach l a t t i c e .
L
L
the following conditions are
equivalent. (i)
The r w r m
(ii)
Every norm bounded linear functional on L
i s order continuous, i.e.,
P
is
L
We r e c a p i t u l a t e
.
L = Lan
i s a normal integraZ,
.
i . e . , L*= L* ( i i i ) Every order bounded increasing sequence i n L
i s convergent i n
norm. (iv)
m e norm
Furthermore, L
i s o-order continuous and
p
i s Dedekind o-complete.
L
i s super Dedekind comp1et;e i f these equivalent condi-
tions are s a t i s f i e d . Dedekind o-completeness and t h e p r o p e r t y t o have a o-order continuous norm are independent. I f
L
i s Dedekind o-complete b u t
continuous, t h e n i t may happen t h a t sequence s p a c e
.em )
but
L
X
with
L
and it may a l s o happen t h a t
complete ( t h e s p a c e of a l l r e a l point set
bounded f u n c t i o n s
I
p ( f ) = s u p ( l f ( x ) :x€X))
i s n o t Dedekind o-complete,
i s n o t o-order
p
i s s u p e r Dedekind complete ( t h e
L
. If
i s n o t s u p e r Dedekind f
p
on a n uncountable
i s o-order continuous
t h e n i t may happen t h a t p i s o r d e r con-
t i n u o u s ( t h e s p a c e of a l l real s t e p f u n c t i o n s on Lebesgue measurable s e t s i n (x:O<xSl)
, with
o n l y a f i n i t e number of s t e p s and w i t h t h e u s u a l i d e n t i f i c a -
t i o n o f f u n c t i o n s d i f f e r i n g only on a s e t of a measure z e r o ; t h e norm i s t h e
L 1 -norm).
I t may a l s o happen t h a t
f o r exarcple, i f
L
p
t h e s p a c e of a l l r e a l f u n c t i o n s
f
which t h e r e e x i s t s a f i n i t e number > E
:xu()
i s n o t o r d e r continuous. T h i s o c c u r s ,
i s t h e space mentioned i n Example 103.5, t h a t i s t o s a y , on t h e uncountable p o i n t set f(m)
such t h a t , given
f o r a t most f i n i t e l y many
. It
E
x ; t h e norm i s
> 0 p(f)
X
b e proved n e x t t h a t i f t h e norm
p
L
have
=
w a s proved i n Theorem 2 5 . l ( v ) t h a t t h i s s p a c e
t h e p r i n c i p a l p r o j e c t i o n p r o p e r t y , and so
for
, we
L
does
i s n o t Dedekind
i s order continuous, then
L
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
342
h a s t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y , i . e . ,
...)
(unk:n,k=1,2, a sequence
+
z
m numbers, we have
given
+
satisfying 0
in z
remarkable t h a t i f
uo 2 unk 0 for a l l n k such t h a t f o r every p a i r (m,n)
L
i.e.,
for a l l
there e x i s t s of n a t u r a l
.
f o r an a p p r o p r i a t e k = k(m,n) It i s n,k(m,n) i s a Banach l a t t i c e , a-order c o n t i n u i t y of t h e norm has t h e s t r o n g Egoroff p r o p e r t y ,
L
t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y h o l d s f o r any double sequence
Sk 0
,
u
2
m L
i s already s u f f i c i e n t t o guarantee t h a t unk
and t h e double sequence
0
uo 2
Ch. 15,51031
n ; t h e f i x e d upper bound
(u,)
satisfying
i s n o t n e c e s s a r y now. The
uo
d e t a i l s follow. THEOREM 103.10. I f the R i e s z n o m L
L
in
p
is order continuous, then
has the Egoroff property. PROOF. L e t
uo
+k
unk
2
0
for
... . Since
n = 1,2,
p
is order
continuous, t h e r e e x i s t s f o r every p a i r ( j , n ) of n a t u r a l numbers an index -1 -n such t h a t ~ ( u ~ , ~ ( S~ j, ~ .2 ) ) We may assume t h a t k ( j , n ) i s
.
k(j,n)
j
increasing as
b e t h e supremum of t h e
u
0 5 p(u ) 5
(1)
f o r every for a l l
u u )
(2)
. The , we
n , k ( j ,n)
set
(u,)
have
v-u
P(v-ua)
+
f i x e d and with
(U n , k ( j , n ) 1)
cn
u
n = nl
=
(nl,
,.. . ,n P .
...,n
)
C
u,v
0
let
u
Then
< j-’ -
i s d i r e c t e d upwards, and w r i t i n g
u
,
(since
L
P
V = (v:v>u
i s Archimedean), so
0
a ,v
by t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of V
j
i n c r e a s e s . For
p
.
It i s important a t t h i s p o i n t t o observe t h a t
i s n o t empty, because t h e given element
uo
is
a member of
V
. Combi-
n i n g (1) and (2), we f i n d t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s an element w E V such t h a t . I j p(w.) 5 2JJ Now, l e t z = i n f ( w w ) f o r m = 1,2 Since w . 2 u m m J n,k(j,n)” 2 U f o r a l l n and j = 1, ,m , w e have z 2 u for a l l n,k(m,n) m n,k(rp,n) -1 n Furthermore, z J. and p(zm) 5 p(wm) S 2m f o r e v e r y m , so
.
.
p(zm) C 0
. It
,,...,
m
follows t h a t
zm S 0
...
. The
,... .
sequence
(2,)
s a t i s f i e s , there-
f o r e , a l l c o n d i t i o n s r e q u i r e d f o r t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y . THEOREM 103.11. I f
continuous, then
L
L
is a Banach l a t t i c e and t h e norm
has t h e strong Egoroff property.
‘
p
is a-order
a. 15,§1031 PROOF. Let
.I
u
nk k tinuous, we can determine and
k(j,n)
w.=c J
0
k(j,n)
j
exists in
n,k(j,n)
. Since
n = l,2,...
for
increasing as
u
n
343
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
as before, i . e . ,
i n c r e a s e s . Then L
.
i s o-order con-
p
P(un,k(j,n)) ~ j - I . 2 - ~
Cn p ( u
, so
s j-I
)
n , k ( j ,n) by t h e Riesz-Fischer property and
-1 ~ ( w . ) < T . ~ ( u ~ , ~ ( 5~ ,j ~ ) ) Note t h a t the Riesz-Fischer property holds 3 because L i s a Banach l a t t i c e . Writing z = i n f ( w l , w ) for
m
1,2,
=
m
and
... , we .
m
f i n d as before t h a t
z
.I 0
m
..., m
and
z
m
for a l l
t u
n,k(m,n)
R
Let
be t h e Riesz space of a l l r e a l functions
L
point s e t
such t h a t
X
I
I
p ( f ) = max( f (x) :xEX)
f(x)
# 0
f
on t h e i n f i n i t e
f o r only f i n i t e l y many
. The norm
x
E X , with
i s o r d e r continuous, s o
p
Egoroff property. It i s easy t o s e e , however, t h a t
has t h e
L
does n o t have t h e
L
strong Egoroff property. For a f u r t h e r i n v e s t i g a t i o n of t h e Banach l a t t i c e i n Example 103.5 with p o-order continuous b u t not order continuous, we
L
r e f e r t o Exercise 103.15. For a d i f f e r e n t proof of t h e l a s t theorem, based on t h e r e s u l t s i n Chapter 10, we r e f e r t o Exercise 103.19. W e conclude t h e s e c t i o n by showing t h a t i f t h e norm
continuous and
i s a principal ideal i n
A
A
be a principal ideal in the noned Riesz space,
L* = L,*
, and by
CT
the c a r r i e r s
A
that of
L
. Since t h e elements
CT
let
. Note
T
such t h a t
A*
denote t h e carrier
a r e d i s j o i n t normal i n t e g r a l s on A ,
@T
a r e pairwise d i s j o i n t by Theorem 90.6. J,,
A
generated by t h e element
a maximal d i s j o i n t system i n
generated by t h e system of a l l
. Now,
CT
Let
and assume t h a t
B
be t h e i d e a l
0 < v E A
be a p o s i t i v e p-bounded l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on
A
and such
J, (v) = 1 ; t h e minimal p o s i t i v e l i n e a r extension of t h e r e s t r i c t i o n 0 J,o t o t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l generated by v w i l l be denoted by J, Then
$(f) = 0 of
be t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l i n
(OT:?E{~}) be
A
there e x i s t s a positive p-bounded
a r e p o s i t i v e and have norm one. For each
+T
@T
I B
. %en
such that $ is s t r i c t l y positive on is a normal integral.
0
A
let
@
on L
@
, so
PROOF. Let uo 2 0
in
.
THEOREM 103.12. Let
linear functional
V
t h e r e e x i s t s a p-bounded
i s s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e on
such t h a t
that
all
i s order
L
@
with order continuous norm p
of
, then
L
on
linear functional
L
L
p in
$
satisfies
, so
f 1v
for a l l N
JI
3
again by Theorem 90.6).
CT
J,
for a l l
vanishes on T
,
and so
, i.e.,
B J,
.
the n u l l ideal
I$, f o r a l l
'I
N
(Once
This c o n t r a d i c t s t h e maximality of t h e system
JI
($T)
-
It follows t h a t t h e i d e a l uo
Ch. 15,51031
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
344
i s o r d e r dense i n
B
A , : s o t h e given element
satisfies
Since
i s o r d e r continuous, t h e r e e x i s t s by Theorem 103.2 a sequence
p
.
0 < v
in
such t h a t
i s a f i n i t e sum ( e q u i v a l e n t -
4 uo Each v n l y , a f i n i t e supremum) of elements i n t h e s e t s
(v,)
B
number of assume t h a t Then fact
v
Iv
O that
{TI i s
occurring thus i n a l l
CT C
n uo
CT
. Hence,
the t o t a l
t o g e t h e r i s a t most countable. Now
v
does n o t occur i n t h i s manner, and l e t 0 < vo E C . '0 f o r a l l n , and s o vo I sup v - uo This c o n t r a d i c t s t h e g e n e r a t e s t h e whole of
a t most c o u n t a b l e , so l e t
i s a s t i c t l y p o s i t i v e p-bounded a p o s i t i v e p-bounded
.
A
($T)
.
It follows t h a t t h e index s e t
. Then @A = Z y 2-n@n . Extending $A a s
=
l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on
A
L (which i s p o s s i b l e
l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l t o t h e whole of
by Lemma 1 0 2 . 4 ) , we o b t a i n a l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l
$
having a l l d e s i r e d
properties. Note t h a t i f
i s a RBesz space (not n e c e s s a r i l y normed) such t h a t
L
A
f o r each p r i n c i p a l i d e a l i n t e g r a l on
A
,
$o
i s given and
in
t h e r e e x i s t s a s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e normal
L
then
L h a s t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y . Indeed, i f 0 < u E L 0 i s a s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e n o r m a l i n t e g r a l on t h e p r i n c i p a l
i d e a l A generated by uo , t h e n p ( f ) = $ , ( l f l ) i s an o r d e r continuous 0 Riesz norm i n A. , so t h e proof of Theorem 103.10 can b e a p p l i e d . EXERCISE 103.13. Show t h a t i f
L
space
$(f) t 0
such t h a t
HINT: Assume
f = f + - f-
there exists
Q E L*
take
Q-
$+
or
r e s t r i c t i o n of = $(f-)
Then
> 0
. Let
$
and
J , ( f ) = -J,(f-)
with J,
i s an element i n t h e normdd Riesz
f
for a l l with
$(f-)
# 0
0
f-
$
# 0
. We
E L*, t h e n
. By
t h e Hahn-Banach
may assume
theorem
$ t 0 ; otherwise
t o t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l generated by for a l l
g I f-
. Contradiction.
EXERCISE 103.14. L e t
.
b e t h e minimal p o s i t i v e l i n e a r e x t e n s i o n of t h e
$(g) = 0 < 0
f t 0
L
. In
Hence
f-
, so
J,(f-) =
p a r t i c u l a r , J,(f+) = 0
f 2 0
.
.
b e a normed Riesz space. Show t h a t every o r d e r
bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i n
L
has a norm l i m i t i f and only i f every
o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i n
L
i s weakly convergent, i . e . ,
€or
a. 15,§103]
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
+ S uo in n every $ E L*
0 5 u
there exists
L
-
HINT: Note f i r s t t h a t
f o r every
0 5 $ E L*
f o r every
0 5 $ E L*
U-u
for a l l
2 0
(u,)
EXERCISE 103.15. a l l r e a l functions
+
for
$(u)
i s decreasing
+
$(u-un)
u s e Lemma 102.5 t o conclude t h a t
p(u-un)vO
h a s a norm l i m i t .
I n Example 103.5 w e have i n t r o d u c e d t h e space
f
on a n uncountable p o i n t s e t such t h a t , given
0
,
f(m)
If(x)-f(m)l
holds f o r a t most f i n i t e l y many
.
p ( f ) = s u p ( l f ( x ) l :xEX)
0
t h e p r e c e d i n g e x e r c i s e t o conclude t h a t
a f i n i t e number > E
$(un)
i s d e c r e a s i n g , s o $(u-un) n $(u-un) + 0 by h y p o t h e s i s , so
. Finally,
Hence, t h e sequence
such t h a t
u E L
u-u
. But . Use
n
345
E
>
It was proved t h a t
of
L
f o r which t h e r e e x i s t s
X
the i n e q u a l i t y x ; t h e norm
is
p(f)
i s a-order continuous, b u t
p
n o t o r d e r continuous. The same space was mentioned i n connection w i t h Theorem 103.9, where i t was r e c a l l e d ( r e f e r r i n g back t o Theorem 2 5 . l ( v ) ) that
does n o t p o s s e s s t h e p r i n c i p a l p r o j e c t i o n p r o p e r t y , and s o
L
n o t Dedekind a-complete. now t h a t
Investigating
is
L
s t i l l a l i t t l e more c l o s e l y , show
L
has t h e following properties.
L
(i)
L
i s a Banach l a t t i c e .
(ii)
L
i s n o t Dedekind a-complete.
( i i i ) The norm
i s o-order c o n t i n u o u s , b u t n o t o r d e r continuous.
p
(iv)
L
(v)
The l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l
h a s t h e s t r o n g Egoroff p r o p e r t y . $
, defined
by
$ ( f ) = f(m)
,
i s an
i n t e g r a l b u t n o t a normal i n t e g r a l . (vi)
The normal i n t e g r a l s s e p a r a t e t h e p o i n t s of
,
L
i.e.,
EXERCISE 103.16. I n s e c t i o n 85 i t was observed t h a t t h e r e e x i s t nonzero
.
s i n g u l a r l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s on t h e ( r e a l ) sequence space Lm Note t h a t (since
.em
.em
i s norm bounded. Let
e E
Theorem 86.3 e v e r y i n t e g r a l Some
0
=
,...)
( i ) Show t h a t i f ( i i ) Show t h a t i f E (c)
, where
, and
=
.ez
have a l l i t s c o o r d i n a t e s e q u a l t o one. By
on
i s of t h e form
i t follows e a s i l y t h a t
(.em): , t h e n
$ f
f
$ E
fm = l i m f
em $
s i d e r f i r s t t h e case- t h a t f
Lz
i s a Banach s p a c e ) , s o every o r d e r bounded l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on
n
$(f) = 0
$
E
$ ( f ) = POifi
el
for a l l
.
f
for
E (co) ; con-
h a s only a f i n i t e number of nonzero c o o r d i n a t e s .
(em): as
and n
+
$(e) m
.
= a
,
then
$ ( f ) = af,
f o r any
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
346
( i i i ) Conversely, i f that
$ ( f ) = af,
$ E
for a l l
Ch. 15,§1031
LE and i f t h e r e e x i s t s a c o n s t a n t
, then
f E (c)
(em): .
$ E
such
a
HINT: ( i ) Let be t h e sequence w i t h one as n-th c o o r d i n a t e and en z e r o s elsewhere. Assume now t h a t 0 2 $ E (La): Then i f i f ( $ , $ ) = 0 f o r
every E
(Lm)r
0 5 $ E
> 0
$(v) + $(w) <
, i.e.,
E
$(v) <
v+w = e (I-E)$(en)
i t follows t h e n t h a t
$(v) <
2
$(f) = 0
f o r any
let
0 < f E (c,)
for
n 2 no
$(f) = 0
0
for
i s given, then
,... )
(u1,u2
,
> 0
E
E Lz
$
E
> 0
.
satisfy
E Ll , s o $(w)
no
. Let
1 1
and
f = ( f l , f 2 ,...)
+ w
(O,l,O,l,O, ...) and l e t (c,)
g E (c,) (i)
and
v
and
B
Show t h a t
f = g + au + Bv (ii)
0 5 $
E (Lm):
. Take
w E
for
the
w
s u f f i c i e n t l y l a r g e . Since
e
and
=
,
$(e-w)
+ $(w) <
$(e-w)
.
, so
V
1,
such t h a t
f
E
V
E
$
(em):
...)
with and
L,
generated
f = g + au + Bv
i s of t h e form
with
r e a l numbers. g,a
Show t h a t i f
and
B
a r e uniquely determined i n
f = g + au + Bv t 0
+ au +
+ :B
for
(iv)
Show t h a t f o r any
f = g
if
$ ( f ' ) = $(f) ) is called
then
be t h e l i n e a r subspace of
every
= 0
. Hence
E
on
$
u = (l,O,l,O,l,
( i i i ) Show t h a t t h e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l = :a
, so
f E (c)
n
f ' = ( 0 , f l , f 2 ,...)
v =
E
c o o r d i n a t e s and ones elsewhere. Then
l i m i t . For t h e proof t h a t n o t every
by
<
b e r e p r e s e n t e d by
$
f o r any
is a Banach-Mazur l i m i t , l e t
,u ,a
and
. Hence
and having t h e p r o p e r t y of being t r a n s l a t i o n i n v a r i a n t ( i . e . ,
a Banach-Mazur $(e) = 1
,
0 2 f
$ ( f ) < E$(e)
EXERCISE 103.17. Any s i n g u l a r l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l $(e) = 1
. From
n
for
E
(e-w)
.
E
$(en) = 0
such t h a t
$(f) = afm for a l l
Cu.w.
=
i s given, $(w) <
{inf($,$)j(e) = 0
<
. Then
I t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t i f
{inf($,$)}(e) = 0
by h y p o t h e s i s , we have
0 S w
n implies
. This
t h e r e s u l t a l r e a d y proved, we g e t
5
so
v t (I-E)e
there e x i s t s
sequence having zeros a s i t s f i r s t if
so
is the linear
$
,
$(w) = wn
,
> I-E
v
. If
E
f o r any given
such t h a t
w i t h only f i n i t e l y many nonzero c o o r d i n a t e s . Now,
f
E (c,)
f
$(w) <
el , then
$(en)n< € ( I - € ) - '
. Given
. Using
.
( i i i ) Let $(f) = 0
, so
E
e = v+w (v,wrO)
and
E
en E
, so
{inf($,$)}(e) = 0
t h e r e e x i s t s a decomposition
f u n c t i o n a l r e p r e s e n t e d by
so
.
. Hence
PI
=
BV
, is
fo E
, $o
on
p o s i t i v e on
em
a t 0
then V
v
.
,
and
B 2 0
d e f i n e d by
t h e r e e x i s t s an element
.
$O(f) =
f E V
Ch. 15,51031
satisfying
$o
on
V
ORDER CONTINUOUS N O W
fo
9
f
, defined
. dhow
t h a t , consequently, t h e p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l
i n ( i i i ) , has a p o s i t i v e l i n e a r extension
Lm . Then
whole of
347
0
9
0 E (L-):
with
$,(u)
a
=
and
t o the
$
$,(v)
, so
=
i s n o t a Banach-Mazur l i m i t . EXERCISE 103.18.
( i ) One of t h e c o n d i t i o n s f o r
i s a Banach l a t t i c e .
L
show t h a t t h i s does n o t imply t h a t
i n Theorem 103.6 i s
L
s h a l l have a norm l i m i t .
L
t h a t every o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i n
( i i ) Show t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s a normed Riesz space
such t h a t every
L
o r d e r bounddd i n c r e a s i n g sequence i s p-Cauchy and f o r a t l e a s t one o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence but
(u,)
i s n o t t h e norm l i m i t of
uo
norm
uo = sup u
t h e element u
n
.
exists i n
n It might look a s i f
L
,
with t h e
s a t i s f i e s t h e s e c o n d i t i o n s ( c f . E x e r c i s e 100.12), b u t t h i s space c o n t a i n s o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequences t h a t f a i l t o b e p-Cauchy.
Show t h a t
Lm
with
where
0
5
$
E ( L w ) z with
EXERCISE 103.19.
$(e) = 1
, satisfies
Show t h a t by u s i n g Theorem 70.2 one c a n g e t a s l i g h t l y
d i f f e r e n t proof of t h e r e s u l t t h a t i f continuous norm, t h e n EXERCISE 103.20. t h e space sequence
L (u,
L
L
i s a Banach l a t t i c e w i t h o-order
h a s t h e s t r o n g Egoroff p r o p e r t y .
I n Theorem 103.2 i t was proved t h a t i f
0 5 u
w i t h o r d e r continuous norm, t h e n in
)
t h e conditions.
(u,)
. Show now
that i f
0
S
u
,n
4u
4 u
(U
)
TF
in
strictly positive integral p(f) = $(lfl)
(u,)
4
. Hence,
,
then
i f a Riesz space
9
0 L
L
. It
+
u
so
follows t h a t any Riesz
p o s s e s s i n g a s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e i n t e g r a l on every p r i n c i p a l i d e a l h a s t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y .
in
5 u 4 u for n possesses a
0 i s a normal i n t e g r a l , and
i s an o r d e r continuous norm i n
u
i n a Riesz space
L possessingna s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l , t h e n Some sequence
0
f o r a t l e a s t one
348
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
EXERCISE 103.21.
Show t h a t i f
Ch. 15,81031
h a s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s norm and
L
L
has a f i n i t e o r countable o r d e r b a s i s , then t h e r e e x i s t s a s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e p-bounded
4
linear functional
a s t r i c t l y monotone norm i n such t h a t
and
X
H I N T : Let
that exists
u > 0 n
0
(un:n=1,2, ...)
n
n
t h e i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by p o s i t i v e on
u
.
L
and
such t h a t
E L*
, and
L
0
5
u
a r e e q u i v a l e n t norms.
p
for a l l
5 $
on
L (i.e.,
implies
< u2
1
b e an o r d e r b a s i s i n u t u for m t n m n p*($,) = 1 and On
. Then
is
X(f) = p ( f ) + $ ( i f [ )
hence
L
. By
.
h ( u l ) < A(u2) )
I t may be assumed
Theorem 103.12 t h e r e
i s s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e on
i s p-bounded and s t r i c t l y
@ = Z2-"$
EXERCISE 103.22. I n E x e r c i s e 103.14 i t was proved t h a t weak convergence of e v e r y o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i n
is equivalent t o the
L
c o n d i t i o n s i n Theorem 103.6, one of which i s t h e c o n d i t i o n t h a t t h e norm
i s a - o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s and
L
i s Dedekind a-complete.
p
We p r e s e n t s t i l l an-
o t h e r e q u i v a l e n t c o n d i t i o n . Show t h a t t h e c o n d i t i o n s i n Theorem 103.6 a r e s a t i s f i e d i f and o n l y i f t h e norm
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s and
p
complete i n t h e s e n s e of E x e r c i s e 101.8 ( i . e . , v -u C 0 n n
that n
1.
HINT: I f
, then
there exists
u
n and
5 u 2 v
L
for a l l
n
and
i s order vnC
un 2 u 2 v
n
. Asssume,
L
that
u = sup u
conversely, t h a t
p
satisfies
i s o r d e r continuous
i s o r d e r complete. F o r t h e proof of Dedekind a-completeness,
.
0 5 u +5uo
such
for a l l
s a t i s f i e s t h e c o n d i t i o n s i n Theorem 103.6, t h e n i t f o l l o w s
L
from t h e Dedekind a-completeness of
u
0 2 u 4
if
E L such t h a t
L
let
L e t $ b e a s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e p-bounded l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on n t h e i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by uo (Theorem 103.12). F i n a l l y , l e t (vn) be a
d e c r e a s i n g sequence i n = inf($(v):v€V)
2 v -u
n
n
for a l l exists
.
for a l l
n
u
u = sup u n
, which
f o r a l l n ) such t h a t i n f $(vn) = n I t i s e a s y t o s e e t h a t v -u C 0 , b e c a u s e i f 0 5 w 2 n n n , then v -w E V f o r a l l n , s o n
$(w) = 0
implies
such t h a t
.
V = (v:vtu
u 2 u 2 v n n
EXERCISE 102.23. L e t
q
, so
for a l l
w = 0 n
. Now,
. It
by h y p o t h e s i s t h e r e
i s evident t h a t
b e a pseudonorm i n t h e R i e s z s p a c e
L
such
Ch. 15,§1041
that
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
q(f) = 0
f = 0
implies
h o l d i f i n s t e a d of t h e norm
. Many P
349
r e s u l t s i n t h e p r e s e n t s e c t i o n continue
we have t o do w i t h t h e pseudonorm
.
q
p r e c i s e l y , show t h a t t h e f o l l o w i n g h o l d s . ( i ) Every o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i s q-Cauchy i f and only i f every o r d e r bounded upwards d i r e c t e d system i s q-Cauchy. ( i i ) If
0 S u
i s o r d e r continuous and
q
4 u
i n (u,) such t h a t 0 5 u 4 u . n ,n ( i i i ) The c o n d i t i o n s i n Lemna 103.3 h o l d (with
,
then there e x i s t s a
sequence
(iv)
q
i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f
q
i n s t e a d of
p )
.
i s o-order continuous
q
and every o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i s q-Cauchy. (v)
q
i s a-order continuous and
L
i s Dedekind o-complete
only i f every o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i s q-convergent
if and only i f
q
i s o r d e r continuous and
gent ( i n p a r t i c u l a r , i f q
L
i s a complete m e t r i c space w i t h r e s p e c t t o
and a l s o i f and only i f
i s o-order continuous
q
i s Dedekind o-complete.
L
(vii) I f
q
i s o r d e r continuous, t h e n
104. Meyer-Nieberg's
L
h a s t h e Egoroff p r o p e r t y .
lemma and d i s j o i n t sequences
I n Theorem 103.9 i t was proved t h a t t h e norm
i n a Banach l a t t i c e
p
i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f e v e r y o r d e r bounded in
q ),
i s o r d e r continuous i f and o n l y i f e v e r y o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g
sequence i s q-convergent and
i s Dedekind complete.
If every o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g q-Cauchy sequence i s q-conver-
(vi) then
L
i f and
and a l s o
L
i n c r e a s i n g sequence
h a s a norm l i m i t . We s h a l l prove now t h a t t h e s e c o n d i t i o n s a r e equi-
L
v a l e n t t o t h e c o n d i t i o n t h a t f o r e v e r y o r d e r bounddd sequence of d i s j o i n t P o s i t i v e elements i n p. Meyer-Nieberg
(C
t h e norm tends t o zero. This r e s u l t i s due t o
L
1 1 , 1 9 7 3 ) . For t h e proof we need a lemma, known a s
Meye r - N i ebe r g ' s lemma. LEMMA 104.1. Let
. .)
p
be a Riesz seminorm i n the Riesz space
be a sequence of p o s i t i v e elements i n L following conditions. (fn:n=l,2,.
There e x i s t s a number E > 0 There e x i s t s a number C > 0
(i) (ii)
such t h a t such that
(iii) The sequence i s order bounded, i.e., and aZZ
n
.
L
and l e t
, s a t i s f y i n g the
p(fn) t I + €
for a l l
n
.
P ( E ~ = f~ k ) S C for at2 n.
0 s fn 2 fo
for some f u € L
350
MEYER-NIEBERG'S
Then there e x i s t s a subsequence ( f k l , f k ,...) ( g l , g 2 , ...Iof d i s j o i n t elements such d a t 0 for a l l
n
a > 0
( f k l , f k2,...)
with
n 2 no
fll = f,
By assumption, such t h a t
so
p(gn) 2 1
b e given. We show f i r s t t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s a subse-
. In o t h e r words,
such t h a t
no
.
; j = 2,3,
i E
< I+;€
p((afl-fn)-)
t h e r e e x i s t s a subsequence
(f
and < 1 +
dition ( I ) ,
L
such t h a t
I f n o t , t h e r e e x i s t s a n a t u r a l number for a l l
and a sequence gn 5 fk, and 1
5
.
PROOF. Let quence
Ch. 15,51041
LEMMA
* j =1,2, ...)
Ij.
... .
does n o t have a subsequence s a t i s f y i n g con-
(f 1 2 , f 1 3 , . .) (fll,fI2,fl3,
...)
( f Z 1, f 2 2 .
c o n t a i n s a subsequence
- -.)
f Z 1 = f 1 2 and p((af21-f2j)-)
1~
< 1 +
; j = 2,3,
Repeating t h i s procedure and s e t t i n g a subsequence
(gl,g2,
... )
p((agk-gj)-)
of
g
(fl,f2, for
< 1 +
=
...) j
... .
fkl
for
k
=
1,2,
...
, we
obtain
such t h a t
> k
.
This l e a d s t o a c o n t r a d i c t i o n , however, because a C 2 a ~ ( ~ gk) ~ = =l P(ngn+l-(gn+l-agl)-. 2 p(ngn+l-(gn+l-agl)+-.
..-(gn+l-agn) +\I 2
(agk-gn+l)-) for
n = 1,2,
... . Hence,
.-(gn+
2 n(l+E)
-
t h e assumption i s f a l s e , s o
subsequence s a t i s f y i n g c o n d i t i o n ( 1 ) . Now, l e t where
(fkn)
a = 3 ~ - lp(f ) 0
and w r i t e
h
= ( f k -afk
i s t h e subsequence s a t i s f y i n g ( I )
n(l
( f l , f 2,...)
has a
... ,
) + f o r n = 2,3, n 1 f o r t h i s particular value
Ch.
15,51041
of
a
0 5 h
. Finally, "
5 fk
n
g l I hn
so
and
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
5
0 5 g
w r i t e g1 = ( f k - a - l f 0 ) + Then f o r n = 2,3, .'Furthermore
for
...
n = 2,3,
... . The norms
l
S
fk
and
1
satisfy
.
for a l l n p(h ) Z I + ; € n We have t h u s o b t a i n e d a n element
i n t h e d i s j o i n t complement of
0
.
35 1
hn
5
f
g1
gl
and a sequence
such t h a t
w i t h norms s a t i s f y i n g
O
g1
fkl
kn p(gl) t 1
and
p(h ) 2 1 + n
;E
Applying t h e same p r o c e d u r e t o t h e sequence p o s i t i v e element
g2
with
p(g2) t 1
for
n = 2,3,
...)
:n=2,3,
(hn
and
... .
(hn:n=2,3, ...)
, we
find the
and m a j o r i z e d by one of t h e
(and t h e r e f o r e m a j o r i z e d by one of t h e
hn ) . Continuing, we o b t a i n a
sequence w i t h t h e d e s i r e d p r o p e r t i e s . By means of t h i s lemma i t i s now e a s y t o prove t h e f o l l o w i n g theorem.
THEOREM 104.2. I n a normed Riesz space
L
t h e following conditions are
equivalent. (i)
Every order bounded increasing sequence i n L
i s a p-Cauchy
sequence. ( i i ) For every order bounded sequence o f d i s j o i n t positive
in
L
elements
the norm tends t o zero.
In a Banach l a t t i c e these conditions are therefore equivalent t o the
condition that every order bounded increasing sequence i n L i n norm, that i s t o say (by Theorem 103.9), only i f the norm p i s order continuous.
i s convergent
these conditions hold i f and
35 2
PROOF. ( i )
=$
Ch. 15,01041
LEMMA
MEYER-NIEBERG'S
( i i ) . L e t ( i ) hold and l e t
.
...)
(~=1,2,
,
L
s o by assumption t h i s i s a p-Cauchy
implies t h a t (ii)
p(um) = p ( s
-s
) + 0
m m-l ( i ) . L e t ( i i ) h o l d and l e t
as
-.
sequence, which immediately
m
+
(g : n = l , Z ,
i s n o t a p-Cauchy sequence, t h e r e e x i s t s a number
,. ..) w i t h n l < n2 < ... ... . I n t h i s c a s e , i f E >
such t h a t
)
0
Then
-1 f k 5 6 (I+€)f0
C
The sequence
(fl,f2,
for all
...)
. This
~ ( g ~ ~ + >~ 6 - fgo r~ ~ )
for
k = l,Z,
... .
. Furthermore,
k
and
p ( f k ) t I+E
s a t i s f i e s , t h e r e f o r e , t h e c o n d i t i o n s of Meyer-
t i v e e l e m e n t s , majorized by n
0 5 g 1.2 f o . I f (8,) n and a subsequence
6 > 0
lemma, s o t h e r e e x i s t s a d i s j o i n t sequence
Nieberg's
h e an o r d e r bounded
i s given, l e t
0
f k = 6-1(1+E)(g%+l -g nk
...)
L , so
i n c r e a s i n g sequence of p o s i t i v e elements i n (gn ,gn 1 2 k = 1,2,
be an o r d e r
L Then s = Em m n=l un i s an o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence of p o s i t i v e elements
hounded sequence of d i s j o i n t p o s i t i v e elements i n in
...)
(un:n=l,2,
6-'(l+c)f0
(hl,h2,
and s a t i s f y i n g
c o n t r a d i c t s h y p o t h e s i s ( i i ) . Hence, ( g l , g 2 ,
...)
...)
p(h )
2
of posifor all
I
i s a p-Cauchy
sequence. EXERCISE 104.3. that i f
L
Let
L
b e a Dedekind o-complete Banach l a t t i c e . Show
i s s e p a r a b l e ( w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e norm
p ) , then
p
i s order
continuous. HINT: I f
p
j o i n t sequence
all
n
. For
i s n o t o r d e r continuous t h e r e e x i s t s a n o r d e r bounded d i s ( u 1 , u 2 , ...) of p o s i t i v e elements such t h a t
A
any s u b s e t
. The
p(un)
>_
1
for
of t h e s e t of n a t u r a l numbers, l e t
i s uncountable and f o r d i f f e r e n t subuA s e t s A and B of t h e n a t u r a l numbers w e have p(u -u ) >_ 1 This c o n t r a A B d i c t s t h e norm s e p a r a b i l i t y .
uA = sup(un:n€A)
EXERCISE 104.4. Riesz space
L
set of a l l
Let
such t h a t
(pa:a€{a}) pa(f) = 0
.
be a system of R i e s z seminorms i n t h e for all
a
implies
f = 0
and l e t
a. I 5 , § l 0 5 l T
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
b e t h e corresponding topology i n
102.23). The topology to z e r o i n u
(i)
in
C 0
L
.
u
n
u
converges t o zero i n
converges
u
in
C 0
100.18 and
and
L
i f and only i f
L
i s Dedekind o-complete
and
i f and only i f
L
i s Dedekind complete and
T
is
L
T-Cauchy i f and only i f every o r d e r bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n
T
is
L
i s Lebesgue.
( i i i ) Show t h a t every o r d e r bounddd i n c r e a s i n g sequence i n
t o zero i n
is
L
i s o-Lebesgue.
T
Show t h a t every o r d e r bounded upwards d i r e c t e d s e t i n
T-convergent
is
T
f o r any d e c r e a s i n g
T
n Show t h a t every o r d e r b o u n d e d ' i n c r e a s i n g sequence i n
T-convergent (ii)
i s c a l l e d a Lebesgue topology i f
T
s a i d t o b e o-lebesgue i f sequence
L ( a s i n E x e r c i s e s 100.17,
f o r any downwards d i r e c t e d system
T
35 3
.
tends
L
P a r t ( i i i ) , even under somewhat more g e n e r a l c o n d i t i o n s , i s proved i n D.H.
F r e m l i n ' s book ( [ I ] , P r o p o s i t i o n
Meyer-Nieberg's
24H); t h e proof does n o t depend on
lemma.
105. Ando's theorem and t h e o r d e r topology I n s e c t i o n 100 i t was proved t h a t i n a Banach l a t t i c e every o r d e r c l o s e d
s e t i s norm c l o s e d and every norm c l o s e d s e t i s r e l a t i v e l y uniformly closed. This i s no l o n g e r always t r u e i n a normed Riesz space which i s n o t a Banach l a t t i c e ; t h e r e may e x i s t o r d e r c l o s e d s e t s t h a t f a i l t o b e norm c l o s e d (Example 100.13). It remains t r u e , however, t h a t i n a normed Riesz space every o r d e r c l o s e d i d e a l i s norm c l o s e d (Theorem 100.7). s i n c e an o r d e r c l o s e d i d e a l i s t h e same a s a o - i d e a l ,
L
I n o t h e r words,
every a - i d e a l i n
L
norm c l o s e d . The converse i s f a l s e ; t h e i d e a l in L
(c,) of all n u l l sequences Lrn i s norm c l o s e d , b u t i t i s n o t a o - i d e a l . We s h a l l prove now t h a t i n
every norm c l o s e d i d e a l i s o r d e r c l o s e d ( i . e . ,
only i f
i t i s a a - i d e a l ) i f and
i s o-order continuous. S i m i l a r l y , every norm c l o s e d i d e a l i s a
p
band i f and only i f t h a t f o r every i d e a l o r d e r c l o s u r e of
i s o r d e r continuous (T. Ando,1965).
p
A
in
L
t h e norm c l o s u r e of
i f arid only i f
A
A
It w i l l f o l l o w
i s t h e same a s t h e
i s o-order continuous.
p
THEOREM 105.1. The following conditions i n the normed Riesz space
are equivalent. (i)
p
(ii)
If f n
implies n c O then p ( f n ) + 0
i s a-order continuous, i . e . , +
0
i n order i n
L
,
u
.
p(un)
c
O
L
.
is
354
TnEomM AND
ANDO'S
( i i i ) Every norm closed s e t i n
subset
(iv)
PROOF. ( i )
...)
=$
*
in
f
f-f
n
3
D fn
0
+
0
.
i s order cZosed (hence, f o r every
fn
i n o r d e r . There e x i s t s a sequence lfnl
5
p
n
, so
C 0
p ( f n ) 5 p(p ) C 0 n
b e a norm c l o s e d s u b s e t of in
D
. We have
i n o r d e r , we have
E D , since a l l (it;)
p(fn)
( i i i ) Let + 0
-t
such t h a t
L
( i n order) with a l l Since
fn
( i i ) Let
( i ) . This shows t h a t (ii)
L
-t
0
D
(iv)
+
=5
-f
belongs t o
L
.
P
i s o r d e r c l o s e d by
.
+ p{(au-un)+}
+
0
<
E
. Choose > 0 , and . It f o l l o w s t h e n from E
. Since
(au-u )+ i s d e c r e a s i n g a s n n c r e a s e s , i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove now t h a t p{(au-u ) + I 5 E f o r some p(u-u )
c
E
system o-ideal
n
.
in-
n
,
p(u-u ) < Z E f o r a l l m t n Observing t h a t u - au 1. ( I - a ) u n + m (u -au) 1. (1-a)u , s o d e n o t h g by A t h e i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by t h e n , i t i s e v i d e n t t h a t u belongs t o t h e (vn=(un-au)+:n=1,2,
s i n c e then
we get
.
D
( i ) This i s t h e more d i f f i c u l t p a r t of t h e p r o o f . Let
u u in L We have t o prove t h a t p(u-un) n t h e n take a such t h a t 0 < a < 1 and (1-a)p(u)
that
f
i s norm c l o s e d (as obser-
L
hypothesis. 5
f
fn
by
by h y p o t h e s i s . This i m p l i e s
belong t o t h e norm c l o s e d s e t
( i v ) Every o r d e r c l o s e d i d e a l i n
and l e t
L
t o prove t h a t
p(f-fn)
ved above). Conversely, e v e r y norm c l o s e d i d e a l i n
0
IS,§lO51
of L , t h e order closure of S i s contained i n the norm S 1. Norm closed i d e a l s i n L are t h e same as order closed i d e a l s .
S
closure of
(pn:n=1,2,
Ch.
ORDER TOPOLOGY
...)
A
g e n e r a t e d by
by h y p o t h e s i s , s o
A-
-p
A
. The
norm c l o s u r e
i s a o-ideal containing
,
-
A of A i s o r d e r c l o s e d P A But t h e n Acontains
.
P
E A, c A . This i m p l i e s t h a t , f o r t h e given E > 0 , t h e r e e x i s t s P an element w E A such t h a t p(u-w) < E . Then w+ E A and p(u-w+) < E . I n o t h e r words, w e may j u s t a s w e l l assume immediately t h a t 0 < w E A . S i m i l a r l y , r e p l a c i n g w by i n f ( w , u ) , we may assume t h a t 0 5 w < u . From
A,
,
so
u
t h e d e f i n i t i o n of t h e i d e a l
n
such t h a t
v n
= (u
-au)+
w
A
i t follows t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s a n a t u r a l number
i s c o n t a i n e d i n t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by
, so
Ch. 15,51051
Since both
and
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
and
w
2 p(u-w)
p{(au-un)+)
SO
a r e majorized by
(uu-u ) + n
Every barid i n
<
E
.
u
355
, we
get therefore that
This t h e desired r e s u l t .
i s a o - i d e a l and, t h e r e f o r e , i t i s a norm c l o s e d
L
i d e a l . It may b e asked i f , i n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n , t h e r e i s a c o n d i t i o n on t h e norm
p
under which every norm c l o s e d i d e a l is a band. A s may b e ex-
p e c t e d a f t e r t h e l a s t theorem, such a c o n d i t i o n should b e somewhat s t r o n g e r t h a n o-order
c o n t i n u i t y of
THEOREM 105.2.
R iesz space
L
ideal i n
i s a band i f and un2y i f
L
. For
p
T
an i n c r e a s i n g sequence
. Then
(u
Tn u
A
:n=1,2,
A
) C 0
...)
0 S u
i n t h e system of a l l
4 u
T
by t h e system of a l l r a t e d by A;
2
B
A
, which
, because
we s e t
v
v
follows t h a t
. It
4 u
and
i s a band.
A
and
= (uT-au)+
u
i s a band. It i s
L
. The proof
p(u-uT) C 0
implies
such t h a t
u
i s norm c l e s e d , we f i n d
A A
i s almost t h e same a s i n t h e p r e c e d i n g theorem; we choose before, f o r every
0 S u
by h y p o t h e s i s , s o t h e r e e x i s t s
Conversely, assume t h a t e v e r y norm c l o s e d i d e a l i n s u f f i c i e n t t o prove now t h a t
b e a norm c l o s e d
i s a band, assume t h a t
p(u-u
~ ( u - u ) C 0 , Since a l l belong t o Tn Tn This shows t h a t t h a t u belongs t o A
.
is order continuous.
p
be o r d e r continuous and l e t
t h e proof t h a t
E A for a l l
u
.
(Ando's theorem.) Every norm c2osed idea2 i n the normed
PROOF. L e t f i r s t with
p
A
e
and
as
a
i s t h e i d e a l generated
belongs t o t h e band
B
gene-
u E A- ( s i n c e Ap - i s a band by h y p o t h e s i s , so P i s t h e s m a l l e s t band c o n t a i n i n g A ). The remaining
implies
B
p a r t of t h e proof i s now e v i d e n t . The method of proof i n t h e l a s t two theorems i s due t o T. Ando, who perLuxemburg (Theorem
m i t t e d h i s r e s u l t t o b e included i n a p a p e r by W.A.J.
4 7 . 3 i n Note X I V of C31, 1965). It i s of i n t e r e s t t o observe t h a t t h e condit i o n t h a t e v e r y norm c l o s e d i d e a l should b e a band i s e q u i v a l e n t t o a cond i t i o n t h a t a t f i r s t s i g h t seems weaker. We r e c a l l t h a t f o r any order dual
L"
set of a l l
f E L
of a Riesz s p a c e satisfying
L
t h e null i d e a l
1$1(lfl) = 0
. If
L
N
$
$
i n the
i s d e f i n e d as t h e
i s normed and i f
ANDO’ S THEOREM AND ORDER TOPOLOGY
356
$
E L* , t h e n i t i s e a s y t o see t h a t
N
i s norm c l o s e d . Hence, i f
$
o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s , t h e n (by our l a s t theorem) N $ E L*
. We
ideal
N
Ch. I5,§lO5l
$
s h a l l prove now t h a t i f i n t h e normed Riesz space
i s a band & o r e v e r y
4
,
$ E L*
then
is
p
i s a band f o r e v e r y L
the null
i s o r d e r continuous.
p
Furthermore, w e i n c l u d e s t i l l a n o t h e r e q u i v a l e n t c o n d i t i o n . THEOREM 105.3. The following conditions f o r the normed Riesz space
L
are equivalent. (i)
Every norm closed i d e a l i s a band ( i . e . ,
(ii)
For every
$ E L*
the n u l l i d e a l N
( i i i ) For every
$ E L*
which i s not the n u l l functional the c a r r i e r
i s a band.
$
+ {OI .
c+
C$ = ( N ~ s) a~t i s f i e s
i s order continuous).
p
PROOF. As observed above, ( i ) i m p l i e s ( i i ) . It i s a l s o e v i d e n t t h a t
0 # 4 E L*
( i i ) i m p l i e s ( i i i ) because i f g e n e r a t e d by implies
N
4
i s t h e whole of
NO
, so 4
= L
.
0
=
.
L
and
Since
C N
Contradiction.
$
0
,
= {O)
t h e n t h e band
i t s e l f i s a band, t h i s
I n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n , we f i r s t prove t h a t ( i i i ) i m p l i e s ( i i ) . Assume, f o r t h i s purpose, t h a t ( i i i ) h o l d s and l e t The r e s t r i c t i o n of
. Let
t o t h e band
$
1
{N
$
0 5 $ E L*
g e n e r a t e d by
b e t h e minimal p o s i t i v e e x t e n s i o n of
N
b e given.
w i l l b e denoted
$
t o t h e whole of m d L Hence, by Theorem 83.3, = I) on IN$) and I)m = 0 on {N$} = C $ . I t f o l l o w s t h a t I)m v a n i s h e s on N 8 C $ + ’ so t h e n u l l i d e a l of I)m cont a i n s t h e o r d e r dense i d e a l N 8 C But t h e n t h e c a r r i e r of $m c o n s i s t s
by
of
.
I)
I)
only, so
{O)
t h e band
{N+)
I)
m
, i.e.,
0
0
=
N
I)
0 -
by h y p o t h e s i s . This i m p l i e s t h a t = {N
$
$
,
so
N
i s a band. I f
$
v a n i s h e s on
$
$ E L*
and
is
$
N = N , s o N i s a band a l s o i n t h i s case. $ F i n a l l y , assuming ( i i ) , we prove ( i ) . For t h i s purpose, l e t A be a
not positive, then
norm c l o s e d i d e a l and l e t not i n
A
,
so
p(u) > 0
. It
cause
0
follows t h a t
A
.,
b e a p o s i t i v e element i n
=
such t h a t
\I)\ s a t i s f i e s
i s a n i d e a l ) . Furthermore,
band by h y p o t h e s i s . g e n e r a t e d by
A
not contained i n
i s contained i n A
such t h a t
$
I)(u) = p(u) > 0
$(u) > 0
. It
N
4
and
u
. Hence,
A c N
since
I) = 0
and
$ = 0
i s a n element of
It f o l l o w s , t h e r e f o r e , from
u i s n o t contained i n {A}
L
is
By one of t h e v a r i a n t s of t h e Hahn-Banach theorem
I) E L*
t h e r e e x i s t s an element
A
u
L*
on
, so
A
(be-
N
$ t h a t t h e barid
$ $(u) > 0
,
on
is a {A}
t h e element
h a s been proved t h u s t h a t any p o s i t i v e element
i s not contained i n
{A}
e i t h e r . This shows t h a t
Ch. I5,§105l
,
A = {A}
357
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
i.e., A
i s a band
We s h a l l prove now s e v e r a l simple lemmas r e l a t e d t o t h e r e s u l t proved above t h a t norm c l o s e d i d e a l s i n and only i f
a r e t h e same a s o r d e r c l o s e d i d e a l s i f
L
i s o-order continuous. F i r s t we r e c a l l t h e d e f i n i t i o n s of
p
t h e o r d e r c l o s u r e and t h e pseudo o r d e r c l o s u r e of a s u b s e t i n an a r b i t r a r y Riesz s p a c e
L
( c f . s e c t i o n 1 6 ) . The o r d e r c l o s e d s e t s i n
of
L
with the property t h a t i f
sets
S
all
,
n
then
. These
f E S
fn
+
f
a r e t h e sub-
L
i n o r d e r and
fn € S
for
s e t s s a t i s f y the conditions f o r closed s e t s of
a topology, t h e o r d e r topology. The o r d e r c l o s u r e of an a r b i t r a r y s u b s e t of
i s t h e c l o s u r e of
L
-
a l s o by
. The
Sor
of a l l
f
pseudo o r d e r c l o s u r e
such t h a t
E L
of
S'
S
cl(S)
i s by d e f i n i t i o n t h e s e t
i s t h e o r d e r l i m i t of a sequence i n
f
2r
S
or
S
. The
h o l d and i t was proved i n Theorem 16.6 t h a t
S c S ' c S-
inclusions
i n t h e o r d e r topology, denoted by
S
S = S'
-
already implies S = S and t h a t S ' = ( S ' ) ' a l r e a d y i m p l i e s S ' = 'or or Furthermore, i n Theorem 65.3 i t was shown t h a t i f A i s an i d e a l i n L ,
A
ideal
-
and
A'
then so a r e
the ideals
*
Aor
. We
s h a l l prove now, more p r e c i s e l y , t h a t f o r any
A'
and
A,,
-
c o i n c i d e . A t t h e same time, t h i s w i l l
g i v e an a l t e r n a t i v e approach t o t h e s t a t e m e n t i n Theorem 20.3 about t h e a - i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by a given i d e a l . LEMMA 105.4.
in order w i t h a l l 0 5 u
that
4 f+
A
(i) I f
A
f i
with a l l and
-f
Pn
( i ) If
.
A
+
. Let
i n the R$esz space
-
f
ideal
A'
f
with a l l
f
+ "+
0 S u
4 f+
that
n
0
5
A
in t h e i d e a l
f
(A')' c A'
, then
. Similarly, un
.
f o r each
+
fn
,... . Then
+
p
0 5 u
f o r any i d e a l
f
+ E
"+
4 f
A
.
A
.
i s t h e o r d e r l i m i t of a sequence i n t h e
s o by p a r t ( i ) t h e r e e x i s t elements
unk
L the pseudo order closure
,...,
n
E ( A ' ) ' , t h e element
,
f
are the same.
( i i ) It i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t
Given
+
0 5 u E A such n 0 I vn E A such t h a t
pn = i n f ( f ,f ) f o r n = 1 , 2 n It f o l l o w s t h a t u = s u p ( p l p,) E A and
in
f+
fn
there e d s t elements
Aor
and the order closure PROOF.
fn
and
L
i n A , t h e n there e x i s t elements
fn
. Similarly,
0 s v 4 f - . n ( i i ) For any i d e a l
A'
i s an i d e a l i n the Riesz space
u
n ' Then, w r i t i n g
u
t h e r e exis:
E A'
such t h a t
elements
u
nk
E A
such
358
we have
wk
vnk E A
5
f+
for a l l
. Let
w
for a l l
k
n 2 m
for
Ch. I5,§lO5l
ANDO'S THEOREM AND ORDER TOPOLOGY
=
. Any
and, furthermore, v
n,k
vkk
for
k = l,2,
upper bound
nk
... . Then
1.
wk
k
u and vnk t vmk n i s i n c r e a s i n g and
of t h e sequence
p
(w : k = l , 2 , k
satisfies
so
we g e t
(k-)
p 2 un
for a l l
n
,
, which
implies
p t f+
i s the l e a s t upper bound of t h e sequence, i . e . ,
f+
that
k 2 n
for
p 2 wk = vkk t vnk
f + E A'
shows t h a t
. Similarly
f- E A'
...)
, and
f E A'
so
. It
w 4 f+ k
.
follows
. This
The next l e m a follows immediately. LEMMA 105.5. For any i d e a l
-
closure
A
P
of
A
i n the normed Riesz space
A
L
the norm
i s an i d e a l s a t i s f y i n g
PROOF. The order c l o s u r e
-
i s an o r d e r closed i d e a l , s o
Aor
-
norm closed by Theorem 100.7. The norm closure closed s e t containing
A
,
so
A,
c
A
-
Aor
is
i s t h e s m a l l e s t norm
Air . The proof P
that
i s simple.
i s an i d e a l
A-
P
We can now extend Theorem 105.1 as follows.
THEOREM 105.6. The norm
i n the nomed Riesz space
p
continuous i f and only i f , f o r eoery i d e a l i s t h e same as the order closure PROOF. Assume f i r s t t h a t
p
-
Aor
.
A
in L
L
i s o-order
, t h e norm closure
A-
that so
- p
A
ideal
P
A
L
. On account
of
A c A- c P
Air
i s o r d e r closed. This i s evident s i n c e i s order closed. Conversely, assume t h a t
. Since
P
i s a-order continuous, so norm closed
i d e a l s a r e t h e same a s o r d e r closed i d e a l s by Theorem 105.1. Let arbitrary ideal i n
-
A
A
be an
i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o show
A-
P
i s a norm closed i d e a l ,
A- = Aholds f o r every P or every o r d e r closed i d e a l i s norm closed (Theorem 100.7), i t
i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t every norm closed i d e a l i s o r d e r closed, i . e . ,
Ch. lS,§l051
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t
implies
A = AP
from t h e h y p o t h e s i s .
The q u e s t i o n a r i s e s whether e q u a l i t y of A
in
A
L S
-
-
and t h e o r d e r c l o s u r e
P
A;
ask whether
=
Air
Sor
. This
A = Aor
-
-
Aor
and
P i m p l i e s perhaps t h a t , f o r e v e r y s u b s e t
closure and
359
of
S
L
i s evident
f o r every i d e a l
,
t h e norm
a r e t h e same. I n o t h e r words, we
A
f o r every i d e a l
implies t h a t t h e topologies
T
P
a r e i d e n t i c a l . The answer i s t h a t t h i s i s n o t s o , a s shown by t h e
T
or f o l l o w i n g theorem and t h e example n e x t t o i t . THEOREM 105.7. The norm topoZogy
T
and t h e order topoZogy
P
in
T~~
the normed Riesz space L are identicaZ i f and onZy i f t h e norm p i s o-order continuous and every norm cunvergent sequence i n L has an order convergent subsequence. In p a r t i c u l a r , since t h e Zast condition i s s a t i s f i e d i n any Banach Zattice, t h e norm topology and the order topoZogy i n a Banach l a t t i c e are i d e n t i c a l i f and onZy i f the norm i s o-order continuous.
Air
.
T = T Then A- = f o r any i d e a l A P or P i s a-order continuous by t h e l a s t theorem. It remains t o prove t h a t
PROOF. Assume f i r s t t h a t so
p
,
e v e r y norm convergent sequence has an o r d e r convergent subsequence. Hence, let
p(f-fn) + 0
in
.
L
If
fn = f
f o r i n f i n i t e l y many
n
, we
l y have an o r d e r convergent subsequence. Assume, t h e r e f o r e , t h a t fn # f
. Omitting
n
f o r only f i n i t e l y many assume t h a t
f o r only f i n i t e l y many
m
a s well assume t h a t
# fn
f
Then S'
of
Hence
fm
(since
i s not equal t o
S
, where
c o n t a i n s only t h e p o i n t b e a p o i n t of
S'
. It
verging i n order t o
f
f
these
= f n from t h e sequence, we may
fn
any f i x e d
n
f m tends t o
f
m # n
for
does n o t belong t o S c S' c Sir
. For
n
for a l l
, but
. Let
S
, we
can have f = f m n i n norm). Hence, w e may
b e t h e set
(fl,f2,
.
...I
.
f E S- = S i r The pseudo o r d e r c l o s u r e P i t s e l f , because S = S ' would imply S = S-o r
S
S
-
t h e f i r s t i n c l u s i o n i s proper. But b e s i d e s t h e p o i n t s of
follows t h a t
.
Conversely, assume t h a t
immediatef
S
i t s e l f , so
.
S i r = SP f must
(fn:n=1,2, ...) has a subsequence con-
i s o-order continuous and every norm con-
p
v e r g e n t sequence h a s an o r d e r convergent subsequence. We prove f i r s t , u s i n g only t h e o-order c o n t i n u i t y of closed. L e t
S
all
S
fn
in
, that
p
e v e r y norm c l o s e d s e t i s o r d e r
b e a norm c l o s e d s u b s e t of
. Then
p(f-fn)
-f
0
since
L p
and l e t
fn
+
f
i n order with
i s o-order continuous (Theorem
360
f
l05.l), s o
E
since
S
i s norm c l o s e d . This shows t h a t
S
c l o s e d . I n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n , assume t h a t s e t of
L
and l e t
fn
+
f
i n norm w i t h a l l
s i s , t h e r e e x i s t s a subsequence f E S
since
S
gk = f
T
and
P
EXAMPLE 105.8. ( i ) L e t Lebesgue measure, where
T
u
n
on
. Then,
S
by hypothe-
or
L = L l f?
i s norm c l o s e d . I t h a s
S
on t h e i n t e r v a l
L,
1
Then
T
P
= T
or
.
with
[0,11
i s n o t only a-order
p
...
n = 1,2,
,
let
and z e r o e l s e w h e r e . Then
[0,n-21
, so
f
have t h e same c l o s e d sets, so
c o n t i n u o u s , b u t even o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s . F o r function equal t o
in
converging i n o r d e r t o
i s t h e L -norm.
p
is order
S
i s an o r d e r c l o s e d sub-
S
fn
"k i s o r d e r c l o s e d . T h i s shows t h a t
b e e n shown t h u s t h a t
so
Ch. 15,§l05l
ANDO'S THEOREM AND ORDER TOPOLOGY
be the
u
p(uz) = n
-1
,
converges i n norm t o z e r o . There does n o t e x i s t any subsequence
n 0 implies p j 2 u converging i n o r d e r t o z e r o , b e c a u s e 0 5 un j s P j "k f o r a l l k 2 j , s o p . would b e a n unbounded f u n c t i o n , which i s i m p o s s i b l e . J It f o l l o w s t h a t , a l t h o u g h A- = Af o r e v e r y i d e a l A i n L , t h e topoloP or and T a r e n o t t h e same. Every norm c l o s e d s e t i s o r d e r c l o s e d gies T P or ( a s observed above, t h i s f o l l o w s from t h e a - o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of p ) , s o
+
.
S i r c Sf o r every S c L The s e t S = ( u 1 , u 2 , . ..) above i s an example P of a n o r d e r c l o s e d s e t which f a i l s t o b e norm c l o s e d . Compare t h e s p a c e i n t h i s example w i t h t h e s p a c e i n E x e r c i s e 100.13. ( i i ) For t h e n e x t example w e prove f i r s t t h a t i f Riesz-Fischer
L
s a t i s f i e s t h e weak L
c o n d i t i o n , t h e n e v e r y norm c o n v e r g e n t sequence i n
has a
r e l a t i v e l y u n i f o r m l y c o n v e r g e n t subsequence. To b e g i n w i t h , n o t e t h a t i f
,...
-3 E L+ f o r n = 1,2 and p(vn) < n f o r a l l n , then n s o by t h e weak Riesz-Fischer c o n d i t i o n t h e r e e x i s t s s t 0 i n
v
nv
5 s
if
fn
for a l l
n
, which
implies
converges i n norm t o
f
with
,
.
v
S
n
-1
s
, i.. e . ,
Zp(nvn) < L
m
such t h a t
.
v -t 0 ( r u ) Hence, n gk = f (k=l,2, ) "k 0 ( r u ) by what w a s j u s t
t a k e a subsequence
...
p(f-g ) 5 k-3 f o r a l l k Then f-gk -t k proved. As an immediate consequence i t f o l l o w s t h a t any norm convergent
sequence i n a normed Riesz s p a c e p o s s e s s i n g t h e weak R i e s z - F i s c h e r p r o p e r t y h a s a l s o an o r d e r convergent subsequence. This l e a d s t h e n t o t h e r e s u l t t h a t if
L
h a s t h e weak Riesz-Fischer
p r o p e r t y , t h e n t h e norm topology and t h e
o r d e r topology c o i n c i d e i f and o n l y i f
p
i s a-order continuous.
Ando's theorem can b e g e n e r a l i z e d t o t h e c a s e t h a t norm i n t h e R i e s z s p a c e
L
. For
n e c e s s a r i l y Archimedean) and l e t
t h i s purpose, l e t p
s e c t i o n 102, t h e s e t of a l l p-bounded
L
p
i s a Riesz s e m i -
be a Riesz space (not
b e a Riesz seminorm i n
L
l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s on
L
. AS
in
is d e n o t e d
,
Ch. 15,§1051
by
me
.
n = 1,2, of
of
D
L
. It
such t h a t in
36 1
D
...
and
p(f-fn)
-f
0
. For
f E D
that
t h e s m a l l e s t p-closed s e t c o n t a i n i n g
i s e a s y t o s e e t h a t t h e p-closure of p(f-fn)
. Denoting
-f
f o r some sequence
0
the ideal
(f:p(f)=O)
an a r b i t r a r y s u b s e t
i s c a l l e d t h e p-closure
D
by
N
,
with a l l
fn as i n s e c t i o n 102, i t i s
f o l l o w s immediately from t h e d e f i n i t i o n s t h a t , f o r any ideal
N
4
i s p-closed.
Note a l s o t h a t t h e p - c l o s u r e
is a g a i n a n i d e a l . Indeed, i f
/gl 5
,
If1
5
so
for
gn = i n f ( l f n l , g + ) E A
then
o s
g+
-
gn = i n f ( / f ,g+)
llfl-If
p(g+-gn) + 0 g-
. Hence
II
2
, which g E A;
If-f
. This
with a l l
(i)
L
of an i d e a l fn
in
.
It
the null A
A
in
and i f
5
g+
shows t h a t
i s contained i n AP
A-
. Similarly
i s an i d e a l .
theorem.
is a Riesz seminorm i n
P
.
p(un) i
P
L/Np
,
I ,
If every p-closed i d e a l i n
continuous, i . e . ,
-
I$ E L*
and
THEOREM 105.9. The following r e s u l t s hold i f
the Riesz space
A
- i n f ( l f n l ,g+)
implies t h a t
We now e x t e n d Ando's
'
+ 0
p(f-f,)
f E L
c o n s i s t s of a l l
D
( f n : n = l , 2 , ...)
P e v i d e n t how t o i n t e r p r e t t h e s e n o t i o n s i n t h e normed R i e s z space
L
.
N
L* = L* I t was proved i n Theorem 102.3 t h a t L* i s an i d e a l i n L P s u b s e t D of L i s s a i d t o b e p-closed i f i t f o l l o w s from f n E D
for D
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
o
L
i s a a-ideal, then
f o r any sequence
u
.L 0
( i i ) If every p-closed icieal in L i s a band, then tinuous, i . e . , p ( u T ) c 0 for any downwards directed s e t PROOF. ( i ) The proof i s t h e same as f o r ( i i )
*
i s a-order
p
.
p
is order con-
u
i 0
.
( i ) i n Theorem 105.1.
( i i ) A s i n Theorem 105.2. I f e v e r y p-closed f o r every
4 E L*
. The
i d e a l i s a band, t h e n i n p a r t i c u l a r
N
i s a band
4
converse h o l d s as w e l l , as shown by t h e n e x t theorem.
Hence, i n p a r t ( i i ) of t h e l a s t theorem above i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o know t h a t N4
i s a band f o r e v e r y
c o n t i n u o u s if and o n l y i f
I$ E L* ( i . e . , w e g e t t h e r e s u l t t h a t N
4
only i f e v e r y p-closed i d e a l i n
i s a band f o r e v e r y L
i s a band).
p
i s order
4 E L* , and a l s o if and
ANDO'S THEOREM AND ORDER TOPOLOGY
362
THEOREM 105.10. Let
PROOF. Assume t h a t p-closed i d e a l i n
A
E A because
N
u
. Then
A
i s p-closed).
. Let
be a p o s i t i v e element i n
p(u) > 0
(since
p(u) = 0
.
i s a band
N4
4 E L*
i s a band f o r every
4
and l e t
L
i s n o t contained i n u
i s a band i f and only i f
.
4 E L*
L
be a Riesz seminorm i n the Riesz space
P
m e n every p-closed ideal i n L f o r every
Ch. I5,SlOSl
be a
A
such t h a t
L
u
would imply
From t h i s p o i n t on t h e proof i s e x a c t l y t h e
same a s i n Theorem 105.3. should be a band i s necessary N4 t o b e o r d e r continuous. I f , however, we know t h a t
A s shown e a r l i e r , t h e c o n d i t i o n t h a t but not sufficient for N
J,
0
$I
i s a band and, b e s i d e s t h a t , we know a l s o t h a t i n t h e i d e a l generated by
$I
,
then
N
i s a band f o r a l l
J,
i s o r d e r continuous. The proof
@
follows. THEOREM 105.11.
A
denote by
L be an arbitrary Riesz space, l e t
Let
the principal ideal i n L"
4 order continuous i f and only i f PROOF. I f
N
J,€ A4
i n t r o d u c e t h e Riesz seminorm
. The members
p(f) = 1$1(lfl)
J,
in
A
of
in
p
@
E L" , and 4 is
Then
E A+
A
i s a band. Assume now, conversely, t h a t
. We
J,
J,
.
$
i s a band f c r every
J,
i s o r d e r continuous, t h e n every
$
t i n u o u s , and s o f o r every
N
generated by
.
i s o r d e r con-
4
N
J,
i s a band
by d e f i n i n g
L
a r e now e x a c t l y t h e p-bounded l i n e a r
4
is a NJi t h e l a s t theorem t h i s i s e q u i v a l e n t t o t h e s t a t e -
f u n c t i o n a l s , s o t h e h y p o t h e s i s can be expressed by s a y i n g t h a t
. By
J, E L*
band f o r every
ment t h a t every p-closed
i d e a l i s a band. It follows then from Ando's
theorem ( f o r seminorms) t h a t u
141
J. 0
,
. In
$
COROLLARY 105.12.
the band
Lz
A
f = 0
, is
+
0
f o r every downwards d i r e c t e d system
I$I
implies
(u,)
J. 0
. This
shows t h a t
o r d e r continuous.
If A i s an ideal i n
L"
, then
A
i s contained i n
of a l l order continuous linear functionals if and only i f
is a band f o r every of
J. 0
o t h e r words, u
and hence a l s o
p(u )
@
E A
=
101
. If, i n addition,
, i.e.,
satisfies
'A
, then
i s order dense i n Lz
A
i f
+(f) =
.
the inverse annihilator
o
f o r ~ Z Z4 E A
N o
A
implies
+
Ch.
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
I5,§lOSl
363
PROOF. The f i r s t p a r t i s c l e a r . Assume now t h a t
.
4J I J, f o r a l l J, E A We have t o prove t h a t 4 = 0 f o r a l l J, E A t h a t t h e c a r r i e r C satisfies 4J C4 I C f o r a l l J, E A , i . e . , C c N f o r a l l J, E A (Theorem 90.6). J, O J , This i m p l i e s t h a t i f 0 5 u E C i s g i v e n , t h e n $ ( u ) = 0 f o r a l l J, E A 4 s o u = 0 a c c o r d i n g t o our h y p o t h e s i s . Hence C = I 0 1 Since N is 4J d ' a band (because 4 E L; ) , we g e t now t h a t N = (C ) d = { O } = L , s o 4 4
Let
0
5
4J E L:
'A = {O}.
and
A c LL
and
.
4J I J,
I t follows from
.
,
4J=o.
COROLLARY 105.13. Every R i e s z seminom in
and only if L" = :L
.
N
PROOF. Assume f i r s t t h a t
L
. Then
that
N
, so
L* c L" = L :
L
every
i s a band f o r every
4J
L is order continuous if
N
= L
and l e t
E L* , and so
$
b e a Riesz seminorm i n
p
i s o r d e r continuous. This i m p l i e s
4 E L*
i s o r d e r continuous.
p
For t h e proof of t h e converse, assume t h a t every Riesz seminorm i n N
i s o r d e r continuous. L e t seminorm i n
L
,
T$
E L
t h e seminorm
4J
continuous. It follows t h a t
4J E L",
so
L"=
p
. Since
p(f)
=
L
\ $ i ( \ f \ ) i s a Riesz
i s o r d e r continuous, i . e . ,
i s order
101
i s o r d e r c.ontinuous. This holds f o r every
L;.
E a r l i e r i n t h i s s e c t i o n we have proved s e v e r a l theorems i n a normed Riesz s p a c e concerning t h e r e l a t i o n s b e t w e e n t h e o r d e r topology, t h e norm topology and o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y ( o r u-order
c o n t i n u i t y ) of t h e norm. It i s
n a t u r a l t o i n v e s t i g a t e a l s o whether t h e r e e x i s t s i m i l a r theorems i n which t h e norm topology and t h e r e l a t i v e l y uniform topology (ru-topology)
are
compared. The r e s u l t s i n t h i s d i r e c t i o n a r e n o t s o s t r i k i n g and t h e r e i s n o t such an e v i d e n t r e l a t i o n w i t h o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of t h e norm. The ru-closed f
s e t s i n an a r b i t r a r y Riesz s p a c e
L w i t h t h e property that i f
of
E
S
. These
ru-topology. only i f
L
f
are the subsets
L
E S n
for a l l
n
,
S
then
sets s a t i s f y t h e c o n d i t i o n s f o r c l o s e d sets of a topology, t h e
i s Archimedean. The r u - c l o s u r e of an a r b i t r a r y s u b s e t S
pseudo r u - c l o s u r e
S:u
f
and
S e t s c o n s i s t i n g of one p o i n t a r e c l o s e d i n t h i s topology i f and
i s t h e c l o s u r e of that
fn + f(ru)
i n t h e ru-topology;
i s t h e ru-limit
of
S
i t w i l l b e denoted by
i s by d e f i n i t i o n t h e s e t of a l l
of a sequence i n
h o l d and i t was proved i n Theorem 16.8 t h a t
S
. The
inclusions
S = S'
ru
-
S
Sru f
of
L
. The
E L such
S c Su :
already implies
c SiU
ANDO'S THEOREM AND ORDER TOPOLOGY
364
and S i u = (S;u);u already implies ru i n Theorem 72.3 t h a t i n an Archimedean space
h o l d s f o r every s u b s e t i.e.,
i n Theorem 63.1
AiU
and
-
.
ArU
of
S
any sequence i n
-
S;u
S = S-
. It
= Sru
the equality
L
i f and only i f
L
Ch. 15,91051
L
was proved Su:
-
Sru
=
h a s t h e o-property,
i s c o n t a i n e d i n a p r i n c i p a l i d e a l . Furthermore,
L
i t was shown t h a t i f
i s an i d e a l i n
A
L
,
then s o a r e
Before d i s c u s s i n g t h e s i t u a t i o n i n a normed Riesz s p a c e , we make a f u r t h e r remark about t h e o-property.
Let us s a y , f o r a moment, t h a t
t h e weak o-property i f every sequence i n
has
L
h a s a subsequence contained
L
i n a p r i n c i p a l i d e a l . We prove t h a t t h e weak o-property i s e q u i v a l e n t t o t h e o-property. and l e t vn =
For t h i s purpose, assume t h a t
(f :n=1,2,
+" + s u p ( f l , ...,f )
a subsequence of f:
b e a sequence i n
satisfies
, say).
This i m p l i e s t h a t a l l A
B (generated by
v
. S i m i l a r l , y , na l l
z
,
sequence i n
L
L
t h e sequence o f a l l
A
-
fn
sup(w,z)
,
A
are contained i n
a r e contained i n
s a y ) . I t follows t h a t a l l
c o n t a i n e d i n t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by L e t us assume now t h a t
h a s t h e weak a-property,
L
. Then
contained i n a p r i n c i p a l i d e a l
a r e contained i n
a principal ideal
L
; hence, by h y p o t h e s i s , t h e r e i s
0 5 v 4
(vn:n=1,2, ...)
w
( g e n e r a t e d by and s o a l l
...)
fn
.
are
i s a normed Riesz space. Every ru-convergent
i s norm convergent, and s o every norm c l o s e d s e t i s ru-
c l o s e d ( i n o t h e r words, t h e norm topology i s weaker t h e n t h e ru-topology).
It f o l l o w s immediately t h a t , f o r every s u b s e t
-
-
S
.
of
,
L
t h e ru-closure
Sru i s c o n t a i n e d i n t h e norm c l o s u r e S We i n d i c a t e a n e c e s s a r y and P s u f f i c i e n t c o n d i t i o n f o r t h e two t o p o l o g i e s t o c o i n c i d e . THEOREM 105.14. If T
P
L
i s a normed Riesz space, then the norm topology
coincides with the ru-topology
sequence i n L then
T~~
i f and only if every norm convergent
has a ru-convergent subsequence. Furthermore, i f
-
S- = S i u = Sru P
holds f o r e v e w subset
S
of
L
.
PROOF. I t was observed a l r e a d y t h a t every ru-convergent
T
p
= T
ru'
sequence i n
i s norm convergent, which i m p l i e s t h a t any norm c l o s e d s e t i s ru-closed.
L
If
i t i s g i v e n now t h a t every norm convergent sequence h a s a ru-convergent subsequence, t h e n i t f o l l o w s immediately t h a t e v e r y ru-closed s e t is norm coincide. ru The proof t h a t e v e r y norm convergent se-
c l o s e d . Hence, i n t h i s case t h e t o p o l o g i e s Conversely, l e t
T
P
= T
T
P
and
T
quence has a ru-convergent subsequence i s v e r y s i m i l a r t o t h e proof i n
Ch. I5,§105l
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
Theorem 105.7 t h a t i f
T
,
= T~~
P
365
then every norm convergent sequence has
a n o r d e r convergent subsequence. If T = T and S i s an a r b i t r a r y s u b s e t of P ru It remains t o prove t h a t f E s ; ~ i m p l i e s f E S i u f E
s;,
. Then
= S-
P
p(f-fn)
+
o
f o r some sequence
L
,
then
. Hence,
let
(fn:n=1,2
S- = SP ru
,... )
The sequence h a s a subsequence converging r e l a t i v e l y uniformly t o which shows now t h a t
f
belongs t o
%u
in
. s
,
f
.
*
I t i s i n t e r e s t i n g t o observe t h a t i n a Banach l a t t i c e every norm con-
v e r g e n t sequence has a ru-convergent subsequence. Hence, i n view of t h e l a s t theorem, t h e norm topology and t h e ru-topology
c o i n c i d e i n any Banach
l a t t i c e . More p r e c i s e l y , we have t h e f o l l o w i n g theorem. THEOREM 105.15. I n the normed Riesz space
conditions implies the next one. (i) L i s a Banach l a t t i c e , i . e . , L
L
each of the following
s a t i s f i e s the Fiesz-Fischer
condition. (ii)
L
(iii)
T
s a t i s f i e s the weak Riesz-Fischer condition. P
= T~~
, i . e . , every norm convergent sequence i n
L
has a
ru-convergent subsequence. (iv)
i.e., i f
Every monotone norm convergent sequence i n L i s ru-convergent, u
+
and
p(un)
-f
0
, then
un
+
0 (ru).
(v)
For evemj ideal
A
in L
(vi)
For every ideal
A
i n L we have
PROOF. ( i )
=,
we have
A- = A' A
e
p -
( i i ) i s evident, a s well as ( i i i )
ru
. *
=e.
( i v ) and (v)
The proof t h a t ( i i ) i m p l i e s ( i i i ) i s i n c l u d e d i n Example 1 0 5 . 8 ( i i ) . l e a v e s only ( i v )
*
( v ) . Let
A
b e an i d e a l i n
holds always, we have t o prove t h a t f E A-
P
. As
A
P
L
=e.
(vi).
This
. Since AiU c A i u c A]; AiU . Hence, l e t
i s contained i n
observed e a r l i e r ( L e m a 1 0 5 . 4 ( i ) ) , t h e r e e x i s t s a sequence
(un:n=1,2, ...)
in
A
such t h a t
by h y p o t h e s i s ( i v ) , we have I n a space
L
u
+
0 5 u
+S f+
and
f (ru)
, so
f+ E
+
"
p(f+-un) J. 0 . Hence, AiU . S i m i l a r l y f o r f - .
p o s s e s s i n g t h e o-property i t i s p o s s i b l e t o d e r i v e a
p a r t i a l r e s u l t i n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n . We s h a l l prove t h a t ( v i ) t o g e t h e r w i t h t h e o-property i m p l i e s ( i v ) , b u t n o t ( i i i ) . The proof i s along t h e same l i n e s a s i n Theorem 105.1, where i t was shown t h a t i f n o m c l o s e d i d e a l s a r e t h e same hs o r d e r c l o s e d i d e a l s , then
un J. 0
implies
366
Ch. I5,§1051
ANDO'S THEOREM AND ORDER TOPOLOGY .C 0
P(u,)
. In
t h e p r e s e n t c a s e t h e r e i s , however, a n a d d i t i o n a l compli-
c a t i o n caused by t h e f a c t t h a t we s h a l l have t o d e a l w i t h a countable number of sequences each of which i s r e l a t i v e l y uniformly convergent, t h e k-th sequence b e i n g w -uniformly convergent, s a y . Then, and t h i s i s where k we a r e going t o use t h e a - p r o p e r t y , t h e r e e x i s t s an element such t h a t wo a l l sequences a r e w O-convergent.
THEOREM 105.16. If the normed Riesz space
has the o-property and if, f o r every idea2 A i n L , the norm closure o f A i s the same as the ru-cZosure o f A , then every monotone norm convergent sequence in L i s ru-convergent.
+
PROOF. Let
0 I u 4
in
n
with
L
u u h o l d s r e l a t i v e l y uniformly. n f o r any f i x e d k and n = 1,2,
...
r a t e d by t h e system
we have u
E
(%);
sequence fin
+
let
v = kn w i l l be denoted by
.
, Since
-.
, which
u
4,
)u-v 1 5 p(u-u ) + 0 a s n + This shows t h a t k kn By h y p o t h e s i s (4,); = (4,)iu= (4,)iu, s o t h e r e e x i s t s a
...)
(fkn:n=1,2, 5
,
...)
. We have t o prove t h a t ... , l e t 4, = I-k-l and, (u -a u ) + . The i d e a l genen k
) .C 0 n k = 2,3,
p(u-u
For
p{(l-a
u(ru)
0 5 zin
(vkn:n=1,2,
L
and
in
4,
such t h a t
i m p l i e s t h a t t h e elements
z' kn
-+
u(ru)
. Hence,
writing
fkn
+
u(ru)
as
z' = inf (fln,u) kn
n
-+
-.
Then
satisfy
kn
.
0 < z 4 5 u and z + u(ru) Note t h a t zkn E 4, f o r a l l kn n kn By d e f i n i t i o n , z -+ u ( r u ) means t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s a n element wk E L+ P kn such t h a t zkn converges wk-uniformly t o u a s n + As observed above,
w e have
n
.
i t f o l l o w s from t h e a-property of such t h a t , f o r each formly t o
u
.
k
, the
We s h a l l prove now t h a t t h i s purpose, l e t E > 0
k-l <
E
. Then i t
L
sequence
-.
wo E L+
t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s an element (zkn:n=1,2,
...)
converges w -mi0
.
u converges (u+w )-uniformly t o u For n 0 be givep. Choose t h e n a t u r a l number k such t h a t
follows from
Ch. 15,SlOSl
367
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
)u
0 5 u-u m = ( I - %
E(u+wo)
+
(aku-um)+
5
)+
+
5
5 EU +
t h a t i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t
(a u-u ) + 5 “w0 f o r some n a t u r a l k m t h i s w i l l imply t h a t u-u 5 2c(u+wO) As shown above, m ) i n the ideal t h e r e e x i s t s an i n c r e a s i n g sequence (zkn:n=1,2, 4,
m
number
, because
such t h a t
zkn
converges wo-uniformly t o
c a l l i t simply
, satisfies
z
d e f i n i t i o n of t h e i d e a l m
such t h a t
Vkm
one of t h e
. From
EW
z kn the
’
i t follows t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s a n a t u r a l number
4,
I f\um-aku/)-
z
and
z +
and s o
u-z 5
and
, so
= (urn-@+
Since both
0 5 z 5 u
i s contained i n t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l generated by
z
z
... . Hence,
u
.
=
f\aku-umj\+ .
(a u-u )+ k m
(aku-ull)+ 5
u
, we
get t h e r e f o r e t h a t
,
u
. This
(agu-um)+ 5 u-z 5
EXAMPLE 105.17.
a r e majorized by
i s the d e s i r e d r e s u l t .
E W ~
( i ) As promised, we show f i r s t t h a t t h e hypotheses i n
the l a s t theorem a r e not s u f f i c i e n t t o conclude t h a t t h e topologies
T
P
and
a r e t h e same. I n o t h e r words, we show t h a t these hypotheses do not
T
ru permit us t o conclude t h a t every norm convergent sequence has a ru-convergent subsequence. Let sequences
c o n s i s t of a l l
L
f(k) = f ( l )
the property t h a t
for a l l
f = (f(I),f(Z), k 2 k
...)
E Lrn with
( i n o t h e r words, a l l
f t h a t from a c e r t a i n p o i n t on, t h e p o i n t depending on
f
f
, are
constant and equal t o t h e value i n the f i r s t p o i n t ) . The norm p ( f ) i s m -k The space L has e = ( ] , I , . . . I as a s t r o n g defined by p ( f ) = C 1 2 f ( k )
.
u n i t , s o the space has t h e o-property and ru-convergence i s the same a s
.
u C i n L with p(un) 4 0 Then un conn verges pointwise t o zero. We prove t h a t t h e convergence i s uniform. Given e-uniform convergence. Let now
E
> 0
,
let
such t h a t
n
Z
no
k
=
I,
no u
“0 and a l l
...,k0 - 1
shows t h a t
satisfy
(k) = u
u
n
k 2 ko
, we
get
u
(I)
.
(I) < E There e x i s t s a n a t u r a l number kg “0 f o r a l l k 2 ko Hence un(k) < E f o r a l l
. Determining un(k) <
E
n
,
.
t no
for a l l
such t h a t u
n 2 nl
nl
and a l l
(k) < k
E
. This
for
converges uniformly t o zero. It remains t o show t h a t t h e r e
ANDO’S THEOREM AND ORDER TOPOLOGY
368
Ch. I5,SlOSl
e x i s t s a norm convergent sequence w i t h o u t a ru-converging n = l,Z,
...
subsequence. For
, l e t vn E L b e d e f i n e d by vn(k) = n f o r k = n and for a l l other k Then p(vn) = n.2-n + 0 a s n m , and
v (k) = 0 n
.
-f
obviously t h e r e i s no uniformly convergent subsequence. ( i i ) If T
= T
P ru (un:n=l , 2 , .
proof, l e t
holds i n
. .)
,
L
then
L
b e a sequence i n
has t h e o-property. L+
numbers
.
. Choose
For t h e
s t r i c t l y positive
a (n=l ,?.,...) such t h a t p ( a u ) + 0 Since T = T the n n n p ru ’ h a s a ru-convergent subsequence norm convergent sequence of a l l a u n n (an.un.:i=1,2, ) Let t h e subsequence b e w-uniformly convergent, say.
... .
The’se4uence
w
t e d by
u i s t h e n contained i n t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l generan. shows t h a t L has t h e weak o-property which, a s observed
of a l l
. This
e a r l i e r , i s e q u i v a l e n t t o t h e o-property
itself.
Summarizing, we have proved now t h a t t h e f o l l o w i n g i m p l i c a t i o n s hold.
A- = Adenotes t h a t t h i s e q u a l i t y h o l d s f o r every i d e a l A i n L P ru (and s i m i l a r l y f o r A- = A’ ) and where t h e a b b r e v i a t i o n mon i s used t o P ru denote t h e c o n d i t i o n t h a t every monotone norm convergent sequence i s ru-
where
convergent. As proved i n p a r t ( i ) , t h e f i r s t i m p l i c a t i o n does n o t hold i n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n . The same i s t r u e f o r t h e second i m p l i c a t i o n . To
L
show t h i s , l e t
em
be t h e i d e a l i n
c o n s i s t i n g of a l l
only f i n i t e l y many nonzero c o o r d i n a t e s . Here t h e p r o p e r t y L
does n o t have t h e u-property. ( i i i ) The o-property
example, l e t
L
f u n c t i o n s on
C0,ll
u n i t , so d e f i n e d by Then mon
L
does n o t imply t h e p r o p e r t y
mon
f
E Lrn w i t h
mon
holds, but
. By
way of
b e t h e Riesz s p a c e of a l l r e a l bounded Lebesgue measurable with
p(f) =
has t h e a-property.
u (x)
= 1
+
if
x E
/, 1
IfIdx
For
. The u n i t f u n c t i o n i s a s t r o n g ... , l e t t h e f u n c t i o n un b e
n = 1,2, and
CO,n-’l
+
un(x) = 0
elsewhere on
C0,ll
u J. and p(un) 0 , but u 0 ( r u ) does n o t hold. n Note, f i n a l l y t h a t s i n c e t h e o-property does n o t imply t h e p r o p e r t y
,
t h e a-property does n o t imply
f o r every i d e a l Conversely, A- = AP ru cause o t h e r w i s e we should have
A-
P
=
A-
ru
* (A-=AP ru
and u)
f o r every i d e a l A e i t h e r . ru does n o t imply t h e u-property, be-
A- = AP
A
* mon * Ap
-
- Aru
.
Ch. 15,11051
369
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
which would imply t h a t i f t h e p r o p e r t y mon h o l d s , t h e n so does t h e o-propert y , c o n t r a r y t o what we have s e e n i n t h e l a s t example i n p a r t ( i i ) . The
o-property and t h e p r o p e r t y t h a t t h e r e f o r e independent. EXERCISE 105.18. Let Theorem 105.2 t h a t
p
L
h o l d s f o r every i d e a l
A- = AP ru
b e a normed
Riesz space. I t was proved i n
i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f every norm c l o s e d
-
A
i d e a l i s a band o r , e q u i v a l e n t l y , i f and only i f t h e norm c l o s u r e
A
any i d e a l
are
A
i s a band, which i s n e c e s s a r i l y t h e band
of
P
g e n e r a t e d by
Add
B i s a band s a t i s f y i n g A C B C A- , then B i s norm P dd B = A- ) . Hence, p i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f A- = A P P holds f o r every i d e a l A i n L There i s a n o t h e r e q u i v a l e n t c o n d i t i o n
A (because i f closed, so
.
which a t f i r s t s i g h t seems weaker. Show t h a t
A- = Add
only i f
A
holds f o r e v e r y i d e a l
P
p
i s o r d e r continuous i f and
satisfying
Add = L ( i n o t h e r
words, i f and only i f every o r d e r dense i d e a l i s norm d e n s e ) .
A
HINT: Let
b e an a r b i t r a r y i d e a l . On account of
have only t o show t h a t satisfies
Cdd = L
i s a sequence (replacing for a l l u
n
n
E A
u
(un:n=1,2, by
n
. It
n
P
...)
. This
in
such t h a t
C
u I Ad
implies
that
u E A-
P
For t h i s purpose, show t h a t f o r any
A
Pu
E 0
.
un I Ad
for a l l
,
P
u E L+
then
A
L
. There
Add
and
n
0 I u
,
so
n
5 u
the ideal
A
i s a p r o j e c t i o n band.
we have a decomposition
(UAPU) + (u-uAPu)
U =
u
+
( i ) Show t h a t i f i n t h e Riesz space
i s t h e range of a p o s i t i v e p r o j e c t i o n
with
0 5 u
~(u-u,)
i f n e c e s s a r y ) we may assume t h a t
inf(u,u:)
EXERCISE 105.19.
AP by h y p o t h e s i s . Take
C- = L
follows from
for a l l
.
i s included i n
Add
, so
A c A- c Add we P d The i d e a l C = A 8 A
E A and u-u
A
Pu E Ad
. This
follows (Theorems 24.1 and 2 4 . 2 ) t h a t ( i i ) Show t h a t i n t h e Riesz space
A L
implies
L = A 0 Ad
, so
it
i s a p r o j e c t i o n band. t h e s e t of a l l i d e a l s t h a t a r e t h e
range of a p o s i t i v e p r o j e c t i o n i s t h e same a s t h e s e t of a l l p r o j e c t i o n bands. (iii) Let t y . Show t h a t ideal i n
L
L p
b e a normed Riesz s p a c e p o s s e s s i n g t h e p r o j e c t i o n proper-
i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f every norm c l o s e d
i s t h e range of a p o s i t i v e p r o j e c t i o n i n
L
. In
t h i s case, i f
ANDO'S THEOREM AND ORDER TOPOLOGY
370
P
i s a p o s i t i v e p r o j e c t i o n on t h e norm
Ch. I5,§lO5l
closed i d e a l
, then
A
t h e r e f o r e a p r o j e c t i o n band. Show t h a t t h e o r d e r p r o j e c t i o n satisfies
6 5 Po 2 P
Po
.
( i v ) Show t h a t i f
i s a Banach l a t t i c e , t h e n
L
i f and only i f every norm c l o s e d i d e a l i n
A
is
on
A
i s o r d e r continuous
p
i s t h e range of a p o s i t i v e
L
p r o j e c t i o n (use Theorems 103.9 and 105.2). HINT: For ( i ) , we have
and f o r any
g E A
g = Pf = P2f = Pg Let that
u-u
Pf E A
there e x i s t s for a l l
f E L
such t h a t
,
Pf
g E A
u
E L+ be given. Then u
A
Pu
i s a member of
for a l l
f E L
Ad
and A
1
Pu E A
. Let
Pf2
S
, so
, Pu for
f
for
0
2
. Hence
g = Pf 1
5
f2
u 2 0 in
. It
is sufficient to
Pp = p
. Furthermore,
v E A+
L
.
i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove
prove t h a t
satisfies
p = 0
. Note
f i r s t that
p E A
, so
we
have p 5 u-u
A
Pu
,
so
It f o l l o w s t h a t
p 2 inf(u-uAPu,Pu-uAPu)
= inf(u,Pu)
-
u
A
Pu = 0
i s due t o T. Ando (C41,1969);
The r e s u l t i n t h i s e x e r c i s e
.
the indicated
proof i s from an e x p o s i t o r y p a p e r by H. E l t o n Lacey and S.J. Bernau ( [ I ] , 1974). EXERCISE 105.20. Let
L
b e an Archimedean Riesz space. We s h a l l b e
d e a l i n g w i t h t h e f o l l o w i n g p r o p e r t i e s ( i ) , ( i i ) and ( i i i ) . (i)
Order convergence i n
L
is stable (i.e.
o r d e r converging
sequences and uniformly converging sequences a r e t h e same). (ii)
Any p o s i t i v e l i n e a r o p e r a t o r from
L
i n t o a n Archimedean Riesz
Ch. 15,01051
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
space i s o-order (iii) L
37 1
continuous.
i s normed and h a s o-order continuous norm.
Show t h a t (i) i m p l i e s ( i i ) and i n a normed Riesz space ( i i ) i m p l i e s ( i i i ) . Show t h a t i n a Banach l a t t i c e a l l t h r e e p r o p e r t i e s a r e e q u i v a l e n t . These r e s u l t s a r e due t o C.T.
Tucker ([11,1977).
HINT: I f ( i ) h o l d s , then t h e o r d e r topology and t h e r e l a t i v e l y uniform
topology i n
L
a r e i d e n t i c a l . Hence, every ru-closed i d e a l i n
is order
L
closed. I t f o l l o w s t h a t ( i i ) holds,(Theorems 83.23 and 83.20). I f (norm p ) and ( T i ) h o l d s , t h e n i n p a r t i c u l a r
t o a-order c o n t i n u i t y of
. Assume now
p
that
P
equivalent
i s Banach and ( i i i ) holds.
L
implies u C 0 (ru). n n and by Theorem 105.15 t h e r e i s now a ru-conver-
To prove ( i ) , i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o show t h a t p(u ) C 0 n ging subsequence. But t h e n , i n view of
By ( i i i ) we have
EXERCISE 105.21. Let
L
t h e Riesz s p a c e
, which is
L* = L*
L = L
u C n
, we
have
C 0 (ru).
u
b e a system of Riesz pseudonorms i n
(qa:a€{a))
such t h a t
C 0
u
qa(f) = 0
for a l l
a € {a) i m p l i e s
f = 0
.
T b e t h e topology i n L g e n e r a t e d by t h e system of a l l q We t h a t T i s c a l l e d a Lebesgue topology i f u converges t o z e r o i n T f o r any downwards d i r e c t e d system u C 0 i n L , and l e t
r e c a l l ( E x e r c i s e 104.4)
T i s c a l l e d o-Lebesgue i f
and
sequence
(if in
L
+
u
0
in
n Show t h a t
L
.
T
u
converges t o zero i n
T
f o r any
i s Lebesgue i f and only i f every T-closed i d e a l
i s a band and a l s o i f and only i f e v e r y o r d e r dense i d e a l i n
L
is
T-dense. (ii) in
L
Show t h a t
T i s a-Lebesgue i f and only i f every T-closed i d e a l
i s o r d e r closed. ( i i i ) Assuming t h a t a l l
q
a r e Riesz seminorms, show t h a t N
Lebesgue i f and only i f t h e n u l l i d e a l linear functional
c
the c a r r i e r
$
$
satisfies
q(f) = 0
topology. E v i d e n t l y
i s a band f o r every T-continuous
and a l s o i f and only i f , f o r every T-continuous
EXERCISE 105.22. Let such t h a t
0
T is
C0
q
only f o r T
# I01
.
b e a Riesz pseudonorm i n the Riesz space f = 0
0 ,
L
T be t h e corresponding m e t r i c
and l e t
i s Lebesgue o r o-Lebesgue whenever
q
i s order
continuous o r o-order continuous r e s p e c t i v e l y . By E x e r c i s e 100.20 e v e r y o r d e r c l o s e d i d e a l i s T-closed. of
D
by
D-
For any s u b s e t
and t h e o r d e r c l o s u r e of
D D
of by
L Dor
, we
.
denote t h e T-closure
372
ANDO'S THEOREM AND ORDER TOPOLOGY
(i)
Show t h a t
i s u-order continuous i f and only i f t h e c o l l e c -
q
t i o n of a l l o r d e r c l o s e d i d e a l s i n
i s t h e same a s t h e c o l l e c t i o n of
L
A- = Aor
a l l T-closed i d e a l s and a l s o i f and only i f (ii) if
Show t h a t
Ch. 15,§1061
T
and t h e o r d e r topology
T
f o r every i d e a l
A
.
c o i n c i d e i f and only
or i s u-order continuous and every T-convergent sequence h a s an o r d e r
q
convergent subsequence. ( i i i ) With t h e same a b b r e v i a t i o n s a s i n Example 105.17, show t h a t
EXERCISE 105.23. Extend t h e r e s u l t s i n t h i s s e c t i o n t o a complex Riesz space.
106. Order c o n t i n u i t y and t h e o r d e r dual In s e c t i o n 89 we have i n v e s t i g a t e d t h e s i t u a t i o n t h a t o r complex v e c t o r space and d u a l of
Ao
. For
W
subsets
A
i s a l i n e a r subspace of t h e a l g e b r a i c
of
W
and t h e i n v e r s e a n n i h i l a t o r
Ao =
OB =
f
i$EW':$(f)=O 0
'(W')
W'
; i.e.,
W'
of
B
the annihilator
f o r a l l fEAj
J'
few :$(f)=O f o r a l l +EB W
= {O}
and s u b s e t s
OB a r e d e f i n e d by
(
I t i s obvious t h a t
is a real
W
W'
j -
= { O } ; i t i s assumed t h a t
s e p a r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
i s so l a r g e t h a t
W' W
. This
implies t h a t
may b e regarded a s a l i n e a r subspace of t h e a l g e b r a i c d u a l of p o i n t s of logy
W
o(W,W')
$ E W'
...,$,
E W'
W'
i s by d e f i n i t i o n t h e weakest topology i n
a r e continuous f u n c t i o n s on
i s a base f o r
@,,
a c t a s d i f f e r e n t l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s on
a(W,W') and
,
W
. The
. The
space
W
W
(different
) . The weak topo-
such t h a t a l l
W
system of a l l s e t s
t h e b a s e s e t depending on
6 > 0
W'
fo E W
, n,
w i t h t h e topology
o(W,W')
is a
Ch. 15,11061
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
373
Hausdorff t o p o l o g i c a l v e c t o r space and f o r any l i n e a r subspace the
o(W,W')
c l o s u r e of
hold f o r t h e W'
o(W',W)
t h e Banach d u a l
o(W,W*)
in
i s t h e l i n e a r subspace
A
topology i n
, we
W*
. If
W'
. As
L"
o(P,W)
88.2).
If
ideal i n
,
L"
then
. It
L
i s an i d e a l i n
A
L
follows t h a t
, then
have t o d e a l w i t h t h e s i t u a t i o n t h a t dual W'
B
=
, where
i s an i d e a l i n
B
and
L
= {O}
, i.e.,
i s Archimedean (Lemma
L
; if
L"
i s an
B
i s n o t t h e whole of t h e o r d e r
W'
. More
L"
satisfying
L"
'(L")
L (Theorem 88.4). We s h a l l a l s o
b u t only a l i n e a r subspace of
L"
.
W*
i s a band i n
Ao
i s an i d e a l i n
OB
in
i s a Riesz space
W
above, we assume a l s o t h a t
s e p a r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
L"
Similar f a c t s
i s normed and we choose f o r
W
I n t h i s s e c t i o n we s h a l l f i r s t assume t h a t W ' i s the order dual
W
o b t a i n i n t h i s manner t h e weak topology
and t h e weak s t a r topology
W
.
'(Ao)
of
A
p r e c i s e l y , we s h a l l have
. In
OB = { O }
t h i s case
we have t o d i s t i n g u i s h between t h e a n n i h i l a t o r Ao i n L" of a s u b s e t A 0 of L and t h e a n n i h i l a t o r A fl B i n B of t h e same s e t A For bre0 v i t y we s h a l l denote A f l B by AD Note t h a t t h e l i n e a r subspace C of
.
.
L"
is of
C
o(L",L)
is
B
c l o s e d i f and only i f o(B,L)
THEOREM 106.1. Let
D = (OD)'
L"
be an i d e a l i n
B
and t h e l i n e a r subspace 0 0
D = (OD)'
c l o s e d i f and o n l y i f
= (
suck t h a t
.
fl B
D)
. !Then
OB = { O }
the following holds. 1;)
The null idea2 N
(it)
Every band i n
( i i i ) Every PROOF. N
9
o(B,L)
is
N
tb
a(L,B)
B
b e given. I f a(L,B)
N
9
i s a band i n
B
(i.e.,
9
= L
if
open. Let
f E L
Then a t l e a s t one of
is the case f o r
f+
f+
. is the null
c l o s e d . We may assume t h e r e f o r e , t h a t
, so
0 5 J, < 141
f-
with
191
. Let
. It
A l l t h i s makes i t c l e a r t h a t t h e
QI' d e f i n e d by
J,
J,(f+) = l$l(f')
$(f) > 0
f o l l o w s from
-
b e t h e minimal p o s i t i v e
t o t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by
on
N
is
9
N = N 9 191 i s i n t h i s complement; assume t h a t t h i s
Igl(f+) > 0
e x t e n s i o n of t h e r e s t r i c t i o n of
. Hence
N
be an element i n t h e complement of and
.
9 E B
closed.
9 # L and we have t o show t h a t t h e s e t t h e o r e t i c complement of
O(L,B)
f+
closed for every
i s 5(L,B)
is
c b s e d idea2 i n
9 E B
( i ) Let
f u n c ti o n a l ) , then
L
0 s J, s 101
that
> 0 J,
u(L,B)
E
and B
J,(f-)
and t h a t
=
0
J,
neighborhood of
, so vanishes
f
,
h a s no p o i n t s i n common w i t h plement of
N
( i i ) Let let
f
Ib
, so
NQ
the arbitrary point
i s a n i n t e r i o r p o i n t . But t h e n
A
be an a r b i t r a r y band i n
be a point not i n
Archimedean, t h e i d e a l
A
,
A
f o r example
f+
Taking i n t o account t h a t OB = (03 ) we have
v E Ad
Qo(v) > 0
Ib0
g Iv
. This
$ O ( f ) = $,(f+) =
on
0
A
. Hence,
> 0
-
that
C
B
i s a band i n
# L , so
. Since
A
0 < v < f+
Qo E B
is
L
A
,
,
so (since
it follows
. Once
the
u(L,B)
A
may assume
0
=
we have
on
$o E
neighborhood of
. It
. Observing B .
, we $o
v
and
. Summing up,
b e an a r b i t r a r y
n
closed. A
+> .
f o r some p o s i t i v e
Qo(f ) = 0
h a s no p o i n t s i n common w i t h ( i i i ) Let C 0 0 0 0 C = ( C) = ( C )
o(L,B)
again, re-
by t h e minimal p o s i t i v e e x t e n s i o n of i t s r e s t r i c -
implies
2 $,(v)
not i n
such t h a t
t i o n t o t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by all
i n t h e com-
may assume
i s n o t contained i n t h e band
f+
t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s an element p l a c i n g i f necessary
f
i s o r d e r dense, s o
Ad
8
is
N$
. We
L
u+v:O
$o
Ch. 15,11061
ORDER CONTINUITY AND ORDER DUAL
374
follows t h a t o(B,L)
that
f
A
A B
. ,
and
$O(f) > 0
, defined
is
by
o(L,B)
close'd.
closed i d e a l i n
B
. Then
i s a band i n
L"
, it
(OC)'
for
Qo(g) = 0
Note a l s o t h a t
follows
We s h a l l prove now t h a t t h e converse of p r o p e r t y ( i i ) a s w e l l a s of p r o p e r t y ( i i i ) i n t h e l a s t theorem h o l d s i f t h e i d e a l
B
i s contained i n
t h e band
L" of a l l normal i n t e g r a l s . This has important consequences f o r n t h e c a s e t h a t L i s a normed Riesz space L and B i s t h e Banach d u a l
L*
.
THEOREM 106.2.
that
OB = 101
A s i n the last theorem, l e t
. Then
B
be an i d e a l i n
N
L
such
the f o l Z m i n g conditions are equivalent.
(i) B i s contained in :L ( i . e . , B c o n s i s t s of normal i n t e g r a l s ) o r , equivalently by Corollary 105.12, t h e n u l l i d e a l N i s a band f o r $ every Q E B .
15,§1061
Ch.
(ii)
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
o(L,B)
Eveqi
( i t ? ) For every
# 0 in B
(iv)
Every band i n
B
(v)
If
and
0 < u E L v E L
e x i s t s an element J,(v) = 0
i s a band. the carrier C of
closed i d e a l i n
$
.
I01
C$ #
and i f
0 < v s u
, then t h e r e
Q(u) > 0
with
.
J, I $
satisfying
satisfies
$
closed.
0 < Q E B
such t h a t
f o r a l l J, E B
L
$
o(B,L)
is
375
Furthermore, i f these equivalent conditions hold, then
B
is order
(by CorolLary 105.12).
L :
dense in
and
Q(v) > 0
PROOF. Before p r e s e n t i n g t h e p r o o f , we g i v e some comment on c o n d i t i o n
(v). The p r o p e r t y i n t h i s c o n d i t i o n i s o b v i a u s l y a d u a l t o t h e p r o p e r t y t h a t $(u) > 0
if J,
E
with
and
u
Indeed, t a k e f o r
p o s i t i v e , t h e n t h e r e e x i s t s an element
Q
0 < J, < $
such t h a t
L"
J,(u) > 0
with
(i) A =
O
=$
D
(A )
Every
N
$
(ii)
( i i ) Let
,
(since
*
be a
( i ) For any
L
N
( i i i ) Let
o(L,B)
follows t h a t i f (iii)
u
.
closed i d e a l i n
L
. Then
i s a band.
A
t h e null i d e a l
$ E B
i s a band by ( i i )
$
. The
Q E B
. Hence,
ideal
N
*
# Q E B , then
0
$
8
C
$ OB = { O }
imp ies
Co = { O }
N
i s o(L,B)
4
c l o s e d by
This shows t h a t ( i ) h o l d s .
i s Archimedean on account of
4 E B c Lz
since
v I
for all
i.e.,
Theorem 106.1, s o (i)
A
i s a band by ( i ) , s o
*
$(v) = 0
t h e minimal p o s i t i v e e x t e n s i o n of t h e r e s t r i c t i o n of
il,
t o t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by
$
and
01
.
N
0
i s o r d e r dense i n ) and
N
= L , s o
C, # ( i ) The proof i s almost t h e same a s f o r ( i i i )
L
i s a band
0
$ = O . I t
*
(ii) in
Theorem 105.3. (i) B
, but
*
( i v ) Let
not t o
C
and
Ql E C
b e a band i n
B
Q2 1 C
,
$2 # 0
is not the null functional; l e t also t h a t the c a r r i e r implying ( i i i ) . Let elements of
L :
B
, and
i s an i d e a l i n
assume t h a t
Q
L"
has the projec-
and
L"
has likewise the projection property, s o
tion property, B with
C
. Since
, so
C(Qd)
. Then
Qi # 0
satisfies
0 < u E C(Qi)
. All
i t follows from
one a t l e a s t of
, say. C(Q;)
Note t h a t
#
{O}
belongs t o
Q
QI
+
=
and
$I I C
Qi
and n o t e
on account of ( i )
l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s involved a r e
Qi I C
and
4; I $;
that
U.
C($d) c NJ,
$i(u)
for a l l
, which
0
=
and
J, E C
. It
C
( i v ) + ( i ) We have t o prove t h a t
,
so
$,(u) = 0
and
implies
h a s no p o i n t s i n common w i t h Hence, l e t
. Hence,
C($l) c N ( $ i )
This makes i t c l e a r t h a t t h e a ( B , L )
$
Ch. 15,51061
ORDER CONTINUITY AND ORDER DUAL
376
, defined
neighborhood of
$
follows t h a t
is
N
C
closed.
o(B,L)
i s a band f o r every
$
by
$ E B
.
0 I $ E B b e g i v e n and l e t @ b e t h e band i n B g e n e r a t e d by 0 = O Since B h a s t h e p r o j e c t i o n p r o p e r t y , we have
.
N
B = 8 @ O d Q , where both
hypothesis t h a t
ed
and
8
and
8
a r e bands i n
Qd
are
, which
B
i m p l i e s by
c l o s e d . This i s e x a c t l y t h e
o(B,L)
s i t u a t i o n i n Theorem 8 9 . 4 ( i i ) , t h a t i s t o s a y , O
and
are
Od
o(B,L)
c l o s e d l i n e a r subspaces having only t h e n u l l element i n common and d O '(@-SO ) = B = {O} According t o t h e theorem r e f e r r e d t o t h i s i m p l i e s
.
that
and
@ '
'(ad)
have o n l y t h e n u l l element i n common and
I n o t h e r words, denoting t h e i d e a l N
$
and
are disjoint (i.e.,
M
N
'(Od)
by
I M ) and
4
f o r a moment, t h e i d e a l s
M
(N +M)' $
t h e minimal p o s i t i v e e x t e n s i o n of t h e r e s t r i c t i o n of g e n e r a t e d by M 1 {N
$
1
NIP
. Then
The l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s It f o l l o w s t h a t
$,
v a n i s h e s on
$
, and
so
band. This proof i s due t o T. Ando. (i)
*
(v) L e t
0 < u E L v E L
for a l l
J,
OB
), the ideal
= {O}
$
and a l s o on
$m c o i n c i d e on
and
$
INd} c N
t o f i n d an element
N
$
0
J,
C
I$ $
@
$
$ '
0 < v S u
. Since
L
{N$}
,
be
IN$}
M (since
(N$SM)O = { O }
, so
$
=
$(u) > 0
$(v) > 0
and
on
0
This shows t h a t
and l e t
0 < $ E B
such t h a t
E B satisfying N
and
{N } = N
$,
t o t h e band
$
$m i s t h e null f u n c t i o n a l because
). B u t then
. Let
= {O}
N
ib
. We
. {N
$
is a have
$(v) = 0
i s Archimedean (on account of
i s o r d e r dense, s o
Ch. 15,11061
It follows t h a t
+
so
satisfying (v)
Let Since and
,
I C
+2
0 < u E L
#
satisfies
+
and assume t h a t
all
, which
I
one a t l e a s t of
,
I) I +
0 < v < u
then
C
+
c N
in J,’
belongs t o
+
+ +2
=
-
and
@;
, but
B
not t o
C
0, E C
with
i s not the n u l l
+2
# 0 , s a y , This i m p l i e s t h e e x i s t e n c e of an element +i(u) > 0
. Hence,
by h y p o t h e s i s , t h e r e e x i s t s an
++(v) > 0
satisfying
+I . In particular,
J,
E C
. Then
such t h a t
0 < v E L
such t h a t J,
B
0
4;
functional; l e t element
J, E B
has t h e p r o j e c t i o n p r o p e r t y , we have
B +2
. If
i s o r d e r con-
( i v ) This proof i s s i m i l a r t o t h e proof t h a t (i) i m p l i e s ( i v ) .
=$
b e a band i n
C
+(u) > 0
$(v) > 0
.
$(v) = 0
,vSu) , because 9 + , t h e r e e x i s t s an element
$ ( u ) = sup($.:v):OgvEC
tinuous. Hence, s i n c e C
377
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
2
and
$(v) = 0
-
JI E B
for a l l
t h e r e f o r e , $,(v)
=
0
$(v) = 0
neighborhood of
+
,
d e f i n e d by
is
o(B,L)
and
for
implies
I t i s e v i d e n t now t h a t t h e o(B,L)
has no p o i n t s i n common w i t h
C
.
It f o l l o w s t h a t
C
closed.
Before d i s c u s s i n g some c o r o l l a r i e s , we n o t e t h a t c o n d i t i o n ( i i ) i n t h e last theorem can a l s o b e expressed by s a y i n g t h a t an i d e a l i n band i f and only i f i t i s
o(L,B)
L
is a
c l o s e d . This follows from Theorem 106.1.
S i m i l a r l y , we o b t a i n an e q u i v a l e n t f o r m u l a t i o n f o r c o n d i t i o n ( i v ) by s a y i n g t h a t an i d e a l i n
B
i s a band i f and only i f i t i s
f o r m u l a t i o n s emphasize t h e symmetry between
L
and
o(B,L) B
c l o s e d . These
i n t h e conditions
mentioned. A s s e e n above, t h e c o n d i t i o n s h o l d i f and only i f tained i n
L i
.
The dual c o n d i t i o n t h a t
m a t i c a l l y s a t i s f i e d because E L+
. This
$
4 0
in
L
i s contained i n
B
implies
+,(u)
+
B
i s con-
:B
i s auto-
0
f o r every
e x p l a i n s why ( i i ; and ( i i i ) i n Theorem 106.1 h o l d w i t h o u t
e x t r a c o n d i t i o n , b u t t h e i r converses, ( i i ) and ( i v ) i n Theorem 106.2, h o l d only i f
B c L :
COROLLARY 106.3.
equivaknt.
.
If O(L-3
= {O}
J
then the foZZowing conditions are
.
ORDER CONTINUITY AND ORDER DUAL
378
-
15,81061
Ch.
N
(i) L = L ( i . e . , every linear functional on L i s a normal integral). ( i i ) Every o(L,L") closed ideal i n L i s a band. ( i i i ) For every Q # 0 i n L" the carrier C of Q s a t i s f i e s Q CQ # CO) . (iv)
Every band in
(v)
If 0
e x i s t s an element J,(v) =
o
for a l l
< u
L"
E L and
v E L
CI(L",L)
is
0 <
Q E L"
with
0 < v
such that
JI E L-
closed.
satisfying
J,
u
5
.
IQ
@(u) > 0
I n t h e f i n a l c o r o l l a r y i t w i l l b e assumed t h a t
space. The Banach dual
i s an i d e a l i n
L*
Hence, w e can apply t h e l a s t theorem w i t h
, then there
Q(v)> 0
with
i s a normed Riesz
L
satisfying
L"
. Before
B = L*
and
O(L*)
= {O}
.
doing t h i s , we
r e c a l l t h a t (according t o a well-known theorem) i n a normed v e c t o r space a l i n e a r subspace i s norm c l o s e d i f and only i t i t i s weakly c l o s e d . I n t h e p r e s e n t c a s e , a l i n e a r subspace of
i s norm c l o s e d i f and only i f i t i s
L
closed.
o(L,L*)
COROLLARY 106.4. I n the normed Riesz space
L
the following conditions
are equivalent.
i s order continuous.
(i)
p
(ii)
L* = L* ( i . e . ,
every bounded linear functional on L
i s a normal
integml). ( i i i ) Every norm closed ideal i n
in
L
i s a band i f and only i f it i s norm closed). (iv)
CQ
L i s a band (equivalently, an ideal
# {OI (v)
.
For every
Q # 0 in
Every band in
L*
L*
the carrier
C
Q
of
Q
satisfies
i s weak s t a r closed, i . e . , o(L*,L)
closed
(equivalently, an ideal i n L* i s a band if and only i f it i s weak s t a r closed). (vi)
If
0 < u
E L and
e x i s t s an element
v E L
$(v) = 0
(J
for all
E L*
PROOF. The f a c t t h a t
0 < Q
such that satisfying p
E L* with 0 < v
5 u
I$
.
$(u) > 0
with
, then there
+(v) > 0
i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f
and
L* = L*
h o l d s was proved i n t h e beginning of s e c t i o n 103. Note t h a t t h e equivalence of ( i ) , ( i i i ) and ( i v ) was a l r e a d y proved i n Theorem 105.3, b u t h e r e we
Ch. 15,11061
379
ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
f i n d t h i s r e s u l t a g a i n a s a c o r o l l a r y of t h e more g e n e r a l Theorem 106.2. EXERCISE 106.5. Let an element for a l l
v E L
0
C
0
0 <
and
. Let 0
v
EXERCISE 106.6.
L
0
0 < v
such t h a t satisfying
$ € L*
HINT: Note t h a t
L = N
b e a Banach l a t t i c e w i t h o r d e r continuous norm.
L
0 < u E L
Show t h a t i f
f = 0
and l e t
p
seminorms
i s i t s e l f one of t h e
onal
on
$
l e a s t one
C 0
p,(uT)
$(v) = 0
so
0' p,(f)
=
b e t h e topology i n
L
. We
pa
b e a system of
0
for a l l g e n e r a t e d by t h e
r e c a l l that the linear functi-
0 is
O(L*) = {Ol
p -bounded f o r a t
L* = (L,T)*
i s an i d e a l i n
L
t o show i n E x e r c i s e 1 0 2 . 2 4 ( i i i ) t h a t from E x e r c i s e 1 0 2 . 2 4 ( i i ) t h a t implies
and
@(u)
(p,:a€{a})
and we r e c a l l a l s o t h a t t h e system
T-continuous l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s on
L
let
i s T-continuous i f and only i f
L
p,
=
may b e assumed t h a t every f i n i t e supremum of t h e
system of a l l p,
C
such t h a t
L
T
in
u
As i n E x e r c i s e 102.23,
. It
$(v)
then there e x i s t s
i s Dedekind complete (Theorem 103.9),
b e t h e component of
Riesz seminorms i n t h e Riesz s p a c e a E {a) i m p l i e s
,
$(u) > 0
with
u
5
.
$ 1
with
E L*
L"
of a l l
. I t was
. Show t h a t
i t follows
i s a Lebesgue topology ( i . e . ,
T
f o r every
p
asked
u
J. 0
in
L* = L* ( i . e . ,
) i f and only i f
n
l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l i s a normal i n t e g r a l ) . Show now t h a t
every T-continuous
the following conditions a r e equivalent. (i)
The topology
(ii)
Every
ideal i n (;it) (iv) in
L* (v)
.
For every
0#
Every band i n
0
in
L*
a(L,L*)
the carrier
L*
is
i s a band ( e q u i v a l e n t l y , an
L
o(L*,L)
If
0 < u E L
for all
v E L
9 E L*
EXERCISE 106.7.
Let
and
0 <
0 < v
satisfying L,L*
and
with
E L*
such t h a t
5
I0 T
C
0
closed). of
0
satisfies
closed (equivalently, an i d e a l
i s a band i f and only i f i t i s o(L*,L)
e x i s t s a n element $(v) = O
closed i d e a l i n
i s a band i f and o n l y i f i t i s
L
c0 # CO}
T i s Lebesgue.
o(L,L*)
u
-
closed). $(u) > 0
with
,
then there
$(v) > 0
and
b e t h e same as i n t h e p r e c e d i n g
e x e r c i s e . We compare t h e r e s u l t s i n t h e l a s t e x e r c i s e w i t h t h o s e i n Exerc i s e 105.20, where i t was shown t h a t T-closed i d e a l i n
L
T
i s Lebesgue i f and only i f every
i s a band, whereas i n t h e l a s t e x e r c i s e w e found t h a t
380
T
Ch. 15,11061
ORDER C O N T I N U I T Y AND ORDER DUAL
i s Lebesgue i f and only i f every
o(L,L*)
c l o s e d i d e a l i s a band. These
r e s u l t s a r e a c t u a l l y t h e same. Show t h a t every
o(L,L*)
closed s e t is
The converse i s n o t t r u e i n g e n e r a l , b u t i s t r u e t h a t every
T-closed.
T-closed l i n e a r subspace of
is
L
o(L,L*)
c l o s e d . We i n d i c a t e a s h o r t
p r o o f , s i m i l a r t o t h e proof i n t h e normed case. I f
i s a T-closed l i n e a r
A
and
fo
belongs t o t h e complement of
a T-neighborhood of
fo
having no p o i n t s in common w i t h
subspace of
L
A
,
then there e x i s t s
A
. We may
assume
t h a t t h i s neighborhood i s of t h e form
where
p
fies
d >
g = afo by
i s one of t h e
-
g = af
t i o n a l on
so
$
E
, so
f (a 0
- f
d > 0
pa
. It
. Let
follows t h a t
A[f
):fa) satis0 1 b e t h e l i n e a r subspace of a l l elements
0
r e a l , f E A ) . Note t h a t
. For
A[fO] ,$
this
g
, let
v a n i s h e s on
i s p-bounded on
A[fOl
a
d = inf(p(f-f
and
$(g) = ad A
. Now
and
extend
$(fo) = d
$
o(L,L*)
neighborhood of
fo
a r e uniquely determined $
i s a l i n e a r func-
. Furthermore
t o a p-bounded l i n e a r func-
t i o n a l (Hahn-Banach), which we s h a l l c a l l a g a i n
is a
f
. Then
d i s j o i n t from
$
. The
A
.
set
CHAPTER 16
EMBEDDING IN BIDUALS
The first sections of this chapter (107 and 108) deal mainly with the structure of the set
S
of all Rkesz seminorms in a Riesz space L
is partially ordered by defining that
.
p 1 S p2
holds in S
. The set
S
whenever
for all f E L With respect to this partial ordering pl(f) 5 p2(f) is a lattice; supremum and infimum of p and p 2 are given by
S
1
The Riesz seminorms generated by the positive linear functionals on a special subset of seminorm in L
S ;
. These
is a norm in L and
$
p
,
if Q E (L-)'
Q
then p$(f) = $(lfl)
L form
is a Riesz
are called the additive seminorms in L
. If
p
is a positive and sequentially order continuous
linear functional in L which is not identically zero, then the Riesz seminorm inf(p,p$)
is not identically zero. It follows from this result
that for a normed Riesz space L and L* L*
n
is order dense i n
L"
is not order dense in L".
P
.
the space L,* is order dense in :L It should be observed here that in general
The normed Riesz space L
is said to have
the weak Fatou property for directed sets (or for monotone sequences) if every norm bounded upwards directed set (or increasing sequence) of positive elements in L
has a supremum. Then
L
is a Dedekind complete (or Dede-
kind o-complete) Banach lattice and in the case of directed sets thereexists a constant k
=
k(p)
such that
0
5
u
1. u
implies
similarly in the case of increasing sequences. If property for directed sets and :L
p(u)
L
S
k(p).sup
p(u,)
has the weak Fatou
separates the points of
L , then the
supremum of all additive order continuous Riesz seminorms which are majorized by P"
p
is a norm in L which is equivalent to
is defined by 381
p
. In other words, if
;
382
Ch. 163
CHAPTER 16
for.every f E Lp , then precisely, p"
k
5 p S
2
is a norm in L
p"
(p).p"
, where
equivalent to
. More
p
is the same constant as above.
k(p)
As defined earlier, a Riesz seminorm in the Riesz space L norm in L which i s absolute (i.e., p ( f ) well as monotone (i.e., 0
v
5
5
u
for all
= p(/fl)
implies p(v)
5
is a semi-
f € L ) as
). The ordinary
p(u)
Euclidean norm in the lexicographically ordered plane is abslute, but not monotone. In a space L
Riesz seminorm. More generally, if space L
,
then
L
of finite dimension this does not happen if
is Archimedean because then every absolute seminorm in L
is already a
is an absolute seminorm in the Riesz
p
is a Riesz seminorm if and only if the functional
p
is sublinear. In the converse direction it is easy to indicate p(f) = p ( f t ) monotone norms that are n o t absolute. of all Riesz seminorms in L
The lattice S but in general S
is not distributive. Every
additive seminorms less than or equal to the additive seminorm generated by (L-)'
into
S
$
p
-+
E (L )
is Dedekind complete,
E
p
is the supremum of all
S
. As above, we denote by . The mapping $ p $
p
$
from
+
preserves addition, multiplication by non-negative constants,
order, suprema of upwards directed sets and infirna of arbitrary sets. The Riesz seminonus in
and
p1
p2
are called disjoint if
(notation p 1 I p 2 ) . If
S
a t 0 and
I p3 , then Q I J, in (L-)+ p1
for all
p1 l p 3
p1
.
I
The subset A (i)
pI,p2 E A
(p +p )
2
of
S
3
p1
p3
E
A
E D
p2
,
then
=
0 holds
I ap2 for all real
p
. Furthermore, if p
Q
1 p
J
pI
I
I p 2 and
if and only if
is called a semilinear lattice ideal in S
implies alpl+a2p2 E A
for all real al,a2 t 0
the set Dd
if
,
is called a lattice band if, in addition,
for any upwards directed set p , 4 p
Finally, for D c S p'
1 p2
. Finally, we have
The semilinear lattice ideal A p
<
inf(pl,p2)
of all
p
with
E
is called the disjoint complement of
S
D
the corresponding notions i n the Riesz space L complete; every disjoint complement in S
p,
E
A
for all
such that p I
p'
T
.
for all
. Note the similarity with
itself. The analogy is not
is a semilinear lattice but not
ch. 161
383
EMBEDDING IN BIDUALS
necessarily a lattice band. The set
S1
of all elements of
majorized
S
by an additive Riesz seminorm is a semilinear lattice ideal but not necessarily a lattice band. Let
B
let f E L
be an ideal in the order dual
of the Riesz space L and
L"
on
be given. The real linear functional f"
for all f"($) = $(f) and the mapping a: L The mapping
a
-+
.
E B
$
B
is defined by
It is proved in section 109 that f" E :B
Bi , defined by
,
a(f) = f"
is a Riesz homomorphism.
is a Riesz isomorphism if and only if bhe ideal ; hence, L
its image o(L)
B
L (i.e., OB = { O } ) . In this case we identify
tes the points of
separa-
L
and
is now embedded in BL as a Riesz subspace.
L in Bpreserves arbitrary suprema and infima if and n is contained in L" (i.e., every element of B is a normal in-
The embedding of only if
B
tegral on L ). The case then L
L
B
=
" " L
is embedded in:):L(
n
is of special importance; if (L' ):
is equal to the whole space
- N
-
(Ln)n
In section 110 it is proved that L and
0
5
u 4 with
sup $(uT) <
, the space L is said to be perfect, = I03
is perfect if and only if):L('
E (Li)+
for every
implies that
exists in L. For any arbitrary Riesz space L
sup u
= {O},
as a Riesz subspace. If, in this situation,
the order dual
L"
is perfect and any band in a perfect Riesz space is itself perfect. In the next section we assume that L
carries a norm
p
and we prove that L
a perfect Banach lattice (with respect to p ) if and only if (L' ): and
L = L
is
= {O}
has the weak Fatou property for directed sets (a result essen-
D
tially due to T. Mori, I. Amemiya and H. Nakano). For any normed Riesz space
L
the Banach dual L*
is perfect. In section 112 the situation is speci-
alized to the case that
(X,A,p) is a a-finite measure space and
ideal in the space M(X,p)
may be assumed that the carrier of a norm p
,
so
L
=
L
of all functions g
P '
The space :L
L is the set X
then the space :L
such that fg
and the possibly smaller space L:
L
L is an
or all real p-measurable functions on X itself. If
L
. It
carries
may be identified with the space
is p-summable over X consists of all
for all
g E Ln
f E L
such that
, aiso sometimes denoted by L' , is the associate space of
(mentioned already in section 9). We shall prove that L'
ficiently many functions; precisely, the carrier of the carrier of the second associate space L"
=
(L')'
L'
is X
contains suf-
. Hence,
is also equal to X
.
CHAPTER 16
384
i s Banach ( i . e . ,
if
Ch. 163
i s a Banach f u n c t i o n s p a c e ) , t h e n
If
L
L"
c o n t a i n t h e same f u n c t i o n s i f and o n l y i f
L
lently i n this situation (since
and
L
i s p e r f e c t o r , equiva-
L
i s o r d e r s e p a r a b l e ) , i f and only i f
L
has t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r monotone sequences. I n t h i s c a s e t h e
L
norms
and
p
in
p"
,
a r e equivalent. I f t h e Fatou constant
L
p" = p , which i s t h e r e s u l t of W.A.J.
k(p)
sa-
tisfies
k(p) = 1
and G.G.
Lorentz mentioned a l r e a d y i n s e c t i o n 9 . I n s e c t i o n 113 i t w i l l b e
then
proved t h a t i n a n ~ r m e dR i e s z s p a c e
Luxemburg
o-order c o n t i n u i t y of
L
together
p
w i t h t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r sequences i s e q u i v a l e n t t o o r d e r c o n t i n u i ty
of
t o g e t h e r w i t h t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s and a l s o
p
e q u i v a l e n t t o t h e c o n d i t i o n t h a t e v e r y norm bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence of p o s i t i v e elements i n t i o n s , then
h a s a norm l i m i t . I f
L
s a t i s f i e s t h e s e condi-
L
i s a s u p e r Dedekind and p e r f e c t Banach l a t t i c e .
L
The f a m i l i a r embedding of a normed Riesz s p a c e
i n i t s Banach bidu-
L
a1 L** i s a Riesz isomarphism; a c t u a l l y , theembedding i s i n t o (L*)* .Suprema n and i n f i m a of c o u n t a b l e ( o r a r b i t r a r y ) systems i n L a r e p r e s e r v e d i f a n d o n l y
P
is a n i d e a l
i f p i s o-order c o n t i n u o u s ( o r o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s ) . The s p a c e L in
if and only i f
L**
L
i s Dedekind o-complete and
c o n t i n u o u s ( e q u i v a l e n t l y , i f and o n l y i f and
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s ) . The s p a c e
p
only i f
i s o-order c o n t i n u o u s and
p
i s s u p e r Dedekind complete
L
i s a band i n
L p
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s and
h a s t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s ) . The s p a c e i v e i f and only i f and
and t h e norm
p
p*
i f and
L**
h a s t h e weak F a t o u p r o p e r t y f o r
L
sequences ( e q u i v a l e n t l y , i f and o n l y i f
i s o-order
p
in
are
L*
L
i s reflex-
L
o-order c o n t i n u o u s
h a s t h e weak F a t o u p r o p e r t y f o r sequences ( e q u i v a l e n t l y , i f and
L
only i f
and
p
p*
a r e o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s and
L
h a s t h e weak Fatou
p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s ) . T h i s r e f l e x i v i t y r e s u l t i s due t o T. Ogasawara.
I n s e c t i o n 115 we d i s c u s s o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r s space
i n t o t h e Dedekind complete Riesz s p a c e
L
F o r any operator T
+
T'
of t h i s class, l e t
T
T"
T'
M
,
from t h e Riesz
T
i.e.,
be t h e r e s t r i c t i o n t o
( a s i n s e c t i o n 9 7 ) . Then, i f
'(Mi)
= {O}
,
.
T E Lb(L,M) M i of t h e a d j o i n t
t h e mapping
i s a Riesz homomorphism, i . e . , (TIvT2)' = Ti v T;
and
(TlhT2)' = T;
I n t h e f i n a l s e c t i o n 116 we assume t h a t l a t t i c e s (norms such t h a t
K
and
p
and LA
L
P
A
and
.
Ti
LA
a r e Banach
A ). I f t h e r e e x i s t s a Riesz subspace
are R i e s z isomorphic and t h e norms
p
K
and
of A
L
in
P
16,51071
Ch.
K
385
EMBEDDING IN BIDUALS
are equivalent, then K
LA
is called a copy of
several theorems about copies in L
in L
P
. We
P '
tion are due to G.Ya. Lozanovskii. Here we mention that L contain a copy of more, L (c,)
(c,)
L
if and only if
is reflexive if and only if
L
L
then
N
and
p
4 The set
(f)
in Lc
be an arbitrary Riesz space and let
.
If
apl+bp2 and
p3 =
p ,p
E S
and
a,b
is the least upper bound of ordering. Given
and
p1
, and in
p2
apl(f)+bp2tf)
p 1 5 p2
S
.
whenever
obviously the above defined
and
p1
p3 (f) =
f E L , are again members of
for all
f E L
for all
be the set of all
S
is partially ordered by defining that
S
p l ( f ) 5 p2(f)
in L:
L:
and of
are non-negative constants,
1 2 s u p f ~ ~ ,, ~defined ~ ) by
p4 =
max{p,(f),p2(f)}
=
; further-
does not contain a copy of
107. Riesz seminorms and order density of :L
Let
does not
is a band in L**
.
or a copy of L l
Riesz seminorms in L
shall prove
the earliest results in this direc-
*
sup(pl,p2)
with respect to the partial
p2
, it is easy to prove that
S
p5
f E L
for any
is again a member of
greatest lower bound of
and
p1
To see this, note first that p6
S
. The Riesz seminorm
in the sense of the partial ordering.
p2
is a lower bound of
p5
p1
and
p6(f)
5
follows that
p5 =
If1
v+w with v,w E L+
=
inf(p ,p ) 1
2
. For any
tinguish carefully between the numbers that p 5 ( u )
5
min{pl(u),p2(u)}
u
E L+
.
If
p5(u)
, so
p5(f)
(x:O<x
pl(f)
(rn:n=l,2, ...) =
I
=
1,1
IfIdx and
p2(f)
= Z y 2-"lf(rn)l
is the set of all rational numbers in
for all x
. Note
and min{pl(u),p2(u)}
; the sign of inequality may occur. As an
be the space of all real continuous functions on
with
. It
it is necessary to dis-
example, let L
= 0
p2
is another lower bound, then
for any decomposition
U(X)
is the
p5
,then min{pl(u),p2(u)}
. Note that in this example
p1
and
= 1 p2
, where
(x:05x51)
. If
, but (inf(pl,p2)j(u)
are norms in L
=
. The Riesz
Ch. 16,51071
R I E S Z SEMINORMS AND ORDER DENSITY
386
seminorms derived from t h e p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s on s p e c i a l subset of seminorm i n
. We
L
S ; if
0
$ E L"
5
,
then
s h a l l say t h a t these
p
(f)
0
form a
L
i s a Riesz
$(if\)
=
a r e the a d d i t i v e seminorms i n
p$
L . LEMMA 107.1. If
i s a norm i n L and 0 5 $ E L" i s a-order eontinuous and n o t identieaZZy zero i i . e . , 0 < $ € L" ), t h e n t h e R i e s z seminorm i n f ( p , p b ) i s n o t identieaZZy zero. p
PROOF. The proof i s very s i m i l a r t o t h e proof of Theorem 90.5. We
and w e choose
inf(p,p ) = 0
assume t h a t
$
Then t h e r e e x i s t sequences 5 2-"
p(un) + $(u:) all
. Now we
n
for a l l
+
p(zn)
Since
. Hence
0
(vn,wn,z : n = l , 2 , n E for a l l n
, @(wn) <
i s a norm, i t follows from
p
+
n
such t h a t
E L+
such t h a t
Cp(un) <
...)
L+
in
5
u = v + w n n n z J. with p ( z )
n
.
+
E
0 2 v
such t h a t
and
0
.
+ u' and n n 0 5 u 2 u for
and
m
$(u) > 0
u = u
apply Corollary 90.3, according t o which, f o r any
t h e r e e x i s t sequences with
u
...)
(un,u;:n=1,2,
for a l l
0
,
> 0
n n
S z C
n
.
that
z 0 (Theorem 100.4); hence, 0 5 v 5 z C 0 From u ' = u-u = u-v -w n n n n n n s o +(u-vn) 5 2-" + E f o r a l l n we d e r i v e now t h a t u-v = u ' + w n n n ' A l s o , s i n c e u-z 2 u-v 5 u and $ i s a-order continuous, i t follows from z
n
E
J. 0
> 0
$ ( u ) = l i m @(u-vn)
that
,
$(u) = 0
so
. But
. Hence
t h e r e f o r e , t h a t the Riesz seminorm Assume now t h a t that
L"
and
L*,
$(u) <
t h i s contradicts
E
.
. This holds f o r every . The f i n a l r e s u l t i s ,
$(u) > 0
i s not i d e n t i c a l l y zero.
inf(p,p$)
i s a normed Riesz space with norm
L
a r e t h e spaces of a l l i n t e g r a l s
. We
p
recall
(o-order continuous
l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s ) and a l l norm bounded i n t e g r a l s r e s p e c t i v e l y . S i m i l a r l y , LL
and
L*
a r e t h e spaces of a l l normal i n t e g r a l s (order continuous
l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s ) and a l l norm bounded normal i n t e g r a l s . It was proved
L:
i n Theorem 102.6 t h a t
L*
Since any band i n
i s norm closed, i t follows t h a t
norm closed i n ideals i n
Lz
L*
L*
. We
and :L
and
are ideals i n
s h a l l i n v e s t i g a t e now how respectively. I f
no problem s i n c e i n t h i s case we have
L*
L
L" L*,
dense ideal in L z and
L
(and so
i s a normed R i e s z spaee,then L:
LE
and
and L:
L*
.
are
L:
behave as
i s a Banach l a t t i c e there i s
= L"
L* = L" ) . n n THEOREM 107.2. I f
and bands i n
u
L* = L c c
LE
is an order dense i d e a Z , i n :L
and
i s an order
.
Ch. 16,51071
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
PROOF. We s h a l l p r e s e n t t h e proof f o r that i f that
L',
387
. It
w i l l b e shown f i r s t
E L z i s given, t h e r e e x i s t s a f u n c t i o n a l 0 < $ E L r such and $ ( u ) I p ( u ) f o r every u E L+ . This follows e a s i l y
0 < $
$(u) 5 $ ( u )
p ' = inf(p,p$)
from t h e l a s t lemma according t o which t h e Riesz seminorm
i s n o t i d e n t i c a l l y zero. By Theorem 85.4 t h e r e e x i s t s now a p o s i t i v e l i n e a r functional
on
$
L
, not
i s t o s?y, $(u) I p'(u) and
$(u) 5 p(u)
. The
i d e n t i c a l l y z e r o and majorized by
f o r every
u E L+
. This
l a s t i n e q u a l i t y shows t h a t
$ E L',
,
p'
implies t h a t
that
$(u) S $ ( u )
. We have proved
Lr
i s an i d e a l i n L r w i t h t h e p r o p e r t y t h a t f o r any 0 < $ E L', Since t L z t h e r e e x i s t s a f u n c t i o n a l J, E L r such t h a t 0 < $ 5 $ i s o r d e r dense i n i s Archimedean, t h i s i s e x a c t l y t h e s t a t e m e n t t h a t thus t h a t
.
Lr
( c f . Theorem 2 2 . 3 ( v i ) ) .
L"
I n g e n e r a l , L*
i s n o t o r d e r dense i n
L"
. As
be t h e space of a l l r e a l continuous f u n c t i o n s on 1
= =
If Idx
f ( x0 )
implies
. Given
E C 0 , l l , t h e non-zero l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l
i s p o s i t i v e b u t n o t p-bounded. $I
. This
I L*
A s observed
if
xo
p(u ) 4 0
shows t h a t
e a r l i e r , t h e Riesz seminorm
4 u
f o r any downwards d i r e c t e d system
implies
p(u )
+
p(u)
and
p(u) 5 k(p).supp(uT)
. Every
p
if
pl s p
P
,
= sup p
then
p1
in
.
, which
i s o r d e r continuous
L
4 0
u
N
L
in
L
. There
are
w i l l b e c a l l e d a weakly Fatou k(p)
such t h a t
0 S u
4 u
o r d e r continuous Riesz seminorm i s
Fatou and every Fatou seminorm i s weakly Fatou. I f and
$(f) =
i s c a l l e d a Fatou serknom i f
p
seminomi i f t h e r e e x i s t s a f i n i t e c o n s t a n t implies
p
L p(f) =
Furthermore, i n f ( p , p $ ) = 0
i s n o t o r d e r dense i n
L*
weaker c o n d i t i o n s . The Riesz seminorm 0 I u
an example, l e t
( x : O S ~ l ) with
p
i s o r d e r continuous
i s o r d e r continuous. F i n a l l y , i t i s e a s y t o s e e t h a t
and a l l
p,
in
(p,:uECa})
a r e Fatou, t h e n
p
I n P a r t i c u l a r , any supremum of o r d e r continuous Riesz seminorms seminorm. W e mention some simple examples. I f
(X,h,u)
is a
i s Fatou. i s a Fatou
o-finite
measure s p a c e , t h e n t h e L -norm i n t h e space L (X,p) i s o r d e r continuous P P for I 2 p < m and t h e Lm-norm i s Fatou b u t n o t o r d e r continuous. This holds i n p a r t i c u l a r i f
X
i s t h e s e t of n a t u r a l numbers and
LI
i s the
measure a s s i g n i n g t h e v a l u e one t o each p o i n t . I n t h i s c a s e , t h e norm
388
in
RIESZ SEMINORMS AND ORDER DENSITY
lmi s weakly Fatou, b u t n o t Fatou. in
L
and t h e c a r r i e r
C
For any Riesz seminorm
N
P
= (fEL:p(f)=O)
i s , t h e r e f o r e , a band i n a band i n L = C
P nent of
and
C
N
8
. If
L
u
and
P
in
. If
P that
Hence, if
. If
L
we d e f i n e t h e n u l l i d e a l by
such t h a t
8
N(p)
component of
in
proved o n l y i n
C(p)
p(u )
n
+
. Let
, so
, there
< a
.
0 5 u
+
0
s u-u'n n
i s Dedekind complete, we have
v E n s u with n
This h o l d s f o r every
THEOREM 107.4. I f
L such t h a t
E
C(p)
and assume t h a t
i n particular
e x i s t , and we have
v C and n C ( p ) c C ( h ) , t h i s implies t h a t u-v
n
p(u) 5 k(p).supp(u-v
nom in
.
u = u n + un ' such t h a t L t h e elements By t h e Dedekind completeness of
. Since
= u
e x i s t s and
, then
e x i s t s a decomposition
= ~ u p ( u ~ + ~ : m = 0 , 1...) ,2,
.i/2n-1 u-v
2"A(u;)
n
P
sup { i n f ( p , n A ) l
p
and
N
.
C(p)
supn{inf(p,nh)}(u) < a
Then, f o r each
for
C(p)
.
p ( u ) = p(u ) f o r any u E L+ , where u i s the P P Hence, t h e i n e q u a l i t y on t h e r i g h t has t o be
and
u
L
i s t h e compo-
P
are weakZy
p = supn{inf(p,nh)}
. Since
p
p
N
h
C(p) c C ( h >
PROOF. It i s e v i d e n t t h a t t h e seminorm
u
and
N(p)
f o r any Riesz norm
L i s Dedekind complete and
P
i s likewise P i s weakly F a t o u , then
, where
u EL+
convenient, we w r i t e
i s l e s s than o r equal t o L = C(p)
p
N by P carrier C
. The
= (Np)d
C
P P i s weakly F a t o u , t h e n
f o r any
= p(up)
i s Fatou, then
p
p
C(p) = L
L
Fatou seminorms i n
p
i s Dedekind complete and
p(u)
C
. Note
P
L
LEMMA 107.3. I f
v
Ch. 16,81071
n
4 u
, and
vn C 0
) 5 k(p).supp(u ) 5 k(p).a n
i s Archimedean and
C(p) c C(h)
, then
. Then
so
a > supn{inf(p,nX)}(u) L
h(vn) 2 k(X).
,
.
so t h e d e s i r e d r e s u l t f o l l o w s . p
and
h
are Fatou semi-
EMBEDDING IN BIDUALS
ch. 16,11073
3 89
1
I' PROOF. Observe f i r s t t h a t t h e Fatou seminorm t o t h e Dedekind completion
p-
norm i n for
LA
. Indeed,
0 5 u-EL-
then
,
then
C(p) c C(A)
in
,
C(X)
,
p - 5 p;
and l e t
L
. Note
L-
which extends
w e have
in
L
and
and
A
b e Fatou i n
in
p- = p
(pw)rs
let
b e t h e i r e x t e n s i o n s . Since
p
. Hence,
and
N(p)
denotes t h e r e s t r i c t i o n of
n
v
v
so i t i s sufficient t o
first that
{inf(pA,nAA)}rs i s majorized by
s ~ p ~ [ i n f , ( p - , n A ^ ) S} ~v ~
. As
[+;>
in
we have s e e n above,
to
L
, N
. We
p = (p )rs
now t u r n
we s h a l l denote by L-
. This can be e v i d e n t t h a t v 5 p . We have prove now t h a t p 5 v . Note
p = w,
N
N ( A ) c N(p)
a s a Fatou seminorm t o
i s a Fatou seminorm i n
proved, b u t we do n o t need i t h e r e . It i s
f o r any c o l l e c t i o n of seminorms
p
N
and
N ( A ^ ) c N(p-1
supn[inf(p-,nA^)}
=
, which
sup { i n f ( p , n A ) }
prove t h a t
(p )rs 5 w
p
L
i s included
LA by t h e p r e c e d i n g lemma, which i m p l i e s
u n l e s s we f i r s t prove t h a t
It f o l l o w s t h a t
N
writing
that
p-
f o r any
such t h a t
L C(p)
satisfy
N(A)
and
A-
f o r b r e v i t y . Note t h a t we cannot e x t e n d
i.e.,
i s defined
p-
a r e Fatou i n
. Now,
our a t t e n t i o n t o t h e seminorm
v
p1
p-,A-
c c(h-)
C(p-) N
, where
i s a Fatou semi-
. Similarly
p
t h e d i s j o i n t complements
, i.e.,
L^
p
that i f
It f o l l o w s t h e n from t h e d e f i n i t i o n s of
in
p-
by
i s a Fatou seminorm i n
p-
such t h a t
L
i t i s n o t d i f f i c u l t t o prove t h a t i f
o t h e r Fatou seminorm i n p 5 p1
LA of
has a unique e x t e n s i o n
p
p
. Since L-
L
a s w e l l a s by
, we
nh
,
to
so
~ u p ( A , ) ~= ~( S U P A ; ) ~ ~ get
= p . Hence
P 5
v
. This
i s the desired r e s u l t . A t t h i s p o i n t w e i n t r o d u c e a p r o p e r t y f o r a normed Riesz s p a c e , con-
s i d e r a b l y s t r o n g e r than t h e weak F a t o u p r o p e r t y f o r t h e norm. We s h a l l say
.
390
RIESZ SEMINORMS AND ORDER DENSITY
t h a t t h e normed Riesz s p a c e
L = L
Ch. 16,§1071
h a s t h e weak Fatou property f o r d i r e c t -
P
ed s e t s i f e v e r y norm bounded upwards d i r e c t e d s e t of p o s i t i v e elements i n L
i f i t f o l l o w s from
h a s a supremum, i . e . ,
5
uT+
and
sup p ( u T ) <
m
e x i s t s . We n o t e a l r e a d y t h a t i t e a s y t o p r o v e t h a t e v e r y
sup u
that
0
Banach d u a l
L*
has t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s ( c f . a l s o
C o r o l l a r y 111.2). THEOREM 107.5. L
then
If L
f o r directed s e t s ,
has the weak Fatou property
i s a Dedekind complete Banach l a t t i c e and t h e nomi
i s weakly
p
Fatou. 0 5 u .f 5 uo
PROOF. I f
,
then
sup p ( u T ) 5 p(uo) <
e x i s t s by h y p o t h e s i s . T h i s shows t h a t L
L
, so
m
sup u
i s Dekiekind complete. Furthermore,
s a t i s f L e s t h e Riesz-Fischer condition ( i f
0 S u
E L
n
for
n
= 1,2,
and a = Zp(u ) < m , t h e n p ( s ) 5 a f o r a l l s = C: \ , so n n e x i s t s by h y p o t h e s i s ) . T h i s skows t h a t L i s a Banach l a t t i c e . F i n a l l y , w e prove t h a t e x i s t s a number .sup p ( u T )
k(p)
. Assume
n a t u r a l number k 3 supT p(uTk) inequality for
0 5 uTk
+T
u
uk
u
=
0
for all
. Hence,
, and
T
so
\
0
e x i s t s by h y p o t h e s i s . But p ( v ) 2 p('uk) > k k(p)
i k(p).
p(x) >
, because
, contradicting
the
m u l t i p l y i n g by a p p r o p r i a t e c o n s t a n t s , w e -2 , and s o p(uk) > k f o r e v e r y k L e t
.
supT p(uTk) = k
v = sup v
f o r every
k
t sup
. This
uTk =
and
(T
so
0)
number
p(u)
t h e r e e x i s t s f o r every
such t h a t =
n
w e prove t h a t t h e r e
implies
. Then
b e t h e s e t of a l l f i n i t e suprema of a l l u .rk -2 0 5 v 4 and p(v,) i Zk < f o r every v
{vo} Then
so
k(p)
s = sup s
i s i m p o s s i b l e t h a t sup, p(uTp) = 0 f o r some k
Tk p(uk)
may assume t h a t
+
0 5 u
such t h a t
t h e r e e x i s t s no s u c h
a directed set
k
. It
t h i s would imply
2 1
i s weakly F a t o u , i . e . ,
p
...
\
k
variable).
v = sup v
f o r every
k
,
is impossible, so there e x i s t s a
with the desired property.
For t h e n e x t r e s u l t s we need a s i m p l e lemma about t h e c a r r i e r s of normal i n t e g r a l s . LEMMA 107.6. Let
L
be a RGesz space such t h a t
(L ' :)
= I01
and l e t
( @ T : ~ E { ~ } )be a maximal d i s j o i n t system of non-zero p o s i t i v e elements i n L i L
.
.
For each T , l e t CT be the c a r r i e r o f 0, Then t h e band generated by the system of a l l CT i s L i t s e l f .
Co
in
a. 16,11071 If
PROOF.
39 1
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
Co
# L
,
t h e r e e x i s t s an element
u > 0
in
d
Co
. Since
= { O } , t h e r e e x i s t s a l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l 4 such t h a t 0 < 4 E L L '(L-) n and $ ( u ) > 0 Let $o be t h e minimal p o s i t i v e l i n e a r extension of the d r e s t r i c t i o n of $ t o Co , s o $,(u) = $ ( u ) > 0 and $ O ( f ) = 0 f o r a l l
.
f
E
Cd: =
(note t h a t
L
i s Archimedean because
f o r every band
A
in
= Co
A
the null ideal
i s included i n
.
T
$T
are normal i n t e g r a l s ( i . e . ,
$o I
t h i s implies by Theorem 90.6 t h a t (r$T:~€{~})
the hypothesis t h a t elements i n
L :
=
0
; hence,
i s included i n
Co
N($O) of $o I t follous t h a t t h e carrier C($,) of d Co , s o C(o0) I Co and hence C(@,) I CT f o r every
$o and a l l
Since
.
'(2)
L ) . This shows t h a t
. Hence,
C = L 0
$T
for a l l
T
elements of
,
L;
and t h e element
L
u E L+
$u(lfI) P
< p(f)
satisfies
i s a maximal system of nonzero p o s i t i v e
.
0,
5 p ).
p
in
a r e given, t h e r e e x i s t s by Theorem 85.4 a
$u
f E L
for a l l p
),
contradicting
We need s t i l l another simple observation. I f t h e Riesz seminorm positive l i n e a r functional
$0
on
such t h a t
L
$ u ( u ) = p(u)
and
( i n o t h e r words, the a d d i t i v e seminorm
Hence
+U
which shows t h a t every Riesz seminorm seminorms less than o r equal t o THEOREM 107.7.
t h e norm
p
Let
L
p
i s t h e supremum of a l l a d d i t i v e
p
.
be a Dedekind complete Banuch l a t t i c e such t h a t 0
i s weakly Fatou and l e t
(Li) = { O }
. 172en t h e s u p r e m of
a l l a d d i t i v e and order continuous Riesz seminorms which are majorized by i s a norm in
L
which is equivalent t o
(
2 p" 2 p 5 k ( p ) . p "
, where
formula expressing t h a t P(u)
2
p
if
'
p " = sup p$:p$
then
. More p r e c i s e l y ,
i s t h e constant occurring i n t h e
k(p)
i s weakly Fatou ( i . e . , 0
5
uT 4 u
implies
k(p).sup p(u,> 1.
PROOF. Before p r e s e n t i n g t h e proof, we note t h a t l a t t i c e by hypothesis,
SO
L* = L"
ence, t h e r e f o r e , i f we should w r i t e
and L:
.
i s a Banach
L
L* = L" I t would make no d i f f e r n n i n s t e a d of L" Turning t o t h e n
.
392
RIESZ SEMINORMS AND ORDER DENSITY
p r o o f , i t i s e v i d e n t from t h e d e f i n i t i o n of
Ch. 16,91071
that
p"
. For
p" 5 p
the
o t h e r i n e q u a l i t y , l e t a g a i n ( a s i n t h e l a s t lemma) t h e system (QT:~€h))
L i
b e a maximal d i s j o i n t system of non-zero p o s i t i v e e l e e n t s i n
and, f o r each
carriers
CT
,
T
let
aT . Note
be t h e c a r r i e r of
CT
that the
a r e m u t u a l l y d i s j o i n t by Theorem 90.6. By t h e l a s t
s m a l l e s t band c o n t a i n i n g a l l
i s t h e space
CT
through t h e f i n i t e d i r e c t sums of t h e
i s denoted by
ponent of
u
in
f i x e d and
B
v a r i a b l e ) i s d i r e c t e d upwards and
B
uB
emma t h e
itself, so i f
a n d , f o r any
CT
,
L
then t h e s e t
,
u E L+ of a l l
. Let
uB 4 u
B
runs
t h e com-
uB ( f o r B
u
be one of
t h e s e f i n i t e d i r e c t sums. Then t h e c o r r e s p o n d i n g f i n i t e sum of t h e i n t e g r a l s i s a s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e normal i n t e g r a l
$T
$
is
B ) . The c o r r e s p o n d i n g
seminorm w i t h c a r r i e r pB = 0
B
,
p
$
on
$
B
(i.e.,
t h e c a r r i e r of
i s , t h e r e f o r e , a n o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s Riesz
so t h a t i f we s e t
on t h e d i s j o i n t complement of
B
,
pE = p .
on
B
and
i t f o l l o w s now from Lemma 107.3
that
Now, i n f ( p B , n p + ) i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s s i n c e
p
hence (by t h e o b s e r v a t i o n above) t h e seminorm
$
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s , and i s t h e supremum
inf(pB,np ) $
of a s e t of o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s a d d i t i v e s e m i n o r m , e a c h of t h e s e seminorms o b v i o u s l y m a j o r i z e d by
and i t i s s t i l l t r u e f o r
p
. The
same i s t h e n t r u e f o r t h e seminorm
p ^ = supB p i
. Hence,
s i n c e f o r each f i x e d
B
we have by (1) t h a t
and s i n c e
p-
5 p"
n i t i o n of
p"
, we
by t h e j u s t observed p r o p e r t y of find already that
t h e p r o o f , we n o t e a g a i n t h a t i f of
u
in
B
,
then
P(U)
5
u
4 u
, and
k ( p ) . s u p B P(u,)
pB 2 k(p).p"
u € L+
p-
and by t h e d e f i -
f o r each
i s g i v e n and
uB
B
. To
i s t h e component
so = k ( p ) . s u P B P,(U)
2
finish
2 k (P).P"(~)*
Ch. 16,11071
393
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
Note t h a t i f
i s a normed Riesz space having t h e weak Fatou
L
property f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s , then ( i n view of Theorem 107.5) L
satisfies 0
the hypotheses of t h e l a s t theorem (assumed, of course, t h a t a l s o =
I01
) . The sequence space
(c,)
-
(L,)
=
of a l l r e a l sequences converging t o zero
s a t i s f i e s t h e hypotheses of t h e l a s t theorem, but
(c,)
does, not have t h e
weak Fatou property f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s . Furthermore, note t h a t t h e defining formula f o r
i n t h e l a s t theorem can a l s o be w r i t t e n , f o r
p"
0 2 u E L
,
as
The analogy with t h e formula
holding f o r any Banach space (not n e c e s s a r i l y a Banach l a t t i c e ) , i s evident The formula (3) i s a consequence of t h e f a c t t h a t ( i s o m e t r i c a l l y ) with a l i n e a r subspace of 111.1 that, i f
'(L;)
= {O}
with
(Li);
, it
L
. We
L**
can be i d e n t i f i e d
L
s h a l l prove i n Theorem
has the weak Fatou property f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s and
w i l l follow from formula ( 2 ) t h a t
. This was
L
can be i d e n t i f i e d
proved by T. Mori, I. Amemiya and H. Nakano ( [ I ] ,
1955); t h e r e s u l t about the equivalence of
p
and
p"
i n our l a s t
theorem i s t h e main instrument i n t h e proof. EXERCISE 107.8. Show t h a t the converse of Theorem 107.5 does not hold.
H I N T : Take f o r
L
t h e space
EXERCISE 107.9. Show t h a t i f
Archimedean space
,
L
then
v
=
(c,) p
with uniform norm. and
inf(p,A)
A
a r e Fatou norms i n t h e
i s a norm i n
example a t t h e beginning of t h e s e c t i o n , where norms
p1
and
p2
.
HINT: Note f i r s t t h a t V
f a i l s t o be a norm, then
{inf(p,nA)}(u) = 0
for a l l
inf(p,nh) = inf(p,nv) v(u) = 0 n
f o r some
. Now use
L
. Note
inf(Pl,p2) = 0
for u > 0
Theorem 107.4.
n = l,2,
. Hence
the
f o r the
... . I f
MORE ABOUT RIESZ SEMINORMS
394
Ch. 16,11081
108. More about Riesz seminorms Riesz seminorms i n a Riesz space t h e s p e c i a l property t h a t p
i s absolute ( i . e . ,
p
f E L ) and monotone ( i . e . ,
0 i v
i s a b s o l u t e i f and only i f
satisfying
inf(u,v) = 0
a r e seminorms
L
5
p(f)
implies
u
p(v)
p(u+v) = p(u-v)
. The o r d i n a r y
=
p
in
p(lf1)
5 p(u)
having
L
for all
) . Note t h a t
holds f o r a l l
u,v E L+
Euclidean norm i n t h e l e x i c o g r a p h i -
c a l l y o r d e r e d p l a n e i s a b s o l u t e , b u t n o t monotone. This shows t h a t , even i n a Riesz s p a c e of f i n i t e dimension, t h e r e can e x i s t a b s o l u t e norms t h a t f a i l t o b e monotone. This does n o t happen i f t h e space i s Archimedean. THEOREM 108.1.
L
If t h e Riesz space
i s Archimedean and of f i n i t e
dimension, then every absolute seminorm in PROOF. We may assume t h a t c o o r d i n a t e w i s e o r d e r i n g ) . Let t o b e shown t h a t and
v = (vl,
p
...,v n )
f i r s t coordinates numbers
a and 1 It f o l l o w s t h a t
, so
such t h a t
(since
=
p
satisfying
L
-u, < v 1 5 u 1
f L
be an a b s o l u t e seminorm i n
be points i n
\V I , U 2 , . . . , U n )
holds i n
L = En f o r some n a t u r a l number p
i s monotone. For t h i s purpose, l e t
satisfy
a2
is already a Riesz seminom.
L
, so
a l + a2 = 1
aI(uI,u2
,...,un)
L
n (with
.
It h a s
...,un ) . Then t h e
u = (ul,
0 i v 2 u
t h e r e e x i s t nonnegative and
v
= UIUl
+ a2(-uI,u2
.
+ a2(-u1)
,...,un )
is a b s o l u t e ) we g e t
Proceeding by i n d u c t i o n , i t f o l l o w s t h a t
p(v) i p ( u )
.
I n an Archimedean s p a c e of i n f i n i t e dimension t h e r e can e x i s t an abs o l u t e norm t h a t f a i l s t o b e monotone. We p r e s e n t an example. L e t v e c t o r space of a l l r e a l continuous f u n c t i o n s piecewise l i n e a r ( t h a t i s t o s a y , t h e graph of number of linesegments) and such t h a t
f(0) = 0
f
on
f
(x:O<x
derivative
f'
satisfies
If'I
=
llfl'l
be the
c o n s i s t s of a f i n i t e
. The
space
space w i t h r e s p e c t t o o r d i n a r y p o i n t w i s e o r d e r i n g . For any Hence,
L
that are
L
i s a Riesz
f E L
,
the
a t a l l b u t f i n i t e l y many p o i n t s .
Ch. 16,51081
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
p(f) =
IIIf'Idx 0
satisfies that
p
f u r any
. Furthermore,
p(f) = p(lfI)
if and only i f
395
p(f) 2 0
f = 0 (here i t i s used t h a t
i s an a b s o l u t e norm i n
0 < u E L
L
.
for a l l
f
and
p(f) = 0
f ( 0 ) = 0 ). I t follows e a s i l y
The norm
i s not monotone. I n f a c t ,
p
we have
This example makes i t reasonable t o ask f o r a general condition implying
t h a t an absolute seminorm be monotone. I n the next theorem we p r e s e n t a condition of t h i s kind.
is an absolute semzhorm in t h e P i e s 2 space L , then P i s monotone if and onZy if t h e functionaZ p ( f ) = p ( f + ) is subZinear f i . e . , p ( a f ) = a p ( f ) for constants a > 0 and p ( f + g ) s p ( f ) + p ( g ) THEOREM 108.2.
for
If
p
f , g E L ). PROOF. I t i s easy t o s e e t h a t
Conversely, l e t p ( v ) S p(u)
. By
functional
$
f E L
. Since
$(-w)
2 p(-w)
f u n c t i o n a l on that
0 2 v 5 u
. We
i s monotone.
p
have t o show t h a t
the Hahn-Banach extension theorem t h e r e e x i s t s a l i n e a r
on
such t h a t
L
w 2 0 =
i s sublinear i f
p
be s u b l i n e a r and l e t
p
0
L
,
implies
so
$(v) = p(v) p(-w) = p { ( - w ) + }
$(w) 2 0
. This
. But
then we have
and
p(v) = p(v)
p(u) = p ( u )
and
$(f)
p(f)
p(0) = 0
=
shows t h a t
,
for a l l we have
is a positive linear
$
p ( v ) = $(v) 5 $ ( u ) < p ( u )
. Hence
p(v) 5 p(u)
.
. Note
now
In the converse d i r e c t i o n , i t i s easy t o i n d i c a t e a monotone norm t h a t
i s not absolute. Let P(f) < p(f+)
+ p(f-)
t h e uniform norm i n
p
be a Riesz norm i n the Riesz space
holds f o r a t l e a s t one C([O,ll)
or in
f
in
L
lm1. Then p ( f )
L
such t h a t
(such a s f o r example = p(f+)
+ p(f-)
i s a monotone norm t h a t f a i l s t o be a b s o l u t e . These r e s u l t s about absolute and monotone seminorms a r e due t o W.A.J. in
lRn
Luxemburg. The r e s u l t i n Theorem 108.1 t h a t every a b s o l u t e seminorm (with coordinatewise ordering) i s a Riesz seminorm was known e a r l i e r
i n a paper by F.L.
Bauer, J. S t o e r and C. Witzgall, (C11,1961);
proof i s somewhat simpler.
the present
MORE ABOUT RIESZ SEMINORMS
396
A s b e f o r e ( i n s e c t i o n 107), l e t i n t h e Riesz space
L
. It was
T
lattice
i s a s u b s e t of
(P,:T€{T})
all
. The
pl(f) < p2(f)
ever
,
then define
p(f)
be t h e s e t of a l l Riesz seminorms
S
proved t h a t
t o t h e p a r t i a l ordering generated i n S
by
s
p,
f o r some
po
p ( f ) = sup, p,(f)
. Since any s u b s e t
p,
p1
<
when-
p2
i s Dedekind complete. Indeed, i f
easy t o s e e t h a t p i s a Riesz seminorm and s e t of a l l
is a l a t t i c e with respect
S
by d e f i n i n g t h a t
S
such t h a t
S
Ch. 16,§108]
p
t h e z e r o seminorm, i t follows now t h a t
inf p
T
.
f E L
It i s
i s t h e supremum of t h e of
(~,:T€{T})
and
po E S
f o r every S
i s bounded below by
exists i n
S (cf. f o r
example Theorem 1 . 2 , where i t was proved t h a t i f i n a p a r t i a l l y o r d e r e d s e t e v e r y s u b s e t bounded above has a supremum, then every s u b s e t bounded below has an infimum).
I n general the l a t t i c e
an example, l e t
L
such t h a t f E L
,
i s n o t d i s t r i b u t i v e . To mention
b e t h e space of a l l r e a l f u n c t i o n s on a p o i n t s e t
c o n t a i n s a t l e a s t two p o i n t s . Let
X
let
(PIAp3)(f)
S
pi(f) = If(xi)l for
0 i f E L
for
. For
i = 1,2
and
x1,x2 E X
p 3 = A(pI+p2)
t h i s purpose, l e t
X
and, f o r any
. We
f = u+v w i t h
compute u , v E L+.
Then
so t h e infimum f o r a l l decompositions
This shows t h a t
A p3
p
= Apl
f = u+v
. Similarly
of t h i s k i n d i s
p2 A P3 = 1P2
*
fp,(f)
.
Then
and
f o r t h e same of
PI’P2’P3
pI,p2,p3
The seminorm every
u E L+
a s above, b u t of course not f o r a l l p o s s i b l e choices
*
,
p
i n t h e Riesz s p a c e
t h e number
L
i s c a l l e d order bounded i f , f o r
s u p ( p ( v ) : O ~ v s u ) i s f i n i t e . Every Riesz seminorm
Ch. 16,§1081
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
39 7
i s o r d e r bounded. In t h e converse d i r e c t i o n , i f seminorm and
then
i s defined i n
p1
is an o r d e r bounded
p
by
L
i s a Riesz seminorm.We i n d i c a t e t h e proof t h a t
p1
satisfies
p1
the t r i a n g l e i n e q u a l i t y , t h e o t h e r p r o p e r t i e s b e i n g e v i d e n t . If and
0 i v 5 u1+u2
and
0 i v 2 i u2
and hence
,
u1,u2 E L+
t h e r e i s a decomposition v = v I + v 2 w i t h
0 i vI i u1
, SO
. For
pI(uI+u2) i p I ( u I ) + p1(u2)
arbitrary
fl,f2 E L
it
follows t h a t
Note t h a t i f
i s a norm, t h e n
p
i s a norm.
p1
As d e f i n e d e a r l i e r , t h e Riesz.seminorm
p(u+v) = p ( ~ )+ p ( v )
if
holds f o r a l l
i s d e f i n e d f o r every
$(f)
f E L
a p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on
$
,
then
p
-
-+
4 E (L )
(i.me., and
L
p
i s called additive
L
. If
by $ ( f ) = p ( f + )
L
i s a p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on P$(f) = + ( i f \ )
in
p
u,v E L'
L
. As
$
i s defined i n
4
observed e a r l i e r , every Riesz seminorm
into
(L-)'
mapping
f o r every $ + p$
p
is
$
by
L
. Evidently,
L
p$
$
i s a Riesz
i s t h e supremum
p
. The mapping
$
+
p$
p r e s e r v e s a d d i t i o n , m u l t i p l i c a t i o n by non-negative
S
0
c o n s t a n t s and o r d e r . Furthermore, i f 4 $(u)
then
) . Conversely, i f
i s an a d d i t i v e Riesz seminorm i n
of a l l a d d i t i v e seminorms l e s s t h a n o r e q u a l t o from
,
p(f-)
i s s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e i f and only i f t h e corresponding
norm i n
i s a d d i t i v e and
p
u E L+
from
,
(L-)+
i.e.,
p
into
$?
S
5
p$
$
in
4 $
in
S
L-
. This
,
then
0 5 $,(u)
p r e s e r v e s suprema of upwards d i r e c t e d
s e t s . I t i s l e s s t r i v i a l t o s e e t h a t t h e mapping a l s o p r e s e r v e s i n f i m a of a r b i t r a r y s e t s . For t h e p r o o f , l e t
$o
=
i n f $,
in
L-
. Let
($,:T€{T})
p = i n f p$,
any a d d i t i v e R i e s z seminorm s a t i s f y i n g
4
shows t h a t t h e
in
s
p$ s p
b e a s u b s e t of
. Then ,
then
p
2 p
(L-)'
. If
pJ'2 p i p $0
0,
with P$
for
is
398
MORE ABOUT RIESZ SEMINORMS
every
,
T
so
in
J, 5 $,
, and
L-
pJ' 5 p$o and s o , on account of
final result is that
p = p
.
hence
0
holds i n
S
i f and only i f
t h a t t h e Riesz seminorms hold5 i n (L-)+
follows t h a t get
p 5 p
, then
E (L-)'
holds i n
. The
inf(p+,p$) =
. We
L"
a r e d i s j o i n t whenever
p2
$0
s h a l l say
inf(pl,p2) = 0
(where t h e z e r o on t h e r i g h t denotes t h e z e r o seminorm). I f
S
convenient, we s h a l l w r i t e in
@,J,
inf($,J,) = 0
and
p1
, we
JI-
@O I t i s an immediate consequence t h a t i f
=
. It
(J 5 $,
p = sup(p :p
Ch. 16,91081
.
p1 I p2
. Hence,
p o I pJ,
i f and only i f
THEOREM 108.3. R i e s z seminorms i n the Riesz space
L
i n f ( p l .p2+p3) 5 i n f ( P 1 ,p2)
(ii)
p 1 1, p 2
and p3 implies
5 p2
( i i i ) p 1 I p2 (iv)
and
I
p 1 I p2
p1
p1 p3
i n f ( P 1 ,p3)
+
implies
PROOF. For t h e proof of ( i ) , w r i t e tions
Set
If1 =
u' = sup(u2,u3)
It f o l l o w s t h a t
Hence, denoting 2 p;(f)
.
p1
.
$I
p 1 ,p2,p3
.
.
I (p2+p3)
i n f ( p 1 , p 2 ) = p;
and
inf(pI,p3) =
E L and E > 0 b e given. There e x i s t decomposiu2 + v2 and If I = u3 + v3 i n L+ such t h a t
f o r b r e v i t y . Let
= p i
f o r aZl
implies P I I P 3 I ap2 for a l l a z 0
I
have the f o l l o -
wing properties. (i)
$
+ p;(f)
11'
f
and
v ' = If1 - u'
+ v' = If I
inS(p1,p2+p3)
, which
. Then
u',v'
E L+ and
and
by
p i
, we
have now t h a t
pi(f) 2
i s t h e d e s i r e d r e s u l t . P a r t (ii) i s e v i d e n t , and
( i i i ) i s proved e x a c t l y a s f o r elements of a R i e s z s p a c e ( c f . Theorem 1 4 . 2 ( i i ) ) . F i n a l l y , ( i v ) follows from ( i ) .
Ch. 16,51081
Let
L
. The
399
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
be again t h e l a t t i c e of a l l Riesz seminorms i n t h e Riesz space
S
subset
of
A
w i l l be c a l l e d a serrLlinear l a t t i c e i d e a l i n
S
S
if (a) it follows from alpl
al,a2
and
A
r e a l and non-negative t h a t
,
a2P2 E A
+
E
p,,p2
(b) i t follows from
p1
E A and
that
p2 I p1
E A
p2
.
The semilinear l a t t i c e i d e a l
A
i s c a l l e d a l a t t i c e band i f i n a d d i t i o n
i t follows from
p,
E A for a l l
and
4 p
p,
any s e m i l i n e a r l a t t i c e i d e a l i n from
, is
S
If p
E
of
. The
D
that
T
p
E A
. Note
that
t h e p a r t i a l ordering i n h e r i t e d
a Dedekind complete l a t t i c e . i s any non-empty subset of
D
such t h a t
S
, with
S
p
I
for a l l
p'
p'
S
,
then t h e s e t
Dd
of a l l
E D i s c a l l e d the d i s j o i n t compZernent
d e f i n i t i o n i s s i m i l a r t o t h e d e f i n i t i o n i n a Riesz space, where
every d i s j o i n t complement i s a band. Here we have a s i m i l a r s i t u a t i o n , b u t t h e r e a r e d i f f e r e n c e s . Every d i s j o i n t complement i s a s e m i l i n e a r l a t t i c e i d e a l (as evident from Theorem 108.3), For an example t h a t the points
xl,
by
...,xP
pCxI,
in
...,x
P
b u t not n e c e s s a r i l y a l a t t i c e band.
i s not a l a t t i c e band, l e t
Dd
C0,ll
, define
L = C(c0,ll)
t h e Riesz seminorm
l ( f ) = max[ I f ( x ) l : n = l , ( n
. Given
pCx I . . . . , x
P
1
..., ,...,
p and x ],...,x v a r i a b l e we have p[xl x 3 4 p , where p i s P P the uniform norm. Let t h e p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l 41 on L be given 1 by $ ( f ) = f(x)dx , so For
lo
p@(f)=
Now, l e t pCxl,.
D
. . , xP 1
I
0
If(x)ldx
be t h e . s u b s e t of i s a member of
. S
Dd
c o n s i s t i n g of because f o r any
p
4I
only. Every f
E L there e x i s t s a
..
decomposition If1 = u+v i n L+ such t h a t u vanishes a t X I , . ,x 1 ' d and v(x)dx i s a r b i t r a r i l y small. I t i s not t r u e , however, t h a t p E D
lo
Indeed, i f
p
I
f o r the function
p$
, we
u(x)
should have
i d e n t i c a l l y one on
C0,ll
,
and hence f o r every
.
E
t h e r e would be a decomposition
> 0
in
C(C0,ll)
such t h a t max f v(x):O<xsl
+ Il{l-v(x)}dx
\
i s not a l a t t i c e band i n
i s not a member of
. Hence,
into
S
1
so
Dd
majorized by
S
i s a semilinear l a t t i c e i d e a l i n
+
i s a Dedekind complete l a t t i c e , and t h e mapping
S1
(L")'
, and
Dd
be the s e t of a l l elements bf
S1
an a d d i t i v e Riesz seminorm. Evidently, S 1 from
.
E
be the l a t t i c e of a l l Riesz seminorms i n the
S
and l e t
L
p
.
S
EXERCISE 108.4. L e t
Riesz space
<
0
This i s impossible. It follows t h a t
S
Ch. 16,11081
MORE ABOUT R I E S Z SEMINORMS
400
+
p+
preserves a r b i t r a r y infima and a l s o preserves suprema
of upwards d i r e c t e d s e t s . (i) with
Let
v(X)
be a o - f i n i t e measure without atoms i n t h e p o i n t s e t
p
and l e t
> 0
L =
with
Lm(X,v)
i s not majorized by an a d d i t i v e Riesz seminorm, i . e . , Note, f o r t h i s purpose, t h a t i f we should have p+
, then
+(xE) t p ( x , )
Hence, decomposing we get
+(xE)
( i i ) Let i s not i n
S1
n
2
= 1
into
E
f o r any subset n
. This would
L = C(C0,ll)
. Show also
hold f o r a l l p
p[xl
where (as above) pCxI,
Since
pCx,,
...,xP l ( f )
...,xP 1 4
p
,
=
L = L2(X,u)
with
p
H I N T : Since
L2
2
with
t h e uniform norm i n for a l l
E S1
(
*
.
p(E) > 0
L
. x1
Show t h a t
,...,xP
p
'
J '
p
p
i s not a l a t t i c e band.
S1
be a a - f i n i t e measure without atoms
i s not i d e n t i c a l l y zero and l e t
the L -norm. Show t h a t
a d d i t i v e Riesz seminorm.
X
.
n
,...,xP J
i t follows t h a t
such t h a t
X
of
E
s1
f o r some a d d i t i v e
max I f ( x n ) l : l < n < p
EXERCISE 108.5. Once more, l e t
i n the point s e t
p i s not i n
p s p$
p
d i s j o i n t sets of equal p o s i t i v e measure,
with
that
X
the L_-norm. Show t h a t
p
p
i s not majorized by an
is a Banach l a t t i c e , any p o s i t i v e l i n e a r functional
Ch. 16,51081
4
on
L2
such t h a t
,/
5
uvdp
$(f) =
fvdp
f o r every m
. Then . The
f E L2
for a l l
. Let
0 5 u E L
vdp t { p ( E ) } ' l 2
u = a'112
xE
function
v
E
. If
b e a s u b s e t of
satisfies
E
,
such t h a t p(E) = n-'
so
n S N2
.
1,
and s o
r e s u l t . On t h e o t h e r hand we have
/E
Contradiction.
then
p(u) 5
such t h a t
X
, so
p(u) = 1
i s n o t i d e n t i c a l l y z e r o and f i n i t e
i s of f i n i t e measure. For some
= (x:v(x)
,
p 5 p$
almost everywhere, s o t h e r e e x i s t s a n a t u r a l number subset
0 5 v ( x ) E L2
i s norm bounded, s o t h e r e e x i s t s a f u n c t i o n
0 < p(E) = a <
1,
401
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
n > N2 vdp t n
vdp S Nn
such t h a t
N
,
-1
the s e t
*
. Hence
-1
=
EO Eo has a
by t h e above -112 Nn-l n
,
EXERCISE 108.6.
( i ) Show t h a t t h e same proof works f o r L (X,p) w i t h -1 -1 P L*=L for p + q = I . P 4 ( i i ) Show t h a t i f L = LI(X,p) w i t h p t h e L -norm (and even w i t h o u t 1
I < p < m . U s e t h a t e x t r a h y p o t h e s i s on
p ) , then every seminorm
an a p p r o p r i a t e m u l t i p l e of C > 0
exist in
L+
E L+
with
, but
such t h a t
, so
p
p'
S1 = S
,
5 Cp
p'
in
. Indeed,
i s majorized by
L
i f t h e r e does n o t
t h e n t h e r e i s a sequence
(un:n=1,2,
.
m
.
( i i i ) The r e s u l t i n p a r t ( i i ) can be g e n e r a l i z e d . Show t h a t i f i n c r e a s i n g p-Cauchy sequence i n Riesz seminorm i n 1
= S
...)
Then u = C n 2 ~ n E p(un) = 1 and p'(un) > n3 f o r a l l n 1 -2 Contradictiorz. p'(un) > n f o r a l l n t n
p'(u)
L
an a d d i t i v e Riesz norm i n t h e Riesz space
S
-
has an upper bound i n
L+
,
L+
i s majorized by a p o s i t i v e m u l t i p l e of
L
p
is
w i t h t h e p r o p e r t y t h a t every p
t h e n every
. Hence,
i n t h i s case.
EXERCISE 108.7. L e t
and
S
Riesz seminorm i s a member of
i s a d d i t i v e (note t h a t f o r
S1
S1
p,
and
p
E S1
a d d i t i v e i n g e n e r a l ) . Every
be t h e same a s b e f o r e . Every a d d i t i v e
b u t , i n g e n e r a l , n o t every member of p2
additive, sup(pl,p2)
is not
s1
h a s a minimal a d d i t i v e m a j o r a n t , given
by
0
p $ = i n f p$:p$tp
where t h e infimum i s t a k e n i n
S1 (or, equivalently, i n
S ) . Note t h a t t h e
(L7+ infimum on t h e r i g h t i s a d d i t i v e ( s i n c e t h e mapping $ + p $ from i n t o S p r e s e r v e s a r b i t r a r y i n f i m a ) . More p r e c i s e l y , $ = inf($:p$tp) , where t h e infimum i s now t a k e n i n
L"
. We
shall w r i t e
$
f o r the ele-
MORE ABOUT RIESZ SEMINORNS
402
ment
$
which t h u s corresponds t o
E (L-)'
This formula has a c o u n t e r p a r t .
exists since
x
$' Z $
. On
(note t h a t i t
x x
t h e o t h e r hand i t follows from
satisfying
J,
p
imp 1i e s
$1
0'
, we
get
<
that
i s Dedekind complete). Since p = sup(p : p S p )
L-
so
f o r any
51)
Show t h a t
Denote t h e supremum i n t h e l a s t formula by
HINT:
,
. Hence
.
+ < p > = inf(Ji:p$Zp)
p@r Z p
p E S1
Ch. 16,51081
0
= sup i(:p 5 p
$
5
( x
,
> p
Ji-
EXERCISE 108.8. Show t h a t
and t h e r e f o r e
x
px
5 $
p
, which
. s 1 onto
i s a mapping from
p + $
(L-)+
w i t h t h e following p r o p e r t i e s
+
f o r every
(i)
$
=
(ii)
$= a $
( i i i ) $<suppT> = sup +p @inf ( p l
(iv) p,
in
I p2
,.. . ,pn)>
>
i f and only i f
S1
$i = sup($:p$Spi)
+
5
Similarly f o r
x 1 2 /
+
for
J, Z $ < p T >
$2 t $
hence
. For
+pT>
that
p
J,
J, t $<supp >
.
i
P$
Finally, f o r (iv), w r i t e
sI
'
and
we have
$2
respective-
, so
,P$5P2)
5
.
. i s an upper bound of t h e
$<sup p >
any o t h e r upper bound t pT
by
$
= 1,2,
= $
For ( i i i ) , i t i s e v i d e n t t h a t s e t of a l l
and
$
,
al,a2 t 0
exists i n
. .,$) . Hence, I $ < p 2 > i n L- .
$
(
\
for real
>
2 2 sup p,
if
$2 = sup $+jl:P$
sup x : p 5 p +p
,
inf ( $ < p l > , .
=
HINT: For ( i i ) , denote l y . Then
1
4 E (L-)+ > + a $
for a l l
p* = i n f ( P I , .
T
it f o l l o w s from
J,
,
..,P
so )
pJi 2 sup p
and
, and
Ch.
16,11081
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
We have t o show t h a t
Q
=
i s s u f f i c i e n t t o show t h a t
0'
403
holds. Since
$ 2
. Since
$ ' 5 $
is evident, it
Q'
we g e t
Every n - t u p l e
f o r which t h i s h o l d s s a t i s f i e s
EXERCISE 108.9. T
E
{T}
,
( i ) Show t h a t i f
and it i s g i v e n t h a t
p,
I. p
p,po
E S,
and
p,
and
p,
for a l l
E S1
,
then
t h e i n t e r s e c t i o n of
S1
I po
for a l l
T
P I P o .
( i i ) Show t h a t f o r any s u b s e t t h e d i s j o i n t complement
of
Dd
HINT: For ( i ) , n o t e t h a t
D
of
S1
i s a l a t t i c e band i n
D
I. $ < p >
$
. Hence, i n L" , a l l $
b e l o n g t o t h e $ . T h i s d i s j o i n t complement i s a band i n
and
$
L"
, so
i.e.,
p
T
(since
$ < p T > f $
) . Hence
EXERCISE 108.10.
$
I
$<po>
if X
and
= sup($,$)
Show a l s o t h a t i f
$(f) = f(y) in
*
I $
for a l l 0 d i s j o i n t complement o f
it contains
I po
.
$
(i) L e t L be t h e R i e s z s p a c e of a l l r e a l f u n c t i o n s
on a p o i n t s e t c o n s i s t i n g of two p o i n t s $(f) = f(x)
,
s1
and
L-
,
, so
x and
$
and
y
. For
b e l o n g t o (L")'
$
X(f) = f ( x ) + f ( y )
then
p = sup(pg,pJI)
,
any
f o r every
f E L
,
let
. Show t h a t f 6 L .
then
1 J f o r every mapping
f E L $ + pb
. Derive
that
p
<
p
X
and
p
#
px
. This
d o e s n o t p r e s e r v e a r b i t r a r y suprema.
show t h a t t h e
Ch. 16,51091
EMBEDDING I N THE ORDER BIDUAL
404
( i i ) Let
be an a r b i t r a r y Riesz space and l e t
L
and
S
same as i n t h e e a r l i e r e x e r c i s e s . Show t h a t t h e s e t equivalence c l a s s e s
belong t o t h e same equivalence c l a s s whenever and
p1
$ < p l > = $
belong t o t h e same equivalence c l a s s , then
p2
p1
and
. Show t h a t
sup(pl,p2)
p2
if
and
belong a l s o t o t h a t same c l a s s . Show t h a t every equivalence
inf(p1,p2)
c l a s s contains e x a c t l y one a d d i t i v e Riesz seminorm. and
be t h e
i s decomposed i n t o
S1 p + $ ; t h e seminorms
by t h e mapping
S1
,
0,
$
=
then t h e equivalence c l a s s of
Explicitly, i f contains
po
s1
$0 i s t h e l a r g e s t member of
no o t h e r a d d i t i v e Riesz seminorm. Furthermore, p
49 equivalence
t h a t p a r t i c u l a r equivalence c l a s s . Hence, t h e
Po
and
p
c l a s s of t h e zero
seminorm c o n s i s t s of t h e zero seminorm only. Show t h a t f o r and
E
pl,p2
, the
S,
through t h e equivalence c l a s s e s of by p a r t ( i ) ) t h a t
p;
equivalence c l a s s of If
0 s QT f $
J, = sup $T p o = sup p
pl + p
(L-)
in
, but
exists in
$T
S1
pl,p2
and
p1
E
,
S1
let
p;
p
and
and
3
run
p i
r e s p e c t i v e l y . Show (again
p2
2,
.
,
then
p
t h e system and
po
4JT
in
p4J
+
.
S1
I f , however,
i s not d i r e c t e d upwards, then
satisfies
s
po
may b e d i f f e r e n t ( c f . again p a r t ( i ) ) , show t h a t
$
+ inf(p1,p2)
does not n e c e s s a r i l y run through the whole
+ pi
(L")'
in
p 3 = sup(p,,p2)
belong t o t h e same equivalence c l a s s . Note t h a t
p 4 = p 1 + p2
may be d i f f e r e n t ( c f . p a r t ( i ) ) . For
p4
p
seminorms
p$ po
. Although and
p+
and 0 belong t o p
t h e same equivalence c l a s s .
109. Embedding of Let by of
B
. We
B
. In
f o r every
prove t h a t
every p o s i t i v e
. Hence,
if
i t follows from
$
f
$
f"
in
B
of t h e Riesz space
. Evidently,
B
f"
on
in
, so
L
-
and B
B-
. For
B#
t h e proof,
f"($) = $ ( f ) 2 0
for
is now a p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on
f" (f-)" B
L
i s defined on
i s a r e a l l i n e a r func-
f"
i s p o s i t i v e , then
i s an a r b i t r a r y element of f" = (f+)"
B
i s a member of t h e a l g e b r a i c dual
belongs t o t h e o r d e r dual
f
p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s on is that
E
o t h e r words, f "
note t h a t i f t h e given B
L"
be given. The realvalued f u n c t i o n
f"($) = $ ( f )
t i o n a l on
i n t o t h e o r d e r bidual
be an i d e a l i n t h e o r d e r dual
B
f E L
let
L
that
, i.e.,
f"
L (not n e c e s s a r i l y p o s i t i v e ) , i s t h e d i f f e r e n c e of two
f " E B"
. The next
f a c t t o observe
for a l l
f,g E L
. On
account of g = 0
formula ( 1 ) o n l y f o r that
(f')"
405
EMBEDDING IN BIDUALS
Ch. 16,81091
(f")+
=
,
(f-g)"
it i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove
f"-g"
=
t h a t i s t o s a y , i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove
. For
f E L
f o r every
0
t h i s purpose, l e t
$ E B
S
.
Then
by Theonem 83.9. Since
t h e l a s t e x p r e s s i o n i s equal t o $(f+) =
,
(f+)"($)
f o r every p o s i t i v e
in
$
B
so
d i a t e consequence of formula ( 1 )
(f")+
=
-
,
f E L
a Riesz subspace of
0 5 $=
+
0
u: L
+ B"
, defined
i s a Riesz homomorphism. A c t u a l l y , u
of a l l normal i n t e g r a l s on
Bn
let
a s d e s i r e d . I t i s an imme-
(f')"
t h a t a s i m i l a r formula i s t r u e f o r
I t has been proved t h u s t h a t t h e mapping
space
holds
, i.e.,
inf(f,g)
for a l l
$(f+) =
. This
(f")+($) = (f+)"($)
it f o l l o w s t h e r e f o r e t h a t
in
B" B
contained i n
. It
B BZ
, i.e.,
. For
maps
t h e image
into the
u(L)
of
(f")+($,)
+
is
L
f E L
t h e proof, l e t
i s s u f f i c i e n t t o show t h a t
u(f) = f"
by L
aad 0
.
This f o l l o w s by o b s e r v i n g t h a t
Before proceeding, w e s t a t e two more simple f a c t s about t h e Riesz homomor-
.
u
phism
LEMMA 109. I .
o
that
5
, then it foZZows from o , i . e . , o 5 u(uT) 4 u(u) .
( i ) ~f B c L;
uy o ul' i n
:B
( i i ) The Riesz homomorphism B
separates t h e p o i n t s of L
Q
in
PROOF. B ,
(i) Let
B c:L
u
0
u
4 u
in
L
i s a Riesz isomorphism i f and o n l y i f
, i.e., and
5
i f and o n l y i f 5
u
4 u
in
L
OB = 103
. Then,
.
f o r any p o s i t i v e
406
0
which implies
.
u" 4 u"
5
( i i ) Follows by observing t h a t i t follows from If L
Ch. 16,91093
EMBEDDING I N THE ORDER BIDUAL
$(f) = 0
for all
"
Bn
.
o(L)
f = 0
implies that
E B
$
i s a Riesz isomorphism ( i . e . ,
u
and i t s image
space of
f" = 0
.
f = 0
O B = {O}
if
) , we s h a l l i d e n t i f y
I n o t h e r words, we s h a l l regard
and we s h a l l say t h a t
i s embedded i n
L
i f and only i f
a s a Riesz sub-
L
as a Riesz sub-
BX
space. I n t h i s case, the a d d i t i o n a l condition t h a t B i s contained i n :L i s equivalent t o s e v e r a l o t h e r c o n d i t i o n s , as s t a t e d i n Theorem 106.2. One of these conditions, which we s h a l l need f o r t h e next theorem, s t a t e s t h a t i f
E L and 0 < $ E B a r e such t h a t $(u) > 0 , then t h e r e e x i s t s an v E L such t h a t 0 < v 5 u with $(v) > 0 and $(v) = 0 f o r
0 < u
element all
satisfying
J, E B
J,
I
. Furthermore,
$
a s mentioned i n the same
Theorem 106.2, i t follows from Corollary 105.12 t h a t i n t h i s case
. We
o r d e r dense i n
L: l e n t t o t h e condition t h a t THEOREM 109.2.
If
B
is
s h a l l present now two more c o n d i t i o n s , each equivaB
B
i s contained i n
i s an ideal i n L"
LZ
.
*B = {O}
such that
, then the
following conditions are equivalent. (i) (ii) Of
L
.
i s contained i n L"n The ideat D generated by B
.
( i i i ) The embedding of
L
L
:B
in
in
i s a Dedekind completion
:B
preserves arbitrary suprema and
i n f ima. PROOF. ( i )
*
( i i ) . The o r d e r dual
(Corollary 83.5). Hence, s i n c e
of
B-
B
i s an i d e a l i n
D
i s Dedekind complete
i s Dedekind complete. I n v i r t u e of the d e f i n i t i o n of ment of
D
i s majorized
by an element of
i s a Dedekind completion of t h a t f o r every
0
uo S u-
u E L
X > 0
, it
u-
S u
u- = 0
x
, which
. Hence,
t h e r e e x i s t s an element
. For
for all
D
every p o s i t i v e e l e f o r t h e proof t h a t
A > 0
uo E L
such t h a t
be given. There e x i s t s an element
a l l real
would imply
D
follows t h a t
i s s u f f i c i e n t (by Theorem 32.6) t o show
t h e r e f o r e , 0 < u- E D
satisfying
impossible t h a t for a l l
0 < u-ED
. Let,
L
L
, it
B"
A
,
let
, because
u- = 0
(since
UA
=
then BL
(u^-hu)+
u-
5
Xu
. It
is
would hold
i s Archimedean).
D
Ch. 16,01091
,
A
let
be the n u l l i d e a l of
UA
uX > 0
such t h a t
A > 0
Hence, t h e r e e x i s t s a number value of
40 7
EMBEDDING I N B I D U A L S
uX
,
. For
this particular
i.e.,
uA= and l e t of
in
UA
g r a l on B
be the c a r r i e r of
CA
B
,
B
, i.e.,
ui
.
since
A
UA
. As
CA
0
i s the d i s j o i n t complement
From u- E D c B r i t follows t h a t u^ i s a normal i n t e A A s o t h e n u l l i d e a l UA of i s a band i n B Furthermore,
has t h e p r o j e c t i o n property (since
B = U
CA
,
u^ > 0 A
i s a normal i n t e g r a l on
observed already, uX the carrier
of
CA
9 0 . 4 ) , s o t h e r e e x i s t s an element
.
i s Dedekind complete). Hence,
B
satisfies
uX
$o E
0 <
CA
CA
# {O}
such t h a t
. Hence,
B
(by Theorem
u;($~) > 0
.
I t follows then from
that
$,(u)
cluded i n that
. As
2 u*($ ) > 0
A
0
s t a t e d above, the hypothesis t h a t
L i implies now t h e e x i s t e n c e of an element
$,(v)
>
0
and
$(v) = 0
for a l l
p a r t i c u l a r , t h e r e f o r e , $(v) = 0
J,
for a l l
E UA
$-$A
,
so
The elements on
B
, so
($-$A)(v) = 0
u i = (u^-Au)+
.
(u^-Xu)-
$
in
CA
by
$A
and
(u^-Au)-
Since
$A
E
CA
u*($~) t X$A(u)
.
. Then
CA
,
a r e d i s j o i n t normal i n t e g r a l s of
UA
i s contained i n t h e
t h i s implies
(~^-AU)-($~)
which implies t h a t
Hence
. In
o r , i n o t h e r words,
by Theorem 90.5 the c a r r i e r
n u l l i d e a l of
1 $,
be an a r b i t r a r y p o s i t i v e
$
and denote t h e component of
B
J,
such
J,
For t h e f i n a l p a r t of t h e proof, l e t element of
E B satisfying E UA '
i s in-
B
0 < v s u
I n v i r t u e of (Z),
i t follows t h a t
=
0
,
408
This shows t h a t t h e element element
uo = Xv
=)
( i i i ) . By assumption, the i d e a l
a Dedekind completion of
L
. If
the equality (iii)
0 L
0E
5
in
. The
D
D
in
L
holds i n
is
:B
,
L
then t h e
i s an i d e a l i n
,
:B
as well. S i m i l a r l y f o r i n f i m a .
B;
( i ) . In t h i s p a r t of the proof we denote t h e image of any
u" f 0
. This
. Since
D
holds now i n
under t h e embedding i n
implies for
*
f = sup f
generated by
D
f = sup(f :oE{o})
same holds i n the Dedekind completion
f E L
0 < uo I u^
satisfies
h a s , t h e r e f o r e , t h e required p r o p e r t i e s .
uo
(ii)
on
Ch. 16,51091
EMBEDDING I N THE ORDER BIDUAL
B
BI;
, i . e . , ~ " ( 0 )f , we have $(uT)
shows t h a t
again by
0
$ 2 0
f 0
= u:($)
assumption, u in
, i.e., 0
i s contained i n
B
. By
f"
f o r every
C 0
. Hence,
i s a normal i n t e g r a l
.
LI;
B
We n o t e , f i n a l l y , t h a t i s i s not d i f f i c u l t t o give a d i r e c t proof t h a t ( i ) implies ( i i i ) ; c f . Lemma 1 0 9 . 1 ( i ) . The following theorem i s now an immediate consequence, I t deals with the case t h a t
B = L" n
THEOREM 109.3. D
the ideal and
D
.
('L:)
If L i s a R5esz space s a t i s f y i n g L
generated by
in
. Furthermore,
(LZ);
i s order dense i n
t h e embedding of
(Li)I; preserves arbitrary suprema and infima. I t follows t h a t (L;);
ideal i n
, then
= {O}
i s a Dedekind completion o f
(L;);
under the embedding i f and o n l y i f
L
L L
L
in
i s an
i s Dedekind
complete. EXAMPLE 109.4. We mention one example; f u r t h e r examples w i l l follow
i n t h e next s e c t i o n . Let
L
be the space ( c ) of a l l ( r e a l ) convergent
sequences. A l i t t l e more i n d e t a i l , we may say t h a t (re al ) functions
f = (f(l),f(Z),
converges a s
m
n
+
. We w r i t e
uniform norm, then e,(X,)
, where
e x i s t s an element
for a l l
f
E L
on
X = (l,Z,
. If
such t h a t
becomes a Banach l a t t i c e , s o the o r d e r dual XI = { O } U X
. Precisely,
(a(O),a(l),a(Z),...)
. Any
...)
i s t h e space of a l l
$
with
a(0) = 0
in
f(n)
i s equipped with t h e
L
L* a r e i d e n t i c a l . A s well-known,
t h e Banach dual with
L
...)
L = c(X)
L
L*
f o r any
L,({O}UX)
L"
and
may be i d e n t i f i e d $
E L*
there
such t h a t
i s obviously a normal i n t e g r a l on
Ch. 16,51101
. The
409
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
E L has the f i r s t n n o r d i n a t e s z e r o and t h e remaining c o o r d i n a t e s one, then f n + 0 , so
L
$,(fn)
+
converse h o l d s a s w e l l (because i f $ E L :
for
0
, which
= L :
from which i t f o l l o w s t h a t L = c(X)
in
L (:):
=
(L;):
f
implies
a(0)
. The
= La(X)
lae_CX) i s t h e space
in
=
sa(X)
L :():
L , (X) ,
itself. (c,)
of a l l sequences
(:): = L-(X) L = ( c ) = co(X) , t h e n L 0 i s now t h e s p a c e L i t s e l f .
converging t o z e r o , i . e . , L
L :
i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by
Note a l r e a d y t h a t i f we s t a r t w i t h t h e space generated by
0 ) . Hence
=
co-
; the ideal
110. P e r f e c t Riesz s p a c e s
I n t h e preceding s e c t i o n we have i n t r o d u c e d t h e Riesz homomorphism
, where
L + (L-)"-n a l l 4 E Ln
0:
u(f)
. Identifying
f E L
i s defined f o r L
w i t h i t s image
Example 109.4, i t can occur t h a t
i s t h e whole space
u(f)($) = $(f)
,
t h e space
for
is
L
a s a Riesz subspace. The Riesz homomor-
embedded i n t h i s manner i n:):L(
0
phism i s a Riesz isomorphism i f and only i f u(L)
by
o(L)
(L;):
L ():
. As
= {O}
seen i n
i s a Riesz isomorphism and t h e image
u
. In
o t h e r words, we may w r i t e
L = (Lz):
i n t h i s c a s e , where t h e s i g n of e q u a l i t y denotes t h a t t h e homomorphism
i s an isomorphism, Any Riesz space s a t i s f y i n g
L = (L-)n n
is called a
p e r f e c t R i e s z space. The name was i n t r o d u c e d o r i g i n a l l y f o r t h e c a s e t h a t i s an i d e a l i n t h e sequence space
L =
(fl,fg,
...)
such t h a t t h e c a r r i e r of
numbers. I n t h i s c a s e :L Clfngnl f
E L
,
then
L
z/fngnl
PROOF. Let f i r s t
L
wards d i r e c t e d system i n
sup $ ( u ) <
5
P($) <
m
such t h a t
p ( $ ) = sup $(u,)
and
-
sup $(uT) <
f o r every
P ( $ ~ + $ ~=) p ( $ , )
such t h a t
+
g E L" n
f o r every
be p e r f e c t and assume t h a t L+
...)
only i f
is p e r f e c t if and only if
L
.
put
g = (gl,g2,
converges f o r a l l
= { o } a n d it folZows from 0 5 u t and E :L t h a t sup uT e x i s t s i n L
. We
i s t h e s e t of a l l n a t u r a l
is perfect.
THEOREM 110.1. The Riesz space
E :L
L
f =
( c f . Theorem 8 6 . 3 ) . I t i s e v i d e n t t h a t
f E L
. If
(L):
of a l l r e a l sequences
i s t h e space of a l l
converges f o r every
i s included i n
L
(s)
P($,)
0
5
for
(L ' ):
0 5 $ E
i s an up-
(u~:T€{T}) m
$ E L-
0 E
f o r every
. It
9, ,
=
0 5 $ €
is evident that N
$2 E L,
. Hence,
410
PERFECT R I E S Z SPACES
extending
p
i n the obvious manner t o the whole of
f u n c t i o n a l , we f i n d t h a t
. Furthermore,
E (LL)-
p
i t follows t h a t element
. Hence,
p E :L)(:
E L such t h a t
u
0 5 $ E L i
.
u = sup u
p
This shows t h a t
holds i n
,
= u
0 5 u 4 and in
L
. The
s u p $(u,)
<
since i.e.,
since
0
in
S $A 4 $
in
1 u^
0 < $ E
every
follows t h a t i.e.,
u1 E L
0 5 $
5 , so
u
f o r every
4 $(uo)
$(u,)
with
L :():
f o r every
u
E L-n
Since a l s o 0 5 $ E L;
L
i s a band i n
. Note
E L*
f E L
{' (L"):}
and
f^($) = 0
= {O}
f^($) = 0
0 5 $ E L"
now t h a t i f
then i n p a r t i c u l a r elements
$
and
under t h e embedding of
$(uT)
. For
$ = 0
as desired.
Next, l e t
0 < $,
4
"
. Then,
easily that shows t h a t
in
L"
and
N
(L ) n
sup u^($,)
i n p a r t i c u l a r , sup $,(u)
p(u) = sup $ ( u ) p = sup $
<
m
LN
L"
.
it
,
is p e r f e c t .
t h i s purpose, we have f^
, then
E (L-):
for a l l
f-
<
, as
,
E (L-):
explained i n the
$(f) = 0
m
f o r any
f o r any u
E L+
for a l l
0
. It
i s a p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on
holds i n
,
u^ = uo
t h a t a r e images of N
in
L
is
for
4 u^($)
. But then (L;); .
fa($) = 0 f1
. It .
sup $ ( u T ) <
for a l l
f o r a l l those
E L , and s o
U
(L-)Hence, l e t n n In o t h e r words, $(uT) 4
beginning paragraph of s e c t i o n 109. It follows t h a t
E (L ln
N
(Ln)*
t h e order dua2
L
exists
by hypothesis. Then
L
.
shows t h a t
0
.
T
f o r every
T-
PROOF. We f i r s t prove t h a t
t o show t h a t i f
sup u
i s Dedekind complete.
L
implies t h a t exists i n
$ E Ln
5
u ^ ( $ ) = $(u,)
. This
E L for a l l
THEOREM 1 10.2. For any Riesz space
$ = 0
that
i s a band i n
L
. This
= sup u
O
and t h e r e f o r e
and t h a t i t follows from
0 I $ E L l
i s an o r d e r dense i d e a l i n
s u f f i c i e n t , t h e r e f o r e , t o prove t h a t 2 u
,
(Ln)n
l a s t condition implies immediately t h a t
Hence, by Theorem 109.3, L
1. u - ( $ )
holds i n
(LL) = { O }
f o r every
m
f o r every
A. ,-
is perfect.
L 0
i s p e r f e c t , t h e r e e x i s t s an
L
$ ( u ) = sup $ ( u , )
u = sup u
because
L
Assume now, conversely, t h a t
f
as a linear
L :
implies
:L
0
16,51101
Ch.
u^
E
follows L
, which
Hence, t h e p e r f e c t n e s s conditions mentioned i n the l a s t theorem hold
Ch. 16,11101
in
. It
L
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
follows t h a t
411
i s perfect.
L"
THEOREM 110.3. I f the Riesz space
L
is p e r f e c t . In p a r t i c u l a r , f o r any Riesz space L t h e space i s a band i n t h e p e r f e c t space L" ) . f e e t ( s i n c e :L A
PROOF. Let
be a band i n the p e r f e c t Riesz space L = A
i s Dedekind complete (by t h e p e r f e c t n e s s ) , s o o f any normal i n t e g r a l on
. To
A
If
j
show now t h a t
'(A;)
and a l s o
I E
E A
If
0 S $
+(if\) = 0
f o r any
0 2 $
. Then
E A"
0 5 $
n
sup $(uT) <
-
0
0 5 u
exists i n
u = sup u
let
f
E A
(A ' ):
in
4
A
in
4
that
satisfy
f E
0
i s an i d e a l i n
and
-
sup $(uT) <
.
Hence, s i n c e n Evidently, u E A (since
.
L
restriction
(A")
?!
A
. Then . Hence .
f o r every
and, once again by the remark above,
L
E L"
0 5 $
L
. The
Ad
.
u
5
f o r every
. Note
E A,". Then, i n view of the remark above, = {O} E L i , and s o I f ( = 0 because ('L:)
= {O}
Furthermore, l e t
@
L
i s per-
L :
i s , t h e r e f o r e , a normal i n t e g r a l on
, since
(A ' ):
f o r any (A ' ):
,
= {O}
$(lfI) = 0
This shows t h a t
A
to
L
L
i s p e r f e c t , then any band i n
L
is p e r f e c t ,
A
i s a band). The
conditions of Theorem 110.2 a r e s a t i s f i e d t h e r e f o r e . It follows t h a t
A
is
perfect. The next theorem goes i n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n . THEOREM 110.4. I f
A
such t h a t
PROOF. Let 0
5 $
If1
=
0
Q E L"
5
u' + u"
with
o
, and
5 $
in
A
u
@
O(L;)
Q ( I ~ =I )o
, so
f o r every
Ad
=
. Furthermore, T
, so If
0 5 u u' + 'u T
t h a t every p o s i t i v e normal i n t e g r a l $ on A ( s e t $ = 0 on Ad ), it follows t h a t $(u') = 0
L
E :A
hence
Now, l e t we have
I ~ EI
by the Dedekind completeness of L , we have d 0 5 u' E A and 0 5 u" E A , s o Q(u') = 0 f o r every
L = A
can be extended t o = 0
. Then
f E '(L;)
L
is p e r f e c t .
. Observing now
f o r every IJ"
A i s a band i n
i s Dedekind complete and
are p e r f e c t , then L
. Since
E :L
L
a d
I
= u'
+ u"
in
L
with
0
4 T
u' =
sup $(u:)
o
on account of =
and 5
<
-
0
. This
sup Q.:u ) <
u' E A
-
'(A;)
shows t h a t
0
5 $I
E A :
. Similarly .
= {O}
f o r every
andT 0 2 u" E Ad
f o r every
= {o}
'(L;)
0 5 Q E L"
. Hence ,
0 5 'u
. 4
s i n c e every posi-
t i v e n o r m a l i n t e g r a l o n A can be extended t o a p o s i t i v e n o r m a l i n t e g r a l on Land
Ch. 16,§1101
PERFECT R I E S Z SPACES
412
s i n c e 0 5 u ' 5 u . It follows, by the p e r f e c t n e s s of T T exists in A S i m i l a r l y , u" = sup u" e x i s t s i n Ad
.
= sup u
holds i n
. The
L
space
A ,that
. Hence,
u ' = sup u'
'
u' + u" =
s a t i s f i e s , therefore, the perfectness
L
conditions of Theorem 110.2. EXAMPLE 110.5. ( i ) I f
L = Lm and
A s an example, l e t
,
= L
A
i s p e r f e c t and
L
i s an i d e a l i n
A
i s not n e c e s s a r i l y p e r f e c t , even i n the case t h a t
A
so
. Then
A = (c,)
i s p e r f e c t . On t h e o t h e r hand, A:
L
=
:L
=
b,
L
,
then
i s order dense.
A
L,
and
and
(A:)
N
N
(Ln)n =
Lm
1- , so
=
i s not p e r f e c t . ( i i ) If
i s an i d e a l i n the p e r f e c t Riesz space
A
i s p e r f e c t i n i t s own r i g h t , then
L = 1-
an example, l e t
and
i s not n e c e s s a r i l y a band i n
A
f i n i t e number of nonzero coordinates. Then A
L
A
. As
t h e i d e a l of a l l sequences with only a
A
( i ) ) and f o r the proof t h a t
such t h a t
L
i s p e r f e c t (as seen i n p a r t
L
i s p e r f e c t , note t h a t
A" = ( s )
,
the space
of a l l r e a l sequences. ( i i i ) Let
be a Riesz space such t h a t
L
and
4 (n=l,2,...)
0 S u
the e x i s t e n c e of
sup u
words, t h e d i r e c t e d s e t
n
sup $ ( u n ) <
. Then 0 S u
L
(L ' ):
on
f
E L i implies
L
.
0 S u 4 A s an example, l e t X n the Riesz space of a l l bounded r e a l
which vanish o u t s i d e a countable s u b s e t of
X
f ) . Then
subset varying with
L
X (this
i s Dedekind complete (even super Dedekind
-
complete) and i t i s not d i f f i c u l t t o v e r i f y t h a t
. Also,
5 $
i s not n e c e s s a r i l y p e r f e c t . I n o t h e r
110.2 cannot be replaced by a sequence functions
0
i n t h e p e r f e c t n e s s condition of Theorem
4
be an uncountable p o i n t s e t and
and such t h a t
= {O)
f o r every
m
L"
n
=
1 , (X) , s o '(L;)
=
N
sup $ ( u ) < f o r every 0 5 $ E Ln = n n = L,(X) , then the sequence (u :n=l,2, ) i s bounded i n t h e uniform norm n (apply t h e Banach-Steinhaus theorem t o the l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s un = {O)
if
0 S u
(X) 1:
-
f o r every u
2 u
i?,(X)
) . It follows t h a t
i s t h e space of a l l bounded functions on
completion of that
...
sup u exists. n (Ln)n = "
i s not p e r f e c t , a s follows by observing t h a t
EXERCISE 110.6. <
and
on t h e Banach space
(n=l,2,...)
Nevertheless, L =
4
L
0
Let
'(L;)
=
{Ol
. Show
that
i f and only i f i t follows from 2
$
for a l l
E -L: T
X
an example.
i s a Dedekind
L :():
0 5 u
t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s an element
. Give
.
N
and
4
u
in
sup $(uT) L
such
Ch. 16,51111
HINT: Assume t h a t
with
0 5 u
4
(L:):~
and sup u
=
-
sup $(uT) <
exists i n
L (:)
,
L
for a l l
uT 5 u
N
5
$ E Ln N
L (:)
by Theorem 110.1. Since
0 < u
I.
and
. Choose an a r b i t r a r y in
L
(Lz):
f o r every
0 5 $ E ; L
such t h a t
u 2 v
u^ 5 u
. This
ideal
D
v
in
in
u E L
(L:):
.
-
f o r every
such t h a t
u
Since t h e i d e a l
5 u
D
by hypothesis, t h e r e e x i s t s a n elemenb
u
u^ = sup(v:u->vEL)
satisfying
u- t v E L u- E L (:) N
-
D = (Ln)n
, which
,
u- 5 u
D
have
. Hence completion of L . L
4
(the i a s t
and s i n c e
shows t h a t every p o s i t i v e
generated by
i s a Dedekind
. Hence,
for a l l
0 5 u
i s a Dede-
(L;):
i s a Dedekind completion of
, we
i s order dense i n:):L(
u^ 2 0
and l e t
such t h a t
u E L
sup $(uT) <
implies t h e e x i s t e n c e of an element
generated by
. Then-
N
L
i s a l s o p e r f e c t , so
.
T
N
0 5 $ E {(Ln)n}n = Ln
t h e r e e x i s t s an element
Conversely, assume t h a t 0 5 $ E L" n for a l l T
0
f o r every f o r every
i s p e r f e c t ) . But
L :
kind completion of and s o
i s a Dedekind completion of
L (:):
sup $(uT) <
e q u a l i t y because U-
413
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
L
, so
. It
E L
follows t h a t
i s contained i n t h e implies t h a t
1 1 1 . P e r f e c t Banach l a t t i c e s
The property of a Riesz space t o be p e r f e c t i s obviously s i m i l a r t o t h e property of a Banach space t o be r e f l e x i v e . A s we s h a l l s e e ( i n Theorem 1 1 4 . 9 ) , any r e f l e x i v e Banach l a t t i c e i s p e r f e c t . The converse does not hold; the space
La
i s p e r f e c t , b u t not r e f l e x i v e . Another p o i n t t o observe i s
the s i m i l a r i t y between the weak Fatou property f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s ( i n a normed
-
f i e s z space) and t h e p e r f e c t n e s s condition r e q u i r i n g t h a t i t follows from 0
5
u
t
and
sup $(uT) <
f o r every
0 < $ E L i
that
sup uT
exists.
It i s easy t o s e e t h a t i n a p e r f e c t Banach l a t t i c e t h e norm possesses t h e
weak Fatou property f o r d i r e c t e d sets. The converse is a l s o t r u e , b u t t h i s
i s more d i f f i c u l t t o prove. The d e t a i l s a r e contained i n t h e following theorem, which i s e s s e n t i a l l y due t o T. Mori, I. Amemiya and H. Nakano ([11,1955); 107.
t h i s i s t h e theorem r e f e r r e d t o i n t h e l a s t paragraph of s e c t i o n
PERFECT BANACH LATTICES
414
THEOREM 1 1 1 . 1 .
The normed R i i s z space
Banach Zattice i f and onZy i f
('L:)
t h e existence of
sup u
in
PROOF. Assume f i r s t t h a t
4
( w i t h norm
L
and
= {O}
property f o r directed s e t s ( i . e . , 0 < u
sup $(u,)
<
n e s s of
L
m
,
that
m
implies
i s a p e r f e c t Banach l a a t t i c e . I t i s i n -
L
if
0 5 u
0 < $ E L* = :L
n exists i n
sup u
has t h e weak Fatou
p
L i.
. Hence,
L" = L* n n f o r every
i s a perfect
p
sup $ ( u ) <
and
(L ' :)
cluded i n t h e d e f i n i t i o n of p e r f e c t n e s s t h a t Banach, we have
Ch, 16,51113
L
4
= {O}
with
. This
. Since
sup p(u ) <
is
L
, then
m
i m p l i e s , by t h e p e r f e c t -
. The norm
p
has, therefore,
t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s . Convereely, assume t h a t
0
(L):
and
= {O}
has t h e weak Fatou
p
p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s . A s shown i n Theorem 107.5, L complete Banach l a t t i c e . I t f o l l o w s t h a t that
N
L
(since
= L*
.
i s now a Dedekind i s Banach) and
L
= (L*)* I t remains t o show L o i s embedded as an i d e a l i n (L")" n n n n t h a t L = (L*)* For t h i s purpose we r e c a l l formula ( 2 ) i n t h e l a s t n n paragraph of s e c t i o n 107 f o r t h e norm p " i n L According t o t h i s formula
.
.
we have
f o r every norm
p
u
. For
E L+ , and by Theorem 107.7 t h e norm
-
t h e proof t h a t
pl'
i s equivalent t o the
i s p e r f e c t , assume now t h a t
L
0
.
5
u
in
I.
0 < $ E L* = L" Each u i s a bounded n n and su~Iu~($)I= supI$(uT)I < l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on t h e Banach s p a c e L;
L
and
sup $(u ) <
f o r every
$
f o r every
, so
E L:
(~"(U~):T€{T})
Banach-Steinhaus theorem. But t h e n p"
a r e e q u i v a l e n t , and hence
i s a bounded
i s bounded s i n c e
(P(U~):T€{T))
sup u
COROLLARY 1 1 1.2.
L*
For any rwrmed Riesz space
L*
has
p
is perfect.
(with mrm p ), the
i s perfect.
PROOF. Note f i r s t t h a t i f p e r f e c t , so
L
L
and
p
e x i s t s by t h e h y p o t h e s i s t h a t
t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s . This shows t h a t
Banach dual
L
i s Banach, t h e n
L* = L"
and
is
L"
i s p e r f e c t . What we have t o prove, t h e r e f o r e , i s t h a t
is perfect also i f
L
be i d e n t i f i e d with
(L-)*
i s n o t Banach. One method i s t o show t h a t
, where
L-
-
s e t of numbers by t h e
i s t h e norm completion of
L* L
L*
may
.A
Ch. 16,51121
415
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
second method i s t o apply t h e p e r f e c t n e s s theorem which we proved a moment ago. Note f i r s t t h a t every $(f) = 0
that on
0
2
$
a c t s a s a normal i n t e g r a l on
E L
E L*
implies
,
L*
f
i.e.,
=
. Hence,
0
O{(L*),}
and
L*
t h e normal i n t e g r a l s
. For
= {O}
t h e proof
has t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s , assume t h a t
L*
in
.f
such t h a t
L*
. Writing
u E L+
f o r e:ery that
f
$
s e p a r a t e t h e p o i n t s of
L*
that
for a l l
a
sup p * ( $ , )
=
$ ( u ) = sup $,(u)
i s p o s i t i v e and a d d i t i v e on
$
1 1 1 . 1 , L*
$
, we
have
. Then
m
L
in
,
a.p(u)
it i s e v i d e n t
e x i s t s , t h e r e f o r e , a norm
which extends
$ = sup $,
sup $,(u)
u E L+
for
. There
L+
bounded p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on f u n c t i o n a l a g a i n by
<
L*
. Denoting
$
. Hence,
this
by Theorem
is perfect.
EXERCISE 1 1 1 . 3 . Show t h a t f o r a normed Riesz space w i t h o r d e r continuo u s norm t h e r e s u l t in Theorem 1 1 1 . 1 may be d e r i v e d e a s i l y from Theorem
110.1.
112. Banach f u n c t i o n s p a c e s I n t h e p r e s e n t s e c t i o n we assume t h a t
i s a u - f i n i t e measure
(X,A,y)
space. As on e a r l i e r o c c a s i o n s , t h e Riesz space of a l l ( r e a l ) w m e a s u r a b l e f u n c t i o n s on denoted by
X
( w i t h i d e n t i f i c a t i o n of u-almost
M(X,u)
. Let
L
b e an i d e a l i n
o r d e r s e p a r a b l e , every i n t e g r a l on u-order
proved i n Theorem 86.3 t h a t i f
L
on
X
is
M(X,p)
every
i s o r d e r continuous. I t was
i s an i n t e g r a l on
$
g
. Since
M(X,p)
i s a normal i n t e g r a l , i . e . ,
L
continuous l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on
a umeasurable r e a l function
equal functions) w i l l be
L
,
then there e x i s t s
such t h a t
A
f E L
holds f o r a l l
. Without
l o s s of g e n e r a l i t y i t may b e assumed t h a t
,
and t h e n
g
i s U-almost everywhere
uniquely determined. Hence, i f t h e c a r r i e r of
L
is the s e t
v a n i s h e s o u t s i d e t h e c a r r i e r of
L z (=L-> tions all
L
X
g
i t s e l f , then
may be i d e n t i f i e d w i t h t h e space of a l l ( r e a l ) p-measurable funcg
f E L
on
X
, and
having t h e p r o p e r t y t h a t if
g
and
gf
i s u-smmable over
X
for
6 L z correspond i n t h i s manner, t h e n t h e y
determine e a c h o t h e r uniquely. I t may happen t h a t
L :
c o n s i s t s of t h e n u l l
416
BANACH FUNCTION SPACES
Ch. 16,11123
u
f u n c t i o n a l only. In s e c t i o n 85 i t was shown, f o r example, t h a t i f
no atoms and
i s e i t h e r t h e whole space
L
M(X,u)
has
o r one of t h e spaces
.
f o r 0 < p < 1 , then L" = I03 , and t h e r e f o r e L : = TO} We L (X,u) P s h a l l prove now t h a t t h i s does not happen i f L i s equipped with a norm. P r e c i s e l y , we prove t h a t i f
is
L
YL;)
=
, then
i s a norm i n t h e i d e a l
p
and t h e c a r r i e r
L
L* i s X , i . e . , '(L:) n w i l l follow then immediately t h a t t h e c a r r i e r of L : is
of
X
{03
t h e c a r r i e r of
. It
= {O}
x ,
.
i.e.,
F i r s t we make some remarks. A s observed i n Theorem 110.3, t h e space
L;
is perfect. Also, since
space
L,* i s a band i n t h e p e r f e c t space L* , t h e
i s p e r f e c t . Furthermore, note t h a t whereas
LE
( r e a l and measurable) f u n c t i o n s
, the
f E L
g
possibly smaller space
on
:L
where, a s evident from t h e formula, p * g 5 L i
and any
f
with
p(fl) 5 1
and
number
t h e number
a
sgna = 1
gfldu =
X
such t h a t
c o n s i s t s of a l l
L;
I
IgfIdv < g
c o n s i s t s of a l l
E
5-
denotes t h e norm i n
for a l l
m
such t h a t
. For
L*
p(f) 5 1
t h e function
f
(we r e c a l l t h a t f o r any r e a l o r complex
Igf ldu
i s defined by
sgn a
f l = Ifl/sgn
s g n a = a/lal i f
satisfies
g
a # 0
and
a = 0 ). It follows t h a t we may j u s t as well say t h a t
if
c o n s i s t s of a l l
g E L" n
any
L:
such t h a t
sup(1 l g f l d u : p ( f ) < l and t h i s supremum i s then e x a c t l y the norm THEOREM 1 1 2 . 1 .
on
X
.
Let X
ideal with carrier
L
PROOF. Let
X,
of
g
, as
be a normed Riesz space such t h a t M(X,u)
i n t h e space
Then the c a r r i e r of
p*(g)
L,*
is X
, and hence ):L(' X
-
= '(L:)
such t h a t
i s t h e c a r r i e r of
X
L
i s an
of a l l measurable functions
be a measurable subset of
but otherwise a r b i t r a r y . Since
defined above.
L
,
= TO}
p(X,)
> 0
. ,
it follows from
t h e d e f i n i t i o n of t h e n o t i o n of a c a r r i e r ( s e c t i o n 86) t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s of
such t h a t
0 < p(E) <
a subset
E
function
xE
Hence, A
c o n s i s t s of a l l measurable
of
X, E
belongs t o
L
. Let
A
and t h e c h a r a c t e r i s t i c be t h e i d e a l generated by
and (almost everywhere) bounded
xE.
Ch. 16, §1121
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
. It
functions vanishing outside
E
M(X,u)
The i d e a l
as well as i n
.
L
i s obvious t h a t
xE
a normed Riesz space. Evidently
417
,
A
, and
E A:
n a l . Let
g(x)
#
A:
, non-negative
E
$
. Since
{O}
(by Theorem 107.2) i t f o l l o w s t h a t
:A
exists a positive linear functional
, is
p
t h e r e f o r e t h e corresponding
linear functional i s not the n u l l functional, so o r d e r dense i n
i s an ideal i n
A
equipped w i t h t h e norm
#
A:
{O)
A* i s n so there
,
which i s n o t t h e n u l l f u n c t i o -
A:
and n o t i d e n t i c a l l y z e r o on
, be
E
the corre-
sponding f u n c t i o n , i . e . ,
for a l l 5
f E A
II$l\.p(f)
f
0 5 f E L
Let now f
. Denoting
for a l l
E A f o r a l l n , so
for a l l
n
.
Setting
t h e norm of
E A
. There
by
$
.
1 1 $ 1 1 , we 0 5 f
e x i s t s a sequence
g(x) = 0
outside
E
, we
have
+
l+(f)l 5 fXE
such t h a t
find that
hence
1
.
gfdu 5 l l $ l l . p ( f )
X
This shows f i r s t of a l l t h a t Hence, w r i t i n g
0
$(f) =
i s u - s u m a b l e over
gf
gfdu
for
i s r e p r e s e n t e d by t h e f u n c t i o n
c a l l y z e r o on t h e s u b s e t every s u b s e t
XI
of
X
E
g
XI
x. A s observed above, 'L* n
X,
f o r every 0
#
$
f
.
E L and
E :L
which, a s s e e n above, i s n o t i d e n t i -
. We
. This
X
E L , we f i n d t h a t
have proved t h e r e f o r e t h a t f o r
there e x i s t s a function
i s n o t i d e n t i c a l l y z e r o on
such t h a t
of
f
g
in
L*
such t h a t
i m p l i e s t h a t t h e c a r r i e r of
c o n s i s t s of a l l measurable f u n c t i o n s
L*
g
on
g
is
X
i s t h e norm i n t h e Banach d u a l
where p *
sometimes c a l l e d t h e a s s o c i a t e to by
.
p'
Since
,
L*
space
space of
L'
=
L
and t h e r e s t r i c t i o n of
P
, we
. For
p
is
f u n c t i o n s p a c e :L
p*
s i m p l i c i t y of n o t a t i o n ,
and t h e c o r r e s p o n d i n g a s s o c i a t e norm
i s a band (and t h e r e f o r e norm c l o s e d ) i n t h e Banach
L;
t h e space
L'
i s a Banach l a t t i c e w i t h r e s p e c t t o
L'
more, as proved, t h e c a r r i e r of
is
L'
X
. In
p'
.Further-
view of t h e d e f i n i t i o n of
have
f E L
for a l l
and
a s s o c i a t e s p a c e of =
. The
L*
i s then c a l l e d t h e a s s o c i a t e norm of
L*
we d e n o t e t h e a s s o c i a t e s p a c e by
p'
Ch. 1 6 , § 1 1 2 1
BANACH FUNCTION SPACES
418
L'
. Note
= (L')-
(L');
n
. Repeating
g E L'
, we
o b t a i n t h e second a s s o c i a t e s p a c e
h
Note t h a t , f o r
X
on
L"
= (L')'
t h a t t h e l a s t e q u a l i t y f o l l o w s from t h e f a c t t h a t
i s Banach. The c a r r i e r of functions
t h e p r o c e d u r e , i . e . , making t h e
is
L"
X
and
L"
=
L'
c o n s i s t s of a l l measurable
such t h a t
,
0 I h E L"
t h i s may b e w r i t t e n as
hgdp:g>O,p'(g)
=
1 I '
Compare t h i s formula a l r e a d y w i t h formula ( 2 ) i n s e c t i o n 107. If = L"
f
E L , then
I lfgldy
by t h e d e f i n t i o n of
Hence, L
is included i n
look a t t h e embedding of i n Theorem 109.2. in that
N
L
B
such t h a t
Writing
L" L
and into
B = L'
OB = { O }
i s contained i n
<
Lz
m
g E L'
for all
. Furthermore,
L"
,
p" 5 p
L"
on
L
.
, and
so
f
E (L'):
=
It i s i n s t r u c t i v e t o
from t h e p o i n t of view of t h e r e s u l t s
f o r a moment, we s e e t h a t
B
is
X
b e c a u s e t h e carrier of
. Furthermore,
B
L'
i s an i d e a l
,
and such
i s Dedekind complete. Hence,
Ch. 16,§1121
419
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
by Theorem 109.2, L
i s an order dense i d e a l i n
(L')-
. This
= L"
i s quite
i n agreement with what we have found now i n a d i f f e r e n t manner. Let us ment i o n some examples. I f L' =
L,
and
.em .
L" =
L
i s t h e space
If
L
f i n i t e l y many nonzero terms, then L' = L,:
L,
=
and
.
Lm
L" =
(c,)
with t h e uniform norm, then
i s t h e space of a l l sequences with only N
Ln
i s t h e space of a l l sequences,
The next question t o consider i s under which conditions with
. If
L"
i s a Banach l a t t i c e with r e s p e c t t o
L
coincides
L
p (i-e.,
if
is
L
a Banach f u n c t i o n s p a c e ) , the answer can be derived immediately from Theorem 1 1 1 . 1 . =
.
L (:):
only i f
I n t h i s case
It follows t h a t
N
N
L ' = L* = L and t h e r e f o r e L" = (L ) * = n n n n L and L" contain t h e same f u n c t i o n s i f and
i s p e r f e c t . Hence, by Theorem 1 1 1 . 1 ,
L
under which conditions
L
and
t h e answer t o t h e question
coincide i s contained i n t h e f i r s t p a r t
L"
of t h e following theorem. THEOREM 112.2.
only i f
L
(i) I f
, then
L
the carrier of
L
L"
is
contain the same functions i f and
i s perfect or, equivalently, i f and o n l y i f
L
X
i s a Banach function space such that
and
Fatou property f o r directed s e t s ( i . e . , 0
5
f
has t h e weak
p
sup p ( f T )
i n L with
4
implies t h a t the function sup f T' which e x i s t s i n M ( X , u ) , i s an element of L 1 . I n t h i s ease the norms p and p" i n L = L " are <
m
P
equivalent. ( i i ) If L"
L
i s a normed Riesz space with carrier
contain the same functions and such that
norms i n
L
PROOF.
, then
L
and
X
, so
('L:)
=
L
{O}
has c a r r i e r
given already t h a t p
L
and
are equivalent
p"
('L:)
=
and
, L
L"
the space
,
the space
L
:L
i s a Banach
c o n s i s t of the i f it is
i s p e r f e c t . By Theorem 1 1 1 . 1 ,
L
{O}
X
. Furthermore,
l a t t i c e by hypothesis. Hence,as observed above, L same f u n c t i o n s i f and only i f i f and only i f
such that
i s perfect.
( i ) Note f i r s t t h a t s i n c e
has likewise c a r r i e r
p
X
P
i s a p e r f e c t Banach l a t t i c e
has t h e weak Fatou property f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s . Observe
now t h a t i n view of formula ( 2 ) near t h e end
of s e c t i o n 107 t h e norm
p"
i s e x a c t l y t h e one occurring i n Theorem 107.7. Since the hypotheses of Theorem 107.7 a r e s a t i s f i e d i f
p
has t h e weak Fatou property f o r d i r e c t -
ed s e t s ( t h i s implies Dedekind completeness), i t follows t h a t a re equivalent i n
L = L"
.
p
and
p"
420
BANACH FUNCTION SPACES
( i i ) Since
and
p
p"
Banach ( w i t h r e s p e c t t o
are e q u i v a l e n t i n
Ch. 16,§1121
L = L"
L" i s
and s i n c e
p" ), i t f o l l o w s immediately t h a t
L
i s Banach
(with r e s p e c t t o p ) . Hence, we a r e back i n t h e s i t u a t i o n of p a r t ( i ) .
I n Theorem 107.5 i t w a s proved t h a t i f t h e normed Riesz space t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s , then Banach l a t t i c e and t h e norm
i s weakly Fatou ( i . e . ,
p
has
L
i s a Dedekind complete
L
t h e r e e x i s t s a con-
s t a n t k ( p ) 5 1 such t h a t 0 < u + u i n L i m p l i e s p ( u ) < < k ( p ) . s u p p ( u ) ). Besides t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s t h e r e e x i s t s a s i m i l a r p r o p e r t y f a r monotone sequences. The normed Riesz space L
i s s a i d t o have t h e weak Fatou property f o r monotone sequences i f i t
follows from
0
_<
u
n
1. (n=l,Z,
.
...)
in
and
L
sup p(un) <
m
that
exists i n L It i s e v i d e n t t h a t t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i sup u n r e c t e d s e t s i m p l i e s t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r monotone sequences. Under c e r t a i n a d d i t i o n a l c o n d i t i o n s t h e converse h o l d s . We s h a l l d i s c u s s t h e s e i n t h e n e x t s e c t i o n , b u t we mention a l r e a d y one case because i t can b e a p p l i e d
L
immediately i n t h e p r e s e n t s i t u a t i o n where i n t h e space Riesz s p a c e
M(X,p)
L
. The c a s e we wish
i s an i d e a l w i t h c a r r i e r
X
t o mention i s t h e one where t h e
i s o r d e r s e p a r a b l e and h a s an a t most countable o r d e r b a s i s .
Then t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r monotone sequences i m p l i e s t h e same f o r d i r e c t e d sets. The proof w i l l b e g i v e n i n Theorem 113.2. Applying t h i s r e s u l t t o t h e s i t u a t i o n i n t h e p r e s e n t s e o t i o n , we g e t THEOREM 112.3.
( i ) Let
be an ideal with carrier
be a a-finite measure space, l e t
(X,A,p)
i n the space
p
. Then
p
and
( i i ) A s i n p a r t ( i ) , Zet p
be a Banach function space with L"
con-
L i s perfect or, equivalently,
L has t h e weak Fatou property f o r monotone sequences. I n
t h i s case t h e norms and l e t
L
of a l l ( r e a l ) p-measur-
L and i t s second associate space
t a i n the same functions i f and only i f i f and only i f
M(X,p)
L
and, f i n a l l y , l e t
able functions on X respect t o the norm
X
t h e f o l l o w i n g theorem.
in
p"
L
be a Riesz norm i n L
L = L"
are equivalent.
be an ideal with carrier
. If, i n
t a i n the same functions and t h e norms
p
X
i n M(X,p)
t h i s situation, L and
and
p"
L"
con-
are equivalent, then L
i s perfect. Hence, L has nOzJ the weak Fatou property for directed s e t s (as well as for monotone sequences). We f i n a l l y r e c a l l t h a t a normed Riesz space
L
such t h a t
L
i s an
Ch.
16,11131
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
i d e a l i n t h e space
42 1
of a l l u-measurable f u n c t i o n s on
M(X,u)
times c a l l e d a nomed Kb’the space ( t h e
i s some-
X
c a s e of sequence spaces was inves-
t i g a t e d by G. KEthe b e f o r e t h e g e n e r a l theory was developed). It i s of int e r e s t t o compare t h e c o n t e n t s of t h e p r e s e n t s e c t i o n w i t h what was observed (without p r o o f s ) i n s e c t i o n 9 about normed KGthe spaces. I n p a r t i c u l a r , n o t e t h a t i f t h e Fatou c o n s t a n t
k(p)
satisfies
k(p) = 1
i n t h e l a s t theorem, and t h u s we g e t t h e r e s u l t of W.A.J. G.G.
, then
= p
p”
Luxemburg and
Lorentz mentioned i n s e c t i o n 9 .
113. The Fatou p r o p e r t y
A s d e f i n e d e a r l i e r , t h e normed Riesz space
that
sup u
case
L
exists i n
L
. It
and
4
i s a Dedekind complete Banach l a t t i c e and t h e norm I. u
in
implies
L
the l a s t inequality (i.e.,
sup p ( u T ) < m
was proved i n Theorem 107.5 t h a t i n t h i s
Fatou, which means t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s a c o n s t a n t 0 5 u
has t h e weak Fatou
L
0 5 u
p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s i f i t f o l l o w s from
k(p) 2 1
.
p ( u ) 5 k ( p ) . s u p p(u,)
If
i s weakly
p
such t h a t
k(p) = 1
satisfies
i f p(u) = sup p ( u ) ) , we s h a l l say t h a t
t h e Fatou property for directed s e t s and
p
has
L
i s t h e n c a l l e d a Fatou nom.
There i s a s i m i l a r s i t u a t i o n f o r monotone sequences i n s t e a d of d i r e c t e d s e t s . The space L i s s a i d t o have t h e weak Fatou property for monotone sequences ( a l s o c a l l e d t h e sequential weak Fatou property) i f it f o l l o w s
...
) and sup p(un) < m t h a t from 0 5 u 4 ( n = l , 2 , n We f i r s t prove a theorem p a r a l l e l t o Theorem 107.5.
THEOREM 113.1.
If
L
sup u
exists i n
n
L
.
has t h e sequential weak Fatou property, then L
i s a Dedekind o-complete Banach l a t t i c e and the norm p i s s e q u e n t i a l l y weakly Fatou, i . e . , there e x i s t s a constant k ( p ) 2 1 such t h a t 0 5 u n 4 u in L
implies
P ( U ) 5 k ( p ) . s u p P(u,)
.
0 5 u 4 5 uo i n L , t h e n sup p(un) 5 p ( u o ) < m , so n e x i s t s by h y p o t h e s i s . This shows t h a t L i s Dedekind o-complete
PROOF. I f SUP
u
n Furthermore, L n = 1,2 SO
,...
sup s
n
and
s a t i s f i e s t h e Riesz-Fischer c o n d i t i o n ( i f
a = C p(un) <
m
e x i s t s by h y p o t h e s i s ) .
We prove now t h a t
p
,
then
n This shows t h a t
0
for a l l
p(s ) 5 a
L
5
u
n
E L
for
sn = Z y \ , i s a Banach l a t t i c e .
i s s e q u e n t i a l l y weakly Fatou. I f n o t , t h e r e
e x i s t s f o r e v e r y n a t u r a l number
k
a sequence
0 5 unk Sn
\
such t h a t
422
FATOU PROPERTY > k
P(\)
3
sup, p(unk)
. It is impossible that
, because this would imply unk dicting the inequality for p(uk)
k
constants, we may assume that every 2
k
. For
s Ck-2
P(v,)
sup unk
=
n = 1,2,
...
for every n
\
Ch. 16,51133
for every
sup, p(unk) for all n , and s o
= 0
. Hence, multiplying by
sup, p(unk)
=
k-2
'PI
, let now vn = , s o sup vn exists k , s o p(sup vn) 2
,
and
so
.
0 for some \ = 0 , contra-
=
appropriate > k
p(uk)
for
Then 0 2 v11 4 and unk by hypothesis. But sup v 2 n
p(uk)
k for every k
>
.
This is impossible. If the smallest possible number k(p) k(p)
=
1 , i.e., if 0
2 u
in the last theorem satisfies
implies p ( u ) = sup p(un) , we
in L
4 u
has the Fatou property f o r monotone sequences (sequential
shall say that L
Fatou property) and the norm
is said to be sequentially Fatou. It is
p
evident that the (weak) Fatou property for directed sets implies the (weak) sequential Fatou property. We shall discuss now several conditions under which the converse holds. THEOREM 113.2. If L
i s an order separable nomed Riesz space possess-
i n g an a t most countable order b a s i s and having the (weak) sequential Fatou property, then
has t h e (weak) Fatou property f o r directed s e t s .
L
PROOF. Let
...)
(bn:bn+12b tO;n=1,2,
let the number k 2 1
in the preceding theorem) and
L
such that
sup p(u,) <
exists. For this purpose, we set v n
. Then
is Dedekind o-complete (as proved
is order separable (by hypothesis), the
is super Dedekind complete. Now, let 0 5 u
directed set in L
and
be a constant corresponding to the weak sequential
Fatou property. Note first that since L space L
be an order basis of L
T ,n
m
. We
I.
be an upwards
have to show that sup u
= inf(uT,nbn)
for all
T
and all
exists in L by the Dedekind completeness and by n V,,n is the supremum of a sequence taken the super Dedekind completeness s s
from the set
(v,,~:, variable). It may be assumed that the sequence is
increasing. It follows that
p(sn)
2
k sup p(u,)
for every n
. Since
5 s 4 in L and sup p ( s n ) 2 k sup pfu,) , we may apply the sequential n exists in L Fatou property once more and we find thus that sup s n Furthermore,
0
.
Ch. 16,11131
423
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
2 sup s = sup uT , s o p(sup u ) 2 k sup p(uT) n shows t h a t , under t h e mentioned c o n d i t i o n s , t h e
It i s a l s o easy t o see t h a t
The s p e c i a l c a s e
k
1
=
.
Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s f o l l o w s from t h e s e q u e n t i a l F a t o u p r o p e r t y . The weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s i s analogous, i n some s e n s e , t o Dedekind completeness. The l a s t may b e expressed by s a y i n g t h a t every o r d e r bounded upwards d i r e c t e d s e t has a supremum and t h e f i r s t by s a y i n g t h a t every norm bounded upwards d i r e c t e d s e t of p o s i t i v e elements has a supremum. S i m i l a r l y , t h e weak s e q u e n t i a l F a t o u p r o p e r t y and Dedekind u-comp l e t e n e s s a r e analogous. Now, i n Theorem 103.6 we have proved an important r e s u l t of H. Nakano f o r a normed Riesz space
L = L
u-completeness t o g e t h e r w i t h u-order c o n t i n u i t y of
P ' p
s t a t i n g t h a t Dedekind i s equivalent t o
Dedekind completeness (even s u p e r Dedekind completeness) t o g e t h e r w i t h o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of
p
. We
s h a l l prove t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s a p a r a l l e l theorem
f o r t h e Fatou p r o p e r t y . P r e c i s e l y , t h e weak s e q u e n t i a l Fatou p r o p e r t y w i t h u-order c o n t i n u i t y of
p
i s e q u i v a l e n t t o t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r
d i r e c t e d s e t s t o g e t h e r w i t h o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of
p
. In
Nakano's theorem
t h e r e i s a t h i r d e q u i v a l e n t c o n d i t i o n . This i s t h e c o n d i t i o n t h a t every o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i n
L
must have a norm l i m i t . S i m i l a r l y , i n t h e
c a s e of t h e Fatou p r o p e r t y , t h e t h i r d c o n d i t i o n s t a t e s t h a t every norm bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence of p o s i t i v e elements i n
L
must have a norm l i m i t .
This p a r a l l e l theorem was e s s e n t i a l l y known t o Nakano (Theoaem 30.20 i n t h e book C41). We begin w i t h a lemma which p a r a l l e l s Lemma 103.3. The f i r s t p a r t i s even i d e n t i c a l .
LENMA 113.3. ( i ) I f
0 5 uT 6
i s a p-Cauchy system and
sequence o f p o s i t i v e numbers, there e x i s t s a sequence t h a t uT + and
(uT ) n
cn+ 0
in
is a
(uT)
such
n
f o r a%%n
. Furthermore,
any upper bound of t h e sequence
.
(uT 1 n
i s an
upper bound of the system ( u T ) ( i i ) I f every increasing p-Cauchy sequence has a norm l i m i t and 0 2 u f i s a p-Cauchy system, then u = sup u e x i s t s and any increasing sequence (u as i n p a r t ( i ) above s a t i s f i e s sup u = u = sup u Tn n Furthermore p(u-uT) $ 0
.
.
FATOU PROPERTY
424
(iii) If
L
has the weak sequential Fatou property and
i s a p-Cauchy system, then u (u,
n
= sup
u
0 5 u
4
e x i s t s and any increasing sequence sup u
as i n part ( i ) above s a t i s f i e s
)
Ch. 16,51133
n
.
u
= sup
PROOF. (i) A s p a r t ( i ) of Lemma 103.3. 0 s u
( i i ) Let sequence
f
b e a p-Cauchy system. For any i n c r e a s i n g
4
(u ) as i n p a r t ( i ) w e have
in
(u, ) n
)
-u
P\'Tn+m
=
Tn+m
TnJ
,u
)-u ,nJ
'n
}
2 En
,
) i s a n i n c r e a s i n g p-Cauchy sequence. Hence, by h y p o t h e s i s , u n Tn converges i n norm t o some u € L But t h e n , by Theorem 100.4, u = sup u ,n By p a r t ( i ) , u i s now a l s o an upper bound of t h e s y s t e m (u,) Hence,
so
(u,
sup u u
'n
4
e
.
that
p(u-u
'n 0 2 u
(iii) Let
i n c r e a s i n g sequence bounded and
L
By p a r t ( i ) , u = u
. It
= u = sup u
=supu
f o l l o w s immediately from
) C 0
ii
+
,
so
p(u-u,)
+
0
p(u-u
.
b e a p-Cauchy system i n
L
Tn
) + 0
h a s t h e weak s e q u e n t i a l Fatou p r o p e r t y , u = sup u
.
i s a l s o an upper bound of t h e s y s t e m
(u,)
and
(u, )
and l e t
as i n p a r t ( i ) . S i n c e t h e sequence
(u,)
.
.
, so
iP
be an
norm
exists. 'n sup u = n
THEOREM 113.4. The following conditions for t h e nomed Riesz space
L
are equivalent. (i)
-The norm p
i s u-order continuous and
L
has the weak sequential
Fatou property. Every norm bounded increasing sequence o f p o s i t i v e elements i n L
(ii)
has a norm limit. ( i i i ) m e norm
p
i s order continuous and L has t h e weak Fatou
property f o r directed s e t s . If
L
s a t i s f i e s one (and therefore each) of these conditions, then
L
i s a super Dedekind compZete and p e r f e c t Banach l a t t i c e . Note t h a t spaces L s a t i s f y i n g these conditions are exactly the KB-spaces mentioned i n s e c t i o n 95.
-.
PROOF. The proof i s s i m i l a r t o t h e proof i n Theorem 103.6. (i)
*
(ii). Let
0 5 u
4
with
weak s e q u e n t i a l Fatou p r o p e r t y , so
sup p ( u ) < The s p a c e L h a s t h e n exists in L Then
u = sup u
.
Ch. 16,§1131
u-u
,
C 0
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
t h e norm l i m i t of (ii)
u
n
since
.
,
n
. Then
E L
uo
in
(uT )
0
5
u
C 0
v
=
. We
such t h a t
(uT)
c o n t r a d i c t i n g our ;resent
i s o r d e r continuous, l e t some
c o n t i n u o u s . Hence, u
i s a p-Cauchy system ( i f n o t , t h e r e would e x i s t a number
and a n i n c r e a s i n g sequence for a l l
i s o-order
p
hypothesis).
, so
(vT)
-u
uo 2 u T C 0
may assume t h a t
uo-uT I. uo
(uT
,
p(uo-vT) C 0
i.e.,
For t h e proof t h a t let
+
0 5 u
with
p(uT)
L
+
0
(iii)
*
L
If n u i t y of
p
tained i n
) >
E
p
for (vT)
.
,
h a s t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d sets,
sup p ( u ) <
u = sup u
> 0
i s a p-Cauchy system.
m
. Then
(uT)
i s a p-Cauchy system, s o
t h e h y p o t h e s e s of p a r t ( i i ) i n Lemma 113.3 a r e now s a t i s f i e d f o r follows t h a t
E
For t h e f:bofT?hat
The h y p o t h e s e s o f p a r t ( i i ) i n Lemma 113.3 a r e now s a t i s f i e d f o r so
is
( i i i ) Note f i r s t t h a t e v e r y norm bounded upwards d i r e c t e d s e t
9
+
0 S u
C 0
p(u-un)
so
425
(uT)
. It
exists.
( i ) Evident.
s a t i s f i e s t h e s e c o n d i t i o n s , i t f o l l o w s from t h e o r d e r c o n t i 0 t h a t L* = L* so = O(L*) = { O } S i n c e L: i s con(L:) n ' L : , we f i n d t h a t '(L;) = { O } . Combining t h i s w i t h t h e
.
condition t h a t
L
1 1 1 . 1 shows t h a t
h a s t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s , Theorem L
i s a p e r f e c t Banach l a t t i c e . F i n a l l y , i t f o l l o w s from
c o n d i t i o n ( i i ) t h a t e v e r y o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i n
L
has a
norm l i m i t , which i s one of t h e e q u i v a l e n t c o n d i t i o n s i n Nakano's theorem (Theorem 103.6). Hence, a l l c o n d i t i o n s i n Nakano's theorem h o l d . I n particular, L
i s s u p e r Dedekind complete.
A s observed a l r e a d y , t h e e q u i v a l e n t c o n d i t i o n s i n t h e p r e s e n t theorem imply t h e c o n d i t i o n s i n Nakano's theorem (Theorem 103.6). For t h e c o n v e r s e , n o t e t h a t t h e sequence s p a c e
(c,)
of a l l r e a l n u l l sequences ( w i t h t h e
uniform norm) s a t i s f i e s a l l c o n d i t i o n s of Nakano's theorem, but n o t t h o s e of t h e p r e s e n t theorem. Note a l s o t h a t i f , f o r example, L L,(X,p)
with
p
Lebesgue measure i n
L_-norm,
then
p
i s n o t o-order c o n t i n u o u s , b u t
X = C0,ll
s e q u e n t i a l F a t o u p r o p e r t y and h e n c e , s i n c e f i n i t e order basis, L
L
and w i t h L
i s t h e space p
t h e usual
obviously has t h e
i s o r d e r s e p a r a b l e and h a s a
h a s t h e Fatou p r c p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s .
It was proved i n Theorem 83.12 t h a t any o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r mapping
a Banach l a t t i c e i n t o a Dedekind complete normed R i e s z s p a c e i s norm bounded. I n t h e c o n v e r s e d i r e c t i o n , a norm bounded o p e r a t o r i s n o t o r d e r bounded
FATOU PROPERTY
426
Ch. 16,§1131
i n g e n e r a l ( c f . t h e remark i n Exercise 98.7, where i t i s shown among o t h e r things t h a t a c e r t a i n unitary operator i n i s n o t o r d e r bounded). I n f2 c e r t a i n c a s e s , however, norm bounded o p e r a t o r s a r e a l s o o r d e r bounded. A t y p i c a l example occurs i n Dunford's theorem ( C o r o l l a r y 9 8 . 4 ) , s t a t i n g t h a t
if
and
(X,A,u)
Ll(Y,v)
(Y,Z,v) a r e a - f i n i t e measure spaces and t h e number
1 < p 5
satisfies
into
course t h a t
T
m
,
t h e n any norm bounded o p e r a t o r
L (X,u) i s an a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r , which i m p l i e s of P i s o r d e r bounded. Dunford's theorem i s a s p e c i a l c a s e of
a more g e n e r a l theorem (Theorem 98.3), b e as above and l e t
(Y,Z,v)
a s follows. Let
equipped w i t h a Riesz norm with respect t o
.
p
p
(X,A,u)
b e an i d e a l w i t h c a r r i e r
M
of a l l r e a l u-measurable f u n c t i o n s on
M(X,u)
p
which maps
T
such t h a t
M
X
i n t h e space that
is
M
i s a p e r f e c t Banach l a t t i c e
I f , f u r t h e r m o r e , t h e a s s o c i a t e norm
c o n t i n u o u s , t h e n every norm bounded o p e r a t o r
X
. Assume now
and
T
from
p'
Ll(Y,v)
i s o-order into
M
i s an a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r . The hypotheses i n t h i s theorem a r e s t r o n g because i t has t o b e shown not only t h a t T
T i s o r d e r bounded b u t a l s o t h a t
can b e expressed by means of a k e r n e l . We s h a i l prove now a theorem
which i n one r e s p e c t i s more g e n e r a l , d e a l i n g w i t h a b s t r a c t Banach lattices (not n e c e s s a r i l y c o n s i s t i n g of measurable f u n c t i o n s ) , b u t which h a s on t h e o t h e r hand a more moderate aim because i t mentions only c o n d i t i o n s under which norm boundedness of an o p e r a t o r i m p l i e s o r d e r boundedness. Before s t a t i n g t h e theorem, we s t i l l n o t e t h a t i n t h e r e s u l t r e f e r r e d t o above
i s supposed t o b e p e r f e c t , t h i s i m p l i e s t h a t
M
(Theorem 98.3), where
M
h a s t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s . This p r o p e r t y of t h e range space
M
w i l l b e of importance i n t h e proof t h a t c e r t a i n norm bounded
o p e r a t o r s a r e o r d e r bounded. Another important h y p o t h e s i s w i l l b e t h a t t h e domain space i s of L -type. We r e c a l l t h a t t h e Banach l a t t i c e L i s c a l l e d I an a b s t r a c t L - s p a c e i f t h e norm p i s a d d i t i v e , i . e . , p(u+v) = p ( u ) + p(v) 1
for a l l positive
u
and
THEOREM 113.5. Let
v
L
an abstract L -space and
P
in
and
L
.
MA
be Banach l a t t i c e s such t h a t
L
P
is
has t h e weak Fatou property f o r directed s e t s MA 1 (hence, MA i s Dedekind complete by Theorem 107.5). Then any norm bounded mapping L
operator
T
k = k(h)
i s a constant corresponding t o the weak Fatou property i n MA T and IT1 s a t i s f y
P
then t h e operator n o m o f
i n t o MA i s order bounded. Furthermore, i f
,
Ch. 16,51131
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
PROOF. Let
0 5 u
427
be given. Denote by
E L
Su
t h e s u b s e t of
M
c o n s i s t i n g of t h e elements x = ITu
1
1 +
... +
[Tun[
f o r a l l p o s s i b l e decompositions u = u 1 + t i v e . Let
... + un
u = u1 +
= uf +
n
Z. u
U. = 1
so
u = Cij
so
sup(x,x')
uij 5
uij
J
(i=l,
i ; uf j
. Then y = C i j ITuijI E . This shows t h a t Su i n Mh . Furthermore, i f
y
s i t i v e elements
ul,.
and
x f = :1
posi-
u;,
...,n ; j , ...,k)
for a l l
ij
.. ,un
with
i.
n x = C 1 ITuil
be two of t h e s e decompositions w i t h There e x i s t elements
...
... + un
= Z.
u
1
Su
for a l l
ij
and
x 5 y
j
.
lTu!I J
such t h a t
,
a s well a s
x' 5 y
i s an upwards d i r e c t e d s e t of pon x = E l ITuil i n Su , then
so
Hence, s i n c e
MA has t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s , sup S
.
exists i n
MA
s e t of
, say
Lp
I t follows now e a s i l y t h a t i f If
i s o r d e r bounded i n
so
ITfI 5 sup S
I
5
MA
. This
for a l l
u
. For
D
i s an o r d e r bounded sub-
E D , then the image f E D . Then
f
shows t h a t
T
ITfI 5 I T I ( l f l )
of
D
i s o r d e r bounded.
For t h e r e l a t i o n between t h e o p e r a t o r norms of IT1 and f i r s t that
T(D)
t h e proof, l e t
f o r every
f E Lp
,
so
T
we n o t e
,
Ch. 16,§1131
FATOU PROPERTY
This shows t h a t
IlTll 5 lllTlIl
.
Now, l e t
sponding t o t h e weak Fatou property i n before, i t follows from ( 1 )
k = k(h)
. With
MA
be a constant corret h e same n o t a t i o n s a s
that
Hence, s i n c e
we g e t
A(IT1 ( u ) ) 5 k. l/TII.p(u)
EXERCISE 113.6. Let
L
. For
L
f
E Lp
t h i s implies
be a normed Riesz space.
( i ) Show t h a t i f t h e norm p then
an a r b i t r a r y
is o-order continuous and
i s Dedekind complete, and hence
L
L
is perfect,
s a t i s f i e s a l l conditions of
Nakano’s theorem (Theorem 103.6).
(ii) Show t h a t i f
L
i s t h e sequence space of a l l r e a l sequences with
only f i n i t e l y many nonzero terms (and with t h e uniform norm), then s a t i s f i e s the hypotheses of p a r t ( i ) , but ( i i i ) Show t h a t i f the norm p e r f e c t , then L
L
p
L
i s not Banach.
i s o-order continuous and
( i ) The space
(Li)-
is
L = (LT;”;
L
i s Banach.
i s Dedekind complete and any band i n a
Dedekind complete space i s Dedekind complete, s : o):L( Hence, s i n c e
L
has the weak s e q u e n t i a l Fatou property ( t h a t i s t o say,
s a t i s f i e s a l l conditions of Theorem 113.4) i f and only i f HINT:
L
by hypothesis, t h e space
i s Dedekind complete. L
i s Dedekind complete.
( i i i ) Any space s a t i s f y i n g the conditions of Theorem 113.4 i s Banach. For t h e proof i n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n , use Theorem 1 1 1 . 1 .
Ch.
16,51143
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
429
1 1 4 . Embedding i n t h e Banach b i d u a l ; r e f l e x i v i t y Let L
L-
. Hence,
such t h a t
f E L
(L*)-
,
, i.e.,
O(L*) = { O }
L* i s an i d e a l i n t h e
s e p a r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
L*
, defined
o: L + (L*)-
t h e Riesz homomorphism
f o r every have
b e a normed Riesz space. The Banach d u a l
L
order dual
by
o(f)($) = $(f)
i s a Riesz isomorphism (Lemma 109.1). Furthermore, we L* i s Banach. The Riesz isomorphism
since
= (L*)*
t h e r e f o r e , e x a c t l y t h e f a m i l a r embedding of
o is,
into the bidual
L
proved i n s e c t i o n 109, t h e embedding i s a c t u a l l y i n t o t h e band
. The
= (L*):
that
L
. As
L** (L*):
=
embedding p r e s e r v e s f i n i t e suprema and infima; it f o l l o w s
i s a Riesz subspace of
. The
(L*):
embedding a l s o p r e s e r v e s t h e
norm; it w i l l c a u s e no confusion, t h e r e f o r e , i f we denote t h e norm i n a g a i n by p
.
THEOREM 1 1 4 . 1 .
( i ) Suprema and infima of countable systems i n
L** i f and only if t h e norm
preserved under t h e embedding i n t o
L
L**
are
is
p
o-order continuous. ( i i ) Suprema and infima o f a r b i t r a r y systems i n
I,**
under t h e embedding i n t o
L
are preserved
i f and only i f t h e norm
ous and a l s o i f and only i f t h e i d e a l generated by
.
Dedekind completion of L ( i i i ) If L i s Banach and L**
L
i s order continuL**
in
is a
hasordercontinuous norm, y e n s o has L .
PROOF. ( i ) Assume t h a t suprema and i n f i m a of c o u n t a b l e systems a r e p r e s e r v e d . For t h e proof t h a t
L
. Then,
0
2
by h y p o t h e s i s , u
$ E L*
i.e.,
L*
=
i s o-order continuous, l e t
p
in
J. 0
L**
,
i.e.,
$(un> J. 0
. This shows t h a t every element of L* L* . The last e q u a l i t y i s e q u i v a l e n t t o
u J. 0 i n n f o r every
i s an i n t e g r a l on t h e statement t h a t
,
L p
is
a-order continuous. Conversely, assume now t h a t
.
u 4 u in L Then u + s u i n n n of L** , t h e r e e x i s t s an element It follows t h a t
we have f o r every
$(un)
$(un) 4 $(u) $
4
i s o-order continuous. L e t f i r s t
p
L**
. Hence,by
u" E L**
f o r every
u"($)
t h e Dedekind completeness
such t h a t
0 5 $ E L*
by t h e o-order c o n t i n u i t y of
E L* , which shows t h a t
u" = u
, and
p
so
4 u" i n
u
. On t h e . Hence u
o t h e r hand u"($)
in
4 u
.
L**
L**
= $(u)
.
S i m i l a r l y f o r d e c r e a s i n g sequences. It h a s been proved t h u s t h a t t h e embedd i n g p r e s e r v e s suprema and infima of monotone sequences. I f n e c e s s a r i l y monotone sequence i n =
sup(u,,
...,un)
for
n = 1,2,
L with
...
sup un = u
satisfies
v
4 u
, then
. But
i s a not
(u,)
v
=
then both
430
Ch. 16,§1141
EMBEDDING I N THE BANACH BIDUAL
...,
v
= sup(ul, u ) and v 4 u h o l d i n n e a s i l y t h a t sup u = u h o l d s i n L**
a s w e l l . It follows
L**
.
( i i ) The proof t h a t suprema and infima of a r b i t r a r y systems i n preserved under t h e embedding i f and only i f t h e norm
are
L
i s o r d e r continu-
p
o u s i s s i m i l a r t o t h e proof i n p a r t ( i ) . A second proof i s o b t a i n e d from
Theorem 109.2. Indeed, choosing embedding of
L
i f and only i f
n
in
B = L*
i n Theorem 109.2, we see t h a t t h e
(L*), = (L*)* p r e s e r v e s a r b i t r a r y suprema and infima n i s contained i n L i , i . e . , i f and only i f L* =
L*
. Since
L* = L* i f and only i f p i s o r d e r continuous, n t h e proof i s complete. A t t h e same time Theorem 109.2 shows t h a t t h i s
= L*
:L
= L:
s i t u a t i o n o c c u r s i f and only i f t h e i d e a l generated by i s a Dedekind completion of
= (L*):
L
in
L
.
(L*):
=
( i i i ) Observe t h a t (by Theorem 104.2) i n a Banach l a t t i c e t h e norm i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f every o r d e r hounded d i s j o i n t sequence converges t o zero i n norm.
In C o r o l l a r y 105.12 i t was proved t h a t i f is an ideal i n
L i
o r d e r dense i n
:L
space
L
into
(L*):
Obviously
A
. Let
(L*);
=
A
L
s e p a r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
,
then
A
p
. As
shown above, L
b e t h e i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by
s e p a r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
L* (because
L
L
. It
is
A
i s embedded in
follows t h a t , f o r every
(L*)F,
.
already separates
L* ) . Hence, by C o r o l l a r y 105.12 a s mentioned, A
(L*):
A
apply t h i s t o t h e c a s e t h a t we have a normed Riesz
w i t h o r d e r continuous norm
t h e p o i n t s of dense i n
such t h a t
. We
i s a Riesz space and
L
0 2 u" E (L*):
, we
i s order have
u" = sup (v":v"€A,O
\
A s t r o n g e r r e s u l t i s t r u e , a s shown i n t h e f o l l o w i n g lemma. LEMMA 114.2. If p
and i f
0
2
Ull
u"
L
i s a normed Riesz space with order continuous norm
, then
E (L*):
= sup (u:uEL,O
\
) -
PROOF. A s observed above, t h e r e e x i s t s a d i r e c t e d s e t
ideal
A
generated by
L
in
is t h e Dedekind completion of
(L*): L
, we
such t h a t have
0
v" 4 u"
(vy)
i n the
. Since
A
Ch.
f o r every T
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
16,§1141
. The
T
set o f a l l
u"
u <
satisfying
u E L
i s d i r e c t e d upwards and h a s
43 1
f o r a t l e a s t one
V"
as i t s supremum i n
. The
L**
desired
r e s u l t follows.
A s shown i n Theorem 1 1 4 . 1 , t h e i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by
i s i n f a c t t h e i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by of
L
i f and o n l y i f
L
in
i s a Dedekind completion of u € L
by
L
in
L**
by
L
in
L**
case
. In . It
. This
and only i f
(L*)*) i s a Dedekind c o m p l e t i o n
shows t h a t
o t h e r words,
L
u
(L*):
for a l l
.
L**
= sup p ( u ) <
shows t h a t
u"
. Then
m
, defined
L**
. In
T
m
(L*)E
. Hence
(L*):
i s t h e i d e a l generated
i s a Dedekind completion of
sup $ ( u ) 2 a.p*($)
in
(L*),T
L**
, we
S u
m
p
(L*):
.
We have t o show t h a t
u"
directed s e t
that the ideal
p
i s a Dedekind completion of A = (L*): (uT)
in
L
For t h a t p u r p o s e , l e t belongs t o L
such t h a t
A
0
. By
0 2 u
with
E
, which L* , i s
f o r some
0 2 u
4
i s m a j o r i z e d by some
(uT)
f o l l o w s from t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of in
u" 5 u
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s and
implies t h a t
0 5
. Then
L L
. Hence, s i n c e a l l u (L*): . This i m p l i e s
L ) that
.
for a l l T
in
I.
0 5 @ E L*
f o r every L**
u" E
have
i s a Dedekind completion o f u
sup p ( u T ) <
prove t h a t
in
u" = sup u
0 5 u
f o r every
u"($) = sup $ ( u )
by
Conversely,assume t h a t with
i f
u E L
t h a t there e x i s t s an element
t h i s case
(L*)E
satisfying
b e l o n g t o t h e band
E L
L
i s a Dedekind completion o f
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s a s observed above. Now, l e t
(since
i s t h e n major-
E (L*):
i t s e l f i s now t h e i d e a l g e n e r a t e d
(L*):
sup p ( u T ) <
with
2 u
a member of
L
u"
belongs t o the i d e a l generated
u"
f o l l o w s t h e r e f i o r e from Theorem 1 1 4 . 1 t h a t i n t h i s
PROOF. Assume f i r s t t h a t
u
itself
(L*):
is order continuous and i f , i n addition, i t follows from
p
in
4
such t h a t by L i n
a
(which
i s of some importance. I n view of t h e
L
THEOREM 114.3. The space
p
L**
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s . More p r e c i s e l y , t h e f o l l o w i n g h o l d s .
p
0 5 u
in
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s . The c a s e t h a t
p
d e f i n i t i o n of a Dedekind completion any p o s i t i v e i z e d by some
L
. Hence,
A
in
u E L
.
L It
g e n e r a t e d by
it is sufficient to
0 2 u" E (L*):
be g i v e n .
t h e l a s t lemma t h e r e e x i s t s a 4 u"
in
L**
, so
sup p(u,)
5
432
S
EMBEDDING I N THE BANACH BIDUAL
p(u") <
u
that
. Hence,
m
in
5 u
which i m p l i e s the ideal
L
by h y p o t h e s i s , t h e r e e x i s t s an element for a l l
u" = sup u g e n e r a t e d by
A
. But
T
in
u
S
L
in
COROLLARY 114.4. The space
then
L** L**
L**
. It .
16,§1141
Ch.
u
E L
such
< u holds as well i n
u
follows t h a t
u"
L**
,
belongs t o
L
i s a Dedekind completion of
i f
and only i f the following three conditions are s a t i s f i e d . (i)
(L*)* = L**
(ii)
p
.
i s order continuous.
s u
(iii) 0
in
L
u E L
.
f
majorized by some
L**
I n t h i s case
sup p(u,)
with
<
implies that
m
i t s e l f i s the ideal generated by
L
(uT) L**
in
We s h a l l d e r i v e now n e c e s s a r y and s u f f i c i e n t c o n d i t i o n s f o r a n i d e a l ( o r even an o r d e r dense i d e a l ) i n
L
is
. t o be
.
L**
THEOREM 114.5. The following conditions are equivalent.
.
(i)
L
i s an i d e a l i n
(ii)
L
i s Dedekind o-complete and
(iii) L
L**
i s o-order continuous.
p
i s super Dedekind complete and
I f these canditions are s a t i s f i e d , then
Furthermore, note t h a t i f
L
L
i s order continuous.
p
(L*):
i s order dense i n
i s Banach, then order continuii;y of
p
. implies
super Dedekind completeness (by Theorem 103.9). >PROOF. ( i ) =+ ( i i ) The s p a c e space
L**
r a t e d by
; t h e space L
in
L**
L
i s an i d e a l i n t h e Dedekind complete
i s t h e r e f o r e Dedekind complete. The i d e a l gene-
L
, which
now a Dedekind completion of
under t h e p r e s e n t h y p o t h e s i s i s L
, and
so
p
itself, is
L
is o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s by
Theorem 114.1 (ii). (ii)
*
( i i i ) T h i s i s Nakano's
(iii)
(i)
Since
114.l(ii) that the ideal completion of
L
. For
L
A
g e n e r a t e d by
every p o s i t i v e
which shows t h a t t h e set since
theorem (Theorem 103.6).
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s we conclude from Theorem
p
u"
(u:uEL,O
L in
in
A
L**
i s a Dedekind
we have, t h e r e f o r e , t h a t
i s o r d e r bounded i n
L
. Hence,
i s Dedekind complete and s i n c e suprema of a r b i t r a r y systems i n
L
Ch. 16,51141
433
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
a r e preserved under the embedding (Theorem 1 1 4 . 1 ( i ) ) , i t follows t h a t
.
u" E L in
L**
I n o t h e r words, we have
. This
A = L
.
shows t h a t
i s an i d e a l
L
I f t h e conditions ( i ) , ( i i ) , ( i i i ) a r e s a t i s f i e d , then L i s an i d e a l 0 I t follows, = I01 i n (L*): and, e v i d e n t l y , (L) = I01 , s o o{(L*);l 0 t h a t L i s o r d e r dense i n (L*); t h e r e f o r e , from '(L) = I(L*):l
.
.
THEOREM 114.6. The following conditions are equivalent.
(i)
L
i s a order dense ideaZ i n
(ii)
L
i s Dedekind o-complete and both
L**
.
and the norm
p
p*
L*
in
are a-order continuous. (iii) L
and
L*
are super Dedekind complete and both
and
p
p*
are
order continuous. PROOF.
( i ) w ( i i ) I f i t i s given t h a t
v a l e n t l y , i f i t i s given t h a t continuous), t h e space dense i n
L**
,
L
i s an i d e a l i n
L**
i s Dedekind o-complete and
i s order dense i n
i f and only i f
L**
i s a band i n i.e.,
L
L
. Hence,
(L*):
i s o r d e r dense i n
(L*):
L**
t h i s i s equivalent t o the condition t h a t
equivalent t o the condition t h a t the norm
p*
in
L*
L
(equi-
i s a-order
p
i s order
. Since
(L*):
(L*)* = L** n i s order
,
L* i s Dedekind complete, t h i s again i s equivalent
continuous. But, s i n c e
by Nakano's theorem t o t h e condition t h a t
p*
i s a-order continuous.
( i i ) e 9 ( i i i ) Nakano's theorem. Note t h a t i f
L =
L1 with t h e corresponding
e 1-norm,
then
L
i s Dede-
kind a-complete and the norm i s o-order continuous, s o (by Theorem 114.5)
e**
.
i s an i d e a l i n = L* I f L = (c ) , then L* = L 1 ; i t follows 1 0 i s an t h a t condition ( i i ) of t h e l a s t theorem i s s a t i s f i e d . Hence (c,)
el
o r d e r dense i d e a l i n
(co)** =
1
, as
a l s o immediately v i s i b l e . This
example shows t h a t t h e conditions i n the l a s t theorem a r e not s u f f i c i e n t t o imply t h a t L
i s r e f l e x i v e , even i f
L
i s Banach. Note, f i n a l l y , t h a t i f
L
i s t h e space o f a l l sequences having only a f i n i t e number of nonzero
terms, with
p
t h e uniform norm, then
L* =
; the condition ( i i ) i n t h e
l a s t theorem i s again s a t i s f i e d , t h e r e f o r e . Hence, L dense i d e a l i n
L** =
Lm , but now
L
i s again an o r d e r
i s not Banach.
F i n a l l y , we prove t h a t each of the equivalent conditions i n Theorem 113.4 i s necessary and s u f f i c i e n t f o r
L
t o be a band i n
L**
.
Since any
434
L
Ch. 16,§1141
ENBEDDING I N THE BANACH BIDUAL
s a t i s f y i n g t h e c o n d i t i o n s o f Theorem 113.4 i s a l s o known a s a KB-space,
we prove t h e r e f o r e t h a t
i s a band i n
L
i f and only i f
L**
is a
L
KB-space.
The following conditions f o r t h e normed Riesz space
THEOREM 1 1 4 . 7 .
are e q u i v a l e n t .
L
.
(i)
L
(ii)
Every norm bounded increasing sequence of p o s i t i v e elements i n
i s a band i n
L**
has a norm l i m i t . ( i i i ) The norm
p
i s o-order continuous and
t i a l Fatou property. ( i v ) The norm
p
i s order continuous and
L L
has t h e weak sequen-
has t h e weak Fatou
property f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s . PROOF. The equivalence of ( i i ) , ( i i i ) and ( i v ) was proved i n Theorem
113.4. (i)
*
( i v ) Since
i s a band i n
L
L**
i t follows a l r e a d y from Theorem 114.5 t h a t
,
and hence an i d e a l i n
i s Dedekind complete and
L
i s o r d e r continuous. Furthermore, according t o t h e same theorem, L dense i n t h e band now t h a t
. Hence,
(L*):
.
L = (L*):
since
L
completion of
,
L
sup p(u,)
since
L
m
L = (L*)*
,
then
0
sup u
+ in L . Hence, L . This
uT
S
L
exists i n
h a s t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s .
L
*
is a Dedekind
i s an o r d e r bounded set i n
(u,)
p
i s order
h a s t h e weak
n
i t follows from Theorem 114.3 t h a t i f
i s Dedekind complete, t h e element
shows t h a t (iv)
<
,
i t s e l f i s a band, i t follows
It remains t o prove t h a t
Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s . S i n c e , e v i d e n t l y , (L*): with
L**
( i ) Since h y p o t h e s i s ( i v ) i m p l i e s t h a t
i s o r d e r continuous
p
and s i n c e t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y i m p l i e s Dedekind completeness, i t follows (by Theorem 114.5) from t h e Dedekind completeness of c o n t i n u i t y of
that
p
L
i s an i d e a l i n
i n Theorem 114.3 a r e s a t i s f i e d ; t h e space g e n e r a t e d by Hence
L,
i s a band i n
. But,
L**
. This
L = (L*):
Note t h a t
Ll
in
L
L**
shows t h a t
L
and t h e o r d e r
. Furthermore,
(L*):
a s observed, L
L
the conditions
is, therefore, the ideal i t s e l f i s an i d e a l i n
i s a band i n
L**
.
L**
s a t i s f i e s c o n d i t i o n ( i i ) of t h e l a s t theorem. Hence,
Lr*= Lz
. More p r e c i s e l y ,
=
(Lm)E .
W e proceed t o i n v e s t i g a t e now c o n d i t i o n s under which
L
is r e f l e x i v e .
.
Ch. 16,11141
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
It i s evident t h a t
is reflexive, i.e.,
L
435
,
L = L**
i f and only i f
a t t h e same time a band a s w e l l a s a n o r d e r dense i d e a l i n dition that p
i s a band i n
L
L**
con-
i s e q u i v a l e n t t o o-order c o n t i n u i t y of
t o g e t h e r w i t h t h e weak s e q u e n t i a l Fatou p r o p e r t y , which i m p l i e s t h e r e -
f o r e Dedekind o-completeness. in
. The
L**
is
L
L**
The c o n d i t i o n t h a t
i s e q u i v a l e n t t o o-order c o n t i n u i t y of
Dedekind o-completeness. r e f l e x i v i t y of
L
L p
i s an o r d e r dense i d e a l and p* t o g e t h e r w i t h
Combining t h e s e c o n d i t i o n s , i t f o l l o w s t h a t
i s e q u i v a l e n t t o o-order c o n t i n u i t y of
and
p
to-
p*
g e t h e r w i t h t h e weak s e q u e n t i a l Fatou p r o p e r t y . Furthermore, an i n s p e c t i o n of t h e c o n d i t i o n s i n t h e l a s t two theorems shows t h a t t h i s a g a i n i s equiv a l e n t t o o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of
p
and
p*
t o g e t h e r w i t h t h e weak Fatou
p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s . This y i e l d s t h e f i r s t p a r t of t h e f o l l o w i n g theorem. THEOREM 114.8. The following conditions f o r the normed Riesz space
L
are equivalent. (i)
L
(ii)
The norms
i s reflexive.
and
p
p*
are o-order continuous and
L
has the
weak sequential Fatou property. ( i i i ) The norms
p
and
p*
are order continuous and
L
has the ueak
Fatou property f o r directed s e t s . Every norm bounded increasing sequence of p o s i t i v e elements i n
(iv) L
has a norm l i m i t and, similarly, every norm bounded increasing sequence
of positive elements i n
L*
has a norm l i m i t .
Every norm bounded increasing sequence of p o s i t i v e elements i n
(v) L
has a norm l i m i t and every order bounded increasing sequence o f p o s i t i v e elements i n L* has a norm l i m i t . PROOF. ( i ) (i)
=s
- (ii)
(iv) L
( i i i ) This was e x p l a i n e d above.
i s r e f l e x i v e and, t h e r e f o r e , L
i s a band i n
L**
. This
i m p l i e s , by Theorem 114.7, t h a t every norm bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence of p o s i t i v e elements i n
L
h a s a norm l i m i t . Since
s i m i l a r r e s u l t holds i n (iv) (v)
* (v) Evident. * ( i i i ) From t h e
continuous and
L
L*
.
L* i s a l s o r e f l e x i v e , a
f i r s t p a r t of (v) i t follows t h a t
p
is order
h a s t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y (Theorem 114.7). From t h e
second p a r t of (v) i t follows by Nakano's theorem (Theorem 103.6) t h a t i s o r d e r continuous.
p*
436
Ch. 16,§1141
EMBEDDING I N THE BANACH BIDUAL
I t w i l l f o l l o w from o u r f i n a l theorem t h a t r e f l e x i v i t y i m p l i e s p e r f e c t -
ness.
L
THEOREM 114.9. I f
Banach, then i.e., L
m
L** = (L)nn
L
i f
and
i s r e f l e x i v e , then L
L
is
,
(LIZ
=
is p e r f e c t .
PROOF. Since
i s Banach, w e have
L
i s an o r d e r dense i d e a l i n o r d e r continuous, s o Since
L**
i s an order dense i d e a l in
. Hence,
,
L**
L* = (L
1;
L* = L"
. Furthermore,
since
i t f o l l o w s from Theorem 114.6 t h a t
. Hence,
we have a l r e a d y t h a t
L
is
p
L* = (L):
.
i s a l s o o r d e r continuous (Theorem 114.6 a g a i n ) , we can apply
p*
t h e same argument t o
and we g e t
L*
L** = (L)nn
.
The r e f l e x i v i t y theorem (Theorem 114.8) i s due t o T. Ogasawara ( [ l ] , 1942-1944,
i n Japanese; a l s o Ch.V,§4, Theorem 1 i n t h e book [23, i n Japan-
e s e ) . The p r e s e n t proof i s d i f f e r e n t from Ogasawara's p r o o f . For t h e c a s e that
i s a Banach f u n c t i o n space, independent p r o o f s a r e t o b e found i n
L
work by H.W.
E l l i s a n d I . H a l p e r i n ([11,1953),
Luxemburg's t h e s i s (111,1955).
W.A.J.
I. H a l p e r i n ([1],1954)
as p r e s e n t e d above, i s e s s e n t i a l l y t h e same a s i n a paper by W.A.J. burg-A.C.
EXERCISE 114.10. L e t
L
Luxem-
Zaanen (C11,Note 13,1964).
f u n c t i o n s on of
and i n
The proof of t h e r e f l e x i v i t y theorem,
L
b e t h e space
w i t h t h e L2-norm.
CO,l]
i s t h e space
. Show t h a t
L,([O,l])
continuous, b u t t h e norms i n
L
-
C([O,ll)
of a l l r e a l continuous
Show t h a t t h e norm completion
, L*
and
L
t h e norm i n
L** = L
-
L
-
i s not order
a r e o r d e r continuous.
Compare t h i s w i t h Theorem 1 1 4 . l ( i i i ) . EXERCISE 114.11. and o n l y i f
L
( i ) Show t h a t t h e Banach l a t t i c e
i s p e r f e c t and
( i i ) Show t h a t
L
p
L
i s a KB-space i f
i s o r d e r continuous.
i s r e f l e x i v e i f and only i f
L
and
L*
a r e KB-
spaces. HINT:
(i) If
L
i s a band i n
i s a KB-space,
i t f o l l o w s e a s i l y from Theorem 114.7
.
(L*)* = (L)"" I n view of Lemma 114.2 t h e band nn n "-itself. Hence L = (L)&". Conversely, generated by L i n (L)zn- i s ( L )nn nn i f L i s a p e r f e c t Banach l a t t i c e and p i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s , t h e n p h a s
that
L
t h e weak Fatou p r o p e r t y f o r d i r e c t e d s e t s (Theorem 111.1). Hence, by Theorem
Ch. 16,01153
114.7, L
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
437
i s a KB-space.
115. Adjoint o p e r a t o r s We r e c a l l t h e main p o i n t s of what w a s observed i n s e c t i o n 97 about a d j o i n t o p e r a t o r s . A s b e f o r e , any l i n e a r mapping from one v e c t o r space i n t o
L
a n o t h e r v e c t o r space i s c a l l e d an o p e r a t o r . I f
L#
with a l g e b r a i c duals
and
then t h e a l g e b r a i c a d j o i n t d e f i n e d by
(T#$)(f)
t h e mapping
T
specially, L M
,
M
T
then t h e r e s t r i c t i o n
T"
M"
and
a r e v e c t o r spaces
M
i s a n o p e r a t o r from
i s an o p e r a t o r from
T
and a l l
f E L
M#
into
L
into
into
L"
of
to
Tff
L
i s order
T"
i s l i n e a r and p o s i t i v e . More p r e c i s e l y ,
0 : T + T"
Ln(M",L-)
h(L,M)
; we r e c a l l t h a t
N
T"
i s Is-order continuous o r o r d e r continuous, t h e n
into
is
Ln(M ,L )
t h e band of a l l o r d e r continuous and o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r s from T
,
i s a n o r d e r bounded
M"
i s true; the operator
i s p o s i t i v e and maps t h e Dedekind complete Riesz space
. If
L#
. Note t h a t a T # . I f , more 2 2
$ E M#
i s an o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r from
. Even more
t h e Dedekind complete Riesz space L"
,
M
(a T +a T ) # = a T# + 1 1 2 2 1 1 a r e Riesz s p a c e s s u c h t h a t M i s Dedekind complete
continuous. The mapping
Q
of
T
for a l l
if
o p e r a t o r from
and
is linear, i.e.,
T#
and
T#
$(Tf)
=
T E L b ( ~ , ~,) i . e . ,
and i f into
+
M#
M"
-
into
has s p e c i a l
p r o p e r t i e s . This was proved i n Theorem 9 7 . 1 , which we r e p e a t h e r e . ( i ) If T € L (L,M) b
i s Is-oPder continuous, then
( i i ) I f T € Lb(L,M)
i s order continuous, then
We s h a l l b e i n t e r e s t e d h e r e i n t h e r e s t r i c t i o n of t h e r e s t r i c t i o n of
to
T#
d i d i n s e c t i o n 9 7 ) , we have t i v e o p e r a t o r mapping ( i i ) above, T ' jince .'I
E
T'
Ln(
(L-):,
(M):;
.
T ' E Ln(Mi,L")
Lb(L,M)
and
Ln(Mi,L")
Ln(Mi,Li)
N
-f
T"
if
T
-- ,
Ln(Mn,L )
P: T
N
into Lc. N
maps M i i n t o Ln to + T'
.
M" ( e q u i v a l e n t l y , n
T'
( a s we
i s now a posi-
. Furthermore,
by remark
i s o r d e r continuous.
i s o r d e r continuous f o r any
LEMMA 115.1. The p o s i t i v e operator Y:
T"
maps M"
1. Denoting t h i s r e s t r i c t i o n by
L b ( ~ , ~ i)n t o
belongs t o
E Ln(Mi,L")
M"
T"
T E Lb(L,M)
, we
Hence, get
PROOF. L e t
T- C 8
,
be a downwards d i r e c t e d s e t i n
TT
+
t h a t i s t o say, T u
0 5 JI E M :
we have now
T h i s shows t h a t
T'
(g:JI)Cu)
f o r any
0
= JI(T,u)
J. 0
5
holds i n t h e space
8
J-
0
We have i n t r o d u c e d t h e r e s t r i c t i o n
. Of
. If
M
. For
,
so
satisfying
every
T'JI J. 0
holds i n
.
L"
.
to
MX
M;
i s not too small. P r e c i s e l y ,
T'
t h e s i t u a t i o n i s of maximal i n t e r e s t i f
Lb(L,M)
u E L
Ln(M:,L")
course, t h i s i s of i n t e r e s t only i f
r a t e s t h e p o i n t s of
16,§1151
, i s order continuous.
Y(T) = T '
defined by
T-
Ch.
ADJOINT OPERATORS
$38
(M ' ):
of t h e a d j o i n t o p e r a t o r
,
{O}
=
i.e.,
i f :M
sepa-
t h i s c o n d i t i o n i s s a t i s f i e d , t h e n (by Theorem
109.2) t h e i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by M i n M (:): under t h e n a t u r a l embedding i s S i n c e M i t s e l f i s Dedekind complete by hypoa Dedekind completion of M
.
again t h a t
T
i s an i d e a l i n
M
t h e s i s , t h i s means t h a t
f E L
a & observed above. We prove t h a t i f under t h e n a t u r a l embedding of
L
n a t u r a l embedding of
M
THEOREM 1 1 5 . 2 .
,
then
T"f"
i s t h e image of
. Then
and
L
'(Mi)
=
{O}
be t h e r e s t r i c t i o n t o M :
t h e p o s i t i v e operator
M
Tf
Y: T
-+
T'
(Mi):
C
M
.
under t h e
. Then
T"f" = (Tf)"
.
i s Dedekind complete and T'
a s i t s image
E
t h e p r o o f , l e t J, E M Z
( J . Synnatschke,[11,1972). Let
M
T 5 L b ( ~ , ~,) l e t T"
. For
l e t us assume
f" E (L"),
it follows t h a t n ' i s t h e image of Tf
o t h e r words, T"f"
operator
T"f" N
(Mn)n
$ E M"
Since t h i s holds f o r every
spaces such t h a t
N
into
N
(L ) n
NOW,
b e l o n g s t o Lfi((L'7:,(Q;)
has N
into
More p r e c i s e l y , we s h a l l prove t h a t
f o r any
.
M (:):
E Lb(L,M) , so t h a t , t h e r e f o r e , T"
. In
be Riesz
. Furthermore, of t h e a d j o i n t
i s a Riesz homomor-
phism. I n other words, we have ( T ~ V T ~ )=' T ; v
for a l l
T1
and
T2
T I
2
.
Lb(~,~)
in
PROOF. It i s s u f f i c i e n t t o p r o v e t h a t i f then Since
T'
1 8
A
T; = 8
5 S 5
Ti
in and
Ln(M;,L-) Ti
. For
T1
A
T2 = 8
t h e p r o o f , we w r i t e
in
Lb(L,M)
,
S = T' A T' 1 2 ' i s o r d e r continuous, t h e o p e r a t o r S i s a l s o
EMBBDDING IN BIDUALS
Ch. 16,51151
order continuous. Hence, S '
belongs to
image S f 0 (L )n "
in
N
Since M
. For any
L
"
,
N
(Mn)n
into M
So 5 T1
It follows that
A
, so
T2 = 6
.
So = 6
. Hence,
Sof E M
it follows that
, i.e.,
T' 1
Ti
A
is
So
5 So 2 Tk
=
.
T2
T1 and
PROOF. For every
for all
and
(5AT2 ) "
=
T"
1
A
and M
L
2
T E L (L,M)
the corresponding T '
b
belongs to
such that S 1
will imply S'
A
A
S;
=
8
if
(L")"
1 This is certainly the case; the subset of
of elements
0 E L"
f E L
S
2
= 8
,
then S;
E L , which implies 0
for all
n
n
M
S;
=
6
that T','
T" = 8' 2 S1 A S 2 = 8 A
A
Sq
, beT;
. By
=
the
in
N
f"
,
L"
then $(f)
(because = 0
for all
= 0 ).
Once more, let T E Lb(~,~) and assume that T Then T ' E Ln(M",L")
A
and
separates the points o f L". " , (L consisting of all images
already separates the points of
satisfies f"($) = 0
also that L and
S1
sufficient, therefore, to prove that if
theorem whibh has just been proved, the hypothesis that
if
have
Lb(~,~)
Lb(Mi,L")
f"
, we
T"
cause it will follow then in particular from T' A T; = 6 1 = 8 , and hence it will follow from T, A T2 = 8 that T',' Lb(Mi,LM)
E M" n'
$J
.
in
. It will be
are members of
S$ = 0
shows that
8.
(T vT ) " = T',' v T;' 1 2
Ln(Mi,L-)
. This
Under t h e same hypotheses about
COROLLARY 115.3.
f
the
E L
for k = 1 , 2 = Sof = 0 S'f" But then
and satisfying 8
and all $ E MX
f E L
S = 8
fur a22
+
f E L , which implies
for every
so
0
L
, where f" is the image of f
= S'f"
it
f E L we have
is an ideal in
an operator mapping
for all
S f
is defined by
. This makes """ ( M , ) , ; for any f E L
Ln((L")",(M")")
So:
possible to define a positive operator
439
and, therefore, ):T" ):M(,:)E:L((nL
is order continuous.
. Assuming now
are perfect, the space L may be identified with
A D J O I N T OPERATORS
440
and t h e space
;):L( any
=
,
T"f"
identify
f " F: L (:)
t h e image
(Tf)"
i t follows t h a t i f we i d e n t i f y
T f and
. Hence,
M (:):
may b e i d e n t i f i e d w i t h
M
w i t h image
f E L
(Tf)"
Ch. 16,§1151
f
, but
T
of Theorem 115.2 (and C o r o l l a r y 115.3) i t occurs f o r
i s a r b i t r a r y , then
T E Lb(L,M)
and :M
N
L
respectively).
f"
Tf
satisfies
,
t h e n we must
T"f" as w e l l . I n o t h e r words, we i d e n t i f y
I n g e n e r a l , t h i s s i t u a t i o n does n o t occur f o r
the spaces
of
and
T ' E Ln(M:,L")
since f o r
and
T
T"
.
under t h e c o n d i t i o n s
. Indeed,
T'
if
i s o r d e r continuous and
a r e p e r f e c t (by Theorem 110.2 and Theorem 110.3
It follows t h a t
and
T'
may b e i d e n t i f i e d . This
T"'
i m p l i e s immediately t h a t (T1vT2)"' = TY' v T;" for a l l
T1
and
in
T2
and
Lb(L,M)
115.2 a r e s a t i s f i e d ( i . e . , M
(T,hT2)"' = T',''
, provided
A
Ti'
t h e c o n d i t i o n s f o r Theorem
Dedekind complete and
'(Mi)
) . Similar-
= {O]
l y f o r a l l higher adjoints. If
M
i s Dedekind complete b u t
Ln(Mz,L-)
T1
and
T2
applied t o
with
L"
a r e a r b i t r a r y members of
T' v T '
and
(T'vT')' 1 2
=
1
2
i s n o t s a t i s f i e d , then
= {O}
T E L (L,M) t h a t t h e corresponding T' belongs b Dedekind complete and '((L"):) = {O} Hence, i f
i t remains t r u e f o r any to
(M ' ):
T' 1
T','
THEOREM 115.4. Let
A
v T"
2
L
T' 2
, showing
and
and M
,
Lb(L,M)
(T'hT')' 1 2
.
t h e n Theorem 115.2 may be
that = T','
A
TY
.
be Banach l a t t i c e s ( w i t h norms
p!
and
X r e s p e c t i v e l y ) such t h a t T E L b ( ~ , ~,) then
T'
X i s order continuous. A s before, i f is t h e r e s t r i c t i o n t o Mi; of t h e order a d j o i n t
and T* i s t h e Banach a d j o i n t of T (note t h a t T i s norm bounded since any p o s i t i v e operator on a Banach l a t t i c e i s norm bounded). Then
T"
T*
=
T'
and, for a17. T1
PROOF. Note t h a t T E Lb(L,M)
. Note
and
in
Lb(L,M)
, we have
.
and M" = M* = M* Hence T* = T ' f o r every n '(MT;' = O(M*) = ( 0 ) , and M i s Dedekind
L" = L*
now t h a t
T2
complete (Theorem 103.9),so Theorem 115.2 may b e a p p l i e d t o
Ti
=
T;
.
Ti
=
TT
and
Ch. 16,11161
EMBEDDING I N BZDUALS
44 1
The r e a d e r is a d v i s e d t o compare t h e r e s u l t s i n t h e p r e s e n t s e c t i o n w i t h t h o s e i n E x e r c i s e 97.5, where we have t h e s p e c i a l c a s e t h a t
ind
L
are
M
spaces of measurable f u n c t i o n s .
L
EXERCISE 115.5. Once more, l e t
i s Dedekind complete and
M
O(M;)
under t h e n a t u r a l embedding of
=
=
f"
f"
t h e space
. It
M
,
L
b e Riesz spaces such t h a t image of an element i s denoted by
(L"):
.
f"
L"
seems somewhat s u r p r i s i n g a t f i r s t , t h e r e f o r e , t h a t i n
. Ex-
f " = f " i m p l i e s Tfl = Tf2 f o r every T E'Lb(L,M) 1 2 p l a i n t h i s . Also e x p l a i n t h a t f " = f " does not n e c e s s a r i l y imply
if
If
has n o t h i n g t o do w i t h
s p i t e of t h i s
Tfl = Tf2
f E L
then it i s very well possible t h a t
. This phenomenon
f l # f2
holds f o r points
. The
into
L
does n o t s e p a r a t e t h e p o i n t s of
and M
{O}
('M;)
{ O } does n o t hold.
=
v = f -f s a t i s f i e s v" = f',' - f; = 0 , t h e n v E '(L") . 1 2 T'JI E L" f o r every J, E M" , t h i s i m p l i e s t h a t (T'J,)(v) = 0 , s o
HINT: I f
Since
J,(Tv) = 0 Tfl = Tf2 L"
=
M"
. It . If
f o l l o w s t h e n from (M "' ): M (' ):
= {O}
and w i t h
= {O}
T
=
{O}
Tv = 0
that
i s not r e q u i r e d , we can choose
,
i.e.,
L = M
with
the i d e n t i t y operator.
EXERCISE 115.6. I n Lemma 115.1 i t w a s shown t h a t t h e p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r 'Y
, defined
by
J . Synnatschke
Y(T) = T ' , i s o r d e r continuous. It w a s observed by ( [ I 1 ) t h a t t h e p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r Q , d e f i n e d by Q(T)
i s n o t even a-order =
fl,
n for
continuous i n g e n e r a l . Show t h i s by choosing
and d e f i n i n g t h e o p e r a t o r s
f = (f, ,f7,.
...)
(n=I,Z,
T",
L = M =
by
...,fn,O,O ,...
. .) E
. Then
i d e n t i t y o p e r a t o r . Note now t h a t n ( E x e r c i s e 103.16)
T
=
.
Tn 4 I
in
Lb(Lm,Lm)
TZ$ = 0 f o r a n y
, where
4 E (La):
I
i s the
and f o r
116. D i s j o i n t sequences and o r d e r continuous norms I n t h e p r e s e n t s e c t i o n we assume t h a t
The Banach d u a l t h e space
L*
L* (norm
p*)
L
i s a Banach l a t t i c e (norm P >
and t h e o r d e r d u a l
L-
a r e now i d e n t i c a l ;
i s t h e r e f o r e a Dedekind complete Banach l a t t i c e . As proved
DISJOINT SEQUENCES AND ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
442
Ch. 16,11163
i n Theorem 104.2 ( a s an immediate consequence of Meyer-Nieberg's t h e norm
in
p
i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f every o r d e r bounded
L
d i s j o i n t sequence i n thus t h a t t h e norm
converges t o z e r o i n norm. Applied t o
L
in
p*
o r d e r bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n
Fremlin ([11,1979)
that order
a l s o e q u i v a l e n t t o a c e r t a i n p r o p e r t y of d i s j o i n t sequences i n l y s t a t e d , t h e norm
in
p*
get
converges t o z e r o i n norm. It was
L*
Dodds and D.H.
i s n o t only r e l a t e d t o d i s j o i n t sequences i n
p*
, we
L*
i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f every
L*
proved now r e c e n t l y by P.G. c o n t i n u i t y of
lemma),
but is
L*
. Precise-
L
i s o r d e r continuous i f and only i f every
L*
norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n
L
converges weakly t o z e r o . We p r e s e n t
t h e proof. THEOREM 116.1. Let
1 . Then
L* (norm p*
be a Banach l a t t i c e (norm
L
1 w i t h Banach dual
p
i s order continuous i f and only i f every norm
p*
bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n
converges weakly t o zero.
L
PROOF. ( i ) Assume f i r s t t h a t
p*
i s o r d e r continuous. For t h e proof
t h a t every norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence in
L
converges weakly t o z e r o
i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o c o n s i d e r p o s i t i v e d i s j o i n t sequences of norm a t most
one. Hence, l e t and
p(un)
prove t h a t
1
5
0
u E L ( n = l , 2 , ...) w i t h a l l un mutually d i s j o i n t n for all n Furthermore, l e t 0 5 E L* We have t o
+(u )
S
+
.
0
as
n t h e Banach b i d u a l t h e space
i m p l i e s t h a t t h e sequence
n
+
L
m
. Under
becomes a Riesz subspace of
(un:n=1,2,
...)
carriers
C(u )
. It
L*
a r e mutually d i s j o i n t bands i n
+
ed d i s j o i n t sequence i n
in
C(un) and
L*
L*
(Qn:n=1,2,
u (+) = un(+ )
n
. Since
n
. Let ...)
+n b e t h e comi s an o r d e r bound-
f o r every
n
, i.e.,
i s o r d e r continuous and t h e
f o r every
sequence
i s o r d e r bounded and d i s j o i n t , we have
p*
. This
(L*):
follows t h a t t h e
$(un) = $n(un) (9,)
n
. Then
into
L
i s a d i s j o i n t sequence of posi-
t i v e o r d e r continuous l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s on ponent of t h e given
.
+
t h e n a t u r a l embedding of
p*(+,)
+
0
(by
Theorem 104.2). Hence
( i i ) Assume now t h a t e v e r y norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n v e r g e s weakly t o z e r o . For t h e proof t h a t
p*
L
con-
i s o r d e r continuous, i t i s
s u f f i c i e n t t o show (by Thbocem 104.2 a g a i n ) t h a t
p*(+,)
+ 0
f o r every d i s -
Ch. 16,81161
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
j Q i n t sequence
($n)
in
satisfying
L*
Assuming t h i s t o b e f a l s e , l e t p*($,)
>
0
E >
f o r some
p o s i t i v e element m
$n(u)
C,
5 $(u) <
E
such t h a t
E L
mn
f o r every
for a l l
5 $ E L*
$
n.
b e such a sequence s a t i s f y i n g n and a l l n For every n t h e r e e x i s t s a
($ )
> 0
u
s
0
443
.
p(un) 5 1
, we
u E L+
and
$n(un) >
. Since
E
may assume (by passing t o a
subsequence, i f n e c e s s a r y ) t h a t
For
n = 2,3,
...
,
let
0 5 v 5 u f o r every n and (vn:n=1,2, ...) i s a d i s j o i n t sequenn n e x i s t s s i n c e L i s Banach. The d i s j o i n t n e s s follows ce. Note t h a t Z2-ky,
Then
from v n 5 ( ~ ~ urn)+ - 2 ~ and
vm
5
2-"(2"
=
E
'+
um-un,
for
m < n
.
Furthermore,
n 2 E
for
n
-
-
'
n
m
n+l
2-k P*($)
s u f i f i c i e n t l y l a r g e . Hence
-
&€
$(vn) > 1s
-
2-n
for
' 1E
P*($)
n
s u f f i c i e n t l y large.
.
But (v ) i s a norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n L T h e r e f o r e , $(vn) n by h y p o t h e s i s . C o n t r a d i c t i o n . It f o l l o w s t h a t p* i s o r d e r continuous.
A s a c o r o l l a r y we f i n d t h a t t h e norm
in
p**
case
(0,)
E L+
~ " ( 4 ~ + )0
f o r every
converges a l s o weak star t e z e r o , i . e . ,
. Hence,
if
d i s j o i n t sequence i n
p**
L*
i s o r d e r continuous and
,
then
$,(u)
+
0
v e r s e does n o t h o l d , By way of example, l e t L**
Then
=
em . For Qn(u)
+
n = l,Z, 0
...
f o r every
,
let
u E L+
On
(0,)
in
0 s u" € L** $,(u) ($n)
f o r every L = (c ) 0
+
0
p**
con-
L*
. In
this
f o r every
i s a norm bounded u E L+
, so
. The
L* =
be t h e n-th u n i t v e c t o r i n
, but
0
i s o r d e r continu-
L**
ous i f and only i f everynorm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence verges weakly t o z e r o , i . e . ,
+
e,
conand L* =
( t h e Lm-norm) i s n o t o r d e r
Ll
.
444
D I S J O I N T SEQUENCES AND ORDER CONTINUOUS NORMS
16,81161
Ch.
continuous. It i s n a t u r a l , t h e r e f o r e , t o ask what c o n c l u s i o n ( i f any) can be drawn from t h e h y p o t h e s i s t h a t every norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n L*
converges weak s t a r t o zero. The n a t u r a l c o n j e c t u r e i s norm c o n t i n u i t y
of
p
. We
prove t h e c o n j e c t u r e t o b e c o r r e c t . The proof i s s i m i l a r t o ,
b u t s i m p l e r t h a n t h e proof of t h e l a s t theorem. THEOREM 116.2. A s before, l e t L* (norm
Banach dual
L
p* ). Then
be a Banach l a t t i c e (norm L*
every norm bounded d i s j o i n t seqttence i n PROOF. ( i ) Assume f i r s t t h a t Theorem 103.9, t h e space band i n of
0
$
5
n for a l l
as
n
C($n)
-. n
i s o r d e r continuous. Note t h a t , by
p
p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on
...) w i t h a l l . Furthermore, l e t 0 Since a l l in
u
. Then
and
L
$,(u)
o r d e r continuous and t h e sequence p(un)
+
0
. We have
u E L
5 1
p*($,)
t o prove t h a t
$ (u)
n
-+
0
a r e o r d e r continuous and d i s j o i n t , t h e c a r r i e r s
$n C($n)
d i s j o i n t sequence i n
i s o r d e r continuous. Let
L
mutually d i s j o i n t and
$* I
a r e mutually d i s j o i n t bands i n
given element
we have
converges weak s t a r t o zero.
i s now Dedekind complete (and, t h e r e f o r e , every
L
E L* (n=l,2,
+
with
i s a p r o j e c t i o n band). Also, on account of t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y
L
, every
p
p )
i s order continuous i f and only i f
p
. Let
L
(un:n=l,2, =
gn(un)
be t h e component of t h e
u n
...)
i s a n o r d e r bounded
f o r every
n
. Since
is
p
i s o r d e r bounded and d i s j o i n t
(un)
(by Theorem 104.2). Hence
( i i ) Assume, c o n v e r s e l y , t h a t every norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence in
converges weak s t a r t o zero. For t h e proof t h a t
L*
t i n u o u s , i t i f s u f f i c i e n t (by Theorem 104.2) t o show t h a t every d i s j o i n t sequence
n
. Assuming
p(un) >
E
(un)
in
t h i s t o be f a l s e , l e t
> 0
for a l l
n
. The
0
n
sequence
. By
L*
n
n
) 5 1
n and, t h e r e f o r e ,
hypothesis
2 $ (u ) = un(+,)
p*($
> E
(4), for a l l
u
p(u,)
L*
, which
for
for a l l
and (0,)
L*
u ~ ( $ ~>) E
implies that the
. For
every
. It may b e
n
, let
assumed
i s a norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence
converges weak s t a r t o z e r o . But
n
+ 0
5 u E L
i s then a d i s j o i n t sequence
(u,)
a r e mutually d i s j o i n t bands i n
satisfy
$n E C(un)
that in
C(u )
$n E L*
I
I
i s o r d e r con-
(un) be such a sequence s a t i s f y i n g
of o r d e r continuous l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s on carriers
0
satisfying
L
p
. Contradiction.
$,(u)
2
Ch. 16,11161
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
445
I n t h e s e p r o o f s we have e s t a b l i s h e d s e v e r a l r e l a e i o n s between d i s j o i n t sequences i n
L* .It i s worth w h i l e t o l i s t t h e s e s e p a r a t e l y a s a
and
L
theorem f o r l a t e r r e f e r e n c e . Note how much h e a v i e r i t i s t o o b t a i n d i s j o i n t sequences i n
than i n
L
L*
.
THEOREM 116.3. Once more, l e t L* i n o m
Banach dual (i)
If (un)
that
i s a d i s j o i n t sequence i n L+
=
(and hence also i n
i s given, then the components $n of $ i n form an order bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n (L*)+ such
C(u )
$,(u,) (ii)
with
p )
0 s $ E L*
(L**)+ ) and i f
the carriers
be a Banach l a t t i c e (norm
L
J.
p*
f o r all n and
$(un)
Assume
$,(urn) = 0 L
i n addition that
for m # n
.
i s DeJekind complete. Then, i f
i s a d i s j o i n t sequence of order continuous elements i n (L*)+ and i s given, the components un of u i n the carriers ~ ( 4 ~ ) form an order bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n L+ such that $ n ( ~ n )= $n(u) ($n)
i f
0 s u E L
for a l l
n
> 0
$,(urn) = 0 f o r
and
(iii) I f
f o r all n
m
.
# n
i s a d i s j o i n t sequence i n L+
(un)
satisfying
, then there e x i s t s a d i s j o i n t sequence
($n)
p(u ) >
E
n of positive
>
elements i n the u n i t b a l l of $ (u ) = 0
*n zn
2.
for
m
.
# n
p(un) = 1
with
L* such that On(un) > E f o r a l l n and In particular, i f (u,) i s a d i s j o i n t sequence for all n , and i f E > 0 i s given, there e x i s t s
of p o s i t i v e elements i n the u n i t b a l l of L* for a12 n and $,(urn) = 0 for m # n
(0,)
a d i s j o i n t sequence such that
I--E
< $,(u
(iv)
If
($n)
n
)
.
1
5
i s an order bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n
satis-
(L*)+
fying p*($,) t E > 0 f o r a l l n , and i f 0 < 6 < E , there e x i s t s natural numbers n , ,n2 ,... and a d i s j o i n t sequence (un,,un2 ) of p o s i t i v e elements i n t h e u n i t b a l l of L such t h a t $ ( ) > 6 f o r k = 1,2,
,...
with
p*(On) = 1
j o i n t sequence that I-E < $
f o r a12
(x) )
% %
PROOF.
(ii)
i s an order bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n n
, and
i f
E
> 0
5
1
for k = I,Z,,..
(L*)+
i s given, there e z i s t s a dis-
of positive elements in the u n i t b a l l of
(U
... .
"k unk
(9,)
I n particular, i f
.
L
such
( i ) This was proved i n p a r t ( i ) of t h e proof of Theorem 116.1.
On account of t h e a d d i t i o n a l c o n d i t i o n on
L
and s i n c e a l l
a r e o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s , t h e proof of p a r t ( i ) can b e taken o v e r ( a s was a c t u a l l y done i n t h e proof of Theorem
116.2).
( i i i ) This was proved i n p a r t ( i i ) of t h e proof of Theorem 116.2. (iv)
This was proved i n p a r t ( i i ) of t h e proof of Theorem 116.1.
+tl
446
COPIES
EXERCISE 116.4. Show t h a t i f
Ch. 16,11171
i s a normed Riesz space b u t n o t a
L
Banach l a t t i c e , t h e n i t may occur t h a t every norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence converges weak s t a r t o z e r o , b u t t h e norm i n
in L*
L
is not o r d e r
continuous. HINT: Let
satisfying
b e t h e space
L
1 5 p <
EXERCISE 116.5. remains t r u e i f
C([O,ll) w i t h L -norm f o r some P ( c f . a l s o Exercise 114.10).
m
p
Show t h a t t h e s t a t e m e n t i n p a r t ( i i ) of Theorem 116.3
i s only Dedekind o-complete.
L
H I N T : Use Theorem 90.4.
117. Copies Let
L
and
P
LX b e normed Riesz spaces (norms p
b e a Riesz subspace of t h e norms
and
p
X
L
in
been c a r r i e d over from K
and
LA
a copy of space
. If
respect t o
LA
and A ) and l e t
to
LX
A
has
by means of t h e Riesz isomorphism between
K
the case t h a t
K
a r e Riesz isomorphic and
a r e e q u i v a l e n t . Note h e r e t h a t t h e norm
K
L
i s Banach w i t h r e s p e c t t o
K
and
K
t h i s s i t u a t i o n o c c u r s , we s h a l l s a y t h a t
. In
LA
P
such t h a t
and
P
LX
contains P a r e Banach l a t t i c e s , t h e L
(by t h e isomorphism) a s w e l l a s w i t h
A
p (because t h e norms a r e e q u i v a l e n t ) . We s h a l l d i s c u s s s e v e r a l
c o n d i t i o n s under which a Banach l a t t i c e o r i t s d u a l c o n t a i n s ( o r f a i l s t o c o n t a i n ) a copy of THEOREM 1 1 7 . 1 . p
copy of
in L
P
(c,)
or
.
Lw
L contains a copy of (c,) such P i s order bounded i n L if and only i f the
The Bamch l a t t i c e
that the u n i t b a l l of norm
, Ll
(c,)
(c,)
P
i s not order continuous. I n particular, L* contains a i f and onZy if the rwm
p*
i n L* P
P
i s not order continuous.
PROOF. A s proved i n Theorem 104.2, t h e norm p i n L is order P continuous i f and only i f e v e r y o r d e r bounded d i s j o i n t sequence i n L tends t o z e r o i n norm. I n t h i s case i t i s e v i d e n t , t h e r e f o r e , t h a t cannot c o n t a i n a copy of bounded i n
L
type
p
then
P
. In
(c,)
such t h a t t h e u n i t b a l l of
o t h e r words, i f
L
P
c o n t a i n s a copy
(c,) of
(c,)
L
P P
i s order of t h i s
i s n o t o r d e r continuous. For t h e proof i n t h e converse
d i r e c t i o n , we assume t h a t
p
i s n o t o r d e r continuous. Then (once more by
Ch. 16,51171
447
EMBEDDING In BIDUALS
Theorem 104.2) t h e r e e x i s t s an o r d e r bounded d i s j o i n t sequence L
P
5
such t h a t u
E L
P
p(un) = 1
and
(u,)
in
0 5 u 5 n are arbitrary real
does not tend t o zero. We may assume t h a t
p(un)
for a l l
.
n
If
a l ,...,a
n
numbers, then
I t follows t h a t i f
,
( a l , a2,...) E (c,)
then
...+anun :n=1,2,... )
( s =aIuI+
n
)
i s a p-Cauchy sequence i n
L
P i n Banach space theory . ( i f a l l
m
Z 1 aiui
; we w r i t e the l i m i t as
a r e non-negative,
a.
, as
usual
t h i s i s t h e r e f o r e the
supremum of t h e p a r t i a l sums). Note t h a t
...
It i s e v i d e n t now t h a t t h e mapping of
(c,)
in
L
P (c,)
u n i t b a l l of
such t h a t , on account of
i s order bounded i n
F i n a l l y , f o r the r e s u l t about of L*
(c,)
. To
P u E L* P
,
(al,a2, )
then the u n i t b a l l of
L* P (c,)
L
m
+ C1
0 5 u
.
P
, note
n
for a l l
5 u
that i f
generates a copy
aiui
n
, the
contains a copy
L*
P
i s automatically o r d e r bounded i n
s e e t h i s , i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h e e x i s t e n c e of an element such t h a t
C
W
I
a.u. 1
1
I
u
holds f o r a l l
(i=1,2 ,...)
0 5 a. 5 1
.
s = :1 u. , the element n 1 1 L* The ( c )-norm of every s i s equal t o one, so P 0 n 5 A f o r some constant A z 0 and a l l n But then, s i n c e
Hence, i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o show t h a t , w r i t i n g sup s we have
L* P
.
exists in p(sn)
.
i s p e r f e c t (Corollary 111.2),
sup p ( s ) 5 A n
that
sup s
n
exists in
The next theorem d e a l s w i t h result that Copy of
La
i t follows from L*
P
n
I.
and
together. It contains t h e P L contains a copy of L l i f and only i f L* contains a P P The theorem i s due t o B. Kihn ( [ 1 1 , 1 9 7 9 ) . The proof a s presenL
P
and
.
0 5 s
L*
.
t e d h e r e (due t o A.R. except f o r ( i i i )
*
Schep) i s d i f f e r e n t from the proof i n Kihn’s paper,
(iv).
448
Ch. 1 6 , 8 1 1 7 1
COPIES
THEOREM 1 1 7 . 2 . The following conditions f o r t h e Banach l a t t i c e
are equivalent. (i)
L*
contains a copy of
(ii)
L*
contains a copy of
(c ) 0
( i i i ) The nomi i n (iv)
=5
P
.
L* i s not order continuous. contains a copy of b,
L
.
PROOF. We s h a l l prove ( i )
(i)
.
b,
L = L
( t i ) For
n = 1,2,
*
...
(ii)
,
=$
let
(iii) e
*
(iv)
*
*
(iii)
be the element of
(i). (c,)
with
the n-th coordinate equal t o one and a l l o t h e r coordinates zero. Let be
$n under t h e isomorphism. Then n i s a d i s j o i n t sequence of p o s i t i v e elements i n L* and on account
t h e element of
($n)
corresponding t o
L*
e
of t h e norm equivalence t h e r e e x i s t p o s i t i v e c o n s t a n t s
and
A
such
B
that
for a l l NOW,
n = 1,2 all L*
s
.
a = (al,a2
,...)
,... , we have . Hence, s i n c e
E
L:
particular, A 5 p*($
. men,
writing
n
) 5 B
= al$l
s
+
for a l l
... +
n
an$n
. for
0 5 s I. and p * ( s ) 5 B sup(la.1) = B . l l a l l m f o r n n i s p e r f e c t , .the element s = sup s exists in n Each p o s i t i v e element a i n b, generates thus a p o s i t i v e element
n
= s(a)
in
additive, so into
. In
...) E (c,)
(a,,.,,
let
L*
L*
L*
.
S
extends uniquely t o a p o s i t i v e l i n e a r mapping from
. Note
It i s e a s i l y seen t h a t the mapping
t h a t , f o r every
a = ( a l , a 2 , . ..) Eb,
S: a
, we
-t
is
s(a)
b,
have
(where we use t h a t 0 < s I. s implies p * ( s n ) I. p * ( s ) ) . Furthermore, S n preserves d i s j o i n t n e s s , s o t h a t , t h e r e f o r e , S i s a Riesz homomorphism. Combining these f a c t s , S and t h e L,-norm
contains a copy of (ii)
*
i s seen t o be a Riesz isomorphism such t h a t
a r e equivalent i n the range of
( i i i ) If
bm
.
L* contains a copy of
S
. This
,
there e x i s t s i n
shows t h a t
p*
L* L*
an
o r d e r bounded d i s j o i n t sequence of elements of norm one. Hence, by Theorem 104.2 again, the norm
p*
i s not o r d e r continuous.
(iii) * ( i v ) Since the norm
p*
i s not o r d e r continuous, t h e r e e x i s t s
(by Theorem 116.1) a norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence (u : n = l , 2 ,
n
...)
of
Ch. 16,11171
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
p o s i t i v e elements i n 0 2 $ E L*
which does not converge weakly t o zero. Hence,
L
we may assume t h a t
p(un)
and some
the l i n e a r mapping
L,
(the notation
we have
+
T
C
T(a) = E l aiui
. Now
n
for a l l
a
=
define
(a1,"*,...)€
m
Banach, i t follows t h a t such t h a t
B > 0
i s norm bounded, i . e . ,
T
p{T(a)} 2 B l l a l l l
Hence, p that
and t h e
t h e r e e x i s t s a constant
. For
a € L,
. Then
an e s t i m a t e i n
L 1-norm a r e equivalent i n the range of L, .
. It
T
follows
contains a copy of
L
*
(iv)
el
( i i i ) There e x i s t s i n
a norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence
of p o s i t i v e elements and t h e r e e x i s t s a p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l
(en)
E
=
km such t h a t
contains a copy
L
for a l l
a E kl
t h e converse d i r e c t i o n , l e t
K
+(en) = 1
,
of
for a l l
a p o s i t i v e l i n e a r functional and
lJ,(f)l 2 Ap(f)
on
$
i s a Riesz subspace of
L
, so
$
on
for a l l
(and hence i n
K
L ) a
of p o s i t i v e elements and t h e r e e x i s t s K
f o r some constant
bounded l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l $(un) = 1
n .Hence, s i n c e by hypothesis
there e x i s t s i n
norm bounded d i s j o i n t sequence (u,)
K
for a l l
E
m
by
L
and a l s o t h a t f o r some
n
$(un) >
a.u i s i n t h e sense of norm convergence). Then 1 i i i s a Riesz isomorphism and, t h e r e f o r e , T i s p o s i t i v e . Since L i s
E k,
)I
for a l l
1
S
> 0
E
T:
449
J,
L
such t h a t A > 0
J,(un) = I
and a l l
for a l l
f E K
n
. The copy
can be extended t o a p o s i t i v e norm (Theorem 85.5). It follows from
n t h a t t h e norm bounded sequence
(un)
converge weakly t o zero. Hence, by Theorem 116.1, t h e norm
in
L
does not
p*
i s not
order continuous. (iii)
*
( i ) By hypothesis, t h e norm
ous. Hence, by Theorem I 1 7.1,
p*
in
L*
contains a copy of
L*
i s not o r d e r continu(c,)
.
In t h e f i r s t theorem of t h e p r e s e n t s e c t i o n we have proved t h a t the norm p
of
in (c,)
L
f a i l s t o be o r d e r continuous i f and only i f such t h a t t h e u n i t b a l l of
(c,)
L
contains a copy
i s o r d e r bounded i n
L
second theorem we have seen t h a t i f a s i m i l a r s i t u a t i o n occurs i n p*
not o r d e r continuous), then
L*
contains n o t only a copy of
. In
the
L* ( i . e . ,
(c,)
, but
COPIES
450
one df i.e.,
La
a s w e l l . I t may be asked, t h e r e f o r e , i f t h e same h o l d s i n
i f t h e hypothesis t h a t
La
c o n t a i n s a Copy of
L
Ch. 16,§1171
,
f a i l s t o be o r d e r continuous i m p l i e s t h a t
p
. The
L
answer i s n e g a t i v e . The supremum norm i n
t h e Banach l a t t i c e ( c ) of a l l ( r e a l ) convergent sequences i s n o t o r d e r continuous. Therefore, ( c ) c o n t a i n s a copy of (c ) w i t h o r d e r bounded 0 I f L i s a Dedekind ( c ) does n o t c o n t a i n a copy of La
.
unit b a l l , but
a-complete Banach l a t t i c e , t h e s i t u a t i o n becomes d i f f e r e n t , a s shown by t h e f o l l o w i n g theorem. THEOREM 117.3.
L
The Dedekind a-complete Banach l a t t i c e
Lm if and only if t h e norm
a copy o f
tinkous. Note t h a t f o r
contains
in L fails t o be order con-
p
t h i s simply means t h a t conditions ( i i ) and
L*
( i i i ) in t h e preceding theorem are equivalent. PROOF. I t i s e v i d e n t t h a t i f
L
La ,
c o n t a i n s a copy of
then
L
c o n t a i n s an o r d e r bounded d i s j o i n t sequence of elements of norm one. Hence, by Theorem 104.2, t h e norm
p
i s n o t o r d e r continuous. For t h e converse,
assume t h a t i n t h e Dedekind a-complete space continuous. We have t o prove t h a t
L
L
t h e norm
c o n t a i n s a copy of
p
La
i s not order
. As
i n the
proof of Theorem 1 1 7 . 1 , t h e r e e x i s t s an o r d e r bounded d i s j o i n t sequence (u,)
in
Cn u.
< u
1
1
f o r each
0 < u
such t h a t
L
for a l l
n
and
L
. The
...) E
(al,a2,
t o some element of
E 1- and t h e mapping phism from
La
f i n i t e sum
lalIul +
into
we f i n d t h a t
Furthermore, s i n c e
L:
S:
L
< u E L and
p(un) = 1
i s Dedekind o-complete,
t h e p a r t i a l sums same h o l d s
( a l , a 2 ...) ,
C y aiui
for a l l
m
L . Since p ( C a.u.) = 1 1 ... + l a n / u n s a t i s f i e s
p(C
. Since
converge i n o r d e r
then f o r an a r b i t r a r y Z 1 aiui
n
i t i s evident t h a t
...) E
(al,a2,
d e f i n e s a Riesz isomorlailui)
and s i n c e any
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
Ch. 16,51171
45 1
we g e t
It f o l l o w s t h a t
mapping
S
. This
and t h e La-norm aye e q u i v a l e n t i n l t h e range of t h e
p
shows t h a t
.
c o n t a i n s a copy of
L
We have s e e n i n t h e f i r s t theorem of t h e p r e s e n t s e c t i o n t h a t i n a Banach l a t t i c e
L
o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of t h e norm
sufficient for
L
n o t t o c o n t a i n a copy of
o r d e r bounded i n
(c,)
. There
L
L
n o t to c o n t a i n a copy of
c a n t i n u i t y of
p
alone i s not s u f f i c i e n t .
THEOREM 117.4. The Banach L a t t i c e (c,)
L
i f and only i f
L
i s a band i n p
w i t h t h e u n i t b a l l of
i s a l s o a simple n e c e s s a r y and s u f f i c i e n t
condition f o r
114.71, i f and only i f
i s n e c e s s a r y and
p
(c,)
L**
(c,)
a t a l l . Obviously, o r d e r
does not contain a copy of
, t h a t i s t o say (by Theorem L
i s order continuous and
has t h e weak
sequential Fatou property. PROOF. Assume f i r s t t h a t
L
does n o t c o n t a i n a copy of
as observed above, i t follows from Theorem 1 1 7 . 1 t h a t tinuous. Therefore, since
i s s u p e r Dedekind complete.
L
Hence, by Theorem 114.5, we s e e a l r e a d y t h a t L
i s o r d e r dense i n
It remains t o prove t h a t
i s an i d e a l i n
L
.
(L*);
m
such t h a t
i s n o t p-Cauchy.
(u,)
such
L**
h a s t h e weak s e q u e n t i a l Fatou p r o p e r t y .
L
Assume, f o r t h i s purpose, t h a t we have a sequence sup p(un) <
i s o r d e r con-
p
i s now a Banach l a t t i c e w i t h o r d e r continuous
L
norm, we d e r i v e from Theorem 103.9 t h a t that
. Then,
(c,)
+
0 5 u i n L with n It i s e v i d e n t t h a t
w" = sup u e x i s t s i n L** , simply by d e f i n i n g t h a t ~ " ( 0 )= sup g(un) n is perfect). f o r every 0 2 L$ E L* ( a l t e r n a t i v e l y , by observing t h a t L** Since W"
0 5 u E L c (L*);E n
for
E (L*)E , which shows t h a t
t o t h e non-p-Cauchy
sequence
i t may b e assumed t h a t Setting
fn = u p**(L;
~ -+ un~
n = l,Z,
0 5 u (un)
n
.
~(U,+~-U,) >
, we
have
... and
4 w"
i s a band, we g e t
(L*)E
holds i n
(L*)E
. We
return
P a s s i n g t o a subsequence i f n e c e s s a r y , E
f o r some
0 5 f 2
n
w"
f k ) = p**\un+l -u 1) 2 p**(w")
E
> 0
and a l l
n
as well a s and
p**(fn) >
6
.
COPIES
452
for a l l
. Hence,
n
t h e sequence
(f ) n
Ch. 1 6 , § 1 1 7 3
lemma (Lemma 104.1) t o
we may apply Meyer-Nieberg's t o o b t a i n a d i s j o i n t sequence
0 5 v" 5 w"
(vi)
.
in
such
(L*):
p**(v") > E f o r a l l n For each n t h e r e n = 1 and v"($ ) > E e x i s t s a p o s i t i v e $n E L* s a t i s f y i n g p*'($,) n n Furthermore, s i n c e L i s o r d e r dense i n (L*): , t h e r e e x i s t s f o r each that
n
an element
@,(zn) > Since
.
E
and
such t h a t 0 i z 5 v" and z ~ ( $ >~ )E , i . e . , n n n On account of p * ( $ ) = 1 i t follows t h a t p(zn) > E n
z E L
i s a d i s j o i n t sequence, so i s
(v;)
j o i n t sequence i n If
...,an
al ,
L
as well as i n
= alzl + n sequence i n
.
. Hence,
(2,)
, majorized
(L*):
i s a dis-
(2,)
by
w"
in
(L*):
.
a r e a r b i t r a r y r e a l numbers, t h e n
As i n Theorem 117.1 i t follows t h a t i f s
.
... + an zn f o r L . Writing Z
before that
Hence, t h e sequence
(2,)
n = 1,2, a.z.
1 1
...
(a,,a2,
,
...)
then
and
E (c,)
(s,)
i s a p-Cauchy
f o r t h e l i m i t , i t f o l l o w s s i m i l a r l y as
g e n e r a t e s a copy of
(c,)
L
in
,
contradicting
our h y p o t h e s i s . We have proved t h u s t h a t n o t only every o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g Sequence i n quence i n
b u t a l s o every norm bounded i n c r e a s i n g se-
L'
i s p-Cauchy and hence i s norm convergent. Since t h e norm
L+
l i m i t i s a l s o t h e supremum, t h i s shows t h a t
L
h a s t h e weak s e q u e n t i a l
Fatou p r o p e r t y .
I n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n , l e t
L
have o r d e r continuous norm a s w e l l
a s t h e weak s e q u e n t i a l Fatou p r o p e r t y and assume t h a t , n e v e r t h e l e s s , L c o n t a i n s a copy of
-
(c,)
(un)
a d i s j o i n t sequence 2 p(un) 5 B <
all n
, and
. The
l a s t assumption i m p l i e s t h e e x i s t e n c e of
of p o s i t i v e elements i n
L
such t h a t
f o r appropriate s t r i c t l y positive constants
.
p s-(u
as
n + m
, since
0 < A 9 and
On account of t h e weak p ( u , + ...+u ) < B f o r a l l n n s = s u p ( u l +...+ u ) e x i s t s , so n- I
also
Fatou p r o p e r t y t h e element
{
A,B
I
+...+ unp
c 0
i s o r d e r continuous. On account of
Ch. 16,11171
EMBEDDING I N BIDUALS
0 i un 5 s
it follows t h a t Hence, L
-
453
(uI+...+u n- 1
p(u ) + 0
, contradicting
cannot c e n t a i n a copy of
(c,)
p(un)
.
5
A > 0
for a l l
.
n
The l a s t theorem, a s a l s o t h e p r e c e d i n g one and t h e r e f l e x i v i t y theorem which f o l l o w s , i s e s s e n t i a l l y due t o G. Ya Lozanovskii ([21,[31,[41, 1967-1969).
Independent p r o o f s occur i n papers by H.P. Lotz ([21,1974) and
P. Meyer-Nieberg
(C 11,1973).
THEOREM 1 1 7 . 5 . The f o l l o v i n g conditions f o r the Banach i a t t i c e
L
are
equivalent. (i)
L
i s reflexive.
(ii)
L
does not contain a copy of
(c,)
o r a copy of
b,
( i i i ) L* does not contain a copy o f
(c,)
o r a copy of
L,
PROOF. ( i ) L
, then
(c,)
L
i s r e f l e x i v e , then
does n o t c o n t a i n a copy of
*
(c,)
o r a copy
( i ) From t h e h y p o t h e s i s t h a t
L
.
1‘
does n o t c o n t a i n a copy of p
i s o r d e r continuous and
h a s t h e weak s e q u e n t i a l p r o p e r t y . It remains t o prove (Theorem 114.8)
that
p*
i s o r d e r continuous. I f n o t , t h e space
(iii)
L
c o n t a i n s a copy of
117.2), c o n t r a r y t o h y p o t h e s i s . Hence, p *
L, (Theorem
*
(c,)
i s o r d e r continuous.
( i i ) We have t o show t h a t i f ( i i ) does n o t h o l d , t h e n ( i i i )
does n o t hold. I n o t h e r words, w e have t o show t h a t i f of
(c,)
i s r e f l e x i v e . Hence, L*
L*
o r a copy of
it f o l l o w s (by t h e l a s t theorem) t h a t
(c,)
L
c o n t a i n s a copy of
are not reflexive. (iii) If
=$
(ii)
L
t h i s copy i s r e f l e x i v e . This i s i m p o s s i b l e , however, s i n c e
and (i)
( i i ) Any norm c l o s e d l i n e a r subspace of t h e r e f l e x i v e
i s r e f l e x i v e . Hence, i f
space of
. .
as w e l l a s a copy of
a copy of
Ll
a copy of
(c,)
, it
Ll , t h e n s o does
L*
L
c o n t a i n s a copy
. Since
f o l l o w s immediately from Theorem 117.2 t h a t
. Since
L
c o n t a i n s a copy of
once a g a i n by Theorem 117.2, t h e space
L*
(c,)
, so
does
c o n t a i n s a copy of
L
contains
L*
contains
. Hence,
L** 1‘
EXERCISE 117.6. Various r e s u l t s i n t h i s c h a p t e r ( n o t r e s t r i c t e d t o t h e l a s t s e c t i o n ) can b e complexified. In t h i s e x e r c i s e we assume t h a t
L
Archimedean and uniformly complete Riesz space. The c o m p l e x i f i c a t i o n of
is an L
COPIES
454
i s denoted by
L"
. For
on
B+iB
f" + ig"
. Similarly
L+iL
any
h
f+ig with
=
as i n s e c t i o n 109, l e t
f,g
E
L
be d e f i n e d by
h"($) = $(h)
with
g"
f"
and
Ch.
, let
b e an i d e a l i n
B
the complexvalued f u n c t i o n
f o r every
belonging t o
16,81173
B-
. It
,
. Then
E B+iB
@
h"
h" =
was proved i n s e c t i o n
(f vf ) " = f',' v f " 1 2 2 (f hf )" = f',' A f " I n p a r t i c u l a r , t h e r e f o r e , we have I f [ " = If"I 1 2 2 For t h e proof t h a t l h l " = Ih"I h o l d s f o r any h = f + i g for a l l f E L 109 t h a t i f
fl
and
and
f2
.
.
a r e elements of
L
then
,
n o t e the following f a c t s . (i) If
f < g
in
L
If cos8+g s i n e l 5 Ihl of t h e s e t o f a l l ( i i ) If f:
+
f"
fn
in
n
-+
for a l l
f
. Hence,
s
E C0,21r)
9
in
+ IgI
B"
. By
h(e1)
.
that
Ihl"
in
L
f o r some
so
s"
5
s"
p < Ihl"
n as well as to
for a l l
,...,h ( 8n ) n
. Show t h a t
. Therefore
Ihl"
t h e supremum of t h e s e t of a l l Note t h a t i f
L
m i l i a r embedding of t h e r e f o r e , with
u
2
p = Ihl"
s"
n
. Assume now
L+iL i n t o
.
.
such t h a t
, and
,
i.e.,
,
then
is
p
,
p 5 Ihl"
it follows t h a t
If" cos8+g" sin81 (L+iL)**
that
converges el'-uniformly
Ihl"
Ihl" = Ih"/
i s a Banach l a t t i c e and we a r e d e a l i n g
If"+ig"I
Ih"l
E L+ , then
E x e r c i s e 91.12 t h e r e e x i s t s a sequence
converges e " - u n i f o m l y t o Ihl" n an upper bound of t h e s e t of a l l If" cos8+g" sin81 -+ m
i s an upper bound
o t h e r words, Ihl"
h ( 8 . ) = If cos8.+g s i n 5 . I f o r a l l j , then 3 J 3 converges e-uniformly t o Ihl a s
such t h a t i f of
. In
h o l d s u-uniformly
e = If1
[0,21r)
t h e supremum
f " < g " . I n p a r t i c u l a r , i t f o l l o w s from
then
If" cos8+g" sin81
h o l d s u"-uniformly
( i i i ) Let
(ej>
,
to
.
p is
with the fa-
I f + i g l correspbnds
It f o l l o w s , f o r example, t h a t t h e r e s u l t s i n
s e c t i o n 1 1 4 and 117 about t h e Banach b i d u a l and about e o p i e s can b e extended immediately t o t h e complex case.
CHAPTER 17 ABSTRACT Lp - SPACES
If
i s a Riesz space equipped w i t h a Riesz norm
L
1 5 p <
number s a t i s f y i n g
pp(u+v) = pp(u) + pp(v) Similarly, p u
and
v
t h e norm
p m
p =
, then
for a l l
t h e norm and
u
is s a i d t o be --additive
in
that
m
L
in
i s p-additive
in
p
is a real
satisfying
L
. If
f o r some
i s included h e r e ) , t h e n
and
inf(u,v)= 0 .
p(u+v) = max{p(u),p(v)}
inf(u,v) = 0
satisfying
L
v
if
p
i s s a i d t o be p-additive i f
p
p
for a l l
i s a Banach l a t t i c e and
L
satisfying
1 2 p 5
m
(note
i s c a l l e d an a b s t r a c t L -space. For P P = 1 , we t h e r e f o r e g e t an a b s t r a c t L -space, which i s a l s o c a l l e d an ab1 s t r a c t L-space o r an AL-space. For p = , an a b s t r a c t L_-space i s a l s o L
c a l l e d an a b s t r a c t M-space o r an AM-space. Among t h e main examples a r e spaces C(X) X
, where
Lp(X,u)
, i.e.,
. One
i s a measure space, and spaces of type
(X,A,p)
spaces of continuous f u n c t i o n s on a compact t o p o l o g i c a l space
of our p r i n c i p a l purposes i n t h e p r e s e n t c h a p t e r i s t o r e p r e s e n t an
L (X,u) P
a b s t r a c t L -space as a space of t y p e P space of type C(X)
.
o r a s a Riesz subspace of a
I n s e c t i o n 118 i t w i l l be proved f i r s t t h a t i f t h e norm i n
p-additive dual
p
satisfying
i s q-additive f o r
L*
1 5 p<m
f o r some
,
then
L
p
-1
1
S
+ q- 1
= 1
This i m p l i e s t h a t i f u
and
space
L
(norm
P(f)
1
implies
space of type
v
L in
i s an AL-space,
L+
. The
. Any
or
C(X)
Lm(X,u)
holds f o r a l l then
L*
i s order
L
and
u
v
p(u+v) = p ( u ) + p(v)
p o s i t i v e element
e
in
L+.
holds
i n t h e normed Riesz p(e) = 1
and
s t r o n g norm u n i t i s a s t r o n g u n i t . I n a
, with
uniform norm, t h e f u n c t i o n i d e n t i -
c a l l y one i s a s t r o n g norm u n i t . I t w i l l be proved t h a t i f space, t h e n t h e Banach d u a l
is
(T. Ando). Furthermore, i f
p ) i s c a l l e d a s t r o n g norm u n i t i f
If1 5 e
L
t h e norm i n t h e Banach
i s super Dedekind complete and t h e norm i n
continuous. Also, pp(u+v) 2 pp(u) + pp(v) for a l l
, then
pSm
L
i s an AL-
i s an AM-space p o s s e s s i n g a s t r o n g norm
unit.
455
Ch. 1 7 , 5 1 1 8 1
CHAPTER 17
456
A s observed a l r e a d y , t h e Banach d u a l of a normed Riesz space w i t h
norm i s an AL-space.
-additive
p r o p e r t y t h a t t h e band l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s on
(norm
in
Lg
although
=
1
i t s e l f i s not
L*
It was proved by E. d e Jonge t h a t t h e s e a r e t h e
d e f i n e d ( i n s e c t i o n 119) a s b e i n g normed Riesz spaces
p ) with t h e property t h a t f o r a l l
= p(u2)
possessing t h e
L
( c o n s i s t i n g of a l l norm bounded s i n g u l a r
L*
L ) i s an AL-space,
n e c e s s a r i l y an AL-space. semi-M-spaces,
There e x i s t Riesz spaces
and f o r any sequence
(v,)
.
l i m p(vn) 5 1
u1,u2
with
p
1 5 p <
satisfying
-
with
L+
sup(ul,u2) 2 v
+
L
p(ul) = 0
we have
i s e i t h e r an a b s t r a c t L P o r a Dedekind complete Riesz space
I n s e c t i o n 120 i t i s proved now t h a t i f space f o r some
in
L
p o s s e s s i n g a s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e o r d e r continuous l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l , t h e n
i s e i t h e r Riesz isomorphic (and norm isomorphic) t o a space t o an i d e a l i n a space
, where
L1(X,A,u)
compact Hausdorff space
. The
X
b l u s t (1940). F i n a l l y , i f
theorem. I f AL-space.
r e s u l t f o r L -spaces goes back t o F. BohnenP i s an AM-space p o s s e s s i n g a s t r o n g norm u n i t ,
L
therefore
. This
C(X)
such t h a t
X
L
L*
i s an
i s an AM-space w i t h a s t r o n g norm u n i t , and
L**
i s isomorphic t o some
L**
i s Riesz
f o l l o w s from Yosida's r e p r e s e n t a t i o n
i s an a r b i t r a r y AM-space, t h e n t h e Banach d u a l
L
It follows t h a t
L
or
P i s a measure i n t h e l o c a l l y
p
t h e n t h e r e e x i s t s a compact t o p o l o g i c a l space isomorphic t o t h e space
L (X,A,u)
Riesz subspace of a space of type
. Thus L i s isomorphic t o a . The i n v e s t i g a t i o n of AM-spaces goes
C(X)
C(X)
back t o S . Kakutani (1941).
118. Riesz s p a c e s w i t h p - a d d i t i v e norm Let
L
a r e a l number s a t i s f y i n g if
-.
be a Riesz space equipped w i t h a Riesz norm
1 s p <
pP(u+v> = pp(u) + pp(v)
inf(u,v) = 0
and
p
holds f o r a l l
u
and
The norm
holds f o r a l l
v
in
L
satisfying
,
p
if
v
in
L
satisfying
p(u+v) = max{p(u),p(v)}
inf(u,v) = 0 nad
be
p
. If
L
is a
i s p - a d d i t i v e f o r some
i s c a l l e d an a b s t r a c t L -space. For P p = 1 , we t h u s g e t a n a b s t r a c t L 1 -space which i s a l s o c a l l e d an abstract p
satisfying
L-space o r an &-space.
m
For
then
p
i s s a i d t o b e p-additive
p
and
i s s a i d t o be --additive
Banach l a t t i c e w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e norm
1 5 p s
u
and l e t
p
L
p =
m
an abstract M-space o r an AM-space. p - a d d i t i v e norm a r e t h e space
, an
a b s t r a c t Lm-space i s also c a l l e d
Among t h e main examples of s p a c e s w i t h
Lp(X,p)
, where
(X,A,u)
i s a measure space
Ch. 17,§1181
The s p a c e space
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
of a l l ( r e a l ) c o n t i n u o u s f u n c t i o n s on a compact t o p o l o g i c a l
C(X)
w i t h t h e uniform norm i s an AM-space.
X
457
Another example of a n AM-
s p a c e i s o b t a i n e d by t a k i n g t h e second commutant
C”(D)
of a set
of
m u t a l l y commuting H e r m i t i a n o p e r a t o r s i n a H i l b e r t s p a c e ( c f . s e c t i o n 57). Abstract L -spaces,
P
1 _< p <
for
m
, were
i n t r o d u c e d by F. Bohnenblust ( [ I ] ,
1940); AM-spaces were i n v e s t i g a t e d i n a p a p e r by S. Kakutani ( [ l I , l 9 4 1 ) , w i t h an immediate s e q u e l b y Bohnenblust and Kakutani j o i n t l y ( [ l ] , l 9 4 l ) .
One
of t h e main purposes i n t h e s e p a p e r s i s t o r e p r e s e n t a n a b s t r a c t L -space a s P a s p a c e of t y p e L (X,u) on an a p p r o p r i a t e measure s p a c e o r a s a R i e s z subP s p a c e of a s p a c e of t y p e C(X) on an a p p r o p r i a t e t o p o l o g i c a l s p a c e X
.
As well-known, o-finite,
p
(i.e.,
q =
t h e Banach d u a l of t h e s p a c e if
m
p
=
LI(X,p)
now g e n e r a l l y t h a t i f
,
1 5 p <
for
, unless
L
L*
p
satisfying
h a s q - a d d i t i v e norm f o r
p
such t h a t
q-additive for
p-l
+ q-l
m
= 1
L
s p e c t i v e l y . Assume f i r s t t h a t > 0
+ q-l
= 1
Lacey and
. Then .
and 1
L* 5
t h e norm i n t h e Banach dual
w i l l be denoted by
p <
m
b e g i v e n . There e x i s t s an element
. Let
p
inf(+,$) = 0
u t 0
in
L
L*
is
and
p*
re-
in
L*
and l e t
such t h a t
p(u) = I
and
Since V
.
be a normed R i e s z s p a c e v i t h p - a d d i t i v e norm f o r
L
1 5 p 2
PROOF. The norms i n
E
p-l
Bernau ([1],1974).
THEOREM 118.1. L e t some
is
i s 1 - a d d i t i v e . We s h a l l prove
(L,(X,p))*
h a s p - a d d i t i v e norm f o r some
t h e n t h e Banach d u a l
= 1
i n very t r i v i a l c a s e s , i t i s not
The p r o o f , due t o T. Ando, i s from a n e x p o s i t o r y p a p e r by H.E. S.J.
and
m
L (X,p) w i t h q determined by p-l + q-l 4 1 ). A l s o , a l t h o u g h t h e Banach d u a l of Lm(X,p)
d i f f i c u l t t o show t h a t t h e norm i n
m
,
i s t h e space
properly l a r g e r than
1 5 p 5
Lp(X,p)
0 = { i n f ( $ , $ ) } ( u ) = inf($(v)+$(u-v):O
E L with
0 S v 5 u
and
$(v)
+ $(u-v)
<
E
,
t h e r e e x i s t s a n element
. Hence
For
p = 1
and, s i n c e
, this
i s majorized by
{(u-v)-inf(u-v,v)}
bracket i s equal t o
p{u-2
Since, conversely, p*($+Q) p
Ch. 17,§1181
RIESZ SPACES WITH p-ADDITIVE NORM
458
i s 1 - a d d i t i v e , then
A
{v-inf(u-v,v)l
2
p*
=
5 p(u) = 1
inf(u-v,v)}
max{p*($),p*($)}
i s --additive.
,
0
,
,
t h e l a s t square
s o (1) becomes
it i s e v i d e n t now t h a t i f
Then, by HBlder’s i n e q u a l i t y , t h e l a s t e x p r e s s i o n i n ( 1 )
pJ (u-v)
*
lP ‘I
- i n f (u-v ,v ) ‘1+ppJv- i n f (u-v
J ‘ 1
S i m i l a r l y a s b e f o r e , i t follows from A
{v-inf(u-v,v)}
=
0
1 < p <
Assume now t h a t
,v)
‘1PP (1 +
{ (u-v)-inf (u-v,v)
3E
1
m
.
is majorized by
.
A
t h a t t h e l a s t square b r a c k e t i s e q u a l t o
so ( 1 ) becomes
T h i s holds f o r every
E
> 0
, and
hence
{p*($+$)lq 5 { p * ( $ > j q
Far t h e i n e q u a l i t y i n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n , l e t such t h a t
p(u)
=
p(v) = 1
and
0 5 u
+
,v
{P*($)lq E L
be
Ch. 17,11181
Put
P
w = { $ ( U ) } ~ - ' U and
Since
459
ABSTRACT L -SPACES
inf(+,$) = 0
,
(w -w A Z 0 0 0
( z -w
.
z = {$(v)}q-'v
w
0
there e x i s t
0
Then
5 w
0 5 zo 5 z
and
such t h a t
Hence
Since
A
0
0
AZ
0
= 0
This h o l d s , t h e r e f o r e , a l s o f o r
i t follows t h a t that i f
1 < p <
The c a s e
+
{p*(+)Iq m
and
p = =
p
, we
0
E =
have
. Observing
5 {p*(++$)}'
{p*($)Iq
i s p-additive,
i s l e f t . Since
p*($+$)
i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove i n t h i s c a s e t h a t for
inf(+,$) = 0
. Again,
let
E >
0
then
. There
now t h a t
. This
5 p*(+)
exist
-1
=
q
-1
,
concludes t h e proof
i s q-additive.
p*
p*(+)
1-p
+
p*($)
+ p*($>
5
always h o l d s , p*($+$)
0 5 u,v E L
holds
such t h a t
R I E S Z SPACES WITH p-ADDITIVE
460
p(u) = p(v) = 1
NORM
Ch.17,§1181
and
inf($,JI) = 0
Furthermore, s i n c e
,
0 2 w 2 u
there e x i s t
and
0
Iz 2
v
such t h a t
Hence
This holds f o r
as w e l l , so
= 0
E
p*($) + p*(JI)
.
2 p*($+$)
-
For 1 2 p < , a b s t r a c t L -spaces have s p e c i a l p r o p e r t i e s . A s Riesz P spaces these spaces a r e super Dedekind complete and t h e norm i s o r d e r continuous. THEOREM 118.2. I f 1 Ip <
m
, then
L
L
i s an abstract L -space f o r some
P
p
i s super Dedekind complete and the norm i n
satisfying L
is
order continuous. PROOF. Let
(un:n=1,2,
p o s i t i v e elements i n m
+ n . Then
sm =
norm by
p
, we
for a l l
m
, so
L
~ ' pun
,
...)
say
be an order bounded sequence of d i s j o i n t
0
5
u
satisfies
n
Iuo
o
for a l l
< sm < uo
n
and
for a l l
m
u Iu for m n Denoting t h e
.
have
p(un)
+
0
as
n
+
-.
Since
L
i s a Banach l a t t i c e with
ABSTRACT L -SPACES
Ch. 17,11181
46 1
P
respect t o
p
by assumption, i t f o l l o w s from Theorem 104.2 t h a t every
o r d e r bounded i n c r e a s i n g sequence i n
i s convergent i n norm. By Theorem
L
103.6, however, t h i s i s e q u i v a l e n t t o s u p e r Dedekind completeness of
L
t o g e t h e r w i t h o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of t h e norm.
-
I t f o l l o w s from t h e l a s t theorem t h a t i f
f o r some L
, then
p
satisfying
1 5 p <
f o r any p o s i t i v e
u
and
i s an a b s t r a c t L -space P i s a given p o s i t i v e element i n
e
L
i n t h e band g e n e r a t e d by 0 5 s
(by F r e u d e n t h a l ' s s p e c t r a l theorem) a sequence s
a f i n i t e sum
n elements
pi
C a.p.
with the c o e f f i c i e n t s
1 1
mutually d i s j o i n t components of
t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of
p
, so
t y of
in
4 u
, each
L
nonnegative and t h e
. Then
. Note
there exists
p(u-sn)
+
0
by
t h a t Freudenthal's
i s Dedekind complete. This proper-
L
w i l l b e used i n t h e proof of t h e n e x t theorem.
L
THEOREM 118.3. 1 5 p <
a.
e
4 p(u)
p(sn)
s p e c t r a l theorem may b e a p p l i e d s i n c e
e
m
If
L
p
i s an a b s t r a c t L -space for some P
, then
holds f o r a l l pDsitive elements
u
and
v
in L
. In
such t h a t
other words, t h e
i s p - s u p e r a d d i t i v e . If L i s an abstract L-space (AL-space), holds f o r a l l p o s i t i v e u and v i n L
norm
p
then
p(u+v) = p ( u ) + p(v)
PROOF. Note f i r s t t h a t numbers
.
(a+b)'
2
f o r a r b i t r a r y non-negative
a p + bp
a , b ; hence pp(aw+bw) 2 pp(aw) + pp(bw) w E L+
f o r any
. This
i s obviously a v e r y simple case of t h e theorem t o b e
proved; we s h a l l reduce t h e g e n e r a l proof t o t h i s case. For t h i s purpose,
0
let
5
u
,v E
L
b e g i v e n and s e t
e = u+v
p o s i t i v e elements i n t h e i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by
. Then ,
e
u
and
v
are
and t h e r e f o r e (by
F r e u d e n t h a l ' s s p e c t r a l theorem, a s observed above) u
and
v
may b e
approximated from below by f i n i t e l i n e a r combinations of d i s j o i n t components Of
e
w i t h non-negative c o e f f i c i e n t s . Given
t = 1b.p:
J J
E
> 0
,
let
be l i n e a r combinations of t h i s k i n d such t h a t
s = 1a.p.
1 1
and
pp(s) > pp(u)
-
E
RIESZ SPACES WITH
462
and
-
p P ( t ) > pp(v)
coefficients i n
and
s
d i s j o i n t ) components Zipij
pi
=
. We
E
for all
:3 i,j
s
aipij
= Ci,j
may assume t h a t
Ch. 1 7 , § 1 1 8 1
Cpi = CpJ = e
(some
may t h e n be z e r o ) . I n t r o d u c i n g t h e (mutually
t
p..
p-ADDITIVE NORM
=
pi
A
, we
pj
may w r i t e
CjPij
and
,
t = C.
1,
,
Pi
.
bjpij
j
=
I n view of t h e remark a t t h e beginning of t h e proof we f i n d now t h a t P P (u+v) 2 p P ( s + t ) = pp { c i , j (ai+bj)pij} = C.
1,
Since
E
If
u,v
pP{(ai+bjjpij} 1
i s an AL-space,
. Since
+ c.
pp(aipij)
2
i s a r b i t r a r y , i t follows t h a t
> 0 L
E L+
j
2(bjPij)
1,j
.
pp(u+v) 2 pp(u) + pp(v)
we g e t thus t h a t
p(u+v) t p(u) + p(v)
for a l l
t h e r e v e r s e i n e q u a l i t y h o l d s always, i t follows t h a t f o r all
p(u+v) = p ( u ) + p(v)
.
u , v E L+
As
We now t u r n our a t t e n t i o n t o a b s t r a c t Lm-spaces (AM-spaces). examples we mentioned a l r e a d y t h e space of type spaces of type
=
C(X)
with
compact and
X
and a l s o t h e
Lm(X,u)
t h e uniform norm. Some
p
f u r t h e r examples follow. (i) and
i s a given p o i n t i n
xo (ii)
X
.
.
xo,xb
given points i n
( i i i ) For any i n f i n i t e p o i n t set Riesz space of a l l r e a l (x:lf(x)I>E)
f
on
x
# xn
and
l i m f(xn) = 0
supremum norm i s an AM-space.
X
, we
, where Xo
and
X
define
as
f
E co(X)
{xn} n
+
-. of
again
E
is
X
i s a given r e a l
co(X)
such t h a t , f o r e v e r y
X
i s f i n i t e . Note t h a t
e x i s t s an a t most c o u n t a b l e s u b s e t all
i s compact and Hausdorff
X
C(Xlxo,x~,Xo) = {f:f€C(X),f(xO)=AO f ( x b ) }
compact Hausdorff w i t h number
, where
C(X(xo) = (f:fEC(X),f(xo)=O)
t o be t h e
,
> 0
the s e t
h o l d s i f and only i f t h e r e X
such t h a t
The space
Note t h a t t h e norm i n
f(x) = 0
with the
c (X)
0 co(X)
for
i s o r d e r con-
tinuous. The p o s i t i v e element
e
i n t h e n o m e d Riesz space
L = L
P
is called
Ch.
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
17,§1183
a strong norm u n i t i n
if
L
p(e) = 1
and
p(f)
It f o l l o w s immediately t h a t a s t r o n g norm u n i t
A
o t h e r words, t h e i d e a l
g e n e r a t e d by
463
1
5
5
.
e
is a strung unit; i n
e
satisfies
e
If1
implies A
= L
. Also,
any
normed Riesz space can have a t most one s t r o n g norm u n i t . I n a space of type
or
Lw(X,u)
t h e f u n c t i o n i d e n t i c a h l y one i s a s t r o n g norm
C(X)
-
u n i t . The spaces mentioned above i n t h e examples ( i ) , ( i i ) and ( i i i ) , w i t h t h e uniform norm, do n o t p o s s e s s a s t r o n g norm u n i t . Also f o r s p a c e s of type
P
I n t h e l a s t theorem we have seen t h a t i n an AL-space satisfies
p(u+v) = p(u) + p(v)
t h e norm
L
and
L
i s an AL-
space, then
is an AM-space w i t h t h e p r o p e r t y t h a t p*($v$) =
L*
i n f ($,$)
=
0
for a l l positive
. Furthermore
THEOREM 118.4. I f
and
$
we show t h a t
$
in
L*
,
and n o t only i f
L* p o s s e s s e s a s t r o n g norm u n i t .
i s an AL-space, then L*
L
,
u
s h a l l prove now t h a t i f
inf(u,v) = 0
v
p
f o r a l l p o s i t i v e elements
. We
and n o t only i f
= max(p*($),p*($))
,
do n o t p o s s e s s a s t r o n g norm u n i t ( u n l e s s i n very
L (X,p)
t r i v a l cases).
1 5 p <
i s an A??-space with
the property that
and
p
strong norm unit
$o , defined by
PROOF. For any
$
f E L
. Furthermore
L*
in
for a22 p o s i t i v e
the space L* has a f o r a22 f E Lo
$O(f) = p(f+) - p(f-)
we d e f i n e
$O(f) = p(f+)
-
p(f-)
. It
follows
from
+
( f + d + + fand t h e a d d i t i v i t y of p{ff+g)+} So
p
-
g- = ( f + g ) - + f
+
+ g
that p{(f+g)-}
$ O ( f + g ) = $ O ( f ) + $o(g)
$ O ( a f ) = a$ ( f ) 0
+
. From -
-
p(f-)
+ p(g+)
-
p(g-)
,
the d e f i n i t i o n i t i s evident t h a t
a 2 0
for a l l real
$ J O ( - f ) = p{(-f)+}
= P(f+)
. Furthermore
p{(-f)-}
=
-{P(f+)-P(f-)}
=
.
.
RIESZ SPACES WITH p-ADDITIVE NORM
464
Hence
$JO(af) = a$ (f)
$o is a positive linear functional on L
already that
$o
. Thus we have proved . For the norm of
for all real numbers a
0
Ch. 17,11181
we f;nd that
Also, if j , E L *
for all u
2
. Hence
0
$o
far that
p*(j,>
and
is a
5
,
1
,
1
then p * ( i J I I )
SO
. It follows from what we strong norm unit in L* . 191 5 0 ,
It remains to prove that p*($v$) For this purpose, let
$,j,
2
=
have proved
max{p*($),p*($)}
$,I) t 0
for $
0 be given. If one at least of
so
.
and j ,
is
the null functional, the proof i s trivial. Hence, we may assume that p*($>
#
0
p*(j,)
and
Similarly $
5
# 0
.
. Since
~ * ( j , ) . $ ~ Hence
p*C$/p*($)}
5 1
, we
get
$ 5 P*($).$~
, which
$ v j , 5 max{p*(+),p*($)}.$o
.
implies
that
The inequality in the converse direction is trivial. The question may be put forward if for any normed Riesz space L
(not
necessarily a Banach lattice) with p-additive norm (for some p satisfying 1 2 p < m ) it remains true that the norm is p-superadditive, i.e.,
.
Similarly, we ask if in a space for all u,v E L+ pp(u+v) 2 pp(u) + pp(v) with --additive norm the equality ~ ( u w )= max{p(u),p(v)} holds for all u,v E L+
. The answer is affirmative.
THEOREM 118.5.
norm
p
for some
holds f o r a l l
u,v E L+ L
L is a normed Riesz space uith p-additive
p satisfying
u,v E L+
holds for all (ii) If
(i) If
. For .
p
1 = 1
p <
5
m
, the
, then
equality
pP(u+v)
t pP(u)
is a normed Riesz space with -additive norm
~(uvv) = max{p(u),p(v)l
holds for a12
u,v E L+
.
+ pp(v)
p(u+v) = P ( U ) + ~ ( v ) p
, then
465
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
Ch. 1 7 , 9 1 1 9 1
PROOF. (i) The Banach bidual L** is norm complete with p-additive norm (Theorem 118.1)
more, L
and, therefore, L** is an abstract L -space. FurtherP is embedded in L** with preservation of the norm. The result
follows then from Theorem 118.3. (ii) The Banach dual L* norm in L**
in L**
is an AL-space. Hence, by Theorem 118.4,
has the desired property. Once again, since L
the
is embedded
as a Riesz subspace with preservation of the norm, the norm in
L has the desired property.
11 9. Semi- M-spaces
It was shown in the preceding section that if L space with -additive norm (in particular, if L
is a normed Riesz
is an AM-space),
then the
Banach dual L* is an AL-space. In the present section we shall deal with a particular kind of normed Riesz spaces L possessing the property that the band
in L*
L*
functionals on
(consisting of all norm bounded singular linear
L ) is an AL-space, although L*
itself is not necessarily
an AL-space. We recall for this purpose that the order dual L" arbitrary Riesz space L where
is the direct
sum of
the bands L :
of an
and
LL
,
L z consists of all integrals (sequentially order continuous linear
functionals on
L ) and L"
Hence, for any
$ E L"
$ = $c + $,
with
oc
,
is the disjoint complement of
L :
.
in L"
there exists a uniquely determined decomposition
E L"
and
0, E
L :
. The ebements of
LL are called
the singular linear functionals. We shall now need a certain property of these singular linear functionals. This property was actually mentioned already in Exercise 90.12. THEOREM 119.1.
i n t e g r a l component
Hence, $
For any given $c o f
$
i s singular ( i . e . , $
e x i s t s a sequence
0 < u
+
u
$ 2 0
in
L"
and
u 2 0
i n L , the
satisfies
= $s
in L
I i f and only i f f o r any such t h a t
0
$(un) <
PROOF. Denote the right hand side of (1) by $ (u)
E > E
0
there
for all
. Evidently, we
n have
.
SEMI-M-SPACES
466
. We
0 5 $ (u) 5 $(u)
t o see t h a t
inequality, take
> 0
E
l i m $(wn) < $,(u+v) v
=w-u n n n for a l l n
+
forall
$,(u) =
.
O s u + u , O < v 4 v n
s l i m $ ( un ) + l i i n $(vn)
+ $r(v)
$r p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on L
m
$,(u)
= C1
sequence
$r(vn)
. Now,
/
let
, choose
(vnk:k=1,2,
< $r(vn) + ~
and
and
u + v n n
= W
n
=
. Thus
0,
i s a d d i t i v e on
L+
,
can be extended i n t h e obvious manner a s a
. For
t h e proof t h a t
$r
i s countably
we n o t e f i r s t t h a t , by d e f i n i t i o n ,
L+
u E L+
f o r every
i s easy
the inverse
,
E
$r(u) + $ r ( v ) 5 $r(u+v)
from which i t follows t h a t a d d i t i v e on
. It
L+
. For
a sequence
l i m $(wn) < $r(u+v) +
and t h e r e f o r e
u,v E L+
0 s w 4 u+v s a t i s f y i n g n Now, by Theorem 1 5 . 5 ( i ) , i f un = inf(u,wn)
and
E
i s a d d i t i v e on
for a l l
+ $,(v)
n,then
. Hence
4,
show f i r s t t h a t
$ r ( ~ + v ) 5 $,(u)
Ch. 17,51193
...)
u = C
a number
wn
I
v
n
E
in > 0
L+
. For
L+ such t h a t
in
.2Now~ l e t
m
t h e proof t h a t
every
C k v nk
Cp=I Ct=l v j k
=
. For
for a l l
.
,
n
vn
=
there exists a
and
Ck $(vnk) <
. Then
n
0 5 wn 4 u
and $(wn) < C . 4 ( v . ) + E f o r every n It follows t h a t $,(u) J r J The i n v e r s e i n e q u a l i t y i s e v i d e n t . It has been shown t h u s t h a t p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on by
$
. Equivalently,
follows t h a t j o r i z e d by
($c)r
that
0,
($ ) = c r
p
. The
. Hence
space
...)
dent t h a t i f L = 1
L
u1,u2 E L+
(vn:n=1,2,
with p
0,
5 $,
p(ulvu2)
a d d i t i v e on
L
L+
such t h a t
. It
O S $ ~5 $
i s t h e l a r g e s t p o s i t i v e i n t e g r a l ma-
i s majorized by
. It
$
,
$
. The
t h e d e f i n i t i o n of
$
same d e f i n i t i o n i m p l i e s a l s o
follows t h a t
$c = $r
.
i s a normed Riesz space; t h e norm w i l l be denoted
L
i s c a l l e d a semi-M-space i f it has t h e p r o p e r t y t h a t
with
and f o r any sequence
p ( u l ) = p(u2) = 1
u1 v u2 5 vn J. 0
i s @=-addv ite
i s a semi-M-space, that
$c
$c
i s majorized by
Assume now t h a t for a l l
(because
$ ) . Since
implies t h a t
by
i s an i n t e g r a l on
$
$ r < $c
, countably
L
sC.6 ( v . ) . 4 r J 1s a $r and majorized
l i m p(vn) 5 1
we have
(in particular, i f
L
. Also,
i f t h e norm
p
i s evi-
i s a n AM-space),
because i n t h i s c a s e it follows from = 1
. It
then
p(u ) = p(u ) =
1 2 is o r d e r continuous, t h e n
L
46 7
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
Ch. 1 7 , 8 1 1 9 1
is a semi-M-space, because in this case it follows from vn J. 0 that = 0
lim p(vn)
. There are
less obvious examples of semi-M-spaces; some of
these (the Orlicz spaces) will be presented in section 131. The semi-Mspaces are characterized by the following property. THEOREM 119.2. The normed Riesz space L
if the band Lg i n the Banach dual
in L
and
will be denoted by
L*
,
+ P*($~)
t p*($,) E
p(u ) 1
>
u
=
$2
p
and
respectively. We have to
p*
=
p(u ) 2
=
1
E
. Then
$ = $, + $,
. Writing
for all n
and
u
n
) < 1 + ~ for all
Hence
p*(o1+O2)
that P * ( $ , + $ ~ )
2 2
in L+
2
u E L+
v
2
and w
0
n
(l+c)
2 no
-1
2
)2
such
. Hence, such that
=
=
such that
n we get
for all
{P*($~)+P*($,)-~E}
.
$ E L:
u-w for all n , we have u1 u2 n in view of the hypothesis that L is a
n
. For these values of
P*($~) + p*($,)
5
in L
4 u
= u > v J. 0 , s o lim p(v ) 5 1 n n semi-M-space. Therefore, there exists a natural number no p(v
1
and
by the last theorem, there exists a sequence 0
$(wn) <
then p * ( $ +$
the inverse inequality being evident. For the proof,
and
v u2
,
are positive elements of L z
0 be given. There exists elements u1
let that
Set u
and
is an AL-space.
is a semi-M-space. As before, the norms
PROOF. Assume first that L prove that if
L*
is a semi-M-space if and o n l y
E
> 0
, which
implies
holds. It has been shown thus that P *
is 1-additive on Lz Since L : is norm complete (being a band in the Banach space L* ), it follows that LE is an AL-space. For the proof in the converse direction we assume that L a semi-M-space and we shall prove that u , , u 2 E L+ u1 v u2
2
and a sequence vn 4 0
with
(v,)
lim p(v
Lz in L+ such that
) = a > 1
fails to be
is not an AL-space. There exist
. By
p ( u I ) = p(u2)
=
1
and
the Hahn-Banach theorem there
Ch. 17,81191
SEMI- M-SPACES
468
e x i s t s f o r every
n
p(vn) = JIn(vn)
. Then
The u n i t b a l l
B = ($:p*($)~l)
of accumulation
$,
(0),
gy. The sequence
$o
JI, E L*
an element =
lJInl
p*($,)
of
i s compact i n t h e weak s t a r topolo-
L*
B
, so
t h i s sequence has a p o i n t
every weak s t a r neigborhood of
i n f i n i t e l y many p o i n t s of t h e sequence). I n p a r t i c u l a r , i f E
> 0
a r e a r b i t r a r y , t h e neighborhood
i n f i n i t e l y many $,(u)
$o
2
E B
0
,
.
so
0,
. Since
P*($~) 5 1
.
and l e t
> 0
t 0
$,(u)
This h o l d s f o r a l l
u t 0
{$:
n
E
I $ ( U ) - $ ~ ( U ) I <E)
for a l l
, so
This i m p l i e s t h a t
theref ore
Now, f i x
and
= 1
satisfies
i s contained i n (i.e.,
such t h a t
4,
n 2
0
, it
$o c o n t a i n s u E L+
and
contains
follows t h a t
. Furthermore
0 5 c$ O(vn ) 5 p(vn)
we have
, and
be given. I n t r o d u c i n g t h e weak s t a r open neigh-
borhood
.
w e have
$ E U f o r i n f i n i t e l y many v a l u e s of m Since m t n i m p l i e s m $m(vn) 2 $m(vm) = p(v ) , i t f o l l o w s t h a t p(vm) 5 c$o(vn) + E f o r t h o s e m m t n f o r which $ E U Hence m
.
l i m p(vm) c $o(vn) +
(3)
E
. .
T h e r e f o r e , i n view of (2) and ( 3 ) , lim $ (v ) = l i m p ( v ) = a Observe now O n n t h a t $o = $c + $ s w i t h 0 5 $= E LE and 0 5 $ E L* Furthermore, l i m $ (v ) = 0 on account of v J- 0 , s o c n u 1 v u2 t v f o r a l l n , i t follows t h a t n
Let now of
Qs
osl
s
s
.
l i m $s(vn) = a > 1
. Since
be t h e minimal p o s i t i v e l i n e a r e x t e n s i o n of t h e r e s t r i c t i o n
t o the principal ideal
A
P
generated b y t h e element
p = (u 1-u 2 ) +
,
69'1
d S33VdS- 'I L3WILSBV
[611
§'f I ' q 3
I t i s easy t o s e e t h a t
if
f o r a f i x e d constant
A
complete, i . e . ,
in
I.
L
sup f
and
p(fn) S A
for a l l
E L ) . I t follows t h a t
d i v i d e the i n t e r v a l
n
and
i s norm
L
is
L
i n t o t e n equal i n t e r v a l s
[;,11
[:,;I
i n t o one hundred
'
ui =
u = u1 v u2
:j
3 ?xEi
u(x)
=
23
and
for a l l
,
n
vn = uxFn
,
so
('E. 1 , j :j
E2 = U.
1,j
h > 0
f o r any
. Then
(i=1,2)
satisfies
Fn = CO,n-ll
and
1 , and
p(E ) = u(E2) = 1
.
...,
,j \ E i ,
E l = Ui
p(u.) S I
for a l l v1 = u
i t i s evident t h a t
x
even
1
J *
we have
for
i
. For
4 0
u t v
and
l i m p(v )
and
= 1,2
n = 1,2
.
let
Since
p(vn) =
does not hold. There-
1
S
,
i s not a semi-M-space.
fore, L
EXERCISE 119.4. Let
L
be the space introduced i n the l a s t exampl?.
i s not a semi-M-space,
L
Since
n
, and s o on. Generally, d i v i d e E 2 , 1 , * - * ,E 2,100 i n t o lon equal i n t e r v a l s E (j=l, lon) Let n,j
~2-~,2-"+'1
$
then
possessing t h e s e q u e n t i a l weak
(from l e f t t o r i g h t ) , then divide
E l . l ~ * * * 1.10 ~ E equal i n t e r v a l s
Now, l e t
0 5 f
,
L
i s a Banach function space. For the proof t h a t
L
not a semi-M-space,
Then
i s a norm i n
p
Fatou property ( i . e . ,
=
Ch. 17,§1191
SEMI- M-SPACES
470
i t follows t h a t
Lz
contains o t h e r func-
t i o n a l s besides the n u l l f u n c t i o n a l . But then, s i n c e the inverse a n n i h i l a t o r '(Lf) La
Lt
of
satisfies
f E L
such t h a t
If[ t u
( i ) Show t h a t i f in
'(L;)
i s properly contained i n
,
C0,ll
then
f
( i i ) Show t h a t tends t o zero a s HINT:
1; .
over
[O,ll 4 0
0 < h
S
h
implies satisfies
La
i s t h e s e t of a l l
p(un) 4 0
.
f(x) = 0
on some i n t e r v a l
.
vanish on
JA
C0,6]
and observe t h a t f E L
. Furthermore,
. Set
by Theorem 102.8, i t i s evident t h a t recall that
c o n s i s t s of a l l
La
f
undu
( i i ) Let f i r s t If1 t u
. We
h
-1
f E L
f o r which
h
and l e t
If[ t u
4 0
[0,61 If Idu
h C 0
( i ) Let
p(un) < - 6-I
C 0
f E L
E La
= La
L
f = f
1
satisfy let
+ f2
E
h > 0
, where
h lo IfIdp
-I
. f
undp 4 0
1
since
+
0
as
Then
h-'
1;
= f
on
CO,hcl
n
f
. Prove
h J. 0
If Idu < and
that
i s sumable
E
and l e t for fl = 0
Ch. 17,51201
elsewhere. S i m i l a r l y , decompose 5
p(fl) <
<
E
for
n
u
for a l l
s u f f i c i e n t l y large.
Conversely, l e t
u
=
that
and
f E La
I f l x En
u
as
n
p(un2) J 0
E
n
functions
47 1
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
.
) < nl by p a r t ( i ) , we f i n d t h a t p ( u n ) <
Then, f o r
I
satisfy
fl t u
n
= unl + un2 , Since
h J. 0 and E n n c 0 , so p(un)
=
p(u
C0.h;
. It
c o
,
the
follows
120. Representation by a space of measurable f u n c t i o n s We r e c a l l some r e s u l t s from Chapter 1 concerning Boolean a l g e b r a s . Let
is a distributive lattice
be a Boolean a l g e b r a , t h a t i s t o say, A
A
with n u l l element ( s m a l l e s t element) and u n i t element ( l a r g e s t element) such
a E A
t h a t every element
has a complement
e
u n i t element a r e denoted by ment
a'
of
ideal
P
a
A
implies
a l v a2 E I
at
and
i s denoted by
a2
P
i s not contained i n
and
belongs t o
.
For any
a'
A
the s e t s
{PIa
a
. This
a3
A
P
5
I
of
a3 E I
. The
a F: A
topology i n
. The
i s an i d e a l i f
A
implies al
a
4
E I
a2 E P
. The
t h a t one
s e t of a l l proper prime i d e a l s
t h e s e t of a l l {PIa
P
A
. The
. The base
P E P
s e t of a l l
such t h a t {PIa
is
s e t s a r e open and
P which i s both open and closed i s one
i s based on t h e formulas
a s well a s on t h e f a c t t h a t i f such t h a t
element and t h e
a v a' = e
and
= 63
i s denoted by
P
closed. C o w e r s e l y , any subset of
a3 F: A
. The n u l l
i s c a l l e d order complete i f every non-empty subset of
A
a base f o r t h e hull-kernel
Of
a'
r e s p e c t i v e l y ; the (unique) comple-
i s c a l l e d a prime i d e a l i f i t follows from
a t l e a s t of in
e
has a supremum and an infimum. The subset
al,a2 E I
a
i s determined by
a
Boolean a l g e b r a A
and
a2
=
8
{P} c {P}a , then t h e r e e x i s t s an element a2 1 a v a = a l , and t h e r e f o r e t h e s e t
and
{P} and {PI i s {PIa3 . The space P i s a1 a? compact and Hausdorff i n i t s hull-kernel topology. Tne space P i s a l s o t h e o r e t i c d i f f e r e n c e of
t o t a l l y disconnected ( i - e . , t h e topology has a base c o n s i s t i n g of s e t s t h a t are open a s w e l l a s c l o s e d ) . I f
A
i s o r d e r complete, t h e hull-kernel
472
REPRESENTATION BY MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
P is extremally disconnected (i.e. the closure of any open
topology of set i s open). =
0
-
. We
sup a
To see this, let 0
be open,
prove that the closure 0
-
.
so
0
of
0 = UT {PI Let aT is exactly {PI ?O
of
0
-
{PIa
0
is contained in 0
A
-
is contained in the complement of
is of the form Uy {PIa
,
(sup aT) = 0
with
i.e?, a
A
a .a
a
A
V
T
= 0
{PIa
0
.
0
Since
-
The complement of 0
for all
= 0
T
.
Hence
(we use here that i n a Boolean alge-
bra the infinite distributive law holds, cf. Exercise 4.13).
It follows
.
{PI is contained in the complement of {PI aV a0 An important example of a Boolean algebra A is an algebra (or field)
from a
A
. a
a =
.
{PI , it is sufficient to aO or, equivalently, that thecomplement
is evidently contained in the closed set
show that
a
Ch. 17,11201
that
= 8
of subsets of a fixed set X
, partially
element of A
. According
any Boolean algebra A
ordered by inclusion. In this case and the set X
the empty set is the null element of A
itself is the unit
to Stone's representation theorem (Theorem 6.6)
can be represented as an algebra of subsets of some
P is the set of all proper prime ideals in A , then A is lattice isomorphic with the algebra of subsets of P of the
fixed set. Precisely, if form
1
{PIa = (PEP: a not contained in P
j -
The isomorphism is given by A
a
c-f
{P}a
.
of
Note that the null element 8
corresponds with the empty set and the unit element of
A
corresponds
{PI,
E
of aZ1 subsets
A
and l e t
A
{PIa of
P
be isomorphically represented by t h e algebra
. Furthermore,
i n t o t h e non-negative numbers such that v(a va 1 1 2
Then t h e mapping
=
v(a ) + v(a 1
v
a,
A
l e t v be a mapping of a2 = 8 implies
A
.
2
v may be regarded j u s t as well as a mapping from
t h e non-negative nwnbers such t h a t The f u n c t i o n
n
P be the s e t of a l l proper p r i m e i d e a l s i n the
LEMMA 120.1. Let Boolean algebra
1
v
E
into
i s a f i n i t e t y a d d i t i v e measure on E
i s even a o-additive measure on
E
.
.
Ch. 1 7 , § 1 2 0 1
PROOF. By taking
+
v(a2)
element
,
a3 E A
v
i n the formula
a l = a2 = 8'
v(0) = 0
we get
= v(a2) + v(a3)
that i f
473
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
such t h a t
, which
. Furthermore, a,
a2 = 0
A
v(a,)
implies
1
a
v(a ) 1
v a
. It
2
,
t h e r e e x i s t s an
=
al
a2 5 a l
if and
5
v(a va ) = v ( a , ) +
i s now regarded as a non-negative f u n c t i o n on
a f i n i t e l y a d d i t i v e measure on
. For
E
. Hence
v(a,) =
follows immediately
t h e proof t h a t
v
,
E
then
is
v
i s a-additive,
. Then, s i n c e {PIa i s compact and a l l {PI {PIa = U y [P) an an a r e open, t h e r e e x i s t s a number no such t h a t {PIa = C y { P I , i.e., an Hence, i f a l l an a r e d i s j o i n t , then a = '8 f o r a l l n > no
assume t h a t
.
v({PIa) = E p o v({P} If
v
i s a non-negative
'
an)
= C;
v(IPIa
i s c a l l e d a s t a t e on
v
E
,will
v
,
v*(V)
and the subset
for a l l
W c
P
v
be the
of
V
P
the e x t e r i o r
i s defined by
V
of
, where
P i s c a l l e d v-measurable i f
Vc
denotes the s e t t h e o r e t i c d i f f e r e n c e
f o r these s e t s t h e e x t e r i o r measure v
and
A,P,E
be extended now by means of the f a m i l i a r Carathsodory
r e c a l l the following f a c t s . A l l s e t s i n the algebra measure
having
defined f o r a l l s e t s i n the
extension procedure. We r e c a l l t h a t f o r any subset measure
A
i s not i d e n t i c a l l y zero, then
A ( c f . Exercise 4.18). Let
same as i n t h e l a s t lemma. The measure algebra
).
f u n c t i o n on t h e Boolean a l g e b r a
the p r o p e r t i e s described i n the lemma and
v
n
. Every
v*
E
P-V
. We
a r e measurable and
i s the same a s t h e o r i g i n a l
s e t of e x t e r i o r measure zero i s measurable. The measurable
s e t s form a a-algebra, and t h e r e f o r e f i n i t e o r countable unions and i n t e r s e c t i o n s of measurable s e t s a r e measurable. I n p a r t i c u l a r , any s e t
v
, with Vn E E f o r a l l n , i s measurable. S e t s of t h i s type a r e I n sometimes c a l l e d a-sets. I t follows t h a t any s e t W = fl" W , with W a I n a-set f o r a l l n , i s a l s o measurable. S e t s of t h i s type a r e sometimes c a l l e d 0
= Urn V
6- s e t s .
I t i s an important f a c t f o r many a p p l i c a t i o n s t h a t every measurable
s e t i s t h e s e t t h e o r e t i c d i f f e r e n c e of a a - s e t and a s e t of e x t e r i o r 6
Ch. 17, 1203
REPRESENTATION BY MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
474
measure z e r o . It i s customary t o w r i t e set
v(V)
i n s t e a d of
i s measurable and t o c a l l t h i s t h e measure of
V
e x t e r i o r measure of
V
.
v*(V)
i f the
i n s t e a d of t h e
V
I n p a r t i c u l a r , s e t s of e x t e r i o r measure z e r o a r e
c a l l e d s e t s of measure z e r o . The measurable s e t s v-almost e q u a l i f t h e s e t t h e o r e t i c d i f f e r e n c e s measure z e r o . I n t h i s c a s e w e s h a l l w r i t e
V
-
and
V
V-W
. The
W
a r e s a i d t o be
W
and
a r e of
W-V
relation t o be
v-almost e q u a l i s a n e q u i v a l e n c e r e l a t i o n . Under c e r t a i n a d d i t i o n a l c o n d i t i o n s on t h e Boolean a l g e b r a function
v
on
P
s e t s of
i t t u r n s o u t t h a t t h e c o l l e c t i o n of
A
i s e s s e n t i a l l y n o t much l a r g e r than t h e c o l l e c t i o n
of t h e form
. More
{PIa
t h a t t h e Boolean a l g e b r a
. These
E
v
tisfies
a
a
to
J 8
,
by
v ( b T ) J. 0
b
,
. Hence,
v(aT) J 0
then
a = sup a
i f now
i s o r d e r con-
(aT:T€{T})
t i n u o u s i n t h e s e n s e t h a t i f t h e downwards d i r e c t e d s e t ed, then
a
A
bT = 8
and
a
v
and
A,P,E
P
a
= a ) , we have
v(aT) = v(a) - v(bT)
and t h e r e f o r e
lemma, showing t h a t e v e r y open s u b s e t of LEMMA 120.2. Let
v bT
+
. We
v(a)
i n A sa-
i s upwards d i r e c t -
(aT)
e x i s t s and, d e n o t i n g t h e complement of
(i.e.,
of sets
E
a d d i t i o n a l c o n d i t i o n s are
i s o r d e r complete and t h a t
A
sub-
s e t i s t h e n v-almost
p r e c i s e l y , any v-measurable
e q u a l t o a s e t from t h e c o l l e c t i o n
and t h e
A
v-measurable
relative bT J 8
, so
f i r s t prove a
i s v-measurable.
be as before, and assume furthermore
A
is order complete and v i s order continuous in t h e sense a s exThen v*(O) = v(O-) plained above. Now, l e t 0 be an open subset of P that
0
where
-
denotes t h e closure of
exists a set since
V
V
c 0 c
€ E
such t h a t
VE c 0
v
0-
0- w i t h
"(o-)
-
. Furthermore,
0
"(VE) <
and
.
f o r any
A
i s o r d e r complete, t h e h u l l - k e r n e l the closure
as w e l l a s c l o s e d . I t f o l l o w s t h a t E A
. In
o t h e r words, 0
makes s e n s e t o w r i t e
u(O-)
t h e topology. The open set
-
0
-
0
-
. The
0
there
i s measurable.
topology i n
of any open s e t
i s of t h e form
i s one of t h e s e t s from
0
0
. Hence,
,
E
extremally disconnected, i.e., a.
E
measurable and
i t follows from a f a m i l i a r theorem i n measure theory t h a t PROOF. S i n c e
>
E
v(VE) > v*(O) -
and
E
sets i n the a l g e b r a
i s t h e r e f o r e o f t h e form
{P}
. Ta0 his
E
0
P
is
i s open
f o r some shows t h a t i t
form a b a s e f o r 0 = ti
{PI
. Note
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
17,11201
Ch.
t h a t any f i n i t e union of s e t s
{PIa
475
i s again of the form
adding a l l these f i n i t e unions t o t6e s e t of a l l
0
s i t u a t i o n t h a t we may assume t h a t
0
d i r e c t e d and sup v({P} find t h a t
-
.
)
a,
{PI
=
for
aO Since e v i d e n t l y
v(o-)
= V*(O)
a
UT {PI
=
. aT It
= sup a
v(O-)
Z
v*(O)
{PI aT
with
, we
a r e i n the
(aT:T'E{?))
follows t h a t
t v({P}
a,
. Hence,
{PIa
upwards
v(O-)
=
for a l l
)
T
, we
0.
= sup v {PI
a7
A l l r e s u l t s t o be proved follow now immediately.
P
Since
i s compact i f and only i f i t i s
P
i s compact, any s u b s e t of
closed.The u-algebra generated by the compact s e t s ( i . e . ,
the smallest
u-algebra containing a l l compact s e t s ) i s t h e r e f o r e the same a s the ualgebra generated by the open s e t s . Borel sets i n
P
.
The s e t s i n t h i s a-algebra a r e t h e
Since every open s e t is v-measurable by the l a s t lemma,
i t follows t h a t t h e Borel s e t s form a a-subalgebra of t h e a-algebra of a l l v-measurable s e t s . As promised, we prove now t h a t every v-measurable s e t
i s v-almost equal t o a s e t i n the a l g e b r a open-closed
E
,
i.e.,
v-almost equal t o an
set.
THEOREM 120.3. Let
A
be an order co?rplete Boolean algebra, P
the s e t
o f a l l proper prime i d e a l s i n A , E the alqebra of a l l subsets o f P of the form {PIa ( e q u i v a l e n t l y , the algebra of a l l open-closed s e t s i n t h e hull-kernel topology i n P ) and v an order continuous f u n c t i o n on A Then ( a s already proved) P . The measure v has the property t h a t every v-measurable s e t i s v-almost equal t o a s e t i n the algebra E . Hence, i f as usual we i d e n t i f y v-almost equal s e t s , we may say t h a t E i s a c t u a l l y the c o l l e c t i o n of a l l v-measurable s e t s . s a t i s f y i n g the conditions mentioned i n Lemma 120.1. v
i s a measure i n
PROOF. L e t
W =
n"I
(with
W
V
be an a r b i t r a r y v-measurable s e t . There e x i s t s a a o-set f o r every
Wn
n r e t i c d i f f e r e n c e of
W
and a s e t of measure zero. Hence
v-almost equal; i n n o t a t i o n (Wn:n=l,2,
fig,
Wk
...)
, which
n ) such t h a t
V -W
. It
V
and
W
are
may be assumed t h a t the sequence
i s descending, because otherwise we replace i s a l s o a o-set.
a -set 6
i s t h e s e t theo-
V
It follows t h a t
by
Wn
v(Wn) J. v(W)
.
WA =
Every
n'
Ch. 1 7 , 9 1 2 0 1
REPRESENTATION BY MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
416
i s t h e union of (countably many) open-closed s e t s , so every
v(Wn) = v(Wn)
I n view of t h e preceding lemma we have then t h a t
The sequence of open-closed s e t s
-
Wn
i s descending. The s e t
Wi
i s open.
,
S =
i s t h e r e f o r e c l o s e d , and
n"I
Wn
.
i v(S)
V(W;1)
and so
-
.
Hence v(W) = v(S) and W = fl" W c n" W- = S , s o W S Now, a s we I n I n have s e e n , any open s e t and i t s c l o s u r e have t h e same measure. Taking complements, i t follows t h a t any c l o s e d s e t
and i t s i n t e r i o r
F
int F
have t h e same measure. Furthermore, s i n c e t h e c l o s u r e of any open s e t i s open-closed,
t h e i n t e r i o r of any c l o s e d s e t i s a l s o open-closed.
this t o the s e t S open-closed. that
V
-
, we
get
v(S)
=
, so
v ( i n t S)
S
-
int S
Combining now a l l r e s u l t s , we conclude from
int S
with
int S
V
an open-closed s e t .
Applying
- - with
W
int S
S
int S
The measure theory as developed above w i l l b e a p p l i e d i n t h e f o l l o w i n g s i t u a t i o n . Let a l l bands i n
22.8). K2
a r e bands, t h e n
g e n e r a t e d by of
{O}
K
K
i s t h e band
K
1
K1
A
K2 = K1
. In particular,
U K2
i f and only i f
K1
and
n K1
K2
A
K
P
p r o p e r prime i d e a l s i n sets
K
. The
i s e q u a l t o t h e n u l l element
. Assuming
now t h a t
v
L
. Accor-
i s l a t t i c e isomorphic w i t h t h e
, where P
i s t h e s e t of a l l
isomorphism i s d e f i n e d by
K
++
{ P I K a r e e x a c t l y t h e open-closed s e t s i n t h e h u l l - k e r n e l
P
K1
i s t h e band
a r e d i s j o i n t bands i n
{ P I K of
Boolean a l g e b r a of a l l s u b s e t s
K2
itself. If
L
K 1 v K2
and
K2
d i n g t o t h e Stone r e p r e s e n t a t i o n theorem
of
of
g e n e r a t e d by t h e n u l l
{O}
i s t h e space
K
and t h e u n i t element of
L
K
i s an o r d e r complete Boolean a l g e b r a ( c f . Theorems 2 2 . 7 and
The n u l l element of
element of and
b e a Dedekind complete Riesz space. The c o l l e c t i o n
L L
{P}K ; t h e topology
i s a non-negative r e a l f u n c t i o n on
K
such
that
0
v K1vK2
for disjoint
KI,K2
= v(K,)
and
+ v(K2)
v(KT) i 0
for
KT
+
{O}
,
i t f o l l o w s from t h e
Ch. 17,81201
ABSTRACT L -SPACES
r e s u l t s proved s o f a r t h a t v
p
the s e t
477
P
may be regarded a s a 0-additve measure i n
such t h a t modulo s e t s of v-measure zero t h e c o l l e c t i o n of a l l
procedure
v
of a f u n c t i o n
p
f o r some e
. By
in
i s simply defined t o be equal t o
v({P} ) K
of t h i s kind i s obtained i f
satisfying
1
5
Theorem 118.2 the space e
K
in
by
order p r o j e c t i o n on t h e band where
i s the norm i n
p
v!K
d i s j o i n t and
L
) J. 0
v(K)
i s an a b s t r a c t L -space
L
f i r s t that
L
P has a weak u n i t
i s Dedekind complete and the norm
L
i s o r d e r continuous. Every band
L
the component of
K2
. Assume
p <
. In this . An example
{PIK
v-measurable s e t s i s e x a c t l y the c o l l e c t i o n of a l l s e t s
,we
K
i s a p r o j e c t i o n band; denoting
k = Q e , whete QK i s t h e K For every band K , l e t V(K) = pP(QKe),
k
K . . Then
have
v(K VK ) = v(K ) + V(K2) f o r K1 and 1 2 1 KT 4 10) ; the f i r s t immediately from t h e
for
d e f i n i t i o n of an a b s t r a c t L -space and the l a s t because KT C { O } P e 4 0 and p i s order continuous. Transplanting t h e r e f o r e v
QKT
p
implies t o the
P by d e f i n i n g v({P}K ) = v(K) f o r every K , we o b t a i n a o-additive measure v i n P such t h a t , modulo s e t s of measure zero,
subsets
{PIK of
every v-measurable s e t i s one of t h e s e t s
{PIK
. Since
x{PIK i s t h e c h a r a c t e r i s t i c f u n c t i o n of
where
correspondence between t h e components functions
QKe of
preserves the L -norm.
x{P},
P
{PIK e
, the
one-one
and t h e c h a r a c t e r i s t i c
I t i s now a n a t u r a l question t o ask
whether t h e r e e x i s t s a norm preserving one-one corresponding between t h e elements of
L
and those of t h e space
Lp(P,v)
, an
extension of the one
j u s t e s t a b l i s h e d . Such an extension does indeed e x i s t and t h e r e a r e s e v e r a l methods t o prove t h i s . For t h e method we s h a l l use i t i s necessary t o e s t a b l i s h f i r s t some f a c t s about t h e subspace of combinations of components of t h e weak u n i t
L
formed by the f i n i t e l i n e a r
e ; we s h a l l c a l l these e-step
elements. Once again, l e t weak u n i t
K
e
. All
bands
w i l l be denoted by
ion on
K
sup(kl,k2)
. Note and
combination :1
L
k
that i f inf(k aiki
be a Dedekind complete Riesz space possessing a K
a r e p r o j e c t i o n bands; t h e component of
. Hence kl
e
in
k = Q e , where QK i s the band p r o j e c t K and k2 a r e components of e , then
.
k ) are again components of e Any l i n e a r 1’ 2 of components of e (with r e a l c o e f f i c i e n t s ) i s c a l l e d
Ch. 1 7 , 5 1 2 0 1
REPRESENTATION BY MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
478
an e - s t e p element. I f a l l C y ki
=
vn k = e ) and i f a l l a . a r e m u t u a l l y d i f f e r e n t , t h e n 1 i i s s a i d t o be w r i t t e n i n standard form. This i m p l i e s , t h e r e f o r e ,
e (i.e.,
C p aiki
a r e nonzero and m u t u a l l y d i s j o i n t such t h a t
ki
t h a t one of t h e c o e f f i c i e n t s may b e z e r o . I f i t i s only g i v e n t h a t a l l
E y ki
a r e m u t u a l l y d i s j o i n t and
standard form. I f
s = Cn o k .
and
s t 0
s
a.k. t 0 1 1
satisfies
,
a. t 0
so
1
,
'i
and
and
= s+
C'
= s
-"C
-
L
a. < 0
such t h a t
.
f o r a t l e a s t one of
and
s+
s
-
s
i
i.e.,
s = Ca. ki
(al-
. Then
s = 'C
'C
-
and
-"C
.
(-"E)
It
s = C
then t h e r e i s no uniqueness
assume, t h e r e f o r e , t h a t n a.k. a r e non-negative 1
1
s
1
m
s
is
i f this
6.k' i n s t a n d a r d form. I ~j i s t r i v i a l , we may assume t h a t a. > 0 f o r a t
0
=
,
s
i s t h e s t a n d a r d form. Assume now t h a t a l s o l e a s t one v a l u e of
if
,
i s w r i t t e n i n standard form, t h e n
s
. We may
a l l coefficients i n
Since the case t h a t
...,n
i s unique.
s
PROOF. I f t h e r e i s no uniqueness f o r positive, i.e.,
I,
c o n s i s t s of a l l t e r m s w i t h
'C
LEMMA 120.4. I f an e-step element t h i s way of w r i t i n g
=
...,n . Furthermore,
, where
are p o s i t i v e and d i s j o i n t elements of follows t h a t
i
for
i
c o n s i s t s of a l l term w i t h
"1
ki i s w r i t t e n i n almost
Cn a . k 1 i i
then
QK s t 0
i = l,
for
,
e
i n s t a n d a r d form o r almost s t a n d a r d form
1
then
m o s t s t a n d a r d ) , l e t s = '1 + "1
a. 2 0
=
. Without
= C
l o s s of g e n e r a l i t y , l e t t h i s be f o r
i = 1
Then
Not a l l kl
A
kl
k; > 0
k'
A
j
a l k l > 0 ) ; w i t h o u t l o s s of g e n e r a l i t y , l e t
vanish (since
. Then
QK; Q K l s = " I \ (k 1 ~ k1 )" = B I \(k 1hk"1) which shows t h a t only one
kl kl
A
Bj
k! > 0 J
. Since
a, =
B1
. It 1
all
,
= (vk!)
J
A
, we
kl
=
Bj
i.e.,
follows t h a t a l l o t h e r
Ck! = vk' = e J j k
. Since B j - al
satisfying
a r e mutually d i f f e r e n t , t h e r e i s k;
k!
J f i n d now t h a t
k'
1
h
k
1 '
'
i s t he only
k' satisfying j a r e d i s j o i n t t o the given
Ch. 17,51201
SO
Blk;
k' 1
2
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
. But
kl
now, s i n c e
i n s t e a d of f o r
B1
. We
alkl
=
a1 > 0
, we
g e t thus t h a t
It f o l l o w s t h a t e v e r y term o c c u r r i n g i n
479
can r e p e a t t h e argument f o r k
Ca.k.
1
1 1
. Hence
Z k;
with
a. > 0
kl = k;
.
occurs also
CB.k' ; c o n v e r s e l y , e v e r y t e r m i n ZB.k! with B . > 0 o c c u r s i n ~j J J J Ca.k. But t h e n t h e t e r m w i t h c o e f f i c i e n t z e r o ( i f o c c u r r i n g ) i s a l s o t h e in
.
1 1
same i n b o t h e x p r e s s i o n s .
s
COROLLARY 120.5. I f
= C y aiki
i s the unique standard form f o r
Is1
i n standard form, then
.
C y lailk;
THEOREM 120.6. Every e-step element can be w r i t t e n uniquely i n stand-
ard form. PROOF. L e t f i r s t k i j = ki
A
k'
for a l l
j
s = Ca k
i i
. Then
i,j
and
s'
= CB k '
ki = C.k 1 ij
j j and
i n s t a n d a r d form. L e t k! = Cikij I
,
so
and t a k i n g t o g e t h e r kij = 0 terms w i t h e q u a l c o e f f i c i e n t s , w e o b t a i n t h e s t a n d a r d form f o r s + s ' By
i n almost s t a n d a r d form. Omitting terms w i t h induction i t follows t h a t i f then s o can
s1
+
... +
s
s i s t s of one t e r m , i . e . ,
,
e-k
we g e t
s
n s = ak
n e c e s s a r i l y a R i e s z space. L e t that
in T
L
,
into
L
w e have a r e a l v e c t o r s p a c e
i i
T
M (in notation
It f o l l o w s immediately t h a t
we had b e f o r e i s t h a t . T
T
M
, not
yet
b e a mapping from t h e s e t of components q
=
~ ( k ) f o r every
i s a d d i t i v e i n the sense t h a t i f
t h e mapping
con-
can be w r i t t e n i n s t a n d a r d form.
a k.
kl
A
k = QKe )
k2 = 0 ( i . e . , k l
= k l + k 2 ), t h e n
v
s
t h e n by adding a t e r m e q u a l t o z e r o t i m e s
Cn
1
Assume now t h a t b e s i d e s e
can be w r i t t e n i n s t a n d a r d form,
now t h a t i f t h e e - s t e p element
i n s t a n d a r d form. Hence, i n view of t h e r e s u l t a l r e a d y
proved, e v e r y e - s t e p element
of
...,s n
sl,
. Note
.
~ ( 0 =) 0
. The main
V
such k
2
=
d i f f e r e n c e w i t h t h e mapping
i s n o t n e c e s s a r i l y r e a l v a l u e d . W e wish t o extend
t o t h e s p a c e of e - s t e p elements by d e f i n i n g
Ch. 17,11201
REPRESENTATION BY MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
480
n s = 1 a.k 1 i i
f o r any e - s t e p element
This d e f i n i t i o n makes s e n s e o n l y i f s (i.e,,
, not C
i t should n o t depend on how
n e c e s s a r i l y i n s t a n d a r d form.
a . ~ ( k . ) i s uniquely determined by
1
1
1
i s w r i t t e n as a l i n e a r combination
s
of components). We prove f i r s t t h a t t h i s i s indeed t h e c a s e .
If s
LEMMA 120.7.
aiki
= Cy
PROOF. Assume f i r s t t h a t
+
S I
=
C
1 1
A
k! 1
,
, then
and
s'
=
we have
ZB.k! J J
, both
i n stand-
c ~ (ai+Bj)kij , ~
i n almost s t a n d a r d form. S i n c e t h e a d d i t i v i t y of
s = Ca.k.
kij = k . 1
a r d form. W r i t i n g a g a i n
Bjk;
= C y
k. = C. k 1
that
T
J
a i ~ ( k . )= C . a. ?(kij) 1,j 1
ij
for all
i
, it
f o l l o w s from
.
Similarly
Hence
+
C a. T(k.) 1
1
and u s i n g a g a i n t h a t
T
C B . ~ ( k ! ) = Zi
J
J
i s a d d i t i v e , i t i s e a s y t o see t h a t t h e l a s t
, where C y k" i s t h e s t a n d a r d form P P + s B y i n d u c t i o n t h i s r e s u l t i s extended t o t h e sum s 1 + for n ' e a c h of s l , s i n s t a n d a r d form. n n L e t now s = E l aiki , n o t n e c e s s a r i l y i n s t a n d a r d form. Write each expression is equal t o s+s'.
C yp r ( k i )
...
...,
term s e p a r a t e l y i n s t a n d a r d form by adding a t e r m w i t h c o e f f i c i e n t zero. This g i v e s us sI +
... +
s
n
s
1
,...,sn . Applying
, we
get
the j u s t obtained r e s u l t t o
Ch. 17,51201
where C
6 k' , j i
48 1
P
y k"
C
Hence
ABSTRACT L -SPACES
i s the standard form of P P then we g e t s i m i l a r l y
C oi .r(ki)
=
1
can a l s o be w r i t t e n as
s
.
Z 5 . r(k!) 1
. If
s
3
We s p e c i a l i z e the s i t u a t i o n by assuming now t h a t complete Riesz space possessing a weak u n i t
mapping o f t h e Boolean a l g e b r a of a l l components algebra of a l l components of plained above, because
kl
A
. Then
d
k2 = 0
be an isomorphic
T
k
i s a Dedekind
M
. Let
d
e
of
onto the Boolean
i s a d d i t i v e i n the sense ex-
T
implies
r(kl)
A
r(k2) = 0
by the
isomorphism. Hence
I t follows now from the l a s t lemma t h a t T
can be extended uniquely t o t h e
space of a l l e-step elements by d e f i n i n g T
fZ
a.k
i,
=
.
Z a. ~ ( k . ) 1
1
Every d-step element i s the image of some e-step element, i . e . , of
i s now t h e space of a l l d-step elements.
T
The s i t u a t i o n becomes even more s p e c i a l i f t i v e and u-additive) i n a p o i n t s e t i s the space
M(X,v)
X
i s a measure (non-nega-
v
such t h a t
v(X)
for a l l
x E X
i s now a weak u n i t i n
the c h a r a c t e r i s t i c functions s e t of
X
i s f i n i t e and
of a l l r e a l v-measurable f u n c t i o n s on
t i f i c a t i o n of v-almost equal f u n c t i o n s ) . The f u n c t i o n = 1
the range
. The mapping
x,(x)
M D
X (with iden-
satisfying
and the components of
d(x) = d
algebra of a l l components of s e t s . I n t h i s case, t h e r e f o r e ,
-i(z
e
onto the Boolean algebra of allv-measurable T
may be extended t o t h e space of a l l e-step
.
a . k . ) = Z ai ~ ( k . ) The extended 1 1
T
is
l i n e a r and maps the space of e-step elements i n a one-one manner onto the space of v-step functions.
are
an a r b i t r a r y v-measurable sub-
i s now an isomorphic mapping from t h e Boolean
T
elements by d e f i n i n g t h a t
for
d
M
REPRESENTATION BY MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
482
Assume now, once more, t h a t satisfying
we s e t
1 5 p <
component of
e
a l g e b r a of a l l
p
. Again,
m
v(K) = pP(QKe)
i s called
k = Q e K
let
, where
i n t h e band
L
p
.
K
i s an a b s t r a c t L -space f o r some p P e b e a weak u n i t i n L . A s b e f o r e ,
i s t h e norm i n L and Q e i s t h e K The isomorphic mapping of t h e Boolean
o n t o t h e Boolean a l g e b r a of t h e s u b s e t s
T
. As
i s ( e x c e p t f o r a s e t of v-measure
P
of
{P}K
and
T
i s a measure on t h e a l g e b r a of a l l {P}K in
Ch. 17,51201
proved, e v e r y v-measurable s e t
z e r o ) one of t h e
{PIK
. Hence,
i s e s s e n t i a l l y a mapping o n t o t h e c o l l e c t i o n of a l l v-measurable s e t s .
A s above, w e e x t e n d
T
t o t h e s p a c e o f a l l e - s t e p e l e m e n t s by d e f i n i n g t h a t
. done t h i s , we compute T(Z a . k . ) = C a . ~ ( k . ) Having 1 1
s =
Z a.k.
1 1
. For
1
1
t h i s p u r p o s e , we may assume t h a t
a r d form. Furthermore, f o r b r e v i t y , w r i t e Then, by t h e a d d i t i v i t y of
M
Once more f o r b r e v i t y , w r i t e
M(f)
s
pp(s)
for
i s w r i t t e n i n stand-
= pp(f)
f o r any
f € L
.
f o r d i s j o i n t elements,
xi
f o r t h e c h a r a c t e r i s t i c f u n c t i o n of
{PIKi
{PI a r e m u t u a l l y d i s j o i n t . The l a s t e x p r e s s i o n Ki i n !the formula above now becomes
and n o t e t h a t t h e s e t s
The one-one l i n e a r mapping now e x t e n d
T
T p r e s e r v e s , t h e r e f o r e , t h e L -norm. We s h a l l P once more, which g i v e s r i s e t o t h e f o l l o w i n g theorem.
THEOREM 120.8. Any abstract L -space f o r a v a h e o f P
1 5 p <
type
m
p
such t h a t
and possessing a weak u n i t i s Riesz isomorphic w i t h a space of
L (X,v) P
, where
v(X)
i s f i n i t e . The isomorphism i s mm preserving.
More i n detaiZ, t h e weak u n i t i n
L
corresponds (under t h e isomorphism)
w i t h t h e f u n c t i o n identieaZZy one on X and the s e t
X
is a compact
Ch. 1 7 , 9 1 2 0
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
483
Hausdorff t o p o l o g i c a l s p a c e which is e x t r e m a l l y d i s c o n n e c t e d and h a s t h e p r o p e r t y t h a t e v e r y v-measurable s e t is v-almost e q u a l t o an open-closed s e t in t h i s topoZogy. PROOF. The space L ( X , v ) w i l l be t h e space L (P,v) P P a r e as i n t r o d u c e d above. The one-one l i n e a r mapping T
v
i n t r o d u c e d , maps t h e space of a l l e - s t e p elements i n v-step
functions i n
. Note
Lp(P,v)
a r e p o s i t i v e mappings. We e x t e n d f
pose, l e t p(f-s
f o r any
) J. 0 > 0
E
o n t o t h e s p a c e of
L
and i t s i n v e r s e
T
t o t h e whole space
be an a r b i t r a r y p o s i t i v e element of
wards d i r e c t e d system Then
T
t h a t both
, where P and , a l s o already
.
L
. There
L
t h e r e e x i s t s a n e - s t e p element
.
e x i s t s a n up-
I n o t h e r words, t h e e - s t e p elements a r e l y i n g norm dense i n of c o u r s e , t h e v-step f u n c t i o n s a r e l y i n g norm dense i n obvious now how t o extend v i n g . Indeed, i f ments such t h a t in
Lp(P,v)
f
such t h a t
T
p(f-sn)
+
.
0
Then
( s :n=1,2,
n (Tsn:n=1,2,
n o t on t h e approaching sequence. Now d e f i n e Then
T
,
p(f-s
t h u s d e f i n e d on
L T
.
, is
Lp(P,v)
...)
...)
T
-1
T
(sn:n=1,2,
...)
Tf
=
I
Ifl-lsnl
f
,
I
,
f
and
t o be t h i s l i m i t function.
obviously l i n e a r , norm p r e s e r v i n g and a n
b e a p o s i t i v e element of
b e e - s t e p elements such t h a t
I
It i s
i s a Cauchy sequence
T
T i s t h e whole s p a c e L (P,v) P i s a Rie.sz isomorphism, i t remains t o prove t h a t T
If-lsnl we have
.
Extending s i m i l a r l y t h e o r i g i n a l
are p o s i t i v e mappings. L e t
5
1)
If-snl
p(f-sn)
+
0
L
. Since
-1
,
. For
it the
and
and l e t
I
.
L (P,v) P A l l T ( ~ S I ) are p o s i t i v e and t h e p o s i t i v e cone i s norm c l o s e d , s o Tf i s n -1 p o s i t i v e . This shows t h a t T i s p o s i t i v e . The proof f o r T is similar.
p(f-lsnl)
+
0
Tf-T(/s
t e n d s t o z e r o i n norm i n
The s t a t e m e n t s i n t h e theorem about t h e topology i n
X = P
were proved
e a r l i e r i n t h i s section. The theorem which w e have t h u s proved shows t h a t an a b s t r a c t L -space
(I
E.
b e e - s t e p ele-
becomes e v i d e n t t h a t t h e range of proof t h a t
) <
. Similarly,
L
t h e r e f o r e a l i m i t . The l i m i t depends only on
e x t e n s i o n of t h e o r i g i n a l
4 f.
s
5
remains l i n e a r and norm p r e s e r -
T
E L is a r b i t r a r y , l e t
, having
0
It f o l l o w s t h a t
satisfying
s
-1
For t h i s pur-
of e - s t e p elements such t h a t
(sa:a€{a))
by t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of t h e norm p
T
P
can b e r e p r e s e n t e d (Riesz i s o m o r p h i c a l l y and i s o m e t r i c a l l y ) as a
REPRESENTATION BY MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
484
Ch. 17,11201
concrete L -space of measurable functions. The question a r i s e s what can be P i n f e r r e d i n the more general s i t u a t i o n t h a t L i s a Banach l a t t i c e with 'order continuous norm and having a weak u n i t . We s h a l l prove t h a t a l s o i n t h i s case
L
i s Riesz isomorphic t o a space of measurable functions. For
t h i s purpose we show f i r s t t h a t under t h e mentioned conditions
L
possesses
a s t r i c t l y positive l i n e a r functional. THEOREM 120.9. Every normed Riesz space
L
with order continuous norm
and having a weak u n i t possesses a norm continuous and s t r i c t l y positive linear functional. Note that the functional i s also order continuous (since
p
the norm i s order continuous). PROOF. In Theorem 103.12 i t was proved t h a t i f
space with order continuous norm and
A
L
t h e r e e x i s t s a norm continuous l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on p o s i t i v e on
A
. In
i s a normed Riesz
is a principal ideal i n A
the p r e s e n t s i t u a t i o n , l e t
L
L
, then
which i s s t r i c t l y
be the p r i n c i p a l i d e a l
generated by the weak u n i t . There e x i s t s t h e r e f o r e , a norm continuous linear f u n c t i o n a l $
$
on
such t h a t
L
i s a l s o s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e on
L
$
i s s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e on
, because
A
. Then
i s the band generated by
L
A .
For l a t e r a p p l i c a t i o n s i t i s of i n t e r e s t t o consider t h e s i t u a t i o n t h a t L
i s a Dedekind complete Riesz space with a weak u n i t and possessing a
s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e o r d e r continuous l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l . Note t h a t i f
L
is
a Banach l a t t i c e with o r d e r continuous norm and having a weak u n i t , then L
s a t i s f i e s these conditions ( t h e Dedekind completeness follows from
Theorem 103.9 and the e x i s t e n c e of a s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e o r d e r continuous l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l follows from the l a s t theorem). THEOREM 120.10. Let
unit tional
e
L
be a Dedekind complete Riesz space with a weak
and possessing a s t r i c t l y positive order continuous Zinear func$
.
Then
L
i s Riesz isomorphic with an ideal
L l ( X , v ) of ( r e a l ) v - s m a b l e functions, where
v ( X ) = + ( e ) 1 . The weak u n i t i n
L
the function i d e n t i c a l l y one on
X
V(X)
M
i n a space
is f i n i t e (actually,
corresponds (under the isomorphism) with
. It
folluws that every bounded v-measur-
.
able function on X i s contained i n M This r e s u l t holds i n particular i f L i s a Banach l a t t i c e with order continuous nomi and having a weak u n i t .
Ch. 17,11201
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
PROOF. Define
in
L
p(f) = + ( I f / )
f o r every
. Then
f E L
algebra
of a l l bands i n
K
.
K
and, f o r every band
L
K
The Boolean a l g e b r a
,
K
let
i s a d d i t i v e and o r d e r continuous on
+
from t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of a l g e b r a of a l l i.e.,
be t h e
Q,
i s o r d e r complete ( s i n c e
i s Dedekind complete). Likewise a s b e f o r e , t h e f u n c t i o n
,
.
p(u+v) = p(u) + p(v) f o r a l l u , v E L+ P b e t h e s e t of a l l p r o p e r prime i d e a l s i n t h e Boolean
band p r o j e c t i o n o n t o L
i s a norm
p
having t h e p r o p e r t y t h a t
As b e f o r e , l e t
T
485
v(K) = p(QKe)
K ( t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of
follows
v
) . The isomorphic mapping from t h e Boolean
{PIK i s denoted by
QKe o n t o t h e Boolean a l g e b r a of a l l
T(Q,~) = {PIK f o r a l l
K
. Transferring
the function
to the
v
{PIK by d e f i n i n g
c o l l e c t i o n of a l l
=
,
p(QKe) = $(Q,e)
we o b t a i n once more ( a s i n t h e L Lease) a o - a d d i t i v e measure v such t h a t P a f t e r e x t e n s i o n by means of t h e Carathsodory procedure, any w-measurable s u b s e t of P
i s v-almost
isomorphism
T
T ( S ) = Z;
e q u a l t o one of t h e s e t s
t o t h e s e t of a l l e-step elements
1
1
$(lsl)
= P(S)
I
=
s
. Extending
= Zn
k l ,...,k
f o r a r b i t r a r y components
a. T ( k . )
{PIK
1
n
ci.k i i e
of
the
by d e f i n i n g
, we
get
.
IT(S)ldW
.
For any S i m i l a r l y as i n t h e L -case, we now extend T t o t h e whole of L P of e-step e l e f E L t h e r e e x i s t s an i n c r e a s i n g sequence (s,)
positive
ments such t h a t t h e norm
p
sequence i n
.
.
0 5 s
I. f Then p(f-sn) n It follows t h a t t h e sequence
LI(P,w)
quence. Note t h a t
. We
-rf
define
,
T
e x t e n s i o n of t h e o r i g i n a l
T
by t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of
( T S ~ ) of images i s a Cauchy
t o b e t h e l i m i t of t h i s Cauchy se-
Tf
depends only on
sequence. Note a l s o t h a t
J. 0
f
and n o t on t h e approximating
thus d e f i n e d on
, is
L
with the property t h a t
obviously a l i n e a r T
-1
preserves t h e
L -norm (and, t h e r e f o r e , t h e i n v e r s e mapping T e x i s t s ) . The proof t h a t 1 -1 T and T a r e p o s i t i v e i s a s i n t h e L -case. Hence, T i s a Riesz isomorP It remains t o prove t h a t M i s phism from L onto i t s image M = r(L)
an i d e a l i n
L1(P,u)
.
.
Denote t h e f u n c t i o n s i n
(with i d e n t i f i c a t i o n of w-almost 5
v
N
with
v" = T ( V ) f o r some
of s t e p f u n c t i o n s such t h a t
LI(P,v)
by
fN,g , u N
e q u a l f u n c t i o n s ) . Assume now t h a t v E L+
0 d s-
+
u"
. There
e x i s t s a sequence
and f o r e v e r y
N
s
n
N
,...
0 d u
N
5
N
(sn)
t h e r e e x i s t s an
REPRESENTATION BY MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
486
e - s t e p element
2 0
s
such t h a t
0 5 s
such t h a t
0 <
Hence, s i n c e
N
0
follows t h a t
0 < u
5
.
Ll(P,w)
v
N
with
v
s
N
5
by h y p o t h e s i s , w e have N
i s an i d e a l i n
. It
L
4 u”
S”
T h i s shows t h a t i f M
in
4 u
n
.
,
= s Then 0 < s 4 5 v i n L n n L t h e r e e x i s t s a n alzment u E L+
TS
s o by t h e Dedekinnd completeness of
Ch. 17, 51201
N
u
E M , then
N
in
4 TU
,
= TU
E M
tiN
LI(P,v) N
i.e.,
u
.
E M
. Therefore,
.
We e x t e n d Theorem 120.8 ( a b s t r a c t L -space f o r 1 S p < m ) and Theorem P 120.10 (Dedekind complete s p a c e w i t h s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l ) t o t h e c a s e t h a t t h e s p a c e does n o t have a weak u n i t . I n e i t h e r of t h e s e c a s e s , l e t by
Ka
. The
. The
L
p o s i t i v e elements i n system
every
t h e element
a
b e a maximal d i s j o i n t system of s t r i c t l y
band g e n e r a t e d i n
L
K
i s a weak u n i t i n
e
measure s p a c e s w i l l b e denoted by
. Hence,
.
Ka
T (K )
a
spaces
(Pa,Aa,va)
t o b e open whenever
P
C
. The
thus obtained
V
n
Pa
i s open i n X
Pa
. The
.
f o r every
Pa
X
. It
of
X
Pa
follows t h a t
of
V
X
Pa
satisfying
f o r every
v
(since every
from
V E A
A
ha
V
n Pa A
E Aa
s e e t h i s , obC
f o r every
a
,
so there
w i l l be
of a l l measurable s e t s i s a
i s a a-a3gebra i n
i n t o t h e extended r e a l numbers by
( t h i s implies t h a t
. To
Pa
v(V) =
m
P
) . We d e f i n e a
w(V)
=
X a va(VnPa)
i f t h e r e a r e more than
a o u n t a b l y many s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e t e r m s ) . I t w i l l b e shown f i r s t t h a t a non-negative for
V,W E A
and a - a d d i t i v e measure. E v i d e n t l y , v ( $ ) = 0 with
V c W
. For
them-
i s a compact sub-
i s an open c o v e r i n g of
c a l l e d a measurable s e t . The c o l l e c t i o n X
Pa
these
i s a l o c a l l y compact s p a c e . Any compact sub-
X
s e r v e t h a t t h e c o l l e c t i o n of a l l
mapping
Pa
i s c o n t a i n e d i n a f i n i t e union of s e t s
Any s u b s e t
i s easy
i s Hausdorff
X
i s open a s w e l l a s
i n i t s own topology i s compact, Pa
e x i s t s a f i n i t e subcovering.
o-algebra i n
Every
, it
a
topology i n
i s H a u s d o r f f , and f o r p o i n t s i n d i f f e r e n t
c l o s e d , and s i n c e s e t of
Hence, we may a p p l y
Ka
.
s e l v e s a r e d i s j o i n t open neighborhoods).
set
. For
{O}
and t h e c o r r e s p o n d i n g R i e s z
T (K )
t o s e e t h a t t h i s d e f i n e s a topology i n (each
K =
i s e i t h e r t h e s p a c e L (P , A a a p a a%) Or i s an i d e a l i n the space L (P A ) Thinking of t h e t o p o l o g i c a l 1 a ’ a’va Pa a s d i s j o i n t s e t s , we p u t X = !ja Pa D e f i n i n g a s u b s e t V of Ta
isomorphism by
X
w i l l b e denoted
e
Ka , then
i s disjoint to a l l
e i t h e r Theorem 120.8 o r Theorem 120.10 t o e v e r y
a
by
i s a d i s j o i n t system of b a n d s , maximal i n t h e
{Ka}
s e n s e t h a t i f t h e band
{e }
t h e proof t h a t
v
and
i s a-additive,
v
is
v(V ) 5 v(W) let
Ch. 1 7 , 5 1 2 0 1
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
E A
V =U V and a l l Vn m u t u a l l y d i s j o i n t . Then I n w i t h d i s j o i n t t e r m s , and hence
V,V =
E
U
487
with
(V n P ) 1 n a
We now a p p l y CarathGodory's e x t e n s i o n p r o c e d u r e t o t h e measure does n o t produce any v - m e a s u r a b l e s e t s which a r e n o t a l r e a d y
A
. For
t h e proof, n o t e f i r s t t h a t every s u b s e t
Now, l e t
be a s u b s e t of
V
W c Pa
Then, f o r any
, we
W
Pa
of
V
n Pa
=
. This
v
members of satisfies
which i s v - m e a s u r a b l e ( a f t e r t h e e x t e n s i o n ) .
X have
V*(W) = v *(w) = v*(wnv) + v*
T h i s shows t h a t
V
t h a t t h e a-algebra s e t s of
X
.
n Pa
i s v measurable, i.e.,
A
V ll Pa E
Aa
. It
follows
i s p r e c i s e l y t h e o - a l g e b r a of a l l v - m e a s u r a b l e sub-
As u s u a l , t h e Riesz s p a c e of a l l e q u i v a l e n c e c l a s s e s of r e a l v-almost everywhere f i n i t e v a l u e d v - m e a s u r a b l e f u n c t i o n s on
. Note
M(X,v)
that
v need n o t be o - f i n i t e .
p r o j e c t i o n on t h e band
. We
Ka
In
L
d e f i n e a mapping
X
,
w i l l b e denoted by let
be t h e o r d e r
Pa
from
T
L
into
M(X,v)
by
'1
(Tf)(x) = (Ta(Paf) (x)
I
Since a l l
Ta
and a l l
homomorphism. I f p f = 0 that
f o r every
f = 0
. Thus
Pa
Tf = 0 a T
In the case that
,
whenever
x E P
a r e Riesz homomorphisms, T then
, because
T (P f) = 0 CYa
each
f o r every
( w i t h norm p
( i n view of Theorem 120.8) t h a t i f
i s l i k e w i s e a Riesz a
, and
hence
Tcc i s a one-one mapping. It f o l l o w s
i s a one-one mapping, i . e . , L
.
T
i s a R i e s z isomorphism.
is a n a b s t r a c t L -space, we know P f E L i s g i v e n , t h e n e v e r y Ta(Paf) i s
Ch. 17,§1201
REPRESENTATION BY MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
488
L (P , v )
an elment of Since
Paf
# 0
P
and the L -norm of Ta(Paf) i s the same as p(Paf). a P holds f o r a t most countably many values of a , the element
i s the o r d e r l i m i t (and hence the norm l i m i t ) of a sequence
f
. It
a f i n i t e sum of elements of the form
s
n Tf
Paf and the L -norm of Tf P P The proof t h a t , conversely, every element g E Lp(X,v) of
f
belongs t o
g = Tf
f o r some
f E L
holds i f
g
each
p(f)
.
i s of the form
.
) f o r some a P a c t L i s a Dedekind complete space possessing a s t r i c t l y
positive l i n e a r functional
,
$
v
the measure
and from t h e weak u n i t
$
,
i s s i m i l a r , s t a r t i n g from the observation t h a t
E L (P , v
In the case t h a t from
i s equal t o
L (X,v)
g = Tf
(sn)
follows t h a t the image
e
i n Theorem 120.10. Since f o r any
in f
Pa i s
i n each
derived
i n a c e r t a i n manner described
Ka
E L each component
P f
belongs t o
.
L (P v ) , i t follows as above t h a t each f E L belongs t o L,(X,v) In 1 a' a g e n e r a l , however, t h e image T(L) of L under the isomorphism T w i l l
not be equal t o the whole space in
. It
LI(X,v)
f
and
g
E T(L)
g
L (X,v). We prove t h a t 1
satisfy
. Observing
t h a t t h e product
0
2
that
fxp
ua E Ka
i n v e r s e image of ness of
L
,
0
. Obviously
f (i.e.,Tu
Tu = Tu
. It
in
, so ,
LI(X,v)
Tu = g
see t h a t
5
u
uo f o r any
2
gxp a
f o r some
, where
uo i s the
a
u
exists i n
a
L
. Since
u = u
+ (u-u,)
+ T(u-ua) = gxp + T(u-ua) a
. This
(Tu)x
&-
= gXpa
concludes t h e proof t h a t
holds f o r
i s an i d e a l
.
M(X,v)
and hence an i d e a l i n
. This T(L)
We f i n a l l y make some remarks about compact s e t s and Borel s e t s i n
B
By d e f i n i t i o n , the a-ring
of a l l Borel s e t s i n
containing a l l compact s u b s e t s of of a l l subsets V X
. It
Hence
8c
of
of
X
such t h a t
i s e a s i l y seen t h a t C
. We
and
Pa
E T(Ka) because
gxpa = T g
follows t h a t
0
with d i s j o i n t terms, which implies t h a t
a
, we
T(Ka)
f ). Hence, i n view of t h e Dedekind complete-
=
0 u = sup
the element
holds v -almost everywhere on
f
2 g 2
belongs t o
with d i s j o i n t terms, we have
every
i s an i d e a l
E T(L) v-almost everywhere on X , then
g(x) 5 f ( x )
i s an i d e a l in" LI(Pa,va)
T(Ka)
non-negat i v e
T(L)
i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t i f the v-measurable f u n c t i o n s
prove t h a t
a l l v-measurable s e t s . Let
C C
V E C
X
. Let
X
X
.
i s the s m a l l e s t a-ring
us consider now t h e c o l l e c t i o n
V Cl C E
B
C
f o r every compact subset C
i s a u-algebra containing a l l compact s e t s .
i s a sub-o-algebra
. It
of t h e u-algebra
A of
follows from t h e d e f i n i t i o n t h a t
Ch. 17,81201
V
n Pa
E B
489
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
for every
. This shows that
a
V n Pa
is a Borel subset of
P (because the relative topology in Pa is the original topology in Pa But then V
n
Let C that C
P, E ha
for all a , so V E A
.
. Then there exist al,.. .,a such (k=l,...,n ) . Since the characteristic
be a compact subset of X
C c P ak P belong to T(L) and T(L) ak it follows that the characteristic function of Ck
= U;
with
functions of the sets
,
M(X,v)
>.
is an ideal in C
belongs to T(L).
We summarize the obtained results in the following theorem. THEOREM 120.11. Let
satisfying
1
5
p <
m
L
be e i t h e r an abstract L -space f o r some P
p
or a Dedekind complete Riesz space possessing a
s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e order continuous l i n e a r functional. Then L is e i t h e r R i e s z isomorphic t o a space L ( X , A , v ) or t o an i d e a l i n a space Ll(X,A,v), P where X i s a l o c a l l y compact Hausdorff space, v is a ( n o t necessarily u - f i n i t e ) measure and t h e u-algebra A o f a l l v-measurable subsets of X contains t h e o-algebra of a l l s e t s V w i t h t h e property t h a t v n C i s a
Borel s e t f o r every compact subset X
of any compact subset of
.
isomorphism T
1
S
X
. The c h a r a c t e r i s t i c
belongs t o t h e image
T(L)
of
L
function
under t h e
EXERCISE 120.12. Any abstract L -space L (for some p satisfying P S - ) is Banach, and therefore L is uniformly complete. It follows
p
that the complexification L+iL
1)
exists. The norm
. Show that
p(f)
= p(lf
for
1 < p
-
p(f)
for f E L+iL
is
the abstract L -space P is Riesz isomorphic (and norm isomorphic) to a complex space Lp(X,A,u)
defined by t
of
C
Similarly, any Dedekind complete Riesz space L therefore L+iL
exists. Show that if L
<
.
is uniformly complete and
is Dedekind complete and possesses
a strictly positive order continuous linear functional, then L+iL isomorphic to an ideal in a space of type Ll(X,A,lI) HINT: Let L
be isomorphic to the real space L
Note now that in L+iL f = f +if
1
(f,
f
.
and
the ordinary absolute value f2
is
of the desired type. (f:+fi)'
of a function
real) is the same as the function
sup\fl cos8+f2 sin't3:0<8<2a
J'
where the supremum is taken with respect to the order in L
.
Ch. 17,11211
REPRESENTATION BY CONTINUOUS FUNCTIONS
490
1 2 1 . R e p r e s e n t a t i o n by a space of continuous f u n c t i o n s I n t h i s f i n a l s e c t i o n we b r i e f l y d i s c u s s AM-spaces. an AM-space p o s s e s s i n g a s t r o n g norm u n i t L
by
p
, we
have
p(e)
,
1
=
p(f) 5 1
It f o l l o w s immediately t h a t
Xo > 0
number
, i.e.,
p(f)
C(X)
for
X
5
d e n o t i n g t h e norm i n
p(f) 5 1
i f and o n l y i f
If
I
S
, which
X1
p(f) = 0
and t h i s holds a l s o i f space
be
L
implies
Ifl
S
0 <
A,<
. If
e
If\
5 e
the
i s given, then
I f , i n t h i s c a s e , we should have p(Xil f ) 5 1
. Hence,
e
and f u r t h e r m o r e
First, let
.
X 1e
f o r some
lo
then
i s a g a i n s t our h y p o t h e s i s . Hence
I n the p a r t i c u l a r case t h a t
is a
L
compact ( w i t h t h e uniform norm) o r a space
( w i t h t h e c o r r e s p o n d i n g L_-norm),
,
L_(X,p) X
t h e n t h e f u n c t i o n i d e n t i c a l l y one on
i s a s t r o n g norm u n i t . The formula ( 1 ) becomes now
i n the case t h a t
L = C(X)
,
and
A : / f ( x ) l < h f o r p-almost a l l i n the case t h a t
L = L_(X,u)
. L
We r e t u r n t o t h e case t h a t
e
. More
generally, let f i r s t
L
i s a n AM-space w i t h a s t r o n g norm u n i t be a normed Riesz s p a c e w i t h - a d d i t i v e
norm and p o s s e s s s i n g a s t r o n g norm u n i t L
, i.e.,
e
t h e p r i n c i p a l i d e a l g e n e r a t e d by
. Then e
e
is a strong unit i n
i s t h e space
L
i t s e l f . This
i s immediately v i s i b l e from formula ( 1 ) . According t o t h e Yosida represent a t i o n theorem (Theorem 4 5 . 3 ) t h e r e e x i s t s now a compact Hausdorff space C(J)
J
. The
such t h a t subspace
h o l d s i f and o n l y i f h o l d s i f and o n l y i f
L "L
L
i s R i e s z isomorphic t o a Riesz subspace i s uniformly dense i n i s e-uniformly
C(J)
,
and s o
-L
-L = C(J)
complete. I n o t h e r words, -L
L i s n o r m complete, i . e . ,
i f and o n l y i f
of
L
=
C(J)
is a n AM-
Ch. 17,11211
49 1
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P
J
space. I n c i d e n t a l l y , we r e c a l l t h a t the p o i n t s of
J
in
L
and the value satisfying
ci
of the f u n c t i o n J E J
f E L ) a t the p o i n t
t o t h e element number
"f(J) cue-f E J
. Under
. The
E J
J
norm
in
p
L
(corresponding
i s the uniquely determined
t h e isomorphism the s t r o n g u n i t
J , i . e . , -e(J)
corresponds with t h e f u n c t i o n i d e n t i c a l l y one on all
a r e the maximal i d e a l s
-f E -L
i s transferred t o
e for
= 1
; according t o ( 1 )
-L
we have
This shows t h a t
i s t h e uniform norm i n
"p
space with a s t r o n g norm u n i t , then phic t o
L
.
C(J)
Now, l e t
L
. Hence,
-L
L*
be an a r b i t r a r y AM-space.
i s an AL-space.
L
i s an
AM-
i s Riesz isomorphic and norm isomorThen the norm i n
t i v e , s o by Theorem 118.1 the norm i n the Banach dual i.e.,
if
L*
L
i s m-addi-
i s I-additive,
B u t then, by Theorem 118.4, L**
i s an AM-space
possessing a s t r o n g norm u n i t . A s seen above, t h e r e e x i s t s a compact Hausdorff space
J
embedded i n
L**
follows t h a t
L
such t h a t
i s isomorphic t o
L**
C(J)
. Furthermore,
is
L
as a Riesz subspace (with p r e s e r v a t i o n of t h e norm). It
i s isomorphic t o a R i e s z subspace of
C(J)
. Combining
a l l r e s u l t s , we have proved t h e following theorem. THEOREM 1 2 1 . 1 . Any AM-space possessing a strong norm u n i t i s Riesz C(X)
isomorphic and norm isomorphic t o a space Hausdorff space space of some
X
. Any
C(X)
arbitrary AM-space i s isomorphic t o a Riesz subX
with
EXERCISE 1 2 1 . 2 . Let
V
compact and Hausdorff. be a ( r e a l or complex) vector space. The k e r n e l
( n u l l space) of any l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l $I
i s t h e n u l l f u n c t i o n a l , then
such t h a t Let J, =
J,
$(e) = 1
. It
for an appropriate compact
$
on
N($) = V
follows t h a t
f
-
. If
.
EXERCISE 121.3.
Show t h a t and only i f
$
Let
$
and
f o r every
N($) c N($)
e
. Show
E
V
f
E V
0 5 J,
5 $
implies
L $ =
.
that
be a l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on the Riesz space
i s a Riesz homomorphism (from $ 2 0
E N($)
. If
N($)
not, there e x i s t s
$(f)e
be another l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s a t i s f y i n g
$(e).$
i s denoted by
V
L
i n t o t h e r e a l numbers) i f
a 4 f o r some r e a l number
.
492
a
REPRESENTATION BY CONTINUOUS FUNCTIONS
satisfying
0
HINT: I f
$
.
L"
0 5 (I
now t h a t
that
4
w E L+
a
. Let
implies
J,(u) = $ ( u ) > 0
. The
0
i s sufficient
. We
may
be defined
J,
f E K
$(w) = 0
J, = a$
we have
a = 1
for a l l
0 5 w I u
f o r some r e a l number
, so
J, = $
. Hence
a
.
.
$(v) =
b e a convex s u b s e t of t h e r e a l v e c t o r s p a c e
K
i s c a l l e d an extrernal p o in t of
f = ag + (I-a)h
. In
and
d e s i r e d r e s u l t follows.
EXERCISE 121.4. L e t
. The
. It
...
. By h y p o t h e s i s
$(v) = 0
f = g = h
N
L
$(u+v) = max{$(u),$(v)}
$(u) = $(u) > 0
with
In particular
K
, which
N($) c N(J,)
the positive linear functional
On a c c o u n t of
The p o i n t
. Hence
by
0 5 J, 5 $
= $(v) =
p o s i t i v e . Assume
( i n view of t h e p r e c e d i n g e x e r c i s e ) .
$(wAnu):n=I,Z, Then
0 is
i t f o l l o w s from
b e a p o s i t i v e atom i n
inf(u,v) = 0
$(u) > 0
assume t h a t
. Then
l$(f)l 5 $ ( l f l ) = 0
f o r some number
Conversely, l e t
for
$ i s t h e n a p o s t i v e atom i n
I n o t h e r words,
$(f) = 0
and
$
, so
(I = a$
t o prove t h a t
.
i s a R i e s z homomorphism, t h e n 5
$(lfl) = 0
implies
a 5 1
5
Ch. 17,§1211
g,h E K
for
and a number
a
i f i t f o l l o w s from
K
f
that
can l i e wholly i n
i s denoted by
K
0 < a < 1
satisfying
o t h e r words, no l i n e segment through
s e t of a l l e x t r e m a l p o i n t s of
V.
. We
Ext K
mention
some examples.
V
( a ) Let
be two-dimensional
p(f) = I f l [ + If2\ V
,
i.e.,
K = (f:p(f)
(O,l),(-l,O) (0,O)
.
(b) L e t in f
V
V
f = (f
.
(O,-l)
K+ = ( f : f > O , p ( f ) < l ) and
for
.
then
Let
K+
r e a l number s p a c e w i t h L -norm, i . e . , 1 L e t K b e t h e c l o s e d u n i t b a l l of
.
Ext K
c o n s i s t s of t h e p o i n t s
be t h e p o s i t i v e p a r t o f
Ext K+
that
p(f) = 1 K
and
p(g) = p ( h ) = 1
f o r any
.
K
c o n s i s t s of t h e p o i n t s
be a r e a l H i l b e r t s p a c e and l e t
. Show f i r s t ,
.
Show t h a t
i s an e x t r e m a l p o i n t of
0 < a < 1
,f ) 1 2 Show t h a t
K
(l,O),
i.e.,
(l,O),(O,l)
be t h e closed u n i t b a l l
f E Ext K
f = ag + (I-a)h
,
. Next,
with
g,h
F i n a l l y , assume now t h a t
show t h a t i f
E K
and
p ( g ) = p(h) =
Ch. 1 7 , 5 1 2 1 1
= 1
,
g # h
Show t h a t
49 3
ABSTRACT L -SPACES P and
f = ag + (I-a)h
f o r some
satisfying
a
.
0 < a < 1
p ( f ) < 1 .Combining t h e s e r e s u l t s , show t h a t e v e r y f E K
i s a n e x t r e m a l p o i n t of
P(f) = 1
satisfying
H I N T : For t h e l a s t p a r t of ( b ) , l e t
.
K
p(g) = p(h) = 1
and
g
.
# h
By t h e p a r a l l e l o g r a m law i n H i l b e r t s p a c e we have
Since
, it
> 0
p(g-h)
any p o i n t
f
follows t h a t
121.5. L e t
EXERCISE
closed u n i t b a l l i n
g
then
and
p(f) < 1
# 0 of
f
.
(b) Show t h a t any e x t r e m a l p o i n t
f
of
or
K
.
K
satisfies
K+
f t 0
satisfies
K
be t h e
K
b e t h e p o s i t i v e p a r t of
K"
for
.
h
(norm p ) , l e t
b e an AL-space
L
and l e t
L
( a ) Show t h a t any e x t r e m a l p o i n t p(f) = 1
. But
p($g+ih) < 1
on t h e l i n e s e g m e n t p r o p e r l y between
or
f 5 0 . ( c ) Show t h a t any p o s i t i v e e x t r e m a l p o i n t of of
and any nonzero e x t r e m a l p o i n t of
K+
i s t h e union of
Hence, Ext K
f+ > 0
H I N T : For ( b ) , assume =
, so
p(If1) = 1
and
0 < p(f+)
, we
h = -f-/p(f-)
,
g # h
Ext K+
have
0 < p(f-)
contradicting the hypothesis t h a t
Assume now t h a t g,h
E K
f
0 < a < 1
.
Note t h a t
f
which would imply
p ( f l ) > p(f) = 1
p(g+) 5 1 h = h+
and
. Now
p(h) 5 1
use t h a t
EXERCISE 121.6. e x e r c i s e . Show t h a t and
p(f) = 1 0 5 a S 1
one i n
L
. It .
0
5
with
K
f
that
f
L,K
and
and l e t
K+
. Show now
p(f) = 1
f
K'
. Hence K+ .
+
)
E K and
1
K+.
f = ag
+ (I-a)h
that
g = g+,
= cig+ +
(I-a)h
,
g = g+ and, s i m i l a r l y ,
be t h e same as i n t h e p r e c e d i n g
i s a nonzero e x t r e m a l p o i n t of implies
=
+
On t h e o t h e r hand, i t f o l l o w s from
p(fl) 5 1
i s extremal i n
(a) L e t
g 5 f
.
g,h
p(f-)
g = f /p(f
i s an e x t r e m a l p o i n t i n
would b e p r o p e r l y smaller t h a n
because o t h e r w i s e
.
i s e x t r e m a l . For ( c ) , i t i s
f
# 0 i s a n e x t r e m a l p o i n t of
and
K
minus t h e p o i n t z e r o .
. Then p ( f + ) + < 1 . Writing
f = p(f+).g + p(f-).h
obvious t h a t any p o s i t i v e e x t r e m a l p o i n t of with
Ext (-K+)
f- > 0
and and
< 1
i s a n e x t r e m a l p o i n t of
K+
and
i s an extremal p o i n t
K
g = af
K+
f o r some number
follows t h a t t h e e x t r e m a l p o i n t s of
K
i f and only i f
a
satisfying
are t h e atoms of norm
Ch. 17,51211
REPRESENTATION BY CONTINUOUS FUNCTIONS
494
( b ) Show t h a t if t h e measure
in
li
X
h a s no atoms, t h e n t h e c l o s e d
L (X,li) does n o t have any e x t r e m a l p o i n t s . 1 ( c ) Show t h a t t h e e x t r e m a l p o i n t s of t h e p o s i t i v e p a r t of t h e c l o s e d
u n i t b a l l of
u n i t b a l l of n a t e of
u
(d) L:t
( n = l , Z , ...) , where t h e n-th c o o r d i n i s one and a l l o t h e r c o o r d i n a t e s a r e z e r o .
b, L
a r e a l l elements
u
b e an AM-space and l e t
c l o s e d u n i t b a l l of
L*
. Show t h a t
B+
t h e s e t of a l l e x t r e m a l p o i n t s of
0 S $ E L*
c o n s i s t s of t h e n u l l f u n c t i o n a l and a l l $
i s a R i e s z homomorphism (from
p(g)
Writing
and
p(f-g)
g1 = g / p ( g )
f = p(g).g,
Conversely, l e t
h l = (f-g)/p(f-g)
. Hence p(f) = 1
some
B
satisfying
0 2 B
some
a
satisfying
0 < a < 1
i s a p o s i t i v e m u l t i p l e of
0
with f
ag S f
g,h
,
0 < g
i
f
.
,
have
that
E K+
and
p(g) + p(f-g) = 1
.
0 i g 2 f
. Assume now S
, we
f = g l = g/p(g) and l e t
1
5
Furthermore, on account of g
K+
a r e s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e and
and
+ p(f-g).hl
B+
of norm one such t h a t
i n t o t h e r e a l numbers).
i s e x t r e m a l p o i n t of
f > 0
HINT: I n ( a ) , i f then
L
b e t h e p o s i t i v e p a r t of t h e
imply
g = Bf
for
f = ag + (I-a)h
for
. Then
.
p(g) = p(h) = 1
i t f o l l o w s from t h e h y p o t h e s i s t h a t
. Similarly
for
h
. Hence
g = h = f
.
CHAPTER 18
COMPACT OPERATORS
The p r e s e n t c h a p t e r d e a l s mainly w i t h c o n d i t i o n s , n e c e s s a r y and ( o r ) s u f f i c i e n t f o r an o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r from one Banach l a t t i c e i n t o a n o t h e r t o b e compact. A s well-known,
the operator
a n o t h e r i s s a i d t o be compact i f
T
T
from one Banach s p a c e i n t o
maps norm bounded s e t s i n t o precompact
t o t a l l y bounded) sets. I n Banach l a t t i c e s i t makes s e n s e t o i n t r o d u c e
(i.e.,
a l s o o p e r a t o r s which map o r d e r bounded s e t s i n t o precompact s e t s . I n doing s o , i t becomes c l e a r v e r y soon t h a t t h e r e i s s t i l l a n o t h e r c l a s s of s e t s p l a y i n g a p r i n c i p a l r o l e . These a r e t h e almost o r d e r bounded s e t s . The subset
L ( w i t h norm
of t h e Banach l a t t i c e
S
almost o r d e r bounded i f f o r any [p,q ] in
L
such t h a t
S
p(f) 5
E
)
. In
> 0
and u n i t b a l l
p
B ) i s called
t h e r e e x i s t s an o r d e r i n t e r v a l
i s i n c l u d e d i n t h e a l g e b r a i c s u m [ p , @ ] + EB
(where, a s u s u a l , t h e n o t a t i o n satisfying
E
EB
means t h a t
EB
c o n s i s t s of a l l
f
E L
s e c t i o n 122 i t i s observed t h a t precompact s e t s
a s w e l l a s o r d e r bounded s e t s a r e almost o r d e r bounded and almost o r d e r bounded s e t s a r e norm bounded, b u t i n g e n e r a l no i m p l i c a t i o n i n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n h o l d s . Of c o u r s e , i f f o r example L u n i t ( a s p a c e of type
i s an AM-space w i t h s t r o n g norm
Lm ), t h e n o r d e r bounded s e t s , almost o r d e r bounded
s e t s and norm bounded s e t s c o i n c i d e . I n Theorem 83.3 i t was proved t h a t i f space
L
T
i s an o p e r a t o r from t h e Riesz
i n t o t h e Dedekind complete Riesz space
bounded i f and only i f
T = T
,
- T2
with
T1
M and
,
then
T
is order
T2 p o s i t i v e , and i n
t h i s case the s e t L (L,M) of a l l o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r s (from L i n t o b M ) i s a Dedekind complete Riesz s p a c e . I f M f a i l s t o b e Dedekind comp l e t e , t h e d e f i n i t i o n of a n o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r from unchanged and
Lb(L,M)
L i n t o M remains
i s now a v e c t o r s p a c e , b u t n o t n e c e s s a r i l y a Riesz
space. I t i s p o s s i b l e i n t h i s c a s e t h a t t h e v e c t o r s p a c e of a l l with
T1
and
T2
T
p o s i t i v e ( c a l l e d t h e s p a c e of J o r d a n o p e r a t o r s ) i s
s m a l l e r t h a n t h e space of a l l o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r s . Note t h a t i f M
a r e Banach
T
=
L
l a t t i c e s , t h e n every p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r (and hence e v e r y r. a c
1
-
T2
and
496
Ch., 183
CHAPTER 18
J o r d a n o p e r a t o r ) i s norm bounded ( s i n c e that i f
i s Banach). Furthermore, r e c a l l
L
i s a Banach l a t t i c e w i t h o r d e r continuous norm, t h e n
M
is
M
Dedekind complete (Theorem 103.9) and hence t h e space of J o r d a n o p e r a t o r s (from
L
M ) c o i n c i d e s now w i t h t h e Riesz space
into
. After
Lb(L,M)
t h e s e p r e l i m i n a r i e s we can now g i v e a d e f i n i t i o n t h a t f i t s t h e f a c t s . The Jordan o p e r a t o r
T
(from t h e Banach l a t t i c e
M ) i s c a l l e d AM-compact i f
compact s u b s e t s of compact. Also i f Lm
>,
M
i n t o t h e Banach l a t t i c e
L
maps o r d e r bounded s u b s e t s of
T
. Evidently,
i n t o pre-
L
every compact J o r d a n o p e r a t o r i s AM-
i s an AM-space w i t h s t r o n g norm u n i t ( a space of t y p e
L
t h e n t h e Jordan o p e r a t o r
i s compact i f and o n l y i f
T
i s AM-
T
compact. This e x p l a i n s t h e terminology. AM-compact o p e r a t o r s a r e r e l a t e d Fremlin i n t h e i r fun-
t o t h e AMAL-compact o p e r a t o r s of P.G. Dodds and D.H. damental paper ([1],1979).
I n s e c t i o n 123 i t will be proved f i r s t t h a t t h e
Jordan o p e r a t o r
i s AM-compact i f and only i f
T
i n t o precompact s u b s e t s of
M
T: L + M
o r d e r bounded s u b s e t s of
L
maps almost
. This
shows
a l r e a d y t h a t i f one wishes t o i n v e s t i g a t e compact Jordan o p e r a t o r s , i t w i l l be n e c e s s a r y t o i n t r o d u c e a s w e l l o p e r a t o r s t h a t map norm bounded s e t s i n t o almost o r d e r bounded s e t s (because t h e n , i f
i s AM-compact,
t h e composition
has t h i s p r o p e r t y and
T1
about AM-compact o p e r a t o r s i s t h e theorem t h a t i f t h e space
M
has o r d e r
continuous norm, t h e n t h e s e t of a l l AM-compact o p e r a t o r s (from M ) i s a band i n t h e Riesz space
T2
w i l l b e compact). The main r e s u l t
T2T,
Lb(L,M)
. The
into
L
r e s u l t i s due t o Dodds-
Fremlin. The proof i n t h e i r paper i s a s i m p l i f i e d v e r s i o n of t h e i r o l d e r p r o o f ; t h e s i m p l i f i c a t i o n i s due t o A.R.
Schep. S t i l l assuming t h a t
o r d e r continuous norm, an immediate consequence i s t h a t i f and only i f
T
has
M
i s AM-compact
i s so and a l s o any p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r majorized by an
IT1
AM-compact o p e r a t o r i s AM-compact i t s e l f . Another consequence i s t h a t i n some c a s e s t h e s e t of a l l o r d e r bounded compact o p e r a t o r s ( f r o m
is a band i n
Lb(L,M)
. This
w i t h s t r o n g norm u n i t and happens a l s o i f
L*
M
happens, f o r example, i f
L
L
into
M)
is a n AM-space
has o r d e r continuous norm and, d u a l l y , i t
has o r d e r continuous norm and
M
i s an AL-space.
The
proof of t h e d u a l theorem i s based on Synnatschke's theorem (Theorem 115.4) stating that
IT/
*
= /T*l
for a l l
a r e Banach f u n c t i o n s p a c e s such
T E Lb(L,M)
that
every a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r (from
M
L
. Finally,
if
L and
M
has o r d e r continuous norm, then into
M ) i s AM-compact.
In s e c t i o n 124 we i n t r o d u c e o p e r a t o r s napping norm bounded s e t s i n t o almost o r d e r bounded s e t s . These a r e sometimes c a l l e d L-weakly
compact, but
49 7
COMPACT OPERATORS
Ch. 181
we shall call them semi-compact. Evidently, any compact operator is semicompact. Also, if L,M,K and
T2: M
+
tions that
K
are Banach lattices with T,: L
+
M
semi-compact
AM-compact, then it follows immediately from the definiT: L + L
is compact. In particular, if
T2Tl: L + K
compact as well as AM-compact, then T2
is semi-
is compact. It is easy to see that
any positive operator majorized by a semi-compact operator is semi-compact itself. It follows now that if L
is a Banach lattice with order continu-
T are positive operators from L into itself such that T is compact and 0 2 S 2 T , then S inherits both AM-compactness ous norm and
and
S
and semi-compactness from T
so
that, therefore, S2
,
ty the same holds if, instead of L
is compact. By duali-
the dual space L*
nuous norm. The problem arises what happens if neither
has order continor L* has order
L
continuous norm. In this case we have the deeper result that now it follows from 0
5 S 5
T with
T
what happens if both L
compact that and
L*
S3
is compact. Finally, we may ask
have order continuous norm. More generally,
we shall discuss the situation (in section 125) that L lattices such that M
and L*
order bounded operator mapping and only if 0 5 S 5 T
T
and
and M
are Banach
have order continuous norm and T L
into M
. In this case
T
is an
is compact if
is AM-compact as well as semi-compact. It follows that if T
is compact, then
S
is compact. These last results are
among the main Dodds-Fremlin results; the theorems about
S2
and
S 3 (which
are best possible) are due to C.D. Aliprantis and 0. Burkinshaw ([21,1980). The proofs which we present in sections I 2 4 and 125 are somewhat simpler and more elementary than the original proofs (simplifications due to A.R. SchepX It will be observed that even if all norms involved are order continuous,
the set of all semi-compact
operators is not always an ideal. We present an
already classical example in L, but
1
TI
is not. This is caused by the fact that although
compact, 1 TI L*
and
then T Pagter)
M
.
(due to U. Krengel) that T
is compact,
I TI
is AM-
fails to be semi-compact, Finally, we mention that if both
have order continuous norm and
is AM-compact if and only if
T*
T: L
+
M
is order bounded,
is so (a result due to B. de
In section 126 we shall deal with conditions for semi-compactness of an operator. Let L
and
M
be Banach lattices such that, to begin with, M
has only the principal projection property. For any decreasing sequence (B,) Of
of principal bands in M , let order projections. Then I l B
= {O}
(P )
be the corresponding sequence
if and only if
Pn C 0
. We
shall
498
Ch, 181
CHAPTER 18
prove t h a t i f
i s a p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r from
T
L
into
M
IIPnT/I J 0
and
f o r e v e r y sequence P C 0 as e x p l a i n e d , t h e n T i s semi-compact. I n n I I S I I J O f o r e v e r y sequence (Sn) s a t i s f y i n g particular, therefore, i f
C 0
T 2 S
, then
i s semi-compact. As an a p p l i c a t i o n w e g e t a s i m p l e
T
proof of t h e c l a s s i c a l theorem t h a t k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s w i t h a Hille-Tamarkin k e r n e l a r e compact. I f w e r e q u i r e more from /IS
11
M
,
i s a p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r from
T
o r d e r continuousnorm and T
and
L
the condition t h a t
i 0 i s n o t only s u f f i c i e n t , but a l s o necessary. I f both
i s semi-compact i f and o n l y i f
S t i l l assuming t h a t
M
and
L*
/IS
/I
M and L* have into
L
J 0 f o r e v e r y sequence
,
M
then
T 2 S
J 0 .
have o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s norm, w e d i s c u s s i n
s e c t i o n 127 s e v e r a l c o n d i t i o n s (due t o Dodds-Fremlin a g a i n ) , n e c e s s a r y s u f f i c i e n t f o r semi-compactness
s a r i l y p o s i t i v e t h e r e f o r e ) . L e t u s mention h e r e o n l y t h a t n + m
f o r a l l d i s j o i n t norm bounded sequences
elements i n
M*
L and
l/QnTII J 0
+
f o r e v e r y sequence
0
L
-f
($n)
as
of p o s i t i v e
M
i s semi-compact i f and only i f
T
(Q,)
and a l s o i f and o n l y i f
order projections i n
and
0
$n(T~n)
r e s p e c t i v e l y . A s an a p p l i c a t i o n w e prove i n s e c t i o n
128 t h a t t h e o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r Q
(un)
and
( n o t neces-
i s semi-compact
T
i s semi-compact and a l s o i f and o n l y i f
T*
i f and o n l y i f
T
of an o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r
of p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r s i n
/IPnTI/
satisfying
+
0
Pn C 0
M
f o r e v e r y sequence
.
satisfying (P,)
of
I f we assume i n a d d i t i o n t h a t
h a s t h e p r i n c i p a l p r o j e c t i o n p r o p e r t y , t h e r e i s a n even b e t t e r theorem.
I n t h i s case quences
P
T
C 0
i s semi-compact i f and only i f and
J 0
Q
i o n s on p r i n c i p a l bands i n
i s e v i d e n t because
lIPnTI/
IIPnTQnII
of o r d e r p r o j e c t i o n s i n L
+
M
-t
0
f o r a l l se-
and o r d e r p r o j e c t -
r e s p e c t i v e l y . The n e c e s s i t y of t h i s c o n d i t i o n s
0
i s already necessary; i t i s the sufficiency
which i s i m p o r t a n t h e r e . The l a s t theorems a r e due t o P. van E l d i k and
J.J. G r o b l e r (1979). A s an a p p l i c a t i o n , l e t s p a c e s such t h a t
L*
and
M
L
and
M
b e Banach f u n c t i o n
have o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s norm
and l e t
T(x,y)
b e t h e k e r n e l o f t h e o p e r a t o r T from L i n t o M . Then T i s compact i f and only i f
i t i s t r u e f o r a l l sequences
E
J I$
in
X
and
F
C $I
in
Y
t h a t t h e norm of t h e o p e r a t o r w i t h k e r n e l
tends t o zero as p a p e r of W.A.J. L -spaces, P
n
+ m
. This
i s e s s e n t i a l l y t h e main r e s u l t i n a 1963
Luxemburg and A.C.
Zaanen ( f o r O r l i c z s p a c e s , i n c l u d i n g
t h i s goes back t o a p a p e r by T. Ando, 1962). These p a p e r s were
Ch. 18,51221
499
COMPACT OPERATORS
one of the motivations for the later developments in Banach lattices. In section 129 the notions of upper and lower index for a Banach lattice are introduced. Let
1 i
p
5
. The Banach
m
said to have the d -decomposition property if P order bounded disjoint sequence (un) in L+
lattice L (norm
p ) is
dP for every
(p(un))
E
and
is said to have the
L
d -composition property if supIp(~;1 anun)}
for every sequence im P The (an) E dp and every norm bounded disjoint sequence (u,) in L+
.
numbers inf(p:L has the R -decomposition property), P sup(p:L has the d -composition property) P are called the upper index and lower index of L respectively. If o(L) < u(L)
=
s(L)
=
then L has order continuous norm. If
=
decomposition property if and only if L* It follows that
1 If L
Is(,*,\- 1 'I I
=
is called the lower and
1
.
1
1
is of infinite dimension, then s(L)
why
1
+
9
o(L)
s(L)
5
o(L)
9
m
If L
and M
, then
implies that L*
and
norm. Hence, the order bounded operator T: L if
T
is AM-compact. In particular, if L
spaces satisfying o(M) < s(L) into M
, then
1
5
=
is an
a(L) o(L)
= p =
m.
r < p i
m
)
.
M -f
M
and M
-f
M
is semi-compact.
have order continuous is compact if and only are Banach function
any absolute kernel operator from L
is compact (for example, if L
space with
=
are Banach lattices of infinite dimension such that any order bounded operator T: L
o(M) < s(L)
Note that
. This explains
the upper index. If L
abstract L -space (l
has order con-
has the d P has the d -composition property. 4
tinuous norm. Furthermore, for p-' + q-'
IU(J1
, then L* , the space L
> 1
s(L)
m,
is an L -space and M
P
is an L -
122. Compact sets, precompact sets and almost order bounded sets As well-known, the linear operator T the Banach space W set in
V
from the Banach space V
into
is called compact if the image of every norm bounded
is a precompact set in W
. Evidently
it is sufficient that the
500
PRECOMPACT AND ALMOST ORDER BOUNDED
Ch. 18,81221
image of t h e u n i t b a l l i s precompact. We r e c a l l t h a t a s u b s e t o f
is
W
s a i d t o b e precompact whenever i t s c l o s u r e ( w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e norm topology i n
W ) i s compact. For a b e t t e r u n d e r s t a n d i n g we a l s o r e c a l l some pro-
p e r t i e s of compact s e t s and precompact s e t s i n a Banach s p a c e , o r even more g e n e r a l l y i n a complete m e t r i c s p a c e . Hence, l e t s p a c e ; t h e d i s t a n c e between t h e p o i n t s and t h e open b a l l let
(y:d(x,y)
b e a s u b s e t of
S
.
E
x
b e a complete metric
E
and
y
in
w i l l b e denoted by
The s e t
w i l l be
E
d(x,y)
. Furthermore,
B(x;r)
may have one o r s e v e r a l of t h e
S
following properties: S
i s compact, i . e . , e v e r y open cover of
S
i s sequentiazly compact, i . e . ,
quence converging t o a p o i n t of
e v e r y sequence i n
t h a t any f i n i t e
every i n f i n i t e subset
S (with the understanding
automatically has t h i s property).
S
i s totaZZy bounded, i . e . ,
S
f o r any
> 0
E
t h e r e e x i s t a f i n i t e sub-
(x,
,...,xn)
S
i s precompact, i . e . ,
S
i s sequentiaZZy precompact, i . e . , e v e r y sequence i n
set
of
such t h a t
S
i s contained i n
S
-
the closure
S
of
-
Uy=l
B(x.;E)
.
i s compact.
S
v e r g i n g subsequence ( t h e l i m i t need n o t b e a p o i n t of S
h a s a subse-
S
.
S
h a s a t l e a s t one p o i n t of accumulation i n
S
h a s a f i n i t e subcover.
h a s t h e BoZzano-Weierstrass property, i . e . ,
S of
S
S
h a s a con-
S ). Equivalently,
i s s e q u e n t i a l l y compact. h a s t h e conditional BoZzano-Weierstrass property, i . e . , e v e r y i n -
S
f i n i t e subset of
S
not necessarily i n
h a s a t l e a s t one p o i n t of accumulation i n S
,
therefore). Equivalently, S
-- -
s t r a s s property.
These p r c p e r t i e s f o r t h e s u b s e t
-
of
S
sequentiaZly compact
compact
E
-
E (this point
h a s t h e Bolzano-Weier-
are r e l a t e d , a s f o l l o w s
BoZzano-Weierstrass prop
19
cZosed and totalZy bounded.
Hence, i f i t i s n o t knownwhether t h e s e t S i s c l o s e d , t h e f o l l o w i n g c o n d i t i o n s for
are equivalent:
S
precompact
s e q u e n t i a l l y precompact
0
conditiona2 BoZzano-Weierstrass property
-
totaZZy bounded.
The p r o o f s b e l o n g t o t h e e l e m e n t a r y t h e o r y of m e t r i c s p a c e s ; we r e s t r i c t o u r s e l v e s h e r e t o t h e proof t h a t if
S
corrpact. Then point
S
i s s e q u e n t i a l l y comapct i f and o n l y
i s c l o s e d and t o t a l l y bounded. Assume f i r s t t h a t x
1
E S
S
. If
i s o b v i o u s l y c l o s e d . Now, l e t S
is contained i n
t a l l y bounded i s complete. I f n o t , l e t
E
> 0
is sequentially
S
b e given. Choose a
B ( X ~ ; E ), t h e proof t h a t x2
b e a p o i n t of
S
S
outside
is to-
Ch. 1 8 , 5 1 2 2 1
.
B(x~;E)
50 1
COMPACT OPERATORS
If
i s c o n t a i n e d i n t h e union of
S
B(xl;€)
and
B ( x ~ ; E ), t h e
proof i s complete. I f n o t , w e c o n t i n u e i n t h i s way, The p r o c e d u r e ends a f t e r
a f i n i t e number of s t e p s , b e c a u s e o t h e r w i s e t h e sequence b e a sequence i n
converse d i r e c t i o n , w e assume t h a t s = (x1,x2,
. .)
...)
h a s a Cauchy subsequence
S
b e a n a r b i t r a r y sequence i n
.
S
Since
is totally
S
4,
bounded, t h e r e e x i s t s a f i n i t e number o f open b a l l s , each of r a d u s that
such
i s c o n t a i n e d i n t h e union of t h e s e b a l l s . I t f o l l o w s t h a t t h e
S
s1 = (xll,xI2,.,.)
h a s a subsequence
sequence. s
t h e s e b a l l s . S i m i l a r l y , s 1 h a s a subsequence
. We
31
i n a b a l l of r a d i u s (xl
would
i s c l o s e d and t o t a l l y bounded. It i s
S
s u f f i c i e n t now t o prove t h a t e v e r y sequence in Let
(xl ,x2,.
w i t h o u t c o n v e r g e n t subsequence. For bhe p r o o f i n t h e
S
.
c o n t a i n e d i n one of
s 2 = ( X ~ ~ , X ~ ~ , .c o . n. t)a i n e d
c o n t i n u e i n t h i s way. The d i a g o n a l sequence
now a Cauchy sequence.
, X ~ ~ , X ~. ) ~ , i. s
F o r t h e d e f i n i t i o n of a n a l m o s t o r d e r bounded set w e assume t h a t L i s a Banach l a t t i c e (norm p ) . The s u b s e t
bounded s e t i f f o r any g i v e n =
Cp,ql = (g:p
f = f where
+ f2
1
in fl E A
with
and
i s t h e u n i t b a l l of
B
a symmetric o r d e r i n t e r v a l
t o see t h a t t h e s u b s e t f o r any f
E
S
> 0
E
. Indeed,
t h e r e exists -u 5 g < u
u
there exists if
5
E
. In
o t h e r words, S c Cp,ql
such chat
S c [-u,ul
such t h a t
E L+
. Compare
E
. The
+ EB ,
+ EB
. It
i s easy
L+ i s a l m o s t o r d e r bounded i f and o n l y i f u
and n o t e now t h a t
p(h) <
E
A =
i s of t h e form
In t h i s case, t h e r e e x i s t s 05 c o u r s e
s u c h that e v e r y
p(h) <
f = f A u + (f-u)' p{(f-u)+}
i
f E S
p{(f-u)+} <
i s a l m o s t o r d e r bounded and
S
E L+
and
.
[-u,uJ of
S
p(f2) L
i s c a l l e d an almost order
there e x i s t s an order i n t e r v a l
> 0
E
such t h a t every
L
L
of
S
f € S
> 0
E
f o r every
E
i s given, then
i f of the form
f = g+h
with
t h i s decomposition w i t h ( f - u ) + 5 (f-g)+ = h+ 5 / h i
, so
c o n c l u s i o n i n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n i s e v i d e n t .
I t i s a l s o e v i d e n t t h a t t h e a l g e b r a i c sum of a f i n i t e number of almost o r d e r bounded sets i s a l m o s t o r d e r bounded.
THEOREM 122.1. ( i ) The subset
S
o f the Baruch l a t t i c e
almost order bounded i f and o n l y if t h e s e t
IS1 = (1fl:fES)
L
(norm
p)
is
i s aZmost order
bounded. ( i i ) The subset
S
of the Banach Zattice
bounded i f and o n l y i f f o r any p{(lfl-u)+}
E
f o r every
f E
E
s
> 0
.
L
there e x i s t s
p) i s almost order E Li such t h a t
(norm u
502
PRECOMPACT AND ALMOST ORDER BOUNDED
( i ) It i s e v i d e n t t h a t i f
PROOF.
is
IS1
E > 0
. Assume now
there e x i s t s
If1 = g+h w i t h
that
u
fi
0 < f. < u
IS1 i s almost o r d e r bounded, i . e . ,
-u i g 5 u 0
and
i
for
=
1,3
p(h) < ;E
f + i u + Ihl
5
(i=l,2,3,4)
E L+
i s almost o r d e r bounded, t h e n so
S
E L+ such t h a t every
theorem i t follows from exist
Ch. 18,51221
such t h a t
and
0
If1
. By
E
t h e dominated decomposition
0 < f - i u + Ihl
and
f l + f2 = f + , f 3 + f
f . 5 Ihl
f o r any g i v e n
i s of t h e form
IS1
f = ( f l - f 3 ) + (f -f ) w i t h -u 5 f l - f 3 5 u and 2 4 S i s almost o r d e r bounded.
4
-
. Hence
i = 2,4
for
that there
= f
,
p ( f 2 - f 4 ) 5 2p(h) <
E
.
This shows t h a t
i s almost o r d e r bounded i f and only
(ii) S
only i f f o r any f o r every
f
E >
E S
.
0
there exists
E
u
i s so, i . e . ,
IS1
such t h a t
L+
THEOREM 122.2. For subsets of the Banach l a t t i c e
i f and
p I ( l f 1 -u)+l < E
(non
L
p)
the
following inp l i e a t i o n s hold. t o t a l l y bounded
alsmost order bounded * norm bounded.
order bounded
st
For examples showing t h a t no implication i n the converse d i r e c t i o n holds, we r e f e r t o the e x e r c i s e s . PROOF. Assume f i r s t t h a t
S
b e given. There e x i s t
gl,
E >
0
in
Ijy=l
B(gi;E)
such t h a t and
. Hence,
f = g. + f 2
q = sup(gl
f o r any with
,...,gn) , we
f i n d , t h e r e f o r e , t h a t every fl
E
Cp,q]
and
p(f2) < E
i s a t o t a l l y bounded s u b s e t of
... gn 9
f E S
p(f2) < have f E S
. This
in E
such t h a t
S
L
. Let
i s contained
S
t h e r e i s a t l e a s t one of t h e
. Setting
for a l l
p 2 gi 5 q
i s of t h e form shows t h a t
gi
p = i n f ( g l , . . . , g ,)
i
f = f
= 1
,...,n . W e
+ f2
with
1 i s almost o r d e r bounded.
S
I t i s obvious t h a t o r d e r bounded s e t s a r e almost o r d e r bounded and
almost o r d e r bounded s e t s a r e norm bounded. EXERCISE 122.3. We f i r s t p r e s e n t a norm bounded s e t i n a Banach l a t t i c e wh?ch f a i l s t o b e almost o r d e r bounded. For
n
=
1,2,
...
, let
e
be the n c o o r d i n a t e one and
L, ( i . e . , en h a s t h e n-th a l l o t h e r c o o r d i n a t e s z e r o ) . Show t h a t t h e s e t of a l l e i s norm bounded i n n L2 , b u t n o t almost o r d e r bounded. I t follows t h a t t h e u n i t b a l l i n g2 i s n-th u n i t v e c t o r i n t h e space
n o t almost o r d e r bounded.
Ch.
COMPACT OPERATORS
18,91221
EXERCISE 122.4. W e r e c a l l t h a t f o r set
the function
X
a r e a l function
is d e f i n e d by
sgn f
503
sgn f
=
on t h e p o i n t
f
f/lfI
f(x) # 0
where
and z e r o elsewhere. The f u n c t i o n
...) . L e t
i s c a l l e d t h e n-th Rademacher function (n=0,1,2, measure i n function
X
. Neglecting
Ir -r I
t a k e s t h e v a l u e 2 on a s e t of measure
m n z e r o on t h e remaining s e t of measure
...)
S = (rl,r2,
b e Lebesgue
p
a set of measure z e r o , n o t e t h a t f o r
. It
T
II
m > n
f o l l o w s t h a t t h e sequence
does n o t p o s s e s s a p o i n t w i s e (almost everywhere on
converging subsequence. Show t h a t L (X,u) P
f o r any
p
satisfying
1 5 p 2
-.
L2(X,u)
H I N T : From what i s observed above, i t f o l l o w s immediately t h a t
n o t p o s s e s s a subsequence which converges i n norm. T h e r e f o r e , S s e q u e n t i a l l y precompact, i . e . , EXERCISE 122.5. For
e2 . L e t
(~~:n=1,2, )
and
=
S =
E~
S
or,
does
i s not
i s n o t t o t a l l y bounded.
S
n = 1,2,
...
,
let
be t h e n-th u n i t v e c t o r i n en be a sequence of p o s i t i v e numbers such t h a t E ~ 0S
... . Furthermore, l e t un = En e n f o r a l l (ul,u2, ...) i s t o t a l l y bounded (and hence almost C
X )
i s o r d e r bounded (and hence almost
S
o r d e r bounded), b u t n o t t o t a l l y bounded i n t h e Banach l a t t i c e for that matter, i n
the
and t h e v a l u e
m
but n o t o r d e r bounded. Extend t h e r e s u l t t o s p a c e s
n
. Show t h a t
-
o r d e r bounded) i n
Lp
for
1 5 p <
L2 and
a l s o t o t h e s p a c e L (X,u) of t h e previous e x e r c i s e by choosing f o r (en) 2 now an a p p r o p r i a t e d i s j o i n t sequence of non-negative f u n c t i o n s i n L2(X,p) each
e
n
,
of u n i t norm.
HINT: Note t h a t e v e r y subsequence of
S
h a s a subsequence converging
i n norm t o t h e n u l l f u n c t i o n . EXERCISE 122.6. L e t c i s e s and l e t
(X,u)
b u t n o t t o t a l l y bounded and Show t h a t t h e a l g e b r a i c sum bounded, a l t h o u g h
Sl + S2
S2 S
1
S 1 + S2
L2(X,p)
such t h a t
S1
i s o r d e r bounded
i s t o t a l l y bounded b u t n o t o r d e r bounded. + S2
i s n e i t h e r o r d e r bounded n o r t o t a l l y
i s almost o r d e r bounded.
HINT: The a l g e b r a i c sum of
s u b s e t of
b e t h e same as i n t h e two p r e c e d i n g exer-
S1,S2 b e s u b s e t s of
S1
and S2 i s n o t o r d e r bounded. I n f a c t , t h e
c o n s i s t i n g of a l l
fl + f2
, where
f l E S1
i s f i x e d and
AM-CONPACT OPERATORS
504
Ch. 18,91233
r u n s through S2 , f a i l s a l r e a d y t o be o r d e r bounded. S i m i l a r l y , S1 + S f2 2 i s n o t t o t a l l y bounded. S i n c e b o t h S l and S2 a r e almost o r d e r bounded,
"the same h o l d s f o r
S1 + S2
.
( i ) Show t h a t i f i n a Banach l a t t i c e e v e r y o r d e r
EXERCISE 122.7.
bounded s e t i s t o t a l l y bounded, t h e n e v e r y almost o r d e r bounded s e t i s tot a l l y bounded.
eP
( i i ) Show t h a t i n t o t a l l y bounded.
e v e r y almost o r d e r bounded set i s
(lsp<-)
EXERCISE 122.8. In a n AM-space w i t h s t r o n g norm u n i t e v e r y norm bounded s e t i s o r d e r bounded. In t h e converse d i r e c t i a n , show t h a t i f
L
i s a Ba-
nach l a t t i c e i n which e v e r y norm bounded s e t i s almost o r d e r bounded, t h e n there exists i n
norm) L
L
a n e q u i v a l e n t norm such t h a t
( w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h i s new
i s a n AM-space w i t h s t r o n g norm u n i t (communication by B.de P a g t e r ) .
HINT: The c l o s e d u n i t b a l l B i m p l i e s t h e e x i s t e n c e of
e E L+
in
L
i s almost o r d e r bounded, which
such t h a t
B c [-e,el + J B c C-e,e] +
[-he,lel
+
t B c C -3~ e3, ~ e+l a B
,
and s o on. G e n e r a l l y
for
... . It . Since L
n = 1,2,
unit i n
L
follows t h a t
B c [-2e,2el
. Hence,
e
i s a strong
i s a Banach l a t t i c e ( w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e g i v e n norm
1, t h e s p a c e L i s uniformly complete (Theorem 100.4). But t h e n L i s a Banach l a t t i c e w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e e-uniform norm 11 . / I , i . e . , L i s an AM-space w i t h r e s p e c t t o 11 .I/ . S i n c e B c 2 Ee,e 1 and [ -e,e] c p(e)B , p
t h e two norms are e q u i v a l e n t .
123. The band o f AM-compact o p e r a t o r s I n D e f i n t i o n 83.2 t h e n o t i o n of an o r d e r bounded ( l i n e a r ) o p e r a t o r T (from a R i e s z space The o p e r a t o r
T
L
i n t o a Dedekind complete Riesz s p a c e
i s c a l l e d o r d e r bounded i f
T
M ) was defined.
t r a n s f o r m s o r d e r bounded sub-
Ch. 18,91233
s e t s of
i n t o o r d e r bounded s u b s e t s of
L
505
COMPACT OPERATORS
M
. It
f o l l o w s immediately t h a t
e v e r y p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r (and hence any d i f f e r e n c e of two p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r s )
i s o r d e r bounded. S i n c e i.e.,
T
M
i s Dedekind complete, t h e converse h o l d s a s w e l l ,
i s o r d e r bounded i f and o n l y i f
s i t i v e (Theorem 8 3 . 3 ) . The s e t (from L
into
T = TI-T2
with
TI
and
T2
po-
of a l l o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r s
&(L,M)
M ) i s a Dedekind complete R i e s z space (Theorem 8 3 . 4 ) .
If
M
f a i l s t o b e Dedekind complete, t h e d e f i n i t i o n of a n o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r from
L
into
M
Lb (L,M)
remains unchanged and
not n e c e s s a r i l y a Riesz space. Also, i f tain that
T
i s of t h e form
with
T = TI-T2
i s now a v e c t o r s p a c e , b u t
i s o r d e r bounded, i t i s n o t c e r -
T
and
TI
p o s s i b l e , t h e r e f o r e , t h a t t h e v e c t o r s p a c e of a l l
T2
positive.Itis with
T = T,-T2
TI
and
p o s i t i v e ( c a l l e d t h e s p a c e of Jordan operators) i s smaller t h a n t h e
T2 space of a l l o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r s . Note a l r e a d y t h a t i f
L
and
M
are
Banach l a t t i c e s , t h e n e v e r y p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r (and hence e v e r y J o r d a n operat o r ) from
L
into
emphasize t h a t i f
i s norm bounded ( s i n c e
M
bounded o p e r a t o r s (from
L
into
M
i s Banach). Once more, we
M ) are t h e same, and t h e v e c t o r s p a c e of
a l l J o r d a n o p e r a t o r s i s now t h e R i e s z s p a c e call that i f
L
i s Dedekind complete, t h e n J o r d a n o p e r a t o r s and o r d e r
M
$,(L,M)
. Furthermore,
we re-
i s a Banach l a t t i c e w i t h o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s norm, t h e n
M
is
indeed Dedekind complete (Theorem 103.9). DEFINITION 123.1.
i n t o t h e Banach Zattice bounded subsets o f
L
The Jordan operator M
T
from the Banach l a t t i c e
i s said t o be AM-compact i f
i n t o precompact subsets o f
M
T
. Note
L
transforms order t h a t the d e f i -
n i t i o n applies t o Jordan operators only, s o t h a t , therefore, every AM-compact operator i s nomi bounded. It i s evildent t h a t e v e r y compact J o r d a n o p e r a t o r i s AM-compact.
The
converse does n o t h o l d , s i n c e i n g e n e r a l norm bounded s e t s are n o t almost o r d e r bounded, l e t a l o n e o r d e r bounded. I n some c a s e s , however, norm bounded
sets a r e o r d e r bounded. Obvious examples a r e t h e AM-spaces s t r o n g norm u n i t p(f) 5 1
implies
e
, because If1 5 e
then ( i f
. This
p
i s t h e norm i n
e x p l a i n s t h e terminology. I f
AM-space w i t h a s t r o n g norm u n i t , t h e n t h e J o r d a n o p e r a t o r
M ) i s compact i f and o n l y i f
T
L
possessing a
L ) the inequality L
T (from
i s an L
into
i s AM-compact.
The f i r s t r e s u l t a b o u t AM-compactness which w e s h a l l prove now shows t h a t an AM-compact o p e r a t o r t r a n s f o r m s n o t o n l y o r d e r bounded s e t s i n t o p r e -
AM-COMPACT OPERATORS
506
Ch. 18,51231
compact s e t s , b u t transforms almost o r d e r bounded s e t s i n t o precompact s e t s a s well. THEOREM 123.2. The Jordan operator
I i s AM-compact i f and only i f
M
the Baruch l a t t i c e
order bounded subsets of
be AM-compact.
T
almost o r d e r bounded s u b s e t of
and
L
by
M
L
and
E
in
S1
L
such t h a t
IlTll i s t h e o p e r a t o r norm of
since
T
S c S
1
+ E
and
BL
respecti-
BM
~
i s an
S
E
. There
,Bwhere ~
E
T (as observed e a r l i e r , T
1
T(S)
e x i s t s an o r d e r =
E / { ~ ~ I T \ Iand }
i s norm bounded
i s a Jordan o p e r a t o r ) . Then T ( S ) c T ( s ~ )+ E ~ T ( )B c T ( s ~ )+ L
The s e t
.
i s given, t h e image
> 0
into
L
transforms almost M
I t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o show t h a t i f
can b e covered by f i n i t e l y many b a l l s of r a d i u s interval
T
i n t o precompact subsets of
L
PROOF. Denote t h e u n i t b a l l s i n v e l y and l e t
T (from the Banach l a t t i c e
T(SI)
E ~ I I T I I B ~=
T ( s ~ )+
~
.B
~
i s precompact ( i n view of t h e d e f i n i t i o n of AM-compactness).
Therefore, T ( S I )
can b e covered by f i n t e l y many b a l l s of r a d i u s
f o l l o w s now from
T(S) c T ( S I ) + ~
many b a l l s of r a d i u s
E
.
E
tBh a t~
T(S)
;E
. It
can b e covered by f i n i t e l y
The compact J o r d a n o p e r a t o r s (from t h e Banach l a t t i c e Banach l a t t i c e
E
L
i n t o the
M ) f o m a v e c t o r space because t h e a l g e b r a i c sum of two
precompact s e t s i s precompact. S i m i l a r l y , t h e AM-compact o p e r a t o r s form a v e c t o r space. One of t h e main r e s u l t s t o be proved i n t h e p r e s e n t s e c t i o n
i s t h a t i f t h e norm i n form a band i n
L(L,M)
M
i s o r d e r continuous, t h e n t h e AM-compact o p e r a t o r s
. Note
t h a t t h i s s t a t e m e n t makes s e n s e because
M
i s now Dedekind complete (Theorem 103.9), and t h e r e f o r e t h e space of Jordan o p e r a t o r s i s now i d e n t i c a l w i t h t h e Dedekind complete Riesz space
Lb(L,M)
I n t h e proof we s h a l l need an i n e q u a l i t y which i n a c e r t a i n s e n s e i s somewhat s t r o n g e r t h a n t h e t r i a n g l e i n e q u a l i t y . The i n e q u a l i t y s t a t e s t h a t i f and
g
a r e a r b i t r a r y elements of a Riesz space
The proof follows by o b s e r v i n g t h a t
L
,
then
f
ch. 18,11231
COMPACT OPERATORS
507
where we have used one of t h e Birkhoff i n e q u a l i t i e s and t h e t r i a n g l e ine q u a l i t y . A f u r t h e r r e s u l t we s h a l l need w a s a l r e a d y mentioned i n E x e r c i s e 83.31. We r e p e a t t h i s r e s u l t i n t h e f o l l o w i n g l e m a ; f o r t h e proof we r e f e r t o t h e h i n t s g i v e n i n t h e exercise. LEMMA 123.3. Let
L
be an arbitrary Riesz space and M
compZete Riesz space. Furthermore, Zet from
L
i n t o M and l e t E
u
=
\ Cn(T I 1u .1) A ( T2u i ):n
is downwards directed and i n f THEOREM 123.4. Let
L
E
u
L
and
T2
cnu
variabze,
l i
be p o s i t i v e operators
=u, a12 uiEL+)
= (T AT ) ( u 1 2
M be Banach h t t i c e s ( n o n s
and
respectiveZy) such t h a t t h e norm AM-compact operators from
TI
. Then t h e s e t
u E L+
a Dedekind
A
and
p
A
i n M i s order continuous. Then t h e
i n t o M form
a band i n
.
$,(L,M)
PROOF. As observed a l r e a d y , t h e AM-compact o p e r a t o r s form a l i n e a r subspace of
$,(L,M)
d i s j o i n t operators i n and
T2
the s e t
. We
s h a l l prove now f i r s t t h a t i f
h(L,M)
TI+T2
such t h a t
TI
and
T2
a r e AM-compact. It i s s u f f i c i e n t t o show t h a t f o r any g i v e n (T1v:Osvsu)
i s a precompact s u b s e t of
are
i s AM-compact, t h e n M
. According
T1 u
E L+
t o the last
lemma, i f we w r i t e n :n v a r i a b l e , c l u i = u, a l l uiEL+\
1’
then T2
inf E
= ( I T I I ~ I T 2) ( u ) = 0 ; t h e l a s t e q u a l i t y h o l d s because
a r e d i s j o i n t . Hence, s i n c e t h e norm
a downwards d i r e c t e d s e t , w e have
now a l s o given, t h e r e e x i s t such t h a t
u1,u2
i s o r d e r continuous and
A
A(EU) .L 0
,...,un
TI
in
. It L+
follows t h a t i f with
EU E
> 0
u +u +...+ u = u 1 2 n
and
is is
508
AM-COMPACT OPERATORS
Ch. 18,11231
Using t h e dominated decomposition p r o p e r t y we s e e t h a t f o r e v e r y
0 i v S u
fying and
0 S v . i u. 1
1
there e x i s t
i = 1,2,
f o r every
v1,v2,
. By
( i = 1 , 2 ,...,n)
...,n
such t h a t
v
=
satis-
v +v +...+ v
1 2 n there e x i s t s T1+T2 of t h e o r d e r i n t e r v a l [O,uil
t h e assumption on
a f i n i t e subset
D.
t h e r e i s a member
0 i v' i u.
such t h a t f o r e v e r y
...,v
v
I n p a r t i c u l a r t h e r e e x i s t s f o r every
v.
w
of
w.
an element
1
E
satisfying
D.
D.
1
such t h a t
(3) I t f o l l o w s by means o f t h e i n e q u a l i t y ( 1 )
i
holds f o r every
, so
1,2,. . . , n
=
above t h a t
Note t h a t on account of ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) t h e norm o f t h e r i g h t hand s i d e does n o t exceed
. Writing
E
X'T
v-T w'
\ I
Let
D
I /
+ w2 +
w = w = h(Zn
\ I
T (v -a')' S X'En I i i J \ I
w , + w2 +
be t h e f i n i t e s e t of a l l
through
D.
0 5 v 5 u
(i=1,2,
...,n ) . We
-
TI
compact. Hence,
, we
have t h e r e f o r e
IT 1 ( v 1 . - w1. ) I > <
... + w
for
w.
have proved now t h a t f o r e v e r y
t h e r e e x i s t s a n element
shows t h a t t h e s e t
... + wn
(T,v:Oiv
w E D
E
.
running
v
satisfying
.
such t h a t
X(T1v-T w) < E This 1 i s t o t a l l y bounded, i . e . , t h e s e t i s p r e - , )
i s now a l s o AM-compact.
i s AM-compact. Of c o u r s e , T2
We may conclude from t h e above t h a t t h e AM-compact o p e r a t o r s form a Riesz s u b s p a c e of and
T
= -T
-
$,(L,M)
. Indeed,
and i t f o l l o w s t h a t
if T+
2 For t h e n e x t p a r t of t h e p r o o f , l e t
o p e r a t o r s such t h a t
0 i T
+
T
in
i s AM-compact, we p u t
T and
T-
b e a s e t of AM-compact
(Ta:aE{a})
Lb(L,M)
T I = T+
a r e AM-compact.
. Let
u
E L+
and
E
> 0
be
Ch. 18,51231
COMPACT OPERATORS
given. It f o l l o w s from f o r some
T u
. Hence
uo E {a)
0 5 v < u
holds f o r a l l
+
in
Tu
that
. By
L
h(Tu-Tau)
E
(Tv:OSv
. In o t h e r words,
+
, so
0
assumption t h e s e t
be covered by f i n i t e l y many open b a l l s of r a d i u s the s e t
509
4.
A(Tu-T
a0
u) <
(Tanv:O
, so
;E
can
i n view of ( 4 )
can be covered by f i n i t e l y many open b a l l s of r a d i u s
i s t o t a l l y bounded. This shows t h a t
(Tv:OSvSu)
is
T
AM-compact. For t h e proof t h a t t h e AM-compact o p e r a t o r s form an i d e a l i n i t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove now t h a t i f
then
0 5 S S T
i s AM-compact. We may assume t h a t
S
T > 0
and
. It
follows from t h e f i r s t
p a r t of t h e p r e s e n t proof t h a t U i s AM-compact whenever 0 i . e . , e v e r y componentof
,
Lb(L,M)
i s AM-compact,
T
U 5 T and U A(T-U) =O.
T i s AM-compact. Hence, every f i n i t e l i n e a r combination
of components of T i s AM-compact. By F r e u d e n t h a l ' s s p e c t r a l theorem t h e r e e x i s t s asequence i n L,,(L,M).
...)
of t h e s e l i n e a r combinations such t h a t O C S f S h o l d s n I t follows from t h e p r e c e d i n g p a r t of t h e proof t h a t S i s AM-compact.
(Sn:n=1,2,
F i n a l l y , f o r t h e proof t h a t t h e i d e a l of AM-compact o p e r a t o r s i s a band, 0 < T
let
+
T
with a l l
T
AM-compact. A s proved above, T
AM-compact. Hence, t h e AM-compact o p e r a t o r s form a band i n
M
i s o r d e r continuous i s due t o D.H.
.
Lb(~,~)
The r e s u l t t h a t t h e AM-compact o p e r a t o r s form a band i n norm i n
i s now a l s o
L(L,M)
i f the
Fremlin (1976). H i s o r i g i n a l
proof was r a t h e r complicated. A few months l a t e r P. Dodds o b t a i n e d a more d i r e c t p r o o f . The method of proof g i v e n above, due t o A.R.
Schep, i s some-
what s i m p l e r t h a n Dodds' p r o o f , although i t i s hased on t h e same i d e a s . F o r t h e work of Dodds and Fremlin, c o n t a i n i n g t h e i r main r e s u l t t h a t compactness of and
i m p l i e s corrpactness of
T M
S
if
0 S S
S
T
in
$,(L,M)
and both
L*
have o r d e r continuous norm, we r e f e r t o t h e i r paper (C11,1979). We
w i l l come back t o t h i s r e s u l t and r e l a t e d r e s u l t s i n t h e n e x t s e c t i o n s , b u t f i r s t we c o l l e c t some f u r t h e r p r o p e r t i e s of AM-compactness
i n the following
theorem. THEOREM 123.5.
and
M
( i ) If L
i s an AM-space possessing a strong norm unit
i s a Banaeh L a t t i c e w i t h o r d e r continuous norm, then t h e s e t o f aLL
order bomded compact operators (from L
into M
is a band i n
$(L,M)
.
AM-COMPACT OPERATORS
5 10
( i i ) If L
M
and
Ch. 18,91231
are Banach l a t t i c e s and if $ E L*
and
h E M
are given, then the f i n i t e rank operator T: L + M , defined by Tf = $ ( f ) . h for al7, f E L , i s AM-compact. Hence,if M has order continuous norm, the ~~ by the operators of f i n i t e rank i s contained in band ( L * @ M )generated the band of AM-compact operators. PROOF.
( i ) As already observed, any subset of
i s o r d e r bounded i f
L
T E L (L,M) i s compact i f and b The s e t of o r d e r bounded compact o p e r a t o r s
and only i f i t is norm bounded. Hence, any only if
i s AM-compact.
T
c o i n c i d e s , t h e r e f o r e , with the band of AM-compact o n e r a t o r s . ( i i ) Note f i r s t t h a t t h e given operator (because
L* = L-
is a Jordan operator. Since
T
i s Banach), the given l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l
L
transforms any o r d e r bounded s e t i n
bounded. Hence, $
is o r d e r
$
i n t o an order
L
bounded subset of t h e r e a l numbers. Since any o r d e r bounded s e t of r e a l numbers i s precompact, t h i s shows t h a t the given o p e r a t o r
i s AM-compact.
T
Our next theorem i s a dual of p a r t ( i ) of the l a s t theorem. I t says that i f
L*
has order continuous norm and
o r d e r bounded compact o p e r a t o r s (from
i s an AL-space,
M
into
L
then the
M ) form a band i n
I n the proof we s h a l l need the c l a s s i c a l r p s u l t t h a t an operator a Banach space
i n t o a Banach space
V
Banach a d j o i n t o p e r a t o r
T* (from W+
i s compact i f and only i f i t s
W into
V* ) is compact. Furthermore,
we s h a l l make use of t h e v a r i a n t of Synnatschke's Theorem 115.4: I f that and i f
and
L
a r e Banach l a t t i c e s (norms
M
TI
ticular
and
belong t o
T2
for a l l
IT/* = IT*l
THEOREM 1 2 3 . 6 .
If
continuous norm and
M
E $,(L,M)
0
5
that
T* S 5 T
(T*$)(f) = $(Tf)
0 5 S 5 T
$,(L,M) and
implies
T
L" = L*
, holding
i s p o s i t i v e whenever in
and
h ) such
i s an AL-space),
(T VT ) * = TT v Tt 1 2
.
i n t o M I i s a band in
PROOF. We f i r s t r e c a l l t h a t
f o r e from
then
p
M
. In
par-
L i s a Banach l a t t i c e such that L* has order i s an AL-space, then the s e t of a l l order bounded
compact operators (from L
that
,
$(L,M) T
as s t a t e d i n
theorem
i s o r d e r continuous ( t h i s holds, t h e r e f o r e , i f
h
L(L,M).
from
T
T
M"
and
for all
$(L,M) =
H
f € L
.
. It
follows there-
and a l l
$
E
i s p o s i t i v e . It i s a l s o c l e a r t h a t
0 5 S* S r*
i s compact. Then
in
0 5 S*
= M-
h(M*,L*) . Assume now
5
T*
and
T*
is
,
18,11231
Ch.
COMPACT OPERATORS
511
P
compact. Furthermore, i n view of Theorem 118.4, t h e space
i s an AM-
space w i t h a s t r o n g norm u n i t , so by p a r t ( i ) of t h e l a s t theorem t h e ope-
s*
rator
i s compact. Thus
i t s e l f i s compact. Assume now t h a t
S
i s compact. Then
E L(L,M)
T
i s compact, and t h e r e f o r e , s i n c e ( a g a i n
T*
by p a r t ( i ) of t h e l a s t theorem) t h e o r d e r bounded compact o p e r a t o r s from into
@
form a band, IT*[
L*
i s compact. But then T
T+
and
IT*l
, so
= ITI*
ITI*
i s compact. We have t h u s proved t h a t compactness
IT1
i m p l i e s compactness of
of
i s compact. But
. Conversely,
IT1
if
i s compact, then
IT1
a r e compact by t h e f i r s t p a r t of t h e p r e s e n t p r o o f , and s o
T-
T
i s compact. It h a s t h u s been shown a l r e a d y t h a t t h e o r d e r bounded compact o p e r a t o r s from
L
Finally, l e t Then
0
into 0
form an i d e a l i n
M T
5
, so
f o r a l l a~ E L+
T u 4 Tu
0 E M* (note t h a t every
5
Lb (L,M)
in
4 T
@ E
P
that
. This
u E L+
pact, so
T*
shows t h a t
T:
Ta
.
compact f o r a l l
4 T*
4 (T*@)(u)
in
i s compact. This shows t h a t
Lb(@,L*) T
a
.
for a l l
@(Tau) 4 @(Tu)
i s o r d e r continuous s i n c e
continuous norm). I n o t h e r words, (T:@)(u) and
L(L,M)
with
f o r every
. All
has order
M
E @
@
are com-
T*,
i s compact.
The l a s t theorem h a s a v a r i a n t which can b e a p p l i e d t o t h e t h e o r y of k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s . We r e c a l l t h a t i f N
the order dual on
L
therefore
Li
=
L :
p'
i s a Riesz s p a c e , then t h e band i n
c o n s i s t i n g of a l l o r d e r continuous l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l s
L
i s denoted by
b e denoted by
L
LL
. If
L
i s a Banach l a t t i c e , t h e n
. The r e s t r i c t i o n of t h e norm p* i n . I n s t e a d of r e q u i r i n g o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y
L-
L* of
l a s t theorem, we s h a l l now only r e q u i r e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of
=
to p* p'
L*
and
L:
will
as i n the
. Instead
of proving t h a t t h e o r d e r bounded compact o p e r a t o r s form a band, w e prove now t h a t t h e o r d e r continuous compact Operators form a band. THEOREM 123.7. If
L
i s a Banach l a t t i c e such that t h e mrm
continuous compact operators (from L i n t o M I i s a band i n contained i n t h e band L
P'
in
i s order continuous and M i s an AL-space, then the s e t of a l l order
L :
L,(L,M)
$,(L,M)
,
of a l l order continuous operators (from
i n t o M ). PROOF. A s i n t h e l a s t theorem, we have
L" = L*
shows a l r e a d y t h a t , f o r any o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r dual
T"
i s t h e same a s t h e Banach d u a l
TC
. Also,
and T: L
since
+
M-= fi M M
,
. cis
the order
i s an AL-space,
512
AM- COMPACT OPERATORS
t h e norm i n
M
T
=
the order dual
t h e r e f o r e , T*
4
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s . Hence, e v e r y
continuous, i . e . , M * = M" tinuous
Ch.
maps
n T-
n maps
into
M*
.
= M*
M"
By Theorem 9 7 . 1 , M,"
. Since
L,*
E M-
into
Li
. In
=
M*
18,11231
i s order
f o r any o r d e r conthe present case,
i s an AM-space p o s s e s s i n g
M*
a s t r o n g norm u n i t and i s a Banach l a t t i c e w i t h o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s norm, L: w e may a p p l y Theorem 1 2 3 . 5 ( i ) t o conclude t h a t t h e s e t of a l l o r d e r bounded
.
compact o p e r a t o r s (from M* i n t o L* ) i s a band i n h(M*,L:) This makes n i t p o s s i b l e now t o show t h a t t h e s e t of a l l o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s compact operat o r s (from
L
M ) i s a band i n
into
,
$,(L,M)
t h e l a s t theorem, r e p l a c i n g everywhere
L*
by
by i m i t a t i n g t h e proof of L:
.
We r e t u r n f o r a moment t o o p e r a t o r s of f i n i t e r a n k , mapping t h e Banach lattice
L
i n t o t h e Banach l a t t i c e ' M
then the operator
T: L + M
,
. If
d e f i n e d by
$
and
E L*
Tf = $ ( f ) . h
h
E M a r e given, f E L , is
for a l l
4 E LIT
J o r d a n and compact (hence norm bounded). I f t h e s t r o n g e r c o n d i t i o n
is s a t i s f i e d (i.e.,
4
o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s ) , then
T
i s o r d e r continuous and
compact. We F e c a l 1 t h a t e v e r y f i n i t e l i n e a r combination ( w i t h r e a l c o e f f i c i e n t s ) of o p e r a t o r s of t h i s t y p e i s c a l l e d a f i n i t e rank o p e r a t o r . The
s e t of a l l f i n i t e t a n k o p e r a t o r s i s denoted by concerns f u n c t i o n a l $ from compact and e v e r y
T E LE
LE ) . Hence, e v e r y 0
M
L* 0 M ( o r T E L* @ M
if it
L* B M
i s J o r d a n and
i s o r d e r continuous and compact. T h i s l e a d s
now t o t h e f o l l o w i n g c o r o l l a r y . COROLLARY 123.8. M
form a band
A
(i) I f the compact Jordan operators from
, then t h e band
This s i t u a t i o n o c c m s i f e i t h e r M
and
(L*@M)dd
L
into
i s contained i n the band A
.
i s an AM-space w i t h a strong norm u n i t
L
has order continuous norm o r
L*
has order continuous norm and
M
is an AL-space. ( i i ) I f t h e order continuous and compact Jordan operators from M
form a band
B
, then the band
!l%is s i t u a t i o n occurs i f e i t h e r and
M
(L2M)dd L
L into
i s contained i n the band B
.
is an AM-space with a strong norm u n i t
has order continuous norm o r
L:
has order continuous norm and
M
i s an AL-space. The s i t u a t i o n i n p a r t ( i i ) of t h e l a s t c o r o l l a r y o c c u r s i n p a r t i c u l a r
if L
and
M
are Banach f u n c t i o n s p a c e s . L e t
M(X,u)
and
M(Y,v) b e t h e
Riesz s p a c e s of a l l r e a l measurable f u n c t i o n on t h e a - f i n i t e measure s p a c e s (X,A,u)
and
(Y,Z,v)
r e s p e c t i v e l y and l e t
L
and
M
be ideals i n
M(Y,v)
18,51231
Ch.
and
COMPACT OPERATORS
r e s p e c t i v e l y . Without l o s s of g e n e r a l i t y w e may assume t h a t
M(X,p)
t h e c a r r i e r of L
and
513
is
L
Y
and t h e c a r r i e r of
M
is
X
.
Assume a l s o t h a t
are Banach l a t t i c e s w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e norms
M
spectively (i.e.,
p
and
,A
re-
and
M
a r e Banach f u n c t i o n s p a c e s ) . Note t h a t by
Theorem 1 1 2 . 1 t h e s p a c e s
L
and
t h e c a r r i e r of
L
i n our case
LIT
L i = L*
have t h e s a m e c a r r i e r , i . e . ,
i s a l s o equal t o
. Then
Y
Theorem 95.1
may b e a p p l i e d , s t a t i n g t h a t t h e s e t of a l l a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s (from L
into
M ) i s e x a c t l y t h e band
(Lz@M)dd
. Hence,
i f t h e c o n d i t i o n s men-
t i o n e d i n p a r t ( t i ) of t h e l a s t c o r o l l a r y a r e satisfied, e v e r y a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r (from given t h a t
M
into
L
M ) i s compact. Note t h a t i f i t i s only
c o n t i n u o u s norm, t h e n i t f o l l o w s from Theorem
has order
1 2 3 . 5 ( i i ) t h a t e v e r y a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r (from
L
M ) i s AM-
into
compact.
If
and M are Banach f u n c t i o n spaces such t h a t e i t h e r L i s an Lm-space and M has order continuous norm o r the associate space LE has order continuous norm and M i s an L -space, then 1 every absolute kernel operator ( f r o m L i n t o M I i s compact. This holds THEOREM 123.9.
L
i n p a r t i c u l a r f o r absolute kernel operators from
Lm
into
.
L
P
( Isp< - )
If it i s o n l y known t h a t M has order conP tinuous norm, then every absolute kerne2 operator (from L i n t o M I is
and from
(p>l) into
L
Ll
AM-compact. The Theorems 123.6 and 123.7 ( w i t h t h e a p p l i c a t i o n s mentioned i n Coroll a r y 123.8 and Theorem 123.9) are due t o A.R.
l i z a t i o n o f Theorem 123.9 i s c o n t a i n e d i n C o r o l l a r y EXERCISE 123.10. According t o Theorem 123.8, i f T: L
(p>l)
-+
P pact. Also, i f bounded, t h e n
Ll
or
T
129.8. T: Lm + L
is an absolute kernel operator, then
P
(p<-) T
or
i s com-
T: L (p<-) + Lm o r T : L l + Lp ( p > l ) and T i s norm P T i s a n a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r (Theorem 98.2 and C o r o l l a -
r Y 98.4; t h e c a s e either
and
A genera-
Schep ([41,1980).
Ll
-+
L (p>l) P
i s Dunford's theorem). Assume now t h a t
DODDS-FREMLIN AND ALIPMNTIS-BUFXINSHAW THEOREMS
514
where
i s a n a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r and
TI
Ch. 18,51241
i s norm bounded. Show
Tp
T2TI i s a compact a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r . S i m i l a r l y , show t h a t i f
that
or
m
I1
Ll
m
Lp ( P > l )
T I i s norm bounded and
where
l2
L1
’
i s an absolute k e r n e l o p e r a t o r , then
T2
i s a compacf a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r . More g e n e r a l r e s u l t s a r e con-
T2TI
t a i n e d i n E x e r c i s e 129.10.
EXERCISE 123.11. L e t and T2
T2: M
+
be Banach l a t t i c e s and l e t
L,M,K
TI: L
be J o r d a n o p e r a t o r s . Show t h a t i f one a t l e a s t of
K
i s AM-compact, t h e n
T2TI: L
+
K
+
M and
TI
i s AM-compact.
124. Theorems of Dodds-Fremlin and Aliprantis-Burkinshaw
Let
L
and
M
be Banach l a t t i c e s . One of t h e main theorems w e s h a l l
prove i n t h e p r e s e n t s e c t i o n i s t h a t i f
norms and and
T
S
and
T
a r e o p e r a t o r s from
i s compact, t h e n
S
L*
L
into
M
have o r d e r continuous
M
such t h a t
continuous norm ( b u t n o t alwasy imply t h a t L
nor
L*
compact i m p l i e s t h a t due t o C.D.
L* S
T
S 5 T
5
S
in
L L
i s i t s e l f compact. I f
L
has order
0 5 S 5 T
T
compact does
has n o t ) , then
i s compact, b u t now
S2
with
i s compact. F i n a l l y , i f
h a s o r d e r continuous norm, t h e n S3
0
I n p a r t i c u l a r we f i n d t h a t i f
have o r d e r continuous norm, t h e n any p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r
dominated by a compact o p e r a t o r
neither
and
i s a l s o compact. This r e s u l t i s due t o
P.G. Dodds and D. H. Fremlin ([ll,l979). and
L*
0 5 S 5 T
i s compact. These r e s u l t s a b o u t
A l i p r a n t i s and 0. Burkinshaw ([2]1980).
S2
with and
S3
T are
The AM-compact o p e r a t o r s
p l a y a n i m p o r t a n t p a r t , as w e l l a s o p e r a t o r s mapping norm bounded s e t s o n t o almost o r d e r bounded s e t s . A s observed i n Theorem 123.2, AM-compact o p e r a t o r s map almost o r d e r bounded s e t s o n t o precompact s e t s . I t is. obvious now t h a t
Ch. 18,11241
if
L,M,K
5 I5
COMPACT OPERATORS
a r e Banach l a t t i c e s and T,:
L
M
-f
,
T2: M
+
K
a r e operators possessing the properties t h a t onto almost o r d e r bounded s e t s and
maps norm bounded sets
TI
i s AM-compact,
T2
then
T2TI: L
-f
K
i s compact. a r e Banach l a t t i c e s ; t h e norm c l o s e d u n i t
In what f o l l o w s , L,M,N,K b a l l of
L
norm i n
L
for
M,N
w i l l b e denoted by
, the and
set
BL
. As
(fEL:p(f)iE)
before, i f
E
> 0
w i l l be denoted by
and
.
E B ~ Similarly
.
K
is the
p
LEMMA 124.1. Let 0 i S i T
.If
then so does
T S
.
S and T be operators from L i n t o M s a t i s f y i n g maps mrm bounded s e t s onto a h o s t order bounded s e t s ,
PROOF. It i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t
maps t h e u n i t b a l l
S
onto
BL
-
.
an almost o r d e r bounded s e t . Let B+ = (fEB :f>O) and BL = (fEBL:f
.
.
f o r e , t o show t h a t
S(Bi)
i s almost o r d e r bounded. By h y p o t h e s i s
i s almost o r d e r bounded, i . e . , such t h a t f o r any A(h)
i E
u E BE
(where
E
we have
> 0
i s given, there e x i s t s w i t h -w i g i w
Tu = g+h
i s t h e norm i n t h e space
h
(Tu-w)+ i (g-w) so
if
(Su-w)+ i (Tu-w)'
i Ihl
+
+
+ h
, and
+
= h
T(Bi)
w E M'
and
M ). I t f o l l o w s t h a t
S l h l ,
therefore
A{(Su-w)+)
i
E
. This
shows
that Su = w
with
0 i w
A
SU
A
S w
Su + (Su-w)+
and
A{(Su-w)+}
c E
S(B+) i s c o n t a i n e d i n t h e a l g e b r a i c sum L almost o r d e r bounded. COROLLARY 124.2. I f the operators
S
. In o t h e r words,
t h e image
r0,wl + E B , ~ i.e.,
and
T
(from L
S(Bt)
into M
is
)
sa-
516
DODDS-FREMLIN AND ALIPRANTIS-BURKINSHAW THEOREMS
0
tisfy
2
S 5 T
T
and
i s compact, then
Ch. 18,11243
maps norm bounded s e t s
S
onto almost order bounded s e t s . PROOF. The image T(B ) i s precompact, and t h e r e f o r e T(BL) i s a l m o s t L o r d e r bounded. But then S(BL) i s a l m o s t o r d e r bounded i n view of what we have j u s t proved. THEOREM 124.3 ( i ) If the operators
S2: M
and
+
, and
K
i f the image
i s AM-compact, then ( i i ) Let
that
0 S S
1
TI
S
mapping M i n t o in
K
S2SI: L
and
S1
.
T,
+
S1: L
satisfy
S2
such t h a t
S2 and
0 5 S
2 TI
0 5 S s T
continuous, then compactness of
S2
T
and L
in
such
T2
be p o s i t i v e operators
T2
be compact. Then
. Furthermore,
T2
5
M
l e t the norm
and the norm i n
implies compactness of
S2S1 i s
L i s order
.
S'
PROOF. ( i ) I t f o l l o w s immediately from t h e h y p o t h e s e s t h a t
i s precompact, i . e . ,
M
K i s compact.
be order continuous and l e t
compact. In p a r t i c u l a r , i f
-f
i s almost order bomded and
be p o s i t i v e operators mapping L i n t o
Similarly, l e t
K
and
S1
S 1 (BL)
S2SI(BL)
i s a compact o p e r a t o r .
S2S1
i s a l m o s t o r d e r bounded. F u r t h e r 1 L i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s , t h e AM-compact o p e r a t o r s
( i i ) By C o r o l l a r y 124.2 above, S (B ) more, s i n c e t h e norm i n from
M
into
K
K
form a band (Theorem 123.4). Hence, s i n c e
p a c t (by h y p o t h e s i s , T 2 rator
S2
i s AM-compact.
i s even compact) and s i n c e
i s AM-com-
T2
< T2 , t h e ope-
0 < S
S2SI i s
I n view of p a r t ( i ) i t f o l l o w s t h a t
compact. The same i n c l u s i o n as i n p a r t ( i i ) h o l d s i f i n s t e a d of assuming o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of t h e norm i n L*
K
.
THEOREM 124.4. Let
n m t h a t the norm i n
L*
S.
we assume o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of t h e norm i n
(i=1,2)
PROOF. The p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r s satisfy
0 5 S* < T;
satisfy
0 < S* < T*
2 1
1
T.
and
( i = 1 , 2 ) be a s above and assume
i s order continuous. Then again
. Similarly, . Since T7
S;
S.7
and
and and T;
T;
T*
I
map map
K*
M*
S2SI i s compact. into
into
L*
M*
and they and t h e y
are compact and t h e norm i n
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s , t h e l a s t theorem shows t h a t
SyS;
L*
i s compact, i . e . ,
Ch. 18,51243
i s compact. I t follows t h a t
(S2S1)*
517
COMFACT OPERATORS
i s compact.
S2SI
In t h e n e x t theorem we drop a l l assumptions about o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of norms. THEOREM 124.5. Let
and Si ( i = 1 , 2 , 3 ) be operators s a t i s f y i n g
Ti
0 5 Si 5 T.
Furthermore, l e t
S3S2SI: L
pact. Then
and
T
K
M
,
(i=1,2,3)
Ti
0
5
be corn
S 5 T
and
i s a compact o p e r a t o r mapping
TI
.
'M
Hence, i f
E >
0
S (B+) i s an alrrost I L i s given, t h e r e e x i x t s
A,
I
(B+) c [-w,wl L
+ SIBM for
be the principal ideal i n
E
1
=E/(II~,II.IIS
g e n e r a t e d by
M
w
II
2 )
. The
ideal
a normed Riesz space w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e w-uniform norm, d e f i n e d by W
L
i t f o l l o w s from C o r o l l a r y 124.2 above t h a t
s
llfll
in L
such t h a t
E 'M
Let
s3
i s compact.
0 5 S1 5 T I
o r d e r bounded s u b s e t of w
( i = 1 , 2 , 3 ) and Zet a22
i s compact. I n p a r t i c u l a r , i f S3
i s compact, then
PROOF. Since into
-f
s2
s1 L-M-N-K.
and
=
inf(A:lfl
for a l l
f
E
. This
A,
norm i s --additive
A
W
is
on
i s Banach w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e t h u s i n t r o d u c e d
and we show now t h a t
A, norm. For t h i s purpose, l e t
(fn:n=1,2,
...)
be a Cauchy sequence, i . e . , ,
.
we have If -f 1 5 6w f o r s u f f i c i e n t l y l a r g e m,n n m A(f -f ) 5 6.A(w) , i . e . , ( f n ) i s a Cauchy sequence w i t h n m r e s p e c t t o t h e norm A i n M Since M i s Banach, t h e r e e x i s t s an
f o r any given
6 > 0
It follows t h a t
element
f
.
E M such t h a t
A ) . It f o l l o w s now from n 2 m for
fn fm
t h a t t h e norm l i m i t large
m
, and
hence
llf\lw
. The
-
of
f
Banach d u a l
6w 5 f
A,
A(f) 5 h(w)
,
C-w,wl. i.e.,
fn
f + 6w m satisfies
5
for sufficiently large
i s an AM-space w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e w-uniA :
Note t h a t t h e c l o s e d u n i t b a l l of order interval
n
f (with r e s p e c t t o t h e norm
f m - 6 w 5 f 5 f + 6w m i s t h e w-uniform l i m i t of t h e sequence (f,)
f
I t h a s been shown t h u s t h a t
form
converges t o
h a s t h e r e f o r e a n o r d e r continuous norm.
A,
(with respect t o
Ilfllw )
This i s a s u b s e t of t h e s e t of a l l
f
is the satisfying
i t i s a n o m b o u n d e d s e t (with r e s p e c t t o A ) . Now con-
518
DODDS-FREMLIN AND ALIPRANTIS-BURKINSHAW THEOREMS
s i d e r the operator
T2
and i t s r e s t r i c t i o n t o
A,
. Since
Ch. 18,91241
i s compact
T2
by h y p o t h e s i s , t h e image of e v e r y norm bounded s e t ( w i t h r e s p e c t t o precompact i n N.
N ; i n p a r t i c u l a r , t h e image of
I n o t h e r words, t h e r e s t r i c t i o n
T2: A,
+
X )
is
i s precompact i n
(f:Ilfl,Fl)
i s a compact o p e r a t o r . W e
N
get th e r e f o r e t h e following s i t u a t i o n : T A w - -T2 - - + N & K
with
T2,T3
and
compact and t h e norm i n
from Theorem 124.4 t h a t
S S ([-w,wl) 3 2
S3S2: A,
+
o r d e r continuous. It follows t h e n
K
of t h e c l o s e d u n i t b a l l
( e q u i v a l e n t l y , t o t a l l y bounded i n
K
i s compact, i . e . , t h e image
[-w,w]
in
>.Applying
i s precompact i n
A,
the operator
s3s2
to
and
. The
right
K
formula (11, we f i n d
where
11 S211
11
and
SdI
are t h e o p e r a t o r norms of
S2
Sj
hand s i d e (and t h e r e f o r e t h e l e f t hand s i d e ) c a n b e covered by f i n i t e l y many b a l l s of r a d i u s
, i.e.,
ZE
S3S2S,:
L
+
K
i s compact.
W e mention some immediate a p p l i c a t i o n s ( a l s o due t o A l i p r a n t i s -
Burkinshaw). THEOREM 124.6.
t h e operator
T: L
(i) +
L
If L i s a Dedekind complete Banach l a t t i c e and has the property t h a t I T ( i s compact, then T3 i s
compact. If it i s known i n a d d i t i o n t h a t t h e norm i n L
or i n
L * is order
i s compact. ( i i ) fie i d e n t i t y operator i n a Banach Z a t t i c e of i n f i n i t e dimension
continuous, then
T~
cannot be dominated by a compact operator. PROOF. ( i ) Each term i n T
3
(T+-T-l3
=
=
... +
(T+l3 +
- 3
(-T )
i s a product of t h r e e f a c t o r s ; e a c h f a c t o r i s e i t h e r 0 s T" s IT1
and
0 s T-
S
IT1
and
IT1
T2
i f t h e norm i n
L
or in
or
T-
. Since
i s compact, i t f o l l o w s from t h e
l a s t theorem t h a t e a c h term i s compact, and t h e r e f o r e larly for
T+
L*
T3
i s compact. Simi-
i s o r d e r continuous.
Ch. 18,51243
519
COMPACT OPERATORS
(ii) If the identity operator I in the Banach lattice L dimension is dominated by a compact operator, then I is impossible since the closed unit ball in L
=
of infinite
I3 is compact. This
is not precompact.
For the discussion of certain conditions under which any positive operator dominated by a compact operator is compact itself, we need the notion of precompactness with respect to a seminorm. For the definition, assume
. The
is a seminorm in the vector space V
that p
subset D of
V
is
said to be p-precompact if every sequence in D has a subsequence, say
,...
, which
fl,fg
is p-Cauchy, i.e., p(fn-fm)
+
0 as m,n
+
=
. We
explici-
tly mention the case that the vector space is a Banach lattice and the seminorm is derived from a linear functional. DEFINITION 124.7. Let
the seminorm p6
L
in
L be a Banach l a t t i c e , l e t
be defined by
p (f)
=
$
6 E L* and l e t
0 5
$(If/) f o r a l l
.
f E L
l?ae subset D of L i s said t o be p precompact i f every sequence i n D 6 has a p -Cauchy subsequence ( i . e . , i f f , , f 2 , . . i s the subsequence, then
.
6
$(lfn-fml)
+
as
0
m,n
+
m
1.
It is obvious that precompactness of D D
for every 0
in L
5
6
E L*
implies p -precompactness of
. Under certain conditions for
6
D
and for the norm
the converse holds.
LEMMA 124.8. Let
lattice
L
only i f
D is
D be an a h o s t order bounded subset of t h e Banach
w i t h order continuous norm p p precompact f o r every 6
PROOF. Assume first that
that D
D
. Then
D
6E
L*
0 5
i s precompact i f and
.
is an order bounded subset of L
is p -precompact for every
6
0
5
6E
L*
. Assume
also that
to be precompact. This implies the existence of a nmber sequence '(fn:n=1,2, Since D
...)
in D
satisfying p(fn-fm)
is order bounded, we have
-$u
5
fn
.
5
hu
E >
> E
such D
fails
0 and a
for all m # n
for some u E L+
and
If -f 1 5 u for all m,n Furthermore, since the norm n m is order continuous, there exists (by Theorem 103.12) a positive linear
all n ; hence functional $I ideal A,
on L
such that
generated by
u
6 is strictly positive on the principal
. The sequence
(fn)
is included in D
is p -precompact, so there exists a subsequence fn ,fn 6 1 2
,...
and D
such that
.
520
MDDS-FREMLIN AND ALIPMNTIS-BURKINSHAW THEOREMS
+ ( l f -f nk Ilk+l' ) < complete (because
'-' p
... . The
k = 1,2,
for
Banach l a t t i c e
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s ) and
If
L
f o r every 5
. But
+(wn) + 0
that
c:
p(w ) C 0 n p ( f -f ) + 0 "k nk+l m # n Hence, D hence
n
+(I
fn;fnk+l
then
wn
-
1)
+
as
k +
+
and
D
0 5 0 E L*
D-
of
i s s t r i c t l y p o s i t i v e on p
. It
AU
1,
follows t h a t
p(fn-f,)
>
E
for
. Let
i s almost o r d e r bounded and
L
D+ = (f+:fED)
and
D- = (f-:fED)
+
a r e almost o r d e r bounded and p -precompact
I f-gl i.e.,
t o t a l l y bounded. For t h i s purpose, l e t
+
for a l l k,
f o l l o w s from
, contradicting the fact that
+ + E L* ( t h e l a s t because I f -g 1 and 1. I t w i l l be s u f f i c i e n t , t h e r e f o r e ,
0 s
5 u
i s precompact.
for a l l
D+
+
0 (since
Assume now t h a t t h e s u b s e t p -precompact
i s Dedekind
L
I
s 2 -n+ 1
i n view of t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of
.
Note t h a t
+ . It
0 < w
and we have
nk+l
"k
so
exists in
-f
Ch. 18,51243
1 f--g-l
u E L+
i s almost o r d e r bounded, t h e r e e x i s t s
a r e m a j o r i z e d by
> 0
i s precompact,
D+
t o prove t h a t E
be g i v e n . S i n c e
such t h a t every
f+
E
D+ D+
satisfies f+
=
(f'hu)
+
+ ( f -u)
+
with
p((f+-u)+}
<
AE ,
and t h e r e f o r e
Note now t h a t t h e o r d e r bounded s e t
0 5 $ E L* (because
(f+Au:fED)
is p
/ f + ~ u - g + h u l i s m a j o r i z e d by
+- precompact
If+-g+l
f o r every
for a l l
f , g 5 D ) . Hence, a s shown i n t h e f i r s t p a r t of t h e p r o o f , t h e s e t (f+Au:fED)
i s precompact and c a n be c o v e r e d , t h e r e f o r e , by a f i n i t e number
of b a l l s of r a d i u s
1~
. It
f o l l o w s from formula ( 2 ) above t h a t
covered by a f i n i t e number of b a l l s of r a d i u s bounded.
E
.
f o r every
, i.e.,
D+
D+
can b e
is totally
COMPACT OPERATORS
Ch. 18,51241 COROLLARY 124.9.
Let
and
L
52 1
be Bmach Zattices with norms
M
and
p
X be order continuous and l e t T be an order bounded operator from L i n t o M . Then T is AM-compact i f and only if the image of any almost order bounded s e t in L i s p -peeompact i n M f o r every 4 0 5 $ E M* . Equivakntly, T i s AM-compact if and only if the image of any order bounded s e t in L i s p -peeompact in M for every 0 5 $ E M* . 6 A
respectively, l e t
A s an i n t r o d u c t i o n t o t h e n e x t theorem, we r e c a l l some f a c t s about quotient spaces. I f L
and
p
$
Riesz seminorm i n ideal N by
in
6
Cfl,Cgl,
L
...
f ) and d e f i n e Riesz norm i n
completion of
p ( f ) = $ ( / f l ) for a l l
. The s e t of
L
. Denote
(i.e.,
$
all
satisfying
[fl
[fl
L/N
i s t h e e q u i v a l e n c e c l a s s modulo
$
and
[gl
in
L/N+
. Now, p
i s a Riesz space i n which
i s an &-space
p
let
i s an L/N4
containing
$
$
p
(L/N ) $
L
i s a Riesz norm). It i s
4
f o r p o s i t i v e elements i s p r e s e r v e d .
$
w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e norm
ond
M
be t h e norm
( c f . s e c t i o n 100 f o r t h e
p
. We now s t a t e
$
be Banach 2attices:such that the norms
m d in M are order continuous. Furthermore, l e t i n t o M such that
operators from L
0 5 S 5 T
and
S(Bl)
of
S
T
and
T
be
is compact. Then
is compact. PROOF. W e prove f i r s t t h a t t h e image
f o r every
0 5 $ E M*
l a r l y a s above, l e t norm completion f
N
.
with r e s p e c t t o t h e norm
THEOREM 124.10. Let
T"
is a
p (f) = 0 $
and prove t h e Dodds-Fremlin theorem.
S
p4
t h e elements of t h e q u o t i e n t Riesz s p a c e
e a s y t o s e e t h a t t h e a d d i t i v i t y of
in L*
then
4
(L/N$)
Hence, (L/N$)-
f E L
,
f E L
p a l s o i n L / N + by p $ ( C f l ) = p $ ( f ) Then p is a $ $ L/N+ w i t h t h e p r o p e r t y t h a t p i s I-additive, i . e . ,
for all positive proof t h a t
i s a p o s i t i v e l i n e a r f u n c t i o n a l on t h e Riesz space
$
i s d e f i n e d by
. For
(M/N )$
Tf
. The
of
T
into
p
$
) of t h e q u o t i e n t
M/N$
, defined
by
i s t h e e q u i v a l e n c e c l a s s modulo
[Tfl
operator
L
0 5 $ E M*
T"
i s p$-precompact be given. Simi-
be t h e AL-space which one g e t s by t a k i n g t h e
(with r e s p e c t t o
be t h e o p e r a t o r from
E L , where
t h i s purpose, l e t
BE
M/N$
. Now
TNf = [ T f l N+
let
f o r every
containing
i s compact. Indeed, i t follows from t h e compactness
t h a t t h e image of any norm bounded set i n
L
c o n t a i n s a norm con-
522
WDDS-FREMLIN AND ALIPRANTIS-BURKINSHAW THEOREMS
v e r g i n g sequence
(Tfn:n=1,2
p -convergent i n
M/N+
A
S f = [Sf]
for a l l
in
,
M
. The o p e r a t o r S" . This l e a d s t o
and t h e n
i s compact, where
L
(M/N+)-
into
([Tfnl:n=1,2
,...)
is
i s defined si m i l a r l y , i . e . ,
f E L
a r e p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r s from T-
,...)
Ch. 18,91241
the s i t u a t i o n t h a t
(M/N+)-
0
such t h a t
i s an AL-space and
2
S" N
S
and
T"
N
and
I T
L* has o r d e r continuous
norm. By Theorem 123.6 t h e s e t of a l l o r d e r bounded compact o p e r a t o r s from L
into
(M/N#)-
t h e operator minology i n
+
i t s e l f ( i n s t e a d of i n
S(B;)
124.8 t h a t
N
and
T
2
i s compact,
T"
S(B+) of B; L Hence, i f we can prove
M / N ) t h e image
i s p+-precompact. This holds f o r every that
0 I S
i s l i k e w i s e compact. I n o t h e r words, r e t u r n i n g t o t h e t e r *
S-
M
N
i s a band. Hence, s i n c e
0 I
+
E fl
.
i s almost o r d e r bounded, i t w i l l f o l l o w by means of Lemma i s a precompact s u b s e t of
S(B:)
t h e n compact. The almost o r d e r boundedness of
1 2 4 . 1 . Indeed, T
maps
BE
compact), and hence s o does
, i.e.,
M
S(B+)
L
the operator
f o l l o w s from Lemma
o n t o an almost o r d e r bounded s e t ( s i n c e S
T
is
by t h e lemma r e f e r r e d t o .
As mentioned a l r e a d y , Theorem 124.5 ( t h e theorem about Aliprantis-Burkinshaw.
is
S
S
3
) i s due
to
The proof p r e s e n t e d h e r e , due t o A . R . Schep, i s
d i f f e r e n t from and s i m p l e r t h a n t h e o r i g i n a l p r o o f . The l a s t theorem (about S
S2
i t s e l f ) i s t h e Dodds-Fremlin and
S3
due t o A.R.
. The
theorem, which was p r i o r t o t h e r e s u l t s about
p r e s e n t p r o o f , making an a p p e a l t o Theorem 123.6, i s a g a i n
Schep.
F i n a l l y , we p r e s e n t s e v e r a l examples showing t h a t t h e theorems proved i n t h i s s e c t i o n a r e b e s t p o s s i b l e . I t i s convenient f o r t h i s purpose t o make use of t h e Rademacher f u n c t i o n s
r (x) = sgn s i n 2"x, 1 on
\
A s u s u a l , we denote
max(rn(x),O)
measure
TI
= [0,2.rrl
for
n
=
1,2
,... .
.
by
r+(x) N e g l e c t i n g a s e t of Lebesgue +n h a s t h e v a l u e one on a s e t of n and t h e v a l u e z e r o on t h e remaining s e t of measure 'TI Similarly,
measure zero, n o t e t h a t t h e f u n c t i o n the function
x
++
r r
(m#n)
mn v a l u e z e r o elsewhere.
r
.
h a s t h e v a l u e one on a s e t of measure
Our f i r s t example w i l l show t h a t t h e Dodds-Fremlin n e c e s s a r i l y h o l d i f one a t l e a s t of t i n u o u s norm. Define
L*
and
M
~ I I
and t h e
theorem does n o t
f a i l s t o have an o r d e r con-
18,11243
by
S l ( a ) = C 1 anrn
m
+
(
S2f =
by
f o r every f r i dx, X
f E L2(X)
f o r every
T a = C 1
m
an.xx
(where
1
1
and
2
dx,
fdx,
...)
E t, and
...1 )
define
xx(x) = 1
fdx,
for a l l
x E X ) and
...) .
X
a r e compact (each i s of rank one). Furthermore,
T2
i
for
fr'
. Similarly,
X Evidently, T I
I
a = (al,a2,
X
(
T2f =
0 5 S. 5 T.
523
COMPACT OPERATORS
Ch.
= 1,2
.
Of 'course, a l l
S.
and
T.
(i=1,2)
a r e norm
bounded, being p o s i t i v e operators between Banach l a t t i c e s . Denoting t h e u n i t vectors i n
Ll
( e l y e 2 ,...)
by
S S (e -e ) = S (r+-r+) 2 1 n m 2 n m S S (e -e ) i s equal t o 2 1 n m
, which
, we
have
S e
=
r:
for a l l
n
S2SI
pact. Note t h a t f o r
.
S1
t h e f a i l u r e i s due t o t h e f a c t t h a t the norm i n
i s not o r d e r continuous, whereas f o r t h a t t h e norm i n
Lm of
S S (e -e ) f o r m # n i s a t l e a s t ;IT It f o l 2 1 n m i s not compact and, t h e r e f o r e , n e i t h e r S 1 nor S2 i s com-
and hence t h e Lm-norm of lows t h a t
. Hence
shows t h a t the n i t h coordinate i n
.em
the f a i l u r e comes from t h e f a c t
S2
.e?;
i s not o r d e r continuous.
I n t h e second example we show t h a t the Aliprantis-Burkinshaw theorem about
S3
i s b e s t p o s s i b l e . Let
a s i n t h e f i r s t example and l e t
Note t h a t n e i t h e r operator
S: L + L
L
nor
L*
and
Si
L
T.
(i=1,2)
be t h e same o p e r a t o r s
be t h e d i r e c t sum
has o r d e r continuous norm. Now d e f i n e the
t o be equal t o
S1
on
Ll
, equal
to
S2
on
L2(X)
and
524
COMPACT, AM-COMPACT AND SEMI-COMPACT
em. S i m i l a t l y ,
z e r o on T2 S
on
L2(X)
let
and z e r o on
T: L
+
em . Then
i s n o t . Furthermore, t h e o p e r a t o r
z e r o on
L2(x)
,
@
be e q u a l t o
L
0 5 S 5 T
L1
@
,
L2(X)
S
i t can be shown t h a t t h e theorem
Ll
S ~ S I on
s 2 i s n o t compact. of c o u r s e , ~3
so
S i m i l a r l y , bymeans of analogous o p e r a t o r s L =
i s compact and
holds, T
i s equal t o
S2
I, , e q u a l t o
on
TI
and
18,51251
Ch.
and
i s compact.
on
T
about
o
=
i s b e s t possi-
S2
ble. t h e f i r s t example i s a
These examples are due t o Aliprantis-Burkinshaw, v a r i a n t upon a n o l d e r example of P. Dodds.
125. Compactness, AN-compactness If
a r e Banach l a t t i c e s and
L,M,K
TI: L
-f
T2: M
+
and semi-compactness Tl,T2
a r e o p e r a t o r s such t h a t
M
maps norm bounded sets i n t o almost o r d e r bounded s e t s and
K
i s AM-compact, t h e n
compact s e t s , i . e . , note t h a t i f
T: L
+
T2TI: L
K
maps norm bounded s e t s i n t o pre-
i s a compact J o r d a n o p e r a t o r , t h e n
M
t h e mentioned p r o p e r t i e s ( i . e . , o r d e r bounded s e t s i n
+
i s a compact o p e r a t o r , I n t h e converse d i r e c t i o n
T2T1
M
and
T
i s a l s o AM-compact).
T
T
maps norm bounded s e t s i n
h a s both o f i n t o almost
L
It i s a n a t u r a l
q u e s t i o n t o a s k i f t h e converse of t h e l a s t s t a t e m e n t h o l d s , i . e . , Jordan operator
T: L + M
i f the
has both p r o p e r t i e s , i s i t t r u e then t h a t
is
T
compact? The proof of t h e theorem t h a t under c e r t a i n norm c o n d i t i o n s ( o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of t h e norms i n
L*
i z e d by a compact o p e r a t o r
T
and i n
M ) any p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r
S
major-
i s i t s e l f compact makes i t p l a u s i b l e t h a t t h e r e
must e x i s t some r e s u l t s i n t h i s d i r e c t i o n , because obviously t h e compactness of
S
is related t o the f a c t that
S
i n h e r i t s from
both p r o p e r t i e s w e
T
have j u s t mentioned. I f , however, t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y c o n d i t i o n s f o r t h e norms are only p a r t i a l l y s a t i s f i e d ( e x p l i c i t l y , i f norm, b u t
compact t h a t
S
last section) S t h e spaces
L
M
h a s n o t ) , i t f o l l o w s j u s t a s w e l l from
L*
h a s o r d e r continuous
0 5 S 5 T
with
T
h a s b o t h p r o p e r t i e s , b u t ( a s s h a m i n t h e examples i n t h e
i s now n o t n e c e s s a r i l y compact ( a l t h o u g h and
M
S2
i s compact i f
are i d e n t i c a l ) . This shows t h a t o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y and
of t h e norm i n only one o f t h e s p a c e s
M
c o n j e c t u r e t o b e t r u e . We s h a l l prove
t h a t i f both
L*
i s n o t enough f o r o u r M
and
L*
have o r d e r
continuous norm, then t h e c o n j e c t u r e i s t r u e . It i s n e c e s s a r y t o do some p r e l i m i n a r y work. W e b e g i n by o b s e r v i n g t h a t i n g e n e r a l t h e norm c l o s e d u n i t b a l l i n t h e Banach l a t t i c e
L
i s n o t almost o r d e r bounded, even i n t h e case t h a t
Ch.
18,51251
t h e norm
COMPACT OPERATORS
in
p
L
and t h e norm
in
p*
L*
525
a r e b o t h o r d e r continuous ( a s
shown i n E x e r c i s e 122.3; s e e 122.8 f o r c o n d i t i o n s when norm bounded s e t s a r e almost o r d e r bounded). This i s d i f f e r e n t i f i n s t e a d of a norm we have a c o l l e c t i o n of R i e s z seminorms. L e t Banach l a t t i c e
L
bounded i f f o r any f
E
E >
subset
0
D
of
i s s a i d t o be p-almost order
L
f = f
+ f2
1
p{(lfl-u)+} < E
with
f o r every
L*
1 . Then
B
in
L
L
p
; norm
@ ) there exists
B
E
> 0
E L*
0 5 @
4
elements i n
p(f2) <
E
4
p -almost order bounded f o r e v e w
PROOF. Assume f i r s t t h a t
@
such t h a t e v e r y and
f E D ). A s b e f o r e , i f
be a Banach l a t t i c e (norm
i s o r d e r continuous, but
p*
0 S @
p -almost o r d e r bounded f o r some fixed
u
p*
in
i s order continuous i f and only i f the closed u n i t b a l l
p*
is
E L+ 5
p ( f ) = @ ( I f I ) f o r every
f E L . THEOREM 125.1. Let
u
-u 5 f l
E L* , t h e seminorm p4 i s d e f i n e d by
I$
be a R i e s z seminorm i n t h e
t h e r e e x i s t s a n element
can b e w r i t t e n a s
D
(equivalently, i f
0 5
. The
p
E L*
. It
and a sequence
.
B
f a i l s t o be
follows t h a t ( f o r t h i s
...)
(un:n=1,2
of p o s i t i v e
such t h a t
4(ul)
> E
,
@{(u2-4ul)+} >
,
E
@{(u3-8(ul+u2)
+}
> E,...
.
Generally uir}
(1)
for
> E
Note now t h a t f o r any n a t u r a l number
n = 2,3,
... .
t h e norm l i m i t
n
Cm
n+ 1
sequence of p a r t i a l sums ( Z nk+ l
exists i n
L
2-iui:k=n+l,n+2,.
, because
L
n = 2,3,
... . Then,
of t h e
..
i s a Banach l a t t i c e ( t h e norm l i m i t i s a l s o t h e
supremum of t h e p a r t i a l sums). P u t
for
2-iui
v
1
i n view of ( 1 )
=
0
, w1
= u1
above, $(wn) >
and
E
f o r every
n
.
526
COMPACT. AM-COMPACT AND SEMI-COMPACT
Ch. 18,51251
Furthermore,
... . Hence, $(wn-vn) . This i m p l i e s t h a t $(vn)
for
n = 2,3,
<
1~
for a l l
n
ate
n
> ie
for a l l
n t no
0 t o observe is t h a t t h e sequence
. Indeed,
L
for vn
5
m < n
we have
f\un-2"
urn)'
and
v
d i s j o i n t and
1~
$(vn) >
for a l l
Conversely, assume now t h a t
. Let
val
CO,$l
(cpn:n=1,2,...)
L*
in
. For
s u f f i c i e n t t o show t h a t By h y p o t h e s i s
${(I
that
u
and
c o n t r a d i c t s Theorem 116.1,
i s p a l m o s t o r d e r bounded f o r every $
b e a d i s j o i n t sequence i n t h e o r d e r i n t e r -
t h e proof t h a t p*($,)
.
is
B
+ 0
i s o r d e r continuous it i s
p*
n +
as
m
(Theorem 104.2). L e t
E
> 0.
i s p -almost o r d e r bounded, s o t h e r e e x i s t s u E L+ such $ 1~ f o r a l l f E B S i n c e 2'; gn(u) 5 g ( u ) f o r t h i s
B
and a l l
a n a t u r a l number n t no
i s norm bounded and
i m p l i e s t h a t e v e r y norm bounded
p*
0 5 Q1 E L* B
.
fl -u)+] <
particular
next thing
converges weakly t o z e r o . It f o l l o w s t h a t
L
p -almost o r d e r bounded for e v e r y
0 5 $ E L*
(vn:nmo)
. This
n t no
a c c o r d i n g t o which o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of d i s j o i n t sequence i n
. The
i s a d i s j o i n t sequence i n
2-n(2num-un)t
5
m
i s o r d e r continuous, t h e sequence
Hence, p *
$
...)
(vn:n=1,2,
exceeding an appropri-
no
f E B
k
, we
have
such t h a t
Q1,(u)
$,(u)
<
-t
1~
0
as
for all
n
-+
m
, so
n t no
there e x i s t s
. Then,
if
a r e given, we have
There e x i s t s a d u a l theorem, a s f o l l o w s .
THEOREM 125.2. The norm
p
f o r every =
I @I(u)
0 5 u
L is order continuis p -almost order bounded
i n the Banach l a t t i c e
ous i f and only if t h e closed u n i t b a l l i n
L*
E L , where t h e seminorm pu i n L* is defined by
f o r every
cp E L*
.
~ ~ ( =$ 1
18,11251
Ch.
COMPACT OPERATORS
527
PROOF. The proof i s q u i t e s i m i l a r t o t h e proof of t h e l a s t theorem, u s i n g now t h a t o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of j o i n t sequence in
i m p l i e s t h a t every norm bounded d i s -
p
converges weak s t a r t o z e r o (Theorem 116.2).
L*
COROLLARY 125.3. Let
be a p o s i t i v e operator, mapping the Banach
T
, and
l a t t i c e L i n t o the Banach l a t t i c e M order continuous. Then the image T(B) i s p -almost order bounded f o r every
l e t the n o m
i n L* be
p*
of the elosed u n i t b a l l 0
5 $
E M*
B
.
in L
~
PROOF. L e t $ ( f ) = $(Tf)
be g i v e n and l e t
0 5 $ t: M*
for a l l
. Since
f E L
(by Theorem 125.1) f o r any given ${(lfl-u)+} <
for a l l
E
Note now t h a t
(Tg)'
for a l l
. It
f E B
,
f E B
Tg'
5
i.e.,
f o r every
follows t h a t
an element
> 0
E
0 s I$ t: L*
b e d e f i n e d by
i s o r d e r continuous, t h e r e e x i s t s
p*
u
${T(lfl-u)+} < g E L
. For
such t h a t
E L+ E
for a l l
g = If1
-
f E B
.
t h i s gives
u
T(B) i s p -almost o r d e r bounded. Note t h a t $
t h e l a s t i n e q u a l i t y i n (2) i s somewhat s t r o n g e r t h a n t h e s t a t e m e n t t h a t
i s p. -almost o r d e r bounded.
T(B)
J,
THEOREM 125.4. Let
i n L*
and
M
be Banach l a t t i c e s such t h a t t h e n o m s
are order continuous and l e t t h e operator T
order bounded. Then bounded s e t i n
and M
L
L
i s p precompact i n M f o r every $
PROOF. I f t h e image of any norm bounded s u b s e t of f o r every s e t of
L
$
Conversely, l e t 0 5 J, E M*
T(B)
be
0 5 JI € M* L
.
i s p -precompact
9
b e AM-compact. I t w i l l b e s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t
T
of t h e u n i t b a l l
s e c t i o n 122, T(B)
...,hn
M
in
i s AM-compact.
T
. Similarly as
bounded, i . e . , h,,
-f
JI E M* , t h e n c e r t a i n l y t h e image of any o r d e r bounded subi s p -precompact f o r e v e r y 0 s $ € M* . T h i s i m p l i e s immediately,
0 5
by C o r o l l a r y 124.9, t h a t t h e image
T: L
i s AM-compact i f and o n l y i f t h e image of any n o m
i s p -precompact
f o r any M
J,
B
in
L
i s p -precompact f o r e v e r y $
observed f o r a d i s t a n c e i n a m e t r i c space i n
E >
such t h a t
0
i f and only i f T(B) i s p - t o t a l l y J, t h e r e e x i s t s a f i n i t e s e t of elements
COMPACT, AM-COMPACT AND SEMI-COMPACT
528
Note f i r s t t h a t t h e space
i s Dedekind complete ( s i n c e
M
continuous norm); i t f o l l o w s t h a t t h e o p e r a t o r
0 5 $ E M*
let
and
E
> 0
b e given. Write
o r d e r continuous norm, t h e s e t f = g+h
t h e form
compact, t h e image of a f i n i t e s e t
with
g E
g ,,. ..,gn
be a r b i t r a r y . Then
f E B For
gi
gi
u E L
[-U,U]
++
such t h a t
+(I h l ) <
and
in
[-u,u]
,
f o r which
. Since
every
f E B
. Since
JE
such t h a t f o r every $(\Tg-Tgi
1)
L*
has
T
i s of
i s AM-
g E [-u,u]
AE .
<
g E C-u,ul
f = g+h w i t h
T(B)
(Tf:fEB,$(l
Tf-Tgi]
Now, l e t
+ ( l h l ) < 1~
and
.
J,
and
T: L + M
set
D
of
)<E
i s p - t o t a l l y bounded
It has been shown t h u s t h a t i f
L
L*
and
M
i s AM-compact, t h e n t h e image i s p -precompact f o r every J,
t o compare t h i s r e s u l t w i t h Lemma 124.8,
0
have o r d e r continuous norm
T(D) 5 $
of any norm bounded sub-
€ M*
. It
which i s almost o r d e r bounded a s w e l l a s p -precompact $
t o conclude t h a t compact f o r every
T(D)
T(D)
i s precompact, because a l t h o u g h
0 5 $ E M*
and
T(D)
i s n o t almost o r d e r bounded u n l e s s
c o n d i t i o n . I n o t h e r words, even i f
L*
i s compact. I n mentioned above
i s p -pre-
T(D)
J,
i s a l s o (of c o u r s e ) norm bounded, T and
s a t i s f i e s an a d d i t i o n a l M
have o r d e r continuous norm,
i t i s n o t t r u e i n g e n e r a l t h a t an AM-compact o p e r a t o r bounded s e t s i n t o precompact s e t s , i . e . ,
i s of importance
according t o which any s u b s e t of
g e n e r a l we cannot apply t h i s l a s t r e s u l t t o t h e s e t
T(D)
e x i s t s . Now,
i s covered by t h e f i n i t e union Ui,ln
M
!TI*$
=
has o r d e r
M
M
as above, t h i s g i v e s
Hence, T(B)
i.e.,
4
-t
i s t o t a l l y bounded, which i m p l i e s t h e e x i s t e n c e
T[-u,uI
t h e r e i s one t h e s e , say
ITI: L
i s p -almost o r d e r bounded (Theorem
B
Therefore, there e x i s t s
125.1).
Ch. 18,11251
T: L
-f
M
maps norm
i t i s n o t t r u e t h a t an AM-compact
o p e r a t o r i s always compact. Obviously, t h e e x t r a h y p o t h e s i s we need ( b e s i d e s
Ch. 18,81251
T ) i s that i f the subset
AM-compactness of t h e image
529
COMPACT OPERATORS
of
D
i s norm bounded, t h e n
L
i s almost o r d e r bounded, because t h e n
T(D)
0
o r d e r bounded a s w e l l a s p -precompact f o r e v e r y jl
124.8 can be a p p l i e d t o conclude t h a t
5
i s almost
T(D)
Ji E M* , s o L e m a
i s compact. Order bounded o p e r a t o r s
T
from one Banach l a t t i c e i n t o a n o t h e r , mapping norm bounded s e t s i n t o almost o r d e r bounded s e t s a r e sometimes c a l l e d L-weakly compact operators ( f o l l o w i n g P . Meyer-Nieberg,
[21,1974), but we s h a l l p r e f e r t o call these operators
The r e s u l t mentioned above w i l l now be f o r m u l a t e d as a theorem.
semi-compact.
The theorem i s due a g a i n t o Dodds-Fremlin THEOREM 125.5.
(Z: I ] ) .
If L and M are Banach Lattices such t h a t L*
compact i f and only i f
is
T
and
T: L
M have order continuous norm, then the order bounded operator
+
M
AM-compact and semi-compact.
is
To conclude t h i s s e c t i o n , we d i s c u s s some c o n d i t i o n s under which AM-
compactness of
T
i m p l i e s AM-compactness of
and c o n v e r s e l y . The theorem
T*
which f o l l o w s i s due t o B. de P a g t e r . THEOREM 125.6. Let
norms
and
p*
(i)
If
L
and
M
L*
and
M* ) .
be Banach l a t t i c e s (norms
T*
and
M
is
i s AM-compact,
T
then
T: L
A
are order continuous and t h e operator
T
i s AM-compact i f and only i f
T = T
follows t h a t
p*
( i ) Note f i r s t t h a t
- T2
with
> 0
TI
lTfl 5 S ( l f 1 )
W e have t o prove t h a t E
p*
i s Jordan (since
T
and
T
for a l l
T*[O,$]
b e given. S i n c e
2
(in
f E B , i. . e . ,
M ) of t h e s e t
f E L
. Now,
let
T*
T: L
0 5 $
${S((h/)} <
31 "
. Since
T
, it
+ T2
1
E fl b e g i v e n . L*
. Let
B
in
g E [-u,ul
i s AM-compact,
i s compact, Denote t h i s c l o s u r e by
L
also
is
u E L+
Therefore, there e x i s t s with
M
i s AM-compact), S = T
i s a t o t a l l y bounded s u b s e t of
f = g+h
+
i s AM-compact.
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s , t h e u n i t ball
i s of t h e form
T[-u,u]
T
p o s i t i v e . Writing
p S * y a l m o s t o r d e r bounded (Theroem 125.1). such t h a t e v e r y 1 ( S * $ ) ( l h l ) < 3'
AM-
M has the property t h a t
+
and
PROOF.
,
i s AM-compact.
i s order bounded, then
hence
A
i s order continuous ( s o t h a t , therefore, M i s Dedekind
A
( i i i ) If
+
p
i s AM-compact.
compLete) and the order bounded operator T*
T: L
i s order continuous and the operator
p*
compact, then (ii) I f
in
A*
and the closure X
. Hence,
5 30
X
COMPACT, AM-COMPACT AND SEMI-COMPACT
Ch. 18,81251
i s a compact m e t r i c space (with r e s p e c t t o t h e d i s t a n c e f u n c t i o n for a l l points
d ( p I , p 2 ) = A(p -p ) Tg
1
f u n c t i o n on C(X)
2
g E [-u,ul
for
. Therefore,
X
pI,p2
in
LO,$]
X
a r e uniformly bounded and equicontinuous on Theorem t h e s e t
[O,$l
$ E
Now, l e t
f E B
f = g+h
and
that
Q E [O,$l
5
E
,
(i2iIn)
T*Qi
,
and
of
i.e.,
for a l l
$i
. Hence
1 5~
be a s above. We
. This
f E B
implies
i s covered by t h e union of t h e b a l l s
T*[O,$]
and r a d i u s
such t h a t
.
g E [-u,ul
E
. This
C(X) LO,$]
, satisfying
$i
${S(lhl)} <
<
CO,$l
in
Q
s o t h a t i n view of the
b e a r b i t r a r y , and l e t
I (T*$)(f)-(T*Qi)(f) I
p*(T*Q-T*Qi)
with centers
X
(Ql,...,Qn)
for a l l
g E [--u,ul
with
It follows t h a t
The f u n c t i o n s
t h e r e i s one of t h e s e , say
lQ(Tg)-Qi(Tg)l< E;1
have
.
i s t o t a l l y bounded i n
[O,$l
i m p l i e s t h e e x i s t e n c e of a f i n i t e s u b s e t f o r each
i s a r e a l continuous
Q E @
i s a s u b s e t of t h e s p a c e
= ($:O<$I$)
of a l l r e a l continuous f u n c t i o n s on
Ascoli-Arzela
X ) and t h e p o i n t s
form a dense s u b s e t . Every
E
. This
shows t h a t
i s to-
T*[O,$I
t a l l y bounded. ( i i ) The proof i s s i m i l a r , Note f i r s t t h a t Dedekind complete). Furthermore, s i n c e
A
theorem (Theorem 115.4) may be a p p l i e d , i . e . , we have t o prove t h a t given. Since
A
TIO,u]
i s o r d e r continuous, t h e u n i t b a l l
$ E B*
I $ " I ( I T I U<) Since
1
3E ,
i s of t h e form
i.e.,
the
function
on
$ = $ ' + $"
X
X ( t h e v a l u e of
i s a s u b s e t of t h e space
f
. Every
. The
X
i m p l i e s t h e e x i s t e n c e of
v
each
. This
v E C0,ul
in
B*
with
0 Iu E L ,
also is
M*
E
> 0
be
'ITlu-
E @ such Q' E [-$,$I and $
1
L* ) of t h e s e t
x
, so
t h e r e i s one of t h e s e , say
E X
functions
,,...,v
C0,ul
v.
T*[-$,$l
.
is
i s a r e a l continuous
f E L
a t the point C(X)
formly bounded and equicontinuous on C(X)
. Given
. Let
M
Therefore, t h e r e e x i s t s
closure (in
compact. Denote t h i s c l o s u r e by C0,uI
is
M
U T * I ( I Q I ~ I ) I=( {~I )T I * ( I $ ~ ~ I ) } ( ~=) I $ " I ( I T I <~ )?E
i s AM-compact,
T*
ITI* = \T*l
i s t o t a l l y bounded i n
almost o r d e r bounded (Theorem 125.2). t h a t every
e x i s t s (since
IT1
i s o r d e r continuous, Synnatschke's
in
,
is v
X(f) ). T h e r e f o r e , in
[O,ul
a r e uni-
i s t o t a l l y bounded i n C0,ul
satisfying
such t h a t f o r
Ch. 18,11251
Now, l e t
g
have
COMPACT OPERATORS
Q E B* =
g ' + 9''
It f o l l o w s t h a t
X(Tv-Tv.) centers
5 E
Tv.
and
v E [O,u]
be a r b i t r a r y , and l e t
g ' E [-$,+I
with
Ig(Tv)-g(Tvi)l<
, i.e.,
TC0,ul
(I
531
and
b e a s above. We
{~T*~(~g"~)}(u)
4 E B*
for a l l
E
v.
. This
implies t h a t
i s covered by t h e union of t h e b a l l s w i t h
and r a d i u s
E
. This
shows t h a t
TC0,ul
i s totally
bounded. ( i i i ) Follows immediately from p a r t s ( i ) and ( i i ) . It i s of some i n t e r e s t t o observe a l r e a d y t h a t i t w i l l b e proved i n
Theorem 127.4 t h a t i f o r d e r bounded, t h e n if
T*
so
T
p*
X
and
a r e o r d e r continuous and
i s semi-compact i f and only i f
T
i s AM-compact a s w e l l a s semi-compact,
T*
i s compact by Theorem 125.5, which i m p l i e s t h a t
T*
T*
EXERCISE 125.7. Let a s w e l l a s semi-compact (i)
S
and
Show t h a t
S
Show t h a t
S2
is T
,
i s compact. Note
i s o r d e r continuous. For t h e same reason,
@*
0 < S < T
M
i t s e l f , s i n c e we do
p a t t ( i i ) of t h e l a s t theorem does n o t f o l l o w immediately from
i n t o i t s e l f such t h a t
+
t h e n t h e same holds f o r
t h a t Theorem 125.5 cannot immediately be a p p l i e d t o n o t know whether t h e norm i n
T: L
i s s o . Hence
T
part (i).
be o p e r a t o r s from t h e Banach l a t t i c e
. Assume
furthermore t h a t
(so t h a t , t h e r e f o r e , T 2 i s compact i f b o t h
L*
T
L
i s AM-compact
i s compact). and
L
have o r d e r c o n t i -
nuous norm. (ii)
i s compact i f
L
h a s o r d e r continuous norm.
( i i i ) Show t h a t , w i t h o u t c o n t i n u i t y assumptions, S4 t h i s purpose, n o t e f i r s t t h a t
o r d e r bounded (where unit ball such t h a t
B
of
B+
S
i s semi-compact.
i s compact. For
Hence, S(B+)
i s almost
i s t h e set of a l l p o s i t i v e elements i n t h e c l o s e d
L ). I t f o l l o w s t h a t f o r
E
> 0
given t h e r e e x i s t s
w E L+
532
COMPACT, AM-COMPACT AND SEMI-COMPACT
S(B+) c C-w,wl
+ clB
with
E]
&/l\SII
=
3
Ch. 18,51251
.
4 + For t h e proof t h a t S (B ) i s t o t a l l y bounded, i t i s s u f f i c i e n t , t h e r e f o r e , 3 4 + i s precompact (because S (B ) i s i n c l u d e d i n t o show t h a t S C-w,wl 3 S [-w,wl
A,
+ EB ). The p r i n c i p a l i d e a l
g e n e r a t e d by
w
i s an AM-space
as i t s c l o s e d u n i t b a l l ( s e e t h e p r o o f of Theorem 1 2 4 . 5 ) .
[-w,w]
with
Denote t h e r e s t r i c t i o n s of
and
S
to
T
by
A,
T1
and
S1
respectively.
I t i s s u f f i c i e n t t o prove t h a t S S S I : A,
+
L
+
L
-+
L
3
i s compact, b e c a u s e t h e n t h e image
C-W,~]
unit ball
in
by showing t h a t T2
A
S;(S*)2r
2
S C-w,wl
= S S
A,
i s AM-compact. S i n c e
i s an AM-space,
TT: L*
-t
A*
W
of t h e c l o s e d 2 S S 1 can b e proved
i s compact. For t h i s p u r p o s e , n o t e t h a t
+ A:
i s compact from which i t f o l l o w s t h a t ST
C-w,wl
i s precompact. Compactness of
L*
(T*)’
semi-compact), which i m p l i e s semi-compactness of prove t h a t
1
the operator
TI
i s compact (and hence (S*)’
i s AM-compact
TI
.
I t remains t o
(by h y p o t h e s i s ) and
i s compact. It f o l l o w s t h a t
is compact, and hence AM-compact. But t h e n
i s a l s o AM-
ST
compact (because t h e AM-compact o p e r a t o r s from
L* i n t o t h e AL-space A: form a band). T h i s proof i s due t o P . van E l d i k ( r e p l a c i n g a s i m p l e r proof
that
S5
i s compact).
EXERCISE 125.8. L e t
i t was proved t h a t i f o p e r a t o r s (from
M
L into
L
and
M
b e Banach l a t t i c e s . I n Theorem 123.4
h a s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s norm, then t h e AM-compact M ) form a band i n t h e s p a c e of o r d e r bounded
o p e r a t o r s . I n Theorem 125.5 i t w a s proved t h a t i f c o n t i n u o u s norm, t h e n and semi-compact.
T: L + M
T
L* have o r d e r
i s compact i f and o n l y i f
second proof of t h e r e s u l t ( i n Theorem 124.10) and
and
i s &compact
T
Show t h a t by combining t h e s e r e s u l t s w e can o b t a i n a
o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s norm and
0 5 S < T
M
S,T
i s compact, t h e n
EXERCISE 125.9. For
that i f
a r e o p e r a t o r s from
n = 0,1,2,
S
...
L
M
and
into
have
L*
M
such t h a t
i s compact.
,
let
Ln
b e a Zn-dimensional
real
v e c t o r s p a c e w i t h t h e u s u a l c o o r d i n a t e w i s e o r d e r i n g and t h e norm d e r i v e d from t h e u s u a l i n n e r p r o d u c t . For e v e r y i t s e l f i s g i v e n by t h e m a t r i x
An
n
, where
,
an o p e r a t o r mapping
Ln
into
Ch. 18,81251
533
COMPACT OPERATORS
Since the matrix B = 2-n/2A is orthogonal, Bn determines a norm presern n ving operator in Ln It follows that Cn = 2-"An determines an operator
.
I(Tnf 1 1
in Ln preserving orthogonality and such that
Tn
for every
f E Ln
. Since all entries in the matrix
of
=
2-"12 11 f 11
ITn/ are equal to
2-n , we have lTnlenk where
enk (k=1,2,...,2n)
Z&
= 2-n/2
,
. Note that
are the basis vectors of Ln
enk satisfies I/ p ( 1
f = Z a enk E Ln
if
2" Ek=l enk
2-
=
IT Ip,
and
= 1
p,
=
p
=
. Furthermore:
is arbitrary, then
.
ITn If = 2-n/2( ikak)Pn
Note now that, by the familiar Schwarz inequality,
It follows that
I/ I Tnl f 1)
with
, show
ITnlpn = p,
11 ITn/11
= 1
.
The space
=
2-n(Cak)2
b2 can be written as a direct
Define the operator T:
.
a T For n O n the operator norm of = Cm
result that T /TI
m
= Co 8
ITn[
Ekat
=
L2 + b,
,...
0,1,2
T?Sn
8
Show that
derive from this result that
let
Tn on each Ln , i.e.,
Sn = T 8 T, 0
tends to zero as n ITlp, = p,
IT1
ITn/ satisfies
sum
to be equal to
,
. Combining this result
I/ f It2
... .
+
... 8
(where
p,
.
Show that T n and derive from this
8
IT\ exists in L,
is compact. Show now that
.
=
that the operator norm of
Cm8L = L 8 L @L O n 0 1 2
T
5
and satisfies
is as defined above) and
is not compact. It follows that the set
L2 i s not a band in the Space all order bounded operators in L2 (although L2 and L; have order
of all order bounded compact operators in of
continuous norm). This example is due to U. Krengel ([21). that
IT/
is a positive kernel operator in
L, , so
Finally, note
that by Theorem 123.8
534
SEMI-COMPACTNESS AND ORDER
the operator
CONTINUITY
(TI is AM-compact. It follows that
Ch. 18,11261
IT/ must fail to be
semi-compact. This can be seen in a direct way by observing that =
, where
for all n
pn
(pn:n=0,1,2,
...)
IT\pn= is norm bounded, but not almost
order bounded. EXERCISE 125.10. In Theorem 125.6 it is shown that if L Banach lattices such that L* T: L
+
M
and M
are
has order continuous norm and the operator is AM-compact. If the norm in L*
is AM-compact, then T*
is
not order continuous, this does not necessarily hold. A s an example, let T: L ,
+
where
L [0,27~1 be defined by 1
r
bounded. Since every order bounded subset of 122.7), it is clear that in L1
is positive and norm
is the n-th Rademacher function. Then T
by
, we
en
have
T
is AM-compact. Denoting the n-th unit vector
Ten
=
+
for all n
r n
Idx This shows that
Ll
is precompact (Exercise
=
71
.
Hence
for m # n
.
T is not compact. Show now that T*: Lm
AM-compact (because AM-compactness of
is not
+
T would trivially imply compactness).
126. Semi-compact,operators and order continuity of the operator norm
In this section L and M
A
are again Banach lattices (norms
and
respectively). A s defined in the previous section, the order bounded ope-
rator T: L unit ball
+
B
M
o f the closed
is called semi-compact if the image T(B)
in L
there exists 0
2
is almost order bounded in M
v C: M
(1)
, i.e.,
for all
c E
exist such that
T
f E B
is semi-compact, but
in Lemma 124.1, if 0 IT1
exists and
S S 2
IT1
if for any
E
> 0
such that
.
As we have seen in Exercise 125.9, it is possible that T
if
p
T
and T
and
IT1
both
\TI is not. Furthermore, as shown
is semi-compact, then so is S
is semi-compact, then so is
T
.
. Hence,
Ch. 18,11261
5 35
COMPACT OPERATORS
We shall firstindicate a sufficient condition for a positive operator to be semi-compact, holding under rather weak hypotheses for the spaces L and M
.
Under much stronger assumptions the condition is also necessary, as will be shown later. To begin with, assume only that M has the principal projection property (besides the general assumption that L Banach lattices). Let (Pn:n=1,2,
...)
principal bands (B :n=1,2,...)
in M
nnBn
=
COI ). Let
order projection on
R=
pn
-
P,+]
d Bn+l
Bn
and M
are
be any sequence of order projections on such that P
for n = 1,2,
.
+
0 (equivalently,
... . Therefore, Qn
is the
L rmd M be Banach l a t t i c e s such that M has the p r h ~ c i p a lprojection property and l e t T: L + M be a p o s i t i v e operator. For any descending sequence (Bn:n=1,2, ) o f principal bands i n M satisfying n B = {O} , l e t Pn and Qn be defined as explained above. n n (i) I f , for every choice of the descending sequence (B,) with n Bn = { O } , the operator norm /lQnTII of QnT tends t o zero as n + m , then T i s semi-conpact. (ii) I f , f o r eve22 choice of the descending sequence (B,) with ll Bn = { O } , the operator norm IIPnTII of PnT tends t o zero as n + m , then T i s semi-compact. (iii) I f , f o r every sequence (Sn:n=1,2, ) of operators from L THEOREM 126.1. Let
...
i n t o M satisfying i s semi-compact.
T 2 Sn J. 0
, the norm
PROOF. It is sufficient to prove (i). (i) holds, but T
...)
2 E
and
T
Assume that the hypothesis in
is not semi-compact. Then there exists a number
and a sequence (u :n=l,2, n L such that h(Tu 1
...
llSnll tends t o zero, then
E
of positive elements in the unit ball
X
-2" Zf'
Tq)f}
z
E
for n 2 2
> 0
B
.
Let w
n
= (Tun-2"
'-:X
Tt-L
m
2-kTtj)f
n+1
Note that r - 01 n - 'n+l 2-kTq exists in M an order limit) because M is Banach and
for n = 1,2,..
..
as a norm limit (and hence as
T is norm bounded. Since rn
of
536
tends t o zero i n norm a s n
n
-+
s u f f i c i e n t l y l a r g e , say f o r
sequence
(wn:n=1,2,
wm
-
...)
2-"(
5
-
,
Ch. 18,11261
AND ORDER CONTINUITY
SEMI-COMF'ACTNESS
i t follows from (2) t h a t
. Note
n 2 no
A(wn) t
for
;E
a l s o t h a t t h e norm bounded
i s d i s j o i n t . Indeed, f o r
m < n
we have
2nTum-Tuny = 2-n(Tun-2nTum)-
..
n = I,.?.,. , l e t Bn be the band i n M generated by -k e = C 2 wk Then f l Bn = {O} and, with t h e n o t a t i o n s agreed upon, n n Qn By hypothesis i s t h e order p r o j e c t i o n on t h e band generated by w
Now, f o r
IIQnTII
.
-+
as
0
n
119nTI1 n t no
for
-.
-+
.
On the o t h e r hand,
X(Q Tu ) t X(Qnwn) = X(wn) t n n
2
. Contradiction.
Hence, T
:E
i s semi-compact.
The theorem j u s t proved has a p p l i c a t i o n s t o k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s from one Banach function space i n t o another. Let spaces
M(Y,v)
and
M
(Y,C,v)
and
r e s p e c t i v e l y . Note t h a t
(X,h,u)
a r e Dedekind complete. We may assume t h a t t h e c a r r i e r of
t h e c a r r i e r of
M
is
X
. Assume
with r e s p e c t t o t h e norms
M
be i d e a l s i n t h e Riesz
of a l l r e a l measurable f u n c t i o n s on t h e o-fi-
M(X,p)
n i t e measure spaces
M
and
L
and
p
also that
X
L
and
M
L
is
L
to
Y
has t h e same c a r r i e r as
. Furthermore,
o p e r a t o r s (from
L
and hence a l s o operator (from
into
(LFM)dd L
, i.e.,
by Theorem 95.1,
a r e Banach l a t t i c e s
M
, is
M
and L* = L"
n
L* i s a l s o equal n t h e space of a l l absolute k e r n e l
t h e c a r r i e r of
M ) i s e x a c t l y t h e band
123.5(ii) i t was shown t h a t i f I n o t h e r words, i f
L
and
r e s p e c t i v e l y . I n o t h e r words, L
a r e Banach f u n c t i o n spaces. By Theorem 112.1 t h e a s s o c i a t e space
of
and
L Y
. I n Theorem
(L:BM)dd
has order continuous norm, then
dd (L*@M)
contained i n t h e band of AM-compact o p e r a t o r s .
has order continuous norm, then every absolute k e r n e l
into
M ) i s AM-compact. Our next purpose i s t o f i n d
reasonable conditions under which every absolute k e r n e l operator i s semicompact. Assume f i r s t t h a t theorem, T n + Pn f 0
P
in
M
T
i s p o s i t i v e . Then, according t o t h e l a s t
i s semi-compact i f t h e o p e r a t o r norm
f o r every sequence
. Since
M
n
(P,)
IlP TI1 tends t o zero as
of order pEojections i n
i s an i d e a l i n t h e space
M(X,p)
,
M
satisfying
any order p r o j e c t i o n
can be w r i t t e n a s a m u l t i p l i c a t i o n by a c h a r a c t e r i s t i c f u n c t i o n
Ch. 1 8 , 5 1 2 6 1
xE
f o r some p-measurable
= xE(x)f(x)
subset
E
almost everywhere i n
that the s e t
of X
has the kernel
xE(x)T(x,y)
projections i n
M
X
, and
operator
that is t o say, (Pf)(x) =
f o r every
. To
f E M
M(X,p) ; t h e s e t T
j.
i s now simply
,
T(x,y)
any sequence E
see t h i s , note
E
has t h e k e r n e l
. Furthermore,
P
0
j.
0
then
PT
of o r d e r
of measurable s e t s
conversely. Therefore, i t i s s u f f i c i e n t f o r the p o s i t i v e k e r n e l T(x,y) Z 0
with kernel
T
x
f o r e v e r y sequence
E
0
j.
in
X
t o be semi-compact (x) T(x,y)
EIl Of c o u r s e , i f
.
i s o r d e r bounded b u t n o t p o s i t i v e , and t i s f i e s t h e mentioned c o n d i t i o n , t h e n T
,
c o r r e s p o n d s w i t h a sequence
norm of t h e o p e r a t o r w i t h k e r n e l
so i s
X
i s an i d e a l i n
(Pf:fEM)
t h e c a r r i e r o f t h a t i d e a l . Hence, i f
in
537
COMPACT OPERATORS
.
Assume now t h a t b o t h
L*
and
M
T
compact, t h e n
T
L
T(x,y) ) sa-
and hence
have o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s norm. Then,
T: L
i s AM-compact a s w e l l a s semi-compact.
T
i s an a b s o l u t e k e r n e l o p e r a t o r from
+ m
IT(x,y)/ )
i s semi-compact,
IT1
n
(with k e r n e l
(with k e r n e l
IT1
a c c o r d i n g t o Theorem 125.5, any o r d e r bounded o p e r a t o r i f and o n l y i f
t h a t the operator
t e n d s t o z e r o as
into
M
+
M
i s compact
I f , therefore, T
such t h a t
T
i s semi-
i s a l r e a d y compact. As observed above, i t i s s u f f i c i e n t
f o r semi-compactness
of
T
t h a t , f o r e v e r y sequence
En
j.
0 in
X
,
the o p e r a t o r norm of t h e o p e r a t o r w i t h k e r n e l
tends t o zero a s satisfying
n
1 < p <
. As
+ m m
a n example, l e t L = L (Y,v) f o r some p P M = L (X,p) f o r some q s a t i s f y i n g 1 5 q < q, -1 p-I + (p ) = 1 Note t h a t L* and M have
and
.
L* = L , ( Y , v ) for P o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s norm. Assume now t h a t t h e ( u x v ) - m e a s u r a b l e f u n c t i o n
Then
T(x,y)
satisfies
It i s e a s i l y s e e n t h a t
T(x,y)
i s t h e k e r n e l of a n o r d e r bounded k e r n e l
operator T: L ( Y , v ) P and
IT(x,y)l
-t
Lq(X,v)
is t h e k e r n e l of
, IT1
. Furthermore,
m.
t h e o p e r a t o r norm of
5 38
SEMI-COMPACTNESS AND ORDER C O N T I N U I T Y
i s majorized by
IT1
, because
I!ITlllpq
f o r any
f
E
Ch. 18,51267
t h e norm
L
we have
1 5
where
p (f) S
P
1
(ITlf)(x) PPl{TX(Y
Tx(y) = T(x,y)
for
x
f i x e d . Hence
which i m p l i e s
Therefore, t h e corresponding o p e r a t o r norm tends t o z e r o a s w e l l . I n view of t h e above remarks, t h i s shows t h a t
and
IT(
T
a r e compact.
We formulate t h e obvious g e n e r a l i z a t i o n t o Banach f u n c t i o n s p a c e s , which w i l l a l s o cover t h e case
p =
m
i n t h e example above. The proof f o r
t h i s more g e n e r a l case i s n o t a l t o g e t h e r t r i v i a l s i n c e i t i s based on a n o t
s o obvious m e a s u r a b i l i t y r e s u l t , namely, t h e Luxemburg-Gribanov r e s u l t A s mentioned above, we may assume t h a t
i n Theorem 99.2 and C o r o l l a r y 99.3. both Lt
L
and t h e
associate space
i s t h e n sometimes denoted by
r e s t r i c t i o n of t h e norm L = L_(Y,v)
,
then
in
p*
I
if
X
p
and
have c a r r i e r
L
and X
and we r e c a l l t h a t
Y
and t h e norm i n
L'
L* ) i s then denoted by
(i.e., p'
the
. Note
that
(Theorem 118.1; l a s t
i s o r d e r continuous (Theorem 118.2). The
p*
a s s o c i a t e space i s now t h e space THEOREM 126.2. Let
L'
i s an a b s t r a c t L-space
L*
p a r t of t h e p r o o f ) , and so
abooe) with noms
L:
LI(Y,v) M
.
be Banach function spaces (as defined
respectivezy such t h a t the norm
p*
i n L*
i n M are order continuous (hence, the norm p ' i n L' i s likewise order continuous). Fwthermore, Let the (pw)-measurable real function T(x,y) on X x Y s a t i s f y and the n o m
Ch. 18,51261
Tx(y) = T(x,y)
where x
5 39
C W A C T OPERATORS
for f i x e d
x
, i.e.,
f i x e d . Then the absolute kernel operator
T(x,y) T: L
as a function of
* N with kernel
y
for
T(x,y)
is compact. PROOF. By t h e r e s u l t of Luxemburg i n Corollary 99.3 t h e f u n c t i o n
i s a p-measurable non-negative
t ( x ) = p'iTx(y)} that
IIITlllpk
A(t) <
, i.e.,
f o r any
f E L
and t h e r e f o r e of
IT1
f u n c t i o n on
X ; i t follows
i s a w e l l defined number. By our hypothesis, w e have the function with
t
X(ITIf)
5
i s a menher of the space
M
. Furthermore,
w e have
p(f) 5 1
X(t) =
!llTlllph
. It
follows t h a t the o p e r a t o r norm
satisfies
I f t h e sequence
(En)
t xEn(x)t(x) i 0
, xhi& ,
of s u b s e t s of
implies
X
x(x
satisfies t) 4 0
0 ,
En J.
bscausr
h
then
t(x) 2
is order c o n t i -
mobs. In o t h e r word6
i.e.,
IT1
i s semi-compact by what was observed before. I t follows t h a t
i s compact and, t h e r e f o r e , T The number
IIITll/pA i s c a l l e d t h e double norm of the kennel operator
T (more p r e c i s e l y , t h e ph-double
norm). Operators with
lllTlllpA f i n i t e a r e
-
and
c a l l e d operators of f i n i t e double norm. For k e r n e l o p e r a t o r s with
lllTlllpq <
because t h e theorem t h a t E. H i l l e and J . D .
lllTlllpq <
-
1 < p 2
m
1 5 q <
m
,
a r e c a l l e d HilZe-Tamrkin operdtors,
Tamarkin (C11,1934).
implies compactness of
T
i s due t o
Their proof i s q u i t e d i f f e r e n t from
the proof as presented here. Note t h a t f o r
i s equal t o
IT1
i s compact.
p = q = 2
the number
lllTlllpq
SEMI-COMPACTNESS AND ORDER CONTINUITY
540
Ch. 18,51261
XXY
t h e corresponding o p e r a t o r s a r e t h e Hilbert-Schmidt o p e r a t o r s . I n t h e b e g i n n i n g of t h e p r e s e n t s e c t i o n i t w a s shown t h a t i f
/ISnlI
t h e p r i n c i p a l p r o j e c t i o n p r o p e r t y and i f
J- 0
M
has
f o r any sequence
+
(Sn)
L into M satisfying T 2 S 0 , then T i s s e m i n compact. We s h a l l prove now t h a t t h e converse h o l d s under t h e much s t r o n g e r
of o p e r a t o r s from
condition t h a t both
L*
THEOREM 126.3. Let
A
and L
M
have o r d e r continuous norm. M
and
be Banach l a t t i c e s (with norms
r e s p e c t i v e t y l such t h a t t h e norm p* T
ordercontinuous. Furthermore, l e t M
. Then
T
of operators s a t i s f y i n g
and the n o m
(1 n
T
/IS
S
2
n
C 0
PROOF. I t i s only n e c e s s a r y t o prove t h a t i f
t h e mentioned c o n d i t i o n h o l d s . Hence, l e t The image
i.e.,
T(B)
of t h e u n i t b a l l
there exists
{
0 5 vo E M
A (Tu-v )
o+>
<
E
Furthermore, s i n c e t h e norm closed u n i t b a l l i n
@
is p
in
VO
Now, t a k e any a r b i t r a r y
0 5 u E B
that
A*($)
< 1
. It
L
into
holds f o r any se-
. T
i s semi-compact,
b e semi-compact and
then
M
E @
.
i s o r d e r c o n t i n u o u s , t h e norm
f o l l o w s from
such t h a t
and any a r b i t r a r y
0 5 $ E
fi
.
T2 S C 0 n M ,
-almost o r d e r bounded (Theorem 125.2), i . e . ,
0 S @
0
0
and
i s almost o r d e r bounded i n
0 < u E B
for all
A
T L
C
p
i n M are
such t h a t
t h e r e e x i s t s a n element
ing
in
B
A
be a p o s i t i v e operator from
i s semi-compact i f and only i f
(Sn)
quence
L*
in
satisfy-
Ch. 18,91261
54 1
COMPACT OPERATORS
(3)
By h y p o t h e s i s
Sn C 0
$o(Snw) C 0
hence
,
0 5 w 5 L
has o r d e r continuous norm, s o
,
i.e.,
p*(S;$*)
(3) t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s a n a t u r a l number
such t h a t
0
5
IJJ E
$(Snu) < 3~
M*
holds f o r
holds f o r a l l
satisfying
A*($)
11 Snll
0
as
C 0
S;+,
+
0
no n
2
holds i n
C 0
. It
, and
L
b0
is
no
, all
1
. But
L*
L*
follows t h e r e f o r e from
(not depending on
. The l a s t f a c t 5 u 5 B . But t h e n n + . 5
and a l l
n Z no
I n o t h e r words,
in
h a s o r d e r continuous norm). This shows t h a t
M
f o r any
C 0
n
$o t h e same a s above ( n o t e h e r e t h a t
o r d e r continuous s i n c e (S;$o)(w)
w Z 0
f o r any a r b i t r a r y
S w C 0
so
for
0
5
5
A(Snu) 5 3~
for
3~
$ )
and a l l
u E B
implies t h a t
1 1 Sn 11
or
u
n 2 n
0 '
m
The r e a d e r i s warned a g a i n s t t r y i n g t o avoid t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of p*
$o
by a r g u i n g t h a t
C 0
S
S u C 0
implies
and hence
$J~(S,U)C 0
i s o r d e r continuous i n view of t h e o r d e r c o n t i n u i t y of
t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s a n a t u r a l number
n 1. n,
. We
nl
such t h a t
cannot be s u r e , however, t h a t
nl
$,(Snu)
1.
A
<
E
(since
I t follows
for a l l
does n o t depend on
u
.
The r e s u l t i n t h e l a s t theorem o c c u r s i n t h e Dodds-Fremlin paper el1 (combination of Theorem 5.1 and 5.2 of t h a t paper; Theorem 5 . 2 i s based on t h e r a t h e r complieated Theorem 2.5). The d i r e c t proof p r e s e n t e d h e r e goes back t o Fremlin (1975). If
L
and
M
and ( a s b e f o r e )
a r e Banach l a t t i c e s such t h a t
bounded o p e r a t o r s from
M
i s Dedekind complete
i s t h e Dedekind complete Riesz s p a c e of a l l o r d e r
Lb(L,M)
L
into
M
,
t h e n ( a s f o l l o w s from Theozem 83.12)
T E L (L,M) i s norm bounded. To each T E L (L,M) we a s s i g n now t h e b b o p e r a t o r norm of IT1 and we denote t h i s number by / / T l l r , i . e . ,
every
The number IlTll
= IITll,
i s c a l l e d t h e r-norm of
IlTll
Riesz norm i n
Lb(L,M) if
T
. Furthermore,
IlTll
T 5
. Obviously,
ikTllr f o r every
t h e r-norm i s a T
and
i s p o s i t i v e . According t o Theorem 102.8 t h e s u b s e t of
SEMI-COMPACTNESS AND ORDER CONTINUITY
542
Lb(L,M)
of all T
,
in Lb(L,M)
11s I I J . 0 is an ideal
IT1 2 Sn C 0 implies
such that
n
the largest ideal on which the r-norm is
Our last theorem shows that if the norms in L* o u s , this ideal is exactly the set of all
corresponding
IT1
T
18,81261
Ch.
a-order continuous.
and M
are order continu-
L (L,M)
in
for which the b is semi-compact. Note that this set may be properly
smaller than the set of all semi-compact T because, as we have seen, there exist semi-compact T
IT1
for which
is not semi-campact.
Although it is somewhat outside of the main subject in the present discussion, we include a proof that
Lb(L,M)
i s a Banach lattice with
respect to the r-norm. THEOREM 126.4. Let
such t h a t
M
L and
M
be Banach l a t t i e e s [norms p
i s Dedekind complete. Then the Riesz space
X I
and
Lb(L,M)
is a
Lb(L,M)
with re-
Banach l a t t i c e w i t h respect t o the r-norm. PROOF. Let
(Tn:n=1,2,
...)
be a Cauchy seqeunce in
spect to the r-norm. By passing to a subsequence if necessary we may assume that 11 Tn+l-TnIIr 5 2-(n+1)
for all n
. The sequence
(T,)
is Cauchy with
respect to the ordinary operator norm as well and, therefore, Tn to a norm bounded operator T (from L
converges
into M ) with respect to the
ordinary operator norm. It follows that for any
-
, the
f E L
.
element
T f is the norm limit of Zq (Tn+,-Tn)f Hence, I Tf-T f 1 is the P n=p P norm limit of IZ:,p(Tn+l-Tn)f I .Now, let u E L+ be given. Then the sum
Tf
is increasing as q for k > q > p
increases and
we have
Hence, the norm limit s
of
s
Q
s
4
converges in norm as q
is equal to
. All
sup s
q
X(s ) 5 2-’.p(u) , which implies h ( s ) 2 2-’.p(u) since s 9 limit of s Finally, let f E L satisfy If/ 5 u Then
. 4
11; (Tn+I-Tn)fl
.
5
Ef, ITn+,-Tn 1(u) = s9
5
s
.
s
9
+
- 7
because
satisfy
is the norm
Ch.
18,51261
COMPACT OPERATORS
It f o l l o w s t h a t t h e norm l i m i t ( a s
s
i s a l s o majorized by
, i.e.,
q
-+ m
ITf-T f l P
5
543
) of t h e e x p r e s s i o n on t h e l e f t
. Hence
s
Taking norms, we g e t
{
X IT-Tpl(u)}
.
X(s) 5 2-’.p(u)
5
I i s a norm bounded o p e r a t o r w i t h o p e r a t o r norm a t P It f o l l o w s t h a t T i s t h e l i m i t most e q u a l t o 2-’ , i . e . , I[T-T 11 5 2-’ P r bf (T : p = l , 2 , ) w i t h r e s p e c t t o t h e r-norm. P This shows t h a t
IT-T
.
...
A t t h i s p o i n t i t i s perhaps of some i n t e r e s t t o make t h e f o l l o w i n g
remarks about semi-compact o p e r a t o r s and AM-compact o p e r a t o r s (from
L
into
M ). Semi-compactness has t h e p l e a s a n t p r o p e r t y t h a t any p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r
majorized by a semi-compact o p e r a t o r i s i t s e l f semi-compact
(Lemma 124.1).
b u t a t t h e s a m e time i t i s u n p l e a s a n t t h a t (even i f a l l norms involved a r e o r d e r continuous) t h e semi-compact o p e r a t o r s may f a i l t o form an i d e a l , i.e.,
i t may happen t h a t
125.9). M
T
i s semi-compact and
IT1
i s not (Exercise
On t h e o t h e r hand, AM-compactness h a s t h e p l e a s a n t p r o p e r t y t h a t i f
has o r d e r continuous norm, t h e n t h e AM-compact o p e r a t o r s form a band.
I f , however, t h e norm i n
M
i s n o t o r d e r continuous, i t may occur t h a t a
p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r majorized by a n AM-compact o p e r a t o r is n o t AM-compact (because o t h e r w i s e i t would always f o l l o w from that
S2
EXERCISE 126.5. L e t
L
p r o j e c t i o n p r o p e r t y and l e t with t h e property t h a t
T
L
compact
T
b e a p o s i t i v e AM-compact o p e r a t o r i n
IIPnTII f O
p a c t f o r any p o s i t i v e o p e r a t o r if
with
b e a Banach l a t t i c e p o s s e s s i n g t h e p r i n c i p a l f o r every sequence
p r o j e c t i o n s on p r i n c i p a l bands. Show t h a t S
in
S
in
L
satisfying
0 < S
T2
S2 5
T
.
HINT: Theorem 126.1 and E x e r c i s e 125.7.
P,
4 0
i s compact and
satisfying
L
has o r d e r continuous norm, t h e n
operator
0 5 S 5 T
i s compact, which i s n o t t h e case a s shown i n examples i n s e c h i o n 124).
0 2 S 2 T
L
of o r d e r S4
i s com-
. Show t h a t
i s compact f o r any p o s i t i v e
SEMI-COMPACT OPERATORS AND D I S J O I N T SEQUENCES
544
. 18,11273
Ch
127. Semi compact operators and d i s j o i n t sequences A s i n t h e p r e v i o u s s e c t i o n , w e assume t h a t
ces (norms
p
and
r e s p e c t i v e l y , norms
X
L and M a r e Banach l a t t i -
p*
and
i n the Banach
X*
d u a l s ) . I n Theorem 3 of t h e previous s e c t i o n i t w a s proved t h a t i f the norms and
p*
M
,
then
a r e order continuous and
X T
T
i s a p o s i t i v e operator from
i s semi-compact i f and only i f
.
llSnllS 0
L
into
holds f o r every se-
quence (Sn) satisfying T 2 S S 0 I n the p r e s e n t s e c t i o n we s h a l l deal n with s e v e r a l o t h e r c o n d i t i o n s , necessary and s u f f i c i e n t f o r T t o be semicompact. In these conditions
i s not n e c e s s a r i l y p o s i t i v e . A s seen
T
e a r l i e r ( i n formula ( 1 ) of the previous s e c t i o n ) , i t i s an immediate consequence of t h e d e f i n i t i o n of semi-compactness t h a t the o r d e r bounded operator T
(from
L
-.
into
M ) i s semi-compact i f and only i f f o r any
E
> 0
there
v = v
for a l l
f
exists a positive i n the u n i t b a l l I T I(w)
for a l l
B
of
in L
f o r an appropriate
.
M
such t h a t
I n some cases t h e element
w E L+
i s Dedekind complete (so t h a t every
. For
0 5 f E B
and l e t f i r s t
Also, since
so
v
i s of the form
, so
f