Rotary Drilling and Blasting in Large Surface Mines
Book.indb i
11/22/2010 2:33:39 PM
Rotary Drilling and Blasting in Large Surface Mines
Bhalchandra V. Gokhale
Book.indb iii
11/22/2010 2:33:40 PM
Cover Illustration:
Atlas Copco Pit Viper 351E drilling 311 mm holes to a depth of 19 m in the Aitik Mine, Sweden, owned by Boliden Mining Co. Courtesy of Atlas Copco, 2009
CRC Press/Balkema is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business © 2011 Taylor & Francis Group, London, UK Typeset by Vikatan Publishing Solutions (P) Ltd, Chennai, India Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe ( A CPI-group Company), Chippenham, Wiltshire All rights reserved. No part of this publication or the information contained herein may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, by photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. Innovations reported here may not be used without the approval of the authors. Although all care is taken to ensure integrity and the quality of this publication and the information herein, no responsibility is assumed by the publishers nor the author for any damage to the property or persons as a result of operation or use of this publication and/or the information contained herein. Published by: CRC Press/Balkema P.O. Box 447, 2300 AK Leiden, The Netherlands e-mail:
[email protected] www.crcpress.com – www.taylorandfrancis.co.uk – www.balkema.nl Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines / editor, Bhalchandra V. Gokhale. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-415-87878-4 (hardback) 1. Blasting. 2. Rotary drilling. 3. Strip mining. I. Gokhale, B.V. (Bhalchandra V.) TN279.R68 2011 622’.292–dc22 2010045162 ISBN: 978-0-415-87878-4 (Hbk) ISBN: 978-0-203-84139-6 (eBook)
Book.indb iv
11/22/2010 2:33:40 PM
Dedication
Dedicated to, My father, who gave me his genes, My mother, who brought me up and showered me with love till my 50s, Both my elder brothers, who supported me after the early demise of my father, My wife, who has been bearing with me for four decades, My daughter, son in law, son and daughter in law who have been making my life worth living, My grand daughter, who has kept me active.
Book.indb v
11/22/2010 2:33:40 PM
Contents
Foreword Preface Credits for illustrations 1 Surface rock excavation scenario 1.1 1.2
1.3 1.4 1.5
1.6
Introduction Need for surface rock excavation 1.2.1 Recovery of minerals or crushed rock 1.2.2 Creation of unobstructed space Strength of rock mass and classes Drill and blast operations Options to drill and blast 1.5.1 Water jetting 1.5.2 Machine digging 1.5.3 Ripping 1.5.4 Rock breaking Oilwell drilling
2 An overview of blasthole drilling 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5
Introduction Basic concepts of drilling Peculiarities of blasthole drilling Comparison of drilling methods Choice of a blasthole drilling method
3 Properties of rocks 3.1 3.2 3.3
Book.indb vii
Introduction Earth and its interior Geological cycle 3.3.1 Igneous rocks
xxv xxvii xxxi 1 1 1 1 3 3 4 7 7 7 8 11 12 15 15 16 22 23 27 31 31 31 34 35
11/22/2010 2:33:40 PM
viii
Contents
3.3.2 3.3.3
3.4
3.5 3.6 3.7
Sedimentary rocks Metamorphic rocks 3.3.3.1 Contact metamorphism 3.3.3.2 Regional metamorphism 3.3.3.3 Dynamic metamorphism 3.3.3.4 Impact metamorphism Formation of rock mass 3.4.1 Volcanic activities 3.4.1.1 Extrusive structures 3.4.1.2 Hypabyssal structures 3.4.2 Plutonic structures 3.4.3 Surface activities Soils, rocks and their profile Occurrence of minerals Rock specimen properties 3.7.1 Density 3.7.2 Compressive strength 3.7.3 Tensile strength 3.7.4 Hardness 3.7.4.1 Shore hardness 3.7.4.2 Vickers hardness 3.7.5 Toughness 3.7.6 Brittleness 3.7.7 Coefficient of internal friction 3.7.8 Swell factor 3.7.9 Abrasiveness 3.7.9.1 Cerchar abrasiveness test 3.7.9.2 Miniature drill test 3.7.9.3 Bit wear test
4 Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5
Introduction Era of shot hole drilling Rotary drilling Rotary blasthole drilling Truck mounted rotary blasthole drills
5 Rotary blasthole drilling bits 5.1 5.2
Book.indb viii
Introduction Drag bits 5.2.1 Blade bits 5.2.2 Claw bits 5.2.3 Feed force and rotation of drag bits
36 37 38 38 38 38 40 40 40 40 40 43 43 44 46 47 47 50 52 53 54 54 54 55 57 57 57 58 60 61 61 61 63 71 80 83 83 83 83 85 85
11/22/2010 2:33:40 PM
Contents
5.3
5.4
5.5
5.6 5.7
Tricone bits 5.3.1 Types and nomenclature 5.3.2 Geometrical design aspects 5.3.2.1 Fluid circulation 5.3.2.1.1 Air cooled tricone bits 5.3.2.1.2 Sealed bearing bits 5.3.2.2 Size and shapes of teeth 5.3.2.3 Cone size 5.3.2.4 Number of teeth 5.3.2.5 Cone orientation 5.3.2.6 Top connections 5.3.3 Metallurgy 5.3.3.1 Materials 5.3.3.2 Heat treatment 5.3.4 Summary of design features 5.3.5 Bit load and rotation of tricone bits 5.3.6 IADC code Dull bit analysis 5.4.1 Bit observation 5.4.1.1 Observation during drilling operation 5.4.1.2 Observation after bit withdrawal 5.4.1.3 Observation at final bit rejection Bit records 5.5.1 General data 5.5.2 Formation data 5.5.3 Blasthole drill and accessories details 5.5.4 Bit performance details 5.5.5 Bit discard details Bit failure analysis and remedy Discarding drill bits
6 Rotary blasthole drilling accessories 6.1 6.2
6.3
6.4
Book.indb ix
Introduction Drill pipes 6.2.1 Integral drill pipes 6.2.2 Fabricated drill pipes 6.2.3 Choice of a drill pipe Stabilizers 6.3.1 Replaceable sleeve stabilizers 6.3.2 Welded blade stabilizers 6.3.3 Integral blade stabilizers 6.3.4 Roller stabilizers Crossover subs
ix
86 87 91 91 91 94 95 95 98 99 100 100 101 102 103 105 105 107 108 108 108 108 109 109 111 111 111 111 112 114 117 117 117 118 118 122 123 125 126 126 127 128
11/22/2010 2:33:40 PM
x
Contents
6.5
6.6
6.7
Shock absorbers 6.5.1 External shock absorber 6.5.2 In the hole shock absorbers Miscellaneous accessories 6.6.1 Thread protectors 6.6.2 Lifting bails and hoisting plugs 6.6.3 Blasthole plugs 6.6.4 Rotary deck bushing 6.6.5 Drill stem wrench 6.6.6 Bit breaker 6.6.7 Blasthole inclinometer 6.6.8 Blasthole camera 6.6.9 Feed force measuring kit 6.6.10 Blasthole dewatering pump 6.6.11 Recovery tools 6.6.12 Blasthole sampler 6.6.13 Laser measuring instruments Miscellaneous safety items 6.7.1 Close fitting shirt and long pants 6.7.2 Safety glasses 6.7.3 Safety toed shoes 6.7.4 Ear plugs or ear muffs 6.7.5 Safety vest 6.7.6 Respirator 6.7.7 Rain coat 6.7.8 Face shield
7 Rotary blasthole drills 7.1 7.2 7.3
7.4 7.5
Book.indb x
Introduction Assemblies in rotary blasthole drills 7.2.1 Assembly placement Types of rotary blasthole drills 7.3.1 Special purpose rotary blasthole drills 7.3.2 Conventional rotary blasthole drills 7.3.2.1 Crawler mounted rotary blasthole drills 7.3.2.2 Carrier mounted rotary blasthole drills 7.3.2.3 Comparison of crawler vs. carrier Layouts of rotary blasthole drills Details of assemblies 7.5.1 Assemblies in the lower group 7.5.1.1 Carrier undercarriage 7.5.1.2 Crawler undercarriage
128 130 132 134 134 134 134 136 136 137 137 139 141 143 144 145 147 150 150 150 150 150 150 151 151 151 153 153 153 155 156 157 160 160 160 161 163 163 163 163 166
11/22/2010 2:33:40 PM
Contents
7.5.2
7.5.3
7.5.4
Book.indb xi
7.5.1.2.1 Slewing crawler undercarriage 7.5.1.2.2 Pivoted crawler undercarriage 7.5.1.2.3 Crawler track components Assemblies in the upper group 7.5.2.1 Main frame 7.5.2.2 Leveling jacks 7.5.2.3 Prime mover 7.5.2.4 Compressor 7.5.2.5 Hydraulic system 7.5.2.6 Bit lubricating system 7.5.2.7 Automatic lubrication system 7.5.2.8 Radiators and oil coolers 7.5.2.9 Machinery house 7.5.2.10 Dust control system 7.5.2.10.1 Wet dust control 7.5.2.10.2 Dry dust control 7.5.2.11 Operator’s cab 7.5.2.12 Driver’s cab 7.5.2.13 Fuel tanks 7.5.2.14 Transformer and cable reel Assemblies in the mast group 7.5.3.1 Mast 7.5.3.2 Mast raising cylinders and mast braces 7.5.3.3 Mast ladder 7.5.3.4 Pipe changer 7.5.3.4.1 Carousel pipe changers 7.5.3.4.2 Single pipe changers 7.5.3.5 Bit changer 7.5.3.6 Angle hole attachments 7.5.3.7 Rotary head 7.5.3.8 Feed mechanism 7.5.3.8.1 Double drum and wire rope 7.5.3.8.2 Hydraulic cylinder and wire rope 7.5.3.8.3 Hydraulic cylinder and chain 7.5.3.8.4 Fixed sprockets and chain 7.5.3.8.5 Rack and pinion with chain 7.5.3.8.6 Chainless rack and pinion 7.5.3.9 Auxiliary winch 7.5.3.10 Tool handling jib 7.5.3.11 Centralizer Special purpose items 7.5.4.1 Language name plate 7.5.4.2 Lighting
xi
166 169 169 172 173 174 175 176 177 177 178 181 181 181 182 184 186 188 189 189 189 190 191 191 191 191 194 196 196 198 200 200 200 201 201 202 203 204 204 205 205 206 206
11/22/2010 2:33:40 PM
xii
Contents
7.6
7.7
7.5.4.3 Fast fuel fill system 7.5.4.4 Depth indicator 7.5.4.5 Fast retract system 7.5.4.6 Tow hook 7.5.4.7 Fire extinguishers 7.5.4.8 Automatic fire suppression system 7.5.4.9 Welding outlet 7.5.4.10 Automatic leveling system 7.5.4.11 Remote propel control 7.5.4.12 Air conditioners 7.5.4.13 Heaters 7.5.4.14 Hydraulic test station 7.5.4.15 Video camera system Extreme cold operation devices 7.6.1 Engine starting aid 7.6.1.1 Glow plugs 7.6.1.2 Manifold flame heater 7.6.2 Batteries 7.6.3 Double wall machinery house 7.6.4 Machinery house heater 7.6.5 Operator cab heater 7.6.6 Other enclosures and heaters 7.6.7 Protective coating on steel components Comparison of types of blasthole drills
8 Compressed air and air compressors 8.1 8.2
8.3
Book.indb xii
Introduction Compressed air 8.2.1 Gas laws 8.2.1.1 Boyle’s law 8.2.1.2 Charles’ law 8.2.1.3 Guy Lussac’s law 8.2.1.4 Joule’s law 8.2.1.5 Poisson’s law 8.2.1.6 Amagat’s law 8.2.1.7 Avogadro’s law 8.2.1.8 General gas law 8.2.2 Power required for air compression Flow of compressed air 8.3.1 Compressed air flow in steel pipes 8.3.1.1 Simplified formulae 8.3.1.1.1 Harris formula 8.3.1.1.2 Engineering toolbox formula
207 209 209 210 210 212 213 213 214 215 215 215 215 217 217 218 218 218 218 219 219 219 220 220 223 223 223 225 225 225 226 226 226 227 227 227 228 231 233 239 239 240
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
Contents
8.3.2 Compressed air flow in hose pipes 8.3.3 Compressed air flow in pipe fittings 8.3.4 Effect of ups and downs in the flow path 8.3.5 Effect of curvature in the flow path 8.3.6 Compressed air flow through nozzles 8.3.7 Leakage of compressed air 8.4 Compressors used on blasthole drills 8.4.1 Sliding vane rotary compressors 8.4.2 Rotary screw compressors 8.4.3 Discharge and pressure control 8.4.3.1 Load/no load control 8.4.3.2 Modulation control 8.4.3.3 Load/no load and modulation control 8.5 Measurements of compressed air 9 Mechanics of rock fracture under a drill bit 9.1 9.2
9.3
9.4
9.5 9.6
Book.indb xiii
Introduction Rock fracture in drilling 9.2.1 Modes of fragmentation 9.2.2.1 Mechanical energy 9.2.2.1.1 Crushing 9.2.2.1.2 Impact crushing 9.2.2.1.3 Scratching 9.2.2.2 Heat energy 9.2.2.2.1 Spalling 9.2.2.2.2 Fusion and vaporization 9.2.2.3 Chemical energy Basic theory of solid fracture 9.3.1 Mohr-Coulomb theory of shear failure 9.3.2 Griffith theory of tensile failure Fracture of rock in drilling 9.4.1 Penetration of an indenter 9.4.2 Penetration of a wedge 9.4.3 Formation fracture below a drill bit 9.4.4 Specific energy Drillability of rocks Estimation of penetration rate 9.6.1 Protodyakonov approach 9.6.2 Paone and Bruce approach 9.6.3 Bauer, Calder and Workman approach 9.6.4 Specific energy approach 9.6.5 Microbit test approach 9.6.6 Indenter test approach
xiii
240 241 243 244 245 247 247 248 250 254 254 255 255 256 259 259 259 261 261 261 262 262 263 263 263 263 264 265 267 270 270 272 274 280 281 282 282 284 286 289 289 290
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
xiv
Contents
10 Flushing the blasthole 10.1 10.2 10.3
10.4
10.5 10.6
10.7 10.8 10.9
Introduction Why compressed air? Schematics of flushing 10.3.1 Gravitational force 10.3.2 Buoyant force 10.3.3 Drag force 10.3.4 Terminal velocity 10.3.5 Laws for settlement of particles in fluid Formulation of desired bailing velocity 10.4.1 Size of fragments 10.4.2 Density of fragments 10.4.3 Roundness of fragments 10.4.4 Roughness of fragments 10.4.5 Rate of fragmentation 10.4.6 Annular space 10.4.7 Inclination of the blasthole 10.4.8 Quantity of water injection 10.4.9 Other approaches Formulation of compressed air pressure 10.5.1 Oil injection Choosing a drill pipe 10.6.1 Drill pipe dimensional parameters 10.6.2 Drill pipe surface treatment 10.6.3 Size and shape of drill cuttings 10.6.4 Bailing velocity 10.6.5 Drill pipe wall thickness Discarding a drill pipe Choosing nozzles for tricone bits Choosing the right compressor
11 Effect of altitude and severe weather 11.1 11.2
11.3
Book.indb xiv
Introduction Atmosphere 11.2.1 Effects of altitude on atmosphere 11.2.2 Effects of humidity on atmosphere Effect of scarce air in drilling 11.3.1 Diesel engines 11.3.2 Electric motors and transformers 11.3.3 Hydraulic system 11.3.4 Air compressors 11.3.5 Blasthole flushing 11.3.6 Drill lubrication
295 295 295 296 297 297 297 298 299 301 302 304 304 304 305 305 305 306 308 308 309 310 311 311 313 314 314 317 320 326 327 327 327 329 329 330 330 333 335 335 336 338
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
Contents
11.4
Effect of severe weather 11.4.1 Stormy winds 11.4.2 Heavy rainfall 11.4.3 Heavy snowfall 11.4.4 Extreme hot weather 11.4.5 Extreme cold weather
12 Computers in rotary blasthole drilling 12.1 12.2
12.3 12.4
12.5
12.6
12.7
12.8
Book.indb xv
Introduction Drill operation 12.2.1 Tramming 12.2.2 Leveling 12.2.3 Drilling and pipe handling Modes of blasthole drill computerization Drilling knowledge systems 12.4.1 Formation logging units 12.4.2 Analog drilling recorders 12.4.3 Electronic drilling recorders 12.4.4 Parameters of drilling knowledge data Positioning by GPS 12.5.1 Location recognition by GPS 12.5.2 Movement of drill by using GPS Computerized drill systems 12.6.1 Measurements while drilling 12.6.1.1 Independent parameters 12.6.1.1.1 Time 12.6.1.1.2 Depth 12.6.1.1.3 Rotary speed 12.6.1.1.4 Weight on the bit 12.6.1.1.5 Torque 12.6.1.1.6 Vibrations 12.6.1.1.7 Compressed air pressure 12.6.1.2 Calculated parameters 12.6.1.2.1 Rate of penetration 12.6.1.2.2 Blastability index 12.6.2 Automation systems Hardware for drill computerization 12.7.1 System unit 12.7.2 Display monitor 12.7.3 Input device 12.7.4 Software Advantages of drill computerization 12.8.1 Advantages of drilling knowledge system
xv
338 339 340 340 340 340 343 343 343 344 344 344 345 348 348 349 350 351 351 353 353 354 355 356 356 357 357 357 357 357 358 358 358 358 359 362 362 363 363 364 365 366
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
xvi
Contents
12.8.2 12.8.3 12.8.4 12.8.5
Advantages of drill automation system Advantages of GPS positioning system Advantages of integrated mining system Advantage of added safety 12.8.5.1 Blasthole depth limiting input 12.8.5.2 Tram interlock for pipe in hole 12.8.5.3 Centralizer damage prevention 12.8.5.4 Leveling jack interlock 12.8.5.5 Carousel damage prevention 12.8.5.6 Breakout wrench damage prevention
13 Concepts for rotary blasthole drill design 13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5 13.6 13.7 13.8 13.9 13.10 13.11
375
Introduction Primary requirements of the drill Size and weight of the drill Rotary speed and torque Feed force and speed Pullout force and speed Breakout torque Hydraulic leveling jacks Ground load bearing Compressor discharge and pressure Engine power
375 375 376 378 383 384 384 385 385 386 386
14 Cost analysis of rotary blasthole drilling
389
14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4
14.5
Book.indb xvi
369 369 371 372 372 372 372 373 373 373
Introduction Working pattern of a blasthole drill Factors related to blasthole drilling cost Owning cost 14.4.1 Purchase expenditure 14.4.2 Yearly taxes, duties and levies 14.4.3 Salvage value 14.4.4 Calculation of owning cost 14.4.4.1 Single installment 14.4.4.2 Multiple installments Operating cost 14.5.1 Cost of maintenance and repairs 14.5.2 Cost of consumables 14.5.2.1 Cost of power 14.5.2.2 Drill lubricants 14.5.2.3 Oils 14.5.2.4 Water
389 390 393 393 393 396 396 397 398 398 399 399 400 401 401 403 403
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
Contents
14.6 14.7 14.8 14.9
14.5.2.5 Tires 14.5.2.6 Power cable 14.5.3 Cost of accessories and bits 14.5.3.1 Drilling accessories 14.5.3.2 Tricone bits 14.5.4 Cost of operating labor Overhead cost Total blasthole drilling cost General considerations in cost estimation Example of cost estimation
15 Procurement of rotary blasthole drills 15.1 15.2
15.3
Introduction Pre procurement considerations 15.2.1 Which drilling method? 15.2.2 What type of drill? 15.2.3 How many blasthole drills? Procurement methodology 15.3.1 Draft of specification for the drill 15.3.2 Erection and commissioning of the drill 15.3.3 Drill manuals 15.3.4 Operation and maintenance training
16 Tips for operating rotary blasthole drills 16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4 16.5 16.6 16.7 16.8 16.9 16.10 16.11
Introduction Knowing the environment Moving the rotary blasthole drill Setting up the rotary blasthole drill Operating a rotary blasthole drill Controlling dust emissions Transporting the drill Maintenance activities Periodical check ups Drilling records Safety precautions
17 Mechanics of blast fragmentation 17.1 17.2 17.3 17.4
Book.indb xvii
Introduction Explosion process Formation of a crater by a blast Blast fragmentation mechanism
xvii
404 404 404 405 405 406 406 406 407 407 419 419 419 420 420 421 421 421 422 423 423 425 425 425 426 428 428 431 431 432 432 432 434 435 435 435 437 439
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
xviii
Contents
17.4.1 17.4.2 17.4.3 17.4.4 17.4.5 17.4.6 17.4.7 17.4.8
Crushing of rock Radial cracking Circumferential cracking Spalling Radial push by gases Cracking by flexure Collision of fragments Separation of beds
18 Properties of explosives 18.1 18.2 18.3
Introduction Explosives Properties of explosives 18.3.1 Velocity of detonation 18.3.2 Detonation pressure 18.3.3 Blasthole pressure 18.3.4 Strength 18.3.4.1 Weight and bulk strength 18.3.4.2 Absolute and relative strength 18.3.5 Heat of explosion 18.3.6 Specific gas volume 18.3.7 Sensitivity 18.3.7.1 Sensitivity to shocks 18.3.7.2 Sensitivity to friction 18.3.7.3 Sensitivity to heat 18.3.7.4 Sensitivity to detonator strength 18.3.7.5 Gap sensitivity 18.3.8 Handling and transport safety 18.3.9 Brisance value 18.3.10 Charging density 18.3.11 Toxic fumes 18.3.12 Water resistance 18.3.13 Hygroscopicity 18.3.14 Storage life 18.3.15 Volatility 18.3.16 Material coexistence 18.3.17 Minimum hole diameter
19 Thermochemistry of explosives 19.1 19.2 19.3
Book.indb xviii
Introduction Chemical nature of explosives Reactions of explosive chemicals
440 440 441 442 442 442 444 444 445 445 445 449 449 451 452 452 452 453 453 453 453 454 454 454 454 455 455 455 455 456 458 459 459 460 460 460 463 463 463 463
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
Contents
19.3.1 19.3.2 19.3.3 19.3.4
Oxygen balance Volume of products of explosion Heat of explosion Strength of explosive
20 Explosives – their history and composition 20.1 20.2 20.3
20.4
Introduction Brief history of explosives Types of explosives in a blasthole 20.3.1 Detonator (blasting cap) 20.3.2 Primary explosive 20.3.3 Booster 20.3.4 Main explosive 20.3.4.1 Nitroglycerin 20.3.4.2 Nitrocellulose 20.3.4.3 Ammonium nitrate 20.3.4.4 Sodium nitrate 20.3.4.5 Fuel oil 20.3.4.6 Wood pulp 20.3.4.7 Sulfur 20.3.4.8 Antacid Explosive mixes used in mine blasts 20.4.1 Dry blasting agents 20.4.1.1 Poured ANFO 20.4.1.2 Packaged ANFO 20.4.1.3 Heavy ANFO 20.4.2 Slurry 20.4.2.1 Bulk slurry 20.4.2.2 Cartridged slurry 20.4.3 Emulsions 20.4.4 Dynamite 20.4.4.1 Granular dynamite 20.4.4.2 Gelatin dynamite
21 Tests on explosives 21.1 21.2
Book.indb xix
Introduction Tests for measurements of VOD 21.2.1 D’Autriche method 21.2.2 Chronograph method 21.2.3 Fiber optic sensor method 21.2.4 SLIFER method 21.2.5 Optical measurement method
xix
465 467 468 469 471 471 471 473 474 475 475 475 477 477 477 478 479 479 479 479 479 479 484 485 485 485 486 486 487 488 488 489 493 493 493 494 494 495 495 495
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
xx
Contents
21.3
21.4
21.5
21.6
Tests for measurement of strength 21.3.1 Ballistic mortar test 21.3.2 Cratering test 21.3.3 Underwater test 21.3.4 Plate dent test 21.3.5 Traulz lead block test 21.3.6 Cylinder compression test Tests for measurement of sensitivity 21.4.1 Shock sensitivity test 21.4.2 Heat resistance test 21.4.3 Cap sensitivity test 21.4.4 Gap sensitivity test 21.4.5 Friction sensitivity test 21.4.6 Electrostatic discharge sensitivity test Tests related to storage of explosive 21.5.1 Effect of wetness test 21.5.2 Internal ignition test 21.5.3 Material compatibility test 21.5.4 Vacuum stability test Miscellaneous tests 21.6.1 Critical diameter test 21.6.2 Critical height test 21.6.3 Bullet impact test 21.6.4 Koenen test
22 Blasting consumable and accessories 22.1 22.2
Book.indb xx
Introduction Blasting consumables 22.2.1 Initiation transmission line 22.2.1.1 Safety fuse for transmitting fire 22.2.1.2 Electric transmission wires 22.2.1.3 Detonating cord for transmitting detonation 22.2.1.4 Detonating cord for transmitting shock 22.2.1.5 Hercudet tube for transmitting fire 22.2.2 Detonator 22.2.2.1 Delay element 22.2.2.2 Electric detonators 22.2.2.2.1 Solid pack electric detonator 22.2.2.2.2 Fusehead electric detonator 22.2.2.2.3 Exploding bridgewire detonator 22.2.2.3 Non-electric detonators 22.2.2.4 Electronic detonators
496 497 497 497 497 498 499 500 500 500 502 502 502 503 503 503 503 504 504 504 504 505 505 505 507 507 507 509 509 510 510 511 512 512 512 513 514 515 515 516 518
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
Contents
22.3
22.4
Blasting instruments 22.3.1 Testing instruments 22.3.1.1 Blaster’s multimeter 22.3.1.2 Blaster’s ohmmeter 22.3.1.3 Blaster’s tagger 22.3.2 Initiating instruments 22.3.2.1 Safety fuse initiator 22.3.2.2 Electric detonation initiator 22.3.2.3 Generator type blast initiator 22.3.2.4 Capacitor discharge type blast initiator 22.3.2.5 Detonation wave initiator 22.3.2.6 Shock wave initiator 22.3.2.7 Hercudet system initiator 22.3.2.8 Electronic blast initiator 22.3.3 Measuring instruments 22.3.3.1 Hot hole meter 22.3.3.2 Burden measuring instrument 22.3.3.3 Seismograph 22.3.3.4 VOD meter 22.3.3.5 High speed camera Blasting tools and miscellaneous items
23 Hazards to and from blasting 23.1 23.2
23.3
Book.indb xxi
Introduction Hazards to blasting process 23.2.1 Presence of ground structure 23.2.2 Seepage of ground water 23.2.3 Hot blastholes 23.2.4 Hole deviation Hazards of blasting process 23.3.1 Misfires 23.3.1.1 Faulty safety fuse installation 23.3.1.2 Faulty electric blasting circuits 23.3.1.3 Faulty detonating cord circuits 23.3.1.4 Faults of exploder or faulty operation 23.3.1.5 Unnoticed ground water inflow 23.3.2 Ground vibrations 23.3.2.1 Nature of ground vibration waves 23.3.2.2 Prediction of ground vibration levels 23.3.2.2.1 Langefors formula 23.3.2.2.2 Scaled distance formula 23.3.2.3 Damage by ground vibrations
xxi
519 519 519 519 520 520 521 521 522 522 523 523 523 525 525 525 525 527 528 529 529 533 533 533 533 534 534 534 534 535 535 535 536 536 536 537 537 539 539 540 541
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
xxii
Contents
23.3.3
23.3.4 23.3.5 23.3.6
Air blast 23.3.3.1 Prediction of air blast pressure 23.3.3.2 Damage by air blast pressure Fly rocks Air pollution Environmental changes
24 Properties of rock masses 24.1 24.2
24.3
24.4
Introduction Rock specimen properties and blasting 24.2.1 Influence of rock strength on blasting 24.2.2 Influence of rock density on blasting 24.2.3 Influence of rock porosity on blasting 24.2.4 Specimen blastability Properties of rock masses and blasting 24.3.1 Voids 24.3.2 Folds, unconformities and bedding planes 24.3.2.1 Shooting with the dip 24.3.2.2 Shooting against the dip 24.3.2.3 Shooting along the strike 24.3.3 Faults and joints Classification of rock masses 24.4.1 Classification by visual observation 24.4.2 Classification by index 24.4.2.1 RQD based classification 24.4.2.2 RMR based classification 24.4.2.3 RTQI based classification 24.4.3 BI index based classification 24.4.3.1 Index proposed by Hansen (1968) 24.4.3.2 Index proposed by Hainen and Dimock (1976) 24.4.3.3 Index proposed by Ashby (1977) 24.4.3.4 Index proposed by Langefors (1978) 24.4.3.5 Index proposed by Lilly (1986) 24.4.3.6 Index proposed by Ghose (1988) 24.4.3.7 Index proposed by Gupta (1990) 24.4.3.8 Index proposed by JKMRC (1996) 24.4.3.9 Index proposed by Han, Weiya and Shouvi (2000)
25 Methods and patterns of charging blastholes 25.1 25.2
Book.indb xxii
Introduction Mechanized blasthole charging system
545 546 547 549 550 552 553 553 553 554 554 555 555 555 556 556 558 558 559 560 560 560 560 562 563 564 564 565 566 566 566 566 568 568 569 569 571 571 571
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
Contents
25.3
25.4
25.2.1 Trucks for loading ANFO or heavy ANFO 25.2.2 Trucks for loading slurry or emulsion 25.2.3 Safety features of bulk delivery system Blasthole charging pattern 25.3.1 Type and placement of primer 25.3.2 Direction of propagation of detonation 25.3.2.1 Top priming 25.3.2.2 Bottom priming 25.3.2.3 Multi point priming 25.3.3 Continuous side initiation 25.3.4 Air decking 25.3.5 Priming under special rock mass conditions 25.3.5.1 Well defined ore layer 25.3.5.2 Heavy water seepage in blasthole 25.3.5.3 Hard boulder in soft bed 25.3.5.4 Cavities in the rock mass Drilling and firing patterns 25.4.1 Drilling patterns 25.4.2 Firing patterns 25.4.2.1 “V” pattern 25.4.2.2 Echelon delay pattern 25.4.2.3 Flat face pattern 25.4.2.4 Channel delay pattern 25.4.2.5 Sinking hole pattern
26 Design of a surface blast 26.1 26.2 26.3
26.4
Book.indb xxiii
Introduction Blastholes in a mine bench Types of blasting in surface mines 26.3.1 Conventional bench blasting 26.3.2 Secondary blasting 26.3.3 Cast blasting 26.3.4 Presplitting 26.3.5 Snake hole blasting 26.3.6 Rip rap blasting What is involved in design of a blast 26.4.1 Powder factor 26.4.2 Blasting direction 26.4.3 Number of free faces 26.4.4 Blasthole diameter 26.4.4.1 Desired rate of production 26.4.4.2 Desired fragmentation
xxiii
572 573 574 575 576 580 581 582 582 583 583 586 586 586 587 587 588 589 592 592 593 593 593 595 597 597 597 598 598 599 599 599 601 603 603 603 604 604 605 605 606
11/22/2010 2:33:41 PM
xxiv
Contents
26.5 26.6 26.7 26.8
26.4.4.3 Properties of rock specimen 26.4.4.4 Presence of geological structures 26.4.5 Blasthole depth 26.4.5.1 Combination of shovel and dumper 26.4.5.2 Walking dragline 26.4.5.3 Combination of wheel loader and dumper 26.4.6 Blasthole inclination 26.4.7 Burden 26.4.8 Blasthole spacing 26.4.9 Subdrilling 26.4.10 Stemming height 26.4.11 Size of the blast Calculation of burden Relationship of blasthole parameters Design of conventional surface blast Design of other types of blasts 26.8.1 Rip rap production blasting 26.8.2 Snake hole blasting 26.8.3 Cast blasting
Appendix 1 Appendix 2 Appendix 3 Appendix 4 Appendix 5 Appendix 6 Appendix 7 Appendix 8 Appendix 9 Appendix 10 Appendix 11 Appendix 12 Appendix 13 Appendix 14 Appendix 15 Index
Book.indb xxiv
Properties of atmospheric air at high altitudes Air properties at various temperatures Bailing velocities in blasthole annulus Air pressure loss in steel pipes Air pressure loss in hose pipes Air pressure loss in pipe fittings A note on tungsten carbide and other hard metals Scales of hardness – measurements and their conversion Manufacturers of rotary blasthole drilling equipment Details of rotary blasthole drills manufactured all over the world Details of drill pipes used for rotary blasthole drilling Details of stabilizers and other miscellaneous items Details of shock absorbers Properties of some rocks Bibliography
606 606 609 609 610 611 612 616 617 618 620 620 621 625 627 630 630 630 632 639 643 647 651 657 661 667 675 679 687 693 699 707 709 717 737
11/22/2010 2:33:42 PM
Foreword
I joined Bucyrus-Erie in 1974 after finishing my graduate studies. BE assigned me working on the design and test of rotary blast hole drills in the U.S., Canada and South Africa. In 1976 we had offered BE 45R (and also 40R which was soon to be discontinued) rotary blasthole drill to Malanjkhand Copper Project in India. To follow up this potential business I, as a young Sales Manager of BE, visited the mining site near Balaghat, with another young sales executive Mr. B.V. Gokhale from our Indian distributor. I vividly remember, Mr. Taneja, the director of the project, stating in our last meeting, “Mr. Johnson, we can’t purchase 45R because it is too large and too expensive for our job and your 40R does not have angle hole drilling attachment which is so important for our job. However, I must say that you and Mr. Gokhale have certainly taught us many aspects of rotary blasthole drilling in our discussions. Many thanks for that.” BV and I traveled throughout India to sites operated by Hindustan Copper, KIOCL, and Coal India at a later date. We had discussion on different types of equipment. I found BV not only had a superior knowledge of blast hole drills but also rigid frame haul trucks, dragline, electric mining shovels etc. When BE were considering starting manufacture of their shovels in India, we found BV as the most suitable individual to work as consultant to BE. Based on some of his work we were able to form a joint venture for electric mining shovels with Heavy Engineering Corporation and had signed a MOU for blast hole drill manufacturing. BV then conducted an in depth study of the Indian Coal sectors and equipment demands for the next 20 years. His study involved visit to all sites in the country for coal mining and accessing the precise long term demand for coal for power generation. His study convinced BE to establish a subsidiary operation in India. I was convinced beyond doubt that knowledge of BV in the domain of blasthole drilling was of highest caliber. Sometime during 1984 he mentioned to me that he is going to write a book on blasthole drilling. I knew he had all the necessary talent and knowledge for the venture. I wished him best luck and was really eager to see the book because there was no book on the subject of blasthole drilling. The nearest to the subject was “Drilling of Rocks” by McGregor but was grossly outdated within a decade after its publication in 1967.
Book.indb xxv
11/22/2010 2:33:42 PM
xxvi
Foreword
I was naturally pleased to see his book “Blasthole Drilling Technology” published in 2003. It does contain lot of useful material on the subject. But as the book was published by him, without backing of an international publisher, it has remained somewhat unknown. Now he has come up with this “Rotary Drilling and Blasting in Large Surface Mines”. I have read a few chapters of the book and I find that BV has put many innovative ideas on various topics. I can whole heartedly recommend this book to everyone directly or indirectly involved in blasthole drilling. It covers every aspect of rotary blasthole drilling. To a mining engineering student it gives complete knowledge of the machine and methods of its use without spending hours of field work. For a driller it will give deep insight into the various factors that affect the drilling process and several associated topics. To a mining superintendent it shows how to choose machine drill pipes and other high value consumables. For him the elaboration of cost calculations is of great importance. To a design engineer with a drill manufacturer it reveals several concepts that form the basis of the actual drilling process, and guiding principles for the design of a rotary drill. In short, by reading this book everyone involved with rotary blasthole drilling, will get a deep insight in the subject and will become acquainted with many ideas that can be used to get better results in drilling operations. Later in the book BV has also covered blasting techniques. Whereas I don’t have adequate knowledge to comment on the blasting part, after quickly reading it, I certainly feel that he has described the explosives, the process of rock fracture in blasting, thermochemistry of explosive and the design of a blast for surface mining operations in most appropriate manner. With a worldwide sales network CRC Press/Balkema are well placed to spread the knowledge of relatively untouched subject of rotary blasthole drilling and blasting through this book. I wish grand success to both BV and CRC Press/Balkema. Dean Johnson, Ex VP Terex Corporation. Currently Capital Goods Consultant for Global Sales and Distribution of Open Pit Mining and Construction Equipment.
Book.indb xxvi
11/22/2010 2:33:42 PM
Preface
Nearly seven years ago I wrote and published my book titled ‘Blasthole Drilling Technology’. Many readers of the book, found it very useful because it contained more detailed information about rotary and rotary percussion drilling than almost all other books. Some of the readers, however, did express that I should have written two separate books – one on rotary blasthole drilling and the other on rotary percussion blasthole drilling. When I thought over this suggestion, I did realize that these two modes of blasthole drilling are vastly different from each other in terms of equipment and techniques. The only commonality is that both can be effectively used for the blasthole drilling application. Even for such application rotary percussion drilling is best suited for drilling small diameter blastholes, whereas, rotary drilling is best suited for drilling larger blastholes. Therefore, initially I decided to write a book only on rotary blasthole drilling. As I thought further over the matter I realized that in ‘Blasthole Drilling Technology’ blasting was covered only through one chapter and hence gave only rudimentary knowledge of it to the readers. In other words the book was subject-oriented and not application-oriented. In reality blasthole drilling and blasting are so inseparable that every book on blasthole drilling must cover blasting to a considerable extent. Considering all these aspects I have written this book. The book is named ‘Rotary Drilling and Blasting in Large Surface Mines’ because rotary blasthole drilling is almost exclusively carried out in large surface mines. The book also covers blasting to sufficient depth. Quite a bit of text matter as well as illustrations in this book have been repeated from ‘Blasthole Drilling Technology’ but there have been many additions to the text matter and illustrations. This surely makes it worthwhile to purchase this book even if one has a copy of ‘Blasthole Drilling Technology’. This book is surely not a work of art but a book pertaining to specific techniques. The purpose of the book is to make the readers understand the techniques of drilling large diameter blastholes by rotary drilling method, subsequently filling them with appropriate explosives in apt manner and finally blasting them to get desired fragmentation of the rock mass. When it comes to understanding, a picture is always worth thousands of words. Keeping this saying my in mind I have included nearly 400 illustrations in this book. Almost 60% of these illustrations are based on the images that I have retrieved from internet websites. As it was necessary to change these images to suit the context.
Book.indb xxvii
11/22/2010 2:33:42 PM
xxviii
Preface
I have modified almost all the images. I have endeavored my best efforts in obtaining permission for us of the original image. In this regard I must honestly confess that without use of such images this book would not have been complete. On pages immediately following the table of contents of this book in a section titled ‘Credits for Illustrations’ I have given due credit to the organizations or individuals for initial use of the mother image. In case some name has been missed please consider such errors to be inadvertent. Readers are sincerely requested to bring all such error to my notice through a letter, so appropriate action will be taken at the time of preparing the next edition of this book. During the early years of my interest many manufacturers and suppliers fed me with their product and technical literature to turn me towards the field of drilling. I am thankful to them. Some names that I vividly remember in this regard are, Tamrock, Atlas Copco, Ingersoll Rand, Joy Manufacturing Co., Gardner Denver. I worked in Greaves Cotton Co. Ltd., Voltas Ltd., Bucyrus Erie Co. and Harnischfeger Corporation. As a product manager my job was to understand technological aspects of different types of construction and mining equipment and answer technical queries of customers. Without the generous attitude of organizations mentioned in earlier paragraphs this book would not have seen the light of day. From late 1990s Internet became the source of my information. It is ever expanding. There are many individuals, without whom this book would not have been possible. In this regard the first name that comes to my mind is Ms. Germaine Seijger, Senior Acquisition Editor of CRC Press/Balkema. Apart from her there are many individuals from CRC Press/Balkema who have taken lot of efforts in greatly elevating the standard of this book. Next in the line is Mr. Dean Johnson, Ex VP Terex Corporation. Right from the days in 1977 when our friendship began, till now he has been sending me very valuable articles, books etc. on drilling so as to be well informed in the subject. Perhaps more important is the fact that he has always kept my enthusiasm burning, I have personally not met him since 1986 but on his own he has gifted me two most recently published books on blasthole drilling. I cannot forget the names of Prof. A.K. Ghose, Former Director of ISM Dhanbad, Dr. A.K. Chakraborty and Mr. G.K. Pradhan, Joint Director of PCRA. After reading my book ‘Blasthole Drilling Technology’ these respected persons were largely instrumental in spontaneously awarding me with a Lifetime Achievement Award for Outstanding Contribution in Drilling Engineering through Indian Mining Journal at RockEx 2005 held in Nagpur. This was a great moral booster for me. It kept my interest in the field alive to culminate in this book. A technical book is always backed by technical data. While preparing the table of appendix 10 many persons gave the needed information promptly. I am thankful to them. Ms. Amanda Finn – Measurement Devices Ltd., Mr. Brian Fox – Atlas Copco Drilling Solutions, Mr. K.S. Ramchandran – Revathi Equipment Ltd., Mr. Tharmarajah Ramchandran – Sandvik Mining and Construction, Mr. Greg Scott – Bucyrus International Inc., Mr. Fred Slack – Schramm Inc.
Book.indb xxviii
11/22/2010 2:33:42 PM
Preface
xxix
I believe, that every technical book written by any author must be read by at least one external editor who can make the book easily “digestible” to the readers. For my book this was very ably done by Dr. James Rainbird. He not only polished my language but with his superb memory and “hawk” eye went on to point out a few anomalies as distantly placed as chapters 3 and 22. I am greatly indebted to him. Finally, I thank my wife Suneeti, son Amit, daughter in law Anjali for smilingly bearing the neglect shown towards them while writing the book. B.V. Gokhale Mumbai, August 8, 2010
Book.indb xxix
11/22/2010 2:33:42 PM
Credits for illustrations
Literally hundreds of illustrations have been included in this book so as make the contents easily understandable to the readers. Nearly 60% of the illustrations are based on images gathered by me from various sources viz. books, periodicals and particularly internet websites of many manufacturers and suppliers. I have made changes in the images to suit the contents in the book. Thanks are due to all these individuals or organizations for such indirect contribution. Following is a list of individuals or organizations who originally have published the mother images.
Name of individual or organization
Figures for which credit given
AB Nordbok Acker Drill Co. Allis Chalmers American Coldset Corporation Aquila Mining System Atlas Copco
4.1 5.1 8.11-8.14 6.8 12.5, 12.6, 12.9, 12.10, 12.11, 12.13 2.2-2.5, 2.7, 4.10, 5.5, 5.6, 5.8, 6.5, 6.9, 7.1, 7.4, 7.6, 7.28, 7.31, 7.34-7.36, 7.41, 7.43, 7.57, 7.58, 8.5, 10.4, 10.5, A12.1, Table 5.13 7.23 4.12, 4.13 22.11, 22.20 22.20 5.2, 5.3 2.8, 4.8, 4.18, 4.19, 7.2, 7.8, 7.9, 7.22, 7.25, 7.38-7.40, 7.42, 7.50, 7.59, 6.2, 6.4, 8.3, 13.1, 26.3, 26.7 1.9, 7.10, 7.15 3.10 7.51 12.3, 26.14 26.27-26.30 4.14, 4.16 2.6, 6.1, 6.6 6.14, 6.15 22.7, 22.12, 22.14, 22.15 3.7
Autolub Lubin Baroid Inc. Blasting Accessories Inc. Blasters Tool and Supply Co. Inc. Blue Demon Bucyrus International Inc. Caterpillar Christine Rasch+Dr. Wolfgang Kollenberg Christopher Bills CR Books D’Appolonia Dave Lang Drillco Smithtool Duraquest Dyno Nobel ELE International
(Continued )
Book.indb xxxi
11/22/2010 2:33:42 PM
xxxii
Credits for illustrations
Name of individual or organization
Figures for which credit given
Elvex Corporation Explosiva Fluid Control Products Inc. Geolograph GeoSonic GeoVision Gulf Publishing Hamlyn Publications implosionworld.com International Drilling Services J. Trent Bruce Joy Manufacturing Co. Keith Haddock Kennmetal Laser Measuring Instruments Inc Laval Measurement Surveys LIM SA Lincoln M&P Flange and Pipe Protection Mammoth Technologies Measurement Devices Ltd. Mining Technology International Modular Mining System Nordex Explosives Ltd NTNU – Norwegian Univ. of Sci. and Tech. Oil Tool International Services Pvt Ltd Olympus Orica P&H Mining Prof Hustrulid Pulsar Measuring Co. R. Smith and Sons Inc. Research Energy of Ohio Inc. Sandvik Schlumberger Schramm Inc. SDS Corporation Security BDS Smith Drilling Co. SA Smithtool Steve (Hanna Equipment Co.) Thomas Instrument Inc. ThyssenKrupp Fordertechnik TLC Engineering Solutions + Vibronics Transtronics Trumph Drilling Tools Twin Disk US Army US Dept. of Interior+US BM+OSHA Ultra Enviro-Systems (P) Ltd. United Nations Environmental Program
6.38 25.3 7.52 12.2 22.17 6.26 4.2-4.5, 4.7, 4.11 3.1, 3.2, 3.5 22.13 A12.2, A12.5 8.15 4.15, 7.5, 7.7 4.6, 4.20 5.4 6.33 6.27 6.23, 12.4 7.24 8.17 6.21 6.31, 6.34-6.37 6.12, 6.13 12.8 25.4 3.11, 3.14, 17.10 A12.8 22.19 25.1 7.26, 7.30, 7.32, 7.37, 7.47, 7.56, 8.6, 26.10, 26.11 25.2 6.25 6.18 22.11 4.21, 7.16, 7.48, 23.7, 26.6, A7.1 6.22 7.13, 7.14, 7.27, 7.49 6.32 5.9, 6.28, 8.18 6.16 5.7, 5.11, 5.12, 5.14, 5.17, 5.18, 5.29, 5.21 1.8 22.11 1.7 21.2 6.24 A12.7 7.21 25.20 7.54, 9.16, 9.24, 20.1, 20.2, 22.2, 22.18 22.18 1.12 (Continued )
Book.indb xxxii
11/22/2010 2:33:42 PM
Credits for illustrations
Book.indb xxxiii
Name of individual or organization
Figures for which credit given
University of Western Australia Untraced Uralmash Vermeer Corporation Vibronics Inc. World Mining Equipment www.all-security-system.com www.geology.ebr.state.nc.us www.soundwaves.usgs.gov
26.14 23.4, 23.9, 23.10, 25.18 5.10 1.10 21.2 7.20 7.53 1.11 1.6
xxxiii
11/22/2010 2:33:42 PM
Chapter 1
Surface rock excavation scenario
1.1
INTRODUCTION
Excavation of rock at the surface of the ground becomes necessary for several reasons. Drill and blast is the most commonly adopted method for such excavations. In essence, this consists of drilling an array of holes in the rock mass, filling them with explosives and then initiating an explosion so that the release of enormous energy breaks the large rock mass into small pieces. This may appear quite simple, but the techniques of drilling the holes and blasting them have advanced very greatly through the experience gained in the past four centuries over which this excavation method has been used. Excavation of rock below the surface of the ground is also essential for various purposes. The techniques, methods and equipment used for underground excavation differ considerably from those used for surface rock excavation. Apart from drill and blast, other alternative techniques and corresponding equipment are used for surface rock excavation. This chapter is devoted to essential background knowledge of surface rock excavation techniques.
1.2
NEED FOR SURFACE ROCK EXCAVATION
Surface rock excavation can mean an excavation carried out by means of equipment that stands on the surface of the ground. However, in this book its meaning is taken as the excavation of the rock lying below the surface of ground at shallow depth. The need for surface rock excavation is felt for three basic reasons as follows. 1 2
Recovery of minerals or crushed rock Creating an unobstructed space These points are elaborated further below.
1.2.1
Recovery of minerals or crushed rock
Many minerals of commercial importance, called ores, are located at shallow depths below the ground surface. Mineral deposit is the term used for a rock mass that
Book.indb 1
11/22/2010 2:33:43 PM
2
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
contains a mineral of commercial importance in economically large proportions. A mineral deposit is usually surrounded by other minerals that have no economic importance. These are called waste. Since they often lie above the mineral deposits, as in surface coal mines, they are also called overburden. When mineral deposits lie near the surface of the ground, as illustrated in Figure 1.1, the volume of waste to be removed is comparatively less. In such cases, the whole rock mass is fragmented by one of the rock excavation methods. It is very easy to visually differentiate and pick up ore from such a fragmented rock mass with loading equipment and to transport it by hauling equipment to the place designated for further processing of the ore. To ensure continuity of operation of ore recovery, it also becomes necessary to transport the waste to a dumping place. This is sometimes carried out by using different types of equipment. All the activities narrated in the above paragraphs are together called surface mining, or open pit mining, or opencast mining. Large pieces of rocks are used in the construction of dams, breakwaters and the substrate of road and railway embankments. Smaller crushed rock pieces of different sizes are used in large quantities for making concrete used for the construction of objects such as dams, bridges, harbor wharves, buildings etc. For making very strong and durable structures, the concrete must have great strength. This is possible only when the pieces of rock used in making concrete have a high compressive strength. Therefore, crushed rock is recovered from rock masses in specific areas. The activities carried out for getting crushed rock are similar to those adopted in surface mining. Since no specific mineral is involved and the whole rock mass is of importance, all these activities together are called quarrying rather than mining.
Overburden
Ore Bodies
Figure 1.1 Ore bodies below a hillock.
Book.indb 2
11/22/2010 2:33:43 PM
Surface rock excavation scenario
1.2.2
3
Creation of unobstructed space
Instances in which it is necessary to make suitable space, by removing obstructions and unevenness of the ground, are met in virtually every type of construction. Some common examples are described below. Huge skyscrapers constructed in many cities have to stand and remain stable on the ground for over a hundred years. A sufficiently competent rock mass, capable of bearing the enormous load imposed by such buildings, is met only at depths in the ground. This makes it necessary to excavate a large rock mass for construction of the foundations. Foundations of bridges have to reach to great depths and have to penetrate into competent rock to a certain depth, because only at such depth is the load-bearing capacity of the ground sufficiently high. The danger of the whole foundation drifting under heavy water currents is also minimized when foundations are constructed in this manner. Roads and railways have to pass through hilly regions at several places. Since locomotives and vehicles have limited grade ability, at many places it is safer and economical to make a long cutting or to construct a tunnel along the road or railway route rather than make a long circuitous route. Depending upon the topography and the width of the road or number of railway tracks, the cutting can be of enormous size. Cuttings of very large dimensions are required to be excavated for water supply or navigation canals. Concrete dams have to be anchored well in the rock mass beneath the ground surface in the river basin as well as at both sides. For properly anchoring a large concrete dam, excavation can spread over a very large area and to great depths. In all the examples mentioned above, surface excavation of the rock has to be carried out by one of the excavation methods. Often a rock mass measuring several million cubic meters is removed in the excavation process.
1.3
STRENGTH OF ROCK MASS AND CLASSES
The word ‘rock’ will be repeatedly used in forthcoming chapters. The meaning of this word is viewed differently by geologists and engineers. To a geologist, every aggregate of minerals means rock, because he is more concerned with the formation, stratification, mineral contents etc. of the rock, rather than its strength. A civil engineer looks at the rock from the viewpoint of strength, load-bearing capacity etc., as he is more concerned with either making something by using rock pieces or breaking a rock mass to create space and construct a structure at the place. A mining engineer is concerned with both the above viewpoints. The properties of rocks from an engineering viewpoint have been elaborated in chapter 3 because they are more closely connected to drilling. The properties of rock masses assume larger importance in the realm of blasting and are, therefore, detailed in chapter 23. The properties of rock masses are however, for the better understanding of various aspects, presented in the first and second chapters, so the concept of the strength of rock must be introduced here first.
Book.indb 3
11/22/2010 2:33:43 PM
4
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Table 1.1 Strength based rock classification. Qualitative name
Strength in MPa
Strength in psi
Extremely Hard Very Hard Hard Moderate Soft Very Soft Extremely Soft
More than 345 207 to 345 103 to 207 69 to 103 34 to 69 7 to 34 Less than 7
More than 50000 30000 to 50000 15000 to 30000 10000 to 15000 5000 to 10000 1000 to 5000 Less than 1000
When referring to the strength of rock, one is most commonly referring to its compressive strength. Let us presume that a cylindrical sample of rock, having a length of 100 mm and diameter of 60 mm is subjected to a steadily increasing axial compressive load and breaks when the load reaches 200 kN. In such cases the strength of the rock can be calculated by dividing the breaking force by the cross sectional area of the sample. For the specific values of the parameters mentioned here, the compressive strength Sc will be: Sc = 200*103/(π*602/4) = 70.735 N/mm2 i.e. Sc = 70.735 MPa For giving some idea of the strength of rocks, adjectives such as soft, hard etc. are arbitrarily applied before their names. The arbitrary nature of these terms can be removed to a good extent by following the nomenclature in Table 1.1.
1.4
DRILL AND BLAST OPERATIONS
Drill and blast operations have a unique place in mining and civil engineering. When the volume of hard rock mass to be excavated is very large, the use of mechanical cutting methods is snail-slow and ineffective. Blasting, however, can quickly fragment even the hardest known rocks over a large area. Breaking of rock mass into fragments requires energy. For any specific weight of rock mass the surface area is inversely proportional to the size of the fragments formed in fragmentation. When rock mass is blasted by the drill and blast method, the confinement of the explosive in the blastholes generates extremely high pressure and a huge quantity of heat. When this pressure and heat passes on to the surrounding rock mass, the rock mass just behind the wall of the blasthole gets pulverized into very fine particles. This happens because in that region new cracks are developed due to high energy concentration. However, at greater distances only the most vulnerable pre-existing cracks expand and join together to form a parting plane. Many such planes give rise to very large fragments in comparison to those formed by the other methods of breaking rocks.
Book.indb 4
11/22/2010 2:33:43 PM
Surface rock excavation scenario
5
Naturally, blasting proves to be the most economical method of primary rock fragmentation. Figure 1.2 shows the effectiveness of different rock fragmentation methods. The lower and upper curves of the shaded area indicate operations of high and poor efficiency respectively. For a typical surface rock excavation, many blastholes are drilled systematically in a vertical or near vertical direction, filled with explosives and then blasted. These blastholes have specific diameter, depth and distance between them. After removal of the fragmented rock, depending upon the extent of excavation, many step-like benches, as shown in Figure 1.3, are formed.
Energy Required to Break in kW/kg
60 Medium Rotary Blasthole Drill (Chips)
52.5
Extra Large Rotary Blasthole Drill (Chips)
45
Road Header
37.5
Surface Miner
30
Full Face Tunneling
22.5
Ripping
15
Blasting
7.5 0
0
25
50
75 100 125 150 175 200 225 250
Mean Fragment Size in mm
Figure 1.2 Average fragment size achieved by different fragmentation methods.
Bench 1
Bench 2 Bench Height
Figure 1.3 Benches formed in mining process.
Book.indb 5
11/22/2010 2:33:43 PM
6
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Various parts of a bench and its surroundings are shown in Figure 1.4. The top openings of blastholes are in a straight line parallel to the crest of a bench; this line is called the row. Only one row of blastholes is shown in Figure 1.4 but in actual practice 3 to 8 rows of blastholes are drilled and filled with explosive to carry out a blast. More detailed nomenclature of a bench is given in Figure 1.5
Backbreak
Ideal Crest Line Crest or Bench Edge Overburden Bench Top
Blastholes
Overbreak Overhang Bench Face
Sockets
Toe Bench Floor Stump
Burden Below Grade
Figure 1.4 Bench nomenclature.
First Row
Spacing Bench Edge
Bench Top Burden
Bench Height = K Bench Floor Blasthole Bottom Level Reduced Level A Blastholes
Reduced Level of the Bench
Mean Sea Level
Figure 1.5 Bench and blasthole terminology.
Book.indb 6
11/22/2010 2:33:44 PM
Surface rock excavation scenario
1.5
7
OPTIONS TO DRILL AND BLAST
When all is said and done, blasting is a hazardous and dangerous operation. Due to its harmful effects like vibrations, flying rocks, poisonous gases etc., it is prohibited in areas that are in proximity to human populations, important structures etc. Even if drilling and blasting is carried out in a remote area, it remains a dangerous operation for those who work on the site or live in the vicinity. Before concluding that blasthole drilling and blasting is needed, the necessity and feasibility of other ‘no blast’ methods of rock excavation have to be thoroughly examined. Excavation methods that require no blasting are: 1 2 3 4
Water Jetting Machine Digging Ripping Rock Breaking
In general, if the formation can be described in one or more of the following terms, in most of the cases it can be excavated by one of the above ‘no blast’ methods. Soil, Loess, Talus, Gravel, Peat, Loam, Sandy Clay, Alluvium, Sand Bed, Soft Coal, Shingle, Weathered Limestone, Weathered Rock.
1.5.1 Water jetting Water Jetting is used for excavation in semi-consolidated or loosely cemented mineral masses, that can be termed as soil or extremely soft rocks. In this method a high pressure water jet is directed at the rock mass. The soft rock simply crumbles under the impact of water. Broken rock fragments flow with the water. Gold mines, which are often located in the alluvial areas near a river, or soft sedimentary rock formations on the slopes of hills, use this excavation method. Since the water used for breaking the rock mass cannot easily be recovered, a huge quantity of water is needed for such operations. A typical water jetting operation on hill slopes is shown in Figure 1.6.
1.5.2
Machine digging
If well consolidated and cemented rocks, e.g. iron ore-bearing laterite, have low strength binding between the particles, they can be directly dug by means of rope or hydraulic shovels, provided a wall-type face is available for such digging. Deposits of lignite coal are often horizontal and have a layer of soft sandstone above them. Bucket wheel excavators are preferred for excavation in such lignite mines. Figure 1.7 shows a bucket wheel excavator in action. Buckets are fixed to the rotating wheel of the excavator. As the wheel rotates, the buckets scrape or rip the soft overburden which fills the buckets. As the buckets tilt, the material collected in the bucket falls on the conveyor belt system of the excavator. The conveyer belts then carry the material to the dumping area. Horizontal beds of lignite are thus brought into the open. This method proves economical and effective due to its continuity in excavation.
Book.indb 7
11/22/2010 2:33:45 PM
8
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Figure 1.6 Water jetting in gold mining.
Figure 1.7. A giant bucket wheel excavator.
1.5.3
Ripping
When the rock mass is too hard for excavation by water jetting or machine digging, a third available alternative is ripping. Ripping has been used in the farming industry for thousands of years under the name plowing. Ripping means deep scraping the ground with one or many teeth attached to a moving machine. This method proves very economical in soft and medium-hard formations with compressive strength less than about 70 MPa.
Book.indb 8
11/22/2010 2:33:45 PM
Surface rock excavation scenario
9
There are many ways in which ripping is carried out. Most of the crawler dozers can be equipped with an optional single shank or multi shank ripper attachment. This attachment is fixed at the back of the dozer and is operated hydraulically to force the tooth or teeth in the ground to the desired depth. This depth is suitably chosen according to machine power and formation hardness. Once this is done the dozer is moved. As the dozer moves, the tooth or teeth break the surrounding rock like a plow in farming. A single tooth behind a large dozer can penetrate even 1 m depth in medium soft ground. Light duty ripping can be carried out with motor graders by using a ripper attachment. Figure 1.8 illustrates a dozer, equipped with a three shank ripper attachment, busy ripping in a medium soft formation. Nowadays large dozers, equipped with powerful engines and strong single or multi-shank ripper attachments, are encroaching on the traditional drill and blast territory. Formation rippability can be decided on the basis of the seismic wave velocity. A well known chart universally adopted for the purpose, is reproduced in Figure 1.9. If formations composed of other types of rocks are encountered, verification of their rippability, either by means of field tests or reliable information on ripping in similar formations, is desirable. If the formation is highly fissured and jointed, ripping becomes easier. During the process of ripping some large size boulders are often encountered. Such boulders can be broken with hydraulic hammers attached to a hydraulic excavator. For a long time, machines having a rotating drum with long teeth have been used for scraping the top bituminous layers of roads. This is also an example of ripping. Recently, similar but very heavy and powerful machines have been introduced in the mining industry under the name ‘Surface Miner’. Some small mines and civil engineering contractors opt for such surface miners. One such surface miner is shown in Figure 1.10.
Figure 1.8 Three shank ripper attachment behind a crawler dozer.
Book.indb 9
11/22/2010 2:33:50 PM
10
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Seismic Wave Velocity in m/s 0
1000
500
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
4500
Topsoil Clay Glacial Till Igneous Rocks Granite Basalt Trap Rock Sedimentary Rock Shale Sandstone Siltstone Claystone Conglomerate Breccia Cliche Limestone Metamorphic Rocks Schist Slate Minerals and Ores Coal Iron Ore Rippable
Marginally Rippable
Non Rippable
Figure 1.9 Formation rippability chart.
Figure 1.10 A surface miner.
Surface miners are equipped with a rotating drum on their front side. The drums have tungsten carbide teeth fitted into the fixtures provided for the purpose. As the drum is pushed into the ground by means of hydraulic cylinders provided for the purpose, and is rotated by means of the hydraulic motors within the drum, the teeth
Book.indb 10
11/22/2010 2:33:53 PM
Surface rock excavation scenario
11
scrape or break the ground. As the teeth of surface miners are of small size, compared to those of a ripper, the broken rock fragments are also of small size. Compared to dozers with a ripper attachment these machines are less effective on hard rocks but more effective on soft rocks.
1.5.4
Rock breaking
A hand held paving breaker is a very commonly used tool for breaking pavements in cities. In essence it is a percussion hammer. When the rock mass to be broken is hard and large in volume, the energy output of the paving breaker falls very short of requirements. Therefore, when large scale hard rock excavation is to be carried out, very large size percussion hammers mounted on the booms of hydraulic excavators are used, as shown in Figure 1.10. Hydraulically driven percussion hammers require very low energy input due to their efficient power transmission as compared to the compressed air hammers. A hydraulic excavator is chosen for mounting these hammers because the hydraulic excavator is easily available, works on hydraulic energy, is very versatile in placing the hammer at any alignment and can reach tall heights. All that has been said above may induce readers to draw a conclusion that in soft and medium-hard rippable formations no blasthole drilling and blasting is necessary. This is not true. Overburden in some coal mines can have marginal rippability. Coal can also have marginal rippability. Even if both overburden and coal in coal deposits are rippable, blasthole drilling and blasting are often practiced for overriding considerations as follows. 1
2
3
4
A sizable part of the sedimentary formation may be non-rippable. In such cases, if bucket wheel excavators are used they may either prove unsuitable or the hard portion has to be blasted by drilling closely spaced small diameter blastholes so that the resulting rock fragments are sufficiently small, and their excavation and transportation can be done by using the bucket wheel excavators. It is to be noted that by their design and construction, bucket wheel excavators are suitable only in easily rippable formations. When the formation in a coal mine is difficult to rip and the coal seam is very thick, it is often more advantageous to use a dragline for overburden removal and shovels for coal removal. In such an event blasthole drilling and blasting becomes necessary in both overburden and coal. Dozer ripping can be done in relatively hard formations. However, when such ripping is done the broken formation remains in a horizontal layer. Loading of waste from such broken layers into the hauling equipment, without unacceptable air pollution, is difficult. Moving the fragmented rock mass by using dozers over a long distance is often impracticable.
One important factor, to be taken into account before resorting to drilling and blasting or ripping, is the cost of crushing. Fragment size distribution achieved by drilling and blasting is far different than that by machine digging or ripping.
Book.indb 11
11/22/2010 2:33:57 PM
12
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Figure 1.11 Hydraulic hammer attached to an hydraulic excavator.
Small size fragments can be obtained by ripping with multi shank rippers. Similar adjustments can also be made in blasting where the diameter of the holes as well as burden (the distance between two adjacent rows), and spacing ( the distance between two adjacent blastholes in a row), can be reduced to give smaller blast fragments. In any case for large scale excavation operations, where the rock is non-rippable, drilling and blasting is the only available alternative. Needless to say nearly 80% of the excavation in mining activities is carried out by drilling and blasting.
1.6
OILWELL DRILLING
One more important and very useful mineral that is abundantly available in the crust of earth is crude petroleum oil. In terms of the importance attributed to the mineral obtained, oil gets far more preference than other minerals that are in solid form. Oil is retrieved from the earth’s crust by means of drilling holes into the oil reserves. Since oil is in fluid form, it can be easily pumped by pumps that are placed on the ground. For this reason, there is no necessity of blasting in the oilwell drilling industry. Rotary drilling techniques are invariably used in current oilwell drilling practice. The reasons are: 1 2 3
Book.indb 12
Oil reserves are very often at great depths and it is almost impossible to reach to such depths by using other drilling methods. Progress achieved by other drilling methods is very slow. Many techniques such as hole deviation, well cementation, blowout prevention etc. are not possible without using many accessories that can be used only with rotary drilling.
11/22/2010 2:33:58 PM
Surface rock excavation scenario
13
Due to the economic preference given to the oil industry over the mining industry, far more rotary drilling research is carried out by the oilwell industry than is carried out by the mining industry. However, rotary oilwell drilling vastly differs from rotary blasthole drilling. Similarities between the two are limited only to the fact that both use rotary drilling Table 1.2 Comparison of oil well drilling and rotary blasthole drilling.
Book.indb 13
Aspect
Oil well drilling
Blasthole drilling
Hole Depth
Holes are very deep. Depth often exceed 5000 m.
Holes are shallow. Depth rarely exceeds 50 m.
Hole Diameter
Holes may start with large diameter, sometimes even 600 mm, but the diameter reduces to about 200 mm at maximum depth.
Holes have uniform diameter from top to bottom. Diameter ranges between 152 to 445 mm.
Hole Spacing
There is no defined pattern of hole placement.
Holes are always drilled in a well defined rectangular or triangular pattern.
Hole Straightness
Holes are rarely straight. Often they are purposefully deviated.
Holes are required to be straight. Hole deviation is undesirable and avoided.
Need for Casings
Holes are always cased to considerable depth. Casing within casings i.e. telescoping casings are usual. Huge quantity of tubular steel is required for casings.
Holes are never cased.
Drilling Rig
Rig is in modular form. Several pieces of equipment such as diesel engines, derrick, drawnwork, mud pump etc. are assembled at the site of the hole and after completion of the hole, all the pieces are dissembled. Moving from one hole to the other requires 20 to even 100 truckloads and takes 15 days upward.
Rig is composite and is termed a rotary blasthole drill. It contains everything that is needed for drilling the hole. It is moved from one hole to the other in about two minutes and does not require any other carriers. Drill rods are added to the drill string automatically by pipe changer.
Flushing Medium
Water is a usual medium of flushing. Often many different additives are mixed with water for specific purposes. In very few cases gas is also used as medium.
Air is invariable flushing medium. Small quantity of oil and water is mixed for bit cooling, bit lubrication as well as dust suppression.
Drill Pipes
Mostly integral drill pipes are used. High tensile strength is the most important property. Pipes are external upset and internal flush.
Mostly fabricated drill pipes are used. High surface hardenability is the most important property. Pipes are external flush.
Testing in the Hole
Many tests are carried out in the hole at various depths by pausing the drilling.
No test is carried out by pausing the drilling. In fact there are no tests.
Drilling in Sea
Holes are often drilled in sea from specialized ships, jackups, submersibles etc.
Holes are always drilled on land by the drill standing on the surface of ground.
11/22/2010 2:34:00 PM
14
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Figure 1.12 Scenario of a typical oil well drilling operation on land.
techniques and tricone bits attached to the drill string composed of drill rods. Even these accessories, used in these two domains of drilling, are not interchangeable. Of several points of dissimilarities only a few are mentioned in Table 1.2. Due to such differences, the research carried out in rotary drilling by the oilwell industry is of very limited use for the mining industry. A typical scenario of oilwell drilling operation is shown in Figure 1.12. Oilwell drilling equipment usually comprises many components that are carried to the worksite in several trucks and assembled for drilling operations.
Book.indb 14
11/22/2010 2:34:01 PM
Chapter 2
An overview of blasthole drilling
2.1
INTRODUCTION
The most effective, and hence most usually adopted, method of destruction of an object is by blasting. This method invariably aims at breaking the object into several small pieces. Explosives are used for the purpose of breaking the object. An explosive is a substance that generates a very high volume of gases and a huge quantity of heat within a very short time span of a few milliseconds as soon as it is ignited. When gases are generated by ignition in this way, very high pressure is exerted on the surroundings. At the same time, the strength of the surrounding material also reduces considerably due to the heat. As a result of this, cracks develop in the material and the material gets fragmented. When the place of generation of gases is confined, the gases cannot escape to atmosphere and the intensity of the pressure increases to a considerably higher level. This results in maximum destruction. For the most effective destruction of surrounding material, a hole is drilled in the material to be destroyed. After completion of drilling, the hole is charged (i.e. filled with explosive material) in a certain predefined manner. A detonator, connected by two copper wires, is kept in the hole while the explosive is filled. The hole is then sealed from the top. Once the appropriateness of all the precautionary measures is verified, an electric current is sent through the wires. The electric current heats the wire in the detonator and the explosive material in the detonator explodes. This explosion causes further detonation in the explosive filled in the hole. The hole drilled for filling explosives in this manner is called a blasthole. The process of drilling such holes is called blasthole drilling. A machine used for drilling the hole is called a blasthole drill or often simply a drill. Except cases like breaking a boulder in field etc., a blasthole is seldom drilled in singular. They are drilled in numbers, perhaps in hundreds, one after another, then charged and blasted simultaneously. The fragmented rock mass formed by blasting is almost always moved away, either to create space, as in civil engineering projects or to extract a mineral of interest, as in mining or quarrying. If the sizes of the fragments are small they can be moved easily. In order to have small size of rock fragments after a blast, blastholes are required to be located in a properly planned manner. This requires careful design to determine the diameter, depth and inclination of the holes, and also layout and other relevant parameters of the holes. Rotary drilling is one of the two methods currently used for drilling blastholes in the ground. The other method is called rotary percussion drilling. This book deals with rotary blasthole drilling and covers it from the theoretical as well as practical aspects.
Book.indb 15
11/22/2010 2:34:03 PM
16
2.2
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
BASIC CONCEPTS OF DRILLING
In actual practice, drilling is carried out by using a drill bit connected at the bottom of a drill string that consists of drill pipes, as shown in Figure 2.1. A drill string often consists of some other items, not shown in the figure, that have specific purposes. The drilling bit is meant to interact with the rock. When energy in some form is passed to the rock from the drill bit the rock fractures. The drill string enables a continuous supply of energy to the drill bit so that rock fracture continues at progressive depths. As the bit interacts with rock and breaks it, rock cuttings are formed. These cuttings are moved away by means of a circulating fluid that is pumped to the bit through the central bore in all the drill string components. When fluid escapes from the bit and starts moving up to the ground surface through the annular space, as shown in the figure, it drags the cuttings along with it and deposits them on the ground surface. Thus, the bit keeps on breaking fresh portions of the rock.
Drilling Fluid Moving Up through the Annular Space Between Hole Walls and Drill Pipes
Drill Pipe
Drilling Fluid Moving Down through the Central Bore of the Drill Pipes
Drill Bit
Figure 2.1 Drilling Schematics.
Book.indb 16
11/22/2010 2:34:03 PM
An overview of blasthole drilling
17
The drill string is also given rotary motion so the bit rotates and its cutting points cover a complete cross sectional area to form a cylindrical blasthole. The drilling process can commence, continue, and be complete only when the following essential technical requirements are fulfilled. 1
2 3 4
5
6 7 8 9
The drilling bit, meant for breaking the rock formation, must have adequate hardness, heat resistance, strength, toughness, etc., so it can keep on breaking the formation over a long period of time. Energy, in one of the many possible forms, must be supplied to the bit to cause rock disintegration. The drill bit must be rotated to ensure a circular hole, irrespective of bit cross section. Components in the drill string must also have specific properties to effectively transfer feed force, rotary torque, percussion blows etc., without undue deformations. The rock cuttings formed in the process of formation disintegration must be taken out of the hole as soon as possible, so they do not waste energy in getting crushed once again. The drill should be able to supply sufficient energy to the drill bit through the drill string components to cause formation fracture. The drilling bit must be advanced in the intended direction of the drillhole. The walls of the hole, formed as the drilling progresses, must be prevented from collapsing inside the hole. After attaining the desired drillhole depth, it must be possible to withdraw the drill string composed of drill bit, drill pipes and other accessories.
Combinations of means of fulfilling these essential requirements give rise to different drilling methods. Besides the above technical requirements, it is also necessary to fulfill certain other environmental and economic needs. These are, I Cuttings of very small size – in the form of dust – generated during the process of drilling, should be prevented from mixing with atmospheric air and polluting it. II The process of drilling should continue at optimum speed so as to keep the cost of the operation to a bare minimum. III Noise generated by the drilling equipment must be kept to an acceptable low level. Theoretically, there are many forms of energy that have been applied to a rock mass for its disintegration in laboratories, but in current field practice only mechanical energy is used. Two forms of mechanical energy, viz. percussive and rotary, are used for drilling. In either case the drill string and the drill bit are rotated. Accordingly, the drilling methods are called rotary percussion drilling and rotary drilling. A schematic of both these drilling methods is in Figure 2.2. In rotary percussive drilling the energy generated at the drill is in the form of repeated blows like those of a hammer used in manual chiseling. These blows create
Book.indb 17
11/22/2010 2:34:04 PM
18
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Heavy Feed Force Without Percussive Blows
Low Feed Force With Percussive Blows
High Torque Low Torque
Large Diameter Drill Pipes
Small Diameter Drill Rods Drill Bit With Rotating Cones
Drill Bit Without Moving Parts
Figure 2.2 Schematics of percussion and rotary drilling.
shock waves in the drill string. The shock waves that travel to the bit are passed on to the rock mass through the cutting edges or points on the bit. As a result, cracks are formed in the rock mass and result in formation of rock chips. In rotary drilling the drill pushes the bit into the rock mass with very heavy force. When this heavy feed force is transmitted to the rock mass through the cutting points of the drill bit, cracks develop and rock chips are formed. In both rotary and rotary percussion drilling, cuttings are removed from the hole by a fluid circulated from bottom to top. A drill contains many assemblies meant for various purposes. In a rotary percussion drill the assembly used for generating blows is called the hammer. Hammers are of two types viz. top hammers and down-the-hole hammers. Figure 2.3 shows rotary percussion drilling with these hammers. A top hammer is so called because it always remains at the top of the drill string and hence out of the hole. It creates impacts by causing to and fro movement of a piston contained within it. In addition, it also generates rotary motion through a motor within it. The piston movement or rotary motion are caused by hydraulic fluid or compressed air (now obsolete) depending upon the type of drill. Top hammers give fastest penetration rates in hard rocks. They are mostly used for drilling holes for different purposes on construction sites, small opencast mines,
Book.indb 18
11/22/2010 2:34:04 PM
An overview of blasthole drilling
19
Feed Frame Feed Motor
Rotary Head
Boom Hoisting Cylinder
Top Hammer Feed Frame Hoisting Cylinder Boom
Drill Pipe Crawler Mounting DTH Hammer
Drill Rod Drill Bit
Figure 2.3 Schematics of top hammer and down the hole hammer drilling.
quarries and underground mines. The diameter of holes that can be drilled with top hammers is usually within 38 to 152 mm. The efficiency of top hammer drilling reduces rapidly as more drill rods are added to reach greater depth. Drilling holes deeper than 30 m with a top hammer is difficult because of the energy lost at the connections of the drill rods. Some top hammers are rated for drilling holes to 50 m depth by use of special drill string components. A down-the-hole hammer, usually abbreviated as DTH hammer, is attached to the bottom of the drill string. A drill bit is attached to the lower end of the DTH hammer. A DTH hammer always goes inside the hole along with the bit. The movement of the piston in the DTH hammer is caused by compressed air. The rotary movement for drilling is generated by the rotary head in the drill and is passed on to the drill bit through drill string components and DTH hammer. DTH hammers give fast penetration rates in hard rocks. They are also used for drilling holes for different purposes on construction sites, opencast mines, quarries and underground mines. The diameter of holes that are usually made with DTH hammers is within 100 to 200 mm. Many large hammers, used with specially built drills, are capable of drilling holes of diameter up to 900 mm and in case of specially built hammers even to 1500 mm. Holes of depth 1000 m or even more can be drilled by DTH drilling as the impact energy used for drilling is generated right above the bit and is, therefore, not lost in transmission.
Book.indb 19
11/22/2010 2:34:05 PM
20
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Drill bits used with top or DTH hammers are made from alloy steel. On one side they have tungsten carbide inserts. For most of the bits used now, the inserts are in the form of buttons because such bits are found to be superior to chisel shaped inserts arranged in cross or X shape. On their other side, top hammer bits have female threads that enable them to be attached to the drill rods. DTH bits have splines and collars for attachment to the hammers. Tungsten carbide insert buttons are shrink fitted in the holes made in the steel body, whereas the chisel-shaped inserts are brazed into pre-machined grooves by means of a suitable brazing alloy. Top hammer drilling bits are small in size and are firmly coupled to the drill rods by means of threads. DTH bits are loosely coupled to the DTH hammers and have splines to ensure rotation as well as a collar at their top end to ensure that the bits are not detached from the hammer while drilling is carried out or when they are retracted after completion of the hole. Figures 2.4 and 2.5 show some bits used in top and DTH hammer drilling respectively. Schematic of rotary blasthole drilling is shown in Figure 2.6.
Button Bit
Cross Bit
X Bit
Figure 2.4 Bits used in top hammer drilling.
Splines
Collar Cross Bit
X Bit
Button Bit
Figure 2.5 Bits used in down the hole hammer drilling.
Book.indb 20
11/22/2010 2:34:05 PM
An overview of blasthole drilling
21
Mast Drill Head Shock Absorber Mast Braces Machinery House Operator’s Cab
Crawler Mounting
Drill Pipes Stabilizer Drill Bit
Figure 2.6 Schematics of rotary blasthole drilling.
In a rotary blasthole drill, the rotary motion is generated at the drill head by hydraulic or electric motors. The head is pushed down through the feed mechanism to exert the necessary feed force. Drills used for rotary blasthole drilling are very large and heavy, as they have to exert a very high feed force and high torque on the bit through the drill string. Crawler mounting is best suited for the large, tall and heavy drills and for traveling in rough ground. The components, from top to bottom, in a rotary drill string are a shock absorber, a saver sub, drill pipes, a stabilizer and a drill bit. Rotary drilling is carried out by using tricone roller bits in soft to very hard rock mass. In a soft rock mass, drag bits or claw bits are also used. These three types of bits are shown in Figure 2.7. All the three types of bits use tungsten carbide inserts fixed onto a steel body either by shrink fitting, brazing, or mechanical pin or circlip fitting. Tricone bits have three rotating cones fixed into the bit legs through roller and ball bearings. Unlike rotary percussion bits, they have moving parts. Under the heavy force exerted onto the bit, the buttons or teeth on the rotating cones of the bit penetrate into the rock mass. With the heavy torque, they crush, scrape or plow the rock mass to create cuttings. These cuttings are moved out by drilling fluid circulated through the central bore of the drill string components. When rotary or rotary percussion drilling methods are used for blasthole drilling, it is customary to use compressed air as the drilling fluid because it is far more efficient in cutting removal as compared to water or other types of drilling fluids.
Book.indb 21
11/22/2010 2:34:06 PM
22
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Blade Bit
Claw Bit
Tricone Bit
Figure 2.7 Rotary drilling bits.
2.3
PECULIARITIES OF BLASTHOLE DRILLING
Compared to the other purposes of drilling, such as waterwells, oilwells, exploration etc., blasthole drilling has some peculiarities as follows, 1
2
Book.indb 22
Blastholes are drilled at the same location. In the case of huge mining projects there may be a need to drill many million blastholes within an area of say ten square kilometers. Most of such mining projects last for fifty or more years. Some mines are productive even for a century. When a set of blasthole drills becomes inefficient after years of use it is replaced. In many mines, not only one or two but several such blasthole drill generations are replaced one after another. In the case of tunnel construction all the blastholes lie along the alignment of the tunnel. Here too, millions of blastholes are localized between the two ends of a tunnel. For other purposes of drilling, such as oil or water wells only a few holes are drilled at one location. The drilling work may last for a few weeks or months at the most. The location of the next drill hole may be far away, sometimes even thousands of kilometers. Blastholes are very near to each other. In surface mining operations several hundred blastholes are drilled at each of the benches. The distance between the blastholes is often from 3 to 12 m. In the case of underground mining or tunneling Operations, many blastholes are drilled at the face of tunnel. The distance between two blastholes can be as low as half meter or even lesser. Therefore, a drill is not required to be moved but the feed frames of the drill can be moved and suitably aligned for drilling each of the blastholes. Movement of the drill becomes necessary for drilling blastholes in the next face after the blasted fragments are removed. This distance is often from 3 to 5 m. In rock faces formed after blasting, blastholes are drilled in a very specific pattern, that is more or less the same as previous. For other purposes of drilling, even if few holes are required to be drilled at the same location, the distance between holes can be very large. Further, in many cases there is no definite pattern for drilling such holes.
11/22/2010 2:34:08 PM
An overview of blasthole drilling
3
4
5
6
7
23
Blastholes are shallow in depth. In tunneling, the blastholes are horizontal and rarely exceed 6 m in length. In underground mining blastholes may be reach 30 m in length or depth. In the case of surface mines, blasthole depths vary from 10 m to 50 m depending upon the mining method and the machinery used for moving the rock. For other purposes of drilling, such as oil or water wells, the hole depth is commonly in terms of hundreds of meters. Particularly in oilwell drilling, hole depth can be between one to seven kilometers or even more, the deepest being over 10 km. Blastholes are drilled in rock masses that have a high degree of uniformity. In surface mining the blastholes are drilled in a more or less uniform rock mass. This rock mass may be stratified but the properties of the strata do not vary greatly. In underground mining, and particularly in tunneling, the rock mass characteristics may greatly differ from one place to the other but the variation within a group of, say, 100 blastholes is very small. For other purposes of drilling, the variety of rock masses can be very large. In very few cases, if any, the rock mass at two locations of the hole is the same. Blastholes are drilled in the same environment. In surface or underground mining as well as tunneling, the holes are required to be drilled at almost the same depth and surroundings. For other purposes of drilling, two holes may be in radically different surroundings. For example, one waterwell may be in a busy locality near a sea port, whereas the next hole may be at a hill station at high altitude. No testing is done in blastholes. In the case of blastholes, no testing is involved. The holes are drilled, charged with explosives and fired. After removing the fragmented rock by using loading and hauling equipment, the process of drilling is continued once again over the freshly exposed area. In a few instances it may be essential to carry out a few tests in blastholes but such tests are carried out only after the hole is drilled and the drill is moved to next blasthole location. For other purposes of drilling, a lot of ‘in hole’ testing may have to be done in the midst of the drilling process. For hole path orientation test, permeability test, borehole logging etc. special tools have to be lowered into the hole. Blastholes are always straight. Barring unavoidable deviation, blastholes are intended to be in a straight line. In other purposes of drilling, holes may be purposefully deviated and so are on a curved path.
In view of all these peculiarities of blasthole drilling, the drills, components and tools are designed with an objective of giving fastest economical output in terms of meters drilled.
2.4
COMPARISON OF DRILLING METHODS
Rotary percussion and rotary drilling methods described above have been compared in Table 2.1. The comparison is made on a technological basis from the blasthole drilling viewpoint.
Book.indb 23
11/22/2010 2:34:09 PM
Book.indb 24
Table 2.1 Comparison of blasthole drilling methods on the basis of essential requirements. Rotary percussion blasthole drilling
11/22/2010 2:34:09 PM
Criteria of comparison
Top hammer drilling
Down the hole hammer drilling
Rotary blasthole drilling
Means of Achieving Formation Disintegration
By means of blows generated at the drilling machine located above the ground.
By means of blows generated in the down the hole hammer placed just above the drill bit in the drill hole.
By means of static pressure given by the feed force exerted by the drilling machine placed on ground.
Type of Drill String
Relatively slender as it comprises of drilling rods coupled together by means of sleeves.
Relatively rigid because it comprises of large diameter drill pipes that have male and female threads on their ends. No sleeve is required for coupling the pipes.
Rigid because it comprises of even larger diameter and heavier drill pipes that have male and female threads on their ends. No sleeve is required for coupling the pipes.
Transfer of Impacts and Rotary Motion
Both impacts and rotary movement are transferred through drill string.
Only the rotary movement is transferred through drill string. Impacts are generated at the hammer in the hole just above the bit.
Very heavy static feed force instead of impacts and rotary movement are transferred through the drill string.
Practical Hole Dia. Range
38 mm to 150 mm.
89 mm to 250 mm.
150 mm to 445 mm.
Practical Hole Depth Range and Susceptibility to Hole Deviation
0 to 18 m. Highly susceptible to deviation at higher depths due to high slenderness ratio of the drill rods.
0 to 100 m. Hole deviation is relatively small because drill pipes have low slenderness ratio.
0 to 60 m. Hole deviation is relatively small because drill pipes have low slenderness ratio.
Book.indb 25
Possibility of Angle Hole Drilling
As holes are drilled with light equipment they can be drilled at any angle.
As holes are drilled with medium equipment drilling holes in direction other than vertical or near vertical is difficult.
Drilling equipment is very heavy.Vertical or slightly inclined holes are possible.
Effect of Depth on Penetration Rate
Penetration rate is considerably reduced with depth because of loss of percussion energy. It is absorption by drill rods.
No significant loss of penetration rate as the hole depth increases because no energy is lost in transmission.
Penetration rate is unaffected by increase in the depth of the hole because impact energy is not used.
Means of Cutting Removal from the Hole
By means of compressed air circulated through the drill string. Sometimes water is also used as circulation medium.
By means of compressed air circulated through the drill string.
By means of compressed air circulated through the drill string.
Magnitude of Feed Force Required on Drilling Tool
Small force is essential to ensure that the bit is in contact with the formation.
Small force is essential to ensure that the bit is in contact with the formation.
Very heavy force is essential to ensure that the bit remains in contact with the formation and crushes the formation beneath it.
Effect of Extreme Cold Weather
As hydraulic oil is the medium of power transfer, great difficulties are experienced due to oil viscosity changes.
As compressed air is the medium of power transfer, difficulties in cold weather are easily surmountable.
Electric drills operate satisfactorily. In hydraulic drills difficulties are experienced due to oil viscosity changes.
11/22/2010 2:34:09 PM
26
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Table 2.2 presents a qualitative comparison between top hammer and downthe-hole hammer drilling methods in typical limestone quarries. Faster penetration rate is one of the most important criteria of a drilling method. Figure 2.8 illustrates the penetration rates experienced while drilling about 150 mm blastholes in quarries by Rotary, DTH and Top Hammer drilling methods. The variation of penetration rates is of a qualitative nature.
Table 2.2 Qualitative comparison of TH and DTH drilling. Criteria of comparison
TH drilling
DTH drilling
Diameter of Blastholes in mm Penetration Rate Achieved Straightness of the Blasthole Suitability for Drilling Deep Blastholes Production Capacity per shift Low Fuel Consumption Economic Service Life of Drill String Suitability for Drilling in Difficult Conditions Suitability for Drilling in Good Conditions Simplicity of Drilling From Operator’s Viewpoint
75–127 ♦♦♦♦ ♦♦♦ ♦♦♦ ♦♦♦♦ ♦♦♦♦♦ ♦♦♦ ♦♦♦ ♦♦♦♦♦ ♦♦♦♦
127–300 ♦♦♦ ♦♦♦♦♦ ♦♦♦♦♦ ♦♦♦ ♦♦♦ ♦♦♦♦ ♦♦♦♦ ♦♦♦♦ ♦♦♦♦♦
Hard Monolithic Rock Mass DTH
Rotary Drifter
Increasing Penetration Rate
Increasing Penetration Rate
Soft Rock Mass
DTH Rotary
Increasing Rock Strength
Drifter
Increasing Rock Strength
Increasing Penetration Rate
Hard Fractured Rock Mass
DTH Drifter Rotary
Increasing Rock Strength
Figure 2.8 Penetration rates experienced in drilling about 150 mm blastholes in limestone.
Book.indb 26
11/22/2010 2:34:09 PM
An overview of blasthole drilling
27
It must be borne in mind that the trend of penetration rates shown in Figure 2.8 does change when the rock to be drilled is different and particularly when the holes are of larger or smaller diameter.
2.5
CHOICE OF A BLASTHOLE DRILLING METHOD
Once it is decided that blasthole drilling is to be carried out in preference to other ‘no blast’ methods of rock excavation described in chapter 1, the next logical question is “Which should be the blasthole drilling method?”. The main factors that influence the choice of drilling method are: 1 2 3 4
Period over which operations continues. Diameter of the hole. Depth of the hole. Characteristics of the formation to be drilled.
The most important factor that affects the choice of method is the continuity of operations. In the case of civil engineering, the quantum of blasthole drilling to be carried out is relatively very small as compared to mining. To be specific, a civil engineering contractor may rarely have a need for continuous blasthole drilling at one location for more than two years. Thus, for a civil contractor it is wise to select many smaller machines rather than few large machines for his civil engineering projects, because after completion of the project the smaller machines can be distributed on many separate small jobs. Blastholes in civil engineering are rarely larger than 127 mm in diameter and almost never larger than 200 mm. The depth of a blastholes is also limited to about 20 m. Civil engineering firms, therefore, usually choose top hammer drilling for blastholes of smaller diameter and DTH drilling in case of larger blastholes. In mining choosing the right drilling method is very critical as the blasthole drilling operations continue for decades and blasthole drills specifically designed for a method are to be procured before commencing the operation. Choice of incorrect drills can be disastrous as reselling drills at a fair price is difficult. When blasthole drilling is to be carried out it in the soft sedimentary overburden of opencast coal mines, the diameters of the hole range between 152 to 381 mm and depths range between 15 to 55 m. In soft thick coal beds blasthole diameters range between 152 to 200 mm and depths between 10 to 20 m. For soft sedimentary formations suitability of a blasthole drilling method is illustrated in Figure 2.9. In many opencast metal mines the formations are hard and the variation in hardness is over a very wide range. Here both overburden and ore are removed by using shovels and dumpers. For this reason the blasthole depths lie between 10 to 20 m and diameters can be from 100 to even 445 mm. For all such cases the blasthole drilling method can be chosen on the basis of the illustration in Figure 2.10. In underground coal or metal mines, blasthole diameters are between 51 to 100 mm but in certain cases can be as high as 152 mm. The depths of blastholes can be from 2 to 30 m.
Book.indb 27
11/22/2010 2:34:09 PM
28
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Top Hammer Rotary with Drag or Tricone Bit Rotary with Tricone Bit (Rarely Needed) Rotary Drag Bit
Rotary with Tricone Bit
Soft Very Soft 50
0
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
Blasthole Diameter in mm
Figure 2.9 Suitability of blasthole drilling method in very soft and soft formations. TH Drilling DTH Drilling TH or DTH Rotary with Tricone Rotary with Drilling Bit or DTH Tricone Bit Extreme Hard Very Hard Hard Medium Hard 0
50
100
150 200 250 300 Blasthole Diameter in mm
350
400
450
Figure 2.10 Suitability of blasthole drilling method in medium to very hard formations.
In coal mines it is very common to use rotary drag bit drilling. In hard coal formations top hammers are often used for drilling blastholes. When holes of diameter 152 mm to 30 m depth are to be drilled, as in some metal mines, DTH hammer is the most usual choice because the size of the drilling machines used for DTH drilling is small. In tunneling or shaft sinking operations, diameters of blastholes are 38 to 64 mm. The depths of the blastholes, in a very few instances, can be as much as 25 m but in most of the cases depths are between 2 to 6 m. The top hammer rotary percussion drill is almost exclusively used in all such operations. Two important points must always be remembered while choosing the right drill for blasthole drilling. Rotary drilling requires exerting a heavy feed force in the downward direction on the drill string. Hence the drills are very heavy. If they are not heavy, their ability in drilling large diameter blastholes remains limited and must be investigated cautiously. Percussive drills need not exert heavy feed force, but when drilling upward holes the weight of the piston acts adversely to the blow energy. Percussive drill performance must be judged in the light of this fact.
Book.indb 28
11/22/2010 2:34:10 PM
An overview of blasthole drilling
29
The performance of blasthole drilling equipment can be judged by means of carrying out certain laboratory tests. However, due to many influencing factors, it cannot be totally relied upon, while tackling an important issue like choosing a blasthole drill. Field trials by using hired equipment before taking a final decision about the suitable blasthole drilling method is a far better alternative, even if it is expensive. In this chapter both rotary percussion and rotary drilling methods have been described briefly. As the subject of this book is rotary blasthole drilling, in all forthcoming chapters all the elaborations are presented from the a viewpoint of rotary blasthole drilling.
Book.indb 29
11/22/2010 2:34:10 PM
Chapter 3
Properties of rocks
3.1
INTRODUCTION
Blasthole drilling is a part of earth excavation processes. Needless to say, some basic knowledge of earth science, and particularly the properties of rock and rock masses, is very essential to a person engaged in blasthole drilling. Earth science is a very wide subject and has many branches within it. Branches that are important in the context of blasthole drilling are geology, mineralogy, meteorology and rock mechanics. This chapter presents essential knowledge of Geology and mineralogy. Topics on rock mechanics are covered in chapter 9. Meteorology is elaborated in chapter 11. The properties of rock masses have been covered in chapter 23 as they are more relevant to blasting than drilling.
3.2
EARTH AND ITS INTERIOR
Earth is one of the planets revolving around the sun in an elliptical orbit, having a mean diameter of 1.496 × 106 km. The shape of the earth is almost spherical. Earth rotates around its axis and completes one rotation in one day. The two points at which the earth’s rotational axis crosses its surface are called poles. According to the magnetic properties of the earth these poles are named south and north. An imaginary circle, perpendicular to the earth’s rotational axis, that lies on the surface of the earth and thus divides the earth into two equal hemispheres, is called an equator. The equatorial diameter of the earth is 12756.6 km and the polar diameter is 12713.8 km. The volume of the earth is 1.08323 × 106 km3. The total surface area of the earth is calculated to be 510 × 106 km2 of which land covers only 149 × 106 km2 i.e. 29.22%. The remaining 70.78% area is covered with water. Average land height is estimated to be about 840 m above the mean sea level. The average depth of the water below the mean sea level is 3804 m. Various experiments have proved that the average density of the earth is 5517 kg/m3 and accordingly the mass of the earth works out to be 5.976 × 1024 kg. The interior of the earth consists of three zones as illustrated in Figure 3.1. The innermost zone, spherical in shape with a radius of about 3400 km, is called the core. The core itself is subdivided into an inner core and an outer core. The outer core is
Book.indb 31
11/22/2010 2:34:10 PM
32
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Inner Core Outer Core Inner Mantle Crust
Outer Mantle
Figure 3.1 Interior of the earth.
believed to be composed of molten iron and nickel and has a density of 10000 kg/m3. The inner core is believed to be in a solid state and has a density of 17000 kg/m3. The next outer zone, called the mantle, has a thickness of about 2900 km. The mantle is again subdivided into two zones viz. inner and outer mantle. The inner and outer mantle have a density of 5700 kg/m3 and 3300 kg/m3 respectively. The outer mantle consists of rock-forming minerals. The outermost zone is called the crust. It is contained in a shell of thickness varying between 5 to 40 km. As illustrated in Figure 3.2, the thickness of the crust is smaller below the oceans and seas and is much larger below the middle portion of the land—particularly mountains. These portions of the crust are called oceanic crust and continental crust. Earth’s crust is also divided in sial and sima. Sial, i.e. outer shell of the crust, is mainly composed of silica and aluminum and hence the acronym sial. Sial is present below the continental shelf and shallow sea/ocean floor. Its thickness varies between 0 to 13 km. Sial is absent below the deep ocean floors. The average density of sial shell is 2700 kg/m3. It is mostly composed of granitic rocks mainly formed from quartz and orthoclase. Sima is the inner shell of the crust. As it comprises silica and magnesia, it is named by the acronym sima. Sima is present everywhere i.e. below the sial as also the ocean floors. Sima thickness increases towards the center of the continental crust. Average density of sima is about 2940 kg/m3. It is mostly composed of basic rocks e.g. gabbro and basalt. Most of the elements found in earth’s crust are in compound form of which oxides are the main type. The proportions of various oxides found in the earth’s crust is given in Table 3.1. The proportion of elements that form these compounds is given in Table 3.2. Oxides chemically combine with each other, or with other substances, to form minerals that are the main constituents of rock. A mineral is an inorganic substance having definite chemical composition and properties. Earth’s crust contains more than 2000 minerals.
Book.indb 32
11/22/2010 2:34:10 PM
Properties of rocks
Mountains
33
Oceanic Crust Ocean
Sial
Sima Mantle
Figure 3.2 Earth’s crust.
Table 3.1 Oxide proportion in earth’s crust. Common name of oxide
Chemical formula
% Wt. in earth’s crust
Silica Corundum Calcium Oxide Ferrous Oxide Sodium Oxide Magnesium Oxide Ferric Oxide Potassium Oxide Water Titanium Dioxide Other Oxides
SiO2 Al2O3 CaO FeO Na2O MgO Fe2O3 K2O H2O TiO2 –
59.1 15.2 5.1 3.7 3.7 3.5 3.1 3.1 1.3 1.0 1.2
Table 3.2 Element proportion in earth’s crust.
Book.indb 33
Element name
Chemical symbol
% Wt. in earth’s crust
Oxygen Silicon Aluminum Iron Calcium Sodium Potassium Magnesium Titanium Hydrogen Other Elements
O Si Al Fe Ca Na K Mg Ti H –
47.0 27.0 8.0 5.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 0.5 0.17 1.33
11/22/2010 2:34:11 PM
34
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
3.3
GEOLOGICAL CYCLE
One of the fundamental laws in respect of matter states that matter can neither be created nor destroyed but can only be altered. Accordingly, all the land that has come into existence, is actually as a result of transformation through many activities. Such activities are going on even now and will never stop. Figure 3.3 shows a flow diagram which indicates all such activities. These activities are geologic in nature i.e. they commence, continue and complete within the earth and its surroundings. Being cyclic in form they are called the ‘Geological Cycle’. Magma is the most primary matter in the geological cycle. It is a very hot, viscous, siliceous rock melt containing many minerals, water and gases. In addition to silica and oxygen, that are the major constituents of magma, it also contains elements such
Magma Mixing of Magma with Water in Volcanic Activity
Mixing of Magma with Air in Volcanic Activity
Solidification of Magma After Igneous Intrusions and Extrusions
Matter Suspended in Air
Matter Suspended in Water
Biological Activity
Biological Activity
Sedimentation and Deposition Sedimentation and Deposition
Igneous Rocks
Weathering and Transportation
Anatexis i.e. Regeneration of Magma by Fluxing of Pre Existing Rocks Biological Activity
Metamorphism Biodeposits
Biological Activity
Sediments and Soils
Diagenesis
Diagenesis
Weathering and Transportation Anatexis i.e. Regeneration of Magma by Fluxing of Pre Existing Rocks
Weathering and Transportation
Weathering and Transportation
Sedimentary Rocks
Weathering and Transportation
Weathering and Transportation
Metamorphism
Metamorphic Rocks
Figure 3.3 Geological cycle.
Book.indb 34
11/22/2010 2:34:13 PM
Properties of rocks
35
as potassium, sodium, calcium etc. Magmas are accumulated at great depth below the surface of the earth. Due to superheated steam and hot gases, magma always exerts very high pressure on its surroundings. Such high pressure sometimes exceeds the limit of strength of the surrounding mass, resulting in formation of cracks in the surrounding mass. Being in a fluid state, magma flows through such cracks and either intrudes below or extrudes above the surface of the earth. Depending upon the magnitude of the pressure and the rate at which the magma flows, violent volcanic eruptions or slow intrusions take place. When magma cools down, it transforms into different types of rocks. Such rocks, formed after magma intrusion or extrusion, are called igneous rocks. Igneous rocks are found at great depths below all the surface of earth i.e. land or oceans. Various weathering agents e.g. water, wind, sea, river, glacier, biological activities, trees etc. cause continuous disintegration of igneous rocks. Resultant materials, that are in unconsolidated granular form, are called sediments. Sediments are often moved away by transporting agents such as streams, rivers, wind. These sediments eventually get deposited at other locations. When these sediments get cemented and/or consolidated, they turn into a hard and strong sediment mass that is called sedimentary rock. In volcanic activities, sometimes the sedimentary and igneous rocks get heated to very high temperature and are also subjected to very high pressure. Under such conditions the igneous and sedimentary rocks undergo transformation on a large scale to form metamorphic rocks. In some very large scale volcanic activities, all the three kinds of rocks are thrown from the place of their original formation to great depths below the earth’s crust. Inflow of enormous heat from the surroundings increases the temperature of these rocks to such a level that they melt and transform into magma. This process of magma formation is called anatexis.
3.3.1
Igneous rocks
Igneous rocks are composed of minerals that have silica as one of the main constituents. These minerals are quartz, orthoclase, plagioclase, hornblende, mica, augite and olivine. A mineral composition and texture-based genetic classification of igneous rocks is generally followed in geology. According to this basis of classification, there are four classes of igneous rocks, viz. acidic, intermediate, basic and ultrabasic. Acidic rocks have higher quartz contents than other igneous rocks. Quartz crystals can be separately observed in such rocks. The other major constituent of acidic rock is orthoclase. Besides this plagioclase, mica and hornblende are also present. Intermediate rocks may have some quartz and orthoclase but usually less than 10% each. The main constituents of intermediate rocks are plagioclase, mica and hornblende. Basic rocks do not contain any quartz. Their main constituent is plagioclase. Other constituents are hornblende, augite and olivine. Ultrabasic rocks are mostly formed from olivine and have some quantities of augite and plagioclase. Acidic rocks are generally lighter in color, whereas intermediate, basic and ultrabasic rocks are increasingly darker in that order.
Book.indb 35
11/22/2010 2:34:13 PM
36
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
The density of acidic rocks is about 2600 kg/m3. For intermediate, basic and ultrabasic rocks it increases gradually to finally reach the level of 3300 kg/m3. The names of some igneous rocks are: granite, basalt, andesite, syenite, dolerite, gabbro, granodiorite, peridotite, ignimbrite, rhyolite, diorite, pumice, ash, eclogite, pitchstone. Figure 3.4 illustrates different classes of igneous rocks mentioned above. Igneous rocks are also classified on the basis of their texture i.e. the relationship between the grains forming the rock. It depends upon grain size, grain shape, degree of crystallinity and grain contact relationship. In this type of classification specific names of the rocks are used. Unfortunately the names of rocks are colloquial in nature and, therefore, there is no unification or standardization in the names of the rocks. Some rocks and their texture-based classification is shown in Table 3.3.
3.3.2
Sedimentary rocks
In the transportation of fragments formed by weathering and erosion, the solid materials get deposited. These deposits are in the form of layers and are called sediments. Sedimentary rocks are formed from these sediments. Therefore all sedimentary rocks are layered. Consolidation, cementation and crystallization turn sediments into sedimentary rocks.
Approximate Percentage of Principal minerals
Acidic
Intermediate
Basic
Ultrabasic
100
75
Quartz Plagioclase
50 Orthoclase
Mica
25
Augite
Olivine
Hornblende 0
Figure 3.4 Composition of igneous rocks. Table 3.3 Classification of igneous rocks. Nature of composition Grain and crystal
Rock type
Coarse Grain, Large Crystals Plutonic Medium Grain, Large Crystals
Acidic
Granite Porphyritic Granite Hypabyssal Granophyre
Medium Grain, Medium Crystals Fine Grained, Medium Crystals Fine Grained, Small Crystals Extrusive
Book.indb 36
Intermediate Basic
Ultrabasic
Diorite Porphyrite
Peridotite
Quartz Porphyry Rhyolite Andesite
Gabbro
Dolerite
Basalt Trachyte
11/22/2010 2:34:13 PM
Properties of rocks
37
Often particles in a sediment are of very small size. Due to their predominantly cohesive nature, these particles remain bonded together. Very small pore spaces within these particles are filled with water. When pressure gets exerted on such sediments the water from the pore spaces gets oozed out. In absence of water all the pressure is borne by the particles so the cohesive bonding between particles increases. Eventually a solid hard mass is formed. This mass is called sedimentary rock. The process of oozing out of water and the formation of a solid mass is called consolidation. In certain cases the sediments have particles formed out of very fine materials of a particular nature—mainly calcareous in their chemical composition. When these materials come in contact with water, a chemical reaction takes place and the particles stick together with a very high bonding force. The result is the formation of a hard mass. This process, called cementation, also gives rise to sedimentary rocks. Occasionally, the cementing materials occupy spaces between larger fragments deposited earlier. In such sedimentary rocks two distinct particle sizes are easily noticeable. The process of crystal formation from dissolved minerals often occurs in the shallow parts of the sea or in lakes, in desert areas etc., where evaporation is much higher than precipitation. The sea or lake contains dissolved minerals such as calcium bicarbonate and calcium sulfate. As evaporation takes place, water is lost and the dissolved minerals form crystals. These crystals settle on the bottom of the sea or lake. As evaporation continues, more crystals from and accumulate on the sea or lake floor. After some time interval, they transform into sedimentary rocks. Sedimentary rocks are found near the surface of the earth. They may also be composed of many different types of minerals. Their thickness is usually less than 1 km but can be as high as 10 km. The names of some sedimentary rocks are: breccia, conglomerate, sandstone, limestone, coal, lignite, chalk, dolomite, arkose, greywacke, shale. Sedimentary rocks are classified on the basis of particle size as shown in Table 3.4, or on the basis of their chemical composition as shown in Table 3.5.
3.3.3
Metamorphic rocks
Metamorphic rocks are formed by recrystallization or transformation of already existing rock masses or sediments. The process is called metamorphism. It requires high temperature or pressures or both. Table 3.4 Classification of sedimentary rocks on the basis of their particle size. Class of rock
Grain size
Name of the fragment class
Names of some of the rocks in the class
Rudaceous
Larger than 256 mm
Boulders
Conglomerate (Rounded Fragments) or Breccia (Angular Fragments )
Between 64 and 256 mm
Cobbles
Between 2 and 64 mm
Peebles
Between 1/16 and 2 mm
Sand
Arenaceous
Argillaceous Between ½56 and 1/16 mm Silt Less than ½56 mm
Book.indb 37
Clay
Sandstones Siltstones Mudstones, Shale
11/22/2010 2:34:14 PM
38
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Table 3.5 Classification of sedimentary rocks on the basis of their chemical composition. Composition
Chemical sediment
Organic sediment
Calcareous Carbonaceous Siliceous Ferruginous Aluminous Phosphatic Saline
Oolithic Limestone, dolomite – Flint, Chert Oolithic Limestone, Laterite Bauxite Phosphorite Rock Salt, Gypsum, Anhydrite
Reef and Shelly Limestone, Chalk Peat, Lignite, Coal Diatomite, Radiolarite Bog Iron Ore – Guano, Bonebeds –
Metamorphism is of four different types as follows. 3.3.3.1
Contact metamorphism
In contact metamorphism very little pressure is involved. The metamorphism is mainly due to heat that transforms matter into metamorphic rocks. During the process of magma intrusion, the heat from magma is given to the adjoining rock. Very high temperatures at the contact between the intrusive body and surrounding older formation causes recrystallization. In this manner a layer of metamorphic rocks is formed around an intrusive body. In the case of small intrusive bodies, the thickness of such layers can be very small but for large intrusive bodies it can even be 2 to 3 km. 3.3.3.2
Regional metamorphism
Changes in the lower crust and mantle exert high pressures and medium temperatures in some parts of the earth’s crust. If the disturbances are very large, existing rocks may be thrown as deep as 10 to 15 km, where pressure and temperatures are very high. These conditions result in metamorphism in that region. The metamorphic rocks formed in this manner are not in layered form but in massive bodies lying within that region which often have dimensions exceeding tens of kilometers. 3.3.3.3
Dynamic metamorphism
Changes in the crust and mantle of the earth can develop cracks in the ground. Very often the layers on one side of the crack are moved up or down relative to others. Such movement generates very high pressure and temperature at the crack. These give rise to metamorphic rocks in thin layers. As the reason of the metamorphism is movement, it is called dynamic metamorphism. 3.3.3.4
Impact metamorphism
When a large meteorite hits the earth’s surface, the impact generates heat and pressure that results in the formation of metamorphic rocks in the immediate vicinity of the impact area.
Book.indb 38
11/22/2010 2:34:14 PM
Properties of rocks
39
Names of some metamorphic rocks are: slate, schist, gneiss, marble, quartzite, skern, hornfels, amphibolite, mylonite, granulite, epidorite. Classification of metamorphic rocks is less rigidly adhered to than rocks of the other two types. A few rocks are recognized on the basis of their distinct textural and mineralogical features. Composite names are used to achieve greater precision in describing metamorphic rocks. In such composite names, the main constituent of the rock is usually mentioned first, e.g. Garnet-Mica Schist. Table 3.6 describes the generally accepted classes of metamorphic rocks. These classes are based the original rock from which they were formed. Table 3.6 Classification of metamorphic rocks on the basis of original rocks and formation process. Original rock Argillaceous Sediments
General description
Slate
Very fine grained with flat platy cleavages. Often dark in color. A product of low grade metamorphism.
Phyllite
Fine grained with undulating, lustrous cleavage planes. Commonly greenish in color. Exhibits higher metamorphism than slate.
Mica Schist
Medium to coarse grained with rough often puckered cleavage parallel to mica foliation. Middle to high grade of metamorphism.
Gneiss
Medium to coarse grained. Foliation of streaky bands of mica, quartz and feldspar. High grade metamorphism.
Granofels
Fine to coarse but even grained, unfoliated, often quartofeldsparthic. A product of medium to high grade metamorphism.
Arenaceous Sediments
Quartzite
Highly interlocking quartz grains. Usually lacks foliation. Occasionally contains mica crystals. Mostly white in color. High grade of metamorphism.
Calcareous Sediments
Marble
Contains interlocking calcite and dolomite grains. Sometimes contains calcium and silicate minerals. Usually white, gray or buff color. A product of high grade metamorphism.
Basic Igneous Rocks
Antinolite and Chlorite Schist
Greenish rocks with high degree of foliation. Undulated or puckering cleavage. Low to middle grade of metamorphism.
Amphibolite
Medium to coarse grained rocks. Usually found in blocks. Usually foliated and banded. Hornblende and plagioclase are the main constituents. High degree of metamorphism.
Eclogite
Medium to coarse grained rocks. Greenish red color due to red garnet set in a matrix of green pyroxene. Exhibits high grade of metamorphism.
Hornfels
Mostly fine grained rocks. Formed by contact metamorphism. Dark in color. Unfoliated.
Mylonite
Very fine grained flinty rocks. Thinly banded. Usually dark colored. Formed as a result of mechanical crushing and grinding.
Mixed Sediments or Acidic IgneousRocks
Various Sediments
Book.indb 39
Metamorphic rock
11/22/2010 2:34:14 PM
40
3.4
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
FORMATION OF ROCK MASS
Rock mass is formed at or near the surface of the earth by different activities that take place near the surface of the earth. Main activities in this regard are 1 2 3
Volcanic Activities Plutonic Activities Surface Activities
These have been briefly accounted for in earlier parts of this book. The following is a larger elaboration.
3.4.1 Volcanic activities Volcanic activities are those in which magma, which exists at depths within earth under very high pressure and temperature, finds a way to flow above or near the surface of earth. In this activity different types of rock masses are formed. In geological terms they are called structures. Two classes of volcanic structures are known. They are, 1 2
Extrusive Structures Hypabyssal Structures
3.4.1.1
Extrusive structures
Extrusive structures are formed when magma erupts above the ground surface. Such magma, that erupts on the surface of ground, is called lava. Some extrusive structures are lava plateaux, lava cones, hornitos, craters, calderas etc. Descriptions of these extrusive structures are given in Table 3.7. Usually lava cools very rapidly at the surface of the earth. Therefore, rocks found in these structures are fine grained. 3.4.1.2
Hypabyssal structures
When structures are formed by magma intrusion at shallow depths, they are termed hypabyssal structures. Some hypabyssal structures are volcanic plugs, dikes, laccoliths, sills etc. Descriptions of these hypabyssal structures are given in Table 3.8. As the cooling rate of magma in these structures is not very high, the rocks formed in them are medium grained. Occasionally, when the earth surface covering these structures gets eroded, they become visible on the ground surface.
3.4.2
Plutonic structures
Plutonic structures are formed by magma intrusions at great depth below the surface of the earth. Usually these structures are of very large size that ranges from ten to even many hundred kilometers. The rate of cooling of the magma is very slow. More often than not, these structures have layers of rocks. Due to the extremely slow process of
Book.indb 40
11/22/2010 2:34:14 PM
Properties of rocks
41
Table 3.7 Extrusive structures. Name
Description
Lava Plateau
Lava plateau are formed on the surface of the earth by flow of magma through fissures. Fissures are thin but long and deep seated gaps at the surface of the earth. Magma that flows through these fissures is low in viscosity and flows over a very large surface. It cools rapidly and rocks formed in the process are basalt.
Lava Cone
Lava cones are formed when lava flows to the surface of earth through medium sized pipelike structures. Usually such lava has somewhat intermediate viscosity and, therefore, spreads less easily on the surface of the earth. In the process a hillock with gentle slope on all the sides is formed.
Hornito
Hornitos are formed when highly viscous lava flows to the surface of earth through large structures. Hornitos are tall but small diameter structures with steep slopes on the sides.
Crater
Craters are depressions in the ground. They are formed at the mouth of a volcano. Craters can also be formed when a meteorite hits the earth surface.
Caldera
Caldera are very large depressions on the surface of the earth. They are formed by coalescence of several small craters or repeated explosions of a volcano at adjacent places or ground subsidence of a large portion of earth surface in a huge hollow formed just below the surface of the earth during a violent volcanic eruption. Calderas can be very large in diameter – often tens of kilometers.
Table 3.8 Hypabyssal structures. Name
Description
Volcanic Plug
During volcanic intrusions magma often flows to the ground surface through circular feed channels. After the volcanic activity comes to an end such channels remain filled with solidified magma. Later the surrounding structure may get eroded, leaving behind the magma channel in vertical or near vertical position. This is called a volcanic plug.
Dike
Often magma flow cuts across the bedding planes of the older formations and forms sheet like structures. These are called dikes. Many different types of dikes – based on their shapes – are known e.g. parallel dikes, radial dikes, ring dikes etc.
Laccolith
Intrusive magma often takes the shape of a dome having flat underlying surface and arch like top surface. In appearance this structure looks like a mushroom. These are called laccolith. Laccoliths are called composite when they are formed from two different sources of magma. Similarly two or more laccoliths formed from the same magma source are called multiple laccoliths. Cedar tree laccoliths are the laccoliths lying one above another and resemble to the shape of a cedar tree. All these laccoliths are formed from the same magma source.
Sill
Book.indb 41
When magma intrudes in between two bedding planes and forms a sheet like structure, of nearly same thickness and negligible concavity, it is known as a sill. Sills, like laccoliths, can be multiple or composite.
11/22/2010 2:34:14 PM
42
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
cooling, the fluid state of magma lasts for a long time. Acidic magma, which has lower density, floats at the top and the basic magma settles down to greater depth. In this condition the upper rocks are coarse grained acidic—granites—and the lower rocks are coarse grained basic—gabbro. Various plutonic structures are batholiths, stocks, lopoliths, phacoliths etc. Descriptions of these extrusive structures are given in Table 3.9. Table 3.9 Plutonic structures. Name
Description
Batholith
Batholiths are gigantic structures having a cross sectional area of more than 100 km2. The structure goes on enlarging horizontally with increasing depth. There is no apparent bottom to the batholith. It can be considered as a part of inner crust. Stocks are similar to batholiths but much smaller in their physical dimensions. Structures smaller than 100 km2 area are classified as stocks. When the magma intrusions take a saucer like shape with the upper and lower concave surfaces as seen from the top, the resulting structure is called a lopolith. By their nature the lopoliths are formed by magma intrusions between two concave layers. The path of magma is somewhat narrow. Therefore, the type of magma that intrudes in lopoliths is basic in nature. Naturally, rocks formed in the lopoliths are coarse grained basic rocks. When magma intrudes in between two convex beds, as seen from the top, the resultant structure is called phacolith. In other words phacoliths are similar to lopoliths but inverted upside down.
Stock Lopolith
Phacolith
Table 3.10 Surface structures. Name
Description
Unconformity During the deposition of the sediments that give rise to the beds, there is a time interval during which no deposition takes place. Therefore, a surface formed during this time interval separates the old beds from new beds. On many occasions, due to change in the mode of deposition or change in the type of sediment, such surface is very distinct and is called unconformity. Angular, Parallel, Non Depositional and Hetrolithic are the four different types of unconformities. Joints During tectonic activities different types of stresses are developed on the beds. Rocks are capable of withstanding high compressive stresses but are weak in tension. Due to this, cracks i.e. joints develop at various places in the rock mass. The most important property of joints is that there is no apparent movement on two sides of the joint with respect to each other. A series of parallel joints is called as a set of joints. Joints are classified on the basis of mode in which they were formed. Three classes of joints viz. Shrinkage, Tectonic and Sheet are generally recognized. Faults Fractures in formation beds, along which there has been observable movement of the formation on each of the sides of the fracture plane, are termed as faults. Normal, Hinge, Pivot, Tear and Reverse are the five types of faults Folds During tectonic movements the plane beds are often converted into a wave form. Such structures are called folds. The trough like portion of a fold is termed as syncline, whereas, the crest like portion is named as anticline. There are nearly ten different types of folds.
Book.indb 42
11/22/2010 2:34:14 PM
Properties of rocks
3.4.3
43
Surface activities
Denudation is a general term used to refer to the processes that alter the surface of the earth. It therefore consists of weathering, transportation and erosion. Weathering means natural disintegration and/or decomposition of the rock mass. Transportation means shifting of the disintegrated or decomposed material away from the place at which they were initially formed. While the broken materials are transported, they come in physical contact with other fresh uneroded formations. The friction developed between the two causes weathering of the fresh formation. This process is termed erosion. As all the above processes take place on the surface of the earth, they are called surface processes. Almost all the surface processes result in deposition of the material on the earth surface in layers and the structures formed in the process are unconformities, joints, faults, folds. A description of different surface structures is given in Table 3.10.
3.5
SOILS, ROCKS AND THEIR PROFILE
The term soil originates from the farming industry. In civil engineering it is defined as an unconsolidated, uncemented mineral mass containing air, water and other impurities of organic nature. Soil is also a product of weathering. It usually lies at or near the surface of the ground. When an excavation below the surface of ground is carried out in the form of a trench or vertical cut, different layers having different constituents and colors are visible on the wall. The composite structure of such layers is called a soil profile. Soil profiles depend upon many factors. Different soil profiles are seen in different regions. Some typical soil profiles are shown in Figure 3.5. In modern nomenclature the ‘O’ horizon is the topmost. It consists of fresh litter in its upper, and decomposed organic matter in its lower, part. It retains soil moisture. The ‘A’ horizon, having a dark blackish brown color, underlies the ‘O’ horizon and consists of a mixture of minerals and organic material. Leaching, i.e. chemical decomposition, removes minerals like Ca, Fe as well as decomposed organic matter to lower horizons. The ‘E’ horizon underlies the ‘A’ horizon. Usually it is a light-colored horizon with ongoing activity of leaching, or the removal of clay particles, organic matter, and/or oxides of iron and aluminum. In some forest regions the ‘E’ horizon has a high concentration of quartz giving the horizon an ash-gray appearance. Beneath the ‘E’ horizon lies the ‘B’ horizon. Most of the fine matter leached in the upper horizons is accumulated in the ‘B’ horizon. The accumulation of fine material leads to the creation of a dense layer in the soil. In some soils the ‘B’ horizon is enriched with calcium carbonate in the form of nodules or as a layer. This occurs when the carbonate precipitates out from capillary action of soil or water moving downward. The ‘C’ horizon is the next deeper horizon. It mainly consists of parent rock in weathered form. The lowermost horizon is the ‘D’ horizon and represents the parent rock in intact form. In some places some horizons are absent.
Book.indb 43
11/22/2010 2:34:14 PM
44
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Tundra Profile
A - Peat
Terra Rossa Profile A - Red Clay
O (Contains organic matter) A (Rich in humus)
B - Clay
B - Limestone
B (Rich in Mineral salts)
C (Subsoil and weathered rock)
Laterite Profile
Desert Profile A - Sand (No Dunes) A - Clay
B - Concentration Rich in salt D (Solid rock)
C - Leached Zone D D - Solid Rock
Figure 3.5 Soil profile under different environments.
3.6
OCCURRENCE OF MINERALS
A rock mass is formed by the assemblage of several minerals. Some of these minerals are of great economic importance because they are useful in many ways e.g. for extraction of metals, for use in different manufacturing processes, for medical use, for ornamental use etc. Mineral deposit is a term used for an assemblage of minerals where one or more, but not all, the minerals in the assemblage are of value. When a granite formation is used for production of tiles for house flooring, kitchen platform etc., it is not called a mineral deposit since it does not involve any specific mineral. But when a granite formation is excavated for obtaining pyrite contained in it, the granite formation is called mineral deposit. An ore body is the specific portion in a mineral deposit that fully or largely contains the mineral of economic importance. The remaining portion of the mineral deposit is considered as waste and is usually called overburden because it lies above the ore body. It has to be removed to gain access to the ore body. When an ore body contained in a mineral deposit has to be accessed it becomes essential to break the overburden or the surrounding rock mass and move it away. The ore itself has to be crushed before subjecting it to further chemical processes. All such activities together are called mining. When the rock mass is excavated as a whole, the activity is called quarrying. Examples of this are the rock mass excavation in broken form e.g. large stone pieces
Book.indb 44
11/22/2010 2:34:14 PM
Properties of rocks
45
or crushed stone required in the construction industry or in dimensional block form for cutting tiles for house flooring etc. In nature, mineral deposits occur in many different forms. During the formation of igneous rocks, the magma often contains small quantities of minerals of copper, lead, zinc etc. These minerals do not find a place in the main rock mass that contains quartz, feldspar, mica etc. Therefore, these minerals get separated into ore bodies. Water superheated to very high temperatures is very active and can dissolve many economically important minerals to form a hydrothermal fluid. When an igneous rock mass forms, the hydrothermal fluid usually accumulates at the top of the rock mass as it has low density. After a certain time interval the water itself gets evaporated and the compounds crystallize to form a mineral deposit. On many occasions, the hydrothermal fluid mentioned above enters and spreads through cavities such as joints, fissures etc. This gives rise to vein minerals in the form of large crystals. Tourmaline, topaz, cassiterite etc. are some of the important vein minerals. In certain cases the hydrothermal fluid intrudes the existing rock bodies and forms a mineral deposit called a replacement mineral deposit. Minerals of lead and zinc are found in such deposits. The process of magmatic differentiation during the formation of intrusive and extrusive igneous bodies gives rise to pyritic deposits containing iron and sulfur. With the magma intrusion, hot gaseous substances flow in the magma mass. As the magma cools these gaseous substances deposit certain minerals, which till then are in a volatile state. The process of formation of such deposits is called pneumatolysis. The most important mineral contained in such deposits is Wolframite. At times, due to different degrees of metamorphism, not all the minerals change their form. In the process some minerals become liquid in their state and easily flow away. What remains is a skeleton of fibrous silicates commonly known as Asbestos. In certain instances, the formations in which metamorphism takes place involve carbon in the form of coal or carbonaceous gases. These get converted into graphite or diamonds. Mineral deposits are also associated with sedimentary rocks. The flow of water in a river may carry minerals of low specific gravity due to the limited velocity of water. Such minerals are mostly silicates. What remains in their place is a mineral mass of high specific gravity. These are called placer deposits. Gold, platinum, antimony etc. are associated with such placer deposits. Sea water contains many dissolved minerals. The proportion of these is about 31 parts per thousand. When sea water enters certain depressions at the time of high tide, it may remain entrapped in the depression for a long time. Evaporation of the water leads to formation of a thin layer of mineral deposit. When the process of such evaporation gets repeated with the next equal high tide the thickness of mineral deposit grows and eventually the deposit acquires a thickness of considerable magnitude. Such deposits are called evaporites. Potash, magnesium, gypsum etc. are associated with such deposits. Laterite is also a form of sedimentary mineral deposit. Laterite deposits are formed in tropical regions in the rainy season. Sediments formed are transported to flat surfaces where they penetrate into the ground. In the dry season some minerals
Book.indb 45
11/22/2010 2:34:17 PM
46
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
containing the leached ions are drawn to the surface of the ground by capillary action. In the next rainy season these minerals are washed away and fresh sediments are redeposited. In this manner higher density minerals remain deep seated and form a large mineral mass. Iron ore or bauxite are the minerals found in such deposits.
3.7
ROCK SPECIMEN PROPERTIES
The objective of blasthole drilling is to drill a hole in the rock at the fastest possible penetration rate, while giving maximum life to the blasthole drill and components like drill bits, drillstring accessories etc. The progress of a blasthole is within a very small cylindrical path in a rock mass. Therefore, when it comes to blasthole drilling, the characteristics of the whole rock mass are less important as compared to the properties of a rock sample or specimen. In the rotary blasthole drilling process, the intact rock at the bottom of the hole is crushed or scraped and chips formed are blown out along with circulating compressed air. If any discontinuities, like joint, fracture etc. are perpendicular to the blasthole alignment they usually help the blasthole drilling process and result in faster penetration rates. However, if they are at an angle with the blasthole alignment and if the strength properties of the rock on two sides of the cracks or joints are far different, the blasthole can deviate from its intended alignment to an unacceptable level. From the standpoint of blasthole drilling, the most important property of intact rock is drillability, and from the viewpoint of blasting it is blastability. Drillability is a complex combination of several factors amongst which engineering properties of the rock specimen play a very important role. Some of these are density, compressive strength, tensile strength, hardness, toughness, brittleness, coefficient of internal friction, and abrasiveness. Drillability is treated in separate chapters in this book but the other engineering properties are briefly dealt with in the following subsections. Since intact rock specimens from different depths are usually obtained in the forms of cores in diamond core drilling, these cylindrical cores are used for most of the tests in a rock testing laboratory. The cores are carefully prepared before testing so that they have appropriate length and diameter. The ends of the test specimens are also carefully cut so the circular surface is exactly perpendicular to the core axis and is in a plane so that the specimen is subjected to uniform load and not point loads. When hard rock cores are to be shaped, diamond tools are used for the shaping. To prevent diamonds from burning, water is used as a coolant. The specimens so prepared are dried before testing. For shaping cores of soft rock that contain clay and other constituents that may be affected by water, tungsten carbide tools are used. Such tools do not require water as a coolant. In order to get truly a representative value of the property, many tests are carried out and the mean value of the property is taken as the correct representation. A few formulae are given in the following elaboration. As these formulae are only for the purpose of understanding the relation of various quantities, no units of measurements have been given for the quantities. In any case these formulae are unified and will give desired results when consistent units for all the terms and appropriate values of the constants in the formulae are used.
Book.indb 46
11/22/2010 2:34:17 PM
Properties of rocks
3.7.1
47
Density
Density of rocks, usually measured in terms of kg/m3 or lb/ft3, is not so important from the viewpoint of formation fracturing, but is of great importance when it comes to flushing. As per Stoke’s law, discussed in one of the later chapters, chips of the rocks with low density, such as shale, coal etc., are bailed out from the blasthole very easily but chips of the rocks with high density such as iron ore, uranium ore etc., are bailed out with relatively great difficulty. Fortunately, the density of rocks is usually within a small range. When the bailing velocity of compressed air is properly selected by use of an appropriate compressor, the penetration rate does not reduce on account of the density of rocks. Densities of many different rocks are given in one of the appendices at the end of the book.
3.7.2
Compressive strength
In plain words, compressive strength means ability to resist compression. When a cylindrical rock sample is subjected to increasing axial compressive force as shown in Figure 3.6, its axial length goes on reducing and at the same time its diameter goes on increasing. Stress exerted on rock sample is calculated as σ = F/A = F/(π ∗ d2/4) The strain that results from the test is calculated as ε = ΔL/L Explanation of the symbols F, d, L is contained in Figure 3.6 itself. At certain values of compressive stress the rock sample fails. Thereafter the compressive strain keeps on increasing even when the axial load is not increased, or in fact even when it is decreased, resulting in unchanged or reduced compressive stress. Eventually, the rock sample crumbles into pieces. The maximum value of stress to which the rock specimen is subjected in such a test process, is called compressive strength. In most of such tests
ΔL
Compression Force F
Original Shape of the Rock Sample is in Gray Color
Top Plate Averaged Shape After Compression L Likely Failure Plane ΔL1
Bottom Plate
Figure 3.6 Uniaxial compression test.
Book.indb 47
11/22/2010 2:34:17 PM
48
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
the rock sample is subjected to compressive pressure only in the axial direction and no pressure is applied on its cylindrical side except the atmospheric pressure. Therefore, the strength is termed as uniaxial compressive strength and abbreviated as UCS. Sometimes UCS is also taken as an acronym of unconfined compressive strength. UCS is measured in the laboratory in a machine that exerts force on the material sample as shown in Figure 3.7. The machine is called a Universal Testing Machine. It consists of special servo-controlled mechanisms for measurements. Rock samples used for the test are usually cylindrical in shape and the circular surfaces of the sample are very carefully polished to avoid point loading. The force exerted on the sample is increased at a certain rate and the material sample eventually fails. Brittle materials, like rock, get crushed into pieces. The compressive strength of the material is calculated by dividing the breaking force by the cross sectional area of the sample. UCS of a dry rock sample is always more than that of a wet rock sample. For some sedimentary rocks the difference is very high. The commonly adopted procedure for determination of UCS is as per American Standard ASTM D2938. Stress-strain curves plotted from the observations of unconfined compression tests on samples of quartzite, hornfels and marble are shown in Figure 3.8. Rock is said to be elastic when the strain is linearly proportional to stress, whereas when the relationship is non linear the rock is called plastic. Quartzite shows perfectly elastic behavior throughout up to a point B, and thereafter shows slightly plastic behavior up to the ultimate compressive strength at point C.
Figure 3.7 Rock core sample being subjected to UCS test.
Book.indb 48
11/22/2010 2:34:17 PM
Properties of rocks
300 B
Stress in MPa
250 200
B1
49
C Quartzite
C1 Hornfels
150 100
2
C2
50
3
Marble
0
10
20 30 40 Strain in mm ×106
50
60
Figure 3.8 Stress strain curves for some rocks.
Since the length of the curve OB is several times longer than the length BC and even the zone BC is only slightly plastic, it is safe to say that quartzite is an elastic rock. Hornfels shows perfectly elastic behavior up to point B1 and thereafter significantly plastic behavior up to the ultimate compressive strength at point C1. Hornfels is considered an elastoplastic rock because the length of plastic zone B1C1 is of significant magnitude as compared to elastic zone OB1 and the plasticity in zone B1C1 is also of considerable magnitude. In the case of marble there is no elastic zone at all. Marble, therefore, is considered a plastic rock. When rock is subjected to compression, failure occurs due to shear stress at an inclined plane as shown in Figure 3.6. Some important properties of rock determined from the readings of uniaxial compression tests are the ‘Modulus of Elasticity’, ‘Modulus of Plasticity’ and ‘Poisson’s Ratio’. If rock shows elastic behavior then the modulus of elasticity within elastic zone is given by the equation E = (σ1 − 0)/(ΔL1 − 0) Modulus of plasticity in the plastic zone is calculated by the equation EPL = (σcom − σ1)/(ΔLcom − ΔL1) The meaning of the symbols used in the above two equation can be easily understood from Figure 3.9. Poisson’s ratio is the ratio of lateral strain to axial strain. In case of Figure 3.6 it equals μ = ΔL1/ΔL
Book.indb 49
11/22/2010 2:34:22 PM
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Stress in MPa
50
C1
σcom B1
σ1
0 0
ΔL1
Strain
ΔLcom
Figure 3.9 Stress strain curves for elastoplastic rocks.
In all the compression or tension tests carried on the rocks, the rate at which stress is applied has a great bearing on the ultimate compressive or tensile strength. All rocks show very high strength when the compressive force is applied rapidly. UCS of rocks has a reasonably good correlation with point load index and shore hardness. Often rock specimens (not rock masses) are classified on the basis of their UCS as indicated by Table 3.11. UCS of some commonly occurring rocks is given in Table 3.12 and also in Appendix 14. A special test, called triaxial compression test, is also sometimes carried out on soft rock samples. In such tests the rock sample is subjected to pressure on the cylindrical side of the sample. The value of compressive strength obtained in triaxial compression tests is higher than the UCS. The triaxial compression test has a far better resemblance of in-situ behavior of the rock, because in actual practice a portion of rock in the alignment of the blasthole is always surrounded by an adjacent portion of rock mass. Such rock mass invariably exerts horizontal pressure on the portion of rock in blasthole alignment. The commonly followed procedure for determination of CS by triaxial compression test is as per American Standard ASTM D2664.
3.7.3 Tensile strength The concept of tensile strength is almost identical to that of compressive strength, but the direction of the axial force acting upon the sample is exactly opposite. Here, as the sample is subjected to increasing tensile force, the diameter of the rock sample goes on reducing and the axial length goes on increasing. Tensile stress and tensile strain are observed in the tests in the same manner as those in compressive stress and strain. At a certain value of tensile stress, the rock sample fails. At this point the rock sample usually breaks apart in the case of elastic rocks. In some rocks, that show high plasticity, the tensile strain keeps on increasing even when the axial force is not increased. The value of the stress at such point is called tensile strength.
Book.indb 50
11/22/2010 2:34:22 PM
Properties of rocks
51
Table 3.11 Rock classification on the basis of unconfined compressive strength. Uniaxial compressive strength in MPa
Point load Schmidt index in hardness by MPa L – hammer
Method of strength in the field
R5 – Extremely >250 Strong
>10
50–60
R4 – Very Strong
100–250
4–10
40–50
R3 – Strong
50–100
2–4
30–40
R2 – Medium Strong
25–50
1–2
15–30
R1 – Weak
5–25
–
<15
R0 – Very Weak
1–5
–
–
Extremely Weak
0.25–1
–
–
Rock material only chipped under repeated hammer blows Requires many blows of a geological hammer to break intact rock specimens Hand held specimens broken by a single blow of a geological hammer Firm blow with geological pick indents rock to 5 mm, knife just scrapes surface Knife cuts material but too hard to shape into triaxial specimens Material crumbles under firm blows of geological pick, can be scraped with knife Indented by thumbnail
Class
Examples of rocks in the class Fresh Basalt, Chert, Diabase, Gneiss, Granite, Quartzite Amphibolite, Sandstone, Basalt, Gabbro, Gneiss, Granodiorite Limestone, Marble, Phyllite, Sandstone, Schist, Shale Claystone, Coal, Concrete, Schist, Shale, Siltstone
Chalk, Rocksalt, Potash
Highly Weathered or Altered Rock
Clay Gouge
Unlike metals, where the compressive strength and tensile strength have comparable values, for most rocks the tensile strength has a much lower value than that of compressive strength. When the ratio of compressive to tensile strength is higher, the rock is more brittle. Tensile strength σTP of a rock sample is determined indirectly by a test, often called the ‘Brazilian Tensile Strength’ test and abbreviated as ITS. In ITS a rock sample having core diameter d and length L is subjected to a load as shown in Figure 3.10. The length L of the rock sample used for the test must not be more than 2 times its diameter d. The diameter d must also be larger than 22 mm. If the rock sample breaks at point load FP then the point load tensile strength is taken as σTP = 2 ∗ FP/(π ∗ L ∗ d)
Book.indb 51
11/22/2010 2:34:23 PM
52
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Table 3.12 Range of UCS of some common rocks. UCS range Rock name
App. MPa
psi
Diorite Gabbro Granite Andesite Basalt Rhyolite Trachyte Dolomite Limestone Conglomerate Sandstone Shale Gneiss Marble Quartzite Schist Slate Taconite
170–300 260–350 200–350 300–400 250–400 120–130 330–350 150–170 120–130 140–150 160–260 60–75 140–300 100–200 160–220 60–400 150–160 300–600
24500–43500 37500–50500 29000–50500 50500–58000 36000–58000 17500–19000 47500–50500 21500–24500 17500–18500 20500–21500 23000–37500 8500–11000 20500–43500 14500–29000 23000–32900 8500–58000 21500–23500 24500–87000
Measurements in the ITS test are done by an electronic servo-controlled machine. The procedure for the ITS test is given in ASTM D3967. Particular attention must be given to the placement of the sample in the ITS test when the rock samples are layered. In such rocks the tensile strength across the layers can be far higher than that along the layers.
3.7.4
Hardness
Hardness means resistance of a substance to penetration by another hard substance. Rock is composed of many minerals. Every mineral has a specific value of hardness, but due to differences in the percentages of minerals, the hardness of the same type of rocks differs within a certain range. Different scales for measuring hardness of materials exist. The basis on which these scales are formulated also differ. Appendix 8 at the end of this book presents a table for converting hardness from one scale to the other. Hardness is measured by many different types of tests, each using specific types of testing machines. Therefore, the value of hardness pertains to a specific hardness scale. For rock samples the most commonly used scales and tests for hardness are: Shore Rebound Hardness Vickers Indention Hardness Knoop Indention Hardness.
Book.indb 52
11/22/2010 2:34:23 PM
Properties of rocks
53
Figure 3.10 Brazilian tensile strength test setup.
3.7.4.1
Shore hardness
The apparatus used for this test was originally made by the Shore Instrument and Manufacturing Company. The instrument is called a scleroscope, hence the hardness is often called scleroscope hardness. The apparatus consists of a steel rod i.e. ‘Hammer’
Book.indb 53
11/22/2010 2:34:23 PM
54
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
having a diamond tip at one of its ends. This end is allowed to fall freely under gravity from a fixed height onto the polished surface of the material to be tested. After the impact the hammer rebounds freely. From several readings of the rebound height an average height of rebound is calculated. The hardness of the rock sample is determined by correlating the average rebound height with a chart made for the purpose. 3.7.4.2
Vickers hardness
In the Vickers hardness test a square-shaped diamond pyramid mounted on the tip of a rod is pushed into the polished surface of the rock sample with pre-adjusted force. The area of the indention made by the diamond is measured through a microscope. The hardness of the rock is then determined by correlating the measured area with a chart. Values of hardness of some important minerals are given in Table 3.13. Range of Vickers hardness values for some rocks are given in Table 3.14.
3.7.5 Toughness Toughness means resistance of the material to propagation of cracks. Tough rocks like basalt are difficult to break but may not have very high hardness. Toughness y, of rocks is calculated by the equation, y = (E/EPL) ∗ σcom where E = Modulus of elasticity EPL = Modulus of plasticity σcom = Unconfined compressive strength
3.7.6
Brittleness
Brittleness refers to relative ease of the material in its disintegration under impact loads. Highly brittle materials like glass break suddenly. Brittleness of rocks is evaluated by a test called the Impact Test. For the impact test, a sample of crushed rock is first sieved through a sieve with square openings of 16 mm. Pieces retained on the sieve are rejected. Pieces passing through the 16 mm sieve are further sieved through a sieve with square openings of 11.2 mm. From the aggregate retained on the 11.2 mm sieve about 0.5 kg sample is selected for the test. From this sample rock pieces without cracks are used for the test. The exact weight of the sample W1 is recorded. The sample is then put into a steel container having very thick walls. A heavy steel piece is then placed on the sample and it is subjected to impacts by a 14 kg weight falling through 25 cm height. The set up is shown in Figure 3.11. After 20 blows of the falling weight on the rock sample, the sample is carefully removed and again sieved through a sieve having 11.2 mm square opening. The weight of the sample retained on the sieve W2 is again recorded. The S20 value, which is an indicator of brittleness of rock, is calculated as S20 = 100 ∗ (W1 − W2)/W1
Book.indb 54
11/22/2010 2:34:30 PM
Properties of rocks
55
Table 3.13 Hardness values for some minerals. Hardness values on different scales Mineral name
Chemical composition
Vickers
Knoop
Rosiwal
Corundum Quartz Garnet Olivine Hematite Pyrite Plagioclase Diopside Magnetite Orthoclase Augite Ilmenite Hiperstene Hornblende Chromite Apatite Dolomite Pyrrhotite Fluorite Pentlandite Sphalerite Chalcopyrite Serpentine Anhydrite Calcite Biotite Galena Chalcocite Chlorite Gypsum Talc Halite Sylvite
Al2O3 SiO2 Silicates of Fe-Mg-Al-Mn-Ca-Cr (Mg, Fe)2SiO4 Fe2O3 FeS2 (Na, Ca)(Al,Si) AlSi2O8 CaMdSi2O6 Fe3O4 KAlSi3O8 Ca(Mg, Fe, Al)(Al, Si)2O6 FeTiO3 (Mg, Fe)SiO3 NaCa2(Mg, Fe, Al)5(Al, Si)8O22 (Mg, Fe)Cr2O4 Ca5(PO4)3(F, Cl, OH) CaMg(CO3)2 Fe1-XS CaF2 (Fe, Ni)9S8 (Zn, Fe)S CuFeS2 Mg6Si4O10(OH)8 CaSO4 CaCO3 K(Mg, Fe)3(AlSi3O10)(OH)2 PbS Cu2S (Mg, Fe, Al)6(Al, Si)4O10(OH)8 CaSO4 · 2H2O Mg3Si4O10(OH)2 NaCl KCl
2300 1060 1060 980 925 800 800 800 730 730 640 625 600 600 600 550 365 310 265 220 200 195 175 160 125 110 85 65 50 50 20 17 10
1700 790
1000 141
3.7.7
395
7.3
85
4.08
32 12
0.85 0.82
Coefficient of internal friction
The coefficient of internal friction of a rock is an indicator of resistance to the sliding of two rock particles or pieces with respect to each other in a state where their surfaces are in contact with each other.
Book.indb 55
11/22/2010 2:34:30 PM
56
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Table 3.14 Vicker’s hardness for some rocks. Rock type
Vickers hardness
Amphibolite Andesite Anorthosite Basalt Black Shale Chromite Cooper Ores Diabase/Dolerite Diorite Epidotite Gabbro Gneiss Granite/Granite Gneiss Granodiorite Granulite/Leptite Green Schist Greenstone Hornfels Limestone Marble Metadiabase Metagabbro Micagneiss Micaschist Nickel Ores Norite Porphyrite Pyrite Ores Phyllite Quartzite Rhyolite Sandstone Serpentinite Shale/Silstone Skarn Sphalite Ores Tonalite Tuffite
500–750 550–775 600–800 450–750 300–525 400–610 350–775 525–825 525–775 800–850 525–775 650–925 725–925 725–925 725–925 625–750 525–625 600–825 125–350 125–250 500–750 450–775 500–825 375–750 300–550 575–725 550–850 500–1450 400–700 900–1060 775–925 550–1060 100–300 200–750 450–750 200–850 725–925 150–850
When rock breaks, the particles formed in the process always tend to slide along each other until they reach a stable condition. In situations such as calculations of the stability of a slope and calculations of the volume of the heaps formed by dumped material etc., the coefficient of internal friction gains importance.
Book.indb 56
11/22/2010 2:34:30 PM
Properties of rocks
57
14 kg Weight
250 mm Fall
Guide
Aggregate
Container
Bottom Plate
Figure 3.11 Impact test for brittleness of rocks.
3.7.8
Swell factor
When intact rock, having volume V is broken, and the gross volume V1 of such broken pieces is measured, it is observed that V1 is larger than V. This increase in volume, called ‘Swelling’, results from the voids created by the haphazard placement of the broken pieces. The swell factor, SF, is measured in % and is given by the formula: SF = 100 ∗ (V1 − V)/V This factor is very important in calculations for the transportation of the blasted rock because blasted rock is always in swollen conditions.
3.7.9
Abrasiveness
Abrasiveness of a rock means the property of the rock to wear out (by friction) metal tools used for drilling or cutting. It is measured by any of the three tests viz. 1 2 3
Cerchar Abrasiveness Test Miniature Drill Test Bit Ware Index Test These tests are described in following paragraphs.
3.7.9.1
Cerchar abrasiveness test
The tool used for testing abrasiveness of rock is made from steel having a compressive strength of 200 kgf/mm2. The tip of the pin has a conical shape with cone angle
Book.indb 57
11/22/2010 2:34:30 PM
58
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
of 90°. In the test this tip is placed on a carefully prepared, polished, plane surface of the rock sample with a piercing force of 7 kgf. The rock sample is then made to move over a distance of 10 mm in one second. The diameter of wear flat created at the tip is carefully measured in mm. Coating the pin tips with machinist’s blue dye prior to testing, makes the wear flat more visible. This procedure is repeated five times on a fresh surface of the rock sample that is undisturbed by the first scratch. A new pin is used every time. The whole procedure is repeated on 3 to 5 samples of the same rock. Cerchar Abrasivity Index, CAI, is then calculated by the equation: CAI = (10 ∗ Σdwearflat)/N where N = The number of observations d = Wearflat diameter in micrometers A schematic of the apparatus used for the Cerchar Abrasiveness Test is shown in Figure 3.12. CAI values for some rocks are given in Table 3.15. Tests carried out on many rock samples have shown that for most of the rocks having a CAI more than 0.7, there exists a correlation between CAI and Vickers hardness as indicated by the following equation. VH = 145 ∗ CAI 3.7.9.2
Miniature drill test
The miniature drill test actually simulates drag bit drilling on the rock sample.
Pull Handle
7 Kg Weight Hinge Steel Pin With 90° Apex Angle Limiting Screw
Rock Sample
Bench Vise Limiting Block
Figure 3.12 Apparatus for cerchar abrasiveness test.
Book.indb 58
11/22/2010 2:34:31 PM
Properties of rocks
59
Table 3.15 CAI for some common rocks. Rock type
C AI value
Basalt Diabase Andesite Diorite/Syenite Granite Limestone Sandstone1 Sandstone2 Phyllite Mica Schist Mica Gneiss Felsic Gneiss Amphibolite Quartzite
1.7–5.2 3.8–5.4 1.8–3.5 3.0–5.6 3.7–6.2 0.1–2.4 0.1–2.6 2.3–6.2 1.3–4.3 1.8–5.0 1.8–5.0 3.7–6.3 2.8–3.7 4.8–7.3
The test setup is as shown in Figure 3.13. The rock sample used for the miniature drill test is of the size and shape of a brick commonly used in building construction. The sample is firmly held by clamps on the upper head of the testing machine as shown in the figure. The upper head assembly can freely move up and down in the slider tubes when its holding brake is released. By suitably adding weight on this head, the total weight of the head together with the brick sample, is made equal to 20 kg. Thus, a constant bit weight of 20 kg is used for drilling. A drill bit made from tungsten carbide, with a tip width of 8.5 mm and tip angle of 110°, is used in the test for drilling into the sample. The drill bit is fixed in the low speed rotation motor, adjusted to run between 175 to 200 rpm speed, with its tip pointing upwards as shown. Since the bit drills into the sample in an upward direction, the cuttings formed in the process of drilling fall down under gravity without any need for a flushing device. When the drill head assembly is lowered, the tip of the drill bit touches rock surface. At this point the rotation electric motor is rotated at a constant low speed to create a hole in the rock sample. A revolution counter on the test apparatus continuously indicates the number of revolutions made by the drill bit. When the drill bit makes 200 revolutions the drilling is stopped. The depth of the hole is measured correctly to 1/10th of a millimeter with the help of a vernier caliper. The SJ value for the rock equals 10 times the average depth found in the series of eight tests. To get a realistic reading of the SJ value for the rock, care must be taken to drill holes parallel to the rock foliation. In the case of coarse grained rocks, holes have to be drilled in all the grain types.
Book.indb 59
11/22/2010 2:34:32 PM
60
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
8.5 mm 110 g
Rock Sample
Chuck Guide
Tungsten carbide drill bit
Guide 175−200 RPM
Figure 3.13 Miniature drill test.
Figure 3.14 Abrasion value test.
3.7.9.3
Bit wear test
The set up of the test used for evaluating the abrasion value of a rock is shown in Figure 3.14. In this test a piece of tungsten carbide, having the dimensions as shown in the magnified view of the bit in Figure 3.14, and having a Vickers hardness value of 1300 is used. The weight of the piece is carefully measured before starting the test. Crushed powder of the rock to be tested is continuously fed on a rotating disc at a feed rate of 80 g/min through a vibrating feeder. The drill bit is pressed on the powder with a force of 10 kg. The rock powder is sucked by a vacuum sucker after it has passed underneath the bit, so that any tungsten carbide powder separated from the bit and mixed with the rock powder is not used for further grinding of the bit in the next revolution. The disc is rotated at 20 rpm for 5 minutes. The abrasion value of the rock in the test is the loss of bit weight in mg. The test is repeated 8 times and the average weight loss is taken as the abrasion value for the rock.
Book.indb 60
11/22/2010 2:34:32 PM
Chapter 4
Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling
4.1
INTRODUCTION
Blasthole drilling, as we see it today, has developed through need. For centuries past, the needs have been ever increasing, and in the future also the trend will continue to increase. The existence of water and minerals in the ground was known even in the prehistoric era. Wells were dug for extraction of water that percolated into them. When pumping water from small diameter holes became possible, the need for drilling deep holes to access the deep-seated water sources was felt. The percussion drilling method was used for water wells for over two thousand years till the recent past. Even metals have been known to the human race for more than seven thousand years. Ore, needed for making metals, was excavated from the surface mineral deposits by hand digging methods as late as the beginning of the seventeenth century. Georgius Agricola, the first of the great engineers of modern times, wrote his treatise ‘De Re Metallica’. It was published it in 1556. The work extensively dealt with the mining practice of those days and contained many woodcut illustrations. Many devices, such as windlass, hoist, horse power etc., are shown in the book, but there are no references to drilling holes or blasting techniques. As the book was meant to cover mining, it can be inferred that drilling was not carried out in the mining practice of those days.
4.2
ERA OF SHOT HOLE DRILLING
A shot hole means a blasthole of small diameter. Gunpowder was known to the Chinese as early as the ninth century. The technique of manufacturing gunpowder became known to the Europeans only in the eleventh century. ‘De Mirabili Potestate Artis et Nature’ written by Roger Bacon, published in 1242, gives details about the destructive power of gunpowder and a formula for making it. For many centuries the use of gun powder was restricted to war equipment like bombs, guns, cannons etc. The concept of drilling holes in rock, filling them with gunpowder and blasting them was first proposed in 1617 by Martin Weigel, a mining superintendent at Frieberg, Germany. Casper Windt is said to have used this concept successfully in 1623 at a German town Schemitz.
Book.indb 61
11/22/2010 2:34:34 PM
62
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
One of the earliest articles that appeared on holes for the purpose of blasting was authored by Sir Richard Morey in the Philosophical Transactions of Royal Society in the year 1665. He described Monsieur Du Son’s method of rock blasting, along with the illustration of piercer – a drilling rod etc. His article reads, “… There is a tool of iron well steeled at the end, which cuts the rock 20 or 22 inches long or more and some 2.25 inch diameter at the steeled end the rest being somewhat more slender. The angle at the end is so shaped as to make it most apt to pierce the rock. The tool is to be held by hand in the place of the hole … so one may manage hammer while the other holds the tool … after the stroke of the hammer he that holds the piercer, is to turn it a little on its point so that edges at the point may strike all upon new surface … till the hole is 20 to 22 inch deep …” Sir Richard Morey further goes on to explain the method of stemming the hole and blasting it. Drilling deeper holes for prospecting became necessary with the increasing demand for minerals, particularly coal. On several occasions the depth of the holes for coal prospecting exceeded 6 m. For reaching this depth the idea of joining the drilling rods by means of screwed ends was born. The author of ‘Compleat Collier’, published in 1708, described the method used for exploration holes as, “… We have two labourers at a time, at the handle of the bore and they chop or pounce with their hands up and down to cut the stone or mineral, going round, which of course grinds them small so that finding your rod to have cut down four or six inches they lift up the rod, either all at once, as there conveniency for its lifts or by joynts fixing the key which is to keep the rods from falling down into the hole … taking off the cutting chisel, put or screw on the wimble or scoop which takes of the cut stuff be it what happens; and so by sight of the stuff … and so what consequently follows at any depth; for by addition of the joynts (which we screw on to the rod) we can decend to any depth”. Blasthole drilling became a faster process when two men hammered the ‘piercer’, and even faster when iron rods with chisel ends were initiated in Hungary in 1749. The idea of dropping some weight on a fixed steel bar was first put into practical use by Huthmann in 1683. In his ‘boring machine’ the weight was raised by a rope that was repeatedly pulled and released by two men. Similar machines with some differences were also later developed by Barthels in 1721 and still later by Gainsbrigg in 1803. The dawn of the industrial revolution began in Europe in the late eighteenth century. Activities in virtually every field increased on a very large scale. Many needs and consequent inventions, discoveries etc., directly or indirectly affected blasthole drilling technology. Some of the affecting factors were: 1
Book.indb 62
Electric detonators had been invented in 1829 by Moses Shaw in New York. In 1831, William Bickford of Tuckingmill in England invented the safety fuse. Both these inventions made blasting operations far less dangerous as compared to the earlier practice of using black gunpowder for blasting where frequent premature explosions occurred.
11/22/2010 2:34:34 PM
Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling
2 3
4 5
6
63
Use of positive displacement steam engines entered mining activities by the end of eighteenth century. Initially steam power was deployed for winches and haulage. Nitroglycerine was developed by Sobrero in 1847. It was far more powerful and devastating than black powder but very dangerous as it exploded with even slight frictional heat. Dynamite developed by Noble in 1866 was equally powerful but far less dangerous. The use of these explosives made it possible to dramatically increase mine productivity and advance rates in tunnels. Construction of many canals began in the first few decades of the nineteenth century. These projects needed excavation in rock where blasting was essential. Invention of the steam locomotive resulted in the laying of railways tracks in Europe, USA and many other countries, as a mean of quick transport. Construction of tunnels was needed to avoid long loops of railway tracks in the hilly regions. Use of compressed air for ventilation in tunnels was practiced in the early 1830s. As the heavy steam boilers could not be taken into tunnels, and as the steam quickly condensed in longer pipes, the use of compressed air instead of steam was introduced for power transmission. In 1844 Brunton suggested the use of compressed air for powering a rock drill and named it the ‘Wind Hammer’.
With all these and many other factors the demand for metals increased exponentially. To cope with such increased demand, drilling larger and deeper blastholes became essential. As the limitations of manual drilling were recognized, the introduction of mechanization in drilling was thought to be the best alternative. Efforts were made in that direction from the early nineteenth century. 4.3
ROTARY DRILLING
The origins of rotary drilling go back to nearly two thousand years before Christ. The earliest proof of human beings drilling holes in stones can be found in the quarries made for extraction of stone blocks for pyramids in Egypt. Holes as deep as 6 m and as large as 500 mm diameter were drilled in those days. Cores of basalt and obsidian, recovered from some of these quarries and kept in pyramids, have now been preserved in some of the well-known museums in the world. The length of some of these cores is as much as 500 mm. A closer examination of the cores indicates helical grooves on the outer surface of the cores. This leads to the conclusion that the drilling method employed must have been very similar to the calyx drilling, which is still practiced in developing countries as a labor intensive low cost form of core drilling. An artist’s impression, based on limited evidence and estimates, indicated that the assembly used by the Egyptians for drilling might have been like the one shown in Figure 4.1. Due to the primitive techniques used in those days the drilling speed was very slow in such rotary drilling. Hence rotary drilling was hardly ever used for drilling holes in the ground. Some references to rotary drilling being used for drilling water wells are found in France in the early eighteenth century. Until the end of the nineteenth century mines were small. In fact larger excavation activities were in the civil engineering domain. Even though the steam excavator was
Book.indb 63
11/22/2010 2:34:34 PM
64
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Figure 4.1 An Egyptian drill, 2000 BC.
invented by Otis in 1838, only a few of them were available to companies other than the manufacturer. Thus, the loading of blasted material into rail transport wagons was done manually. For this reason blastholes used to be of small diameter and shallow depth so they yielded small size fragments suitable for manual operation. In terms of their spacing and depth, blastholes differ radically from the holes drilled for oilwells and waterwells. It was, therefore, obvious that unless the heavy drilling mechanisms required for rotary drilling could become portable, the rotary drilling could not be used for blasthole drilling. The idea of introducing portability in large hole drilling machines was conceived way back in the 1860s, and the earliest portable machine appeared in 1867. It was said that this earliest rotary drilling machine was built by Henry Kelly – the founder of Kelly, Morgan and Company. For his efforts in reviving the rotary drilling method, Kelly is still remembered by his name given to the specialized drill rod with three or more grooves, alternately square or hexagonal in cross section, with which it is possible to impart rotation to the drill string. Kelly, Morgan and Company later became Armstrong Quam Company in 1904 and merged in 1933 with Bucyrus Erie Company, now known as Bucyrus International, Inc. Kelly apparently did not take a patent. His idea of portability was used by others, and the first portable percussion drilling machine of which there is a record was patented by Nelson in 1871. This is shown in Figure 4.2. During the 1870s and 1880s many manufacturers built portable cable tool drilling rigs. R. M. Downie was the first. The drill made by Downie is shown in Figure 4.3. In this drill the tripod type mast was not a part of the drill. A drill with built-in mast was developed by Downie during the early 1890s. The first such machine is shown
Book.indb 64
11/22/2010 2:34:34 PM
Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling
65
Figure 4.2 Nelson’s portable cable tool drill, 1871.
Figure 4.3 Downie’s portable cable tool drill, 1880.
Book.indb 65
11/22/2010 2:34:35 PM
66
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
in Figure 4.4. The trade name of these rigs was ‘Keystone’. Originally such rigs were made for drilling oil wells, but soon they were deployed for blasthole drilling. Spudder was a very common name for such percussion blasthole drills. One of the earliest all-steel spudder made by Armstrong is shown in Figure 4.5. First major project to use spudders was the construction of the Panama Canal. It began in 1904 and was completed in 1914. The authorities of the project initially purchased sample drills from twelve manufacturers and eventually purchased 218 drills made by Star Drilling Co. for the project. The other manufacturers of spudders in those days were Armstrong, Keystone, Austin and Columbia. An early self-propelled percussion blasthole drill on wheels was developed by Armstrong in 1917. One of these drills is shown in Figure 4.6.
Figure 4.4 Downie portable drill with A-frame mast, 1892.
Figure 4.5 Armstrong tow type churn blasthole drill, 1915.
Book.indb 66
11/22/2010 2:34:37 PM
Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling
67
Figure 4.6 Armstrong self propelled churn blasthole drill, 1922.
Figure 4.7 Keystone churn drill with crawler tracks, 1933.
Crawlers were first developed for farm tractors by Benjamin Holt in 1904. They were very successful in slushy ground. Soon their potential in moving on rough ground was also realized and machines used in mines were mounted on crawler tracks. They were termed churn drills. One such churn drill, made by Keystone in the late 1920s, with crawlers on the drilling side of the machine is shown in Figure 4.7.
Book.indb 67
11/22/2010 2:34:38 PM
68
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Churns, as shown in Figure 4.8, were used in many mines till the mid 1950s, when their use sharply declined as rotary blasthole drills for large diameter blastholes were developed. For drilling in extremely hard and tough rocks, a drilling method, called ‘Jet Piercing’, that worked on the principle of thermal fragmentation, was also used successfully in some mines. These drills were jointly developed by Union Carbide and Bucyrus Erie in the early 1950s. A typical jet piercing drill looked like the one shown in Figure 4.9. It could give a penetration rate of the order of 5 to 6 m in an hour and required 170 kg fuel oil and 567 kg oxygen per hour. This method also was discarded in the early 1960s, after the newly developed tungsten carbide inserted tricone bits made it possible to drill large blastholes in hard rocks at much lower expense and in a far safer way.
Figure 4.8 Churn drills in a mine, 1937.
Book.indb 68
11/22/2010 2:34:39 PM
Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling
69
Figure 4.9 Jet piercing drill of Russian origin.
Hard rock rotary drilling became possible after Sharp and Hughes developed the rolling cutter rock bit in the year 1909. It looked like the one shown in Figure 4.10. In the year 1912 the two cones of the bits were replaced by three cones. This wonderful tool gave tenfold faster penetration rates in hard formations as compared to the drag
Book.indb 69
11/22/2010 2:34:43 PM
70
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Figure 4.10 Sharp and Hughes two cone bit, 1909.
Figure 4.11 Moving rotary head in a patent filed by Ross, 1891.
Book.indb 70
11/22/2010 2:34:44 PM
Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling
71
bits used till then. In 1925, with the invention of intermeshing cones, the two cone rock bits became acceptable in the oilwell drilling industry. By the second world war, rotary drilling was a standard method used in oil well drilling. The original idea of a moving drill head is quite old as can be seen from Figure 4.11 that represents a sketch from Ross’s patent of 1891. Such mechanisms were used for oilwell drilling rigs, where the tall derricks enabled use of a long drill string. Heavy drill collars were used right at the beginning for exerting a heavy weight on the tricone drill bit.
4.4
ROTARY BLASTHOLE DRILLING
The first use of rotary blasthole drilling was way back in the year 1865. The excavation of Mont Cenis Tunnel in the Alps, that joins French and Italian railways, began in the year 1854. Initially the work progressed at such a slow pace that the completion of the tunnel was expected only after about 40 years. Low drilling speed was the bottleneck in completing the tunnel quickly. As an attempt to increase the speed of drilling, a French engineer named Leschot, working on the project from the French side, developed a drill and a bit studded with diamonds to drill blastholes in the hard rock along the alignment of the tunnel in the year 1863. This drill could drill holes of diameter 50 to 75 mm. The patent drawing of the drill and the diamond bit in the form of a core barrel is shown in Figure 4.12. When both these devices were used together, the speed of drilling increased greatly but was still much less than expected. Drilling with the diamond bit and the drill was soon abandoned because the percussion drill, developed by Sommiller and being used on the Italian side of the tunnel, gave a much faster penetration rate. Thereafter, till today, diamond core drilling is rarely used for drilling blastholes, but the potential of this rotary drilling method was recognized in the USA as early as 1876. A huge steam driven diamond drill, shown in Figure 4.13, was exhibited in the Centennial Exhibition of Philadelphia State. Today, a greatly improved form of diamond drilling is very extensively used for oilwell drilling. Often blastholes are required to be drilled in hard rock right from the top of the ground surface. The heavy feed force necessary for such drilling cannot be generated by using heavy drill collars with a large, tall derrick that poses a problem in mobility. In the second half of the 1940s the problem was solved by as many as three manufacturers each in a different manner. In the late 1890s some manufacturers started making self-propelled rotary drilling rigs. These were made for exploratory drilling. One of the earliest rotary drills, made by Austin Manufacturing Company, is shown in Figure 4.14. In 1946 the Joy Manufacturing Company, a successor of Sullivan Machinery Company, introduced the first crawler-mounted rotary blasthole drill. This drill used a tricone bit rotated by a Kelly drill rod and rotary table mechanism. Water was used as a circulating fluid. The feed force required on the tricone bit was exerted through a chain pulldown mechanism. The water which accumulated in the blastholes was removed by lowering a pipe to the bottom of the hole and flushing the hole with compressed air.
Book.indb 71
11/22/2010 2:34:46 PM
72
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Figure 4.12 Drawing of the diamond drill and diamond studded core barrel submitted for second patent by Leschot in 1869.
The idea of the use of rotary drilling for blastholes worked well and many Joy blasthole drills were deployed in mines. In 1949 a mud pump on one of the blasthole drills working on the site of Michigan Limestone Co. failed and could not be repaired or replaced quickly. The company experimented with compressed air instead of water for a flushing medium. The results of this innovation were very encouraging. Very fast penetration rates could be achieved but the damage to the bearings of the tricone bits was excessive. Hughes Tool Company joined the drilling program and noticed that bit failure resulted from inadequate cooling of the bit bearings. They soon developed a tricone bit where compressed air was passed through passages made around the bearings. The idea worked and rotary drilling was established in blasthole drilling practice in 1949, with model 56BH made by Joy Manufacturing Company. This 56BH blasthole drill featured air circulation to the tricone rock bits through its drill string. The drill string was rotated through a rotary table, very much like the rotary table used in the oil well drilling industry. This drill is illustrated in Figure 4.15. The use of a Kelly in the drill was a limiting factor. Adding drill pipes to the drill string was rather difficult due to the presence of a Kelly and hence drilling deeper holes was very cumbersome.
Book.indb 72
11/22/2010 2:34:46 PM
Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling
73
Figure 4.13 Sullivan P2 diamond core drill, 1876.
Figure 4.14 Self propelled rotary drill by Austin manufacturing company, 1903.
Book.indb 73
11/22/2010 2:34:47 PM
74
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Figure 4.15 Joy 56BH blasthole drill, 1946.
Joy 56BH was acceptable for shallow blastholes of about 10 m depth, but for matching the excavation capabilities of some large draglines and stripping shovels the need was for 250 mm diameter blastholes of more than 30 m depth. Bucyrus Erie Co., which enjoyed a very large market share for their churn drills, anticipated a challenge from the rotary drilling method and soon started developing a rotary drill. In 1949, they developed a drill where a drill head mounted on the top of a frame was pulled down by means of hydraulic cylinders as shown in Figure 4.16. The prototype never made it to the worksite, probably because Bucyrus anticipated something far better. In 1950 Wendell Reich developed a crawler-mounted blasthole drill with a moving rotary head driven by hydraulic motor. It was pulled up and down by a hydraulic cylinder and wire rope mechanism. These blasthole drills, due to their compressed air circulation arrangements, became quite popular and were used for drilling 150 to 165 mm blastholes in hard formations. In 1951 Bucyrus Erie Company developed a heavy crawler mounted blasthole drill model 50R and introduced it in practice in 1952. In the 50R the drill string was rotated by a top drive rotary head. This rotary head was moved up and down through a wire rope wrapped around a shipper shaft drum. It could be used for drilling blastholes of diameters up to 311 mm to depths of 39.5 m with a carousel for holding four drill pipes. Unlike Joy and Reich the Bucyrus drill was all electric. The only hydraulic actuators in the drill were the hydraulic leveling jacks. Figure 4.17 shows an early 50R drill. Electric drives used for other mechanisms offered extreme reliability in the machine. As the blasthole diameters possible with the 50R were most suitable for the production rates needed to match large shovels and draglines, the 50R became very popular. Soon smaller drills viz. 30R and 40R were added to the Bucyrus Erie lineup.
Book.indb 74
11/22/2010 2:34:50 PM
Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling
75
Figure 4.16 Earliest version of Bucyrus rotary blasthole drill, 1949.
The extreme wear resistance and hardness of Tungsten Carbide (TC) inserts used for detachable bits was known from the field use of top hammer drilling. By taking a clue from such use, Morlan, Scott and Wood of Hughes Tool Company developed a tungsten carbide inserted tricone bit in 1951. It was initially called ‘Chert Bit’. As the bit did not have sharp teeth, like all the steel bits used to have till then, drillers doubted the capabilities of the new bit. However, to everyone’s surprise the Chert Bit gave almost the same penetration rate under the same operating conditions, and gave 3 to 10 times longer life. Soon, in 1959, chert bits with air circulation arrangements were also made for blasthole drilling. Today, TC inserted tricone bits are used in most hard rock blasthole drilling all over the world. Loss in electric power transmission is very low as compared to the equivalent hydraulic system. Thus, under most circumstances an all-electric drill is likely to be more efficient and reliable, but with high pressure hydraulics and improved components the difference has dwindled. For this reason the use of electric power for driving the components of rotary blasthole drills has now remained confined to very large blasthole drills. The decade of the 1960s saw a sudden spurt in demand for energy and metals. This resulted in an exponential increase in coal and metal mining activities in the USA and other parts of the world. The demand for rotary blasthole drills was so high that several companies started the manufacture of rotary blasthole drills. Leswell’s article published in 1977 lists as many as 12 manufacturers from the USA. Some of them like Portadrill, Davey/Rousselle made only truck-mounted rotary blasthole drills and eventually went out of the race because blasthole drilling work always looked for sturdy crawler mounting.
Book.indb 75
11/22/2010 2:34:50 PM
Figure 4.17 Bucyrus Erie 50R introduced in 1952.
Book.indb 76
11/22/2010 2:34:51 PM
Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling
77
Many manufacturers use hydraulic power rather than electric for small, medium and large drills and even the stubborn supporters of electric now use hydraulic power for driving the propel motors of their very large electric drills. Rotary blasthole drills can be divided into four classes, on the basis of the Feed Force (FF) they can exert on the drilling bit, as follows: Small Medium Large Extra Large
(100 kN < FF < 225 kN), (226 kN < FF < 350 kN), (351 kN < FF < 500 kN), and (FF > 501 kN)
Today, in 2010, rotary blasthole drills are being made by many companies spread over many countries. A broad idea of their product range is shown by Table 4.1. In the late 1970s the list of manufacturers of rotary blasthole drills included Atlas Copco, Bucyrus Erie, Chicago Pneumatics, Driltech, Gardner Denver, Hausherr, Ingersoll Rand, Joy Robbins, Marion, Reedrill, Rudgormash and Schramm. The manufacture of rotary blasthole drills is not a very lucrative business. Many companies built rotary blasthole drills in the past, but very limited demand for the product has forced them either to close or sell the manufacturing rights and lose their identity. Bucyrus kept their leadership in large rotary blasthole drills virtually till the end of the last millennium, through acquisition of Marion. In the meanwhile in 2003 Atlas Copco, well known all over the world for their top hammer and down-the-hole hammer drills acquired and amalgamated the Ingersoll Rand drilling equipment line with their percussion and DTH drill line. With this move they seem to have overtaken Bucyrus. However, Bucyrus have recently
Table 4.1 Rotary blasthole drill manufacturers and their range. Manufacturing range
Book.indb 77
Manufacturer
Country of mfg.
Small
Medium
Large
E. large
Atlas Copco Bucyrus Intl. Changsha Keda CMCL Emico Elecon Globe Drill Hausherr Heavy Eng. Corp. KLR LMP Precision NKMZ P&H Mining Revathi Equipment Rudgormash Sandvik Driltech
USA USA China India Australia Germany India India India USSR USA India USSR USA
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes
Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes
Yes
11/22/2010 2:34:51 PM
78
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
countered this move by acquiring Terex Mining who, about three years ago had acquired and amalgamated Reedrill. Whether Bucyrus regain their leadership is yet to be seen. Other major players in large rotary blasthole drills are P&H Mining with inheritance from Robbins and Gardner Denver, and Sandvik with inheritance from Driltech. Very heavy machines, weighing more than 150,000 kg and capable of exerting bit loads more than 550 kN are now being manufactured by Bucyrus International, P&H Mining and Atlas Copco. Some of them can drill 20 m deep holes of diameters in excess of 406 mm in one single pass. The largest amongst these is the Bucyrus International 59HR that weighs up to 193,000 kg, can exert a bit load up to 734 kN and is rated for drilling blastholes of 445 mm diameter. It is shown in Figure 4.18. Most of the manufacturers mentioned above are of US origin, but the Russians had also independently developed electric blasthole drills for drilling blastholes of 320 mm diameter to 32 m depth some forty years back. They are often found in East European and some other Asian countries. One of the deep-rooted ideas in the minds of blasthole drill designers was a drill with twin mast, meant to drill two blastholes simultaneously. Marion Power Shovel Company developed one such drill and put it to field trials at Squaw Creek Mine. It did work and produced results but not to the level of satisfaction that the customer could order more of its kind. The drill is shown in Figure 4.19. All through the history of rotary blasthole drilling, the objective in improving machinery has been to introduce safety, efficiency, reduced maintenance and automation. The earliest step towards this was pipe handling. Carousel pipe changers were used even in the early 1950s. Single pipe changers, developed in the 1960s, were better at handling long and heavy drill pipes. Drilling recorders were introduced in blasthole drills in the early 1960s. In the early 1980s they became electronic. Automatic fire extinguishing systems and automatic lubricating systems were incorporated into blasthole drills in the late 1960s. In 1971 blasthole drills entered an era of automation, when Bucyrus Erie adapted a primary logic circuit to control some of the drilling operations on their blasthole drill model 60R. Early electric drills featured Ward Leonard controls for accurately controlling the DC electric motors in the rotary head. Some manufacturers adopted AC motors and frequency variation to control the motors in the early 1980s. However, advances in Static or Thyristor Control for DC motors have still retained DC motors on the rotary heads of blasthole drills. In the 1990s integrated circuits revolutionized the blasthole drills to a very great extent. They made it possible to precisely measure and monitor several functions in the drilling operation. Some features offered by such systems were useful in the following manner. 1
Book.indb 78
With the drilling recorder the driller could record the values of as many as 6 parameters of the drilling activities. With this facility the operators could moni-
11/22/2010 2:34:52 PM
Brief history of rotary blasthole drilling
2
79
tor the drilling process very effectively. Later, when digital systems were introduced the number of parameters went to as much as 12 and their values could be seen on the screen in the operator’s cab. Blasthole drills could be automatically leveled within an accuracy of 0.25°.
Figure 4.18 The largest, Bucyrus International’s 59HR, 2003.
Book.indb 79
11/22/2010 2:34:52 PM
80
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Figure 4.19 Marion twin mast rotary blasthole drill, 1986.
3
4
5
With specialized drill process software, stored in the computerized system of the blasthole drill, it became possible to control drilling operations in the most appropriate manner by automatically adjusting feed force, feed rate, rotary speed, compressed air supply and so on. Radio control for propelling operations of the blasthole drills made it possible to move the drill to the next blasthole by an operator who stood on the ground near the new hole position rather than the operators cab of the drill at the position of the already drilled hole. Very high positioning accuracy was achieved through such remote control propelling. With the introduction of Global Positioning Systems (GPS) it became possible not only to navigate the blasthole drill even more accurately, but also to integrate the drilling operation with a comprehensive mine operation system to increase productivity.
Technological advances in the new millennium have pushed automation further by introducing GPS. More details on these are given later in a separate chapter that deals with computers in rotary drilling. 4.5 TRUCK MOUNTED ROTARY BLASTHOLE DRILLS For almost a decade after the first world war, self propelled cable tool drilling rigs were being manufactured by manufacturers like Keystone, Star, and Armstrong. However when trucks became easily available in the early 1930s, many drill manufacturers started making their drills on a frame which could be simply mounted at the time of delivery onto the truck chassis purchased from the truck manufacturers.
Book.indb 80
11/22/2010 2:34:53 PM
Figure 4.20 Sandvik truck mounted rotary blasthole drill, 2008.
Book.indb 81
11/22/2010 2:34:54 PM
82
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
This move was beneficial to both manufacturers and purchasers. Drill manufacturers because it considerably reduced their inventory, and purchasers because it enabled them to get spare parts for half of their machine far more quickly from the truck manufacturers. The choice of truck-mounted rotary blasthole drills for the main mining operations is made very rarely for several reasons, explained in one of the next chapters, but many mining companies often keep one rotary blasthole drill in their fleet of equipment because: 1 2 3
It can be taken from one bench to another in much less time. It can be used for drilling deep holes often required in mine benches. If the main crawler blasthole drill fails and needs a long time for repairs, the truck-mounted blasthole drill can temporarily carry out the blasthole drilling work as a stopgap arrangement.
In the early 1970s many manufacturers made truck-mounted rotary blasthole drills, but currently only a few of them have continued their manufacture. Truck-mounted rotary blasthole drills are now available from Atlas Copco, Sandvik, Schramm. Most of the truck-mounted rotary blasthole drills can handle four to six drill pipes of length 7.6 m and diameters up to 127 mm, and are suitable for drilling 200 mm blastholes. One such drill is shown in Figure 4.20. Their bit load capability is of the order of 133 kN. Larger truck mounted drills, capable of drilling blastholes of diameters up to 311 mm with 219 mm drill pipes of length 12.2 m each, are also available. These drills have bit loading capacity of 311kN.
Book.indb 82
11/22/2010 2:34:56 PM
Chapter 5
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
5.1
INTRODUCTION
The drill string used in rotary drilling comprises many items, but the most important component in it is the drill bit. The drill bit disintegrates the formation under its teeth or cutting edges, and enables progress of the blasthole in the intended direction. In this process the bit undergoes very heavy wear and the penetration rate eventually drops down below an acceptable level. Thereafter the bit is required to be replaced. As a drill bit is an expensive and critical item, it is thoroughly dealt with in this separate chapter. Other accessories used in a rotary drill string are elaborated in chapter 6. Two types of drilling bits, viz. drag bits and tricone bits are used in blasthole drilling.
5.2
DRAG BITS
In the early days, drag bits made from cast steel were used for drilling blastholes in soft and very soft formations. Ever since tungsten carbide inserted drag bits made entry into the field of blasthole drilling, the use of cast steel bits stands almost discarded. Today, tungsten carbide inserted drag bits are used everywhere but in the near future drag bits, made with thermally stable diamond compacts, may change the whole scenario of rotary blasthole drilling. Two types of tungsten carbide inserted drag bits, viz. blade bits and claw bits, are currently used.
5.2.1
Blade bits
Blade bits have two types of cutting edges viz. Chevron Type and Step Type. A Bit with chevron cutting edge is shown in Figure 5.1. Such a cutting edge is usually found on small diameter bits used for drilling blastholes in underground mines. The step type cutting edge, shown by line drawing in Figure 5.2, is adopted for larger diameter bits that are used for drilling blastholes in surface mining operations. Step type drag bits are less prone to blasthole deviation. Blade bits have two, three or four wings. At their cutting edges they have flat, blade-like tungsten carbide inserts brazed to the main cast steel body.
Book.indb 83
11/22/2010 2:34:56 PM
84
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Figure 5.1 Chevron blade type drag bit.
Figure 5.2 Step blade type drag bit.
Experiments at various research centers have indicated that the shear strength of the material used for bonding the carbide inserts to the steel body of the blade bit should be more than 240 MPa for the bit to work satisfactorily. If blade type bits are used with air flushing, they attain high temperatures, and the possibility of losing a tungsten carbide insert increases considerably due to weakening of the brazing material that joins the carbide insert to the bit body. Therefore, blade type bits are either used with water circulation or water is injected in the stream of compressed air used for flushing.
Book.indb 84
11/22/2010 2:34:56 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
85
Since most of the soft formations, such as alluvial overburden in coal mines, coal seams, potash deposits etc., that require blasthole drilling are non-abrasive, the body of the bit remains intact for a long time. In such a situation drag bits with replaceable blades, as shown in Figure 5.3, can be used with advantage. Details of some blade type drag bits used in blasthole drilling are given in Table 5.1. More data can be obtained from the manufacturers.
5.2.2
Claw bits
A typical claw bit is shown in Figure 5.4. Depending upon the bit diameter, it has five or more replaceable teeth and a replaceable pilot. All the teeth are fixed in a forged, machined and heat-treated bit body by means of steel pins or circlips. Since the inserts in the claw bits are not brazed, the bit can be used with air circulation along with water injection. The performance of claw type drag bits is better, as penetration of the teeth of the bit in the soft formation is deeper. For this reason, claw bits require higher torque than the blade bits. Claw bits are chosen for drilling in formations having UCS ranging from 35–70 MPa. In any case, while drilling blastholes with drag bits, a large quantity of water is required to be injected with the compressed air for bit cooling. Details of some claw type drag bits used in blasthole drilling are given in Table 5.2.
5.2.3
Feed force and rotation of drag bits
Due to its low importance, the process of drag bit drilling has not been researched or recorded as deeply as have tricone bits. Field practice in using drag bits suggests that blade bits should be used with a bit weight of 100–200 N per mm bit diameter and rotated at 20–50 rpm, whereas claw bits should be subjected to a feed force of 3000–5000 N per tooth of the bit and rotated at 10–40 rpm.
Connector
Reaming Stabilizer Holder
Bit Shank
Blades
Figure 5.3 Replaceable blade drag bit.
Book.indb 85
11/22/2010 2:34:57 PM
86
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Table 5.1 Details of some blade type drag bits. Nominal bit diameter mm
Inches
Connection
48–64 70 73 70–89 92–120 127 130 133–140 143 152–171 178–203 178–311
1.7/8–2.1/2 2.3/4 2.7/8 2.3/4–3.1/2 3.5/8–4.3/4 5 5.1/8 5.1/4–5.1/2 5.1/4–5.1/2 6–6.3/4 7–8 7–12.1/4
AW or A Rod AW or A Rod AW or A Rod NW or N Rod 2.3/8" API Reg. 2.3/8" API Reg. 2.7/8" API Reg. 2.7/8" API Reg. 3.1/2" API Reg. 3.1/2" API Reg. 3.1/2" API Reg. 3.1/2" API Reg. 4.1/2" API Reg.
Configuration – (chev./step) and number of wings C3 C3 C3 C3, C4, S3 C3, C4, S3 C3, C4, S3 C3, C4, S3 C3, C4, S3 C3, C4, S3 C3, S3 C3 S3
Figure 5.4 Claw type drag bit.
5.3 TRICONE BITS Today, only about 2% of rotary blasthole drilling is carried out with drag bits. The remaining 98% is carried out with tricone bits. Tricone bits with meshing cones were introduced in oilwell drilling practice in 1933. Initially tricone bits were used only for oilwell drilling. When bits with a facility for compressed air circulation through their bearings were developed in 1949,
Book.indb 86
11/22/2010 2:34:58 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
87
Table 5.2 Details of some claw type drag bits. Nominal bit diameter mm
Inches
Connection
Number of teeth
98–101 105–108 114–120 127–130 140–149 152–165 178–190 203–216 250 270 280 311
3 7/8–4 4 1/8–4¼ 4½–4¾ 5–5 1/8 5 ½–5 7/8 6–6½ 7–7½ 8–8½ 9 7/8 10 5/8 11 12
2.3/8" API Reg. 2.3/8" API Reg. 2.3/8" API Reg. 2.3/8" API Reg. 2.7/8" API Reg. 3.1/2" API Reg. 3.1/2" API Reg. 4.1/2" API Reg. 4.1/2" API Reg. 6.5/8" API Reg. 6.5/8" API Reg. 6.5/8" API Reg.
4 4 4 4 5 6 6–7 8 9–10 10–12 12 14
Pilot bit diameter mm 40 40 40 40 40 40 50 50 50 50 50 50
tricone bits were also introduced into blasthole drilling practice. Tungsten carbide inserted bits were initiated in 1951, and sealed bearing bits made their appearance in 1959. Sealed journal bearing bits were launched in 1968.
5.3.1 Types and nomenclature Drag bits, as shown in Figure 5.1 to 5.4, do not have any moving parts. Tricone bits, however, are assembled by using many parts, some of which move while the drilling operation goes on. The reasons for having three cones on a bit are: 1
2
The contact between the cone of a bit and the horizontal bottom of the blasthole is always linear. In two-cone bits these two lines are actually collinear. In threecone bits the three lines are radial. Therefore, a blasthole drilled with two-cone bits is far more prone to deviation. Tricone bits exert the bit weight in three vertical planes in a far better balanced manner and reduce the hole deviation to a great extent. The balanced bit load distribution also gives longer life to a tricone bit as compared to a two-cone bit. Bits with more than three cones can give better weight distribution but in such case the size of the cones has to be reduced and so the bearings within them have to be smaller. This leads to very weak bits that are susceptible to early bearing failure.
Primarily two types or tricone bits are made, viz. milled tooth bits and tungsten carbide insert bits. Milled tooth bits are also called steel tooth bits. In milled tooth bits the cones are completely made from alloy steel and the teeth are formed by milling – a mechanical metal cutting process.
Book.indb 87
11/22/2010 2:34:58 PM
88
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Tungsten carbide inserted bits have different types of carbide inserts firmly fixed into the holes drilled in the cones by another manufacturing technique called shrink fitting. Since tungsten carbide is a much harder and abrasion-resistant material, the carbide inserted bits give far better performance – often 3 to 9 times – than that of a comparable milled tooth bit operating under similar conditions. Milled tooth and tungsten carbide insert tricone bits are shown in Figure 5.5. Tungsten carbide inserted bits are more expensive than milled tooth bits due to the higher price of tungsten carbide inserts and added manufacturing costs. Some manufacturers make composite bits where the cones have steel teeth on all the portion except the outer edges, where tungsten carbide inserts are fitted. The design principles of a milled tooth bit also apply to a tungsten carbide insert bit. Three cones of a milled tooth tricone bit, when seen from bottom of the bit, look like those shown in left side picture in Figure 5.6. No. 1 cone is the cone which has a spear point i.e. the teeth at the apex of the cones. The next cone, i.e. cone no. 2, has teeth on a circle at a small distance from the apex of the cone. The row of these teeth is called the nose row. The nose row on cone no. 3 is at a slightly larger distance from its apex compared to cone no. 2. The diameter of a tricone bit is equal to the inner diameter of the smallest circular ring through which the bit can pass. This dimension is treated as the nominal hole size of a new bit. Even though used for blasthole drilling, tricone bits are made to the standards laid down by the American Petroleum Institute. Acceptable tolerances in the diameter of tricone bits as per API Standards are given in Table 5.3.
Figure 5.5 Milled tooth and tungsten carbide insert tricone bits.
Book.indb 88
11/22/2010 2:34:58 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
Gage Teeth
Bit Leg
Cone No.2
Air Passage Air Exit
Nose Row
Intermediate Row
Ball Bearing
Nose of Cone 2
Spear point
89
Nose of Cone 3 Cone Shell
Intermediate Row Nose Row Gage Row Roller Bearing
Gage Teeth
Gage Teeth Cone No.3
Cone No.1
Gage Insert Bush Bearing
Thrust Button
Figure 5.6 Nomenclature of tricone bits. Table 5.3 Acceptable tolerances in tricone bit diameter. Bit diameter mm
Higher size tolerance
Lower size tolerance
85.7–349.2 mm 355.6–444.5 mm Larger than 445 mm
0.79 mm 1.59 mm 2.38 mm
0 mm 0 mm 0 mm
In the early days, tricone rock bits of diameters as low as 100 mm were made but, since it is now possible to drill holes of diameter up to 150 mm by rotary percussion drilling at faster penetration rates, use of such small size tricone bits has remained restricted to soil investigation and some other purposes, where drilling is to be carried out with least disturbance to the rock mass. In any case, small diameter tricone bits do not perform well in hard formations, because small tricone bits have very small bearings. Further it is also not possible to give adequate feed force on the tricone bits through slender drill rods as they are susceptible to buckling. The cross section of a roller and corresponding leg is shown on the right-hand picture in Figure 5.6. To enable the roller to roll over the formation as the drill string is rotated, bearings are provided between the cones and respective legs. Usually the innermost bearing is a journal type. It involves no moving parts, and therefore can transfer very heavy radial loads. The middle bearing is ball type. It interlocks the cone with the leg. The outermost bearing is roller type. It allows the bit to withstand very heavy downward thrust while being rotated at low frictional resistance. Figure 5.6 shows three rows of teeth on the cone and three rows of bearings. These are applicable to bits of small diameter. Sometimes more than three rows of teeth as well as bearings are provided on large diameter bits. Components of a tricone bit are made separately and are assembled later. Each of the three legs of a tricone bit is made from a forging of an alloy steel. The forged leg is very precisely machined for the dimensions of grooves for roller, ball and
Book.indb 89
11/22/2010 2:35:00 PM
90
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
journal bearings. Once the machining process has finished, the machined portion is heat treated to the desired hardness by carburizing. Figure 5.7 shows a tricone bit leg. The cones are made from their respective forging, then machined and heat treated. After this, if applicable, carbide inserts are shrink-fitted in the holes. Journal and rollers of the bearing are then inserted in the appropriate grooves of the cone. Once this is done, the leg is inserted in the cone in which the roller bearings are held in their final position. The balls of the ball bearings are inserted from outside through a hole provided for the purpose.
Figure 5.7 A tricone bit leg.
Book.indb 90
11/22/2010 2:35:01 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
91
Assembling of one leg is complete once the balls are appropriately inserted and the hole is plugged by a pin that is later welded to the leg. The three legs of a bit are then held together firmly and their sides are welded to form a tricone bit. After the welding and stress-relieving operations are over, the top portion of the bit is machined to form an API Regular pin connection. This connection enables coupling the bit to the stabilizers or bit subs which are the next bottommost components of a drill string. The names of many other portions of a tricone rock bit are shown in Figures 5.8 and 5.9.
5.3.2
Geometrical design aspects
Many factors relating to the geometry of the components of a tricone bit, such as cone size, cone offset, size and shape of teeth etc., play a very important role in its field performance. While designing a bit, all these must be given due consideration. 5.3.2.1
Fluid circulation
Aspects related to removal of cuttings from a blasthole by circulating compressed air have been dealt with in a separate chapter of this book. Apart from the need to bring the drill cuttings to ground surface, the compressed air is also required to dissipate the heat generated by friction between cones and the formation, as well as within the bearings located inside the cones of a tricone bit. If bits with bearings lubricated in the factory and meant to be used with water circulation are used in blasthole drilling, the compressed air proves insufficient in heat dissipation, and consequently the bearings fail soon after the lubricant melts and oozes out or burns and becomes ineffective. In 1949 this problem was solved by providing air passages like those shown in Figure 5.9. Another, more recent way, is to use a bit provided with a composite seal, made of elastomer plus metal, and a reservoir built into the bit leg to store a special lubricant. Such lifetime-lubricated bits can defy temperatures to even 400°C. 5.3.2.1.1
Air cooled tricone bits
Air-cooled bits are of two types viz. regular and jet circulation as shown in Figure 5.10. In a regular circulation tricone bit, three passages to the bearings of the three cones are provided for air circulation through the bearings and the main airflow is through a central hole. In a jet circulation tricone bit, three passages to the bearings of the three cones are also provided for air circulation through the bearings, but the main airflow is also through three jet nozzles provided on the three legs of the bit. As a general norm, it is desired that at least about 30% of the total compressed air supplied to the bit should flow through bit bearings so the bearings cool sufficiently. The size of the air passages to bearings is given appropriate dimensions to achieve this objective. In most of the regular circulation bits, this objective is achieved when compressed air pressure at the bit is about 280 to 300 kPa. In jet circulation bits, three independently replaceable nozzles are provided to achieve this. When nozzles of smaller
Book.indb 91
11/22/2010 2:35:02 PM
Book.indb 92
Nozzle Retaining Pin
Bit Type Emboss
Bit Serial Number Emboss
Shank
Bit Size Emboss
Shank
Nozzle
Bit Assembly Number Emboss One of the Three Legs
Shirttail Hardfacing
Gage Teeth
Figure 5.8 Nomenclature of tricone bits.
Cone Gage Surface
11/22/2010 2:35:02 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
93
Water Separator
Snap Ring
Air Screen Bit Leg
Rubber Flapper Screen Tube Assembly
Main Air Passage Air Passage to Ball Bearing Air Passage to Pilot Bearing Pilot Pin Shirttail Inserts
Cone Gage Inserts
Leg Journal
Cutting Surface Inserts Cone
Roller Bearing Ball Bearing Bush Bearing
Figure 5.9 Air cooling of blasthole bits.
Regular Circulation
Jet Circulation
Air Flow through Central Hole
Air Passage to Bearings
Air Flow through Jet
Air Passage to Bearings
Jet Nozzle
Figure 5.10 Regular and jet circulation bits.
central bore are chosen, a lower volume of compressed air flows through the nozzles and consequently a higher volume of compressed air is forced to flow through the air passages of the bearings on account of higher pressure built up behind the nozzles. Blasthole drills often have provisions for injecting water into the flow of compressed air. This injected water flows to the drill bits. The purpose of such water circulation is
Book.indb 93
11/22/2010 2:35:03 PM
94
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
to suppress the dust formed during formation fracture. This water, in the form of fog, also passes through the bearings of the bit and helps in cooling the bearings. Many blasthole drills are provided with filter type dust collection systems instead of dust suppression by water injection. In such blasthole drills, if an oil injection system is provided instead of water injection, the oil mixed with compressed air reaches the bearings of the drill bit and lubricates them. This type of bit lubrication proves far more effective and the life of the bit increases by as much as 20%. Air circulation tricone bits are usually provided with a back flow valve at the top, so sudden flow of water in the bit is prevented. 5.3.2.1.2
Sealed bearing bits
Originally these bits were developed for drilling geothermal wells where they had to work in high temperature surroundings. Now they are also used in blasthole drilling applications. The cross section of a leg of a sealed bearing bit looks like the one shown in Figure 5.11. The lubricant reservoir stores an adequate quantity of lubricant and supplies it to the bearings in the cone. The bellow type reservoir keeps the lubricant under pressure,
Sealed journal bearing
Diaphragm Reservoir Cap Grease Reservoir Silver Plates Beryllium Copper Thrust Face Radial Elastomer Seal Journal Hard Metal Gauge Gauge Protection Friction Pin Cone Tungsten Carbide Inserts
Figure 5.11 Cross section of a sealed bearing bit.
Book.indb 94
11/22/2010 2:35:06 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
95
so the lubricant flows to the bearings. The lubricant is prevented from escaping out of the cone by a composite seal of elastomer and metal. Sealed bearing bits have given considerably better performance in terms of drilled meterage and long life as compared to air circulation bits. 5.3.2.2
Size and shapes of teeth
A tricone bit, and the pattern of fractured formation made by one at the bottom of a hole, are shown in Figure 5.12. The indention made by the teeth can easily be observed in the pattern. Actually, the pattern shown is for a hole made in soft rock by mud flush drilling. In blasthole drilling, a bit is exerted with slightly higher feed force. The hole is flushed by compressed air. It removes larger cuttings from the hole bottom without any need for secondary crushing. Thus, in blasthole drilling, even deeper indentions than those shown in Figure 5.12 are formed at the hole bottom. Since in subsequent formation fracture the teeth have to touch at the crest in between two indentions, the number of teeth is often kept odd for the fracture to be more effective. Milled tooth bits have three distinct shapes for a tooth viz. Chisel, H and T. They all are shown in Figure 5.13. All these teeth shapes are formed by milling processes in the rock bit plant. When the angle between the two slanting surfaces of a tooth is small, tooth height is large and vice versa. For drilling in softer formations, the taller teeth give better performance because they can fragment larger cuttings of rock without getting blunt. For drilling in harder formations, the teeth are required to have lesser height since in such cases the tooth angle reduces and the teeth are less susceptible to breakage. The T and H type teeth are found only on the outermost, i.e. gage, rows where they give excellent resistance to higher wear. The teeth of milled tooth bits are usually given a hard facing on their sides for the purpose of extra wear resistance. In carbide inserted bits, the insert tips are made with different shapes during the sintering process. Some insert shapes are as shown in Figure 5.14. The apex angle between the sides of the surfaces near the tip differs considerably. Larger apex angle at the tip gives more strength and higher wear resistance to the insert; however, it reduces the penetration of the insert in the rock. Tricone bits meant for drilling in soft formations have inserts with low apex angle. Inserts at the cone gage and shirttail portion have a dome shape to give very high wear resistance because even in soft formations they merely rub against the formation. In extremely hard formations, carbide insert bits with synthetic diamond caps or diamond coating are chosen. 5.3.2.3
Cone size
The cones of the tricone bit are never true cones but a composite of two cones as shown in Figure 5.15. The main reason for choosing such a shape for the cone is that such a cone is bulged at the center and, therefore, it can accommodate much larger ball and roller bearings within it. This gives higher strength to the cone and the bearings, so much heavier bit loads can be exerted.
Book.indb 95
11/22/2010 2:35:08 PM
96
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Figure 5.12 Indention made by tricone bit.
When such a composite cone rolls along the formation surface, the teeth of the bit penetrate into the formation and cause indention. Neither the shapes of the teeth, nor the shapes of the indention caused by the teeth, have the shape of a perfect gear tooth. Therefore, slip is caused and side loads are exerted on the bit as well as on the formation. This causes large scale fracture of the formation.
Book.indb 96
11/22/2010 2:35:08 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
Top Surface
Side Surface
Side Surface
Chisel Type Tooth
H Type Gage Tooth Shirttail Hardfacing Gage Hardfacing Tooth Hardfacing
97
T Type Gage Tooth
Figure 5.13 Various shapes of tricone bit teeth.
Soft Formations
Soft to Medium Formations Medium to Hard Formations
Hard Formations
Figure 5.14 Various shapes of carbide inserts.
Deeper indention is desirable while drilling soft formations because it creates larger side loads and a larger portion of the formation gets fractured without causing any damage to the tooth. In the case of tricone bits to be used for drilling in hard formations, the outer cone is made bigger and the inner cone smaller, as shown in Figure 5.16. This enables accommodation of even larger bearings. The teeth of such bits are also made smaller so as to reduce the amount of slip when the cone rotates and the teeth penetrate. All this makes the bit suitable for drilling in hard formations where the strength of the cone has higher importance. In hard formations, the slip and consequent side force on the formation
Book.indb 97
11/22/2010 2:35:10 PM
98
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Envelope of Outer Cone
Cross Section of Actual Cone
Envelope of Inner Cone
Axis of Cone Rotation
Figure 5.15 Two cone composition of the cone of a tricone bit.
Envelope of Outer Cone
Cross Section of Actual Cone
Envelope of Inner Cone
Axis of Cone Rotation
Figure 5.16 Large outer and small inner cone envelopes of the cone of a tricone bit.
does not contribute much to the formation fracturing. Thus, a lower amount of slip is more desirable. A lower amount of slip also causes less wear on the tooth. From the above it can be easily surmised that a longer tooth will give more formation fracture but will be more susceptible to breakage and wear. If a bit meant for drilling soft formations is used for drilling hard formations, premature tooth breakage will occur. 5.3.2.4
Number of teeth
As the height of the teeth of a soft formation bit is large and that of hard formation bit is small, it is possible to accommodate more teeth on the cones of a hard formation bit. This can be observed in Figure 5.17, where cones of the same size have been
Book.indb 98
11/22/2010 2:35:14 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
99
shown. In harder formations, more teeth are necessary because the material removed by each tooth is relatively small, and to make full use of the bit strength in order to allow higher bit loads, more teeth are desirable. For the same reason, there are more inserts on a tungsten carbide inserted bit meant for drilling in hard formations. 5.3.2.5
Cone orientation
If a perfect cone is rolled over a smooth plane surface, it will roll through a perfect circle on that surface. The apex of the cone will lie at the center of such circle. In such rolling of the cone, there will be no slippage between the cone surface and the surface in the circle over which the cone rolls. Even a composite smooth cone (without any teeth) will not slip on a surface formed by two cones. In order to get more formation fracture and faster penetration rate in very soft formations such as coal, it is desirable to have larger amount of slip of the teeth on the cones. Such slip gives a much higher volume of fractured formation and consequently much faster penetration rate. There is always a limit imposed by the geometry on the height of the teeth. Thus, to achieve the higher amount of slip that is desirable in drilling soft formations, the cones of the bit are oriented with an offset as shown in Figure 5.18.
Many small height teeth can be accommodated in a bit meant for drilling in hard formation
Fewer tall height teeth can be accommodated in a bit meant for drilling in soft formation
Figure 5.17 More teeth on hard formation tricone bits.
Direction of Bit Rotation
Bit Rotation Axis Offset Angle
Axes of Cone Rotation
Figure 5.18 Offset of mounting of the cones.
Book.indb 99
11/22/2010 2:35:15 PM
100
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Offset can be defined as the perpendicular distance between the axis of rotation of the bit and the axis of rotation of the cone. When smooth cones with offset mounting are rotated on any surface profile they invariably slip. If the cones have teeth, the offset adds to the slip of the teeth and the formation is fractured with higher side forces. This results in a faster penetration rate. Even hard formation tricone bits also have some offset. Only the bits meant for drilling in extremely hard formations do not have any offset because normally such formations are very abrasive and providing offset in them creates a large magnitude of friction which results in very rapid tooth wear. 5.3.2.6
Top connections
Most of the developments of tricone bits were made long before the bits appeared on the blasthole drilling horizon. These developments were quickly built into the Standards set forth by the American Petroleum Institute. Air blast tricone bits are used not only by the blasthole drilling industry but also by the oilwell and waterwell drilling industries. It is, therefore, quite natural that tricone bit manufacturers have retained API Standard for air blast bits and have adapted API Regular type for the top-threaded connection of their bits. Tricone bits of different sizes have different API Regular pin connections as detailed in Table 5.4. The table also gives approximate weights of the bits. Some manufacturers do make blasthole bits with BECO connections which are more popular in the mining domain.
5.3.3
Metallurgy
Metallurgy plays a very important role in the manufacture of tricone rock bits. Important parts of a tricone bit, viz. the legs and cones, are made from forgings. After
Table 5.4 Top connections and weights of most commonly used for tricone blasthole bits. Nominal bit diameter
Book.indb 100
mm
Inches
Connection
Weight of the bit in kg
143 152 159 171 187 200 229 251 279 311 349 381 406 445
5 5/8 6 6¼ 6¾ 7 3/8 7 7/8 9 9 7/8 11 12¼ 13¾ 15 16 17½
3.1/2″ API Regular Pin 3.1/2″ API Regular Pin 3.1/2″ API Regular Pin 3.1/2″ API Regular Pin 4.1/2″ API Regular Pin 4.1/2″ API Regular Pin 4.1/2″ API Regular Pin 6 5/8″ API Regular Pin 6 5/8″ API Regular Pin 6 5/8″ API Regular Pin 7 5/8″ API Regular Pin 8 5/8″ API Regular Pin 8 5/8″ API Regular Pin 8 5/8″ API Regular Pin
10 13.6 15.9 21.8 22.7 33 43 62 75 100 125 160 180 210
11/22/2010 2:35:16 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
101
machining, metallurgical process such as case hardening, stress relieving, shrink filling etc., have to be carried out in many stages. Even the tungsten carbide inserts are made by sintering – a metallurgical process. 5.3.3.1
Materials
The first step in the manufacture of a tricone rock bit is to select the right materials for various components of the bit. Since a tricone bit is subjected to very heavy stresses, the tolerance levels in the composition of the materials to be chosen for bit manufacture are very low. The materials usually used for milled tooth tricone bits are given in Table 5.5. The materials mentioned in the table are readily available, but in composition their tolerance limits are generally wider, and hence unacceptable for manufacture of a tricone bit component. Therefore, it is necessary to choose very specific materials from selected suppliers. Choosing appropriate inserts for tungsten carbide insert type bits is equally important. Detailed information on tungsten carbide is given in Appendix 7 at the end of this book. The following rudimentary knowledge in this regard is given for the sake of completeness. A tungsten carbide insert is formed by sintering a mixture of tungsten carbide and cobalt. Tungsten carbide is extremely hard and wear-resistant but at the same time very brittle. Cobalt, which serves as binder between tungsten carbide particles, is necessary to give the desired toughness. The proportion of tungsten carbide in an insert varies between 84% and 96%. A higher proportion of tungsten carbide is better suited for the manufacture of hard formations bits. Modern manufacturing techniques have made it possible to make even better tungsten carbide inserts. Two such techniques are as follows. Tungsten carbide (TC) inserts prior to the 1980s had the same composition throughout their volume. With the new technique it is possible to use a composition rich in tungsten for the outer side of the insert and a composition with larger proportion of cobalt in the central core. Sintering in this manner results in an insert with high wear resistance at the surface and the desired level of toughness throughout its Table 5.5 Materials used for manufacture of various components of tricone bits. Component name
Desired material properties
Material chosen
Material composition
Cones
Abrasion and Impact Resistance Weldability, High Impact Resistance, Surface Fatigue Resistance High Strength, Impact Resistance Wear Resistance Wear Resistance Wear Resistance Extreme Abrasion Resistance
ANSI 4817
C, Si, Mn, Ni, Mo, S, P
ANSI 8720
C, Si, Mn, Ni, Cr, Mo, S, P
ANSI S2
C, Si, Mn, Mo
ANSI 431 ANSI M2 Chrome Cobalt Tungsten Carbide
C, Si, Mn, Ni, Cr C, W, Cr, Mo,Va Co, Cr, C, W, Ni W, C, Co
Legs
Roller and Ball Bearings Journal Bushing Thrust Button Bearing Hardfacing Tooth Hardfacing
Book.indb 101
11/22/2010 2:35:16 PM
102
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
volume. Often materials like silicon carbide, boron nitride etc. are also mixed in the outer layer in small proportions so the insert surface gets added wear resistance. Another manufacturing technique makes it possible to make tungsten carbide inserts with an outer cover of diamond. Because diamond is the hardest and most wear resistant material, diamond coated tungsten carbide inserts have extreme wear resistance. Modern bits usually use flat diamond compacts of 2 to 3 mm thickness on a base of tungsten carbide for gage wear resistance. When the formations to be drilled are extremely hard and abrasive all the inserts are diamond coated. During drilling operations the bearings of the tricone bits – particularly the bush bearings – generate a very high quantum of heat. This heat is released to atmosphere in two ways as follows: 1 2
Convection of heat through compressed air used for bit cooling. Conduction of heat from the bearings to the surfaces of cones and legs, from where it is again transferred by compressed air through convection.
While drilling in very hard formations with extremely heavy bit loads, the quantum of heat generated is so high that compressed air flowing through the bearings is not able to transfer the heat at the desired transfer rate. Three decades ago some manufacturers used silver alloy inlays at the bush bearing portion, as shown in Figure 5.19. Silver being a far better medium for the transfer of heat, the inlays quickly brought the heat to the outer surface of the cones. Current techniques provide small diameter through holes in the cones. These holes serve as passages for compressed air and dissipate heat efficiently. 5.3.3.2
Heat treatment
Heat treatment is the key process that gives the essential properties to a component of a tricone bit. Many intricate heat treatment processes are required to be adapted during the manufacture of a tricone bit component.
Silver Inlays
Figure 5.19 Silver alloy inlays in a cone.
Book.indb 102
11/22/2010 2:35:16 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
103
To give surface wear resistance to a cone, the surface is carburized. Carburization is a process where components are packed in a carbonaceous carburizing compound in a closed box and heated in a furnace up to about 925°C. At such temperatures the carburizing compounds liberate carbon monoxide (CO) gas. Carbon in this gas penetrates the surface of the alloy steel component through the process of diffusion, and dissolves. As a result, the surface of the component becomes very hard and wear resistant. The thickness of such a hard surface lies between 1.7 mm to 3.3 mm depending upon the component and the time period over which it is kept in the carbon- based atmosphere. The central portion, where carbon is not absorbed, remains tough. Carbon content of the surface material varies between 0.7% to 1.2%. Figure 5.20 shows a portion of a cone where the darker carburized surface can be easily differentiated. Sometimes instead of using carbonaceous compounds, CO gas is used directly. The hardness level achieved in this manner is 63–65 Rockwell C. Certain portions of the surface are not to be carburized as they have to be machined further. In such cases, a coating is applied to that portion before it is carburized. The coating does not allow absorption of carbon at the surface beneath it. This type of selective carburizing can also done by heating the desired portion of the part by using a high intensity oxyacetylene flame of proper size and shape. Figure 5.21 shows a bit leg where the dark carburized surface is seen only on one portion that was not coated while carburizing. Metallurgical processes described here need very specialized equipment in the manufacturing plant. Quality control is of prime importance in the manufacturing process since performance of the bits is watched by the end users very carefully. Guarantees of bit performance have now become an almost unavoidable feature of bit sale.
5.3.4
Summary of design features
The chart in Figure 5.22 gives the qualitative summary of design features of various bits. The levels of different parameters indicated by bar graphs are variable between the two extreme values for the parameter viz. 0 to 10. Naturally, all the levels are
Hard Carburized Surface Tough Non Carburized Core
Figure 5.20 Cone carburization.
Book.indb 103
11/22/2010 2:35:17 PM
104
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Carburized Surface
Non Carburized Surface
Figure 5.21 Selective carburization. Bit Type Basic Design
Soft
Medium
Hard
Extra Hard
Offset Journal Angle
Cutting Structure Design
Scraping Action Crushing Action Tooth Depth Tooth Spacing Included Tooth Angle
Strength
Bearing Strength Carburized Case Depth
Metallurgy Tooth Hardfacing Gage Hardfacing
Figure 5.22 Summary of design features.
Book.indb 104
11/22/2010 2:35:18 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
105
Table 5.6 Recommended bit loads and rotary speeds for tricone bits. IADC code
Bit load kN/mm
Rotary speed in RPM
Steel tooth bits 112⇒142 212⇒242 312⇒342
0.175⇒0.525 0.525⇒0.875 0.700⇒1.225
70–120 60–100 50–80
TC insert bits 412⇒442 512⇒542 612⇒642 712⇒742 812⇒842
0.175⇒0.875 0.525⇒1.137 0.700⇒1.225 0.700⇒1.400 1.050⇒1.575
50–150 50–150 50–120 50–90 40–80
relative and not absolute. Similarly the hardness of the formation indicated by ten columns is also relative and not to any specific scale.
5.3.5
Bit load and rotation of tricone bits
As is amply evident from the discussion about the cutting action under the teeth of tricone bits, very high side forces are also exerted on tricone bits during the formation fracturing process. Naturally, tricone bits have to be rotated at low speed and high torque. With increasing feed force the torque requirement rises. To avoid shocks being experienced by the teeth, the rotary speed is required to be reduced. Normal recommended bit loads and rotary speeds to be used in tricone bit drilling are as shown in Table 5.6. For larger diameter bits, lower rotary speeds and higher bit loads should be chosen. An empirical equation put forth by Praillet for calculating optimum weight on the tricone bit is as follows. Wo = σc ∗ D/2 where Wo = Optimum weight on the bit in kg σc = Compressive strength of rock in kg/cm2 D = Diameter of the tricone bit in cm
5.3.6
IADC code
The International Association of Drilling Contractors (IADC) has formulated a standard four digit code for classification of tricone bits. It is explained in Figure 5.23. Almost every tricone bit manufactured by any manufacturer can be classified by choosing appropriate numerals or letters in place of the digits. This code is very suitable for comparing tricone bits and for unambiguous report preparation.
Book.indb 105
11/22/2010 2:35:21 PM
106
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
First Digit
Used for Bit Type and Formation
Second Digit
Used for Further Formation Suitability
Third Digit
Used for Bearing Type
Fourth Digit
Used for Additional Design Features
Figure 5.23 Explanation of Four Digits in IADC Code.
Table 5.7 Key to first digit of IADC code. Number
Description (bit type and formation)
1 2 3 4 5
Steel Tooth Bit for Soft Formations Steel Tooth Bit for Medium Formations Steel Tooth Bit for Hard Formations TC Insert Bit for Soft Formations TC Insert Bit for Medium Soft Formations TC Insert Bit for Medium Formations TC Insert Bit for Medium Hard Formations TC Insert Bit for Hard Formations
6 7 8
The first digit of the code is a numeral which broadly indicates the type of bit and the formation hardness for which the bit is suitable. One of eight numerals can be chosen for this digit. Table 5.7 gives the key for selecting the appropriate numeral for the first digit. The second digit of the code is a numeral that broadly indicates the formation hardness for which the bit is suitable. One of four numerals can be chosen for this digit. Table 5.8 gives the key for selecting the appropriate numeral for this basis. The third digit of the code is a numeral that indicates the type of bearing used in the bit. One of seven numerals can be chosen for this digit. Table 5.9 gives the key for selecting the appropriate numeral according to this criterion. The fourth digit of the code is a letter that indicates the additional features provided in the bit. One of nine letters can be chosen for this digit. Table 5.10 gives the key for selecting the appropriate letter according to this criterion. Due to continuous developments in manufacturing techniques of tricone bits, most of the manufacturers restrict to first three digits of IADC codes for their bits and use the fourth digit as per a table made by them for their bits which can contain more letters than those presented in Table 5.10.
Book.indb 106
11/22/2010 2:35:21 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
107
Table 5.8 Key to second digit of IADC code. Number
Description (further formation suitability)
1 2 3 4
Soft Formations Medium Formations Hard Formations Extra Hard Formations
Table 5.9 Key to third digit of IADC Code. Number
Description (bearing type)
1 2 3
Standard Open Bearing Standard Open Bearing for Air Flushing Standard Open Bearing with TC Hardfacing or TC Insert Protection at the Cone Heel Roller Sealed Bearing Roller Sealed Bearing with TC Inserts at the Cone Heel Journal Sealed Bearing Journal Sealed Bearing with TC Inserts at the Cone Heel
4 5 6 7
Table 5.10 Key to fourth digit of IADC code.
5.4
Letter
Description (additional design feature)
A R C S D E G Z J
Air Flush Application Reinforced Welds Single Central Jet Standard Steel Tooth Model Deviation Control Feature Extended Jet Nozzle Extra Gage Protection Other Shapes of TC Inserts Jet Deflection
DULL BIT ANALYSIS
Observations about the conditions of a bit are made frequently during drilling. Eventually, like everything else in this world, a tricone bit comes to the end of its useful life. Such bit can be scrapped or sent for salvage, if economically feasible. Before doing so, it is very essential to carefully observe the condition of the failed bit and analyze the reasons for failure. Reasons for failure established by such analysis give good guidance to the user for achieving more efficient operations and better drilling economy in future. If such data are provided to bit manufacturers it can be very helpful in their research towards improved products.
Book.indb 107
11/22/2010 2:35:22 PM
108
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
5.4.1
Bit observation
In any observation ‘when’ and ‘what’ are the most important criteria. As far as ‘when’ is concerned, there are three stages of bit observations viz. 1 2 3
Observation During Drilling Operation Observation After Bit Withdrawal Observation At Final Bit Rejection
5.4.1.1
Observation during drilling operation
During blasthole drilling operations the driller does not see the bit because it is inside the hole. He cannot even see the cuttings ejected out of the blasthole as the area is covered by a large dust hood. However, the driller is able to see the rotating drill pipe and can judge the penetration rate from axial movement of the drill pipe. On most modern blasthole drills a drilling recorder is provided in the operators cab. In addition to the information on other drilling parameters, the recorder almost invariably gives the current penetration rate in numerical units. From such indirect observations an experienced operator can judge if the bit is performing as per expectations or whether there is something wrong with the drilling bit. 5.4.1.2
Observation after bit withdrawal
It is a good practice to inspect a tricone bit after drilling a certain number of blastholes. As the bit usually remains within the dust hood, the hood has to be lifted and a torch has to be used for inspection of the bit. In many sophisticated and large blasthole drills, arrangements are provided for mechanical raising of the dust hood. The dust hood must be lifted before the drill moves to the location of a new blasthole so that the hood itself does not push the cuttings back into the blasthole. These curtain lifting arrangements come in very handy while inspecting the drill bit, cuttings and other associated factors. The best time to inspect the bit is when the drill has moved to the new blasthole position and is being leveled by using its jacks. In this type of inspection, the bit can be inspected for general wear condition of the cones, loss of gage i.e. reduction of the bit diameter, free rotation of the cones and broken teeth. 5.4.1.3
Observation at final bit rejection
When a bit starts giving a penetration rate below the acceptable level, it is replaced by a new bit. Observation of the rejected bit can be done far more thoroughly by considering the following conditions: 1 2 3 4
Tooth or Insert Conditions Cone Shell Conditions Bearing Conditions Bit Body Conditions
For the purpose of keeping records, the abbreviations shown in Table 5.11 are often used. As most of the abbreviations are acronyms of the condition to be observed,
Book.indb 108
11/22/2010 2:35:22 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
109
Table 5.11 Key for recording observations of a rejected bit. Tooth or insert conditions BT Broken Teeth or Inserts CD Cone Dragged CR Cored RG Rounded Gage WG Worn Out of Gage BG Broken Gage Insert Cone shell conditions BA Broken Axially BC Broken on Circumference BS Broken Spear point IH Cone Interference – Heel IM Cone Interference – Middle IN Cone Interference – Nose CS Cracked Axially CC Cracked on Circumference EC Eroded Cone shell
Rotation or bearing conditions BF Bearing Failure BP Broken Bearing Pin BR Broken Rollers CL Cone Locked IT Inward Thrust Wear LC Lost Cone LR Lost Rollers NF Nose Bearing Failure NL Nose Bearing Loose OT Outward Thrust Bit body conditions BL Bent Legs DB Damaged Bit SB Shirttail Broken SW Shirttail Worn
they are easy to remember. The table also gives a very clear idea as to what is required to be observed under each of the above conditions. Besides the reasons for bit rejection, as given in Table 5.11, a remark regarding how well the bit has performed, must also be recorded. For this purpose letters G+, G, A+, A, A−, P and P− are used to indicate very good, good, above average, average, below average, poor and very poor.
5.5
BIT RECORDS
It is very important to keep records of bit performance. For this purpose, a sample form duly filled is shown in Table 5.12. In the form, anything that has to appear on the original blank form, is printed on gray background. Whatever appears on white background is the data to be filled by the user. Sample data is filled up in these cells for guidance. All the data mentioned in the form, including the name of the company, drill models bit manufacturers etc., is hypothetical. Since the data have been chosen arbitrarily, two values of otherwise dependent factors may not even have any correlation. Therefore, the data should not be used for drawing any conclusions. Instructions for filling the form are as follows.
5.5.1
General data
All the details to be filled in are self explanatory. They can be obtained from geographical and meteorological records of the mine site.
Book.indb 109
11/22/2010 2:35:22 PM
Table 5.12 Sample bit record form. Indian Copper Ltd.
Head Office - 1732, Uttung Towers, 9th Road, Andheri, Mumbai 400053. Mines - Anypore, Bihar; Malanjkhand, Madhya Pradesh.
Tricone Bit Record
Date :- April 14, 1997
General Data Mine Location
Malanjkhand
Block Name
17H
Altitude in m
1000
Approximate Temp. in °C
24
Waste Type
Granite
Ore Name
Chalcopyrite
UCS of Waste in MPa
220
UCS of Ore in MPa
100
DRI of Waste
38
DRI of Ore
68
Special Details of the Block
The block has very low percentage of intermixed ore and therefore all the blasted and excavated material will be treated as waste
Formation Data
Blasthole Drill And Accessories Details Make and Model
Bucyrus Intl. 39R
Drill Recorder and GPS
Drill Recorder Yes, GPa None
Maximum Bit Weight (kN)
540
Max. Rotary Speed (RPM)
160
Air Discharge (m3/min)
85.5
Air Pressure (kPa)
448
Drill Pipe Diameter (mm)
273
Single Pass Length (m)
13.7
Drill Bit Diameter (mm)
349
Stabilizer Type
Roller Stabilizer
Bit Performance Details Bit Make Bit Model
Serial No.
Meters Drilled
Assay. No.
Ore
Waste
Total
Hours in Use
Bit Weight kN
ROP in m/h
RPM
Perform. Class
Hughes
HH55
AA123
722K
-
2615
2615
38.5
67.92
360 - 380
50 - 60
G+
Smith
Q5JL
BQ117
573H
1320
1257
2577
48.25
53.41
350 - 370
60 - 70
A+
Reed
MCM
AJ338
119P
837
1570
2407
53
45.42
360 - 380
45 - 60
A
Security
M8M
ZZ101
357S
889
1805
2694
55.5
48.54
350 - 390
50 - 60
G
Bit Discard Details Serial Number
AA123
BQ117
AJ338
Discard Reasons
BF, RG
NF
SW, LR
ZZ101 BT
Cone Number
1
2
3
1
2
3
1
2
3
1
2
3
Bearing Condition
7
6
7
7
7
8
7
7
7
6
6
5
Spear point Condition
5
0
0
7
0
0
2B
C
1M
7
6
7
Inner Teeth Condition
5
5
5
6
6
6
1B1M
3B
C
5
6
6
6B1M
1B
8B2M
5
5
4
1B
1M
2B
1B
2B
2M
Gage Condition NOTES -
Book.indb 110
11/22/2010 2:35:22 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
5.5.2
111
Formation data
UCS means Unconfined Compressive Strength. DRI means Drilling Rate Index. Both these values are determined in a rock testing laboratory. In most of the mining operations the type of rock in which blastholes are drilled does not change very frequently. Hence the tests for UCS and DRI are carried out only when a substantial change is experienced in penetration rate, bit wear etc. In the item ‘Specific Details of the Block’, as many relevant details of the rock mass as possible are to be given.
5.5.3
Blasthole drill and accessories details
All the details to be filled in, are self-explanatory. These can be copied from the manufacturers’ details of the blasthole drill and accessories.
5.5.4
Bit performance details
Bit details, viz. bit type, serial no., assembly no., etc. are embossed on the pin as shown in Figure 5.8 from where they should be copied. ROP means the net rate of penetration which equals meters drilled divided by hours spent on actual drilling operation. Time for moving the drill to the blasthole location, leveling the drill, adding or removing the drill pipe etc. should not be included in the actual drilling operation hours. Bit weight should be mentioned in terms of kN i.e. if the pulldown ranged between 550 kN and 580 kN the figure to be entered in the column should be 550–580. RPM means rotary speed in revolutions per minute. The range should be mentioned by choosing the fastest and slowest speed. For entering proper values in the bit weight and RPM columns, data may be obtained from the drilling recorder provided in the blasthole drill. Abbreviations meant for indicating the performance class have been mentioned in earlier sections.
5.5.5
Bit discard details
Discard reasons should be mentioned by using the abbreviations given in Table 5.11. Bearing, spear point and inner teeth conditions should be mentioned for each of the three cones of the bit by estimating the amount of wear in terms of levels 0 to 8 (Table 5.12). Here 0 means virtually no wear and 8 means full wear. If some inserts of the bit have broken or are missing, the number of such inserts followed by B (broken) and M (missing) should be mentioned. Photographs of rejected bits may be taken in cases where the failure is abnormal and they should be stored systematically by modern methods of electronic data storage. For any additional details separate blank pages should be used. If a warranty claim for very poor performance of the bit is to be raised, the bit along with copies of the bit report form, corresponding drill recorder chart and the bit photograph must be sent to the manufacturer. The manufacturer is not likely to consider replacement without such information.
Book.indb 111
11/22/2010 2:35:23 PM
112
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Depending upon the manner in which bits have failed, it may be possible to repair and reuse some tricone bits. Many manufacturers do such types of refurbishing. Lastly, a discarded tricone rock bit may still have tungsten carbide inserts, silver alloy etc. and can fetch some salvage value. Therefore, it should be preserved for a meaningful salvage. 5.6
BIT FAILURE ANALYSIS AND REMEDY
Table 5.13 gives many types of bit failures along with their photographs and discusses the reasons of failure as well as some suggested remedial actions for achieving better performance. Table 5.13 Bit failure analysis and remedial measures. The teeth of this bit are worn out only at the surface that touched the bottom of the blasthole. Teeth on the inner portion of the cone are intact. Spiral marks can be easily observed at the worn out surface. This means that the bit failed prematurely because the rollers, somehow, got locked and drilling operation was carried out by friction scraping of the formation at the bottom of the hole much like that of a diamond bit. Tricone bits are primarily designed for crushing action with little scraping associated with it due to offset. Such failure can be easily noticed by an attentive operator because the penetration rate drops suddenly and the torque required for rotating the drill string increases suddenly. Wear on the gage teeth of this bit is much more than that on the inner teeth. Such failure pattern can be encountered when medium soft but very abrasive formations, such as sandstone, are drilled with a bit meant for drilling non abrasive formations. Obviously the selection of this bit must have been incorrect. A bit with better gage protection such as H or T gage with gage hardfacing or a milled tooth bit with TC inserts on the gage will give better performance in the formation. Excessive wear of the teeth can be seen on all the three cones. Further the wear is uniform from gage to the center of the cone as well as all around the cone. If the bit has failed prematurely the reason of failure must have been excessive weight on the bit. Excessive weight can result in quick wear of the tip of the teeth and once the carburized portion at the tip of the teeth is worn out the inner portion wears very easily as it is not hardened. Operating drill with lesser feed force may give better performance. Such a wear can be caused when the bit is rotated in hard and abrasive formations at a high speed without adequate feed force. Rotary speed in such conditions causes wear on the bit in a manner similar to grinding action. Performance of the bit will improve by reducing the rotary bit or alternatively by choosing a harder formation bit which has more number of teeth.
(Continued)
Book.indb 112
11/22/2010 2:35:23 PM
Table 5.13 (Continued) In this bit very heavy wear on the shirttail and the gage inserts of left hand side cone is clearly visible. Such failure can be caused when the bit is coupled to a bent drill pipe. Rotary motion given to such a pipe always cause very heavy side thrust through the bit. In particular, one or two of the cones have to bear the load to a much greater extent than the others. Such failure can also occur if the carbide inserts of the bit brake loose and remain in a position just above the cone due to insufficient flushing. Remedial action will be in replacing the damaged drill pipe. In this bit the wear on all the three cones of the bit is very similar. The inserts on the gage of all the three cones have broken but comparatively much less wear can be seen on the inner cones. Such wear pattern can occur when a bit meant for drilling in the soft formation is used for drilling very hard formations. In such conditions the force to which the gage inserts are subjected is very high. Remedial action will be to choose a proper hard formation bit.
In this picture a vertical crack can be seen on the pin of the bit. Besides some damage to the threads of the pin shown by another bunch of arrows can also be seen in the middle of the pin. Such thread damage and cracks are formed when the bit is cross threaded to the drill pipe or the stabilizer and is used for drilling. Remedial measure will be to remove the drill pipe or the stabilizer with damaged threads of the box. Normally the box of the drill pipe or stabilizer. Bearing failure of the bit can be easily observed in upper photograph. The failure is so predominant that the rollers of the bearing have been lost. The bearing failure can be seen only on one of the three cones. For further investigations when the three legs of the bit were separated, it could be seen that the thrust button below the cone of which the bearing failed, had bent as shown in the lower photograph.This must have resulted in very little or no air circulation through the bearing. Consequently the bearings and the surrounding surface got hot and the carburized case as well as the bearings must have lost hardness.The journals of the bearings of other two cones were intact. A centrally located crack, all along the seam of the two legs, can be observed on the bit. Such a failure can occur if the bit was accidentally dropped to the bottom of the hole.The impact experienced by the bit was so high that the tensile stresses developed along the seam were higher than the strength of the weld. Alternatively such failure can occur if the stress relieving operations during the process of manufacturing the bit were not done or were not properly carried out. A centrally located crack, all along the seam of the two legs, can be observed on the bit. Such a failure can occur if the bit was accidentally dropped to the bottom of the hole. The impact experienced by the bit was so high that the tensile stresses developed along the seam were higher than the strength of the weld. Alternatively such failure can occur if the stress relieving operations were not done or were not properly carried out during the process of manufacturing the bit. (Continued)
Book.indb 113
11/22/2010 2:35:25 PM
114
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Table 5.13 (Continued) The cone of this bit has broken circumferentially. The nose and inner portion of the cone has been lost. The bearings under the cone have been exposed and some have been lost. When bearing of a bit fails the cones may interfere with each other and only one of the three cones gets subjected to full weight on the bit. In such circumstances this type of failure occurs. The cone of the bit has cracked near the shirt tail of the bit. This type of failure can take place when the bit is dropped in the blasthole with a heavy drill string weight on it. Such failure can also be caused by loading the bit with excessive bit weight in extremely hard formation. One of the three legs of the bit is completely broken and lost. This type of failure takes place when a bit is dropped or when it hits a ledge in the blasthole or when it hits. If the leg has a crack and that has remain undetected in the quality control checks the failure of this type can take place very easily. One cone of the bit is completely lost. The other cone is also broken circumferentially. This failure can be considered as advanced stage of cone breakage because a cone can be completely lost only when one cone breaks circumferentially. The root cause of this type of failure is the bearing failure which in turn is caused by when one of the three cones gets subjected to the full weight exerted on the bit.
5.7
DISCARDING DRILL BITS
Bits wear out when used for drilling. In some cases the loss of gage is intolerable or in other cases the penetration rate drops down to an unacceptable level. A driller must know what is meant by ‘intolerable’ or unacceptable. Drilling with a bit that has lost its gage will give lower blasthole volume. The quantity of explosive accommodated in the blasthole will thus be lower, and insufficient for achieving the desired level of fragmentation. Generally the tolerance level of a quantity of explosive in a blasthole is about 8%. Therefore, a drill bit should be discarded when the cross sectional area of the hole reduces to 92% of the original. This happens when the diameter of the bit reduces to about 0.96 times the original nominal diameter. It is very uneconomical to continue drilling with a bit that is giving low penetration rate because the blasthole drill that costs several hundred times more than the cost of a drill bit, is being utilized wastefully for merely saving the cost of a bit. Solutions to these situations are in sharpening the bit by grinding to give a faster penetration rate, or in a very few cases welding hardmetal by special electrodes. Blade type drag bits can easily be reconditioned by blade grinding. Hardmetal side welding to restore gage is a bit more difficult but can be tried. As such, blade bits can be used almost to complete destruction.
Book.indb 114
11/22/2010 2:35:28 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling bits
115
Percentage of Penetration Rate of the New Bit
The teeth of a claw type drag bit can be changed when penetration rate is unacceptable. It is possible to grind these tips and reuse them, but in most cases this will result in a serious loss of gage so replacing the peripheral inserts is very essential. Steel tooth tricone bits are not subjected to grinding because in grinding the hardened surface is seriously weakened and cannot be restored. If a steel tooth bit is reused after grinding, it may give satisfactory penetration rate for a very short duration but very soon will become worth discarding. Thus, the reuse will not be worth the cost incurred in grinding and keeping the drill functionally idle while changing the bit. TC (tungsten carbide) insert tricone bits can be subjected to grinding if the wear on the inserts is very high and the bit is otherwise, i.e. from the viewpoint of bearing condition etc. in good condition. Figure 5.24 shows the manner in which the penetration rate of a tricone bit reduces with the increase in bit wear. The actual curve for a bit lies within the shaded area and the curvature is very similar to the upper or lower limiting curve. Averages of the data indicate that in the case of tricone bits, a completely worn out bit gives only 20% penetration rate as compared to the new bit. Whether to continue drilling till the bit is completely worn out, is more of an economical decision rather than a technical one. From the economic angle this topic has been discussed in the chapter on costing. It is not out of place to mention here that many bit manufacturers conduct short training courses about use of their drill bits in the field. Such training courses can also be arranged at the worksite office. Attempts should be made to arrange such a training course so that many drillers can take advantage of it.
100 80
60 40
20 0
0
20
40
60
80
100
Percentage of Bit Wear Figure 5.24 Reduction in penetration rate with bit wear.
Book.indb 115
11/22/2010 2:35:29 PM
Chapter 6
Rotary blasthole drilling accessories
6.1
INTRODUCTION
Besides a drill bit, the other components in a rotary blasthole drill string are a stabilizer, drill pipes, a shock absorber and crossover subs. Apart from their specific individual functions, all these components have three common functions viz: 1 2 3
Transmitting the feed force exerted by the feed mechanism of the blasthole drill to the drill bit. Transmitting the rotary motion generated at the rotary head of the blasthole drill to the drill bit. Allowing a continuous flow of compressed air to the next lower component in the drill string without significant pressure loss.
During the transmission of feed force and torque, the components are subjected to very heavy vibrations and must be very strong in their fatigue life. Blasthole drilling operations also require some more items that are not part of drill string but are frequently needed for some specific purpose. Specific information on these accessories is given in the following elaboration.
6.2
DRILL PIPES
The drill pipe is a very important component of a drill string. In all the rotary blasthole drills, the drill pipes are stored in a pipe changer fitted in the mast and are mechanically added to the drill string as the drilling advances, or removed and stored back in the pipe changer when the drill string is being withdrawn after completion of the blasthole. Drill pipes used in rotary blasthole drilling are flush type – meaning that their outside diameter is the same through out their length. They have a box connection (i.e. female threads) at one end and a pin connection (i.e. male threads) at the other end. They have wrench flats near both their ends to facilitate easy coupling or uncoupling by the wrenches provided in the blasthole drill. Drill pipes are of two types – fabricated or integral. Both are illustrated in Figure 6.1.
Book.indb 117
11/22/2010 2:35:30 PM
118
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Upper Tool Joint Fabricated Drill Pipe
Lower Tool Joint
Lower Connection
Wrench Flat
Weld
Seamless Tube
Weld
Wrench Flat
Upper Connection Integral DrillPipe Upper Tool Joint
Figure 6.1 Fabricated and integral drill pipes.
6.2.1
Integral drill pipes
Integral drill pipes are made from solid alloy steel bars and as such they are in one piece. They have a central bore of uniform diameter through which compressed air flows to the bit. As the wall thickness of integral drill pipes is large, they are very heavy and sturdy. Due to large wall thickness they are stiff, and their susceptibility to buckling under heavy feed force is very low. Integral drill pipes are made from alloy steel, such as ANSI 4145, and are surface hardened by heat treatment. Compared to fabricated drill pipes, integral drill pipes are expensive but have much longer life. Single piece integral drill pipes are available in lengths up to about 12 m.
6.2.2
Fabricated drill pipes
Fabricated drill pipes have three pieces, viz. upper tool joint, seamless tube and lower tool joint, welded together. The upper and lower tool joints are made from alloy steels such as ANSI 4140 or 4145. The seamless tube is made from standard carbon steels such as A-106B or J55. Some manufacturers use an alloy steel tube of the same material as that of the tool joint so as to enable uniform heat treatment to be given to the complete drill pipe. Due to lesser weight and manufacturing cost, the price of fabricated drill pipes is relatively low. Fabricated drill pipes have a large diameter bore. Therefore air pressure loss in these pipes is slightly less compared to integral drill pipes. For large diameter drill pipes, tubes with larger wall thickness are chosen. Such thick tubes enable the drill pipes to withstand very heavy compressive and shear stresses generated by heavy feed force and torque exerted by the blasthole drill. Details of standard fabricated and integral drill pipes are given in Appendix 11 at the end of this book. The length of tubes used for fabricating drill pipes is normally limited to about 12 m. Longer drill pipes, of length ranging between 13.71 to 21.3 m length are also required for some blasthole drills. In such case many manufacturers use special welding techniques to weld two tubes end to end, and then add the tool joints to the long
Chapter 06.indd 118
11/22/2010 3:33:05 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling accessories
119
tube. This alternative is better than using two shorter drill pipes permanently coupled together. Tool joints, i.e. box or pin type end connections of the drill pipes, are either API Regular or BECO type. API Regular tool joints originate from the oilwell drilling industry. For a long time they were successfully used for drill pipes in the long rotary drill string used for oilwell drilling. In the beginning of rotary blasthole drilling, they were adopted for the short drill strings of rotary blasthole drilling also. In the late 1950s Bucyrus Erie Company developed BECO tool joint with a coarser BECO thread form. Profiles of the thread forms used for API and BECO tool joints are shown in Figure 6.2 and their dimensional details are given in Table 6.1 and 6.2 respectively. Profile and dimensional details of the API Regular tool joints are in Figure 6.3 and Table 6.3. Profile and dimensional details of the BECO tool joints are in Figure 6.4 and Table 6.4. API threads were made from the viewpoint of deep drilling with fluid circulation. They were fine threads, so the cross section of the spiral tunnel formed between apex API Threads
P Box
Srn rcn H
h
r
Position of Spiral Tunnel Fcs
Fcn 60°
r 30°
rcs
fcn Pin Axis of Thread
90°
BECO Threads Box
T
P H
Position of Spiral Tunnel
30° 30° r
Pin 90°
Figure 6.2 Thread forms used for API and BECO tool joints.
Book.indb 119
11/22/2010 2:35:31 PM
120
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Table 6.1 Dimensional details of thread forms used for API regular tool joints. Thread form
Taper %
H in mm
hn = hs in mm
Srn = Srs in mm
fcn = fcs in mm
Fcn = Fcs in mm
rcn = rcs in mm
r in mm
V.0.040 V.0.050
25 25
4.38 5.47
2.99 3.74
0.51 0.63
0.88 1.09
1.02 1.27
0.51 0.63
0.38 0.38
Table 6.2 Dimensional details of thread form used for BECO tool joints. Thread form
Taper %
H in mm
P in mm
T ± 0.0508 in mm
r in mm
BECO
25
7.366
12.7
2.7686
1.1938
A
F 5/ 8” 30°
G
D
C
H – Threads Per Inch
B
E G
K – Inclination of the Taper
Figure 6.3 Profile of API regular tool joint. Table 6.3 Dimensional details of the API regular tool joint and thread forms used (All dimensions in mm). API pin size
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
K
Thread form
2–3/8 2–7/8 3–1/2 4–1/2 5–1/2 6–5/8 7–5/8 8–5/8
3 3–1/2 3–3/4 4–1/4 4–3/4 5 5–1/4 5–3/8
3–1/8 3–3/4 4–1/4 5–1/2 6–3/4 7–3/4 8–7/8 10
2–5/8 3 3–1/2 4–5/8 5–33/64 6 7 7–61/64
1–7/8 2–1/8 2–9/16 3–9/16 4–21/64 5–5/32 5–11/16 6–19/64
2–11/16 3–1/16 3–9/16 4–11/16 5–37/64 6–1/16 7–1/16 8–1/64
3–3/8 3–7/8 4–1/8 4–5/8 5–1/8 5–3/8 5–5/8 5–3/4
1 1–1/4 1–1/2 2–1/4 2–3/4 3–1/2 4 4–3/4
5 5 5 5 4 4 4 4
3 3 3 3 3 2 3 3
V-.040 V-.040 V-.040 V-.040 V-.050 V-.050 V-.050 V-.050
of male threads and trough of female threads was very small and did not allow any significant leak of the circulating fluid that was flowing under very high pressure. As against this, BECO threads were made for blasthole drilling, where the pressure of compressed air was low. Thus, despite the larger cross section, the leakage in the spiral tunnel was sufficiently low.
Book.indb 120
11/22/2010 2:35:31 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling accessories
A
121
F 5/8” 30°
G
D
H – Threads Per Inch
B E
C
G
K – Inclination of the Taper
Figure 6.4 Profile of BECO tool joint.
Table 6.4 Dimensional details of the BECO tool joint and thread forms used (Dimensions are in mm unless specified otherwise). BECO tool size
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H K Thread form
3″ BECO 3½″ BECO 4″ BECO 4½″ BECO 5¼″ BECO 6″ BECO 8″ BECO 10″ BECO 11″ BECO (11½″)
80 83 90 93 109 112 115 166 179
4½″ 5″ 5½″ 6¼″ 7½″ 8 5/8″ 10¾″ 13 3/8″ 15″
85.70 98.43 111.00 123.80 142.80 162.00 212.70 263.50 289.00
51.00 60.33 73.00 84.00 98.50 117.50 167.00 205.00 255.50
92.00 104.80 117.50 130.20 149.00 168.30 219.00 270.00 295.00
111.00 114.00 120.00 124.00 140.00 140.00 146.00 194.00 206.50
38.00 38.00 57.00 57.00 76.00 102.00 120.00 120.00 120.00
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
BECO Standard BECO Standard BECO Standard BECO Standard BECO Standard BECO Standard BECO Standard BECO Standard BECO Standard
Comparatively very coarse BECO threads enable the tool joint to have the following advantages: 1 2 3 4 5
Ease in frequent coupling and uncoupling of the drill pipes. Rigidity in the tool joint to reduce vibration. Leakproof when they are lubricated with thick grease that fills the spiral tunnel. Excellent ability in withstanding rough use. Much higher maximum torque rating as can be seen from Table 6.5.
Since all the above aspects are of greater importance in rotary blasthole drilling, BECO type connections are becoming more popular in rotary blasthole drilling practice. On many occasions purchasers are unaware of the difference between the drill pipes used in the oil or waterwell drilling industry and those used in the blasthole drilling industry. Purchase of inexpensive drill pipes meant for the waterwell drilling industry and their use for rotary blasthole drilling work can prove disastrous. Hence to avoid such instances, the differences are elaborated in Table 6.6.
Book.indb 121
11/22/2010 2:35:32 PM
122
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Table 6.5 Max. torque ratings of BECO and API reg. tool joints. BECO tool joint
API regular tool joint Maximum rated torque
Maximum rated torque
Drill pipe diameter in
mm
Tool loint name
lbft
Nm
Tool joint name
lbft
Nm
3.500 4.000 4.500 5.000 5.500 6.000 6.250 6.500 6.625 7.000 7.625 8.625 9.250 9.625 10.750 11.750 12.750 13.375 15.000
88.9 101.6 114.3 127 139.7 152.4 158.75 165.1 168.275 177.8 193.675 219.075 234.95 244.475 273.05 298.45 323.85 339.72 381
None None None 3½ BECO 3½ BECO 3½ BECO 4½ BECO 4½ BECO 4½ BECO 5¼ BECO 5¼ BECO 6 BECO 6 BECO 7 BECO 8 BECO 8 BECO 8 BECO 10 BECO 12 BECO
Nap Nap Nap 18000 18000 18000 24300 24300 24300 36300 36300 55600 55600 88000 120000 120000 120000 120000 NS
Nap Nap Nap 24405 24405 24405 32946 32946 32946 49216 49216 75383 75383 119312 162698 162698 162698 222100 NS
2 3/8 API R 2 7/8 API R 3½ API R 3½ API R 4½ API R 4½ API R 4½ API R 4½ API R 5½ API R 5½ API R 5½ API R 6 5/8 API R 6 5/8 API R 6 5/8 API R 6 5/8 API R 6 5/8 API R 6 5/8 API R 7 5/8 API R 8 5/8 API R
NS 7000 9500 9500 16000 16000 16000 16000 32000 32000 32000 44000 44000 44000 44000 44000 44000 70000 98000
NS 9491 12880 12880 21693 21693 21693 21693 43386 43386 43386 59656 59656 59656 59656 59656 59656 94907 132870
6.2.3
Choice of a drill pipe
For efficient blasthole drilling at fastest penetration rates, choosing the most appropriate drill pipe is of extreme importance. The choice is mainly related to the diameter of blasthole. The diameter of a blasthole is decided on the basis of many factors related to production requirements, blasting method, parameters pertaining to loading and hauling equipment used in the mine, etc. They are elaborated elsewhere in this book. Factors to be considered for choosing the appropriate drill pipe are: 1 2 3 4 5 6
Drill Pipe Weight Drill Pipe Dimensional Parameters Drill Pipe Surface Treatment Size and Shape of Drill Cuttings Bailing Velocity in the Blasthole Drill Pipe Wall Thickness
A logical method to be adopted for choosing the most appropriate drill pipe is presented in Chapter 10 of this book.
Book.indb 122
11/22/2010 2:35:32 PM
Rotary blasthole drilling accessories
123
Table 6.6 Comparison of drill pipes used for blasthole drilling with those used for oil well/water well drilling. Aspect
Oil well or water well drilling
Blasthole drilling
Dimensional precision
Need not be so exact as the pipes are not handled by a mechanical pipe changer but are stacked loosely near the mast. Length is medium i.e. often of the order of 9 m. Often 3 drill pipes are stacked without being separated.
Has to be very precise as they are handled by a mechanical pipe changer. Length is long. Mostly more than 9 m. Often as much as 18 to 21 m. They are stored singularly in a pipe changer. Since the pipes are subjected to high compressive forces during drilling hence they are susceptible to buckling. For this reason the thickness of drill pipe has to be large so the moment of inertia increases. The weight of the drill pipe is very important as they are stored in a pipe rack and affect the stability of drill. Surface hardening treatment is very essential because the pipes are continuously subjected to sand blasting from the large rock cuttings that travel upwards through the annulus at a very high uphole velocity.
Length
Thickness
Are relatively thin as they are mainly subjected to high tensile stresses while drilling or very low compressive stresses while being stacked. There is no question of buckling of these drill pipes.
Weight
The weight of drill pipe does not matter as the drill pipes are stored on ground.
Wear Properties and surface hardening
The velocity of flushing water is low. The size of particles is also small. Hence these pipes are not subjected to very high external abrasion. Surface hardening treatment of the drill pipes is not very essential when used for water well drilling. In oil well drilling it may be necessary because when holes are deviated intentionally the pipes rub against the walls of the hole. Sealing properties are very important as the pressure inside the pipe bore and that in the annulus differ very greatly. Small pitch threads or special threads that have a very small cross section of the spiral tunnel at the apexes of the threads, are used for tool joints.
Threads
6.3
Sealing properties are not very important as the pressure inside the pipe bore and that in the annulus is nearly the same. BECO threads are preferred for tool joints.
STABILIZERS
Even though the depth of the blasthole is shallow, the characteristics of the formations lying on its alignment are not truly uniform. They change in terms of voids, cracks, compressive strength etc. If drilling is continued in a blasthole having formation conditions as shown in Figure 6.5, the direction of progress of the blasthole tends to deviate from the intended direction. Reasons for such deviation are: 1 2
Book.indb 123
Male and female threads of the tool joint of the drill pipe are not perfect. Due to the bend caused, the feed force exerted on the drill bits is not truly axial. Drill pipe is relatively slender.
11/22/2010 2:35:32 PM
124
Rotary drilling and blasting in large surface mines
Drill Pipe Upward Air Flow of Compressed Air Flow Used For Flushing Blasthole Wall
Drill Bit Soft Rock
Hard Rock Deviated Path of the Blasthole Intended Path of the Blasthole
Figure 6.5 Blasthole deviation.
3
4 5
A large gap between outer surface of the drill pipe and the walls of the hole may allow the drill pipe to buckle under heavy feed force exerted by the feed mechanism of the drill. Vibrations are caused by imperfect material balance in the drill string. The length that effectively resists hole deviation is only the short length of about 100 to 200 mm of the drill bit shoulder.
Besides deviation, the hole may also not be truly cylindrical as it assumes a spiral shape. Disadvantages of having deviated blastholes are: 1
2
3
The periphery i.e. the shirttail of the tricone bit undergoes non-uniform