The Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Nobuyuki Nakajima
Contents
1
Introduction ...
802 downloads
3445 Views
13MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Nobuyuki Nakajima
Contents
1
Introduction .................................................................................................... 5 1.1
2
3
Polymerisation and molecular architecture ............................................ 5 1.1.1
Natural rubber ........................................................................... 5
1.1.2
Styrene-butadiene copolymer ..................................................... 5
1.1.3
Polybutadiene ............................................................................ 8
1.1.4
Nitrile rubber ............................................................................. 9
1.1.5
Ethylene-propylene terpolymer ................................................ 10
1.1.6
Polyethylacrylate ...................................................................... 10
1.1.7
Polydimethyl siloxane .............................................................. 11
1.1.8
Masterbatches .......................................................................... 11
1.2
What is rubber? ................................................................................... 11
1.3
Formulation ......................................................................................... 14
1.4
Mixing equipment ............................................................................... 15
Mill Processability ......................................................................................... 23 2.1
Mastication and mill processability ..................................................... 23
2.2
Interpretation of mill processability ..................................................... 25
2.3
Science of mill processability................................................................ 27
Overview of Mixing of Rubber ..................................................................... 33 3.1
Unit processes ...................................................................................... 33
3.2
Interpretation of the mixing process .................................................... 35
3.3
Compaction as a part of the mechanism in incorporating carbon black into an elastomer ............................................................ 42
i
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
4
5
6
ii
3.3.1
Introduction ............................................................................. 42
3.3.2
Experiment-I ............................................................................ 42
3.3.3
Results-I ................................................................................... 44
3.3.4
Discussion-I ............................................................................. 51
3.3.5
Experiment-II ........................................................................... 55
3.3.6
Results-II ................................................................................. 56
3.3.7
Discussion-II ............................................................................ 68
Viscoelasticity and Fracture ........................................................................... 71 4.1
Introduction to viscoelasticity .............................................................. 71
4.2
Viscoelasticity for characterisation....................................................... 77
4.3
Viscoelastic behaviour of rubber in an internal mixer .......................... 78
4.4
Mechanism of fracture of gum rubber ................................................. 81
Characterisation of Gum Rubber Using Dilute Solution Methods .......................................................................................... 87 5.1
Introduction ......................................................................................... 87
5.2
Gel determination ................................................................................ 90
5.3
Dilute solution method ........................................................................ 92
5.4
Relationship between dilute solution properties and processability ... 100
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber ............................................. 103 6.1
Introduction ....................................................................................... 103
6.2
Methods of describing deformation ................................................... 103
6.3
Non-linear viscoelasticity ................................................................... 106
6.4
Conventional methods of characterisation ......................................... 110
6.5
Characterisation based on viscoelasticity ........................................... 113
6.6
Processability and molecular structure ............................................... 126
6.7
Processability and viscoelastic characteristics..................................... 128
Contents
6.8
7
6.7.1
Cis-1,4-polybutadiene ............................................................ 128
6.7.2
Polyethylacrylate .................................................................... 165
Linear viscoelasticity .......................................................................... 175 6.8.1
Linear viscoelasticity and mixing of rubber ........................... 176
6.8.2
Relaxation time and its distribution ....................................... 176
6.8.3
Linear viscoelasticity as a conceptual background for the mixing of rubber .............................................................. 180
6.8.4
Viscoelasticity and memory ................................................... 181
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Rubber Compounds ................................................................................................. 189 7.1
Introduction ....................................................................................... 189
7.2
Viscoelastic properties of compounds ................................................ 189
7.3
Strain- and strain-rate amplification .................................................. 198
7.4
Unique characteristics of compounds ................................................. 207
7.5
Application of characterisation methods for a specific problem ......... 208 7.5.1
8
9
Effect of fillers and rubber structures on tensile behaviour of filled, unvulcanised compounds of cis-1,4-polybutadiene ............................................................. 208
Rheology of Gum Rubber and Compound.................................................. 227 8.1
Rheometry ......................................................................................... 227
8.2
Slip ..................................................................................................... 236
8.3
Extrudate shrinkage ........................................................................... 238
8.4
Yielding ............................................................................................. 243
8.5
Effect of concentration and structure of carbon black ....................... 246 8.5.1
Hydrodynamic theories .......................................................... 246
8.5.2
Concentration dependence ..................................................... 248
Reinforcing Fillers and Liquid Additives ..................................................... 251
iii
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
9.1
9.2
Reinforcing fillers .............................................................................. 251 9.1.1
Introduction ........................................................................... 251
9.1.2
Mixing ease of fillers.............................................................. 251
9.1.3
Structure of aggregate and agglomerate ................................. 259
Liquid additives ................................................................................. 269
10 The Energy Aspects of Mixing Rubber........................................................ 273 10.1 Introduction ....................................................................................... 273 10.2 Energy balance ................................................................................... 273 10.2.1 Experiment ............................................................................ 274 10.2.2 Experimental programme ...................................................... 275 10.2.3 Results ................................................................................... 277 10.2.4 Summary ............................................................................... 288 11 Mixing Mechanisms .................................................................................... 291 11.1 Introduction ....................................................................................... 291 11.2 Problems associated with internal mixers .......................................... 291 11.3 Approach to simulation ..................................................................... 293 11.4 Proposed model of a mixing mechanism ............................................ 294 11.4.1 Changes in material during mixing ........................................ 294 11.4.2 Mechanical actions ................................................................ 296 11.4.3 Material-machine interaction ................................................. 299 11.4.4 Macroscopic versus microscopic deformation........................ 300 11.5 Modelling of the fracture of rubber particles ..................................... 301 11.5.1 Material ................................................................................. 301 11.5.2 Dynamic state of the elastomer .............................................. 302 11.5.3 Basic mixing model ................................................................ 303 11.5.4 Model of unit processes ......................................................... 304 11.6 Model of material behaviour in the internal mixer ............................ 306
iv
Contents
11.6.1 Material properties ................................................................ 306 11.6.2 Pressure profile in the internal mixer ..................................... 307 11.6.3 Deformation of material between rotor edge and chamber wall ......................................................................... 307 11.6.4 Probability and distribution in mixing ................................... 308 11.6.5 Calculation of mixing energy ................................................. 308 11.7 Discussion .......................................................................................... 310 11.8 Nano and molecular scale of mixing .................................................. 313 11.9 Chemical reactions during mixing ..................................................... 318 11.10 Optimisation of operation and improvements of mixers ................... 319 11.10.1 Introduction .......................................................................... 319 11.10.2 Optimum state of the elastomer for mixing .......................... 321 11.10.3 Improvements in rotor design ............................................... 322 12 Post-Mixing Processes ................................................................................. 331 12.1 Introduction ....................................................................................... 331 12.2 Extrusion ........................................................................................... 331 12.2.1 Causes of non-uniformity in feeding ...................................... 331 12.2.2 Material behaviour in the screw ............................................ 333 12.3.3 Flow mechanisms in the extruder .......................................... 336 12.2.4 Homogenisation devices before the die entrance and after the exit .................................................................... 339 12.3 Mixing and extrusion of high silica and all silica-natural rubber compounds ........................................................................................ 340 12.3.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 340 12.3.2 Samples .................................................................................. 341 12.3.3 Mixer and mixing conditions ................................................. 342 12.3.4 Extruder and extrusion test ................................................... 343 12.3.5 Results and discussion ........................................................... 344 12.4 Injection moulding ............................................................................. 356
v
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
12.4.1 Introduction ............................................................................ 356 12.4.2 Flow mechanisms .................................................................... 356 13 Material Testing, Quality Control and Process Control ........................................................................................... 365 13.1 Introduction ....................................................................................... 365 13.2 Material testing .................................................................................. 365 13.3 Test for the uniformity of gum rubber ............................................... 367 13.4 Mooney relaxation curve ................................................................... 371 13.5 Testing for uniformity of compound .................................................. 372 13.6 Process control ................................................................................... 373 14 Mixing of Rubber without using a Mill or Internal Mixer ............................................................................................ 379 14.1 Masterbatch ....................................................................................... 379 14.2 Continuous mixing ............................................................................ 380 14.3 Handling of new material .................................................................. 385 Abbreviations and Acronyms............................................................................. 387 Author Index ..................................................................................................... 391 Company Name Index ....................................................................................... 397 Main Index ........................................................................................................ 399
vi
Preface
Manufacturing rubber products requires the use of many additives. Therefore, mixing is a very important step in rubber processing. There have been extensive research efforts to understand the relationships between formulation and the product properties. On the other hand processes such as mixing and shaping have only recently become the focus of systematic inquiry. Recognising that there are more than 100 years history in the rubber industry and a number of possible combinations of ingredients in the rubber formulation, the accumulated knowledge of processing must be enormous. However, the knowledge of processing exists in fragments scattered as in-house ‘know-how’ among manufacturers and more likely as the personal experience of the individual operator. This work is an effort to summarise systematically the above fragmented knowledge within a unifying scheme, which is based on scientific principles. However, there are difficulties: first, there are so many variables that it is impossible to include every phase of the subject. Therefore, the treatment must be limited to highlights. Another difficulty is that information from practical experience is usually incomplete. For example, a decrease of Mooney index on milling is interpreted as a decrease of molecular weight, resulting from breaking of polymer chains. The chain-break, however, does not necessarily result in the decrease of molecular weight. It might create a larger molecule by generating long branches. Such a structure sometimes causes a decrease of Mooney index. Another lack of information is in the description of processability. Some rubber is reported to be poorly processed on the mill. However, there are at least three different causes of this problem. Unless the circumstances are known, the poor mixing cannot be explained. Along with a systematic treatment of the practical experience, the gap in knowledge as well as misconceptions must be pointed out. In the very beginning we must recognise the fact that there are two different definitions of ‘rubber’. One is based on the chemical make-up, such as natural rubber and polybutadiene. The other is based on its physical behaviour. Sometimes a statement is made, ‘after a long time (gum) rubber flows’. In this statement the ‘rubber’ is chemical by definition. The physical description is ‘after a long time the material is no longer a rubber because it flows’.
1
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The Mooney index is usually measured under the conditions, i.e., time and temperature, where the material behaviour is rubbery and not flow. Therefore, what is measured is not a viscosity. Yet, it is erroneously called Mooney viscosity. The deformation and fracture may be observable using coloured markers on the rubber specimen. The rubber behaviour in mixing is also in most cases, deformation and fracture instead of flow. Viscosity contributes only as a frictional heat generation. Namely, the material behaviour is viscoelastic, but the interpretation of mixing has by and large ignored viscoelasticity. One of the objectives of this book is to introduce viscoelasticity to those who are not familiar with this subject. The misconceptions and lack of understanding are not limited to the material behaviour, but also include molecular architecture. Although the importance of molecular weight and its distribution are well recognised, the subject of branching has been less critically examined. Often the presence of branches has a dominant influence on the rubber behaviour. In addition there are two aspects of this subject which are not well recognised. The first is a crossover phenomenon, in that the presence of long branches has an opposite effect depending upon the imposed conditions. For example, at long times or at low frequencies, the presence of long branches increases modulus, but at short times or high frequencies, it decreases the modulus. There are many examples of the crossover phenomena so that a statement like ‘the long branch does this or does that’, cannot be made. Another problem concerns various branch patterns. The behaviour of one pattern may be quite different from that of another. For example, a long branch may be so long that it gives strain-hardening upon stretching but if the other long branch is not as long, it will give strain-softening under the same conditions. Long branching with equal armstars or combs is a very special type and findings from these cannot be generalised to all branch patterns. Another subject of importance is a ‘gel’, which is present in many rubbers. The definition of the term is unique in the field of rubber and is different from that used in physical chemistry. In physical chemistry, gel is a solvent-swollen polymer, which is capable of supporting a finite stress. In the field of rubber, gel is a gigantic molecule but comes in different structures. This subject has not been explored sufficiently, but influence of gels on the mixing has been recognised to be important. Even when the relationship between the molecular architecture and the mixing behaviour are carefully investigated, a knowledge gained from one type of rubber, for example, ethylene-propylene-diene copolymer can not entirely be used to interpret the relationship in other types of rubber, such as butadiene-acrylonitrile copolymer.
2
Preface In order to understand mixing of rubber one has to have a breadth and depth of knowledge, including polymerisation processes and post-mixing processes such as extrusion and injection moulding. This book is written for students, teachers and those outside of the rubber industry. It is also written for those in rubber industry, who wish to acquire a scientific viewpoint. Last but not least it is written for the researchers in this field. In this regard subjects for future research are pointed out wherever appropriate. With varied readers in mind, each chapter is written in such a way that it may be read independently from others. The author wishes to thank many people who generously shared their experience and his former colleagues for their contributions.
Professor N Nakajima The University of Akron December 1999
3
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
4
1
Introduction
1.1 Polymerisation and molecular architecture Listed in Table 1.1 are a representative selection of commercially available rubbers. The commercial rubbers are those confined within the cost-performance window and there are other rubbers which may be synthesised, if needs arise. Some rubbers are used to perform mechanical functions only and others are used because of additional special features. Such features may be the outdoor- and chemical-stability, oil resistance and high temperature stability. Within each rubber there are many variations, i.e., commercial grades, which are finetuned for specific applications. Because each grade of rubber has its own processing characteristics, those who handle them need to know the properties of the rubbers that they use. Even for those who purchase rubbers for processing, some knowledge of their manufacture is helpful. For those who are in the marketing of rubbers, relationships between manufacturing conditions and processability must be understood for technical as well as economic reasons. Even though the description of the manufacturing of rubbers is outside of the scope of this book, some highlights need to be given. This will be done with selected group of rubbers. For further information on this topic, readers are referred to encyclopaedia [1] and review [2].
1.1.1 Natural rubber NR is the only natural product amongst those in Table 1.1. It is a cis-polyisoprene but contains a variety of impurities such as proteins and resins. It crystallises much more readily upon stretching compared to synthetic cis-polyisoprene, IR, which does not contain the impurities. NR has a very high molecular weight (MW) and contains long branches.
1.1.2 Styrene-butadiene copolymer SBR comes in two distinctly different forms. One is emulsion-polymerised, E-SBR and the other is solution-polymerised, S-SBR.
5
Commercial rubbers
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Table 1.1 Abbreviations of Representative Commercial Rubbers Natural Rubbers
NR
Styrene-butadiene copolymer
SBR
Styrene-isoprene-butadiene terpolymer
SIBR
Polyisoprene Acrylonitrile-butadiene copolymer Polychloroprene Ethylene-propylene copolymer Ethylene-propylene-diene terpolymer Polyisobutylene
IR NBR CR EPM EPDM IIR
Polyethylacrylate
ACM
Chlorosulphonated polyethylene
CSM
Polydimethylsiloxane
MQ
Vinylidene fluoride type polymer
FKM
Tetrafluoroethylene-propylene
TFEP
Tetrafluoroethylene-perfluoromethyl vinylether
FFKM
Fluorosilicone
FQ
Epichlorohydrin rubber
CO
Epichlorohydrin-ethyleneoxide
ECO
Polysulphide
T
Polyurethane
U
Chlorinated polyethylene
CP E
Ethylene vinylacetate polymer
EVA
Most of the E-SBR contains about 24% by weight of styrene and it is a random copolymer with butadiene. Some specific grades contain as much as 40~46% styrene, and are much stiffer. The polymerisation is by free radical initiator and there is a finite probability of chain-transfer reaction, which generates long branches. Because the chain-transfer targets
6
Introduction existing polymer chains, a larger molecule offers a better target. It results in a branched molecule becoming more branched. At the high conversion the polymer concentration within the emulsion droplets becomes very high and the long branches are more readily formed. The extensive formation of branches results in a gigantic molecule, which is called gel. The definition of the term ‘gel’ is unique to rubber technology and different from the one defined in physical chemistry; in the latter the gel is a solvent-swollen network, which is capable of supporting a finite stress. To a rubber technologist the gel is a constituent of gum rubber, and usually it has the same chemical composition to other parts of the rubber. Because the term has been used for so many years one has to accept it as is, but should not be confused with the definition of gel outside of the field of rubber. The determination of the amount of gel requires a good solvent for the rubber and subsequent filtration. Sometimes the presence of long branches and gel are ignored and the MW and its distribution are reported. Such information is misleading. The subject of the molecular architecture has a critical importance on the mixing behaviour and will be discussed later in more detail. Another important feature is the sequence [3] by which butadiene polymerises; it is called a ‘microstructure’, resulting from different ways of addition. A typical value for E-SBR is 13% cis-1,4, 69% trans-1,4 and 18% 1,2 addition. The 1,2 addition results in vinyl pendent group. A pendent group is a small side group, which usually has a different chemical composition from that of the main chain, e.g., the phenyl-group in SBR. If the composition is the same and it has a polymeric sequence it will be called a ‘branch’ in this book. E-SBR is one of the first commercial rubbers; in the early days of manufacture the polymerisation temperature was high and many long-branches and gels were formed. The rubber was stiff and difficult to mill. It was called ‘hot rubber’. Later polymerisation at a lower temperature became possible, giving less branches and gels; this is called ‘cold rubber’. Polymerisation temperature for hot rubber is typically 25-50 °C and that for cold rubber is 5-25 °C. Today most of the E-SBR is of the latter type, but some high-gel rubber is made for a special purpose. It may be made either at a higher temperature or carrying the polymerisation to a higher conversion at a lower temperature. S-SBR comes in two distinctly different subgroups, one made by an anionic initiator and the other by, for example, free radical initiators. The anionic rubbers have a very narrow MW distribution, sometimes called ‘monodispersed’; the expression is only symbolic and not accurate. This molecular feature results in a unique mixing behaviour. The rubber has no branches or gels unless specifically designed to have them. The MW distribution can also be broadened by design. The microstructure of butadiene portion is for example, 33% cis-1,4, 54% trans-1,4 and 13% vinyl.
7
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing However, a high vinyl rubber is also made. The styrene content may be varied widely. The chain-end may be modified to improve affinity to carbon black, resulting in a better dispersion of the filler. These variations in molecular architecture were developed for satisfying the requirements of automotive tyres for a low energy loss and a high skid resistance. The anionic polymerisation provides a flexibility in designing molecular architecture; such a flexibility is unavailable for the current practice of other polymerisation systems. S-SBR made from initiators other than anionic has a broader MW distribution, which depends upon the polymerisation conditions. The branching probability is much less than that in the emulsion polymerisation primarily because of the lower local concentration of polymer. The mechanisms of the long branch-formation are different for different initiator (catalyst) systems. This aspect will be discussed with butadiene (BR) polymerisation.
1.1.3 Polybutadiene BR is made with similar polymerisation systems as SBR. The molecular architecture of the anionic BR is essentially the same as that described for the anionic SBR. The microstructure is also the same and some high vinyl BR is also made. This system gives well-defined polymers, for example ‘monodispersed’ linear and equal-arm star molecules. The equal arm star molecule is a branched polymer with equal branch-lengths. These samples have been extensively investigated to obtain scientific information. BR made by emulsion polymerisation with a free radical initiator is used as the rubber component of a high impact polystyrene and acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene (ABS) resins. No discussion will be given on the molecular structure of this rubber. For those, who are interested in the relationship between molecular architecture and mixing behaviour, this is discussed in Section 1.1.2 on E-SBR. Cis-1,4-BR is one of the rubbers widely used for the automotive tyres. It has a high ciscontent (greater than 90%), and the remainder is vinyl. Because of its unique microstructure it must be regarded as a polymer, which is chemically different from other BRs. Use of the same symbol, BR, for all rubbers polymerised from butadiene, may be misleading. Cis-1,4-BR is polymerised with a catalyst, a metal-coordination complex, where the metal may be cobalt, neodymium, nickel or titanium and the rest consists of organic moieties having coordination bonding with the metal. A co-catalyst may also be used. The polymerisation mechanism is distinctly different from that in the free-radical system.
8
Introduction In the latter the growing end is the free radical, where the monomer reacts and keeps the chain growing. In the metal-complex system the growing polymer is attached to the metal and a monomer is inserted between the metal and the growing chain. The polymer chain is pushed out as it grows, in a similar way to the growth of a hair. Because the growth mechanisms are different between the free-radical and the metalcomplex systems, mechanisms of branch formation and resulting branch patterns are also quite different. The free radical of the growing-end, abstracts the hydrogen atom from other polymer-chain and thus terminates its growth. The other polymer chain, where hydrogen was abstracted, now has a radical at the site, which starts growing a new polymer branch. As explained using E-SBR as an example in Section 1.1.2, the branched chain becomes more branched and the branched-branches are the pattern. The extensive formation of branches results in gigantic molecules, called gels. The mechanism of branch-formation in the metal-complex system is insertion; instead of the monomer being inserted, a grown polymer chain becomes inserted, i.e., a macromer insertion. Because the vinyl group in cis-BR is more reactive than the double-bond along the main chain, the vinyl is the most likely group to be inserted. There is a trend that when the vinyl content is higher in the rubber, there are more long branches. Because the macromer is more difficult to insert than the monomer, the branch-formation is not frequent. Once branching occurs an additional branch-formation becomes less likely because of the steric effect. Therefore, not only the branch pattern is different from that in the free-radical systems, but also there is no gel formation. The degree and length of branching depend upon the availability of the macromer and the nature of the catalyst site. For example, cobalt-based cis-1,4-BR shows significant branching with increased conversion [4] and the presence of chain insertion to aluminium alkyl during polymerisation was suggested for the neodymium catalyst system [5]. It has also been shown that the degree of branching can be controlled by a use of a highly reactive catalyst and co-catalyst [6].
1.1.4 Nitrile rubber NBR is made as an emulsion with a free radical initiator. Therefore, the mechanisms of polymerisation and branch (gel) formation are very similar to those of E-SBR. Polymers are made with an acrylonitrile (AN) content of, for example, 28, 33 or 40 weight percent, depending upon the required oil resistance. The copolymerisation is described as ‘random’ but the reactivity ratio is such that it is biased towards an alternating sequence. Because of this and because AN is the minor component, it is used up early and polymer formation at a later stage of polymerisation becomes butadiene rich [7]. In order to have a uniform composition among polymer chains, the monomer mixture of the prescribed ratio is ‘metered in’ with the progress of polymerisation.
9
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing A special grade contains as much as 70% gel, which is a ‘tree-like’ branched molecule. Another special grade is made with a ‘crosslinking termonomer’, a difunctional monomer. This makes a microscopic network of the emulsion polymer, a ‘micro ping pong ball’. This is also called a gel, but has a different molecular architecture. In order to differentiate these two types, the former has been called a ‘macro-gel’ and the latter ‘microgel’. The above terms originated from the work-place and became accepted widely but only within rubber technology. Concerning the microgel there are two different usages even within the field. With rubbers made by methods other than emulsion polymerisation, micro ping pong balls are not made. With these rubbers, the term ‘microgel’ is sometimes used for a smaller sized tree-like molecule. In this case the difference between macro and micro is only a difference in degree. On the other hand with the emulsion polymerised rubbers there is a distinct difference between micro- and macro-gel in structure and in processability.
1.1.5 Ethylene-propylene terpolymer EPM and EPDM are made using a metal coordination complex. Although there are minor variations, it is generally called ‘Ziegler-Natta’ polymerisation. MW distribution varies and not ‘monodispersed’ like that in the anionic polymerisation. EPMs are linear. EPDM contains a difunctional comonomer, either ethylidene-norbornene (ENB) or dicyclopentadiene (DCPD). These comonomers are there to provide crosslinking sites for vulcanisation. However, some crosslinking occurs during polymerisation, resulting in long branch formation. The branch pattern may lead to a branched-branch and to a gel formation. Here also, the degree of long branching and that of gel are very important to the processability.
1.1.6 Polyethylacrylate This rubber is made by the emulsion polymerisation with a free radical initiator. Therefore, the mechanisms of polymerisation and the long-branch (gel) formation are the same as those of SBR and NBR. However, there are some significant differences in the nature of the chain: (i)
it has a large pendent group, which forms 73% of its MW so that it is a fat and short chain for a given MW.
(ii)
it is a polar polymer, having a polar group on every other carbon atom along the chain.
10
Introduction (iii)
it has a saturated chain so that a cure-site comonomer is copolymerised for providing crosslinking sites. It is called a ‘homopolymer’ commercially. The ‘copolymer’ contains a third monomer in the chain.
1.1.7 Polydimethyl siloxane MQ is usually made by a condensation polymerisation, which gives a theoretically dictated ‘equilibrium’ molecular-weight-distribution. This means there is significant amount of the low MW fraction. The extremely low MW fraction is removed prior to finish manufacturing. However, the intermediate low MW fraction weakens the crosslinked product, because the free-ends do not contribute to the strength. The condensation mechanism does not create a very high MW tail, which is often found with other rubbers. The polymer may also be made with an anionic system. In this case the MW distribution is very narrow and it does not contain a low MW fraction.
1.1.8 Masterbatches Some gum rubbers come with preblended oil or preblended carbon black. They are called ‘oil-masterbatch’ or ‘carbon black masterbatch’, respectively. The oil is called ‘extending oil’ and is either aliphatic, naphthenic or an aromatic fraction of petroleum. Some standard grades of E-SBR oil masterbatch contain 37.5-50 parts oil by parts per hundred by weight of rubber (phr). However, the oil masterbatch does not give an oily surface and it is not easy to distinguish it from non-oil extended rubber. Gum rubber used to prepare the oil masterbatch usually has a very high MW and long branches. Without the preblended oil, it may be difficult to mill. Because of these molecular features, the products made from the masterbatch have good strength in spite of the presence of large amount of oil. Oil masterbatches are among the standard grades in E-SBRs, cis-1,4-BRs and EPDMs. The carbon black masterbatches are also among the standard grades in E-SBR and cis1,4-BR. The amount of carbon black is typically 50 or 100 phr. With a use of a masterbatch a better dispersion of carbon black may be obtained.
1.2 What is rubber? In this book the word ‘rubber’ means uncrosslinked raw material unless stated otherwise. By posing the question ‘what is rubber?’ we are concerned with fundamental but very common sense meaning of the term.
11
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The word, rubber usually indicates such substances as NR, SBR and so on. But, this does not lead to the definition of rubber. The definition is actually based on a very simple experience: (i)
A rubber material allows a large deformation without break; it stretches easily several times and even more than fifteen times in some case.
(ii)
The deformation recovers almost 100% instantly.
The substances usually called rubber, exhibit the above behaviour at ambient conditions. However, the same substance called rubber loses the behaviour (i) at low temperatures, becoming a glass. When a rubber is heated to a high temperature, it becomes a viscous fluid, losing the behaviour described in (ii). Here the word, rubber, is used in two different ways; one is referring to specific substances such as natural rubber and SBR. The other is an expression of mechanical behaviour for material at a specific temperature range. In the rest of the book the former will be termed as gum rubber and the latter as the rubbery state or rubbery behaviour. Among the substances encountered daily, there are many which exhibit behaviour (i) such as hot candies and bread dough; but they do not exhibit behaviour (ii). On the other hand most solids behave as (ii) but break without giving large deformation (i). The rubber is the only substance which satisfies both conditions (i) and (ii). Stated differently, any substance which shows both (i) and (ii) behaviour is a rubber, regardless of its chemical nature. Namely, the definition of rubber is based on purely physical behaviour. This is in contrast to chemically based definitions of substances such as carbohydrates, alcohols and hydrocarbons. A substance exhibiting rubbery behaviour may become glassy if a very high rate of deformation is imposed. This is rather difficult to demonstrate, because extremely high rates are required. On the other hand, if the rate is very low, it deforms permanently, i.e., flows. This is also difficult to demonstrate, but is observable with relatively low MW rubber. When bales of such a rubber are stuck on top of the others, the bottom bale may show a ‘cold flow’ over a long period of time. Because a high rate of deformation corresponds to a short time, we can see that the rubbery behaviour is manifested only within a certain time-frame. It is manifested within a certain temperature-frame also. Putting the time and temperature frames together, it is called the ‘time-temperature window’. Only when a polymer is within this window, does it exhibit rubbery behaviour. Outside of the window at the higher rates (shorter times) or
12
Introduction at a lower temperature, it is glassy. At the lower rates (longer time) or the higher temperature, it is a high viscosity fluid. Even though the definition of rubber is based on physical aspects only, there must be structural features which provide rubbery behaviour. In fact, there are three structural requirements for a given substance to be a rubber. First, rubber is made up of a polymer chain, linear or branched. Second, the chain is flexible. And, third, the chain is longer than a certain threshold length. The last is called ‘entanglement coupling distance’ [8], Xe and in terms of the corresponding MW, Me. The entanglement is a coupling of adjacent chains to form a three-dimensional network, giving rubber the appearance of a solid, albeit a ‘soft solid’. This network and the flexibility of the chain are the reasons why rubber behaves as defined earlier in (i) and (ii). The concept of entanglement is indispensable for explaining rubber behaviour. Yet, nobody has observed the entanglement as such. The concept is a result of rationalisation that because polymer chains are long, they must entangle. Spaghetti and worms are often cited as models. However, these models are not proof. From a similarity in behaviour of a crosslinked rubber-network and an uncrosslinked rubber, the latter is assumed to have a ‘network’ made up of the entanglements. Those who are interested in a more critical discussion, are referred to Ferry [8]. In this book the term ‘entanglement’ is used without specifying the nature of the interactions among polymer chains. However, understanding of behaviour as a manifestation of the entanglement is indispensable for interpreting processing of rubber. Even though the rubbery behaviour is defined by time as well as temperature, the various gum rubbers are usually classified according to their temperature dependence alone. This is probably because the temperature dependence is more obvious. For convenience the temperature at which the rubber becomes glassy is selected as a representative parameter and designated as glass transition temperature (Tg). Because there is a temperature range where rubbery behaviour changes to glassy, exactly which temperature in the glass-rubber transition to be assigned as Tg must be decided. Also, the transition behaviour depends upon the time-scale (or frequency) of measurements and the cooling rate. Therefore, the data of Tg are those measured with mutually agreed procedures. For more detailed discussion the readers are referred to Ferry [8]. Table 1.2 lists Tgs, for representative commercial rubbers [8]. A more flexible chain tends to have a lower Tg as can be seen with cis-1,4-BR. The pendent group and its size tends to increase the Tg as can be seen in IR against cis-1,4-BR and SBR against NR. The presence of polar groups in NBR and ACM raises Tg.
13
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Table 1.2 Glass-Rubber Transition Temperature, Tg, of Representative Rubbers Rubber
Tg, °C
Remarks
NR
–7 3
SBR
–63
23.5% styrene
BR
–112
Cis-1,4
–6 8
Cis, trans, vinyl
–58
20% A N
–24
40% A N
NBR
CR EPM
EPDM
–50 ~ –45 –31
E/P=16/84 by mole
–57
E/P=56/44 by mole
–60 ~ –40
IIR
–70
MQ
–123
ACM
–14
E/P: Ethylene:Propylene ratio
In addition to low temperature limit, Tg, the ceiling temperature for the rubbery behaviour is important, because the gum rubber changes into a high viscosity fluid. A very low Tg rubber tends to have the low ceiling temperature, but the Tg alone does not have an exact relation to the temperature of rubber-to-flow transition. As the ceiling temperature is approached, some rubber loses chemical stability. The initial reaction is crosslinking, creating long-branches. When the reaction is extensive both chain-scission and crosslinking occur. Such a reaction may be intensified by the mechanical action like milling and by the presence of oxygen or peroxide.
1.3 Formulation Rubber is seldom used alone. Almost always a number of additives are used [9]. Table 1.3 gives an example of a passenger tyre formulation [10], which is also called a ‘recipe’.
14
Formulation passenger car tyre
Introduction
Table 1.3 Example of a Rubber Formulation for a Passenger Car Tyre phr SBR 1712
96.25 (70.0 rubber, 26.25 oil)
Cis-1,4 BR
30.0
Zinc oxide
3.0
Stearic acid
2.0
Carbon black (N-330)
85.0
Aromatic oil
20.0
Anti-oxidant
1.0
Accelerator
1.2
Sulphur
1.5
Total Rubber %
239.95 41.7
SBR 1712 is an E-SBR extended with 37.5 phr of aromatic oil. Zinc oxide shortens the cure-time and stearic acid promotes the efficiency of the accelerator in vulcanisation. Examples of typical formulations for specific applications are given in handbooks [11]. Even though there are many additives most of the attention in this book will be given on mixing of rubber and reinforcing fillers. This is because mixing of these is most difficult and when it is done satisfactorily, other ingredients are usually well mixed. Some additives cause specific effects on mixing; for example, a premature crosslinking reaction during mixing will be discussed in Chapter 12.
1.4 Mixing equipment There are essentially two types of mixing equipment, a roll-mill and an internal mixer. Examples are shown in Figures 1.1 and 1.2 . With the roll-mill an operator performs part of mixing operation whereas with the internal mixer, only charging and discharging are done by the operator.
15
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 1.1 Roll Mill. Reproduced by kind permission of Kobelco Stewart Bolling, Inc.
The rolls in a roll-mill are rotated at constant speeds, 15-20 rpm, with the back roll running a little faster. A gap between the rolls is adjustable. The rolls may be heated or cooled with a liquid circulating inside. The entire mixing operation is performed through repeated charging and discharging of rubber. The additives are charged while the rubber is banded onto a roll.
16
Introduction
Figure 1.2a Internal Mixer. Reproduced by kind permission of Kobelco Stewart Bolling, Inc.
17
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 1.2b Internal Mixer. Reproduced by kind permission of Kobelco Stewart Bolling, Inc.
18
Introduction Mixing with the internal mixer is performed with two rotors, which are confined within a chamber (see Figures 1.2a, 1.2b and 1.3). Unless specially modified, the rotor speeds are fixed and there may be a small difference in the speed of two rotors. Both the chamber wall and rotors may be heated or cooled with a circulating liquid. Usually, it is cooled with water.
Figure 1.3 Rotors for an internal mixer. Reproduced by kind permission of Kobelco Stewart Bolling, Inc.
The internal mixers are made in two types, one is tangential and the other is intermeshing [12]. Most widely used in mixing rubber are Banbury mixers (see Figures 1.4a and 1.4b), which are tangential. An intermeshing type is shown in Figure 1.4c. In the tangential mixer, there is a gap between two rotors. The mixing action is primarily between the rotor tip and the chamber wall, the milling zone. The rest of the space is used to circulate material.
19
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 1.4 Examples of rotor designs (arrows indicate pumping action of wings). a) Banbury two-wing, wings pumping from ends to centre section b) Banbury four-wing, wings pumping from ends to centre section c) Shaw intermix three-wing, the large wings on each rotor pump to opposite ends, while the small ones do not contribute very much to axial flow d) Werner & Pfleiderer four-wing, the two large wings on each rotor pumping from ends to centre section, while the two small ones operate to give a reversing action. Reprinted with permission from H. Palmgren, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1975, 48, 3, 462. Copyright 1975, Rubber Division of the ACS.
Figure 1.5 illustrates these actions schematically [13]. The descriptions such as longitudinal cut-back, kneading and lateral overlap are derived from the behaviour of rubber on the mill. The longitudinal cut-back is slicing the band of rubber on the mill and laying sidewise to form a double layer. The lateral overlap is making layers of rubber by rolling a sheet of rubber off the mill and recharging. Kneading is the action of the rubber above the mill rolls prior to entering into the mill gap. Similar behaviour is assumed to occur in the internal mixer also, but the content of the mixer may not always behave in this manner because each rubber behaves differently. With the intermeshing rotors the milling zone is between the rotors as well as between the rotor and chamber wall.
20
Introduction
Figure 1.5 Behaviour of compound in the internal mixer. Reprinted with permission from Understanding the Banbury Mixer, The Farrel Company. Copyright 1968, The Farrel Company.
Choice of a mixer depends upon technical as well as economic requirements. Roll-mill is more labour intensive and often used for research and development. However, in many production lines the mixing is started in an internal mixer and finished in a roll-mill as the two types of mixers are installed in tandem.
References 1
Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, 4th Edn., Wiley, New York, 1997, 8, 905 and 9, 1.
2
Rubber Chemistry and Technology, Annual Reviews: Emulsion Technology: J. Ugelstad and F. K. Hansen, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1976, 49, 3, 536. C. A. Uraneck, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1976, 49, 3, 610. Anionic Polymerisation: M. Morton and L. J. Fetters, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1975, 48, 3, 359. B. J. Bauer and L. J. Fetters, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1978, 51, 3, 406. A. F. Halasa, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1981, 54, 3, 627.
a) b) c) d) e)
21
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing 3
Y. Tanaka, H. Sato, K. Hatada, Y. Terawaki and H. Okuda, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1978, 51, 2, 168.
4
L. J. Kuzma and W. J. Kelly in Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, 3rd Edn., Wiley, New York, 1978, 8, 555.
5
H. L. Hsieh and H. C. Yen, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 1, 117.
6
H. Fries and B. Stollfuss, Presented at the 134th Meeting of the ACS Rubber Division, Cincinnati, OH, Fall 1988, Paper No.8.
7
A. H. Jorgensen, L. A. Chandler and E. A. Collins, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1973, 46, 4, 1087.
8
J. D. Ferry, Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers, 3rd Edn., John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1980, 241 and 280.
9
Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, 4th Edn., Wiley, New York, 1996, 21, 460.
10
JSR Handbook, JSR Ltd., Tokyo, Japan, p.45.
11
The Vanderbilt Rubber Handbook, R. T. Vanderbilt Co., Inc., Norwalk, CT, 1990.
12
H. Palmgren, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1975, 48, 3, 462.
13
Understanding the Banbury Mixer, The Farrel Company, Ansonia, CT, 1968, p.8.
22
2
Mill Processability
2.1 Mastication and mill processability Mixing of rubber is often preceded by kneading the gum rubber to soften it, a process called mastication. What happens to the rubber in this process may be observed in a mill. During World War II when synthetic rubbers were being developed difficulty in milling was one of the problems that needed to be overcome. In the later years with the introduction of a variety of synthetic rubbers, each rubber was found to show a unique behaviour on the mill. Through experience mill operators learned that there are certain patterns in mill behaviour. Accordingly, they adjusted milling conditions to ease the milling difficulties. Subsequently, the milling patterns were classified by Tokita and White [1] into four regions of mill processability [1], see Figure 2.1.
Figure 2.1 Regions of mill behaviour of rubber. Reprinted with permission from N. Tokita and J. L. White, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1968, 12, 7, 1589. Copyright 1968, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
23
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing When a piece of rubber is charged into a mill, if the rubber is too stiff, it slips on the roll and does not go into the mill-gap. If the rubber is forced into the gap, it breaks into pieces, falling down underneath instead of banding around the roll; this is Region I. When the rubber is soft enough it enters the mill-gap easily and forms a band around the roll. When the banded rubber is elastic enough and acts as if squeezing the roll, this is Region II. When the rubber is even softer, it enters the mill-gap, forming a band, but the band does not have the elastic tension; it tends to sag and tear, Region III. Further softening of rubber is accompanied by development of tack, whereby the rubber bands on the roll, however, there is no elastic tension, Region IV. Similar observations have been reported on the behaviour of rubber in the internal mixer [2]. When the behaviour of rubber is in Region I, the operator must scoop up the broken pieces of rubber and recharge them into the mill. This makes the milling operation cumbersome; therefore, the operator makes the mill-gap wide enough so that the rubber goes through without breaking or with a minimum break. The gap is gradually narrowed, while the rubber is passed through the gap repeatedly. Meanwhile the rubber becomes warmer and as a result its behaviour changes to that of Region II. The rubber behaviour in Region II is preferable, not only for mastication, but also for incorporation and dispersion of the reinforcing filler, such as carbon black or silica. In Region III, the operator sometimes pushes rubber against the roll in an attempt to establish a tight band but it is often ineffective. Moreover, the rubber sometimes adheres to the back roll, which is rotating at a somewhat higher speed. There are times when only a part of the rubber goes into the back roll and the rest remains on the front roll. All in all the handling of rubber is very difficult. The operator tries to avoid Region III behaviour as much as possible. In Region IV there is no problem in the incorporation of the filler but the dispersion is not effective, because the stress transmitted from the machine to the filler agglomerate is not high enough to break it. The tack of the rubber also makes handling difficult. When the internal mixer is used, the rubber behaviour is not directly observable. However, if the rubber behaviour is in Region I, the rubber breaks down to many pieces. If the filler is added before the rubber is massed, the incorporation becomes difficult. The mixing either takes too long or results in unsatisfactory dispersion. Region II is also the most preferred behaviour with the internal mixer. When the rubber is expected to behave in Region III or IV, the usual practice is to charge the filler first, followed by rubber, i.e., upside-down mixing. In this way a good dispersion of filler may be achieved. Sometimes rubber and additives are charged together into the internal mixer without masticating the rubber. This is done with relatively soft rubber or with the aid of a ‘process oil’. During mastication, NR chains break, resulting in a substantial decrease of
24
Mill Processability molecular weight. With synthetic rubbers only a small number of the chains usually break. However, some chain breaking does occur, resulting in the generation of free radicals. The free radicals react with other polymer chains to form long branch chains. NR, in general, has a very high MW and mastication is used to bring its molecular weight down to a more easily processible range. Traditionally, the MW level expressed as a Mooney index of 50 was considered to be the easiest processing level. This is the reason why the standard grade, E-SBR 1500 (copolymer of styrene and butadiene prepared by emulsion polymerisation) was made to a Mooney index of 50. The E-SBR, as is wellknown, was the first synthetic rubber designed to be a substitute for NR.
2.2 Interpretation of mill processability In section 2.1 the behaviour of rubber on the mill was explained with respect to four typical behaviours, i.e., four regions of processability. With some rubbers, milling starts from Region I, finishing at Region II, and other rubbers remain at Region II throughout milling. Starting from Region II, sometimes rubbers go to Region III or Region IV. Nevertheless, the four regions of behaviour are common to all rubbers; therefore, it provides a means of systematic classification. The scientific explanation for the four regions of processability behaviour is as follows. In Region I, the rubber is too stiff which means that the modulus is too high. If the rubber is forced into the mill-gap, it breaks into pieces because the strain at break is not large. In Region II, rubber has an ideal softness; that is, the modulus is lower than that in Region I. The rubber does not break and makes a tight band around the roll because its strain at break is large. In both Regions I and II the elasticity is the controlling factor. But, what is elasticity in this context? The high elasticity does not necessarily mean a high modulus. It is related to the extensibility and more importantly to the ability of the rubber to recover from deformation. Although elasticity controls Region I and II, the temperature of the rubber increases as the milling continues. This is due to the internal friction, which is the viscous contribution. Therefore, both viscosity and elasticity are recognised to be the contributing factors. Thus, the subject of viscoelasticity is introduced into mixing of rubber. When a certain amount of mechanical energy is imparted to rubber a part of the energy is stored as elastic energy and other part is dissipated as heat. A part of the energy converted to heat is lost. Only the elastic energy is effective for recovering from deformation. When the elasticity is controlling Region I and Region II behaviour, it means the ratio of stored energy to dissipated energy is high.
25
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing In Region IV, the modulus is lower than in Region II; the elasticity becomes low, giving a large permanent deformation. It is a fluid state, which is manifested as tackiness. In Region IV viscosity is the controlling factor. Region III is the border between Region II and IV where elasticity and viscosity compete with each other for the control of the overall behaviour. Rubber on the mill is not uniform; when it is taken out as a sheet, it is wavy and has non-uniform thickness. In Region III the overall behaviour comes from Region II in some areas and Region IV in other areas. Region II and IV co-exist like a mosaic pattern. The areas where viscosity dominates lack tension and therefore, the rubber sags. The areas of high elasticity pull apart the viscous, weak areas, which deform permanently and tear. Summarising the discussion up to this point, the state of rubber during roll-milling may be classified using modulus, strain at break and a ratio of elastic to viscous energy. The modulus and the viscoelastic ratio are subjects concerning deformation and flow, i.e., rheology. The strain at break is related to a large deformation and failure. Thus, a bridge is built between the hands-on experience of roll-milling and scientific methodology. The increase of the temperature resulting from the milling of rubber tends to change the behaviour of rubber in the direction from Region I towards Region IV. Instead of the viscous heat generation, the machine or rubber may be externally heated to bring about the same change. This indicates that temperature is an important (dynamic) state variable. When a rubber has a milling problem in Region I, the mill-gap is made wider in the beginning and gradually the gap is made narrower. When the roll speed is kept constant, a wider gap makes the deformation rate lower. The wider gap also gives a smaller deformation. However, the rubber behaviour needs to be considered from a dynamic (time-dependent) view point; therefore, deformation rate is selected rather than deformation itself as a variable. In general, when the gap is made wider, the rubber behaviour changes in a direction from Region I towards Region II; the reverse change can also occur. Therefore, the deformation rate is also a dynamic-state variable. Increasing temperature and decreasing deformation rate changes the rubber behaviour in the same direction: that is, there is a correspondence between temperature and deformation rate. Under the lower deformation rate, deformation takes a longer time. Therefore, the above correspondence may also be called time-temperature correspondence. However, at this stage of the discussion the correspondence principle remains to be qualitative. It must be differentiated from the quantitative definition of viscoelasticity [3]. When the mill processability is in Region II, it is within the time-temperature window, which defines the rubbery state. The Region I is the border (transition) between the
26
Mill Processability rubbery and glassy state. The Region IV is the flow state outside of the window. The Region III is at the border between rubbery and flow state. Although most of mixing of rubber has been done with a tangential mixer, some rubbers like EPDM may be more advantageously mixed with an intermeshing mixer. If a relatively stiff rubber such as E-SBR or NBR is charged into an intermeshing mixer, the rubber tends to behave like Region I in the mill because the gap is narrow. The problem may be overcome by prewarming the rotors. EPDM softens easily and is not likely to give the behaviour of Region I. The basic difference between EPM and NBR in viscoelastic characteristics is described in Chapter 6. So far the discussion has covered traditional rubber processing for making tyres, belts, and other industrial products. However, the recent trend of using new materials such as thermoplastic elastomers and polymer blends should also be noted. Also, non-traditional formulations have been developed, for example, for rollers in office printers and belts for money changers. Sound-proofing and vibration-damping are another area, which bring new formulations. For these new areas, the criteria of the mill processability may or may not be valid. When polymers of widely varied glass transition temperature (Tg) are blended, grafted or block-polymerised, the time-temperature correspondence discussed earlier, becomes very complicated. Therefore, interpretations of the mill behaviour must be properly modified. Even when the four regions of the mill processability appear applicable, subsequent handling of material may require fresh thinking. More discussion on this topic will be given in Chapter 14.
2.3 Science of mill processability When the mill behaviour can be related to the fundamental properties of rubber, the mill-operator’s experience can be interpreted in a scientific manner. When a piece of rubber is subjected to tensile testing, its modulus and the strain at break can be evaluated. The test may be performed at different temperatures and with different deformation rates, in order to include all ranges of temperature and deformation rates encountered in the mixer. An example of tensile stress-strain data is shown in Figure 2.2 for a sample of NBR [4]. A high speed tensile tester was used to match the deformation rates in the internal mixer. This type of experiment has been a subject of scientific investigation for some time. The failure behaviour is presented as a locus of breaking strength and the breaking strain, i.e., failure envelope [5]. Examples of the failure envelopes are shown in Figure 2.3a for four different grades of NBR [4].
27
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 2.2 Tensile stress-strain data of NBR. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, E. A. Collins and H. H. Bowerman, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1974, 47, 2, 318. Copyright 1974, Rubber Division of the ACS.
The stress, σ, based on the undeformed cross-section is converted to that based on the deformed cross-section with a use of the extension ratio, α. The value plotted in the figure, σ α, is therefore the true stress. As mentioned in section 2.2, the characteristic mill behaviour can be defined on the basis of modulus and strain at break. Therefore, a new failure envelope is proposed as a locus of the modulus at break and the strain at break [4], see Figure 2.3b. The upper part of the figure corresponds to the lower temperature or a higher rate of deformation; the modulus is high and the breaking strain is small, Region I. Either by increasing temperature or decreasing the rate of deformation, the behaviour moves downward in the figure, showing the lower modulus and the larger strain at break, Region II. Passing downward through this region in the figure, the strain at break becomes smaller, Region III. The bottom part of the figure represents Region IV, where the temperature is even higher or the deformation rate is lower. Whether the breaking strain becomes larger or not, cannot be ascertained, because at Region IV the specimen tends to elongate non-uniformly.
28
Mill Processability
Figure 2.3 Failure envelopes of butadiene-acrylonitrile copolymer, samples A, B, C and D. a) locus of breaking strength and breaking strain b) locus of modulus at break and elongation at break Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, Polymer Engineering Science, 1979, 19, 3, 215. Copyright 1979, Society of Plastic Engineers.
In this figure, samples A and B show Region II behaviour, indicated here with large strain at break; these are easy to mill. Sample D does not deform as much as samples A and B. Also, at the maximum strain at break, the modulus is high. Sample D tends to give Region I behaviour. Although not shown in Figure 2.3b, the behaviour of sample C is similar to those of A and B. Because the mill behaviour and the results of the tensile test are shown to be related, the tensile test results may be used for the characterisation of processability for a given rubber. This aspect will be expanded in Chapter 6.
29
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Mixing in a mill or an internal mixer involves both small and large deformations. The modulus at break is only one point in the large deformation. Therefore, the evaluation of modulus over the range from small to large deformation is required in order to fully explain the mixing behaviour. Samples A and B are ‘gel-free’ grades and sometimes called easy processing grades. Method of the gel determination is given in ASTM D3616-95 [6] and sometimes as much as a few percent of gel may be found by this method without giving processing difficulty. A difference between A and B is their MW level. A lower MW rubber, A, was made using a MW modifier, which also suppressed the branch formation. Sample D was made in such a way that it contained approximately 70% of macrogel. Although this material presents mixing difficulties, it is made for special applications. For example, it accepts a higher amount of reinforcing filler, e.g., carbon black, compared to samples A and B. It also provides a higher ‘green-strength’ (resistance to sagging), when a sheet of uncrosslinked compound is held up. When high gel-content latex is coagulated, dried and compressed into a bale, the multi-branched gels appear to form a complex network of entanglement. This entanglement is different from that formed by linear molecules. The entangled gel-network makes the bale appear as if it were permanently crosslinked. This type of gel is sometimes called a ‘macrogel’, because of its appearance. In reality, however, each gel molecule is microscopic in size, because it was formed in an emulsion particle. The macrogel is different from crosslinked latex particles prepared with use of a difunctional comonomer; the latter is sometimes called, ‘microgel’, which contains crosslinked network chains and some branches. The rubber containing a significant amount of macrogel tends to behave as Region I at the beginning of milling. In the open mill an operator can make an adjustment of mill gap and thereby the milling operation may be controlled. With an internal mixer, however, the behaviour of rubber is not directly observable. Therefore, it is important to know the characteristics of a rubber before mixing. Otherwise, the results of mixing may be unsatisfactory and the compound may have to be remilled. How much macrogel is allowed in a gum rubber in order to avoid the mixing problem, depends upon the mixing conditions and formulation. For example, the mixer may be prewarmed or a process oil may be added. Sample C contains 50% of microgel, and the other 50% is the same as sample B. Its mill behaviour is very similar to samples A and B. All grades of NBR exhibit either Region I or Region II of mill behaviour except for a specially made grade having a very low MW, which may show Region III or IV behaviour. The E-SBRs behave in a similar way. On the other hand rubbers made through anionic polymerisation tend to go into Region III and IV. These rubbers have a very narrow MW distribution and no branches unless 30
Mill Processability the rubber is manufactured to have them by design. The reason for the mill behaviour is the absence of the high MW tail of the distribution. If the distribution is not extended to the high MW tail, even though the distribution is not necessarily narrow, the rubbers still tend to go into Region III and IV. This trend is accentuated if the average MW is low or there are no longer branches. ACM is made through emulsion polymerisation, in much the same way as NBR is. There is a chain transfer mechanism, resulting in long branches and macrogel. Yet, this rubber tends to go to Region III or IV. The reason lies in its chain structure. The 73% of its MW is in the pendent group and therefore, it is a fat and short chain. Even when the MW is high, it acts like an equivalent of the low MW NBR. Cis-1,4-butadiene rubbers (cis-1,4-BR) tend to go into Regions III and IV, even though they are very long and thin molecules, 100% of their MW being in the main chain. This is because their Tg , is very low, -112 ~ -120 °C. The normal milling temperature lies at the upper border of the time-temperature window. In general the question of which region of mill processability a given rubber goes into, is related to its time-temperature window. Temperature-wise it is the processing temperature range compared to the Tg of a given rubber. Time-wise it is related to a ‘mobility’ of a given molecular segment at the shorter times and the mobility of the whole molecule at the longer times. The shorter-time border of the window is independent of the MW and the longer-time border is dependent. In the latter, therefore, the higher the MW the wider the window time-wise. Instead of the term ‘mobility’, the term ‘relaxation-time’ is used in science and its definition is given in Chapter 6. The low MW tail of the molecular weight distribution is usually not a concern in rubber processing. The rubber is manufactured not to have this fraction, because it weakens the finished products. MQ made through a condensation reaction is an exception. Because of the inherent nature of the reaction, there are low MW fractions, as discussed in Chapter 1.
References 1.
N. Tokita and J. L. White, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1966, 10, 7, 1011.
2.
A. Morikawa, K. Min and J. L. White, International Polymer Processing, 1989, 4, 1, 23.
31
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing 3.
J. D. Ferry, Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers, 3rd Edition, John Wiley, New York, 1980.
4.
N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 1.
5.
T. L. Smith, in Strength and Extensibility of Elastomers in Rheology, Vol.5, Ed., F. R. Eirich, Academic Press, New York, 1969, p.127.
6.
ASTM D3616-95 Standard Test Method for Rubber, Raw-Determination of Gel, Swelling Index, and Dilute Solution Viscosity.
32
3
Overview of Mixing of Rubber
3.1 Unit processes Mixing of rubber involves several additives, such as reinforcing fillers, non-reinforcing fillers, oils, vulcanisation chemicals, stabilisers and so on. However, discussion will be limited to rubbers and reinforcing fillers because upon satisfactory mixing of these, other additives are usually well mixed. Often more than one rubber is blended; also more than one kind of reinforcing filler may be used. However, for simplicity, mixing of one rubber and one reinforcing filler, primarily carbon black, will be considered. Use of an internal mixer is the primary interest, although the mill-mixing may be interpreted similarly. Mixing of mutually soluble substances, such as alcohol and water occurs in one step. Therefore, it is a one unit process. Mixing of rubber and carbon black is not done by one step. In general, four unit processes are involved, each requiring separate consideration; they are mastication, incorporation, dispersion and distribution. Mastication has already been discussed in Chapter 2. Incorporation is a process where the filler particles become included inside the rubber. Dispersion is a process where carbon black pellets and their fragments, agglomerates, are broken down to the primary units called aggregates. Distribution corresponds to mixing in the usual sense except that it is homogenisation on the macro-scale. If a rubber is in Region I of mill processability, incorporation is difficult because rubber and carbon black tend to stay separate; sometimes it is described as, ‘a rubber is too dry’. In Region II the rubber is a soft, stretchable solid. Dizon and Papazian [1] removed the contents of an internal mixer at an early stage of incorporation, see Figure 3.1. It consisted of 1,800 identifiable pieces classified into 9 kinds. As incorporation progresses the pieces stick together, becoming compacted to form one piece. This process is sometimes called ‘massing’. How easily and quickly the compaction occurs, depends upon the nature of rubber. When the rubber is in Region IV the massing is easier because the rubber is tacky to begin with. The importance of compaction is obvious, because when compaction is insufficient, the compound becomes very difficult to handle. In addition the transmission of stress becomes ineffective such that dispersion becomes ineffective. Difficulty in compaction tends to occur with a high loading of fillers.
33
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 3.1 Batch appearance of low-energy (200 MJ/m3) mix. Reprinted with permission from E. S. Dizon and L. A. Papazian, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1977, 50, 4, 765. Copyright 1977, Rubber Division of the ACS.
The dispersion process requires transmission of stress from the mixing machine to the carbon black through the medium of rubber and rubber containing already dispersed carbon black. The higher the modulus the more effective is the transmission of stress; therefore, the lower temperature is preferred as long as the rubber stays in Region II. Towards the end of mixing the temperature of compound goes up and if it is excessive the dispersion becomes ineffective, because the modulus becomes low. The distribution depends greatly upon how the compound as a whole moves around in the chamber of the internal mixer. Uniform movement without a partial stagnation is the key. If the mixing chamber is 100% filled, the compound cannot move easily. In an extreme case, the rubber mixture may be separated into one part which passes under the rotor tips repeatedly and another part which does not. The latter will have a higher modulus, because of the poorer dispersion. It is less likely to have a higher modulus fraction passing under the rotor tips than a lower modulus fraction.
34
Overview of Mixing of Rubber
3.2 Interpretation of the mixing process In Chapter 2 the mill processability was related to the viscoelastic characteristics of a given rubber. This establishes a rational basis of interpreting the mixing behaviour of rubber. However, the phenomenon concerns only mastication and the initial stage of mixing. It does not extend to incorporation and dispersion. To consider the mixing of rubber from a scientific viewpoint, questions must be asked about the scientific treatment of mixing. An approach was proposed, which begins with definitions of the initial and final state of mixing [2]. These states are relatively easy to define; and then, the intermediate state of mixing can be examined, which is much more complex. In the beginning a gum rubber and a filler are present separately, assuming only one rubber and one filler is involved. The viscoelastic characteristics of the rubber can be defined as explained already. An additional parameter of importance is the size of the rubber block. The filler may be characterised with respect to structure, surface area and friability. The final state of mixing may be defined by the morphology of the mixed compound; a number of years ago Hess presented many photographs, one of which is reproduced in Figure 3.2 [3]. It is assumed that the equipment used is an internal mixer and that the filler is a carbon black. As in Figure 3.2 the rubber phase is a continuous matrix. However, as a model the rubber may be regarded as domains surrounded with carbon black. The domain-size is in the order of 1 μm. The border of the domain has a pattern, indicating that one domain may consist of many rubber particles of the order of 0.1 μm. A block of rubber charged into the internal mixer has a dimension of several cm or larger. During mixing the size is gradually reduced to the domain size of about 1 μm. The torn and fractured surfaces of the rubber either attach to the surfaces of the carbon black or to that of other pieces of rubber. Considering the process of fracture and attaching, the ultimate domain may be regarded as consisting of many rubber particles of approximately 0.1 μm size. The mechanism of gradual decrease of the rubber particlesize is called comminution [4]. In a recent observation, NR was breaking down to small pieces in the initial stage of milling [5]. In general, with a fracture of a body, new surfaces are created and simultaneously the broken pieces are separated. However, in comminution, only the creation of new surfaces occurs. The fresh surfaces are immediately attached to the surface of carbon black or that of rubber. Therefore, direct observation of comminution is difficult. However, during roll milling lumps are seen; they become smaller with the progress of milling, implying the comminution mechanism.
35
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 3.2 Elastomer domains and well-dispersed carbon black aggregates. Reprinted with permission from W. M. Hess in Reinforcement of Elastomers, Ed., G. Kraus, John Wiley, New York, 1965, Chapter 6. Copyright 1965, John Wiley.
Carbon black is supplied as pellets, which have a size somewhat smaller than 1 mm. At the completion of mixing, the size of the aggregates are in the range of 100 to 10 nm. At the beginning of mixing the pellets break into pieces, agglomerates, in the size range of 100 to 10 μm, but thereafter, the break-down mechanism is not comminution. A microscopic observation by Shiga and Furuta [6] revealed that the aggregates peel off from the surface of the agglomerates in the manner of peeling onion, i.e., the onion model, see Figure 3.3. So far the behaviour of rubber and carbon black has been described separately, but the way in which these components mix with each other has not yet been considered. Usually the rubber is masticated before the mixing starts. The behaviour of rubber at this stage has been discussed already. The mixing process usually consists of incorporation and dispersion. In the incorporation stage, carbon black present on the outside of rubber blocks becomes included inside the rubber. In order to accept a large number and a large
36
Overview of Mixing of Rubber bulk of carbon black particles, the rubber must provide a large surface area. This may be accomplished either with a large deformation (flattening) of the rubber or with generation of small particles [4]. In the former mechanism, carbon black becomes sandwiched between two sheets of rubber; called the ‘lamination mechanism’. The latter mechanism corresponds to the early stage of comminution, see Figure 3.4. Although the lamination and comminution are idealised models, the portions corresponding to these mechanisms appear in the microscopic observation, see Figure 3.5 [6].
Figure 3.3 Photomicrographs of EPDM compound. Photomicrographs a, b and c: EPDM 100, N330 10, oil 10, ZnO 5, stearic acid 1 (all phr); a) after two minutes, b) after 4 minutes, and c) after 6 minutes mixing. Photomicrograph d: EPDM 100, N550 10, oil 10, ZnO 5 and stearic acid 1 (all phr) Photomicrograph e: EPDM 100, N550 20, oil 20, ZnO 5 and stearic acid 1 (all phr) Reprinted with permission from S. Shiga and M. Furuta, Journal of the Rubber Industry, Japan, 1982, 55, 491. Copyright 1982, Society of the Rubber Industry, Japan.
37
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 3.4 Schematic illustration of mechanisms incorporating carbon black into elastomer, a) lamination, b) comminution. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1982, 55, 3, 931. Copyright 1982, Rubber Division of the ACS.
(a)
(b)
Figure 3.5 Incorporation of carbon black into elastomer; photomicrographs of EPDM compound with a mixing time of a) 30 seconds and b) 45 seconds. Reprinted with permission from S. Shiga and M. Furuta, Journal of the Society of the Rubber Industry, Japan, 1982, 55, 491. Copyright 1982, Journal of the Society of the Rubber Industry, Japan.
38
Overview of Mixing of Rubber Once incorporation is accomplished, carbon black agglomerates break into aggregates via the onion model mechanism. When agglomerates practically disappear and disintegrate into aggregates, the mixing is considered to be complete. However, every portion of the compound must have the same composition; namely distributive mixing is also important and must occur simultaneously with dispersion. So far we have discussed the behaviour of rubber, that of carbon black and the rubber-carbon black interaction. Next the interaction between a machine and material will be considered. At the beginning of the mixing the internal mixer contains a large bulk of material, which is compressed with a ram. The ram pressure indirectly contributes to incorporation. The question is whether static pressure would directly aid mixing or not. Comparing the beginning and the end of incorporation, a difference is not only where carbon black is present, from outside to inside of rubber, but also the feel of the rubber surface. In the beginning the rubber surface is dry, but at the end it becomes tacky. This change occurs within about one minute of the incorporation stage. The change is brought about neither with the ram pressure nor with the pressure generated between the rotor and the chamber wall. It is a result of tearing and bringing out fresh surfaces of rubber [7]. This finding has an importance in understanding of mixing of rubber and therefore, the experimental detail will be presented later in a separate section. A reason for the fresh surface being tacky is the result of the pulling out of polymer chains, whose chain-ends become concentrated on the fractured surface. When the compound is aged, the chain-end distribution equalises between surface and bulk, thereby the surface loses the tackiness. The interaction between machine and material is manifested in the temperaturerise, the torque-time curve and the cumulative energy input. Here, we will discuss the torque-time curve, see Figure 3.6 [1]. There are two different interpretations of this curve; one says that the part leading to the second peak corresponds to incorporation and thereafter is dispersion, see Figure 3.7 [8]. However, this interpretation is only approximate. The other interpretation [1] is based on the actual sampling at different stages of mixing. The detailed examination of the state of mixing reveals that except for the very beginning, incorporation and dispersion are occurring simultaneously. In the earlier period incorporation is dominant and in the later period dispersion is dominant. This observation also tells us that the contents of an internal mixer are not uniform.
39
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 3.6 Material transformation process in rubber processing: 1: fragment rubber 2: distribute powders and liquids 3: incorporate powder and liquids 4: fuse fragments 5: break down carbon black 6: disperse carbon black 7: break down rubber and black-polymer interaction 8: shape compound Reprinted with permission from E. S. Dizon and L. A. Papazian, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1977, 50, 4, 765. Copyright 1977, Rubber Division of the ACS.
In the operation of a roll-mill the rubber compound is cut, sheeted out of the mill, rolled up and recharged. This process is then repeated. Therefore, the entire compound receives uniform treatment. In the internal mixer, (i) a part of the content is slowly transported in the wide space between two rotors, (ii) another part passes quickly through the narrow gap between the rotor and chamber wall, (iii) yet another part may stagnate, and (iv) some part is stretched. In the course of mixing the compound does not uniformly receive these four treatments. At the end of mixing the compound consists of parts having a non-uniform mechanical history. The extent of the non-uniformity depends upon the characteristics of gum rubber and the specific formulation used. The extent of the uniformity of the compound has an important bearing on the downstream processability. The characteristics of a compound depends on not only its chemical composition but also the mechanical history of mixing.
40
Overview of Mixing of Rubber
Figure 3.7 Effect of incorporation and dispersion processes on viscosity. Reprinted with permission from G. R. Cotten, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1984, 57, 1, 118. Copyright 1984, Rubber Division of the ACS.
The causes of non-uniformity stated above concern the distributive mixing. They also affect non-uniformity in incorporation and dispersion, because at any time during mixing a part of the rubber compound is receiving a mechanical treatment different from the other part. Because the non-uniformity in the internal mixer has been wellrecognised, the development of the Banbury mixer, for example, follows from a twowing rotor to four-wing rotor. A more recent development is an improved four-wing design, which provides more uniform movement of the contents. This is discussed in Chapter 11. Because incorporation and dispersion are different unit processes, having different requirements, design of the internal mixer optimised for one of the processes may not be the optimum for the other. Therefore, in some production lines only incorporation is done with the internal mixer and the contents are dumped onto a mill or fed into a transfer mixer to complete dispersion. Also, the mixing is not always done in one step from the raw material-charge to dump. The charging of the rubber and additives may be done in two or three steps.
41
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
3.3 Compaction as a part of the mechanism in incorporating carbon black into an elastomer [9] 3.3.1 Introduction Incorporation requires both breaking of the elastomer into smaller pieces and stretching of the elastomer to provide large surface areas. Viscoelastic behaviour and failure characteristics of a given elastomer obviously play important roles. In addition to these two mechanisms, a mixture of elastomer and carbon black have to be compacted. Compaction is the elimination of free spaces between carbon black particles and elastomer domains by an externally applied force. The importance of the compaction step may be illustrated by the following example. A recent development of an efficient cooling design for an internal mixer, allowed the use of warm water cooling instead of the traditional cold water. This resulted in a significant saving of mixing time and energy (this depends upon the choice of elastomer and formulation, of course), [4]. A major saving was found to be in the time period required for ram seating [10], i.e., the compaction. Implied here is a temperature deformation-rate relationship, which dictates an optimum condition for the compaction process. The nature of physical and chemical interactions between the elastomer and the surface of carbon black has been a subject of interest for many years. A prerequisite to such surface interactions is the wetting of the surface with elastomer molecules. However, the elastomer molecules do not spontaneously flow to the surface of carbon black. The elastomer domains must be deformed to conform with the topology of the carbon black and made to relax in the deformed state. This mechanism may constitute the essence of the theory of compaction, which is examined in this study. In order to develop the details of the theory, a model experiment was carried out. A preblend of powdered rubber and carbon black was loaded into a rheometer and compacted. The bulk compression and relaxation behaviour were characterised to gain insight into the time-temperature relationship.
3.3.2 Experiment-I • Samples Usually, the mixing of an elastomer is started by charging a slab of elastomer into a mixing machine. At the onset of mixing there are grossly different sizes of rubber. The
42
Overview of Mixing of Rubber distribution of carbon black is also very non-uniform. Such inhomogeneity is difficult to treat theoretically. Therefore, this problem is left for future research. Instead, a preblend of powdered rubber and carbon black was used. Therefore, the sample was macroscopically uniform from the beginning. The powdered rubber was a butadieneacrylonitrile copolymer with a Mooney index (ASTM D1646-72, [11]) of about 80 and the average particle diameter was approximately 250 μm. The compound formulation is given in Table 3.1. The powder was preblended with a high-intensity Henschel mixer.
Table 3.1 Compound Formulation Rubber
100a
Zinc oxide
5
Stearic Acid
1
N550 Carbon black
65
DOP
10
a
All quantities in phr.
DOP: dioctyl phthalate
A Rheometrics mechanical spectrometer was used with the 25 mm diameter parallel plates assembly to which a moulding ring was affixed. Loading of the sample was done carefully to level the powder, so that it would result in uniform compaction. The top plate was then lowered until the normal force registered about 5 g. This magnitude of normal force indicated that the top plate was pressing the sample very slightly. Under this force, the top plate was rotated slowly in order to pack the powdered sample uniformly. Then, approximately 10 minutes were allowed for the sample to equilibrate to a specific temperature. At this point, the gap between the two plates was measured with a dial gauge. The gaps between the molding ring and the plates were closed with shims (thin pieces of metal) to prevent leakage of material when pressure was applied. The bulk compression was started by quickly lowering the top plate until the normal force reached 9 kg, (nine-tenths of the maximum available load). Then, this load was maintained for 12 minutes by manually lowering the top plate. During this process, the thickness of the sample was recorded as a function of time, using readings from a dial gauge. At the end of 12 minutes, the position of the top plate was fixed and relaxation of the normal force was recorded against time for a specified period of time. Subsequently,
43
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing the sample was removed and left to cool to room temperature. The effectiveness of compaction was evaluated qualitatively by visual inspection of the friability of the moulded piece. The measurements were performed at 100, 150 and 175 °C. The temperature, 100 °C, was selected because the compound temperature at the completion of incorporation (just before dusting) was about 100 °C [12]. The measurements at 150 and 175 °C were made to accelerate the compaction process, because it proceeded very slowly at 100 °C and also, to obtain the temperature-dependence of the process. In addition to the above measurements with the compound, a similar measurement was made for the powdered rubber alone.
3.3.3 Results-I • Morphology of powdered rubber compound Figure 3.8 shows photographs of the powdered rubber and the compound, taken at a low magnification with a scanning electron microscope, AMR Model 1400.
Figure 3.8 Scanning electron micrograph of the powdered rubber (40X) and powdered rubber compound (17X). Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1983, 56, 1, 197. Copyright 1983, Rubber Division of the ACS.
In both photographs, particles of rubber are clearly observed. In the compound, the rubber particles are coated with fine particles as shown at high magnification in Figure 3.9. The fine particles were identified as carbon black. • Compression measurements Figure 3.10 is a result of the compression measurement at 150 °C under a 9 kg load.
44
Overview of Mixing of Rubber
Figure 3.9 Scanning electron micrograph (14,000X) of powdered rubber, carbon black and powdered rubber compound (top to bottom). Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1983, 56, 1, 197. Copyright 1983, Rubber Division of the ACS.
The change of the thickness of the sample is shown over 12 minutes of time. Before the 9 kg load was applied, the sample thickness was 4.652 mm at the 5 g load, but as soon as the 9 kg load was applied, the thickness decreased to very close to 3.4 mm. Because the thickness change was very rapid initially, the first thickness reading was taken after 30 seconds. It was not possible to record the initial thickness under the 9 kg load. Under the same conditions, the compaction of powdered rubber alone or that plus noncarbon black additives was complete within less than ten seconds. Therefore, the behaviour presented in Figure 3.10 is the compaction of rubber onto the complex topology of carbon black, exclusive of the compaction of rubber particles onto themselves.
45
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 3.10 Compression data at 150 °C expressed as change of sample thickness with time. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1983, 56, 1, 197. Copyright 1983, Rubber Division of the ACS.
Although neither initial thickness, So, nor ultimate thickness S∞, is obvious from these data, the thickness, S at corresponding time, t may be represented by the following expression: (S − S∞) / (So − S∞) = e-kt
(3.1)
where k is a rate constant. The fitted curve is shown with the solid line in Figure 3.10. Equation (3.1) was found to fit the results obtained at 100 °C and 175 °C. The deviations of the observed data from the fitted curve were less than 0.004 mm, therefore, the curvefitting was considered to be satisfactory. The 9 kg load corresponds to the pressure of 0.18 MPa, which is the same order of magnitude as the ram pressure. For example, during the mixing of the powdered rubber compound, the ram pressure was maintained at 0.24 MPa [2]. The pressure exerted by the rotating blade is an order of magnitude higher, e.g., 3.5 MPa. The lower pressure level is explored next and the latter pressure level later. The information desired from the compression measurements is a quantitative measure of how closely the rubber particles have become compacted onto the carbon black. The data treatment for this purpose will be done in two ways. One is a degree of packing,
46
Overview of Mixing of Rubber and the other is a degree of penetration into the void volume. The degree of packing, PAC, is defined as PAC = (vp + vc) / V
(3.2)
where vp and vc are volume of polymer (plus non-carbon black additives) and volume of carbon black, respectively. The observed sample volume V is related to the sample thickness, S, by V = S(πr2)
(3.3)
where r is the radius of the rheometer plate. The volumes, vp and vc, are related to the mass of polymer (plus non-carbon black additives) wp, and the mass of carbon black, wc, by vp = wp / ρp
(3.4)
vc = wc / ρc
(3.5)
and
where ρp and ρc are the densities of polymer and carbon black, respectively. The value of ρc is taken as the density of amorphous carbon. The degree of penetration, PEN, into the void volume, vv is expressed as the percentage of void volume occupied by the volume of penetrated rubber, vn: PEN = vn / vv
(3.6)
The void volume may be calculated as a difference between apparent volume of carbon black under a given pressure, va, and its true volume, vc v v = va − vc
(3.7)
vn = (vp + va) − V
(3.8)
The volume of penetrated rubber is
Information on the amount of sample and the corresponding volumes, vp, vc, va, and vv, and the densities are listed in Table 3.2. The bulk compression of elastomer itself is very small and negligible for the purpose of the above calculation [13].
47
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The data on degree of packing and degree of penetration of elastomer into void volume are summarised in Table 3.3.
Table 3.2 Compression Experiment, Material Parameters Experiment No
7
3
5
2
Temperature, °C
100
150
150
175
Sample compound, g
1.36
1.35
1.36
1.33
Rubber and additives, g
0.885
0.878
0.885
0.865
0.9690
0.9645
0.9645
0.9580
Volume of rubber, vp, cm3
0.913
0.910
0.917
0.903
Carbon black, g
0.475
0.472
0.475
0.465
True density of carbon blackb, ρc, g/cm3
1.88
1.88
1.88
1.88
True volume of carbon black, vc, cm3
0.253
0.251
0.253
0.246
Apparent specific volumec of carbon black under 0.18 MPa pressure, cm3/g
2.07
2.07
2.07
2.07
Apparent volume of carbon black under 0.18 MPa, va, cm3
0.983
0.977
0.983
0.963
True volume of sample, vp + vc, cm3
1.166
1.161
1.170
1.149
Apparent volume of sample, vp + va, cm3
1.896
1.887
1.900
1.866
Void volume, vv = va - vc
0.730
0.726
0.730
0.717
Density of rubber, g/cm3
a
a
Temperature dependence of specific volume as given in Reference [14] Density of gas carbon, see Reference [15] c Extrapolated to 0.18 MPa from the data given in Reference [16] b
When the sample is loaded but not compressed, i.e., under 5 g load, the material occupies about 50% of the available space; this indicates a loose packing of the powder-compound. As soon as the 9 kg load is applied, the degree of packing increases to about 70%, indicating a tight packing of the powders. The degree of penetration by the elastomer into the void space of carbon black is about 25-30% in the beginning, increasing to 3035% at the end of 12 minutes of compression. The 30-35% penetration is also the maximum attainable penetration under 0.18 MPa.
48
Overview of Mixing of Rubber
Table 3.3 Compression Experiment, Degree of Packing and Degree of Penetration Into Void Volume Experiment No. Temperature, °C Sample thickness, cm 5 g load 9 kg load So S∞ Sample volume, cm3 5 g load 9 kg Load vo v∞ v at 12 min Degree of packing, % 5 g load 9 kg load PACo PAC∞ PAC at 12 min Degree of penetration into void volume, % PENo PEN∞ PEN at 12 min
7
3
5
2
100
150
150
175
0.4770
0.4652
0.4796
0.4957
0.3468 0.3400
0.3412 0.3330
0.3422 0.3334
0.3423 0.3324
2.342
2.284
2.355
2.433
1.702 1.669 1.669
1.675 1.635 1.636
1.680 1.637 1.638
1.680 1.632 1.633
49.8
50.8
49.7
47.2
68.2 69.5 69.5
69.3 71.0 71.0
69.6 71.5 71.4
68.4 70.4 70.4
26.6 31.1 31.1
29.2 34.7 34.6
30.1 36.8 35.9
25.9 32.6 32.5
• Compressive stress relaxation The compressive stress relaxation experiment followed immediately after compression measurements under 9 kg of a constant load. In the compressive stress relaxation, the behaviour was recorded as the decrease of the load from the initial 9 kg to about 1 kg. The results of measurements at 150 °C and 175 °C (Experiments 2, 3 and 5) are shown in Figure 3.11 with solid curves.
49
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 3.11 Compressive stress relaxation, expressed as relaxation of load with time. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1983, 56, 1, 197. Copyright 1983, Rubber Division of the ACS.
The 150 °C results were obtained in duplicate, which were in good agreement with each other. The time-temperature correspondence in the viscoelastic behaviour of elastomers may be represented with the WLF equation [17]. For the present elastomer, i.e., butadieneacrylonitrile copolymer having 33% acrylonitrile, the temperature time shift factor, aT was previously given by [18] −log aT = 5.95(T − To)(109 + T − To)
(3.9)
Because the Tg of this polymer is about -24 °C, Equation (3.9) is not necessarily expected to apply to the data at 150 °C and 175 °C, which are far removed from the Tg. Nevertheless, the calculated shift factor, 1.86, was found to be exactly the same as the time-shift between the observed data of 150 °C to 175 °C. Subsequently, the 175 °C data were shifted by the calculated shift factor of 10.3 to predict the 100 °C data as shown in Figure 3.11 by the broken curve. The prediction indicates that it will take 15 hours for the load to relax down to 1 kg. At present, this is too long for precise measurement, but an approximate measurement indicated that the prediction is very close. The previous arguments assume that the magnitudes of strain were the same at all three temperatures. Because the vertical axis is the load and not the relaxation modulus, there should be some vertical shift required to compensate for the differences in strain. Since the preceding compression was done at a constant load for a constant period of time, the lower temperature results in a smaller strain. A precise estimate of relative difference of
50
Overview of Mixing of Rubber strain at different temperatures is possible from the present relaxation measurements and it will be pursued in the future. After the relaxation experiment was terminated, the sample was removed from the rheometer. Although it was very friable, the sample was nevertheless compacted into one piece. If an order of magnitude higher pressure had been applied, it would have compacted much better.
3.3.4 Discussion-I The compaction process may be defined as a process whereby the elastomer comes in contact with the topological surface of carbon black. The question is how to express the degree of compaction quantitatively. If carbon black were a porous material, whose pores were as depicted in Figure 3.12a, the degree of compaction might be expressed as a percentage of pore-volume occupied with rubber.
Figure 3.12 Schematic illustrations of penetration of elastomer into hypothetical pore of carbon black (a) and into void volume of carbon black (b). Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1983, 56, 1, 197. Copyright 1983, Rubber Division of the ACS.
In reality, the topology of carbon black is more like Figure 3.12b, so that it is difficult to define the pore volume. For this reason, a void volume is used for a volume to be penetrated by elastomer. The void volume defined here is the difference between the apparent volume under a given pressure and the real volume of carbon black. An advantage of using void volume is that it can be measured quantitatively [15]. It is highly pressure-dependent, which may be expected because some of the void spaces are more easily accessible than others.
51
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The question arises of how to define the total void volume, which is independent of the applied pressure. This is not an easy task, because the apparent specific volume of carbon black is linearly dependent on the logarithm of pressure, so that extrapolation to zero pressure cannot be made. Therefore, a somewhat arbitrary reference pressure must be chosen for defining the total volume. The void volume of carbon black at a pressure of 0.18 MPa was chosen to be the reference in this case. This level for the reference pressure has a practical significance in that it is lower by one order of magnitude than the pressure exerted by the rotor blade of an internal mixer. Accepting this definition of void volume, the degree of penetration into the void volume, PEN, in Table 3.3, becomes a good measure of the degree of compaction. Under the present set of experimental conditions 30-35% of the void volume was penetrated by the elastomer. The degree of packing, PAC, in Table 3.3, also increases with the progress of compaction. Therefore, it serves as a measure of compaction. However, the difference in the degree of compaction is more magnified in PEN than in PAC. • Rate of compaction The rate of compression is expressed by the change of thickness of the sample in Equation (3.1): (S − S∞) / (So − S∞) = e-kt
(3.1)
where k is the constant. If the importance of relaxation in the compaction process is ignored for the moment, the rate of compression may be taken to mean the rate of compaction. The observed values of k are given in Table 3.4
Table 3.4 Rate Constant of Compression Experiment No.
7
3
5
2
Temperature, °C
100
150
150
175
0.00526
0.00399
0.00437
0.00386
31.1
34.7
36.8
32.6
Rate Constant, k, s-1 Degree of Penetration, PEN, %
An inspection of the rate constants at 100 °C and 150 °C reveals that at the lower temperature, the rate is faster. Actually, this is probably a misleading statement. The elastomer has a higher modulus at the lower temperature so that the maximum attainable degree of penetration is smaller than that at the higher temperature (PEN
52
Overview of Mixing of Rubber % values). For this reason, the penetration process is completed sooner at the lower temperature than at the higher temperature. The rate constant at 175 °C is not very different from that at 150 °C. This is probably because the polymer is not entirely stable at 175 °C and slight chemical crosslinking has probably occurred during the compression experiment. The ultimate degree of penetration, PEN∞, at 175 °C is also smaller than that at 150 °C probably because of the crosslinking. • Compressive stress relaxation In the compression experiments, if the pressure is released immediately after termination of the compression, the elastomer recovers from the deformation to some degree. Consequently, the degree of compaction decreases upon release of the pressure. Instead, in this experiment the compressive deformation was held constant and the relaxation of stress was observed. Although the bulk deformation was held constant, the deformation of each elastomer particle might not have remained constant, because it can rearrange its shape within the available void space. Although the details of the relaxation mechanism are a subject of future study, the following point may be emphasised. Our primary interest is the deformation of elastomer particles, and not the bulk deformation of elastomer-carbon black mixture. The change in shape of the elastomer particles to conform to the topology of carbon black is a complex deformation but is a combination of shear and elongation. It is not a compressive deformation. Consequently, the relaxation behaviour is interpreted in terms of viscoelastic behaviour of the elastomer. The temperature dependence of the relaxation is described by the Williams-Landel-Ferry (WLF) relationship of this elastomer. Considering the behaviour of elastomer particles, the compression stage corresponds to creep behaviour in a complex combination of shear and elongational deformation. Then the relaxation follows. This type of relaxation is different from that following instantaneous deformation; such a complex relaxation behaviour is the subject of a separate study [19]. The results from this study will be used to interpret the details of the compaction mechanisms in the future. • Comparison of the present experiments with an actual mixing operation The time spent for the present experiment is unrealistically long. For example, 12 minutes was spent for the compression experiment, when in the actual mixing the incorporation process is finished in 40 seconds [12]. However, the experiments were deliberately made slower in order to provide a better definition of the material behaviour. The pressure of this experiment was also low. It was 0.18 MPa, whereas in the actual mixing, the pressure exerted by the rotor blade of the internal mixer is more than 53
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing one order of magnitude higher, e.g., 3.5 MPa [2]. This higher pressure will undoubtedly expedite the compaction process. It is also expected to increase the degree of penetration from the present 30-35% to a higher percentage. • Energy required for compaction An approximate estimate of the energy of compaction may be calculated from the compression data. With the pressure of 0.18 MPa, this energy is only about 0.2 J/g. In the actual mixing with an internal mixer, the pressure created by the rotor blade is, for example, 3.5 MPa. The energy of compaction for the pressure may be estimated from the present data; this is done by extrapolating the specific volume-logarithm of pressure data to 3.5 MPa as shown in Figure 3.13. The estimated energy of compaction is 3.4 J/g.
Figure 3.13 Apparent specific volume of compound as a function of pressure; observed (), and extrapolated (X). Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1983, 56, 1, 197. Copyright 1983, Rubber Division of the ACS.
54
Overview of Mixing of Rubber In the mixing experiment performed previously, 1,400 g of the powdered rubber compound was charged [2]. For this amount, the estimated energy of compaction according to the present work is about 5 kJ. On the other hand, the total energy for the incorporation process was estimated to be 80 kJ [2]. This large discrepancy needs to be explained. In addition to the energy of compaction, other contributions are the energy required to increase the surface area of elastomer particles and energy loss by the viscous dissipation. Part of the viscous energy is required for raising the temperature of the material in order to facilitate the incorporation process, and the other part is an inevitable loss accompanying any deformational process of elastomers. More detail of the deformational mechanisms of elastomers and compounds will be described in Chapter 4.
3.3.5 Experiment-II • Instruments and operation A Sieglaff-McKelvey capillary rheometer (Tinius-Olsen Testing Machine Company) was used for compression with the barrel plugged and for shear with an appropriate capillary. This rheometer is driven with nitrogen gas pressure applied to a piston, which exerts pressure on the material in the barrel. A barrel of 6.35 mm radius was chosen for this experiment. A predetermined amount of sample was charged and preheated in the barrel for 5 minutes before pressure was applied. Measurements were made at 100 °C and 150 °C. Also, a Rheometrics mechanical spectrometer was used with 25 mm diameter parallel plates. Both the flat plates and serrated plates were used. The test geometry consisted of the cavity formed by the parallel plates and a molding ring. A shim was inserted between the bottom plate and the moulding ring in order to prevent leakage of the sample. A constant pressure was maintained by manually adjusting (pressing down) the top plate, while the top plate was rotated at a rotational speed of 0.1 rad/s. This experiment was used to separate the effect of shear from that of pressure on compaction at relatively low pressure levels. Measurements were made at 100 °C.
3.3.6 Results-II • Effect of pressure on compaction (capillary rheometer) The time-dependent compression data at 100 °C with 4 g charges in the capillary rheometer are shown in Figure 3.14 for the five levels of pressure in the range of 0.2-4.0 MPa. This temperature is chosen because at the end of the incorporation step, where the compound
55
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing is compacted, the temperature of the compound is about 100 °C [12]. The lowest pressure, 0.2 MPa, was chosen to compare the compaction data of this work and the previous one, where a different instrument, the Rheometrics mechanical spectrometer, was used. The higher pressure, 1-4 MPa, corresponds to the pressure generated in a commercial internal mixer by the rotor blade working on the compound against the chamber wall [20, 21]. The reproducibility of the data is reasonably good as indicated for the experiment at 2.0 MPa pressure. A general pattern in this result is that at the lowest pressure, the compound quickly comes to an equilibrium. At the higher pressure, there is a transient period, where the volume continues to decrease, eventually reaching equilibrium. This transient period is shortened as the pressure level is increased. The specific volume at equilibrium was plotted against pressure in Figure 3.15. It is called an apparent specific volume because it includes void volume. The data of this work labelled as S-MK are compared to those of the previous work, RH. Obviously, there is a large disagreement between the two sets of data; this will be discussed later in this section. The time-dependent compression data at 150 °C with 4 g charges are shown in Figure 3.16 for the pressure range of 0.2-2.0 MPa.
Figure 3.14 Time-dependent compression curves of a powdered rubber-carbon black mixture at 100 °C; measurements with a Sieglaff-McKelvey rheometer. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392. Copyright 1985, Rubber Division of the ACS.
56
Overview of Mixing of Rubber
Figure 3.15 Apparent specific volume of a powdered rubber-carbon black mixture observed with two different instruments, Rheometrics mechanical spectrometer, RH and Sieglaff-McKelvey capillary rheometer, S-MK, at 100 °C. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392. Copyright 1985, Rubber Division of the ACS.
Figure 3.16 Time-dependent compression curves of a powdered rubber-carbon black mixture at 150 °C; measurements with a Sieglaff-McKelvey rheometer. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392. Copyright 1985, Rubber Division of the ACS.
57
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Except for the irregular pattern at 0.2 MPa, a trend similar to that in Figure 3.14 was observed in regard to the transient period of decreasing volume and subsequent nearequilibrium period. The equilibrium data of the apparent specific volume were added to the data of Figure 3.15 and are presented in Figure 3.17.
Figure 3.17 Apparent specific volume of a powdered rubber-carbon black mixture at 100 °C and 150 °C. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392. Copyright 1985, Rubber Division of the ACS.
The data obtained at 150 °C are in general agreement with those obtained at 100 °C except that the scattering of the data increased somewhat. The degree of penetration of elastomer into the void space is apparently not temperature-dependent. This has also been indicated in previous work at 0.18 MPa. The moduli of this type of elastomer had been shown to be approximately temperature-independent over this temperature range [22]. The compression of the powdered rubber has also been examined in the absence of carbon black. A sample of 8 g was charged and compressed at 100 °C for 4.5 minutes under 4.0 MPa pressure and then, for 10 minutes under 0.20 MPa. The compression behaviour of the powdered rubber itself was found to be very different from that of the mixture with carbon black. The volume equilibrated immediately after the application of pressure and stayed constant for the stated time periods. There was difficulty in maintaining a strictly
58
Overview of Mixing of Rubber constant pressure at the lower pressure level, i.e., 0.17-0.21 MPa, and the volume fluctuated accordingly, but within 1%. The observed specific volume data are presented in Table 3.5.
Table 3.5 The Specific Volume of Powdered Rubber, using Butadiene-Acrylonitrile Copolymer Specific volume, cm3/g Pressure, MPa Observed Calculated
Atmospheric
0.17
0. 2
4.0
—1.032
1.030 1.031
1.022 1.031
0.987 1.011
The calculated data are those of butadiene-styrene copolymer; the handbook values of the specific volume at the ambient condition, thermal expansion data, and compressibility data were used [13]. The observed and calculated data are in good agreement within the error of this work, which is about ±1%. This sequence of experiments demonstrated that the Sieglaff-McKelvey rheometer was providing reliable pressure-volume relationships. However, a few facts suggested that the true equilibrium compression data for the elastomer-carbon black mixture were not being obtained. One fact is that, whereas the rubber alone equilibrates immediately, the mixture goes through a transient volume decrease over 10-20 minutes. Even after this period, the volume is very slowly but perceptibly decreasing. A more dramatic indication of the experiment not reaching its true equilibrium is the top curve in Figure 3.16, where the volume decrease is taking place in steps. The pseudoequilibrium is followed by the decrease of volume, leading to another pseudoequilibrium; the process is repeated with successive pseudoequilibria lasting a longer and longer time. As shown before, the powdered rubber is coated with carbon black particles. When the mixture is charged in the barrel and compressed, it sets a ‘bridging’ structure. At first, the pressure equilibrates with the weakest structure, which soon yields. Then, the pressure equilibrates with the weakest of the remaining structure, which takes a little longer to yield. And this process is repeated. Because the psuedoequilibrium period increases significantly after each step, it is impossible to ascertain whether the true equilibrium is attained or not. Re-examining the raw data presented in Figures 3.14 and 3.16, many examples of the pseudoequilibrium and stepwise compression are seen. However, it is not always obvious, when the data are presented in the linear plot of time. Figure 3.18 shows examples of apparent specific volume plotted against the logarithm of time.
59
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 3.18 Time-dependent compression curves of a powdered rubber-carbon black mixture, indicating yielding of structures with the arrows. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392. Copyright 1985, Rubber Division of the ACS.
This plot emphasises the earlier pseudoequilibrium, which corresponds to a weaker structure. The yielding of the structure is indicated by the arrow. The pattern of pseudoequilibrium and yielding is not always clear, even in the log-time plot. Moreover, it is not reproducible. Therefore, it is suspected that the pattern is influenced by the way the powder in the barrel packs. The 4 g charge produced, depending upon the pressure, a 36-53 mm compressed height in the barrel of 6.35 mm radius. It is very difficult to charge powder uniformly in the deep ‘well’, rheometer barrel. The previous experiment with the Rheometrics mechanical spectrometer was performed with a disc shaped sample of 25 mm diameter and about 3 mm thickness. With the above considerations, a new set of compressive experiments were performed with a decreased charge of 1.5 g. The time-dependent compression data were obtained at 100 °C at the pressures of 0.35, 0.88, and 1.98 MPa. Although the pattern of pseudoequilibrium-yielding was not eliminated, the specific volume was significantly smaller than that with a 4 g charge; the ‘equilibrium’ values estimated at 50 minutes or longer are shown in Figure 3.19.
60
Overview of Mixing of Rubber
Figure 3.19 Apparent specific volume of a powdered rubber-carbon black mixture; the dependence on the sample thickness indicating a presence of a ‘bridging’ structure. RH: this graph was obtained using a Rheometrics Mechanical Spectrometer. S-MK: this graph was obtained using a Sieglaff-Mckelvey capillary rheometer. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392. Copyright 1985, Rubber Division of the ACS.
The three new data points line up well with the extension of the previous data with the Rheometrics mechanical spectrometer. However, the agreement of the data obtained from two different instruments does not necessarily mean that the true equilibrium is reached. For example, if the compression measurements had been continued for several hours instead of less than 2 hours, it is quite possible that even lower values of the specific volume would have been observed. However, such a long time measurement has no practical significance for the mixing behaviour. Rather, an important discovery is that the thickness of material is one of the important controlling variables on the deficiency of compaction. In the internal mixer at the space onequarter of the circumference in front of the rotor tip, a significant level of pressure is maintained during mixing [20]. However, the gap between the rotor and chamber wall is wide except at the rotor tip. The implication is that until a compound passes through the narrowest gap, the compaction is not really effected. In our mixing experiments with a laboratory size mixer, this gap was 2.4 mm [2]. This is similar to the thickness used for our compaction experiments. Therefore, these data are valid for interpreting the mixing results.
61
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Along with the measurements with 1.5 g charges, a few more measurements were made with 3 and 4 g charges. These data are also shown in Figure 3.19. Although the data with a 3 g charge lies between the two lines, so do some of the data with 4 g charges. This indicates the difficulty of reproducing the compaction behaviour with a thick charge in the deep well (barrel). The degree of compaction was calculated at 100 °C per 1 g of compound from RH and S-MK lines of Figure 3.18 and presented in Table 3.6. The quantities, vp, vc and va are independent of the pressure.
Table 3.6 Degree of Compaction Pressure, MPa
0.02
0.1
0. 2
0.4
1.0
2.0
4.0
1.45
1.28
1.22
1.14
1.05
0.98
0.92
59
67
70
75
82
87
93
–0.055
0.115
0.175
0.255
0.345
0.415
0.475
0
21
32
47
64
77
88
—-
—-
1.66
1.51
1.31
1.16
1.02
—-
—-
52
57
65
74
84
—-
—-
–0.265
–0.115
0.085
0.235
0.375
—-
—-
0
0
16
44
70
RH Line
V, cm3 3
vp+vc, cm 0.857 PAC, % vp+va, cm3 1.395 vn, cm3 vv, cm3, 0.538 PEN, % S-MK Line
V, cm3 vp+vc, cm3 0.857 PAC, % vp+va, cm3 1.395 vn, cm3 vv, cm3, 0.538 PEN, %
The degree of compaction evaluated from the RH line of Figure 3.19 is the highest degree of compaction attained in the present study. It also represents the compacted thickness of about 3 mm, which corresponds to the gap between the rotor tip and the chamber wall of the internal mixer.
62
Overview of Mixing of Rubber The degree of compaction estimated from the S-MK line represents the less effective compaction, when more material (an increased thickness) was to be compacted. The structure, resulting from the carbon black bridges, hinders an effective compaction as previously discussed. This situation may correspond to the compaction at the zone in front of the rotor tip in the internal mixer. In the above interpretation, the effect of shear on the compaction has not yet been considered. This subject will be discussed in the next section. The degree of packing (PAC%) indicates a macroscopic picture of the extent of compaction, as it expresses percent of volume occupied by the real volume of carbon black and polymer. The degree of penetration (PEN%) gives an insight into the microscopic picture of the extent of compaction, as it represents a relative measure of how close the rubber particles come in contact with the topology of carbon black. At the pressure level comparable to that generated by the blade tip and the chamber wall of the internal mixer, i.e., 1-4 MPa, and with the material thickness corresponding to the gap between the blade-tip and the chamber wall, the compaction was shown to occur very effectively, with a PAC of 82-93% and a PEN of 64-88%. However, it took 5-10 minutes to reach these values. In the mixing operation, the time available for compaction of the material is only a fraction of a second. The present compaction study does not provide such short time results. It indicates that within such a short time, the compaction does not progress very much (see Figures 3.14, 3.15, and 3.16). Therefore, it is necessary to find out what effect shear has in accelerating compaction. • Effect of shear on compaction The experiments previously described, show that the compaction can be achieved with static pressure alone, i.e., without application of shear. However, the time required to achieve compaction was approximately 5-10 minutes, which is orders of magnitude longer than the action of the blade tip on the material against the chamber wall of the internal mixer, i.e., a fraction of a second. The shearing action must have a significant effect on the rate of compaction; this was explored by applying a shear at different levels of static pressure. For the higher pressure levels, the Sieglaff-McKelvey capillary rheometer was used. For the lower pressure levels, the Rheometrics mechanical spectrometer was used. As will be shown next, the capillary experiments were not successful, but the work with both instruments will be described. Capillary rheometer - Because the material experiences both pressure and shear in the capillary extrusion, the compaction by extrusion is expected to be more effective than
63
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing that by pressure alone. We have attempted to see if the capillary extrusion results in an additional decrease in the specific volume of the compound. The dimensions of dies and the operating pressure are given in Table 3.7.
Table 3.7 Die Dimensions and Operating Pressure Precompaction Die No.
Radius mm
Length mm
1
0.89
25.40
0.88
78
14.0 35.0
2
0.79
0.79
1.76
78
6.9 14.0
3
3.15
25.96
3.5
75
3.5
Pressure MPa
Time min
Extrusion Pressure MPa
The barrel size was 6.35 mm radius. Dies No. 1 and 3 have 90 degree entrance angles; die No. 2 is very short and the entrance geometry from the barrel to the die is ‘wine glass’ shaped. The measurements were performed at 100 °C. The sample was precompacted in a barrel with the die-end closed to form a plug under the pressure and time given in Table 3.7. The plug was removed and recharged after the respective die was attached to the barrel. Then, the compound to be extruded was at the pressure equal to the precompaction pressure to see if the extrusion resulted in the further decrease of specific volume. However, with dies No. 1 and No. 2, a pressure much higher than the precompaction pressure was required to produce ‘flow’. Therefore, any decrease of specific volume could be the result of the applied shear or that of the higher pressure. These two effects could not be separated. Also, the pressure levels required for extrusion were an order of magnitude higher than the highest pressure encountered in the internal mixer. Therefore, the extrusions with these dies were found to lack practical significance. Subsequently, die No. 3, which has a large diameter, 6.3 mm, was used so that the extrusion could be achieved at a pressure comparable to that in the internal mixer. Also, the radius of this die, 3.15 mm, is similar to the gap between the rotor tip and the chamber wall, 2.4 mm. As shown in Table 3.7, the extrusion could be achieved at the pressure of precompaction. However, no significant decrease was found in the specific volume; it was 1.112 ± 0.007 cm3/g before and 1.116 cm3/g after the extrusion. Perhaps, the shear rate of the extrusion was too low, 0.03-0.05 s-1, to demonstrate the effect of shear on compaction.
64
Overview of Mixing of Rubber Mechanical spectrometer -With the top plate rotating, the compound leaked out of the fixture when a 9 kg load was applied. This fact indicates that the force was transmitted more effectively when shear was applied. Also, the bridge structure was effectively destroyed by shear. However, the quantitative measurement on the compaction rate could not be made when the compound was leaking. With a 4.5 kg load (90 kPa pressure), the compound did not leak. Figure 3.20 shows the compaction curve without the plate rotating (curve 1) and curves with the plate rotating (curves 2 and 3).
Figure 3.20 Time-dependent compression curves of a powdered rubber-carbon black mixture at 100 °C under 90 kPa; measurements with a Rheometrics Mechanical Spectrometer. Curve 1 without shear; curves 2 and 3 with shear. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392. Copyright 1985, Rubber Division of the ACS.
The latter indicate the extent of reproducibility; the shape of curve reproduced very well, although the level of the compaction disagreed by 0.1 mm, approximately 3%. The disagreement arises from the difficulty of charging the powder compound in a reproducible
65
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing manner. Therefore, the differences in the level of the compaction curves cannot be attributed to the effect of shear. However, with the application of shear, the compaction proceeds faster in the beginning, for example, at a time of less than one minute. With the serrated plates, the compound leaked out even at 90 kPa when the top plate was rotated. This indicates that the transmission of force and breaking of structure were more effective with the serrated plates. Only with a 0.9 kg load (18 kPa pressure) could the leakage be avoided. In Figure 3.21 curves 1 and 2 were obtained with the flat plates and curve 3 with the serrated plates. Curve 1 is without the top plate rotating and curves 2 and 3 with the rotation. The trend shown by curves 1 and 2 is the same as the case with 90 kPa pressure, that with the application of shear, the compaction occurs faster in the beginning.
Figure 3.21 Time dependent compression curves at 100 °C under 18 kPa. Curves 1 and 2 with flat plates; curve 3 with serrated plates; curve 1 without shear; curves 2 and 3 with shear. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392. Copyright 1985, Rubber Division of the ACS.
66
Overview of Mixing of Rubber Curve 3 shows that with the serrated plates, the effect of shear is even more dramatic. Almost immediately after the application of the load, the volume reached the ultimate value, which is in agreement with the apparent specific volume of RH line, Figure 3.19. In addition, the thickness of the compound fluctuated as shown in Figure 3.22. This behaviour is very different from the smooth curves obtained with the flat plates.
Figure 3.22 The fluctuation of volume under shearing condition. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392. Copyright 1985, Rubber Division of the ACS.
Subsequently, a number of differences in material behaviour were found between the cases with the flat plates and those with the serrated plates. After the compaction experiment was over and the top flat plate was lifted, the compound surface was shiny, indicating that the plate was slipping at the surface. With the serrated plates, there was no slipping at the plate-compound interface. With the flat plates, the compacted material was still friable. With the serrated plates, the rubber particles were ‘fused’ together and no longer friable. When the top plate was lifted, the flat plate cleanly separated at the plate-compound interface. This also implies that there was slipping. When the serrated plate was lifted, the sample broke in the middle. The fractured surface showed that the rubber particles were stretched and torn. The behaviour observed with the serrate plates is very significant, and it will be discussed in section 3.3.7.
67
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
3.3.7 Discussion-II The significant points deduced from the observation with the serrated plates are as follows: •
When the compound does not slip at the interface with the plates, shear is very effective in stretching the rubber particles.
•
The resulting large deformation can lead to a fracture of the rubber.
•
The carbon black probably aids the fracture process as it acts like sandpaper.
•
The newly created surfaces readily adhere to the surface of carbon black.
•
The newly created surfaces attach by cohesion to other rubber particles to ‘fuse’ with each other.
•
Carbon black agglomerates disintegrate, while the rubber particles are deformed and fractured. This aspect has been discussed in section 3.2.
•
The compaction of the mixture of carbon black and powdered rubber proceeds primarily through a large deformation and fracture of rubber particles. The static pressure required is rather small: it is two orders of magnitude smaller than the pressure generated by the action of the rotor blade against the chamber wall and one order of magnitude smaller than the ram pressure.
•
When the large deformation is imposed on the particle-packed systems, there is a tendency for dilatation to occur in order to make a way for the particles to pass each other, [23]. This is indicated by the increase of the thickness of the sample from 4.1 mm to 4.4 mm (see Figure 3.22). The magnitude of the increase is approximately the size of the rubber particles, the average being 0.25 mm in diameter. The thickness decreases to about 4.1 mm as the particles rearrange themselves to new positions.
•
The relaxation of rubber domains occurs as a result of fracture and rearrangement of particles. This explains why the relaxation occurs almost instantaneously during mixing. If the relaxation were through viscoelastic relaxation of the long chain molecules, it would have taken orders of magnitude longer.
•
The previous observation was made with the pressure held constant. If the volume had been kept constant, it would have resulted in the fluctuation of pressure. In the internal mixer, neither pressure nor volume is held constant. However, certain volumetric constraints exist so that the pressure fluctuation occurs [20].
68
Overview of Mixing of Rubber •
During the mixing in the internal mixer the torque fluctuates. This is another observation of the same phenomenon. The end-point of mixing is considered to be the time, when the magnitude of the fluctuation becomes sufficiently small and no longer decreasing. It is proposed here that the magnitude of the fluctuation is related to the rubber-domain size.
From the time of loading to the end of incorporation a significant change takes place under the pressure of the ram and by the action of the rotor blades. What might be taking place with rubber and carbon black has been examined through simulated experiments with laboratory instruments. The most important finding is the contribution of the deformation and fracture of rubber and not just pressure on compaction (massing). The blades of rotors are made with a smooth surface. The present study indicates that a serrated surface is more effective for mixing. Because of the well-known wear of the blades, the serrated surface may not be practical but it may lead to an improvement of the mixing machine, if the way was found to minimise the wear.
References 1.
E. S. Dizon and L. A. Papazian, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1977, 50, 4, 765.
2.
N. Nakajima, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1981, 54, 2, 266.
3.
W. M. Hess, in Reinforcement of Elastomers, Ed., G. Kraus, 1965, John Wiley & Sons, New York, Chapter 6.
4.
N. Nakajima, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1982, 55, 3, 931.
5.
S. Hashizume, Journal of the Society of the Rubber Industry, Japan, 1990, 63, 2, 71.
6.
S. Shiga, and M. Furuta, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 1, 1.
7.
N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392.
8.
G. R. Cotten, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1984, 57, 1, 118.
9.
N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1983, 56, 1, 197.
10. K. Nakagawa and I. Amano, Journal of the Society of the Rubber Industry, Japan, 1980, 53, 9, 550.
69
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing 11. ASTM D 1646 - 96a Test Methods for Rubber - Viscosity, Stress Relaxation and Pre-vulcanization Characteristics (Mooney Viscometer). 12. N. Nakajima, E. R. Harrell and D. A. Seil, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1982, 55, 2, 456. 13. Polymer Handbook, 4th Edn., Eds., J. Brandrup, E. H. Immergut and E. A. Grulke, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1999. 14. R. F. Robbins, Y. Ohori and D. H. Weitzel, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1964, 37, 1, 154. 15. Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 31st Edn., Chemical Rubber Publishing Company, Cleveland, Ohio, 1949, 1715. 16. J-B. Donnet and A. Voet, Carbon Black, Physics, Chemistry and Elastomer Reinforcement, Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York, 1976, 204. 17. J. D. Ferry, Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers, 2nd Edn., John Wiley, New York, 1970, 303. 18. N. Nakajima, H. H. Bowerman and E. A. Collins, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1973, 46, 2, 417. 19. N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Journal of Rheology, 1983, 27, 3, 241. 20. S. Toki, M. Takeshita, Y. Morimoto and M. Okuyama, Presented at the 124th Meeting of the ACS Rubber Division, Fall 1983, Houston, TX, Paper No.37. 21. P. K. Freakley and W. Y. Wan Idris, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1979, 52, 1, 134. 22. N. Nakajima, E. A. Collins and P. R. Kumler, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1974, 47, 4, 778. 23. N. Nakajima, Journal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics, 1983, 12, 349.
70
4
Viscoelasticity and Fracture
4.1 Introduction to viscoelasticity Following the manner of presentation in the previous sections, the subject of viscoelasticity will be explained by reference to experiments familiar to the practitioner of rubber technology. This is a rather unorthodox approach and different from the usual one, which begins with an introduction of the theory. The experiment is tensile stress-strain measurement. In the rubber industry tensile measurements are routinely performed with crosslinked specimens. Here, we are concerned with gum-rubber behaviour. Therefore, we must perform the measurements with uncrosslinked specimens. First, compression-moulded specimens must be prepared; they require special attention, which will be described next. When a gum rubber is compression-moulded for preparing a flat sheet a few millimetres thick, the surface is often uneven, retaining the memory of the sizes and shapes of the pieces of rubber charged to the press. Even when the surface is flat and smooth, the sheet may become wrinkled while in storage. In order to minimise the elastic memory, rubber can be charged as small pieces, evenly spaced, and preheated before applying pressures and/or the pressure may be applied gradually. Even with these precautions, some rubber does not produce a satisfactory sheet. In this case, after compression-moulding, the sheet of rubber is kept in a picture-frame mould with a weight on it and maintained at room temperature for a sufficient time to relax-out the memory. Sometimes this may take more than a week. In general, the higher temperature and the longer time of pressing yield a flat sheet more easily. But it may introduce crosslinks, which alter the viscoelastic properties, thereby, the characteristics of original rubber become obscured. Usually there is a ceiling temperature below which crosslinking does not occur. A typical pressing condition for many commercial rubbers is 160 °C for 20 minutes. Even in this case, the gel-content (insoluble) of the pressed sheet must be checked against that of the rubber before pressing in order to ensure that no significant crosslinking has taken place [1]. Figure 2.2 shows the tensile stress-strain curves of the NBR [2], where the measurements were made with three (high) speeds and at the three temperatures. The same data are replotted in Figure 4.1 as the modulus-strain curves. This conversion is made because the modulus is the material property and the stress is only the manifestation of the property. The
71
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing modulus is observed to decrease with the increase in strain, i.e., strain-softening. The modulus-strain relationship is different for different temperature and different strainrate. At the lower temperature or at the higher strain rate, the modulus is higher and at the reverse conditions the modulus is lower. Data like these can be obtained for the temperature and the strain-rate range corresponding to those during mixing of a rubber.
Figure 4.1 Tensile modulus-strain curves of NBR sample B. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3. Copyright 1996, Hanser Publishers, Munich.
The data of Figure 4.1 can be converted into modulus-time (t) curves; in the tensile measurements, the strain-rate, ε˙ is fixed. Therefore, t may be calculated from the strain-rate and a magnitude of strain, ε: t = ε / ε˙
(4.1)
As shown in Figure 4.2a the data obtained at the lower temperature lie in the shorter time range and those at the higher temperature lie in the longer time range. The next step is the application of the time-temperature correspondence principle [3] to the data at different temperatures, thereby reducing the data to those at 100 °C (Equation 3.9); in this calculation the observed time, t, at a given temperature, T, is changed to the corresponding time, t/aT, at the reference temperature, T0, (100 °C in this case) with the use of the factor, aT (see Figure 4.2b). Then, the time axis is modified further by multiplying with the extension ratio, α, to make it αt/aT. As shown in Figure 4.2c, a master curve is formed from separate curves in Figure 4.2b.
72
Viscoelasticity and Fracture
Figure 4.2a Tensile modulus-time curves at 25, 54, and 97 °C. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3. Copyright 1996, Hanser Publishers, Munich.
Figure 4.2b Tensile modulus-time curves, reduced to 100 °C. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3. Copyright 1996, Hanser Publishers, Munich.
73
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 4.2c Tensile modulus-reduced time curve at 100 °C after application of straintime correspondence. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3. Copyright 1996, Hanser Publishers, Munich.
Among many rubber samples, some of them do not yield a master curve with this treatment. This will be discussed later in this section. In general, the modulus, E, is a function of temperature, T, time, t, and strain, ε or α. At a fixed temperature, E is a function of t and ε(or α). In the above example, E takes a specific form of the dependencies on a time and strain set as αt. This is the same form as the temperature dependence, t/aT. However, aT is species-dependent and requires the experimental determination. On the other hand, α is species-independent, a ‘universal parameter.’ If the temperature dependence of aT is known, the value of the tensile modulus may be calculated from the master curve for any temperature, time, and strain. The implication is that the modulus may be estimated for a rubber in the internal mixer at a specified location and at a specified time, provided that its thermal-mechanical history is known. Modulus-strain curves of another sample of NBR are shown in Figure 4.3 [2]. The shapes of the curves are different from that in Figure 4.1. In Figure 4.3, the modulus is shown to increase with the increase of strain, i.e., strain-hardening.
74
Viscoelasticity and Fracture
Figure 4.3 Tensile modulus-strain curves of NBR sample D. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3. Copyright 1996, Hanser Publishers, Munich.
In this case, the use of reduced time, αt, does not give a master curve, Figure 4.4a. Dividing modulus, E, with a factor, Γ, a master curve is formed as E/Γ ~ αt, Figure 4.4b. The factor, Γ, is an increasing function of α and represents a degree of strain-hardening. With this sample of NBR, Γ takes the following form:
Γ = αn
(4.2)
with n being a positive number. The master curve generated according to the above two methods represents the viscoelastic behaviour of a given gum rubber. Further analyses of the viscoelastic behaviour may be made by the use of these master curves according to the methods given by Ferry [3].
75
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 4.4a Tensile modulus-reduced time aT at 100 °C after application of strain-time correspondence. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3. Copyright 1996, Hanser Publishers, Munich.
Figure 4.4b Tensile modulus divided by strain hardening factor, Γ, plotted against reduced time at 100 °C. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3. Copyright 1996, Hanser Publishers, Munich.
76
Viscoelasticity and Fracture
4.2 Viscoelasticity for characterisation Through hands on experience, a mill operator knows that each gum rubber exhibits a characteristic behaviour. The mill behaviour of gum rubbers is systematically categorised into the four regions of processability [4] in such a way that the behaviour of a given rubber falls in one category or more during milling while temperature of the rubber rises. These four regions obviously describe deformational behaviour, which is shown to correspond to the modulus and the strain at the break [5]. The important point is that the deformational measurements and observations of fracture provide methods for characterising gum rubber. Because the characterisation results must be related to the processability, the above method is most suitable for the purpose. Examples are presented in Section 4.1 of the characterisation of two samples of NBR using tensile stress-strain measurements. The presentation concerns deformational behaviour only, and the failure behaviour will be discussed in Section 4.4. The master curves obtained are related to the MW, its distribution, long branching and gels. This molecular architecture is, in turn, related to the polymerisation conditions. In general, for the polymer characterisation, the standard procedure involves the measurements of MW, its distribution, and branching. With gum rubbers these techniques are often either meaningless or misleading because of the presence of gel, i.e., insoluble fraction. Even small amounts of gel may influence the processability of gum rubber. Therefore, a characterisation method without dissolution of sample is required. The viscoelastic method is suitable for this purpose, although only indirect information is available on the variation of the molecular architecture. Furthermore, there are two types of gels, which require differentiation: one type is a result of the extensive long-branch formation, macrogel; and the other is crosslinked latex particles, microgel. For the samples of unknown origin, the only method available for differentiating macro- and micro-gels is the tensile stress-strain (large deformation) measurements. When the macrogel is present in a significant amount, the rubber exhibits strain-hardening as described in Section 4.1. The exponent n of Equation (4.2), is, therefore, an approximate measure of the macrogel content [6]. When the MW is sufficiently high, the macrogel-containing rubber tends to give a region I behaviour, presenting a difficulty in milling. The relative level of MW may be assessed by comparing master curves of the two samples. Also, the relative degree in the spread of MW distribution is indicated by the shape of the master curve. However, these will be discussed in Chapter 6.
77
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
4.3 Viscoelastic behaviour of rubber in an internal mixer There have been many attempts for describing the behaviour of rubber in internal mixers. Practically all treat rubber as a viscous, inelastic liquid. If the behaviour corresponds to that in Region IV of mill processability [4], it is a viscous fluid but it still has an elastic contribution. As a first step the behaviour of viscous-inelastic fluid and viscoelastic fluid will be compared. A rotational rheometer such as cup-and-bob, cone-plate, or parallel-plates, is switched on at time, t = 0 to start a steady rotation, see Figure 4.5. With a viscous-inelastic fluid, the torque instantly reaches a steady value. With a viscoelastic fluid, it takes a finite time to reach a steady torque. Starting from zero, the torque gradually rises to a constant level for a low rotational speed; it goes over a peak and decreases to a constant value for a high rotational speed, see Figure 4.5. This is called stress overshoot.
Figure 4.5 Operation of rotational rheometers. a: steady rotation b: response of viscous liquid c: response of viscoelastic body d: viscoelastic relaxation from steady state Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3. Copyright 1996, Hanser Publishers, Munich.
78
Viscoelasticity and Fracture When the torque reaches a constant value, the flow is in the steady state; the time period before reaching the steady state is called the transient state. The behaviour in Figure 4.5c is commonly observed with plastic melts and also with gum rubbers [7]. The transient state exists not only when the rotation is started, but also when the rotational speed is changed. When the speed is increased, the torque curve takes the shape shown in Figure 4.5c. When the speed is decreased, the shape is that of the relaxation curve shown in Figure 4.5d. The above behaviour has been described as a relationship between the rotational speed and the responding torque. Taking account of the geometry of the rheometer, the rotational speed may be converted to the shear rate and the torque to the shear stress. In the internal mixer, rubber is present between the chamber wall and a rotor or between two rotors. Using the knowledge of the geometry of the mixer and the relative speed, the shear rate may be calculated for any part of the mixer at a given instant. The key is to recognise that the passageway for rubber is changing all the time; the rubber goes through a wide gap and then a narrow gap. Therefore, the deformation rate is always changing. For viscous-inelastic fluid, the material reaches the steady state instantaneously, but for viscoelastic material it always remains in the transient state. As explained in Chapter 2 the most desirable behaviour of rubber in the mixing process is described by Region II of mill processability [4]. Rubber in this state is elastic and gives a large deformation without break. The torque-time curves recorded at various rotational speed of a rheometer are shown in Figure 4.6 for a sample of gum rubber. The general behaviour is similar to that for the plastic melts shown in Figure 4.5, except that for rubber the torque-level is higher and the stress-over-shoot appears at a relatively lower shear rate [7]. In the on-going discussion it will be assumed that the rubber behaviour in the internal mixer corresponds to Region II of mill processability. Because the rubber in Region II is an elastic material, it deforms and recovers from deformation but it does not flow. Then, the rubber in the internal mixer does not flow but moves to change its position with accompanying deformation and recovery. Is this picture correct? When a rubber is milled in a roll, it deforms initially but gradually takes on the appearance of flow. When the behaviour changes from Region II to Region IV, it starts flowing because Region IV represents viscoelastic fluid. However, even when the rubber behaviour remains in Region II, it gradually assumes an appearance of flow. What is the explanation for this transformation? This question has existed for many years going back at least to the 1940s. When an NR is masticated, polymer chains break, resulting in the significant decrease of MW. The chain scission also occurs with synthetic rubbers but it is usually so slight that it does not noticeably alter the viscoelastic properties
79
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing (synthetic polyisoprene is an exception which degrades like NR). In summary, the chain scission is not an explanation for the appearance of flow.
Figure 4.6 Recorder traces of variable speed Mooney rheometer with SBR 1500 at 100 °C. DR is the dial reading of the Mooney rheometer. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3. Copyright 1996, Hanser Publishers, Munich.
As an explanation, Mooney proposed a generation of super-molecular flow unit [8]. When a matter flows, adjacent molecules present across the velocity gradient changes the mutual position permanently. With an elastic body, the change of the mutual position is not permanent, but recoverable to the original position. However, even with an elastic body, if the strain imposed by the velocity gradient exceeds a limit, it breaks. Between the adjacent broken pieces the mutual position changes permanently. Such broken pieces are much larger than the size of polymer molecules; they are called super-molecular flow units.
80
Viscoelasticity and Fracture Mooney used a parallel plate rheometer with a piece of rubber, with one surface which was dyed. As the rotation continued, the colour of the dye was observed to spread in the direction of thickness of the specimen. The fractured rubber particles, as they rotated under the shear field, carried the dye like an ink-roll. This process imprinted the dye from the surface down to the successive layers of the rubber particles. On the basis of this model Mooney calculated the size of the rubber particles, i.e., the flow unit to be of the order of 10 μm [9]. Mooney’s model on the generation of super-molecular flow units is one of models used as the basis for proposing the comminution model for mixing of rubber with fillers [10]. Thus far the behaviour of rubber in an internal mixer has been explained in terms of shear deformation and fracture to create super-molecular flow units. However, elongational deformation and subsequent fracture is equally important, because wherever the passageway changes its cross-sectional area, the elongational deformation is present. In this case elongational deformation is not limited to pulling. When rubber is squeezed between rotor-tip and the chamber-wall, the deformation is equivalent to elongation. In order to consider the viscoelastic behaviour, therefore, both shear and elongational deformation must be considered. The bulk compression need not be considered because gum rubber is essentially incompressive.
4.4 Mechanism of fracture of gum rubber For a long time it was thought that gum rubber was fractured to smaller and smaller pieces during milling and mixing with carbon black. However, the mechanisms of the fracture of gum rubber had not been examined scientifically. When a given body is deformed gradually to a certain limit, it fractures. This limit is when the stored energy resulting from the deformation becomes equal to the energy required for fracture. With an idealised elastic body, fracture occurs as the elastic stored energy becomes equal to the energy required for creating new fractured surfaces [11]. It is very important to recognise that fracture is inseparable from deformation. Yet, deformation and fracture are distinctly different phenomena. In general, for characterising deformation, the test piece is deformed uniformly. Otherwise, the stress-strain relationship becomes too complex to describe. Even for the treatment of a complex non-uniform deformation, it is sub-divided into small elements, which are assumed to deform uniformly. On the other hand, fracture originates from microscopic flaw, which is an extreme case of non-uniformity. Under the driving force of the stored mechanical energy, the flaw grows to become the fracture surface. In general, unintended or inherent flaw lacks reproducibility, which results in the scatter of the fracture data. In order to improve reproducibility sometimes a prescribed cut is
81
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing made in the specimen to cause stress-concentration. A typical example is the trouser-tear test for rubber [12]. The results of the experiment revealed that the energy required for tear is more than 100 times that for creating new surfaces. Obviously, a large amount of energy is consumed for purposes other than creating new surfaces. The consumption of the energy is attributable to viscoelastic energy-loss in the vicinity of the crack. It is important to explore the mechanism of the viscoelastic loss. Observing the advance of the crack, the vicinity of the crack front is highly deformed. How the crack grows through the highly deformed area is modelled in Figure 4.7.
Figure 4.7 Birth of a vacuole, pull-out of molecular bundle and growth of crack. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3. Copyright 1996, Hanser Publishers, Munich.
According to this model the first step is the generation of a vacuole, which becomes deformed in the direction of stress. The wall between the crack and the deformed vacuole becomes thinner and thinner, eventually breaking into molecular bundles. This is a typical model but the reality may be quite different, depending upon whether the material is in the glassy state, glass-rubber transition, rubbery state or fluid state. For example, in the glassy state the material cannot contract in transverse to the stretch direction; therefore, tensile stress causes dilatation and generates a vacuole. Shear stresses would not generate vacuoles.
82
Viscoelasticity and Fracture In the rubber state, shear stress may become the equivalent of tensile stress if the axis may be freely rotated (Figure 4.8) [13]. For uniaxial extension, there is no vacuole generation, because the volume remains unchanged. However, if the stress is biaxial, the vacuole may form. In the fluid state, local unbalance of the principal stresses becomes shear and there is no vacuole formation.
polymer chain
Figure 4.8 Equivalence of shear and elongational strain, where l o is the original length and l is the increase in length. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1980, 53, 5, 1088. Copyright 1980, Rubber Division of the ACS.
In the process of rubber mixing, which may be either in glass-rubber transition, rubbery state or fluid state, the fracture mechanisms vary. However, a common feature is the pulling out of bundles of polymer chains in the process of creating new surfaces. This must involve disentanglement of chains. Furthermore, the disentanglement must occur through slipping of chain ends. Therefore, the layer close to the fracture surface must have a higher concentration of the chain ends, compared to the interior of the material. Because the chain ends are less constricted by entanglement, they are more fluid compared to the entangled portion of the chain. This explains the fact that rubber becomes tacky as mixing progresses [14]. The next subject is the initiation of the fracture of the rubber during mixing. In the presence of carbon black, sharp corners of the filler may act like sand paper, initiating the tear. Before the addition of the filler, stress concentration is generated when rubber is forced into the narrow gap of a roll-mill or an internal mixer. The flaw initiating the tear must be the molecular heterogeneity of a kind, which gives easier slipping through entanglements. Where the deformation of gum rubber is concerned, the entanglement is assumed to be uniformly distributed. On the other hand, the fracture starts from a microscopic flaw, which is a localised non-uniformity. The presence of the localised non-
83
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing uniformity of entanglement is plausible when we consider the process of polymerisation, where molecules of different size and shapes are generated. They may be different in MW, branching and even in chemical composition, if copolymerisation is involved. The perfect molecular homogenisation probably does not occur, because the resulting entropy-gain is very small. Therefore, at the microscale, there must be regions where entanglements slip easily and other regions where entanglements resist slipping. An extreme example is a rubber containing a microgel, which is made by crosslinking the latex particle with a difunctional comonomer in the emulsion polymerisation. The crosslinked particle is smaller than 100 nm. A rubber containing 50% microgel requires a shorter mixing time compared to the matrix rubber alone without microgels [15]. The microgel introduces the heterogeneity, which facilitates the initiation of fracture. It might also be considered that the microgel constitutes the broken down particles in the comminution mechanism. The pull-out of molecular bundle in fracture of gum rubber is difficult to demonstrate, because the bundle is in a fluid state such that it tends to flatten out. The retraction due to elasticity may also obscure the evidence of the pull-out. When the retraction is slowed, the pull-out in the fracture surface is observed, see Figure 4.9.
Figure 4.9 High magnifications of the fracture sample of PVC-NBR (gel-freeblend) at 0.15 s-1 strain rate. Adapted, by permission, from N. Nakajima and J. L. Liu, Polymer Network Blends, 1993, 3, 2, 93. Copyright 1993, ChemTec Publishing.
84
Viscoelasticity and Fracture The sample was a 50/50 by weight mixture of NBR and polyvinyl chloride (PVC). The NBR contains 33% acrylonitrile and was miscible with PVC. The presence of stiffer PVC chains presumably slowed retraction of the molecular bundle. The fracture was a result of the elongation at room temperature at 0.15 s-1 strain rate. In the previous sections, the fracture of rubber in the mixing process was thought to be different from general behaviour of fracture. The latter involves creation of new surfaces and separation of broken pieces. In the former, the broken pieces do not separate but adhere to the filler surface or to the other piece of rubber. When the adhesion occurs between two pieces of rubber, the healing of the interface is the subject of autohesion [16]. When the surfaces of two pieces of the rubber are contacted for certain period of time and then torn apart at the interface, the force of detachment becomes larger with a longer contact time. This indicates the extent of healing with time by re-establishment of entanglement across the interface. When the force of detachment becomes equal to the force required to create the fresh surfaces in a single piece of specimen of the double thickness, the healing is complete and the interface disappeared completely. Even after 96 hours contact time, a slow peeling indicated that the interface did not heal completely. This means that full reforming of entanglement across the interface takes a long time.
References 1.
N. Nakajima, R. A. Miller and E. R. Harrell, International Polymer Processing, 1987, 2, 2, 88.
2.
N. Nakajima, International Polymer Processing, 1996, 11, 1, 3.
3.
J. D. Ferry, Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1980.
4.
N. Tokita and J. L. White, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1966, 10, 7, 1011.
5.
N. Nakajima and E. A. Collins, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1976, 49, 1, 52.
6.
N. Nakajima, Journal of Applied Polymer Science: Applied Polymer Symposia, 1992, 50, 79.
7.
N. Nakajima and E. A. Collins, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1974, 47, 2, 333.
8.
M. Mooney and W. E. Wolstenholme, Journal of Applied Physics, 1954, 25, 9, 1098.
85
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing 9.
M. Mooney, Journal of Applied Physics, 1956, 27, 7, 691.
10. N. Nakajima, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1982, 55, 3, 931. 11. A. A. Griffith, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 1921, 221, 163. 12. R. S. Rivlin and A. G. Thomas, Journal of Polymer Science, 1953, 10, 3, 291. 13. R. S. Rivlin, in Rheology, Vol. 1, Ed., E. R. Erich, Academic Press, New York, 1956, Chapter 10. 14. N. Nakajima, P. R. Kumler and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 2, 392. 15. M. E. Woods and W. H. Whittington, Presented at the 103rd Meeting of the ACS Rubber Division, Detroit, MI, Spring 1973, Paper No.47. 16. G. R. Hamed and C-H. Shieh, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1985, 58, 5, 1038.
86
5
Characterisation of Gum Rubber Using Dilute Solution Methods
5.1 Introduction The purpose of characterisation may be stated as, in the most general terms, elucidation of a structure-property relationship. The structural characteristics include MW, its distribution, branch patterns and gel types. Microstructure is also included in this category. In addition there are compositional differences among copolymers and blends. The term, property, implies static characteristics such as density and specific heat, although sometimes, dynamic characteristics such as viscoelastic behaviour, are called viscoelastic properties. In order to be all-inclusive the structure-property relationship may be restated as the relationship between the structure/composition and property/behaviour. Why do we need to elucidate such a relationship? This question is seldom asked because the answer may be presumed to be obvious. In the industrial context, the answer lies in the relationship shown in the following sequence: Manufacturing | Characterisation | Processability | Product Properties Specific gum rubber is manufactured to meet the requirements of a finished product having certain properties. This also requires the gum rubber to be processable with the available equipment. Therefore, the characterisation activity is a valuable and often indispensable link in the above relationship. When a problem arises because of an unsatisfactory property in the product or unsatisfactory processability, the final answer must be sought on how to alter the manufacturing process to produce a gum rubber with acceptable properties. In short, we need to establish the above relationship as the background knowledge needed for a day-to-day operation of the manufacturing process as well as for problem solving.
87
88
–12
1000 x 132 51
30
30
41
–30
VT380
–18
–30
VT355
30
101CG
–30
VT330
40
1.00
1.00
1.02
0.98
0.98
0.99
1.00
1.00
Specific Gravity
85
95
55
80
55
30
80
55
Average Mooney Viscosity
High acrylonitrile
Hycar® 1001CG, excellent for high strength adhesives. Available in several cement viscosity ranges and with nonExcellent oil and fuel staining antioxidants. Oil well parts, fuel resistance, controlled cell liners, fuel hose, other uses requiring cement viscosity resistance to aromatic fuels, oils, solvents. Rolls, lathe-cut gaskets, packings, oil seals, O-rings, phenolic resin modification.
Slightly staining
Slightly staining
For better oil, fuel, and solvent resistance than with standard high acrylonitrile Hycar® rubbers: transformer gaskets, fuel lines, et. Hycar® 1000x88 makes outstanding adhesives in blends with thermosetting resins.
Hose, tubing and other extruded goods. Also adhesives and solution coatings.
Print rolls, sheeting, gaskets, resin modification, blends of SBR, Hydrin®, PVC.
Adhesives, moulding, extruding, calendering, non-corrosive to metal.
Fuel hose, rolls, gaskets, packings, oil seals, food grade applications.
Fuel hose, rolls, gaskets, packings, oil seals, food grade applications.
Potential Uses
Very high acrylonitrile polymer; unusually good oil and fuel resistance
High oil resistance. Low foul. Easy processing High oil resistance. Low foul, easy processing Good oil resistance, good water resistance, low foul, easy processing Good oil resistance, good water resistance, low foul, easy processing Good oil resistance, good water resistance, low foul, easy processing
Special Properties
Slightly staining
Nonstaining
Nonstaining
Nonstaining
Nonstaining
Nonstaining
AntiOxidant
BFGoodrich
43
–18
VT480
40
Nominal % Acrylonitrile
Table 5.1 Grades of NBR Manufactured by the BFGoodrich Company
Specific gravity
1000 x 88
–18
VT455
Type
DTA Tg (°C)
NBR Mooney viscosity
Anti-oxidant
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
–29
1022
21
–30.5 –62.0
–43
–52.5
1034-60
1094-80
1095-80
80
80
0.98
55
80
85
50
95
Average Mooney Viscosity
0.95
0.95
0.95
0.98
0.98
0.98
Specific Gravity
Very low nitrile
Nonstaining
Specialised low temperature applications.
Low nitrile with Applications in which excellent lowoutstanding physical temperature properties are critical. properties Nonstaining
Applications in which excellent lowtemperature properties are critical.
Gives minimum die swell in extrusion. Excellent calendering stock with low shrinkage. Recommended for tubing, sheet goods and print plates.
Corrosion resistance Applications in which excellent lowand easy processing temperature properties are critical.
Easy processing polymer
Nerve-free Hycar® 1042, non-soluble. Crosslinked
Slightly staining
Slightly staining
Nonstaining
Low Mooney viscosity, directly Adhesives. Moulded, calendered, soluble, cement extruded goods requiring relatively low grade polymer. FDA moduli. Low heavy metal ion content. applications
Nonstaining
Compounds of Hycar® 1002 have very good water resistance during prolonged service.
Potential Uses
The original medium-high acrylonitrile copolymer
Special Properties
Slightly staining
AntiOxidant
Reprinted with permission from Elastomer Properties, E2, The BFGoodrich Company, Brecksville, OH. Copyright 1985, The BFGoodrich Company.
–
21
21
–61 –39
33
33
33
Nominal % Acrylonitrile
1014
1042x82
–31
DTA Tg (°C)
1002
Type
Table 5.1 Grades of NBR Manufactured by the BFGoodrich Company (continued)
Characterisation of Gum Rubber and Dilute Solution Methods
89
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The characterisation activity may be divided into three kinds. The first is that requiring chemical analysis to find compositional differences. This activity is not dealt with in this book. The second is to find differences among gum rubbers having essentially the same chemical composition but different properties/behaviour. The third is an extreme case of the second; that is, in every respect two gum rubbers are supposed to be the same but either process differently or the properties of the finished products are different. This book deals with the second and the third, where the difference in the processability is the primary focus. Statements on the finished products are also included when they are important. The commercial gum rubbers are made in different grades to satisfy the needs of different applications. The preceding is an example of the grades of NBRs manufactured around 1985 at the BFGoodrich Company, Table 5.1. Among the 15 grades there are compositional differences as well as the differences in structure. Four representative samples, A, B, C, and D, are described in Chapters 2 and 4 with respect to their molecular structure and mill processability. Comparison between the different grades is the first and the second kind of characterisation mentioned earlier. Processability problems may arise within a given grade, if, for example, the processing latitude is very narrow. Matching a competitor’s gum rubber with the same grade may not always work. Handling of these problems requires the third kind of characterisation activity. The dilute solution methods have been used for characterising polymers since day one of polymer science. Measurements of dilute solution viscosity, osmotic pressure and light scattering have been well-established in theory as well as in practice. They are described practically in every textbook and in many review articles. More than 30 years have passed since the introduction of size exclusion chromatography (or gel permeation chromatography; GPC), which provides fractionation data very conveniently. This chapter is not intended to be a review of these methods. It is directed to examining how useful these methods are with respect to sensitivity, reproducibility, and reliability. Stated differently, the question is whether or not differences in processability can be explained on the basis of information available from the dilute solution methods.
5.2 Gel determination As described in Chapters 1, 2 and 4, gels are present in many gum rubbers, exerting a critical influence on their processability. For gel-containing rubbers, the dilute solution methods are not applicable, because gels are removed by filtration. Therefore, the determination of gel content is the first order of the business in the characterisation of gum rubbers.
90
Characterisation of Gum Rubber and Dilute Solution Methods ASTM D3616-95 [1] describes a method for determining of gel, swelling index and dilute solution viscosity (DSV). The method has been developed for E-SBR and NBR, and toluene and methyl ethyl ketone, respectively, are used as solvents. The method is for the determination of macrogel content but it may also be used for microgel, a particle of a crosslinked network. A sample is taken from a bale without milling. Approximately 0.4 g of weighed sample is placed on a 50 mesh screen having 300 μm opening, and soaked in 100 ml of solvent for 16-20 hours at 25 °C without stirring. During this period the soluble fraction is extracted. When the gel-content is high such as 50% or more the sample sitting on the screen is visible to the eyes. The reason why the solution is not stirred is because better reproducibility is obtained. Gels originate in emulsion droplets of less than 0.1 μm diameter and, if stirring breaks up the gels, some of them would go through the screen of 300 μm opening. The gel content is determined indirectly from the amount of soluble fraction and directly by weighing the dried gel. Examples of the reproducibility of the data by round-robin tests are given for two SBR copolymers and three NBRs of 0 to 85% gel content. For the ‘zero’ sample the standard deviation is as high as ± 100% indicating that a very small amount of gel may be distributed non-uniformly. The standard deviations for 50-85% gel samples are at most ± a few per cent. The swelling index indicates a denseness of the branch point; the denser it is, the lower the swelling. The DSV of the soluble fraction is a measure of MW, but only an approximate one, because some molecules may have branches. For the selected samples mentioned previously, the soluble fraction of the higher gel-containing sample had a lower MW. This conforms with the mechanisms of generating branches and gels in free radical polymerisation, which were explained by Flory many years ago, [2]. Because the measured gel content depends upon the pore size of a filter, generally more gel is found with a gel permeation chromatography (GPC) filter having 0.1 - 0.2 μm opening compared to the result from the ASTM screen having a 300 μm opening. The ASTM test is intended to give a pragmatic definition of gel content in such a way that if a sample is gel-free according to this analysis, the effect of gel on the processability is usually negligible. Strictly speaking, this statement may not be acceptable in some cases. For each processability requirement, the assumptions involved in the gel determination need to be examined. Also, the method is only for E-SBRs and NBRs. With ACM gum rubbers, the results from using the 300 μm screen were not useful and the gel-content results obtained with 20 μm opening of a filter paper agreed well with the results from various viscoelastic measurements [3].
91
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Sometimes a gel is generated in the post-polymerisation process; it may come from hung up material somewhere in the reactor, dryer or in the passage-way. They may be hard or soft. They may appear sporadically and are difficult to catch.
5.3 Dilute solution method For gel-containing rubbers the dilute solution properties of the soluble fraction obviously do not represent the gum rubber. On the other hand for completely soluble rubbers such as cis-1,4-BR and ethylenepropylene copolymer (EPM), useful information may be obtained. EPDM tends to have some fraction, which is filtered out with 0.1~0.2 μm filter. The osmotic pressure and light scattering methods give absolute MW, the number-average Mn and the massaverage Mw , respectively. These values alone cannot be used to determine whether a polymer has branches or not. On the other hand, DSV depends upon the degree of branching, because a branched polymer gives a lower viscosity for a given MW. A degree of branching is defined as a ratio of the DSV of a linear sample and that of a branched sample at the same MW. Scientific treatment of DSV is to use the intrinsic viscosity, which is the value extrapolated to zero concentration. For a reason of convenience a DSV at a fixed concentration, for example, 0.2 g/100 ml, is more frequently used in industry. Just which average MW should be used for this comparison may be a problem, if there is a large difference in the MW distribution. Usually a ‘viscosity-average’ MW is used. However, the averaging requires a prior knowledge of the degree of branching, which affects the exponent of Mark-Houwink-Sakurada equation. Original works in developing the method used narrow distribution samples such as a Mw / Mn ratio which was close to one. For finding a difference between samples of the same grade, the method may not be sensitive enough. Because determination of osmotic pressure and light scattering requires special instrumentation and skill to operate, they are usually used for fundamental research only. Because of the convenience, DSV and GPC are more frequently used. GPC provides a fractionation curve, not just mass-average and number-average. DSV is usually just used to obtain a bench-mark of MW, without questioning a presence or absence of branching. The following discussion covers the reliability of information obtainable from GPC with processability in mind. GPC is often described as a method for determining MW and its distribution. This is not true - it is a method for fractionation according to the hydrodynamic size of the swollen polymer coil. The fractionation uses columns packed with porous material; usually it is
92
Characterisation of Gum Rubber and Dilute Solution Methods porous polystyrene beads crosslinked to make them insoluble. Because commercial rubbers often have very broad MW distribution, as many as four columns are used in series, each having different pore size designation. A dilute solution of a sample polymer is injected to a solvent-stream, which is flowing slowly through the columns. Because smaller polymer-chains can diffuse into the pores, it resides in the columns for a longer time. Therefore, the larger molecules are eluted first. The concentration of polymer at any instant of elution is measured by the difference between the refractive index of the solution and that of the solvent. Because the elution time is the measure of the swollen size of the polymer chain, the elution time must be calibrated for the swollen size of polymer chain; then it must be converted to MW. For convenience, usually fractions of known MW of unbranched polystyrene are used for the calibration. If a sample in question is a linear polystyrene, this calibration is satisfactory. For branched polystyrenes the calibration samples must also be branched, because the branched polymer has a smaller hydrodynamic size than the linear one for the same MW. If the branch pattern is different, for example, an equal arm star against a comb-type, the hydrodynamic size is different. For evaluating the MW of a branched polymer by GPC, calibration samples having exactly the same branch pattern are required. When the branch pattern of a sample in question is not known, there is no way to calibrate. The question of calibration is often ignored. The data of MW and MW distribution reported in the literature are often only relative values, based on the linear polystyrene standards. This may still be useful if a sample in question is unbranched. For branched polymers, such data does not have a precise meaning. Some elaborate methods have been developed for obtaining information about the degree of branching from GPC data. It requires a rather tedious procedure. Moreover, degree of branching ignores the difference of branch patterns. Therefore, it has only a very limited use. There are other problems concerning the calibration. The elution time is also a measure of elution volume. The rate of elution must be controlled so that it is constant all times. Earlier GPC instruments were deficient in this regard, contributing to the reproducibility problem. In the later models a satisfactory pumping system giving a steady flow-rate, is installed. The advanced models of GPC are equipped to measure the MW of the eluting polymer with a low angle laser light scattering device (LALLS). This enables the calibration problem to be eliminated. A special attachment to measure the viscosity of the eluting solution is also available. From the above two measurements a degree of branching may be estimated. The information on the branch pattern is not obtainable, however.
93
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Because the LALLS was not available for the earlier work and even at present it is not always used, the following discussion is given on the use of calibration curves. Because a very high MW polymer and a very small gel accumulate in the columns, the column performance changes with time. This requires a frequent re-calibration or a running a reference sample. When columns lose satisfactory performance or eventually even plug up, the columns must be repacked and re-calibrated. For this reason a sample solution is carefully filtered through a 0.1-0.2 mm filter. If a very high MW fraction is removed by filtration, the resulting elution curve does not represent the sample in question. This is a serious problem when we consider that the processability is often affected by the presence of a small amount of very high MW fraction. Most annoying is when it is not known whether the higher MW fraction is removed by filtration or not. Figure 5.1 is an example of the calibration curve [4].
Figure 5.1 Calibration curve obtained using polystyrene standards. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, Advances in Chemistry Series, 1973, 125, 98. Copyright 1973, The ACS.
94
Characterisation of Gum Rubber and Dilute Solution Methods Because the calibration curve is a semi-log relationship, a small error in the elution volume is magnified at the MW scale. Another problem is a lack of the calibration standard at the very high MW. The significance of this is shown in Figure 5.2 [5].
Figure 5.2 A typical 4 column GPC chromatogram of linear polyethylene. Solvent: trichlorobenzene. Temperature: 137 °C. Columns: 7 x 106, 3 x 106, 105, and 103 Å. Solution concentrate: 0.5%. Injection time 130 s. Flow rate: 2 cm3/min. Refractive index difference in relative unit. Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Separation Science, 1971, 6, 2, 277, Figure 1, by courtesy of Marcel Dekker, Inc.
It is evident that below count no. 22, there is no calibration. Assuming the extrapolated part of the calibration curve, is correct, the mathematical moments of the MW distribution were calculated according to Equations (5.1)-(5.5), where Qi’s are zeroth to fourth moments, Ai is the relative MW based on the polystyrene standard and Wi is the mass fraction of polymer having MW, Ai. The corresponding curves for the area-integration are shown in Figures 5.3a-e [5].
(
)
(
)
Q0 = ∫ 1/Ai dWi /dAi dAi = ∫ dWi /dAi d lnAi
(5 .1) (Curve a)
(
)
(
)
Q1 = ∫ dWi /dAi dAi = ∫ Ai dWi /dAi d lnAi
(5.2) (Curve b)
(
)
2
(
)
Q2 = ∫ Ai dWi /dAi dAi = ∫ Ai dWi /dAi d lnAi
(5.3) (Curve c)
95
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing 2
(
)
3
(
)
Q3 = ∫ A i dWi /dAi dAi = ∫ Ai dWi /dAi d lnAi
(5.4) (Curve d)
3
(
)
4
(
)
Q4 = ∫ A i dWi /dAi dAi = ∫ Ai dWi /dAi d lnAi
(5.5) (Curve e)
An = Q1 / Q0
or
1/Q0
(number average)
(5.6)
Aw = Q2 / Q1
or
Q2
(weight average)
(5.7)
Az = Q3 / Q2
(z average)
(5.8)
Az +1 = Q4 / Q3
(z + 1 average)
(5.9)
Figure 5.3a is based on Equation (5.1).
96
Characterisation of Gum Rubber and Dilute Solution Methods
Figure 5.3b is based on Equation (5.2).
Figure 5.3c Based on Equation (5.3).
97
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 5.3d is based on Equation (5.4).
Figure 5.3e is based on Equation (5.5). Figure 5.3 Moments, percentages shown are cumulative weight fractions. Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Separation Science, 1971, 6, 2, 279, Figures 2a, 2b, 2c, 2d and 2e, by courtesy of Marcel Dekker, Inc.
98
Chain length
Moments
Characterisation of Gum Rubber and Dilute Solution Methods
Table 5.2 Moments and Average Chain Length Quantity
Computer integration
Possible range of values resulting from baseline error (hand calculation)
Q0
1.59 x 10-3
Negligible
Q1
1.01
Negligible
Q2
8.95 x 103
Negligible
Q3
4.77 x 108
4.52-4.85 x 108
Q4
4.82 x 1013
4.32-5.30 x 1013
An
6.3 x 102
Negligible
Aw
8.9 x 103
Negligible
Az
5.3 x 104
5.05-5.4 x 104
Az+1
1.01 x 105
0.96-1.09 x 105
Integrating for Q0, (see Figure 5.3a), the entire area falls within the calibration limit and for Q1, (see Figure 5.3b), almost whole area is calibrated. Therefore, the number average MW, A n, given by Equation (5.6), is approximately correct. For Q2 (see Figure 5.3c), only one-half of the area falls within the calibration limit and therefore, the weight average MW, A w, Equation (5.7) is not very reliable. For the Q3 and Q4 integration almost entire areas are not calibrated. Therefore, Z average A z and Z +1 average Az +1 , Equations (5.8) and (5.9), are creations of the arbitrary calibration curve. Because the computer provides a neat printout of Mw , M z and M z+1, the values are often accepted without scrutinising whether they are the creation of the software or not. One more problem with GPC is a possible lack of the resolution at the high molecular tail. In Figure 5.2 the elution appears to start at about count number 19. Is this because the MW distribution has a cut-off or is it the limit of the resolution of the column?
5.4 Relationship between dilute solution properties and processability Because of the calibration problems, the information obtained from GPC is at best the relative values of MW and its distribution. The higher averages such as M z and M z+1
99
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing are often meaningless. When the branching is involved, the credibility is reduced further. For example, when two samples have a difference in the apparent values of Tg, we are not sure whether there is a difference in the true M n or if one sample has more branches than the other. There is a well-established relationship for polymer melts between the low shear Newtonian viscosity and MW, η0 = k M wn (Equation 5.6), where K is a constant and n is 3.4 or a very similar number [6]. Very high MW dependence, i.e., 3.4 power, comes from extensive entanglements of polymer chains, which are slipping through each of the other chains at low shear rate conditions. The low shear Newtonian viscosity is sometimes called zero-shear viscosity. Strictly speaking the two are different. The zero-shear viscosity is a viscosity extrapolated to zero shear rate and the value depends upon the method of extrapolation. This is particularly true for a polymer having a very high MW tail or a polymer with long branches. On the other hand, the low shear Newtonian viscosity is an observed value. The relationship in Equation (5.6) was established with series of samples having different MWs and a very narrow MW distribution. In order to observe the relationship, a given gum rubber must be in the flow state. This often requires a temperature where degradation sets in, or it takes a very long time so as to be impractical. The exception to this is rubbers prepared via anionic polymerisation and polydimethyl siloxane (PDMS); in these rubbers the high MW tail of distribution is not extending very much. In general, a gum rubber has a very high MW fraction, long branches or both. In the processing condition it is usually not in the flow state but it is in the rubbery state. In the latter state a rubber, having apparently a higher MW may have a lower modulus, if it has long branches. Likewise, a lower Mooney index does not necessarily mean a given rubber having lower MW. Instead, it may have more branches. When there are large differences in the pattern of the MW distribution among the samples, GPC may provide information such as shown in Figure 5.4 [7]. A caution is that even in this case the fractionation curve of E-SBR does not represent MW distribution, because there are branches and probably gels in the sample. The main purpose of this chapter is to caution the reader against over-reliance on the dilute solution properties, particularly on GPC. The methods are good for detecting relatively large differences. They often lack sensitivity required for problem solving in processability. Much time may be wasted in trying to interpret data and trying to obtain information, which is not really there.
100
Characterisation of Gum Rubber and Dilute Solution Methods
Figure 5.4 Examples of MW distribution of SBRs. Reprinted with permission from A. Saito, Journal of the Society of the Rubber Industry, Japan, 1998, 71, 6, 316. Copyright 1998, Society of the Rubber Industry, Japan.
References 1.
ASTM D3616-95. Standard Test Method for Rubber, Raw - Determination of Gel, Swelling Index, and Dilute Solution Viscosity.
2.
P. J. Flory, Principles of Polymer Chemistry, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York, 1953, 347.
3.
N. Nakajima and S. K. Sundarapandian, Rubber World, 1995, 212, 3, 33.
101
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing 4.
N. Nakajima, Advances in Chemistry Series, 1973, 125, 98.
5.
N. Nakajima, Separation Science, 1971, 6, 2, 275.
6.
J. D. Ferry, Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers, 3rd Edition, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1980, p.509.
7.
A. Saito, Journal of the Society of the Rubber Industry, Japan, 1998, 71, 6, 315.
102
6
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
6.1 Introduction In the previous chapters the processability of gum rubber was related to its behaviour at large deformation and fracture. A given rubber has a unique deformational behaviour, which may be characterised by its viscoelastic properties. The latter is, in turn, related to the molecular architecture. Therefore, viscoelastic properties play a central role in relating polymerisation conditions to processability of gum rubber. The viscoelastic characterisation has particular importance for gum rubbers, because many of them contain an insoluble fraction called ‘gel’, which makes solution-based characterisation inapplicable. In this chapter, a development of the viscoelastic characterisation method is described. It begins with methods of describing deformation behaviour, subsequently a treatment of non-linear viscoelasticity is presented. Finally, by using the viscoelastic characterisation method, the processability of gum rubber is related to its molecular architecture.
6.2 Methods of describing deformation When the subject of deformation of rubber is considered, a conventional approach such as shear or elongation is accepted. The definition of steady state viscosity is an example of the former and that of tensile testing is an example of the latter. However, the deformation of rubber during mixing is not completely shear nor elongation. Therefore, the way to describe this deformation needs to be examined. The bulk compression need not be considered, because rubber is practically incompressible. For simplicity, consider an elastic body which is in isolation. The deformation of this body may be described by the stress tensor σij and the deformation tensor εij as:
σij = Σaijεij
(6.1)
where the subscripts i and j are for the 1, 2, and 3 directions, in orthogonal co-ordinate systems and aijs are moduli, [1]. Equation 6.1 represents nine equations and is very
103
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing complex. Rubber being an isotropic and amorphous body, the relationship may be simplified to only simple shear, σ12, and normal stress components σ11, σ22, and σ33. For an infinitesimal deformation, the shear modulus G and elongational modulus E are related as: G=
E
(6.2)
2(1 + v )
where v is Poisson’s ratio and equal to 0.5 for rubber: E = 3G
(6.3)
When Equation 6.3 holds, either shear or elongational measurements need to be performed to adequately describe the rubber behaviour. However, this is limited to infinitesimal deformation. For describing a finite deformation, a concept of strain energy function is introduced instead of stress, because energy is the basic quantity and stress is the phenomenological expression for the energy change resulting from deformation. The expression for strain takes a strain invariant form. This is based on the understanding that strain should not depend upon a particular choice of coordinate system. Also, the coordinate axis may be rotated from that before deformation to that after deformation. This enables any deformation to be described with strains in three principal axes only. In order for this to be possible, the body must be isotropic and uniform. Therefore, it is not applicable to compounds containing filler. Also, for the rotation of the axis not to alter the magnitude of strain, the body must be isolated. For interconnected elements in finite element analysis, the rotation of the axis may affect the strain in the neighbouring elements. The final derivation of the above theory [2] is presented in the following form for strain energy U: U=
Σ
i = 0, j = 0
(
) ( I 2 − 3)
Cij I1 − 3
i
j
(6.4)
where Cij is a material constant, I1 and I2 are strain invariants. In this case I3 = 1 because rubber is practically incompressible. When Equation 6.4 is applied to extensional deformation, the following equation is often used: U = C1(I1 − 3) + C2(I2 − 3) This equation is called the Mooney [3] or Mooney-Rivlin equation.
104
(6.5)
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber Although Equation 6.5 is derived through rigorous logic, it is based on a number of premises. Therefore, before applying it to the system of interest, we need to examine if a given case is in conformity with the premises. The equation assumes an equilibrium, and therefore it applies to a crosslinked network only. As gum rubbers are uncrosslinked, they do not attain equilibrium because of the slipping of entanglements. Even with a network, the large deformation data progressively deviate from the form given by the equation. There is another approach which uses the concept of strain energy and principal strains only; it is called the Valanis-Landel equation [4]. It assumes that the total strain energy may be subdivided into those corresponding to each of three principal strains: u(λ1,λ2,λ3) = u(λ1)+u(λ2)+u(λ3)
(6.6)
Where λ1, λ2, and λ3 are strains expressed as the elongational ratios in the direction of the principal axes. This equation assumes that u(λ1), u(λ2), and u(λ3) may in general take different values; this means the coordinate axes are fixed and are not free to be chosen. This is more like the usual shear and elongational measurements where the magnitude of strain is tied to a specific coordinate system. The concept of strain invariance is not used. Ogden’s equation [5] may be regarded as a specific form of Equation 6.6: u(λi) = (μi / αi)(λiαi − 1)
(6.7)
where i = 1, 2, and 3. This equation has six material constants, μi and αi. The approaches described so far employ a specific form of the equation for relating stress and strain (constitutive equation). The equation contains a number of material constants, which must be determined through fitting the equations to the experimental data. Heretofore, there has been no attempt to relate these material constants to the molecular architecture of gum rubbers. Next, an approach commonly used for the viscoelastic treatment, which involves nonequilibrium is presented. The following example relates to elongational measurement. Because gum rubber is amorphous, isotropic and incompressible:
λ1 = 1 / λ2λ3
(6.8)
λ 2 = λ3 =
(6.9)
and λ1
105
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Therefore, λ1 is the only independent variable of strain and the elongational stress σ11 is a function of λ1 only: σ11 = f(λ1) = f′(ε1)
(6.10)
where
λ1 = ε1 +1
(6.11)
Equation 6.10 may be expressed in terms of tensile modulus with the recognition of time-dependence as E = σ/ε = f′′( ε˙ , ε)
(6.12)
where ε˙ is the rate of elongation. Also, the subscript is dropped because it is no longer necessary. When the rate of elongation is constant, time t is given by t = ε / ε˙
(6.13)
E = f′′′(t, ε)
(6.14)
σ = E(t, ε)ε
(6.15)
and
The constitutive equation is
where the stress and strain are related through the material function E(t, ε) instead of the material constants. The use of material functions for describing the mechanical behaviour of polymers is the general method in the field of viscoelasticity [6] and this paper follows the convention.
6.3 Non-linear viscoelasticity When the magnitude of response of a material is proportional to the strength of the imposed field, a linear relationship exists. Typical examples in the field of rheology are Hooke’s law:
σ = Eε
106
(6.16)
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber and the Newtonian flow equation
τ = ηγ˙
(6.17)
where τ is the steady state shear stress and γ˙ is the steady state shear rate. In this case, E and η are material constants. In the field of viscoelasticity, the definition of linearity is modified to
σ = E(t)ε
(6.18)
where E(t) is a function of time, i.e., a material function. The material functions may be the storage modulus G′(ω) and the loss modulus G′′(ω) of shear dynamic measurements, the relaxation modulus, G(t) and creep compliance J(t). For linear viscoelasticity the material functions are functions of the ‘time scale’ only. The time scale includes the observed time as well as the frequency v (Hz) or the angular frequency ω (rad/s). However, the steady state non-Newtonian flow equation
τ = η(γ˙ )γ˙
(6.19)
is understood to be non-linear [6]. Gum rubbers in general exhibit linear behaviour at small deformations. For studying mixing of rubber, we must treat large deformations. In this case, modulus is not only a function of time, but also of strain; the relationship is called non-linear. An example with elongational measurements is already stated in Equation 6.15
σ = E(t,ε)ε When the material behaviour is linearly viscoelastic for a sample (Equation 6.18), E(t) plotted against t forms a curve, which is unique for a given sample; usually a log E(t) versus log t plot is used. When the material behaviour is non-linear, as in Equation (6.15), it requires both the t-axis and ε-axis to present the sample characteristics as a curved surface. Where two different samples are concerned, the two curved surfaces must be compared and the process is rather cumbersome. In addition, many measurements are required to construct the characteristic surface. There have been various attempts to simplify the situation; they are, in general, attempts to ‘linearise’ the non-linear behaviour. The linearisation is possible in some cases and not
107
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing possible in others. In general, it is possible when the ‘separability of time and strain’ holds. The separability may be explained by the following example E(t, ε) = F(t)φ(ε)
(6.20)
At the limit, ε 0, it gives φ(ε) 1 and therefore E(t, ε ) = F(t) ε →0
(6.21)
This gives a linear relationship at infinitesimal strain [7]. When equation (6.20) is written as E(t,ε) / φ(ε) = F(t)
(6.22)
the modulus is linearised through the modification with φ(ε). Although these expressions for linearisation, i.e., equations (6.20-6.22), are often cited, the physical meaning of the function φ(ε) has not been examined. The linear behaviour at small deformations may be interpreted as follows. The elongational modulus E is independent of the magnitude of strain, equation (6.16), a fact which means that the internal structure of the material is unaffected by the deformation. Stated the other way around, if the internal structure is altered as a result of the deformation, E must change. Therefore φ(ε) is a measure corresponding to the change of the internal structure which is affected by strain ε. In general, the internal structure is expected to change upon deformation, and nonlinear behaviour is the rule at a finite deformation. However, the gum rubber chain segments, which are shorter than the entanglement coupling distance, are in liquid motion. Therefore, any change in the structure may immediately be relaxed. This may explain the apparent linear behaviour exhibited by many gum rubbers at finite but relatively small deformations. When rubber crystallises upon stretching, e.g., NR, obviously there is structure change and non-linear behaviour is expected. Even with non-crystallising gum rubbers, nonlinear behaviour is observed at large deformations. With the form given in equations (6.20-6.22), the internal structure is affected by strain but is independent of strain rate. The internal structure of rubber is affected by the motion of chain segments and their relaxation times. Therefore, non-linearity should appear in both time-dependence and
108
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber strain-dependence. With consideration of both dependences, Schapery gave a general form for the separability of time and strain [8]. His theory is presented [1] for the nonlinear creep compliance, Ju(t), and for the non-linear stress relaxation modulus, Gn(t): Ju ( t ) =
Gn (t ) =
e( t )
σ
σ (t ) e
= g0 Ju + g1g2 ΔJ (t / aσ )
(6.23)
= he Gr + h1h2 ΔG(t / ae )
(6.24)
where σ is the stress and e is the strain, Ju is the unrelaxed compliance, i.e., glassy compliance, and
ΔJ(t) = J(t) − Ju
(6.25)
The symbols g0, g1, g2, and aσ are functions of stress and represent the extent of nonlinearity. At the limiting condition, σ 0, these functions approach one, and represent linearity. Referring to equation 6.24, Gr is the relaxed modulus, which has a constant value for crosslinked rubber but otherwise is zero:
ΔG(t) = G(t) − Gr
(6.26)
The symbols he, h1, h2, and ae are functions of strain and represent the extent of nonlinearity. At the limiting condition, e 0, all these approach one. According to the interpretation of this chapter, g0, g1, g2, and he, h1, h2, reflect the changes of internal structure upon application of stress in the former and strain in the latter case, respectively. The functions aσ and ae represent the effect of stress and strain, respectively, on the time scale. This may be explained as follows. When a body is deformed, the corresponding amount of mechanical energy is imparted to the body. This energy brings about a certain degree of excitation. This is analogous to the excitation resulting from thermal energy input. In the latter case, the excitation takes the form of time-temperature correspondence with many polymer melts and rubbers. The extent of temperature effect on time scale is the ‘shift’ factor’, aT, which is a function of temperature. Likewise, the mechanical excitation is expected to have an influence on time scale [9]. In this case, aσ and ae are similar to aT. The material functions g0, g1, g2, aσ and he, h1, h2, ae must be determined
109
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing experimentally. Once they are known, linearisation becomes possible for non-linear behaviour. With many gum rubbers a very simple form of linearisation is possible [10, 11]. In terms of Schapery’s theory, it corresponds to he = 0, h1 = 1, h2 = 1, and ae = 1 / α for the elongation data:
σ = E(αt)ε
(6.27)
Because α is the extension ratio, it is a ‘universal parameter’, which does not require experimental determination. There are gum rubbers which do not obey the relationship given by equation 6.27. One case is rubber exhibiting strain-hardening. The linearisation in this case is in terms of Schapery’s theory, he = 0, h1 = 1, h2 = 1 / Γ(α), and ae = 1 / α. Γ(α) represents the extent of strain-hardening and must be determined from experimental measurements:
σ = [F(αt)Γ(α)]ε
(6.28)
F(αt) = E(ε,t) / Γ(α)
(6.29)
where
A phenomenological explanation has been given for equations 6.27-6.29 by this author [12] without reference to Schapery’s theory. It is a rational analysis of the relationship between macroscopic deformation and the deformation in the segmental level of polymer chains. An increase of free volume resulting from deformation in the dynamic state is the explanation for the strain-time correspondence.
6.4 Conventional methods of characterisation For a given type of gum rubber, if the compositional aspects such as the comonomer ratio, microstructure and their distributions are known, characterisation becomes centered around the determination of MW, its distribution, and the degree of branching. For expediency, the DSV (see Chapter 5) is often used as a measure of MW. For the determination of absolute MWs, osmotic pressure measurement is used for numberaverage and light scattering for weight average. A relative spread of MW distribution is expressed by the ratio of the weight-average to the number-average MW. With the advent of size exclusion chromatography, much more detail of the MW distribution is obtained quickly. The raw data are processed to yield various MW averages, M n, M w, M z, and M z+1. For the dilute solution methods of characterisation the theoretical background has been well developed [13]. On the other hand, the information derived from these
110
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber methods is often inadequate or even misleading when related to the processability of gum rubbers. There are a number of reasons for this: (i)
the sample size is so small that it may not be representative of a large commercial lot
(ii)
the solution is so dilute that the response signal may be weak for the part of the information relevant to processability
(iii)
the high MW chains may associate
(iv)
the ultra-high MW fraction may be filtered off
(v)
the gel, i.e., insoluble fraction, is removed by the filters
(vi)
there may be no adequate resolution for the very high MW range
(vii) there are no calibration standards for the ultrahigh MWs in GPC. Items (iii), (iv), and (v) give much uncertainty in interpreting results, because of the presence or absence of molecular association, ultra-high MW and gel usually remains unknown. The high MW fraction and gel often have significant effects on processability even though the amount is small. In production control, GPC data are sometimes collected routinely along with measurements of the Mooney index [14]. When these two sets of data are compared for hundreds of production lots, in only about 50% of cases may a correlation be found. This is partly because the Mooney index is a very crude measure of rubber property, but the uncertainties described above on GPC data are also responsible. The Mooney index is often called ‘Mooney viscosity’ but there is no rationale that the index represents viscosity. It is an expression of some aspect of viscoelasticity in that there may be some relationship to the processability. The method uses an instrument with a particular design, which provides a simple operation and a quick result. Compared to the dilute solution method, the sample size required is much larger so that it is more representative of the commercial lot. The Mooney index has been used worldwide as a specification for gum rubbers. However, there is no firm theoretical basis for this index. It is only a very crude method of differentiation between samples; for the same value of the index, the processability of two gum rubbers may be different. In other cases, with rather wide differences in the value of the Mooney index, two rubbers may process almost equally well. There have been attempts to interpret the meaning of the Mooney index. Often it is assumed that the measurement concerns steady state viscosity at a prescribed temperature.
111
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The standard procedure [14] requires 1 minute of preheating before the rotation is started. Because the temperature is set at for example, 100 °C, the sample is not even in temperature equilibrium. The procedure is obviously a compromise for obtaining the data quickly. The rotational speed being 2 rpm, most of the rubber at 100 °C shows stress-over-shoot (see section 4.3) [6]. The torque value is recorded after 4 minutes of rotation and expressed as the Mooney unit. At 4 minutes, the torque is usually past the peak and in the relaxation part of the curve but not in the steady state. This is shown in Figure 6.1, for somewhat exaggerated examples, which gave the same Mooney index but vary in viscoelastic behaviour.
Figure 6.1 Typical Mooney curves; very different viscoelastic properties for the same Mooney indices. Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
If sufficient time is given for preheating, more than several minutes, and the rotation is continued, a steady state torque may be observed, [15]. The steady torque is not necessarily the result of the flow, but quite often a result of the fracture of the rubber and the generation of supermolecular flow units [16]. Nevertheless, it is sometimes assumed to be the steady state flow and the steady state viscosity is calculated as a function of shear rate. Such a calculation is quite involved, because of the geometry of
112
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber the instrument and non-uniform distribution of shear rates [17]. More useful is the torque rise part of the curve, the transient behaviour from which a complex property may be calculated. Being a complex property, it may be resolved into elastic and viscous contributions. However, 2 rpm is too fast to obtain accurate data of the torque rise. As slow a rate as possible, e.g., 0.05 rpm, is recommended both for reasons of accuracy and for covering a wide range of time scales. As described in Chapters 4 and 5, an adequate description of gum rubber processability requires a scientific approach; it requires observation of non-linear viscoelasticity and fracture behaviour over a range of temperatures and time. The non-linear viscoelastic data are represented by a curved surface as mentioned earlier in section 6.3 and the fracture behaviour is summarised in a failure envelope. Quite often, numbers (indices) are preferred to graphs and figures for representing a sample; a minimum number of the indices necessary for adequately describing a given gum rubber was determined to be 12, a ‘12 point characterisation’ [18]. If values are known for some of the indices, or if they do not vary among the samples of interest, the number of determinations may be considerably reduced. The method this author prefers is the use of curves. The surface, representing non-linear viscoelasticity, may be converted to a curve, through the linearisation scheme described in section 6.3. The fracture behaviour is expressed as a failure envelope of the modulus and the strain at break.
6.5 Characterisation based on viscoelasticity Characterisation of a gum rubber requires determination of the amount of gel fraction, unless it is known to be gel-free. The most direct means of determining gel content is the filtration of the solution. However, the absolute value of gel content is difficult to assess, because the value depends upon the pore size of the filter. Also, the gel is not necessarily distributed uniformly throughout a given lot so that the data are only approximate measures. The viscoelastic method is relative but more reproducible than filtration because the sample size is larger. For a critical examination of the presence of gel, the viscoelastic method provides a better comparison among samples; the filtration results may be used as supplementary information. The generation of a macrogel, a highly branched insoluble molecule, begins with the formation of long branches. At present, there is no clear knowledge about how many long branches per molecule must form before it becomes insoluble. Because our present interest is in processability and not in solubility, long branches and gel may be considered to be of the same kind but differing in degree. The following method may be used for evaluating the relative degree of long branching or gel content. Firstly, shear dynamic measurements are preformed to obtain storage modulus G´(ω) and loss modulus G´´(ω). Then, G´ and G´´ are 113
Modulus loss elastic Mooney index
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing taken at the same value of ω, and plotted as log G´´ versus log G´. Examples are shown in Figure 6.2 for the samples of NBR which are listed in Table 6.1 [19].
Figure 6.2 Log G´´ - log G´ curves of NBR samples 1-7 (see Table 6.1). Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
Table 6.1. Characteristics of butadiene-acrylonitrile copolymer samples Sample 1 2
a
Mooneyb index ML-4-100 71 22
Acrylonitrile content of polymer (%) 43.7 41.2
Gela (%) 0. 9 0. 1
3 4
12 1 103
39. 4 40.3
0. 1 54. 7
5 6 7
88 52 56
40.9 33.8 28.4
71. 7 0 5.1 1
ASTM D 3616-95 [20], only an approximate measure ASTM D 1646-96a [14]
b
114
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber Samples 1, 6, and 7 are so-called ‘gel-free’, commercial polymers, containing acrylonitrile of 44, 34, and 28%, respectively. The gel determination is based on ASTM D 3616-95 [20], which requires a screen having a 300 μm opening. If a GPC filter with 0.1 ~ 0.2 μm opening is used, a significant amount of gel may be found in the ‘gel-free’ polymer. The ASTM test is intended to give a pragmatic definition of gel content in such a way that if a sample is gel-free according to this analysis, the effect of gel on the processability is negligible. Strictly speaking, the above statement may not be acceptable in some cases. Therefore, for each polymer type and for each processability requirement, the assumptions involved in the gel determination need to be examined. Returning to Samples 1, 6, and 7, the log G´´ versus log G´ curves of these polymers are the same; this fact indicates that these polymers have the same degree of long branching and are ‘gel-free’. Next, Samples 1, 2, and 3 are compared. Samples 2 and 3 were made in a pilot plant under the same polymerisation conditions (except for MW) as that of the commercial product, Sample 1. Sample 2 is made to a lower MW with the use of a modifier, which also suppresses the long branch formation. Sample 3 is made to have a higher MW. Samples 4 and 5 contain significant amounts of gel. In Figure 6.2, the curves of the seven samples form four groups. Sample 2 containing the least long branches lies on the left; the ‘gel-free’ samples, 1, 3, 6 and 7, are in the middle; Sample 4 containing 55% gel is on the right; and Sample 5 containing 70% gel is on the far right. This figure illustrates that from the position of log G´´ versus log G´ plots, the degree of long branching or the gel content may be assessed. The 45° line in the figure represents G´´ = G´. The curve of Sample 2 is above this line, G´´ > G´. The data of this sample are in the flow region. The curves of all other samples are in the state G´ > G´´, indicating the dominance of elastic behaviour over viscous behaviour. In the earlier chapters, the mill processability of gum rubber was interpreted on the basis of whether elasticity or viscous loss dominates. Although the mill processability involves large deformation and the data of Figure 6.2 are limited to small deformations, an approximate relationship between Figure 6.2 and the mill processability may be found. Only one exception to this relationship, but a very important one, is gum rubber containing microgel. The microgel is a particle containing a crosslinked network, which may be formed during emulsion polymerisation with difunctional co-monomer [21]. The response of microgel to processability is entirely different from that of macrogel, and yet in Figure 6.2 only gel content may be assessed but not the difference between macrogel and microgel. In order to differentiate between gel types, large deformation measurements must be performed and the strain-time correspondence must be used for linearisation. The elongation measurements performed at a constant temperature and various elongation rates are expressed
115
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing as the elongational modulus E(αt). With some gum rubbers, E(αt) becomes a master curve, which is independent of the elongation rates, and with others it is rate dependent. The former type is either gel-free or contains a small amount of macrogel and any amount of microgel. The latter type shows strain-hardening and contains a significant amount of macrogel. Typical examples are shown in Chapter 4, but additional examples are now given. Instead of using elongational modulus, the equivalent of complex viscosity may be used:
ηT = E(αt)αt
(6.30)
In this case, ηT is expressed as a function of the reduced rate, 1/αt. If linearisation holds, 1/αt is numerically equal to ω. Further, for a Poisson’s ratio of 0.5, ηT is related to shear complex viscosity |η*| as
ηT = 3 |η*|
(6.31)
In this manner large deformation elongational data may be compared with small deformation shear data. A number of examples are presented below in the form of equation (6.31). Figure 6.3 shows the data for sample C of NBR with 33% acrylonitrile containing about 50% of microgel.
Figure 6.3 Comparison of viscosities calculated from tensile measurements with dynamic shear viscosities for sample C of NBR with 33% acrylonitrile and about 50% microgel. Shear viscosities, ERD; elongation rate, ε˙ . Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
116
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber There is some scatter in data points but the data at three different elongation rates form a master curve, which is also in agreement with the shear data as per equation (6.31). Figures 6.4 and 6.5 are for a sample of SBR 1502, and a sample of SBR 1712, respectively, both being gel-free. SBR 1712 is an oil-extended gum rubber. A sample of polyisobutylene is shown in Figure 6.6. All three samples, even though chemical compositions are quite different, obey the strain-time correspondence. The elongational and the shear data are in good agreement, equation (6.31).
Figure 6.4 Comparison of viscosities calculated from tensile measurements with dynamic shear viscosities for a sample of SBR 1502. Shear viscosity, ERD; elongation rate, ε˙ . Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
117
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.5 Comparison of viscosities calculated from tensile measurements with dynamic shear viscosities for a sample of SBR 1712. Shear viscosity, ERD; elongation rate, ε˙ . Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
Figure 6.6 Comparison of viscosities calculated from tensile measurements with dynamic shear viscosities for a sample of polyisobutylene. Shear viscosity, eccentric rotating disk (ERD); elongation rate, ε˙ . Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
118
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.7 Comparison of viscosities calculated from tensile measurements with dynamic shear viscosities for a sample of polyethylacrylate. Shear viscosity, ERD; elongation rate, ε˙ . Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
Figure 6.8 Comparison of viscosities calculated from tensile measurements with dynamic shear viscosities for a sample of polyepichlorohydrin. Shear viscosity, ERD elongation rate, ε˙ . Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
119
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Examples of polyethylacrylate and polyepichlorohydrin, are shown in Figures 6.7 and 6.8, respectively. These polymers consist of polar monomeric units. They are very different from diene rubbers and polyisobutylene. The elongational data of these polymers obey the straintime correspondence and form master curves. But the elongational and shear data do not agree:
ηT > 3 |η*|
(6.32)
This behaviour may be attributable to intermolecular polar association, which may be weak at small deformations but becomes significant at large deformations, somewhat analogous to strain-induced crystallisation. With NBR having a high polar content, i.e., above 40% acrylonitrile, a similar observation was made about polar association [22]. One note of caution is the effect of humidity on the viscoelastic properties of rubber containing polar groups [23]. The absorbed moisture may prevent the polar association. This can happen in humid climates or when the gum rubber is not completely dried. This aspect warrants further investigation. Gum rubber is not a crosslinked network, but for some reason if a network is formed, the elongational data are as shown in Figure 6.9.
Figure 6.9 Application of strain-line correspondence principle to the tensile stressstrain data of SBR 1502 crosslinked with 2 phr of sulphur. Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. As Figure 6.1.
120
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber The data at different elongation rates do not obey strain-time correspondence but form different curves, which have an upturn indicating limited extensibility [22]. Some gum rubbers obey strain-time correspondence. Other rubbers do not obey the principle, because of strain-hardening. There is yet another type which does not obey strain-time correspondence, because it exhibits linear behaviour even at rather large deformations. In general this type of rubber is soft, and it may be difficult to obtain accurate elongational data. By using a rotational rheometer operated at very low speeds in order to avoid slip, it is possible to obtain accurate data at large shear strains [24]. For shear stress τ and shear strain γ the shear modulus G is G = τ/γ
(6.33)
Because shear strain rate γ˙ is constant, the time t is t = γ/ γ˙
(6.34)
η = τ/ γ˙ = G t
(6.35)
For linear behaviour, viscosity η is
and at equal values of ω and 1/t
η = |η*|
(6.36)
the viscosity η has an equal value to that of the complex viscosity. For non-linear behaviour which obeys strain-time correspondence, viscosities η and |η*| are equal at equal values of ω and 1/αt. Instead of equation (6.35), viscosity has the form
η= G αt
(6.37)
η = (τ/ γ˙ )α = |η*|
(6.38)
or
The relationship between shear strain and the extension ratio is given as [15]:
γ = α −(1/α)
(6.39)
An example with an ethylene-propylene rubber of Mooney index 40, is shown in Figures 6.10a and 6.10b.
121
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The points in the figures represent η and the lines |η*|. Figure 6.10a shows that the linear form, equation (6.35), holds, and Figure 6.10b shows that the non-linear, strain-time correspondence, equation (6.37), does not hold. On the other hand, an NBR with a Mooney index of 35 and acrylonitrile content of 33% does not obey equation (6.35), see Figure 6.11a, but obeys the non-linear equation (6.37), see Figure 6.11b.
Figure 6.10 (a) Complex viscosity of ethylene-propylene rubber (EPR) at 30 °C. The line represents the observed data and the markings are the data calculated from the stress rise at a constant deformation rate. The calculation is based on linear viscoelasticity. The stress rise measurements at ε = 0.025 s-1 were performed in triplicate. The figure shows agreement between calculated and observed data. (b) The same data as in (a), except that the calculation is based on the non-linear relation, the strain-time correspondence. This figure shows disagreement between calculated and observed data. Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
The rubber exhibiting linear behaviour, Figure 6.10a, tends to go to the flow state where viscous contribution dominates over the elastic contribution. This type of rubber has a relatively low MW and no significant long branching. On the other hand, a rubber exhibiting non-linear behaviour, Figure 6.11b may have a high MW, some long branching, and even a small amount of macrogel. The Mooney values of these two rubbers are very similar, but the viscoelastic behaviour of these rubbers is very different.
122
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.11(a) Complex viscosity of NBR sample BN-2 at 100 °C. The line represents the observed data and the markings are the data calculated from the stress rise at constant deformation rates. Three different rates were used. The calculation is based on linear viscoelasticity. This figure shows disagreement between calculated and observed data. (b) The same data as in (a), except that the calculation is based on the non-linear expression, the strain-time correspondence. This figure shows agreement between calculated and observed data. Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
As stated before, the presence or absence of gel is the first and a most important aspect of gum rubber characterisation. When gel is present, the concept of MW loses practical meaning, because the MW of gel is extremely high and cannot be measured. Nevertheless, when two gum rubbers are compared, the question may arise as to which has the higher MW. In such a case, because the comparison of MWs has no real meaning, the question may be redirected to the level of the viscoelastic properties. The Mooney index is usually used for this comparison. However, this practice may be misleading because in some cases, a higher gel content gives a lower Mooney index [21]. What is needed here is some measure of viscoelastic property, which gives a higher value for a higher gel content. If gel is absent, the same property should give a higher value for a higher MW. For this purpose the dynamic complex viscosity at low frequencies may be used. Figure 6.12 shows gel-free EPM. At low frequencies, samples of a higher weightaverage MW M w have a higher |η*| [25].
123
complex GPC Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.12 Effect of variation in M w on the complex viscosity curves at 230°C: (......) A, 1.13 x 105; (− . −) B, 1.35 x 105; (− −) C, 1.56 x 105; (---) D, 1.70 x 105; ( ) XL-0, 1.16 x 105. Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
When the EPM is milled in presence of a peroxide, long branches and gel are generated. As shown in Table 6.2 the different amounts of peroxide do not give a systematic relationship with GPC data nor with DSV.
Table 6.2. GPC measurements of EPMs with differing amounts of long branchesa Sample Designation XL-0 XL-1 XL-2 XL-3 XL-4
Dicumyl Peroxide (phr) 0.0 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.4
DSVb (104) 5.37 4.96 4.34 4.52 4.53
(105) 1.16 1.04 0.96 1.18 2.37
(105) 2.87 2.31 2.34 4.33 41.57
2.16 2.10 2.22 2.61 5.23
(105) 1.04 0.94 0.86 1.02 1.64
1.45 1.40 1.33 1.38 1.67
a Symbols M n, M w, M z, describe relative hydrodynamic size, i.e., MW averages are not corrected for branching b DSV determined with a concentration of 0.1 g/ml in toluene at 25 °C
M v : viscosity average MW
124
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber Unknown amounts of gel must have been removed by filtration. On the other hand, |η*| values at low frequencies in Figure 6.13 are higher for larger amounts of peroxide, clearly indicating the generation of more long branches and gel.
6.13 Effect of increasing long branching (XL-0 - XL-4) on the complex viscosity master curves at 230 °C: ( ) XL-0; (− −) XL-1; (---) XL-2; (− . −) XL-3; (......) XL-4. Reprinted from N. Nakajima, Polymer International, 1995, 36, 2, 105. Copyright 1995, SCI. Reproduced with permission.
A summary of the viscoelastic characteristics of gum rubber is given below. 1.
Relative but quantitative method for the degree of long branching and gel content. Preparation of log G´´ versus log G´ plot. For a higher degree of long branching and higher gel content the curve is placed to the right. With reference to the line G´´ = G´, the position of the curve shows whether viscous behaviour or elastic behaviour dominates.
2.
Differentiating macrogel and microgel. Perform elongation measurements with different rates of elongation and test the applicability of strain-time correspondence. Those rubbers obeying the principle are either linear molecules, molecules with long branching but gel-free (ASTM D3616-95) [20], those containing microgel, or in some cases containing a small amount (<10%) of macrogel. Those containing macrogel, e.g., more than approximately 10%, tend to give strain-hardening.
125
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Linearisation requires shifts in both time axis by α and modulus axis by Γ(α). The latter represents a relative degree of macrogel content. 3.
Rubbers exhibiting linear viscoelastic behaviour. These have either a low MW, a linear molecule, a few long branches, or all of these. The MW distribution is narrow in the sense that there is no excessive spread towards high MWs. Of course, they are gel-free.
4.
Differentiating macrogel from microgel when the former is less than 10%. Compare the elongational data with the shear data according to the method given earlier equation (6.27), i.e., without applying the modulus shift. In the presence of macrogel, the elongational modulus divided by a factor of three is higher than the shear modulus.
5.
In method 4, there is a case where shear modulus is higher than the elongational modulus (after dividing by three). Examples are triblock copolymers; in small strain shear measurements the physical crosslinks remain intact, but in large strain elongational measurements the crosslinks are destroyed, thus softening the rubber [26].
6.
With rubbers having many polar groups, e.g., polyethylacrylate, polyepichlorohydrin, and NBR with 40% acrylonitrile, elongational modulus (divided by three) is higher than shear modulus even in the absence of macrogel. A molecular association similar to strain-induced crystallisation appears to occur at high elongation.
7.
In the presence of absorbed moisture, the molecular association may not occur.
8.
Complex viscosity at low frequency is a good measure of the ‘MW’ of a rubber regardless of the presence or absence of gel.
6.6 Processability and molecular structure Certain specific samples of gum rubber are said to have a good processability or poor processability. These statements have no real meaning unless the processing conditions are specified. For example, the presence of long branching may improve processability or harm it. Therefore, a generalised relationship does not exist between processability and molecular structure. With a full understanding of this difficulty, a discussion is given here on the subject; however, the relationships given are not without exceptions. During the Second World War, in the early days of the emulsion polymerisation of synthetic rubbers, macrogels were generated which caused difficulty in the milling process. If the
126
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber polymerisation temperature was too high, ‘hot rubber’ was produced. The ‘cold rubber’ process was developed later, producing easy processing rubber. Macrogel is also produced at high conversion; therefore, the degree of conversion (of monomer to polymer) is limited to a certain percentage. Even with ‘gel-free’ rubber according to ASTM D3616-95 [20] gel may be detected by the use of a GPC filter. The implication is that below a certain size, or at less than a certain gel content, the macrogel has no adverse effect on mill processability. In some cases the presence of macrogel is preferred. When a large amount of reinforcing filler must be compounded, the compound tends to become crumbly and breaks into pieces, i.e., ‘dry’. In this case, dispersion of carbon black is not achieved and the compound cannot be formed into a shape. The presence of large amounts of macrogel can overcome this problem. Macrogel-containing rubber may be oil-extended to alleviate the milling problem. Sometimes oil-extended rubber has a superior strength as a vulcanisate compared with the gel-free, non-oil-extended counterpart. Without oil extension, macrogel-containing rubber has a low tensile strength as a vulcanisate compared with gel-free rubber. This is because branch points increase the crosslink density, thereby limiting the elongation to break. When green strength is needed for the mixed compound, long branches and even, to some extent, the presence of gel are appreciated. The green strength is the resistance to drape of the sheet made of the uncrosslinked compound. The presence of long branches and gel generates more free ends in vulcanisates compared with linear molecules. Such free ends increase heat build-up of finished products under repeated stressing. Mill processability also depends upon the additives in the formulation. Oils, plasticisers and even small amounts of powder [27] affect the mill performance. However, the present discussion will be confined to gum rubbers only. The most significant difference is found among different types of rubber; cis-1,4polybutadienes being polymerised in solution, the MW distribution is less spread out at the high MW end compared with emulsion polymerised SBR. For this reason and because of the low Tg, some grades of this rubber may tend to go into Region III of mill processability [28] causing mixing problems. The presence of long branches imparts long relaxation times (see section 6.8) and the mixing problem may be overcome. More discussion of this will be given in section 6.7.1.
127
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Even with emulsion polymerisation, polyethylacrylate rubber tends to go into Region IV of mill processability, i.e., the flow region. This is because the rubber has 73% of its MW as the pendent group. It is a fat and short molecule compared with diene rubber. The presence of some long branches may help mill processability. However, when the tendency for Region IV behaviour is known, upside-down mixing, i.e., charging carbon black first into an internal mixer and then the rubber, is the usual practice. Microgel is a crosslinked latex particle. Rubber containing a large amount of microgel breaks down easily on milling, hence decreasing time and energy of mixing [29]. However, the strength of vulcanisate is somewhat inferior because it gives a lower elongation to break. The microgel-containing compounds tend to give a smoother extrudate. Extrudate swelling is reduced and the degree of swelling is independent of the extrusion rate. The spread of MW distribution towards lower MW has no detrimental effect on processability. The mechanical strength is decreased and the heat build-up is increased in the finished product. Although much knowledge has been systematically accumulated on the linear viscoelastic behaviour of gum rubber, attempts to relate the linear behaviour to processability may result in misleading or even wrong conclusions. Gum rubber processing involves non-linear behaviour and fracture, which may not be predictable from linear behaviour.
6.7 Processability and viscoelastic characteristics 6.7.1 Cis-1,4-polybutadiene Bearing the cost-benefit relationship in mind, an important question is what is the minimum activity required for obtaining sufficient information on the characteristics of a given gum rubber. Section 6.6 showed that at least two types of measurement are required; one is the dynamic mechanical measurements over the temperature and the frequency region covering processing conditions. The other is the tensile stress-strain measurements at room temperature with at least three and preferably four strain rates. In this section examples are presented to show how this characterisation scheme is used to determine structure-processability relationships. The first example uses cis-1,4-BR. A major application of cis-1,4-BR is for tyres. The rubber improves wear resistance, rolling resistance, and flexibility at low temperature. It is usually blended with other rubbers, such as NR or SBR because it does not have a good processability, flex-crack resistance and green strength. Because the rubber has a very low Tg of -112 °C, it tends to fall in Region III or IV of the mill processability. In order to overcome the problems associated with milling, long branching is considered to be one of the variables to manipulate. Questions are how much and how long the long
128
properties Cis-1,4-butadiene
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber branch should be. In addition cis-1,4-BR is known to give a strain-induced crystallisation under favourable conditions. Does the strain-induced crystallisation occur during millmixing and if so, what effect does it have? Another question is the effect of addition of crystalline particles on the mill processability and strain-induced crystallisation. The mechanism of branch formation is discussed in Section 1.1.3. In the free radical polymerisation, the chain-transfer mechanism is responsible and the branched molecule becomes more branched leading to gel-formation. In the metal-coordinated catalyst systems used for cis-1,4-BR polymerisation, branches are formed by insertion of macromers. Once insertion occurs, the probability of another insertion is considerably decreased because of the steric effect. Therefore, no gel is formed. Not only are fewer branches present but also the branch pattern is different from those in the free-radical polymerised rubbers. • Experiment - I [30] • Samples The samples were four commercial polybutadienes produced by Bayer AG, see Table 6.3.
Table 6.3 Properties of cis-1,4-butadiene samplesa Sample
BUNA CB11b
BUNA CB22b
BUNA CB23b
BUNA CB24b
Catalyst
Ti
Nd
Nd
Nd
Cis-1,4-(%)
93
98
98
98
1,2-vinyl (%)
4
1
1
1
Mw x 10-4
51
53
51.5
66.5
12
20.5
15
12
4.3
2.6
3.4
5.5
47
63
51
44
–105
–109
–109
–109
10
5
5
3
c
Mn x 10-4 c Mw/Mn MV
c
d
Tg (°C) Degree of branching (%)e
a: All data supplied by the manufacturer b: Registered Trade mark of Bayer AG c: Data obtained by GPC; MW are not absolute but relative values based on the hydrodynamically equivalent volume of polystyrene standards d: Mooney Index e: Calibrated with star-branched polymers Mw: mass-average MW Mn: number-average MW MV: Mooney Viscosity
129
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The sheets of gum rubbers were prepared by pressing at 140 °C for 10 minutes. After removal from the press, the sheets were cut in quarters, piled in four layers, and pressed again under the same conditions to completely remove bubbles. After the second pressing the sheets were placed between two steel plates at room temperature with heavy weights placed on top. The sheets were allowed to rest at least 2 days under the heavy weights to prevent wrinkling when removed. Oscillatory shear specimens were cut from the sheets as discs 25 mm in diameter and tensile specimens were cut using the dumbbell die C described in ASTM D412 [31]. The gel contents of the sheets were measured by dissolving about 0.4 g of rubber in 100 ml of n-heptane for 48 h. The solution was filtered through a Whatman No. 4 filter paper. The filter paper was weighed before and after filtration to estimate the amount of gel removed from the solution. The filtered solution was evaporated in an oven at 110 °C and the amount of dissolved polymer was measured. No gel was found in these samples. • Instruments The oscillatory shear measurements were performed with a Rheometrics mechanical spectrometer (RMS 800) with parallel plates. The angular frequency range was from 10-2 to 102 rad/s. The samples were tested at 30, 60, 120, and 150 °C. In addition to the calibration specified by the instrument manufacturer, a standard silicone rubber (SE30; General Electric Company) was used every time to double-check the calibration. The frequency sweep was made from the lowest to the highest and then reversed to the lowest frequency. The data at the lowest frequency should be reproducible if there is no degradation during the measurements. Tensile tests were performed with a Monsanto Tensometer 500. The strip chart recorder recorded force against time. The force was measured with a 0.45 kg load cell. The extent of deformation was measured by recording with a video camera. An extensometer was not used because the samples were not strong enough to hold it. The samples were held with plastic grips having relatively loose springs in order to prevent breaking at the grips. The tests were performed at room temperature with strain rates of 0.004, 0.017, 0.057, 0.118, and 0.250 s-1. • Results and discussion • Oscillatory shear measurements Time-temperature superposition was performed in the following sequence: first, tan δ data were plotted against log ω. The superposition involves the log ω axis only, because any modulus-shift in G′ and G′′ cancels out. From this procedure the time-shift factor, aT, was evaluated. Next, log |G*| data were plotted against log ωaT. From these plots 130
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber the modulus-shift factor, βT, was evaluated. The results of superposition are shown in Figures 6.14-6.17, where all the data were reduced to 30 °C.
Figure 6.14 Master curves of storage and loss modulus of Buna CB11 (Reference temperature 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.15 Master curves of storage and loss modulus of Buna CB22 (Reference temperature 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
131
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.16 Master curves of storage and loss modulus of Buna CB23 (Reference temperature 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.17 Master curves of storage and loss modulus of Buna CB24 (Reference temperature 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
132
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber The extent of time-shift was rather small; for the data obtained at 30-120 °C, the frequency range was extended only about one decade to lower frequencies. This is because the glass-transition temperature of cis-1,4-BR is very low, -110 °C. All master curves approach the plateau region at the higher frequencies. The lower frequency region is the transition from the plateau towards terminal region. However, these curves do not show a crossover of G´ and G´´. They are almost parallel to each other. This indicates that all these samples have some branching. In Figure 6.18, G´ curves of four samples are compared.
Figure 6.18 Compression of master curves of storage modulus of various Buna samples. (Reference temperature 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
The curve of CB11 shows a smaller slope and higher G´ than those of the other samples at low frequencies. This indicates that CB11 contains a structure having a longer relaxation time compared, for example, to CB24. This cannot be explained from the differences in MW and its distribution because CB24 has a higher MW and broader MW distribution than CB11, see Table 6.3. Therefore, this must be the effect of more extensive branching in CB11 than in the others. The differences among CB22, CB3, and CB24 are related to their MW distribution, and G´ is higher for the higher M n. This indicates the effect of the low MW fraction on G´. Figure 6.19 shows log G´´ versus log G´ plot for the four samples. The curve of CB11 lies at the right side of those of the others [25].
133
loss
storage
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.19 Comparison of log G´´ versus log G´ curves. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
The values of the shift factors, aT and βT are given in Table 6.4. The aTs are sampledependent and CB11, which has the highest degree of branching, shows the highest temperature dependence. At the lower temperature CB24 shows a lower temperature dependence than CB22 and CB23. However, the differences diminish at the higher temperature. The fact that the differences of aT diminish at the higher temperature indicates that the constraints introduced by the branching become less effective at the higher temperature. The observed βT values, Table 6.4, are comparable to the values of ρ0T0/ρT. No further significant information was obtained from βT. From the results mentioned above, (see Figure 6.19 and Table 6.3), the order of degree of branching is CB11>CB22=CB23>CB24. Figure 6.20 shows the absolute values of complex viscosity |η*| of the samples at 30 °C.
134
Shift factors Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber As observed in many commercial rubbers, these do not show the Newtonian region within the observed time scale because of their high MW, broad MW distribution, and branching. At low frequencies, they show the viscosity enhancement resulting from branching, which is longer than the critical length [25]. The sample of CB11, in spite of having the same Mw as those of CB22 and CB23, shows the highest degree of the viscosity enhancement at low frequencies and viscosity reduction at high frequencies; that is the curve of CB11 crosses over the other curves. This also indicates that CB11 has more extensive branching compared to other samples [25]. For CB22, CB23 and CB24 the magnitude of |η*| is in the order of number average MW, Mn , see Table 6.3.
Table 6.4 Shift Factors, aT and βT Temperature (°C) Sample
30
60
90
120
150
CB11
1
0.368
0.171
0.094
0.052*
CB22
1
0.409
0.202
0.124
0.071*
CB23
1
0.400
0.202
0.111
0.066
CB24
1
0.449
0.215
0.117
0.067*
CB11
1
0.934
0.834
0.794
–
CB22
1
0.910
0.803
0.753
–
CB23
1
0.893
0.844
0.734
CB24
1
0.938
0.828
0.726
ρ0T0/ρT
1
0.910
0.835
0.771
aT
βT
0.660 – 0.716
*Slight degradation was noticed.
• Tensile stress-strain measurements Figures 6.21 and 6.22 show tensile stress-strain curves of CB11 and CB24 at various deformation rates. The filled circles show the data at break. Reproducibility shown in the figures is less than ± 15%. The modulus increases with increasing deformation rates.
135
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.20 Comparison of master curves of complex viscosity of BUNA samples (reference temperature 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.21 Tensile stress-strain curves of BUNA CB11. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
136
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.22 Tensile stress-strain curves of BUNA CB24. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.23 shows the plots of tensile modulus, E(t), against time, t, at various deformation rates for CB24. The data obtained at different deformation rates do not give a master curve, because the behaviour is not linearly viscoelastic [7].
137
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.23 Tensile modulus as a function of time for BUNA CB24. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figures 6.24-6.26 show the plots of tensile modulus, E(αt), against reduced time, αt, as given by Equation 6.27.
Figure 6.24 a) Tensile modulus as a function of reduced time at fixed rates for BUNA CB11. b) Tensile modulus as a function of reduced time at fixed extension ratios for BUNA CB11. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
138
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.25 a) Tensile modulus as a function of reduced time at fixed rates for BUNA CB22. b) Tensile modulus as a function of reduced time at fixed extension ratios for BUNA CB22. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.26 Tensile modulus as a function of reduced time at fixed extension ratios for BUNA CB24. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
139
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing In Figures 6.24 (a) and 6.25 (a) the data are plotted for each strain rate, and in Figures 6.24 (b), 6.25 (b) and 6.26 the lines are for constant values of α. CB11 and CB22 show a systematic relationship with α, while CB24 gives a master curve which is independent of α. With CB11 the deviation is in the direction of strain-softening and for CB22 and CB23 it is strain-hardening. Among CB22, CB23, and CB24 the extent of the strainhardening relates to the amount of branching given in Table 6.3. Even though CB11 has the highest amount of branching, it shows strain-softening behaviour. It should be noted that CB11 is made with a catalyst system different from that used for the other systems, see Table 6.3. Evidently, the branches of the polymer are not long enough to provide the constrained entanglement upon stretching. When the modulus shift [32], Equation 6.28, is applied, master curves are formed for CB11, CB22, and CB23. Figure 6.27 shows the result for CB22.
Figure 6.27 Reduced tensile modulus as a function of reduced time for BUNA CB22. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
With the emulsion-polymerised rubbers, the modulus shift is required only when an extensive amount of macrogel is present [22]. However, there is no gel in the samples referred to in this work. This is the only time when strain hardening was observed for the sample containing no gel. It implies that the long branches in these BRs are very long.
140
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber Figure 6.28 shows the modulus shift, Γ(α), for the samples of CB11, CB22 and CB23 as a function of extension ratio.
Figure 6.28 Modulus shift factor as a function of extension ratio. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
In this figure, no data for CB24 are shown. Although CB24 has long branching, it shows neither strain-hardening nor strain-softening. This indicates that it has the critical length of branching bordering strain-hardening and strain-softening. At this critical branchlength, branches no longer contribute to such behaviour as strain-hardening or strainsoftening. Figures 6.29-6.32 show the comparison between the complex viscosity, |η*|, and the equivalent shear viscosity, ηT calculated from the tensile stress-strain data.
141
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.29 Comparison of complex shear viscosity with corresponding viscosity calculated from tensile data for BUNA CB11. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.30 Comparison of complex shear viscosity with corresponding viscosity calculated from tensile data for BUNA CB22. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
142
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.31 Comparison of complex shear viscosity with corresponding viscosity calculated from tensile data for BUNA CB23. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.32 Comparison of complex shear viscosity with corresponding viscosity calculated from tensile data for BUNA CB24. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
143
Mooney Viscosity
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The calculation of ηT for CB11, CB 22, and CB23 includes the modulus shift. The values of ηT are higher than those of |η*| for CB11 and CB24. These results indicate that the deformational modes are different for shear and extension. The ηT for CB11 and CB24 tends to converge with |η*| at the higher reduced rate, ie., at smaller deformation. With CB22 and CB23, the values of ηT agree with |η*|. The above disagreement between ηT and |η*| indicates strain-induced crystallisation at the larger deformation. The rubber, CB11, was previously shown to give the strain-softening, and CB 24 neither softening nor hardening. The implication is that easily stretchable rubbers crystallise more easily upon straining. At present we do not know why strain-induced crystallisation does not appear as strain-hardening. The results of this work show that the effect of branching and that of strain-induced crystallisation are observable separately, the fact which is an obvious advantage in analysing the behaviour. • Experiment-II [33] • Samples The samples used were four commercial polybutadienes, UBEPOL-VCR, produced by UBE Industries, see Table 6.5.
Table 6.5 Properties of UBEPOL-VCR Polybutadienes Sample
VCR309a
VCR412a
VCR617a
VCR512a
Catalyst
Co
Co
Co
Co
b
45.9
45.1
46.2
44.2
Mn 10-4 b
17.1
18.4
17.6
15.5
2.7
2.5
2.6
2.9
SPB c (wt%)
9
12
17
12
MV d
39
45
63
43
Mw 10-4
Mw/Mn
b
Data supplied by the manufacturer a: Registered trademark of UBE Industries b: Data obtained by GPC; MW are not absolute but relative values based on the hydrodynamically equivalent volume of PS standards. The data represent the matrix polymer only. c: The amount of syndiotactic 1,2-polybutadiene crystalline particles d: Mooney Viscosity
144
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber These rubbers contain crystalline particles of syndiotactic 1,2-polybutadiene in the matrix polymer of cis-1,4-BR. The crystalline particle is composed of block copolymers of cis1,4 butadiene/1,2-vinyl butadiene [34]. It has 80% crystallinity in the 1,2-polybutadiene domain and a melting point of 204 °C. The rubbers of VCR309, VCR412, and VCR617 have different amount of crystalline particles in the same matrix polymer. Although not shown in Table 6.5, VCR512 has a different matrix polymer that is more branched than the matrix polymer of other samples. • Results and discussion • Oscillatory shear measurements The results of time-temperature superposition are shown in Figures 6.33 to 6.36, where all the data were reduced to 30 °C. All curves approach the plateau region at the higher frequencies.
Figure 6.33 Master curves of storage and loss modulus of VCR309 (reference temperature is 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
145
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.34 Master curves of storage and loss modulus of VCR412 (reference temperature is 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.35 Master curves of storage and loss modulus of VCR617 (reference temperature is 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
146
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.36 Master curves of storage and loss modulus of VCR512 (reference temperature is 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
However, these curves do not show the cross over of G´ and G´´. They are almost parallel to each other. This is because of the presence of the crystalline particles and branching in the matrix polymer. Figure 6.37 shows log G´´ versus log G´ plot for all four rubbers. The curves shift to the right with an increasing amount of crystalline particles. This indicates that the rubber becomes more elastic in the presence of the particles. The curve of VCR512 lies at the right side of that of VCR412 because the matrix polymer of the former is more branched than the matrix of the latter. The values of the shift factors, aT and βT are given in Table 6.6. The aTs are sample dependent, and VCR309, which has the least amount of the crystalline particles, shows the highest temperature dependence among the rubber having the same matrix polymer. The rubber with a more branched matrix, VCR512, shows somewhat higher temperature dependence than that of VCR412. However, the differences of aT diminish at the higher temperature. The observed values of βT, see Table 6.6, are comparable to the values of ρ0T0/ρT. The temperature dependence of βT decreases with the increasing particle content, and it almost disappears for VCR 617 between 30 and 90 °C. This may be the result of the difference in the thermal expansion coefficients of the matrix rubber and the crystalline particle.
147
loss
storage
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.37 Comparison of log G´´ versus log G´ curves. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Table 6.6 Shift Factors, aT and βT Temperature (°C) Sample
30
60
90
120
150
VCR309
1
0.360
0.171
0.089
0.052
VCR412
1
0.388
0.186
0.111
0.064
VCR617
1
0.404
0.195
0.102
0.065
VCR512
1
0.325
0.178
0.104
0.067
VCR309
1
0.906
0.830
0.731
0.665
VCR412
1
0.971
0.889
0.839
0.793
VCR617
1
1.000
1.000
0.879
0.855
VCR512
1
0.859
0.849
0.774
0.714
ρ0T0/ρT
1
0.910
0.835
0.771
0.716
aT
βT
148
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.38 Comparison of master curves of complex viscosity VCR412 (reference temperature is 30 °C). Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.38 shows the absolute values of complex viscosity |η*| of the rubber at 30 °C. As observed in many commercial rubbers, these do not show the Newtonian region within the observed time scale because of their high MW, broad MW distribution, branching and the presence of the particles. Among VCR309, VCR412, and VCR617, the value of |η*| is higher for larger amount of the crystalline particles. At low frequencies, viscosity enhancement increases with increasing amount of crystalline particles. This is similar to the effect of the dispersed particles on viscosity. At low frequencies, the viscosity of VCR512 is higher than that of VCR412. As the frequency is increased, the curve of VCR512 crosses over the curve of VCR412. This is the result of VCR512 having more extensive branching than VCR412. • Tensile stress-strain measurements Figures 6.39 and 6.40 show tensile stress-strain curves of VCR412 and VCR617 at various deformation rates.
149
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.39 Tensile stress-strain curves of VCR412. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
The stress σ is the true stress based on the deformed cross-section. Reproducibility shown in the figures is less than ±15%. The modulus increases with increasing deformation rates. It is higher for the higher amount of the crystalline particles. The stress-strain curves of the other samples are similar to those shown in Figures 6.39 and 6.40. Figure 6.41 shows the plots of tensile modulus E(αt) against reduced time αt for VCR412, as given by Equation 6.27.
150
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.40 Tensile stress-strain curves of VCR617. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.41 Tensile modulus as a function of reduced time at fixed extension ratios for VCR412. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
151
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing In this figure, the lines connect the data at a constant value of α. Instead of forming a master curve, the data systematically change with α. The deviation is in the direction of strain-softening. When the modulus shift, Equation 6.29 is applied, and master curves are formed for all rubbers, as in Figure 6.42 for VCR412.
Figure 6.42 Reduced tensile modulus as a function of reduced time for VCR412. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.43 shows the modulus shift Γ(α) as a function of the extension ratio. The degree of the strain-softening increases with the increasing amount of the crystalline particles. As mentioned before, the crystalline particles consists of a block copolymer of cis-1,4-BR and 1,2-BR, the latter providing a crystalline morphology. The cis-1,4 chains presumably cover the surface of the particles, compatibilising the particles with the matrix rubber. A diffused boundary between the particle and the matrix was observed with transmission electron microscopy (TEM) for an ultrathin section [34]. Therefore, the cis-1,4 chains are like branches spreading out of the surface of the particles. When the branches are not long enough to give the entanglement constraints, they facilitated stretching by lubrication. Because the crystalline particles confer strain-softening, the branches on the particles are not long enough to give the entanglement constraints. This
152
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber is also evident since more particles give more strain-softening. Although VCR512 and VCR412 contain the same amount of the crystalline particles, the latter gives more strain softening than the former. The matrix polymer of VCR512 has longer branches than that of VCR412 such that the branching in the former is giving a constrained entanglement. The consequent strain-hardening tendency somewhat offsets the overall degree of the strain-softening from the crystalline particles.
Figure 6.43 Modulus shift factor as a function of extension ratio. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figures 6.44 to 6.47 show comparisons between the complex viscosity |η*| and the equivalent of shear viscosity ηT, calculated from the tensile stress-strain data.
153
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.44 Comparison of shear complex viscosity with corresponding viscosity calculated from tensile data for VCR309. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.45 Comparison of shear complex viscosity with corresponding viscosity calculated from tensile data for VCR412. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
154
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.46 Comparison of shear complex viscosity with corresponding viscosity calculated from tensile data for VCR617. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.47 Comparison of shear complex viscosity with corresponding viscosity calculated from tensile data for VCR512. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. Copyright 1996, reprinted by permission of John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
155
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The calculation of ηT includes the modulus shift. The curve of ηT is higher than the curves of |η*| for all rubbers. This indicates the strain-induced crystallisation of the matrix polymer at the large elongational deformation. The curves of ηT and |η*| for VCR309, VCR412, and VCR512 are almost parallel to each other. The curves for VCR617 are not parallel, and the difference becomes larger toward lower frequencies. This is because higher crystalline-particle content introduces higher strain-induced crystallisation, and the crystallisation is more significant at the large deformation, which corresponds to the lower frequency in this presentation. In Experiment I as well as this study, the strainsoftening was found to facilitate the strain-induced crystallisation. This is contrary to what might be expected from the constraint against elongation, forcing the orientation of the chains, and thus enhancing the crystallisation. The exact mechanism of straininduced crystallisation requires further study. • Experiment-III [35] • Samples The gum rubber samples used are listed in Tables 6.3 and 6.5. They may be classified into three groups: 1.
Titanium-polymerised rubber, CB11, is the most branched. However, the branches are relatively short. The rubber gives strain-softening and strain-induced crystallisation upon stretching [30].
2.
Neodymium-polymerised rubbers, CB22, CB23 and CB24, have low degrees of branching compared to CB11. However, the branches are longer; long enough to give a ‘constrained’ entanglement. It results in strain-hardening when the degree of branching is relatively high, i.e., CB22 and CB23. They do not give straininduced crystallisation. The least branched rubber, CB24, gave neither softening nor hardening [30], but gave strain-induced crystallisation.
3.
Cobalt-polymerised rubbers, VCR309, VCR412, VCR617 and VCR512, contain dispersed crystalline particles of 1,2-polybutadiene [34]. The first three have different amounts of particles in the same matrix rubber. The matrix rubber of VCR512 has more long branches than that of VCR412. The crystalline particles are made up of a block copolymer of cis-1,4 and 1,2-butadiene [34]. The crystalline particles cause strain softening. The extent of strain-softening is lessened in VCR512 because the branching of the matrix is long enough to give the ‘constrained’ entanglement resulting in strain-hardening. All VCRs gave strain-induced crystallisation [33].
156
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber The compounds were made from these rubbers with the addition of 50 phr N330 carbon black from Cabot. • Mixing and milling A Banbury-type internal mixer with a 250 ml capacity was used for mixing the compounds. The fill factor was 0.7 and the rotor speed was 100 rpm. After mastication of the rubber for 1 minute, carbon black was added over a period of 1 minute. After an additional 2 minutes, the compound was dumped. All dumped compounds were crumbly and a small amount of the free filler remained. After dumping, the compounds were immediately milled with a 6-inch two-roll mill in order to develop further mixing and to observe mill processability. Photographs (see Figures 6.48-6.57) of the rubber on the mill were taken after milling for 2 minutes. The speed of the fast roll was 28 rpm and the friction ratio was 1:1.26. • Results When CB11 gum was loaded on the mill, it broke into many pieces, which required recharging. The process was repeated several times until a band was formed. The band was loose and sagging as shown in Figure 6.48(a). After taking the photograph, the band was pushed up against the roll in an attempt to make a tight band. The band sagged again if not pushed up and tore at many places as shown in Figure 6.48(b). The CB11 compound did not make a band and crumbled after passing through mill; therefore, no photograph is shown. With CB22, CB23, and CB24, the gum rubbers formed bands immediately after loading. The bands are as shown in Figures 6.49-6.51. The surface of CB22 had a rough texture, that of CB24 was smooth, and that of CB23 was intermediate. The stickiness was observed with all three, but observed least with CB22, more with CB23, and the most with CB24. When the band was cut and the sheet was pulled, CB22 was the most elastic, giving a large mill-shrinkage. The elasticity decreased in the order from CB22 through CB23 to CB24. The CB22, CB23, and CB24 compounds made smooth bands, which were loose on the mill and sagging somewhat, see Figure 6.52. VCR309, VCR412, and VRC617 made smooth bands immediately after charging as shown in Figures 6.53-6.55. For VCR512, although it did not break into pieces, the band sagged. When it was pushed against the roll, the band was torn, see Figure 6.56, but the tearing was not as extensive as that in the case of CB11. The bands were not sticky; when the sheet was cut and pulled out, there was no appreciable elastic tension. The VCR309, VCR412, VCR617, and VCR512 compounds made tight bands, of which VCR412 and VCR617 had a slight tear, see Figure 6.57.
157
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.48 a) Photograph of CB11 gum rubber on the mill.
Figure 6.48 b) Photograph of CB11 gum rubber on the mill. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
158
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.49 Photograph of CB22 gum rubber on the mill. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.50 Photograph of CB23 gum rubber on the mill. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
159
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.51 Photograph of CB24 gum rubber on the mill. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.52 Photograph of CB22 carbon black-filled compound on the mill. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
160
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.53 Photograph of VCR309 gum rubber on the mill. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.54 Photograph of VCR412 gum rubber on the mill. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
161
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.55 Photograph of VCR617 gum rubber on the mill. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Figure 6.56 Photograph of VCR512 gum rubber on the mill. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
162
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.57 Photograph of VCR412 carbon black-filled compound on the mill. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
• Discussion Although CB11 gum broke into many pieces on charging, it is not likely to be processing in Region I, because the rubber is not stiff, and when the band was eventually formed, it behaved more as in processing Region III. If it had been in Region I, it would have moved to Region II eventually. As shown in Figure 6.58, CB11 gum has a rather high rate-dependence (for other CB rubbers, refer to the original articles [30]). From the principle of time-temperature correspondence, we also expect a relatively high temperature dependence. This was already observed in the dynamic measurements [30], where this rubber had highest values of the temperature shift factor, aT. When the rate decreased, the strain at break decreased significantly, meaning that when the temperature increases, the strain at break also decreases, going into Region III. The high-temperature dependence comes from the high degree of branching. The nature of the difficulties in milling of CB11 gum rubber and its compound are from the same origin. Although CB11 gum rubber gave strain-induced crystallisation in tensile tests, it did not help the processability. When the rubber is in Region III, there is insufficient tension to cause the crystallisation.
163
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.58 Tensile stress-strain curves of CB11 gum rubber. Reprinted from N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. Copyright 1997, reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
The stickiness of gum rubbers CB22, CB23, and CB24, indicates that they were in Region IV on the mill. When the carbon black was added, stickiness was no longer observed. Because the stickiness was the reason for forming the band in Region IV, the compound became loose from the surface of the roll. Also, in Region IV, there is insufficient tension to cause strain-induced crystallisation for CB24, which crystallises in a tensile test. With VCR309, VCR412, VCR617 and VCR512, the gum rubbers were in Region II, bordering toward Region III, exhibiting slight sagging and tearing in some cases but not sticky. Consequently, the compounds made tight bands, but showed slight tearing. VCR512 gum showed a relatively large rate-dependence in the stress-strain measurement compared to those of other VCRs. This is similar to the behaviour of CB11 as compared to the
164
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber other CB rubbers. It implies the higher-temperature dependence as well. This explains the fact that VCR512 tends to move toward Region III as the rubber becomes warmer on the mill. This is seen as a slight sagging and a slight tearing, see Figure 6.56, whereas no sagging or tearing occurred with other VCRs. In contrasting three types of gum rubbers, which are represented by CB11, CB22, and VCR412, a clear-cut differentiation may be made about their mill behaviour. CB11 was in Region III, CB22 type was in Region IV and VCR412 type was in Region II. This ordering is related to the modulus level at the very low frequency region in the dynamic shear measurements [30, 33]. The lowerfrequency region of the data represent the higher temperature behaviour, which is encountered in milling. Evidently, the added crystalline particles are most effective in raising the modulus at the low frequency as shown with VCR rubbers. A degree of branching is more effective than is a relative length of branching with respect to the modulus level, CB11 versus CB22. However, if a sticky band, Region IV, is preferred over a sagging band, Region III, CB22 is said to be easier for milling than is CB11. Among the three neodymium-polymerised rubbers, CB22 had the highest degree of branching, followed by CB23, and CB24 was the least branched. Because branching makes rubber more elastic, it explains the roughest texture and least stickiness of CB22 among the three. CB22 was most elastic when pulled from the mill and showed a large mill shrinkage. The difference in CB23 and CB24 may be explained similarly on the basis of the difference of the degree of branching. Concerning VCR309, VCR412, and VCR617, there was no significant difference in mill behaviour among these gum rubbers and also among their compounds, meaning that, within the present variation in the amount of the crystalline particles, no difference was detected in the milling. In detail, however, a significant number of white spots appeared in the band of VCR617, a little in that of VCR412, and none in that of VCR309, see Figures 6.53-6.55. The white spots gradually disappeared when the sheets were removed from the mill and left to relax. The white spots appear to be the strain-induced crystalline domains. Previously, it was noticed with the matrix rubber [33] that in the presence of the larger amount of the crystalline particles there was an indication of more straininduced crystallisation. Among the samples that we examined, the three rubbers of the VCR series were the only ones, which gave an indication of strain-induced crystallisation in milling. This means that in order for the gum rubber and the compound to have strain-induced crystallisation during milling the material must be under sufficient tension, i.e., Region II. The mill behaviour of the compounds with respect to the four regions of processability was readily explained from the mill behaviour of the matrix rubber. Within the
165
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing structural variables investigated in this study, both gum rubbers and the corresponding compounds were in the same region of mill processability.
6.7.2 Polyethylacrylate The next example is ACM, which has a rather high Tg of –14 °C, but it tends to fall in the Region III or IV of mill processability, because it is a relatively short and fat molecule. This polymer is made via emulsion polymerisation with a free radical initiator. Therefore, the presence of macrogel is one of the concerns. In one of the samples a difunctional co-monomer was used for providing a cure site. It presents a possibility of forming microgels. Effects of these structural variables on the viscoelastic behaviour and processability are examined. It is a common occurrence in industry that two elastomers, overall very similar, behave differently on the mill. Sometimes, they are the same grade of material made for the same specification. Other times they are similar but made with some known difference. In either case it is necessary to relate the observed difference in processability with the difference in the molecular architecture of the polymers. Further, such a molecular difference must be related to the difference in the manufacturing process. This work is an example of such an activity, where the rheological analyses have played key roles. Two commercial ACMs, one having an epoxide (EP) crosslinking site and the other ethylidene norbornene (ENB), were used for this study. The dynamic shear oscillation measurements at very small strain were used to characterise the viscoelastic properties. The tensile stress-strain measurements at several different deformation rates were used to characterise the large deformation behaviour. These data were systematically analysed to explain the difference in mill processability. They were also used to pin-point major differences in long branching and gel structure, which impart a dominant influence on rheology and hence, processability. The gel determination was made by filtration in order to support the rheological findings. The dilute solution techniques were not used, because such results would only pertain to the soluble fraction of the polymer. • Experimental • Samples The samples were two commercial ACMs having a Mooney index of about 50 [14]. The carbon black used for the mill processability was a standard N330 [37]; 50 parts per 100 parts of rubber by weight was used.
166
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber The sheets of gum elastomers were prepared in a picture frame between two polished stainless steel plates. The pressing was done at 160 °C for 20 minutes. A mould release agent was used. The sheets were cooled in the press. After removing from the press, the sheets were placed between two steel plates with 10.5 kg weight placed on top. The sheets were allowed to rest for 3 days under the weight to prevent wrinkling. Tensile specimens were cut from the sheets using ASTM D412 dumbbell die C [31]. The gel content of each sample was determined by dissolving about 0.4 g of material in 100 ml of methyl ethyl ketone, and stirring on a magnetic stirrer for 24 hours. The solution was filtered through a Whatman No. 4 filter paper. The filtered paper was weighed before and after filtering to determine the amount of gel removed from the solution. The filtered solution was evaporated and the amount of dissolved polymer was determined. The gel contents before and after pressing are given in Table 6.7.
Table 6.7 Samples and Gel Content Sample
Before pressing (% Gel)
EP ENB
After pressing (% Gel)
9.4
15.9
71.4
66.6
• Instruments • Viscoelastic measurement The viscoelastic properties were measured with a Rheometrics mechanical spectrometer in the oscillation mode. The frequency range was from 10-2 to 102 rad/s. Samples were tested at 25, 60, 100 and 150 °C. • Tensile stress-strain measurement Tensile tests were performed on a Monsanto Tensometer 500. The practical upper limit of crosshead speed was 0.847 cm/s and the lower limit was 0.0359 cm/s. The speed was calibrated by measuring with a stopwatch the time required for the crosshead to travel a set distance measured with a measuring tape. This was double checked by measuring the time required to elongate the specimen an additional 100% as measured by the strip chart recorder. A Monsanto extensometer designed for use with the Tensometer 500 was
167
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing used to record the strain directly as a percentage. The strip chart recorder was equipped with an area compensator so that all stress data were recorded as force per unit original cross-sectional area of the sample. The force was measured by a 45 kg load cell. The samples were held by roller grips. The tensile test was performed at 25 °C and ambient humidity conditions using strain rates of 0.177, 0.0872, 0.0441 and 0.00775 s-1. These strain rates encompass the practical operating conditions of the tester. • Mill processability A Stewart-Bolling laboratory mill of 152 mm diameter and 305 mm width, was used to evaluate the mill processability. The speed of the fast roll was 29 rpm and the friction ratio was 1:1.25. The mill rolls were cooled by circulating city water. • Results Figure 6.59 is the comparison of viscoelastic properties of the two polymers at 25 °C. Both storage modulus, G′ and loss modulus, G′′ are very similar for the two samples, except at the higher frequency the moduli of the ENB polymer are lower than those of the EP polymer. From this limited data no significant information on the molecular structure can be extracted.
Figure 6.59 Storage and loss modulus of EP and ENB ACM at 25 °C. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, R. A. Miller and E. R. Harrell, International Polymer Processing, 1987, 2, 2, 87. Copyright 1987, Hanser Publishers.
Figures 6.60 and 6.61 are G´ and G´´ curves which are extended to lower frequencies with the aid of the temperature reduction scheme [6] using the data obtained at 60, 100 and 150 °C. At the reduced frequency, lower than 10-3 rad/s, there are significant differences in the behaviour of two samples. The G´ and G´´ curves of the EP polymer
168
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber begins to turn downward and assume a slope higher than those of the ENB polymer. This indicates that there are differences in the size and amount of the largest species contained in the samples. Here, the term, species, is used instead of MW in order to include gels. Another important difference is that the G´ and G´´ curves of the EP polymer cross over, G´ becoming lower than G´´ at ω<10-5 rad/s. However, with the ENB polymer the G´ is above G´´ and the two curves are almost parallel to each other. This behaviour indicates that the ENB polymer contains much more gel than the EP polymer. The gel-content data in Table 6.7 support this finding. Figure 6.62 shows log G´´ versus log G´ plots of the EP and ENB polymers. The curve of the ENB polymer lies at the right side of that of EP polymer; this indicates that ENB polymer contains more gel than the EP polymer.
Figure 6.60 Storage and loss modulus as functions of angular frequency. EP ACM data reduced to 25 °C. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, R. A. Miller and E. R. Harrell, International Polymer Processing, 1987, 2, 2, 87. Copyright 1987, Hanser Publishers.
Figure 6.61 Storage and loss modulus as functions of angular frequency. ENB ACM data reduced to 25 °C. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, R. A. Miller and E. R. Harrell, International Polymer Processing, 1987, 2, 2, 87. Copyright 1987, Hanser Publishers.
169
loss Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
Figure 6.62 Modified Cole-Cole plots of EP and ENB ACM. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, R. A. Miller and E. R. Harrell, International Polymer Processing, 1987, 2, 2, 87. Copyright 1987, Hanser Publishers.
The tensile stress-strain data obtained at the previously mentioned four deformation rates have been converted to viscosity as a function of (1/αt). The data are presented in Figures 6.63 and 6.64, as (ηT/3). The data points do not fall on one curve for the EP polymer, except for the shorter time range, at the right hand side of the figure. The deviations are systematic in that a higher deformation rate gives a higher viscosity. The difference appears to increase for the longer time, at the left hand side of the figure. With the ENB polymer the data points fall on one curve, although some deviation of points similar to that of the EP polymer occurs. It can be concluded that the straintime correspondence principle applies approximately to this sample. From the preceding argument, the gel particles in the ENB polymer must be microgels. On the other hand the EP polymer appears to contain long branching and macrogel.
170
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.63 Viscosity evaluated from tensile stress-strain measurements; no formation of master curve, showing inapplicability of strain-time correspondence principle, EP ACM. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, R. A. Miller and E. R. Harrell, International Polymer Processing, 1987, 2, 2, 87. Copyright 1987, Hanser Publishers.
Figure 6.64 Viscosity evaluated from tensile stress-strain measurements; formation of master curve through application of strain-time correspondence principle, ENB ACM. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, R. A. Miller and E. R. Harrell, International Polymer Processing, 1987, 2, 2, 87. Copyright 1987, Hanser Publishers.
171
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing In Figure 6.65 the data of Figure 6.63 and 6.64 are plotted as modulus-reduced time (1/αt) curves. The data had been interpolated at fixed extension ratios of α = 2, 4, and 6. With the EP polymer the modulus data do not fall on one curve so that the strain-time correspondence does not apply. The modulus tends to be higher at the higher extension ratio, indicating strain-hardening. Therefore, the EP sample contains long branching and macrogel. On the other hand with the ENB polymer the modulus is independent of the extension ratio and a function of reduced time only. This means that the gel contained in this polymer is microgel.
Figure 6.65 Modulus at equal strain observed at different deformation rates plotted as function of reduced time; strain hardening for EP sample (above) and no strain hardening for ENB sample (below). Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, R. A. Miller and E. R. Harrell, International Polymer Processing, 1987, 2, 2, 87. Copyright 1987, Hanser Publishers.
• Discussion • Mill processability and viscoelastic properties Figure 6.66 (left and right) are photographs, illustrating the major differences in processability.
172
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.66 Banding characteristics of EP (right) and EMB (left) polyethacrylate at 150 °C. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, R. A. Miller and E. R. Harrell, International Polymer Processing, 1987, 2, 2, 87. Copyright 1987, Hanser Publishers.
Figure 6.67 Complex viscosity-angular frequency curves of EP and ENB at 150 °C. Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima, R. A. Miller and E. R. Harrell, International Polymer Processing, 1987, 2, 2, 87. Copyright 1987, Hanser Publishers.
173
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Whereas, the ENB polymer formed a smooth band around the roll and presented no problem in incorporating carbon black, the EP polymer became sticky and partially transferred into the backroll. There is a clear difference in the mill processability [28]. The ENB polymer exhibited Region II behaviour, which was a highly extensible, elastic state and best suited for mill processing. On the other hand the EP polymer was in Region IV, which was a flow state like a plastic melt. The relative difference in the behaviour may be understood by comparing the data of Figures 6.60 and 6.61 at the lower end of the frequency. Also, the same data at 150 °C are reproduced as the complex viscosity, |η*| as a function of ω, see Figure 6.67. At the lower frequency the viscosity of the EP polymer is lower than that of the ENB polymer. It should be remembered that polyethylacrylate polymer has 73% of its MW in the pendent, ester group [36]. Therefore, it is a relatively short chain for a given MW, with a larger cross-section compared to diene-rubbers, for example. This makes the polymer readily go to the molten state, when the temperature increases. The presence of microgel is known to introduce long relaxation times [38] such that the above undesirable tendency may be overcome. These results of the mill processability depend upon the temperature and the deformation rate; a higher rate corresponds to a lower temperature. Since our mill does not have a precise temperature control, the first batch starts at a lower temperature. The mill-mixing was conducted on different days; one day ENB was milled first and then EP. On another day it was in the reverse order. Although the EP polymer became sticky in both cases, it was less sticky when started with a colder mill. • Mechanisms of gel formation An inherent tendency for the polyethylacrylate to form long branching and gel has already been discussed in Section 1.1.6. In addition, the data of Table 6.7 show that the EP polymer crosslinked during pressing at 160 °C for 20 minutes. The gel content increased from 9.4 to 15.9%. This must have contributed to the strain-hardening tendency shown in Figure 6.65. In the polymerisation of the ENB polymer, ENB is copolymerised to give a crosslinkable site. Since ENB is a difunctional monomer, it is hoped that only one functional group is incorporated into polymer chain. However, there must be a finite probability that the second functional group also becomes incorporated in the chain. This reaction leads to the microgel formation. • Temperature dependence of viscoelastic property The temperature shift factors found in shifting the observed curves of G´ and G´´ are given in Table 6.8. For the accuracy of superposition, the curves of G´ and G´´ are shifted together. The time shift factor, aT and modulus shift factor, βT are both based on 25 °C, T0 = 298 K. The WLF constants [6], C1 and C2 are also given in Table 6.8:
174
properties Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
-log aT =
(
C1 T − T0 C2
+
)
(6.40)
(T − T0 )
As far as the time-shift factor, aT, is concerned, the EP polymer has a higher temperaturedependence, compared to the ENB polymer. This difference is apparent in the C2 values, C1 values being approximately equal. This result is similar to the temperature dependence of branched EPDM and linear EPM elastomers [39], where the branched elastomer had a higher temperature-dependence.
Table 6.8 Temperature Dependence of Viscoelastic Properties Sample
Temperature °C
aT
βT
C1
C2
EP
25 60 100 150
1.0 1.7 x 10-2 6.2 x 10-4 6.3 x 10-5
1.0 0.86 0.82 0.82
10.0
160
ENB
25 60 100 150
1.0 3.2 x 10-2 1.2 x 10-3 1.4 x 10-4
1.0 0.92 0.85 0.83
11.4
227
However, the present case is more complicated because the EP sample contains macrogel and the ENB sample contains microgel. Therefore, we cannot readily draw an analogy to the result of the previous study. The modulus shift, βT, is relatively small and subject to a proportionally large error. However, the shift is required for the superposition. This is in contrast to previous work with EPM and EPDM elastomers where such a shift was not required. The value of βT decreases with increasing temperature; the extent of decrease is similar to what is expected from the theory, ρ0T0/ρT. However, this subject is not pursued any further, since it is somewhat outside the scope of the present study.
6.8 Linear viscoelasticity The linear viscoelasticity is a well established science and textbooks are available for understanding theories and practices. Therefore, no review of the subject will be made here. However, it is appropriate to make comments on the importance of linear
175
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing viscoelasticity where (i) it has direct revelance to mixing of rubber and (ii) it provides background for understanding rubber behaviour during mixing.
6.8.1 Linear viscoelasticity and mixing of rubber As has been explained, mixing of rubber involves large deformation and fracture. In the former, non-linear viscoelasticity plays the key role. However, in limited cases linear viscoelastic behaviour also plays a key role. For example, the magnitude of shear storage modulus G′ at the lower frequencies is related to the mill-processability in determining the initial reaction of rubber when it touches the mill-roll. That is, the flow state, rubbery state or rubber-glass transition defined by linear viscoelastic measurements at small deformation provides the practical information. After touching the mill-roll whether or not the rubber stretches and makes a tight band depends upon the non-linear viscoelastic property and fracture characteristics. An exception to this is that some rubber exhibits linear viscoelastic behaviour at a large deformation. Such rubber apparently retains the same internal structure (the arrangement of chains) even after stretching. Otherwise, modulus would change with strain, i.e., nonlinear behaviour. The exact mechanism of how the linear behaviour is maintained in the large deformation is not known and is the subject of future research. Another importance of linear viscoelasticity is that it provides a reference for non-linear behaviour; that is, the latter is expressed as a deviation from the former with use of appropriate parameters. First is the universal parameter, the elongation ratio, α, which reduces the time-scale of nonlinear behaviour to that of linear behaviour. Next is the modulus shift factor, Γ(α), which indicates the degree of strain-hardening or strainsoftening. Finally, comparison of linearised elongation data with that of shear data indicates, if they disagree, the presence of strain-induced crystallisation or strain-induced association. All these deviations from linearity are related to the structure of rubber. Thus far, a considerable variety of gum rubbers have been investigated and the characterisation scheme defined in this book is satisfactory. However, the applicability of the scheme is limited to the behaviour where strain-dependence and time-dependence are separable.
6.8.2 Relaxation time and its distribution In order to relate viscoelasticity to processability, it helps to understand the concept of relaxation time. The definition of relaxation time customarily uses a spring and dashpot
176
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber for illustration. However, a definition is given here without using the spring and dashpot model. Starting with a situation, where a stimulus is given to a system to excite it, the extent of the excitation is expressed by C*. If the system is allowed to return to the ground state spontaneously, the rate -dC*/dt is proportional to the extent of excitation, C*. −dC*dt = kC*
(6.41)
The integration of this equation gives a well-known equation, C* = C0*e−kt
(6.42)
where C0* is the value of C* at t = 0. This equation is for the first order reaction in chemical kinetics. It is also the equation for the decay of radioisotopes in physics. In viscoelasticity k = 1/λ
(6.43)
where λ is the relaxation time. In the field of viscoelasticity there is ‘retardation time’ and relaxation time. Qualitatively these terms may be understood by analogy to human behaviour. Suppose the reader has played tennis with his friend at lunch break and just returned to his work. After changing his clothes, he immediately resumes his work. His friend keeps talking about tennis and cannot go back to work. Which one of them has a longer relaxation time is obvious. On a fine day at the weekend a reader invites his friend for a hike. He is ready to go but his friend is taking a long time in preparing for the hike. Which one of them has the longer retardation time is obvious. In science, relaxation time and retardation time are quantitatively defined. In the viscoelasticity of polymers, the relaxation time is in general not a constant but it has a broad distribution. The retardation time also has a broad distribution. In linear viscoelasticity the distribution of relaxation time is shown in a stress relaxation experiment. The distribution of retardation time is shown by a creep experiment.
177
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing The distribution of relaxation time and that of retardation time are quantitatively related. Also, the result from any linear viscoelastic experiment is quantitatively related to distribution of relaxation or retardation time. Therefore, from the result of one type of linear viscoelastic measurement, the data of any other type of measurement can be calculated, provided the data are available for a wide range of time scales. For example, dynamic shear storage modulus, G′(ω) and dynamic shear loss modulus, G′′(ω), may be calculated from relaxation modulus, G(t). The method of calculation is described in textbooks [6] and outside of scope of this book. The importance here is to recognise that the distribution of the relaxation time is related to every data of linear viscoelasticity. Accordingly, ‘response time’ or ‘material time’ is used to include both relaxation time and retardation time. Also, relaxation time is used somewhat loosely to represent both relaxation and retardation time for explaining observed phenomena. For discussing processability, it includes nonlinear viscoelasticity and the use of relaxation time tends not to be rigorous in the quantitative sense. In the foregoing discussion the relaxation time is used in a relative sense invoking only long or short relaxation times. In equation (6.41) for the chemical reaction, C* is the concentration of the reactant. In radioisotope chemistry, the identity of the isotope is known. On the other hand in viscoelasticity, a material exhibiting certain relaxation time is often not clearly identified. Considering of the distribution of relaxation time, what is the counterpart of the distribution in material? Although much of this relationship is the subject of current and future studies, a general statement may be made as follows: for linear polymer chains, the size of the molecule and the relaxation time are directly related. However, the relaxation time of a given polymer chain is not only dependent on its size but also on its environment. For monodispersed polymers, when the MW is smaller than the entanglement coupling distance, Me, and when it is larger than Me, the environmental effect is completely different. For the latter case the environmental effect is called entanglement. For a molecule larger than Me, a local motion of a chain segment, which is smaller than Me, is also present. For a given polymer molecule, its motion may be divided into relatively fast motions of the segments which are smaller than Me and relatively slower motions of the whole chain, which is larger than Me. This interpretation may be expanded to include polymers having MW distribution. Considering the whole polymer there must be a relationship between the longest relaxation time (terminal relaxation time) and its MW. An example is the relationship between low shear Newtonian viscosity, η0, and MW. With commercial gum rubbers, η0 is observed only with low MW polymer or a polymer whose MW distribution lacks the high MW tail. Nevertheless, η0 will be considered for a moment.
178
Molecular weight Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber The presence of long branches is very common in gum rubbers and the branch pattern varies widely. For simplicity, a ‘star-branched’ polymer will be taken as an example. The reader should be aware that this type of model polymer does not represent all other types of branched polymers. Nevertheless, some common features of the branched polymers may be extracted by examining these model polymers. Figure 6.68 presents plots of η0 against weight average MW, M w for linear, 3 arm-star and 4 arm-star polymers [40].
Figure 6.68 Relationship between Newtonian viscosity and MW. : Linear molecule : Tribranched molecule : Tetrabranched molecule Reprinted from G. Kraus and J. T. Gruver, Journal of Polymer Science, 1965, A3, 1, 105. Copyright 1965, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
179
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing They are BRs prepared through anionic polymerisation. Compared at a fixed MW, the branched polymer has a lower η0 below certain MW and a higher η0 above certain MW. The relaxation time apparently depends upon not only the size of molecule but also its shape, which is branching in this case. Compared at the same size, the branching makes relaxation time shorter below certain branch length and longer above this branch length. The critical branch length is 3 to 4 times of Me [41, 42, 43, 44]. Above this crossover MW, the long branch enhanced viscosity. With a branched polymer exhibiting viscosity enhancement, the extent of the enhancement decreases with increasing shear rate, eventually crossing over the viscosity curve of the linear polymer. That is, at the high shear rate the viscosity is reduced by the presence of long branches. The commercial gum rubbers have branch patterns quite different from the model star polymers. However, often branching is present in the high MW fraction so that the viscosity enhancement at the low shear rates and viscosity reduction at the high shear rates are common observations. This crossover behaviour is also observable in the frequency dependence of the dynamic viscosity, see Figure 6.13 [32]. The long relaxation times introduced by the long branches of commercial gum rubbers have significant influence, even though the amount of the branched fraction may be very small. In the characterisation using dilute solution methods sometimes the branched fraction is filtered off. Then, the interpretation of the processability becomes very difficult. The presence of gel molecules may be interpreted as a part of the size distribution. The effect of gel is to introduce a very long relaxation time. It exhibits viscosity enhancement at the low shear rate and viscosity reduction at the high shear rate. This occurs with both macrogel and microgel. The details of this mechanism are subjects for future study. When a polymer blend has island-and-sea morphology, the deformation of the island has a very long relaxation time. The viscosity enhancement was observed at the low shear rate [45].
6.8.3 Linear viscoelasticity as a conceptual background for the mixing of rubber Different deformational measurements are used to obtain linear viscoelastic data. It may be in simple shear or in elongation. However, the behaviour of rubber during
180
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber mixing is neither simple shear nor elongation. Also, in the laboratory measurements, conditions are imposed to be a constant temperature, a constant rate of deformation, a constant frequency, a constant strain or a constant stress over a period of time. Neither one of these conditions are met by the behaviour of rubber during mixing. Then, what is the use of these idealised measurements? There are two important answers to satisfy the question: one is that the information obtained for a given gum rubber with the above measurements are all related and that from the result of one type of measurement, the result of any other type of measurement, can be calculated. The implication is that if one type of measurement is made then everything about a given gum rubber is known with respect to its linear viscoelastic behaviour. The information is, of course, limited to the range of time scale and the range of temperature of observation. The other importance is the additivity of the memory. That is, using shear stress relaxation as an example, the cumulative memory of stresses imposed at different times may be calculated with a theory of Boltzmann’s superposition principle. The implication of these two statements is profound. When the separability of time and strain holds for a given gum rubber, subsequent linearisation of the data enables one to describe the behaviour of a gum rubber under any situation, at least in principle. This means that with the understanding of linear viscoelasticity plus the parameters for linearisation, there is adequate information for diagnosing processing problems.
6.8.4 Viscoelasticity and memory The concept of memory is well accepted today. Memory tapes, memory discs and other memory storage devices are an integral part of our society. However, they are usually either electromagnetic or optical devices. Actually material possesses the ability to retain memories of various kinds; it is also capable of losing memory. In the field of viscoelasticity, the memory appears as a change of shape. If a body is elastic but non-viscous, the memory is retained while a stress is imposed; upon removal of the stress, the memory recovers by 100% and the shape returns to the original. Then, the memory of the deformation is completely gone. With a viscoelastic body, it is not as simple. When a constant stress is imposed, the deformation is not instant but increases with time; this phenomenon is called creep. When the stress is removed, the memory does not recover instantly. It does not necessarily return to the original shape. When a constant strain is imposed, the stress decreases with time. This is called stress relaxation. The manner of the relaxing stress is a manifestation of the memory loss.
181
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing Creep and stress relaxation are model experiments. The stress-strain relations in polymer processing are much more complex. However, the memory phenomena are observed frequently. A typical example is the extrudate swell [46]. In the mixing of rubber it appears as the mill-shrinkage. When the rubber is sheeted out of the mill roll, the thickness increases, and the width and the length decrease. The extent of the change depends upon the material and therefore, the mill-shrinkage has been used as a measure of the material characteristics. When the manner of the memory-loss in the stress-relaxation is considered, there are memories lost in a short time and those retained for a long time. The former memory arises from short relaxation times and the latter from the long relaxation times. The polymer has a distribution of relaxation times and the memory phenomenon is their manifestation. The relaxation time, λ, is expressed as the ratio of viscosity, η, and elastic (shear) modulus, G,
λ = η/G
(6.44)
When a system has a single relaxation time, this relationship is easy to understand. When there is a distribution of relaxation times, the meaning of η and G, is not very simple. Therefore, instead of separating the relaxation time into η and G, the relaxation time itself will be used to describe material behaviour. In the rubber processing neither stress nor strain remains constant over time. Therefore, creep or stress relaxation is not an appropriate model. On the other hand a very complicated stress-strain history is difficult to interpret. A simpler model which offers some insight into processability may be found in transient behaviour. One example is a stress-growth under a constant rate of deformation and observation of stress relaxation. To be realistic, the strain must be large and the behaviour must be in nonlinear viscoelasticity. The experiments may be carried out with a rotational rheometer but they are restricted to low rates of deformation, because otherwise rubber slips at the rheometer interface [47, 48]. Figure 6.69 shows examples of stress history. Curve 3 is the stress relaxation from the ‘instantaneous’ deformation, which retains 100% memory at t = 0 and exhibits the memory-loss thereafter.
182
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
Figure 6.69 Schematic illustration of types of experiments: 1) steady state 2) stress-rise 3) stress relaxation after instantaneous deformation 4) stress relaxation after the cessation of flow 5) stress relaxation after constant rate of deformation Reprinted from N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Journal of Rheology, 1983, 27, 3, 241. Copyright 1983, The Society of Rheology. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Curve 2 shows stress-growth with low rates of deformation, during which a part of memory is lost. If the deformation is stopped and the strain is held constant, the relaxation shown by curve 5 is observed. When the deformation is carried to the steady state condition, the stress becomes constant, Curve 1. It means that stress is proportional to strain rate and no longer increases with deformation. Curve 4 is the relaxation from the steady state. It is a manifestation of the steady state memory and its dissipation with time. When the relaxation curves, 3, 4 and 5, are expressed as relaxation modulus-time curves, see Figure 6.70, larger differences are observed in the shorter times, but for the longer times the curves merge. This means that the memory associated with short relaxation times is lost during the imposition of deformation but the memory associated with long relaxation times is retained. Understanding the meaning of the experiment helps interpretation of memory phenomena in processing.
183
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
·
Figure 6.70 Relaxation modulus after constant rate of deformation ( ) compared with that after instantaneous deformation (upper curve) and that after cessation of flow (lower curve) for BN-1 sample. Rate of deformation = 0.049-0.050 s-1 and strain = 0.405 (O), 0.785 ( ) and 1.205 ( ). Reprinted with permission from N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Journal of Rheology, 1983, 27, 3, 241. Copyright 1983, The Society of Rheology. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
One drawback of the previous experiment is the slow rate of deformation. In order to match the deformation rate to that in processing, a capillary rheometer may be used. A memory introduced in the deformation at the capillary entrance corresponds to curve 2. Once a material is in the capillary the behaviour is like curve 1, except that some relaxation takes place during the flow through capillary. The recovery of memory appears as the extrudate swell, which is not stress relaxation but like a creep recovery. Because some relaxation takes place during the flow, the recovery depends upon the residence time in capillary which is proportioned to the L/D of the capillary. The higher shear rate results in a shorter residence time in capillary. Therefore less memory is lost and the extrudate swell is higher. Experiments described in this section concern transient behaviour. Although they are model experiments, they are a closer simulation to the deformational behaviour of gum rubber during mixing than the use of steady state viscosity. The analyses of the transient behaviour with uses of relaxation times, and the interpretation of the memory are a useful way for diagnosing mixing behaviour.
184
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber
References 1.
I. M. Ward, Mechanical Properties of Solid Polymers, 2nd Edition, WileyInterscience, New York, 1983.
2.
R. S. Rivlin, in Rheology, Vol. 1, Ed., F. R. Eirich, Academic Press, New York, 1956, Chapter 10.
3.
M. Mooney, Journal of Applied Physics, 1940, 11, 582.
4.
K. C. Valanis and R. F. Landel, Journal of Applied Physics, 1967, 38, 2997.
5.
R. W. Ogden, P. Chadwick and E. W. Hadden, Quarterly Journal of Mechanics and Applied Mathematics, 1973, 26, 23.
6.
J. D. Ferry, Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers, 3rd Edition, Wiley, New York, 1980.
7.
T. L. Smith, Transactions of the Society of Rheology, 1962, 6, 61.
8.
R. A. Schapery, Polymer Engineering Science, 1969, 9, 4, 295.
9.
B. Bernstein and A. Shokooh, Journal of Rheology, 1980, 24, 189.
10. N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1980, 53, 1, 14. 11. N. Nakajima, J. J. Scobbo, Jr., and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1987, 60, 742. 12. N. Nakajima, Journal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics, 1983, 12, 349. 13. P. A. Small, Advances in Polymer Science, 1975, 18, 1. 14. ASTM D 1646-96a Standard Test Methods for Rubber - Viscosity, Stress Relaxation, and PreVulcanisation Characteristics (Mooney Viscometer). 15. N. Nakajima and E. A. Collins, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1974, 47, 2, 333. 16. M. Mooney and W. E. Wolstenholme, Journal of Applied Physics, 1954, 25, 1098. 17. N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1979, 52, 1, 9.
185
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing 18. K. Ninomiya, S. Kusamizu, E. Maekawa and G. Yasuda, Progress in Polymer Science in Japan, Vol. 1, Eds., M. Imoto and S. Onogi, Kodansha, Tokyo, 1971, p.377. 19. N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, in Current Topics in Polymer Science, Vol. II, Eds., R. M. Ottenbrite, L. A. Utracki and S. Inoue, Hanser Publications, New York, 1987, p.150. 20. ASTM D 3616-95. Standard Test Method for Rubber, Raw - Determination of Gel, Swelling Index, and Dilute Solution Viscosity. 21. N. Nakajima, E. R. Harrell, P. R. Kumler, D. A. Seil and A. H. Jorgensen, Advances in Polymer Technology, 1984, 4, 3/4, 267. 22. N. Nakajima, C. D. Huang, J. J. Scobbo, Jr., and W. J. Shieh, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1989, 62, 2, 343. 23. N. Nakajima, D. Erbe, A. Maeda and H. Yamazaki, Rubber World, 1991, 205, 2, 33. 24. N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1983, 56, 5, 1019. 25. E. R. Harrell and N. Nakajima, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1984, 29, 3, 995. 26. N. Nakajima, M. H. Chu and R. Babrowicz, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1990, 63, 4, 624. 27. N. Nakajima, W. J. Shieh and Z. G. Wang, International Polymer Processing, 1991, 6, 4, 290. 28. N. Tokita and J. L. White, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1966, 10, 7, 1011. 29. W. H. Whittington and M. E. Woods, Presented at the 100th Meeting of the ACS Rubber Division, Cleveland, OH, Fall 1971, Paper No.38. 30. N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 61, 9, 1525. 31. ASTM D412-98a Standard Test Methods for Vulcanised Rubber and Thermoplastic Rubbers and Thermoplastic Elastomers - Tension
186
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Gum Rubber 32. N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1980, 53, 1, 14. 33. N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1996, 62, 13, 2329. 34. M. Takayanagi, Presented at the 19th Annual Meeting of the International Institute of Synthetic Rubber Producers, Inc., Hong Kong, 1978, Paper No.21 35. N. Nakajima and Y. Yamaguchi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1997, 65, 10, 1995. 36. R. D. DeMarco, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1979, 52, 1, 173. 37. Encyclopedia of Composite Materials and Compounds, Ed., M. Grayson, Wiley, New York, 1983. 38. N. Nakajima and E. A. Collins, Journal of Rheology, 1978, 22, 5, 547. 39. N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Journal of Rheology, 1982, 26, 5, 427. 40. G. Kraus and J. T. Gruver, Journal of Polymer Science, 1965, A3, 105. 41. V. R. Raju, G. G. Smith, G. Marin, J. R. Knox and W. W. Graessley, Journal of Polymer Science: Polymer Physics, 1979, 17, 7, 1183. 42. W. E. Rochefort, G. G. Smith, H. Rachapudy, V. R. Raju and W. W. Graessley, Journal of Polymer Science: Polymer Physics, 1979, 17, 7, 1197. 43. H. Rachapudy, G. G. Smith, V. R. Raju and W. W. Graessley, Journal of Polymer Science: Polymer Physics, 1979, 17, 7, 1211. 44. V. R. Raju, H. Rachapudy and W. W. Graessley, Journal of Polymer Science: Polymer Physics, 1979, 17, 7, 1223. 45. N. Nakajima and P. S. L. Wong, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1965, 9, 9, 3141. 46. N. Nakajima, Journal of the Rheology Society, Japan, 1990, 18, 5. 47. N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Journal of Rheology, 1983, 27, 3, 241. 48. N. Nakajima and E. R. Harrell, Journal of Rheology, 1986, 30, 2, 383.
187
Science and Practice of Rubber Mixing
188
7
Viscoelastic Characterisation of Rubber Compounds
7.1 Introduction The viscoelasticity of a compound is intimately related to its processability in the postmixing operation such as extrusion and injection moulding. In this chapter, however, viscoelasticity is used to characterise the end-product of mixing. One area of importance is to relate the viscoelastic properties to the composition of the compounds. Because the rubber formulation usually contains many additives, only the additives which have a significant influence on mixing and on viscoelastic properties of the compound are discussed. This narrows down the material variables