Science of Microscopy
Science of Microscopy Edited by
Peter W. Hawkes John C.H. Spence
Volume I
Peter W. Hawkes C...
382 downloads
3011 Views
54MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Science of Microscopy
Science of Microscopy Edited by
Peter W. Hawkes John C.H. Spence
Volume I
Peter W. Hawkes CEMES CNRS Toulouse France
John C.H. Spence Department of Physics Arizona State University Tempe, AZ and Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory Berkeley, CA USA
Library of Congress Control Number: 2005927385 ISBN 10: 0-387-25296-7 ISBN 13: 978-0387-25296-4 Printed on acid-free paper. © 2007 Springer Science+Business Media, LLC All rights reserved. This work may not be translated or copied in whole or in part without the written permission of the publisher (Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, 233 Spring Street, New York, NY 10013, USA), except for brief excerpts in connection with reviews or scholarly analysis. Use in connection with any form of information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed is forbidden. The use in this publication of trade names, trademarks, service marks, and similar terms, even if they are not identified as such, is not to be taken as an expression of opinion as to whether or not they are subject to proprietary rights. 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 (corrected printing, 2008) springer.com
Preface
In these two volumes, we have asked many of the leaders in the field of modern microscopy to summarize the latest approaches to the imaging of atoms or molecular structures, and, more especially, the way in which this aids our understanding of atomic processes and interactions in the organic and inorganic worlds. Man’s curiosity to examine the nanoworld is as at least as old as the Greeks. Aristophanes, in a fourth-century bc play, refers to a burning glass; the Roman rhetorician Seneca describes hollow spheres of glass filled with water being used as magnifiers, while Marco Polo in the thirteenth century remarks on the Chinese habit of wearing spectacles. Throughout this time it would have been common knowledge that a drop of water over a particle on glass will provide a magnified image, while a droplet within a small hole does even better as a biconvex lens. By the sixteenth century magnifying glasses were common in Europe, but it was Anthony van Leeuwenhoek (1632–1723) who first succeeded in grinding lenses accurately enough to produce a better image with his single-lens instrument than with the primitive compound microscopes then available. His 112 papers, published in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, brought the microworld to the general scientific community for the first time, covering everything from sperm to the internal structure of the flea. Robert Hooke (1635–1703) developed the compound microscope, publishing his results in careful drawings of what he saw in his Micrographia (1665). The copy of this book in the University of Bristol library shows remarkable sketches of faceted crystallites, below which he has drawn piles of cannon balls, whose faces make corresponding angles. This strongly suggests that Hooke believed that matter consists of atoms and had made this discovery long before its official rediscovery by the first modern chemists, notably Dalton in 1803. (Greeks such as Leucippus (450 bc) had long before convinced themselves that a stone, cut repeatedly, would eventually lead to “a smallest fragment” or fundamental particle; Democritus once said that “nothing exists except atoms and empty space. All else is opinion” (!)) This atomic hypothesis itself has a fascinating history, and is intimately connected with the history of microscopy. It was Brown’s observation in 1827 of the motion of pollen in water by optical microv
vi
Preface
scopy which laid the basis for the modern theory of matter based on atoms. As late as 1900 many chemists and physicists did not believe in atoms, despite the many independent estimates that could be made of their size. These were summarized by Kelvin and Tait in an appendix to their Treatise on Natural Philosophy, together with an erroneous and rather superficial estimate of the age of the earth, to be used against Darwin. (This text was the standard English language physics text of the late nineteenth century, despite its failure to cover much of Maxwell’s work.) Einstein’s 1905 theory of Brownian motion, and Perrin’s (1909) more accurate repetition of Brown’s experiment, using microscope observations to estimate Avogadro’s number, finally settled the matter regarding the existence of atoms. Einstein does not reference Brown’s paper, but indicates that he had been told about it. But as Archie Howie has commented, it is interesting to speculate how different the history of science would be if Maxwell had read the Brown paper and applied his early statistical mechanics to it. By the time of Perrin’s paper, Bohr, Thomson, Rutherford and others were well committed to atomic and even subatomic physics. In biology, the optical microscope remained an indispensable tool from van Leeuwenhoek’s time with many incremental improvements, able to identify bacteria and their role in disease, but not viruses, which were first seen with the transmission electron microscope (TEM) in 1938. With Zernike’s phase contrast theory in the thirties a major step forward was taken, but the really dramatic and spectacular modern advances had to await the widespread use of the TEM, the invention of the laser and the CCD detector, the introduction of the scanning mode, computer control and data acquisition, and the production of fluorescent proteins. The importance of this early history should not be underestimated— in the words of Feynman “If in some cataclysm, all scientific knowledge were to be destroyed and only one sentence passed on to the next generation of creatures, what statement would contain the most information in the fewest words? I believe it is the atomic hypothesis— that all things are made of atoms.” Images of individual atoms were first provided by Muller’s field-ion microscope in the early 1950s, soon to be followed by Albert Crewe’s Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope (STEM) images of heavy atoms on thin-film surfaces in 1970. With its subångström resolution, the modern transmission electron microscopes (TEM) can now routinely image atomic columns in thin crystals. For favorable surface structures, the scanning tunneling microscope has provided us with images of individual surface atoms since its invention in 1982, and resulted in a rich spin-off of related techniques. Probes of condensed and biological matter must possess a long lifetime if they are to be used as free-particle beams. For the most part this has limited investigators to the use of light, X-rays, neutrons and electrons. The major techniques can then often be classified as imaging, diffraction, and spectroscopy. These may be used in both the transmission and reflection geometries, giving bulk and surface information respectively. Chapter 8 (Bauer) reviews both the low-energy electron
Preface
microscope (LEEM) and spin-polarized LEEM methods which, using reflected electrons, have recently revolutionized surface science and thin-film magnetism. Here the high cross-section allows movies to made of surface processes at submicrometer resolution, while Auger electron spectroscopy is conveniently incorporated. Chapter 9 (Feng and Scholl) deals with the closely related photoelectron microscopy, where a LEEM instrument is used to image the photoelectrons excited by a synchrotron beam. Here the superb energy selectivity of optical excitation can be used to great advantage. Chapter 3 (Reichelt) describes advances in scanning electron microscope (SEM) research, where the lower-energy secondary electrons provide images with large depth of focus for the most versatile of all electron-optical instruments. The numerous modes of operation include X-ray analysis, cathodoluminescence, low-voltage modes for insulators and the controlled-atmosphere environmental SEM (ESEM). Turning now to the transmission geometry, we review the latest work in atomic-resolution TEM in Chapter 1 (Kirkland, Chang and Hutchison), the technique which has transformed our understanding of defect processes in the bulk of solids such as oxides, and the STEM mode in Chapter 2 (Nellist). STEM provides an additional powerful analytical capability, which, like the STM, can provide spectroscopy with atomic-scale spatial resolution. An entire chapter (Chapter 4, Botton) is then devoted to analytical TEM (AEM), with a detailed analysis of the physics and performance of its two main detectors, for characteristic X-ray emission and energy-loss spectroscopy. The remarkable recent achievements of in-situ TEM are surveyed in Chapter 6 (Ross), including transmission imaging of liquid cell electrolysis, observations of the earliest stages of crystal and nanotube growth, phase transitions and catalysts, superconductors, magnetic and ferroelectric domains and plastic deformation in thin films, all at nanometer resolution or better. Again, the large scattering cross-section of electron probes provides plenty of signal even from individual atoms, so that movies can be made. Chapter 5 (King, Armstrong, Bostanjoglo and Reed) summarizes the dramatic recent revival of time-resolved electron microscope imaging, which uses laser-pulses to excite processes in a sample. The excited state may then be imaged by passing the delayed pulse to the photocathode of the TEM in this “pumpprobe” mode. Single-shot transmission electron diffraction patterns have now been obtained using electron pulses as short as a picosecond. Most of these techniques are undergoing a quiet revolution as electronoptical aberration corrector devices are being fitted to microscopes. The dramatic discovery, that, after 60 years of effort, aberration correction is now a reality, was made about ten years ago, and we review the relevant electron-optical theoretical background in Chapter 10 (Hawkes). Finally, in biology, potentially the largest scientific payoff of all is occurring in the field of cryo-electron microscopy, where single-particle images of macromolecules embedded in thin films of ice are imaged, and a three-dimensional reconstruction is made. While the structure of the ribosome and purple membrane protein (among many others) have already been determined in this way, the grand challenge of locating every protein and molecular machine in a single cell remains
vii
viii
Preface
to be completed. We summarize this exciting field in Chapter 7 (Plitzko and Baumeister). Electrons, with the largest cross-section and a source brighter than current generation synchrotrons, provide the strongest signal and hence the best resolution. They do this in a manner that can conveniently be combined with spectroscopy, and we now have aberrationcorrected lenses for them. But multiple scattering and inelastic background scattering often complicate interpretation. X-ray imaging of nanostructures, even at synchrotrons, involves much longer data acquisition times but the absence of background and multiple scattering effects greatly improves quantification of data, and thicker samples can be examined. (It is easy to show that the small magnitude of the fine-structure constant will almost certainly never permit imaging of individual atoms using X-rays. We should also recall that in protein crystallography, about 98% of the X-ray beam hits the beam-stop and does not interact with the sample. Of the remaining 2%, 84% is annihilated in production of photoelectrons, and 8% in Compton scattering, while only the remainder produces Bragg diffraction. For light elements the inelastic cross-section for kilovolt electrons is about three times the elastic.) Success with X-rays has thus come mainly through the use of crystallographic redundancy to reduce radiation damage in protein crystallography. However, soft X-ray imaging with zoneplate lenses provides about 30 nm resolution in the “water window” with the advantages of thick samples and an aqueous environment. Applications have also been found in environmental science, materials science and magnetic materials. In addition, the equivalent of the STEM has been developed for soft X-rays: the scanning transmission x-ray microscope (STXM), which uses a zone-plate to focus X-rays onto a sample that can be translated by piezo motors. This arrangement can then provide spatially-resolved X-ray absorption spectroscopy. This work is reviewed in Chapter 13 (Howells, Jacobsen and Warwick). Both X-ray and electron-beam imaging methods are limited in biology by the radiation damage they create, unlike microscopy with visible light, which also allows observations in the natural state. Optical microscopy is undergoing a revolution, with the development of super-resolution, two-photon, fluorescent labeling and scanning confocal methods. These methods are reviewed in Chapters 11 and 12. Chapter 11 (Diaspro, Schneider, Bianchini, Caorsi, Mazza, Pesce, Testa, Vicidomini, and Usai) discusses two-photon confocal microscopy, in which the spot-scanning mode is adopted, and a symmetrical lens beyond the sample collects light predominantly from the excitation region, thereby eliminating most of the “out-of-focus” background produced in the normal full-field “optical sectioning” mode. Threedimensional image reconstruction is then possible. Two-photon microscopy combines this with a fluorescence process in which two low-energy incident photons are required to excite a detectable photon emitted at the sum of their energies. This has several advantages, by reducing radiation damage and background, and allowing observation of thicker samples. The method can also be used to initiate photochemical reactions for study. Chapter 12 (Hell and Schönle) describes the
Preface
latest super-resolution schemes for optical microscopy, which have now brought the lateral resolution to about 28 nm and, by the symmetrical lens arrangement (4-π confocal), increased resolution measured along the optic axis by a factor of up to seven. The lateral resolution can be improved by modulating the illumination field or by using the stimulated emission depletion microscopy mode (STED), in which saturated excitation of a fluorophor produces nonlinear effects allowing the diffraction barrier to resolution to be broken. For the scanning near-field probes new possibilities arise. Although restricted to the surface (the site of most chemical activity) and requiring in some cases complex image interpretation, damage is reduced, while the subångström resolution normal to the surface is unparalleled. The method is also conveniently combined with spectroscopy. Early work was challenged by problems of reproducibility and tip artifacts, but Chapters 14–17 in this book show the truly remarkable recent progress in surface science, materials science and biology. Chapter 14 (Nikiforov and Bonnell) describes the various modes of atomic force microscopy which can be used to extract atomic-scale information from the surfaces of modern materials, including oxides and semiconductors. Work-functions can be mapped out (a Kelvin probe with good spatial resolution) and a variety of useful signals obtained by modulation spectroscopy methods. In this way maps of magnetic force, local dopant density, resistivity, contact potential and topography may be obtained. Chapter 15 (Sutter) describes applications of the scanning tunneling microscope (STM) in materials science, including inelastic tunneling, surface structure analysis in surface science, the information on electronic structure which may be extracted, atomic manipulation, quantum size and subsurface effects, and high temperature imaging. Weierstall, in Chapter 16, reviews STM research at low temperatures, including a thorough analysis of instrumental design considerations and applications. These include measurements of local density-of-states oscillations, energy dispersion measurements, electron confinement, lifetime measurements, the Stark and Kondo effects, atomic manipulation, local inelastic tunneling spectroscopy, photon emission, superconductivity and spinpolarized tunneling microscopy. Finally, in Chapter 16, Amrein reviews the special problems that arise when the atomic force microscope (AFM) is applied to the imaging of biomolecules; much practical information on instrumentation and sample preparation is provided, and many striking examples of cell and macromolecule images are shown. We include two chapters on unconventional “lensless” imaging methods—Chapter 18 (Dunin-Borkowski, Kasama, McCartney and Smith) deals with electron holography and Chapter 19 with diffractive imaging. Gabor’s original 1948 proposal for holography was intended to improve the resolution of electron microscopes, and only recently have his plans been realized. Meanwhile, electron holography using Möllenstedt’s biprism and the Lorentz mode has proved an extremely powerful method of imaging the magnetic and electrostatic fields within matter. Dramatic examples have included TEM movies of superconducting vortices as temperature and applied fields are varied, and ferroelectric and magnetic domain images, all within thin selfsupporting films. Chapter 19 (Spence) describes the recent develop-
ix
x
Preface
A projection from a three-dimensional image of a carbon nanotube with gold clusters attached. This was reconstructed by taking a series of projected STEMADF images at different tilt angles. A faceted gold cluster is shown in the inset. Electron tomography makes it possible to study the three-dimensional nanotube–metal contact geometry which determines the electrical contact resistance to the nanotubes (courtesy of J. Cha, M. Weyland, and D. Muller, 2006).
ment of new iterative solutions to the non-crystallographic phase problem, which now allows diffraction-limited images to be reconstructed from the far-field scattered intensity distribution. This has produced lensless atomic-resolution images of carbon nanotubes (reconstructed from electron microdiffraction patterns) and phase contrast images from both neutron and soft X-ray Fraunhofer diffraction patterns of isolated, non-periodic objects. In this work, lenses are replaced by computers, so that images may now be formed with any radiation for which no lens exists, free of aberrations. Our volumes end with a chapter by van Aert, den Dekker, van Dyck and van den Bos on the definition of resolution in all its forms. Coverage has been limited to high-resolution methods, with the result that some important new microscopies have been omitted (such as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), projection X-ray tomography, acoustic imaging etc.). Field-ion microscopy and near-field optical microscopy are also absent. Conversely, although there is no chapter on tomography in materials science, we must mention the rapid progress of these techniques, which has culminated in a remarkable nearatomic reconstruction by J. Cha, M. Weyland and D. Muller of a carbon nanotube to which gold clusters are attached (see figure). For further information on this branch of tomography, see Midgley and Weyland (2003), Midgley (2005), Weyland et al. (2006) and Kawase et al. (2007). The ingenuity and creativity of the microscopy community as recorded in these pages are remarkable, as is the spectacular nature of the images presented. Neither shows any signs of abating. As in the past, we fully expect major advances in science to continue to result from breakthroughs in the development of new microscopies. Peter W. Hawkes John C.H. Spence
Preface
References Kawase, N., Kato, M., Nishioka, H. and Jinnai, H. (2007). Transmission electron microtomography without the “missing wedge” for quantitative structural analysis. Ultramicroscopy 107, 8–15. Midgley, P.A. (2005). Tomography using the transmission electron microscope. In Handbook of Microscopy for Nanotechnology (Yao, N. and Wang, Z.L., Eds) 601–627 (Kluwer, Boston). Midgley, P.A. and Weyland, M. (2003). 3D electron microscopy in the physical sciences: the development of Z-contrast and EFTEM tomography. Ultramicroscopy 96, 413–431. Weyland, M., Yates, T.J.V., Dunin-Borkowski, R.E., Laffont, L. and Midgley, P.A. (2006). Nanoscale analysis of three-dimensional structures by electron tomography. Scripta Mater. 55, 29–33.
Note on the second printing Barely a year has passed since we wrote the above Preface but very considerable progress has been made in many forms of microscopy. These are indicated in the additional comments and references at the ends of the chapters. One technique that was not accorded a chapter in the first printing has come of age in 2007. This is scanning ion microscopy. Although attempts to use ions in a scanning instrument go back to the 1960s (e.g., Drummond and Long, 1967; Martin, 1973), it is only very recently that technical progress has resulted in a highresolution commercial instrument (the ORION helium ion microscope released by Carl Zeiss in 2007). The secret of this advance lies in the atomic-level ion source (ALIS): the tip is precisely shaped with either an atomic triad or a single atom at its apex and operates at liquidnitrogen temperature. A resolution of 0.7 nm with 45 keV helium ions has been obtained with a prototype; the quoted energy spread is only 0.3 eV and the brightness is of the order of 109 A/cm2 sr. The current is, however, very low, in the femtoampère or picoampère range and thus considerably less than that in a STEM. Earlier scanning ion microscopes used liquid-metal ion sources and their resolution rarely exceeded 10 nm. For the background to this development, see Ishitani and Tsuboi (1997), Sakai et al. (1999), Ishitani and Ohya (2003) and Maclaren et al. (2003) and for recent progress, Ward et al. (2006), Griffin and Joy (2007) and Joy et al. (2007).
References Drummond, I.W. and Long, J.V.P. (1967). Scanning ion microscopy and ion beam machining. Nature 215, 950–952. Griffin, B.J. and Joy, D.C. (2007). Imaging with the He scanning ion microscope and with low-voltage SEM – a comparison using carbon nanotube, platinum thin film, cleaved molybdenum disulphide samples and metal standards. Acta Microscopica 16, Suppl. 2, 3–4.
xi
xii
Preface Ishitani, T. and Ohya, K. (2003). Comparison in spatial spreads of secondary electron information between scanning ion and scanning electron microscopy. Scanning 25, 201–205. Ishitani, T. and Tsuboi, H. (1997). Objective comparison of scanning ion and scanning electron microscope images. Scanning 19, 489–497. Joy, D.C., Griffin, B.J., Notte, J. and Fenner, C. (2007). Device metrology with high-performance scanning ion beams. Proc. SPIE 6518, to be published. Maclaren, D.A., Holst, B., Riley, D.J. and Allison, W. (2003). Focusing elements and design considerations for a scanning helium microscope (SheM). Surface Rev. Lett. 10, 249–255. Martin, F.W. (1973). Is a scanning ion microscope feasible? Science 179, 173– 175. Sakai, Y., Yamada, T., Suzuki, T. and Ichinokawa, T. (1999). Contrast mechanisms of secondary electron images in scanning electron and ion microscopy. Appl. Surface Sci. 144, 96–100. Ward, B.W., Notte, A. and Economou, N.P. (2006). Helium ion microscope: a new tool for nanoscale microscopy and metrology. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B24, 2871–2874. PWH and JCES
Contents
VOLUME I PART I IMAGING WITH ELECTRONS 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy Angus I. Kirkland, Shery L.-Y. Chang and John L. Hutchison 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy Peter D. Nellist
1 3 65
3 Scanning Electron Microscopy Rudolf Reichelt
133
4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Gianluigi Botton
273
5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy Wayne E. King, Michael R. Armstrong, Oleg Bostanjoglo, and Bryan W. Reed
406
6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Frances M. Ross
445
7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET) Juergen M. Plitzko and Wolfgang Baumeister
535
8 LEEM and SPLEEM Ernst Bauer
605
9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM) Jun Feng and Andreas Scholl
657
10 Aberration Correction Peter W. Hawkes Index
696 I1 xiii
xiv
Contents
VOLUME II PART II IMAGING WITH PHOTONS
749
11 Two-Photon Excitation Fluorescence Microscopy Alberto Diaspro, Marc Schneider, Paolo Bianchini, Valentina Caorsi, Davide Mazza, Mattia Pesce, Ilaria Testa, Giuseppe Vicidomini, and Cesare Usai
751
12 Nanoscale Resolution in Far-Field Fluorescence Microscopy Stefan W. Hell and Andreas Schönle
790
13 Principles and Applications of Zone Plate X-Ray Microscopes Malcolm Howells, Christopher Jacobsen, and Tony Warwick
835
PART III NEAR-FIELD SCANNING PROBES
927
14 Scanning Probe Microscopy in Materials Science Maxim P. Nikiforov and Dawn A. Bonnell
929
15 Scanning Tunneling Microscopy in Surface Science Peter Sutter
969
16 Atomic Force Microscopy in the Life Sciences Matthias Amrein
1025
17 Low-Temperature Scanning Tunneling Microscopy Uwe Weierstall
1070
PART IV HOLOGRAPHIC AND LENSLESS MODES
1139
18 Electron Holography Rafal E. Dunin-Borkowski, Takeshi Kasama, Martha R. McCartney, and David J. Smith
1141
19 Diffractive (Lensless) Imaging John C.H. Spence
1196
20 The Notion of Resolution S. Van Aert, Arnold J. den Dekker, D. Van Dyck, and A. Van den Bos
1228
Index
I1
Contributors
Matthias Amrein Microscopy and Imaging Facility, Faculty of Medicine, Department of Cell Biology and Anatomy, University of Calgary, Calgary, Canada Michael R. Armstrong University of California Chemistry and Materials Science Directorate, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA, USA Ernst Bauer Department of Physics, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, USA Wolfgang Baumeister Max Planck Institute of Biochemistry, Martinsried, Germany Paolo Bianchini Department of Physics, LAMBS-IFOM MicroScoBIO Research Centre, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy Dawn A. Bonnell Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Nano-Bio Interface Center, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA Oleg Bostanjoglo Optisches Institut, Sekr. P1-1, Technische Universität Berlin, Berlin, Germany Gianluigi Botton Department of Materials Science and Engineering, McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada Valentina Caorsi Department of Physics, LAMBS-IFOM MicroScoBIO Research Centre, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy xv
xvi
Contributors
Shery L.-Y. Chang Department of Materials, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK Arnold J. den Dekker Delft Centre for Systems and Control, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands Alberto Diaspro Department of Physics, LAMBS-IFOM MicroScoBIO Research Centre, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy Rafal E. Dunin-Borkowski Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK; also at Centre for Electron Nanoscopy, Technical University of Denmark, Kongens Lyngby, Denmark Jun Feng Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, USA Peter W. Hawkes CEMES-CNRS, Toulouse, France Stefan W. Hell Department for NanoBiophotonics, Max Planck Insitute of Biophysical Chemistry, Göttingen, Germany Malcolm Howells Advanced Light Source, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA, USA John L. Hutchison Department of Materials, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK Christopher Jacobsen Department of Physics and Astronomy, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, NY, USA Takeshi Kasama Frontier Research System, Institute of Physical and Chemical Research, Hatoyama, Japan, and Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK Wayne King Chemistry and Materials Science Directorate, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA, USA Angus I. Kirkland Department of Materials, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
Contributors
Davide Mazza Department of Physics, LAMBS-IFOM MicroScoBIO Research Centre, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy Martha R. McCartney Department of Physics and Astronomy and Center for Solid-State Science, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, USA Peter D. Nellist Department of Physics, Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland; Department of Materials, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK Maxim P. Nikiforov Nano-Bio Interface Center, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA Mattia Pesce Department of Physics, LAMBS-IFOM MicroScoBIO Research Centre, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy Juergen Plitzko Max Planck Institute of Biochemistry, Martinsried, Germany Bryan W. Reed Chemistry and Materials Science Directorate, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA, USA Rudolf Reichelt Institut für Medizinische Physik und Biophysik, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität, Münster, Germany Frances M. Ross IBM Research Division T. J. Watson Research Center, Yorktown Heights, NY, USA Marc Schneider Biopharmaceutics and Pharmaceutical Technology, Campus Saarbrücken, Germany Andreas Scholl Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, USA Andreas Schönle Department of NanoBiophotonics, Max Planck Institute of Biophysical Chemistry, Göttingen, Germany
xvii
xviii
Contributors
David J. Smith Department of Physics and Astronomy and Center for Solid-State Science, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, USA John C.H. Spence Department of Physics, Arizona State University Tempe, AZ, and Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, USA Peter Sutter Center for Functional Nanomaterials, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, NY, USA Ilaria Testa Department of Physics, LAMBS-IFOM MicroScoBIO Research Centre, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy Cesare Usai National Research Council Institute of Biophysics, Genoa, Italy Sandra Van Aert University of Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium A. Van den Bos Faculty of Applied Sciences, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands D. Van Dyck University of Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium Giuseppe Vicidomini Department of Physics, LAMBS-IFOM MicroScoBIO Research Centre, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy Tony Warwick Advanced Light Source, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, USA Uwe Weierstall Department of Physics, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, USA
1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy Angus I. Kirkland, Shery L.-Y. Chang and John L. Hutchison
1 Introduction and Historical Context 1.1 Introduction High-Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy (HRTEM) uses a self-supporting thin sample (typically tens of nanometes) illuminated by a highly collimated kilovolt electron beam. A series of magnetic electron lenses image the electron wavefield across the exit face of the sample onto a detector at high magnification. HRTEM has evolved from initial instrumentation constructed by Knoll and Ruska (1932a–c) to its current state where individual atom columns in a wide range of materials can be routinely imaged (Smith, 1997; Krakow et al., 1984) using sophisticated computer-controlled microscopes (Figure 1–1). For this reason HRTEM now occupies a central place in many characterization laboratories worldwide and has made a substantial contribution to key areas of materials science, physics, and chemistry [for key examples showing its wide ranging influence see the frontispiece in the book by Spence (2002)]. Instrument development for HRTEM also supports a substantial commercial industry of manufacturers (Hall, 1966; Hawkes, 1985; Fujita, 1986).1 Numerous HRTEM studies of bulk semiconductors (Smith and Lu, 1991; Smith et al., 1989), defects (Figure 1–2) (Olsen and Spence, 1981), and interface structures (Figure 1–3), (Bourret et al., 1988; Gutekunst et al., 1994) in these materials, of metals and alloys (Penisson et al., 1988; Krakow, 1990; Ishida et al., 1983; Amelinckx et al., 1993; Thomas, 1962), and of ceramics, particularly oxides (Lundberg et al., 1989; Buseck et al., 1989), have been reported in a vast literature spanning four
1
We note that HRTEM has also made substantial contributions to structural biology (see, Burge, 1973; Unwin and Henderson, 1975; Henderson, 1995; Koehler, 1973, 1978, 1986 for reviews of selected representative examples from this field; see also Chapter 7 by Plitzko and Baumeister in this volume). However, due to limitations of space we will not consider this aspect further. 3
4
A.I. Kirkland et al. Figure 1–1. A modern 200-kV HRTEM fitted with a (a) field emission gun, (b) probe and (c) image forming aberration correctors, and (d) an omega geometry energy filter.
Figure 1–2. HRTEM image of a [110] oriented CVD deposited diamond film showing twins, stacking faults, and nanograins. Note the local disorder at the intersection of the stacking faults and twins.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy Figure 1–3. (a) HRTEM image of a lattice matched heterojunction between InP and (Ga, In)As. At the defocus used and for this particular foil thickness differences in scattering between these two isostructural materials allows them to be distinguished. (b) HRTEM image of a heterojunction between InAs and (In, As)Sb that have a significant lattice mismatch. In this case the lattice misfit is accommodated as a regular array of Lomer dislocations marked.
decades (for additional general reviews see Buseck et al., 1989; Smith, 1997; van Tendeloo, 1998; Spence, 1999). An excellent collection of representative HRTEM images can be found in Shindo and Hiraga (1998). More recently HRTEM has become an essential tool in the characterization and discovery of nanoscale materials (Figure 1–4) (see, for example, Iijima, 1991; Yao and Wang, 2005). Of crucial importance in all of these areas is the ability of HRTEM to provide real-space images of the atomic configuration at localized structural irregularities and defects in materials, that are inaccessible to broad-beam bulk diffraction methods and that largely control their properties. Advances in instrumentation for HRTEM over the same timescale have enabled this information to be recorded with increasing resolution and precision leading to improvements in the quantification of the data obtained.
5
6
A.I. Kirkland et al.
Figure 1–4. HRTEM image of a nanocrystalline gold particle supported on a {111} cerium oxide surface. The gold particle shows an almost perfect cubeoctahedral morphology and both particle and substrate are in an epitaxial [110] orientation despite the large lattice mismatch.
This chapter concentrates on HRTEM at atomic resolution. Following a brief historical overview of the development of HRTEM (for a more detailed article outlining key events in the history of electron microscopy see Haguenau et al., 2003) we begin by outlining some of the theory pertinent to image formation at high resolution and the effects on recorded images of the aberrations introduced by imperfect objective optics. We also provide various definitions of resolution. The second section surveys the key instrumental components affecting HRTEM and provides an outline of currently available solutions. The final section describes computational approaches to both the recovery of the specimen exit-plane wavefunction (coherent detection) from a series of images and methods available for HRTEM image simulation. 1.2 Historical Summary Historically, the resolving power of the electron microscope rapidly matched and then exceeded that of the optical microscope in 1934 (Ruska, 1934). However, further improvements in resolution proved relatively slow due to the need to identify and overcome various instrumental limitations (see later). The first subnanometer lattice-fringe images were obtained in the 1950s (Menter, 1956) from phthalocyanine crystals and this was later extended to lattice images of metal foils showing crossed fringe patterns (Komoda, 1966). Concurrently, the first published HRTEM images of complex transition metal oxides provided preliminary evidence that many of these (specifically those of Mo, W, Ti, and V) were not perfect structures (Allpress et al., 1969; see also Buseck et al., 1989, for a review). These observations of planar faults in oxides possibly represent the first occa-
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
sion in which useful information at the atomic level was provided by HRTEM. This work created much interest among solid-state chemists, who for the first time saw a new scientific tool that would enable them to overcome the barriers to structural determinations of these materials imposed by their large unit cells and often extensive disorder. It also immediately provided an explanation for nonstoichiometry in these materials and entirely changed the way in which thermodynamic properties of oxides were modeled. The work summarized above was possible with the typical instrumental resolutions available in most laboratories at that time. However, it was not until this improved that it became possible to resolve individual cation columns in these and certain other classes of material. In the 1970s the first images showing the component octahedra were published (Cowley and Iijima, 1972) with a resolution of 0.3 nm for a series of mixed Ti–Nb structures that demonstrated a direct correspondence between the lattice image and the projected crystal structure. The typical spatial resolution (slightly better than ca. 0.5 nm) provided by most commercial instruments in the 1960s and 1970s was largely limited by mechanical and electrical instabilities. Subsequent improvements in instrument design and construction led to a generation of microscopes becoming available in the mid 1970s with point resolutions of less than 0.3 nm operating at intermediate voltages around 200 kV (Uyeda et al., 1972). Toward the end of this period the dedicated 600 kV Cambridge HREM (Cosslett et al., 1979) and several other high-voltage instruments also became operational (Hirabayashi et al., 1982), providing a resolution somewhat better than 0.2 nm. The following two decades saw further significant improvements in microscope design with dedicated high-resolution instruments being produced by several manufacturers. One outcome of these developments was the installation of commercial high-voltage HRTEMs (operating at ca. 1 MV) in several laboratories worldwide (Gronsky and Thomas, 1983; Matsui et al., 1991). These machines were capable of point resolutions of ca. 0.12 nm, significantly higher than that available in intermediate voltage instruments. Concurrently, commercial instrument development also started to concentrate on improved intermediate voltage instrumentation (at up to 400 kV) (Hutchison et al., 1986) with interpretable resolutions between 0.2 and 0.15 nm. In the 1990s further progress was made in improving resolution through a combination of key instrumental and theoretical developments. For the former the successful design and construction of improved high-voltage instrumentation (Phillip et al., 1994; Allen and Dorignac, 1998) demonstrated interpretable resolutions close to the long sought after goal of 0.1 nm. Perhaps more significantly, field emission sources became widely available on intermediate voltage microscopes (Honda et al., 1994; Otten and Coene, 1993) improving the absolute information limits of these machines to values close to the point resolutions achievable at high voltage. This new generation of instruments also led to renewed theoretical and computational efforts aimed at reconstructing the complex specimen exit wavefunction using either electron holograms (Lichte, 1991;
7
8
A.I. Kirkland et al.
Orchowski et al., 1995) or extended focal or tilt series of HRTEM images (see later). These latter “indirect” approaches extended the interpretable resolution beyond conventional axial image limits and provided both the phase and modulus of the specimen exit wavefunction, free from effects due to the objective lens rather than the aberrated intensity available in a conventional HRTEM image. The latest instrumental developments have seen the successful completion and testing of the necessary electron optical components for direct correction of the spherical aberration present in all electromagnetic round lenses and these corrected instruments are now capable of directly interpretable resolutions close to or below 0.1 nm at intermediate voltages.
2 Essential Theory In this section we outline some of the essential theory required for understanding HRTEM image contrast. Many of the topics described here are treated in more detail elsewhere (see, for example, Spence, 2002; Reimer, 1984, 1997; Hawkes and Kasper, 1996; Ernst and Rühle, 2003) (for the latter see Chapter 2 in particular) and only selected frameworks directly relevant to HRTEM imaging using modern instrumentation are discussed further. We begin with a general review of the essentials of the HRTEM image formation process and subsequently treat the key areas of resolution, and the effects of the objective lens and source in more detail. 2.1 Image Formation As shown schematically in Figure 1–5 (from a simplified ray optical perspective and from a wave optical perspective as described subsequently) the overall process in the formation of an HRTEM image involves three steps. 1. Electron scattering in the specimen. 2. Formation of a diffraction pattern in the back focal plane of the objective lens. 3. Formation of an image in the image plane.2 To understand the relationship between contrast recorded in an HRTEM image and the atomic arrangement within the specimen it is essential to develop theoretical frameworks describing each of these steps. To describe the general case (of arbitrary specimens) each of the above steps requires a complex mathematical and computational treatment that is outside the scope of the section (comprehensive accounts can be found elsewhere, e.g., Spence, 2002; Buseck et al., 1989; Cowley,
2 Although not formally derived here it can easily be shown that the specimen, back focal, and image planes are mathematically related by Fourier transform operations.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
Figure 1–5. (a) Schematic optical ray diagram showing the principles of the imaging process in HRTEM and indicating the reciprocal relationships between specimen, diffraction and image spaces. (b) Schematic diagram illustrating the wave optical relationship between the recorded image intensity in HRTEM and the specimen exit-wave through the objective lens aberration function.
1975; Reimer, 1997; Ernst and Rühle, 2003; Hawkes and Kasper, 1996). We therefore restrict ourselves to treatment of the simplest cases for illustrative purposes and subsequently follow the nomenclature and sign conventions given in Spence (2002). For thin specimens, neglecting absorption, the effect of the specimen on an incident electron wave is to alter only its phase leaving the amplitude unchanged. Under this phase object approximation (POA), which ignores Fresnel diffraction within the specimen but includes the
9
10 A.I. Kirkland et al.
effects of multiple scattering, the specimen exit-wave complex amplitude can be written as ψ e ( x , y ) = exp{−iσφ p ( x , y )}
(1)
where σ is an interaction constant given by σ = 2πme λ r h 2
(2)
in which both m and λr are relativistically corrected values of the t2
electron mass and wavelength and φ p = ∫ φ( x , y , z)dz is the two−t 2 dimensional projection of the specimen potential along the beam direction. The interaction constant decreases with accelerating voltage (with values of 0.00729 V−1 nm−1 at 200 kV decreasing to 0.00539 V−1 nm−1 at 1000 kV), whereas the specimen inner potential generally increases with atomic number, although this also depends on the density (Shindo and Hiraga, 1998) (Table 1–1). Equation (1) shows that within this model the effect of the specimen is to advance the phase of the electron wave by σφp(x, y) over the wave in vacuum. For suitably thin specimens of low atomic number the values of the mean inner potential are such that this phase advance is small and hence the exponential term in Eq. (1) can be expanded and approximated as3 ψ e ( x , y ) ≈ 1 − iσφ p ( x , y )
(3)
in the weak phase object approximation (WPOA), which assumes kinematic scattering within the specimen requiring that the intensity of the central unscatttered beam is significantly stronger than that of the diffracted beams. It is important to note that both of the above formulations are projection approximations such that atoms within the specimen can be moved along the incident beam direction without affecting the exit wavefunction.
Table 1–1. Mean inner potential of representative materials in volts. Element C
Z (atomic number) 6
Mean inner potential (V) 7.8 ± 0.6
Al
13
13 ± 0.4
Si
14
11.5
Cu
29
23.5 ± 0.6
Ge
32
15.6 ± 0.8
Au
79
21.1 ± 2
3 Strictly it is the variation in the phase change produced by different parts of the specimen that is important, which supports this approximation.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
The complex amplitude of the scattered wave in the back focal plane of the objective lens is given by the Fourier transform of Eq. (3). With φp(x, y) real this gives ψ d (u, v) = δ(u, v) − iσF{φ p ( x , y )}
(4)
Equation (4) is subsequently modified by the presence of a limiting objective aperture and by phase shifts introduced by the objective lens. The former can be included through the simple function
P (kx , ky ) = 1
|k| ≤ r .
P (kx , ky ) = 0
|k| ≥ r .
(5)
The phase shifts introduced by the objective lens are parameterized by the coefficients of a wave aberration function, W(u, v), which is treated in detail in a subsequent section. Thus, including aperture and lens effects the complex amplitude, under the WPOA, is given by
ψd0 (kx , ky ) = δ(kx , ky ) − iσF {φp (x, y)}P (kx , ky ) exp[iW (kx , ky )]. (6) A further Fourier transform of Eq. (6) finally gives the image amplitude (in the image plane) as
ψi (x, y) = 1 − iσ {φp (−x, y)} F {P (kx , ky ) exp[iW (kx , ky )]}.
(7)
Since the cosine terms in the expansion of equation (7) cancel, the recorded image intensity, to first order, is I ( x , y ) = ψ i ( x , y )ψ *i ( x , y ) ≈ 1 + 2σφp (−x, −y) ∗ F{sin[W (kx , ky )]P (kx , ky )}.
(8)
The above expression shows that for this simplest theory the image contrast is proportional to the projection of the specimen potential convolved with an impulse response function arising from the instrument. Detailed treatment of the latter requires the inclusion of the effects due to the partial coherence of the electron source, which acts to damp higher spatial frequencies (see later), and of the detector, which also modifies the recorded contrast through its modulation transfer function (see later). A useful modification to the above treatment makes the potential φp(x, y) complex. This complex projected specimen potential (Cowley and Pogany, 1968) provides a description of the attenuation of the image wavefeld through either scattering outside a limiting aperture or more usefully for unfiltered HRTEM by the depletion of the elastic wavefeld by inelastic processes (Yoshioka, 1957).
11
12 A.I. Kirkland et al.
A number of further extensions to this basic treatment have previously been proposed to overcome the limitations of a projection approximation in the thick phase grating approximation (Cowley and Moodie, 1962). We do not give a detailed derivation here but note that this approximation successfully accounts for multiple scattering and a degree of curvature of the Ewald sphere (Fresnel diffraction within the specimen) and is thus more generally applicable to HRTEM imaging under less restrictive conditions than the WPOA. The projected charge density (PCD) approximation is an alternative extension that provides a tractable analytic expression for the image intensity including the effects of multiple scattering (unlike the weak phase object) but retaining the restriction of a projection approximation. Starting from the expression for the specimen exit-wave complex amplitude given by the POA in the absence of an objective aperture and with no wave aberration function we can write ψ e ( x , y ) = exp{−iσφ p ( x , y )}
(9)
The amplitude in the back focal plane of the objective lens is given by Fourier transformation of the above as ψd (kx , ky ) = F {exp[−iσφp (x, y)]} exp[iπ∆C1 λ(u2 + v 2 )] ≈ Φ(kx , ky )[1 + iπ∆C1 λ|k|2 ].
(10)
if only a small defocus, ∆C1, is allowed and where Φ(kx , k y) represents the Fourier transform of exp[iσφp(x, y)]. Thus the image amplitude (in the image plane) is given by ψi (x, y) = exp(−iσφp (x, y)) + iπ∆C1 λF −1 {(k2x + k2y )Φ(kx , ky )}.
(11)
A standard theorem from Fourier analysis is now used (Bracewell, 1965), which states that if f(x, y)and Φ(u, v) are a Fourier transform pair then F −1 {(k2x + k2y )Φ(kx , ky )} = − 1 π 2 [∇2 f (x, y)]. 4
(12)
Applying this result the image amplitude is given by ψ i ( x , y ) = exp[−iσφ p ( x , y )] − i∆C1 λ 4 π ∇ 2 {exp[−iσφ p ( x , y )]} = exp[−iσφ p ( x , y )] + (i∆C1λ σ 4 π)exp[−iσφ p ( x , y )] × {σ∇φ p ( x , y ) + i∇ 2 φ p ( x , y )}
(13)
which yields an image intensity to first order as I ( x , y ) ≈ 1 − (∆C1λσ 2π)∇ 2 φ p ( x , y )
(14)
From Poisson’s equation ∇ φp(x, y) = −ρp(x, y)/ε0ε we finally obtain 2
I(x, y) = 1 + (∆C1 λσ/2π²0 ²)ρp (x, y).
(15)
in which ρp(x, y) is the projected total charge density including the nuclear contribution.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
Historically, the restriction of limited defocus and no spherical aberration (or other uncorrected aberrations) meant that the application of the PCD approximation was restricted to relatively low resolution imaging. However, this approximation would now seem to be ideal for the interpretation of aberration corrected images (see later) in which these restrictions can be experimentally achieved at high resolution (O’Keefe, 2000). Finally, we note that this theory has also been modified (Lynch et al., 1975; Chang, 2000) to include the effects due to higher order lens aberrations and the presence of a limiting objective aperture. Further extensions to the models outlined above require solution of the dynamic electron diffraction problem using one of several possible computational algorithms, a description of which is outside the scope of this section (Goodman and Moodie, 1974; Cowley, 1975; Self et al., 1983; Jap and Glaeser, 1978; van Dyck, 1983; van Dyck and Coene, 1984; Coene and van Dyck, 1984a,b; Hirsch et al., 1965; Stadelmann, 1987, 1991; Spence and Zuo, 1992; Chen and van Dyck, 1997; Kirkland, 1998; Ernst and Rühle, 2003). However, for generalized HRTEM image simulation the multislice algorithm (Cowley, 1959a–c, 1975; Goodman and Moodie, 1974) has been most commonly employed for the simulation of HRTEM images, to a large extent due to its computational efficiency compared to alternative methods (van Dyck and Op de Beeck, 1994) such as Bloch wave calculations, and this is therefore outlined in a subsequent section.
2.2 Resolution Limits Unlike their optical equivalents there is no simple measure of resolution for the electron microscope, as the resolution depends on both the instrument and also on the scattering properties of the sample used.4 The ultimate resolution of any optical system is the diffraction limit imposed by the wavelength of the radiation, λ, and the aperture angle of the objective lens, α, and the refractive index, n, which can be formalized through Abbe’s equation as5 rd = kλ n sin(α )
(16)
However, due to imperfections in the objective lens and limited coherence (as discussed subsequently) experimental resolution limits are far lower than that set by Eq. (16) and hence a “single figure” definition of resolution for HRTEM is not possible. Two independent definitions of attainable resolution are commonly used, defined, respectively, by the key optical properties of the objective lens and those of the source.
4 For a more detailed treatment of resolution see Chapter 20 by van Aert et al. in this volume. 5 The value of the constant k lies between 0.6 and 0.8 depending on the coherence of the illumination.
13
14 A.I. Kirkland et al.
The first of these is the “directly interpretable” or Scherzer limit (Scherzer, 1949) or point resolution, which defines the maximum width of a pass band transferring all spatial frequencies from zero, without phase reversal, and is determined by the coefficients of the wave aberration function of the objective lens (see later). Ignoring the phase shifts due to higher order aberrations (see later) the phase contrast transfer function (PCTF) (Hawkes and Kasper, 1996) due to defocus and spherical aberration is given by sin W (k) = sin{πC1 λ|k|2 + π C3 λ3 |k|4 }. 2
(17)
For HRTEM this defines a focus setting (Scherzer, 1949) that offsets the phase shift due to spherical aberration, C3 through a suitable choice of defocus: 6 C1,Scherzer = −1.2(C3 λ )1 2
(18)
which leads to a broad band of phase contrast transfer without zero crossings (Figure 1–6) up to a frequency of k max = 1.6(C3λ3)−1/4. The reciprocal gives the point resolution as d1 = 0.625(C3 λ 3 )1 4
(19)
Thus, HRTEM images of thin specimens recorded at the Scherzer defocus (or its extended variant) will have components that are directly proportional to the (negative of) the projected potential of the specimen extending to spatial frequencies equal to the interpretable resolution limit (Cowley and Iijima, 1972; Hanßen, 1971). For higher spatial frequencies up to that defi ned by the information limit the contrast is partially reversed as the PCTF starts to oscillate (Figure 1–6).7 Given the form of Eq. (19) it is evident that a decrease in electron wavelength has a greater effect than an equivalent decrease in the spherical aberration, and for this reason high-voltage instrumentation (see earlier) has, until recently, been the preferred route to achieving higher interpretable resolutions. The higher resolution, the information limit, defines the highest spatial frequency transferred from the specimen exit wavefunction to the image intensity. This is determined by the effects of spatial and temporal coherence (see later) in the illumination and by mechanical instabilities and acoustic noise that also act to damp the transfer of higher spatial frequencies.
6 In this definition of the Scherzer focus, the passband in the CTF contains a local minimum = 0.7. The original definition, C1, Scherzer = (C3λ)1/2, avoids a local minimum in the passband at the cost of a slightly poorer point resolution ρS = 0.707(C3λ3)1/4. 7 The above definitions of point resolution assume a fixed positive C3. Variable C3 in corrected microscopes modifies these results as detailed in a subsequent section.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
15
Figure 1–6. Phase contrast transfer functions (PCTFs) plotted in one dimension (a and b) and two dimensions (c and d) calculated for a modern 300-kV FEGTEM illustrating the interpretable resolution (d1) and information limits (d2). (a and c) calculated at the Scherzer defocus (−34.4 nm) (b and d) calculated at the higher Lichte underfocus (−174.4 nm). In all cases CTFs are calculated for 300 kV, C3 = 0.6 mm, ∆E = 0.8 eV, beam divergence = 0.1 mrad and the interpretable and information limits are indicated.
16 A.I. Kirkland et al.
As will be discussed in detail in a subsequent section the effects of temporal and spatial coherence (see also Hawkes and Kasper, 1996) can be treated through respective envelope functions of form Ef (k) = exp{− 0.5 π 2 ∆ 2 (λk 2 )2 } Es (k) = exp{− π 2 q02 (C1λk + C3 λ 3 k 3 )2 }
(20)
in which the expression for the spatial envelope includes only defocus and spherical aberration, with q0, the standard deviation of a Gaussian modeling the convergent cone of illumination at the specimen surface, and where σ 2 (V0 ) 4σ 2 (I 0 ) σ 2 (E0 ) ∆ = Cc + + I 02 V02 V02
12
(21)
In Eq. (21) Cc is the chromatic aberration, E0 is the spread in electron energies arising from the source, V0 is the accelerating voltage, and I0 is the objective lens current, which affects the objective lens magnetic field (O’Keefe, 1992).8,9 The form of these distributions is far less important than their width and in general, as above, Gaussian distribution functions are used, as this makes any further derivation analytically tractable.10,11 The form of these two envelope functions leads to definitions of information limits in which the information transfer drops to a level of exp(−2) or 13.5% given by (O’Keefe and Pitt, 1980). d2 = πλ d 2 d3 = S+1 3 + S−1 3
(22) 2 12 3.3 C13 3.3 2 S± = ± + C3 λ 2 4 πq0 27 C3 λ 4 πq0 However, it should be noted that the limit defined by d3 increases with defocus and does not therefore define an absolute information limit
8 The last term is written here in terms of the objective lens current I0 following convention. However, this is not strictly correct, particularly if the lens is operated close to saturation where the magnetic field is not proportional to the current. 9 It may seem surprising that the objective lens current influences the variation of focus only in the presence of chromatic aberration. However, this is due to the general scaling rule that electron trajectories are identical when energy and magnetic field are changed according to E′ = k2E and B′ = kB. Hence, in a microscope corrected for chromatic aberration, the focus cannot be changed by changing the currents in all lens elements by the same factor. 10 For the defocus spread, the terms due to voltage and lens current instabilities are well described by Gaussian function, whereas the intrinsic source energy spread would be more accurately described by a Maxwellian distribution for thermionic emitters or the Fowler–Nordheim equation (Fowler and Nordheim, 1928) for field emitters. 11 The above definition of δ assumes that the fluctuations are independent of each other.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
per se. In particular, for the case of field emission sources where the source size is small, the spatial coherence is not limiting and thus the information limit due to temporal coherence determines the information limit for all defoci. 2.3 The Wave Aberration Function The key optical component affecting HRTEM image formation is the objective lens and in this section we review its influence in terms of the wave aberration function (see also Hawkes and Kasper, 1996). For an ideal lens, a point object at a position (x, y) in the object plane leads to a spherical wavefront in the diffraction plane, contracting to a conjugate point in the image plane.12 However, all electromagnetic lenses suffer from aberrations causing deviations from this ideal spherical wavefront thus reducing the sharpness of an image point much more severely than the diffraction limit. For HRTEM, a wave aberration function W(u, v) is therefore defined that describes the distance between the ideal and actual wavefronts in the diffraction plane as a function of the position of the point object in the diffraction plane, (u, v) (Saxton, 1995) (Figure 1–7).13 The wave aberration function, W(ω), written in terms of a complex position variable ω = u + iv can be Taylor expanded to 3rd order in terms of the axial aberrations as
Figure 1–7. Schematic diagram showing the origin of the wave aberration function, W(u,v), which describes the complex deviation from an ideal spherically diffracted wave.
12
For a pure phase object this condition would, however, lead to lead to zero contrast at the Gaussian focus. 13 More rigorously W is a function of both position of the point object in the diffraction and image planes, i.e., W(x, y, u, v). However, HRTEM experiments are carried out at high magnifcation and hence the feld of view is small and the dependence of W on (x, y) can be neglected in the isoplanatic approximation.
17
18 A.I. Kirkland et al.
W (ω) = <{2π {A0 λω ∗ + 12 A1 λ2 ω ∗2 + 1 C1 λ2 ω ∗ ω λ + 13 A2 λ3 ω ∗3 + 13 B2 λ3 ω ∗2 ω
2
+ 14 A3 λ4 ω ∗4 + 14 S3 λ4 ω ∗3 ω + 14 C3 λ4 ω ∗2 ω 2 + . . .}}
(23)
Converting to polar notation, with ω = keiφ, An = |An|eiαn and Bn = |Bn|eiβn, Eq. (23) can be more conveniently rewritten as
{|A0 |λk cos(φ − α0 ) W (k, φ) = 2π λ + 12 |A1 |λ2 k 2 cos 2(φ − α1 ) + 12 C1 λ2 k 2 + 13 |A2 |λ3 k 3 cos 3(φ − α2 ) + 13 |B2 |λ3 k 3 cos(φ − β2 ) + 14 |A3|λ4 k 4 cos 4(φ − α3 ) + 14 |S3 |λ4 k 4 cos 2(φ − σ3 ) + 14 C3 λ4 k 4 + . . .}
(24)
which makes the azimuthal and radial dependence of the various aberration terms more apparent. Table 1–2 lists the aberration coefficients important in HRTEM ignoring those with a chromatic dependence.14 All of the aberration coefficients listed in Table 1–2 except C1 and C3 are due to lens imperfections (either mechanical or electrical) and would not appear in a perfect round lens (Scherzer, 1949). However, they can be corrected using combinations of multipole fields of appropriate symmetry and in recent years this approach has enabled the Table 1–2. Isoplanatic HRTEM. Aberration A0
Order in w 1
aberration
coefficients
Azimuthal symmetry 1
important
for
Name and description Image shift
A1
2
2
Two-fold astigmatism
A2
3
3
Three-fold astigmatism
A3
4
4
Four-fold astigmatism
B2
3
1
Axial coma
S3
4
2
Axial star
C1
2
•
Defocus
C3
4
•
Spherical aberration
14
The seemingly counterintuitive notation (e.g., C1 in Table 1–2 for a secondorder term in the wave aberration fucntion stems from the ray-optical theory of Seidel aberrations (Hawkes and Kasper, 1989), which are described in terms of displacements of ray-path intersections with the image plane as a function of (u,v). These displacements are proportional to the gradient of the wave aberration function and hence an nth-order Seidel aberration corresponds to a term of order n + 1 in the wave aberration function.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
19
Table 1–3. Accuracy of aberration coefficients. a Resolution K max (/nm -1) d min (nm)
A 1, C1 (nm)
Accuracy A 2, B 2 (nm) A 3, S 3, C 3 (mm)
Tilt (mrad)
11
0.09
0.5
35
2.1
21
10
0.1
0.6
47
3.1
27
9
0.11
0.8
64
4.8
38
8
0.125
1.0
92
7.6
54
7
0.14
1.3
137
13
a
80
Accuracy to which the aberration coefficients need to be determined such that each of them causes a maximum RMS error in the wave aberration function of less that λ/16, i.e., a phase change of less than π/8 for a given target resolution. The values are calculated for an accelerating voltage of 300 kV (λ ≈ 2 pm). The necessary accuracy for the beam tilt τ is calculated from that for B2 using ∆τ = −∆B2/(3C3) with C3 = 0.57 mm.
correction of C3 using long hexapole fields (see later) (Rose, 1981, 1990; Haider et al., 1998c; Urban et al., 1999). For HRTEM imaging the effects of the coefficients of the wave aberration function are to introduce phase shifts in the image given by multiplying each term in W by 2 π/λ. These phase shifts can also be used to estimate the maximum tolerable value in any coefficient for a particular target resolution (Table 1–3). Few of the aberration coefficients defined above are directly observable under axial illumination and their determination therefore relies on measurements taken as a function of known injected beam tilts. If the illumination is tilted by an angle τ the new aberration coefficients up to C3 (marked with a prime) are given by A0′ = A0 + A1 τ * + A2 τ * 2 + C1 τ + A1′ = A1 + 2 A2 τ * 2 τ +
1 * 2 2 B2 τ + B2 τ * τ + C3 τ * τ 2 3 3
2 B2 τ + C3 τ 2 3
4 (25) C1′ = C1 +R( B2 τ*) + 2C3 τ * τ 3 A2′ = A2 B2′ = B2 + 3C3 τ C3′ = C3 From Eq. (25) it is immediately apparent that the shift A′0 − A0 between two images taken at beam tilts differing by τ depends on all the other aberration coefficients. Hence, measuring the image shifts induced by a suitable set of beam tilts provides a method for measuring all coefficients. Alternatively, the tilt-induced changes, C′1 − C1 and A′1 − A1 in defocus or two-fold astigmatism measured from diffractograms (Figure 1–8), depend on A1, C1, A2, B2, and C3, thus providing an alternative measure of these coefficients. If the spherical aberration is independently determined then measurement of the orientations only of diffractograms also provides another simple measure of A1, A2, and B2 (Saxton, 2000). Measurements of diffractograms (Krivanek, 1976; Krivanek and Leber, 1994; Zemlin et al., 1978; Zemlin, 1979; Typke and Dierksen, 1995; Pan, 1998; Saxton, 1995) or image shifts (Typke and Dierksen, 1995;
20 A.I. Kirkland et al.
Figure 1–8. Individual axial diffractograms calculated from HRTEM images of a thin amorphous germanium foil showing the effects odefocus (C1) and two-fold astigmatism (A1). (a) Axial image recorded at large underfocus with the two-fold astimatism corrected. (b) Axial image in the presence of a small amount of two-fold astigmatism giving rise to an elliptical diffractogram. (c) As for (b) but with a larger two-fold astigmatism giving rise to a “Maltese Cross”-shaped diffractogram showing overfocus and underfocus along the axes indicated. (d) Representative tableau of diffractograms recorded for a set of differently titled illumination conditions illustrating the variation in A1 and C1 with illumination tilt. Each experimental diffractogram is shown merged with a simulated diffractogram calculated from the fitted values of A1 and C1. The illumination tilt axes are indicated.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
Koster et al., 1987, 1989; Koster, 1989; Koster and de Ruijter, 1992; Saxton, 1995), however, have their own particular experimental advantages and disadvantages. A practical difficulty with the application of tilt-induced displacements arises from the measurement of the image shifts using the peak position in the cross-correlation function defined as XCF = FT −1 [c1* c2 ]
(26)
The tilt-induced change in A0 introduces a linear phase variation in the cross spectrum c*1c2, which leads to a displacement of the XCF peak to a position given by the shift vector between the images. As already shown, the other imaging parameters also change as the beam is tilted and this causes the phase variation to become nonlinear at higher spatial frequencies and leads to distorted cross-correlation peaks. However, when the imaging conditions in both images are approximately known, these nonlinear phase shifts can be compensated and a sharp XCF peak can be recovered (Saxton, 1994; Kirkland et al., 1995). Shift measurements also fail for clean perfectly periodic specimens in which image positions differing by any integer multiple of a lattice vector cannot be distinguished. A more severe problem associated with the tilt-induced shift method is that any displacement due to specimen drift is indistinguishable from the tilt-induced displacement required and hence this approach is most frequently used at low resolution or for initial coarse alignment at high resolution. Conversely, diffractogram measurements require the presence of an area of thin disordered material and are thus less generally applicable. However, they are insensitive to specimen drift and their measurement is relatively straightforward even under tilted illumination conditions. Hence defocus and astigmatism measurements are best suited to fine adjustment at high resolution (Pan, 1998). Historically the use of diffractograms for the determination of aberrations was first suggested by Thon (1966) for the measurement of defocus from ring positions in an optically generated diffractogram. This method was later extended through the use of diffractogram tableaus acquired with different beam tilt azimuths (Figure 1–8) to the measurement of the spherical aberration C3, axial coma B2, and threefold astigmatism A2 by Krivanek (1976) and Zemlin et al. (1978). However, the diffractogram tableau method was computationally too demanding for routine use at this time and was used only to demonstrate that the alignment achieved from current reversal or voltage centering was inadequate as an alignment for HRTEM (Saxton et al., 1983).15
15
The current reversal center alignment involves reversing the current of the objective lens and is no longer practical with the strong lenses used in modern instruments. It should not be confused with the current center alignment, where the objective lens current is oscillated by a small amount. Similarly, in the voltage center alignment, the high tension is oscillated. Generally, the axes found by the three methods are distinct and the voltage center provides a workable approximation to the coma-free axis, but for HRTEM coma-free alignment is preferred.
21
22 A.I. Kirkland et al.
Fitting C1 and A1 to match simulated diffractogram patterns with experimental ones can be done manually to relatively high accuracy (Figure 1–8d; Chand, 1997). This, however, is a lengthy and tedious process and automation of this task is highly desirable. This problem has been addressed by Baba et al. (1987) and Fan and Krivanek (1990) in an algorithm where the diffractogram is divided into 32 sectors and the defocus along the directions in each sector is determined by crosscorrelating the rotational sector average with an array of theoretical diffractograms. The sinusoidal focus variation as a function of the azimuth angle obtained is subsequently fitted to the measured focus values to determine C1 and A1 and automatic alignment can be achieved using a tableau with as few as four tilt azimuths. More generally, the major challenges for implementing a robust automated diffractogram fitting procedure are as follows: 1. The most abundant amorphous material in the microscope, carbon, is a weak scatterer. Hence, particularly at high spatial frequencies, the signal is weak compared to the noise background affecting overall diffractogram quality. 2. The strength of the observed signal depends on the object as well as on the phase contrast transfer function. 3. Diffractograms taken close to Scherzer or Gaussian defocus show few rings and are difficult to fit. 4. In the presence of large two-fold astigmatism and at close to Gaussian defocus the diffractograms are cross- rather than ring-shaped, which leads to difficulties for algorithms based on the evaluation of rotationally averaged sectors of the diffractogram. 5. It is difficult to distinguish between overfocus and underfocus. 6. Most automated algorithms fail when a significant amount of crystalline material is present, leading to strong reflections at positions unrelated to the ring pattern. More recently the advent of C3-corrected microscopes (see later) has made automated aberration measurement more important because the nonround lens elements introduce a multitude of high-order aberrations (up to six-fold astigmatism) that require correction in an elaborate alignment procedure. Uhlemann and Haider (1998) have implemented an algorithm that can evaluate the apparent defocus and astigmatism from a diffractogram in less than 400 ms based on a comparison of the experimental diffractogram with an extensive library of precalculated diffractograms and is robust to disturbances from the presence of crystalline material. However, given the limitations of both of these traditional methods an alternative method has also been proposed, which is both applicable to a wide range of specimens and sufficiently accurate for use in atomic resolution imaging (Meyer, 2002; Meyer et al., 2002, 2004). In this approach a phase correlation function (PCF) (Figure 1–9) (Kuglin and Hines, 1975) is initially calculated (defined as the conventional XCF with the modulus set to unity): c1 (k) * c2 (k) PCF(x ) = FT −1 F(k) c1 (k) * c2 (k)
(27)
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy Figure 1–9. Comparison of a (a) cross- and (b) phase correlation functions (XFC and PCF) between two images of a crystalline material with a defocus difference of 69 nm. Due to the periodicity of the crystalline specimen, the XCF peak repeats periodically but the PCF dose not show this repetitive pattern and consists of a single peak broadened into a concentric ring pattern due to the defocus difference.
where ci (k) are the image Fourier transforms and F(k) is a rotationally symmetric weighting factor used to suppress high-frequency noise. The modulus normalization is essential as it suppresses the crystal reflections that make the conventional XCF periodic, thus allowing aberration measurement in the absence of amorphous material. The PCF calculated between two images recorded at different defocus levels consists of a centrosymmetric ring pattern, the exact form of which depends on the relative defocus between them (assuming that the other aberration coefficients remain constant between the two images) (Figure 1–9). It is possible to compensate for the phase shifts giving rise to this ring pattern by the application of a phase factor dependent on the defocus difference, thus defining a phase compensated PCF cos[WD (k)]c1* (k)c2 (k) PCFw (x ) = FT −1 F(k) |cos[WD (k )]c1* (k)c2 (k) + h|
(28)
23
24 A.I. Kirkland et al.
in which the very small positive number, h, prevents a zero denominator and where WD (k) = π∆C1λ|k|2 describes the propagation from the first to the second image in the presence of only a defocus difference ∆C1. When the value of ∆C1 matches the actual focus difference the phase compensated PCF collapses to a sharp localized correlation peak. Hence the relative defocus difference between two images can be determined by simply maximizing peak height in the phase compensated PCF as a function of the compensated defocus difference (Figure 1–10), which with subsequent refinement can yield relative defoci to an accuracy better than 1 nm (Meyer et al., 2002). In the second step an initial restored image wavefunction (see later for details of the restoration process), ψi(k), in the plane of a reference image is restored and the absolute values of A1 and C1 are determined using a phase contrast index function (PCI) f PCI given by f PCI (k , C1 , A1 ) = − cos[arg(ψ si (k))] + arg[ψ si (− k)] + 2W (k , C1 , A1 )
(29)
where
W (k, C1 , A1 ) = 21 |A1 |λk2 cos 2(φ − α1 ) + 21 C1 λk2 + 21 C3 λ3 k4 .
(30)
Figure 1–10. Peak height of the PCF (solid line) and XCF (dashed line) (shown against the left hand side and right hand side scales) between two images as a function of compensated focus difference showing a sharp maximum at the correct compensating focus difference in the PCF.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
25
Figure 1–11. Phase contrast index function f PCI. For mismatched values of C1 (a) −50 nm, (b) −10 nm, f PCI shows dark rings, whereas at the correct values of C1, f PCI is close to one (white) at all spatial frequencies (c). (d) The f PCI averaged over k and plotted as a function of C1 showing a sharp maximum at the correct focus value of −128 nm. The values ∆C1 given in (a) to (c) are relative to this focus.
is the symmetric part of the wave aberration function defined earlier with trial parameters C1, A1 and fixed spherical aberration C3. This function measures the conjugate symmetry in the corrected image wavefunction and has a value of +1 when this is conjugate antisymmetric and −1 when conjugate symmetric. Therefore under the weak phase object approximation when the trial values of C1 and A1 are correct the f PCI tends to 1 for all spatial frequencies, whereas for mismatched parameters, f PCI shows dark bands (Figure 1–11a–c). In practice, the correct values of C1 and A1 are readily determined from a plot of the f PCI averaged over k (Figure 1–11(d)). This general method is best implemented experimentally using a combined tilt-defocus dataset geometry as illustrated in Figure 1–12, which comprises a set of short focal series recorded at a number of tilt azimuths. This dataset is overredundant and can be used to calculate values of C1 and A1 for each of the recorded tilt azimuths using the PCF/PCI approach. For all three measurement methods described, data recorded for a suitable number of defined illumination directions and magnitudes provide the full set of aberration coefficients (Meyer, 2002) and these
26 A.I. Kirkland et al.
Figure 1–12. Schematic representation of the combined tilt/defocus dataset used for both aberration determination using the PCF/PCI approach and tilt azimuth reconstruction described in a subsequent section. A three member focal series is recorded for each of six different tilt azimuth angles and also for axial illumination. Image numbers refer to the experimental recording sequence designed to minimize hysteresis in the objective lens and beam tilt coils and to enable measurement of focus drift during acquisition.
can be conveniently and reliably determined in practice by least-squares fitting of the parameters to be determined to the observations available. Where the injected tilt is known accurately the dependence of the observables on the aberration coefficients is linear yielding an easily found, unique solution (Saxton, 1995; Meyer et al., 2004). Alternatively, if the calibrations of the beam tilt coil magnitudes and orientations are not known, these unknowns can be fitted in an additional nonlinear iterative minimization of the residual misfit from the linear fitting of the aberration coefficients (Saxton, 1995). 2.4 Coherence As already described, contrast in a high-resolution image formed in an electron microscope arises from the interference of electron waves that have been scattered by the specimen. The degree to which these waves can interfere is often referred to as the degree of coherence (Born and Wolf, 1999). Hence, the degree of coherence is vital in determining high-resolution image contrast (for a review see Hawkes, 1978). For all electron sources used in HRTEM imaging (Reimer, 1997), the source is only partially coherent (Hawkes and Kasper, 1996; Hawkes, 1978). There are two aspects to this partial coherence: partial spatial coherence, due to the finite dimensions of the electron source (Born and Wolf, 1999), and partial temporal coherence, which is associated with the finite energy distribution of the source and fluctuations in both the accelerating voltage and the objective lens current (Hanßen and Trepte, 1971). The effect of this partial coherence of the source is to restrict the amount of information that can be extracted from high-resolution images (Frank, 1973; Wade and Frank, 1977; Hawkes, 1978). Thus, the source and the associated condenser lens system represent the second major optical component that directly affects HRTEM image contrast. Frequently, the illumination system of the electron microscope is treated as an incoherently filled effective source (Hopkins, 1953, 1951) with an intensity distribution S(q). Within this model the effects of
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
partial spatial coherence on the HRTEM image intensity can be calculated by incoherent summation of intensities over all the incident angles from the effective source.16 For this source model the temporal partial coherence effect can also be treated incoherently (Hanßen and Trepte, 1971) and it is generally assumed that the spatial and temporal distributions of the source are not correlated (for a detailed treatment of the case in which this is not valid see Hawkes and Kasper, 1996). Under these conditions the image intensity can be written as P P I(x) = q f S(q)F (f )|F −1 {ψd (k; q) exp{−iW (k, C1 + f, q)}}|2 . (31) in which the incoherent summations of the coherent image intensities at incident angles q and focus spread levels, f are weighted by the spatial and temporal intensity distributions S(q), F(f), respectively. The individual coherent image intensities are thus given as the modulus square of the convolution of the Fourier transform of specimen exit wavefunction ψ(k,q) at an incident angle q and the objective lens aberration function W(k,C1 + f,q) with corresponding beam tilt and defocus. General computation of the image intensity therefore involves the full dynamical calculation of coherent image intensities over an equally spaced mesh of beam tilts, q and focal spread values, f. This is optimally tackled through the use of numerical Monte Carlo integration (Chang et al., 2005). A number of approximations may also be made that make this calculation more tractable and that provide analytical solutions. For small beam tilts of the incident wave and for modest specimen thickness, the specimen exit wavefunction can be approximated as a single exit wavefunction at the mean incident illumination angle. A further approximation can also be made by expanding the aberration function to only first order which is valid if the beam tilt and focal spread are small as typified by many modern instruments. Using these approximations and assuming that the focal spread and beam divergence distributions are Gaussian with e−1 values of q0 and C1 respectively the image intensity can be written as (Ishizuka, 1980)
I(k) = Σk0 ψ(k + k0 )ψ ∗ (k0 )T (k + k0 , k0 ).
(32)
with T (k1 , k2 ) = exp{−i[W (k1 ; C1 ) − W (k2 ; C1 )]} exp{−π 2 q02 [Wk0 1 − Wk0 2 ]2 } ∂W × exp{−π 2 ∆2 [ ∂C |k=k1 − 1
∂W | ]2 }. ∂C1 k=k2
(33)
16 For cases in which this basic assumption does not hold the mathematical description of coherence is best treated in terms of the mutual dynamic object spectrum and associated mutual coherence function. This treatment is outside the scope of this section and an excellent overview can be found in Ernst and Rühle (2003).
27
28 A.I. Kirkland et al.
The Fourier transform of Eq. (33) is given by the integral over all pairs of diffracted beams with T representing a transmission cross coefficient (TCC) (Figure 1–13). Within this expression for the TCC the first exponential term describes the spatial coherence for a Gaussian spatial intensity distribution with an even aberration function. This term is a
Figure 1–13. Moduli of the transmission cross-coefficient (TCC) functions defined in the text for combined spatial and temporal coherence and calculated under (a) the weak object approximation and (b) for a strong object. In both case the functions are shown for defoci ranging from −1 to −9 Scherzer. All calculations were carried out at 300 kV with C3 = 0.6 nm and with e−1 values of Gaussian beam divergence and focal spread distributions of 0.28 mrad and 4.7 nm, respectively (Chang, 2004).
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
function of the square difference of the gradient of the aberration function at two spatial frequencies and allows maximum transfer when the slopes of the aberration function are identical at k1 and k2. The second exponential term describes the temporal coherence, and is a function of the square difference of the derivative of the aberration function with respect to the focus at two spatial frequencies. This function has maximum transfer when |k1| = |k2|. If a further assumption of a weak scattering object is made, such that only interference between the transmitted beam and diffracted beams is considered, the TCC can be further simplified as (Wade and Frank, 1977) T (k) = exp[−iW (k)] exp{−π 2 q02 (C1 λk + C3 λ3 k 3 )2 } exp[−π 2 ∆2 (λk 2 /2)2 ]. (34)
In this limit both spatial and temporal coherence functions for weak objects decrease with increasing spatial frequencies (Figure 1–13), and can be recognized as the simple damping envelopes described in an earlier section defining the information limit.
3 Instrumentation This section describes certain aspects of instrumental design that are important for HRTEM in that they directly contribute to the resolution attainable. Inevitably, due to limitations of space, not all aspects are covered fully and the reader is referred to one of several dedicated texts on HRTEM and electron optics for more detailed treatments of individual areas (Spence, 2002; Hawkes, 1972, 1982; Reimer, 1984, 1995; Hawkes and Kasper, 1989). 3.1 Electron Sources For HRTEM electron sources have to fulfill a number of key requirements summarized as follows (Spence, 2002; Hawkes and Kasper, 1989): 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
High brightness and coherence. High current efficiency. Long life under available vacuum conditions. Stable emission characteristics. Low energy spread.
An ideal source would therefore provide independent control of the illumination intensity and coherence for any given illuminated area, a situation that is currently best approximated by field emission sources. For any source, the current, I, passing through an area, A, is proportional to both A and to the solid angle subtended by the illumination aperture at the source (Reimer, 1984). A beam brightness can be defined as the constant of proportionality, β, in the above relationship and as the area and angle tend to zero this is given by β = I/πAθ2
(35)
29
30 A.I. Kirkland et al.
for an aperture semiangle θ. The effect of an ideal lens (Hawkes, 1982; Reimer, 1984; Hawkes and Kasper, 1989) below the source forming the illumination system is to reduce the current density by M2 but to increase the angular aperture by 1/M2. Thus, in the absence of any lens aberrations, the brightness remains constant at all conjugate planes in the microscope. To compare different source types a theoretical brightness for a particular source can be expressed in terms of the emission current density at the cathode (filament), ρ, the cathode temperature, T, and the relativistic high voltage, V, as βm = ρeV/πkT
(36)
although this requires optimal operating conditions and in practice is often reduced to lower values for thermionic sources of between 0.1 and 0.5 βm. Table 1–4 lists values of βm together with other physical and operational characteristics for the four sources commonly used in HRTEM instruments. Tungsten hairpin and LaB6 cathodes rely on thermionic emission of electrons, where at suitably high temperatures electrons in the tail of the Fermi distribution acquire sufficient kinetic energy to overcome the workfunction of the cathode material. Tungsten hairpin sources are the oldest electron sources in commercial use but are only marginally useful for HRTEM and have largely been replaced by LaB6 cathodes (Ahmed and Broers, 1972) and more recently by field emission sources (Honda et al., 1994; Otten and Coene, 1993). The choice of single crystal LaB6 cathodes as thermionic emitters for HRTEM is largely due to their higher brightness while still being operable under relatively poor vacuum conditions. They also have the advantage of operating at a lower temperature than W filaments (due to a lower workfunction), thus providing lower energy spreads. For these reasons until the relatively recent availability of commercial field emission sources LaB6 cathodes were most widely deployed for HRTEM.
Table 1–4. Physical properties of modern electron sources important for HRTEM. a Virtual source diameter 100 nm
Measured brightness at 100 kV (A cm -2 sr-1) 107–10 8
Room temperature field emission
2 nm
Hair-pin fi lament
30 mm
Spource Heated field emission ZrO/W
LaB6 a
From Spence (2002).
5–10 mm
Energy FWHM (eV) 0.8
Melting point (°C) 3370
2 ¥ 109
0.3
5 ¥ 105
0.8
6
7 ¥ 10 (at 75 kV)
1
Vacuum required (torr) 10 -8 10 -9
Emission current (mA) 50–100
3370
10 -10
10
3370
10 -5
100
2200
-6
10
50
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
The detailed physics of field emission and the design of field emission guns for HRTEM are beyond the scope of this section and the article by Crewe (1971) and the chapter in Reimer (1997) provide detailed reviews. These sources are now relatively common in HRTEM instruments and consist of either a heated or, more rarely, an unheated single crystal of tungsten in a 〈111〉 or 〈311〉 orientation. In operation the tip of the source is held in a region of high electrostatic field enabling electrons to tunnel through the lowered potential energy barrier at the surface. In many HRTEM instruments the alternative Schottky emitter comprising a ZrO-coated W tip (Tuggle and Swanson, 1985; Swanson and Schwind in Orloff, 1997), in which the workfunction is lowered to 2.8 eV (from 4.6 eV), is often used allowing electrons to overcome the potential barrier at a lower temperature than for conventional thermionic sources leading to a reduced energy spread. True field emission sources operating at room temperature have been less widely employed due to the need for stringent ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) conditions at the tip region to avoid contamination (Von Harrach, 1995). However, these sources provide the highest brightness and lowest energy spread. The above physical requirements of the source with respect to brightness and energy spread affect HRTEM images via image recording times and the resolution limit imposed by temporal coherence. The detail in an HRTEM image is also strongly affected by the spatial coherence of the electrons emitted from the source and certain physical parameters contribute to this. A theoretical treatment of coherence and its influence on HRTEM images has been given in a previous section and we therefore confine discussion here to the relevant physical characteristics of the source itself. As already described an effective source can be defined as an imaginary electron emitter filling the illuminating aperture (Hopkins, 1951, 1953). In this case each point within the aperture represents a point source of electrons giving an emergent spherical wave, becoming approximately plane at the specimen. Thus, at the specimen plane each electron can be specified by the direction of an incident plane wave. Hence increasing the size of the illuminating aperture increases the size of the central diffraction spot and decreases the spatial coherence. This can also be described as a coherence width, which defines the transverse distance at the object plane over which the illuminating radiation may be treated coherently. Thus waves scattered from atoms separated by less than this distance will interfere coherently and their complex amplitudes must be added, whereas atoms separated by more than this distance scatter incoherently and the intensities of the scattered radiation are added. For sources to fulfill the commonly held assumption that the illuminating source can be replaced by an incoherently filled aperture (see earlier) the coherence width in the plane of this aperture must therefore be small compared to its size, thus making the degree of coherence dependent only on the size of the illuminating aperture. The effect of source size on coherence hence becomes important only for sources smaller than ca. 1 µm, e.g., the smallest LaB6
31
32 A.I. Kirkland et al.
or pointed tungsten sources available. Field emission sources do not conform to this model and for FEG HRTEM instruments the degree of coherence is critically dependent on both the source size and the excitation of the condenser and gun lens system. 3.2 Optics The optical column of a modern HRTEM instrument typically consists of two or three condenser lenses, an objective lens, and up to six imaging lenses below the specimen. The science of magnetic lens design dates back to the late 1920s (Busch, 1926) when it was realized that rotationally symmetric magnetic fields could be used to focus electrons and that to produce a lens of high refractive power the magnetic field along the axis of rotational symmetry needed to be confined to a small region in which the field strength was sufficiently high. This and other elegant early work using algebraic expressions for the lens field has been extensively reviewed elsewhere (Hall, 1966; Hawkes, 1972, 1982; Hawkes and Kasper, 1989; Orloff, 1997) and due to limitations of space is not considered further. Modern lens design is guided by computed solutions of the Laplace equation (see, for example, Septier, 1967, for a review) and subsequent numerical solution of the ray equation (Mulvey and Wallington, 1973). The practical design of electron optics has also been extensively reviewed elsewhere (Hawkes, 1982; Grivet, 1965; Tsuno, 1999; Hawkes and Kasper, 1989) (see also the chapter by Tsuno in Orloff, 1997) including not only the design of the lens polepiece itself but also that of the overall magnetic circuit. For these reasons we provide here only a brief non-mathematically rigorous summary of selected aspects of electron optics relevant to HRTEM and further restrict our discussion to the properties of the objective lens only.17 For all lenses the aberrations important for HRTEM increase with angle and it is largely the optical properties of the objective lens that dominate the final quality of the image formed. These can be treated analytically through either the Eikonal (Sturrock, 1955) or the Trajectory methods (for collected references to these see Hawkes, 1982, Chapter 1). Alternatively, a numerical approach has been described by (Munro, 1973; Orloff, 1997) based on finite element calculation (FEM) of the magnetic flux density distribution for a trial model lens geometry (see also Lencova in Orloff, 1997, for details). Subsequently this can be used to calculate the axial magnetic field distributions and the paraxial rays, which can be finally combined to calculate the aberration integrals (for further details see Tsuno, 1999, and Orloff, 1997). The most important lens aberrations for HRTEM are spherical and chromatic aberration and the effects of these are illustrated in Figure 1–14.
17
Lenses which use the image formed by a preceding lens as an object are classed as projector lenses and include “intermediate” lenses in modern instruments. These are thus distinguished from the objective lens which uses the physical specimen as its object.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
Figure 1–14. Illustration of certain lens aberrations. (a) A perfect lens focuses a point source to a single image point. (b) Spherical aberration causes rays at higher angles to be overfocused. (c) Chromatic aberration causes rays at different energies (indicated by color) to be focused differently. (See color plate.)
Spherical aberration occurs when rays leaving an object at large angle, θ0, are refracted too strongly in the outer regions of the lens and are brought to a focus before the Gaussian image plane. If all rays from such an object are considered then the radius of the circle of least confusion due to the spherical aberration is r = MC3θ30 in the Gaussian image plane, with M the magnification. The value of C3 depends on the lens geometry and excitation and on the object position within the lens field and typically takes values between between 0.5 and 2 mm for modern HRTEM instruments and sets the limit to the interpretable resolution (see earlier) in the absence of corrector elements. For a known lens geometry with a defined magnetic field distribution values for the spherical aberration can be obtained from either computed solutions of the full (nonparaxial) ray equation (Liebmann, 1949) or through the use of the expression below due to Glaser (1956): C3 =
e 16 m0Vr
z2
{
dBz ( z) ∫ dz z1
}
2
+
{ }
h ′( z ) 3e Bz4 ( z) − Bz2 ( z) h( z) 8 m0Vr
2
4 h ( z)dz
(37)
where h(z) is the paraxial trajectory of a ray that leaves an axial object with unit slope and Bz (z) is the magnetic field.18 The presence of derivatives in Eq. (37) explains why the value of C3 is sensitive to the shape of the field. For this reason the detailed geometry of the polepiece (Munro, 1973) and the location of the specimen within the polepiece gap are key design parameters of the objective lens (Tsuno, 1999). Chromatic aberration arises from variations in the lens focal length with wavelength and hence electron energy. As all electron sources are polychromatic to a greater or lesser extent (see earlier) a series of infocus images are formed on a set of planes normal to the optic axis, one for each wavelength present in the illumination. A geometrical optics treatment, as a first approximation, can be used to determine the effects of this focal length variation, which leads to an extended disk
18 The spherical aberration can be measured using either diffractograms of image shifts as detailed earlier.
33
34 A.I. Kirkland et al.
in the Gaussian image plane (of a point object) with radius, r = Mθ0 Cc[(∆V0/V0) − (2∆I/I)]. Typical values for Cc in modern instruments are similar to those for C3 and contribute to setting the absolute information limit for HRTEM (see earlier). In a similar fashion to the spherical aberration the value of the chromatic aberration can also be evaluated if the field distribution is known (Glaser, 1952) as Cc =
e 8 m0Vr
z2
∫ B (z)h(z) dz 2 z
2
(38)
z1
For applications to HRTEM both of these aberrations can be reduced by introducing the specimen into the field of an immersion objective lens for which the magnetic field on the illumination side of the electron optical column (the prefield) does not directly affect image formation. This symmetrical (condenser objective) geometry also has the significant practical advantage of enabling switching from HRTEM using a relatively broad parallel beam to probe-forming modes for analysis or convergent beam electron diffraction from the same area of the sample and has largely replaced earlier asymmetric “top entry” lens designs. The spherical and chromatic aberration are sensitive to the overall geometry of the polepiece, which is often described in terms of the key dimensions defining the upper and lower polepiece faces and bores and the gap between the two polepieces. However, the behavior of both C3 and Cc (and of focal length) can be readily calculated for a given geometry as a function of the lens excitation (Spence, 2002; Tsuno, 1999; Hawkes, 1982) and specimen position enabling these coefficients to be optimized, subject to constraints imposed by machining tolerances and requirements for specimen movement and tilt. 3.3 Specimen Stages The most important purely mechanical components of modern HRTEM instruments are the specimen holder and the goniometer into which it is fitted. A number of complex designs for these, retaining maximum flexibility in specimen movement and access to peripheral devices under constraints of extremely high mechanical and thermal stability, have been proposed and are reviewed elsewhere (Valdrè, 1979; Valdrè and Goringe, 1971; Watt, 1986; Turner et al., 2005). Most recently facilities for nanoscale specimen manipulation and electrical measurement have also been included (Wang, 2003). The original designs for instruments used for high resolution were based on “top entry” goniometers into which a conical cartridge was inserted fitting into the upper tapered bore of the objective lens polepiece with the specimen supported in a cup at the base of the cartridge. However, this arrangement leads to restrictions in objective lens design as the polepiece bore must be grossly asymmetric with an upper bore of sufficient diameter to allow the specimen to pass (Tsuno, 1999). Translate and tilt movements also require complex, high precision mechanical mechanisms as the specimen is located at the base of the
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
cartridge surrounded by the polepiece. The geometry of top entry stages also precludes any EDX analysis and the provision of specimen heating or cooling is extremely difficult (Watt, 1986). Despite these limitations this design has inherent advantages in that the specimen cartridge is mechanically and acoustically isolated from the external environment and its cylindrical symmetry leads to high thermal stability. The more common side-entry design in which the specimen is attached to a rod that is inserted into the goniometer allows far greater flexibility but introduces potential mechanical and thermal instability. However, this is outweighed for many applications by the flexibility of this design (for example, in providing specimen heating and cooling) and modern commercial implementations are sufficiently stable for atomic resolution imaging. In the majority of cases commercial sideentry goniometers provide high precision computer control of all five axes of specimen movement with stepper motors or donator drives (Emile et al., 1993). This design aspect has recently been further improved to subnanometer precision in movement using additional piezo controls for translation (Kondo et al., 1994a). It is also worth noting that several designs for fully bakable UHV HRTEM stages have been proposed in which a side-entry mechanism is employed with a detachable tip that locates within the goniometer allowing the transfer rod to be withdrawn (Kondo et al., 1994b). 3.4 Energy Filters In many applications of HRTEM, energy filtering is of great importance, particularly in improving quantification and interpretability of images by removal of inelastically scattered electrons (Stobbs and Saxton, 1987; Krivanek et al., 1990; Boothroyd, 1998, 2000; see Reimer, 1995, for reviews). At this point we note that the energy filters outlined here also find widespread application as spectrometers for electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) and in energy filtered imaging at medium resolution (Reimer, 1995; Tsuno, 1999; Egerton, 1996). However, this section is restricted to briefly reviewing their use for imaging. Imaging filters are best differentiated by the nature and geometry of their constituent optical elements and can be classified as purely electric, purely magnetic, and combined electric/magnetic (Uhlemann and Rose, 1996). To separate electrons according to their energy loss dipole fields are required and hence all filters have a curved optic axis with the notable exception of the Wien filter (Tsuno, 1993). For HRTEM purely electric (see, for example, Henkelman and Ottensmeyer, 1979) and combined electric/magnetic filters have the disadvantage of being limited to operation at relatively low accelerating voltages due to difficulties associated with the large electric field strengths required at higher voltage. However, as discussed later, these have found recent alternative application as monochrometers in which the electrons have an energy of only a few electronvolts (Rose, 1990). Magnetic filters have been constructed as both straight vision (in-column) types (Rose and Plies, 1974; Tsuno et al., 1997) and in a
35
36 A.I. Kirkland et al.
postcolumn geometry, which can be retrofitted to conventional instruments (Krivanek et al., 1992). The former can be classified further as either Ω geometries in which the deflection angles of the sector magnets cancels to zero and α filters in which the sum of the deflection angles equals 2π (Lanio, 1986). For routine operation and ease of alignment of in-column filters simple filter geometries are required while any residual aberrations should not appreciably affect the quality of the final HRTEM image. This can be achieved through careful choice of suitable symmetries of the magnetic deflection field and of the paraxial rays about the midplane of the system by which second-order axial aberrations and distortions can be canceled making these designs suitable for energy-filtered HRTEM. Based on this principle several commercial filters have been successfully produced (Rose and Plies, 1974; Tsuno et al., 1997). A fully corrected Ω geometry filter has also been proposed and constructed, initially using curved polepiece faces (Rose and Pejas, 1979) but subsequently revised to use straight polepiece faces and additional sextupole elements (Lanio et al., 1986). Finally we note that a corrected in column filter, with an extremely high dispersion achieved through the use of inhomogeneous magnetic fields created by conical magnets has also been described (Uhlemann and Rose, 1994). The alternative postcolumn filter geometry based on a single 90° sector magnet with curved polepiece faces has also been produced commercially and has found found widespread application (Krivanek et al., 1992). For energy-filtered HRTEM this design has the disadvantage of nonzero second-order distortions and chromatic aberration of magnification. These filters therefore operate at a large intermediate magnification so that these do not appreciably affect the image quality. However, due to the large magnifications required the third-order distortions and higher order chromatic aberrations limit the number of clearly resolved object elements. For these reasons a sequence of quadrupole and hexapole elements is incorporated after the sector magnet and alignment to third order is carried out by automated computer control. A significant practical advantage, however, of this geometry is that it can be retrofitted to conventional microscopes. Finally, we also note that investigations into the contribution of phonon scattering to the Stobbs factor (Boothroyd, 2000) in off-axis electron holograms provide compelling evidence for intrinsic elastic energy filtering (within experimental limitations) in this mode. This issue has been rigorously treated (van Dyck et al., 2000) in a quantum mechanical framework using a global Hamiltonian describing the electron, source and object to prove that although inelastic interference is possible it is too small to be observed. Hence, electron holography provides de facto perfect energy filtering, which therefore suggests that electron-optical filters may be redundant in this geometry. 3.5 Detectors Image recording should not impair the overall resolution of HRTEM data. However, unless the detector used is carefully optimized with respect to microscope operating conditions this component can have a negative effect on overall performance. Historically, photographic
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
plates using one of several possible specialist emulsions were universally used for image recording (Kuo and Glaeser, 1975; Zeitler, 1992) but these have now been largely superseded by digital detectors of which slow-scan charge-coupled device (CCD) cameras are most commonly used (Spence and Zuo, 1988). Particular benefits associated with these detectors (Zuo, 2000; Fan and Ellisman, 2000; de Ruijter, 1995; Spence and Zuo, 1988) are that the images are instantly available, quantitatively in digital form, and the camera response is practically linear over a large dynamic range. Their sensitivity is also far higher than that of most photographic emulsions, making single electron detection possible. Though limited early experiments using CCD chips as direct TEM electron detectors have been performed (Roberts et al., 1982), these were not viable due to the sensitivity of the gate insulator to radiation damage. For low energies (<10 keV), this damage can be avoided using back-thinned CCDs (Ravel and Reinheimer, 1991), but higher energy electrons penetrate through to the sensitive gate oxide on the front side. Moreover, a primary electron of energy E generates E/3.64 eV electronhole pairs in silicon (Fiebiger and Müuller, 1972) leading to saturation of the CCD well capacity after the detection of only a few electrons at typical energies used in HRTEM. For this reason indirect detection is employed in all cameras currently used for HRTEM by which the electrons impinge on a YAG single crystal19 or phosphor powder scintillator20 and the generated light is relayed to the CCD chip via a lens- or fiber optical coupling (Figure 1–15). Within this complex coupling, scattering of both the primary incident electrons and the emitted photons in the scintillator material occurs. These processes blur the image, attenuating its high spatial frequencies leading to relatively poor Modulation Transfer Functions (MTFs) (Meyer and Kirkland, 1998, 2000; Meyer et al., 2000b). Electron-sensitive imaging plates have also found application as an alternative digital recording media (Zuo, 2000; Zuo et al., 1996). These consist of a thin embedded layer (ca. 40 µm thick) of a photostimulable phosphor. Luminescence is activated postexposure by a scanning laser in a separate processing system that includes a photomultiplier to convert the output light into a digitized electronic signal. The exposed plate can be subsequently erased by exposure to a suitable light source. These systems provide excellent recording linearity over a wide dynamic range with a sensitivity about three times that of photographic emulsions, but which is voltage dependent. However, their performance also depends strongly on electron dose and drops rapidly at low dose levels. Hence, the most promising application of this technology is in recording quantitative diffraction information (Zuo, 2000). Very recent experiments by several groups (Faruqi et al., 1994, 2005a,b; Faruqi and Cattermole, 2005; Fan et al., 1998; Milazzo et al., 19
YAG: yttrium-aluminum-garnet Y3Al5O12, a transparent crystal that is made scintillating by doping with impurity atoms, usually europium (YAG:Eu) or cerium (YAG:Ce). 20 A wide range of materials is available for powder scintillators. Popular choices in CCD cameras include P22 (Y2O2S:Eu) and P43 (Gd2O2S:Tb).
37
38 A.I. Kirkland et al.
Figure 1–15. Schematic diagram of a CCD detector used for HRTEM. The incoming high-energy electrons are scattered and along their trajectory within the scintillator where they give rise to photon emission. Electrons that penetrate through the scintillator may be back-scattered into the scintillator from the fiber plate or a mechanical support layer. A lens- or fiber-optical coupling system conveys the generated light to the CCD chip where the photons generate electron-hole pairs. The electrons of these pairs are collected in pixelated potential wells. (Taken from Meyer et al., 2002.)
2005) suggest that detectors for HRTEM are on the verge of a revolution in which direct injection of beam electrons into solid-state devices may be achieved leading to substantial increases in both resolution and sensitivity. At the time of writing a number of pixellated CMOS-based devices have been fabricated (albeit with initially limited array sizes) including active pixel sensors (Milazzo et al., 2005) in which the readout electronics and amplification are integrated at each pixel. These have demonstrated direct electron imaging with performance characteristics exceeding indirect CCD devices in cryoelectron microscopy and diffraction from radiation-sensitive biological material (Faruqi et al., 1994, 2005a,b; Faruqi and Cattermole, 2005). 3.5.1 Detector Characterization All digital detectors can be characterized in terms of three key parameters that, in combination, describe their overall performance. These involve measurement of the gain, resolution, and detector quantum efficiency (DQE). The linearity and uniformity of the response may also be important, but in currently available CCD devices are generally extremely well controlled. Detector resolution is expressed through the MTF, which describes the spatial-frequency-dependent signal transfer, which is affected by both electron and photon scattering within the detection chain. This parameter can be evaluated by integration (over the scintillator area) of the ratio of the output to the input signal in reciprocal space (u, v), normalized to unity at zero spatial frequency (Meyer and Kirkland, 1998). More formally MTF(u, v) = 1 G ∫ gµ (u, v)dµ
(39)
where the Fourier transform of the light intensity (number of photons per unit area) collected at a particular position on the detector in its
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
focal plane is given by gˆµ (u, v), dµ defines the probability of a particular electron hitting the scintillator at this point, and G is the total gain, i.e., the average number of detectable CCD well electrons per primary electron given by G = ∫ gˆ µ (0 , 0 ) dµ
(40)
The inverse Fourier transform of this MTF is the point spread function (PSF) PSF ( x , y ) = 1 G ∫ gˆ µ ( x , y ) dµ
(41)
The DQE measures the statistical performance of radiation detectors (Hermann and Krahl, 1982) generally defined as the quotient of the squared signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) at the output and input of the detector [in general as a function of spatial frequency (de Ruijter, 1995)]. This can also be expressed in terms of experimentally accessible quantities as DQE (u, v ) =
pˆ (0 , 0 ) G 2 [ MTF (u, v )]2 V (u , v )
(42)
where pˆ(0, 0) is the total number of electrons recorded in each exposure, V (u, v) is the variance, (in units of “number of CCD well electrons squared”) and G is the gain defined previously. It should be noted that unless the dose is very low, in which case dose-independent noise sources such as readout noise become important, the observed variance V (u, v) is proportional to the electron dose and therefore the DQE is dose independent. The above expression can be conveniently rewritten through a simple rescaling of units into the digital numbers (DN) that are read out directly from the camera to give the expression DQE (u, v ) =
I DN GDN [ MTF (u, v )]2 VDN (u, v )
(43)
where GDN is the gain in digital numbers per incident electron, IDN = pˆ(0, 0)GDN is the total intensity in digital numbers, and VDN(u, v) is the variance in (DN)2. Experimentally these performance characteristics can be readily measured from a series of controlled exposures of a deterministic input signal (such as a knife edge) (Meyer et al., 2000b) for a range of experimental conditions (Figure 1–16). 3.6 Aberration Correctors One of the long standing goals in electron optics has been the correction of the positive spherical aberration that is present in all round lenses (Scherzer, 1949). The essential optical elements used in all correctors are nonround (multipole) lenses as originally proposed by Scherzer (1947).21 Subsequently designs for various correctors have 21
For a more detailed treatment of spherical aberration correctors see Chapter 10 by Hawkes in this volume.
39
40 A.I. Kirkland et al.
Figure 1–16. (a) MTFs measured for 1024 × 1024 and 2048 × 2048 CCD cameras. Solid line, 1024 × 1024; short dashed line, 2048 × 2048; long dashed line, 2048 × 2048 with 2 × 2 pixel binning. (b) DQEs corresponding to (a). In all cases plots extend from 0 spatial frequency to the spatial frequency at the corner of Fourier space. (Adapted from Meyer et al., 2002.)
been proposed (for reviews see Rose, 1990; Hawkes and Kasper, 1989). However, it is only relatively recently that these components have been developed to a level at which improvements to the highest performance uncorrected instruments can be made. For the most part this has been due to the extreme mechanical precision and electrical stability required in the corrector elements and the need for sophisticated computer control of the corrector alignment. However, in the 1990s significant improvements in resolution for both HRTEM (Haider et al., 1998a,b) and Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (STEM) (Krivanek et al., 1999) were demonstrated, although for the purpose of this section we will not consider the latter further. We also note that very recently proposals for correction of both spherical and chromatic aberration have also been detailed (Rose, 2005) based on a combination of electromagnetic and electrostatic multipole elements.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
Correctors for HRTEM are based on a pair of strong electromagnetic hexapole elements together with four additional lenses (Haider et al., 1995). Correction is achieved due to the fact that the primary, nonrotationally symmetric second-order aberrations of the first hexapole (a strong three-fold astigmatism) are exactly compensated by the second hexapole element. Because of their nonlinear diffraction power, the two hexapoles additionally induce a residual secondary, third-order spherical aberration that is rotationally symmetric (Beck, 1979) and proportional to the square of the hexapole strength. This aberration has a negative sign, thus canceling the positive spherical aberration of the objective lens. For HRTEM applications it is essential that the corrector is aplanatic to provide a sufficiently large field of view, which is achieved by matching the comafree plane of the objective lens to that of the corrector using a round transfer lens doublet. To reduce the azimuthal (anisotropic) component of the off-axial coma the current direction of the first transfer lens doublet is opposite to that in the objective lens. In addition to these primary optical elements commercial correctors (Haider et al., 1998a; Hutchison et al., 2005) contain a number of additional multipole elements for alignment and correction of any residual parasitic aberrations. The main difficulties associated with the practical operation of these complex electron optical components are the requirements for sophisticated computer control of the various elements and a systematic alignment procedure providing rapid, accurate measurement of the coefficients of the wave aberration function. In practice, this is achieved using measurements of the two-fold astigmatism, A1, and defocus, C1, from tableaus of diffractograms recorded at known beam tilts (see earlier). These measured values are subsequently used to calculate the aberrations present in the corrector and the appropriate currents to the optical elements are then applied under direct computer control. 3.6.1 Aberration-Corrected Imaging Conditions for HRTEM The optimization of imaging conditions for corrected instruments and the interpretation of the images obtained have also required renewed analysis. It is possible to identify three conditions for HRTEM imaging when spherical aberration is a variable parameter (Lentzen, 2004). If the spherical aberration of the objective lens is exactly corrected and the defocus is also set to zero, then the phase contrast transfer function equals 0 for all spatial frequencies up to the information limit set by partial coherence, while the amplitude contrast transfer function equals 1.22 Under these conditions HRTEM can be carried out under pure amplitude contrast conditions in a mode that is not available in a standard uncorrected TEM (Lentzen, 2004). Alternatively, phase contrast HRTEM images can be obtained using several conditions in which the spherical aberration and defocus are balanced against either C 5 or the chromatic aberration coefficient, C c (Chang et al., 2003; Chang et al., 2006).
22 The above treatment ignores the effects of higher order aberrations such as C5, which also contribute to high resolution phase contrast.
41
42 A.I. Kirkland et al.
For the first of these conditions, in the presence of C5, restricting the phase shifts due to the wave aberration function to lie between 0 and π/2 gives optimum values for C1 and C3 as C1 = 1.56(C5λ2)1/3 C3 = −2.88(C25λ)1/3
(44)
with a corresponding point resolution, limited by C5, given by d = (C5λ5)1/6/1.47
(45)
Under circumstances in which C5 = 0 the choice of C1 reduces to the conventional Scherzer defocus (C1 = −(C3λ)1/2) (for finite positive C3) with a corresponding point resolution (as defined previously) of (C3 λ 3 )1/ 4 d= . 2 Matching the first zero of the phase contrast transfer function to the information limit of the instrument, determined by Cc, and again constraining the phase shifts due to the aberration function to lie between 0 and π/2, yields alternative optimum values of C1 = 1.7 π∆ C3 = −3.4
( π∆ )2
(46) λ ( π∆ )3 C5 = 1.3 2 λ where ∆ is the focal spread defined in a previous section. By analogy with the C5 limited condition when C5 is zero the above reduce to (O’Keefe, 2000; Chang et al., 2006) C1 = − π∆ (π∆ )2 (47) λ For either of these conditions when C5 is zero or has a negligible effect at the experimentally available resolution, the signs of both C3 and C1 can be inverted, and this has been shown to differentially affect the transfer of the linear and nonlinear components of the image intensity in images of complex oxides, providing higher contrast at the weakly scattering anion sites (Lentzen et al., 2002). C3 =
3.7 Monochromators As already discussed, one of the limiting factors in determining the information limit for HRTEM is the energy spread of the source.23 One possible route to reducing the energy spread is in the use of high brightness sources with intrinsically low energy spreads such as nanometer-sized cold field emitters (Morin and Fink, 1994; Purcell et al., 1995) or more ambitiously, ballistic emission sources (Borgonjen et al., 1997), photocathodes (Baum et al., 1995a,b), and metal ion sources (Purcell and Bihn, 2001). However, none of these has currently been 23
In addition to the benefits of a reduced energy spread for HRTEM there are also substantial benefits in EELS and related techniques where a lower energy spread improves the spectral energy resolution.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
manufactured with sufficient brightness and stability for routine use in HRTEM. For this reason monochromation of the electron beam produced from conventional Schottky or cold field emission sources using dedicated electron optical components provides an attractive alternative that has now been realized experimentally using several different designs operating at 120 kV and 200 kV (Mook and Kruit, 1999; Rose, 1999; Batson, 1986). The number of possible monochromator geometries that have been proposed and tested can broadly be divided into those with straight optical axes (typically Wien filters) (Mook and Kruit, 1999; Rose, 1987; Tsuno, 1999) and those with curved axes (typified by Ω geometries) (Rose, 1999; Kahl and Rose, 1998). The former require both electromagnetic and electrostatic elements to satisf y the Wien condition and to achieve the required energy dispersion, whereas the latter can be constructed from purely electromagnetic or electrostatic elements. Further classification of monochromators can be made by considering whether the monochromator and/or the energy selecting slit are operated at high potential or at ground and whether the monochromator is a single dispersion or double dispersion design. Finally, monochromators can be operated in either short field (deflector) mode, in which the monochromator field length is short compared to the distance to the beam focus, or in long field mode, in which the monochromator also acts as a focusing element. Within these various classes there are advantages and disadvantages associated with each configuration that have been extensively reviewed by Mook and Kruit (1999). For all of the above design possibilities the monochromator must provide sufficient current density for HRTEM at a given energy resolution determined by the energy selecting slit width. Monochromation inevitably reduces brightness as it filters electrons with unwanted energies and thereby reduces the current. However, the optical design of the monochromator itself also affects the brightness through the aberrations introduced by the filter and effects due to Coulomb interactions within the monochromator (Rose, 1999; Tsuno, 1999; Mook and Kruit, 1999).
4 Exit-Wave Reconstruction Although HRTEM now routinely achieves atomic resolution, the relationship of the image contrast to the underlying object structure for a single image is complex due to the nature of the scattering and imaging processes, as already outlined. A number of alternative approaches to inversion of the imaging process to recover the specimen exit-plane wavefunction, including holography, first proposed by Gabor (1948) and more recently realized at atomic resolution (Lichte, 1991; Orchowski et al., 1995; Lehmann et al., 1999; Tonamura, 1987, 1999). The particular approach described in this section combines the complementary information available from images taken under different conditions in indirect exit-wave reconstruction, which is directly related to the more general problem of coherent detection (Spence, 2002).
43
44 A.I. Kirkland et al.
As already discussed, the wave aberration function of the objective lens defines a passband of well transmitted spatial frequencies up to the instrument point resolution (at the Scherzer defocus) and beyond this limit the transfer function oscillates. At higher values of defocus this passband extends to higher frequencies, which suggests, in principle, that the addition of several images recorded at different defoci should enable the deconvolution of the effects of the objective lens transfer function and provide a wider passband extending to the axial information limit. This forms the basis of focal series restoration (reconstruction). A simpler alternative using only a single image has also been proposed (O’Keefe et al., 2001) but suffers from difficulties associated with the positions of the zero crossings in the transfer function that prevent deconvolution and from amplification of noise. 4.1 Theory The recorded image plane intensity can be written as24 I(x) = |ψi (x)|2 = 1 + ψi (x) + ψ*i (x) + |ψi (x)|2
(48)
For conditions in which the quadratic term is small then the Fourier transform of the image contrast (the fractional intensity deviation) is given as c(k) = ψi(k) + ψ*i(−k)
(49)
The Fourier transforms of the object wave (in the back focal plane of the objective lens) and image waves are related by the previously described phase shifting wave aberration function and thus ψi(k) = ψd(k)w(k)
(50)
w(k) = exp {−iW(k)}
(51)
where
Hence in terms of the object wave (in the back focal plane of the objective lens) the Fourier transform of the image contrast can be rewritten as c(k) = ψd(k)w(k) + ψ*(−k)w(−k) + n(k) d
(52)
in which the term n(k) represents the observational noise in the image. The essence of all reconstructions is now to find an estimate ψ′d(k) of ψd(k) given a set of observed image contrast Fourier transforms c(k) and measurements of the individual w(k). Given data from several differently aberrated images (obtainable from focal or tilt azimuth dataset geometries as described later), an
24 Throughout this section we use k and x as Fourier space and real-space variables rather than (u, v) and (x, y) as in Section 2.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
optimum solution for ψ′d(k) can be defined in various ways (Saxton, 1988). In particular, a Wiener filter applied to a series of images (Schiske, 1973) in the presence of noise gives an optimal estimate of the reconstructed wavefunction, expressed in the form of a weighted superposition of the individual transforms as ψ d′ (k) = ∑ i ri (k)ci (k) (53) in which the restoring filters, ri (k), depend on the wi (k) for the set of images as W (− k)w*i (k) − C * (k)wi (− k) ri (k) = W (− k)W (k) − C(k) 2 + ν(k ) (54) C(k) = ∑ i wi (k)wi (− k) W ( k ) = ∑ i wi ( k ) 2 From Eq. (55) above it can be seen that the effect of the restoring filters on a Fourier component transmitted in only a single image is simply to retain it after division by the corresponding transfer function and for Fourier components present in multiple images to average the estimates. For a Fourier component not transferred in any image the value of the filter tends to zero due to the inclusion of the noise-toobject power ratio, ν(k).25 In the final step of the overall reconstruction process the exit-plane wavefunction itself is obtained simply by inverse transformation. For completeness we also provide an alternative formulation of through focal series restoration by Spence (2002), which gives useful insight into the behavior of the various terms and clearly illustrates the general power of coherent detection methods. The image amplitude under the WPOA for a single image at a defocus, C1n is given as ψ i (x , C1n ) = 1 − iσφ p (− x )⋅ F{P(k)exp[iW (k)]} = φ p (x )⋅ F {P(k)exp[iW (k , C1n )]}
(55)
with an image intensity I (x , C1n ) = 1 + ψ i (x , C1n ) 2 = 1 + ψ i (x , C1n ) + ψ *i (x , C1n ) + h
(56)
where h are the higher order, nonlinear terms. We are now able to extract the wanted second term in Eq. (56) and discriminate against the conjugate and the higher order terms. To effect this we first multiply the transform of the intensity by the conjugate of the transfer function to deconvolve it and then sum over N images recorded at different defoci. This gives
25
This is the major advantage of the Wiener filter in preventing noise amplification where wi (k) is close to zero.
45
46 A.I. Kirkland et al.
S(k) = ∑ I (k , C1n )exp[−iW (k , C1n )] n
= δ(k) + φ p (k)∑ 1 + φ *p (− k) ∑ exp[−2iW (k , C1n )] n
n
+ ∑ H n (C1n )exp[−iW (k , C1n )]
(57)
n
where φ(k) = 1 − iσF {φp(x)} is the image we wish to restore. Equation (57) now clearly shows the power of coherent detection. The second term sums as N times the wanted image, whereas the unwanted third and fourth terms sum as N1/2 times their initial values. The final term behaves as a two-dimensional random walk. Overall the effects of the coefficients of the wave aberration function appear to have been eliminated and the only remaining resolution limiting effect is the function P(k).26 A further independent formulation of a linear restoration scheme similar to that described above, known as the parabaloid method, has also been reported (Op de Beeck et al., 1996; Thust et al., 1996a,b). This is based on a three-dimensional Fourier transform of a through focal series of images with the third variable conjugate to the defocus. The exit-wave sought is localized on a parabolic shell in this threedimensional space and can readily be separated from the conjugate eave and the nonlinear terms. This approach has the attraction of providing intuitive insight into how the information from a series of images is gathered to yield the complex exit-wave, although unlike the Wiener filter it is nonoptimal in its suppression of the conjugate wave and experimental noise (Saxton, 1994). The approaches for exit-plane wavefunction restoration described above assume linear imaging. An alternative method has also been developed for a more general case, including the nonlinear contributions to the image intensity. In the original implementation of this latter approach (Kirkland et al., 1985; Kirkland, 1984, 1988) the nonlinear image reconstruction is accommodated by matching the intensities calculated from the restored wave to the measured intensities of images in a focal series through minimization of a least-squares functional [the multiple input maximum a posteriori (MIMAP)]. The more recent improved maximum likelihood (MAL) description (Coene et al., 1992, 1996; Thust et al., 1996a) provides a computationally efficient and numerically optimized recursive solution and explicitly includes the coupling between the exit wave and its complex conjugate. An alternative imaging geometry for use in reconstruction uses a dataset recorded for several different illumination tilts (of the same magnitude but with different azimuths) (Kirkland et al., 1995, 1997) in a super resolution scheme also referred to as aperture synthesis. The basis of this approach relies on the fact that for an incident beam tilt
26 We note that the above describes a general approach of integration against a kernel to provide a stationary phase condition for a wanted signal and as such finds widespread application throughout physics.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
of a Bragg angle Θb the optic axis bisects the angle Θ = 2Θb between the incident beam and a first-order Bragg beam. For this geometry the two beams define the diameter of an achromatic circle (for positive C3) on which all even-order terms on the wave aberration function cancel. However, only one sector of the diffraction pattern contributes to each image and it is therefore necessary to record images at several (minimally four) different tilt azimuths. The method is also restricted to relatively thin samples due to the effects of parallax (Kirkland et al., 1997). The restoring filters required are of a form similar to those used for focal series reconstruction but with the transfer functions modified so as to be appropriate to tilted illumination (Saxton, 1988). The advantage of this geometry is in the improved flat information transfer, albeit in only one direction in a single image, with the disadvantage of poorer low-frequency transfer in the restored wave. In this way spatial frequencies up to twice the conventional Scherzer limit can be recovered from a dataset composed of four tilted illumination images recorded with orthogonal tilt directions (Kirkland et al., 1995). It is also worth noting that although the reconstructed wavefunction is free of artefacts due to the lens aberrations, there still exists a significant discrepancy between absolute values of the experimental and simulated exit wavefunctions (Meyer et al., 2000a). The cause of this discrepancy (frequently known as the Stobbs factor; Boothroyd, 1998, 2000), which is also observed in comparisons between conventional experimental HRTEM images and simulations, remains an active research area and recent holographic data (Lehmann and Lichte, 2002) suggest that phonon scattering may make a substantial contribution. 4.2 Experimental Geometries The most widely applied procedure for exit-wave reconstruction is, as already described, to record several (or many) images at different focus levels for which the positions of weak transfer are different. This provides almost continuous transfer in the recovered exit-wave extending to the ultimate limits set by the axial coherence envelopes (Figure 1–17). In practice the dataset for a focal series reconstruction is relatively easily obtained and typically some 20 or more images separated by close focal increments can conveniently be recorded on a CCD detector utilizing external computer control of the microscope. The subsequent processing involves image registration across the series (to account for specimen drift) and the determination of the individual imaging conditions (using one of the methods described earlier). The basic methodology for recording data for use in tilt series reconstruction is the same as that for focal series but particular attention must be paid to the image registration (due to the distorted form of cross-correlation functions involving tilted illumination images) and to the initial defocus condition. In general, for this geometry optimal transfer is achieved in the tilted illumination mode (with positive C3) when C1 = θ2 with C1 and θ being the defocus and illumination tilt measured in reduced units of ( (C3 λ ) ) and (λ/C3)1/4, respectively (Hawkes, 1980) (Figure 1–17). With the development of aberration-
47
48 A.I. Kirkland et al.
Figure 1–17. A comparison of transfer functions. (a) Conventional phase contrast transfer function (PCTF) for a single Scherzer defocus image. (b) Effective wave transfer function (WTF) for a 21-member focal series with a defocus step between images of 5 nm. (c) Effective wave transfer function for a 6 member tilt azimuth series with a tilt of 7.7 mrad. (d) Two-dimensional representation of the effective wave transfer function in (b). (e) Two-dimensional representation of the effective wave transfer function in (c). In all cases electron optical parameters appropriate to a 300-kV FEGTEM were used (300 kV, Cs = 0.57 nm, focal spread = 4 nm, beam divergence = 0.1 mrad). (a) Scaled −1 to 1; (b and c) scaled 0 to 1; (d and e) scaled 0 to 1 (black to white).
corrected instruments, this method is further enhanced by the removal of these restrictions in the absence of C3. In practice a combined defocus/tilt geometry provides optimal transfer and has the additional benefit of providing the required data for the determination of the aberration coefficients (see earlier). 4.3 Exit-Wave Restoration of Complex Oxides To illustrate the benefits of exit-wave restoration over conventional HRTEM imaging we have chosen two examples of complex oxides. Figure 1–18a shows a structural model of Nb16W18O94 projected along
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
49
Figure 1–18. (a) Structural model of the complex oxide Nb16W18O94 projected along [001]. (b) Conventional axial HRTEM image recorded at the Scherzer defocus of a thin crystal. (c) Reconstructed modulus of the exit-plane wavefunction of Nb16W18O94 with the marked area enlarged (inset), which directly shows the cation positions (black) with improved resolution compared to the axial image. The line indicates a stacking fault with a shift of a third of a unit cell along [010]. (d) Reconstructed phase of the exit-plane wavefunction with the marked area enlarged (inset). The cation sites in the phase are recovered with positive (white) contrast and additional weak between the cation atomic columns which indicate the positions of the oxygen anions are also resolved. The reconstructed phase and modulus are shown at the same scale. (See color plate.)
50 A.I. Kirkland et al.
[001] together with an axial image recorded at the Scherzer defocus (Figure 1–18b) and the restored exit-plane wavefunction (Figures 1-18c and d) recovered to a resolution of ca. 0.11 nm. It is apparent that although the basic cation lattice can be determined from the axial image the restored modulus shows the positions of the cation columns in projection at substantially higher resolution. Moreover, the modulus remains directly interpretable to a greater specimen thickness than the axial image. The restored phase shows a more complex contrast changing rapidly with specimen thickness. In addition to the strong positive contrast (white, corresponding to a phase advance) located at the cation sites and corresponding directly to the positions of strong negative (black) contrast in the modulus there is additional weak contrast at positions between the cations at the anion sublattice sites. Our second example illustrates an experimental tilt azimuth series restoration of an inorganic perovskite with 0.1 nm information transfer. The basic perovskite structure is cubic with general formula ABO3 and can be considered as an array of corner-sharing BO6 octahedra where B is typically a small transition metal cation (Figure 1–19). The cuboctahedral interstices generated by this basic lattice are occupied by larger A cations, typically alkali earth or rare earth metals. Few
Figure 1–19. Simplified structural models of AnBnO3n+2 compounds represented by corner-sharing BO6 octahedra and isolated A cations. Octahedra and cations drawn with light gray shading are half a lattice plane below those with darker shading. (a) The basic perovskite ABO3. (b and c) The n = 5 structure A5B5O17 with layers five octahedra wide, projected in the [100] and [010] directions.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
51
Figure 1–20. (a) Enlarged region taken from the reconstructed modulus calculated from a tilt azimuth dataset of an Nd4SrTi5O17 crystal edge in the [010] projection showing a small difference in positions of the Nd(4) and Nd(5) cations at the interface between adjacent perovskite slabs. (b) Reconstructed phase of the same region as (a) showing details of the oxygen anion sublattice between the Ti sites. The experimental data were recorded using the tilt series geometry described in the text with a JEOL JEM-3000F FEGTEM, 300 kV, C3 = 0.57 mm with an injected tilt of 1.9 mrad. (See color plate.)
perovskites are cubic and most distort to a lower symmetry to stabilize the structure. The layered structure described here (of general formula AnBnO3n+2) is composed of slabs of perovskite sliced along the [110] plane with the two excess oxygen anions accommodated at the interface region between two slabs (Figure 1–19). These structures show similar distortions to bulk perovskites but with additional degrees of freedom at the interface. The restored exit-plane wavefunction for Nd5Ti5O17 in the [010] projection is shown in Figure 1–20. The restoration again shows improved resolution in both modulus and phase compared to the conventional axial image and an enhanced sensitivity to the weakly scattering oxygen sublattice in the restored phase. Comparison with the structural model shown in Figure 1–19 shows that the Ti are bridged by O anions and correspondingly in the restored phase, the Nd rows show distinct cations whereas the Ti rows also show weak contrast between the cation sites (Figure 1–20) corresponding to the anion positions. The reconstruction also reveals local distortions present in this material by which the Nd cations at the outside of the perovskite slabs are displaced by small amounts in alternate directions (Figure 1–20).
5 Image Simulation A key step in the process of obtaining quantitative structural information from HRTEM images is the calculation of image simulations based on defined structural models and imaging conditions for comparison with experimental images. As already discussed, simple models for
52 A.I. Kirkland et al.
electron scattering and imaging at high resolution suffer from limitations and in general, computationally tractable N-beam dynamic calculations are essential to this process. For this purpose, the multislice method is most commonly used to compute the electron wave at the exit-plane of a specimen with known atomic structure. This approach was first suggested by Cowley and Moodie (1957) and has found extensive use in HRTEM simulation (Goodman and Moodie, 1974). In particular, the availability of efficient Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) algorithms and the general increase in readily available computing power have made earlier constraints on its accuracy due to limitations in the number of slices or the number of diffracted beams immaterial. An alternative to the multislice method is the Bloch wave approach, first introduced by Bethe (1928) and described in detail, for instance, in Buseck et al. (1989). By analogy with the Bloch theorem in solid-state physics, the solution of the Schrödinger equation in a periodic crystal potential is written as a product of a plane wave and a function that has the same periodicity as the crystal. The latter function is then expanded into its Fourier components from which the Schrödinger equation reduces to a matrix equation in these Fourier coefficients. For simple crystals, relatively accurate solutions can be obtained using only a few of these Bloch waves, with the minimal case requiring only two (the two beam approximation). This approach has the advantage of providing valuable insight into the working of dynamic electron diffraction and explains phenomena such as thickness fringes. However, for complex crystals with large unit cells, the method becomes impractical, as a large number of beams has to be used in the calculation and the computation time for the matrix solution scales with N3, where N is the number of beams included. For this reason it has only rarely been applied to calculations of HRTEM images. Finally we note that for the majority of cases matching of experimental and simulated images is carried out purely visually with limited attempts to define quantitative figures of merit (FOM) describing the differences between experimental and simulated images (or restored exit wavefunctions). In part this is due to the large number of parameters involved in HRTEM simulations (including atomic coordinates and those describing imaging conditions) giving rise to a large multiparameter optimization problem with many local minima. However, a number of possible FOMs have been reported (Mobus et al., 1998; Tang et al., 1993, 1994; Saxton, 1997) based on comparisons in both image and Fourier space. 5.1 The Multislice Formalism The formal basis of the multislice method (for an extensive treatment see Kirkland, 1998) is the division of the specimen into a number of thin slices perpendicular to the direction of the incident beam. The effects of the specimen potential (transmission, in real space) and of Fresnel diffraction (propagation, in Fourier space) are than treated separately for each slice (Figure 1–21). It is a requirement that the individual slices used in the simulation must be thin enough to be weak
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
Figure 1–21. (a) Schematic diagram showing the real space transmission and fourier space propagation steps. (b) Flow chart illustrating the steps involved in a multislice simulation.
53
54 A.I. Kirkland et al.
phase objects and that they obey periodic boundary conditions perpendicular to the incident beam direction. The equations central to the multislice algorithm can be formally derived starting from the Schrödinger equation for the wavefunction ψf, of an electron in the electrostatic potential V (x, y, z) of the specimen: 2 − ∇ 2 − eV ( x , y , z ) ψ ( x , y , z ) = Eψ ( x , y , z ) f 2m f
(58)
where m is the relativistically corrected electron mass. For high-energy electrons, the motion is predominantly in the z direction. Hence, it is convenient to separate the full wavefunction, ψf, into a product of the solution of the free Schrödinger equation (with V ≡ 0), which is a plane wave propagating in the z direction, and a wavefunction ψ that represents the effects due to the specimen and varies much more slowly with z: ψf(x, y, z) = e2πkz ⋅ ψ(x, y, z)
(59)
where k = 1/λ is the inverse wavelength of the free electron. Substituting this into Eq. (58) and using E = h2k2/2m yields27 −
2 2 ∂2 ∂ 2meV ( x , y , z ) ∇ xy + 2 + 4 πk + ψ (x, y , z) = 0 2m ∂z ∂z 2
(60)
In an elastic scattering process away from the z direction, kx and ky are proportional to the scattering angle, while the change, ∆kz, is proportional to its square. For small scattering angles therefore the term |∂2ψ/∂z2|<<|∇2xyψ| and can be neglected in the paraxial approximation. What remains is a first-order differential equation in z ∂ψ ( x , y , z ) = [ A + B] ψ ( x , y , z ) ∂z
(61)
iλ 2 ∇ xy 4π
(62)
B = iσV (x, y, z)
(63)
with the operators A=
and the interaction parameter σ defined here as σ=
2πmeλ h2
(64)
This differential equation has the formal solution ψ ( x , y , z + ∆z ) = exp
z + ∆z
∫
[ A ( z ′ ) + B ( z ′ )] dz ′ ψ ( x , y , z )
z
(65)
When ∆z is small, this reduces to 27
It should be noted that k is defined here as 1/λ rather than 2π/λ and - is used in the expression for E. therefore h rather than h
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
iλ ψ ( x , y , z + ∆z ) = exp ∆z∇ 2xy + iσV∆z ( x , y , z ) ψ ( x , y , z ) 4 π
(66)
where V∆z is the projected specimen potential between z and z + ∆z: V∆z ( x , y , z ) =
z + ∆z
∫
V ( x , y , z ′ ) dz ′
(67)
z
The two operators in the exponent in Eq. (66) do not commute and therefore this function cannot be rewritten as a product of two exponential functions. However, as both operators are small (to the order of ∆z), the approximation e εA + εB = e εA e εB +
ε2 [B, A] +O (ε 3 ) = e εA e εB +O (ε 2 ) 2
(68)
can be used. This leaves the expression ψ ( x , y , z + ∆z ) = exp
( iλ4∆πz ∇ ) t (x, y, z) ψ (x, y, z) 2 xy
(69)
where t(x, y, z) is the transmission function for the specimen slice between z and z + ∆z: t(x, y, z) = exp[iσV∆z (x, y, z)]
(70)
The first operator can be further separated into components for x and y coordinates as exp
(
)
iλ∆z 2 ∂2 ∂2 ∇ xy = exp iα 2 exp iα 2 ∂x ∂y 4π
(71)
where α = λ∆z/4π. Considering the Fourier transform of the operator for the x direction applied to a function f(x): ∂2 ∂2 FT exp iα 2 f ( x ) = ∫ e −2 πkx exp iα 2 f ( x ) dx ∂x ∂x
(72)
=∑
(iα )n −2 πkx ( 2 n ) e f ( x )dx n! ∫
(73)
=∑
(iα )n (−2πk )2 n ∫ e −2 πkx f ( x)dx n!
(74)
2k 2α
= e−4iπ
FT[f(x)]
(75)
The above can be repeated for the y direction, finally yielding
(
)
iλ∆z 2 FT exp ∇ xy f ( x , y ) = exp [ −iπλ∆z ( k x2 + k y2 )] FT [ f ( x , y )] 4π
(76)
Using this result a single multislice step can be written as ψ(x, y, z + ∆z) = FT−1 {P(kx, ky)FT [t(x, y, z)ψ(x, y, z)]}
(77)
where the real-space transmission function, t(x, y, z), and the Fourier space propagation function, P(kx, ky), are given by
55
56 A.I. Kirkland et al.
t(x, y, z) = exp[iσV∆z (x, y, z)]
(78)
P(kx, ky) = exp[−iπλ∆z(k + k )] 2 x
2 y
(79)
It should be noted that the propagator has the same form as a wave aberration with a defocus of ∆z. The algorithm can be implemented very efficiently using FFTs and is particularly suitable for simulations of crystals, as only one unit cell has to be calculated and the periodic boundary conditions necessary for the Fourier transforms are automatically fulfilled. The density of sampling points in the unit cell determines the maximum spatial frequency in the Fourier transform and therefore the maximum number of diffracted beams included in the simulation. To avoid aliasing artifacts, it is also necessary to exclude all beams above a limit less than the Nyquist frequency in the propagation step (Kirkland, 1998). Although the multislice method provides an accurate and computationally tractable method for calculating HRTEM images the approximations made in the above derivation can, under certain conditions, limit the accuracy achieved. The number of beams included in the simulation is ultimately limited by the discrete sampling of the unit cell. Unlike the Bloch wave approach (Bethe, 1928), which gives self-consistent results even with a relatively small number of beams, the multislice method is reliable only when scattering into beams that are not included in the simulation is negligible. For any given simulation, this latter effect can be tested by verifying that the total intensity of the wavefunction does not decrease significantly as the wave propagates through the specimen. A decrease of 5% over the complete specimen is considered acceptable (Kirkland, 1998), but with modern computers it is possible to choose a sufficiently large number of beams to give a loss of intensity smaller than 0.1%. The paraxial approximation implies the neglect of the term iλ ∂ 2 ψ 4 π ∂z 2
(80)
A wave scattered by an angle, θ, toward the x direction can be written as ψ = e2πk[sin θx+(cos θ−1)z]
(81)
∂2 ψ 4 < π 2 k 2 θmax ∂z 2
(82)
with k = 1/λ, hence
Therefore, the error due to the paraxial approximation accumulated over a specimen thickness, t, can be estimated as ∆ψ <
λt ∂ 2 ψ 4 π ∂z 2
< max
πt 4 θmax 4λ
(83)
This term is vanishingly small for typical situations in HRTEM (e.g., E = 300 keV, λ = 2 pm, t = 20 nm, θmax = 20 mrad yields ∆ψ =
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy
0.16%) and therefore any error introduced by the paraxial approximation can generally be neglected. In principle, the error due to the paraxial approximation can be made arbitrarily small by making the slices sufficiently thin. However, as the potential of each atom is usually projected into the slice that contains the atom center, the accuracy is still limited when propagation over the range of the atomic potential has a noticeable effect. In this case, the atomic potential has to be divided across several slices. A useful feature of the exit-plane wavefunction calculated using the multislice method is that it depends qualitatively on the local potential of the crystal within a small cylinder whose axis is aligned to the incident beam direction with a diameter of typically a few nanometers for HRTEM imaging conditions. This suggests that HRTEM images of defects within a crystalline supercell can be simulated without perfectly smooth periodic continuation of the crystal potential at the supercell boundaries, as any abrupt changes in the potential will influence the exit-plane wavefunction only laterally, within the radius of the above cylinder. Thus, simulated images of large scale defects can be separately computed in a montage of “patches” and subsequently joined (Olsen and Spence, 1981) provided the small allowance described is made at the borders for discontinuities in the potential. Significantly this is not the case for simulations of dynamic electron diffraction patterns from equivalent structures and these cannot be calculated using this “patching” approach. Finally we observe that the derivation of the multislice algorithm described here is based on the Schrödinger equation, whereas a fully relativistic treatment would require the use of the Dirac equation. However, it has been shown (Fujiwara, 1962; Moodie et al., 2001) that provided relativistically correct expressions are used for both electron mass and wavelength, the expressions derived from the Schrödinger equation are an extremely good approximation of those derived from the Dirac equation.
6 Conclusions and Future Prospects The current status of HRTEM is such that instrumentation, theory, and computational tools are available for structural determination of a wide range of technologically important materials at atomic resolution. However, there still remain a number of significant experimental and theoretical challenges within this field. From a theoretical standpoint the majority of HRTEM images are still matched with simulations qualitatively, and even in instances in which quantitative metrics are applied a relatively poorly understood contrast mismatch remains (Boothroyd, 1998). There are also the continuing requirements for refinement and extension of current theoretical frameworks to accommodate the increasing resolution and precision in the data available. Similarly, almost all HRTEM data are recorded for a limited number of projections and therefore access to full threedimensional information is restricted.
57
58 A.I. Kirkland et al.
Instrumentation for HRTEM continues to develop and the relatively recent development of monochromators, aberration correctors, and energy filters represent substantial advances. However, there remains considerable scope for improvements in detectors and the correction of chromatic aberration has not been realized experimentally at the time of writing. Therefore, at present, the “grand challenge” is still the fully quantitative determination of an unknown structure from HRTEM data, quantitatively matched to accurate image simulations and with sufficient resolution to determine the coordinates of all atom species in three dimensions. References Ahmed, H. and Broers, A. (1972). J. Appl. Phys. 43, 2185–2192. Allen, C. and Dorignac, D. (1998). In Proceedings of the 14th ICEM (H.A.C. Benavidez and M.J. Yacaman, Eds.), Vol. 1 of Electron Microscopy 1998, 275–276 (IoP, Cancun). Allpress, J., Sanders, J. and Wadsley, A. (1969). Acta Crystallogr. B25, 1156–1164. Amelinckx, S., Milat, O. and van Tendeloo, G. (1993). Ultramicroscopy 51, 90–108. Baba, N., Oho, E. and Kanaya, K. (1987). Scanning Microsc. 1, 1507–1514. Batson, P. (1986). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 57, 43–48. Baum, A., Spicer, W., Pease, R., Costello, K. and Aebi, V. (1995a). SPIE 2522, 208–219. Baum, A., Spicer, W., Pease, R., Costello, K. and Aebi, V. (1995b). SPIE 2550, 189–196. Beck, V. (1979). Optik 53, 241–255. Bethe, H. (1928). Ann. Phys. 87, 55–129. Boothroyd, C. (1998). J. Microsc. 190, 99–108. Boothroyd, C. (2000). Ultramicroscopy 83, 159–168. Borgonjen, E., van Bakel, G., Hagen, C. and Kruit, P. (1997). Appl. Surf. Sci. 111, 165–169. Born, M. and Wolf, E. (1999). Principles of Optics, 7th ed. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Bourret, A., Rouvière, J. and Penisson, J. (1988). Acta Crystallogr. A44, 838–847. Bracewell, R. (1965). The Fourier Transform and Its Applications (McGraw-Hill, New York). Burge, R. (1973). J. Microsc. 98, 251–285. Busch, H. (1926). Arch. Electrotech. 18, 583–594. Buseck, P., Cowley, J. and Eyring, L. (1989). High ResolutionTransmission Electron Microscopy and Related Techniques (Oxford University Press, Oxford). Chand, G. (1997). Aberration Determination and Compensation in High Resolution Electron Microscopy. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cambridge. *Chang, L.Y. (2004). PhD thesis, Cambridge University. Reference to Figure 1–13. *Chang, L.Y., Chen, F.R., Kai, J.J. and Kirkland, A.I. (2000). Proc. 12th European Congress on Electron Microscopy 3, 89–90. *Chang, L.Y., Chen, F.R., Kai, J.J. and Kirkland, A.I. (2003). J. Elec. Microsc. 52, 359–364. Chang, L., Meyer, R. and Kirkland, A. (2005). Ultramicroscopy 104, 271–280. *Chang, L.Y., Kirkland, A.I. and Titchmarsh, J. (2006). Ultramicroscopy 106, 301–306. Chen, J. and van Dyck, D. (1997). Ultramicroscopy 70, 29–44.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy Coene, W. and van Dyck, D. (1984a). Ultramicroscopy 15, 41–50. Coene, W. and van Dyck, D. (1984b). Ultramicroscopy 15, 287–300. Coene, W., Janssen, G., Op de Beeck, M. and van Dyck, D. (1992). Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 3743–3746. Coene, W., Thust, A., Op de Beeck, M. and van Dyck, D. (1996). Ultramicroscopy 64, 109–135. Cosslett, V., Camps, R., Saxton, O., Smith, D., Nixon, W., Ahmed, H., Catto, J., Cleaver, J., Smith, K., Timbs, A., Turner, P. and Ross, P. (1979). Nature 281, 49–51. Cowley, J. (1959a). Acta Crystallogr. 12, 367–375. Cowley, J. (1959b). Acta Crystallogr. 12, 353–359. Cowley, J. (1959c). Acta Crystallogr. 12, 360–367. Cowley, J. (1975). Diffraction Physics (North Holland, Amsterdam). Cowley, J. and Iijima, S. (1972). Z. Naturforsch A27, 445–451. Cowley, J. and Moodie, A. (1957). Acta Crystallogr. 10, 609–619. Cowley, J. and Moodie, A. (1962). J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 17 (Suppl B. II), 86–91. Cowley, J. and Pogany, A. (1968). Acta Crystallogr. A24, 109–116. Crewe, A. (1971). In Electron Microscopy in Materials Science (U. Valdre, Ed.), 162–207 (Academic Press, New York). de Ruijter, W. (1995). Micron 26, 247–275. Egerton, R. (Ed.) (1996). Electron Energy-Loss Spectroscopy in the Electron Microscope, 2nd ed. (Plenum, New York). Emile, P., Asselbergs, S., Brock, J., de Jong, M. and Otten, M. (1993). In Institute of Physics Conference Series, EMAG 95 (A. Craven, Ed.), Vol. 138, 503–506. Institute of Physics, (London). Ernst, F. and Rühle, M. (Eds.) (2003). High Resolution Imaging and Spectrometry of Materials (Springer, Berlin). Fan, G. and Ellisman, M. (2000). J. Microsc. 200, 1–13. Fan, G. and Krivanek, O. (1990). In Electron Microscopy 1990 (L. Peachey and D. Williams, Eds.), Vol. 1, 532–533 (San Francisco Press, Seattle). Fan, G., Datte, P., Beuville, E., Beche, J., Millaud, J., Downing, K., Burkard, F., Ellisman, M. and Xuong, N. (1998). Ultramicroscopy 70, 107–113. Faruqi, A. and Cattermole, D. (2005). Nucl. Instrum. Methods A549, 192–198. Faruqi, A., Cattermole, D., Henderson, R., Mikulec, B. and Raeburn, C. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 94, 263–276. Faruqi, A., Henderson, R., Pryddetch, M., Allport, P. and Evans, A. (2005a). Nucl. Instrum. Methods A546, 170–175. Faruqi, A., Henderson, R. and Tlustos, L. (2005b). Nucl. Instrum. Methods A546, 160–163. Fiebiger, J. and Müller R. (1972). J. Appl. Phys. 43, 3202–3207. Fowler, R. and Nordheim, L. (1928). Proc. R. Soc. London A 119, 173–181. Frank, J. (1973). Optik 38, 519–536. Fujita, H. (1986). History of Electron Microscopes (Komiyama Printing Co., Tokyo). Fujiwara, K. (1962). J. Phys. Soc. Jpn 17(Supplement B2), 118–123. Gabor, D. (1948). Nature 161, 777–778. Glaser, W. (1952). Grundlagen der Elektronenoptik (Springer, Berlin). Glaser, W. (Ed.) (1956). In Handbuch der Physik (S. Flügge, Ed.). Vol. 33, 123–395 (Springer, Berlin). Goodman, P. and Moodie, A.F. (1974). Acta Crystallogr. A30, 280–290. Grivet, P. (Ed.) (1965). Electron Optics (Pergamon, London). Gronsky, R. and Thomas, G. (1983). In Proceedings of the 41st Annual Meeting of the Electron Microscopy Society of America (G. Bailey, Ed.) (San Francisco Press, San Francisco, CA). Gutekunst, G., Mayer, J. and Rühle, M. (1994). Scripta. Metall. 31, 1097–1102.
59
60 A.I. Kirkland et al. Haguenau, F., Hawkes, P., Hutchison, J., Satiat-Jeunemaître, B., Simon, G. and Williams, D. (2003). Microsc. Microanal. 9, 96–138. Haider, M., Braunshausen, G. and Schwan, E. (1995). Optik 99, 167–179. Haider, M., Rose, H., Uhlemann, S., Kabius, B. and Urban, K. (1998a). Nature 392, 768–769. Haider, M., Rose, H., Uhlemann, S., Kabius, B. and Urban, K. (1998b). J. Electron Microsc. 47, 395–405. Haider, M., Rose, H., Uhlemann, S., Schwan, E., Kabius, B. and Urban, K. (1998c). Ultramicroscopy 75, 53–60. Hall, C. (1966). Introduction to Electron Microscopy (McGraw-Hill, New York). Hanßen, K. (1971). Adv. Opt. Electron Microsc. 4, 1–84. Hanßen, K. and Trepte, L. (1971). Optik 33, 166–181. Hawkes, P. (1972). Electron Optics and Electron Microscopy (Taylor and Francis, London). Hawkes, P. (1978). Adv. Opt. Electron Microsc. 7, 101–184. Hawkes, P. (1980). Ultramicroscopy 5, 67–70. Hawkes, P. (Ed.) (1982). Magnetic Electron Lenses (Springer, Berlin). Hawkes, P. (1985). Adv. Electron. Electron Phys. 16(Supplement). Hawkes, P. and Kasper, E. (1989). Principles of Electron Optics: Basic Geoemtrical Optics (Academic Press, London). Hawkes, P. and Kasper, E. (1996). Principles of Electron Optics: Wave Optics (Academic Press, London). Henderson, R. (1995). Q. Rev. Biophys. 28, 171–193. Henkelman, R. and Ottensmeyer, F. (1979). J. Microsc. 102, 79–95. Hermann, K. and Krahl, D. (1982). J. Microsc. 127, 17–29. Hirabayashi, M., Hiraga, K. and Shindo, D. (1982). Ultramicroscopy 9, 197–202. Hirsch, P., Howie, A., Nicholson, R., Pashley, D. and Whelan, M. (1965). Electron Microscopy of Thin Crystals (Butterworths, London). Honda, T., Tomita, T., Kaneyama, T. and Ishida, Y. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 54, 132–144. Hopkins, H. (1951). Proc. Roy. Soc. A208, 263–277. Hopkins, H. (1953). Proc. Roy. Soc. A217, 408–432. Hutchison, J., Honda, T. and Boyes, E. (1986). JEOL News E24, 9–13. Hutchison, J., Titchmarsh, J., Cockayne, D., Doole, R., Hetherington, C., Kirkland, A. and Sawada, H. (2005). Ultramicroscopy 103, 7–15. Iijima, S. (1991). Nature 354, 56–58. Ishida, Y., Ichinose, H., Mori, M. and Hashimoto, M. (1983). Trans. Jpn. Inst. Metals 24, 349–359. Ishizuka, K. (1980). Ultramicroscopy 5, 55–65. Jap, B. and Glaeser, R. (1978). Acta Crystallogr. A34, 94–102. Kahl, F. and Rose, H. (1998). In Electron Microscopy 1998, Vol. 1, 71–72 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Kirkland, E. (1984). Ultramicroscopy 15, 151–172. Kirkland, E. (1988). In Image and Signal Processing in Electron Microscopy, Proceedings of the 6th Pfefferkorn Conference, Niagara (P. Hawkes, F. Ottensmeyer, O. Saxton and A. Rosenfeld, Eds.), 139 (Scanning Microscopy International, Chicago). Kirkland, E. (1998). Advanced Computing in Electron Microscopy (Plenum, New York). Kirkland, E., Siegel, B., Uyeda, N. and Fujiyoshi, Y. (1985). Ultramicroscopy 17, 87–103. Kirkland, A., Saxton, O., Chau, K-L., Tsuno, K. and Kawasaki, M. (1995). Ultramicroscopy 57, 355–374. Kirkland, A., Saxton, O. and Chand, G. (1997). J. Electron Microsc. 1, 11–22.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy Knoll, M. and Ruska, E. (1932a). Z. Phys. 78, 318–339. Knoll, M. and Ruska, E. (1932b). Ann. Phys. 12, 607–640. Knoll, M. and Ruska, E. (1932c). Ann. Phys. 12, 641–661. Koehler, J. (Ed.) (1973). Biological Electron Microscopy Advanced Techniques I (Springer, Berlin). Koehler, J. (Ed.) (1978). Biological Electron Microscopy Advanced Techniques II (Springer, Berlin). Koehler, J. (Ed.) (1986). Biological Electron Microscopy Advanced Techniques III (Springer, Berlin). Komoda, T. (1966). Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 5, 603–607. Kondo, Y., Hosokawa, F., Okhura, M., Hamochi, M., Nakagawa, A., Kirkland, A. and Honda, T. (1994a). In Electron Microscopy 1994, (B. Jouffrey and C. Colliex, Eds.), Vol. 1, 275–276 (Les Editions de Physique, Les Ulis, France). Kondo, Y., Kobayashi, H., Kasai, T., Nunome, H., Kirkland, A. and Honda, T. (1994b). In Electron Microscopy 1994 (B. Jouffrey and C. Colliex, Eds.), Vol. 1, 269–270 (Les Editions de Physique, Les Ulis, France). Koster, A. (1989). Ultramicroscopy 31, 473–474. Koster, A. and de Ruijter, W. (1992). Ultramicroscopy 40, 89–107. Koster, A., van den Bos, A. and van der Mast, K. (1987). Ultramicroscopy 21, 209–221. Koster, A., de Ruijter, W., van den Bos, A. and van der Mast, K. (1989). Ultramicroscopy 27, 251–272. Krakow, W. (1990). J. Mater. Res. 5, 2658–2662. Krakow, W., Smith, D. and Hobbs, L. (Eds.) (1984). Electron Microscopy of Materials (North Holland, Amsterdam). Krivanek, O. (1976). Optik 45, 97–101. Krivanek, O. and Leber, M. (1994). In Proceedings of the 13th ICEM (B. Jouffrey and C. Coliex, Eds.), Vol. 1 of Electron Microscopy 1994, 157–158. (les Editions de Physique, Paris). Krivanek, O., Ahn, C. and Wood, G. (1990). Ultramicroscopy 33, 177–185. Krivanek, O., Gubbens, A., Dellby, N. and Meyer, C. (1992). Microsc. Microanal. Microstruct. 3, 187–199. Krivanek, O., Delby, N. and Lupini, A. (1999). Ultramicroscopy 78, 1–11. Kuglin, C. and Hines, D. (1975). Proc. IEEE Int. Conf. Cybernet. Soc. 163–165. Kuo, I. and Glaeser, R. (1975). Ultramicroscopy 1, 53–66. Lanio, S. (1986). Optik 73, 99–107. Lanio, S., Rose, H. and Krahl, D. (1986). Optik 73, 56–68. Lehmann, M. and Lichte, H. (2002). Microsc. Microanal. 8, 447–466. Lehmann, M., Lichte, H., Geiger, D., Lang, G. and Schweda, E. (1999). Materials Character. 42, 249–263. Lentzen, M. (2004). Ultramicroscopy 99, 211–220. Lentzen, M., Jahnen, B., Jia, C., Thust, A., Tillmann, K. and Urban, K. (2002). Ultramicroscopy 92, 233–242. Lichte, H. (1991). In Advances in Optical and Electron Microscopy, Vol. 12, 25 (Academic Press, London). Liebmann, G. (1949). Proc. Phys. Soc. B62, 753–772. Lundberg, M., Hutchison, J. and Smith, D. (1989). J. Solid State Chem. 80, 178. Lynch, D., Moodie, A. and O’Keefe, M. (1975). Acta Crystallogr. A31, 300–307. Matsui, Y., Horiuchi, S., Bando, Y., Kitami, Y., Yokoyama, M. and Suehara, S. (1991). Ultramicroscopy 39, 8–20. Menter, J. (1956). Proc. Roy. Soc. A236, 119–135. Meyer, R. (2002). Quantitaive Automated Object Wave Restoration in High Resolution Electron Microscopy, Ph.D. Thesis. Dresden Technical University. Meyer, R. and Kirkland, A. (1998). Ultramicroscopy 75, 23–33. Meyer, R. and Kirkland, A. (2000). Microsc. Res. Technol. 49, 269–280. Meyer, R., Sloan, J., Dunin-Borkowski, R., Kirkland, A., Novotny, M., Bailey, S., Hutchison, J. and Green, M. (2000a). Science 289, 1324–1326.
61
62 A.I. Kirkland et al. Meyer, R., Kirkland, A., Dunin-Borkowski, R. and Hutchison, J. (2000b). Ultramicroscopy 85, 9–13. Meyer, R., Kirkland, A. and Saxton, O. (2002). Ultramicroscopy 92, 89–109. Meyer, R., Kirkland, A. and Saxton, O. (2004). Ultramicroscopy 99, 115–123. Milazzo, A., Leblanc, P., Duttweiler, F., Jin, L., Bouwer, J., Peltier, S., Ellisman, M., Bieser, F., Matis, H., Wieman, H., Denes, P., Kleinfelder, S. and Xuong, N. (2005). Ultramicroscopy 104, 152–159. Mobus, G., Schweinfest, R., Gemming, T., Wagner, T. and Rühle, M. (1998). J. Microsc. 190, 109–130. Moodie, A., Cowley, J. and Goodman, P. (2001). In International Tables of Crystallography, Vol. B: Reciprocal Space, 2nd ed. (U. Shmueli, Ed.), (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht). Mook, H. and Kruit, P. (1999). Ultramicroscopy 78, 43–51. Morin, R. and Fink, H. (1994). Appl. Phys. Lett. 65, 2362–2364. Mulvey, T. and Wallington, M. (1973). Rep. Prog. Phys. 36, 347–421. Munro, E. (1973). In Image Processing and Computer Aided Design in Electron Optics (P. Hawkes, Ed.), 284 (Academic Press, London). O’Keefe, M. (1992). Ultramicroscopy 47, 282–297. O’Keefe, M. (2000). In Proceedings Microscopy and Microanalysis 2000 (Cambridge, Philadelphia). O’Keefe, M. and Pitt, A. (1980). In Proceedings of the Seventh European Conference on Electron Microscopy (P. Brederoo and G. Boom, Eds.), 122–123 (The Hague). *O’Keefe, M.A. and Sanders, J.V. (1973). Acta Crystallogr. A29, 381. Reference to PCD approximation. O’Keefe, M., Hetherington, C., Wang, Y., Nelson, E., Turner, J., Kisielowski, C., Malm, O., Mueller, R., Ringnalda, J., Pan, M. and Thust, A. (2001). Ultramicroscopy 89, 215–241. Olsen, A. and Spence, J. (1981). Phil. Mag. A43, 945–965. Op de Beeck, M., van Dyck, D. and Coene, W. (1996). Ultramicroscopy 64, 167–183. Orchowski, A., Rau, W. and Lichte, H. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 399–402. Orloff, J. (Ed.) (1997). Handbook of Charged Particle Optics. (CRC Press, New York). Otten, M. and Coene, W. (1993). Ultramicroscopy 48, 77–91. Pan, M. (1998). In Proceedings of the 14th ICEM (H.A.C. Benavidez and M.J. Yacaman, Eds.), Vol. 1 of Electron Microscopy 1998, 263–264 (IoP, Cancun). Penisson, J., Nowicki, T. and Biscondi, M. (1988). Phil. Mag. A58, 947–956. Phillip, F., Hoschen, R., Osaki, M., Möbus, G. and Rühle, M. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 56, 1–10. Purcell, S. and Bihn, V. (2001). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B19, 79–86. Purcell, S., Binh, V. and Garcia, N. (1995). Appl. Phys. Lett. 67, 436–438. Ravel, M. and Reinheimer, A.L. (1991). SPIE 1447, 109–122. Reimer, L. (1984). Transmission Electron Microscopy (Springer, Berlin). Reimer, L. (Ed.) (1995). Energy Filtering Transmission Electron Microscopy (Springer, Berlin). Reimer, L. (1997). Transmission Electron Microscopy: Physics of Image Formation and Microanalysis, 4th ed. (Springer, Berlin). Roberts, P., Chapman, J. and Macleod, A. (1982). Ultramicroscopy 8, 385–396. Rose, H. (1981). Nucl. Instrum. Methods 187, 187–199. Rose, H. (1987). Optik 77, 26–34. Rose, H. (1990). Optik 85, 19–24. Rose, H. (1999). Ultramicroscopy 78, 13–25. Rose, H. (2005). Ultramicroscopy 103, 1–6. Rose, H. and Pejas, W. (1979). Optik 54, 235–250. Rose, H. and Plies, E. (1974). Optik 40, 336–341.
Chapter 1 Atomic Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy Ruska, E. (1934). Z. Phys. 87, 580–602. Saxton, O. (1988). In Image and Signal Processing in Electron Microscopy, Proceedings of the 6th Pfefferkorn Conference, Niagara (P. Hawkes, F. Ottensmeyer, O. Saxton and A. Rosenfeld, Eds.), 213 (Scanning Microscopy International, Chicago). Saxton, O. (1994). J. Microsc. 174, 61–68. Saxton, O. (1995). J. Microsc. 179, 201–213. Saxton, O. (1997). J. Microsc. 190, 52–60. Saxton, O. (2000). Ultramicroscopy 81, 41–45. Saxton, O., Smith, D.J. and Erasmus, S. (1983). J. Microsc. 130, 187–201. Scherzer, O. (1947). Optik 2, 114–132. Scherzer, O. (1949). J. Appl. Phys. 20, 20–29. Schiske, P. (1973). In Image Processing and Computer Aided Design in Electron Optics (P. Hawkes, Ed.), 82 (Academic Press, London). Self, P., O’Keefe, M., Buseck, P. and Spargo, A. (1983). Ultramicroscopy 11, 35–52. Septier, A. (Ed.) (1967). Focusing of Charged Particles (Academic Press, New York). Shindo, D. and Hiraga, K. (1998). High Resolution Electron Microscopy for Materials Science (Springer, Tokyo). Smith, D. (1997). Rep. Progr. Phys. 60, 1513–1580. Smith, D. and Lu, P. (1991). Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. Microsc. Semiconducting Mater. 117, 1–10. Smith, D., Glaisher, R. and Lu, P. (1989). Phil. Mag. Lett. 59, 69–75. Spence, J. (1999). Mater. Sci. Eng. R26, 1–49. Spence, J. (2002). High Resolution Electron Microscopy, 3rd ed. (Oxford University Press, Oxford). Spence, J. and Zuo, J. (1988). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 59, 2102–2105. Spence, J. and Zuo, J. (1992). Electron Microdiffraction (Plenum, New York). Stadelmann, P. (1987). Ultramicroscopy 21, 131–146. Stadelmann, P. (1991). Micron Microsc. Acta 22, 175–176. Stobbs, M. and Saxton, O. (1987). J. Microsc. 151, 171–184. Sturrock, P. (Ed.) (1955). Static and Dynamic Electron Optics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Tang, D., Kirkland, A. and Jefferson, D. (1993). Ultramicroscopy 48, 321–331. Tang, D., Kirkland, A. and Jefferson, D. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 53, 137–146. Thomas, G. (Ed.) (1962). Transmission Electron Microscopy of Metals (Wiley, New York). Thust, A., Coene, W., Op de Beeck, M. and van Dyck, D. (1996a). Ultramicroscopy 64, 211–230. Thust, A., Overwijk, M., Coene, W. and Lentzen, M. (1996b). Ultramicroscopy 64, 249–264. Tonamura, A. (1987). Rev. Mod. Phys. 59, 639–669. Tonamura, A. (Ed.) (1999). Electron Holography, 2nd ed. (Springer, Heidelberg). Tsuno, K. (1993). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 64, 659–666. Tsuno, K. (1999). J. Electron Microsc. 48, 801–820. Tsuno, K., Kaneyama, T., Honda, T., Tsuda, K., Terauchi, M. and Tanaka, M. (1997). J. Electron Microsc. 46, 357–368. Tuggle, D. and Swanson, L. (1985). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B3(1), 220–223. Turner, J., Valdre, U. and Fukami, A. (2005). J. Electron Microsc. Technol. 11, 258–271. Typke, D. and Dierksen, K. (1995). Optik 99, 155–166. Uhlemann, S. and Haider, M. (1998). Ultramicroscopy 72, 109–119.
63
64 A.I. Kirkland et al. Uhlemann, S. and Rose, H. (1994). Optik 96, 163–178. Uhlemann, S. and Rose, H. (1996). Ultramicroscopy 63, 161–167. Unwin, N. and Henderson, R. (1975). J. Mol. Biol. 94, 425–432. Urban, K., Kabius, B., Haider, M. and Rose, H. (1999). J. Electron Microsc. 48, 821–826. Uyeda, N., Kobayashi, E., Suito, Y., Harada, M. and Watanabe, J. (1972). J. Appl. Phys. 43, 5181–5189. Valdrè, U. (1979). J. Microsc. 117, 55–77. Valdrè, U. and Goringe, M. (1971). In Electron Microscopy in Materials Science (U. Valdre, Ed.), 208 (Academic Press, New York). van Dyck, D. (1983). J. Microsc. 132, 31–42. van Dyck, D. and Coene, W. (1984). Ultramicroscopy 15, 29–40. van Dyck, D. and Op de Beeck, M. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 55, 435–457. van Dyck, D., Lichte, H. and Spence, J. (2000). Ultramicroscopy 81, 187–194. van Tendeloo, G. (1998). J. Mater. Chem. 8, 797–808. Von Harrach, H. (1995). Ultramicroscopy 58, 1–5. Wade, R. and Frank, J. (1977). Optik 49, 81–92. Wang, Z. (2003). Adv. Mater. 15, 1497–1514. Watt, I. (1986). J. Phys. E. Sci. Instrum. 19, 668–678. Yao, N. and Wang, Z. (Eds.) (2005). Handbook of Microscopy for Nanotechnology (Springer, Berlin). Yoshioka, H. (1957). J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 12, 618–628. Zeitler, E. (1992). Ultramicroscopy 46, 405–416. Zemlin, F. (1979). Ultramicroscopy 4, 241–245. Zemlin, F., Weiss, K., Schiske, P., Kunath, W. and Herrmann, K. (1978). Ultramicroscopy 3, 49–60. Zuo, J. (2000). Microsc. Res. Technol. 49, 245–268. Zuo, J., McCartney, M. and Spence, J. (1996). Ultramicroscopy 66, 35–47.
*References added since the first printing.
2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy Peter D. Nellist
1. Introduction The scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) is a very powerful and highly versatile instrument capable of atomic resolution imaging and nanoscale analysis. The purpose of this chapter is to describe what STEM is, to highlight some of the types of experiments that can be performed using a STEM, to explain the principles behind the common modes of operation, to illustrate the features of typical STEM instrumentation, and to discuss some of the limiting factors in its performance. 1.1 The Principle of Operation of a STEM Figure 2–1 shows a schematic of the essential elements of a STEM. Most dedicated STEM instruments have their electron gun at the bottom of the column with the electrons traveling upward, which is how Figure 2–1 has been drawn. Figure 2–2 shows a photograph of a dedicated STEM instrument. More commonly available at the time of writing are combined conventional transmission electron microscope (CTEM)/STEM instruments. These can be operated in both the CTEM mode, where the imaging and magnification optics are placed after the sample to provide a highly magnified image of the exit wave from the sample, or the STEM mode as described in Section 8. Combined CTEM/STEM instruments are derived from conventional transmission electron microscopy (TEM) columns and have their gun at the top of the column. The pertinent optical elements are identical, and for a TEM/STEM Figure 2–1 should be regarded as being inverted. In many ways, the STEM is similar to the more widely known scanning electron microscope (SEM). An electron gun generates a beam of electrons that is focused by a series of lenses to form an image of the electron source at a specimen. The electron spot, or probe, can be scanned over the sample in a raster pattern by exciting scanning deflection coils, and scattered electrons are detected and their intensity 65
66
Peter D. Nellist
Figure 2–1. A schematic of the essential elements of a dedicated STEM instrument showing the most common detectors.
plotted as a function of probe position to form an image. In contrast to an SEM, where a bulk sample is typically used, the STEM requires a thinned, electron transparent specimen. The most commonly used STEM detectors are therefore placed after the sample, and detect transmitted electrons. Since a thin sample is used (typically less than 50 nm thick), the probe spreading within the sample is relatively small, and the spatial resolution of the STEM is predominantly controlled by the size of the probe. The crucial image forming optics are therefore those before the
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
sample that are forming the probe. Indeed the short-focal-length lens that finally focuses the beam to form the probe is referred to as the objective lens. Other condenser lenses are usually placed before the objective to control the degree to which the electron source is demagnified to form the probe. The electron lenses used are comparable to those in a conventional TEM, as are the electron accelerating voltages used (typically 100–300 kV). Probe sizes below the interatomic spacings in many materials are often possible, which is the great strength of STEM. Atomic resolution images can be readily formed, and the probe can then be stopped over a region of interest for spectroscopic analysis at or near atomic resolution. To form a small, intense probe we clearly need a correspondingly small, intense electron source. Indeed, the development of the cold field emission gun by Albert Crewe and co-workers nearly 40 years ago (Crewe et al., 1968a) was a necessary step in their subsequent construction of a complete STEM instrument (Crewe et al., 1968b). The quantity of interest for an electron gun is actually the source brightness, which will be discussed in Section 9. Field-emission guns are almost always
Figure 2–2. A photograph of a dedicated STEM instrument (VG Microscopes HB501). The gun is below the table level, with most of the electron optics above the table. At the top of the column can be seen a magnetic prism spectrometer for electron energy-loss spectroscopy.
67
68
Peter D. Nellist
used for STEM, either a cold field emission gun (CFEG) or a Schottky thermally assisted field emission gun. In the case of a CFEG, the source size is typically around 5 nm, so the probe-forming optics must be capable of demagnifying its image of the order of 100 times if an atomic sized probe is to be achieved. In a Schottky gun the demagnification must be even greater. The size of the image of the source is not the only probe size defining factor. Electron lenses suffer from inherent aberrations, in particular spherical and chromatic aberrations. The aberrations of the objective lens generally have greatest effect, and limit the width of the beam that may pass through the objective lens and still contribute to a small probe. Aberrated beams will not be focused at the correct probe position, and will lead to large diffuse illumination thereby destroying the spatial resolution. To prevent the higher angle aberrated beams from illuminating the sample, an objective aperture is used, and is typically a few tens of microns in diameter. The existence of an objective aperture in the column has two major implications: (1) As with any apertured optical system, there will be a diffraction limit to the smallest probe that can be formed, and this diffraction limit may well be larger than the source image. (2) The current in the probe will be limited by the amount of current that can pass through the aperture, and much current will be lost as it is blocked by the aperture. Because the STEM resembles the more commonly found SEM in many ways, several of the detectors that can be used are common to both instruments, such as the secondary electron (SE) detector and the energy-dispersive X-ray (EDX) spectrometer. The highest spatial resolution in STEM is obtained by using the transmitted electrons, however. Typical imaging detectors used are the bright-field (BF) detector and the annular dark-field (ADF) detector. Both these detectors sum the electron intensity over some region of the far field beyond the sample, and the result is displayed as a function of probe position to generate an image. The BF detector usually collects over a disc of scattering angles centered on the optic axis of the microscope, whereas the ADF detector collects over an annulus at higher angle where only scattered electrons are detected. The ADF imaging mode is important and unique to STEM in that it provides incoherent images of materials and has a strong sensitivity to atomic number allowing different elements to show up with different intensities in the image. Two further detectors are often used with the STEM probe stationary over a particular spot: (1) A Ronchigram camera can detect the intensity as a function of position in the far field, and shows a mixture of real-space and reciprocal-space information. It is mainly used for microscope diagnostics and alignment rather than for investigation of the sample. (2) A spectrometer can be used to disperse the transmitted electrons as a function of energy to form an electron energy-loss (EEL) spectrum. The EEL spectrum carries information about the composition of the material being illuminated by the probe, and even can show changes in local electron structure through, for example, bonding changes.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
1.2 Outline of Chapter The crucial aspect of STEM is the ability to focus a small probe at a thin sample, so we start by describing the form of the STEM probe and how it is computed. To understand how images are formed by the BF and ADF detectors, we need to know the electron intensity distribution in the far field after the probe has been scattered by the sample, which is the intensity that would be observed by a Ronchigram camera. This allows us to go on and consider BF and ADF imaging. Moving on to the analytical detectors, there is a section on the EEL spectrum that emphasizes some aspects of the spatial localization of the EEL spectrum signal. Other detectors, such as EDX and SE, that are also found on SEM instruments are briefly discussed. Having described STEM imaging and analysis we return to some instrumental aspects of STEM. We discuss typical column design, and then go on to analyze the requirements for the electron gun in STEM. Consideration of the effect of the finite gun brightness brings us to a discussion of the resolution limiting factors in STEM where we also consider spherical and chromatic aberrations. We finish that section with a discussion of spherical aberration correction in STEM, which is arguably having the greatest contribution in the field of STEM and is producing a revolution in performance. There have been several review articles previously published on STEM (for example, Cowley, 1976; Crewe, 1980; Brown, 1981). More recently, instrumental improvements have increased the emphasis on atomic resolution imaging and analysis. In this chapter we tend to focus on the principles and interpretation of STEM data when it is operating close to the limit of its spatial resolution.
2. The STEM Probe The crucial aspect of STEM performance is the ability to focus a subnanometer-sized probe at the sample, so we start by examining the form of that probe. We will initially assume that the electron source is infinitesimal, and that the beam is perfectly monochromatic. The effects of these assumptions not holding are explored in more detail in Section 10. The probe is formed by a strong imaging lens, known as the objective lens, that focuses the electron beam down to form the crossover that is the probe. Typical electron wavelengths in the STEM range from 3.7 pm (for 100-keV electrons) to 1.9 pm (for 300-keV electrons), so we might expect the probe size to be close to these values. Unfortunately, all circularly symmetric electron lenses suffer from inherent spherical aberration, as first shown by Scherzer (1936), and for most TEMs this has typically limited the resolution to about 100 times worse that the wavelength limit. The effect of spherical aberration from a geometric optics standpoint is shown in Figure 2–3. Spherical aberration causes an overfocusing of the higher angle rays of the convergent beam so that they are brought to a premature focus. The Gaussian focus plane is defined as the plane
69
70
Peter D. Nellist
Figure 2–3. A geometric optics view of the effect of spherical aberration. At the Gaussian focus plane the aberrated rays are displaced by a distance proportional to the cube of the ray angle, θ. The minimum beam diameter is at the disc of least confusion, defocused from the Gaussian focus plane by a distance, z.
at which the beams would have been focused had they been unaberrated. At the Gaussian plane, spherical aberration causes the beams to miss their correct point by a distance proportional to the cube of the angle of ray. Spherical aberration is therefore described as being a thirdorder aberration, and the constant of proportionality is given the symbol, CS, such that ∆x = CSθ 3
(2.1)
If the convergence angle of the electron beam is limited, then it can be seen in Figure 2–3 that the minimum beam waist, or disc of least confusion, is located closer to the lens than the Gaussian plane, and that the best resolution in a STEM is therefore achieved by weakening or underfocusing the lens relative to its nominal setting. Underfocusing the lens compensates to some degree for the overfocusing effects of spherical aberration. The above analysis is based upon geometric optics, and ignores the wave nature of the electron. A more quantitative approach is through wave optics. Because the lens aberrations affect the rays converging to form the probe as a function of angle, they can be incorporated as a phase shift in the front-focal plane (FFP) of the objective lens. The FFP and the specimen plane are related by a Fourier transform, as per the Abbe theory of imaging (Born and Wolf, 1980). A point in the frontfocal plane corresponds to one partial-plane wave within the ensemble of plane waves converging to form the probe. The deflection of the ray by a certain distance at the sample corresponds to a phase gradient in the FFP aberration function, and the phase shift due to aberration in the FFP is given by
(
)
χ(K) = πzλ|K|2 + 1_2πCSλ3|K|4
(2.2)
where we have also included the defocus of the lens, z, and K is a reciprocal space wavevector that is related to the angle of convergence at the sample by K = θλ
(2.3)
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
71
Thus the point K in the front-focal plane of the objective lens corresponds to a partial plane wave converging at an angle q at the sample. Once the peak-to-peak phase change of the rays converging to form the probe is greater than π/2, there will be an element of destructive interference, which we wish to avoid to form a sharp probe. Equation (2.2) is a quartic function, but we can use negative defocus (underfocus) to minimize the excursion of χ beyond a peak-to-peak change of π/2 over as wide a range of angles as possible (Figure 2–4). Beyond a critical angle, α, we use a beam-limiting aperture, known as the objective aperture, to prevent the more aberrated rays contributing to the probe. This aperture can be represented in the FFP by a twodimensional top-hat function, Hα (K). Now we can define a so-called aperture function, A(K), that represents the complex wavefunction in the FFP, A(K) = Hα (K)exp[iχ(K)]
(2.4)
Finally we can compute the wave function of the probe at the sample, or probe function, by taking the inverse Fourier transform of (2.4) to give P (R ) = ∫ A (K ) exp ( −i 2πK ⋅ R ) dK
(2.5)
To express the ability of the STEM to move the probe over the sample, we can include a shift term in (2.5) to give P (R − R 0 ) = ∫ A (K ) exp ( −i 2πK ⋅ R ) exp ( i 2πK ⋅ R 0 ) dK
(2.6)
Figure 2–4. The aberration phase shift, χ, in the front-focal, or aperture, plane plotted as a function of convergence angle, θ, for an accelerating voltage of 200 kV, CS = 1 mm and defocus z = −35.5 nm. The darker lines indicate the π/4 limits giving a peak-to-peak variation of π/2.
72
Peter D. Nellist
Moving the probe is therefore equivalent to adding a linear ramp to the phase variation across the FFP. The intensity of the probe function is found by taking the modulus squared of P(R), as is plotted for some typical values in Figure 2–5 Note that this so-called diffraction limited probe has subsidiary maxima sometimes known as Airy rings, as would be expected from the use of an aperture with a sharp cut-off. These subsidiary maxima can result in weak features observed in images (see Section 5.3) that are image artifacts and not related to the specimen structure. Let us examine the defocus and aperture size that should be used to provide an optimally small probe. Different ways of measuring probe size lead to various criteria for determining the optimal defocus (see, for example, Mory et al., 1987), but they all lead to similar results. We can again use the criterion of constraining the excursions of χ so that they are no more than π/4 away from zero. For a given objective lens spherical aberration, the optimal defocus is then given by z = −0.71λ1/2CS1/2
(2.7)
allowing an objective aperture with radius α = 1.3λ1/4 CS −1/4
(2.8)
to be used. A useful measure of STEM resolution is the full-width at half-maximum (FWHM) of the probe intensity profile. At optimum
Figure 2–5. The intensity of a diffraction-limited STEM probe for the illumination conditions given in Figure 2–4. An objective aperture of radius 9.3 mrad has been used.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
defocus and with the correct aperture size, the probe FWHM is given by d = 0.4λ3/4CS1/4
(2.9)
Note that the use of increased underfocusing can lead to a reduction in the probe FWHM at the expense of increased intensity in the subsidiary maxima, thereby reducing the useful current in the central maximum and leading to image artifacts. Along with other ways of quoting resolution, the FWHM must be interpreted carefully in terms of the image resolution.
3. Coherent CBED and Ronchigrams Most STEM detectors are located beyond the specimen and detect the electron intensity in the far field. To interpret STEM images, it is therefore first necessary to understand the intensity found in the far field. In combination CTEM/STEM instruments, the far-field intensity can be observed on the fluorescent screen at the bottom of the column when the instrument is operated in STEM mode with the lower column set to diffraction mode. In dedicated STEM instruments it is usual to have a camera consisting of a scintillator coupled to a CCD array in order to observe this intensity. In conventional electron diffraction, a sample is illuminated with a highly parallelized plane wave illumination. Electron scattering occurs, and the intensity observed in the far field is given by the modulus squared of the Fourier transform of the wavefunction, y (R), at the exit surface of the sample, I (K ) = Ψ (K ) 2 =
∫ ψ (R) exp [i2πK ⋅ R ] dR
2
(3.1)
The scattering wavevector in the detector plane, K, is related to the scattering angle, q, by K = θλ
(3.2)
A detailed discussion of electron diffraction is in general beyond the scope of this text, but the reader is referred to the many excellent textbooks on this subject (Hirsch et al., 1977; Cowley, 1990, 1992). In STEM, the sample is illuminated by a probe that is formed from a collapsing convergent spherical wavefront. The electron diffraction pattern is therefore broadened by the range of illumination angles in the convergent beam. In the case of a crystalline sample where one might expect to observe diffracted Bragg spots, in the STEM the spots are broadened into discs that may even overlap with their neighbors. Such a pattern is known as a convergent beam electron diffraction (CBED) or microdiffraction pattern because the convergent beam leads to a small illumination spot. See Spence and Zuo (1992) for a textbook covering aspects of microdiffraction and CBED and Cowley (1978) for a review of microdiffraction.
73
74
Peter D. Nellist
3.1 Ronchigrams of Crystalline Materials If the electron source image at the sample is much smaller than the diffraction limited probe, then the convergent beam forming the probe can be regarded as being coherent. A crystalline sample diffracts electrons into discrete Bragg beams, and in a STEM these are broadened to give discs. The high coherence of the beam means that if the discs overlap then interference features can be seen, such as the fringes in Figure 2–6. Such coherent CBED patterns are also known as coherent microdiffraction patterns or even nanodiffraction patterns. Their observation in the STEM has been described extensively by Cowley (1979b, 1981) and Cowley and Disko (1980) and reviewed by Spence (1992). To understand the form of these interference fringes, let us first consider a thin crystalline sample that can be described by a simple transmittance function, φ(R). The exit-surface wavefunction will be given by, y (R, R0) = P(R − R0)f (R)
(3.3)
Where R0 represents the probe position. Because Eq. 3.3 is a product of two functions, taking its Fourier transform [inserting into Eq. (3.1)] results in a convolution between the Fourier transform of P(R) and the Fourier transform of φ (R). Taking the Fourier transform of P(R), from Eq. (2.5) simply gives A(K). For a crystalline sample, the Fourier transform of φ (R) will consist of discrete Dirac δ-functions, which correspond to the Bragg spots, at values of K corresponding to the reciprocal lattice points. We can therefore write the far field wavefunction, Ψ(K), as a sum of multiple aperture functions centered on the Bragg spots, Ψ (K, R 0 ) = ∑ φg A (K − g ) exp [i 2π (K − g ) i R 0 ]
(3.4)
g
Figure 2–6. A coherent CBED pattern of Si<110>. Note the interference fringes in the overlap region that show that the probe is defocused from the sample.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
where φg is a complex quantity expressing the amplitude and phase of the g diffracted beam. Equation 3.4 is simply expressing the array of discs seen in Figure 2–6. To examine just the overlap region between the g and h diffracted beam, let us expand (3.4) using (2.4). Since we are just interested in the overlap region we will neglect to include the top-hat function, H(K), which denotes the physical objective aperture, leaving Ψ(K, R 0) = φ g exp[iχ(K − g) + i2π(K − g) · R 0 ] + φh exp[iχ(K − h) + i2π(K − h) · R0]
(3.5)
and we find the intensity by taking the modulus squared of Eq. (3.5), I(K, R0 ) = |φg| + |φh| + 2|φg||φh|cos[χ(K − g) − χ(K − h) + 2π(h − g) · R0 + ∠φg − ∠φh] 2
2
(3.6)
where ∠φg denotes the phase of the g diffracted beam. The cosine term shows that the disc overlap region contains interference features, and that these features depend on the lens aberrations, the position of the probe, and the phase difference between the two diffracted beams. If we assume that the only aberration present is defocus, then the terms including χ in (3.6) become χ(K − g) − χ(K − h) = πzλ [(K − g) − (K − h)2 ] = πzλ[2K · (h − g) + |g|2 + |h|2 ]
(3.7)
Because Eq. (3.7) is linear in K, a uniform set of fringes will be observed aligned perpendicular to the line joining the centers of the corresponding discs, as seen in Figure 2–6. For interference involving the central, or bright-field, disc we can set g = 0. The spacing of fringes in the microdiffraction pattern from interference between the BF disc and the h diffracted beam is (zλ|h|)−1, which is exactly what would be expected if the interference fringes were a shadow of the lattice planes corresponding to the h diffracted beam projected using a point source a distance z from the sample (Figure 2–7). When the objective aperture is removed, or if a very large aperture is used, then the intensity in the detector plane is referred to as a shadow image. If the sample is crystalline, then the shadow image consists of many crossed sets of fringes distorted by the lens aberrations. These crystalline shadow images are often referred to as Ronchigrams, deriving from the use of similar images in light optics for the measurement of lens aberrations (Ronchi, 1964). It is common in STEM for shadow images of both crystalline and nonperiodic samples to be referred to as Ronchigrams, however. The term containing R0 in the cosine argument in Eq. (3.6) shows that these fringes move as the probe is moved. Just as we might expect for a shadow, we need to move the probe one lattice spacing for the fringes all to move one fringe spacing in the Ronchigram. The idea of the Ronchigram as a shadow image is particularly useful when considering Ronchigrams of amorphous samples (see Section 3.2). Other aberrations, such as astigmatism or spherical aberration, will distort
75
76
Peter D. Nellist
Figure 2–7. If the probe is defocused from the sample plane, the probe crossover can be thought of as a point source located distant from the sample. In the geometric optics approximation, the STEM detector plane is a shadow image of the sample, with the shadow magnification given by the ratio of the probe-detector and probe-sample distances. If the sample is crystalline, then the shadow image is referred to as a Ronchigram.
the fringes so that they are no longer uniform. These distortions may be a useful method of measuring lens aberrations, though the analysis of shadow images for determining lens aberrations is more straightforward with nonperiodic samples (Dellby et al., 2001). The argument of the cosine in Eq. (3.6) also contains the phase difference between the g and h diffracted beams. By measuring the position of the fringes in all the available disc overlap regions, the phase difference between pairs of adjacent diffracted beams can be determined. It is then straightforward to solve for the phase of all the diffracted beams, thereby solving the phase problem in electron diffraction. Knowledge of the phase of the diffracted beams allows immediate inversion to the real-space exit-surface wavefunction. The spatial resolution of such an inversion is limited only by the largest angle diffracted beam that can give rise to observable fringes in the microdiffraction pattern, which will typically be much larger than the largest angle that can be passed through the objective lens (i.e., the radius of the BF disc in the microdiffraction pattern). The method was first suggested by Hoppe (1969a,b, 1982) who gave it the name ptychography. Using this approach, Nellist et al. (1995; Nellist and Rodenburg, 1998) were able to form an image of the atomic columns in Si〈110〉 in a STEM that conventionally would be unable to image them. Ptychography has not become a common method in STEM, mainly because the phasing method described above works only for thin samples. In thicker samples, for which dynamic diffraction theory is applicable, the phase of the diffracted beams can depend on the angle of the incident beam. The inherent phase of a diffracted beam may therefore vary across its disc in a microdiffraction pattern, making the simple phasing approach discussed above fail. Spence (1998a,b) has discussed in principle how a crystalline microdiffraction pattern data set can be inverted to the scattering potential for dynamically scattering samples, though as yet there has not been an experimental demonstration.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
3.2 Ronchigrams of Noncrystalline Materials When observing a noncrystalline sample in a Ronchigram, it is generally sufficient to assume that most of the scattering in the sample is at angles much smaller than the illumination convergence angles, and that we can broadly ignore the effects of diffraction. In this case only the BF disc is observable to any significance, but it contains an image of the sample that resembles a conventional bright-field image that would be observed in a conventional TEM at the defocus used to record the Ronchigram (Cowley, 1979b). The magnification of the image is again given by assuming that it is a shadow projected by a point source a distance z (the lens defocus) from the sample. As the defocus is reduced, the magnification increases (Figure 2–8) until it passes through an infinite magnification condition when the probe is focused exactly at the sample. For a quantitative discussion of how Eq. (3.6) reduces to a simple shadow image in the case of predominantly low angle scattering, see Cowley (1979b) and Lupini (2001). Aberrations of the objective lens will cause the distance from the sample to the crossover point of the illuminating beam to vary as a function of angle within the beam (Figure 2–3), and therefore the apparent magnification will vary within the Ronchigram. Where crossovers occur at the sample plane, infinite magnification regions will be seen. For example, positive spherical aberration combined with negative defocus can give rise to rings of infinite magnification (Figure 2–8). Two infinite magnification rings occur, one corresponding to infinite magnification in the radial direction and one in the azimuthal direction (Cowley, 1986; Lupini, 2001). Measuring the local magnification within a noncrystalline Ronchigram can readily be done by moving the probe a known distance and measuring the distance features move in the Ronchigram. The local magnifications from different places in the Ronchigram can then be inverted to values for aberration coefficients. This is the method invented by Krivanek et al. (Dellby et al., 2001) for autotuning of a STEM aberration corrector. Even for a non-aberration corrected machine, the Ronchigram of a nonperiodic sample is typically used to align the instrument (Cowley, 1979a). The coma free axis is immediately obvious in a Ronchigram, and astigmatism and focus can be carefully adjusted by observation of the magnification of the speckle contrast. Thicker crystalline samples also show Kikuchi lines in the shadow image, which allows the crystal to be carefully tilted and aligned with the microscope coma-free axis simply by observation of the Ronchigram. Finally it is worth noting that an electron shadow image for a weakly scattering sample is actually an in-line hologram (Lin and Cowley, 1986) as first proposed by Gabor (1948) for the correction of lens aberrations. The extension of resolution through the ptychographical reconstruction described in Section (3.1) can be extended to nonperiodic samples (Rodenburg and Bates, 1992), and has been demonstrated experimentally (Rodenburg et al., 1993).
77
78
Peter D. Nellist
a
b
Figure 2–8. Ronchigrams of Au nanoparticles on a thin C film recorded at different defocus values (a and b). Notice the change in image magnification, and the radial and azimuthal rings of infinite magnification.
4. Bright-Field Imaging and Reciprocity In Section 3 we examined the form of the electron intensity that would be observed in the detector plane of the instrument using an area detector, such as a CCD. In STEM imaging we detect only a single signal, not a two-dimensional array, and plot it as a function of the
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
probe position. An example of such an image is a STEM BF image, for which we detect some or all of the BF disc in the Ronchigram. Typically the detector will consist of a small scintillator, from which the light generated is directed into a photomultiplier tube. Since the BF detector will just be summing the intensity over a region of the Ronchigram, we can use the Ronchigram formulation in Section 3 to analyze the contrast in a BF image. 4.1 Lattice Imaging in BF STEM In Section 3.1 we saw that if the diffracted discs in the Ronchigram overlap then coherent interference can occur, and that the intensity in the disc overlap regions will depend on the probe position, R0. If the discs do not overlap, then there will be no interference and no dependence on probe position. In this latter case, no matter where we place a detector in the Ronchigram, there will be no change in intensity as the probe is moved and therefore no contrast in an image. The theory of STEM lattice imaging has been described (Spence and Cowley, 1978). Let us first consider the case of an infinitesimal detector right on the axis, which corresponds to the center of the Ronchigram. From Figure 2–9 it is clear that we will see contrast only if the diffracted beams are less than an objective aperture radius from the optic axis. The discs from three beams now interfere in the region detected. From (3.5), the wavefunction at the point detected will be Ψ(K = 0, R0) = 1 + φg exp[iχ(−g) − i2πg · R0] + φ−g exp[iχ(g) + i2πg · R0]
(4.1)
Figure 2–9. A schematic diagram showing that for a crystalline sample, a small, axial bright-field (BF) STEM detector will record changes in intensity due to interference between three beams: the 0 unscattered beam and the +g and -g Bragg reflections.
79
80
Peter D. Nellist
which can also be written as the Fourier transform of the product of the diffraction spots of the sample and the phase shift due to the lens aberrations, Ψ ( K = 0 , R 0 ) = ∫ [ δ ( K ′ ) + φ g δ (K ′ + g ) + φ − g δ (K ′ − g ) ] exp [iχ (K ′ )] exp ( i 2πK ′ ⋅ R 0 ) dK ′
(4.2)
Equations (4.1) and (4.2) are identical to those for the wavefunction in the image plane of a CTEM when forming an image of a crystalline sample. In the simplest model of a CTEM (Spence, 1988), the sample is illuminated with plane wave illumination. In the back focal plane of the objective lens we could observe a diffraction pattern, and the wavefunction for this plane corresponds to the first bracket in the integrand of (4.2). The effect of the aberrations of the objective lens can then be accommodated in the model by multiplying the wavefunction in the back focal plane by the usual aberration phase shift term, and this can also be seen in (4.2). The image plane wavefunction is then obtained by taking the Fourier transform of this product. Image formation in a STEM can be thought of as being equivalent to a CTEM with the beam trajectories reversed in direction. What we have shown here, for the specific case of BF imaging of a crystalline sample, is the princple of reciprocity in action. When the electrons are purely elastically scattered, and there is no energy loss, the propagation of the electrons is time reversible. The implication for STEM is that the source plane of a STEM is equivalent to the detector plane of a CTEM and vice versa (Cowley, 1969; Zeitler and Thomson, 1970). Condenser lenses are used in a STEM to demagnify the source, which corresponds to projector lenses being used in a CTEM for magnifying the image. The objective lens of a STEM (often used with an objective aperture) focuses the beam down to form the probe. In a CTEM, the objective lens collects the scattered electrons and focuses them to form a magnified image. Confusion can arise with combined CTEM/STEM instruments, in which the probe-forming optics are distinct from the image- forming optics. For example, the term objective aperture is usually used to refer to the aperture after the objective lens used in CTEM image formation. In STEM mode, the beam convergence is controlled by an aperture that is usually referred to as the condenser aperture, although by reciprocity this aperture is acting optically as an objective aperture. The correspondence by reciprocity between CTEM and STEM can be extended to include the effects of partial coherence. Finite energy spread of the illumination beam in CTEM has an effect on the image similar to that in STEM for the equivalent imaging mode. The finite size of the BF detector in a STEM gives rise to limited spatial coherence in the image (Nellist and Rodenburg, 1994), and corresponds to having a finite divergence of the illuminating beam in a STEM. In STEM, the loss of the spatial coherence can easily be understood as the averaging out of interference effects in the Ronchigram over the area of the BF detector. At the other end of the column there is also a correspondence between the source size in STEM and the detector pixel size in a CTEM. Moving the position of the BF STEM
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
detector is equivalent to tilting the illumination in CTEM. In this way dark-field images can be recorded. A carefully chosen position for a BF detector could also be used to detect the interference between just two diffracted discs in the microdiffraction pattern, allowing interference between the 0 beam and a beam scattered by up to the aperture diameter to be detected. In this way higher-spatial resolution information can be recorded, in an equivalent way to using a tilt sequence in CTEM (Kirkland et al., 1995). Although reciprocity ensures that there is an equivalence in the image contrast between CTEM and STEM, it does not imply that the efficiency of image formation is identical. Bright-field imaging in a CTEM is efficient with electrons because most of the scattered electrons are collected by the objective lens and used in image formation. In STEM, a large range of angles illuminates the sample and these are scattered further to give an extensive Ronchigram. A BF detector detects only a small fraction of the electrons in the Ronchigram, and is therefore inefficient. Note that this comparison applies only for BF imaging. There are other imaging modes, such as annular dark-field (Section 5), for which STEM is more efficient. 4.2 Phase Contrast Imaging in BF STEM Thin weakly scattering samples are often approximated as being weak phase objects (see, for example, Cowley, 1992). Weak phase objects simply shift the phase of the transmitted wave such that the specimen transmittance function can be written φ(R0) = 1 + iσV(R0)
(4.3)
where σ is known as the interaction constant and has a value given by σ = 2πmeλ/h2
(4.4)
where the electron mass, m, and the wavelength, λ, are relativistically corrected, and V is the projected potential of the sample. Equation (4.3) is simply the expansion of exp[iσV(R0)] to first order, and therefore requires that the product σV(R0) is much smaller than unity. The Fourier transform of (4.3) is ˜(K′) Φ(K′) = δ(K′) + iσV
(4.5)
and can be substituted for the first bracket in the integrand of (4.2) Ψ (K = 0 , R 0 ) = ∫ [δ (K ′ ) + iσV (K ′ ) exp [iχ (K ′ )] exp ( i 2πK ′.R 0 ) dK ′
(4.6)
Noticing that (4.6) is the Fourier transform of a product of functions, it can be written as a convolution in R0. Ψ(K = 0, R0) = 1 + iσV(R0) 䊟 FT{cos[χ(K′)] + i sin[χ(K′]}
(4.7)
Taking the intensity of (4.7) gives the BF image I(R0) = 1 − 2σV(R0) 䊟 FT{sin[χ(R0]}
(4.8)
81
82
Peter D. Nellist
where we have neglected terms greater than first order in the potential, and made use of the fact that the sine and cosine of χ are even and therefore their Fourier transforms are real. Not surprisingly, we have found that imaging a weak-phase object using an axial BF detector results in a phase contrast transfer function (PCTF) (Spence, 1988) identical to that in CTEM, as expected from reciprocity. Lens aberrations are acting as a phase plate to generate phase contrast. In the absence of lens aberrations, there will be no contrast. We can also interpret this result in terms of the Ronchigram in a STEM, remembering that axial BF imaging requires an area of triple overlap of discs (Figure 2–9). In the absence of lens aberrations, the interference between the BF disc and a scattered disc will be in antiphase to that between the BF disc and the opposite, conjugate diffracted disc, and there will be no intensity changes as the probe is moved. Lens aberrations will shift the phase of the interference fringes to give rise to image contrast. In regions of two disc overlap, the intensity will always vary as the probe is moved. Moving the detector to such two beam conditions will then give contrast, just as two-beam tilted illumination in CTEM will give fringes in the image. In such conditions, the diffracted beams may be separated by up to the objective aperture diameter, and still the fringes resolved. 4.3 Large Detector Incoherent BF STEM Increasing the size of the BF detector reduces the degree of spatial coherence in the image, as already discussed in Section 4.1. One explanation for this is the increasing degree to which interference features in the Ronchigram are being averaged out. Eventually the BF detector can be large enough that the image can be described as being incoherent. Such a large detector will be the complement of an annular dark-field detector: the BF detector corresponding to the hole in the ADF detector. Electron absorption in samples of thicknesses usually used for highresolution microscopy is small compared to the transmittance, which means that the large detector BF intensity will be IBF(R0) = 1 − IADF(R0)
(4.9)
We will defer discussion of incoherent imaging to Section 5. It is, however, worth noting that because IADF is a small fraction of the incident intensity (typically just a few percent), the contrast in IBF will be small compared to the total intensity. The image noise will scale with the total intensity, and therefore it is likely that a large detector BF image will have worse signal to noise than the complimentary ADF image.
5. Annular Dark-Field Imaging Annular dark-field (ADF) imaging is by far the most ubiquitous STEM imaging mode [see Nellist and Pennycook (2000) for a review of ADF STEM]. It provides images that are relatively insensitive to focusing
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
errors, in which compositional changes are obvious in the contrast, and atomic resolution images that are much easier to interpret in terms of atomic structure than their high-resolution TEM (HRTEM) counterparts. Indeed, the ability of a STEM to perform ADF imaging is one of the major strengths of STEM and is partly responsible for the growth of interest in STEM over the past two decades. The ADF detector is an annulus of scintillator material coupled to a photomultiplier tube in a way similar to the BF detector. It therefore measures the total electron signal scattered in angle between an inner and an outer radius. These radii can both vary over a large range, but typically the inner radius would be in the range of 30–100 mrad and the outer radius 100–200 mrad. Often the center of the detector is a hole, and electrons below the inner radius can pass through the detector for use either to form a BF image, or more commonly to be energy analyzed to form an electron energy-loss spectrum. By combining more than one mode in this way, the STEM makes highly efficient use of the transmitted electrons. Annular dark-field imaging was introduced in the first STEMs built in Crewe’s laboratory (Crewe, 1980). Initially their idea was that the high angle elastic scattering from an atom would be proportional to the product of the number of atoms illuminated and Z3/2, where Z is the atomic number of the atoms, and this scattering would be detected using the ADF detector. Using an energy analyzer on the lower-angle scattering they could also separate the inelastic scattering, which was expected to vary as the product of the number of atoms and Z1/2. By forming the ratio of the two signals, it was hoped that changes in specimen thickness would cancel, leaving a signal purely dependent on composition, and given the name Z contrast. Such an approach ignores diffraction effects within the sample, which we will see later is crucial for quantitative analysis. Nonetheless, the high-angle elastic scattering incident on an ADF detector is highly sensitive to atomic number. As the scattering angle increases, the scattered intensity from an atom approaches the Z2 dependence that would be expected for Rutherford scattering from an unscreened Coulomb potential. In practice this limit is not reached, and the Z exponent falls to values typically around 1.7 (see, for example, Hartel et al., 1996) due to the screening effect of the atom core electrons. This sensitivity to atomic number results in images in which composition changes are more strongly visible in the image contrast than would be the case for high-resolution phase-contrast imaging. It is for this reason that using the first STEM operating at 30 kV (Crewe et al., 1970), it was possible to image single atoms of Th on a carbon support. Once STEM instruments became commercially available in the 1970s, attention turned to using ADF imaging to study heterogeneous catalyst materials (Treacy et al., 1978). Often a heterogeneous catalyst consists of highly dispersed precious metal clusters distributed on a lighter inorganic support such as alumina, silica, or graphite. A system consisting of light and heavy atomic species such as this is an ideal subject for study using ADF STEM. Attempts were made to quantify the number of atoms in the metal clusters using ADF intensities. Howie
83
84
Peter D. Nellist
(1979) pointed out that if the inner radius was high enough, the thermal diffuse scattering (TDS) of the electrons would dominate. Because TDS is an incoherent scattering process, it was assumed that ensembles of atoms would scatter in proportion to the number of atoms present. It was shown, however, that diffraction effects can still have a large impact on the intensity (Donald and Craven, 1979). Specifically, when a cluster is aligned so that one of the low order crystallographic directions is aligned with the beam, a cluster is observed to be considerably brighter in the ADF image. An alternative approach to understanding the incoherence of ADF imaging invokes the principle of reciprocity. Phase contrast imaging in an HREM is an imaging mode that relies on a high degree of coherence in order to form contrast. The specimen illumination is arranged to be as plane wave as possible to maximize the coherence. By reciprocity, an ADF detector in a STEM corresponds hypothetically to a large, annular, incoherent illumination source in a CTEM. This type of source is not really viable for a CTEM, but illumination of this sort is extremely incoherent, and renders the specimen effectively self-luminous as the scattering from spatially separated parts of the specimen are unable to interfere coherently. Images formed from such a sample are simpler to interpret as they lack the complicating interference features observed in coherent images. A light-optical analogue is to consider viewing an object with illumination from either a laser or an incandescent light bulb. Laser beam illumination would result in strong interference features such as fringes and speckle. Illumination with a light bulb gives a view much easier to interpret. Although ADF STEM imaging is very widely used, there are still many discrepancies between the theoretical approaches taken, which can be very confusing when reviewing the literature. A picture of the imaging process that bridges the gap between thinking of the incoherence as arising from integration over a large detector to thinking of it as arising from detecting predominantly incoherent TDS has yet to emerge. Here we will present both approaches, and attempt to discuss the limitations and advantages of each.
5.1 Incoherent Imaging To highlight the difference between coherent and incoherent imaging, we start by reexamining coherent imaging in a CTEM for a thin sample. Consider plane wave illumination of a thin sample with a transmittance function, φ(R0). The wavefunction in the back focal plane is given by the Fourier transform of the transmittance function, and we can incorporate the effect of the objective aperture and lens aberrations by multiplying the back focal plane by the aperture function to give Φ(K′)A(K′)
(5.1)
which can be inverse Fourier transformed to the image wavefunction, which is then a convolution between φ(R0) and the Fourier transform of A(K′), which from Section 2 is P(R0). The image intensity is then
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
I(R0) = |φ(R0) 䊟 P(R0)|2
(5.2)
Although for simplicity we have derived (5.2) from the CTEM standpoint, by reciprocity (5.2) applies equally well to BF imaging in STEM with a small axial detector. For the ADF case we follow the argument first presented by Loane et al. (1992). Similar analyses have been performed by Jesson and Pennycook (1993), Nellist and Pennycook (1998a), and Hartel et al. (1996). Following the STEM configuration, the exit-surface wavefunction is given by the product of the sample transmittance and the probe function, φ(R) P(R−R0)
(5.3)
We can find the wavefunction in the Ronchigram plane by Fourier transforming (5.3), which results in a convolution between the Fourier transform of φ and the Fourier transform of P [given in Eq. (2.6)]. Taking the intensity in the Ronchigram and integrating over an annular detector function gives the image intensity I ADF (R 0 ) = ∫ DADF (K ) ∫ Φ (K − K ′ )A (K ′ ) exp ( i 2πK ′ ⋅ R 0 ) dK ′ 2 dK
(5.4)
Taking the Fourier transform of the image allows simplification after expanding the modulus squared to give two convolution integrals IADF (Q) = ∫ exp ( i 2πQ ⋅ R 0 )∫ DADF (K ) {∫ Φ (K − K ′ ) A (K ′ ) exp ( i 2πK ′ ⋅ R 0 ) dK ′} × {∫ Φ * (K − K ′′ ) A* (K ′′ )
exp ( −i 2πK ′′ ⋅ R 0 ) dK ′′} dK dR 0
(5.5)
Performing the R0 integral first results in a Dirac δ-function, IADF (Q) = DADF (K ) Φ (K − K ′ )A (K ′ ) Φ * (K − K ′′ )
∫∫∫
A* (K ′′ ) δ (Q + K ′ − K ′′ ) dK dK ′ dK ′′
(5.6)
which allows simplification by performing the K″ integral, IADF (Q) = DADF (K ) A (K ′ ) A* (K ′ + Q) Φ (K − K ′ )
∫∫
Φ * ( K − K ′ − Q ) dK d K ′
(5.7)
Equation (5.7) is straightforward to interpret in terms of interference between diffracted discs in the Ronchigram (Figure 2–10). The integral over K′ is a convolution, so that (5.7) could be written, IADF (Q) = ∫ DADF (K ) {[ A (K ) A* (K + Q)] ⊗K [Φ (K ) Φ * (K − Q)]} dK
(5.8)
The first bracket of the convolution is the overlap product of two apertures, and this is then convolved with a term that encodes the interference between scattered waves separated by the image spatial frequency Q. For a crystalline sample, Φ(K) will have values only for discrete K values corresponding to the diffracted spots. In this case (5.8) is easily
85
86
Peter D. Nellist
Figure 2–10. A schematic diagram showing the detection of interference in disc overlap regions by the ADF detector. Imaging of a g lattice spacing involves the interference of pairs of beams in the convergent beam that are separated by g. The ADF detector then sums over many overlap interference regions.
interpretable as the sum over many different disc overlap features that are within the detector function. An alternative, but equivalent, interpretation of (5.8) is that for a spatial frequency, Q, to show up in the image, two beams incident on the sample separated by Q must be scattered by the sample so that they end up in the same final wavevector K where they can interfere (Figure 2–10). This model of STEM imaging is applicable to any imaging mode, even when TDS or inelastic scattering is included. It was immediately concluded that STEM is unable to resolve any spacing smaller than that allowed by the diameter of the objective aperture, no matter which imaging mode is used. Figure 2–10 shows that we can expect that the aperture overlap region is small compared with the physical size of the ADF detector. In terms of Eq. (5.7) we can say the domain of the K′ integral (limited to the disc overlap region) is small compared with the domain of the K integral, and we can make the approximation, IADF (Q) = ∫ A (K ′ ) A* (K ′ + Q) dK ′ × ∫ DADF (K ) Φ (K − K ′ ) Φ * ( K − K ′ − Q ) dK
(5.9)
In making this approximation we have assumed that the contribution of any overlap regions that are partially detected by the ADF detector is small compared with the total signal detected. The integral containing the aperture functions is actually the autocorrelation of the aperture function. The Fourier transform of the probe intensity is the autocorrelation of A, thus Fourier transforming (5.9) to give the image results in
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
I(R0) = |P(R0)| 䊟 O(R0)
87
(5.10)
where O(R0) is the inverse Fourier transform of the integral over K in (5.9). Equation (5.10) is essentially the definition of incoherent imaging. An incoherent image can be written as the convolution between the intensity of the point-spread function of the image (which in STEM is the intensity of the probe) and an object function. Compare this with the equivalent expression for coherent imaging, (5.2), which is the intensity of a convolution between the complex probe function and the specimen function. We will see later that O(R0) is a function that is sharply peaked at the atom sites. The ADF image is therefore a sharply peaked object function convolved (or blurred) with a simple, real pointspread function that is simply the intensity of the STEM probe. Such an image is much simpler to interpret than a coherent image, in which both phase and amplitude contrast effects can appear. The difference between coherent and incoherent imaging was discussed at length by Lord Rayleigh in his classic paper discussing the resolution limit of the microscope (Rayleigh, 1896). A simple picture of the origins of the incoherence can be seen schematically by considering the imaging of two atoms (Figure 2–11). The scattering from the atoms will give rise to interference features in the detector plane. If the detector is small compared with these fringes, then the image contrast will depend critically on the position of the
Figure 2–11. The scattering from a pair of atoms will result in interference features such as the fringes shown here. A small detector, such as a BF, will be sensitive to the position of the fringes, and therefore sensitive to the relative phase of the scattered waves and phase changes across the illuminating wave. A larger detector, such as an ADF, will average over many fringes and will therefore be sensitive only to the intensity of the scattering and not the phase of the waves.
88
Peter D. Nellist
fringes, and therefore on the relative phases of the scattering from the two atoms, which means that complex phase effects will be seen. A large detector will average over the fringes, destroying any sensitivity to coherence effects and the relative phases of the scattering. By reciprocity, use of the ADF detector can be compared to illuminating the sample with large angle incoherent illumination. In optics, the Van Cittert–Zernicke theorem (Born and Wolf, 1980) describes how an extended source gives rise to a coherent envelope that is the Fourier transform of the source intensity function. An equivalent coherence envelope exists for ADF imaging, and is the Fourier transform of the detector function, D(K). As long as this coherence envelope is significantly smaller than the probe function, the image can be written in the form of (5.10) as being incoherent. This condition is the realspace equivalent of the approximation that allowed us to go from (5.7) to (5.9). The strength at which a particular spatial frequency in the object is transferred to the image is known, for incoherent imaging, as the optical transfer function (OTF). The OTF for incoherent imaging, T(Q), is simply the Fourier transform of the probe intensity function. In general it is a positive, monatonically decaying function (see Black and Linfoot (1957) for examples under various conditions), which compares favorably with the phase contrast transfer function for the same lens parameters (Figure 2–12). It can also be seen in Figure 2–12 that the interpretable resolution of incoherent imaging extends to almost twice that of phase-contrast imaging. This was also noted by Rayleigh (1896) for light optics. The explanation can be seen by comparing the disc overlap detection in Figure 2–9 and Figure 2–10. For ADF imaging single overlap regions can be detected, so the transfer continues to twice the aperture radius. The BF detector will detect spatial frequencies only to the aperture radius. An important consequence of (5.10) is that the phase problem has disappeared. Because the resolution of the electron microscope has always been limited by instrumental factors, primarily the spherical aberration of the objective lens, it has been desirable to be able to deconvolve the transfer function of the microscope. A prerequisite to doing this for coherent imaging is the need to find the phase of the image plane. The modulus-squared in (5.2) loses the phase information, and this must be restored before any deconvolution can be performed. Finding the phase of the image plane in the electron microscope was the motivation behind the invention of holography (Gabor, 1948). There is no phase problem for incoherent imaging, and the intensity of the probe may be immediately deconvolved. Various methods have been applied to this deconvolution problem (Nellist and Pennycook, 1998a, 2000) including Bayesian methods (McGibbon et al., 1994, 1995). As always with deconvolution, care must be taken not to introduce artifacts through noise amplification. The ultimate goal of such methods, though, must be the full quantitative analysis of an ADF image, along with a measure of certainty; for example, the positions of
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
89
Figure 2–12. A comparison of the incoherent object transfer function (OTF) and the coherent phasecontrast transfer function (PCTF) for identical imaging conditions (V = 300 kV, CS = 1 mm, z = −40 nm).
atomic columns in an image along with a measure of confidence in the data. Such a goal is yet to be achieved, and the interpretation of most images is still very much qualitative. The object function, O(R0), can also be examined in real space. By assuming that the maximum Q vector is small compared to the geometry of the detector, and noting that the detector function is either unity or zero, we can write the Fourier transform of the object function as O (Q) = ∫ DADF (K ) Φ (K )DADF (K − Q) Φ * (K − Q) dK (5.11) This equation is just the autocorrelation of DADF (K)φ(K), and so the object function is ˜ ADF (R0) 䊟 f (R0)|2 O(R0) = |D
(5.12)
Neglecting the outer radius of the detector, where we can assume the strength of the scattering has become negligible, DADF (K) can be thought of as a sharp high-pass filter. The object function is therefore the modulus-squared of the high-pass filtered specimen transmission function. Nellist and Pennycook (2000) have taken this analysis further by making the weak-phase object approximation, under which condition the object function becomes
90
Peter D. Nellist
O (R 0 ) =
J1 ( 2πkinner R ) [ σV(R 0 + R/2) 2π R half plane − σV(R 0 − R/2 )]2 dR
∫
(5.13)
where kinner is the spatial frequency corresponding to the inner radius of the ADF detector, and J1 is a first-order Bessel function of the first kind. This is essentially the result derived by Jesson and Pennycook (1993). The coherence envelope expected from the Van Cittert–Zernicke theorem is now seen in (5.13) as the Airy function involving the Bessel function. If the potential is slowly varying within this coherence envelope, the value of O(R0) is small. For O(R0) to have significant value, the potential must vary quickly within the coherence envelope. A coherence envelope that is broad enough to include more than one atom in the sample (arising from a small hole in the ADF), however, will show unwanted interference effects between the atoms. Making the coherence envelope too narrow by increasing the inner radius, on the other hand, will lead to too small a variation in the potential within the envelope, and therefore no signal. If there is no hole in the ADF detector, then D(K) = 1 everywhere, and its Fourier transform will be a delta-function. Eq. (5.12) then becomes the modulus-squared of f, and there will be no contrast. To get signal in an ADF image, we require a hole in the detector leading to a coherence envelope that is narrow enough to destroy coherence from neighboring atoms, but broad enough to allow enough interference in the scattering from a single atom. In practice, there are further factors that can influence the choice of inner radius, as discussed in later sections. A typical choice for incoherent imaging is that the ADF inner radius should be about three times the objective aperture radius. 5.2 ADF Images of Thicker Samples One of the great strengths of atomic resolution ADF images is that they appear to faithfully represent the true atomic structure of the sample even when the thickness is changing over ranges of tens of nanometers. Phase contrast imaging in a CTEM is comparatively very sensitive to changes in thickness, and displays the well-known contrast reversals (Spence, 1988). An important factor in the simplicity of the images is the incoherent nature of ADF images, as we have seen in Section 5.1. The thin object approximation made in Section 5.1, however, is not applicable to the thickness of samples that are typically used, and we need to include the effects of the multiple scattering and propagation of the electrons within the sample. There are several such dynamical models of electron diffraction (see Cowley, 1992). The two most common are the Bloch wave approach and the multislice approach. At the angles of scatter typically collected by an ADF detector, the majority of the electrons are likely to be thermal diffuse scattering, having also undergone a phonon scattering event. A comprehensive model of ADF imaging therefore requires both the multiple scattering and the thermal scattering to be included. As discussed earlier, some approaches assume that the ADF signal is dominated by the TDS, and this is assumed to be inco-
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
herent with respect to the scattering between different atoms. The demonstration of transverse incoherence through the detector geometry and the Van Cittert–Zernicke theorem is therefore ignored by this approach. For lower inner radii, or increased convergence angle (arising from aberration correction, for example) a greater amount of coherent scatter is likely to reach the detector, and the destruction of coherence through the detector geometry will be important for the coherent scatter. As yet, a unifying picture has yet to emerge, and the literature is somewhat confusing. Here we will present the most important approaches currently used. Initially let us neglect the phonon scattering. By assuming a completely stationary lattice with no absorption, Nellist and Pennycook (1999) were able to use Bloch waves to extend the approach taken in Section 5.1 to include dynamical scattering. It could be seen that the narrow detector coherence function acted to filter the states that could contribute to the image so that the highly bound 1s-type states dominated. Because these states are highly nondispersive, spreading of the probe wavefunction into neighboring column 1s states is unlikely (Rafferty et al., 2001), although spreading into less bound states on neighboring columns is possible. Although this analysis is useful in understanding how an incoherent image can arise under dynamical scattering conditions, its neglect of absorption and phonon scattering effects means that it is not effective as a quantitative method of simulating ADF images. Early analyses of ADF imaging took the approach that at high enough scattering angles, the TDS arising from phonons would dominate the image contrast. In the Einstein approximation, this scattering is completely uncorrelated between atoms, and therefore there could be no coherent interference effects between the scattering from different atoms. In this approach the intensity of the wavefunction at each site needs to be computed using a dynamical elastic scattering model and then the TDS from each atom summed (Pennycook and Jesson, 1990). When the probe is located over an atomic column in the crystal, the most bound, least dispersive states (usually 1s- or 2s-like) are predominantly excited and the electron intensity “channels” down the column. When the probe is not located over a column, it excites more dispersive, less bound states and spreads leading to reduced intensity at the atom sites and a lower ADF signal. Both the Bloch wave (for example, Pennycook, 1989; Amali and Rez, 1997; Mitsuishi et al., 2001; Findlay et al., 2003b) and multislice (for example, Dinges et al., 1995; Allen et al., 2003) methods have been used for simulating the TDS scattering to the ADF detector. Typically, a dynamic calculation using the standard phenomenological approach to absorption is used to compute the electron wavefunction in the crystal. The absorption is incorporated through an absorptive complex potential that can be included in the calculation simultaneously with the real potential. This method makes the approximation that the absorption at a given point in the crystal is proportional to the product of the absorptive potential and the intensity of the electron wavefunction at that point. Of course, much of the absorption is TDS, which is likely to be detected by the ADF detector.
91
92
Peter D. Nellist
It is therefore necessary to estimate the fraction of the scattering that is likely to arrive at the detector, and this estimation can cause difficulties. Many estimates of the scattering to the detector, however, make the approximation that the TDS absorption computed for electron scattering in the kinematic approximation to a given angle will end up being at the same angle after phonon scattering. The cross section for the signal arriving at the ADF detector can then be approximated by integrating this absorption over the detector (Pennycook, 1989; Mitsuishi et al., 2001), σ ADF = ( 4 πm/m0 )( 2π/λ )
∫
f ( s) [1 − exp ( − Ms2 )] d 2 s 2
(5.14)
ADF
where s = θ/2λ and the f(s) is the electron scattering factor for the atom in question. Other estimates have also been made, some including TDS in a more sophisticated way (Allen et al., 2003b). Caution must be exercised, though. Because this approach is two step—first electrons are absorbed, then a fraction is reintroduced to compute the ADF signal—a wrong estimation in the nature of the scattering can lead to more electrons being reintroduced than were absorbed, thus violating conservation laws. Making the approximation that all the electrons incident on the detector are TDS neglects any elastic scattering that might be present at the detection angles, which might become significant for lower inner radii. In most cases, including the elastic component is straightforward because it is always computed in order to find the electron intensity within the crystal, but this is not always done in the literature. Note that the approach outlined above for incoherent TDS scatterers is a fundamentally different approach to understanding ADF imaging, and does not invoke the principles of reciprocity or the Van Zittert– Zernicke theorem. It does not rely on the large geometry of the detector, but just on the fact that it detects only at high angles at which the TDS dominates. The use of TDS cross sections as outlined above also neglects the further elastic scattering of the electrons after they have been scattered by a phonon. The familiar Kikuchi lines visible in the TDS are manifestations of this elastic scattering. Such scattering occurs only for electrons traveling near Bragg angles, and the major effect is to redistribute the TDS in an angle. It may be reasonably assumed that an ADF detector is so large that the TDS is not redistributed off the detector, and that the electrons are still detected. In general, therefore, the effect of elastic scattering after phonon scattering is usually neglected. A type of multislice formulation that does include phonon scattering and postphonon elastic scattering has been developed specifically for the simulation of ADF images, and is known as the frozen phonon method (Kirkland et al., 1987; Loane et al., 1991, 1992). An electron accelerated to a typical energy of 100 keV is traveling at about half the speed of light. It therefore transits a sample of thickness, say, 10 nm in 3 × 10−17 s, which is much smaller than the typical period of a lattice vibration (~10−13 s). Each electron that transits the sample will see a
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
lattice in which the thermal vibrations are frozen in some configuration, with each electron seeing a different configuration. Multiple multislice calculations can be performed for different thermal displacements of the atoms, and the resultant intensity in the detector plane is summed over the different configurations. The frozen phonon multislice method is therefore not limited to calculations for STEM; it can be used for many different electron scattering experiments. In STEM, it will give the intensity at any point in the detector plane for a given illuminating probe position. The calculations faithfully reproduce the TDS, Kikuchi lines, and higher-order Laue zone (HOLZ) reflections (Loane et al., 1991). To compute the ADF image, the intensity in the detector plane must be summed over the detector geometry, and this calculation repeated for all the probe positions in the image. The frozen phonon method can be argued to be the most complete method for the computation of ADF images and has been used to compute contrast changes due to composition and thickness changes (Hillyard et al., 1993; Hillyard and Silcox, 1993). Its major disadvantage is that it is computational expensive. For most multislice simulations of STEM, one calculation is performed for each probe position. In a frozen phonon calculation, several multislice calculations are required for each probe position in order to average effectively over the thermal lattice displacements. Most of the approaches discussed so far have assumed an Einstein phonon dispersion in which the vibrations of neighboring atoms are assumed to be uncorrelated, and thus the TDS scattering from neighboring atoms incoherent. Jesson and Pennycook (1995) have considered the case for a more realistic phonon dispersion, and showed that a coherence envelope parallel to the beam direction can be defined. The intensity of a column can therefore be highly dependent on the destruction of the longitudinal coherence by the phonon lattice displacements. Consider two atoms, A and B, aligned with the beam direction, and let us assume that the scattering intensity to the ADF detector goes as the square of the atomic number (as for Rutherford scattering from an unscreened Coulomb potential). If the longitudinal coherence has been completely destroyed, the intensity from each atom will be independent and the image intensity will be ZA2 + ZB2. Conversely, if there is perfect longitudinal coherence the image intensity will be (ZA + ZB)2. A partial degree of coherence with a finite coherence envelope will result in scattering somewhere between these two extremes. However, frozen phonon calculations by Muller et al. (2001) suggest that for a real phonon dispersion, the ADF image is not significantly changed from the Einstein approximation. Lattice displacements due to strain in a crystal can be regarded as an ensemble of static phonons, and therefore strain can have a large effect on an ADF image (Perovic et al., 1993), giving rise to so-called strain contrast. The degree of strain contrast that shows up in an image is dependent on the inner radius of the ADF detector. As the inner radius is increased, the effect of strain is reduced and the contrast from compositional changes increases. Changing the inner radius of the detector and comparing the two images can often be used to distinguish between
93
94
Peter D. Nellist
strain and composition changes. A further similar application is the observation of thermal anomalies in quasicrystal lattices (Abe et al., 2003). It is often found in the literature that the veracity of a particular method is justified by comparing a calculation with an experimental image of a perfect crystal lattice. An image of a crystal contains little information: it can be expressed by a handful of Fourier components and is not a good test of a model. Much more interesting is the interpretation of defects, such as impurity or dopant atoms in a lattice, and particularly their contribution to image when they are at different depths in the sample. Of particular interest is the effect of probe dechanneling. In the Bloch wave formulation, the excitation of the various Bloch states is given by matching the wavefunctions at the entrance surface of a crystal. When a small probe is located over an atomic column, it is likely that the most excited state will be the tightly bound 1s-type state. This state has high transverse momentum, and is peaked at the atom site leading to strong absorption. Whichever model of ADF image formation is used, it may be expected that this will lead to high intensity on the ADF detector and that there will be a peak in the image at the column site. The 1s states are highly nondispersive, which means that the electrons will be trapped in the potential well and will propagate mostly along the column. This channeling effect is well known from many particle scattering experiments, and is important in reducing thickness effects in ADF imaging. The 1s state will not be the only state excited, however, and the other states will be more dispersive, leading to intensity spreading in the crystal (Fertig and Rose, 1981; Rossouw et al., 2003). Spreading of the probe in the crystal is similar to what would happen in a vacuum. The relatively high probe convergence angle means that the focus depth of field is low, and beyond that the probe will spread. Calculations suggest that this dechanneling can lead to artifacts in the image whereby the effect of a heavy impurity atom substitutional in a column can be seen in the intensity of neighboring columns. The degree to which this occurs, however, is dependent on the model of ADF imaging used, and the literature is still far from agreement on this issue. 5.3 Examples of Structure Determination Using ADF Images Despite the complications in understanding ADF image formation, it is clear that atomic resolution ADF images do provide direct images of structures. An atomic resolution image that is correctly focused will have peaks in intensity located at the atomic columns in the crystal from which the atomic structure can be simply determined. The use of ADF imaging for structure determination is now widespread (Pennycook, 2002). The subsidiary maxima of the probe intensity (see Section 2) will give rise to a weak artifactual maxima in the image (Figure 2–13) [see also Yamazaki et al. (2001)], but these will be small compared with the primary peaks, and often below the noise level. The ADF image is somewhat “fail-safe” in that incorrect focusing leads to very low con-
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
95
Figure 2–13. An ADF image of GaAs<110> taken using a VG Microscopes HB603U instrument (300 kV, CS = 1 mm). The 1.4-Å spacing between the “dumbbell” pairs of atomic columns is well resolved. An intensity profile shows the polarity of the lattice with the As columns giving greater intensity. The weak subsidiary maxima of the probe can be seen between the columns.
trast, and it is obvious to an operator when the image is correctly focused, unlike phase contrast CTEM for which focus changes do not reduce the contrast so quickly, and just lead to contrast reversals. There are now many examples in the literature of structure determination by atomic resolution ADF STEM. An excellent recent example is the three-dimensional structural determination of a NiS2/Si(001) interface (Falke et al., 2004) (Figure 2–14). The ability to immediately interpret intensity peaks in the image as atomic columns allowed this structure to be determined, and to correct an earlier erroneous structure determination from HRTEM data. A disadvantage of scanned images such as an ADF image compared to a conventional TEM image that can be recorded in one shot is that instabilities such as specimen drift manifest themselves as apparent lattice distortions. There have been various attempts to correct for this by using the known structure of the surrounding matrix to correct for the image distortions before analyzing the lattice defect of interest (see, for example, Nakanishi et al., 2002).
Figure 2–14. An ADF image of an NiS2/Si(001) interface with the structure determined from the image overlaid. [Reprinted with permission from Falke et al. (2004). Copyright (2004) by the American Physical Society.] (See color plate.)
96
Peter D. Nellist
5.4 Examples of Compositionally Sensitive Imaging The ability of ADF STEM to provide images with high composition sensitivity enabled the very first STEM, operating at 30 kV, to image individual atoms of Th on a carbon support (Crewe et al., 1970). In such a system, the heavy supported atoms are obvious in the image, and little is required in the way of image interpretation. A useful application of this kind of imaging is in the study of ultradispersed supported heterogeneous catalysts (Nellist and Pennycook, 1996). Figure 2–15 shows individual Pt atoms on the surface of a grain of a powered γalumina support. Dimers and trimers of Pt may be seen, and their interatomic distances measured. The simultaneously recorded BF image shows fringes from the alumina lattice, from which its orientation can be determined. By relating the BF and ADF images, information on the configuration of the Pt relative to the alumina support may be determined. The exact locations of the Pt atoms were later confirmed from calculations (Sohlberg et al., 2004). When imaging larger nanoparticles, it is found that the intensity of the particles in the image increases dramatically when one of the particle’s low-order crystallographic axes is aligned with the beam. In such a situation, quantitative analysis of the image intensity becomes more difficult. A more complex situation occurs for atoms substitutional in a lattice, such as dopant atoms. Modern machines have shown themselves to be capable of detecting both Bi (Lupini and Pennycook, 2003) and even Sb dopants (Voyles et al., 2002) in an Si lattice (Figure 2–16). In Voyles
Figure 2–15. An ADF image of individual atoms of Pt on a γ-Al2O3 support material. The BF image collected simultaneously showed fringes that allowed the orientation of the γ-Al2O3 to be determined. Subsequent theory calculations (see text) confirmed the likely locations of the Pt atoms.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
97
Figure 2–16. An ADF image (left) of Si<110> with visible Sb dopant atoms. On the right, the lattice image has been removed by Fourier filtering leaving the intensity changes due to the dopant atoms visible. (From Voyles et al. (2002), reprinted with permission of Nature Publishing Group.)
et al. (2004) it was noted that the probe channeling then dechanneling effects can change the intensity contribution of the dopant atom depending on its depth in the crystal. Indeed there is some overlap in the range of possible intensities for either one or two dopant atoms in a single column. Another similar example is the observation of As segregation at a grain boundary in Si (Chisholm et al., 1998). Naturally, ADF STEM is powerful when applied to multilayer structures in which composition sensitivity is desirable. There have been several examples of the application to AlGaAs quantum well structures (see, for example, Anderson et al., 1997). Simulations have been used to enable the image intensity to be interpreted in terms of the fractional content of Al, where it has been assumed that the Al is uniformly distributed throughout the sample.
6. Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy So far we have considered the imaging modes of STEM, which predominantly detect elastic or quasielastic scattering of the incident electrons. An equally important aspect of STEM, however, is that it is an extremely powerful analytical instrument. Signals arising from inelastic scattering processes within the sample contain much information about the chemistry and electronic structure of the sample. The small, bright illuminating probe combined with the use of a thin sample means that the interaction volume is small and that analytical information can be gained from a spatially highly localized region of the sample.
98
Peter D. Nellist
Electron energy-loss spectroscopy (EELS) involves dispersing in energy the transmitted electrons through the sample and forming a spectrum of the number of electrons inelastically scattered by a given energy loss versus the energy loss itself. Typically, inelastic scattering events with energy losses up to around 2 keV are intense enough to be useful experimentally. The energy resolution of EELS spectra can be dictated by both the aberrations of the spectrometer and the energy spread of the incident electron beam. By using a small enough entrance aperture to the spectrometer the effect of spectrometer aberrations will be minimized, albeit with loss of signal. In such a case, the incident beam spread will dominate, and energy resolutions of 0.3 eV with a CFEG source and of about 1 eV with a Schottky source are possible. Inelastic scattering tends be low angled compared to elastic scattering, with the characteristic scattering angle for EELS being (for example, Brydson, 2001) θE = ∆E 2E
(6.1)
0
For 100-keV incident electrons, θE has a value of 1 mrad for a 200 eV energy loss ranging up to 10 mrad for a 2 keV energy loss. The EELS spectrometer should therefore have a collection aperture that accepts the forward scattered electrons, and should be arranged axially about the optic axis. Such a detector arrangement still allows the use of an ADF detector simultaneously with an EELS spectrometer (see Figure 2–1), and this is one of the important strengths of STEM: an ADF image of a region of the sample can be taken, and spectra can be taken from sites of interest without any change in the detector configuration of the microscope. There are reviews and books on the EELS technique in both TEM and STEM (see Egerton, 1996; Brydson, 2001; Botton, this volume). In the context of this chapter on STEM, we will mostly focus on aspects of the spatial localization of EELS. 6.1 The EELS Spectrometer A number of spectrometer designs have emerged over the years, but the most commonly found today, especially with STEM instruments, is the magnetic sector prism, such as the Gatan Enfina system. An important reason for their popularity is that they are not designed to be in-column, but can be added as a peripheral to an existing column. Here we will limit our discussion to the magnetic sector prism. A typical prism consists of a region of homogeneous magnetic field perpendicular to the electron beam (see, for example, Egerton, 1996). In the field region, the electron trajectories follow arcs of circles (Figure 2–1) whose radii depend on the energy of the electrons. Slower electrons are deflected into smaller radii circles. The electrons are therefore dispersed in energy. An additional property of the prism is that it has a focusing action, and will therefore focus the beam to form a line spectrum in the so-called dispersion plane. In this plane, the electrons are typically dispersed by around 2 µm/eV. Some spectrometers are fitted with a mechanical slit at this plane that can be used to select part of the
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
spectrum. A scintillator–photomultiplier combination allows detection of the intensity of the selected part of the spectrum. Using this arrangement, a spectrum can be recorded by varying the strength of the magnetic field, thus sweeping the spectrum over the slit and recording the spectrum serially. Alternatively, the magnetic field can be held constant, selecting just a single energy window, and the probe scanned to form an energy-filtered image. If there is no slit, or the slit is maximally widened, the spectrum may be recorded in parallel, a technique known as parallel EELS (PEELS). The dispersion plane then needs to be magnified in order that the detector channels allow suitable sampling of the spectrum. This is normally achieved by a series of quadrupoles (normally four) that allows both the dispersion and the width of the spectrum to be controlled at the detector. Detection is usually performed either by a parallel photodiode array, or more commonly now using a scintillator–CCD combination. Like all electron-optical elements, magnetic prisms suffer from aberrations, and these aberrations can limit the energy resolution of the spectrometer. In general, a prism is designed such that the secondorder aberrations are corrected for a given object distance before the prism. Prisms are often labeled with their nominal object distances, which is typically around 70 cm. Small adjustments can be made using sextupoles near the prism and by adjusting the mechanical tilt of the prism. It is important, though, that care is taken to arrange that the sample plane is optically coupled to the prism at the correct working distance to ensure correction of the second-order spectrometer aberrations. More recently, spectrometers with higher order correction (Brink et al., 2003) have been developed. Alternatively, it has been shown to be possible to correct spectrometer aberrations with a specially designed coupling module that can be fitted immediately prior to the spectrometer (see Section 8.1). Aberrations worsen the ability of the prism to focus the spectrum as the width of the beam entering the prism increases. Collector apertures are therefore used at the entrance of the prism to limit the beam width, but they also limit the number of electrons entering the prism and therefore the efficiency of the spectrum detection. The trade-off between signal strength and energy resolution can be adjusted to the particular experiment being performed by changing the collector aperture size. Aperture sizes in the range of 0.5–5 mm are typically provided. 6.2 Inelastic Scattering of Electrons The different types of inelastic scattering event that can lead to an EELS signal have been discussed many times in the literature (for example, Egerton, 1996; Brydson, 2001; Botton, this volume), so we will restrict ourselves to a brief description here. A schematic diagram of a typical EEL spectrum is shown in Figure 2–17. The samples typically used for high-resolution STEM are usually thinner than the mean free path for inelastic scattering (around 100 nm
99
100 Peter D. Nellist
Figure 2–17. A schematic EEL spectrum.
at 100 keV), so the dominant feature in the spectrum is the zero-loss (ZL) peak. When using a spectrometer for high energy resolution, the width of the ZL is usually limited by the energy width of the incident beam. Because STEM instruments require a field-emission gun, this spread is usually small. In a Schottky gun this spread is around 0.8 eV, whereas a CFEG can achieve 0.3 eV or better. The lowest energy losses in the sample will arise from the creation and destruction of phonons, which have energies in the range of 10–100 meV. This range is smaller than the width of the ZL, so such losses will not be resolvable. The low-loss region extends from 0 to 50 eV and corresponds to excitations of electrons in the outermost atomic orbitals. These orbitals can often extend over several atomic sites, and so are delocalized. Both collective and single electron excitations are possible. Collective excitations result in the formation of a plasmon or resonant oscillation of the electron gas. Plasmon excitations have the largest cross section of all the inelastic excitations, so the plasmon peak dominates an EEL spectrum, and can complicate the interpretation of other inelastic signals due to multiple scattering effects. Single electron excitations from states in the valence band to empty states in the conduction band can also give rise to low-loss features allowing measurements similar to those in optical spectroscopy, such as band-gap measurements. Further information, for example, distinguishing a direct gap from an indirect gap is available (Rafferty and Brown, 1998). Detailed interpretation of low-loss features involves careful removal of the ZL, however. More commonly, the low-loss region is used as a measure of specimen thickness by comparing the inelastically scattered intensity with the intensity in the ZL. The frequency of inelastic scattering events follows a Poisson distribution, and it can be shown that the sample thickness can be estimated from
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
t = Λ ln(IT/IZL)
(6.2)
where IT and IZL are the intensities in the spectrum and zero loss, respectively, and Λ is the inelastic mean-free path, which has been tabulated for some common materials (Egerton, 1996). From 50 eV up to several thousand eV of energy loss, the inelastic excitations involve electrons in the localized core orbitals on atom sites. Superimposed on a monatonically decreasing background in this highloss region are a series of steps or core-loss edges arising from excitations from the core orbitals to just above the Fermi level of the material. The energy loss at which the edge occurs is given by the binding energy of the core orbital, which is characteristic of the atomic species. Measurement of the edge energies therefore allows chemical identification of the material under study. The intensity under the edge is proportional to the number of atoms present of that particular species, so that quantitative chemical analysis can be performed. In a solid sample the bonding in the sample can lead to a significant modification to the density of unoccupied states near the Fermi level, which manifests itself as a fine structure (energy loss near-edge structure, ELNES) in the EEL spectrum in the first 30–40 eV beyond the edge threshold. Although the interpretation of the ELNES can be somewhat complicated, it does contain a wealth of information about the local bonding and structure associated with a particular atomic species. For example, Batson (2000) has used STEM EELS to observe gap states in Si L-edges that are associated with defects observed by ADF. Beyond the near edge region can be seen weaker, extended oscillations (extended energy loss far-edge structure, EXELFS) superimposed on the decaying background. Being further from the edge onset, these excitations correspond to the ejection of a higher kinetic energy electron from the core shell. This higher energy electron generally suffers single scattering from neighboring atoms leading to the observed oscillations and thereby information on the local structural configuration of the atoms such as nearest-neighbor distances. Clearly EELS has much in common with X-ray absorption studies, with the advantage for EELS being that spectra can be recorded from highly spatially localized regions of the sample. The X-ray counterpart of ELNES is XANES (X-ray absorption near-edge structure), and EXELFS corresponds to EXAFS (extended X-ray absorption fine structure). There are many examples in the literature (for a recent example see Ziegler et al., 2004) in which STEM has been used to record spectra at a defect and the core-loss fine structure used to understand the bonding at the defect. 6.3 The Spatial Localization of EELS Signals and Inelastic Imaging The strength of EELS in a STEM is that the spectra can be recorded with a high spatial resolution, so the question of the spatial resolution of an EELS signal is an important one. The literature contains several papers demonstrating atomic resolution EELS (Batson, 1993; Browning et al., 1993) and even showing sensitivity to a single impurity atom
101
102 Peter D. Nellist
(Varela et al., 2004). The lower the energy loss, however, the more the EELS excitation will be delocalized, and an important question is for what excitations is atomic resolution possible. In addition to the inherent size of the excitation, we must also consider the beam spreading as the probe propagates through the sample. A simple approximation for the beam spreading is given by (Reed, 1982), b = 0.198(ρ/A)1/2 (Z/E0)t3/2
(6.3)
where b is in nanometers, ρ is the density (g cm−3), A is the atomic weight, Z is the atomic number, E0 is the incident beam energy in keV, and t is the thickness. At the highest spatial resolutions, especially for a zone-axis oriented sample, a detailed analysis of diffraction and channeling effects (Allen et al., 2003a) is required to model the propagation of the probe through the sample. The calculations are similar to those outlined in Section 5. Having computed the wavefunction of the illuminating beam within the sample, we now need to consider the spatial extent of the inelastic excitation. This subject has been covered extensively in the literature. Initial studies first considered an isolated atom using a semiclassical model (Ritchie and Howie, 1988). A more detailed study requires a wave optical approach. For a given energy-loss excitation, there will be multiple final states for the excited core electron. The excitations to these various states will be mutually incoherent, leading to a degree of incoherence in the overall inelastic scattering, unlike elastic scattering, which can be regarded as coherent. Inelastic scattering can therefore not be described by a simple multiplicative scattering function, rather we must use a mixed dynamic form factor (MDFF), as described by Kohl and Rose (1985). The formulation used for ADF imaging in Section 5.1 can be adapted for inelastic imaging. Combining the notation of Kohl and Rose (1985) with (5.7) allows us to replace the product of transmission functions with the MDFF, S ( k , k + Q) Iinel (Q) ∝ ∫∫ Dspect (K ) A (K ′ ) A* (K ′ + Q) 2 dK dK ′ k k+Q2
(6.4)
where some prefactors have been neglected for clarity and D now refers to the spectrometer entrance aperture. The inelastic scattering vector, k, can be written as the sum of the transverse scattering vector coupling the incoming wave to the outgoing wave, and the change in wavevector due to the energy loss, k=
θE ez + K − K′ λ
(6.5)
where ez is a unit vector parallel to the beam central axis. Equations (6.4) and (6.5) show that for a given spatial frequency Q in the image, the inelastic image can be thought of arising from the sum over pairs of incoming plane waves in the convergent beam separated by Q. Each pair is combined through the MDFF into a final wavevector that is collected by the detector. This is analo-
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
gous to the model for ADF imaging (see Figure 2–10), except that the product of elastic scattering functions has been replaced with the more general MDFF allowing intrinsic incoherence of the scattering process. In Section 5.1 we found that under certain conditions, (5.7) could be split into the product of two integrals. This allowed the image to be written as the convolution of the probe intensity and an object function, a type of imaging known as incoherent imaging. Let us examine whether (6.4) can be similarly separated. In a similar fashion to the ADF incoherent imaging derivation, if the spectrometer entrance aperture is much larger than the probe convergence angle, then the domain of the integral over K is much larger than that over K′, and the latter can be performed first. The integral can be then separated thus, S ( k , k + Q) Iinel (Q) ∝ ∫ A (K ′ )A* (K ′ − Q) dK ′ ∫ Dspect (K ) 2 dK k k+Q2
(6.6)
where the K′ term in k is now neglected. Since this is a product in reciprocal space, it can be written as a convolution in real space, Iinel (R0) ∝ |P(R0)| 䊟 O(R0)
(6.7)
where the object function O(R) is the Fourier transform of the integral over K in (6.5). For spectrometer geometries, Dspect(K), that collect only high angles of scatter, it has been shown that this can lead to narrower objects for inelastic imaging (Muller and Silcox, 1995; Rafferty and Pennycook, 1999). Such an effect has not been demonstrated because at such a high angle the scattering is likely to be dominated by combination elastic–inelastic scattering events, and any apparent localization is likely to be due to the elastic contrast. For inelastic imaging, however, there is another condition for which the integrals can be separated. If the MDFF, S, is slowly varying in k, then the integral in K′ over the disc overlaps will have a negligible effect on S, and the integrals can be separated. Physically, this is equivalent to asserting that the inelastic scattering real-space extent is much smaller than the probe, and therefore the phase variation over the probe sampled by the inelastic scattering event is negligible and the image can be written as a convolution with the probe intensity. We have described the transition from coherent to incoherent imaging for inelastic scattering events in STEM. Note that these terms simply refer to whether the probe can be separated in the manner described above, and does not refer to the scattering process itself. Incoherent imaging can arise with coherent elastic scattering, as described in Section 5.1. The inelastic scattering process is not coherent, hence the need for the MDFF. However, certain conditions still need to be satisfied for the imaging process to be described as incoherent, as described above. An interesting effect occurs for small collector apertures. Because dipole excitations will dominate (Egerton, 1996), a probe located exactly over an atom will not be able to excite transverse excitations because it will not apply a transverse dipole. A slight displacement of the probe is required for such
103
104 Peter D. Nellist
an excitation. Consequently a dip in the inelastic image is shown to be possible, leading to a donut type of image, demonstrated by Kohl and Rose (1985) and more recently by Cosgriff et al. (2005). This can be thought of as arising from an antisymmetric inelastic object function for a transverse dipole interaction. With a larger collector aperture, the transition to incoherent imaging renders the object function symmetric, removing the dip on the axis. The width of an inelastic excitation as observed by STEM is therefore a complicated function of the probe, the energy, and the initial wavefunction of the core electron and the spectrometer collector aperture geometry. Various calculations have been published exploring this parameter-space. See, for example, Rafferty and Pennycook (1999) and Cosgriff et al. (2005) for some recent examples. 6.4 Spectrum Imaging in the STEM Historically, the majority of EELS studies in the STEM have been performed in spot mode, in which the probe is stopped over the region of interest in the sample and a spectrum is collected. Of course, the STEM is a scanning instrument, and it is possible to collect a spectrum from every pixel of a scanned image, to form a spectrum image. The image may be a one-dimensional line scan, or a two-dimensional image. In the latter case, the data set will be a three-dimensional data cube: two of the dimensions being real-space imaging dimensions and one being the energy loss in the spectra (Figure 2–18). The spectrum-image data cube naturally contains a wealth of information. Individual spectra can be viewed from any real-space location, or energy-filtered images formed by extracting slices at a given energy loss (Figure 2–18). Selecting energy losses corresponding to the characteristic core edges of the atomic species present in the sample allows
Figure 2–18. A schematic diagram showing how collecting a spectrum at every probe position leads to a data cube from which can be extracted individual spectra or images filtered for a specific energy.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
105
Figure 2–19. A spectrum image filtered for Gd (A) and C (B). Individual atoms of Gd inside a carbon nanotube can be observed. [Reprinted from Suenaga et al. (2000), with copyright permission from AAAS.]
elemental mapping, which, given the inelastic cross sections of the core-loss events, can be calibrated in terms of composition. Using this approach, individual atoms of Gd have been observed inside a carbon nanotube structure (Suenaga et al., 2000) (Figure 2–19). A more sophisticated approach is to use multivariate statistical (MSI) methods (Bonnet et al., 1999) to analyze the compositional maps. With this approach, the existence of phases of certain stoichiometry can be identified, and maps of the phase locations within the sample can be created. Even the fine structure of core-loss edges can be used to form maps in which only the bonding, not the composition, within the sample has changed. An example of this is the mapping of the sp2 and sp3 bonding states of carbon at the interface of chemical vapor deposition diamond grown on a silicon substrate (Muller et al., 1993) (Figure 2–20). The sp2 signal shows the presence of an amorphous carbon layer at the interface. A similar three-dimensional data cube may also be recorded by conventional TEM fitted with an imaging filter. In this case, the image is recorded in parallel while varying the energy loss being filtered for. Both methods have advantages and disadvantages, and the choice can depend on the desired sampling in either the energy or image dimensions. The STEM does have one important advantage, however. In a CTEM, all of the imaging optics occur after the sample, and these optics suffer significant chromatic aberration. Adjusting the system to change the energy loss being recorded can be done by changing the energy of the incident electrons, thus keeping the energy of the desired inelastically scattered electrons constant within the imaging system. However, to obtain a useful signal-to-noise ratio in energy-filtered transmission electron microscopy (EFTEM), it is necessary to use a selecting energy window that is several electronvolts in width, and even this energy spread in the imaging system is enough to worsen
106 Peter D. Nellist
C 1s p*
Figure 2–20. By filtering for specific peaks in the fine structure of the carbon K-edge, maps of π and σ bonded carbon can be formed. The presence of an amorphous sp2 bonded carbon layer at the interface of a chemical vapor deposition (CVD)-grown diamond on an Si substrate can be seen. The diamond signal is derived by a weighted subtraction of the π bonding image from the σ bonding image. [Reprinted from Muller et al. (1993), with permission of Nature Publishing Group.]
C 1s s*
Diamond
5 nm
the spatial resolution significantly. In STEM, all of the image-forming optics are before the specimen, and the spatial resolution is not compromised. Inelastic scattering processes, especially single electron excitations, have a scattering cross section that can be an order of magnitude smaller than for elastic scattering. To obtain sufficient signal, EELS acquisition times may be of the order of 1 s. Collection of a spectrum image with a large number of pixels can therefore be very slow, with
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
the associated problems of both sample drift, and drift of the energy zero point due to power supplies warming up. In practice, spectrum image acquisition software often compensates for these drifts. Sample drift can be monitored using cross-correlations on a sharp feature in the image. Monitoring the position of the zero-loss peak allows the energy drift to be corrected. The advent of aberration correction will have a major impact in this regard. Perhaps one of the most important consequences of aberration correction is that it will increase the current in a given sized probe by more than an order of magnitude (see Section 10.3). Fast elemental mapping through spectrum imaging will then become a much more routine application of EELS. However, to achieve this improvement in performance, there will have to be corresponding improvements in the associated hardware. In general, commercially available systems can achieve around 200 spectra per second. Some laboratories with custom instrumentation have reported reaching 1000 spectra per second (Tencé, personal communication). Further improvement will be necessary to fully make use of spectrum imaging in an aberration corrected STEM.
7. X-Ray Analysis and Other Detected Signals in the STEM It is obvious that the STEM bears many resemblances to the SEM: a focused probe is formed at a specimen and scanned in a raster while signals are detected as a function of probe position. So far we have discussed BF imaging, ADF imaging, and EELS. All of these methods are unique to the STEM because they involve detection of the fast transmitted electron through a thin sample; bulk samples are typically used in an SEM. There are of course, a multitude of other signals that can be detected in STEM, and many of these are also found in SEM machines. 7.1 Energy Dispersive X-Ray Analysis When a core electron in the sample is excited by the fast electron traversing the sample, the excited system will subsequently decay with the core hole being refilled. This decay will release energy in the form of an X-ray photon or an Auger electron. The energy of the particle released will be characteristic of the core electron energy levels in the system, and allows compositional analysis to be performed. The analysis of the emitted X-ray photons is known as energydispersive X-ray (EDX) analysis, or sometimes energy-dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) or X-ray EDS (XEDS). It is a ubiquitous technique for SEM instruments and electron-probe microanalyzers. The technique of EDX microanalysis in CTEM and STEM has been extensively covered (Williams and Carter, 1996), and we will review here only the specific features of EDX in a STEM. The key difference between performing EDX analysis in the STEM as opposed to the SEM is the improvement in spatial resolution (see Figure 2–21). The increased accelerating voltage and the thinner sample used
107
108 Peter D. Nellist
STEM
SEM
100 nm
1 nm 10 nm
excitation volume ~ 1 mm3
excitation volume ~ 10 nm3
Figure 2–21. A schematic diagram comparing the beam interaction volumes for an SEM and a STEM. The higher accelerating voltage and thinner samples in STEM lead to much higher spatial resolution for analysis, with an associated loss in signal.
in STEM lead to an interaction volume that is some 108 times smaller than for an SEM. Beam broadening effects will still be significant for EDX in STEM, and Eq. (6.2) provides a useful approximation in this case. For a given fraction of the element of interest, however, the total X-ray signal will be correspondingly smaller. For a discussion of detection limits for EDX in STEM see Watanabe and Williams (1999). A further limitation for high-resolution STEM instruments is the geometry of the objective lens pole pieces between which the sample is placed. For high resolution the pole piece gap must be small, and this limits both the solid angle subtended by the EDX detector and the maximum take-off angle. This imposes a further reduction on the X-ray signal strength. A high probe current of around 1 nA is typically required for EDX analysis, and this means that the probe size must be increased to greater than 1 nm (see Section 10), thus losing atomic resolution sensitivity. A further concern is the mounting of a large liquid nitrogen dewar on the column for the necessary cooling of the detector. It is often suspected that the boiling of the liquid nitrogen and the unbalancing of the column can lead to mechanical instabilities. A positive benefit of EDX in STEM, however, is that windowless EDX detectors may commonly be used. The vacuum around the sample in STEM is typically higher than for other electron microscopes to reduce sample contamination during imaging and to reduce the gas load on the ultrahigh vacuum of the gun. A consequence is that contamination or icing of a windowless detector is less common. For the reasons described above, EDX analysis capabilities are sometimes omitted from ultrahigh resolution dedicated STEM instruments, but are common on combination CTEM/STEM instruments. A notable exception has been the development of a 300-kV STEM instrument with the ultimate aim of single-atom EDX detection (Lyman et al., 1994).
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
It is worth making a comparison between EDX and EELS for STEM analysis. The collection efficiency of EELS can reach 50%, compared to around 1% for EDX, because the X-rays are emitted isotropically. EELS is also more sensitive for light element analysis (Z < 11), and for many transition metals and rare-earth elements that show strong spectral features in EELS. The energy resolution in EELS is typically better than 1 eV, compared to 100–150 eV for EDX. The spectral range of EDX, however, is higher with excitations up to 20 keV detectable, compared with around 2 keV for EELS. Detection of a much wider range of elements is therefore possible. 7.2 Secondary Electrons, Auger Electrons, and Cathodoluminescence Other methods commonly found on an SEM have also been seen on STEM instruments. The usual imaging detector in an SEM is the secondary electron (SE) detector, and these are also found on some STEM instruments. The fast electron incident upon the sample can excite electrons so that they are ejected from the sample. These relatively slow moving electrons can escape only if they are generated relatively close to the surface of the material, and can therefore generate topographical maps of the sample. Once again, because the interaction volume is smaller, the use of SE in STEM can generate high-resolution topographical images of the sample surface. An intriguing experiment involving secondary electrons has been the observation of coincidence between secondary electron emission and primary beam energy-loss events (Mullejans et al., 1993). Auger electrons are ejected as an alternative to X-ray photon emission in the decay of a core-electron excitation, and spectra can be formed and analyzed just as for X-ray photons. The main difference, however, is that whereas X-ray photons can escape relatively easily from a sample, Auger electrons can escape only when they are created close to the sample surface. It is therefore a surface technique, and is sensitive to the state of the sample surface. Ultrahigh vacuum conditions are therefore required, and Auger in STEM is not commonly found. Electron-hole pairs generated in the sample by the fast electron can decay by way of photon emission. For many semiconducting samples, these photons will be in or near the visible spectrum and will appear as light, known as cathodoluminescence. Although rarely used in STEM, there has been the occasional investigation (see, for example, Pennycook et al., 1980).
8. Electron Optics and Column Design Having explored some of the theory and applications of the various imaging and analytical modes in STEM, it is a good time to return to the details of the instrument itself. The dedicated STEM instrument provides a nice model to show the degrees of freedom in the STEM optics, and then we go on to look at the added complexity of a hybrid CTEM/STEM instrument.
109
110 Peter D. Nellist
8.1 The Dedicated STEM Instrument We will start by looking at the presample or probe-forming optics of a dedicated STEM, though it should be emphasized that most of the comments in this section also apply to TEM/STEM instruments. In addition to the objective lens, there are usually two condenser lenses (Figure 2–1). The condenser lenses can be used to provide additional demagnification of the source, and thereby control the trade-off between probe size and probe current (see Section 10.1). In principle, only one condenser lens is required because movement of the crossover between the condenser and objective lens (OL) either further or nearer to the OL can be compensated by relatively small adjustments to the OL excitation to maintain the sample focus. The inclusion of two condenser lenses allows the demagnification to be adjusted while maintaining a crossover at the plane of the selected area diffraction aperture. The OL is then set such that the selected area diffraction (SAD) aperture plane is optically conjugate to that of the sample. In a conventional TEM instrument, the SAD aperture is placed after the OL, and the OL is set to make it optically conjugate to the sample plane. The SAD aperture then selects a region of the sample, and the post-OL lenses are used to focus and magnify the diffraction pattern in the back-focal plane of the OL to the viewing screen. By reciprocity, an equivalent SAD mode can be established in a dedicated STEM (Figure 2–22). With the condenser lenses set to place a crossover at the
sample objective lens objective aperture selected area diffraction aperture scan coils condenser lens
imaging mode
diffraction mode
Figure 2–22. The change from imaging to diffraction mode is shown in this schematic of part of a STEM column. By refocusing the condenser lens on the objective lens FFP rather than the SAD aperture plane, the objective lens generates a parallel beam at the sample rather than a focused probe. The SAD aperture is now the beam-limiting aperture, and defines the illumination region on the sample.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
SAD, an image can be formed with the SAD selecting a region of interest in the sample. The condenser lenses are then adjusted to place a crossover at the front focal plane of the OL, and the scan coils are set to scan the crossover over the front focal plane. The OL then generates a parallel pencil beam that is rocked in angle at the sample plane. In the detector plane is therefore seen a conventional diffraction pattern that is swept across the detector by the scan. By using a small BF detector, a scanned diffraction pattern will be formed. If a Ronchigram camera is available in the detector plane, then the diffraction pattern can be viewed directly and scanning is unnecessary. In practice, SAD mode in a STEM is more commonly used for measuring the angular range of BF and ADF detectors rather than diffraction studies of samples. It is also often used for tilting a crystalline sample to a zone axis if a Ronchigram camera is not available. To avoid having to mutually align the two condenser lenses, many users employ only one condenser at a time. Both are set to focus a crossover at the SAD aperture plane, but the different distance between the lenses and the SAD plane means that the overall demagnification of the source will differ. Often the two discrete probe current settings then available are suitable for the majority of experiments. Alternatively, many users, especially those with a Ronchigram camera, need an SAD mode very infrequently. In this case, there is no requirement for a crossover in the SAD plane, and one condenser lens can be adjusted freely. In more modern STEM instruments, a further gun lens is provided in the gun acceleration area. The purpose of this lens is to focus a crossover in the vicinity of the differential pumping aperture that is necessary between the ultrahigh vacuum gun region and the rest of the column. The result is that a higher total current is available for very high current modes. For lower current, higher resolution modes, a gun lens is not found to be necessary. Let us now turn our attention to the objective lens and the postspecimen optics. The main purpose of the OL is to focus the beam to form a small spot. Just like a conventional TEM, the OL of a STEM is designed to minimize the spherical and chromatic aberration, while leaving a large enough gap for sample rotation and providing a sufficient solid angle for X-ray detection. An important parameter in STEM is the postsample compression. The field of the objective lens that acts on the electrons after they exit the sample also has a focusing effect on the electrons. The result is that the scattering angles are compressed and the virtual crossover position moves down. Most of the VG dedicated STEM instruments have topentry OLs, which are consequently asymmetric in shape. The bore on the probe forming (lower) side of the OL is smaller then on the upper side, and therefore the field is more concentrated on the lower side. The typical postsample compression for these asymmetric lenses, typically a factor of around 3, is comparatively low. The entrance to the EELS spectrometer will often be up to 60 cm or more after the sample, to allow room for deflection coils and other detectors. A 2-mm-diameter EELS entrance aperture then subtends a geometric entrance semiangle of
111
112 Peter D. Nellist
1.7 mrad. Including the factor of 3 compression from the OL gives a typical collection semiangle of 5 mrad. The probe convergence angle of an uncorrected STEM will be around 9 mrad, so the total collection efficiency of the EELS system will be poor, being below 25% after accounting for further angular scattering from the inelastic scattering process. After the correction of spherical aberration, the probe convergence semiangle will rise to 20 mrad or more, and the coupling of this beam into the EELS system will become even more inefficient. A postspecimen lens would in principle allow improved coupling into the EELS by providing further compression after the beam has left the objective lens. However, there needs to be enough space for deflection coils and lens windings between the lenses, so it is hard to position a postspecimen lens closer than about 100 mm after the OL. By the time the beam has propagated to this lens, it will be of the order of 1 mm in diameter. This is a large diameter beam to be handled by an electron lens, in the lower column typical widths are 50 µm or less, and large aberrations will be introduced that will obviate the benefit of the extra compression. In many dedicated STEMs, therefore, postspecimen lenses are rarely used. A more common work around solution is to mount the sample as low in the OL as possible and to excite the OL as hard as possible to provide the maximum compression possible, though it is difficult to do this and to maintain the tilt capabilities. A novel solution demonstrated by the Nion Co. is to use a fourquadrupole four-octupole system to couple the postspecimen beam to the spectrometer and provide increased compression. The fourquadrupole system has enough degrees of freedom to provide compression while also ensuring that the virtual crossover as seen by the spectrometer is at the correct object distance. As with any postspecimen lens system in a top entry STEM, the beam is so wide at the lens system that large third-order aberrations are introduced. The presence of the octupoles allows for correction of these aberrations and additionally the third-order aberrations of the spectrometer, which in turn allows a larger physical spectrometer entrance aperture to be used. Collection semiangles up to 20 mrad have been demonstrated with this system (Nellist et al., 2003). 8.2 CTEM/STEM Instruments At the time of writing, dedicated STEM columns are available from JEOL and Hitachi. Nion Co. has a prototype aberration-corrected dedicated STEM column under test, and this will soon be added to the array of available machines. However, many researchers prefer to use a hybrid CTEM/STEM instrument, which is supplied from all the main manufacturers. As their name suggests, CTEM/STEM instruments offer the capabilities of both modes in the same column. A CTEM/STEM is essentially a CTEM column with very little modification apart from the addition of STEM detectors. When fieldemission guns (FEGs) were introduced onto CTEM columns, it was found that the beam could be focused onto the sample with spot sizes down to 0.2 nm or better (for example, James and Browning, 1999). The
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
addition of a suitable scanning system and detectors thus created a STEM. The key is that modern CTEM instruments with a side-entry stage tend to make use of the condenser-objective lens (Figure 2–23). In the condenser-objective lens, the field is symmetric about the sample plane, and therefore the lens is just as strong in focusing the beam to a probe presample as it is in focusing the postsample scattered electrons as it would do in conventional TEM mode. The condenser lenses and gun lens play the same roles as those in the dedicated STEM. The main difference in terminology is that what would be referred to as the objective aperture in a CTEM/STEM is referred to as the condenser aperture in a TEM/STEM. The reason for this is that the aperture in question is usually in or near the condenser lens closest to the OL, and this is the condenser aperture when the column is used in CTEM mode. An important feature of the CTEM/STEM when operating in the STEM mode is that there are a comparatively large number of postspecimen lenses available. The condenser-objective lens ensures that the beam is narrow when entering these lenses, and so coupling with high compression to an EELS spectrometer does not incur the large aberrations discussed earlier. Further pitfalls associated with high compression should be borne in mind, however. The chromatic aberration of the coupling to the EELS will increase as the compression is increased, leading to edges being out of focus at different energies. Also, the scan of the probe will be magnified in the dispersion plane of the prism, so careful descan needs to be done postsample. A final feature of the extensive postsample optics is that a high magnification image of the probe can be formed in the image plane. This is not as useful for diagnosing aberrations in the probe as one might expect because the aberrations might well be arising from aberrations in the TEM imaging system. Nonetheless, potential applications for such a confocal arrangement have been discussed (see, for example, Möbus and Nufer, 2003).
pole piece sample electron beam
Figure 2–23. A condenser-objective lens provides symmetrical focusing on either side of the central plane. It can therefore be used to provide postsample imaging, as in a CTEM, or to focus a probe at the sample, as in a STEM, or even to provide both simultaneously if direct imaging of the STEM probe is required.
113
114 Peter D. Nellist
9. Electron Sources 9.1 The Need for Sufficient Brightness Naively one might expect that the size of the electron source is not critical to the operation of a STEM because we have condenser lenses available in the column to increase the demagnification of the source at will, and thereby still be able to form an image of the source that is below the diffraction limit. We will see, however, that increasing the demagnification decreases the current available in the probe, and the performance of a STEM relies on focusing a significant current into a small spot. In fact, the crucial parameter of interest is that of brightness (see, for example, Born and Wolf, 1980). The brightness is defined at the source as B = I AΩ
(9.1)
where I is the total current emitted, A is the area of the source over which the electrons are emitted, and Ω is the solid angle into which the electrons are emitted. Brightness is a useful quantity because at any plane conjugate to the image source (which means any plane where there is a beam crossover), brightness is conserved. This statement holds as long as we consider only geometric optics, which means that we neglect the effects of diffraction. Figure 2–24 shows schematically how the conservation of brightness operates. As the demagnification of an electron source is increased, reducing the area A of the image, the solid angle Ω increases in proportion. Introduction of a beamlimiting aperture forces Ω to be constant, and therefore the total beam current, I, decreases in proportion to the decrease in the area of the source image.
condenser lens objective aperture
objective lens
Figure 2–24. A schematic diagram showing how beam current is lost as the source demagnification increased. Reducing the focal length of the condenser lens further demagnifies the image of the source, but the solid angle of the beam correspondingly increases (dashed lines). At a fixed aperture, such as an objective aperture, more current is lost when the beam solid angle increases.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
Conservation of brightness is extremely powerful when applied to the STEM. At the probe, the solid angle of illumination is defined by the angle subtended by the objective aperture, α. The maximum value of α is dictated primarily by the spherical aberration of the microscope, and can therefore be regarded as a constant. Given the brightness of the source, we can immediately infer the beam current given the desired size of the source image, or vice versa. Knowledge of the source size is important in determining the resolution of the instrument for a given source size. We can now ask what the necessary source brightness for a viable STEM instrument is. In an order-of-magnitude estimation, we can assume that we need about 25 pA focused into a probe diameter, dsrc, of 0.1 nm. In an uncorrected machine, the spherical aberration of the objective lens limits α to about 10 mrad. The corresponding brightness can then be computed from B=
(
I πdsrc 2
)
2 4 ( πα )
(9.2)
which gives B ~ 109 A cm−2 sr−1, expressed in its conventional units. Having determined the order of brightness required for a STEM we should now compare this number with commonly available electron sources. A tungsten filament thermionic emitter operating at 100 kV has a brightness B of around 106 A cm−2 sr−1, and even an LaB6 thermionic emitter improves this by only a factor of 10 or so. The only electron sources currently developed that can reach the desired brightness are field-emission sources. 9.2 The Cold Field-Emission Gun In developing a STEM in their laboratory, a prerequisite for Crewe and co-workers was to develop a field emission gun (Crewe et al., 1968a). The gun they developed was a CFEG, shown schematically in Figure 2–25. The principle is shown in Figure 2–26. A tip is formed by electrochemically etching a short length of single crystal tungsten wire (a typical crystallographic orientation is [310]) to form a point with a typical radius of 50–100 nm. When a voltage is applied to the extraction anode, an intense electron field is applied to the sharp tip. The potential in the vacuum immediately outside the tip therefore has a large gradient, resulting in a potential barrier small enough for conduction electrons to tunnel out of the tungsten into the vacuum. An extraction potential of around 3 kV is usually required. A second anode, or multiple anodes, is then provided to accelerate the electrons to the desired total accelerating voltage. Although the total current emitted by a CFEG (typically 5 µA) is small compared to other electron sources (a W hairpin filament can reach 100 µA), the brightness of a 100-kV CFEG can reach 2 × 109 A cm−2 sr−1. The explanation lies in the small area of emission (~ 5 nm) and the small solid angle cone into which the electrons are emitted (semiangle of 4°). Electrons are likely to tunnel into the vacuum only over the small area in which the extraction field is high enough or where a surface with a suit-
115
116 Peter D. Nellist second anode 100 kV first anode ~ 3 kV
field emission tip
Figure 2–25. A schematic diagram of a 100-kV cold field-emission gun. The proximity of the first anode combined with the sharpness of the tip leads to an intense electric field at the tip, thus extracting the electrons. The first anode is sometime referred to as the extraction anode. The second anode provides the further acceleration up to the full beam energy.
ably low workfunction is presented, leading to a small emission area. Only electrons near the Fermi level in the tip are likely to tunnel, and only those whose Fermi velocity is directed perpendicular to the surface, leading to a small emission cone. In addition, the energy spread of the beam from a CFEG is much lower than for other sources, and can be less than 0.3 eV FWHM. A consequence of the large electrostatic field required for cold field emission is that ultrahigh vacuum conditions are required. Any gas molecules in the gun that become positively ionized by the electron beam will be accelerated and focused directly on the sharp tip. Sputtering of the tip by these ions will rapidly degrade and blunt the tip until its radius of curvature is too large to generate the high fields required for emission. Pressures in the low 10−11 Torr are usually maintained in a CFEG. Achieving this kind of pressure requires that the gun be bakable to greater than 200°C, which imposes constraints on the materials and methods of gun construction. Nonetheless, the tip will slowly become contaminated during operation leading to a decay in the beam current. Regular “flashing” is required, whereby a current
f EF
slope due to electric field
tunnelling
free electron propagating in vacuum
Figure 2–26. A schematic diagram showing the principle of cold fieldemission. The vacuum energy level is pulled down into a steep gradient by the application of a strong electric field, producing a triangular energy barrier of height given by the work function, φ. Electrons close to the Fermi energy, EF, can tunnel through the barrier to become free electrons propagating in the vacuum.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
is passed through the tip support wire to heat the tip and to desorb the contamination. This is typically necessary once every few hours. 9.3 The Schottky FEG Cold FEGs have until now been found commercially only in dedicated STEM instruments of VG Microscopes (no longer manufactured) and in some instruments manufactured by Hitachi, although the manufacturers’ ranges are always changing. More common is the thermally assisted Schottky field-emission source, introduced by Swanson and co-workers (Swanson and Crouser, 1967). The principle of operation of the Schottky source is similar to the CFEG, with two major differences: the workfunction of the tungsten tip is lowered by the addition of a zirconia layer, and the tip is heated to around 1700 K. Lowering the workfunction reduces the potential barrier through which electrons have to tunnel to reach the vacuum. Heating the tip promotes the energy at which the electrons are incident on the potential barrier, increasing their probability of tunneling. Heating the tip is also necessary to maintain the zirconia layer on the tip. A reservoir of zirconium metal is provided in the form of a donut on the shank of the tip. The heating of the tip allows zirconium metal to surface migrate under the influence of the electrostatic field toward the sharpened end, oxidizing as it does so as to form a zirconia layer. Compared to the CFEG, the Schottky source has some advantages and disadvantages. Among the advantages are the fact that the vacuum requirements for the tip are much less strict since the zirconia layer is reformed as soon as it is sputtered away. The Schottky source also has a much greater emission current (around 100 µA) than the CFEG. This makes is a useful source for combination CTEM/STEM instruments with sufficient current for parallel illumination for CTEM work. Disadvantages include a lower brightness (around 2 × 108 A cm−2 sr−1) and a large emission area, which requires greater demagnification for forming atomic sized probes. For applications involving high-energy resolution spectroscopy, a more serious drawback is the energy spread of the Schottky source at about 0.8 eV.
10. Resolution Limits and Aberration Correction Having reviewed the STEM instrument and its applications, we finish by reviewing the factors that limit the resolution of the machine. In practice there can be many reasons for a loss in resolution, for example, microscope instabilities or problems with the sample. Here we will review the most fundamental resolution-limiting factors: the finite source brightness, spherical aberration, and chromatic aberration. Round electron lenses suffer from inherent spherical and chromatic aberrations (Scherzer, 1936), and these aberrations dominate the ultimate resolution of STEM. For a field-emission gun, in particular a cold FEG, the energy width of the beam is small, and the effect of CC is usually smaller than for CS. The effect of spherical aberration on the resolution and the need for an objective aperture to limit the higher-angle more
117
118 Peter D. Nellist
aberrated beams have been discussed in Section 2, so here we focus on the effect of the finite brightness and chromatic aberration. Finally we describe the benefits that arise from spherical aberration correction in STEM, and show further applications of aberration correction. 10.1 The Effect of the Finite Source Size In Section 1 it was mentioned that the probe size in a STEM can be either source size or diffraction limited. In both regimes, the performance of the STEM is limited by the aberrations of the lenses. The aberrations of the OL usually dominate, but in certain modes, such as particularly high current modes, the aberrations of the condenser lenses and even the gun optics might start to have an effect. The lens aberrations limit the maximum size of the beam that may pass through the OL to be focused into the probe. A physical aperture prevents higher angle, more aberrated rays from contributing. The size of the diffraction-limited probe was described in Section 2. When the probe is diffraction limited, the aperture defines the size of the probe. The resolution of the STEM can be defined in many different ways, and will be different for different modes of imaging. For incoherent imaging we are concerned with the probe intensity, and the fullwidth at half-maximum may be used given by Eq. (2.9), and repeated here, ddiff = 0.4λ3/4CS1/4
(10.1)
In the diffraction-limited regime, there is no dependence of the probe size on the probe current. Once the image of the demagnified source is larger than the diffraction limit, though, the probe will be source size limited. Now the probe size may be traded against the probe current through the source brightness, by rearranging Eq. (9.2) to give dsrc =
4I Bπ 2 α 2
(10.2)
Note that the probe current is limited by the size of the objective aperture, α, and is therefore still limited by the lens aberrations. The effect of the finite source size will depend on the data being acquired. It can be thought of as an incoherent sum (i.e., a sum in intensity) of many diffraction-limited probes displaced over the source image at the sample. To explain the effect of the finite source size on an experiment, the measurement made for a diffraction-limited probe arising from an infinitesimal source should be summed in intensity with the probe shifted over the source distribution. The effect on a Ronchigram is to blur the fringes in the disc overlap regions. Remember that the fringes in a disc overlap region correspond to a sample spacing whose spatial frequency is given by the difference of the g-vectors of the overlapping discs. Once the source size as imaged at the sample is larger than the relevant spacing, the fringes will disappear. This is a very different effect to increasing the probe size through a coherent aberration, such as by defocusing the probe. Defocusing the
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
119
probe will lead to changes in the fringe geometry in the Ronchigram, but not in their visibility. The finite source size, however, will reduce the visibility of the fringes. The Ronchigram is therefore an excellent method for measuring the source size of a microscope. The effect of the finite source size on a BF image is a simple blurring of the image intensity, as would be expected from reciprocity. Once again the image should be computed for a diffraction limited probe arising from an infinitesimal source, and then the image intensity blurred over the profile of the source as imaged at the sample. Because BF is a coherent imaging mode, the effect of a finite source size is different to simply increasing the probe size. The effect of the finite source size on incoherent imaging, such as ADF, is simplest. Because the image is already incoherent, the effect of the finite source size can be thought of as simply increasing the probe size in the experiment. Assuming that both the probe profile and the source image profile are approximately gaussian in form, the combined probe size can be approximated by adding in quadrature, d 2probe = d 2diff + d 2src
(10.3)
This allows us now to generate a plot of the probe size for incoherent imaging versus the probe current (Figure 2–27). 10.2 Chromatic Aberration It is not surprising that electrons of higher energies will be less strongly deflected by a magnetic field than those of lower energy. The result of 100000
Probe current (pA)
10000
1000 Uncorrected Cs-Corrected 100
10
1 0
2
4
6
8
10
Probe size (angstroms)
Figure 2–27. A plot of probe size for incoherent imaging versus beam current for both a CS-afflicted and CS-corrected machine. The parameters used are 100 kV CFEG with CS = 1.3 mm. Note the diffraction-limited regime where the probe size is independent of current, changing over to a source-sizelimited regime at large currents.
120 Peter D. Nellist
this is that the energy spread of the beam will manifest itself as a spread of focal lengths when focused by a lens. In fact, the intrinsic energy spread, instabilities in the high-voltage supply, and instabilities in the lens supply currents will all give rise to a defocus spread through the formula ∆E 2∆I ∆V ∆z = Cc + + V0 I0 V0
)
(10.4)
where ∆E is the intrinsic energy spread of the beam, ∆V is the variation in accelerating voltage supply, ∆V0, and I is the fluctuation in the lens current supply, I0. In a modern instrument, the first term should dominate, even with the low energy spread of a CFEG. A typical defocus spread for a 100-kV CFEG instrument will be around 5 nm. Chromatic aberration is an incoherent aberration, and behaves in a way somewhat similar to the finite source size as described above. The effect of the aberration again depends on the data being acquired. The effect of the defocus spread can be thought of as an incoherent sum (i.e., a sum in intensity) of many experiments performed at a range of defocus values integrated over the defocus spread. The effect of chromatic aberration on a Ronchigram has been described in detail by Nellist and Rodenburg (1994). Briefly, the perpendicular bisector of the line joining the center of two overlapping discs is achromatic, which means that the intensity does not depend on the defocus value. This is because defocus causes a symmetric phase shift in the incoming beam, and beams equidistant from the center of a disc will therefore suffer the same phase shift resulting in no change to the interference pattern. Away from the achromatic lines, the visibility of the interference fringes will start to reduce. The effect of CC on phase contrast imaging has been extensively described in the literature (see, for example, Wade, 1992; Spence, 1988). Here we simply note that in the weak-phase regime, CC gives rise to a damping envelope in reciprocal space, ECc(Q) = exp−1–2π2λ2(∆z)2|Q|4 (10.5) where Q is the spatial frequency in the image. Clearly Eq. (10.5) shows that the Q4 dependence in the exponential means that CC imposes a sharp truncation on the maximum spatial frequency of the image transfer. In contrast, the effect of CC on incoherent imaging is much less severe. Once again, the effect for incoherent imaging can simply be incorporated by changing the probe intensity profile, Pchr(R), through the expression Pchr (R ) = ∫ f ( z ) P (R , z ) 2 dz
(10.6)
where f(z) is the distribution function of the defocus values. Nellist and Pennycook (1998b) have derived the effect of CC on the optical transfer function (OTF). Rather than imposing a multiplicative envelope function, the chromatic spread leads to an upper limit on the OTF that goes as 1/|Q|. A plot of the effects of CC on the incoherent optical transfer function is shown in Figure 2–28. An interesting feature
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
121
dE = 0
OTF
dE = 0.5 eV dE=1.5 eV 1/Q
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1/angstrom
Figure 2–28. A plot of the incoherent optical transfer functions (OTFs) for various defocus spread FWHM values. The microscope parameters are 100 kV with CS corrected but C5 = 0.1 m. Note how the effect is to limit the magnitude of the OTF by a value proportional to the reciprocal of spatial frequency. Such a limit mostly affects the midrange frequencies and not the highest spatial frequencies.
of the effect of CC on the incoherent transfer function is that the highest spatial frequencies transferred are little affected, explaining the ability of incoherent imaging to reach high spatial resolutions despite any effects of CC, as shown in Nellist and Pennycook (1998b). An intuitive explanation of this phenomenon can be found in both real and reciprocal space approaches. In reciprocal space, STEM incoherent imaging can be considered as arising from separate partial plane wave components in the convergent beam that are scattered into the same final wavevector and thereby interfere (see Section 5). The highest spatial frequencies arise from plane wave components on the convergent beam that are separated maximally, which, since the aperture is round, is when they are close to being diametrically opposite. The interference between such beams is often described as being achromatic because the phase shift due to changes in defocus will be identical for both beams, with no resulting effect on the interference. Coherent phase contrast imaging, however, relies on interference between a strong axial beam and scattered beams near the aperture edge, resulting in a high sensitivity to chromatic defocus spread. The real-space explanation is perhaps simpler. Coherent imaging, as formulated by (5.2), is sensitive to the phase of the probe wavefunction, and the phase will change rapidly as a function of defocus. Summing the image intensities over the chromatic defocus spread will then wash out the high resolution contrast. Incoherent imaging is sensitive only to the intensity of the probe, which is a much more slowly varying
122 Peter D. Nellist
function of defocus. Summing probe intensities over a range of defocus values (see Figure 2–29) shows the effect. The central peak of the probe intensity remains narrow, but intensity is lost to a skirt that extends some distance. Analytical studies will be particularly affected by the skirt, but for a CFEG gun, the effect of CC will show up only at the highest resolutions, and typically is only seen after the correction of CS. Krivanek (private communication) has given a simple formula for the fraction of the probe intensity that is shifted away from the probe maximum, fs = (1 − w)2
(10.7)
w = 2d2gE0/(∆ECCλ) or w = 1, whichever is smaller,
(10.8)
where
A 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
angstrom B 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
angstrom Figure 2–29. Probe profile plots with (A) and without (B) a chromatic defocus spread of 7.5 nm FWHM. The microscope parameters are 100 kV with CS corrected but C5 = 0.1 m. Note that the width of the main peak of the probe is not greatly affected, but intensity is lost from the central maximum into diffuse tails around the probe.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
and dg is the resolution in the absence of chromatic aberration. At a resolution dg = 0.8 Å, energy spread ∆E = 0.5 eV, coefficient of chromatic aberration Cc = 1.5 mm, and primary energy E0 = 100 keV, the above gives fs = 30% as the fraction of the electron flux shifted out of the probe maximum into the probe tail. This shows that with the low energy spread of a cold field emission gun, the present-day 100 kV performance is not strongly limited by chromatic aberration. 10.3 Aberration Correction We have spent a lot of time discussing the effects of lens aberrations on STEM performance. Except for some specific circumstances, round electron lenses always suffer positive spherical and chromatic aberrations. This essential fact was first proved by Scherzer in 1936 (Scherzer, 1936), and until recently lens aberrations were the resolution-limiting factor. Scherzer also pointed out that nonround lenses could be arranged to provide negative aberrations (Scherzer, 1947), thereby providing correction of the round lens aberrations. He also proposed a corrector design, but it is only within the last decade that aberration correctors have started to improve microscope resolution over those of uncorrected machines [see, for example, Zach and Haider (1995) for SEM, Haider et al. (1998b) for TEM, and Batson et al. (2002) and Nellist et al. (2004) for STEM]. The key has been the control of parasitic aberrations. Aberration correctors consist of multiple layers of nonround lenses. Unless the lenses are machined perfectly and aligned to each other and the round lenses they are correcting perfectly, nonround parasitic aberrations, such as coma and three-fold astigmatism, will arise and negate the beneficial effects of correction. Recent aberration correctors have been machined to extremely high tolerances, and additional windings and multipoles have been provided to enable correction of the parasitic aberrations. Perhaps even more crucial has been the development of computers and algorithms that can measure and diagnose aberrations fast enough to feed back to the multipole power supplies to correct the parasitic aberrations. A particularly powerful way of measuring the lens aberrations is through the local apparent magnification of the Ronchigram of a nonperiodic object (Dellby et al., 2001) (see Section 3.2). The key benefits of spherical aberration correction in STEM are illustrated by Figure 2–27. Correction of spherical aberration allows a larger objective aperture to be used because it is no longer necessary to exclude beams that previously would have been highly aberrated. A larger objective aperture has two results: First, the diffraction-limited probe size is smaller so the spatial resolution of the microscope is increased. Second, in the regime in which the electron source size is dominant, the larger objective aperture allows a greater current in the same size probe. Figure 2–27 shows both effects clearly. For low currents the diffraction-limited probe decreases in size by almost a factor of two. In the source size-limited regime, for a given probe size, spherical aberration correction increases the current available by more than an order of magnitude. The increased current available in a CS cor-
123
124 Peter D. Nellist
rected STEM is very important for fast elemental mapping or even mapping of subtle changes in fine structure using spectrum imaging (Nellist et al., 2003) (see Section 6). So far, the impact of spherical aberration correction on resolution has probably been greater in STEM than in CTEM. Part of the reason lies in the robustness of STEM incoherent imaging to CC. Correction of CC is more difficult than for CS, and at the time of writing a commercial CC corrector for high-resolution TEM instruments is not available. We saw in Section 10.2 that compared to HRTEM, the resolution of STEM incoherent imaging is not severely limited by CC. Furthermore, the dedicated STEM instruments that have given the highest resolutions have all used cold field emission guns with a low intrinsic energy spread. A second reason for the superior CS-corrected performance of STEM instruments lies in the fact that they are scanning instruments. In a STEM, the scan coils are usually placed close to the objective lens and certainly there are no optical elements between the scan coils and the objective lens. This means that in most of the electron optics, in particular the corrector, the beam is fixed and its position does not depend on the position of the probe in the image, unlike the case for CTEM. In STEM therefore, only the so-called axial aberrations need to be measured and corrected, a much reduced number compared to CTEM for which off-axial aberrations must also be monitored. Commercially available CS correctors are currently available from Nion Co. in the United States and CEOS GmbH in Germany. The existing Nion corrector is a quadrupole–octupole design, and is retrofitted into existing VG Microscopes dedicated STEM instruments. Because the field strength in an octupole varies as the cube of the radial distance, it is clear that an octupole should provide a third-order deflection to the beam. However, the four-fold rotational symmetry of the octupole means that a single octupole acting on a round beam will simply introduce third-order four-fold astigmatism. A series of four quadrupoles is therefore used to focus line crossovers in two octupoles, while allowing a round beam to be acted on by the third (central) octupole (see figures in Krivanek et al., 1999). The line crossovers in the outer two octupoles give rise to third-order correction in two perpendicular directions, which provides the necessary negative spherical aberration, but also leaves some residual four-fold astigmatism that is corrected by the third central round-beam octupole. This design is loosely based on Scherzer’s original design that used cylindrical lenses (Scherzer, 1947). Although this design corrects the third-order CS, it actually worsens the fifthorder aberrations. Nonetheless, it has been extremely successful and productive scientifically. A more recent corrector design from Nion (Krivanek et al., 2003) allows correction of the fifth-order aberrations also. Again it is based on third-order correction by three octupoles, but with a greater number of quadrupole layers, which can provide control of the fifth-order aberrations. This more complicated corrector is being incorporated into an entirely new STEM column designed to optimize performance with aberration correction. An alternative corrector design that is suitable for both HRTEM and STEM use has been developed by CEOS (Haider et al., 1998a). It is based on a design by Shao (1988) and further developed by Rose (1990).
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
78 pm
Figure 2–30. An ADF STEM image of Si<112> recorded using a 300-kV VG Microscopes HB603U STEM fitted with a Nion aberration corrector. The 78 pm spacing of the atomic columns in this projection is well resolved, as can be seen in the intensity profile plot from the region indicated.
It includes two sextupole lenses with four additional round lens coupling lenses. The primary aberration of a sextupole is three-fold astigmatism, but if the sextupole is extended in length it can also generate negative, round spherical aberration. If two sextupoles are used and suitably coupled by round lenses, the three-fold astigmatism from each of them can cancel, resulting in pure, negative spherical aberration. The optical coupling between the sextupole layers and the objective lens means that the off-axial aberrations are also canceled, which allows the use of this kind of corrector for HRTEM imaging in addition to STEM imaging. Aberration correction in STEM has already produced high impact results. The improvement in resolution has been dramatic with a resolution as high as 0.78 Å and information transfer to 0.6 Å being demonstrated (Figure 2–30) (Nellist et al., 2004). The ability to image at atomic resolution along different orientations has allowed a full, threedimensional reconstruction of a heterointerface to be determined (Falke et al., 2004). Spectroscopy of single atoms of impurities in a doped crystalline matrix has been demonstrated (Varela et al., 2004). Clearly, aberration correction in STEM is now well established and will become more commonplace.
11. Conclusions In this chapter we have tried to describe the range of techniques available in a STEM, the principles behind those techniques, and some examples of applications. Naturally there are many similarities
125
126 Peter D. Nellist
between the CTEM and the STEM, and some of the imaging modes are equivalent. Certain techniques in STEM, however, are unique, and have particular strengths. In particular, STEM is being used for ADF and electron energy-loss spectroscopy. The ADF imaging mode is important because it is an incoherent imaging mode and shows atomic number (Z) contrast. The incoherent nature of ADF imaging makes the images simpler to interpret in terms of the atomic structure under observation, and we have described how it has been used to determine atomic structures at interfaces, even correcting earlier structural analyses by HRTEM. The CTEM cannot efficiently provide an incoherent imaging mode. The spatial resolution of STEM can also be applied to composition analysis through EELS, and atomic resolution and single-atom sensitivity are both now being demonstrated. Not only can EELS provide compositional information, but analysis of the fi ne structure of spectra can reveal information on the bonding between materials. The capabilities listed above, combined with the availability of combination CTEM/STEM instruments, has dramatically increased the popularity of STEM. For many years, the only high-resolution STEM instruments available were dedicated STEM instruments with a CFEG. These machines were designed as high-end research machines and they tended to be operated by experts who could devote time to their operation and maintenance. Modern CTEM/STEM instruments are much more user friendly, and the Schottky gun system usually found on such machines is easier to operate. We have also discussed some of the technical details of the electron optics and resolution- limiting factors, which raises the question of where the development of STEM instrumentation is likely to go in the future. Clearly spherical aberration correction is already having a major impact on STEM performance, and the fraction of STEM instruments fitted with correctors is bound to increase. The benefits of aberration correction are not only the increased spatial resolution, but also the dramatically improved beam current and also the possibility of creating more room around the sample for in situ experiments. The increased beam current already allows fast mapping of spectrum images with sufficient signal to noise for fitting of fine-structure changes. Much faster elemental mapping should become possible, with acquisition rates perhaps reaching 1000 spectra/s, which would allow a 256 by 256 pixel spectrum image to be recorded in around 1 min. To achieve this goal, however, requires further development of the spectra acquisition instrumentation, such as the CCD camera and probe scan controller. With aberration correction now available it is often found that the STEM performance is being limited by other aspects of the instrumentation. It is now an excellent time for a reevaluation of the design of electron-optical columns to be used for aberration-corrected STEM. Already a number of manufacturers are launching new columns and the STEM community is eagerly awaiting new data demonstrating their performance. New columns also allow the inclusion of in situ experiments, and we are likely to see columns fitted with scanning probe systems, nanomanipulators, or environmental cells. Environ-
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
mental cells, for example, would add to the STEM’s existing strengths in the imaging of dispersed catalysts by allowing samples to be viewed while being dosed with active gases. The other important technical development currently being introduced into STEM instruments is monochromation. There are two motivations for this development. Obviously a more monochromated beam will lead to improved energy resolution in EELS. Defect states in band gaps would become visible in the low-loss spectrum and core-loss fine structure would show greater detail. Furthermore, Schottky guns have a greater energy spread in the beam (about 0.8 eV) compared to a CFEG (about 0.3 eV), so there is a strong motivation to fit Schottky systems with a monochromator to improve their energy resolution. With a spherical aberration-corrected machine, the spatial resolution is then limited by chromatic aberration, which will be worse for a Schottky gun, hence a spatial resolution benefit from monochromation. An important consequence of monochromation, however, is that it reduces the brightness of the electron gun. Nonetheless, it is possible to produce monochromated atomic-scale probes (Mayer et al., 2007). Starting with a gun that is brighter and has an intrinsically narrower energy spread, such as a CFEG, obviously has strong benefits for STEM. Time will tell whether the CFEG will become more popular again. Nevertheless, it is clear that STEM itself has a very strong future in the imaging and analysis of materials. References Abe, E., Pennycook, S. J. and Tsai, A. P. (2003). Direct observation of a local thermal vibration anomoly in a quasicrystal. Nature 421, 347. Allen, L. J., Findlay, S. D., Lupini, A. R., Oxley, M. P. and Pennycook, S. J. (2003a). Atomic-resolution electron energy loss spectroscopy imaging in aberration corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy. Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 105503. Allen, L. J., Findlay, S. D., Oxley, M. P. and Rossouw, C. J. (2003b). Latticeresolution contrast from a focused coherent electon probe. Part I. Ultramicroscopy 96, 47. Amali, A. and Rez, P. (1997). Theory of lattice resolution in high-angle annular dark-field images. Microscopy and Microanalysis 3, 28. Anderson, S. C., Birkeland, C. R., Anstis, G. R. and Cockayne, D. J. H. (1997). An approach to quantitative compositional profiling at near-atomic resolution using high-angle annular dark field imaging. Ultramicroscopy 69, 83. Batson, P. E. (1993). Simultaneous STEM imaging and electron energy-loss spectroscopy with atomic-column sensitivity. Nature 366, 727. Batson, P. E. (2000). Structural and electron characterisation of a dissociated 60 degrees dislocation in GeSi. Phys. Rev. B 61, 16633. Batson, P. E., Dellby, N. and Krivanek, O. L. (2002). Sub-ångstrom resolution using aberration corrected electron optics. Nature 418, 617. Black, G. and Linfoot, E. H. (1957). Spherical aberration and the information limit of optical images. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 239, 522. Bonnet, N., Brun, N. and Colliex, C. (1999). Extracting information from sequences of spatially resolved EELS spectra using multivariate statistical analysis. Ultramicroscopy 77, 97. Born, M. and Wolf, E. (1980). Principles of Optics (Oxford, Pergamon Press).
127
128 Peter D. Nellist Brink, H. A., Barfels, M. M. G., Burgner, R. P. and Edwards, B. N. (2003). A sub-50 meV spectrometer and energy-filter for use in combination with 200 kV monochromated (S)TEMs. Ultramicroscopy 96, 367. Brown, L. M. (1981). Scanning transmission electron microscopy: microanalysis for the microelectronic age. J. Phys. F 11, 1. Browning, N. D., Chisholm, M. F. and Pennycook, S. J. (1993). Atomicresolution chemical analysis using a scanning transmission electron microscope. Nature 366, 143. Brydson, R. (2001). Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy (Oxford, BIOS). Chisholm, M. F., Maiti, A., Pennycook, S. J. and Pantelides, S. T. (1998). Atomic confi guration and energetics of arsenic impurities in a silicon grain boundary. Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 132. Cosgriff, E. C., Oxley, M. P., Allen, L. J. and Pennycook, S. J. (2005). The spatial resolution of imaging using core-loss spectroscopy in the scanning transmission electron microscope. Ultramicroscopy 102, 317. Cowley, J. M. (1969). Image contrast in a transmission scanning electron microscope. Appl. Phys. Lett. 15, 58. Cowley, J. M. (1976). Scanning transmission electron microscopy of thin specimens. Ultramicroscopy 2, 3. Cowley, J. M. (1978). Electron microdiffraction. Adv. Electronics & Electron Phys. 4,6, 1. Cowley, J. M. (1979a). Adjustment of a STEM instrument by Use of Shadow Images. Ultramicroscopy 4, 413. Cowley, J. M. (1979b). Coherent interference in convergent-beam electron diffraction & shadow imaging. Ultramicroscopy 4, 435. Cowley, J. M. (1981). Coherent interference effects in SIEM and CBED. Ultramicroscopy 7, 19. Cowley, J. M. (1986). Electron-diffraction phenomena observed with a highresolution STEM Instrument. J. Electron Microsc. Tech. 3, 25. Cowley, J. M. (1990). Diffraction Physics (Amsterdam, North-Holland). Cowley, J. M. (1992). Electron Diffraction Techniques (Oxford, OUP). Cowley, J. M. and Disko, M. M. (1980). Fresnel diffraction in a coherent convergent electron beam. Ultramicroscopy 5, 469. Crewe, A. V. (1980). The physics of the high-resolution STEM. Rep. Prog. Phys. 43, 621. Crewe, A. V., Eggenberger, D. N., Wall, J. and Welter, L. M. (1968a). Electron gun using a field emission source. Rev. Sci. Instr. 39, 576. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J. and Welter, L. M. (1968b). A high-resolution scanning transmission electron microscope. J. Appl. Phys. 39, 5861. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J. and Langmore, J. (1970). Visibility of single atoms. Science 168, 1338. Dellby, N., Krivanek, O. L., Nellist, P. D., Batson, P. E. and Lupini, A. R. (2001). Progress in aberration-corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy. J. Electron Microsc. 50, 177. Dinges, C., Berger, A. and Rose, H. (1995). Simulation of TEM images considering phonon and electron excitations. Ultramicroscopy 60, 49. Donald, A. M. and Craven, A. J. (1979). A study of grain boundary segregation in Cu-Bi alloys using STEM. Philosophical Magazine A39, 1. Egerton, R. F. (1996). Electron Energy-Loss Spectroscopy in the Electron Microscope (New York, Plenum Press). Falke, U., Bleloch, A. L., Falke, M. and Teichert, S. (2004). Atomic structure of a (2x1) Reconstructed NiSi2/Si(001) Interface. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 116103. Fertig, J. and Rose, H. (1981). Resolution and contrast of crystalline objects in high-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy. Optik 59, 407.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy Findlay, S. D., Allen, L. J., Oxley, M. P. and Rossouw, C. J. (2003). Latticeresolution contrast from a focused coherent electron probe. Part II. Ultramicroscopy 96, 65. Gabor, D. (1948). A new microscope principle. Nature 161, 777. Haider, M., Rose, H., Uhlemann, S., Schwan, E., Kabius, B. and Urban, K. (1998a). A spherical-aberration-corrected 200 kV transmission electron microscope. Ultramicroscopy 75, 53. Haider, M., Uhlemann, S., Schwan, E., Rose, H., Kabius, B. and Urban, K. (1998b). Electron microscopy image enhanced. Nature 392, 768. Hartel, P., Rose, H. and Dinges, C. (1996). Conditions and reasons for incoherent imaging in STEM. Ultramicroscopy 63, 93. Hillyard, S., Loane, R. F. and Silcox, J. (1993). Annular dark-field imaging: resolution and thickness effects. Ultramicroscopy 49, 14. Hillyard, S. and Silcox, J. (1993). Thickness effects in ADF STEM zone axis images. Ultramicroscopy 52, 325. Hirsch, P., Howie, A., Nicholson, R., Pashley, D. W. and Whelan, M. J. (1977). Electron Microscopy of Thin Crystals (Malabar, Krieger). Hoppe, W. (1969a). Beugung im inhomogenen primärstrahlwellenfeld. I. Prinzip einer Phasenmessung von Elektronenbeugungsinterferenzen. Acta Cryst. A 25, 495. Hoppe, W. (1969b). Beugung im inhomogenen primärstrahlwellenfeld. III. Amplituden- und Phasenbestimmung bei unperiodischen Objekten. Acta Cryst. A 25, 508. Hoppe, W. (1982). Trace structure analysis, ptychography, phase tomography. Ultramicroscopy 10, 187. Howie, A. (1979). Image contrast and localised signal selection techniques. J. Microsc. 117, 11. James, E. M. and Browning, N. D. (1999). Practical aspects of atomic resolution imaging and analysis in STEM. Ultramicroscopy 78, 125. Jesson, D. E. and Pennycook, S. J. (1993). Incoherent imaging of thin specimens using coherently scattered electrons. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 441, 261. Jesson, D. E. and Pennycook, S. J. (1995). Incoherent imaging of crystals using thermally scattered electrons. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 449, 273. Kirkland, A. I., Saxton, W. O., Chau, K. L., Tsuno, K. and Kawasaki, M. (1995). Superresolution by aperture synthesis—Tilt series reconstruction in CTEM. Ultramicroscopy 57, 355. Kirkland, E. J., Loane, R. F. and Silcox, J. (1987). Simulation of annular dark field STEM images using a modifi ed multislice method. Ultramicroscopy 23, 77. Kohl, H. and Rose, H. (1985). Theory of image formation by inelastically scattered electrons in the electron microscope. Adv. Electronics & Electron Phys. 65, 173. Krivanek, O. L., Dellby, N. and Lupini, A. R. (1999). Towards sub-Å electron beams. Ultramicroscopy 78, 1. Krivanek, O. L., Nellist, P. D., Dellby, N., Murfitt, M. F. and Szilagyi, Z. (2003). Towards sub-0.5 Å electron beams. Ultramicroscopy 96, 229. Lin, J. A. and Cowley, J. M. (1986). Reconstruction from In-Line Electron Holograms by Digital Processing. Ultramicroscopy 19, 179. Loane, R. F., Xu, P. and Silcox, J. (1991). Thermal vibrations in convergentbeam electron diffraction. Acta Cryst. A 47, 267. Loane, R. F., Xu, P. and Silcox, J. (1992). Incoherent imaging of zone axis crystals with ADF STEM. Ultramicroscopy 40, 121. Lupini, A. R. (2001). Cavendish laboratory, The University of Cambridge. PhD Thesis.
129
130 Peter D. Nellist Lupini, A. R. and Pennycook, S. J. (2003). Localisation in elastic and inelastic scattering. Ultramicroscopy 96, 313. Lyman, C. E., Goldstein, J. I., Williams, D. B., Ackland, D. W., Von Harrach, S., Nicholls, A. W. and Statham, P. J. (1994). High performance X-ray detection in a new analytical electron microscope. J. Microsc. 176, 85. *Mayer, J., Houben, L., Lopatin, S., Luysberg, M., and Thust, A. (2007). Performance and applications of the aberration corrected TEM and STEM instruments at the Ernst Ruska-Centre. In Proceedings of microscopy and microanalysis 2007, Microscopy and Microanalysis 13(Suppl 2), 128. McGibbon, A. J., Pennycook, S. J. and Angelo, J. E. (1995). Direct observation of dislocation core structures in CdTe/GaAs(001). Science 269, 519. McGibbon, M. M., Browning, N. D., Chisholm, M. F., McGibbon, A. J., Pennycook, S. J., Ravikumar, V. and Dravid, V. P. (1994). Direct determination of grain boundary atomic structures in SrTiO 3. Science 266, 102. Mitsuishi, K., Takeguchi, M., Yasuda, H. and Furuya, K. (2001). New scheme for calculation of annular dark-field STEM image including both elastically diffracted and TDS wave. J. Electron Microsc. 50, 157. Möbus, G. and Nufer, S. (2003). Nanobeam propagation and imaging in a FEGTEM/STEM. Ultramicroscopy 96, 285. Mory, C., Colliex, C. and Cowley, J. M. (1987). Optimum defocus for STEM imaging and microanalysis. Ultramicroscopy 21, 171. Mullejans, H., Bleloch, A. L., Howie, A. and Tomita, M. (1993). Secondaryelectron coincidence detection and time-of-flight spectroscopy. Ultramicroscopy 52, 360. Muller, D. A., Edwards, B., Kirkland, E. J. and Silcox, J. (2001). Simulation of thermal diffuse scattering including a detailed phonon dispersion curve. Ultramicroscopy 86, 371. Muller, D. A. and Silcox, J. (1995). Delocalisation in inelastic imaging. Ultramicroscopy 59, 195. Muller, D. A., Tzou, Y., Raj, R. and Silcox, J. (1993). Mapping sp2 and sp3 states of carbon at sub-nanometre spatial resolution. Nature 366, 725. Nakanishi, N., Yamazaki, T., Recˇnik, A., Cˇeh, M., Kawasaki, M., Watanabe, K. and Shiojiri, M. (2002). Retrieval process of high-resolution HAADF-STEM images. J. Electron Microsc. 51, 383. Nellist, P. D., McCallum, B. C. and Rodenburg, J. M. (1995). Resolution beyond the “information limit” in transmission electron microscopy. Nature 374, 630. Nellist, P. D., Dellby, N., Krivanek, O. L., Murfitt, M. F., Szilagyi, Z., Lupini, A. R. and Pennycook, S. J. (2003). Towards sub-0.5 angstrom beams through aberration corrected STEM. Proceedings of EMAG2003, Oxford, (IOP Conf. Ser. 179). Nellist, P. D., Chisholm, M. F., Dellby, N., Krivanek, O. L., Murfitt, M. F., Szilagyi, Z., Lupini, A. R., Borisevich, A., Sides, W. H. J. and Pennycook, S. J. (2004). Direct sub-angstrom imaging of a crystal lattice. Science 305, 1741. Nellist, P. D. and Pennycook, S. J. (1996). Direct imaging of the atomic configuration of ultradispersed catalysts. Science 274, 413. Nellist, P. D. and Pennycook, S. J. (1998a). Accurate structure determination from image reconstruction in ADF STEM. J. Microsc. 190, 159. Nellist, P. D. and Pennycook, S. J. (1998b). Subangstrom Resolution by Underfocussed Incoherent Transmission Electron Microscopy. Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 4156. Nellist, P. D. and Pennycook, S. J. (1999). Incoherent imaging using dynamically scattered coherent electrons. Ultramicroscopy 78, 111.
Chapter 2 Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy Nellist, P. D. and Pennycook, S. J. (2000). The principles and interpretation of annular dark-field Z-contrast imaging. Adv. Imaging & Electron Phys. 113, 148. Nellist, P. D. and Rodenburg, J. M. (1994). Beyond the conventional information limit: the relevant coherence function. Ultramicroscopy 54, 61. Nellist, P. D. and Rodenburg, J. M. (1998). Electron ptychography I: experimental demonstration beyond the conventional resolution limits. Acta Cryst. A 54, 49. Pennycook, S. J. (1989). Z-contrast STEM for materials science. Ultramicroscopy 30, 58. Pennycook, S. J. (2002). Structure determination through Z-contrast microscopy. Adv. Imaging Electron Phys. 123, 173. Pennycook, S. J., Brown, L. M. and Craven, A. J. (1980). Observation of cathodoluminescence at single dislocations by STEM. Phil. Mag. A 41, 589. Pennycook, S. J. and Jesson, D. E. (1990). High-resolution incoherent imaging of crystals. Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 938. Perovic, D. D., Rossouw, C. J. and Howie, A. (1993). Imaging elastic strain in high-angle annular dark-field scanning transmission electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 52, 353. Rafferty, B. and Brown, L. M. (1998). Direct and indirect transitions in the region of the band gap using EELS. Phys. Rev. B 58, 10326. Rafferty, B., Nellist, P. D. and Pennycook, S. J. (2001). On the origin of transverse incoherence in Z-contrast STEM. J. Electron Microsc. 50, 227. Rafferty, B. and Pennycook, S. J. (1999). Towards column-by-colum spectroscopy. Ultramicroscopy 78, 141. Rayleigh, Lord (1896). On the theory of optical images with special reference to the microscope. Philosophical Magazine (5) 42, 167. Reed, S. J. B. (1982). The single-scattering model and spatial-resolution in Xray analysis of thin foils. Ultramicroscopy 7, 405. Ritchie, R. H. and Howie, A. (1988). Inelastic scattering probabilities in scanning transmission electron microscopy. Phil. Mag. A 58, 753. Rodenburg, J. M. and Bates, R. H. T. (1992). The theory of super-resolution electron microscopy via wigner-distribution deconvolution. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A 339, 521. Rodenburg, J. M., McCallum, B. C. and Nellist, P. D. (1993). Experimental tests on double-resolution coherent imaging via STEM. Ultramicroscopy 48, 303. Ronchi, V. (1964). 40 Years of history of grating interferometer. Applied Optics 3, 437. Rose, H. (1990). Outline of a spherically corrected semiaplanatic mediumvoltage transmission electron microscope. Optik 85, 19. Rossouw, C. J., Allen, L. J., Findlay, S. D. and Oxley, M. P. (2003). Channelling effects in atomic resolution STEM. Ultramicroscopy 96, 299. Scherzer, O. (1936). Über einige Fehler von Elektronenlinsen. Zeit Physik 101, 593. Scherzer, O. (1947). Spharische und chromatische korrektur von elektronenlinsen. Optik 2, 114. Shao, Z. (1988). On the fifth order aberration in a sextupole corrected probe forming system. Rev. Sci. Instr. 59, 2429. Sohlberg, K., Rashkeev, S., Borisevich, A. Y., Pennycook, S. J. and Pantelides, S. T. (2004). Origin of anomolous Pt-Pt distances in the Pt/alumina catalytic system. ChemPhysChem 5, 1893. Spence, J. C. H. (1988). Experimental High-Resolution Electron Microscopy (New York, OUP).
131
132 Peter D. Nellist Spence, J. C. H. (1992). Convergent-beam nanodiffraction, in-line holography and coherent shadow imaging. Optik 92, 57. Spence, J. C. H. (1998a). Crystal structure determination by direct inversion of dynamical microdiffraction patterns. J. Microsc. 190, 214. Spence, J. C. H. (1998b). Direct inversion of dynamical electron diffraction patterns to structure factors. Acta Cryst. A 54, 7. Spence, J. C. H. and Cowley, J. M. (1978). Lattice imaging in STEM. Optik 50, 129. Spence, J. C. H. and Zuo, J. M. (1992). Electron Microdiffraction (New York, Plenum Press). Suenaga, K., Tencé, M., Mory, C., Colliex, C., Kato, H., Okazaki, T., Shinohara, H., Hirahara, K., Bandow, S. and Iijima, S. (2000). Element-selective single atom imaging. Science 290, 2280. Swanson, L. W. and Crouser, L. C. (1967). Total energy distribution of fieldemitted electrons and single-plane work functions for tungsten. Phys. Rev. 163, 622. Treacy, M. M. J., Howie, A. and Wilson, C. J. (1978). Z contrast imaging of platinum and palladium catalysts. Phil. Mag. A 38, 569. Varela, M., Findlay, S. D., Lupini, A. R., Christen, H. M., Borisevich, A. Y., Dellby, N., Krivanek, O. L., Nellist, P. D., Oxley, M. P., Allen, L. J. and Pennycook, S. J. (2004). Spectroscopic imaging of single atoms within a bulk solid. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 095502. Voyles, P. M., Muller, D. A., Grazul, J. L., Citrin, P. H. and Gossmann, H. J. L. (2002). Atomic-scale imaging of individual dopant atoms and clusters in highly n-type bulk Si. Nature 416, 826. Voyles, P. M., Muller, D. A. and Kirkland, E. J. (2004). Depth-dependent imaging of individual dopant atoms in silicon. Microscopy and Microanalysis 10, 291. Wade, R. H. (1992). A brief look at imaging and contrast theory. Ultramicroscopy 46, 145. Watanabe, M. and Williams, D. B. (1999). Atomic-level detection by X-ray microanalysis in the analytical electron microscope. Ultramicroscopy 78, 89. Williams, D. B. and Carter, C. B. (1996). Transmission Electron Microscopy (New York, Plenum Press). Yamazaki, T., Kawasaki, M., Watanabe, K., Hashimoto, I. and Shiojiri, M. (2001). Artificial bright spots in atomic-resolution high-angle annular darkfield STEM images. J. Electron Microsc. 50, 517. Zach, J. and Haider, M. (1995). Correction of spherical and chromatic aberration in a low-voltage SE. Optik 98, 112. Zeitler, E. and Thomson, M. G. R. (1970). Scanning transmission electron microscopy. Optik 31, 258. Ziegler, A., Idrobo, J. C., Cinibulk, M. K., Kisielowski, C., Browning, N. D. and Ritchie, R. O. (2004). Interface structure and atomic bonding characteristics in silicon nitride ceramics. Science 306, 1768.
*References added since the first printing.
3 Scanning Electron Microscopy Rudolf Reichelt
1 Introduction The earliest historical contribution to the idea of a scanning electron microscope (SEM) was probably made by H. Stintzing in 1927 in a German patent application (Stintzing, 1927). In his patent he proposed irradiating a sample with a narrowly collimated beam (light, X-ray, corpuscles) and moving the sample transversely to the beam. The magnitude of interaction between beam and sample was to be measured by a sufficiently sensitive recording device, to be amplified and then displayed on an electron tube. This idea aimed to determine the size of small particles not accessible to light microscopy. However, the method proposed was unable to generate a magnified image. The first electron beam scanner capable of producing an image of the surface of a bulk sample with the emitted secondary electrons (SE) was developed by H. Knoll in 1935 (Knoll, 1935). In this instrument a focused electron beam was scanned across the sample surface by magnetic deflection line by line. The generated SE were converted into an electronic signal, which was amplified and then used to modulate the brightness of an electron tube. Both the electron beam of the scanner and of the display tube were scanned synchronously across the same distance by perpendicular pairs of deflection coils, thus the electron beam scanner at that time possessed unit magnification. The contrast in the SE image was due to the varying yield of SE caused by the different local chemical composition of the sample surface. However, submicroscopic resolution with an SEM was first obtained by M. von Ardenne using the transmission mode [so-called scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM)] (von Ardenne, 1938). The early development of electron microscopy up to 1940 has been described extensively by E. Ruska (1979). While the development of SEM in Europe was interrupted by World War II, the idea of SEM was used by Zworykin, Hillier, and Snyder in the United States for the construction of such an
Dedicated to my wife Doris and my daughter Hanna. 133
134
R. Reichelt
instrument (Zworykin et al., 1942). After World War II experiments with scanning electron microscopes started in England and France. Since 1948 C.W. Oatley from the Engineering Laboratory of the University of Cambridge directed intensive development in that field, which led to the first commercial scanning electron microscope available in 1965. Pioneering work in the improvement of instrumentation (e.g., electron sources, electron optics, detectors, signal processing), the investigation of electron-specimen interaction, elucidation of fundamental contrast mechanisms, and development of methods for the preparation of samples were done in the 1960s and 1970s (for books, proceedings of SEM conferences, and reviews see, e.g., Oatley, 1972; Ohnsorge and Holm, 1973; Holt et al., 1974; Wells, 1974, 1975; Hayat, 1974; Goldstein and Yakowitz, 1975; Reimer and Pfefferkorn, 1973, 1977; Pfefferkorn, 1968; Johari, 1968; Reimer, 1978). At the same time the SEM was applied extensively in very different fields for imaging of surfaces, for the local crystallographic characterization of polycrystalline materials by electron backscattered diffraction (EBSD), and in combination with X-ray microanalytical equipment such as an energy dispersive spectrometer (EDX) or a wavelength dispersive spectrometer (WDX) for the local element analysis of specimens (for books or proceedings of SEM conferences see, e.g., Heywood, 1971; Fujita et al., 1971; Thornton, 1972; Troughton and Donaldson, 1972; Siegel and Beaman, 1975; Chandler, 1978; Revel et al., 1983; Newbury et al., 1987; Wetzig and Schulze, 1995; Reed, 1996; Goldstein et al., 1984, 2003; Pfefferkorn, 1968; Johari, 1968). A significant improvement in SEM instrumentation was made by the development of the field emission scanning electron microscope (FESEM) that became commercially available in the 1980s. In the FESEM instead of a thermionic gun a field emission gun (FEG) is used for electron beam generation, which allows the formation of an electron probe with a diameter of about 0.5 nm. Together with further improvements in electron optics and electron detectors on the one hand and in specimen preparation on the other hand, high-resolution imaging by FESEM became feasible. Additionally, the FESEM enables specimens to be imaged at low acceleration voltages, i.e., below 5 kV, also at high resolution. The operation of the FESEM at low acceleration voltages opens new avenues for interesting applications in the characterization of surfaces (for reviews of specific aspects of the instrumentation, image formation, and application of FESEM at conventional or low acceleration voltages, respectively, see, e.g., Lyman et al., 1990; Reimer, 1993; Joy, 1995; Sawyer and Grubb, 1996; Müllerova and Frank, 2003). A very interesting step forward in the instrumentation was the development of a so-called environmental scanning electron microscope (ESEM) pushed in the 1980s in particular by G.D. Danilatos. Investigations of specimens using secondary or backscattered electrons for imaging, in SEM and FESEM restricted to high vacuum, can be performed in the ESEM in a low vacuum at a pressure of about 10 up to a few thousands Pa. Obviously, this is of great interest for samples that consist of materials or may contain dirt or fluids, respectively,
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
having a partial pressure in the low vacuum range mentioned. Typical examples are water or oil containing natural specimens. Moreover, electric insulators can be imaged without prior conductive coating by ESEM in low vacuum without significant electric charging artifacts. The ESEM (ESEM is used as a trade name by the manufacturers Electroscan/Philips/FEI) became commercially available in 1987 (for reviews of specific aspects of the instrumentation, image formation, and application of ESEM see, e.g., Danilatos, 1988, 1990). Since about the second half of the 1990s other manufacturers also offer commercial SEMs for low vacuum operation, usually referred to as low vacuum SEM, variable pressure SEM, natural SEM, etc.; however, these instruments are restricted typically to a maximum pressure of about 300 Pa and allow imaging only with backscattered electrons (BSE). Modern high-resolution FESEMs have at an electron energy of 30 keV a specified resolution power in the SE mode in the range of 0.5–1 nm, which corresponds to about the size of a small molecule. It marks the smallest size of a structure accessible on one hand. Working at the smallest magnification of an SEM on the other hand allows imaging of visible structures as large as about 1 mm, i.e., high-resolution SEMs cover a wide range of six orders of magnitude for the structural characterization of surfaces. A further advantage of the SEM is the simultaneous acquisition of different signals generated by the local interaction of the beam electrons with the specimen. Each of these signals, e.g., SE and BSE, carries different information about the sample, thus an extensive multidimensional data set about an area of interest can be obtained by one scan line-by-line across this area. The recording time may vary from a few seconds only to about 1 min depending on the strength of the signal and the signal-to-noise ratio required. The scanning electron microscopy is now a well-established method for the characterization of surfaces in ultrahigh vacuum (UHV), high vacuum (HV), and low vacuum (LV) in many different fields. Clearly, it is not possible to mention all of them, however, the main fields are certainly the materials (metals, alloys, ceramics, glasses) and surface sciences, semiconductor research and industry, life sciences, and miscellaneous sciences such as polymer and food research, mineralogy, geology, the oil industry, and archaeology. In addition to scanning electron microscopy some other surfacesensitive methods such as atomic force microscopy, scanning tunneling microscopy, and photoelectron microscopy are described in the book “Science of Microscopy.” It is certainly of particular interest to see in detail how these surface-sensitive methods complement each other, what specific advantages they offer, and how they compare with SEM. 1.1 Abbreviations ADC
Analog-to-digital-converter
AE
Auger electrons
AES
Auger electron spectroscopy
135
136
R. Reichelt
AFM
Atomic force microscope/microscopy
ASEM
Atmospheric scanning electron microscope/ microscopy
CC
Charge collection
CE
Collection efficiency
CFEG
Cold field emission gun
CL
Cathodoluminescence
CRT
Cathode ray tube
CSEM
Conventional high vacuum scanning electron microscope/microscopy
EBIC
Electron beam-induced current
EBSD
Electron backscattered diffraction
ECP
Electron channeling pattern
EDX
Energy dispersive X-ray
ESEM
Environmental scanning electron microscope/microscopy
ET
Everhart–Thornley
ETD
Everhart–Thornley detector
FEG
Field emission gun
FESEM
Filed emission scanning electron microscope/microscopy
FLM
Fluorescence light microscopy
HFEG
Hot field emission gun
HRSEM
High-resolution scanning electron microscope/microscopy
HV
High vacuum
LCD
Liquid crystal display
LEED
Low-energy electron diffraction
LP
Light pipe
LV
Low vacuum
LVSEM
Low-voltage scanning electron microscope/microscopy
MCP
Microchannel plate
MEMS
Microelectromechanical systems
NEMS
Nanoelectromechanical systems
OIM
Orientation imaging microscopy
PC
Personal computer
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
SAM
Scanning Auger microscopy
SE
Secondary electrons
SEC
Schottky emission cathode
SEM
Scanning electron microscopes
SLEEM
Scanning low-energy electron microscope/microscopy
S/N
Signal to noise
SNR
Signal-to-noise ratio
STEM
Scanning transmission electron microscope/ microscopy
STM
Scanning tunneling microscope/microscopy
UHV
Ultrahigh vacuum
UV
Ultraviolet
VLVSEM
Very low-voltage scanning electron microscopy
WD
Work distance
WDX
Wavelength dispersive X-ray
YAG
Yttrium-aluminum-garnet
YAP
Yttrium-aluminum-perovskite
3D
Three dimensional
1.2 Symbols A
Atomic weight
Cc
Chromatic aberration constant
Cs
Spherical aberration constant
d
Lattice-plane spacing
dp
Final electron probe diameter dp at the specimen
dpe
Effective final electron probe diameter
dp,min
Minimum effective electron probe diameter
dc
Diameter of the error disc of chromatic aberration
df
Diameter of the diffraction caused Airy disc
ds
Diameter of the error disc of spherical aberration
do
Diameter do of the first crossover
E
Electron energy
EAE
Energy of Auger electrons
Eo
Electron energy of the beam electrons
137
138
R. Reichelt
EBSE
Energy of backscattered electrons
E2
Beam electron energy where the number of incoming and emitted electrons is equal
EX
X-ray energy
Eexm
Mean energy per excitation of an electron hole pair
F
Flux of gas molecules
f
Focal length of a lens
ICC
Charge-collection current
Ip
Electron probe current
Ip,max
Maximum electron probe current
jc
Current density for thermionic emission
J
Mean ionization potential
L
Electron path length in gas
N
Number of atoms per unit volume
NA
Avogadro’s number
N⋅I
Ampere-windings of an electromagnetic lens
nm
Mean number of electron hole pairs
M
Magnification
p
Object distance to the center of the lens
pg
Pressure in the specimen chamber of the SEM
px
Parallax
q
Image distance to the center of the lens
R
Electron range
RB
Bethe range
T
Temperature
t
Specimen thickness
Z
Atomic number
αp
Semiangle of the convergent impinging electron probe at the specimen
αopt
Optimum value of αp
∆E
Energy spread of the beam electrons
Φ
Work function
θ
Angle of incidence of the electron beam
Θ
Tilt angle of the specimen
ϕ
Scattering angle
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
ϑ
Bragg angle
αo
Semiangle of divergence of the first crossover
δ
Secondary electron yield
η
Backscattered electron coefficient
λ
Wavelength of the beam electrons
λx
Wavelength of X-ray
Λ
Mean free path for electron scattering in gas
Λel
Mean free path for elastic scattering
Λin
Mean free path for inelastic scattering
σ
Electron scattering cross section
σel
Elastic electron scattering cross section
σin
Inelastic electron scattering cross section
σg
Total electron scattering cross section of gas molecule
ε
Complex dielectric constant
ε0
Dielectric constant
ν
Frequency of radiation
ω
Fluorescence yield of X-rays
2 Conventional Scanning Electron Microscopy The principle of a scanning electron microscope is shown schematically in Figure 3–1. The two major parts are the microscope column and the electronics console. The microscope column consists of the electron gun (with the components cathode, Wehnelt cylinder, anode), one or two condenser lenses, two pairs of beam deflection coils (scan coils for X, Y deflection), the objective lens, and some apertures. In the specimen chamber at the lower end of the microscope column are located the specimen stage and the detectors for the different signals generated by the electron–specimen interaction. The microscope column and the specimen chamber are evacuated using a combination of prevacuum and high vacuum pumps (usually oil diffusion pumps). The pressure in the specimen chamber typically amounts to about 10−4 Pa, allowing the beam electrons to travel from the cathode to the specimen with little interaction with the residual gas molecules. The electronics console consists of the electric power supplies for the acceleration voltage (usual range about 0.5–30 kV) as well as the condenser and objective lenses, the scan generator, and electronic amplifiers for the different signals acquired. Moreover, the console also houses one or more monitors [cathode ray tube (CRT) or liquid crystal display (LCD)] for displaying the micrograph(s), a photo-CRT for analogous image recording, and numerous knobs and a computer keyboard to control the electron
139
140
R. Reichelt c w
Accelerating voltage + Lens currents
A
Monitor
Photo-Monitor
ConA ConL Defl. X,Y
Scan generator
Defl. X,Y OL OA Det. O
SE BSE STEM CL X-ray
DF-D
Microscope column Specimen chamber Detectors
PC
Amplifier
Electronics
Image display Photography
Digital scan Digital image Acquisition & storage Image display Image processing
Figure 3–1. Schematic drawing of a conventional SEM. The evacuated microscope column (inside the bold dashed frame) contains the electron gun, electromagnetic lenses, electromagnetic deflection coils, apertures, the specimen stage, and the detectors. The electronics console houses the power supplies for the acceleration voltage and the electromagnetic lenses, the scan generator, amplifiers for the signals, and monitors for display and recording of images. Modern SEMs are controlled by a PC. A, anode; BSE, backscattered electrons; C, cathode; ConA, condenser aperture; ConL, condenser lens; CL, cathodoluminescence; Defl. X, pair of beam deflection coils in the X direction; Defl. Y, pair of beam deflection coils in the Y direction; Det., detectors; DF-D, dark-field detector; O, specimen; OA, objective aperture; OL, objective lens; PC, personal computer; SE, secondary electrons; STEM, scanning transmission electron microscope signal; W, Wehnelt cylinder; X-ray, X-ray signal.
beam, the signals selected, and the image recording. Now modern SEMs mostly use a PC to control the electron beam, to select the signals, and to record as well as to store the digital image(s). In that case the numerous knobs are obsolete and are replaced by a mouse-controlled interactive program running on the PC. How does the SEM work? The beam electrons are emitted from the cathode and accelerated by a voltage of 0.5–30 kV between the cathode and anode forming a smallest beam cross section—the crossover—near the anode with a diameter of about 10–50 µm. This spot size is too large to produce a sharp image. Therefore the crossover is demagnified by the lens system consisting of one or two condenser lenses and one objective lens and focused on the specimen surface. Most SEMs can produce an electron beam having a smallest spot size of about 5–10 nm and an electron probe current in the range of 10−12–10−10 A, which is sufficient to form an image with a reasonable signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio. For higher probe currents required for some modes of operation the smallest probe spot size increases to 100 nm or more. The objective lens has a variable relatively long focal length that allows a large
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
working distance (WD; it corresponds to the distance between the specimen and lower pole piece) in the range of about 5–30 mm. This ensures that the various signals generated by the impinging beam electrons (Figure 3–2) in the small specimen interaction volume can be collected by detectors located lateral above the specimen with sufficient efficiency. Pairs of beam deflection coils located in front of the objective lens and controlled by a scan generator scan the electron probe line by line across a small area of the specimen. Simultaneously, the scan generator controls the deflection coil system of a monitor. The intensity of the monitor is modulated by the amplified signal selected by the operator. The signals may vary from one location to another as the electron– specimen interaction changes due to, e.g., topography and specimen composition. The magnification of the image is given by the ratio of the length of the scan on the monitor and the corresponding length of the scan on the specimen. For example, an increase in magnification can simply be achieved by decreasing the current of the deflection coils in the microscope column (i.e., lowering the length of the scan on the specimen) and keeping the image size on the monitor constant. It should be mentioned that the magnification also depends on the WD, however, modern SEMs compensate automatically for each WD, thus keeping the displayed magnification correct. Figure 3–3 shows a series of images recorded with increasing magnifications over a range of almost three orders of magnitude. For crystal structure analysis (cf. Section 7) basically two strategies exist: (1) The mode of beam deflection changes from scanning line by line to rocking of the electron beam when the probe is at rest on a chosen location and the angle of incidence is scanned within a select-
Primary electrons E0 = 0.1 - 30 keV Cathodoluminescence / X-rays hν < E0
Backscattered electrons 50eV < E ≤ E0
Auger electrons E = EAE
Secondary electrons E ≤ 50eV
Specimen
Unscattered electrons E0
Inelastically scattered electrons E = E0 - E ∇
Elastically scattered electrons E = E0
Figure 3–2. Schematic drawing of signals for a thin sample generated by the impinging electrons. EO, energy of beam electrons; E, energy of signal electrons; EAE, energy of Auger electrons; ∆E, energy loss of inelastically scattered electrons; hν, energy of radiation.
141
142
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–3. Micrograph series of increasing magnification of the head and the eye of a fly (Drosophila melanogaster), recorded with secondary electrons at 30 kV. The specimen was air dried and sputter coated with about 15 nm gold. Note the large depth of focus. The last magnification step from (e) to (f) barely reveals further fine details of the specimen because of the preparation used. The scale of dimensions of the micrographs covers about three orders of magnitude.
able angular range to form an electron channeling pattern. (2) The electron backscattered diffraction pattern from the point of electron beam impact is recorded by means of a position-sensitive detector and analyzed revealing information about the local crystal structure. One of the greatest strengths of the SEM is the tremendous depth of focus, i.e., the range of heights of the specimen being simultaneously in focus (cf. Figure 3–3). Due to the small objective aperture diaphragm (about 50–100 µm) and the large WD the semiangle αp of the convergent
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
impinging electron probe is in the order of 10 mrad only. At magnifications that are comparable to those of light microscopy (e.g., 1000×) the SEM has a depth of focus that is about 100 times greater than that of an optical microscope, obviously because the semiangle of convergence is much larger in the latter case. To take full advantage of all the information that SEM can provide, an understanding of its operation modes and the influence of electron beam parameters on the image resolution, the image contrast, the signal strength, and the S/N ratio as well as the electron–specimen interaction is mandatory. The remarkable success of scanning electron microscopy over several decades is mainly due to the tremendous depth of focus, the brilliant image contrast, and the relatively straightforward sample preparation for imaging of surfaces, and, in combination with X-ray microanalytical equipment, its capability of local quantitative element analysis of specimens. 2.1 Electron Guns, Electron Lenses, Detectors, and Stages 2.1.1 Electron Guns The electron gun provides the SEM with an electron beam of adjustable current and energy. The most classic electron gun is the triode gun based on thermionic emission from a tungsten filament heated to about Tc = 2700 K (cf. Figure 3–4). The filament has a diameter of about 0.1 mm and is bent in the shape of a V hairpin to localize the emission area on the tip. The size of this area is around 100 × 150 µm. By thermionic excitation the electrons overcome the work function Φ of the tungsten tip and a current with the density jc is emitted according to the Richardson law jc = ATc2 exp(−Φ/kTc)
(2.1)
UH UW
Ic
Cathode Wehnelt Crossover
RW –
U= 1-50 kV
+ Anode
Figure 3–4. Schematic drawing of the thermionic emission triode gun with a tungsten hairpin filament. The filament is heated by the applied voltage UH. Rw, variable resistor to adjust the potential UW between the Wehnelt cylinder and cathode; U, acceleration voltage. [Adapted from Reimer (1993); with kind permission of the International Society of Optical Engineering (SPIE), Bellingham, WA.]
143
144
R. Reichelt
where A represents a constant depending on the cathode material and k is the Boltzmann constant; Φ = 4.5 eV for tungsten. The density jc depends strongly on the temperature: jc is about 1.8 A cm−2 for Tc = 2700 K and about 3 A cm−2 for Tc = 2800 K. The emitted electrons are accelerated from the filament at a high negative potential (e.g., −30 kV) toward the anode at ground potential (0 V). Central holes in the Wehnelt cylinder and in the anode enable a fraction of the accelerated electrons (e.g., Eo = 30 keV) to move toward the lenses in the microscope column. The emission current is typically in the order of 100 µA and can be controlled by the bias of the Wehnelt cylinder, which surrounds the filament. The negative Wehnelt bias is provided by a voltage drop caused by the emission current through the resistor RW. The electrostatic field distribution inside the triode gun has a focusing action to the emitted electrons generating a crossover that is located between the Wehnelt cylinder and the anode. This crossover can be characterized by the diameter do and the semiangle αo of the divergence. do is usually in the order of 50 µm. As we will see later the condenser and objective lenses produce a demagnified image of that crossover on the specimen surface representing the final electron probe (diameter dp). An important parameter of an electron gun is its axial brightness β, which is defined as the beam current per area (equal to current density) into a solid angle πα2 (Reimer, 1985) β = j/πα2 = const.
(2.2)
It is important to note that the brightness remains constant for all points along the electron optical axis from the cathode through the microscope column to the specimen. This means that the brightness of the final electron probe on the specimen surface is equal to the brightness of the gun regardless of apertures in the microscope column, i.e., β = 4Io/π2 do2αo2 = 4Ip/π2 dp2αp2
(2.3)
where Io is the beam current at the crossover inside the electron gun. Equation (2.3) shows that the characteristic illumination parameters Ip, dp and αp cannot be changed independently. For example, an increase of β for given dp and αp clearly requires an increase of Ip. The work function of tungsten is relatively high. Lanthanum hexaboride (LaB6) has a significantly lower work function (Φ = 2.7 eV) and can therefore emit greater current densities at lower temperature (Tc = 1900 K). At the same time the brightness of the electron probe is also increased since the maximum brightness of an electron gun (Reimer, 1985) is given as β = jcEo/πk Tc
(2.4)
i.e., the brightness β is inversely proportional to the temperature of the cathode. The LaB6 cathode consists of a small piece of an LaB6 single crystal with a tip radius typically of about 1 µm. The single crystal is supported by a nonreactive material and is resistively heated. It seems worth mentioning that (1) in the cathode chamber the operation of an
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
145
LaB6 requires a vacuum better than 10−4 Pa to avoid cathode contamination (tungsten cathode: about 10−3 Pa) and (2) its alignment is critical. Characteristic values of the triode gun with thermionic tungsten and the LaB6 cathode are summarized in Table 3–1. 2.1.2 Electron Lenses As discussed in Section 2.1.1 the electrons emerge from the electron gun as a divergent beam. Two or three electromagnetic lenses and apertures in the microscope column (cf. Figure 3–1) reconverge and focus the beam into a demagnified image of the first crossover generated by the gun. The final lens—the objective lens—focuses the beam into the smallest possible spot of 4–10 nm on the sample surface, i.e., the total demagnification is about 5000×. Rotationally symmetric electromagnetic lenses consist of a coil with N ⋅ I ampere windings inside an iron pole piece. Typically, N ⋅ I is in the order of 103 A for the condenser and objective lenses. The iron pole piece has a small gap in its axial bore. The current in the coil generates a magnetic field carried by the iron, which also appears at the gap forming a bell-shaped stray field distribution on the optical axis with a radial and axial field component. Off-axis electrons move due to the Lorentz force along screw trajectories because the radial component of the field results in a rotation around the optical axis. Electrons emerging divergently from a point in front of the lens are focused in an image point behind the lens. The lenses of SEMs can usually be considered weak lenses (because the pole piece is not saturated). In this case, the principal planes of the lens coincide with its optical center and the formulas for thin light optical lenses can be used. In close analogy to light optics the strength of an electromagnetic lens can be characterized by its focal length f. Using the thin lens formulas we can write
Table 3–1. Characteristic parameters of different electron guns. Source
Parameters Brightness (A cm -2 sr-1)
Thermionic W-cathodea 105
LaB6 cathodea,b 106
Cold FEGc 107–10 8
Hot FEGc 107–10 8
Schottky emission cathodec 107–10 8
Energy spread (eV)
1–3
0.5–2
0.2–0.4
0.5–0.7
0.8
Vacuum (Pa)
~10 -3
~10 -4
10 -8 –10 -9
10 -8 –10 -9
10 -8
Emission current (mA)
~100
1–>50
~10
~10
30–70
Life time
~40 h
~200 h
>1 year
>1 year
>1 year
d
~150 h a b c d
Reimer (1985). DeVore and Berger (1996). Reimer (1993). Reichelt (unpublished).
~8 years
d
146
R. Reichelt
1/f = 1/p + 1/q
(2.5)
where p is the distance from the object (= crossover) and q is the distance to the image. Both, p and q are related to the center of the lens. The magnification M is given simply by M = q/p
(2.6)
where M < 1 for p > 2f, i.e., a demagnified image of an object is obtained at these imaging conditions. Therefore, a strong demagnification of about 5000× of the first crossover can be obtained for p >> 2f for each of the two or three lenses by successive demagnification of each intermediate crossover. In case of two condenser lenses they usually are combined and adjusted by one control only. The pole pieces of condenser lenses are symmetrical, i.e., the diameters of the axial bores in the upper and lower half of the pole piece are identical. In contrast to that the pole piece of the objective lens is very asymmetric (1) to limit the magnetic field at the specimen level and (2) to house the beam deflections coils, the adjustable objective aperture, and the stigmator (not shown in Figure 3–1). The asymmetric objective lens (called the pinhole or conical lens) adapts for the wide range of the WD of about 5–30 mm by an adjustable focal length. However, working at a large WD inevitably degrades the electron optical properties of the objective lens and enlarges the final spot size dp. For a detailed description of the electron optical properties of electromagnetic lenses and deflection coils the reader is referred to books about electron optics (e.g., Glaser, 1952; Grivet, 1972; Klemperer, 1971; Reimer, 1998). All electromagnetic lenses involved in successive demagnification suffer from an imperfect rotational symmetry and aberrations, which degrade their electron optical performance. The effects of lens aberrations cannot be compensated, however, they can be minimized, which is most effective for the final—the objective—lens. Let us consider briefly the three significant effects. 1. Spherical Aberration. The spherical aberration constant Cs causes an error disc of the diameter (Cosslett, 1972) ds = 1/2 Csαp3
(2.7)
2. Chromatic Aberration. The chromatic aberration caused mainly by the energy spread of the electrons from the gun is characterized by the constant Cc causes an error disc of the diameter dc = Cc ⋅ ∆E/Eo ⋅ αp
(2.8)
where ∆E/Eo represents the relative energy spread of the beam electrons. 3. Diffraction. The diffraction of electrons on the objective aperture results in a further error disc—the Airy disc—of diameter df = 0.6λ/αp where λ is the wavelength of the electrons.
(2.9)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
In a first approximation it is possible to superpose the squared diameters of the individual discs to estimate the effective electron probe diameter dpe2 = dp2 + ds2 + dc2 + df2
(2.10)
−2
d is given by Eq. (2.3) as d = (4Ip/π2β)αp . More precise, but at the same time more complicated relations for the effective probe diameter were derived by Barth and Kruit (1996) and Kolarik and Lenc (1997). Under the conditions normally used in conventional SEM (i.e., Eo = 10–30 keV) the chromatic aberration as well as the effect of the diffraction are relatively small compared to the remaining contributions and can be neglected (Reimer, 1985). The optimum aperture αopt, which allows the smallest effective electron probe diameter dmin, can be obtained by the first derivative ∂dpe/∂αp = 0 and is given as 2 p
2 p
αopt = (4/3)1/8 [(4Ip/π2β)1/2/Cs]1/4
(2.11)
By using the approach mentioned above, i.e., dpe = d + ds , and Eqs. (2.3), (2.7), and (2.11), the minimum effective electron probe diameter is 2
dp,min = (4/3) 3/8 [(4Ip/π2β) 3/2Cs]1/4
2 p
2
(2.12)
It is obvious that dp,min increases as Ip increases or β decreases. Both, Ip and β are parameters depending on the performance of the electron gun [cf. Eq. (2.3)]. Cs is a parameter characterizing the performance of the objective lens and should be as small as possible. As previously mentioned, the operation of the SEM at a large WD inevitably degrades the electron optical properties of the objective lens, i.e., Cs increases as the WD increases. Just to provide a rough idea about values for dp,min and αopt at usual electron energies (10–30 keV), a moderate WD and a probe current Ip of about 10−11 A, which gives a sufficient S/N ratio, dp,min typically amounts to approximately 10 nm and αopt to 5–10 mrad. It is also of interest to know the maximum probe current Ip,max under these conditions. Using the Eqs. (2.12) and (2.3) one obtains Ip,max = 3π2/16 ⋅ β Cs−2/3 dp,min8/3
(2.13)
Interestingly, it becomes obvious from Eq. (2.13) that including the effect of the spherical aberration, Ip is now proportional to dp8/3 instead of dp2 as before [cf. Eq. (2.3)]. The electron probe current in a SEM equipped with a thermionic gun can be increased several orders of magnitude above 10−11 A as required, e.g., for microanalytical studies (cf. Section 6). It is clear from the considerations above that an increase in the probe current inevitably increases the probe size. A rough estimate for 30 keV electrons shows that an increase of Ip to 10−9 A requires a probe size of about 60 nm. However, due to the electron–specimen interaction the lateral resolution of X-ray microanalysis is limited to about 1 µm for thick samples. Therefore, a probe diameter of 100 nm or even several hundred nanometers can be tolerated without disadvantage for X-ray microanalysis in this case.
147
148
R. Reichelt
When considering the effective electron probe diameter the chromatic aberration of the objective lens could be neglected for energies >10 keV. Because dc is inversely proportional to Eo [cf. Eq. (2.8)] there is a significant increase for energies below 10 keV, in particular for the low-voltage range below 5 keV. For example, for 1 keV electrons the diameter of the chromatic error disc increases by a factor of 30 compared to 30 keV! When using a thermionic cathode with a tungsten filament and a probe current of about 10−11 A the energy spread is about 2 eV (cf. Table 3–1) and dc contributes dominantly to the enlargement of the probe diameter [cf. Eq. (2.10)]. Therefore, the thermionic source is inappropriate for imaging in the low-voltage range. As we shall see in Section 3, field emission guns with a one order of magnitude smaller energy spread and about five orders of magnitude larger brightness are very well suited for low-voltage SEM (LVSEM). In the context of the objective lens the existence of a stigmator was mentioned, which usually is located near the pole-piece gap. Due to imperfect rotational symmetry of the pole-piece bores, magnetic inhomogeneities of the pole piece, or some charging effects in the bore or at the objective aperture, the magnetic field in the objective lens becomes asymmetric. This causes different focal lengths in the sagittal and meridional planes, which leads to low image quality degraded by astigmatism. The astigmatism can be compensated for by adding a cylinder lens adjustable in its strength and azimuth. The effect of a cylinder lens is realized by the stigmator consisting of a pair of quadrupole lenses. 2.1.3 Detectors and Detection Strategies Electron detectors specifically collect the signals emerging from the specimen as a result of electron–specimen interaction. The efficiency of the signal collection depends on the type of the detector, its performance, and its detection geometry, i.e., its position related to location of the signal emitting area. For an understanding of the recorded signals, knowledge of the influence of these parameters is critical. 2.1.3.1 Detectors To detect electrons in SEM three different principles are commonly used. One principle is based on the conversion of signal electrons to photons by a scintillation material. Then, the photons are converted into an electric signal by a photomultiplier, which is proportional to the number of electrons impinging on the scintillator. The second principle is based on the conversion of electrons to electron hole pairs by a semiconductor, which can be separated before recombination causing an external charge collection current. This current is proportional to the number of electrons impinging on the semiconductor. While the principle of scintillation detection is used for secondary, backscattered, and transmitted electrons (in case of thin specimens), the semiconductor detector is mostly used for backscattered electrons only. Finally, the third principle is based on the electron channel multiplier tube, which converts the signal electrons by direct impact at its
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
input to secondary electrons and multiplies them inside the tube. The output signal is proportional to the number of impinging signal electrons. As we shall see later, Auger electrons (AE) have a characteristic energy, which is related to the atomic number of the element involved in their generation. For recording of AE in the energy range from 50 eV to several keV, spectrometers with a high energy resolution and high angular collection efficiency are needed in combination with the scintillation detection used, e.g., for secondary and backscattered electrons. The most widely used spectrometer for AE spectroscopy is the cylindrical mirror analyzer. Only those electrons, which pass the energyselecting diaphragm of the spectrometer, can impinge on the scintillator, thus contributing to the signal. Besides of electrons the electron–specimen interaction can also produce electromagnetic radiation, namely cathodoluminescence (CL) and X-rays (cf. Figure 3–2). Cathodoluminescence shows a close analogy to optical fluorescence light microscopy (FLM) where light emission is stimulated by irradiation with ultraviolet light (photoluminescence). In principle, for the detection of emitted light, which has a wavelength in the range of about 0.3–1.2 µm, a photomultiplier is very well suited (see above) and therefore most often used. However, the commonly low intensity of the CL signal requires, for a sufficient S/N ratio, a high collection efficiency of the emitted light. Table 3–2 presents the most common detector types for SE, BSE, and CL. The detectors for X-rays will be described in Section 6 of this chapter. Scintillation Detector. The scintillation detector for SE—the Everhart– Thornley (ET) detector (Everhart and Thornley, 1960)—is shown schematically in Figure 3–5. The generated SE are collected by a positively biased collector grid, then they pass the grid and are accelerated by about 10 kV to the conductive coated scintillator. The scintillation material converts electrons to photons, which are guided by a metal-coated quartz glass to the photocathode of a photomultiplier where photoelectrons are generated and amplified by a factor of about 106. Usually the electronic signal at the output of the photomultiplier is further amplified. Several scintillator materials, such as plastic scintillators, lithiumactivated glass, P-47 powder, or YAG and YAP single crystals, are in use, which differ in their performance (for details see, e.g., Reimer, 1985; Autrata, 1990; Autrata and Hejna, 1991; Autrata et al., 1992a,b; Schauer and Autrata, 2004). When the collector grid of the ET detector is negatively biased by <−50 V SE are not collected. In this case only the BSE can reach the scintillator on almost straight trajectories because of their higher energies. The detected fraction of BSE is very low because of the small solid angle of collection, i.e., small angular collection efficiency (CE). However, for an efficient detection of BSE the solid angle of collection of BSE detectors is significantly larger by using a larger scintillator and at the same time a shorter distance to the specimen. The BSE detector does not require the collector grid used for the SE (cf. Figure 3–5).
149
a
Autrata et al. (1992); Bond et al. (1974); Rasul and Davidson (1977); Reimer (1985)
Postek and Keery (1990)
High CE; EBSE ≥1 keV; negatively biased front plate
Electron multiplier tube
MCP
High CE; normally simultaneous BSE detection is not possible (for exceptionsee Autrata et al., 1992)
Stephen et al. (1975)
Electron hole pair generation
Mirror–PM; mirror– spectrometer–PM; mirror–LP–PM
Robinson (1990)
High CE; EBSE ≥0.9 keV High CE; EBSE ≥1.5 keV bandwidth about ≤2 MHz
Scintillator–LP–PM
Robinson
Solid state
Ellipsoidal or parabolic mirror with parallel or focused light output or coupled to an LP
Autrata et al. (1992)
High CE; EBSE ≥0.8 keV
Scintillator–LP–PM
Autrata
Postek and Keery (1990); Reimer (1985)
Crewe (1970); Reimer (1985)
References Everhart and Thornley (1960); Reimer (1985)
Everhart and Thornley (1960); Reimer (1985)
Positively biased from plate
SE are accelerated to>10 keV before detection
Specifications High CE; positively biased collector grid
Very low CE; negatively biased collector grid
Electron multiplier tube
MCP Scintillator–LP–PM
Electron hole pair generation
Solid state
Everhart–Thornley
Principles Scintillator–LP–PM
Type of detector Everhart–Thornley
MCP, Microchannel plate; LP, light pipe; PM, photomultiplier; CE, collection efficiency; EBSE, energy of backscattered electrons.
CL
BSE
Signal SE
Table 3–2. Most common electron detectors for SEM. a
150 R. Reichelt
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
PE SE
Collector Grid and screen ± 200 V BSE
Specimen
BSE Scintillator
Photomultiplier
SE
Photocathode Dynodes Light pipe 1ehv
Anode Signal 106e
Optical contact +10 kV
151
10 nF
R 1 MΩ
100 kΩ UPM = 500 – 1000 V
Figure 3–5. Schematic drawing of Everhart–Thornley detector (scintillator–photomultiplier combination) for recording secondary electrons (SE). BSE, backscattered electrons; PE, primary electrons; PM, photomultiplier; hν, energy of photons. [From Reimer (1985); with kind permission of Springer-Verlag GmbH, Heidelberg, Germany.]
Semiconductor Detector. The semiconductor detector—often denoted as a solid state detector—generates from an impinging electron with the energy E a mean number of electron hole pairs given by nm = E/Eexm
(2.14)
where Eexm = 3.6 eV is the mean energy per excitation in silicon (Wu and Wittry, 1974). The electron hole pairs can be separated before recombination, in this way generating an external charge collection current, which is proportional to the number of impinging electrons. Because of the energy dependence of nm the BSE with higher energy contribute with a larger weight to the signal than the BSE having low energies. The semiconductor detector can be used only for the direct detection of BSE because impinging SE are absorbed in its thin electrical conductive layer. However, a special detector design for accelerating the SE to energies above 10 keV also allows for detection of SE (Crewe et al., 1970). Microchannel Plate Detector. A microchannel plate (MCP) consists of a large number of parallel very small electron multiplier tubes (diameter about 10–20 µm, length of a few millimeters) covering an area of about 25 mm in diameter (e.g., Postek and Keery, 1990). Thus this detector is thin and, when placed between objective pole piece and specimen, enlarges the work distance by only about 3.5 mm. The MCP detector system is efficient at both high and low accelerating voltages, and is capable of both secondary electron and backscattered electron detection. The MCP becomes of increasing interest for studies with low currents and in low-voltage scanning electron microscopy (Russel and Manusco, 1985). However, as yet the MCP detector is not as common as the other detector types described above. Cathodoluminescence Detectors. In the few cases of strongly luminescent specimens a lens or a concave mirror is sufficient for light collection (Judge et al., 1974). As mentioned above, mostly the intensity of the CL signal is low, thus a high collection efficiency of the emitted light is
152
R. Reichelt
indispensable. This requires a solid angle of collection as large as possible, an optimum transfer of the collected light to a monochromator or directly to the photomultiplier, and a photomultiplier with a high quantum efficiency in the spectral range of the CL (Boyde and Reid, 1983). Commercial CL collector and imaging systems allow for investigations with a wavelength from less than 200 nm to about 1800 nm in the imaging and spectroscopy mode. The following are the most commonly used collection systems. 1. Parabolic or elliptic mirrors. The light-emitting area of the specimen is located at the focus of the mirror and is formed into a parallel beam for a parabolic mirror (Bond et al., 1974) or focused to a slit of a spectrometer for an elliptic mirror (e.g., McKinney and Hough, 1977). The solid angle of collection is in the order of π sr but SE detection with an ET detector is still feasible. 2. Rotational ellipsoidal mirror. The light-emitting area of the specimen is located at one focus of the half of the ellipsoid of rotation (Hörl, 1972). The emitted light is focused to a light pipe or to the focal point of an optical microscope objective at the second focal point of the ellipsoid. Although the ellipsoidal mirror has the largest collection angle, the effective collection angle is limited by the acceptance angle of the light pipe or the optical microscope objective, respectively, to about 0.75 π sr. The limitation by the acceptance angle can be avoided by placing a parabolic mirror below the second focal point of the ellipsoid (Hörl, 1975). Very recently Rau et al. (2004) proposed an ellipsoidal confocal system collecting the emitted light, which enables CL microtomography in SEM. In principle, the proposed system allows for CL studies at high resolution, which is well below the size of the lightemitting volume. 3. Optical microscope objective. The CL of an optically transparent specimen can be studied by an optical microscope objective positioned below the specimen. The collection angle of this setup amounts to about 1.4 π sr (Ishikawa et al., 1973). 2.1.3.2 Detection Strategies Generally, the detectors for the various signals can be combined and each of them should have an optimum position to make the best use of the electron–specimen interaction. The use of electron spectrometers for AE, BSE, and SE can provide supplementary information about the specimen surface but additional space is needed for a spectrometer. As a matter of fact, the space for detectors is limited in particular with a short WD or with an in-lens position of the specimen for higher resolution. Very recently a proposal was made to improve this situation in scanning electron microscopes with a new design (Khursheed and Osterberg, 2004). The suggested arrangement allows for the efficient collection, detection, and spectral analysis of the scattered electrons on a hemispherical surface that is located well away from the rest of the SEM column. A conventional SEM commonly is equipped with an ET detector located laterally above the specimen and a BSE detector (for different types see Table 3–2) located centrally above the specimen (top position). Additional ports at the specimen chamber of the SEM enable
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
additional detectors to be installed. Because of limited space not all of the installed detectors may be used simultaneously, however, there are retractable detectors (e.g., BSE detectors) available, which can be kept in the retracted position when not needed (providing space for another detector or allowing for a shorter WD) and can readily be moved into working position if required for signal recording. Numerous multidetector systems have been proposed for BSE and SE (for review see Reimer, 1984a, 1985). In the top position, e.g., two semiannular semiconductor detectors (Kimoto et al., 1966; Hejna and Reimer, 1987) allow for separation of topographic and material contrast; with a fourquadrant semiconductor detector (Lebiedzik, 1979; Kaczmarek, 1997; Kaczmarek and Domaradzki, 2002) the surface profile can be reconstructed and the distinction between elements with different atomic numbers is improved. Even a six-segment semiconductor detector is of interest (Müllerová et al., 1989). A combination of two opposite ET detectors, A and B, allows two SE signals, SA and SB, to be recorded simultaneously. The difference signal SA − SB illustrates the topographic contrast whereas the sum SA + SB signal illustrates the material contrast (Volbert and Reimer, 1980; Volbert, 1982). The mixing of the analog electronic signals at that time was performed by electronic circuitry. After analog signal mixing the two original signals were lost. Today, modern SEMs usually record digital images, which are stored in a PC. Thus the mixing of images (their raw data are stored in a memory) can be performed readily after image recording by means of image processing software available from numerous software companies. For high-resolution and LVSEM the work distance should be as short as possible (say below 5 mm) because both the focal length and the aberrations of the objective lens increase with the WD (see also Sections 2.1.2 and 3). In contrast to the asymmetric objective lens (large focal length) where the region above the specimen is a magnetic field free space, the specimen is immersed in the field of the objective lens with a short focal length. In this case the specimen is very close to the lower objective pole piece or is placed directly inside the pole-piece gap [as in a transmission electron microscope (TEM); see Chapters 1, 2, 6, and 7]. For the latter lens type—the specimen has an “in-lens” position and is limited in size to a few millimeter only—the collection of SE takes advantage of the fact that they can spiral upward in the magnetic field of the objective lens due to their axial velocity component. The SE have to be deflected off the axis to be recorded by an ET detector located laterally above the lens (cf. Figure 3–6). The separation of the downward moving beam electrons and the upward moving secondary electrons can be done most efficiently by an E × B system, which employs crossed electric and magnetic fields. The forces of these fields compensate each other for the beam electrons, but add for the opposite moving secondary electrons. This magnetic “through-the-lens” detection (for review see Kruit, 1991) of SE has several advantages: (1) SE are separated from BSE, which do not reach the detector because their higher kinetic energy causes different trajectories; (2) very high collection efficiency for real SE emerging from the specimen and a suppression of SE created on the walls of the
153
154
R. Reichelt +10 kV +200 V
ETD
SE
B
Figure 3–6. Schematic drawing of the magnetic “through-the-lens” detection of secondary electrons (SE) for the “in-lens” position of the specimen. B, magnetic field lines, ETD, Everhart–Thornley detector. [From Reimer (1993); with kind permission of the International Society of Optical Engineering (SPIE), Bellingham, WA.]
system by BSE; (3) improved collection efficiency from inside a porous specimen (in particular cavities or holes facing the electron beam) (Lukianov et al., 1972); and (4) loss of directionality in the image because the SE are detected irrespective of the direction of emission (in contrast to the lateral position of the ET detector; cf. Figure 3–7a). However, a combination of two opposite ET detectors to illustrate the topographic or material contrast has not been tried as yet. It seems worth mentioning that a real “through-the-lens” detection system was incorporated in one of the early SEMs (Zworykin et al., 1942). The magnetic “through-the-lens” detection of SE was established by Koike et al. (1970) using a TEM with scanning attachment. Finally, magnetic “through-the-lens” detection can be combined with any electron spectrometer as done in SE and Auger spectroscopy (for review see Kruit, 1991). Another type of “in-lens” detection of SE and BSE is used in the electrostatic detector objective lens (Zach and Rose, 1988a,b; Zach, 1989). The detector is of the annular type and possesses a high collection efficiency of SE of about 75%. Replacing the annular detector by a combination of two semiannular detectors A and B (Figure 3–8) could be used to illustrate the topographic or material contrast, respectively (Reimer, 1993). Similarly, “in-lens” annular type detection of SE and BSE is also used in combined magnetic-electrostatic objective lenses (Frosien et al., 1989), known under the trade name of “Gemini lens.” Both types of lens are advantageous for low-voltage SEM (see Section 3.2) because they provide excellent image resolution at low electron energies.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
155
Figure 3–7. Secondary (a) and backscattered electron (b) micrograph of a 1-mm steel ball. The arrow in (b) indicates the direction of the backscattered electron (negatively biased ETD) and the secondary electron detector.
2.1.4 Specimen Stages and Attached Equipment A conventional SEM is equipped with a specimen stage. The stage commonly can be loaded with the specimen via a specimen-exchange chamber without breaking the high vacuum in the specimen chamber. –10
– 5 mm
0
+10
+5
A
B 5 kV
4 eV
9 eV
1 eV 7.5 kV
0.5 kV Specimen
Figure 3–8. Schematic drawing of the “in-lens” detection of secondary electrons (SE) with the electrostatic detector–objective lens (Zach and Rose, 1988a,b; Zach, 1989). [From Reimer (1993); with kind permission of the International Society of Optical Engineering (SPIE), Bellingham, WA.]
156
R. Reichelt
The stage allows X, Y, Z movements, rotation around 360°, and tilting (the tilting range depends on the type of the stage, e.g., −15° to +75°) of the specimen. The movements, rotation, and tilt are usually motorized in modern scanning electron microscopes. The specimen stage is eucentric if the observation point does not vary during tilting and rotation, however, some stages have this property only for tilting (semieucentric specimen stage) or do not have it (goniometric specimen stage). If the specimen stage is eucentric or semieucentric, the WD and therefore the magnification do not change during X, Y movement or movement along the tilt axis, respectively. Usually, the specimen is at ground potential (0 V), however, the wiring allows also the recording of the specimen current or absorbed current. It is obvious that the higher the electron optical performance of the SEM the better the quality of the specimen stage in terms of mechanical and thermal stability. The manufacturers of SEMs as well as small companies supplying special attachments offer optionally specimen stages for specific investigations. For example, there are commercial hot stages available for in situ surface investigations at elevated temperatures. Depending on the type of heating device, it is possible to reach specimen temperatures up to about 1370 K with a maximum heating rate of about 200 K/min. A hot specimen stage in an environmental scanning electron microscope (see Section 4) is, among other things, very useful in studying the surface modifications caused by chemical reactions due to the exposure of samples to gases. For specific in situ heating experiments, e.g., local heating with rapid thermal loads, irradiation heating by a high-power laser coupled to an SEM can be used (see, e.g., Menzel et al., 1992; Wetzig and Schulze, 1995). Mainly for investigations of organic materials and, in particular, of biological specimens, cold stages are of great interest for low temperature studies. At low temperature the electron beam damage of the sample due to electron–specimen interaction is smaller than at room temperature (see, e.g., Craven et al., 1978; Isaacson, 1977, 1979a; Reimer and Schmidt, 1985; Egerton et al., 2004) and specimens can be investigated in the frozen-hydrated stage (see, e.g., Bastachy et al., 1988; Read and Jeffree, 1990; Walther et al., 1990). However, cold stages are also of significant interest for materials science to investigate the low temperature behavior of materials such as changes in mechanical properties or variations in electrical conductivity. In most cases liquid nitrogen or liquid helium is used as the cooling medium. In particular the temperature range around 4 K and below down to about 1.5 K allows for the investigation of typical low temperature phenomena such as superconductivity and low temperature devices used in cryoelectronics. Furthermore, experiments can be performed in which the temperature range of liquid He is required by the measuring principle, e.g., the ballistic phonon signal represents an example. Here the small specimen volume locally heated by the electron beam acts as a source of phonons, which propagate ballistically (i.e., without scattering) to the opposite side of the crystal where the photon detector is located. Both, the specimen and the detector have to be kept in the temperature range of liquid He. The SEM at very low temperatures was reviewed by Huebener (1988).
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
Further, deformation stages are used in materials science to study static and dynamic specimen deformation-related phenomena in situ (e.g., Wetzig and Schulze, 1995). In more detail, different types of sample deformation such as tension and compression, unidirectional bending, bending fatique, materials machining (e.g., study of the microscopic mechanisms of abrasive wear), and microhardness testing can be performed with a microhardness tester mounted on the stages in the SEM specimen chamber. This allows for very precise positioning of the indentations generated with a very low force and their subsequent viewing/measuring. In combination with a surface displacement transducer for the detection of acoustic emission signals, the quantitative acoustic emission due to crack coalescence can be measured (Lawson, 1995). There are also stages in different laboratories that combine, e.g., deformation and heating capabilities. With high-precision stages based on laser interferometer technology, a new field of ap-plications is opened up in the area of SEM/ FIB-based e-beam lithography, metrology, and semiconductor failure analysis. The fine positioning of the stage is made with piezoelements, which, according to the manufacturer’s specification, allow a positioning reproducibility of better than 50 nm. To obtain ultralow magnification SEM images an SEM equipped with a motor drive specimen stage fully controlled with a personal computer (PC) has been utilized (Oho and Miyamoto, 2004). This motor drive stage works as a mechanical scanning device. To produce ultralow magnification SEM images, a combination of the mechanical scanning, electronic scanning, and digital image processing techniques is used. This is a time-saving method for ultralow magnification and wide-area observation. The stage in the SEM specimen chamber can integrate not only tools such as a microhardness tester but also other types of high-resolution microscopes, e.g., a scanning tunneling (Gerber et al., 1986; Stemmer et al., 1994; Troyon et al., 1992), scanning force (Joachimsthaler et al., 2003), or scanning near-field optical microscope (Heiderhoff et al., 2000), thus combining two different microscopic techniques with their specific advantages in one hybrid microscope. As mentioned in the previous section, the specimen in “in-lens” SEMs must be small because it has to be placed in the gap of the objective lens. This requires specimen stages and holders almost identical to the ones used in TEM (side-entry sample exchange system). The specimen is mounted in a specimen holder, which commonly allows for tilting the specimen around one axis by ±30° or ±40°. Optionally, there are, for example, double-tilt specimen holders with two tilt axes as well as hot and cold/cryoholders available. The specimen holders also normally allow the use of support grids 3 mm in diameter, which is of interest for studies in transmission mode. 2.1.5 Special Topics 2.1.5.1 Digital Image Recording As mentioned briefly in Section 2.1.3.1, the SEM generates analog electronic image signals. In older SEMs the electron beam must be scanned incessantly across the surface area of interest while viewing the image
157
158
R. Reichelt
on the monitor. The information obtained by each scan is just used to refresh the image on the monitor unless the image is recorded photographically. The electron irradiation dose of each scan accumulates to a high total dose. Because radiation damaging as well as beaminduced contamination scale with the total electron dose applied, irradiation-sensitive materials in particular are possibly already damaged during the visual inspection, i.e., before recording an image of the viewed area. Modern SEMs allow recording of multichannel (e.g., SE and BSE) digital images, which are stored pixel by pixel (pixel: picture element) in a PC. Digital images usually have a square size of 512 × 512, 1024 × 1024 pixels or larger (Postek and Vladár, 1996), however, rectangular image formats are also in use, e.g., 3000 × 2000 pixels. For each pixel the analog signal arriving from the detector is integrated during the pixel time. The value obtained represents the pixel intensity, which is digitized by an analog-to-digital-converter (ADC) usually into a range of 10 or 12 bits. In practice, a sufficient lateral and signal resolution can be obtained with 1024 × 1024 pixels and 10 bits, respectively, which requires a storage capacity over 107 bits, i.e., 2 MB. Twice the number of pixels in the X and Y direction requires a 4-fold storage capacity, i.e., 8 MB. A modern PC presently has roughly 200 GB mass storage on the harddisk, which corresponds to about 105 images of 2 MB or 2.5 × 104 images of 8 MB, respectively. The fast processors presently used in PCs allow the display of an 8-MB image within milliseconds. For final storage, the digital images can be transferred from the PC via fast data transfer to external mass storage devices or big computers. However, access to images stored in an external mass storage device is slower than for direct access to the harddisk of the PC. 2.1.5.2 Specimen Tilting and Stereo Imaging Specimen stages allow the sample to be tilted, which is of interest for several special applications such as stereo imaging, reconstruction of the topography, three-dimensional morphometry, and possibly contrast enhancement. In case of a flat object aligned normal to the beam, i.e., the title angle Θ amount to 0°, there is no distortion of the projected shape of structures. For example, circular holes in a flat specimen appear circular in the image (Figure 3–9a). After tilting the flat object (the tilt axis has a horizontal direction in the micrograph) two effects become obvious in the image (especially visible at high tilt angles, e.g., Θ = 45°) (Figure 3–9b): (1) the circular holes have an elliptic shape with an axis ratio of approximately 0.7, i.e., the shape is distorted, and (2) the upper and lower rim of the upper and lower hole appears unsharp whereas the rim of the central hole appears sharp. The first effect is caused by the fact that due to the tilt the scanned range on the specimen surface perpendicular to the tilt axis is enlarged by a factor 1/cos Θ (Figure 3–9e). That corresponds to a reduced magnification M′ = M cos Θ
(2.15)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
159
Figure 3–9. Effect of tilt compensation and dynamic focusing in the SEM. Secondary electron micrographs of the holes in a flat aluminum specimen. (a) Tilt angle Θ = 0°. (b) Tilting Θ = 45° around the horizontal axis (the focus of the beam is located in the center of the micrograph). (c) Tilt compensation is “ON.” (d) Tilt compensation and dynamic focusing are “ON.” The visible wall of the bore of the holes proves that the specimen is still tilted. (e) Schematic illustration of the effects caused by tilting the sample. The position of the optimum focus plane, the depth of focus D, and the height range ∆z (∆z > D) are shown for a constant focus of the beam (solid lines). In that case, only a central region along the tilt axis is within the depth of focus (i.e., sharp image) whereas the lower and the upper range are outside D (unsharp region of the image). In case of the dynamic focus, three positions of the beam (dashed lines) are drawn indicating that the whole scan range will be in focus, thus being imaged sharply.
160
R. Reichelt e- - beam
∆Z
D
surface
scan range
Focus plane
tilt axis
sample
e
unsharp
sharp
unsharp
Figure 3–9. Continued
in the direction of the short axis whereas along the tilt axis the magnification M is not affected. The effect can be fully compensated by enlarging the reduced magnification by 1/cos Θ, which restores the magnification M (Figure 3–9c and e). The tilt compensation can be performed directly by electronic means (hardware; the unit is called “tilt compensation”) during scanning or posterior by digital image processing on condition that the directions of the tilt axis and the tilt angle are known. The second effect is caused by the fact that due to the tilt the height range of the tilted specimen extends the depth of focus, thus the image is not sharp in regions outside the depth of focus. This effect can be compensated by “dynamic focusing” (Yew, 1971), i.e., by adjusting the strength of the objective lens as a function of the scan position perpendicular to the tilt axis. This adjustment brings the optimum focus position in coincidence with the surface at all working distances in the scanned range (Figure 3–9d and e). Both effects mentioned can be compensated completely only for planar specimens and a known tilt angle. The SEM forms in imaging mode a two-dimensional image of a three-dimensional specimen with each of the signals generated by
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
161
electron–specimen interaction (cf. Figure 3–2). Although these images contain a wealth of information about the specimen, there is no solid information about the third dimension, which is parallel to the optical axis. Stereo imaging is one possibility to obtain information about the third dimension. It takes advantage of the fact that depth perception is obtained when viewing an object from two separate directions. In an SEM stereo imaging is performed by taking two images—the stereo pair—at two different tilt angles of the specimen. A good stereo effect is obtained when the angles differ form each other by about 6°. A significantly larger difference in Θ overemphasizes the stereo effect whereas a smaller difference in Θ shows a softened stereo effect. Usually, a stereo pair is viewed through a stereo viewer. A simple version of a stereo viewer consists of two short focal lenses on a stand at the correct distance from the stereo pair. There are more sophisticated versions with lens–mirror combinations, which allow for a larger field of view. For each type of viewer it is mandatory to place and to align both images precisely to obtain correct depth perception. Figure 3–10 shows a stereo pair of SEM micrographs. A further method for viewing the stereo images is the anaglyph technique (Judge, 1950), which can now readily be performed by PC (cf. Figure 3–56). In this technique both images are superimposed in
Figure 3–10. Stereopair of a radiolarian with radiating threadlike pseudopodia and a siliceous skeleton re-corded in SE mode at 15 keV. The specimen was sputter coated with gold for sufficient electrical conductivity. The difference in tilt angles of the micrographs amounts to (Θr − Θ1) = 6°. (The stereopair was kindly provided by Rudolf Göcke, Institut für Medizinische Physik und Biophysik, Münster, Germany.)
162
R. Reichelt
different colors. A red–green stereo anaglyph coding can be obtained readily by commercial software, e.g., AnalySIS Pro 3.1 [Soft Image System (SIS), Münster, Germany]. This allows for a quick and simple qualitative assessment. Usually, red is used for the “left eye” and green for the “right eye” image. The mixed colored image has to be viewed by colored glasses using red for the left and green for the right eye. However, the stereo pair can also be used to calculate the height difference ∆h between two image points 1 and 2 by measuring the parallax px given as px = (x21 − x11) − (x2r − x1r)
(2.16)
∆h = px/2M sin(Θr − Θ1)
(2.17)
and
where (x21 − x11) corresponds to the distance between the two points in the left and (x2r − x1r) to the distance between the two points in the right image. Θr and Θ1 correspond to the tilt angle of the specimen used for the right and left image, respectively. Equation (2.17) holds for magnifications M > 100, i.e., in case of parallel projection. The successful application of the latter two formulas requires (1) distinct surface structures to measure px with sufficient accuracy, and (2) the magnification and the tilt angle must be known exactly. On the basis of the relations (2.16) and (2.17) and data analysis software [e.g., AnalySIS Pro 3.1 (SIS, Münster, Germany), 3-D Morphometry in SEM (ComServ, Salzburg, Austria), and MeX (Alicona Imaging GmbH, Grambach, Austria)] quantitative dimensional and angular measurements, the reconstruction of the specimen topography and three-dimensional morphometry can be achieved. The latter is very useful to analyze microstructures such as blood capillaries, which have diameters in the range of a few micrometers (Malkusch et al., 1995; Minnich et al., 1999, 2003). Using the image pair imported for anaglyph generation, a point of reference has to be selected in one of the images that would also be clearly visible in the second image. The software (e.g., AnalySIS Pro 3.1, see above) uses this reference point to define a small region and then uses correlation to accurately align the images. Once aligned, the parallax difference allowed generation of a new 8-bit grayscale image in which depth differences are encoded as different gray values. Quantitative measurements, e.g., the volume of depressions, can be performed using an SIS Macro (macroinstruction, i.e., application of a specific programming language), based on the SIS-Stereo imaging module. 2.1.5.3 Magnification Calibration The actual magnification of the SEM is indicated numerically and by a scale bar on the monitor with a precision of about ±3%. However, if exact measurements have to be made (e.g., see Section 2.1.5.2), the magnification should be verified using an external standard. Calibrated gratings with known spacings are commercially available from different suppliers of electron microscopy accessories (e.g., Agar Scientific, http://www.agarscientific.com). For a magnification
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
163
range up to about 100,000× crossed gratings with spacings of 1200 and 2160 lines/mm (cf. Figure 3–11) are recommended. Latex spheres of defined diameter (different diameters in the range from about 0.1 to 1 µm are commercially available) can also be used. However, the size of the latex spheres varies to some extent (e.g., small diameter, 0.112 µm; standard deviation, 10−3 µm; large diameter, 1.036 µm; standard deviation, 16.1 × 10−3 µm). Moreover, the latex spheres are sensitive to electron radiation, thus their size may change caused by electron dose-induced damages. To calibrate the magnification range above 100,000× negatively stained catalase (periodic lattice spacings: 8.75 and 6.85 nm) can be used as standard (preferentially in the STEM mode). 2.2 Electron–Specimen Interaction and Signal Generation As the beam electrons enter the specimen, they interact with the atoms of the specimen. This interaction either results in elastic or inelastic scattering of the impinging electrons. The elastic scattering of the electron is caused by its interaction with the electrical field of the positively charged nucleus and results only in a deflection of the beam electron, i.e., after the scattering event the electron trajectory has a different direction than before scattering. There is almost no loss of kinetic energy of the electron scattered elastically. For scanning electron microscopy it is necessary to know the elastic electron scattering through large angles between 0° and 180°. The scattering can be described quantitatively by the scattering cross section σ. The exact elastic scattering cross sections for large-angle
Figure 3–11. SE micrographs of a commercial cross-grating replica with 2160 lines/mm at low (a) and medium magnification (b).
164
R. Reichelt
scattering are the Mott cross sections σM,el, which, in contrast to Rutherford scattering, consider the electron spin and spin-orbit coupling during scattering (for details see, e.g., Reimer and Krefting, 1976; Rez, 1984; Reimer, 1985). The easy to calculate unscreened differential Rutherford cross section dσR,el/dΩ are given as (Reimer, 1985) dσR,el/dΩ = e4 Z2/[4(4πε0)2m2v4sin4(ϕ/2)]
(2.18)
where dΩ is the cone of the solid angle, e is the electric charge (e = 1.602 × 10−19 C) and m the mass of the electron, v is the velocity of the electron, Z is the atomic number, ε0 is the dielectric constant (ε0 = 8.85 × 10−12 C/ Vm), and ϕ is the scattering angle. The comparison of the differential Mott cross sections dσM,el/dΩ (Reimer and Lödding, 1984) with the unscreened differential Rutherford cross sections dσR,el/dΩ for electron energies between 1 and 100 keV shows that there are strong deviations of the Rutherford cross section, particularly for high Z. Mott cross sections for electron energies below 1 keV (energy range 20 eV to 20 keV) were calculated by Czyzewski et al. (1990; see also http://web.utk. edu/~srcutk/Mott/mott.htm). There is very reasonable agreement between both cross sections for low atomic numbers and electron energies above 5 keV. However, for low Z and energies below 5 keV, the Rutherford cross sections are larger than the Mott cross sections for scattering angles below 70°–80° and are smaller than the Mott cross sections for scattering angles above 70°–80°. The probability for elastic scattering is approximately proportional to Z2 and inversely proportional to E2 (with E = mv2/2), i.e., the scattering cross section strongly increases with the atomic number and decreases for increasing electron energy E. The total elastic scattering cross section σel can be obtained by integration π
σ el = 2π ∫ (dσ el/dΩ)sin ϕdϕ 0
(2.19)
σel can be used to calculate the mean free path for elastic scattering Λel, i.e., the free path between two consecutive elastic scattering events in a specimen consisting of many atoms, which is given as Λel = 1/Nσel
(2.20)
N represents the number of atoms per unit volume and can be calculated simply by N = NAρ/A
(2.21)
where ρ is the density, NA is Avogadro’s number (NA = 6.0221 × 1023 mol−1), and A is the atomic weight (g/mol). Much more detailed data of elastic electron scattering cross sections were recently published (Jablonski et al., 2003). As we shall see later, the mean free path is an important quantity for describing plural (mean number of collisions <25) and multiple electron scattering (mean number of collisions >25 ± 5). The inelastic scattering of the electron is caused by its interaction with the electrical field of the electrons in the solid, i.e., either with the electrons in the valence or conduction band and with atomic electrons of
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
inner shells, respectively. After an inelastic scattering event the electron trajectory has a slightly different direction than before scattering (typically the inelastic scattering angles are of the order of a few milliradians only) and less kinetic energy. If the lost energy was transferred to electrons in the valence or conduction band then the excitation of plasmons (a plasmon is a longitudinal charge-density wave of the valence or conduction electrons) or inter- and intraband transitions may occur. Both the energy of plasmons and the energy differences of inter- and intraband transitions are in the order of about 5–50 eV. The physics of the latter processes is reviewed by Raether (1980). If the lost energy was transferred to atomic electrons of inner shells then, for example, K-, L-, or M-shell ionization may occur. In this case the energy loss typically is higher than 50 eV. The differential inelastic electron scattering cross section with a free electron (which is an approximation for an electron in the valence or conduction band) is given (Reimer, 1985) as dσin/dW = πe4/[(4πε0)2EW2]
(2.22)
where W is the energy loss. The equation shows that the differential inelastic scattering cross section is inversely proportional to electron energy E and to W2 and that small energy losses occur with a larger probability. In a more complex approach for the differential inelastic scattering cross section the energy loss function Im(−1/ε) is used taking the dielectric properties of the material into account (e.g., Powell, 1984). An impinging electron can be inelastically scattered passing the atom even in a distance of a few nanometers, thus the inelastic scattering is delocalized to a certain extent (Isaacson and Langmore, 1974; Zeitler, 1978; Reichelt and Engel, 1986; Müller and Silcox, 1994, 1995). In the case of inner shell excitation the electron interaction is localized to an electron shell. The corresponding inelastic scattering, also called ionization cross section, is the probability of bringing a scattering atom to a given excited state through an inelastic process. The related cross sections are typically at least two orders of magnitude smaller than those for the electrons in the valence or conduction band. Calculations of the ionization cross sections of the K-, L-, and M-shell have been published (see, e.g., Leapman et al., 1980; Inokuti and Manson, 1984; Egerton, 1986). The total inelastic scattering cross section σin can be obtained by integration π
σ in = 2π ∫ (dσ in/dΩ)sin ϕdϕ 0
(2.23)
The mean free path for inelastic scattering Λin is given analogous to Eq. (2.20) as Λin = 1/Nσin
(2.24)
(for detailed data and calculation of the electron inelastic mean free path see Powell and Jablonski, 2000). The total scattering cross section then is given as σ = σel + σin
(2.25)
165
166
R. Reichelt
In bulk specimens multiple scattering of the impinging electrons takes place. Mainly the multiple elastic scattering causes a successive broadening of their angular distribution and can, after numerous scattering events, result in beam electrons leaving the specimen. The beam electrons, which leave the specimen, are designated as backscattered electrons and carry an important class of information about the local specimen volume through which they have been passing. Multiple inelastic scattering along the electron trajectories results in a slowing down and the beam electron can come to a standstill if it cannot leave the specimen as BSE. The majority of beam electrons are scattered both elastically as well as inelastically. Therefore, the majority of BSE have energies smaller than E0 (cf. Figure 3–12). The broadening of the angular distribution can be calculated analytically using the autoconvolution of the single scattering distribution expanded in terms of Legendre polynomials (Goudsmit and Saunderson, 1940). Another method to treat multiple scattering is the simulation of the successive scattering events by Monte Carlo calculations for about 103–105 electron trajectories (cf. Figure 3–13; for Monte Carlo simulations of electron scattering see, e.g., Reimer and Krefting, 1976; Kyser, 1984; Reimer and Stelter, 1986; Joy, 1987b; Reimer, 1968, 1996; Drouin et al., 1997; Hovington et al., 1997a,b). In this method, the most important scattering parameters, such as scattering angle, mean free electron path, and energy loss, are simulated for each individual scattering event along the trajectory by a computer using random numbers and probability functions of the scattering parameters. The energy loss along the trajectory can be described by the Bethe continuous-slowing-down approximation (Bethe, 1930) dE/ds[eV/cm] = −7.8 × 1010 (Zρ/AE)ln(1.166 E/J)
(2.26)
nel SE
BSE
AE
E0
50 eV
E
EAE
Figure 3–12. Schematic energy distribution of electrons emitted from a surface as a result of its bombardment with fast electrons with energy E0. AE, Auger electrons; BSE, backscattered electrons; SE, secondary electrons; EAE, energy of AE; ne1, energy-dependent number of emitted electrons.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy C E0 = 30 keV
2 µm
167
Au E0 = 30 keV
200 nm
C E0 = 5 keV
200 nm
C E0 = 1 keV
20 nm
Au E0 = 5 keV
20 nm
Au E0 = 1 keV
2 nm
Figure 3–13. Monte Carlo simulation of the trajectories of 100 electrons for carbon (atomic number Z = 6) and gold (Z = 79) for electron energies E0 = 30, 5, and 1 keV. For simulation of the electron trajectories the Monte Carlo program MOCASIM (Reimer, 1996) was used. Note the different scales across three orders of magnitude indicated by bars and the variation of the shape of the local volume where electron scattering takes place. That local volume is usually denominated as the excitation volume.
R. Reichelt
where ρ is the density (g/cm3), E the electron energy (eV), and J the mean ionization potential (Berger and Seltzer, 1964) given by J[eV] = 9.76Z + 58.8Z−0.19
(2.27)
The limitations of the Bethe expression at low electron energy can be overcome by using an energy-dependent value J* for the mean ionization potential (Joy and Luo, 1989) J* = J/(1 + kJ/E)
(2.28)
where k varies between 0.77 (carbon) and 0.85 (gold). The total traveling distance of a beam electron in the specimen—the Bethe range RB —can be obtained by integration over the energy range from E0 to a small threshold energy and extrapolation to E = 0. The practical electron range R (cf. Figure 3–14) obtained by fitting experimental data of specimens with different Z over a wide energy range is given by the power law R = aE0n
(2.29)
where n is in the range of about 1.3–1.7 and the parameter a depends on the material (Reimer, 1985). Characteristic values for R, σel, σin, Λel,
CL
e-
X-ray
BSE1 BSE2 SE1
AE
SE2
tSE
tBSE
Specimen thickness
168
R
Figure 3–14. Schematic illustration of the generation of secondary electrons SE1 and SE2, backscattered electrons BSE1 and BSE2, Auger electrons AE, cathodoluminescence CL, and X-rays in a bulky specimen. tSE and tBSE indicate the escape depth for SE and BSE, respectively. R is the electron range.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
169
Table 3–3. Characteristic values for R, sel, sin, Lel, and Lin. a E 0 = 1 keV 0.65
E 0 = 5 keV 0.11
Element Carbon
Parameter sel (nm2 ) ¥ 102
Z=6
sin (nm2 ) ¥ 102
1.95
0.33
Lel (nm)
1.5
9.0
Copper Z = 29
Z = 79
a
0.165
E 0 = 30 keV 0.018 0.054
18
55 18
Lin (nm)
0.5
3.0
6
R (mm)
0.033
0.49
1.55
9.7
1.84
0.64
0.37
0.15
sel (nm2 ) ¥ 102 2
sin (nm ) ¥ 10
2
Lel (nm)
Gold
E 0 = 10 keV 0.055
1.10
0.38
0.22
0.09
0.64
1.8
3.2
7.8
Lin (nm)
1.07
3.0
5.3
R (mm)
0.007
0.11
0.35
2.26
3.93
1.6
1.05
0.52
sel (nm2 ) ¥ 102 2
sin (nm ) ¥ 10
2
13
0.79
0.32
0.21
0.10
Lel (nm)
0.43
1.0
1.6
3.3
Lin (nm)
2.15
5.0
8.0
16.5
R (mm)
0.003
0.05
0.17
1.0
Values are listed for four different electron energies between 1 and 30 keV and three elements having a low (C), medium (Cu), and high atomic number (Au), respectively. For calculation, the following densities were used: C, ρ = 2 g cm−3; Cu, ρ = 8.9 g cm−3; Au, ρ = 19.3 g cm−3.
and Ιin are shown in Table 3–3. It shows that independent on the electron energy the electron range for carbon is about one order of magnitude larger than for gold. The decrease of the electron energy from 30 to 1 keV, i.e., a factor of 30, reduces the electron range by a significantly higher factor of roughly 300. The mean free path lengths indicate after which traveling distance on average elastic and inelastic collisions will occur. For example, in a thin organic specimen having a thickness of 50–100 nm only a few collisions on average will take place with 30-keV electrons but about seven times more with 5-keV electrons. Specimens, which have thicknesses of about t ≤ 10[ΛelΛin/(Λel + Λin)] can also be imaged in the transmission mode (cf. Figures 3–1 and 3–2) using unscattered, elastically or inelastically scattered electrons, respectively. The angular and energy distribution of the scattered electrons can be calculated by Monte Carlo simulations if the elemental composition and the density of the specimen are known (Reichelt and Engel, 1984; Krzyzanek et al., 2003). The inelastic electron scattering events in the specimen cause secondary electrons, Auger electrons, cathodoluminescence, and X-rays, which carry a wealth of local information about the topography, the electronic structure, and the composition of the specimen. The signals, resulting from inelastic electron scattering, can also be calculated by Monte Carlo simulations. 2.2.1 Secondary Electrons The energy spectrum of the electrons emitted from a specimen irradiated with fast electrons consists of secondary electrons, backscattered
170
R. Reichelt
electrons, and Auger electrons (cf. Figure 3–12). The SE show a peak at low energies with a most probable energy of 2–5 eV. By definition the maximum energy of SE amounts 50 eV. Secondary electrons are generated by inelastic scattering of the beam electrons along their trajectories within the specimen (Figure 3–14). The physics of secondary electron emission is reviewed by Kollath (1956) and Dekker (1958) but is beyond the scope of this chapter. Due to the low energy of the SE only those SE are observable that are generated within the escape depth from the surface. The actual escape depth of SE for pure elements varies with their atomic number (Kanaya and Ono, 1984). A general rule for their escape depth is tSE = 5 ΛSE (Seiler, 1967), where ΛSE is the mean free path of the SE. tSE amounts to about 5 nm for metals and up to about 75 nm for insulators (Seiler, 1984). The angular distribution of SE follows Lambert’s Law, i.e., is a cos ζ distribution, where ζ represents the SE emission angle relative to the surface normal (Jonker, 1957; Oppel and Jahrreiss, 1972). The angular distribution of the SE is not important for the image contrast in SEM because the extraction field of the ET detector normally collects the emitted SE. The situation, however, is different in case of magnetic “through-the-lens” detection where no electric extraction field is applied (cf. Figure 3–6). Figure 3–15 shows schematically the SE yield δ versus the energy of the beam electrons, which is the number of SE produced by one beam electron. δ increases with E0, reaches its maximum δm at E0,m, and then decreases with further increasing E0. Typical values for metals are 0.35 ≤ δm ≤ 1.6 and 100 eV ≤ E0,m ≤ 800 eV and for insulators 1.0 ≤ δm ≤ 10 and 300 eV ≤ E0,m ≤ 2000 eV (Seiler, 1984). For E0 >> E0,m δ is proportional to E0 −0.8 (Drescher et al., 1970), which indicates that δ is significantly smaller at 30 than at 5 keV. Both parameters, δm at E0,m depend on the ionization energy of the surface atoms (Ono and Kanaya, 1979). Figure 3–16 shows the SE yield δ versus the energy E0 for the element copper. There is no monotonic relation between δ and the atomic number as shown in Figure 3–17. However, published data of δ scatter which
δ
δm 1
0 0
E0,1
E0,m
E0,2
E0
Figure 3–15. Schematic representation of the SE yield δ vs. the energy E0 of beam electrons.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy 1.4 1.2 η+δ 1 0.8
δ
0.6 η
0.4 0.2 0 0.5
0
1
1.5
2 E0 (keV)
2.5
3.5
3
4
Figure 3–16. SE yield δ, BSE yield η, and δ + η versus the energy E0 for polycrystalline copper at θ = 0°. (Data from Bauer and Seiler, 1984.)
0.6 η
Eo = 30 keV 0.5
δ, η
0.4
0.3
0.2 δ 0.1
0 0
20
40
60
80
100
Atomic number Z
Figure 3–17. SE yield δ and BSE yield η versus atomic number Z at E0 = 30 keV and θ = 0°. (Data from Heinrich, 1966; Wittry, 1966.)
171
172
R. Reichelt
indicates that the specimen surface conditions and the quality of the vacuum can significantly affect the secondary yield (cf. “Data Base on Elector-Solid Interactions” by Joy, 2001). Secondary electrons generated by the incident beam electrons are designated SE1 (Drescher et al., 1970). The SE1 carry local information about the small cylindrical volume that is given approximately by the cross section of the beam (π/4)dpe2 and the escape depth tSE. For a beam diameter about ≤1 nm the SE1 deliver high-resolution information. Those beam electrons, which are multiply scattered and emerge from the specimen as BSE, also generate secondary electrons within the escape depth. These secondary electrons are designated SE2 (Drescher et al., 1970). Their origin is far from the point of incidence of the beam caused by the spatial distribution of BSE. Changes of the amount of SE2 correlate with corresponding changes of BSE, thus SE2 carry information about the volume from which the BSE originate. The size of the volume depends on the electron range R and is much larger than the excitation volume of the SE1 for electron energies E0 > 1 keV (cf. Figure 3–14 and Table 3–3); thus SE2 deliver low-resolution information. The SE yield δ consists of the contributions of SE1 and SE2 given as δ = δSE1 + ηδSE2
(2.30)
where η is the BSE coefficient and δSE2 the SE2 yield, i.e., the number of SE2 generated per BSE. For E0,m < E0 < 5 kV the ratio δSE2/δSE1 amounts to about 4 and for E0 ≥ 10 kV about 2 (Seiler, 1967). For an increasing angle of incidence θ, this ratio decreases (Seiler, 1968). The SE yield increases with increasing angle of incidence θ according to δ(θ) = δ0/cos θ;
δ0 = δ(θ = 0)
(2.31)
(Figure 3–18). This relation is valid for a specimen with a mean atomic number, for E0 ≥ 5 keV, and θ up to a few degrees below 90°. The increase of δ with θ is greater for specimens with a low atomic number and smaller for samples with high Z (Reimer and Pfefferkorn, 1977). For crystalline objects, the increase of δ with θ is superimposed by electron channeling and crystalline orientation contrast (see Section 2.3). The distinct dependence of the SE yield on θ provides the basis for the topographic contrast in secondary electron micrographs. 2.2.2 Backscattered Electrons The majority of BSE is due to multiple scattering of the beam electrons within the specimen (Figure 3–14). The energy spectrum of the backscattered electrons is shown schematically in Figure 3–12. By definition the energy of BSE is in the range 50 eV < EBSE ≤ E0. The BSE spectrum has a small peak consisting of elastically scattered electrons at E0 (this peak is not visible in Figure 3–12). Toward energies lower than E0 there is a broad peak, which covers the range down to about 0.7E0 for high atomic numbers and further down to about 0.4E0 for low atomic numbers. The majority of BSE are within this broad peak. For high atomic number elements such as gold, the maximum of the distinct peak is at about 0.9E0, whereas for low atomic numbers, e.g., carbon, the maximum of the less distinct peak is located at about (0.5–0.6)E0.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy 6 δ∗ 5
η∗
δ,η
4
Cu
3
2 η∗
Au
1
0 0
20
40
60
80
100
Θ (1°)
Figure 3–18. Normalized SE yield δ* and BSE yield η* versus the angle of incidence θ of the electron beam. δ* = δ(θ)/δ0, η* = η(θ)/η0. η was calculated for gold and copper according to Eq. (2.34).
The cumulative fraction of 50% of BSE is reached for carbon at EBSE/E0 = 0.55 and for gold at 0.84, respectively (Goldstein et al., 2003). It seems worth mentioning that the energy distribution of BSE is shifted toward higher energy if the angle of incident electrons is larger than 70° (Wells, 1974). As shown in Figure 3–14, the BSE can originate either from the small area directly irradiated by the electron beam—they are denoted as BSE1—or after multiple elastic and inelastic scattering events from a significantly larger circular area around the beam impact point, which are designated BSE2. The lateral distribution of BSE2 has been calculated by Monte Carlo simulation for different materials (see, e.g., Murata, 1974, 1984). It shows that the BSE-emitting surface area increases with electron energy E0. For a given energy E0 the size of the BSE-emitting area increases with descending atomic number. As with SE1, the BSE1 carry local information about the small volume and deliver high-resolution information for a beam diameter of about ≤1 nm. As a consequence of lateral spreading the BSE2 carry information about a much larger region, thus fine structural details on the scale of the beam diameter cannot be resolved. Figure 3–14 also shows that the beam electrons travel in a small subsurface volume before they return to the surface to escape as BSE2. The escape depth of BSE is much larger than tSE and depends on—in
173
174
R. Reichelt
contrast to tSE—the electron energy E0. Experimental data for different materials show that tBSE amounts to about half of the electron range R (Drescher et al., 1970; Seiler, 1976). Knowledge of the angular distribution of BSE is of great importance for understanding and optimization of BSE detection geometry. For normal beam incidence the angular distribution can be approximated by a cos ζ distribution (Drescher et al., 1970), where ζ represents the BSE emission angle relative to the surface normal. Due to the fact that the emitted BSE move on nearly straight trajectories, the angular detector position has a strong influence on the collection efficiency of the detector. For nonnormal beam incidence the distribution is asymmetric and a reflection-like emission maximum is observed. The angular distribution consists for large angles of incidence θ of cosine distribution approximately directed to −θ and a superimposed fraction at smaller emission angles (Drescher et al., 1970). The BSE coefficient η is defined by η = nBSE/nb
(2.32)
where nBSE is the number of BSE and nb is the number of incident electrons. η is approximately independent of the electron energy E0 in the range of about 10–30 keV. For low atomic numbers and beam energies below 5 keV η increases as E0 decreases, whereas for medium and high atomic numbers η decreases with E0 (cf. Figure 3–16) (Reimer and Tollkamp, 1980). However, at low energies η depends in a complex manner on the atomic number (Heinrich, 1966; cf. “Data Base on Electron-Solid Interactions” by Joy, 2001). The BSE coefficient monotonically increases with the atomic number as shown for 30 keV in Figure 3–17. Because of the approximate independence of the electron energy E0, the graph of the BSE coefficient is valid for beam energy ranging from 30 down to about 5 keV. The graph of η versus Z can be approximated by a polynomial (Reuter, 1972) η(Z) = 0.0254 + 0.016 Z − 1.86 × 10−4 Z2 + 8.31 × 10−7 Z3
(2.33)
For energies below 5 keV the dependence of η on Z is more complicated (for details see Hunger and Kuchler, 1979; Joy, 1991; Zadrazil et al., 1997). The distinct dependence of the BSE coefficient on the atomic number Z provides the basis for the atomic number contrast (see Section 2.3). Like the SE yield, the backscattering coefficient also increases monotonically with increasing angle of incidence θ according to (Arnal et al., 1969) η(θ) = (1 + cos θ)−9/
Z
(2.34)
Figure 3–18 shows the graphs η(θ) versus θ for Cu (Z = 29) and Au (Z = 79). The graphs indicate the strong influence of the atomic number, in particular for θ > 50°. The monotonic increase of η with θ provides the basis for the topographic contrast in BSE micrographs. For the sake of completeness it should be mentioned that Drescher et al. (1970) derived from experimental data at 25 keV an analytical expression for η(θ, Z) other than the one given by Eq. (2.34).
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
The backscattering coefficient of a single crystal depends sensitively on the direction of the incident electrons related to the crystal lattice (Reimer et al., 1971; Seiler, 1976). This dependence is caused by the regular three-dimensional arrangement of the atoms in the lattice, whose atomic density depends on the direction. The backscattering coefficient is lower along directions of low atomic density, which permits a fraction of the incident electrons to penetrate deeper than in amorphous material before being scattered. Those electrons have a reduced probability of returning to the specimen surface and leaving the sample as BSE. The maximum relative variation of the backscattering coefficient is in the order of 5%. 2.2.3 Transmitted Electrons When the thickness of a specimen approaches the electron range R or becomes even smaller than R, an increasing fraction of beam electrons is transmitted. Those transmitted electrons interact with the support, thus generating non-specimen-specific signals, which superimpose the specimen-specific signals. The spurious contribution of the support to the signal, originating from the specimen, can be reduced significantly by replacing the solid support by a very thin (about 5–15 nm thick) amorphous carbon film. Such thin carbon films supported by a metallic mesh grid are commonly used in TEM and STEM as electrontransparent support for thin specimens. To improve the stability of the 5-nm-thick carbon film, the film is placed onto a holey thick carbon film supported by a mesh grid. In contrast to a solid support, a 5-nmthick carbon film contributes only insignificantly to the SE and BSE signal (cf. Figure 3–19), thus particles deposited onto a thin support film can be imaged in the normal manner using SE and BSE, respectively. In addition to the reduction of spurious signal, the transparent support film enables use to be made of the transmitted electrons, which carry information about the interior of the specimen (in some SEM the specimen stage must be altered to make the transmitted electrons accessible). As a result of electron–specimen interaction the transmitted electrons can be unscattered or elastically or inelastically scattered (cf. Figure 3–2). Due to their characteristic angular and energy distribution, the transmitted electrons can be separated by placing suitable detectors (preferentially combined with an electron spectrometer) below the specimen. Frequently, a rather simple and inexpensive device for observing an STEM image (Oho et al., 1986)—sometimes called “poor man’s STEM in SEM detector”—is used. The transmitted electrons are passing through an angle-limiting aperture, strike a tilted gold-coated surface, and thus create a high SE and BSE signal, which can then be collected by a conventional ET detector. The angle-limiting aperture cuts off the transmitted, scattered electrons. In this case the “poor man’s STEM in SEM detector” acquires those electrons, which represent the bright-field signal. The “poor man’s STEM in SEM detector” just cuts the transmitted scattered electrons without making use of their inherent information. Both the elastically and the inelastically scattered electrons are signals, which very sensitively depend on the
175
176
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–19. SE and annular dark-field micrographs showing a particle on an ∼4-nm-thick amorphous carbon film (CF) attached to a holey carbon film of ∼20 nm in thickness (HF), which is supported by a Cu mesh grid (G). (a) SE micrograph recorded with a probe current of about 30 pA at 30 kV. A very low probe current of ∼3 pA (pixeltime: 23 µs. i.e., ∼430 incident electrons/pixel) was used for simultaneously recording the SE micrograph (b) and the dark-field micrograph with scattered transmitted electrons (annular dark-field mode) (c). The image intensity and the signal-to-noise ratio in (c) is much higher than the intensity in (b) because the number of SE (almost only SE1 are generated) is significantly smaller than the number of the collected transmitted scattered electrons. No usable BSE signal can be detected from the thick and thin carbon films. The scale bar corresponds to 20 µm.
mass thickness ρt if the specimen thickness t ≤ [ΛelΛin/(Λel + Λin)] (Reichelt and Engel, 1984, 1985) (Figure 3–20) can be used, e.g., for mass determination of biomolecules and assemblies thereof (Zeitler and Bahr, 1962; Lamvik, 1977; Engel, 1978; Wall, 1979; Feja et al., 1997). Although most of the mass determination studies were made with dedicated STEM, high-resolution FESEM equipped with an efficient
Fraction of electrons
1 unscattered
0.8
scattered
0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
20
40 60 t [nm]
80
100
Figure 3–20. Fraction of transmitted electrons scattered into an angular range of 25–300 mrad for carbon (ρ = 2 g cm−3; solid line) and protein (ρ = 1.35 g cm−3; dashed line). Parameters: E0 = 30 keV, αp = 10 mrad. The graphs show an increasing fraction of scattered and a decreasing fraction of unscattered electrons with increasing thickness. (Calculation according to Krzyzanek and Reichelt, 2003.)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
annular dark-field detector capable of single-electron counting and MHz counting rates would allow for such quantitative studies (Reichelt et al., 1988; Krzyzanek and Reichelt, 2003; Krzyzanek et al., 2004). Another important application of STEM imaging is the measurement of the physical probe size of the SEM using a thin carbon fi lm (thickness below 10 nm, preferably containing nanoparticles of gold or gold-palladium for better contrast). In this case the broadening of the electron beam in the fi lm is negligible and so the resolution of the STEM image is equal to the probe diameter. The image resolution can be determined either by analysis of the diffractogram (power spectrum) of the STEM micrograph (Frank et al., 1970; Reimer, 1985; Joy, 2002) or by cross-correlation function analysis (Frank, 1980) of the phase noise in the bright-field STEM image of the carbon fi lm. The latter directly yields the probe diameter of the SEM (Joy, 2002). Combining the SE and BSE detectors above as well as the bright-field and dark-field detectors below the specimen, its surface as well as its internal structure can be observed simultaneously in the SEM. 2.2.4 Cathodoluminescence Cathodoluminescence (CL) is the emission of light generated by the electron bombardment of semiconductors and insulators (Muir and Grant, 1974; cf. Figure 3–14). Those materials have an electronic band structure characterized by a filled valence band and an empty conduction band separated by an energy gap ∆ECV = EC − EV. Electrons from the valence band can interact inelastically with a beam electron and can be excited to an unoccupied state in the conduction band. The excess energy of the excited electron will be lost by a cascade of nonradiative phonon and electron excitations. Most of the recombination processes of excited electrons with holes in the valence band are nonradiative processes, which elevate the sample temperature. There are different radiative processes, which take place in inorganic materials, semiconductors, and organic molecules. In inorganic materials intrinsic and extrinsic transitions can take place. The intrinsic emission is due to direct recombination of electron hole pairs. Extrinsic emission is caused by the recombination of trapped electrons and holes at the donor and acceptor level, respectively. The trapping increases the probability of recombination. The extrinsically emitted photons have a lower energy than intrinsically emitted photons. In semiconductors the radiative recombination can be due to the direct collision of an electron with a hole with the emission of a phonon. Depending on the nature of the band structure of the material, the recombination can be either direct or indirect. In the latter case the recombination must occur by simultaneous emission of a photon. Indirect recombination is less likely than direct recombination. If the material contains impurities, the process of recombination via impurity level becomes important. The modification of CL efficiency as a function of the purity and the perfection of the material is the most important aspect of the use of this method in scanning electron
177
178
R. Reichelt
microscopy. It is because of such modifications that a contrast is generated (for details see, e.g., Holt and Yacobi, 1989; Yacobi, 1990). It was shown in some cases that the sensitivity of CL analyses can be at least 104 times higher than that obtainable by X-ray microanalysis, i.e., an impurity concentration as low as 1014 cm−3 (Holt and Saba, 1985). In organic materials the excitation is inside an individual molecule. Electrons go from a ground state to a singlet state at least two states above. Then the deexcitation to the ground state is radiationless up to the singlet state directly above the ground level and from this state the deexcitation can be either radiationless or radiative with decay times larger than 10−7 s (fluorescence). The CL spectra depend on the chemical structure of the molecule (DeMets et al., 1974; DeMets, 1975). Cathodoluminescence of organic matter also can be caused by selective staining with luminescent molecules (fluorochromes). Typical fluorochromes are, e.g., fluoresceine, fluoresceine isothiocyanate (FITC), and acridine orange. Independent on the material the light generated by CL inside the specimen has to pass the surface according to the Snell law (Bröcker et al., 1977). The critical angle θt of total internal reflection is given as sin θt = n1/n
(2.35)
where n1 = 1 (vacuum) and n is the refractive index of the specimen (1 < n < 5). As shown by Eq. (2.35) the fraction of emitted light is significantly reduced by total internal reflection for n > 2 (semiconductors). 2.2.5 X-Rays The X-ray spectrum is considered to be that part of the electromagnetic spectrum that covers the wavelengths λX from approximately 0.01 to 10 nm. The energy of X-rays is given as EX = hν = hc/λX
(2.36)
where h = 6.6256 × 10−34 Js is Planck’s constant, c = 2.99793 × 108 m/s is the speed of light, and ν is the frequency of X-rays. The X-rays are generated by deceleration of electrons (X-ray continuum or bremsstrahlung) or by electron transition from a filled higher state to a vacancy in a lower electron shell (characteristic X-ray lines) (Figure 3–21). The X-ray continuum is made up of a continuous distribution of intensity as a function of energy whereas the characteristic spectrum represents a series of peaks of variable intensity at discrete elementspecific energies. As the electron energy increases the intensity of the continuous spectrum also increases and the maximum of the distribution is shifted toward higher energies. The general appearance of the continuous spectrum is independent of the atomic number of the specimen, however, the absolute intensity values are dependent on the atomic number. The maximum possible energy EX is given by the electron energy E0, which corresponds to instantaneous stopping of an electron at a single collision (Duane-Hunt limit). According to Kramers
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
Intensity
Characteristic X-ray spectrum
X-ray continuum
Ex
Figure 3–21. Schematic representation of the X-ray spectrum emitted from a specimen bombarded with fast electrons.
(1923) the intensity of the continuous spectrum Ic emitted in an energy interval with the width dEX is given as IC(EX)dEX = kZ(E0 − EX)/EX ⋅ dEX
(2.37)
k represents the Kramers constant, which varies slightly with the atomic number (Reimer, 1985). A detailed treatment of the continuous X-ray emission is given by Stephenson (1957). The characteristic X-ray spectrum consisting of peaks at discrete energies is superimposed on the continuous X-ray spectrum (cf. Figure 3–21). Their positions are independent of the energy of the incident electrons. The peaks occur only if the corresponding atomic energy level is excited. The generation of characteristic X-rays consists of three different steps. First, a beam electron interacts with an inner shell electron of an atom and ejects this inner shell electron leaving that atom in an excited state, i.e., with a vacancy on the electron shell. Second, subsequently the excited atom relaxes to the ground state by transition of an electron from an outer to an inner shell vacancy. The energy difference ∆Ech between the involved shells is characteristic for the atomic number. Third, this element-specific energy difference is expressed either by the emission of an electron of an outer shell with a characteristic energy (Auger electron) or by the emission of a characteristic X-ray with energy EX = ∆Ech. The fraction of characteristic Xrays emitted when an electron transition occurs is given by the fluorescence yield ω. This quantity increases with the atomic number and depends on the inner electron shell involved (Figure 3–22). The complement, 1 − ω represents the Auger electron yield, which gives the corresponding fraction of Auger electrons produced. The fluorescence yield for the different shells and subshells can be calculated (for details see Bambynek et al., 1972).
179
R. Reichelt 0.3
0.7 K-shell 0.6
0.4
0.5
0.5 L-shell
0.4
0.6
0.3
0.7
0.2
0.8
1-ω
Fluorescence yield ω
180
M-shell 0.9
0.1
1.0
0 0
20
40 60 Atomic number
80
100
Figure 3–22. Dependence of the X-ray fluorescence yield ω and its complement (1 − ω) of the K-, L-, and M-shell from the atomic number. The complement (1 − ω) corresponds to the Auger electron yield.
Moseley studied the line spectra in detail and found that the general appearance of the X-ray spectrum is the same for all elements. The energy of a characteristic X-ray line depends on the atomic shells involved in the transition resulting in the emission of this line. The Xray lines can be classified in series according to the shell where the ionization took place, e.g., K-, L-, M-shell, etc. The quantum energies of a series are given by Moseley’s law EX = A(Z − B)2
(2.38)
where A and B are parameters that depend on the series to which the line belongs. The characteristic X-ray energy Ex is denoted by symbols that identify the transition that produced it. The first letter, e.g., K, L, identifies the original excited level, whereas the second letter, e.g., α, β, designates the type of transition occurring. For example, Kα denotes the excitation energy between the K- and L-shell, whereas Kβ denotes the excitation energy between the K- and M-shell. Transitions between subshells are designated by a number, e.g., a transition from the subshell LIII to K is denoted as Kα1 and from the subshell LII to K is denoted as Kα2, respectively. The transition from the subshell LI to K is forbidden. The characteristic X-ray energies and X-ray atomic energy levels for the K-, L-, and M-shells are listed in tables (Bearden, 1967a,b). Fortunately, the atomic energy levels are not strongly influenced by the type and strength of the chemical bonds. However, chemical effects on X-ray emission are observed for transitions from the valence electron states, which are involved in chemical bonds. In such cases the narrow lines show changes of their shape and their position (energy shift <1 eV) as well (Baun, 1969).
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
2.2.6 Auger Electrons As mentioned in Section 2.2.5, when an excited atom relaxes to the ground state by transition of an electron from an outer to an inner shell the energy difference ∆Ech between the involved shells can be expressed by the emission of an electron of an outer shell with a characteristic energy EAE. The emission is due to the Auger effect (Burhop, 1952; Åberg and Howart, 1982) and the emitted electron is designated as an Auger electron (AE). Its energy EAE is given by EAE = ∆Ech − Eionr
(2.39)
where the term Eionr contains the ionization energy of the AE emitting outer shell and also considers relaxation effects. The shape and the position of the AE peaks are influenced by the type and strength of the chemical bonds (Madden, 1981). The AE peaks have an energy width of a few electronvolts and are superimposed on the low-energy range of the BSE spectrum up to energies of about 2.5 keV (Figure 3–12). The identification of the AE peaks on the BSE background (Bishop, 1984) can be improved by differentiation of the electron energy spectrum. The Auger electrons are generated within the excitation volume (Figure 3–14). Due to their low energies only AE with a short pathway to the specimen surface can escape. However, energy losses caused by inelastic scattering on the pathway to the surface remove AE from the AE peaks. The decrease of the AE peak is proportional to exp(−x/ΛAE), where x denotes the length of the path inside the specimen and ΛAE the mean free path of the AE. Depending on their energy and the atomic number of the specimen the mean free path ΛAE can have values in the range of about 0.4 nm to a few nanometers (Palmberg, 1973; Seah and Dench, 1979). If AEs are inelastically scattered on their path to the surface, then they cannot be identified as an AE in the BSE background. Therefore, only atoms within a depth of about ΛAE can contribute to the AE peaks. Since Auger electrons yield information on element concentrations very near the surface, the specimen must be in an ultrahigh vacuum environment and special sample preparations are required (e.g., ion sputtering in situ, cleavage in situ) to obtain clean surfaces. Because the AE yield of the K-shell 1 − ωK is much larger than ωK for light elements (cf. Figure 3–22) AE spectroscopy is advantageous for elements with atomic number Z = 4(ωK = 4.5 × 10−4) up to Z ∼ 30(ωK = 4.8 × 10−1) (Bauer and Telieps, 1988). Similar to SE, which are also emitted only from a very thin surface layer, the AE can be generated directly by the beam electrons and by BSE within a larger circular area around the beam impact point (cf. Figure 3–14). Like the SE yield, which increases with increasing angle of incidence θ according to δ(θ) = δ0/cos θ [cf. Eq. (2.31)], the integral AE peak intensity is proportional to 1/cos θ (Bishop and Riviere, 1969; Kirschner, 1976; Reimer, 1985). Recent developments in scanning Auger microscopy and AE spectroscopy are described by Jacka (2001).
181
182
R. Reichelt
2.2.7 Others The incident electron beam bombards the specimen with electrons thereby introducing a negative electric charge. A certain amount of negative electric charge is leaving the specimen as secondary (ISE), backscattered (IBSE) and Auger electrons (IAE). To avoid an accumulation of charges a specimen current Isp must flow from the specimen to the ground. The conservation equation for the electric charge is Ip = ISE + IBSE + IAE + Isp
(2.40)
where Ip is the probe current. The specimen current changes the sign when ISE + IBSE + IAE > Ip. Because ISE + IBSE >> IAE this means basically that δ + η > 1 (cf. Figure 3–16). Isp depends on the angle of beam incidence θ and the electron energy E0 as expected from δ(θ, E0) and η(θ, E0) (Reimer, 1985). The resolution of specimen current images is comparable to that of BSE images. One advantage of the specimen current mode is that the contrast is independent on the detector position. A critical review of this mode was published by Newbury (1976). The electron–specimen interaction also generates acoustic waves. The frequencies of these waves depend on the imaging conditions of the SEM and the specimen studied. They cover a range from low sound up to very high ultrasound frequencies. The electron acoustic mode, usually denoted as scanning electron acoustic microscopy (SEAM), was introduced by Brandis and Rosencwaig (1980) and Cargill (1980). SEAM uses a periodic beam modulation or short electron beam pulses that allow for analysis of the SEAM frequency response (Balk and Kultscher, 1984; Balk, 1986; Kultscher and Balk, 1986). The SEAM was reviewed by Balk (1989) and applications of this method in semiconductor research (Balk, 1989) and for the investigation of magnetic structures were shown (Balk et al., 1984). 2.3 Contrast Formation and Resolution Since the image formation is due to the image signal fluctuation ∆S from one point to another point, the contrast C is designated as in television to be C = (S − Sav)/S = ∆S/S
(2.41)
Sav is the average value of the signal and S represents the signal of the considered point (S > Sav, i.e., C is always positive). The signal fluctuation may be caused by local differences in the specimen topography, composition, lattice orientation, surface potential, magnetic or electric domains, and electrical conductivity. The minimum contrast is obtained if S = Sav, whereas the maximum contrast is obtained for Ssv = 0. This is the case, e.g., when the signal S from a feature is surrounded by a background with Sav = 0. The contrast will be visible if C exceeds the threshold value of about 5 × 10−2. According to the point-resolution criterion two image points separated by some horizontal distance (i.e., within the x–y plane perpendicular to the optical axis) are resolved when the minimum intensity
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
between them is 75% or less of the maximum intensity. The point resolution therefore corresponds to the minimum distance of two object points, those superimposed image intensity distributions drop to 75% of their maximum intensity between them. Due to the inherent noise of each signal of the SEM characterized by its signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) the drop to 75% of the maximum intensity will not be reliably defined at the minimum distance. Consequently, at low SNR two image points can be resolved only if their distance is larger than the minimum distance reliably defined for noiseless signals. As opposed to the light or transmission electron microscope the resolution of the SEM cannot be defined by Rayleigh’s criterion. The resolution obtained in the SEM image depends in a complex manner on the electron beam diameter, the electron energy, the electron– specimen interaction, the selected signal, the detection, as well as the electronic amplification and electronic processing. An object “point” corresponds to the size of a small local excitation volume (cf. Figures 3–13 and 3–14) designated as the spatial detection limit from which a sufficient signal can be obtained. Obviously, the point resolution cannot be less than the spatial detection limit. It becomes clear from Figure 3–14 that the spatial resolution of an SEM is different for each signal since the size of the signal emitting volume as well as the signal intensity depends on the type of signal selected. The important “quality parameters” such as spatial resolution, astigmatism, and SNR of SEM images, as well as drift and other instabilities that occur during imaging, can be determined most reliably and objectively by Fourier analysis of the recorded micrographs (Frank et al., 1970; Reimer, 1985). Recently, a program SMART (Scanning Microscope Analysis and Resolution Testing) became freely available, which allows the SEM resolution and the imaging performance to be measured in an automated manner (Joy, 2002). It should be mentioned in the context of resolution that the ultimate resolution of an SEM specified by the manufacturers is determined by imaging a test sample (gold or gold–palladium-coated substrate with a low atomic number). However, such samples are quite atypical compared to those usually investigated, thus the resolution determined in this way is not properly representative of the routine performance of the SEM. At present, conventional SEMs using a heated tungsten or lanthanum hexaboride emitter as the electron source have a specified resolution in the range of 3–5 nm at an acceleration voltage of 30 kV. 2.3.1 Topographic Contrast Presumably the SEM is most frequently used to visualize the topography of three-dimensional objects. The specimen topography gives rise to a marked topographic contrast obtained in secondary and backscattered images. This contrast has a complex origin and is formed in SE images by the following mechanisms: 1. Dependence of the SE yield δ on the angle of incidence θ of the electron beam at the local surface element [cf. Eq. (2.31)]. The tilt angle of the local surface elements is given by the topography of the sample.
183
184
R. Reichelt
2. Dependence of the detected signal on the angular orientation of the local surface element related to the ET detector (see Section 2.1.3). SE generated “behind” local elevations, in holes, in fissures, or in cavities reach the ET detector incomplete. This causes a more or less pronounced shadow contrast (cf. Figure 3–7a). 3. Increase of the SE signal when diffusely scattered electrons pass through an increased surface area. This is the case at edges or at protruding surface features, which are smaller than the excitation volume. Electron diffusion leads to overbrightening of edges and small surface protrusions in the micrograph and is known as an edge effect. 4. Charging artifacts with objects of low electric conductivity. Contributions (1) to (3) are illustrated by SE micrographs of different specimens shown in Figures 3–23a and 3–24a as well as schematically by profiles of the topography and the related SE signals in Figure 3–25. In these figures the direction to the ET detector is indicated. The ball in Figure 3–23a shows a contrast, which is mainly due to the varying angle θ of beam incidence across the ball [cf. (1) above] and the angular orientation of the local surface elements related to the ETD [cf. (2) above]. The collection efficiency of the ETD is significantly higher for surface elements facing the detector than for those on the back (shadow region). Whereas the intensity of emitted secondary electrons of the ball reveals radial symmetry, the effect of detection geometry causes the nonradial symmetric image intensity distribution of the ball (cf. Figure 3–25a–c). The rim of the ball is bright in the SE image because of the enhanced SE emission due to an incidence angle θ ≈ 90° and the effect of diffusely scattered electrons passing through an increased surface area [cf. (3) above]. The radius of the ball is larger than the electron range R (cf. Figure 3–14) therefore the latter effect occurs just near the rim of the ball. If the mean radius of ball-like particles becomes comparable or smaller than the electron range, diffusely scattered electrons generate more SE over the whole particle surface, thus the SE emission typically is distinctly enhanced (small particles are marked by small arrowheads in Figures 3–23a and 3–24a). If the shadow contrast is visible in the image and the direction toward the ETD is known then elevations and depressions clearly can be readily identified (cf. Figure 3–23a). Another way to distinguish elevations and depressions is to record and to analyze SE stereopairs. The SE micrograph of large crystal-like particles (Figure 3–24a) basically shows the same contrast mechanisms as discussed above but with a more complex structured sample than the ball. The individual flat surface planes of the crystal-like particles occur with almost constant brightness because of the constant angle of beam incidence and the constant detection geometry (provided that there is no shadow effect from other large particles). Some surface planes possess fissures of different size, which typically appear rather dark because just a minor fraction of the generated SE can escape from inside the fissures. In such cases SE can be extracted either by a positively biased grid in front of the specimen (Hindermann and Davis, 1974) or by a superimposed magnetic field in which the SE follow spiral trajectories around the
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
185
Figure 3–23. Secondary (a) and backscattered electron micro graphs (b–d) of a steel ball recorded at 30 kV and normal beam incidence. The arrow in (a) indicates the direction of the laterally located ET detector. The BSE micrographs shown in (c and d) were acquired using a four-quadrant semiconductor detector mounted below the objective pole piece, which records BSE over a large solid angle. The steel ball is mounted on carbon (marked by C), which is supported by aluminum (marked by Al). The small arrowheads in (a) indicate small particles with enhanced SE emission (bright blobs in the SE image). Elevations (E) and depressions (D) are also marked by small arrowheads.
186
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–24. Secondary (a) and backscattered electron micrographs (b and c) of 10-nm gold-coated crystal-like tartar (tartar contains mostly potassium–hydrogen–tartrate and calcium–tartrate) recorded at 30 kV and normal beam incidence. The arrow in (a) indicates the direction of the laterally located ET detector. The BSE micrograph shown in (c) was acquired using a four-quadrant semiconductor detector mounted below the objective pole piece, which records BSE over a large solid angle. The small arrowheads in (a) indicate small particles with enhanced SE emission (bright blobs in the SE image).
(a)
e-
ETD
nSE
(b)
0
SSE
(c)
SBSE
0 (d)
0
Figure 3–25. Schematic specimen surface profile of an assumed topography having elementally shaped elevations and a depression (a). Those elemental shapes are present in the samples shown in Figures 3–23 and 3–24. The size of the excitation volume of the electron beam is drawn in relation to the local topographic structures. The amount nSE of locally emitted SE is shown qualitatively in (b) and the corresponding SE signal SSE in (c). The BSE signal SBSE collected by the negatively biased ET detector is schematically presented by the graph in (d). ETD, Everhart–Thornley detector.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
lines of magnetic flux until they reach the collecting field of the ETD (Lukianov et al., 1972). It should be mentioned that the laterally located ETD also register those BSE, which are within the small solid angle of collection defined by the scintillator area and the specimen–scintillator distance. The BSE contribute in the order of 10–20% to the SE signal (Reimer, 1985) and are the same as those collected by the negatively biased ET detector. Furthermore, BSE that are not intercepted by the detector strike the pole piece of the objective lens and the walls of the specimen chamber. These stray BSE generate so-called SE3 emitted from the interior surfaces of the specimen chamber. The SE3 carry BSE information and form a significant fraction of the SE signal for specimens with an intermediate and high atomic number (Peters, 1984). The contrast in BSE images is formed by the following mechanisms: 1. Dependence of the BSE coefficient η on the angle of incidence θ of the electron beam at the local surface element [cf. Eq. (2.34)]. 2. Dependence of the detected signal on the angular orientation of the local surface element related to the BSE detector (see Section 2.1.3). BSE emitted “behind” local elevations, in holes, or in cavities, which do not reach the BSE detector on nearly straight trajectories, are not acquired. This causes a pronounced shadow contrast (cf. Figure 3–7b). 3. Increase of the BSE signal when diffusely scattered electrons pass through an increased surface area. This is the case at edges or at protruding surface features, which are smaller than the excitation volume. The BSE leave the specimen on almost straight trajectories and only those within the solid angle of collection of the BSE detector can be recorded. Thus, dedicated BSE detectors have a large solid angle of collection to record a significant fraction of the BSE and to generate a signal with a sufficient SNR. The larger the solid angle of collection the less pronounced the shadow effects. Contributions (1) to (3) mentioned above are illustrated by BSE micrographs from two specimens used for SE imaging and are shown in Figures 3–23b and c and 3–24b and c as well as schematically by profiles of the topography and the related BSE signals in Figure 3–25. Two different types of BSE images are shown: the highly directional image recorded with the negatively biased ETD (Figures 3–23b and 3– 24b) and the “top-view” image recorded with the four-quadrant semiconductor detector mounted below the objective pole piece (Figures 3–23c and 3–24c). The ball in Figure 3–23b shows a contrast, which is mainly due to the varying angle θ of beam incidence across the ball [cf. (1) above] and the angular position of the local surface elements related to the negatively biased ETD [cf. (2) above]. A pronounced sharp shadow occurs at the back of the ball and behind the ball (shadowed oblong area of the support). Whereas the intensity of the BSE of the ball reveals radial symmetry, the effect of detection geometry causes the nonradial symmetric image intensity distribution of the ball (cf. Figure 3–25a and d). The fade contour of the ball at its back is due
187
188
R. Reichelt
to BSE redirected toward the negatively biased ETD by scattering on some interior surfaces of the specimen chamber. The pronounced directional shadow contrast in the image allows for unambiguous identification of elevations and depressions (cf. Figure 3–23b). Moreover, if the detection geometry of the BSE is known, the length of the shadow can be used in some cases to obtain a rough estimate of the height of elevations or depth of depressions. The BSE micrograph of the ball recorded with the four-quadrant semiconductor detector (Figure 3–23c) shows an almost radial symmetric image intensity distribution. It is obvious that the increase of the BSE coefficient η with the increasing angle of incidence θ (see Figure 3–18) toward the rim of the ball is superimposed by the stronger counteracting effect of the directed asymmetric distribution, for a large θ reflectionlike angular distribution of BSE for nonnormal beam incidence (cf. Section 2.2.2). The shadow-like hem along the contour of the elevations reflects the fact that BSE emitted from the lower surrounding areas toward elevations can be absorbed or redirected; thus those BSE do not reach the BSE detector. In case of depressions there is also a shadow-like hem but it is located inside the contour of the depression. A comparison of the different types of BSE images in Figure 3–23b and c clearly shows that the topography of the sample is pronounced in Figure 3–23b while— as we shall see later—the atomic number contrast is pronounced in Figure 3–23c. The BSE micrographs of large crystal-like particles (Figure 3–24b and c) basically show the same contrast mechanisms as discussed previously [no orientation anisotropy of the electron backscattering and SE emission (Reimer et al., 1971; Seiler and Kuhnle, 1970) is involved]. Figure 3–24b recorded with the negatively biased ETD shows large shadowed regions (containing almost no information) and some highlighted individual flat surface planes of the crystal-like particles that occur with almost constant brightness because of the constant angle of beam incidence of the constant detection geometry. Figure 3–24b demonstrates that the detection geometry used for recording was not optimum. The micrograph obtained with the four-quadrant semiconductor detector is shown in Figure 3–24c, which depicts exactly the same area as Figure 3–24b. Due to the large solid angle of collection of this BSE detector the effects mentioned above in (1) and (2) do generate just small differences in the image intensity of differently oriented surface planes of the crystal-like particles. The effect of shadowing is not substantial in that micrograph. The increase of the BSE signal at edges, at surface steps, and small protruding particles [cf. (3) above] located on the flat surface planes due to enhanced BSE emission is significant. The fissures on some surface planes of the crystal-like particles (cf. Figure 3–24a) occur in the BSE micrograph also as rather dark features because just a minor fraction of the BSE can escape from inside the fissures. The SEM micrographs are closely analogous to viewing a macroscopic specimen by eye. In the light optical analogy the specimen is illuminated with light from the side of the detector and viewed from the position of the electron beam (see, e.g., Reimer et al., 1984). When
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
a rather diffuse illumination is used then all surface elements are illuminated but those directed to the light source are highlighted. This corresponds to the situation for the positively biased ETD. The light optical analogy shows a pronounced shadow contrast if a directional light source illuminates the specimen surface from a suitable direction. This situation closely resembles BSE images recorded with a positively biased ETD. The strong light optical analogy very likely explains the fact that SEM micrographs of objects with a distinct topography can be readily interpreted even without extensive knowledge of the physics “behind” the imaging process. As briefly mentioned in Section 2.1.3.2, the topographic and the material contrast can be pronounced or suppressed, respectively, by a combination of the signals of two oppositely placed detectors, A and B. Two BSE semiconductor detectors were first used by Kimoto et al. (1966) and they showed that the sum A + B results in material and the difference A − B in topographic contrast. Volbert and Reimer (1980) used a BSE/SE converter system and two opposite ET detectors for that kind of contrast separation in the SEM. The four-quadrant semiconductor detector used for recording Figures 3–23c and 3–24c allows for signal mixing of the four signals acquired simultaneously. Figures 3–23c and 3–24c represent the sum of the four signals (SQ1, . . . , SQ4), thus both micrographs show a pronounced material contrast. By addition of the signals of two adjacent quadrants at a time (i.e., SQ1 + SQ2 = A; SQ3 + SQ4 = B) the effect of two semiannular detectors A and B is obtained. The difference image A − B shows a pronounced topographic contrast (Figure 3–23d). The directionality in Figure 3–23d can be varied readily by using a different combination of the individual signals of the quadrants, e.g., A = SQ2 + SQ3 and B = SQ1 + SQ4. Difference SE and BSE images recorded at exactly defined detection geometry allow for the reconstruction of the surface topography (Lebiedzik, 1979; Reimer, 1984a; Kaczmarek, 1997; Kaczmarek and Domaradzki, 2002; see also Sections 2.1.3.2 and 2.1.5.2). However, special care is required for the reconstruction of the surface topography using BSE images because of artifacts in the reconstructed image (Reimer, 1984a). To demonstrate the effect of directionality for four different detection Figure 3–26 shows four individual BSE micrographs each recorded with another quadrant of the semiconductor detector. The individual BSE images contain superimposed topographic and compositional contrast components. 2.3.2 Material Contrast The material or compositional contrast arises from local differences in chemical composition of the object investigated. As shown in Figure 3–17, the SE yield δ increases weakly with increasing atomic number but the increase is significantly less than that of the BSE coefficient η. Experimental values of δ (see, e.g., the data collection by Joy 2001) scatter strongly around a mean curve. The increase of δ(Z) with Z is mainly due to SE [cf. Eq. (2.30)] generated by emitted BSE near the specimen surface (SE2). At electron energies larger than 5 keV the SE images usually show the same compositional contrast as the
189
190
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–26. BSE micrographs of a steel ball on carbon (cf. Figure 3–23) each recorded with another individual quadrant of the four-quadrant semiconductor detector. (a) (−X)-quadrant, (b) (+Y)-quadrant, (c) (−Y)-quadrant, (d) (+X)-quadrant. The micrographs were recorded at 30 kV and normal beam incidence. The angular position of the four-quadrant semiconductor detector is rotated clockwise against the x–y coordinates of the images by 34°. Shadows of the surface step of the feature at the bottom left of each image help to identify the position of the active quadrant visually.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
Table 3–4. Compositional contrast calculated according to Eq. (2.33) for normal beam incidence q = 0 for the elements C, A1, and Fe. a Element 1 (Z) Aluminum (13)
Element 2 (Z) Carbon (6)
h1 0.1530
h2 0.0641
C = (h1 - h2 )/h2 0.581
Iron (26)
Carbon (6)
0.2794
0.0641
0.771
Iron (26)
Aluminum (13)
0.2794
0.1530
0.452
a
Compare Figures 3–23b and c and 3–26. E0 = 30 keV.
corresponding BSE image. This situation is illustrated in Figure 3–23a– c where at normal beam incidence carbon (Z = 6) is darker than aluminum (Z = 13) in both the SE and BSE image. Table 3–4 gives some numerical values for the compositional contrast for carbon, aluminum, and iron calculated with the related BSE coefficients for normal beam incidence, which qualitatively agrees with the contrasts obtained in Figure 3–23c. 2.3.3 Other Contrasts 2.3.3.1 Voltage Contrast The secondary electron image intensity varies if the potential of the specimen is positively or negatively biased with respect to the ground. In principle, a positively biased surface area shows decreased image intensity because low-energy SE are attracted back to the specimen by the electric field. Conversely, a negatively biased surface area shows enhanced image intensity because all SE are repulsed from the specimen. This voltage-dependent variation in contrast is designated as voltage contrast and dates back to the late 1950s (Rappaport, 1954; Oatley and Everhart, 1957; Everhart et al., 1959). Strictly speaking all emitted electrons are influenced to some extent by the potential of the sample, but only the SE and, in principle, the Auger electrons can be used for voltage contrast studies (Werner et al., 1998). The use of Auger electrons is more difficult than that of SE because of the very low yield of AE and the ultrahigh vacuum requirements of AE analysis. The voltage contrast depends on the energy of the beam electrons and on the properties of the specimen, being most pronounced in the low electron energy region where the SE yield is highest (cf. Figure 3– 12). Biasing the specimen positively or negatively by a few volts not only affects the amount of emitted SE but also their trajectories. This is caused by the fact that the majority of the SE have energies of a few electron volts in contrast to BSE and Auger electrons. The effect of specimen voltage on the SE trajectories is rather complex because it depends on the SE detection geometry, the sample position in the specimen chamber, the properties of the sample, and the operation conditions of the SEM. However, voltage contrast is a valuable tool for the investigation of a wide range of simple faults in microelectronic devices or studies of the potential distribution at grain boundaries obtained on the cross section of varistors at applied low DV voltage and their breakdown behavior at elevated voltage (Edelmann and Wetzig, 1995). The voltage contrast is also used to characterize the surface charge distribution of ferroelectrics (Uchikawa and Ikeda, 1981;
191
192
R. Reichelt
Hesse and Meyer, 1982; Roshchupkin and Brunel, 1993) and piezoelectrics (Bahadur and Parshad, 1980). Voltage contrast measurements can also be performed in a dynamic mode on semiconductor devices by pulsing the electron beam [called electron stroboscopy (Spivak, 1966)] synchronously with the device signal as shown by Plows and Nixon (1968). This dynamic mode allows for quantitative voltage contrast measurements on semiconductor devices at high-frequency operation conditions known as electron beam testing widely used by the electronics industry for the development, fault diagnosis, and debugging of innovative integrated circuits. High-frequency electron stroboscopy requires high-speed electrostatic beam blanking systems with subnanosecond time resolution. For very high-frequency electron stroboscopy in the gigahertz range a special transverse-longitudinal combination gate system (Hosokawa et al., 1978) or microwave structure-based beam blanking techniques have been employed (Fujioka and Ura, 1981). A comprehensive treatment of the fundamentals of voltage contrast and stroboscopy has been published by Davidson (1989) and the state of the art of voltage contrast has been review by Girard (1991). Furthermore, improvements of voltage contrast detectors as well as of detection strategies are discussed in detail by Dubbeldam (1991). Voltage contrast is now of a mature age, but the extension to future microelectronics also presupposes an extension in the domain of in situ testing methods and techniques. 2.3.3.2 Electron Beam-Induced Current The electron beam generates a variety of signals emitted from the specimen as shown in Figures 3–2 and 3–14. In semiconductors the primary electrons generate electron hole pairs or minority carriers within the excitation volume. The mean number of electron hole pairs is given by E0/Eexm [cf. Eq. (2.14)], where Eexm is the mean energy per electron hole pair forming event. For example, Eexm amounts to 3.6 eV for Si and 2.84 eV for Ge, i.e., one 10-keV electron generates on average approximately 2.7 × 103 electron hole pairs in Si and 3.5 × 103 in Ge (McKenzie and Bromely, 1959). The charge collection (CC) signal is detected between two electric contacts; one of these contacts collects the electrons and the other one collects the holes. If electromotive forces caused by electron voltaic effects are generated by the beam electrons in the specimen then a charge collection current ICC designated as an electron beam-induced current (EBIC) flows through the ohmic contacts. If no electron voltaic effects occur, the beam electrons cause local β-conductivity, where the separation of charge carriers results in an electron beam-induced voltage (EBIV). The most important type of signal of the two charge-collecting modes is EBIC. A detailed treatment of the basic physical mechanisms and applications of the charge collection mode is given by Holt (1974, 1989), Deamy (1982), Reimer (1985), Shea et al. (1978), Alexander (1994), and Yakimov (2002). EBIC can be observed in SEM simply by connecting a high-gain large bandwidth amplifier across the specimen using the amplified EBIC signal as a video signal. The input impedance of the amplifier must be
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
very low relative to that of the specimen to measure the true EBIC. For usual electron probe currents of some nanoamperes the charge collection currents are in the order of microamperes since for many materials the mean energy per electron hole pair is between approximately 1 and 13 eV (Holt, 1989). In contrast to EBIC, for the measurement of the true EBIV an amplifier with a very high input resistance is necessary. The resolution obtained in the charge-collecting modes depends on the size of the excitation volume within the specimen, which readily can be extracted from Monte Carlo simulation data (see Section 2.2). For the CC mode, a depth and a lateral resolution have to be defined. The depth-dose function, which represents the energy loss per unit depth in the electron beam direction, determines the depth resolution. The lateral-dose function, which represents the energy loss per unit distance perpendicular to the electron beam direction, determines the lateral resolution. There are also empirical (Grün, 1957) and semiempirical expressions (Everhart and Hoff, 1971) as well as several analytical models (Bishop, 1974; Leamy, 1982) for the depth-dose and for the lateral-dose function as well (Bishop, 1974; Leamy, 1982). Electron beam chopping and time-resolved EBIC can enhance the accuracy of measurements in several cases, e.g., for the estimation of the depth of p–n junction parallel to the surface (Georges et al., 1982) or allows for quantitative analysis of electrical properties of defects in semiconductors (Sekiguchi and Sumino, 1995) and interesting applications for the failure analysis of VLSI circuits (Chan et al., 2000). 2.3.3.3 Crystal Orientation Contrast As previously mentioned, the backscattering coefficient η of a single crystal varies with the direction of the incident beam electrons related to the crystallographic orientation (cf. Section 2.2). This effect is caused by the variation of the atomic density, which the incident electrons encounter when penetrating into the crystal. In certain crystallographic directions the beam electrons penetrate more deeply. Those directions represent “channels” for the incident electrons. Changing the direction of the incident electrons relative to the crystallographic orientation causes the so-called crystal orientation or channeling contrast of the BSE image, which amounts to a maximum of approximately 5%. Crystal orientation contrast arises if a large single crystal is imaged at very low magnification using a small electron probe aperture of about 1 mrad. Scanning at low magnification both moves the electron probe and changes the angle of incidence across the field, thereby generating an electron channeling pattern (ECP). At higher magnification the angle of beam incidence varies just insignificantly across the small scanned field and channeling contrast is obtained in polycrystalline samples from small grains with different crystal orientations (Figure 3–27). The information depth of the crystal orientation contrast is in the order of a few nanometers only (Reimer, 1985) and therefore the contrast is very sensitive to distortions of the crystal at the surface. The channeling contrast reaches the maximum at energies between 10 and 20 keV (Reimer et al., 1971; Drescher et al., 1974). An orientation anisotropy also occurs for the secondary yield (Reimer et al., 1971), which gives rise to an SE orientation contrast.
193
194
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–27. Cross section of a polycrystalline sample having grains with different crystal lattice orientation relative to the electron beam.
2.3.3.4 Magnetic Contrasts Basically, two different types of magnetic contrast can arise from the interaction of the emitted electrons with the magnetic field of small domains of the specimen. Type-1 Magnetic Contrast. Secondary electrons are deflected after emission by an external magnetic field, thus generating a magnetic contrast (Dorsey, 1969). External magnetic fields can exist in natural or synthetic engineered ferromagnetic materials such as magnetic tape, magnetic cards, and computer disks. The fringe fields near the surface are highly inhomogeneous and the SE trajectories are affected by the Lorentz force, which is proportional to v × B where v is the velocity vector of the SE and B the magnetic field. The most probable velocity corresponds to the electron energy of a few electronvolts (see Section 2.2.1). The acting Lorentz force deflects the trajectories of the SE and the resulting effect can be approximated to a tilt of Lambert’s angular SE emission characteristics of the SE (see Section 2.2.1; Reimer, 1985). Figure 3–28 illustrates this effect for two domains in the specimen having oppositely directed external magnetic fields. To observe type-1 magnetic contrast in case of weak magnetic fields an ETD with a high angular sensitivity, a two-detector system (Dorsey, 1969; Wardly, 1971) or digital image processing (Szmaja, 2000, 2002) has been employed. For the type-1 magnetic contrast low beam electron energies are favorable because of the enhanced SE yield and therefore an increased signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). The actual problems related to the complicated mechanism of type-I magnetic contrast and its relatively low resolution were discussed by Szmaja (2002). Type-2 Magnetic Contrast. This type of contrast arises from the deflection of backscattered electrons by the internal magnetic field within the specimen (Philibert and Tixier, 1969; Fathers et al., 1973). Depending on the direction of the magnetic field inside the sample, the BSE are bent toward or away from the surface between consecutive scattering events, i.e., the BSE coefficient is increased in domains where trajectories are bent toward the surface and decrease when bending the BSE trajectories in an opposite direction. To observe a sufficient type-2 magnetic contrast the beam electrons need an energy of at least 30 keV and a relatively high beam current. The type-2 contrast is maximized if the
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
195
ETD
Fm
Fm
external magnetic field
Specimen
Figure 3–28. Scheme of type-1 magnetic contrast formation between two domains having oppositely directed external magnetic fields. The dashed lines indicate the SE trajectories for the most probable SE energy to the positively biased Everhart–Thornley detector (ETD) without magnetic field and the solid lines the trajectories with magnetic fields. The effect of the magnetic force Fm on the SE tilts the trajectories by a small angle toward or away from the ETD, respectively.
specimen is tilted by approximately 40–60°, however, the maximum contrast also depends on the takeoff angle of the BSE detector (Wells, 1978; Yamamoto et al., 1976). The BSE signal modulation due to magnetic fields inside the specimen is typically less than 1% of the collected current and unwanted topographic contrasts can be reduced in comparison with this magnetic contrast by a lock-in technique (Wells, 1979). 2.4 Specimen Preparation The specimen preparation procedures required for optimum results of scanning electron microscopic investigations are of crucial importance. The dedicated preparation of the specimen under study is an essential prerequisite for the reliability of the experimental data obtained and has a significance comparable to the performance of the SEM used for the investigation. Unfortunately, the importance of specimen preparation is often underestimated. In principle, the preparation required depends significantly on the properties of the specimen to be investigated as well as on the type of SEM study, i.e., whether imaging of the surface or of cross sections of the sample (cf. Sections 2.2, 2.3, and 3–6), crystallographic characterization by electron diffraction techniques (cf. Section 7), or X-ray microanalytical investigations (cf. Section 6) are considered. Bearing in mind the variety of specimens having unknown properties on the one hand and the multitude of possible investigation techniques on the other hand, it is obvious that the choice of the most promising preparation procedures can be a rather complex matter. Although the preparation techniques are described in a variety of books (e.g., Reimer, 1967; Hayat, 1974–1976, 1978; Revel et al., 1983; Polak
196
R. Reichelt
and Varndell, 1984; Müller, 1985; Steinbrecht and Zierold, 1987; Albrecht and Ornberg, 1988; Edelmann and Roomans, 1990; Grasenick et al., 1991; Echlin, 1992; Malecki and Romans, 1996), collections of methods (e.g., Schimmel and Vogell, 1970; Robards and Wilson, 1993) with updates, and publications, the successful preparation still also depends in many cases on experience and skillful hands. It is beyond the scope of this chapter to discuss the wide field of preparation techniques. Therefore, a brief rather general outline of specimen preparation with reference to specific literature will be given. Figure 3–29 schematically outlines some important preparation procedures used for inorganic and organic materials. As a general rule, a successful investigation by SEM requires specimens, which have clean surfaces, sufficient electrical conductivity, are not wet or oily, and possess a certain radiation stability, to resist electron irradiation during imaging. An exception of this rule is allowed only for SEMs working at ambient pressure (say at low vacuum; see Section 4), which permits direct imaging of dirty, wet, or oily samples, although radiation damage occurs with radiation-sensitive specimens. The goal of an ideal prepa-
Organic Material (without water)
Inorganic Material Conductive
Organic Material (with water)
Nonconduct.
Nonconduct.
Surface treatment
Nonconduct.
Surface treatment Rapid freezing
Chemical Fixation
Water withdrawal / substitut. AD
Ultramicrotomy
FIB / IBSC
Ultramicrotomy
Cryo ultramicrotomy
CPD FD
Ultramicrotomy
Embedd.
Cryo ultramicrotomy
Freeze etching Evaporation / Sputtering
Evaporation / Sputtering SEM
SEM / Cryo-SEM
SEM
SEM / Cryo-SEM
Evaporation / Sputtering SEM
SEM / Cryo-SEM
Figure 3–29. Schematic drawing of important preparation procedures for SEM used for inorganic and organic materials with and without water. AD, air drying; CPD, critical point drying; FD, freeze drying; FIB, focused ion beam; IBSC, ion beam slope cutting.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
ration consists in making specimens accessible for high vacuum SEM studies without changing the relevant properties under investigation. Many inorganic samples with sufficient electrical conductivity, such as metals, alloys, or semiconductors, can be imaged directly with little or no specimen preparation (Figure 3–29). This is one very useful feature of scanning electron microscopy. In some cases a surface treatment may be required, e.g., to clean the specimen surface with an appropriate solvent, possibly in an ultrasonic cleaner, and with lowenergy reactive gas plasma for the removal of hydrocarbon contamination (Isabell et al., 1999). The cleanings are suitable to prepare electrically conductive specimens for surface imaging in SEM. In case of nonconductive samples, such as ceramics, minerals, or glass, a conductive coating (e.g., Willison and Rowe, 1980) with a thin metal film (e.g., gold, platinum, tungsten, chromium) or a mixed conductive film (e.g., gold/ palladium, platinum/carbon, platinum/iridium/carbon) is required for good-quality imaging. For X-ray microanalysis carbon coating is preferred because of its minimum effect on the X-ray spectrum. The coating can be performed by evaporation (e.g., Reimer, 1967; Shibata et al., 1984; Hermann et al., 1988; Robards and Wilson, 1993), by diode sputtering (Apkarian and Curtis, 1986), or by planar magnetron sputtering (Nagatani and Saito, 1989; Müller et al., 1990). High-quality conductive thin-film coating for high-resolution SEM (see Section 3) can be performed in an oil-free high vacuum by both evaporation, using e.g., tungsten, tantalum/tungsten, platinum/carbon, or platinum/iridium/ carbon, and rotary shadowing methods (Gross et al., 1985; Hermann et al., 1988; Wepf and Gross, 1990; Wepf et al., 1991) as well as by ion beam and by penning sputtering with, e.g., chromium, tantalum, and niobium (Peters, 1980). For the study of microstructural features (see Section 7) and for microanalytical investigations (see Section 6) a flat surface is required, therefore rough specimen surfaces have to be flattened by careful grinding and subsequent polishing according to standard metallographic methods (Glauert, 1973). To remove mechanical deformations caused by grinding and mechanical polishing, a final treatment with electrochemical polishing or ion beam polishing may be necessary. In case of polycrystalline and heterogeneous material, selective etching by ion bombardment may be used, which generates a surface profile caused by locally different sputtering yields, thus giving rise to topographic contrast of grains and the individual materials (Hauffe, 1971, 1995). Often, specimens need to be characterized and analyzed both above and below the surface, e.g., if the subsurface composition of the material, process diagnosis, failure analysis, in situ testing, or threedimensional reconstruction of the spatial microstructure is required. Flat cross sections through the specimen can be obtained by ultramicrotomy (Reid and Beesley, 1991; Sitte, 1984, 1996; the block face can be used for SEM imaging), ion beam slope cutting (Hauffe, 1990; Hauffe et al., 2002), an FIB technique (Kirk et al., 1988; Madl et al., 1988; Ishitani and Yaguchi, 1996; Shibata, 2004; Giannuzi and Stevie, 2005), or by a combination of an FIB system with a field emission SEM (SEM/FIB),
197
198
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–30. Integrated circuit with two perpendicular vertical cross sections into the interior. FIB sectioning was performed with the CrossBeam® tool from Carl Zeiss NTS. The secondary electron images using the EDT were obtained by the field emission SEM (a) at 3 kV and by the FIB system (b) at 5 kV. Both micrographs reveal the site-specific internal structure of the integrated circuit, although some features occur with different contrast caused by different mechanisms of SE generation by electrons (a) and ions (b) (Courtesy of Carl Zeiss NTS, Oberkochen, Germany.)
which allows the precise positioning of the cross section and, most importantly, realtime high-resolution SEM imaging of the cutting process, which enables, among other things, the examination of the spatial structure (Sudraud et al., 1987; Gnauck et al., 2003a, b; McGuinness, 2003; Holzer et al., 2004; Sennhauser et al., 2004). An example for two perpendicular vertical cross sections into an integrated circuit is shown in Figure 3–30. The combined SEM/FIB additionally can be equipped with analytical techniques such as energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy, wavelength-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy, Auger electron spectroscopy, and secondary ion mass spectrometry allowing for three-dimensional elemental analysis of the interior of the specimen. The other class of samples consists of organic material, which usually has an insufficient electrical conductivity for scanning electron microscopy. Although biological specimens contain water—the water content ranges in human tissues from approximately 4 to 99% (Flindt, 2000)— many other organic materials do not, e.g., numerous polymers. The preparation strategies to be applied to specimens with and without water differ (cf. Figure 3–29), although there are also some similarities between them.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
The surface treatment of organic specimens without water, such as cleaning, grinding, polishing, and etching by dissolution, chemical attack, or ion bombardment, has many similarities to the surface treatment of inorganic materials. A detailed discussion of and the recipes for specific preparation procedures for polymers are given in the chapter “Specimen preparation methods” in the book by Sawyer and Grubb (1996). Analogous to nonconductive inorganic materials, conductive coating with a thin metal film (e.g., gold, platinum, tungsten, chromium) or a mixed conductive film (e.g., gold/palladium, platinum/carbon, platinum/iridium/carbon) is required for good-quality imaging. If the subsurface structure of the material has to be studied, flat cross sections usually are prepared by ultramicrotomy or cryoultramicrotomy, depending on the cutting behavior of the specimen under study. In principle, cutting with ions and imaging and analysis with electrons by using a combined FIB/SEM tool seem possible also with polymers. It was recently shown that ion milling is possible, e.g., with rubber (Milani et al., 2004; cf. also Figure 3–31) and with plastic material (cf. Figure 3–32). As yet, the application of FIB for cutting and milling of organic specimens is rare. Most of the organic specimens that contain water are biological samples. A small fraction of water-containing specimens is nonbiological, e.g., hydrogels. Caused by the high vacuum in the SEM the watercontaining specimens cannot be investigated in the wet state. In principle, three different preparation strategies exist to make wet specimens accessible to SEM investigations: 1. Withdrawal of the water; 2. replacement of the water by some vacuum-resistant material such as resins or freeze substitution (Feder and Sidman, 1958; Hess, 2003) of the ice of the rapidly frozen specimen by some organic solvent; and 3. rapid freezing of the water. Irrespective of the preparation strategy used the native spatial structure of the specimen should be maintained. Air drying, which is the most simple method of drying, is not suitable for drying soft specimens because the surface tension induces remarkable forces during the process of air drying, deforming the specimen irreversibly (Kellenberger and Kistler, 1979; Kellenberger et al., 1982). Figure 3–29 shows different paths, which can be used, even though the degree of structural preservation depends on the preparation procedures applied. The different preparation procedures have been described in detail (Kellenberger and Kistler, 1979; Robards and Sleytr, 1985; Steinbrecht and Zierold, 1987; Dykstra, 1992; Echlin, 1992; Kellenberger et al., 1992; Robards and Wilson, 1993). Among the different preparation methods rapid freezing is the method of choice for preparing biological specimens in a defined physiological state (Echlin, 1992). In case of chemical fixation, which may create artifacts (Kellenberger et al., 1992), the water of the sample has to be withdrawn or replaced afterward. If the surface structure of the specimen has to be studied, then the specimen surface has to be coated with a thin conductive film prior to SEM investigation. If the interior of the specimen has to be studied, the sample has to be
199
200
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–31. Secondary electron micrograph (“though-the-lens” detection) of a site-specific FIB cross-sectioned abrasive wear particle of a tyre supported onto carbon. The FIB sectioning and imaging at 5 kV was performed with the CrossBeam® tool combining a focused ion beam system with a field emission SEM (cf. Gnauck et al., 2003a). The cross section reveals the interior features of the rubber particle. (Courtesy of Carl Zeiss NTS, Oberkochen, Germany.)
opened by sectioning with the ultramicrotome or possibly FIB and subsequently coated. In case of physical fixation, i.e., rapid freezing, the specimen has to be opened by freeze fracturing (for review see Severs and Shotton, 1995; Walther, 2003), cryosectioning, or now possibly by ion milling the frozen-hydrated sample [ion milling in ice is possible (McGuinness, 2003)]. After short partial freeze drying (also called freeze etching), the fracture face or block face have to be properly coated by a conductive film and then can be directly analyzed in the cryo-SEM (Echlin, 1971; Hermann and Müller, 1993; Walther and
Figure 3–32. Secondary electron micrograph of an FIB cross-sectioned color film. The SE image is composed of the signals of two SE detectors, where the “through-the-lens” detection contributes a fraction of 60% and the positively biased ETD a fraction of 40%. The FIB sectioning and imaging at 5 kV were performed with the CrossBeam® tool combining a focused ion beam system with a field emission SEM (cf. Gnauck et al., 2003a). The cross section in the lower half of the micrograph reveals the interior of the film (three color layers corresponding to red, green, and blue and the submicrometer features as well), whereas the upper half of the micrograph shows the porous outer surface of the film. (Courtesy of Carl Zeiss NTS, Oberkochen, Germany.)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
Müller, 1999; Walther, 2003). Another possible path is complete freezedrying and subsequent conductive coating of the sample, which then can be analyzed at room temperature in the SEM. As yet, FIB sample preparation and subsequent FIB or SEM imaging are in early stages of application in the life sciences. Very recently, in situ FIB sectioning was successfully performed with critical-pointdried hepatopancreatic cells (Drobne et al., 2004) and some epithelium cells (Drobne et al., 2005). 2.5 Radiation Damage and Contamination The inelastic electron–specimen interaction inevitably damages the irradiated specimen and can induce contamination at the specimen surface. Once radiation damage, in particular of organic specimens, has been extensively investigated for thin films in transmission electron microscopy, comparatively little is systematically studied for irradiation-sensitive samples in SEM. This may be due to the fact that the interpretation of radiation damage in TEM is easier because of the uniform ionization density through thin specimens. In bulk specimens, however, the ionization density is a function of the depth (for a detailed treatment of the depth dose function see, e.g., Shea, 1984) and a layer below the surface at the maximum ionization density will be damaged faster than others within the electron range R (cf. Figures 3–13 and 3– 14). According to the Bethe stopping power [see Eq. (2.26)], the damage will be proportional to 1/E ln(1.166 E/J). Table 3–5 gives values of the stopping power for carbon and protein for electron energies from 0.1 to 30 keV, which show the increase of the stopping power with decreasing electron energy. It is commonly assumed that the shape of the depth– dose curve is not a function of either the primary electron energy or the material when normalized to the electron range (Shea, 1984). That means that the layer with the maximum ionization density approaches the surface as the electron energy decreases. In organics, the radiation breaks due to the transfer of typically tens of electron volts to an electron at the site of the interaction of many intra- and intermolecular bonds, which generates free radicals (e.g., Bolt and Carroll, 1963; Dole, 1973; Baumeister et al., 1976). Many excited
Table 3–5. Mean ionization potential J [Eqs. (2.27) and (2.28), respectively] and the Bethe stopping power dE/ds [Eq. (2.26)] for carbon and protein at different electron energies.a E (keV) Parameter
0.1
1.0
5.0
10
30
Carbon
J (eV) dE/ds (eV/cm)
56.5 -56.4
92.8 -19.7
98.5 -6.4
99.2 -3.7
100.4 -1.5
Protein
J (eV) dE/ds (eV/cm)
50.6 -43.8
78.0 -14.2
82.0 -4.5
83.0 -2.6
83.0 -1.1
Sample
a
The values listed for dE/ds have to be multiplied by 107. The following values were used for the calculation (Reichelt and Engel, 1984): carbon: Z = 6; A = 12; ρ = 2 g/cm3; protein: mean atomic number = 3.836; A = 7.7; ρ = 1.35 g/cm3.
201
202
R. Reichelt
species will very rapidly recombine in 10−9 to 10−8 s and will reform the original chemical structure dissipating the absorbed energy as heat. Some recombinations will form new structures, breaking chemical bonds and forming others. If the material was initially crystalline, defects will form and gradually it will become amorphous. In addition to these structural changes the generated free radicals will rapidly diffuse to and across the surface or can evaporate, i.e., loss of mass and composition change will occur (e.g., Egerton, 1989, 1999; Egerton et al. 1987; Engel, 1983; Isaacson, 1977, 1979a; Reimer, 1984b; Reichelt et al., 1985). Bubbles may form at high dose rates when volatile products are trapped. Not only the beam electrons damage the organic sample but also fast secondary electrons (ESE > 50 eV) can produce damages outside the directly irradiated specimen area (Siangchaew and Libera, 2000). Furthermore, beam-induced electrostatic charging and heating can also damage organic samples. Conductive coating of the organic specimen, as suggested for inorganic materials by Strane et al. (1988), can keep trapped free radicals as well as reduce beam-induced temperature rise or electrostatic charging (Salih and Cosslett, 1977). Lowering of the temperature of the specimen is a further measure to reduce the sensitivity of an organic specimen to structural damage and mass loss. However, the reduction factor depends considerably on the material of the specimen. The radiation damage mechanisms in semiconductors are different from those described above. As mentioned in Sections 2.1.3.1 and 2.3.3.2, the incident electrons generate electron hole pairs, which will be trapped in the Si2O layer due to their decreased mobility. This can generate space charges, which in turn can affect the electronic properties of the semiconductor. Beam-induced contamination is mass gain, which occurs when hydrocarbon molecules on the specimen surface are polymerized by the beam electrons. The polymerized molecules have a low surface mobility, i.e., the amount of polymerized molecules increases in the surface region where polymerization takes place. There are two main sources for hydrocarbon contamination: (1) gaseous hydrocarbons arising from oil pumps, vacuum grease, and possibly O-rings, and (2) residual hydrocarbons on the specimen. Several countermeasures exist to reduce the contamination to a tolerable level (see, e.g., Fourie, 1979; Wall, 1980; Postek, 1996). The amount of gaseous hydrocarbons is substantially reduced when the SEM is operated with an oil-free pumping system and a so-called cold finger located above the specimen. Further, the contamination rate falls more rapidly as the specimen temperature is lowered, and below −20°C contamination is difficult to measure (Wall, 1980). This is caused by the reduced diffusion of hydrocarbons on the specimen. In some cases, preirradiation of a large surface area with the electron beam is helpful, which immobilizes (polymerizes) hydrocarbons around the field of view to be imaged. Finally, specimens are mostly exposed to the atmosphere before transfer into the specimen chamber. Weakly bound molecules (e.g., hydrocarbons) can be completely eliminated by gently heating the sample in the specimen exchange chamber (low vacuum) to 40–50°C for several minutes by a spot lamp (Isaacson et al., 1979b). A detailed topical review on the
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
203
radiation damage and contamination in electron microscopy is given by Egerton et al. (2004). 2.6 Applications Scanning electron microscopy is an indispensable tool for investigations of a tremendous variety of specimens from very different fields such as materials science, mineralogy, geology, semiconductor research, microelectronics, in-dustry, polymer research, ecology, archeology, art, and life sciences. Although the investigations are not restricted just to imaging of surface structures, the majority of SEM studies apply the imaging modes. As mentioned previously, considerable additional information about the local elemental composition, electronic and magnetic properties, crystal structure, etc. can be acquired when the SEM is combined with supplementary equipment such as electron and X-ray spectrometers to take advantage of the energy spectra of the emitted electrons and X-rays. Table 3–6 surveys the information, which can be obtained from inorganic and organic specimens not containing Table 3–6. SEM applications on specimens from materials science, mineralogy, geology, polymer science, semiconductors, and microelectronics. a Specimen Metals, alloys, and intermetallics
Information At the specimen surface: Topography (three-dimensional); microroughness; cracks; fissures; fractures; grain size and shape; texture; phase identification; localization of magnetic domains; size and shape of small particles; elemental composition; elemental map Inside the specimen: Grain and phase structures; three-dimensional microstructure; cracks; fissures; material inclusions; elemental composition
Ceramics, minerals, glasses
At the specimen surface: Topography (three-dimensional); microroughness; cracks; fissures; fractures; grain size and shape; pores; phase identification; size and shape of small particles; elemental composition Inside the specimen: Grain and phase structures; three-dimensional microstructure; cracks; fissures; material inclusions; pores; elemental composition
Polymers, wood
At the specimen surface: Morphology; topography (three-dimensional); microroughness; cracks; fissures; fractures; pores; size and shape of small fibers and particles; fiber assemblage in woven fabrics; elemental composition Inside the specimen: Cracks; fissures; fractures; pores; composite structure; elemental composition
Semiconductors, integrated circuits, microelectronic devices a
Dislocation studies (with CL); metallization and passivation integrity; quality of wire bonds; electrical performance; design validation; fault diagnosis; testing
State-of-the-art preparation and image analysis techniques are required to take full advantage of the capabilities of SEM.
204
R. Reichelt
water. Further, in situ scanning electron microscopy allows for different specific specimen treatments in the specimen chamber (see, e.g., Wetzig and Schulze, 1995), which serves as a microlaboratory, and the simultaneous observation of the specimen response (cf. Table 3–7). The advancement of nanoscale science and technology demands the manipulation of nanoobjects at the molecular level and ultimately the manufacture of things via a bottom-up approach. Very recently, a four nanoprobe system has been installed inside a field emission SEM, which may be used for gripping, moving, and manipulating nanoobjects, e.g., carbon nanotubes, setting up electric contacts for electronic measurements, tailoring the structure of the nanoobject by cutting, etc. and for making nanostructures (Peng et al., 2004). The SEM in this setup allows for visualization of the four nanoprobes operating inside the specimen chamber as well as the process of formation of microstructures. Less spectacular, but nevertheless important, are applications of scanning electron microscopy to image macroscopic samples in the millimeter range at very low magnification (about 10× to 100×), which cannot be seen clearly by the eye or by the light microscope for some reasons. Two examples from very different fields are shown in Figures 3–33 and 3–34 taking advantage of the large depth of focus as well as distinct topographic and material contrast. Working in the low magnification range, the depth of focus limit in the SEM (see Section 2.1.5.2) can be overcome by recording stacks of through-focus images (as in conventional and confocal optical microscopy), which are digitally postprocessed to generate an all-in-focus image (Boyde, 2004). The application of the technique is advantageous when BSE imaging of spongy specimens is required, as demonstrated with examples from the study of human osteoporotic bone (Boyde, 2004). Table 3–7. In situ treatments in SEM and available information about specimens from materials science. Treatment
Information
Static and dynamic deformation, e.g.,by tension, compression, bending, machining
Kinematic processes during deformation; submicrometer cracks visible only under load; localized deformation centers, e.g., slip bands, crack nucleation; deformationinduced acoustic emission
Laser irradiation, e.g., in pulse mode, Q-switch mode
Phase transformations; structural modifications; crack formation due to thermal shock; diffusion processes; laserinduced surface melting and evaporation processes; vapor deposition on substrates; cumulative effects of multiple laser pulses
Ion beam irradiation
Depth profi le/cross section; grain boundaries; spatial microstructure; internal grain and phase structures
Electrical and magnetic effects
Reversible and irreversible breakdown of voltage barriers; size distribution of magnetic and ferroelectric domains; orientation distribution of magnetic and ferroelectric domains; effects accessible by EBIC, EBIV, and CL
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
205
Figure 3–33. Secondary electron micrograph of the material of white lines, dividing the opposite lanes on roads, used to reflect the light from the headlights of cars. Some of the light-reflecting glass spheres are damaged or snatched off (their original positions can be recognized by sphere-like indentations). For safety reasons protruding sharp-edged particles are embedded in the material (e.g., at the bottom left corner) to generate a high friction between the tire and the white line. The sample is sputter coated with gold. (Micrograph kindly provided by Rudolf Göcke, Institut für Medizinische Physik und Biophysik, Münster, Germany.)
In life sciences, application of SEM mainly for morphological studies is also widespread and started when commercial SEMs became available in the late 1960s (see, e.g., Pfefferkorn and Pfautsch, 1971). However, in life sciences SEM is used less than TEM. Table 3–8 provides a survey of the specimens and information that can be obtained by SEM. Engineered biomaterials and tissues are becoming increasingly important
Figure 3–34. Secondary electron (a) and backscattered electron (b) micrograph of carbonized fossil remains of a fern bot embedded in clay. The sample is coated with a very thin carbon film. The contrast in the SE image is caused by the topography, whereas the BSE image shows a distinct atomic number contrast. The carbonized fossil remains appear dark due to the lower mean atomic number surrounded by bright areas of clay. (Micrographs kindly provided by Rudolf Göcke, Institut für Medizinische Physik and Biophysik, Münster, Germany.)
206
R. Reichelt
Table 3–8. SEM applications on specimens from life sciences. a Specimen Bones, teeth, dentin, cartilage, hairs, fi ngernails, toenails
Information At the specimen surface: Morphology; ultrastructure, pathological alterations of ultrastructure, microstructure, roughness; cracks; fissures; fractures; elemental composition Inside the specimen: Three-dimensional microstructure; cracks; fissures; elemental composition
Biominerals, e.g., gallstone, kidney stone, tartar, calcification
At the specimen surface: Morphology; microstructure, cracks; fissures; fractures; grain size and shape; size and shape of small particles; elemental composition Inside the specimen: Grain size and shape; microstructure; cracks, fissures; material inclusions; cavities; elemental composition
Soft tissues cells, bacteria
At the specimen surface: Morphology; topography (three-dimensional); roughness; ultrastructure; pathological alterations of ultrastructure; size and shape of cells and bacteria; elemental composition Inside the specimen: Ultrastructure; pathological alterations of ultrastructure; elemental composition
Biomaterials, implants, prostheses
Morphology; biocompatibility; biostability; ultrastructure of and degradation mechanisms at the bone–implant interface; mineral apposition; cell and tissue apposition; adsorption behaviors of fibrinogen, albumin, and fresh plasma on implants for the cardiac–vascular systems; fault diagnosis of prostheses; failure analysis after loading tests in simulator; wear of prostheses; surface erosion of prostheses after use
a
State-of-the-art preparation and image analysis techniques are required to take full advantage of the capabilities of SEM.
in biomedical practice and it has become clear that cellular responses to materials depend on structural properties of the material at both the micrometer and nanometer scale. SEM is one of several methods for controlling material properties on both of these scales and thus it is increasingly used to study those materials. Scanning electron microscopy can be used for comparative morphological studies of tissues as demonstrated by the application in cardiovascular surgery to detect endothelial damage caused by skeletonization (Rukosujew et al., 2004). In cardiovascular surgery, the radial artery is increasingly used for myocardial revascularization because of its presumed advantageous long-term patency rates. The vessel can be harvested as a pedicle or skeletonized. The SEM reveals the endothelial morphology (cf. Figure 3–35), and thus allows comparison of the skeletonization technique with pedicle preparation using either an ultrasonic scalpel or scissors.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
207
Investigation of implants is a strongly growing field, where scanning electron microscopy is an indispensable tool. Figure 3–36 shows an example from ophthalmology where a technique for knotting a suture to the haptic of an intraocular lens is used for its firm fixation onto the sclera to avoid postoperative dislocation. Because of the large depth of focus and the distinct topographic contrast in the secondary electron micrograph, which conveys a pseudo three-dimensional and detailed view, the SEM allows checking as to the extent to which the haptic and suture can be damaged by knotting. Moreover, the quality of knots can be studied. Microtechnology and “microelectromechanical systems” (MEMS) are additional fields in which SEM is used as a tool for monitoring processes, detecting defects, or measuring sizes and distances, e.g., in micromachines and micromechanical or micromachining processes (see, e.g., Ishikawa et al., 1993; Aoyagi, 2002; Hernandez-Lopez et al., 2003; Khamsehpour and Davies, 2004). The acquisition of quantitative data about the third dimension (stereo, 3D) of surfaces and interior specimen structures was previously mentioned (see Sections 2.14, 2.15, and 2.4). In general, this requires digital image analysis, specific instrumentation for the SEM (e.g., specimen stage, detectors), and special specimen preparation (e.g., ultramicrotome, IBSC, FIB). Recently, interesting applications of 3D morphometry for accurate dimensional and angular measurements of microstructures (Minnich et al., 1999, 2000) and of volumetric measurements (Chan et al., 2004) were shown using stereopaired images and digital image analysis.
Figure 3–35. Secondary electron micrograph of the cross-sectioned radial artery at low magnification (a) and of the endothelial cells at medium magnification (b). The vessel was critical point dried and sputter coated with gold.
208
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–36. Secondary electron micrographs of a poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) intraocular lens (IOL) with knots from 10-0 polypropylene (Prolene) on the haptic recorded at different magnifications. (a) Whole IOL with the haptic and the fixated sutures; (b–e) Detailed views to the haptic and knots, respectively, showing some minor damage. The IOL is sputter coated with gold and imaged at 25 kV.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
3 Field Emission Scanning Electron Microscopy The diameter of the electron beam at the specimen surface sets a fundamental lower limit to the signal localization and, therefore, also to the resolution, which can potentially be obtained. As discussed in Section 2.2 and shown in Figures 3–13 and 3–14, the SE and BSE are emitted from a surface area, which commonly is much larger than the beam diameter at the specimen surface. The large emitting area is caused by multiple elastic and inelastic electron scattering events within the excitation volume, whose size depends on the specimen composition and energy of the beam electrons. Only the SE1 and BSE1 generated as the beam enters the specimen carry local information, while the SE2 and BSE2 carry information about the larger region surrounding the point of beam entrance (cf. Figure 3–14). High-resolution information can be obtained from SE1 and BSE1 generated by an electron probe with a diameter at the specimen surface of about 1 nm or even less. A probe of that small size can be achieved by using field emission electron sources, electromagnetic lenses with low aberration coefficients (cf. Eqs. 2.7, 2.8, and 2.10), and both highly stabilized acceleration voltage (cf. Eq. 2.8) and objective lens current. High-resolution scanning electron microscopy at conventional acceleration voltages— that is 5–30 kV—will be treated in Section 3.1. Alternatively, highresolution information, in principle, can also be achieved when the excitation volume is reduced to a size similar to the SE1 and BSE1 emitting area by using low-energy beam electrons. By definition, electrons below 5 keV are considered low-energy beam electrons and, consequently, scanning electron microscopy at low energies is called scanning low-energy electron microscopy or low (acceleration)-voltage scanning electron microscopy (LVSEM). This type of scanning electron microscopy will be treated in Section 3.2. However, the majority of commercial high-resolution SEMs are capable of operation at both conventional energies, i.e., from 5 to usually 30 keV, and at low energies, i.e., below 5 keV down to usually 0.5 keV.
3.1 High-Resolution Scanning Electron Microscopy 3.1.1 Electron Guns Three different types of electron guns are suitable sources for highresolution SEM: the cold fi eld emission gun (FEG), the hot FEG, and the so-called Schottky emission cathode (SEC). The characteristic parameters of the different electron guns are listed in Table 3–1. Schottky emission cathodes are of the ZrO/W(100) type—also called ZrO/W(100) thermal field emitter (TFE)—and have a tip radius of 0.6–1 µm (Tuggle and Swanson, 1985). The work function of the TFE is lowered to about 2.8 eV. In operation the SEC is heated to about 1800 K and electrons are extracted by a high electric field, which lowers the potential barrier (Schottky effect). The SEC brightness is about three orders of magnitude higher and the energy spread of the emitted electrons is about a factor of 2 lower than those for the thermionic W-
209
210
R. Reichelt
cathode. Presently, the SEC in commercial high-resolution SEM is less frequently an electron source than the FEG. The FEG usually consists of a very sharp [100] or [321] oriented tungsten single crystal and two anodes in front, which extract (first anode) and accelerate or decelerate (second anode) the electrons by the electric field to a final energy E0 = eU (Figure 3–37). Caused by the small tip radius r, which is in the range of 10 to about 50 nm, the electric field strength amounts to at least 108 V/cm with an extraction voltage of approximately 4–5 kV applied between the first anode and the tip. Due to the high field strength at the tip the width of the potential barrier is significantly reduced and field emissions take place. The field emission current density jc is described by the Fowler–Nordheim equation jc = c1|E|2/Φ exp(−c2Φ3/2/|E|)
(3.1)
where |E| ≈ U1/r, c1 and c2 depend weakly on |E|, and Φ is the work function of tungsten. The density jc depends strongly on |E|, and E can be varied by U1. The so-called cold FEG (CFEG) is operated at room temperature and generates a current density of typically 2 × 105 A cm−2. However, after several hours of work adsorbed gas layers have to be removed by short heating to about 2500 K (flashing), otherwise the emission current becomes very unstable. The distinct advantage of the cold FEG is the low-energy spread. The hot FEG (HFEG) is operated at approximately 1800 K, which increases the energy spread to about twice that from the cold FEG. The current density is higher than for the cold FEG and typically amounts to 5 × 106 A cm−2. The advantage of the hot FEG is the less noisy emission current.
UH
U1 1st
– U= 1-50 kV +
2nd Anode
Figure 3–37. Schematic drawing of the field emission gun with an electrolytically polished sharp monocrystalline tungsten tip. The hot FEG operates the tip at high temperature heated by the applied voltage UH. U, acceleration voltage; U1, extraction voltage. [Adapted from Reimer (1993); with kind permission of the International Society of Optical Engineering (SPIE), Bellingham, WA.]
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
Field emission guns require ultrahigh vacuum in the order of 10−8– 10 Pa in the gun chamber, which is generated by ion getter pumps. This means that SEMs equipped with an FEG need a sophisticated and consequently cost-intensive vacuum system. Another disadvantage of FEGs compared to the thermionic W-cathode is their significantly lower short- and long-time beam current stability. −9
3.1.2 Electron Lenses Electron lenses are used to demagnify the virtual source size, which amounts to 3–5 nm for both the cold and hot FEG, and about 20–30 nm for the SEG. To obtain and electron beam diameter of about 1 nm or less a demagnification of only 10–100× is required in contrast to up to about 5000× for the thermionic emission triode gun (cf. Section 2.1.2). To achieve the smallest effective electron probe diameter, the spherical and the chromatic aberration constants have to be as small as possible [see Eqs. (2.7), (2.8), and (2.10)]. In the conventional SEM usually large working distances ranging from about 10 to 40 mm are used. Typical values of the spherical aberration constant Cs are 10–20 mm. Since Cs increases strongly with increasing WD (Cs ∼ WD3) sufficiently small values of Cs ∼ 1–2 mm can be achieved only with very short WD, i.e., the focus of the electron beam has to be inside (so-called “in-lens” type) or very close to the objective lens [frequently called “semi-inlens” with a snorkel-type conical objective lens (Mulvey, 1974)]. The chromatic aberration constant Cc corresponds approximately to the focal length of the objective lens for large WD, i.e., also the chromatic aberration is strongly lowered at a very short WD. The shortest WD of the “in-lens” type SEM is about 2.5 mm in order to secure a specimen traverse in the x and y direction perpendicular to the optical axis as well as specimen tilt angles up to a maximum of |±15°|. Larger tilt angles obviously require a larger work distance. To obtain the minimum effective electron probe diameter under these conditions, the optimum aperture αopt has to be used [see Eq. (2.11)]. Presently, the highest resolution obtained with the “in-lens” type FESEM at 30 keV using a test sample amounts to 0.4 nm (Hitachi, 2001). 3.1.3 Detectors and Detection Geometries The detectors used in field emission scanning electron microscopes (FESEM) have been described in Section 2.1.3.1. The detection geometry depends on the particular type of the FESEM. The instruments using the conventional specimen position outside the objective lens (“out-lens”), i.e., the WD is in the range of about 5–30 mm, are commonly equipped with an ET detector located laterally above the specimen and a BSE detector located centrally above the specimen. The “semi-in-lens” instruments, where the specimen is outside but immersed in the field of the objective lens, usually have both the detector arrangement of the “out-lens” type SEM and the “through-the-lens” detection, thus combining the advantages of both detection geometries. The “in-lens” type SEM is restricted to “through-the-lens” detection (cf. Section 2.1.3.2).
211
212
R. Reichelt
3.1.4 Specimen Stages The purpose of the specimen stage in high-resolution scanning electron microscopes is of course the same as in conventional SEM, i.e., the stage has to allow for precise backlash-free movement, tilting, and possibly rotation of the sample during the investigation. As for conventional SEM, there are optionally special specimen stages available that allow investigations of the specimen at elevated temperature, during different types of mechanical deformation, at positive or negative bias, and last at low temperature. Independent on the special type of specimen stage, a higher stability in terms of mechanical vibrations as well as mechanical or thermal drift is required to avoid any deterioration of the performance of the high-resolution SEM. The “in-lens”-type SEMs use side-entry specimen holders, which are almost identical to the ones used in TEMs (cf. Section 2.1.4). However, the limited space available in this type of SEM places some restrictions on the specimen stage for the ultimate resolution of “in-lens”-type FESEM. 3.1.5 Contrast Formation and Resolution At high beam energy, e.g., 30 keV, the lateral extension of the excitation volume in the specimen is for carbon approximately 10 µm and for a high atomic number element such as gold about 1 µm (cf. Figure 3–13). Secondary and backscattered electrons are emitted from a surface area of the specimen, which corresponds in size to about the lateral extension of the excitation volume (cf. Figure 3–14). As discussed in Sections 2.2.1 and 2.2.2, the SE2 and BSE2 represent the majority of the SE and BSE, respectively, whereas the SE1 and BSE1, both carrying highresolution information, represent the minority. Assuming for simplicity an electron beam diameter of 1 nm, the ratio of the lateral size of the excitation volume and the beam diameter amounts to approximately 104 for carbon and 103 for gold. By choosing the magnification such that the field of view at the specimen surface approaches the lateral size of the excitation volume, i.e., related to a 100-mm image size about 10,000× for carbon and 100,000× for gold, both the SE2 and the BSE2 contributions will change in response to the features of the field of view on the size scale of the excitation volume. In contrast to this the SE1 and BSE1 contributions will change in response to the features of the field of view approximately on a size scale of the electron beam diameter. That means that in the course of scanning the electron beam across the field of view, the SE2/BSE2 contribution only insignificantly varies from pixel to pixel whereas the SE1/BSE1 contribution depends sensitively on local features as small as the beam diameter. With a further increase of magnification the field of view becomes significantly smaller than the lateral size of the excitation volume, consequently the SE2/BSE2 contribution is almost constant over the image. The changes in the total SE/BSE signal are almost exclusively due to the SE1/BSE1 component and correspond to the changes in the very tiny volume where SE1/BSE1 are generated. Figure 3–38 shows an example of a high-resolution SE micrograph recorded from a test sample at a magnification of 500,000×. The distinct changes in image intensity reflect the variation of the SE1 component, which is due to
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
213
Figure 3–38. High-resolution secondary electron micrographs of test specimens recorded with the “in-lens” field emission scanning electron microscope S-5000 (Hitachi Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) at 30 kV (a) and 1 kV (b). The test specimens were Au–Pd particles on carbon (a) and magnetic tape evaporated with gold (b). The related power spectra are inserted at the top right. The dashed circles correspond to (0.6 nm)−1 (a) and (3.5 nm)−1 (b), respectively.
the large differences in the atomic number between the carbon and the Au–Pd particles. This type of test sample is usually used to demonstrate the performance of SEMs. The low SE yield of low atomic number specimens (cf. Figure 3–17) such as soft biological objects and polymers limits the resolution due to the poor SNR. However, the SNR can be improved significantly by coating the specimen surface with an ultrathin very fine-grain metal film (Peters, 1982) by Penning sputtering or by evaporation in oil-free high vacuum (cf. Section 2.4). The thickness of such films can be as small as 1 nm and, as we shall see later, such ultrathin films do not mask fine surface structures. In addition to improving the SNR the ultrathin coating plays an important role in contrast formation and the image resolution obtainable. As mentioned earlier, the SE1 arise from the area directly irradiated by the electron beam and its immediate vicinity caused by the delocalization of the inelastic scattering in the order of a very few nanometers (cf. Section 2.2). In the case of the specimen coated with an ultrathin metal film the SE1 generation is confined almost exclusively to the film. Figure 3–39a shows schematically the cross section of an object coated with a continuous metal film of constant thickness. As the electron beam is scanned across the object the projected film thickness will vary between the nominal film thickness
R. Reichelt
e-
Layer Specimen
SE1-yield (arb. units)
214
0 0 a
b
1
2 T(nm)
3
4
Figure 3–39. Schematic cross section of a specimen coated with an ultrathin continuous metal layer of constant thickness (a). The projected mass thickness of the metal layer varies as the electron beam is scanned across the specimen. (b) Graph of the SE1 yield versus the thickness of the coating film.
and the maximum, which is several times greater than the nominal thickness. As shown by Monte Carlo calculations the SE1 yield increases very quickly with the thickness of the metal film (Joy, 1984). For example, the Monte Carlo calculations by Joy (1984) reveal for chromium and 20-keV electrons that half of the maximum SE1 yield is reached for a thickness of 1–1.5 nm only. The dependence of the SE1 yield versus the thickness of a coating film is shown schematically in Figure 3–39b. It indicates that the increase of the SE1 yield with the thickness slows down at twice the thickness at half of the maximum SE1 yield, i.e., the continuous film should be as thin as possible. Monte Carlo calculations of the SE1 yield for some of the metals suitable for preparing ultrathin very fine-grain metal films show a monotonic increase with the atomic number (Joy, 1991); thus some further improvement of the SNR may be expected with high atomic number metals. The ultrathin very fine-grain metal film on the sample surface also improves the BSE1 component significantly, thus improving the SNR in high-magnification BSE micrographs. The BSE1 are very important for high-resolution SEM because the elastic electron scattering is strongly localized. The intensity of the BSE1 component increases with the projected film thickness, i.e., increases with the number of atomic scattering centers. Since the BSE coefficient strongly increases with the atomic number (cf. Figure 3–17), the BSE1 component of the metal film is significantly larger than the contribution from the coated low-atomic number specimen. The same is also true for small metal clusters or small particles at the specimen surface, e.g., such as colloidal gold down to a minimum diameter of 0.8 nm (Hermann et al., 1991), which can be identified unambiguously in the high-resolution BSE micrograph. 3.1.6 Selected Applications Since the achievable resolution is the main difference between the high-resolution field emission SEM and the conventional SEM, it is obvious that the high-resolution SEM (HRSEM) can readily handle almost all of the applications mentioned in Section 2.6. Exceptions are
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
possibly, such as applications in which high emission currents (cf. Table 3–1) or high electron beam current stability are indispensable. Because vacuum conditions in FESEMs are more strict concerning the pressure in the specimen chamber (at least one order of magnitude less than in CSEM) as well as the content of gaseous hydrocarbons and hydrocarbons at the specimen, some specimens may not meet the requirements for cleanness and very low partial pressure. However, if highresolution FESEM is applied instead of CSEM, more information about the specimen will be obtained due to the higher resolution as soon as the magnification used exceeds approximately 10,000× to 20,000×. That means that lateral resolutions requiring magnifications clearly beyond about 20,000× belong to the dedicated domain of high-resolution SEM. The following few applications selected from an almost unlimited quantity should domonstrate the strength of HRSEM in several fields of research. It is clearly beyond the scope of this section to discuss in this context specific details about the specimens and imaging techniques. Figure 3–40a shows the secondary electron micrograph of a regular protein surface layer of a bacterial cell envelope. The specimen was unidirectional shadowed with an ultrathin tungsten layer leaving an uncoated region behind the latex bead. Comparison of the regular structure of the HPI layer in the coated and the uncoated region shows that the contrast in the uncoated area is significantly lower than in the coated region, though the resolution of structural details is very similar as verified by the related power spectra. This example also demonstrates that coating with the ultrathin very fine-grain metal film does not mask fine structural features. On principle, a similar resolution can also be obtained with nonregular organic specimens, however, it remains more difficult to quantify unambiguously the resolution obtained. An extremely important application of HRSEM, as yet unrivaled by other surface imaging techniques, is the localization of molecules on surfaces by immunolabeling techniques (for review see, e.g., Griffith, 1993; Hayat, 1989/1991, 2002; Polak and Varndell, 1984; Verkleij and Leunissen, 1989). The use of HRSEM for immunoelectron microscopy started more than 20 years age (de Harven et al., 1984; Gamliel and Polliack, 1983; Hicks and Molday, 1984; Molday and Maher, 1980; Walther and Müller, 1985, 1986; Ushiki et al., 1986). Since then efforts were made to optimize the technique of immuno-scanning electron microscopy in terms of localization precision, contrast, and SNR (e.g., Albrecht et al., 1988; Hermann et al., 1991; Hirsch et al., 1993; Simmons et al., 1990). While the colloidal gold can be localized directly in the BSE image, the precision of the indirect localization of the antigen depends on the type of labeling and the size of the colloidal gold and ranges from less than 5 to about 30 nm (Baschong and Wrigley, 1990; Müller and Hermann, 1990). Figure 3–41b demonstrates the unambiguous detection of immunogold-labeled calcium-binding birch pollen allergen Bet v4 in birch pollen using 10 nm colloidal gold (Grote et al., 1999b). The BSE micrograph shows the topographic features and the
215
216
R. Reichelt
small colloidal gold beads as sharp bright spots due to the material contrast. However, for more than a decade immuno-scanning electron microscopy has been established as a trusted technique and, with the commercial availability of high-quality gold probes (available in sizes ranging from 1 to 40 nm), is used in many electron microscopic laboratories for various studies (e.g., Apkarian and Joy, 1988; Erlandsen et al., 1995; Grote et al., 2000; Müller and Hermann, 1992; Ris and Malecki, 1993; Yamaguchi et al., 1994). The interior structure of biological specimens is accessible by HRSEM, if samples are rapidly frozen and opened by cryofracturing or cryoul-
Figure 3–40. Secondary electron micrograph of a regular protein surface layer [hexagonally packed intermediate (HPI) layer (Baumeister et al., 1982)] of Deinococcus radiodurans recorded with an “in-lens” FESEM at 30 kV (a). The specimen was unidirectional shadowed (see arrow) at an elevation angle of 45° with a 0.7-nm-thick tungsten layer leaving an uncoated region behind the latex bead. The power spectra of a coated (b) and an uncoated (c) region of the HPI layer reveal the resolution obtained (outermost diffraction spots are indicated and the corresponding reciprocal values of resolution are given). The contrast in the uncoated region is about 15–20% of that from the coated region. [Micrograph kindly provided by Dr. R. Wepf; from Reichelt (1995); with kind permission of GIT Verlag, Darmstadt, Germany.]
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
217
Figure 3–41. Secondary electron micrograph from a birch pollen at low magnification (a) and the backscattered electron micrograph at high magnification recorded with an “in-lens” FESEM at 10 kV. Immunolabeling of the calcium-binding birch pollen allergen Bet v4 in dry and rehydrated birch pollen was performed using 10-nm colloidal gold (for more details see Grote et al., 1999a,b). The BSE image shows superimposed topographic and material contrast. The colloidal gold beads are unambiguously detected in the BSE micrograph as tiny bright spots.
tramicrotomy. After partial freeze-drying and double-layer coating of the block face, the specimen can be directly analyzed in the cryo-SEM (Echlin, 1971; Hermann and Müller, 1993; Walther et al., 1995). Figure 3–42 shows for comparison the BSE micrograph of the cryosectioned and the cryofractured block face of high-pressure frozen yeast cells (Walther and Müller, 1999). At low magnification the cryosectioned block face appeared very flat in the image (Figure 3–42a), whereas the cryofractured face exhibits the typical rough fracture pattern (Figure 3–42c). At high magnification (Figure 3–42b and d) the cytoplasm appeared densely packed with different classes of particle. Particles as small as 25 nm can be visualized clearly. It is important to mention that the typical artifacts of cryosections such as compression and crevasses are not visible on the block face. Both strengths of the HRSEM, namely the high resolution and the high depth of focus, are required to resolve surface structures at the nanometer scale on tilted surfaces randomly oriented. One typical example with submicrometer-sized crystalline zeolite particles is shown in Figure 3–43. The HRSEM is the tool most suited to characterize the habit of the individual particles as well as to visualize the fine surface structure such as growth steps of terraces (see, e.g., González et al., 2004). The growth step-edge height, usually in direct relation to the unit cell dimension and important in understanding the crystal growth mechanism of this novel microporous material, cannot be measured precisely by HRSEM, but the atomic force microscope (AFM) enables measurement of direct height with subnanometer resolution. Thus, the combination of the two high-resolution surface-imaging methods HRSEM and AFM is strongly advisable to obtain more complete information as demonstrated by different applications (e.g., González et al., 2004; Huang et al., 2004; Keller and Chih-Chung, 1992; Lian et al., 2005; Stracke et al., 2003; Wang et al., 2004; Z. X. Zhao et al., 2005).
218
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–42. BSE micrographs of high-pressure frozen yeast cells recorded in an “in-lens” cryoFESEM at 10 kV. (a and b) Block face after cryosectioning and (c and d) block face after freeze facturing. The block faces were double-layer coated with 2.5 nm platinum/carbon and subsequently with 5–10 nm carbon. The cytoplasm from both the sectioned (b) and the fractured (d) sample appears to consist of particles with variable size. [From Walther and Müller (1999); with kind permission of Blackwell Publishing Ltd., Oxford, U.K.]
HRSEM is also a very valuable tool for the evaluation of mechanical properties of structural materials. For example, most structural materials are strengthened by fine particles of second phases usually having diameters less than 500 nm. The strengthening effect is primarily governed by the mean size, the size distribution, and the volume fraction of the particles. Both HRSEM and AFM allow for the precise determination of the mean size, size distribution, and volume fraction of the particles as demonstrated by Fruhstorfer et al. (2002). Figure 3–44 shows the SEM micrograph (Figure 3–44a) and the AFM topograph (Figure 3–44c) of the electrolytically polished surface of the superalloy NIMONIC PE16 with the protruding caps of the second phase parti-
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
cles. In contrast to AFM, where corrections were necessary to take into account the exact tip radius, corrections for the very small electron probe diameter are not urgently required in HRSEM. The size distribution function and mean radius of the second phase particles calculated from HRSEM (Figure 3–44b) and AFM (Figure 3–44d) data are in excellent agreement with those gained earlier by TEM (Nembach, 1996). The distinct advantages of HRSEM in this application are that micrographs are readily recorded and the data can be processed without additional correction procedures. The characterization of porous materials such as porous silicon or porous aluminum oxide gains increasing attention because of important potential applications (see, e.g., Anglin et al., 2004; Galca et al., 2003; Pan et al., 2004; Yamazaki, 2004; Z. X. Zhao et al., 2005; Y. C. Zhao et al., 2005). Among others, HRSEM is an indispensable tool for structural characterization of porous materials taking advantage of the large depth of focus and the high resolution obtainable. Figure 3–45 shows high-resolution SE and BSE micrographs of the surface and cross section of porous aluminum oxide, which exhibits a network with randomly distributed, but almost perfectly aligned cylindrical pores perpendicular to the substrate. The simultaneous imaging of the surface and the cross section reveals information about the three-dimensional specimen structure. Under the conditions given the SE mode yields higher resolution than the BSE mode. However, the BSE mode is of significant importance if greater information depth and material differentiation are required. Figure 3–46 shows SE and BSE micrographs of temperature-sensitive hydrogels, based on poly (vinylmethyl ether) (PVME), with ferromagnetic properties due to incorporated nickel particles used as ferromagnetic filler. The contrast in the SE micrograph (Figure 3–46a) is mainly caused by
Figure 3–43. Secondary electron micrograph of zeolite FAU (faujasite) particles recorded with an “in-lens” field emission SEM at 10 kV. The particles are adsorbed to a thin hydrophilic amorphous carbon film and rotary shadowed with 1.5 nm platinum/carbon (Pt/C) at an elevation angle of 65° and, additionally, unidirectional shadowed with 2 nm Pt/C at an elevation angle of 10°. The habit, intergrowth of particles, and growth steps at the surface are clearly visible. (Specimen kindly provided by Dr. G. Gonzaléz, Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones Científicas, Caracas, Venezuela.)
219
220
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–44. Surface of electrolytically polised superalloy NIMONIC PE16. Secondary electron micrograph recorded with an “in-lens” FESEM at 10 kV (a) and AFM topograph (c). The related distribution functions g of the true radii ρ are shown for the HRSEM in (b) and for the AFM in (c). [Adapted from Fruhstorfer et al. (2002); with kind permission of Taylor & Francis Ltd., http://www.tandf.co.uk/ journals.
the very thin membrane-like PVME, which envelops the nickel particles, whereas the BSE image (Figure 3–46b) has a strong material contrast component due to the nickel particles underneath the PVME membrane. This new class of hydrogels is of great interest for delivery of materials at the micro- and nanometer scale. As mentioned in Section 2.2.3, the high-resolution “in-lens” FESEM equipped with an annular dark-field detector is capable of mass measurements on thin specimens (Engel, 1978; Wall, 1979) at a resolution close to that of a dedicated STEM (Reichelt et al., 1988; Krzyzanek and Reichelt, 2003; Krzyanek et al., 2004). Mass measurement of molecules
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
221
Figure 3–45. High-resolution micrographs of the surface (upper part of image) and the cryosectioned cross section (lower part of image) of porous aluminum oxide recorded with an “in-lens” FESEM at 8 kV with SE (a) and BSE (b). The specimen is rotary shadowed with 1.5 nm platinum/carbon. The bar corresponds to 200 nm. (Specimen kindly provided by Drs. C. Blank and R. Frenzel, Institut für Polymerforschung Dresden e.V., Dresden, Germany.)
and molecular assemblies are of great importance in biophysics and structural biology (for review see, e.g., Müller and Engel, 2001). Finally, nanotechnology and “nanoelectromechanical systems” (NEMS) are additional fields in which HRSEM is used as a tool for monitoring processes, detecting defects, or measuring sizes and distances, e.g., in nanodevices, which will contain nanotubes, nanoparticles, nanowires, and other particles (see, e.g., Aoyagi, 2002; Nagase and Kurihara, 2000; Nagase and Namatsu, 2004). 3.2 Low- and Very-Low-Voltage Scanning Electron Microscopy Scanning electron microscopy with electron energies below 5 keV is usually designated as scanning low-energy electron microscopy
Figure 3–46. High-resolution micrographs of poly(vinyl methyl ether) (PVME) hydrogel with ferromagnetic properties filled with submicrometer nickel particles in the swollen state. The hydrogel was rapidly frozen, freeze dried, and rotary shadowed with an ultrathin layer of platinum/carbon. The SE (a) and BSE (b) micrograph were recorded with an “in-lens” FESEM at 10 kV, (Specimen kindly provided by Dr. K.-F. Arndt, Institut für Physikalische Chemie und Elektrochemie, Technische Universität Dresden, Dresden, Germany.)
222
R. Reichelt
(SLEEM) or, related to the acceleration voltage, LVSEM. The energy of 5 keV can be considered as some threshold energy because the monotonic dependence of the BSE coefficient on the atomic number breaks below this (cf. Section 2.2.2). A second prominent energy threshold is at about 50 eV, which corresponds to the electron energy with minimum inelastic mean free path of electrons in matter (Seah and Dench, 1979). Therefore, scanning microscopy with electron energies below 50 eV is designated as scanning very low-energy electron microscopy (Müllerova and Frank, 2003) or, related to the acceleration voltage in the scanning mode, very low-voltage scanning electron microscopy (VLVSEM). What is the motivation for low electron energy operation in SEM? What are the advantages expected at low energies and what are the inherent disadvantages? Clearly, almost all of the advantages for working at low energy derive directly from the energy dependence of the electron–specimen interaction (see Section 2.2). The advantages include the following: 1. The penetration depth of the impinging electrons decreases with decreasing energy due to the reduced electron range R [Eq. (2.29)], i.e., the excitation volume in the specimen shrinks (cf. Figure 3–13) and the volume emitting SE2 and BSE2 approaches the volume emitting SE1 and BSE1 (cf. Figure 3–14). As a result the edge effect, i.e., overbrightening of edges, is strongly reduced or even suppressed completely. 2. The SE yield δ increases because of the reduced electron range and the SE are generated near the surface, where they can escape (cf. Figure 3–15). As a result, the SNR of the SE signal increases with decreasing energy as low as E0,m. 3. As the SE yield increases, the total amount of emitted electrons approaches unity (cf. Figure 3–16). Because of the conservation of electric charge [Eq. (2.40)] the amount of incoming and emitted charges is balanced and, consequently, the specimen current equals zero. That means that at this particular electron energy E2 no electric conductivity of the specimen is required. Ideally, imaging of electric insulators without conductive coating becomes possible. For normal incidence, E2 is within the range 0.5–5 keV for most of the materials. E2 increases with the increasing angle of beam incidence θ according to E2(θ) = E2(0)/cos2θ
(3.2)
where E2(0) = E2(θ = 0) (Joy, 1989), i.e., increases as θ increases. 4. As mentioned above, the monotonic de-pendence of the BSE coefficient on the atomic number breaks below 5 keV (Reimer and Tollkamp, 1980; Schmid et al., 1983). This behavior enables the material contrast in the BSE image to be finetuned by choosing the most suitable electron energy (Müllerova, 2001). 5. There is a reduced depth of specimen radiation damage (see Section 2.5). At very low electron energies, say less than 30 eV, the elastic scattering dominates and radiation damage becomes negligible (Müllerova and Frank, 2003). The problems and disadvantages inherent to microscopy at low electron energy concern both the instrumentation and the specimen include the following:
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
1. Reduced resolution due to chromatic aberration and diffraction [see Eqs. (2.8)–(2.10)]. 2. Stronger sensitivity of the electron beam to electromagnetic stray fields. 3. Special detector strategies required for SE and BSE. 4. Enhanced contamination rate, which can be counteracted by ultrahigh vacuum. 5. Reduced topographic contrast in SE and BSE micrographs. For electron energies below 5 keV, the increase of SE yield δ(θ) with increasing θ [cf. Eq. (2.31)] drops way down to 0.5 keV as shown for different metals experimentally and by Monte Carlo simulation (Joy, 1987a; Böngeler et al., 1993). Similarly, the backscattering coefficient η(θ) shows less increase with θ than given by Eq. (2.34), which is more pronounced at low electron energies (Böngeler et al., 1993). 6. Reduced material contrast, because the differences of the backscattering coefficient between low and high atomic number material become smaller (Darlington and Cosslett, 1972; Lödding and Reimer, 1981; Reimer and Tollkamp, 1980). 3.2.1 Electron Lenses Modern commercial field emission scanning electron microscopes can operate usually from 30 keV down to 1 keV or even 0.5 keV, i.e., that energy range covers conventional electron energies and most of the low-energy region. Improved computer-aided methods enable electron optical systems to be designed that have high performance within the whole energy range mentioned above. Compared with the oldfashioned thermionic gun scanning electron microscopes the aberration coefficients of the objective lens were improved dramatically for modern field emission instruments commercially available: Cs was reduced by a factor of about 30 down to Cs = 1.6 mm (Uno et al., 2004), and Cc was reduced by a factor of about 10. With the ultrahighresolution objective lens, the CFEG, improved electrical and mechanical stability, as well as strongly reduced specimen contamination rate, the resolution obtained with test specimens amounts presently to 0.5 nm (at 30 keV) and 1.8 nm (at 1 keV) (Sato et al., 2000). Those values are exemplary for the high performance of commercial FESEM over an energy range from 1 to 30 keV, though obtained with special test specimens. Very recently, a new commercial FESEM became available equipped with a spherical and chromatic aberration corrector, which consists of four sets of a 12-pole component that corrects the spherical and chromatic aberration simultaneously (Kazumori et al., 2004). Using the spherical and chromatic correction, the resolution obtained with the test specimen amounts to 1.0 nm (at 1 keV) and 0.6 nm (at 5 keV) (Kazumori et al., 2004). Electrostatic as well as combined magnetic and electrostatic lenses in LVSEM are a very interesting alternative to the magnetic lenses mentioned above. Microscopes equipped with this type of objective lens permit nonconstant beam energy along the column, i.e., the beam electrons pass the column with high energy and are decelerated to low energy in the immersion electrostatic lens. First, the magnitude of the
223
224
R. Reichelt
aberrations of immersion electrostatic lenses corresponds to the high energy at the entrance side. A more detailed treatment of the estimation of electrostatic lenses is beyond the scope of this section (see, e.g., Lencová and Lenc, 1994; Lencová, 1997). Second, the high electron energy in the column is advantageous because the gun brightness increases with electron energy [see Eqs. (2.4) and (3.1)] and electromagnetic stray fields result in less deterioration of the electron beam at high energy. The combined magnetic–electrostatic objective lens (Frosien et al., 1989) has aberration coefficients as low as Cs = 3.7 mm and Cc = 1.8 mm. Martin et al. (1994) achieved with this lens a resolution of 2.5 nm at 5 keV, 4.0 nm at 1 keV, and 5.0 nm at 0.5 keV. Very low landing energies of the electrons can be realized with a retarding-field SEM. There are several retarding-field configurations described in the literature but basically in all of them the specimen is connected to the adjustable bias supply Usp (e.g., Zworykin et al., 1942; Paden and Nixon, 1968; Zach and Rose, 1988a,b; Munro et al., 1988; Müllerova and Lenc, 1992). The landing energy of the beam electrons simply is given by the difference E0 − eUsp. Using retarding-field SEM, landing energies of a few electronvolts are achievable and recently micrographs with reflected electrons even at 0.5 eV were obtained (Müllerova et al., 2001). With the availability of magnetic materials having high coercive force permanent rare-earth-metal magnets attract attention as replacements for magnetic lens coils (Adamec et al., 1995). Khursheed (1998) proposed a portable SEM column design, which makes use of permanent magnets. The column of this miniature SEM amounts to a height of less than 12 cm and is designed to be modular, so that it can fit onto different specimen chamber types, and can also be readily replaced. Focusing of the electron beam onto the specimen can be achieved by varying the specimen height or by an outer magnetic slip ring on the objective lens, which controls the strength of the magnetic field on the axis. Scanning of the beam is performed by deflection coils, which are located above and within the permanent magnet objective lens. A highresolution miniature SEM with a total height of less than 5.5 cm, proposed by Khursheed (2000), uses a permanent magnet objective lens that lies outside the vacuum with spherical and chromatic aberration coefficients (parameters: E0 = 1 keV, WD = 7.5 mm) of 0.36 and 0.6 mm, respectively. These aberration coefficients are about an order of magnitude smaller than those for conventional SEMs with comparable working distance conditions. Miniaturization of the SEM column has advantages such as microlenses with small aberration coefficients, reducing the influence of electromagnetic stray fields and of the electron–electron interaction, improving the mechanical stability, and reducing the demands on space for the microscope. Chang et al. (1990) proposed a miniaturized electron optical system consisting of a field emission microsource and an electrostatic microlens for probe forming with performance, exceeding that of a conventional system over a wide range of potentials (0.1– 10 kV) and working distances (up to 10 mm). Liu et al. (1996) proposed another design that has a column length of only 3.5 mm and can be
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
operated over a wide retarding range of potentials (0.1–10 kV). The instrument has an optimized design (mircoeinzel lens followed by a retarding region) to minimize the primary beam diameter and to maximize secondary electron collection (approximately 50% of SE are collected). 3.2.2 Detectors and Detection Strategies As mentioned previously, modern commercial FESEMs can operate usually from 30 keV down to 1 keV or even 0.5 keV; the commonly used detectors and detection strategies of these instruments were discussed in Sections 2.1.3 and 3.1.3. It is clear from Figure 3–12 that the lower the energy E0 of the beam electrons the lower the energy difference between the secondary and backscattered electrons. The lower the difference of the different signal electrons the more difficult is their separation. At very low electron landing energies SE and BSE are almost indistinguishable, thus the total emission is detected. Very recently, Kazumori (2002) proposed two new SE detection systems in a commercial FESEM, the so-called “r-filter” and the “Gentle Beam,” for high-resolution observation of tiny regions of uncoated specimens that include domains with low or no electrical conductivity at low electron energies. The “r-filter” is an energy-selective SE detection system, and the “Gentle Beam” system consists of a strongly excited conical lens (semi-in-lens type) that can retard the beam electrons and works together with the 1–2 kV negatively biased specimen. The “Gentle Beam” system improves the obtainable resolution significantly for acceleration voltages below 3 keV. SE micrographs of good quality down to 100 V can be recorded by the system (Kazumori, 2002). In the past few years there have been many attempts to improve the noise and time characteristics of semiconductor detectors, to improve the properties of microchannel plate detectors, and to increase the light output as well as lower the energy threshold of scintillator-based BSE detectors below 2 keV (Autrata and Schauer, 2004; Schauer and Autrata, 2004). Compared with the semiconductor detectors and the MCP, the scintillator-photomultiplier still possesses the best SNR and bandwidth characteristics. 3.2.3 Contrast Formation The contrast formation in LVSEM and VLVSEM is controlled—as at conventional electron energies—by the electron specimen interaction at the electron energy used, the specific signal considered, the detector, and the detection geometry. However, the contrast formation at low energies is much more complex than for electron energies ranging from 5 to 30 keV. A variety or reasons accounts for this complexity. For example, the BSE coefficient is for a given material almost constant and the SE yield depends just weakly on the electron energy for E0 ≥ 5 keV. In contrast to this, the monotonic increase of the BSE coefficient with rising atomic number breaks below 5 keV as previously mentioned and, additionally, the BSE coefficient becomes dependent on the electron energy for many chemical elements. Furthermore, the signals obtained at low electron energies are affected more strongly on electron beam-
225
226
R. Reichelt
induced contamination or other thin layers on the surface, which is caused by the strongly reduced electron range. Nevertheless, the main types of contrast, such as topographic, compositional, voltage, electron channeling, crystal orientation, and type-1 and type-2 magnetic and mass-thickness contrast, are also observed in LVSEM, although it is in many respects different from that obtained at conventional energies. There are also several observations that evidently show some “chemical” or “electronic” contrast, i.e., contrast that does not result from an increase in the mean atomic number of the specimen (e.g., Wollman et al., 1993; Bleloch et al., 1994; Perovic et al., 1994). Although these effects may also be visible at conventional energies they are most readily observed at low energies where the SE yield is higher. The thickness contrast described in Section 3.1.5 also plays an important role in LVSEM of electric insulators. Though direct imaging of electrical insulators without electric charge-up should be feasible at electron energy E2, where incoming and emitted charges are balanced, in practice it often does not work for various reasons. Therefore, coating the specimen surface with an ultrathin very fine-grain metal film (Peters, 1982) by Penning sputtering or by evaporation in oil-free high vacuum is often done. As in high-resolution SEM with conventional beam energies, the film plays an important role in contrast formation, in image resolution obtainable, and in the improvement of the SNR. The image contrast of coated specimens essentially depends on the projected film thickness, which will vary between the nominal film thickness and the maximum film thickness, which is several times greater than the nominal thickness in tilted regions (cf. Figure 3–39a). Monte Carlo calculations of the SE yield of a film of chromium at 2 keV also prove for low electron energy a monotonic increase with film thickness (Joy, 1987a). 3.2.4 Selected Applications The application of LVSEM and VLVSEM logically seems likely in cases in which SEM at conventional acceleration voltages obviously would fail, e.g., the investigation of uncoated insulating materials and radiation-sensitive semiconductors. Another compelling reason is the necessity of a reduced electron range, e.g., with specimens having one or more very thin surface layers and samples possessing a spongy- or foam-like fine structure. SEM studies of these types of specimens aim at information restricted to the surface-near zone. With ever decreasing device dimension and film thickness this issue becomes more and more crucial. There are also noncompelling, but still for good reasons, which may aim at optimum imaging conditions at low electron energy, or LVSEM may be part of a series of increasing or decreasing electron energies over a wide energy range as used for depth profiling. Finally, there are also applications of LVSEM that may also work at conventional energies but are most readily obtained at low energies. The LVSEM is widely applied to semiconductor structures relating to an examination of their geometry, critical dimensions, and local
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
voltages or currents, which may be either biased or induced by the electron beam. One example of an integrated circuit was previously shown in Figure 3–30. Figure 3–47 shows the cross-fractured semiconductor structure with Schottky barrier on tungsten contacts. A nanostructured two-dimensional lattice of 100-nm spaced inverted square pyramids in silicon used as standard for scanning probe microscopy is shown in Figure 3–48. Imaging of the uncoated lattice is necessary to avoid modifications of the standard by thin film coating, thus LVSEM is most appropriate. Another challenging application for LVSEM is the quantitative characterization of the geometry and radius of very sharp tips for atomic force microscopy, which are necessary for many quantitative measurements with the AFM (e.g., Fruhsdorfer et al., 2002; Matzelle et al., 2000, 2003). Figure 3–49 shows two extremely sharp commercial tips. The tip radius at the very end amounts typically to 2–3 nm, thus only SE1 contribute to the signal. An optimum quality of SE imaging in terms of sharpness, contrast, and SNR can be obtained with electron energies ranging from about 3 to 10 keV. It seems worth mentioning that very sharp tips are interesting samples with which to study experimentally the delocalization of the secondary electrons. The characterization of organic mono- and multilayers on solids is especially valuable in technology development, such as bio- and chemosensors, since detailed information on the film surface and its morphology is obtained. Figures 3–50 to 3–53 demonstrate with different mono- and multilayered ultrathin uncoated and coated organic films how direct information about the film thickness, step heights of the film, and differences in the “chemistry” and molecular packing density can be obtained. As shown by Figure 3–50a, upward and downward steps with height differences of a few nanometers can be readily
Figure 3–47. Secondary electron micrograph (“through-the-lens” detection) of a cross-fractured semiconductor structure with Schottky barrier on tungsten contacts. The image was recorded at 3.04 kV. The cross-fracture reveals the interior features and the potential barrier of 0.6 eV (dark due to voltage contrast). (Courtesy of Carl Zeiss NTS, Oberkochen, Germany.)
227
228
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–48. Secondary electron micrographs of an uncoated 100-nm calibration standard made from silicon for scanning probe microscopy (NANOWORLD, Neuchatel, Switzerland) recorded with an “in-lens” field emission SEM at 3 kV. The calibration standard consists of a two-dimensional lattice (lattice constant = 100 nm) of inverted pyramids shown at different magnifications (a and b). (c) Structural details of a large pyramidal pit.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
229
Figure 3–49. Secondary electron micrographs of uncoated SuperSharpSilicon AFM Probe silicon cantilevers for noncontact/tapping mode (NANOWORLD, Neuchatel/Switzerland) in atomic force microscopy recorded with an “in-lens” field emission SEM at 3 kV (a) and at 10 kV (b). The tip radius of both tips amounts to about 2–3 nm.
Figure 3–50. Secondary electron micrographs of a phospholipid/protein film [dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC):dipalmitoylphosphatidylglycerol (DPPG) (ratio = 4 : 1)/pulmonary surfactant protein C (SP-C; 0.4 mol%)] supported by a silicon wafer. The organic film has terrace-like regions of different thickness (height differences between terraces are between 5.5 and 6.5 nm (von Nahmen et al., 1997). Micrographs were recorded with an “in-lens” FESEM at 2 keV from the ultrathin platinum/ carbon-coated film (tilted 40° around the horizontal axis) (a) and at 1.8 keV from the uncoated film (b). [Specimens kindly provided by Dr. H.-J. Galla and Dr. M. Siebert, Institut für Biochemie, University of Münster, Münster, Germany.)
230
R. Reichelt
Å 600
400
200
0
0
0.5
1
1.5
2 µm
Figure 3–51. Secondary electron micrograph (a) and AFM topography (b) of the same area of an uncoated phospholipid/protein film [dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC):dipalmitoylphosphatidylglycerol (DPPG) (ratio = 4 : 1)/pulmonary surfactant protein C (SP-C; 0.4 mol%)] supported by a silicon wafer. The organic film has terrace-like regions of different thickness [height differences between terraces are between 5.5 and 6.5 nm (von Nahmen et al., 1997)]. The micrograph was recorded with an “in-lens” FESEM at 2 keV. The scale inbetween (a) and (b) represents the coding of brightness relative to the height used in the topograph (b). (Specimens kindly provided by Dr. H.-J. Galla & Dr. M. Siebert, Institut für Biochemie, University of Münster, Münster, Germany.)
Figure 3–52. Secondary electron micrographs of a patterned self-assembled thiol monolayer on polycrystalline gold recorded at 2 keV with the “in-lens” FESEM. (a) Uncoated monolayer. The circular domains consist of —S(CH2)15CH3 molecules (hydrophobic), which are surrounded by —S(CH2)12OH molecules (hydrophilic). The contrast is due to the different end groups rather than to the small difference in chain length. (b) Monolayer coated with an ultrathin platinum/carbon film. (Specimen kindly provided by Dr. G. Bar, Freiburger Material Forschungszentrum, Freiburg, Germany.)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
231
Å 1200 Å 800
400
40.0
20.0
0 0.0 LC-phase, uncoated area LE-phase, uncoated area Pt/C-coated area
Figure 3–53. Secondary electron micrographs (A and B) and AFM topographs (C and D) of the same area of a 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphothioethanol (DPPTE) monolayer on a silicon wafer having domains with densely [liquid condensed (LC) phase] and losely [liquid expanded (LE) phase] packed molecules. The specimen was masked by a TEM finder grid and then coated with an ultrathin platinum/carbon film to obtain neighboring coated and uncoated areas on the specimen (for details see Bittermann et al., 2001). The SE micrographs were recorded with an “in-lens” FESEM at 5 keV. The brighter regions of the SE micrograph (B) correlate with the elevated domains (LC phase) in the AFM topograph (D), whereas the darker regions correlate with the LE phase. In contrast to the SE micrograph (A) the height differences in coated areas of the film, which are related to its molecular packing density, are still visible in the AFM topograph (C). [From Bittermann et al. (2001); with kind permission of the American Chemical Society, Columbus, OH.]
232
R. Reichelt
identified on a tilted sample coated with an ultrathin conductive film. Whereas the step of constant height reveals in an “in-lens” SEM a constant intensity at normal electron beam incidence, tilting causes an asymmetry such that steps can face upward or downward, which leads to an increase or decrease of their image intensities, respectively. Uncoated organic layers on solids usually reduce the SE yield as shown in Figure 3–50b. As demonstrated in Figure 3–51 by a comparison of an SE micrograph with an AFM topograph of the same area, the SE intensity decreases with increasing thickness of the organic layer (Reichelt, 1997). The monotonic dependence of SE intensity and the thickness of the organic film enables its thickness to be mapped without destruction of the film. The influence of organic film thickness on the SE yield vanishes after ultrathin coating of the organic film as proven by Figure 3–50a. Figure 3–52a demonstrates that the SE yield also depends on the chemical nature of the molecules assembling an organic film. For example, differences in the terminal group of molecules obviously cause a significant difference in the SE yield, which creates a sufficient chemical contrast in the micrograph. This chemical contrast vanishes after ultrathin coating of the organic film (Figure 3–52b). Finally, Figure 3–53 shows that the SE yield is sensitive to the molecular packing density of the organic film, i.e., the number of organic molecules per area (Bittermann et al., 2001). It is easy to understand that the BSE signal is not sensitive to the film thickness and differences in the “chemistry” and molecular packing density, because the backscattering of thin low atomic number films is negligible compared with those of the substrate having a significantly higher atomic number. Figures 3–54 and 3–55 show secondary electron micrographs of an uncoated glass micropipette and a microtome glass knife, which are almost free of electric charging. However, at higher magnifications the typical signs of charging occur. The characterization of sponge-like microstructures, such as hydrogels and microgels, is a further challenging application of LVSEM, where a large depth of focus, high resolution, and low penetration power (i.e., small electron range) of the electron beam are required. Figure 3–56 shows a stereopair of highly magnified SE micrographs of a hydrogel. The optimum imaging quality of fine structural details well below 10 nm was obtained with electron energies around 2 keV. Figures 3–57 and 3–58 show a set of secondary electron micrographs recorded from biological samples at low magnification with different electron energies. The micrographs demonstrate to what extent the contrast and information depth vary with the electron energy in a range from 0.4 to 30 keV, which corresponds to about the accessible energy range of commercial FESEMs. As yet, not all of the contributing contrast mechanisms are fully understood, thus the interpretation of micrographs recorded at a specific selected energy requires great care. Finally, LVSEM is also a promising and efficient alternative to conventional approaches for micromorphological and microstructural
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
233
Figure 3–54. Secondary electron micrograph series (a–d) of increasing magnification of an uncoated glass micropipette recorded at 2 kV with an “out-lens” FESEM. The uppermost part of the tip of the micropipette is within the depth of focus. The lower part is out of focus.
234
R. Reichelt
b,c Cutting edge
d,e
Figure 3–55. Scheme and SE micrographs of an uncoated microtome glass knife recorded at 1 kV with an “out-lens” FESEM. The arrows in (a) indicate the two directions of the electron beam related to the glass knife, which were used for imaging. (b and c) The electron beam has a shallow angle against the cutting edge. Only the uppermost part of the cutting edge is within the depth of focus. (d and e) The electron beam impinges perpendiculary onto the cutting edge. The different mean brightness of the clearance angle side and backside of the knife is due to the effect of the detection geometry of the ET detector.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
235
Figure 3–56. Stereo pair of SE micrographs (a and b) of the hydrogel poly-(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAAm) in the swollen state recorded at 2 keV with the “in-lens” FESEM. The specimen was rapidly frozen, freeze dried, and ultrathin rotary shadowed with platinum/carbon (for details see Matzelle et al., 2002). (c) Red–green stereo anaglyph prepared from (a and b). The tilt axis has a vertical direction. (d) Red–green stereo anaglyph in a “bird view.” (For parts c and d, see color plate.)
236
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–57. Secondary electron micrograph series of increasing electron energies from 0.5 to 30 keV from a keratinocyte. The micrographs are recorded with an “in-lens” FESEM. The image contrast varies significantly with the electron energy. Inhomogeneities in the “leading edge” of the keratinocyte, which has a thickness of about 200–400 nm, are most clearly visible at 2 keV. (Micrographs kindly provided by Dr. R. Wepf, Beiersdorf AG, Hamburg, Germany.)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
237
Figure 3–58. Secondary electron micrograph pair of the cuticula of a leaf recorded at electron energies of 0.4 (a) and 30 keV (b) with an “in-lens” SEM. The low-energy image contains information only from the surface whereas the 30-keV image also reveals information about structural features below the surface, e.g., new spores, which are not visible in (a). (Micrographs kindly provided by Dr. R. Wepf, Beiersdorf AG, Hamburg, Germany.)
characterization of polymers (Berry, 1988; Butler et al., 1995; Brown and Butler, 1997; Sawyer and Grubb, 1996).
4 Scanning Electron Microscopy at Elevated Pressure The scanning electron microscopic investigation of specimens must meet several requirements, which were mentioned in previous sections. To sum it up, it can be said that specimens (1) have to be compatible with the low pressure in the specimen chamber (∼10−3 Pa in conventional SEM and 10−5 –10−4 Pa in field emission SEM), (2) have to be clean, i.e., the region of interest has to give free access to the primary beam, (3) need sufficient electrical conductivity, (4) need to be resistant to some extent to electron radiation, and (5) have to provide a sufficient contrast. In a narrower sense, only metals, alloys, and metallic compounds fulfill those requirements. Numerous preparation procedures mentioned in Section 2.4 were developed in the past and are still in the process of improvement, to provide a sufficient electrical conductivity to nonconductive specimens, to remove the water in samples, and to replace it or to rapidly freeze it in a structure-conserving manner. Nevertheless, there was and still is enormous interest in investigating specimens in their genuine state. Thirty years ago Robinson (1975) proposed examining any uncoated insulating specimen in the SEM at high accelerating voltages in the specimen chamber, which had been modified to contain a small residual water vapor environment. It appeared that the presence of the water vapor sufficiently reduced the resistance of the insulator so that no charging effects were detected in backscattered electron micrographs. Danilatos (1980) developed an “atmospheric scanning electron microscope” (ASEM), which later was called an “environmental scanning
R. Reichelt
electron microscope” (ESEM®) (Danilatos, 1981) and is now a registered trademark. To enable the investigation of water and water-containing specimens in their native state at stationary conditions a minimum pressure of water vapor of about 612 Pa is required at 0°C (cf. Figure 3–59). Stationary conditions in the specimen chamber of the SEM can be accomplished by controlling the water vapor pressure p in close vicinity of the specimen as well as the specimen temperature T such that the p–T values always correspond to points on the solid p–T graph in Figure 3– 59. For example, at 20°C a water vapor pressure as large as about 2330 Pa is required for stationary conditions. p–T values below the solid graph, e.g., 300 Pa at 0°C (Figure 3–59), corresponds to a relative humidity of less than 100%, thus representing nonstationary conditions. How can stationary conditions be reached during imaging of a wet sample in the specimen chamber of an SEM? Figure 3–60 shows the cross section of the ESEM, which permits investigations at pressures sufficient for stationary conditions. Basically, the electron beam propagates in the column as in a conventional SEM until it reaches the final aperture. Then, since the pressure increases gradually as the electrons proceed toward the specimen, the electrons undergo significant scattering on gas molecules until they reach the specimen surface. The electron–gas interaction is discussed in detail by Danilatos (1988). According to this study the average number of scattering events per electron n can be approximated by n = σg pgL/kT
(4.1)
where σg represents the total scattering cross section of the gas molecule for electrons, L is the electron path length in gas, and k is the Boltzmann constant. These approximations hold for Λ >> L, where Λ represents the
4000
3000
Liquid
Solid
p [Pa]
238
2000
Vapor
1000
0 –5
0
5
10 15 T [°C]
20
25
30
Figure 3–59. Phase diagram of water. Solid line, 100% relative humidity (saturated vapor conditions); dashed line, 50% relative humidity. (Data from Lax, 1967.)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
239
Valve Gauge ION PUMP
GUN CHAMBER
manual valve G1
G2
V2 DIF 1
RP1 G4
V12 VENT V1
V6
G3
V5
G5
V7
V3
V4
DIF 2
V13 RP2
EC1
V8 RP3
EC2 regulator valve G7
SPECIMEN CHAMBER
V9 AUX IL IARY GAS V10
WATER VAPOR
V11 VENT
Figure 3–60. Schematic cross section of the first commercial Electroscan Environmental SEM (ESEM®) showing the vacuum and pumping system. Two pressure-limiting apertures separate the electron optical column from the specimen chamber. Differential pumping of the stage above and between the two pressure-limiting apertures ensures the separation of high vacuum in the column from low vacuum in the specimen chamber. The differential pumping of two stages and optimum arrangement of the pressure-limiting apertures can work successfully to achieve pressures up to 105 Pa in the specimen chamber. [From Danilatos, 1991; with kind permission of Blackwell Publishing Ltd., Oxford, U.K.]
mean free path of a beam electron in the gas. According to Eq. (4.1) the average number of collisions increases linearly with the gas pressure pg and the path length in the specimen chamber. Furthermore, n depends via the scattering cross section on the type of gas molecules and on the temperature. When the beam electrons start to be scattered by the gas molecules, the fraction of scattered electrons is removed from the focused beam and hit the specimen somewhere in a large area around the point of incidence of the focused beam. The scattered electrons form a “skirt” around the focused beam, which has a radius of 100 µm for a pathlength of 5 mm (conditions: E0 = 10 keV, water vapor pressure = 103 Pa) (Danilatos, 1988). Using a phosphor imaging plate, the distribution of unscat-
240
R. Reichelt
tered beam electrons and the scattered “skirt” electrons was directly imaged by exposure to the electron beam for a specified time (Wight and Zeissler, 2000). Related to the electron beam intensity within 25 µm, the “skirt” intensity as a function of the distance from the center drops to 15% at 100 µm, 5% at 200 µm, and 1% at 500 µm (conditions: E0 = 20 keV, water vapor pressure = 266 Pa, l = 10 mm) (Wight and Zeissler, 2000). The signals generated by the electrons of the skirt originate from a large area, which contributes to the background, whereas the unscattered beam remains focused to a small spot on the specimen surface, although its intensity is reduced by the fraction of electrons removed by scattering. The resolution obtainable depends on the beam diameter and the size of the interaction volume in the specimen, which is analogous to the situation in conventional and high-resolution SEM, i.e., the resolving power of ESEM can be maintained in the presence of gas. The detection of BSE, CL, and X-rays is to a great extent analogous to the detection in a conventional SEM, because these signals can penetrate the gas sufficiently (Danilatos, 1985, 1986). However, the situation is completely different for the detection of SE. The conventional Everhart–Thornley detector would break down at elevated pressure in the specimen chamber. However, the gas itself can be used as an amplifier in a fashion similar to that used in ionization chambers and gas proportional counters. An attractive positive voltage on a detector will make all the secondary electrons drift toward it. If the attractive field is sufficiently large, each drifting electron will be accelerated, thus gaining enough energy to cause ionization of gas molecules, which can create more than one electron. This process repeating itself results in a significant avalanche amplification of the secondary electron current, which arrives at the central electrode of the environmental secondary electron detector (ESD) (Danilatos, 1988). The avalanche amplification works best only in a limited pressure range and can amplify the SE signal up to three orders of magnitude (Thiel et al., 1997). Too high pressure in the specimen chamber makes the mean free path of the electrons very small and a high electric field between specimen and detector is required to accelerate them sufficiently. Too low pressure in the chamber results in a large mean free electron path, i.e., only a few ionization events take place along the electron path from the specimen to the detector, thus the avalanche amplification factor is low. The new generation of ESD, the gaseous secondary electron detector (GSED), which consists of a 3-mmdiameter metallic ring placed above the specimen, provides better discrimination against parasitic electron signals. Both the ESD and GSED are patented and are available only in the ESEM. However, the ionization of gas molecules creates not only electrons but also ions and gaseous scintillation. The latter can be used to make images (Danilatos, 1986), i.e., in that case the imaging gas acts as a detector. This principle is used in the patented variable pressure secondary electron (VPSE) detector. Nonconductive samples attract positive gas ions to their surface as negative charge accumulates from the electron beam, thus effectively suppressing or at least strongly reducing charging artifacts (Cazaux, 2004; Ji et al., 2005; Tang and Joy, 2003; Thiel et al., 2004; Robertson et al., 2004). The gas ions can affect or even reverse the contrast in the GSED image under specific conditions, e.g.,
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
at specimen regions of enhanced electron emission, where the rate of electron–ion pairs increases (Thiel et al., 1997). The highly mobile electrons generated by electron–gas interaction are removed from the gas by rapid sweeping to the GSED, which in turn causes an increased concentration of positive ions during image acquisition due to different electric field-induced drift velocities of negative and positive charge carriers in the imaging gas (Toth and Phillips, 2000). However, imaging of wet, soft specimens can be hampered by the effect of surface tension (Kellenberger and Kistler, 1979), which may flatten and hereby deform the specimen. Obviously, this is a misleading situation demonstrating that “environmental conditions” do not necessarily guarantee structural preservation. As mentioned above, about 612 Pa is the crucial minimum pressure for wet specimens. In addition to the ESEM, which enables imaging with SE at pressures up to about 6500 Pa, numerous variable pressure SEM (VPSEM), high pressure SEM, and low vacuum SEM (sometimes the abbreviation LVSEM is used, which cannot be distinguished from the low-voltage SEM) became commercially available. The water vapor pressure in the specimen chamber of those SEM is typically at maximum 300 Pa, i.e., below the crucial value of 612 Pa, which is not sufficient for imaging of wet specimens at stationary conditions. To separate the specimen pressure of maximum 300 Pa from the high vacuum in the column only one pressure-limiting aperture is sufficient. For imaging at pressures in the range from 250 to 300 Pa backscattered electrons are utilized. Very recently, Thiberge et al. (2004) demonstrated scanning electron microscopy of cells and tissues under fully hydrated atmospheric conditions using a small chamber with a polyimide membrane (145 nm in thickness) that is transparent to beam and backscattered electrons. The membrane protects the fully hydrated sample from the vacuum. BSE imaging at acceleration voltages in the range of 12–30 kV revealed structures inside cultured cells and colloidal gold particles having diameters of 20 and 40 nm, respectively. Another interesting experimental setup is the habitat chamber designed to keep living cells under fully hydrated atmospheric conditions as long as possible and to reduce the exposure time to the lower pressure in the ESEM below 2 min (Cismak et al., 2003). Scanning electron microscopy at elevated pressure is increasingly used in very different fields. Apart from variations in the pressure and chamber gas a heating stage (maximum temperature about 1500°C) allows changes in the specimen temperature. For example, chemical reactions such as corrosion of metals, electrolyte–solid interactions, alloy formation, and the degradation of the space shuttle ceramic shields by increasing oxygen partial pressures at high temperatures are possible with micrometer resolution. The onset of chemical reactions that depend on various parameters can by studied in detail. Insulators, including oil and oily specimens, can be directly imaged. Water can also be imaged directly in the ESEM, which allows studies of wetting and drying surfaces (e.g., de la Parra, 1993; Stelmashenko et al., 2001; Liukkonen, 1997) and direct visualization of the dynamic behavior of a water meniscus (Schenk et al., 1998; Rossi et al., 2004). Figure 3–61 shows an example of dynamic studies of a water meniscus between the scanning tunneling tip and a support when the tip is
241
242
R. Reichelt
Figure 3–61. Time-resolved sequence of secondary electron images recorded with an ESEM®-E3 (ElectroScan Corp., Wilmington, MA). The water meniscus between the hydrophilic tungsten tip (normal electron beam incidence) and the Pt/C-coated mica (incidence angle of 85°) is clearly visible (a–d). Due to locally decreasing relative humidity the meniscus becomes gradually smaller until it snaps off (e). The absence of the meniscus leads to a significant change of shape of the water bead below the tip [cf. (d) and (e)]. Some water drops are located on the sample in front of and behind the tip. The sequence was recorded within 11 s and each image was acquired within about 2 s. Experimental conditions: E0 = 30 keV, Ip = 200 pA, pg = 1.2 kPa. (From Schenk et al., 1998; with kind permission of the American Institute of Physics, Woodbury, NY.)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
moved across the sample. The wetting of the tip indicates a hydrophilic surface, whereas Figure 3–62 clearly indicates a hydrophobic tip surface. ESEM studies of the wettability alteration due to aging in crude oil/brine/rock systems that are initially water wet are of significant importance in the petroleum industry in understanding the water condensation behavior on freshly exposed core chips. Surface active compounds are rapidly removed from the migrating petroleum, thus changing the wettability and subsequently allowing larger hydrophobic molecules to sorb (Bennett et al., 2004; Kowalewski et al., 2003; Robin, 2001). Furthermore, the ESEM is a powerful tool with which study the influence of salt, alcohol, and alkali on the interfacial activity of novel polymeric surfactants that exhibit excellent surface activity due to their unique structure (Cao and Li, 2002). Environmental scanning electron microscopy disseminates rapidly among scientific and engineering disciplines. Applications range widely over diverse technologies such as pharmaceutical formulations, personal care and household products, paper fibers and coatings, cement-based materials, boron particle combustion, hydrogen sulfide corrosion of Ni–Fe, micromechanical fabrication, stone preservation, and biodeterioration. In spite of the broad applications, numerous contrast phenomena are not fully understood as yet. This is illustrated in Figure 3–63 by a series of SE micrographs recorded at different electron energies, but otherwise identical conditions. In addition, ESEM investigations of polymeric and biological specimens, which are known from conventional electron microscopy to be highly irradiation sensitive, are more difficult because water acts as a source of small, highly mobile free radicals, which accelerate specimen degradation (Kitching and Donald, 1996; Royall et al., 2001).
Figure 3–62. Secondary electron image recorded with an ESEM-E3 (ElectroScan Corp., Wilmington, MA) from a hydrophobic tungsten tip (normal electron beam incidence) and a water bead on Pt/C-coated mica (incidence angle of 85°). The shape of the deformed water surface in the submicrometer vicinity of the tip clearly indicates its hydrophobic surface. The spherical object (black) at the right of the tip in the back is probably a polystyrene sphere and any resemblance is purely coincidental. (From Schenk et al., 1998; with kind permission of the American Institute of Physics, Woodbury, NY.)
243
244
R. Reichelt
Glycolys D
30 kV 500x 15 mm 3Torr
60 µm
Glycolys D
20 kV 500x 15 mm 3Torr
60 µm
Glycolys D
15 kV 500x 15 mm 3Torr
60 µm
Glycolys D
10 kV 500x 15 mm 3Torr
60 µm
Glycolys D
7.5 kV 500x 15 mm 3Torr
60 µm
Glycolys D
5 kV 500x 15 mm 3Torr
60 µm
Figure 3–63. Secondary electron micrograph series of the starch glycolys D recorded at electron energies from 30 keV down to 5 keV (see the individual legends below each micrograph) with an ESEM demonstrating the effect of the electron energy on image contrast. (Micrographs kindly provided by Fraunhofer-Institut für Werkstoffmechanik, Halle, Germany; the project was supported by the State Sachsen-Anhalt, FKZ 3075A/0029B.)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
5 Ultrahigh Vacuum Scanning Electron Microscopy in Surface Science Ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) scanning electron microscopy is from the point of view of the pressure inside the specimen chamber the opposite of SEM at elevated pressure. Since the conventional SEMs typically work at high vacuum with a pressure of about 10−4 Pa inside the specimen chamber, the elevated pressure SEMs are operated at pressures six to seven orders of magnitude higher and the UHV SEMs about three to four orders of magnitude lower than 10−4 Pa. UHV is required for most surface science experiments for two principal reasons: 1. To obtain atomically clean surfaces for studies and to maintain such clean surfaces in a contamination-free state for the duration of the experiment. 2. To permit the use of a low-energy electron technique and, in addition to that, ion-based and scanning probe techniques without undue interference from gas phase scattering. One crucial factor in determining how long it takes to build up a certain surface concentration of adsorbed species is the incident molecular flux F of gas molecules on surfaces given by the Hertz–Knudsen equation F = p g / (2πmkT )
(5.1)
where m is the molecular mass, k is the Boltzmann constant, and T is the temperature (K). To obtain the minimum estimate of time it will take for a clean surface to become covered with a complete monolayer of adsorbate, a sticking probability S = 1 and a monolayer coverage typically in the order of 1015 –1019 molecules/m2 are assumed. Then the minimum time per monolayer simply equals 1019 ⋅ (2πmkT ) / pg , i.e., the lower the pressure the longer the time for coverage. At a pressure of about 10−4 Pa forming a monolayer takes about 1 s. Clean surfaces and UHV are required to apply very surface-sensitive methods such as Auger electron spectroscopy (AES) and spectromicroscopy, X-ray- and UV-induced photoelectron spectroscopies, and LVSEM and VLVSEM. SEM in UHV can be done with customized FESEMs equipped with an energy analyzer for AES, chemical state analysis, or trace element detection, respectively. These UHV-SEMs enable highly sensitive surface area observation using high-resolution SE imaging and are very well suited for EBSD observation (see Section 7) of electron chan neling patterns without contamination as well as low accelerating voltage EDX analysis (see Section 6). An attached neutralizing ion gun allows analysis of insulating bulk materials and thin films without electrical charge ups. SEM in UHV can also be performed with commercial surface science UHV chamber systems and a UHV SEM column attached to it. Such chamber systems offer an in situ combination of several imaging methods (e.g., LVSEM, SAM, AFM, and STM), methods for chemical analysis such as AES, and diffraction methods such as low-energy
245
246
R. Reichelt
electron diffraction (LEED). Dual-chamber systems have a large chamber for the imaging and analysis techniques mentioned above and a second chamber for specimen preparation such as ion sputtering, heating, and thin film growth. SEM in UHV combined with other imaging, spectroscopic, and diffraction methods enables the true surface structure and chemistry to be studied. In particular, LVSEM and VLVSEM are most powerful in UHV because of their high surface sensitivity, which is not noticeably degraded by irradiation-induced contamination.
6 Microanalysis in Scanning Electron Microscopy The generation of X-rays due to electron–specimen interactions was discussed in Section 2.2.5. The characteristic X-rays emitted from the specimen carry information about its local element composition, which is utilized as a powerful microanalytical tool combining SEM with EDX and WDX spectrometers. X-Ray microanalysis is by far the most widely used method combined with SEM, which enables in various modes qualitative and quantitative element analysis from a point or area of interest as well as mapping of the distribution of various elements simultaneously with SE and BSE imaging. The size of the interaction volume emitting X-rays is significantly larger than the ones for AE, SE, and BSE because of the weaker absorption of X-rays inside the specimen (cf. Figure 3–14) and the secondary emission by X-ray fluorescence outside the electron interaction volume. The secondary X-ray emission volume is much larger than that for primary X-ray emission since X-rays are more penetrating than electrons having the same energy. For electron-excited X-ray spectrometry performed on thick specimens in the SEM, the range R for X-ray excitation is given according to Kanaya and Kayama (1972) by R [µm] = (0.0276 A/ρZ0.89) · (E01.67 − Ex1.67)
(6.1)
where A is the atomic weight (g/mol), ρ is the density (g/cm3), Z is the atomic number, E0 is the incident electron energy (keV), and EX is the X-ray energy (keV). For reliable quantitative X-ray microanalytical studies, X-ray absorption, X-ray fluorescence, and the fraction of backscattered electrons, all of which depend on the composition of the specimen, have to be taken into account and are performed by the so-called ZAF correction. Z stands for atomic number, which affects the penetration of incident electrons into the material, A for absorption of X-rays in the specimen on the path to the detector, and F for fluorescence caused by other Xrays generated in the specimen. Two different types of detectors are used to measure the emitted Xray intensity as a function of the energy or wavelength. In an EDX system (Figure 3–64) the X-rays enter the solid-state semiconductor detector and create electron hole pairs that cause a pulse of current to flow through the detector circuit. The number of pairs produced by each X-ray photon is proportional to its energy (see Section 2.1.3.1). In a WDX spectrometer (Figure 3–65) the X-rays fall on a bent crystal and
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy Preamplifier
Si (Li) diode 3 – 5 mm p
RF
U
20 nm Au +
X-ray
CF
–
i
Uo
n
Time Output
FET
p
Bias voltage –1 000 V
Figure 3–64. Scheme of Si(Li) X-ray diode coupled to a field effect transistor (FET) with a resistive feedback loop (R F, CF). The shape of the output signal is shown in the output voltage vs. time diagram. Typically, this principle is used in energy-dispersive X-ray (EDX) detectors. (From Reimer, 1985; with kind permission of Springer-Verlag GmbH, Heidelberg, Germany.)
Analysing crystal with lattice planes of radius rd
d π – 2ΘB
PE
rd = 2r
f
X
Specimen
Slit rf
Rowland circle of radius r f
Proportional counter
Figure 3–65. Principle of a wavelength-dispersive X-ray (WDX) spectrometer. Generated X-rays that hit the analyzing crystal are focused and due to Bragg reflection directed to a slit in front of the proportional counter lying on a Rowland circle with radius rf. The lattice planes of the crystal are bent to a radius of 2rf. (From Reimer, 1985; with kind permission of Springer-Verlag GmbH, Heidelberg, Germany.)
247
248
R. Reichelt
are reflected only if they satisfy Bragg’s law. The crystal bending is such that it focuses X-rays of one specific wavelength onto a proportional counter and rotates to scan the wavelength detected. Some important features of both types of X-ray spectrometer are listed in Table 3–9. However, since instrumentation and analysis of data in X-ray microanalysis are usually considered a separate discipline, no further details are discussed in this section [see, e.g., Heinrich (1982), Heinrich and Newbury (1991), Reimer (1998), Goldstein et al. (1984, 2003), and Newbury and Bright (2005)]. A selected application of the very powerful combination of SEM imaging, X-ray microanalysis, and element mapping—the latter was invented almost exactly 50 years ago by Cosslett and Duncumb (1956)— is illustrated in Figure 3–66. The selected specimen is a Cr–Fe alloy with an Si phase, which has a locally varying composition as clearly indicated by the energy-dispersive spectra in Figure 3–66a and b recorded at different locations (Figure 3–66c). The area under each characteristic peak represents the amount of X-ray counts, which is—after subtraction of the unspecific background below the peak and ZAF correction—a direct quantitative measure of the number of atoms of the specific element belonging to that peak. However, a simple visual inspection of the spectra shows, e.g., that the location “Punkt1” (see Figure 3–66a) contains significantly more chromium and less iron than location “Punkt2” (see the spectrum in Figure 3–66b). In addition, a strong silicon peak emerges in the spectrum of location “Punkt2” not present in the spectrum of “Punkt1” (see the spectrum in Figure 3–66a). The element distribution maps of four important chemical elements in the specimen, namely iron, chromium, silicon, and titanium, are shown in Figure 3–66d–g. Comparing the information given by the four element distribution maps on the one hand and the two spectra on the other hand immediately makes clear why the titanium peak does not emerge in the spectra and the chromium peak is dominant at location “Punkt1” but not at “Punkt2”. By means of simple image processing procedures the SE micrograph (Figure 3–66c) and the element distribution maps (Figure 3–66d–g) can be superimposed in one image (Figure 3–66h) presenting information for five individual images. The most powerful tool in electron beam microanalysis is the ability to depict the elemental compositional heterogeneity of matter with micrometer to nanometer lateral resolution. Many developments have occurred since the intervening years to advance this critical method. We are now on the leading edge of extraordinary new X-ray mapping performance: the emergence of the silicon drift detector (SDD) that permits recording of X-ray spectrum images (XSI) in an energy-dispersive operating mode with output count rates of 600 kHz and even higher (cf. Table 3–9). Further, computer-controlled SEM in connection with image processing and EDX spectrometry enables the unattended and automated determination of both the geometric parameters and the chemical composition of thousands of individual particles down to a size of 50–100 nm (see, e.g., Poelt et al., 2002). Consequently, correlations between particle size, chemical composition, the number of
133 eV (at 10 4 cps) 115 eV (at 103 cps) 3 ¥ 10 4 cps
150 eV (at 5.9 keV)
3 ¥ 103 cps
All energies simultaneously
0.1–20
Energy resolution
Maximum counting rate
Spectrum acquisition
Probe current (nA)
g
f
e
d
c
b
a
150 eV (at 105 cps) 230 eV (at 6 ¥ 105 cps)
Z≥4
Z ≥ 11 (Be window) Z ≥ 4 (windowless)
Element detection
Si(Li), Lithium drifted silicon; HPGe, high-purity germanium; cps: counts per second. Reichelt (1995). Strüder et al. (1998a). Strüder et al. (1998b). Lechner et al. (2001). Newbury et al. (1999). With BN/Moxtek window, thermal isolation, and Au-absorber.
0.1–10
All energies simultaneously
Z≥5
ª100%
ª100%
Quantum efficiency
0.1–10
All energies simultaneously
ª6 ¥ 105 cps
>90%
<2%
Energy dispersive Si drift (SD) X-ray detectorc,d,e <2%
<2%
Energy dispersive HPGe X-ray detector b
Geometric collection efficiency
Features
Energy dispersive Si(Li) X-ray detector b
Detector
0.1–10
All energies simultaneously
8 ¥ 102 cps–103 cps
1–100
One wavelength at a time
105 cps
ª5 eV
Z≥4
Z ≥ 6g 12 eV (at 5.9 keV) 3.1 eV (at 1.49 keV)
£30%
Wavelength dispersive X-ray detector b <0.2%
60–80% (within 1–2 keV)
ª8 ¥ 10 −3%
Energy dispersive microcalorimeter X-ray detectorf
Table 3–9. Characteristic features of energy-dispersive X-ray (EDX) and wavelength-dispersive X-ray (WDX) detectors. a
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy 249
x 1E3 Pulses/eV 4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
0.0 a
2
4
6 - keV -
8
10
2
4
6 - keV -
8
10
x 1E3 Pulses/eV 3.0
2.0
1.0
0.0 b
Figure 3–66. X-Ray microanalysis of a Cr–Fe-alloy with a Si phase. The EDX spectra (a and b) were recorded with the Röntec XFlah3001 from locations “Punkt1” and “Punkt2” marked in the SE micrograph of the specimen (c). The positions of the characteristic X-ray energies for the various elements emerging in the spectra are indicated by thin colored lines, which are labeled with the chemical symbol of the corresponding chemical element. The elements iron, chromium, and vanadium occur with one Kα peak each in the energy range from 4.95 to 6.40 keV and with one less intense L α peak each in the energy range from 0.51 to 0.71 keV. Elemental distribution maps of Fe (d), Cr (e), Si (f), and Ti (g) were recorded using the Kα lines. (h) Mixed micrograph obtained by superimposition of the SE image and the maps of the distribution of Fe, Cr, Si, and Ti within the field of view. Experimental conditions: SEM, LEO 438VP. For recording spectra: E0 = 20 keV; count rate, ≈ 3 × 103 cps; acquisition time, 300 s. For recording maps: E0 = 25 keV; count rate ≈ 1.5 × 105 cps; acquisition time 600 s. (EDX spectra, SE micrograph, and elemental distribution maps were kindly provided by Röntec GmbH, Berlin, Germany.) (See color plate.)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
Figure 3–66. Continued
251
252
R. Reichelt
different compounds, and their contribution to the overall concentration can be established. Problems may arise in connection with specimen preparation, optimization of the image contrast, the sometimes nonhomogeneous composition of particles, shadowing of the X-rays in case of large particles, and the lack of a rigorous ZAF correction procedure for particles of arbitrary shape. Another increasingly important application is multilayer analysis, i.e., the nondestructive measurement of the thickness and composition of thin films both unsupported and on substrates, which can be performed with high accuracy down to a thickness of 2 nm by a combination SEM and EDX (see, e.g., Hu and Pan, 2001; Rickerby and Thiot, 1994; Rickerby et al., 1998; Smith et al., 1995). For this purpose the ratio between the X-ray intensity of the film and the intensity of the same element of a bulk standard is used. Low-voltage scanning electron microscopy (E0 < 5 keV) offers both high spatial resolution and a significantly reduced X-ray generation depth. This enables the composition of thin layers on substrates to be determined without the need to use a dedicated thin film analysis program. The analysis of small phases down to a size of 50 nm is also possible (see, e.g., Poelt, 2000; Wurster, 1997). However, the disadvantages are that the X-ray intensity produced is small because of low fluorescence yield ω (cf. Figure 3–22) and not all elements can be analyzed. In principle elements of higher atomic number can be identified using L- and M-shell X-rays, but these are much more complicated than the rather simple K-shell X-ray emissions. Although the enhanced surface sensitivity may be useful sometimes, in many cases it is more likely to be a problem. If thin film coating is required this film may be a significant fraction of the electron range, and without it the specimen may charge up. Working at E0 = E2, where incoming and emitted electrons are balanced, is usually not sufficient. Furthermore, having the electron beam stationary on the specimen for a long time to integrate the weak signals is exactly the way to produce contamination, which can stop the electrons before they reach the real specimen surface. Then X-ray microanalysis does not relate to the specimen at all.
7 Crystal Structure Analysis by Electron Backscatter Diffraction In crystalline specimens electrons are diffracted at lattice planes according to Bragg’s law given as 2d sin ϑ = nλ
(7.1)
where d is the lattice-plane spacing, ϑ is Bragg’s angle, and λ is the electron wavelength. Bragg’s law requires that the incident and emergent angles should be equal ϑ. As previously mentioned, the backscattering coefficient sensitively depends on the tilt of the incident electron beam relative to the lattice and Bragg position. Changing the tilt of the
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
incident beam relative to the lattice, e.g., by rocking the electron beam or tilting the specimen, affects the backscattering coefficient, which results in an electron channeling pattern (ECP). To obtain from an ECP information about the crystal structure, e.g., the crystal orientation and the lattice plane spacings, a so-called panorama diagram recorded by successively tilting the specimen over a large angular range is required (Joy et al., 1982; van Essen et al., 1971; Reimer, 1998). However, establishing a panorama diagram is a somewhat difficult task. Another way of obtaining information about the crystal structure of the specimen is the use of electron diffraction effects associated with the scattered electrons. As described in Section 2.2, the beam electrons are scattered elastically and inelastically due to the electron–specimen interaction, thus scattered beam electrons travel within the excitation volume in all directions (cf. Figure 3–13). This scattering process can be considered as a small electron source inside the crystalline specimen emitting electrons in all directions as shown in Figure 3–67. These electrons may be diffracted at sets of parallel lattice planes according
Electron beam Crystal surface
Lattice planes
Cone 1 Cone 2 2ϑ
Figure 3–67. Scheme of the formation of one pair of cones from diffraction of scattered electrons at one set of parallel lattice planes.
253
254
R. Reichelt
to Bragg’s law [(Eq. (7.1)] as first observed by Venables and Harland (1973). Figure 3–67 illustrates that the electrons emitted from one point and diffracted at lattice planes will form pairs of cones centered with respect to the normal vector of these lattice planes. The opening angle of the cones is 180° −2ϑ and the angle between them is 2ϑ. Since the Bragg angle is in the order of 1° for 15–30 keV electrons and latticeplane spacings of 0.2–0.3 nm, the intersections of the cones with a flat observation screen positioned at a distance much large than d (usually 2–4 cm from the point of beam–specimen intersection) and tangential to the propagation sphere of the scattered electrons are almost straight and parallel pairs of lines. The are called Kikuchi lines. The angle between parallel pairs of Kikuchi lines is 2ϑ. The whole EBSD pattern with the Kikuchi lines reveals local information about the crystalline structure within the individual excitation volume. A detailed treatment of EBSD, which is beyond the scope of this section, is given by Wilkinson and Hirsch (1997). Nevertheless, it is worth mentioning that the relationship between EBSD and the previously introduced ECP is characterized by the reciprocity of their ray diagrams (Reimer, 1985). The recording of the EBSD pattern, which originally was performed by exposure of a photographic film, is now done by positionsensitive detectors such as a phosphorous screen coupled to a TV camera or a scintillation window with a CCD camera attached. To allow the diffracted electrons to escape from the specimen its surface is usually tilted approximately 60° or 70° toward the screen. The EBSD patterns are digitally acquired by computer, which also controls the positioning of the beam. In case of automated crystal orientation mapping, the computer scans the electron beam stepwise across the specimen and controls the dynamic focusing of the beam (cf. Figure 3–9e and Section 2.1.5.2). Since special software algorithms for the automated detection and indexing of Kikuchi lines in EBSD pattern were introduced by Krieger-Lassen et al. (1992), Adams et al. (1993) developed a new scanning technique called “orientation imaging microscopy” (OIM). In OIM, which is also called automated crystal orientation mapping, the EBSD pattern from each individual point at the specimen surface radiated by the electron beam is recorded and analyzed. The current state of the art of OIM is reviewed by Schwarzer (1997) and Schwartz et al. (2000). In the past decade EBSD has become a powerful tool for crystallographic analysis such as the determination of the orientation of individual crystallites of polycrystalline materials in the SEM, phase identification, and characterization of grain boundaries, which is illustrated by the following examples. Figure 3–68 shows two different EBSD patterns from an as-cast niobium sample recorded with high (Figure 3–68a) and low resolution (Figure 3–68b), respectively (Zaefferer, 2004), at a stationary beam position. Figure 3–68c shows the colored pairs of Kikuchi lines generated by automatic indexing and overlayed to the EBSD monitored in Figure 3–68a. Figure 3–69a shows an SE micrograph of polycrystalline austenite with the related color-coded orientation map of polycrystalline austenite monitored in Figure 3–69b (Zaefferer et al., 2004). The spatial resolu-
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
255
Figure 3–68. ESBD patterns from an as-cast niobium specimen. (a) High-resolution EBSD pattern with background subtraction. Exposure time, 7 s. (b) Raw data EBSD pattern for high-speed mapping. Exposure time, 15 ms. EBSD patterns are recorded with thermal FESEM JSM-6500F. (c) EBSD pattern from (a) with colored pairs of Kikuchi lines generated by automatic indexing. [EBSD patterns were kindly provided by Dr. S. Zaefferer, Max-Planck-Institut für Eisenforschung, Düsseldorf, Germany. (a and b) From Zaefferer, 2004; with kind permission from JEOL (Germany) GmbH, München, Germany.] (For part c, see color plate.)
tion obtained amounts to about 50 nm (at E0 = 15 keV), i.e., smaller grains or precipitates cannot be detected in the orientation map. The map shown in Figure 3–69c provides information about the grain boundary character and the orientation variations inside of each grain. The latter is shown for an individual grain in more detail in Figure 3–70. The OIM developed into a powerful technique providing a wealth of information about the type and distribution of different phases, the size, shape, and defects of grains, the type of grain boundaries, the local crystal orientation, and the preferential orientation (texture). To take full advantage of this new imaging technique in terms of spatial and orientation accuracy the thermal field emission SEM providing a high beam current is most suitable. Furthermore, the SEM needs a very high mechanical and electronic sta bility because EBSD measurements require very long recording time, e.g., up to 12 h for very large orientation maps (Zaefferer, 2004). Finally, the preparation of specimens is a very delicate task since EBSD is a very surface-sensitive technique with an information depth of less than 10 nm up to a few tens of nanometers. Thus, the surface-near zone must be free of any deformation and, in addition, the surface has to be rather smooth because any surface relief may affect data acquisition. The application of OIM is not restricted to metals and alloys. Crystalline materials such as semiconductors (e.g., Wilkinson, 2000), ceramics (e.g., Katrakova and Mucklich, 2002; Koblischka and KoblischkaVeneva, 2003), and minerals (e.g., Mauler et al., 2001; Prior et al., 1999) can be investigated.
256
R. Reichelt
a)
5.00 µm = 100 steps
b)
111
colour coding: ND hatched areas: austenite
001
101
c)
grain boundary character rotation angle fraction 41˚ 42˚ 0.051 42˚ 43˚ 0.112 43˚ 44˚ 0.140 44˚ 45˚ 0.132 45˚ 46˚ 0.097 46˚ 47˚ 0.018
deviation to centre grain orientation orientation class <001> ll ND (max. 20˚) all other orientations austenite
Figure 3–69. Secondary electron micrograph of austenite (a) with rough (1), relatively smooth (2), and smooth (3) surface areas. (b) Orientation map of (a) measured by automated crystal orientation mapping and color coded for the crystal direction parallel to the normal direction (ND) of the sheet. Hatched areas correspond to austenite grains. (c) The boundary character between γ- and α-grains, different orientation components [(001)||ND, red; all others blue] and the orientation variations inside of each grain (color shading; b, bainite). The micrograph and the maps are recorded with thermal FESEM JSM-6500F. Note: the extension toward the top and bottom of the measured are in (b) and (c) is larger than the area marked in (a). (Reprinted from Zaefferer et al., 2004; copyright 2004, with permission from Elsevier.) (For parts b and c, see color plate.)
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy
a
b
b
b
a
f
b
Boundary levels: 15˚ 2˚ 41˚ 42˚ 43˚ 44˚ 45˚ 46˚
2.50 µm = 50 steps austenite
Angular deviation to orientation in grain centre
Figure 3–70. Orientation map of one grain from the microstructure in Figure 3–69a. Color code: angular deviation of every mapping point to one orientation in the center of the grain. Bainite appears in conjunction with a steep orientation gradient in ferrite. The white line marks the maximum extension of austenite at austenization temperature. f, ferrite; a, austenite (hatched); b, bainite. [Reprinted from Zaefferer et al., 2004; copyright, 2004, with permission from Elsevier.] (See color plate.)
Acknowledgments. I would like to acknowledge the very valuable help of Dipl.-Ing. Harald Nüsse [Institut für Medizinische Physik und Biophysik (IMPB)] in preparing numerous schematic drawings and figures composed of individual micrographs. Dr. Vladislav Krzyzanek (IMPB) kindly contributed data from Monte Carlo simulations of the electron scattering in thin and in bulky specimens. I am greatly indebted to Mrs. Ulrike Keller (IMPB) for expert technical assistance in the preparation and scanning electron microscopic investigation of numerous specimens. Finally, the expert photographic work of Mrs. Gudrun Kiefermann (IMPB) with those micrographs, which were recorded in the Institut für Medizinische Physik und Biophysik, is greatly acknowledged. References Åberg, T. and Howat, G. (1982). In Handbuch der Physik, vol 31 (Mehlhorn, W. and Flügge, S., eds) 469–619. (Springer, Berlin). Adamec, P., Delong, A. and Lencova, B. (1995). J Microsc 179, 129. Adams, B.L., Wright, S.I. and Kunze, K. (1993). Metall Trans 24A, 819. Albrecht, R.M. and Ornberg, R.L. (eds.) (1988). The Science of Biological Specimen Preparations for Microscopy and Microanalysis. (Scanning Microscopy International, Chicago).
257
258
R. Reichelt Albrecht, R.M., Simmons, S.R., Prudent, J.R. and Erickson, C.M. (1988). In 46th Ann Meeting Electron Microscopy Soc America (Bailey, G.W., ed.) 214–217. (San Francisco Press, San Francisco). Alexander, H. (1994). Materials Sci Engin B: Solid State Mat Adv Technol 24, 1. Anglin, E.J., Schwartz, M.P., Ng, V.P., Perelman, L.A. and Sailor, M.J. (2004). Langmuir 20, 11264. Aoyagi, S. (2002). JEOL News 37, 70. Apkarian, R.P. and Curtis, J.C. (1986). Scann Electr Microsc 4, 1381. Apkarian, R.P. and Joy, D.C. (1988). In Microbeam Analysis (Newburry, D.E., ed.) 459–462. (San Francisco Press, San Francisco). Arnal, F., Verdier, P. and Vincensini, P.-D. (1969). Comp rend Acad Sci (Paris) 268, 1526. Autrata, R. (1990). Scann 12, 119. Autrata, R. and Hejna, J. (1991). Scann 13, 275. Autrata, R. and Schauer, P. (2004). In 13th Eur Congr Microscopy, vol 1 (Schryvers, D., Timmermans, J.-P., van Dyck, D. and van Oostveldt, eds.) 75–76. (Belgian Society for Microscopy, Liége). Autrata, R., Hermann, R. and Müller, M. (1992a). Scann 14, 127. Autrata, R., Jirák, J., Spinka, J. and Hutar, O. (1992b). Scann Microsc 6, 69. Bahadur, H. and Parshad, R. (1980). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 509. Balk, L.J. (1986). Can J Phys 64, 1238. Balk, L.J. (1989). In SEM Characterization of Semiconductors (Holt, D.B. and Joy, D.C., eds.) 425–445. (Academic Press, New York). Balk, L.J. and Kultscher, N. (1984). J Phys (Paris), Colloque C2, C2-873. Balk, L.J., Davies, D.G. and Kultscher, N. (1984). IEEE Transact Magnet 20, 1466. Bambynek, W., Crasemann, B., Fink, R.W., Freund, H.U., Mark, H., Swift, C.D., Price, R.E. and Rao, P.V. (1972). Rev Mod Phys 44, 716. Barth, J.E. and Kruit, P. (1996). Optik 101, 101. Baschong, W. and Wrigley, N.G. (1990). J Electr Microsc Techn 14, 313. Bastacky, J., Wodley, C., Labrie, R. and Backhus, C. (1988). Scann 10, 37. Bauer, E. and Telieps, W. (1988). In Surface and Interface Characterization by Electron Optical Methods (Howie, A. and Valdre, A., eds.) 195–233. (Plenum, New York). Bauer, H.E. and Seiler, H. (1984). In Scanning Electron Microscopy, vol 3 (Johari, O., ed.) 1081–1088. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Baumeister, W., Hahn, M., Seredynski, J. and Herbertz, L.M. (1976). Ultramicroscopy 1, 377. Baumeister, W., Karrenberg, F., Rachel, R., Engel, A., ten Heggeler, B. and Saxton, W.O. (1982). Eur J Biochem 125, 535. Baun, W.L. (1969). Adv Electr Phys Suppl. 6, 155. Bearden, J.A (1967a). Rev Mod Phys 39, 78. Bearden, J.A. (1967b). Rev Mod Phys 39, 125. Bennett, B., Buckman, J.O., Bowler, B.F. and Larter, S.R. (2004). Petrol Geosci 10, 271. Berger, M.J. and Seltzer, S.M. (1964). In Penetration of Charged Particles in Matter (Fano, U., ed.) 205–268. National Academy of Sciences–National Research Council Publication 1133. Berry, V.K. (1988). Scann 10, 19. Bethe, H. (1930). Ann Phys 5, 325. Bishop, H.E. (1974). In Quantitative Scanning Electron Microscopy (Holt, D.B., Muir, M.D., Grant, P.R. and Boswarva, I.M., eds.) 41–64. (Academic Press, London).
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy Bishop, H.E. (1984). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 259–269. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Bishop, H.E. and Riviere, J.C. (1969). J Appl Phys 40, 1740. Bittermann, A.G., Jacobi, S., Chi, L.F., Fuchs, H. and Reichelt, R. (2001). Langmuir 17, 1872. Bleloch, A.L., Castell, M.R., Howie, A. and Walsh, C.A. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 54, 107. Bolt, R.O. and Carroll, J.G. (eds.) (1963). Radiation Effects on Organic Materials. (Academic Press, New York). Bond, E.F., Beresford, D. and Haggis, H.H. (1974). J Microsc 100, 271. Böngeler, R., Golla, U., Kässens, M., Reimer, L., Schindler, B., Senkel, R. and Spranck, M. (1993). Scann 15, 1. Boyde, A. (2004). Scann 26, 265. Boyde, A. and Reid, S.A. (1983). Scann Electr Microsc IV, 1803. Brandis, E. and Rosencwaig, A. (1980). Appl Phys Lett 37, 98. Bröcker, W., Krefting, E.-R. and Reimer, L. (1977). Beitr Elektronenmikr Direktabb Analyse Oberfl 10, 647. Brown, G.M. and Butler, J.H. (1997). Polymer 38, 3937. Burhop, E.H.S. (1952). The Auger Effect. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Butler, J.H., Joy, D.C., Bradley, G.F. and Krause, S.J. (1995). Polymer 36, 1781. Cao, Y. and Li, H.L. (2002). Eur Polym J 38, 1457. Cargill, G.S. III (1980). Nature 286, 691. Cazaux, J. (2004). Microsc Microanal 10, 670. Chan, D.S.H., Phang, J.C.H., Chin, J.M. and Kolachina, S. (2000). Beam Inject Assess Microstruct Semiconduct 78–79, 11. Chan, E.K.M., Darendeliler, M.A., Petocz, P. and Jones, A.S. (2004). Eur J Oral Sci 112, 134. Chandler, J.A. (1978). X-Ray Microanalysis in the Electron Microscope. (NorthHolland Publ., Amsterdam). Chang, T.H.P., Kern, D.P. and Muray, L.P. (1990). J Vac Sci Technol B 8, 1698. Cismak, A., Schwanecke, M., Füting, M. and Heilmann, A. (2003). Microsc Microanal 9 (Suppl 3), 480. Cosslett, V.E. (1972). Optik 36, 85. Cosslett, V.E. and Duncumb, P. (1956). Nature 177, 1172. Craven, A.J., Gibons, J.M., Howie, A. and Spalding, D.R. (1978). Phil Mag 38, 519. Crewe, A.V., Isaacson, M. and Johnson, P. (1970). Rev Sci Instrum 41, 20. Czyzewski, Z., O’Neill MacCallum, D., Romig, A. and Joy, D.C. (1990). J Appl Phys 68, 3066. Danilatos, G.D. (1980). Scann 3, 215. Danilatos, G.D. (1981). J Microsc 121, 235. Danilatos, G.D. (1985). Scann 7, 26. Danilatos, G.D. (1986). Scann 8, 279. Danilatos, G.D. (1988). In Advances in Electronics and Electron Physics (Hawkes, P.W., ed.) 109–250. (Academic Press, London). Danilatos, G.D. (1990). In Advances in Electronics and Electron Physics (Hawkes, P.W., ed.) 1–102. (Academic Press, New York). Danilatos, G.D. (1991). J Microsc 162, 391. Darlington, E.H. and Cosslett, V.E. (1972). J Phys D 5, 1969. Davidson, S.M. (1989). In SEM Microcharacterization of Semiconductors (Holt, D.B. and Joy, D.C., eds.) 153–240. (Academic Press, New York). Deamy, H.J. (1982). J Appl Phys 53, R51.
259
260
R. Reichelt de Harven, E., Leung, R. and Christensen, H. (1984). J Cell Biol 99, 53. Dekker, A.J. (1958). Solid State Phys 6, 251. de la Parra, R.E. (1993). Microsc Res Techn 25, 362. DeMets, M. (1975). Microsc Acta 76, 405. DeMets, M., Howlett, K.J. and Yoffe, A.O. (1974). J Microsc 102, 125. DeVore, W. and Berger, S.D. (1996). J Vac Sci Technol B 14, 3764. Dole, M. (ed.) (1973). The Radiation Chemistry of Macromolecules. (Academic Press, New York). Dorsey, J.R. (1969). Adv Electr Phys Suppl 6, 291. Drescher, H., Reimer, L. and Seidel, H. (1970). Zeit Angew Phys 29, 332. Drescher, H., Krefting, E.-R., Reimer, L. and Seidel, H. (1974). Zeit Naturforsch 29a, 833. Drobne, D., Milani, M., Ballerini, M., Zrimec, A., Zrimec, M.B., Tatti, F. and Draslar, K. (2004). J Biomed Opt 9, 1238. Drobne, D., Milani, M., Zrimec, A., Zrimec, M.B., Tatti, F. and Draslar, K. (2005). Scann 27, 30. Drouin, D., Hovington, P. and Gauvin, R. (1997). Scann 19, 20. Dubbeldam, L. (1991). In Advances in Optical and Electron Microscopy, vol 12 (Mulvey, T. and Sheppard, C.J.R., eds.) 139–242. (Academic Press, London). Dykstra, M.J. (1992). Biological Electron Microscopy. (Plenum, New York). Echlin, P. (1971). Scann Electr Micros 1, 225. Echlin, P. (1992). Low-Temperature Microscopy and Analysis. (Plenum, New York). Edelmann, J. and Wetzig, K. (1995). In In Situ Scanning Electron Microscopy in Materials Research (Wetzig, K. and Schulze, D., eds.) 109–125. (Akademie Verlag, Berlin). Edelmann, L. and Roomans, G.M. (eds.) (1990). The Science of Biological Specimen Preparations for Microscopy and Microanalysis, vol 5, Chicago: Scanning Microscopy International. Egerton, R.F. (1986). Electron-Energy-Loss Spectroscopy in the Electron Microscope. (Plenum, New York). Egerton, R.F. (1989). Electron-Energy-Loss Spectroscopy in the Electron Microscope. 2nd ed. (Plenum, New York). Egerton, R.F. (1999). Ultramicroscopy 80, 247. Egerton, R.F., Crozier, P.A. and Rice, P. (1987). Ultramicroscopy 23, 305. Egerton, R.F., Li, P. and Malac, M. (2004). Micron 35, 399. Engel, A. (1978). Ultramicroscopy 3, 273. Engel, A. (1983). In Microscopie Électronique en Science des Matériaux Bombannes (Jouffrey, B., Bourret, A. and Colliex, C., eds.) 185–192. (Éditions du CNRS, Toulouse). Erlandsen, S.L., Nelson, R.D., Hasslen, S.R., Dunney, G.M., Olmsted, S.B., Frethem, C. and Wells, C.L. (1995). Hitachi Instrum News 27, 10. Everhart, T.E. and Hoff, P.H. (1971). J Appl Phys 42, 5837. Everhart, T.E. and Thornley, R.F.M. (1960). J Sci Instrum 37, 246. Everhart, T.E., Wells, O.C. and Oatley, C.W. (1959). J Electron Control 7, 97. Fathers, D.J., Jacubovics, J.P., Joy, D.C., Newbury, D.E. and Yakowitz, H. (1973). Phys Stat Sol (a) 20, 535. Feder, N. and Sidman, R.L. (1958). J Biophys Biochem Cytol 4, 593. Feja, B., Dürrenberger, M., Müller, S., Reichelt, R. and Aebi, U. (1997). J Struct Biol 119, 72. Flindt, R. (2000). Biologie in Zahlen, 5th ed. (Spektrum Akademischer Verlag, Berlin). Fourie, J.T. (1979). Scann Electr Microsc 2, 87. Frank, J. (1980). In Computer Processing of Electron Microscope Images (Hawkes, P.W., ed.) 187–222. (Springer, New York).
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy Frank, J., Bussler, P., Langer, R. and Hoppe, W. (1970). Ber Bunsengesellsch Phys Chem 74, 1105. Frosien, J., Plies, E. and Anger, K. (1989). J Vac Sci Techn B 7, 1874. Fruhstorfer, B., Mohles, V., Reichelt, R. and Nembach, E. (2002). Phil Mag A 82, 2575. Fujioka, H. and Ura, K. (1981). Appl Phys Lett 39, 81. Fujita, T., Tokunaga, M.D.J. and Inoue, H. (1971). Atlas of Scanning Electron Microscopy in Medicine. (Elsevier, Amsterdam). Galca, A.C., Kooij, E.S., Wormeester, H., Salm, C., Leca, V., Rector, J.H. and Poelsema, B. (2003). J Appl Phys 94, 4296. Gamliel, H. and Polliack, A. (1983). Scann Electr Microsc 2, 929. Georges, A., Fournier, J.M. and Bois, D. (1982). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 147. Gerber, C., Binnig, G., Fuchs, H., Marti, O. and Rohrer, H. (1986). Rev Sci Instrum 57, 221. Giannuzzi, L.A. and Stevie, F.A. (2005). Introduction to Focused Ion Beams: Instrumentation, Theory, Techniques and Practice. (Springer, New York). Girard, P. (1991). J Phys IV C6, 259. Glaser, W. (1952). Grundlagen der Elektronenoptik. Wien: Springer. Glauert, A.M. (ed.) (1973). Practical Methods in Electron Microscopy. (NorthHolland Publishing Comp., Amsterdam). Gnauck, P., Hoffrogge, P. and Greiser, J. (2003a). Eur Microsc Anal 82, 7. Gnauck, P., Zeile, U., Rau, W. and Schuhmann, M. (2003b). Microsc Microanal 9 (Suppl 3), 524. Goldstein, J. and Yakowitz, H. (1975). Practical Scanning Electron Microscopy. (Plenum, New York). Goldstein, J.J., Newbury, D.E., Echlin, P., Joy, D.C., Fiori, C. and Lifshin. E. (1984). Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-Ray Microanalysis. A Text for Biologists Material Scientists and Geologists. (Plenum, New York). Goldstein, J.J., Newbury, D.E., Joy, D.C., Lyman, C.E., Echlin, P., Lifshin, E., Sawyer, L.C. and Michael, J.R. (2003). Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-Ray Microanalysis. (Kluwer Academic/Plenum, New York). González, G., Stracke, W., Lopez, Z., Keller, U., Ricker, A. and Reichelt, R. (2004). Microsc Microanal 10, 224. Goudsmit, S.A. and Saunderson, J.L. (1940). Phys Rev 58, 36. Grasenick, F., Aldrian, A., Bauer, R., Bangert, H., Essl, R., Haefer, R.H., Hagemann, P., Hermann, K.-H., Hörl. E.M., Karnthaler, P., Knapek, E., Nobiling, R., Peters, K.-R. and Weber, G. (1991). Elektronenmikroskopie. Erweiterte Einsatzmöglichkeiten und spezielle Abbildungs- und Präparationsmethoden. Ehningen bei Böblingen: Expert Verlag. Griffith, G. (1993). Fine Structure Immunocytochemistry. (Springer, Berlin). Grivet, P. (1972). Electron Optics. (Pergamon Press, Oxford). Gross, H., Müller, T., Wildhaber, I. and Winkler, H. (1985). Ultramicroscopy 16, 287. Grote, M., Reichelt, R. and Wiermann, R. (1999a) Micron 30, 65. Grote, M., Hayek, B., Reichelt, R., Kraft, D. and Valenta, R. (1999b) Int Arch Allergy Immunol 120, 287. Grote, M., Mahler, V., Spitzauer, S., Fuchs, T., Valenta, R. and Reichelt, R. (2000). J Allergy Clin Immunol 105, 561. Grün, A.E. (1957). Zeit Naturforsch 12a, 89. Hauffe, W. (1971). Phys Stat Sol (a) 4, 111. Hauffe, W. (1990). Beitr Elektronenmikr Direktabb Analyse Oberfl 23, 305. Hauffe, W. (1995). In In Situ Scanning Electron Microscopy in Materials Research (Wetzig, K. and Schulze, D., eds.) 195–218. (Akademie Verlag, Berlin). Hauffe, W., Pannicke, S., Däbritz, S. and Schade, P. (2002). Surf Interface Anal 34, 768.
261
262
R. Reichelt Hayat, M.A. (ed.). (1974–1976). Principles and Techniques of Scanning Electron Microscopy. Vol. 1–6. (Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York). Hayat, M.A. (ed.). (1978). Principles and Techniques of Biological Scanning Electron Microscopy. (University Park Press, Baltimore). Hayat, M.A. (ed.) (1989/91). Colloidal Gold. Principles, Methods, and Applications, vol 1–3. (Academic Press, London). Hayat, M.A. (ed.) (2002). Microscopy, Immunohistochemistry, and Antigen Retrieval Methods: For Light and Electron Microscopy. (Kluwer Academic/Plenum, New York). Heiderhoff, R., Sergeev, O.V., Liu, Y.Y., Phang, J.C.H. and Balk, L.J. (2000). J Cryst Growth 210, 303. Heinrich, K.F.J. (1966). In Fourth International Congress on X-Ray Optics and Microanalysis (Castaing, R., Deschamps, P. and Philibert, J., eds.) 159–167. (Hermann, Paris). Heinrich, K.F.J. (1982). Microbeam Analysis. (San Francisco Press, San Francisco). Heinrich, K.F.J. and Newbury, D.E. (eds.) (1991). Electron Probe Quantification. (Plenum, New York). Hejna, J. and Reimer, L. (1987). Scann 9, 162. Hermann, R. and Müller, M. (1993). Scann Microsc 7, 343. Hermann, R., Pawley, J., Nagatani, T. and Müller, M. (1988). Scann Microsc 2, 1215. Hermann, R., Schwarz, H. and Müller, M. (1991). J Struct Biol 107, 38. Hernandez-Lopez, J.L., Bauer, R.E., Chang, W.S., Glasser, G., Grebel-Koehler, D., Klapper, M., Kreiter, M., Leclaire, J., Majoral, J.P., Mittler, S., Mullen, K., Vasilev, K., Weil, T., Wu, J., Zhu, T. and Knoll, W. (2003). Mater Sci Eng C 23, 267. Hess, M.W. (2003). J Microsc 212, 44. Hesse, D. and Meyer, K.-P. (1982). In Elektronenmikroskopie in der Festkörperphysik (Bethge, H. and Heydenreich, J. eds.) 473–507. (VEB Deutscher Verlag der Wissenschaften, Berlin). Heywood, V.H. (1971). Scanning Electron Microscopy. Systematic and Evolutionary Applications. (Academic Press, London). Hicks, D. and Molday, R.S. (1984). In The Science of Biological Specimen Preparation for Microscopy and Microanalysis (Johari, O., ed.) 203–220. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Hindermann, D.K. and Davis, R.H. (1974). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 183. Hirsch, P., Kässens, M., Reimer, L., Senkel, R. and Spranck, M. (1993). Ultramicroscopy 50, 263. Hitachi (2001). Technical Data. Sheet No. 98, HTD-E050-01 2001.11. Holt, D.B. (1974). In Quantitative Scanning Electron Microscopy (Holt, D.B., Muir, M.D., Grant, P.R. and Boswarva, I.M., eds.) 213–286. (Academic Press, London). Holt, D.B. (1989). In SEM Characterization of Semiconductors (Holt, D.B. and Joy, D.C., eds.) 241–338. (Academic Press, London). Holt, D.B. and Saba, F.M. (1985). Scann Electr Microsc 3, 1023. Holt, D.B. and Yacobi, B.G. (1989). In SEM Microcharacterization of Semiconductors (Holt, D.B. and Joy, D.C., eds.) vol 12. London: Academic Press. Holt, D.B., Muir, M.D., Grant, P.R. and Boswarva, I.M. (eds.) (1974). Quantitative Scanning Electron Microscopy. (Academic Press, London). Holzer, L., Indutnyi, F., Gasser, P.H., Munch, B. and Wegmann, M. (2004). J Microsc 216, 84. Hörl, E.M. (1972). Micron 3, 540. Hörl, E.M. (1975). Beitr Elektronenmikroskop Direktabb Analyse Oberfl (BEDO) 8, 369.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy Hosokawa, T., Fujioka, H. and Ura, K. (1978). Rev Sci Instrum 49, 624. Hovington, P., Drouin, D. and Gauvin, R. (1997a). Scann 19, 1. Hovington, P., Drouin, D., Gauvin, R., Joy, D.C. and Evans, N. (1997b). Scann 19, 29. Hu, Y. and Pan, Y. (2001). X-Ray Spectrom 30, 110. Huang, L.M., Cui, X.D., Dukovic, G. and O’Brien, S.P. (2004). Nanotechnology 15, 1450. Huebener, R.P. (1988). In Advances in Electronics and Electron Physics, vol 70 (Hawkes, P.W., ed.) 1–78. (Academic Press, New York). Hunger, H.-J. and Küchler, L. (1979). Phys Stat Sol 56, K45. Inokuti, M. and Manson, S.T. (1984). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 1–17. (Scann Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Isaacson, M. (1979a). Ultramicroscopy 4, 193. Isaacson, M. (1979b). Ultramicroscopy 4, 97. Isaacson, M. and Langmore, J.P. (1974). Optik 41, 92. Isaacson, M.S. (1977). In Principles and Techniques of Electron Microscopy, vol 7 (Hayat, M.A., ed.) 1–78. (Van-Nostrand Reinhold, New York). Isabell, T.C., Fischione, P.E., O’Keefe, C., Guruz, M.U. and Dravid, V.P. (1999). Microsc Microanal 5, 126. Ishikawa, A., Mizuno, F., Uchikawa, Y. and Maruse, S. (1973). Jpn J Appl Phys 12, 286. Ishikawa, H., Dobashi, H., Kodama, T., Furuhashi, T. and Uchikawa, Y. (1993). J Electr Microsc 42, 35. Ishitani, T. and Yaguchi, T. (1996). Microsc Res Techn 35, 320. Jablonski, A., Salvat, F. and Powell, C.J. (2003). NIST Electron Elastic-Scattering Cross Section Datbase #64 Version 3.1. (National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD). Jacka, M. (2001). J Electr Spectrosc Rel Phenom 114–116, 277. Ji, Y., Guo, H.S., Zhong, T.X., Zhang, H., Quan, X.L., Zhang, Y.Q. and Xu, X.D. (2005). Ultramicroscopy, 103, 191. Joachimsthaler, I., Heiderhoff, R. and Balk, L.J. (2003). Measure Sci Technol 14, 87. Johari, O. (ed.) (1968). Proceedings of the Annual Scanning Electron Microscopy Symposium. Annual Conferences since 1968. (IIT Research Institute; since 1987 Scanning Microscopy. Scanning Microsc. Intl., Chicago). Jonker, J.L.H. (1957). Philips Res Rep 12, 249. Joy, D.C. (1984). In Microbeam Analysis (Romig, A.D. Jr. and Goldstein, J.I., eds.) 81–86. (San Francisco Press, San Francisco). Joy, D.C. (1987a). In Electron Microscopy Microanalysis, vol 90 (Chapman, J.N. and Craven, A.J., eds.) 175–180. Bristol: Institute of Physics Conf Series. Joy D.C. (1987b). J Microsc 147, 51. Joy D.C. (1989). Scann 11, 1. Joy D.C. (1991). J Microsc 161, 343. Joy D.C. (1995). Monte Carlo Modeling for Electron Microscopy and Microanalysis. (Oxford University Press, New York). Joy D.C. (2001). A Data Base on Electron-Solid Interactions. This compilation is © David C Joy. Joy D.C. (2002). J Microsc 208, 24. Joy D.C. and Luo, S. (1989). Scann 11, 176. Joy D.C. Newbury, D.E. and Davidson, D.L. (1982). J Appl Phys 53, R81. Judge, A.W. (1950). Stereographic Photography. (Chapman and Hall, London). Judge, F.J., Stubbs, J.M. and Philp, J. (1974). J Phys E 7, 173.
263
264
R. Reichelt Kaczmarek, D. (1997). Scann 19, 310. Kaczmarek, D. and Domaradzki, J. (2002). Scann 24, 65. Kanaya, K. and Kayama, S.O. (1972). J Appl Phys 5, 43. Kanaya, K. and Ono, S. (1984). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 69–98. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Katrakova, D. and Mucklich, F. (2002). Prakt Metallogr 39, 644. Kazumori, H. (2002). JEOL News 37E, 44. Kazumori, H,. Honda, K., Matuya, M. and Date, M. (2004). In 8th Asia-Pacific Conference on Electron Microscopy (8APEM Publication Committee, ed.) 52– 53. (Yoshida Printing Inc., Kanazawa). Kellenberger, E. and Kistler, J. (1979). In Advances in Structure Research by Diffraction Methods, vol 3 (Hoppe, W. and Mason, R., eds.) 49–79. (Friedrich Vieweg, Wiesbaden). Kellenberger, E., Häner, M. and Wurtz, M. (1982). Ultramicroscopy 9, 139. Kellenberger, E., Johansen, R., Maeder, M., Bohrmann, B., Stauffer, E. and Villiger, W. (1992). J Microsc 168, 181. Keller, D.J. and Chih-Chung, C. (1992). Surf Sci 268, 333. Khamsehpour, B. and Davies, S.T. (2004). Vacuum 45, 1169. Khursheed, A. (2000). Rev Sci Instrum 71, 1712. Khursheed, A. and Osterberg, M. (2004). Scann 26, 296. Khursheed, A. Phang, J.C. and Thong, J.T.L. (1998). Scann 20, 87. Kimoto, S., Hashimoto, H. and Suganama, T. (1966). In The Electron Microprobe (McKinley, T.D., Heinrich, K.F.J.H. and Wittrey, D.B., eds.) 480–489. (John Wiley, New York). Kirk, E.C.G., McMahon, R.A., Cleaver, J.R.A. and Ahmed, H. (1988). J Vac Sci Technol B 6, 1940. Kirschner, J. (1976). In Scanning Electron Microscopy, vol. 1 (Johari, O., ed.) 215–220. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Kitching, S. and Donald, A.M. (1996). In 11th Europ Conf Electron Microscopy, vol 1 (Comm. Europ. Soc. Microscopy, ed.) 138–139. Dublin: Comm. Europ. Soc. Microscopy. Klemperer, O. (1971). Electron Optics. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Knoll, M. (1935). Zeit Techn Phys 11, 467. Koblischka, M.R. and Koblischka-Veneva, A. (2003). Phys C-Superconduct Appl 392, 545. Koike, H., Ueno, K. and Watanabe, N. (1970). In Proceedings of the 7th International Congress on Electron Microscopy, vol 1 (Favard, P., ed.) 241–242. (Societe Française de Microscopie Electronique, Grenoble). Kolarik, R. and Lenc, M. (1997). Optik 106, 135. Kollath, R. (1956). In Handbuch der Physik, vol XXI (Flügge, S., ed.) 232–302. (Springer, Berlin). Kowalewski, E., Boassen, T. and Torsaeter, O. (2003). J Petrol Sci Eng 39, 377. Kramers, H.A. (1923). Phil Mag 46, 836. Krieger-Lassen, N.C., Juul-Jensen, D. and Conradsen, K. (1992). Scann Microsc 6, 115. Kruit, P. (1991). In Advances in Optical and Electron Microscopy, vol 12 (Mulvey, T. and Sheppard, C.J.R., eds.) 93–137. (Academic Press, London). Krzyzanek, V. and Reichelt, R. (2003). Microsc Microanal 9 (Suppl 3), 110. Krzyzanek, V., Nüsse, H. and Reichelt, R. (2004). In Proc 13th Europ Microscopy Cong, vol 1 (van Dyck, D. and van Oostveldt, P., eds.) 391–392. (Belgian Society for Microscopy, Antwerp). Kultscher, N. and Balk, L.J. (1986). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 33.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy Kyser, D.F. (1984). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 119–135. Chicago: Scanning Electron Microscopy, Inc. Lamvik, M.K. (1977). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 401. Lawson, L. (1995). Scann 17, 322. Lax, E. (ed.) (1967). D’ans. Lax. Taschenbuch für Chemiker und Physiker. (Springer, Berlin). Leamy, H.J. (1982). J Appl Phys 53, R51. Leapman, R.D., Rez, P. and Mayers, D.F. (1980). J Chem Phys 72, 1232. Lebiedzik, J. (1979). Scann 2, 230. Lechner, P., Fiorini, C., Hartmann, R., Kemmer, J., Krause, N., Leutenegger, P., Longoni, A., Soltau, H., Stotter, D., Stotter, R., Strüder, L. and Weber, U. (2001). Nucl Instrum Methods Phys Res Sect A 458, 281. Lencová, B. (1997). In Handbook of Charged Particle Optics (Orloff, J., ed.) 177–221. (CRC Press, New York). Lencová, B. and Lenc, M. (1994). Optik 97, 121. Lian, J.S., Dong, Q.Z., Guo, Z.X., Xu, Q., Yang, J., Hu, J.D., Guan, Q.F. and Chen, B. (2005). Mater Sci Eng A 391, 210. Liu, W., Ambe, T. and Pease, R.F. (1996). J Vac Sci Technol B 14, 3738. Liukkonen, A. (1997). Scann 19, 411. Lödding, B. and Reimer, L. (1981). Beitr Elektronenmikr Direktabb Analyse Oberfl (BEDO) 14, 315. Lukianov, A.E., Spivak, G.V., Rau, E.I. and Gorodsky, D.D. (1972). In Proc 5th Europ Congr Electron Microscopy (Cosslett, V.E., ed.) 186–187. (The Institute of Physics, London). Lyman, C.E., Newbury, D.E., Goldstein, J.I., Williams, D.B., Romig, A.D., Armstrong, J.T., Echlin, P., Fiori, C.E., Joy, D.C., Lifshin, E. and Peters, K.-R. (1990). Scanning Electron Microscopy, X-Ray Microanalysis and Analytical Electron Microscopy. (Plenum, New York). Madden, H.H. (1981). J Vac Sci Technol 18, 677. Madl, K., Toth, A.L. and Barna, A. (1988). Inst Phys Conf Ser 93, 65. Malecki, M. and Roomans, G.M. (eds.) (1996). The Science of Biological Specimen Preparations for Microscopy. (Scanning Microscopy International, Chicago). Malkusch, W., Konerding, M.A., Klapthor, B. and Bruch, J. (1995). Anal Cell Pathol 9, 69. Martin, J.P., Weimer, E., Frosien, J. and Lanio, S. (1994). Eur Microsc Analysis 28, 43. Matzelle, T.R., Kruse, N. and Reichelt, R. (2000). J Microsc 199, 239. Matzelle, T.R., Ivanov, D., Landwehr, D., Heinrich, L.A., Herkt-Bruns, C., Reichelt, R. and Kruse, N. (2002). J Phys Chem B 106, 2861. Matzelle, T.R., Gnaegi, H., Ricker, A. and Reichelt, R. (2003). J Microsc 209, 113. Mauler, A., Godard, G. and Kunze, K. (2001). Tectonophysics 342, 81. McGuinness, P.E. (2003). Scann 25, 221. McKenzie, J.M. and Bromely, D.A. (1959). Phys Rev Lett 2, 303. McKinney, W.R. and Hough, P.V.C. (1977). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 251. Menzel, S. and Wetzig, K. (1992). J Mat Sci: Mat Electron 3, 5. Milani, M., Pucillo, F.P., Ballerini, M., Camatini, M., Gualtieri, M. and Martino, S. (2004). Mat Character 52, 283. Minnich, B. and Lametschwandtner, A. (2000). Scann 22, 173. Minnich, B., Leeb, H., Bernroider, E.W.N. and Lametschwandtner, A. (1999). J Microsc 195, 23. Minnich, B., Krautgartner, W.-D. and Lametschwandtner, A. (2003). Microsc Microanal 9 (Suppl. 3), 118.
265
266
R. Reichelt Molday, R.S. and Maher, P. (1980). Histochem J 12, 273. Muir, M.D. and Grant, P.R. (1974). In Quantitative Electron Microscopy (Holt, D.B., Muir, M.D., Grant, P.R. and Boswarva, I.M., eds.) 287–334. (Academic Press, London). Müller, D.A. and Silcox, J. (1994). In 13th Intern Congr Electron Microscopy, vol 1. (Jouffrey, B. and Colliex, C., eds.) 741–742. (Les Editions de Physique Les Ulis, Paris). Müller, D.A. and Silcox, J. (1995). Ultramicroscopy 59, 195. Müller, M. (ed.) (1985). The Science of Biological Specimen Preparations for Microscopy and Microanalysis. (Scanning Microscopy International, Chicago). Müller, M. and Hermann, R. (1990). Hitachi Instr News 19, 50. Müller, M. and Hermann, R. (1992). In 10th Europ Congr Electron Microsc, vol 3. (Megías-Megías, L., Rodríguez-García, M.I., Ríos, A. and Arias, J.M., eds.) 741–742. (Secretariado de Publicaciones de la Universidad de Granada, Granada). Müller, S.A. and Engel, A. (2001). Micron 32, 21. Müller, T., Walther, P., Scheidegger, C., Reichelt, R., Müller, S. and Guggenheim, R. (1990). Scann Micr 4, 863. Müllerová, I. (2001). Scann 23, 379. Müllerová, I. and Frank, L. (2003). In Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics (Hawkes, P.W., ed.) 310–443. (Academic Press, Amsterdam). Müllerová, I. and Lenc, M. (1992). Mikrochim Acta 12 (Suppl), 173. Müllerová, I., Lenc, M. and Florián, M. (1989). Scann Micr 3, 419. Müllerová, I., Frank, L. and Hutar, O. (2001). Scann 23, 115. Mulvey, T. (1974). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 43. Munro, E., Orloff, J., Rutherford, R. and Wallmark, J. (1988). J Vac Sci Technol B 6, 1971. Murata, K. (1974). J Appl Phys 45, 4110. Murata, K. (1984). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 311–329. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Nagase, M. and Kurihara, K. (2000). Microelectron Engin 53, 57. Nagase, M. and Namatsu, H. (2004). Jpn J Appl Phys Part 1 43, 4624. Nagatani, T. and Saito, S. (1989). Inst Phys Conf Ser No 98, 519. Nembach, E. (1996). Particle Strengthening of Metals and Alloys. (Wiley, New York). Newbury, D., Wollman, D., Irwin, K., Hilton, G. and Martinis, J. (1999). Ultramicroscopy 78, 73. Newbury, D.E. (1976). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 111. Newbury, D.E. and Bright, D.S. (2005). Scann 27, 15. Newbury, D.E., Joy, D.C., Echlin, P., Fiori, C.E. and Goldstein, J.I. (1987). Advanced Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-Ray Microanalysis. (Plenum, New York). Oatley, C.W. (1972). The Scanning Electron Microscope—Part 1: The Instrument. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Oatley, C.W. and Everhart, T.E. (1957). J Electron 2, 568. Ohnsorge, J. and Holm, R. (1973). Rasterelektronenmikroskopie—Eine Einführung für Mediziner und Biologen. Stuttgart: Georg Thieme Publishers. Oho, E. and Miyamoto, M. (2004). Scann 26, 250. Oho, E., Sasaki, T., Adachi, K., Muranaka, Y. and Kanaya, K. (1986). In 11th International Congress on Electron Microscopy, vol 1. (T. Imura, S. Maruse and T. Suzuki, eds.) 421–422. Kyoto: Japanese Society of Electron Microscopy. Ono, S. and Kanaya, K. (1979). J Phys D: Appl Phys 12, 619. Oppel, W. and Jahrreiss, H. (1972). Zeit Phys 252, 107.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy Paden, R.S. and Nixon, W.C. (1968). J Phys E 2, 1073. Palmberg, P.W. (1973). Anal Chem 45, 549A. Pan, H., Gao, H., Lim, S.H., Feng, Y.P. and Lin, J. (2004). J Nanosci Nanotechnol 4, 1014. Peng, L.-M., Chen, Q., Liang, X.L., Gao, S., Wang, J.Y., Kleindiek, S. and Tai, S.W. (2004). Micron 35, 495. Perovic, D.D., Castell, M.R., Howie, A., Lavoie, C., Tiedje, T. and Cole, J.S.W. (1994). In 13th International Congress on Electron Microscopy, vol 1 (Jouffrey, B. and Colliex, C., eds.) 91–92. (Les Editions de Physique Les Ulis, Paris). Peters, K.-R. (1980). Scann Electr Microsc I, 143. Peters, K.-R. (1982). Scann Electr Microsc 4, 1359. Peters, K.-R. (1984). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 363–372. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Pfefferkorn, G. (ed.) (1968). Beiträge zur elektronenmikroskopischen Direktabbildung und Analyse von Oberflächen (BEDO) (Engl.: Proceedings of Direct Electron Microscopic Imaging and Analysis of Surfaces). Annual Conferences since 1968 (vol 1) until 1995 (vol 28). (R.A. Remy, Münster). Pfefferkorn, G. and Pfautsch, M. (1971). Beitr Elektronenmikr Direktabb Analyse Oberfl (BEDO) 4, 137. Philibert, J. and Tixier, R. (1969). Micron 1, 174. Plows, G.S. and Nixon, W.C. (1968). J Phys E 1, 595. Poelt, P. (2000). Mikrochim Acta 132, 129. Poelt, P., Schmied, M., Obernberger, I., Brunner, T. and Dahl, J. (2002). Scann 24, 92. Polak, J.M. and Varndell, J.M. (eds.) (1984). Immunolabelling for Electron Microscopy. (Elsevier Science Publ., Amsterdam). Postek, M.T. (1996). Scann 18, 269. Postek, M.T. and Keery, W.J. (1990). Rev Sci Instrum 61, 1648. Postek, M.T. and Vladár, A.E. (1996). Scann 18, 1. Powell, C.J. (1984). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 19–31. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Powell, C.J. and Jablonski, A. (2000). NIST Standard Reference Database #71 Electron Inelastic-Mean-Free-Path Database Version 1.1. (National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD). Prior, D.J., Boyle, A.P., Brenker, F., Cheadle, M.C., Day, A., Lopez, G., Peruzzo, L., Potts, G.J., Reddy, S., Spiess, R., Timms, N.E., Trimby, P., Wheeler, J. and Zeterstrom, L. (1999). Am Mineral 84, 1741. Raether, H. (1980). In Springer Tracts in Modern Physics, vol 88. (Höhler, G., ed.). (Springer, Berlin). Rappaport, P. (1954). Phys Rev 93, 246. Rasul, A. and Davidson, S.M. (1977). Scann Electr Microsc I, 233. Rau, E.I., Sennov, R.A., Chan, D.S.H. and Phang, J.C.H. (2004). In Proc 13th Europ Congr Microscopy, vol 1 (Timmermans, J.-P., Schryvers, D., van Dyck, D. and van Oostveldt, P., eds.) 411–412. (Belgian Society for Microscopy, Liège). Read, N.D. and Jeffree, C.E. (1990). J Microsc 161, 59. Reed, S.J.B. (1996). Electron Microprobe Analysis and Scanning Electron Microscopy in Geology. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Reichelt, R. (1995). In Mikroskopie in Forschung und Praxis (Robenek, H., ed.) 185–217. (GIT Verlag, Darmstadt). Reichelt, R. (1997). Unpublished results. Reichelt, R. and Engel, A. (1984). Ultramicroscopy 13, 279.
267
268
R. Reichelt Reichelt, R. and Engel, A. (1985). J Microsc Spectrosc Electr 10, 491. Reichelt, R. and Engel, A. (1986). Ultramicroscopy 19, 43. Reichelt, R., Carlemalm, E., Villiger, W. and Engel, A. (1985). Ultramicroscopy 16, 69. Reichelt, R. and Engel, A. and Aebi, U. (1988). In Proc 9th Europ Cong Electron Microscopy, vol 1 (Dickinson, H.G. and Goodhew, P.J., eds.) 33–34. (IOP Publishing, York). Reid, N. and Beesely, J.E. (1991). Sectioning and Cryosectioning for Electron Microscopy, vol 13, (Elsevier Science Publ., Amsterdam). Reimer, L. (1967). Elektronenmikroskopische Untersuchungs- und Präparationsmethoden, 2nd ed. (Springer, Berlin). Reimer, L. (1968). Optik 27, 86. Reimer, L. (1978). Scann 1, 3. Reimer, L. (1984a). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 299–310. (SEM, Chicago). Reimer, L. (1984b). Ultramicroscopy 14, 291. Reimer, L. (1985). Scanning Electron Microscopy. (Springer, Berlin). Reimer, L. (1993). Image Formation in Low-Voltage Scanning Electron Microscopy, vol TT12. (O’Shea, D.C., ed.). (SPIE Optical Engineering Press, Bellingham & Washington). Reimer, L. (1996). Beitr Elektronenmikroskop Direktabb Analyse Oberfl (BEDO) 29, 1. Reimer, L. (1998). Scanning Electron Microscopy, 2nd ed. (Springer, Berlin). Reimer, L. and Krefting, E.-R. (1976). In NBS Spec Publ 460 (Heinrich, K.F.J., Newbury, D.E. and Yakowitz, H., eds.) 45–60. (U.S. Department of Commerce, Washington, DC). Reimer, L. and Lödding, B. (1984). Scann 6, 128. Reimer, L. and Pfefferkorn, G. (1973). Raster-Elektronenmikroskopie. (Springer, Berlin). Reimer, L. and Pfefferkorn, G. (1977). Raster-Elektronenmikroskopie. (Springer, Berlin). Reimer, L. and Schmidt, A. (1985). Scann 7, 47. Reimer, L. and Stelter, D. (1986). Scann 8, 265. Reimer, L. and Tollkamp, C. (1980). Scann 3, 35. Reimer, L., Badde, H.G. and Seidel, H. (1971). Zeit Angew Phys 31, 145. Reimer, L., Riepenhausen, N. and Tollkamp, C. (1984). Scann 6, 155. Reuter, W. (1972). In Sixth Intern Cong on X-ray Optics and Microanalysis (Shinoda, G., Kohra, K. and Ichinokawa, T., eds.) 121–130. (University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo). Revel, J.-P., Haggis, G.H. and Barnard, T. (eds.) (1983). The Science of Biological Specimen Preparation for Microscopy and Microanalysis. (Scann Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Rez, P. (1984). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 43–49. (SEM, Chicago). Rickerby, D.G. and Thiot, J.-F. (1994). Mikrochim Acta 114/115, 421. Rickerby, D.G., Wächter, N. and Reichelt, R. (1998). Mikrochim Acta Suppl 15, 149. Ris, H. and Malecki, M. (1993). J Struct Biol 111, 148. Robards, A.W. and Sleytr, U.B. (1985). Low Temperature Methods in Biological Electron Microscopy, vol 10. (North-Holland, Amsterdam). Robards, A.W. and Wilson, A.J. (eds.) (1993). Procedures in Electron Microscopy. (John Wiley, Chichester).
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy Robertson, K., Gauvin, R. and Finch, J. (2004). Microsc Microanal 10, 721. Robin, M. (2001). Oil Gas Sci Technol—Revue Institut Francais Petrole 56, 55. Robinson, V.N.E. (1975). J Phys E 8, 638. Robinson, V.N.E. (1990). Hitachi Instrum News 19, 32. Roshchupkin, D.V. and Brunel, M. (1993). Scann Microsc 7, 543. Rossi, M.P., Ye, H.H., Gogotsi, Y., Babu, S., Ndungu, P. and Bradley, J.C. (2004). Nano Lett 4, 989. Royall, C.P., Thiel, B.L. and Donald, A.M. (2001). J Microsc 204, 185. Rukosujew, A., Reichelt, R., Fabricius, A.M., Drees, G., Tjan, T.T.D., Rothenburger, M., Hoffmeier, A., Scheld, H.H. and Schmid, C. (2004). Ann Thorac Surg 77, 120. Ruska, E. (1979). Die frühe Entwicklung der Elektronenlinsen und der Elektronenmikroskopie. (Deutsche Akademie der Naturforscher Leopoldina, Halle). Russel, P.E. and Mancuso, J.F. (1985). J Microsc 140, 323. Salih, S.M. and Cosslett, V.E. (1974). Phil Mag 30, 225. Sato, M., Kageyama, K. and Nakagawa, M. (2000). Hitachi Intrum News 36, 9. Sawyer, L.C. and Grubb, D.T. (1996). Polymer Microscopy. (Chapman & Hall, London). Schauer, P. and Autrata, R. (2004). In 13th Europ Congr Microscopy, vol 1 (Schryvers, D., Timmermans, J.-P., van Dyck, D. and van Oostveldt, eds.) 69–70. (Belgian Society for Microscopy, Liège). Schenk, M., Füting, M. and Reichelt, R. (1998). J Appl Phys 84, 4880. Schimmel, G. and Vogell, W. (1970). Methodensammlung der Elektronenmikroskopie. vol 1 and 2. (Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft mbH, Stuttgart). Schmid, R., Gaukler, K.H. and Seiler, H. (1983). Scann Electr Microsc 2, 501. Schwartz, A.J., Kumar, M. and Adams, B.L. (eds.) (2000). Electron Backscatter Diffraction in Materials Science. (Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publ., New York). Schwarzer, R.A. (1997). Micron 28, 249. Seah, M.P. and Dench, W.A. (1979). Surf Interface Anal 1, 2. Seiler, H. (1967). Zeit Angew Phys 22, 249. Seiler, H. (1968). Beitr Elektronenmikr Direktabb Analyse Oberfl (BEDO) 1, 27. Seiler, H. (1976). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 9. Seiler, H. (1984). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 33–42. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Seiler, H. and Kuhnle, G. (1970). Zeit Angew Phys 29, 254. Sekiguchi, T. and Sumino, K. (1995). Rev Sci Instrum 66, 4277. Sennhauser, U., Jacob, P. and Gasser, P. (2004). Pract Metallogr 41, 199. Severs, N.J. and Shotton, D.M. (eds.) (1995). Rapid Freezing, Freeze Fracture and Deep Etching. (John Wiley, Chichester). Shea, S.P. (1984). In Electron Beam Interactions with Solids for Microscopy, Microanalysis & Microlithography (Kyser, D.F., Niedrig, H., Newbury, D.E. and Shimizu, R., eds.) 145–151. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Shea, S.P., Partain, L.D. and Warter, P.J. (1978). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 435. Shibata, M. (2004). JEOL News 39, 28. Shibata, Y., Arima, T. and Yamamoto, T. (1984). J Microsc 136, 121. Siangchaew, K. and Libera, M. (2000). Phil Mag A 80, 1001. Siegel, B.M. and Beaman, D.R. (1975). Physical Aspects of Electron Microscopy and Microbeam Analysis. (John Wiley, New York). Simmons, S.R., Pawley, J.B. and Albrecht, R.M. (1990). J Histochem Cytochem 38, 1781.
269
270
R. Reichelt Sitte, H. (1984). In The Science of Biological Specimen Preparation for Microscopy and Microanalysis (Johari, O., ed.) 97–104. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Sitte, H. (1996). In The Science of Biological Specimen Preparation for Microscopy and Microanalysis (Malecki, M. and Roomans, G.M., eds.) 387–466. (Scanning Microscopy International, Chicago). Smith, G.C., Park, D. and Cochonneau, O. (1995). J Microsc 178, 48. Spivak, G.V. (1996). Izv Akad Nauk SSSR, Ser Fiz 30, 749. Steinbrecht, R.A. and Zierold, K. (eds.) (1987). Cryotechniques in Biological Electron Microscopy. (Springer, Berlin). Stelmashenko, N.A., Craven, J.P., Donald, A.M., Terentjev, E.M. and Thiel, B.L. (2001). J Microsc 204, 172. Stemmer, A., Reichelt, R. Wyss, R. and Engel, A. (1991). Ultramicrosc 35, 255. Stephen, J., Smith, B.J., Marshall, D.C. and Wittam, E.M. (1975). J Phys E 8, 607. Stephenson, S.T. (1957). In Handbuch der Physik, vol 30 (Flügge, S., ed.) 337–370. (Springer, Berlin). Stintzing, H. (1927). Verfahren und Einrichtung zum automatischen Nachweis, Messung und Zählung von Einzelteilchen beliebiger Art, Form und Grösse. German Patent No. 485155, patent applied for on 14-06-1927, patent granted on 10-10-1929. Stracke, W., González, G., Keller, U., González, S., Ricker, A. and Reichelt, R. (2003) Microsc Microanal 9(Suppl 3), 126. Strane, J., Marks, L.D., Luzzi, D.E., Buckett, M.I., Zhang, J.P. and Wessels, B.W. (1988). Ultramicroscopy 25, 253. Strüder, L., Lechner, P. and Leutenegger, P. (1998a). Naturwissenschaften 85, 539. Strüder, L., Meidinger, N., Stotter, D., Kemmer, J., Lechner, P., Leutenegger, P., Soltau, H., Eggert, F., Rohde, M. and Schulein, T. (1998b). Microsc Microanal 4, 622. Sudraud, P., Ballongue, P., Varoquaux, E. and Avenel, O. (1987). J Appl Phys 62, 2163. Szmaja, V. (2002). Czechoslovak J Phys 52, A145. Szmaja, W. (2000). J Magnet Magnet Mater 219, 281. Tang, X. and Joy, D.C. (2003). Scann 25, 194. Thiberge, S., Nechushtan, A., Sprinzak, D., Gileadi, O., Behar, V., Zik, O., Chowers, Y., Michaeli, S., Schlessinger, J. and Moses, E. (2004). Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101, 3346. Thiel, B.L., Bache, I.C., Fletcher, A.L., Meredith, P. and Donald, A.M. (1997). J Microsc 187, 143. Thiel, B.L., Toth, M. and Craven, J.P. (2004). Microsc Microanal 10, 711. Thornton, P.R. (1972). Scanning Electron Microscopy. Application to Materials and Device Science. (Chapman & Hall, London). Toth, M. and Phillips, M.R. (2000). Scann 22, 370. Troughton, P.R. and Donaldson, L.A. (1972). Probing Plant Structure. (Chapman & Hall, London). Troyon, M., Lei, H.N. and Bourhettar, A. (1992). Ultramicroscopy 42–44, 1564. Tuggle, D.W. and Swanson, L.W. (1985). J Vac Sci Technol B 3, 220. Uchikawa, Y. and Ikeda, S. (1981). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 209. Uno, S., Honda, K., Nakamura, N., Matsuya, M. and Zach, J.(2004). In 8th AsiaPacific Conf Electron Microscopy (8APEM Publication Committee, ed.) 46–47. (Yoshida Printing Inc., Kanazawa). Ushiki, T., Yui, R. and Fujita, T. (1986). J Electr Microsc 35, 157. van Essen, C.G., Schulson, E.M. and Donaghay, R.H. (1971). J Mater Sci 6, 213.
Chapter 3 Scanning Electron Microscopy Venables, J.A. and Harland, C.J. (1973). Phil Mag 27, 74. Verkleij, A. and Leunissen, J. (1989). Immunogold Labelling in Cell Biology.) (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL). Volbert, B. (1982). Scann Electr Microsc 3, 897. Volbert, B. and Reimer, L. (1980). Scann Electr Microsc 4, 1. von Ardenne, M. (1938). Zeit Techn Phys 19, 407. von Nahmen, A., Schenk, M., Sieber, M. and Amrein, M. (1997). Biophys J 72, 463. Wall, J.S. (1979). Scann Electr Microsc 2, 291. Wall, J.S. (1980). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 99. Walther, P. (2003). J Microsc 212, 34. Walther, P. and Müller, M. (1985). In 43rd Annual Meeting of the Electron Microscopy Society of America (Bailey, G.W., ed.) 538–541. (San Francisco Press, San Francisco). Walther, P. and Müller, M. (1986). In Science of Biological Specimen Preparation (Müller, M., Becker, R.P., Boyde A. and Wolosewick, J.J., eds.) 195–201. (Scanning Electron Microscopy, Chicago). Walther, P. and Müller, M. (1999). J Microsc 196, 279. Walther, P., Hentschel, J., Herter, P., Müller, T. and Zierold, K. (1990). Scann 12, 300. Walther, P., Wehrli, E., Hermann, R. and Müller, M. (1995). J Microsc 179, 229. Wang, C., Krausch, G., Radlein, E., Tratzky, S., Schramm, M. and Weber, A. (2004). Glass Sci Technol 77, 273. Wardly, G.A. (1971). J Appl Phys 42, 376. Wells, O.C. (1974). Scanning Electron Microscopy. (McGraw-Hill, New York). Wells, O.C. (1975). Scanning Electron Microscopy. (McGraw-Hill, New York). Wells, O.C. (1978). Scann Electr Microsc 1, 293. Wells, O.C. (1979). Appl Phys Lett 35, 644. Wepf, R. and Gross, H. (1990). In 12th Intern Congr Electron Microscopy (Peachy, L.D. and Williams, D.B., eds.) 6–7. (San Francisco Press, Seattle). Wepf, R., Amrein, M., Bürkli, U. and Gross, H. (1991). J Microsc 163, 51. Werner, W.S.M., Lakatha, H., Smith, H.E., LeTarte, L., Ambrose, V. and Baker, J. (1998). J Vac Sci Technol B: Microelectron Nanometer Struct 16, 420. Wetzig, K. and Schulze, D. (eds.) (1995). In Situ Scanning Electron Microscopy in Materials Research. (Akademie Verlag, Berlin). Wight, S.A. and Zeissler, C.J. (2000). Scann 22, 167. Wilkinson, A.J. (2000). J Electr Microsc 49, 299. Wilkinson, A.J. and Hirsch, P.B. (1997). Micron 28, 279. Willison, J.H.M. and Rowe, A.J. (1980). Replica, Shadowing and Freeze-Etching Techniques. (North-Holland, Amsterdam). Wittry, D.B. (1966). In Fourth Intern Cong on X-ray Optics and Microanalysis (Castaing, R., Deschamps, P. and Philibert, J., eds.) 168–180. (Hermann, Paris). Wollman, E.W., Frisbie, C.D. and Wrighton, M.S. (1993). Langmuir 9, 1517. Wu, C.H. and Wittry, D.B. (1974). J Appl Phys 49, 2827. Wurster, R. (1997). J Trace Microprobe Techn 15, 467. Yakimov, E.B. (2002). J Phys Cond Matter 14, 13069. Yakobi, B.G. and Holt, D.B. (eds.) (1990). Cathodoluminescence Microscopy of Inorganic Solids. (Plenum, New York). Yamaguchi, J., Shibano, M. and Saito, T. (1994). In 13th Intern Congr Electron Microscopy, vol 3A (Jouffrey, B. and Colliex, C., eds.) 43–44. (Les Editions de Physique Les Ulis, Paris). Yamamoto, T., Nishizawa, H. and Tsuno, K. (1976). Phil Mag 34, 311. Yamazaki, Y. (2004). Electrochim Acta 50, 663. Yew, N.C. (1971). Scann Electr Microsc 33.
271
272
R. Reichelt Zach, J. (1989). Optik 83, 30. Zach, J. and Rose, H. (1988a). In 9th Europ Congr Electron Microscopy, vol 1 (Dickinson, H.G. and Goodhew, P.J., eds.) 81–82. (IOP Publishing Ltd., York) Zach, J. and Rose, H. (1988b). Scann 8, 285. Zadrazil, M., El-Gomati, M.M. and Walker, A. (1997). J Comput Assist Microsc 9, 123. Zaefferer, S. (2004). JEOL News 39, 10. Zaefferer, S., Ohlert, J. and Bleck, W. (2004). Acta Mater 52, 2765. Zeitler, E. (1978). Ann NY Acad Sci 306, 62. Zeitler, E. and Bahr, G.F. (1962). J Appl Phys 33, 847. Zhao, Y.C., Chen, M., Zhang, Y.N., Xu, T. and Liu, W.M. (2005). Mater Lett 59, 40. Zhao, Z.X., Cui, R.Q., Meng, F.Y., Zhou, Z.B., Yu, H.C. and Sun, T.T. (2005). Solar Energy Mater Solar Cells 86, 135. Zworykin, V.K., Hillier, J. and Snyder, R.L. (1942). ASTM Bull 117, 15.
4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Gianluigi Botton
1 Introduction The term analytical electron microscopy (AEM) refers to the collection of spectroscopic data in the transmission electron microscope (TEM) based on various signals generated following the inelastic interaction of the incident electron beam with the sample. These signals can be used to identify and quantify the concentration of the elements present in the analyzed area, map their distribution in the sample with high spatial resolution (down to 1 nm or better), and even determine their chemical state. Although there are several signals generated by the interaction of primary incident electrons on a sample (Figure 4–1), the two main techniques at the core of AEM are based on the detection of X-ray signals generated in the sample by the primary incident electrons with the technique called energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDXS) and the measurement of the energy lost by the incident electrons with electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS). These techniques are used within a TEM (Figure 4–2) equipped with EDXS, EELS detectors, and other detectors to record TEM images, diffraction patterns, and other signals that can be combined to form other images containing additional information on the chemical nature and structure of the sample. Other techniques such as cathodoluminescence, Auger spectroscopy, and electron beam-induced current imaging are also part of the arsenal of techniques available in the TEM but are less frequently implemented in commercial TEMs or have been used only as proof of concept. Convergent beam electron diffraction has traditionally been considered one of the AEM techniques, but given the breadth of this topic, the chapter will focus on the principles of EDXS and EELS, instrumentation requirements, the quantitative aspects of microanalysis, and the respective advantages and limitations. Throughout this chapter, several examples of application of these techniques in practical problems will be given. A comparison of these AEM methods with other analytical techniques is presented in a summary. Since this topic has been extensively covered in key detailed early textbook references (Joy et al., 1986; Williams and Carter, 1996) an update on the current status of the tech-
273
274
G. Botton
Figure 4–1. Signals generated when high-energy incident electrons interact with a thin sample.
niques will be given based on recent published literature and examples of work. 1.1 Overview of EDXS As incident electrons generated by the electron gun in the TEM interact with atoms and their electrons in the solid, various inelastic processes are generated. When the primary electron excites bound electrons on a given shell (Figure 4–3), a core hole is created. This excited state is created only temporarily and the empty state is therefore filled by electrons from higher energy levels through a deexcitation process by generation of photons (of sufficient energy to be considered in the X-ray
Figure 4–2. Example of a commercially available analytical TEM. Visible are the energy dispersive X-ray detector, the energy loss spectrometer, and digital cameras and detectors.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
275
Figure 4–3. Energy level diagrams showing the transitions required for the generation of X-rays and Auger electrons following the excitation of core electrons by the primary incident electrons.
part of the spectrum) or Auger electrons. The energy of these X-rays, typically in the range of few hundred electronvolts to 20–40 keV, is also characteristic of the energy differences between the levels involved in the excitation and deexcitation process (Figures 4–4 and 4–5). Because various energy shells can be excited, peaks in the spectra are labeled according to the corresponding quantum levels involved in the transitions based on the nomenclature illustrated in Figure 4–4. The dependence on characteristic energy levels of the bound electrons makes it possible to identify the atomic number of the elements that have been involved in the excitation process. However, not all transitions between
Figure 4–4. Detailed energy levels, their associated quantum number n, l, and j, and associated families with the transitions respecting the selection rules described in the text.
276
G. Botton Figure 4–5. Characteristic X-ray energy for different families of lines as a function of atomic number.
the energy levels are allowed: there must be a change in the angular momentum quantum numbers 艎 and j for transitions to be observed according to the rule ∆艎 = ±1, ∆j = −1, 0, +1 (Figure 4–4). The probability of these excitations and generation of X-rays or Auger electrons varies with atomic number based on cross sections and fluorescence yield. The efficiency of the detection of the X-rays also varies according to their energy due to absorption in the detector material. In addition, the X-rays generated can be absorbed in the sample itself before reaching the detector. The spectrum itself consists of the characteristic X-ray peaks for the excited atoms present in the sample superimposed on a continuum noncharacteristic background (Figure 4–6). To relate the intensity detected in spectra to the concentration of the elements, several effects must therefore be considered: the intensity of the peaks in the spectra must be corrected using cross sections and fluorescence corrections and absorption in the sample and in the detector. Figure 4–7 summarizes the process of signal generation, collection, display, and quantification in a flow chart containing various steps of signal correction. Based on the quantification of signals, it is possible
Figure 4–6. EDS spectrum demonstrating the characteristic lines (with energies presented in Figure 4–5) and the continuum background.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
277
Figure 4–7. Schematic diagram for the generation of X-rays in the sample, detection of the X-rays in the detector (by generation of electron and hole pairs), pulse analysis, and quantification process of the spectrum to derive the composition of the sample. Detailed procedures of quantification are described in Section 4.
to measure the local concentration to an accuracy limited by the statistic uncertainty of the spectrum and the errors in the cross sections. Due to the limited signal collection efficiency of the detector, the finite acquisition time and the presence of a noncharacteristic background under the element-specific peaks, the technique is generally not suitable for the detection of trace elements in samples but it can provide rapid quantitative data on elements to within a few atomic percent accuracy, with detection limits typically of a few percent. Improvements in collection efficiency and long acquisition times, however, have led to detection limits of fractions of 1% (see Section 7 of this chapter). Using software that can control the electron beam position on the sample and the data collection in a sequential manner, generated signals can be collected over an area of the sample so that the intensity of characteristic signals, as a function of position, represents the local composition variations in the sample as displayed in an elemental map (Figure 4–8). Further processing of spatially resolved spectra can also be carried out so that quantitative maps and statistical analysis of the concentration and element distribution can be displayed. Details of the performance and limitations of EDXS as well as the approaches used to quantify the data are given in subsequent sections.
278
G. Botton
Figure 4–8. Schematic diagram describing the processes necessary to record an elemental map with EDXS. The synchronous scan of the beam is associated with a pixel position where the recording of the signal takes place. The peak intensity is measured for each element at each pixel position and is plotted in a two-dimensional elemental map.
1.2 Overview of Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy EELS is based on the measurement of the energy that the primary incident electrons have lost while causing various inelastic processes in the sample. The excitation of electrons from core energy levels that precedes the generation of X-rays or Auger electrons is only one of the mechanisms by which the primary electrons can lose some of their energy. For this particular case, the energy loss process gives rise to signals known as “core edges” with characteristic energies closely related to the binding energy of the excited electrons (Figure 4–9) in the atoms. Excitation of valence electrons into the conduction band and collective excitation of weakly bound electrons are also potential energy loss processes (Figure 4–9) called plasmons. These losses contribute to the low loss part of the spectrum (Figure 4–10) from a few to about 50–100 eV. Although characteristic core edges can appear at relatively low energies, strong low-loss signals contain information about the materials dielectric properties. With reference spectra and databases, it is therefore possible to identify particular compounds based on the shape of the low-loss spectrum. Identification of the chemical state and the compound is also possible through the analysis of fine modulations appearing in the first few electronvolts from the core edges threshold. These modulations are known as electron energy loss near-edge structure (ELNES) and contain information about the electronic structure and bonding environment of the excited atom. This information is now frequently used in the study of electronic structure and chemical state
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
279
Figure 4–9. Schematic diagram of the associated features in a spectrum. The core edges arise from transitions from deep core levels to the first unoccupied states above the valence band (and Fermi energy) and the continuum. Excitation from defect states in the gap are also shown as well as collective excitations of valence electrons giving rise to broad features called plasmon peaks.
Figure 4–10. Full energy loss spectrum recorded over a large energy range demonstrating the large dynamic range of the recorded intensities and the relative intensity of core losses as compared with the background. (Courtesy of H. Sauer, Fritz-Haber Institut/MPG, Berlin.)
280
G. Botton
of materials with applications ranging from semiconductor devices to the study of minerals whereas low-loss structures have been used in the study as diverse as biological structures to superconductors. Similar to the case of EDXS microanalysis, the intensity of core edges is related to the probability of excitation and thus to cross-section values and the concentration of elements. The intensity of edges relative to the background, however, is strongly dependent on the thickness of the analyzed area and edges can remain simply undetected in the case of thick samples. As in the case of EDXS analysis, this technique is not ideal for routine detection of trace elements due to the very intense background typically dominating the signal at the edges and the overall small recorded signal of edges with respect to the total recorded signal (Figure 4–10), although acquisition conditions can be optimized for the detection of minor constituents (discussed in Section 7.1). EELS signals offer the advantage of being generated by a primary event: the loss of energy. As compared to EDXS, the intensity of recorded signals is therefore not linked to the secondary process of fluorescence resulting in the deexcitation via X-ray emission. For light elements such as O, N, C, B, this is a remarkable advantage because the fluorescence yield (the probability of X-ray relative to Auger electrons generation, see Section 4.1) decreases by orders of magnitude as compared to higher atomic number elements such as transition metals. Therefore, EELS analysis is generally considered to be more appropriate for the detection of light elements than EDXS analysis. The core edges can be identified and labeled according to the energy levels of the ejected electron and the respective quantum numbers. K, L, M, N, O edges are related to the transitions involving n = 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 principal quantum numbers, respectively. The angular momentum quantum numbers 艎 (s,p,d,f) and j lead to sublabels as indicated in Figure 4–11. A summary of the information that can be retrieved from EELS spectra is shown in Table 4–1 (Colliex, 1996). The collection of EELS spectra is carried out with an energy loss spectrometer either attached at the bottom of the TEM column (postcolumn filter) or within the projector lens system (in-column filter) (Section 2.4.1). In both cases, the electron energy distribution is analyzed with one or a series of dispersing elements that separate the electrons according to their energy. The dispersion will result in the generation of a spectrum that will be recorded on a detector system. Depending on the filter electron optical configuration and detector system, spectra, images and diffraction patterns corresponding to specific energy losses can be recorded as discussed in Section 2.4.1. When images or diffraction patterns are obtained using electrons with specific energy losses or with electrons having lost no energy, the technique is called energy-filtered microscopy. 1.3 Comparison with Other Spectroscopies EDXS and EELS offer information complementary to other techniques that yield compositional or spectroscopic data typically available in
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Figure 4–11. Diagram demonstrating the origin of the spectroscopic labels of energy loss spectra and the associated core levels. (Adapted from EELS Atlas, C.C. Ahn and O.L. Krivanek.)
surface analysis instruments such as X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), Auger spectroscopy, X-ray absorption spectroscopy, inverse photoemission, etc. XPS provides information on the binding energy (Eb) of electrons in atomic core levels as ejected by incident photons. These photoelectrons with kinetic energy Ek are detected in vacuum as they Table 4–1. Information from EELS spectra. Spectral region
Type of information
Application
Full spectrum
Thickness, inelastic mean free path
All analytical methods of quantification, volume fraction
Low-loss
Average electron density
Microanalysis of alloys, H content, identification of phases
Low-loss
Joint density of states
Optical properties of solids, electronic structure, correlation effects, bandgap measurement
Low-loss
Dielectric properties/interfaces
Relativistic effects, interface excitation effects/modes
Core-loss
Edges intensity
Quantification of concentration of elements
Core-loss
Near edge structures
Chemical state, coordination, ionicity/valence, phase identification
Core-loss
Extended fi ne structure
Determination of radial distribution functions
Core-loss
White lines: density of holes in the d-band
Formal charge, charge transfer
281
282
G. Botton
escape the sample surfaces and the system workfunction (φ). This process typically detects photoelectrons with very low kinetic energy as the incident X-rays photons (Ev) are typically a few kiloelectronvolts and Ek = Ev − (Eb + φ). The technique thus provides essentially information from the topmost few atomic layers and is used to analyze ultrathin layers and quantify composition of thin films deposited on surfaces, surface contaminants etc. Although the lateral resolution is typically about a few tens of micrometers in commercial instruments, near micrometer resolution can be achieved in synchrotron facilities and in imaging XPS instruments. Using ion beams to sputter the sample surface, depth profiling can be carried out with a depth resolution of 2–5 nm due to the (energy-dependent) escape depth of the electrons and, when sputtering is used, the ballistic mixing induced by the incident ions. Angular resolved XPS methods can reach a depth resolution of about 1–2 nm as the escape angle can be tuned with the spectrometer. The technique can therefore provide information on the composition of surface layers and changes in the chemical state of atoms as reflected in the changes in binding energy. In Auger spectroscopy, the energy of the Auger electrons typically ranges from a few tens of electronvolts to 1–2 keV and, as in the case of XPS, the escape depth from the sample surface is also limited to the topmost few nanometers. The Auger electron energy between energy levels A (initial core level) and levels B and C (secondary levels) (Figure 4–3) is determined by the energy levels involved in the transition as EABC = EA − EB − EC − φ. The changes in bonding due to changes in oxidation state or structure are therefore reflected in the energy of Auger peaks as the energy levels would be affected by the changes in bonding. The technique therefore provides both information on the elemental composition and the chemical state. X-Ray absorption spectroscopy provides information on the absorption process of incident photons caused by transitions from inner-shell energy levels to the unoccupied states just above the Fermi energy and the continuum free states. The technique is therefore complementary to EELS as unoccupied states are probed but it offers the advantage of giving access to higher energy edges and the possibility of analysis in a controlled nonvacuum environment. With zone plate focusing of incident photons in third-generation synchrotrons, it is possible to obtain spot sizes of 15–30 nm. The X-ray absorption process can be directly observed in transmission mode or via indirect yield of electrons generated via the absorption process (total electron yield or fluorescence yield). In the latter case, the technique becomes surface sensitive as the escape depth of detected electrons is limited by their energy. Detection of elements in ppm concentration is possible due to the low background of edges as compared to EELS. As compared with these spectroscopic techniques, EDXS, carried out with typical commercial detectors, can be considered a “bulk” analysis technique yielding elemental information through the thickness of the thin TEM foil with practically no content on the chemical state of the detected elements. EELS in the analytical microscope also provides information on the chemical composition through the thin foil thick-
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
283
Table 4–2. Comparison of spectroscopy techniques. Technique
Lateral resolution limits
EDXS
1–2 nm
Depth resolution No
Detection limit
Elemental information
Spectroscopic information
Minor
Yes
No
EELS
0.5–1 nm
No
Minor
Yes
Yes
Auger
10–50 nm
Yes (2–5 nm)
Minor
Yes
Yes
XPS
1–10 um
Yes (1–5 nm)
Minor
Yes
Yes
XAS
20–100 nm
No
Trace
Yes
Yes
ness, but offers the clear advantage of providing spectroscopic information on the chemical state. Table 4–2 summarizes the general applications of the techniques, limitations, resolution, etc. Characteristic details on resolution vary depending on the acquisition conditions, energy of the elements of interest, and efficiency of the detection system.
2 Instrumentation The ultimate aims of AEM are to analyze materials with high spatial resolution. These goals require the use of electrons source and electron optic components capable of producing intense beam currents into small electron probes, and detectors to collect the various analytical signals generated from the interaction of incident electrons with atoms in the solid. These requirements are met in a TEM configured for analytical work offering bright electron sources, flexible condensing optics, clean vacuum, and a range of detectors for imaging and spectroscopy. Thin and very clean samples are a necessity for achieving the ultimate performance expected from the high-spatial resolution techniques and these are as important as the quality of the microscope. 2.1 Electron Sources and Probes TEMs for conventional TEM, high-resolution TEM, and AEMs can be equipped with two types of electron sources—thermionic and field emission. Thermionic sources such as W hairpin filaments and refractory crystals such as LaB6 operate at high temperature and emit electrons that are subsequently accelerated by the anode potential (100–200 kV or more). The thermionic sources are heated either by a flow of current through the emitting material itself (for the W hairpin cathode filament) or by thermal contact of a low-workfunction emittor material such as LaB6 and resistive heating of a W wire supporting material. The field-emission gun (FEG) source operates on the principles of electron tunneling from the tip to vacuum following the application of a strong electric field (≈109 V/m) generating a very large electric field gradient at the tip of the cathode. This high field results in a very narrow potential barrier allowing tunneling of the electrons from a low-workfunction metallic tip to vacuum. This emission is generated
284
G. Botton
from a very small area (in the order of 10 nm or less) of a single crystal tip resulting in high current density. There are variants to this gun configuration. Cold FEGs emit at room temperature and have the disadvantage of requiring ultrahigh vacuum (10−8–10−9 Pa) to prevent the adsorption of gas molecules on the surface of the tip. This leads to a reduction of the emission current and to instabilities caused by an increase of the workfunction due to the surface contaminants. To reduce this sensitivity to adsorption, thermally assisted field emission and Schottky emission sources have been introduced. Thermally assisted FEGs are based on the application of a high electric field to W single crystal tips heated to about 1600 K. The emission also occurs through tunneling from a small area of the tip and the characteristics are similar to cold field emission. The benefits of high temperature operation is the increased stability due to a cleaner tip at the expense of a higher energy spread of the emitted electrons as compared to cold FEG. The last type of source also considered in the class of FEGs is the Schottky gun. These guns are based on the Schottky emission principle that causes a reduction of the energy barrier for simple thermionic emission with a combination of electron image forces and strong electric fields applied to the tip (e.g., see Reimer, 1984; Solymar and Walsh, 2004). Strictly speaking, the emission is therefore not due to tunneling as it combines thermal emission with high electric fields. Due to the high coherence and brightness, however, Schottky sources are also considered in the class of field emission sources. To further decrease the workfunction, the W tip is generally coated with ZrO to increase the emission current. Optimal current stability is obtained with W crystals oriented so as to expose (100) crystalline facets and ZrO coating. The high operating temperature reduces the sensitivity to adsorption but it has the drawback that the material is sensitive to reactions with the gases present in the gun area. Ultrahigh vacuum is therefore required but at less strict levels than what is necessary for cold FEG. High current densities can be achieved with Schottky sources due to the very small emission area. High total emission currents can also be generated by controlling the extraction voltage and the gun lens operation parameters. In some implementations of the Schottky guns, total beam currents in the order of 100–300 nA can be achieved. The previous description has been very qualitative and further analysis is required to effectively compare the performance of the various types of sources and understand the requirements for AEM. A key quantity characterizing the gun performance is the brightness of the source B defined as the current per unit area and solid angle B=
4ie ie = 2 2 ( π ( d 2) πα πdα )2
(1)
where ie is the current emission, d is the beam diameter, α is the convergence angle of the cone containing the electrons, and πα2 is the solid angle corresponding to the cone. The units of B are A/(m2 sr) and the values scale with the accelerating voltage (B values are typically given at 100 keV) and are maintained throughout the optical system (from the emission source to the sample).
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
285
The emission current density J for thermal sources is related to the material and the operation temperature T and follows the Richardson’s law J = AT 2 exp(−φ/KT)
(2)
where A is a constant of the material (the Richardson constant given in units of A/cm2 K2), and φ is the workfunction. The field emission current is related to the tunneling process and thus to the electric field at the tip. For Schottky emission, the workfunction is effectively reduced by a factor ∆φ due to the strong electric field applied to the tip and becomes φeff = φ − ∆φ = φ − e eE 4 πε 0 where E is the electric field (in the order of 108 V/m), ε0 is the vacuum permittivity, and e is the electron charge. This reduction of the workfunction arises from the wellestablished Schottky effect (e.g., Solymar and Walsh, 2004) that effectively increases the emission current by a factor exp(∆φ/kT) (Egerton, 2005) due to the negative term in the exponential factor in Richardson’s law [Eq. (2)]. The temperature of the source will affect the temporal coherence of the source and the energy spread of the electrons due to thermal energy. The source size and the angular spread α will affect the spatial coherence. Considering the source size, the temperature of the source, the vacuum requirements, and the brightness, the sources can be compared (Table 4–3). It is possible to comment on the merits of the various electron sources for AEM. The high brightness of the cold FEG makes it the ideal tool for analytical work requiring a small probe. Minimal source demagnification is required as the source size is in the order of 10 nm although the ultimate probe size and shape will depend on electron optical considerations related to aberration of the probe forming optics (see below). An additional advantage of the cold FEG is the low energy
Table 4–3. Comparison of sources. Thermionic W hairpin
Characteristic
Thermionic LaB6
Schottky emission FEG (ZrO on W crystal)
Thermal FEG W (100) orientation
Cold FEG (W single crystal)
f (eV)
4.5
2.7
2.8
4.5
4.5
Jc (A/m2 )
ª10 4
ª106
ª107
ª107–10 8
ª109
a (rad)
ª10 -2
ª10 -2
ª10 -3
ª10 -3 –10 -4
ª10 -4
ª50
ª10
ª0.02–0.03
ª0.01–0.1
ª0.01
d (mm)
a 2
Brightness [A/(m sr)] Temperature (K)
b
ª10
9
2700 c
Energy spread (eV)
1–3
Vacuum (Pa)
10 -2
a
ª10
10
11
ª10 –10
1800 0.6–2 10 -4
1800 c
0.6–1.5 10 -7
c
12
ª10
12
ª1012–1013
1600
300
0.6–0.8
0.3
10 -7
10 -8
Specific values depend on the exact tip configuration. The brightness values are given for 100-keV electrons and scale linearly with accelerating voltage. The reduced brightness is given by B/V (where V is the accelerating voltage in volts). c The energy spread is dependent on the operation condition of the gun (the bias of the Wehnelt, filament heating current, or the extraction voltage of the Schottky FEG). b
286
G. Botton
spread of the electron source allowing, in principle, detailed analysis of the energy loss near-edge structures in EELS spectra. Although the ultimate brightness of the Schottky sources is lower by about one order of magnitude, the practicalities of the less stringent vacuum and demonstrated reliability have made the Schottky guns very common within the AEM field. Worth mentioning is the fact that the total current might be a more important parameter for some AEM analysis techniques such as energy-filtered imaging when a large field of view needs to be illuminated (with enough current per individual pixel in a map). In that case, the thermionic emission sources (LaB6 in particular) provide very large total currents. New research is in progress to develop alternate even brighter sources by exploiting low workfunction materials, carbon nanotube electronic properties (Fransen et al., 2005), and semiconductor p–n junctions. Once the electrons are accelerated by the anode stack to the highvoltage potential of the TEM, the condensing optics demagnifies (Figure 4–12) the source image in the plane of the sample. In this chapter we will not describe the various aberrations and defects of lenses but refer the reader to other chapters in this book. We remind the reader, however, that all round electromagnetic lenses have positive spherical aberration coefficients Cs (in the order of Cs = 0.5–1.0 mm for high-resolution microscopes offering limited sample tilt and a small polepiece gap and around Cs = 1.5–3 mm for large tilt and large polepiece gaps). Electromagnetic lenses also suffer from chromatic aberrations Cc in the order of Cc = 1–2 mm and that, just as in light optics, the wave nature of elec-
Figure 4–12. Schematic diagram of a field emission electron gun with gun anodes (also called gun lens) and the accelerating anodes (accelerating the electrons up to the accelerating voltage of the TEM). The illumination system consists of condenser lenses (C1, C2, Cm) and the objective lens (OL). See the text for function details.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
trons imposes a diffraction limit to the resolution as imposed by the Rayleigh criterion. Given these imperfections of the lenses and wave nature of electrons, the probe size at the specimen level d0 is limited not only by the demagnified image source size ds but also by a combination of the aberration of the illumination system (spherical and chromatic) and the diffraction limit of the probe-forming aperture all added in quadrature (Spence and Zuo, 1992; Reimer, 1984) d20 = d2s + d2d + d2sa + d2c + d2f
(3)
where ds is the demagnified source image, dd = 0.6λ/α is the diffraction limit broadening, dsa = 0.5 Csα3 is the spherical aberration broadening, dC = (∆E/E0)CCα is the chromatic aberration contribution of the probe forming lens, df = 2α∆f is the defocus contribution to a small defocus error where α is the convergence half-angle at the specimen determined by the condenser C2 aperture limiting the probe and ∆f is the defocus of the probe forming lens. The size of the unaberrated probe source image ds is related to the definition of brightness that, as mentioned above, is constant through the illumination system (from the gun to the sample) and is determined as ds = ( 2 πα ) I b B where Ib is the beam current. Calculations of the unaberrated source size therefore assume that the current at the sample is known (or can be measured). Equation (3) assumes incoherent illumination, i.e., all electrons at the aperture are not in phase and every point within the aperture can be considered as an independent source. Strictly speaking, this assumption is not valid for high brightness field emission sources (and for particular operating conditions of thermionic electron sources) and it is necessary to define the conditions where incoherence in illumination applies to determine the conditions of validity of Eq. (3) for the calculation of the probe size. Due to the various aberration terms in Eq. (3) there is an optimum probe size as a function of the illuminating angle. Plots for two microscope configurations and sources are shown in Figure 4–13 for a high-resolution microscope configuration—not dedicated to analytical work but for designed optimum imaging resolution (low tilt angle in the specimen area: ±20–24°)—and for a high-tilt analytical configuration (±35–40°). It is clear that the use of FEG allows smaller probes. Based on the equations above and typical gun brightnesses for Schottky guns, it is possible to calculate the probe current dependence with probe size, calculated based on the incoherent illumination condition, for an FEG and an LaB6 source (Figure 4–14). We also demonstrate the effect of reducing the spherical aberrations in the probe-forming lens using the recently developed correctors in a cold FEG-scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) operating at 100 kV based on the data reported in the literature (Dellby et al., 2001) (Figure 4–15). For the latter case, Eq. (3) needs to be modified to account for the limited residual aberrations (see Chapter 2, this volume; Dellby et al., 2001). As discussed above, the coherence of the source is a key concept that needs to be considered for high-brightness field emission sources and analytical microscopy. In conditions of coherent illumination all electrons can be considered to be emitted by a single point source and all
287
288
G. Botton Figure 4–13. Variation of the electron probe size for analytical TEM work as a function of the illumination aperture convergence for instruments equipped with different electron sources and lenses.
Figure 4–14. Variation of the electron beam current with electron probe size for two instruments equipped with a thermionic source and Schottky FEG.
Figure 4–15. Variation of the probe current as a function of probe size for a conventional cold field emission source dedicated scanning transmission electron microscope and an aberration corrected cold-FEG microscope. (From Dellby et al., © 2001. Reprinted with permission from the Japanese Microscopy Society.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
are in phase in the illuminating aperture and on the electron wavefront at the sample. This condition implies that interference effects between electrons can occur. A detailed discussion on coherence and sources can be found in Spence and Zuo (1992) and we summarize the key elements of coherence relevant to the discussion on the probe size for the purpose of discussing the ultimate limits of the instrumentation. Following the concepts developed in classical optics, it is necessary to consider the transverse coherence width Xa concept related to the width of the electron beam in the plane of the condensor aperture Xa = λ/(2πθs) = fC2λ/(πds) where θs is the angular width of the probe of size ds (i.e., not the convergence angle) as subtended at the condensor aperture (Figure 4–16). This angle can be determined geometrically given a probe size ds and focal length fC2 of the probe-forming lens. Source points in the aperture plane closer than Xa can interfere as in a slit experiment with coherent light. This transverse coherence term must be compared with the diameter of the probe-forming aperture DC2 to determine if the illumination is coherent or not. If Xa << DC2, the aperture is incoherently illuminated and all points in the illumination aperture can be considered as emitting independently. Still, for a given aperture of convergence angle α incoherently filled, the coherence width will be Xs = λ/(2πα). Object points at the sample separated by a distance smaller that Xs will be illuminated coherently and will give rise to interference effects. In the other extreme, if Xa > DC2, the aperture is coherently filled and the electron wavefront illuminating the sample will be in phase. For example, for the smallest probe in an FEG (say 0.2 nm), a C2 aperture of 5 µm would be coherently filled. At 200 keV, for a LaB6 emitter and a probe size of about 3 nm, one would need an aperture of 0.5 µm for the coherence criterion to be fulfilled. By changing the illumination conditions (demagnification of the source and reducing the accelerating voltage) and the condenser aperture, the coherence illumination condition could be achieved even for thermionic sources as demonstrated by Dowell and Goodman (1973). In coherent illumination conditions, the terms contributing to the determination of the probe size cannot be added incoherently as inde-
Figure 4–16. Factors entering the description of the source coherence for illumination of samples. (Adapted from Spence and Zuo, 1992.)
289
290
G. Botton
pendent contributions [as done in Eq. (3)] and detailed calculations based on the incident electron wavefunction and the transfer function of the objective lens must be carried out. It has been demonstrated that with the judicious choice of defocus of the probe forming lens, subÅngstrom electron probes can be obtained even without aberration correctors (Nellist and Pennycook, 1998) to improve imaging resolution albeit with very small currents and tails to the intensity distribution containing up to 50% of the beam current. Such beams, although relevant for optimal imaging resolution, are therefore not suitable for analytical work. Optimum probe sizes (Mory et al., 1987) for analytical work are achieved with convergence αC and defocus ∆f conditions deter1/2 mined by α C = 1.27 Cs−1/4λ1/4 and ∆f = −0.75 C1/2 s λ . In these optimal conditions, the probe size containing 80% of the intensity is d (80%) = 3/4 0.4 C1/4 . For aberration corrected instruments these terms need to be s λ revised to correctly treat the contributions of the residual aberrations as discussed in Dellby et al. (2001) and in Chapter 2 (this volume). 2.2 Electron Optic Configuration In the discussion so far we have made abstraction of the technical aspects necessary to achieve the demagnification of the source required for small probe analysis and the need to provide, with the same system, illumination at the sample for conventional imaging and energyfiltered microscopy. Modern instruments capable of conventional TEM and STEM are based on the double condensing optic system (C1 + C2) with the addition of a supplementary weaker condenser lens Cm (called “condenser minilens” or “minicondenser”) and a strong magnetic field before the sample (i.e., a prefield) generated by an objective lens (OL) composed of two parts: an upper lens and a lower lens surrounding the sample (Figure 4–17). “Parallel” illumination at the sample plane is achieved by a combination of C2 and Cm yielding, at the focal point of the objective lens, a convergent beam that is then made parallel by the strong upper objective lens field (Figure 4–17a). A small probe required for analytical work or for STEM imaging and analysis in STEM mode is obtained by effectively optically switching the Cm off (using various schemes depending of the exact location of the Cm lens) and by making use of the strong OL prefield (of the upper objective lens) to achieve large convergence angles and large source demagnification (Figure 4–17b). Practically speaking, this mode of operation is called the nanoprobe or energy-dispersive spectrometry (EDS) mode. STEM operation for these microscopes is achieved in exactly the same electron-optical configuration. FEGs (cold and Schottky) have an additional electrostatic gun lens (Figure 4–12) leading to additional demagnification of the source and more flexibility in the gun operation. The strength of the C1 lens determines the fraction of electrons (hence the current) that will enter the C2 aperture and the demagnification of the source. A strongly excited C1 lens will give rise to larger demagnification and, conversely, a weakly excited C1 lens will result in a smaller demagnification and more current entering the C2 aperture. In this fixed operation mode, changes in the convergence angle are achieved
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Figure 4–17. Electron optical configuration of the illumination system of a double-objective lens system. Configuration (a) describes the formation of parallel illumination while configuration (b) describes the conditions needed to achieve a highly convergent and small focused electron beam.
by changing the physical aperture size (using a strip aperture containing four to eight apertures, including a top hat Pt aperture for analytical work—see Sections 2.3.6 and 7.2 on instrumental contributions in EDXS analysis). Continuous change in convergence is achieved by controlling the strength of the Cm lens and OL prefield or/and addition of a third condenser lens. The electron optical configuration required for STEM imaging and analysis is achieved, in a TEM-STEM instrument capable of both operation modes and, as discussed above, with the combination of the Cm lens optically switched off and the subsequent focus of the nearly parallel beam into a small source image by the upper OL field. The scanning operation of the beam over the sample is carried out by deflection coils located before the specimen (optically before the upper objective lens) so that the beam is shifted (but not tilted) on the specimen plane (Figure 4–18). As the beam is rastered pixel by pixel over the area of sample of interest, various signals (including analytical information) can be recorded sequentially at each position to form images and elemental maps based on analog or digital signals recorded synchronously (e.g., bright-field, secondary electrons, backscattered electrons, annular dark-field electrons, and EELS, EDXS, etc). Dedicated commercial STEM instruments (offering no TEM operation mode) built by the company Vacuum Generator in the 1980s and 1990s have traditionally been equipped with cold FEG and, in the later models, operate with a gun lens, two condenser lenses, and an asymmetric objective lens (no imaging lenses are necessary). Their design is based on the gun located at the “bottom” of the microscope column for stability reasons with the detectors at the “top.” New commercial instruments
291
292
G. Botton
Figure 4–18. Electron optical configuration for STEM operation showing the role of the deflection coils in shifting the electron beam over the sample (without tilt of the beam) and the detection of signals on the dark-field STEM detectors and bright-field or energy-loss spectrometer. (Adapted from Gross et al., 1987.)
developed based on the same approach and equipped with aberration correctors are in development (Krivanek, 2005). Dedicated STEM instruments based on the upper portion of a conventional TEM column (but in this case without imaging lenses) are also available. These instruments are designed for quick and simple operation particularly popular for routine analysis in device fabrication environments. As supplementary information, we should briefly note that the processes of image formation and interpretation in STEM mode and TEM mode are closely linked by the reciprocity theorem further discussed in Chapter 2 (this volume) and earlier references (Cowley, 1986; Humphreys, 1979). This principle links the electron source in STEM to a detector point in the TEM image (pixel on a camera or negative plate) and the detector in STEM to the source of electrons in TEM. Effectively, the principle states that for identical optical components, sources, and detectors, STEM and TEM images will show the same resolution, and contrast. Given the respective strengths and weaknesses of these techniques (related to the field of view, recording time, dose, sequential recording, and analytical signals) the techniques should be considered
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
as complementary and not competitive (Cowley, 1986). Practically, this implies that materials analysis, and AEM in particular, should involve all possible optimized techniques and instrumentation both for TEM and STEM approaches. As demonstrated in the case of EELS analysis, energy-filtered imaging carried out in the TEM mode is highly complementary to the scanning EELS imaging method with both approaches offering advantages and presenting limitations (Section 6). 2.3 EDXS Detector Systems 2.3.1 The EDXS Detector In AEM experiments, photons are emitted in the sample following ionization of atoms by the primary incident electrons and subsequent deexcitation process. The energy of these photons is in the X-ray part of the electromagnetic spectrum (a few hundred electronvolts to a few tens of kiloelectronvolts) and we therefore refer to them as X-rays. In the analytical TEM, the most common and effective tool for the detection of X-rays is the energy-dispersive detector that is attached to the microscope column (refer to Figures 4–2 and 4–19) with the active component detecting the X-rays located as close as possible to the sample. Alternative approaches to detect X-ray signals with wavelength dispersive detectors have been attempted in prototype systems but have not been commercially implemented due to low efficiency (serial analysis of X-rays energies) and compatibility with the geometry of the microscope column (solid angle, vacuum etc.). The key component of the energy-dispersive X-ray detector is a semiconductor material (Si or Ge) that absorbs incident photons by generating electron hole (e–h)
Figure 4–19. Schematics of a commercial EDXS detector showing the detector front, the Dewar system to cool the detector, and various components that are interfaced in the electron microscope. (Courtesy of N. Rowlands, Oxford Instruments.) (See color plate.)
293
294
G. Botton
pairs through photoelectric effect. When this process occurs in an electric field, a current pulse is generated and subsequently measured by low-noise electronic components. Detectors based on Si are more commonly used in AEM because of the lower cost than Ge-based detectors (described below). Due to the fact that very high purity Si crystals are not available, Li additions in Si are used to compensate for residual impurity dopants that would create undesirable recombination sites for electronhole pairs and uncharacteristic current related to the existence of impurity-generated acceptor levels (thus holes in the valence band). The Li role in the so-called Si(Li) detectors is therefore to effectively create an intrinsic semiconductor region where e–h pairs generated by the incident photons produce a current flow that can be measured. Incident photons generate e–h pairs at the rate of 1 pair/ 3.8 eV. The number of e–h pairs generated in the “active layer” of the detector is thus proportional to the incident photon energy (which is, in turn, related to the energy level involved in the transitions following ionization of the atom by the incident electron beam). For Ge detectors, high-purity crystals can be obtained and Li additions are not necessary. The electric field in the detector necessary to cause the current flow is generated by metallic contacts (Au) (Figure 4–20) on the front and back surfaces of the crystals (typically 3 mm thick) and the application of a bias (0.5–1 kV) between the front and back of the detector with electrons traveling to the positive electrode and holes to the negative electrode. Some loss of charges occurs, however, in proximity of the contacts due to recombination in the charges near the metallic contact (about 200 nm in width). These regions are typically referred to as “dead-layers” in the literature as they do not contribute to the generation of signal and transfer of charge. The thickness of the crystal is normally large enough to convert all the photons to e–h pairs but for
Figure 4–20. Diagram of an EDXS detector demonstrating the various elements of the detector contacts, the dead layer, and the preamplifier. (Adapted from Woldseth, 1973.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
Figure 4–21. Schematics of the detector front of a TEM with components inserted into the TEM column detector window. (Courtesy of N. Rowlands and A. Kirk, Oxford Instruments.)
high-energy X-rays, transmission through the detector is possible. Measurement of the current is carried out from the back electrode, which is connected to a field effect transistor (FET) that acts as a first stage of amplification. The detector and FET are cooled to low temperature by a Cu rod connected to a liquid nitrogen reservoir (Figure 4–19) to prevent the diffusion of Li in the electric field and to reduce the thermal noise of the e–h generation and the FET electronics. The mechanical design of the detector assembly is crucial to reduce the transfer of mechanical vibrations into noise in the spectra. For example, bubbling in the Dewar arising from floating ice crystals and vibrations from the microscope frame or other components (such as fans) touching the detector can result in additional noise. The detector should therefore be supported by the same support mechanism as the frame of the microscope column and be isolated from the rest of the microscope components. 2.3.2 Detector Windows Due to the low operating temperature, the detector can act as a cold trap attracting contaminants to the detector front. For this reason, detector windows are used to isolate the detector from the vacuum of the microscope (Figure 4–21). The window technology has evolved in recent decades with the initial technology based on Be windows (7– 8 µm in thickness) allowing X-rays for elements down to Na to be detected due to the absorption of lower energy photons in this material. This limitation for the detection of light elements has led to the development of polymer-based thin windows and some implementation of systems without windows at all (called windowless detectors). Various polymer-based window materials are available in ultrathin windows (UTW). These use proprietary technology combining light element composites (polymers, diamond, nitrides, etc.) some of which are strong enough to withstand atmospheric pressure (labeled as atmospheric thin windows—ATW). Due to the combination of various X-ray absorbing materials the sensitivity of the detector system for light elements strongly varies at low energy due to the absorption the “soft” X-rays into the window material. UTWs, for example, allow detection of elements down to B but with reduced sensitivity as compared to
295
296
G. Botton
windowless detectors that are actually able to detect X-rays down to the BeKα line. The latter technology, however, normally requires the use of ultrahigh vacuum in the microscope to prevent rapid contamination of the crystal by the microscope environment and the related absorption of soft X-rays by the ice contamination layer. Whether windowless or UTW, most detectors are equipped with crystal heaters that gently warm up the crystal surface causing desorption of the ice layer built up on the crystal surface. Ice contamination is revealed by a reduction of the intensity of soft X-ray lines as compared to higherenergy lines such as demonstrated by the NiL/NiK ratios measured as a function of time. Since the Ni-L line at 0.85 keV is much more strongly absorbed than the NiK (at about 7 keV) set of lines the ratio is an effective means to appreciate the contamination effect (L’Espérance et al., 1990). The detector efficiency (Figure 4–22) accounts for all these effects and represents the fraction of X-rays that is transmitted through the window system as compared to the incident intensity as a function of energy. Windowless detectors still show an important drop in efficiency at low energy due to the presence of the dead layer and metallization in front of the intrinsic active portion of the detector. Even for UTW and ATW detectors, the efficiency drops significantly for lowenergy X-rays resulting in difficulties for the analysis of light elements in low concentration. Discontinuities in the detector efficiency are visible at the energies corresponding to the absorption edges of the elements contained in the window material (e.g., C, O, B, N, for example), the detector, and metallization. As discussed above, metallization is required for the application of a bias on the semiconductor crystal but it is also necessary on the window material to prevent light (generated by some samples by cathodoluminescence) from entering the detector system and resetting the signal amplification system.
Figure 4–22. Detector efficiency curves for various materials used as detector windows. (From Williams and Carter, © 1996, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
In addition to the fact that high-purity Ge (HPGe) crystals can be produced and no Li additions are required, Ge-based detectors offer the advantage that the absorption of X-ray is stronger (1 e–h pair/2.9 eV) and higher-energy lines can be analyzed as the related high-energy X-rays are not transmitted through the crystal. The width of the X-ray peaks is narrower for Ge detectors than Si(Li) detectors leading to better sensitivity and less overlap in measurements. Some AEM systems are therefore equipped with a combination of both Si(Li) and HPGe detectors for a more efficient analysis of X-rays from a larger range of elements. 2.3.3 Signal Processing The e–h pair-generated current is detected by the FET as a pulse signal that is subsequently fed into a main amplifier system as a voltage. The sequence of pulses, separated by a time interval, generates a staircase signal where each step represents a photon arrival and the height is linked to the energy of the photon. After the integrated signal reaches a threshold level, the FET must be reset to a base value by the means of a light pulse generated by a light-emitting diode in a “optoelectronic feedback” system. This is necessary to avoid saturation of the signals. Each step rise lasts in the order of 150 ns. Pulses can be amplified and shaped for subsequent analysis (to determine exact height and thus photon energy) with analog technology. Analog systems give the user flexibility on the process time of the pulse and thus accuracy in the signal analysis. High processing speeds of pulses (in the order of few microseconds process time per pulse) result in low energy resolution of the peaks due to the uncertainty in the pulse height and thus the energy of the photon. Low processing speed (about 50 µs/pulse) results in more accurate determination of the pulse height and more accurate determination of the X-ray energy. During analysis of the pulses, the detector is effectively not able to process more photons entering the detector resulting in analysis dead time, which represents the time the detector is not processing signals. Due to this limitation, the output count rate is not linear with input count rate at high X-ray fluxes. Count rates imposing detector dead times in the order of 60% are acceptable for modern systems and exhibit a nearly linear response. Above 60% dead time, there is a drop in the output rate with an increase in the input rate. Therefore, with thick samples and thus large photon fluxes, high processing speeds are required to reduce the process time and the resulting dead time. Recent developments have allowed much faster pulse processing with digital technology resulting in higher throughputs of signals and linear response of the system with respect to the input count rates. With digital technology, the voltage rise output from the FET is directly digitized and can subsequently be processed with numerical pulse processing techniques leading to reduced noise and better high-count rate responses. Details of the various tests and procedures to determine linearity of the system response and examples are given in Williams and Carter (1996) and Goldstein et al. (2003). 2.3.4 Peak Shapes The intrinsic width of an X-ray emission line is in the order of 1–2 eV. The width of the X-ray peaks as processed by the detector system,
297
298
G. Botton
however, depends on the generation of e-hole pairs and the noise introduced during the measurement process. A peak in the spectrum represent the distribution of X-rays “detected” at a given energy with each incident photon generating a variable number of e–h pairs due to statistical fluctuations in the generation process. The standard deviation of the number of e–h pairs produced is one of the factors affecting the width of the peaks. The noise of the detector system and detector collection artifacts, however, also contribute to the broadening. The broadening due to the statistical generation of e–h pairs is given by ∆Es = 2.35 εFE with ε representing the energy for e–h pair creation (3.8 eV in Si, 2.9 eV in Ge), E the energy of the X-ray peak, and F a parameter representing the statistical correlation in the e–h pair generation process known as the Fano factor, which varies between 0 and 1. F = 1 if there is no correlation between the e–h generation events and F = 0 if the processes are completely deterministic (the process is completely reproducible and yields the same result time after time). Noise and artifacts also contribute to the broadening ∆EN yielding a total broadening of a Gaussian peak distribution ∆E = FWHM (full width at half maximum) of the X-ray peaks as ∆E2 = (∆Es)2 + (∆EN)2 = (2.35)2 εFE + (∆EN)2
(4)
For Si(Li), F = 0.12, and the FWHM of the MnKα line (used as a reference for resolution because of availability of radioactive standards producing MnKα peaks) is around 138–140 eV. If the noise contributions were completely removed, the theoretical resolution is solely based on the e–h generation process and would be around 110 eV for the MnKα peak. The energy width decreases at lower energy with FWHM below 100 eV for light elements. Since the noise term is not linear with energy and depends on the processing time of the amplification system, a full prediction of the peak resolution depends on the operating conditions and energy. Reference values given for the MnKα lines are used to compare the electronics and detector performance and are usually given at optimum process time with typical values around 140 eV FWHM at the MnKα line. Improved energy resolution is achieved even for high count rates on digital detectors and with HPGe detectors due to the lower ε values (FWHM for MnKα is around 120 eV). Noise introduced by vibrations (e.g., mechanical coupling with environment and/or ice crystals floating in the Dewar) can also contribute to peak broadening, hence lowering the spectral resolution, and should be minimized. 2.3.5 Detector and Signal Processing Artifacts A summary of detection artifacts is presented here with further details given in more extended reviews (e.g., Goldstein et al., 2003; Williams and Carter, 1996). In perfect detector conditions, the peak shape is expected to be Gaussian but small distortions can arise if the generation of e–h pairs is perturbed. For example, recombination of e–h pairs in the dead layer or at lattice defects generated by high-energy incident electrons accidentally entering the crystal can give rise to a phenomenon known as incomplete charge collection. This effect gives rise to
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
low-energy tails in the peak distribution as not all the e–h pairs are collected. Incident X-rays can cause fluorescence of the SiKα line (or a Ge line). If SiKα photons are not absorbed within the detector and exit the active area, incident photons will have lost a fraction of their energy in this process equivalent to the SiKα ionization energy (1.74 keV). This will cause an “escape peak” in the spectrum at an energy Ees = E − ESiKα. This effect is particularly important when small trace elements are investigated since there is potential overlap between Ees and X-ray lines (for example Fe overlaps with the escape peak of the CuKα line). If the count rate is high, there is the possibility that two incident photons of energy E will be perceived by the pulse counter as one single photon of energy 2E. This effect, known as a “sum peak,” is visible when count rates are above the reliable limit of the system (which of course varies depending on the processing technology). High count rates, leading to dead times greater than around 60%, are likely to lead to sum peaks. Internal fluorescence peaks can be also detected if the incident photons generate a Si (or Ge) Kα peak in the dead layer of the detector, which is subsequently detected in the active area of the detector. This effect is small but can, once again, be significant for trace analysis. High-energy incident electrons can also generate spurious signals and damage the semiconductor crystals. The location of the detector and the operation of the microscope should be such that these contributions are minimized (for example, objective apertures must be removed during acquisition). 2.3.6 Geometry of the EDXS Detector in the AEM To optimize the solid angle and thus the collection of the X-ray radiation generated by the incident electron, the detector is placed as close as possible to the sample area (Figure 4–23). The Si(Li) detector active area A is typically 10 mm2 with recent systems as large as 30 mm2. For a detector positioned at a distance R with respect to the optic axis (and the origin point of the emission) the solid angle Ω = A/R 2 (measured
Figure 4–23. Interface of the detector with the microscope sample area. (Adapted from Otten, 1996.)
299
300
G. Botton
in steradians) is the key parameter determining how effective the system collects emitted X-rays. For optimal solid angle, the detector normal is in direct line of sight to the emission point and not tilted away from it. Typical solid angles in current AEM are 0.13 sr but with combinations of large detector areas and effective coupling with the microscope specimen area, solid angles in the order of 0.3 sr have been achieved. For Ω = 0.13 sr the fraction of collected X-rays with respect to the full emission solid angle is only 1%! The detection of X-rays is therefore a very inefficient process considering that the X-ray emission is fully isotropic. The elevation angle (also known as the “take-off” angle in the literature) is an important parameter affecting the quantification of data through the absorption correction and the quality of the spectra. A large elevation angle minimizes the path length of X-rays into the sample (see the quantification section) and also reduces the continuum background emission, which is forward peaked. High detector elevation angles, however, are impractical in the TEM due to the fact that the detector would need to be above or within the objective lens at a large distance from the sample, resulting in even lower collection efficiency. In addition, backscattered electrons have direct sight to the detector and can cause significant contributions and potential damage to the detector. Lower elevation angles (0–20°) allow larger solid angles and lead to an effective shielding of the backscattered electrons by the objective lens magnetic fields. This shielding is not as effective for high elevation angles. The interest in large solid angles and the proximity of the detector to the sample lead to significant drawbacks in terms of spurious signal collection. The field of view of the detector is much larger than the sample area and X-rays generated by backscattered electrons or by fluorescence of hard X-rays generated in upper parts of the illumination area of the microscope easily enter into the detector (see Section 7.2). High-energy backscattered electrons can also enter the detector and generate additional secondary electrons/X-rays while low-energy electrons would spiral away from the detector due to the high magnetic field of the objective lens or the presence of a magnetic trap in the detector system (Figure 4–19). To reduce these effects, detectors are equipped with collimators that limit the field of view to the smallest possible area, thus preventing hard X-rays generated in the illumination system from directly hitting the detector, and contain baffles that reduce the effects of potential incident backscattered electrons that might enter the collimation system. Many other contributions arising from stray electrons hitting the microscope components such as apertures, cold traps, the polepieces, etc. lead to increased noncharacteristic signals resulting in weak detection limits. As demonstrated in the work of Nicholson et al. (1982), many of these contributions can be reduced by improving the microscope and detector chamber using coatings to cover the microscope components with low atomic number materials and by improving the collimation system. These effects can be minimized in systems using the precautions discussed in Section 7.2.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
2.4 EELS 2.4.1 Spectrometers The measurement of energy losses suffered by the incident electrons as they exit the sample is carried out with energy loss spectrometers. These devices also make it possible to select electrons with a particular energy loss (or no loss at all) with the use of energy-selecting slits. The ability to select electrons with a particular energy loss is called energyfiltered microscopy. The technique also allows the operator to obtain images and diffraction patterns where parts of the inelastically scattered electrons are filtered out so that information deriving from the elastically scattered electrons only is used. These instruments are based on the use of a magnetic field that modifies the trajectory of the electron according to the electron energy. The radius of curvature Re of the electron trajectory is related to their velocity ν and magnetic field strength Bf as Re =
γ m0 v eBf
(5)
where γ = 1 1 − v 2 c 2 is the relativistic factor and m0 is the rest mass of the electron. Slower electrons will follow trajectories with a smaller radius of curvature and will be dispersed on a detector plane located after the spectrometer. The dispersion refers to the separation of electron energies in space and is typically in the order of 1–2 µm/eV at 100 keV. The exact location of this detector depends on the implementation of the spectrometer and its coupling with the microscope column (see below). The most common electron optical component generating the magnetic field is a magnetic sector (used in various configurations, whether the spectrometer is implemented within the microscope column or after the viewing chamber of standard TEMs). Current flow in the prism generates the required field Bf that disperses the electrons (Figure 4–24). Other approaches to filtering have been implemented in
Figure 4–24. Prism spectrometer system showing the bending of electrons as they travel through the spectrometer. Dispersion of electrons according to their energy is achieved by the spectrometer in one direction and focusing is achieved in the other direction of travel.
301
302
G. Botton
prism-mirror spectrometers (see below) and Wien spectrometers, which combine magnetic and electrostatic fields in different configurations (Egerton, 1996). Two types of energy filtering spectroscopy approaches should be distinguished (Figure 4–25). The so-called in-column filter/spectrometers are located within the projector lens system/postspecimen area of the microscope column. These spectrometers generate electron trajectories and dispersion that will result in the transfer of the electrons into the projector lens system and viewing chamber of the microscope. The alternative approach is realized with the postcolumn spectrometers/filters attached at the bottom of the microscope column. In the case of in-column filters, energy loss spectra and/or energy filtered images (obtained by selection of electrons of a particular value of energy loss using a slit) are realized. For postcolumn spectrometers, dedicated imaging lenses are required to generate energy-filtered images after selection of electrons of a particular energy loss. Two implementations of postcolumn spectrometers therefore exist. For acquisition of spectra only, the magnetic prism is followed by a series of optical components dedicated to increase/vary the dispersion at the detector system. For energy-filtered imaging, a more elaborated series of nonround lenses (i.e., based on multipoles) and a removable energy selecting slit are used to provide both spectroscopy and imaging capabilities. There are various implementations of in-column filters. The earliest commercial applications were based on the electrostatic mirror-prism system initially proposed by Castaing and Henry (1962) implemented in the Zeiss microscope (Figure 4–26a). These instruments were developed on 80 keV microscopes and thus remained very popular for biological applications, although excellent fundamental electron scattering experiments were carried out on such instruments (Mayer et al., 1995). The first portion of the prism is used for an initial dispersion and the
Figure 4–25. Schematic diagrams of energy-filtered electron microscopes. The postcolumn configuration (left) is based on the simple prism attached at the bottom of the microscope while the in-column configuration (right) is achieved by various components inserted in the projector lens system.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
a
b
303
c
Figure 4–26. Various in-column spectrometer configurations. (a) Mirror-prism spectrometer, (b) OMEGA filter, and (c) Mandolin filter. (Courtesy of P. Schlossmacher, Zeiss SMT.) (See color plate.)
electrostatic mirror’s function is to deflect the electrons back on the second section of the prism and then the optic axis. The mirror voltage must be close to the accelerating voltage of the microscope. After the mirror-prism, electrons are dispersed and continue to travel down the optic axis of the microscope. Energy-filtered images are obtained by allowing electrons to pass through the slit and the projector lens system. Energy loss spectra, angular resolved energy-scattering diagrams (showing the energy loss distribution as a function of scattering angle), and filtered images and diffraction patterns can be obtained by careful selection of the operating conditions of the microscope and crossover points. This can be achieved by selecting, with the microscope postspecimen lenses (objective, intermediate), the object point entering the spectrometer and the transfer of the crossover points on the viewing screen. Subsequent implementations of the in-column filters in higher voltage instruments (100, 200 keV microscopes) are based on OMEGA-type spectrometers that use four magnetic sectors (Figure 4–26b) generating the dispersion and transfer of electrons back onto the optic axis of the microscope. Aberrations of the spectrometer that lead to loss of resolution in spectra and generate nonuniformities in the energy distribution of electrons in images are reduced by a combination of design of the magnetic sectors entrance and exit faces, the symmetry of the configuration (the fact that the aberration of the first two sectors is compensated by the aberrations in the opposite direction of the third and fourth sectors), and the use of a series of multipoles within the path of the electrons. These filters are introduced within the projector lens system (Figure 4–27). The last implementation of in-column spectrometers is the Mandolin filter recently developed (Essers and Benners, 2006) (Figure 4–26c). This filter generates larger dispersions (a factor 3 larger than OMEGA) and is optimized for lower aberrations. This system is ideally suited for energy filtering with very narrow energy windows and large fields of view.
304
G. Botton Figure 4–27. Schematic diagram of the in-column energy-filtered microscope (Zeiss-Libra 200). (Courtesy of P. Schlossmacher, Zeiss SMT.) (See color plate.)
Images, diffraction patterns (filtered/nonfiltered), and spectra for in-column filters can be observed directly on the viewing screen of the microscope and recorded with analog techniques (on negatives), imaging plates, or a digital camera following conversion of the incident electrons to photons using scintillator materials (YAG, phosphor, etc.). For postcolumn spectrometers/imaging filters, the technology is based on the magnetic sector (Figure 4–24). Aberrations of the prism can be minimized through design of the spectrometer entrance and exit faces and the use of multipole correcting elements before the prism. Only one prism generates the required dispersion to form a spectrum in the dispersion plane. The early spectrometers were used to generate energy loss spectra by making use of a serial detection system where the spectrum is scanned, using an electrostatic field, in front of an energy slit. The number of electrons (or the current) entering the slit is subsequently measured with a scintillator detector and photomultiplier with pulse counting or current measurement methods. This serial detection process (one energy recorded at a time) is extremely inefficient for recording large energy ranges (several seconds/minutes) and
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
therefore parallel detectors were developed in the late 1980s (Krivanek et al., 1987) to record a portion of the spectrum of 1024 energy channels. For this early technology, the slit is replaced by a series of multipole lenses (three quadrupoles) to focus and magnify the spectrum (Figure 4–28). These optical elements change the prism dispersion (from about 1.8 µm/eV at 100 keV) to up to 1 mm/eV at the detector plane (Krivanek et al., 1987). Incident electrons are converted to photons using a scintillator material (e.g., YAG) and a photodiode array (with 1024 channels) is used as the recording system with acquisition times as short as 25 ms. Recent commercial spectrometers have more complex optics (better focusing capability and aberration correction of the magnification lenses), new scintillator materials with improved transfer function, and improved transfer of the generated light between the scintillator and detector. Fast-readout two-dimensional arrays (now about 100 × 1200 pixels) allow acquisition of more than 100 spectra per second in commercial systems (the ENFINA spectrometer from Gatan). Noncommercial systems have achieved the same readout performance and used optical lenses to transfer the signal generated in the scintillator to two-dimensional (2D) detectors (Tencé, 2002). For the acquisition of energy-filtered images using postcolumn filters, a series of multipole lenses (Figure 4–29) is used to transform the spectrum at the slit plane back to an image (or diffraction pattern) at the detector plane and to correct the image distortions and aberration. This “transformation” is possible because both the in-column filter and the postcolumn prism are electron optical components that produce, at the dispersion plane, spectra that contain information on the object that
Figure 4–28. Schematic diagram of the parallel EELS spectrometer. (Adapted from Krivanek et al., 1987.)
305
306
G. Botton
enters the spectrometer. The slit allows selection of the electrons with the energy loss of interest, which is subsequently used to form an image at the detector plane. As for the in-column filters, both images and diffraction patterns can be obtained in the detector plane of postcolumn filters depending on whether an image or diffraction pattern is projected at the entrance plane of the spectrometer. Worth mentioning is the use of filters to remove inelastically scattered electrons from diffraction patterns (Figure 4–30) of thick samples to enhance the visibility of the dynamic structure in the convergent beam disks and to retrieve quantitative information on structure factors (Saunders, 2003). Further details of the optical function, aberration of the spectrometers, and filters have been described extensively (Rose and Krahl, 1995; Krivanek et al., 1991a, 1995a; Egerton, 1996).
a)
b) Figure 4–29. (a) Postcolumn imaging filter (Gatan Imaging Filter GIF); schematic diagram of the electron optics components and detection system (top diagram). (Adapted from Krivanek, Gubbens et al., 1991a.) (b) Actual spectrometer [Gatan’s GIF 2000 series spectrometer (Tridiem model)] and components (bottom diagram). (Courtesy of M. Kundman, Gatan.) (See color plate.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
a)
307
b)
Figure 4–30. Energy-filtered electron diffraction pattern of Si (110) orientation. (a) Pattern recorded by selecting only the electrons that have lost no energy (Zero-loss filtering) and (b) pattern recorded without energy filtering.
Alignments in postcolumn filters are carried out using automated routines tuning the multipole lenses functions so as to minimize distortions, aberrations, and the uniformity of the energy within the field of view so that every point in an image corresponds to the same energy loss (the isochromaticity). The detection of images in postcolumn filters can only be carried out using scintillators and CCD cameras. From a practical point of view, in-column energy filters offer the advantage that energy-filtered images can be directly observed on the microscope viewing screen while the postcolumn filters offer the advantage of being added to a microscope column as a optional attachment. As various implementations and models of in-column and postcolumns exist, a detailed comparison of the two filtering techniques should be carried out cautiously based on the type of application of interest and thus the specific relevant parameters for that application. 2.4.2 New Developments: Monochromators Based on the interest in energy loss near edge structures and for the purpose of increasing the temporal coherence terms of the imaging transfer function, the energy spread of the electron energy source must be decreased. One approach is to use electron guns with narrower energy distribution (e.g., see Table 4–1 in Section 2.1). This approach is limited to about 0.3 eV energy distribution with cold FEG as measured at the FWHM of the energy distribution. For cold FEG, the distribution is nonsymmetrical due to the nature of the tunneling process, which follows a Fowler–Nordheim distribution. Although this energy width allows the acquisition of good quality energy loss spectra where the intrinsic broadening of the features is in the order of 0.3 eV or greater, there are cases when spectra obtained with electrons having a narrower energy distribution is of interest (Terauchi et al., 1999; Egerton,
308
G. Botton
Figure 4–31. Various implementations of monochromators in commercially available instruments. Left: The FEI monochromator, single Wien filter. (Courtesy of P. Tiemeijer, FEI Company.) Center: The JEOL monochromator double-Wien filter. (Courtesy of JEOL Ltd.) Right: The lectrostatic omega filter implemented in the Libra Zeiss microscope. (Courtesy of M. Haider, CEOS GmbH.) (See color plate.)
2003; Lazar et al., 2003; Mitterbauer et al., 2003). This can be achieved with gun monochromators and improvements in microscope stability and spectrometer resolution (Barfels et al., 2002). Improvements in energy resolution to 0.1 eV have been obtained in recent commercial instruments based on various approaches (Figure 4–31). Three types of monochromators have recently been developed commercially based on the Wien spectrometer (Tiemeijer et al., 2001), the double focusing Wien spectrometer (Tanaka et al., 2002), and the omega-type filter (Uhlemann and Haider, 2002). The effect of monochromation on the energy distribution of the incident electrons is shown in Figure 4–32 and on spectra in Figure 4–33. 2.5 Sample Preparation Requirements Although the quality of the microscope and of the vacuum are key elements of good AEM work, sample preparation and cleanliness are certainly factors affecting the quality of the data. To avoid sample contamination buildup under the electron beam, plasma cleaning of the samples with dedicated systems prior to insertion into the TEM column has become a routine practice. This technique gently burns off all hydrocarbons built up on the surface of the sample so that diffusion of the species during analysis in the TEM is no longer possible. An alternative to this approach is to gently heat the samples prior to insertion on the TEM with a halogen lamp in vacuum (it is possible to build such a system with off-the-shelf vacuum components) at temperatures of about 70–80°C. Although this technique does not replace the plasma cleaning approach, it is a solution for samples that might be sensitive
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Figure 4–32. Zero-loss peaks obtained with a monochromator switched on using a Schottky FEG source (with stabilized electronics); the same instrument with the monochromator switched off and with a cold-field emission source (VG-STEM).
to the reactive gases used in the plasma process and often solves contamination problems due to the sample. Samples permitting, alternatives are also low-energy milling (a few hundred electronvolt ions) prior to sample insertion (with regular mills or dedicated lowenergy systems). Cooling samples in a dedicated cryogenic analytical holder in the TEM also reduces the contamination buildup during
Figure 4–33. Effects of a monochromator on the visibility of peaks of the Ti L23 edge in CaTiO3. Clearly resolved are the small triplet states in front of the first strong peak.
309
310
G. Botton
analysis but at the expense of increased drift rate during very long analyses. Removal of the amorphized layer produced by ion milling has become an increasingly common approach as ever thinner samples are used to achieve the ultimate spatial resolution in analysis. A combination of mechanical polishing and low-energy milling has proved excellent for obtaining very clean samples and minimal amorphous damage. Several manufacturers offer these new approaches to improve the quality of the samples. Often these methods make the difference between successful work, major scientific breakthrough, and plain disaster! 2.6 New Developments in Electron Optics In recent years, there have been significant developments in electron optics that have led to a new generation of instruments with much finer probe-forming capabilities making use of aberration correctors (Section 2.1 and this volume, Chapter 2). Although there is emerging literature making use of these capabilities, particularly with EELS systems (Varela et al., 2004; Arslan et al., 2005), results on EDXS are very limited at this moment in the open literature (e.g., Watanabe and Williams, 2005b; Watanabe et al., 2005). The main advantage of the aberration corrector of the probe-forming lens for AEM purposes is not the ability to form smaller probes (although a positive advantage) but rather the significant increase in electron beam current for a given spot size (see Figure 4–15). It is expected that the launch of commercial instruments equipped with such correctors will result in a dramatic improvement in the analytical performance of new AEMs. There will be new limitations, however, facing the users as electron beam damage will undoubtedly be the ultimate barrier in the analysis of most interesting materials.
3 Fundamentals 3.1 Fundamental Processes of Elastic and Inelastic Scattering The interaction of primary electrons with electrons and nuclei in the solid results in various scattering processes and the generation of signals that can be detected in different analysis tools such as the TEM, the scanning electron microscopes, or surface analysis instruments. We can subdivide these processes into elastic and inelastic based on the energy changes of the primary incident electrons following the scattering event. Elastic scattering causes no detectable change in the energy of the primary electrons within the resolution of the measurement system typically available in the TEM. These processes do not give rise to “analytical” signals in the strict sense of the term but are nevertheless very relevant to the understanding of signal generation, imaging, and all discussions on spatial resolution as they significantly affect the angular distribution of the incident electrons, their propagation in the solid, and consequently the spatial spread of these electrons as they travel through the sample. Elastic scattering is at the basis of contrast mechanisms in TEM and STEM imaging and can directly
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
affect the interpretation of energy-filtered images. Furthermore, the powerful technique of Z-contrast imaging (see Chapter 2, this volume) is based on signals generated by electrons elastically scattered at high angles. The technique is commonly used in combination with analytical measurements using EELS or X-ray microanalysis and provides indirect information on changes in average atomic number within the area illuminated by the electron beam. Although traditionally this is not considered an analytical technique, this imaging method combined with spectroscopic measurements such as EDXS and EELS provides the most powerful ability to analyze materials with the highest spatial resolution. Inelastic processes are the key to all analytical measurements as they directly and indirectly give rise to the signals detected. Figure 4–34 summarizes the various energy loss processes generating the excitation and the subsequent signal generation processes by deexcitation. Analysis techniques focus, on the one hand, on the detection of the primary event of energy loss where excitation of single electrons from strongly bound core energy levels (inner-shell ionization) and weakly bound electrons (from the valence band) occurs. These excitations cause transitions of electrons from the deep bound states to levels just above the Fermi energy and the continuum. Energy losses for the primary electrons can also occur through collective excitation of weakly bound valence electrons in the solid behaving as an electron gas (known as plasmon excitations) (Figure 4–34) or from defect states within the gap of a material. In the case of EELS, the energy losses of the primary electrons range from a few electronvolts to tens of elec-
Figure 4–34. Various processes of inelastic scattering events from core levels, valence states, and defect states. Inelastic processes via collective excitation of valence electrons is also possible. Measurement of the energy losses of the primary electrons is possible with EELS. The deexcitation processes give rise to X-ray and Auger signals.
311
312
G. Botton
tronvolts (typically up to 50–60 eV) in the case of single electron valence excitation and plasmon losses while core losses range from a few tens of electronvolts (typically down to 30 eV) up to a few kiloelectronvolts for the core losses with significant overlap between these regions. Other processes of inelastic scattering leading to detectable signals in the spectra include the excitation of quasi-free single electrons (also known as Compton scattering) and losses due to radiative phenomena (Cerenkov effect). On the other hand, secondary processes give rise to other signals (Figure 4–3) used in analytical techniques. The deexcitation process leads to the generation of photons detected with EDXS or Auger electrons with related characteristic energies. 3.2 Elastic Cross Sections As discussed above, some theoretical background on elastic scattering is useful to understand electron propagation in the sample and the related contributions on inelastic signal generation. A good understanding of elastic scattering is particularly useful to simulate electron trajectories and to estimate the electron beam broadening and thus the spatial resolution in analytical measurements. We will follow the description given in detail by Reimer (1995) and Egerton (1996) using the terminology adopted by R.F. Egerton. The differential elastic cross section dσ/dΩ representing the probability of scattering per unit solid angle dΩ is given by dσ = f dΩ
2
(6)
where the amplitude of the scattering factor f is directly proportional to the Fourier transform of the potential of the atom. Various models and approximations of the potential can be used. In its simplest form, the potential considers the unscreened electrostatic Coulomb potential of type V (r) =
Ze 4 πε 0 r
(7)
for a free atom yielding the Rutherford cross section dσ 4 γ 2 Z 2 = 2 4 dΩ a0 q
(8)
where a0 is the Bohr radius, γ is the relativistic factor [γ2 = (1 − v2/c2)−1], q = 2k0 sin (θ/2) represents the amplitude of the scattering vector q shown in Figure 4–35, h¯ k0 = γm0v represents the momentum of the incident electron, q is the scattering vector defined in Figure 4–35, and h¯ q0 is the momentum given to the nucleus. This first approximation of the unscreened electrostatic Coulomb potential satisfactorily describes scattering for light atoms, for large scattering angles and high incident electron energy (typical of TEM). The model, however, needs refinements for elements of high atomic number, for small scattering angles, and low incident energies (in low
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Figure 4–35. Diagram for an elastic scattering process.
voltage SEM, for example) due to a singularity in the cross sections at θ = 0 arising from neglect of the screening. The Rutherford model can be subsequently refined by incorporating an exponential screening factor used in the Wentzel atomic model V (r) =
Ze exp ( − r r0 ) 4 πε 0 r
(9)
where r0 is the screening radius that can be estimated by r0 = a0Z−1/3. This potential and the screening radius lead to a Lenz model of differential cross section dσ 4 γ 2 Z 4 γ 2 Z 2 1 = 2 2 −2 ≈ 2 4 dΩ a0 q + r0 a0 k0 (θ 2 + θ 2 )2 0
(10)
where θ0 is the characteristic elastic scattering angle representing the width of the angular distribution of elastic scattering. The total scattering cross section is obtained by integrating Eq. (10) over all scattering angles π
dσ 4 πγ 2 2π sin θ dθ = 2 Z 4 3 dΩ k0 0
σe = ∫
(11)
A more accurate model of the potential considering electron spin and relativistic effects leads to the Mott cross section applicable to a large range of atomic numbers, low voltages, and low scattering angles. Based on the elastic cross sections and the number of atoms per unit volume na we can define a quantity called the elastic mean free path λe = (σena)−1
(12)
which represents the mean distance between elastic scattering events in a solid assumed, for simplicity, to be amorphous. In crystals, the elastic scattering must account for diffraction effects and the treatment of the electron distribution in the solid follows the diffraction theory developed elsewhere in this volume. With the development of Z-contrast imaging as one of the tools available in the analytical electron microscope and use of this technique with electron probes of diameter smaller than the unit cell, the characteristics of electron beam propagation in the sample become important. Detailed calculations with the multislice technique have shown that when a
313
314
G. Botton
small probe is positioned on an atomic column, electrons are channeled along the column for samples of thicknesses up to a few nanometers. When the beam is positioned in between the columns it strongly disperses and broadens while propagating in the sample (Dwyer & Etheridge, 2003) (Figure 4–36). This effect is probe size dependent with the channeling conditions being more relaxed with “larger” probes of 0.2 nm. Calculations show that the electron intensity builds up in the adjacent columns as the electron beam propagates (Figure 4–36b). The effect is demonstrated in other calculations (Voyles and Muller, 2004; Mobus and Nufer, 2003) showing that the beam can channel on an adjacent column and give rise to a signal even if not nominally on the initial position (Figures 4–36b, 4–37b). Although these effects are not part of the traditional AEM literature, they are becoming increasingly relevant when the very smallest probes produced by aberrationcorrected instruments are used to achieve the ultimate spatial resolution in very thin samples (Section 5.1). 3.3 Inelastic Scattering Cross Sections Before describing the cross sections of various inelastic processes, it is useful to review the concept of the total inelastic cross sections so that a comparison of elastic and inelastic scattering distributions can be made. The total inelastic cross section is also relevant to understand the process of energy losses that slow down the electrons in thin foils or in bulk samples. This concept is useful in the modeling of electron propagation in samples using Monte Carlo methods. The differential inelastic cross section can be calculated by dσ i 4 γ 2 Z 1 = 2 4 1 − (13) 2 dΩ a0 q [1 + ( qr0 )2 ] where γ, a0, and r0 are as described in Section 3.2. As the scattering vector q is energy loss dependent (Section 3.4), it is approximated for the purpose of the evaluation of the total cross sections by q2 ≈ k20 (θ 2 + θ¯ E2 )
(14)
where k0 = 2π/λ = γm0v/h¯ is the magnitude of incident wavevector, θ is – the scattering angle, and θ¯ E = E/(γm0v2) is the characteristic scattering – angle corresponding to the mean energy loss E. As pointed out in Egerton (1996), the first term of the expression of the total inelastic cross section [Eq. (13)] is similar to the Rutherford elastic cross section with a second term being described by the inelastic form factor. Substitution of the scattering vector by the scattering angle leads to the angular dependence of total inelastic scattering (Colliex & Mory, 1984) θ04 dσ i 4 γ 2 Z 1 = 2 4 1 − 2 2 (15) dΩ a0 k0 (θ 2 + θ 2 ) (θ 2 + θ 2 + θ 2 ) E
−1
E
0
where θ0 = (k0r0) is related to the elastic scattering distribution defined in Section 3.2. As demonstrated in Figure 4–38, the expressions for the
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
a)
Figure 4–36. Real space intensity distribution of the probe electron density in the sample as it propagates through the thickness of the foil. Plots of the intensity distribution at two depths (100 and 500 Å) are shown for incident probe sizes of 2, 1.4, and 0.7 Å (as obtained with an aberration-corrected microscope) when the electron beam is positioned on the atomic column down the 110 orientation of the crystal (arrow length is 16.3 Å). The electron beam is channeled onto the atomic column, but the intensity maxima moves from one atomic column to the adjacent one (Dwyer and Etheridge, 2003). (Images courtesy of C. Dwyer and J. Etheridge.) (b) Alternate visualization of the process of channeling viewed as a function of thickness. The beam intensity clearly channels from one atomic column to the adjacent one as the electrons propagate in the sample (Voyles and Muller, © 2004. Reprinted with permission from Cambridge University Press.)
b)
315
316
G. Botton
0.7 Å probe ON column
0.7 Å probe OFF columns
300 Å
300 Å
min = 0.00
max = 0.36
min = 0.00
max = 0.02
16.3 Å
a)
b)
Figure 4–37. Real space intensity plots demonstrating the dispersion of the electron intensity when the electron beam is located on top of the atomic column and when it is located between two atomic columns. The bright empty circles indicate the position of the atoms in the cell closest to the point of impact of the electron beam. Channeling is observed when the beam is positioned on the atomic column (a) while much stronger dispersion is observed when the electron beam is not on the atomic column (b). (Data courtesy of C. Dywer and J. Etheridge.) (For part A, see color plate.)
total inelastic and elastic scattering cross sections make it possible to compare the width of the respective angular distributions. The angular distributions are Lorentzian with an angular width of θ¯ E for the inelastic distributions and θ0 for the elastic distribution. It is also possible to note that the angular width of the elastic distribution (for scattering from free atoms) is larger than the inelastic distribution.
Figure 4–38. Comparison of the elastic and total inelastic angular scattering distributions for the C atoms at 100 keV. The characteristic angles for the inelastic and elastic distributions (θE and θ0), the mean angle θ¯ , the median angle θ˜, and the root-mean-square angle θrms are shown. (From Egerton, © 1996, with permission from Springer Science+ Business Media.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
The total cross section integrated up to a scattering angle β is relevant when calculating the inelastic free path or the stopping power (see below) σ i (β ) =
8 πγ 2 Z1 3 (β 2 + θE2 ) (θ02 + θE2 ) ln 2 2 2 2 k02 θE (β + θ0 + θE )
(16)
The total inelastic scattering cross section integrated over all scattering angles is approximated by σi ≈ 16πγ2Z1/3 ln (θ0/θE) ≈ 8πγ2Z1/3 ln (2/θE)
(17)
by replacing the cutoff angle θ0 with the Bethe-ridge angle (2θE)1/2. This expression leads to a comparison of the relative magnitude of the elastic and inelastic cross sections as described by σi/σe ≈ 2 ln (2/θ¯ E)/Z = C/Z (18) where the coefficient C (around 20) does not vary significantly with atomic number and incident electron energy. This expression can be used to calculate the scattering contrast as defined in Reimer (1995) and to interpret the contrast in STEM images obtained by calculating the ratio of inelastic and elastic signals. These calculations are a good first approximation of the behavior of the inelastic cross sections with further refinements, accounting for the outer-shell electrons, leading to systematic variations in the total cross sections related to the filling of the periodic table. Minima in the inelastic cross sections occur for atoms with closed shell while maxima occur for atoms filling the s shell due to strong effects of valence excitations (Egerton, 1996) (Figure 4–39). The importance of the total inelastic cross section becomes apparent in AEM as it forms the basis of calculations of the stopping power of the electrons in the solid. This quantity is therefore relevant to understanding the propagation of the electrons and simulation of electron trajectories in Monte Carlo simulations (Section 5.1): S=
dE = na Eσ i dz
(19)
– where E is the energy loss, z is the distance traveled in the sample, E is the mean energy loss for the inelastic event, and na is the number of atoms in the solid per unit volume. The total inelastic cross section considers all possible events giving – rise to energy losses represented by an average energy loss E and does not consider the individual interactions of the incident electrons with the inner shells or outer shell atomic electrons. Predictions of the details of a spectrum and the intensity at a given energy loss, however, must take into account these various inelastic processes, their energy dependence, and the angular distribution of scattering. To do so, we must consider Bethe’s theory to predict the probability of transitions of electrons from an initial state wavefunction ψ0 to final state wavefunction ψn following interaction with incident fast electrons and the related cross section. If the energy losses and the momentum transfer are small compared to the momentum of the incident electron and there
317
318
G. Botton
is only one scattering event during the interaction (the first Born approximation) the cross section can be described by dσ n 4 γ 2 k1 = ε n (q) 2 dΩ a02 q 4 k0
(20)
where k0 and k1 are the magnitudes of the wave vectors of the incident electron before and after scattering respectively and q is the scattering vector related to the momentum transfer h¯ q = h¯ (k0 − k1) (Figure 4–40). The first term has already been encountered in the description of Rutherford scattering for a single charge [Eq. (8)] and constitutes the amplitude factor in the cross section. This term is modified by the inelastic form factor related to the transition matrix element defined as ε n = ∫ Ψ*n ∑ exp (iq ⋅ rj ) Ψ0 dτ = Ψ0 |∑ exp (iq ⋅ rj )|Ψ0 j
j
(21)
which expresses the interaction of the incident electron and the atomic electron via an operator exp(iq ⋅ rj) where rj is the coordinate position of the fast electron treated as a plane wave and the sum is carried out over the atomic electrons from j = 1 to j = Z. This form factor contains the information related to the properties of the material through the wavefunctions of the electrons in the solid (see Section 8.1). |εn (q)|2 is independent of the electron energy and solely dependent of the atom and its environment. From the form factor, the generalized oscillator strength (GOS) can be defined as
Figure 4–39. Total inelastic cross sections as a function of atomic number (80 keV electrons). Open circles are calculations based on the Hartree–Slater models, solid squares are based on calculations accounting for plasmon losses, and the solid circles are experimental data. (From Egerton, © 1996, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Figure 4–40. Inelastic scattering diagram showing the scattering vectors, the energy loss, and the effect of the classical impact parameter b on the scattering angle (also refer to discussions on spatial resolution in Section 6).
f n (q) =
En ε n ( q) 2 R ( qa0 )2
(22)
where R is the Rydberg energy (13.6 eV) and En is the energy loss of the transition. This term contains also information on the probability of the transition from an initial state wavefunction ψ0 to a final state wavefunction ψn. Using the concept of the generalized oscillator strength, the cross section can be expressed as dσ n 4 γ 2 R k1 = f n (q) dΩ En q2 k0
(23)
The full angular and energy dependence of the scattering can be described by the double differential cross section d2σ 4 γ 2 R k1 df ( q, E) = dΩdE Eq2 k0 dE
(24)
where the scattering vector q is expressed in term of scattering angle θ (Figure 4–40) and the initial and final wavevectors k0 and k1. For small scattering angles and small energy losses relative to the incident energy (as in typical TEM experiments) k1/k0 ≈ 1 and q2 ≅ k20 (θ2 + θE2 )
(25)
with θE the relativistically corrected characteristic scattering angle θE =
E E E E0 + m0 c 2 = = γm0 v 2 (E0 + m0 c 2 ) (v c )2 E0 E0 + 2m0 c 2
(26)
and the cross section becomes 8 a 2 R2 1 df d2σ 4 γ 2 R 1 df ≈ = 0 2 2 2 2 2 dΩdE Ek0 θ + θE dE Em0 v θ + θE2 dE
(27)
319
320
G. Botton
The first two terms of Eq. (27) represent a kinematic term of the scattering while the df/dE term provides the information on the initial and final wavefunctions of the electrons (including changes in the bonding state) either via inner shell or valence excitations. The second term imposes a Lorentzian angular distribution of scattering at small scattering angles as it contains the term θE representing the half-width of the distribution. At low energy losses and small scattering angles (i.e., q → 0), df/dE does not vary with θ and it can therefore be considered as a dipole oscillator strength. In this region of scattering (achieved by limiting the maximum scattering angle θ with a small aperture β) the response to the excitation from an electron would be equivalent to the excitation by a photon. 3.3.1 Outer Shell Excitations The expression of df/dE has been derived in Bethe’s theory using atomic models. To treat inner shell excitations, the initial and final wavefunctions of the electrons must be known. These wavefunctions vary with the chemical state in a solid but the atomic models are still a good approximation for the purpose of quantification of the atomic concentration based on intensity of edges. In the case of a solid, however, wavefunctions related to outer shell excitations are much more strongly modified by the interaction between atoms and the collective behavior of the electrons. Similarly, to model fine modulations in the edges simple atomic models are not sufficient (Section 8.1). To consider these effects it is more convenient to consider the dielectric response of the medium ε(q,E) to the incident electron treated as a point charge perturbing the solid. The dielectric formulation of scattering relates the double differential scattering cross section to Im [ − 1 ε ( q, E)] 1 d2σ ≈ dΩdE π 2 a0 m0 v 2 na θ 2 + θE2
(28)
thus the GOS relates to the dielectric function as df 2E −1 ( q, E) = 2 Im dE πEa ε ( q, E)
(29)
where E2a = h¯ 2nae2/(ε0m0), na is the number of electrons per unit volume, and Im[−1/ε(q,E)] is the loss function that contains all the material dependence via the complex dielectric response of the solid ε = ε1 + iε2 to electromagnetic radiation. The real part of the dielectric function Re[ε(q,E) − 1] = ε1(q,E) − 1 is related to the polarizability of the medium and the imaginary part Im[ε(q,E)] = ε2 is related to the absorption. Maxima in the loss function Im(−1/ε) = ε2/(ε21 + ε22) that result in strong peaks in the energy loss spectra (Figure 4–7) occur when ε1 = 0 and ε2 is small (the damping is weak). The condition ε1 = 0 suggests that a condition of resonance is met and that the medium in unstable. This instability corresponds to creation of a quasiparticle called plasmon of energy Ea. Further discussion on the derivation of the loss function and applications can be found in Section 8.2.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
3.4 Calculations of Cross Sections Quantification of EELS and EDXS spectra based on signals recorded from edges and X-ray peaks (Section 4) is based on the knowledge of cross sections. For inner shell excitations in EELS (and the related EDXS peaks) it is assumed, as a first approximation, that the initial and final wavefunctions are not affected by collective electron behavior and the cross sections can be calculated using various models based either on the simple hydrogenic description of the atomic electrons or the more accurate Hartree–Slater method. For an atom of atomic number Z, the hydrogenic model uses the simplification of the electrostatic potential arising from the treatment of the nuclear charge Ze and the screening due to remaining inner nonexcited electrons. Different expressions of the effective charges are used for K and L shells and consideration is given to the presence of outer electrons in higher energy levels that modify the binding energy of the inner shell electrons. Solving the Schrödinger equation in the revised simplified potential leads to analytical solutions that can be easily calculated for K shells using programs developed by Egerton (1996). The treatment of L shells, although initially unsuccessful due to the simplifications of the hydrogenic model, was revised by considering experimental optical and energy loss data with built-in corrections. These modifications have led to improved accuracy in the treatment of L shells for transition metals; programs and models for L shells are also available (Egerton, 1996) in the literature and in commercial EELS analysis programs (the Digital Micrograph software from Gatan). Empirical modifications of the hydrogenic models for M edges have also been developed (Luo & Zeitler, 1991). The Hartree–Slater (HS) approach requires iterative solutions that lead to more accurate cross sections that consider a potential calculated based on the charge density of the electrons in a selfconsistent manner. Cross section tabulations have been developed by Leapman et al. (1980) and Rez (1982) and the results have been implemented within commercial EELS analysis software for K, L, and M shells within Digital Micrograph. The HS model predicts more realistic shapes of edges and includes corrections for sharp features related to unoccupied bound states present on transition metal L edges. Recent developments allow the combination of solid-state effects near the edge threshold, calculated from band structure techniques, with the atomic models at higher energy losses into more accurate cross section models (Potapov et al., 2004). 3.4.1 Angular and Energy Dependence of the GOS Some physical insight into the scattering process is given by the analysis of the angular and energy dependence of the GOS df(q,E)/dE, known as the Bethe surface, as plotted for the C K edge (Figure 4–41a). This plot also provides information related to the optimization of the acquisition conditions as it shows the dependence of the differential cross section on angle and energy loss. There are two regions of key importance on the Bethe surface. At energy losses just above the threshold, the distribution is peaked at small scattering angles (θ = 0, q → 0) and the angular dependence in the cross section d2σ/dΩdE is controlled by
321
322
G. Botton
a)
b) Figure 4–41. (a) Two-dimensional angular and energy distribution of the general oscillator strength per unit energy loss (df/dE) for the CK edge (also described as the Bethe surface of scattering). The “hump” at high energy from the edge onset and large scattering vector q is the Bethe ridge. (From Egerton, © 1996, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.) (b) Two-dimensional schematic plot of the full energy and scattering angle distribution of inelastic losses including plasmon losses, core losses, as well as the Bethe ridge and the plasmon dispersions. The diagram shows the elastic scattering as part of Bragg peaks (as in a crystalline sample). Scattering from atoms or amorphous samples would give rise to a broad peak centered at zero scattering angle. The angle (β) and energy (∆) integration windows for the calculations of the partial cross sections are identified. (Adapted from Schattschneider and Werner, 2005.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
the kinematic term of the cross section since the GOS does not vary strongly with q at small scattering angles. This region of the GOS is known as the dipole region and represents collisions with a large impact parameter b (see Figure 4–40 and Section 5.2) and little momentum transfer. Spectra acquired with small scattering angles in electron energy loss experiments are thus equivalent to optical (X-ray) absorption spectra where only dipole transitions are allowed. Based on this equivalence, photoabsorption spectra can be used to improve GOS models for use in cross-sectional calculations (Egerton & Leapman, 1995; Egerton, 1993). The dipole transitions also imply that the change of angular momentum quantum number 艎 when the electron is initially excited from a core level “i” to a final level “f” is ∆艎 = ±1. At larger energy losses from threshold, corresponding to collision with nearly-free electrons, the GOS peaks at large scattering angles θC = (E/E0)2 corresponding to what is known as the Bethe ridge. Experimentally, this peak can be readily visualized by collecting energy loss spectra in thin samples with a spectrometer aperture centered few tens mrad off the transmitted beam collection angle (thus away from the forward scattered direction). This acquisition condition is equivalent to Compton scattering experiments between an incident electron and a free electron. As discussed in a review by Schattschneider and Exner (1995), a quantitative analysis of the width of this experimental peak provides information on the momentum distribution of atomic electrons. Similarly, by recording diffraction patterns of thin specimens with an energy filter (see Section 2.4.1) at high energy loss (few hundred electronvolts) it is possible to see a ring corresponding to the Compton scattering peak (Mayer et al., 1995; Egerton, 1996). The full energy and scattering angle dependence of the entire spectrum includes therefore the various processes of low-loss scattering (including the dispersion of plasmon losses, the elastic Bragg scattering (in crystalline specimens) and the core losses (with the Bethe ridge visible) (Figure 4–41b). 3.4.2 Partial and Total Ionization Cross Sections Whether we have to compute cross sections for quantification of EDXS or energy loss spectra, the differential cross sections have to be integrated with respect to angle and energy loss to yield partial or total cross sections. In the case of energy loss experiments, the spectra are recorded with a fixed collection angle β and the partial cross section is therefore related to the double differential cross section through integration up to an angle β dσ 4 R 2 ≅ dE Em02 v 2
β
∫0
df ( q, E) θ 2π 2 dθ dE (θ + θE2 )
(30)
where the GOS is expressed in terms of the scattering vector q and the scattering angle is θ. By considering the kinematics of scattering (Figure 4–40), q2 ≅ k20 (θ2 + θE2 ) and the integration can be either carried out over θ or, after transformation of variables and limits of integration, over q (Egerton, 1996). The partial cross section follows a simple trend as dσ/ dE ⬀ E−s where s is the slope of the function.
323
324
G. Botton
For the purpose of quantification in energy loss spectroscopy (see Section 4.2), core shell edge spectra acquired with a collection angle β are integrated over an energy window ∆. The integrated signal for a given collection angle β and energy window is thus related to the partial cross section as I1k (β,∆) = NI0σk (β,∆)
(31)
where N is the number of atoms per unit area, I0 is the incident intensity (approximated by the number of counts under the zero-loss peak), and σ k (β, ∆ ) = ∫
Ek + ∆
Ek
dσ dE dE
(32)
Examples of the values of partial cross section for light elements as a function of collection angle β are shown in Figure 4–42. These plots
Figure 4–42. Angular dependence of the partial cross sections for lighter elements. The energy integration is carried out over an energy window ∆ equivalent to 0.2 Ek where Ek is the threshold energy. (From Egerton, © 1996, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Figure 4–43. Comparison of cross section for various scattering processes for Al as a function of incident electron energy. The comparison shows the strongest inelastic scattering (dominated by plasmon losses P), followed by elastic scattering (E), L shell ionization (L), K shell ionization (K), fast secondary electrons (FSE), and secondary electrons (SE). The generations of FSE and SE are not discussed in this chapter. (From Joy et al., © 1986, with permission from Springer Science+ Business Media.)
show the increase of expected signal with increases of collection angle and the variation with atomic number. Note the asymptotic behavior of the cross sections for large scattering angles approaching 100 mrad. This effect suggests that by using large collection angles above a few tens of millirad, the collected intensity does not increase significantly. This asymptotic behavior affects the optimization of signals and signalto-background ratios as discussed in relation to the detection limits (Section 7). This integration over scattering angles and energy window is demonstrated in the hatched area in Figure 4–41b. For the calculation of the probability of X-ray signal generation following ionization, the collection angle of the primary electrons is irrelevant and it is necessary to consider all possible scattering angles of the incident electron. The integration must be carried out up to β = π, which includes possible backscattering. This integration leads to the total inelastic cross section for core shell ionization that is used in X-ray quantification (Section 4.1.1) σk ≅ 4πa20Nkbk (R/T)(R/Ek) ln (ckT/Ek)
(33)
where Nk is a number related to the occupancy in a particular shell (2, 8, 18 for K, L, M shells, respectively) and bk and ck are factors deduced from theory or experiments [(Inokuti, 1971, 1978; Powell, 1976), also tabulated in Goldstein et al. (1986)] and T is the kinetic energy of the electron. It is useful to compare the magnitude of the cross sections for elastic and various inelastic events such as K and L shell excitation, outer shell (including excitations of plasmons), and generation of secondary electrons (Figure 4–43) as a function of energy. Based on the inelastic cross sections it is possible to define an inelastic mean free path (mean distance between inelastic scattering of events) in a fashion similar to the elastic mean free path (Section 3.1). For an inelastic scattering event i, λi = (naσi)−1
(34)
where na is the number of atoms per unit volume and σi is the cross section for an inelastic event i (either total inelastic scattering or K, L shell excitation).
325
326
G. Botton
3.5 Shape of EELS Edges There are two factors that contribute to the shape of inner-shell absorption edges observed in energy loss spectra. The atomic calculations of the cross sections (hydrogenic of Hartree–Slater) give, to a first good approximation, the expected shape of the edge related to transitions from a core state to free continuum states. Although the general shape is reproduced particularly well at high energies from the threshold, details arising from transitions to discrete unoccupied bound states can be important. These effects are visible both in terms of the integrated edge intensity (particularly for transition metal L edges) and in terms of the fine details arising from electronic structure and the bonding environment in the solid state. These latter modulations are called ELNES. The dipole selection rules for the transitions from an initial core level to a final state (see Section 8.1) imply that there must be a change in angular momentum quantum number ∆艎 = ±1. This implies that the angular character of the final states (i.e., the symmetry) is determined by the core state quantum numbers. Making use of the nomenclature presented in Figure 4–11, the following rules can be summarized. For K edges, the principal quantum number is n = 1, the angular momentum quantum number of the core state is s (i.e., 艎 = 0), and the final state character is p (艎 = 1). For L23 edges, the core level is 2p and the final states probed are s (艎 = 0) and d (艎 = 2). For M45 edges, the core level is 3d and the final states will be f or p. Spectroscopically the K, L, M, N, and O edges therefore reflect the main quantum number of the core level n = 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, respectively, and each edge presents sublevels due to the angular momentum quantum number 艎 and spinorbit coupling due to the j quantum number (Figures 4–11 and 4–4). L edges thus present transitions to three sublevels for 2s, 2p3/2, and 2p1/2 giving rise to the L1, L2, and L3 edges, respectively, while M edges have five sublevels and so forth as summarized in figure 4–11. A summary of the types of shapes is reflected in Figures 4–44 and 4–45 along with a table (Table 4.4) showing the expected edges visible for energy losses up to 2000 eV. These edges can be detected in typical TEM experiments. K edges are observed for light elements up to Si
Figure 4–44. Schematic diagram of edge shapes. (Adapted from Colliex, 1984, and Hofer, 1995.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
a)
b) Figure 4–45. (a) Trends in K edges for light elements and (b) sp electron metals.
(1800 eV) and generally present a sawtooth shape. The overall edge shapes are relatively well predicted by the hydrogenic and Hartree– Slater cross section models although, within the first 30 eV from the edge threshold, fine variations due to the bound final states of pcharacter in the ELNES are present. L edges are observed for a larger range of elements and the shape of these varies with the atomic number. The L2 and L3 edges (also labeled as L23 edges) are the strongest in the series due to the large cross sections and the selection rules imposing transitions to unoccupied levels with large density of states above the Fermi energy (if there are 3d empty states). The L1 edges are hardly visible in typical acquisition conditions favoring the dipole transitions (i.e., small collection angle). The edges of elements Na to Ar present
327
328
G. Botton
c)
d) Figure 4–45. Continued (c) Trends in L23 edge intensities (called white lines) for the transition metal series. It is clearly visible that the strong peaks at the edge threshold decrease in intensity with respect to the continuum after the edge threshold. This effect reflects the filling of the 3d transition metal band with electrons. (d) Shape of delayed M edges (Zaluzec, 1982, 1984). (Courtesy of N. Zaluzec.)
the so-called “delayed edges” (Figure 4–44b) with a broad maximum of the edge intensity 10–20 eV above the edge threshold. This delayed shape is predicted by cross-sectional calculations and is due to a maximum in the effective atomic potential resulting in a “centrifugal barrier” that prevents the overlap between the core and the broad final
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
Table 4–4. Summary of Expected Edges. Edge
Level
K
1s
L23
2 p1/2, 2 p3/2
Elements Li-Si
Shapes a
Mg-Ar
b
K-Ni
c
Cu-B
b
M 23
3 p1/2, 3 p3/2
K-Cu
d
M45
3 d3/2, 3 d5/2
Se-Kr
d
Rb-I
b
Cs-Yb
c
Lu-Au
b
N45
4 d3/2, 4 d5/2
Cs-Yb
d
O45
5 d3/2, 5 d5/2
U,Th
d
state wavefunctions at low energy from the threshold. This poor overlap results in low values of the matrix element near the edge threshold (see Section 8.1). When the final state wavefunctions are very localized, as in the case of the 3d electrons, they are contained within the barrier and there is therefore a strong overlap with the core wavefunctions. This results in strong features at the edge threshold for the L23 edges in the series K to Ni where the 3d band is being filled and transitions to empty 3d electron states are possible. In these cases, sharp features, known as “white-lines,” are clearly visible leading to noticeable trends in the transition metal series (Figure 4–45). For the Cu L23 edge, where the 3d band is full with 10d electrons, the delayed maximum is again observed without strong peaks at the edge threshold. When solid-state effects result in changes in the electronic configuration, however, for example, when Cu loses 3d electrons when bonding to O (such as CuO or CuO2), white lines do appear in the spectra (Figure 4–46). In Zn and its oxide ZnO, however, the electrons affected by bonding are of s character and the changes with bonding are not visible in the L edge of Zn. White line features in L23 edges are observed for the 4d transition metals (the series Rb to Pd) at higher energy losses. The M45 and M23 edges are the strongest in the M series with large cross sections. These edges exhibit the same trends with delayed
Figure 4–46. Cu L23 edge in metallic Cu, CuO, Cu2O. The presence of the white line in CuO and Cu2O (as compared to metallic Cu) reflects the transfer of electrons from the 3d band to O atoms in the oxidation.
329
330
G. Botton
Figure 4–47. Nb M45 and Ba M45 edges. While the Ba edge shows strong peaks and a lower continuum past the edge onset, the Nb M45 edge shows a strong rising intensity at the postedge threshold.
maxima and strong white lines depending on the atomic number (Figure 4–47). For the series Rb to In, a delayed maximum is observed due to transitions to delocalized empty f states well above the Fermi level while strong white lines are visible for Cs to Yb since the f states are bound and are being filled in the series. The very strong white lines make these edges very suitable for detection of trace quantities of elements in samples. For Lu to Au, as the f band is completely filled, very broad delayed edges are present and their detection, due to the background in the spectra, is often difficult even for elements present in samples in large concentrations. M23 edges are detected for the K to Zn series in the energy range between 30 and 100 eV with plasmon-like features represented in Figure 4–44d. These edges overlap with the strongly varying background in the low portion of the energy loss spectrum and are thus difficult to extract from the spectra. Due to the large cross sections, however, elemental maps can be easily obtained with very high spatial resolution (Freitag & Mader, 1999). 3.6 The Background in EELS and EDXS The background in core level energy loss spectra (Figure 4–10) is dominated by lower energy loss processes such as lower core losses and plasmon/outer shell losses and the characteristic signal of edges must be extracted with procedures described in Section 4.2.1. In the case of
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
EDXS, the continuum background depicted in Figure 4–6c arises from the “bremsstrahlung” radiation (or braking radiation) as the electrons are subjected to centripetal acceleration forces in the Coulomb potential of the atoms in the solid as their trajectories are modified. The X-rays are generated over a continuous energy range from 0 eV up to the energy of the incident electrons. The angular distribution of the emitted X-ray due to the bremsstrahlung radiation is not isotropic as in the case of the characteristic radiation emitted following ionization and deexcitation. The distribution is almost forward-peaked with maxima in intensity a few degrees from the forward direction and very little intensity emitted in the backscattered direction. Hence the peak over background ratio is dependent on the location of the EDXS detector (lowest peak-overbackground with higher elevation angles) although additional difficulties in the acquisition of spectra arise due to the solid angle limitations and the instrumental contribution of the spectra (see Section 7.2). Expressions describing the continuum spectrum intensity (Icm) demonstrate the dependence on the incident current and the average atomic number – Z of the sample irradiated by the electron beam (Kramers, 1923) I cm (Ev ) ∝ ib Z
E0 − Ev Ev
)
(35)
where ib is the beam current, E0 is the incident energy of the electrons, and Ev is the energy of the emitted radiation. At lower energy, the recorded spectrum does not show the increase in the intensity expected from Eq. (35) due to the absorption in the sample and in the detector. Although the generated continuum spectrum does not show sharp features, in crystalline solids well-defined peaks can occur due to coherent bremsstrahlung reported by Reese et al. (1984) when electrons travel close to a zone axis. The coherent bremsstrahlung energy peak positions ECB are related to the spacing of the atomic planes in the direction of the electron beam (L), the ratio of the velocity of the electrons/velocity of light (v/c), and the elevation angle αE (Figure 4–23) as described by Spence et al. (1983) and Reese et al. (1984) ECB ( keV ) =
12.4 (v c ) L [1 − (v c ) cos (90 + α E )]
(36)
These peaks can be mistaken for minor constituent phases when they overlap in energy with characteristic peaks and can be minimized by carrying out analyses when the samples are oriented far from major zone axes.
4 Quantification 4.1 EDXS Microanalysis 4.1.1 Quantification in EDXS As indicated in Figure 4–7, there are several processes that need to be considered in the measurements of concentration based on the detected signals. First, X-rays generated by the excited atoms must travel through the specimen and are therefore subjected to absorption. These X-rays
331
332
G. Botton
can also cause possible fluorescence of secondary X-ray radiation within the sample, which generates additional signals further away from the site irradiated by the primary electrons. The subsequent detection process includes transmission through a detector window, various detector layers, and generation of electron-hole pairs in the solid-state detector device. All these effects need to be considered in the quantification procedure. We shall consider the different processes starting with the generation of X-rays in the sample assuming that the characteristic signals in the spectrum can be extracted from the continuum background by simple interpolation of the background intensity under the characteristic peak from the background on the low and high energy sides of the characteristic peak. As electrons travel through a sample of thickness t and are scattered at various angles according to the elastic cross section (Sections 3.1 and 3.2) losing energy as dictated by the inelastic cross sections and the stopping power (Sections 3.1, 3.3, and 3.4) they generate photons in the X-ray portion of the electromagnetic spectrum. The generated X-ray intensity for element A is I*A ⬀ (CAωAσAaAt)/AA
(37)
where CA = ωA = aA = AA = σA =
weight fraction of element A, fluorescence yield for the K, L, or M line, fraction of the total K, L, or M line intensity that is measured, atomic weight of element A, total ionization cross section for a shell K, L, or M for atom A in the specimen, and t = the sample thickness.
The total ionization cross section derived in Section 3.4 can be expressed in terms of the overvoltage U = (E0/EC) relative to the ionization energy EC and incident energy E0 commonly used in the AEM literature where the constants have been included into one single term and N, b, c are the same constants found in Equation (33) with subscripts related to the shell s, i.e., 6.51 × 10 −20 σ=Q= N s bs ln ( csU ) (38) EC2 When the thickness of the sample satisfies the thin-film criterion (Section 4.1.2), the absorption and fluorescence in the sample can be neglected. In this condition, the X-ray intensity still remains to be corrected for the detection process that includes absorption in the detector’s various layers and for the efficiency of the detector active layer in generating electron-hole pairs from the impinging X-rays (Sections 2.3.1 and 2.3.2). For each particular X-ray peak, the intensity detected must therefore include a detector efficiency term that describes how the intensity is absorbed IA = IA* εA where
(39)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy A εA = {exp[−(µ/ρ)W ρWXW − (µ/ρ)AAuρAuXAu − (µ/ρ)ASiρSiXSi]} {1 − exp[−(µ/ρ)ASiρSiYSi]}
(40)
and (µ/ρ) = the mass absorption coefficients for elements A in the window material W, the Au contact layer, and the Si, ρ = the densities of the window material W, Au surface contact layer, and Si dead layer, X = the thickness of the window W, the Au layer, and the Si dead layer, and YSi = the EDXS detector active layer thickness, The second term accounts for the detector thickness that generates the signal based on the electron-hole pairs created by the incident photons (the active layer thickness). Although these equations can, in principle, be easily calculated, exact values of the various constants, sample thickness t, and detector layer thicknesses are not known to sufficient accuracy and alternative approaches have been suggested to eliminate the influence of these parameters on quantification. The calculation of the relative concentration of elements (CA/CB) makes it possible to include all the constant terms both in the cross sections and detector response into one single term and thus eliminates the need to know the sample thickness CA (σωa A )B ε B I A = CB (σωa A )A ε A I B
(41)
The term within brackets is a constant for a given set of X-ray peaks for elements A and B, detector, and accelerating voltage. This term allows the user to relate the intensity ratio for two peaks to the relative concentration of the elements in the sample. The kAB factor approach suggested by Cliff and Lorimer (1975) makes it possible to simplify the calculation of relative concentration of elements provided that standards can be obtained so that CA IA = k AB CB IB
(42)
For binary systems, the concentration can be retrieved assuming CA + CB = 1 and for ternary systems a similar assumption can be made. In principle, the kAB term in Eq. (41) can be calculated based on knowledge of the terms within the bracket but the significant advantage of the Cliff–Lorimer approach resides in the fact that the kAB factors can be obtained from a standard of known composition CA and CB related to one reference element. As a convention, k factors can be expressed in terms of a standard with respect to Si and Fe (i.e., kASi kBSi or kAFe, kBFe, etc.) so that any set of kAB factors can be retrieved by k AB =
k ASi K BSi
(43)
Reference k factors can be developed with respect to any elements but references to Si and Fe were historically developed for users in the
333
334
G. Botton
geological science and metallurgy communities. Examples of kAFe factors are shown in Figure 4–48 and can be used as a good approximation to quantify measurements, although the exact values are dependent on a particular detector (and in particular detector efficiency) and accelerating voltage. Some tabulated values for a range of elements can be found in Williams and Carter (1996). Users of EDXS in AEM typically develop their own standards based on samples of known composition CA, CB to quantify unknown samples containing the same elements. These kAB factors would therefore account for the specifics of the microscope-detector system. Standardless kAB factors can be calculated based on the knowledge of all the terms expressed in Eq. (41) making use of constants tabulated in the literature. The fluorescence term can be derived based on the parameterization
Figure 4–48. Experimental kAFe factors for a range of elements (top) for Kα lines and (bottom) for Lα lines. The limits reflect the range of theoretical values obtained with different cross-sectional parameterizations. (From Williams and Carter, © 1996, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Figure 4–49. Fluorescence coefficient for families of lines as a function of atomic number. (From Egerton, © 1996, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.)
[ω/(1 − ω)]1/4 = A + BZ + CZ3
(44)
where the constants for K, L, and M edges have been summarized in Goldstein et al. (1986) and they give rise to the dependence shown in Figure 4–49. Parameterization of the cross sections and the constants found in Eqs. (37) and (41) have been discussed in detail in Goldstein et al. (1986) and show that relative errors in kAB factors in the range of 1–5% for K lines and higher for L lines (10–15%) can be expected based on the various sources of data and estimates of detector parameters as compared with experimental data. Quantification packages in modern AEM systems provide accurate quantification based on more precise knowledge of the internal parameters for the detector often not accessible to the end user. Verification of the quantification procedure is, however, suggested based on standards of known composition to validate the built-in procedures of the EDXS software. 4.1.2 Absorption The simple expression for the quantification of EDXS spectra with kAB factors based on standards, or with the standardless approach discussed above, assumes that the sample is thin enough that the absorption and fluorescence terms can be neglected, i.e., the thin-film criterion is applicable. Photons generated by the incident electrons, however, are absorbed by atoms in the sample via electron excitation processes while traveling from their origin point to the detector. As in the case of absorption of X-rays occurring in the EDXS detector, the strength of the absorption process is related to the X-ray absorption coefficient (tabulated in Goldstein et al., 1981) for a given X-ray line and a specific absorbing element. The intensity of the incident radiation (and not the energy) will decrease with an exponential decay (Figure 4–50) while it travels through a sample. Large absorption coefficients occur when low-energy X-ray lines are just above the absorption thresholds of the absorbing element, i.e., when the photoabsorption cross sections are high. At the other extreme, small absorption coefficients occur for high-
335
336
G. Botton Figure 4–50. Absorption process of X-rays and variation of the absorption coefficient with energy.
energy lines far away from the absorption threshold of the absorbing element. Considering these effects, the thin film criterion stipulates that the kAB factors should not change more than the arbitrary value of 3% (or less stringent 10%) due to absorption. If the generation of X-rays is uniform throughout the sample thickness, the kAB factor is modified by the absorption correction factor (ACF) term: Thin Flim
k AB = k AB
Thin Flim
k AB = k AB
( ACF )
{ {
} }
A B (µ ρ)spec 1 − exp− (µ ρ)spec cos ec α (ρt ) B A (µ ρ)spec 1 − exp− (µ ρ)spec cos ec α (ρt )
(45)
Thin Film where kAB is the kAB factor for the thin film without the absorption term, µ/ρ is the absorption coefficient for element A or B in the sample, and α is the X-ray elevation (or take-off) angle required to calculate the pathlength of X-rays in the sample (Figure 4–51). In practical cases, it clear that the 3% limit to the absorption correction is very stringent and severely limits the practical applications of the Cliff and Lorimer approach, thus forcing the use of the correction term and the measurement of the sample thickness. Examples of calculations of the thickness satisfying the thin film criterion [Eq. (45)] are given in Table 4–4 for the 10% and 3% criteria (Goldstein et al., 1986). By inspection, it is possible to note that to avoid absorption corrections, extremely thin samples are required when low-energy X-ray lines are generated in the sample and when there are elements with absorption thresholds in proximity of the X-ray lines. For higher energy photons (and larger separation between the photon energy and the
Figure 4–51. Absorption length dependence on elevation angle and foil thickness.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
Table 4–5. Thickness criteria for the 10% and 3% absorption limit. Material
Thickness for 10% limit 3% limit
Absorbed X-ray line
Fe–5% Ni
322
89
NiKa
MgO
304
25
MgKa, OKa
NiAl
32
9
AlKa
SiC
13
3
SiKa, CKa
413
6
SiKa, NKa
Si3N4
absorption threshold), absorption can be neglected in typical AEM samples. To illustrate this effect, Table 4–5 indicates that an NiAl specimen of 9 nm thickness would satisfy the 3% criterion, while a Fe–5% Ni alloy would require an ≈90-nm-thick foil. The calculation of the absorption correction factor implies that absorption coefficients are known, the density of the sample is known, and that the thickness of the sample can be measured at the point of analysis so that the pathlength of the X-rays can be determined. Although tabulated values for the mass absorption coefficients for pure elements can be easily found in the literature (e.g., Goldstein et al., 1986), the knowledge of the actual sample mass absorption coefficient and sample density means that the composition of the sample should be calculated in an iterative process where initial input of composition, and thus density and mass absorption coefficient values, is refined at each iteration step. An additional complication resides in the requirement to calculate the mass absorption coefficients based on all elements present in the sample even if only relative concentrations are of interest. The mass absorption coefficient of the sample is determined from A (µ ρ)spec = ∑ Ci (µ ρ)iA
(46)
i
where the composition Ci for each element is used. All elements where absorption is potentially significant should be considered, particularly for low-energy peaks in the presence of light elements where absorption is important. Similar difficulties arise with the determination of the sample density that must be deduced following a weighed average based on the concentration of the pure elements (whether the elements are detected/analyzed or not). Given the complexity of novel synthetic structures produced by chemists and physicists and materials scientists, extrapolating the density of materials is not a trivial task for some samples and the best approach to quantification is to avoid thick regions where absorption correction is required. An additional parameter required for absorption correction is the sample thickness that must be determined accurately. Various approaches based on convergent beam electron diffraction (Kelly et al., 1975; Williams and Carter, 1996), contamination spot measurements (Goldstein et al., 1986; Williams and Carter, 1996), and electron energy loss spectroscopy (Section 8.2 in this chapter) exist to retrieve the sample thickness. Their accuracy, however, is approximately 5–10% at
337
338
G. Botton Figure 4–52. Absorption path for two configurations of sample with respect to the detector. When the sample is rotated so that the detector is in position A (relative to the sample), the absorption length is significantly longer than when the detector is in position B (relative to the sample). (Adapted from Goldstein et al., 1986.)
best. An additional difficulty in the evaluation of the absorption pathlength, from the point of origin to the exit point of the sample, is the knowledge of the sample geometry and the position of the detector relative to the point of analysis. This is demonstrated in Figure 4–52 where the sample is tilted for analysis or when the area of analysis is not suitably positioned with respect to the detector (this might be necessary to achieve a suitable contrast condition in the image or to align an interface so that the electron beam is parallel to the interface plane). Significant differences in absorption corrections, and therefore relative concentration, can occur if careful consideration is not given to these issues during experiments (Glitz et al., 1981; Goldstein et al., 1986). Errors in concentration up to a factor of two have been demonstrated if the detector position is not known during the analysis (Glitz et al., 1981). Similarly, quantitative analysis of interfaces and grain boundaries should be carried out so that the X-ray path from the analysis point to the detector and the electron beam are contained in the same plane. This approach simplifies all correction procedures since the absorption is considered within the boundary itself and the X-rays are generated by the electron beam traveling within the same material (Figure 4–53). These difficulties in accurately determining the correction coefficients, density, exact geometry of analysis, and the detector efficiency, particularly at low energies, suggest that quantitative work on carbides, nitrides, and oxides is particularly prone to inaccuracies and error propagation so that complementary quantitative measurements with EELS should be carried out whenever possible. For higher energy peaks (such as transition metal K lines) absorption is significantly lower and grain boundary plane
incident e-
EDXS detector
sample
x-rays
Figure 4–53. Ideal geometry for analysis of interfaces and grain boundaries. The electron beam and the absorption path of X-rays from the generated area to the detector are all contained within the plane of the boundary.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
can more easily be neglected in TEM measurements on typical thin foils. Alternative approaches to retrieve the composition of TEM samples while considering the absorption effects are given by the extrapolation techniques developed over the past decade. These approaches involve sequences of measurements at increasing thicknesses as discussed in Section 4.1.4. 4.1.3 Fluorescence Fluorescence occurs when X-rays have sufficient energy to ionize atoms and new photons are generated by the deexcitation process. For example, the FeKα (6.4 keV) can generate fluorescence of Cr (5.9 keV) X-rays but cannot excite MnK (6.5 keV) lines. However, the FeKβ (7.0 keV) line can generate the MnK X-rays (although the contribution would be small since the intensity of the Kβ is about 14% of the Kα). At low energies, fluorescence can be important given the proximity of several lines. Although it is possible to generate fluorescence far away from the point of origin, fluorescence in thin specimens is not as important as in bulk samples for the simple reason that there is less material to fluoresce. The original developments required to correct for fluorescence effects are due to Philibert and Tixier (1975). Their model considered that the X-rays are generated from the middle of the tin foil and predicted small changes in intensities due to fluorescence. Improvements were later proposed by Nocholds et al. (1979) to consider uniform emission of Xrays in the sample including tilted sample geometries when element B causes fluorescence of element A: E ln E0 ECB IA AA (µ ρ)BA CA = CB ω B [( rA − 1) rA ] IA AB ECB ln E0 ECA B 0.932 − ln (µ ρ)spec ρt sec α
{
}
ρt 2 (47)
where IA/IA = the ratio of fluorescence intensity to primary intensity, ωB = fluorescence yield of element B, rA = absorption edge jump ratio of element A, (µ/ρ)BA, (µ/ρ)Bspec = mass absorption coefficients of X-rays from element B in element A, and the specimen, AA , AB = atomic weights of elements A and B, and ECA, ECB = critical excitation energy for the characteristic radiation of A and B. As in the case of the absorption corrections, prior knowledge of the sample composition (in this case of element B) is required for the calculations, thus resulting in an iterative process to estimate the correction term. This expression proved effective in correcting for fluorescence in very thick samples by modern AEM standards (Figure 4–54). Additional corrections for the fluorescence caused by the continuum radiation are presently considered to be negligible. 4.1.4 Correction Techniques The k factor expression [Eq. (42)] assumes that the sample is infinitesimally thin and corrections are not required. The thin-film criterion
339
340
G. Botton
discussed above states that corrections are not required if the kAB factors do not change by more than about 3%. This implies that estimates of the absorption correction factors using Eq. (45) are necessary if the thickness does not satisfy this criterion and that estimates of the sample thickness for the points of analysis are required. If the ACF is greater than 1.03 or smaller that 0.97, corrections must be carried out and exact measurements of the thickness are necessary. Similarly, fluorescence corrections are required if the X-rays of one of the elements generate significant X-ray emission from other elements present in the sample. The fluorescence correction term proposed by Nocholds et al. (1979) with estimates of the thickness is used to calculate the ratio of fluoresced intensity to primary intensity IA/IA for element A (and for the other elements present). When the correction term is greater than 5%, the thin-film criterion is not met and the correction is required. If both the thin-film criteria for absorption and fluorescence are not satisfied, quantification requires the related corrections CA IA 1 = k AB ( ACF ) CB IB 1 I + ( A IA )
(48)
where it is assumed that element A is fluoresced by element B and the thickness is calculated at each analysis point. As discussed in Sections 4.1.2 and 4.1.3, the calculations require “prior” knowledge of the sample composition, thus leading to the use of iterative techniques with initial assumptions of the composition and refinement of the compositions until there is agreement between the input and output concentrations. Various approaches have been proposed over the past few years to simplify the quantitative analysis of samples without prior knowledge of the sample thickness. These methods rely on the extrapolation of the composition for a “zero-thickness” sample based on several measurements obtained from areas of different (but unknown) thicknesses. These measurements would require a constant acquisition time and electron beam current during the series of measurements and a uniform sample concentration in the areas of analysis. The original approach was proposed by Horita et al. (1987) who suggested the use of measure-
Figure 4–54. Effect of fluorescence correction on the quantification of spectra as a function of thickness. The raw data show strong thickness dependence while corrected data are shown with Eq. (47) is independent of thickness.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Figure 4–55. Extrapolation procedure using the method proposed by Horita et al. (1987). The kAB factor is plotted as a function of the integrated number of counts of an X-ray line (not absorbed in the sample) as an indirect indicator of the thickness of the sample. Extrapolation to zero counts leads to the determination of the kAB factor of a thin sample. The nonabsorbed X-ray line must be of sufficiently high energy and far from any absorption edge.
ments of kAB factors at different sample thickness. By plotting the kAB factors as a function of the intensity of one high-energy X-ray line in the spectrum and extrapolating the curve to zero intensity, an “absorption and fluorescence-free” kAB factor can be obtained (Figure 4–55). This approach is based on the assumption that the high-energy X-ray line is not strongly absorbed and that its intensity is therefore directly related to the sample thickness [Eq. (37)]. This method can be used to determine “zero-thickness” kAB factors of standard samples and the composition of unknown samples following the extrapolation of X-ray line intensity ratios to zero thickness. Although extremely useful for the quantification of homogeneous samples, the extrapolation techniques are not suitable for the determination of the composition of structures where the variations in thickness cause overlap of phases throughout the analyzed area. For example, when the composition of precipitates in a thin foil is required, only areas where the precipitates do not overlap with the matrix can be analyzed. Various modifications to the Horita technique were proposed later by Van Cappellen (1990) for work on alloys, Eibl (1993) and Van Cappellen and Doukhan (1994) for work on oxides using the charge neutrality concept, and in light element analysis demonstrated by Westwood et al. (1992). 4.2 Quantification in EELS 4.2.1 Quantification Procedures The atomic cross sections (Section 3) describe the probability of excitation of an atom by a fast incident electron. The energy dependence of these cross sections provides a basic description of the shape of the edges (without any solid-state and bonding effects) while the partial cross section integrated for a given collection angle and energy window allows the intensity recorded in the spectrum to be related to the incident beam current and the number of atoms excited by the primary electron beam. The recorded signal for a particular edge, however, is superimposed on a large background due to lower energy excitations (including collective excitations and lower energy ionization edges). Therefore, even for elements present in the sample in large concentrations, the background can constitute the major contribution to the
341
G. Botton Figure 4–56. Background extrapolation of EELS edges. Fitting of the background is carried over a window Γ and integration is carried out over an energy window ∆.
∆ Intensity
342
Γ Energy loss
intensity at a given energy loss (Figure 4–10) and must be removed, prior to the integration of the signal of the characteristic edge, using an extrapolation technique (Figure 4–56). The extrapolation is based on a power-law dependence of the background derived from atomic physics (Section 3.4.2) Ib (E) = AE−r
(49)
where A and r can be considered as constants within a small region of the spectrum and their values can be retrieved based on a fit of the spectrum over an energy window prior to the edge of interest. The A parameter is strongly dependent on the intensity of the spectrum (hence, the current, recording time, collection efficiency, etc.) whereas the r parameter (related to the slope of the spectrum) varies between the values of 2 and 6 and is mostly dependent on energy loss and angular collection conditions. The fit and extrapolation of the background are carried out over energy windows (Figure 4–56) using leastsquares fitting after transformation of the intensity and energy to a logarithmic scale so that the intercept of the fit relates to the A parameter and the slope to the r parameter. Alternatively, nonlinear least squares can also be used. Once the A and r parameters are found in the fitting region, the extrapolation makes it possible to subtract the background and to extract the characteristic edge (Figure 4–56). This power-law extrapolation assumes that the contributions from multiple inelastic losses to the spectrum in the region of interest are small. For typical samples having thicknesses in the order of 50–100 nm, this requirement is relatively easy to meet at high energy losses (a few hundred electronvolts and higher) but low energy edges (<80 eV) such as AlL23 and LiK are particularly difficult to analyze due to the rapid variation of r and the contributions of multiple scattering (see Section 8.2). Very thin samples are thus required and more advanced approaches able to deal with the steep background and rapid variation of the r parameter for extrapolation are necessary. Polynomial-based extrapolation and/or constraint power-law (forcing the background to cross the spectrum at a given energy) can be used to deal with numerical instabilities arising from the extrapolation. To remove the complications due to multiple scattering when extracting low-energy edges, deconvolution of the spectrum using the Fourier-log technique is necessary (see Section 8.2). Fitting approaches
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
343
using reference spectra and multiple scattering convolution with lowloss spectra have been developed recently (Verbeeck and Van Aert, 2004) to deal very successfully with weak and/or overlapping edges (Figure 4–57). Signal extraction using difference techniques (Egerton and Leapman, 1995) has also been used to analyze very weak signals for elements present in trace concentrations (Leapman and Newbury, 1993; Shuman and Somlyo, 1987). A variant of this latter method uses a numerical difference technique (Zaluzec, 1985). This technique is relatively insensitive to the sample thickness. Following the extraction of the background, integration of the signal over an energy window ∆ must be carried out (Figure 4–56) to relate the signal to the number of atoms present under the electron beam. Assuming that single scattering is dominant (i.e., one single loss event occurs when the electron travels through the sample), the integrated edge intensity, obtained for a given collection angle β and integration window ∆, is related to the number of atoms per unit area N, the unscattered intensity I0 (the zero-loss peak is assumed to be nearly equal to the incident beam in a single scattering first approximation), and the partial cross section σk for the same collection and integration conditions I1k (β,∆) = NI0σk (β,∆)
(50)
Figure 4–57. Model-based quantification of EELS of edges using maximum likelihood estimators of parameters of spectra and variation of quantification with respect to thickness (bottom panel). Models include thickness effects and cross sections. The top panel shows that quantification with this technique appears to be less sensitive to thickness variations based on a series of measurements with increasing thickness (relative to the inelastic mean free path) on a wedge sample (Reprinted from Microscopy, 101, J. Verbeeck and S. Van Aert, Model based quantification of EELS spectra, p. 207–224 © (2004), with permission from Elsevier.)
344
G. Botton
Figure 4–58. Extrapolation of edge signals and the integration windows used for quantification. The integration of the signal over the window ∆ is carried out for the signal at the edge and for the low-loss part of the spectrum [based on Eq. (51)]. G is the value of the gain change (scale change factor) to visualize the high-energy part of the spectrum.
where the index refers to the single scattering assumption. More realistically, we must consider that plasmon interactions redistribute the intensity in the spectrum causing multiple inelastic processes visible both at low energy and at the core edges (i.e., core loss and plasmon scattering occurs as discussed in Section 8.2) (Figure 4–58). Furthermore, elastic scattering reduces the collected intensity by scattering electrons outside the collection aperture both for the apparent zero-loss intensity, relative to the incident beam intensity, and for the edge. In these conditions, we must integrate the spectrum intensity above the zero-loss peak so as to include inelastic scattering up to an energy loss ∆ (Figure 4–58). Ik (β,∆) = NI(β,∆)σk (β,∆)
(51)
Although this equation allows us to measure the absolute number of atoms per unit area, the more typical approach in EELS quantification is to use intensity ratios to deduce the relative concentration using Na I ka (β, ∆ ) σ jb (β, ∆ ) = N b I jb (β, ∆ ) σ ka (β, ∆ )
(52)
In this case, the indices k and j relate to the fact that different types of edges can be used for quantification (K, L, or M). When multiple scattering is removed from the spectrum through the use of deconvolution techniques (Section 8.2) the expression remains the same but the extracted intensity is obtained from extrapolation of the deconvoluted spectrum. 4.2.2 Correction for Convergence Equation (52) assumes that the incident beam is parallel and the angular distribution of scattering (represented by the Bethe surface in Figure 4–41) is not altered by any convergence of the incident beam. Corrections to account for convergence of the incident beam onto the sample, however, become necessary when the electron beam is convergent (α ≥ ≥0.3β) as in the case of analysis in STEM mode. In STEM configuration the convergence angle α typically exceeds this criterion (Figure 4–59). The relative concentration must be calculated by including convergence
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Figure 4–59. Relation between the convergence and collection angles for quantification of spectra accounting for the incident beam convergence.
correction factors into Eq. (52) that can be deduced analytically (Egerton, 1996) for each particular edge. The relative concentration becomes Na I ka (β, ∆ ) σ jb (β, ∆ ) F1b = N b I jb (β, ∆ ) σ ka (β, ∆ ) F1a
(53)
where F1a,b are the convergence correction factors that are dependent on the angular scattering distribution for a particular edge via the characteristic scattering angle θE. Correction factors must therefore be calculated for each edge of interest in the quantification and can be deduced from Figure 4–60 or from simple programs (Egerton, 1996). It is possible to note that for edges of very similar intrinsic angular distributions (i.e., two edges close in energy will have very similar θE) the
Figure 4–60. Correction factors F1 useful to quantify spectra accounting for convergence of the incident beam α. The convergence factors F1 must be determined for each edge based on the convergence angle α relative to the collection angle β. For each edge, the characteristic angle θE relative to the collection angle β must be used to identify the appropriate curve to be used in the quantification. The F2 curves are used only for absolute quantification. (From Egerton © 1996, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.)
345
346
G. Botton
ratio F1b/F1a is close to one and no effect of convergence is visible irrespective of the convergence angle. For absolute quantification, the correction of the expression relating the number of atoms and the recorded intensity under the edge [Eq. (51)] becomes necessary irrespective of the intrinsic angular distribution Ik (β,∆,α) ≈ F2 NI(β,∆)σk (β,∆α)
(54)
where the correction factor F2 ≈ F1 for α ≤ β and F2 = (α/β)2 F1 for α ≥ β and can be deduced from Figure 4–60. 4.2.3 k-Factor Approach All the expressions for relative quantification in EELS are similar to the kAB factor equations in EDXS microanalysis. In a similar manner, a k-factor approach has been proposed (Malis and Titchmarsh, 1985) to quantify EELS spectra, although the experimental and sample conditions (convergence, collection, sample thickness) must be very strictly controlled and reproducible. Once the k-factor has been determined on the reference sample accounting for the cross-sectional ratios and possible convergence effects, the same k-factor can be used to deduce the composition of the unknown samples as in EDXS microanalysis. Cross section calculations using the currently available models (Hartree– Slater or hydrogenic, see Section 3.4) and convergence corrections are already built-in in commercial programs that control the acquisition functions of the spectrometers. An additional calculation approach to deduce the cross sections necessary for the quantification makes use of tabulations of the oscillator strengths obtained from optical data (see Section 3.4.1). These methods require the acquisition of spectra in dipole conditions (i.e., with small collection angles) and within the energy range where the angular distribution of scattering is still dominated by the Lorentzian term of Eq. (27) (i.e., near the edge threshold). The methodology is described in Egerton (1993) and summarized in Egerton and Leapman (1995). 4.2.4 Limitations in Analysis and Quantification Although EELS quantification is not affected by absorption or fluorescence, there are major drawbacks in quantitative and even qualitative EELS analysis. The major difficulty is the strong effect of the sample thickness on the detection of EELS edges. For example, spectra from specimens of very simple composition a few tens of nanometers in thickness can reveal well-resolved edges while spectra from “thicker” areas (as thin as 100 nm) might show no edges (Figure 4–61). This severe limitation to the visibility of edges is due to the contribution of multiple inelastic scattering that increases the background under the edge. The contribution of multiple scattering, however, is not uniform as a function of energy loss and the quantification of spectra for increasingly thick samples demonstrates a variation of the apparent concentration with thickness. Systematic measurements of the ratio of two elements, for example, show that samples with thickness relative to the mean inelastic free path (Sections 3.4 and 8.2) t/λ > 0.5 are unreliable (Figure 4–62). Even when multiple scattering effects are removed with
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Figure 4–61. Variation of the visibility of spectra with increasing thickness of the sample. Thick samples will not necessarily show EELS edges even for major constituents.
deconvolution techniques (Section 8.2), the effects persist (Egerton, 1996), suggesting that additional contributions due to the angular distributions of losses are present and cannot be neglected in correction approaches. Calculations that include the contributions of elastic scattering (Cheng and Egerton, 1993) and convolutions of the energy and angular distributions of the scattering angle (Su et al., 1995) demonstrate trends that are consistent with the experimental variation of the composition with thickness. Correction programs have been developed to account for these effects (Wong and Egerton, 1995). The lack of visibility of edges in spectra, even for pure elements, implies that users should be particularly cautious about drawing conclusions on the absence of elements during the analysis of point spectra and particularly with the application of energy-filtered imaging techniques. In the latter condition, since spectra are usually disregarded and the acquisition is done in an automatic procedure, erroneous results can often be obtained if care is not taken to check the sample thickness prior to the analysis of spectra. Relative thickness maps should therefore be used as a routine check prior to elemental imaging to verify the applicability of the t/λ > 0.5 condition. The procedure for the measurement of the relative thickness is described in detail in Section 8.2.
Figure 4–62. Variation in the quantification of two elements as a function of thickness relative to the total inelastic mean free path.
347
348
G. Botton
5 Resolution in Microanalysis 5.1 EDXS Microanalysis Two contributions determine the spatial resolution in X-ray microanalysis. The first contribution arises from the electron beam diameter and the second from the electron beam broadening generated when electrons travel in the sample. The early analytical TEMs provided beam diameters of the order of tens to a hundred nanometers and the beam broadening within the sample was not a significant issue. Measurements using contamination spots demonstrated that the illuminated area on the top of the sample was essentially the same as the exit surface of the electron beam (e.g., see Stenton et al., 1981). The situation changed radically with the development of analytical instruments equipped with field emission sources capable of achieving probe sizes in the order of a nanometer or smaller (Section 2.1) whereby the ultimate limits in spatial resolution due to the intrinsic beam broadening could be probed. To determine electron beam broadening, we must consider that the trajectory of the incident beam is controlled by an elastic scattering process that causes the deviation of the incident electrons as they travel through the sample. Transport equations (Rez, 1984) and detailed multislice calculations (e.g., Loan et al., 1988; Mobus and Nufer, 2003; Voyles and Muller, 2004; Dwyer and Etheridge, 2003; and Section 3.2) have been developed to describe electron beam propagation [including the impact of sub-Angstrom beams (Dwyer and Etheridge, 2003)] but more extensive work has been carried out in the field of AEM using Monte Carlo simulations that consider the individual trajectories of the incident electrons, the elastic scattering cross sections that modify the electron trajectories, and the inelastic scattering that causes the slowdown of the electrons (Figure 4–63). Monte Carlo approaches are easily applicable in complex geometries of samples (for example, interfaces and particles), although they neglect the effect of channeling of electrons in crystal and therefore assume the sample is amorphous or tilted away from a zone axis. The Monte Carlo technique is based on the generation of random numbers that are used to calculate the scattering angles [via equations of the elastic cross sections: Eq. (11)], the pathlength between scattering events [using the elastic mean free path of Eq. (12)], and the energy loss between the scattering events [using the stopping power derived from the inelastic cross sections: Eq. (19)]. Electron trajectories simulated with the Monte Carlo method for thin films show the dependence of beam broadening on the accelerating voltage (Figure 4–64). The effect of the average atomic number and sample geometry can also be easily determined. With these simulations, it is possible, in principle, to evaluate the exit area and the volume containing an arbitrary fraction of electrons that will contribute to the generation of the X-rays signal and thus the spatial resolution. For example, the interaction volume containing 90% of scattered electrons is typically used as a reference in the AEM literature to determine the resolution, although more stringent criteria [with 95% of the electrons
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
Figure 4–63. Simulation of the electron trajectories in a thin sample of Au (100 nm thickness) using the Monte Carlo method for 100-keV incident electrons. Calculations of electron trajectories are carried out using the publicdomain code CASINO developed in the Gauvin group (Hovington et al., 1997) available on the web (http://www.montecarlomodeling.mcgill.ca).
(Faulkner and Norrgard, 1978) and 99% of the electrons (Reed, 1966)] have also been proposed. Although broadening values can be retrieved from the simulated trajectories in a few minutes of computation even on laptop computers or through web-based programs (Hovington et al., 1997), quick estimates of the electron beam broadening are necessary to evaluate the approximate loss of spatial resolution in microanalysis. Goldstein et al. (1977) developed a simple analytical model assuming a single scattering event in the middle of the foil thickness
Figure 4–64. Electron trajectories in a 100-nm-thick Au Monte Carlo calculations for 300-keV incident electrons.
349
350
G. Botton Figure 4–65. Simplified diagram describing the broadening of electronic samples. The parameter b describes the broadening at the bottom of the foil using Eq. (55) and the single scattering assumption.
(Figure 4–65) to calculate the broadening of the electron beam b that contains 90% of the scattered electrons: b = 7.21 × 10 5
( )
Z ρ E0 A
12
t3 2
(55)
where b is the broadening in centimeters, Z is the atomic number, A is the atomic weight, E0 is the accelerating voltage (electronvolts), ρ is the density (grams/cubic centimeter), and t is the specimen thickness (centimeters). This simple equation is the most common method to estimate the broadening and is most suitable for foils of thickness approximately equal to the elastic mean free path (see Section 3.2), although refinements were proposed to account for multiple scattering in thicker foils (Cliff and Lorimer, 1981; Goldstein et al., 1986). The spatial resolution can be determined based on the contribution of both the electron beam size (d) and the electron beam broadening (b). Early models proposed the addition of the two terms in quadrature R = (b2 + d2)1/2
(56)
to yield the resolution R, but the currently adopted definition is based on experimental evidence suggesting the use of a less stringent, but still arbitrary, average sum of the two terms leading to a definition of spatial resolution based on the broadening in the middle of the foil thickness as suggested in Figure 4–66:
Figure 4–66. Definition of parameters related to the calculation of the resolution with Eqs. (57) and (56) [where Rmax is estimated with Eq. (56) as the maximum broadening at the bottom of the foil] and R is the broadening in the middle of the foil. d is the diameter of the incident electron beam.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
R=
d + Rmax 2
(57)
where Rmax is determined from Eq. (56) as the maximum broadening at the bottom of the foil. If 90% of the beam current distribution is considered, the resolution becomes (Keast and Williams, 2000) R = d 2 + bd + b 2 3
(58)
Recent measurements with sample geometries that probe the electron beam broadening at the bottom of the foil have been published and have led to the conclusion that although the single scattering models predict the right beam broadening magnitude, these quantitatively overestimate the broadening observed experimentally (Nakata et al., 2001). More accurate models (Keast and Williams, 2000; Doigt and Flewitt, 1982) consider a Gaussian probe distribution of standard deviation σ and hence a probe with an FWHM of 4.29σ propagating the foil with a distribution accounting for beam spreading and the incident probe distribution (Keast and Williams, 2000) I (x, y , t) =
2 2 ib − (x + y ) exp 2σ 2 + βt 3 π ( 2σ 2 + βt 3 )
(59)
where β = 500(4Z/E0)2(ρ/A) and ib is the incident beam current. Using this more detailed electron distribution in the probe (as well as more simple models) as it travels through the sample, Keast and Williams (1999, 2000) determined the equilibrium segregation profile in grain boundaries based on composition line scans and twodimensional map measurements (Figure 4–67). Based on the Gaussian intensity distribution of incident electrons the resolution, for a given fraction of electrons Q, as a function of thickness, can be defined as Q=
1 h − R2 1 − exp dt ∫ 2 3 h 0 4 2 σ + β t ( )
(60)
where the integration is carried out over the thickness up to t = h where R is the diameter of the cone defining the resolution. The distribution is assumed circularly symmetric (since there is no dependence of the azimuth angle in the equation) and applicable to a two-dimensional case. By defining the resolution criteria based on the fraction of 0.1
Figure 4–67. Composition profile of S segregation at an Ni grain boundary. The profile is based on the modeling of the beam profile using a Gaussian probe distribution and Eq. (59) (Keast and Williams, 2000). (Profile courtesy of V. Keast, University of Sydney.)
S/Ni (counts)
0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0 -0.02 -4
-2
0 distance (nm)
2
4
351
352
G. Botton Figure 4–68. Resolution variation as a function of thickness for the 50% and 90% fraction of electrons within the beam. (Adapted from Keast and Williams, 2000.)
electrons within a given radius, it is possible to plot the expected resolution (Figure 4–68) for a diameter containing 50% and 90% of electrons. A comparison of the predictions with experimental profiles obtained on equilibrium segregation in Cu (for FWHM and at 10% maximum) (Keast and Williams, 2000) shows excellent agreement for thicknesses up to the elastic mean free path. With a dedicated STEM, recent work on grain boundary segregation and multilayer composite materials has shown that it is possible to detect submonolayer segregation at grain boundaries (Keast et al., 1998; Keast and Williams, 1999, 2000) and map the composition of quantum wells in semiconductor materials (Figure 4–69). EDXS analysis with
Figure 4–69. Quantitative EDXS elemental maps of In-rich quantum wells in semiconductors and related intensity profiles across the quantum wells. (Courtesy of V. Keast, University of Sydney.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
aberration-corrected instruments has been recently reported by Watanabe et al. (2005) and Watanabe and Williams (2005a). 5.2 Energy-Filtered Microscopy and EELS Microanalysis The spatial resolution in energy loss spectroscopy measurements is strongly dependent on the operating mode of the microscope during EELS analysis due to the illumination conditions of the area of interest, the effects of lens aberration, and the spectrometer coupling conditions. The contribution from the microscope lens aberrations comes essentially from the objective lens and can be calculated as follows. With respect to an incident beam of primary energy E0 propagating along the optic axis, the inelastic interactions that induce an energy loss E and scattering at an angle θ will cause a blur of an object point (and the image on the viewing screen of the microscope) due to chromatic aberrations R = M0θ∆f where M0 is the magnification of the objective lens and ∆f = Cc(E/E0). According to the Rayleigh criterion, two object points with blurred independent distributions can be resolved if they are separated by a distance giving rise to an intensity drop of 20% between the maxima of the summed distributions (Figure 4–70). The distance between these two points is defined as the resolution and is obtained as (Egerton, 1996) ri ≈ 2θE∆f ≈ Cc(E/E0)2
(61)
This resolution is expected for energy-filtered images acquired at an energy loss E when the incident electron energy is kept constant, the image is initially focused for electrons that have lost no energy (which is also known as a zero-loss image, Section 2.4.1), and the scattering angles are limited only by the intrinsic scattering distribution at the energy loss E (i.e., no limiting objective aperture is used). For images of thick samples, it should be pointed out that the inelastic losses can constitute the most important part of the signal resulting in significant blurring of images. These contributions can be removed by energy filtering so that the inelastically scattered electrons are removed with the
Figure 4–70. Rayleigh definition of resolution based on the overlap of two diffracting-limited functions placed in close proximity to each other. If the sum of the two intensity profiles shows a dip of 20% of the maximum intensity, the peaks are considered to be resolvable.
353
354
G. Botton
a)
b)
Figure 4–71. (a) Energy-filtered image of an Al alloy with strengthening precipitates. The image has been obtained by selecting only the electrons that have not lost significant amounts of energy (i.e., zero-loss image) and (b) unfiltered image (containing all the inelastically scattered electrons). Although the total intensity is reduced, the precipitates are more clearly defined with sharper edges in the zero-loss image.
energy-selecting slit and the images appear sharp even for thick samples (Figure 4–71). In typical conditions for optimum energy loss imaging at an energy loss E, however, the incident electron energy is readjusted so that the spectrometer is focused at the energy loss E (i.e., by raising the high tension of the microscope so that the primary energy is now E0 + E) and the electrons of the related loss are in focus. If an energyselecting slit ∆E wide is used, the resolution becomes (Egerton, 1996) ri ≈ 2θE∆f ≈ (CC/4)(∆E/E0)2
(62)
When the angular distribution of scattering is limited by an objective aperture β smaller than the angular distribution of scattering, namely θE, other contributions become dominant (diffraction limit, spherical aberration, delocalization of scattering) and the spatial resolution in elemental maps is derived from a combination of all factors as described in Section 6.2.3. For point analyses carried out in TEM image mode, the spectrometer entrance aperture is used to select electrons from the regions of interest so that they enter the spectrometer for analysis. In these conditions, the chromatic aberration will also cause contributions from areas further away from the spectrometer aperture-delimited area due to the significant broadening of the angular distributions and high energy losses. If no angular-selecting aperture (the objective aperture in this case) is used, the total broadening due to angular scattering up to the Bethe-ridge (θr = θC, which includes most of the scattering intensity, see Section 3.4.1) is rc ≈ θr∆f
(63)
while the use of an angular-selecting aperture (in the objective backfocal plane when the TEM is operated in image mode) will limit the
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
broadening to rc(β) ≈ β∆f. Once again, two cases can be distinguished: ∆f = Cc(E/E0) if the image is focused at the primary energy E0 and ∆f = Cc(∆E/4E0) if the electrons are focused at an energy loss of interest and an energy selecting slit ∆E wide is used (Egerton, 1996). The broadening due to aberrations is a significant contribution that cannot be reduced in current instrumentation, although work is in progress to develop chromatic aberration correctors that would significantly impact the ultimate resolution in energy-filtered imaging. Thus, at the present time, the ultimate resolution is achieved by limiting the illuminated area with the electron beam. Current commercial Schottkytype FEG instruments make it possible to achieve a probe size of about 0.2 nm with typically 10 pA of current (more with a cold field emission source). Spherical aberration correctors can be used to improve the probe-forming capability. These instruments have already been developed and implemented on different platforms by major manufacturers on both dedicated scanning transmission microscopes and STEM-TEM instruments yielding sub-Ångstrom probes with 10–20 pA current or about a few hundred picoamperes for 0.2-nm-diameter probes [Dellby et al., 2001; Krivanek et al., 2003; Batson et al., 2002; Krivanek et al., 2003; and Chapter 2 (this volume)]. With such small probes, however, it becomes increasingly important to be aware of the detailed electron propagation within the sample as discussed in Section 3.2. Since the electron propagation process in the sample is the same irrespective of the microanalysis technique probing various signals, elastic scattering does affect the broadening of the electron beam not only in EDXS but also in EELS measurements. The impact of this broadening on the degradation of the spatial resolution, however, can be somewhat controlled with the use of a collection aperture that limits the scattering angles entering the spectrometer. As shown in Figure 4–72a, electrons scattered at high angles (thus away from the forward direction and the incident probe distribution) can be eliminated with the use of an angle-limiting collection aperture (either the objective aperture if the spectra are acquired in image mode or the spectrometer aperture if the spectra are acquired in diffraction and STEM mode). Assuming that the elastic scattering distribution is large compared to the collection angle and that there is no strong Bragg scattering (essentially an amorphous sample) the fraction of electrons contained within a radius r for a given sample thickness t and collection aperture β can be estimated geometrically (Figure 4–72b and c). Based on Figure 4– 72b we can estimate this geometric broadening contribution for a parallel incident electron beam. For a sample thickness of 100 nm and a collection angle of 10 mrad, the fraction of electrons contained within 0.5 nm would be 85% and nearly 100% for 1 nm. These contributions can be small compared to the intrinsic broadening due to the convergence of the electron beam required for STEM imaging and optimal probe size (in the range from a few millirad to a few tens of millirad in the case of aberration-corrected STEM instruments (see Section 2.1). The latter geometric broadening contribution for a 100-nm-thick sample assuming optimal probe size with 30 mrad convergence in an aberration corrected STEM would be 3 nm! Although these numbers repre-
355
356
G. Botton
a)
b)
c)
Figure 4–72. Geometric contribution to the broadening of the electron beam. (a) The effective broadening can be reduced by using an angle-limiting aperture even if the real broadening still occurs in the sample as larger scattering angles (causing the broadening) are cut off by the aperture. (b) Diagram defining the broadening terms necessary to calculate the fraction of electrons scattered outside a radius r for a given combination of thickness and collection aperture. (c) Geometric evaluation of the fraction of electrons contained within a radius r. (From Egerton © 1996, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.)
sent an extreme effect due to the sample thickness, typical samples used to demonstrate the ultimate resolution tend to be in the order of 5–10 nm thick as required to limit the propagation of the electron beam within a single atomic column (Section 3.2). In these cases, the geometric broadening would be of the order of 0.1–0.3 nm. When the electron beam size is in the order of a fraction of a nanometer, a significant contribution affecting the spatial resolution is the delocalization of inelastic scattering, i.e., the excitation and energy loss can occur even for electrons traveling at a finite distance b from the target atoms and not only when the incident electron is “directly on the atom” in the classical particle point of view. This factor ultimately limits the spatial resolution in EELS analysis with aberration-corrected electron microscopes capable of achieving sub-Ångstrom beam sizes. As expected from the wave-mechanical perspective, the origins of the delocalization effect are quantum mechanical in nature and relate
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
to the uncertainty relation, but a simple classical treatment makes it possible to identify the significant elements related to spatial resolution. Based on classical scattering, the impact parameter b is related to the scattering angle of electrons (Figure 4–40): large scattering angles are indicative of a smaller impact parameter and thus interactions closer to the atom. Hence, measurement of energy losses carried out on electrons scattered at a large scattering angle would imply higher apparent resolution. The simplest treatment of the spatial resolution involving the uncertainty principle (e.g., Brown, 1999) invokes the time of interaction (∆τ) of an electron traveling at a speed v and at a distance b from the atom. The interaction time is ∆τ = b/v. Applying the uncertainty relation ∆E∆τ ≤ h yields bmax = hv/∆E with b considered the ultimate spatial resolution and ∆E the energy loss. For energy losses of about 20 eV (at 100 keV) the delocalization is of the order of 2 nm while for energy losses of 200 eV it would be 0.2 nm. A more detailed analysis (Pennycook, 1982; Pennycook et al., 1996) based on the same principles yields a delocalization with the form b=
vβ 2 β2 2 β θ + ln 1 + ( ) E ∆E θE2
−1 2
(64)
where β is the limiting collection angle (the maximum scattering angle entering the spectrometer) and θE is the characteristic scattering angle at the energy loss ∆E (θE = ∆E/2E0). The detailed quantum mechanical treatments by Muller and Silcox (1995) and Kohl and Rose (1985) as well as the work of Pennycook (1982) led to results (in terms of trends and order of magnitude) similar to the simpler analysis presented by Egerton (1996, 1999), who considered a spatial resolution related to the diffraction limit imposed by the width of the energy-dependent scattering distribution and the collection aperture. This approach can be deduced as follows. For high energy losses, the angular distribution can be broader than the collection aperture and thus the diffraction limit imposes a resolution determined by the collection aperture β similar to the Rayleigh criterion, i.e., 0.6λ/β. When the angular scattering distribution is not limited by the collection aperture (typically for low energy losses), the scattering distribution is limited by a cut-off angle θc = (2θE)1/2 related to the Bethe-ridge maximum scattering angle (Sections 3.3 and 3.4.1). In this case, the median scattering θ˜ angle containing 50% of the electrons is θ˜ ≈ (θEθc)1/2 and thus θ˜ ≈ 1.2(θE) 3/4. By considering that the limiting aperture containing 50% of the electrons is effectively given by θ˜, this diffraction limit contribution will be 0.6λ/θ˜, i.e., 0.5λ/(θE) 3/4. Combining the two limiting terms in quadrature, the delocalization contribution to the resolution, related to inelastic scattering of 50% of the intensity, is d50 ≈
[0.5 λ
(θE )3 4 ] + (0.6 λ β )2 2
(65)
Experimental measurements roughly agree with these estimates and more detailed quantum mechanical treatments (Kohl and Rose, 1985; Muller and Silcox, 1995) (Figure 4–73). More recent work deals with the impact of aberration correction and ultimate spatial resolution by combining the effects of inelastic scattering and sub-Ångstrom beam prop-
357
358
G. Botton
Figure 4–73. Localization of inelastic scattering as a function of energy loss for a collection angle β of 10 mrad. Curves are based on a Rayleigh approach to the evaluation of the localization. Various experimental measurements based on the literature are presented (filled symbols). (From Egerton, 1996.)
agation in the sample (Oxley et al., 2005; Cosgriff et al., 2005; Dwyer, 2005). This delocalization contribution enters the definition of resolution for energy-filtered elemental mapping (Section 6.2.3). It is important to note that elastic scattering can affect the apparent resolution shown in inelastic images due to the modulation of the signal entering the spectrometer. If strong elastic contrast is present (for example, lattice fringes, larger atomic number elements, or diffraction contrast), inelastic images might show features with apparent resolution that is not simply related to the inelastic scattering distribution but rather to the much more localized elastic scattering (Spence and Lynch, 1982). Lattice images obtained with inelastically scattered electrons can be obtained, therefore, at energy losses where the localization contribution is, in principle, larger than the interatomic spacing due to these effects. As discussed in Section 6.2, approaches have been devised to circumvent these effects by selecting the collection aperture so that the phase contrast, giving rise to lattice images, disappears and by normalizing the inelastic images with the background prior to the edge threshold (Freitag and Mader, 1999; Hofer et al., 2000).
6 Elemental Mapping 6.1 Elemental Mapping EDXS With the control of scanning coils of the electron microscope (Section 2.2) and by recording X-ray counts within a particular energy window
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
of interest under a characteristic peak or even the full spectrum at each pixel of a rastered area, it is possible to combine the intensity recorded for each element into a map to display the distribution of elements in the sample with a resolution appropriate to the experimental conditions and sample thickness. Due to the long recording time at each pixel necessary to obtain a statistically significant number of counts at each pixel and still maintain a small probe size compatible with the spatial resolution of the technique, the acquisition of elemental maps with EDXS can take several minutes to a few hours. Examples of such maps in the case of semiconductor materials are shown in Figures 4–69 and 4–74. Although simple unprocessed elemental maps provide a wealth of information on the distribution of elements, it is also possible to extract quantitative information on the concentration of elements based on the use of ratios of images and the use of k-factor analysis. Relative concentration maps for elements A and B can thus be obtained by processing the entire image rather than just integrated intensities under an energy window. The quantitative concentration map can be obtained as ICA/CB (x,y) = kAB[IA(x,y)/IB(x,y)] where kAB is the Cliff–Lorimer factor discussed in Section 4.1.1 and IA,B (x,y) are the elemental maps for elements A and B, respectively. Each elemental map has a background image (obtained by recording the intensity within a window where no characteristic peak is visible) subtracted prior to the quantification. The division is carried out pixel by pixel with the constant kAB factor. If absorption is not significant, relative concentration maps are insensitive to changes in thickness. Therefore, although raw elemental maps show changes in intensity related to variations in the projected density
Figure 4–74. Color-coded elemental map of a device showing the distribution of elements in the rastered area: red, Al-rich area; blue, Si-rich area; green, Tirich area. White, W. Interdiffusion of Si into the Al is noted through the bottom barrier layer containing Ti. (See color plate.)
359
360
G. Botton
a) Dark field image STEM
b) Ni map
c) Cr map
d) Cr/Ni map
Figure 4–75. Elemental maps of Ni-based alloy with intergranular product. (a) STEM image; (b) Ni map showing the variation of intensity due to thickness variations (from the top left corner to the bottom right corner); (c) Cr elemental map with similar variations in intensity due to thickness; (d) elemental ratio map for Ni/Cr demonstrating the correction of the thickness variations in the maps. The intergranular product contains a Cr-rich carbide phase surrounded by oxidation product. (See color plate.)
of atoms with changes in thickness, the ratio map does not (Figure 4– 75). When absorption is significant, this simple approach fails and absorption correction is required. For this correction, the sample thickness must be determined. To deal with strong absorption cases without calculation of the absorption correction factor (Section 4.1.2), quantification of maps through the ζ-factor approach have been proposed (Williams et al., 2003; Watanabe et al., 1996; Watanabe and Williams, 1999). The technique makes it possible to circumvent the problem of having to determine the sample thickness independently (with intrinsic large errors) by calculating the absorption correction composition and the sample thickness simultaneously. The ζ-factor relates the intensity and composition of a standard sample to the mass thickness for both elements A and B as
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
ρt = ζ A
IA CA
and ρt = ζ B
IB CB
361
(66)
where IA,B are the intensities recorded for elements A and B and CA,B are the concentrations of the same elements. If the ζ-factors are determined through measurements of standards of known composition and thickness via Eq. (66) the concentrations are deduced as (Williams et al., 2003) CA =
I Aζ A I Bζ B , CB = , ρt = I Aζ A + I Bζ B I Aζ A + I Bζ B I Aζ A + I Bζ B
(67)
Quantitative concentration and thickness maps accounting for this effect have been demonstrated (Figure 4–76). Advanced analysis techniques based on the full processing of the spectrum and multivariate analysis make it possible to extract the occurrence of the various phases without prior knowledge of the individual component phases within the samples. Examples of multivariate analysis at high spatial resolution have been demonstrated in AEM (Kotula et al., 2003) following initial developments in SEM (Kotula et al., 2001) and earlier work of line profiles by Titchmarsh and Dumbill (1996) and Chevalier and Botton (1999). These techniques are particu-
Figure 4–76. Quantitative elemental maps of an NiAl multilayer obtained with the ζ-factor approach. The gray scale represents the quantitative information on sample composition including correction for absorption. (Reprinted from Williams et al. © 2003, with permission from Elsevier.)
362
G. Botton
larly useful for the analysis of segregation at grain boundaries and interfacial phases. 6.2 EELS Mapping 6.2.1 Energy-Filtered TEM Mapping With both postcolumn and in-column energy filters described in Section 2.4.1, it is possible to retrieve images at specific energy losses by taking advantage of an energy selected slit. These images can show the distribution of elements following the extraction of the background from the images. Recent reviews of the technique and the applications have been given in Hofer and Warbichler (2004), Verbeeck et al. (2004), and Hofer et al. (2000), and we will summarize the approaches here. In the basic approach of energy-filtered elemental mapping, this extraction of element-specific images can be achieved through two different methods: the three-window technique and the jump-ratio technique. In both cases, energy-selected images at selected energy losses must be taken before the ionization edge and at the edge of interest (Figure 4–77). In the three-window method, two energy-filtered images (called preedge images) acquired prior to the edge onset are used to extrapolate the noncharacteristic background under the edge where the third energy-filtered image (called postedge image) has been acquired. The same power-law extrapolation model used for quantitative analysis is used [namely, Ib (E) = AE−r] using the two preedge windows. The elemental map is then obtained by subtraction of the background image from the postedge image. Because there are only two images for this extrapolation, the resulting error in the intensity of the postedge background image, and thus the subtraction, can be large. If the intensity in the recorded images is low and the background varies steeply at the energy loss of interest, spurious images with negative extracted intensity can often be obtained because the variance in the extrapolation can be larger than the intensity of the ionization edge. Since the signal in the ionization edge is related to the ionization cross section and the number of atoms (Section 4.2.1) images represent the quantitative distribution of elements within the field of view. The second approach to extract the distribution of elements is through jump ratio images. In this case, the postedge image is divided by one of the preedge images (generally obtained just before the edge threshold). Although these images are not directly quantifiable, they have the advantage that the noise is lower (no extrapolation is involved), the elastic contrast (due to diffraction, high atomic number, and phase contrast) is canceled as it affects both the preedge and postedge images in a similar way, and finally there is less drift involved as only two images are used (and thus a shorter acquisition time) (Verbeeck et al., 2004). This latter point significantly affects the spatial resolution of images as discussed below. Both methods can be applied with energy filters (irrespective of whether they are in-column or postcolumn) and also in STEM instruments equipped with serial spectrometers allowing the acquisition of energy-filtered images through an energy-selecting slit.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
363
Figure 4–77. Various approaches to EFTEM imaging. Zero-loss (ZL) filtered imaging (selecting only electrons that have lost no significant amounts of energy), plasmon imaging (selecting only electrons that have lost energy in the 10–30 eV range), and core loss imaging with the three-windows technique (extrapolation of the background under the edge) and the jump-ratio technique. (See color plate.)
Early serial spectrometers on dedicated VG-STEM and the first serial spectrometers from Gatan both equipped with scintillators and photomultipliers served this purpose. Parallel spectrometers and imaging filters equipped with single-channel photomultiplier detectors (Krivanek et al., 1994) or a fast array of photomultipliers (developed by the Ottensmeyer group in Toronto) (Ottensmeyer, 2004) were also developed in prototype systems but were superseded by the development of much faster detectors allowing the acquisition of full spectra at each pixel of the rastered area as discussed in Section 6.2.2. In addition to these basic energy-filtered TEM (EFTEM) acquisition techniques, there have been variants of the three-window and jumpratio methods for EELS imaging based on the development of more advanced acquisition software controlling the spectrometer, the microscope, and increased storage capabilities in desktop computers. One variant is the EFTEM-spectrum imaging method initially proposed by
364
G. Botton
Lavergne et al. (1992) and fully developed as very powerful tools for mapping and quantitative analysis by Mayer et al. (1997) and Thomas and Midgley (2001a,b). This technique is now implemented in commercial packages from energy filter vendors. The method is based on the acquisition of an information data cube consisting of a large number of energy-filtered images with narrow energy windows (from 1–2 to 5–10 eV) and small step intervals making it possible to cover large energy ranges around the edges [in some cases even from 0 eV to the characteristic core losses (Thomas and Midgley, 2001b)] so that the full information from the spatial distribution and energy loss can be retrieved with high spatial sampling (Figure 4–78). If the spatial drift of the sample is well corrected in the image stack using automated
Figure 4–78. Schematic description the energy-filtered TEM spectrum imaging technique (EFTEMSI). Each image obtained at a given energy loss is part of a three-dimensional data cube containing information on the distribution of elements. The technique provides detailed sampling of the spatial information with little sampling of the energy loss distribution (energy window widths can vary from less than 1 to 10 eV).
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
procedures (Schaffer et al., 2004), these datasets have the advantage that the background extrapolation can be carried out with much higher precision than in the three-window technique. Energy windows as small as 0.1 eV have been used on instruments equipped with monochromators and high-resolution filters corrected up to third-order aberrations (Hofer et al., 2005). Quantitative analysis to extract the absolute atomic density and deconvolution of the effects of multiple scattering are also possible since the full spectrum is retrievable at each pixel (Thomas and Midgley, 2001b). In fact, for each pixel of the image sequence the intensity can be measured and a spectrum of energy resolution equivalent to the width of the energy-selecting slit is deduced. Based on limited sequences of images with narrow energy windows (1–2 eV) and selection of spectra at the edge threshold, this approach has demonstrated that changes in the near-edge structure due to variations in the chemical bonding state of elements are visible (Muller et al., 1993; Botton and Phaneuf, 1999; Bayle-Guillemaud et al., 2003; Hofer et al., 2000). This capability suggests that similar to X-ray absorption scanning transmission microspectroscopy (e.g., Hitchcock et al., 2005), bonding changes can be visualized with EELS mapping, albeit with a spatial resolution typical of EFTEM images (see Section 6.2.3). 6.2.2 STEM-EELS Mapping The other variant of the more advanced EELS imaging technique makes use of developments in fast detectors, large storage capacity, and fast computers. The approach is based on the use of STEM instruments equipped with parallel or dedicated 2D fast detectors. The original idea of this technique was proposed by the Orsay group (Jeanguillaume and Colliex, 1989) and implemented in subsequent years by various groups (Hunt and Williams, 1991; Botton and L’Espérance, 1994; Colliex et al., 1994). As for EFTEM spectrum imaging, the STEM-EELS imaging is also commercially available from the spectrometer manufacturer Gatan. The technique involves the sequential acquisition of an energy loss spectrum (acquired with the photodiode array or a 2D detector) at each pixel of a rastered area. The filling of the data cube (Figure 4–79) is thus achieved by scanning the beam over each pixel of the area of interest (pixel by pixel in two dimensions or over a line across interfaces) with the third (and fourth) dimension in the data cube being the energy loss spectrum (energy and intensity). The advantage of this approach is the availability of the full spectrum at each pixel making it easy to implement various data-mining approaches. Signals can be extracted with advanced methods, including multiple least-squares techniques, and the detailed shapes of the near-edge structures can be fitted with reference standards from different phases. This technique can therefore be used to map changes in the chemical bonding environment of atoms in nanoscale structures as in EFTEM imaging but with much higher spectral sampling. Through the analysis of a single edge and with reference standards, it is thus possible to extract the distribution of the individual phases rather than just the chemical composition. This powerful technique can be imple-
365
366
G. Botton
Figure 4–79. Schematic description of the STEM spectrum imaging technique (STEM-SI). For each pixel of the rastered area an energy loss spectrum is acquired. Although the spatial sampling is typically lower than in the EFTEMSI technique, the spectral sampling is higher with easy recording of the near-edge structure features at each pixel.
mented in one or two dimensions (Figure 4–80) for core loss near-edge structure features and also for low-loss features. Using the differences in low-loss spectra of various biological structures and ice, Sun et al. (1995) were able to map the distribution of the various functional components in cells (Figure 4–81). Similarly, for the analysis of polymerbased materials, the use of low-loss features related to the presence of π and π + σ plasmons has been used to distinguish polystyrene and polyethylene in composite blends (Figure 4–82) (Oikawa, 2006; Hunt et al., 1995). 6.2.3 Quantitative EELS Imaging If core-loss spectra are combined with low-loss spectra acquired from the same pixel, it is possible to retrieve more quantitative information on the sample. Hence, deconvolution techniques (Section 8.2) can be applied to retrieve the single scattering distribution for accurate quantification (Section 4.2), dielectric function measurements (Section 8.2),
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
367
a)
b) Figure 4–80. (a) Application of the STEM-SI technique to determine the distribution of elements across interfaces between a high dielectric constant material (Hf-O-N) and Si (STEM annular dark-field image, left). EDXS spectra and EELS spectra were recorded simultaneously to extract the elemental composition (bottom right profile). By analysis of the near-edge structure shape of the Si L23 edge and O K edge, it is possible to distinguish and map the contribution of pure Si, Si-O-N, and Hf-O-N. (Courtesy of M. Couillard, McMaster University.) (b) Two-dimensional phase maps of B nanostructure with BN, B2O3, and metallic B separated according to the shape of the near-edge structure spectra of the B K edges using the STEM-Spectrum imaging technique and least-squares fitting of spectra. The structure consists of a metallic B core with a thin BN shell and outer thick shell of B2O3. (Courtesy of O. Stephan and C. Colliex, University Paris-Sud.)
368
G. Botton
e) Figure 4–81. STEM images and phase component maps in frozen hydrated liver tissue. (a) Low-dose dark-field STEM image sectioned sample showing no contrast; (b) bright-field image of the same region based on integration of all signals on the spectrum at each pixel of the STEM-SI (the intensity drop is due to the variation of beam current during the acquisition); (c) relative thickness map (t/λ), contrast is visible on the lipid droplets; (d) water maps and identification of the various biological components based on the multiple least-squares fit of the low-loss spectra with water and protein reference compounds and the amount of water within the structure: L, lipid droplet (zero water content); P, plasma (91% water); R, erythrocyte (65% water); M, mitochondria (57% water); (e) low-energy loss spectra of the various components differentiating the phases. Bar marker is 1 µm. (From Sun et al. © 1995, reprinted with permission from Blackwell Publishing.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
369
Figure 4–82. Section of polyfin–polycarbonate polymer composite. The low-loss spectrum of the polyfin (top left) does not show the π plasmon resonance visible on the spectrum of the polycarbonate material (top right). The zero-loss image (bottom left) does not show strong contrast between the two phases while the π plasmon energy-filtered image (bottom right) clearly makes it possible to distinguish the regions where the polycarbonate is present. (Courtesy of Dr. T. Oikawa, JEOL.)
and the thickness relative to the inelastic mean free path of the sample (Section 8.2), and also to implement quantitative statistical analysis (Bonnet et al., 1999) to retrieve significant spectral components and analyze changes in bonding at interfaces in materials. Thickness maps, relative to the mean free path (Section 8.2), can be obtained with the EFTEM and STEM imaging approaches by acquiring a zero-loss image I0 (x,y) and an unfiltered image It(x,y). Following the approach discussed in Section 8.2 for the analysis of individual spectra to obtain relative thickness (t/λ) values, the ratio of the two images can be combined to give the relative thickness map It/λ (x,y) = ln[It (x,y)/I0 (x,y)]. The variant of this EFTEM method is to acquire the low-loss spectrum at each pixel and process the individual spectra to deduce t/λ at each
370
G. Botton
point of an image (see Section 8.2). This information on the sample thickness is valuable for the determination of the volume of the sample under analysis (hence the volume fraction of particular phases or defects), or to determine whether the changes in thickness affect the apparent intensity of elemental maps. The thickness information is also useful to verify whether the thickness of the sample is beyond the critical thickness at which accurate extraction and quantification can be carried out (Section 4.2.4). Finally, the thickness information, if combined with EDXS maps, can lead to fully quantitative X-ray maps accounting for X-ray and absorption corrections. As in the case of EDXS imaging, elemental maps can also be combined to retrieve fully quantitative concentration maps and deduce phase analysis histograms using experimental k-factors or cross sections (Hofer et al., 1997; Kothleitner and Hofer, 2003). The advantage of concentration maps is, as in the case of EDXS mapping, the fact that within a range of relative thickness t/λ < 0.5, images are independent of thickness as discussed in Section 4.2.4. Diffraction effects due to elastic scattering of electrons outside the objective aperture can also lead to apparent variations in the intensity of elemental maps and can be canceled out using the jump-ratio imaging technique. Concentration maps based on the single scattering distribution of energy losses obtained after deconvolution of the full spectrum at each pixel show that reliable quantitative images can be obtained for thickness up to t/λ ≅ 2 (Thomas and Midgley, 2001a). Another useful technique demonstrating the removal of diffraction effects is the use of the rocking beam method during the acquisition of energy-filtered images. In this approach, the incident electron beam is tilted over a cone of angles (of the order of the Bragg angle) so as to average out the local diffraction effects including deviations of the scattering due to dislocations. Energy-filtered images with little diffraction contrast can thus be obtained even in bent and highly deformed samples (Hofer and Warbichler, 1996; Hofer et al., 2000) (Figure 4–83). Removal of diffraction contrast for qualitative imaging and visualization of precipitates in highly deformed samples has also been demonstrated using ratios of plasmon images obtained at different energies (Carpenter, 2004). Various aspects of optimization of signals for EFTEM and STEMEELS maps, including the position of energy windows, automatic detection of edges, illumination conditions, and magnification, are discussed in the work of Kothleitner and Hofer (1998, 2003), Grogger et al. (2003), Berger and Kohl (1992, 1993), and Berger et al. (1994). Through image analysis of the quantitative maps, it is also possible to segment images based on the composition and relative fraction of elements (Hofer et al., 1997, 2000). Algorithms to allow automatic detection of edges, for quantitative analysis of phase distributions, for the determination of thresholds for phase detection and problematic zones in the samples have also been developed with the use of full spectra recorded in STEM mode (Kothleitner and Hofer, 2003). Corrections of drifts in EFTEM images for quantitative analysis have been discussed in detail in Schaffer et al. (2004).
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
371
Figure 4–83. Imaging of precipitates in a steel sample. (a) TEM bright-field image of the 10% Cr steel with Cr23C6-VN and Nb(C,N) precipitates. (b) EELS spectrum with the Fe-M23 edge. (c) Fe-M23 jump-ratio image recorded with the rocking beam illumination. (d) Cr-L23 jump-ratio image. (e) V-L23 jump-ratio image. (f) Nb-M45 jump-ratio image. (From Hofer et al. © 2000, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.)
6.2.4 Spatial Resolution in EFTEM Elemental Mapping The resolution in EFTEM elemental mapping depends on several factors related to the operation parameters of the microscope and the energy loss of interest so that further discussion of this topic is required. When no angular limiting aperture is present (in imaging the objective aperture would be limiting the scattering angles) the dominant factor is related to the chromatic aberration term discussed in Section 5.2. For general conditions, however, we must summarize the contributions that need to be added in quadrature to retrieve the total broadening of an object point (Krivanek et al., 1995b). 1. Following the discussion in Section 5.2, the chromatic aberration broadening term when a limiting aperture is used can be described as dc = Cc
∆E β E0
(68)
where β is the collection angle (limited by the objective aperture in imaging mode), ∆E is the width of the energy window used to acquire the image, and E0 is the incident energy. This expression assumes that images are focused at the energy loss E where the energy window is located (rather than at the elastic image) and that the aperture is filled with the electrons. This assumption is important since, as discussed in Section 5.2, the width of angular distribution of scattering can be smaller and the contribution to the chromatic aberration term would
372
G. Botton
be modified. As experimental conditions often impose some convergence in the illumination and the chromatic aberration term is small compared to the subsequent broadening terms for low scattering angles (either limited by β or θE) this assumption if often assumed to be valid. 2. The delocalization of inelastic scattering term b [introduced in Section 5.2, Eq. (64)] contributes to the broadening with an energy and angular-dependent term increasing at low energy losses and low scattering angles (large scattering angles imply a small impact parameter). 3. The diffraction limit contribution arises from use of the objective aperture and dominates for small angles due to the denominator term dd = 0.6 λ/β
(69)
4. The spherical aberration term ds = 2Csβ3 strongly varies with β and is considered to contribute to a uniform background in the image and a decrease of contrast when the conditions are optimized for minimal chromatic aberration contributions (Krivanek et al., 1995b). Egerton’s work (1999) showed that this term is smaller than the chromatic aberration term for typical energy windows used for EFTEM mapping, but for small energy windows (a few electronvolts wide as used, for example, in EFTEM spectrum imaging) the term will dominate the resolution at high collection angles and will need to be included in the analysis. Experimental evidence suggests that the term should be neglected given the good spatial resolution of energy-filtered images with relatively large collection angles. Additional terms affecting the resolution depend on the noise in the images (requiring averaging of signals and increase of acquisition time), radiation damage of the specimen due to the high doses required for imaging at core losses, and instabilities of the sample and microscope leading to drift of the area under analysis during acquisition. Considering the significant terms added in quadrature it is possible to determine the ultimate physical limits to EFTEM mapping resolution (Krivanek et al., 1995b) 2 dtot = dc2 + (2b)2 + dd2
(70)
The trends, as a function of collection aperture, suggest that there are optimal operating conditions for a given energy loss, energy window ∆E, and microscope characteristics (Figure 4–84). When energy losses of the order of a few hundred electronvolts are analyzed, for small collection angles the diffraction limit term dominates, while for large angles the chromatic aberration term is most important. The width of the energy window has a significant effect on the resolution as it is linearly related to the chromatic contribution. Quite often, large energy windows are used to increase the counting statistics and reduce the noise in the images. When the energy window is large, the choice of the optimal collection aperture is more crucial as the chromatic aberration term rises steeply. For modern analytical TEMs oper-
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
Figure 4–84. Calculations of the expected resolution in EFTEM elemental maps at the oxygen K edge (530 eV) as a function of the collection angle for two energy-filtering windows of width ∆E = 5 and 20 eV and Cs = Cc = 1 mm (at 200 keV).
ating at or above 200 keV, and for lenses with chromatic aberration parameters around 1 mm, the delocalization term [Eq. (64)] is not a limiting factor for core losses above around 500 eV. For lower energy losses, in the order of 100 eV or less, this term can dominate the resolution limit in theory. Experimental results in the literature, however, suggest that the low losses delocalization terms based on Eq. (64) are overestimated (Muller and Silcox, 1995; Grogger et al., 2005). For high core losses, elemental maps show resolution limits consistent with the calculations of optimal values given above (e.g., below 1 nm based on Figure 4–84) while for low energy losses (including plasmon losses around 10–20 eV), images with a resolution around 1 nm (significantly better than the prediction of 4–5 nm) have been obtained (Grogger et al., 2005). Based on the significant contributions of chromatic aberrations for EFTEM imaging, the optimal approach to achieve the ultimate spatial resolution limits in EELS mapping, as imposed by unavoidable delocalization, is to use the STEM approach with small and high-intensity probes achievable today on modern analytical electron microscopes. With current technology making use of bright electron sources and aberration correctors it is possible to focus several hundred picoamperes of current into a near 2 Å probe [Sections 2.1 and 2.2 and Chapter 2 (this volume)]. Examples of chemical analysis with a noncorrected STEM demonstrate the ability to resolve individual atomic planes of Ca in the Bi2Sr2Ca1Cu2O8+δ superconductor (Figure 4–85) and analyze half-unit cell defects where the Ca planes are not present, suggesting the existence of a Bi2Sr2Ca0Cu1O8+δ subunit cell intergrowth.
373
374
G. Botton
Figure 4–85. High-resolution EELS profile of Ca in Bi2Sr2Ca1Cu2O8-δ based on the Ca L23 edge showing the detection of a single plane of Ca in the half-unit cell of the structure. The central panel shows a high-angle annular dark-field image of the sample. The profile shows the presence of a half-unit cell defect of the Bi2Sr2Ca0Cu2O8-δ phase (where there is a missing plane of Ca) in the structure. (Courtesy of Y. Zhu, McMaster University.)
7 Detection Limits in Microanalysis The very high spatial resolution of both EDXS and EELS results in relatively low detection limits for most elements as compared to “bulk” analysis methods. This effect is caused by a combination of factors including the small analyzed volumes, the low signals resulting from poor efficiency in signal collection, or/and low incident beam current, high background, short acquisition time, and instrumental contributions. Two quantities characterize the detection limits for EDXS and EELS depending on information of interest. The minimum detectable fraction (MDF) refers to a dilute element uniformly distributed in the
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
analysis area and represents the lowest concentration that can be detected. The minimum detectable number (MDN) refers to the smallest number of atoms that can be detected. This applies to analyses in which these atoms are clustered (such as biological molecules containing few atoms, atomic clusters, etc.) or very small probes are used and only a few atoms of impurity are being analyzed in the interaction volume. Predictions of the MDF are related to the process of signal generation (incident number of electrons, cross sections, fluorescence yield), collection efficiency of the detector system (solid angle, detector quantum efficiency, noise), sample characteristics (thickness, scattering outside apertures leading to loss of signal, background signal, and signal extraction variance), and potential sources of noncharacteristic signals arising from the instrument. The overall principle for estimating the MDF is based on the statistical certainty of detecting a signal above a background containing some noise due to the variance in the background intensity. This detection is based on the Rose visibility criterion (Rose, 1970) which states that the signal should be three times the standard deviation of the background (the noise) for reliable identification of the signal as genuine in a 98% confidence level. This criterion ensures that the signal can be clearly distinguishable from a simple statistical variation of the background with a high degree of confidence. This general criterion is applicable in both EELS and EDXS measurements (as in any other signal processing method). 7.1 Detection Limits for EDXS We can describe the evaluation of the MDF for EDXS as follows. Assuming that the noise in the background signal follows a Poisson statistical distribution, the minimum detectable signal for element B (Imin B ) in EDXS measurements is I Bmin ≥ 3 2 ⋅ I Bb where the square root term represents the variance of the background signal under the peak of element B (IbB), i.e., the noise (Figure 4–86). Experimentally, the detection limit of an element B in a matrix A can easily be determined by using a standard of known composition CB and the detected signal IB. The MDF is the concentration resulting in a minimum signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) CB = 3, hence SNRstd = (I B − I Bb ) 2 ⋅ I Bb and SNR MDF = 3 (the SNR corresponding to the Rose criterion and the MDF). This resulting concentration yielding an SNR = 3 is the minimum detectable fraction: CBMMF =
CB ⋅ 3 2 ⋅ I Bb I B − I Bb
(71)
If the standard containing element B is not available, we can still retrieve the detectable fraction based on a pure element A standard using kAB factors (see Section 4) and by assuming that the background under the peak of element B (if it was present) is not significantly altered when this element is in trace concentration in a sample. In this case, we obtain CBMMF =
CA ⋅ 3 2 ⋅ I Bb k AB ( I A − I Ab )
(72)
375
376
G. Botton
Figure 4–86. Definition of peak and background intensities in EDXS spectra. The peak intensity is defined with respect to intensities just beside the peak.
where IbAis the background under the peak of element A and CA is the concentration of element A (assumed to be 1 if the standard is pure). From this simple empirical treatment it can be seen that improvements in detection limits (i.e., lower values) can be achieved by increasing the peak intensity (through a longer acquisition time and/or larger probe current) and by reducing the background. This latter contribution is affected by sample thickness, instrument operating conditions, and instrumental contributions (discussed in Section 7.2). The general treatment required to understand the trends in detection limits is due to Ziebold (1967), who related the MMF to microanalysis conditions (Goldstein et al., 1986) MMF ∝
1 P ( P B) nτ
(73)
where P is the peak above the background count rate, P/B is the peakto-background ratio (with integration of the background defined over the same energy window as the peak), n is the number of analyses, and τ is the acquisition time for each analysis carried out. It is possible to increase the peak counts by increasing the electron beam current, the thickness of the sample, and the collection efficiency (larger solid angle of the detector) while increasing the P/B ratio by increasing the accelerating voltage of the microscope and reducing the instrumental contribution leading to noncharacteristic signals. Although a large fraction of the background arises from bremsstrahlung radiation in the sample, significant contributions can come from spurious signals arising from electrons scattered at high angles (including backscattering), which, in turn, generate X-rays within the column. An additional contribution to the background arises from hard X-rays generated in the condenser lens system—when electrons hit apertures in the optic path—that fluo-
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
resce X-rays in the specimen area, including the sample holder. Such spurious signals are known as instrumental contributions. As discussed above, increased count rates for a given spot size can be achieved through brighter electron sources (Section 2.1) and thicker samples, although the latter will also lead to increased undesired contributions (increase in background) and loss of spatial resolution (Section 5). Increased total analysis time nτ can be achieved only if the sample is stable under the electron beam (due to electron beam damage, contamination, etc.) and sample drift is minimal or can be corrected via alignment algorithms. A clean vacuum system and clean samples are of the utmost importance. Dry pumping systems, bakeable columns, clean sample holders always kept in vacuum, and plasma cleaning of the samples prior to the TEM sessions are key components of improved analytical performance of the microscope and are ultimately as important as the quality of the EDXS detector and the microscope. With the use of analytical electronic microscopes equipped with small electron beams, thin samples, and more recently aberration correctors, it has been possible to achieve fractions of 1% detection with subnanometer spatial resolution (Figure 4–87) (Watanabe and Williams, 2005a). 7.2 Instrumental Contributions in EDXS These spurious signals can be minimized by improvements in the column, detector, and sample holder designs. For example, a significant reduction in hard X-rays generated in the upper part of the column can be achieved by using thick top-hat-shaped Pt apertures. These are now available in most modern analytical microscopes as part of the selection of C2 apertures (some might just be Mo or lighter elements allowing transmission of hard X-rays). Good collimation of the detector is also important to minimize the line of sight between the specimen and the active area of the detector so that X-rays generated elsewhere in the speci-
Figure 4–87. Detection limits reached in modern AEM and various examples of performance reached with different instruments. WDS is data obtained with a dedicated microprobe (30 keV), AEM (1) 120 keV, AEM (2) 100 keV, LaB6 instruments, 100 keV FEG, 300 keV (Watanabe and Williams, 1999), and aberration-corrected FEG. (Adapted from Watanabe and Williams, 2005a, and Williams and Carter, 1996.)
377
378
G. Botton
Figure 4–88. Instrumental contributions to the characteristic signals detected from the sample. Spurious X-rays are produced by the scattered electrons interacting with the microscope components (labeled 1, 2, 4). Spurious signals are also produced by hard X-rays generated on the top part of the column hitting the sample holder, grid, and other parts of the specimen chamber (labeled 5, 6, and 3). Nonoptimal collimation allows X-rays generated other than the sample area to reach the detector (compare with Figure 4–23).
men chamber area by scattered electrons reaching apertures, the polepiece of the objective lens, do not reach the detector (Figures 4–23 and 4–88). Using small samples (rather than the standard 3-mm disks with bulk edges) also minimizes the contributions due to fluorescence and electron scattering (electrons returning back to the sample after hitting parts of the column). Finally, the sample holder must be designed for analytical purposes (these are available commercially), namely, built with light element materials, ideally Be as one of the main components in the specimen supporting area, with a Be ring to tighten the sample and a design geometry allowing the acquisition of spectra without significant tilt of the sample (Figure 4–89). This configuration leads to minimal instrumental contributions so that X-rays generated in the sample have a
Figure 4–89. Sample holders for AEM (top) JEOL 2010F microscope holder and (bottom) Philips/FEI CM-Tecnai series holder with machined grove for minimal tilt of sample.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
direct line of sight to the detector without being absorbed (and causing fluorescence) in the sample holder. Sample grids made of Cu (or other metals such as Ni or Mo) to support continuous, lacey or holey C films where the sample is distributed (in the form of dispersed particles, replicas, or lift-out focused ion beam samples) generate significant spurious signals as shown by the presence of peaks of the grid material even if the electrons are not directly illuminating the grid. Recently, diamond grids have been developed to minimize these contributions when these problems affect the analysis. In many cases, the selection of the grid material can be made judiciously to avoid quantification problems given the commercial availability of several grid materials. Based on these instrumental considerations, the overall quality of the microscope analytical performance can be evaluated with measurements of the “hole-count” signals. By measuring the signal generated when the electron beam is directed into the hole of the sample, contributions from the grid, the microscope chamber, and holder can potentially be observed (and identified from the element present) and should be, in a good analytical TEM, less than 1% of the signal generated on the sample. Quantitative evaluation of the performance can be carried out using standard samples of Cr (100 nm thick) and NiO and welldefined tests based on P/B ratios (Williams and Carter, 1996; Egerton and Cheng, 1994). Overall, low instrumental contributions lead to lower peak-to-background values and improved detection limits. Welldesigned analytical microscopes (Section 2.3.6) and the use of analytical conditions (correct analytical apertures, sample geometry, tilt) lead to significantly improved detection limits. 7.3 EELS Detection Limits The basic statistical principle for detection of signals used in EDXS (the Rose criterion) is also applicable in the case of EELS. The empirical approach to estimate the detection limit based on experiments and known standards is the same as in EDXS but with additional complications due to the determination of the noise component arising from the extrapolation of the background rather than the simple interpolation. The noise, and thus the SNR, cannot be determined based on the simple variance of the number of counts at a given energy loss. The noise must be estimated directly from a detailed statistical analysis of the spectra and the errors related to the determination of the extrapolation parameters (Trebbia, 1988) or simpler approximations of the extrapolation error based on the width of the fitting and extrapolation windows (Egerton, 1996). From first principles, it is possible to estimate the detection limits accounting for these statistical effects and physical principles as described in detail by Egerton (1996) and Egerton and Leapman (1995). The variance of the signal must take into account the error due to the extrapolation of the background under the edge and the introduction of noise related to the detective quantum efficiency (DQE) of the spectrometer. The DQE is defined (Krivanek et al., 1987; Egerton, 1996) as SNR 2output / 2 (where the indices “input” and “output” are based on the SNRinput
379
380
G. Botton
incident counting statistic and measured statistic, respectively) and varies with the number of incident electrons, but, for the purpose of our estimations, is assumed constant and not equal to one as generally assumed in the case of EDXS spectra. The determination of the EELS detection limits must also include the effect of elastic scattering reducing the efficiency of collection of the signals due to scattering outside the aperture. Accounting for the detector response, the SNR is (Egerton, 1996), SNR ≈ DQE
Ik
(74)
h⋅I b
where Ib is the background under the edge, h is an error parameter due to the extrapolation, and Ik is the integrated edge intensity. Large fitting intervals close to the edge threshold and small integration windows lead to small h parameters (around 5–10), while small fitting intervals further from the edge and large integration windows result in large h values (as large as 20–30) (Egerton, 1996). The number of electrons causing a signal is related to the dose D [coulomb/(unit area)] and the area illuminated by a probe with diameter d as I(β,∆) ≈ (π/4)d2(D/e)exp(−t/λe)
(75)
where the exponential term represents the loss of electrons following elastic scattering outside the collector aperture β in a specimen of thickness t relative to the elastic mean free path λe. The background signal (Ib) related to the number of atoms of the matrix Nt and the number of atoms of the trace element N giving rise to edge signals Ik are related to the respective cross sections and the number of incident electrons and number of atoms in the volume as Ib ≈ Nt I(β,∆)σb (β,∆) and Ik ≈ NI(β,∆)σk(β,∆)
(76)
Since the fraction of trace element f = N/Nt we obtain f =
SNR hσ b (β,∆ ) 1 2 (DQE)−1 2 σ k (β,∆ ) N t I (β,∆ )
(77)
The MDF is the fraction fmin corresponding to an SNR = 3 (as in the case of EDXS following the Rose criterion). This yields (Egerton, 1996) MDF = fmin ≈
( )
3 1.1 hσ b (β,∆ ) σ k (β,∆ ) d (DQE) (D e ) N t
12
t exp 2λ e
)
(78)
The minimum detectable number quantity is related to the number of atoms within the analyzed area corresponding to the minimum detectable fraction determined above: MDN =
π 2 2.7 d N t hσ b (β,∆ ) d fmin N t ≈ 4 σ k (β,∆ ) (DQE) (D e )
12
t exp 2λ e
)
(79)
By calculating the various cross sections (Section 3), detection limits can be estimated. Assuming a DQE ≈ 0.5 typical of parallel spectrometers, h = 9, λe = 200 nm, a carbon matrix of 30 nm thickness, based on the
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
expression given above (Egerton, 1996) calculated the detection of Ca atoms for a range of doses using 100 keV electrons and hydrogenic cross sections. The detection of a few atoms within a 1-nm probe is possible assuming the sample can withstand doses of the order of 106 C/cm2. For elements with large cross sections (such as L and M lines) detection of a few ppm has been demonstrated (Leapman and Newbury, 1993) while higher detection limits are possible for K edges and delayed edges of elements such as Ag, Au, and S. A significant improvement in the detection limits is achieved if the spectra are processed using multiple leastsquares analysis of data acquired in spectral-difference mode (see Section 4.2.1) where reference data are fitted to the experimental spectrum. This approach results in a much lower signal extraction error with h values approaching 1. Detection of single atoms of thorium was demonstrated by Krivanek et al. (1991b) and individual Gd atoms were detected by Suenaga et al. (2000). More recently, systematic work on Ca and Fe containing molecules demonstrated elemental maps with the detection of just a few (7–8) base pairs of a DNA molecule under the electron beam (within the pixel size) containing 14–16 P atoms and 4 atoms of Fe in the one single hemoglobin molecule (Leapman and Rizzo, 1999) and single Ca atom detection (Leapman, 2003). Experiments demonstrating detection of a few ppm in standard reference materials of known composition have been reported by Leapman and Newbury (1993), Newbury (1998), and Newbury et al. (2000) (Figure 4–90). The work assumes detection of the edges based on spectral difference technique (Section 4.2.1), parallel detection spectrometers, and very long acquisition times. These detection limits also assume very thin samples, typically t/λ < 0.3–0.5 (see Section 4.2.4). If thicker samples are used, the detection limits degrade significantly up to the point at which even pure elements would not be detected in samples as a result of the increase in the background due to multiple scattering (Section 8.2) that masks the edges. A summary of the detection limits based on the work of Leapman and Newbury (1993; Newbury, 1998; Newbury et al., 2000) is presented in Table 4–6. A detailed simulation package predicting the detection limits including the effects of increased background, multiple scattering, and angular collection has been developed commercially (available by Gatan as the “EELS advisor”) based on the initial work of Natusch et al. (1999) and Menon and Krivanek (2002). Applications of these simulations are extremely useful in predicting whether elements present at low concentration levels in any matrix can be detected and in suggesting experimental conditions to detect these elements. 7.4 Comparison of EELS and EDXS Detection Limits An expression for the detected X-ray signal based on the incident current I and acquisition time T can be deduced so that the relative merits of EDXS and EELS can be compared (Egerton, 1996). Following the description given for X-ray signal quantification (Section 4.1) we describe the intensity Ix = N(I/e)Tωkσkηx
(80)
381
382
G. Botton
Figure 4–90. Extraction of signals using the second-difference technique for the detection of trace concentration of reference materials in a standard sample (SRM 610 glass from NIST). (Reprinted from Leapman and Newbury © 1993, American Chemical Society.) In the raw spectrum nearly all edges of trace constituents are not visible. In the second difference spectrum (bottom) the edges of trace elements are well resolved. Elements Ba, La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, and Yn are present in the 60–80 ppm range. Sc, Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, and Co are present in the 150–240 ppm range.
Table 4–6. Edge shapes and labels for elements of the periodic table as detectable in EELS experiments. Detection limit
Element and edges
10–100 ppm
3d transition metals and preceding alkaline earth elements: L edges (Ca, Sc, . . . Ni) 4f lanthanides and preceding alkaline earth elements M45 edges (Ba, La, . . . Yb)
100–1000 ppm (0.1%)
Light elements: K edges (Li, Be, B. . . . P) L23 edges(Mg, Al, Si, P, S, Cl) 4d transitionmetal elements and preceding alkaline earth elements L23 edges (Sr, Y, . . . Rh)
>1000 ppm (0.1%)
Ga, Ge, As, Se, Ag, Cd, In, Sn, Sb, Te, I, W . . .
Edge type (following the Gatan chart convention)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
where ωk is the fluorescence yield for the particular line, σk is the total cross section (integrated over all the angles; see Section 3.4.2), and ηk is the collection efficiency including all the detector components and any absorption in the sample. The relative sensitivity of EELS and EDXS signals can be calculated by discussing the ratio of EELS and EDXS intensities I k σ k (β,∆ ) 1 −t exp = λe Ix ω k σ k ηx
)
(81)
The ratio of the partial and total cross-sectional term is typically in the order of 0.1 (Egerton, 1996), although large scattering angles and energy windows (∆ > 50 eV) would tend to include most of the inelastic distribution given the asymptotic behavior of the scattering distribution and the cross sections (Section 3.4). The fluorescence term is the major contributor to the greater effectiveness of EELS for the detection of a large number of elements in “ideal” samples. For K edges of heavy elements with Z > 40 (difficult to reach in TEM-EELS experiments given their high energy loss), ω approaches 1 (Figure 4–49), but for light elements or L edges, it drops very sharply (for K edges it is around 0.1 for Al, 0.02 for Na, down to 0.001 for B, while for L edges it is less than 0.001 for Z < 20). The detector efficiency term also has a significant effect on the relative merit of EELS. The small solid angle of the EDXS detector implies that only 1% of the emitted X-rays are collected by the detector. Furthermore, low-energy X-rays can be absorbed in the thin window and the dead layer of the detector (Section 2.3.2). Due to the combined terms of fluorescence and detector efficiency, the EELS signals are three to four orders of magnitude stronger than EDXS signals for light elements while they are slightly stronger for most heavy elements. The relative merits are summarized in Figure 4–91. The drawback with EELS, however, is not fully accounted for in Eq.
Figure 4–91. Comparison of the relative sensitivity of EELS/EDXS detection limits. Note that the calculations assume samples are very thin. (Reprinted from Egerton and Leapman © 1995, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.)
383
384
G. Botton
(81) due to the strong increase of background with thickness arising from multiple scattering. For thick samples, even of pure elements, EELS would not show any edge irrespective of the atomic number, while EDXS spectra would still show peaks (even for light elements, albeit small)! The absence of EELS edges in a spectrum from just a sample does not necessarily imply the absence of any elements.
8 Energy Loss Fine Structures As discussed in the introduction of this chapter, there are fine modulations in the structure of spectra that yield useful information on the chemical environment of the atoms and the dielectric properties of the material. These fine structures can be subdivided into three parts. The ELNES are modulations appearing in the first 10–20 eV from the ionization edge threshold (Figure 4–92). These are now used almost routinely to characterize the chemical environment of atoms, including the type of phases and valence state. At higher energy losses (from about 30–50 eV of the threshold up to several hundred electronvolts), the extended energy loss fine structures (EXELFS) provide information on the radial distribution function of the material [similar to X-ray absorption fine structures (XAFS)] (Figure 4–92). These modulations arise from the backscattering of the ejected electron in the solid and the creation of interference between the ejected and backscattered wavefunctions and are particularly useful in providing the bond distances in amorphous solids at a nanometer scale. Since current applications of the technique in the AEM literature are limited we will refer the reader to a good overview of this technique in Egerton (1996) and to XAFS literature describing the principles of the analysis method. Finally, the fine modulations in the low-loss part of the EEL spectra (from 0 to 50–100 eV) also provide a wealth of information on the dielectric properties of materials. Quantitative analysis makes it possible to compare optical spectroscopy measurements to low-loss energy loss data and measure electron density using some simple approximations for metals. Qualitative analysis allows us to use the differences in spectra for various materials to map the distribution of phases. Given the impact of the ELNES and low-loss spectra in AEM, details of these two techniques are presented below.
Figure 4–92. Regions and energy ranges for the energy loss nearedge structures (ELNES) and extended energy loss fine structures (EXELFS) of core edges.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
a)
b) Figure 4–93. Relationship between the near-edge structure observed on the EELS edges and the unoccupied electronic states. (a) Transitions are observed from core levels to unoccupied electronic states above the Fermi level. (b) Example of near-edge structure (experimental spectrum) for the C K edge in graphite with the relationship between the π and σ orbitals (and the antibonding orbitals π* and σ*) in the hybridized atoms and the related bands in the solid.
8.1 Energy Loss Near Edge Structure As discussed in the introductory section of this chapter, ELNES provide information on the electronic structure and bonding environment of the atoms probed by the incident fast electrons. An example of the information is demonstrated in Figure 4–93 showing the relationship between
385
386
G. Botton
the spectrum and the energy states along with examples of near edge structures for different compounds (Figure 4–94). The features visible in the near edge structure represent the unoccupied energy states as modified with respect to a free atom by effects such as hybridization, coordination changes, and solid-state effects. The technique therefore provides data equivalent to the well-established X-ray absorption nearedge structure (XANES) spectroscopy carried out in synchrotrons. As such, reference data and literature from XANES can often be used to identify compounds and understand trends and electronic structure effects in ELNES. Examples of changes in the ELNES derived from changes in the electronic structure demonstrate the sensitivity to the structural environment and the chemical state (Figure 4–94). In addition to the changes in the shape of near edge structures, the energy position of the edges can vary with the oxidation state in a manner similar to Xray photoelectron spectroscopy. Changes in the core energy level and the position of unoccupied states can result from charge transfer effects due to oxidation, bonding, and coordination changes. Systematic trends
a) Figure 4–94. Examples of near-edge structures in (a) various carbon-based compounds showing the sensitivity to the structural environment and hybridization and in (b) Fe-based compounds. (From Garvie et al., 1994.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
b) Figure 4–94. Continued
are therefore observed for several metals with oxidation states for both X-ray absorption spectroscopy (Chen, 1997) and for EELS (e.g., Mansot et al., 1994). Detailed reviews on applications of ELNES can be found in Botton (1999), Keast et al. (2001), and Garvie et al. (1994). Examples demonstrating the application of ELNES at high spatial resolution are given in Batson (1993), Muller et al. (1999, 2004) and Spence (2005). At a more quantitative level, the sensitivity of the ELNES to bonding can be explained by the general oscillator strength and the form factor terms of the partial cross sections (Section 3.3). These two terms are dependent on the initial and final state wavefunctions of the interacting electrons and thus contain information on the chemical state and electronic structure of the probed atoms as modified in the solid. In the dielectric formulation of the cross sections (Section 3.3.1), it is also possible to understand how the energy loss spectrum relates to other spectroscopy measurements: d2σ 1 ∝ 2 Im [ − 1 ε ( q,E)] dΩdE θ + θE2
(82)
where ε is the dielectric function of the material (Section 3.3.1), which can be expressed by its real part ε1(related to the screening process of
387
388
G. Botton
the electrons) and its imaginary part ε2 (related to the absorption process and thus to optical and X-ray absorption measurements). The first term in Eq. (82) is general and is related to the kinematics of scattering. It imposes a simple Lorentzian angular distribution to the scattering and the rapid drop in intensity with increasing scattering angle. The second term is the loss function, which is related to the dielectric response of the solid to an electromagnetic radiation and is therefore ultimately linked to the intrinsic properties of the solid. At high energy losses (from about 50–100 eV and above) where the screening of the incident electron charge by collective effects is not important, ε1 → 1 and ε2 is small (ε2 << ε1) so that the loss function is reduced to Im(−1/ε) = ε2/(ε21 + ε22) = ε2 and is thus directly related to the absorption part of the dielectric function and therefore to absorption measurements. In this particular condition and in the one electron approximation, the cross section can be calculated based on Fermi’s golden rule describing the transition rate of an electron from an initial energy level i described by an initial wavefunction ψi of energy Ei to a final level f described by a wavefunction ψf of energy Ef d2σ 2 ∝ ∑ Ψf exp (iq ⋅ r ) Ψi δ (E − Ef + Ei ) (83) dΩdE i ,f where we have omitted the first (kinematic) term from Eq. (82) because it is independent of the solid state effects. As defined in Section 3.3, the scattering vector q = k0 − k1 where k0 and k1 are the incident and final wavevectors of the incident electron. The exponential operator is derived from the Hamiltonian describing the interaction between the incident electron, the nucleus, and the atomic electrons in the solid [see Paxton (2005) for a detailed derivation of this term]. The sum is carried out over all possible final energy states limited by the δ function to ensure the conservation of energy in the scattering event so that the energy loss E corresponds to the difference in the energies of the final and initial states. The exponential operator can be expanded as a Taylor series exp(iq ⋅ r) = 1 + iq ⋅ r + 1–(iq ⋅ r)2 . . . (84) 2 The first term of this expansion is zero due to the orthogonality of the initial and final wavefunctions (i.e., 〈ψf|ψi〉 = 0). For most conditions used in EELS experiments (i.e., small spectrometer collection angles β and edges above around 100 eV), only the term related to dipole excitation q ⋅ r is retained because the scattering angles are small and the core wavefunctions are very localized in typical EELS experiments. In these conditions, q ⋅ r << 1 leads to what is known as the dipole approximation and the second term in the Taylor expansion can be neglected (the treatment is thus similar to X-ray absorption spectroscopy). For larger scattering angles or/and for very low core losses (the core state wavefunctions are less and less localized as the core energy decreases, i.e., the mean radius of the core wavefunction increases), this approximation is, strictly speaking, no longer valid but it gives a good representation of the spectra [nonetheless, full calculations with nondipole terms are possible with current methodologies (Blaha et al., 2001)]. In the dipole approximation, we obtain
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
d2σ ∝ ∑ Ψf q ⋅ r Ψi dΩdE i ,f
2
δ (E − Ef + Ei )
(85)
The squared term is the dipole matrix element representing the transition rate from a core state to a final state. In this condition, the sum in Eq. (85) is simplified as d2σ ∝ M , −1 ( E) 2 ρ −1 ( E) + M , +1 ( E) 2 ρ +1 ( E) dΩdE
(86)
where ρ(E) is the density of states (DOS) resolved in angular momentum components 艎 (s, p, d, f). In the development of the matrix elements of Eq. (85), the decomposition of the wavefunctions in radial and angular terms imposes two very interesting effects summarized by Eq. (86). The radial part of the matrix elements reveals that for a transition to be observed (i.e., M ≠ 0), there must be an overlap between the core states and the final state wavefunctions. This implies that the energy loss spectra probe the site-dependent electronic structure projected on the excited atom. Practically speaking, since the core states are very localized, the information is also very local and is not limited just to the electron beam illuminated area but is specific to the atom type excited by the electron beam: different atoms in the same area illuminated by the electron beam will have a different “local” electronic structure environment. Second, from the development of the angular parts of Eq. (85), the matrix element of a transition from a state of angular momentum component 艎 is zero unless the final state is of angular momentum 艎 ± 1 as suggested by the subscripts in Eq. (86). Hence, transitions will therefore occur for states with a change in angular momentum component ∆艎 = ±1. This implies that if the initial state is of s character (艎 = 0), the transition will occur only to states of p character (艎 = 1). This is observed for K edges where the core state is 1s. For an initial state of p character (艎 = 1), transitions will be observed to states of s (艎 = 0) and d character (艎 = 2). This applies to L23 edges arising from the 2p3/2 and 2p1/2 initial states. The matrix elements therefore allow us to probe the local DOS of each element separately by selecting the edge corresponding to the atomic number of the element of interest and the edge type (K, L, etc.) according to different principal and angular momentum quantum numbers. This latter sensitivity is very illuminating since EELS experiments allow us to probe not only the unoccupied states but also the atom-sitespecific and symmetry-projected density of unoccupied states. The calculations of near-edge structures using Eq. (86) have been demonstrated to be equivalent for XANES and ELNES in most experimental collection conditions respecting the dipole approximation. The only difference in the formulation between XANES and ELNES derives from the fact that the scattering vector q is replaced by the electric field E in Eqs. (84) and (85). The ELNES is therefore an extremely powerful probe of the electronic structure of solids with high spatial resolution as compared to other valence or conduction band spectroscopies in which the entire bands (valence or conduction) are probed irrespective of the angular momentum character.
389
390
G. Botton
The calculations based on Eq. (86) with density of states determined by first principle methods assume an infinite lifetime of the excited state. To account for more realistic conditions where the decay occurs via deexcitation processes, a finite lifetime must be considered. This can be achieved artificially by broadening the δ function with a Lorentzian distribution to account for the finite lifetime of the excited state, the lifetime of the core state, as well as the instrumental function accounting for the energy spread of the incident electrons and the resolution of the spectrometer. The derivation of Eqs. (83)–(86) has been described here very briefly and we refer the interested reader to the work of Fink (1992), Vvedensky (1992), Saldin (1987), and Schattschneider and Jouffrey (1995) and more recently a review by Paxton (2005) for further details. It is important to mention, however, some of the limitations of this description to give an idea of what can be expected from first principle calculations. First, the one electron derivation of the transition probability is based on the “single particle” approach. This simplification assumes that the excited state (where there is a hole in the core state and an ejected electron) can be represented by ground state wavefunctions (no excitation effects are accounted for). This most important approximation can be improved on, in principle, by considering the final state rule proposed by von Barth and Grossmann (1982), which considers the electronic structure of the system in the potential probed by the ejected electron, i.e., with a core hole in the initial level. In spite of this approximation, the single particle approach is a first useful step in understanding general features in the spectra and in assessing the need for more refined models accounting for the more realistic final state. For many systems including metallic materials and even some insulators where the screening of the core hole is effective, this description is successful, whereas in others, the interactions between the core hole and the ejected electron significantly modify the ground state electron wavefunctions of the solid. A second limitation is related to the specific approaches used to describe the electronic structure of the solid. The predictions of the DOS are based on the use of density functional theory and the different implementations to calculate the electron wavefunctions (for a review, see Hébert, 2006). For the most part, electronic structure calculations for solids have focused on the description of occupied states and lowlying unoccupied states. This presents a limitation for the calculations of energy loss spectra that probe unoccupied states 10–30 eV above the threshold (and thus above the Fermi energy). To simplify the computation, linear band structure methods are often used (such as linear muffin tin orbital methods and linear augmented plane wave), only a limited energy range will be reproduced (5–20 eV from the edge threshold). Alternatives to these techniques are the multiple scattering-based techniques such as the Korringa–Kohn–Rostoker method [(used for transition metal edges (Botton et al., 1997)], the real space multiple scattering technique (Ankudinov et al., 1998), and the pseudopotential technique based on the use of plane waves that has produced impressive results at about 40–50 eV above the threshold in diamond (Pickard and Payne, 1997).
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
In addition to these calculations of ELNES based on band structure techniques or real space methods, other approaches must be used to deal with systems demonstrating strong electron–electron interactions due to the localization of the electrons. For these systems the band structure and real space methods fail to describe the spectra and a different scheme must be used. For transition metals L edges and rareearth M edges, a description based on atomic multiplet theory is much more effective in describing the spectra. These techniques include solid-state effects by including crystal field and charge transfer effects to describe the structural and bonding environment. A full description of the methods is given in the excellent reviews by deGroot (1994, 2005). Examples of calculations with this technique and a range of other methods are shown in Figure 4–95. A description of the hierarchy of these methods starting from the molecular orbital approach and multiple scattering methods can be found in Rez et al. (1995). In addition, the flexibility of EELS experiments in the TEM makes it possible to tune very effectively and elegantly the scattering vector of
a) Figure 4–95. Examples of calculations of ELNES with (a) the multiple scattering method for the Al K edge in AlN and (b) bandstructure technique: O K edge in rutile experiments (dots) and calculations (full line) with abinitio code Wien2K. (Spectrum courtesy of P. Tiemeijer, FEI.) (c) Atomic multiplet calculations of the MnL23 edge in MnTiO3. (Courtesy of G. Radtke, McMaster University.)
391
392
G. Botton
b)
c) Figure 4–95. Continued
the incident electron using momentum-resolved energy loss experiments to study anisotropic materials. Experiments demonstrating this effect in low-loss spectra (Fink, 1989, 1992) and core losses (Radtke et al., 2003; Botton et al., 1995a; Jouffrey et al., 2004) and to record inelastic scattering distributions (Botton, 2005) can be found in the literature. Various tools are therefore available to materials scientists and microscopists with which to understand and model near edge structures should the need arise. In many cases of AEM applications, however, a detailed comparison of various edges with reference materials is sufficient to understand the trends and associate the spectral features to bonding bands and materials properties. Databases are currently in development allowing users to access libraries of spectra from various compounds: http://www.cemes.fr/~eelsdb and http:// people.ccmr.cornell.edu/~davidm/WEELS.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
8.2 Low-Loss Spectroscopy 8.2.1 Fundamentals At low energy losses (0 to 50–100 eV), the most intense part of the spectrum is directly related to the collective response of the electrons in the solid to the fast incident electron. The incident charges with their associated electric field polarize the medium and set up oscillations of the weakly bound electrons of the solid at particular eigenfrequencies related to the mass of the electrons and their density in the solid. This is analogous to the resonance frequency of an object of mass m attached to a spring with spring constant k of classical mechanics. The collective behavior of these electrons in a solid is best characterized by treating the collective response as an effective particle called plasmon oscillating at a frequency ωp that results in an energy loss of the primary electron equivalent to the energy Ep = -hωp. The link between the spectrum, the general oscillator strength, and the loss function presented in Section 3.3.1 can be discussed in the context of low energy losses. Whereas at high energies (Section 8.1) the loss function is essentially determined by ε2, at low energies the screening of the electrons is very effective and |ε1| becomes much greater (in simple metals) than (or is about the same order of) ε2. The loss function Im(−1/ε) = ε2/(ε21 + ε22) must then consider both the polarizability and the absorption terms essentially describing the dielectric response of the solid to electromagnetic radiation. Detailed derivations of the models describing the formulation of the dielectric response have been reviewed by Schattschneider and Jouffrey (1995) and Raether (1980) and only a brief summary is given here to explain the most significant features in the spectra and the relation to the dielectric response of the medium. The Drude model is the simplest case that deals with freeelectron metals and the dielectric function of the material. This model considers electrons in the solid as free particles interacting with the medium via a simple damping term τ describing the relaxation time due to friction in the electron gas. The dielectric function then becomes ε (ω ) = 1 −
na e 2 1 ⋅ 2 mε 0 ω + (iω τ )
(87)
where we define the term ωp =
na e 2 mε 0
(88)
as the eigenfrequency of the electron plasma oscillation with ω p2 1 − (89) ωτ ω 2 + (1 τ 2 ) ω 2 + (1 τ 2 ) τ is related to the FWHM of the plasmon peaks ∆Ep = -h/τ, m is the effective mass of the electrons, ε0 is the vacuum dielectric constant, and na is the free electron density and the plasmon energy ε1 = Re {ε} = 1 −
ω p2
and ε 2 = Im {ε} =
393
394
G. Botton
Ep = ω p =
na e 2 mε 0
(90)
The free-electron model, although very applicable for many sp metals, is not realistic for all materials or even all metals. To treat the full range of transition metals, insulators, and semiconductors more realistically, there must be provision for transitions from various occupied to unoccupied bands in addition to contributions from the free electrons. This is done in the Drude–Lorentz model where discrete transitions are added by considering independent oscillators having eigenfrequencies equal to the transition energies (for example, to account for band-toband transitions related to d electrons and interband transitions from the valence to conduction band). The expression contains the free oscillators (such as the Drude oscillators) and the “bound” oscillators. The dielectric function is therefore the sum over all these oscillators “j”: nj e2 ε (ω ) = 1 + ∑ (91) mε 0 j (ω 2j − ω 2 − i ω τ ) where nj is the number of electrons able to oscillate at the eigenfrequency ωj. The presence of oscillators due to interband transitions or low-energy edges causes the peaks in the absorption part of the dielectric function and generates shifts in the position of the plasmon peaks. Similarly, the effect of the plasmon peaks is to shift the apparent energy of the interband transitions in the energy loss spectra with respect to the energy in the absorption part of the dielectric function. Such shifts therefore imply that caution should be taken when interpreting peaks in spectra: the position of a peak at a given energy loss E does not imply that there is an interband transition with same exact energy E. 8.2.2 Applications The effects discussed in the previous section, even if not always fully quantified in analytical electron microscopy work, can be exploited in energy-filtered “plasmon” images to identify the presence of phases with different electron densities (hence plasmon position) or dielectric function. Systematic variations of the plasmon energy as a function of the atomic number have been demonstrated in the early work of Colliex (1984) (Figure 4–96). Plasmon energies in alloys and metallic hydrides as a function of alloying element concentration and hydrogen content have been tabulated from various sources in Egerton (1996). This technique of plasmon measurement has also been applied to study the ratio of sp2/sp3 hybridization bonding in C films and the water content in biological structures (Figure 4–81) (Sun et al., 1995). Although a detailed analysis of the low-loss spectra is not yet a routine AEM techniques, detailed study of spectra can be extremely useful to understand some of the functional properties of materials. For examples, the relationship between the spectrum and the dielectric properties of solids can help elucidate some local variations of optical properties of materials (Turowski and Kelly, 1992; Schamm and Zanchi, 2003; Mullejans and French, 2000). Such studies make use of some key
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
Figure 4–96. Variation of the plasmon energy for a series of pure elements. “x” symbols are experimental values and full circles are theoretical values calculated with the free electron model of Eq. (90). (Reprinted from Colliex © 1984, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.)
properties of the dielectric function and, in particular, the Kramers– Kronig relations (Wooten, 1972) that link the real and imaginary parts of the dielectric function with the help of the Kramers–Kronig analysis (KKA): if the loss function Im{−1/ε} is known from the measurement of a spectrum,1 then Re{1/ε} can be determined by KKA. Based on this relationship it is possible to retrieve both ε1 and ε2 and gain full knowledge of the dielectric function of a material (Figure 4–97). Once the
Figure 4–97. Real and imaginary part of the dielectric function based on Kramers–Kronig analysis of energy loss spectra for (a) TiN and (b) VC. (Reprinted from Schattschneider and Jouffrey © 1995, with permission from Springer Science+Business Media.) 1
To retrieve the loss function from a spectrum, the single scattering distribution must be retrieved as demonstrated below.
395
396
G. Botton
dielectric function is known, the results can be compared to optical measurements at low energies and can be used to associate peaks to features in electronic transitions. One important advantage of the dielectric function measurement with EELS (as compared to optical techniques) is in the energy range of the measurements. With EELS, it is possible to analyze energies up to few hundred electronvolts covering, with the use of monochromator energies as low as the infrared region of the spectrum (down to about 0.5 eV), the visible and the UV up the soft X-ray region (few 100 eV). Examples of KKA with EELS to study the dielectric function of material is given in Moreau and Cheynet (2003) and Launay et al. (2004). Systematic work on the modeling of low-loss spectra using first principles and a discussion of the limitation of this approach has been presented by Keast (2005). Another very useful application of low-energy losses is related to the strong dependence of the spectra on the thickness of the samples (Figure 4–98). As the sample thickness increases, the probability of multiple inelastic losses increases. For example, the incident electron can excite one or more plasmon losses when traveling in the sample. If the mean distance between inelastic losses is λ, the probability of multiple loss events n is given by Pn =
( ) exp (− λt )
1 t n! λ
n
(92)
If we consider the intensity of the zero-loss peak I0 (corresponding to zero plasmon loss events, i.e., n = 0) with respect to the total intensity in the spectrum It, we can deduce the probability P0 for n = 0 and
Figure 4–98. Example of the variation of the low-loss spectrum in Al for two different relative thicknesses. The increase in thickness (from t/λ = 0.2 to t/λ = 2.2) causes multiple plasmon losses visible at energy values of multiple single losses (i.e., n times Ep). For broad plasmon peaks, multiple peaks are not well resolved. (Courtesy of N. Braidy, McMaster University.)
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
Figure 4–99. Features used for the determination of the relative thickness t/λ according to Eq. (94).
( )
(93)
)
(94)
I0 t = P0 = exp − It λ This expression is typically used as t It = ln λ I0
with the mean free path λ values either tabulated in the literature (for a standard collection condition) or based on measurements with standards of known thickness or local measurements using complementary techniques (such as convergent beam or contamination spot measurements) (Williams and Carter, 1996; Kelly et al., 1975). Measurements of the intensities for It and I0 are based on the integration of the spectra over windows as demonstrated in Figure 4–99. The measurements of thickness have been demonstrated to be reliable for thickness up to t/λ = 4 (Botton et al., 1995b). Values of the inelastic mean free path are dependent on the energy of the primary electrons, the material, and the angular collection conditions. Estimates of λ can be obtained based on the work of Malis et al. (1988). The use of a finite collection angle β results in scattering outside the collection aperture and affects the thickness measurements. For multiple inelastic losses, the total angular distribution emerging from the sample is broader as compared to the single scattering distribution due to multiple scattering events and the convolution of the inelastic scattering distributions. A finite collection angle therefore results in loss in collection efficiency of electrons having lost higher energies by multiple events and leads to changes in the apparent mean free path. Approaches to convert mean free paths from one aperture collection condition to another have been presented by Botton et al. (1995b), while iterative methods and computer programs have been developed by
397
398
G. Botton
Egerton (1996). Mean free paths for 100 keV electrons and β = 10 mrad are in the range of 115 nm for C, 100 nm for Al, 110 for Si, and 75 nm for Fe and have been tabulated in Egerton (1996) and Malis et al. (1988). The mean free path can be estimated with some basic assumptions on the sample composition if β << (E/E0) where E is the energy loss and E0 is the incident energy (so as to satisfy the dipole condition). If these conditions are respected, values of mean free paths can be calculated using (Malis et al., 1988) λ (β ) ≈
106 F (E0 Em ) ln ( 2βE0 Em )
(95)
with E0 values given in kiloelectronvolts, λ in nanometers, and β in millirad. F is a relativistic factor that can be calculated as F=
1 + E0 1022
(1 + E0 511)2
(96)
and Em is the mean energy loss in electronvolts. Em can be approximated as Em ≈ 7.5 Z0.36 without taking into account any contributions from changes in density or the crystallographic structure. For compounds containing elements of known atomic fraction fi, a mean effective atomic number can be calculated by summing over each element i as f Z1.3 ∑ i i i Zeff = (97) ∑ i fi Zi0.3 so that the effective atomic number Zeff can be used to determine the mean energy loss Em. Using the Kramers–Kronig analysis of the scattering distribution, the absolute sample thickness can also be calculated (Yang and Egerton, 1995) without prior knowledge of the sample. From the recorded spectra containing multiple inelastic losses (e.g., Figure 4–98), the single scattering distribution can be retrieved using deconvolution methods. These techniques are founded on the principle that the recorded spectrum is based on the sum of the single scattering distribution, the double scattering distribution, . . . , the i scattering distribution, up to the nth scattering distribution. Each i distribution is obtained by the convolution of the single scattering distribution with itself i times. This sum of convolutions can be analyzed with Fourier techniques to retrieve, from the experimental spectrum containing multiple inelastic losses, the original single scattering distribution. These methods are available in commercial EELS analysis packages as standard functions. In this context, the Fourier-log technique is used to process the full spectrum (Egerton, 1996) from zero electronvolts to few hundred electronvolts. The analysis of the spectrum to retrieve the distribution representative of single scattering is necessary for all quantitative work related to the Kramers–Kronig analysis and the measurement of absolute thickness discussed in Egerton (1996) and Egerton and Cheng (1987). The additional application of the deconvolution method is to remove multiple scattering effects from core loss spectra.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy
Figure 4–100. Effect of multiple inelastic losses on the shape of the ELNES.
The probability of multiple scattering including one core loss and plasmon losses increases in thick samples and the effect is visible as an increased intensity further away from the edge threshold: the spectra appear as a convolution of the low-loss spectra with the expected edge profile (Figure 4–100). These multiple scattering effects must be removed by deconvolution methods (in this context using the Fourier ratio method) to correctly interpret modulations in the spectra at high energy from the threshold. Structures within a few electronvolts from the edge threshold, however, are less sensitive to these multiple scattering effects.
Acknowledgments. I am grateful for the patience and understanding of Profs. Peter Hawkes and John Spence who allowed me to complete the work with on-going academic commitments, conference organization, and setting up of a new facility. I am indebted to members of my group for providing some figures and for feedback, in particular, N. Braidy, G. Radtke, M. Couillard, C. Maunders, and Y. Zhu. I want to thank several collaborators and friends who have provided, over the years, interesting samples, motivating discussions, and moral support. References Ankudinov, A.L., Ravel, B., Rehr, J.J. and Conradson, S.D. (1998). Phys. Rev. B 58, 7565. Arslan, I., Bleloch, A., Stach, E.A. and Browning, N.D. (2005). Phys. Rev. Lett 94, 025504. Barfels, M.M.G., Burgner, P., Edwards, R. and Brink, H.A. (2002). In Microscopy and Microanalysis 2002 (E. Voelkl, D. Piston, R. Gauvin, A.J. Lockley, G.W. Bailey and S. McKernan, Eds.), p. 614CD (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Batson, P.E. (1993). Nature 366, 727. Batson, P.E., Dellby, N. and Krivanek, O.L. (2002). Nature 418, 617. Bayle-Guillemaud, P., Radtke, G. and Sennour, M. (2003). J. Microsc. 210, 66. Berger, A. and Kohl, H. (1992). Microsc. Microanal. Microstruct. 3, 159. Berger, A. and Kohl, H. (1993). Optik 92, 175. Berger, A., Mayer, J. and Kohl, H. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 55, 101.
399
400
G. Botton Blaha, P., Schwarz, K., Madsen, G., Kvasnicka, D. and Luitz, J. (2001). Wien2k, An augmented Plane Wave Plus Local Orbitals Program for Calculating Crystal Properties. Vienna University of Technology, Institute of Physical and Theoretical Chemistry. Bonnet, N., Brun, N. and Colliex, C. (1999). Ultramicroscopy 77, 97. Botton, G.A. (1999). In Impact of Electron and Scanning Probe Microscopy on Materials Research (D.G. Rickerby, G. Valdré and U. Valdré, Eds.), p. 265 (Kluwer Academic Publishers, London). Botton, G.A. (2005). J. El. Spect. Rel. Phen. 143(2–3), 129–137. Botton, G.A. and L’Espérance, G. (1994). J. Microsc. 173, 9. Botton, G.A. and Phaneuf, M.W. (1999). Micron 30, 109. Botton, G.A., Boothroyd, C.B. and Stobbs, W.M. (1995a). Ultramicroscopy 59(1– 4), 93–107. Botton, G.A., L’Espérance, G., Gallerneault, C.E. and Ball, M.D. (1995b). J. Microsc. 180, 217. Botton, G.A., Guo, G.Y., Temmerman, W.M. and Humphreys, C.J. (1997). In Properties of Complex Inorganic Solids (A. Gonis, A. Meike and P. Turchi, Eds.), p. 175 (Plenum Press, New York). Brown, L.M. (1999). In Impact of Electron and Scanning Probe Microscopy on Materials Research (D.G. Rickerby, G. Valdré and U. Valdré, Eds.), p. 231 (Kluwer Academic Publishers, London). Carpenter, G.J.C. (2004). Microsc. Microanal. 10, 435. Castaing, R. and Henry, L. (1962). C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris B255, 76. Chen, J.G. (1997). Surface Sci. Rep. 30, 1. Cheng, S.C. and Egerton, R.F. (1993). Micron 24, 251. Chevalier, E.J.A. and Botton, G.A. (1999). Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. 161 EMAG 99, p. 175. Cliff, G. and Lorimer, G.W. (1975). J. Microsc. 103, 203. Cliff, G. and Lorimer, G.W. (1981). In Quantitative Microanalysis with High Spatial Resolution (G.W. Lorimer, M.H. Jacobs and P. Doigt, Eds.), p. 41 (The Metals Society, London). Colliex, C. (1984). In Advances in Optical and Electron Microscopy (V.E. Cosslett and R. Barer, Eds.), Vol. 9, p. 65 (Academic Press, London). Colliex, C. (1996). J. Electron Microsc. 45, 44. Colliex, C. and Mory, C. (1984). In Quantitative Electron Microscopy (J.N. Chapman and A.J. Craven, Eds.), p. 149 (SUSSP Publications, Edinburgh). Colliex, C., Tencé, M., Mory, C., Gu, H., Bouchet, D. and Jeanguillaume, C. (1994). Mikrochim. Acta 114, 71. Cosgriff, E.C., Oxley, M.P., Allen, L.J. and Pennycook, S.J. (2005). Ultramicroscopy 102, 317. Cowley, J. (1986). In Principles of Analytical Electron Microscopy (D.C. Joy, A.D.J. Romig and J.I. Goldstein, Eds.) (Plenum, New York). deGroot, F.M.F. (1994). J. El. Spect. Rel. Phen. 64, 529. deGroot, F.M.F. (2005). Coord. Chem. Rev. 249, 31. Dellby, N., Krivanek, O.L., Nellist, P.D., Batson, P.E. and Lupini, A.R. (2001). J. Elect. Microsc. 50, 177. Doigt, P. and Flewitt, P.E.J. (1982). Met. Trans. A 13, 1397. Dowell, W.C.T. and Goodman, P. (1973). Phil. Mag. 28, 471. Dwyer, C. (2005). Ultramicroscopy 104, 141. Dwyer, C. and Etheridge, J. (2003). Ultramicroscopy 96, 343. Egerton, R.F. (1993). Ultramicroscopy 50, 13. Egerton, R F. (1996). Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy in the Electron Microscope, 2nd ed. (Plenum, New York). Egerton, R.F. (1999). J. Electron Microsc. 48, 711.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Egerton, R.F. (2003). Micron 34, 127. Egerton, R.F. (2005). Physical Principles of Electron Microscopy (Plenum, New York). Egerton, R.F. and Cheng, S.C. (1987). Ultramicroscopy 21, 231. Egerton, R.F. and Cheng, S.C. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 55, 43. Egerton, R.F. and Leapman, R.D. (1995). In Quantitative Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy, Energy Filtering Transmission Electron Microscopy (L. Reimer, Ed.), p. 269 (Springer, Heidelberg). Eibl, O. (1993). Ultramicroscopy 50, 179. Essers, E. and Benners, G. (2006). Ultramicroscopy (submitted). Faulkner, R.G. and Norrgard, K. (1978). X-ray Spectrom. 7, 184. Fink, J. (1989). Adv. Electr. Electron Phys. 75, 121. Fink, J. (1992). In Unoccupied Electronic States (J.C. Fuggle and J.E. Inglesfield, Eds.), p. 139 (Springer-Verlag, Berlin). Fransen, M.J., van Rooy, T.L. and Kruit, P. (2005). Appl. Surf. Sci. 146, 312. Freitag, B. and Mader, W. (1999). J. Microsc. 194, 42. Garvie, L.A.J., Craven, A.J. and Brydson, R. (1994). Am. Mineral. 79, 411. Glitz, R.W., Notis, M.R. and Williams, D.B. (1981). Microbeam Analysis—1981 (R.H. Geiss, Ed.), p. 309 (San Francisco Press, San Francisco). Goldstein, J.I., Costley, J.L., Lorimer, G.W. and Reed, S.J.B. (1977). In SEM/77 (O. Johari, Ed.), p. 315 (IITRI, Chicago). Goldstein, J.I., Newbury, D.E., Echlin, P., Joy, D.C., Fiori, C.E. and Lifshin, E. (1981). Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-ray Microanalysis: A Text for Biologists, Materials Scientists and Geologists (Plenum, New York). Goldstein, J.I., Williams, D.B. and Cliff, G. (1986). In Quantitative X-ray Analysis, Principles of Analytical Electron Microscopy (D.C. Joy, A.D.J. Romig and J.I. Goldstein, Eds.), p. 155 (Plenum, New York). Goldstein, J.I., Newbury, D.E., Echlin, P., Joy, D.C., Lyman, C.E., Lifshin, E., Sawyer, L. and Michael, J.R. (2003). Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-ray Microanalysis (Kluwer Academic, New York). Grogger, W., Schaffer, B., Krishnan, K.M. and Hofer, F. (2003). Ultramicroscopy 96, 481. Grogger, W., Varela, M., Ristau, R., Schaffer, B., Hofer, F. and Krishnan, K.M. (2005). J. El. Spect. Rel. Phen. 143, 139. Gross, U., Mescher, F.J.M. and Tiemeijer, J.C. (1987). Philips Tech. Rev. 43, 273. *Gu, L., Srot, V., Sigle, W., Koch, C., van Aken, P., Scholz, F., Thapa, S.B., Kirchner, C., Jetter, M. and Rühle, M. (2007). Band-gap measurements of direct and indirect semiconductors using monochromated electrons. Physical Review B 75: Art. No. 195214. Hébert, C. (2006). Micron (in press). Hitchcock, A.P., Morin, C., Zhang, X.R., Araki, T., Dynes, J., Stover, H., Brash, J., Lawrence, J.R. and Leppard, G.R. (2005). J. El. Spect. Rel. Phen. 144, 259. Hofer, F. (1995). In Inner Shell Ionization, Energy-Filtering Transmission Electron Microscopy (L. Reimer, Ed.), p. 225 (Springer, Heidelberg). Hofer, F. and Warbichler, P. (1996). Ultramicrosc. 63, 21. Hofer, F. and Warbichler, P. (2004). In Transmission Electron Energy Loss Spectrometry in Materials Science and the EELS Atlas (C.C. Ahn, Ed.), p. 195 (Wiley-VCH, New York). Hofer, F., Grogger, W., Kothleitner, G. and Warbichler, P. (1997). Ultramicroscopy 67, 83. Hofer, F., Grogger, W., Warbichler, P. and Papst, I. (2000). Mikrochim. Acta 132, 273. Hofer, F., Schaffer, B., Grogger, W. and Kothleithner, G. (2005). In Microscopy and Microanalysis 2005 (R. Price, P. Kotula, M. Marko, J.H. Scott, G.F. Van der Voort, M. Mah Lee Ng, K. Smith, B. Griffin, P. Smith and S. McKernan, Eds.), Vol. 11, Suppl. 2, p. 48 (Cambridge University Press, Honolulu, HI). Horita, Z., Sano, T. and Nemoto, M. (1987). Ultramicroscopy 21, 271.
401
402
G. Botton Hovington, P., Drouin, D. and Gauvin, R. (1997). Scanning 19, 1. Humphreys, C.J. (1979). In Principles of STEM, Introduction to Analytical Electron Microscopy (D.C. Joy, A.D.J. Romig and J.I. Goldstein, Eds.) (Plenum, New York). Hunt, J.A. and Williams, D.B. (1991). Ultramicroscopy 38, 47. Hunt, J.A., Disko, M.M., Behal, S.K. and Leapman, R.D. (1995). Ultramicroscopy 58, 55. Inokuti, M. (1971). Rev. Mod. Phys. 43, 297. Inokuti, M. (1978). Rev. Mod. Phys. 50, 23. Jeanguillaume, C. and Colliex, C. (1989). Ultramicroscopy 28, 252. Jouffrey, B., Schattschneider, P. and Hebert, C. (2004). Ultramicroscopy 102, 61. Joy, D.C., Romig, A.D.J. and Goldstein, J.I. (1986). Principles of Analytical Electron Microscopy (Plenum, New York). Keast, V.J. (2005). J. El. Spect. Rel. Phen. 143, 97. Keast, V.J. and Williams, D.B. (1999). Acta Mater. 47, 3999. Keast, V.J. and Williams, D.B. (2000). J. Microsc. 199, 45. Keast, V.J., Bruley, J., Rez, P., MacLaren, J.M. and Williams, D.B. (1998). Acta Mater. 46, 481. Keast, V.J., Scott, A.J., Brydson, R., Williams, D.B. and Bruley, J. (2001). J. Microsc. 203, 135. Kelly, P.M., Jostson, A., Blake, R.G. and Napier, J.G. (1975). Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 31. Kohl, H. and Rose, H. (1985). Adv. Electron. Electron Phys. 65, 175. Kothleitner, G. and Hofer, F. (1998). Micron 29, 349. Kothleitner, G. and Hofer, F. (2003). Ultramicroscopy 96, 491. Kotula, P., Michael, J.R. and Kennan, M.R. (2001). Microsc. Microanal. 7, 198. Kotula, P., Kennan, M.R. and Michael, J.R. (2003). Microsc. Microanal. 9, 1. Kramers, M.A. (1923). Phil. Mag. 46, 836. Krivanek, O.L., Bacon, N.J., Corbin, G.J., Dellby, N., Hincirik, P., Krivanek, O.L., McNamara-Smith, A., Murfitt, M.F. and Szilagy, Z.S. (2005). Microsc. Microanal. 11 (Supplement 2), 1422. Krivanek, O.L., Ahn, C.C. and Keeney, R.B. (1987). Ultramicroscopy 22, 103. Krivanek, O.L., Gubbens, A.J. and Dellby, N. (1991a). Microsc. Microanal. Microstruct. 2, 315–332. Krivanek, O.L., Mory, C., Tencé, M. and Colliex, C. (1991b). Microsc. Microanal. Microstruct. 2, 257. Krivanek, O.L., Bui, D.N., Ray, D.A., Boothroyd, C.B. and Humphreys, C.J. (1994). In 13th International Electron Microscopy Congress, p. 167 (Les Editions de Physique, Les Ulis, Paris). Krivanek, O.L., Friedman, S.L., Gubbens, A.J. and Kraus, B. (1995a). Ultramicroscopy 59, 267. Krivanek, O.L., Kundmann, M.K. and Kimoto, K. (1995b). J. Microsc. 180, 277. Krivanek, O.L., Nellist, P.D., Dellby, N., Murfitt, M.F. and Z., S. (2003). Ultramicroscopy 96, 229. L’Espérance, G., Botton, G.A. and Caron, M. (1990). Proceedings of the Microbeam Analysis Society 1990 (J.R. Michael and P. Ingram, Eds.), p. 284. (San Francisco Press, San Francisco). Launay, M., Boucher, F. and Moreau, P. (2004). Phys. Rev. B 69, 03101. Lavergne, J.-L., Martin, J.-M. and Belin, M. (1992). Microsc. Microanal. Microstruct. 3, 517. Lazar, S., Botton, G.A., Wu, M.-Y., Tichelaar, F.D. and Zandbergen, H.W. (2003). Ultramicroscopy 96, 535. Leapman, R.D. (2003). J. Microsc. 210, 5. Leapman, R.D. and Newbury, D.E. (1993). Anal. Chem. 65, 2409. Leapman, R.D. and Rizzo, N.W. (1999). Ultramicroscopy 78, 251.
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy Leapman, R.D., Rez, P. and Mayers, D.F. (1980). J. Chem. Phys. 72, 1232. Loan, R.F., Kirkland, E.J. and Silcox, J. (1988). Acta Crystallogr. A 44. Luo, B.P. and Zeitler, E. (1991). J. El. Spect. Rel. Phen. 57, 285. Malis, T. and Titchmarsh, J.M. (1985). In Electron Microscopy and Analysis 1985, p. 181 (Institute of Physics Conference Series, Institute of Physics, Bristol). Malis, T., Cheng, S.C. and Egerton, R.F. (1988). J. Electron Microsc. Tech. 8, 193. Mansot, J.L., Leone, P., Euzen, P. and Pavaldeau, P. (1994). Microsc. Microanal. Microstruct. 5, 79. Mayer, J., Deininger, C. and Reimer, L. (1995). In Energy Filtering Transmission Electron Microscopy (L. Reimer, Ed.) (Springer, Heidelberg). Mayer, J., Eigenthaler, U., Plitzko, J.M. and Dettenwanger, F. (1997). Micron 28, 361. Menon, N. and Krivanek, O.L. (2002). Microsc. Microanal. 8, 203. Mitterbauer, C., Kothleithner, G., Hofer, F. and Zandbergen, H. (2003). Ultramicroscopy 96, 469. Mobus, G. and Nufer, S. (2003). Ultramicroscopy 96, 285. Moreau, P. and Cheynet, M.C. (2003). Ultramicroscopy 94, 293. Mory, C., Colliex, C. and Cowley, J. (1987). Ultramicroscopy 21, 171. Mullejans, H. and French, R.H. (2000). Microsc. Microanal. 6, 297. Muller, D.A. and Silcox, J. (1995). Ultramicroscopy 59, 195. Muller, D.A., Tzou, Y., Raj, R. and Silcox, J. (1993). Nature 366, 725. Muller, D.A., Sorch, T., Moccio, S., Baumann, F.H., Evans-Luttertodt, K. and Timp, G. (1999). Nature 399, 758. Muller, D.A., Nakagawa, N., Ohtomo, A., Grazul, J.L. and Hwang, H.Y. (2004). Nature 430, 657. Nakata, K., Okada, O. and Ueki, Y. (2001). J. Electron Microsc. 50, 89. Natusch, M.K.H., Humphreys, C.J., Menon, N. and Krivanek, O.L. (1999). Micron 30, 173. Nellist, P. and Pennycook, S.J. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 4156. Newbury, D.E. (1998). J. Electron Microsc. 47, 407. Newbury, D.E., Wollman, D.A., Hilton, G.C., Irwin, K.D., Bergren, N.F., Rudman, D.A., and Martinis, J.M. (2000). J. Radioanal. Nucl. Chem. 244, 627. Nicholson, W.A.P., Gray, C.C., Chapman, J.N. and Robertson, B.W. (1982). J. Microsc. 125, 25. Nocholds, C., Nasir, M.J., Cliff, G. and Liorimer, G.W. (1979). In Electron Microscopy and Analysis (T. Mulvey, Ed.), p. 417 (Institute of Physics Conference Series No. 52, Institute of Physics, London). Oikawa, T. (2006). Private communication. Otten, M.T. (1996). The CM Series Transmission Electron Microscopes in Materials Research. (Electron Optics, Eindhoven, The Netherlands). Ottensmeyer, F.P. (2004). Private communication. Oxley, M.P., Cosgriff, E.C. and Allen, L.J. (2005). Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 203906. Paxton, A.T. (2005). J. El. Spect. Rel. Phen. 143, 51. Pennycook, S.J. (1982). Contemp. Phys. 23, 371. Pennycook, S.J., Jesson, D.E., McGibbon, A.J. and Nellist, P.D. (1996). J. Electron Microsc. 45, 36. Philibert, J. and Tixier, R. (1975). In Physical Aspects of Electron Microscopy and Microbeam Analysis (D.R. Beaman and B.M. Siegel, Eds.), p. 333 (Wiley, New York). Pickard, C.J. and Payne, M.C. (1997). In Institute of Physics Conference Series 153 EMAG 97, p. 179 (Institute of Physics, London). Potapov, P.L., Jorissen, K., Schryvers, D. and Lamoen, D. (2004). In European Microscopy Congress (D. Schryvers and P. Van Oostveldt, Eds.), p. 247 (Belgian Society for Microscopy, Antwerp). Powell, C.J. (1976). Rev. Mod. Phys. 48, 33.
403
404
G. Botton Radtke, G., Epicier, T., Bayle-Guillemaud, P. and Le Bosse, J.C. (2003). J. Microsc. 210, 60. Raether, H. (1980). Excitations of Plasmons and Interband Transitions by Electrons (Springer-Verlag, New York). Reed, S.J.B. (1966). Proceedings of the 5th International. Congress on X-ray Optics and Microanalysis (R. Castaing, R. Deschamps and J. Philibert, Eds.), p. 339 (Herman, Paris). Reese, G.M., Spence, J.C.H. and Yamamoto, Y. (1984). Phil. Mag. A 49, 697. Reimer, L. (1984). Transmission Electron Microscopy (Springer-Verlag, Heidelberg). Reimer, L. (1995). In Introduction, Energy Filtering Transmission Electron Microscopy (L. Reimer, Ed.), p. 1 (Springer, Heidelberg). Rez, P. (1982). Ultramicroscopy 9, 283. Rez, P. (1984). Ultramicroscopy 12, 29–38. Rez, P., Bruley, J., Brohan, P., Payne, M. and Garvie, L.A.J. (1995). Ultramicroscopy 59, 159. Rose, A. (1970). Image Technol. 12, 1315. Rose, H. and Krahl, D. (1995). In Electron Optics of Imaging Filters, Energy Filtering Electron Microscopy (L. Reimer, Ed.), p. 43 (Springer, Heidelberg). Saldin, D.K. (1987). Phil. Mag. B 25, 515. Saunders, M. (2003). Microsc. Microanal. 9, 411. Schaffer, B., Grogger, W. and Kothleithner, G. (2004). Ultramicroscopy 102, 27. Schamm, S. and Zanchi, G. (2003). Ultramicroscopy 96, 559. Schattschneider, P. and Exner, A. (1995). Ultramicroscopy 59, 241. Schattschneider, P. and Jouffrey, B. (1995). In Energy Filtering Transmission Electron Microscopy (L. Reimer, Ed.), p. 151 (Springer, Heidelberg). Schattschneider, P. and Werner, W.S.M. (2005). J. El. Spect. Rel. Phen. 143, 81. Shuman, H. and Somlyo, A.P. (1987). Ultramicroscopy 21, 23. *Sigle, W. (2005). Analytical transmission electron microscopy. Annual Review of Materials Research 35, 239–314. *Sigle, W., Kramer, S., Varshney, V., Zern, A., Eigenthaler, U. and Rühle, M. (2003). Plasmon energy mapping in energy-filtering electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 96, 565. Solymar, L. and Walsh, D. (2004). Lectures on the Electronic Properties of Materials, 6th ed. (Oxford. University Press, Oxford). Spence, J.C.H. (2006). Rep. Prog. Phys. 69, 725. Spence, J.C.H. and Lynch, J. (1982). Ultramicroscopy 9, 267. Spence, J.C.H. and Zuo, J.M. (1992). Electron Microdiffraction (Plenum, New York). Spence, J.C.H., Reese, G.M., Yamamoto, Y. and Kurizki, G. (1983). Phil. Mag. B 48, L39. Stenton, N., Notis, M.R., Goldstein, J.I. and Williams, D.B. (1981). In Quantitative Analysis with High Spatial Resolution (G.W. Lorimer, M.H. Jacobs and P. Doigt, Eds.), Book 277, p. 35 (The Metals Society, London). *Stöger-Pollach, M., Franco, H., Schattschneider, P., Lazar, B., Schaffer, B., Grogger, W. and Zandbergen, H.W. (2006). Cerenkov losses: a limit for bandgap determination and Kramers–Kronig analysis. Micron 37, 396–402. Su, D.S., Wang, H.F. and Zeitler, E. (1995). Ultramicroscopy 59, 181. Suenaga, K., Tencé, M., Mory, C., Colliex, C., Okazaki, T., Shinohara, H., Hirahara, K., Bandow, S. and Iijima, S. (2000). Science 290, 2280. Sun, S.Q., Shi, S.L., Hunt, J.A. and Leapman, R.D. (1995). J. Microscopy 177, 18. Tanaka, M., Terauchi, M., Tsuda, K., Saitoh, K., Mukai, M., Kaneyama, T., Tomita, T., Tsuno, K., Kersker, M., Naruse, M. and Honda, T. (2002). In Microscopy and Microanalysis 2002 (E. Voelkl, D. Piston, R. Gauvin,
Chapter 4 Analytical Electron Microscopy A.J. Lockley, G.W. Bailey and S. McKernan, Eds.), p. 68 (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Tencé, M. (2002). Private communication. Terauchi, M., Tanaka, M., Tsuno, K. and Ishida, M. (1999). J. Microsc. 194, 203. Thomas, P.J. and Midgley, P.A. (2001a). Ultramicroscopy 88, 187. Thomas, P.J. and Midgley, P.A. (2001b). Ultramicroscopy 88, 179. Tiemeijer, P.C., van Lin, J.H.A. and de Jong, A.F. (2001). Microsc. Microanal. 7, 1130. Titchmarsh, J.M. and Dumbill, S. (1996). J. Microsc. 184, 195. Trebbia, P. (1988). Ultramicroscopy 24, 399. Turowski, M.A. and Kelly, T.F. (1992). Ultramicroscopy 41, 41. Uhlemann, S. and Haider, M. (2002). In Microscopy and Microanalysis 2002 (E. Voelkl, D. Piston, R. Gauvin, A.J. Lockley, G.W. Bailey and S. McKernan, Eds.), p. 584CD (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Van Cappellen, E. (1990). Microsc. Microanal. Microstruct. 1, 1. Van Cappellen, E. and Doukhan, J.C. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 53, 343. Varela, M., Findlay, S.D., Lupini, A.R., Christen, H.M., Borisevich, A.Y., Dellby, N., Krivanek, O.L., Nellist, P.D., Oxley, M.P., Allen, L.J. and Pennycook, S.J. (2004). Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 095502. Verbeeck, J. and Van Aert, S. (2004). Ultramicroscopy 101, 207. Verbeeck, J., Van Dyck, D. and Van Tandeloo, G. (2004). Spectrochim. Acta B 59, 1529. von Barth, U. and Grossman, G. (1982). Phys. Rev. B 25(8), 5, 50 Voyles, P. and Muller, D.A. (2004). Microsc. Microanal. 10, 291. Vvedensky, D.D. (1992). In Theory of X-Ray Absorption Fine Structure, Unoccupied Electronic States (J.C. Fuggle and J.E. Inglesfield, Eds.), p. 138 (SpringerVerlag, Berlin). Watanabe, M. and Williams, D.B. (1999). Microsc. Microanal. 5, 88. Watanabe, M. and Williams, D.B. (2005a). Microscopy and Microanalysis 2005, Vol. 11, Suppl. 2, edited by R. Price, P. Kotula, M. Marko, J.H. Scott, G.F. Van der Voort, M. Mah Lee Ng, K. Smith, B. Griffin, P. Smith and S. McKernan, p. 1362. Honolulu, HI: Cambridge University Press. Watanabe, M. and Williams, D.B. (2005b). Scanning 27, 94. Watanabe, M., Horita, Z. and Nemoto, M. (1996). Ultramicroscopy 65, 187–198. Watanabe, M., Ackland, D.W., Burrows, A., Kiely, C.J., Williams, D.B., Kanno, M. and Hynes, R. (2005). In Microscopy and Microanalysis 2005 (R. Price, P. Kotula, M. Marko, J.H. Scott, G.F. Van der Voort, M. Mah Lee Ng, K. Smith, B. Griffin, P. Smith and S. McKernan, Eds.), Vol. 11, Suppl. 2, p. 2132 (Cambridge University Press, Honolulu, HI). Westwood, A.D., Michael, J.R. and Notis, M.R. (1992). J. Microsc. 167, 287. Williams, D.B. and Carter, C.B. (1996). Transmission Electron Microscopy, A Textbook for Materials Science (Plenum, New York). Williams, D.B., Watanabe, M., Papworth, A.J. and Li, J.C. (2003). Thin Solid Films 424, 50. Woldseth, R. (1973). X-Ray Energy Spectrometry (Kevex Instruments). Wong, K. and Egerton, R.F. (1995). J. Microsc. 178, 198. Wooten, F. (1972). Optical properties of solids. (Academic Press, New York). Yang, Y.Y. and Egerton, R.F. (1995). Micron 26, 1. *Yurtserver, A., Weyland, M. and Muller, D.A. (2006). Three-dimensional imaging of nonspherical silicon nanoparticles embedded in silicon oxide by plasmon tomography. Applied Physics Letters 89, 151920. Zaluzec, N.J. (1982). Ultramicroscopy 9, 319. Zaluzec, N.J. (1984). J. Phys. 45 (Suppl. 2), C2-429. Zaluzec, N. (1985). Ultramicroscopy 18, 185. Ziebold, T.O. (1967). Anal. Chem. 39, 858.
*References added since the first printing.
405
5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy Wayne E. King, Michael R. Armstrong, Oleg Bostanjoglo, and Bryan W. Reed
1 What Is High-Speed Electron Microscopy? Historically, transmission electron microscope (TEM) images have been recorded on film using exposure times of a few seconds. The use of the TEM, and especially the high-voltage electron microscope, for in situ experiments stimulated interfacing of video cameras with the microscope column. This enabled capture of frames with millisecond exposure times and interframe times of milliseconds and proved to be very useful for the study of dynamic phenomena with characteristic times that were consistent with the time resolution of the detectors, such as dislocation motion in deforming metals. Many phenomena in chemistry, biology, and materials science proceed at rates that are significantly faster than could be captured with standard video methods. Figure 5–1 attempts to represent some of those phenomena in terms of spatial resolution and time resolution. Experimental techniques exist for probing most of this space, but the quadrant at high space and time resolutions has proved to be the most difficult to access. The chemistry community, which studies phenomena with characteristic time scales of the order of the atomic vibrational period, has employed short pulse lasers and optical techniques to study ultrafast phenomena. Likewise, X-rays are becoming an important tool for ultrafast studies. Recently, ultrafast electron diffraction (UED) has been developed with time resolutions approaching that of optical and X-ray methods.1–9 Although optical and X-ray methods are powerful, the widespread use of TEMs and the accompanying extensive literature demonstrate that there are many scientific investigations that benefit from high spatial resolution imaging. In materials science, these include observation of defects in crystalline materials (e.g., dislocations, grain boundaries, and heterophase boundaries) in which imaging affords a more direct interpretation of the defect structure than does diffraction. One group has demonstrated the potential of high-speed TEM or dynamic (DTEM).10–16 This group has produced an imaging instrument
406
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
407
1010 Making and Breaking of Bonds
Spatial Resolution (m-1)
109 108
Dislocation Dynamics at Conventional Strain Rates
structural changes in biology
melting and resolidification
107
magnetic switching
Diffraction of Phase Transformations
106 Imaging of Phase Transformations
105 104
nucleation and growth of damage
103 100
102
104
106
108
1010
1012
1014
Time Resolution (s-1) Figure 5–1. Phenomena classified by spatial and temporal resolution. Spatial resolution, is defined as follows: (1) if the technique is an imaging method, the low end of the bounding box would be defined by the smallest resolvable feature and the high end by the typical field of view or (2) for a nonimaging technique, the bounding box would be defined by the range of probe or spot sizes. Time resolution is defined as that for a single-shot investigation of irreversible processes. So time resolution is defi ned as the single-shot exposure time to obtain data that demonstrate a particular spatial resolution. (See color plate.)
with time resolution ∼3–10 ns10,11 and has demonstrated pump/probetrain “movie” or nanosecond multiframe operation.17,18 In this chapter we review the events leading to the development of the DTEM. We then describe the technologies employed in DTEM. Finally, we discuss the performance, limitations, and applications and conclude with a look to the future of these instruments.
2 Technologies of DTEM 2.1 Anatomy of a DTEM Figure 5–2 shows a photo of the DTEM that was developed at TU Berlin. The instrument in Berlin is based on a Siemens Elmiskop 1A constructed in 1961. Several modifications, shown in Figure 5–3, were required to convert the instrument from a conventional continuouswave (CW) mode to an instrument that could carry out pump-probe
408
W.E. King et al.
experiments. These included the development of a photoelectron gun to replace the conventional thermionic tungsten filament. This was realized by interfacing a laser to the electron-optical column via a vacuum feed-through and directing that laser to the filament using a turning mirror. The photocathode is driven by a Q-switched frequencyquadrupled Nd:YAG laser (wavelength 266 nm). Using the photoelectric effect, a short laser pulse stimulates the emission of a low-energy electron bunch that is accelerated by the high-voltage stage of the electron microscope. In CW mode, the self-biasing Wehnelt brings the electrons emitted at the filament to a focus, thus defining the object plane for the condenser lens system. In the pulsed mode, circuit time constants inhibit the self-biasing effect of the Wehnelt, no crossover is formed, and the optics are a bit different than CW operation. The photocathode in the Berlin instrument has been designed so that it can operate in either CW or pulsed modes. This facilitates easy electronoptical alignment of the instrument. Since the electrons are emitted from slightly different regions of the cathode in thermionic operation compared with pulsed operation, it is essential to be able to align the gun in pulsed mode. This is achieved by pulsing the photocathode periodically at a rate of several pulses per second, observing the image on the digital image capture system (discussed later), and carrying out a gun alignment. Accelerators for TEMs are designed to give smooth electric field gradients and stable potentials. The TU Berlin instrument typically operates at 80 kV with an accelerating gap of 1 cm. This corresponds to
Figure 5–2. The DTEM at TU Berlin. Cathode and sample drive lasers are at left. (See color plate.)
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
Figure 5–3. TU Berlin dynamic transmission electron microscope. (See color plate.)
a field gradient of 8 × 104 V/cm. When electrons are photoemitted at low energy from the cathode, they are most vulnerable to space charge effects. It is therefore advantageous to optimize the extraction potential at the cathode and the field gradient to minimize space charge effects. This may be achieved by using an extraction electrode similar to those used in field emission electron guns. The steady-state current limit due to space charge in a parallel-plate accelerating gap is dictated by the Child–Langmuir law,19 and varies as V 3/2/d2, with V the voltage and d the distance between the cathode and the extraction electrode. Thus it is most effective to have both a large electric field (possibly enhanced by surface curvature of the cathode) and a short gap.
409
410
W.E. King et al.
Since the photoemitted electrons will be incoherent, it is not essential to have a very small source size. Therefore, it may be possible to spread the laser beam across a relatively large area to ensure that sufficient electrons can be generated without damaging the cathode with the laser. Of course, the size of the souce will control the size of the smallest electron beam spot on the sample. Therefore, there will be a trade-off between the region of interest and source size. The source size should be adjusted to achieve the desired viewing area and no larger (to minimize space charge effects). Apertures will play an important role in limiting space charge effects in DTEM. The condenser aperture should be removed to maximize the electron fluence on the sample. The objective aperture can be used to produce contrast by blocking scattered electrons as is routinely done in diffraction contrast imaging. This will decrease the number of electrons in the beam as the beam passes through the projector lens system. Alternatively, it is possible to block the main beam and allow the scattered electrons to pass. In a double condensor lens system common to most electron microscopes, the first condensor will likely be opperated at low or zero excitation to allow as many electrons as possible to pass to the second condensor lens. This lens can then be used in conjunction with the source size to optimize the illumination area on the sample. Because of the energy spread in pulsed beams, chromatic aberration will limit the obtainable resolution. Thus constraints on the design of the objective lens can be relaxed until a need for high resolution arises. At that point, an aberration correction may be possible. The projector lens has the potential to introduce distortion in the image if space charge and trajectory displacement effects are significant at the numerous crossovers in the projector lens system. For sufficiently short pulses, a lateral space charge effect could become significant at the crossovers. The time resolution of the TU Berlin instrument is currently 3–10 ns. At this resolution, the electron pulse length is controlled primarily by the laser pulse length and by the number of electrons in an electron bunch required to obtain an image. By making a few simplifications and assumptions, the number of electrons needed to form an image can be estimated. The current state of the art in low-dose TEM applications in the biological sciences requires an average of about 100 electrons per pixel.20 For a 1 k % 1 k pixel image, this requirement leads to 107–108 total electrons at the image plane (see Figure 5–4). This number of electrons per pulse is currently achieved by the nanosecond electron microscope at TU Berlin.11 However, many electrons are lost in the TEM condenser lenses. Thus, the number of electrons that is required at the cathode may be substantially higher. Other factors that will influence the number of electrons arriving at the image plane include specimen thickness, diffracting conditions chosen for image formation, and the size and placement of the objective aperture. The number of electrons needed to form a diffraction pattern can be substantially less than that required for an image. As few as 104 electrons may be needed for the qualitative assessment of a diffraction
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
411
Figure 5–4. Simulation demonstrating the number of electrons required for a given image quality. The original 512% 512 8-bit grayscale image was normalized and taken as the probability distribution for the detected position of each independent electron. Binning to a smaller number of pixels would reduce the required number of electrons, but at the expense of resolution. Various methods for estimating this (including the one shown here) consistently indicate that 106 –108 electrons are needed at the detector, depending on the number of pixels and the required contrast. Crystalline diffraction patterns require ∼10–100 times fewer electrons because of the concentration of intensity into relatively few pixels.
pattern.20 However, for quantitative assessment, more (as many as 108) could be required for improved signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). It is desirable to have the ability to induce physical changes in the sample that can be easily synchronized with the probe electron pulse. This has been accomplished at TU Berlin by interfacing a pump laser with the DTEM instrument. The pump beam is fed into the column at a position above the objective lens and directed to the sample by a turning mirror. Using this configuration, it is possible to bring an ∼20µm-diameter pump beam into coincidence with the probe electron beam. In the TU Berlin instrument, two different lasers are used for pump and probe. This is reasonable for systems with time resolutions on a nanosecond scale. At higher time resolutions, unacceptable jitter between the lasers will require the use of a single seed-laser with beam split into pump and probe beams. Because of the limited number of electrons per pulse, it is essential to have a highly efficient detector, the so-called “every-electron camera.” Space-charge limits on the number of electrons in a short pulse put a premium on detection efficiency. However, because of the large spec-
412
W.E. King et al. Electron Microscope
Base plate Insertable gate valve
Phosphor Fibre optics CCD Peltier cooling element Water jacket
Preamplifiers
Vacuum system
Cooling water
CCD drive pulses
Figure 5–5. Directly coupled CCD camera system.
trum of desired electron energies (keV–MeV) and the disparate requirements of imaging and diffraction, it is clear that no single camera is ideal for every application. At high energies (>100 keV), phosphor scintillators are preferred (Figure 5–5). Phosphor thickness can be optimized to achieve an energy conversion efficiency of ∼0.12 (with intensification not required).21 Light-scattering effects within the phosphor and the various optical interfaces limit system resolution.22 The point spread function (PSF) for a detector system composed of phosphor on a fiberoptic faceplate is determined by electron and photon scattering as well as the numerical aperture (NA) of the fiberoptic plate. The next step is to couple the phosphor to the charge-couple device (CCD). This is typically achieved using a fiberoptic bundle or lens coupling. Fiberoptic coupling is preferred for energies below 400 keV because of the high-photon-collection solid angle from the phosphor. Because the PSF of the phosphor is greater than the pixel size of typical CCDs, taper-fiber bundles are often employed to improve the PSF/pixel size match. However, tapered bundles can exhibit spatial distortions of ∼2–3% that need to be corrected before quantitative measurements can be made from images or diffraction patterns.21 With the availability of large CCD chips, 1 : 1 coupling becomes practical. Also, binning of adjacent pixels is used to boost the detective quantum efficiency (DQE). Finally, to achieve images that follow the evolution of dynamic processes, a multiframe movie mode is desirable. Interframe times less than a nanosecond are desirable to observe dynamic processes. Currently, no technology exists that will enable such rapid filling and readout of CCD cameras. At TU Berlin, movie mode is achieved through the use of an electrostatic beam shifter (Figure 5–3). An image-shifting capacitor with low inductance leads is used to produce successive frames by displacing an image patch across the detector between the
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
electron pulses. For multiframe imaging of the specimen, the image is confined by an adjustable slit aperture in the second-intermediate image plane, exploiting the space between the intermediate and projector lenses. For multiframe diffraction, the diffraction pattern in the back focal plane of the objective lens is confined with a suitable aperture, and this pattern is as usual transferred with the intermediate and projector lenses to the detector.10 The beam shifter is a low-capacitance rectangular plate capacitor mounted on a side-entry retractable holder. It was designed to fit into the space between the intermediate and projector lenses. Two blades glued onto the plate electrodes at the beam entrance serve as the image field-confining aperture. The plates of the capacitor are tilted to prevent the deflected electrons from hitting the attracting electrode. The capacitor can be axially moved and the distance between the plates varied, allowing alignment and field selection. The deflecting unit is inserted at such a location that the second intermediate image can be positioned near the field-confining slit aperture. Three-frame imaging is achieved by applying a two-step voltage waveform across the capacitor (Figure 5–6). Because the deflecting field is short due to limited space and since the deflection occurs near an image plane, high voltages of several hundred volts are required to shift 100-kV electron images. The shifting steps are produced by shorting voltages with fast transistor-based switches (Figure 5–7). When both switches are open the image is on the left-hand side (Figure 5–6). As switch S1 closes, the image is moved to the center. Finally, switch S2 closes transferring a positive voltage step via the 6.8-nF capacitor to the right electrode, thereby displacing the image to the right side. A high-voltage radio frequency n-channel metal oxide semiconductor field-effect transistor and cascaded bipolar transistors (Motorola 2N5551) driven in the avalanche mode were used as switches. The voltage fall times were 2–3 ns. Overshoot and ringing were minimized by careful grounding, shielding, and placing of leads avoiding stray capacitance, parasitic inductance, and closed loops. In addition, ferritedamping beads were suitably distributed along the leads. The switches were mounted directly on the holder of the shifting capacitor to avoid voltage distortions caused by reflections and to minimize electromagnetic interference. Electromagnetic interference easily was kept below a deleterious level using the MOSFET-based switch. But it is rather inconvenient to
Figure 5–6. Generation of voltage steps across the image shifting capacitor for threeframes imaging.
413
414
W.E. King et al.
Figure 5–7. Fast high-voltage switches. (a) High-power radiofrequency nchannel MOSFET for shutting down a positive voltage below 500 V. DE275 is supplied by Directed Energy Inc. (b) Cascaded avalanche npn transistors for switching off a negative voltage of twice the collector-base breakdown voltage (about −700 V). The transformer is a high-frequency ferrite ring (40–400 MHz) with five windings of strand wire for each coil. The Schottky diodes and the 100-Ω resistor protect the trigger circuit against voltage steps passed by the gain-multiplied collector-base capacitance during switching. The 200-pF capacitor holds off the DC high voltage in case of isolation failure.
supply the required large gate currents if a high negative voltage is to be switched, since gate and source are then at a high potential. In contrast, the voltage-triggered avalanche transistor cascades can readily be used as switches for voltages of either polarity. Unfortunately, electromagnetic interference is pronounced, and it proved problematic to prevent two cascades from firing simultaneously. For these reasons switch 1, handling a positive voltage, is based on the fast MOSFET, and the avalanche transistor cascade is used to switch the negative voltage. 2.2 Photoelectron Guns DTEM requires an extremely bright pulsed electron source. A 512 % 512 pixel image on the border of usefulness requires ∼106 electrons at the detector, while a good image requires ∼108 (Figure 5–4). To obtain a usable image in a single shot, this number of electrons must pass through the sample region of interest in ∼1–10 ns, which implies a
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
current of order 0.01–10 mA. Further, to obtain good results the illumination spot must be significantly larger than the region of interest, and some electrons will have to be thrown away at various apertures. So even these enormously high currents may not be enough for some applications. To squeeze 10 mA of current into a 1-µm radius spot with a 1 milliradian convergence semiangle would require a normalized brightness of order 4 % 109 A cm−2 steradian−1 (assuming a typical TEM voltage of 200 keV). This is too high a brightness for a thermionic cathode (pulsed or otherwise) and too much current for a typical field emission gun.23 This brightness is just within reach for a pulsed photocathode-based system24,25 and the required current can be attained by using a somewhat larger emission area than is typical for TEM. Beyond this point, signal levels must be traded off against spot size and/or convergence angle—or invent a brighter electron source, possibly using pulse compression (discussed in a later section). Phenomena such as charge trapping26 and space-charge repulsion from previously emitted electrons (i.e., the effect that leads to Child’s law in the steady-state case)27 may also limit the number of electrons in a pulse. Bostanjoglo et al. report a maximum current of 20 mA in a 20-ns pulse at 80 kV with a brightness of ∼2 % 106 A cm−2 steradian−1, achieving a factor of 50 enhancement in brightness by operating in a laser-driven pulsed mode as compared to a DC thermionic mode.27–29 The energy spread was reported as 8.7 eV. Brightness is roughly proportional to accelerating voltage in this regime; most of the reported increase of brightness with voltage may be attributed to the conservation of normalized brightness, which is ∼6 % 106 A cm−2 steradian−1 for this case. Pulsed high-voltage RF photoelectron guns can significantly exceed this brightness and current,24,25,30 but at the cost of very high energy spreads ∼1% or more, which may limit their suitability for DTEM applications. An interesting near-future challenge would be to determine whether and how to borrow design concepts from the RF guns to improve the DTEM sources.30 At any rate, in the DTEM every electron is precious. In static TEM it is common practice to block most of the electrons at the condenser apertures in order to attain good spatial co-herence and small lateral emittance [emittance is, to within definition-dependent factors of order unity,31 the product of the spot size and convergence angle and is a conserved purely geometric quantity in a linear electron-optical system at constant voltage with no apertures (Reiser,19 pp. 56ff)]. This allows the production of very fine spots limited in size primarily by diffraction and spherical aberration, or of wider spots with very small incident angular spreads. This enables the familiar “nanoanalytical” and “parallel-beam” modes of operation. In the DTEM one will typically be electron-starved and will not have the luxury of using a small condenser aperture; the instrument performance will necessarily suffer. A typical TEM that can attain atomic resolution lattice images and subnanometer spot sizes in a static mode will simply not be able to do these things in nanosecond pulses with any foreseeable electron source.
415
416
W.E. King et al.
2.3 Materials for Photoelectron Guns The ideal photo cathode should (1) be able to produce high current densities of about 1 kA/cm2, (2) be resistant to residual gases in a high vacuum (oxygen, water, hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide, and carbon dioxide), (3) be tolerant to ion bombardment and thermal spikes due to arcing. and (4) exhibit a low work function to relax requirements on the driving photons.32 To shift the negative space-charge-induced saturation of the electron emission to higher current densities, the accelerating electric field should be as high as possible. This increases the chance for an electric breakdown between the cathode and the accelerating anode. An ion bombardment of the cathode results until the charge of the capacitance between the cathode (usually at high negative potential) and ground is exhausted. The ions are produced by ionization of evaporated anode material and desorbed/disintegrated layers (oxides, hydrocarbons, water, air molecules) covering all surfaces in an ordinary high vacuum system. If the capacitance between cathode and ground is not small enough a high current arc can develop between cathode and anode. The energy of the impinging ion pulse is large enough to sputter and heat the cathode substantially. A weak but continuous ion bombardment derives from electron beam-induced ionization of the residual gas. The sputtering and chemical reaction caused by these ions are negligible, when the cathode is operated in ultrahigh vacuum. Materials suitable for photocathodes can be divided in semiconducting and metallic photoelectron emitters in view of their band structure and associated current limitation. 2.3.1 Semiconducting Emitters In semiconducting emitters valence electrons are photoexcited into the conduction band. If the energy of the photons exceeds the sum of band gap and electron affinity, some excited electrons tunnel through the surface potential barrier and escape to the vacuum. The rest are trapped in surface states, increasing the surface barrier. Fortunately, they are neutralized by thermionic and tunneling holes from the valence band, which restore the equilibrium surface barrier. However, if the photocathode is driven with nanosecond and shorter light pulses of high intensity, the number of excited electrons that are trapped can become too large to be compensated by the restoring hole currents. The surface barrier is then increased, and the extractable charge saturates at a value lower than the space charge limit. This surface charge limit effect is a characteristic of nonmetallic emitters.26 Cesium-based antimonides, such as Cs2Sb and K2CsSb, are among the materials with low work function (about 2 eV).33 But they are extremely sensitive to contamination, thermal spikes, and ion bombardment. For a higher work function, about 3.5 eV, there are materials that are much more resistant to contamination by residual gases such as Cs2Te and GaAs-based emitters.33–36 Their thermal stability is poor, however. Providing heavily p-doped GaAs or other III–V semiconductors with Cs-suboxide surface layers produces materials with a nega-
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
tive electron affinity.34–37 These materials have large quantum efficiencies for spin-polarized electrons, 0.3% for wavelengths of 810–830 nm. The heavy surface doping also enhances the restoring hole currents that compensate trapped photoexcited electrons, avoiding the surface charge limit phenomenon.35–37 Unfortunately, the doped surface layers make the negative electron affinity cathodes again vulnerable to contamination, ion bombardment, and thermal stressing. In contrast to all the above semiconducting materials, p-doped diamond and fullerene films38 are extremely wear and heat resistant. The quantum efficiencies, however, are distinctly lower (about 3 × 10−4 for 217-nm photons). 2.3.2 Metallic Emitters Metallic emitters can be subdivided into compounds with metallic conductivity and metals. Rare earth monosulfides39 and hexaborides,40–42 borides and carbides of refractory metals, are examples of compounds with a low work function and high conductivity.40 The rare earth sulfides, e.g., CeS, NdS, and PrS, are distinguished by very low work functions of 1.1–1.4 eV, high melting temperatures of 2400–2700 K, and high resistance to ion bombardment and contamination. Thin films of these materials are readily produced by vacuum evaporation. However, their vapor pressure at elevated temperatures is substantial, which prohibits thermionic operation. The rare earth hexaborides LaB6 and CeB6 are widely used in thermal cathodes. They are thermally more stable than the monosulfides, but they are disintegrated by ion bombardment and have a higher work function of about 2.6 eV. Borides and carbides of refractory metals have even higher work functions of 3.0–3.5 eV. But since their melting temperatures are extremely high, e.g., 3800 K in the case of ZrC, these emitters readily tolerate arcing. In addition, they are not sensitive to contamination and can therefore be operated in ordinary high vacuum. Metals exhibit a wide range of work functions as well as thermal and mechanical strengths. Candidates for high-performance photocathodes are reviewed by Travier.43 Alkali and alkali earth metals are at the low end of the work functions. They are chemically extremely sensitive and mechanically and thermally weak. The mechanical strength and tolerance to arcing of cathodes based on these high quantum efficiency metals can be substantially increased by implanting their atoms into tungsten or other high melting metals.44 Nonetheless, these cathodes remain sensitive to contamination and require ultrahigh vacuum. Rare earth metals have medium work functions of about 3.5 eV. They are mechanically strong and high melting metals. But they vigorously react with oxygen producing highly isolating oxide layers. Positive ions attracted by the negative cathode settle on the oxide layer where they produce a high electric field, which in turn triggers a breakdown (Malter effect). Accordingly, rare earth cathodes suffer from perpetual electric breakdowns when they are operated in high vacuum.
417
418
W.E. King et al.
Most metals with a high thermal and electrical stability and tolerating high vacuum have inconveniently large work functions. Zirconium is a compromise. This metal combines a medium work function (3.8– 4.05 eV depending on impurities) with a high melting temperature (2130 K), and it forms semiconducting suboxides in high vacuum, which neither deteriorate the quantum efficiency nor favor an electric breakdown. The influence of impurities on photoemission is very complicated. Surface contamination by water, carbon monoxide, and carbon dioxide, and hydrocarbons usually poisons photoemitters by producing hydroxide or carbonaceous layers. Oxygen, for instance, can either increase or reduce the work function, depending on the material, the emitting crystal lattice plane, and the surface coverage. Oxidation of materials with a low or medium work function usually decreases photoemission. Zirconium is an exception, if oxidation is limited so that only a few layers of the suboxide ZrO are formed.45 Water, carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and hydrocarbon molecules can poison photoemitters by producing covering oxides or carbonaceous layers. Alkali and alkali earth metals are chemically most reactive and therefore very sensitive to the vacuum atmosphere. Cs2Tb is a favorable exception33 as it is relatively unaffected by carbon compounds abundant in conventional high vacuum, such as CO, CO2, and CH4. If contamination is an issue, a satisfactory lifetime (several hours) can be achieved only at pressures below 10−9 mbar. The choice of a photocathode is a compromise between high quantum efficiency and long stable operation. Having selected the material and the driving photon source, being almost exclusively a laser, the generation of electron pulses with high current densities can be improved in several ways: 1. Using a photoelectron emitter with a rough surface enhances light absorption, makes use of field-assisted photoemission (Schottky effect), and photo-assisted field emission, increases the accelerating field and thus shifts the space charge-induced saturation to higher current densities, and provides the correct orientation of many surface elements to the electric field vector of the light for a maximum electron yield. Depending on the nature and degree of roughness the quantum efficiencies can be increased by a factor of three46 and more.47 2. Producing a small plasma cloud with the driving laser pulse, the saturation of the electron current due to negative space charge is avoided, and the electron pulse charge is augmented by secondary electrons.27 However, the pulse is stretched as trapped electrons are released when the plasma decays. 3. Ultrashort driving laser pulses provide additional benefits. First, if the emitted ultrashort electron bunch is shorter than the accelerating gap, its space charge field is approximately jτ/2ε0, with j the electron current density, τ the pulse duration, and ε0 the vacuum permittivity. The current density saturates as this obstructing field approaches the accelerating field, at values that may exceed the Child–Langmuir limit of stationary space charge by orders of magnitude.48 Second, if the laser
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
pulse duration is shorter than the electron–phonon relaxation time, about 10 ps for metals, the electrons can be excited to a high temperature and be thermally emitted before losing substantial energy to the lattice.49 If photoemitters on substrates are to be subjected to elevated temperatures, e.g., for continuous thermionic emission to simplify alignment and for cleaning and conditioning as in the case of dispenser cathodes,50 the supporting material should neither disintegrate the photoemitter nor produce a low melting eutectic. Substrate atoms rapidly penetrate along grain boundaries and eutectic channels to the surface and deteriorate the quantum efficiency if their work function is high.51 In view of this, for example, Zr on W or Re is a bad choice, as eutectics exist for these systems. However, Zr on Ta works well since these metals have a miscibility gap confining Ta that reaches the surface predominantly to Zr grain boundaries (Figure 5–8). A Zr-covered Ta hairpin emitter can be used as a conventional thermionic electron source and as a pulsed high- current photocathode, both in a normal high vacuum (<10−4 mbar). Electron pulses with a current density of 700 A/cm2 were produced by a laser radiation with a wavelength of 266 nm.51 In summary, the quantum efficiencies (QE) of different less sensitive metals are listed with references in Table 5–1 with the exciting wavelength. Photocathodes used at TU Berlin had a brightness of ∼6 % 107 A/cm2 sr at 100 kV, a quantum efficiency of 1.2 % 10−5, and emitted photoelectron pulses with current densities of up to 700 A/cm2 from an area of 20 µm diameter.10 2.4 Lasers Two lasers are required in the typical DTEM pump-probe experiment—one each for the cathode and the sample. At TU Berlin, these lasers must produce ∼6–10 ns pulses with spot diameters of 20–40 µm. This is achieved with Q-switched Nd:YAG and Ti:Sapphire lasers. The
Figure 5–8. A Zr on Ta cathode after 6 h of operation as a thermionic cathode, imaged by scanning electron microscopy with energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy. The bright islands between the Zr grains (dark) are Ta, which has penetrated the Zr layer. The quantum efficiency (4% 10−5 for light with a wavelength of 266 nm) was not affected.
419
420
W.E. King et al.
Table 5–1. Quantum efficiencies of less sensitive metals. 193
211
213
248
l (nm) 263 266 −5 QE (10 ) 2.6 a 2.0 b
Ag
28.4 a
Al
35.9a
84 c
2.6 a
a
c
a
Au Cu
16.2 20 c
28.6 a
40
1.1
15 c
3.2 c c
1.3, 4.7
0.84 a
Mg Nb
45d
1.2 b a
a
6.8
Ta
12.5 a
0.94 a
a
0.61
a
13.9a
1.4 a
8.9
0.47
72 b
0.016 c
1.0 b 23b 0.27, c 50 b 35 e
W(BaO) W(Ba-Ca-Sr-O)
230 24.7a
1.4 a
14 e
1.4 b 1.0 b
Li-Al
60f
b
c
d
e
f
2.3 e
d
Zr a
0.11c 1.2 c
W(K+)
Zn
0.016 c
b
0.3d
Sm
Y
0.034 c
0.49a
Pd
Tb
355
b
0.22, c 14 a,b 62
14.4 a
Mo
308
10f
Anderson T., Tomov I.V., Rentzepis P.M. Laser-driven metal photocathodes for picosecond electron and X-ray pulse generation. J Appl Phys 1992;71(10):5161–5167. Srinivasan-Rao T., Fischer J., Tsang T. Photoemission studies on metals using picosecond ultraviolet-laser pulses. J Appl Phys 1991;69(5):3291–3296. Chevallay E., Durand J., Hutchins S., Suberlucq G., Wurgel M. Photocathodes tested in the Dc gun of the Cern Photoemission Laboratory. Nucl Instrum Meth A 1994;340(1):146–156. Leblond B., Rajanoera G. Photoemission in the picosecond regime from a coated trioxide cathode. Nucl Instrum Meth A 1994;340(1):195–198. Leblond B. Short pulse photoemission from a dispenser cathode under the 2nd, 3rd and 4th harmonics of a picosecond Nd-Yag laser. Nucl Instrum Meth A 1992;317(1–2):365–372. Septier A., Sabary F., Dudek J.C., Bergeret H., Leblond B. A binary A1/Li alloy as a new material for the realization of high-intensity pulsed photocathodes. Nucl Instrum Meth A 1991;304(1–3):392–395.
required pulse energy depends significantly on the application and can be as high as ∼200 µJ for driving a pulsed thermionic cathode.29 Frequency doubling and quadrupling is employed to more effectively drive the required material transitions. This is especially important for the photocathode guns, which require ultraviolet light and are driven with a frequency-quadrupled Nd:YAG laser at 266 nm wavelength. The laser spots have Gaussian profiles, which affects the spatial uniformity of both the sample drive and the cathode emission. The need for multiple-frame movies (with each frame illuminated by its own cathode pulse) complicates the laser situation somewhat, especially since different applications may require very different pulse delays. The TU Berlin pulsed photocathode can produce single 7-ns
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
electron pulses, but uniformity suffers as the number of pulses is increased. This is because of the difficulty of producing multiple closely spaced identical pulses in a Q-switched nanosecond laser system. The second and third pulses have durations of 10 and 11 ns, respectively, with spacings ranging from 20 ns to 10 µs.52 Producing more than three nearly uniform pulses becomes progressively more difficult. The development of many-frame movies will require that this challenge be fully addressed.
3 Limitations 3.1 Time Resolution The duration of the electron pulse at the sample determines the time resolution of the DTEM in a normal imaging or diffraction mode. This will be our primary concern in this section. Higher time resolution has been demonstrated in a streak mode,53,54 at the cost of having only a one-dimensional image available at any given point in time. The great majority of the electrons penetrating the sample are lost in these cases, but the higher time resolution may be worthwhile for many applications. The electron pulse length is essentially equal to the cathode laser pulse length in current instruments. The cathode laser pulses are several nanoseconds long, whereas the mechanisms that would further degrade the time resolution typically occur on a picosecond scale. The time delay between a photon striking the cathode material and a photoelectron exiting is much faster than a nanosecond (streak cameras and ultrafast electron diffraction systems would not work otherwise), provided the emission is purely via the photoelectric effect. Schafer and Bostanjoglo27 reported a pulse duration of 20 ns due to heating and cooling of the filament and plasma relaxation processes, but this was in a laser-driven thermionic source rather than a true photocathode; in later work this limitation is bypassed.52 Temporal expansion due to the energy spread in the pulse in the initial acceleration region is of order ∆t =
(m∆E/2)1/2 d eV
(1)
with m and e the electron mass and charge, ∆E the energy spread, d the cathode–anode distance, and V the accelerating voltage.55 This amounts to a few picoseconds or less for typical DTEM parameters. After initial acceleration, the velocity spread is less than one part per thousand and again is a negligible source of temporal spread. The pulse of electrons is much longer than it is wide—a 1-ns, 200-keV pulse will be ∼15 cm in length but a small fraction of a millimeter in diameter (depending on lens settings and position within the column). In this high-aspect-ratio limit, longitudinal space charge effects can be practically neglected except near the very leading and trailing edges of the pulse. Image charges in the metal walls of the column may interact with nonuniformities in the linear charge density to produce broadening and instabilities,56–58 but it is fairly easy to estimate from the gov-
421
422
W.E. King et al.
erning equations that this phenomenon will have a negligible effect over the few nanoseconds that the electrons are in the DTEM column. The effect is far more important for large-scale particle accelerators. Space charge thus might spread out the tails of the temporal response curve but will have very little effect on its FWHM; the pulse is for the most part steady state. Timing jitter in laser pump-probe experiments is similarly on the picosecond scale or faster. Thus until DTEM pulses get into the picosecond range (which is likely to be very difficult for the above reasons), the time resolution will be controlled entirely by the photocathode pulse length. Picosecond DTEM will also be extremely challenging purely on the basis of signal levels. As we have seen, the DTEM is already electron starved in the nanosecond regime, so that the optimal time resolution is dictated by (1) the required fluence at the sample, (2) the maximum tolerable convergence angle, and (3) the brightness of the electron source. Pushing the time resolution to the picosecond range will only be possible either with an extremely bright electron source or with very unchallenging imaging requirements. It will likely be some time before this is accomplished. In summary, the time resolution for a single shot is dictated by the electron fluence requirements and directly controlled by the photocathode laser pulse duration. What then determines the interframe time resolution for a multiple-shot experiment? Single-electron-sensitive high-resolution high-dynamic-range cameras with nanosecond readout times are somewhat beyond current technology. This means multiple shots must be fit into a single CCD image, which is read out once after all exposures are complete. This is achieved with the previously described “movie mode,” implemented with a stepped electrostatic deflector system. The minimum interframe time is ∼20 ns, dictated by the ring-down time of the high-voltage switching circuitry. With the principle proven, the problem of producing better movies (with more frames and/or reduced interframe times) is a nontrivial matter of high-voltage/high-speed electrical engineering. The driving system must produce a series of preprogrammed voltage plateaus at very precise times with as little ring-down as possible. It needs to be flexible, precise, and as free of parasitic inductance and capacitance as possible. Some advantage may be gained by using a more recent TEM column design with more than one intermediate lens. Such columns offer more degrees of freedom to optimize the “leverage” (displacement at the camera plane per unit deflection voltage). It may also be possible to increase the frame count by using a two-dimensional deflector, although this greatly complicates the electrical design problem. Ongoing developments in multiframe camera technology59–61 may improve the frame counts, particularly if combined with an advanced electrostatic frame shifter. Each buffered CCD frame could thereby contain multiple images, and the CCD’s interframe time could be much longer than the DTEM’s interframe time. This would unfortunately force the high-voltage switching system to repeat its performance multiple times with very little delay, not to mention the challenges in producing the required cathode laser pulses. If the engineering problems
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
turn out to be surmountable, we may (although certainly not very soon) see DTEM movies with hundreds of frames and interframe times perhaps as short as 1 ns. It is instructive to compare the time resolution in DTEM with that of conventional in situ TEM. Conventional systems are typically limited to video rate imaging, ∼30 ms per frame. DTEM thus opens up a regime of more than six orders of magnitude in time resolution. This advantage is currently offset by the stringent limitations on multiframe DTEM movies. DTEM is therefore complementary to conventional in situ techniques. Video-rate TEM is too slow to capture many nanoscale solid state processes—often a significant part of the dynamics occurs between two frames of video.62 DTEM offers an opportunity to help fill in these gaps of time, provided issues of timing and frame count limitations can be addressed. 3.2 Image Resolution Our present understanding of the spatial resolution limits in DTEM is limited, due to a lack of systematic studies on both empirical and theoretical fronts. This section must therefore be considered as a sort of snapshot of our current state of understanding in a very young field. Still, we can make some statements on general principles and identify future areas of research. The stated resolution in the TU Berlin instruments in pulsed mode is ∼200 nm52 (in some of the images features as small as ∼100 nm seem to be coming through63). This resolution limit is attributed to a combination of the point spread function of the camera and the SNR limiting the pixel size for a given fluence52 (recall Figure 5–4). Both limits could in principle be improved by increasing magnification and reducing the illuminated area, but these will incur various tradeoffs. For example, time-dependent radiation sensitivity of the sample may limit the current density in specific cases, so that the practical resolution limit may be very strongly dependent on the robustness of the sample under the electron beam. Also, the uniformity of the illumination area may suffer due to the large beam emittance coupled with condenser lens aberrations and nonuniform emission at the cathode. In any case, if we assume that the sample can survive the required fluence, then the fundamental resolution limit of the machine must lie in the electron optics. The ability of static TEM to attain Angstromscale resolution is dependent on several factors including brightness, energy spread, objective lens aberrations, the quality of the sample, and the faithful magnification of the image by the intermediate/projector lens system. All of these may have to be compromised in the DTEM. Further, electron–electron interactions including space charge, Boersch effects, and trajectory displacement effects64–66 will be much more important in the DTEM, with its extremely high currents compared to static TEM. The DTEM has at least one advantage, in that low-frequency vibrations and high-voltage drift that would harm the resolution in the conventional TEM will have no effect on a nanosecond-exposure image.
423
424
W.E. King et al.
Let us consider the electron-optical factors in some detail. First, consider the need for a bright electron source. As we have discussed, high brightness is needed to attain high fluence with nearly parallel illumination. Any angular spread in the condensed beam will tend to wash out the high-spatial-frequency information.67 The necessarily large emittance of the DTEM electron source will tend to compromise this performance. Also, the energy spread ∆E of the electrons will be quite large in the DTEM, due most likely to an enhanced Boersch effect at high currents.52 ∆E is about 8 eV for the TU Berlin instruments.28 The energy spread will interact with the objective lens chromatic aberration CC to limit resolution to dC = CC θ
∆E E
(2)
where θ is the angular deviation of the electron path from the optic axis.67 If we make the simplifying assumption of normal incidence, then θ is related to the feature spacing d via the usual formula d = λ/θ
(3)
(assuming coherent single scattering and small angles), and this implies a chromatic resolution cutoff of order dC = CC λ
∆E E
(4)
In addition, spherical aberration limits resolution to a value of order67 dS = 0.66(CSλ3)1/4
(5)
This rounds out the list of electron-optical effects that usually limit resolution in a conventional TEM. These effects all interact with one another, and it is best to use TEM simulation software (such as Java EMS,68 used here) to understand their combined effects. The square root dependence in Eq. (4), for example, is very much complicated by beam convergence effects. Consider Figure 5–9, which presents amplitude and phase contrast transfer functions for a set of imaging parameters that are similar to those that occur in a DTEM. Parameters comparable to the ones used in this calculation were measured28 near, at, or below the sample position and thus include all effects that take place in the gun, accelerator, and condenser systems. It would appear that atomic resolution (via phase contrast, at spatial frequencies ∼3 cycles/nm or higher) will be extremely difficult, but that it may well be possible to achieve usable contrast up to a resolution limit of ∼1–2 cycles/nm, particularly through amplitude contrast mechanisms. The rough square root dependence on energy spread helps to minimize the impact of chromatic aberration; Eq. (4) predicts a cutoff of 1.4 cycles/nm. Spherical aberration [Eq. (5)] predicts a roughly comparable 2.1 cycles/nm. The lack of spatial coherence (represented in the simulation as an incident angular spread) interacts with the other parameters in a complicated way, broadening the CTF pass band but significantly reducing its amplitude. Thus it may be
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
425
Figure 5–9. Phase and amplitude contrast transfer functions (CTF’s) as simulated by the commercial software package Java EMS [68] for the following parameters: E = 100 keV, DE = 5 eV (the maximum allowed by the software), CS = CC = 2 mm, convergence semi-angle 10 mrad, defocus 105 nm, no objective aperture. The cross-interaction between convergence angle and aberrations is primarily responsible for the low contrast. Phase contrast will be very weak, however amplitude contrast mechanisms should produce reasonable images with better than 1 nm resolution under the assumptions in this model. Therefore the effects that limit DTEM resolution must be among those not included in this simulation, which was designed for conventional TEM.
426
W.E. King et al.
very important to control the convergence angle to obtain a good DTEM image. Reasonably high-quality selected area diffraction patterns have been achieved in DTEM over areas of some tens of micrometers,69 indicating that the convergence angles can be kept to reasonable levels. In short, the estimated resolution limit accounting for all known (and measured) effects in the gun, accelerator, condenser system, and objective lens would appear to be ∼1 nm, dramatically better than is achieved experimentally. This suggests that the limitation is in one of the effects not included in conventional TEM simulations; this also suggests that if the limiting factor can be identified and eliminated, a great improvement in resolution should be possible. The above argument indicates that the culprit should be either in the sample, in the postsample lens systems, or (as indicated in Domar and Bostanjoglo52) in the camera (including detection statistics). The balance of this section will discuss some of these effects. Consider the interaction of a very intense beam with a solid sample. In conventional TEM, 1 µA would be an extremely high current at the sample; this corresponds to roughly 1 electron per 160 fs, with an axial spacing of ∼33 µm at 200 keV. Plasmon lifetimes are in the femtosecond range, while TEM samples are usually less than 1 µm thick, so each electron encounters a sample that has had time to relax since the last electron passed through it (apart from heating and radiation damage). DTEM currents may be four orders of magnitude larger. More than one electron will be in the sample at a time, and at high fluences each electron may encounter multiple previously excited plasmons on its way through the material. The theory of electron–sample interactions in the electron microscope always makes the one-electron-at-a-time approximation. This theory may have to be modified for the DTEM. Further, a great deal of energy will be deposited in a region highly localized in time and space, which raises the possibility of new radiation damage mechanisms. It is not clear at this time whether and how these effects might worsen the image resolution. The abnormally high currents in the DTEM may also affect the behavior of the intermediate lens system, specifically through electron–electron interactions in the intense crossovers. We have performed rough estimates of the various effects involved (space charge, Boersch, and stochastic particle displacement), following the formalism of Kruit and Jansen.65 Space charge effects can change the effective focal lengths and aberration coefficients of each of the lenses. Space charge defocusing would merely require a readjustment of the lens currents and a possible recalibration of the microscope in pulsed mode. The experience at TU Berlin suggests that this is not a major issue. Estimating the effects of space-charge-induced spherical aberration is somewhat more difficult and has not yet been performed in detail. Part of the problem is that this effect vanishes to first order for a circular beam of uniform intensity,65 so any associated distortions would have to be driven by nonstatistical inhomogeneities in the beam intensity (including those due to
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
the image contrast itself). Little more can be said without extensive modeling, but fortunately the relevant models are already well developed in other contexts.66 The Boersch effect acts to increase the energy spread of a charged particle beam by coupling the lateral and longitudinal degrees of freedom via statistical electron–electron interactions.64–66 This process will saturate when all degrees of freedom are, in some sense, in thermal equilibrium. Saturation energy spreads depend on accelerating voltages and convergence angles.66 Rough estimates suggest that this effect has adequate time to saturate in the early part of the column, and that it may well be responsible for much of the energy spread measured by Bostanjoglo et al.28 [a very rough estimate of the saturation energy spread based on assumed parameters yields ∼10 eV, compared to the measured 8.7 eV, while the original authors used Loeffler’s formalism (validated to within ∼20%)70 to estimate a value of 7.6 eV]. In any case it would seem that the maximal effect of chromatic spread would already have occurred in the objective lens (with a resolution limit ∼1 nm), so that it seems doubtful that chromatic aberration in the intermediate lenses is to blame for the observed resolution limit of ∼200 nm. This brings us to the trajectory displacement effect,65,66 which slightly and randomly deflects electrons in and near a crossover. Suppose we take an intermediate lens with focal length 24 mm forming an image of radius 0.1 mm at a distance of 60 mm, with a crossover at 27 mm. The divergence angle α0 is therefore 3 mrad. These values might come up between the first and second intermediate lenses of a typical TEM in a moderate-magnification imaging mode, with an illuminated area of 1 µm at the sample. Suppose 108 electrons are in a pulse of duration 1 ns, for a current of 16 mA at 200 keV. Using the formulas quoted by Kruit and Jansen,65 we find that we are in the Gaussian regime, with an average random trajectory displacement of 2.2 µm at the crossover and an estimated 5 µm at the image plane. The result will be an image blur much like what happens in projection electron lithography systems. Referencing this displacement back to the sample plane yields a resolution limit of ∼50 nm due to this crossover alone, assuming that the rest of the optical system faithfully transfers this image plane to the screen. This is a very significant limitation to the resolution (comparable to the quoted resolution limit of ∼200 nm in current instruments52), yet it must be taken as only a very rough estimate of the effect in a real TEM column. This resolution limit depends strongly on all relevant parameters, including the positions, intensities, and convergence angles of all crossovers, the positions and degrees of magnification at every image plane, and the beam current and voltage. This means that (1) much more involved calculations and experiments are required if we are to understand if this is truly the resolution limit, and (2) if it is the resolution limit, then it may be possible to dramatically reduce its effects by changing the lens excitations in the intermediate/projector lens system. The idea would be to avoid intense crossovers with small convergence angles at high-leverage parts of the column. A simple way to test the
427
428
W.E. King et al.
hypothesis would be to take the same pulsed images with and without a small selected-area aperture. If trajectory displacement is the resolution limit, then when the aperture is inserted the electrons from outside the region of interest will no longer be present at the intermediate lens crossovers, and the effect should be greatly reduced. We should also remember that the sample may well be moving, rapidly, during the exposure. A phase front or shock wave moving at roughly the speed of sound in the material may move several micrometers during a few-nanosecond electron pulse. The sample may also be distorting from local heating or moving vertically (out of focus) due to the effects of the pump laser. These effects must be considered in the design of experiments. However this does not appear to be the resolution limit in the experiments to date; roughly the same resolution is obtained in test shots on a static sample. In summary, the observed resolution limit in DTEM may arise from a combination of intermediate crossover interactions, motion blurring, and low signal levels, while the effects that limit resolution in conventional TEM would suggest a pulsed image resolution ∼1 nm. Various experiments are proposed that may identify the true culprits, while some methods of mitigating their effects are suggested. This is the present state of knowledge at the time of writing; the near-future evolution of the understanding of these effects is likely to be rapid. 3.3 Damage Due to the inelastic scattering of electrons in TEM, a large amount of energy (typically some 10s of electron-volts per primary electron) is deposited in the sample, and in many cases damage due to energy deposition is a limiting factor in obtaining high-resolution images. For continuous electron exposure used in standard TEM, damage is linearly related to the total radiation dose,71,72 but to fully understand the impact of damage on image quality in DTEM, the effects of higher dose rate and the time-dependent nature of radiation damage must also be considered. At this point, we do not know enough about either of these subjects to confidently predict the damage-related resolution degradation in a DTEM image. Nevertheless, here we briefly review what is known as a baseline for further investigation. The consequences of energy deposition for TEM images depend strongly on the nature of the sample. Although a wide variety of inorganic and metallic samples can be readily imaged, sometimes with very high resolution and contrast,73 damage is the most significant limiting factor for imaging less robust samples such as biomaterials. Although damage in solid-state material due to direct atomic displacement can be significant at high beam currents,74 typically this is appreciable only for a large integrated number of primary electrons incident on the sample and can be avoided (in standard TEM) through the use of a primary electron energy that is less than a sample-dependent threshold. For a current density of 105 A/cm2 through a carbon film sample at between 100 and 200 keV, the sputtering rate is roughly 10 nm/s.74 Although the instantaneous current density in DTEM could
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
be considerably higher than this (as high as 107 A/cm2 in future instruments), this current density will be sustained only over nanoseconds. Assuming the sputtering rate is linearly related to the current density (which may not be the case for DTEM), sputtering would be insignificant for less than millions of shots. Since the time scale of the electron pulse can be comparable to the thermal diffusion time, sample heating is a more significant issue for DTEM than standard TEM, but this depends strongly on the sample and beam properties. The deposited energy density can be very large. For water irradiated by ∼200 keV electrons at a density of 10 electrons/ Å2 (a typical density for cryoEM) in a single pulse, straightforward estimates of the inelastic cross section71 result in a deposited energy density of about 300 eV/nm3, about 10 eV per water molecule! For a Gaussian beam with 1/e radius of 100 nm and 1/e half width of 1 ns in water, naively assuming only standard thermal diffusion using room temperature constants, the deposited energy density will reach 90% of the value it would have with no diffusion. The situation is significantly better with the lower heat capacity and larger thermal conductivity found in metals. With the same beam properties, the energy density in an aluminum sample will reach only 5% of the zero diffusion energy density. These results depend strongly on the pulse duration. A pulse of sufficiently short duration (less than 10s of picoseconds for a 100-nm radius beam in aluminum) will still overwhelm diffusion within this model. At a sufficiently short pulse duration and electron density, sample heating may result in sample melting and lowering the atomic displacement energy threshold. Nonetheless, questions remain as to the actual state of the material at these early times and high temperatures—it is unlikely that any standard assumptions about thermal transport or material stability would still apply. Biomaterials (such as proteins) are especially ill suited to examination via TEM due to their native aqueous environment, caustic species created in the irradiation of water, low contrast, intrinsic radiolytic susceptibility, and the relatively weakly bound tertiary and quaternary structures of proteins. The “lifetime” of irradiated protein crystals (i.e., the amount of time a crystal may be irradiated until its diffraction pattern fades) is a well-documented obstacle75 to high-resolution protein structural characterization. Yet, biology would benefit immensely from the ability to efficiently image proteins at high resolution. Knowledge of the detailed functioning of biomolecules and biomolecular complexes is essential to our understanding of the functioning and evolution of life.76 Here we focus on the imaging of biomaterials, since this application has great scientific benefit as well as being very challenging. Damage mechanisms would be simpler for just about any other condensed-state sample. Specifically, how much will damage degrade the resolution of a DTEM image over the time scale of the electron pulse? More optimistically, is it possible to effectively mitigate the effects of damage with respect to a high-resolution image by using a short electron pulse? Such an idea has already been proposed for imaging with X-rays,77 where single particle diffractive protein imaging is thought to be
429
430
W.E. King et al.
possible using a 10-fs duration X-ray pulse. Although pulsed imaging ultimately results in the destruction of the sample, the idea is to obtain the image before damage has significantly distorted the structure being imaged. An incidental, yet highly beneficial product of this scheme is the ability to time-resolve structural changes, enabling the direct visualization of nanobiostructural dynamics—a molecular movie.9 An analogous imaging scheme using electron pulses presents both advantages and challenges. Electrons deposit much less energy per inelastic scattering event than X-rays: less than 50 eV per event for electrons71 versus approximately 10 keV for X-rays, and the ratio of inelastic to elastic scattering events is roughly a factor of three smaller for electrons.9 This results in about 600–1000 times less energy deposited in the sample per unit signal for electrons compared to X-rays. Furthermore, electrons scatter with 104 greater probability than Xrays, allowing imaging with a much lower electron density. Yet, electrons are electrically charged fermions, which (as discussed in the sections on photoelectron guns and resolution) limits the fluence at the sample and both the spatial and temporal resolution. The challenge of pulsed electron microscopy will be to obtain a pulse of sufficient quality and electron density to obtain a high-resolution image, which is also short enough to avoid damage to the sample during the pulse. Hydrodynamic modeling of single particle diffractive imaging with electrons (in analogy with the X-ray method above) 78 indicates that 4 Å resolution is possible for a molecule of 10 nm radius with 100 keV electrons at a density of 107 electrons/(100 nm) 2, with a pulse width of 2 ps. Using the same model for the X-ray case and sufficient photon density to achieve the same resolution, an X-ray pulse of 2 fs is required. These results are reasonably consistent with expectations, giving a difference in the maximum acceptable pulse length of 1000, exactly the ratio of deposited energy per unit signal between the Xray and electron cases. These single particle models consider “naked” molecules only where the damage mechanism is Coulomb explosion. For the X-ray case, damage by this mechanism is the result of ionized electrons exiting the sample and leaving a net positive charge, resulting in rapid sample distortion due to electrostatic repulsion. Charging is much less severe for an electron probe due to the much lower kinetic energy of ionized secondary electrons. Also, it is likely that damage will occur on a slower time scale in solution, where the dispersion of molecules will be impeded by the presence of solution and secondary electron transit will be significantly reduced, resulting in less charging. In this case, the primary damage mechanism may be radical chemistry and diffusion, rather than Coulomb expansion. Although a 2-ps electron pulse width is probably beyond the capability of DTEM using standard electron guns, sub-100-ps pulse widths are not inconceivable at the required electron density. Attaining the necessary spatial and temporal coherence for diffractive imaging using such a pulse will probably be very difficult but perhaps within the reach of foreseeable improvements in electron gun technology.
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
Although atomic resolution may be challenging, electron gun modifications to shorten the pulses into the 10s of picoseconds may well allow very efficient imaging of protein complexes at sufficient resolution to significantly contribute to our understanding of their structure and dynamics. Furthermore, the RF accelerator community is aware of the potential for ultrashort, high brightness electron guns in electron microscopy.30 Such sources do not currently exist, but if these were developed, they could very significantly improve our ability to rapidly image biomolecules. Currently, there is very little information directly concerning biosample radiolysis damage at the very high current densities that will be found in DTEM. Although simulations such as those described above can provide us with some insight into the damage process, they do not consider the effect of an aqueous solution surrounding the sample. It is likely that a surrounding solution will significantly alter the damage process and may impede the physical diffusion of a damaged biosample long enough to obtain a high-resolution image with an electron pulse that is longer than 2 ps. Given the available information, it is difficult to speculate. Nonetheless, here we attempt to approach the problem based on what is known. First, we consider standard TEM. In some cases, the difficulty in imaging biomaterials may be overcome with standard TEM via any of three strategies, which all depend on the mitigation of damage: increasing sample contrast (via, for example, staining), increasing the sample damage threshold (as in cryoelectron microscopy75), or reducing the dose per unit sample (as in diffraction and cryoEM) with signal averaging over many samples. Of these techniques, cryoEM most closely approximates imaging of biosamples in a native environment, since this method does not require contrast enhancement. In cryoEM, a sample is flash frozen such that the embedding ice is vitreous rather than crystalline.79 This minimally distorts the sample and reduces diffractive background signal in the image. In addition, cooling of the sample to cryogenic temperatures increases the radiation tolerance by factors of thousands75 with respect to image-manifested damage. Although irradiation may have caused the conditions under which sample damage would occur, the physical diffusion that would make this apparent in an image does not occur when the sample is frozen in place.74 This result indicates that molecular diffusion, and temperature and phase-dependent chemical reactions play a role in damage,74,75 and that damage resulting from direct atomic displacement is insignificant at the doses (1–10 electrons/Å2) used in cryoEM. To further establish the relevance of diffusion in damage, an early time diffusional dependence is indicated by electron energy loss experiments that demonstrate an orders of magnitude increase in the damage threshold with reduced excitation volume at equivalent or greater irradiation density. Varlot et al.80 observed a change in damage threshold of 104 between a 100 nm and 0.7 nm radius cylindrical excitation volume irradiating polymers. Their analysis did not attribute the change in damage threshold to temperature effects and they speculated that dif-
431
432
W.E. King et al.
fusion of damaged molecules (e.g., free radicals) might explain the effect. Siangchaew et al.81 also observed a substantial increase in the damage threshold of polyethylene using a small electron probe. They speculate that the increase in damage threshold is due to fast secondary electrons (of energy >50 eV) exiting the 100-nm-diameter probe region. These electrons create damage collateral to the probe region, but leave the probe region relatively pristine. Egerton et al.74 disagree with this interpretation, asserting that (for polyethylene) the number, range, and energy of fast secondary electrons (FSEs) should result in 75% of the FSE energy being deposited within 2 nm of the probe beam. Slow electrons have longer mean free paths and may exit a small probe region,82 but it is not known how damaging these low-velocity electrons would be to organic samples. Diffusion also plays a primary role in radiolysis damage. In an aqueous environment, radiolysis damage is complex and involves many disparate processes. The physical excitation of secondary electrons through inelastic scattering is followed by electron thermalization and diffusional transport, and trapping occurring over a time scale on the order of 1 ps, along with the initial generation of radicals. This is followed by equilibrium with nuclei, which occurs in a few picoseconds. At longer time scales, chemistry begins to occur. Ionization and energy deposition in the first stage result in a transient distribution of radicals and other species (including H +, OH, eaqu, and H2O2 in water), which then diffuse and react with solutes and each other, reaching a homogeneous chemistry limit within micro- to milliseconds.83,84 With respect to solute interactions, pulse radiolysis studies indicate that the primary damage mechanism in DNA is attack by radiation-created hydroxyl radicals85 and based on simulations, the time scale of this process is thought to be hundreds of femtoseconds,86 assuming low deposited energy density. These data seem to indicate that the time scale for image manifested damage of a biomolecule in aqueous solution would be no faster than a few picoseconds, possibly much longer. Nonetheless, these data do not directly address the question. Although pulse radiolysis studies have provided a significant amount of information,87 this information generally concerns the time domain behavior of irradiated water (cf. time domain spectroscopy) and stoichiometric chemistry. Such data and corroborating simulations83,84 can be used to aid in the understanding of the diffusion of energy and radiolytic species in water, but ultimately they do not tell us about structural damage in solutes, particularly within a few picosecond time scale. More specific experimental studies of biomolecules such as DNA address damage, but again, this typically provides information regarding the chemistry of damage (typically via radiation-induced radicals) and the functional viability of irradiated molecules without reference to detailed structure.85,88 Furthermore, the energy deposition used in pulse radiolysis studies is much lower (∼10 Gr) 89 than what is used in TEM (>107 Gr),75 and the excitation volume in TEM is correspondingly much smaller. As a result, transport and relaxation of secondary electrons71 and high-dose rate effects90 will probably play a significant role in the
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
damage process in DTEM. These issues are not as significant for continuous irradiation in conventional TEM since thermal diffusion occurs on a faster time scale than the average time between electrons transiting the sample. The instantaneous energy density in the DTEM will be much higher, and these data do not provide information in this regime. Finally, we note that there is actually some empirical evidence that damage will be significantly reduced by the use of pulsed electron exposure. Fryer91 observed damage thresholds of 90–100 e/Å2 using 10- to 100-ms pulses to image monolayer films of aromatic hydrocarbons. Using continuous exposure, the damage threshold for these samples was 3–4 e/Å2, comparable to the damage threshold for proteins in cryoEM. This 22–25% improvement was observed for much longer pulses than we will use in the DTEM and points in the direction of trying even shorter pulses. Unfortunately, no currently available data directly address the question of resolution smearing in DTEM due to damage from short pulses of electrons. As far as damage is concerned, currently available simulations and empirical results do not unambiguously exclude the possibility of molecular bioimaging with short electron pulses, but they do not clearly indicate that it is possible, either. As with many aspects of DTEM, the development and use of the instrument will ultimately provide these answers.
4 DTEM Applications We include a brief historical review that attempts to put electron imaging in the context of work on electron diffraction. For the purpose of this discussion, we limit the review to time resolutions of microseconds or less. Figure 5–10 provides a summary. In the mid1970s, Bostanjoglo et al.16,92 developed a technique to produce stroboscopic images in TEM using beam blanking. In these pump-probe studies, ultrasonics were used to pump samples that were studied stroboscopically. This led to a number of papers studying fast transitions.93–101 Stroboscopic diffraction studies were carried out in the early 1980s.102–104 Real-time gas-diffraction experiments were reported in 1984.105 The first picosecond time-resolved structural studies in the solid state occurred in the early 1980s with a streak camera used as the basis of a diffraction instrument.1,3 This led to the first picosecond timeresolution observation of a phase transition in Al.2 In the late 1980s, pulsed photocathode,106 multiframe movies,107 and dynamic imaging were demonstrated at TU Berlin.108 In the 1990s there was work in gasphase energy transfer,109 superheating of lead, and structural dynamics.110 The techniques were applied to complex transient phenomena including dynamics of cyclohexadiene,6 photo-dissociation,111 direct observation of ultrafast thermal lattice expansion (Ag) on picosecond time scales,112 melting of amorphous Si,7 phase explosion in metal films,113 and melting of Al.114
433
434
W.E. King et al. First time-resolved pump-probe diffraction (20 ps)2
Electron diffraction of Al (100ps)1
Stroboscopic electron microscope (200 ps)16
"Real-time"gas diffraction (16 ms)105
Direct observation of lattice heating and diffusion (Ag) on ps time scales (<400 fs)112
Multiframe "movie" (<10 ns with 25 ns frames)107
Reflection microscope (20 ns)14
Pulsed cathode TEM (20 ns)15
Structural dynamics (1.4 ps)110
Gas phase energy transfer (15ns)109
1980s
1970s
Stroboscopic time-resolved electron diffraction (100 ns)102
Photoreaction in gas phase (few ps)139
Dynamics of cyclohexadiene (few ps)6
1990s
First dynamic Superheating TEM images (20 ns)15 of Pb (200 ps)140
Stroboscopic time-resolved LEED (10 ns)103
Stroboscopic time-resolved diffraction (100 s)104
Time-resolved RHEED (200 ps)141
Phase change in clusters (1 s)142
Melting of Si (few ps)7
2000s
Melting of Al (600 fs)114
Photodissociation (few ps)111
Phase explosion in metal films (3 ns)10
Figure 5–10. Timeline showing the parallel development of ultrafast electron diffraction and DTEM technologies.
TEM with high time resolution began at TU Berlin in the 1970s with stroboscopic imaging of periodic processes using a periodically deflected electron beam.16,115 In this configuration, time resolutions of 200 ps were achieved for periodic processes up to 100 MHz.116 This technique was applied to ultrasonically driven disruption of crystals and magnetoelastic effects92,115 and magnetic-field-induced oscillations of the domain magnetization, of domain walls, and of their substructures.98,116,117 After 1980, the instrument was modified to study nonperiodic processes. That instrument operated in three modes:
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
1. Selected-area image-intensity streaking provided time resolution of 3 ns and selected areas ≥500 nm.94 This was applied to studies of electron94,95,99 and laser-induced118,119 crystallization of metals and semiconductors, thermocapillary oscillations,53,120 and solidification of laserinduced melts.53,69,120 2. Streaked imaging was used to study solidification,53 flow,53,121,122 and evaporation121,122 of laser-pulsed samples. 3. High-speed imaging and three-frame movies with temporal/ spatial resolutions of 10 ns/200 nm, interpulse spacing >20 ns,10 and diffraction with time resolution of 10 ns were demonstrated.10 Several techniques were employed to achieve the high time resolution, including gating the electron detector,108,122,123 rapid beam blanking,124 laser-induced thermal emission,27–29,69,125 and finally laser-induced photoemission.10,126 Nanosecond time resolution studies, using the photoemission source, were carried out on hydrodynamic instabilities caused by chemocapillary, thermocapillary,127 and mechanical stresses.128 Phase explosion and plasma formation of highly superheated metals were studied at the same time resolution.113,129
5 Future 5.1 Improving Time Resolution 5.1.1 Pulse Compression To recap, the electron pulse duration at the sample is equal to the single-shot time resolution of the DTEM. At present this is essentially equal to the cathode laser pulse duration and is dictated by the experiment’s fluence requirements and the electron gun brightness. However, many methods exist for longitudinally compressing an electron pulse, many of them having been developed by the accelerator community for high-voltage RF electron guns. These involve passing the pulse through specialized elements such as a microwave cavity operating at a carefully chosen phase,58,130,131 or static magnetic fields in a chicane,132–134 α,135 or other pulse-compressing136 arrangement. These devices are routinely used to compress multimegavolt pulses of ∼1010 electrons down to picosecond or shorter durations, with normalized emittance values ∼1 µm radian and ∼1% energy spreads. The desired DTEM parameter space is very different, of order 200 keV, 108 electrons, less than 0.1-µm radian emittance, and an energy spread of order one part in 105. Significant work will be required to adapt the technology, possibly involving fundamental redesigns and entirely new ideas for pulse generation and compression. The outcome of research in the infant field of DTEM pulse compression is quite impossible to predict at this time; future DTEM electron guns might look almost nothing like the current designs. Pulse compression may be the only way to dig deeply into the subnanosecond regime, however. Without increasing the effective brightness of the electron source by crowding the
435
436
W.E. King et al.
electrons into a shorter pulse, there are many measurements (requiring a combination of high fluence, small convergence angle, and high time resolution) that will simply be impossible. Even then, there will be fundamental limits. Electrons are fermions, and can be compressed to a finite density only in six-dimensional phase space.64 The best electron pulses produced to date are still roughly four orders of magnitude short of this quantum degeneracy limit, as they have been for decades.64 Passive transformations to the electron pulse (e.g., acceleration, lens action, and most compression methods) can change only the shape of the phase space envelope, and not its density64 (also see Reiser,19 pp. 62ff). Thus every compression method that does not actually refrigerate the electron pulse will involve trading off one design parameter against another. 5.2 Relativistic Beams An alternate method to achieve high time resolution is to increase the accelerating voltage of the electrons. RF guns with thermionic cathodes have been used for many years for injection into storage rings83 and RF guns with photocathodes as sources for free-electron lasers (FELs).84 Currently photocathode rf guns are the brightest electron gun sources available.85 Bright beams can be generated due to the high rf fields (typically 100 MV/m or more) used to accelerate the beam over a short distance. The beams become relativistic in a few centimeters, quickly reducing the space-charge force repulsion. (Space-charge force is reduced for high-energy beams. Several books derive the space-charge equations for both longitudinal and transverse space charge showing the force varies as the Lorentz factor γ−2.137,138) The particles are typically accelerated to ∼5–6 MeV depending on the rf amplitude and the electron beam launch phase. It is conceivable that such a gun could be fitted to an electron optical column suitably engineered for operation with 5–6 MeV electrons. This would, however, require large-scale installations similar to previous HVEM facilities. Two significant differences would be that the accelerator would be less than 10% of the size of previous HVEMs and that there would be no need for the elaborate and costly vibration isolation schemes that were needed. Further, because the duty cycle of the pulsed instruments is small compared with CW instruments, it is possible that some of the radiation shielding requirements may be relaxed in pulsed machines.
6 Conclusions It appears that the growing interest in ultrafast science using optical and X-ray methods will spawn a new group of investigations using electrons. The potential for doing ultrafast diffraction experiments is already well established. The scientific case for extending this to ultrafast imaging with electrons is compelling. Technical hurdles remain to be overcome but it is clear that imaging will play a role certainly for experiments in which nanometer spatial resolution and nanosecond
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy
time resolution are required. It is also clear that experiments at time resolutions previously inaccessible (nanosecond to millisecond) in which space charge limitations are not a factor will also benefit from this technology. Extension of this technology to femtosecond time resolution and atomic spatial resolution is a worthy goal and conceptually achievable. The benefits that accrue from going to relativistic accelerating voltages may revive interest in high-voltage electron microscopes with pulsed electron sources. Acknowledgments. This work was performed under the auspices of the U.S. Department of Energy by the University of California, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and supported by the Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Division of Materials Sciences and Engineering, of the U.S. Department of Energy under contract No. W-7405-Eng-48. References 1. Mourou, G. and Williamson, S. (1982). Picosecond electron-diffraction. Appl. Phys. Lett. 41, 44–45. 2. Williamson, S., Mourou, G. and Li, J.C.M. (1984). Time-resolved laserinduced phase-transformation in aluminum. Phys. Rev. Lett. 52, 2364–2367. 3. Williamson, S. and Mourou, G. (1982). Electron-diffraction in the picosecond domain. Appl. Phys. B-Photo. 28, 249–250. 4. Ewbank, J.D., Schafer, L., Paul, D.W. and Benston, J. (1984). Real-time data acquisition for gas electron-diffraction patterns. Abstr. Pap. Am. Chem. S. 188, 97-Anyl. 5. Elsayed-Ali, H.E. and Herman, J.W. (1990). Picosecond time-resolved surface-lattice temperature probe. Appl. Phys. Lett. 57, 1508–1510. 6. Dudek, R.C. and Weber, P.M. (2001). Ultrafast diffraction imaging of the electrocyclic ring-opening reaction of 1,3-cyclohexadiene. J. Phys. Chem. A. 105, 4167–4171. 7. Ruan, C.Y., Vigliotti, F., Lobastov, V.A., Chen, S.Y. and Zewail, A.H. (2004). Ultrafast electron crystallography: Transient structures of molecules, surfaces, and phase transitions. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 101, 1123–1128. 8. Ruan, C.Y., Lobastov, V.A., Vigliotti, F., Chen, S.Y. and Zewail, A.H. (2004). Ultrafast electron crystallography of interfacial water. Science 304, 80–84. 9. Siwick, B.J., Dwyer, J.R., Jordan, R.E. and Miller, R.J.D. (2004). Femtosecond electron diffraction studies of strongly driven structural phase transitions. Chem. Phys. 299, 285–305. 10. Dömer, H. and Bostanjoglo, O. (2003). High-speed transmission electron microscope. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 74, 4369–4372. 11. Bostanjoglo, O. (2002). High-speed electron microscopy. Adv. Imag. Elect. Phys. 121, 1–51. 12. Bostanjoglo, O., Elschner, R., Mao, Z., Nink, T. and Weingartner, M. (2000). Nanosecond electron microscopes. Ultramicroscopy 81, 141–147. 13. Bostanjoglo, O. and Weingartner, M. (1997). Pulsed photoelectron microscope for imaging laser-induced nanosecond processes. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 68, 2456–2460. 14. Bostanjoglo, O. and Heinricht, F. (1988). A laser pulsed high emission thermal electron-gun. Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. 105–106.
437
438
W.E. King et al. 15. Bostanjoglo, O., Tornow, R.P. and Tornow, W. (1987). Nanosecond transmission electron-microscopy and diffraction. J. Phys. E. Sci. Instrum. 20, 556–557. 16. Bostanjoglo, O. and Rosin, T. (1976). Stroboscopic study on ultrasonic activity in electron-microscope. Mikroskopie. 32, 190. 17. Dömer, H. and Bostanjoglo, O. (2003). High-speed transmission electron microscopy of laser-pulsed metal films, splashing by a hydrodynamic instability. Microsc. Microanal. 9, 358–359. 18. Dömer, H. and Bostanjoglo, O. (2002). Stress effects in laser-pulsed chromium films tracked by nanosecond transmission electron microscopy. Adv. Eng. Mater. 4, 623–625. 19. Reiser, M. (1994). Theory and Design of Charged Particle Beams. New York: Wiley, pp. xix, 607. 20. Reed, B. (2004). Propagation dynamics of femtosecond electron packets and relativistic effects in ultrafast electron microscopy (UEM). (First National Lab and University Alliance Workshop on Ultrafast Electron Microscopies, Pleasanton, CA). 21. Faruqi, A.R. and Subramaniam, S. (2000). CCD detectors in highresolution biological electron microscopy. Q. Rev. Biophys. 33, 1–27. 22. Faruqi, A.R. and Andrews, H.N. (1997). Cooled CCD camera with tapered fibre optics for electron microscopy. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 392, 233–236. 23. Qian, W., Scheinfein, M.R. and Spence, J.C.H. (1993). Brightness measurements of nanometer-sized field-emission-electron sources. J. Appl. Phys. 73, 7041–7045. 24. Bluem, H., Todd, A.M.M., Cole, M.D., Rathke, J. and Schultheiss, T. (2003). Recent advances in high-brightness electron guns at AES. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 507, 215–219. 25. Dowell, D.H., Bolton, P.R. and Clendenin, J.E. (2003). Slice emittance measurements at the SLAC gun test facility. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 507, 327–330. 26. HerreraGomez, A., Vergara, G. and Spicer, W.E. (1996). Physics of highintensity nanosecond electron source: Charge limit phenomenon in GaAs photocathodes. J. Appl. Phys. 79, 7318–7323. 27. Schafer, B. and Bostanjoglo, O. (1992). Laser driven thermionic electrongun. Optik. 92, 9–13. 28. Bostanjoglo, O., Heinricht, F. and Wunsch. F. (1990). Performance of a Laser-Pulsed Thermal Electron Gun. Proc. 12th Intl Congr Electron Microsc. San Francisco, pp. 124–125. 29. Bostanjoglo, O. and Heinricht, F. (1987). Producing high-current nanosecond electron pulses with a standard tungsten hairpin gun. J. Phys. E. Sci. Instrum. 20, 1491–1493. 30. Lewellen, J.W. (2004). Overview of High-Brightness Proceedings of LINAC 842–846 (JACOW, Lübeck). 31. Brau, C.A. (2000). What brightness means. In: Rosenzweig J, Travish G, Serafini L, eds. The Physics and Applications of High Brightness Electron Beams. Proceedings of the ICFA Workshop. World Scientific, pp. 1–27. 32. Michaelson, H.B. (1977). Work function of elements and its periodicity. J. Appl. Phys. 48, 4729–4733. 33. Michelato, P. (1997). Photocathodes for RF photoinjectors. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 393, 455–459. 34. Baum, A.W., Spicer, W.E., Pease, R.F., Castello, K.A. and Aebi, V.W. (1995). Negative electron affinity photocathodes as high performance electron sources. SPIE 2522, 208–212.
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy 35. Togawa, K., Nakanishi, T. and Baba, T. (1998). Surface charge limit in NEA superlattice photocathodes of polarized electron source. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 414, 431–445. 36. Saka, T., Kato, T. and Nakanishi, T. (2000). Spinpolarized electron sources with GaAs-GaAsP superlattices for surface analyses. Surf. Sci. 454, 1042–1045. 37. Luh, D.-A., Brachmann, A., Clendenin, J.E., Desikan, T., Garwin, E.L., Harvey, S., Kirby, R.E., Maruyama, T., Prescott, C.Y. and Prepost, R. (2003). Recent polarized photocathode R&D at SLAC. AIP Conf. Proc. 675, 1029–1033. 38. Muggli, P., Brogle, R., Jou, S., Doerr, H.J., Bunshah, R.F. and Joshi, C. (1996). Photoemission from diamond and fullerene films for advanced accelerator applications. IEEE T. Plasma. Sci. 24, 428–438. 39. Modukuru, Y., Thachery, J., Tang, H., Malhotra, A., Cahay, M. and Boolchand, P. (2001). Growth and characterization of rare-earth monosulfides for cold cathode applications. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B. 19, 1958–1961. 40. Yada, K. (1986). Researches of cathode materials for thermionic emission. In: Imura T, Maruse S, Suzuki T, eds. Proc 11th Int Congr Electron Microscopy, Vol. 1, pp. 227–228. 41. Watari, F. and Yada, K. (1986). Photoemission from LaB6 cathode using an excimer laser. In: Imura T, Maruse S, Suzuki T, eds. Proc 11th Int Congr Electron Microscopy, Vol. 1, pp. 261–262. 42. May, P.G., Petkie, R.R., Harper, J.M.E. and Yee, D.S. (1990). Photoemission from thin-film lanthanum hexaboride. Appl. Phys. Lett. 57, 1584–1585. 43. Travier, C. (1994). An introduction to photo-injector design. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 340, 26–39. 44. Girardeau-Montaut, J.P., Girardeau-Montaut, C., Afif, M., Perez, A. and Moustaizis, S.D. (1995). Enhancement of photoelectric-emission sensitivity of tungsten by potassium-ion implantation. Appl. Phys. Lett. 66, 1886–1888. 45. Orloff, J. (1986). Development of the ZrO/W thermal field cathode. In: Imura T, Maruse S, Suzuki T, eds. Proc 11th Int Congr Electron Microscopy, Vol. 1, pp. 211–214. 46. Nassisi, V. and Perrone, M.R. (1999). Generation and characterization of high intensity electron beams generated from rough photocathodes. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 70, 4221–4224. 47. Boussoukaya, M., Bergeret, H., Chehab, R., Leblond, B. and Leduff, J. (1989). High quantum yield from photofield emitters. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 279, 405–409. 48. Kawamura, Y., Jeong, Y.U., Akiyama, Y., Kubodera, S., Midorikawa, K. and Toyoda, K. (1993). Generation of high-current photoelectrons using a subpicosecond ultraviolet-laser. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. Part 2-Lett 32, L297–L299. 49. Korte, F., Serbin, J. and Koch, J. (2003). Towards nanostructuring with femtosecond laser pulses. Appl. Phys. A.—Materials Sci. Process 77, 229–235. 50. Bergeret, H., Boussoukaya, M., Chehab, R., Leblond, B. and Leduff, J. (1991). Short pulse photoemission from a dispenser cathode. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 301, 389–394. 51. Höbel, F., Dömer, H., Gartenschläger, C., Gernert, U., Nink, T. and Bostanjoglo, O. (2003). A rugged cathode for photoelectron and DC thermionic operation. In: Gemming T, Lehmann M, Lichte H, Wetzig K, eds. Proc Micros Conf Microsc Microanal. Volume 9 Suppl. 3, 150–151. 52. Domer, H. and Bostanjoglo, O. (2003). High-speed transmission electron microscope. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 74, 4369–4372. 53. Bostanjoglo, O. and Nink, T. (1996). Hydrodynamic instabilities in laser pulse-produced melts of metal films. J. Appl. Phys. 79, 8725–8729.
439
440
W.E. King et al. 54. Bostanjoglo, O. and Nink, T. (1997). Liquid motion in laser pulsed Al, Co and Au films. Appl. Surf. Sci. 110, 101–105. 55. Bradley, D.J., Roddie, A.G. and Sibbett, W. (1975). Picosecond X-ray chronoscopy. Opt. Commun. 15, 231–236. 56. Hansen, S., Hereward, H.G., Hofmann, A., Hubner, K. and Myers, S. (1975). Effects of space-charge and reactive wall impedance on bunched beams. IEEE T. Nucl. Sci. NS22, 1381–1384. 57. Neuffer, D. (1979). Longitudinal motion in high-current ion-beams— self-consistent phase-space distribution with an envelope equation. IEEE T. Nucl. Sci. 26, 3031–3033. 58. Qin, H. and Davidson, R.C. (2002). Longitudinal drift compression and pulse shaping for high-intensity particle beams. Phys. Rev. Spec. Top-Ac 5, 034401. 59. Ben-Yakar, A. and Hanson, R.K. (2002). Ultra-fast-framing schlieren system for studies of the time evolution of jets in supersonic crossflows. Exp. Fluids 32, 652–666. 60. Kosonocky, W.F., Yang, G. and Kabra, R.K. (1997). 360 × 360 element threephase very high frame rate burst image sensor: Design, operation, and performance. IEEE T. Electron. Dev. 44, 1617–1624. 61. Reich, R.K., Rathman, D.D. and O’Mara, D.M. (2003). High-speed, electronically shuttered solid-state imager technology (invited). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 74, 2027–2031. 62. Minor, A.M., Lilleodden, E.T., Stach, E.A. and Morris, J.W. (2004). Direct observations of incipient plasticity during nanoindentation of Al. J. Mater. Res. 19, 176–182. 63. Domer, H. and Bostanjoglo, O. (2003). Phase explosion in laser-pulsed metal films. Appl. Surf. Sci. 208, 442–446. 64. Rose, H. and Spehr, R. (1983). Energy broadening in high-density electron and ion-beams—the Boersch effect. Adv. Electron. Electron. Phys. Suppl 13C, 475–530. 65. Kruit, P. and Jansen, G.H. (1997). Space charge and statistical Coulomb effects. In: Orloff J, ed. Handbook of Charged Particle Optics, pp. 275–318. (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL). 66. Jansen, G.H. (1990). Coulomb Interactions in Particle Beams. (Academic Press, San Diego). 67. Cowley, J.M. (1992). Imaging. In: Buseck P, Cowley JM, Eyring LE, eds. High-Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy and Associated Techniques, pp. 3–37. (Oxford University Press, Oxford). 68. Stadelmann, P. and Java, E.M.S. (2001). http://cimewww.epfl.ch/people/ stadelmann/jemswebsite/jems.html. (Institution, Lausanne). 69. Bostanjoglo, O. and Otte, D. (1993). High-speed transmission electronmicroscopy of laser quenching. Mat. Sci. Eng. A.—Struct 173, 407–411. 70. Loeffler, K.H. (1969). Energy-spread generation in electron-optical instruments. Z. Angew. Phys. 27, 145–149. 71. Egerton, R.F. (1986). Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy in the Electron Microscope. (Plenum Press, New York). 72. Henderson, R. (2004). Realizing the potential of electron cryomicroscopy. Q. Rev. Biophys. 37, 3–13. 73. Sun, K., Liu, J. and Browning, N.D. (2002). Correlated atomic resolution microscopy and spectroscopy studies of Sn(Sb)O-2 nanophase catalysts. J. Catal. 205, 266–277. 74. Egerton, R.F., Li, P. and Malac, M. (2004). Radiation damage in the TEM and SEM. Micron. 35, 399–409. 75. Henderson, R. (1990). Cryoprotection of protein crystals against radiation-damage in electron and X-ray-diffraction. Proc. R. Soc. London Ser. B. Biol. Sci. 241, 6–8.
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy 76. Schotte, F., Lim, M.H., Jackson, T.A., Smirnov, A.V., Soman, J., Olson, J.S., Phillips, G.N., Wulff, M. and Anfinrud, P.A. (2003). Watching a protein as it functions with 150-ps time-resolved X-ray crystallography. Science 300, 1944–1947. 77. Neutze, R., Wouts, R., van der Spoel, D., Weckert, E. and Hajdu, J. (2000). Potential for biomolecular imaging with femtosecond X-ray pulses. Nature 406, 752–757. 78. Hau-Riege, S.P., London, R.A. and Chapman, H.N. (2004). Pulse requirements for electron diffraction imaging of single biological molecules: LLNL internal report. 79. Dubochet, J., Adrian, M., Chang, J.J., Homo, J.C., Lepault, T.J., McDowall, A.W. and Schultz, P. (1988). Cryo-electron microscopy of vitrified specimens. Q. Rev. Biophys. 21, 129–228. 80. Varlot, K., Martin, J.M. and Quet, C. (1998). Physical and chemical changes in polystyrene during electron irradiation using EELS in the TEM: Contribution of the dielectric function. J. Microsc. Oxford 191, 187–194. 81. Siangchaew, K. and Libera, M. (2000). The influence of fast secondary electrons on the aromatic structure of polystyrene. Phil. Mag. A. 80, 1001–1016. 82. Emfietzoglou, D. and Moscovitch, M. (2002). Inelastic collision characteristics of electrons in liquid water. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B. 193, 71–78. 83. Cobut, V., Frongillo, Y., Patau, J.P., Goulet, T., Fraser, M.J. and Jay-Gerin, J.P. (1998). Monte Carlo simulation of fast electron and proton tracks in liquid water—I. Physical and physicochemical aspects. Radiat. Phys. Chem. 51, 229–243. 84. Frongillo, Y., Goulet, T., Fraser, M.J., Cobut, V., Patau, J.P. and Jay-Gerin, J.P. (1998). Monte Carlo simulation of fast electron and proton tracks in liquid water—II. Nonhomogeneous chemistry. Radiat. Phys. Chem. 51, 245–254. 85. Dizdaroglu, M. (1992). Measurement of radiation-induced damage to DNA at the molecular-level. Int. J. Radiat. Biol. 61, 175–183. 86. Wu, Y.D., Mundy, C.J., Colvin, M.E. and Car, R. (2004). On the mechanisms of OH radical induced DNA-base damage: A comparative quantum chemical and Car-Parrinello molecular dynamics study. J. Phys. Chem. A. 108, 2922–2929. 87. Zimbrick, J.D. (2002). Radiation chemistry and the radiation research society: A history from the beginning. Radiat. Res. 158, 127–140. 88. Douki, T., Spinelli, S., Ravanat, J.L. and Cadet, J. (1999). Hydroxyl radicalinduced degradation of 2'-deoxyguanosine under reducing conditions. 1875–1880. 89. Wardman, P. (1978). Application of pulse-radiolysis methods to study reactions and structure of biomolecules. Rep. Prog. Phys. 41, 259–302. 90. Jay-Gerin, J.-P. (2004). Personal communication. 91. Fryer, J.R. (1987). The effect of dose-rate on imaging aromatic organiccrystals. Ultramicroscopy 23, 321–327. 92. Bostanjoglo, O. and Rosin, T. (1977). Ultrasonically induced magnetic reversals observed by stroboscopic electron-microscopy. Opt. Acta. 24, 657–664. 93. Bostanjoglo, O. and Horinek, W.R. (1983). Pulsed Tem—a new method to detect transient structures in fast phase-transitions. Optik. 65, 361–367. 94. Bostanjoglo, O., Schlotzhauer, G. and Schade, S. (1982). Shaping trigger pulses from noisy signals and time-resolved TEM of fast phasetransitions. Optik. 61, 91–98.
441
442
W.E. King et al. 95. Bostanjoglo, O. (1982). Time-resolved TEM of pulsed crystallization of amorphous Si and Ge films. Phys. Status. Solidi. A. 70, 473–481. 96. Bostanjoglo, O. and Hoffmann, G. (1982). Time-resolved TEM of transient effects in pulse annealing of Ge and Ge-Te films. Phys. Status. Solidi. A. 73, 95–105. 97. Bostanjoglo, O. and Schlotzhauer, G. (1981). Impulse stimulated crystallization of Sb films investigated by time resolved TEM. Phys. Status. Solidi. A. 68, 555–560. 98. Bostanjoglo, O. and Rosin, T. (1980). Resonance oscillations of magnetic domain-walls and Bloch lines observed by stroboscopic electronmicroscopy. Phys. Status. Solidi. A. 57, 561–568. 99. Bostanjoglo, O. and Liedtke, R. (1980). Tracing fast phase-transitions by electron-microscopy. Phys. Status. Solidi. A. 60, 451–455. 100. Bostanjoglo, O. and Rosin, T. (1980). Stroboscopic TEM studies of highfrequency magnetic test materials. Mikroskopie 36, 344. 101. Bostanjoglo, O. and Gemund, H.P. (1978). Low-temperature specimen holder for magnetization processes by means of short field pulse. Mikroskopie 34, 188. 102. Ischenko, A.A., Golubkov, V.V., Spiridonov, V.P., Zgurskii, A.V., Akhmanov, A.S., Vabischevich, M.G. and Bagratashvili, N. (1983). A stroboscopical gas-electron diffraction method for the investigation of short-lived molecular-species. Appl. Phys. B-Photo 32, 161–163. 103. Becker, R.S., Higashi, G.S. and Golovchenko, J.A. (1984). Low-energy electron-diffraction during pulsed laser annealing—a time-resolved surface structural study. Phys. Rev. Lett. 52, 307–310. 104. Rood, A.P. and Milledge, J. (1984). Combined flash-photolysis and gasphase electron-diffraction studies of small molecules. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 2 80, 1145. 105. Ewbank, J.D., Schafer, L., Paul, D.W., Benston, O.J. and Lennox, J.C. (1984). Real-time data acquisition for gas electron-diffraction. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 55, 1598–1603. 106. Bostanjoglo, O., Endruschat, E., Heinricht, F., Tornow, R.P. and Tornow, W. (1987). Short-interval electron-microscopy and pulsed lasers. Eur. J. Cell Biol. 44, 10. 107. Bostanjoglo, O., Kornitzky, J. and Tornow, R.P. (1989). Nanosecond doubleframe electron-microscopy of fast phase-transitions. J. Phys. E. Sci. Instrum. 22, 1008–1011. 108. Bostanjoglo. O., Tornow, R.P. and Tornow, W. (1987). Nanosecondexposure electron-microscopy of laser-induced phase-transformations. Ultramicroscopy 21, 367–372. 109. Ewbank, J.D., Luo, J.Y., English, J.T., Liu, R.F., Faust, W.L. and Schafer, L. (1993). Time-resolved gas electron-diffraction study of the 193-nm photolysis of 1,2-dichloroethenes. J. Phys. Chem-Us 97, 8745–8751. 110. Dantus, M., Kim, S.B., Williamson, J.C. and Zewail, A.H. (1994). Ultrafast electron-diffraction. 5. Experimental time resolution and applications. J. Phys. Chem-Us 98, 2782–2796. 111. Ihee, H., Lobastov, V.A., Gomez, U.M., Goodson, B.M., Srinivasan, R., Ruan, C.Y. and Zewail, A.H. (2001). Direct imaging of transient molecular structures with ultrafast diffraction. Science 291, 458–462. 112. Cao, J., Hao, Z., Park, H., Tao, C., Kau, D. and Blaszczyk, L. (2003). Femtosecond electron diffraction for direct measurement of ultrafast atomic motions. Appl. Phys. Lett. 83, 1044–1046. 113. Dömer, H. and Bostanjoglo, O. (2003). Phase explosion in laser-pulsed metal films. Appl. Surf. Sci. 208, 442–446.
Chapter 5 High-Speed Electron Microscopy 114. Siwick, B.J., Dwyer, J.R., Jordan, R.E. and Miller, R.J.D. (2003). An atomiclevel view of melting using femtosecond electron diffraction. Science 302, 1382–1385. 115. Bostanjoglo, O. and Rosin, T. (1976). Ultrasonicly induced magnetoelastic effects observed by stroboscopic electron microscopy. In: Brandon DG, ed. Proc 6th Eur Congr Electr Microscopy, Vol. 1. Jerusalem, p. 360. 116. Bostanjoglo, O. and Rosin, T. (1980). Stroboscopic Lorentz TEM at 100 kV up to 100 MHz. In: Brederoo P, Boom G, eds. Proc 7th Eur Congr Electr Microscopy. The Hague, p. 88. 117. Bostanjoglo, O. and Rosin, T. (1980). Mass and relaxation time of domain walls in thin NiFe films from forced oscillations. J. Magnetism. Magnetic Mat. 15–18, 1529–1539. 118. Bostanjoglo, O., Endruschat, E. and Tornow, W. (1986). Time-resolved TEM of laser-induced phase transitions in a-Ge and a-Si/Al films. Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 71, 345–350. 119. Bostanjoglo, O. and Endruschat, E. (1985). Kinetics of laser-induced crystallization of amorphous germanium films. Phys. Status. Solidi. A. 91, 17–28. 120. Bostanjoglo, O. and Nink, T. (1996). Liquid motion in laser-pulsed Al, Co, and Au films. Appl. Surf. Sci. 109–110, 101–105. 121. Bostanjoglo, O., Kornitzky, J. and Tornow, R.P. (1991). High-speed electron-microscopy of laser-induced vaporization of thin-films. J. Appl. Phys. 69, 2581–2583. 122. Bostanjoglo, O. and Kornitzky, J. (1990). Nanoseconds double-frame and streak transmission electron microscopy. Proc 12th Int Congr Electr Microscopy. San Francisco, p. 180. 123. Bostanjoglo, O., Tornow, R.P. and Tornow, W. (1987). A pulsed image converter for nanosecond electron-microscopy. Scan. Microsc. 197–203. 124. Bostanjoglo, O., Niedrig, R. and Wedel, B. (1994). Ablation of metal-films by picosecond laser-pulses imaged with high-speed electron-microscopy. J. Appl. Phys. 76, 3045–3048. 125. Bostanjoglo, O. and Otte, D. (1995). High-speed electron-microscopy of nanocrystallization in Al-Ni films by nanosecond laser-pulses. Phys. Status. Solidi. A. 150, 163–169. 126. Nink, T., Galbert, F., Mao, Z.L. and Bostanjoglo, O. (1999). Dynamics of laser pulse-induced melts in Ni-P visualized by high-speed transmission electron microscopy. Appl. Surf. Sci. 139, 439–443. 127. Nink, T., Mao, Z.L., and Bostanjoglo, O. (2000). Melt instability and crystallization in thin amorphous Ni-P films. Appl. Surf. Sci. 154, 140–145. 128. Dömer, H. and Bostanjoglo, O. (2002). Laser ablation of thin films with very high induced stresses. J. Appl. Phys. 91, 5462–5467. 129. Dömer, H. and Bostanjoglo, O. (2003). Relaxing melt and plasma bubbles in laser-pulsed metals. J. Appl. Phys. 94, 6280–6284. 130. Steinhauer, L.C. and Kimura, W.D. (1999). Longitudinal space charge debunching and compensation in high-frequency accelerators. Phys. Rev. ST-AB 2, 081301. 131. Serafini, L. (1996). Micro-bunch production with radio frequency photoinjectors. IEEE T. Plasma. Sci. 24, 421–427. 132. Anderson, S.G., Rosenzweig, J.B., Musumeci, P. and Thompson, M.C. (2003). Horizontal phase-space distortions arising from magnetic pulse compression of an intense, relativistic electron beam. Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 074803. 133. Dowell, D.H., Adamski, J.L., Hayward, T.D., Johnson, P.E., Parazzoli, C.D. and Vetter, A.M. (1997). Results of the Boeing pulse compression and energy recovery. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 393, 184–187.
443
444
W.E. King et al. 134. Zhou. F., Cline, D.B. and Kimura, W.D. (2003). Beam dynamics analysis of femtosecond microbunches produced by the staged electron laser acceleration experiment. Phys. Rev. Spec. Top-Ac. 6, 054201. 135. Kung, P., Lihn, H.C., Wiedemann, H. and Bocek, D. (1994). Generation and measurement of 50-Fs (Rms) electron pulses. Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 967–970. 136. Kozawa, T., Kobayashi, T., Ueda, T. and Uesaka, M. (1997). Generation of high-current (1kA) subpicosecond electron single pulse. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 399, 180–184. 137. Chao, A. (1993). Physics of Collective Beam Instabilities in High Energy Accelerators. New York: Wiley. pp. x, 371. 138. Edwards, D.A. and Syphers, M.J. (1993). An Introduction to the Physics of High Energy Accelerators. New York: Wiley, pp. xii, 292. 139. Williamson, J.C., Cao, J.M., Ihee, H., Frey, H. and Zewail, A.H. (1997). Clocking transient chemical changes by Ultrafast electron diffraction. Nature 386, 159–162. 140. Herman, J.W. and Elsayedali, H.E. (1992). Superheating of Pb(111). Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 1228–1231. 141. Elsayedali, H.E. and Mourou, G.A. (1988). Pico second reflection highenergy electron-diffraction. Rev. Phys. Lett. 52, 103–104. 142. Bartell, L.S. and Dibble, T.S. (1990). Observation of the time evolution phase—changes in clusters. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 112, 890–891.
6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Frances M. Ross
1 A Working Definition of in situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Since the earliest days of transmission electron microscopy, microscopists have realized the potential of microscopy for studying dynamic processes. Images recorded sequentially can be used to track the changes caused by deliberate actions, such as heating or straining, or uncontrolled processes, such as beam damage. The class of experiments where a specimen is changed or acted on while it remains under observation (i.e., in situ in the polepiece) is referred to as in situ microscopy. In a sense every TEM observation is an in situ experiment, since every specimen is affected by the electron beam to some extent. But the in situ experimenter aims to modify the specimen in a deliberate way and learn something from the results. In the best in situ experiments, a controlled change is made to a specimen’s environment, and this is correlated with the resulting change in its structure, measured using any of the imaging, analytical, or diffraction techniques available, or its electronic or mechanical properties, which can also be measured in situ. Preferably both the “input,” in other words the change in sample environment, and the “output,” or consequent change in structure or properties, are recorded simultaneously and quantitatively. Given sufficient care with artifacts, a quantitative understanding of a fundamental physical process can be obtained. There are numerous advantages to performing experiments in situ. A single in situ experiment gives a continuous view of a process, so may take the place of multiple post-mortem measurements. A single heating experiment, for example, can provide information that would otherwise have to be extracted by examination of many samples which had been annealed to different temperatures or for different times. Because an in situ experiment is continuously recorded, it is easier to catch a transient phase or observe a nucleation event. In situ experiments can yield specific and detailed kinetic information, measuring
445
446
F.M. Ross
for example the motion of individual dislocations under known stress, or the growth rates of individual nanocrystals. Properties can be determined for well-characterized nanostructures, such as the conductivity of single nanotubes or the melting point of precipitates. Finally, growth experiments in particular provide a window into the behavior of materials under real processing conditions, since significant changes can occur if we remove a material from the growth chamber and perform analysis post-mortem. Although in situ experiments provide unique information, it is at a cost of increased experimental complexity. Careful design of the specimen is necessary to minimize thin foil effects. Tests must be carried out to understand beam effects, and calibration of the applied stimulus is critical. Given the complexity of some in situ experiments, what is remarkable and inspirational is the variety of materials and properties that have been studied in situ. In the vast majority of experiments, the “input” to the specimen ranges from simple beam heating to controlled sample heating, cooling, or straining; application of a voltage or a magnetic field; or even modification with a scanning probe tip. A specially designed sample holder may be used which could include a heater, electrical contacts, a tip, or a mechanical straining stage. Such experiments can be carried out in most microscopes, apart from those with the tiniest polepiece gaps, although a side entry design is most convenient for experiments involving feedthroughs. A second, less common class of experiments is based on changing the sample’s environment by, for example, exposing it to a reactive gas or depositing another material onto it. For such studies, two experimental strategies are possible. Firstly, one can use a conventional microscope, but achieve environmental control in a modified sample holder in which the sample and reactive environment are enclosed in a region between two electron-transparent membranes. Alternatively, the microscope itself may be modified, for example by adding gas feedthroughs to the specimen area. The sample can then be exposed to the desired environment in a standard holder. For certain experiments involving reactive surfaces, a clean environment is important and the entire microscope must then be designed for ultra high vacuum (UHV). A UHV specimen region allows clean surfaces to be prepared (for example by heating) and then modified controllably in the polepiece. True UHV systems are relatively rare as they represent a large investment. They often include side chambers attached to the microscope in which other preparation or deposition treatments can be carried out ex situ. In terms of collecting the “output” data, some in situ experiments require atomic resolution, while others use lower resolution strain or defect imaging, diffraction analysis, and occasionally elemental mapping. Data may be collected onto videotape or hard drive or as a series of still images, and in some cases high speed image acquisition may be necessary. Commonly, other measurements, such as sample temperature, gas pressure, electrical conductivity or applied force, are collected simultaneously and may be written onto the video tape or stored electronically with the images.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
The following sections will describe some of the accomplishments of in situ microscopy in improving our understanding of the bulk properties and surface physics of materials. In situ microscopy has a rich history, but here we will focus on more recent experiments, mainly within the last decade, with the hope that this emphasis will capture the ongoing excitement of this quickly developing field. Along the way we will discuss experimental requirements for in situ experiments and the recognition and elimination of artifacts. We hope to show how widely in situ microscopy has enhanced our understanding of phenomena associated with phase transformations, crystal growth, electrical and mechanical properties, magnetism and ferroelectricity, implantation and beam effects, and even processes which take place in the liquid phase. Improvements such as the larger polepiece gap made possible by aberration correction, more sophisticated data analysis techniques, and enhanced abilities to fabricate specimens of controlled geometry, promise to extend the possibilities of in situ techniques even further.
2 Phase Transformations The largest body of work accomplished using in situ TEM techniques has been in the area of phase transformations: melting, crystallization, transformations between crystal structures, and the formation of new phases by solid state diffusion. An understanding of such transformations is scientifically interesting and technologically essential in, for example, the processing of alloys or the development of new materials having extreme hardness or superplastic, magnetic or shape memory properties. In situ TEM has provided detailed information on the mechanism, kinetics, and structures produced during many phase transformations, both in the bulk and in nanoscale volumes. Microscopy is well suited for such studies because its high resolution allows atomic motions to be visualized, and diffraction can identify the phases present under changing conditions. Small precipitates or nuclei can be characterized and their evolution followed, and complex or incommensurate structures can be analyzed. The requirements for these studies are usually simple, consisting of time-resolved imaging and a heating stage, although some experiments involve cooling, straining, or deposition. Images are commonly recorded at video rate (30 images per second) and the temperature can often be chosen to give a convenient reaction velocity. Heat is applied using the electron beam, or, more controllably, by heating a furnace or a resistive wire close to the sample. Alternatively, a heating current may be passed through the sample or the sample may be stuck onto a resistively heated wire. For qualitative results, such as determining reaction mechanisms, structural changes are observed during heating and cooling. For quantitative measurements the sample temperature must be measured accurately. This is a challenge since the temperature measured at the furnace by a thermocouple, say, may not be the same as the temperature at the region under observation. However, with some effort, careful calibrations have been achieved.
447
448
F.M. Ross
We first discuss transformations in bulk materials, then examine transformations in small volumes of material. These small volumes may be free-standing nanostructures or nanoparticles encapsulated in a matrix. A recurring theme will be the finding that small volumes do not transform under the same conditions as larger volumes, which is extremely important for the development of complex materials. 2.1 Crystallization, Melting and Grain Growth in Bulk Materials 2.1.1 Amorphization and Crystallization The crystallization of amorphous materials is an interesting and important process which is uniquely suited to TEM analysis. Early, elegantly simple experiments involved the recrystallization of silicon, deposited as an amorphous thin film and then heated in cross section in a high resolution TEM. These experiments (Parker et al., 1986; Sinclair et al., 1987) showed the power of high resolution imaging at high temperature. The nucleation of crystallites was visualized, allowing estimation of the critical nucleus size, and the irregular progress of the reaction front was demonstrated, even though macroscopically the kinetics were consistent with a more continuous ledge mechanism. This pioneering work provided an atomic scale view of a bulk phase transformation, showing the start-stop motion we now expect for atomic scale processes. Using multilayer specimens to extend this approach to metal-mediated crystallization of Si, Ge, or C clearly demonstrated the mechanism for these reactions as well (Figure 6–1, Konno and Sinclair, 1992, 1995a, b, c; Sinclair et al., 2002). Si crystallization has now been so well studied, both in situ and ex situ, that it has actually been used as a calibration tool to measure the temperature in thin specimens (Hull and Bean, 1994; Stach et al., 1998a). An accurately calibrated temperature is essential in obtaining quantitative information, such as activation energy, for reactions carried out in situ. More recent crystallization studies have used plan view rather than cross sectional geometry, allowing many individual grains to be imaged. For example, the nucleation and growth rates of individual NiTi crystals during heating were found to be in agreement with the Johnson-Mehl-AvramiKolmogorov model (Lee et al., 2005), allowing grain size distributions to be predicted in this shape-memory alloy. An interesting industrial application of this type of experiment, relevant to new types of information storage, is shown in Figure 6–2. Phase change materials such as GeSb and GeSbTe can store bits of information as amorphous areas embedded in crystalline regions. A high laser power is used to write amorphous spots, a medium power erases by recrystallizing, and a low power (or other measurement) reads the bits. In situ observations of crystallization have been made in films deposited on SiN membranes (Kooi et al., 2004; Kooi and De Hosson, 2004), free-standing films (Petford-Long et al., 1995) and actual compact disc materials (Kaiser et al., 2004). Beam heating shows nucleation and growth kinetics (Figure 6–2B), while more controlled experiments using a heating stage measure activation energies (Figure 6–2A). SbOx, another potential phase change material, has been examined in
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
449
Figure 6–1. Metal-induced crystallization. In situ high-resolution images recorded during the Agmediated crystallization of Ge at 250°C. The time between frames is 8 s. The Ag is the faulted region in the center and the crystalline Ge is in the upper left. The Ag crystal appears to migrate toward the amorphous Ge region but the faults remain fixed (one fault is indicated by a line). The inference is that Ge is supplied by diffusion through the Ag lattice, and the net motion of the Ag is caused by counterdiffusion of Ag atoms. The lack of any amorphous entectic is dearly demonstrated. (From Konno and Sinclair, 1995a, with kind permission of Taylor and Francis Ltd.)
situ for different stoichiometries x, again determining activation energy (Missana et al., 1999). Although stress effects may change the kinetics in electron transparent foils, these experiments are useful in allowing transformation parameters to be measured and structural changes examined. The reverse process of solid state amorphization is hard to measure using other experimental techniques. In situ heating of systems such as Ti-Si, Zr-Si, Pt-GaAs (Sinclair, 1994), and Al-Pt (Blanpain et al., 1990) allow nucleation locations to be determined and diffusion processes to be characterized. Amorphization can also be induced by the electron beam, as will be discussed in Section 8.
450
F.M. Ross
A (a)
(b)
(c)
B Figure 6–2. The amorphous to crystalline transformation in phase change materials. (A) Bright-field images recorded during crystallization of a 40-nm Sb3.6Te film at 85°C. The film was deposited on an SiN membrane. Note that the growing crystal was prenucleated by heating for 5 min at 95°C. (Repinted with permission from Kooi and de Hosson, © 2004. American Institute of Physics) (B) Bright-field images displaying stepwise electron irradiation-induced crystallization of an amorphous data mark in 14-nm-thick Ga15Sb85 after irradiation for the times indicated at a current density of 1.5 nA mm−2. The specimen was made from a conventional CD-RW/DVD1RW disk consisting of a ZnS:SiO2/GaSb/ ZnS:SiO2/SiN/Ag/SiN layered stack on a polycarbonate substrate, with all layers removed except for the GaSb and surrounding dielectric layers. The phase-change layer was crystallized using a broad laser beam then amorphous data marks were “written” using a home-built recorder. (Reprinted with permission from Kaiser et al., © 2004. American Institute of Physics)
2.1.2 The Solid-to-Liquid Transformation and the Structure of the Solid-Liquid Interface Melting and freezing can be observed in situ by diffraction or imaging. Perhaps the ultimate example is the “nanothermometer” shown in Figure 6–3, fabricated by enclosing Ga in a large diameter carbon
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
451
nanotube (Gao and Bando, 2002; Z. Liu et al., 2004). This structure was used to measure the expansion coefficient of liquid Ga and observe different structures on freezing. Several other transformations involving liquids have also been studied in situ. It may at first appear surprising that liquids can be examined at all. However, liquids with low vapor pressure, such as Ga, In, Si, or Al, may be treated in the same way as solids, provided they do not move around too much, while liquids with high vapor pressure can be observed if they are naturally encapsulated, for example as inclusions, or are cooled. High vapor pressure liquids which are not in the form of inclusions require special techniques which will be described in Section 7. Liquids which are not encapsulated and are too mobile may be studied by coating the thin foil with a polymer to maintain shape (Kato et al., 2000; Senda et al., 2004). Such studies show that melting points in thin films differ from bulk (Senda et al., 2004). TEM studies have provided information about the structure of the solid-liquid interface and the transformation between solid and liquid. In spite of extensive theoretical work on solid-liquid interface structure and the transient ordering in liquids just before solidification, such phenomena have proven difficult to study experimentally using other techniques. Even with TEM, relatively few systems have been examined. The nature of the solid to liquid transition in Xe films has been determined using diffraction in an environmental cooling cell (Zerrouk et al., 1994). Imaging studies have shown the persistence of order into liquids, for example at the (211) interface in PdSi (Howe, 1996) and at the interfaces of liquid Xe inclusions in Al (Donnelly et al., 2002). A combination of energy filtered imaging and diffraction contrast has been used to examine the interface between Al-Si eutectic and solid Al-Si alloy, to determine that the interface is quite abrupt and that changes in crystallinity correlate with composition (Storaska et al., 2004). Finally, the Si crystal-liquid interface has been imaged at high
Figure 6–3. The Ga thermometer. Ga contraction and expansion inside a carbon nanotube upon cooling and heating. The background feature is part of the carbon support film. Scale bar = 100 nm. (a) At room temperature, 21°C. (b) At −40°C. (c) At −80°C, when solidification occurred. (d) The crystallized Ga was melted at −20°C. (e) Reheated to room temperature, 21°C. (Reprinted with permission from Z. Liu et al., © 2004 by the American Physical Society)
452
F.M. Ross
A
B
Figure 6–4. Grain boundary dynamics. (A) High-resolution electron microscopy images of a [110] θ = 14° tilt grain boundary in Au at 893K. Individual frames are shown from a video sequence recorded near optimum defocus. (a) GB at t = 15.37 s. (b) GB has moved to the right at t = 44.93 s and is near the (6, −6, 1) symmetric orientation. (c) Detail of (a) depicted at various times in the four panels. A small region composed of eight atomic columns switches orientation between the two grains. Note the stacking disorder and misfit localization at the dislocation cores. Reprinted with permission from Merkle et al., © 2002b by the American Physical Society. (B) High-resolution image of the Cu Σ = 3 interface imaged along [01-1]. The grain boundary is dissociated into a narrow slab of 9R stacked material (fcc stacking but with an intrinsic stacking fault inserted every three planes). The two images were recorded 5 min apart after 400 kV electron beam irradiation and the 9R stacked region has expanded due to changes in the internal stress state induced by the beam. Stacking defects in the 9R structure can be related to the presence of secondary grain boundary dislocations at the interface. (From Medlin et al., 1998, with permission from Elsevier.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
temperature (Nishizawa et al., 2002) to determine the planarity of different index interfaces. As well as static configurations at the solid-liquid interface, interface dynamics during solidification have been examined in several bulk materials. Arai et al. (2000, 2003) observed Si growth in the Al-Si system, while Sasaki and Saka (1996), Kamino et al. (1997a) and Saka et al. (1999) imaged surface melting in Al and Al2O3, observing ledge motion during solidification. Other studies have involved nanoparticles and inclusions and will be discussed below. 2.1.3 Grain Growth and Grain Boundary Motion Grain boundaries in polycrystalline materials can move on annealing or mechanical deformation. Just as we have seen for crystallization studies, in situ observation of grain boundary dynamics can supply information on the growth mechanism, and even measure the effects of impurities and gas atmosphere. Grain boundary motion during heating has been observed for metals such as Cu, Au, and Al (Keller et al., 1997; Dannenberg et al., 2000; Kaouache et al., 2003). For nanocrystalline Ag thin films, the measurement of kinetic parameters demonstrated that grain growth is dominated by surface diffusion mass transport (Dannenberg et al., 2000). Grain boundary motion during mechanical stressing will be discussed in Sections 5.1 and 5.3. More complex grain boundary dynamics can also be studied. An interesting example is the penetration of liquid Ga along grain boundaries in Al, relevant to the important embrittlement process (Hugo and Hoagland, 1998, 1999). The structure and strain field during penetration, the kinetics in different grain orientations, and the effects of dislocations were observed. While dark field imaging works well for grain boundary dynamics in polycrystalline films or at low symmetry boundaries, high resolution heating experiments are very useful for understanding high symmetry boundaries. High resolution experiments on bicrystals having engineered boundaries with high symmetry, particularly in Au and Cu (Medlin et al., 1998; Merkle and Thompson, 2001; Merkle et al., 2002a, b), enable very detailed measurements at the atomic level and the determination of grain boundary migration mechanisms. In situ experiments show that collective mechanisms operate during migration, and that unusual structures may form and grow at boundaries (Figure 6–5). Dislocations may also be emitted, and the details of their structure and relationship with the boundaries can be measured (Lucadamo and Medlin, 2002). 2.2 Structural Phase Transitions As well as the phenomena of melting, solidification and grain boundary motion, in situ techniques have been applied to understand transformations between different crystal structures and solid state reactions involving diffusion. These experiments have mostly relied on in situ sample heating, although transformations have also been initiated by straining, electron beam heating, electric and magnetic fields, and a gas environment. High resolution imaging and analysis, diffraction, or
453
454
F.M. Ross
Figure 6–5. Phase stability in NiAl. When a martensitic Ni-rich Ni xAl1−x sample, with x > 63at.%, is annealed at moderate temperatures (550°C) it transforms into Ni5Al3. On further heating to 780°C, the Ni5Al3 phase itself decomposes, forming B2 grains in a twinned L12 matrix. This image is part of a sequence obtained during heating that shows a smaller B2 grain growing by forming a small extension (marked as X) into the L12 matrix, consuming some twins, then rapidly expanding laterally. The Ni5Al3 phase is undesirable as it degrades the shape memory properties by inhibiting the transformation back to austenite, and its formation and stability are therefore important. (From Schryvers and Ma, 1995 with permission from Elsevier.)
low resolution weak beam or bright field imaging provide information that is complementary to that obtained from other in situ techniques, such as x-ray diffraction, which average over larger volumes. Subtle changes in symmetry can be detected using the sensitive combination of diffraction and high resolution imaging. These combined techniques show the transformations between orthogonal, tetragonal, and cubic phases in oxides such as SrRuO3 (Jiang and Pan, 2000). They also work well for transformations involving charge ordering and incommensurate phases, which will be discussed in Sections 4.1 and 4.3. Ordering can be investigated directly in the STEM, using its capabilities for elemental analysis of individual atomic columns. For example, Klie and Browning (2001) heated LaSrFeO3 in the STEM, using the column environment, which is low in oxygen, to reduce the material. EELS showed that the resulting change in symmetry was due to ordering of oxygen vacancies. When planning to study these sorts of phase transformations, it is important to consider the same experimental artifacts that we have already mentioned for melting and solidification. The results described below illustrate both the advantages and some pitfalls of in situ TEM. We first consider transformations in intermetallic alloys such as shape memory alloys, which provide an excellent opportunity for in situ microscopy to display its strength. For example, for TiNi, the orientation relation between the different phases can be determined, and the dynamics of the emergence of martensite plates during straining can be observed in situ (Gao et al., 1996; Ma and Komvopoulos, 2005). In situ heating of NiAl alloys (Schryvers and Ma, 1995, Schryvers et al., 1998) showed how the texture and defect structure in the high tem-
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
perature phase are derived from the lower temperature phase, and illustrated the processes occurring during phase decomposition with low resolution imaging and diffraction (Figure 6–5). Higher resolution imaging showed details of the formation of the gamma phase in TiAl which would have been difficult to ascertain otherwise, for example, the ledge motion of interfaces (Howe et al., 2004). Other materials examined include the shape memory alloys CuAlMn (Dutkiewicz et al., 1995), TiNiHf (Han et al., 1997), and FeMnSi (Jiang et al., 1997). Crystallographic relationships, the interaction of dislocations with the transformation front, and the morphology of phases produced on heating or straining were studied. The presence and significance of incommensurate reflections in related materials have been examined using imaging plates and an in-column filter (Tamiya et al., 1998; Cai et al., 1999; Murakami and Shindo, 2001; Ii et al., 2003). Cooling stages allow an even larger range of transformations to be accessed (Tanner et al., 1990). However, thin foil effects are important in these transformations. Kuninori et al. (1996) showed that the foil thickness influences transformation temperatures—indeed, transformations do not occur at all at some thicknesses—and Ma and Komvopoulos (2005) showed that thickness can affect the sequence of phases. Electron irradiation effects are also important, for example in inducing some transformations in NiMnTi (Schryvers et al., 1996), and in changing the formation kinetics of the omega phase in beta phase Ti-Mo alloys on cooling (Matsumoto et al., 1999), a transformation which is important in understanding the anomalous electrical conductivity of these alloys. Both beam and thin foil effects, of course, must be considered in any in situ transformation. Beam effects should always be evaluated by examining unirradiated areas after the transformation. Thin foil effects can be minimized in some cases by depositing the material of interest onto an electron transparent membrane. This reduces buckling and provides a more uniform temperature than a conventional specimen of varying thickness, advantageous for quantitative studies. An example is the transformation between beta and alpha phases of tungsten, for which the change in stress state is important in lithographic mask applications. Deposition of a uniform W film on a silicon nitride membrane (Ross et al., 1994a) allowed the transformation dynamics to be measured and the presence of voids to be related to the initial grain structure. Membrane specimens have been used successfully for many types of material, for example, by Morkved et al. (1998), Dannenberg et al. (2000), Kooi and de Hosson (2004), Grant et al. (2004), and Lee et al. (2005). 2.2.1 A Solid-State Diffusion Reaction: Silicide Formation Reactions which occur at a planar interface between two materials have provided fruitful subjects for in situ experiments. In situ observations may allow determination of the diffusing species, the nature of nucleation sites, the sequence of phases, and the relationship between the crystal structures of the initial and final phases. However, the complexity of these reactions, compared to the crystallization and
455
456
F.M. Ross
melting reactions described previously, means that we have to be particularly careful to avoid artifacts. For example, if the sample dimensions are comparable to or less than the diffusion lengths of the moving species, then surface diffusion may affect the kinetics. Surface nucleation sites may be significant, and beam effects and stress relaxation in thin regions of the foil must be recognized. In spite of these issues, a successful body of work has been carried out on these transformations. We illustrate this by discussing silicide formation, a popular “test system” of great relevance to the microelectronics industry that has been examined using a range of in situ TEM techniques. In situ silicidation was initially studied in cross section by heating a metal film such as Ti, Zr, or Cr that had previously been deposited on Si (H. Tanaka et al., 1995, 1996, 1998; Sidorov et al., 1998a; Figure 6–6A). Plan view experiments later provided the opportunity to examine silicidation on patterned substrates to study, for example, nucleationlimited transformations in small areas (Teodorescu et al., 2001; Ghica et al., 2001; Gignac et al., 1997; Figure 6–6B). These in situ experiments were very helpful in showing the sequence of phases, some of which are short-lived or hard to see otherwise; as mentioned previously, a single in situ experiment can replace a whole series of ex situ preparations (Wang and Chen, 1992). It is interesting to consider the sample geometry, however, as it illustrates some limitations of the in situ studies. In a cross sectional experiment, quantitative results are only obtained if surface diffusion pathways are suppressed (perhaps by coating the sample) and nucleation sites on the milled surface are minimized. It can only be assumed that the in situ experiment is an accurate representation of the bulk situation if both the activation energy of the reaction, and the final structure produced, are comparable with bulk experiments (Sinclair et al., 1988). In plan view, surface effects are not as significant, but thin film buckling must be considered. Specialized in situ deposition techniques offer an interesting alternative way of looking at silicide formation. Rather than depositing a metal on the Si (or Ge) substrate ex situ, the substrate can be cleaned in situ in a UHV TEM and the metal then deposited in situ. The metal may be deposited onto a cool substrate which is then heated (Gibson et al., 1987; Ross, 2000) or it may be deposited at high temperature, where silicide phases form at once as islands (Ross et al., 1999a; H.P. Sun et al., 2005; Nath et al., 2005). To study the structure of such 3D islands in more detail, a combined UHV system allowing sequential TEM and STM imaging has been used to determine surface reconstruction as well as the sequence of phases (Tanaka et al., 2004). In situ deposition has also been used to study more complex silicide reactions, such as oxide and nitride mediated epitaxy (Kleinschmit et al., 1999; Chong et al., 2003). The experimental complexities of carrying out deposition in situ will be discussed in more detail in Section 3. But the advantages are clear in terms of avoiding contamination or oxidation (or evaluating their effects; see Figure 6–6C), discovering changes in the phase sequence as a function of film thickness, and looking at kinetic effects during deposition, such as coarsening.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
457
B
A Figure 6–6. Silicide phase transformations. (A) Sequence of cross-sectional images recorded during heating of a 50 nm CoSi2 film on Si(001), showing interface roughening and pinhole formation. (From Sidorov et al., 1998a.) (B) Silicide formation in a patterned area defined by an oxide window. After deposition of 12 nm Ni over an 800 nmwide line (a), the successive plan view images show the formation of Ni silicides at different temperatures: (b) formation of NiSi2 (flower-like contrast); (c) NiSi2 pyramids are well formed; (d) After 10 minutes at 400ºC some NiSi has formed in the center of the line but NiSi2 remains along the edges. (Reprinted with permission from Teodorescu et al., © 2001. American C Institute of Physics.) (C) The C49–C54 phase transformation in TiSi2 which had been deposited and annealed in situ (left hand column), compared to ex situ deposited TiSi2, where Auger spectroscopy showed the presence of oxygen (right hand column). Times are shown in seconds and the arrow marks a fixed point on the specimen. The phase transition occurs smoothly in the clean film while it is strongly pinned at grain boundaries in oxidized films. (Reprinted with permission from Ross, ©2000 AAAS.)
458
F.M. Ross
2.3 Phase Transformations in Nanostructured Materials So far we have discussed phase transformations in bulk materials or thin films, where in situ microscopy allows us to see changes in structure, how phases nucleate, and how growth fronts propagate. But TEM is particularly good at imaging nanostructures; in other words, resolving the shape, structure, and composition of small regions of a specimen. Thus, the techniques applied to study transformations in bulk materials can naturally be extended to transformations in small volumes, either embedded in a matrix or free standing. The stability of phases and the mechanisms of transformations in small volumes have been determined for several cases, confirming the important general conclusion that small particles show different phase diagrams compared to larger volumes of the same material. This is especially important given the many applications of nanostructured materials, for example, in high strength metal alloys, and individual, freestanding nanoparticles, for example, as catalysts or components in advanced electronic devices. 2.3.1 Size-Dependent Transformations in Embedded Nanostructures By focusing on an individual inclusion or precipitate, in situ microscopy provides precise information about phase transformations and stability in nanoscale volumes. Excellent quantitative work in several systems shows the potential of the technique for future studies on a wider range of materials. Pb in Al is a model system, since the lack of solubility of Pb in Al means that Pb spontaneously forms small cuboctahedral inclusions with a cube-on-cube orientation relation. Heating experiments allow strain, melting, and diffusion phenomena to be studied. A fascinating range of size-dependent properties has been seen (Figure 6–7). Melting of the Pb particles is size-dependent with huge supercooling possible, and there is a hysteresis on solidification due to the difficulty of nucleating ledges (Gabrisch et al., 2000). The decay of strain during solidification and melting provides information on the diffusion of point defects (Zhang et al., 2004). In particles at grain boundaries, which have complex structures, the melting of each interface at a different temperature can be seen (Bhattacharya et al., 1999; Dahmen et al., 2004). Co-implantation of different materials into Al, such as Cd/Pb, Sn/Pb, or Tl/Pb, allows phenomena associated with phase separation, melting, and interface structure to be examined (Johnson et al., 2002) and binary phase diagrams determined as a function of size. Phase transformations involving precipitate growth have provided equally interesting information. In cases where precipitates are pinned on dislocations, diffusion parameters can be measured from their coarsening (Legros et al., 2005) or motion (Johnson et al., 2004). The kinetics of ledge motion and kink nucleation on precipitates can be observed during high resolution heating experiments (Howe, 1998). For example, for precipitate plates in Al-Cu-Mg-Ag alloys, imaging parallel and perpendicular to the interface demonstrated that precipitates grow by the terrace-ledge-kink mechanism (Benson and Howe, 1997) and even
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
459
A
B Figure 6–7. Nanoparticle melting phenomena. (A) Size-dependent melting of Pb inclusions in Al. The sample was produced by rapid solidification of an Al–0.5% Pb alloy and the image shows an array of particles at 423°C, which is 96°C above the bulk melting point. The rounding of most particles indicates their liquid state, while the smallest particles (arrow) are still faceted and solid. By measuring the dependence of inclusion shape on temperature and considering the inclusion shape change kinetics, the step energy as a function of temperature for steps on the inclusion surface can be calculated (lower graph). The least-squares fit indicates a roughening transition at about 600°C. (From Gabrisch et al., 2001 with permission from Elsevier.) (B) Reversible melting of 25-nm Pb inclusion at a grain boundary in Al (a–h). This particle has two different interfaces with two different grains and the two interfaces melt at different temperatures. The thin black line indicates the solid–liquid interface at different temperatures. (From Dahmen et al., 2004 with kind permission of Taylor and Francis Ltd.)
460
F.M. Ross
allowed the rate limiting steps and thermodynamic parameters of kink nucleation to be determined (Figure 6–8). Analytical techniques provide complementary information on the relationship between composition and structure at these growing interfaces, and the development of simulations for dynamic high-resolution imaging promises to make these studies even more quantitative (Howe et al., 1998). Other reactions, such as oxidation and reduction, can also be observed in precipitates (for example Isshiki et al., 1995; Kooi and De Hosson, 2001).
A
B Figure 6–8. Precipitate growth mechanism. High-resolution image of a single ledge on a 111 θ plate in an Al–Cu–Mg–Ag alloy during growth at about 220°C, and a graph showing the position of the ledge as a function of time demonstrating growth by irregular motion of ledges. The ledge height is two 111 matrix planes high (half a unit cell). The circled area appears blurred in videos due to enhanced atomic motion there. (From Howe et al., © 1998 Courtesy of Cambridge University Press.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
2.3.2 Phase Transformations and Sintering in Free-Standing Nanoparticles Isolated nanoparticles are often used as catalysts, and this has generated interest in understanding the factors determining their shape, phase stability, and sintering. For precipitates, we have seen properties quite different from the bulk material. Similar results are found for free-standing nanostructures when studied in situ. The earliest in situ studies of free-standing particles demonstrated the dynamic nature of the atomic arrangement (Smith et al., 1986; Iijima and Ichihashi, 1986), and the large fraction of atoms on or near the surface indeed leads to unusual behavior. TEM has shown that phase transformations in free-standing particles are different from those in bulk, for example in observations of size-dependent melting (Howe, 1997) and changes in phase stability (Chatterjee et al., 2004). In this context, binary systems such as Au-Sn, Pb-Sn, Bi-Sn, and In-Sn have been extensively studied. For this, a two-source evaporator is used to form mixed composition clusters in situ (Figure 6–9). The binary phase diagram is found to depend strongly on size, with changes in the eutectic temperature (Yasuda et al., 2001; Lee et al., 2002a). Melting behavior, phase separation, and mixing also depend on the composition and size (Yasuda et al., 2000, Lee and Mori, 2004a, b). These effects reflect a change in solubility or the relatively high cost of forming phase boundaries. Unusual structures may occur in certain free-standing particles on melting. In Al-Si, a solid Al particle inside a molten Al-Si sphere can form, moving with fractional Brownian motion (Yokota et al., 2004). In GaSb, particles decompose into a crystalline Sb core surrounded by liquid Ga (Yasuda et al., 2004). Stress may also play an important role in particle reactions. Metals encapsulated within multiwalled carbon onions have changed melting points due to the pressure (Banhart et al., 2003; Schaper et al., 2005), and the metal can even migrate through the graphitic covering (Schaper et al., 2005). When there is a solid oxide layer covering a nanoparticle, stress relief can cause cracking (Storaska and Howe, 2004). Sintering of free-standing particles is particularly important in materials processing and has been examined in situ. Ceramic particles such as SiN can be made to sinter in a conventional microscope provided that a very high temperature stage is used (Kamino et al., 1995). For metals, of course, the surface oxide strongly influences sintering. For example, the degree of sintering of Fe and Nb nanoparticles on membranes, prepared ex situ but observed at high resolution during annealing in high vacuum (Vystavel et al., 2003a, b), was found to depend on surface oxidation. To solve this problem, an integrated system may be used, where particles are created and imaged in the same high vacuum. Yeadon et al. (1997) connected a sputtering chamber to a UHV TEM to carry out successful studies of metal sintering. Sintering of Cu on Cu foils proceeded by neck growth and grain boundary motion, whereas Co particles on Cu and Ag foils “burrowed” beneath the surface to minimize surface energy (Zimmermann et al., 1999). Sintering of metal particles on oxide substrates in a controlled environment is of
461
462
F.M. Ross
Figure 6–9. Intermixing in small particles. Sequence of images showing the alloying of Sn into Bi at 350K. (a) As-evaporated Bi particle; (b–e) the same particle during in situ Sn deposition. First a crystalline–liquid interface forms [arrows in (b)] and this then propagates through the crystal until the whole particle becomes liquid. EDX shows a composition of 50% Sn at this point (f). Not shown is the asymmetric behavior of Sn particles during Bi deposition; these become liquid at once without forming a phase boundary, an abrupt crystalline to liquid transition that is not expected from the bulk phase diagram. (From Lee and Mori, 2004a with kind permission of Taylor and Francis Ltd.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
particular relevance to catalysis, and will be discussed in that context in Section 3.2. 2.4 Summary In situ microscopy of phase transformations has touched on a wide range of materials and addressed important problems related to crystallization and melting, diffusion, structural transformations, and grain boundary dynamics. Bulk crystals, embedded nanostructures, and free-standing nanoparticles have been studied, yielding quantitative information on reaction mechanisms and on the relationship of structure to dynamics. From this survey of results, it is clear that the in situ techniques we have described could be applied to many currently unstudied systems. However, for proper interpretation of results, care must be taken with thin foil effects, such as strain, surface diffusion and surface nucleation, and with beam effects. High voltage microscopes have significant advantages in minimizing thin foil artifacts, though at the cost of increased beam damage. But even at intermediate voltage, careful accounting for these effects can lead to quantitative results relevant to materials development.
3 Surface Reactions and Crystal Growth A unique application of in situ microscopy, building on some of the techniques we have discussed above, is the examination of surface reactions and crystal growth. Rather than looking at bulk transformations as in Section 2, here we are more concerned with changes to the specimen surface. These changes may be initiated by heating or by exposure to a reactive environment or deposition flux. It is possible to study atomic scale processes on surfaces, including step dynamics and surface phase formation, as well as the growth of thin films and nanostructures. As we might expect from the discussion in Section 2, these in situ surface studies allow transient structures to be seen and kinetics to be measured. We will show that such experiments indeed contribute to an understanding of both surface reactions and growth, in some cases leading to improved control of surface structure or crystal size and shape. These studies usually take place in a controlled environment TEM. The column of a standard TEM contains a mildly reducing atmosphere of 10−6 to 10−7 mbar and may also be contaminated with hydrocarbons. By controlling the environment, the specimen can be exposed to, for example, clearly oxidizing or reducing conditions, a solvent rich atmosphere to prevent dehydration (see Section 7), or an environment that allows vapor phase growth. Many such experiments can be carried out by leaking gases into the specimen area of a conventional TEM. However, some specimens require a microscope capable of UHV base pressure to avoid any background contamination. Such microscopes can be complex and expensive, but they enable experiments which can not be realized otherwise, especially if adjacent chambers are available for sample preparation. Major advances in surface science have been
463
464
F.M. Ross
achieved using UHV microscopy, and the equipment and the science have recently been reviewed by Poppa (2004). 3.1 Measurement and Modification of Surface Structure Step flow and the development and stability of surface structures such as reconstructions may be studied by controlled heating, beam irradiation, or environmental stimuli such as deposition or exposure to a reactive environment. It may appear surprising that TEM is appropriate for surface studies at all, since the issues of temperature nonuniformity and strain relaxation associated with the preparation of thin foils could be avoided completely by using techniques such as LEEM and UHV SEM. But TEM has a wide variety of imaging and analytical modes sensitive to different aspects of a surface, and can be highly quantitative in terms of image analysis. Scanning probe microscopy also provides sensitive imaging of surface structures but lacks the time resolution necessary for surface dynamics, requiring typically 30 seconds to acquire each frame. In situ TEM initially gained attention as a surface science tool with the successful determination of the Si (111) 7 × 7 reconstruction (Takayanagi et al., 1985), an accomplishment which STM and LEED had not been able to achieve at that time. A clean Si surface was prepared by heating in a UHV TEM and diffraction patterns were obtained and analyzed. Since then, many other static and dynamic surface structures have been determined after in situ preparation. Surface structures may be prepared in the UHV microscope column by heating or deposition onto a thin foil (e.g., Kamino et al., 1997a; Oshima et al., 2000; Liu et al., 2001), or may be prepared in an adjacent chamber connected to the microscope by UHV (Marks et al., 1998). Every possible mode of the TEM has been used to analyze these surface structures. In plan view, diffraction techniques have solved reconstructions of metals on Si (Collazo-Davila et al., 1998; Oshima et al., 2000). Reflection electron microscopy (REM) has been used extensively to examine suface step dynamics due to electromigration, and the effect of metal adsorption on surface structure (Aoki et al., 1998; Minoda and Yagi, 1999; Minoda et al., 1999; Latyshev et al., 2000; Figure 6–10A). REM has also provided useful information on polar surface structures in oxides (Gajdardziska-Josifovska et al., 2002) and decomposition of the InP surface on heating (Gajdardziska-Josifovska et al., 1997). Information from REM and plan view TEM is complementary to that obtained from in situ SEM (Homma and Finnie 2002). Profile imaging, in which a surface parallel to the beam is imaged at high resolution, shows directly the periodicity and corrugations associated with surface reconstructions. This was first recognized early on (Marks, 1983; Bovin et al., 1985; Mitome et al., 1990; Smith et al., 1993), and has recently helped to determine complex structures like Si (5 5 12) (Liu et al., 2001) as well as faceting, reconstructions and dynamics of Au-decorated Si surfaces (Kamino et al., 1997b; Figure 6–10B) and beam-induced changes in surface structure and stoichiometry (Ning et al., 1996).
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
A
Figure 6–10. Deposition of Au on Si observed by different in situ imaging modes. (A) Step bunching on vicinal Si(001). A series of REM images obtained during the deposition of Au at 800°C onto a vicinal (4° miscut) Si(001) surface shows first the formation of (001) terraces in (a) and (b). Step bunching and formation of step bands are shown in (c) and (d); facet nucleation on the step bands in shown in (f) and (g). Finally there is a complete transformation of the entire vicinal surface into a hill-andvalley structure of (001) superterraces and (119) and (117) facets (h). (From Minoda et al., 1999 with kind permission of Taylor and Francis Ltd.) (B) The Au-induced reconstruction of a flat Si(001) surface on heating. The sample was prepared by depositing Au onto a rough, oxidized Si particle. The irregular sample geometry means that the temperature is not accurately known, However, on heating, the Au first agglomerated; further heating caused the oxide layer to disappear and the Au to spread over the surface (dark line along the sample edge), causing localized faceting into (001) and other terraces. The (001) facets then reconstruct over the timeframe shown, starting from the terrace boundary (arrows A and B). (Reprinted with permission from Kamino et al., © 1997 by the American Physical Society.)
B
465
466
F.M. Ross Figure 6–11. Nanostructures formed by surface mobility. Images of stable Au nanowires observed during the electron beam thinning of a specimen. The diameters of the wires are (A–D) 1.3, 1.1, 0.8, and 0.6 nm, respectively. The wire images are wavy, especially the thinnest, and can be modeled with helical structures. (Reprinted with permission from Kondo and Takayanagi, © 2000, AAAS.)
Surface diffusion under beam irradiation is evident during profile imaging. This has been used to advantage to study narrow wires in situ. Two adjacent holes are formed in a thin foil and the neck between them observed as it thins and breaks due to inbuilt stresses. Such experiments show a variety of interesting non-bulklike structures in Au (Figure 6–11), such as single chains (Koizumi et al., 2001) and helical multishell wires (Kondo and Takayanagi, 2000; Oshima et al., 2003a), with some of the structures related to shear (Oshima et al., 2003b). Beam-induced atom migration reduces the dimensions one layer at a time (Oshima et al., 2002). Unusual wire structures also form in Pt (Oshima et al., 2002). The surface diffusion of single atoms, for example W on MgO, can be imaged in TEM (N. Tanaka et al., 1998). Controlled environment and UHV TEM thus has an excellent track record for creating and observing surface reconstructions and observing step motion and surface diffusion. We now focus on some specific applications where the ability to characterize and modify surfaces in situ has led to particularly interesting and significant advances. 3.2 Catalysis Controlled environment TEM has enabled pioneering studies of the structural details of reactions during heterogeneous catalysis (Gai, 2002a; Sharma, 2001, 2005). High resolution imaging can be carried out at high temperature and under a controlled gas environment, up to several millibar of, say, H2, CO, or O2. Catalyst surface structure has been related to reactivity, intermediate phases have been determined, and changes in catalyst structure have been visualized during activation and poisoning. Several controlled environment TEMs are in opera-
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
tion in industrial laboratories, and we suspect that the many important results remain proprietary! Most studies have focused on catalysts consisting of metal particles on an oxide substrate (Figure 6–12). Gai et al. (1990) first examined shape changes in Cu particles in oxidizing and reducing environments, and observed the stability of Pt and Ru particles on TiO2 (Gai 1998; Gai et al., 2000). Hansen et al. examined the effect of Ba promoters on surface structures in Ru particles (2001), and used the shapes of Cu particles to determine relative surface energies under oxidizing and reducing conditions (2002; Figure 6–12B). Regeneration processes are important in such catalysts, and here too in situ studies have proven useful. For example, during regeneration of Pd/Al2O3 catalyst, sintering also takes place. The sintering behavior of “used” Pd particles, studied using analytical TEM as well as controlled environment heating, is affected by hydrocarbons which build up during use of the catalyst (R.-J. Liu et al., 2004; Figure 6–12A). A wide variety of other materials and reactions have also been investigated under a controlled environment. Gai and Kourtakis (1995) observed a glide shear rearrangement in vanadium pyrophosphate during reduction, and developed a model for the surface activity of this material, which is important in butane catalysis. Sharma et al. (2004a) examined structural changes during reduction of CeO2 catalyst, and interestingly used in situ energy loss spectroscopy to determine oxidation states as a function of temperature. Even the growth of polymeric reaction products in situ has been observed (Crozier et al., 2001; Gai, 2002b). Other reactions include intercalation in some interesting layered structures (Diebolt et al., 1995; Sidorov et al., 1998b), the nitridation of zirconia (Sharma et al., 2001), and de- and rehydroxylation of the lamellar material Mg(OH)2, which is important in CO2 sequestration (McKelvy et al., 2001). The reaction of MgO with water vapor has also been observed in situ (Sharma et al., 2004b; GajdardziskaJosifovka et al., 2005). Finally, photocatalysis can be studied in situ if a UV light source is brought into the specimen area. High resolution in situ imaging of the decomposition of hydrocarbons deposited on a TiO2 film (Yoshida et al., 2005) provides information on the mechanism of the process. These exciting results suggest that in situ studies will continue to have an important impact in the future development of catalysts and other functional materials. 3.3 Oxidation of Surfaces Corrosion of metals has significant impact on industry, so it is important to gain a fundamental understanding of oxidation and reduction by comparing controlled observations with theoretical predictions. For copper, oxidation was found to proceed via nucleation, growth, and coalescence of oxide islands (Figure 6–13). This result allowed the development of oxidation theories beyond simple models that had assumed a continuous oxide film (Yang et al., 1998, 2002; Zhou and Yang, 2002, 2003). Other than Cu and its alloys (Wang and Yang, 2005),
467
468
F.M. Ross
A
B
Figure 6–12. In situ imaging of catalysts. (A) Fresh Pd/Al2O3 catalyst (used for hydrogenation of acetylene) (a) in the as-received condition (room temperature), and (b–d) after heating in 500 m Torr steam at 700ºC for 1, 4, and 7 hours. Catalysts are regenerated by heating in steam to remove hydrocarbon buildup, but this causes sintering of the metal particles, reducing activity. In situ experiments show that, for fresh catalysts, sintering is by conventional Ostwald ripening, while movement and coalescence occurs for used catalysts. (Reprinted with permission from R.-J. Liu et al., © 2004 AAAS.) (B) Images of a Cu/ZnO catalyst (the methanol synthesis catalyst) in various environments at 220ºC, together with the corresponding Wulff constructions of the Cu nanocrystals. (a, b) 1.5 mbar H2 at 220ºC; (c, d) in a mixture of H2 and H2O with ratio 3 : 1 at a total pressure of 1.5 mbar; (e, f) in a mixture of 95% H2, 5% CO at a total pressure of 5 mbar. These images allow the relative surface energies to be determined as a function of environment. (From Hansen et al., © 2002. Courtesy of Cambridge University Press.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
469
Figure 6–13. Mechanism of copper oxidation. Dark-field images obtained during oxidation of Cu at 0.1 Torr and 350°C in a UHV TEM. Imaging using the Cu2O {110} reflection showed that oxidation is not planar, but takes place by Cu2O island (a) nucleation (5 min), (b) growth (15 min), and (c) coalescence (25 min). The specimen was prepared by floating a 60-nm Cu film onto a support and then removing the surface oxide in situ by annealing at 350°C in methanol vapor for 15–30 min. The area and number density of the islands grown both at low pressure and at high pressure (shown here) were modeled using Johnson–Mehl–Avrami–Kolmogorov theory to give surface diffusion parameters. (Reprinted with permission from Yang et al., © 2002. American Institute of Physics.)
metal oxidation remains largely unstudied, but in situ experiments could clearly offer the possibility of improving corrosion resistance through alloying or surface processing. Silicon oxidation is another industrially significant process, as a defect-free Si/SiO2 interface is fundamental to transistor operation. For Si(111) (Figure 6–14A), forbidden-reflection imaging showed that steps do not move during oxidation, meaning that any surface roughness remains during processing (Ross and Gibson, 1991; Ross et al., 1994b). For Si(001), the same result is seen (Figure 6–14B). Forbidden reflection experiments are useful in their ability to probe the buried Si/SiO2 interface, and are complementary to results obtained by in situ scanning reflection electron microscopy (Ichikawa, 1999). High resolution imaging provides insights into reactions in more complex materials. By oxidizing and reducing niobium oxides, Sayagues and Hutchison (1996, 2002) showed the formation of a series of block structures with changing stoichiometry (Figure 6–15). The combination of analytical techniques with imaging would undoubtedly lead to further useful insights into oxidation and related reactions. 3.4 Growth of Carbon Nanostructures The growth of carbon nanostructures has been extensively studied in situ since the discovery of these interesting materials by TEM. It is relatively easy to form carbon structures in situ with a controlled environment plus a catalyst or a graphitic precursor (Figure 6–16). Beam effects provide an important ingredient in the synthesis, especially if catalysts are not used. The beam interacts with the atmosphere above the specimen producing a plasma that can generate fullerenes (Burden and Hutchison, 1998). Alternatively, irradiation of graphitic materials
470
A
F.M. Ross
B
Figure 6–14. Mechanism of silicon oxidation. (A) Series of images of an Si(111) sample observed in plan view during oxidation in 2 × 10−6 Torr water vapor at 400°C. The time of each frame is given. A 1/3 (422) forbidden reflection was used to form the images so that the gray levels correspond to terraces, with intensities repeating every unit cell (three steps). Steps do not move during oxidation of several layers showing that step sites are no more reactive than terrace sites. (Reprinted with permission from Ross and Gibson, © 1991 by the American Plysical Society.) (B) Two images of an Si(001) sample observed before and after oxidation in air at room temperature. A 1/4 (220) forbidden reflection was used to form these images. The steps do not move on this surface either.
Figure 6–15. Oxidation of a block oxide structure. High-resolution image of an Nb22O54 crystal after heating by the electron beam and exposure to 15 mbar oxygen. The partly oxidized structure consists of microdomains of Nb10O25 (arrowed) in an Nb22O54 matrix. These images have been used to identify the structure of the Nb10O25 phase and the complete oxidation sequence from Nb12O29 to Nb10O25 has been determined using in situ experiments. (From Sayagues and Hutchison, 2002 with permission from Elsevier.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
Figure 6–16. Carbon nanostructure growth in situ. (A) Formation of diamond in situ. Polyhedral graphitic particles were produced by arc-discharge and were transformed into perfectly spherical onions by electron beam irradiation above 600K. The decreasing distance between shells toward the center showed that the onions are in a state of high selfcompression. The nucleation of cubic diamond occurs in the centers of the onions during irradiation above 900K, and the diamond grows until, surprisingly, almost all the onion shells are consumed. (a) After 2 h of irradiation at 1.25 MeV and 20 mA cm−2. (b) After a further hour of irradiation. A typical twin is visible in the diamond. High pressure appears necessary to nucleate the diamond, but further growth is by beam-induced defects. (Reprinted with Permission from Banhart, © 1997. American Institute of Physics.) (B) Growth of multiwalled carbon nanotubes by catalytic chemical vapor deposition. Brightfield images showing an Ni-SiO2 catalyst (a) exposed to H2 at 450°C; (b) after exposure to acetylene (300 mTorr of an H2–C2H2 mixture), and (d) another part of the sample after 3 min. The arrows show an individual Ni particle. At higher temperatures single-walled tubes formed but with catalysts present at the bases rather than the tips of the tubes. (Reprinted with permission from Sharma and Iqbal, © 2004. American Institute of Physics.)
A
B
471
472
F.M. Ross
generates point defects which deform the graphitic sheets, forming new structures (Ugarte, 1992; Banhart, 1997), while irradiation of materials such as Cu implanted with C causes graphitic onions to grow (Abe et al., 2002). Familiar or new C and BN structures, and even formation of diamond from graphite, can thus be observed in situ (Ugarte, 1992; Ru et al., 1996; Niihara et al., 1996; Banhart, 1997, 1999, 2003; Bengu and Marks, 2000; Roddatis et al., 2002; Troiani et al., 2003; Gloter et al., 2004; Wang et al., 2005). Carbon nanotubes are of particular interest, and can be grown in situ by introducing a precursor gas such as methane, propylene, or acetylene over a catalyst (Sharma and Iqbal, 2004; Sharma et al., 2005). During growth, individual catalyst particles change their shape, and nucleation sites can be identified (Helveg et al., 2004). Once grown, carbon nanotubes can be modified with the beam (Terrones et al., 2000, 2002) to produce more complex structures. 3.5 Epitaxial and Polycrystalline Thin Film Growth The experiments in Section 3.4 have shown the exciting possibilities for controlled environment growth of nanostructures. Continuous thin films can also be grown in situ, and this allows important processes such as nucleation, development of surface morphology, and relaxation to be observed. Although some studies describe polycrystalline film growth (for example Al; Drucker et al., 1995), most systems examined in situ have been epitaxial. These include Au on MgO (Kizuka and Tanaka, 1997a, b), Ge on Si (see below), and silicides on Si (Section 2). These experiments can provide detailed and quantitative information if growth conditions such as flux and temperature are calibrated carefully. The most detailed studies have examined Ge and SiGe epitaxy on Si. This is a “test system” for studying epitaxial growth phenomena which also has great relevance to the development of microelectronic devices. A true UHV environment is required for the experiments, as the Si substrate foil is cleaned by heating in UHV to above the oxide desorption temperature. Growth is then carried out by UHV-CVD using gases such as disilane or digermane. Growth was observed by Krishnamurthy et al. (1991) in STEM, and by Minoda and Yagi (1996) and Ichikawa et al. (1998) in REM. But most work in this system has been carried out using conventional weak beam imaging in plan view, giving the highest sensitivity to strain fields (Figure 6–17). LeGoues et al. (1996) and Hammar et al. (1996) grew Ge on Si(111) and (001) in situ, clearly imaging the initial surface reconstruction, the nucleation of Ge islands, and later their growth and coalescence. The structures produced depend strongly on growth conditions. By varying the parameters, a range of fascinating phenomena now known to be common in other epitaxial systems was observed, such as the change in island shape during the introduction of stress-relieving dislocations (LeGoues et al., 1994, 1995). The range of structures observed in these studies would have been tedious to capture ex situ, and dynamic phenomena
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy 200nm
D
P
Is
A
3
473
12
7
16
34 0
4
50 sec
3.0
60
2.5
50
Island size
Island diameter (nm)
Tim e (seconds) 70
40 30 20
DL
2.0
VC V 1
1.5
PS
1.0 0.5
10
0.0
0 0
20
40
60
80
0
10
Time (seconds)
B
20
30
Time step
D1
C
D2
D2 0.0a
b
D
d
D3
D3
D3
e
50nm
c
f
Figure 6–17. Ge island nucleation, growth, and relaxation. (A) Island coarsening. A series of video frames showing stages of island growth within a 0.5 µm × 0.5 µm area. Growth conditions were 5 × 10−7 Torr Ge2H6 and 650°C. Weak beam images were acquired in a (g, 3g) condition with g = 220. The time of each frame after “nucleation” (first appearance of islands) is given. (B) The time evolution of every island within the area. (C) A simulation showing the fate of islands with different initial sizes, based on a modified Ostwald ripening process in which islands coarsen but also undergo a shape transition at Vc. The scale of the plot is chosen to match the data shown in (b). (Reprinted with permission from Ross et al., © 1998 by the American Physical Society.) (D) The introduction of dislocations into a partially relaxed island. Images were obtained 59, 94, 96, and 140 min after the beginning of growth, with the last three images taken within 1 s of each other. Growth conditions were 650°C and 10−6 Torr of 10 : 1 He : GeH4. Only dislocations in the dark part of the image can be seen (D1–D3). (From Hammar et al., 1996 with permission from Elsevier.)
such as island shape changes and the essential role of Ostwald ripening (Ross et al., 1998) would not have been detected without the use of in situ TEM. Changes caused by the presence of surfactants during growth have also been examined in situ (Maruno et al., 1996;
474
F.M. Ross
Portavoce et al., 2004). It is interesting to note that complementary studies using in situ LEEM have been important in fully understanding growth in the SiGe system, as LEEM is more sensitive to surface structure (e.g., Ross et al., 1999b). When low Ge content (say 15%) SiGe is grown on Si, islands are not seen, but instead a continuous flat layer forms. When sufficiently thick, this film relaxes by introduction of dislocations. The motion of these dislocations can be measured during film deposition and compared with dislocation dynamics during post-growth annealing, which will be discussed in Section 5. Interestingly, the parameters governing dislocation motion are different during growth, where the surface is H terminated, versus during annealing, where the surface is oxidized (Stach et al., 1998b, 2000). A higher kink nucleation rate under the oxidized surface, perhaps due to surface stress or increased point defects, is the probable cause. This is important for modeling relaxation during device processing, and shows once again the unique information that can be obtained when materials are observed during growth rather than ex situ. 3.6 Crystal Growth on Patterned Surfaces An interesting extension of the growth studies described above is the study of crystal growth on a non-uniform substrate. By carrying out growth on substrates which have been patterned to create areas of different reactivity, strain, or topographic contrast, the effect of these parameters on growth may be visualized directly and even quantitatively, if kinetic data is obtained. Again, most work has been done in the SiGe system, motivated by an interest in controlling island self-assembly for fabricating novel electronic devices. It is well known that if Ge is deposited on patterned Si, islands form at positions aligned with the topography. In situ measurement of nucleation times at different locations (Ross et al., 2004) showed that this is controlled by competition between edge adsorption of adatoms and terrace nucleation. Patterns may also be created with a focused ion beam. At low doses, this forms a shallow topography (Figure 6–18A) that is sufficient to control nucleation and alter wetting layer thickness (Kammler et al., 2003; Portavoce et al., 2006). In these experiments the focused ion beam gun was installed in a chamber connected to the TEM by UHV. The inclusion of surface processing tools that are not in situ (i.e., in the polepiece) but are within the microscope’s vacuum system enables a wider range of processes to be carried out controllably. A second example also relates to semiconductor nanostructures: vapor-liquid solid growth of nanowires. Here, a droplet of liquid eutectic catalyzes growth to form elongated wirelike structures. This process has been imaged in situ in plan view, allowing wire growth to be observed qualitatively, in Si/Au (Wu and Yang, 2001), Si/Fe (Zhou et al., 2002), and GaN (Stach et al., 2003). In GaAs/Au (Persson et al., 2004), post-growth heating of wires was used to deduce an alternative mechanism, vapor-solid-solid growth. If experiments are performed in
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
A
475
Figure 6–18. Growth on patterned substrates. (A) Bright field image of a Si substrate with g = 220, recorded directly after focused ion beam patterning using an irradiation time of 0.1 ms per feature (left). After annealing followed by deposition of Ge at 650ºC and 5 × 10−8 Torr; (g, 3 g) weak beam image with g = 220 (right), showing islands (small dots) on the irradiated areas. (Reprinted with permission from Kammler et al., 2003. American Institute of Physics.) (B) Growth of an epitaxial Si nanowire by the vapour-liquid-solid mechanism, at 620ºC and 3 × 10−6 Torr Si2H6 with times in seconds indicated. The wire direction is (111) and the viewing direction is near (01-1) in this dark field g = 220 series. The Au-Si droplet is visible on the end of the wire. As growth continues, the droplet shrinks due to diffusion of Au down the wire surface, causing the wire diameter to decrease with it.
B
reflection geometry, however, growth kinetics can be measured quantitatively (Figure 6–18B). Such studies demonstrate effects that are not expected from the basic growth model, such as surface faceting (Ross et al., 2005) and catalyst diffusion during growth (Hannon et al., 2006). 3.7 Summary In this section we have highlighted insights in surface physics and crystal growth derived from in situ TEM. Experiments in this field, while often requiring dedicated equipment with complex additional preparation chambers, provide information that is difficult or impossible to obtain using other techniques. Continuous and direct observation in situ avoids artifacts arising from ex situ observation, which may be especially significant for growth studies. It is particularly encouraging that realistic growth conditions can be accessed in the TEM, enabling in situ studies of, for example, catalysis or CVD to be related
476
F.M. Ross
to their counterparts in the outside world. Indeed, the relevance of in situ TEM to the catalyst and microelectronics industries is shown by the presence of environmental microscopes in several industrial laboratories. Opportunities clearly exist for further study. Growth on patterned surfaces, prepared if necessary with integrated processing tools in the TEM system, seems a particularly exciting way to examine the fundamental processes controlling growth and to fabricate nanoscale objects with particular properties. Another potentially significant area is the correlation of structural or kinetic in situ measurements with macroscopic properties such as stress. Stress may be measured by depositing onto a crystalline membrane whose curvature can be observed. This may provide insight into the important processes associated with coalescence and grain boundary motion during polycrystalline film growth, as well as stress relaxation mechanisms in epitaxial films.
4 Magnetic, Ferroelectric, and Superconducting Materials It is happily convenient that magnetic and ferroelectric domain walls and magnetic flux vortices can be visualised relatively easily in the TEM using several different imaging modes. This provides us with the opportunity to study the dynamics of ferromagnetic and ferroelectric domain switching, as well as interesting phase transformations associated with magnetic, ferroelectric, and superconducting materials. Holography or Lorentz imaging, either in Fresnel or Foucault mode, can be used to visualise magnetic domain walls and flux vortices, while ferroelectric domains can be observed through their strain field or defect structure. By applying a varying magnetic or electric field to the sample, or by changing its temperature, we can modify its magnetic or ferroelectric structure and correlate the change with the physical microstructure. Such experiments have provided insight into domain boundary dynamics, useful in modeling the workings of storage media or memory elements, as well as providing compelling illustrations of the motion of flux vortices through superconductors. 4.1 Magnetic Domain Motion in Ferromagnetic Materials The interesting physics and industrially important applications of magnetic materials have generated a strong in situ experimental effort in this area. Studies have been motivated by a desire for a basic understanding of magnetic phenomena, as well as by the use of magnetic materials in storage, sensor, and other applications, where the magnetization of small regions of a material has to change controllably and reversibly many times. The most powerful experiments have related in situ observation of, say, the micromagnetic changes during a hysteresis cycle to the macroscopic magnetic properties. This allows us to understand, for example, the volume fraction of ferromagnetically or antiferromagnetically coupled regions in a material, or the structural reasons for an imperfect coupling of adjacent layers.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
To carry out in situ magnetic experiments, two components are required: the ability to apply a controlled field to the specimen, and appropriate imaging capabilities for resolving its magnetic structure. Also useful is the ability to heat or cool the sample so that phenomena can be studied around the Curie temperature. For applying a controlled magnetic field, it is preferable if the microscope is designed so that the sample sits in a field-free or low-field region. However, if a conventional microscope is used, the objective lens can be switched off, and the magnification this lens usually supplies can be achieved with the other lenses. The controlled magnetic field can then be applied using coils placed in the column or on the specimen holder. Several different designs of specimen holders incorporating coils have been developed to generate in-plane and out of plane fields, preferably without shifting the beam (for recent examples see Uhlig et al., 2003 and Yi et al., 2004). An alternative holder geometry (Park et al., 2005) uses a sharp needle made of a permanent magnet to produce a strong field near the specimen. A simpler solution that does not involve modification of the sample holder is to tilt the sample in an excited objective lens, thereby changing the field it experiences. This has been used to good effect in the experiments on superconductors described in Section 4.2. Several imaging techniques are available for magnetic structures. These are described in detail elsewhere (Zhu and De Graef, 2001), and include holography, Lorentz imaging in the Fresnel (easier) or Foucault (higher resolution) modes, and the differential phase contrast technique. These techniques have been used extensively to examine static magnetic structures, but here we discuss only experiments where the magnetic structure is deliberately changed. Such experiments have been carried out on single crystals, thin films (often of complex multilayers), and patterned magnetic elements. 4.1.1 Thin Film Magnetic Materials The motion of domain walls in polycrystalline magnetic materials has been studied for over 30 years to determine how domain walls move in perfect materials, how they interact, and how grain boundaries and other defects alter their motion by pinning. For example, macroscopic hysteresis loops have been correlated with pinning and domain size in Co/Pt (Donnet et al., 1993), and during magnetization reversals in NdFe-B, the grain structure has been shown to affect the mechanism and motion of the domain boundaries (Thompson et al., 1997; Volkov and Zhu, 2000). Interesting and complex functionalities can be obtained by fabricating multilayered materials where each layer has different magnetic properties. For example, two ferromagnetic materials separated by a conducting layer can show giant magnetoresistance properties which have applications in nonvolatile magnetic random access memory and magnetoresistive read head technologies. When one ferromagnetic layer is “pinned” by an adjacent antiferromagnetic layer, multistep hysteresis loops make the structures suitable for spin valves or spin tunnel junctions. Magnetic tunnel junctions made of two (or more)
477
478
F.M. Ross
magnetic layers separated by an insulating tunnel barrier can also be used for storage or sensing. Details of the magnetization reversal mechanism (for example, whether it occurs by domain nucleation and growth or by spin rotation), and the relationship of the hysteresis loop to the microstructure (interface roughness and grain size) are open questions in these interesting multilayers. For NiFe/Al-oxide/Co and Co/NiFe/Al-oxide/NiFe multilayers, Lorentz imaging in Fresnel mode (Yu et al., 2002a, b) showed the process of magnetization reversal by wall motion and rotation (Figure 6–19), and the relationship of grain size and texture to domain wall motion. Lim et al. (2002, 2004) examined reversal in the complex structures such as PtMn/CoFe/Ru/CoFe/ Cu/CoFe/NiFe used in advanced spin valves, while Portier et al. (1999a) studied the effect of heating on Ta/NiFe/Cu/Co/MnFe/Ta films to model thermal damage in spin valves. In IrMn/CoFe films, in situ experiments showed that magnetization reversal must overcome two energy barriers, explaining the asymmetry in the reversal behavior and other features of the hysteresis loop, as well as the dependence of the properties on the layer thicknesses (Y.G. Wang et al., 2002). It is clear that in situ experiments provide a unique way of studying the properties of the ever more complex multilayers being developed for modern read heads and other applications. 4.1.2 Small Magnetic Elements Since most applications of magnetic materials require the material to be patterned into small elements, it is naturally useful to examine the behavior of individual elements in situ. Typically an electron transparent substrate such as a SiN layer is used, on which magnetic elements of different shapes and sizes are patterned using electron beam lithography. The elements may either be far apart so that they can be studied in isolation, or near their neighbours so that crosstalk can be observed. It is possible to perform micromagnetic simulations of the complete structures, to provide a way to understand the microstructural observations and relate them to macroscopic measurements of hysteresis loops. A switching experiment carried out on arrays of Co elements is shown in Figure 6–20 (Volkov et al., 2004). Such experiments have allowed the switching field of several materials to be measured (e.g., K.J. Kirk et al., 1999). Permalloy (NiFe) elements have been particularly closely examined (Johnston et al., 1996, McVitie and Chapman, 1997, Schneider et al., 2001, 2002, 2003, X.X. Liu et al., 2004, Lau et al., 2005). These studies showed how the different configurations of remanent magnetization and the process of magnetization reversal depend on the aspect ratio and symmetry of the elements, as well as the temperature, and how the reversal rate of the field affects the final domain configuration. Multilayer elements can also be studied, and by examining spin valve elements, Portier and Petford-Long (2000) showed that certain end shapes allowed easier switching by enabling 360º domain walls to form. Analogous phenomena occur when arrays of holes (antidots) are patterned in an otherwise continuous film. In Permalloy, antidots alter the domain structure and reversal mechanism (Toporov et al., 2000).
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
Figure 6–19. Magnetization of a multilayered film in situ. Lorentz Fresnel images (a–k) of the magnetization process for an NiFe/Al-oxide/Co junction film. The direction of the applied field H is indicated. All images are of the same area. Also shown is the normalized magnetization vs applied field for the same film. The corresponding domain structure at different field values along the hysteresis loop is shown. (Reprinted with permission from Yu et al., © 2002a. American Institute of Physics.)
479
480
F.M. Ross
Figure 6–20. Magnetization of small elements. (A, B) In situ magnetization of two Co elements 25 nm thick and 6?m on a side on an SiN membrane. Images are shown as a function of decreasing applied field, achieved by tilting the sample in a fixed normal field excited by the objective lens (160 Oe), and images are obtained using defocused Fresnel mode. Large and small arrows show the direction of the applied field and local magnetization, respectively. The nucleation of the reverse domain is indicated with asterisks. Only the upper semiloop of the hysteresis curve is shown; the reverse process is somewhat alike but differs in the reverse switching field. The processes observed in these images are coarsening of ripples, due to coherent spin rotation; nucleation and expansion of reverse domains; wall motion and spin rotation in the remaining domains; expulsion of unfavorable boundary domains; and edge annihilation. (From Volkov et al., 2004 with kind permission of Taylor and Francis Ltd.)
An interesting extension of these in situ studies on magnetic elements has been the simultaneous measurement of resistivity. Using a holder in which the resistivity of a single lithographically patterned element can be measured while its magnetization is changed, Portier et al. (1997, 1998, 1999b) were able to correlate magnetoresistance with the magnetic domain structure. Studies on single spin valves made of multilayers such as NiFe/Cu/Co/NiFe/MnNi allowed magnetoresistance to be correlated with the angle between the magnetization directions in the ferromagnetic layers. It was also possible to show the mechanism of magnetization reversal, and to demonstrate the effect of stray-field coupling, which introduces edge domains, on the reversal mechanism. 4.1.3 Phase Transitions in Magnetic Materials The industrial application of materials with giant magnetoresistance has stimulated study of an unusual class of materials which show colossal magnetoresistance. These are certain manganites with the perovskite structure, such as LaSrMnO3, which have both ferromag-
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
netic and paramagnetic phases. The phase transition and mixed phase regions in these materials can be studied in situ in a cooling stage using electron holography. The nucleation of ferromagnetic domains can be observed on cooling (Yoo et al., 2004a), while in the mixed phase region, application of a magnetic field creates channels connecting ferromagnetic regions, thereby changing the conductivity (Yoo et al., 2004b). These studies help to explain details of the mechanism of colossal magnetoresistance. Another interesting class of magnetic materials is ferromagnetic shape memory alloys such as Ni2MnGa and CoNiAl. In these materials, the shape change may be induced by applying a magnetic field. Again, in situ TEM using Lorentz imaging and a cooling stage (Murakami et al., 2002, Park et al., 2003) allows the correlation of the magnetic domain structure with the grain structure in these materials. Phase transformations in Ni2MnGa are shown in Figure 6–21. In experiments like this on bulk materials, the effects of varying sample thickness on domain motion should be considered in order to obtain the most quantitative results. 4.2 Superconducting Materials In situ TEM has provided a fascinating glimpse into the dynamics of superconducting materials. Over the last several years, several groups, most notably that of Tonomura and coworkers, have observed the presence and dynamics of vortices in superconductors using in situ techniques. Single vortices, with their magnetic flux of h/2e, have an observable effect on the phase of the imaging electrons. Thus Lorentz microscopy or holographic techniques can be used to determine their positions and characteristics. A medium or high voltage TEM with a cooling stage is used for these studies and the magnetic field can be conveniently applied to the sample by tilting the sample in the existing field of the objective lens. These experiments have provided unique insights into the behavior of superconducting materials, in particular concerning the formation of vortex lattices, as well as vortex pinning, which must be controlled for practical applications of superconductors. Real time imaging has allowed vortex pinning and dynamics to be related to microstructural features for several superconducting materials (Figure 6–22). The motion of vortices was first imaged in Nb foils below 5 K (Figure 6– 22A). The effects of grain boundaries on vortex motion were immediatedly visible (Harada et al., 1992, Bonevich et al., 1993; Tonomura, 2002). The role of dislocations in pinning vortices and nucleating locally ordered regions of vortices (the Abrikosov lattice) was demonstrated (Horiuchi et al., 1998). Nb specimens which had been irradiated with an FIB to produce artificial pinning centers showed fascinating vortex dynamics in which local regions of Abrikosov lattice formed and most motion took place at the boundaries of such lattices (Matsuda et al., 1996). Regular arrays of vortices could be formed with period matching the pinning point period (Harada et al., 1996a). Vortex annihilation was also observed (Harada et al., 1997) and the interactions between vortices
481
482
F.M. Ross
Figure 6–21. Phase transformation in a magnetic material. (a–h) Bright-field images and electron diffraction patterns of the three phases of Ni2MnGa: the parent phase at 294K, intermediate phase at 207K, and martensite at 170K (P, I, and M, respectively). Both the crystal structure (via diffraction) and the magnetic structure (magnetic domains observed by Lorentz microscopy) are visible. BC and DW represent the bend contours and the domain walls, respectively. (Reprinted with permission from Park et al., © 2003. American Institute of Physics.)
quantified (Sow et al., 1998) by analyzing their motion through the foil. Most recently, asymmetric (one-way) motion of vortices has been controlled by FIB-patterning asymmetric channels (Togawa et al., 2005). For high temperature superconductors, with their potentially wide range of applications, the pinning of vortices is weak and therefore particularly important to understand and control. Harada et al. (1996b) showed that, in these materials, vortex dynamics also depend on the defects present. The effects of artificial pinning centers are highly temperature dependent, giving useful insight into the different mechanisms active (Tonomura et al., 2001). Furthermore, the vortices adopt unusual chainlike arrangements in these superconductors (Matsuda et al., 2001, Tonomura et al., 2002), as shown in Figure 6–22B. It is worth noting that a high voltage (1 MeV) TEM was required to obtain the necessary resolution for studying these materials (Tonomura, 2003).
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
483
4.3 Ferroelectric Phenomena Ferroelectric domain boundary motion due to an applied electric field or stress has applications in information storage, and the piezoelectric properties of these materials make them interesting as sensors, actuators and transducers. Two key issues in the development of ferroelectric devices are fatigue, in other words the change in boundary dynamics resulting from repeated cycling, and the effects of film thickness and electrode material on boundary dynamics. Polarized optical
A
B Figure 6–22. Vortex motion in superconductors. (A) Pinning of vortices in Nb. Typical interaction between the vortex lattice and an array of defects produced in an Nb thin foil by irradiation with a Ga+ focused ion beam. In the first image, obtained at 4.5K, the pinning site acts as a domain boundary, while at higher temperatures (8K, lower image) pinning points typically act as cores of edge dislocations in the lattice. (From Harada et al., 1997b with permission from Elsevier.) (B) A series of Lorentz micrographs of vortices in field-cooled Bi-2212 film at 50 K when a magnetic field Bz perpendicular to the layer plane is applied. The in-plane magnetic field Bx is fixed at 5 mT. (a) Bz = 0 (b) Bz = 0.02 mT. (c) Bz = 0.1 mT. (d) Bz = 0.17 mT. The arrangement of the vertical vortices in chains is marked with arrows. These chains are caused by interactions with horizontal vortices produced by the in-plane field. (Reprinted with permission from Tonomura et al., © 2002 by the American Physical Society.)
484
F.M. Ross
microscopy and AFM have been used successfully to investigate the overall features of boundary motion, but naturally TEM is unparalleled in its ability to relate the microstructural features within the material to boundary motion. In situ experiments are usually carried out by using a specimen holder with electrical connections to apply an electric field, although domain motion during heating and straining has also been studied. A heating biasing holder is preferable as it allows domain dynamics to be studied at different distances from the transition temperature. Ferroelectric biasing has been carried out both on mechanically thinned polycrystalline or single crystal samples, and on thin films deposited on a substrate. Depending on the material geometry, the electrical contacts may either both be on top of the sample or one on each surface. As in other experiments, for quantitative analysis a well controlled specimen and field geometry is important. Changes in sample thickness may change the area of domain walls and therefore influence kinetics. Furthermore, as we show below, defects affect wall motion, so the defects introduced during sample preparation must be minimized. For all these reasons, experiments on bulk materials may provide more qualitative information, whereas thin films, especially on substrates which can be made into electron transparent membranes with a controlled electrode geometry and with minimal processing, provide the best opportunity for quantitative results. For example, thin film studies provide the opportunity to understand the “dead layer,” in which surface pinning retards domain motion. Domain motion has been observed under electron beam heating, for example in K(Ta,Nb)O3 (Xu et al., 1993), and during straining, for example in ferroelastic zirconia (Baufeld et al., 1997). Most studies, however, have used in situ biasing or controlled heating to achieve domain motion. The most detailed results have come from studies of BaTiO3 and related materials. For example, Ren et al. (1994) observed domain wall motion in PbTiO3, while Snoeck et al. (1994) observed domain growth in BaTiO3 by tip motion and then by lateral wall motion, and noted defects along the domain boundaries. Krishnan et al. (1999, 2000, 2002; Figure 6–23) observed different modes of domain wall motion in BaTiO3 and KNbO3 under heating, biasing, and UV irradiation. These studies showed that the motion of 90o boundaries depends on their curvature and on locking interactions with neighboring domains, and that motion may occur by rippling rather than rigidly. Interestingly, images showed the presence of trapped charge at curved or tilted boundaries or at domain tips. The buildup of charge at boundaries observed in situ may be important in fatigue. In relaxor ferroelectrics such as Pb(Mg,Nb)O3-PbTiO3, cracking is important in piezoelectric applications. The structures of domain wall intersections has been characterized in these materials (Tan and Shang, 2004a, b; Tan et al., 2005). Cycling the electric field causes cracking in the TEM specimens, thereby providing information on crack propagation pathways along domain walls (Xu et al., 2000; Tan et al., 2000, 2005).
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
485
Figure 6–23. Domain wall motion in ferroelectrics under biasing. Bright field images of single crystal KNbO3 viewed close to the [010] direction. (a) Before applying an E-field. (b) After applying the field. Initially, numerous needle-like 90º domain walls as well as dislocations (dark wiggly features) and other domain wall geometries (vertical stripes) exists. On application of the field, the needle like walls move readily, coarsening the domain structure and forming straighter walls which then move less easily. This is because curved and tilted 90º domain walls (indicated by 1) must support a geometrically required Maxwellian displacement charge hence experience a direct force from an applied field, while charge-neutral domain wall regions (indicated by 2) do not experience a direct force. This suggests an intrinsic mechanism of fatigue. (Reprinted with permission from Krishnan et al., © 2000. American Institute of Physics.)
486
F.M. Ross
By analogy with the magnetic phase transitions described in Section 4.1.3, ferroelectric phase transitions may be examined by applying an electric field in situ. An example is the electric field-induced transformation of incommensurate modulations in Sn-modified Pb(Zr,Ti)O3 (He and Tan, 2004, 2005). Other ferroelectric materials, such as Ba2NaNb5O15, show interesting incommensurate phases on heating or cooling, and these have been studied in situ for several decades. For Ba2NaNb5O15, the incommensurate to tetragonal phase transition has been examined in diffraction (Pan et al., 1985; S. Mori et al., 1997). The nucleation of the incommensurate phase can be investigated (Verwerft et al., 1988) as well as the effect of beam-induced defects on the phase transformation (Barre et al., 1991). We have seen that many ferroelectric phenomena have been examined using electric field and/or hot stage TEM. But it is worth noting that, in comparison with magnetic studies of reversal phenomena, the study of ferroelectric materials has not been as quantitative. As with the magnetic studies, it may be possible to combine simulations with in situ studies on patterned ferroelectric elements (Lin et al., 1998), perhaps prepared using focused ion beam processing, to obtain a more detailed understanding of switching and phenomena such as surface effects and fatigue. 4.4 Summary In situ experiments have provided a persuasive demonstration of the dynamic processes within superconducting, magnetic, and ferroelectric materials: domain motion, flux vortex arrays, and pinning. In the future, where applications of nanostructured ferroelectric and ferromagnetic materials in storage and microelectronic devices may become even more important, in situ techniques are ideally suited to analyze switching and fatigue effects. This will be especially useful in combination with nanoscale patterning to create well-defined geometries. We envisage interesting results if such studies are combined with high speed imaging techniques as well as 3D analysis techniques, such as tomography, for boundary or vortex configurations. However, it is also worth noting that real materials are buried within structures, giving boundary conditions for the electric, magnetic, and strain fields which are different from those found in a TEM foil. Care must be taken that this does not limit the utility of in situ TEM. For modeling real life systems, these effects must be included, perhaps by imaging at higher voltage or using tomographic or other analytical techniques to pick out the material of interest from within a complex structure.
5 Elastic and Plastic Deformation TEM is well suited for studying the mechanical properties of materials. Under appropriate conditions, TEM is very sensitive to lattice distortion, allowing observation of both elastic and plastic deformation via strain fields. In situ deformation studies aim to impose a known stress
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
on a sample and measure the response quantitatively. This may be achieved using a straining stage to pull the specimen uniaxially or biaxially with piezo or mechanical linkages. Alternatively, stress can be imposed by heating samples with a thermal expansion mismatch or an inbuilt stress, such as epitaxial films. Straining can even be carried out in a controlled atmosphere to simulate phenomena such as hydrogen embrittlement. The sample itself may be a thin film, a nanostructure or a bulk material, perhaps notched to initiate cracks. The information from in situ experiments is important because deformation is a bulk process and so requires a technique that can see deep into the specimen; surface techniques can not give the whole picture, even if the signature of dislocations can sometimes be seen on the surface. Of course TEM samples are thin in the beam direction so have free surfaces nearby, a factor that must be considered in interpreting results. This can actually be put to good use, though, in studies of tribology or the deformation of individual nanostructures in situ. 5.1 Microscopic Phenomena during Deformation of Bulk Materials Structural changes during deformation, such as grain boundary motion, dislocation motion, and cracking have been studied in situ for just about every class of bulk material. These experiments have yielded useful information on dislocation interactions, pinning, the transfer of strain across boundaries, and the effects of temperature. This area has a history going right back to the start of high voltage microscopy, and a review of the first, pioneering work can be found in Butler and Hale (1981). Here we discuss some recent studies on metals, ceramics, semiconductors and alloys. Most experiments require straining stages which are also capable of heating, up to very high temperatures in some cases. Design rules for such extreme heating and straining holders are discussed by Messerschmidt et al. (1998) and Komatsu et al. (1994). Other studies examine the mechanical response of materials to irradiation and will be discussed in Section 8. 5.1.1 Deformation Phenomena in Single Crystals and Polycrystalline Materials For single crystals, it is possible to relate an applied stress to the motion and interactions of specific types of dislocations. In situ observations provide detailed measurements of dislocation generation and multiplication mechanisms, as well as geometry, dissociation, interactions, and slip systems (Figure 6–24A). Studies on polycrystalline materials, on the other hand, allow us to understand the important process of strain transmission across grain boundaries. Heating, straining, and heating/ straining experiments have been the focus of several groups, and comprehensive reviews are available (Messerschmidt et al., 1997; Mori, 1998; Pettinari et al., 2001; Vanderschaeve et al., 2001; Messerschmidt, 2003). We first consider metals and alloys. Dislocation motion has been studied in single crystals such as Mg, Cu, and Al at moderate temperature, while refractory metals require high temperatures (Mori, 1998).
487
488
A
B
F.M. Ross
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
489
Figure 6–24. Deformation of bulk crystals. (A) Dislocations moving away from a localized source during in situ deformation of a MoSi2 single crystal at ~900ºC. The loading axis is [201], which is a soft orientation, and dislocations of Burgers vectors 1/2 <111> are activated on {110} planes. The traces of these slip planes run horizontally. Owing to the generation of these dislocations in localized sources, as shown here, planar slip dominates. The foil plane is (010) and g = [220]. (From Messerschmidt et al., © 1998. Courtesy of Cambridge University Press.) (B) Deformation of a refractory metal, V, without formation of dislocations. Diffraction patterns are obtained near the crack tip during deformation of a notched foil. As the internal stresses increase, the spots expand perpendicularly to the crack so appear elongated. (The central spot is masked to prevent overexposure.) Images do not show clusters of point defects in V, unlike the case of Au strained under the same conditions. (From Komatsu et al., 2003 with permission from Elsevier.)
Most studies apply a uniaxial stress, although, for example, cyclic shearing of Al single crystals has been described (Kassner et al., 1997). Plastic deformation does not always require dislocation generation or motion, and in V, Mo, and other bcc metals, deformation may occur by formation of point defects rather than dislocations. This too can be observed in situ with appropriate diffraction and imaging techniques (Komatsu et al., 2003; Figure 6–24B). The challenge in all these straining experiments is to make them quantitative. One interesting technique for the measurement of local stress is through the curvature of dislocations between pinning points (Pettinari et al., 2001). As an intermediate case between single crystal and polycrystalline metals, bicrystals provide the opportunity to apply the precision of single crystal experiments to studies of strain transfer across boundaries. For example, in symmetric Σ 3 Fe-4 at.% Si bicrystals, Gemperlova et al. (2002) determined the primary slip system and studied the particular slip systems which can transmit stress across the boundary. For polycrystalline metals, deformation can be investigated for thin films by either straining or heating. TEM is well suited to these thin film studies, although the sample geometry must still be controlled (for example with respect to thickness uniformity) to avoid artifacts, and surface passivation can affect the results. Straining experiments have shown, for example, that the failure mode of polycrystalline Ni films depends on grain boundary structure (Hugo et al., 2003). Thermal cycling experiments show grain boundary motion (see Section 2.1.3) and the interactions of dislocations with grain boundaries and precipitates (e.g., Kaouache et al., 2003). For thin Cu and Al films, the higher yield stress known for these materials has been related to particular types of dislocation motion (Dehm and Arzt, 2000; Balk et al., 2003). Threading dislocation motion and the effect of the passivation layer have also been studied (Keller-Flaig et al., 1999; Legros et al., 2002). Recent progress with nanoindentation stages (Section 5.3.1) and the development of specimens incorporating microelectromechanical (MEMS) free-standing films (Section 5.1.2) promise further developments in understanding the deformation of polycrystalline films in the future. We now consider intermetallics, which have been examined in situ to understand the mechanism of their high temperature toughness and phase transformations. Generally, dislocation dynamics change as a
490
F.M. Ross
function of temperature in these materials (e.g., Haussler et al., 1999). Dislocation interactions, cross slip, and nucleation of loops control work hardening, ductility, and the critical resolved shear stress (Legros et al., 1996, 1997; Legros and Caillard, 2001). Dislocation motion during creep has also been examined (Malaplate et al., 2004). Polysynthetically twinned TiAl crystals have lamellar structures with well-defined boundaries. By analogy with the bicrystal experiments, strain propagation across these boundaries can be quantified in situ (Zghal et al., 2001; Pyo and Kim, 2005). Transformations in shape memory alloys have already been mentioned in Section 2, and in situ straining experiments relate the microstructural changes during deformation to the stress-strain response (Jiang et al., 1997; Dutkiewicz et al., 1995; Gao et al., 1996). The cracking of intermetallics is also important in applications. Dislocations emitted at a crack tip can be analyzed (in NiAl; Caillard et al., 1999), and amorphization can be detected at crack tips (in NiTi ordered alloys; Watanabe et al., 2002). Quasicrystals have interesting mechanical properties and dislocation geometry. In situ heating and straining experiments have led to the identification of shear systems and models for dislocation motion in these materials (Messerschmidt et al., 1999; Messerschmidt, 2001; Caillard et al., 2002; Mompiou et al., 2004; Bartsch et al., 2005). Ceramics have been important subjects of study since the 1970s, with an interest in comparing dislocation motion at lower and higher temperatures (e.g., in zirconia, Messerschmidt et al., 1997; alumina, Komatsu et al., 1994; MoSi2, Guder et al., 2002). In quartz, strain-induced phase transformations have been studied by combined straining/heating experiments (Snoeck and Roucau, 1992). We finally consider semiconductors. Kinetic studies show that dislocation motion is consistent with glide governed by the Peierls mechanism (Vanderschaeve et al., 2001). From dislocation motion and pinning, the kink mean free path and formation and migration energies can be determined (Gottschalk et al., 1993; Vanderschaeve et al., 2000; Kruml et al., 2002). Radiation enhances the glide of dislocations by changing some of these parameters (Section 8). Most studies have used low resolution, dark field imaging to record dislocation motion, but it is actually possible to observe directly the thermal motion of kinks in Si using a high resolution forbidden reflection imaging technique (Kolar et al., 1996). This generates fascinating information. The kink formation energy and unpinning barrier can be derived from the distribution and pinning of individual kinks, and videos show directly that kink migration is the rate limiting step in dislocation motion. This technique should be applicable to other materials and is expected to lead to further advances in our understanding of dislocation motion (Spence et al., 2006). 5.1.2 Deformation of Multiphase, Composite, or Layered Materials Deformation experiments in multiphase materials, such as dispersion strengthened alloys, are particularly important in materials development, since they show how strain is transmitted between components. Dispersion strengthened Al alloys have been examined extensively, to
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
491
characterize the nucleation of dislocations at precipitates and their motion past precipitates (Vetrano et al., 1997; Hattenhauer, 1994). These phenomena are critical in high temperature deformation of such alloys. Other phenomena, such as grain boundary migration, coalescence, and elimination of subboundaries, occur during dynamic continuous crystallization on loading in the TEM (Vetrano et al., 1995; Dougherty et al., 2003), with in situ studies helping to understand the processes. Steel
Figure 6–25. Deformation in a Cu–Nb multifilamentary composite. Nanocomposite materials are used in wires requiring high strength and high conductivity. This sample was prepared by cold drawing an Nb rod inside a Cu jacket several times until a composite was formed consisting of Cu– 17%vol–Nb with 107 Nb filaments 40 nm across in Cu. The Cu channels have <111> texture, the Nb filaments have <110> texture, and the Cu–Nb interfaces are semicoherent. The sequence of images shows the introduction of dislocations under an applied force of 8 N. At this point Cu is plastically deformed while Nb is still elastically deforming. The area shown is a Cu channel of width about 100 nm (white) between two Nb filaments (black). At the beginning of the sequence (image a), five dislocation loops are present on parallel planes. A few seconds later the sixth and seventh loops appear (images b and c). By the end of the sequence 13 loops are present, and they have interacted to produce a honeycomb pattern (circles in images c–f). This dislocation behavior is used in a plastic flow model, which explains the very high ultimate tensile stress of fcc–bcc nanocomposite structures. (From Thilly et al., 2002, with kind permission of Taylor and Francis Ltd.)
492
F.M. Ross
Figure 6–26. Dislocation motion in H atmosphere. Showing the effect of H on the mobility of dislocations in 310S stainless steel. (a) dislocation configuration in vacuum under constant load; (b) 35 Torr; (c) 90 Torr of hydrogen; (d) composite image formed by subtracting (c) from (a). (Reprinted with permission from Robertson and Teter, © 1998 by the American Physical Society.)
is of course another multiphase material whose behavior in situ has been studied for some time (Caillard et al., 1980); industrially relevant studies of dislocation motion and slip transmission through interfaces in steels continue (Verhaeghe et al., 1997; Janecek et al., 2000; Zielinski et al., 2003). Many other nanocomposite materials provide interesting examples of dislocation-interface interactions. One such is shown in Figure 6–26 (Thilly et al., 2002) and other work is reviewed by Louchet et al. (2001). Techniques developed for multiphase materials extend easily to engineered multilayers, where the interaction of dislocations or cracks with interfaces is of interest. Cross sections of multilayers may be prepared using a FIB to form a thin section at which cracks will initiate (Wall et al., 1995; Wall and Barbee, 1997). Alternatively, multilayers (or thin films) may be integrated into a mechanical testing stage. One example is a piezo stage for cyclic loading of solder thin films, use to show that cavitation is the dominant fatigue damage mechanism (Tan et al., 2002). In this stage, a multilayered structure is fabricated which includes the material of interest as well as a piezoelectric layer. The future for thin film and multilayer studies undoubtedly lies in extending this sort of approach, achieving controlled deformation using MEMS-based techniques. MEMS force sensors and displacement
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
measurement systems can be integrated with the film of interest, allowing for quantitative experiments. Stages for uniaxial tensile testing of free-standing thin films have already been demonstrated (Haque and Saif, 2003, 2004, 2005; Hattar et al., 2005), with initial results on polycrystalline Al thin films, and other functionalities such as heating are under development (Zhang et al., 2005). We anticipate further exciting progress in this area. 5.1.3 Deformation in a Controlled Atmosphere By combining mechanical testing with controlled environment TEM, a very important objective, understanding the mechanism of hydrogen embrittlement of steels, has been achieved (Figure 6–27). In situ straining experiments carried out in an environmental cell showed that solute hydrogen can increase the speed at which dislocations move through the material, as well as increasing the rate of crack propagation (Robertson and Teter, 1998; Teter et al., 2001; Sofronis and Robertson, 2002). By quantitatively analyzing dislocation dynamics on adding and removing hydrogen, competing mechanisms for embrittlement could be distinguished. The hydrogen shielding model was confirmed, in which the hydrogen-enhanced localized plasticity mechanism is the shielding of the dislocation from interactions with other strain centers such as pinning points, other dislocations, or solutes. Few other materials have been strained in a controlled atmosphere, although Maeda et al. (2000) showed that the incorporation of hydrogen from a plasma increases the motion of dislocations in semiconductors. Further studies could provide a sensitive probe of dislocation properties and interactions. 5.2 Relaxation of Epitaxially Strained Materials In this section, we consider another method of straining a material: growth of the material epitaxially on a lattice mismatched substrate. As the layer is deposited a high intrinsic stress builds up, and, once above a “critical thickness,” the layer may relax by forming a network of dislocations at the layer-substrate interface (Figure 6–27A, B). This phenomenon can be examined in situ. First, a layer thicker than the critical thickness is grown, but at a temperature that is too low to allow dislocation nucleation or propagation. Then a plan view TEM specimen is prepared and heated in situ, allowing relaxation to be observed as a function of temperature. The advantage of this type of experiment is that the stress state is very well defined, making this a situation where dislocation dynamics can be measured quantitatively. Such studies are motivated by their importance to the microelectronics industry, since the positions of individual dislocations, the density of threading arms, and the motion of dislocations during processing are known to affect device performance. This work was carried out for the system Si1-xGex on Si, with x ranging from about 0.05 to 0.3 (Hull et al., 1989, 1991). Measurements of dislocation velocity as a function of layer parameters are shown in Figure 6–27C. For capped layers, the results supported the diffusive kink pair model of dislocation propagation, and for uncapped layers they showed that propagation is through motion of single kinks.
493
494
F.M. Ross
A
B
C Figure 6–27. Dislocation dynamics in SiGe heterostructures. (A) Image showing the typical dislocation structure in SiGe heterostructures. Plan-view TEM image of a relaxed 300 nm Si/150 nm Si80Ge20/ Si(001) heterostructure. Closely spaced interfacial dislocation pairs are segments of the same dislocation loop at the top and bottom SiGe/Si interfaces. (From Stach et al., © 1998b Courtesy of Cambridge University Press.) (B) 220 g, 3 g weak-beam dark-field micrograph of a threading dislocation segment connecting two interfacial dislocation segments. (From Stach et al., 1998b.) (C) Measured dislocation velocities compared with predictions of the double-kink theory for SiGe layers buried beneath a 300 nm Si cap, as in (A). The Ge concentrations, x, and epilayer thicknesses are given on the graphs while the dislocation velocities are given in Angstrom s−1. The fitting parameter used in the model is half the double-kink nucleation energy, taken as 1.0 eV. (Reprinted with permission from Hull et al., 1991. American Institute of Physics.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
Activation energies and prefactors were measured for dislocation nucleation and propagation. Note that a well calibrated system is necessary if TEM-derived parameters such as activation energy are to be meaningful. In this case, the sample temperature was calibrated using Si regrowth (Section 2.1.1), and finite element analysis was used to determine the conditions under which sample bending could be neglected (Hull and Bean, 1994). The parameters determined in situ were eventually used in a processing model for microelectronic device design (Hull et al., 1989). A similar experimental approach allows other features of the relaxation process to be examined as well. Dislocation nucleation has been studied in SiGe/Si implanted with F (Stach et al., 1998a) and with He, which forms platelets and bubbles (Follstaedt et al., 1997; Hueging et al., 2005). Although most work has been in the SiGe/Si system, a few other epitaxial systems have been studied as well, such as BaTiO3 on SrTiO3 (Sun et al., 2004), ZnSe on GaAs (Lavagne et al., 2001), and Al on Al2O3 (Dehm et al., 2002). Clearly, many other materials systems could yield useful information with this technique. We finally note that dislocation configurations in thin films, such as in Figure 6–27A, are somewhat random. However, in well controlled geometries—relaxed epitaxial islands, or surfaces with modulated stress fields—dislocation locations can be predicted accurately (Liu et al., 2000; Kammler et al., 2005). This suggests opportunities for in situ TEM to provide quantitative information on dislocation nucleation and growth in finite nanostructures with built in strain, such as epitaxial islands or composite wires or ribbons. 5.3 Mechanical Properties of Nanostructures, Thin Films, and Surfaces TEM is particularly appropriate for studying the mechanical properties of small volumes of material. In the work discussed so far, the same stimulus (strain, heat) is applied to the entire specimen. By applying the stimulus to only a small part of the specimen, the correlation between mechanical input and structural response can hopefully be made more precise. In this section we discuss experiments in which small volumes of a specimen are mechanically deformed (nanoindentation), the surface is probed, or nanostructures are deformed. These experiments make use of scanning probe techniques to bring a tip near the sample for controlled deformation of an area under observation. 5.3.1 In Situ Indentation of Thin Films By integrating a nanoindenter into a specimen holder, it is possible to examine localized deformation of single crystals, polycrystalline materials, and layered structures. Nanoindentation holders have been described by Wall and Dahmen (1998), Stach et al. (2001), Minor et al. (2001), Bobji et al. (2003) and Ii et al. (2004). The design must include some way of making sure the indent occurs in an electron transparent region of the specimen. In the design of Wall and Dahmen, for example, a Si sample (mounted vertically) is etched to form a ridge which projects out into the beam. Elastic deformation followed by dislocation
495
496
F.M. Ross
Figure 6–28. Nanoindentation of steel. Series of images of an Fe-C martensite, including a low-angle grain boundary. (a) Before indentation, (b) at 21 nm penetration depth, showing dislocation emission beneath the indenter, (c) at 46 nm penetration depth, showing dislocation pileup at the grain boundary, and (d) at 84 nm penetration depth, demonstrating dislocation emission at the far side of the grain boundary. (From Ohmura et al., ©2004. Courtesy of Institute of Materials Research Society.)
formation is visible in this ridge during indentation. Using this sample geometry, the motion of dislocations and grain boundaries under the indenter tip has been studied in a variety of materials deposited onto the substrate. In ultra fine grained Al, for example, grain boundary motion occurs under the tip (Jin et al., 2004). This does not occur in Al-Mg, suggesting that solute drag is important (Soer et al., 2004). Similarly, in Ni, deformation proceeds by diffusion-controlled grain boundary-mediated processes rather than dislocation motion within grains (Shan et al., 2004). Si shows dislocation plasticity on room temperature nanoindentation (Minor et al., 2005). Nanoindentation of martensitic steel is shown in Figure 6–28 (Ohmura et al., 2004), and the formation of dislocations and the strain transfer across grain boundaries are visible. As well as dislocation formation and motion, nanoindentation can cause crack propagation. The nature and pathway for such cracks can be determined (Ii et al., 2004; Matsunaga et al., 2004). In the future, we expect to see exciting developments in the area of in situ nanoindentation, driven by the incorporation of sensors that allow stress-strain curves to be measured during deformation. This suggests exciting possibilities for quantitative analysis of nanoscale mechanical properties.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
497
5.3.2 Tribology and Nanomanipulation Nanoindentation is only one of several interesting experiments that can be carried out in holders incorporating a scanning tip with piezoelectric actuators. For example, the tip can be used for fundamental studies of tribology by scraping it across a surface. Tip-substrate interactions were observed in reflection mode geometry as a graphite specimen was imaged using STM (Spence et al., 1990; Lo and Spence, 1992), and changes in the surface were attributed to shearing and abrasion. Using a similar holder in a UHV TEM, Naitoh et al. (2000) correlated the atomic configuration at a tip surface with the resolution of STM images it produced. Fujisawa and Kizuka (2003a) and Ohnishi et al. (1998a) observed the motion of a tip across a stepped surface and determined the effects of rastering and surface topography on lateral displacement. This sort of information is naturally important in interpreting scanning probe images. Alternatively, an in situ STM tip can be used to form small necks or grain boundaries by touching it to the surface, deforming both materials (Figure 6–29). The structure of these necks can then be observed at
Figure 6–29. STM surface manipulation. Series of high-resolution images of atomic-scale removal type mechanical processing of an Au surface. A region six atomic columns wide on the fixed side (B) is removed by the Au tip on the mobile side (A). On both sides the beam is parallel to the [110] axis. The time is (a) 0 s, (b) 1.2 s, (c) 3.5 s, and (d) 5.8 s. Boxed circles show the unit cell of Au. These images give a visual impression of events that may occur during STM operation as well as phenomena associated with friction. (From Kizuka et al., © 1998c. Courtesy of Cambridge University Press.)
498
F.M. Ross
high resolution. Kizuka and Hosoki (1999) recorded the interactions as two oxidized Si tips came into contact, observing the strength of the boundaries formed, and Naitoh et al. (2000) observed twins in necks of Si formed between clean Si and a W tip. Most work, however, has involved Au. Kizuka (1998a, b) showed formation of a neck between Au contacts and observed compression, shear, deformation, slip, and twinning. These videos give a stunning visual impression of the interaction of the tip with a surface during scanning, and allow a study of friction at the nanoscale (Fujisawa and Kizuka, 2003b). Naturally, the electrical properties of such necks can also be studied, and this will be described in Section 6. 5.3.3 Mechanical Properties of Nanostructures The mechanical properties of elongated nanostructures are a natural subject for in situ studies. For carbon nanotubes, mechanical parameters such as Young’s modulus were first measured by observing the vibration of tubes which extend out as cantilevers (Krishnan et al., 1998). These tubes vibrate because of coupling to motion in the stage. However, the mechanical properties of tubes can also be measured by bending them with an STM tip. Individual CNTs can be bent and broken (Kuzumaki et al., 2001) and stress and strain can be measured during deformation (Asaka and Kizuka, 2005). The welding of CNTs to a tip can be seen (Hirayama et al., 2001; Kuzumaki et al., 2004). A tip can even be used to operate a bearing made of telescoping CNTs (Cumings and Zettl, 2000; Figure 6–30). Such experiments can use the
Figure 6–30. Mechanical properties of a carbon nanotube. Selected frames of a video recording of the in situ telescoping of a multiwalled nanotube. In the first five frames, the core nanotubes are slowly withdrawn to the right. In the sixth image, which occurred one video frame after the core was released, the core has fully retracted into the outer nanotube housing as a result of the attractive van der Waals force. (Reprinted with permission from Cumings and Zettl, © 2000, AAAS.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
499
Figure 6–31. Mechanical properties of a nanobelt. A ZnO nanobelt at (a) stationary, (b) the first-harmonic resonance in the x direction, frequency 622 kHz, and (c) the first-harmonic resonance in the y direction, frequency 691 kHz. (d) An enlarged image of the nanobelt and its electron diffraction pattern (inset). The projected shape of the nanobelt is apparent. (e) The FWHM of the resonance peak measured from another ZnO nanobelt. The resonance occurs at 230.9 kHz. (Reprinted with permission from Bai et al., © 2003. American Institute of Physics.)
TEM for more than just imaging; for example, Suenaga et al. (2001) were able, using EELS, to probe changes in electronic structure during bending of multiwalled and bundled single walled CNTs, and correlate these changes with deformation. By using a stage with piezo drives to induce an alternating electrical field between a nanowire and an electrode, controlled frequency vibrations can be set up in the nanowire (Wang et al., 2001, 2002a). For example, in ZnO wires of rectangular cross section, each direction of vibration has its own resonances from which the modulus and time constant or Q factor can be derived (Bai et al., 2003a; Figure 6–31). Such measurements of bending modulus can be related to defects in individual structures (Gao et al., 2000). In fact, the mechanical resonance depends so sensitively on the structure that modulus measurements have potential use for measuring small masses. A less quantitative application (at present) is a stage developed for stretching chains of nanoparticles, of interest for their use as reinforcing fillers and their
500
F.M. Ross
presence in diesel exhausts (Suh et al., 2004). It will be exciting to see these mechanical techniques applied to more complex structures such as composite nanowires or filled CNTs. 5.4 Summary Mechanical deformation has been successfully examined in situ using several innovative techniques. The future challenge in mechanical testing is to make its results even more quantitative and to minimize or account for thin foil effects. Customised design of specimens using MEMS technology, integrating for example tensile testers, tweezers, notches, or other structures, will certainly become more widespread for thin film experiments. Measurement of stress-strain curves during nanoindentation will provide accurate information on the mechanical response of a system, for example as single dislocations are introduced. Deposition of a film of interest, perhaps with an engineered boundary, onto a crystalline membrane may become useful in some cases, since the substrate deformation can be measured accurately from its strain contrast. Integration of such experiments with controlled atmosphere TEM will allow materials to be tested under the most realistic conditions. Elegant results on nanostructures have already been achieved using nanomanipulation with a tip. There is no doubt that these types of experiments are already bringing our understanding of the mechanical properties of small volumes of materials to a new level of precision.
6 Correlation of Structural and Electrical Properties of Materials We have shown that fascinating data can result from the correlation between an applied stimulus, such as temperature, environment, or strain, and a microstructural change. Extending this approach, if we measure the electrical properties of a material while also observing or changing its structure, we can investigate structure-electrical property relationships in a unique way. The material under study can have a large volume, perhaps most or all of the TEM sample. Alternatively, structure-property relationships can be derived for individual nanostructures. These interesting experiments all require electrical biasing holders, but not necessarily video rate recording, since the sample itself may change only slowly, or not at all. Examples include measuring the conductivity of individual nanowires as a function of their diameter, measuring changes in resistance as voids form during electromigration, measuring the potential distribution across p-n junctions as a function of bias, or measuring conductivity after dislocations are introduced. 6.1 Electrical Measurements on TEM Samples: Complete Samples as Devices Many important processes can be studied by applying a voltage across a bulk or patterned specimen in situ. We have already described the
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
use of an applied voltage to generate an electric field for ferroelectric switching (Section 4.3), and now consider other possibilities. One interesting example is the measurement of electric fields across p-n junctions. This has been a favorite topic from the early days (Darlington and Valdre, 1975). More recently, a varying bias has been applied in situ across a FIB-prepared p-n junction, using holography to measure the potential distribution (Twitchett et al., 2002, 2004). The eventual aim of such studies is to understand the complex fields within real transistors, although quantitative image matching shows that surface effects must first be understood. Similar biasing experiments can be useful probes of other materials too. For example, the potential distribution across the boundary in a ferroelectric bicrystal was mapped by holography (Johnson and Dravid, 1999, 2000), showing breakdown and the presence of trap states associated with dopants. In situ biasing also allows resistivity to be measured, which can then be correlated with a structural transformation. Thus, the amorphous to crystalline transformation for phase-change memory materials (Section 2.1) can be correlated with resistivity, as shown in Figure 6– 32A (Verheijen et al., 2004). Similarly, phase transformations in TiNi shape memory alloys can be related to resistivity (Ma and Komvopoulos, 2005). Another interesting application of in situ resistivity measurement is the observation of conductivity changes during ion or electron beam irradiation to determine the cross section and threshhold energy for Frenkel pair production (King et al., 1981; Haga et al., 1986). In situ resistivity measurements have also been used to probe the electrical properties of dislocations (Ross et al., 1993). In this experiment, dislocations are formed progressively in a p-n junction diode by heating a metastable SiGe layer (Section 5.2) in situ. Measurement of the diode reverse leakage current as a function of dislocation density yielded the leakage current per length of dislocation, useful in device modeling. In this experiment, however, leakage was measured through the whole device, while dislocation density was measured only in the electron transparent area. Imaging of the whole device would have been more precise. Mathes et al. (2003) were, in fact, able to thin the entire active region of a laser structure by FIB, and observed degradation by dislocation formation during device operation. Such biasing studies could be combined with laser excitation in situ to examine degradation mechanisms and photoplasticity. Current flow through narrow metal lines results in electromigration. Due to its importance and its strong dependence on microstructure, electromigration has been studied intensively in situ (Figure 6–32B). Current is passed through an Al or Cu line patterned onto an oxide substrate, with the aim of observing void formation and dynamics at microstructural features such as grain boundaries and precipitates. There are two important experimental concerns in these experiments. Passivation of the metal surface is known from SEM studies to alter failure lifetimes (Doan et al., 2001); passivating the lines makes the experimental results more relevant to real life, but it is then harder to see void shapes and dynamics. Joule heating in the lines can be another problem (Shih and Green, 1995), especially since elevated temperatures
501
502
A
F.M. Ross
B Figure 6–32. Correlation of resistivity with structure. (A) Video images taken at 15 s time intervals simultaneously displaying the crystallization of an Al–Ge film at 450K and the accompanying drop in electrical resistance (insets). The crystallization front can be seen to proceed from the right- to the left-hand side. (Reprinted with permission from Verheijen et al., © 2004. American Institute of Physics.) (B) Evolution of a 300 nm wide Al (0.5 wt% Cu) interconnect line, 400 nm thick and 150 mm long on a 20 nm TiN underlayer. Lines are deposited on a SiN/SiO2 bilayer membrane to minimise changes in the stress state on heating. 100 nm oxide passivation is added, and the lines are then annealed to form the bamboo structure (i.e., all grain boundaries run perpendicularly across the line). In situ stressing is carried out at 320ºC and a current density of 2 × 106 Acm−2, for (a) 3.5, (b) 4.0, (c) 4.1, (d) 4.5, (e) 4.6 and (f) 5.5 hours. (Reprinted with permission from Lau et al., © 1998 by the American Physical Society.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
and current densities above 106 Acm-2 are used for accelerated testing, so in some experiments, on-chip heat sink structures are integrated into the samples (Prybyla et al., 1998). These studies show that electromigration-induced voids nucleate well before complete failure of the lines (Riege et al., 1996), and void dynamics depend on the local grain boundary structure. The failure mechanism depends on temperature, since at high temperature voids unpin from grain boundaries while at lower temperatures they grow at their nucleation site (Prybyla et al., 1998). Interestingly, when TiN barrier layers are present, voids do not migrate, presumably due to changes in surface diffusion (Lau et al., 2000). Even thin oxide films alter electromigration kinetics. Surface diffusion is in fact the dominant failure mechanism if grain boundary motion is hindered (Vook, 1994; Chang and Vook, 1995). Since a thick passivation layer may be essential for meaningful results, in some studies the sample is mounted vertically and imaged in cross section at high voltage (Okabayashi et al., 1996; H. Mori et al., 1997). Such experiments show mass transport through Al and TiN layers, as well as vertical void and whisker growth. The measurement of local strain by CBED during electromigration (Nucci et al., 2005) is an exciting recent development that promises to relate these in situ results more closely to models. 6.2 Electrical Measurements on Individual Nanostructures The experiments described above, where electrical biasing is applied to a relatively large volume of the specimen, probe several important phenomena. At the nanoscale, equally interesting information is provided by biasing individual nanostructures using STM technology. Commercial TEM/STM holders are in fact becoming increasingly common for both electrical and mechanical applications (www. nanofactory.com, www.gatan.com). As with the mechanical experiments in Sections 5.3.2 and 5.3.3, carbon nanotubes and Au wires are favored for electrical studies. We firstly discuss CNTs. One can bias a tip on which a tube has been placed or grown, or equivalently bias the tip and approach a tube on the substrate. This allows observation of the electric field distribution at the tip of a biased tube (Cumings et al., 2002), and structural changes during field emission (Wang et al., 2002b; Kuzumaki et al., 2004; Jin et al., 2005). The work function of CNTs can be measured and related to structure (Gao et al., 2001; Bai et al., 2003b; Xu et al., 2005a, b) and CNT growth can be observed in the gap between a biased tip and the substrate (Yamashita et al., 1999). If an individual tube is contacted, its conductivity can of course be measured. Kociak et al. (2002) were even able to correlate the chiral indices of double walled tubes, measured using diffraction, with their transport properties (Figure 6–33). Conductivity measurements show that CNTs are ballistic conductors at room temperature (Poncharal et al., 2002), and that the telescoping multiwalled CNTs mentioned in Section 5.3.3 behave as near-ideal rheostats (Cumings and Zettl, 2004).
503
504
F.M. Ross
Structural changes taking place during current transport have also been observed (Huang et al., 2005). The other common material for electrical studies is Au. When thin wires are formed by touching Au tips to a substrate and then pulling away, the conductance can be measured and correlated with the structure. Figure 6–34 demonstrates quantized conductance through single and double Au chains (Ohnishi et al., 1998b). Single chains in fact show a metal-insulator transition (Kizuka et al., 2001a). Conductance and structure change together, showing the dynamic nature of the system (Kizuka et al., 2001b; Oshima et al., 2003c). Catalytically grown nanowires (Section 3.6) provide another interesting subject for study. Although Larsson et al. (2004) measured the conductivity of GaAs nanowires, nanowire electrical properties have generally not been examined in as much detail as Au wires or CNTs. For any nanostructure studied in situ, the nature of the contact, for example how the STM tip is cleaned, is important in ensuring that the measurements relate to the structure rather than the contact. A drop of Hg can be used (Poncharal et al., 1999; Wang et al., 2001; Kociak et al., 2002) to measure properties like work function and quantum conductance, but there are still real issues in creating ohmic contacts to nanostructures (Larsson et al., 2004) which must be solved before extending these experiments to a wider range of materials systems.
Figure 6–33. Simultaneous structure analysis and measurement of transport properties for a double-walled nanotube (DWNT). (A) Experimental diffraction pattern of a DWNT. The iris-like ring is an artifact. Note the layered line structure of the diffraction pattern. The white arrow indicates the equatorial line, and the gray ones indicate some other intensity lines. (B) Current-voltage characteristic of the same tube. Ohmic behavior is visible up to 0.5 V. Insets: Diffraction geometry. The upper inset shows the electron beam oriented along X with (X′, Y′, Z′) the frame of reference of the MWNT. The diffraction pattern is recorded in the YZ plane. In the lower inset, a carbon atom (gray dot) is characterized by a translation distance Zfo and a rotation angle Φfo with respect to the tube axis. (Reprinted with permission from Kociak et al., © 2002 by the American Physical Society.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Figure 6–34. Electrical properties of nanowires. Quantized conductance of a single and a double strand of gold atoms prepared by contacting an Au surface with an STM tip in a UHV TEM. (a) Conductance change of the contact while withdrawing the tip. Conductance is shown in units of G 0 = 2e2/h = (13kΩ)−1. (b) Electron microscope images of gold bridges obtained simultaneously with the conductance measurements in (a). Left, bridge at step A; right, bridge at step B. The bridge at step A has two rows of atoms; the bridge at step B has only one row of atoms. The distance from P to Q [(see (b)] is about 0.89 nm, wide enough to have two gold atoms in a bridge if the gold atoms have the nearest-neighbor spacing of the bulk crystal (0.288 nm). (From Ohnishi et al., © 1998. Courtesy of Nature/NPG.)
A
B
6.3 Outlook In situ electrical experiments have touched a range of phenomena, providing detailed and unique information on both bulk and nanoscale materials. With nanostructured materials appearing in more and more electronic applications, we anticipate increased demand for the sort of information that only these experiments can provide. We also anticipate that other properties may be amenable to an analogous approach. Perhaps nanoscale optical response could be studied by feeding a laser beam into the sample area, or thermoelectric properties could be measured in nanoscale structures. No doubt equally fascinating behavior would be revealed.
7 Liquid Phase Processes We now consider another unusual application of in situ TEM: studying the important class of processes that takes place in the liquid phase. For the vapor phase crystal growth and surface reaction processes of Section 3, real time observations clearly improved our understanding of nanostructure formation and thin film growth. Is it possible to carry out the same sort of quantitative studies for crystal growth from the liquid phase, or study other liquid processes? The answer, perhaps surprisingly, is yes, and the presence of a liquid is not incompatible with the vacuum requirements of the TEM. In this section we describe several studies involving liquids, which range from electrochemical deposition to the hydration of minerals and the growth of polymers.
505
506
F.M. Ross
In Sections 2.1 and 2.3 we presented examples of experiments involving melting and crystallization. These succeeded in the TEM either because the liquid was naturally trapped as an inclusion in a solid matrix, or because it had a low vapor pressure. Studies of vapor-liquidsolid growth (Section 3.6) also succeeded because of the low vapor pressure of the eutectic. For example, the vapor pressure above the Si-Au droplets in Figure 6–18 is only 10−10 Torr at the growth temperature. But for liquids with higher vapor pressure, most importantly water, TEM can present some challenges. The liquid must be artificially encapsulated or differentially pumped to keep the pressure at the gun low enough for operation. Thus it is necessary either to use a special “window cell,” in which the liquid is hermetically sealed between electron transparent membranes (windows), or to modify the microscope to increase pumping to the specimen area. Both approaches have advantages and disadvantages. If a hermetically sealed cell is used, the windows cause undesirable background in the images. Furthermore, since the liquid scatters just as strongly as a solid, it must be confined within a short path length. Either it must be present as a thin film covering a solid support, or (if it is to fill the cell) the windows must be very close together, which can be an engineering challenge. Even for thin liquid films on a solid support, the window separation should be minimized, as a long path length of vapor above the liquid leads to undesirable electron-gas interactions, especially for water vapor (Shah, 2004). Window cells are complex and do not usually allow heating or two-axis tilting, although, as we will see below, electrical connections are possible. In spite of the experimental limitations, a hermetically sealed cell can allow liquidcovered specimens to be examined in a close to natural state, or can be used to maintain a solvent-rich atmosphere. In the alternative approach, no windows are used, but instead additional apertures are incorporated into the TEM and the pumping in the specimen area is modified to maintain a high pressure at the sample while leaving the rest of the column at low pressure. Microscopes with differential pumping have already been described in the context of gas phase reactions, but they can also be used to observe samples on which a liquid is present. The liquid can be introduced by injecting it through a valve. This approach requires a dedicated microscope, but has the potential to provide higher resolution images than are possible using window cells, and is also compatible with conventional heating, cooling, and tilting holders. Several studies involving liquids have overcome the experimental challenges described above and have yielded useful and unique information. Liquid phase TEM is still uncommon, however, and this is an area offering many opportunities. 7.1 Imaging in a Saturated Environment or Under a Liquid Film Window cells or differentially pumped microscopes have been used in studies of a range of phenomena including hydration and dehydration of minerals, the growth of nanostructures, and the action of cata-
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
lysts. Early work was carried out using window cells to provide a water saturated atmosphere, for example in studying the hydration of Portland cement (see Butler and Hale, 1981, for a review). The use of high voltage microscopes meant that the window separation was not too critical. Since then, several groups have used window cells to image biological and non-biological samples. Such cells are often based on the design of Fukami et al. (1991). The windows consist of 20 nm amorphous C membranes attached over a perforated metal disc. This material can withstand a pressure differential of 250 Torr and does not produce much background in the images. Imaging in an atmosphere of ∼100 Torr air saturated with water vapor allowed Sugi et al. (1997) to examine an interesting biological mechanism: the movement of the myosin head in living muscle filaments. It also allowed Daulton et al. (2001) to determine the oxidation state of Cr in particles produced by an important Cr-reducing bacterium. Use of a window cell for biological materials avoids cryofixation with its attendant artifacts, so that for example bacterial cells do not burst, although beam damage still occurs at high doses. By injecting liquid droplets into a window cell, Foo et al. (2001) and Chiou et al. (2002) examined the arrangement and shape of small particles suspended in solvent, such as fume silica, smectite, and Au modified with DNA. Use of the window cell avoided the problem of agglomeration which usually occurs on evaporation. Although not strictly in situ experiments, this work illustrates the possibilities for examining liquid phase dynamics of small particles. As mentioned above, the use of a differentially pumped electron microscope allows for greater flexibility in the sample holder during liquid experiments. This approach has been successful for examining melting of Xe films (Zerrouk et al., 1994), liquid phase synthesis of Au nanorods (Gai and Harmer, 2002), and several important catalytic reactions, including the sequence used to form nylon (Gai, 2002b). The first reaction in this sequence, shown in Figure 6–35, was observed by injecting the precursor, in a methanol solvent, over a metal/TiO2 catalyst specimen, while simultaneously heating the catalyst and flowing hydrogen; the second reaction was observed at a higher temperature on introduction of adipic acid. Since many commercial polymerization reactions take place from solution, these types of experiments can have significant impact on the development of industrial processes, in the same way that gas phase experiments have supported industrial development of gas reaction catalysts. Recently, imaging in an environment of varying relative humidity using differential pumping and a cooling stage has allowed the deliquescence of salt and aerosol particles to be correlated with their structure and composition (Wise et al., 2005). The importance of these particles in the Earth’s atmosphere makes this an urgent area for further investigation. 7.2 Electrochemical Deposition Electrochemical deposition is an important crystal growth process which takes place from the liquid phase. Among its many applications
507
508
F.M. Ross
Figure 6–35. A liquid phase reaction in situ. The hydrogenation of adiponitrile (ADN) forms hexamethylene diamine (HMD), an important material since it in turn is reacted with adipic acid and polymerized to produce nylon 6,6. The ADN to HMD reaction is carried out with ADN in a methanol solvent under gaseous hydrogen over a metallic catalyst. (a) High-resolution image of the catalyst, nanoclusters of Co–Ru (arrowed, c) over rutile titania support (with larger grains, u), at RT. (b) After immersion in adiponitrile in solvent and H2 gas, at RT. (c) The formation of layers of the product HMD at 31°C. The width is indicated by double arrows. (d) Thicker layers form at 81°C (arrowed) after 3 min. (S with dots indicated the original catalyst profile.) (From Gai, 2002. Courtesy of Cambridge Univesity Press.)
is the formation of the copper interconnects in integrated circuits, and a detailed understanding of nucleation and growth is important in optimizing this process. In order to study electrochemical deposition, not only must imaging be carried out in a stable liquid environment, but it must also be done under electrochemical control. Thus the experiment uses a window cell, as described above, with electrical connections, as discussed in Section 6.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
The electrochemical window cell (Williamson et al., 2003; Radisic et al., 2006) includes three electrodes connected externally to a potentiostat, allowing the same degree of control as a standard electrochemical cell. The entire volume between the windows is filled with the electrolyte, and the current passes between the working and counter electrodes through this liquid. The working electrode, on which the material of interest is deposited, is patterned over one of the windows. The counter electrode and reference electrodes are thin wires extending into the liquid reservoir. Since the cell volume is completely filled, unlike the experiments described above, it is particularly important to restrict the window spacing to below 1–2 µm to minimize multiple scattering. An imaging filter may be used to improve the contrast. Typical results, given in Figure 6–36, show the nucleation and growth of copper clusters on a gold electrode in real time, with simultaneous measurement of the voltage applied and the current flowing in the cell. If care is taken to verify that the behavior of the small area of electrode under observation is typical of the entire electrode, and that the small volume cell behaves like a standard electrochemical cell, quantitative data on individual clusters can be compared with electrochemical models. In the experiment shown here, conventional electrochemical models could not explain the nucleation density and growth rates observed. Conventional models include only direct attachment of copper ions onto existing clusters, and to explain the results it was necessary to modify these models to include a parallel pathway, direct attachment of Cu onto the electrode followed by surface diffusion to clusters (Radisic et al., 2006). Although complex, the electrochemical liquid cell developed here may be adapted for a variety of electrochemical growth and corrosion processes. In the future, this type of experiment could be enhanced by combining the cell with microfluidics technology to allow flowing rather than stationary liquid, and to enable controlled mixing or heating of liquids.
7.3 Outlook Dynamic processes which take place in liquids and at liquid/solid interfaces have great importance across broad areas of science and technology. The results described in this section show that processes involving water or other liquids may indeed be observed in real time and with reasonable spatial resolution in situ, providing information which is difficult to obtain using techniques such as scanning probe microscopy or SEM. Further experiments could improve our understanding of, for example, changes in electrode surfaces during battery charging or underwater corrosion of metals such as steel. We anticipate that future liquid studies in the TEM will provide important information relevant to microelectronics fabrication, catalyst design, and certain biological processes, making this a key area of in situ TEM for further development.
509
510
F.M. Ross
Figure 6–36. Electrochemical deposition of copper. Deposition was carried out in situ onto a gold electrode from acidified CuSO4 solution. First a reverse potential was applied for 2 seconds to clean the electrode, then deposition was carried out at a constant potential of −0.07 V, measured with respect to a Cu reference electrode. The upper graph shows the current flowing through the TEM cell. After a sharp transient, the current curve shows a characteristic maximum (−0.26 µA after 1.5 seconds in this case) which can be fitted with a model of cluster nucleation and growth. The images provide a direct view of cluster evolution on part of the electrode, with Cu appearing dark. The lower graph shows the growth of a single cluster (radius vs. time) compared with the prediction of two models. The growth rate is much slower than predicted, and the cluster density much higher, suggesting that the models needs to be modified by the inclusion of surface diffusion effects. (From Radisic et al., © 2006 with permission of the American Chemical Society.)
8 Ion and Electron Beam-Induced Processes Ion and electron beams have multiple effects on a specimen, depending on the material, and atomic displacements, implantation of atoms, or ionization may all be seen during in situ experiments. Irradiation
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
effects are certainly worthy of study both as basic and applied science, and are of interest far beyond simply understanding TEM artifacts. Historically, irradiation damage by ions, electrons, or both simultaneously was studied in situ in attempts to model neutron damage in the context of nuclear electric power generation and the development of host materials for long term nuclear waste storage. The high dose rates possible make TEM useful for accelerated experiments, and irradiation-induced defects and the effects of irradiation on phase equilibria and electrical and mechanical properties were studied. However, several other areas have recently become interesting. These include materials processing (ion beam assisted deposition, ion beam modification of interfaces, and ion implantation for microelectronics processing), development of semiconductor devices for aerospace applications, photoplasticity, and the study of radiation damage in minerals in order to improve the dating of radioisotope-bearing minerals. A recent review can be found in Birtcher et al. (2005). 8.1 Electron Beam-Induced Phenomena In this section we discuss several effects of the electron beam on the specimen. Electron beam effects may be obvious, such as heating that induces or accelerates phase transformations, or more subtle, such as an increased point defect concentration that may affect deformation. Beam effects must of course be considered when interpreting any TEM observation, but can also be used to probe defect dynamics or growth processes. 8.1.1 Interaction with the Atmosphere Above the Specimen As discussed in Section 3.4, the interaction of the electron beam with the column atmosphere produces a plasma in which structures such as fullerenes can grow, or certain components of oxides can be etched. Water vapor has a particularly strong interaction with the beam, as mentioned in Section 7. Beam-atmosphere interactions must be considered when using a microscope without a controlled environment, because they can lead to uncontrolled effects. But even when the environment is controlled, interactions will of course still occur. For example, in the hydrogen embrittlement studies described in Section 5.1, the electron beam significantly increases the “fugacity” (an effective partial pressure) of the hydrogen (Bond et al., 1986). Beam effects in a reactive atmosphere can be used to advantage for deposition. For example, tungsten can be deposited via electron beam stimulated decomposition of W(CO) 6 (Furuya et al., 2003) to grow structures such as that shown in Figure 6–37. Similarly, iron can be deposited from Fe(CO) 5 (Tanaka et al., 2005; Takeguchi et al., 2005). Three dimensional structures may even be formed using a programmed STEM (Shimojo et al., 2004). 8.1.2 Formation and Dynamics of Point Defects Once the beam hits the sample it creates point defects, and both point defect motion and the dynamics of phenomena induced by point defects can be examined in situ. In general, individual point defects are
511
512
F.M. Ross
difficult to see. However, if the specimen is thin and has a well-defined structure, such as a carbon nanotube, it may be possible to image point defects directly. Thus, point defects caused by irradiating graphene sheets may be imaged at high resolution (Hashimoto et al., 2004), and individual vacancy-interstitial pairs can be observed in double walled CNTs (Urita et al., 2005). Their relaxation can be measured, as can the defect-induced migration of metal atoms (Urita et al., 2004). When point defects cluster into extended defects, the extended defect dynamics can be measured to obtain indirect information about the point defects such as their diffusion parameters. The fundamentals of point defect motion have been studied in many materials in this way using high voltage microscopy and are reviewed by Kiritani (1999). For example, by measuring the growth and shrinking of interstitial loops during intermittent irradiation, it is possible to obtain activation energies for vacancy migration and self diffusion (Arai et al., 1995). The density of point defects can be measured by examining the formation of jogs in dislocation loops (Arakawa et al., 2000) while their diffusion parameters can be measured by examining extended defect dynamics far from the irradiated area (Arai et al., 2004). Loop growth and shrinkage can even be used to investigate defects produced by ex situ neutron irradiation (Horiki et al., 1998; M.A. Kirk et al., 1999). Extended defect dynamics also provides information on interactions between point defects and extended defects. In Cu, irradiation causes growth of stacking fault tetrahedra, and an analysis of size fluctuations showed that growth is by ledge motion after capture of defects (Arakawa et al., 2002). In Si, irradiation forms interstitial clusters, and Fedina et al. (1998) and Vanhellemont et al. (1995) observed their structure and formation kinetics (Figure 6–38). Strain fields influence point
Figure 6–37. Fabrication of nanostructures by beam-vapor interaction. Nanoscale fabrication carried out on a carbon grid, using a JEM 2500SE STEM operated at 200 kV with a beam size of 0.8 nm and a beam current of 0.5 nA. W(CO) 6 gas was used at a flux of approximately 2 × 10−4 Pa L s−1. A line across a hole was produced followed by fabrication of a circle. (From Shimojo et al., 2004; with kind permission of Blackwell Publishing, Ltd., Oxford, U.K.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
Figure 6–38. Irradiation damage. High-resolution electron micrograph image of point defect aggregates created in Si during electron irradiation at room temperature. Irradiation was carried out at 400 kV and 1020 electrons cm−2 s−1 for 35 min. The {113} and {111} defects are marked with single and double arrows, respectively. (From Fedina et al., 1998 with kind permission of Taylor and Francis Ltd.)
defect clustering (Vanhellemont et al., 1995; Fedina et al., 1997), so presumably clustering could be used to measure strain locally. However, imaging of defect clusters can be challenging and special weak beam imaging techniques may be necessary (M.A. Kirk et al., 1999). High voltage electron irradiation can be used to move atoms, say from the surface into the bulk of a substrate, via elastic collisions of the electrons with the heavy atoms. Systems studied include Au implanted into Si (Mori et al., 1992), Hf into SiC (Yasuda et al., 1992), and Au into Al (Lee et al., 2002b), which forms Al2Au phases that move downstream. These experiments are useful in studying the phenomena taking place during ion beam processing. 8.1.3 Beam-Induced Phase Transformations, Surface Reactions and Growth We have seen examples throughout this chapter where the beam has induced a phase transformation or caused a growth process. To understand these phenomena it is important to separate heating effects from those caused by knock-on damage or electronic excitations. This may require detailed hot stage measurements. Amorphization is the most commonly observed beam-induced transformation, taking place for example in SiC (Inui et al., 1992), Si (Takeda and Yamasaki, 1999) and GaAs (Yasuda and Mori, 1999). In InGaN, beam-induced amorphization looks just like compositional fluctuations (Smeeton et al., 2003) which may of course cause problems in image interpretation. Interestingly, in Zr2Ni and Zr3Al, the amorphization kinetics are changed by the presence of hydrogen (Tappin et al., 1995), which alters the stability of the defective structure. Thus the microscope atmosphere should be considered in these transformations as well. The reverse process of beam-induced recrystallization also
513
514
F.M. Ross
occurs, for example in semiconductors (e.g., Jencic et al., 1995). It may be seen at voltages below those required to create point defects, and may be caused by the formation of dangling bonds at the crystalline/ amorphous interface. Other beam effects include phase separation and the formation of non-equilibrium phases (Section 2). For example, in borosilicate glasses, which have applications in nuclear waste storage, B-rich phases separate under the beam (K. Sun et al., 2005). Beam-induced growth processes have interesting applications in nanofabrication. Apart from the beam-induced deposition described in Section 8.1.1, nanostructures can be built by defect generation in suitable substrates (see Section 3.4 for C examples) and wires can be formed by beam-enhanced surface diffusion (see Section 3.1 for an Au example). Nanostructured material can also be formed by beam-induced decomposition. This has been examined particularly in SiO2, where a combination of sputtering and desorption produces Si rich regions (Fujita et al., 1996; Chen et al., 1998; Du et al., 2003; Furuya et al., 2003). Beaminduced decomposition occurs in many materials (Al2O3, MgO, AlF, etc.) and may proceed from either or both surfaces. Several processes are active, including interactions with the atmosphere, changes in surface diffusion (Mera et al., 2003) and surface roughening (Grozea et al., 1997). If the beam is finely focused, such as in a STEM, hole drilling may occur (e.g., Berger et al., 1987; Walsh, 1989; Kizuka and Tanaka, 1997a, b), another possible method of fabricating nanostructures. 8.1.4 Radiation-Enhanced Dislocation Motion In many materials, the electron beam influences dislocation motion. Radiation-enhanced dislocation glide during heating or straining has been studied quantitatively by recording the motion of individual dislocations (Figure 6–39). Such measurements suggest a mechanism based on an enhancement in the creation rate of kink pairs, due to energy that is released by nonradiative recombination of electron-hole pairs at electronic levels associated with dislocations (Levade et al., 1994; Werner et al., 1995; Yonenaga et al., 1999; Vanderschaeve et al., 2000, 2001; Maeda et al., 2000). The radiation-enhanced motion of individual kinks can actually be observed directly in plan view (Inoue et al., 1998). A radiation-enhanced climb process can also occur, due to absorption of interstitials by dislocations (Yonenaga et al., 1998). These studies are important in interpreting in situ deformation experiments, but also have a close relationship to the phenomenon of photoplasticity which is relevant to optoelectronic device degradation. 8.2 Ion Implantation It is possible to irradiate a sample with ions while simultaneously imaging or irradiating it with electrons. This area of research requires complex, expensive instruments with tandem accelerators. However, because of the importance of the results, such equipment has been funded by several institutions around the world. A discussion of the microscopes capable of simultaneous ion and electron irradiation can be found in Allen and Ryan (1998) and some of the research has been summarized by Ruault et al. (2005). Our understanding of sputtering, ion
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
Figure 6–39. Radiation-induced dislocation glide. Velocity of dislocations in ZnS of different types per unit length, plotted as a function of electron beam intensity. Velocities were measured during in situ straining at 40±10 MPa and 390K. The motion remains slow suggesting that the Peierls mechanism still controls motion, and velocity is proportional to dislocation length showing that kinks form individually and do not collide. The linear regime at low intensity suggests a change (reduction) in apparent activation energy due to nonradiative recombination of carriers at dislocations, assisting kink formation. At high intensities the recombination rate saturates. (From Levade et al., 1994 with kind permission of Taylor and Francis Ltd.)
implantation, and materials processing, for example by impurity doping, may be developed using tandem microscopes. However, the driving force for these microscopes is a need to understand the effects of radiation on materials which may be used in reactor walls or for storage of radioactive waste. Simultaneous ion and electron irradiation simulates the defect types and concentrations created by irradiation with high energy neutrons from nuclear reactions. Neutrons induce displacement damage and cause the formation of helium as a byproduct. The helium forms bubbles and causes swelling, embrittlement, and radiationinduced segregation, and phase stability may change as a result. Because of their industrial importance, many irradiation studies have been carried out in steels. These include determining the stability of different phases after Xe irradiation (Chu et al., 2002) and measuring parameters of the motion of bubbles formed by He implantation (Ono et al., 2002). Quantitative studies provide information on the key defect formation and diffusion processes taking place. For example, in Cu, the kinetics of displacement collision cascade formation and the recombination of point defects into clusters were measured using Kr irradiation (Daulton et al., 2000), while in Si, irradiation with Si shrinks the bubbles caused by H implantation (Ruault et al., 2002). Bubble motion has been studied in most detail in a simple system, however. This model system consists of insoluble noble gases such as Ar, Ne, or Xe implanted into an Al or similar matrix, forming small precipitates (Figure 6–40A). Implantation can be carried out ex situ (Birtcher et al.,
515
516
F.M. Ross
A
B Figure 6–40. Dynamics of Xe precipitates. (A) Motion and coalescence of two isolated crystalline Xe preciptitates (Xe implanted ex situ) during continuous 1 MeV electron irradiation at room temperature. The irradiation causes a damage rate in Al of approximately 3.9 × 10−2 displacements per atom (dpa) per second. Measured from the first image, the elapsed times at which video frames were recorded are (a) 0, (b) 101, (c) 418, (d) 549, (e) 550, (f) 551, (g) 561, (h) 584, and (i) 727 s. Traces of crystallographic planes are indicated in frame (a). Analysis of such data shows that surface diffusion of Al is responsible for motion and shape changes, while the Xe deforms by shear in response to the reshaping of its cavity. Since the total volume, not the surface area, was conserved during coalescence, cavity pressure depends on the gas structure and not just the interface structure. (Reprinted with permission from Birtcher et al., © 1999 by the American Physical Society.) (B) Mean square displacement of a Xe precipitate containing approximately 38 Xe atoms (in a volume equivalent to that of approximately 128 Al atoms), as a function of damage in the Al matrix under 1 MeV electron irradiation. The precipitate moves because of Al jumps on its surface, and these data yield values for the diffusivity and an average jump frequency of about 5600 jumps/dpa. (Reprinted with permission from Allen et al., © 1999. American Institute of Physics.)
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
1999; Allen et al., 1999; Ono et al., 2002) or in situ (Song et al., 2002), so that the coalescence of defects to form the precipitates can be studied as a function of dose. Striking dynamic changes occur in these precipitates under 1 MeV electron irradiation (Birtcher et al., 1999; Allen et al., 1999) or on heating (Ono et al., 2002): migration, shape changes, faulting, melting, crystallization, and coalescence. The shape, nature, and motion of the enclosed phase provide information on interface energies, structure, and diffusion pathways (Donnelly et al., 2002; Allen et al., 2003; Figure 6–40B). We conclude with a related but lower voltage ion irradiation project: the integration of a 20 kV focused ion beam into a TEM (M. Tanaka et al., 1998; Gnauck et al., 1998). This tandem microscope allows the damage produced by the FIB to be observed directly, which is useful for understanding artifacts and low voltage damage effects. It also allows sample thinning to be carried out in situ so that the area imaged has not been exposed to the air. Studies of focused ion beam damage are increasingly important since the FIB is used for materials processing, surface patterning, growth, and fabrication of nanostructures.
9 Outlook In this chapter we have attempted to show some of the outstanding recent results achieved using in situ microscopy and to illustrate the huge variety of experiments possible. In spite of experimental complexity, many successful and informative experiments have mimicked the real world inside the microscope column. It has become clear that there is no one “in situ microscope.” Interesting experiments can be done in conventional machines, using standard holders, just by heating the sample with the electron beam. More complex experiments can be carried out by purchasing commercial in situ holders (heating, cooling, straining) or by developing customized ones (nanoindenters, electrical biasing holders, window cells). Many experiments also require the ability to measure some property of the sample, such as resistivity, simultaneously with imaging its structure. The most complex in situ experiments take place in expensive microscopes which are modified to achieve a controlled specimen environment or are designed for UHV. This is an exciting time for in situ microscopy. Specimen design is developing rapidly with innovative use of FIB preparation or integration of thin film specimens into micromachined substrates. Furthermore, as we have emphasized throughout this chapter, the increased interest in nanostructures fits perfectly with the ability of TEM to analyze small volumes of material with minimal sample preparation. Apart from thin foil effects and beam-induced artifacts, the main limitation of in situ microscopy has been the small space available in the polepiece. In the future this problem too will be solved by the ongoing developments in aberration correction. Corrected microscopes have an increased polepiece gap for the same resolution. The extra space will help experiments requiring combined stimuli (heating and irradiation,
517
518
F.M. Ross
straining in a gas environment, simultaneous E and B fields) or new stimuli (lasers, micromanipulators, microfluidics). An increased polepiece gap will also improve calibration of the sample environment. It is hard to overemphasize the importance of this for quantitative results. For example, one could include a fiber optic coupled to a radiation thermometer (Isshiki et al., 1998), a thickness monitor for growth experiments, a pressure gauge, or MEMS-based sensors. Aberration correction would also allow low voltage microscopes to achieve a resolution comparable with today’s high voltage microscopes. This will reduce beam damage, although sample thickness, or more generally sample design, will remain a constraint to decreasing the voltage. However, there are many areas where in situ techniques could be extended even without aberration correction. Relatively few in situ experiments have used analytical techniques, such as energy filtered imaging or EELS, to examine time-resolved chemical changes. This is probably because rapid acquisition limits the signal to noise ratio. Thus, the ongoing improvements in detectors are promising for in situ analytical studies. Similarly, convergent beam electron diffraction has not been widely used in situ, but could give useful information on changes in local strain. And other advanced TEM techniques such as tomography, holography, or imaging of amorphous materials could also be used in situ, providing the phenomenon of interest is slow enough to make image acquisition feasible. High speed imaging, discussed elsewhere in this book, will of course open a new set of phenomena for study. And in terms of data collection and analysis, direct storage of images and videos on disc is improving the searchability of data, although most data collection still leaves something to be desired in terms of usability. Intelligent analysis of video data, such as object detection and tracking, is currently a limitation, as custom software often has to be developed for each experiment. A final comment arises from the complexity of controlled environment in situ microscopes, which has increased since the development of the first such TEM by Poppa (1965). Although some processes, such as sample heating, must take place in the polepiece, it is an advantage to keep others out of the polepiece though still in the same vacuum system. Examples include ion guns or deposition tools such as evaporators. Moving some capabilities ex situ, but within the same vacuum system, improves the reliability of complex microscope systems and provides a more flexible approach to experiments, especially in a multiuser environment where time is a constraint. The field of in situ transmission electron microscopy has advanced tremendously since its beginning in the 1960s. We anticipate even more exciting results over the next few decades.
Acknowledgments. I would like to acknowledge the inspirational scientists with whom I have had the pleasure of working. In particular, my Ph.D. advisor the late Mike Stobbs, who emphasized quantitative information from TEM; my colleagues Murray Gibson, Robert Hull, Uli Dahmen, and Ruud Tromp; and Mike McDonald, Mark Reuter, and
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy
Arthur Ellis, whose outstanding technical help made out in situ experiments possible. I would like to acknowledge the support of IBM’s T.J. Watson Research Center with its far sighted view of basic research. I would also like to thank my husband and baby daughter, without whom writing this chapter would have been much easier. References Abe, H., Yamamoto, S. and Miyashita, A. (2002). J. Electron Microsc. 51 (Supplement), S183–187. Allen, C.W. and Ryan, E.A. (1998). Microsc. Res. Tech. 42, 255–259. Allen, C.W., Birtcher, R.C., Donnelly, S.E., Furuya, K., Ishikawa, N. and Song, M. (1999). App. Phys. Lett. 74, 2611–2613. Allen, C.W., Birtcher, R.C., Donnelly, S.E., Song, M., Mitsuishi, K., Furuya, K. and Dahmen, U. (2003). Philos. Mag. Lett. 83, 57–64. Aoki, K., Minoda, H., Tanishiro, Y. and Yagi, K. (1998). Surface Rev. Lett. 5, 653–663. Arai, S., Morita, C., Arakawa, K. and Kiritani, M. (1995). J. Electron Microsc. 44, 1–7. Arai, S., Tsukimoto, S., Muto, S. and Saka, H. (2000). Micros. Microanal. 6, 358–361. Arai, S., Tsukimoto, S. and Saka, H. (2003). J. Electron Microsc. 52, 79–84. Arai, S., Satoh, Y., Arakawa, K., Morita, C. and Kiritani, M. (2004). J. Electron Microsc. 53, 21–27. Arakawa, K., Satoh, Y., Arai, S. and Kiritani, M. (2000). Philos. Mag. A 80, 2041–2055. Arakawa, A., Arai, S., Orihara, H., Ono, K. and Kiritani, M. (2002). J. Electron Microsc. 51 (Suppl), S225–229. Asaka, K. and Kizuka, T. (2005). Phys. Rev. B 72, 115431. Bai, X.D., Gao, P.X., Wang, Z.L. and Wang, E.G. (2003). App. Phys. Lett. 82, 4806–4808. Bai, X.D., Wang, E.G., Gao, P.X. and Wang, Z.L. (2003b). Nano Lett. 3, 1147–1150. Balk, T.J., Dehm, G. and Arzt, E. (2003). Acta Mat. 51, 4471–4485. Banhart, F. (1997). J. App. Physi. 81, 3440–3445. Banhart, F. (1999). Rep. Prog. Phys. 62, 1181–1221. Banhart, F., Hermandez, E. and Terrones, M. (2003). Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 185502/1–4. Barre, S., Mutka, H., Roucau, C., Litzler, A., Schneck, J., Toledano, J.C., Bouffard, S. and Rullier-Albenque, F. (1991). Phys. Rev. B 43, 11154–11161. Bartsch, M., Schall, P., Feuerbacher, M. and Messerschmidt, U. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1814–1824. Baufeld, B., Baither, D., Messerschmidt, U., Bartsch, M., Foitzik, A.H. and Ruhle, M. (1997). J. Amer. Ceramic Soc. 80, 1699–1705. Bengu, E. and Marks, L.D. (2001). Phy. Rev. Lett. 86, 2385–2387. Benson, W.E. and Howe, J.M. (1997). Philos. Mag. A 75, 1641–1663. Berger, S.D., Salisbury, I.G., Milne, R.H., Imeson, D. and Humphreys, C.J. (1987). Philos. Mag. B 55, 341–358. Bhattacharya, P., Bhattacharya, V. and Chattopadhyay, K. (1999). J. Electron Microsc. 48 (Supplement), S1047–1054. Birtcher, R.C., Donnelly, S.E., Song, M., Furuya, K., Mitsuishi, K. and Allen, C.W. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 1617–1620. Birtcher, R.C., Kirk, M.A., Furuya, K., Lumpkin, G.R. and Ruault, M.O. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1654–1683.
519
520
F.M. Ross Blanpain, B., Legresy, J.-M. and Mayer, J.W. (1990). Colloque Phys. C-4, 131–137. Bobji, M.S., Ramanujan, C.S., Doole, R.C., Pethica, J.B. and Inkson, B.J. (2003). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Pro. 778, 105–110. Bond, G.M., Robertson, I.M. and Birnbaum, H.K. (1986). Scripta Metallurgica 20, 653–658. Bonevich, J.E., Harada, K., Matsuda, T., Kasai, H., Yoshida, T., Pozzi, G. and Tonomura, A. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 2952–2955. Bovin, J.-O., Wallenberg, R. and Smith, D.J. (1985). Nature 317, 47–49. Burden, A.P. and Hutchison, J.L. (1998). Carbon 36, 1167–1173. Butler, E.P. and Hale, K.F. (1981). Dynamic Experiments in the Electron Microscope, Vol. 9. In Practical Methods of Electron Microscopy (North-Holland, Amsterdam). Cai, W., Murakami, Y. and Otsuka, K. (1999). Mat. Sci. Eng. A 273–275, 186–189. Caillard, D., Martin, J.L. and Jouffrey, B. (1980). Acta Metallurgica 28, 1059–1067. Caillard, D., Vailhe, C. and Farkas, D. (1999). Philos. Mag. A 79, 723–739. Caillard, D., Roucau, C., Bresson, L. and Gratias, D. (2002). Acta Materialia 50, 4499–4509. Cantoni, M., Uchida, M., Matsui, Y., Takekawa, S., Tsuruta, T. and Horiuchi, S. (1998). J. Electron Microsc. 47, 443–448. Chang, C.Y. and Vook, R.W. (1993). Thin Solid Films 223, 23–30. Chatterjee, K., Howe, J.M., Johnson, W.C. and Murayama, M. (2004). Acta Mat. 52, 2923–2935. Chen, G.S., Boothroyd, C.B. and Humphreys, C.J. (1998). Philos. Mag. A 78, 491–506. Chiou, W.-A., Ishikawa, A., Foo, K.H., Miyata, H., Tsukada, H. and Fukushima, K. (2002). Proc. ICEM-15 1, 937–938. Chong, R.K.K., Yeadon, M., Choi, W.K., Stach, E.A. and Boothroyd, C.B. (2003). App. Phy. Lett. 82, 1833–1835. Chu, F., Song, M., Mitsuishi, K., Yasuda, H. and Furuya, K. (2002). J. Electron Microsc. 51 (Supplement), S231–234. Collazo-Davila, C., Grozea, D. and Marks, L.D. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 1678–1681. Crozier, P.A., Oleshko, V.P., Westwood, A.D. and Cantrell, R.D. (2001). Electron Microsc. Anal. 2001. Proceedings 393–396. Cumings, J. and Zettl, A. (2000). Science 289, 602–604. Cumings, J. and Zettl, A. (2004). Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 086801/1–4. Cumings, J., Zettl, A., McCartney, M.R. and Spence, J.C.H. (2002). Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 056804/1–4. Dahmen, U., Hagege, S., Faudot, F., Radetic, T. and Johnson, E. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 2651–2662. Dannenberg, R., Stach, E., Grozac, J.R. and Dresser, B.J. (2000). Thin Solid Films 379, 133–138. Darlington, E.H. and Valdre, U. (1975). J. Phys. E 8, 321–324. Daulton, T.L., Kirk, M.A. and Rehn, L.E. (2000). Philos. Mag. A 80, 809–842. Daulton, T.L., Little, B.J., Lowe, K. and Jones-Meehan, J. (2001). Microsc. Microanal. 7, 470–485. Dehm, G. and Arzt, E. (2000). App. Phys. Lett. 77, 1126–1128. Dehm, G., Wagner, T., Balk, T.J., Arzt, E. and Inkson, B.J. (2002). J. Mat. Sci. Tech. 18, 113–317. Diebolt, L., Sharma, R., McKelvy, M. and Glaunsinger, W.S. (1995). Mat. Res. Soc. Proc. 404, 183–188.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Doan, J.C., Lee, S., Lee, S.-H., Flinn, P.A., Bravman, J.C. and Marieb, T.N. (2001). J. App. Phy. 89, 7797–7808. Donnelly, S.E., Birtcher, R.C., Allen, C.W., Morrison, I., Furuya, K., Song, M., Mitsuishi, K. and Dahmen, U. (2002). Science 296, 507–510. Donnet, D.M., Lewis, V.G., Chapman, J.N., O’Grady, K. and van Kesteren, H.W. (1993). J. Phys. D 26, 1741–1745. Dougherty, L.M., Robertson, I.M. and Vetrano, J.S. (2003). Acta Mat. 51, 4367–4378. Drucker, J., Sharma, R., Weiss, K. and Kouvetakis, J. (1995). J. App. Phys. 77, 2846–2848. Du, X.W., Takeguchi, M., Tanaka, M. and Furuya, K. (2003). App. Phys. Lett. 82, 1108–1110. Dutkiewicz, J., Bartsch, M., Miura, S., Messerschmidt, U. and Kato, H. (1995). J. Phys. IV (Colloque) 5(C2), 275–280. Fedina, L., Lebedev, O., Van Tendeloo, G. and Van Landuyt, J. (1997). Proc. Microsc. Semicond. Mat. 10, 55–58. Fedina, L., Gutakovskii, A., Aseev, A., van Landuyt, J. and Vanhellemont, J. (1998). Philo. Mag. A 77, 423–435. Follstaedt, D.M., Myers, S.M., Floro, J.A. and Lee, S.R. (1997). Nucl. Inst. Methods Phys. Res. B 127–128, 375–378. Foo, K.H., Chiou, W.-A., Ishikawa, A., Fukushima, K. and Meshii, M. (2001). Microsc. Microanal. 7 (Supplement 2), 1216–1217. Fujisawa, S. and Kizuka, T. (2003a). J. J. App. Phys. Part 2 42, L1182–1184. Fujisawa, S. and Kizuka, T. (2003b). Tribol. Lett. 15, 163. Fujita, S., Maruno, S., Watanabe, H. and Ichikawa, M. (1996). App. Phys. Lett. 69, 638–640. Fukami, A., Fukushima, K. and Kohyama, N. (1991). In Microstructure of Fine Grained Sediments from Mud to Shale (Bennett, R.H., Bryant, W.R., Hulbert, M.H., Eds.) 321–331 (Springer-Verlag, New York). Furuya, K., Mitsuishi, K., Shimojo, M. and Takeguchi, M. (2003). Rev. Adv. Mat. Sci. 5, 381–386. Gabrisch, H., Kjeldgaard, L., Vaernholt Olesen, A., Johnson, E. and Dahmen, U. (2000). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 580, 257–264. Gabrisch, H., Kjeldgaard, L., Johnson, E. and Dahmen, U. (2001). Acta Mat. 49, 4259. Gai, P.L. (1998). Adv. Mat. 10, 1259–1263. Gai, P.L., Kourtakis, K. and Ziemecki, S. (2000). Microsc. Microanal. 6, 335–342. Gai, P.L. (2002a). Top. Catalysis 21, 161–173. Gai, P.L. (2002b). Microsc. Microanal. 8, 21–28. Gai, P.L. and Harmer, M.A. (2002). Nano Lett. 2, 771–774. Gai, P.L. and Kourtakis, K. (1995). Science 267, 661. Gai, P.L., Smith, B.C. and Owen, G. (1990). Nature 348, 430–432. Gajdardziska-Josifovska, M., Malay, M.H. and Smith, D.J. (1997). Surface Rev. Lett. 4, 655–669. Gajdardziska-Josifovska, M., Plass, R., Schofield, M.A., Giese, D.R. and Sharma, R. (2002). J. Electron Microsc. 51 (Supplement), S13–S26. Gajdardziska-Josifovska, M. and Sharma, R. (2005). Microsc. Microanal. 11, 524–533. Gao, R., Wang, Z.L., Bai, Z., de Heer, W.A., Dai, L. and Gao, M. (2000). Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 622–625. Gao, R., Pan, Z. and Wang, Z.L. (2001). App. Phys. Lett. 78, 1757–1759. Gao, Y. and Bando, Y. (2002). Nature (London) 415, 599. Gao, Y., Liu, Y.Q. and Wu, K.H. (1996). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 404, 171–176.
521
522
F.M. Ross Gemperlova, J., Jacques, A., Gemperle, A., Vystavel, T., Zarubova, N. and Janecek, M. (2002). Mat. Sci. Eng. A 324, 183–189. Ghica, C., Nistor, L., Bender, H., Steegen, A., Lauwers, A., Maex, K. and Van Landuyt, J. (2001). J. Mat. Res. 16, 701–708. Gibson, J.M., Batstone, J.L. and Tung, R.T. (1987). App. Phys. Lett. 51, 45–47. Gignac, L.M., Svilan, V., Clevenger, L.A., Cabral, C. and Lavoie, C. (1997). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 441, 225–230. Gloter, A., Suenaga, K., Kataura, H., Fujii, R., Kodama, T., Nishikawa, H., Ikemoto, I., Kikuchi, K., Suzuki, S., Achiba, Y. and Iijima, S. (2004). Chem. Phys. Lett. 390, 462–466. Gnauck, P., Nisch, W. and Piles, E. (1998). Proc. 14th Internat. Cong. Electron Microsc. 3, 515–516. Gottschalk, H., Hiller, N., Sauerland, S., Specht, P. and Alexander, H. (1993). Phys. Status Solidi A 138, 547–555. Grant, A.W., Hu, Q.-H. and Kasemo, B. (2004). Nanotechnology 15, 1175–1181. Grozea, D., Landree, E. and Marks, L.D. (1997). App. Phys. Lett. 71, 2301–2303. Guder, S., Bartsch, M. and Messerschmidt, U. (2002). Philos. Mag. A 82, 2737–2754. Haga, K., King, W.E., Merkle, K.L. and Meshii, M. (1986). Nuc. Inst. Methods Phys. Res. B 16, 134–142. Hammar, M., LeGoues, F.K., Tersoff, J., Reuter, M.C. and Tromp, R.M. (1996). Surface Sci. 349, 129–144. Han, X.D., Wang, R., Zhang, Z. and Yang, D.Z. (1997). Mat. Lett. 30, 23–28. Hannon, J.B., Kodambaka, S., Ross, F.M. and Tromp, R.M. (2006). Nature, advanced online publication, 29 January (DOI 10.1038/nature04574). Hansen, P.L., Wagner, J.B., Helveg, S., Rostrup-Nielsen, J.R., Clausen, B.S. and Topsoe, H. (2002). Science 295, 2053–2055. Hansen, T.W., Wagner, J.B., Hansen, P.L., Dahl, S., Topsoe, H. and Jacobsen, C.J.H. (2001). Science 294, 1508–1510. Haque, M.A. and Saif, M.T.A. (2003). Exp. Mech. 43, 248–255. Haque, M.A. and Saif, M.T.A. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1769–1777. Haque, M.A. and Saif, M.T.A. (2004). Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 101, 6335–6340. Harada, K., Matsuda, T., Bonevich, J., Igarashi, M., Kondo, S., Pozzi, G., Kawabe, U. and Tonomura, A. (1992). Nature 360, 51–53. Harada, K., Kamimura, O., Kasai, H., Matsuda, F., Tonomura, A. and Moshchalkov, V.V. (1996a). Science 274, 1167–1170. Harada, K., Kasai, H., Kamimura, O., Matsuda, T., Tonomura, A., Okayasu, S. and Kazumata, Y. (1996b). Phys. Rev. B 53, 9400–9405. Harada, I., Kasai, H., Matsuda, T., Yamasaki, M. and Tonomura, A. (1997a). J. Electron Microsc. 46, 227–232. Harada, K., Matsuda, T., Kasai, H., Kamimura, O. and Tonomura, A. (1997b). Ultramicroscopy 67, 133–141. Hashimoto, A., Suenaga, K., Gloter, A., Urita, K. and Iijima, S. (2004). Nature 430, 870–873. Hattar, K., Han, J., Saif, M.T.A. and Robertson, I.M. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1869–1877. Hattenhauer, R., Bartsch, M., Messerschmidt, U., Haasen, P. and Wilbrandt, P.-J. (1994). Philos. Mag. A 70, 447–461. Haussler, D., Bartsch, M., Aindow, M., Jones, I.P. and Messerschmidt, U. (1999). Philos. Mag. A 79, 1045–1071. He, H. and Tan, X. (2004). App. Phys. Lett. 85, 3187–3189. He, H. and Tan, X. (2005). Phys. Rev. B 72, 24102.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Helveg, S., Lopez-Cartes, C., Sehested, J., Hansen, P.L., Clausen, B.S., RostrupNielsen, J.R., Abild-Pedersen, F. and Norskov, J.K. (2004). Nature 427, 426–429. Hirayama, H., Kawamoto, Y., Ohshima, Y. and Takayanagi, K. (2001). App. Phys. Lett. 79, 1169–1171. Homma, Y. and Finnie, P. (2002). J. Crystal Growth 237–239, 28–34. Horiki, M., Arai, S., Satoh, Y. and Kiritani, M. (1998). J. Nucl. Mat. 255, 165–173. Horiuchi, S., Cantoni, M., Uchida, M., Tsuruta, T. and Matsui, Y. (1998). App. Phys. Lett. 73, 1293–1294. Howe, J.M. (1996). Philos. Mag. A 74, 761–775. Howe, J.M. (1997). Interf. Mat. (Wiley, New York). Howe, J.M. (1998). Mat. Trans, JIM 39, 3–23. Howe, J.M., Murray, T.M., Moore, K.T., Csontos, A.A., Tsai, M.M., Garg, A. and Benson, W.E. (1998). Microsc. Microanal. 4, 235–247. Howe, J.M., Reynolds, W.T., Jr. and Vasudevan, V.K. (2004). Z. Met. 95, 275–278. Huang, J.Y., Chen, S., Jo, S.H., Wang, Z., Han, D.X., Chen, G., Dresselhaus, M.S. and Ren, Z.F. (2005). Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 236802/1–4. Hueging, N., Luysberg, M., Urban, K., Buca, D. and Mantl, S. (2005). App. Phys. Lett. 86, 42112–42113. Hugo, R.C. and Hoagland, R.G. (1998). Scripta Mat. 38, 523–529. Hugo, R.C. and Hoagland, R.G. (1999). Scripta Mat. 41, 1341–1946. Hugo, R.C., Kung, H., Weertman, J.R., Mitra, R., Knapp, J.A. and Follstaedt, D.M. (2003). Acta Mat. 51, 1937–1943. Hull, R. and Bean, J. (1994). Mat. Res. Soc. Bull. 19 (6), 32–37. Hull, R., Bean, J.C. and Buescher, C. (1989). J. App. Phys. 66, 5837–5843. Hull, R., Bean, J.C., Bahnck, D., Peticolas, L.J., Jr., Short, K.T. and Unterwald, F.C. (1991). J. App. Phys. 70, 2052–2065. Ichikawa, M., Fujita, S. and Maruno, S. (1998). Proc. 14th Internat. Cong. Electron Microsc. 13, 147–148. Ichikawa, M. (1999). J. Phys. Cond. Matt. 11, 9861–9870. Ii, S., Nishida, M., Murakami, Y. and Shindo, D. (2003). J. Phys. IV (Proceedings) 112, 1035–1038. Ii, S., Iwamoto, C., Matsunaga, K., Yamamoto, T., Yoshiya, M. and Ikuhara, Y. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 2767–2775. Iijima, S. and Ichihashi, T. (1986). Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 616–619. Inoue, M., Suzuki, K., Amasuga, H., Mera, Y. and Maeda, K. (1998). J. App. Phys. 83, 1953–1957. Inui, H., Mori, H., Suzuki, A. and Fujita, H. (1992). Philos. Mag. B 65, 1–14. Isshiki, T., Ohta, M., Nishio, K. and Shiojiri, M. (1995). Thin Solid Fims 271, 84–87. Isshiki, T., Nishio, K., Deguchi, Y., Yamamoto, H. and Shiojiri, M. (1998). Proc. 14th Internat. Cong. Electron Microsc. 3, 521–522. Janecek, M., Louchet, F., Doisneau-Cottignies, B. and Brechet, Y. (2000). Philos. Mag. A 80, 1605–1619. Jencic, I., Bench, M.W., Robertson, I.M. and Kirk, M.A. (1995). J. App. Phys. 78, 974–982. Jiang, B., Tadakit, T., Mori, H. and Hsu, T.Y. (1997). Mat. Trans. JIM 38, 1072– 1077 and 1078–1082. Jiang, J.C. and Pan, X.Q. (2000). Philos. Mag. Lett. 80, 271–279. Jin, M., Minor, A.M., Stach, E.A. and Morris, J.W., Jr. (2004). Acta Mat. 52, 5381–5387. Jin, C.H., Wang, J.Y., Wang, M.S., Su, J. and Peng, L.M. (2005). Carbon 43, 1026–1031.
523
524
F.M. Ross Johnson, E., Johansen, A., Nelson, C. and Dahmen, U. (2002). J. Electron Microsc. 51 (Supplement), S201–209. Johnson, E., Levinsen, M.T., Steenstrupt, S., Prokofjev, S., Zhilin, V., Dahmen, U. and Radetic, T. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 2663–2673. Johnson, K.D. and Dravid, V.P. (1999). Microsc. Microanal. 5, 428–436. Johnson, K.D. and Dravid, V.P. (2000). Interface Sci. 8, 189–198. Johnston, A.B., Chapman, J.N., Khamsehpour, B. and Wilkinson, C.D.W. (1996). J. Phys. D 29, 1419–1427. Kaiser, M., van Pieterson, L. and Verheijen, M.A. (2004). J. App. Phys. 96, 3193–3198. Kamino, T., Yaguchi, T., Ukiana, M., Yasutomi, Y. and Saka, H. (1995). Mat. Transac, JIM 36, 73–75. Kamino, T., Sasaki, K. and Saka, H. (1997a). Microsc. Microanal. 3, 393–408. Kamino, T., Yaguchi, T., Tomita, M. and Saka, H. (1997b). Philos. Mag. A 75, 105–114. Kammler, M., Hull, R., Reuter, M.C. and Ross, F.M. (2003). App. Phys. Lett. 82, 1093–1095. Kammler, M., Chidambarrao, D., Schwarz, K.W., Black, C.T. and Ross, F.M. (2005). App. Phys. Lett. 87, 133116. Kaouache, B., Gergaud, P., Thomas, O., Bostrom, O. and Legros, M. (2003). Microelectr. Eng. 70, 447–454. Kassner, M.E., Wall, M.A. and Delos-Reyes, M.A. (1997). Metallurg. Mat. Transac. A 28, 595–609. Kato, T., Nunome, K., Morimoto, Y., Nishimura, K. and Saka, H. (2000). Philos. Mag. Lett. 80, 187–192. Keller, R.-M., Sigle, W., Baker, S.P., Kraft, O. and Arzt, E. (1997). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 436, 221–226. Keller-Flaig, R.-M., Legros, M., Sigle, W., Gouldstone, A., Hemker, K.J., Suresh, S. and Arzt, E. (1999). J. Mat. Res. 14, 4673–4676. King, W.E., Merkle, K.L. and Meshii, M. (1981). Phys. Rev. B 23, 6319–6334. Kiritani, M. (1999). Radiat. Eff. Def. Sol. 148, 233–267. Kirk, K. J., Chapman, J.N., McVitie, S., Aitchison, P.R. and Wilkinson, C.D.W. (1999a). App. Phys. Lett. 75, 3683–3685. Kirk, M.A., Jenkins, M.L. and Fukushima, H. (1999b). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympo. Proc. 540, 521–526. Kizuka, T. (1998a). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 4448–4451. Kizuka, T. (1998b). Phys. Rev. B 57, 11158–11163. Kizuka, T. and Hosoki, K. (1999). App. Phys. Lett. 75, 2743–2745. Kizuka, T. and Tanaka, N. (1997a). Phys. Rev. B 56, R10079–10082. Kizuka, T. and Tanaka, N. (1997b). Philos. Mag. Lett. 76, 289–297. Kizuka, T., Uhmehara, S. and Fujisawa, S. (2001a). J. J. App. Phys., Part 2 40, L71–74. Kizuka, T., Ohmi, H., Sumi, T., Kumazawa, K., Deguchi, S., Naruse, M., Fujisawa, S., Sasaki, S., Yabe, A. and Enomoto, Y. (2001b). J. J. App. Phys. 40, L170–L173. Kizuka, T., Tanaka, N., Deguchi, S. and Naruse, M. (1998c). Microsc. Microanal. 4, 218–225. Kleinschmit, M.W., Yeadon, M. and Gibson, J.M. (1999). App. Phys. Lett. 75, 3288–3290. Klie, R.F. and Browning, N. (2001). J. Electron Microsc. 50 (Supplement), S59. Kociak, M., Suenaga, K., Hirahara, K., Saito, Y., Nakahira, T. and Iijima, S. (2002). Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 155501. Koizumi, H., Oshima, Y., Kondo, Y. and Takayanagi, K. (2001). Ultramicroscopy 88, 17–24.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Kolar, H.R., Spence, J.C.H. and Alexander, H. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 4031–4034. Komatsu, M., Mori, H. and Iwasaki, K. (1994). J. Amer. Ceramic Soc. 77, 839–842. Komatsu, M., Matsukawa, Y., Yasunaga, K. and Kiritani, M. (2003). Mat. Sci. Eng. A 350, 25–29. Kondo, Y. and Takayanagi, K. (2000). Science 289, 606–608. Konno, T.J. and Sinclair, R. (1992). Philos. Mag. B 66, 749–765. Konno, T.J. and Sinclair, R. (1995a). Philos. Mag. B 71, 179–199. Konno, T.J. and Sinclair, R. (1995b). Philos. Mag. B 71, 163–178. Konno, T.J. and Sinclair, R. (1995c). Acta Met. Mat. 43, 471–484. Kooi, B.J. and De Hosson, J.T.M. (2001). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 654, AA4.1.1–12. Kooi, B.J. and De Hosson, J.T.M. (2004). J. App. Phys. 95, 4714–4721. Kooi, B.J., Groot, W.M.G. and De Hosson, J.T.M. (2004). J. App. Phys. 95, 924–932. Krishnamurthy, M., Drucker, J.S. and Venables, J.A. (1991). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 202, 77–82. Krishnan, A., Dujardin, E., Ebbesen, T.W., Yianilos, P.N. and Treacy, M.M.J. (1998). Phys. Rev. B 58, 14013–14019. Krishnan, A., Bisher, M.E. and Treacy, M.M.J. (1999). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 541, 475–480. Krishnan, A., Treacy, M.M.J., Bisher, M.E., Chandra, P. and Littlewood, P.B. (2000). Ameri. Inst. Phys. Conf. Proc. 535, 191–200. Krishnan, A., Treacy, M.M.J., Bisher, M.E., Chandra, P. and Littlewood, P.B. (2002). Integ. Ferroelectrics 43, 31–49. Kruml, T., Caillard, D., Dupas, C. and Martin, J.-L. (2002). J. Phys. Cond. Matt. 14, 12897–12902. Kuninori, T., Sukedai, E. and Hashimoto, H. (1996). Mat. Trans, JIM 37, 1404–1407. Kuzumaki, T., Sawada, H., Ichinose, H., Horiike, Y. and Kizuka, T. (2001). App. Phys. Lett. 79, 4580–4582. Kuzumaki, T., Horiike, Y., Kizuka, T., Kona, T., Oshima, C. and Mitsuda, Y. (2004). Diamond Rel. Mat. 13, 1907–1913. Larsson, M.W., Wallenberg, L.R., Persson, A.I. and Samuelson, L. (2004). Microsc. Microanal. 10, 41–46. Latyshev, A.V., Nasimov, D.A., Savenko, V.N. and Aseev, A.L. (2000). Thin Sol. Films 367, 142–148. Lau, J.T., Prybyla, J.A. and Theiss, S.K. (2000). App. Phys. Lett. 76, 164–166. Lau, J.W., Beleggia, M., Schofield, M.A., Neumark, G.F. and Zhu, Y. J. (2005). App. Phys. 97, 10E702/1–3. Lavagne, S., Levade, C. and Vanderschaeve, G. (2001). Proc. Microsc. Semicond. Mat. 2001, 219–224. Lee, H.-J., Ni, H., Wu, D.T. and Ramirez, A.G. (2005). App. Phys. Lett. 87, 124102. Lee, J.G. and Mori, H. (2003). J. Electron Microsc. 52, 57–62. Lee, J.G. and Mori, H. (2004a). Philos. Mag. 84, 2675–2686. Lee, J.G. and Mori, H. (2004b). Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 235501/1–4. Lee, J.G., Mori, H. and Yasuda, H. (2002a). Phys. Rev. B 65, 132106/1–4. Lee, J.G., Taguchi, E. and Mori, H. (2002b). J. Electron Microsc. 51 (Suppl), S195–200. LeGoues, F.K., Reuter, M.C., Tersoff, J., Hammar, M. and Tromp, R.M. (1994). Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 300–303. LeGoues, F.K., Tersoff, J., Reuter, M.C., Hammar, M. and Tromp, R. (1995). App. Phys. Lett. 67, 2317–2319.
525
526
F.M. Ross LeGoues, F.K., Hammar, M., Reuter, M.C. and Tromp, R.M. (1996). Surface Sci. 349, 249–266. Legros, M. and Caillard, D. (2001). J. Microsc. 203, 90–98. Legros, M., Couret, A. and Caillard, D. (1996). Philos. Mag. 73, 61–80 81–99. Legros, M., Minonishi, Y. and Caillard, D. (1997). Philos. Mag. A 76, 995–1011 and 1013–1032. Legros, M., Hemker, K.J., Gouldstone, A., Suresh, S., Keller-Flaig, R.M. and Arzt, E. (2002). Acta Mat. 50, 3435–3452. Legros, M., Kaouache, B., Gergaud, P., Thomas, O., Dehm, G., Balk, T.J. and Arzt, E. (2005). Philos. Mag. 85, 3541–3552. Levade, C., Faress, A. and Vanderschaeve, G. (1994). Philos. Mag. A 69, 855–870. Lim, C.K., Chapman, J.N., Rahman, M., Johnston, A.B. and O’Donnell, D.O. (2002). J. Phys. D 35, 2344–2351. Lim, C.K., Chapman, J.N., Rahman, M., Johnston, A.B. and O’Donnell, D.O. (2004). J. App. Phys. 95, 1510–1515. Lin, X., Murray, C. and Dravid, V.P. (1998). Proc. Microsc. Microanal. 1998, 552. Liu, J., Takeguchi, M., Tanaka, M., Yasuda, H. and Furuya, K. (2001). J. Electron Microsc. 50, 541–544. Liu, R.-J., Crozier, P.A., Smith, C.M., Hucul, D.A., Blackson, J. and Salaita, G. (2004). Microsc. Microanal. 10, 77–85. Liu, X.H., Ross, F.M. and Schwarz, K.W. (2000). Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 4088–4091. Liu, Z., Bando, Y., Mitome, M. and Zhan, J. (2004). Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 095504/1–4. Liu, X.X., Chapman, J.N., McVitie, S. and Wilkinson, C.D.W. (2004). App. Phys. Lett. 84, 4406–4408. Lo, W. and Spence, J. (1992). Ultramicroscopy 48, 433. Louchet, F., Blandin, J.-J. and Veron, M. (2001). Adv. Eng. Mat. 3, 608–612. Lucadamo, G. and Medlin, D.L. (2002). Acta Mat. 50, 3045–3055. Ma, X.-G. and Komvopoulos, K. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1808–1813. Maeda, K., Suzuki, K., Yamashita, Y. and Mera, Y. (2000). J. Phys. Cond. Matt. 12, 10079–10091. Malaplate, J., Caillard, D. and Couret, A. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 3671–3687. Marks, L.D. (1983). Phys. Rev. Lett. 51, 1000. Marks, L.D., Bengu, E., Collazo-Davila, C., Grozea, D., Landree, E., Leslie, C. and Sinkler, W. (1998). Surface Rev. Lett. 5, 1087–1106. Maruno, S., Fujita, S., Watanabe, H., Kusumi, Y. and Ichikawa, M. (1996). App. Phys. Lett. 68, 2213–2215. Mathes, D.T., Hull, R., Choquette, K.D., Geib, K.M., Allerman, A.A., Guenter, J.K., Hawkins, B. and Hawthorne, R.A. (2003). Proc. SPIE 4994, 67–82. Matsuda, T., Harada, K., Kasai, H., Kamimura, O. and Tonomura, A. (1996). Science 271, 1393–1395. Matsuda, T., Kamimura, O., Kasai, H., Harada, K., Yoshida, T., Akashi, T., Tonomura, A., Nakayama, Y., Shimoyama, J., Kishio, K., Hanaguri, T. and Kitazawa, K. (2001). Science 294, 2136–2138. Matsumoto, H., Sukedai, E. and Hashimoto, H. (1999). Mat. Trans. JIM 40, 1436–1443. Matsunaga, K., Ii, S., Iwamoto, C., Yamamoto, T. and Ikuhara, Y. (2004). Nanotechnology 15, S376–S381. McKelvy, M.J., Sharma, R., Chizmeshya, A.V.G., Carpenter, R.W. and Streib, K. (2001). Chem. Mat. 13, 921–926. McVitie, S. and Chapman, J.N. (1997). Microsc. Microanal. 3, 146–153.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Medlin, D.L., Campbell, G.H. and Carter, C.R. (1998). Acta Mat. 46, 5135–5142. Mera, Y., Suzuki, K. and Maeda, K. (2003). Phys. B 340–342, 488–491. Merkle, K.L. and Thompson, L.J. (2001). Mat. Lett. 48, 188–193. Merkle, K.L., Thompson, L.J. and Phillipp, F. (2002a). Philos. Mag. Lett. 82, 589–597. Merkle, K.L., Thompson, L.J. and Phillipp, F. (2002b). Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 225501/1–4. Messerschmidt, U. (2001). J. Microsc. 203, 68–71. Messerschmidt, U. and Bartsch, M. (2003). Mat. Chem. Phys. 81, 518–523. Messerschmidt, U., Baither, D., Baufeld, B. and Bartsch, M. (1997). Mat. Sci. Eng. A 233, 61–74. Messerschmidt, U., Baither, D., Bartsch, M., Baufeld, B., Geyer, B., Guder, S., Wasilkowska, A., Czyrska-Filemonowicz, A., Yamaguchi, M., Feuerbacher, M. and Urban, K. (1998). Microsc. Microanal. 4, 226–234. Messerschmidt, U., Bartsch, M., Feuerbacher, M., Geyer, B. and Urban, K. (1999). Philos. Mag. A 79, 2123–2135. Minoda, H. and Yagi, K. (1996). J. Crystal Growth 163, 48–53. Minoda, H. and Yagi, K. (1999). Surface Sci. 437, L761–766. Minoda, H., Yagi, K., Meyer zu Heringdorf, F.-J., Meier, A., Kahler, D. and Horn von Hoegen, M. (1999). Phys. Rev. B 59, 2363–2375. Minor, A.M., Morris, J.W. and Stach, E.A. (2001). App. Phys. Lett. 79, 1625–1627. Minor, A.M., Lilleodden, E.T., Jin, M., Stach, E.A., Chrzan, D.C. and Morris, J.W. (2005). Philos. Mag. 85, S323–S330. Missana, T., Afonso, C.N., Petford-Long, A.K. and Doole, R.C. (1999). Philos. Mag. A 79, 2577–2590. Mitome, M., Takayanagi, K. and Tanishiro, Y. (1990). Phys. Rev. B 42, 7238–7241. Mompiou, F., Caillard, D. and Feuerbacher, M. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 2777. Mori, H., Yasuda, H., Koyama, H., Sumida, N. and Fujita, H. (1992). Nucl. Inst. Methods Phys. Res. B 63, 291–296. Mori, H., Okabayashi, H. and Komatsu, M. (1997). Thin Sol. Films 300, 25–29. Mori, H. (1998). Mat. Trans. JIM 39, 959–966. Mori, S., Yamamoto, N., Koyama, Y. and Uesu, Y. (1997). Phys. Rev. B 55, 11212–11217. Morkved, T.L., Lopes, W.A., Hahm, J., Sibener, S.J. and Jaeger, H.M. (1998). Polymer 39, 3871–3875. Murakami, Y. and Shindo, D. (2001). Philos. Mag. Lett. 81, 631–638. Murakami, Y., Shindo, D., Oikawa, K., Kainuma, R. and Ishida, K. (2002). Acta Mat. 50, 2173–2184. Naitoh, Y., Takayanagi, K., Oshima, Y. and Hirayama, H. (2000). J. Electron Microsc. 49, 211–216. Nath, R., Soo, C.W., Boothroyd, C.B., Yeadon, M., Chi, D.Z., Sun, H.P., Chen, Y.B., Pan, X.Q. and Foo, Y.L. (2005). App. Phys. Lett. 86, 201908-1–3. Niihara, K., Sekino, T., Nakahira, A., Kamino, T. and Yaguchi, T. (1996). Mat. Lett. 27, 121–124. Ning, X.G., Avalos-Borja, M. and Ye, H.Q. (1996). J. App. Phys. 79, 125–128. Nishizawa, H., Hori, F. and Oshima, R. (2002). J. Crystal Growth 236, 51–58. Nucci, J., Krämer, S., Arzt, E. and Volkert, C.A. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1851–1859. Ohmura, T., Minor, A.M., Stach, E.A. and Morris, J.W., Jr. (2004). J. Mat. Res. 19, 3626–3632.
527
528
F.M. Ross Ohnishi, H., Kondo, Y. and Takayanagi, K. (1998a). Surface Sci. 415, L1061–1064. Ohnishi, H., Kondo, Y. and Takayanagi, K. (1998b). Nature 395, 780–783. Okabayashi, H., Kitamura, H., Komatsu, M. and Mori, H. (1996). App. Phys. Lett. 68, 1066–1068. Ono, K., Arakawa, K., Hojou, K., Oohasi, M., Birtcher, R.C. and Donnelly, S.E. (2002). J. Electron Microsc. 51 (Supplement), S245–251. Oshima, Y., Hirata, T., Yokoyama, T., Hirayama, H. and Takayanagi, K. (2000). Surface Sci. 465, 81–89. Oshima, Y., Koizumi, H., Mouri, K., Hirayama, H., Takayanagi, K. and Kondo, Y. (2002). Phys. Rev. B 65, 121401/1–4. Oshima, Y., Kondo, Y. and Takayanagi, K. (2003a). J. Electron Microsc. 52, 49–55. Oshima, Y., Onga, A. and Takayanagi, K. (2003b). Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 205503/1–4. Oshima, Y., Mouri, K., Hirayama, H. and Takayanagi, K. (2003c). Surface Sci. 531, 209–216. Pan, X.-Q., Hu, M.-S., Yao, M.-H. and Feng, D. (1985). Phys. Stat. Sol. A 92, 57–68. Park, H.S., Murakami, Y., Shindo, D., Chernenko, V.A. and Kanomata, T. (2003). App. Phys. Lett. 83, 3752–3754. Park, H.S., Park, Y.-G., Gao, Y., Shindo, D. and Inoue, M. (2005). J. App. Phys. 97, 33908-1–4. Parker, M.A., Sigmon, T.W. and Sinclair, R. (1986). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 62, 311–322. Parker, M.A. and Sinclair, R. (1986). Nature 322, 531–533. Persson, A.I., Larsson, M.W., Stenstrom, S., Ohlsson, B.J., Samuelson, L. and Wallenberg, L.R. (2004). Nat. Mat. 3, 677–681. Petford-Long, A.K., Doole, R.C., Afonso, C.N. and Solis, J. (1995). J. App. Phys. 77, 607–613. Pettinari, F., Couret, A., Caillard, D., Molenat, G., Clement, N. and Coujou, A. (2001). J. Microsc. 203, 47–56. Poncharal, P., Frank, S., Wang, Z.L. and de Heer, W.A. (1999). Eur. Phys. J. D 9, 77–79. Poncharal, P., Berger, C., Yan Yi, Wang, Z.L. and de Heer, W.A. (2002). J. Phys. Chem. B 106, 12104–12118. Poppa, H. (1965). J. Vac. Sci. Tech. 2, 42–48. Poppa, H. (2004). J. Vac. Sci. Tech. A 22, 1931–1947. Portavoce, A., Kammler, M., Hull, R., Reuter, M.C., Copel, M. and Ross, F.M. (2004). Phys. Rev. B 70, 195306-1–9. Portavoce, A., Hull, R. and Ross, F.M. (2006). In Lateral Alignment of Epitaxial Quantum Dots (O. Schmidt, Ed.). Springer, New York. Portier, X. and Petford-Long, A.K. (2000). App. Phys. Lett. 76, 754–756. Portier, X., Petford-Long, A.K., Doole, R.C., Anthony, T.C. and Brug, J.A. (1997). App. Phys. Lett. 71, 2032–2034. Portier, X., Tsymbal, E. Yu., Petford-Long, A.K., Anthony, T.C. and Brug, J.A. (1998). Phys. Rev. B 58, R591–594. Portier, X., Petford-Long, A.K., Anthony, T.C. and Brug, J.A. (1999a). App. Phys. Lett. 75, 1290–1292. Portier, X., Petford-Long, A.K., Anthony, T.C. and Brug, J.A. (1999b). J. App. Phys. 85, 4120–4126. Prybyla, J.A., Riege, S.P., Grabowski, S.P. and Hunt, A.W. (1998). App. Phys. Lett. 73, 1083–1085. Pyo, S.G. and Kim, N.J. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1888–1901. Radisic, A. (2004). Ph.D. Thesis, The Johns Hopkins University.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Radisic, A., Vereecken, P.M., Hannon, J.B., Searson, P.C. and Ross, F.M. (2006). Nano Lett. 6, 238–242. Ren, S.B., Lu, C.J., Shen, H.M. and Wang, Y.N. (1994). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 404, 95–100. Riege, S.P., Prybyla, J.A. and Hunt, A.W. (1996). App. Phys. Lett. 69, 2367–2369. Robertson, I.M. and Teter, D. (1998). Microsc. Res. Tech. 42, 260–269. Roddatis, V.V., Kuznetsov, V.L., Butenko, Yu, V., Su, D.S. and Schlogl, R. (2002). Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 4, 1964–1967. Ross, F.M. (2000). IBM J. Res. Dev. 44, 489–501. Ross, F.M. and Gibson, J.M. (1991). Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 1782–1785. Ross, F.M., Hull, R., Bahnck, D., Bean, J.C., Peticolas, L.J. and King, C.A. (1993). App. Phys. Lett. 62, 1426–1428. Ross, F.M., Kola, R.R., Hull, R. and Bean, J.C. (1994a). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympo. Proc. 318, 697–702. Ross, F.M., Gibson, J.M. and Twesten, R.D. (1994b). Surface Sci. 310, 243–266. Ross, F.M., Tersoff, J. and Tromp, R.M. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 984–987. Ross, F.M., Bennett, P.A., Tromp, R.M., Tersoff, J. and Reuter, M. (1999a). Micron 30, 21–32. Ross, F.M., Tromp, R.M. and Reuter, M.C. (1999b). Science 286, 1931–1934. Ross, F.M., Kammler, M., Walsh, M.E. and Reuter, M.C. (2004). Microsc. Microanal. 10, 105–111. Ross, F.M., Tersoff, J., Kodambaka, S. and Reuter, M.C. (2006). Springer Proccedings in Physics 107, 283–286. Ross, F.M., Tersoff, J. and Reuter, M.C. (2005). Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 146104/ 1–4. Ru, Q., Okamoto, M., Kondo, Y. and Takayanagi, K. (1996). Chem. Phys. Lett. 259, 425–431. Ruault, M.O., Fortuna, F., Bernas, H., Chaumont, J., Kaitasov, O. and Borodin, V.A. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1758–1768. Ruault, M.O., Fortuna, F., Bernas, H., Ridgway, M.C. and Williams, J.S. (2002). App. Phys. Lett. 81, 2617–2619. Saka, H., Arai, S., Tsukimoto, S. and Sasaki, K. (1999). Mat. Sci. Forum 294–296, 617–620. Sasaki, K. and Saka, H. (1997). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 466, 185–190. Sayagues, M.J. and Hutchison, J.L. (1996). J. Sol. State Chem. 124, 116–122. Sayagues, M.J. and Hutchison, J.L. (2002). J. Sol. State Chem. 163, 137–143. Schaper, A.K., Phillipp, F. and Hou, H. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1844–1850. Schneider, A., Hoffmann, H. and Zweck, J. (2003). J. Magn. Magn. Mat. 257, 1–10. Schneider, M., Hoffmann, H. and Zweck, J. (2001). App. Phys. Lett. 79, 3113–3115. Schneider, M., Hoffmann, H., Otto, S., Haug, Th. and Zweck, J. (2002). J. App. Phys. 92, 1466–1472. Schryvers, D. and Ma, Y. (1995). Mat. Lett. 23, 105–111. Schryvers, D., Lahjouji, D.E., Slootmaekers, B. and Potapov, P.L. (1996). Scripta Mat. 35, 1235–1241. Schryvers, D., Yandouzi, M. and Toth, L. (1998). Thin Sol. Films 326, 126–133. Senda, Y., Sasaki, K. and Saka, H. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 2635–2649. Shah, J. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 2749–2765. Shan, Z., Stach, E.A., Wiezorek, J.M.K., Knapp, J.A., Forstaedt, D.M. and Mao, S.X. (2004). Science 305, 654–657. Sharma, R. (2001). Microsc. Microanal. 7, 494–506.
529
530
F.M. Ross Sharma, R. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1695–1707. Sharma, R. and Iqbal, Z. (2004). App. Phys. Lett. 84, 990–992. Sharma, R., Crozier, P.A., Kang, Z.C. and Eyring, L. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 2731–2747. Sharma, R., McKelvy, M.J., Bearat, H., Chizmeshya, A.V.G. and Carpenter, R. W. (2004b). Philos. Mag. 84, 2711–2729. Sharma, R, Naedele, D. and Schweda, E. (2001). Chem. Mat. 13, 4014–4018. Sharma, R., Rez, P., Treacy, M.M.J. and Stuart, J. (2005). J. Electron Microsc. 54, 231–237. Shih, W.C. and Green, A.L. (1995). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympo. Proc. 356, 417. Shimojo, M., Mitsuishi, K., Tanaka, M., Han, M. and Furuya, K. (2004). J. Microsc. 214, 76–79. Sidorov, M.V., Kardynal, B. and Smith, D.J. (1998a). Microsc. Microanal. 4, 317–324. Sidorov, M.V., McKelvy, M.J., Sharma, R. and Glaunsinger, W.S. (1998b). J. Sol. State Chem. 141, 330–337. Sinclair, R. (1994). Mat. Res. Soc. Bull. 19(6), 26–31. Sinclair, R., Parker, M.A. and Kim, K.B. (1987). Ultramicroscopy 23, 383–395. Sinclair, R., Yamashita, T., Parker, M.A., Kim, K.B., Holloway, K. and Schwartzman, A.F. (1988). Acta Cryst. A 44, 965–975. Sinclair, R., Itoh, T. and Chin, R. (2002). Microsc. Microanal. 8, 288–304. Smeeton, T.M., Kappers, M.J., Barnard, J.S., Vickers, M.E. and Humphreys, C. J. (2003). App. Phys. Lett. 83, 5419–5421. Smith, D.J., Petford-Long, A.K., Wallenberg, L.R. and Bovin, J.-O. (1986). Science 233, 872–875. Smith, D.J., Gajdardziska-Josifovska, M., Lu, P., McCartney, M.R., Podbrdsky, J., Swann, P.R. and Jones, J.S. (1993). Ultramicroscopy 49, 26–36. Snoeck, E. and Roucau, C. (1992). Phys. Rev. B 45, 12720–12724. Snoeck, E., Normand, L., Thorel, A. and Roucau, C. (1994). Phase Trans. A 46, 77–88. Soer, W.A., De Hosson, J.T.M., Minor, A.M., Morris, J.W., Jr. and Stach, E.A. (2004). Acta Mat. 52, 5783–5790. Sofronis, P. and Robertson, I.M. (2002). Philos. Mag. A 82, 3405–3413. Song, M., Mitsuishi, K., Yasuda, H. and Furuya, K. (2002). J. Electron Microsc. 51 (Supplement), S211–214. Sow, C.-H., Harada, K., Tonomura, A., Crabtree, G. and Grier, D.G. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 2693–2696. Spence, J.C.H., Lo, W. and Kuwabara, M. (1990). Ultramicroscopy 33, 69–82. Spence, J.C.H., Kolar, H.R., Hembree, H.R., Humphreys, C.J., Barnard, J., Datta, R., Koch, C., Ross, F.M. and Justo, J.F. (2006). Philosophical Magazine, in press. Stach, E.A., Hull, R., Bean, J.C., Jones, K.S. and Nejim, A. (1998a). Microsc. Microanal. 4, 294–307. Stach, E.A., Hull, R., Tromp, R.M., Reuter, M.C., Copel, M., LeGoues, F.K. and Bean, J.C. (1998b). J. App. Phys. 83, 1931–1937. Stach, E.A., Hull, R., Tromp, R.M., Ross, F.M., Reuter, M.C. and Bean, J.C. (2000). Philos. Mag. A 80, 2159–2200. Stach, E.A., Freeman, T., Minor, A.M., Owen, D.K., Cumings, J., Wall, M.A., Chraska, T., Hull, R., Morris, Jr., J.W., Zettl, A. and Dahmen, U. (2001). Microsc. Microanal. 7, 507–517. Stach, E.A., Pauzauskie, P.J., Kuykendall, T., Goldberger, J., He, R. and Yang, P. (2003). Nano Lett. 3, 867. Storaska, G.A. and Howe, J.M. (2004). Mat. Sci. Eng. A 368, 183–190. Storaska, G.A., Moore, K.T. and Howe, J.M. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 2619–2634.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Suenaga, K., Colliex, C. and Iijima, S. (2001). App. Phys. Lett. 78, 70–72. Sugi, H., Akimoto, T., Sutoh, K., Chaen, S., Oishi, N. and Suzuki, S. (1997). Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 94, 4378–4382. Suh, Y.J., Prikhodko, S.V. and Friedlander, A.K. (2004). Microsc. Microanal. 8, 497. Sun, H.P., Pan, X.Q., Haeni, J.H. and Schlom, D.G. (2004). App. Phys. Lett. 85, 1967–1969. Sun, H.P., Chen, Y.B., Pan, X.Q., Chi, D.Z., Nath, R. and Foo, Y.L. (2005a). App. Phys. Lett. 86, 71904-1–3. Sun, K., Wang, L.M., Ewing, R.C. and Weber, W.J. (2005b). Philos. Mag. 85, 597–608. Takayanagi, K., Tanishiro, Y., Takahashi, S. and Takahashi, M. (1985). Surface Sci. 164, 367–392. Takeda, S. and Yamasaki, J. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 320–323. Takeguchi, M., Shimojo, M. and Furuya, K. (2005). Nanotechnology 16, 1321–1325. Tamiya, T., Shindo, D., Murakami, Y., Bando, Y. and Otsuka, K. (1998). Mat. Trans. JIM 39, 714–723. Tan, X., Xu, Z., Shang, J.K. and Han, P. (2000). App. Phys. Lett. 77, 1529–1531. Tan, X., Du, T. and Shang, J.K. (2002). App. Phys. Lett. 80, 3946–3948. Tan, X. and Shang, J.K. (2004a). J. App. Phys. 95, 2805–2810. Tan, X. and Shang, J.K. (2004b). J. App. Phys. 96, 635–639. Tan, X.L., He, H. and Shang, J.K. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1641–1653. Tanaka, H., Konno, T.J., Sinclair, R. and Hirashita, N. (1995). J. App. Phys. 78, 4982–4987. Tanaka, H., Hirashita, N. and Sinclair, R. (1996). Jap. J. Appl. Phys. Part 2 (Letters) 35, L479–481. Tanaka, H., Hirashita, N. and Sinclair, R. (1998a). Jap. J. Appl. Phys. Part 1, 37, 4284–4287. Tanaka, N., Kimata, H., Takashima, T. and Kizuka, T. (1998b). Surface Rev. Lett. 5, 723–729. Tanaka, M., Furuya, K. and Saito, T. (1998c). Microsc. Microanal. 4, 207–217. Tanaka, M., Han, M., Takeguchi, M. and Furuya, K. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 2699–2709. Tanaka, M., Chu, F., Shimojo, M., Takeguchi, M., Mitsuishi, K. and Furuya, K. (2005). App. Phys. Lett. 86, 183104. Tanner, L.E., Pelton, A.R., Van Tendeloo, G., Schryvers, D. and Wall, M.E. (1990). Scripta Met. Mat. 24, 1731–1736. Tappin, D.K., Robertson, I.M. and Birnbaum, H.K. (1995). Phys. Rev. B 51, 14854–14860. Teodorescu, V., Nistor, L., Bender, H., Steegen, A., Lauwers, A., Maex, K. and Van Landuyt, J. (2001). J. App. Phys. 90, 167–174. Terrones, M., Terrones, H., Banhart, F., Charlier, J.-C. and Ajayan, P.M. (2000). Sci. 288, 1226–1229. Terrones, M., Banhart, F., Grobert, N., Charlier, J.-C., Terrones, H. and Ajayan, P.M. (2002). Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 075505/1–4. Teter, D.F., Robertson, I.M. and Birnbaum, H.K. (2001). Acta Mat. 49, 4313–4323. Thilly, L., Veron, M., Ludwig, O., Lecouturier, F., Peyrade, J.P. and Askenazy, S. (2002). Philos. Mag. A 82, 925–942. Thompson, P., Gutfleisch, O., Chapman, J.N. and Harris, I.R. (1997). J. Phys. D 30, 1854–1860. Togawa, Y., Harada, K., Akashi, T., Kasai, H., Matsuda, T., Nori, F., Maeda, A. and Tonomura, A. (2005). Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 87002. Tonomura, A. (2002). J. Electron Microsc. 51 (supplement), S3–S11.
531
532
F.M. Ross Tonomura, A. (2003). J. Electron Micrsoc. 52, 11–19. Tonomura, A., Kasai, H., Kamimura, O., Matsuda, T., Harada, K., Nakayama, Y., Shimoyama, J., Kishio, K., Hanaguri, T., Kitazawa, K., Sasase, M. and Okayasu, S. (2001). Nature 412, 620–622. Tonomura, A., Kasai, H., Kamimura, O., Matsuda, T., Harada, K., Yoshida, T., Akashi, T., Shimoyama, J., Kishio, K., Hanaguri, T., Kitazawa, K., Masui, T., Tajima, S., Koshizuka, N., Gammel, P.L., Bishop, D., Sasase, M. and Okayasu, S. (2002). Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 237001/1–4. Toporov, A. Yu., Langford, R.M. and Petford-Long, A.K. (2000). App. Phys. Lett. 77, 3063–3065. Troiani, H.E., Camacho-Bragado, A., Armendariz, V., Gardea Torresday, J.L. and Yacaman, M.J. (2003). Chem. Mat. 15, 1029–1031. Twitchett, A.C., Dunin-Borkowski, R.E. and Midgley, P.A. (2002). Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 238302/1–4. Twitchett, A.C., Dunin-Borkowski, R.E., Broom, R.F. and Midgley, P.A. (2004). J. Phys. Cond. Matt. 16, S181–192. Ugarte, D. (1992). Nature 359, 707–709. Uhlig, T., Heumann, M. and Zweck, J. (2003). Ultramicroscopy 94, 193–196. Urita, K., Sato, Y., Suenaga, K., Gloter, A., Hashimoto, A., Ishida, M., Shimada, T., Shinohara, H. and Iijima, S. (2004). Nano Lett. 4, 2451–2454. Urita, K., Suenaga, K., Sugai, T., Shinohara, H. and Iijima, S. (2005). Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 155502. Vanderschaeve, G., Levade, C. and Caillard, D. (2000). J. Phys. Cond. Matt. 12, 10093–10103. Vanderschaeve, G., Levade, C. and Caillard, D. (2001). J. Microsc. 203, 72–83. Vanhellemont, J., Romano-Rodriguez, A., Fedina, L., Van Landuyt, J. and Aseev, A. (1995). Mat. Sci. Tech. 11, 1194–1202. Venables, J. (1981). Ultramicroscopy 7, 81–98. Verhaeghe, B., Louchet, F., Doisneau-Cottignies, B., Brechet, Y. and Massoud, J.-P. (1997). Philos. Mag. A 76, 1079–1091. Verheijen, M.A., Donkers, J.J.T.M., Thomassen, J.F.P., van den Broek, J.J., van der Rijt, R.A.F., Dona, M.J.J. and Smit, C.M. (2004). Rev. Sci. Inst. 75, 426–429. Verwerft, M., Van Tendeloo, G., Van Landuyt, J. and Amelinckx, S. (1988). Ferroelectrics 88, 27–36. Vetrano, J.S., Bruemmer, S.M. and Robertson, I.M. (1995). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 404, 177–182. Vetrano, J.S., Bruemmer, S.M., Pawlowski, L.M. and Robertson, I.M. (1997). Mat. Sci. Eng. A 238, 101–107. Volkov, V.V. and Zhu, Y. (2000). J. Magn. Magn. Mat. 214, 204–216. Volkov, V.V., Zhu, Y. and Malac, M. (2004). Philos. Mag. 84, 2607–2617. Vook, R.W. (1994). Mat. Chem. Phys. 36, 199–216. Vystavel, T., Palasantzas, G., Koch, S.A. and De Hosson, J.T.M. (2003a). App. Phys. Lett. 82, 197–199. Vystavel, T., Palasantzas, G., Koch, S.A. and De Hosson, J.T.M. (2003b). App. Phys. Lett. 83, 3909–3911. Wall, M.A. and Barbee, T.W., Jr. (1997). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 480, 245–250. Wall, M.A. and Dahmen, U. (1998). Microsc. Res. Tech. 42, 248–254. Wall, M.A., Barbee, T.W. and Weihs, T.P. (1995). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 404, 43–48. Walsh, C.A. (1989). Philos. Mag. A 59, 227–246. Wang, M.H. and Chen, L.J. (1992). J. App. Phys. 71, 5918–5925. Wang, Y.G. and Petford-Long, A.K. (2002). J. App. Phys. 92, 6699–6707.
Chapter 6 In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy Wang, Z.L., Gao, R.P., Pan, Z.W. and Dai, Z.R. (2001). Adv. Eng. Mat. 3, 657–661. Wang, Z.L., Dai, Z.R., Gao, R. and Gole, J.L. (2002a). J. Electron Microsc. 51 (Supplement), S79–85. Wang, Z.L., Gao, R.P., de Heer, W.A. and Poncharal, P. (2002b). App. Phys. Lett. 80, 856–858. Wang, L. and Yang, J.C. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1902–1909. Wang, M.S., Wang, J.Y., Chen, Q. and Peng, L.M. (2005). Adv. Funct. Mat. 15, 1825–1831. Watanabe, S., Haishi, Y., Suda, T., Ohnuki, S., Takahashi, H. and Kiritani, M. (2002). Radia. Eff. Def. Sol. 157, 101–108. Werner, M., Weber, E.R., Bartsch, M. and Messerschmidt, U. (1995). Phys. Stat. Sol. A 150, 337–341. Williamson, M.J., Tromp, R.M., Vereecken, P.M., Hull, R. and Ross, F.M. (2003). Nature Mat. 2, 532–536. Wise, M.E., Biskos, G., Martin, S.T., Russell, L.M. and Buseck, P.R. (2005). Aerosol Sci. Tech. B, 849–856. Wu, Y. and Yang, P. (2001). J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 123, 3165. Xu, H.P., Li, Q., Feng, D., Shen, G.J., Guan, Q.C. and Wang, J.Y. (1993). Ferroelectrics 146, 137–144. Xu, Z., Tan, X., Han, P. and Shang, J.K. (2000). App. Phys. Lett. 76, 3732–3734. Xu, Z., Bai, X.D., Wang, E.G. and Wang, Z.L. (2005b). App. Phys. Lett. 87, 163106. Xu, Z., Bai, X.D., Wang, E.G. and Wang, Z.L. (2005a). J. Phys.—Cond. Matter. 17, L507–L512. Yamashita, J., Hirayama, H., Ohshima, Y. and Takayanagi, K. (1999). App. Phys. Lett. 74, 2450–2452. Yang, J.C., Kolasa, A.B., Gibson, J.M. and Yeadon, M. (1998). App. Phys. Lett. 73, 2841–2843. Yang, J.C., Evan, D. and Tropia, L. (2002). App. Phys. Lett. 81, 241–243. Yasuda, H. and Mori, H. (1999). J. Electron Microsc. 48, 581–584. Yasuda, H., Mori, H., Sakata, T., Naka, M. and Fujita, H. (1992). Philos. Mag. B 65, 1001–1009. Yasuda, H., Mori, H. and Furuya, K. (2000). Philos. Mag. Lett. 80, 181–186. Yasuda, H., Mitsuishi, K. and Mori, H. (2001). Phys. Rev. B 64, 094101/1–6. Yasuda, H., Mori, H. and Lee, J.G. (2004). Phys. Rev. B 70, 214105/1–6. Yeadon, M., Yang, J.C., Averback, R.S., Bullard, J.W., Olynick, D.L. and Gibson, J.M. (1997). App. Phys. Lett. 71, 1631–1633. Yi, G., Nicholson, W.A.P., Lim, C.K., Chapman, J.N., McVitie, S. and Wilkinson, C.D.W. (2004). Ultramicroscopy 99, 65–72. Yokota, T., Howe, J.M., Jesser, W.A. and Murayama, M. (2004). J. App. Phys. 95, 5756–5761. Yonenaga, I., Brown, P.D. and Humphreys, C.J. (1998). Mat. Sci. Eng. A 253, 148–150. Yonenaga, I., Werner, M., Bartsch, M., Messerschmidt, U. and Weber, E.R. (1999). Phys. Stat. Sol. A 171, 35–40. Yoo, J.H., Murakami, Y., Shindo, D. and Ohsuna, T. (2004a). Philos. Mag. 84, 2597–2606. Yoo, J.H., Murakami, Y., Shindo, D., Atou, T. and Kikuchi, M. (2004b). Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 047204/1–4. Yoshida, K., Yamasaki, J. and Tanaka, N. (2004). App. Phys. Lett. 84, 2542–2544. Yu, A.C.C., Lo, C.C.H., Petford-Long, A.K., Jiles, D.C. and Miyazaki, T. (2002a). J. App. Phys. 91, 780–784.
533
534
F.M. Ross Yu, A.C.C., Petford-Long, A.K., O’Grady, K. and Miyazaki, T. (2002b). J. App. Phys. 91, 5234–5239. Zerrouk, T.E.A., Hamichi, M., Pilkington, J.D.H. and Venables, J.A. (1994). Phys. Rev. B 50, 8946–8949. Zghal, S., Coujou, A. and Couret, A. (2001). Philos. Mag. A 81, 345. Zhang, L.H., Johnson, E. and Dahmen, U. (2004). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 821, 181–186. Zhang, M., Olson, E.A., Twesten, R.D., Wen, J.G., Allen, L.H., Robertson, I.M. and Petrov, I. (2005). J. Mat. Res. 20, 1802–1807. Zhou, G. and Yang, J.C. (2002). Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 106101/1–4. Zhou, G. and Yang, J.C. (2003). Surface Sci. 531, 359–367. Zhou, G., Yang, J.C., Xu, F., Barnard, J.A. and Zhang, Z. (2002). Mat. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 737, F6.3. Zhu, Y. and De Graef, M., Eds. (2001). Magnetic Imaging and Its Applications to Materials. (Academic Press, San Diego). Zielinski, W., Swiatnicki, W., Barstch, M. and Messerschmidt, U. (2003). Mat. Chem. Phys. 81, 476–479. Zimmermann, C.G., Yeadon, M., Nordlund, K., Gibson, J.M., Averback, R.S., Herr, U. and Samwer, K. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 1163–1166.
7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET) Juergen M. Plitzko and Wolfgang Baumeister
Clearly, if recent improvements in electron microscopes are to be fully utilized in biology, contrast must be enhanced without drastic molecular alteration of the specimen or obscuration by extraneous material. . . . Thus the polytropic montage seems to offer a means of determining the three-dimensional structures of low-contrast biological specimens at a resolution of 3 Å, or the best resolution attainable with existing electron microscopes. (Hart, 1968)
1 Introduction More than 70 years have now passed since the invention of the first transmission electron microscope (Knoll and Ruska, 1932; Ruska, 1987). Many reports and publications have been written covering the technological achievements in electron microscopy (EM) and more important the scientific breakthroughs related to the information disclosed by EM studies. EM, in its various “flavors” (see below), is now a wellestablished method in life as well as in material science. Therefore, almost every laboratory in the field of structural analysis is equipped with one or several low or intermediate voltage microscopes for routine use and in some instances for high-end applications. However, compared to light microscopy, EM is still a “young” method but with great potential for further improvements. This has been shown, especially in the past decade: among the highlights are the incorporation of energy filters, monochromators, aberration correctors, and above all the almost complete replacement of negative plates by charge coupled device (CCD) cameras and imaging plates. By all means, these technical achievements have been supported by the development of the computer and its availability throughout science. The various techniques in EM, such as bright field (BF) or dark field (DF) imaging, weak beam imaging, conventional transmission EM (CTEM), high-resolution TEM or EM (HRTEM or HREM), scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM), energy-filtered TEM (EFTEM), and many others, have been improved and, moreover, expanded with the computer power on hand. Today’s most modern techniques are all based on automated acquisition
535
536
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
and alignment procedures, reconstruction algorithms, and especially on elaborate image processing routines. Here, we address the advances made in biological EM and especially in cryo-EM. Biological structures can be, by and large, characterized as pleiomorphic. Just as every human being has a different face, cells, proteins, and macromolecular complexes have different shapes and forms, designed for a higher functional purpose. It is far from random and instead of addressing them as “amorphic” or “amorphous,” as in physics for randomly ordered solids, they are called “pleiomorphic” or “pleiomorph.” Moreover, the inside of a cellular structure resembles the image of a giant factory, where the single constituents act together, building highly specific molecular machines and, if necessary, change their purpose (Alberts, 1998). Therefore it is a highly variable and dynamic environment. Every intrusion into this fragile system can lead to changes. The suitable preparation for a final characterization with the EM is a major challenge. And it is likewise a challenge in terms of the environment inside EMs: an ultrahigh vacuum and electron radiation. Despite the fact that biologists were impressed by the resolving power of the EM, they remained very sceptical about the usefulness of the EM in structural biology. The major drawback was and still is the sensitivity to radiation of the biological samples. After a few minutes exposure to the electron beam the biological substance in question is literally “incinerated.” However, the present knowledge about the ultrastructure of cells, viruses, and other biological substances was accumulated by EM investigations with, at that time, suitable preparation techniques. Higher vacuum resistance was achieved by dehydration and water-substitution methods, beam resistance was increased by staining the samples with heavy metals (Brenner and Horne, 1959), and, in addition, enhanced contrast and transparency were obtained by sectioning, e.g., “big” cells in slices about 200 nm thick, with ultramicrotomes (Porter and Blum, 1953). These preparation techniques enabled biologists to establish the basis of a common image of the cell’s interior. Nevertheless, this “image” remained incomplete and was still at a resolution far above that potentially available with the EM. Additionally the samples were altered by these preparation methods, thus complicating and limiting image interpretation. In some instances the artifacts introduced even misled scientists. Although these preparation techniques are still used in various ways, but there was an obvious need for far more reliable and less harmful procedures. In 1981 Dubochet and McDowall introduced a new means of sample preservation for EM investigations: the cryotechnique. Without doubt, cryopreparation is one of if not the greatest development in biological EM. Instead of replacing the water or dehydrating the whole system, the biological substance is embedded within its original buffer solution or simply water by rapidly freezing at very low temperatures, namely the temperature of liquid nitrogen (∼90 K). This way the water was transferred into an amorphous state, inhibiting crystallization, and thus disruption of the cell due to the volume increase of crystalline water. This plunge-freezing technique revolutionized the field of structural
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
biology, because for the first time it was possible to investigate biological samples in their native state, without introducing any artifacts, corroborating image interpretation. Excluding artifacts was clearly one achievement in obtaining higher resolved images of biological structures, but since these structures are pleiomorphic, single two-dimensional (2D) images are clearly insufficient for a complete structural characterization, which can only be done three-dimensionally (3D). Additionally, due to the large depth of focus of the EM, images represent only 2D projections of the specimen, in which almost all information about the third dimension is lost. As mentioned, sectioning can help, and especially serial sectioning, where the structure of interest, e.g., big cells, is serially sliced. However, serial sectioning was previously done only on epoxy resin-embedded samples, limited in resolution to the section slice thickness (∼50 nm) and having lost any information about the molecular organization. But it was evident that information retrieval down to the supramolecular level for all three dimensions is absolutely crucial for an in-depth structural analysis of native biological samples. In the late 1960s and early 1970s three groups independently experimented with the possibility of 3D microscopy, namely electron tomography (Hart, 1968; DeRosier and Klug, 1968; Hoppe et al., 1968; Hoppe, 1974). Perhaps inspired by the tomographic methods invented for medical examinations (Cormack, 1963, 1980; Hounsfield, 1972) they developed acquisition schemes to access the 3D information by recording images from different orientations or from differently oriented particles. DeRosier and Klug (1968) studied the helical tails of T4bacteriophages and with a single EM they were able to present a complete 3D reconstruction. By selecting an object with the a priori knowledge of its helical symmetry they avoided a complicated data acquisition procedure. In the same year Hart (1968) reported very precisely on his idea: the “polytropic montage.” He investigated the rodshaped tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). Hart and later Hoppe have chosen a more complicated and cumbersome acquisition process: the manual rotation of the object perpendicular to the incoming electron beam and the acquisition of single projections from different viewing angles. They reported on the 3D representation from a series of images acquired over a large angular regime. In the late 1960s, when the average electron microscopist used photographic plates, these procedures were inevitably very cumbersome and time consuming and of course reconstruction calculations were possible only with large supercomputers. Nevertheless, with the introduction of CCD cameras for image recording in EM in the late 1980s (Mochel and Mochel, 1986) and the introduction of computer-controlled EMs attempts (Figure 7–1) were made to improve the pioneering work with the prospect of implementing it for routine and fast use (Typke et al., 1991; Koster et al., 1992, 1997). With the addition of suitable preparation techniques such as cryofixation of biological specimens, cryo-EM promised to be the method of choice for further structural work in molecular biology. Nevertheless, it was not until the mid-1990s that the first reports on applications on automated cryo-electron tomography appeared (Horowitz et al., 1994;
537
538
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
Figure 7–1. Transmission electron microscopes (TEM) in the past and today. a) 1939; First commercial TEM (‘Siemens Super Microscope’) from Siemens & Halske Ltd., Berlin, Germany. b) 2002; Tecnai F30 Helium (‘Polara’) from FEI company, Eindhoven, The Netherlands as installed at the MPI of Biochemistry in Martinsried (near Munich), Germany. A computer controlled TEM dedicated for cryo-electron microscopy, which allows cooling to liquid nitrogen (90 K) and helium temperature (∼10 K).
Dierksen et al., 1995; Grimm et al., 1996a; Walz et al., 1997a; Nitsch et al., 1998), now abbreviated cryo-ET or, for the extended community, three-dimensional electron microscopy (3DEM). Today, cryo-EM is established in the field of structural biology and three different techniques are building the base for 3D characterization: electron crystallography (cryo-EC), single-particle EM (cryo-EM), and electron tomography (cryo-ET). In the following we will describe and explain one of these tomographic approaches, namely cryo-ET (Frank, 1992, 1996), in detail.
2 Three-Dimensional Cryoelectron Microscopy 2.1 Principles of 3D Imaging The main contrast mechanism in cryo-EM is phase contrast. In firstorder approximation, the micrograph is an interference pattern of the primary beam and the focused scattered beam. In this so-called weak phase approximation, the electrostatic potential of the sample is the quantity that is imaged. To create a phase delay between the primary and scattered beams, the objective lens has to be defocused. The
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
imaging process of weakly scattering objects in a TEM can be summarized elegantly by introducing a contrast transfer function (CTF) in Fourier space (Reimer, 1993). In this notation, the image Ixy of an 3D object with an electrostatic potential Vxyz can be written as
[
]
I xy = F −1 CTFkx ,ky ⋅ F ( ∫ dzVxyz ) .
Here, F denotes the Fourier transform and kx and ky denote the reciprocal vectors. The CTF is an oscillating function of the defocus value ∆z, which is damped by an envelope function. The envelope function finally limits the resolving power of a TEM. To achieve high-resolution data in biological EM, the use of a field emission gun (FEG) instrument with a high coherence and brightness is mandatory (Baumeister and Typke, 1993), since the increased temporal and spatial coherence reduces the damping of the envelope function (Frank, 1973). The oscillatory behavior of the CTF leads to contrast inversion of Ixy for certain frequency bands. Provided the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of Ixy is sufficient, Ixy can be corrected for these CTF effects, but CTF correction will not be feasible close to the zeros of the CTF where hardly any signal is transferred. In single particle analysis or cryoelectron crystallography, images of different focus levels are recorded to avoid that problem; the data of different focus levels can then be combined in a so-called focus series (Schiske, 1968, 1973; Typke, 1992), which ensures data coverage in Fourier space without gaps around CTF zeros. Through-focus series reconstruction is particularly suitable in material science studies where high magnifications combined with a high dose can be utilized almost without restrictions to determine the atomic positions even for very light elements in crystalline specimen (Thust et al., 1994, 1996; Coene et al., 1996; Kisielowski et al., 2001). However, in low-dose EM, the CTF is often not easily accessible due to the low SNR, in particular if a CCD camera is used as a detecting device. Therefore, the first zero crossing of the CTF often limits the attainable resolution in a cryoelectron micrograph, for example, in cryo-ET. Since an EM image is essentially a projection, features from different z-levels within the object overlap in the resulting micrograph and cannot be separated. The traditional way to extract meaningful information from an electron micrograph is to reduce the z-dimension of the object, i.e., to image almost 2D objects. In biological imaging of cells this was accomplished by sectioning the previously fixed object using an ultramicrotome (Porter and Blum, 1953). By means of serial sectioning even 3D data could be obtained by imaging successive sections belonging to the same cell. In this case, the achievable resolution in z depends on the thickness of the sections; the best resolution attained was in the range of 50 nm. However, the combination of serial sectioning with tomographic data acquisition (see below) offers the possibility of improving the resolution (Soto et al., 1994; Mueller-Reichert et al., 2003). A different approach is to combine different views of the specimen to derive 3D information (Figure 7–2). The cryo-EM methods for obtaining 3D data can be summarized as tomographic or at least quasitomographic. They all rely on the fact that the parallel projection of a 3D object corresponds to a slice in the 3D Fourier space of the object. This
539
540
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
Figure 7–2. The Figure 7-shows a single axis tilt series data acquisition scheme. The object is represented by a pleiomorphic object (in this case a knot) to emphasize the fact that electron tomography can retrieve 3D information from non-repetitive structures. a) A set of 2D projection images is recorded while the specimen is tilted incrementally around an axis perpendicular to the electron beam, and projection images of the same area are recorded on a CCD camera at each tilt angle. Tilt range is typically ±70° with tilt increments between 1.5–3°. b) The backprojection method explains the principle of 3D reconstruction in a fairly intuitive manner. For each weighted projection, a backprojection body is calculated, and the sum of all projection bodies represents the density distribution of the original object—the tomogram.
“projection-slice theorem” and the possibility of restoring the 3D data using their projections were first discovered by Radon (1917). An English translation of this paper can be found in Deans (1983). To obtain the 3D information, different slices of the Fourier space, i.e., projections in real space, have to be gathered to sample the entire information. Different orientations of the sample can be realized by changing the orientation of the specimen. For this purpose the specimen has to be rotated, as is the case in electron crystallography or ET, or identical copies of a specimen that occur in different orientations can be reconstructed in a 3D model as in “single particle” analysis. In the field of EM, those tomographic methods for 3D structure determination were proposed in the late 1960s (Hart, 1968; Hoppe et al., 1968) and realized in the pioneering work of DeRosier and Klug (1968). 2.2 The Single-Particle Approach One powerful advantage of EM is the fact that it produces projection images, unlike X-ray crystallography, which yields diffraction data with no information on the position; this is known as the “phase problem.” Thus, images may be treated in real space as well as in Fourier space and there is no difference between those that contain information about a single molecule without any internal symmetry and those generated by a 2D crystalline array. This fact is exploited in the so-called single-particle approach, which enables the electron microscopist to determine 3D density maps of individual macromolecules (Frank, 1996). Depending on a variety of conditions the 3D models show near-atomic, or, in the more characteristic case, intermediate resolution (≥7 Å) (Jiang et al., 2003a; Spahn et al., 2001).
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
541
Projection images from macromolecules contain information about the 3D structure as 2D density profiles, characteristic of the particular orientation of the particles in the electron beam (Figure 7–3). To disentangle molecular substructures in the third dimension a number of different images of known projection geometry have to be combined. Protein complexes not too large in size are usually oriented arbitrarily in vitrified ice, so that even one EM image contains many different projections of the isolated protein species (Figure 7–3A). Once the relative orientations of the particles are known, i.e., the three Eulerian angles (j, Y, q) defining the rotation of a particle around the axes in 3D space, their projections can be placed on the surface of a sphere centered on the origin of a common coordinate system. The Eulerian angles exactly define the positions of the projections that can now be backprojected centrally in such a way as to superimpose the 2D densities into a common 3D volume of the particle. The most popular and utilized reconstruction algorithm in real space is the so-called weighted backprojection (Radermacher, 1992; see Section 3.5.2). Very large macromolecular complexes, filamentous aggregates, or proteins embedded in biological membranes usually occur in preferred orientations in frozen samples. Here, and in cases where nonredundant structures such as singular protein assemblies are to be investigated, the specimen is tilted around a fixed axis at a certain angular incre-
Figure 7–3. Single particle investigation of the giant protein complex TPP II from Drosophila melanogaster embedded in vitrified ice. In eukaryotes, tripeptidyl peptidase II (TPPII) is a crucial component of the protein degradation pathway. The 150-kDa subunits of Drosophila TPPII assemble into a giant proteolytic complex of 6 MDa with a remarkable architecture consisting of two segmented and twisted strands that form a spindle-shaped structure (length 56 nm, width 24 nm). a) Cryo-electron micrograph of isolated TPP II complexes illustrating the very weak image contrast and the high level of noise. b) Averaging and classification of a large number of equivalent projections of separate molecules. Once a large set of views is available, a preliminary 3D reconstruction can be computed and refined iteratively. c) The 3D model obtained by cryo-electron microscopy, reveals details of the molecular architecture and, in conjunction with biochemical data, provides insight into the assembly mechanism. The building blocks of this complex are apparently dimers, within which the 150 kDa monomers are oriented head to head. Stacking of these dimers leads to the formation of twisted single strands, two of which comprise the fully assembled spindle (Rockel et al., 2002 and 2005). (See color plate.)
542
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
ment in the EM to obtain a series of projections. This approach of electron tomography is applicable almost universally if the specimen is not too thick for the electrons to penetrate. Since the electron exposure must be restricted to a value low enough not to destroy the sensitive biological material, the images contain a high level of so-called “shot noise” (statistical variation in the number of electrons detected at each pixel in the image). Additionally electron scattering from elements low in atomic number (Z), like the constituents of most biological materials, e.g., carbon, oxygen, and hydrogen, produces very weak image contrast. Based on these facts biological structures are barely visible in single cryo-EM images. Furthermore the exact alignment of the particles becomes a challenge, which is tackled by averaging a large number of equivalent projections of separate molecules, thus reducing the noise level. For this purpose, the images of some 103 to 105 particles are sorted into distinct classes of views by multivariate statistical analysis (Van Heel and Frank, 1981). Once a large set of views is available, a preliminary 3D reconstruction can be computed and refined iteratively. Typically, molecular complexes must be large in size (>200 kDa; 1 Da = 1 U = 1.66 × 10−24 g) to provide sufficient signal for the alignment at high resolution. If the particles possess a high internal symmetry, e.g., virus capsids or regular structures like 2D crystals, the averaging and reconstruction process is simplified and the number of images necessary and the computation time are reduced. To determine the structural basis of the working mechanism of molecular machines we have to study the structures, positions, and interactions of their building blocks, i.e., their distinct subunits. Since the structure of protein–protein contacts is resolved only at near-atomic resolution it is hardly possible to identify molecular borders in 3D models of cryo-EM data by visual inspection. But the ability to identify elements of secondary structure, and α-helices in particular, at a resolution of about 6–8 Å, makes it possible to fit a previously determined (atomic) model of protein subunits or subcomplexes into 3D density maps of larger assemblies obtained by cryo-EM (Li et al., 2002; Bottcher et al., 1997). This approach, called “docking,” enables us to unravel the organization of macromolecular machines that cannot be structurally characterized otherwise. Right now researchers continue to develop quantitative criteria that can guide this operation (Volkmann and Hanein, 1999). Single–particle cryo-EM is a powerful but still slow method compared to X-ray crystallography, provided that for the latter welldiffracting crystals are available. The data collection and processing can extend over several months or longer even for specialists in the field. However, with the advent of computer-controlled electron microscopes data acquisition and analysis have become subject to the development of elaborate automation procedures that promise to reduce the time needed to create high-resolution 3D density maps of large macromolecular complexes considerably. The real bottleneck for investigations of known or still unknown molecular machines arose from another experimental task. Purification procedures commonly used in biochemistry tend to select stable
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
543
and abundant protein complexes only. Very large molecular machines, rare or transient macromolecular assemblies, complexes consisting of membrane spanning and soluble components, and all those held together by forces too weak to withstand the purification procedures, escape isolation or even detection. The lesson is twofold: We need new approaches for isolating or reconstituting fragile assemblies, and cryoEM of isolated single particles will probably not give us the whole truth. To address the full complexity of functional macromolecular assemblies noninvasive 3D imaging techniques have to take over to fulfill the task of studying the supramolecular architecture in its native, cellular context (Plitzko et al., 2002). The technique of cryo-ET is a “nouvelle route” with a great potential in the field of structural biology that promises to provide noninvasive and deep insight into the functional organization of the cellular proteome (Sali et al., 2003). 2.3 Cryoelectron Tomography CET is unique in the sense that it can image nonpurified macromolecules three-dimensionally. However, in terms of resolution, cryo-EC and single-particle analysis are currently superior, which makes cryoET a complementary method to the aforementioned. In contrast to these methods, cryo-ET does not involve implicit or explicit averaging of the specimen, which makes it a suitable method for imaging of pleiomorphic objects. Therefore it is suitable to image entire cells (Grimm et al., 1998; Medalia et al., 2002; Kuerner et al., 2005; Nicastro et al., 2000, 2005; Scheffel et al., 2005) or nonsymmetric viruses (Gruenewald et al., 2003) in situ (Figure 7–4). Furthermore it has the
Figure 7–4. Cellular cryo-electron tomography of the magnetotactic microorganism Magnetospirillum griphiswaldense. The entire bacterium is oriented like a compass needle inside the magnetic field in its search for optimal living conditions. The miniature cellular compass is made by a chain of single nano-magnets, called magnetosomes (the scale bar represents 200 nm). a) The two-dimensional image represents one projection (at 0°) from an angular tilt-series. b) x–y slices along the z axis through a typical three-dimensional reconstruction (tomogram). c) Surface-rendered representation of the inside of the cell showing the membrane (blue), vesicles (yellow), magnetite crystals (red) and a filamentous structure (green). Until now, it was not clear how the cells organise magnetosomes into a stable chain, against their physical tendency to collapse by magnetic attraction. However, the biochemical analysis revealed a protein responsible for the chain formation and the 3D investigation a cytoskeletal structure, which aligns the magnetosomes like pearls on a string (Scheffel et al., 2005). (See color plate.)
544
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
potential to unravel not only the structure but also the molecular interactions of the various macromolecules inside a cell (Beck et al., 2004). Whereas tomography of plastic embedded specimens (Marsh et al., 2001; Murk et al., 2003) reveals primarily data on the ultrastructure and morphology of a cell cryo-ET aims to resolve the cell at a molecular level. Although the SNR of a tomogram of a frozen hydrated specimen is generally worse than that of a plastic embedded specimen, more biologically significant information is contained in the high spatial frequencies since the preparation technique does not limit the interpretable information. A cryo-electron tomogram essentially depicts the entire proteome of a cell. Therefore, cryo-ET can make significant contributions to the larger enterprise of structural proteomics (Sali et al., 2003). It has the potential to unravel the interactions of the various proteins that reside not only in the cytoplasm but also in the cell membrane. Moreover, it can provide medium resolution structural characterization of complexes that are largely undescribed to date. A prerequisite for those contributions is sufficient resolution to recognize macromolecules in a cellular tomogram. The first published cryo-electron tomogram of a eukaryotic cell (Figure 7–5), the slime mould Dictyostelium discoideum, demonstrated that cryo-ET is able to resolve individual macromolecular complexes such as ribosomes or the 26S proteasome in the context of a cell (Medalia et al., 2002). Currently, cellular cryo-ET is effectively confined to relatively thin samples. Cells of a thickness beyond 1 µm are not transparent to the electron beam at a voltage of 300 kV. These cells are typically prokaryotic cells or unusually thin eukaryotic cells. Electron tomography of frozen hydrated sections of cells (Hsieh et al., 2002; Leis et al., 2005) can possibly extend the specimen class to thicker cells and even tissue cells. Unfortunately, the sectioning process still introduces severe artifacts; in particular, the forces that arise during the sectioning process tend to compress the cells strongly. The use of vibrating cryoknifes can possibly offer some remedy from these shortcomings (Al-Amoudi et al., 2003). The technique is promising, but it is far from being a routine preparation technique, as yet. To date, cryo-ET is effectively the only 3D imaging technique that can image cells or organelles in a close-to-native state at molecular resolution. It is of vital importance to have an imaging method that can image biological macromolecules since many of the complexes present in a cell tend to be fragile or transient. The detection of statistically significant distribution patterns can provide unprecedented information about the interaction of macromolecules, in transient complexes, for example. The basic problem that cryo-ET has to face is to derive statistically significant information from the initially very noisy tomograms. Interpretation of the raw data can be performed only by lowpass filtering the data to a resolution that is regarded as significant. Application of so-called “denoising” algorithms can extend this limit gradually and greatly improve the visualization of tomograms. These techniques mainly perform nonlinear filtering of the data (Frangakis
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
545
Figure 7–5. First electron tomographic investigation of a eukaryotic cell; the slime mould Dictyostelium discoideum embedded in vitrified ice. a) Phase contrast image and corresponding fluorescence image (inset) of cells on TEM grids. b) Cryo-electron micrograph at 0° tilt (conventional 2D projection) of a ∼200 nm thin peripheral region of the cell. c) Tomographic reconstruction from a complete tilt-series (120 images) and d) visualization by segmentation. Large macromolecular complexes, e.g. Ribosomes are shown in a green color, the actin filament network in orange-red and the cells’ membrane in blue. Cryo-tomograms of Dictyostelium discoideum cells grown directly on carbon support films have provided unprecedented insights into the organization of actin filaments in an unperturbed cellular environment. The tomograms show, on the level of individual filaments, their modes of interaction (isotropic networks, bundles, etc.), they allow us to determine the branching angles precisely (in 3-D), and they reveal the structure of membrane attachment sites (Medalia et al., 2002). (See color plate.)
and Hegerl, 2001; Jiang et al., 2003b). The main purpose of filtering/ “denoising” is to improve the visualization of the raw data and to facilitate interpretation primarily at the level of the ultrastructure. However, interpretation at the molecular level requires more quantitative methods.
546
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
A prerequisite for understanding the interaction of proteins is the localization of macromolecules in the cell. Practical ways to achieve this goal are labeling of macromolecules by specific and electron-dense markers (Koster and Klumperman, 2003) or recognition of individual particles by their known structural signature. The former is very hard to realize under in vivo conditions, whereas the latter requires sufficiently high resolution. Moreover, labeling techniques can be used for only a few macromolecules simultaneously since the different labels need to be distinguishable and specific. In the context of structural proteomics this makes recognition by means of the structural signature favorable since simultaneous recognition of molecules under at least close-to-native conditions is mandatory. It has been shown previously that the currently achieved resolution of cryo-ET should suffice to identify large protein complexes in the range of 1 MDa (Boehm et al., 2000). Moreover, detection of proteasomes (Lowe et al., 1995; Zwickl, 2000) and thermosomes (Klumpp et al. 1997; Klumpp and Baumeister, 1998) in phantom cells, which mimic real cells in size and composition with the advantage of being biochemically well defined, showed that this approach is also feasible experimentally (Frangakis et al., 2002). The approach used in these works requires structural knowledge from other sources; matched filtering of the tomograms with a structural template yields the locations and orientations of these complexes in the cell (see Section 3.5.4). Therefore, cryo-ET requires structural data from other techniques such as X-ray crystallography or single-particle analysis to obtain molecular information. The principal dose limitation of cryo-ET does not permit high-resolution structure determination on the basis of the tomogram alone. The dose fractionation theorem (Hegerl and Hoppe, 1976; McEwen et al., 1995) states that tomography images each volume element with the same statistical significance as a 2D projection acquired with the same overall dose. This makes tomographic data highly advantageous for location of features since the information is distributed over three dimensions. However, the statistical significance of each volume element is generally not sufficient to resolve macromolecules at the level of tertiary or quaternary structural elements initially. However, the combination of cryo-ET and single-particle averaging can offer a remedy for this; by averaging identical copies of complexes, they can potentially be resolved to at least a few nanometers. First realizations of the combination of cryo-ET and single-particle averaging have been reported for isolated proteins and yielded structures of 800-kDa protein complexes to ∼2 nm resolution (Nitsch et al., 1998); averaging of complexes directly from tomograms of organelles or viruses is a novel approach (Figure 7–6). First 2D results on the envelope complexes of dried and stained retroviruses indicated the potential of this approach (Zhu et al., 2003). Recent 3D results on the structure of the nuclear pore complex, a membrane complex that is difficult to assess by other techniques, taken from tomograms of entire nuclei, showed that this approach can yield structural characterization of unprecedented resolution (Beck et al., 2004, 2007).
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
547
Figure 7–6. CET in combination with the single particle approach of transport-competent Dictyostelium discoideum nuclei. a) Three-dimensional reconstruction of the peripheral rim of an intact nucleus. X-y slice of 10 nm thickness along the z axis through a typical tomogram. Side views of nuclear pore complexes (NPCs) are indicated by arrows. Ribosomes connected to the outer nuclear membrane are visible (arrowheads). Inset displays a phase-contrast image and the corresponding fluorescence image. b) Surface rendered representation of a segment of nuclear envelope (NPCs in blue, membranes in yellow). c) Structure of the Dictyostelium NPC after classification and averaging of subtomograms. Cytoplasmic face of the NPC (upper left); the cytoplasmic filaments are arranged around the central channel. Nuclear face of the NPC (upper right); the distal ring of the basket is connected to the nuclear ring by the nuclear filaments. Cross sectional view of the NPC (bottom). The dimensions of the main features are indicated. All views are surface-rendered (nuclear basket in brown; Beck et al. 2004). (See color plate.)
3 Major Difficulties in Cryoelectron Tomography Despite the fact that the acquisition process for ET sounds very simple and straightforward, the acquisition of a tomographic tilt series, especially from biological samples is, even today, a major technical challenge. The explanation will be given in the following sections addressing the five major obstacles (“core problems”) of ET: (1) sample preparation and preservation, (2) radiation sensitivity, (3) tilting geometry, (4) instrumentation (EM, energy filters, CCD detectors, etc.) and automation, and (5) alignment, reconstruction, and visualization. 3.1 Sample Preparation 3.1.1 Basics Biological objects such as cells consist mainly of water (more than 70%). Built up from carbon-based molecules, they form the essential framework of life but for a closer structural investigation with the EM they have to withstand a constant “bombardment” of fast electrons under ultrahigh vacuum conditions: clearly not the best starting points
548
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
and clearly conditions that are far from natural and extremely inhospitable. Indeed, the central goal in any EM study is the observation of structures down to the atomic level. Unlike material science studies, where the samples remain steady, biological specimens tend to be more “resistant” to an investigation with the EM. First they are exposed to ionizing radiation, namely electrons with speeds usually above 200,000 km/s, according to the acceleration voltage used. Second, the ultrahigh vacuum generates an ambient pressure far below the atmospheric pressure, and thus literally “sucks” out every shred of liquid, subsequently resulting in the implosion of the biological structure. Third, they are build up from carbon-based compounds plus elements with very low atomic numbers like hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen, and minute amounts of other low Z-elements, all very weak scatterers, in regard to their interaction with electrons, resulting in low-contrast images. Fourth, if we regard cellular structures of higher organisms, such as mammalian cells, they can easily reach sizes of tenth of micrometers in all three dimensions, and are therefore almost or effectively impenetrable to the electron beam. Fifth, the secrets of these structures are hidden in a highly crowded environment, the cytoplasm, where functional units like proteins, protein complexes, or even molecular machines are “densely packed,” literally touching each other. This “molecular crowding” (Ellis, 2001; Ellis and Minton, 2003) makes it difficult to separate them for structural characterization. Sixth and last, every cell is different, just as every human has a different face. Thus, single 2D projections will not provide a complete 3D characterization, and averaging techniques as in the so-called single-particle approach are therefore impractical. All six of these facts have to be addressed in any life science study and especially when investigating biological structures in a close-to-life state, quasi in vivo. The electron beam represents a form of ionizing radiation that is harmful to the health of any living organism. Clearly, we cannot shield the biological substance but we can try to extend its “life-span” during investigation before structural damage occurs. Researchers in the past have been ingenious in inventing preparation techniques for EM studies of biological samples. In the late 1950s staining techniques were introduced that addressed the first three issues at once (Brenner and Horne, 1959). Staining with salts from heavy metals (usually osmium or uranium salts) envelopes the structure of interest and after insertion into the EM the negative imprint of the structure can be observed. Moreover, it increases the contrast dramatically, according to the high atomic numbers of the metals used. However, the biological structure desiccates in the vacuum environment of the microscope and illumination by the electron beam literally incinerates whatever is left of the biological substance, leaving behind the imprint of the structure outlined by the staining substance. Staining and dehumidification alter the structure and, because of the nanocrystalline nature of the staining salts, limit the resolution, in the best cases, to approximately 2 nm. The major advantage of this technique is its simplicity (no special instrumentation is required), its speed, and the fact that
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
the negative “shadow” of the sample is almost unaffected by radiation damage. The obvious disadvantage is the highly “unnatural” state in which the investigation is performed, leading to artifacts and possible misinterpretations. To study larger objects such as cells or organelles staining has been combined with embedding in epoxy resins and subsequent sectioning with the help of ultramicrotomes (Porter and Blum, 1953). Despite the fact that almost all our ultrastructural knowledge of the cell interior is based on this technique, there are some obvious limitations. First the substitution material, e.g., epoxy resin, shrinks during hardening, thus deforming the original structure. Second the stain applied after sectioning reduces the resolution (as described above) and third a second shrinkage step of the section is observed after initial illumination in the EM. This effect can be as large as 30–40% in the direction of the electron beam and 5–10% in the plane perpendicular to it. Shrinkage of the initial section dimensions is caused by outgassing of the solid polymer in the ultrahigh vacuum and to a larger extent by the loss of mass due to radiation damage (Luther, 1992). However, shrinkage occurs early in the illumination process, so that preexposing the sample until the contraction is complete can help to stabilize the section. The total electron dose is therefore increased dramatically and can lead to dose-induced stain aggregation. After preexposure the sample remains steady for further investigation of the modified structures and can be reused almost indefinitely. 3.1.2 Cryopreparation In the 1970s researchers experimented on 2D protein crystals with the possibility of preserving specimen hydration in the EM (Taylor and Glaeser, 1973, 1974). However, In 1981 Dubochet and McDowall published their work on the vitrification of pure water for EM and in 1984 Adrian et al. reported the first successful investigation of a shockfrozen biological object, namely viruses, embedded in vitrified ice, now known as the cryopreparation technique. There is no doubt that this invention is one of the important milestones in life science EM studies, if not the most important. With this technique, scientists were, for the first time, able to investigate biological objects in a close-to-life state, quasi in vivo. The object-holders are commercially available copper grids with a diameter of 3 mm (Figure 7–7A). They can be purchased in different geometries, mesh formats, and with different coatings (Plano GmbH, Wetzlar, Germany; Ted Pella, Inc., Redding, CA; Quantifoil Micro Tools GmbH, Jena, Germany; Ermantraut et al., 1998). Typically these grids are coated with a very thin support foil, usually amorphous carbon with thicknesses ranging between 4 and 20 nm. Shock-freezing has to be done very fast and therefore a special apparatus is necessary. These “guillotine”-like instruments, so called plungers, permit freezing of the sample in milliseconds to a temperature of liquid nitrogen (∼90 K). To ensure a direct phase transformation from liquid to an amorphous (vitrified) solid, cryogens with very high cooling rates, like ethane or less frequently propane, are used (Figure 7–7B and C).
549
550
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
The grid is clamped in an inverse tweezer and vertically mounted into the plunging instrument. A droplet of a couple of microliters of the sample solution, either isolated protein complexes or whole cells in their buffer solution, is applied to the surface of the copper grid. Since only thin objects in the range of a couple of hundred nanometers (t ≤ 500 nm) are suitable for investigation with the EM, the sample volume, typically in the range of 1–4 µl, has to be reduced. This is done with a filter paper carefully brought either to one side or to both sides of the grid to remove excess liquid. This process is called blotting. To prevent any mechanically induced disruption of, e.g., cellular structures, blotting can be done from the backside of the grid (Figure 7–8). Depending on the duration of the blotting process, the viscosity of the sample solution, and the size of the object, the thickness of the resulting ice layer can be adjusted. It guarantees a complete vitrification, without the formation of unwanted and harmful ice crystals, which can already be observed with fluid layers exceeding a couple of micrometers.
Figure 7–7. Plunge freezing instrumentation. a) Typical arrangement of cells cultured on TEM grid just prior to plunging. The schematic indicates the dimensions. b) CAD (computer aided design) image of a home-build plunge freezing apparatus (Images courtesy of R. Gatz, MPI of Biochemistry, Martinsried (near Munich), Germany). The small reservoir (yellow) in the middle of the dewar (green) contains the liquid ethane, which is chilled by a surrounding bath of liquid nitrogen. The forceps, which hold the grid are attached to a weighted arm. When the arm is released by means of a foot-trigger, the grid is gravity-plunged into the ethane. The cross-sectional scetch (left part of image B) illustrates the ‘guillotine-like’ arrangement. c) The Vitrobot (FEI company, Eindhoven, The Netherlands), a ‘robot’ for vitrification, allows the control of environmental and all necessary processing parameters. (See color plate.)
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
Figure 7–8. Steps to be taken in the plunge freezing process. I Apply the solution containing protein complexes or cells (TEM grid illustrated in a cross sectional way). To remove the excess solution and thus adjust the ice layer thickness, II blotting is done with a filter paper, carefully brought to the frontor backside of the TEM grid. After blotting the remaining solution on the grid is rapidly plunged III into liquid ethane, and afterwards kept at all times at liquid nitrogen temperature to prevent contamination, crystallization or smelting of the amorphous (vitrified) ice layer. (See color plate.)
Existing cryoplungers are mainly home-built and vary in design. Quite recently commercially available instruments have been introduced with the additional ability to adjust and control some of the preparation parameters, such as humidity, temperature, and air pressure, in specially designed environmental chambers. Moreover the whole process, except for the application of the sample, which has to be done manually, is computer controlled and automated, to facilitate the sample preparation process and expand its reproducibility (Vitrobot, FEI company, Eindhoven, Netherlands). After vitrification, the sample is transferred in a cryoholder, specially designed to ensure that the sample remains in the frozen state at approximately liquid nitrogen temperature. If, by any chance, the temperature drops below −160°C the possibility that the vitrified ice will start to crystallize increases. Therefore during transfer and during the subsequent investigation, frozen-hydrated samples have to be kept at all times at liquid nitrogen temperature and below −160°C, which resulted in the name cryoelectron microscopy. Compared to the commonly used techniques, cryopreparation allows us to preserve the native structure of the cytoplasm and the whole arrangement within the cell and even the physiological state at the moment of plunging. We thus circumvent alterations or modifications as seen with staining or epoxy resin embedding. The technique is
551
552
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
much more sophisticated and the result of the preparation is not known until a look is taken through the EM. The task of determining suitable processing parameters for the material at hand, to get, in the end, the best preparation result for an in-depth investigation of the biological structure, can therefore be very tedious. 3.1.3 Cryosectioning While plunge-freezing is now almost routinely used for the preparation of purified and isolated macromolecular complexes as well as for prokaryotic and very small eukaryotic cells, larger bulky structures, such as big mammalian cells or larger organelles, cannot be addressed as a whole for EM investigations. However, the technique of sectioning using ultramicrotomes, likewise known from epoxy resin-embedded samples, has been adapted for the use in combination with highpressure frozen samples. To obtain a vitrified sample of a specimen tenths of micrometers in dimension, plunge-freezing as described above is not sufficient, because of its limited “depth of vitrification,” explained by the freezing rate, which is, for example 106°C/s for pure water. If the sample dimensions exceed approximately 10 µm, vitrification is incomplete, which will result in the formation of cubic ice crystals. Therefore, high-pressure freezing is the method of choice, because the increase in pressure will lower the freezing rate (Moore, 1987). The lowest values are observed around 2000 bar, where the depth of vitrification increases up to 10 times as compared to freezing at ambient pressures (Sartori et al., 1993). The sample material, e.g., a cell suspension, is forced into a 15-mm-long copper tube with an inner diameter of approximately 0.3 mm. Afterward a pressure of 2000 bar builds up in a few milliseconds and, as soon as the pressure is established, cooling of the specimen, e.g., with a jet of pressurized liquid nitrogen, takes place. Before cutting the sections the copper jacket has to be removed using the cryo-ultramicrotome, designed to enable cutting at liquid nitrogen temperature. This is normally done with a diamond trimming device to form a square face of about 150–200 µm. Subsequent sectioning can be carried out using a diamond or a good glass knife (Figure 7–9). Cutting conditions such as knife-angle, cutting speed and stroke time, and temperature of the specimen, of the knife, and of the surrounding liquid nitrogen gas can be adjusted according to the specimen properties and the desired section thickness. However, the optimum sectioning conditions have to be found empirically in each experiment. In contrast to conventional room temperature sectioning, where the sections are floated on water, cryosections have to be transferred manually to an EM grid with an eyelash, a tedious procedure that requires patience and great skill. The sections tend to attract contaminating ice crystals in the preparation chamber of the cryoultramicrotome and during transfer to the EM. Furthermore they are generally not flat and exhibit cutting artifacts, e.g., deformation, crevasses, chatter, and knife marks (for a complete description of cryosectioning and related cutting artifacts see Dubochet et al., 1988; Frederik et al., 1991; Michel et al., 1991; Sitte, 1996; Al-Amoudi et al., 2005).
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
553
Figure 7–9. Cryo-sectioning. a) Cross-sectional schematic of the cryo-sectioning process with a cryo-ultramicrotome. b) View into the cryo-ultramicrotome during sectioning. The inset shows a magnification of the trimmed copper tube and the ‘ribbon’ formed after several cutting cycles. c) Low-magnification image of a cryo-section placed on a TEM grid. d) Cryo-electron micrograph at higher magnification of the sectioned cells (unicellular red algae Cyanidioschyzon merolae; images courtesy of A. Leis and L. Andrees, MPI of Biochemistry, Martinsried, Germany). The cutting artefacts are clearly visible.
While the idea of high-pressure freezing and cryosectioning is relatively old (Moore and Riehle, 1968; Bernhard, 1965) and commercially available instruments have been available for almost 20 years, its impact on biological and biomedical research has been comparatively small, owing to the fact that its use in combination with cryoultramicrotomy is still technically difficult, the yield of good micrographs is low, and the cutting artifacts in most of the sections complicate subsequent image analysis. However, in recent years cryosectioning was somehow rediscovered, and improvements have been made to facilitate the freezing and cutting procedure and to minimize the influence of cutting artifacts (Studer and Gnaegi, 2000; Al-Amoudi et al., 2003). Cryosec-
554
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
tioning to fabricate thicker sections of 150–200 nm for cryo-ET studies or even serial sectioning, likewise used in room temperature experiments (Soto et al., 1994), in combination with cryo-ET would definitely help in the 3D investigation of larger structures. The production of undistorted vitrified sections remains a specialized task and it is by no means a routinely used technique. Nevertheless the prospects for the future of cryosectioning in combination with cryo-ET are promising (Hsieh et al., 2002; Leis et al., 2005). 3.2 Radiation Sensitivity—Beam Damage When biological specimens are irradiated by the electron beam in the EM, the specimen structure is damaged as a result of ionization and subsequent chemical reactions. Ionization occurs if energy is deposited in the specimen as a result of inelastic scattering events. This can primarily induce the heating of the sample in the irradiated area, radiochemical decomposition of water (radiolysis), as well as secondary chemical reactions (breaking of chemical bonds, formation of new molecules or even radicals). Unlike materials science, where beam damage is almost negligible, radiation damage in life sciences is the fundamental limitation in any cryo-EM investigation. The damage that occurs depends on the number of electrons transmitted through the sample. Therefore the current density per unit area j (A/cm2) multiplied by the exposure time t (s) has been chosen as an appropriate measure for the electron dose (C/cm2, or e−/Å2, e− = electrons). This is not the same as the definition in radiochemistry, where the dose is defined in units of gray; the energy adsorbed per unit weight (Gy = J/kg). According to the last definition, a carbon sample exposed to 50 e−/Å2 generated by a 300 kV source would correspond to a dose of 1.6 × 108 Gy, which, e.g., can be observed in the vicinity of a nuclear reaction! Since the amount of damage is proportional to the applied dose, and the amount of exposure received by the specimen escalates with the square of the magnification, it is clear that this is the fundamental limitation in HREM of biological materials. However, several measures can be taken to partially evade this dilemma. Although the ionization processes are not temperature dependent, the resulting beam damage, e.g., bubbling, mass loss, diffusion of free radicals, is. Therefore, by lowering the temperature to, for example, liquid nitrogen temperature (∼190°C), radiation damage effects can be drastically reduced. Cooling the sample from room temperature to 90 K, the “lifetime” (the time the sample can be investigated before structural damage is observed) can be increased by a factor of approximately nine, the so called cryoprotection factor Cp (Knapek, 1982; Conway et al., 1993; Stark et al., 1996). This cryoprotection factor is given by the ratio of the critical dose Ne at different temperatures (Ne is defined as the dose at which the diffraction intensity has fallen to 1/e (∼37%) of its original value (Hayward and Glaeser, 1979). Further cooling to liquid helium temperature (∼4 K) has been proven to be advantageous for very thin specimens as used for electron crystallography or even in selected cases for single particle
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
555
work [Cp ∼ 2, if compared to liquid nitrogen studies (Fujiyoshi, 1998)]. However, the benefit of liquid helium cooling is still a subject of discussion, especially for cryo-ET, where cells embedded in thick ice layers are typically used. Unfortunately, the cryoprotection can be determined quantitatively only by measuring the fading of the electron diffraction patterns using 2D protein crystals. The transfer of these findings to frozen-hydrated specimens of, for example, cellular structures, where in most cases no crystalline arrays are present, remains difficult and therefore these values can be regarded as only a rough estimate. Moreover, the experiments made at helium temperature indicate a change in the density of the vitrified ice (after an initial illumination of a couple of e−/Å2), from a low-density amorphous phase at liquid nitrogen temperature to a high-density form at liquid helium temperature, which could be responsible for the decreased contrast observed at around 9 K (Heide, 1984; Schweikert et al., 2007; Plitzko et al., 2004; Comolli and Downing, 2005; Wright, 2006). Regarding the complexity of the biological system at hand, every sample material will show a slightly different behavior during the investigation at low temperatures. High amounts of sugars, for example, either as ingredients of the buffer solution (DeCarlo et al., 1999) or the RNA content of the macromolecules, tend to increase the acceptable dose. Overall it can be said that electron damage at lower temperatures induces a gradual loss of high-resolution features, much slower than in room temperature experiments, and a reduced mass loss. However, at “very high doses” (>500 e−/Å2) extensive mass loss, the formation of bubbles, and various other dimensional changes can be seen in all cases (Figure 7–10).
Figure 7–10. Electron dose and radiation damage shown for vitrified samples. a) Cryo-electron micrograph of a ice embedded prokaryotic cell on lacey carbon film exposed to 50 e−/Å2. b) The same cell after an exposure to 500 e−/Å2. The adverse effect of increased electron exposure manifest at the carbon foil and within the cellular structure in the formation of bubbles and furthermore in the smelting of the ice (Images courtesy of S. Nickell, MPI of Biochemistry, Martinsried, Germany).
556
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
A second measure among the physical methods to improve the stability of the sample in the electron beam is the use of intermediate voltage instruments. The ionization probability is, in a first-order approximation, inversely proportional to the acceleration voltage. Thus increasing the acceleration voltage will increase the penetration depth and thus reduce the influence of multiple scattering. Unfortunately, transmission electron microscopes with, e.g., 1250 kV acceleration voltage are huge instruments extending over almost three stories of a regular building. The cost for the instrument and for all subsequent resources is immense, making it almost impossible to place it in a normal laboratory environment. Furthermore, the higher the voltage used the lower the recorded image contrast, which is undesirable in the case of ice-embedded biological samples, where scattering occurs mainly from low Z-elements. Therefore, only a few high-voltage EMs have been built and installed around the world at selected places. It is more practical to operate EMs in the intermediate voltage range, between 200 and 400 kV. Instruments with 300-kV guns are the most common and they represent a good compromise in costs and resulting performance. A last measure to reduce the exposure to electron radiation is the application of so-called “low-dose” acquisition schemes (Dierksen et al., 1992; Rath and Marko, 1997; see Section 3.4.7). Only during the time of recording electron micrographs is the electron beam allowed to illuminate the specimen. In all other cases the beam remains blanked. Additionally, the microscope can be preset in different states, to reduce the amount of time needed for changing the magnification or the adjustment of other electron optical parameters, during the process of screening, focusing, and final image acquisition. It is obvious that this “low-dose” approach became possible only with the introduction of computer-controlled instruments with the necessary stability and reproducibility in the illumination system. During the acquisition of a tilt series in electron tomography, where typically 100–200 images are recorded, it is essential that the total applied dose stays below a critical value, which is given by the specific sample at hand. Most biological materials can tolerate an exposure of no more than 10 e−/Å2 to 100 e−/Å2, at which point major changes will have become evident in the structure of the specimen. According to the dose-fractionation theorem (Hegerl and Hoppe, 1976), the integrated dose of a conventional 2D image is likewise sufficient for a 3D reconstruction, if the resolution and the statistical significance between the two are identical. It is therefore feasible to distribute the total applied dose among as many statistically “noisy” 2D images as possible. A total applied dose of 50 e−/Å2 distributed among 100 2D images over an angular range would correspond to 0.5 e−/Å2 per image. Thus the resulting single images will be of a very noisy quality. Depending on the detection device utilized the statistical fluctuations from one picture element (pixel) to another can be much greater than the inherent change in image intensity from one pixel to another, i.e., the statistical fluctuations may exceed the inherent contrast. While the structure of interest is well preserved, it is impossible to observe the structural
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
detail because of the noisy quality of the image, associated with the very low SNR. Therefore it is very important that the quality and the performance of the detection device are sufficient to record images, even at very low doses (see Section 3.4.5). While the radiation sensitivity of biological samples restricts the exposure to the electron beam, the detection device fundamentally limits the resolution of the recorded tomogram. Investigations on ice-embedded biological samples under low-dose conditions can literally be described as “cloak-and-dagger operations” and only by means of appropriate data acquisition schemes and image analysis methods, i.e., tomographic methods, can the structural “secret” of the biological entity be disclosed. 3.3 Tilting Geometry 3.3.1 Single-Axis Tilting The quality of a tomographic reconstruction is furthermore dependent on the tilting geometry within an electron microscope. In contrast to computer-assisted tomography (CT), tilting the specimen through the complete angular regime of 180° within the EM is not possible. For the collection of a single-axis tilt series, the specimen is typically tilted around ±70° in very small increments between 0.5° and 3° and an image of the same object area is recorded for every tilt angle. This restricted tilt range is due to the limited spacing within the objective lens polepieces, the slab geometry of the holder, and moreover the planar geometry of the object itself. At higher tilt angles (e.g., ±90°) the electron beam is blocked by the holder and eventually by the bars of the copper grid, depending on the location of the structure within a mesh of the grid. This angular gap can be nicely illustrated in reciprocal space (respectively, Fourier space), where a wedge-shaped “blind” region is formed, the so-called “missing wedge” (Figure 7–11A). However, the requirement for a distortion-free 3D reconstruction, all projections of the sample over the complete tilt range (±90°) (Barnard et al., 1992), is not fulfilled, thus leading to imperfections in the reconstructed object. There are mainly two types of distortions that can be distinguished. First the resolution of the 3D reconstruction will be direction dependent. The resolution parallel to the tilt axis dx will be determined by the resolution of the instrument itself. Perpendicular to the direction of the tilt axis, the resolution dy will be directly related to the angular increment α0 and thus to the number of projections N. The relationship between resolution dy, increment α0, and the amount of projections N for a spherical object with diameter D is given by the Crowther theorem (Hoppe, 1969; Crowther et al., 1970), based on the projection slice theorem (Radon, 1917): dy = π ⋅
D N
The reconstruction of a 200 nm-thick cell (assuming that the cell is spherical), with a resolution of 2 nm, requires 320 projections with an angular increment of 0.6°. The Crowther expression assumes that the N projections cover the full angular space of ±90°. Therefore the angular
557
558
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
Figure 7–11. The diagrams show schematically the sectors in the Fourier domain, which remain unsampled owing to the limited tilt range (here ± 60°). a) In single-axis tilting there is a ‘missing wedge’. b) In dual-axis tilting a ‘missing pyramid’. The artefacts resulting from the missing information are shown below for an ideal thin-walled vesicle. In the single-axis case, the vesicle walls perpendicular to the tilt axis and the poles of the vesicle are poorly represented in the reconstruction. In the two-axis case, only the poles of the vesicle are affected by the missing information. In both cases, the same threshold level has been applied.
gap has to be included to determine the maximum achievable resolution in a tomogram, which directly implicates the second type of distortion that can be observed in ET: features will become elongated in the direction of the missing wedge. A spherical object, for example, a gold bead, will be elongated in its 3D reconstruction. This elongation can be described with the elongation factor eyz, which includes the maximum tilt angle α (Radermacher and Hoppe, 1980): e yz =
α + sin α ⋅ cos α α − sin α ⋅ cos α
The resolution in the third direction dz, the “depth direction,” is therefore further degraded to dz = dy ⋅ eyz To provide the maximum amount of 3D information, as many projections as possible should be acquired over as wide a tilt range as pos-
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
sible. In practice the molecular resolution is not limited by the Crowther criterion but by the structural preservation of the specimen and the signal recording and the noise (see above). Moreover, the size and the shape of the recorded object are poorly defined, especially in cellular tomography, where the cellular structure itself consists of objects of various sizes. However, it remains a useful guide for the expected resolution for a 3D reconstruction. 3.3.2 Dual-Axis Tilting To reduce the missing information space in single-axis tomography, the acquisition of a second single-axis tilt series, where the tilt axis is rotated in-plane by 90°, can offer some remedy. Dual-axis tilting will reduce the “missing wedge” to a “missing pyramid” and thus increase the amount of information up to almost 20% (Figure 7–11B). Although the maximum resolution is not necessarily increased, the achievable resolution is definitely more isotropic. Moreover, structures that are “hidden” in the single-axis case, because of their orientation relative to the tilt axis and their location in regard to the missing wedge, will emerge in a dual-axis acquisition scheme. However, dual-axis tilting for cryoapplications is demanding in two ways. First, special cryoholders have to be built, to enable the physical 90° rotation at liquid nitrogen temperatures within the EM (Nickell et al., 2003; Gatan, Pleasanton, USA). Second, for the 3D reconstruction both tilt series have to be combined as accurately as possible, which demands refined alignment routines (Penczek et al., 1995; Mastronarde, 1997; Nickell et al., 2007). It is clear that acquisition of a dual-axis tilt series requires either lowering the dose further or reducing the number of projections to preserve the structure under investigation, to comply with the requirements stated above. Dual-axis tilt cryoholders are now commercially available, which allows either a discrete or semicontinuous in-plane rotation by 90° (Gatan, Pleasanton, CA). The continuous rotation, implemented in side-entry cryoholders, simplifies the “tracking” (see Section 3.5.7) at lower magnifications of the sample during the in-plane rotation because the sample stays inside the objective. The discrete rotation is done “outside” the objective lens system but within the vacuum of the system, making it sometimes tedious to recenter the region of interest after the in-plane rotation. Despite the missing information in Fourier space (wedge or pyramid), a more fundamental limitation in a tilting experiment within the EM is the increasing specimen thickness at larger tilt angles. Because of the planar (slab) geometry of the sample–holder arrangement, the transmission path of the electrons will increase. Simple geometric calculations show that the transmission path of the electrons for a specimen initially 100 nm thick will double at 60° (200 nm), almost triple at 70° (290 nm), and the projected thickness will be increased more than five times at 80° (590 nm). Thus at very high tilt angles the image contrast is dramatically reduced because of the increase in multiple scattering. For specimens with an initial thickness of more than 500 nm the projected thickness at high tilt angles would even prevent the trans-
559
560
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
mission of electrons in commonly used 300 kV instruments! However, to preserve the contrast at even higher tilts for imaging thick specimens such as vitrified cells, which can easily reach dimensions of a couple of hundred nanometers, energy filtering can offer some remedy (see Section 3.4.6). 3.4 Instrumentation and Automation Among the keys to the successful investigation of biological structures at cryotemperatures and especially for the application of cryo-ET are certainly the transmission electron microscope (TEM), the preparation of the specimens (see Section 3.1), and sophisticated acquisition and automation procedures (see Section 3.4.7). We therefore have dedicated one section of this chapter to the equipment and the technical improvements made, and to a description of the necessary technical requirements for 3D structural analysis with the EM. 3.4.1 Acceleration Voltage and Emission TEMs are now operated typically in an acceleration voltage regime between 100 and 1250 kV. With increasing voltage the penetration depth of the electrons increases, allowing us to image samples a couple of micrometers thick; at the same time the inelastic cross section is reduced, thus directly resulting in a longer resistance against beam damage (Wilson et al., 1992; Martone et al., 1999, 2000; O’Toole et al., 1999). However, high-voltage EMs are less frequently used for biological studies, mainly because of the decreased image contrast due to the reduced cross section. The gain in penetration power is limited, because the elastic σel as well as the inelastic cross section σin are in a good approximation proportional to 1/β2 (Scherzer, 1970), where β is the ratio of electron velocity to the velocity of light (β = v/c). Thus, increasing the acceleration voltage from 100 to 300 kV results in an improvement of a factor of 2, while an additional increase from 300 kV to 1.2 MV will result in only a 1.5 times increase (Koster et al., 1997). As mentioned earlier, it is more practical to operate EMs in the intermediate voltage range, between 200 and 300 kV, because this represents a good compromise in cost and resulting performance and, additionally, EMs are available in combination with FEGs. FEGs were implemented in the late 1980s. Compared to thermionic emitters FEGs possess several advantages, notably a very small energy spread, usually in the range of ∼0.8 eV, combined with an increased brightness. Both properties lead to an improved envelope of the CTF, since the increased temporal and spatial coherence reduces the damping of the envelope function (Frank, 1973). This is especially advantageous for ET of ice-embedded specimens at intermediate resolution (∼1–2 nm) because a relatively large defocus (several micrometers) can be selected without sacrificing good contrast transfer. FEG instruments at 200 and 300 kV are today’s “workhorses” in many different laboratories from life and material sciences. But LaB6 120-kV systems are widespread as well and are adequate whenever high resolution is not of major interest, e.g., for sample screening and assessment.
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
3.4.2 Electron Optics Like regular light microscopes the EM is built up from three major lens systems: the condenser, the objective, and the projective lenses. The performance of these electromagnetic lenses almost exclusively determines the quality of the recorded image. Most important are the properties of the objective lens system, likewise known from light microscopy, especially the value of Cs, the spherical aberration coefficient. The objective lens influences the transfer of electrons, and together with the illumination system (FEG or LaB6) and the chosen focus, is described by the CTF. The opening in the center of the objective lens system, where the electron beam passes, affects the magnitude of Cs. In simple terms, the bigger this gap the higher Cs, the higher the contrast, but the lower the resulting resolution. However, the sample holder with the specimen is located inside the objective lens system and therefore the gap dimensions cannot be too small. In particular, to tilt the holder, e.g., for an angular acquisition, a considerable amount of space is required to allow tilts to higher angles, or the sample holder has to be designed in a way to enable tilting even within very small gaps (Fischione Instruments, Inc., Export, PA; Gatan, Inc., Pleasanton, CA). The objective lens spacing in current EM systems is in the range of a couple of millimeters, thus resulting in Cs values from 0.7 mm (lowest) up to 6 mm (highest). For life science applications typically objectives with a Cs of ∼2 mm are used, because they offer enough space for tilting the specimen and at the same time the possibility of recording highresolution images. Ongoing instrumental improvements include, for example, the use of Cs correctors, which, especially in materials science, already revealed new possibilities and real image improvement (Haider et al., 1998; Lentzen et al., 2002; Jia et al., 2003; Freitag et al., 2005). However, in biological EM we have to cope with very weak scatterers and so, for reasonable image contrast, we have to defocus in the range of a couple of micrometers even for very thin objects. Since this low-frequency information is essential for cryo-EM investigations, the advantage of Cs correction is almost canceled (Plitzko et al., 2005). However, there is reason to believe that Cs correctors might be beneficial for biological EM and especially cryo-EM if used in combination with phase plates (Unwin, 1972; Danev and Nagayama, 2001; Majorovits and Schroeder, 2002; Lentzen, 2004; Marko, 2004). Another important fact is the change in the direction and angle of the tilting axis at different magnifications due to a rotation of the image within the electron optics of the microscope. Previously this change was obvious at every magnification step. It is now partly compensated by so-called “rotation-free lens series,” which guarantee an almost “fixed” (in angle and direction) tilt axis in distinct magnification ranges. This is crucial, especially in low-dose acquisition schemes, where a fast transition and reproducible change between states (see Section 3.4.7) and sample areas at different magnifications are necessary, e.g., in dual-axis experiments to reposition the area of interest after the inplane rotation.
561
562
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
3.4.3 Tilting Device: Goniometer Tilt Stage As already mentioned, tilting the holder inside the microscope is a fundamental requirement for ET. The tilting device, normally located outside the EM column, is called the goniometer tilt stage and in some instances the “compustage,” because of its power to be controlled by computers. However, tilting is now done in an exclusively mechanical way, thus resulting in a major practical difficulty: the mechanical imperfections and the inability to set the eucentric height of the specimen precisely. The eucentric plane is normal to the optic axis; this way a point on the optic axis should not move laterally when tilted around the holder axis. As a result, specimens can experience significant shifts in the x, y, and z directions during the course of angular acquisition. Shifts in the z direction cause severe focus changes, and in an uncorrected case, complicate the 3D reconstruction or even render a reconstruction meaningless. Typically, side entry holders are used—at the rear part of which a small Dewar for liquid nitrogen is located (Figure 7–12). The Dewar is connected to a temperature conduction rod, transferring the temperature of ∼180°C to the specimen mounted at the outermost end of the holder tip. The cryoholder, almost 30 cm in length, is tilted by the goniometer around its vertical axis. It is easy to imagine that tilting must be very inaccurate. Especially at high tilt angles above ±45° imprecise tilting will add up to displacements in the micrometer range. However, at a resolution of 10 Å a tolerable deviation would be in the range of 3 Å, thus resulting in a discrepancy of three to four orders of magnitude between the desired resolution and the actual precision of the tilting device. The best current stages can tilt and move the sample within an accuracy of 0.5 µm. To partially compensate for the still large displacements, automation is mandatory during the acquisition of a tilt series composed typically out of 100 micrographs. Therefore sophisticated acquisition and correction schemes have been developed, to keep the feature of interest at all times focused and centered (see Section 3.4.7).
Figure 7–12. Photographs of a standard side entry cryo-holder (Model 626 Gatan, Pleasanton, CA, USA). a) The holder is almost 30 cm in length and equipped with a nitrogen dewar in the back. b) Images of the tip of the holder with open (top) and closed ‘shutter’ (bottom). The stationary cryoshield (‘shutter’) protects the grid from mechanical damage and from frost accumulation during transfer from the specimen loading workstation (not shown) into the TEM.
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
Developments have already been made to test and implement piezocontrolled stages into the EM environment to allow nanopositioning in the order of ∼1 nm, which might enable accuracy during tomographic acquisition to be improved dramatically (Lengweiler et al., 2004; JEOL Ltd., Tokyo, Japan). 3.4.4 Cooling System Since all investigations in cryo-EM have to be made under cryo conditions, i.e., under constant cooling with liquid nitrogen, special holders and/or special cryostages have to be designed. Typically, side entry holders are used—fitted with a small Dewar for liquid nitrogen (Gatan Inc., Pleasanton, CA). The requirements for mechanical and temperature stability are severe and it is quite clear that the dimensions of the holder tip must be smaller than the polepiece gap of the objective. Moreover, special cryoshields have to be installed to guarantee contamination-free investigations. They are seated next to the tip of the holder inside the microscope and connected to the cooling trap of the microscope for constant cooling with liquid nitrogen. Side-entry cryoholders are routinely used, but recently stages incorporating the cooling system within the electron microscope have been designed (“Polara” Tecnai F30 by FEI Company, Eindhoven, Netherlands, and Jeol 3200FSC by JEOL Ltd., Tokyo, Japan). By including the cooling system for the sample holder into the microscope the mechanical stability and the temperature stability of the holder are improved enormously, and additionally these systems allow cooling to very low temperatures, even to liquid helium temperature (∼10 K). Furthermore the temperature can be kept stable over longer time periods; instead of hours in the side-entry case, days or even weeks are now possible. Moreover the stages designed for these cooling systems can hold several samples, unlike the side-entry holder where only one individual sample can be mounted at a time (Figure 7–13). Additionally, prototypes have been developed and tested holding up to 100 different samples, to enable high-throughput applications in the future (Gatan Inc., Pleasanton, CA). The exchange of samples is faster and the transfer of the samples to the microscope is done under vacuum conditions, to minimize the chance of contamination. 3.4.5 Detector Temperature and mechanical stability of the stages, holders, and goniometers as well as the overall performance of the electron optics are crucial for high-resolution data acquisition, however, the quality of the detector system used is of vital importance, especially in cryoapplications under low-dose conditions (Downing and Hendrickson, 1999; Fan and Ellisman, 2000). Previously photographic plates were utilized, making a fast assessment of the collected data impossible; however, today microscopes are equipped with TV rate systems and digital cameras (Krivanek and Mooney, 1993; Faruqi and Subramanian, 2000), so-called CCD cameras (Janesick, 2001). With the help of the CCD camera it is possible to easily calculate online the Fourier transformation of the image, for example, to determine the focus or to readjust the microscope, e.g., astigmatism and coma correction. In principle they
563
564
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister Figure 7–13. Multispecimen chamber and cartridges for the Polara Tecnai F30 (FEI company, Eindhoven, The Netherlands). a) The multispecimen chamber allows the storage of up to 6 samples, which are all protected by stationary cryoshields. b) The samples are clamped or screwed into cartridges (insets) and the transfer of the complete system is done under cryo- and vacuum conditions.
are built up from a scintillator (either a single crystal or a polycrystalline coating), “decelerating” the electrons and thus creating photons by cathodoluminescence. The scintillator is coupled to a fiber optic array, which will transfer the light optical signal to the CCD sensor, which is built up from a series of metal oxide semiconductor (MOS) capacitors, where the light induces the creation of electron hole pairs in the active area. CCD cameras are now available in dimensions between 1024 × 1024 and 4096 × 4096 pixels with a pixel size ranging from 15 to 30 µm. Thus they are still smaller than the typical photographic plate dimensions (∼10,000 × 8000 pixels assuming a pixel size of 10 µm for a typical plate). However, CCDs possess an excellent linearity and a large dynamic range [i.e., ratio between maximum signal and the root mean square (RMS) of the noise level]. Because of the excellent linearity the intensity distribution of the recorded image is directly proportional to the number of primary electrons hitting the detection device. However, the lateral resolution is worse than in photographic plates, because of the signal spreading within the whole CCD assembly. This spreading is mainly caused by multiple light scattering of the photons created and by electron backscattering within the scintillator. Thus a point-like input signal produces an output that is spread over several pixels of the CCD chip. In real space this will result in a “blurring” of the recorded image, which is similar to a Gaussian smoothing of the image. In Fourier space it can be observed as a damping of the high spatial frequencies. The extent of this spread can be quantitatively analyzed by inspection of the modulation transfer function (MTF), which is the Fourier transform of the point spread function (PSF), to measure the spatial frequency response (Weickenmeier et al., 1995; Ruijter, 1995).
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
The second major characteristic of a CCD camera is the sensitivity, quantitatively expressed in the detection quantum efficiency (DQE). In combination with the conversion efficiency (number of created pixel electrons per primary electron) the DQE describes the influence of the detector noise on the SNR of a transferred image and is defined as the ratio of the square of the SNR at the output to the same quantity at the input of the detection device (Herrmann and Krahl, 1982; Fan and Ellismann, 2000). There are essentially four main sources of noise: (1) variations in the electron conversion of electrons into photons, (2) fluctuations in the generation of electron hole pairs on the chip, (3) dark current noise, and (4) preamplifier noise. To reduce the dark current noise, which mainly stems from the electronics, the whole array is cooled down to a temperature of −30°C. Depending on the scintillator material and thickness, the primary energy of the electrons, and the coupling of the scintillator to the capacitors the detector will show slightly different characteristics (Fan and Ellisman, 1996). The scintillator has the key role in the performance of an image converter since it primarily determines sensitivity, resolution, and noise contribution. Typically, single crystals (YAG = Y3Al5O12:Ce2+) or polycrystalline phosphor scintillators (e.g., P43 = Gd2O2S:Tb3+) are used in commercially available CCDs. Since high resolution is of major interest in materials science, CCDs for this purpose are normally equipped with very thin scintillator coatings to minimize the point spread function and to obtain the best transfer, especially in the high-frequency domain. On the other hand, the detection sensitivity and the amplification of the incoming signal are of minor interest since the specimens are not subject to restricted illumination conditions. This is in contrast to biological applications, where low-dose exposure schemes are typically used, demanding a very high sensitivity of the detection device and thus a somewhat greater scintillator thickness. The optimum thickness of the scintillator depends on the application and on the acceleration voltage used. While the performance for CCDs in the voltage range below 200 kV is satisfactory, it drops dramatically for intermediate or high acceleration voltages. However, in principle both are needed; the highest sensitivity combined with the maximum transfer of low and high frequencies. But these two requirements are in conflict with each other; the higher the sensitivity, the thicker the scintillator layer, and the greater the possibility of electron backscattering and multiple light scattering, resulting in a severe damping of high-frequency information, especially at primary energies at and above 300 keV. Clearly, the ideal detector for cryo-ET has not yet been invented, but there are possible ways to overcome the shortcomings of “classical” CCDs, at least to some extent: modified CCDs (Fan et al., 2000), lenscoupling (Mooney and Krivanek, 1994; Mooney, 2004) instead of fiber coupling, “decelerators” in combination with CCDs (Downing et al., 2000; Downing and Mooney, 2004), and active pixel detectors (APS; Fan et al., 1998; Faruqi et al., 2003a,b; Evans et al., 2005). In lens-coupled systems the glass fiber array, transferring the light without magnifica-
565
566
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
tion, has been replaced by huge optical lenses focusing the photons arising from one electron onto the CCD chip. A free-standing scintillator foil generates the light, which is then deflected by a 45° mirror into the lens-coupling system. In this way scattering from the interface between scintillator and glass fibers, and from within the glass fibers is eliminated and moreover the detection of X-ray quanta is completely bypassed, since they are not reflected in the optical mirror. The setup provides a definite gain in resolution, while the detection efficiency is more or less kept constant if compared to highly sensitive fiber-coupled CCDs (Agard; Mooney, 2004). The main technical difficulty in lens coupling is the quality and thus the performance of the optical lens system to guarantee an undistorted transfer (mainly geometric distortions) of the light onto the full array of the CCD chip. Deceleration of, e.g., 300 keV electrons to 100 keV is technically difficult, because it is necessary to slow down the electrons with a “countervoltage” of, e.g., 200 kV (Downing and Mooney, 2004) before detection. This countervoltage is generated with an electrostatic deflector stack floated at a voltage comparable to the acceleration voltage of the microscope. The CCD, the associated electronics, and the electrostatic deflector are enclosed within an insulated high-voltage tank. However, the shielding of the CCD against AC magnetic fields and against possible discharges is still a major technical difficulty, which will have to be addressed in the future. While lens-coupled systems and decelerators have been designed and tested for 300 kV instruments and represent bulky apparatuses, detectors based on the active or hybrid pixel sensor designs [mainly based on complementary metal oxide semiconductors (CMOS)] come in sizes comparable to “classical” CCDs, with the possibility of detecting the incoming electrons directly. Pixel detectors have been successfully used in the field of X-ray crystallography and condensed matter physics and they do possess some distinct advantages; instead of indirect detection of the incoming electrons, pixel detectors detect the signal directly, the lateral resolution is dramatically increased, and moreover dark noise (mainly from the electronic readout) is quasinonexistent (Turchetta et al., 2001). The signal produced by pixel detectors is intrinsically digital, thus allowing very fast readouts, but one major handicap is their “radiation hardness”; while CCDs can continue to be used, pixel detectors do have a somewhat limited lifetime. However, recent developments based on the latest CMOS technology have shown that the radiation hardness can be increased, e.g., if the size of the CMOS capacitors is reduced (Evans et al., 2005). All three of these different detection “philosophies” are currently being tested in prototypes in combination especially with 300-kV instruments to find an optimum recording device and a long-term solution for digital TEM imaging. 3.4.6 Energy Filter To image thick specimens such as vitrified cells, the development and the subsequent integration of energy filters (Krivanek et al., 1991, 1995) have been a major breakthrough for biological imaging and especially
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
567
fraction of detected electrons
for ET. Electrons interacting with the sample atoms can be scattered elastically (no loss in energy but change in direction) or inelastically (loss of energy due to interaction with core shell electrons). The mean free path Λin of inelastically scattered electrons (the path length after an inelastic scattered electron has been scattered once on average) is about 280 nm in vitrified ice at 300 kV at liquid nitrogen temperature and around 210 nm at liquid helium temperature (Schweikert et al., 2007; Plitzko et al., 2004; Wright et al., 2006). Thus for specimens with a thickness in the range above 200 nm multiple scattering is inevitable (Figure 7–14). For biological specimens and vitrified ice, which are almost exclusively built up of light atoms, inelastic scattering is much stronger than elastic scattering. However, the elastically scattered electrons carry the main portion of structural information of the specimen, whereas inelastically scattered electrons form a strong inelastic background and thus contribute significantly to the shot noise of the image background, obscuring fine details. Because of the different energies of inelastically scattered electrons, they are slightly “out of focus” and will thus contribute to a “blurring” of the final image and hence they decrease the SNR. Energy filters are in principle electron energy loss spectrometers with the additional ability to image the sample at a specific kinetic energy. Introduced in the early 1990s (Krivanek et al., 1992; Probst et al., 1993; Gubbens et al., 1993) they are widespread in materials science for the
inelastic
mixed
unscattered elastic thickness [nm]
Figure 7–14. Distribution of scattered electrons for vitreous ice. Distribution (without an aperture) over the elastic (lower intermediate grey area), inelastic (upper dark grey area), and mixed (light grey area) scattering channels for vitreou s ice as a function of thickness for 300 kV, in nm). The dashed lines mark fractions of single (elastic or inelastic) scattering.
568
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
analysis of the chemical composition, either by high resolution electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) or electron spectroscopic imaging (ESI). For a complete description of energy filters see Reimer (1995) and for electron energy loss spectroscopy see Egerton (1996). Energy losses can be selected that are specific to certain elements to obtain so-called elemental maps, visualizing the elemental distribution in one single 2D image (Figure 7–15). However, the dose typically used for an elemental map is in the order of 10,000 e−/Å2, thus orders of magnitude higher than what would be allowed for the investigation of biological structures. Nevertheless, instead of using the specific energy loss of elements (characteristic ionization edges) for “inelastic filtering” it is always possible to operate the energy filter for “elastic” filtering or to use a more common expression for “zero-loss” filtering. The energy-selecting slit aperture is positioned around the energy of the primary beam, selecting only the unscattered and elastically scattered electrons for imaging. The energy window is typically in the range of 20 eV or slightly larger, but it has to be smaller than the smallest relevant energy loss in the sample (in most cases the 20–25 eV single plasmon loss peak). Basically the energy filter is built up from one or several magnetic prisms. If an electron travels through a homogeneous magnetic field it will move in circles whose radius is proportional to the kinetic energy of the electron, and in this way electrons of different energy are separated. In the so-called energy-selective plane (or plane of energy dispersion) they are located in different positions, and produce a spectrum, which is called the EELS. A mechanical slit aperture can be inserted in this plane to select electrons with a specific energy. There are basically two types of energy filters: postcolumn energy filters (Krivanek et al., 1991) and in-column energy filters (Rose and Plies, 1974; Lanio, 1986; Lanio et al., 1986). For the postcolumn filter only one 90° magnetic prism is utilized and placed at the lower end of an EM behind the
Figure 7–15. Electron spectroscopic imaging of microtubulis embedded in virtified ice. With the help of an energy filter one can select energy losses specific to certain elements to obtain so-called elemental maps. The maps shown here are created with the three-window technique. Two images have been acquired in front of the ionization edge (pre-edge images) and one directly after it (post-edge image). The two pre-edge images are used to calculate the background intensity, which is extrapolated and subtracted from the post-edge image, resulting in the net-signal of the element under scrutiny. a) Shows the elemental distribution of oxygen, b) of carbon and c) of nitrogen.
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
projective lens system. In-column energy filters, mainly omega (Ω) filters, are placed above the projective lens system of the microscope within the column. In omega filters the beam has to pass through four magnetic prisms in a symmetric path corresponding to the greek letter omega. Energy filters are additional optical elements and therefore they will add optical distortions of different kinds (spectral aberrations both transmissivity and nonisochromaticity as well as geometric distortions; Uhlemann and Rose, 1996) to the final image, which have to be compensated by adding additional multipole lenses to the system. In the case of the postcolumn energy filter (Gatan Imaging Filter, GIF, Gatan, Pleasanton, CA) several quadrupoles and hexapole lenses are placed behind the magnetic prism to correct these distortions up to a certain degree. These lenses have to be aligned on a day-to-day basis, to ensure the best performance of the system and, to make life easier, the necessary alignment routines have to be computer controlled and automated. Because of the symmetry of the in-column omega filter, a number of aberrations are canceled out in this type of energy filter, simplifying the alignment procedure. Furthermore, the pre- and postfilter electron trajectories are parallel, which makes the in-column filter design an obvious choice. However, in-column filters cannot be included in an existing TEM column, in contrast to postcolumn energy filters, which lack the symmetry, but which can be attached to almost every existing microscope column. Moreover, with the addition of energy filters the whole electron optical path will be increased, thus naturally resulting in an additional magnification factor. In the case of the in-column filter this magnification factor is quite small, while for the postcolumn filter the magnification factor ranges between 20 and 40 depending on the acceleration voltage used. Obviously, this postmagnification is well suited for highresolution work, as typically used in materials science. However, to apply the filter to biological specimens, the magnification range, in which the objective lens is excited (to allow focus adjustments), has to be extended to much lower magnifications. Therefore special lens series have to be utilized, called EFTEM series, which demagnify the image, before entering through the spectrometer entrance aperture into the energy filter. In this way, the magnification factor is reduced to a value in the range of 2–3 if compared to images observed on the viewing screen. Recently, larger entrance apertures (5 mm in diameter) for the energy filter have been introduced (Brink et al., 2003) to increase the collection angle and thus allow the magnification factor to be further reduced. Especially in biological applications in cryoconditions where limitations include the dose and thus the applied magnification, this has proven to be beneficial because the field of view (FOV) can be considerably increased. The application of zero-loss filtering for collecting high-resolution structural data from ice-embedded biological macromolecules, which are normally small in size compared to cellular structures, provides only a minor improvement, and therefore it is rarely used (Langmore
569
570
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
and Smith, 1992; Schroeder et al., 1993; Frank et al., 1995; Zhu et al., 1997; Angert et al. 2000). Typically these ice-embedded isolated particles are thinner and thus smaller than the inelastic mean free path and therefore the influence of inelastically scattered electrons is comparably small. However, zero-loss filtering allows the use of smaller defocus values without impairing the accuracy of the subsequent alignment of the particles as required for averaging (see Section 2.2). In electron crystallography, energy filtering has its advantages even for thin specimens, as shown by Yonekura et al. (2002). Overall the effect of energy filtering (especially zero-loss filtering) for thick specimens in the thickness range above the mean free path (∼200 nm for 300-keV electrons) is more obvious, because details can be observed with a higher contrast and higher resolution than in the unfiltered case (Figure 7–16). Moreover in very thick specimens, in which most of the electrons have been inelastically scattered, it is possible to choose an energy-selective window close to the most probable, instead of the zero-loss value (Olins et al., 1989; Han et al., 1996; Bouwer et al., 2004). Moreover, energy filtering allows us to estimate or, if the mean free path is known, to determine the absolute specimen thickness quickly and simply by means of the so-called log-ratio technique (Malis et al., 1988; Grimm et al., 1996b); by taking the logarithm of the ratio between an unfiltered image and a zero-loss image the relative thickness of the specimen can be obtained in units of the inelastic mean free path. If the inelastic mean free path is known this value can be easily converted to the absolute thickness. This simple procedure can be additionally utilized for the determination of the inelastic mean free path, if the thickness of the specimen has been determined by other techniques (Grimm et al., 1996b; Feya and Aebi, 1999). Thickness determination is advantageous to ascertain suitable sample areas for follow-up in-depth structural investigation and thus represents a quality criteria, especially for automated acquisition schemes.
Figure 7–16. Influence of zero-loss filtering on the investigation of ice-embedded thick specimens (Thermoplasma acidophilum, images courtesy of C. Kofler, MPI of Biochemistry, Martinsried, Germany). Unfiltered (a) and zero-loss (b) filtered images of a Thermoplasma acidophilum cell. The specimen thickness is almost 500 nm, which is greater than the mean free path of 300 kV electrons in ice at liquid nitrogen temperature. The slit-width was 20 eV. c) shows a section through a tomographic reconstruction based on the filtered image set.
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
571
Figure 7–17. Experimental setup for automated tomography based on an intermediate voltage (300 kV) instrument (1) equipped with an energy filter (2). The CCD camera (3) makes the image formation available instantaneously and, in conjunction with a computer (4), allows measurement of deviations from a perfectly eucentric tilt geometry. This information is then used, in a feedback loop to the microscope, to activate auto-tuning functions that compensate for the mechanical imperfections of the system.
3.4.7 Automation Experimentally, the acquisition of a tomogram requires recording of a “tilt series,” which is a sequence of micrographs from different angles containing the feature of interest. However, it took more than a decade after the pioneering work of Hart and Hoppe to establish angular acquisition schemes, especially under cryoconditions as a routine and robust method in structural biology (Hart, 1968; Hoppe et al., 1968; Figure 7–17). This is due to the fact that the specimen, or the feature of interest, inevitably moves out of the field of view during physical tilting of the specimen holder as a result of the mechanical inaccuracies of the tilting device (see Section 3.4.3; Figure 7–18A). The adjustment of the microscope optics, the recentering of the specimen in the electron beam, focusing, and the final recording of the electron micrograph were exclusively done by hand in the first experiments. However, the additional exposure time required for these steps resulted in the overexposure of the specimen and thus in extensive beam damage, which finally culminated in the loss of the sample. Manual recording of a tilt series is therefore inappropriate and the implementation of automated acquisition, which includes “tracking” (recentering) of the specimen, refocusing with a minimum additional exposure (Dierksen et al., 1992;
572
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
B change tilt angle
is ax lt Ti
A
Tracking
‚image shift‘ correction Focus
Focus correction Exposure
image acquisition
Figure 7–18. a) Geometric model of specimen rotation around a tilt axis. b) Automated data collection scheme for the ‘full-tracking/ full-focusing’ case. For tracking, focusing and the fi nal image acquisition the same magnification is used and the beam is adjusted in a way that the areas where tracking, focusing and exposure is done do not overlapp (blue and green circle). Using very short exposure times in combination with high binning values (4 × 8 or even 8 × 8) the exposure to the sample in auto-tracking and auto-focusing can be minimized. (See color plate.)
Koster et al., 1992; Braunfeld et al., 1994; Rath et al., 1997), and image acquisition, was essential for the success of ET in structural biology. Clearly, only with the introduction of computer-controlled electron microscopes was automation within reach. Automated tomography includes three major steps for every tilt angle: tracking, focusing, and final image acquisition (Figure 7–18B). Under strict low-dose conditions, the tracking and focusing steps are normally carried out adjacent to the area of interest, to reduce the dose that is delivered to the specimen area. These areas are positioned along the tilt axis with respect to the actual acquisition area to determine the correct shift and focus levels prior to final image recording. During the tracking step a micrograph with a very low exposure time at a higher binning mode of the CCD camera is acquired, which is correlated with a micrograph from the previous tilt. Utilizing cross-correlation or by a manual inspection of prominent features (e.g., gold beads), the shift relative to the preceding micrograph can be determined. Depending on the SNR of the image, the cross-correlation algorithm might fail and must be supported by suitable image processing routines, e.g., bandpass filtering or the use of a Hanning window. This is especially the case at higher tilt angles where the projected thickness increases. The shifts are typically compensated by moving the beam with the image deflection coils back to the region of interest. To obtain a higher accuracy (better than 1%) with autotracking the procedure can be repeated several times. The offset in z between the object and the tilt axis z0 can be minimized by setting the eucentric height. Procedures have been developed to adjust the sample z height automatically until minimum image movement is detected while the goniometer is wobbling within a specified angular range (“Explore3D,” automated tomography software of FEI Company, Eindhoven, Netherlands; Schoenmakers et al., 2005). However, due to mechanical imperfections of the goniometer, it
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
is very difficult to tune z0 to zero. As a result, the uncorrected residue of z0 can still be severe enough to make the object disappear from the field of view at high magnification and lead to significant focus changes during the acquisition of a tilt series. Furthermore, it is observed that this offset in z depends not only on the actual sample being used but also varies from point to point within a sample. This can be attributed to many factors including nonuniform thickness and flatness of the specimen. Therefore z0 has to be determined during data collection for each selected tilt angle. Automated focusing or autofocusing is achieved by acquiring images with different beam tilts (Koster et al., 1992; Koster and de Ruijter, 1989; Ziese et al., 2003) prior to the final exposure. It is based on the fact that tilting the illuminating beam will result in an image displacement, if the image is out of focus. The amount of this displacement, measured by means of crosscorrelation, is proportional to the focus change and can be used to readjust the objective lens current, rather than using the z adjustment of the stage. The amount of shift and focus change that occurs during data collection depends on the goniometer and specimen holder. In most experiments, accumulated shifts are in the order of 1–3 µm during the acquisition of a complete tilt series, provided that the specimen was set as accurately as possible to the eucentric height. Image shifts are measured by determination of the peak position of the cross-correlation function (XCF) of an image recorded after setting a new tilt angle with a reference image that was recorded previously. Since the two correlated images are acquired at different tilt angles, they will not only be shifted relative to each other but they will also differ to some extent as a result of their different projection angles. Moreover, a tilted image (assuming the tilt axis is parallel to the y-axis and in the center, of the image) will exhibit a defocus difference between the left side of the image, the center, and the right side of the image. Thus defocus determination by the beam-tilt method for tilted samples is impaired by an elongation of the cross-correlation peak, which has contributions from areas with different defocus values. Therefore, prior to the computation of the cross-correlation function, “stretching” of the image at a higher modulus can be applied (Guckenberger, 1982; Ziese et al. 2003). “Stretching” is typically done perpendicular to the tilt axis by a factor of cos(α − α0)/cos α or a similar expression depending on the sign of the actual tilt angle α and the tilt angle increment α0 (Koster et al., 1997). Instead of stretching the image, the focus determination can also be done in the center region of the image provided that beam tilting is done along the tilt axis to minimize errors in the autofocus procedure. The accuracy of the beam-tilt autofocus procedure without stretching can be as good as ±50 nm (Dierksen et al., 1993). Since the effective thickness of the specimen in the beam direction varies during tilting, the portion of “absorbed” electrons will increase with the tilt angle. There are two possible ways to account for this effect: a tilting scheme with a finer sampling at higher tilt angles and an increase in exposure time for higher tilt angles to obtain a similar SNR
573
574
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
within the projections of a tilt series. A tilting scheme according to Saxton has been widely adapted (“Saxton scheme”; Saxton et al., 1984). Since this scheme was proposed for crystalline specimens a slightly different expression is typically used in electron tomography: αn+1 = αn + arcsin(sin α0 ⋅ cos αn). To achieve a uniform SNR in the single projections of a tilt series and to prevent an insufficient SNR at high tilt angles, and an unnecessarily high SNR at low tilts, the exposure time can be varied in different ways. Instead of using the constant exposure scheme (t = t0) it is possible to use an exponential scheme or a cosine scheme to allow for the thickness increase at high tilts:
[ ( cosα1 − 1)]
t = t0 exp T ⋅ or t = t0 ⋅
1 cosα
or t = t0 ⋅
1 exp[cosα ]
where T is the relative specimen thickness in units of the mean free path (Grimm et al., 1998; see Section 3.4.6). For the reconstruction, the images have to be normalized with respect to the exposure time, so that the incident beam dose will stay nominally constant for all tilt angles. Since the thickness of the sample under investigation is normally not known beforehand, the cosine scheme is favored and is primarily used for the acquisition of a tilt series. To minimize the electron dose that is delivered to the specimen, the images required for these automated procedures have to be recorded on areas that do not coincide with the chosen area of interest. This way almost all of the total dose (97%) can be employed for the acquisition of the single projections and only a fraction of it (3%) is used for the autoadjustment procedures. In less strict low-dose schemes, these necessary steps can be performed directly on the region of interest, but with different illumination and exposure settings, which will then sum up to 10–15% of the total applied dose. Clearly, tracking and autofocusing prior to the final exposure are time consuming. However, with the improvements made in electron optics, stage designs, and specimen cooling, even of the already computer-controlled microscopes, it became feasible to use calibration and prediction schemes to dramatically reduce the amount of time typically used for the acquisition of a tilt series (Zheng, 2004; Ziese, 2002). The acquisition schemes and software packages of today can be grouped in roughly three major domains: the almost classical “fulltracking/full-focusing,” the “precalibrated,” and the “on-the-fly or dynamic prediction” procedure. Naturally, there are various deriva-
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
tives and hybrids of these three different acquisition models, especially modified to serve specific purposes and applications. The full-tracking full-focusing scheme (described above) is the most common, due to the fact that it can be literally used universally, e.g., with almost any kind of sample and microscope and holder system. However, the time required for the recording of a tilt series can be very long, up to several hours, depending on the acquisition parameters. The precalibration model was developed originally for side-entry systems. It mainly includes the calibration of the tilting stage synchronized with the specimen holder. The basic idea is that the image movement is determined prior to data collection. The movement of the stage is measured with a calibration sample (typically fiducial markers on a carbon foil) both in the xy plane (image shifts) and the z direction (defocus change) for the range of tilt angles needed to acquire a tilt series. Typically, the calibration is started at a high tilt angle (e.g., either −65° or +65°, depending on the characteristics of the stage) and continues to the outermost tilt on the opposite side. For every tilt angle an image is acquired and the image feature is recentered automatically (as described above) while the defocus change is measured (not corrected) only with the beam-tilt method. In this way, the absolute image shifts in xy and z (defocus) can be determined and stored in a calibration file, which then provides the basis for the xy and z shift compensation during actual data acquisition. Moreover, it is also possible to mathematically model (least-squares fit) the displacements during tilting, based on the calibration curves now available, to predict the behavior of the stage. However, there are some restraints on this course of action: the calibration strongly depends on the initial setup of the microscope (illumination settings, image shift settings, distance from eucentricity, initial xy position of the stage), sample being used, and thermal stability of the cryoholder utilized. Thermal drift of the specimen is not included in the calibration. For higher magnifications, especially, it has to be addressed separately, for example, with an additional tracking step by cross-correlation. Additionally, a significant misalignment of the optic axis relative to the tilt axis can necessitate large corrections in both translation and focus, which in turn can lead to image rotation and magnification changes. Since the image rotation and a possible change in magnification are not covered by the pre-calibration procedure, the acquisition is severely hampered. However, prealigning the optic axis to the tilt axis by invoking an appropriate amount of image shift can circumvent this possible source of error (Ziese et al., 2002). Based on the measured calibration curve this “optimized position” (where the optic axis coincides with the tilt axis) can be determined and adjusted. Overall, it can be said that even in case of thermal instabilities, which will lead to rather small displacements, not every change in tilt angle will require a tracking step and thus the acquisition of a tilt series by precalibration is definitely sped up enormously (five times faster than the full-tracking method). The prediction-based scheme assumes that the sample follows a simple geometric rotation and that the optical system can be characterized in terms of an offset between the optic and mechanical axes of
575
576
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
the microscope (Zheng et al., 2004). In contrast to the precalibration and full-tracking procedures where the acquisition begins at one end of the tilt range, the prediction scheme starts at zero tilt. In this way, it is possible to model and compensate for any errors in sample geometry simultaneously. The image movement in the xy and z direction due to a stage tilt can be dynamically predicted without precalibration. Mathematically, one data point, characterized by the tilt angle and the x translation, is sufficient to calculate the offset between the object and tilt axis (z0). However, least-squares fitting from multiple data points is typically used to minimize the consequences of errors introduced when measuring the x translation. In this way, it is possible to estimate and refine “on-the-fly” the focus offset z0 during the course of data collection, with an accuracy of 100 nm. The microscope optical system (beam/image shift and focus) is automatically adjusted to compensate for the predicted and refined image movement prior to taking the projected image at each tilt angle. As a consequence, it is not necessary either to record additional images for tracking and focusing during the course of data collection or to spend valuable setup time in a lengthy precalibration of stage motions. However, thermal drift is not taken into account in the dynamic prediction procedure, which will affect the precision of the prediction and thus the quality of the recorded tilt series. Nevertheless, the acquisition of tilt series of cryosamples even with the given advances in automation is not yet performed on a high throughput basis. This is mainly due to the fact that side-entry cryoholders are typically used, which are still subject to thermal instabilities, and that the accuracy and reproducibility of mechanical tilting still require compensation with elaborate automation procedures (see above). However, recent advances in instrumentation, like the integration of the cooling system into the microscope column, the simplification of the sample transfer and mounting procedure, multispecimen holders, and the development of piezo-controlled stages will widen the prospects of high-throughput approaches in the near future. 3.5 Alignment, Reconstruction, and Visualization 3.5.1 Alignment To obtain the 3D image from a set of acquired projections two initial steps have to be carried out: first the individual micrographs need to be aligned to a common coordinate system. The second step is the actual 3D reconstruction of the tomographic volume. The compensation of the specimen movement during the data acquisition process will keep the feature focused in most cases but the compensation for the xy displacement is not sufficient for a subsequent reconstruction, which makes a second, more precise alignment necessary. Primarily, the alignment procedure has to determine the angle of the tilt axis and the lateral shifts. Other changes, such as magnification changes or image rotation, due to large defocus changes during the acquisition, have to be determined and compensated for as well, if present in the recorded tilt series.
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
Alignment of the individual micrographs in cellular tomography is normally done by high-density markers, so-called fiducial markers. Typically, spherical gold beads with a diameter of ∼10 nm are added to the sample solution or directly onto the carbon foil prior to the vitrification process. They can be easily recognized within a single 2D micrograph as “black dots,” due to their high Z number and thus their pronounced elastic scattering. The coordinates of the markers on each projection are determined manually or automatically. To minimize the alignment error as a function of the lateral translations and the tilt axis angle, an alignment model can be calculated based on least-squares procedures (Lawrence, 1992). Their locations are then adjusted to a 3D coordinate system. Apart from translations, this procedure for the determination of a common origin often accounts for possible image rotations or magnification changes (Lawrence, 1992; Luther, 1988). However, the larger the number of determined parameters, the more gold beads need to be located to achieve a sufficient significance level during the minimization of the residual. Therefore, another alignment approach is by means of cross-correlating the entire image (Taylor et al., 1997) or part of the images. Sequentially the images are compared and compensated for image shifts throughout the series. This procedure can be repeated iteratively to achieve a higher accuracy of the alignment. However, this approach inevitably requires some approximation of the shape of the objects to interpolate data from different tilt angles. Moreover, distinct features will dominate the outcome of the cross-correlation, which might not be suitable for proper alignment. Therefore it is often useful to apply image filters (Fourier filter, Sobel filter, etc.) prior to the cross-correlation, to enhance features that are expected to correlate well. The major problem in using crosscorrelation-based alignment procedures in combination with low-dose cryoimages of vitrified samples is the very low SNR of these images and the very weak contrast, since cross-correlation methods are typically very noise sensitive. Therefore they work well only for a limited class of specimens, e.g., high-contrast or paracrystalline objects, or in cases where fiducial markers are not present, or difficult to add, as seen in tilt series from cryosections. The marker alignment method is definitely more general because it can even cope with very low SNRs and is therefore more common in cryo-ET applications. 3.5.2 Reconstruction Although the first practical formulation for applied tomography was achieved in the 1950s (Bracewell, 1956), Johan Radon first outlined the mathematical principles behind the technique in 1917 (Radon, 1917; English translation in Deans, 1983). The paper defines the Radon transform R as the mapping of a function f(x, y), describing a real space object D, by the projection, or line integral, through f along all possible lines L: Rf = ∫ f ( x , y )ds L
where ds is the unit length of L. A discrete sampling of the Radon transform is geometrically equivalent to the sampling of an experimen-
577
578
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
tal object by some form of transmitted signal: a projection. The consequence of such equivalence is that the reconstruction of an object f(x, y) from projections Rf can be achieved by implementation of the inverse Radon transform. All conventional reconstruction algorithms are approximations, with varying accuracy, to this inverse transform. It is mathematically convenient to use polar coordinates (r, φ), related to Cartesian axes for an explicit description of the Radon transform. The Radon transform operation converts the coordinates of the experimental data into “Radon space,” where l is a line perpendicular to the projection direction and θ denotes the angle of the projection. Thus a point in real space (r, φ) becomes a line in Radon space (l, θ) with the relation l = r ⋅ cos (θ − φ). This relationship between real space and Radon space allows a more explicit examination of the experimental situation. A single projection of a one-dimensional (1D) object, for example, a point in real space (a discrete sampling of the Radon transform) is a 2D line at constant θ in Radon space. Thus a series of projections at different angles will provide an increased sampling of the Radon space. Given a sufficient number of (n − 1)-dimensional projections (of an n-dimensional object) from different views, an inverse Radon transform should reconstruct the n-dimensional object. However, in ET the experimental sampling (l, θ) is discrete (limited amount of projections in a restricted angular range), therefore the inversion will be imperfect and the problem of an undistorted and complete reconstruction, especially in ET, becomes evident: to achieve the best reconstruction of the object it is necessary to obtain as many projections as possible in an angular regime as large as possible. In practice the reconstruction from projections is aided by the understanding of the relationship of a projection in real space and Fourier space. The “projection-slice theorem” states that a 2D projection at a given angle is a central section through the 3D Fourier transform of this object (Figure 7–19). If a series of projections is acquired at different tilt angles, each projection will correspond to part of an object’s Fourier transform, thus sampling the object over the full range of frequencies in a central section. The shape of most objects will be described only partially by the frequencies in one section, but by taking multiple projections at different angles many sections will be sampled in Fourier space. This will describe the Fourier transform of an object in many directions, allowing a fuller description of an object in real space. In principle a sufficiently large number of projections taken over all angles will provide a complete description of the object. Therefore tomographic reconstruction is possible from an inverse Fourier transform of the superposition of a set of Fourier transformed projections: an approach known as direct Fourier reconstruction. This was the approach formulated by Bracewell (1956) and was used for the first tomographic reconstruction from electron micrographs (DeRosier and Klug, 1968). It is also known as “Fourier synthesis” and used for atomic structure determination by electron (Henderson et al., 1990) and X-ray crystallography (Perutz et al., 1960). The direct interpretation of the projection-slice theorem would suggest a reconstruction algorithm based in Fourier space (Hoppe and
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
579
Figure 7–19. ‘Projection-slice theorem’. a) An object is shown in real space (x, y) at the origin, and one of its projection images is presented fromed by tilted parallel beams. b) The Fourier transform of the projection is a section through the origin of the Fourier space (k x, ky) tilted by θ.
Hegerl, 1980). Despite the fact that the first 3D reconstruction by DeRosier and Klug (1968) was carried out in Fourier space, it is common to use real-space-based reconstruction algorithms, because the practical implementation of Fourier-space reconstruction is not as simple as an inverse transform. The projection data are always sampled at discrete angles leaving regular gaps in Fourier space (Figure 7–20). But the inverse transform intrinsically requires a continuous function and therefore interpolation is required to fill the gaps in Fourier space (Crowther et al., 1970). However, the quality of a Fourier-space reconstruction is greatly affected by the type of interpolation implemented,
Figure 7–20. Illustration of the effect of sampling at discrete angles in a 2 dimensional example. a) For 18 projections over the full angular range at 10° increment. b) For 36 projections at 5° increment and c) for 72 projections at 2.5° increment which is almost identical to the original image.
580
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
as examined by Smith et al. (1973). Although elegant, Fourier reconstruction methods have the disadvantage of being computationally intensive and rather difficult to implement. Therefore they have been superseded by faster real-space alternatives since interpolations are easier to implement there. By far the most widely utilized algorithm is weighted backprojection (Radermacher, 1992). Algebraic reconstruction techniques (ART) are also well established, despite the fact that they were subject to criticism in their beginnings (Crowther and Klug, 1971; for a detailed review of reconstruction algorithms we refer to Frank, 1996). The theory of backprojection relies on a simple principle: a point in space may be uniquely described by any three “rays” passing through that point. However, as the object increases in complexity more “rays” are required to describe it uniquely. A projection of an object is the inverse of such a “ray,” and will describe some of the complexity of the object at hand. Therefore by inversing the projection, smearing out the projection into an object space at the angle of projection, a “ray” is generated that will uniquely describe an object in the projection direction, a process known as backprojection. With sufficient projections, from different angles, the superposition of all the backprojected “rays” will reproduce the shape of the original object—a reconstruction technique known as direct backprojection. Direct backprojection is used for reconstruction in classical computerassisted tomography (CT; Herman, 1980), and it was the technique used by Hart (1968) for the “polytropic montage.” It was also mentioned as an alternative to Fourier methods by Crowther et al. (1970). However, reconstructions made by direct backprojection are exceptionally blurred, showing distinct enhancement of low frequencies, while fine spatial details are reconstructed poorly. This problem is an effect of the uneven sampling of spatial frequencies in the series of original projections (Figure 7–21). In 2D each of the acquired projections is a line intersecting the center of the Fourier space. Assuming a regular sampling of Fourier space in each projection, far more sampling points are located in the center of Fourier space than in the periphery. The outcome of this is an “undersampling” of the high spatial frequencies and an “oversampling” of the low spatial frequencies of the object, which will subsequently result in a “blurred” reconstruction. Therefore, to remove the blurring in real space and to restore the correct “frequency balance” in Fourier space, it is necessary to apply weighting schemes. The weighted backprojection consists of two steps: First the aligned projections are weighted in Fourier space by a function that characterizes the different sampling density in Fourier space. Assuming an infinitely small tilt increment the weighting has to be proportional to the amount of the spatial frequency orthogonal to the tilt axis (“analytical” weighting); more precise weighting (“exact” weighting) has to consider the shape function of the object to approximate the sampling density in Fourier space, normally using a sine function, which is retained only up to its first zero crossing (Harauz and van Heel, 1986; Hoppe and Hegerl, 1980). The second step is the backprojection of the weighted micrographs into the reconstruction body, most frequently by trilinear interpolation.
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
Figure 7–21. Illustration of the sampling ‘density’ problem in Fourier space. The large number of sampling points at low frequencies (darker area) are in contrast to the periphery (high frequencies), very only few sampling points are included in the single projections (brighter area). This sampling imbalance will result in ‘blurred’ reconstructions, which can be overcome by weighting schemes.
ART formulates the Radon transform as a system of algebraic equations. The inversion of this algebraic system is performed iteratively until self-consistency is achieved. The solutions of both reconstruction methods should be similar; however, ART determines the correct weighting parameters automatically whereas weighted backprojection requires a priori knowledge about the specimen to provide a correct weighting parameter for exact weighting. Despite this fact weighted backprojection is used in most software packages for 3D reconstruction due to its computational speed. However, the development of parallelized implementations as described in Fernandez et al. (2002) might establish ART as an alternative. Several methods have been introduced to increase the quality of tomographic reconstructions, i.e., improving the SNR of the data and filling unsampled regions of the object’s Fourier space with consistent data. All of these methods incorporate additional constraints to restrict the solution of the reconstruction. Application of solvent flattening in single particle analysis (van Heel, 2000), projection onto convex sets (Carazo and Carrascosa, 1987), or the Gerchberg–Fienup algorithm (Spence et al., 2003) in electron crystallography can improve the
581
582
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
resulting reconstructions considerably. Despite this fact, in most cases collection of sufficient data is preferred since confining the basis set of the reconstruction can cause artifacts. In cryo-ET there is typically no a priori information available; furthermore the data are not fully consistent because some features occurring at high tilt angles are not present in low tilt angles, i.e., the “unit cell is only partially defined” (Hoppe and Hegerl, 1980). Therefore, refinement techniques are commonly not used in cryo-ET, despite unproven claims of resolution improvement close to the subnanometer regime (Sandin et al., 2004). To extend the interpretability of tomograms beyond the first zero of the CTF it would be necessary to correct for the effects of the CTF as is done in single-particle analysis. Corrections based on exit-wave reconstruction, which rely on very few projections, have been proposed to extend the achievable resolution of tomograms (Han et al., 1996). For practical implementation of a CTF correction for tomography the lateral focus gradient, particularly for high tilt angles, needs to be incorporated, which make exit-front reconstructions considerably more complicated. A simpler restoration method, which requires only one micrograph per tilt and incorporates the lateral focus gradient, has been realized recently (Winkler and Taylor, 2003). However, this restoration method is designed primarily for thin specimens. In cryo-ET, CTF corrections have not been established yet. This is primarily due to the fact that the SNR of the individual micrographs is still too low, particularly because of the poor MTF of the CCD cameras, which prohibits a precise determination of the CTF. 3.5.3 Visualization and Image Analysis The interpretation of tomograms at the ultrastructural level requires decomposition of a tomogram into its structural components, e.g., the segmentation of intracellular membranes or the assignment of organelles. Currently, a manual assignment of features is commonly used because human anticipation is still superior in most cases to available segmentation algorithms, although machine-based segmentation is in principle more objective (Frangakis and Hegerl, 2002; Volkmann, 2002). Instead of addressing the ultrastructure (Ladinsky et al., 1999), cryo-ET provides the basis for interpreting tomograms even at the molecular level. However, the analysis and 3D visualization are hampered by a very low SNR. To increase the SNR, so-called denoising algorithms have been developed (reviewed in Frangakis and Foerster, 2004). These algorithms aim to identify noise and remove it from the tomogram, but in practice, they also remove a certain fraction of the signal, resulting in data with reduced information but higher SNR. The simplest denoising techniques used diverse linear filtering operations, such as a simple low-pass filtering in Fourier space. Better signal preservation can be achieved by nonlinear filtering algorithms, such as nonlinear anisotropic diffusion (NAD) (Frangakis and Hegerl, 2001; Fernandez and Li, 2003) or bilateral filtering (Jiang et al., 2003b). NAD is particularly useful for the visualization of the ultrastructural features because it can enhance features such as membranes. In addition, these filters preserve the signal, without major alterations, which is especially suit-
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
able for visualization at the molecular resolution level. Denoising based on the wavelet transformations (Stoschek and Hegerl, 1997) maintains the high-resolution content, but requires immense computational efforts, thus currently favoring the former approaches. CET enables us to resolve large macromolecular complexes such as the 26S proteasome inside intact cells (Medalia et al., 2002). Highresolution structures of numerous macromolecules are available from X-ray crystallography or nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The purpose of many ongoing structural genomics projects is to generate a comprehensive library of protein structures. Therefore, molecular recognition is the task of locating a priori known structures in the context of cells or other complex biological samples rather than clarifying structurally novel features, e.g., as intended with denoising methods. Mapping of macromolecules on the basis of their structural signature requires the quantitative comparison of tomogram data with a library of macromolecular structures. Ideally, the search of tomograms should be exhaustive and would reveal a cellular atlas of resolvable macromolecules. Simulations and experiments with “phantom cells,” i.e., liposomes encapsulating macromolecules, indicated that such an approach is feasible (Boehm et al., 2000; Frangakis et al., 2002). The information addressing the spatial relationship of different complexes fosters and complements other proteomic methods and will be indispensable for structural proteomic approaches (Sali et al., 2003). The most common molecular detection algorithm is a locally normalized, matched filter, introduced in a different context (Roseman, 2000, 2003). It was modified to account for the missing-wedge effect (Frangakis et al., 2002) and applied to cryotomograms (Rath et al., 2003). These applications demonstrated that it is feasible to identify large macromolecular complexes (>500 kDa) within cryotomograms with high fidelity. Furthermore, the high computational demand of template matching is significantly reduced by parallelization. The information an individually resolved macromolecule contains is limited because of the low electron dose and the missing-wedge effect. Averaging techniques aim to overcome the dose limitation of resolution by explicit averaging of different reconstructions from the same particle. Iterative algorithms are used to align subtomograms of arbitrarily oriented copies of a particle and obtain a consistent average. Medium resolution (2–3 nm) structures of the thermosome and tricorn could be obtained from cryotomograms of purified complexes (Walz et al., 1997b; Nitsch et al., 1998). Generally, the resolution from cryo-ET is inferior to conventional single-particle reconstructions, which use 2D projections of particles recorded on film to obtain 3D structures. Considering the aforementioned dose fractionation theorem (see Section 3.2), the higher information content of tomograms should favor averaging of tomograms over the averaging from projections. However, the low resolution of CCD cameras compared with that of film, the alignment error of the micrographs prior to 3D reconstruction, and the current inability to correct reliably for the CTF argue against averaging of tomograms. Nevertheless, cryo-ET can provide medium-resolution structures of protein complexes without using extensive purification
583
584
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
procedures (Foerster et al., 2005). Furthermore, structures obtained by cryo-ET can be used as starting models that are refined by singleparticle techniques or can be combined with other higher resolution structural techniques to provide comprehensive descriptions of molecular complexes. 3.5.4 Identification Strategies of Macromolecular Complexes A very common approach to the task of locating features of known structure in an input scene is “matched filtering.” Matched filtering is basically the computation of a suitable cross-correlation function (CCF) of the template, a macromolecule of known structure, and the input scene, the cryo-electron tomogram (Figure 7–22). Cross-correlation functions are straightforward to compute as a function of spatial parameters r, since they can be calculated using use the fast Fourier transform (FFT) (F): CCFr = ∑ I r +r′ ⋅ Tr′ = F −1[ F( I ) ⋅ F(T )* ] . r′
The gray values of the input scene are denoted Ir and the template’s gray values are Tr. The maxima of this cross-correlation function should
Figure 7–22. Detection and identification of individual macromolecules in cellular tomograms is based on their structural signature. Because of the crowded nature of the cytoplasm and ‘contamination’ with noise, an interactive segmentation and feature extraction is not feasible. It requires sophisticated pattern recognition techniques to exploit the information contained in the tomograms. A volume rendered presentation of a 3D image is presented on the left. Even though some high-density features may be visible, an unambiguous identification of individual structures would be difficult if not impossible given the residual noise. An approach, which has proven to work, is based on template matching. Templates of the macromolecules under scrutiny are obtained by a high- or medium resolution technique (X-ray crystallography, NMR, electron crystallography or single particle analysis). These templates (4 times magnified in this figure; 20S proteasome and thermosome) are then used to search the entire volume of the tomogram systematically for matching structures by threedimensional cross-correlation and the result is refined by multivariate statistical analysis. In principle the 3D image has to be scanned for all possible Eulerian angles ϕ,ψ and θ around three different axes, with templates of all the different protein structures one is interested in e.g. the thermosome (blue) and proteasome (yellow). The search procedure is computationally very demanding but can be parallelized with respect to the different angular combinations in a highly efficient manner. Finally, the position and orientation of the different complexes can be mapped directly in the 3D image. (See color plate.)
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
585
Figure 7–23. Mapping ribosomes in an intact S. melliferum cell. a) x–y slice from the corresponding tomogram. Image analysis of this portion of the cell is displayed in subsequent panels. b) Locations and orientation of all ribosomes detected by template matching. Each 70S ribosome is represented by the averaged density (see Fig. 26) derived from the tomogram. The colour coding indicates the detection fidelity; green is high, yellow is intermediate, red is low and probably represents false positives. The brightness of the colour corresponds to correlation peaks heights. c) Final ribosome atlas after removal of putative false positives (images courtesy of J. Ortiz, MPI of Biochemistry, Martinsried, Germany; Ortiz et al., 2006). (See color plate.)
mark the positions of the features in the input scene. Three different CCFs have been introduced in the field of 2D electron microscopy: conventional XCF, phase-only filtering (POF), (Horner and Gianino, 1964), and mutual cross-correlation function (MCF; van Heel et al., 1992). In all those methods a cross-correlation function is computed: The XCF computes the unmodified cross-correlation function of template and micrograph whereas the POF and MCF vary the moduli of the template to sharpen the cross-correlation peaks. In electron microscopy especially, the low frequencies carry an extraordinarily strong signal, which can be misleading (van Heel et al., 1992). The strength of the low-frequency contributions can differ considerably within electron micrographs of amorphous specimens, such as vitrified specimens, since these are typically nonhomogeneous. The POF sets the moduli of template and input scene to one while the MCF replaces the moduli by their square roots to reduce the influence of the very lowfrequency amplitudes systematically. Another way of taking into account the strong local variations of the image contrast has been introduced recently (Roseman, 2000). By normalizing the XCF to the local cross-correlation function (LCF) variance, the efficiency of locating local features such as macromolecules within a micrograph can be increased significantly. Typically, the normalization region should correspond to the shape of the molecule. This calculation of the local variance does not lengthen the computing time unreasonably, since it can be calculated very efficiently in Fourier space too (Figures 7–23 and 7–24).
586
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
A
B CC range ribosomes expected in CC range (~fit) CC peaks presumably correct (~fit) detection reliability
I
II
III
0.3 ≥ CC>0.257
0.343 ≥ CC>0.3
CC>0.343
16,50%
33%
50%
433
127
137
26
174
143
6%
73%
96%
Figure 7–24. a) Histogram of experimentally obtained CCCs (dashed line). Ideally, the histogram should be Gaussian, reflecting the variances in SNR of individual ribosomes in the tomogram, and thresholding of the CCC should allow discriminating between correctly identified ones and false positives. Non-specific correlation with high contrast features such as the cell membrane, leads to a relative large number of false positives. For an objective setting of thresholds, the Gaussian fit (continuous line) was divided into three probability sectors larger than the mean CCC value (I, dark grey); lower than the mean value up to one standard deviation (II, intermediate grey); lower than the mean value and between one and two standard deviations (III, light grey). The spreadsheet in b) illiustrates the Gaussian fit of the experimental distribution of CCCs and the fidelity of the experimental detection of 70S ribosomes. About 80% of the particles are detected with more than 85% reliability (images courtesy of J. Ortiz, MPI of Biochemistry, Martinsried, Germany; Ortiz et al., 2006).
To evaluate which filter is best for the task of locating macromolecules, some theoretical considerations are useful. The conventional XCF has been shown to be optimal with respect to minimization of the location error (Kumar et al., 1992) and high SNR of the resulting function (VanderLugt, 1964). However, use of the XCF for locating small features within micrographs or cryoelectron tomograms yields intolerably high rates of false positives; the XCF tends to locate high-contrast features rather than low-contrast macromolecules. The same typically holds for the MCF, whereas the POF overamplifies noise, which makes
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
it unfavorable. Therefore, local normalization is appropriate. However, regarding the SNR of the resulting correlation function, the LCF is inevitably worse than XCF or MCF; confinement of the correlation to N voxels raises the noise level, which should be proportional to N−1/2. The size of the normalization region should correspond to the envelope of the template under scrutiny. Choosing the local region larger will increase the SNR of the filter output at the cost of increasing the chance of false positives simultaneously, in particular if particles tend to be very dense within the input scene. Whenever justified circular (2D) or spherical (3D) normalization regions (Θ) will be used because this accelerates the computation considerably compared to approaches using asymmetric regions. If the template has one rotational degree of freedom perpendicular to the specimen plane within the input scene, the problem of matching a 2D template in a 2D image can be formulated as determining the maxima of a cross-correlation function as a function of spatial variable r and rotation angle ϕ: XCFr ,ϕ = ∑ I r + r ′ ⋅ Rϕ (Tr ′ ) . r′
Here Rϕ denotes the rotation operator. By expanding the template in circular harmonics, exhaustive scanning of the polar angle ϕ can be avoided (Kunath and Sack-Kongehl, 1989). In 3D, the problem of finding a macromolecule in a tomogram that matches a 3D template by crosscorrelation becomes six-dimensional: Using the Euler angles ϕ, ψ and ϑ to describe the orientation, the maxima of the CCF.r;ϕψϑ are to be determined. Again, the translational dependence can be covered using FFT, but it is normally necessary to perform an explicit scanning in angular space to cover those parameters. An exhaustive search is computationally very time demanding. However, because of the emerging facilities of parallel computing this task can easily be faced: Since the CCF can be computed individually for different orientations, the entire calculation can be distributed over different processors with hardly any administrative overlap (Frangakis and Hegerl, 2002; Rath et al., 2003). In cryo-ET the partial sampling of the object’s Fourier space, the “missing wedge,” has to be considered further. This can be done by confining the correlation to the sampled region in Fourier space or equivalently by convoluting the object with the point-spread function (Frangakis and Hegerl, 2002). In the framework of the locally normalized CCF the missing wedge affects the local normalization. The missing wedge can be taken into account in Fourier space by multiplication of the template with a suitable binary function or equivalently by convoluting with a suitable PSF in real space. In this notation, the confined cross-correlation function can be defined as CCFrϕψϑ =
∑
I
r′ r +r′
∑
r′
⋅ (Tr′ϕψϑ ⊗ PSFϕψϑ ⋅ Θ r′ ) Q r′ ⋅ ( I r +r′ − I r′ )
2
where I¯ r′ represents the local mean value within Θ. A natural way of avoiding the limitation of beam damage in tomography is averaging of copies of structural elements occurring in a tomogram. Saxberg and
587
588
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
Saxton (1981) already concluded from their results on resolution limitation in electron tomography due to beam damage that averaging is a practical way of increasing the effective electron doses and should be considered to achieve high resolutions. The importance of those techniques to derive information on the molecular level was reemphasized recently (Steven and Aebi, 2003). According to the dose fractionation theorem a tomogram describes a volume element with the same statistical significance as a projection with the same dose (Hegerl and Hoppe, 1976; McEwen et al., 1995). Therefore, tomograms should be just as well suited to posterior averaging procedures for obtaining high-resolution information as compared to single-particle averaging. In practice, both approaches have their pros and cons, which are discussed below. Averaging of particles from tomograms can be performed in the same way as single-particle averaging. Projection matching is crucial in these techniques: The individual particle projections are iteratively aligned to projections of a reference from different angles by means of cross-correlation. The reference is thus the average of the particles using the orientations and displacements of the previous iteration. The iterative refinement of orientation and displacements improves the resolution of the average until convergence is achieved. The analogous procedure in cryo-ET could be termed “tomogram matching.” Subtomograms containing the roughly centered particles of interest need to be extracted from the entire tomogram and aligned using procedures as sketched in Figure 7–25. The aim of those tomogram matching procedures is to optimize the orientations, i.e., the Euler angles ϕ, ψ, and ϑ, and the displacement shifts of the individual particles. A first realization of this approach was reported by Walz et al. (1997). Application of this implementation on tomograms of purified protein complexes resulted in the generation of a pseudo-atomic map of the thermosome in the open conformation (Nitsch et al., 1998).
Figure 7–25. a) Averaged structure of the 70S ribosome derived from the dataset above (average from 300 individual particles to ∼4 nm resolution). The map highlights the 30S subunit in yellow. b) Docking of high resolution structures of the 70S ribosome into the map shown in A. c) “Crown view” of B (images courtesy of J. Ortiz, MPI of Biochemistry, Martinsried, Germany). (See color plate.)
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
However, cryo-ET is conventionally not used for this purpose for several major reasons: (1) It is much easier to acquire the data by spending the entire dose on only one projection; this makes acquisition of large amounts of individual molecules much easier. (2) The SNR of a projection of a particle is better than the SNR of a tomogram of the same particle acquired with the same electron dose. (3) There is only one level of alignment: In tomography the projections need to be aligned to a common origin prior to aligning the individual particles with respect to each other. Both steps inevitably introduce errors that sum up. But averaging of cryo-ET data can offer some advantages that are worth the additional efforts in some cases. The most important reason is the ability to image nonpurified samples (Figure 7–26). CET is currently the only technique that can be used for quaternary structure determination of fragile or even transient complexes. The degree of alteration that biological macromolecules undergo under physiological conditions is largely undetermined since there was no imaging technique that could resolve them in the context of a cell. Apart from this, averaging of subtomograms also offers one principal advantage compared to averaging from projections: It is fundamentally easier to determine the orientations of an individual copy from 3D data than from projection data.
4 Perspectives: New Strategies and Developments The achievements made by cryo-ET over the past decade have proven the possibilities and the feasibility of this technique for quasi in vivo studies of the ultrastructure and larger supramolecular assemblies within whole cells. However, based on the initial developments in cryo-ET, major improvements in instrumentation and sample preparation have to be made in the future to exploit its full potential. The ultimate goal in structural biology is to investigate the structure–function relationship of molecular complexes and supramolecular assemblies in their native environment, e.g., in large cells or even tissue, across several dimensions, from the micrometer level to the subnanometer level, and if possible within one single experiment, to realize the complete view into the inner space of cells and its constituents. Even at the present practical level cryoelectron tomograms of organelles and cells contain an imposing amount of information. They are, essentially, 3D images of entire proteomes, and they should ultimately enable us to map the spatial relationships of the full complement of macromolecules in an unperturbed cellular context. However, it is obvious that new strategies in sample preparation, advancements in instrumentation, and innovative image analysis techniques are needed to make this dream come true, at least to some extent. In principle there are three major routes to increase the image quality, and especially the 3D image quality, which are intrinsically linked to each other: (1) the technological developments comprising
589
590
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
advanced electron optics, highly resolved high-sensitive detection, improved tilting devices, and the geometry of the sample holder, (2) the sample preparation and thus the quality of the sample, and (3) the design of new software algorithms and acquisition schemes to guarantee a quantitative, objective, and exhaustive analysis of the recorded data. TEM or EM is still a very young method if compared to light microscopy. While the latter was developed and improved over centuries, EM has a history of less than 80 years. Microscopes can now easily can reach a resolution in 2D of less than 1 Å, clearly orders of magnitude better than what light microscopy can offer. However, the electron optical system, determined mainly by the objective lens system and characterized by the spherical and chromatic aberration coefficients, is far from being ideal and is still inferior to light optical devices. Simplified, the performance of present objective lens systems in EM can be described as an attempt to focus through the bottom of a champagne bottle. This way, the quality of the recorded micrograph in EM suffers greatly from the severe shortcomings of the objective lens system, e.g., the higher the spherical aberration coefficient Cs, the better the resulting image contrast, but the lower the resolution. However, the spherical aberration coefficient is linked directly to the “spacing” inside the objective lens system and thus determines the maximum achievable tilt range for an angular acquisition. Recent developments in Cs correction technology for TEM (and even for SEM) demonstrated the possibilities and the final image improvement, especially in material science studies. However, EM investigations of biological samples at cryotemperatures are characterized by a very low image contrast, due to the very weak scatterers, mainly low Z elements, such as carbon, oxygen, and hydrogen. Thus high defocus values are more or less mandatory, to increase the image contrast. Unfortunately, by tuning the objective lens to very low defocus values of a couple of micrometers, low-frequency information is enhanced, while high-frequency information is almost completely obscured if not totally lost. Thus Cs correction without any additional equipment is not an option in any cryo-EM study, because the actual improvement in image quality is restricted to a defocus regime in the range of a couple of tenths of nanometers, thus orders of magnitude higher than what would be needed for a highcontrast (low-dose) cryoimage. Nevertheless, it might be possible to increase the contrast without defocusing the objective lens, by using so-called phase plates in combination with Cs correctors. The benefit of Cs correction would then become clearly visible, because even highfrequency information would be accessible. Clearly the design and the application of phase plates are not new, but the technological problems in former times could not be addressed to enable their routine use. Two of the major problems were contamination and stability. While placed in the back focal plane, very close to the sample, contamination caused charging and drift problems. Moreover, because the stability was low, it was mandatory to readjust the phase plate in respect to the central beam, which, in terms of required accuracy, is
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
possible today only with piezo-controlled stages. However, present achievements and possibilities in nanostructuring and nanotechnology made it possible to utilize the already existing designs of phase plates, addressing the aforementioned problems, and place them in a normal EM environment. The prospects are good and in the near future experiments will be done to show not only the feasibility of this approach, but also the final image improvement if, for example, used in combination with Cs correction. However, the total sum of elastically scattered electrons will be reduced and thus the large fraction of inelastically scattered electrons has to be removed or even utilized for final image formation. “Removal” can be done with imaging energy filters, which are now routinely incorporated into the EM setup. They are especially helpful in studies in which thick cells or sections are used, because the larger the material layer to be penetrated by the electron beam, the larger the fraction of inelastically and multiple-scattered electrons. They will have a different energy, and thus they will be slightly out of focus, blurring the recorded image. However, if the chromatic electrons are removed, the image contrast can be definitely improved, but the number of elastically scattered electrons (forming the image) will be just a fraction of the total sum of electrons leaving the sample. In most cases the amount is only a half or a third of the total applied electron dose to the sample, which contributes to final image contrast. This way, the detection has to be very sensitive, so that literally every electron will count. Today, typically CCD cameras are used, which detect the signal indirectly and which add noise to the recorded image. Moreover the signal is spread over several pixels, decreasing the lateral resolution and thus the transfer of the recorded image. Direct detection would be beneficial and favorable, because every electron would contribute to the final signal, with no readout noise and the best possible lateral resolution. Developments will utilize detectors based on CMOS technology, which will guarantee a noise-free detection and, if backthinned, a highly resolved recording. However, the radiation hardness of these devices, for 300-keV electrons, is at the moment insufficient for routine use in EM, but improvements are being made to increase the lifetime of these detection devices, so that they can be used almost continuously. Since we cannot increase the total applied dose to the sample, not even by cooling to liquid helium temperature, the only option we do have is to increase the performance of the detection device and the electron optics. If, for example, an almost ideal detector, could be utilized, the dose in a recorded image can be as low as possible and thus the number of acquired projections in an angular regime can be as large as possible. This way the fi nal resolution would be defi nitely improved. Moreover, if high-end electron optical systems are used, e.g., Cs or even Cc correctors (which would even utilize the fraction of inelastically scattered electrons for image formation) in combination with phase plates and energy filters, not only the low-frequency information, responsible for the fi nal image contrast, but also the high-frequency information, containing the fi ne struc-
591
592
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister
tural details, could be harvested. Moreover, with just one single 2D image, it would be possible to obtain phase and amplitude information separately. In addition to the improved quality of the single 2D projection, in phase plate Cs-corrected imaging, ET is still hampered by an uneven sampling in Fourier space and thus by the fact that information in the direction of the tilt axis cannot be accessed. This missing information (missing wedge), due to the limited tilt range, can be decreased by utilizing dual-axis acquisition schemes to a missing pyramid. Clearly, with the 90° in-plane rotation of the sample and the acquisition of twotilt series of the same sample area, it is possible to increase the amount of information by more than 20% and thus reduce the resulting artifacts related to single-axis-acquisition schemes. The resolution is not improved, however, it is definitely more isotropic. Especially for subsequent automatic detection of macromolecules and proteins within the tomographic volume, e.g., by template matching, errors (falsepositives) can be minimized, and thus the quality of the detection can be vastly improved. At the present resolution of 4–5 nm only very large complexes (ribosomes, 26S proteasomes) can be detected reliably within cryoelectron tomograms of whole cells. However, an improvement in resolution to 2 nm will allow us to detect medium sized complexes in the range of 200–400 kDa. Some of the problems in the interpretation of tomograms will disappear once a resolution of 2 nm is obtained. At the moment, with a resolution of 4–6 nm, docking of high-resolution structures to yield pseudo-atomic maps of molecular complexes is computationally demanding and time consuming. However, this procedure of template matching and docking will become easier if a resolution of 2 nm can be routinely obtained. The computational methods described will aid and complement the information provided by other approaches and information, such as localization, labeling studies, and the binding properties of molecules. While tomograms with a resolution of 2 nm are a realistic prospect, major technical innovations (see above) will be required to go beyond this. CET of whole cells allows us to investigate the structure– function relationship of molecular complexes and supramolecular assemblies in their native environment. It thus results in a fundamental change in the way we approach biochemical processes that underlie and orchestrate higher cellular functions. In the past, molecular interactions were studied mostly in a collective manner, whereas now we have the tools to visualize the interactions between individual molecules in their unperturbed functional environments. Although they share common underlying principles, no two cells or organelles are identical, owing to the inherent stochasticity of biochemical processes in cells as well as their functional diversity. Therefore, it will be a major challenge to extract generic features from the maps, such as the modes of interaction between molecular species. The ultimate goal, the discovery of general rules that underlie cellular processes, has to go beyond observing qualitative features and has to be based on stringent analytical criteria (Lucic et al., 2005).
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET)
References Al-Amoudi, A., Dubochet, J., Gnaegi, H., Lueth, W. and Studer, D. (2003). An oscillating cryo-knife reduces cutting-induced deformation of vitreous ultrathin sections. J. Microsc. 212(1), 26–33. Al-Amoudi, A., Studer, D. and Dubochet, J. (2005). Cutting artefacts and cutting process in vitreous sections for cryo-electron microscopy. J. Struct. Biol. 150(1), 109–121. Alberts, B. (1998). The cell as a collection of protein machines: Preparing the next generation of molecular biologists. Cell 92, 291–294. Adrian, M., Dubochet, J., Lepault, J. and McDowall, A.W. (1984). Cryo-electron microscopy of viruses. Nature 308, 32–36. Agard, D.A. (2005). Private communications. Angert, I., Majorovits, E. and Schroeder, R.R. (2000). Zero-loss image formation and modified contrast transfer theory in EFTEM. Ultramicroscopy 81(3–4), 203–222. Barnard, D.P., Turner, J.N., Frank, J. and McEwen, B.F. (1992). A 360° single-axis tilt stage for the high-voltage electron microscope. J. Microsc. 167, 39–48. Baumeister, W. and Typke, D. (1993). Electron crystallography of proteins: State of the art strategies for the furure. MSA Bull. 23, 11–19. Beck, M., Forster, F., Ecke, M., Plitzko, J.M., Melchior, F., Gerisch, G., Baumeister, W. and Medalia, O. (2004). Nuclear pore complex structure and dynamics revealed by cryoelectron tomography. Science 306(5700), 1387–1390. *Beck, M., Lucic, V., Förster, F., Baumeister, W. and Medalia, O. (2007). Snapshots of nuclear pore complexes in action captured by cryo-electron tomography. Nature 449, 611–615. Bernhard, W. (1965). Ultramicrotomie à basse température. Ann. Biol. 4, 5–19. Boehm, J., Frangakis, A.S., Hegerl, R., Nickell, S., Typke, D. and Baumeister, W. (2000). Toward detecting and identifying macromolecules in a cellular context: Template matching applied to electron tomograms. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 97, 14245–14250. Boehm, J., Lamber, O., Frangakis, A.S., Letellier, L., Baumeister, W. and Rigaud, J.L. (2001). FhuA-mediated phage genome transfer into liposomes: A cryoelectron tomography study. Curr. Biol. 11, 1168–1175. Bottcher, B., Wynne, S.A. and Crowther, R.A. (1997). Determination of the fold of the core protein of hepatitis B virus by electron cryomicroscopy. Nature 386, 88–91. Bouwer, J.C., Mackey, M.R., Lawrence, A., Deerinck, T.J., Jones, Y.Z., Terada, M., Martone, M.E., Peltier, S. and Ellisman, M.H. (2004). Automated mostprobable loss tomography of thick selectively stained biological specimens with quantitative measurement of resolution improvement. J. Struc. Biol. 148(3), 297–306. Bracewell, R.N. (1956). Strip integration in radio astronomy. Aust. J. Phys. 9, 198–217. Braunfeld, M.B., Koster, A.J., Sedat, J.W. and Agard, D.A. (1994). Cryo automated electron tomography—towards high resolution reconstructions of plastic embedded structures. J. Microsc. 172(2), 75–84. Brenner, S. and Horne, R.W. (1959). A negative staining method for high resolution electron microscopy of viruses. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 34, 60–71. Brink, H.A., Barfels, M.M.G., Burgner, R.P. and Edwards, B.N. (2003). A sub-50 meV spectrometer and energy filter for use in combination with 200 kV monochromated (S)TEMs. Ultramicroscopy 96(3–4), 367–384. Carazo, J.M. and Carrascosa, J.L. (1987). Restoration of direct Fourier threedimensional reconstructions of crystalline specimens by the method of convex projections. J. Microsc. 145(2), 159–177.
593
594
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister Coene, W.M.J., Thust, A., Op de Beeck, M. and Van Dyck, D. (1996). Maximumlikelihood method for focus-variation image reconstruction in high resolution transmission electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 64(1–4), 109–135. Comolli, L.R. and Downing, K. (2005). Dose tolerance at helium and nitrogen temperature for whole cell electron tomography. J Struct. Biol. 152, 149–156. Conway, J.F., Trus, B.L., Booy, F.P., Newcomb, W.W., Brown, J.C. and Steven, A.C. (1993). The effects of radiation damage on the structure of forzen hydrated HSV-1 capsids. J. Struct. Biol. 111(3), 222–233. Cormack, A.M. (1963). Representation of a function by its line integrals, with some radiological applications. J. Appl. Phys. 34(1530), 2722–2727. Cormack, A.M. (1980). Early two-dimensional reconstruction and recent topics stemming from it. Nobel lecture 1979. Medi. Phys. 7(4), 277–282. Crowther, R.A. and Klug, A. (1971). ART and science or conditions for threedimensional reconstruction from electron microscope images. J. Theor. Biol. 32, 199–203. Crowther, R.A., DeRosier, D.J. and Klug, A. (1970). The reconstruction of a three-dimensional structure from its projections and its applications to electron microscopy. Proc. R. Soci. London 317, 319–340. Danev, R. and Nagayama, K. (2001). Complex observation in electron microscopy. II. Direct visualization of phases and amplitudes of exit wave functions. J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 70(3), 696–702. Deans, S.R. (1983). The Radon Transform and Some of Its Applications (John Wiley & Sons, New York). De Carlo, S., Adrian, M., Kalin, P., Mayer, J.M. and Dubochet, J. (1999). Unexpected property of trehalose as observed by cryo-electron microscopy. J. Microsc. 196(1), 40–45. DeRosier, D.J. and Klug, A. (1968). Reconstruction of three dimensional structures from electron micrographs. Nature 217, 130–134. Dierksen, K., Typke, D., Hegerl, R., Koster, A.J. and Baumeister, W. (1992). Towards automated electron tomography. Ultramicroscopy 40, 71–87. Dierksen, K., Typke, D., Hegerl, R. and Baumeister, W. (1993). Towards automatic electron tomography. II. Implementation of autofocus and low-dose procedures. Ultramicroscopy 49(1–4), 109–120. Dierksen, K., Typke, D., Hegerl, R., Walz, J., Sackmann, E. and Baumeister, W. (1995). Three-dimensional structure of lipid vesicles embedded in vitreous ice and investigated by automated electron tomography. Biophys. J. 68, 1416–1422. Downing, K.H. and Hendrickson, F.M. (1999). Performance of a 2k CCD camera designed for electron crystallography at 400 kV. Ultramicroscopy 75(4), 215–233. Downing, K.H. and Mooney, P.E. (2004). CCD camera with electron decelerator for intermediate voltage electron microscopy. Microsc. Microanal. 10(Suppl. 2), 1378–1379. Downing, K.H., Favia, P. and Mooney, P.E. (2000). Electron decelerator for improved CCD performance in intermediate voltage electron microscopy. Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the Microscopy Society of America, 734–735. Dubochet, J. and McDowall, A.W. (1981). Vitrification of pure water for electron microscopy. J. Microsc. 124, RP3–4. Dubochet, J., Adrian, M., Chang, J.J., Homo, J.-C., Lepault, J., McDowall, A.W. and Schultz, P. (1988). Cryo-electron microscopy of vitrified sections. Quart. Rev. Biophys. 21(2), 129–228. Egerton, R.F. (1996). Electron Energy-Loss Spectroscopy in the Electron Microscope (Plenum Press, New York).
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET) Ellis, R.J. (2001). Macromolecular crowding: Obvious but underappreciated. Trends Biochem. Sci. 26(10), 597–604. Ellis, R.J. and Minton, A.P. (2003). Join the crowd. Nature 425, 27–28. Ermantraut, E., Wohlfart, K. and Tichelaar, W. (1998). Perforated support foils with pre-defined hole size, shape and arrangement. Ultramicroscopy 74(1–2), 75–81. Evans, D.A., Allport, P.P., Casse, G., Faruqi, A.R., Gallop, B., Henderson, R., Prydderch, M., Turchetta, R., Tyndel, M., Velthuis, J., Villani, G. and Waltham, N. (2005). CMOS active pixel sensors for ionising radiation. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. Sect. A—Accel. Spectrom. Detect. Assoc. Equip. 546(1–2), 281–285. Fan, G.Y. and Ellisman, M.H. (1996). Optimization of thin-foil based phosphor screens for CCD imaging in TEM in the voltage range of 80–400 kV. Ultramicroscopy 66(1–2), 11–19. Fan, G.Y. and Ellismann, M.H. (2000). Digital imaging in transmission electron microscopy. J. Microsc. 200(1), 1–13. Fan, G.Y., Datte, P., Beuville, E., Beche, J.F., Millaud, J., Downing, K.H., Burkard, F.T., Ellisman M.H. and Xuong, N.H. (1998). ASIC-based eventdriven 2D digital electron counter for TEM imaging. Ultramicroscopy 70(3), 107–113. Fan, G.Y., Peltier, S., Lamont, S., Dunkelberger, D.G., Burke, B.E. and Ellisman, M.H. (2000). Multiport-readout frame-transfer 5 megapixel CCD imaging system for TEM applications. Ultramicroscopy 84(1–2), 75–84. Faruqi, A.R. and Subramaniam, S. (2000). CCD detectors in high-resolution biological electron microscopy. Quart. Rev. Biophys. 33(1), 1–27. Faruqi, A.R., Cattermole, D.M. and Raeburn, C. (2003a). Direct electron detection methods in electron microscopy. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. Sect. A—Accel. Spectrom. Detect. Assoc. Equip. 513(1–2), 317–321. Faruqi, A.R., Cattermole, D.M., Henderson, R., Mikulec, B. and Raeburn, C. (2003b). Evaluation of a hybrid pixel detector for electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 94(3–4), 263–276. FEI Company, Hillsboro, OR and Eindhoven, Netherlands (www.feicompany. com). Fernandez, J.J. and Li, S. (2003). An improved algorithm for anisotropic nonlinear diffusion for denoising cryo-tomograms. J. Struct. Biol. 144(1–2), 152–161. Fernandez, J.J., Lawrence, A.F., Roca, J., Garcia, I., Ellisman, M.H. and Carazo, J.M. (2002). High-performance electron tomography of complex biological specimens. J. Struct. Biol. 138(1–2), 6–20. Feya, B. and Aebi, U. (1999). Determination of the inelastic mean free path of electrons in vitrified ice for on-line thickness measurements by zero-loss imaging. J. Microsc. 193, 15–19. Fischione Instruments, Inc., Export, PA (www.fischione.com). Forster, F., Medalia, O., Zauberman, N., Baumeister, W. and Fass, D. (2005). Retrovirus envelope protein complex structure in situ studied by cryoelectron tomography. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 102(13), 4729–4734. Frangakis, A.S. and Hegerl, R. (2001). Noise reduction in electron tomographic reconstructions using nonlinear anisotropic diffusion. J. Struct. Biol. 135(3), 239–250. Frangakis, A.S. and Hegerl, R. (2002). Segmentation of two- and threedimensional data from electron microscopy using eigenvector analysis. J. Struct. Biol. 138(1–2), 105–113. Frangakis, A.S. and Foerster, F. (2004). Computational exploration of structural information from cryo-electron tomograms. Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 14, 1–7. Frangakis, A.S., Böhm, J., Förster, F., Nickell, S., Nicastro, D., Typke, D., Hegerl, R. and Baumeister, W. (2002). Identification of macromolecular complexes
595
596
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister in cryoelectron tomograms of phantom cells. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 99(22), 14153–14158. Frank, J. (1973). The envelope of electron-microscopic transfer functions for partially coherent illumination. Optik 38, 519–539. Frank, J. (1992). Electron Tomography: Three-Dimensional Imaging with the Transmission Electron Microscope (Plenum Press, New York). Frank, J. (1996). Three-Dimensional Electron Microscopy of Macromolecular Assemblies (Academic Press, London). Frank, J., Zhu, J., Penczeck, P., Li, Y., Srivastava, S., Verschoor, A., Radermacher, M., Grassucci, R., Lata, R.K. and Agrawal, R.K. (1995). A model of protein synthesis based on cryo-electron microscopy of the E. Coli ribosome. Nature 376, 441–444. Frederik, P.M., Bomans, P.H.H. and Stuart, M.C.A. (1991). The ultrastructure of cryo-sections and intact vitrified cells—The effect of cryoprotectants and acceleration voltage on beam induced bubbling. Scanning Microsc. (Suppl. 5), S43–S52. Freitag, B., Kujawa, S., Mul, P.M., Ringnalda, J. and Tiemeijer, P.C. (2005). Breaking the spherical and chromatic aberration barrier in transmission electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 102(3), 209–214. Fujiyoshi, Y. (1998). The structural study of membrane proteins by electron crystallography. Adv. Biophys. 35, 25–80. Gatan, Inc., Pleasanton, CA (www.gatan.com). Gilbert, P.F.C. (1972). The reconstruction of a three-dimensional structure from projections and its application to electron microscopy. II. Direct methods. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B Biol. Sci. 182, 89–102. Grimm, R., Baermann, M., Haeckl, W., Typke, D., Sackmann, E. and Baumeister, W. (1996a). Energy-filtered electron tomography of ice-embedded actin and vesicles. Biophys. J. 72, 482–489. Grimm, R., Barmann, M., Typke, D. and Baumeister, W. (1996b). Determination of the inelastic mean free path by examination of tilted vesicles and most probable loss imaging. Ultramicroscopy 63(3–4), 169–179. Grimm, R., Singh, H., Rachel, R., Typke, D., Zillig, W. and Baumeister, W. (1998). Electron tomography of ice-embedded prokaryotic cells. Biophys. J. 74, 1031–1042. Gruenewald, K., Desai, P., Winkler, D.C., Heymann, J.B., Belnap, D.M., Baumeister, W. and Steven, A.C. (2003). Three-dimensional structure of herpes simples virus from cryo-electron tomography. Science 302, 1396–1398. Gubbens, A.J. and Krivanek, O.L. (1993). Applications of a post-column imaging filter in biology and materials science. Ultramicroscopy 51(1–4), 146–159. Gubbens, A.J., Kraus, B., Krivanek, O.L. and Mooney, P.E. (1995). An imaging filter for high voltage electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 59(1–4), 255–265. Guckenberger, R. (1982). Determination of a common origin in the micrographs of tilt series in three-dimensional electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 9, 167–174. Haider, M., Uhlemann, S., Schwan, E., Rose, H., Kabius, B. and Urban, K. (1998). Electron microscopy image enhanced. Nature 392, 768–769. Han, K.F., Gubbens, A.J., Sedat, J.W. and Agard, D.A. (1996). Optimal strategies for imaging thick biological specimens—exit wave-front reconstruction and energy filtered imaging. J. Microsc. 183, 124–132. Harauz, G. and van Heel, M. (1986). Exact filter for general geomer threedimensional reconstruction. Optik 73, 146–156. Hart, R.G. (1968). Electron microscopy of unstained biological material: The polytropic montage. Science 159, 1464–1467. Hayward, S.B. and Glaeser, R.M. (1979). Radiation damage of purple membrane at low temperature. Ultramicroscopy 4(2), 201–210.
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET) Hegerl, R. and Hoppe, W. (1976). Influence of electron noise on threedimensional image reconstruction. Z. Naturforschung. 31a, 1717–1721. Heide, H.G. (1984). Observation on ice layers. Ultramicroscopy 14(3), 271–278. Henderson, R., Baldwin, J.M., Ceska, T.A., Beckman, E., Zemlin, F. and Downing, K. (1990). A model for the structure of bacteriorhodopsin based on high resolution electron cryomicrsocopy. J. Mol. Biol. 213, 899–929. Herman, G.T. (1980). On the noise in images produced by computed tomography. Comput. Graphics Image Process. 12(3), 271–285. Herrmann, K.-H. and Krahl, D. (1982). The detection quantum efficiency of electronic image recording systems. J. Microsc. 127(1), 17–28. Hoppe, W. (1969). Das Endlichkeitspostulat und das Interpolationstheorem der dreidimensionalen elektronenmikroskopischen Analyse aperiodischer Strukturen. Optik 29, 617–621. Hoppe, W. (1974). Towards three-dimensional electron microscopy at atomic resolution. Z. Naturwissenschaft. 61, 239–249. Hoppe, W. and Hegerl, R. (1980). Three-dimensional structure determination by electron microscopy (nonperiodic specimens). In Computer Processing of Electron Microscopic Images (P.W. Hawkes, Ed.), 127–185 (Springer-Verlag, Berlin). Hoppe, W., Langer, R., Knesch, G. and Poppe, C. (1968). Proteinkristallstrukturanalyse mit Elektronenstrahlen. Z. Naturwissenschaft. 55, 333–336. Hoppe, W., Gassmann, J., Hunsmann, N., Schramm, H.J. and Strum, M. (1974). Three dimensional reconstruction of individual negatively stained yeast fatty-acid synthetase molecules from tilt series in the electron microscope. Hoppe-Seylers Z. Physiol. Chem. 335, 1483–1487. Horner. J.L. and Gianino, P.D. (1964). Phase-only matched filtering. Appl. Opt. 23, 812–816. Horowitz, R.A., Agard, D., Sedat, J.W. and Woodcock, C.L. (1994). The threedimensional architecture of chromatin in situ: Electron tomography reveals fibers composed of a continuously variable zig-zag nucleosomal ribbon. J. Cell Biol. 125, 1–10. Hounsfield, G.N. (1972). A method and apparatus for examination of a body by radiation such as X- or gamma radiation. The Patent Office, London. Hsieh, C.E., Marko, M., Frank, J. and Mannella, C.A. (2002). Electron tomographic analysis of frozen-hydrated tissue sections. J. Struct. Biol. 138(1–2), 63–73. Janesick, J.R. (2001). Scientific Charge-Coupled Devices (SPIE Press, Bellingham, WA). JEOL Ltd., Tokyo, Japan (www.jeol.com). Jia, C.L., Lentzen, M. and Urban, K. (2003). Atomic-resolution imaging of oxygen in perovskite ceramics. Science 299, 870–873. Jiang, W., Li, Z., Zhang, Z., Baker, M.L., Prevelige Jr, P.E. and Chiu, W. (2003a). Coat protein fold and maturation transition of bacteriophage P22 seen at subnanometer resolutions, Nature Struct. Biol. 10, 131–135. Jiang, W., Baker, M.L., Wu, Q., Bajaj, C. and Chiu, W. (2003b). Applications of a bilateral denoising filter in biological electron microscopy. J. Struct. Biol. 144(1–2), 114–122. Kisielowski, C., Hetherington, C.J.D., Wang, Y.C., Kilaas, R., O’Keefe, M.A. and Thust, A. (2001). Imaging columns of the light elements carbon, nitrogen and oxygen with sub Angstrom resolution. Ultramicroscopy 89(4), 243–263. Klumpp, M. and Baumeister, W. (1998). The thermosome—Archetype of group II chaperonins. FEBS Lett. 430(1–2 Special Issue SI), 73–77. Klumpp, M., Baumeister, W. and Essen, L.O. (1997). Structure of the substrate binding domain of the thermosome, an archeal group II chaperonin. Cell 91(2), 263–270.
597
598
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister Knapek, E. (1982). Properties of organic specimens and their supports at 4K under irradiation in an electron microscope. Ultramicroscopy 10(1–2), 71–86. Koster, A.J. and de Ruijter, W.J. (1992). Practical autoalignment of transmission electron microscopes. Ultramicroscopy 40, 89–107. Koster, A.J. and Klumperman, J. (2003). Electron microscopy in cell biology: Integrating structure and function. Nature Cell Biol. (Suppl. S), SS6–SS10. Koster, A.J., de Ruijter, W.J., van den Bos, A. and van der Mast, K.D. (1989). Autotuning of a TEM using minimum electron dose. Ultramicroscopy 27(3), 251–272. Koster, A.J., Chen, H., Sedat, J.W. and Agard, D. (1992). Automated microscopy for electron tomography. Ultramicroscopy 46, 207–227. Koster, A.J., Grimm, R., Typke, D., Hegerl, R., Stoschek, A., Walz, J. and Baumeister, W. (1997). Perspectives of molecular and cellular electron tomography. J. Struct. Biol. 120(3), 276–308. Knoll, M. and Ruska, E. (1932). Das Elektronenmikroskop. Z. Phys. 78, 318–339. Kremer, J.R., Mastronarde, D.N. and Mcintosh, J.R. (1996). Computer visualization of three-dimensional data using IMOD. J. Struct. Biol. 116(1), 71–76. Krivanek, O.L. and Mooney, P.E. (1993). Applications of slow-scan CCD cameras in transmission electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 49(1–4), 95–108. Krivanek, O.L., Gubbens, A.J. and Dellby, N. (1991). Development in EELS instrumentation for spectroscopy and imaging. Microsc. Microanal. Microstruct. 2, 315–332. Krivanek, O.L., Gubbens, A.J., Dellby, N. and Meyer, C.E. (1992). Design and first applications of a post-column imaging filter. Microsc. Microanal. Microstruct. 3(2–3), 187–199. Krivanek, O.L., Friedman, S.L., Gubbens, A.J. and Kraus, B. (1995). An imaging filter for biological applications. Ultramicroscopy 59(1–4), 267–282. Kumar Vijaya, B.V.K., Dickey, F.M. and DeLaurentis, J.M. (1992). Correlation filters minimizing peak location errors. J. Opt. Soc. Am. A—Opt. Image Sci. 9(5), 678–682. Kunath, W. and Sack-Kongehl, H. (1989). Circular harmonic averaging of noisy single-molecule images. Ultramicroscopy 27(2), 171–184. Ladinsky, M.S., Mastronarde, D.N., McIntosh, J.R., Howell, K.E. and Staehelin, L.A. (1999). Golgi structure in three dimensions: Functional insights from the normal rat kidney cell. J. Cell Biol. 144(6), 1135–1149. Langmore, J.P. and Smith, M.F. (1992). Quantitative energy filtered electron microscopy of biological molecules in ice. Ultramicroscopy 46, 349–373. Lanio, S. (1986). High-resolution imaging magnetic energy filters with simple sructure. Optik 73, 99–107. Lanio, S., Rose, H. and Krahl, D. (1986). Test and improved design of a corrected imaging magnetic energy filter. Optik 73(2), 56–68. Lawrence, M.C. (1992). Least-squares method of alignment using markers. In Electron Tomography: Three-Dimensional Imaging with the Transmission Electron Microscope (J. Frank, Ed.), (Plenum Press, New York). Leis, A., Andrees, L., Gruska, M., Al-Amoudi, A., Sartori, A., Dubochet, J. and Baumeister, W. (2005). Cryo-electron tomography and fluorescence microscopy of unicellular algae in vitreous cryosections. Proceedings of the 63rd Annual Meeting MSA. Microsc. Microanal. 11(Suppl. 2), 330–331. Lengweiler, S., Birrer, G., Müller, M. and Stemmer, A. (2004). Ideal eucentric goniometer for electron tomography. Proceedings of the 13th European Microscopy Congress, Antwerp, Belgium, Vol. 1, IM07.O4 CD. Lentzen, M. (2004). The tuning of a Zernike phase plate with defocus and variable spherical aberration and its use in HRTEM imaging. Ultramicroscopy 99(4), 211–220.
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET) Lentzen, M., Jahnen, B., Jia, C.L., Thust, A., Tillmann, K. and Urban, K. (2002). High-resolution imaging with an aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope. Ultramicroscopy 92(3–4), 233–242. Li, H.L., DeRosier, D.J., Nicholson, W.V., Nogales, E. and Downing, K.H. (2002). Microtubule structure at 8 Ångstrom resolution. Structure 10(10), 1317–1328. Lowe, J., Stock, D., Jap, R., Zwickl, P., Baumeister, W. and Huber, R. (1995). Crystal strcuture of the 20S proteasome from the archaeon T-acidophilum at 3.4Å resolution. Science 268(5210), 533–539. Lucic, V., Foerster, F. and Baumeister, W. (2005). Structural studies by electron tomography: From cells to molecules. Annu. Rev. Biochem. 74, 833–865. Luther, P.K. (1992). Sample shrinkage and radiation damage. In Electron Tomography: Three-Dimensional Imaging with the Transmission Electron Microscope (J. Frank, Ed.), 39 (Plenum Press, New York). Luther, P.K., Lawrence, M.C. and Crowther, R.A. (1988). A method for monitoring the collapse of plastic sections as a function of electron dose. Ultramicroscopy 24, 7–18. Majorovits, E. and Schroeder, R.R. (2002). Improved information recovery in phase contrast EM for non-two-fold symmetric Boersch phase plate geometry. Microsc. Microanal. 8(Suppl. 2), 540 CD. Malis, T., Cheng, S.C. and Egerton, R. (1988). EELS log-ratio technique for specimen-thickness measurement in the TEM. J. Electron Microsc. Tech. 8, 193–200. Marko, M. (2004). Techniques for electron tomography in biological and material science. Microsc. Microanal. 10(Suppl. 2), 154–155. Marsh, B.J., Mastronarde, D.N., Buttle, K.F., Howell K.E. and McIntosh, J.R. (2001). Organellar relationships in the Golgi region of the pancreatic beta cell line, HIT-T15, visualized by high resolution electron tomography. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 98(5), 2399–2406. Martone, M.E., Deerinck, T.J., Young, S.J. and Ellisman, M.H. (1999). Three dimensional protein localization using high voltage electron microscopy. Acta Histochem. Cytochem. 32(1), 35–43. Martone, M.E., Deerinck, T.J., Yamada, N., Bushong, E. and Ellisman, M.H. (2000). Correlated 3D light and electron microscopy: Use of high voltage microscopy tomography for imaging large biological structures. J. Histotechnol. 23, 261–270. Mastronarde, D.N. (1997). Dual-axis tomography: An approach with alignment methods that preserve resolution. J. Struct. Biol. 120(3), 343–352. Mcewen, B.F., Downing, K.H. and Glaeser, R.M. (1995). The relevance of dose-fractionation in tomography of radiation-sensitive specimens. Ultramicroscopy 60(3), 357–373. Medalia, O., Weber, I., Frangakis, A.S., Gerisch, G. and Baumeister, W. (2002). Macromolecular architecture in eukaryotic cells visualized by cryoelectron tomography. Science 298, 1209–1213. Michel, M., Hillmann, T. and Mueller, M. (1991). Cryosectioning of plant material frozen at high pressure. J. Microsc. 193, 3–18. Mochel, M.E. and Mochel, J.M. (1986). A CCD imaging and analysis system for the VG HB5 STEM. In Proceedings of the 51st Annual Meeting of the Microscopy Society of America, San Francisco Press, 262–263. Mooney, P.E. (2004). Private communications. Mooney, P.E. and Krivanek, O.L. (1994). Image-coupling methods in CCD cameras for electron microscopy. In Proceeding of the 52nd Annual Meeting of the Microscopy Society of America, San Francisco Press, 406–407.
599
600
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister Moore, H. (1987). Theory and practice of high-pressure freezing. In Cryotechniques in Biological Electron Microscopy (R.A. Steinbrecht, and K. Zierold, Eds.), 175–191 (Springer, Berlin). Moore, H. and Riehle, U. (1968). Snap freezing under high pressure: A new fixation technique for freeze-etching. In Electron Microscopy 1968 (D.S. Bocciarelli, Ed.), Vol. 2. Proceedings of the 4th European Regional Conference on Electron Microscopy Rome, 33–34. Mueller-Reichert, T., Hohenberg, H., O’Toole, E.T. and Mcdonald, K. (2003). Cryoimmobilization and three-dimensional visualization of C-elegans ultrastructure. J. Microsc. 212(1), 71–80. Murk, J.L., Humbel, M., Ziese, U., Griffith, J.M., Posthuma, G., Slot, J.W., Koster, A.J., Verkleij, A.J., Geuze, H.J. and Kleijmeer, M.J. (2003). Endosomal compartmentalization in three dimensions: implications for membrane fusion. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 100(23), 13332–13337. Nicastro, D., Frangakis, A.S., Typke, D. and Baumeister, W. (2000). Cryo-electron tomography of Neurospora mitochondria. J. Struct. Biol. 129, 48–56. Nicastro, D., McIntosh, J.R. and Baumeister, W. (2005). 3D structure of eukaryotic flagella in a quiescent state revealed by cryo-electron tomography. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 102, 15889–15894. Nickell, S., Hegerl, R., Baumeister, W. and Rachel, R. (2003). Pyrodictium cannulae enter the periplasmatic space but do not enter the cytoplasm, as revealed by cryo-electron tomography. J. Struct. Biol. 141, 34–42. Nickell, S., Hegerl, R., Sillje, H. and Baumeister, W. (2007). Dual-axis cryoelectron tomography. J. Struct. Biol., submitted. Nitsch, M., Walz, J., Typke, D., Klumpp, M., Essen, L.O. and Baumeister, W. (1998). Group II chaperonin in an open conformation examined by electron tomography. Nature Struct. Biol. 5(10), 855–857. Olins, A.L., Olins, D.E., Levy, H.A., Margle, S.M., Tinnel, E.P. and Dufree, R.C. (1989). Tomographic reconstruction from energy-filtered images of thick biological sections. J. Microsc. 154, 257–265. *Ortiz, J., Förster, F., Kürner, J., Linaroudis, A.A. and Baumeister, W. (2006). Mapping 70S ribosomes in intact cells by cryoelectron tomography and pattern recognition. Journal of Structural Biology 156, 334–341. O’Toole, E.T., Winey, M. and McIntosh, J.R. (1999). High-voltage electron tomography of spindle pole bodies and early mitotic spindles in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Mol. Biol. Cell 10(6), 2017–2031. Penczek, P., Marko, M., Buttle, K. and Frank, J. (1995). Double-tilt electron tomography. Ultramicroscopy 60(3), 393–410. Perutz, M.F., Rossmann, M.G., Cullis, A.F., Muirhead, H. and North, A.C.T. (1960). Structure of haemoglobin: A three-dimensional Fourier synthesis at 5.5 resolution, obtained by x-ray analysis. Nature 185, 416–422. Plano GmbH, Wetzlar, Germany (www.plano-em.de). Plitzko, J.M., Frangakis, A.S., Nickell, S., Förster, F., Gross, A. and Baumeister, W. (2002). In vivo veritas: Electron cryotomography of cells. Trends Biotech. 20(Suppl. 8), S40–S44. Plitzko, J.M., G. Schweikert, G., Pfeifer, G., Nickell, S., Luecken, U. and Baumeister, W. (2004). The benefit of liquid Helium cooling for cryo-electron tomography: a quantitative comparative study. Proc. of the 13th European Microscopy Congress, Antwerp, Belgium Vol 2, IM07.04 CD. Plitzko, J.M., Freitag, B., Hegerl, R. and Luecken, U. (2005). Aberration free microscopy for life science applications. Proceedings of the 63rd Annual Meeting of the Microscopy Society of America. Micrsoc. Microanal. 11(Suppl. 2), 2140–2141. Porter, K.R. and Blum, J. (1953). A study in microtomy in electron microscopy. Anat. Rec. 117, 685–710. Probst, W., Benner, G., Bihr., J. and Weimer, E. (1993). An omega energy filtering TEM—principles and applications. Adv. Mater. 5, 297–300.
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET) Quantifoil Micro Tools GmbH, Jena, Germany (www.quantifoil.com). Radermacher, M. (1992). Weighted backprojection methods. In Electron Tomography: Three-Dimensional Imaging with the Transmission Electron Microscope (J. Frank, Ed.), 91–115 (Plenum Press, New York). Radermacher, M. and Hoppe, W. (1980). Properties of 3-D reconstruction from projections by conical tilting compared to single-axis tilting. 7th European Congress on Electron Microscopy, Den Haag, 132–133. Radon, J. (1917). Über die Bestimmung von Funktionen durch ihre Integralwerte längs gewisser Mannigfaltigkeiten. Math. Phys. Klasse 69, 262–277. Rath, B.K., Marko, M., Radermacher, M. and Frank, J. (1997). Low-dose automated electron tomography: A recent implementation. J. Struct. Biol. 120, 210–218. Rath, B.K., Hegerl, R., Leith, A., Shaikh, T.R., Wagenknecht, T. and Frank, J. (2003). Fast 3D motif search of EM density maps using a locally normalized cross-correlation function. J. Struct. Biol. 144(1–2), 95–103. Reimer, L. (1993). Transmission Electron Microscopy (Volume 36 of Springer series in Optical Sciences), 3rd Ed. (Springer, Berlin). Reimer, L. (1995). Energy-Filtering Transmission Electron Microscopy (Volume 71 of Springer series in Optical Sciences) (Springer, Berlin). Rockel, B., Peters, J., Kuhlmorgen, B., Glaeser, R.M. and Baumeister, W. (2002). A giant protease with a twist: The TPP II complex from Drosophila melanogaster studied by electron microscopy. EMBO J. 22, 5979–5984. Rockel, B., Peters, J., Müller, S.A., Gönül, S., Ringler, P., Hegerl, R., Glaeser, R.M. and Baumeister, W. (2005). Molecular architecture and assembly of Drosophila tripeptidyl peptidase II. PNAS 102(29), 10135–10140. Rose, H. and Plies, E. (1974). Entwurf eines fehlerarmen magnetischen EnergieAnalysators. Optik 40, 336–341. Roseman, A.M. (2000). Docking structures of domains into maps from cryoelectron microscopy using local correlation. Acta Crystallogr. Sect. D—Biol. Crystallogr. 56(10), 1332–1340. Roseman, A.M. (2003). Particle finding in electron micrographs using a fast local correlation algorithm. Ultramicroscopy 94(3–4), 225–236. Ruijter, W.J. (1995). Imaging properties and applications of slow-scan charge coupled device cameras suitable for electron microscopy. Micron 26(3), 247–275. Ruska, E. (1987). The development of the electronmicroscope and electron microscopy. Nobel lecture 1986. Rev. Modern Phys. 59(3), 627–638. Sali, A., Glaeser, R., Earnest, T. and Baumeister, W. (2003). From words to literature in structural proteomics. Nature 422, 216–225. Sandin, S., Ofverstedt, G., Wikstrom, A.C., Wrange, O. and Skoglund, U. (2004). Structure and flexibility of individual immunoglobulin g molecules in solution. Structure (Camb.), 12(3), 409–415. Sartori, N., Richter, K. and Dubochet, J. (1993). Vitrification depth can be increased more than 10-fold by high-pressure freezing. J. Microsc. 172, 55–61. Saxberg, B.E.H. and Saxton, W.O. (1981). Quantum noise in 2D projections and 3D reconstructions. Ultramicroscopy 6(1), 85–89. Saxton, W.O., Baumeister, W. and Hahn, M. (1984). Three-dimensional reconstruction of imperfect two-dimensional crystals. Ultramicroscopy 13(1–2), 57–70. Scheffel et al. (2005). Advance online publication, Nature doi:10.1038/ nature04382 and Scheffel, A., Gruska, M., Faivre, D., Linaroudis, A., Plitzko, J.M. and Schüler, D. (2006) An acidic protein aligns magnetosomes along a filamentous structure in magnetotactic bacteria. Nature 440(7080), 110–114.
601
602
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister Scherzer, O. (1970). Die Strahlenschädigung der Objekte als Grenze für die hochauflösende Elektronenmikroskopie (Radiation damage of objects as limiting factor of high-resolution electron microscopy). Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 74, 1154–1167. Schiske, P. (1968). Zur Frage der Bildrekonstruktion durch Fokusserien. Electron Microscopy 1968 (D.S. Bocciarelli, Ed.), Proceedings of the 4th European Regional Conference on Electron Microscopy, Rome, 145–146. Schiske, P. (1973). Image Pocessing and Computer Aided Design in Electron Optics (Academic Press, New York). Schoenmakers, R., Perquin, R., Fliervoet, T., Voorhout, W. and Schirmacher, H. (2005). New software for high-resolution, high-throughput electron tomography. Microsc. Anal. 96, 13–14. Schroeder, R.R., Manstein, D.J., Jahn, W., Holden, H., Rayment, I., Holmes, K.C. and Spudich, J.A. (1993). Three-dimensional atomic model of F-actin decorated with Dictyostelium myosin S1. Nature 364, 171–174. Schweikert, G., Pfeifer, G., Nickell, S., Luecken, U., Baumeister, W. and Plitzko, J.M. (2007). Helium vs. Nitrogen cooling of biological samples: A quantitative comparative study. J. Struct. Biol., submitted. Sitte, H. (1996). Advanced instrumentation and methodology related to cryoultramicrotomy: A review. Scanning Microsc. (Suppl. 10), 387–466. Smith, P.R., Peters, T.M. and Bates, R.H.T. (1973). Image reconstruction from finite numbers of projections. J. Phys. A: Math. Nucl. Gen. 6, 361–382. Soto, G.E., Young, S.J., Martone, M.E., Deerinck, T.J., Lamont, S., Carragher, B.O., Hama, K. and Ellisman, M.H. (1994). Serial section electron tomography, a method for three-dimensional reconstruction of large structures. Neuroimage 1, 230–243. Spahn, C.M.T., Beckmann, R., Eswar, N., Penczek, P.A., Sali, A., Blobel, G. and Frank, J. (2001). Structure of the 80S ribosome from Saccharomyces cerevisiae—tRNA-ribosome and subunit-subunit interactions. Cell 107(3), 373–386. Spence, J.C.H., Weierstall, U., Fricke, T.T., Glaeser, R.M. and Downing, K.H. (2003). Three-dimensional diffractive imaging for crystalline monolayers with one-dimensional compact support. J. Struct. Biol. 144(1–2), 209–218. Steven, A.C. and Aebi, U. (2003). The next ice age: Cryo-electron tomography of intact cells. Trends Cell Biol. 13(3), 107–110. Stoschek, A. and Hegerl, R. (1997). Denoising of electron tomographic reconstructions using multiscale transformations. J. Struct. Biol. 120(3), 257–265. Studer, D. and Gnägi, H. (2000). Minimal compression of ultrathin sections with use of an oscillating diamond. J. Microsc. 197, 94–100. Taylor, K.A. and Glaeser, R.M. (1974). Electron diffraction of frozen, hydrated protein crystals. Science 186(4168), 1036–1037. Taylor, K.A. and Glaeser, R.M. (1973). Hydrophilic support films of controlled thickness and composition. Rev. Scient. Instrum. 44(10), 1546–1547. Taylor, K.A., Tang, J., Cheng, Y. and Winkler, H. (1997). The use of electron tomography for structural analysis of disordered protein arrays. J. Struct. Biol. 120(3), 372–386. Ted Pella, Inc., Redding, CA (www.tedpella.com). Thust, A., Lentzen, M. and Urban, K. (1994). Non-linear reconstruction of the exit plane wave function from periodic high-resolution electron microscopy images. Ultramicroscopy 53(2), 101–120. Thust, A., Coene, W.M.J., Op de Beeck, M. and Van Dyck, D. (1996). Focalseries reconstruction in HRTEM: Simulation studies on non-periodic objects. Ultramicroscopy 64, 211–230. Turchetta, R., Bertst, J.D., Casadei, B., Claus, G., Colledani, C., Dulinski, W., Hu, Y., Husson, D., Le Normand, J.P., Riester, J.L., Deptuch, G., Goerlach,
Chapter 7 Cryoelectron Tomography (CET) U., Higueret, S. and Winter, M. (2001). A monolithic active pixel sensor for charged particle tracking and imaging using standard VLSI CMOS technology. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. Sect. A—Accel. Spectrom. Detect. Associ. Equip. 458(3), 677–689. Typke, D., Dierksen, K. and Baumeister, W. (1991). Automatic electron tomography. Proceedings of the 49th Annual Meeting of the Microscopy Society of America, San Francisco Press, 544–545. Typke, D., Hegerl, R. and Kleinz, J. (1992). Image restoration for biological objects using external TEM control and electronic image recording. Ultramicroscopy 46, 157–173. Uhlemann, S. and Rose, H. (1996). Acceptance of imaging energy filters. Ultramicroscopy 63(3–4), 161–167. Unwin, P.N.T. (1972). Electron microscopy of biological specimens by means of an electrostatic phase plate. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A. 329, 327–359. VanderLugt, A. (1964). Signal detection by complex spatial filtering. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, IT 10, 139–145. Van Heel, M. and Frank, J. (1981). Use of multivariate statistics in analyzing the images of biological macromolecules. Ultramicroscopy 6, 187–194. Van Heel, M., Schatz, M. and Orlova, E.V. (1992). Correlation function revisited. Ultramicroscopy 46, 307–316. Van Heel, M., Gowen, B., Matadeen, R., Orlova, E.V., Finn, R., Pape, T., Cohen, D., Stark, H., Schmidt, R., Schatz, M. and Patwardhan, A. (2000). Singleparticle electron cryo-microscopy: Towards atomic resolution. Q. Rev. Biophys. 33, 307–369. Volkmann, N. (2002). A novel three-dimensional variant of the watershed transform for segmentation of electron density maps. J. Struct. Biol. 138(1–2), 123–129. Volkmann, N. and Hanein, D. (1999). Quantitative fitting of atomic models into observed densities derived by electron microscopy. J. Struct. Biol. 125(2–3), 176–184. Walz, J., Tamura, T., Tamura, N., Grimm, R., Baumeister, W. and Koster, A.J. (1997a). Tricorn protease exists as an icosahedral supermolecule in vivo. Mol. Cell 1(1), 59–65. Walz, J., Typke, D., Nitsch, M., Koster, A.J., Hegerl, R. and Baumeister, W. (1997b). Electron tomography of single ice-embedded macromolecules: Three-dimensional alignment and classification. J. Struct. Biol. 120, 387– 395. Weickenmeier, A.L., Nuechter, W. and Mayer, J. (1995). Quantitative characterization of point spread function and detection quantum efficiency for a YAG scintillator slow scan CCD camera. Optik 99(4), 147–154. Wilson, C.J., Mastronarde, D.N., McEwen, B. and Frank, J. (1992). Measurement of neuronal surface area using high-voltage electron microscope tomography. Neuroimage 1, 11–22. Winkler, H. and Taylor, K.A. (2003). Focus gradient correction applied to tilt series image data used in electron tomography. J. Struct. Biol. 143(1), 24–32. Wright, E.R., Iancu, C.V., Tivol, W.F. and Jensen, G.J. (2006). Observation on the behaviour of vitreous ice at ~82 and ~12 K. J. Struct. Biol. 153, 241–252. Yonekura, K., Yonekura, S.M. and Namba, K. (2002). Quantitative comparison between zero-loss and conventional electron diffraction from 2 dimensional and thin three dimensional protein crystals. Biophys. J. 82, 2784–2797. Zheng, Q.S., Braunfeld, M.B., Sedat, J. and Agard, D.A. (2004). An improved strategy for automated electron microscopic tomography. J. Struct. Biol. 147(2), 91–101.
603
604
J.M. Plitzko and W. Baumeister Zhu, P., Penczeck, P., Schroeder, R.R. and Frank, J. (1997). 3-dimensional reconstruction with contrast transfer-function correction from energy filtered cryoelectron micrographs—Procedure and application to the 7os E. Coli ribosome. J. Struct. Biol. 118, 197–219. Zhu, P., Chertova, E., Bess, J., Lifson, J.D., Arthur, L.O., Liu, J., Taylor, K.A. and Roux, K.H. (2003). Electron tomography analysis of envelope glycoprotein trimers on HIV and simian immunodeficiency virus virions. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 100(26), 15812–15817. Ziese, U., Janssen, A.H., Murk, J.-L., Geerts, W.J.C., van der Krift, T., Verkleij, A.J. and Koster, A.J. (2002). Automated high-throughput electron tomography by pre-calibration of image shifts. J. Microsc. 205(2), 187–200. Ziese, U., Geerts, W.J.C., Van Der Krift, T.P., Verkleij, A.J. and Koster A.J. (2003). Correction of autofocusing errors due to specimen tilt for automated electron tomography. J. Microsc. 211(2), 179–185. Zwickl, P., Goldberg, A.L. and Baumeister, W. (2000). Proteasomes in prokaryotes. In Proteasomes: The World of Regulatory Proteolysis, 8–20 (Landes Bioscience, Georgetown, TX).
*References added since the first printing.
8 LEEM and SPLEEM Ernst Bauer
1 Introduction Low-energy electron microscopy (LEEM: http://www.leem-user.com) is an imaging method that makes use of elastically backscattered electrons with energies below about 100 eV, frequently with less than 10 eV. In contrast to transmission electron microscopy (TEM), which generally works with electrons in the 100 keV range where backscattering is negligible, the backscattering cross sections for low-energy electrons are large enough to make them useful for surface imaging. This was already evident in the classical diffraction experiments of Davission and Germer,1 but it took 35 years before the use of slow diffracted electrons for surface imaging was suggested2 and another 23 years before convincing images could be published.3 Thus, although diffraction of slow electrons and imaging with slow emitted electrons with resolution in the micrometer range were demonstrated4 before TEM reached submicron resolution,5 LEEM became a viable imaging method only much later. The reasons for this late appearance of LEEM in electron microscopy are 2-fold: (1) for LEEM well-defined surfaces are necessary, which in general requires ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) and efficient surface cleaning procedures. Although these have been available for some time in glass systems such as in Farnsworth’s low-energy electron diffraction (LEED) systems,6–8 glass systems are not very user friendly and metal UHV technology did not come into widespread use until the beginning of the 1960s. In fact, the first display type LEED system that started the revival of LEED was a glass system9,10 as was the first unsuccessful model of an LEEM system.2 (2) There was the widespread belief in the electron microscope community based on the fundamental theoretical work of Recknagel on emission electron microscopy11 that the chromatic aberration of the objective lens would limit the resolution to such an extent that LEEM would be unattractive. This of course was a misunderstanding as already pointed out in the early phase of the development of LEEM.12,13 In the decades since then LEEM has developed slowly into a powerful surface imaging technique as recounted elsewhere.14
605
606
E. Bauer
In the past 10 years developments concentrated on the combination of LEEM with X-ray induced photoemission electron microscopy (XPEEM), which resulted in the spectroscopic photoemission and low-energy electron microscope (SPELEEM),15,16 and on the correction of the aberrations of the objective lens.17 Despite these efforts LEEM is still far behind the technological state that TEM has now reached. This chapter reviews the basics of LEEM, its present state of art, and its applications. An associated imaging method, spin-polarized LEEM (SPLEEM), which gives magnetic information, will also be discussed. Other methods, such as mirror electron microscopy (MEM), which gives information mainly on the local surface potential, Auger electron emission microscopy (AEEM), which gives chemical information, electron energy loss microscopy (EELM), which gives some electronic information, and secondary electron emission microscopy (SEEM), will be mentioned only briefly because they have been used much less frequently, although they are also useful. Photoelectron emission microscopy (PEEM), in particular XPEEM, is included only in connection with the discussion of SPELEEM because it is the subject of another chapter.
2 Electron Beam–Specimen Interactions To understand the possibilities and limitations of LEEM and of the associated techniques, a fundamental understanding of the interactions of slow electrons with condensed matter is necessary. The following interactions have to be taken into account: elastic scattering, inelastic scattering, and quasielastic scattering (phonon and in magnetic materials magnon scattering). The interactions of slow electrons with matter are vastly different from those of fast electrons. In ferromagnetic materials they depend in addition upon the relative orientation of the spin of the incident electrons and the electrons in the matter. Consider first elastic scattering. Because of its low velocity v = 2E / m the interaction time of a slow electron is much longer than of the fast electrons used in TEM and an n-electron atom may no longer be considered as undisturbed but becomes an n + 1 electron system during the interaction. Therefore the incident electron experiences the temporary excitations of the n-electron atom. This can be taken into account by adding a correlation potential to the potential of the ground state nelectron atom. Similarly the repulsive interactions between electrons with the same spin due to the Pauli principle cause a spin-dependent potential that also has be added. As a consequence, the scattering of slow electrons by the atoms that constitute the condensed matter can no longer be described by the first Born approximation, which assumes a static atom in the ground state and which is a good approximation at high energies. Instead, a partial wave analysis is necessary, taking into account the exchange and correlation potentials.18,19 No calculations of this type for condensed atoms, whose potentials are truncated by overlap with the neighbor atoms, are available. Fortunately the magnitudes of the correlation and exchange potential decrease rapidly with energy so
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
that they may be neglected in the energy range of conventional LEED studies (usually above 30 eV). In LEEM, however, they should be taken into account. This is a formidable task that has not been mastered up to now. Therefore, only some results of partial wave analysis calculations for truncated ground state potentials will be given here. In the partial wave analysis20 the incident plane wave and the outgoing scattered wave are expanded into spherical harmonics centered at the atom, and the phase differences ηl between the incident and outgoing partial waves are calculated. In the nonrelativistic case the scattering amplitude is given by f(θ, k) = (1/2ik)Σ(2l + 1)[exp(2iηl − 1)]Pl (cos θ)
(1)
with the sum over l extending from zero to infinity. k is the wave number and the Pl ’s are Legendre polynomials. The intensity distribution of the scattered electrons as a function of scattering angle θ and energy E ∼ k is then simply ∼|f(θ, k)|2. Figure 8–1 shows the angular distribution of the scattered intensity of 50 eV electrons, calculated in this manner for realistic solid state Ag, Al, and Cu atomic potentials.18 It shows that not only is the total scattering cross section of Cu (Z = 29) smaller than that of Al (Z = 13), but also its back-scattering cross section, and that Al scatters nearly as much as the much heavier Ag atom (Z = 47). The scattering is, however, strongly energy dependent. This is illustrated for the scattering into a 30° cone around the backward direction in Figure 8–2,19 which shows that at very low energies Cu scatters nearly as strongly as W (Z = 74) while Al and Ag scatter much more weakly in the backward direction. It should be noted that the zero of the energy is the inner potential resulting from the overlap of the free atom potentials so that the maxima of the W and Cu backscattering cross sections are just around the vacuum level.
15 Ag Al Cu
I (u) (a02)
10
5
0°
50°
υ 100°
150°
Figure 8–1. Angular distribution of 50 eV electrons elastically scattered from Ag, Al, and Cu atoms in the solid state.18
607
E. Bauer
W
2
Figure 8–2. Energy dependence of the backscattering into a 30° cone around the backward direction for Ag, Al, Cu, and W atoms in the solid state.19
Backscattering into angular region from 150° to 180°
Cu QR (Å2)
608
Ag
1
Al
0
0
50
100 E (eV)
150
200
In condensed matter the electrons are, of course, not only scattered within one atom but also by the atoms surrounding it, causing strong multiple scattering. This is taken into account in LEED in the dynamic theory of electron diffraction.21,22 Another way to look at the problem of scattering in a periodic system is in terms of the band structure theory if we assume that the n + 1-electrons system (n crystal electrons + incident electron) does not differ significantly from the n-electron system (Koopman’ theorem23). Then the 180° backscattering from a single crystal surface is determined by the band structure E(k) perpendicular to the surface. This is illustrated in Figure 8–3 for the W(110) surface.24 The band structure in the [110] (ΓN) direction has a wide
Figure 8–3. Normal incidence specular reflectivity of a W(110) surface (top) and band structure along the surface normal (bottom).24
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
band gap between about 1 and 6 eV above the vacuum level. An electron incident in this direction, therefore, does not find allowed states in the crystal and forms an evanescent wave. The extinction length of this electron wave in the crystal is quite short in the center of the gap, only about two monolayers,25 so that the electron is reflected before it is attenuated significantly by inelastic scattering. This, together with the strong backscattering cross section, causes the high reflectivity at about 2–3 eV. The second reflectivity peak is due to the low density of states in the crystal as indicated by the steep bands. The band structure influence is strongly orientation dependent. For example, on the W(100) surface the band gap is located between 3 and 5 eV above the vacuum level,24,26 which causes a pronounced reflectivity peak at about 4 eV. This is preceded by a deep reflectivity minimum, which is caused by the strong inelastic scattering of the electron that could otherwise penetrate deeply into the crystal. A second reflectivity peak occurs around 8 eV where the density of state in the crystal is small. This simple picture neglects the influence of surface effects. For quantitative agreement between experiment and theory the surface barrier,27 surface resonances,24 and reconstruction have to be taken into account. For LEEM these details are not important, at least at the present state of art, because they determine mainly the reflected intensity and have little influence on the contrast. The main factor that determines the high surface sensitivity of LEEM is in general not the influence of the band structure and of elastic scattering but the strong attenuation of slow electrons by inelastic scattering. Inelastic scattering is due to single electron excitations (electron hole pair creation) and collective electron excitations (plasmon creation). In the energy range of LEEM single electron excitations mainly involve valence band and weakly bound outer shell core electrons. The universal inelastic mean free path (IMFP) curves usually found in the literature are of rather limited value at the low energies used because they do not take into account the differences in the electronic structure of the various materials. Therefore, only some general features will be discussed and some specific examples will be given. In materials that may be described approximately by a free electron gas imbedded in a homogeneous background of equal charge (“jellium model”) the IMFP is a function of k/kF (kF Fermi wave number) with the electron density as parameter.18,19,28 As an example, the attenuation length µ = (IMFP)−1 of Al, for which the free electron approximation is good, is shown in Figure 8–4 together with the attenuation coefficient ν due to elastic backscattering, assuming a random distribution of Al atoms with bulk density (“randium model”).29,30 The initial rise of µ until the volume plasmon creation threshold at ET = 17.5 eV (above vacuum level) is due to single electron excitations. The maximum of µ and the corresponding minimum of about 0.3 nm of the IMPF at about 37 eV is mainly due to plasmon losses. Figure 8–4 also shows that attenuation by elastic backscattering is much weaker above ET than that by inelastic scattering. For most metals the jellium approximation is not useful, in particular for transition and noble metals. For example, in contrast to jellium, transition metals have a high density of unoccupied states just above
609
E. Bauer
µ,ν (Å–1)
0.3
µ
0.2
0.1 ν
50
100 EVac (eV)
150
200
Figure 8–4. Energy dependence of the attenuation coefficients µ,ν of slow electrons in Al by inelastic scattering and elastic backscattering, respectively.29
the Fermi level into which excitations can occur. The deviation from jellium can be partially taken into account by replacing the ω dependence in the Lindhard dielectric function εL(ω, q), which is used in the jellium calculations, by that obtained in the experiment for zero momentum q transfer, that is by optical data for which q = 0. Results of such calculations31 give typically minimum IMFPs in metals of 0.3–0.5 nm at energies between 30 and 120 eV for Mg and Au, respectively, with a rapid increase at low energies to values as high as 2.4 nm in Si and 3.5 nm in W at 10 eV, for example. Figure 8–5 illustrates the agreement between theory and experiment that can be obtained in this approximation.32 The deviations below E − EF = 5 eV are irrelevant for LEEM because the work function of Au is about 5 eV; those above 50 eV are probably due to inaccurate 5p and 4f ionization cross
102
Au 101 λin (nm)
610
100
10–1 100
101
102 E–EF (eV)
103
104
Figure 8–5. Energy dependence of the inelastic mean free path of electrons in Au. The points and dots are experimental data and the dashed and solid lines are theoretical data using different approximations.32
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
sections. The agreement is surprisingly good considering that the q dependence of ε has been approximated by simple expressions and that correlation and exchange have not been taken into account. At energies below several 10 eV these are of comparable importance for inelastic scattering as for elastic scattering, in particular the influence of the detailed band structure and of nondirect (q # 0) transitions.33 For example, inclusion of exchange in the dielectric model of the IMFP gives IMFP values that are by a factor of 1.3 and more larger than without exchange.34 The IMFPs calculated in this approximation for insulators are even larger, such as 6 nm at 10 eV for KCl.31 For several groups of insulators with large band gaps (condensed noble gases, N2, and organic dielectrics such as benzene or methane) no electronic excitations are possible at low energies. Here the (quasi)elastic mean free path (EMFP) determines the sampling depth. EMFP measurements in the energy range from 2 to 15 eV give EMFPs up to 10 nm.35 An example is shown for solid Xe in Figure 8–6.36 Thus the MFP may be very long at low energies (≤10 eV) while at energies between about 30 eV and 100 eV, depending upon the material, it may be only a few tenths of a nm. The large mean free paths (MFPs) at very low energies are, however, not general. They depend strongly on the density of unoccupied states into which bound electrons can be excited as clearly evident in an insulator with wide band gaps.35 These are extreme cases inasmuch as their band gaps are so large that the density of unoccupied states becomes significant only at several electronvolts above the vacuum level. At the other extreme are transition metals with their unfilled d bands with high density of states just above the Fermi level. Here the IMFPs are very short as seen in Figure 8–737 in which the reciprocal values of the IMFPs are plotted as a function of the number of d holes. The values shown are for electrons with energies between 5 and 10 eV above the Fermi energy. For Fe the IMFP is only about 0.5 nm and for Gd only
Mean Free Path (nm)
10
Solid Xe T = 45 K
6
2
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Electron Energy (eV)
Figure 8–6. Energy dependence of the elastic mean free path of slow electrons in solid Xe.36
611
E. Bauer
Figure 8–7. Reciprocal inelastic mean free path in nm−1 of electrons with energies between 5 and 10 eV above the Fermi level as function of the number of holes in the 3d and 4d shell.37
0.25 nm. In ferromagnetic materials the density of unoccupied states differs between majority and minority spin states, which causes corresponding differences in the excitation probabilities. Calculations that take this into account show a significant difference between the IMFPs of incident electrons with majority and minority spin as seen in Figure 8–8.38 The zero of the energy is the Fermi energy; the work
20
spin down spin up 15
IMFP(Å)
612
10
5
0 0.0
5.0
10.0 15.0 20.0 Electron Energy (eV)
25.0
Figure 8–8. Energy dependence of the inelastic mean free path of majority and minority spin electrons in Fe.38
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
function of Fe is 4.5 eV so that 1 eV above the vacuum level the IMFPs are only 0.6 and 0.2 nm for majority and minority spin electrons, respectively. At 10 eV above the vacuum level the corresponding values are 0.45 and 0.3 nm, which are much lower than the 1.6 nm obtained from the dielectric theory discussed above. For more information see Bauer.39 While the knowledge of reliable absolute numbers for elastic and inelastic mean free paths at low energy is still limited, the influence of phonon and magnon excitation on the effective sampling depth is much less understood. Both processes involve only small energy losses up to several 100 meV but can occur with large momentum transfer. In LEEM only the electrons in a diffraction spot and its immediate environment contribute to the image formation. Therefore energy losses with momentum transfer larger than that determined by the radius of the contrast aperture cause an attenuation of the intensity contributing to the image formation. At not too high temperatures this can be taken into account by the Debye–Waller factor. At higher temperatures multiphonon and -magnon excitations occur that cause an increased attenuation, which may be described by an anharmonic Debye–Waller factor.40 In this conventional description of the influence of phonons on the scattering from surfaces there is no thickness dependence. However, in thin films the number of electrons scattered outside the contrast aperture increases with increasing thickness so that an effective attenuation coefficient could be defined. This has not been done to date for several reasons: (1) there are no numbers for the cross sections for phonon and magnon scattering that could be compared with those for inelastic scattering, (2) with increasing temperature there is frequently atomic disordering that causes diffuse scattering, and (3) at high temperatures thin films usually break up into three-dimensional crystals before attenuation by these processes becomes significant. A rough idea of the influence of thermal vibrations on the attenuation length may be obtained from the analysis of LEED patterns from Cu single crystal surfaces. At 50 eV the total attenuation length, which includes elastic backscattering, inelastic scattering, and phonon scattering, from the (111) surface is 0.33 nm at 300 K versus 0.34 nm at 0 K.41 The difference is well within the limits of error of the values so that at least at this energy phonon scattering does not limit the sampling depth. According to the present state of understanding the sampling depth of LEEM and SPLEEM is primarily determined by inelastic and elastic backscattering. Depending upon the energy and electronic structure of the material, the sampling depth may be as small as a few tenths of a nanometer, for example, around the plasmon excitation maximum, in transition metals with a high density of unoccupied states above the Fermi level, or in band gaps along the k direction normal to the surface. On the other hand, sampling depths as large as several nanometers can occur at very low energies, for example, in insulators and free electron like metals. In many cases this allows tuning of the sampling depth by proper choice of the energy, which makes LEEM and SPLEEM ideal for imaging of surfaces and thin films.
613
614
E. Bauer
3 Instrumentation The electron optics of an LEEM/SPLEEM instrument in the imaging section is essentially the same as in emission electron microscopes, which date back to the 1930s. In these microscopes the specimen is the cathode of a so-called cathode lens in which the slow emitted electrons are accelerated in a high field to the first of several image-forming electrodes of an electrostatic lens or to the entrance of a magnetic lens. This lens is the objective lens of the microscope, which produces a primary image with fast electrons. The subsequent electron optics is basically the same as in TEM. In fact, the first objective lens used in LEEM was a modified version of an electrostatic triode lens developed for PEEM.42 To do LEEM with such a system fast electrons have to be injected from the high-energy side of the objective lens along its optical axis. In the cathode lens they are decelerated to the desired low energy at the specimen. To be able to produce an image, this incident beam has to be separated from the reflected beam by a beam divider. As a consequence an LEEM or SPLEEM system has a bent optical axis. A schematic of the first instrument is shown in Figure 8–9.3 The beam separator (1) deflects the incident beam from a field emission gun (2) that is focused by two quadrupoles (3), the deflection field (1), and optionally by a collimator lens (4) into the back focal plane of the objective lens (5). They reach the specimen (7) on parallel trajectories with an energy that is determined by the adjustable potential difference between field emitter and specimen. The specimen is imaged by the elastically reflected electrons into the center of the beam separator, its diffraction pattern into the back focal plane of the objective lens where the angle-limiting contrast aperture is located. The astigmatism of the objective lens is corrected with
Figure 8–9. Schematic of the first LEEM instrument. For explanation see text.3
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
a magnetic stigmator (6). The primary image in the center of the beam separator is imaged with a magnetic intermediate lens (9) and a projective lens (10) onto the final screen, and the diffraction pattern by adjusting the focal length of the intermediate lens. The purpose of the electrostatic filter lens (11) was to filter out secondary and inelastically scattered electrons but was later removed because it was found that the dispersive properties of the magnetic beam separator (1) were sufficient to eliminate them from the image. A pair of multichannel plates (12) enhances the image intensity on the fluorescent screen (8), allowing observation and image recording with a video camera (13) at very low beam currents. Both illumination and imaging columns are equipped with deflectors and stigmators, some of which are indicated (16). Emission microscopy is possible with thermionic emission by heating the specimen, with photoelectrons generated by a 100-W high-pressure Hg arc lamp (14) and with secondary electrons using an auxiliary electron gun (15). While Figure 8–9 shows the principle of the LEEM system, more recent instruments differ considerably in detail. For example, a transfer lens, which transfers the diffraction pattern from the back focal plane of the objective lens toward the front of the intermediate lens, is now inserted just behind the beam separator, so that the illuminating beam does not have to pass through the contrast aperture as in the original design. The electrostatic triode lens is now replaced by lenses with better resolution such as the electrostatic tetrode lens, the magnetic diode lens, or the magnetic triode lens, which will be briefly discussed below. The beam separator has been improved in a variety of ways, such as by close-packed or separated multiple magnetic prisms, concentric square or round pole pieces, or a Wien filter, resulting in deflection angles ranging from 16° to 90° compared to the original 60°. In addition, energy filters have been added to instruments so that they can also be used for AEEM, low electron energy loss microscopy (LEELM), energy-filtered SEEM, and spectroscopic PEEM. Before discussing these components of an LEEM instrument, a short account of the various designs is appropriate. The first major development after the original instrument and a similar one43 also used a beam separator with 60° deflection but with close-packed multiple magnetic prisms and only magnetic lenses, including the objective lens, a LaB6 cathode, and a transfer lens so that the contrast aperture could be placed behind the beam separator.44 The magnetic prism on the illumination side of the instrument can be excited differently from that on the exit side so that a higher beam energy is possible than on the imaging side, which allows AEEM when an energy filter is added to the instrument. The dense packing of the magnetic lenses together with the shielding of the beam separator and the specimen region makes the magnetic shielding used in the more open earlier instruments unnecessary. The addition of an energy filter allows not only AEEM but in combination with synchrotron radiation also spectroscopic X-ray PEEM.13,45,46 From this instrument the presently most widespread commercial instrument shown in Figure 8–10 developed later. The version with energy filter, the SPELEEM, which is presently the
615
616
E. Bauer
Figure 8–10. Commercial LEEM instrument. The illumination column is on the right side and the imaging column on the left side. The 60° beam separator is hidden behind the specimen chamber in the center, which also contains the objective lens. (Courtesy of ELMITEC GmbH.)
most versatile instrument, has been described repeatedly47 in connection with PEEM. Therefore, a cross section of the presently best homebuilt pure LEEM instrument (Figure 8–11)48 is shown here. Similar to the previous instrument (Figure 8–10) it has densely packed magnetic lenses both in the illumination (top) and in the imaging (bottom) section. However, it uses a beam separator with 90° deflection that is incorporated in the vacuum system (center). The objective lens (right
Figure 8–11. Cross section of a LEEM instrument with a 90° separator. The illumination column with the field emission gun is on top and the imaging column is at the bottom. The right side shows the specimen chamber, airlock, and part of the pumping system.48
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
OBJECTIVE LENS
6˝ FLANGE BEAM SEPARATOF APERTURE MANIPULATOR FLANGES IMAGE INTENSIFIER UNIT
SPECIMEN MAGNETIC SCREENING VACUUM CHAMBER
BASIS FLANGE 8˝
ELECTRON GUN UNIT
Figure 8–12. Schematic of the mechanical configuration of a flange-on LEEM system.49
side) is a magnetic diode and consists of two sections with opposing image rotation. A commercial cold field emission electron gun (top) with an energy spread of about 0.25 eV allows a theoretical resolution of 0.4 nm at 10 eV. The right side is the specimen chamber and a preparation chamber plus airlock. This instrument presently holds the resolution record (0.5 nm) among the instruments without aberration correction. The instruments described above are free-standing instruments. There has long been the wish to add a LEEM instrument to existing UHV systems. To be practical, such LEEM systems must be much smaller and have small deflection angles. Two solutions were chosen: one uses a simple beam separator with a small deflection angle (10°)49 and the other one uses three deflections by 45°.50 In both cases the instrument is mounted on an 8-in.-diameter UHV flange and can be attached to a UHV system via a 6-in.-diameter UHV flange. All lenses are electrostatic, including the electrostatic tetrode lens. In contrast to magnetic lenses, electrostatic lenses can be easily floated at high voltage. Therefore the complete electron optics can be at high voltage so that the specimen can be near ground potential, whereas in the magnetic lens systems the specimen is at high voltage. Because of the compact design, high-voltage insulation requirements allow final energies of only 5 keV, in contrast to the 15–20 keV used in the larger systems. Only the extraction electrode of the tetrode lens can be increased to 15 kV. External fields are screened by internal µ-metal screening. Figure 8–12 shows the mechanical configuration of one of these flange-on LEEM instruments.49 Its overall length is 60 cm and its weight is about 20 kg. Several other LEEM instrument designs have been proposed and in part realized. One design51 included some interesting features such as a combined magnetic-electrostatic beam separator that allows different energies to be used in the illumination and imaging beams, an electrostatic tetrode combined with a Schwarzschild-type optical mirror objective, which focuses UV radiation onto the specimen for PEEM, and a 70° spherical condenser for electron energy filtering. Unfortunately it never came into operation. In another design that is used in a commercial instrument52 the beam separation is achieved by a Wien filter into which the illumination beam enters at an angle of 36° while the imaging beam runs along its optical axis. A second Wien filter is used as an energy filter. This instrument has been used mainly for PEEM, MEM, and
617
618
E. Bauer
metastable impact electron emission microscopy (MIEEM). Apparently the difficulty of aligning the incident beam normal to the surface and keeping the imaging beam on axis makes systematic LEEM studies with acceptable resolution difficult. A similar problem has to be overcome in an instrument in which the beam separator is replaced by a W single crystal.53 This crystal is tilted 45° against the optical axis and reflects a low-energy electron beam from a side-mounted gun along the optical axis. Exact normal incidence on the sample requires that the reflector is on the optical axis, which would obstruct the imaging beam. This instrument, called a double reflection electron emission microscope (DREEM), is also commercially available. Other LEEM instruments have been built as well but their design has not been published. All instruments discussed up to now suffer from the large chromatic and spherical aberration of the objective lens. That these aberrations can be corrected with an electron mirror has been known for some time but only during the past decade have efforts been made to develop aberration-corrected instruments. Simultaneously, however, the aberrations of the beam separator have to be corrected. This has led to the design of a complex system54,55 that has already been realized in the so-called SMART (Spectromicroscope for All Relevant Techniques) instrument,17,56,57 schematically shown in Figure 8–13. Similar to the SPELEEM system, the instrument is designed for a wide range of operation modes,58 one of which is LEEM. The centerpiece is the beam separa-
objective
beam separator
transfer optics
energy filter
field emission gun transfer lens T1 deflector D1
electric-magnetic specimen deflectors objective lens
field aperture
projector / detector
energy selection slit
projector lens
condensor lens D2
L3 L4 D3
L5 T2 D4
dipole P1
quadrupole
T3 D5
P4
H6 field lens L1
beam separator
L2
X-ray mirror
hexapole H1
H2
H5
H3
H4
P2 inner electrode
dodecapole
P3
slow scan CCD
electric-magnetic deflectors/dodecapoles
tetrode mirror
X-ray illumination
outer electrodes
monochromator exit slit
X-ray optics
channel plate
aperture
mirror corrector
0
100
200
300
400
500
600 mm
optic axis
field ray
axial ray
dispersion ray
Figure 8–13. Schematic of the electron-optical configuration of the SMART system.56
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
tor to which the illumination system, a field emission gun, the objective lens, and the mirror corrector are attached via field lenses (L). Beyond the beam separator five electrostatic lenses transfer either the diffraction pattern in the plane of the contrast aperture between L3 and L4 or the primary image at various magnifications into the entrance of the Ω-type energy filter where the field limiting aperture is located. With the energy selection slit inserted, the subsequent projective lens system produces an energy filtered image or diffraction pattern on the Channel plate-fluorescent screen unit, which is fiberoptically coupled to the CCD camera. Numerous deflectors (Di) allow precise alignment and several n-pole elements (n = 2, 6, 12) are used for the correction of residual aberrations. The instrument operates at 15 kV and is expected to have a resolution in LEEM of 1 nm at 10 eV.
4 Electron Optics Unless aberrations of the beam separator, the energy filter, other optical components or vibrations, electromagnetic fields, charging, or other disturbances are resolution limiting the chromatic and spherical aberrations of the objective lens determine the resolution. The aberrations of the accelerating field of the cathode lens cause much higher limiting values of the resolution than in transmission microscopy. These values can be calculated analytically by assuming that the lens may be separated into a homogeneous field in front of the specimen, which produces a virtual image behind the specimen, and an einzel lens, which produces a real image of the virtual image. Realistic calculations have to consider the cathode lens as a unit and have been made by many authors. A comparison of the resolution obtainable with an electrostatic triode, electrostatic tetrode, and magnetic triode lens (Figure 8–14) shows that the electrostatic tetrode and the magnetic triode lenses are much better than the original triode lens because in the latter the field strength at the sample is low under focusing conditions (1.18–0.52 kV/mm vs. 10 kV/mm in the other two lens types) (Figure 8–15).59 The data are for the optimum aperture, which is determined by minimizing the contributions of the aberration discs due to diffraction at the angle-limiting aperture, chromatic and spherical aberrations. These contributions can be seen in Figure 8–16 together with the radius of the optimum aperture. From these figures it is clear that the magnetic triode is superior to the electrostatic tetrode both in resolution and transmission. Transmission does not play an important role in LEEM but is important in XPEEM with photoelectrons and secondary electrons, which have a wide angular distribution. Today the magnetic diode, which differs from the triode only in that both pole shoes are at the same potential, is the standard in the best LEEM instruments without aberration correction while the electrostatic tetrode is the domain of the smaller, purely electrostatic LEEM instruments. In the multimethod instruments15–17,44,56,57 combined electrostatic–magnetic cathode lenses, such as the magnetic triode, are useful because they allow the field strength at the specimen to be varied. Such a lens with a design somewhat different from that shown in Figure 8–14 is used in the
619
E. Bauer b. ELECTROSTATIC TRIODE
4 E(Z)
2 TADIAL POSITION (mm)
r(Z) c. ELECTROSTATIC TETRODE
4 E(Z)
2 r(Z) d. MAGNETIC TRIODE
6 E(Z)
4
BZ(Z)
2
r(Z)
2
4 6 8 10 AXIAL POSITION (mm)
12
Figure 8–14. Schematic configurations of LEEM cathode lenses. One-half of the electrodes/pole pieces, the electron energy E(z), and the electron ray path r(z) is shown.59
SMART instrument. Because the chromatic and spherical aberrations of the objective lens are corrected in this instrument by the mirror corrector, the largest aberrations are now those of the energy filter. The resolution improvement obtained by correction is shown in Figure 8–17 as a function of angular acceptance for a start energy of 10 eV, an energy width of
1.18 20
RESOLUTION δ (nm)
620
1.15 1.12
15
1.08 FOCUSSED E.S. TRIODE .98 E.S. TETRODE .87 MAGNETIC TRIODE .52
10 5
HOMOGENEOUS (NON-FOCUSSING) FIELD
1
10
100
INITIAL ENERGY (eV)
Figure 8–15. Comparison of the resolution of the lenses shown in Figure 8–14 for a final energy of 20 keV, an energy spread of 0.5 eV, and optimized aperture.59
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM b. ELECTROSTATIC TRIODE
RESOLUTION COMPONENT (nm) OR RADIUS (µm)
Figure 8–16. Energy dependence of the contributions of the spherical, chromatic, and diffraction aberrations (dashed, dotted, and dash–dotted lines) to the resolution (solid line) at the optimum aperture with radius r for the lenses shown in Figure 8–14. In the triode the field strength has to be changed for forming a real image; in the other two lenses 10 kV/mm has been choosen. Energy spread 0.5 eV.59
10 5
FIELD STRENGTH 1.18→ .58 kV/mm FOR FOCUS AT INFINITY NET RESOLUTION δ 0 DIFFRACTION .6 λ0 /αopt CHROMATIC CCO αopt ∆E/E0 ϒ
SPHERICAL CSO α3opt
c. ELECTROSTATIC TETRODE ϒ
10
FIELD STRENGTH 10 kV/mm a
5
b
c d
d. MAGNETIC TRIODE FIELD STRENGTH 10 kV/mm
20 ϒ
15 10 5
a
a – NET RESOLUTION b – DIFFRACTION c – CHROMATIC d – SPHERICAL ϒ – APERTURE RADIUS c
1
b d
10 100 INITIAL ENERGY (eV)
2 eV, and a final energy of 15 keV.57 The dashed lines show the contributions of the aberrations of the uncorrected lens and the thin solid lines those of the energy filter. For LEEM instruments with LaB6 or field emission guns that have lower energy widths, the resolution is still improved by about a factor of 5. The main advantage of aberration correction, the large increase in transmission, however, comes to bear only in emission microscopy, in particular in AEEM and XPEEM.
Figure 8–17. Resolution limit d as a function of the acceptance angle α without and with correction of the spherical and chromatic aberrations. Data for the system shown in Figure 8–13 for 10 eV start energy and 2 eV energy spread. In the uncorrected system d is limited by the chromatic and spherical aberrations (dashed lines) and in the corrected system by higher order aberrations (solid lines).57
621
622
E. Bauer
The next critical component of a LEEM instrument is the beam separator. Early beam separators3,43 aimed only at the reduction of the unidirectional beam dispersion in the deflection plane. This was achieved with a D-shaped cutout in the round pole pieces.60 The focusing action of the fringing field of the magnet was compensated by magnetic quadrupoles. In contrast to these first separators, which tried to eliminate its focusing action, later separators made use of it in order to obtain optimum image and diffraction pattern transfer in close-packed magnetic prism arrays. They consist of an array of inner pole pieces surrounded by a single outer pole piece with different relative excitations. Such arrays act almost like round lenses. They transfer image and diffraction planes stigmatically and distortion free to corresponding planes behind the separator but at different settings.61,62 A 90° deflector with four inner prisms was suggested for the addition of a mirror corrector62 and a 60° deflector with three inner prisms was realized in the first fully magnetic LEEM instrument.44 If illumination and imaging beam have the same energy as in LEEM—in contrast to the more versatile instruments—then a single inner pole surrounded by an outer pole ring are sufficient. Both square48,54,63–65 and round 90°64,66 separators have been proposed and built. With proper geometry and excitation ratio, astigmatic and distortion-free imaging can be achieved for image and diffraction plane with the same settings. For an aberration-corrected microscope the aberrations of these separators would limit the resolution and have to be corrected. This is achieved in the highly symmetric beam separator seen in Figure 8–13.67–69 In small flange-on LEEM instruments the design of the beam separator is determined less by minimizing aberrations than by geometry and space considerations.49,50 For example, to achieve parallel illumination and imaging beams within a minimum of space, the beams were translated achromatically70 by magnets with field boundaries perpendicular to the beam and electrostatic cylinder lenses in order to achieve stigmatic focusing.50 Finally a Wien filter may also be used as a beam separator71 though with some alignment difficulties. Although the use of electron mirrors for the correction of lens aberrations was proposed many years ago72,73 and suggested for the correction of the cathode lens aberrations in LEEM and PEEM instruments in the early 1990s54,61,74 serious efforts have been made only in the past 10 years75–77 and only one instrument, the SMART, is presently equipped with a mirror corrector and is in its testing stage. An energy filter is not needed in simple LEEM instruments with sufficiently large separator deflection angles because at low energies, at which the energy of the secondary electrons differs little from that of the elastically reflected electrons used for the LEEM image, the secondary electron intensity is small compared to the diffracted beam intensity. With increasing energy, when the elastically backscattered intensity decreases and the secondary electron intensity increases, the dispersive action of the sector field deflects the secondary electrons sufficiently so that only a small fraction passes through the contrast aperture. Likewise, inelastic scattering in the high LEEM energy range occurs mainly in the forward direction so that it can be seen in the backward direction
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
623
Figure 8–18. The three fundamental operation modes of a SPELEEM system. The various sections of the instrument are shown folded into one plane. In imaging and diffraction the energy selection slit is inserted in the dispersive plane DP and the image/diffraction pattern behind DP is imaged with the projector. The intermediate lens IL is used to switch between imaging and diffraction, simultaneously with the exchange of the contrast aperture in FPI and the field-limiting aperture in IIP. For fast spectroscopy both apertures are inserted, the energy selection slit is removed, and the dispersive plane is imaged by the projector.15 (See color plate.)
only through diffraction, either via energy loss before or after diffraction. Therefore it is a second-order effect. Furthermore, the dispersion of the beam separator and the momentum transfer in the energy loss ensure that most inelastically scattered electrons do not pass through the contrast aperture. In the low LEEM energy range inelastic scattering is less in the forward direction but in general is weak, so that it does not contribute noticeably to image formation. The main advantage of having an energy filter in a LEEM instrument is that it eliminates the secondary and inelastically scattered electrons in the LEED pattern. In many cases this is not important but in materials with high secondary electron yield it improves the LEED pattern dramatically. Also, for quantitative analysis of the background in LEED patterns an energy filter is useful. The main motivation for adding an energy filter to a LEEM instrument is its importance in multimethod instruments such as the SPELEEM or the SMART. It allows LEEM to be combined with lowelectron energy loss spectroscopy and microscopy. Furthermore, when higher beam energy can be used in the illumination beam than in the imaging beam, Auger electron emission spectroscopy (AEES) and AEEM are possible too. These various operation modes of such an instrument are schemetically shown in Figure 8–18.15,47 In SEEM, whether excited by electrons, X-ray photons, or energetic ion/ neutrals, it allows selection of a narrow energy window from the wide
624
E. Bauer
secondary electron energy distribution. This leads to a noticeable resolution improvement, also in the aberration-corrected systems, in which the correction rapidly deteriorates at low energies with decreasing energy.57 A number of different energy filters are used in these multimethod instruments: one hemispherical analyzer, two hemispherical analyzers, a Wien filter, or an Omega filter. As they are not essential for LEEM they will not be discussed here.
5 Contrast For imaging with LEEM several contrast mechanisms are available, depending upon the specimen to be imaged. The fundamental contrast is diffraction contrast in crystalline samples or backscattering contrast in amorphous or fine-grained crystalline materials. The origin of the backscattering contrast is evident from Figure 8–1. An example of its consequences is shown in Figure 8–19. Because of the higher backscattering cross section of Co at the selected energy the fine-grained polycrystalline Co squares appear bright compared to the Si surrounding, which is covered with native oxide. A slight preferred orientation of the Co layer enhances the contrast.78 In general, however, larger crystals or single crystalline layers with a well-defined orientation are studied. In this case not only the specular beam [(00) beam] but other diffracted beams may be used for imaging. An atomically flat single crystal surface without steps and other defects produces contrast only when regions with different crystal structure are present. A standard example is the Si(111) surface when the unreconstructed (1 × 1) and reconstructed (7 × 7) structure coexist. Here, both normal and lateral periodicity differ and produce strong contrast (Figure 8–20a).79 The Si(100) surface reconstructs with the formation of dimer rows whose orientation rotates from terrace to terrace by 90°, with constant normal periodicity. Here, the two resulting (2 × 1) domains are equivalent at normal incidence and wellcentered aperture. Contrast is obtained by either tilting the incident beam or shifting the aperture somewhat in the direction of one of the rows. Using the ½ order spot of one of the domains gives maximum contrast (Figure 8–20b).80 Similar domain contrast can be obtained on all
Figure 8–19. Backscattering contrast from 20-nm-thick Co squares on an Si substrate. The electron energy is 5.1 eV and the diameter of field of view is 10 µm.78
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
625
b)
a)
Figure 8–20. Diffraction contrast from Si surfaces. a) Si(111). (Normal incidence) contrast due to different normal periodicity of coexisting (1 × 1) (dark) and (7 × 7) (bright) structure. Electron energy 10 eV, diameter of field of view 6 µm. Inset: LEED pattern.79 b) (Oblique incidence) contrast due to different azimuthal orientation of coexisting (2 × 1) and (1 × 2) domains. Electron energy 6 eV, image width 3 µm.80
reconstructed surfaces on which reconstruction domains exist with different azimuthal orientations. All surfaces have steps or step bunches that will produce another contrast to be described below. In general surfaces are heterogeneous not only in crystallography but also in composition and topography. Composition differences are usually connected with crystallographic differences and produce, together with backscattering differences, diffraction contrast in the (00) beam. Also here imaging with nonspecular beams is useful for identifying different coexisting phases as illustrated in Figure 8–21,81 which is from an Si(111) surface covered with a submonolayer of Au. The three LEEM images are taken with the (00) beam and with nonspecular beams (1/5-order beams) of (5 × 2) superstructure domains. This allows the identification of the dark regions between the bright ( 3 × 3 )-R30° structure regions in the specular image with different (5 × 2) domains. Topography distorts the electric field distribution on the surface. This causes the usual topographic contrast, which is most evident near zero electron energy. Topography also produces diffraction contrast. This happens when surface elements are inclined against the average surface, for example, in small crystals on an otherwise flat surface. In a LEEM instrument the positions of the LEED spots from a flat surface do not change with energy as they do in an ordinary LEED system. This is due to the fact that the observed LEED pattern is a magnified image of the LEED pattern in the back focal plane of the objective lens, where the electrons have a constant high energy E = (h2/2m)k2 independent of their start energy. Because the wave number k is proportional to the refractive index n, we have k sin θ = ko sin θo
(2)
where θ and θo are the angles of the electron trajectories with the optical axis in the back focal plane and at the surface, respectively. For two-dimensional diffraction
626
E. Bauer
k sin θo = 2πh
(3)
where h is the distance of the LEED spot h = (h1, h2) from the (00) beam, which is on the optical axis at normal incidence. Combining the two equations leads to k sin θ = 2πh
(4)
Thus the angular distance θ of the LEED spot h in the back focal plane is independent of the start energy Eo = (h2/2m)k2o and depends only on the final energy E = (h2/2m)k2. This is no longer true when the surface normal is inclined against the optical axis. Then the specular beam is off-axis and the diffracted beams h move toward the specular beam with increasing energy. The simple geometric relations at normal incidence, which lead to Eo-independent spot positions, are no longer valid so that the spots move now in the back focal plane. An example of these spot movements is shown in Figure 8–22.82 A simple geometric analysis allows deduction of the inclination of the surface. Faceted surfaces, that is surfaces on which all surface elements are tilted, so that no specular beam is on the optical axis, can be imaged either by selecting an energy at which one of the diffracted spots passes
Figure 8–21. Phase identification by dark-field imaging. The LEED pattern (a) of the Au submonolayer on Si(111) shows a hexagonal pattern from the ( 3 × 3 )-R30° phase and two linear patterns from the (5 × 2) phase. The bright-field image (b) shows dark regions that are identified as (5 × 2) regions by imaging with (1/5, 0), spots (c and d). Electron energy in (a) 30 eV and in (b–d) 6 eV.81
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
Figure 8–22. Drawing of the movements of LEED spots from faceted Cu silicide crystallites on a Si(111) surface. The open circles are from the Si(111)-δ(7 × 7) structure. The small solid and shaded circles are from the crystallites. Increasing shading shows the movement of the spots with energy increasing from 3 to 10.5 eV.82
through the optical axis or by tilting the illuminating beam or by shifting the contrast aperture off axis into one of the specular beams. For large tilt angles only the first mode is practical. Another important contrast mechanism is the interference contrast on flat surfaces with height differences such as atomic steps. The step contrast was already observed in the early studies (Figure 8–231) and attributed to destructive interference between the wave fields reflected from the adjoining terraces within the lateral coherence length (Figure
Figure 8–23. Monatomic steps on an MO(110) surface. Electron energy 14 eV.3
627
628
E. Bauer
Figure 8–24. Conditions for phase contrast in LEEM. (a) Step contrast. (b) Quantum size contrast. The penetration of the electron wave upon reflection is indicted.
8–24a). Detailed model calculations based on Fresnel diffraction from two adjoining straight edges shifted relative to each other by the step height produce all salient features of the step contrast.83,84 Here some results of the general theory of image formation by a typical magnetic cathode lens will be given.85 In the absence of aberrations the reflection of slow electrons from a point source would produce an interference pattern that extends far out from the step. This would make image interpretation in the presence of several steps difficult. The spherical aberration reduces the range of the interference pattern significantly and the chromatic aberration reduces it to one intensity maximum next to the step at energy spreads as low as 0.5 eV. The intensity distribution around the step depends upon the phase difference between the waves reflected from both sides of the step, that is upon the step height and the wave length, and upon the defocus. This is illustrated in Figure 8– 2585 for two phase shifts ∆ϕ = nπ (n = 0.5, 1) and several defocus values ∆z* = ∆z(Csλ)−1/2, where ∆z is the geometric defocus, Cs the spherical aberration constant, and λ the wavelength. ∆z* = 0, 1 corresponds to the Gaussian image and to the Scherzer focus, respectively. For integer n the step contrast is symmetric and optimum at ∆z* = 0; for noninteger n it is asymmetric, with the bright edge changing from one side of the step to the other when the sign of the defocus changes. Optimum contrast is achieved for slight defocus. A third contrast mechanism, the quantum size contrast, is also based on wave interference, which not necessarily requires crystal periodicity. In a thin film bounded by two parallel surfaces the wave reflected from the bottom surface can interfere constructively or destructively with that reflected from the top surface similar to a Fabry–Perot interferometer, depending upon the wavelength λ, the thickness t, and the phase shifts ϕ upon reflection at the surfaces (Figure 8–24b). Constructive interference and therefore enhanced reflectivity occurs whenever n(λ/2) + ϕ = t, where n is an integer and λ is the wavelength in the film, which differs from the vacuum wavelength by the inner potential. As a consequence, regions with different thickness appear in the image with different brightness. This was first observed in Cu films on Mo(110) 86 and has been studied since in detail in several other systems with the goal to determine the band structure k(E) above the vacuum
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM I
∆ z* = –2
I
1.50
1.50
1.00
1.00
0.50
0.50
0.00 –30 –20 –10
I
0
10 20 30 x[nm]–30 –20 –10
∆ z* = 0
I
1.50
1.50
1.00
1.00
0.50
0.50
0.00 –30 –20 –10
I
0
10 20 30 x[nm]–30 –20 –10
I
1.50
1.50
1.00
1.00
0.50
0.50
0
10 20 30x[nm]–30 –20 –10 0
10 20 30x[nm]
0
10 20 30x[nm]–30 –20 –10 0
10 20 30x[nm]
0
10 20 30x[nm]–30 –20 –10 0 10 20 30x[nm]
∆ z* = 2
0.00 –30 –20 –10
10 20 30x[nm]–30 –20 –10 0 10 20 30x[nm]
0
∆ z* = 0
0.00 –30 –20 –10
0 10 20 30x[nm]
∆ z* = 2
0.00 –30 –20 –10
∆ z* = –2
0.00 –30 –20 –10
0 10 20 30x[nm]
629
Figure 8–25. Step contrast for the phase differences ∆ϕ = π (left) and ∆ϕ = 0.5π (right) between the waves reflected from the terraces next to the step for zero defocus and small positive and negative defocus.85
level,83,87,88,89 spin-dependent electron reflectivity effects,90 or to understand specific features in thin film growth.91,92,93 To determine the band structure, the constructive interference condition above is rewritten by replacing λ by k = 2π/λ, which leads to k(E)t − k(E)ϕ(E) = nπ. The energy-dependent phase term can be eliminated by choosing film thickness pairs t1, t2 for which this condition is fulfilled (with different n), which gives a set of k(E) values. With proper growth conditions regions with different thickness can be obtained (Figure 8–2687) and analyzed quasisimultaneously. After subtraction of
6ML 7ML 8ML
5.2 eV
6.4 eV
9.6 eV
11.4 eV
Figure 8–26. Quantum size contrast between regions with different thickness of an Fe film on W(110), taken with different electron energies, that is wavelengths. The images in the top row show the intensity and those at the bottom the magnetic signal (exchange asymmetry). Blue and red correspond to opposite magnetization directions.88 (For the bottom row, see color plate.)
630
E. Bauer
Figure 8–27. Quantum size oscillations of the reflectivity of spin-up (•) and spin-down (*) electrons in a six-monolayer-thick Fe film on W(110) as a function of energy.88
the reflectivity of a thick film, which does not show quantum size effects, the oscillations of the reflectivity due to constructive and destructive interference can clearly be seen. This is illustrated in Figure 8–2791 for a ferromagnetic film in which the band structures of the majority and minority spin electrons differ by the exchange splitting. The reflectivity curve for the minority spin electrons is shifted relative to that of the majority electrons due to this splitting and is also damped more strongly due to the shorter IMFP of the minority electrons mentioned in Section 2.
6 Applications 6.1 General Comments The high intensity available in LEEM studies of single-crystal surfaces, which allows rapid image acquisition, the high surface sensitivity, which strongly accentuates the topmost layer in imaging, both discussed in Section 2, and the various contrast mechanisms described in Section 5 have made LEEM one of the most powerful methods for surface studies, in particular of the thermodynamics of surfaces and of the kinetics of surface processes. While most of this information came from detailed studies of semiconductor surfaces, mainly from Si(111) and Si(100) surfaces, important insight into surface processes have also been obtained from various metal surfaces and oxide surfaces such as the TiO2(110) surface. The information obtained from such studies ranges from the chemical potential of adatoms, diffusion across terraces and steps, anisotropic step free energy, step stiffness, step mobility, step–step interactions, surface free energy and surface stress, vacancy exchange between the bulk and the surface to nucleation, growth, phase transi-
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
631
tions, self-organization, faceting, segregation, oxidation, and other surface and thin film phenomena. Only some examples can be mentioned in the following subsections. These are organized according to the material, but the references will provide access to most of the relevant work done up to now. For illustrations results of the early, exploratory work will be used because the later quantitative studies require much more discussion. 6.2 The Si(111) Surface The Si(111) surface is probably the surface most studied with LEEM, mainly because of its phase transition from the reconstructed (7 × 7) to the disordered “(1 × 1)” at 1100 K or 1135 K, depending upon author. In precise LEED diffractometer measurements,94 see also95 the superstructure spots disappeared at 1120 K and an intensity fit assuming a continuous transition gave a critical temperature of 1100 K ± 1 K. However, no critical scattering was observed, which put into question earlier conclusions that the phase transition was second order. The first LEEM measurements79,80,96 demonstrated without doubt that the transition was first order as seen in the nucleation and growth of the (7 × 7) structure (Figure 8–28). The growth rate of the (7 × 7) domains was found to increase linearly with undercooling ∆T and for ∆T > 12 K nucleation also occurred on the terraces. The transition was found to be strongly influenced by impurities.97 In particular, the apparent discrepancy between LEEM and the preceding LEED studies could be attributed to near-surface contamination during the long measurement time near the phase transition needed in the quantitative LEED studies. This is illustrated in Figure 8–29,80 which shows that long annealing near the transition temperature
Figure 8–28. Nucleation and growth of the (7 × 7) structure at surface steps with different orientations at low supersaturation. Electron energy: top 10.5 eV and bottom 1.5 eV.96
632
E. Bauer
Figure 8–29. Comparison of a surface that had been annealed for a long time around the transition temperature (a) and one that has been cooled rapidly from 1450 K to this temperature (b). Electron energy 10.5 eV.80
completely destroys the regular domain structure. The LEED patterns differ only by a slightly higher background in the annealed sample but the transition range is now much wider, similar to that in the LEED studies. On clean surfaces that have been quenched rapidly and have converted completely into the (7 × 7) structure many domains with various sizes form. Upon subsequent annealing they coarsen without preference of certain boundary orientations and number of bounding domain walls.98 Recent, more detailed studies99–109 have shed considerable light on the forces and processes involved in the phase transition, such as adatom diffusion,99,100,104 the influence of the surface stress difference between the (7 × 7) and (1 × 1) phases and of long-range interactions on phase coexistence,101 shape,105,109 and distribution of the (7 × 7) domains106 and other aspects. There are excellent reviews on these subjects110,111 where details may be found. Another phenomenon that has been studied with LEEM and that is closely related to the (1 × 1) to (7 × 7) phase transition upon cooling is the faceting of vicinal (stepped) Si(111) surfaces.112–114 Other studies have been concerned with the conditions for step flow growth instead of two-dimensional nucleation from which the parameters that determine the growth kinetics can be derived.115–117 In and Sb surfactants that form a ( 3 × 3 )R30° structure were found to either enhance or to suppress step flow, respectively.118 An apparently similar boron-induced surface structure [( 3 × 3 )R30°–B] has a quite different effect: it causes twinning.115 6.3 Si(100) This surface is the basis of semiconductor technology and has, therefore, attracted particular attention. It was studied qualitatively in the early years of LEEM80 (see Figure 8–20b) and showed convincingly the inequivalence of the A and B type steps, the lower energy SA steps being smooth while the higher energy SB steps were rough. Step migra-
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
tion during sublimation119 and interaction with dislocations formed by plastic deformation during cooling120 were studied as well as the enhancement of one domain upon elastic defomation.80,120 Other processes included consecutive “Lochkeim” formation during sublimation of flat regions121 and homoepitaxial growth.80,121–123 From the terrace shape during growth close to equilibrium (Figure 8–30) a lower limit of the ratio of the step free energies of SB and SA of βB/βA ≥ 2.6 at about 800 K was obtained. In other qualitative work124,125 the step morphology was studied in more detail as a function of miscut angle, which led to a step “phase diagram” ranging from a “hilly” phase near zero miscut via single height wavy steps, straight steps to double height steps at a miscut of about 0.1°. In subsequent quantitative studies126–137 comprehensive information could be deduced from step and island shapes and distributions. Many of the results can also be found in the reviews mentioned above.110,111 Some of them are the determination of the mobility and stiffness of the SA and SB steps,126,130 of their free energy,126 and of the anisotropy of the surface stress;137 the extraction of the chemical potential, formation energy, and diffusion coefficients of adatoms from number, area, and distribution of two-dimensional islands.127,131,134 On the more qualitative side, the fabrication of large step-free regions129,136 and of periodic gratings132,133,135 by e-beam lithography, reactive ion beam etching, and high-temperature annealing has also contributed considerably to the understanding of the surface properties. Other methods of surface modifications have been studied as well. Oxygen etches the surface at high temperature and produces vacancy islands.138,139,140 Arsenic was found to displace Si even on large terraces, driven by surface stress,
Figure 8–30. Images from a video taken during the homoepitaxial growth of Si(100) at low supersaturation so that growth can occur only from a defect at the lower edge of the image. Electron energy 5 eV.122
633
634
E. Bauer Figure 8–31. Images from a video taken during the segregation and desegregation of B from B-doped Si(100) during cooling and heating. Electron energy 4.2 eV; diameter of field of view 7 µm.
causing two-dimensional island formation.141 Boron segregation leads to strong temperature-dependent surface roughening at the monolayer level, forming a striped (Figure 8–31) or triangular-tiled surface structure.142–145 Originally believed to be driven mainly by surface stress relaxation142 it was shown later that a strong reduction of the step free energy of the SA steps was the main driving force.143,144 6.4 Other Elemental Semiconductor Surfaces On the silicon-on-insulator (SOI) (100) surface LEEM was used to determine the dislocation-induced strain.146 On the Si(311) surface the LEEM image intensity fluctuations in small surface regions were measured during the continuous disordering transition of the (3 × 1) reconstruction around 965 K, in order to determine the critical parameters.147
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
The first-order transition at about 1005 K from the high-temperature “(1 × 1)” to the low-temperature “(16 × 2)” structure of the Si(110) surface and the stress-stabilized coexistence of the two phases was the subject of another study.148 Similar to the work on Si(111) and Si(100), various surface thermodynamic data have also been obtained for the Si(110) surface from island decay measurements.149 Finally, an LEEM study of the (2 × 1) to (1 × 1) phase transition above 925 K on Ge(100) led to the conclusion that the transition was due to dimer breakup and roughening.150 6.5 Thin Films on Semiconductors Because of its importance in the semiconductor industry Ge or more precisely SiGe on Si(100) has been the most-studied system.151–161 This system initially forms a several monolayer thick layer that is highly strained depending upon alloy composition. From this layer threedimensional islands develop with facets that depend upon size and composition, leading to a rich variety of phenomena well suited for LEEM studies. The transition from the initial layer to the threedimensional islands is strain driven and does not require threedimensional nucleation.156,157,159 Surface steps play a critical role in the alloying of Ge with the Si(100) surface.160 The results up to 2000 are summarized in an excellent review.161 The growth of Ge on other Si surfaces has been studied in much less detail. On the (111) surface the influence of the surfactant Sb on the growth was studied,162 on the (311) surface the transition from the two-dimensional layer to threedimensional islands.163 These showed a much more complicated facet structure than on Si(100). Finally, the growth of Ge on GaAs(100) has also been studied briefly.164 The growth of metals on semiconductor surfaces can also be studied very well with LEEM. Most of the work was done on Si(111) surfaces, some also on Si(100), using video recording of the growth, diffusion, ordering, and disordering processes. Au on Si(111) is a good example: after several two-dimensional superstructures have formed with increasing coverage, three-dimensional particles grow that show an interesting temperature dependence due to the formation of an Au–Si eutectic.165,166 On vicinal Si(100) surfaces with a miscut of 4°, adsorption of a monolayer of Au causes pronounced faceting at elevated temperatures.167–170 The growth of Ag on Si(111) has also been studied extensively,162,171–174 in particular the growth shape,172,174 and has been used to demonstrate that buried interfaces can be imaged via their strain fields.173 In the various studies of Ag on Si(100)175–177 a straininduced shape transition of Ag crystals into “quantum wires”175 and bamboo-like growth178 have been observed. Substrate material incorporation into the two-dimensional superstructure177 and the influence of steps on the domain ordering in it176 were found. On vicinal Si(100) self-assembled Ag “quantum wires” form at high temperatures.179 The growth of Cu on Si(111) has been studied both on the clean and on the hydrogen-passivated surface.180–184 Hydrogen termination strongly influences the formation of the two-dimensional “(5 × 5)” superstruc-
635
636
E. Bauer
ture and the three-dimensional nucleation of Cu silicide. At higher temperatures at which hydrogen is desorbed large Cu3Si crystals in a variety of shapes and facets form. In Al films on Si(111) the two-dimensional phase diagram and the phase transitions between the phases have been studied.185 The growth of Pb on Si(111) has been used to obtain an understanding of how interfactants, that is substrate surface layers that remain at the interface during growth, produce quasi-monolayer-by-monolayer growth, using Au and Ag as interfactants.186–188 Figure 8–32 illustrates the influence of an Au interfactant layer on the growth of Pb. On the Si(100) surface Pb grows in <111>-oriented crystals on the two-dimensional initial layer. The crystal, have frequently “ashtray” shape due to the large supply of Pb atoms by diffusion on the initial layer.189 On vicinal and high index surfaces of Si, which have been faceted by Au adsorption, Pb grows in mesoscopic wires.190,191 In was found not to wet the Si(111)(7 × 7) surface but to grow at low temperature monolayer-by-monolayer on the Si(111)-( 3 × 3 )-R30° surface with a variety of superstructures. Three-dimensional crystals that grow at somewhat higher temperatures have predominantly (100) orientation with a surface reconstruction similar to that of the underlying two-dimensional layer.192,193 The Si(100) surface is etched at high temperatures by In similar to the situation mentioned above for Ag, at lower temperatures a superstructure forms.194 Transition metals are highly reactive with Si and form silicides that frequently are more stable at high temperatures than Si. An example is Co. When deposited or annealed at high temperatures Co layers form more or less hexagonal CoSi2 crystals that show misfit dislocation contrast when thin enough. When heated to temperatures at which Si sublimes CoSi2-topped hillocks form because of the lower vapor pressure of CoSi2 (Figure 8–33).97,195 At lower temperatures the crystals
Figure 8–32. Images taken during the growth of Pb on Si(111) at 290 K with (top) and without Au surfactant (bottom). Electron energy 8 eV.186
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM Figure 8–33. Hillocks on an Si(111) surface caused by CoSi2 crystals during the sublimation of Si.97
are triangular and act as Co scavengers cleaning the surrounding surface from Co so that it develops the (7 × 7) structure of the clean surface. At very low Co coverages an interesting “ring cluster” (RC) phase forms, which has been studied in considerable detail.196–198 Ni forms a similar RC phase.199 Another transition metal, Ti, spontaneously forms Ti silicide “nanowires” when deposited at about 1120 K. Their formation process and stability have been studied in detail.200 Only a few nonmetal films on Si have been studied with LEEM: CaF2 and Si nitride. In CaF2 films both the complexities of the formation of the first two layers have been studied201 as well the formation mechanism of the interfacial dislocation network with increasing film thickness.202 The Si nitride work was concerned mainly with the formation of the initial epitaxial layer by reaction with NH3 at high temperatures, which occurs via nucleation and growth of nitride domains similar to the (7 × 7) domains on the clean surface.203 6.6 Wide-Band Semiconductors Very little work has been with LEEM on these materials. There is a cursory study of the temperature dependence of the structure of the 6H-SiC(0001) surface used as a substrate in the growth of GaN layers.204 The structure of the GaN(0001) surface was studied with dark-field imaging, which allowed determination of the surface termination,205 similar to that of the SiC(0001) surface.204 The importance of the Ga/N ratio in homoepitaxial growth of GaN was demonstrated in several papers,204,206,207 in particular the necessity of a Ga double layer on top of the GaN surface for the growth of films with (0001) surfaces.204,207,208 The double layer shows an interesting phase transition.204 Without an adsorbed Ga layer the GaN films grow rough, with {10-11} and {101-2} facets. GaN growth on 6H-Si(0001) is similar209 and not as reported in another paper,210 except that initially three-dimensional crystals form instead of the spiral and step flow growth in homoepitaxial growth on GaN.
637
638
E. Bauer
6.7 Metal Surfaces Refractory metal surfaces have been the most popular subject in LEEM because of their high melting point and low vapor pressure that allow experiments over a wide temperature range. W and Mo can be cleaned easily by heating in oxygen. The chemisorbed oxygen is then flashed off at high temperatures, a procedure that is not successful in Nb and Ta, in which oxygen goes into solid solution and can be partially removed only by lengthy sputter and annealing cycles. The imaging of the step structure on the Mo(110) surface (Figure 8–23) was one of the first demonstrations of the power of LEEM and step contrast has been one of the mayor tools in the study of surface processes on clean surfaces. While W(110) and Mo(110) have been used frequently as substrates for thin films, and to a much lesser extent also W(100) and W(111), little has usually been published about the clean surface, except for a brief study of the Mo(110) surface.211 Extensive work was done, however, on epitaxial Mo(110)212–217 and Nb(110)215,218–220 layers grown on sapphire (11–20) surfaces at high temperatures, which after proper cleaning produces surfaces that are comparable in quality to single crystal surfaces. A complication is the interfacial strain and the dislocations introduced upon cooling and thermal cycling by the different thermal expansion coefficients between film and substrate. Nevertheless, pure surface quantities such as the step stiffness could be extracted from such films. In the case of the Nb(110) films the situation is complicated by the residual oxygen. This causes reconstruction and faceting,215,218,219 which in themselves are interesting processes and are useful for the study of extended defects.220 Some work on Ta(110) films was also done.215 Noble metal surfaces have also been the subject of several LEEM studies. For Pt(111) single crystal surfaces step stiffness, step–step interactions, step free energy,215,217,221 and bulk-surface vacancy exchange222,223 have been determined. For Pd(111) surfaces the step stiffness217 has been obtained and sputter erosion processes224 have been observed. Studies of the island decay on Rh(100) indicated a new surface diffusion process.225 Step fluctuation spectroscopy of Au(111) yielded the surface mass diffusion coefficient and the orientationdependent step stiffness.226 Dark-field imaging of the reconstructed Au(100) surface was used to establish the connection between the reconstruction domains and the step orientations (Figure 8–34).80,227,228 On the Ag(111) surface a critical island size for layer-by-layer growth was found.229 From an investigation of the homoepitaxial growth of Cu on Cu(100) the Ehrlich–Schwoebel barrier, the energy barrier for diffusion across a step, was deduced.230 Similar to other fcc(110) surfaces, the Pb(110) surface reconstructs. A LEEM study of the various reconstructions, some of them alkali induced, revealed the topography of the various phases and the influence of surface defects on the transitions between them.231,232 Finally, studies of the surface morphology of the NiAl(110) surface demonstrated the importance of bulk diffusion for surface smoothing.233 Most experiments on clean surfaces rely on the step contrast discussed in Section 5, which illustrates its usefulness.
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
Figure 8–34. Au(100) surface. Bright-field image (a) and dark-field images (c and d) taken with the “(5 × 1)” superstructure reflections indicated in the LEED pattern (b). Electron energy in the images 16 eV.227
6.8 Metal Layers on Metals Although the growth of many metals on W(110) and Mo(110) has been studied with other methods, LEEM has been used infrequently, often only in a very cursory manner. Cu is the most investigated layer material, both on Mo86,123,166,234,235 and W. The growth on both substrates is similar and has been studied in detail on W(110).236 Layer spacings have been determined using the quantum size effect discussed in Section 5.237 The more qualitative work on Mo revealed an interesting striped phase upon annealing at high temperatures and details in the structural phase transition in the double layer. Layer spacings have also been obtained from the quantum size effect for Ag on W(110).92 Au has been studied briefly on Mo(110) in the submonolayer range where it forms needle-like crystals.123,235 In Pd layers on W(110) the transition from two- to three-dimensional growth was the subject of a combined LEEM–XPEEM study.238 The growth of Ag and Cu on the Ru(0001) surface served as a demonstration of the influence of substrate steps on the growth of three-dimensional crystals.239 In the metal-on-metal systems discussed up to now the substrate surface is not modified or is modified only a little by the growing film. This is not the case on less densely packed surfaces such as the W(111) surface that facets upon deposition of certain metals at high temperatures. Pt growth on W(111) is a case study for this process.240,241 The growth of ferromagnetic layers will be discussed in Section 7 in connection with SPLEEM.
639
640
E. Bauer
In many cases the deposited metal forms a surface alloy with the substrate. Pd on Mo(100) is an example that was studied in detail by LEEM up to several monolayers.242 Clear alloying was observed up to a monolayer followed by two-dimensional Pd growth without faceting. Alloying of Sn with Cu(111) is strikingly different: at very low coverages large two-dimensional islands form that travel across the surface, leaving alloy behind and, thereby, decreasing in size.243 Pb forms on the Cu(100) surface initially several two-dimensional structures followed by the growth of three-dimensional crystals. LEEM clearly shows the correlation between the crystals and the initial layer,244 evidence for the surface alloying in the initial layer at low coverages, followed by dealloying.245,246 The nature of the disordering transitions of these phases was also determined.246 One of the most impressive results that LEEM has produced up to now is the self-assembly of stress domain patterns in the two-dimensional Pb–Cu alloy on Cu(111), which consist of domains of a Pb-rich and Pb-poor phase. This process has been studied in great detail, which has produced a wealth of information on stress-induced ordering phenomena247–251 and has been well reviewed.252 Finally, the influence of the interface between Pb droplets and the Cu(111) surface on the shape and melting of the droplets has been the subject of an LEEM study.253,254 6.9 Reactions on Metal Surfaces Although LEEM is well-suited for the study of reactions on surfaces with gases or impurities from the bulk, very little work has been done up to now. Segregation of impurities from the bulk and the formation of precipitation products on the surface are routinely observed before the crystal has been cleaned completely. Surface carbide formation on W and Mo surfaces is an example. Images of such carbides and of carbides formed by CO dissociation have sometimes been published,123,213,234 but the precipitation process was never studied in detail. As far as oxidation is concerned, only three systems have been studied: the initial oxidation of W(100),255,256 the low oxygen coverage region on Nb(100),257 and the growth of oxide domains on NiAl(110).258 All three studies show interesting unexpected phenomena. More work has been done on surface reactions in which the reaction products desorb, that is in heterogeneous catalysis. The first studies looked with very limited resolution at reactions of CO with O2,259,260 with NO261 and at the reaction of NO and H2,262 mainly at the propagation of the reaction front and its pinning by defects. On Pt(110) pattern formation in the CO oxidation has been studied263,264 and on Rh(110) the reaction of NO265 and of O2 with H2.266,267 Most of this work has been done with low resolution, but the possibilities of LEEM in this particular field are evident in some studies.265,267 The contrast is due to the fact that surface regions with different reactant composition have different structures, which produce characteristic LEED patterns. These can be used for dark-field imaging of these regions.265 Such dark-field images are shown in Figure 8–35 of the NO + H2 reaction on Rh(110). The propagation of a spiral wave reaction is imaged with the diffraction
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
641
Figure 8–35. Dark-field images taken during the reaction of NO with H2 on Rh(110) with LEED spots characteristic for the various phases in the oscillatory reaction.265
spots of pure N phases (a and b), a mixed N + O phase (c), and a pure O phase (d), which occur during the oscillatory reaction. Because of the high brightness, LEEM is preferable to PEEM because it allows following the kinetics of the reaction wave propagation and it is superior to MEM because of its better resolution. 6.10 Oxides and Nitrides The only LEEM work on oxides published up to now is that on the TiO2(110) surface.268–271 TiO2 is a particularly good example of the influence of the exchange of defects between the bulk and the surface on its structure because its stoichiometry can vary considerably. On the nonstoichiometric surface a (1 × 1) to (1 × 2) phase transition occurs as a function of temperature due to vacancy exchange between the bulk and the surface, which was studied thoroughly.268–270 When exposed to oxygen, the nonstoichiometric, surface grows via step flow at high temperatures but via two-dimensional nucleation at lower temperatures. With suitable growth conditions the surface topography can be changed and the oxygen content of the bulk can be increased.271 The only nitride studied to date—silicon nitride and GaN, which have been discussed in Sections 6.5 and 6.6, respectively, excepted—is the (111) surface of TiN layers. These layers form mounds with spiral steps or stacks of two-dimensional islands. The mass transport at high temperatures can be studied well by following the step motion and the diffusion processes and constants can be derived from it.272,273 6.11 Concluding Remarks The applications discussed in this subsection clearly show the many possibilities of LEEM in the study of surfaces and thin films of a wide variety of materials. Important information on the physical and chemical properties of surfaces and thin films has been extracted from these studies. These can be found in the references cited. Diffraction contrast, step contrast, and quantum size contrast, together with the real time capability, are the essential features that make LEEM so powerful in these studies. It should also be emphasized that LEEM is primarily an imaging method for in situ studies. Sample exchange is more timeconsuming than in standard transmission and scanning electron
642
E. Bauer
microscopy because the sample has to be transferred into ultrahigh vacuum, usually after cleaning in a preparation chamber, and then aligned in the microscope. These steps are necessary because of the high surface sensitivity of the method and because the sample is part of the objective lens so that its surface has to be exactly perpendicular to the optical axis. An important aspect of LEEM is that it can be easily combined with other, in part complementary surface imaging techniques. MEM is useful whenever no strong diffracted beam is available for imaging, for example, on fine-grained polycrystalline or amorphous samples. In this case the sample potential is chosen such that the electrons cannot penetrate into the sample. Contrast is then determined by surface topography, surface potential, and work function differences. MEM has been used, for example, in the study of chemical reactions.259,260 Ultraviolet lightexcited photoemission electron microscopy (UVPEEM) is probably the most popular auxiliary imaging method in LEEM instruments. It is used when fields of view larger than those possible in LEEM have to be imaged or in samples in which it produces better contrast than LEEM. A good example is the study of the growth of pentacene films on oxidized Si.274,275 The application range of UVPEEM is the same as that of MEM, but the resolution is in general much better. Synchrotron radiation-excited XPEEM provides chemical information and chemically specific magnetic information. It can be combined easily with LEEM, in particular in instruments equipped with an energy filter, the SPELEEM mentioned in Section 3. XPEEM is discussed elsewhere in the book. Other imaging methods that are possible in LEEM instruments are thermionic emission electron microscopy (TEEM). TEEM is useful in general only for samples with locally varying work functions and that can be heated high enough for thermionic emission. Metastable impact electron emission microscopy (MIEEM) is another imaging method with limited application range. In this method276 deexcitation of metastable He* atoms at the surface causes electron emission up to energies of 15–20 eV. Because of the chromatic aberration resolutions of 100 nm or less can be achieved only with a band pass energy filter.277 The main application of MIEEM is in the study of adsorbates, which consist of regions with different deexcitation processes. In LEEM instruments that allow higher energies in the illumination system than in the imaging system SEEM and in particular AEEM are possible. AEEM is useful for chemical analysis but inferior to XPEEM because of the larger characteristic peak width and the larger background. As in XPEEM, a band pass energy filter is indispensable for selection of a narrow energy band at the Auger electron peaks. The energy filter is also useful for SEEM whose application range is similar to that of UVPEEM and MEM.
7 Spin-Polarized LEEM (SPLEEM) SPLEEM is a version of LEEM that requires a separate treatment because it does not give structural but magnetic information. It differs from LEEM only in that the illumination system produces a partially
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM Figure 8–36. Schematic of the spin manipulator. For explanation see text.285
spin-polarized electron beam. The polarization is achieved by illuminating a GaAs (100) surface with circular polarized light with the wavelength corresponding to the band gap of GaAs. The surface is activated by Cs and O2 exposure to negative electron affinity so that electrons that have been excited to the bottom of the conduction band can escape the surface. Optical selection rules produce a spin selection in the excitation process such that the spin of the emitted electrons points normal to the surface either inward or outward, depending upon the helicity (right or left) of the exciting light. With specially designed photocathodes spin polarizations up to 80% have been achieved, but the ordinary cathodes used in SPLEEM usually have a polarization of only about 20–30%. Details of this kind of cathode can be found in Pierce.278 After extraction from the cathode, the electron beam is deflected 90° by a combined electrostatic–magnetic sector field. In pure electrostatic deflection the direction of the spin polarization P is unchanged, in pure magnetic deflection P is deflected 90°, and if both fields are used for 90° deflection P can be rotated in any direction in the plane indicated in Figure 8–36. In the early SPLEEM studies279–284 only electrostatic deflection was available. Later the magnetic rotator lens indicated in this figure was added, which now allows P to rotate in any direction in space.285 Usually, however, only three directions are selected, one normal to the surface of the crystal and the other two in preferred directions in the surface plane (easy and hard magnetic axes). The “spin manipulator” shown in Figure 8–36 is incorporated in the original LEEM described in Section 3 (Figure 8–9) and in a second instrument.50,286
643
644
E. Bauer
The magnetic contrast is due to the fact that the 180° backscattering from magnetic materials depends upon the relative orientation of the spin of the incident electrons and of the electrons in the material, or in other words upon the relative orientation of the polarization P and the magnetization M. The intensity in the image is then given by I = Istr + c P ⋅ M where Istr is determined by the structure and topography of the surface, c is a small proportionality constant, and the dot indicates the scalar product. Pure magnetic contrast is obtained by subtracting two images taken with opposite P direction pixel by pixel. Maximum contrast occurs obviously for P || ± M. For P ⊥ M the contrast between magnetic domains with opposite magnetization vanishes and only the domain walls produce contrast. Maximum contrast requires imaging at very low energies, typically a few electronvolts. At these energies the exchange splitting of the band structure and the difference between the inelastic mean free paths of the spin-up and spin-down electrons, which were mentioned in Section 2, cause the strongest difference between the backscattering for the two spin directions. Because the magnetic signal is only a small fraction of the total signal, the signalto-noise ratio in the difference image is small and frequently limits the resolution.287 Addition of two images with opposite P direction produces only structural contrast, which makes SPLEEM ideal for the correlation between magnetism and structure. More information on magnetic contrast formation may be found in recent SPLEEM reviews.288,289 In most of the SPLEEM studies the ferromagnetic samples are prepared in situ while observing the magnetic structure together with the crystal structure and topography via several contrast mechanisms. However, ex situ prepared samples can also be studied after proper surface cleaning as illustrated in Figure 8–37 for a Co(0001) surface that had been sputter-cleaned and annealed.279 Ex situ prepared samples can also be studied when passivated with a thin layer that is sufficiently transparent for slow electrons such as noble metals.290 In this method it has to be taken into account that such overlayers can change the magnetization in the film below.291,292 The in situ studies cover single
Figure 8–37. SPLEEM image of the closure domains on a Co(0001) surface. Electron energy 2 eV.279
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
ferromagnetic layers, ferromagnetic layers covered with nonmagnetic overlayers, ferromagnetic–nonmagnetic–ferromagnetic sandwiches, and small ferromagnetic crystals. Under certain conditions large regions of a thin Fe film can be grown with constant thickness and atomically flat surfaces. These show pronounced quantum size effects (Figure 8–26).88 The intensity reflected from regions with different thickness shows pronounced spindependent quantum size oscillations as a function of energy (Figure 8–27) from which the exchange-split band structure above the vacuum level can be derived.87,88 The early SPLEEM work concentrated on Co films on W(110) without279–281 and with282 nonmagnetic overlayers, on Co on Au films on W(110),283 and on initial studies of Co/Cu/Co sandwiches.280 Some of the more interesting results were the dependence of the spin reorientation transition from out-of-plane to in-plane magnetization— deduced from the disappearance of the in-plane magnetic contrast—upon the state of the Au film and the strong influence of the substrate topography;283 the large difference in the damping of the magnetic signal by Cu and Pd overlayers due to the different inelastic mean free paths in these materials; and the quantum size effect in the magnetic signal caused by Cu overlayers,282 which was studies later in considerable detail in Cu films on fcc Co(100).90 With the spin manipulator all three M components can be measured. Co on W(110) was found to have up to about ten monolayers an interesting “wrinkled,” predominantly in-plane magnetization293. The mechanism of the spin-reorientation transition in Co layers on Au(111) layers on W(110) could be elucidated in great detail294. Because of the long inelastic mean free path in Cu and Au and the short inelastic mean free path in Co, the interlayer exchange coupling between Co layers through Cu and Au layers could be shown to be much more complex than deduced from macroscopic measurements. In particular, the dependence of interface roughness-induced biquadratic coupling upon film thickness and growth conditions could be demonstrated295,296. A good example of the sensitivity and flexibility of SPLEEM is the study of the spin reorientation transition of Fe–Co alloy layers on Au(111) layers on W(110)297,298. As seen in Figure 8–38 the magnetic contrast is already quite strong at 1.22 monolayers, increases only slightly with thickness, and then decreases when film approaches the spin reorientation transition at about 2.7 monolayers. During the approach of the transition a pronounced striped phase develops and the magnetization tilts increasingly but converts abruptly into large, predominantly in-plane magnetized domains. The surface has large step bunches pointing toward and away from the vapor source, which causes the transition to occur earlier or later. In lateral averaging studies this would smear out the transition so that it would appear more continuous. Many other details can be extracted from the SPLEEM images, which indicate a rather complex transition. The growth and magnetic domain structure on other W surfaces shows the crucial role that the substrate orientation plays. On a welloriented W(111) surface many small domains in various orientations
645
646
E. Bauer
are observed, indicating weak in-plane anisotropy in the Co(0001)-like layer that forms after the initial pseudomorphic growth. On a slightly misoriented surface only large domains with opposite M are observed, presumably induced by steps299. On the W(100) surface Co grows with (11–20) plane parallel to the substrate and forms long narrow and tall crystals. No magnetic signal could be obtained because the top surface of the crystals is not parallel to the substrate so that no electrons are reflected along the optical axis in the energy range in which the magnetic signal is strong300. This shows one of the limitations of SPLEEM. Another interesting and much discussed magnetic thin film system is Fe on Cu(100). This system passes through several magnetic transitions with increasing film thickness and has been studied thoroughly with SPLEEM as a function of thickness, deposition rate, and temperature301,302. Quantitative measurements allowed fitting of the data to theoretical models of the thickness dependence of the Curie temperature and of the critical behavior. The deposition rate was found to have major influence on initial film growth and magnetism. The same system, Fe/Cu(100), was used to demonstrate that SPLEEM imaging is also possible in a magnetic field perpendicular to the surface. From the images taken in fields up to ±20 Oe the hysteresis curve of the layer could be determined303. In Ni films on Cu(100) very large domains were
Figure 8–38. The spin reorientation transition in a Fe–Co alloy layer on Au(111). The top row shows the out-of-plane component of the magnetization and the bottom row the in-plane component. Electron energy 2.5 eV and diameter of field of view 10 µm.298
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM
Figure 8–39. Epitaxial Fe ribbon crystals on W(110).305
observed whose domain walls were wide enough (400 nm) to allow determination of the profile of the Néel walls304. SPLEEM can be used not only for the study of the magnetization in thin films but also for that in small particles whose domain structure is of interest in magnetic recording. Small particles with a wide range of shapes can be grown in a SPLEEM instrument on single crystal substrates either by deposition or by annealing at elevated temperatures. The shapes range from nearly isometric crystals with lateral dimensions of several 100 nm to long wires with widths down to less than 10 nm.305 Figure 8–39 illustrates an intermediate case, wide Fe ribbons on W(110). The domain structure in these crystals is determined mainly by shape and misfit strain anisotropy. Concluding this section, the strengths of SPLEEM should be emphasized once more: correlation with the microstructure, fast image acquisition compared to other magnetic imaging methods, high surface sensitivity, and easy access to all three magnetization components. References 1. Davisson, C.J. and Germer, L.H. (1927). Phys. Rev. 30, 705. 2. Bauer, E. (1962). In Fifth International Congress for Electron Microscopy (Breese, S.S., Jr. ed.), pp. D-11–12. (Academic Press, New York). 3. Telieps, W. and Bauer, E. (1985). Ultramicroscopy 17, 57. 4. Brüche, E. and Knecht, M. (1934). Z. Phys. 92, 462. 5. Mahl, H. (1939). Z. Techn. Phys. 20, 316. 6. Farnsworth, H.E. (1929). Phys. Rev. 34, 679. 7. Farnsworth, H.E. (1950). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 21, 102. 8. Schlier, R.E. and Farnsworth, H.E. (1954). J. Appl. Phys. 25, 1333 and references therein. 9. Scheibner, E.J., Germer, L.H. and Hartmann, C.D. (1960). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 31, 112. 10. Germer, L.H. and Hartmann, C.D. (1960). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 31, 784. 11. Recknagel, A. (1941). Z. Phys. 117, 689. 12. Bauer, E. (1964). J. Appl. Phys. 35, 3079. 13. Cruise, D.R. and Bauer, E. (1964). J. Appl. Phys. 35, 3080. 14. Bauer, E. (1994). Surf. Sci. 299/300, 102.
647
648
E. Bauer 15. Schmidt, T., Heun, S., Slezak, J., Diaz, J., Prince, K.C., Lilienkamp, G. and Bauer, E. (1998). Surf. Rev. Lett. 5, 1287. 16. Bauer, E. and Schmidt, T. (2003). In High Resolution Imaging and Spectroscopy of Materials (Ernst, F. and Rühle M., eds.), pp. 363–390. (Springer, Berlin). 17. Wichtendahl, R., Fink, R., Kuhlenbeck, H., Preikszas, D., Rose, H., Spehr, R., Hartel, P., Engel, W., Schlögl, R., Freund, H.-J., Bradshaw, A.M., Lilienkamp, G., Schmidt, Th., Bauer, E., Benner, G. and Umbach, E. (1998). Surf. Rev. Lett. 5, 1249. 18. Bauer, E. (1970). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. 7, 3. 19. Bauer, E. (1972). In Les interactions des électrons avec la Matière Condensée. Applications a l’etude du Solide, pp. 42–96. (AVCP, Verbier). 20. Wu, T.-Y. and Ohmura, T. (1962). Quantum Theory of Scattering, p. 4. (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ). 21. Pendry, J.B. (1974). Low-Energy Electron Diffraction. (Academic Press, London). 22. Van Hove, M.A., Weinberg, W.H. and Chan, C.-M. (1986). Low-Energy Electron Diffraction. (Springer, Berlin). 23. Seitz, F. (1940). The Modern Theory of Solids, p. 313. (McGraw-Hill, New York). 24. Herlt, H.-J. (1982). Ph.D. thesis, TU Clausthal. 25. Feibelman, P.J. and Eastman, D.E. (1974). Phys. Rev. B 10, 4932. 26. Bauer, E. (1988). In Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis (Koukal, J., ed.), pp. 26–36. (Elsevier, Amsterdam). 27. Herlt, H.-J., Feder, R., Meister, G. and Bauer, E.G. (1981). Solid State Commun. 38, 973. 28. Lundquist, B.I. (1969). Phys. Stat. Sol. 32, 273 and references therein. 29. Bauer, E. (1972). Z. Metallkde. 63, 437. 30. Bauer, E. (1975). In Interactions on Metal Surfaces (Gomer, R., ed.), pp. 225– 274. (Springer, Berlin). 31. Tanuma, S., Powell, C.J. and Penn, D.R. (1991). Surf. Interface Anal. 17, 911, 927. 32. Ding, Z.-J. and Shimizu, R. (1996). Scanning 18, 92. 33. Bauer, E. (1969). Z. Phys. 224, 19. 34. Powell, C.J. and Jablonski, A. (1999). J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 28, 19. 35. Goulet, T., Jung, J.-M., Michaud, M., Jay-Gerin, J.-P. and Sanche, L. (1994). Phys. Rev. B 50, 5101. 36. Keszei, E., Goulet, T. and Jay-Gerin, J.-P. (1988). Phys. Rev. A 37, 2183. 37. Siegmann, H.C. (1994). Surf. Sci. 307, 1076. 38. Hong, J. and Mills, D.L. (2000). Phys. Rev. B 62, 5589. 39. Bauer, E. (2005). In Magnetic Microscopy of Nanostructures (Hopster, H. and Oepen H.P., eds.), pp. 111–136. (Springer, Berlin). 40. Georgiev, N., Pavlovska, A. and Bauer, E. (1995). Phys. Rev. B 52, 2878 and references therein. 41. Rundgren, J. (1999). Phys. Rev. B 59, 5106. 42. Bartz, G. (1960). In 4th International Congress on Electron Microscopy, Vol. l, pp. 201–207. (Springer, Berlin). 43. Tromp, R.M. and Reuter, M.C. (1991). Ultramicroscopy 36, 99. 44. Veneklasen, L.H. (1991). Ultramicroscopy 36, 76. 45. Bauer, E., Franz, T., Koziol, C., Lilienkamp, G. and Schmidt, T. (1997). In Chemical, Structural and Electronic Analysis of Heterogenous Surfaces on Nanometer Scale (Rosei, R., ed.), pp. 73–84. (Kluwer, Dordrecht). 46. Bauer, E., Koziol, C., Lilienkamp, G. and Schmidt, T. (1997). J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 84, 201. 47. Bauer, E. (2001). J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 114, 975; J. Phys. Condens. Matter 13, 11391.
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM 48. Tromp, R.M., Mankos, M., Reuter, M.C., Ellis, A.W. and Copel, M. (1998). Surf. Rev. Lett. 5, 1189. 49. Adamec, P., Bauer, E. and Lencová, B. (1998). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 69, 3583. 50. Grzelakowski, K. and Bauer, E. (1996). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 67, 742. 51. Liebl, H. and Senftinger, B. (1991). Ultramicroscopy 36, 91 52. Sakai, Y., Kato, M., Masuda, S., Harada, Y. and Ichinokawa, T. (1998). Surf. Rev. Lett. 5, 1199. 53. Grzelakowski, K. (1999). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 70, 3346; Surf. Sci. 454, 1094. 54. Rose, H. and Preikszas, D. (1992). Optik 92, 31. 55. Preikszas, D., Hartel, P., Spehr, R. and Rose, H. (2000). In EUREM 12 (Cˇ iampor, P. and Frank, L., eds.), pp. I81–I84. (Czechoslovak Society of Electron Microscopy, Brno). 56. Fink, R., Weiss, M.R., Umbach, E., Preikszas, D., Rose, H., Spehr, R., Hartel, P., Engel, W., Degenhardt, R., Wichtendahl, R., Erlebach, W., Ihmann, K., Schlögl, R., Freund, H.-J., Bradshaw, A.M., Lilienkamp, G., Schmidt, Th., Bauer, E. and Benner, G. (1997). J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 84, 231. 57. Schmidt, Th., Groh, U., Fink, R., Umbach, E., Schaff, O., Engel, W., Richter, B., Kuhlenbeck, H., Schlögl, R., Freund, H.-J., Bradshaw, A.M., Preikszas, D., Hartel, P., Spehr, R., Rose, H., Lilienkamp, G., Bauer, E. and Benner, G. (2002). Surf. Rev. Lett. 9, 223. 58. Veneklasen, L.H. (1992). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 63, 5513. 59. Chmelik, J., Veneklasen, L. and Marx, G. (1989). Optik 83, 155. 60. Archard, G.D. and Mulvey, T. (1958). J. Sci. Instrum. 35, 279. 61. Manˇkosˇ, M., Kolarˇ ik, V. and Veneklasen, L.H. (1990). Nuclear Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A289, 189. 62. Kolarˇ ik, V., ManˇKosˇ , M. and Veneklasen, L.H. (1991). Optik 87, 1. 63. Degenhardt, R. (1992). Ph.D. thesis, TU Darmstadt. 64. Satchenko, V. (1999). Unpublished. 65. Kan, H.-C., Auerbach, D. and Phaneuf, R.J. (2002). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 74, 1008. 66. Kan, H.-C., Dürkop, T. and Phaneuf, R.J. (2003). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B20, 2519. 67. Müller, H., Preikszas, D. and Rose, H. (1999). J. Electron Microsc. 48, 191. 68. Spehr, R., Hartel, P., Müller, H., Preikszas, D. and Rose, H. (2000). In EUREM 12 (Cˇ iampor, P. And Frank, L., eds.), pp. I85–I86. (Czechoslovak Society of Electron Microscopy, Brno). 69. Wu, Y.K., Robin, D.S., Forest, E., Schlueter, R., Anders, S., Feng, J., Padmore, H. and Wei, D.H. (2003). Nuclear Instrum. Methods phys. Res. A519, 230. 70. Swenson, D.A. (1964). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 35, 608. 71. Tsuno, K. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 55, 127. 72. Zworykin, V.K., Morton, G.A., Ramberg, E.G., Hillier, J. and Vance, A.W. (1946). Electron Optics and the electron Microscope, pp. 29, 630, 645. (John Wiley, New York). 73. Ramberg, E.G. (1949). J. Appl. Phys. 20, 183. 74. Skoczylas, W.P., Rempfer, G.F. and Griffith, O.H. (1991). Ultramicroscopy 36, 252. 75. Preikszas, D. and Rose, H. (1992). J. Electron Microsc. 46, 1. 76. Hartel, P., Preikszas, D., Spehr, R. and Rose, H. (2000). In EUREM 12 (Cˇ iampor, P. and Frank, L., eds.), pp. I153–I154. (Czechoslovak Society of Electron Microscopy, Brno). 77. Wan, W., Feng, J., Padmore, H.A. and Robin, D.S. (2004). Nuclear Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 519, 222. 78. Cherifi, S., Hertel, R., Wang, H., Kirschner, J., Belkhou, R., Locatelli, A., Heun, S., Pavlovska, A. and Bauer, E. (2005). Appl. Phys. 98, 843–901.
649
650
E. Bauer 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. 84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99. 100. 101. 102. 103. 104. 105. 106. 107. 108. 109. 110. 111. 112. 113. 114. 115. 116.
Telieps, W. and Bauer, E. (1985). Surf. Sci. 162, 163. Telieps, W. (1987). Appl. Phys. A 44, 55. Swiech, W., Bauer, E. and Mundschau, M. (1991). Surf. Sci. 253, 283. Yasue, T., Koshikawa, T., Jalochowski, M. and Bauer, E. (2001). Surf. Sci. 493, 381. Altman, M.S., Chung, W.F. and Liu, C.H. (1998). Surf. Rev. Lett. 5, 1129. Chung, W.F. and Altman, M.S. (1998). Ultramicroscopy 74, 237. Müller, T. (1995). M.S. Thesis, TU Clausthal. Mundschau, M., Bauer, E. and Swiech, W. (1989). J. Appl. Phys. 65, 581. Zdyb, R. and Bauer, E. (2002). Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 1666403. Zdyb, R. and Bauer, E. (2002). Surf. Rev. Lett. 9, 1485. Altman, M.S. (2005). J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 17, S1305. Wu, Y.Z, Schmid, A.K., Altman, M.S., Jin, X.F. and Qiu, Z.Q. (2005). Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 027201. Altman, M.S., Chung, W.F., He, Z.Q., Poon, H.C. and Tong, S.Y. (2001). Appl. Surf. Sci. 169/170, 82. Chung, W.F., Feng, Y.J., Poon, H.C., Chan, C.T., Tong, S.Y. and Altman, M.S. (2003). Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 216105. Man, K.L., Qiu, Z.Q. and Altman, M.S. (2004). Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 236104. Witt, W. (1984). Ph.D. thesis, TU Clausthal. Bauer, E. (1987). In Structure and Dynamics of Surfaces II (Schommers, W. and von Blanckenhagen, P. eds.), pp. 115–179. (Springer, Berlin). Telieps, W. and Bauer, E. (1986). Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 90, 19. Bauer, E., Mundschau, M., Swiech, W. and Telieps, W. (1991). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 9, 1007. Phaneuf, R.J., Bartelt, N.C., Williams, E.D., Swiech, W. and Bauer, E. (1992). Surf. Sci. 268, 227. Hannon, J.B., Hibino, H., Bartelt, N.C., Swartzentruber, B.S., Ogino, T. and Kellogg, G.L. (2000). Nature 405, 552. Hibino, H., Hu, C.-W., Ogino, T. and Tsong, I.S.T. (2001). Phy. Rev. B 63, 245402. Hannon, J.B., Meyer zu Heringdorf, F.-J., Tersoff, J. and Tromp, R.M. (2001). Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 4871. Hu, C.-W., Hibino, H., Ogino, T. and Tsong, I.S.T. (2001). Surf. Sci. 487, 191. Hannon, J.B. and Tromp, R.M. (2001). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 19, 2596. Hibino, H., Hu, C.-W., Ogino, T. and Tsong, I.S.T. (2001). Phys. Rev. B 64, 245401. Hannon, J.B., Tersoff, J. and Tromp, R.M. (2002). Science 295, 299. Hannon, J.B., Tersoff, J. and Tromp, R.M. (2002). J. Crystal Growth 237, 181. Hannon, J.B., Tersoff, J., Reuter, M.C. and Tromp, R.M. (2002). Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 266103. Hibino, H., Homma, Y., Hu, C.-W., Uwaha, M., Ogino, T. and Tsong, I.S.T. (2004). Appl. Surf. Sci. 237, 51. Thayer, G.E., Hannon, J.B. and Tromp, R.M. (2004). Nature Mat. 3, 95. Tromp, R.M. and Hannon, J.B. (2002). Surf. Rev. Lett. 9, 1565. Hannon, J.B. and Tromp, R.M. (2003). Annu. Rev. Mat. Res. 33, 263. Phaneuf, R.J., Swiech, W., Bartelt, N.C., Williams, E.D. and Bauer, E. (1991). Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 2986. Williams, E.D., Phaneuf, R.J., Bartelt, N.C., Swiech, W. and Bauer, E. (1992). Mat. Res. Soc. Proc. 238, 219. Phaneuf, R.J., Bartelt, N.C., Williams, E.D., Swiech, W. and Bauer, E. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 2284. Altman, M.S., Chung, W.F. and Franz, T. (1998). Surf. Rev. Lett. 5, 27. Chung, W.F. and Altman, M.S. (2002). Phys. Rev. B 66, 075338.
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM 117. Chung, W.F., Bromann, K. and Altman, M.S. (2002). Intern. J. Mod. Phys. B 16, 4353. 118. Hibino, H. and Watanabe, Y. (2005). Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 44, 358. 119. Mundschau, M., Bauer, E., Telieps, W. and Swiech, W. (1989). Surf. Sci. 223, 413. 120. Mundschau, M., Bauer, E., Telieps, W. and Swiech, W. (1990). Phil. Mag. A 61, 257. 121. Bauer, E., Mundschau, M., Swiech, W. and Telieps, W. (1990). Vacuum 41, 5. 122. Swiech, W. and Bauer, E. (1991). Surf. Sci. 255, 219. 123. Bauer, E. (1992). Appl. Surf. Sci. 60/61, 350. 124. Tromp, R.M. and Reuter, M.C. (1992). Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 820. 125. Tromp, R.M. and Reuter, M.C. (1993). Phys. Rev. B 47, 7598. 126. Bartelt, N.C., Tromp, R.M. and Williams, E.D. (1994). Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 1656. 127. Theis, W., Bartelt, N.C. and Tromp, R.M. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 3328. 128. Theis, W. and Tromp, R.M. (1966). Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 2770. 129. Tanaka, S., Umbach, C.C. and Blakely, J.M. (1996). Appl. Phys. Lett. 69, 1235. 130. Bartelt, N.C. and Tromp, R.M. (1996). Phys. Rev. B 54, 11731. 131. Bartelt, N.C., Theis, W. and Tromp, R.M. (1996). Phys. Rev. B 54, 11741. 132. Tanaka, S., Bartelt, N.C., Umbach, C.C., Tromp, R.M. and Blakely, J.M. (1997). Phys, Rev. Lett. 78, 3342. 133. Tanaka, S., Umbach, C.C., Blakely, J.M., Tromp, R.M. and Mankos, M. (1998). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 15, 1345. 134. Tromp, R.M. and Mankos, M. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 1050. 135. Blakely, J.M., Tanaka, S. and Tromp, R.M. (1999). J. Electron Microsc. 48, 747. 136. Nielsen, J.-F., Pelz, J.P., Hibino, H., Hu, C.-W, and Tsong, I.S.T. (2001). Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 136103. 137. Zielasek, V., Liu, F., Zhao, Y., Maxson, J.B. and Lagally, M.G. (2001). Phys. Rev. B 64, 201320. 138. Wurm, K., Kliese, R., Hong, Y., Röttger, B., Wei, Y., Neddermeyer, H. and Tsong, I.S.T. (1994). Phys, Rev. B 50, 1567. 139. Hannon, J.B., Bartelt, M.C., Bartelt, N.C. and Kellogg, G.L. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 4676. 140. Hannon, J.B., Kellogg, G.L., Bartelt, M.C. and Bartelt, N.C. (1998). Surf. Rev. Lett. 5, 1151. 141. Tromp, R.M. and Reuter, M.C. (1992). Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 2313. 142. Jones, D.E., Pelz, J.P., Hong, Y, Bauer, E. and Tsong, I.S.T. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 330. 143. Hannon, J.B., Bartelt, N.C., Swartzentruber, B.S., Hamilton, J.C. and Kellogg, G.L. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 4226. 144. Hannon, J.B., Swartzentruber, B.S., Kellogg, G.L. and Bartelt, N.C. (1998), Surf. Rev. Lett. 5, 1159. 145. Nielsen, J.-F., Pelz, J.P., Hibino, H., Hu, C.-W., Tsong, I.S.T. and Kouvetakis, J. (2001). Appl. Phys. Lett. 79, 3857. 146. Sutter, P. and Lagally, M.G. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 1490. 147. Tromp, R.M., Theis, W. and Bartelt, N.C. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 2522. 148. Swiech, W., Schwarz-Selinger, Th. and Cahill, D.G. (2002). Surf. Sci. 519, L599. 149. Watanabe, F., Kodambaka, S., Swiech, W., Greene, J.E. and Cahill, D.G. (2004). Surf. Sci. 572, 425. 150. van Vroonhoven, E., Zandvliet, H.J.W. and Poelsema, B. (2003). Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 116102; 93, 159902.
651
652
E. Bauer 151 Tromp, R.M. and Reuter, M.C. (1992). Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 954. 152. Sutter, P., Mateeva, E. and Lagally, M.G. (1998). J. Vac, Sci. Technol. B 16, 1560. 153. Sutter, P. and Lagally, M.G. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 3471. 154. Sutter, P., Mateeva, E., Sullivan, J.S. and Lagally, M.G. Thin Solid Films 336, 262. 155. Ross, F.M., Tromp, R.M. and Reuter, M.C. (1999). Science 286, 1931. 156. Sutter, P. and Lagally, M.G. (2000). Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 4637. 157. Tromp, R.M., Ross, F.M. and Reuter, M.C. (2000). Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 4641. 158. Maxson, J.B., Savage, D.E., Liu, F., Tromp, R.M., Reuter, M.C. and Lagally, M.G. (2000). Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 2152. 159. Sutter, P. and Lagally, M.G. (2002). Mater. Sci. Engineer. B 89, 45. 160. Hannon, J.B., Copel, M., Stumpf, R., Reuter, M.C. and Tromp, R.M. (2004). Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 216104. 161. Tromp, R.M. and Ross, F.M. (2000). Annu. Rev. Mater. Sci. 30, 431. 162. Denier van der Gon, A.W., Tromp, R.M. and Reuter, M.C. (1993). Thin Solid Films 236, 140. 163. Yasue, T., Koshikawa, T. and Bauer, E. (2002). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 20, 2496. 164. Falta, J., Reuter, M.C. and Tromp, R.M. (1994). Appl. Phys. Lett. 65, 1680. 165. Swiech, W., Bauer, E. and Mundschau, M. (1991). Surf. Sci. 253, 283. 166. Bauer, E., Mundschau, M. and Swiech, W. (1991). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 9, 403. 167. Horn-von Hoegen, M., Meyer zu Heringdorf, F.-J., Kähler, D., Schmidt, Th. and Bauer, E. (1998). Thin Solid Films 336, 16. 168. Meyer zu Heringdorf, F.-J., Kähler, D., Horn-von Hoegen, M., Schmidt, Th., Bauer, E., Copel, M. and Minoda, H. (1998). Surf. Rev. Lett. 5, 1167. 169. Horn-von Hoegen, M., Meyer zu Heringdorf, F.-J., Hild, R., Zahl, P., Schmidt, Th. and Bauer, E. (1999). Surf. Sci. 433, 475. 170. Meyer zu Heringdorf, F.-J., Hild, R., Zahl, P., Schmidt, Th., Ressel, B., Heun, S., Bauer, E. and Horn-von Hoegen, M. (2001). Surf. Sci. 480, 103; 496, 151. 171. Denier van der Gon, A.W. and Tromp, R.M. (1992). Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 3519. 172. Tersoff, J., Denier van der Gon, A.W. and Tromp, R.M. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 1143. 173. Tromp, R.M., Denier van der Gon, A.W., LeGoues, F.K. and Reuter, M.C. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 3299. 174. Tang, W.X., Man, K.L., Huang, H., Woo, C.H. and Altman, M.S. (2002). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 20, 2492. 175. Tersoff, J. and Tromp, R.M. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 2782. 176. Michely, T., Reuter, M.C., Copel, M. and Tromp, R.M. (1994). Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 2095. 177. Tromp, R.M. and Michely, T. (1995). Nature 373, 499. 178. Li, B.Q., Swiech, W., Venables, J.A. and Zuo, J.M. (2004). Surf. Sci. 569, 142. 179. Roos, K.R., Roos, K.L., Horn-von Hoegen, M. and Meyer zu Heringdorf, F.-J. (2005). J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 17, S1407. 180. Mundschau, M., Bauer, E., Telieps, W. and Swiech, W. (1989). J. Appl. Phys. 65, 4747. 181. Yasue, T., Koshikawa, T., Jatochowski, M. and Bauer, E. (2000). Surf. Rev. Lett. 7, 595. 182. Yasue, T., Koshikawa, T., Jatochowski, M. and Bauer, E. (2001). Surf. Sci. 480, 118. 183. Yasue, T., Koshikawa, T., Jatochowski, M. and Bauer, E. (2001). Surf. Sci. 493, 381.
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM 184. Kuroiwa, N., Fukushima, Y., Rajasekar, P., Neddermeyer, H., Jatochowski, M., Bauer, E., Yasue, T. and Koshikawa, T. (2003). Surf. Interface Anal. 35, 24. 185. Michely, T., Reuter, M.C. and Tromp, R.M. (1996). Phys. Rev. B 53, 4105. 186. Schmidt, Th. and Bauer, E. (2000). Phys. Rev. B 62, 15815. 187. Schmidt, Th., Ressel, B., Heun, S., Prince, K.C. and Bauer, E. (2000). In X-Ray Microscopy: Proceedings of the 6th International Conference (Meyer-Else, W., Warwick, T. and Attwood, D., eds.). pp. 27–32. (AIP, Melville, NY). 188. Schmidt, T. and Bauer, E. (2001). Surf. Sci. 480, 137. 189. Li, L., Koziol, C., Wurm, K., Hong, Y., Bauer, E. and Tsong, I.S.T. (1994). Phys. Rev. B 50, 10834. 190. Jatochowski, M. and Bauer, E. (2001). Progr. Surf. Sci. 67, 79. 191. Jatochowski, M. and Bauer, E. (2001). Surf. Sci. 480, 109. 192. Pavlovska, A., Bauer, E. and Giessen, M. (2002). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 20, 2478. 193. Pavlovska, A. and Bauer, E. (2005). Surf. Interface Anal. 37, 110. 194. McKay, H.A. and Feenstra, R.M. (2003). Surf. Sci. 547, 127. 195. Bauer, E. (1994). Scanning Microsc. 8, 765. 196. Phaneuf, R.J., Hong, Y., Horch, S. and Bennett, P.A. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 4605. 197. Phaneuf, R.J., Hong, Y., Horch, S. and Bennett, P.A. (1999). Micron 30, 13. 198. Phaneuf, R.J., Bennett, P.A., Marsi, M., Günther, S., Gregoratti, L., Casalis, L. and Kiskinova, M. (1999). Surf. Sci. 431, 232. 199. Bennett, P.A., Lee, M.Y., Parikh, S.A., Wurm, K. and Phaneuf, R.J. (1995). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 13, 1728. 200. Bennett, P.A., Ashcroft, B., He, Z. and Tromp, R.M. (2002). J. Vac. Soc. Technol. B 20, 2500. 201. Tromp, R.M. and Reuter, M.C. (1994). Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 1236. 202. Tromp, R.M., LeGoues, F.K. and Reuter, M.C. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 2706. 203. Bauer, E., Wei, Y., Müller, T., Pavlovska, A. and Tsong, I.S.T. (1995). Phys. Rev. B 51, 17891. 204. Pavlovska, A., Bauer, E. and Smith, D.J. (2002). Surf. Sci. 496, 160. 205. Maxson, J.B., Perkins, N., Savage, D.E., Woll, A.R., Zhang, L., Kuech, T.F. and Lagally, M.G. (2000). Surf. Sci. 464, 217. 206. Pavlovska, A., Torres, V.M., Edwards, J.L., Bauer, E., Smith, D.J., Doak, R. B., Tsong, I.S.T., Thomson, D.B. and Davis, R.F. (1999). Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 176, 469. 207. Pavlovska, A. and Bauer, E. (2001). Surf. Sci. 480, 128. 208. Pavlovska, A., Bauer, E., Torres, V.M., Edwards, J.L., Doak, R.B., Tsong, I.S.T., Ramachandran, V. and Feenstra, R.M. (1998). J. Crystal Growth 189/190, 310. 209. Pavlovska, A. and Bauer, E. (2001). Surf. Rev. Lett. 8, 337. 210. Hu, Ch., Smith, D.J., Doak, R.B. and Tsong, I.S.T. (2000). Surf. Rev. Lett. 7, 565. 211. Mundschau, M., Bauer, E. and Swiech, W. (1989). Phil. Mag. A 59, 217. 212. Swiech, W., Mundschau, M. and Flynn, C.P. (1999). Appl. Phys. Lett. 74, 2626. 213. Swiech, W., Mundschau, M. and Flynn, C.P. (1999). Surf. Sci. 437, 61. 214. Mundschau, M., Swiech, W., Durfee, C.S. and Flynn, C.P. (1999). Surf. Sci. 440, L831. 215. Ondrejcek, M., Swiech, W., Yang, G. and Flynn, C.P. (2002). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 20, 2473. 216. Ondrejcek, M., Swiech, W., Durfee, C.S. and Flynn, C.P. (2003). Surf. Sci. 541, 31.
653
654
E. Bauer 217. Ondrejcek, M., Swiech, W. and Flynn, C.P. (2004). Surf. Sci. 566, 160. 218. Flynn, C.P. and Swiech, W. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 3482. 219. Flynn, C.P., Swiech, W., Appleton, R.S. and Ondrejcek, M. (2000). Phys. Rev. B 62, 2096. 220. Appleton, R.S., Swiech, W., Ondrejcek, M. and Flynn, C.P. (2003). Phil. Mag. 83, 1639. 221. Flynn, C.P., Ondrejcek, M. and Swiech, W. (2003). Chem. Phys. Lett. 378, 161. 222. Ondrejcek, M., Swiech, W., Yang, G. and Flynn, C.P. (2004). Phil. Mag. Lett. 84, 69. 223. Poelsema, B., Hannon, J.B., Bartelt, N.C. and Kellogg, G.L. (2004). Appl. Phys. Lett. 84, 2551. 224. Ondrejcek, M., Swiech, W., Rajappan, M. and Flynn, C.P. (2003). J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 15, L735. 225. Kellogg, G.L. and Bartelt, N.C. (2005). Surf. Sci. 577, 151. 226. Ondrejcek, M., Rajappan, M., Swiech, W. and Flynn, C.P. (2005). Surf. Sci. 574, 111. 227. Telieps, W., Mundschau, M. and Bauer, E. (1987). Optik 77, 93. 228. Telieps, W., Mundschau, M. and Bauer, E. (1990). Surf. Sci. 225, 87. 229. Tersoff, J., Denier van der Gon, A.W. and Tromp, R.M. (1994). Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 266. 230. Gerlach, R., Maroutian, T., Douillard, L., Martinotti, D. and Ernst, H.-J. (2001). Surf. Sci. 480, 97. 231. Altman, M.S., Chiang, S., Statiris, P., Gustafsson, T. and Bauer, E. (1994). In The Structure of Surfaces IV (Xide, X., Tong, S.Y. and van Hove, M.A., eds.), pp. 183–191. (World Scientific, Singapore). 232. Altman, M.S. and Bauer, E. (1995). Surf. Sci. 344, 51. 233. McCarty, K.F., Nobel, J.A. and Bartelt, N.C. (2001). Nature 412, 622. 234. Mundschau, M., Bauer, E. and Swiech, W. (1988). Catal. Lett. 1, 405. 235. Bauer, E. (1991). Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 95, 1311. 236. Lou, E.Z., Cai, Q., Chung, W.F., Orr, B.G. and Altman, M.S. (1996). Phys. Rev. B 54, 14673. 237. Man, I.K.H. and Altman, M.S. (2005). Surf. Interface Anal. 37, 235. 238. Aballe, L., Barinov, A., Locatelli, A., Heun, S., Cherifi, S. and Kiskinova, M. (2004). Appl. Surf. Sci. 238, 138. 239. Ling, W.L., Giessel, T., Thürmer, K., Hwang, R.Q., Bartelt, N.C. and McCarty, K.F. (2004). Surf. Sci. 570, L297. 240. Pelhos, K., Hannon, J.B., Kellogg, G.L. and Madey, T.E. (1999). Surf. Sci. 432, 115. 241. Pelhos, K., Hannon, J.B., Kellogg, G.L. and Madey, T.E. (1999). Surf. Rev. Lett. 6, 767. 242. Wu, D., Lau, W.K., He, Z.Q., Feng, Y.J., Altman, M.S. and Chan, C.T. (2000). Phys. Rev. B 62, 8366. 243. Schmid, A.K., Bartelt, N.C. and Hwang, R.Q. (2000). Science 290, 1561. 244. Kellogg, G.L. and Plass, R. (2000). Surf. Sci. 465, L777. 245. Plass, R. and Kellogg, G.L. (2000). Surf. Sci. 470, 106. 246. Kellogg, G.L. and Plass, R.A. (2000). Surf. Rev. Lett. 7, 649. 247. Plass, R., Last, J.A., Bartelt, N.C. and Kellogg, G.L. (2001). Nature 412, 875. 248. Plass, R., Bartelt, N.C. and Kellogg, G.L. (2002). J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 14, 4227. 249. van Gastel, R., Plass, R., Bartelt, N.C. and Kellogg, G.L. (2003). Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 055503. 250. van Gastel, R., Bartelt, N.C., Feibelman, P.J., Léonard, F. and Kellogg, G.L. (2004). Phys. Rev. B 70, 245413.
Chapter 8 LEEM and SPLEEM 251. Léonard, F., Bartelt, N.C. and Kellogg, G.L. (2005). Phys. Rev. B 71, 045416. 252. Kellogg, G.L. (2002). In The Chemical Physics of Solid Surfaces, Vol. 10 (Woodruff, D.P., ed.), pp. 152–183. (Elsevier, Amsterdam). 253. Altman, M.S., Cai, Q., Chung, W.F., Luo, E.Z., Pinkvos, H. and Bauer, E. (1995). Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 355, 235. 254. Luo, E.Z., Cai, Q., Chung, W.F. and Altman, M.S. (1996). Appl. Surf. Sci. 92, 331. 255. Altman, M.S. and Bauer, E. (1991). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 9, 659. 256. Altman, M.S. and Bauer, E. (1996). Surf. Sci. 347, 265. 257. Ondrejcek, M., Appleton, R.S., Swiech, W., Petrova, V.L. and Flynn, C.P. (2001). Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 116102. 258. McCarty, K.F. (2001). Surf. Sci. 474, L165. 259. Rausenberger, B., Swiech, W., Engel, W., Bradshaw, A.M. and Zeitler, E. (1993). Surf. Sci. 287/288, 235. 260. Rausenberger, B., Swiech, W., Rastomjee, C.S., Mundschau, M., Engel, W., Zeitler, E. and Bradshaw, A.M. (1993). Chem. Phys. Lett. 215, 109. 261. Schmid, A.K., Swiech, W., Rastomjee, C.S., Rausenberger, B., Engel, W., Zeitler, E. and Bradshaw, A.M. (1995). Surf. Sci. 331, 225. 262. Rausenberger, B., Swiech, W., Schmid, A.K., Rastomjee, C.S., Engel, W. and Bradshaw, A.M. (1998). J. Chem. Soc., Faraday Trans. 94, 963. 263. Rose, K.C., Berton, B., Imbihl, R., Engel, W. and Bradshaw, A.M. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 3427. 264. Wei, H., Lilienkamp, G. and Imbihl, R. (2004). Chem. Phys. Lett. 389, 284. 265. Schmidt, Th., Schaak, A., Günther, S., Ressel, B., Bauer, E. and Imbihl, R. (2000). Chem. Phys. Lett. 318, 549. 266. Marbach, H., Lilienkamp, G., Wei, H., Günther, S., Suchorski, Y. and Imbihl, R. (2003). Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 5, 2730. 267. Locatelli, A., Heun, S. and Kiskinova, M. (2004). Surf. Sci. 566, 1130. 268. McCarty, K.F. and Bartelt, N.C. (2003). Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 046104. 269. McCarty, K.F. and Bartelt, N.C. (2003). Surf. Sci. 527, L203. 270. McCarty, K.F. and Bartelt, N.C. (2003). Surf. Sci. 540, 157. 271. McCarty, K.F. (2003). Surf. Sci. 543, 185. 272. Kodambaka, S., Khare, S.V., Swiech, W., Ohmori, K., Petrov, I. and Greene, J.E. (2004). Nature 429, 49. 273. Kodambaka, S., Israeli, N., Bareño, J., Swiech, W., Ohmori, K., Petrov, I. and Greene, J.E. (2004). Surf. Sci. 560, 53. 274. Meyer zu Heringdorf, F.-J., Reuter, M.C. and Tromp, R.M. (2001). Nature 412, 517; Appl. Phys. A 78, 787. 275. Harada, Y., Yamamoto, S., Aoki, M., Masuda, S., Ichinokawa, T., Kato, M. and Sakai, Y. (1994). Nature 372, 657. 276. Yamamoto, S., Masuda, S., Yasufuku, H., Ueno, N., Harada, Y., Ichinokawa, T., Kato, M. and Sakai, Y. (1997). J. Appl. Phys. 82, 2954. 277. Lilienkamp, G., Wei, H., Maus-Friedrichs, W., Kempter, V., Marbach, H., Günther, S. and Suchorski, Y. (2003). Surf. Sci. 532, 132. 278. Pierce, D.T. (1995). In Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics (Vol. 29A of Experimental Methods in the Physical Sciences) (Dunning, F.B. and Hulet, R.G., eds.), pp. 1–38. (Academic Press, San Diego). 279. Altman, M.S., Pinkvos, H., Hurst, J., Poppa, H., Marx, G. and Bauer, E. (1991). Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 232, 125. 280. Pinkvos, H., Poppa, H., Bauer, E. and Hurst, J. (1992). Ultramicroscopy 47, 339. 281. Pinkvos, H., Poppa, H., Bauer, E. and Kim, G.-M. (1993). In Magnetism and Structure in Systems of Reduced Dimensions (Farrow, R.F.C., Dieny, B., Donath, M., Fert, A. and Hermsmeier, B.D., eds.), pp. 25–31. (Plenum Press, New York).
655
656
E. Bauer 282. Poppa, H., Pinkvos, H., Wurm, K. and Bauer, E. (1993). Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 313, 219. 283. Altman, M.S., Pinkvos, H. and Bauer, E. (1995). J. Magn. Soc. Jpn. 19(Suppl. S1), 129. 284. Bauer, E., Duden, T., Pinkvos, H., Poppa, H. and Wurm, K. (1996). J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 156, 1. 285. Duden, T. and Bauer, E. (1995). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 66, 2861. 286. Grzelakowski, K., Duden, T., Bauer, E., Poppa, H. and Chiang, S. (1994). IEEE Trans. Magnet. 30, 4500. 287. Duden, Th. and Bauer, E. (1998). Surf. Rev. Lett. 5, 1213. 288. Bauer, E. (2005). In Magnetic Microscopy of Nanostructures (Hopster, H. and Oepen, H.P., eds.), pp. 111–136. (Springer, Berlin). 289. Bauer, E. (2005). In Novel Techniques for Characterizing Magnetic Materials (Zhu, Y., ed.), pp. 361–379. (Springer, Berlin). 290. Tober, E.D., Witte, G. and Poppa, H. (2000). J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 18, 1845. 291. Duden, T. and Bauer, E. (1998). J. Electron Microsc. 47, 379. 292. Duden, T. and Bauer, E. (1999). Phys. Rev. B 59, 468. 293. Duden, T. and Bauer, E. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 2308. 294. Duden, T. and Bauer, E. (1997). Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 475, 283. 295. Duden, T. and Bauer, E. (1999). J. Magn. Magn. Mat. 191, 301. 296. Duden, T. and Bauer, E. (1999). Phys. Rev. B 59, 474. 297. Zdyb, R. and Bauer, E. (2003). Phys. Rev. B 67, 134420. 298. Zdyb, R., Locatelli, A., Heun, S., Cherifi, S., Belkhou, R. and Bauer, E. (2005). Surf. Interface Anal. 37, 239. 299. Man, K.L., Zdyb, R., Huang, S.F., Leung, T.C., Chan, C.T., Bauer, E. and Altman, M.S. (2003). Phys. Rev. B 67, 184402. 300. Duden, Th., Zdyb, R., Altman, M.S. and Bauer, E. (2001). Surf. Sci. 480, 145. 301. Man, K.L., Altman, M.S. and Poppa, H. (2001). Surf. Sci. 480, 163. 302. Man, K.L., Ling, W.L., Paik, S.Y., Poppa, H., Altman, M.S. and Qiu, Z.Q. (2001). Phys. Rev. B 65, 024409. 303. Poppa, H., Tober, E.D. and Schmid, A.K. (2002). J. Appl. Phys. 91, 6932. 304. Ramchal, R., Schmid, A.K., Farle, M. and Poppa, H. (2003). Phys. Rev. B 68, 054418. 305. Zdyb, R., Pavlovska, A., Jalochowski, M. and Bauer, E. (2006). Surf. Sci. 600, 1586. *306. Mankos, M., Adler, D., Veneklasen, L. and Munro, E. (2007). Surf. Sci. 601, 4733 (Section 4). *307. de la Figuera, J., Bartelt, N.C. and McCarty, K.F. (2006). Surf. Sci. 600, 4062 (Section 5). *308. Sadowski, J.T., Sazaki, G., Nishikata, S., Al-Mahboob, A., Fujikawa, Y., Nakajiama, K., Tromp, R.M. and Sakurai, T. (2007). Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 046104 (Section 6.5). *309. Tang, S.-J., Kodambaka, S., Swiech, W., Petrov, I., Flynn, C.P. and Chiang, T.-C. (2006). Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 126106 (Section 6.7). *310. van Gastel, R., Bartelt, N.C. and Kellogg, G.L. (2006). Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 036106 (Section 6.8). *311. Man, K.L., Feng, Y.J., Chan, C.T. and Altman, M.S. (2007). Surf. Sci. 601, L95 (Section 6.8). *312. Aballe, L., Barinov, A., Locatelli, A., Mentes, T.O. and Kiskinova, M. (2007). Phys. Rev. B 75, 115411 (Section 6.8). *313. El Gabaly, F., Gallego, S., Munos, Szunyogh, L., Weinberger, P., Klein, Ch., ˇ Schmid, K.A., McCarty, K.F. and de la Figuera, J. (2006). Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 147202 (Section 7).
*References added since the first printing.
9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM) Jun Feng and Andreas Scholl
1 Introduction 1.1 A Brief History of Photoemission Electron Microscopy Photoemission electron microscopy (PEEM) has proven to be a powerful tool in material science, surface physics and chemistry, thin film magnetism, polymer science, and biology. PEEM, also called photoelectron microscopy (PEM), is the most widely used type of emission microscopy and is closely related to the more recently developed lowenergy electron microscopy (LEEM) (Bauer, 1994). In 1905, Einstein proposed that light quanta are quantized and explained the photoelectric effect in terms of a photon’s energy to release an electron from a surface (Einstein, 1905). A photoemission electron microscope forms an image of a solid surface based on the spatial distribution of electrons emitted by the absorption of photons with energy that exceeds the sample work function. Historically, the invention of PEEM dates to the early 1930s shortly after the introduction of electron lenses. The first working photoemission electron microscope was built by Brüche in 1932 using ultraviolet (UV) light to image photoelectrons emitted from a metal (Brüche, 1932; 1933) (Knoll et al., 1932). The principal design of his PEEM is still used. In Brüche’s PEEM, UV light from a mercury lamp was focused by a quartz lens onto the sample cathode. The emitted electrons were accelerated by a potential difference of 10–30 kV between the cathode and the anode of the PEEM and focused onto a phosphor screen. At about the same time, Knoll, Hontermans, and Schulzer constructed an emission microscope using two magnetic lenses (Langmuir, 1937). The first calculation of the resolution in emission microscopy was published by Langmuir in 1937, and subsequent treatments were published by Reckangel (1941). PEEM techniques were refined and improved by Engel (1966). Engel’s PEEM achieved an order-of-magnitude increase in resolution over previous instruments and served as a prototype for the KE-3 emission microscopes developed by Wegmann in the 1970s (1972). At this time it was recognized that PEEM is a surface technique, which requires proper attention to the condition of the sample surface on an atomic scale (Engel, 1966; Griffith and Rempfer, 1987). A detailed
657
658
J. Feng and A. Scholl
description of the early history of electron lenses and electron microscopy can be found in Griffith and Engel (1991) and in Bauer (1994). In the development of PEEM, the Oregon microscope project, lead by Griffith and Rempfer, played an important role. Griffith and Rempfer built an ultrahigh vacuum UV-PEEM with a spatial resolution of 10 nm and produced a steady stream of beautiful micrographs of biological samples (Griffith and Rempfer, 1987; Rempfer and Griffith, 1989). Rempfer also investigated the spatial resolution of PEEM and the properties of electron lenses of different shape and using different operation voltages, both in experiment and in theory (Rempfer, 1985; Rempfer and Griffith, 1989). Bauer and Telieps built an electron microscope with both LEEM and PEEM modes (Telieps and Bauer, 1987). Instead of photoelectrons, the LEEM employs electron diffraction of low-energy electrons and excels at the investigation of crystalline surfaces, epitaxial films, and film growth. A relatively recent development is the use of X-rays instead of UV radiation. X-ray photoemission electron microscopy (X-PEEM) was demonstrated for the first time in 1988 by Tonner and Harp (1988). In 1993 Stöhr et al. (1993) showed that X-PEEM can image magnetic domains at high resolution. X-PEEM instrumentation has evolved rapidly during the past decade, and almost every major synchrotron facility is now home to a PEEM instrument (Anders et al., 1999; Heyderman et al., 2003; Kuch et al., 2000; Schneider and Schönhense, 2002; Wei et al., 2003). PEEM is limited in resolution by the chromatic and spherical aberrations of the electron lenses. It has been shown that an aberration corrector can improve the resolution down to 1 nm (Fink et al., 1997). Currently, two aberration-corrected X-PEEMs are under construction, the “SMART” PEEM at BESSY II (Hartel et al., 2002) and the PEEM-3 at the Advanced Light Source (Wan et al., 2004). In Section 2 we will discuss the basic layout of an X-PEEM experiment. We will also describe the image generation due to X-ray absorption and discuss contrast mechanisms with the aid of some examples. Section 3 will address the electron optics of uncorrected PEEM, and Section 4 will extend the discussion to aberration correction. Section 5 will deal with a very important application of X-PEEM: imaging of magnetic domains. The last section will introduce time-resolved X-PEEM, sometimes called TRPEEM, which is a very recent development. TR-PEEM is used to image magnetic processes on the nanoscale with picosecond time resolution.
2 X-Ray PEEM 2.1 X-Ray Sources Electron storage rings, also called synchrotrons, are today’s premier sources of polarized, intense X-rays. Synchrotron radiation is generated when relativistic electrons are deflected, for example, by a dipole magnet. The radiation, which is polarized, spans a wide range of wavelengths from micrometers (infrared) to Ångstroms (hard X-rays), and energies from millielectronvolts to kiloelectronvolts (Attwood, 2000).
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
Bending magnets or so-called insertion devices are used as X-ray sources. Radiation from a dipole or bending magnet is linearly polarized in the storage ring plane. A few degrees above and below, the radiation is right and left elliptically polarized with a high degree of circular polarization of typically 80%. In a bending magnet beamline, the polarization is chosen by a movable aperture, which masks out a vertical slice of the beam. Insertion devices, in particular undulators or elliptically polarizing undulators (EPUs), provide X-rays of much higher intensity. Undulators are multipole magnet structures that repeatedly deflect the electron beam, generating X-rays at each bend that are coherently superimposed. The magnetic structure in an EPU can be adjusted to generate radiation of variable polarization: left and right circularly polarized, linearly polarized in and perpendicular to the ring plane, and often also linearly polarized at intermediate angles. The X-rays from the storage ring are brought through an evacuated beamline to the experiment (Figure 9–1). A grating monochromator in the beamline generates a monochromatic beam with an energy resolution of typically several 100 meV. X-ray photoemission electron microscopes are mostly used in an energy range between about 100 and 2000 eV, called the soft X-ray regime, which spans the absorption edges of many important elements, in particular of the transition metal ferromagnets Fe, Co, and Ni. The X-rays are focused onto the sample using X-ray mirrors to match the X-ray spot size to the field of view of the microscope, usually a few 10s or 100s of micrometers. The electron optics of the X-PEEM experiment image the photoelectron yield of the sample with magnification onto a detector, usually a phosphor and a charge-coupled device (CCD) camera. The CCD digitizes the signal, which can later be processed by a PC. 2.2 The X-Ray Absorption and Photoemission Process When X-rays are absorbed by matter, electrons are excited from core levels into unoccupied states, leaving empty core states (Figure 9–2). Secondary electrons are excited by the decay of the core hole. Auger processes and inelastic electron scattering create a cascade of lowenergy electrons, of which some penetrate the sample surface, escape
Figure 9–1. Layout of X-ray source, beamline, and PEEM of the Advanced Light Source PEEM-2 microscope.
659
660
J. Feng and A. Scholl
E
E EF
EF
Figure 9–2. Excitation of a core electron into an empty valence state after X-ray absorption (left) and Auger decay of the core hole (right). A cascade of low-energy electrons is created, of which some escape into a vacuum and are detected.
hν
into vacuum, and are collected by the PEEM optics. A wide spectrum of electrons is emitted, with energies between the energy of the illumination and the work function of the sample. This wide electron distribution is the principal source of image aberration in the microscope since electron lenses are chromatic. In the case of X-ray illumination the distribution of the low-energy secondary electrons can be approximated by ne ∼ E/(E + W)4, where W is the work function of the material and E is kinetic energy (Tonner and Dunham, 1994). In Figure 9–3 the electron distributions after X-ray and UV illumination are compared. Note that for X-PEEM in contrast to UV-PEEM a much wider range of energies contribute to the image. Therefore X-PEEM has significantly
Figure 9–3. Energy distribution of the emitted secondary electrons excited by X-rays (solid line) and UV light (dashed line).
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
lower resolution than UV-PEEM, if no aberration corrector is used. The effective mean free path λel of the low-energy secondary electrons sets a limit to the probing depth of the technique. In metals a λel of 1.5–2 nm is typical (Nakajima et al., 1999). In polymers the effective mean free path is at least twice as large (Ohara et al., 1999; Zharnikov et al., 2002). Image contrast can still be obtained through cover layers with a thickness of up to about three times the effective mean free path. The total electron emission of the sample is proportional to the X-ray absorption coefficient averaged over the probed thickness. PEEM images the lateral electron emission and thereby maps the local X-ray absorption of the sample as a function of X-ray energy. Local X-ray absorption spectra are obtained by monitoring the local image intensity while scanning the X-ray energy. Therefore, X-PEEM is called a spectromicroscopy technique. PEEM is also a full-field imaging technique, and spectra from many image points are taken in parallel. 2.3 Image Contrast in X-PEEM Contrast in X-PEEM arises from the element-, chemistry-, and magnetism-specific absorption of different materials. Magnetic contrast will be discussed in Section 5. Two other contrast mechanisms, work function contrast and topographic contrast, appear using both X-ray and UV radiation. Work function contrast is particularly strong if a UV source is used with energy between the work function of two materials that are present at the sample surface. Only the area with low work function emits electrons and appears bright. Topographic contrast arises from rough or structured surfaces. Topographic features shape the electrical potential close to the sample and lead to electron deflection, electron focusing, and defocusing. Usually, experimenters seek to minimize topographic contrast by preparing smooth samples, e.g., single crystals, polished surfaces, or films grown on flat substrates, because sample roughness can lower the image resolution. 2.3.1 Elemental Contrast Elemental contrast is a consequence of the large enhancement (by factors of 10 and more) of the X-ray absorption right above core-level absorption edges, compared to the absorption below the edge. Resonant absorption into valence states can further increase the absorption at particular photon energies. By tuning the photon energy to a specific absorption edge, areas that predominantly contain that particular element light up in the X-PEEM image. K edges of light elements from C to Si, L edges of transition metals from Ti to Zn and of main group elements from Ca to Br, and M edges of rare-earth metals from La to Yb can be studied with soft X-rays. The technologically most important magnetic elements, the transition metals Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, and Ni and the rare-earth metals Sm, Eu, Gd, and Tb, have absorption edges between 570 and 1300 eV, at which magnetism can be measured easily and quantitatively, as will be discussed later. The ultimate frontier of PEEM is the imaging and spectroscopy of nanoscale objects. Although current instruments do not yet possess the ability to spatially resolve a nanometer object, the high sensitivity of PEEM allows us to detect the signal from a single nanoobject, if it is
661
662
J. Feng and A. Scholl Figure 9–4. High-resolution micrograph of 10-nm iron oxide clusters (γ-Fe2O3) imaged by X-PEEM at the Fe edge. Below: local absorption spectra acquired at a cluster position (I) and on the substrate (II). [Reprinted with permission from Rockenberger et al. (2002). Copyright 2002 by the American Institute of Physics.]
sufficiently separated in space from neighboring objects. As an example for the sensitivity of X-PEEM and for elemental contrast imaging, measurements of 10-nm γ-F2O3 clusters are shown in Figure 9–4 (Rockenberger et al., 2002). Clusters that were brought onto HF-etched Si wafers from solution were studied. Images of these clusters were obtained by subtracting a background image acquired before the Fe L edge from an image acquired on the Fe L3 peak (at 710 eV). This oftenused difference method augments the signal originating from a particular element. Individual clusters are visible as light dots. Local spectra acquired from a single cluster (I) and the clean substrate (II) show a clear Fe signal from a single cluster but only background from the surrounding area.
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
663
2.3.2 Chemical Contrast The fine structure, which is superimposed onto the step-like increase in the absorption at photon energies close to the absorption edge, is called near edge X-ray absorption fine structure, or NEXAFS. NEXAFS is selective regarding the electronic structure and chemical environment of the atom that absorbed the X-ray photon (Stöhr, 1992). This chemical and electronic sensitivity is due to the fact that close to the absorption edge photoexcited core electrons are excited into and therefore probe valence states. The density of these states is determined by the electronic band structure and therefore the electronic, chemical, and magnetic properties of the material. In hydrocarbons spectral features can often be associated with particular bonds and molecular orbitals, allowing a fingerprint analysis of spectra (Stöhr, 1992; Urquhart et al., 1999). In inorganic compounds, the NEXAFS spectrum is often used to determine oxidization states. Figure 9–5 shows Fe and Mn images and spectra of a manganese nodule found on the floor of the deep ocean. Regions that are rich in a material containing Mn and Fe ions appear brighter, when imaged at energies that are specific for the oxidization states of ions. Local spectra acquired in selected regions distinguish the materials that dominate in the core and rim region of the studied growth band, providing information about the genesis of the material (Smith et al., 2003).
10µm 1
2
3 Mn2+ – 638.8 eV 0.35
0.30 Rim exterior Rim interior Core region
0.25 0.20
Mn L2,3
0.15
Rim interior Core region
0.25
0.10 0.05
Intensity (arb.units)
0.30 Intensity (arb.units)
Fe3+ – 707.5 eV
Mn3+ – 642.2 eV
0.20 0.15
Fe L3
0.10 0.05 0.00
0.00 635
640 645 Photon Energy (eV)
650
655
700
705 710 Photon Energy (eV)
715
Figure 9–5. Chemical imaging of a manganese nodule from the ocean floor. X-PEEM micrographs and spectra show areas with different Fe and Mn oxidization states. [Reprinted with permission from Smith et al. (2003).35 Copyright 2003 by EDP Sciences.]
664
J. Feng and A. Scholl
3 Uncorrected PEEM Microscopes Most photoemission electron microscopes have some common characteristics. Modern microscopes use at least three lenses—an objective, an intermediate, and a projective lens—to achieve optimum resolution and magnification. The outline of the electron optics is sketched in Figure 9–6. Some microscopes use magnetic or compound magnetic–electrostatic lenses, but here a microscope based on simple electrostatic lenses will be described. The sample, which is illuminated by UV or X-ray radiation, is located in front of an immersion objective lens. In contrast to light microscopes, the sample is an integral part of the first electrostatic lens of the imaging system. The design of the sample stage in a PEEM is critical. Any vibration or drift is magnified by the optics and reduces the microscope resolution. Significant misalignment of the sample causes coma and also a loss of resolution. The sample–objective lens optics consist of two parts: an acceleration field and a unipotential lens. A strong acceleration field of about 20 kV over 2 mm accelerates the electrons between the sample and the first electrode of the objective lens. The strong acceleration limits the relative energy spread and the angular spread of the electrons that are transported into the microscope. The objective lens together with a contrast aperture in the back focal plane determines the resolution and transmission of the system. By choosing different aperture sizes, resolution can be traded for microscope
Figure 9–6. Schematic electron optical layout of a photoemission electron microscope.
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
transmission. A multipole stigmator–deflector is located close to the back focal plane of the objective lens to compensate astigmatism and alignment errors. The intermediate lens and projective lens transfer and magnify the image onto a microchannel plate or a phosphor screen. This phosphor transforms the electron into a visible image, which is captured by a CCD camera. 3.1 The Objective Lens The objective lens is the most important component of the electron optical system. Triode and tetrode cathode lenses have been used. Chmelik et al. compared several types of cathode lenses (Chmelik et al., 1989). Rempfer et al. analyzed different objective lens types based on extensive electron optical bench measurements (Rempfer et al., 1999; Rempfer and Griffith, 1989). The lens evaluation occurs in four steps: (1) calculation of the field distribution of the lens, (2) calculation of the electron trajectories and the electron optical properties, (3) evaluation of the interaction of the lens with other parts of the electron optics, and (4) tolerance analysis in regard to mechanical errors. Often an analytical treatment is not possible and numerical methods must be used, which benefit from the rapid progress in computer technology. A charged particle optics (CPO) program was developed by Read for solving charged particle optics problems using the surface charge method (Harting and Read, 1976).* Munro has developed a series of electron optics programs using the finite element method (Hawkes, 1973; Orloff, 1997). Perhaps the most popular program used in electron optics is SIMION 3D (http:// www.simion.com) which was developed by Dahl (Dahl, 2000). SIMION is an electrostatic and magnetic field modeling program that solves the field using a finite element method and traces the motion of electrons using a fourth-order Range-Kutta integrator. Figure 9–7 shows the equipotential contours of a tetrode objective lens, calculated using SIMION. The acceleration field is approximately uniform in the vicinity of the optical axis except close to the anode aperture. The aperture acts as a thin diverging lens (Rempfer and Griffith, 1989; Davisson and Calbrick, 1932). The objective lens can be characterized by the trajectory of the principal rays, the field ray and the axial ray (Figure 9–8). The calculation treats the electrodes as a single lens because the fields overlap, but it is instructive to describe the objective lens optics as being composed of (1) the accelerating field, (2) a weak diverging lens, and (3) a unipotential lens. The acceleration field forms a virtual image at unit magnification at twice the sample distance l. The weak diverging lens created by the aperture of the first electrode forms another virtual image at distance 3/l behind the sample. It is demagnified by M = 2/3. Finally, the unipotential lens forms a real image with a typical magnification of M = 10–40 (Anders et al., 1999; Schneider and Schöhense, 2002; Watts et al., 1997). * Student versions of the program are available at no coot from http://www. electronoptics.com/.
665
666
J. Feng and A. Scholl
Figure 9–7. Equipotential contours of the electric field of an electrostatic PEEM objective lens at 20 kV sample voltage.
3.2 The Intermediate and Projective Lens The intermediate and projective lenses magnify the image of the objective lens without distortion to reach a final magnification typically between 30 and 4000. The angle and energy-dependent aberrations of the intermediate and projective lenses are negligible because the energy and angular spread of the electron beam are small here. However, the distortion aberrations need to be minimal because the object size after magnification by the objective lens is significant, fractions of a millimeter or more. Therefore, the intermediate and projective lenses are designed to work at minimum focal length. As the excitation of the electrostatic lens is increased, its focal length decreases and the object side focal point enters the lens field. The distortion coefficient can reach zero at minimum focal length. This type of lens has been examined in detail by Rempfer et al. (1991) who studied rotationally symmetric, three electrode, unipotential lenses (Figure 9–9). The term unipotential means that the image and object side electrodes are on the same potential. Important lens parameters are the thickness of the center electrode t, the interelectrode spacing S, the diameter of the center electrode D, the diameter of the end electrode aperture A, and the radius of the center electrode R. Starting with parameters chosen from diagrams
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
Figure 9–8. Principal electron rays in an objective lens: dashed line, axial ray; solid line, field ray; F, back focal plane; I, image plane.
Figure 9–9. Electrode geometry of a symmetric unipotential lens.
667
668
J. Feng and A. Scholl
published by Rempfer (1985), the lens properties can be optimized for a particular application using numerical methods. 3.3 Transmission and Spatial Resolution of PEEM The microscope transmission and spatial resolution determine the quality of a PEEM. Bauer (1991) has used these two quantities to define a quality factor. The spatial resolution determines how well spatial details are preserved, and the transmission determines the noise level in an image and the acquisition speed (Jacobsen et al., 1992; Schneider, 1998). The sample is an integral part of PEEM optics, and the optimum resolution can be achieved only on ideally flat surfaces. The effects of roughness and sample tilt have been previously discussed (Marcus, 2001; Nepijko et al., 2000). 3.3.1 Transmission The microscope transmission is defined as the fraction of emitted electrons that reaches the detector. To reduce aberrations most microscopes contain several apertures of different size that can be moved into the electron beam. Thus transmission can be traded for resolution. The aperture confines the electron beam to the paraxial region and can also limit the energy acceptance of the microscope. Using E/(E + wf)4 for the electron energy distribution for a work function wf and using Lambert’s law for the electron angular distribution, the transmission of PEEM can be evaluated in a simple closed form T = 1−
1 [1 + ( a/f i* )2 (U/W f )]2
(1)
Here, a is the aperture radius, U is the sample potential, and fi* is the image side focal length of the objective lens. A high sample potential and a large aperture improve transmission, whereas a long focal length and large work function reduce transmission (Feng et al., 2002). Figure 9–10 shows SIMION simulations of the angle and energy distribution of the electrons transmitted through apertures of different size. Every point represents one electron. Both the energy spread and the transmission decrease with decreasing aperture size. Note that high-energy, paraxial electrons still pass through the aperture. The resolution is dominated by electron diffraction when the aperture size is lowered beyond a certain minimum value. Therefore, apertures with a diameter larger than 10 µm are usually used. 3.3.2 Spatial Resolution The spatial resolution of microscopes is characterized by a spread function. The spread function describes the microscope image of a chromatic point source and a diverging electron beam. Diffraction, spherical, and chromatic aberrations are regarded as independent contributions and are added quadratically. The total resolution is given by rtot = rs2 + rc2 + rd2
(2)
where the third-order spherical aberration is defined as rs = Csα3
(3)
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
Figure 9–10. SIMION simulations of the angle and energy distribution of the emitted electrons that are accepted by X-PEEM when apertures of different size are used. (a–d) The angle; (e–h) the energy distribution.
the first-order chromatic aberration is defined as rc = CcαδE/(E)
(4)
and the diffraction disk is defined as rd = 0.61λ/α
(5)
669
670
J. Feng and A. Scholl
Figure 9–11. Measured (black dots) and calculated (solid line) modulation transfer function (MTF) of PEEM-2 at the Advanced Light Source.
Here, Cs and Cc are the spherical and chromatic aberration coefficients, λ and E are the electron wavelength and the electron energy, δE is the electron energy spread, and α is the half angle of the pencil beam passing the back focal plane aperture. Though Eqs. (2)–(5) can be easily solved, the results are often misleading because the contributions of aberrations and diffraction are not Gaussian and therefore the equations give only a rough estimate of the microscope resolution. An alternate way of characterizing the spatial resolution is by determining the spatial frequency transfer of the microscope. The intensity distribution of an image produced by a point object under incoherent illumination is called the impulse response function h(x, y). The object intensity distribution f(x, y) and the image intensity distribution g(x, y) are related by the convolution equation g( x ,y ) = ∫∫ f ( x1 , y1 )h( x − x1 , y − y1)dx1 dy1
(6)
After a Fourier transformation one obtains G( fx, f y) = F( fx, f y) ⋅ H( fx, f y)
(7)
G, F, and H are Fourier transforms of g(x, y), f(x, y), and h(x, y). The function H( fx, fy) is the complex optical transfer function (OTF), with real and imaginary parts OTF( f ) = |H( fx, fy)|eiφ( f )
(8)
The real part |H( fx, fy)| is called the modulation transfer function or MTF, and the function φ( f ) is called the phase transfer function.
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
Experimentally, the MTF is measured as the contrast with which spatial frequencies of an object are transferred to an image. Higher frequencies correspond to smaller object features. Figure 9–11 shows the measured and calculated MTF of PEEM-2 at the Advanced Light Source using an extraction field of 20 kV and a 12-µm aperture (Doran et al., in preparation). It starts with unity modulation transfer at low frequencies and gradually drops at higher spatial frequencies. A transfer of 1 indicates that the spatial detail of an object at that frequency is perfectly transferred, while zero transfer indicates a complete loss of information. Values between 0 and 1 indicate partial transfer of spatial frequencies and a reduced contrast. The Rayleigh criterion for spatial resolution is equivalent to a 9% contrast transfer, which is reached for a frequency corresponding to a feature size of 35 nm. Often a higher contrast is required in experiments. At about 80 nm PEEM-2 reaches 40% contrast transfer. The agreement between experiment and simulation over a wide spatial frequency range confirms the accuracy of the simulation.
4 Aberration-Corrected PEEM Microscopes The improvements in resolution of light and electron microscopes over the past two centuries are compared in Figure 9–12 (Rose, 1994). At the beginning of the twentieth century the light microscope had reached its best resolution after the invention of aberration correction by Abbe, using a combination of a concave and a convex lens, called an achromat lens. The electron microscope soon surpassed the resolution of optical microscopes because of the much smaller wavelength of kilovolt elec-
Figure 9–12. History of microscopy techniques and evolution of spatial resolution. Shown are significant steps in the development of optical microscopy, electron microscopy, and X-PEEM. (From Rose, 1994).
671
672
J. Feng and A. Scholl
trons, effectively removing the effect of diffraction, if electrons of sufficiently high energy are used. Today, the electron microscope has not reached the diffraction limit and lens aberrations still dominate. Among these aberrations, astigmatism, coma, and field distortions can either be easily corrected or they are small close to the optical axis of the microscope*. Early in the development of electron optics theory, Scherzer showed that simple electron lenses always suffer from two other important aberrations: chromatic and spherical aberrations (Scherzer, 1936). The electron-optical analogue to a light-optical achromat does not exist. Different approaches have been tried to remove these aberrations by relinquishing one of the conditions of Scherzer’s theorem, which applies only to simple lenses (Hawkes et al., 1996). Multipole aberration correctors, which use a nonrotationally symmetric field, have been successfully used in a low-voltage scanning electron microscope (SEM) (Zach and Haider, 1998), in transmission electron microscopes (TEMs) (Haider et al., 1995, 1998), and in scanning transmission electron microscopes (STEMs) (Dellby et al., 2001; Batson et al., 2002). X-PEEM has much larger aberration coefficients than SEM or TEM, because of the large energy width of the secondary electron distribution, the low initial electron energy, and the large field of view. Therefore, the aberrations of X-PEEM are corrected using an electron mirror, which has approximately opposite chromatic and spherical aberrations of the objective lens. 4.1 Aberrations of an Electron Lens The electron trajectories in an electron lens are affected by spherical and chromatic aberrations (Figure 9–13). The Gaussian image plan is defined as the intersection of the paraxial ray with the optic axis. The spherical aberration refers to the variation of the focal distance with the angle of a ray from the paraxial ray. An electron passing the lens far from its center experiences a higher field and is focused more strongly. The focus lies before the image plane. The chromatic aberration refers to the variation of the focal distance with the electron energy. Slower electrons experience the field for a longer time and are focused more strongly. The focus lies before (slow electrons) or behind (fast electrons) the image plane. Figure 9–14 shows the resolution of a typical X-PEEM with a 2-mm acceleration gap and 20-kV acceleration field for a 4-eV work function, broken down according to the source of the aberration. Dominant are the aberration caused by the accelerating field and the chromatic aberration of the lens. Although the resolution can be improved by using a very small aperture, the usefulness of this approach is limited because of the severe reduction in microscope transmission and the onset of diffraction at very small aperture sizes. An ultimate resolution of close to 20 nm has been achieved in several instruments (Anders et al., 1999; De Stassio et al., 1999; Bauer, 1997; Schönhense and Spiecker, 2002). * A simple electrostatic lens is rotational symmetric, uses static fields, is space charge free, and the electronic lenses does not reverse its direction.
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
Figure 9–13. Illustration of spherical (top) and chromatic (bottom) aberrations of an electron lens.
Figure 9–14. Contributions of various aberrations to the total resolution limit on uncorrected PEEM. Sample voltage 20 kV, gap = 2 mm, work function wf = 4 eV. tot, total aberration; acc, aberration of accelerating field; chr, chromatic aberration of objective lens; sph, spherical aberration of objective lens; diff, contribution of diffraction.
673
674
J. Feng and A. Scholl
Aberration correction promises to significantly improve the ultimate resolution beyond this limit and also to increase the transmission of X-PEEM at moderate resolution by a factor of 100 (Bauer, 2001). 4.2 An Aberration-Corrected Microscope Using an Electron Mirror The idea of using an electron mirror to correct the chromatic and spherical aberration of a round lens dates back more than half a century (Zworykin and Kosma, 1945; Ramberg, 1949). Extensive studies of electron mirrors have been performed by Kel’man (1973, 1974), Dodin (1981), Rempfer (1990, 1992, 1997), Shao (1990a, 1990b), and Rose (1995, 1997), and co-workers. An electron mirror uses a reflecting electrode with a sufficiently high negative potential to reverse the propagation direction of the electron beam. In 1990, Shao and Wu proposed using an electron mirror with more than two electrodes to be able to freely adjust the aberration coefficients.73 Through numerical analysis of a fourelectrode electric mirror, they showed that spherical and chromatic aberrations can be adjusted electrically without changing the image distance of the mirror. Later, a more sophisticated theoretical model using a time-dependent perturbation method was developed by Rose and Preikszas (1995) to fully understand the mirror system. Integral expressions for the aberration coefficients of an electron mirror were derived and higher order aberrations were studied. Currently, two aberration-corrected PEEM microscopes using electron mirrors are being built. The first is called SMART (SpectroMicroscope for All Relevant Techniques) in Germany and has been designed as an ultrahigh-resolution spectromicroscope for BESSY II, Germany (Fink et al., 2003). The second is called PEEM-3 at the Advanced Light Source, USA, and has been designed for the study of magnetic materials and polymers. Both microscopes rely on the correction of chromatic and spherical aberrations using a hyperbolic electron mirror, which was pioneered by Rempfer and co-workers (1997). Here, we will focus on the electron optical system of the aberration-corrected PEEM-3 experiment, although many aspects of the two aberration-corrected microscopes are similar and are based on the Rose design. Figure 9–15 shows a schematic overview of the electron optics of PEEM-3. The electrons travel through the microscope along the dashed lines. The objective lens, together with the field lens, forms a telescopic round lens system. This allows the mirror to run in the so-called symmetric mode in which first-order chromatic distortion and third-order coma vanish and curvature of field effect is reduced (Rose and Preikszas, 1992). A set of two electric dodecapoles steers the beam into the magnetic separator and corrects astigmatism. For a single deflection of 90°, the beam separator images its entrance plane 1 : 1 onto its exit plane, without introducing aberrations of second order or dispersion of the first or second degree. The electron mirror images the mirror-side exit plane of the beam separator back onto itself. To cancel coma generated by the mirror, the magnification of the mirror is chosen to be −1 (Wan et al., 2004). The separator then transfers the aberration-corrected image to the projector optics, which magnify the image. A pair of electromagnetic dodecapoles in the mirror arm steers the beam into the mirror and back into the separator. A CCD camera behind the mirror is
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
675
Figure 9–15. Layout of the aberration-corrected PEEM-3 at the Advanced Light Source. An electron mirror is used as an aberration corrector.
used as a diagnostic to test and optimize the objective lens and the first half of the beam separator. In this operation mode, the mirror acts as a unipotential lens and the electron beam passes though a 500-µm hole in the reflecting electrode. The PEEM-3 electron mirror has four rotationally symmetric electrodes, and the reflecting electrode is a segment of a sphere with a radius of 5.6 mm. The inner electrode is held at ground voltage, while the potentials of the other electrodes provide three free knobs to set the focal length, the chromatic aberration correction, and the spherical aberration correction of the mirror. Figure 9–16 shows the equipotential distribution and correction region of the mirror. This region is sufficiently large to correct the microscope aberrations in various modes of operation. 4.3 The Beam Separator The task of the magnetic beam separator is to separate the aberrationcorrected beam leaving the mirror from the beam that enters the mirror. A separator with very small aberrations is critical for the performance of an aberration-corrected PEEM microscope. Two different separator designs have been considered and are currently being implement. The SMART microscope uses a triple-bend achromat optic in each of the four sectors of the separator magnet, which has a side length of 280 mm. The route to this type of separator was first identified by Rose and Preikszas77 and further developed in the work of Müller et al. (1999) and Wu et al. (2004). The design uses a highly symmetric beam path to cancel a maximum number of aberrations. It is very compact but
676
J. Feng and A. Scholl
Figure 9–16. Aberration correction by a tetrode electron mirror. Left panel, equipotential contours. Right panel, aberration region that can be corrected by the mirror.
poses high demands on tolerances, and on mechanical and electrical stability (Hartel et al., 2002). Figure 9–17 shows the 90° beam separator that will be used in the Advanced Light Source PEEM-3. The separator consists of three round
Figure 9–17. Schematic layout and principal rays in the x–z (top) and y–z (bottom) plane of one 90° sector of the PEEM-3 separator. Two 90° bends transport the beam into the mirror and back to the projector optics. One dipole (DI), two round lenses (RL), and four quadrupoles (EQ) are used.
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
lenses, one dipole magnet, and six electrostatic quadrupoles. Round lenses are chosen to be the main focusing optics. Weak electrostatic quadrupoles are used to form a stigmatic image after each 90° bend. Each 90° bend is mirror symmetric about the center and acts as a telescope in the x–z and the y–z plane. The linear dispersion and the second-order axial aberrations, which are not corrected within each 90° bend, cancel to zero after the second pass through the separator, because of the negative unity magnification of the mirror. Calculations show that the chromatic and spherical aberrations of PEEM-3 and the SMART separator are of the same order (Wan et al., in preparation). The PEEM-3 beam separator uses electrostatic lenses instead of fringe fields for image focusing and is robust regarding the details of the magnetic field in the separator. A simple dipole magnet can be used, and the demands on the power supply stability and mechanical tolerances are relatively low. 4.4 Resolution and Transmission of an Aberration-Corrected PEEM Aberration correction significantly improves both the spatial resolution and the transmission. The resolution of PEEM-3 was modeled in a way similar as that of PEEM-2. An ensemble of electrons with different initial energy and emission angles was sent through a model of the electron optics, intensity weighted with the probability of each emission energy and angle. The diffraction effect was calculated for each electron in the ensemble and the result was summed up to yield the point-spread function. The resolution was defined as the distance between the 15th percentile and 85th percentile of the point-spread function. The resolution and transmission of PEEM-3 are shown in Figure 9–18 in comparison with the uncorrected PEEM-2 (Feng et al., 2004). PEEM-3 is designed to have two main operation modes, a high-esolution mode and a highflux mode. Operating at 20 kV and 2 mm working distance, the resolu-
Figure 9–18. Comparison of calculated resolution versus transmission of the Advanced Light Source PEEM-2 and PEEM-3. The acceleration potential is 20 kV and the sample–lens distance is 2 mm.
677
678
J. Feng and A. Scholl
tion for 100% transmission (no aperture used) reaches 50 nm using the mirror corrector, a significant improvement over PEEM-2, which reaches only 440 nm. Using a small aperture the optimum resolution will be 5 nm at 2% transmission, as opposed to 20 nm at 1% transmission for PEEM-2. For any chosen spatial resolution, a significantly larger aperture can be used, resulting in a large increase in efficiency over PEEM-2. An aberration-corrected X-PEEM such PEEM-3 will have significantly improved ultimate resolution and transmission, key attributes for the imaging of nanostructures (Bauer, 2001a, 2001b).
5 Application: Magnetic Domain Imaging Magnetic materials have applications in key areas of information technology, mainly because of low cost and nonvolatility, the ability to retain information without a power source. Magnetic hard disks are the dominant technology in data storage. New applications for magnetic materials emerge when magnetic and electronic properties are concurrently utilized (Wolf et al., 2001), for example, in magnetic random access memory (MRAM) chips. Magnetic storage technology relies on structures with lateral dimensions of well below 1 µm2. The storage density on commercial hard disks in 2004 was about 60 Gbit/ in2, corresponding to an area of 0.01 µm2 per bit. At a typical bit aspect ratio of about 10 : 1 this corresponds to a bit length of 30 nm and a track width (or bit width) of 300 nm. In demonstrations and in some products even smaller dimensions have been reached. Progress in device development, and also in the fundamental understanding of the properties of magnetic material, depends on our ability to characterize magnetic materials on a nanoscale. 5.1 Magnetic Circular and Linear Dichroism X-ray magnetic circular dichroism (XMCD) is a standard method to study magnetic thin films and surfaces (Rortright et al., 1999). The wide availability of polarized and tunable X-rays from synchrotron sources has played an important role in the success of X-ray dichroism techniques. In the past 15 years there has been great progress following the first XMCD spectroscopy measurements at the important transition metal L edges in 1987 by Schütz et al. (1987), the first imaging of ferromagnetic domains in 1993 by Stöhr et al. (1993), and the first imaging of antiferromagnetic domains by Stöhr et al. (1999) and Scholl et al. (2000). Circularly polarized X-rays measure the direction of the atomic magnetic moment of a ferromagnet relative to the polarization vector of the X-rays. In the presence of spin orbit interaction the photon angular momentum is transferred to the angular momentum of the photoexcited electron, in particular the electron spin, which senses the different density of empty states in each spin channel. An imbalance of the occupation of the majority and minority states is characteristic for a ferromagnet. Strong XMCD effects (up to 40%) appear at the L edges (2p → 3d transition) of the transition metal ferromagnets Fe, Co, and Ni, since the d states carry most of the magnetic moment. The XMCD spectrum is defined as the difference spectrum of two absorption
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
spectra acquired with either opposite polarization or opposite magnetization. The XMCD effect is opposite in sign at the L3 and L2 edge because of the opposite sign of the spin-orbit coupling in the 2p states: l + s for 2p3/2, and l − s for 2p1/2. The different coupling gives rise to a unique feature of XMCD, its ability to separate spin and orbital moment. The spin momentum is proportional to the difference of the integrated XMCD intensity at the L3 and the L2 edge and the orbital momentum is proportional to the sum. Sum rules have been developed that are used to quantitatively determine the spin and orbital magnetic moment per atom (Thole et al., 1992; Wu et al., 1992; Carra et al., 1993). The angle and magnetization dependence of XMCD in the total absorption signal is approximately given by IXMCD ∼ cos α〈M〉T, with α denoting the angle between the X-ray helicity vector Ε (parallel to the X-ray propagation direction) and the magnetization Μ. Figure 9–19 shows X-ray absorption spectra of a Co film, which was magnetized parallel (solid line) and antiparallel (dotted line) to the X-ray polarization. The spectra were obtained by measuring the drain current on the sample using a sensitive picoammeter. The drain current is also called total electron yield (TEY) because it is equal to the total number of electrons that leave the sample in response to the photoexcitation. In the lower part of Figure 9–19, the XMCD difference spectrum is shown. Linearly polarized X-rays probe the anisotropy of the electronic and magnetic structure and are particularly useful for the study of antiferromagnets, which do not possess a macroscopic ferromagnetic moment. In an antiferromagnet with a collinear magnetic structure, linearly polarized X-rays distinguish between a linear polarization vector
Figure 9–19. Co X-ray magnetic circular dichroism (XMCD) spectra acquired for a magnetization M parallel (dotted line) and antiparallel (solid line) to the X-ray polarization σ. At the bottom the difference spectrum is shown.
679
680
J. Feng and A. Scholl
aligned with the magnetic spin axis and a linear polarization vector perpendicular to the magnetic spin axis (Ruiper et al., 1993; Alders et al., 1998; Lüning et al., 2003). In transition metal oxides, such as NiO, CoO, Fe2O3, Fe3O4, LaFeO3, and others, an X-ray magnetic linear dichroism (XMLD) of up to 10% has been observed. Linearly polarized X-rays probe the angle α between the linear X-ray polarization vector Ε and : the orientation of the magnetization axis A. The angle and magnetization dependence of the XMLD intensity is approximately given by IXMLD ∼ (1 − 3 cos2 α)〈M2〉T. Here 〈M2〉T is the statistical average of the squared moment at the temperature T. 5.2 Imaging of Ferromagnetic Domains A subtle balance of energies in a magnetic material causes the formation of magnetic domains. Contributions to the total energy are the exchange energy, the magnetic anisotropy, and the dipolar energy. Dipolar fields are the driving force behind domain creation. Domains minimize the magnetic stray field leaving the sample and therefore minimize the dipolar energy. Exchange and anisotropy fields resist domain formation because they usually favor aligned spins. In magnetic thin films interface effects such as interface exchange coupling, interlayer coupling, and interface anisotropy alter this delicate balance and lead to new magnetic phases. Transitions between different magnetic phases occur as a function of film thickness, interlayer thickness, magnetic field, and temperature, and are extensively studied because of the interesting physics underlying the often complex phase diagrams. High-resolution magnetic imaging is an important tool to study magnetic domains and phase transitions. X-ray techniques are especially powerful because they allow us to separate the magnetic state of individual layers in a multilayer, using element-specific imaging. For a review of domain imaging using X-PEEM see Schneider and Schönhense (2002). As an example, the in- versus out-of-plane transition of a thin facecentered cubic (fcc) Fe film on a five-monolayer Ni/Cu(001) substrate is visualized in Figure 9–20 (Wu et al., 2004). The Ni layer produced an in-plane exchange field that lowered the critical thickness at which the Fe spin reorientation occurred to about 2.6 monolayers. The experiments were conducted on an Fe wedge, which was grown under ultrahigh-vacuum (UHV) conditions. The shown images were acquired in the transition region of in- and out-of-plane magnetization. XMCD images were obtained by dividing a PEEM image taken at the Fe L3 edge by an image taken at the L2 edge. Since the magnetic dichroism has an opposite sign at these edges, the procedure enhanced the magnetic contrast and suppressed nonmagnet effects. Below the transition thickness, stripe domains formed, which had an out-of-plane magnetization. Approaching the transition, these domains shrank in size. Large in-plane domains appeared above the transition thickness. The experimentally observed thickness dependence of the stripe domain width could be explained within a theoretical model that took into account the exchange interaction, the anisotropy, the dipolar field, and the virtual field created by the Ni layer (Wu et al., 2004).
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM) 2.4 ML
2.6 ML
2.8 ML
50 µm
(b) 10 µm
Domain width (µm)
(a) 6
(c)
5 4 3 2 1 0 2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
2.7
Fe thickness (ML)
Figure 9–20. (a) Fe stripe domain structure in Fe/Ni/Cu(001) at the spin reorientation transition from an out-of-plane magnetization for small Fe thickness to an in-plane magnetization for larger thickness. (b) Magnification of the transition region. (c) Domain size as a function of Fe thickness. [Reprinted with permission from Wu et al. (2004). Copyright 2004 by the American Physical Society.]
5.3 Imaging of Antiferromagnetic Domains Antiferromagnetism is a material property that occurs in important material classes: in transition metal oxides, for example, Ni oxide, Co oxide, and Mn oxides, as well as in metallic alloys, for example, Mn alloys. The unidirectional exchange coupling at the interface between an antiferromagnet and a ferromagnet has found particular attention, called exchange bias (Meiklejohn and Bean, 1956; Kiwi, 2001; Berkowitz and Takano, 1999; Nogues and Schuller, 1999). Exchange bias leads to a pinning of the magnetization of the ferromagnet after annealing of the antiferromagnet/ferromagnet structure in a magnetic field. It has found application in technology where it is used to pin the magnetization of a ferromagnetic reference layer in devices that are used as magnetic field sensors, e.g., in hard disk read heads. X-ray spectroscopy and X-ray microscopy have been instrumental in studying and understanding the microscopic magnetic structure of such ferromagnet/antiferromagnet interfaces, because of the sensitivity of X-ray spectroscopy and microscopy to antiferromagnetic order (Stöhr et al., 1999; Scholl et al., 2000, 2001, 2004a, 2004b; Ohldag et al., 2001a, 2001b, 2003; Kuch et al., 2002; Offi et al., 2003a, 2003b, 2004). LaFeO3 is an antiferromagnet with a bulk Néel temperature of 740 K. Figure 9–21 shows local X-ray absorption spectra and images acquired using X-PEEM of an epitaxially grown 40-nm LaFeO3 film on an SrTiO3(001) substrate (Scholl et al., 2000). The spectra were acquired using linearly polarized X-rays. XMLD effect is visible at the L3/2 edges and appears as a variation in the L edge fine structure. Images acquired at energy positions labeled A and B in the spectrum show a dark–bright contrast that due to antiferromagnetic domains
681
682
J. Feng and A. Scholl
Figure 9–21. X-ray absorption spectra and images of micron-sized antiferromagnetic domains in an LaFeO3 thin film. The spectra were measured in single domains and show X-ray magnetic linear dichroism at the L resonances. The images were acquired at energies labeled A and B. Image pB/A is the ratio image.
that are less than 1 µm in size. The image contrast is the result of the different angle between the X-ray polarization and the antiferromagnetic axis in each domain. The ratio image or XMLD image pB/A shows the domains with improved contrast. The spectra were determined from a sequence of images, an image stack, acquired as a function of the energy of the incident X-rays. Local spectra were then calculated within single domains by plotting the local image intensity as a function of the energy at which the image was taken. To prove that the perceived image contrast had a magnetic origin, the antiferromagnetic ordering transition was studied by acquiring temperature-dependent domain images (Scholl et al., 2000). A reduced ordering, or Néel, temperature of 670 K was observed in the film, compared to a bulk Néel temperature of 740 K (Figure 9–22). The domain contrast was compared with a fit function ∼〈M2〉T, which was estimated using mean field theory. The good match between fit and measurement demonstrated that the antiferromagnetic ordering transition in a thin film could be described in the mean field approximation. The exchange coupling and exchange bias at the interface between a ferromagnet and an antiferromagnet has been attributed to uncompensated spins at the surface of the antiferromagnet (Takano et al., 1997). This conjecture was not directly proven until surface- and interfacesensitive X-ray microscopy techniques such as X-PEEM became available. Figure 9–23 shows magnetic domain images of a Co/NiO(001) sample, measured using circular polarization (Ohldag et al., 2001; 2003). The Co film was grown by e-beam evaporation in UHV on a freshly cleaved and in situ-annealed NiO(001) single crystal. Because of the surface sensitivity of PEEM, most of the signal in the images originated from the thin ferromagnet film and the surface region of the antiferromagnet. The Ni moment could be separated from the much larger Co moment, because of the element specificity of the method. The top
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
Figure 9–22. Magnetic contrast in LaFeO3 as a function of temperature. The data of the phase transition are compared with a mean field calculation. [Reprinted with permission from Scholl et al. (2000). Copyright 2000 by AAAS/Science.]
Figure 9–23. Magnetic domain images of Co (top layer, ferromagnetic), NiO (bottom layer, antiferromagnetic), and NiO interface layer (center layer, ferromagnetic).
683
684
J. Feng and A. Scholl
Figure 9–24. Magnetization reversal of Co/LaFeO3 imaged using XMCD. A local bias exists in single domains (hysteresis loops a and b). Integrated over a larger sample area the bias vanishes. [Reprinted with permission from Nolting et al. (2000).100 Copyright 2000 by Nature Publishing Group.]
image was acquired using circular polarization at the Co edge and shows ferromagnetic domains, which were aligned domain-by-domain with NiO antiferromagnetic domains (bottom image). The center image was acquired at the Ni edge using circular polarization and shows the small ferromagnetic moment of the Ni interface layer, which mediated the coupling between the NiO antiferomagnet and the Co ferromagnet. The moment was estimated to be close to the moment of one monolayer. Spectroscopy studies of the chemistry of the interface layer showed that the uncompensated spins were a result of a chemical reaction at the interface, which led to a partial oxidization of the Co and a reduction of the surface of the NiO.111 Similar results were obtained on Co/LaFeO3/SrTiO3(001) (Nolting et al., 2000). The interface coupling led to a uniaxial interface anisotropy and a correlation of the antiferromagnetic and ferromagnetic domains. Furthermore, a unidirectional anisotropy or bias was observed locally in single Co domains. This local bias averaged out to zero over a large area but reached significant values in single, small domains. Remanent magnetization loops of single domains showed a different switching field for opposite directions of the applied field pulse (Figure 9–24). The
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
remanent loops were acquired by detecting the XMCD intensity in a single domain as a function of the strength of the pulsed field. Selected images of a full loop (about 30–40 images) are shown in Figure 9–24. After applying a field pulse in the +y direction, dark regions that were magnetized into the −y direction switched into the +y direction and became bright. Gray domains were magnetized in the ±x direction and did not switch, held by the uniaxial anisotropy induced by the antiferromagnet. Below, remanent loops of two selected domains, marked in the domain pictures, are plotted. The local bias appears as a horizontal shift of the magnetization loop. The local bias reached values of up to 30 Oe. Also shown is a loop averaged over a large area that shows no macroscopic bias. The intensity of the loop is only half the intensity of the local loops because it averaged over ±y domains, which switched, and ±x domains, which did not switch. A statistical analysis of the local switching field demonstrated that the average value of the local bias increased linearly with decreasing inverse domain diameter (Scholl et al., 2004b). 5.4 Linear Dichroism Imaging of Ferromagnets XMLD was also observed in experiments on ferromagnetic metals (Schwickert et al., 1998). Since linear dichroism is a quadratic effect with a 180° periodicity it allows us to distinguish between domains, which have a 90° rotated magnetization, in contrast to XMCD, which also distinguishes 180° domains. As an example PEEM images acquired with X-PEEM of an Fe/NiO(001) sample are shown (Figure 9–25). The
Figure 9–25. X-Ray magnetic circular dichroism (left) and linear dichroism (right) imaging of ferromagnetic Fe domains. Images were acquired at room temperature (bottom) and at the Néel temperature of the NiO substrate (top).
685
686
J. Feng and A. Scholl
images in the left column were acquired using conventional XMCD at the Fe L3/2 edges; the right column shows the corresponding XMLD images, acquired at the left and right side of the Fe L2 edge using linearly polarized X-rays. In the XMCD image domains appear in three colors, white, black, and gray, corresponding to domains with a magnetization pointing up, down, or left–right; the last are not distinguished. In the XMLD image only two colors appear and domains with a magnetization pointing up or down are not distinguished. The images in the bottom row were acquired at room temperature, and the domain structure is a result of exchange coupling to the antiferromagnetic NiO(001) substrate, which forces the magnetization in the Fe layer along the four in-plane <110> directions. When the sample is heated above the Néel temperature of NiO (523 K) the coupling vanishes and only two Fe domains remain (up and down). Arrows indicate the local magnetization direction. The XMLD image acquired at elevated temperature shows contrast from Néel-type domain walls (dark lines at the boundary between 180° domains).
6 Time-Resolved Microscopy 6.1 Introduction Time-resolved X-ray microscopy of magnetization dynamics, although still in its infancy, has made great progress over the past years. Storage rings produce X-ray pulses, which are typically between 30 and 100 ps long. Already with picosecond pulses interesting magnetic processes can be studied: magnetostatic modes, magnetization precession, and magnetic switching (Vogel et al., 2003; Stoll et al., 2004; Choe et al., 2004; Schneider et al., 2004). On a fundamental level, magnetization and spin dynamics have become increasingly i mportant in the field of spin electronics, because the generation, transport, and decay of a spin polarization are important steps in the function of a spin-electronic device. The flow of energy and angular momentum in a magnetic material in response to an external excitation are therefore in the focus of current research (Wolf et al., 2001). X-Ray dichroism techniques have qualities that make them extremely valuable for the study of magnetization dynamics. Besides elemental and chemical specificity, the XMCD sum rules allow us to disentangle and quantify spin and orbital momentum in each component of a multielement system. The sensitivity to both ferro- and antiferromagnetic order is particularly useful in magnetic oxides, which can be in either magnetic state, depending on composition or temperature. High spatial resolution is important for the investigation of nanoscale devices. In a stroboscopic, or a pump-probe experiment using X-rays, the response of the sample to an excitation (pump) pulse occurring at a time t0 is measured after a variable delay time ∆t (Figure 9–26). X-Ray pulses of current synchrotron radiation sources do not contain a sufficient number of photons for a single shot experiment. Therefore, the experiment has to be repeated at high frequency, the repetition frequency of the X-ray and the excitation pulse, typically many kilohertz
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
Figure 9–26. Pulse sequence in a laser-synchrotron pump-probe experiment. A fast optical laser pulse excites the sample (pump) and an X-ray pulse probes the dynamic after a variable delay ∆t.
or megahertz. The signal is accumulated on the CCD detector over millions of cycles and then read out. The time evolution of the event is measured by varying the delay ∆t between pump and probe pulse. Because of the signal averaging, only the repetitive or periodic component of the dynamics of the system is measured. Stochastic events cannot be measured by stroboscopic techniques. The limitation to repeatable dynamics is a lesser constraint in mesoscopic magnetic systems, in which the trajectory of the magnetization is simple and often unique. In the following, experiments of the vortex dynamics in small CoFe patterns will be summarized. 6.2 Experimental Setup We will describe a technique developed at the Advanced Light Source PEEM-2 (Choe et al., 2004a, 2004b). Similar techniques were developed in other groups using electronic pulsers to produce fast electrical pulses in a waveguide, a high bandwidth circuit (Voget et al., 2003; Stoll et al., 2004; Schneider et al., 2004). At the Advanced Light Source, optically triggered photoconductive switches were used for the pulse generation. The photoconductive switches were triggered by a femtosecond laser, synchronized to the X-ray source at a frequency of 125 MHz, producing current pulses with very short rise time. An interdigited, finger-like switch structure maximized the current. Lithography techniques were used to integrate switch, waveguide, and magnetic structure on the GaAs substrate. The magnetic structures were placed on top or next to the waveguide in the magnetic field of the current pulse. The dynamics of the structures were then monitored by XPEEM. A schematic drawing of sample and experiment is shown in Figure 9–27 (Choe et al., 2004c). 6.3 In Situ Measurement of the Field Pulse The electrical potential difference between the waveguide and the surrounding ground plane during the field pulse caused a deflection of the X-ray emitted electrons. The deflection of the electrons led to an expansion or breathing of the PEEM image during the pulse. Figure 9–28 (left) shows narrow slices cut from PEEM images of the waveguide and assembled in a new image and ordered by delay time. The measured expansion is proportional to the time-dependent potential
687
688
J. Feng and A. Scholl
Figure 9–27. Layout of the time-resolved PEEM-2 at the Advanced Light Source experiment. The laser triggers a biased photoconductive GaAs switch and generates a field pulse in a waveguide. The PEEM images the local dynamics of the sample using an X-ray probe pulse. [Reprinted with permission from Choe et al. (2004a). Copyright 2004 by AAAS/Science.]
of the waveguide, and, assuming a resistive load, the current is proportional to that potential. It can be determined quantitatively since the average current drawn by the switch is known. To the right of Figure 9–28, the thus estimated current and the strength of the field pulse are plotted, showing a fast, rising edge, and a slower exponential decay, modulated by a small-amplitude ringing, due to an imperfect impedance match and reflections at the switch and the ground connection. The maximum current at 15 V bias was about 200 mA, which corresponded to a peak field of 13 mT (130 Oe). 6.4 Vortex Dynamics Figure 9–29 shows a time sequence of PEEM XMCD images of a 2.5-µm-wide and 20-nm-thick triangular, soft-magnetic FeCo structure. The original images and images that were processed using a gradient filter are shown. The filter enhances intensity gradients, e.g., from domain walls. It was observed that the center of the magnetic vortex, a curling magnetization, which is the ground state of the triangular pattern, rotated on a spiraling or gyrotropic trajectory around
Figure 9–28. Expansion of the waveguide image caused by the pulsed current flowing through the circuit. A pulse with a fast rising edge and less than 500 ps length was recorded. [Reprinted with permission from Choe et al. (2004c). Copyright 2004 by the American Institute of Physics.]
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
Figure 9–29. Vortex dynamics in a triangular FeCo structure after an in-plane field pulse at t = 0. Gradient images are shown next to the XMCD images, showing domain walls with enhanced contrast.
the pattern center. This rotation of the vortex center occurred at a frequency of 125 MHz, commensurate with the repetition rate of the pump laser and the field pulse. The vortex dynamics were quantitatively studied on a variety of patterns, using a particular advantage of fullfield imaging techniques: the ability to study the dynamics of a large area in parallel. The vortex dynamics were analyzed in detail on four rectangular structures, which contained a single vortex (Choe et al., 2004a). Domain images and trajectories of the vortex center are shown in Figure 9–30. In all patterns a gyrotropic rotation was observed within the observation range of 8 ns, limited by the time gap between consecutive field pulses. The trajectories showed an initial acceleration parallel to the field pulse (blue arrow) and, subsequently, a gyrotropic rotation of the vortex center around the center of the magnetic structure. Interestingly, when the trajectories of patterns II and III were compared, different acceleration directions and rotation senses were observed in two patterns, which had identical in-plane domain structures. This was the result of a hidden parameter in the system: the magnetization in the center of the vortex, called the vortex core. Earlier microscopic studies observed that the vortex core contained a nanometer-sized region, in which the magnetization rotated out of the plane.118 The time-resolved PEEM study found that the vortex core magnetization is responsible for a handedness or chirality in the vortex pattern, which governed the field response and picosecond dynamics of the system. It was observed that a left-handed vortex accelerated parallel to an applied field, whereas a right-handed vortex accelerated opposite
689
690
J. Feng and A. Scholl
Figure 9–30. Top: Domain images of the in-plane magnetization of Pattern I (1 × 1 µm2), Patterns II and III (1.5 × 1 µm2), and Pattern IV (2 × 1 µm2), taken at the specified delay times after the field pulse. The images are part of a time series extending over 8 ns and were chosen so that the horizontal displacement of the vortex has maximum amplitude. Hands illustrate the vortex handedness and the out-of-plane core magnetization as determined from the vortex dynamics. Middle: Trajectories of the vortex core. The dots represent sequential vortex positions (100 ps step). Bottom: Spin structure of a left-handed (left side) and a right-handed (right side) square vortex. Red arrows represent the precessional torque generated by the external magnetic field (purple arrow). [Reprinted with permission from Choe et al. (2004a). Copyright 2004 by AAAS/Science.]
to the field, explaining the observed, opposite rotation sense in two patterns with identical in-plane domain structures but opposite core magnetization. The availability of high-resolution microscopy was essential for the real-space study of the vortex rotation, because of the small amplitude of the vortex motion (∼100 nm).
7 Conclusion X-PEEM as a hybrid technique stands between the worlds of electron microscopy, from which it inherits its high spatial resolution, and of X-ray spectroscopy with its sensitivity to the electronic, chemical, and magnetic structure of solids. It excels at chemical and magnetic imaging of thin films and surfaces, because of its surface sensitivity and its sensitivity to the chemical environment and magnetic structure. Fast dynamics on a picosecond time scale can be measured in pump-probe style using the short and intense X-ray pulses of modern synchrotron sources. New, faster X-ray sources and detection schemes are at the brink of being realized and promise even better temporal resolution.
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM)
New schemes of aberration correction, employing electron mirrors, will soon push down the resolution from a current 20–50 nm to only a few nanometers, opening the door to many exciting applications in the field of nanoscience.
Acknowledgments. The authors would like to thank H. Ohldag, S.-B. Choe, and F. Nolting for their contributions to the experimental work and a rewarding collaboration and in particular W. Wan, A.A. MacDowell, N. Kelez, and R.D. Schlueter for their contributions to the PEEM-3 design and development. This work was supported by the Director, Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Materials Sciences Division, of the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC03-76SF00098 at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. References Alders, D., Tjeng, L.H., Voogt, F.C., Hibma, T., Sawatzky, G.A., Chen, C.T., Vogel, J., Sacchi, M. and Iacobucci, S. (1998). Phys. Rev. B (Cond. Matt.) 57, 11623–11631. Anders, S., Padmore, H.A., Duarte, R.M., Renner, T., Stammler, T., Scholl, A., Scheinfein, M.R., Stöhr, J., Seve, L. and Sinkovic, B. (1999). Rev. Sci. Inst. 70, 3973–3981. Attwood, D.T. (2000). Soft X-Rays and Extreme Ultraviolet Radiation: Principles and Applications (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.). Batson, P.E., Dellby, N. and Krivanek, O.L. (2002). Nature 418, 617–620. Bauer, E. (1991). Ultramicroscopy 36, 52–62. Bauer, E. (1994). Rep. Prog. Phys. 57, 895. Bauer, E. (1994). Surface Sci. 299, 102. Bauer, E. (1997). Chemical, Structural, and Electronic Analysis of Heterogeneous Surfaces on Nanometer Scale (Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht). Bauer, E. (2001a). J. Electron Spectrosc. Rel. Phenomena 114–116, 975–987. Bauer, E. (2001b). J. Phys.—Cond. Matt. 13, 11391–11404. Berkowitz, A.E. and Takano, K. (1999). J. Magn. Magn. Mat. 200, 552–570. Brüche, E. (1933). Z. Phy. 86, 448. Brüche, E. and Johannson, H. (1932). Ann. Phy. 15, 145. Carra, P., Thole, B.T., Altarelli, M. and Xindong, W. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 694–697. Chmelik, J., Veneklasen, L. and Marx, G. (1989). Optik 83, 155–160. Choe, S.B., Acremann, Y., Bauer, A., Scholl, A., Doran, A., Stohr, J. and Padmore, H.A. (2004c). AIP Conf. Proc. 705, 1391–1394. Choe, S.B., Acremann, Y., Scholl, A., Bauer, A., Doran, A., Stohr, J. and Padmore, H.A. (2004a). Science 304, 420–422. Dahl, D.A. (2000). Int. J. Mass Spectrom. 200, 3. Davisson, C.J. and Calbick, C.J. (1932). Phys. Rev. 42, 580. De Stasio, G., Perfetti, L., Gilbert, B., Fauchoux, O., Capozi, M., Perfetti, P., Margaritondo, G. and Tonner, B.P. (1999). Rev. Sci. Inst. 70, 1740–1742. Dellby, N., Krivanek, O.L., Nellist, P.D., Batson, P.E. and Lupini, A.R. (2001). J. Electron Microsc. 50, 177–185. Dodin, A.L. and Nesvizhskii, M.B. (1981). Soviet Phys.—Tech. Phys. 26, 539–541. Doran, A., Scholl, A., Feng, J., Padmore, H.A., Chao, W. and Anderson, E. in preparation.
691
692
J. Feng and A. Scholl Einstein, A. (1905). Ann. Phy. 17, 132. Engel, W. (1966). Proc. 6th Int. Cong. Electron Microsc., Kyoto, Japan, 217. Feng, J., MacDowell, A.A., Duarte, R., Doran, A., Forest, E., Kelez, N., Marcus, M., Munson, D., Padmore, H., Petermann, K., Raoux, S., Robin, D., Scholl, A., Schlueter, R., Schmid, P., Stohr, J., Wan, W., Wei, D.H. and Wu, Y. (2004). AIP Conf. Proc. 705, 1070–1073. Feng, J., Padmore, H., Wei, D.H., Anders, S., Wu, Y., Scholl, A. and Robin, D. (2002). Rev. Sci. Inst. 73, 1514–1517. Fink, R., Weiss, M.R., Umbach, E., Preikszas, D., Rose, H., Spehr, R., Hartel, P., Engel, W., Degenhardt, R., Wichtendahl, R., Kuhlenbeck, H., Erlebach, W., Ihmann, K., Schlogl, R., Freund, H.J., Bradshaw, A.M., Lilienkamp, G., Schmidt, T., Bauer, E. and Benner, G. (1997). J. Electron Spectrosc. Rel. Phenomena 84, 231–250. Griffith, O.H. and Engel, W. (1991). Ultramicroscopy 36, 1. Griffith, O.H. and Rempfer, G.E. (1987). Adv. Opt. Electron Microsc. 10, 269. Haider, M., Rose, H., Uhlemann, S., Schwan, E., Kabius, B. and Urban, K. (1998). Ultramicroscopy 75, 53–60. Haider, M., Uhlemann, S., Schwan, E., Rose, H., Kabius, B. and Urban, K. (1998). Nature 392, 768–769. Hartel, P., Preiksaz, D., Spehr, R., Müller, E. and Rose, H. (2002). Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, Vol. 120 (Elsevier Science, New York). Hartel, P., Preiksaz, D., Spehr, R., Müller, H. and Rose, H. (2002). Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, Vol. 120 (Elsevier Science, New York). Harting, E. and Read, F. (1976). Electrostatic Lenses (Elsevier Scientific, Amsterdam). Hawkes, P., Ed. (1973). Image Processing and Computer-Aided Design in Electron Optics (Academic Press Inc, New York). Hawkes, P.W. and Kasper, E. (1996). Principles of Electron Optics, Vol. 2 (Academic Press, New York). Heyderman, L.J., Nolting, F. and Quitmann, C. (2003). App. Phys. Lett. 83, 1797–1799. Jacobsen, C., Kirz, J. and Williams, S. (1992). Ultramicroscopy 47, 55–79. Kel’man, V.M., Sekunova, L.M. and Yakushev, E.M. (1973). Soviet Phys.—Tech. Phys. 17, 2279. Kel’man, V.M., Sekunova, L.M. and Yakushev, E.M. (1974). Soviet Phys.—Tech. Phys. 18, 1142. Kiwi, M. (2001). J. Magn. Magn. Mat. 234, 584–595. Knoll, M., Hontermans, F.G. and Schulzer, W. (1932). Z. Phy. 78, 340. Kortright, J.B., Awschalom, D.D., Stöhr, J., Bader, S.D., Idzerda, Y.U., Parkin, S.S.P., Schuller, I.K. and Siegmann, H.C. (1999). J. Magn. Magn. Mat. 207, 7–44. Kuch, W., Chelaru, L.I., Offi, F., Jing, W., Kotsugi, M. and Kirschner, J. (2004). Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 017201/1–4. Kuch, W., Gilles, J., Offi, F., Kang, S.S., Imada, S., Suga, S. and Kirschner, J. (2000). J. Electron Spectrosc. Rel. Phenomena 109, 249–265. Kuch, W., Offi, F., Chelaru, L.I., Kotsugi, M., Fukumoto, K. and Kirschner, J. (2002). Phys. Rev. B (Cond. Matt. Mat. Phys.) 65, 140408/1–4. Kuiper, P., Searle, B.G., Rudolf, P., Tjeng, L.H. and Chen, C.T. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 1549–1552. Langmuir, D.B. (1937). Proc. Inst. Rad. Eng. 25, 977. Lüning, J., Nolting, F., Scholl, A., Ohldag, H., Seo, J.W., Fompeyrine, J., Locquet, J.P. and Stöhr, J. (2003). Phys. Rev. B 6721, 4433. Marcus, M. (2001). Surface Sci. 480, 203–207.
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM) Meiklejohn, W.H. and Bean, C.P. (1956). Phys. Rev. 102, 1413–1414. Müller, H., Preikszas, D. and Rose, H. (1999). J. Electron Microsc. 48, 191–204. Nakajima, R., Stohr, J. and Idzerda, Y.U. (1999). Phys. Rev. B (Cond. Matt.) 59, 6421–6429. Nepijko, S.A., Sedov, N.N., Schönhense, G., Escher, M., Bao, X. and Huang, W. (2000). Ann. Phy. 9, 441–451. Nogues, J. and Schuller, I.K. (1999). J. Magn. Magn. Mat. 192, 203–232. Nolting, F., Scholl, A., Stöhr, J., Seo, J.W., Fompeyrine, J., Siegwart, H., Locquet, J.P., Anders, S., Lüning, J., Fullerton, E.E., Toney, M.F., Scheinfein, M.R. and Padmore, H.A. (2000). Nature 405, 767–769. Offi, F., Kuch, W., Chelaru, L.I., Fukumoto, K., Kotsugi, M. and Kirschner, J. (2003a). Phys. Rev. B—Cond. Matt. 67, 94419-1–9. Offi, F., Kuch, W., Chelaru, L.I., Kotsugi, M. and Kirschner, J. (2003b). J. Magn. & Magn. Mat. 261, L1–6. Ohara, H., Yamamoto, Y., Kajikawa, K., Ishii, H., Seki, K. and Ouchi, Y. (1999). J. Synchrotron Radiat. 6, 803–804. Ohldag, H., Regan, T.J., Stöhr, J., Scholl, A., Nolting, F., Luning, J., Stamm, C., Anders, S. and White, R.L. (2001a). Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 247201/1–4. Ohldag, H., Scholl, A., Nolting, F., Anders, S., Hillebrecht, F.U. and Stöhr, J. (2001). Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 2878–2881. Ohldag, H., Scholl, A., Nolting, F., Arenholz, E., Maat, S., Young, A.T., Carey, M. and Stöhr, J. (2003). Phys. Rev. Lett. 9101, 7203. Orloff, J., Ed. (1997). Handbook of Charged Particle Optics (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL). Preikszas, D. and Rose, H. (1997). J. Electron Microsc. 46, 1–9. Ramberg, E.G. (1949). J. App. Phys. 20, 183–186. Reckangel, A. (1941). Z. Phy. 117, 689. Regan, T.J., Ohldag, H., Stamm, C., Nolting, F., Lüning, J., Stöhr, J. and White, R.L. (2001). Phys. Rev. B—Cond. Matt. 64, 214422/1–11. Rempfer, G.F. (1985). J. App. Phys. 57, 2385. Rempfer, G.F. (1990). J. App. Phys. 67, 6027–6040. Rempfer, G.F. and Griffith, O.H. (1989). Ultramicroscopy 27, 273. Rempfer, G.F. and Mauck, M.S. (1992). Optik 92, 3–8. Rempfer, G.F., Desloge, D.M., Skoczylas, W.P. and Hayes Griffith, O. (1997). Microsc. Microanal. 3, 14–27. Rempfer, G.F., Skoczylas, W.P. and Griffith, O.H. (1991). Ultramicroscopy 36, 196. Rockenberger, J., Nolting, F., Lüning, J., Hu, J. and Alivisatos, A.P. (2002). J. Chem. Phys. 116, 6322–6328. Rose, H. (1994). Ultramicroscopy 56, 11–25. Rose, H. and Preikszas, D. (1992). Optik 92, 31–44. Rose, H. and Preikszas, D. (1995). Nucl. Inst. Methods Phys. Res. Section A 363, 301–315. Scherzer, O. (1936). Z. Phy. 101, 593. Schneider, C.M. and Schönhense, G. (2002). Rep. Prog. Phys. 65, R1785–1839. Schneider, C.M., Kuksov, A., Krasyuk, A., Oelsner, A., Neeb, D., Nepijko, S.A., Schonhense, G., Monch, I., Kaltofen, R., Morais, J., de Nadai, C. and Brookes, N.B. (2004b). Appl. Phys. Lett. 85, 2562–2564. Schneider, G. (1998). Ultramicroscopy 75, 85–104. Schönhense, G. and Spiecker, H. (2002). J. Vacuum Sci. Tech. B 20, 2526–2534. Scholl, A., Liberati, M., Arenholz, E., Ohldag, H. and Stöhr, J. (2004a). Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 247201/1–4. Scholl, A., Nolting, F., Seo, J.W., Ohldag, H., Stöhr, J., Raoux, S., Locquet, J.-P. and Fompeyrine, J. (2004b). App. Phys. Lett. 85, 4085–4087.
693
694
J. Feng and A. Scholl Scholl, A., Stöhr, J., Lüning, J., Seo, J.W., Fompeyrine, J., Siegwart, H., Locquet, J.P., Nolting, F., Anders, S., Fullerton, E.E., Scheinfein, M.R. and Padmore, H.A. (2000). Science 287, 1014–1016. Schütz, G., Wagner, W., Wilhelm, W., Kienle, P., Zeller, R., Frahm, R. and Materlik, G. (1987). Phys. Rev. Lett. 58, 737–740. Schwickert, M.M., Guo, G.Y., Tomaz, M.A., O’Brien, W.L. and Harp, G.R. (1998). Phys. Rev. B—Cond. Matt. 58, R4289–4292. Shao, Z. and Wu, X.D. (1990a). Rev. Sci. Inst. 61, 1230–1235. Shao, Z. and Wu, X.D. (1990b). Optik 84, 51–54. Shinjo, T., Okuno, T., Hassdorf, R., Shigeto, K. and Ono, T. (2000). Science 289, 930–932. Smith, A.D., Schofield, P.F., Scholl, A., Pattrick, R.A.D. and Bridges, J.C. (2003). J. Physique IV 104, 373–376. Stöhr, J. (1992). NEXAFS Spectroscopy, Vol. 25 (Springer-Verlag, Berlin). Stöhr, J., Scholl, A., Regan, T.J., Anders, S., Lüning, J., Scheinfein, M.R., Padmore, H.A. and White, R.L. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 1862–1865. Stöhr, J., Wu, Y., Hermsmeier, B.D., Samant, M.G., Harp, G.R., Koranda, S., Dunham, D. and Tonner, B.P. (1993). Science 259, 658–661. Stoll, H., Puzic, A., van Waeyenberge, B., Fischer, P., Raabe, J., Buess, M., Haug, T., Hollinger, R., Back, C., Weiss, D. and Denbeaux, G. (2004). App. Phys. Lett. 84, 3328–3330. Takano, K., Kodama, R.H., Berkowitz, A.E., Cao, W. and Thomas, G. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 1130–1133. Telieps, W. and Bauer, E. (1987). Ultramicroscopy 17, 57. Thole, B.T., Paolo, C., Sette, F. and van der Laan, G. (1992). Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 1943–1946. Tonner, B.P. and Dunham, D. (1994). Nucl. Inst. Methods Phys. Res. A 347, 436–440. Tonner, B.P. and Harp, G.R. (1988). Rev. Sci. Inst. 59, 853–858. Urquhart, S.G., Hitchcock, A.P., Smith, A.P., Ade, H.W., Lidy, W., Rightor, E. G. and Mitchell, G.E. (1999). J. Electron Spectrosc. Rel. Phenomena 100, 119–135. Vogel, J., Kuch, W., Bonfim, M., Camarero, J., Pennec, Y., Offi, F., Fukumoto, K., Kirschner, J., Fontaine, A. and Pizzini, S. (2003). App. Phys. Lett. 82, 2299–2301. Wan, W., Feng, J. and Padmore, H.A. in preparation. Wan, W., Feng, J., Padmore, H.A. and Robin, D.S. (2004). Nucl. Inst. Methods Phys. Res. Section A 519, 222. Watts, R.N., Liang, S., Levine, Z.H., Lucatorto, T.B., Polack, F. and Scheinfein, M.R. (1997). Rev. Sci. Inst. 68, 3464–3476. Wegmann, L. (1972). J. Microsc. 96, 1. Wei, D.H., Hsu, Y.J., Klauser, R., Hong, I.H., Yin, G.C. and Chuang, T.J. (2003). Surface Rev. Lett. 10, 617–624. Wolf, S.A., Awschalom, D.D., Buhrman, R.A., Daughton, J.M., von Molnar, S., Roukes, M.L., Chtchelkanova, A.Y. and Treger, D.M. (2001). Science 294, 1488–1495. Wu, Y., Stohr, J., Hermsmeier, B.D., Samant, M.G. and Weller, D. (1992). Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 2307–2310. Wu, Y.K., Robin, D.S., Forest, E., Schlueter, R., Anders, S., Feng, J., Padmore, H. and Wei, D.H. (2004). Nucl. Inst. Methods Phys. Res. Section A 519, 230–241. Wu, Y.Z., Won, C., Scholl, A., Doran, A., Zhao, H.W., Jin, X.F. and Qiu, Z.Q. (2004). Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 117205/1–4.
Chapter 9 Photoemission Electron Microscopy (PEEM) Zach, J. and Haider, M. (1995). Optik 98, 112–118. Zharnikov, M., Frey, S., Heister, K. and Grunze, M. (2002). J. Electron Spectrosc. Rel. Phenomena 124, 15–24. Zworykin, V.K. and Kosma, V. (1945). Electron Optics and the Electron Microscope (Wiley, New York).
695
10 Aberration Correction Peter W. Hawkes
1 Introduction It has been known since the early days of electron optics that the rotationally symmetric lenses employed in electron microscopes and similar instruments suffer from severe aberrations that cannot be eliminated by skillful lens design (Scherzer, 1936). Immense effort has been devoted to finding lenses with small aberrations and devising aberration correctors. The original demonstration that the two most important aberrations, spherical and chromatic, cannot be eliminated required that several conditions be satisfied and, by relaxing one or the other of these conditions, correctors can be designed. A nearexhaustive list was published by Scherzer (1947) and reviews charting trends in thinking about aberration correction and progress in implementing correctors are to be found in Septier (1966), Hawkes (1980), and Hawkes and Kasper (1989). These contain very full accounts of earlier attempts to correct aberrations with extensive reference lists and the material presented there is not always reproduced here. In particular, a survey of attempts to build apochromats and aplanatic lenses by H. Rose and colleagues in Darmstadt is to be found in the article by Hawkes (1980). The types of corrector that seem most promising today are examined below but first, we describe the various kinds of aberration and explain why they are important. We then look more closely at the aberration coefficients themselves, which leads naturally to a study of the correctors. Some familiarity with basic electron optics is assumed here. In particular, the reader is expected to be acquainted with the paraxial properties of lenses and the cardinal elements that characterize them. The Handbook of Charged Particle Optics edited by J. Orloff (1997) is recommended for readers who wish to brush up their knowledge of electron lenses, notably the chapters by Munro, Tsuno, Lencová, and Hawkes. For very full accounts, see Hawkes and Kasper (1989) and Rose (2008).
696
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
2 Types of Aberration Lens aberrations are of three kinds: geometric aberrations, chromatic aberrations, and parasitic aberrations 2.1 Geometric Aberrations An ideal lens would provide point-to-point mapping of the structure of an object into an image and such imaging is indeed predicted by the simplest approximate description of the effect of a lens on an electron beam, the paraxial approximation. This is valid provided that the electrons remain close to the optic axis (the axis of symmetry in the case of a round lens) and that the electron trajectory remains inclined at a small angle to this axis. When the electrons depart too far from the axis or the trajectories are inclined at a steeper angle, the paraxial approximation is perturbed by geometric aberrations. In the paraxial approximation, electrons (of charge −e and rest mass m0 ) satisfy the linear, homogeneous, second-order differential equation
d ˆ1/ 2 γφ ′′ + η 2 B 2 φ x′ + x =0 dz 4 φˆ1/ 2
(
)
(1)
with an identical equation for y(z), in which φ(z) is the axial electrostatic potential and B(z) is the magnetic induction on the optic axis, which coincides with the coordinate axis z. Primes denote differentiation with respect to z. The field and potential expansions are given in Appendix I; for derivations of these, see Hawkes and Kasper (1989, Chapter 7). Since the chapter by Rose in High-Resolution Imaging and Spectrometry of Materials edited by F. Ernst and M. Rühle is a very relevant reference (Rose, 2002c) to much of the material presented here, the relation between his notation and that adopted here is also given. The relativistically corrected potential φˆ is given by φˆ = φ(1 + εφ)
(2)
where ε = e/2m0 c2 ≈ 0.1 MV−1; γ = 1 + 2εφ and η = (e/2 m0)1/2 ≈ 3 × 105 C1/2 kg−1/2. The distances x(z) and y(z) are the rotating coordinates routinely employed in the study of round magnetic lenses. Such differential equations have the general solution x(z) = Ax1(z) + Bx2(z) where x1(z) and x2(z) are linearly independent solutions of Eq. (1) and A, B are constants. It is frequently convenient to choose for x1(z) and x2(z) the solutions g(z) and h(z) that satisfy the boundary conditions g(zo) = h′(zo) = 1 g′(zo) = h(zo) = 0
(3)
where zo is the object plane, whereupon we have x(z) = xog(z) + x′oh(z) y(z) = yog(z) + y′oh(z)
(4)
697
698
P.W. Hawkes
The cardinal elements of the lens, its focal lengths and the positions of its focal planes and principal planes, are defined with the aid of the rays g(z) and h(z). It is convenient to write u = x + iy and it can readily be shown that zFi − z u fi = u ′ −1/ fi
uo zo − z Fo u ′ o fi T12
(5)
If u is proportional to uo for all values of the gradient u′o, the matrix element T12 vanishes. The plane z is then said to be conjugate to zo and we write z = zi. The matrix equation then collapses to zFi − zi ui fi = ui′ −1/ fi
M uo = zo − zFo u ′ −1/ fi o fi 0
0 u o fo fi M uo′
(6)
Here, M denotes the magnification, g(zi) = M, fo and fi are the object and image focal lengths, and zFo and zFi are the object and image foci. (For more details of paraxial optics, see Chapters 16 and 17 of Hawkes and Kasper, 1989.) In the case of purely magnetic round lenses, fo = fi and we denote the focal length by f. The next higher approximation includes terms of third order in uo and u′o. Systems with a straight optic axis have no second-order terms and the rotational symmetry about the optic axis restricts the permitted third-order terms to the following: ui − Muo = Cuo′ ( xo′ 2 + yo′ 2 ) M + 2 ( K + ik) uo ( xo′ 2 + yo′ 2 ) + ( K − ik ) uo uo′ 2 + ( A + ia) uo2 uo′ ∗ + F ( xo2 + yo2 ) uo′ + (D + id) uo ( xo2 + yo2 )
(spherical aberration ) ( coma) (astigmatism )
(field curvature) (distortion )
(7)
The spherical aberration term is of particular concern since it does not vanish or even dwindle for object points close to or on the axis. This is the region that is imaged in high-resolution operation. We examine this aberration closely in a later section. The other terms are of decreasing interest for objective or probe-forming lenses and, moreover, the coma (next in importance after the spherical aberration) can be avoided. Lenses have a “coma-free plane,” the exact position of which is determined by the relative magnitudes of the spherical aberration and coma coefficients. In practice, for magnetic lenses, it falls within the lens field, upstream from the image focus (the “diffraction plane”). Specifically, let us suppose that the aberrations are expressed in terms of ray position in the object plane, z = zo and some aperture plane, z = za. The paraxial solutions appearing in the aberration integrals will then be s(z) and t(z), which satisfy the conditions
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
s(zo) = t(za) = 1 s(za) = t(zo) = 0
(8)
If another aperture position is selected, z = z¯a, the aberration coefficients will have exactly the same structure but the appropriate paraxial solutions will now be s¯(z) and t¯ (z), s¯(zo) = t¯ (z¯a) = 1 s¯(z¯a) = t¯ (zo) = 0
(9)
Since there can be only two linearly independent paraxial solutions, we must be able to write s¯(z) = αs(z) + βt(z) t¯ (z) = γs(z) + δt(z)
(10)
and obviously α = 1 and γ = 0; for β and δ, we have β = −s(z¯a)/t(z¯a) δ = 1/t(z¯a)
(11)
It is then easy to show that the coma coefficient for z = z¯a, K(z¯a), is related to that for z = za, K(za), as follows: K(z¯a) ∝ K(za) + βCs (za)
(12)
The coma-free point is thus situated at the point for which s( za ) K ( za ) = t( za ) Cs ( za )
(13)
The distortion can be important in projector lenses, in which the trajectories may be relatively far from the axis while the gradient will be very small at high magnification. Astigmatism and field curvature are mainly of importance in devices in which the size of the field is a major preoccupation, such as lithography. For quadrupoles, the situation is slightly more complicated. A quadrupole usually consists of four electrodes or four magnetic poles, though many other configurations that create quadrupole fields exist (see, for example, Hawkes, 1970 or Baranova and Yavor, 1989). For convenience, we assume throughout that the quadrupole is disposed in such a way that the converging and diverging planes coincide with the x–z and y–z planes (Figure 10–1). The paraxial properties of the quadrupole are then characterized by equations of motion for x(z) and y(z) that are uncoupled but no longer identical. They are again linear, homogeneous, second-order differential equations and hence have solutions analogous to those for round lenses. Now, however, we have two sets of cardinal elements, one set for the x–z plane and a second set for the y–z plane. These equations take the form
γφ ′′ − 2γp2 + 4ηQ2φˆ1/ 2 d ˆ1/ 2 φ x′ + x =0 dz 4 φˆ1/ 2 d ˆ1/ 2 γφ ′′ + 2γp2 − 4ηQ2φˆ1/ 2 φ y′ + y =0 dz 4 φˆ1/ 2
( (
) )
(14)
699
700
P.W. Hawkes y –
a +
+
x
–
y
S
–
N
x
s N
a)
b
b) Figure 10–1. Quadrupoles. (a) Quadrupole orientation. The paraxial equations of motion are uncoupled when the x–z and y–z planes coincide with the planes of symmetry of electrostatic quadrupoles and fall midway between the poles of magnetic quadrupoles. (b) Appearance of a mixed magnetic– electrostatic quadrupole.
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
701
c) Figure 10–1. Continued (c) Formation of a line image in a magnetic quadrupole; the arrows show the directions of the currents in the windings. (After Hawkes and Kasper, 1989, courtesy of Elsevier/ Academic Press.)
in which the functions p2(z) and Q2(z) characterize the potential and field distributions (see Appendix I). We can now write (x ) z Fi − z ix x ( z ) ix (x ) f i = (x ) x ′(z ix ) −1 / f i
x o Mx = (x ) (x ) z o − z Fo −1 / f i x o′ f i( x ) 0
0 f o( x ) f i( x ) M x
xo x o′
(15a)
and (y ) z Fi − z iy y ( z ) iy (y ) = fi (y ) y ′(z iy ) −1 / f i
0 yo M y ( y) = fo (y ) (y ) / f − 1 i z o − z Fo (y ) fi M y y o′ (y ) fi 0
yo (15b) y o′
702
P.W. Hawkes
Since the cardinal elements are different in the two planes, the planes conjugate to a given object plane will not, in general, coincide. The system is astigmatic and if we operate two quadrupoles in tandem, the “object” of the second member will be astigmatic. Clearly, if we require quadrupoles to produce a stigmatic image of an object, we must use quadrupole multiplets and must somehow arrange that the cardinal elements of the multiplet are the same in the two planes. One multiplet configuration is of particular importance. It can be shown by symmetry arguments that if the multiplet is geometrically symmetric and electrically antisymmetric about its center plane, the focal lengths in the x–z and y–z planes will be equal. It is then only necessary to satisfy one condition (coincidence of the focal planes) to render the multiplet stigmatic. Quadruplets with this property have been extensively studied and are known as Russian Quadruplets, since their properties were first investigated by Dymnikov and Yavor (1963) in the Ioffe Institute in Saint Petersburg (Figure 10–2). The aberrations of quadrupoles are more numerous than in the case of round lenses but they fall into the same categories: aperture aberrations (the analogues of the spherical aberration), comas, astigmatisms, and field curvatures and distortions. Here we consider only the aperture aberrations, since they will be exploited in aberration correctors. At this point, we note that octopoles, which have eight electrodes or magnetic poles, also have quadrupole symmetry and should hence be included in the formalism for the aberrations. They have no linear effect and hence have no effect on the paraxial behavior. Our interest here is exclusively with aberration correctors, and we therefore assume that any multiplets of quadrupoles and octopoles are stigmatic and that the magnifications in the two planes are likewise equal Mx = My). In these circumstances, the additional terms arising from the aperture aberrations take the following form: ∆x = xo′ (Cx xo′ 2 + Cxy yo′ 2 ) M ∆y = yo′ (Cxy xo′ 2 + C y yo′ 2 ) M
(16)
The other multipoles used for aberration correction are sextupoles (also known as hexapoles). Like octopoles, they have no linear
mid-plane
Q1
Q2 Q1
Q2
Figure 10–2. The “Russian” quadruplet. The excitations of the first and last quadrupoles are equal and opposite, as are those of the second and third quadrupoles. The quadrupoles are disposed symmetrically about the center plane.
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
effect on charged particles but unlike octopoles (and of course quadrupoles), their dominant effect is quadratic. Their primary aberrations are third order, like round lenses and quadrupoles, and their aperture aberration, the aberration that depends only on gradient and is independent of off-axis distance, has the same nature as the spherical aberration of round lenses. It is for this reason that sextupoles are potential correctors of Cs but some way of eliminating the quadratic effects must be devised. We shall see how this is achieved in a later section. For extensive discussion of their optical properties, see Rose (2002c). Since the sextupoles will be used in conjunction with one or more round lenses, the paraxial solutions satisfy Eq. (1). We adopt a slightly different pair of solutions from those of Eq. (2), namely h(x), which, as before, satisfies h(zo) = 0, h′(zo) = 1
(17a)
k(zo) = 1, k(zk) = 0
(17b)
and k(z), where z = zk is the coma-free point discussed earlier. The expression for a general ray becomes u(z) = Ωhh(z) + Ωkk(z)
(18)
in which Ωh and Ωk are simply related to the usual object coordinates (for ample details, see Rose, 2002, which is closely followed here). When this general ray passes through a sextupole lens, it will be deviated through a distance ∆u, which has the form – – – – ∆u = Ω2hu11 + ΩhΩku12 + Ω2k (19) with u11 (z) =
z z 1 2 ( ) − ( ) h z Hh kdz k z Hh 3 dz ∫ ∫ 2 zo zo
z z u12 (z) = h(z) ∫ Hhk 2 dz − k(z) ∫ Hh 2 kdz zo zo
u22 (z) =
(20)
z z 1 3 ( ) − ( ) h z Hk dz k z ∫ Hhk 2 dz ∫ 2 zo zo
The function H(z) characterizes the field distribution in the sextupoles; in the most general case (in which both electrostatic and magnetic sextupoles may be present), H is given by H ( z) = −
exp(−3iχ) (1 + εφ)( p3 + iq3 ) + iη(P3 + iQ3 ) φ^ o1/ 2 φˆ 1/ 2
(21)
where χ(z) characterizes the usual rotation in magnetic lenses. All three contributions must vanish if the unwanted second-order effects of the sextupoles are to be eliminated; this can be achieved if the four integrals
703
704
P.W. Hawkes ze
∫ H(z)h
3−n n
k dz , n = 0, 1, 2, and 3
(22)
zo
all vanish. The form of these conditions, in two of which h(z) is an even function while k(z) may be odd, and in the other two the situation is reversed, indicates that symmetry can be used to eliminate all four quantities. The simplest arrangement is that shown in Figure 10–3. Here, one ray is symmetrical within each sextupole but antisymmetric about the center plane of the combination; the other ray is antisymmetric about the mid-plane of each sextupole but symmetric about the center plane of the whole combination. The members of the round-lens doublet have equal and opposite excitations, chosen in such a way that the centers of the sextupoles are conjugates, with magnification −1. Since the sextupole strength is a free parameter, it can, as we shall see in Section 3.2.2, be used to cancel the spherical aberration of an adjoining round lens. 2.2 Chromatic Aberrations Chromatic aberrations are a consequence of the rapid variation of electron lens strength with electron energy and lens excitation. The electron beam from the gun will inevitably have some energy spread and there will be some variation in the lens excitations, however carefully they have been stabilized. The result is a “chromatic” effect, characterized by chromatic aberration coefficients, that blurs the image. We can include this in the paraxial formalism by writing ∆ ^φ ui − Muo ∆B0 = − {Cc uo′ + (CD + iCθ )uo } ^ 0 − 2 (23) M B0 φ0
Figure 10–3. The simplest sextupole arrangement. No second-order aberrations are introduced outside the corrector. (After Rose, 2003c, courtesy of the author and Springer-Verlag.)
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
in which Cc is the (axial) chromatic aberration coefficient, CD is a measure of the chromatic aberration of magnification, and Cθ is the anisotropic distortion. The quantity ∆φ0 is a measure of the potential variation corresponding to the energy spread of the beam and ∆B0 represents any fluctuations in the field strength of the lens caused by variations of the current. (Here we are considering only magnetic lenses; a similar reasoning applies to electrostatic lenses.) We thus have two types of aberration: the chromatic aberration Cc, which is linear in gradient and hence does not vanish for object points close to the axis, just like the spherical aberration; and the complex chromatic aberration of magnification (CD + iCθ), analogous to the distortion in that it is independent of gradient. We can therefore expect that the chromatic aberration, like the spherical aberration, will impose a limit on the resolution attainable in very high resolution work. In practice, it defines an “information limit.” which, in instruments that have not been corrected for spherical aberration, is usually less severe than the limit imposed by spherical aberration. With the arrival of spherical aberration correctors, however, the situation is reversed and it becomes imperative to correct the chromatic aberration as well, or find some way of rendering it innocuous. Incidentally, this is a return to the situation in the early days of electron microscopy, when chromatic effects dominated as a result of the relatively poor stabilization of circuitry at that time. For quadrupoles, the chromatic aberrations are again different in the x–z and y–z planes: ∆xi = (Ccxx′o + CMxxo)∆c ∆yi = (Ccyy′o + CMyyo)∆c
(24)
in which we have represented the potential and field variation by ∆c [see Eq. (23)]. 2.3 Parasitic Aberrations Parasitic aberrations are, as their name suggests, not intrinsic defects of electron lenses. They result from imperfections of the construction or alignment of the lenses or of the entire instrument in question. The most serious is a (first-order) astigmatism, traditionally associated with imperfect circularity of the bore of the lens: in fact, Fourier analysis shows that this astigmatism will usually be the dominant parasitic effect, whatever the origin of the problem. It is as though a very weak quadrupole had been superimposed on the lens and the effect can be cancelled by adding a weak quadrupole with the opposite strength. Such a device, which in practice has a more complex structure, is known as a stigmator and several such correctors are routinely incorporated in commercial instruments. In high-resolution operation, other parasitic effects become noticeable and ways of correcting or compensating for these are now known. A very detailed study of these parasitic aberrations in the context of electron microscope alignment has been made by Krivanek (Krivanek, 1994; see also Krivanek and Fan, 1992a,b; Krivanek and Leber, 1993,
705
706
P.W. Hawkes
1994; Krivanek and Stadelmann, 1995). For measurement techniques, see Saxton (1995a,b, 2000), Saxton et al. (1994), and Chand et al. (1995) as well as Ishizuka (1994). The work of Zemlin on alignment is also relevant here (Zemlin et al., 1978; Zemlin, 1979). Among the earlier literature on parasitic aberrations, we draw attention to the work of Glaser (1942), Sturrock (1951), Archard (1953), Glaser and Schiske (1953), Der-Shvarts (1954), and Stoyanov (1955). A long survey has been written by Yavor (1993) and other references are listed in Hawkes (1997). The many publications on the stigmator are also relevant; see Chapter 31 of Hawkes and Kasper (1989) for numerous references to these.
3 Aberration Correction 3.1 Introduction The picture of a corrected electron microscope as a standard instrument to which a quadrupole–octopole or sextupole corrector has been added is an oversimplification. Before correction of the spherical aberration of the transmission electron microscope (TEM) and scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) was achieved in the late 1990s, only sporadic attention was paid to any other aberrations that might become troublesome after Cs had been reduced. Now, however, largely due to the theoretical work of H. Rose and the practical designs of O. Krivanek and his group, strategies are being developed to correct all the potentially harmful aberrations in a systematic way. In this section, we first examine the basic correctors of spherical and chromatic aberration and then describe the much more complex correctors that should be capable of a broader range of correction. The latter are still at the planning stage or, at best, exist as prototypes. Spherical aberration is the dominant resolution-limiting aberration in electron microscopes. It is characterized by the spherical aberration coefficient Cs, which can be expressed as an integral of the form zi
CS =
∫
f [B(z), h(z)]dz
(25)
zo
for magnetic lenses, in which as usual B(z) denotes the magnetic flux on the axis and h(z) is the particular solution of the paraxial ray equation (1) that vanishes at the object plane. A similar formula, in which the axial potential distribution φ(z) replaces B(z), gives the spherical aberration coefficient of electrostatic lenses. Here we concentrate on magnetic lenses. The integrand f [B(z), h(z)] can be written in different ways [see Hawkes and Kasper, 1989 for many of these and for a general formula from which all the others can be generated; forms particularly useful for programming are given by Lencová and Lenc, 1990 (magnetic lenses) and 1994, 1977 (electrostatic lenses)]. In 1936, Otto Scherzer derived a nonnegative definite form of the integrand, a sum of squared terms, from which it is clear that the sign of the coefficient cannot
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
change. Scherzer’s formula was nonrelativistic but Rose (1967/8, see corrigendum in Preikszas and Rose, 1995) has established a relativistic version, which essentially confirms Scherzer’s conclusion. Efforts to find field or potential distributions for which the integrand vanishes (Glaser, 1940; Recknagel, 1941) failed, as they were sure to do given the form of the integrand found by Scherzer. (Attempts to find a loophole nevertheless continue; see Nomura, 2004 for a recent claim.) Tretner (1959) later established bounds on the coefficient. However, all was not lost for the derivation of Scherzer’s formula requires a certain number of conditions to be satisfied: the lens must possess rotational symmetry, the excitation must be static, only dioptric operation is permissible (excluding an electron mirror mode), and, in the case of electrostatic lenses, the potential distribution and its derivatives must be continuous. Object and image must both be real (not virtual). Scherzer showed (1947) that by relaxing one or the other of these conditions, a corrector could be devised. Throughout the second half of the twentieth century, efforts were made to build and test the various types of corrector. These are described in detail in Septier (1966), Hawkes (1980), Hawkes and Kasper (1989, Chapter 41), and Hawkes (1997); some more recent information is included in Hawkes (2002). Departure from rotational symmetry has always seemed a promising approach and as early as the 1950s, Seeliger (1949, 1951) attempted to put Scherzer’s suggestion for exploiting the idea into practice, as did Möllenstedt (1956). Archard (1954) showed that relatively simple configurations would create the desired field distribution and Burfoot (1953) found a three-electrode geometry that would in principle at least be aberration-free. Numerous further experiments were made over the years, including a reassuring proof-of-principle experiment by Deltrap (1964), but all attempts to correct a high-resolution microscope objective foundered essentially as a result of the complexity of the necessary system and of the intrinsic instability of the technique. A realistic corrector consists of four (or more) quadrupoles, probably with the “Russian” symmetry, and three octopoles. The asymmetry between the focusing in the x–z and y–z planes is not in itself beneficial, quite the contrary in fact. However, it creates a situation in which octopoles (which have no paraxial effect, we recall) can correct the combined spherical and aperture aberrations of a round lens and the quadrupoles. Even if the quadrupoles and octopoles are combined into single elements, the task of aligning all these individual components is clearly formidable. In addition, the aberrations introduced by the quadrupoles are themselves large, so we have a situation in which a well-designed round lens with a small spherical aberration coefficient is combined with a set of quadrupoles with large aperture aberrations and octopoles, whose role is to cancel the overall aperture aberrations of the combination. It is for this reason that we describe the situation as unstable. For several decades, quadrupoles and octopoles were the only nonrotationally symmetric devices envisaged, although it was known that sextupoles suffer from a spherical aberration that would be suitable, in principle at least, for use as a corrector (Hawkes, 1965). However, the
707
708
P.W. Hawkes
three-fold symmetry and associated optical properties of such multipoles seemed to render them unsuitable for the purpose. But in 1979, Beck suggested that sextupoles could be combined in such a way that they would become attractive for correction, and this proposal was soon thoroughly studied (Crewe, 1980, 1982; Crewe and Kopf, 1980a,b; Rose, 1981; Ximen, 1983; Ximen and Crewe, 1985). In an interesting alternative approach, Dragt and Forest (1986) again showed the suitability of sextupoles as correctors. As we shall see in the following sections, each type of multipole corrector is now in use. The quadrupole–octopole corrector is used in the STEM, a probe-forming instrument in which the very considerable difficulties of correcting a useful area or field of view do not arise. The sextupole arrangement is incorporated in TEMs. A valuable study of the performance of these correctors has been made by Haider et al. (2000). Of the other ways of achieving correction, Scherzer had high hopes of the use of high frequency (Scherzer, 1946, 1947), hopes that were shared by Gabor (1950). The basic idea is easily understood. Electrons are pictured as reaching the lens from a region close to the optic axis at the object; those rays that are more steeply inclined will reach the outer region of the lens (here, an electric lens) slightly later than those leaving the object at the same time but remaining close to the axis. By illuminating the specimen with short pulses of electrons and reducing the excitation of the lens in such a way that the outer electrons encounter a weaker field, it should be possible to focus them all at the same place, thus eliminating the effect of spherical aberration, which would have focused the outer electrons too strongly if the lens strength had not been weakened. For electrons with energies in the tens of kilovolts range, the frequency required is found to be of the order of gigahertz and some experimental studies with a microwave cavity inserted between the polepieces of a magnetic lens were made by Oldfield (1973, 1974). These were not pursued, however, and the problems of generating short enough pulses and, above all, of dealing with the increased energy spread of the beam were clearly formidable. Recently, Calvo has reconsidered the technique along very different lines, but his findings are at present (2005) inconclusive (Calvo, 2002, 2004; Calvo and Lazcano, 2002; Calvo and Laroze, 2002). Yet another way of using dynamic fields for spherical and chromatic aberration correction has been proposed by Schönhense and Spiecker (2002, 2003), with photoemission and lowenergy electron microscopes in mind. For chromatic aberration, an ingenious way of inverting the energy distribution of the electron beam has been found. The electrons are generated at the sample by a pulsed beam and, after acceleration and collimation, they enter a drift space, in which the faster electrons draw away from the slower ones, like horses galloping down the straight in a race. Beyond the drift space is an accelerator, initially switched off. When the fastest electrons emerge from it, the electric accelerating field is rapidly switched on and by suitable choice of the accelerator field, the slower electrons can be accelerated to a higher energy than the fast electrons, thus effectively inverting the original energy distribution (Figure 10–4). The chromatic
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
a)
b)
c) Figure 10–4. Chromatic correction based on inversion of the electron energy distribution. (a) Schematic cross-section of the system (greatly exaggerated in the radial direction). (b) Electron energy distribution as a function of the optical path; Ekin denotes the actual kinetic energy of the electron ensemble. The distribution Ekin as a function of z before and after passing the pulsed accelerating field is denoted by “in” and “out,” respectively. (c) Schematic representation of the electron energy distribution before and after passing the accelerator, Iin and Iout. (After Schönhense et al., 2002, courtesy of the authors and the American Institute of Physics.)
aberration of the final lens will then bring the whole beam to a smaller focus than in the absence of energy inversion. For spherical aberration correction, Schönhense and Spiecker consider an “electrostatic” lens in which the lens strength is abruptly altered when the (pulsed) beam reaches the center. Schönhense and Spiecker explain the correcting effect by regarding the half-lens as a diverging lens (the converging
709
710
P.W. Hawkes
effect of the second half of the lens having been suppressed by switching off the lens). The image of the object is then virtual and Scherzer’s result is no longer applicable. Another way of understanding this is to note that the abrupt change in lens strength is equivalent to a discontinuity in the field and, as for the foil correctors mentioned below, this is known to offer a way of achieving correction. See also Khursheed (2002, 2005). The idea of combining an electron mirror (an electrostatic lens in which there is a potential barrier too high for the electrons to surmount) with a round lens in such a way that spherical and chromatic aberrations of the mirror cancel those of the round lens has been explored and projects based on this are currently being actively pursued. A major problem is to separate the beam incident on the mirror from the beam emerging from it and numerous ways of achieving this have been proposed (see Septier, 1966 and Hawkes, 1980 for earlier suggestions). We return to this in Section 3.3.4. Finally, we draw attention to the method in which a field discontinuity is introduced into an electrostatic lens, by covering the bore with a very thin electron-transparent foil. This was suggested as a means of achieving chromatic correction by Scherzer in 1948 and has subsequently been investigated in great detail and with considerable ingenuity, notably by Typke (1968/9, 1972, 1976) and Scherzer (1980) in Darmstadt, Hoch et al. (1976) in Tübingen, Munro and Wittels (1977), and in Japan (Hanai et al., 1986, 1994, 1995, 1998); for recent work, see Matsuda et al. (2005). The idea has been revived but in a rather different form by van Aken et al. in Delft (van Aken et al., 2002a,b, 2004, 2005; van Aken, 2005). The use of a cloud of space charge also falls into this category (see, for example, Haufe, 1958, where earlier attempts are listed) and has recently been revived by Orloff (Wang et al., 1995; Tang et al., 1996a,b; Chao et al., 1997) for ion-optical systems. Chromatic aberration correction also has a long history, though less effort has been devoted to it than to spherical aberration correction because, in the high-resolution imaging mode, developments in microscope design soon rendered the adverse effect of spherical aberration greater than that of chromatic aberration. This is obvious from an examination of the phase-contrast transfer function, which is a sinusoidal curve in the absence of any energy spread (chromatic effects or temporal partial coherence) and neglecting the nonvanishing source size. The sinusoidal curve is damped by an envelope function, representing the effect of energy spread, but the first zero of the sinusoidal curve (a measure of the limit of resolution determined by the spherical aberration) occurs well before the damping curve reduces it to an unacceptably small value (the so-called information limit). With the arrival of Cs-correctors, however, the situation has changed dramatically and it is now of interest, indeed essential to improve the information limit as well by reducing the undesirable effects of energy spread. The (axial) chromatic aberration of electron lenses is characterized by a coefficient, Cc, which can be written as an integral of the form
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction zi
Cc =
∫
zo
η2 B2 2 h dz 4 φˆ 0
(26a)
for magnetic lenses and Cc = φˆ 10/ 2 ∫
γ φ ′ 2 (3 + 2εφ) 2 h dz 8φˆ 5/ 2
(26b)
for electrostatic lenses. As in the case of Cs (and, indeed, of all the aberration coefficients), the integrands in Eqs. (26a) and (26b) can be written in different ways. The ones given here show immediately that Cc is positive definite and the best that can be hoped for in a round lens is a design for which Cc is small. Over the years, two approaches to the problem of avoiding the limitations imposed by the chromatic aberration of round lenses have emerged. One is a natural continuation of the efforts to reduce the energy spread of the beam emitted by the electron gun; by introducing a monochromator into the column, electrons with energies outside the chosen range can be eliminated. There is of course some loss of beam current but since the energy spread of the filtered beam can be made appreciably narrower than that of the original beam, this reduction in current may be acceptable. This solution is attractive not only in the imaging mode but also for electron energy-loss spectroscopy (EELS) and energy-filtered transmission electron microscopy (EFTEM). We say no more about this here; extensive discussion is to be found in the following books, review articles and other publications: Plies (1978), Tang (1986), Tsuno et al. (1988–9, 1990, 2003, 2005), Tsuno (1991, 1992, 1993, 1999), Reimer (1995), Tsuno and Rouse (1996), Kahl and Rose (1998, 2000), Huber and Plies (1999, 2000), Mook and Kruit (1999a,b, 2000), Mook et al. (1999, 2000), Oshima (1999), Batson et al. (2000), Kahl and Voelkl (2001), Martínez and Tsuno (2002, 2004), Benner et al. (2003c), Mukai et al. (2003a, b), Plies and Bärtle (2003), Ioanoviciu et al. (2004), Huber et al. (2004), Freitag et al. (2005), and Browning et al. (2006). The alternative to using a monochromator is to devise a corrector of chromatic aberration. There are several ways in which such correctors can be conceived, involving the use of superimposed round lens and quadrupole fields, mixed electrostatic–magnetic quadrupoles, or electron mirrors. An early suggestion by Scherzer (1947) involved combining an electrostatic round lens and an electrostatic quadrupole in such a way that the overall chromatic aberration coefficient of the combination is negative. Such a device could then be used to correct the chromatic aberration of a round lens acting as an objective. This suggestion was taken up by Archard (1955) and has subsequently been investigated carefully. In 1961, Kel’man and Yavor showed that the chromatic aberration coefficient of a combined electrostatic–magnetic quadrupole can have either sign, depending on the relative strengths of the component quadrupoles, and hence that such combined lenses could be used to correct chromatic aberration. The result was rediscovered by Septier (1963) and generalized by Hawkes (1964, 1965b). Such combined
711
712
P.W. Hawkes
quadrupoles appear in the latest designs of correctors, intended for the correction of both geometric and chromatic aberrations. Another possibility, pointed out by Rose (1990), involves the use of a long Wien filter. This too has been studied carefully. Finally, an electron mirror can be coupled to a round lens in such a way that the chromatic aberration is cancelled. A practical configuration was examined by Rempfer and Mauck (1985, 1986, 1992) and Skoczylas et al. (1991, 1994). For other proposals, see Shao and Wu (1989, 1990a,b), Rempfer (1990a,b), Crewe et al. (1995a,b, 2000), Tsai (2000), Crewe (2002), and Bimurzaev (2003, 2004). The simple beam-splitter employed by Rempfer and Mauck and later by Rempfer et al. (1997) to separate the incident and emergent beams was dispersive. An improved version, in which the separator is nondispersive, has been studied by Preikszas and Rose (1997) and is incorporated in the optical system of the European SMART (Fink et al., 1997; Wichtendahl et al., 1998; Müller et al., 1999; Hartel et al., 2000, 2002; Preikszas et al., 2000) and of the American PEEM3 (Wan et al., 2004; Wu et al., 2004; Feng et al., 2005; Schmid et al., 2005) projects. 3.2 Spherical Aberration Correctors 3.2.1 Quadrupole–Octopole Correctors For the correction of spherical aberration, Scherzer proposed a sequence of cylindrical lenses and octopoles in his seminal paper of 1947 on ways of avoiding the consequences of his 1936 proof. Cylindrical lenses are the electron optical counterparts of glass lenses with cylindrical (as opposed to spherical) faces and are characterized by a round lens and a quadrupole potential distribution. It was soon realized (Archard, 1954) that quadrupole lenses could be used to advantage instead of cylindrical lenses and the basic corrector configuration, which has remained essentially unaltered, soon emerged (Figure 10–5): a sequence of three or four quadrupole lenses, with an octopole situated at each of the line foci to cancel or overcorrect the aperture aberrations in the x–z and y–z planes, together with a third octopole to complete the task of correction. (Turnbull, 2004, has recently revived the idea of using cylindrical lenses in a combined chromatic and spherical aberration object plane
quadrupole 1 quadrupole 2 first octopole
quadrupole 3 second octopole
round lens
quadrupole 4 final octopole image plane
Figure 10–5. The basic quadrupole corrector arrangement, showing four quadrupoles with octopoles situated at the two line foci and at a third site.
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
corrector.) An important step forward was the introduction of the Russian quadruplet, which has geometric symmetry and electrical antisymmetry about its mid-plane, as we have already mentioned. In common with all multiplets possessing these symmetry properties, such quadruplets have the same focal length in the x–z and y–z planes. For a given geometry, the positions of the foci in these planes can then be made to coincide by suitable choice of the two excitations, whereupon the quadruplet has the same overall paraxial behavior as a round lens. Sets of load curves, showing the appropriate excitations as a function of geometry, are available (see Hawkes, 1970, for many such curves and Baranova and Yavor, 1989). Another interesting early contribution was made by Burfoot (1953), who sought the (electrostatic) configuration with the smallest number of electrodes that would be free of spherical aberration. He established suitably shaped apertures in a three-electrode lens (a remarkable achievement in precomputer times) but concluded that the necessary tolerances could not be achieved in practice; a simpler way of attaining the same objective was proposed by Archard (1958). In 1964, Deltrap showed that the spherical aberration of a test lens could be reduced by means of a quadrupole–octopole corrector and thus confirmed that the principle of correction was sound. However, for the next three decades, all attempts to make a corrector capable of improving the performance of a well-designed objective failed; with hindsight, we can see that these repeated and disappointing failures were due to the natural complexity of the system and to the unstable character of the correction principle mentioned above. Considerable progress was made, notably in the Darmstadt project (Reichenbach and Rose, 1968/9; Rose, 1970, 1971a,b; Bastian et al., 1971; Pöhner 1976, 1977; Bernhard and Koops, 1977; Koops et al., 1977; Koops, 1978, 1978/9; Koops and Bernhard, 1978, Pejas, 1978; Kuck, 1979; Bernhard, 1980; and Fey, 1980; see Scherzer, 1978 for a summing up) and in the Chicago microscope (Crewe et al., 1968; Thomson, 1972; Beck and Crewe, 1974, 1976; Beck, 1977; Crewe, 1978), but neither succeeded in showing any real gain in electron microscope resolution. The tools necessary for the adjustment of such devices were not yet available. In the early 1990s, Zach showed that such correctors could improve the performance of scanning electron microscopes and this finding continues to be exploited in commercial instruments (Zach, 1989, 2000; Zach and Haider, 1995a,b; Honda et al., 2004a,b; Kazumori et al., 2004a,b; Uno et al., 2004a,b). Success came at last in 1997, when Krivanek and colleagues, working in the Cavendish Laboratory in Cambridge, built a corrector equipped with computer control, capable of making the many necessary adjustments rapidly and systematically. This corrector was fitted to a STEM and was hence required to reduce the size of an electron probe (or to allow the angular aperture and hence the probe current to be increased). The Krivanek corrector consists of the basic quadrupoles and octopoles, all under computer control, together with other multipole fields designed to compensate for misalignments and parasitic aberrations in general. In the second-generation Nion corrector, 16 quadrupoles are used together with three combined
713
714
P.W. Hawkes
quadrupole–octopole elements. An additional quadrupole triplet is situated between the corrector and the probe-forming lens. The corrector itself consists of an alternating sequence of quadrupole quadruplets and quadrupole–octopole elements (Figure 10–6a). With this arrangement, the center planes of the quadrupole–octopole elements are all
O
Q
Q+O
O
Q
QQ
Q+O
a)
Q+O
Q
QQ
QQ
O
QQ
Quad. Quadruplet CCD Det. EELS
EELS Aper.
MAADF Gate Valve
HAADF
1kx1k CCD Diffraction Beam Stop
Proj. Lens 2 Pumping Module Proj. Lens 1 Sample Exchange + Storage
OL + Sample Chamber Quad. Triplet
C3/C5 Corrector
Cond. Lens 2 Gate Valve
VOA
Cond. Lens 1 To CFEG
b) Figure 10–6. The Nion quadrupole–octopole corrector incorporated in scanning transmission electron microscopes. (a) The sequence of quadrupole quadruplets and quadrupole–octopoles of which the corrector is composed. Q-Q, quadrupole quadruplet; Q-O, quadrupole-octopole element. (b) Schematic view of the corrector incorporated in an STEM. (After Krivanek et al., 2004, courtesy of the authors and the Belgian Microscopy Society.)
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
conjugates and are also conjugate to a plane close to the coma-free plane of the probe-forming lens. In this way, the fifth-order geometric aberrations of the combination of corrector and probe-forming lens can be eliminated. Software will adjust the various components systematically. The evolution of the corrector, which has been fitted to many VG STEMs, to the two SuperSTEMs at Daresbury, and to the Nion STEM, can be studied in the following publications: Krivanek et al. (1997a,b, 1998, 1999a,b, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004), Dellby et al. (2000, 2001), Batson et al. (2002), Batson (2003), Lupini et al. (2003), Pennycook et al. (2003), Nellist et al. (2004a,b), Dellby et al. (2005), Bacon et al. (2005), Krivanek et al. (2005), and Nellist et al. (2006). Figure 10–6b shows schematically the Nion corrector incorporated in a STEM. The quadrupole–octopole corrector designed for an FEI STEM/TEM is described by Mentink et al. (2004). 3.2.2 Sextupole Correctors Sextupoles were not among the correctors envisaged by Scherzer in his 1947 paper. In 1965, it was pointed out that the third-order aberrations, including of course the spherical aberration, of sextupoles have the same dependence on gradient in the object plane as that of a round lens (Hawkes, 1965a). However, the fact that the lowest order optical effect of sextupoles is not linear, as it is in round lenses and quadrupoles, but quadratic seemed to rule out any hope of using them for aberration correction. It was not until 1979 that combinations of sextupoles and round lenses from which the quadratic effects had been eliminated by compensation were proposed and subsequent developments have confirmed that such correctors are suitable for incorporation into transmission electron microscopes. As we have seen, the second-order effect of a sextupole is characterized by four terms of the form ∫H(z)h3−nkndz, in which H(z) represents the field distribution in the (electrostatic or magnetic) sextupole and h(z), k(z) are two linearly independent solutions of the familiar paraxial equation for round lenses (these solutions collapse to straight lines in the absence of any round lens component). The integer n takes the four values 0, 1, 2, and 3. All four terms can be made to vanish by suitable choice of the symmetry of the configuration; the simplest is shown in Figure 10–7. Before coupling such a device to a microscope objective, we must, however, ensure that the coma-free condition is satisfied. The (isotropic) coma-free plane of an objective is situated within the lens field and must hence be imaged onto the front focal plane of the round-lens doublet in the corrector by means of another doublet (Figure 10–8). If it should be necessary to eliminate the anisotropic coma as well as the isotropic coma, an objective design in which two coils are used in tandem would have to be adopted (Rose, 1971b). Sextupole correction may be traced in the following articles (in addition to the early publications already cited): Haider et al. (1982, 1995, 1998a–c), Rose (1990b, 2002a,b), Haider and Uhlemann (1997), Haider (1998, 2000, 2003), Foschepoth and Kohl (1998), Uhlemann et al. (1998), Urban et al. (1999), Müller et al. (2002), Kabius et al. (2002), Lentzen et al. (2002), Liu et al. (2002), Benner et al. (2003a,b, 2004a,b), Chang et al. (2003), Hosokawa and Sawada (2003), Hosokawa et al. (2003), Jia et al.
715
716
P.W. Hawkes
Figure 10–7. Sextupole correctors. Course of the second-order fundamental rays in the corrector shown in Figure 10–3. (After Rose, 2003c, courtesy of the author and Springer-Verlag.)
(2003), Sawada et al. (2004a–c), Haider et al. (2004), Hartel et al. (2004), Titchmarsh et al. (2004), Hutchison et al. (2005), Haider and Müller (2005), Müller et al. (2005), and Chang et al. (2006). 3.2.3 Foil Correctors The suggestion that spherical aberration can be corrected by incorporating a foil in a rotationally symmetric lens, thus introducing a
Figure 10–8. Sextupole correctors. Correction of coma as well as spherical aberration requires a more complex system. The transfer doublet between the objective lens and the corrector allows for the fact that the coma-free plane lies within the magnetic field of the objective. (After Rose, 2003c, courtesy of the author and Springer-Verlag.)
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
discontinuity in the electric field, has been very thoroughly explored by a Japanese group (see Hanai et al., 1986, 1994, 1995, 1998). In the earlier studies, the lens shown in Figure 10–9 was fitted in a TEM and was shown to reduce the spherical aberration. Subsequent work has extended this to probe-forming instruments, notably the STEM, where again the principle was shown to be valid. The lifetime of the foil was, however, rather short as a result of the build-up of contamination. For a recent work using a curved mesh, see Matsuda et al. (2005). A very different type of foil corrector has been investigated by van Aken (van Aken et al., 2002a,b, 2004, 2005; van Aken, 2005), who attempted to exploit the marked increase in the mean free path of electrons in metal foils at very low voltages. If the latter is atomically flat, a mean free path of the order of 5 nm is expected for several metals
a)
b) Figure 10–9. Foil lens. (a) Schematic cross section of the foil lens. (b) A practical design, showing the foil lens incorporated in a magnetic objective. (After Hanai et al., 1998, courtesy of the authors and Oxford University Press.)
717
718
P.W. Hawkes
Figure 10–10. The van Aken low-energy foil corrector. Electrons are slowed down to a very low energy before passing through the correcting foil and then accelelerated again before entering the microscope column. (After van Aken, 2005, courtesy of the author.)
at 5 eV above the Fermi level and a transmission of about 10% is predicted for thin foils (∼5 nm). By sandwiching the foil between a pair of electrodes, which first retard the incident electrons and then accelerate them again, correction of both chromatic and spherical aberration is in principle possible. Figure 10–10 shows schematically a microscope column incorporating such a corrector. 3.3 Chromatic Aberration Correctors 3.3.1 All-Electrostatic Correctors One form of the chromatic aberration coefficients of a system containing electrostatic round lens fields and electrostatic quadrupole fields is 1 φ′ ( hx′ 2 − hx hx′ )dz 2φ φ1 / 2 1 φ′ Ccy = φ0 ∫ 1/ 2 ( hy′ 2 − hy hy′ )dz 2φ φ Ccx = φ0 ∫
(27)
By introducing the Picht transformation, φ Hx = φ0
1/ 4
φ hx , H y = φ0
1/ 4
hy
(28)
these take the form Ccx = φ0 ∫
2
1 1 φ′2 2 φ′ H x dz H x′ − H x − 2φ 16 φ 2 φ 2
(29)
φ′ 1 φ′2 2 1 H y dz Ccy = φ0 ∫ H y′ − H y − 2φ 16 φ 2 φ If the quadratic term could be reduced to zero (or at least made smaller than the absolute value of the negative term), the overall chromatic aberration coefficient would be negative and the device would hence be suitable for use as a corrector. The quadratic term vanishes if the field distribution is such that the paraxial ray Hx (z) = Cφ1/2 and similarly for Hy (z), where C is an arbitrary constant. In general, this is not an acceptable form for Hx (z) and Hy (z), which must vanish in the object (and
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
image) planes. If, however, the corrector is telescopic, such a form is permissible. By substituting this expression for Hx (z) and Hy (z), and hence hx (z) and hy (z), back into the paraxial equation, it is trivial to show that the field functions φ(z) and p2(z) must be related by the formula p2 = φ ′′ −
φ′2 8φ
(30)
Configurations in which this condition (Scherzer, 1947) is closely satisfied have been found by Weißbäcker and Rose (2000, 2001, 2002) and by Maas and co-workers (Maas et al., 2000, 2001, 2003; Henstra and Krijn, 2000). In the studies of Weißbäcker and Rose, several configurations are examined, in which the complexity increases with the practical usefulness of the corrector. In the simplest design, four distinct elements are employed and the corrector is capable of correcting both the chromatic and the spherical aberration in a scanning instrument. The first element is a quadrupole, the purpose of which is to render the incoming beam astigmatic. This is followed by a three-element corrector consisting of quadrupole fields superimposed on a (round) einzel lens field. A second corrector unit cancels the chromatic aberration in the other plane. Octopoles are incorporated so that the spherical aberration can be corrected simultaneously. Unfortunately, such a corrector introduces large off-axis aberrations and is hence not suitable for use with transmission (fixed-beam) electron microscopes. Weißbäcker and Rose therefore consider first an extended version in which a third such element is added (Figure 10–11) and then propose a doubly-symmetric electrostatic corrector (DECO), in which each correcting element is enclosed within two quadrupole doublets (Figure 10–12). The symmetry conditions can now be arranged in such a way that the chromatic aberration and the coma vanish, while the spherical aberration is corrected by means of octopoles as usual. In the complementary investigations of Henstra, Maas, Mentink, and co-workers, a configuration consisting of nine elements (Figure 10–13) is explored. At the outer extremities are quadrupoles to create astigmatism and subsequently annihilate it. In the center are five combined round lens and quadrupole units. Two other quadrupoles are included to match the slowly decaying round lens field of the first and last combined elements. For further work on this approach, see Baranova et al. (2004). 3.3.2 Mixed Quadrupole Correctors Quadrupole lenses consisting of four electrodes and four magnetic poles situated midway between the electrodes have the power of correcting the chromatic aberration of a round lens. They must of course be part of a suitable configuration and are currently incorporated in the complex superaplanator and ultracorrector described in Section 3.4. Such correctors have not been seriously considered for correction of Cc in the transmission electron microscope in recent years, for the simpler configurations increased the spherical (and other) aberrations unreasonably. However, they have been reconsidered recently (Haider and
719
720
P.W. Hawkes
yb xa
z0
a)
z0 l0 z1
zm z3
l1
z4
zM
z5
z6
z7
z8
zE
b) Q0
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
30 25 xγ 20 15 10
yδ
5 z [mm]
c)
20
40
60
Figure 10–11. Aplanatic corrector of spherical and chromatic aberration. (a) A three-element corrector, in which the first and third elements cancel the chromatic aberration in the x–z plane while the central element cancels it in the y–z plane. (b) Axial rays in the first half of the corrector. (c) Field rays in the first half of the corrector. (After Weißbäcker and Rose, 2002, courtesy of the authors and Oxford University Press.)
Figure 10–12. Doubly symmetric electrostatic corrector (DECO) of spherical and chromatic aberration. (a) Axial and field rays in one-half of the DECO; each half consists of a corrector enclosed between quadupole doublets. (b) Details of the axial rays in one unit of the DECO. (c) Details of the field rays in the first half of the DECO. (After Weißbäcker and Rose, 2002, courtesy of the authors and Oxford University Press.)
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
ai) yb / f
xa / f object
objective- entrance lens doublet
correcting element
exit doublet
yd
xg
aii) Qn
Q0
Q1 Q2 Q1
Q0
Qn
3 2
yβ / f
1 z [mm]
0 50
zM
100
–1 –2
Qα / f
–3
b) Qn
Q0
Q1 Q2 Q1
Q0
Qn
6 yd 4 2 xg 50 –2
–4
c)
–6
100
zM
z [mm]
721
722
P.W. Hawkes
a) 3E+08
Quadrupole field [V/m/m]
2E+08 1E+08 0E+00 -15
-10
-5
5
10
15
-1E+08
Scherzer's condition 3D Quadrupole
b)
0
-2E+08 -3E+08 Z [mm]
Figure 10–13. Electrostatic correction of chromatic aberration. (a) Rays in a quadrupole quadruplet or sextuplet. (b) Match between the potentials needed to satisfy Scherzer’s condition and those in the corrector. (See color plate.)
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
723
2.5 2
X or Y (arb. units)
1.5 1 0.5 0 -90
-60
-0.5
0
30
60
90
-1
XA YA XB YB
c)
-30
-1.5 -2 -2.5 Z [mm]
Figure 10–13. Continued (c) Gaussian rays in the sextuplet after correcting elements have been placed at the line foci. The chromatic aberration has been corrected and the residual chromatic aberration of magnification is small. (After Maas et al., 2001, 2003, courtesy of the authors, SPIE, and the Microscopy Society of America.)
Müller, 2004), for there exist more elaborate arrangements that do not have this handicap. Details are not available as yet. 3.3.3 Wien Filters and Correction In an attempt to design a corrector that is reasonably easy to align and consists of as few separate elements as possible, Rose (1990) has examined the properties of an inhomogeneous Wien filter. If such a filter is to correct chromatic aberration instead of acting as a highly dispersive device, it must be nondispersive, double focusing, and free of all second rank aberrations (apart from the desired rotationally symmetric chromatic aberration). We have seen in other electron optical configurations how useful symmetry and antisymmetry are to eliminate certain aberrations. Here, all geometric second-order aberrations can be excluded by ensuring that the fundamental rays are antisymmetric with respect to the mid-plane of the filter or to the mid-plane of the first or second half of the filter. Rose’s extremely complete study shows that a configuration can be found that will correct chromatic aberration. Furthermore, by adding sextupoles before and after the corrector (Figure 10–14), axial chromatic aberration and spherical aberration can be corrected independently. This idea has been revived by Mentink et al. (1999) and Steffen et al. (2000), who were seeking further simplification and reduction of the number of optical elements and excitations. Rose’s device consisted of a relatively long combined multipole (octopole or dodecapole) with both magnetic and electrostatic components (as in all Wien filters) for chromatic correction, with external sextupoles. In this new design, chromatic correction is achieved by means of the usual magnetic and electrostatic fields of the Wien filter onto which an electrostatic quad-
724
P.W. Hawkes
transfer sextupole 1 lens 1
transfer lens 2
achromator
sextupole 2
Uβδ Uββ
z
–Uδδ
h
h f1
f1
l
f2 = f1
f2 = f1 N
N
a)
corrector object objective plane double lens
sextu- transfer achropole 1 lens 1 mator
transfer sextulens 2 pole 2
axial ray Wx
Z
ZO
field ray
OA
O1
A1
O2
O4
A4
b) Figure 10–14. (a) Wien filter flanked by two sextupoles and the necessary transfer lenses, capable of – correcting both chromatic and spherical aberration. The nodal points N and N coincide with the coma-free points. (b) The corrector in conjunction with a coma-free objective. (After Rose, 1990, courtesy of the author and the Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft.)
rupole is superimposed. No other magnetic fields are required. Spherical aberration is corrected by superimposing sextupole fields, which are of opposite sign in the first and second halves of the Wien filter zone. Unwanted aberrations are introduced by the fringing fields at the extremities of the corrector but it should be possible to control them by shaping the ends of the electrodes and magnetic poles.
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
725
3.3.4 Mirror Correctors Several schemes for compensating the aberrations of round lenses by introducing an electron mirror (see Recknagel, 1937, for early work on electron mirrors) into the optical system have been proposed (Zworykin et al., 1945; Ramberg, 1949; Kasper, 1968/9). Aberration correction has now reached the stage at which simultaneous correction of all the aberrations that are liable to impair the performance of the instrument in question must be envisaged: correction of individual aberrations without considering the effect of the remainder is no longer sufficient. For this reason, we describe here only the scheme devised by Preikszas and Rose (1997) and surveyed by Hartel et al. (2002), intended for the spectromicroscope for all relevant techniques (SMART) project at BESSY II and also adopted for PEEM3 at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Rose et al., 2004; Feng et al., 2005; Schmid et al., 2005). This differs from earlier schemes, notably that of Rempfer and Mauck (1992) and Rempfer et al. (1997), in that the beam splitter, the role of which is to separate the beam incident on the mirror from the beam emerging from it, is nondispersive (Figure 10–15); however, for the application for which it was designed, a low-energy emission microscope, the corrector shown in Figure 10–15 is effective. A four-electrode mirror, such as that shown in Figure 10–16, offers enough degrees of freedom to adjust the focal length and spherical and chromatic aberration coefficients satisfactorily. As an example, Preikszas and Rose (1997) show that the spherical and chromatic aberration coefficients can be chosen anywhere inside the shaded region in Figure 10–17 for a fixed position of the Gaussian image plane. Such a mirror could be combined with a dispersion-free magnetic beam splitter as shown in Figure 10–18a. Figure 10–18b shows the device incorporated in the SMART.
C Magnet
Condenser Lens
Beam Separator Interface Lens
Electron Source
T2
Image of Source Overcorrected Image Electron Mirror
B (Separating) Magnet
Shadow Pattern Final Image
T1
Aberration Corrector A Magnet
Objective Lens
Fine Mesh
Figure 10–15. The optical system described by Rempfer et al. (1997) for correcting chromatic and spherical aberration with the aid of an electron mirror. T1 and T2 are lens triplets, which act as transfer lenses. The shadow thrown by the fine mesh gives a measure of the aberration coefficients. (After Rempfer et al., 1997, courtesy of the authors and the Microscopy Society of America.)
726
P.W. Hawkes Φ
Φ1
Φ2
Φ
3.6 mm
optic axis
Figure 10–16. Section of a tetrode mirror. The potentials applied to the electrons determine the focal length and the chromatic and spherical aberration coefficients. (After Preikszas and Rose, 1997, courtesy of the authors and Oxford University Press.)
3.4 All-Purpose Correctors In his keynote lecture on “High-Performance Electron Microscopes of the Future,” delivered at the twelfth European Congress on Electron Microscopy in Brno, 2000, Rose described a “hexapole planator” capable of correcting the field curvature and (third-order) astigmatism. Such correction is essential for projection lithography systems. This proposal was explored in detail by Munro et al. (2001) who, in an important paper, first examined the present limitations of projection systems for charged particles and then analyzed an electrostatic and a magnetic configuration free of all third-order geometric aberrations, inspired by Rose’s hexapole planator. Subsequently, two very complex correctors have been proposed by Rose, which are capable of correcting the spherical and chromatic aberrations as well as other primary aberrations that could be harmful once the axial aberrations have been brought under control (Rose, 2003, 2004, 2005). These are the superaplanator and the ultracorrector. The first of these is suitable for a transmission electron microscope: it consists of two symmetrical quadrupole quintuplets and three (or more) octopoles and corrects spherical and chromatic aberration. Very high stability of the excitations is essential (Rose, 2005), of the order of a few parts in 107, but this is attainable today. Symmetry is exploited to make the device as easy to use as possible. Thus the quadupole fields are symmetric with respect to the center plane of each quintuplet; conversely, the whole -70
-60
-50
-40
-30
-20
-10
[m] -5 -10 -15 -20 -25 [km]
Figure 10–17. Behavior of the aberration coefficients of the tetrode mirror of Figure 10–16. For a fixed image plane, the spherical and chromatic aberration coefficients fall within the shaded zone. (After Preikszas and Rose, 1997, courtesy of the authors and Oxford University Press.)
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
727
specimen and objective lens
beam separator
optic axis tetrode mirror
projective system
a) Objective
Transfer optics
Mirror corrector
electric/ magnetic specimen deflector objective lens
Energy filter
electron source deflector D1 transfer lens T1 condenser D2 L3 L4 D3
field aperture
projector
energy selection slit
dipole P1
L5 T2 D4
Projector/Detector
quadrupole
T3 D5
P4
H6 field lens L1
beam separator
L2 x-ray mirror
optic axis hexapole H1
H2
H5
H3
H4
P2
x-ray illumination
b)
energy selection slit for x-ray illumination
camera system
apertures
electron mirror
dodecapole
P3
electric-magnetic multipole deflector elements 0
100
200
300
400
500
600 mm
electrode surfaces
axial ray
polepieces
field ray
coils
dispersive ray
Figure 10–18. Incorporation of the tetrode mirror of Figure 10–16 into a complete system. The beam separator is free of dispersion. (a) Basic configuration. (b) The entire layout of the SMART (spectromicroscope for all relevant techniques). [(a) After Preikszas and Rose, 1997, courtesy of the authors and Oxford University Press. (b) After Hartel et al., 2002, courtesy of the authors and Elsevier.]
P.W. Hawkes
(double-quintuplet) unit exhibits antisymmetry about its mid-plane (the plane midway between the two quintuplets). An octopole is placed in this mid-plane and at the center of each quintuplet (Figure 10–19). The superaplanator is adequate for the transmission electron microscope, where no particular attention need be paid to thirdorder astigmatism and field curvature, the zone to be imaged being so small. In electron projection lithography, however, it is desirable to correct all the primary chromatic and geometric aberrations. This can in principle be achieved with the configuration known as the ultracorrector. Here, two identical multipole multiplets are used. Each of these consists of seven quadrupoles and seven octopoles, themselves disposed symmetrically about the center plane of the multiplet. Once again, the multiplet fields are antisymmetric with respect to the plane midway between two multiplets in which an additional octopole is situated (Figure 10–20). Detailed description of the modes of action of these complex structures is to be found in the work of Rose already cited. The suitability of these correctors for the Transmission Electron Aberration-corrected Microscope (TEAM) project is currently (2005) being examined (O’Keefe, 2003, 2004; Kabius et al., 2004).
4 Concluding Remarks If any lesson is to be learned from past attempts to correct spherical and chromatic aberration, it is that complex systems require a rapid and efficient means of adjustment and that beyond a certain degree of complexity, only computer control offers the necessary speed and flexibility. Nevertheless, it remains important to simplify the task as far as possible and this is achieved by exploiting the symmetry properties. The intrinsic simplification of the optics provided by the Russian quadruplet (or multiplet) has long been known and, more recently, very
3
a.u.
728
2
xα
1
Ψ2s l
0
yδ –1 –2 xγ –3
0
yβ 2
4
6
8
10
12
Figure 10–19. The superaplanator. (After Rose, 2005, courtesy of the author and Elsevier.)
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
Figure 10–20. The ultracorrector. (After Rose, 2005, courtesy of the author and Elsevier.)
ingenious blends of symmetry and antisymmetry have been beneficial, or indeed indispensable, in the design of Ω and related types of filters, such as the mandoline filter (see Rose and Krahl, 1995, for a thorough account and Tsuno, 2001, for a schematic appraisal). The symmetry and antisymmetry on which the multicomponent structures of the superaplanator and the untracorrector are based not only help us to understand how they work but also render the adjustment more systematic and less liable to instability. The quest for aberration correctors has always been fuelled by the desire for ever higher resolution but, now that correction has been achieved, microscopists are beginning to realise that such devices will be useful in many other areas of microscopy. In-situ microscopy requires lenses with ample space between the polepieces and the coefficients of spherical and chromatic aberration of such lenses are large. By correcting these aberrations, in-situ microscopy should be capable of providing much finer information. In the life sciences, chromatic correction will make it possible to work with thicker specimens. And no doubt this is only the beginning. The new century is witnessing a new era in electron microscopy.
5 Appendix I 5.1 Power Series Expansions of Electrostatic Potential and Vector Potential The power series expansions used in the foregoing text are identical with those adopted in Hawkes and Kasper (1989) and are reproduced here for the reader’s convenience. However, since the work of Rose is very frequently referred to, the relation between the notation used in his chapter in Ernst and Rühle (2003) and that employed here is also given.
729
730
P.W. Hawkes
5.1.1 Expansions for the Electrostatic Potential In Hawkes and Kasper (1989), the electrostatic potential is written as 1 2 1 2 ( x + y 2 ) φ ′′( z) + ( x 2 + y 2 ) − xF(z)1 − yF2 (z) 4 64 1 1 + ( x 2 + y 2 ) ( xF1′′+ yF2′′) + ( x 2 − y 2 ) p2 (z) + xyq2 (z) 2 8 1 1 2 2 2 2 − ( x + y ) ( x − y ) p2′′ − ( x 2 + y 2 ) xyq2′′ 12 24 1 1 − ( x 3 − 3xy 2 ) p3 ( z) + ( y 3 − 3x 2 y ) q3 (zz) 6 6 1 4 1 2 2 4 + ( x − 6x y + y )p4 (z) + ( x 2 − y 2 ) xyq4 ( z) 24 6
Φ ( x,y,z ) = φ(z) −
Rose (2003c) uses the expansion ∞
∞
ϕ(w , z) = Re ∑ ∑ (−)l m=0 l=0
( )
m! ww l m [ 2 l ] w Φ m ( z) l !(m + l)! 4
in which w = x + iy and [2l] signifies 2l-fold differentiation with respect to z. An overbar indicates the complex conjugate. This leads to the following correspondences: φ(z) = Φ 0 (z) F1 (z) = −Φ(1r) , F2 (z) = −Φ(1i) , Φ1 = −(F1 + iF2 ) 1 (p2 + iq2 ) 2 1 p3 ( z) = −6Φ(3r ) , q3 ( z) = −6Φ(3i ) , Φ 3 = − ( p3 + iq3 ) 6 1 ( p4 + iq4 ) p4 ( z) = 24Φ(4r ) , q4 ( z) = 24Φ(4i ) , Φ 4 = 24
p2 (z) = 2Φ(2r) , q2 (z) = 2Φ(2i) , Φ 2 =
and we have written Φ m = Φ(mr ) + iΦ(mi) 5.1.2 Expansions for the Vector Potential In Hawkes and Kasper, the components of the vector potential are written as
(
)
y 1 1 B − ( x 2 + y 2 )B ′′ + ( x 2 − y 2 )B2′ 2 8 4 1 1 1 2 xy( x 2 + y 2 )B1′′′ − ( x − y 2 )( x 2 + y 2 )B2′′− xyB1′ + 2 24 48 1 1 − ( x 3 − 3 xy 2 )Q2′ − ( y 3 − 3 x 2 y )P2′ 12 12 1 1 + ( x 4 − 6 x 2 y 2 + y 4 )Q3′ − ( x 2 − y 2 )xyP3′ 48 12
Ax = −
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction
Ay =
(
)
x 1 1 B − ( x 2 + y 2 )B ′′ + ( x 2 − y 2 )B1′ 2 8 4 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 xy( x 2 + y 2 )B2′′′ − ( x − y )( x + y )B1′′′+ xyB2′ − 2 24 48 1 1 − ( x 3 − 3 xy 2 )P2′ + ( y 3 − 3 x 2 y )Q2′ 12 12 1 4 1 + ( x − 6 x 2 y 2 + y 4 )P3′ + ( x 2 − y 2 )xyQ3′ 48 12
1 Az = − xB2 ( z)1 − yB1 ( z) + ( x 2 + y 2 )( xB2′′− yB1′′) 8 1 1 2 2 + ( x − y )Q2 ( z) − xyP2 ( z) − ( x 2 + y 2 )( x 2 − y 2 )Q2′′ 24 2 1 1 + ( x 2 + y 2 )xyP2′′− ( x 3 − 3 xy 2 )Q3 ( z) 12 6 1 3 1 4 − ( y − 3 x 2 y )P3 ( z) + ( x − 6 x 2 y 2 + y 4 )Q4 ( z) 6 24 1 − ( x 2 − y 2 )xyP4 ( z) 6 In Rose, the same gauge is adopted and the components of the vector potential are given by A = Ax + iAy = ∞
∞
∞
( )
(−)l m! ww l m + 1 [ 2 l + 1] w Ψ m ( z) 4 m = 0 l = 0 2i l !( m + 1 + l )!
Az = Im ∑ ∑ (−)l m=0 l=0
∞
∑∑
( )
m! ww l m [ 2 l ] w Ψ m ( z) l !(m + l)! 4
The correspondence is now Ψ1 = −(B1 + iB2 ) 1 Ψ 2 = (P2 + iQ2 ) 2 1 Ψ 3 = − (P3 + iQ3 ) 6 1 Ψ4 = (P4 + iQ4 ) 24
References Aken, R.H. van (2005). Low-energy electron beams through ultra-thin foils, applications for electron microscopy. Proefschrift, Delft. Aken, R.H. van , Hagen, C.W., Barth, J.E. and Kruit, P. (2002a). Low-energy foil aberration corrector. Ultramicroscopy 93, 321–330. Aken, R.H. van, Hagen, C.W., Barth, J.E. and Kruit, P. (2002b). Concept for a low energy foil corrector. In Proceedings of the 15th International Congress on Electron Microscopy, Durban (R. Cross, J. Engelbrecht, M. Witcomb, and P. Richards, Eds.), Vol. 1, 1101–1102.
731
732
P.W. Hawkes Aken, R.H. van, Lenc, M. and Barth, J.E. (2004). Aberration integrals for the low-voltage foil corrector. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A519, 205–215. Archard, G.D. (1953). Magnetic electron lens aberrations due to mechanical defects. J. Sci. Instrum. 30, 352–358. Archard, G.D. (1954). Requirements contributing to the design of devices used in correcting electron lenses. Br. J. Appl. Phys. 5, 294–299. Archard, G.D. (1955). A possible chromatic aberration system for electron lenses. Proc. Phys. Soc. (London) 68, 817–829. Archard, G.D. (1958). An unconventional electron lens. Proc. Phys. Soc. (London) 72, 135–137. Bacon, N.J., Corbin, G.J., Dellby, N., Hrncirik, P., Krivanek, O.L., McManamaSmith, A., Murfitt, M.F. and Szilagyi, Z.S. (2005). Nion UltraSTEM: an aberration-corrected STEM for imaging and analysis. Microsc. Microanal. 11 (Supplement 2), 1422–1423 Baranova, L.A. and Yavor, S. Ya. (1989). The optics of round and multipole electrostatic lenses. Adv. Electron. Electron Phys. 76, 1–207. Baranova, L.A., Read, F.H. and Cubric, D. (2004). Computational simulation of an electrostatic aberration corrector for a low-voltage scanning electron microscope. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A519, 42–47. Bastian, B., Spengler, K. and Typke, D. (1971). An electric–magnetic octupole element to correct spherical and chromatic aberrations of electron lenses. Optik 33, 591–596. Batson, P.E. (2003). Aberration correction results in the IBM STEM instrument. Ultramicroscopy 96, 239–249. Batson, P.E., Mook, H.W. and Kruit, P. (2000). High brightness monochromator for STEM. In Microbeam Analysis 2000 (D.B. Williams and R. Shimizu, Eds.), 213–214 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Batson, P.E., Dellby, N. and Krivanek, O.L. (2002). Sub-ångstrom resolution using aberration corrected optics. Nature 418, 617–620. Beck, V. (1977). Experiments with a quadrupole–octupole corrector in a STEM. Proc. Annu. Meeting EMSA 35, 90–91. Beck, V.D. (1979). A hexapole spherical aberration corrector. Optik 53, 241–255. Beck, V. and Crewe, A.V. (1974). A quadrupole octupole corrector for a 100 kV STEM. Proc. Annu. Meeting EMSA 32, 426–427. Beck, V. and Crewe, A.V. (1976). Progress in aberration correction in a STEM. Proc. Annu. Meeting EMSA 34, 578–579. Benner, G., Orchowski, A., Haider, M. and Hartel, P. (2003a). State of the first aberration-corrected, monochromatized 200 kV FEG-TEM. Microsc. Microanal. 9 (Supplement 2), 938–939. Benner, G., Matijevich, M., Orchowski, A., Schindler, B., Haider, M. and Hartel, P. (2003b). State of the first aberration-corrected, monochromatized 200 kV FEG–TEM. Microsc. Microanal. 9 (Supplement 3), 38–39. Benner, G., Essers, E., Huber, B. and Orchowski, A. (2003c). Design and first results of SESAM. Microsc. Microanal. 9 (Supplement 3), 66–67. Benner, G., Essers, E., Matijevic, M., Orchowski, A., Schlossmacher, P. and Thesen, A. (2004a). Performance of monochromized and aberrationcorrected TEMs. Microsc. Microanal. 10 (Supplement 2), 108–109. Benner, G., Matijevic, M., Orchowski, A., Schlossmacher, P., Thesen, A., Haider, M. and Hartel. P. (2004b). Sub-Ångstrom and sub-eV resolution with the analytical SATEM. In Materials Research in an Aberration-Free Environment. Microsc. Microanal. 10 (Supplement 3), 6–7. Bernhard, W. (1980). Erprobung eines sphärisch und chromatisch korrigierten Elektronenmikroskops. Optik 57, 73–94.
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction Bernhard, W. and Koops, H. (1977). Kompensation der Farbabhängigkeit der Vergrößung und der Farbabhängigkeit der Bilddrehung eines Elektronenmikroskops. Optik 47, 55–64. Bimurzaev, S.B., Serikbaeva, G.S. and Yakushev, E.M. (2003). Electrostatic mirror objective with eliminated spherical and axial chromatic aberrations. J. Electron Microsc. 52, 365–368. Bimurzaev, S.B., Serikbaeva, G.S. and Yakushev, E.M. (2004). Calculation of the focussing quality of the electrostatic mirror objective free of the third-order spherical aberration. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A519, 70–75. Browning, N.D., Arslan, I., Erni, R., Idrobo, J.C., Ziegler, A., Bradley, J., Dai, Z., Stach, E.A. and Bleloch, A. (2006). Monochromators and aberration correctors: taking EELS to new levels of energy and spatial resolution. J. Phys. Conf. 26, 59–64 [EMAG-NANO 2005] Burfoot, J.C. (1953). Correction of electrostatic lenses by departure from rotational symmetry. Proc. Phys. Soc. (London) B66, 775–792. Calvo, M. (2002). Transfer theory and image formation in a time dependent aberrationless magnetic field lens. Optik 113, 233–240. Calvo, M. (2004). Optimal resolution of a time-dependent aberrationless magnetic lens. Ultramicroscopy 99, 179–187. Calvo, M. and Lazcano, P. (2002). Theory of a time dependent magnetic lens. Optik 113, 31–34. Calvo, M. and Laroze, D. (2002). Aberrations theory of a time dependent magnetic field lens. Optik 113, 429–434. Chand, G., Saxton, W.O. and Kirkland, A.I. (1995). Aberration measurement and automated alignment of the TEM. In Electron Microscopy and Analysis 1995 (D. Cherns, Ed.), 297–300 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Chang, L.Y., Chen, F.R., Kirkland, A.I. and Kai, J.J. (2003). Calculations of spherical aberration-corrected imaging behaviour. J. Electron Microsc. 52, 359–364. Chang, L.Y., Kirkland, A.I. and Titchmarsh, J.M. (2006). On the importance of fifth-order spherical aberration for a fully corrected electron microscope. Ultramicroscopy 106, 301–306 Chao, L.C., Orloff, J. and Wang, L. (1997). Spherical aberration corrector using space charge. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B15, 2732–2736. Crewe, A.V. (1978). Is there a future for the STEM? In Proceedings of the Ninth International Congress on Electron Microscopy, Toronto (J.M. Sturgess, Ed.), Vol. 3, 197–204 (Microscopical Society of Canada, Toronto). Crewe, A.V. (1980). Studies on sextupole correctors. Optik 57, 313–327. Crewe, A.V. (1982). A system for the correction of axial aperture aberrations in electron lenses. Optik 60, 271–281. Crewe, A.V. (2002). Some Chicago aberrations. Microsc. Microanal. 8 (Supplement 2), 4–5. Crewe, A.V. and Kopf, D. (1980a). A sextupole system for the correction of spherical aberration. Optik 55, 1–10. Crewe, A.V. and Kopf, D. (1980b). Limitations of sextupole correctors. Optik 56, 391–399. Crewe, A.V., Cohen, D. and Meads, P. (1968). A multipole element for the correcting of spherical aberration. In Proceedings of the Fourth Regional Conference on Electron Microscopy, Rome (D.S. Bocciarelli, Ed.), Vol. I, 183 (Tipographia Poliglotta Vaticana, Rome). Crewe, A.V., Ruan, S., Tsai, F. and Korda, P. (1995a). The first test on a magnetically focused mirror corrector. In Electron Microscopy and Analysis 1995 (D. Cherns, Ed.), 301–304 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Crewe, A.V., Tsai, F., Korda, F. and Ruan, S. (1995b). The first test on a magnetically focused mirror corrector. In Microscopy and Analysis 1995 (G.W. Bailey,
733
734
P.W. Hawkes M.H. Ellisman, R.A. Hennigar and N.J. Zaluzec, Eds.), 562–563 (Jones and Begell, New York). Crewe, A.V., Ruan, S., Korda, P. and Tsai, F.C. (2000). Studies of a magnetically focused electrostatic mirror. I. Experimental test of the first order properties. J. Microsc. 197, 110–117. Dellby, N., Krivanek, O.L. and Lupini, A.R. (2000). Progress in aberrationcorrected STEM. Microsc. Microanal. 6 (Supplement 2), 100–101. Dellby, N., Krivanek, O.L., Nellist, P.D., Batson, P.E. and Lupini, A.R. (2001). Progress in aberration-corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy. J. Electron Microsc. 50, 177–185. Dellby, N., Krivanek, O.L., Murfitt, M.F. and Nellist, P.D. (2005). Design and testing of a quadrupole/octupole C3/C5 aberration corrector. Microsc. Microanal. 11 (Supplement 2), 2130–2131. Deltrap, J.M.H. (1964). Correction of spherical aberration with combined quadrupole–octopole units. In Proceedings of the Third European Regional Conference on Electron Microscopy, Prague (M. Titlbach, Ed.), Vol. A, 45–46 (Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences, Prague). Der-Shvarts, G.V. (1954). [Influence of imperfections of the rotational symmetry of the focusing fields on the resolution of the magnetic objectives of electron microscopes]. Zh. Tekh. Fiz. 24, 859–870. Dragt, A.J. and Forest, E. (1986). Lie algebraic theory of charged-particle optics and electron microscopes. Adv. Electron. Electron Phys. 67, 65–120. Dunin-Borkowski, R.E., Kasama, T., Cervera, L., Twitchett, A.C., Midgeley, P. A., Robins, A.C., Smith, D.W., Gronsky, J.J., Thomas, C.M., Fischione, P.E., Hetherington, C.J.D. and Kirkland, A.I. (2004). Aberration correction: Some advantages and alternatives. In Materials Research in an Aberration-Free Environment. Microsc. Microanal. 10 (Supplement 3), 22–23. Dymnikov, A.D. and Yavor, S. Ya. (1963). [Four quadrupole lenses as an analogue of an axially symmetric system]. Zh. Tekh. Fiz. 33, 851–858; Sov. Phys. Tech. Phys. 8, 639–643. Feng, J., Forest, E., Macdowell, A.A., Marcus, M., Padmore, H., Raoux, S., Robin, D., Scholl, A., Schlueter, R., Schmid, P., Stöhr, J., Wan, W., Wei, D.H. and Wu, Y. (2005). An x-ray photoemission electron microscope using an electron mirror aberration corrector for the study of complex materials. J. Phys. Condensed Matter 17, S1339–S1350 Fey, G. (1980). Elektrische Versorgung eines elektronenoptischen Korrektivs. Optik 55, 55–65. Fink, R., Weiss, M.R., Umbach, E., Preikszas, D., Rose, H., Spehr, R., Hartel, P., Engel, W., Degenhardt, R., Wichtendahl, R., Kuhlenbeck, H., Erlebach, W., Ihmann, K., Schlögl, R., Freund, H.-J., Bradshaw, A.M., Lilienkamp, G., Schmidt, T., Bauer, E. and Benner, G. (1997). SMART: A planned ultrahighresolution spectromicroscope for BESSY II. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 84, 231–250. Foschepoth, M. and Kohl, H. (1998). Amplitude contrast—a way to obtain directly interpretable high-resolution images in a spherical-aberrationcorrected transmission electron microscope. Phys. Status Solidi A 166, 357–366. Freitag, B., Kujawa, S., Mul, P.M., Tiemeijer, P.C. and Snoeck, E. (2004a). First experimental proof of spatial resolution improvement in a monochromized and Cs-corrected TEM. In Proceedings of the Eighth Asia–Pacific Conference on Electron Microscopy, Kanazawa (N. Tanaka, Y. Takano, H. Mori, H. Seguchi, S. Iseki, H. Shimada and E. Simamura, Eds.), 18–19 (8APEM Publication Committee, Uchinada, Ishikawa). Freitag, B., Kujawa, S., Mul, P.M. and Tiemeijer, P.C. (2004b). First experimental proof of spatial resolution improvement in a monochromized and Cs-
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction corrected TEM. In Materials Research in an Aberration-Free Environment. Microsc. Microanal. 10 (Supplement 3), 4–5. Freitag, B., Kujawa, S., Mul, P.M., Ringnalda, J. and Tiemeijer, P.C. (2005). Breaking the spherical and chromatic aberration barrier in transmission electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 102, 209–214. Gabor, D. (1950). Electron optics at high frequencies and at relativistic velocities. Rev. Opt. 29, 209–231. Glaser, W. (1940). Über ein von sphärische Aberration freies Magnetfeld. Z. Phys. 116, 19–33 and 734–735. Glaser, W. (1942). Über elektronenoptische Abbildung bei gestörter Rotationssymmetrie. Z. Phys. 120, 1–15. Glaser, W. and Schiske, P. (1953). Bildstorungen durch Polschuhasymmetrien bei Elektronenlinsen. Z. Angew. Phys. 5, 329–339. Haider, M. (1998). Correctors for electron microscopes: Tools or toys for scientists? In Proceedings of EUREM-11, the 11th European Conference on Electron Microscopy, Dublin 1996 (CESEM, Ed.), Vol. I, 363–364 (CESEM, Brussels). Haider, M. (2000). Towards sub-Ångstrom point resolution by correction of spherical aberration. In Proceedings of the 12th European Congress on Electron Microscopy, Brno (P. Tomanek and R. Kolarik, Eds.), Vol. III, I.145–I.148 (Czechoslovak Society for Electron Microscopy, Brno). Haider, M. (2003). Current and future developments in order to approach a point resolution of 0.5 Å. Microsc. Microanal. 9 (Supplement 2), 930–931. Haider, M. and Müller, M. (2004). Design of an electron optical system for the correction of the chromatic aberration Cc of a TEM objective lens. In Materials Research in an Aberration-Free Environment. Microsc. Microanal. 10 (Supplement 3), 2–3. Haider, M. and Müller, H. (2005). Is there a road map of aberration correction towards ultra-high resolution in TEM and STEM? Microsc. Microanal. 11 (Supplement 2), 546–547. Haider, M. and Uhlemann, S. (1997). Seeing is not believing: Reduction of artefacts by an improved point resolution with a spherical aberration corrected 200 kV transmission electron microscope. Microsc. Microanal. 3 (Supplement 2), 1179–1180. Haider, M., Bernhardt, W. and Rose, H. (1982). Design and test of an electric and magnetic dodecapole lens. Optik 63, 9–23. Haider, M., Braunshausen, G. and Schwan, E. (1995). Correction of the spherical aberration of a 200 kV TEM by means of a hexapole-corrector. Optik 99, 167–179. Haider, M., Uhlemann, S., Schwan, E., Rose, H., Kabius, B. and Urban, K. (1998a). Electron microscopy image enhanced. Nature 392, 768–769. Haider, M., Rose, H., Uhlemann, S., Kabius, B. and Urban, K. (1998b). Towards 0.1 nm resolution with the first spherically corrected transmission electron microscope. J. Electron Microsc. 47, 395–405. Haider, M., Rose, H., Uhlemann, S., Schwan, E., Kabius, B., and Urban, K. (1998c). A spherical-aberration-corrected 200 kV transmission electron microscope. Ultramicroscopy 75, 53–60. Haider, M., Uhlemann, S. and Zach, J. (2000). Upper limits for the residual aberrations of a high-resolution aberration-corrected STEM. Ultramicroscopy 81, 163–175. Haider, M., Müller, M. and Hartel, P. (2004). Present state and future trends of aberration correction. In Proceedings of the Eighth Asia–Pacific Conference on Electron Microscopy, Kanazawa (N. Tanaka, Y. Takano, H. Mori, H. Seguchi, S. Iseki, H. Shimada and E. Simamura, Eds.), 16–17 (8APEM Publication Committee, Uchinada, Ishikawa).
735
736
P.W. Hawkes Hanai, T., Hibino, M. and Maruse, S. (1986). Measurement of axial geometrical aberrations of the probe-forming lens by means of the shadow image of fine particles. Ultramicroscopy 20, 329–336. Hanai, T., Hibino, M. and Maruse, S. (1994). Effect of the three-fold astigmatism on the performance of the foil lens used for correction of the spherical aberration of a probe-forming lens. Optik 97, 86–90. Hanai, T., Arai, S. and Hibino, M. (1995). Increase of current density of the electron probe by correction of the spherical aberration with a side-entry type foil lens. J. Electron Microsc. 44, 301–306. Hanai, T., Yoshida, H. and Hibino, M. (1998). Characteristics and effectiveness of a foil lens for correction of spherical aberration in scanning transmission electron microscopy. J. Electron Microsc. 47, 185–192. Hartel, P., Preikszas, D., Spehr, R. and Rose, H. (2000). Performance of the mirror corrector for an ultrahigh-resolution spectromicroscope. In Proceedings of the 12th European Congress on Electron Microscopy, Brno (P. Tomanek and R. Kolarik, Eds.), Vol. III, I.153–I.154 (Czechoslovak Society for Electron Microscopy, Brno). Hartel, P., Preikszas, D., Spehr, R., Müller, H. and Rose, H. (2002). Mirror corrector for low-voltage electron microscopes. Adv. Imaging Electron Phys. 120, 41–133. Hartel, P., Müller, H., Uhlemann, S. and Haider, M. (2004). Residual aberrations of hexapole-type Cs–correctors. In Proceedings of the 13th European Microscopy Congress, Antwerp (D. van Dyck and P. van Oostveldt, Eds.), Vol. I, 41– 42 (Belgian Society for Microscopy, Liège). *Hartel, P., Müller, H., Uhlemann, S. and Haider, M. (2007). First experimental results with advanced hexapole C s -correctors. Microsc. Microanal. 13, Supplement 3, 4–5. Haufe, G. (1958). Korrektur des Öffnungsfehlers bei elektrostatischen Linsen durch Raumladung. Optik 15, 521–537. Hawkes, P.W. (1964). The paraxial chromatic aberrations of quadrupole systems. In Proceedings of the Third European Regional Conference on Electron Microscopy, Prague (M. Titlbach, Ed.), Vol. A, 5–6 (Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences, Prague). Hawkes, P.W. (1965a). The geometrical aberrations of general electron optical systems, I and II, Philos. Trans. Roy. Soc. A257, 479–552. Hawkes, P.W. (1965b). The paraxial chromatic aberrations of rectilinear orthogonal systems, Optik 22, 543–551. Hawkes, P.W. (1970). Quadrupoles in electron lens design. Adv. Electron. Electron Phys. (Supplement 7). Hawkes, P.W. (1980). Methods of computing optical properties and combating aberrations for low-intensity beams. Adv. Electron. Electron Phys. (Supplement 13A), 45–157. Hawkes, P.W. (1997). Aberrations. In Handbook of Charged Particle Optics (J. Orloff, Ed.), 223–274 (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL). Hawkes, P.W. (2002). Signposts in electron optics. Adv. Imaging Electron Phys. 123, 1–28. *Hawkes, P.W. (2008). Aberrations. In Handbook of Charged Particle Optics, 2nd ed. (J. Orloff, Ed.; CRC Press, Boca Raton) *Hawkes, P.W., Ed. (2008). Aberration-corrected electron microscopy. Adv. Imaging & Electron Phys. 155. Hawkes, P.W. and Kasper, E. (1989, 1994). Principles of Electron Optics (Academic Press, London). Henstra, A. and Krijn, M.P.C.M. (2000). An electrostatic achromat. In Proceedings of the 12th European Congress on Electron Microscopy, Brno (P. Tomanek and R. Kolarik, Eds.), Vol. III, I.155–I.156 (Czechoslovak Society for Electron Microscopy, Brno).
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction Herrmann, K.-H., Schiske, P. and Zemlin, F. (1976). Einfluß und Nachweis des dreizähligen Astigmatismus in der Hochauflösungsmikroskopie. Mikroskopie 32, 235. Hoch, H., Kasper, E. and Kern, D. (1976). Der Öffnungsfehler 3. Ordnung und die axiale Farbfehler von rotationssymmetrischen Elektronenlinsen mit gekrümmter geladener transparenter Folie. Optik 46, 463–473. Honda, K., Uno, S., Nakamura, N., Matsuya, M., Achard, B. and Zach, J. (2004a). An automatic geometrical aberration correction system of scanning electron microscopes. In Proceedings of the 13th European Microscopy Congress, Antwerp (D. van Dyck and P. van Oostveldt, Eds.), Vol. I, 43–44 (Belgian Society for Microscopy, Liège). Honda, K., Uno, S., Nakamura, N., Matsuya, M. and Zach, J. (2004b). An automatic geometrical aberration correction system of scanning electron microscopes. In Proceedings of the Eighth Asia–Pacific Conference on Electron Microscopy, Kanazawa (N. Tanaka, Y. Takano, H. Mori, H. Seguchi, S. Iseki, H. Shimada and E. Simamura, Eds.), 44–45 (8APEM Publication Committee, Uchinada, Ishikawa). Hosokawa, F. and Sawada, H. (2003). A Cs-corrected TEM. Denshi Kenbikyo 38 (Supplement 2), 55–58. Hosokawa, F., Tomita, T., Naruse, M., Honda, T., Hartel, P. and Haider, M. (2003). A spherical aberration-corrected 200 kV TEM. J. Electron Microsc. 52, 3–10. Huber, A. and Plies, E. (1999). Numerical ray tracing of electrons in different 3D fringing fields of spherical deflectors. Proc. SPIE 3777, 264–274. Huber, A. and Plies, E. (2000). Simulation of electron trajectories in the 3D field of two coupled hemispherical electrostatic deflectors. In Proceedings of the 12th European Congress on Electron Microscopy, Brno (P. Tomanek and R. Kolarik, Eds.), Vol. III, 1473–1477 (Czechoslovak Society for Electron Microscopy, Brno). Huber, A., Bärtle, J. and Plies, E. (2004). Initial experiences with an electrostatic Ωmonochromator for electrons. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A519, 320–324. Hutchison, J.L., Titchmarsh, J.M., Cockayne, D.J.H., Doole, R.C., Hetherington, C.J.D., Kirkland, A.I. and Sawada, H. (2005). A versatile double aberrationcorrected energy filtered HREM/STEM for materials science. Ultramicroscopy 103, 7–15. Ioanoviciu, D., Tsuno, K. and Martínez, G. (2004). Third order aberration theory of double Wien filters. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 75, 4434–4441. Ishizuka, K. (1994). Coma-free alignment of a high-resolution electron microscope with three-fold astigmatism. Ultramicroscopy 55, 407–418. Jia, C.L., Lentzen, M. and Urban, K. (2003). Atomic-resolution imaging of oxygen in perovskite ceramics. Science 299, 870–873. Kabius, B., Haider, M., Uhlemann, S., Schwan, E., Urban, K. and Rose, H. (2002). First application of a spherical-aberration corrected transmission electron microscope in materials science. J. Electron Microsc. 51, S51–S58. Kabius, B., Miller, D.J. and Zaluzec, N.J. (2004). Aberration correction for the TEAM project: Design and applications. In Proceedings of the 13th European Microscopy Congress, Antwerp (D. van Dyck and P. van Oostveldt, Eds.), Vol. I, 25–26 (Belgian Society for Microscopy, Liège). Kahl, F. and Rose, H. (1998). Outline of an electron monochromator with small Boersch effect. In Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Electron Microscopy, Cancún (H.A. Calderón and M.J. Yacamán, Eds.), Vol. 1, 71–72 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Kahl, F. and Rose, H. (2000). Design of a monochromator for electron sources. In Proceedings of the 12th European Congress on Electron Microscopy, Brno
737
738
P.W. Hawkes (P. Tomanek and R. Kolarik, Eds.), Vol. III, I.459–I.460 (Czechoslovak Society for Electron Microscopy, Brno). Kahl, F. and Voelkl, E. (2001). Present concepts and designs for gun monochromators. Microsc. Microanal. 7 (Supplement 2), 922–923. Kasper, E. (1968/9). Die Korrektur des Öffnungs- und Farbfehlers im Elektronenmikroskop durch Verwendung eines Elektronenspiegels mit überlagertem Magnetfeld. Optik 28, 54–64. Kazumori, H., Honda, K., Matsuya, M., Date, M. and Nielsen, C. (2004a). Field emission SEM with a spherical and chromatic aberration corrector. Microsc. Microanal. 10 (Supplement 2), 1370–1371. Kazumori, H., Honda, K., Matuya, M. and Date, M. (2004b). Field emission SEM with a spherical and chromatic aberration corrector. In Proceedings of the Eighth Asia–Pacific Conference on Electron Microscopy, Kanazawa (N. Tanaka, Y. Takano, H. Mori, H. Seguchi, S. Iseki, H. Shimada and E. Simamura, Eds.), 52–53 (8APEM Publication Committee, Uchinada, Ishikawa). Kel’man, V.M. and Yavor, S. Ya. (1961). Achromatic quadrupole electron lenses. Zh. Tekh. Fiz. 31, 1439–1442; Sov. Phys. Tech. Phys. 6, 1052–1054. Khursheed, A. (2002). A low voltage time of flight electron emission microscope. Optik 113, 505–509. Khursheed, A. (2005). A method of dynamic chromatic correction in lowvoltage scanning electron microscopes. Ultramicroscopy 103, 255–260. Koops, H. (1978). Aberration correction in electron microscopy. In Proceedings of the Ninth International Congress on Electron Microscopy, Toronto (J.M. Sturgess, Ed.), Vol. 3, 185–196 (Microscopical Society of Canada, Toronto). Koops, H. (1978/9). Erprobung eines chromatisch korrigierten elektronenmikroskopischen Objektives. Optik 52, 1–18. Koops, H. and Bernhard, W. (1978). An objective lens for an electron microscope with compensated axial chromatic aberration. In Proceedings of the Ninth International Congress on Electron Microscopy, Toronto (J.M. Sturgess, Ed.), Vol. 1, 36–37 (Microscopical Society of Canada, Toronto). Koops, H., Kuck, G. and Scherzer, O. (1977). Erprobung eines elektronenoptischen Achromators. Optik 48, 225–236. Krivanek, O. (1994). Three-fold astigmatism in high-resolution transmission electron microscopy Ultramicroscopy 55, 419–433. Krivanek, O.L. and Fan, G.Y. (1992a). Complete HREM autotuning using automated diffractogram analysis. Proc. EMSA, 50, Part 1, 96–97. Krivanek, O.L. and Fan, G.Y. (1992b). Application of slow-scan charge-coupled device (CCD) cameras to on-line microscope control. Scanning Microsc. (Supplement 6), 105–114. Krivanek, O.L. and Leber, M.L. (1993). Three-fold astigmatism: An important TEM aberration. In Proceedings of the 51st Annual Meeting Microscopy Society of America (G.W. Bailey and C.L. Rieder, Eds.), 972–973 (San Francisco Press, San Francisco). Krivanek, O.L. and Leber, M.L. (1994). Autotuning for 1Å resolution. In Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Electron Microscopy, Paris (B. Jouffrey, C. Colliex, J.-P. Chevalier, F. Glas, P.W. Hawkes, D. HernandezVerdun, J. Schrevel and D. Thomas, Eds.), Vol. 1, 157–158 (Editions de Physique, Les Ulis). Krivanek, O.L. and Stadelmann, P.A. (1995). Effect of three-fold astigmatism on high-resolution electron micrographs. Ultramicroscopy 60, 103–113. Krivanek, O.L., Dellby, N., Spence, A.J., Camps, A. and Brown, L.M. (1997a). Aberration correction in the STEM. In Proceedings of EMAG 1997 (J.M.
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction Rodenburg, Ed.), 35–39 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Krivanek, O.L., Dellby, N., Spence, A.J., Camps, R.A. and Brown, L.M. (1997b). On-line aberration measurement and correction in STEM. Microsc. Microanal. 3 (Supplement 2), 1171–1172. Krivanek, O.L., Dellby, N. and Brown, L.M. (1998). Spherical aberration corrector for a dedicated STEM. In Proceedings of EUREM-11, the 11th European Conference on Electron Microscopy, Dublin 1996 (CESEM, Ed.), Vol. I, 352–353 (CESEM, Brussels). Krivanek, O.L., Dellby, N. and Lupini, A.R. (1999a). Towards sub-Å electron beams. Ultramicroscopy 78, 1–11. Krivanek, O.L., Dellby, N. and Lupini, A.R. (1999b). STEM without spherical aberration. Microsc. Microanal. 5 (Supplement 2), 670–671. Krivanek, O.L., Dellby, N. and Lupini, A.R. (2000). Advances in Cs-corrected STEM. In Proceedings of the 12th European Congress on Electron Microscopy, Brno (P. Tomanek and R. Kolarik, Eds.), Vol. III, I.149–I.150 (Czechoslovak Society for Electron Microscopy, Brno). Krivanek, O.L., Dellby, N., Nellist, P.D., Batson, P.E. and Lupini, A.R. (2001). Aberration-corrected STEM: The present and the future. Microsc. Microanal. 7 (Supplement 2), 896–897. Krivanek., O.L., Dellby, N., Murfitt, M., Nellist, P.D. and Szilagyi, Z. (2002). STEM aberration correction: Where next? Microsc. Microanal. 8 (Supplement 2), 20–21. Krivanek, O.L, Nellist, P.D., Dellby, N., Murfitt, M.F. and Szilagyi, Z. (2003). Towards sub-0.5 Å beams. Ultramicroscopy 96, 229–237. Krivanek, O.L., Corbin, G.J., Dellby, N., Murfitt, M., Nagesha, K., Nellist, P.D. and Szilagyi, Z. (2004). Nion UltraSTEM: a new STEM for sub-0.5 Å imaging and sub-0.5 eV analysis. In Proceedings of the 13th European Microscopy Congress, Antwerp (D. van Dyck and P. van Oostveldt, Eds.), Vol. I, 35–36 (Belgian Society for Microscopy, Liège). Krivanek, O.L., Dellby, N., McManama-Smith, A., Murfitt, M., Nellist, P.D. and Own, C.S. (2005). An aberration-corrected STEM for diffraction studies. Microsc. Microanal. 11 (Supplement 2), 544–545. *Krivanek, O.L., Corbin, G.J., Dellby, N., Elston, B.F., Keyse, R.J., Murfitt, M.F., Own, C.S., Szilagyi, Z.S. and Woodruff, J.W. (2007). An electron microscope for the aberration-corrected era. Ultramicroscopy. Kuck, (1979). Erprobung eines elektronenoptischen Korrektivs für Farb- und Öffnungsfehler. Dissertation, Darmstadt. Lencová, B. (1997). Electrostatic lenses. In Handbook of Charged Particle Optics (J. Orloff, Ed.), 177–221 (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL). Lencová, B. and Lenc, M. (1990). Computation of multi-lens focusing systems. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A298, 45–55. Lencová, B. and Lenc, M. (1994). Computation of properties of electrostatic lenses. Optik 97, 121–126. Lencová, B. and Lenc, M. (1997). Third order geometrical and first order chromatic aberrations of electrostatic lenses. Optik 105, 121–128. Lentzen, M., Jahnen, B., Jia, C.L., Thust, A., Tillmann, K. and Urban, K. (2002). High-resolution imaging with an aberration-corrected transmission electron microscope. Ultramicroscopy 92, 233–242. Liu, H., Munro, E., Rouse, J. and Zhu, X. (2002). Simulation methods for multipole imaging systems and aberration correctors. Ultramicroscopy 93, 271–291. Lupini, A.R., Varela, M., Borisevich, A.Y., Travaglini, S.M. and Pennycook, S.J. (2003). Advances in aberration corrected STEM at ORNL. In Proceedings of EMAG 2003 (S. McVitie and D. McComb, Eds.), 211–214 (Institute of Physics, Bristol).
739
740
P.W. Hawkes Maas, D.J., Henstra, A., Krijn, M.P.C.M. and Mentink, S.A.M. (2000). Electrostatic correction in LV-SEM. Microsc. Microanal. 6 (Supplement) 2, 746–747. Maas, D.J., Henstra, S., Krijn, M. and Mentink, S. (2001). Electrostatic aberration correction in low-voltage SEM. Proc. SPIE 4510, 205–217. Maas, D., Mentink, S. and Henstra, S. (2003). Electrostatic aberration correction in low-voltage SEM. Microsc. Microanal. 9 (Supplement 3), 24–25. Martínez, G. and Tsuno, K. (2002). BEM simulation of Wien filters. Ultramicroscopy 93, 253–261. Martínez, G. and Tsuno, K. (2004). 2nd order aberration corrected Wien filter. In Proceedings of the 13th European Microscopy Congress, Antwerp (D. van Dyck and P. van Oostveldt, Eds.), Vol. I, 63–64 (Belgian Society for Microscopy, Liège). Matsuda, H., Daimon, H., Kato, M. and Kudo, M. (2005). Approach for simultaneous measurement of two-dimensional angular distribution of charged particles: spherical aberration correction using an ellipsoidal mesh. Phys. Rev. E71, 066503:1–8. Mentink, S.A.M., Steffen, T., Tiemeijer, P.C. and Krijn, M.P.C.M. (1999). Simplified aberration corrector for low-voltage SEM. In Proceedings of EMAG 1999 (C.J. Kiely, Ed.), 83–86 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Mentink, S.A.M., Zande, M.J. van der, Kok, C. and Rooy, T.L. van (2004). Development of a Cs corrector for a Tecnai 20 FEG STEM/TEM. In Proceedings of EMAG 2003 (S. McVitie and D. McComb, Eds.), 165–168 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Möllenstedt, G. (1956). Elektronenmikroskopische Bilder mit einem nach O. Scherzer sphärisch korrigierten Objektiv. Optik 13, 209–215. Mook, H.W. and Kruit, P. (1998). Fringe field monochromator for high brightness electron sources. In Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Electron Microscopy, Cancún (H.A. Calderón and M.J. Yacamán, Eds.), Vol. 1, 73–74 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Mook, H.W. and Kruit, P. (1999a). On the monochromatisation of high brightness sources for electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 78, 43–51. Mook, H.W. and Kruit, P. (1999b). Optics and design of the fringe-field monochromator for a Schottky field-emission gun. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A427, 109–120. Mook, H.W. and Kruit, P. (2000). Construction and characterization of the fringe field monochromator for a field emission gun. Ultramicroscopy 81, 129–139. Mook, H.W., Batson, P.E. and Kruit, P. (1999). Operation of the fringe field monochromator in field emission STEM. In Proceedings of EMAG 1999 (C.J. Kiely, Ed.), 223–226 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Mook, H.W., Batson, P.E. and Kruit, P. (2000). Monochromator for high brightness electron guns. In Proceedings of the 12th European Congress on Electron Microscopy, Brno (P. Tomanek and R. Kolarik, Eds.), Vol. III, I.315–I.316 (Czechoslovak Society for Electron Microscopy, Brno). Mukai, M., Kaneyama, T., Tomita, T., Tsuno, K., Terauchi, M., Tsuda, K., Saitoh, K., Naruse, M., Honda, T. and Tanaka, M. (2003a). ‘MIRAI–21’ electron microscope–performance of the monochromator. Microsc. Microanal. 9 (Supplement 2), 954–955. Mukai, M., Kaneyama, T., Tomita, T., Tsuno, K., Terauchi, M., Tsuda, K., Saitoh, K., Kersker, M., Naruse, M., Honda, T. and Tanaka, M. (2003b). ‘MIRAI–21’ electron microscope–performance of the monochromator. In Proceedings of the 15th International Congress on Electron Microscopy, Durban (R. Cross, J. Engelbrecht and M. Witcomb, Eds.), Vol. 3, 321–322 (Microscopy Society of Southern Africa, Onderstepoort). Müller, H., Preikszas, D. and Rose, H. (1999). A beam separator with small aberrations. J. Electron Microsc. 48, 191–204.
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction Müller, H., Uhlemann, S. and Haider, M. (2002). Benefits and possibilities for Cc-correction in TEM/STEM. Microsc. Microanal. 8 (Supplement 2), 12–13. Müller, H., Uhlemann, S., Hartel, P. and Haider, M. (2005). Optical design, simulations and alignment of present-day and future aberration correctors for the transmission electron microscope. Paul-Scherrer-Institut Proc. 05–01, 6. *Müller, H., Uhlemann, S., Hartel, P. and Haider, M. (2006). Advancing the hexapole Cs -corrector for the scanning transmission electron microscope. Microsc. Microanal. 12, 442–455. Munro, E. (1997). Computational techniques for design of charged particle optical systems. In Handbook of Charged Particle Optics (J. Orloff, Ed.), 1–76 (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL). Munro, E. and Wittels, N. (1977). Calculation of the optical properties of electron lenses with electron-transparent foils. Optik 47, 25–38. Munro, E., Zhu, X., Rouse, J.A. and Liu, H. (2001). Aberration correction for charged particle lithography. Proc. SPIE 4510, 218–224. Nellist, P.D., Dellby, N., Krivanek, O.L., Murfitt, M.F., Szilagyi, Z., Lupini, A. R. and Pennycook, S.J. (2004a). Towards sub 0.5 angstrom beams through aberration corrected STEM. In Proceedings of EMAG 2003 (S. McVitie and D. McComb, Eds.), 159–164 (Institute of Physics, Bristol). Nellist, P.D., Chisholm, M.F., Dellby, N., Krivanek, O.L., Murfitt, M.F., Szilagyi, Z.S., Lupini, A.R., Borisevich, A., Sides, W.H. and Pennycook, S.J. (2004b). Direct sub-Angstrom imaging of a crystal lattice. Science 305, 1741. Nellist, P.D., Chisholm, M.F., Lupini, A.R., Borisevich, A., Sides, W.H., Pennycook, S.J., Dellby, N., Keyse, R., Krivanek, O.L., Murfitt, M.F. and Szilagyi, Z.S. (2006). Aberration corrected STEM: current performance and future directions. J. Phys. Conf. 26, 7–12. Nomura, S. (2004). Aberration-free electron microscope composed of round lenses. In Proceedings of the Eighth Asia–Pacific Conference on Electron Microscopy, Kanazawa (N. Tanaka, Y. Takano, H. Mori, H. Seguchi, S. Iseki, H. Shimada and E. Simamura, Eds.), 34–35 (8APEM Publication Committee, Uchinada, Ishikawa). O’Keefe, M.A. (2003). HRTEM at half-Ångström resolution: From 0ÅM to TEAM. Microsc. Microanal. 9 (Supplement 2), 936–937. O’Keefe, M.A. (2004). Sub-Ångstrom resolution with aberration-corrected TEM: Present and future. In Materials Research in an Aberration-free Environment. Microsc. Microanal. 10 (Supplement 3), 68–69. Oldfield, L.C. (1973). Computer design of high frequency electron-optical systems. In Image Processing and Computer-Aided Design in Electron Optics (P.W. Hawkes, Ed.), 370–399 (Academic Press, London). Oldfield, L.C. (1974). The use of microwave cavities as electron lenses. In Proceedings of the 8th International Congress on Electron Microscopy, Canberra (J.V. Sanders and D.J. Goodchild, Eds.), Vol. I, 152–153 (Australian Academy of Science, Canberra). Orloff, J., Ed. (1997). Handbook of Charged Particle Optics (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL). Oshima, C. (1999). Monochromatic field electron emission from a Nb superconductor. Ultramicroscopy 78, 27–32. Pejas, W. (1978). Magnetische Abschirmung eines korrigierten Elektronenmikroskops. Optik 50, 61–72. Pennycook, S.J., Lupini, A.R., Kadavanich, A., McBride, J.R., Rosenthal, S.J., Puetter, R.C., Yahil, A., Krivanek, O.L., Dellby, N., Hellist, P.D.L., Duscher, G. and Pantelides, S.T. (2003). Aberration-corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy: The potential for nano- and interface science. Z. Metall. 94, 350–357.
741
742
P.W. Hawkes Plies, E. (1978). Proposal for an electrostatic energy filter and a monochromator. In Proceedings of the Ninth International Congress on Electron Microscopy, Toronto (J.M. Sturgess, Ed.), Vol. 1, 50–51 (Microscopical Society of Canada, Toronto). Plies, E. and Bärtle, J. (2003). Proposal of a novel highly symmetric Wien filter monochromator. Microsc. Microanal. 9 (Supplement 3), 28–29. Pöhner, W. (1976). Ein in dritter und fünfter Ordnung sphärisch korrigierter elektronenoptischer Aplanat. Optik 45, 443–454. Pöhner, W. (1977). Ein sphärisch korrigierter elektronenoptischer Apochromat. Optik 47, 283–297. Preikszas, D. and Rose H., (1995). Procedures for minimizing the aberrations of electromagnetic compound lenses. Optik 100, 179–187. Preikszas, D. and Rose, H. (1997). Correction properties of electron mirrors. J. Electron Microsc. 46, 1–9. Preikszas, D., Hartel, P., Spehr, R. and Rose, H. (2000). SMART electron optics. In Proceedings of the 12th European Congress on Electron Microscopy, Brno (P. Tomanek and R. Kolarik, Eds.), Vol. III, I.181–I.184 (Czechoslovak Society for Electron Microscopy, Brno). Ramberg, E.G. (1949). Aberration correction with an electron mirror. J. Appl. Phys. 20, 183–186. Recknagel, A. (1937). Zur Theorie des Elektronenspiegels. Z. Phys. 104, 381–394. Recknagel, A. (1941). Über die sphärische Aberration bei elektronenoptischer Abbildung. Z. Phys. 117, 67–73. Reichenbach, M. and Rose, H. (1968/9). Entwurf eines korrigierten magnetischen Objektivs. Optik 28, 475–487. Reimer, L., Ed. (1995). Energy-Filtering Transmission Electron Microscopy (Springer, Berlin). Rempfer, G.F. (1990a). Comment on “A study on hyperbolic mirrors as correctors.” Optik 86, 73–74. Rempfer, G.F. (1990b). A theoretical study of the hyperbolic electron mirror as a correcting element for spherical and chromatic aberration in electron optics. J. Appl. Phys. 67, 6027–6040. Rempfer, G.F. and Mauck, M.S. (1985). Aberration-correcting properties of the hyperbolic electron mirror. Proc. Annu. Meeting EMSA 43, 132–133. Rempfer, G.F. and Mauck, M.S. (1986). An experimental study of the hyperbolic electron mirror. Proc. Annu. Meeting EMSA 44, 886–887. Rempfer, G.F. and Mauck, M.S. (1992). Correction of chromatic aberration with an electron mirror. Optik 92, 3–8. Rempfer, G.F., Desloge, D.M., Skoczylas, W.P. and Griffith, O.H. (1997). Simultaneous correction of spherical and chromatic aberrations with an electron mirror. Microsc. Microanal. 3, 14–27. Rose, H. (1967/8). Über die Korrigierbarkeit von Linsen für schnelle Elektronen. Optik 26, 289–298. Rose, H. (1970). Berechnung eines elektronenoptischen Apochromaten. Optik 32, 144–164. Rose, H. (1971a). Abbildungseigenschaften sphärisch korrigierter elektronenoptischer Achromate. Optik 33, 1–24. Rose, H. (1971b). Elektronenoptische Aplanate. Optik 34, 285–311. Rose, H. (1981). Correction of aperture aberrations in magnetic systems with threefold symmetry. Nucl. Instrum. Methods 187, 187–199. Rose, H. (1987). The retarding Wien filter as a high-performance imaging filter. Optik 77, 26–34. Rose, H. (1990a). Inhomogeneous Wien filter as a corrector for the chromatic and spherical aberration of low-voltage electron microscopes. Optik 84, 91–107.
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction Rose, H. (1990b). Outline of a spherically corrected semiaplanatic mediumvoltage TEM. Optik 85, 19–24. Rose, H. (2000). High-Performance Electron Microscopes of the Future (P. Tomanek and R. Kolarik, Eds.), Vol. III, I.21–I.24 (Czechoslovak Society for Electron Microscopy, Brno). Rose, H. (2002a). Theory of electron-optical achromats and apochromats. Ultramicroscopy 93, 293–303. Rose, H. (2002b). Correction of aberrations–past, present and future. Microsc. Microanal. 8 (Supplement 2), 6–7. Rose, H. (2002c). Advances in electron optics. In High-Resolution Imaging and Spectrometry of Materials (F. Ernst and M. Rühle, Eds.) (Springer, Berlin). Rose, H. (2003). Outline of an ultracorrector compensating for all primary chromatic and geometrical aberrations of charged-particle lenses. Microsc. Microanal. 9 (Supplement 3), 32–33. Rose, H. (2004). Outline of an ultracorrector compensating for all primary chromatic and geometrical aberrations of charged-particle lenses. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A519, 12–27. Rose, H. (2005). Prospects for aberration-free microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 103, 1–6. Rose, H. (2008). Geometrical Electron Optics. In preparation. Rose, H. and Krahl, D. (1995). Electron optics of imaging energy filters. In Energy-Filtering Transmission Electron Microscopy (L. Reimer, Ed.), 43–149 (Springer, Berlin). Rose, H. and Pejas, W. (1979). Optimization of imaging magnetic filters free of second-order aberrations. Optik 54, 235–250. Rose, H. and Preikszas, D. (1992). Outline of a versatile corrected LEEM. Optik 92, 31–44. Rose, H., Hartel, P. and Preikszas, D. (2004). Outline of the mirror corrector for SMART and PEEM3. In Materials Research in an Aberration-Free Environment. Microsc. Microanal. 10 (Supplement 3), 28–29. Sawada, H., Tomita, T., Kaneyama, T., Hosokawa, F., Naruse, M., Honda, T., Hartel, P., Haider, M., Tanaka, N., Hetherington, C.J.D., Doole, R.C., Kirkland, A.I., Hutchison, J.L., Titchmarsh, J.M. and Cockayne, D.J.H. (2004a). Cs corrector for imaging. Microsc. Microanal. 10 (Supplement 2), 978–979. Sawada, H., Tomita, T., Naruse, M., Honda, T., Hartel, P., Haider, M., Hetherington, C.J.D., Doole, R.C., Kirkland, A.I., Hutchison, J.L., Titchmarsh, J.M. and Cockayne, D.J.H. (2004b). Cs corrector for illumination. Microsc. Microanal. 10 (Supplement 2), 1004–1005. Sawada, H., Tomita, T., Naruse, M., Honda, T., Hartel, P., Haider, M., Hetherington, C.J.D., Doole, R.C., Kirkland, A.I., Hutchison, J.L., Titchmarsh, J.M. and Cockayne, D.J.H. (2004c). 200 kV TEM with Cs correctors for illumination and imaging. In Proceedings of the Eighth Asia–Pacific Conference on Electron Microscopy, Kanazawa (N. Tanaka, Y. Takano, H. Mori, H. Seguchi, S. Iseki, H. Shimada and E. Simamura, Eds.), 20–21 (8APEM Publication Committee, Uchinada, Ishikawa). Saxton, W.O. (1995a). Observation of lens aberrations for very high resolution electron microscopy. I: Theory. J. Microsc. 179, 201–213. Saxton, W.O. (1995b). Simple prescriptions for measuring three-fold astigmatism. Ultramicroscopy 58, 239–243. Saxton, W.O. (2000). A new way of measuring aberrations. Ultramicroscopy 81, 41–45.
743
744
P.W. Hawkes Saxton, W.O., Chand, G. and Kirkland, A.I. (1994). Accurate determination and compensation of lens aberrations in high resolution EM. In Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Electron Microscopy, Paris (B. Jouffrey, C. Colliex, J.-P. Chevalier, F. Glas, P.W. Hawkes, D. Hernandez-Verdun, J. Schrevel and D. Thomas, Eds.), Vol. 1, 203–204 (Editions de Physique, Les Ulis). Scherzer, O. (1936). Über einige Fehler von Elektronenlinsen. Z. Phys. 101, 593–603. Scherzer, O. (1946). Zur Korrigierbarkeit von Elektronenlinsen. Phys. Bl. 2, 110. Scherzer (1947). Sphärische und chromatische Korrektur von Elektronenlinsen. Optik 2, 114–132. Scherzer, O. (1948). Ein elektronenoptisches Apochromat. Z. Naturforsch. 3a, 544–545. Scherzer, O. (1978). Limitations for the resolving power of electron microscopes. In Proceedings of the Ninth International Congress on Electron Microscopy, Toronto (J.M. Sturgess, Ed.), Vol. 3, 123–129 (Microscopical Society of Canada, Toronto). Scherzer, O. (1980). Eine sphärisch korrigierte Folien-Linse für die Phasenmikroskopie mit Elektronen. Optik 56, 133–147. Schmid, P., Feng, J., Padmore, H., Robin, D., Rose, H., Schlueter, R., Wan, W., Forest, E. and Wu, Y. (2005). Correction and alignment strategies for the beam separator of the photoemission electron microscope 3 (PEEM3). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 76, 023302:1–14. Schönhense, G. and Spiecker, H. (2002). Correction of chromatic and spherical aberration in electron microscopy utilizing the time structure of pulsed electron sources. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B20, 2526–2534. Schönhense, G. and Spiecker, H. (2003). Chromatic and spherical correction using time-dependent acceleration and lens fields. Microsc. Microanal. 9 (Supplement 3), 34–35. Seeliger, R. (1949). Versuche zur sphärischen Korrekur von Elektronenlinsen mittels nicht rotationssymmetrischer Abbildungselemente. Optik 5, 490–496. Seeliger, R. (1951). Die sphärische Korrektur von Elektronenlinsen mittels nicht-rotationssymetrischer Abbildungselemente. Optik 8, 311–317. Septier, A. (1963). Lentille quadrupolaire magneto-électrique corrigée de l’aberration chromatique. Aberration d’ouverture de ce type de lentilles. C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 256, 2325–2328. Septier, A. (1966). The struggle to overcome spherical aberration in electron optics. Adv. Opt. Electron Microsc. 1, 204–274. Shao, Z. and Wu, X.D. (1989). Adjustable four-electrode electron mirror as an aberration corrector. Appl. Phys. Lett. 55, 2696–2697. Shao, Z. and Wu, X.D. (1990a). Properties of a four-electrode adjustable electron mirror as an aberration corrector. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 61, 1230–1235. Shao, Z. and Wu, X.D. (1990b). A study on hyperbolic mirrors as correctors. Optik 84, 51–54. Skoczylas, W.P., Rempfer, G.F. and Griffith, O.H. (1991). A proposed modular imaging system for photoelectron and electron probe microscopy with aberration correction, and for mirror microscopy and low energy electron microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 36, 252–261. Skoczylas, W.P., Rempfer, G.F. and Griffith, O.H. (1994). Electron optical benches for in-line and branched systems. A new bench designed for mirror-based aberration correction and low energy electron microscopy. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 65, 3183–3193. Steffen, T., Tiemeijer, P.C., Krijn, M.P.C.M. and Mentink, S.A.M. (2000). Correction of chromatic and spherical aberration using a Wien filter. In Proceedings
Chapter 10 Aberration Correction of the 12th European Congress on Electron Microscopy (P. Tomanek and R. Kolarik, Eds.), Vol. III, I.151–I.152 (Czechoslovak Society for Electron Microscopy, Brno). Stoyanov, P.A. (1955). [The effect of departures of the geometrical shape of the polepieces of an objective from circular symmetry on the resolving power of the electron microscope]. Zh. Tekh. Fiz. 25, 625–635. Sturrock, P.A. (1950). The aberrations of magnetic electron lenses due to asymmetries. Proceedings of the [First] Conference on Electron Microscopy, Delft, 1949 (A.L. Houwink, J.B. Le Poole and W.A. Le Rütte, Eds.), 89–93 (Hoogland, Delft). Sturrock, P.A. (1951). The aberrations of magnetic electron lenses due to asymmetries. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London A243, 387–429. Tanaka, M., Terauchi, M., Tsuda, K., Saitoh, K., Honda, T., Tsuno, K., Naruse, M., Tomita, T. and Kaneyama, T. (2000). An 0.2 eV energy resolution analytical electron microscope. In Microbeam Analysis 2000 (D.B. Williams and R. Shimizu, Eds.), 217–218 (Institute of Physics, Bristol)